[{"audio_id": "HzlQkm2IeBQ", "text": {"HzlQkm2IeBQ-00000-00000267-00002883": "[Music]", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00001-00002884-00003208": "foreign", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00002-00003209-00008483": "[Music]", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00003-00008484-00008656": "do", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00004-00008657-00008835": "[Music]", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00005-00008836-00009932": "[Applause]", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00006-00009933-00011274": "[Music]", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00007-00011275-00019683": "[Music]", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00008-00019684-00020150": "foreign", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00009-00020151-00020647": "what's up", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00010-00020648-00020863": "have all my one month olds out here", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00011-00020864-00021143": "today while i'm cleaning their cages", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00012-00021144-00021343": "they get sun almost every day as long as", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00013-00021344-00021503": "it's not too hot in california", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00014-00021504-00022997": "here's one of my girls", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00015-00022998-00025383": "[Music]", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00016-00025384-00025649": "you", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00017-00025650-00031307": "[Music]", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00018-00031308-00032616": "[Music]", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00019-00032617-00032945": "[Applause]", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00020-00032946-00033316": "[Music]", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00021-00033317-00033705": "[Applause]", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00022-00033706-00035135": "[Music]", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00023-00035136-00035493": "wow", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00024-00035494-00037883": "[Music]", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00025-00037884-00038919": "me", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00026-00038920-00039551": "[Music]", "HzlQkm2IeBQ-00027-00039552-00039760": "i"}}, {"audio_id": "HzwjoNEYIVk", "text": {"HzwjoNEYIVk-00000-00000000-00000231": "what you picture when you see", "HzwjoNEYIVk-00001-00000231-00000383": "documentaries about", "HzwjoNEYIVk-00002-00000384-00000759": "alaska or read about it and what it", "HzwjoNEYIVk-00003-00000760-00001095": "actually is when you are there is not", "HzwjoNEYIVk-00004-00001096-00001863": "the same", "HzwjoNEYIVk-00005-00001864-00002110": "putting it into words the the beauty of", "HzwjoNEYIVk-00006-00002111-00002239": "the place", "HzwjoNEYIVk-00007-00002240-00002567": "the uniqueness and how raw it is trying", "HzwjoNEYIVk-00008-00002568-00002758": "to put that into words", "HzwjoNEYIVk-00009-00002759-00002990": "is not easy", "HzwjoNEYIVk-00010-00002991-00007710": "[Music]", "HzwjoNEYIVk-00011-00007711-00007920": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "HzD1XlJUnxg", "text": {"HzD1XlJUnxg-00000-00000171-00000794": "[Music]", "HzD1XlJUnxg-00001-00000795-00001357": "[Music]", "HzD1XlJUnxg-00002-00001358-00001491": "[Music]", "HzD1XlJUnxg-00003-00001492-00001663": "so", "HzD1XlJUnxg-00004-00001664-00001872": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "HzIHlDJyUCU", "text": {"HzIHlDJyUCU-00000-00001016-00001247": "welcome to this lecture series on", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00001-00001248-00001630": "aspects of western philosophy module 32.", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00002-00001632-00001807": "this lecture", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00003-00001807-00002023": "attempts to introduce", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00004-00002023-00002334": "the philosophy of admin result", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00005-00002335-00002607": "which is known as phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00006-00002608-00002783": "and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00007-00002784-00003031": "we will concentrate on basically on two", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00008-00003032-00003247": "three aspects of phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00009-00003247-00003463": "because it's a very important", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00010-00003464-00003670": "philosophy which is very important in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00011-00003671-00003895": "the sense like 20th century", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00012-00003896-00004079": "european thought particularly the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00013-00004079-00004351": "continental european philosophy", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00014-00004352-00004486": "was", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00015-00004487-00004670": "very significantly influenced by the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00016-00004671-00004806": "contributions of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00017-00004807-00005031": "this philosopher edmund russell", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00018-00005032-00005263": "particularly is phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00019-00005264-00005438": "like some of his famous", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00020-00005439-00005638": "disciples", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00021-00005639-00005831": "one of his famous disciples is martin", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00022-00005832-00005943": "heidegger", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00023-00005944-00006102": "who is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00024-00006103-00006286": "one of the very important and great", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00025-00006287-00006454": "thinkers of 20th century european", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00026-00006455-00006631": "thought", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00027-00006631-00006942": "and many others like uh", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00028-00006943-00007246": "hans georg gadama when he develops his", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00029-00007247-00007463": "hermeneutics he still remains as a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00030-00007464-00007791": "phenomenologist so phenomenological uh", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00031-00007792-00007934": "approaches to philosophy is a very", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00032-00007936-00008159": "significant moment in 20th century", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00033-00008159-00008287": "thinking", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00034-00008288-00008574": "so we'll basically try to focus on the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00035-00008575-00008799": "issues like where", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00036-00008800-00008967": "phenomenology talks about what is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00037-00008968-00009183": "phenomenology we will try to understand", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00038-00009184-00009374": "and then afterwards we will see the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00039-00009375-00009559": "there is another very important problem", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00040-00009560-00009735": "another very important concept the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00041-00009736-00010014": "concept of intentionality", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00042-00010015-00010278": "and then the method the method", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00043-00010279-00010510": "phenomenologist approach or particularly", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00044-00010511-00010814": "at pendulum has adopted the method of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00045-00010815-00011014": "reduction so we will concentrate on", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00046-00011015-00011303": "these three aspects of this philosophy", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00047-00011304-00011487": "so we will start with the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00048-00011488-00011655": "admin result", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00049-00011656-00011774": "he is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00050-00011775-00011942": "no doubt", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00051-00011943-00012127": "one of the most influential philosophers", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00052-00012128-00012414": "of 20th century european thought", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00053-00012415-00012510": "and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00054-00012511-00012807": "his his reputation is mainly due to his", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00055-00012808-00012999": "his contributions to phenomenology so he", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00056-00013000-00013215": "is known as a founder of phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00057-00013216-00013383": "though many others many other", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00058-00013384-00013622": "philosophers before him had talked about", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00059-00013623-00013815": "phenomenology it was as a kind of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00060-00013816-00014158": "philosophy and a kind of method it was", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00061-00014159-00014503": "user who brought phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00062-00014504-00014743": "into the forefront of philosophical", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00063-00014744-00014966": "enterprises", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00064-00014968-00015191": "and now again", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00065-00015191-00015375": "like as i mentioned there are many other", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00066-00015376-00015703": "thinkers like kant feature hegel and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00067-00015704-00015927": "anna smack they all refer to the term", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00068-00015928-00016150": "phenomenology in their respective", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00069-00016151-00016327": "philosophies", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00070-00016328-00016567": "hegel for example has even written a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00071-00016568-00016807": "book phenomenology of the geist of the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00072-00016808-00017150": "spirit credit actually goes to uh ozil", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00073-00017151-00017294": "when it comes to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00074-00017295-00017494": "phenomenology introducing phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00075-00017495-00017791": "as a separate philosophy", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00076-00017792-00017871": "and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00077-00017872-00018086": "so in all all major contributions in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00078-00018087-00018350": "this area are from him and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00079-00018351-00018471": "in philosophy", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00080-00018472-00018630": "phenomenology appears both as a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00081-00018631-00018894": "philosophy as well as a method so he", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00082-00018895-00019094": "suggested method which is known as", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00083-00019095-00019303": "phenomenological method which consists", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00084-00019304-00019550": "of several stages of reduction which", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00085-00019551-00019775": "finally takes us to a kind of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00086-00019776-00020047": "transcendental reduction which isolates", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00087-00020048-00020350": "the transcendental ego", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00088-00020351-00020519": "and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00089-00020520-00020758": "again it was whosoever conceives", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00090-00020759-00021022": "phenomenology as a foundational science", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00091-00021023-00021255": "a presuppositionless philosophy this is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00092-00021256-00021550": "again a very important and interesting", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00093-00021551-00021847": "aspect of his thought because", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00094-00021848-00021967": "ah", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00095-00021968-00022278": "19th century philosophy or 20th century", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00096-00022279-00022407": "by the time", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00097-00022408-00022663": "it was 20th century philosophy was", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00098-00022664-00022871": "gradually losing its importance as a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00099-00022872-00023047": "foundational discipline as all of us", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00100-00023048-00023127": "know", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00101-00023128-00023358": "as we have discussed in our previous", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00102-00023359-00023614": "lectures in this lecture series most of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00103-00023615-00023894": "these traditional european thinkers were", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00104-00023895-00024142": "conceiving philosophy as a foundational", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00105-00024143-00024319": "discipline", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00106-00024320-00024567": "in the greek during the greek ages it", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00107-00024568-00024886": "always enjoyed the status and even when", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00108-00024887-00025158": "in modern philosophy many thinkers", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00109-00025159-00025358": "try to define philosophy as a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00110-00025359-00025599": "foundational discipline by making it", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00111-00025600-00025783": "epistemology they thought that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00112-00025783-00025927": "philosophy is going to do a very", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00113-00025927-00026311": "important job for humanity humanity", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00114-00026312-00026423": "but", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00115-00026424-00026607": "gradually it was losing this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00116-00026608-00026870": "foundational status and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00117-00026872-00027174": "fusel is trying to regain it by", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00118-00027175-00027502": "establishing philosophy as phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00119-00027504-00027702": "as a foundational discipline as a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00120-00027704-00027962": "foundational science which he calls a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00121-00027963-00028283": "presuppositionless philosophy so as a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00122-00028283-00028479": "presuppositionless philosophy", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00123-00028480-00028743": "phenomenology tries to arrive at or", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00124-00028744-00028974": "tries to get a knowledge about the most", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00125-00028975-00029158": "important or rather to put it in other", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00126-00029160-00029483": "words the primordial data of all our", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00127-00029483-00029774": "knowledge so try to capture the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00128-00029775-00030062": "primordial data of all human knowledge", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00129-00030063-00030270": "whether it is science or any field for", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00130-00030272-00030383": "that matter", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00131-00030383-00030639": "the basic experience the primordial data", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00132-00030639-00030943": "of all knowledge or experience", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00133-00030944-00031143": "and the question is where do you find", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00134-00031144-00031327": "them where do you find this primordial", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00135-00031327-00031583": "data and user's answer is we find them", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00136-00031583-00031758": "in our consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00137-00031760-00032046": "so consciousness thus becomes a very", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00138-00032047-00032246": "important domain of philosophical", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00139-00032247-00032358": "inquiry", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00140-00032360-00032639": "and a philosopher should enquire or", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00141-00032639-00032911": "should examine the consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00142-00032912-00033151": "with an intention to understand", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00143-00033152-00033239": "the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00144-00033240-00033502": "most immediately given data to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00145-00033503-00033783": "consciousness when we know something so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00146-00033784-00034031": "all knowledge presupposes this data", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00147-00034032-00034287": "where something is given directly", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00148-00034288-00034543": "immediately to the consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00149-00034544-00034695": "that raw data", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00150-00034696-00034911": "from where the consciousness would later", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00151-00034912-00035174": "on apply its categories and other things", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00152-00035175-00035351": "and develop a knowledge a system of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00153-00035352-00035590": "knowledge but the primary data the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00154-00035591-00035887": "primordial data consists of those", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00155-00035888-00036174": "immediately given things so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00156-00036175-00036383": "philosophy or phenomenology should", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00157-00036384-00036679": "attempt to try to capture that so that's", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00158-00036680-00036839": "the major i mean that's the most", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00159-00036840-00037102": "important aspect of phenomenological", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00160-00037103-00037318": "inquiry the slogan is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00161-00037319-00037543": "back to things themselves so these are", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00162-00037544-00037767": "the things in themselves according to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00163-00037768-00037935": "user they are not the things in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00164-00037936-00038055": "themselves of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00165-00038056-00038423": "the immanuel kant where it has been", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00166-00038424-00038679": "designated as nomina which are", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00167-00038680-00038887": "unknowable which cannot be known through", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00168-00038888-00039079": "sensors or which remains", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00169-00039080-00039335": "uh as in a domain which is unknowable", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00170-00039336-00039630": "agnosticism but here ozone is not an", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00171-00039631-00039918": "agnostic or a skeptic like you but he is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00172-00039919-00040167": "very clear about it he asserts that the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00173-00040168-00040335": "primordial data", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00174-00040336-00040535": "of all knowledge can be found in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00175-00040536-00040774": "consciousness with an inquiry into", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00176-00040775-00040958": "consciousness a phenomenological inquiry", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00177-00040959-00041239": "into consciousness what is this inquiry", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00178-00041240-00041479": "this inquiry consists of removing", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00179-00041480-00041671": "everything that is unimportant and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00180-00041672-00041927": "focusing only on consciousness and its", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00181-00041928-00042174": "content so this is precisely the aim of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00182-00042175-00042367": "consciousness so in summary", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00183-00042368-00042599": "phenomenology consists in this this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00184-00042600-00042783": "assumption this philosophy and this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00185-00042784-00042958": "method", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00186-00042959-00043039": "ok", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00187-00043040-00043455": "now ah let us see who says phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00188-00043456-00043679": "he was a mathematician", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00189-00043680-00043911": "that is another interesting aspect about", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00190-00043912-00044030": "his career", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00191-00044031-00044295": "and since he is a mathematician like all", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00192-00044296-00044495": "mathematicians he is also he was also", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00193-00044496-00044735": "interested in abstract", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00194-00044736-00045039": "concepts entities numbers but then when", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00195-00045040-00045367": "you try to understand what a number is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00196-00045368-00045615": "whether it's a concept in the mind", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00197-00045616-00045807": "if normally understood that one way to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00198-00045808-00046062": "understand the numbers are to conceive", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00199-00046063-00046295": "it as a concept in the mind", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00200-00046296-00046471": "but if it is a concept in the mind", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00201-00046472-00046727": "whether it is a mental entity", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00202-00046728-00046879": "whether it is psychological or", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00203-00046880-00047158": "subjective something which results was", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00204-00047159-00047407": "not very comfortable with so he was as", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00205-00047408-00047615": "part and parcel of his project", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00206-00047616-00047858": "jose advocates a form of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00207-00047859-00048135": "anti-psychologism which is which is also", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00208-00048136-00048383": "found in another contemporary i mean", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00209-00048384-00048518": "contemporary of ozil another", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00210-00048519-00048774": "mathematician and logician ah god love", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00211-00048775-00048895": "freighty", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00212-00048896-00049030": "which you have very briefly been", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00213-00049031-00049223": "mentioned in our one of our previous", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00214-00049224-00049415": "lectures", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00215-00049416-00049639": "so he was to he was a student of france", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00216-00049640-00049895": "brentano who was a psychologist very", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00217-00049896-00050039": "well known very", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00218-00050040-00050223": "interesting philosopher", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00219-00050224-00050479": "his descriptive psychology and was also", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00220-00050480-00050695": "influenced by the empiricism of david", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00221-00050696-00050790": "hume", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00222-00050791-00050951": "and he opposed the naturalism and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00223-00050952-00051238": "historicism in german thought which is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00224-00051239-00051487": "which we can see in for example uh the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00225-00051488-00051735": "historicism the kind of historical", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00226-00051736-00051999": "approach to philosophy so he was sort of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00227-00052000-00052246": "opposing all these things and trying to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00228-00052247-00052342": "be", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00229-00052344-00052607": "trying to do justice to the to the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00230-00052608-00052815": "logical foundations", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00231-00052816-00053007": "or rather to put it in other words", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00232-00053008-00053166": "enquiry into the foundations of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00233-00053167-00053415": "mathematics led him to logic and then to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00234-00053416-00053654": "epistemology and finally to philosophy", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00235-00053655-00053894": "so the root is very clear like as it", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00236-00053895-00054087": "happened in the case of fergie", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00237-00054088-00054326": "wigenstein and many others he started", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00238-00054327-00054423": "out with", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00239-00054424-00054623": "mathematics and from mathematics to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00240-00054624-00054903": "logic but here he goes to epistemology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00241-00054904-00055087": "and later on finds that many of the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00242-00055088-00055366": "questions many of the problems which he", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00243-00055367-00055607": "is concerned about cannot be answered", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00244-00055608-00055838": "from the framework of an epistemologist", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00245-00055839-00056087": "so he epistemological turn in philosophy", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00246-00056088-00056335": "inadequate to answer", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00247-00056336-00056519": "some important questions in philosophy", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00248-00056520-00056742": "so he turns to ah philosophy in a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00249-00056744-00056919": "different way so phenomenology was", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00250-00056920-00057191": "proposed as an alternative method", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00251-00057191-00057359": "now there are basically three", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00252-00057360-00057623": "conceptions of phenomenology the one", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00253-00057624-00057838": "hand it was conceived as a science of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00254-00057839-00058023": "sciences i have already mentioned it the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00255-00058024-00058238": "foundational science it introverts to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00256-00058239-00058542": "discover the basis of consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00257-00058544-00058871": "and so that's what the primary", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00258-00058872-00059126": "entity with which phenomenologists are", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00259-00059127-00059375": "concerned with is consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00260-00059376-00059494": "number two", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00261-00059495-00059807": "it is conceived as a first philosophy", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00262-00059808-00060047": "and in that this sense it is extensive", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00263-00060048-00060391": "with philosophy and the third sense is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00264-00060391-00060682": "where probably the most important", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00265-00060683-00060942": "conceptualization of phenomenology where", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00266-00060944-00061111": "phenomenology is conceived as a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00267-00061112-00061338": "transcendental idealism a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00268-00061339-00061582": "transcendentalism all meaning had its", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00269-00061583-00061775": "source in the transcendental group so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00270-00061776-00061911": "ultimately", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00271-00061912-00062215": "hazel aims at all to this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00272-00062216-00062526": "domain of transcendental ego and its", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00273-00062527-00062694": "pure contents", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00274-00062695-00062903": "so that is it what phenomenology is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00275-00062904-00063082": "ultimate aim is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00276-00063083-00063238": "now", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00277-00063239-00063526": "when you try to assess the contributions", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00278-00063527-00063687": "of phenomenology particularly the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00279-00063688-00063950": "hazarian phenomenology it definitely", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00280-00063951-00064215": "consisted of a break from many", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00281-00064216-00064438": "traditional concerns and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00282-00064439-00064726": "and also inaugurated nuf thinking in in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00283-00064727-00064959": "european philosophy though phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00284-00064960-00065206": "as such is not a very old idea as a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00285-00065207-00065326": "method", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00286-00065327-00065591": "as a philosophy result combines it", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00287-00065592-00065887": "brilliantly and presents it in the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00288-00065888-00066079": "context of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00289-00066080-00066391": "one of the most turbulent centuries 20th", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00290-00066392-00066615": "century in human history", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00291-00066616-00066903": "so it on the one hand there is a break", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00292-00066904-00067111": "from the traditional concerns", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00293-00067112-00067375": "and on the other hand uh it is an", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00294-00067376-00067663": "inaugurates a new ever thinking", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00295-00067664-00067838": "then", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00296-00067839-00068071": "it is also influenced many philosophers", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00297-00068072-00068215": "i have already mentioned a couple of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00298-00068216-00068559": "names heidegger ah martin heidegger the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00299-00068560-00068847": "enhanced geographer", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00300-00068848-00069087": "so french philosopher and existentialist", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00301-00069088-00069350": "ron paul sartre then another very", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00302-00069351-00069606": "notable phenomenologist is maliu ponti", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00303-00069607-00069799": "who is a french phenomenologist and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00304-00069800-00069975": "there are many others so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00305-00069976-00070287": "existentialism", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00306-00070288-00070487": "deconstruction all these people all", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00307-00070488-00070694": "these philosophers who belong to these", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00308-00070695-00070911": "these different schools and traditions", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00309-00070912-00071303": "were influenced by wizards phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00310-00071304-00071615": "and as i already mentioned it emerged at", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00311-00071616-00071791": "a time when philosophy was facing a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00312-00071792-00071959": "crisis so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00313-00071960-00072159": "one of whose aim was to bring back", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00314-00072160-00072343": "philosophy to that status of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00315-00072344-00072575": "foundational discipline by conceiving", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00316-00072576-00072755": "philosophy as a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00317-00072756-00073247": "presuppositionless endeavor", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00318-00073248-00073415": "and provides a new life to german", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00319-00073416-00073623": "philosophy as the decline of great", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00320-00073624-00073855": "idealistic tradition had already begun", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00321-00073856-00074038": "by that time so you can see that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00322-00074039-00074223": "importance of user", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00323-00074224-00074438": "needs to be assessed from this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00324-00074439-00074550": "background", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00325-00074551-00074831": "you can see that two very important", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00326-00074832-00075159": "uh traditions of 28th century philosophy", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00327-00075160-00075294": "hermeneutics", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00328-00075295-00075399": "which was", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00329-00075400-00075719": "primarily spearheaded by gadama", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00330-00075720-00075982": "also to some extent heidegger then on", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00331-00075983-00076206": "the other hand the existentialist or", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00332-00076207-00076462": "existentialism the philosophy which was", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00333-00076463-00076791": "uh advocated by uh french philosophers", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00334-00076792-00077087": "ron paul sartre albert camus and many", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00335-00077088-00077262": "others in europe continental europe they", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00336-00077263-00077559": "were all influenced by ah hazel's", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00337-00077560-00077775": "phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00338-00077776-00078062": "and now let us see the subject matter of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00339-00078063-00078199": "phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00340-00078200-00078543": "phenomena so phenomena is the subject", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00341-00078544-00078679": "matter of philosophy that's the reason", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00342-00078680-00078950": "why we are we call it phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00343-00078951-00079255": "and what is phenomena a phenomena is uh", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00344-00079256-00079535": "there are objects and events around us", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00345-00079536-00079806": "it's a technical term used by uh", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00346-00079807-00080006": "not in the sense in the sense in which", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00347-00080007-00080238": "emmanuel candace used the term phenomena", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00348-00080239-00080455": "where he distinguishes it nomina or", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00349-00080456-00080623": "things in themselves which are ultimate", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00350-00080624-00080847": "realities for can't", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00351-00080848-00081079": "this is an appearance the phenomenal", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00352-00081080-00081247": "world is an appearance it's not", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00353-00081248-00081519": "something which is the real world", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00354-00081520-00081838": "but for a phenomenologist the phenomena", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00355-00081839-00082103": "consists of the primordial entities", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00356-00082104-00082231": "which are directly given to the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00357-00082232-00082423": "consciousness so there are objects and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00358-00082424-00082662": "events around us other people", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00359-00082663-00082950": "ourselves even in reflection our own", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00360-00082951-00083182": "conscious experiences as we experience", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00361-00083183-00083462": "them all these things constitute what we", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00362-00083463-00083726": "understand phenomena is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00363-00083727-00083926": "things as they are given to our", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00364-00083927-00084223": "consciousness whether in perception or", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00365-00084224-00084543": "imagination or thought or relation", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00366-00084544-00084638": "so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00367-00084639-00084815": "things as they are given to our", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00368-00084816-00085103": "consciousness directly given to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00369-00085104-00085343": "most in immediately given to all these", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00370-00085344-00085559": "are descriptions which phenomenologist", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00371-00085560-00085782": "used to describe the concept of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00372-00085783-00085959": "phenomena", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00373-00085960-00086175": "and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00374-00086176-00086375": "there are of course there are two types", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00375-00086376-00086638": "of phenomena we can we can designate and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00376-00086639-00086847": "particularly this distinction was very", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00377-00086848-00087038": "important when ah", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00378-00087039-00087182": "brentano", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00379-00087183-00087423": "ozil's produces a of course not a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00380-00087424-00087591": "phenomenologist he was a descriptive", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00381-00087592-00087847": "psychologist and huzzal also was trained", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00382-00087848-00087975": "by him too", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00383-00087976-00088094": "for some time", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00384-00088095-00088399": "so brentano is the one", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00385-00088400-00088671": "one thinker who has actually", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00386-00088672-00088806": "started", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00387-00088807-00089031": "taking this concept of phenomena to the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00388-00089032-00089311": "forefront of philosophizing", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00389-00089312-00089567": "and brendano does this in order to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00390-00089568-00089894": "distinguish the mental phenomena the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00391-00089895-00090182": "psychic phenomena from physical or", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00392-00090183-00090326": "material", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00393-00090327-00090575": "the events the the phenomena in the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00394-00090576-00090806": "material world so he wants to maintain a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00395-00090807-00091023": "distinction he would assert that the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00396-00091024-00091247": "mental phenomena is unique", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00397-00091248-00091343": "and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00398-00091344-00091575": "according to brentano we'll see it later", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00399-00091576-00091767": "what distinguishes the mental phenomena", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00400-00091768-00091967": "of physical phenomena is the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00401-00091968-00092118": "intentionality", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00402-00092119-00092303": "aspect of it so we'll come to that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00403-00092304-00092526": "result also in the beginning recognizes", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00404-00092527-00092759": "that there is a distinction but he would", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00405-00092760-00093055": "never associate intentionality with", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00406-00093056-00093238": "mental phenomena alone i will come to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00407-00093239-00093471": "that so mental phenomena what occurs in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00408-00093472-00093679": "the mind or acts of consciousness or", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00409-00093680-00093894": "their condense and physical phenomena", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00410-00093895-00094159": "are objects of external perception", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00411-00094160-00094391": "starting with colors and shape elaborate", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00412-00094392-00094638": "these concepts a little later now", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00413-00094639-00094815": "consider phenomenology hizerian", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00414-00094816-00094974": "phenomenology and its fundamental", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00415-00094975-00095126": "objectives", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00416-00095127-00095391": "as i already mentioned it it is a study", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00417-00095392-00095823": "of the phenomena and phenomena is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00418-00095824-00096055": "as we have seen experienced in various", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00419-00096056-00096271": "acts of consciousness they are directly", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00420-00096272-00096431": "given to consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00421-00096432-00096711": "and they are isolated by suspending all", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00422-00096712-00096935": "consideration of their objective reality", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00423-00096936-00097143": "or subjective association so this is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00424-00097144-00097447": "what phenomenology does precisely", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00425-00097448-00097535": "that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00426-00097536-00097735": "you try to isolate this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00427-00097736-00098062": "immediately given most primordial data", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00428-00098063-00098406": "of consciousness by separating them", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00429-00098407-00098591": "by applying a method the method of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00430-00098592-00098838": "reduction we will see it later", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00431-00098839-00099111": "by applying this method you separate", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00432-00099112-00099318": "this conscious", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00433-00099319-00099582": "immediately given data from all other", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00434-00099583-00099767": "associated", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00435-00099768-00099887": "knowledge", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00436-00099888-00100206": "about the reality about our subjective", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00437-00100207-00101047": "prejudices etc", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00438-00101048-00101159": "and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00439-00101160-00101374": "definitely another important thing is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00440-00101375-00101567": "phenomenology is associated with a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00441-00101568-00101862": "search for certainty", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00442-00101863-00102182": "it's a philosophy or particularly hazard", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00443-00102183-00102391": "conceives philosophy as a rigorous", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00444-00102392-00102566": "science dealing with ideal objects or a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00445-00102567-00102758": "senses of things originating in the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00446-00102759-00102990": "consciousness so once you can identify", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00447-00102991-00103215": "them and locate them and isolate them", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00448-00103216-00103439": "you have with you", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00449-00103440-00103566": "things which are", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00450-00103567-00103766": "the most primordial", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00451-00103767-00104039": "the essences of things which", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00452-00104040-00104223": "directly originate in the consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00453-00104224-00104423": "they are the fundamental data of all", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00454-00104424-00104639": "knowledge", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00455-00104640-00104799": "now ah", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00456-00104800-00104951": "as i already", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00457-00104952-00105071": "indicated", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00458-00105072-00105278": "the concept of phenomena when you when", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00459-00105279-00105486": "hazel develops this concept he was", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00460-00105488-00105719": "significantly influenced by brentano his", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00461-00105720-00105895": "own teacher", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00462-00105896-00106007": "and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00463-00106008-00106207": "i already mentioned this that brentano", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00464-00106208-00106334": "makes a distinction between", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00465-00106335-00106758": "psychological and physical phenomena", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00466-00106759-00106927": "and according to him", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00467-00106928-00107231": "what characterizes a mental phenomena is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00468-00107232-00107654": "intentionality the directedness of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00469-00107655-00107871": "experience in our consciousness when i", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00470-00107872-00108127": "see an object say for example the the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00471-00108128-00108334": "chair in front of me", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00472-00108335-00108671": "my consciousness about the chair is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00473-00108672-00108910": "directed towards an object the chair", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00474-00108911-00109119": "which is not there in my mind but which", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00475-00109120-00109271": "is outside", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00476-00109272-00109407": "so this is a very important", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00477-00109408-00109623": "characteristic feature of a mental", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00478-00109624-00109799": "phenomena according to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00479-00109800-00109975": "ah brentano", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00480-00109976-00110247": "and it exists intentionally in acts of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00481-00110248-00110463": "consciousness this is called intentional", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00482-00110464-00110727": "inexistence all mental phenomena exist", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00483-00110728-00110927": "in this way and it defines and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00484-00110928-00111158": "classifies the various types of mental", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00485-00111159-00111334": "phenomena he goes on doing that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00486-00111335-00111486": "elaborately", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00487-00111488-00111775": "now we will see how usual has", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00488-00111776-00111983": "appropriated this notion of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00489-00111983-00112215": "intentionality what makes user's", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00490-00112216-00112463": "position different", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00491-00112464-00112663": "every mental phenomenon or act of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00492-00112664-00112839": "consciousness is directed towards some", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00493-00112840-00113023": "object this is something which observe", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00494-00113024-00113295": "brentano as well as suzel share", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00495-00113296-00113390": "this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00496-00113391-00113678": "intentional directedness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00497-00113679-00113807": "constitute", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00498-00113808-00114078": "as a core of brentano's", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00499-00114079-00114295": "descriptive psychology though there is a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00500-00114296-00114510": "concept a thesis of intentional", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00501-00114511-00114734": "directedness that mental phenomena", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00502-00114735-00114958": "directed towards an object that exists", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00503-00114959-00115095": "outside", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00504-00115096-00115319": "and when it comes to huzzal", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00505-00115320-00115615": "husel replaces psychical phenomena with", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00506-00115616-00115815": "experiences or", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00507-00115816-00116078": "intentional experiences so here he is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00508-00116079-00116310": "not very happy with identifying or with", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00509-00116311-00116590": "the term psychical phenomena because", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00510-00116591-00116863": "results phenomenology as i already", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00511-00116864-00117078": "indicated in the beginning was also", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00512-00117079-00117447": "advocating a form of antipsychologism so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00513-00117448-00117783": "ah according to husser", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00514-00117783-00118119": "intentional means it aims at or refer to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00515-00118120-00118375": "something objective so it cannot be a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00516-00118376-00118647": "subjective feeling but rather it refers", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00517-00118648-00118854": "to something which is objectively out", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00518-00118855-00118966": "there", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00519-00118967-00119247": "also influenced by so in developing the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00520-00119248-00119431": "notion of intentionality and developed", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00521-00119432-00119575": "his own concept", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00522-00119576-00119902": "husel was influenced also by william", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00523-00119903-00120190": "james his principles of psychology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00524-00120191-00120343": "and now", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00525-00120344-00120534": "let us see the the principle of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00526-00120535-00120814": "intentionality discussed by hazel", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00527-00120815-00120958": "so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00528-00120959-00121158": "phenomenological kind of experience when", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00529-00121159-00121399": "you when phenomenologist", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00530-00121400-00121590": "tries to give an account of experience", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00531-00121591-00121807": "he says that says that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00532-00121808-00122143": "everyday experiences are intentional all", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00533-00122144-00122423": "day-to-day experiences are intentional", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00534-00122424-00122599": "but at the same time there is another", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00535-00122600-00122878": "problem like as an empiricist", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00536-00122879-00123190": "or as a philosopher who emphasizes on", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00537-00123191-00123375": "experience everyday experience or", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00538-00123376-00123647": "whatever experiences are always they", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00539-00123648-00123839": "always reveal their objects from a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00540-00123840-00124039": "perspective say for example", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00541-00124040-00124286": "when i see this pen", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00542-00124288-00124486": "when i see this pen", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00543-00124488-00124758": "like this let us keep it like this i", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00544-00124759-00125134": "don't see this this part of the pen", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00545-00125135-00125407": "okay i can see this only if i turn my", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00546-00125408-00125678": "head to this side then i can see this so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00547-00125679-00125975": "my for as far as i am concerned only", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00548-00125976-00126102": "this aspect", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00549-00126103-00126295": "only it is only revealed from this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00550-00126296-00126414": "aspect", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00551-00126415-00126671": "it is perspective in that sense but the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00552-00126672-00126790": "phenomenological account of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00553-00126791-00127023": "intentionality reconcile with the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00554-00127024-00127278": "objectivism of intentionality on the one", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00555-00127279-00127527": "hand perspectiveism or perspectivism of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00556-00127528-00127758": "empiricism on the other so it tries to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00557-00127759-00128039": "combine these two principles into a more", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00558-00128040-00128454": "comprehensive conception of experience", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00559-00128455-00128702": "principle of intentionality where", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00560-00128703-00128919": "consciousness is always consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00561-00128920-00129151": "about something so this aboutness is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00562-00129152-00129271": "emphasized", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00563-00129272-00129486": "it points to something outside the mind", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00564-00129488-00129790": "which is conscious of the object", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00565-00129791-00130007": "and everyday experiences are directed", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00566-00130008-00130223": "towards objects properties and states of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00567-00130224-00130334": "affairs so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00568-00130335-00130510": "this aboutness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00569-00130511-00130743": "is something which makes as one would be", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00570-00130744-00130847": "wondering", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00571-00130848-00131063": "uh a philosopher like usual is talking", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00572-00131064-00131351": "about consciousness he wants you to look", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00573-00131352-00131647": "inside your own consciousness and see", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00574-00131648-00131911": "what are the contents present there so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00575-00131912-00132231": "is it solipsism is it subjectivism", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00576-00132232-00132487": "so the answer probably is that it is not", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00577-00132488-00132663": "subjectivism because", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00578-00132664-00132759": "this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00579-00132760-00133039": "consciousness is not just consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00580-00133040-00133254": "in abstract there is nothing called an", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00581-00133255-00133478": "abstract consciousness a condensed", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00582-00133479-00133687": "consciousness consciousness is always", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00583-00133688-00133902": "treated as consciousness about something", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00584-00133903-00134214": "it points outwardly to an object in the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00585-00134215-00134302": "world", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00586-00134303-00134559": "so it cannot be merely subjective so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00587-00134560-00134727": "everyday experiences are directed", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00588-00134728-00134919": "towards objects properties and states of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00589-00134920-00135151": "affairs and though experience reveals", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00590-00135152-00135390": "its object from a perspective as i have", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00591-00135391-00135551": "already pointed out in the case of this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00592-00135552-00135647": "pen", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00593-00135648-00135902": "it is seen from a perspective", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00594-00135903-00136151": "but we are intentionally directed toward", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00595-00136152-00136423": "a full three-dimensional object but what", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00596-00136424-00136687": "i see is not this part of the pen", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00597-00136688-00137031": "my perception or my con my consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00598-00137032-00137263": "this pen is given", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00599-00137264-00137495": "as a complete object it's not just this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00600-00137496-00137743": "aspect of pen though i don't see it i", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00601-00137744-00137990": "don't see facades or all the aspects of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00602-00137991-00138247": "this pen", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00603-00138248-00138454": "now there are different modes of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00604-00138455-00138702": "consciousness for example", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00605-00138703-00139071": "presentation judgment love hate desire", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00606-00139072-00139239": "these are all different modes of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00607-00139240-00139454": "consciousness i have something there is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00608-00139455-00139719": "a consciousness when i desire an object", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00609-00139720-00139966": "again but all of them what is common to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00610-00139967-00140231": "all of them is they are all about", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00611-00140232-00140511": "something there is an aboutness there is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00612-00140512-00140863": "something which points outward to itself", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00613-00140864-00140951": "and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00614-00140952-00141231": "this is what is called transcending", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00615-00141232-00141447": "so objects are presented in experience", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00616-00141448-00141823": "as transcending in my mind alone but my", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00617-00141824-00142071": "mind or my consciousness point towards", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00618-00142072-00142287": "something that lies outside so there is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00619-00142288-00142502": "an element of transcendence there that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00620-00142503-00142735": "presented as going beyond the experience", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00621-00142736-00143039": "we have of them so as i mentioned the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00622-00143040-00143343": "experience i have of this pen is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00623-00143344-00143559": "confined to are limited to this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00624-00143560-00143902": "part of the pen not this part but still", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00625-00143903-00144078": "what i experience is not this part of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00626-00144079-00144335": "the pen but the whole pen", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00627-00144336-00144678": "the pen as such so in that sense", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00628-00144679-00144847": "they are presented as going beyond the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00629-00144848-00145047": "experiences we have of them", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00630-00145048-00145166": "again", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00631-00145167-00145478": "experience is perspective", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00632-00145479-00145702": "all experiences are perspective as i", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00633-00145703-00145983": "already mentioned but it also presents", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00634-00145984-00146159": "its object", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00635-00146160-00146463": "to us as transcending the perspective", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00636-00146464-00146766": "when we see a tree we do not see a mere", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00637-00146767-00147047": "image of the tree or a packet of sense", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00638-00147048-00147399": "data but we see the tree itself so here", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00639-00147400-00147814": "it goes beyond empiricism", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00640-00147815-00148102": "one theoretical position or theoretical", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00641-00148103-00148487": "aspect which is related to empiricism is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00642-00148488-00148719": "the image theory like we have already", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00643-00148720-00148966": "examined this when we discussed", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00644-00148967-00149247": "john locke's concept there is an image", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00645-00149248-00149487": "an idea which comes to the mind which is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00646-00149488-00149687": "not the object but there are several", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00647-00149688-00149935": "images the mind form several images", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00648-00149936-00150126": "certain id several ideas", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00649-00150127-00150390": "so perception enables us to go beyond", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00650-00150391-00150599": "the image which is presented to us this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00651-00150600-00150839": "is what because the object itself is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00652-00150840-00151007": "given to me", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00653-00151008-00151254": "we relate to the object itself as an", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00654-00151255-00151447": "image to a certain", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00655-00151448-00151726": "extra conscious object so we don't", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00656-00151727-00152023": "probably see all aspects of the object", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00657-00152024-00152271": "at a time because all experience is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00658-00152272-00152526": "perspective but what we see is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00659-00152527-00152783": "essentially related to that object so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00660-00152784-00152975": "for us what is given to us in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00661-00152976-00153223": "consciousness is the entire object as", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00662-00153224-00153454": "such", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00663-00153455-00153663": "we do not get a row", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00664-00153664-00153878": "uninterrupted", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00665-00153879-00153983": "image", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00666-00153984-00154199": "images in consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00667-00154200-00154399": "we get the data that are already", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00668-00154400-00154719": "interpreted as images of some objects or", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00669-00154720-00155039": "other so when i see this pen from this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00670-00155040-00155366": "part i get an image okay i get a data", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00671-00155367-00155526": "there is some data which is received by", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00672-00155527-00155766": "me but this data is not something which", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00673-00155767-00156063": "comes to me in isolation one by one but", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00674-00156064-00156302": "my reception of this data is already", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00675-00156303-00156431": "interpreted", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00676-00156432-00156687": "in a certain way i interpret it as an", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00677-00156688-00157031": "image or a data of the pen which i see", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00678-00157032-00157183": "so the pen as such is given in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00679-00157184-00157351": "consciousness and can discuss forms of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00680-00157352-00157583": "sensibility space and time", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00681-00157584-00157695": "he has", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00682-00157696-00157839": "shown that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00683-00157840-00157983": "objects", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00684-00157984-00158190": "the the sensibility for example the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00685-00158191-00158454": "objects are given through sensors", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00686-00158455-00158711": "already in a pre-ordered form so all", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00687-00158712-00158902": "seeing in one sense is understanding", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00688-00158903-00159143": "there is no pure seeing of an object so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00689-00159144-00159439": "similarly we get the data", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00690-00159440-00159726": "as already interpreted as images of some", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00691-00159727-00160047": "object or other", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00692-00160048-00160439": "so this is uh again uh as i mentioned", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00693-00160440-00160671": "well while developing the theory of uh", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00694-00160672-00160887": "the intentionality principle", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00695-00160888-00161159": "ozil was influenced by uh", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00696-00161160-00161478": "in his teacher brendan franz brendano", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00697-00161479-00161695": "and brentano", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00698-00161696-00161926": "says that every mental phenomena is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00699-00161927-00162095": "characterized by the intentional", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00700-00162096-00162366": "inexistence of an object we have already", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00701-00162367-00162559": "seen this it is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00702-00162560-00162831": "directed toward an object or imminent", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00703-00162832-00162999": "objectivity it's called imminent", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00704-00163000-00163199": "objective the objectivity", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00705-00163200-00163535": "is imminent to that process of being", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00706-00163536-00163639": "conscious", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00707-00163640-00163823": "of an object", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00708-00163824-00164038": "because it is directed towards an object", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00709-00164039-00164375": "that is outside", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00710-00164376-00164583": "every mental phenomenon contains", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00711-00164584-00164863": "something as an object within itself", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00712-00164864-00165087": "although not everyone does so in the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00713-00165088-00165383": "same way this object is the reference to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00714-00165384-00165623": "a content so there is a reference to a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00715-00165624-00165743": "content", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00716-00165744-00166143": "when i see a chair i see a chair not a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00717-00166144-00166414": "part of the chair so it is not just a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00718-00166415-00166631": "mental psychical phenomena in that sense", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00719-00166632-00166775": "there is something to which it is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00720-00166776-00167047": "directed to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00721-00167048-00167326": "but brentano's intentionality principle", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00722-00167327-00167590": "has some limitation we have already i", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00723-00167591-00167847": "have already indicated that that it aims", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00724-00167848-00168063": "at distinguishing the physical from the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00725-00168064-00168351": "psychical which was not actually the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00726-00168352-00168495": "purpose of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00727-00168496-00168671": "husserl", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00728-00168672-00168863": "this is because consciousness is always", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00729-00168864-00169143": "intentional according to brentano", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00730-00169144-00169383": "and in this context", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00731-00169384-00169638": "it becomes necessary for brentano to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00732-00169639-00169902": "initiate a study of consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00733-00169903-00169999": "because", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00734-00170000-00170190": "this is what intentionality is something", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00735-00170191-00170295": "which", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00736-00170296-00170447": "distinguishes", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00737-00170448-00170743": "psychical from physical and psychically", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00738-00170744-00170959": "is always found in the consciousness so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00739-00170960-00171166": "to capture that you have to study", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00740-00171167-00171302": "consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00741-00171303-00171566": "and also on the phenomena as they are", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00742-00171567-00171766": "directly given to consciousness so when", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00743-00171767-00172023": "i see something for instance let us take", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00744-00172024-00172302": "a very concrete example when i see a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00745-00172303-00172543": "ballpoint pen", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00746-00172544-00172943": "what is that which is given to me", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00747-00172944-00173126": "into my consciousness that is the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00748-00173127-00173302": "subject matter of inquiry i am just", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00749-00173303-00173526": "taking a very trivial very day-to-day", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00750-00173527-00173743": "kind of an experience", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00751-00173744-00173975": "uh every mental state contains its", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00752-00173976-00174231": "object completely within itself so this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00753-00174232-00174326": "pen", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00754-00174327-00174575": "i mean this i am conscious of a pen in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00755-00174576-00174838": "which not a part of pen i am conscious", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00756-00174839-00175247": "of i am conscious of this entire pen may", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00757-00175248-00175375": "not contain", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00758-00175376-00175566": "all the fine details of the pen say for", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00759-00175567-00175751": "example its color", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00760-00175752-00175871": "its shape", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00761-00175872-00176063": "its uh make", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00762-00176064-00176287": "the the material out of which it is made", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00763-00176288-00176487": "the things which are written on it", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00764-00176488-00176743": "all these things are details which which", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00765-00176744-00177038": "need not be known to me they understand", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00766-00177039-00177223": "that this is a pen there is something", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00767-00177224-00177478": "which is necessary for me to understand", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00768-00177479-00177702": "this as a ballpoint pen so when i", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00769-00177703-00177999": "understand this as a ballpoint pen or to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00770-00178000-00178214": "put it in other words in the language of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00771-00178215-00178543": "a phenomenologist when this pen is given", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00772-00178544-00178638": "to me", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00773-00178639-00178854": "given to my consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00774-00178855-00179126": "how my consciousness understands it", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00775-00179127-00179351": "what are those aspects which are", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00776-00179352-00179559": "captured by the consciousness that's the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00777-00179560-00179766": "subject matter of inquiry intentional", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00778-00179767-00180031": "object is imminent to the mental state", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00779-00180032-00180278": "now when you come to ozil results", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00780-00180279-00180487": "according to husel experiences are", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00781-00180488-00180678": "directed towards entities which are both", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00782-00180679-00180895": "mental and non-mental i have already", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00783-00180896-00181119": "said this there is no such distinction", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00784-00181120-00181271": "as far as the principle of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00785-00181272-00181543": "intentionality is concerned uh made by", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00786-00181544-00181687": "user", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00787-00181688-00181911": "he says that i do not see color", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00788-00181912-00182238": "sensations but colored things", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00789-00182239-00182478": "so when i see a red flower i don't say", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00790-00182479-00182759": "that i see i have sensations of redness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00791-00182760-00182983": "and sensations of flower", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00792-00182984-00183335": "i would say it's a red flower so i see", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00793-00183336-00183583": "sensations not sensations but colored", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00794-00183584-00183823": "things", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00795-00183824-00184143": "any kind of entity like physical objects", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00796-00184144-00184247": "persons", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00797-00184248-00184526": "numbers which are not spatial temporal", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00798-00184527-00184783": "particulars like a patch of blue", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00799-00184784-00185071": "universals like blueness state of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00800-00185072-00185359": "affairs mental entities like thoughts", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00801-00185360-00185687": "images and feelings etc can become an", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00802-00185688-00185943": "intentional object so the domain of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00803-00185944-00186254": "intentional objects are not confined to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00804-00186255-00186454": "psychical entities", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00805-00186455-00186678": "they include all these things according", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00806-00186679-00186847": "to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00807-00186848-00186990": "then", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00808-00186991-00187295": "he proposes a method to isolate this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00809-00187296-00187559": "directly given essences so there is a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00810-00187560-00187790": "definite method so this is another", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00811-00187791-00187935": "important aspect of fuzzerian", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00812-00187936-00188102": "phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00813-00188103-00188383": "it's not just a philosophy but", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00814-00188384-00188638": "also a method or rather", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00815-00188639-00188838": "to put it more accurately it is a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00816-00188839-00189111": "philosophical method a method that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00817-00189112-00189375": "combines a philosophical theory as well", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00818-00189376-00189454": "as", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00819-00189455-00189950": "a kind of practical application aspect", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00820-00189951-00190214": "phenomenology ah focuses on the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00821-00190215-00190526": "essential aspects which can be termed as", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00822-00190527-00190775": "the meanings the ultimate i mean most", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00823-00190776-00190943": "essential things are the meanings so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00824-00190944-00191175": "phenomenology tries to understand that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00825-00191176-00191511": "and it seeks to isolate the essences so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00826-00191512-00191766": "i've already indicated this that when", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00827-00191767-00191966": "you see this pen for instance let us", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00828-00191967-00192183": "take a very concrete example", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00829-00192184-00192295": "the pen is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00830-00192296-00192454": "in the language of phenomenologist the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00831-00192455-00192590": "pen is directly given to the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00832-00192591-00192911": "consciousness when i understand it now", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00833-00192912-00193023": "what is it", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00834-00193024-00193335": "for a phenomenologist to say that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00835-00193336-00193614": "i understand that this is a pen or an", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00836-00193615-00193847": "understanding the experience of a pen", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00837-00193848-00194031": "consists of what", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00838-00194032-00194278": "so i need to isolate the essence i have", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00839-00194279-00194471": "several details here i've already", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00840-00194472-00194663": "mentioned those details like the make of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00841-00194664-00194911": "the pen the material out of which the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00842-00194912-00195071": "pen is made the color of the pen the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00843-00195072-00195319": "shape of the pen all these things are", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00844-00195320-00195495": "aspects about the pen which are not", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00845-00195496-00195766": "really essential to understand what is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00846-00195767-00196047": "this object so all those aspects which", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00847-00196048-00196326": "are in essential needs to be removed", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00848-00196327-00196414": "and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00849-00196415-00196614": "come to that you know by removing those", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00850-00196615-00196823": "in essential aspects finally you reach", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00851-00196824-00196975": "the essence so that is what", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00852-00196976-00197207": "phenomenologist tries to do", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00853-00197208-00197343": "so everything", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00854-00197344-00197526": "perceived is bound to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00855-00197527-00197743": "bound up with the essence of perception", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00856-00197744-00197911": "which is different from the object that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00857-00197912-00198054": "exists in nature", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00858-00198055-00198238": "every intentional experience gives", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00859-00198239-00198350": "meaning", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00860-00198351-00198550": "has the essential characteristic of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00861-00198551-00198743": "giving some meaning", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00862-00198744-00199102": "so that is again the meaning giving act", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00863-00199103-00199302": "is the intentional act", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00864-00199303-00199623": "so when i am conscious of something", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00865-00199624-00199799": "that very process of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00866-00199800-00200038": "conscious of something is a meaning", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00867-00200039-00200199": "giving act", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00868-00200200-00200454": "which is done by the consciousness and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00869-00200455-00200687": "by the process of giving meaning to that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00870-00200688-00200902": "object the object is comprehended so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00871-00200903-00201102": "it's they cannot be separated they are", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00872-00201103-00201326": "not two different processes", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00873-00201327-00201550": "so in the process of comprehending the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00874-00201551-00201878": "object the meaning giving process also", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00875-00201879-00202119": "is completed let us see i have been", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00876-00202120-00202326": "taking examples of pen", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00877-00202327-00202526": "and as i myself", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00878-00202527-00202735": "mentioned that it's i'm taking a very", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00879-00202736-00202990": "trivial example like and a philosopher", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00880-00202991-00203143": "definitely is not interested in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00881-00203144-00203311": "understanding what is this object", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00882-00203312-00203495": "whether it is a pen or a chair or", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00883-00203496-00203687": "whatever these are something which", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00884-00203688-00203895": "everyone knows that this is a pen i've", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00885-00203896-00204143": "just taken this example to highlight the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00886-00204144-00204431": "important steps involved in a in a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00887-00204432-00204599": "process of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00888-00204600-00204790": "phenomenological understanding the aim", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00889-00204791-00204942": "of phenomenology is to grasp the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00890-00204944-00205214": "perceived as such grasp what is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00891-00205215-00205471": "essentially given not a part of it not", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00892-00205471-00205727": "an aspect of it but the entire thing as", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00893-00205728-00205910": "it is given to the consciousness the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00894-00205911-00206294": "phenomenon as meant needs to be captured", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00895-00206296-00206471": "and search for essences in the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00896-00206471-00206742": "consciousness domain of a sensor so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00897-00206744-00206927": "this is another very fundamental", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00898-00206928-00207134": "assumption of phenomenologist", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00899-00207135-00207414": "that consciousness is the most important", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00900-00207415-00207719": "domain of philosophical explorations", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00901-00207719-00207903": "every meaning because it's consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00902-00207904-00208175": "which gives meaning to the world it is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00903-00208176-00208382": "consciousness which brings the world", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00904-00208383-00208519": "into being", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00905-00208519-00208758": "even that is what says it is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00906-00208759-00208934": "consciousness which brings the world", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00907-00208935-00209119": "into being because if there is no", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00908-00209119-00209446": "consciousness the world as such lacks", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00909-00209448-00209646": "every being all meanings all values", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00910-00209648-00209758": "everything is brought by the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00911-00209759-00209975": "consciousness so consciousness is very", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00912-00209976-00210191": "important in that sense so search for", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00913-00210192-00210367": "consciousness the essences in the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00914-00210367-00210542": "consciousness which is the domain of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00915-00210544-00210775": "essences or meanings", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00916-00210776-00211039": "search for pure mental processes which", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00917-00211040-00211191": "are immanent to the sphere of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00918-00211192-00211415": "consciousness that invest investigates", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00919-00211416-00211639": "them and the focus is on pure", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00920-00211640-00211927": "consciousness so gradually by step by", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00921-00211928-00212206": "step he is taking us to an examination", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00922-00212207-00212463": "of pure consciousness initially you know", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00923-00212464-00212734": "you search for objects then you reach a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00924-00212735-00212919": "point where you struck at", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00925-00212919-00213094": "consciousness and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00926-00213096-00213342": "or rather your ego", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00927-00213344-00213575": "and its objects now what you have to do", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00928-00213576-00213831": "is that apply the same principle to your", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00929-00213832-00214039": "ego itself which will finally take you", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00930-00214040-00214271": "to the conception of transcendental ego", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00931-00214271-00214534": "a little bit more about consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00932-00214535-00214775": "and mental processes so these are some", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00933-00214776-00215015": "of those mental processes", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00934-00215016-00215382": "when i remember something imagining", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00935-00215383-00215487": "judging", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00936-00215488-00215615": "willing", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00937-00215616-00215751": "describing", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00938-00215752-00215855": "feeling", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00939-00215856-00216087": "perceiving all these are mental", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00940-00216088-00216215": "processes", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00941-00216216-00216446": "each has its own presence so in a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00942-00216448-00216671": "process of remembering something is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00943-00216671-00216791": "remembered", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00944-00216792-00217063": "something is imagined something is being", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00945-00217064-00217367": "judged something is being will", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00946-00217367-00217663": "something is described something is felt", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00947-00217664-00217846": "something is perceived", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00948-00217848-00218031": "what is that something", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00949-00218032-00218391": "it is it has its essence and to identify", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00950-00218392-00218575": "to locate that essence the method is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00951-00218576-00218775": "being suggested the method is the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00952-00218776-00219006": "phenomenological method in examining", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00953-00219007-00219246": "these we exclude what does not lie in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00954-00219248-00219519": "the mental act itself in the mental act", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00955-00219519-00219719": "of perceiving the mental act of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00956-00219719-00219967": "imagining the mental act of judging", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00957-00219967-00220079": "or feeling", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00958-00220080-00220271": "so what is it", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00959-00220271-00220527": "so everything else that do not lie in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00960-00220528-00220775": "the sphere of this mental act of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00961-00220776-00220998": "imagining or pressing or whatever needs", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00962-00221000-00221087": "to be", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00963-00221088-00221263": "eliminated", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00964-00221264-00221439": "so a method is devised for this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00965-00221440-00221727": "examination a method to build a science", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00966-00221728-00221951": "of essences because ultimately it deals", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00967-00221952-00222167": "with essences it examines the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00968-00222167-00222327": "consciousness which is a domain of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00969-00222328-00222623": "essences and tries to identify essences", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00970-00222623-00222855": "within consciousness which are imminent", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00971-00222856-00222951": "to that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00972-00222952-00223198": "to find the essence of consciousness by", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00973-00223200-00223503": "excluding what is not essential", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00974-00223504-00223782": "overcome the natural attitude so here", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00975-00223783-00224031": "khuzel talks very elaborately about", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00976-00224032-00224391": "something called natural attitude", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00977-00224392-00224646": "this is something which all of us", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00978-00224648-00224863": "subscribe to natural attitude which is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00979-00224864-00225167": "called natural attitude so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00980-00225167-00225351": "in essence what it is it is by", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00981-00225352-00225567": "suspending the spatial temporal world", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00982-00225567-00225879": "and focusing on pure mental processes so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00983-00225880-00226055": "what happens what is natural attitude", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00984-00226056-00226334": "see for for instance all of us we live", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00985-00226335-00226471": "in a world", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00986-00226471-00226710": "with a natural attitude for a taken care", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00987-00226711-00226927": "of kind of taken for granted kind of an", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00988-00226928-00227142": "attitude we don't reflect upon what is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00989-00227144-00227423": "going on around us i mean i am not even", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00990-00227423-00227606": "consciously aware of the fact that this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00991-00227607-00227791": "is a chair when i came and sat on this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00992-00227792-00227903": "chair", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00993-00227904-00228103": "i just take it for granted that this is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00994-00228104-00228303": "a chair by just seeing it i am not very", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00995-00228304-00228558": "consciously reflecting upon it i just i", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00996-00228559-00228791": "mean because things around me in this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00997-00228792-00229079": "world serves my purposes and there are", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00998-00229080-00229271": "several assumptions i have about things", "HzIHlDJyUCU-00999-00229271-00229494": "in this world all these assumptions put", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01000-00229496-00229710": "together constitute what i mean by what", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01001-00229711-00229846": "results means by", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01002-00229848-00230039": "natural attitude", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01003-00230040-00230319": "so we believe certain things we assume", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01004-00230319-00230479": "certain things we take for granted", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01005-00230480-00230623": "certain things", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01006-00230623-00230806": "we never question them we never reflect", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01007-00230807-00231158": "upon them so this taken for granted kind", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01008-00231159-00231398": "of an attitude and living on the basis", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01009-00231400-00231606": "of that attitude in this world certain", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01010-00231607-00231767": "meanings are already attached please", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01011-00231767-00231991": "opposed to objects", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01012-00231992-00232134": "a chair is something which i am going to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01013-00232135-00232367": "see i don't reflect upon it", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01014-00232367-00232582": "so this kind of an attitude needs to be", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01015-00232583-00232815": "questioned we have to set them aside", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01016-00232816-00232894": "and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01017-00232896-00233103": "such an attitude is an entrance for me", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01018-00233104-00233239": "to examine", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01019-00233240-00233494": "the object and its essence", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01020-00233496-00233687": "so the phenomenological reduction is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01021-00233688-00233919": "performed in this context the process of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01022-00233919-00234191": "bracketing or epoche the greek word", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01023-00234192-00234575": "which means cessation removal or taking", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01024-00234576-00234782": "keeping it aside there are certain", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01025-00234783-00235031": "things about an object which is not", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01026-00235032-00235263": "really required for understanding object", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01027-00235264-00235582": "so you just suspend them so that's what", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01028-00235583-00235839": "it is meant here suspending the spatial", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01029-00235840-00236071": "temporal world and focusing on pure", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01030-00236071-00236294": "mental processes you suspend all your", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01031-00236296-00236551": "judgment see when i see this pen it is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01032-00236552-00236823": "made up of plastic suspend it that's not", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01033-00236823-00237039": "very important for me to know what it is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01034-00237040-00237263": "it is blue in color again put it in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01035-00237264-00237494": "bracket i mean i am not just throwing it", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01036-00237496-00237687": "out but i am just putting it bracket and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01037-00237688-00237982": "not using it for the time being", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01038-00237983-00238271": "so gradually all those inessential", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01039-00238271-00238487": "features and aspects of the pen is being", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01040-00238488-00238791": "bracketed finally to reach a point where", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01041-00238792-00238942": "further bracketing would become", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01042-00238944-00239079": "impossible", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01043-00239080-00239239": "that point", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01044-00239240-00239423": "is where you capture the essence of the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01045-00239423-00239694": "object whatever it is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01046-00239696-00240039": "so here uh exclude all that is not", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01047-00240040-00240255": "genuinely imminent from the sphere of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01048-00240256-00240446": "absolute data so what is the absolute", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01049-00240448-00240694": "data the pen as it is given to me in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01050-00240696-00240927": "consciousness all other things color", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01051-00240928-00241223": "shape everything is in essential to that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01052-00241223-00241463": "so all those things are bracketed kept", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01053-00241464-00241575": "aside", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01054-00241576-00241871": "and what is intended is adequately given", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01055-00241871-00242015": "in itself", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01056-00242016-00242423": "so when i when this pen is given to me", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01057-00242423-00242623": "directly given to me", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01058-00242623-00242758": "i intend it", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01059-00242759-00243046": "i understand it my comprehension of it", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01060-00243048-00243382": "as a pen presupposes me intending it as", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01061-00243383-00243551": "a pen", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01062-00243552-00243767": "so this process is called bracketing", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01063-00243767-00244063": "setting aside or suspension of judgment", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01064-00244064-00244215": "is called bracketing", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01065-00244216-00244479": "a suspension of inquiry the object", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01066-00244480-00244727": "status as reality is suspended a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01067-00244728-00245030": "neutralization of our belief like we may", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01068-00245031-00245279": "believe a lot of things about an object", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01069-00245280-00245519": "all those beliefs are", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01070-00245519-00245742": "are bracketed suspended we are", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01071-00245744-00245887": "neutralizing them", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01072-00245888-00246151": "set aside everything that is external", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01073-00246152-00246358": "and the prejudices that we associate", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01074-00246359-00246679": "with the reality of the world and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01075-00246680-00246903": "concentrate only on the inner content of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01076-00246904-00247303": "our conscious act so it is a gaze inside", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01077-00247304-00247551": "like you look inside deep into your", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01078-00247552-00247727": "consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01079-00247728-00247927": "what is remembered in the act of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01080-00247928-00248167": "remembering imagined in the act of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01081-00248167-00248415": "imagination perceived in the act of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01082-00248416-00248534": "perception", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01083-00248535-00248734": "so that is the essence", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01084-00248735-00249039": "not other paraphernalia of processes and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01085-00249040-00249215": "things that might appear", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01086-00249216-00249398": "when a particular thing is being", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01087-00249400-00249551": "understood there are so many other", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01088-00249552-00249767": "things which we already know about it", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01089-00249767-00250167": "all those things need to be suspended", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01090-00250167-00250263": "there are", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01091-00250264-00250455": "actually different stages of reduction", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01092-00250456-00250694": "phenomenological reductions attempts to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01093-00250696-00250903": "focus on pure consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01094-00250904-00251182": "describes objects as they appear not in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01095-00251183-00251446": "their natural causal relationships we", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01096-00251448-00251687": "know everything is costly connected and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01097-00251688-00251951": "our understanding is when we understand", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01098-00251952-00252110": "an object we also", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01099-00252111-00252327": "know it in connection with other objects", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01100-00252328-00252503": "so all those connections everything", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01101-00252504-00252703": "needs to be suspended", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01102-00252704-00252910": "hence it is phenomenological and it is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01103-00252911-00253030": "transcendental it is called", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01104-00253031-00253198": "transcendental because it deals with the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01105-00253200-00253398": "conditions that make any knowledge", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01106-00253400-00253606": "possible that's given us to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01107-00253607-00253806": "consciousness it is the givenness of an", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01108-00253807-00253942": "object to consciousness which is a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01109-00253944-00254175": "precondition of all knowledge hence it", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01110-00254176-00254487": "is called transcendental now", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01111-00254488-00254775": "we'll wind up this lecture with by very", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01112-00254776-00254942": "briefly examining the three types of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01113-00254944-00255223": "reduction which josel proposes he says", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01114-00255223-00255406": "that there is a phenomenological", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01115-00255407-00255623": "psychological reduction probably there", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01116-00255623-00255863": "is no such hierarchy ozone would have", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01117-00255864-00256023": "imagined but of course there is a kind", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01118-00256023-00256191": "of an order we have to start with the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01119-00256192-00256455": "phenomenological psychological reduction", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01120-00256456-00256694": "which is a little negative which tries", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01121-00256696-00256958": "to avoid and eliminate unwanted", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01122-00256959-00257142": "information about the data which is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01123-00257144-00257279": "directly given", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01124-00257280-00257503": "and then aidatic is as the term", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01125-00257504-00257782": "indicates a dose means essences it is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01126-00257783-00258023": "more positive it tries to isolate the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01127-00258023-00258294": "essences concentrate on that and isolate", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01128-00258296-00258646": "it the third one is transcendental which", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01129-00258648-00258863": "probably is the ultimate", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01130-00258864-00259151": "objective or aim of phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01131-00259152-00259406": "so phenomena the psychological thing is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01132-00259407-00259606": "it is a gateway to phenomenological", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01133-00259607-00259903": "attitude from natural attitude i have", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01134-00259904-00260142": "mentioned what natural attitude is the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01135-00260144-00260287": "kind of taken", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01136-00260288-00260471": "for granted kind of an attitude about", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01137-00260471-00260758": "this world how the world works functions", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01138-00260759-00260871": "all these things we have certain", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01139-00260871-00261110": "assumptions we are not really", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01140-00261111-00261310": "conscious about them unless we start", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01141-00261311-00261510": "reflecting upon them we won't be able to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01142-00261511-00261710": "be conscious of them so a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01143-00261711-00261991": "phenomenologist needs to be careful he", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01144-00261992-00262358": "or she has to be aware of his or her", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01145-00262359-00262647": "prejudices and taken for granted kind of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01146-00262648-00262927": "an attitude in this world so natural", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01147-00262928-00263151": "attitude is bracketed", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01148-00263152-00263406": "description of mental acts free of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01149-00263407-00263567": "theories and presupposition there are so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01150-00263568-00263799": "many things which we know about things", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01151-00263800-00264063": "and events that happen around us so all", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01152-00264064-00264263": "those things have to be bracketed so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01153-00264264-00264527": "that ourselves from all presuppositions", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01154-00264528-00264719": "refrain from taking any natural", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01155-00264720-00264903": "objective position", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01156-00264904-00265206": "so now comes the second stage which is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01157-00265207-00265406": "called editic which is a little more", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01158-00265407-00265543": "important stage", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01159-00265544-00265887": "because it deals with edos or essences", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01160-00265888-00266110": "individual existence of the object in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01161-00266111-00266279": "question is bracketed since", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01162-00266280-00266534": "phenomenology is interested only in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01163-00266535-00266743": "essences", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01164-00266744-00267039": "so here it is it looks more positive", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01165-00267040-00267343": "there is a more positive look on", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01166-00267344-00267551": "the essences an attempt to try to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01167-00267552-00267799": "understand what an essence is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01168-00267800-00268071": "it elevates the edos the essences the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01169-00268072-00268367": "properties kinds of types ideal species", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01170-00268368-00268679": "that entities may may exemplify", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01171-00268680-00269071": "so the essences are being isolated", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01172-00269072-00269351": "properties kinds or types or ideal", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01173-00269352-00269567": "species", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01174-00269568-00269663": "though", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01175-00269664-00269919": "through free variation of individuals in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01176-00269920-00270158": "our imagination several individuals", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01177-00270159-00270415": "which belong to the same class we find", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01178-00270416-00270639": "out what characteristics these things", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01179-00270640-00270879": "have in common that's how you identify", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01180-00270880-00271095": "the essence so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01181-00271096-00271334": "let us go back to this so-called trivial", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01182-00271335-00271599": "example of ours pen", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01183-00271600-00271751": "there are thousand", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01184-00271752-00272015": "types of pens we would have come across", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01185-00272016-00272247": "in our day-to-day life", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01186-00272248-00272503": "these different types of pens might have", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01187-00272504-00272655": "something in common", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01188-00272656-00272903": "not the color not the shape not the make", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01189-00272904-00273119": "not the material but there is something", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01190-00273120-00273358": "in common so our mind and imagination", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01191-00273359-00273623": "can gaze through all these things", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01192-00273624-00273823": "through free variation of these", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01193-00273824-00274071": "individual pens in our imagination we", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01194-00274072-00274271": "can identify what is common to all of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01195-00274272-00274479": "them that is the essence", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01196-00274480-00274710": "and locate the invariant forms which are", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01197-00274711-00274871": "essences", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01198-00274872-00275103": "and now we come to the ultimate goal of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01199-00275104-00275367": "reduction which is transcendental", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01200-00275368-00275582": "subjectivity is the goal", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01201-00275583-00275879": "so this is probably the most important", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01202-00275880-00276158": "and interesting aspect of phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01203-00276159-00276415": "it indicates that reduction", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01204-00276416-00276582": "has the purpose", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01205-00276583-00276847": "to inhibit and take back", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01206-00276848-00277055": "as it were all references to the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01207-00277056-00277287": "transcendent as the intentional", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01208-00277288-00277575": "correlate of our acts and to trace them", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01209-00277576-00277799": "back to the imminent or transcendental", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01210-00277800-00278015": "acts in which they have their source", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01211-00278016-00278215": "this is from spielberg's book on", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01212-00278216-00278406": "phenomenology classic work", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01213-00278407-00278639": "where he says that to trace them back to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01214-00278640-00278895": "the imminent or transcendental acts in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01215-00278896-00279079": "which they have their source", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01216-00279080-00279303": "and husserl makes a very interesting", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01217-00279304-00279558": "observation here he says that i already", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01218-00279559-00279743": "referred i have referred to this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01219-00279744-00280023": "observation made by husal some time back", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01220-00280024-00280255": "without consciousness there would not be", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01221-00280256-00280495": "a world at all", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01222-00280496-00280727": "phenomenology has to study", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01223-00280728-00280958": "the rhythm of pure consciousness and the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01224-00280959-00281367": "essential formations found there", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01225-00281368-00281591": "so here comes the concept of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01226-00281592-00281767": "transcendental ego", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01227-00281768-00281895": "because", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01228-00281896-00282175": "as i mentioned phenomenologists", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01229-00282176-00282367": "are the final ultimate objective of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01230-00282368-00282599": "phenomenology is to transcendental is a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01231-00282600-00282806": "kind of transcendental reduction which", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01232-00282807-00282991": "ultimately takes us to the domain of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01233-00282992-00283247": "consciousness pure consciousness pure", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01234-00283248-00283382": "ego", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01235-00283383-00283558": "the proper understanding of ego is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01236-00283559-00283767": "essential that is probably where", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01237-00283768-00283951": "phenomenology concludes", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01238-00283952-00284206": "there is a fundamental problem with our", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01239-00284207-00284439": "understanding about the ego this is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01240-00284440-00284591": "again a very interesting observation", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01241-00284592-00284839": "because when we talk about ego", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01242-00284840-00285110": "or consciousness it is always linked", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01243-00285111-00285382": "with a notion of mind or something which", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01244-00285383-00285551": "is empirical something which is in this", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01245-00285552-00285647": "world", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01246-00285648-00285815": "the talk of ego brings the natural", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01247-00285816-00286030": "attitude into picture because we always", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01248-00286031-00286239": "find ourselves in a world of objects and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01249-00286240-00286358": "entities", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01250-00286359-00286606": "and bracketing to be applied to the ego", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01251-00286607-00286734": "as well now", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01252-00286735-00286951": "as we have seen phenomenological epoch", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01253-00286952-00287063": "bracketing", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01254-00287064-00287327": "is where you bracket all those aspects", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01255-00287328-00287599": "which are in essential about an object", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01256-00287600-00287799": "like in the case of the pen the peak the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01257-00287800-00288119": "color etc similarly the same method is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01258-00288120-00288399": "applied now to yourself to your", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01259-00288400-00288527": "ego", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01260-00288528-00288782": "and when you apply this method to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01261-00288783-00289006": "yourself when you apply the method of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01262-00289007-00289239": "bracketing to the ego the empirical ego", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01263-00289240-00289447": "there are several factors which", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01264-00289448-00289630": "might condition", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01265-00289631-00289919": "or qualify the empirical ego name place", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01266-00289920-00290103": "all those things all those things", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01267-00290104-00290334": "according to israel are inessential to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01268-00290335-00290551": "understand what the ego is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01269-00290552-00290758": "and you perform a kind of transcendental", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01270-00290759-00290958": "reduction of the ego which finally takes", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01271-00290959-00291047": "you to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01272-00291048-00291282": "a state further detection would be", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01273-00291283-00291606": "impossible so that part part i mean that", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01274-00291607-00291719": "moment", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01275-00291720-00291910": "one can we can say that we have captured", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01276-00291911-00292110": "the ego that is the transcendental ego", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01277-00292111-00292375": "the pure ego so what remains is the pure", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01278-00292376-00292639": "ego and its pure condense the condense", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01279-00292640-00292895": "of its consciousness so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01280-00292896-00293119": "this is the transcendental reduction", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01281-00293120-00293327": "where bracketing the ego and its", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01282-00293328-00293495": "intentions", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01283-00293496-00293703": "ceases to affirm the existence of the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01284-00293704-00293958": "ego as a psychological reality so it's", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01285-00293959-00294254": "not an empirical ego which finds itself", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01286-00294255-00294487": "in this world and stands against the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01287-00294488-00294767": "world as a subject", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01288-00294768-00294919": "i mean in a subject and object", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01289-00294920-00295127": "relationship in that sense a relational", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01290-00295128-00295454": "entity to this world no it is not it is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01291-00295455-00295743": "pure the empirical or psychological ego", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01292-00295744-00296095": "has to be set aside so the empirical and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01293-00296096-00296367": "psychological aspects of the ego is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01294-00296368-00296671": "bracketed suspended and what remains is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01295-00296672-00296951": "the pure ego this is from husser's", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01296-00296952-00297158": "cartesian meditations i quote by", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01297-00297159-00297430": "phenomenological epoch i reduce my", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01298-00297431-00297791": "natural human ego and psychic life the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01299-00297792-00297991": "rhythms of my psychological sense of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01300-00297992-00298230": "experience to my transcendental", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01301-00298231-00298495": "phenomenological ego the rhythm of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01302-00298496-00298663": "transcendental phenomenological", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01303-00298664-00298799": "self-experience", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01304-00298800-00299119": "so here we enter into the domain of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01305-00299120-00299215": "meaning", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01306-00299216-00299423": "not the consciousness of an individual", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01307-00299424-00299758": "human being but the essence of all", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01308-00299759-00299919": "meaning making", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01309-00299920-00300143": "so the essence of all meaning making", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01310-00300144-00300375": "it's not just one person's but the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01311-00300376-00300591": "essence of the meaning making activity", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01312-00300592-00300830": "itself what happens in all consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01313-00300831-00301030": "i may die this is an interesting", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01314-00301031-00301358": "observation which uh ozil made during", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01315-00301359-00301543": "the last days i mean in a private", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01316-00301544-00301751": "conservation to his friend he has stated", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01317-00301752-00302023": "that i may die but my transcendental ego", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01318-00302024-00302230": "is eternal it will not die", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01319-00302231-00302479": "and in that that actually this is one", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01320-00302480-00302727": "aspect of transcen the phenomenology the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01321-00302728-00302982": "transcendental phenomenology which uh", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01322-00302983-00303239": "result would russell had not worked out", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01323-00303240-00303415": "elaborately by the time he died", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01324-00303416-00303647": "unfortunately and also by the time he", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01325-00303648-00303806": "was very old", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01326-00303807-00304110": "and here this is probably had he", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01327-00304111-00304351": "developed this this aspect of", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01328-00304352-00304527": "phenomenology could have been really", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01329-00304528-00304639": "unique", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01330-00304640-00304871": "in western civilization because this is", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01331-00304872-00305110": "something which is very totally alien to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01332-00305111-00305415": "western thinking that conceiving an ego", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01333-00305416-00305503": "which", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01334-00305504-00305695": "i mean of course in plato's philosophy", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01335-00305696-00305839": "and in many other philosophies we have", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01336-00305840-00306206": "seen it but here uh uh it is you can see", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01337-00306207-00306439": "the transcendental ego which is eternal", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01338-00306440-00306695": "which is also again he talks about", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01339-00306696-00307054": "essence the essence of humanity etc so i", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01340-00307055-00307247": "don't want to compare it with anything", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01341-00307248-00307551": "in indian philosophy as such but i could", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01342-00307552-00307806": "i cannot avoid resemblances molarities", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01343-00307807-00307967": "this view has with", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01344-00307968-00308134": "the the conception which is there in the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01345-00308135-00308423": "upanishads about the self the atman the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01346-00308424-00308663": "brahman and all that and phenomenology", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01347-00308664-00308958": "is ultimately the philosophy of self so", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01348-00308959-00309239": "all phenomenology is ultimately a", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01349-00309240-00309406": "philosophy of the self it tries to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01350-00309407-00309606": "understand the self there are different", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01351-00309607-00309767": "phenomenologies phenomenology of the", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01352-00309768-00310030": "body of health", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01353-00310031-00310263": "and many things but", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01354-00310264-00310479": "ultimately all of them", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01355-00310480-00310751": "point to the consciousness to the self", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01356-00310752-00311030": "because the motto of phenomenology can", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01357-00311031-00311279": "be summarized in the statement back to", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01358-00311280-00311558": "things themselves and where do you go", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01359-00311559-00311879": "you go to the consciousness", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01360-00311880-00312158": "i think we'll wind up this lecture here", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01361-00312159-00312391": "as i already mentioned uh results", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01362-00312392-00312551": "influence suzerle has influenced many", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01363-00312552-00312839": "philosophers future thinkers and", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01364-00312840-00313095": "many philosophies like existentialism", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01365-00313096-00313295": "and hermeneutics and others we will be", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01366-00313296-00313479": "examining some of these contributions in", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01367-00313480-00313679": "the subsequent lectures of this lecture", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01368-00313680-00316223": "series thank you", "HzIHlDJyUCU-01369-00316224-00316431": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "HzPlBobrUyY", "text": {"HzPlBobrUyY-00000-00001492-00004228": "um uh", "HzPlBobrUyY-00001-00004229-00012129": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00002-00012130-00019683": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00003-00019684-00020052": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00004-00020053-00022483": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00005-00022484-00022628": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00006-00022629-00025283": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00007-00025284-00025452": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00008-00025453-00026683": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00009-00026683-00027008": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00010-00027008-00027702": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00011-00027704-00029483": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00012-00029483-00029702": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00013-00029704-00032641": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00014-00032642-00035083": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00015-00035084-00035202": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00016-00035203-00044883": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00017-00044884-00045201": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00018-00045202-00046283": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00019-00046284-00046706": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00020-00046707-00048215": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00021-00048216-00053153": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00022-00053154-00053282": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00023-00053283-00053384": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00024-00053385-00054682": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00025-00054683-00055107": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00026-00055108-00056082": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00027-00056083-00056215": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00028-00056216-00057482": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00029-00057483-00057604": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00030-00057604-00063082": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00031-00063083-00063296": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00032-00063297-00067282": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00033-00067283-00067629": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00034-00067630-00068682": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00035-00068683-00069118": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00036-00069119-00072882": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00037-00072883-00073119": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00038-00073120-00073665": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00039-00073666-00074282": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00040-00074283-00074724": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00041-00074725-00075682": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00042-00075683-00076226": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00043-00076227-00081282": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00044-00081283-00081588": "do", "HzPlBobrUyY-00045-00081589-00082782": "[Music]", "HzPlBobrUyY-00046-00082783-00082872": "you", "HzPlBobrUyY-00047-00082873-00083114": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "H-DKMxyAFRk", "text": {"H-DKMxyAFRk-00000-00000000-00000200": "so my job is to walk down memory lane", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00001-00000200-00000443": "and to give you ninety nine years of", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00002-00000444-00000869": "history in less than 15 minutes so i'm", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00003-00000869-00001082": "going to talk really fast you're going", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00004-00001083-00001214": "to see some things on the screen that", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00005-00001215-00001375": "we're going to try and highlight some", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00006-00001376-00001735": "things around campaign but also to tell", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00007-00001736-00001873": "you a little bit about socially what was", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00008-00001875-00002195": "going on during the period of time over", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00009-00002196-00002450": "the last 99 years so let's get started", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00010-00002451-00003089": "and 1910 actually 1914 spring a 1914 the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00011-00003090-00003344": "benevolent and non-sectarian institution", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00012-00003345-00003586": "board had its first initial meeting to", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00013-00003588-00003790": "plan the first United charities campaign", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00014-00003792-00003940": "and we were part of the Chamber of", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00015-00003942-00004190": "Commerce when we started and i nodi", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00016-00004191-00004502": "baird here is here tonight and so the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00017-00004503-00004685": "goal was really to limit the requests", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00018-00004686-00004927": "that donors were getting and to save", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00019-00004928-00005222": "fundraising costs in time our community", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00020-00005223-00005495": "was one of the first three cities in the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00021-00005496-00005801": "united states to start this concept and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00022-00005802-00005986": "i think that's a tribute to Cedar Rapids", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00023-00005987-00006224": "and the first four agencies that we", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00024-00006225-00006436": "funded work the home for the aged women", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00025-00006437-00006881": "what a name the sunshine mission and the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00026-00006881-00007178": "YMCA and YWCA I don't see home for aging", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00027-00007179-00008112": "men there but you know anyway", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00028-00008113-00008437": "the first the first campaign had ten", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00029-00008438-00008638": "solicitors it raised twenty four", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00030-00008639-00008814": "thousand nine hundred dollars and was", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00031-00008815-00009088": "led by archers and Clare and you'll see", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00032-00009089-00009310": "this cartoon the people riding on the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00033-00009311-00009646": "sleigh and being pushed other campaign", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00034-00009647-00009835": "chairs during that decade where Al", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00035-00009836-00010171": "Killian Reverend been whitwer and jst", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00036-00010172-00010467": "Lee and so you can see very prominent", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00037-00010468-00010716": "names the world war one it ended by the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00038-00010717-00011049": "end of the 19 by 1918 but the great", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00039-00011050-00011374": "influenza epidemic had hit by the time", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00040-00011375-00011627": "we move into the 1920s it was", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00041-00011628-00011851": "immigration and the United charities", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00042-00011852-00012119": "name was changed to the Community Chest", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00043-00012120-00012409": "those early campaigns were led by August", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00044-00012410-00012699": "reps he said we call our city we call", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00045-00012700-00012949": "our town a city with a soul let's prove", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00046-00012950-00013180": "it and eighty thousand dollars was", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00047-00013181-00013465": "raised in 1926 benefiting aid agencies", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00048-00013466-00013752": "under the leadership of Arthur po", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00049-00013753-00014044": "services were focused on immigrants AC", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00050-00014044-00014424": "Sinclair and HH cherry led the campaign", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00051-00014425-00014818": "but as we know in the 20s the 1929 stock", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00052-00014819-00015036": "market crash created community-wide", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00053-00015037-00015277": "unemployment and the campaign fell short", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00054-00015278-00015688": "by $25,000 the set up for President", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00055-00015688-00015871": "Roosevelt and the New Deal was just in", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00056-00015872-00016188": "place by the 1930s we moved into the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00057-00016190-00016474": "Great Depression as you know the focus", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00058-00016475-00016725": "of the campaign was to raise relief for", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00059-00016726-00016936": "all the unemployed workers and their", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00060-00016937-00017161": "families through a citywide campaign and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00061-00017162-00017383": "we raised a hundred and sixty-five", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00062-00017384-00017719": "thousand dollars think about that it was", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00063-00017720-00017887": "the largest fund drive in her city's", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00064-00017888-00018024": "history", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00065-00018025-00018292": "campaign chairs during those dick years", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00066-00018293-00018675": "where Arthur Paul HR green al Mulla", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00067-00018676-00018975": "cough and they finally help the campaign", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00068-00018976-00019375": "rebound in the mid-1930s but the most", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00069-00019376-00019558": "memorable of all the community leaders", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00070-00019559-00019849": "was John northcott and as you know the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00071-00019850-00020107": "northcott award is our most prestigious", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00072-00020108-00020400": "volunteer award and it's named after him", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00073-00020401-00020653": "John died before he could complete the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00074-00020654-00020944": "1934 campaign but we have his family", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00075-00020945-00021339": "here Barbara and Louise was obviously", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00076-00021340-00021655": "part of it and we are so indebted to", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00077-00021656-00021858": "John Northcutt and what he did all those", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00078-00021859-00022144": "years the first Council of social", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00079-00022145-00022390": "agencies was formed and this was to", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00080-00022391-00022603": "discuss community needs collaborative", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00081-00022604-00022792": "planning and to promote social", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00082-00022793-00023178": "improvement and as we know the 1930s was", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00083-00023179-00023331": "also the establishment of Social", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00084-00023332-00023556": "Security which a few of us in the room", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00085-00023557-00023955": "probably are getting is the 1940s were", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00086-00023956-00024261": "the Warriors Community Chest goals were", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00087-00024262-00024497": "exceeded during the World War two years", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00088-00024498-00024747": "campaigns were closely aligned with", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00089-00024748-00025078": "patriotic ideals and we saw the red", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00090-00025079-00025309": "feather this became one of the national", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00091-00025310-00025650": "symbols for united way it was patriotic", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00092-00025651-00025902": "to wear a feather it's a feather in your", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00093-00025903-00026115": "cap if you give to the community chest", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00094-00026116-00026485": "was one of the quotes and in 1942 we", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00095-00026486-00026626": "actually changed our name to the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00096-00026627-00026914": "community war chest because half of the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00097-00026914-00027170": "dollars that were raised in that year", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00098-00027172-00027499": "179 thousand dollars half was targeted", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00099-00027500-00027820": "to wartime relief sumner court and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00100-00027820-00028111": "general manager of WMT led the campaign", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00101-00028112-00028452": "and we had campaign chairs like robert", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00102-00028453-00028783": "armstrong and ivy mcgladrey and board", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00103-00028783-00029046": "chair william Baron for two years and I", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00104-00029047-00029106": "know the bear", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00105-00029107-00029457": "family is here tonight also for chair", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00106-00029458-00029610": "william baron was one of the first to", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00107-00029611-00029835": "ask for a community survey to establish", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00108-00029836-00030054": "what the needs were in the community and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00109-00030055-00030297": "it was also a period of time when United", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00110-00030298-00030504": "Way national began establishing a", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00111-00030505-00030717": "relationship with labor and that is", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00112-00030718-00031023": "continued to the state the top companies", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00113-00031024-00031191": "have donated during that time or the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00114-00031192-00031407": "cedar rapids gazette quaker oats and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00115-00031408-00031814": "marian actually ran its own campaign 12", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00116-00031816-00032142": "agencies were funded by then by the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00117-00032143-00032472": "1950s we had to name changes the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00118-00032473-00032643": "Community Chest of Cedar Rapids and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00119-00032644-00032892": "Marion and eventually the United fund of", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00120-00032893-00033201": "Cedar Rapids and Marion the agencies", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00121-00033202-00033384": "that were funded by the Community Chest", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00122-00033385-00033681": "were called red feather agencies and if", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00123-00033682-00033822": "you saw some of the memorabilia out", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00124-00033823-00033948": "there I think you saw some of the red", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00125-00033949-00034263": "feathers Frank 9 was the campaign chair", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00126-00034264-00034608": "in 1950 and there were 26 hundred dollar", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00127-00034609-00034785": "matches that were given that you know", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00128-00034786-00034968": "some of their first challenge grants we", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00129-00034969-00035304": "ever had Rockwell Collins became part of", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00130-00035305-00035550": "the campaign and Duane Arnold was the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00131-00035551-00035979": "campaign chair in 1953 it's not enough", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00132-00035980-00036195": "to be your brother's keeper he said you", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00133-00036196-00036597": "must be your brother's brother and 1954", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00134-00036598-00036816": "was the 40th anniversary already ugh", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00135-00036817-00037104": "United Way residents were asked to turn", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00136-00037105-00037320": "on their porch lights so canvassing", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00137-00037321-00037500": "volunteers could go door-to-door and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00138-00037501-00037953": "raise money and in 1955 norm Lipsky", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00139-00037954-00038363": "campaign chair set off six aerial bombs", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00140-00038364-00038736": "to herald the opening of the campaign so", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00141-00038737-00038907": "if any of you can be in chairs don't", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00142-00038908-00039305": "have any idea there is a few are you and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00143-00039306-00039774": "over 270,000 dollars were raised some of", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00144-00039775-00040020": "the plants that had fun drives were", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00145-00040021-00040343": "link-belt cryovac I was steal an iron", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00146-00040344-00040725": "quaker oats and 14 agencies were funded", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00147-00040726-00040779": "and we can", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00148-00040780-00041087": "but half a million dollar mark by then", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00149-00041088-00041480": "78 cities in Iowa had Community Chest", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00150-00041481-00042033": "models and by 1959 KCRG TV was a new", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00151-00042034-00042345": "medium for the campaign of heal by the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00152-00042346-00042614": "1960s our name had changed again to", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00153-00042615-00042936": "United Community Services and the public", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00154-00042937-00043130": "welfare board recommended that the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00155-00043131-00043374": "United fund separate from the Chamber of", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00156-00043375-00043583": "Commerce and become its own entity and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00157-00043584-00043793": "they hired their first executive", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00158-00043794-00044382": "director jas bill months all who many of", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00159-00044383-00044655": "you know chaired the campaign in 1965", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00160-00044656-00044877": "with the theme George can't do it alone", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00161-00044878-00045108": "and had this cartoon character", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00162-00045109-00045570": "everywhere in the city marshal Hardesty", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00163-00045571-00045824": "was board chair for two years and I know", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00164-00045825-00045993": "the Hardisty family is also represented", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00165-00045994-00046443": "and bobbya also chaired the campaign in", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00166-00046444-00046730": "the early 60s hmm there were two", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00167-00046731-00046917": "executive directors hired during this", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00168-00046918-00047174": "period of time Richard lamping and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00169-00047175-00047474": "Robert fatigue ax and one of the things", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00170-00047475-00047667": "that was emphasized was give your fair", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00171-00047668-00047985": "share one hour of pay per month to the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00172-00047986-00048282": "campaign it was also the war on poverty", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00173-00048283-00048555": "and many agencies were created there", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00174-00048556-00048749": "were civil rights movements Medicare and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00175-00048750-00048995": "Medicaid women's rights and for the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00176-00048996-00049254": "first time loaned executives were used", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00177-00049255-00049530": "when the national owed CEO asked", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00178-00049531-00049842": "companies to loan us an employee Jeff", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00179-00049843-00050039": "Kellogg from rockwell collins was one of", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00180-00050040-00050373": "the first and also we had campaign", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00181-00050374-00050604": "chairs like Clio Edwards Henry Madden", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00182-00050605-00050918": "George Lowe and board president Bob", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00183-00050919-00051083": "chatima and I know Bob is with us", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00184-00051084-00051600": "tonight thank you Bob in the 1970s our", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00185-00051601-00051791": "name was changed to United Way of Linn", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00186-00051792-00051917": "County you think we'd get the name right", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00187-00051919-00052212": "but we kept changing it seven times I", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00188-00052213-00052538": "think using the helping hands logo the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00189-00052539-00052686": "fourth and fifth executive director", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00190-00052687-00053022": "retired and Anita TURP stuff was the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00191-00053023-00053140": "first woman president", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00192-00053141-00053286": "of the board and Anita is with us", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00193-00053287-00053694": "tonight Thank You Anita campaign chairs", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00194-00053695-00053949": "like Tom parks and the Chairman who's", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00195-00053950-00054300": "here beryl justice Darryl Schumacher led", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00196-00054301-00054567": "the campaign to the 1.9 million dollar", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00197-00054569-00054879": "mark and board chairs Marshall Hardesty", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00198-00054880-00055303": "jr. Bernie REM strim and larry mcgrath", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00199-00055304-00055656": "helped lead the organization community", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00200-00055657-00055854": "action agencies were formed and mental", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00201-00055855-00056004": "health services were developed because", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00202-00056005-00056301": "of deinstitutionalization and one of the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00203-00056302-00056566": "quotes was all people have problems some", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00204-00056566-00056799": "just have more than others you need to", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00205-00056800-00057132": "help by the 1980s we acquired our", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00206-00057133-00057282": "current name the United Way of east", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00207-00057283-00057516": "central Iowa and our information and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00208-00057517-00057772": "referral service was developed by now", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00209-00057773-00057985": "our sixth director Tim nan had been", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00210-00057986-00058374": "hired and don knapp grandson of john d", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00211-00058375-00058611": "northcott serves as campaign chair and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00212-00058612-00059179": "board chair in the mid 80s Rick David", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00213-00059179-00059400": "was hired as our 7th executive director", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00214-00059401-00059623": "and panels were formed a community", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00215-00059624-00059892": "leaders and community members to talk", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00216-00059893-00060148": "about what were the social needs we had", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00217-00060149-00060316": "the farm crisis and the United Way", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00218-00060316-00060456": "played a role of bringing people", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00219-00060457-00060799": "together we also had great campaign", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00220-00060800-00061090": "chairs like Gordon epping Dick Johnson", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00221-00061091-00061609": "art Kristofferson and Cathy lamb who was", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00222-00061610-00062121": "our first woman campaign chair mmm and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00223-00062122-00062481": "four chairs Gary strike great picture", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00224-00062482-00063066": "there Gary and David Hughes", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00225-00063066-00063253": "doesn't everybody look young you're", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00226-00063254-00063687": "there right and our 75th anniversary was", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00227-00063688-00064078": "led by Dave Miller in 1989 and I think", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00228-00064079-00064273": "many of you know Dave he said nine out", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00229-00064274-00064443": "of ten people in our community were", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00230-00064444-00064873": "touched by United Way in the 1990s a", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00231-00064874-00065287": "familiar face to all of us led the 1991", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00232-00065288-00065607": "campaign Jack Evans raising 4.4 million", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00233-00065608-00065805": "dollars with a hundred-thousand-dollar", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00234-00065806-00066154": "anonymous gift Henry royer had preceded", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00235-00066155-00066418": "Jack and Don zeroth followed him and our", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00236-00066419-00066801": "first day of caring was held in 1993 the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00237-00066802-00067267": "first volunteer athan in 1994 197,000", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00238-00067268-00067534": "hours of volunteer time was pledged and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00239-00067535-00067907": "who could forget the olympic torch relay", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00240-00067908-00068179": "66 community heroes were chosen to be", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00241-00068180-00068524": "torchbearers Rick David talked about", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00242-00068525-00068754": "developing a human service campus in", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00243-00068755-00069130": "1994 great foresight it just didn't", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00244-00069131-00069391": "happen then and Lynn Nichols was hired", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00245-00069392-00069718": "as the eighth director we offer hope in", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00246-00069719-00069963": "times of despair was one of our quotes", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00247-00069964-00070226": "and campaign chairs during this period", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00248-00070227-00070528": "where your friends and colleagues Denny", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00249-00070529-00070846": "boatman Gary straight Cathy II know", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00250-00070847-00071187": "Terry Kristofferson at board chair Cathy", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00251-00071188-00071500": "lamb Linda duo susie mcdermot Cathy Ino", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00252-00071501-00071746": "and Terry Kristofferson you could tell", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00253-00071747-00072051": "the girls were definitely taking over at", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00254-00072052-00072621": "this", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00255-00072622-00072997": "in 2000 it was challenged and changed", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00256-00072998-00073222": "the lil rel dragan theme was launched", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00257-00073223-00073396": "sometimes you push sometimes you pull", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00258-00073397-00073642": "sometimes you ride and campy and chair", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00259-00073643-00073990": "Bruce Anderson had a very difficult time", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00260-00073991-00074256": "because it was right after 911 and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00261-00074257-00074554": "success although Bruce had 0 was", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00262-00074555-00074779": "overshadowed by the untimely death of", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00263-00074780-00074971": "Linda Nichols who was our executive", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00264-00074972-00075340": "director by 2003 to 11 had been", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00265-00075341-00075559": "developed our information a referral", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00266-00075560-00075820": "line which still exists today and by", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00267-00075821-00076227": "2004 we were supporting 35 agencies", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00268-00076228-00076486": "Milton Dennis was hired as executive", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00269-00076487-00076750": "director and then I was hired in", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00270-00076751-00077053": "November of 2004 following an interim", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00271-00077054-00077266": "period by Dick Johnson thank you dick", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00272-00077267-00077647": "and in the 2000s rec co-chaired the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00273-00077648-00077962": "2,000 campaign and got 29 million but it", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00274-00077963-00078172": "was Lydia brown who hit the 10 million", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00275-00078173-00078577": "dollar mark for the first time the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00276-00078578-00078784": "community impact model was revealed", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00277-00078785-00079080": "focusing on education income and health", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00278-00079081-00079366": "but some of this was unfortunately", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00279-00079367-00079621": "forgotten because of the epic flood of", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00280-00079622-00080017": "2008 United Way answered calls we", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00281-00080018-00080260": "coordinated volunteers and served on", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00282-00080261-00080464": "numerous committees to help in flood", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00283-00080465-00080761": "recovery the chairs during this period", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00284-00080762-00080956": "of time or all people you know and we", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00285-00080957-00081130": "don't have all their pictures there but", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00286-00081131-00081307": "all you have to do is look around the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00287-00081308-00081676": "room Chuck Peters Amy Johnson damn tease", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00288-00081677-00082030": "Jim tinker Jack Cosgrove Dennis Jordan", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00289-00082031-00082321": "Beth Maliki and of course John Bickle", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00290-00082322-00082609": "who had the year of the flood but set a", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00291-00082610-00082825": "record campaign thanks to gifts from the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00292-00082826-00082925": "Hulk right", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00293-00082926-00083261": "and in 2009 we broke ground on the new", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00294-00083262-00083717": "human service campus we relocated to our", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00295-00083718-00084143": "present location in January of 2011 the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00296-00084144-00084407": "human service campus now houses 13", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00297-00084408-00084689": "different agencies it was a 14 million", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00298-00084690-00084964": "dollar project chaired by Rexy know and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00299-00084965-00085238": "our campaign shares during this time", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00300-00085239-00085448": "Dennis Jordan and Beth malicki is our", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00301-00085449-00085706": "first young leader team couples like", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00302-00085707-00086042": "very and Gilda Boyer Tim Kitner who has", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00303-00086043-00086285": "hit our record thus far ten million five", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00304-00086286-00086456": "hundred and eighty thousand dollars and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00305-00086457-00086828": "mark and Kathy gulliksen and of course", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00306-00086829-00087926": "our current campaign chair flat rod and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00307-00087927-00088118": "I think we all around a big round of", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00308-00088119-00088298": "applause because he is doing a terrific", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00309-00088299-00088466": "job this year we're not through the", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00310-00088467-00088640": "campaign yet but it's looking very good", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00311-00088641-00089300": "so thank you", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00312-00089301-00089639": "so 2014 is our 100-year anniversary and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00313-00089640-00089924": "a new era we've come a long way our", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00314-00089925-00090101": "mission of helping those most in need", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00315-00090102-00090404": "has never changed I do want to send out", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00316-00090405-00090656": "a special thanks to Mary Sharpe share", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00317-00090657-00091160": "Jasper's who helped us tremendously and", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00318-00091161-00091325": "pulling some of this history together so", "H-DKMxyAFRk-00319-00091326-00091652": "thank you we really really appreciate"}}, {"audio_id": "H-FkgR0TaP4", "text": {"H-FkgR0TaP4-00000-00000000-00000221": "my name is Jesse Rowan I'm on the farm", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00001-00000222-00000515": "and agribusiness team within extension", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00002-00000516-00000713": "and I wanted to talk a little bit today", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00003-00000714-00000928": "about budgeting for vegetable Crop", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00004-00000930-00001062": "Production", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00005-00001063-00001307": "this is kind of my soapbox so I'll try", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00006-00001308-00001547": "to keep it short", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00007-00001548-00001829": "but to start with", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00008-00001830-00001960": "okay", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00009-00001961-00002107": "so", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00010-00002108-00002405": "I know a lot of y'all no matter what", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00011-00002406-00002681": "size your operation may not exactly", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00012-00002682-00002867": "correlate growing vegetables into", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00013-00002868-00003173": "budgeting I know the fun side of things", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00014-00003174-00003353": "is planting grow and harvesting", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00015-00003354-00003706": "vegetables but budgeting is a really big", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00016-00003707-00003995": "part of it today I'm going to go over", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00017-00003996-00004253": "the why the how and then some of the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00018-00004254-00004559": "resources we have available for you I'm", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00019-00004560-00004804": "going to start this slide with one of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00020-00004805-00005027": "the big reasons why you should budget", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00021-00005028-00005225": "increasing prices", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00022-00005226-00005399": "um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00023-00005400-00005772": "fertilizer you really no one can deny", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00024-00005773-00006070": "fertilizer gas prices just to name a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00025-00006071-00006286": "couple that prices have just gone up", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00026-00006287-00006587": "over the past year or two", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00027-00006588-00006892": "and so another one another one of one of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00028-00006893-00007133": "big reasons why you should budget in", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00029-00007134-00007313": "your vegetable production", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00030-00007314-00007642": "is that just being aware of those", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00031-00007643-00007919": "financial effects and you know being", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00032-00007920-00008119": "able to better control your spending", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00033-00008120-00008363": "that can lead to you making better", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00034-00008364-00008596": "financial decisions for your farm which", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00035-00008597-00008842": "can lead to profitability that's the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00036-00008843-00009059": "really big why so you're doing this so", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00037-00009060-00009221": "you can better plan for your operation", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00038-00009222-00009395": "and so you can better plan for", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00039-00009396-00009592": "profitability", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00040-00009593-00009863": "um budgeting is also just a really good", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00041-00009864-00010091": "management tool to have and it can", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00042-00010092-00010264": "provide a lot of answers to the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00043-00010265-00010601": "questions you have about your operation", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00044-00010602-00010787": "and so", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00045-00010788-00011045": "a little more into detail of why you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00046-00011046-00011278": "should so in your operation no matter", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00047-00011279-00011609": "what size you are you want to use the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00048-00011610-00011824": "resources you have to the best of your", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00049-00011825-00011969": "ability", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00050-00011970-00012124": "um second", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00051-00012125-00012341": "budgeting can really help you determine", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00052-00012342-00012587": "the viability of your operation you need", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00053-00012588-00012802": "to be able to pencil in a profit before", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00054-00012803-00013096": "you even plant or harvest because there", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00055-00013097-00013253": "are enough things outside of your", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00056-00013254-00013463": "control", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00057-00013463-00013697": "um y'all all grow things so you know", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00058-00013697-00013847": "that weather and all that can be", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00059-00013847-00014015": "extremely unpredictable so there's", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00060-00014016-00014158": "enough things outside of your control", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00061-00014159-00014477": "that having a plan to be profitable from", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00062-00014478-00014741": "the get-go is crucial", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00063-00014741-00014903": "um third budgeting can really help you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00064-00014904-00015065": "discover places that could use", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00065-00015066-00015286": "Improvement within your operation", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00066-00015287-00015443": "um things that could be leaner things", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00067-00015444-00015761": "that could be improved or more efficient", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00068-00015762-00016097": "and fourth just having your expenses", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00069-00016097-00016433": "planned out from the beginning can", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00070-00016434-00016625": "really benefit you because there are", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00071-00016626-00016877": "going to be expenses that pop up like I", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00072-00016878-00016979": "said before things that are", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00073-00016980-00017255": "unpredictable but being prepared and at", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00074-00017256-00017513": "least knowing the minimum of what you're", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00075-00017514-00017686": "going to spend or at least having an", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00076-00017687-00018119": "expected amount of expenses listed out", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00077-00018120-00018383": "um that just helps you better plan for", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00078-00018384-00018599": "your expenses and you know for those", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00079-00018600-00018953": "unpredictable things that may pop up", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00080-00018954-00019180": "and so", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00081-00019181-00019372": "if you're willing to start budgeting", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00082-00019373-00019607": "within your operation you might say Hey", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00083-00019608-00019841": "how do I start budgeting you know I've", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00084-00019842-00020105": "just been growing things for years I'm", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00085-00020106-00020339": "trying to actually budget everything out", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00086-00020340-00020525": "and see how much I'm spending see how", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00087-00020526-00020717": "much I'm earning the first step would be", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00088-00020718-00021022": "to assess what you have Machinery land", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00089-00021023-00021280": "anything any kind of fixed asset you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00090-00021281-00021377": "might have", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00091-00021378-00021677": "because that's really going to determine", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00092-00021678-00021821": "a lot of what you can do if you don't", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00093-00021822-00022103": "have a tractor and you want to grow you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00094-00022104-00022391": "know five acres or something you're most", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00095-00022392-00022571": "likely going to need a tractor or a lot", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00096-00022572-00022925": "of Labor and so just laying out and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00097-00022926-00023143": "understanding what you have access to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00098-00023144-00023494": "Second Look at predicted variable cost", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00099-00023495-00023783": "and that's going to be something that me", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00100-00023784-00023939": "or other extension agents can really", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00101-00023940-00024172": "help with help you with you can speak to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00102-00024173-00024377": "Farmers around you you can look at", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00103-00024378-00024605": "budgets and quotes online to figure out", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00104-00024606-00024808": "or at least get estimates on a lot of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00105-00024809-00025092": "variable expenses but the third step", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00106-00025093-00025372": "determining your fixed cost or your sunk", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00107-00025373-00025463": "costs", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00108-00025464-00025667": "that is going to be a lot more specific", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00109-00025668-00025912": "to your operation the sun costs are just", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00110-00025913-00026081": "going to be things that you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00111-00026082-00026381": "'ve spent money on and you can't get you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00112-00026382-00026561": "can't get your money back for it um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00113-00026562-00026783": "they're already sunk into your operation", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00114-00026783-00026957": "and the fixed costs are going to be", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00115-00026958-00027274": "things like Machinery large pieces of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00116-00027275-00027412": "equipment", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00117-00027413-00027479": "um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00118-00027480-00027683": "just even small equipment on your", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00119-00027683-00027964": "operation even the uh", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00120-00027966-00028181": "like uh some of the things you may use", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00121-00028182-00028427": "to outline your operation but those are", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00122-00028427-00028643": "going to be really specific to your", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00123-00028644-00028781": "operation you're not going to be able to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00124-00028782-00029062": "get those numbers from a neighbor or", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00125-00029063-00029212": "something like that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00126-00029213-00029543": "so every form is different", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00127-00029544-00029855": "so I I talk to people and I walk them", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00128-00029856-00030101": "through budgets every day they may see a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00129-00030102-00030274": "budget for someone that's growing the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00130-00030275-00030508": "same thing as them five miles down the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00131-00030510-00030677": "road and it's totally different than", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00132-00030677-00030983": "what their numbers are going to be for", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00133-00030983-00031193": "one you could have a totally different", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00134-00031194-00031361": "type of soil", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00135-00031362-00031439": "um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00136-00031439-00031679": "you could have to apply a lot of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00137-00031680-00031979": "amendments it may be a lot more rockier", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00138-00031980-00032189": "you may just have to spend a lot more", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00139-00032189-00032443": "time making that land workable", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00140-00032444-00032802": "second your location to markets", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00141-00032803-00033005": "depending on where you're at throughout", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00142-00033006-00033215": "the state and how you're", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00143-00033216-00033499": "willing to travel to sell your produce", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00144-00033500-00033749": "that's really going to make a difference", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00145-00033750-00033995": "in how you can Market your products and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00146-00033996-00034261": "what kind of prices you can get for them", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00147-00034262-00034517": "managerial ability is also going to be", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00148-00034518-00034702": "another thing that's different Farm to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00149-00034703-00034895": "farm someone may be doing this full-time", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00150-00034896-00035165": "someone may be doing it part-time you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00151-00035166-00035431": "know have a full-time job off the farm", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00152-00035432-00035651": "and just the time that they're able to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00153-00035652-00035809": "spend with it is going to be different", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00154-00035810-00036046": "like I mentioned a second ago the market", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00155-00036047-00036299": "Channel whether you're selling Wholesale", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00156-00036300-00036659": "direct consumer whether you're selling", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00157-00036660-00036874": "through a CSA those are all going to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00158-00036875-00037151": "depend those are all going to determine", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00159-00037152-00037517": "the pricing that you can use", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00160-00037518-00037733": "and just how your operation is going to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00161-00037734-00038105": "work machinery you may have inherited a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00162-00038106-00038440": "form from your inherited a form", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00163-00038441-00038687": "um just got some land from your dad but", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00164-00038688-00038849": "you need to buy a Machinery you need to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00165-00038850-00039052": "buy everything to get started on a farm", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00166-00039053-00039359": "you may have inherited land that came", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00167-00039360-00039629": "with a 20 year old tractor and you spend", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00168-00039630-00039785": "more on repairs than your next door", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00169-00039786-00039983": "neighbor but you know you're not", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00170-00039984-00040145": "spending a monthly payment on that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00171-00040146-00040361": "tractor every month so Machinery is", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00172-00040362-00040590": "going to be different from Farm to farm", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00173-00040591-00040901": "and depending on even what you buy the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00174-00040902-00041074": "scale of your operation and they spend", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00175-00041075-00041261": "more money get a larger tractor going to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00176-00041262-00041465": "have larger payments", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00177-00041466-00041927": "um but it might be more multi-use and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00178-00041928-00042137": "things like land pulse that's also that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00179-00042138-00042389": "falls intuitive it may be Lynn that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00180-00042390-00042607": "you're renting you might rent equipment", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00181-00042608-00043012": "but machinery and land costs and a lot", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00182-00043013-00043151": "of these things are just going to be so", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00183-00043152-00043373": "different Farm to farm depending on what", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00184-00043374-00043618": "you have to start with", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00185-00043619-00043889": "um what you're willing to take out money", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00186-00043890-00044189": "for and how much uh debt you're willing", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00187-00044190-00044393": "to take out to get started and then also", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00188-00044394-00044602": "you can't forget about access to labor", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00189-00044603-00044818": "depending on where you're located at you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00190-00044819-00045029": "may have you know better or worse access", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00191-00045030-00045239": "to labor", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00192-00045240-00045365": "um everyone knows that fruit and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00193-00045366-00045562": "vegetable production and speaking mainly", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00194-00045563-00045790": "to vegetables here but it's really labor", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00195-00045791-00046085": "intensive so you could plant five acres", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00196-00046086-00046295": "of watermelons but if you don't have", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00197-00046296-00046535": "enough people to pick them", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00198-00046536-00046768": "um it's going to be a really hard go", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00199-00046769-00047045": "once it comes Harvest Time and so you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00200-00047046-00047249": "really just need to think about the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00201-00047250-00047483": "access to labor whether you can use", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00202-00047484-00047723": "something like the h2a program if you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00203-00047724-00047927": "can if you're if you want to go through", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00204-00047928-00048130": "that process and get a handful of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00205-00048131-00048455": "workers or if you're in a location you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00206-00048456-00048611": "know where you can get other seasonal", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00207-00048612-00048958": "workers", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00208-00048959-00049312": "so any kind of budget that you find", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00209-00049313-00049708": "whether I really I promote extension", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00210-00049709-00049918": "budgets because I have worked on those", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00211-00049919-00050152": "for the past year and a half", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00212-00050153-00050218": "um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00213-00050219-00050483": "I think they have really accurate", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00214-00050484-00050674": "information and they've had a lot of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00215-00050675-00050885": "input from Specialists and Farmers alike", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00216-00050886-00051238": "but any budget that you use that's not", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00217-00051239-00051388": "from your Pharma budget that you get", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00218-00051389-00051580": "from somewhere else is really just going", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00219-00051582-00051899": "to be valuable framework for you to use", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00220-00051900-00052144": "it'll be really good to use as a base", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00221-00052145-00052361": "budget to kind of look at it see how", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00222-00052362-00052594": "things are broken down to see what the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00223-00052595-00052816": "expenses are and just kind of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00224-00052817-00053194": "how much the expenses how many how", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00225-00053195-00053416": "trying to say you know the amount of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00226-00053417-00053609": "expenses you spend pre-harvest or", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00227-00053610-00053788": "post-harvest you know how much you can", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00228-00053789-00054041": "expect to go towards Machinery", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00229-00054041-00054335": "um it's really just a good place to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00230-00054336-00054557": "start there and use it as a base and so", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00231-00054558-00054832": "once you use that budget on your farm it", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00232-00054833-00055037": "can become a wonderful Benchmark for you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00233-00055038-00055204": "to use within your operation something", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00234-00055205-00055565": "that you turn to year after year", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00235-00055566-00055709": "um that provides you really good", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00236-00055710-00056032": "insights into your operation if you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00237-00056033-00056237": "start using and updating it with numbers", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00238-00056238-00056488": "every year from your operation so after", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00239-00056489-00056663": "a handful of years you'll be able to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00240-00056664-00056849": "look at the differences from year to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00241-00056850-00057221": "year and see maybe if you switch to a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00242-00057222-00057413": "different irrigation system one year you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00243-00057414-00057641": "can see you know the different expenses", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00244-00057641-00057857": "and the different returns you got based", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00245-00057858-00058042": "off of that change that year you know if", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00246-00058044-00058271": "everything else remained the same you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00247-00058272-00058421": "can just look at different production", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00248-00058422-00058632": "systems say you make a pivot into", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00249-00058633-00059099": "organic whatever it may be really the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00250-00059100-00059321": "goal of an Enterprise budget is for you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00251-00059322-00059419": "to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00252-00059420-00059753": "integrate that into your farm and use it", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00253-00059754-00059992": "year after year and this these are", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00254-00059994-00060221": "important no matter how big or small", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00255-00060222-00060388": "your operation is I mean I've seen", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00256-00060389-00060676": "people use these on a half an acre and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00257-00060677-00060826": "really keep track of what they're", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00258-00060827-00061000": "growing in every square foot of that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00259-00061001-00061325": "half acre and really know the cost and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00260-00061326-00061619": "returns for each row for each crop that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00261-00061620-00061913": "they have", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00262-00061914-00062111": "so I'm going to delve deeper into", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00263-00062112-00062387": "Enterprise budgets specifically the ones", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00264-00062388-00062741": "provided through extension I wanted to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00265-00062741-00062909": "talk about some of the assumptions", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00266-00062910-00063065": "because I get a lot of questions about", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00267-00063066-00063341": "these budgets and like I mentioned a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00268-00063341-00063641": "moment ago I made most of them so I can", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00269-00063641-00063821": "answer about any question you may have", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00270-00063822-00064066": "for them but some of the assumptions", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00271-00064067-00064366": "that are in it they're based on a per", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00272-00064367-00064697": "acre basis so everything is you know an", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00273-00064698-00064900": "acre grown of watermelons an acre of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00274-00064901-00065176": "tomatoes but they all can be scaled down", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00275-00065177-00065387": "or scaled up depending on how big or", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00276-00065388-00065579": "small your operation is", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00277-00065580-00065729": "um you know they can be cut in half in", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00278-00065730-00065969": "quarters or even less if you're willing", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00279-00065970-00066167": "to do the math you know separate like", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00280-00066168-00066311": "that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00281-00066312-00066611": "um also so average prices are used", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00282-00066612-00066815": "that's because", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00283-00066816-00066959": "it would have been a really tedious", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00284-00066960-00067253": "budget if I listed the process for you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00285-00067254-00067450": "know 10 different types of watermelon", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00286-00067451-00067721": "seeds I just looked at watermelon seeds", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00287-00067722-00068026": "watermelon seed prices picked an average", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00288-00068027-00068255": "number in between those and you know use", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00289-00068256-00068447": "that in the budget because again this is", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00290-00068448-00068638": "just a guide it's not the numbers it's", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00291-00068639-00068765": "not the exact numbers you're going to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00292-00068766-00068981": "have on your operation", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00293-00068982-00069131": "um just something to give you a good", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00294-00069132-00069353": "guide to use and so", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00295-00069354-00069719": "also another assumption is that within", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00296-00069720-00069947": "this budget I kind of went under the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00297-00069948-00070121": "assumption that someone is growing this", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00298-00070122-00070288": "crop on an acre", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00299-00070289-00070475": "um they're using a truck and a trailer", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00300-00070476-00070726": "to haul that produce to a wholesale", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00301-00070727-00071141": "market and sell it all in one or two uh", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00302-00071142-00071399": "Soul lumps you know selling it just in", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00303-00071400-00071759": "big volumes at once or maybe twice", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00304-00071760-00071963": "um and again this is where it's greatly", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00305-00071964-00072119": "going to differ if you're selling direct", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00306-00072120-00072269": "to Consumers you're going to have a lot", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00307-00072270-00072406": "different costs and a lot different", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00308-00072407-00072661": "prices that you can get for the produce", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00309-00072662-00072994": "so assuming that it sold wholesale and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00310-00072995-00073288": "using the average interest rate also", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00311-00073289-00073571": "within the budget I assumed that the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00312-00073572-00073913": "land is rented that cost for renting the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00313-00073914-00074141": "land is included in the budget it's", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00314-00074142-00074321": "something that you know you're going to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00315-00074322-00074593": "want to either mix that completely", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00316-00074594-00074909": "if you know if the land is family land", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00317-00074910-00075076": "that you've had for years or if it's", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00318-00075077-00075287": "something you've bought you're going to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00319-00075288-00075503": "need to you know add in those payments", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00320-00075504-00075815": "or at least partial payments for it", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00321-00075816-00075917": "um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00322-00075918-00076067": "you know in the bottom part of that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00323-00076068-00076306": "budget within a fixed cost", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00324-00076307-00076582": "um the last thing that I feel like is", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00325-00076583-00076750": "crucial Within These Enterprise budgets", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00326-00076751-00077094": "is so these budgets are just", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00327-00077095-00077399": "measuring just a set of time for the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00328-00077400-00077567": "months of production for each of those", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00329-00077568-00077729": "crops so", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00330-00077730-00077962": "the budgets related to greens are like", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00331-00077963-00078329": "turnip greens that budget is set up on a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00332-00078330-00078491": "three-month", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00333-00078492-00078773": "time period because that's how short the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00334-00078774-00078959": "window is you know between planting and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00335-00078960-00079138": "harvesting of that crop some of the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00336-00079139-00079265": "other crops that are going to be longer", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00337-00079266-00079469": "they might be six months", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00338-00079470-00079715": "um and I do that so that you can kind of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00339-00079716-00079991": "Stack these and ultimately I'll touch on", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00340-00079992-00080182": "it more later but ultimately create like", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00341-00080183-00080441": "a whole Farm budget and that way you can", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00342-00080442-00080693": "kind of budget through the seasons of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00343-00080694-00080849": "the year you know so if you grow", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00344-00080850-00081041": "watermelons you know throughout the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00345-00081042-00081244": "summer and in the fall you plant a cover", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00346-00081245-00081665": "crop all of that would be put into your", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00347-00081666-00081838": "whole Farm budget but these Enterprise", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00348-00081839-00082282": "budgets are just broken down by crop and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00349-00082283-00082529": "on a per acre basis that's that's kind", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00350-00082530-00082726": "of the definition of enterprise budget", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00351-00082727-00082949": "in my mind is", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00352-00082950-00083381": "um how much you can expect to spend and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00353-00083382-00083765": "get in return for a specific crop on a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00354-00083766-00084076": "specific set acreage", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00355-00084077-00084311": "so I wanted to further break down the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00356-00084312-00084394": "budget", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00357-00084395-00084732": "so the Enterprise budget is set up into", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00358-00084733-00085150": "six really main categories uh some of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00359-00085151-00085432": "them are really just as as simple as one", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00360-00085433-00085882": "line in the budget so like I mentioned a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00361-00085883-00086141": "moment ago pricing is going to greatly", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00362-00086142-00086350": "depend on the market that you sell", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00363-00086351-00086669": "through and your timing so the budget I", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00364-00086670-00086873": "use for this presentation is watermelons", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00365-00086874-00087011": "if you can't tell that's what I've been", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00366-00087012-00087149": "mentioning the whole time", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00367-00087150-00087415": "so I wanted to show kind of the receipts", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00368-00087416-00087869": "uh the revenue section of this budget so", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00369-00087870-00088031": "this would be at the very top of it", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00370-00088032-00088211": "you'd have watermelons", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00371-00088212-00088523": "um an average yield and then a cost per", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00372-00088524-00088865": "unit and again this is wholesale", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00373-00088866-00089068": "um this is look at it wholesale prices", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00374-00089069-00089368": "for the whole season but everyone that's", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00375-00089369-00089626": "ever grown watermelons knows that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00376-00089627-00089897": "there's a peak uh a peak price you can", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00377-00089898-00090299": "get in early July this graph shows um I", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00378-00090300-00090515": "wish I could point it out", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00379-00090516-00090755": "but um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00380-00090756-00091073": "oh okay okay so everyone knows that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00381-00091074-00091367": "around July you can have", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00382-00091368-00091487": "um you can get a really good price on", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00383-00091488-00091655": "your watermelons if they were to come", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00384-00091656-00091829": "into season a little later you might", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00385-00091830-00092009": "fall into that low where prices are", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00386-00092010-00092356": "lower for Farmers as a whole so that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00387-00092357-00092555": "really that's where it's going to depend", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00388-00092556-00092825": "farmer to Farmer and how you sell your", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00389-00092826-00092975": "produce you may sell it to a grocery", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00390-00092976-00093485": "store for 350 each you may sell it at a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00391-00093486-00093665": "farmer's market you know for six dollars", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00392-00093666-00093905": "each because it's the beginning of July", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00393-00093906-00094126": "and that's what everyone's looking for", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00394-00094127-00094318": "and so there's usually a little Peak", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00395-00094319-00094547": "around August and September as well but", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00396-00094548-00094750": "again not nearly as noticeable as that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00397-00094751-00095218": "Peak you have in early July", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00398-00095219-00095447": "um and so the second one variable cost", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00399-00095448-00095729": "that is what makes up a majority of the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00400-00095730-00095921": "budget", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00401-00095922-00096203": "um this is where it breaks down kind of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00402-00096204-00096556": "the it's really the expected cost", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00403-00096557-00096797": "per acre of production of whatever the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00404-00096798-00097055": "crop may be and it's broken down it", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00405-00097056-00097259": "includes things uh some of the same", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00406-00097260-00097450": "things in every budget like a soil test", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00407-00097451-00097661": "because we everyone at extension", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00408-00097662-00097847": "recommends you get a soil test that way", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00409-00097848-00098135": "you're fertilizing accurately", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00410-00098136-00098543": "um and you know plants by by the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00411-00098544-00098926": "Thousand they all have this uh per unit", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00412-00098927-00099155": "uh basis right here that you can look", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00413-00099156-00099275": "and see", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00414-00099276-00099509": "um like the fertilizer is priced by the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00415-00099510-00099653": "unit that's something that my foreign", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00416-00099654-00099803": "agribusiness team we did a lot of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00417-00099804-00100024": "calculations to figure out the price per", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00418-00100025-00100199": "unit", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00419-00100200-00100438": "um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00420-00100439-00100679": "that way you know you're not looking at", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00421-00100680-00100943": "you know the price of because you know", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00422-00100944-00101309": "the the unit and the prices and the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00423-00101310-00101453": "weight are all going to vary depending", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00424-00101454-00101656": "on the blend that you get", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00425-00101657-00101753": "um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00426-00101754-00101993": "and also a lot of these herbicides", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00427-00101994-00102353": "Insecticide Fungicide categories that's", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00428-00102354-00102532": "something that's also going to vary", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00429-00102533-00102832": "greatly farmer to Farmer", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00430-00102833-00103078": "um all the recommendations that I got", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00431-00103079-00103258": "they all came out of that vegetable", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00432-00103259-00103523": "Grower's handbook that was my best", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00433-00103524-00103684": "friend when coming up with some of this", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00434-00103685-00103871": "information just seeing what we", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00435-00103872-00104044": "recommend and then I can call around and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00436-00104045-00104225": "figure out the prices and talk to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00437-00104226-00104356": "Farmers and see what they've actually", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00438-00104357-00104501": "spent", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00439-00104502-00104668": "um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00440-00104669-00104927": "just saying four so like land rent is", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00441-00104928-00105143": "accounted for in here but then I have a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00442-00105144-00105371": "line for crop insurance because I know", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00443-00105372-00105539": "not every farmer is going to have crop", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00444-00105540-00105665": "insurance but I wanted to be something", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00445-00105666-00105833": "they think of and something that they", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00446-00105833-00106097": "think to include in a budget because if", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00447-00106098-00106258": "you were to have a budget of your", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00448-00106259-00106445": "operation and you had crop insurance you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00449-00106446-00106654": "would definitely want to count that and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00450-00106655-00106840": "I know a lot of small farms don't", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00451-00106841-00107033": "necessarily have that especially a lot", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00452-00107033-00107290": "of Diversified operations don't but it's", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00453-00107291-00107423": "just something to think of and something", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00454-00107424-00107752": "you would need to include if you were to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00455-00107753-00107945": "have it for your operation", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00456-00107946-00108202": "and then also I've split up things by", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00457-00108203-00108545": "choice uh by pre-harvest and you know", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00458-00108546-00108875": "Harvest and post-harvest expenses just", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00459-00108876-00109151": "to uh hopefully assist people with a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00460-00109152-00109319": "little bit of plan and cash flow that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00461-00109320-00109493": "way you can kind of break it break it", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00462-00109494-00109721": "down and see you know how much I'm going", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00463-00109722-00109943": "to be spending before I you know even", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00464-00109944-00110183": "Harvest anything out of the ground and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00465-00110183-00110357": "then how much I'm going to be spending", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00466-00110358-00110873": "in a really short window of time", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00467-00110874-00111058": "um so the next category is really not", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00468-00111059-00111281": "even a whole category it's a line so", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00469-00111282-00111533": "underneath", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00470-00111533-00111731": "um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00471-00111732-00112031": "so underneath the variable cost you have", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00472-00112032-00112325": "your income above variable cost this is", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00473-00112326-00112666": "just how much you were to make if you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00474-00112667-00112973": "were to take you know your total revenue", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00475-00112974-00113158": "up here and subtract all your variable", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00476-00113159-00113333": "costs that's how much you have above", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00477-00113333-00113627": "that at that given time before you take", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00478-00113628-00113866": "away any of your fixed costs and that's", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00479-00113867-00114077": "because you know like I mentioned a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00480-00114078-00114275": "minute ago the fixed costs are so", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00481-00114276-00114425": "different from Farm to farm that's", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00482-00114426-00114628": "really hard for me to estimate what it", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00483-00114629-00114808": "is going to be for your farm whereas I", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00484-00114809-00115013": "can give a better estimate on the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00485-00115014-00115147": "variable cost", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00486-00115148-00115510": "and so the next category that's really", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00487-00115511-00115715": "big is important just because I can't", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00488-00115716-00115895": "estimate it as well as I can variable", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00489-00115896-00116134": "cost it's still really important it's", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00490-00116135-00116315": "just really specific to your operation", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00491-00116316-00116513": "that would be the fixed cost that's", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00492-00116514-00116699": "going to be things like depreciation of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00493-00116700-00116849": "your equipment", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00494-00116850-00117108": "land ownership you know if you were to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00495-00117109-00117371": "have a loan out for the landing balls", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00496-00117372-00117586": "they bought five acres for a farm and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00497-00117588-00117725": "you're paying the monthly payment on it", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00498-00117726-00117995": "you'd put that right here this is where", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00499-00117996-00118199": "all of the money you spend on your", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00500-00118200-00118433": "Machinery as far as repairs and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00501-00118433-00118583": "maintenance and depreciation is going to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00502-00118583-00118727": "go there and appreciation can be", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00503-00118728-00118889": "calculated", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00504-00118890-00119063": "um but the repairs and maintenance", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00505-00119064-00119183": "that's going to be something that you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00506-00119183-00119554": "can keep track of over the season", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00507-00119555-00119651": "um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00508-00119652-00120058": "and it's really we usually throw in an", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00509-00120059-00120304": "overhead a miscellaneous overhead charge", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00510-00120305-00120490": "in there just because we know there's", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00511-00120491-00120743": "going to be unexpected costs you know", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00512-00120744-00120995": "that spring up over the season we try to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00513-00120996-00121193": "just put a little bit of a cushion in", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00514-00121194-00121366": "there so that if you're calculating", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00515-00121367-00121547": "these numbers you have a little bit of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00516-00121548-00121889": "room in there for you know if some if", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00517-00121890-00122051": "the irrigation part breaks and you have", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00518-00122052-00122207": "to go buy it you know you've got a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00519-00122208-00122399": "little bit of cushion in there because", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00520-00122400-00122578": "everyone that's ever worked on a farm", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00521-00122579-00122758": "knows that things like that happen every", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00522-00122759-00122921": "day and that you always need to have a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00523-00122922-00123251": "little bit of cushioning for that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00524-00123252-00123463": "and so the last one is going to be", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00525-00123464-00123731": "returned and that's something I'll go", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00526-00123732-00123928": "back to this picture so", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00527-00123929-00124139": "after you come up with your total cost", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00528-00124140-00124397": "that's including variable and fixed cost", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00529-00124398-00124619": "you're going to then start separating", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00530-00124620-00124943": "you know returns to the operator", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00531-00124944-00125189": "the land the capital just you know", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00532-00125190-00125404": "returns to the farm as a whole and then", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00533-00125405-00125627": "also if you're an operator you want to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00534-00125628-00125777": "pay yourself", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00535-00125778-00126016": "these numbers are in here just kind of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00536-00126017-00126245": "as estimates because I know people are", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00537-00126246-00126454": "going to pay themselves different things", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00538-00126455-00126689": "they may pay themselves you know in", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00539-00126690-00126940": "another line they might write some of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00540-00126941-00127210": "their uh expenses some of the money that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00541-00127211-00127331": "they're going to pay themselves they", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00542-00127332-00127486": "might write that in at the top of the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00543-00127488-00127775": "budget you know is operator labor you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00544-00127776-00128002": "know doing stuff earlier in the year but", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00545-00128003-00128147": "this is really just going to show you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00546-00128148-00128465": "the bottom line of your operation", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00547-00128466-00128681": "um and how much money is being returned", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00548-00128682-00129023": "to your farm after all of the expenses", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00549-00129024-00129245": "have been accounted for", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00550-00129246-00129449": "um and also at the very bottom of these", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00551-00129450-00129683": "Enterprise budgets we have got a break", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00552-00129683-00130084": "even table that again it it looks like a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00553-00130085-00130295": "lot of numbers and this is not something", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00554-00130296-00130504": "I want someone to quote these numbers", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00555-00130505-00130781": "exactly for their operation it's just a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00556-00130782-00131116": "guide but I really like these Break Even", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00557-00131117-00131261": "tables and I should have mentioned this", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00558-00131262-00131387": "earlier but all of these Enterprise", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00559-00131388-00131669": "budgets can be played around with within", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00560-00131670-00132028": "Microsoft Excel you can plug and play", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00561-00132029-00132299": "any numbers Within These but these", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00562-00132300-00132545": "break-in Break Even tables they allow", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00563-00132546-00132773": "you to look at you know what if I were", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00564-00132774-00133157": "to raise my price a quarter per box", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00565-00133158-00133427": "um you know and say I made the same", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00566-00133428-00133631": "projected yield it kind of just shows", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00567-00133632-00133901": "you what your different uh", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00568-00133902-00134225": "income might be and of course this is", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00569-00134226-00134495": "all income above variable cost because I", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00570-00134496-00134663": "told you the the fixed costs are going", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00571-00134664-00134890": "to be so different from Farm to farm and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00572-00134891-00135173": "person to person but looking at the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00573-00135174-00135478": "income minus all the variable costs and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00574-00135479-00135761": "just how that can change like even you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00575-00135762-00135959": "could do the math you know do worst case", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00576-00135960-00136313": "scenario say I still uh say I still want", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00577-00136314-00136577": "to charge 350 but I produce you know 15", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00578-00136578-00136864": "less than I thought I was going to make", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00579-00136865-00137183": "I would still make this much money", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00580-00137184-00137573": "above my variable cost", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00581-00137574-00137939": "um it really just it can help you figure", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00582-00137940-00138137": "out how much revenue you need to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00583-00138138-00138311": "generate", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00584-00138312-00138521": "um looking at how much you're doing", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00585-00138522-00138719": "volume wise look at your variable", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00586-00138720-00138899": "expenses", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00587-00138900-00138989": "um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00588-00138990-00139211": "I really just like these because you can", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00589-00139212-00139439": "look you can scoot up and down this", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00590-00139440-00139619": "table and see even if I had to lower my", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00591-00139620-00139727": "prices", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00592-00139728-00140069": "to three dollars a box but if I could", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00593-00140070-00140357": "produce this many watermelons uh you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00594-00140358-00140507": "know I could make that much money which", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00595-00140508-00140728": "is just you know you can just compare it", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00596-00140729-00140969": "between prices and yields I really like", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00597-00140970-00141197": "having that flexibility and having being", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00598-00141198-00141611": "able to look at those different options", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00599-00141612-00141714": "um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00600-00141715-00142013": "and this I'm not going to go real real", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00601-00142014-00142289": "in depth on this but so after you've", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00602-00142290-00142493": "used an Enterprise budget within your", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00603-00142494-00142666": "operation", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00604-00142667-00143009": "um The Next Step would be to have a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00605-00143010-00143231": "whole Farm budget and this is something", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00606-00143232-00143428": "that's really great for determining the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00607-00143429-00143716": "overall profitability profitability of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00608-00143717-00143963": "your operation and you know how well", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00609-00143964-00144316": "you're using the resources you have", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00610-00144317-00144509": "um it's one of the best tools for", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00611-00144510-00144881": "analyzing the impacts of the goals of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00612-00144882-00145109": "the objectives of your farm", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00613-00145110-00145390": "it's really helpful to look at your farm", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00614-00145391-00145625": "as a whole and you know whenever you're", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00615-00145626-00145787": "coming up with this whole Farm budget", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00616-00145788-00145973": "that's a really great time to include", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00617-00145974-00146297": "those things like cover crops", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00618-00146298-00146525": "um it really just gives you a chance to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00619-00146526-00146789": "look at your farm you know on a year yet", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00620-00146790-00147089": "year to year basis not just three months", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00621-00147090-00147316": "here four months here six months here", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00622-00147317-00147569": "you know you may be spending just six", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00623-00147570-00147875": "months on the production of this one", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00624-00147876-00148073": "crop but what are you doing the other", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00625-00148074-00148307": "six months of the year you know how are", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00626-00148308-00148607": "you spending money or not spending money", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00627-00148608-00148840": "to benefit your farm you could be using", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00628-00148841-00148985": "it for just six months out of the year", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00629-00148986-00149297": "and you could throw together a whole", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00630-00149298-00149578": "Farm budget and realize oh if I planted", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00631-00149579-00149777": "a cover crop you know I might could use", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00632-00149778-00150109": "less fertilizer the next season you know", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00633-00150110-00150466": "or I might could grow this other crop in", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00634-00150467-00150689": "this six month window of time that I", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00635-00150690-00150869": "have it just can really open your eyes", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00636-00150870-00151169": "to the different opportunities you have", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00637-00151170-00151457": "um and how you can spread those costs", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00638-00151458-00151643": "out throughout the year and just how you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00639-00151644-00151871": "can manage your land and your farm well", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00640-00151872-00152237": "on a year yearly basis", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00641-00152238-00152483": "and I couldn't leave today without", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00642-00152484-00152795": "talking about budgeting in 2022 this is", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00643-00152796-00153023": "something I have gotten numerous calls", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00644-00153024-00153125": "about", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00645-00153126-00153293": "because like I said at the beginning of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00646-00153294-00153454": "the budget uh at the beginning of the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00647-00153455-00153702": "presentation that you don't want to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00648-00153703-00153947": "forego budgeting", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00649-00153948-00154193": "if for no other reason than the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00650-00154194-00154439": "increasing prices this year so everyone", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00651-00154440-00154595": "knows about the increasing process", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00652-00154596-00154901": "fertilizer gas and most Farmers know", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00653-00154902-00155099": "that they'll have to raise prices some", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00654-00155100-00155404": "this year just how everything else has", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00655-00155405-00155735": "gone up even just the gas to you know", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00656-00155736-00155993": "maybe deliver your crops has gone up you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00657-00155994-00156190": "know abruptly", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00658-00156191-00156526": "um and while there is a threshold you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00659-00156527-00156731": "know that the prices could be too high", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00660-00156732-00156989": "for consumers I wish I could say you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00661-00156990-00157337": "know charge solely based on your cost of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00662-00157338-00157583": "production and you know disregard to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00663-00157584-00157864": "what where the threshold is for your", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00664-00157865-00158014": "customers", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00665-00158015-00158207": "um you have to really find that happy", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00666-00158208-00158489": "medium because if you don't raise your", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00667-00158490-00158657": "prices you know it would it might be", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00668-00158658-00158945": "really hard I say it might be it would", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00669-00158946-00159131": "be really hard to make a profit this", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00670-00159132-00159311": "year just with these two big things", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00671-00159312-00159526": "having gone up so much", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00672-00159527-00159761": "um you can't abruptly raise your prices", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00673-00159762-00160007": "without thinking it through and just", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00674-00160008-00160199": "knowing you know", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00675-00160200-00160523": "having an idea of what my customers are", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00676-00160524-00160745": "willing to pay but also you have to look", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00677-00160746-00161039": "at how your costs have increased", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00678-00161040-00161411": "um and pass it on some and I wanted to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00679-00161412-00161561": "say that I wanted to list some of the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00680-00161562-00161716": "ways you know that you could come back", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00681-00161717-00161831": "that", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00682-00161832-00161904": "um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00683-00161905-00162233": "combat the increasing cost and you know", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00684-00162234-00162413": "the fight to not want to increase your", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00685-00162414-00162683": "prices too much so my first thing I", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00686-00162684-00163019": "would say to control what you can", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00687-00163020-00163078": "um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00688-00163079-00163301": "really uh", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00689-00163302-00163499": "you really don't want to leave you want", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00690-00163500-00163673": "to leave as little up to chance as", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00691-00163674-00163840": "possible you want to have", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00692-00163841-00164128": "a profit penciled out even if you have", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00693-00164129-00164314": "to Pivot even if even if you have to", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00694-00164315-00164495": "change your plan you want to have a plan", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00695-00164496-00164789": "set out at the beginning of the year", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00696-00164790-00165011": "um I'd recommend testing your soil you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00697-00165012-00165226": "don't want to guess on fertilizer", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00698-00165227-00165451": "application on a water application", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00699-00165452-00165707": "that's something that Andre de Silva", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00700-00165708-00165881": "could talk to you further about", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00701-00165882-00166193": "but you know just being as accurate and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00702-00166194-00166433": "efficient as you can controlling what's", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00703-00166434-00166613": "within your means", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00704-00166614-00166937": "um and you know maybe just thinking of", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00705-00166938-00167225": "ways to increase efficiency and the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00706-00167226-00167404": "leanness of your operation just where", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00707-00167405-00167633": "that's possible I know that's tough", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00708-00167634-00167831": "um but a lot of these extension agents", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00709-00167832-00167993": "can help you come up with you know", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00710-00167994-00168299": "Alternatives things that you could do uh", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00711-00168300-00168502": "some examples that come to the top of my", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00712-00168503-00168971": "mind could be Machinery you know either", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00713-00168972-00169204": "getting Machinery that allows you to do", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00714-00169205-00169349": "more", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00715-00169350-00169493": "um you know selling something that you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00716-00169494-00169649": "don't use as much you know and getting", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00717-00169650-00169945": "something that really has several uses", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00718-00169946-00170339": "using weed cloth as many times as you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00719-00170340-00170476": "can", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00720-00170477-00170651": "even if that's", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00721-00170652-00170795": "uh", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00722-00170796-00171040": "just you know whatever you can do within", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00723-00171041-00171281": "your means that can be things like uh", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00724-00171282-00171425": "cover crops like I mentioned on the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00725-00171426-00171640": "slide before something that helps you", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00726-00171641-00171893": "save money the next year", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00727-00171894-00172211": "um but really just focus on efficiency", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00728-00172212-00172654": "and have an open mind on Alternatives a", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00729-00172655-00172883": "lot of these price increases have led", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00730-00172884-00173159": "people to think about you know what", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00731-00173160-00173369": "could I do differently on my farm where", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00732-00173370-00173545": "could I source", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00733-00173546-00173740": "fertilizer you know in a different", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00734-00173741-00173963": "Source uh or you know in a different", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00735-00173964-00174245": "format you know maybe they've never used", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00736-00174246-00174431": "chicken litter before but they do know", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00737-00174432-00174557": "someone down the road that has chicken", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00738-00174558-00174821": "litter you know just being open to those", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00739-00174822-00175043": "Alternatives and", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00740-00175044-00175259": "trying to make it as efficient and lean", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00741-00175260-00175654": "wherever you can", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00742-00175655-00176014": "all right and I'm open to any questions", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00743-00176015-00176188": "um I hope I went through the budget", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00744-00176189-00176416": "pretty thoroughly I was hoping to do so", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00745-00176417-00176549": "because that's something I get probably", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00746-00176550-00176771": "the most questions on", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00747-00176772-00177052": "um but I'll take any questions or I've", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00748-00177053-00177454": "listed my contact information", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00749-00177455-00177557": "um", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00750-00177558-00177802": "and I also have a couple of links here I", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00751-00177803-00177988": "know you can click on these links but", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00752-00177989-00178157": "I'd be willing to send them to y'all or", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00753-00178158-00178325": "I may go ahead and put it in the chat", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00754-00178326-00178619": "these are links to record keeping sheets", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00755-00178620-00178864": "which help you have better budgets on", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00756-00178865-00179159": "your farm and also a link to the", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00757-00179160-00179428": "Horticultural Enterprise budgets that we", "H-FkgR0TaP4-00758-00179429-00179791": "have on the extension website"}}, {"audio_id": "H_4pN1yYmnM", "text": {"H_4pN1yYmnM-00000-00000215-00000511": "insomnia is one of the most common sleep", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00001-00000512-00000719": "disorders in the world it's often", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00002-00000720-00000950": "triggered by stressful traumatic life", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00003-00000951-00001183": "events such as a breakup or even a", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00004-00001184-00001423": "global pandemic in fact the recent", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00005-00001424-00001630": "international study found very high", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00006-00001632-00001855": "rates of insomnia symptoms during the", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00007-00001855-00002183": "first wave of cloven 19 about twice as", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00008-00002184-00002423": "high as those typically reported in", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00009-00002424-00002679": "non-pandemic times it's actually quite", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00010-00002680-00002879": "normal to have some occasional nights", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00011-00002880-00003047": "that you don't sleep well but for", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00012-00003048-00003263": "someone with insomnia they often have", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00013-00003264-00003575": "trouble sleeping even when they are", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00014-00003576-00003775": "having enough kind of opportunity to", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00015-00003776-00004022": "sleep or in a quiet and comfortable", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00016-00004023-00004191": "environment", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00017-00004192-00004454": "people with insomnia can also develop", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00018-00004455-00004735": "unhelpful behaviors such as going to bed", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00019-00004736-00004983": "too early or catastrophizing about a", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00020-00004984-00005206": "poor night's sleep this can make it", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00021-00005207-00005415": "harder to fall sleep in the long run", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00022-00005416-00005638": "that's why some experts recommend", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00023-00005639-00005895": "psychological treatments like cognitive", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00024-00005896-00006159": "behavioral therapy for insomnia compared", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00025-00006160-00006463": "to sleep medication hypnotic medication", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00026-00006464-00006742": "it is really as effective in the short", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00027-00006743-00006959": "term and of course it's much better in", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00028-00006959-00007231": "the longer term because it gives people", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00029-00007231-00007446": "the tools and skills to manage their own", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00030-00007447-00007542": "sleep", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00031-00007543-00007831": "but even small habit changes can make a", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00032-00007831-00008078": "difference if you get up around the same", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00033-00008079-00008359": "time that's going to really help making", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00034-00008360-00008655": "your body clock or circadian rhythm more", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00035-00008656-00008791": "consistent", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00036-00008792-00009110": "over time because our body clock is", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00037-00009111-00009335": "tuned by the light the first ray of", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00038-00009336-00009542": "sunshine that gets into our eyes that", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00039-00009543-00009814": "tunes our clock and so if you're able to", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00040-00009815-00010031": "get bright light when you wake up", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00041-00010032-00010191": "firstly in the morning that can be", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00042-00010192-00010463": "fantastic for tuning in the experts", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00043-00010464-00010751": "also advise spending less awake time in", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00044-00010752-00010951": "bed and avoiding sleep when you're", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00045-00010952-00011167": "feeling alert or agitated", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00046-00011168-00011303": "[Music]", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00047-00011304-00011551": "these simple strategies may be the key", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00048-00011552-00011919": "to getting a good night's rest", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00049-00011920-00012167": "the australian academy of science", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00050-00012168-00012894": "because questions need answers", "H_4pN1yYmnM-00051-00012895-00013103": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "H_7xFm1JAz4", "text": {"H_7xFm1JAz4-00000-00000512-00000857": "hello dear ones it's Alice I am of the", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00001-00000858-00001187": "Stars I have a report about the incoming", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00002-00001188-00001573": "geostorms for you and also some Intel on", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00003-00001574-00001948": "solving uh black magic trick that I", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00004-00001950-00002231": "encountered some years ago on 28", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00005-00002232-00002483": "February 2023", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00006-00002484-00002695": "there was an M", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00007-00002696-00003281": "8.6 class solar flare that is likely to", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00008-00003282-00003754": "create a mild G1 class geostorm here on", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00009-00003755-00004031": "Earth today and tomorrow the fourth and", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00010-00004032-00004469": "5th of March 2023", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00011-00004470-00004649": "yesterday", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00012-00004650-00005129": "3 March 2023 at about 10 a.m Pacific", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00013-00005130-00005497": "Standard time there was an X2 class", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00014-00005498-00005711": "solar flare", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00015-00005712-00006161": "that mild X flare produced a coronal", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00016-00006162-00006431": "mass ejection or CME", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00017-00006431-00006767": "that looks to me to be Earth directed", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00018-00006768-00007133": "if that is so then there may be a", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00019-00007134-00007492": "related geostorm two or three days from", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00020-00007493-00007798": "from now", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00021-00007800-00008119": "as you may know I have a theory that", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00022-00008120-00008428": "geostorms allow clearing of Earth", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00023-00008429-00008669": "malware", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00024-00008670-00008951": "you could say they shed much needed", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00025-00008952-00009209": "light on dark tangles in Earth's", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00026-00009210-00009431": "neurosphere", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00027-00009432-00009803": "I find from a clear perspective that I", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00028-00009804-00010156": "get insights into the dark a few days", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00029-00010157-00010601": "prior to geostorms", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00030-00010602-00011135": "and then ongoing into geostorms as well", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00031-00011136-00011446": "I will describe an Insight I had last", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00032-00011447-00011753": "night that I feel may have to do with", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00033-00011754-00012067": "the mild geostorm anticipated", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00034-00012068-00012503": "by space weather that's https colon", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00035-00012504-00013163": "slash slash www.spaceweather.com", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00036-00013163-00013480": "last Sunday at church I thought I", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00037-00013481-00013786": "spotted the leader of the West Coast", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00038-00013787-00014188": "section of a black magic group whom I", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00039-00014190-00014519": "had encountered at about solar maximum", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00040-00014519-00015071": "during solar cycle 24 about 11 years ago", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00041-00015072-00015365": "it was hard to tell because the person I", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00042-00015366-00015616": "thought might be she was wearing a", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00043-00015618-00016036": "coveted mask whether or not that is so a", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00044-00016037-00016325": "lot has come up both then at the church", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00045-00016326-00016607": "service and again last night in the", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00046-00016608-00016877": "dream time Realm", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00047-00016878-00017158": "at the church I was concerned about", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00048-00017159-00017519": "black magic spell casting as it seemed", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00049-00017520-00017717": "there were five people from the West", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00050-00017718-00018035": "Coast group at the church and I had", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00051-00018036-00018365": "issues with those people in regard", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00052-00018366-00018730": "to that priorly the specialty of that", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00053-00018731-00018983": "group 11 years ago seemed to me", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00054-00018984-00019372": "to be a psychic Swoon technique", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00055-00019373-00019679": "three people in the group would it seems", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00056-00019680-00019805": "to me", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00057-00019806-00020341": "aim energy and dark mantras or chants", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00058-00020342-00020680": "sub-vocally at various parts of my", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00059-00020681-00021005": "energy array and caused me to crumple up", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00060-00021006-00021305": "from a sitting position in a chair and", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00061-00021306-00021719": "lunch forward towards the floor", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00062-00021720-00022169": "the question was why would they do that", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00063-00022170-00022547": "what was the point anyway", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00064-00022548-00022894": "last night in a half dreaming State I", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00065-00022895-00023177": "got an answer from the leader of the", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00066-00023178-00023411": "West Coast group", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00067-00023412-00023753": "she said that the Nationwide leader of", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00068-00023754-00023872": "the group", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00069-00023873-00024299": "her black magic boss as it were", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00070-00024300-00024563": "had taught the West Coast group this", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00071-00024564-00024869": "technique to force the victims to obey", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00072-00024870-00025127": "his will", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00073-00025128-00025427": "according to my dream he told her that", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00074-00025428-00025781": "getting the victims to Swoon and faint", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00075-00025782-00026075": "five times during a meditation session", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00076-00026076-00026440": "would do this", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00077-00026441-00026777": "when I heard that I realized that both", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00078-00026777-00027052": "the West Coast group and the boss's", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00079-00027054-00027402": "Central United States group had had", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00080-00027404-00027712": "prominently displayed in the meditation", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00081-00027713-00028018": "room", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00082-00028019-00028379": "Shiva is known in Hinduism as the", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00083-00028380-00028546": "Destroyer", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00084-00028547-00029020": "the Lincoln is a stylized penis", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00085-00029022-00029374": "The Pianist represents a generative or", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00086-00029375-00029602": "creative power", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00087-00029604-00030214": "yet Shiva represents destructive power", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00088-00030216-00030617": "thus the Shiva lingam as I unfortunately", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00089-00030618-00030905": "learned about a decade ago", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00090-00030906-00031205": "might be a favorite of a confidence gang", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00091-00031206-00031540": "that practices murder", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00092-00031541-00031907": "to avoid recrimination when they fleece", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00093-00031908-00032440": "their victims for example", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00094-00032441-00032723": "it occurred to me last night that the", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00095-00032724-00032974": "Blackmagic group leader might have", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00096-00032975-00033340": "thought in his subconscious mind", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00097-00033341-00033629": "that the Shiva lingam in the meditation", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00098-00033630-00033817": "rooms", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00099-00033818-00034145": "represented his own penis", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00100-00034146-00034451": "and that it was his penis that exerted", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00101-00034452-00034805": "power over the group", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00102-00034806-00035261": "this is by way of subconscious imagery", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00103-00035262-00035639": "that might also explain why at least", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00104-00035640-00035993": "according to the psychic plane back then", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00105-00035994-00036581": "10 years ago I had terrible visions of", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00106-00036582-00036868": "the leader of that group cutting off the", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00107-00036869-00037139": "penises of the man in his group", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00108-00037140-00037427": "what that might signify whether the", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00109-00037428-00037793": "dream time realm or in real life or was", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00110-00037794-00038189": "it seemed to me that he wanted to know", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00111-00038190-00038596": "other men in the group to have", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00112-00038597-00038723": "power", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00113-00038724-00038861": "than", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00114-00038862-00039155": "he himself you see", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00115-00039156-00039443": "he wanted to be the only one with power", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00116-00039444-00039646": "in the group", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00117-00039647-00039935": "I would just like to say right now that", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00118-00039936-00040252": "if there was any physical fact to this", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00119-00040253-00040524": "then I consider this to be a completely", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00120-00040525-00041129": "inhumane and unethical thing to do", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00121-00041130-00041512": "I feel it's very wrong and I feel", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00122-00041513-00041771": "if he is taking control of the minds of", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00123-00041772-00041896": "people", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00124-00041897-00042455": "and then emasculating the men I feel it", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00125-00042456-00042755": "we should do our best as Christians to", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00126-00042756-00042946": "try and stop this kind of barbaric", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00127-00042947-00043499": "procedure I feel it should be illegal", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00128-00043500-00043817": "that's just an aside", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00129-00043818-00044146": "to continue the psychic Swoon or the", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00130-00044147-00044477": "Bowing down black magic trick", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00131-00044478-00044812": "might subconsciously be perceived", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00132-00044813-00045118": "as bowing down to the group Leader's", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00133-00045119-00045437": "penis", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00134-00045438-00045761": "then in that case one might negate the", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00135-00045762-00046049": "effect of the black magic technique in a", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00136-00046050-00046330": "very simple manner", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00137-00046331-00046624": "I thought one might construct a tissue", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00138-00046625-00046962": "paper version of the Shiva lingam", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00139-00046963-00047290": "visualize it as the black magic power of", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00140-00047291-00047629": "this wicked group of conjurers and then", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00141-00047630-00047873": "flattened the mock-up model with a", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00142-00047874-00048202": "hammer", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00143-00048203-00048479": "problem is this might adversely affect", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00144-00048480-00048911": "my romantic prospects I felt what man on", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00145-00048912-00048995": "Earth", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00146-00048996-00049240": "would cozy up to a woman who had", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00147-00049241-00049643": "flattened the Shiva lingam I wondered", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00148-00049644-00049889": "it might be better to just pretend to do", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00149-00049890-00050279": "such a thing telepathically", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00150-00050280-00050467": "I gave it a try last night", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00151-00050468-00050861": "telepathically and it worked like a", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00152-00050862-00051058": "charm", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00153-00051059-00051461": "nevertheless I suggest caution in using", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00154-00051462-00051851": "such a mean and angry visualization", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00155-00051852-00052480": "it just does not seem that a-okay to me", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00156-00052482-00052775": "you might ask what if the odds are", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00157-00052776-00053116": "greatly against me Suppose there are 35", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00158-00053117-00053488": "of those black magic people and only one", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00159-00053489-00053644": "of me", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00160-00053645-00054011": "if a mean and angry visualization does", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00161-00054012-00054347": "the trick and nothing else works", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00162-00054348-00054691": "how art one to proceed", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00163-00054691-00055187": "as kindly as possible I feel while still", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00164-00055188-00055547": "preserving the lives and their free will", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00165-00055548-00055766": "of those we love", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00166-00055766-00055925": "[Applause]", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00167-00055926-00056207": "to find out more about what happened to", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00168-00056208-00056435": "me with regard to that psychic Swoon", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00169-00056436-00056723": "about 10 years ago you can go to my", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00170-00056724-00056830": "website", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00171-00056832-00057091": "Awakening with planet Earth", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00172-00057091-00057491": "https colon slash slash Awakening with", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00173-00057491-00057875": "planet earth.com and search for the blog", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00174-00057876-00058180": "title compendium", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00175-00058182-00058391": "psychic murder", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00176-00058391-00058780": "bow down to me psychic Swoon that has", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00177-00058782-00059069": "links to all of the blogs regarding the", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00178-00059070-00059311": "psychic Swoon which I found", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00179-00059312-00059591": "extraordinarily traumatic and which I", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00180-00059591-00059950": "hope you never have to endure", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00181-00059951-00060280": "that's all for now dear ones God bless", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00182-00060282-00060503": "you all and keep you safe", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00183-00060504-00060976": "and be with you through all your days", "H_7xFm1JAz4-00184-00060977-00061327": "so long till next time"}}, {"audio_id": "H_qQmXO4G6y", "text": {"H_qQmXO4G6y-00000-00000162-00001355": "foreign", "H_qQmXO4G6y-00001-00001356-00002133": "[Applause]", "H_qQmXO4G6y-00002-00002134-00003581": "[Music]", "H_qQmXO4G6y-00003-00003582-00003825": "foreign", "H_qQmXO4G6y-00004-00003826-00004182": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "H_-mXl_PadM", "text": {"H_-mXl_PadM-00000-00000002-00001431": "[Music]", "H_-mXl_PadM-00001-00001432-00002127": "[Music]", "H_-mXl_PadM-00002-00002128-00003253": "[Music]", "H_-mXl_PadM-00003-00003254-00004206": "[Music]", "H_-mXl_PadM-00004-00004207-00004399": "keep on climbing if you take a law just", "H_-mXl_PadM-00005-00004400-00004591": "keep on trying can't trust everybody", "H_-mXl_PadM-00006-00004592-00004622": "keep", "H_-mXl_PadM-00007-00004623-00004822": "up y'all understand i don't live in the", "H_-mXl_PadM-00008-00004823-00004991": "slopes they know i'm blessed like i talk", "H_-mXl_PadM-00009-00004992-00005054": "to the pope", "H_-mXl_PadM-00010-00005055-00005215": "believe in myself man i know that i'm", "H_-mXl_PadM-00011-00005216-00005359": "dope i give them the game now they", "H_-mXl_PadM-00012-00005360-00005463": "calling me coach", "H_-mXl_PadM-00013-00005464-00005711": "i made it it was all survival every day", "H_-mXl_PadM-00014-00005712-00005918": "i wake up read the bible generational", "H_-mXl_PadM-00015-00005919-00006111": "curse i broke the cycle knew i had this", "H_-mXl_PadM-00016-00006112-00006191": "flow system", "H_-mXl_PadM-00017-00006192-00006383": "[Music]", "H_-mXl_PadM-00018-00006384-00006527": "i'm turning up and i'm about to go", "H_-mXl_PadM-00019-00006528-00006719": "global all of the media i don't got", "H_-mXl_PadM-00020-00006720-00006887": "soldiers when you blow up they swear", "H_-mXl_PadM-00021-00006888-00006967": "that they know", "H_-mXl_PadM-00022-00006968-00007119": "riding with my bible on the dash got me", "H_-mXl_PadM-00023-00007120-00007239": "praying through traffic cause i've seen", "H_-mXl_PadM-00024-00007240-00007351": "too much [__]", "H_-mXl_PadM-00025-00007352-00007495": "you don't know depression feel like to", "H_-mXl_PadM-00026-00007495-00007663": "your people that you love is laying", "H_-mXl_PadM-00027-00007664-00007855": "in them cats it's real impossible", "H_-mXl_PadM-00028-00007856-00008031": "because the competition is smaller", "H_-mXl_PadM-00029-00008031-00008246": "i go harder it wasn't easy watching kids", "H_-mXl_PadM-00030-00008247-00008423": "grow up without their father i said [__]", "H_-mXl_PadM-00031-00008424-00008471": "trying", "H_-mXl_PadM-00032-00008472-00008639": "i'm skipping [__] in lunch lines my", "H_-mXl_PadM-00033-00008640-00008960": "whole life i want the truth"}}, {"audio_id": "H__4TRZHiL8", "text": {"H__4TRZHiL8-00000-00000102-00000380": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "H_EvBYqG5pI", "text": {"H_EvBYqG5pI-00000-00000164-00000324": "[Music]", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00001-00000325-00001617": "[Applause]", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00002-00001618-00001910": "[Music]", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00003-00001911-00002079": "one thing about", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00004-00002080-00002369": "what exactly happened in this life", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00005-00002370-00002526": "[Music]", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00006-00002527-00002702": "to kill engineering partners of course", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00007-00002703-00002831": "who kitted", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00008-00002832-00003158": "about how have your strength helps you", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00009-00003159-00003447": "to succeed in life come to connor some", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00010-00003447-00003727": "parts of our roles and highest in life", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00011-00003728-00004038": "but not about naga you are", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00012-00004039-00004206": "some of the things that are you can see", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00013-00004207-00004375": "is a part of your strength because kira", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00014-00004376-00004535": "birandam whispered", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00015-00004536-00004638": "awaken", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00016-00004639-00004991": "the weakest link on the other hand", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00017-00004992-00005263": "has changed their strengths", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00018-00005264-00005495": "and one of the strength in life is about", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00019-00005496-00005679": "your acceptance you accept the latest", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00020-00005680-00005886": "life the weight yes uh now to", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00021-00005887-00006279": "acknowledge that this life sometimes", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00022-00006280-00006431": "those are some of the things become your", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00023-00006431-00006727": "strength not only about the strength but", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00024-00006728-00006934": "there are things that i think they are", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00025-00006936-00007134": "not okay", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00026-00007136-00007263": "but", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00027-00007264-00007398": "you can try", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00028-00007400-00007519": "to bear", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00029-00007520-00007703": "some simple", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00030-00007704-00007855": "uh", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00031-00007856-00008142": "challenges nazir patakua is part of your", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00032-00008143-00008255": "strength", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00033-00008256-00008374": "because", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00034-00008375-00012247": "this life of course", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00035-00012248-00012687": "[Music]", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00036-00012688-00012902": "know how to balance your questions that", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00037-00012903-00013046": "balancing of the questions", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00038-00013047-00013238": "are many people's become a charity", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00039-00013240-00013399": "because", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00040-00013400-00013599": "what an idea", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00041-00013600-00013815": "but she does", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00042-00013816-00014022": "when you have the better opportunities", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00043-00014023-00014222": "the better moments for you utilize our", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00044-00014223-00014471": "time very very cautiously and very well", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00045-00014472-00014686": "so that you can have some generating", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00046-00014687-00014911": "income to save and that one become a", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00047-00014912-00015143": "good thing for your life", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00048-00015144-00015279": "something else is about", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00049-00015280-00015391": "[Music]", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00050-00015391-00015607": "do something which is you are good at", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00051-00015608-00015791": "because sometimes you adapt but you have", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00052-00015791-00016783": "a lot of struggles", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00053-00016784-00017271": "travel too much", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00054-00017272-00017615": "if you can try what you call your best", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00055-00017616-00017871": "try what is possible you can end up", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00056-00017872-00018071": "water become your strength now pata you", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00057-00018072-00018279": "may be a way to succeed in life become", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00058-00018280-00019530": "any", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00059-00019531-00020418": "[Music]", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00060-00020419-00024255": "[Music]", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00061-00024256-00024494": "don't be uh underestimate yourself", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00062-00024495-00024663": "because sometimes it's about adam", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00063-00024664-00024775": "estimating", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00064-00024776-00024942": "you have been respected by people and", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00065-00024943-00025150": "appear you had estimated for yourself", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00066-00025151-00025494": "that is the very serious challenge so", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00067-00025495-00025790": "make sure that you have your", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00068-00025791-00025887": "a", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00069-00025888-00026206": "in spite of your weaknesses utilize", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00070-00026207-00026495": "most of your strength in accompanying", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00071-00026495-00026702": "give your goals which are achievable and", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00072-00026704-00026958": "those goals they adapt better in this", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00073-00026960-00027190": "way life or about", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00074-00027191-00027327": "so", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00075-00027327-00027558": "for me i can see some of", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00076-00027560-00027895": "my strengths i utilize this about when i", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00077-00027895-00028070": "i saw that", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00078-00028072-00028383": "the passion i had for it this idea", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00079-00028383-00028646": "utilized my iit a", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00080-00028647-00028902": "department and my t skills so that i", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00081-00028904-00029190": "catalyst nikakua i'm a good video editor", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00082-00029191-00029351": "i'm a", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00083-00029352-00029462": "actor", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00084-00029463-00029702": "and on the other side pierre una pata", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00085-00029704-00029983": "mit consultant so i can just have some", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00086-00029983-00030255": "web design uh solutions for you graphic", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00087-00030256-00030583": "design for you and some others all those", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00088-00030583-00030783": "are some of my strengths i use and i", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00089-00030783-00031111": "become better for the society because", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00090-00031112-00031262": "in our people in this experience this", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00091-00031263-00031583": "technology i.t has become the backbone", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00092-00031583-00031799": "for the development of technology and", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00093-00031800-00031918": "have bring", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00094-00031919-00032279": "the society to close of the world that", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00095-00032280-00032479": "is why you know but uh most of the news", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00096-00032480-00032623": "people are getting through there so", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00097-00032624-00032839": "media and now you have the platform that", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00098-00032840-00033046": "you can have that platform to me of", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00099-00033047-00033455": "izuri to make sure that uh", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00100-00033456-00033671": "what you can do what you're capable of", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00101-00033672-00034702": "now", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00102-00034703-00034990": "i can tell you that i have used my t", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00103-00034991-00035207": "skills to bring", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00104-00035208-00035415": "my food on the table and to make sure", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00105-00035416-00035535": "that", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00106-00035536-00035871": "i i make a necessary noise in the table", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00107-00035872-00036071": "in the even in the class when i love to", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00108-00036072-00036279": "give a better result even to the", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00109-00036280-00036583": "students among other", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00110-00036584-00036830": "so i'm i'm still a", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00111-00036831-00036959": "college tutor", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00112-00036960-00037151": "uh i'm an a consultant i'm a graphic", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00113-00037152-00037318": "designer all those are part of my", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00114-00037319-00037639": "strength and i love singing so one day i", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00115-00037640-00037815": "believe that i become a very good", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00116-00037816-00038007": "performance in singing despite i have", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00117-00038008-00038111": "not", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00118-00038112-00038351": "reached that level but at least i'm an", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00119-00038352-00038599": "actor i'm a skill writer", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00120-00038600-00038879": "i'm a i'm a director in a script all", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00121-00038880-00039039": "those are part of my strength i have", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00122-00039040-00039262": "used to succeed in this life i'm aiming", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00123-00039263-00039439": "for more and i believe", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00124-00039440-00039567": "this life", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00125-00039568-00039727": "you can give me even more of your", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00126-00039728-00040023": "strength and you do strength for better", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00127-00040024-00040351": "society and better world anyway let me", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00128-00040352-00040535": "enjoy this fruits i can see here in this", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00129-00040536-00040751": "garden over in this", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00130-00040752-00040999": "garden of england here i am i can have", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00131-00041000-00041223": "i'm one of the players in kenya you can", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00132-00041224-00041462": "enjoy half the sea good saline", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00133-00041463-00041807": "atmosphere for this thing let me have i", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00134-00041808-00042167": "enjoy and give a good atmosphere thank", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00135-00042168-00042313": "you for watching", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00136-00042314-00042855": "[Music]", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00137-00042856-00043062": "anyway guys as you can see in this", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00138-00043063-00043318": "garden of eden you can see various uh", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00139-00043319-00043551": "amazing fruits and this fruits are one", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00140-00043552-00043646": "of the", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00141-00043647-00043967": "things about agriculture which becomes", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00142-00043968-00044302": "the backbone of their society because as", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00143-00044303-00044599": "you can see here in this field the very", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00144-00044600-00044718": "meetings", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00145-00044719-00044967": "are becoming good and some of them are", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00146-00044968-00045230": "very bad but the saturn we have right", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00147-00045231-00045311": "now", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00148-00045312-00045599": "is that using this hashamba here you can", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00149-00045600-00045902": "see we have good good things and", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00150-00045903-00046111": "very many good vegetations you can see", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00151-00046112-00046398": "here newaykuhapu", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00152-00046399-00047423": "[Music]", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00153-00047424-00047720": "thank you for watching", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00154-00047721-00049158": "[Music]", "H_EvBYqG5pI-00155-00049159-00049368": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "H_bMusX4FxQ", "text": {"H_bMusX4FxQ-00000-00000008-00000142": "record", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00001-00000143-00000407": "i know i know wilma knows that i'm not", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00002-00000408-00000582": "good at turning on the recording however", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00003-00000583-00000774": "i had my finger on the button in case", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00004-00000775-00001023": "you forgot i know i've successfully", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00005-00001024-00001278": "turned it on twice now so you know", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00006-00001279-00001487": "i i win on the day", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00007-00001488-00001687": "if you have any issues with the with", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00008-00001688-00001910": "video or audio or big blue button", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00009-00001911-00002055": "generally just drop a comment in the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00010-00002056-00002271": "chat and we will do our best to assist", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00011-00002272-00002350": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00012-00002351-00002558": "uh with that let me uh let me turn the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00013-00002559-00002758": "presentation over to dave wiedemann to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00014-00002759-00002975": "get us started", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00015-00002976-00003367": "hello everybody can you hear me okay", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00016-00003368-00003679": "yes yep okay great thanks i am trying to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00017-00003679-00003975": "turn my video on and it says", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00018-00003976-00004254": "webcam not found no supported camera", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00019-00004255-00004415": "profile so i don't think that's going to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00020-00004416-00004647": "work so i hope it's okay if i go", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00021-00004648-00004863": "cameraless", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00022-00004864-00005143": "hi everybody um thank you for having us", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00023-00005144-00005391": "uh thank you to the project team i'm", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00024-00005392-00005575": "dave wiedemann and big thank you to the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00025-00005576-00005759": "sakai community alongside who have been", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00026-00005760-00005967": "sponsoring this work for a couple of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00027-00005968-00006118": "years", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00028-00006119-00006302": "um we are going to talk we're going to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00029-00006303-00006446": "go to the next slide we're going to talk", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00030-00006447-00006655": "today a little bit about our project the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00031-00006656-00006927": "open source health factors project", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00032-00006928-00007142": "a survey that we developed and gave to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00033-00007143-00007391": "the sakai community last month", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00034-00007392-00007551": "give you a little bit of the background", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00035-00007552-00007703": "on the survey and some of the early", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00036-00007704-00007855": "results the survey", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00037-00007856-00008023": "and then we're going to shift into what", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00038-00008023-00008246": "we call the three ponderables which we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00039-00008247-00008391": "think are the big questions that are", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00040-00008392-00008599": "raised by the survey data if you were at", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00041-00008600-00008855": "the lightning round at 12 50", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00042-00008856-00009046": "just an hour ago you would have seen", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00043-00009047-00009214": "these so they're coming back same three", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00044-00009215-00009414": "ponderables but the the difference in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00045-00009415-00009574": "this presentation the lightning round is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00046-00009575-00009759": "that we'll have a chance to engage with", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00047-00009760-00009927": "you around those questions and to get", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00048-00009928-00010119": "your help making sense of the data the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00049-00010120-00010327": "survey gave us", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00050-00010328-00010623": "so that's basically our plan for the day", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00051-00010624-00010903": "as josh said we might not have breakouts", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00052-00010904-00011031": "but we'll have some kind of discussion", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00053-00011032-00011303": "around those ponderables", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00054-00011304-00011663": "with that we can move on", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00055-00011664-00011887": "that's our plan okay so the health", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00056-00011888-00012038": "factors project give you a little", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00057-00012039-00012303": "background we can go to the next slide", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00058-00012304-00012438": "basically", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00059-00012439-00012542": "the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00060-00012543-00012759": "yes there we go the open source health", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00061-00012760-00013007": "factors project kind of has one goal", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00062-00013008-00013183": "one primary goal and that's to answer", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00063-00013184-00013415": "the first question what makes an open", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00064-00013416-00013647": "source community healthy", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00065-00013647-00013935": "and we have a particular definition", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00066-00013936-00014175": "of health and for the organizational", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00067-00014176-00014422": "context then we think healthy means that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00068-00014423-00014511": "the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00069-00014512-00014694": "community takes care of its people does", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00070-00014695-00014927": "its work well endures and thrives that's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00071-00014928-00015119": "a healthy organization healthy open", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00072-00015119-00015335": "source community so our primary goal is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00073-00015336-00015519": "to ask what what", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00074-00015519-00015775": "helps the an organization be healthy our", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00075-00015776-00016047": "secondary goal is to measure how do you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00076-00016047-00016207": "figure that out how do you measure that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00077-00016208-00016391": "if you have it and this is how we run", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00078-00016392-00016575": "about here's our pr our project timeline", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00079-00016576-00016735": "thank you for advancing", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00080-00016736-00016903": "uh we've been working on this a couple", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00081-00016904-00017191": "years uh first phase was basically a lit", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00082-00017192-00017407": "review of open source research and the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00083-00017408-00017543": "research on", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00084-00017544-00017703": "healthy organizations organizational", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00085-00017704-00017871": "development research", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00086-00017872-00018055": "we did a phase of observations and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00087-00018056-00018191": "interviews with members of the sakai", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00088-00018192-00018335": "community you may if you're from the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00089-00018336-00018543": "skype team you may have seen us sitting", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00090-00018544-00018694": "in the back in meetings and things like", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00091-00018695-00018799": "that and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00092-00018800-00019007": "asking a lot of questions from those two", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00093-00019008-00019286": "data sets we identified nine", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00094-00019287-00019463": "factors that we thought would be key to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00095-00019464-00019655": "healthy organizations and we group those", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00096-00019656-00019814": "in three categories so we're going to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00097-00019815-00020007": "share the categories and the factors", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00098-00020008-00020175": "with you in a minute", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00099-00020176-00020391": "um from those factors and categories we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00100-00020392-00020591": "developed a survey designed to you know", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00101-00020592-00020799": "test whether those factors were present", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00102-00020800-00020991": "in an organization", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00103-00020992-00021286": "um the survey we we uh developed and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00104-00021287-00021494": "tested um over the last few months and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00105-00021495-00021703": "we've just now started rolling out the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00106-00021704-00021894": "the tested version of the survey for", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00107-00021895-00022158": "actual use in rural organizations and we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00108-00022159-00022350": "and we have and we implemented it in the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00109-00022351-00022630": "sakai community last month so we have", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00110-00022631-00022807": "data from that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00111-00022808-00023063": "um last phase these last two phases you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00112-00023064-00023255": "can see them as cyclical", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00113-00023256-00023471": "uh we expect to do deployments", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00114-00023472-00023694": "refinements deployments kind of in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00115-00023695-00023991": "perpetuity as we go forward and use the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00116-00023992-00024191": "tool and and get better at using the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00117-00024192-00024294": "tool", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00118-00024295-00024391": "um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00119-00024392-00024542": "the first data are really interesting as", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00120-00024543-00024703": "you'll see so we think there's a future", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00121-00024704-00024903": "there if you're a member of an open", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00122-00024904-00025047": "source community", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00123-00025048-00025191": "and you're interested in using this", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00124-00025192-00025375": "survey with your community let us know", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00125-00025376-00025503": "just want to throw that pitch in there", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00126-00025504-00025639": "because we're looking for people to try", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00127-00025639-00026111": "it out i think we can move on", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00128-00026112-00026318": "the next slide", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00129-00026319-00026551": "so here's an overview of the survey that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00130-00026552-00026790": "we developed it's an online survey it's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00131-00026791-00027070": "got 41 overall questions 31 of those", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00132-00027072-00027255": "questions are really the meat", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00133-00027256-00027487": "and they're asking multiple choice", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00134-00027488-00027783": "questions about that that get us data on", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00135-00027783-00028046": "those nine factors that i mentioned and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00136-00028047-00028174": "we'll show you what those are in a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00137-00028175-00028262": "minute", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00138-00028263-00028383": "there's several multiple choice", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00139-00028383-00028543": "demographic questions because it's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00140-00028544-00028790": "important to know who's in the community", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00141-00028791-00029023": "as well and then uh one of the really", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00142-00029024-00029167": "interesting things about this survey is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00143-00029168-00029351": "it's multi it's mixed methods so there", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00144-00029352-00029527": "are these three questions at the end", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00145-00029527-00029862": "that are open-ended that we invite uh", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00146-00029863-00030031": "survey takers to tell us all kinds of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00147-00030032-00030167": "things and we get", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00148-00030168-00030335": "really interesting rich data we're gonna", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00149-00030336-00030518": "share some of that with you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00150-00030519-00030831": "um that the quick questions are what's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00151-00030832-00030983": "what do you like about your community", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00152-00030983-00031135": "what's one thing you would change and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00153-00031136-00031399": "what else do you have to tell us", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00154-00031400-00031590": "so you can imagine the kind of responses", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00155-00031591-00031783": "that we get from that are really", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00156-00031783-00031918": "interesting", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00157-00031919-00032087": "um the particular administration the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00158-00032088-00032246": "survey one month ago", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00159-00032247-00032439": "was the sakai community", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00160-00032439-00032639": "uh over the week september 21 october", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00161-00032639-00033039": "15th and we had 31 responses uh 70", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00162-00033040-00033215": "completion rate it took people about six", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00163-00033216-00033462": "six minutes so it's a pretty accessible", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00164-00033463-00033607": "online survey that you can do pretty", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00165-00033608-00033759": "quickly which is which is one of the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00166-00033760-00033927": "goals that we had", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00167-00033928-00034607": "i think we can move on to the next slide", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00168-00034608-00034767": "okay so a little bit of results we're", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00169-00034768-00034935": "going to share the categories and the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00170-00034936-00035062": "factors", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00171-00035063-00035295": "from the survey so we can just", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00172-00035296-00035527": "jump right to the next slide", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00173-00035528-00035751": "here we go so what did the sakai", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00174-00035752-00035990": "community tell us about", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00175-00035991-00036111": "itself", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00176-00036112-00036311": "uh when they took this survey", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00177-00036312-00036527": "um and so you're seeing here what we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00178-00036528-00036655": "call the categories these are the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00179-00036656-00036823": "highest level the highest level themes", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00180-00036824-00037015": "that we make that we organize when we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00181-00037016-00037143": "look at the data", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00182-00037144-00037383": "and the three categories are listed in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00183-00037384-00037551": "the left column we give them a color", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00184-00037552-00037646": "code", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00185-00037647-00037807": "because in the next slide we're going to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00186-00037808-00038039": "code the the factors by category so you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00187-00038040-00038230": "can know how they relate back to these", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00188-00038231-00038518": "for the record uh the colors match the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00189-00038519-00038767": "first letter of the category people is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00190-00038768-00038951": "purple task is teal organization is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00191-00038952-00039055": "orange", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00192-00039056-00039271": "um the basic idea of the category is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00193-00039272-00039430": "phrased as a question in the third", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00194-00039431-00039559": "column and then on the fourth column", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00195-00039560-00039735": "here you see of course the results this", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00196-00039736-00039902": "is what fourth common is what the ser", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00197-00039903-00040071": "the community told us", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00198-00040072-00040255": "in response to these", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00199-00040256-00040367": "questions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00200-00040368-00040462": "and we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00201-00040463-00040655": "plotted those means on a scale of one to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00202-00040656-00040807": "100 to make them a little bit easier to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00203-00040808-00040983": "parse and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00204-00040984-00041262": "we think a score over 80", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00205-00041263-00041518": "um is an excellent sign uh score in the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00206-00041519-00041790": "60-79 range means it's pretty decent but", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00207-00041791-00041967": "there might be a few little improvements", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00208-00041968-00042079": "you can make", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00209-00042080-00042343": "and a score below 59 means that there's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00210-00042344-00042567": "probably a more serious situation that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00211-00042568-00042727": "you need to look into", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00212-00042728-00043095": "so in the do we take care of our people", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00213-00043096-00043279": "yes we do really well at taking care of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00214-00043280-00043439": "our people that's what the results from", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00215-00043440-00043727": "our survey showed", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00216-00043728-00043855": "tasks", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00217-00043856-00044046": "how well we coordinate in our work", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00218-00044047-00044207": "pretty good maybe there's a couple", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00219-00044208-00044407": "places we can get better in that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00220-00044408-00044607": "category and same for organization", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00221-00044608-00044790": "pretty good overall maybe a few places", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00222-00044791-00044887": "to change", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00223-00044888-00045015": "so what we're looking at is a pretty", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00224-00045016-00045151": "healthy organization at the highest", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00225-00045152-00045262": "level", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00226-00045263-00045607": "particularly good and think here people", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00227-00045608-00045983": "we can move on to the next slide", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00228-00045984-00046207": "um these are the nine factors so these", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00229-00046208-00046502": "are nine more specific focus areas that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00230-00046503-00046695": "we think are related to organizational", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00231-00046696-00046879": "health so we're specifically testing for", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00232-00046880-00046990": "these", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00233-00046991-00047183": "the factor name is down in the left", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00234-00047184-00047271": "column", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00235-00047272-00047646": "the the category code is the color there", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00236-00047647-00047902": "so purple equals people teal equals task", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00237-00047903-00048095": "so on and then the basic idea again of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00238-00048096-00048286": "the factors phrase is the question and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00239-00048287-00048430": "the third column and then the means", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00240-00048431-00048518": "again", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00241-00048519-00048743": "uh rank uh plotted on a zero to 100", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00242-00048744-00048911": "scale just as before and what we're", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00243-00048912-00049086": "doing here is looking from we've got", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00244-00049087-00049318": "these ranked from the most positive to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00245-00049319-00049543": "the least positive and you can see big", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00246-00049544-00049743": "picture they're all pretty good right so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00247-00049744-00049958": "we're looking at the pretty pretty", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00248-00049959-00050102": "healthy organization across these", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00249-00050103-00050230": "factors", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00250-00050231-00050446": "healthier things are at the top", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00251-00050447-00050646": "and as we get bound as we move into the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00252-00050647-00050862": "yellows you can assume that in that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00253-00050863-00051015": "factor there's an area or two of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00254-00051016-00051183": "improvement and as we move further down", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00255-00051184-00051279": "the screen", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00256-00051279-00051438": "maybe there's a couple more areas of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00257-00051439-00051670": "improvement for the design factor than", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00258-00051671-00051894": "for the problem solving factor", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00259-00051895-00052126": "so that that's kind of the overall", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00260-00052127-00052447": "look of these things and so just", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00261-00052448-00052638": "i can explain a couple of these if we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00262-00052639-00052863": "have questions but um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00263-00052864-00053135": "basically we're looking at uh top two", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00264-00053136-00053375": "factors being really strong so does the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00265-00053376-00053542": "culture support learning it's a cult", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00266-00053544-00053766": "it's a community that prioritizes", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00267-00053767-00053935": "learning and puts things in place to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00268-00053936-00054135": "make sure that learning works happens", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00269-00054136-00054415": "supported taken seriously", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00270-00054416-00054599": "relatedness is connection and community", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00271-00054600-00054911": "emphasized yeah that that the read is a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00272-00054912-00055166": "community of connectionist connectedness", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00273-00055167-00055359": "relatedness community", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00274-00055360-00055582": "really important in the sakai community", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00275-00055583-00055750": "so those things are just jumping off the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00276-00055751-00055999": "charts 82 is a really high score", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00277-00056000-00056191": "and then in terms of these other factors", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00278-00056191-00056399": "problem solving can we solve problems", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00279-00056400-00056599": "and we've got issues do we make good", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00280-00056600-00056807": "decisions we're still pretty healthy in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00281-00056808-00056959": "these areas can people say what they", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00282-00056960-00057135": "think generally yeah but in the yellow", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00283-00057136-00057294": "areas of course there's probably a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00284-00057295-00057703": "nuance or two that we could improve on", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00285-00057704-00057863": "can the lowest score of course is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00286-00057864-00058111": "organizational design that's a category", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00287-00058112-00058279": "where we're trying to see does the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00288-00058279-00058454": "design of the organization the structure", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00289-00058455-00058615": "that you use the assumption it makes", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00290-00058616-00058823": "about how work is done does that match", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00291-00058824-00059038": "the actual work in the context", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00292-00059039-00059287": "do we have a good design we do we have", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00293-00059288-00059479": "um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00294-00059479-00059726": "so we have we have we conceived of an", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00295-00059727-00059911": "organization that matches the work and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00296-00059912-00060030": "the need that it's trying to do and the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00297-00060032-00060263": "people that work in it so that there's a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00298-00060264-00060559": "hint there that we can maybe tweak some", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00299-00060560-00060759": "function some aspect of organizational", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00300-00060760-00061263": "design to improve", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00301-00061264-00061350": "um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00302-00061351-00061679": "so so that's the that's the one once", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00303-00061679-00061847": "over lightly of this", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00304-00061848-00062006": "scale", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00305-00062007-00062230": "um why don't we why don't we move on but", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00306-00062232-00062391": "we can come back to this later in the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00307-00062391-00062542": "discussion area we have a lot of i think", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00308-00062544-00062759": "we'll have time to to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00309-00062760-00063030": "dip into this so oh yes here we are the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00310-00063032-00063254": "pineapple so this is the point where so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00311-00063255-00063454": "we've we of course when we were looking", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00312-00063455-00063711": "at the data we had the the three", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00313-00063712-00063894": "categories we had the nine factors plus", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00314-00063895-00064119": "we had all 41 questions and so what we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00315-00064120-00064415": "did was look across all that data set", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00316-00064416-00064606": "um and some of us are members of the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00317-00064607-00064766": "community and so brought their own", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00318-00064767-00064966": "experience working in the community to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00319-00064967-00065159": "see and looking across all that we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00320-00065160-00065271": "looked for", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00321-00065272-00065479": "the three biggest questions that kind of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00322-00065479-00065767": "left out at us as things that the sakai", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00323-00065768-00065950": "community might want to take", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00324-00065951-00066126": "into consideration think about and chew", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00325-00066127-00066326": "on we call these the ponderables and to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00326-00066327-00066494": "discuss these i'm going to pass it over", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00327-00066495-00066982": "to josh my colleague josh", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00328-00066983-00067182": "all right let me take you through the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00329-00067183-00067503": "ponderables so um we've got a decision", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00330-00067504-00067711": "to make in a few minutes after we take a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00331-00067712-00067863": "quick look at these", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00332-00067864-00068079": "as to whether we break out or whether we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00333-00068080-00068238": "stay in a full group", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00334-00068239-00068535": "and uh if so which of the ponderables we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00335-00068536-00068703": "choose to tackle so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00336-00068704-00068894": "you can you can chew on that for a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00337-00068895-00069047": "moment while we take a look at the three", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00338-00069048-00069247": "ponderable questions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00339-00069248-00069359": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00340-00069360-00069599": "from our read of the quantitative and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00341-00069600-00069823": "the qualitative data", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00342-00069824-00069935": "we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00343-00069936-00070255": "came to these three questions as areas", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00344-00070256-00070494": "in which the sakai community could look", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00345-00070495-00070782": "to improve and so there are these", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00346-00070783-00070943": "three ponderable questions and they're", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00347-00070944-00071103": "not easy right very easy we would have", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00348-00071104-00071311": "done this already", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00349-00071312-00071550": "and the data isn't the data aren't 100", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00350-00071551-00071911": "percent uh black and white clear about", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00351-00071912-00072119": "what to do so there are multiple", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00352-00072120-00072294": "interpretations and that's part of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00353-00072295-00072438": "that's part of what we're going to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00354-00072439-00072550": "discuss", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00355-00072551-00072799": "today so very much looking forward to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00356-00072800-00072982": "your feedback back on these ponderable", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00357-00072983-00073175": "questions so and here they are how could", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00358-00073176-00073343": "we get better at", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00359-00073344-00073543": "hearing varying perspectives and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00360-00073544-00073767": "resolving differences that's one of them", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00361-00073768-00073887": "another", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00362-00073888-00074087": "how could we get better at distributing", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00363-00074088-00074319": "workload and managing burnout", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00364-00074320-00074543": "and a third how could we get better at", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00365-00074544-00075062": "ensuring strategy and coordination", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00366-00075063-00075271": "so let's take a look at these three in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00367-00075272-00075447": "some more depth so for those of you who", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00368-00075448-00075743": "were at the lightning talk earlier today", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00369-00075744-00075935": "you saw two of these data points but", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00370-00075936-00076135": "there are more so this is a deeper dive", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00371-00076136-00076367": "into each ponderable so for this first", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00372-00076368-00076550": "ponderable how can we get better at", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00373-00076551-00076726": "hearing varying perspectives and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00374-00076727-00077038": "resolving differences we pull out six", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00375-00077039-00077375": "quantitative data points and one theme", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00376-00077376-00077623": "from the qualitative data", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00377-00077624-00077791": "so what have we got here and these are", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00378-00077792-00078031": "these are organized from uh lowest mean", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00379-00078032-00078223": "to highest mean", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00380-00078224-00078431": "so as we look at three of these the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00381-00078432-00078671": "three on the bottom we value a wide", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00382-00078672-00078871": "range of perspectives we provide honest", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00383-00078872-00079062": "feedback to each other and i feel", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00384-00079063-00079255": "accepted in our community those have", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00385-00079256-00079503": "fairly high means um they're they're", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00386-00079504-00079815": "above an 80 an 80 an 80 mean on a scale", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00387-00079816-00080055": "of one to one hundred so we consider", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00388-00080056-00080326": "those to be uh in good shape", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00389-00080327-00080694": "the other three are between 65 and 79", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00390-00080695-00080967": "which we consider to be areas that are", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00391-00080968-00081182": "needing some improvement so there there", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00392-00081183-00081455": "are there is one measure that is below", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00393-00081456-00081782": "65 and those are you know below 65 64", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00394-00081783-00081935": "and below are", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00395-00081936-00082094": "areas in which we consider there needs", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00396-00082095-00082335": "to be significant improvement", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00397-00082336-00082535": "um none of these are in this particular", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00398-00082536-00082647": "ponderable", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00399-00082648-00082894": "so so the good news is we value a wide", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00400-00082895-00083071": "range of perspectives we provide honest", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00401-00083072-00083287": "feedback uh people feel accepted so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00402-00083288-00083543": "those those are good things uh slightly", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00403-00083544-00083759": "more challenging uh do we know what to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00404-00083760-00083991": "do when a disagreement occurs well maybe", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00405-00083992-00084143": "a little bit less so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00406-00084144-00084415": "do we address important issues even when", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00407-00084416-00084647": "they make us uncomfortable or maybe a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00408-00084648-00084838": "little even less than that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00409-00084839-00085015": "when an incident involving prejudice", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00410-00085016-00085287": "occurs do we know how to address it", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00411-00085288-00085526": "the mean there was a 63 that that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00412-00085527-00085799": "particular measure was ranked 29 out of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00413-00085800-00085935": "the 31", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00414-00085936-00086087": "measures that we have in the instruments", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00415-00086088-00086191": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00416-00086192-00086423": "not you know not bad", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00417-00086424-00086606": "but not as great as maybe we want it to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00418-00086607-00086679": "be", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00419-00086680-00086926": "and so we've marked in gray two of these", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00420-00086927-00087159": "particular data points that are", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00421-00087160-00087311": "interesting in combination although", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00422-00087312-00087535": "there's lots to be said about", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00423-00087536-00087703": "these data points as we look at them", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00424-00087704-00087967": "together but if we consider that we do a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00425-00087968-00088126": "fairly good job in providing honest", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00426-00088127-00088294": "feedback to each other", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00427-00088295-00088479": "but a slightly less good job in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00428-00088480-00088647": "addressing important issues when they", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00429-00088648-00088831": "make us uncomfortable there's some", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00430-00088832-00089015": "interesting tension there and what do we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00431-00089016-00089175": "make of that you know how do we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00432-00089176-00089343": "understand that tension and what do we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00433-00089344-00089455": "do about it", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00434-00089456-00089631": "so that is uh that is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00435-00089632-00089950": "one approach to this set of ponderables", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00436-00089951-00090206": "and i wanted to share out also uh what's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00437-00090207-00090343": "called down here at the bottom the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00438-00090344-00090543": "illustrative quotation this is one of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00439-00090544-00090718": "the themes that came out strongly in the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00440-00090719-00090894": "open-ended questions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00441-00090895-00091062": "uh the one thing i value in our", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00442-00091063-00091215": "community is the willingness the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00443-00091216-00091406": "willingness to listen to all viewpoints", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00444-00091407-00091518": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00445-00091519-00091606": "this", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00446-00091607-00091847": "aligns very well with", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00447-00091848-00092015": "the idea of being good at providing", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00448-00092016-00092206": "honest feedback so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00449-00092207-00092479": "we listen but then what do we do after", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00450-00092480-00092623": "having listened and i think that's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00451-00092624-00092767": "that's a key question to think about", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00452-00092768-00092887": "here", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00453-00092888-00093287": "let's move on to ponderable number two", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00454-00093288-00093462": "how can we get better at distributing", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00455-00093463-00093726": "workload and managing burnout so here", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00456-00093727-00093911": "again we have six measures", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00457-00093912-00094094": "uh two are in the green", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00458-00094095-00094311": "three are in the yellow one is in the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00459-00094312-00094391": "red", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00460-00094392-00094606": "this this red measure is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00461-00094607-00094879": "the uh 31st", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00462-00094880-00095238": "ranked of 31 measures", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00463-00095239-00095447": "so let's and let's take a look at these", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00464-00095448-00095606": "i have a say in what i do in our", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00465-00095607-00095718": "community", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00466-00095719-00095967": "at a mean of 86 in the green our", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00467-00095968-00096150": "community media our community leaders", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00468-00096151-00096431": "meet regularly 83 also in the green so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00469-00096432-00096591": "those two things we do a pretty good job", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00470-00096592-00096662": "with", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00471-00096663-00096855": "according to these respondents", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00472-00096856-00097071": "uh slightly less good our meetings are", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00473-00097072-00097215": "productive", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00474-00097216-00097294": "um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00475-00097295-00097503": "our community work ratio is ten percent", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00476-00097504-00097655": "of the people do one hundred percent of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00477-00097656-00097950": "the work so work welded well distributed", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00478-00097951-00098047": "uh", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00479-00098048-00098335": "maybe not so much um not awful but not", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00480-00098336-00098606": "great we pause to reflect", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00481-00098607-00098815": "even less great and our community has", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00482-00098816-00099094": "low levels of burnout uh this one's a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00483-00099095-00099471": "challenging thing uh you know so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00484-00099472-00099726": "as we look at this and we consider we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00485-00099727-00099950": "meet regularly we have generally", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00486-00099951-00100111": "productive meetings", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00487-00100112-00100318": "but yet people are somewhat burnt out in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00488-00100319-00100535": "a way that might be concerning what do", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00489-00100536-00100662": "we do with that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00490-00100663-00100759": "um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00491-00100760-00101023": "we don't really pause to reflect as much", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00492-00101024-00101247": "as we ought to it's not awful but it's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00493-00101248-00101367": "not great", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00494-00101368-00101543": "and uh you know what does that have to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00495-00101544-00101799": "do with with burnout what does that say", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00496-00101800-00102055": "about the productivity of our meetings", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00497-00102056-00102206": "um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00498-00102207-00102391": "so interesting things to think about", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00499-00102392-00102590": "here", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00500-00102591-00102758": "let's take a look at the third", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00501-00102759-00102958": "ponderable", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00502-00102959-00103158": "how can we get better at ensuring", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00503-00103159-00103406": "strategy and coordination so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00504-00103407-00103718": "uh five points of measurement here", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00505-00103719-00103934": "plus one theme", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00506-00103935-00104078": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00507-00104079-00104230": "one of these points of measurement is in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00508-00104231-00104454": "the green we have a strategic plan with", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00509-00104455-00104678": "a mean of 83.", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00510-00104679-00104847": "next after that our community leaders", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00511-00104848-00105215": "share a clear vision 76 okay so we do", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00512-00105216-00105471": "pretty well with a strategic plan but", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00513-00105472-00105734": "possibly not quite as well in sharing", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00514-00105735-00105951": "the vision that that plan lays out", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00515-00105952-00106134": "that's kind of an interesting tension", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00516-00106135-00106334": "right there the other three measures", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00517-00106335-00106495": "have more to do with coordination than", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00518-00106496-00106710": "with strategy i know who is responsible", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00519-00106711-00106951": "for what our procedures keep things", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00520-00106952-00107223": "organized i have the resources i need to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00521-00107224-00107399": "do what i need to do in our community so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00522-00107400-00107671": "these are all roughly at the same level", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00523-00107672-00107983": "between a 725 and a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00524-00107983-00108254": "and they they indicate that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00525-00108255-00108383": "you know our coordination and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00526-00108383-00108631": "organization as a community is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00527-00108632-00108854": "decent but not", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00528-00108855-00109031": "top of the scale so what do what do we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00529-00109032-00109190": "do about that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00530-00109191-00109407": "and what if anything does that have to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00531-00109408-00109671": "do with uh the clarity of the vision", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00532-00109672-00109854": "that we share", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00533-00109855-00110166": "and what does it mean uh you know our", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00534-00110167-00110383": "slightly less than optimal coordination", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00535-00110383-00110631": "in the context of a strategic plan that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00536-00110632-00110886": "we consider to be fairly well done and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00537-00110888-00111071": "useful to guide us you know what's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00538-00111072-00111254": "what's what's missing here clearly", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00539-00111255-00111375": "there's something", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00540-00111376-00111551": "and let's take a look at the at the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00541-00111552-00111815": "theme from the qualitative data as well", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00542-00111816-00111999": "i like and appreciate the people in the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00543-00112000-00112199": "community but have little understanding", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00544-00112200-00112399": "of the organization itself", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00545-00112400-00112647": "current projects in progress or", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00546-00112648-00112958": "strategies used in prioritizing work", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00547-00112959-00113039": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00548-00113040-00113310": "interesting", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00549-00113311-00113623": "this in my mind speaks a bit to the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00550-00113624-00113799": "clarity of the vision but also to the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00551-00113800-00113958": "coordination so it'll be interesting to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00552-00113959-00114039": "see", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00553-00114040-00114239": "what people think of that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00554-00114240-00114358": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00555-00114359-00114575": "these are the three ponderables and our", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00556-00114576-00114807": "plan was to break you up into groups and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00557-00114808-00114990": "have each group tackle one of the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00558-00114991-00115119": "ponderables", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00559-00115120-00115351": "with one of the project team members", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00560-00115352-00115615": "serving as a facilitator so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00561-00115616-00115799": "the project team member would facilitate", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00562-00115800-00115958": "and the project team member would report", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00563-00115959-00116175": "out so your job is really just to think", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00564-00116176-00116439": "hard and be thoughtful and reflective in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00565-00116440-00116590": "your breakout session", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00566-00116591-00116663": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00567-00116664-00116847": "we can still perform those roles the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00568-00116848-00117119": "question is do we break out at all or do", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00569-00117120-00117295": "we not so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00570-00117296-00117502": "let me ask you this question so if you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00571-00117503-00117775": "would like to stay in a large group not", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00572-00117776-00117910": "break out", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00573-00117911-00118183": "we have uh maybe seven or eight of us", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00574-00118183-00118334": "martin says 10 people that aren't on the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00575-00118335-00118519": "project team if you would like to stay", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00576-00118520-00118710": "in one large group would you drop a plus", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00577-00118711-00119015": "one in the chat please", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00578-00119016-00119199": "you'd like to stay in one large group", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00579-00119200-00120319": "drop a plus one in the chat", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00580-00120320-00120543": "early returns favor staying in a large", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00581-00120544-00120758": "group does the lake house get extra", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00582-00120759-00120886": "points", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00583-00120888-00121190": "no the lakehouse shares a single vote", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00584-00121191-00121366": "okay", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00585-00121367-00122007": "one owl one vote people", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00586-00122008-00122231": "all right four out of ten are in favor", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00587-00122232-00122423": "of not breaking out do i hear any other", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00588-00122424-00122863": "opinions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00589-00122864-00122990": "probably ought to ask the question the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00590-00122991-00123207": "other way", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00591-00123208-00123558": "if you wanna", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00592-00123559-00124031": "there you go", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00593-00124032-00124175": "going once", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00594-00124176-00124351": "going twice", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00595-00124352-00124502": "all right it sounds like we are going to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00596-00124503-00124758": "be in a large group which is perfectly", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00597-00124759-00124871": "fine", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00598-00124872-00125054": "let me return then to the list of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00599-00125055-00125295": "ponderables so if we're in one group we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00600-00125296-00125502": "have to pick a ponderable to to think", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00601-00125503-00125607": "about", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00602-00125608-00125727": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00603-00125728-00125975": "here are your three choices", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00604-00125976-00126078": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00605-00126079-00126302": "what i would ask is that if you have an", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00606-00126303-00126607": "opinion about which ponderable to tackle", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00607-00126608-00126766": "would you drop the number of that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00608-00126767-00128207": "ponderable in the chat please", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00609-00128208-00128839": "jackie says three", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00610-00128840-00129231": "johnson says three", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00611-00129232-00129519": "any other opinions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00612-00129520-00129719": "got a few more people typing", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00613-00129720-00130534": "three", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00614-00130535-00130775": "all right um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00615-00130776-00130983": "does anyone have a different opinion", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00616-00130983-00131135": "does anyone feel strongly about", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00617-00131136-00132078": "addressing one of the other ponderables", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00618-00132079-00132223": "going once", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00619-00132224-00132407": "going twice", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00620-00132408-00132551": "all right", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00621-00132552-00132799": "let's let's tackle number three", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00622-00132800-00133054": "so um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00623-00133055-00133295": "let's see here so here is here's our set", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00624-00133296-00133519": "of data for number three", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00625-00133520-00133654": "and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00626-00133655-00134023": "it was our plan to take some notes", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00627-00134024-00134190": "while you guys chat so here's what i'm", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00628-00134191-00134351": "going to do i'm going to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00629-00134352-00134483": "open up the notes", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00630-00134484-00134919": "documents um and maybe i can ask um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00631-00134920-00135143": "so trust i've got it open i can i can", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00632-00135144-00135375": "take notes if you like all right i will", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00633-00135376-00135566": "i'll drop the link in the in the chat so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00634-00135567-00135783": "you guys can feel free to see the notes", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00635-00135784-00135966": "document as it's being", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00636-00135967-00136143": "built out but i need to adjust", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00637-00136144-00136407": "permissions sorry about that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00638-00136408-00136687": "so don't follow that link just yet", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00639-00136688-00136927": "[Music]", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00640-00136928-00137063": "gosh there were a couple guiding", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00641-00137064-00137159": "questions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00642-00137160-00137287": "and we were going to use in the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00643-00137288-00137519": "breakouts", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00644-00137520-00137702": "i think they were i'm trying to remember", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00645-00137703-00137919": "them and put them in the yeah they were", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00646-00137920-00138151": "what did the data mean", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00647-00138152-00138527": "yeah what sense do we make of these data", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00648-00138528-00138678": "there we go", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00649-00138679-00138919": "and then what ah there it is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00650-00138920-00139166": "um what what can we do about that what", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00651-00139167-00139359": "does the data say and what can we do", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00652-00139360-00139654": "about that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00653-00139655-00140311": "how might we as big should well might we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00654-00140312-00140447": "i'm typing in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00655-00140448-00140814": "that's fine so we have a record", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00656-00140815-00141054": "all right so so these are the two big", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00657-00141055-00141175": "questions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00658-00141176-00141390": "what are the data say and how how might", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00659-00141391-00141566": "we as a community make improvements so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00660-00141567-00141775": "let's return to the data for number", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00661-00141776-00142039": "three while we have those three things", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00662-00142040-00142239": "in in our minds", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00663-00142240-00142326": "um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00664-00142327-00142766": "i'm i'm curious as we start off um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00665-00142767-00143007": "let's let's prime the pump a tiny bit i", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00666-00143008-00143183": "i wonder if the other project team", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00667-00143184-00143471": "members have any initial reactions to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00668-00143472-00143654": "the data points that we pulled out in in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00669-00143655-00143847": "ponderable three", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00670-00143848-00144102": "yeah so i think maybe uh let's let's ask", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00671-00144103-00144254": "for opinions from the project team", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00672-00144255-00144471": "members and then let's open the floor", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00673-00144472-00145039": "to opinions from others", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00674-00145040-00145190": "i reckon this is where you want me to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00675-00145191-00145414": "say something", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00676-00145415-00145671": "sure", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00677-00145672-00145847": "i think you already said it quite well", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00678-00145848-00146054": "josh but the juxtaposition of those two", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00679-00146055-00146263": "that have the arrows beside them", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00680-00146264-00146447": "we have a strategic plan and you've been", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00681-00146448-00146719": "doing a good job particularly josh of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00682-00146720-00146887": "you know touting the road map and so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00683-00146888-00147078": "forth um you've you've dropped into many", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00684-00147079-00147263": "community meetings and talked about them", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00685-00147264-00147487": "had one-on-one conversations and so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00686-00147488-00147687": "forth and yet", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00687-00147688-00147871": "our community leaders share a clear", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00688-00147872-00148135": "vision doesn't score so well", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00689-00148136-00148263": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00690-00148264-00148526": "what it makes me curious about is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00691-00148527-00148807": "does this mean we have a plan but we're", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00692-00148808-00149087": "unclear what it means we have a plan but", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00693-00149088-00149366": "we haven't shared it so well", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00694-00149367-00149631": "what does this mean i i you know this", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00695-00149632-00149783": "that's this that's one of the reasons", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00696-00149784-00149959": "folks that we uh we thought this would", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00697-00149960-00150143": "be a good ponderable because we're not", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00698-00150144-00150687": "quite sure what it means or at least not", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00699-00150688-00151447": "dave wilma what do you think", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00700-00151448-00151566": "oh hi", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00701-00151567-00151678": "um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00702-00151679-00151847": "yeah there's the contradiction in here", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00703-00151848-00152023": "in those two that would be highlighted", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00704-00152024-00152254": "but i also thought the other three were", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00705-00152255-00152423": "a little low", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00706-00152424-00152814": "um as well um so you'd think i know who", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00707-00152815-00153095": "is responsible for what in our community", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00708-00153096-00153278": "at 18 that's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00709-00153279-00153551": "below halfway on the ranking", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00710-00153552-00153790": "so it's one of the lower", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00711-00153791-00153966": "um points", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00712-00153967-00154190": "and and that's uh for me that's a kind", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00713-00154191-00154454": "of a test of how coordinated people are", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00714-00154455-00154639": "you need to know what roles are who has", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00715-00154640-00154783": "to do things and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00716-00154784-00154983": "and then the procedures question so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00717-00154984-00155278": "uh the second and third rows are ones", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00718-00155279-00155399": "that get my", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00719-00155400-00155559": "attention", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00720-00155560-00155726": "as being kind of you want your", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00721-00155727-00155919": "procedures to keep things organized", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00722-00155920-00156175": "organized but they're number 21 ranked", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00723-00156176-00156959": "overall it's pretty low", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00724-00156960-00157111": "there's also a good point from the lake", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00725-00157112-00157407": "house that that the one about visions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00726-00157408-00157519": "could be that there are actually", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00727-00157520-00158111": "multiple possibly even competing visions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00728-00158112-00158359": "so that's that's a good start uh lake", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00729-00158360-00158495": "house do you want it you want to follow", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00730-00158496-00158639": "up on that and then we'll open the floor", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00731-00158640-00158983": "to uh to everyone", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00732-00158984-00159919": "[Music]", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00733-00159920-00160087": "lake house is quiet oh the lake house is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00734-00160088-00160311": "on listen only most of folks are on", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00735-00160312-00160623": "listen only i'm finding and it's it's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00736-00160624-00160726": "that's going to be an interesting", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00737-00160727-00160871": "challenge", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00738-00160872-00161023": "well it's a good thing we have a chat", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00739-00161024-00161111": "right", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00740-00161112-00161287": "the lake house has no microphone but you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00741-00161288-00161543": "had an owl you had a vowel earlier", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00742-00161544-00161790": "um lake house notes not sharing a clear", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00743-00161791-00161959": "vision might mean there are zero clear", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00744-00161960-00162143": "visions or there are three clear visions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00745-00162144-00162575": "yes very true it's a very good point um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00746-00162576-00162671": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00747-00162672-00162751": "uh", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00748-00162752-00162863": "lake house", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00749-00162864-00163119": "and others that have well actually so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00750-00163120-00163319": "let's uh let's put a pin in that for a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00751-00163320-00163471": "second and let's let's come back to that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00752-00163472-00163678": "and dave you know let's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00753-00163679-00163966": "help me make sure i come back to that um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00754-00163967-00164063": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00755-00164064-00164143": "i'm", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00756-00164144-00164247": "there goes the lake house they're", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00757-00164248-00164359": "offline now", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00758-00164360-00164678": "so others that are in the room um what", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00759-00164679-00164975": "takeaways do you see here uh what do", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00760-00164976-00165247": "what do these data mean before we dive", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00761-00165248-00165454": "into the the related question of what we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00762-00165455-00165759": "might do about it", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00763-00165760-00166487": "how do you interpret these", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00764-00166488-00166663": "feel free to drop your interpretations", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00765-00166664-00166871": "in the chat", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00766-00166872-00167111": "or feel free if you'd rather to uh you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00767-00167112-00167231": "know leave the room and come back and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00768-00167232-00167399": "turn on your microphone that's also fine", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00769-00167400-00167535": "so that you can you can speak up if", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00770-00167536-00167702": "you'd like to yeah that's what the lake", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00771-00167703-00167871": "house did they dropped out and turned", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00772-00167872-00168054": "their mic on and came back in so good", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00773-00168055-00168311": "job", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00774-00168312-00168599": "i sent the lake house away", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00775-00168600-00168831": "here they come", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00776-00168832-00169031": "yeah you may not have you may not you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00777-00169032-00169207": "may rue the day that you invited the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00778-00169208-00169431": "lake house to turn its microphone on", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00779-00169432-00170431": "i i already ruined the day dr chuck", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00780-00170432-00170526": "we're just", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00781-00170527-00170719": "six people on the circle we're eating", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00782-00170720-00171151": "snacks and drinking cider and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00783-00171152-00171519": "we want to be entertained", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00784-00171520-00171743": "well we we do our best over here at uh", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00785-00171744-00172038": "at sakai virtual conference hq angelia", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00786-00172039-00172231": "notes is there a disconnect between the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00787-00172232-00172431": "overall strategic plan and the visions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00788-00172432-00172599": "of each project team", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00789-00172600-00172926": "interesting um that that in some ways uh", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00790-00172927-00173047": "seems to be", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00791-00173048-00173207": "something similar to the idea of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00792-00173208-00173495": "possibly three clear visions um what do", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00793-00173496-00173759": "what what do others think what what else", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00794-00173760-00174038": "uh who else uh thinks that there might", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00795-00174039-00174231": "be multiple clear visions going on that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00796-00174232-00174383": "that's you know who else buys that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00797-00174384-00176935": "interpretation", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00798-00176936-00177095": "are procedures that keep things", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00799-00177096-00177302": "organized may also be an indicator that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00800-00177303-00177526": "there is a disconnect yep yep that that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00801-00177527-00177775": "is true um so i'm kind of curious you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00802-00177776-00177966": "know folks who are active members of the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00803-00177967-00178119": "of the sakai community and attend a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00804-00178120-00178231": "bunch of these meetings so that's the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00805-00178232-00178559": "lake house people that's uh eduardo", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00806-00178560-00178799": "uh uh juanjo", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00807-00178800-00178975": "um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00808-00178976-00179335": "and i suppose uh wilma and martin and me", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00809-00179336-00179599": "um so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00810-00179600-00179814": "you know what is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00811-00179815-00179966": "do", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00812-00179967-00180199": "what's the way i want to articulate this", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00813-00180200-00180423": "um are we those of us who are in lots of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00814-00180424-00180543": "these meetings", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00815-00180544-00180759": "uh seeing multiple visions being", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00816-00180760-00181278": "articulated", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00817-00181279-00181502": "josh this is chris at the lake house i'm", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00818-00181503-00181759": "wondering if some of this is maybe", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00819-00181760-00182102": "uh some of the stuff like looked at as", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00820-00182103-00182711": "practical and some as aspirational maybe", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00821-00182712-00182975": "could be it could be", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00822-00182976-00183175": "um constance notice in the chat that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00823-00183176-00183343": "there are multiple visions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00824-00183344-00183543": "i mean i could see it right even the map", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00825-00183544-00183831": "process would uh lend itself to a slight", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00826-00183832-00184054": "lack of clarity i mean so yes we're", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00827-00184055-00184183": "we're laying out our priorities in the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00828-00184184-00184383": "road map but we have uh there's so many", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00829-00184384-00184559": "things that we want to get done", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00830-00184560-00184751": "you know that i could see that that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00831-00184752-00184919": "that large a list", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00832-00184920-00185143": "might in and of itself produce a lack of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00833-00185144-00185254": "clarity", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00834-00185255-00185454": "that's not working out well now it is it", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00835-00185455-00185695": "was going through the tv", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00836-00185696-00185847": "dave i'm kind of curious i mean you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00837-00185848-00186135": "you've observed us as an outcome", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00838-00186136-00186223": "you know", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00839-00186224-00186383": "do you see multi did you see multiple", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00840-00186384-00186511": "competing visions when you were", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00841-00186512-00186623": "observing it", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00842-00186624-00186966": "at the pre-pandemic skycam", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00843-00186967-00187087": "um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00844-00187088-00187278": "you know", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00845-00187279-00187471": "i may have i mean", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00846-00187472-00187766": "there were yes", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00847-00187767-00188047": "i think i saw people trying to decide", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00848-00188048-00188287": "what vision the vision was", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00849-00188288-00188559": "there were moments where uh", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00850-00188560-00188807": "people were trying to figure out", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00851-00188808-00188975": "you know they were thinking about the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00852-00188976-00189175": "design of sakai and the what it was", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00853-00189176-00189350": "going to look like", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00854-00189351-00189526": "we were trying to decide whether to add", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00855-00189527-00189687": "functionality that one school had", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00856-00189688-00189950": "developed or not that was a big deal", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00857-00189951-00190231": "dr chuck was proposing something", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00858-00190232-00190454": "um and we were thinking about that so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00859-00190455-00190702": "yeah i think that this the camp that i", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00860-00190703-00190863": "watched was", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00861-00190864-00191031": "was a place where multiple visions were", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00862-00191032-00192102": "being considered", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00863-00192103-00192311": "what other thoughts do people have about", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00864-00192312-00192543": "uh this particular tension before we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00865-00192544-00192671": "turn to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00866-00192672-00192943": "uh issues of coordination", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00867-00192944-00193087": "martin writes is it possible that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00868-00193088-00193287": "visions are focused and smaller each", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00869-00193288-00193463": "group has its own smaller vision but it", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00870-00193464-00193671": "isn't the grand vision i suppose the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00871-00193672-00193863": "corollary there is that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00872-00193864-00194047": "you know this this item talks about a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00873-00194048-00194199": "clear vision but maybe to your point", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00874-00194200-00194414": "there isn't one there are multiple", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00875-00194415-00194599": "interlocking visions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00876-00194600-00194823": "yeah i'm just trying to i mean i think", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00877-00194824-00195078": "it was angelia who suggested that it may", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00878-00195079-00195159": "be", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00879-00195160-00195366": "or well no it even goes further back", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00880-00195367-00195535": "than that in the thread that there are", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00881-00195536-00195711": "different visions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00882-00195712-00195863": "and maybe it's just because they're", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00883-00195864-00196031": "smaller kind of focused on the thing we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00884-00196032-00196143": "know", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00885-00196144-00196319": "i don't know just trying to suss this", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00886-00196320-00196468": "out", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00887-00196469-00196695": "[Music]", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00888-00196696-00196878": "lake house i just muted you uh because", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00889-00196879-00196990": "you've got a bunch of people there but", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00890-00196991-00197119": "feel free to unmute when you have stuff", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00891-00197120-00197559": "to say", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00892-00197560-00197743": "yeah i think that if you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00893-00197744-00197895": "i think we are going to always have", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00894-00197896-00198111": "multiple visions and the problem i think", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00895-00198112-00198319": "is with the word vision", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00896-00198320-00198414": "right", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00897-00198415-00198711": "if if what we were was a television", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00898-00198712-00198911": "company and and we were building", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00899-00198912-00199078": "television what's the vision for", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00900-00199079-00199231": "televisions in the next five years", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00901-00199232-00199431": "that's a simple problem", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00902-00199432-00199735": "we are we're many things and to say", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00903-00199736-00200054": "where's the grand vision", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00904-00200055-00200287": "the grand vision is to be the best", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00905-00200288-00200447": "lms for learning and i don't think any", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00906-00200448-00200599": "there's any question", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00907-00200600-00200887": "that that's not our vision right", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00908-00200888-00201126": "so so to say that the product has a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00909-00201127-00201383": "vision that there is one product that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00910-00201384-00201599": "there is one vision i just i think we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00911-00201600-00201838": "shouldn't beat ourselves up about this", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00912-00201839-00202014": "what we have is a lot of different", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00913-00202015-00202175": "visions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00914-00202176-00202302": "and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00915-00202303-00202478": "and these visions are not themselves in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00916-00202479-00202607": "conflict", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00917-00202608-00202790": "and then we come together and then what", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00918-00202791-00203190": "we produce is the sum total of a series", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00919-00203191-00203375": "of visions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00920-00203376-00203607": "and passions and top priorities and my", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00921-00203608-00203743": "top priority might be different than", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00922-00203744-00203990": "earl's top priority but i'm sure glad", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00923-00203991-00204231": "that earl's top priority is what it is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00924-00204232-00204487": "because i'm really glad we have ignite", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00925-00204488-00204654": "and earl's going to be really glad when", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00926-00204655-00204831": "we have sakai plus", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00927-00204832-00205014": "and to say that whoa how come chuck and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00928-00205015-00205271": "earl don't have the same share of vision", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00929-00205271-00205510": "we'd be crazy to try to vote between", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00930-00205511-00205662": "whether my vision is more or less", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00931-00205663-00205798": "important than earl's vision because all", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00932-00205800-00205975": "these visions are important and if", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00933-00205976-00206223": "you're just looking on the side", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00934-00206223-00206342": "you're like whoa", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00935-00206344-00206519": "earl seems to care a lot about this and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00936-00206519-00206671": "chuck seems to care a lot about that are", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00937-00206671-00206838": "they fighting and the answer is no we're", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00938-00206839-00206975": "not fighting", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00939-00206976-00207094": "right", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00940-00207096-00207255": "but we're just not one thing that's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00941-00207256-00207479": "that's this i just don't like the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00942-00207480-00207662": "question i'm sorry", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00943-00207663-00207846": "it's a dumb question", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00944-00207848-00208119": "um so and it's important to remember", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00945-00208119-00208414": "right that this um this project is uh", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00946-00208415-00208710": "not in its infancy uh not on its toddler", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00947-00208711-00209014": "state uh maybe it's past preschool into", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00948-00209015-00209223": "kindergarten you know so the uh", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00949-00209223-00209471": "the first uh large administration of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00950-00209471-00209679": "this instrument is with the sakai", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00951-00209680-00209846": "community as as the sponsor of the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00952-00209848-00210110": "instrument so there definitely there may", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00953-00210111-00210287": "very well be improvements to the the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00954-00210288-00210431": "this instrument as i lo from a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00955-00210432-00210615": "methodological perspective as i look at", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00956-00210616-00210806": "this question it might be a little on", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00957-00210807-00210967": "the broken side it's certainly measuring", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00958-00210967-00211110": "two things right", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00959-00211111-00211191": "uh", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00960-00211192-00211382": "how effectively a vision is shared and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00961-00211383-00211534": "the clarity of the vision and it could", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00962-00211535-00211719": "be that that's muddling things", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00963-00211719-00211806": "um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00964-00211807-00211958": "on the other hand you could look at and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00965-00211959-00212158": "say well you know to dr chuck's point we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00966-00212159-00212334": "have multiple visions multiple visions", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00967-00212335-00212567": "are being articulated so maybe it's a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00968-00212567-00212887": "good thing that uh this particular item", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00969-00212888-00213215": "is has a mean of 76 which is relatively", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00970-00213216-00213406": "which is like halfway up the scale it's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00971-00213407-00213663": "fairly close to being 80 and not being", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00972-00213664-00213855": "not being a problem as we've as we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00973-00213856-00214055": "consider these results so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00974-00214056-00214246": "you know this might be a good story as", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00975-00214248-00214391": "opposed to a not good story but i", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00976-00214392-00214606": "definitely think that it probably bears", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00977-00214607-00214791": "some additional testing and some", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00978-00214792-00214942": "additional look at it from a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00979-00214944-00215175": "methodological perspective", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00980-00215176-00215246": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00981-00215248-00215479": "it is it's 2 30.", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00982-00215480-00215671": "this session runs for another 10 minutes", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00983-00215671-00215894": "or so so um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00984-00215896-00216127": "so let's turn to the coordination", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00985-00216128-00216239": "measures", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00986-00216240-00216406": "um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00987-00216407-00216519": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00988-00216519-00216775": "i have the resources i need to do what i", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00989-00216776-00216958": "i have the resources i need to do what i", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00990-00216959-00217142": "need to do in our community", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00991-00217144-00217391": "our procedures keep things organized i", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00992-00217392-00217598": "know who is responsible for what in our", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00993-00217600-00217751": "community so these are all at roughly", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00994-00217752-00217958": "the same level they're all between", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00995-00217959-00218255": "uh 71 and a half and 72 and a half give", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00996-00218256-00218423": "or take a little tiny bit", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00997-00218423-00218694": "they're toward the bottom of the 31", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00998-00218696-00218887": "points of measurement you know the ranks", "H_bMusX4FxQ-00999-00218888-00219094": "range from 18 to 23. so they're roughly", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01000-00219096-00219279": "at the same level they're sort of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01001-00219280-00219503": "they're in the uh needs a little bit of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01002-00219504-00219663": "improvement category", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01003-00219664-00219823": "um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01004-00219823-00219910": "what are", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01005-00219911-00220063": "what are your thoughts about what these", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01006-00220064-00220398": "data might mean", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01007-00220400-00222998": "how do we interpret these", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01008-00223000-00223158": "i'm waiting for folks to drop your", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01009-00223159-00223327": "nuggets of wisdom in the chat i'll just", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01010-00223328-00225423": "wait you out", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01011-00225423-00225615": "see martin is typing i'm sure others of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01012-00225616-00225982": "you are are considering", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01013-00225983-00226231": "interesting martin notes that uh his", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01014-00226232-00226398": "personal experience is that we actually", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01015-00226400-00226615": "have good processes but a lot of people", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01016-00226616-00226791": "don't know about it", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01017-00226792-00226879": "so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01018-00226880-00227158": "maybe solid processes possibly poorly", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01019-00227159-00227391": "communicated or more poorly than we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01020-00227392-00227567": "would like and martin knows jira as an", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01021-00227567-00227855": "example the lake house is typing", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01022-00227856-00228006": "let me just uh follow up with that with", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01023-00228007-00228303": "the verbal um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01024-00228304-00228542": "there you go lakehouse what do you have", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01025-00228544-00228758": "to say about uh great processes that are", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01026-00228759-00228910": "possibly under communicated do you buy", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01027-00228911-00229151": "the under communicated part", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01028-00229152-00229287": "i don't know but i don't even buy under", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01029-00229288-00229479": "communicated no", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01030-00229480-00229558": "i mean", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01031-00229559-00229782": "i think we have great processes i think", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01032-00229783-00229991": "the roadmap process is great i think our", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01033-00229992-00230231": "ux design process is great", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01034-00230232-00230406": "you know i i've been in this project a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01035-00230407-00230567": "long time and i've seen us when we had", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01036-00230567-00230831": "some really lousy processes", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01037-00230832-00231046": "and i am super proud of the processes we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01038-00231048-00231327": "have right now so i i find it hard to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01039-00231328-00231598": "criticize what we're doing right", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01040-00231600-00231751": "but the interesting thing is is the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01041-00231752-00231967": "processes that i think are the best are", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01042-00231967-00232119": "not", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01043-00232119-00232327": "single vision oriented", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01044-00232328-00232527": "highly coordinated oriented where we're", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01045-00232528-00232703": "picking because that's what we used to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01046-00232704-00232958": "do is we used to try to like", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01047-00232959-00233151": "vet different priorities and tell people", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01048-00233152-00233375": "to stop working on you know", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01049-00233376-00233567": "earl stop working on it", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01050-00233567-00233767": "ignite because we took a vote and lti is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01051-00233767-00233934": "more important than ignite and we would", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01052-00233935-00234367": "do that stuff in 2004 2005-2006", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01053-00234367-00234598": "and now we just say let's just see what", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01054-00234600-00234775": "everyone's doing and everyone's making", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01055-00234776-00235015": "the product better and so the roadmap is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01056-00235016-00235231": "a great process", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01057-00235232-00235446": "because when in doubt we use the road", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01058-00235448-00235606": "map other there's other things that sort", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01059-00235607-00235775": "of get done", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01060-00235776-00235951": "just because they got to get done you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01061-00235952-00236182": "know sam goes and fixes sam ago", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01062-00236183-00236351": "performance he doesn't wait for a road", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01063-00236352-00236510": "map entry for that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01064-00236511-00236663": "and um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01065-00236664-00236798": "and so that's why i mean so i'm not", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01066-00236800-00237031": "being facetious when i say when i say we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01067-00237032-00237231": "have great processes i think we do have", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01068-00237232-00237375": "great processes", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01069-00237376-00237479": "and uh", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01070-00237480-00237679": "i know that because i've seen situations", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01071-00237680-00237871": "where the processes are far less great", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01072-00237871-00238015": "than what we do", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01073-00238016-00238263": "and you can always improve and you can", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01074-00238264-00238415": "always criticize and you can always", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01075-00238416-00238615": "complain but we have great processes i", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01076-00238616-00238839": "think", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01077-00238840-00239055": "so doctor chuck let me oh sorry go ahead", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01078-00239056-00239142": "john i was just going to say in the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01079-00239144-00239358": "spirit of continuous improvement though", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01080-00239359-00239567": "you know i mean our processes", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01081-00239567-00239679": "are you know", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01082-00239680-00239919": "are never so great that they can't bear", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01083-00239919-00240055": "some some fine-tuning and some", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01084-00240056-00240191": "improvement you know that would be", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01085-00240192-00240382": "that's that's my thought there martin go", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01086-00240383-00240558": "ahead say well", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01087-00240559-00240703": "because i'm", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01088-00240704-00240903": "it's it's probably because of the where", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01089-00240904-00241134": "i happen to sit where i'm reaching out", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01090-00241135-00241342": "to non-academic institutions all the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01091-00241344-00241494": "time i mean we probably do we're", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01092-00241496-00241671": "probably doing an average of three to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01093-00241671-00241934": "four demos a week for organizations that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01094-00241935-00242071": "most of you all wouldn't have heard of i", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01095-00242071-00242239": "never heard of them before but they're", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01096-00242240-00242479": "interested in sakai but when i tell them", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01097-00242480-00242767": "the story dr chuck that essentially", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01098-00242767-00242967": "you could propose an improvement to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01099-00242967-00243206": "sakai here's how you do it it's the jira", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01100-00243207-00243398": "thing you know and i talk i try to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01101-00243400-00243582": "communicate how you do that and then", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01102-00243583-00243734": "there's this group of people that meet", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01103-00243735-00243975": "weekly and look at that and decide you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01104-00243976-00244134": "know where we're going to try to deploy", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01105-00244135-00244342": "the resources and then i also think", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01106-00244344-00244503": "about how we have", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01107-00244504-00244606": "um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01108-00244607-00244879": "oh this it's just sort of a network", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01109-00244880-00245039": "of people who are working on things you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01110-00245040-00245167": "know you think about what university of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01111-00245167-00245310": "dayton's working on", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01112-00245311-00245551": "and it just you know it's it's lovely i", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01113-00245552-00245671": "agree with you chuck we have great", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01114-00245671-00245823": "processes but i just feel like people", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01115-00245823-00246030": "don't know about them much because they", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01116-00246031-00246230": "would go wow that's just that's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01117-00246231-00246358": "fantastic", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01118-00246359-00246510": "more than they do they might kind of go", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01119-00246511-00246694": "i don't get it so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01120-00246696-00246879": "i don't know i'm agreeing with you but", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01121-00246880-00247030": "not", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01122-00247031-00247287": "well so i i will say that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01123-00247288-00247534": "we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01124-00247535-00247687": "we have problems", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01125-00247688-00247958": "communicating everything that we are and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01126-00247959-00248239": "everything that we do", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01127-00248240-00248406": "to the people you're you're talking", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01128-00248407-00248598": "about right those people walk into you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01129-00248600-00248823": "and you have to start from scratch", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01130-00248823-00248975": "and you have to create the entire", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01131-00248976-00249255": "narrative martin in those situations", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01132-00249256-00249471": "that's right and part of what we need to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01133-00249471-00249615": "do", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01134-00249616-00249782": "from uh", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01135-00249783-00249927": "like the marketing part of the reason we", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01136-00249928-00250094": "went to educause", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01137-00250096-00250367": "is to talk to strangers", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01138-00250367-00250630": "and tell them our story", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01139-00250631-00250863": "and then watch their reaction and adjust", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01140-00250864-00251071": "our story", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01141-00251071-00251223": "and and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01142-00251223-00251391": "what i'm saying is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01143-00251392-00251510": "part of the reason that we went to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01144-00251511-00251663": "educause this year and we didn't go to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01145-00251664-00251951": "educause four years ago is i didn't have", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01146-00251952-00252119": "feel like i would there was a story", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01147-00252119-00252246": "worth spending", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01148-00252248-00252423": "ten thousand dollars to go talk to some", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01149-00252423-00252567": "strangers about", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01150-00252567-00252742": "but i think today", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01151-00252744-00252975": "we do and and yeah and next year and the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01152-00252976-00253094": "year after", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01153-00253096-00253342": "because we've turned a corner", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01154-00253344-00253567": "yeah right we turned a heck of a corner", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01155-00253567-00253830": "at this point inside sakai in terms of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01156-00253831-00253951": "you know the kinds of things that we're", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01157-00253952-00254127": "spending time on are the kinds of things", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01158-00254128-00254310": "that are really", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01159-00254311-00254542": "advancing us not just like digging out", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01160-00254544-00254863": "of the hole that we got stuck in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01161-00254864-00255191": "for a long time but we now can see", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01162-00255192-00255575": "people talking about things like", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01163-00255576-00255767": "rolled up rubrics i don't know what that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01164-00255767-00255910": "is but the fact that we can talk about", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01165-00255911-00256094": "that and not like have a panic attack", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01166-00256096-00256279": "talking about it", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01167-00256280-00256479": "means that we're different right yeah", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01168-00256480-00256751": "and and for to talk for hear david's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01169-00256752-00256991": "talk about we just used sugi everywhere", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01170-00256992-00257246": "like we didn't always have that and so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01171-00257248-00257519": "the point is is i think that when we say", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01172-00257519-00257806": "communication we got to be careful i", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01173-00257807-00258023": "believe martin our communication to you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01174-00258023-00258191": "is probably okay", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01175-00258192-00258446": "yeah", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01176-00258448-00258719": "it we we don't communicate at all and so", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01177-00258719-00258871": "i think what we have to do is we have to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01178-00258871-00259094": "communicate to people that are not in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01179-00259096-00259327": "our family but i think we got good", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01180-00259328-00259487": "processes i got to think we got good at", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01181-00259488-00259663": "communication internally", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01182-00259664-00259863": "and it is time to communicate that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01183-00259864-00260015": "externally and that's why marketing is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01184-00260016-00260246": "so important it has been growing for the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01185-00260248-00260519": "past 18 months like by leaps and bounds", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01186-00260519-00260703": "our marketing to people that we don't", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01187-00260704-00260815": "already know", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01188-00260816-00260967": "has been growing by leaps and bounds", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01189-00260967-00261255": "yeah but the open source health factors", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01190-00261256-00261439": "i think really is talking more about", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01191-00261440-00261655": "internal stuff", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01192-00261656-00261846": "not not not how are we doing as a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01193-00261848-00262094": "company engaging the market but how are", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01194-00262096-00262303": "we talking to each other", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01195-00262304-00262591": "and again i give us you know an a minus", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01196-00262592-00262815": "it works and you can always do better", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01197-00262816-00263023": "but we're certainly not a c in any of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01198-00263024-00263295": "these things and when we have bins of c", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01199-00263296-00263606": "if you go back to 2007 we were an f", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01200-00263607-00263927": "minus in all these areas", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01201-00263928-00264119": "and i think dr chuck that the the data", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01202-00264120-00264263": "would bear you out you know so what", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01203-00264264-00264447": "we're seeing in these results is", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01204-00264448-00264710": "definitely not see performance uh with", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01205-00264711-00264982": "the exception of burnout uh that that i", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01206-00264983-00265215": "think is a is a c performance the rest", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01207-00265216-00265327": "of these are", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01208-00265328-00265534": "uh you know many of these are strongly b", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01209-00265535-00265743": "plus a minus and several of them are in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01210-00265744-00266023": "the a range you know so you know so the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01211-00266024-00266239": "question is you know how do we you know", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01212-00266240-00266391": "what are the little tweaks that we need", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01213-00266392-00266630": "to make in some of these areas to you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01214-00266631-00266823": "know do a little better to maybe you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01215-00266824-00266982": "know communicate a little bit better you", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01216-00266983-00267206": "know in the the outer reaches you know", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01217-00267207-00267399": "so that the third cousins know what they", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01218-00267400-00267534": "need to know right because they're", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01219-00267535-00267743": "they're not at the core of the family", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01220-00267744-00267879": "necessarily or they're not in every", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01221-00267880-00268063": "family conversation", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01222-00268064-00268215": "there are many things there are many", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01223-00268216-00268447": "things that we're still see at", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01224-00268448-00268703": "but they're not on this screen", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01225-00268704-00268910": "true true right so this screen of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01226-00268911-00269087": "strategy and coordination which we've", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01227-00269088-00269334": "been talking about for a while", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01228-00269335-00269551": "that's not our weakness", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01229-00269552-00269695": "at least internally", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01230-00269696-00269903": "i mean our weakness is gaining new", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01231-00269904-00269999": "people", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01232-00270000-00270151": "our weaknesses", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01233-00270152-00270303": "you know and if we were to if we were to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01234-00270304-00270519": "switch this to a strategic conversation", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01235-00270520-00270839": "rather than an assessment of dave's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01236-00270840-00271063": "you know set of questions to ask any", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01237-00271064-00271206": "open source project which is kind of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01238-00271207-00271406": "what we're doing here but this thing", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01239-00271407-00271655": "only goes so far it can't tell us", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01240-00271656-00271855": "what we should be doing strategically", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01241-00271856-00272047": "and you know", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01242-00272048-00272343": "maybe we should start talking about that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01243-00272344-00272534": "which was laura's old blue sky thing", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01244-00272535-00272623": "right", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01245-00272624-00272695": "but", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01246-00272696-00272927": "we'll name it differently", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01247-00272928-00273055": "we'll call it", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01248-00273056-00273319": "gray sky well i think i think you're", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01249-00273320-00273510": "right i mean the intent of this was not", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01250-00273511-00273655": "to produce something that would tell us", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01251-00273656-00273767": "what to do", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01252-00273768-00273903": "but right", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01253-00273904-00274055": "high-level data that would help us", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01254-00274056-00274206": "figure out you know where to where to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01255-00274207-00274430": "place our efforts and you know where to", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01256-00274431-00274630": "where to think about what we need to do", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01257-00274631-00274734": "next", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01258-00274735-00274982": "and i think it's done a good job of that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01259-00274983-00275158": "as long as we're looking at ourselves", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01260-00275159-00275351": "internally and not how to win in the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01261-00275352-00275463": "market", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01262-00275464-00275663": "this is not a survey about how to win in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01263-00275664-00275934": "the market this is a survey about", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01264-00275935-00276175": "places where we have squeaky squeaky", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01265-00276176-00276527": "things that need to be smoothed out", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01266-00276528-00276719": "places where we're we're stepping on", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01267-00276720-00276871": "ourselves", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01268-00276872-00277047": "you know and slowing ourselves down by", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01269-00277048-00277247": "stepping on our own toes", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01270-00277248-00277375": "and i think we don't do that as much as", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01271-00277376-00277582": "we did in the past and we just keep", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01272-00277583-00277879": "getting better and better at that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01273-00277880-00278206": "so it is it is 2 41 p.m 41 minutes past", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01274-00278207-00278423": "the hour we're a minute past our our", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01275-00278424-00278582": "times we probably ought to be wrapping", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01276-00278583-00278775": "up here um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01277-00278776-00278958": "this was this has been uh this was not", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01278-00278959-00279127": "the conversation i anticipated i was", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01279-00279128-00279343": "thinking like lots more people talking", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01280-00279344-00279558": "in some ways this has been a few of us", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01281-00279559-00279727": "who are deep in the community talking", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01282-00279728-00279999": "about what this means and uh you know a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01283-00280000-00280223": "bunch of people kind of listening in and", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01284-00280224-00280439": "and watching in a fishbowl kind of way", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01285-00280440-00280599": "and that's that's interesting in its own", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01286-00280600-00280767": "right so that was that was kind of fun", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01287-00280768-00281047": "to do so uh thanks dr chuck for uh for", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01288-00281048-00281287": "turning on the mic and and uh you know", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01289-00281288-00281495": "being being as vocal as you were i think", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01290-00281496-00281847": "that was great um i i will say that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01291-00281848-00282087": "i would bet you and you know maybe dr", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01292-00282088-00282239": "chuck can uh you know we'll have", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01293-00282240-00282375": "something to say about this by way of", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01294-00282376-00282471": "closing", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01295-00282472-00282695": "uh i would bet you that our competitors", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01296-00282696-00282830": "don't do this", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01297-00282831-00283167": "that they don't uh they don't uh that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01298-00283168-00283334": "they're they're not introspective in", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01299-00283335-00283495": "this way i mean one of the one of the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01300-00283496-00283743": "measures was we don't pause to reflect", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01301-00283744-00283863": "you know and i think that we don't do", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01302-00283864-00284047": "that as often as we should but i do", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01303-00284048-00284343": "think that this particular piece of work", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01304-00284344-00284551": "you know these these findings these", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01305-00284552-00284799": "conversations are the kind of reflection", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01306-00284800-00285030": "that we need to have and it may be that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01307-00285031-00285110": "you know", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01308-00285111-00285382": "these six data points don't produce", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01309-00285383-00285567": "something as actionable as we had hoped", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01310-00285568-00285758": "but nonetheless we're considering them", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01311-00285759-00285958": "and thinking really hard so uh you know", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01312-00285959-00286206": "i i would offer that as a as you know a", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01313-00286207-00286479": "place where i where i stand on this um", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01314-00286480-00286687": "anyone else want to offer any final", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01315-00286688-00286823": "words before we break we're a little bit", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01316-00286824-00286991": "over time so i would say let's let's", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01317-00286992-00287182": "take 60 seconds anyone who has a last", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01318-00287183-00288639": "thought feel free to share", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01319-00288640-00288806": "yeah i mean martin notes that a non-open", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01320-00288807-00288982": "product would be talking about their", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01321-00288983-00289103": "solely about their role in the", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01322-00289104-00289334": "marketplace you know and and the lake", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01323-00289335-00289551": "house is making a similar point", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01324-00289552-00289647": "all right", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01325-00289648-00289879": "last call for comments before we break", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01326-00289880-00290087": "i'm cutting deeply into your 10 minutes", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01327-00290088-00290423": "of break time and i apologize for that", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01328-00290424-00290599": "our competitors yep", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01329-00290600-00290815": "all right let's call it there um thank", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01330-00290816-00290999": "you guys for a really good conversation", "H_bMusX4FxQ-01331-00291000-00291400": "i am turning off the recording"}}, {"audio_id": "HA4d3hLo8Ky", "text": {"HA4d3hLo8Ky-00000-00000006-00000371": "on the 1st of January 2023 Croatia", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00001-00000372-00000628": "adopted the Euro and with it it became", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00002-00000629-00000916": "the 20th member of the Euro area", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00003-00000917-00001108": "the country has shown great commitment", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00004-00001109-00001331": "along its path towards a Euro which", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00005-00001332-00001618": "hasn't always been easy after joining", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00006-00001619-00001984": "the EU in 2013 Croatia made significant", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00007-00001985-00002249": "progress in getting its economy ready to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00008-00002250-00002509": "adopt the Euro as its official currency", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00009-00002510-00002800": "but how much do you know about Croatia's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00010-00002801-00003071": "economy and about the steps it needed to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00011-00003072-00003256": "join the Euro family", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00012-00003257-00003431": "well that's what we'll be talking about", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00013-00003432-00003767": "today in what is the second episode in", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00014-00003768-00004025": "our mini-series on Croatia's adoption of", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00015-00004026-00004217": "the euro", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00016-00004218-00004399": "you're listening to the ECB podcast", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00017-00004400-00004631": "bringing you insights into the world of", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00018-00004632-00004901": "economics and Central Banking my name is", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00019-00004902-00005075": "Katie Ranger", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00020-00005076-00005309": "I'm joined here in the studio by Martin", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00021-00005310-00005561": "baisterbot who works in our economics", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00022-00005562-00005752": "department and was part of the team", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00023-00005753-00006011": "dealing with Croatia's adoption process", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00024-00006012-00006238": "Martin great to have you here on the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00025-00006239-00006472": "podcast thank you for having me here now", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00026-00006473-00006755": "can you kick things off a little bit by", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00027-00006756-00006970": "telling us something about Croatia's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00028-00006972-00007301": "economy I mean most of us probably know", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00029-00007302-00007553": "the country as a tourist destination but", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00030-00007554-00007745": "I've no doubt that there's much more to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00031-00007745-00008063": "it than that right absolutely I think", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00032-00008064-00008278": "what's interesting is that Croatia is a", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00033-00008279-00008453": "is a small and open economy highly", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00034-00008454-00008639": "integrated with the with the Euro area", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00035-00008640-00008951": "around 4 million inhabitants it's uh", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00036-00008952-00009196": "around half a percent of the Euro area's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00037-00009197-00009509": "GDP so it's a small economy but its", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00038-00009510-00009701": "structure is kind of say broadly similar", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00039-00009702-00009989": "to what we have in the Euro area so um", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00040-00009990-00010223": "but one thing that stands out I think it", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00041-00010224-00010360": "was interesting to mention is the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00042-00010361-00010510": "important role of Tourism as you already", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00043-00010511-00010810": "said it dominates the uh the services", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00044-00010811-00011045": "sector it's actually uh Croatia is one", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00045-00011046-00011195": "of the country countries that depends", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00046-00011196-00011453": "most on on tourism as a source of", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00047-00011454-00011692": "Revenue in the in the European Union and", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00048-00011693-00011974": "and it's around a fifth of the of its", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00049-00011975-00012119": "GDP", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00050-00012120-00012431": "is accounted for by by tourism and and", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00051-00012432-00012592": "that has of course also a sizable", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00052-00012593-00012737": "influence on other sectors of the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00053-00012738-00012965": "economy and maybe one more point that I", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00054-00012966-00013151": "think is relevant uh especially for Euro", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00055-00013152-00013408": "adoption is the uh the fact that Croatia", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00056-00013409-00013594": "has a has a tradition of stable exchange", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00057-00013595-00013858": "rates it created its National currency", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00058-00013859-00014171": "uh in 1994 it was you know it packed the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00059-00014172-00014441": "kuna the previous currency to uh the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00060-00014441-00014675": "German mark back then and after that in", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00061-00014676-00014938": "1999 to the euro so it has that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00062-00014940-00015113": "tradition of stable exchange rate which", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00063-00015113-00015251": "is important for the Europe", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00064-00015252-00015527": "okay so as you mentioned they they tied", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00065-00015528-00015725": "or pegged their previous currency the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00066-00015726-00015958": "corner uh to the euro and they'd been", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00067-00015959-00016241": "doing that since 1999. and that makes me", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00068-00016241-00016463": "wonder whether in fact they already had", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00069-00016464-00016715": "quite strong ties to other Euro", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00070-00016716-00016967": "countries before they even adopted the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00071-00016968-00017129": "currency themselves and particularly", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00072-00017130-00017308": "given the fact that they had already", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00073-00017309-00017572": "been in the EU for for 10 years yes", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00074-00017573-00017705": "absolutely", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00075-00017706-00018022": "um Croatia has had uh very strong ties", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00076-00018023-00018239": "with with the European Union with the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00077-00018240-00018508": "Euro area Financial ties for example uh", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00078-00018509-00018700": "the banking system for example a large", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00079-00018701-00018839": "part of the banking system the vast", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00080-00018840-00019144": "majority of Bank assets are are owned by", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00081-00019145-00019421": "um by by Foreign Banks Banks from the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00082-00019422-00019625": "Euro area especially from Italy and", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00083-00019626-00019805": "Austria so that is definitely one one", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00084-00019806-00020093": "factor another one is trade linkages", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00085-00020094-00020297": "um the Euro area is Croatia's main", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00086-00020298-00020621": "trading partner and in terms of debts uh", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00087-00020622-00020830": "that's that's definitely a factor that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00088-00020831-00021047": "stands out where you see that um you", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00089-00021048-00021191": "know we've seen a very high degree of", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00090-00021192-00021413": "what is called eurization so de facto", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00091-00021414-00021779": "use of the euro in in daily life uh for", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00092-00021780-00021989": "example in the issuance of debt for", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00093-00021990-00022330": "example public debt outstanding", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00094-00022331-00022649": "um is around 70 of that is nominated in", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00095-00022650-00022828": "Europe that's very high for a country", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00096-00022829-00023063": "that you know used to have a different", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00097-00023064-00023167": "currency", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00098-00023168-00023669": "so lots of links there trade Banks also", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00099-00023670-00023867": "this debt in in Euro that you just", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00100-00023868-00023986": "mentioned", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00101-00023987-00024383": "so why didn't Croatia adopt the Euro", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00102-00024384-00024550": "earlier I mean it's clear there were", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00103-00024551-00024749": "lots of links there", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00104-00024750-00025061": "what was their path to joining like", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00105-00025062-00025277": "yeah joining the euro is a long process", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00106-00025278-00025522": "and especially in terms of say", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00107-00025523-00025720": "convergence economic convergence takes", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00108-00025722-00025870": "time", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00109-00025872-00026128": "um Croatia came from a say a different", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00110-00026129-00026333": "starting point after Independence had to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00111-00026333-00026507": "go through an economic transition", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00112-00026508-00026668": "towards a fully functioning market", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00113-00026669-00026885": "economy and that takes time business", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00114-00026886-00027155": "Cycles to converge that also takes time", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00115-00027156-00027389": "set up the institutions for the Euro for", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00116-00027389-00027568": "the European Union takes time so when", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00117-00027569-00028007": "Croatia joined the EU back in 2013 it", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00118-00028008-00028223": "automatically agreed to adopt a Euro", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00119-00028224-00028361": "like that is in principle the case for", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00120-00028362-00028637": "every country that that joins the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00121-00028638-00028912": "European union now when a country says", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00122-00028913-00029051": "that it's ready to adopt the Euro then", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00123-00029052-00029189": "the next step is that the European", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00124-00029189-00029429": "commission and the ecpe need to assess", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00125-00029430-00029758": "whether the country is ready for Euro", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00126-00029760-00029974": "adoption so and that is done based on a", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00127-00029975-00030143": "number of criteria so-called convergence", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00128-00030144-00030370": "criteria okay let's just pause on those", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00129-00030372-00030635": "ones a minute these convergence criteria", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00130-00030636-00030751": "because", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00131-00030752-00030983": "these kind of requirements right that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00132-00030983-00031246": "the country has to fill in order to join", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00133-00031247-00031468": "the Euro area can you just explain a bit", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00134-00031469-00031637": "what they are", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00135-00031638-00031912": "yeah so there are economic criteria and", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00136-00031913-00032129": "there are legal criteria now let me here", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00137-00032130-00032302": "focus on the economic criteria there's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00138-00032303-00032518": "first of all the need to have stable", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00139-00032519-00032735": "prices", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00140-00032736-00032951": "um that means that inflation in the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00141-00032952-00033112": "country the average inflation rate", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00142-00033113-00033389": "cannot be more than uh 1.5 percent above", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00143-00033390-00033640": "the rate of the three best performing EU", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00144-00033641-00033881": "countries in terms of inflation the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00145-00033882-00034061": "logic of that is clear because you need", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00146-00034062-00034337": "to you need to have price stability to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00147-00034338-00034607": "successfully say participate in the in", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00148-00034608-00034852": "in the Euro area so that's basically the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00149-00034853-00035068": "three with the lowest rate of inflation", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00150-00035069-00035362": "essentially correct correct and in the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00151-00035363-00035615": "case of Croatia that inflation rate was", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00152-00035616-00035921": "something like 4.9 so below that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00153-00035922-00036124": "reference value so that is one factor", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00154-00036125-00036293": "now the other Factor", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00155-00036294-00036418": "um the other Criterion that's very", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00156-00036419-00036605": "important is the need to have sounds", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00157-00036606-00037018": "public finances and in in EU jargon that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00158-00037019-00037289": "means not having an excessive deficit so", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00159-00037290-00037487": "that essentially means that a country", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00160-00037488-00037709": "cannot have a deficit that is more than", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00161-00037710-00037955": "three percent of its GDP and it needs to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00162-00037956-00038218": "have a a debt ratio public debt ratio of", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00163-00038219-00038380": "less than 60 of GDP it's a little bit", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00164-00038381-00038543": "more subtle than that but essentially", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00165-00038544-00038680": "that's what a country needs to do you", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00166-00038681-00038885": "need to have and that is crucial because", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00167-00038886-00039101": "once you're in the Euro you don't have", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00168-00039102-00039245": "your own monetary policy anymore you", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00169-00039246-00039395": "don't have your own exchange rate policy", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00170-00039396-00039611": "anymore so you need sound public", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00171-00039612-00039809": "finances for example with fiscal buffers", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00172-00039810-00040079": "to deal with economic downturns so that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00173-00040080-00040307": "is uh the logic of that is very clear", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00174-00040308-00040511": "and it's also in the interest of the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00175-00040512-00040696": "Euro area as a whole to have sound", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00176-00040697-00040877": "public finances right because if that's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00177-00040878-00041080": "not the case it can have spillovers to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00178-00041081-00041345": "other Euro area members we've seen that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00179-00041346-00041543": "in the past and that is definitely uh so", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00180-00041544-00041812": "that is the essence there of the uh of", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00181-00041813-00041974": "the public finances criteria now the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00182-00041975-00042293": "other one is exchange rate stability so", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00183-00042294-00042557": "a country needs to have participated in", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00184-00042558-00042905": "the exchange rate mechanism the erm2 for", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00185-00042906-00043157": "at least two years without devaluing its", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00186-00043158-00043255": "currency", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00187-00043256-00043595": "and that is in a way and say an", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00188-00043596-00043829": "intermediate stage between say fully", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00189-00043830-00044087": "flexible exchange rates and uh and have", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00190-00044088-00044357": "and and having the Euro because it it's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00191-00044358-00044537": "a system of in principle", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00192-00044538-00044711": "fixed exchange rates but they can be", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00193-00044712-00044896": "adjusted and there's a fluctuation", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00194-00044897-00045185": "margin of up to 15 percent around that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00195-00045186-00045490": "Central rate uh so um it's it's a good", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00196-00045491-00045833": "say Preparatory phase for for having the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00197-00045834-00045995": "Euro so for at least two years continue", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00198-00045996-00046180": "to be in there and then we have the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00199-00046181-00046355": "long-term interest rate Criterion so", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00200-00046356-00046546": "their countries need to have low", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00201-00046547-00046768": "long-term interest rates in a way as an", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00202-00046769-00047033": "additional test an additional check to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00203-00047034-00047339": "to to see that the financial markets are", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00204-00047340-00047549": "convinced that the country has converged", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00205-00047550-00047783": "that convergence is sustainable and that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00206-00047784-00048095": "sustainability is a key concept that we", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00207-00048096-00048323": "always emphasize", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00208-00048324-00048557": "convergence needs to be sustainable also", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00209-00048558-00048761": "in the medium term especially given that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00210-00048762-00048940": "your adoption of course is a structural", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00211-00048941-00049157": "change it's a permanent change it's very", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00212-00049158-00049343": "important that a country can continue to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00213-00049344-00049601": "converge also after it it has adopted", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00214-00049602-00049793": "the Euro and then as I briefly mentioned", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00215-00049794-00050027": "there's also the the legal the legal", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00216-00050028-00050212": "framework which is essentially about the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00217-00050213-00050345": "independence of the Central Bank and a", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00218-00050346-00050495": "couple of other things but that is uh", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00219-00050496-00050711": "that is uh we look at that as well in", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00220-00050712-00050873": "our convergence reports that we do every", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00221-00050874-00051101": "two years or upon the request of a", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00222-00051102-00051287": "country when a country wants to adopt", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00223-00051288-00051563": "the Euro those are the criteria okay and", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00224-00051564-00051785": "Croatia officially fulfilled these", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00225-00051786-00052114": "criteria in in June 2022 right so that's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00226-00052115-00052337": "correct the stable prices sound public", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00227-00052338-00052679": "finances stable exchange rate and low", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00228-00052679-00052865": "long-term interest rates plus making", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00229-00052866-00053069": "sure that they can keep all that up", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00230-00053070-00053459": "after adoption yes now let's turn to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00231-00053460-00053837": "look at Croatia's economy today", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00232-00053838-00053980": "how's it doing", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00233-00053982-00054053": "um", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00234-00054054-00054323": "how has a country handled the shocks", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00235-00054324-00054599": "stemming from the pandemic and and also", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00236-00054600-00055066": "from Russia's awful war in Ukraine", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00237-00055067-00055342": "it's true that the uh we've had a few", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00238-00055344-00055529": "major economic shocks in the past few", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00239-00055529-00055685": "years like everywhere in Europe of", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00240-00055686-00055829": "course in Croatia has been been hit", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00241-00055829-00056069": "particularly hard by those as well uh", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00242-00056070-00056194": "being a country that's dependent on", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00243-00056195-00056411": "tourism of course it's no surprise that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00244-00056412-00056680": "the corona pandemic hit the the country", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00245-00056682-00056944": "heart real GDP went down by something", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00246-00056945-00057149": "like eight nine percent back in 2020", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00247-00057150-00057461": "when the when the pandemic came but it", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00248-00057462-00057569": "recovered", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00249-00057570-00057779": "um quite quite quickly actually it grew", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00250-00057779-00058259": "by around 13 uh by in in 2021 thanks to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00251-00058260-00058480": "tourism but also due to strong", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00252-00058482-00058792": "consumption spending investment uh it", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00253-00058794-00058925": "actually remained one of the fastest", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00254-00058926-00059249": "growing economies in the EU in in 22. oh", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00255-00059250-00059488": "wow so that was uh that was that went", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00256-00059489-00059591": "quite well", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00257-00059591-00059675": "um", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00258-00059676-00059903": "in terms of say the more recent shock so", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00259-00059904-00060203": "the the the Ukraine war the country has", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00260-00060204-00060442": "relatively limited say direct links to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00261-00060444-00060803": "to Russia uh so that is not the main the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00262-00060804-00060971": "main Channel through which it is it is", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00263-00060972-00061216": "exposed uh but obviously it is affected", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00264-00061217-00061415": "uh indirectly so that's definitely", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00265-00061416-00061619": "something that is affecting uh the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00266-00061620-00061799": "higher energy prices triggered by the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00267-00061800-00061961": "conflicts for example are affecting", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00268-00061962-00062182": "Croatia as well inflation Rose as a", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00269-00062183-00062488": "result of that and uh and it's uh it's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00270-00062489-00062699": "it's it's Energy prices food prices are", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00271-00062700-00062932": "up and uh even though fiscal measures", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00272-00062933-00063113": "have at least in the short have been", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00273-00063114-00063425": "able to kind of dampen that impact but", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00274-00063426-00063604": "it's clear that that is of course a", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00275-00063605-00063791": "challenge and uh like it is everywhere", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00276-00063791-00064025": "it's it's broadly in line there with uh", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00277-00064026-00064163": "with the rest of the Euro area the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00278-00064164-00064313": "increase in inflationary pressures that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00279-00064314-00064535": "we're that we're seeing but what I think", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00280-00064536-00064763": "is interesting there is that despite", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00281-00064764-00064985": "those shocks that we've seen that that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00282-00064986-00065209": "didn't really impact Croatia's capacity", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00283-00065210-00065500": "to fulfill the criteria for Euro", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00284-00065501-00065759": "adoption okay so similar pick to what", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00285-00065760-00065909": "we're seeing in in other Euro area", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00286-00065910-00066179": "countries but indeed it hasn't had an", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00287-00066180-00066365": "impact on their ability to join the Euro", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00288-00066366-00066563": "which is obviously good news", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00289-00066564-00066743": "now we've talked a lot about everything", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00290-00066744-00067055": "that Croatia has done to join the Euro", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00291-00067056-00067187": "area", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00292-00067188-00067438": "let's turn to talk about the people who", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00293-00067439-00067703": "actually use the currency what has it", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00294-00067704-00068015": "meant more concretely for croatians in", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00295-00068016-00068231": "in their everyday lives", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00296-00068232-00068465": "I think the most concrete thing is the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00297-00068466-00068585": "fact there is no risk of currency", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00298-00068586-00068759": "Flagship work fluctuations vis-a-vis the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00299-00068760-00068993": "euro so that means that people do not", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00300-00068994-00069191": "need to change their their currency", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00301-00069192-00069388": "anymore when they go abroad it also", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00302-00069389-00069641": "means that tourists that come to Croatia", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00303-00069642-00069826": "don't need to exchange their money", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00304-00069827-00070181": "anymore they can just spend spend euros", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00305-00070182-00070493": "and that is good for trade obviously we", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00306-00070494-00070726": "know from the literature that countries", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00307-00070727-00070906": "that share their currencies tend to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00308-00070907-00071105": "trade more with each other it's good for", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00309-00071106-00071305": "investment for cross-border investment", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00310-00071306-00071537": "so that will in the medium term", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00311-00071538-00071753": "certainly have positive impacts and and", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00312-00071754-00072059": "uh on on the Croatian economy so that is", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00313-00072060-00072215": "that is important that's a clear", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00314-00072216-00072550": "Advantage but I think that it's more", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00315-00072551-00072761": "than that it's more than just say the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00316-00072762-00072971": "absence of transaction costs the action", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00317-00072972-00073223": "absence of exchange rate risks", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00318-00073224-00073469": "as president Lagarde said in an", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00319-00073470-00073769": "interview recently the Euro acts as a", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00320-00073770-00074021": "shield it's a commitment in a way to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00321-00074022-00074188": "stick together so it's it's it's more", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00322-00074189-00074429": "than just the currency it also has", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00323-00074430-00074579": "implications of course in terms of say", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00324-00074580-00074867": "the responsibilities that countries have", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00325-00074868-00075082": "um economic policies in countries that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00326-00075083-00075335": "share the Euro cannot diverge too much", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00327-00075336-00075550": "so there is also responsibility to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00328-00075551-00075838": "National policy makers have", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00329-00075839-00076049": "um to ensure the success of the Euro and", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00330-00076050-00076217": "to ensure that the country can reap the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00331-00076218-00076499": "benefits of the of the Euro so I think", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00332-00076500-00076697": "that the benefits these benefits that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00333-00076698-00076888": "I've mentioned are really say recurring", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00334-00076889-00077081": "benefits that keep on coming also in the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00335-00077082-00077429": "longer term uh and uh and yeah they are", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00336-00077430-00077626": "clearly there for Croatia as well", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00337-00077627-00077843": "okay that's that's a lot about benefits", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00338-00077844-00078100": "of which there are many as you've said", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00339-00078101-00078400": "let's talk a bit about the costs", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00340-00078401-00078694": "because we have heard and and it has", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00341-00078695-00078869": "been reported in the media also outside", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00342-00078870-00079109": "Croatia that there have been some", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00343-00079110-00079403": "instances of prices being shall we say", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00344-00079404-00079738": "quietly increased during the conversion", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00345-00079739-00080087": "from Kuna to Euro what exactly is", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00346-00080088-00080267": "happening there Martin", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00347-00080268-00080447": "that's definitely something we take very", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00348-00080448-00080699": "seriously and the Croatian authorities", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00349-00080700-00080938": "are monitoring that very closely so that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00350-00080939-00081100": "there's been some discussion on that and", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00351-00081101-00081359": "there have been uh I think very strong", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00352-00081360-00081575": "measures uh that the the authorities", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00353-00081576-00081862": "have taken to prevent uh that that risk", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00354-00081863-00082043": "so businesses have signed the code of a", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00355-00082044-00082276": "code of ethics for the introduction of", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00356-00082277-00082415": "the Euro", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00357-00082416-00082732": "um so they in this way were obliged to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00358-00082733-00083032": "reflect say a fair pricing in both kuna", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00359-00083033-00083309": "and Euro so since the uh since early", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00360-00083310-00083597": "September for example last year we uh", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00361-00083598-00083831": "retailers have had to to display their", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00362-00083832-00084017": "prices in in both currencies and they", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00363-00084018-00084185": "will have to you know continue to do", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00364-00084186-00084503": "that until the end of the year and if a", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00365-00084504-00084737": "business does raise prices in an", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00366-00084738-00085000": "unjustified way it can be reported by", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00367-00085001-00085259": "consumers and the authorities can can", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00368-00085260-00085565": "can impose fines so I think that there's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00369-00085566-00085762": "a package of measures in place there to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00370-00085763-00086015": "to to address that now when we look at", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00371-00086016-00086206": "what has happened so far", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00372-00086207-00086609": "um and we we see that indeed there has", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00373-00086610-00086794": "been you know some prices have increased", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00374-00086795-00087017": "especially in the services sector we see", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00375-00087018-00087347": "there some signs of of higher prices", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00376-00087348-00087569": "when we look at say the broader picture", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00377-00087570-00087815": "and look at not just Services prices but", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00378-00087816-00087988": "say prices consumer prices in general", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00379-00087989-00088168": "and we have the uh this so-called", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00380-00088169-00088355": "harmonized index for Consumer prices for", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00381-00088356-00088643": "that uh that's like the basket of goods", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00382-00088644-00088793": "isn't it the basket of goods and", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00383-00088794-00089135": "services exactly exactly surprises when", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00384-00089136-00089261": "we look at that and we look at the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00385-00089262-00089476": "January data that we now have we see", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00386-00089477-00089771": "that that effect seems to have been more", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00387-00089772-00090035": "or less in say in in the same order of", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00388-00090036-00090256": "magnitude is that what we've seen during", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00389-00090257-00090503": "earlier changeovers so", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00390-00090504-00090767": "um it there there is some effect but I", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00391-00090768-00091147": "think it is it is not as alarming as as", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00392-00091148-00091444": "reported by some some media and that's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00393-00091445-00091631": "interesting because of course we are we", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00394-00091632-00091781": "have done this in a much more", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00395-00091782-00091943": "challenging environment in a higher", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00396-00091944-00092249": "inflation environment so that also makes", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00397-00092250-00092549": "it more difficult to distinguish between", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00398-00092550-00092806": "say Justified and unjustified price", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00399-00092807-00093065": "increases if prices go up in general uh", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00400-00093066-00093293": "that's a more challenging thing uh to do", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00401-00093294-00093575": "so it's not straightforward to identify", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00402-00093576-00093856": "what is an increase that is not", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00403-00093857-00093994": "explained by for example higher energy", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00404-00093995-00094223": "prices companies in general tend to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00405-00094224-00094409": "adjust their prices often at the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00406-00094410-00094565": "beginning of the year so these are all", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00407-00094566-00094823": "challenges that complicate say the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00408-00094824-00095176": "identification of the of the problem", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00409-00095177-00095375": "um but that's the the picture we have so", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00410-00095376-00095788": "far okay so now that Croatia has joined", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00411-00095789-00096076": "the Euro family does that mean that its", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00412-00096077-00096275": "path has has come to an end so they can", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00413-00096276-00096449": "just sit back and enjoy being in the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00414-00096450-00096688": "euro in a way in a way I would say it's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00415-00096689-00096881": "the beginning of a new past right it's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00416-00096882-00097097": "certainly not the end of the uh of the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00417-00097098-00097355": "efforts because countries uh also once", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00418-00097356-00097541": "they're inside they need to continue to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00419-00097542-00098015": "work on on reforms and uh those reforms", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00420-00098016-00098185": "are crucial to boost", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00421-00098186-00098429": "economic growth to make the economy more", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00422-00098430-00098812": "resilient to shocks to to to downturns", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00423-00098813-00099106": "to economic setbacks and I think when we", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00424-00099107-00099394": "look at Croatia I think a key challenge", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00425-00099395-00099749": "that we see there is uh is a challenge", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00426-00099750-00099959": "that stems from demographic developments", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00427-00099960-00100156": "it's not unique to Croatia other", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00428-00100157-00100324": "European countries are facing similar", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00429-00100325-00100594": "similar issues but we do see in their", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00430-00100595-00100705": "available", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00431-00100706-00101081": "reports that that show that when you", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00432-00101082-00101338": "project the evolution of Croatia's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00433-00101339-00101506": "population over the longer term it's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00434-00101507-00101711": "going to decline further and that is uh", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00435-00101712-00101903": "that is a challenge", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00436-00101904-00101956": "um", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00437-00101957-00102232": "will put pressure on pension systems it", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00438-00102233-00102556": "will put pressure on public finances and", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00439-00102557-00102725": "it will also reduce the availability of", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00440-00102726-00102934": "Staff or that you know could could", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00441-00102935-00103210": "worsen shortages and labor or shortages", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00442-00103211-00103444": "of Staff in in the labor market so", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00443-00103445-00103642": "that's a clear challenge", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00444-00103643-00103834": "um I think another one is really say", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00445-00103835-00104123": "productivity growth uh in the in the in", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00446-00104124-00104344": "the medium term so it's important there", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00447-00104345-00104573": "to you know to focus on say Innovation", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00448-00104574-00104801": "fostering Innovation investment in new", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00449-00104802-00105107": "technologies uh European debate often", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00450-00105108-00105293": "focuses on the green transition the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00451-00105294-00105460": "digital transition these things are", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00452-00105461-00105719": "obviously important also also for for", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00453-00105720-00105845": "Croatia", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00454-00105846-00106133": "and and maybe also to broaden their the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00455-00106133-00106283": "sources of economic growth Beyond", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00456-00106283-00106547": "tourism tourism is clearly it's not it's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00457-00106548-00106810": "natural that that tourism is an", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00458-00106811-00106990": "important factor behind economic growth", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00459-00106991-00107173": "Croatia simply has the natural", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00460-00107174-00107345": "endowments it has a comparative", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00461-00107346-00107633": "advantage in in tourism so it makes", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00462-00107633-00107819": "sense that that is an important sector", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00463-00107820-00108065": "but it is good to you know also to to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00464-00108066-00108383": "broaden those sources of growth uh", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00465-00108383-00108815": "beyond beyond tourism uh into say other", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00466-00108816-00108983": "sectors that can drive growth that can", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00467-00108983-00109151": "drive productivity in the in the more", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00468-00109152-00109271": "medium term and then we have public", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00469-00109272-00109493": "administration the judicial system is", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00470-00109494-00109619": "always a very important one because", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00471-00109620-00109810": "whenever there is a say an economic", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00472-00109811-00110104": "setback in deaths in private sector in", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00473-00110105-00110333": "the private sector increase it's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00474-00110333-00110507": "important to have a well-functioning", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00475-00110508-00110681": "judicial system that can deal with the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00476-00110682-00110890": "debt restructuring that is needed and", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00477-00110891-00111149": "can you know so that that restructuring", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00478-00111150-00111334": "is implemented is done in a swift way", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00479-00111335-00111599": "and sort of bank balance sheets are", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00480-00111600-00112001": "cleaned up quickly so these things are", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00481-00112002-00112228": "are important I think to have in place", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00482-00112229-00112457": "well Croatia has made a lot of progress", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00483-00112458-00112804": "on that front and uh so I think that uh", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00484-00112805-00112954": "we can only be we should be very", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00485-00112955-00113099": "positive on that front but you know", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00486-00113100-00113231": "there's there's it's important to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00487-00113232-00113434": "continue along those lines", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00488-00113435-00113704": "now before we wrap up Martin we we", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00489-00113705-00113860": "always have a question that we ask all", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00490-00113861-00114095": "our guests here on the podcast and", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00491-00114096-00114328": "that's for a hot tip linked broadly", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00492-00114329-00114508": "linked to the topic that we've been", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00493-00114509-00114736": "discussing today now in our previous", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00494-00114738-00115049": "podcast uh on Croatia we talked about", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00495-00115050-00115295": "the animals that are on the the Croatian", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00496-00115296-00115510": "euro coins Martin have you thought of", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00497-00115511-00115775": "something for our listeners", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00498-00115776-00115984": "well you know when I think of this", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00499-00115985-00116278": "process I've seen other countries", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00500-00116279-00116531": "adopting the euro in the past and of", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00501-00116532-00116758": "course we have gone through some say", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00502-00116759-00116957": "more challenging times with the Euro but", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00503-00116958-00117163": "what one thing that strikes me in when I", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00504-00117164-00117497": "see the Croatia adopting the euro is", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00505-00117498-00117683": "really that you know when you look at", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00506-00117683-00117851": "this in a more say longer term", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00507-00117852-00118102": "perspective and we when you compare that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00508-00118103-00118289": "with how we started we started back in", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00509-00118290-00118715": "1999 with 11 countries and now", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00510-00118716-00118901": "um with essentially the you know the", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00511-00118902-00119231": "Euro has doubled almost doubled in size", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00512-00119232-00119375": "when you look at the number of countries", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00513-00119376-00119602": "that that use the euro and I think that", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00514-00119603-00119813": "that's a really strong sign of success", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00515-00119814-00120178": "in only 20 years in only 20 years it", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00516-00120179-00120484": "shows that the Euro area is a an", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00517-00120485-00120797": "attractive place to be and and I think", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00518-00120798-00121013": "that that's something to be proud of", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00519-00121014-00121199": "so I think that that is important to to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00520-00121200-00121481": "to keep in mind and to", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00521-00121482-00121739": "um to celebrate as uh it's a good thing", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00522-00121740-00121984": "that you that the Croatia is there and", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00523-00121985-00122219": "it's a good thing and not just in terms", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00524-00122220-00122458": "of say the number of countries that we", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00525-00122459-00122699": "have but we've also seen the Euro area", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00526-00122700-00122897": "has strengthened over time in terms of", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00527-00122898-00123089": "its institutions that have been put into", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00528-00123090-00123473": "place we have a supervisory system super", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00529-00123474-00123736": "banking supervisory system", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00530-00123738-00123940": "um that has been set up in in something", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00531-00123941-00124102": "like a decade and it's well functioning", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00532-00124103-00124319": "we have the European civility mechanism", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00533-00124320-00124475": "for example you know since the first", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00534-00124476-00124715": "wave of countries we have added a number", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00535-00124716-00124895": "of changes number of institutional", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00536-00124896-00125039": "changes in the Euro area that have", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00537-00125040-00125363": "really strengthened the basis of the of", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00538-00125364-00125536": "the currency Union so I think that's", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00539-00125538-00125752": "that's something to be proud of I think", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00540-00125753-00125945": "we often take for granted just how much", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00541-00125946-00126119": "has been achieved in such a short space", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00542-00126120-00126286": "of time so I think that's a great a", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00543-00126288-00126466": "great note to end on thank you so much", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00544-00126467-00126677": "for joining us today Martin thank you", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00545-00126678-00126958": "very much well that brings us to the end", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00546-00126959-00127139": "of this episode", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00547-00127140-00127384": "I want to thank Martin by sabosh from", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00548-00127385-00127552": "our economics department for giving us", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00549-00127553-00127810": "what was essentially a crash course in", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00550-00127811-00128008": "Croatia's economy and and its Journey", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00551-00128009-00128351": "towards the Euro listeners as usual you", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00552-00128352-00128489": "can check out the show notes for", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00553-00128490-00128836": "additional material on this topic you've", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00554-00128838-00129028": "been listening to the ECB podcast with", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00555-00129029-00129233": "Katie Ranger if you like what you've", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00556-00129233-00129419": "heard Please Subscribe and leave us a", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00557-00129420-00129677": "review until next time thanks for", "HA4d3hLo8Ky-00558-00129678-00129914": "listening"}}, {"audio_id": "HA81398T07M", "text": {"HA81398T07M-00000-00000082-00001495": "[Music]", "HA81398T07M-00001-00001496-00001671": "just to sip and smoke my wheat", "HA81398T07M-00002-00001672-00001910": "hella shawties looking golly i might go", "HA81398T07M-00003-00001911-00002007": "ahead and sit", "HA81398T07M-00004-00002007-00002247": "i arrive with my dogs open the gate", "HA81398T07M-00005-00002248-00002359": "before we leave", "HA81398T07M-00006-00002360-00002631": "every man on his own got always we like", "HA81398T07M-00007-00002632-00002871": "the feasts as soon as they let us in it", "HA81398T07M-00008-00002872-00002999": "don't take much to drop the", "HA81398T07M-00009-00003000-00003254": "leash let the games begin go chase a", "HA81398T07M-00010-00003255-00003431": "bone don't leave no me they told us", "HA81398T07M-00011-00003432-00003719": "arrive at 10 but you know we on cpt drop", "HA81398T07M-00012-00003720-00003870": "the song when we walking", "HA81398T07M-00013-00003871-00004175": "the people bobbing to the beat i have a", "HA81398T07M-00014-00004176-00004392": "long weep but i don't want", "HA81398T07M-00015-00004393-00005054": "[Music]", "HA81398T07M-00016-00005055-00005567": "[Music]", "HA81398T07M-00017-00005568-00005806": "circle with no strings attached hey", "HA81398T07M-00018-00005807-00005999": "don't pull up with the big head we might", "HA81398T07M-00019-00006000-00006118": "have to cat", "HA81398T07M-00020-00006119-00006318": "hey if you don't like kareem you can't", "HA81398T07M-00021-00006319-00006463": "come through with that", "HA81398T07M-00022-00006464-00006703": "hey i fixed my frequency your energy", "HA81398T07M-00023-00006704-00006814": "should match", "HA81398T07M-00024-00006815-00007083": "yeah i'm too far on turbo turn it to the", "HA81398T07M-00025-00007084-00007606": "max", "HA81398T07M-00026-00007608-00007887": "inferno but we don't do switcher raps", "HA81398T07M-00027-00007888-00008087": "and they hit like portals the way we be", "HA81398T07M-00028-00008088-00008223": "switching raps hey", "HA81398T07M-00029-00008224-00008439": "fun to blow volcano take off like a", "HA81398T07M-00030-00008440-00008567": "ziggy zap", "HA81398T07M-00031-00008568-00008783": "we just want to make ends meet like we", "HA81398T07M-00032-00008784-00008871": "building tracks", "HA81398T07M-00033-00008872-00009135": "yeah shook them off their ankles i might", "HA81398T07M-00034-00009136-00009214": "overlap", "HA81398T07M-00035-00009215-00009383": "yeah spit this knowledge through this", "HA81398T07M-00036-00009384-00010071": "tooth aperture no gap down", "HA81398T07M-00037-00010072-00011320": "yeah i said if you were bad [__]"}}, {"audio_id": "HA8OPqXttd8", "text": {"HA8OPqXttd8-00000-00000306-00000493": "[Music]", "HA8OPqXttd8-00001-00000494-00001243": "thank you", "HA8OPqXttd8-00002-00001244-00001757": "can you see it's just me I'm dressed up", "HA8OPqXttd8-00003-00001757-00002341": "to look like a skeleton a scary time", "HA8OPqXttd8-00004-00002342-00002758": "I'm gonna scare you now", "HA8OPqXttd8-00005-00002759-00003445": "thank you", "HA8OPqXttd8-00006-00003446-00004001": "happy Halloween", "HA8OPqXttd8-00007-00004002-00004301": "be Halloween", "HA8OPqXttd8-00008-00004302-00004799": "can you see it's just me I'm dressed up", "HA8OPqXttd8-00009-00004800-00005217": "to look like a vampire a vampire", "HA8OPqXttd8-00010-00005218-00005383": "[Music]", "HA8OPqXttd8-00011-00005384-00005642": "I'm gonna scare you now", "HA8OPqXttd8-00012-00005643-00006991": "[Music]", "HA8OPqXttd8-00013-00006992-00007345": "happy Halloween", "HA8OPqXttd8-00014-00007345-00007846": "can you see it's just me I'm dressed up", "HA8OPqXttd8-00015-00007847-00008248": "to look like a ghost a ghost", "HA8OPqXttd8-00016-00008249-00008431": "[Music]", "HA8OPqXttd8-00017-00008432-00009510": "I'm gonna scare you now", "HA8OPqXttd8-00018-00009511-00010387": "happy Halloween", "HA8OPqXttd8-00019-00010388-00010889": "can you see it's just me I'm dressed up", "HA8OPqXttd8-00020-00010890-00011455": "to look like a monster a monster", "HA8OPqXttd8-00021-00011456-00012464": "I'm gonna scare you now", "HA8OPqXttd8-00022-00012465-00013091": "[Applause]", "HA8OPqXttd8-00023-00013091-00013763": "happy Halloween", "HA8OPqXttd8-00024-00013763-00014794": "foreign", "HA8OPqXttd8-00025-00014796-00015505": "[Music]", "HA8OPqXttd8-00026-00015506-00015899": "do you know what color this is this is", "HA8OPqXttd8-00027-00015900-00015977": "red", "HA8OPqXttd8-00028-00015978-00016163": "[Music]", "HA8OPqXttd8-00029-00016163-00016571": "this is blue the color blue blue blue", "HA8OPqXttd8-00030-00016572-00016747": "blue", "HA8OPqXttd8-00031-00016748-00017299": "this is blue the color blue blue blue", "HA8OPqXttd8-00032-00017300-00017699": "do you know what color this is this is", "HA8OPqXttd8-00033-00017700-00017778": "blue", "HA8OPqXttd8-00034-00017779-00017953": "[Music]", "HA8OPqXttd8-00035-00017954-00018365": "this is green the color green green", "HA8OPqXttd8-00036-00018366-00018569": "green green Green", "HA8OPqXttd8-00037-00018570-00018971": "this is green the color green green", "HA8OPqXttd8-00038-00018972-00019093": "green Green", "HA8OPqXttd8-00039-00019094-00019505": "do you know what color this is this is", "HA8OPqXttd8-00040-00019506-00019769": "green", "HA8OPqXttd8-00041-00019770-00020063": "this is yellow the color yellow yellow", "HA8OPqXttd8-00042-00020064-00020363": "yellow yellow yellow", "HA8OPqXttd8-00043-00020364-00020675": "this is yellow the color yellow yellow", "HA8OPqXttd8-00044-00020676-00020899": "yellow yellow yellow", "HA8OPqXttd8-00045-00020900-00021286": "do you know what color this is this is", "HA8OPqXttd8-00046-00021287-00021541": "yellow", "HA8OPqXttd8-00047-00021542-00021953": "this is white the color white white", "HA8OPqXttd8-00048-00021954-00022141": "white white", "HA8OPqXttd8-00049-00022142-00022558": "this is white the color white white", "HA8OPqXttd8-00050-00022559-00022699": "white white", "HA8OPqXttd8-00051-00022700-00023099": "do you know what color this is this is", "HA8OPqXttd8-00052-00023100-00023335": "white", "HA8OPqXttd8-00053-00023336-00023764": "this is gray the color gray gray gray", "HA8OPqXttd8-00054-00023765-00023947": "gray", "HA8OPqXttd8-00055-00023948-00024358": "this is gray the color gray gray gray", "HA8OPqXttd8-00056-00024359-00024499": "gray gray", "HA8OPqXttd8-00057-00024500-00024893": "do you know what color this is this is", "HA8OPqXttd8-00058-00024894-00024980": "gray", "HA8OPqXttd8-00059-00024981-00025656": "[Music]", "HA8OPqXttd8-00060-00025657-00025711": "[Applause]", "HA8OPqXttd8-00061-00025712-00026305": "[Music]", "HA8OPqXttd8-00062-00026306-00026687": "do you know what color this is this is", "HA8OPqXttd8-00063-00026688-00026776": "black", "HA8OPqXttd8-00064-00026777-00027046": "[Music]", "HA8OPqXttd8-00065-00027047-00027568": "round the color brown brown brown", "HA8OPqXttd8-00066-00027569-00027958": "this is brown the color brown brown", "HA8OPqXttd8-00067-00027960-00028105": "brown", "HA8OPqXttd8-00068-00028106-00028493": "do you know what color this is this is", "HA8OPqXttd8-00069-00028494-00028764": "brown", "HA8OPqXttd8-00070-00028766-00029099": "this is orange the color orange orange", "HA8OPqXttd8-00071-00029100-00029358": "orange", "HA8OPqXttd8-00072-00029360-00029758": "this is orange the color orange orange", "HA8OPqXttd8-00073-00029760-00029911": "orange", "HA8OPqXttd8-00074-00029912-00030274": "do you know what color this is this is", "HA8OPqXttd8-00075-00030275-00030380": "orange", "HA8OPqXttd8-00076-00030381-00030568": "[Music]", "HA8OPqXttd8-00077-00030569-00030946": "this is purple the color purple purple", "HA8OPqXttd8-00078-00030947-00031158": "purple purple", "HA8OPqXttd8-00079-00031160-00031474": "this is purple the color purple purple", "HA8OPqXttd8-00080-00031475-00031711": "purple purple", "HA8OPqXttd8-00081-00031712-00032105": "do you know what color this is this is", "HA8OPqXttd8-00082-00032106-00032177": "purple", "HA8OPqXttd8-00083-00032179-00032364": "[Music]", "HA8OPqXttd8-00084-00032366-00032968": "this is pink the color pink pink pink", "HA8OPqXttd8-00085-00032969-00033505": "this is pink the color pink pink", "HA8OPqXttd8-00086-00033506-00033887": "do you know what color this is this is", "HA8OPqXttd8-00087-00033888-00033996": "Pink", "HA8OPqXttd8-00088-00033997-00034479": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "HAjroFx568I", "text": {"HAjroFx568I-00000-00000008-00000158": "amazon has acquired the production", "HAjroFx568I-00001-00000159-00000511": "company mgm listing on the nasdaq retail", "HAjroFx568I-00002-00000512-00000686": "stores will continue to exist post", "HAjroFx568I-00003-00000687-00000854": "comment 19 plus", "HAjroFx568I-00004-00000855-00001015": "um a very good customer acquisition", "HAjroFx568I-00005-00001016-00001143": "tactic is what's your business", "HAjroFx568I-00006-00001144-00001262": "development process that they started", "HAjroFx568I-00007-00001263-00001391": "what are the steps that you'd recommend", "HAjroFx568I-00008-00001392-00001591": "the business to the uae is one of the", "HAjroFx568I-00009-00001592-00001807": "countries listed that uh will have that", "HAjroFx568I-00010-00001807-00002071": "feature expo 2020 is here and it looks", "HAjroFx568I-00011-00002072-00002487": "great i'm aimed at aitani i'm aiming", "HAjroFx568I-00012-00002488-00002835": "and this is mizrah"}}, {"audio_id": "HAEh1v-yoeU", "text": {"HAEh1v-yoeU-00000-00000634-00001333": "[Applause]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00001-00001334-00001555": "thank you", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00002-00001556-00003578": "[Music]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00003-00003579-00003715": "[Applause]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00004-00003715-00004276": "[Music]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00005-00004277-00004621": "[Applause]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00006-00004622-00004637": "[Music]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00007-00004638-00005065": "[Applause]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00008-00005066-00005449": "thank you", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00009-00005450-00006508": "[Music]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00010-00006509-00006898": "[Applause]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00011-00006900-00007203": "foreign", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00012-00007204-00007552": "[Applause]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00013-00007553-00007739": "[Music]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00014-00007740-00008400": "foreign", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00015-00008401-00010705": "[Music]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00016-00010706-00010763": "[Applause]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00017-00010764-00011328": "[Music]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00018-00011329-00011575": "thank you", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00019-00011576-00011794": "[Applause]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00020-00011795-00012492": "[Music]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00021-00012493-00012605": "thank you", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00022-00012606-00012830": "[Music]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00023-00012831-00013136": "[Applause]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00024-00013137-00013241": "[Music]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00025-00013241-00013897": "[Applause]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00026-00013899-00016767": "[Music]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00027-00016768-00017179": "[Applause]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00028-00017180-00017569": "thank you", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00029-00017570-00018155": "[Music]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00030-00018156-00018462": "foreign", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00031-00018463-00019332": "[Applause]", "HAEh1v-yoeU-00032-00019333-00021580": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "HASuOt8iYPy", "text": {"HASuOt8iYPy-00000-00000000-00000316": "peeps good morning today is April Fool's", "HASuOt8iYPy-00001-00000317-00000763": "Day for us oh yes what Gina I am joke to", "HASuOt8iYPy-00002-00000764-00001031": "have it wasn't supposed to have ever", "HASuOt8iYPy-00003-00001032-00001232": "heard I guess the day were completely on", "HASuOt8iYPy-00004-00001233-00001796": "edge with everything that we do", "HASuOt8iYPy-00005-00001797-00002130": "are super tired you know three days in a", "HASuOt8iYPy-00006-00002131-00002307": "row we've been up since early in the", "HASuOt8iYPy-00007-00002308-00002474": "morning with the bed later south new", "HASuOt8iYPy-00008-00002475-00003840": "prank video you guys must equal fools if", "HASuOt8iYPy-00009-00003840-00004029": "you lean on this wall you'll conquer cuz", "HASuOt8iYPy-00010-00004029-00004374": "it's cardboard I would laugh so hard", "HASuOt8iYPy-00011-00004375-00004652": "like it's it's all cardboard I guess", "HASuOt8iYPy-00012-00004653-00005772": "they're building a new Idol wrong one", "HASuOt8iYPy-00013-00005773-00006035": "yeah", "HASuOt8iYPy-00014-00006036-00006269": "if you guys didn't see yesterday's far", "HASuOt8iYPy-00015-00006270-00006470": "we have had a couple curse words here", "HASuOt8iYPy-00016-00006470-00006629": "like you're supposed to take out that", "HASuOt8iYPy-00017-00006630-00006839": "sword I did we let that [__] work", "HASuOt8iYPy-00018-00006840-00006962": "because we didn't think it was that big", "HASuOt8iYPy-00019-00006963-00007034": "of a deal", "HASuOt8iYPy-00020-00007034-00007226": "originally this all might upset you get", "HASuOt8iYPy-00021-00007227-00010285": "debris do it you guys into this so good", "HASuOt8iYPy-00022-00010286-00011270": "old fresh organic", "HASuOt8iYPy-00023-00011271-00011763": "it's all like fresh handmade stuff and", "HASuOt8iYPy-00024-00011764-00012066": "made homemade whatever juice intended", "HASuOt8iYPy-00025-00012067-00014718": "and man is it isn't it Inessa sagen", "HASuOt8iYPy-00026-00014719-00015202": "to get to work there's like scooter", "HASuOt8iYPy-00027-00015203-00015466": "stations where you can park them up and", "HASuOt8iYPy-00028-00015466-00015757": "it has like a vending machine I mean I", "HASuOt8iYPy-00029-00015758-00015901": "don't know what a scam machines that you", "HASuOt8iYPy-00030-00015902-00016162": "could play let's see I don't know if you", "HASuOt8iYPy-00031-00016163-00016869": "have to I don't think you have to pay", "HASuOt8iYPy-00032-00016870-00017194": "how's your day going I wonder if people", "HASuOt8iYPy-00033-00017195-00017341": "are like on scooters when they pass each", "HASuOt8iYPy-00034-00017342-00017781": "other no hey how you doing nice to see", "HASuOt8iYPy-00035-00017782-00018079": "here's when we were on the Today Show we", "HASuOt8iYPy-00036-00018080-00018268": "yelled out the answers to be annoying on", "HASuOt8iYPy-00037-00018269-00018412": "purpose that critters just told us to do", "HASuOt8iYPy-00038-00018413-00021267": "it", "HASuOt8iYPy-00039-00021268-00023824": "that's still awkward jesse was annoying", "HASuOt8iYPy-00040-00023825-00024028": "this [__] out of her during the whole", "HASuOt8iYPy-00041-00024029-00024289": "show from behind the scenes like behind", "HASuOt8iYPy-00042-00024290-00024544": "the stage and that was just part of the", "HASuOt8iYPy-00043-00024545-00024736": "prank that was it we're on the sedation", "HASuOt8iYPy-00044-00024737-00024985": "walking around the brain leaves your", "HASuOt8iYPy-00045-00024986-00025495": "baseball Network dope sign the wall rock", "HASuOt8iYPy-00046-00025496-00026407": "yeah here take a spot next to somebody", "HASuOt8iYPy-00047-00026408-00028097": "good okay William now be", "HASuOt8iYPy-00048-00028098-00029237": "yeah the market for me to see something", "HASuOt8iYPy-00049-00029238-00030095": "dope studio 3 number 3 for Avery hi I'm", "HASuOt8iYPy-00050-00030095-00030467": "Aiman interface Musti I always wondered", "HASuOt8iYPy-00051-00030468-00031127": "you know I step on this baseball so what", "HASuOt8iYPy-00052-00031127-00031313": "you guys don't know is you're wondering", "HASuOt8iYPy-00053-00031314-00031442": "why we're doing all this baseball stuff", "HASuOt8iYPy-00054-00031443-00031754": "I'm gonna be the new host for a major", "HASuOt8iYPy-00055-00031755-00032306": "league baseball show I mean I keep", "HASuOt8iYPy-00056-00032307-00032447": "looking at this lore interests right", "HASuOt8iYPy-00057-00032448-00032836": "here I want to see if it's back there", "HASuOt8iYPy-00058-00032837-00033449": "here this is cool", "HASuOt8iYPy-00059-00033450-00033758": "oh there's nothing in there best thing", "HASuOt8iYPy-00060-00033759-00033980": "is Jesse thinks that I'm preaching it", "HASuOt8iYPy-00061-00033981-00034259": "and I'm told so I'm gonna just [__] with", "HASuOt8iYPy-00062-00034260-00034400": "him the whole time and that's gonna be", "HASuOt8iYPy-00063-00034401-00034664": "my little April Fool's Day prank on it", "HASuOt8iYPy-00064-00034665-00034805": "cuz you know like we were saying", "HASuOt8iYPy-00065-00034806-00035015": "yesterday if you think if someone thinks", "HASuOt8iYPy-00066-00035016-00035126": "they're getting pranked that's like the", "HASuOt8iYPy-00067-00035127-00035303": "worst thing it's a really horrible", "HASuOt8iYPy-00068-00035304-00035426": "feeling because you're scared or you're", "HASuOt8iYPy-00069-00035427-00035552": "on the edge the whole time so I'm just", "HASuOt8iYPy-00070-00035553-00035786": "gonna mess with them it's really worried", "HASuOt8iYPy-00071-00035787-00035930": "because I just took the camera - I've", "HASuOt8iYPy-00072-00035931-00036119": "makeup on and now we're doing life -", "HASuOt8iYPy-00073-00036120-00036461": "listen live television kind of nervous", "HASuOt8iYPy-00074-00036462-00036593": "they told me everything I should talk", "HASuOt8iYPy-00075-00036594-00036851": "about I forgot already so see how this", "HASuOt8iYPy-00076-00036852-00039600": "goes I'm really bad at talking", "HASuOt8iYPy-00077-00039601-00040039": "that's six four rows back I felt a", "HASuOt8iYPy-00078-00040040-00040369": "little suspicious because choose she was", "HASuOt8iYPy-00079-00040370-00040504": "doing the worst type of prank acting", "HASuOt8iYPy-00080-00040505-00041928": "like there is a paper that really isn't", "HASuOt8iYPy-00081-00041929-00043376": "just as a high baseball", "HASuOt8iYPy-00082-00043377-00043845": "set it up they draw very nice and your", "HASuOt8iYPy-00083-00043846-00044043": "girlfriend Jian is involved in this too", "HASuOt8iYPy-00084-00044044-00044325": "yes yes so you guys must go back oh yeah", "HASuOt8iYPy-00085-00044326-00044505": "we've tried each other that's how we got", "HASuOt8iYPy-00086-00044506-00044658": "here is because of you still pranks all", "HASuOt8iYPy-00087-00044659-00044862": "right though she pranked me on the show", "HASuOt8iYPy-00088-00044863-00045543": "she lifted me up in a 90-foot crane and", "HASuOt8iYPy-00089-00045544-00045681": "we've linked up with Major League", "HASuOt8iYPy-00090-00045682-00045879": "Baseball on YouTube right and without to", "HASuOt8iYPy-00091-00045880-00046098": "speak that opportunity to work with some", "HASuOt8iYPy-00092-00046099-00046257": "major league baseball players to portray", "HASuOt8iYPy-00093-00046258-00046491": "like Charles super game is a probably I", "HASuOt8iYPy-00094-00046492-00046734": "definitely want to take Gary and I and", "HASuOt8iYPy-00095-00046735-00046908": "some of his players forget about what's", "HASuOt8iYPy-00096-00046909-00047175": "going on Utley I let's let's do it I", "HASuOt8iYPy-00097-00047176-00047379": "came out very and we put him in the most", "HASuOt8iYPy-00098-00047380-00047658": "awkward situation that we could go good", "HASuOt8iYPy-00099-00047659-00048899": "work yeah where's she hiding", "HASuOt8iYPy-00100-00048900-00049326": "I thought you were pregnant for real cuz", "HASuOt8iYPy-00101-00049327-00049503": "usually I want to make cool shots of", "HASuOt8iYPy-00102-00049504-00049671": "this area and I was like that's an", "HASuOt8iYPy-00103-00049672-00049812": "excuse for her to sit there and fill me", "HASuOt8iYPy-00104-00049813-00051144": "right now anyway", "HASuOt8iYPy-00105-00051145-00051457": "fear we are all finished I think", "HASuOt8iYPy-00106-00051458-00051856": "everything yeah you made me think that", "HASuOt8iYPy-00107-00051857-00051976": "there was gonna be a prank and it wasn't", "HASuOt8iYPy-00108-00051977-00052274": "a prank it's not so now I think that's", "HASuOt8iYPy-00109-00052275-00052450": "it we're pretty much done so now we can", "HASuOt8iYPy-00110-00052451-00054267": "just chillax", "HASuOt8iYPy-00111-00054269-00054517": "I have something I need to tell you know", "HASuOt8iYPy-00112-00054519-00054722": "one of the first nation to hear about it", "HASuOt8iYPy-00113-00054723-00055211": "till I know I've been acting weird and", "HASuOt8iYPy-00114-00055212-00055454": "I've been like eating a lot of junk food", "HASuOt8iYPy-00115-00055454-00055847": "and having morning sickness and all and", "HASuOt8iYPy-00116-00055848-00056179": "I need to let you know that I'm pregnant", "HASuOt8iYPy-00117-00056179-00056767": "yes and the baby's not yours I'm gonna", "HASuOt8iYPy-00118-00056769-00057904": "have it okay I don't know would it be", "HASuOt8iYPy-00119-00057905-00058138": "two boys cuz I don't want a girl could", "HASuOt8iYPy-00120-00058139-00058342": "then they didn't boys little did little", "HASuOt8iYPy-00121-00058344-00058600": "girl and I'll beat them up I'm just", "HASuOt8iYPy-00122-00058601-00059449": "joking I'm not pregnant", "HASuOt8iYPy-00123-00059450-00059735": "before present yeah really poor we were", "HASuOt8iYPy-00124-00059736-00059929": "so busy the last three days as a prank", "HASuOt8iYPy-00125-00059930-00060454": "Academy with all the media I know but we", "HASuOt8iYPy-00126-00060455-00060641": "couldn't prank each other on April", "HASuOt8iYPy-00127-00060641-00060931": "Fool's Day our guards were way way up", "HASuOt8iYPy-00128-00060932-00061112": "but we did have a good prank to post", "HASuOt8iYPy-00129-00061113-00061456": "today was which was the major league", "HASuOt8iYPy-00130-00061457-00061582": "baseball so if you haven't checked it", "HASuOt8iYPy-00131-00061583-00061709": "out check it out there was a really", "HASuOt8iYPy-00132-00061710-00061987": "really real really real real real funny", "HASuOt8iYPy-00133-00061988-00062305": "prank and yeah I mean that's it for all", "HASuOt8iYPy-00134-00062306-00062482": "the media that we had set up for", "HASuOt8iYPy-00135-00062483-00062699": "pregnancy on TV we're all done so after", "HASuOt8iYPy-00136-00062700-00062869": "we got done that Major League Baseball", "HASuOt8iYPy-00137-00062870-00063161": "thing we laid in bed watch TV until now", "HASuOt8iYPy-00138-00063162-00063761": "edited we Netflix and chill but we're", "HASuOt8iYPy-00139-00063762-00063947": "gonna go off the bed peeps we love you", "HASuOt8iYPy-00140-00063948-00064069": "guys thank you for all the love and", "HASuOt8iYPy-00141-00064070-00064276": "support and if you're a hardcore Pete", "HASuOt8iYPy-00142-00064277-00064475": "please smash the thumbs up button come", "HASuOt8iYPy-00143-00064476-00064669": "on peeps let's go hamburger right now", "HASuOt8iYPy-00144-00064670-00065032": "i'ma wait for y'all did you do it you", "HASuOt8iYPy-00145-00065033-00065174": "didn't do it yet you just sat there or", "HASuOt8iYPy-00146-00065175-00065375": "like now all right now you did it that's", "HASuOt8iYPy-00147-00065376-00065540": "what's up without you guys and we'll see", "HASuOt8iYPy-00148-00065541-00065617": "y'all tomorrow", "HASuOt8iYPy-00149-00065618-00066011": "peace on the streets"}}, {"audio_id": "HAbgEF_wGec", "text": {"HAbgEF_wGec-00000-00000040-00000199": "[Music]", "HAbgEF_wGec-00001-00000200-00000383": "from my part", "HAbgEF_wGec-00002-00000384-00000511": "uh", "HAbgEF_wGec-00003-00000512-00001103": "as much as i can contribute", "HAbgEF_wGec-00004-00001104-00001295": "as for the muslim world league we are", "HAbgEF_wGec-00005-00001296-00001582": "completely ready to help you the earth", "HAbgEF_wGec-00006-00001583-00001926": "is who we are", "HAbgEF_wGec-00007-00001927-00002110": "we're going to save the soil do your", "HAbgEF_wGec-00008-00002111-00002350": "part and saving the soils in our", "HAbgEF_wGec-00009-00002351-00002495": "planet's future", "HAbgEF_wGec-00010-00002496-00002639": "depend on it", "HAbgEF_wGec-00011-00002640-00002887": "save soil my friend let's save soil and", "HAbgEF_wGec-00012-00002888-00003251": "create", "HAbgEF_wGec-00013-00003252-00004135": "[Music]", "HAbgEF_wGec-00014-00004136-00004863": "it is time to save", "HAbgEF_wGec-00015-00004864-00005102": "we know what we must do", "HAbgEF_wGec-00016-00005103-00005359": "so let's make it happen let's make it", "HAbgEF_wGec-00017-00005360-00005559": "happen let's make it happen let's make", "HAbgEF_wGec-00018-00005560-00005799": "it happen let's make this happen let us", "HAbgEF_wGec-00019-00005800-00006086": "make it happen let's make it happen safe", "HAbgEF_wGec-00020-00006087-00007719": "soil let's make it happen", "HAbgEF_wGec-00021-00007720-00008078": "[Music]", "HAbgEF_wGec-00022-00008079-00008207": "our soil", "HAbgEF_wGec-00023-00008208-00008359": "needs nourishing", "HAbgEF_wGec-00024-00008360-00008495": "save soil", "HAbgEF_wGec-00025-00008496-00008791": "let us make it happen and the movement", "HAbgEF_wGec-00026-00008792-00009103": "that you are taken up i could not expect", "HAbgEF_wGec-00027-00009104-00009374": "any more god's blessing than that", "HAbgEF_wGec-00028-00009375-00009663": "guru and this campaign is so important i", "HAbgEF_wGec-00029-00009664-00009903": "welcome satguru's conscious planet", "HAbgEF_wGec-00030-00009904-00011431": "initiative", "HAbgEF_wGec-00031-00011432-00011655": "this is a global goal this must be a", "HAbgEF_wGec-00032-00011656-00012894": "generational aspiration", "HAbgEF_wGec-00033-00012895-00013111": "thanks to you i know that we also are", "HAbgEF_wGec-00034-00013112-00013375": "facing a soil crisis and uh thank you", "HAbgEF_wGec-00035-00013376-00013494": "very much you gave me a lot to think", "HAbgEF_wGec-00036-00013495-00013575": "about", "HAbgEF_wGec-00037-00013576-00013703": "you've been", "HAbgEF_wGec-00038-00013704-00014047": "on this trip 100 days 27 countries safe", "HAbgEF_wGec-00039-00014047-00015166": "soil campaign", "HAbgEF_wGec-00040-00015168-00017583": "good morning", "HAbgEF_wGec-00041-00017584-00018790": "hey", "HAbgEF_wGec-00042-00018791-00019767": "[Music]", "HAbgEF_wGec-00043-00019768-00020206": "again", "HAbgEF_wGec-00044-00020207-00022463": "[Music]", "HAbgEF_wGec-00045-00022464-00022749": "uh", "HAbgEF_wGec-00046-00022750-00023014": "[Applause]", "HAbgEF_wGec-00047-00023015-00024511": "hey", "HAbgEF_wGec-00048-00024512-00025968": "oh", "HAbgEF_wGec-00049-00025969-00027599": "[Music]", "HAbgEF_wGec-00050-00027600-00029295": "oh", "HAbgEF_wGec-00051-00029295-00029543": "soil is not our property", "HAbgEF_wGec-00052-00029544-00029743": "it's a legacy that's come to us from", "HAbgEF_wGec-00053-00029744-00030023": "previous generations and we must pass it", "HAbgEF_wGec-00054-00030024-00031702": "on as living soil for future generations", "HAbgEF_wGec-00055-00031703-00032488": "oh", "HAbgEF_wGec-00056-00032489-00033188": "[Applause]", "HAbgEF_wGec-00057-00033189-00033570": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "HAbkX74FGVc", "text": {"HAbkX74FGVc-00000-00000017-00000313": "okay guys we're back again with another", "HAbkX74FGVc-00001-00000314-00000649": "exciting product and today we're looking", "HAbkX74FGVc-00002-00000650-00001153": "at the sensor bluetooth headphones and", "HAbkX74FGVc-00003-00001154-00001541": "this is righted by Amazon it's the", "HAbkX74FGVc-00004-00001542-00001810": "Amazon choice product it's write it as", "HAbkX74FGVc-00005-00001811-00002246": "one of the best eight phones Bluetooth", "HAbkX74FGVc-00006-00002247-00002674": "headphones in this category you know so", "HAbkX74FGVc-00007-00002675-00003137": "it's ideal for running any kind of hot", "HAbkX74FGVc-00008-00003138-00003329": "work out you doing", "HAbkX74FGVc-00009-00003329-00003797": "it's got noise canceling feature in the", "HAbkX74FGVc-00010-00003797-00003956": "state phone's built-in into the cell", "HAbkX74FGVc-00011-00003957-00004404": "phones and it's just you know it's just", "HAbkX74FGVc-00012-00004405-00005029": "great product it's got this little", "HAbkX74FGVc-00013-00005030-00005315": "feature of year that will obviously", "HAbkX74FGVc-00014-00005316-00005770": "assist the headphone from falling off a", "HAbkX74FGVc-00015-00005771-00006303": "year with a year bad type of speaker", "HAbkX74FGVc-00016-00006304-00006831": "that will obviously also assist the", "HAbkX74FGVc-00017-00006833-00007273": "headphone to stay inside your ear while", "HAbkX74FGVc-00018-00007275-00008164": "doing any kind of workout you get the", "HAbkX74FGVc-00019-00008165-00008810": "carry case with and then a bonus item as", "HAbkX74FGVc-00020-00008811-00009124": "Dominick magnetic covent cell phone man", "HAbkX74FGVc-00021-00009125-00009253": "so awesome", "HAbkX74FGVc-00022-00009254-00009769": "also getting this with this product and", "HAbkX74FGVc-00023-00009770-00010133": "another bonus item of mobile phone well", "HAbkX74FGVc-00024-00010134-00010499": "so you get quite a few things with so", "HAbkX74FGVc-00025-00010500-00010844": "the carry case the cell phone mount and", "HAbkX74FGVc-00026-00010845-00011681": "in the mobile phone wallet", "HAbkX74FGVc-00027-00011682-00012447": "it's just giving you 1 year warranty on", "HAbkX74FGVc-00028-00012448-00012714": "this product and a 30 day money back", "HAbkX74FGVc-00029-00012715-00012872": "guarantee so if you're not fully", "HAbkX74FGVc-00030-00012874-00013074": "satisfied with this product you can", "HAbkX74FGVc-00031-00013075-00013407": "return it within 30 days now questions", "HAbkX74FGVc-00032-00013408-00013638": "are for your money back", "HAbkX74FGVc-00033-00013638-00013913": "great deal I mean here it in two colors", "HAbkX74FGVc-00034-00013915-00014330": "black and I will see the red color", "HAbkX74FGVc-00035-00014331-00014784": "that's red one day and what else do we", "HAbkX74FGVc-00036-00014785-00015013": "have here", "HAbkX74FGVc-00037-00015015-00015585": "and then also they've got 24/7 365 days", "HAbkX74FGVc-00038-00015586-00015947": "live fall in support so I just think you", "HAbkX74FGVc-00039-00015949-00016290": "know from from customer service to what", "HAbkX74FGVc-00040-00016291-00016619": "kind of product it is and that Amazon", "HAbkX74FGVc-00041-00016620-00017061": "writes this product like on top of this", "HAbkX74FGVc-00042-00017062-00017298": "category I think you can't go wrong", "HAbkX74FGVc-00043-00017299-00017573": "getting this product it's a it's really", "HAbkX74FGVc-00044-00017574-00017880": "according to what what what deal you're", "HAbkX74FGVc-00045-00017881-00018090": "getting what customer support you", "HAbkX74FGVc-00046-00018091-00018435": "getting the warranty you getting the", "HAbkX74FGVc-00047-00018436-00018657": "money back guarantee you getting all", "HAbkX74FGVc-00048-00018658-00019022": "about bonus items you getting with this", "HAbkX74FGVc-00049-00019023-00019365": "earphones I just think this is this is", "HAbkX74FGVc-00050-00019366-00019944": "truly a great deal so click on the promo", "HAbkX74FGVc-00051-00019945-00020525": "link get this product to die wall stock", "HAbkX74FGVc-00052-00020526-00020721": "loss because this is this is definitely", "HAbkX74FGVc-00053-00020722-00020978": "gonna go quick guys is gonna is gonna", "HAbkX74FGVc-00054-00020979-00021264": "sell out quick as you can see guys are", "HAbkX74FGVc-00055-00021265-00021425": "buying this guys are buying this very", "HAbkX74FGVc-00056-00021426-00021732": "quickly so click on that promo link and", "HAbkX74FGVc-00057-00021733-00021912": "please remember to subscribe to this", "HAbkX74FGVc-00058-00021913-00022328": "channel we bringing you a lot more deals", "HAbkX74FGVc-00059-00022329-00022722": "on Amazon Amazon page sellers and or", "HAbkX74FGVc-00060-00022723-00023049": "Amazon choice products so please go and", "HAbkX74FGVc-00061-00023050-00023397": "subscribe press the notification the", "HAbkX74FGVc-00062-00023398-00023715": "little Bell button for new notifications", "HAbkX74FGVc-00063-00023716-00024060": "new videos so you guys can be basically", "HAbkX74FGVc-00064-00024061-00024342": "stay updated on all the new products and", "HAbkX74FGVc-00065-00024343-00024723": "what's hot and what's not so until I see", "HAbkX74FGVc-00066-00024724-00024822": "you again", "HAbkX74FGVc-00067-00024823-00025329": "have a lovely day Cheers"}}, {"audio_id": "HBqDys2aWAU", "text": {"HBqDys2aWAU-00000-00000074-00000958": "one button i am stood as much to talk I", "HBqDys2aWAU-00001-00000959-00002508": "didn't let it to you no silly boo ha ha", "HBqDys2aWAU-00002-00002509-00002981": "sure should he tested and is a Buddha oh", "HBqDys2aWAU-00003-00002982-00003722": "oh oh what it was waters commercial KO", "HBqDys2aWAU-00004-00003722-00004465": "phi d 2 tilde and whiskey", "HBqDys2aWAU-00005-00004466-00004935": "next when you lose my son is amazing yes", "HBqDys2aWAU-00006-00004936-00005695": "yeah started a sitter yeah because none", "HBqDys2aWAU-00007-00005696-00006136": "of my night old book hey you got you", "HBqDys2aWAU-00008-00006137-00006372": "would not yet discovered not itchy book", "HBqDys2aWAU-00009-00006373-00006820": "of commission much yea though I study", "HBqDys2aWAU-00010-00006820-00007366": "the book okay mmm and said during the", "HBqDys2aWAU-00011-00007367-00008893": "right okay see ya at HS Clemmie Tim knew", "HBqDys2aWAU-00012-00008894-00009187": "my book already said she I loopner it's", "HBqDys2aWAU-00013-00009188-00009780": "a nutrition through my facial", "HBqDys2aWAU-00014-00009781-00010916": "mnemonic", "HBqDys2aWAU-00015-00010917-00011905": "and then", "HBqDys2aWAU-00016-00011906-00015594": "what and Gloria in tanga tanga and then", "HBqDys2aWAU-00017-00015594-00015975": "marketer with me on my tongue please", "HBqDys2aWAU-00018-00015976-00016455": "kill it I dynasty has done yet a double", "HBqDys2aWAU-00019-00016456-00017043": "vanity with a pearl google chrome glesca", "HBqDys2aWAU-00020-00017044-00017983": "l know let's go oh oh I was Mexico", "HBqDys2aWAU-00021-00017984-00018583": "conmigo period um that is cuz I'm Ellen", "HBqDys2aWAU-00022-00018584-00019102": "don't run nice office what he said it", "HBqDys2aWAU-00023-00019103-00019618": "negative dorm Leslie q yet finished in", "HBqDys2aWAU-00024-00019619-00020065": "here is our office because she was with", "HBqDys2aWAU-00025-00020066-00021525": "Rita are noise I had Casilla in the bed", "HBqDys2aWAU-00026-00021526-00022344": "ah now yet no I didn't let it in yet", "HBqDys2aWAU-00027-00022345-00023052": "susmita down a tree yet to go hideous", "HBqDys2aWAU-00028-00023053-00023600": "hmm get me ma gucci boots cuz he's now 0", "HBqDys2aWAU-00029-00023601-00024097": "0 class II knew you difficult with a new", "HBqDys2aWAU-00030-00024098-00025149": "coach isn't cough cough like a rock ark", "HBqDys2aWAU-00031-00025150-00026747": "ma no no I got eaten yet ah no ah so", "HBqDys2aWAU-00032-00026748-00027120": "shoaib it's just a children SS new", "HBqDys2aWAU-00033-00027120-00027516": "friends Tony's of the poster yo Shawn", "HBqDys2aWAU-00034-00027517-00028497": "and our youth l-dopa probably be that", "HBqDys2aWAU-00035-00028498-00029097": "angry scared rincon be you can't imagine", "HBqDys2aWAU-00036-00029098-00030236": "so this is Sarah ha click huh slip slip", "HBqDys2aWAU-00037-00030237-00030942": "slip ha yep", "HBqDys2aWAU-00038-00030943-00033294": "ha ji hae been met ha pharmacy this is", "HBqDys2aWAU-00039-00033295-00033579": "it illustrates an drugs to children to", "HBqDys2aWAU-00040-00033580-00033996": "stay on mr. Trevor ah he's not your", "HBqDys2aWAU-00041-00033997-00034640": "money apiece Anna Eshoo a grayish see me", "HBqDys2aWAU-00042-00034641-00035160": "investing was not okay all i need to do", "HBqDys2aWAU-00043-00035161-00035763": "a custom y'all should I sure we all said", "HBqDys2aWAU-00044-00035764-00036081": "that Cano fed up invited clueless each", "HBqDys2aWAU-00045-00036082-00036669": "you're gonna get medical in nature sitz", "HBqDys2aWAU-00046-00036670-00037179": "bath shower bobolit ketheria of Jo to be", "HBqDys2aWAU-00047-00037180-00038450": "a better política huh formerly pillows", "HBqDys2aWAU-00048-00038451-00039408": "Stephen Stephen shabba ha flip little", "HBqDys2aWAU-00049-00039409-00040418": "bit", "HBqDys2aWAU-00050-00040419-00041892": "you slippery let it slip nice and yet", "HBqDys2aWAU-00051-00041893-00043617": "mmm what wha eat and q 2 q", "HBqDys2aWAU-00052-00043618-00045154": "you got room mr. musketeer of no gamez", "HBqDys2aWAU-00053-00045155-00046270": "go to a gala here mmm our garba in", "HBqDys2aWAU-00054-00046271-00046570": "managua shimmer knocks it hurt it's k", "HBqDys2aWAU-00055-00046571-00046947": "magic some not this most goal to do them", "HBqDys2aWAU-00056-00046948-00049677": "yes I don't ever do it would go crannies", "HBqDys2aWAU-00057-00049678-00050278": "Becca talked about you need us o my sons", "HBqDys2aWAU-00058-00050279-00050536": "are solving yet Ithaca escamilla only", "HBqDys2aWAU-00059-00050537-00051265": "Nitsa nothing I didn't drag me to take", "HBqDys2aWAU-00060-00051266-00051613": "advantage and worse than you did against", "HBqDys2aWAU-00061-00051614-00051862": "in size in the children Smuggler's", "HBqDys2aWAU-00062-00051863-00052060": "cooker that was ever sit backwards you", "HBqDys2aWAU-00063-00052061-00052805": "come over to me rutila Jackson said", "HBqDys2aWAU-00064-00052807-00053091": "whatever this is I didn't I said when", "HBqDys2aWAU-00065-00053092-00053367": "message a message in the phone then at", "HBqDys2aWAU-00066-00053369-00053679": "16 badges boys are what day yet know the", "HBqDys2aWAU-00067-00053680-00054917": "way sure oh right les calm good friends", "HBqDys2aWAU-00068-00054919-00055362": "never thought what is my frenulum comes", "HBqDys2aWAU-00069-00055363-00056503": "friends full force haha rice once count", "HBqDys2aWAU-00070-00056504-00057619": "Thank stop it oh wow Glennon religion", "HBqDys2aWAU-00071-00057620-00057973": "neeta lulla mantis tell me at the", "HBqDys2aWAU-00072-00057974-00058635": "meanest most of us can escape us a", "HBqDys2aWAU-00073-00058636-00058830": "policeman either i need to go watch", "HBqDys2aWAU-00074-00058832-00059254": "adorable cookie ok a synthetic tu Sugar", "HBqDys2aWAU-00075-00059254-00059539": "Bowl cream cookie with a good program", "HBqDys2aWAU-00076-00059540-00060420": "and show me about it all media us s", "HBqDys2aWAU-00077-00060421-00061176": "listen farms sales gosh worsen how my", "HBqDys2aWAU-00078-00061177-00061754": "metallurgic it's not a dude rushing", "HBqDys2aWAU-00079-00061755-00062563": "rushing me Olga Heidi Rosen Sarah sugar", "HBqDys2aWAU-00080-00062564-00062896": "yeah sure"}}, {"audio_id": "HBevai3k-x4", "text": {"HBevai3k-x4-00000-00000050-00000320": "today's our 35th annual Christmas", "HBevai3k-x4-00001-00000321-00000509": "crusade shopping day oh I have boys and", "HBevai3k-x4-00002-00000509-00000730": "girls and these are nice and warm", "HBevai3k-x4-00003-00000731-00000916": "this year we're shopping for over 300", "HBevai3k-x4-00004-00000917-00001100": "kids eight year old boys let's find them", "HBevai3k-x4-00005-00001101-00001307": "here likes hoodie sweatshirts", "HBevai3k-x4-00006-00001308-00001469": "we're trying to get these kids the most", "HBevai3k-x4-00007-00001470-00001766": "important needs and it's sad", "HBevai3k-x4-00008-00001767-00001960": "unfortunately his most important Nita", "HBevai3k-x4-00009-00001961-00002180": "socks especially needed sighs adult", "HBevai3k-x4-00010-00002181-00002377": "medium shirts officers throughout the", "HBevai3k-x4-00011-00002378-00002549": "year come in contact with kids that they", "HBevai3k-x4-00012-00002550-00002915": "think they might not have a Christmas we", "HBevai3k-x4-00013-00002916-00003272": "want to get back to the community look", "HBevai3k-x4-00014-00003272-00003331": "at that one", "HBevai3k-x4-00015-00003332-00003536": "we want to let them know that officers", "HBevai3k-x4-00016-00003536-00003701": "are humans and that we see the struggles", "HBevai3k-x4-00017-00003702-00003806": "that they're going to and we want to", "HBevai3k-x4-00018-00003807-00003992": "make sure that these kids and families", "HBevai3k-x4-00019-00003993-00004429": "have a Christmas there's so many", "HBevai3k-x4-00020-00004430-00004613": "families out there in the world that", "HBevai3k-x4-00021-00004614-00005081": "they're struggling you want to make sure", "HBevai3k-x4-00022-00005082-00005327": "that we get these gifts to the kids in", "HBevai3k-x4-00023-00005328-00005497": "time for Christmas so that they have", "HBevai3k-x4-00024-00005498-00005773": "gifts for Christmas"}}, {"audio_id": "HBGFgyBTVZu", "text": {"HBGFgyBTVZu-00000-00000287-00000390": "lady", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00001-00000391-00000509": "goes", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00002-00000511-00002738": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00003-00002739-00003254": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00004-00003255-00004719": "okay", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00005-00004720-00005275": "huh", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00006-00005276-00005902": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00007-00005903-00006133": "ready", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00008-00006134-00008982": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00009-00008983-00009614": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00010-00009615-00011871": "ready", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00011-00011872-00012791": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00012-00012792-00012894": "ready", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00013-00012895-00013616": "good", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00014-00013618-00014094": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00015-00014095-00015082": "oh stuff", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00016-00015083-00016430": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00017-00016431-00017215": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00018-00017216-00017385": "dude", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00019-00017386-00019014": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00020-00019015-00020014": "lady god", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00021-00020015-00020572": "huh", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00022-00020573-00021568": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00023-00021569-00023022": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00024-00023023-00023145": "uh", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00025-00023146-00024094": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00026-00024095-00024730": "ready", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00027-00024731-00025704": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00028-00025705-00026662": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00029-00026663-00026918": "three", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00030-00026919-00027551": "baby", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00031-00027552-00028454": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00032-00028455-00031675": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00033-00031676-00033114": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00034-00033115-00035743": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00035-00035744-00036994": "hey", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00036-00036995-00037630": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00037-00037631-00038185": "okay", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00038-00038186-00038879": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00039-00038880-00039202": "okay", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00040-00039203-00040087": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00041-00040088-00040595": "oh", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00042-00040596-00041174": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00043-00041175-00041717": "ladies", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00044-00041718-00042740": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00045-00042741-00043495": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00046-00043496-00044072": "winner", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00047-00044073-00045591": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00048-00045592-00046974": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00049-00046975-00047539": "oh", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00050-00047540-00047958": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00051-00047959-00048397": "hello", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00052-00048398-00049318": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00053-00049319-00051942": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00054-00051944-00052252": "ladies", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00055-00052253-00052890": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00056-00052891-00053974": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00057-00053975-00054750": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00058-00054751-00054863": "lady", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00059-00054864-00055015": "go", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00060-00055016-00055529": "walking", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00061-00055529-00056512": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00062-00056513-00057978": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00063-00057979-00059063": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00064-00059064-00059285": "why not", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00065-00059286-00062726": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00066-00062727-00063247": "winner", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00067-00063248-00065294": "ready", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00068-00065295-00065645": "oh", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00069-00065646-00066667": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00070-00066668-00069150": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00071-00069151-00069505": "monkey", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00072-00069506-00070215": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00073-00070216-00071838": "ladies", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00074-00071839-00072392": "hmm", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00075-00072393-00073526": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00076-00073527-00073631": "lady", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00077-00073632-00075847": "god", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00078-00075848-00076771": "okay", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00079-00076772-00078817": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00080-00078818-00079894": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00081-00079895-00080735": "ready", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00082-00080736-00081965": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00083-00081966-00082223": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00084-00082224-00083927": "eddy", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00085-00083928-00084539": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00086-00084540-00085143": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00087-00085144-00085575": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00088-00085576-00085778": "me", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00089-00085779-00087062": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00090-00087063-00088862": "hmm", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00091-00088863-00089743": "oh", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00092-00089744-00091126": "[Music]", "HBGFgyBTVZu-00093-00091127-00091427": "ready"}}, {"audio_id": "HC5fHxm1EXI", "text": {"HC5fHxm1EXI-00000-00000093-00001171": "[Music]", "HC5fHxm1EXI-00001-00001172-00001511": "[Music]", "HC5fHxm1EXI-00002-00001512-00002286": "uh", "HC5fHxm1EXI-00003-00002287-00003093": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "HCrky7eXoXu", "text": {"HCrky7eXoXu-00000-00000119-00000366": "we're back baby that's right", "HCrky7eXoXu-00001-00000367-00000623": "we're back i'm back we're making youtube", "HCrky7eXoXu-00002-00000624-00000751": "videos what about", "HCrky7eXoXu-00003-00000752-00001007": "who knows but let's go we have", "HCrky7eXoXu-00004-00001008-00001462": "new flashy effects", "HCrky7eXoXu-00005-00001463-00001687": "that's right i just left", "HCrky7eXoXu-00006-00001688-00001830": "the green screen and for the", "HCrky7eXoXu-00007-00001832-00001887": "joke", "HCrky7eXoXu-00008-00001888-00002231": "so we're going for a channel revamp", "HCrky7eXoXu-00009-00002232-00002534": "but uh i'm gonna tell you let's get to a", "HCrky7eXoXu-00010-00002535-00002879": "different location", "HCrky7eXoXu-00011-00002880-00003199": "so i did a whole bit um so", "HCrky7eXoXu-00012-00003200-00003511": "i did all about teleporting around and", "HCrky7eXoXu-00013-00003511-00003599": "drinking", "HCrky7eXoXu-00014-00003600-00003967": "uh i'll put that at some speed", "HCrky7eXoXu-00015-00003968-00004283": "right here and we're gonna move it up", "HCrky7eXoXu-00016-00004284-00004431": "there", "HCrky7eXoXu-00017-00004432-00004886": "actually there sorry this is mirrored", "HCrky7eXoXu-00018-00004887-00005215": "basically here's what we have coming", "HCrky7eXoXu-00019-00005216-00005511": "i don't know but here's some ideas", "HCrky7eXoXu-00020-00005512-00005686": "probably a lot of collab videos this is", "HCrky7eXoXu-00021-00005687-00005751": "kind of", "HCrky7eXoXu-00022-00005752-00006111": "probably become more of a community", "HCrky7eXoXu-00023-00006112-00006518": "project and nothing but views and", "HCrky7eXoXu-00024-00006519-00006687": "subscribers i do not care about the", "HCrky7eXoXu-00025-00006688-00006855": "individual i want that very", "HCrky7eXoXu-00026-00006856-00007046": "clear i don't care about you", "HCrky7eXoXu-00027-00007047-00007406": "yeah we might rate some houses uh", "HCrky7eXoXu-00028-00007408-00007634": "if i can make a drawing video maybe on", "HCrky7eXoXu-00029-00007636-00007783": "scribble.io", "HCrky7eXoXu-00030-00007784-00008078": "scribblio i don't give it we might just", "HCrky7eXoXu-00031-00008079-00008295": "sit down and talk", "HCrky7eXoXu-00032-00008296-00008599": "or if you're feeling", "HCrky7eXoXu-00033-00008600-00009046": "crazy crazy crazy crazy", "HCrky7eXoXu-00034-00009047-00009478": "absolutely insane enough he might", "HCrky7eXoXu-00035-00009479-00009783": "we might bake", "HCrky7eXoXu-00036-00009784-00010174": "cook cooking with pubis and", "HCrky7eXoXu-00037-00010175-00010335": "you'll be right there with it won't you", "HCrky7eXoXu-00038-00010336-00010719": "loyal subscriber", "HCrky7eXoXu-00039-00010720-00011135": "so yeah making", "HCrky7eXoXu-00040-00011136-00011559": "dare i say faking it for views", "HCrky7eXoXu-00041-00011560-00012424": "anyway i'm back"}}, {"audio_id": "HCuXNeIWAt0", "text": {"HCuXNeIWAt0-00000-00000040-00000399": "hello i'm lux and i remember and we both", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00001-00000400-00000639": "love the movie frozen but it's one of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00002-00000640-00000807": "those movies that leaves you with", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00003-00000808-00001158": "questions so here are 10 questions that", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00004-00001159-00001503": "we thought of that frozen made us ask", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00005-00001504-00001726": "obviously spoilers", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00006-00001727-00001910": "our opinions we love the movie don't", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00007-00001911-00002030": "hurt us", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00008-00002032-00002271": "question number one", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00009-00002272-00002559": "how does no one know about elsa's powers", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00010-00002560-00002799": "outside of the family an entire castle", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00011-00002800-00003095": "full of servants no one has ever", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00012-00003096-00003263": "observed anything", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00013-00003264-00003470": "walked in on the girls playing", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00014-00003471-00003719": "caught elsa when she accidentally froze", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00015-00003720-00003831": "something", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00016-00003832-00004119": "and what about later after they reduced", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00017-00004120-00004438": "the castle staff and everything elsa", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00018-00004439-00004591": "can't stay locked in her room the whole", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00019-00004592-00004902": "time you know life doesn't work that way", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00020-00004903-00005151": "one of my so my answers to this is when", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00021-00005152-00005302": "she was younger i don't think there was", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00022-00005303-00005551": "many mistakes because she was happy and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00023-00005552-00005799": "the key to this is the more she's afraid", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00024-00005800-00005983": "the more her powers get out of control", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00025-00005984-00006143": "but the more she's happy the more in", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00026-00006144-00006302": "control she is so when she's younger", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00027-00006303-00006431": "she's more in control so i don't think", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00028-00006431-00006567": "the servants really realized she had", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00029-00006568-00006734": "powers because it looked like anna and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00030-00006736-00006934": "elsa did a lot of playing by themselves", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00031-00006936-00007142": "at night to probably", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00032-00007143-00007246": "keep things", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00033-00007247-00007398": "you know under wraps", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00034-00007400-00007655": "yes but they're laughing and giggling", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00035-00007656-00007910": "and in a castle full of parents and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00036-00007911-00008142": "staff no one's ever heard that and gone", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00037-00008143-00008310": "to check on them they're princesses", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00038-00008311-00008519": "don't they have a nanny or a governess", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00039-00008520-00008767": "good point do you have any answers to it", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00040-00008768-00008967": "yourself um", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00041-00008968-00009287": "that nobody expects a girl to have", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00042-00009288-00009542": "powers therefore they're not looking for", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00043-00009543-00009791": "signs of it and anything they may see", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00044-00009792-00010087": "like some frost on a window or an object", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00045-00010088-00010335": "can easily be explained away or just not", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00046-00010336-00010439": "noticed", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00047-00010440-00010646": "question two who's been running the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00048-00010647-00010967": "kingdom i mean the girls are orphans", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00049-00010968-00011087": "before", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00050-00011088-00011295": "do you want to build a snowman is over", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00051-00011296-00011503": "it looks a bit at least elsa", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00052-00011504-00011703": "may be old enough to quote unquote run", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00053-00011704-00011927": "it and i think she may be running it", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00054-00011928-00012087": "through the door so the servants come up", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00055-00012088-00012270": "to her she tells them what to do and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00056-00012271-00012583": "then so on and so forth and maybe elsa", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00057-00012584-00012695": "is doing", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00058-00012696-00012999": "little stuff but nothing really big", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00059-00013000-00013175": "so they may be running the kingdom kind", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00060-00013176-00013455": "of remotely or by proxy if i use that", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00061-00013456-00013583": "term correctly", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00062-00013584-00013838": "see we have it heavily implied that elsa", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00063-00013840-00014143": "never leaves her rooms so is she", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00064-00014144-00014415": "submitting everything to the council in", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00065-00014416-00014591": "writing and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00066-00014591-00014799": "why would the council listen to her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00067-00014800-00014999": "she's a little girl", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00068-00015000-00015215": "okay i know she looks more teenager-ish", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00069-00015216-00015438": "by the time the parents die but still we", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00070-00015440-00015686": "have the entire implication that elsa", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00071-00015687-00015894": "never leaves her rooms", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00072-00015895-00016175": "well i think like i said by the time the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00073-00016176-00016343": "parents are dead she's old enough to run", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00074-00016344-00016622": "the kingdom and the people come to her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00075-00016623-00016839": "and work out some type of deal or", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00076-00016840-00017039": "something i think she actually doesn't", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00077-00017040-00017279": "um leave the castle but she stays in the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00078-00017280-00017447": "room a lot but i think by the time her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00079-00017448-00017750": "parents are dead she comes out of the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00080-00017751-00017967": "room more and does stuff inside the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00081-00017968-00018239": "castle which then brings up the question", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00082-00018240-00018439": "of how did anna never manage to corner", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00083-00018440-00018630": "her spending all that time trying to get", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00084-00018631-00018791": "a hold of her and running around the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00085-00018792-00019063": "castle i don't really know", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00086-00019064-00019255": "but on to", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00087-00019256-00019463": "question number three what about lessons", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00088-00019464-00019591": "for the girls", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00089-00019592-00019775": "this goes back again to the heavy", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00090-00019776-00020007": "implication that elsa never leaves her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00091-00020008-00020279": "rooms i know that they are princesses", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00092-00020280-00020486": "but i think they're close enough in age", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00093-00020487-00020743": "that they would probably share tutors if", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00094-00020744-00020958": "the parents were trying to reduce elsa's", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00095-00020959-00021263": "contact with other people who taught her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00096-00021264-00021535": "anything okay obvious answer of parents", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00097-00021536-00021783": "because they're in on the secret that", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00098-00021784-00022030": "elsa has powers but they can't teach her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00099-00022031-00022191": "everything hello they're supposed to be", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00100-00022192-00022383": "busy running the kingdom well i think", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00101-00022384-00022535": "there's some indication in the movie", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00102-00022536-00022686": "that you're right that the parents do a", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00103-00022687-00022847": "lot of the teaching", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00104-00022848-00023127": "so maybe it's the mother because it's", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00105-00023128-00023319": "usually the king who does most of the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00106-00023320-00023614": "actual governing of a kingdom", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00107-00023615-00023942": "the queen is there but", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00108-00023943-00024150": "if i remember they're not really that", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00109-00024151-00024391": "important unless the king's not there so", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00110-00024392-00024558": "i'm guessing the mother does a lot of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00111-00024559-00024671": "the teaching", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00112-00024672-00024863": "yes but she still can't teach the girls", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00113-00024864-00025142": "together so she has to spend equal time", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00114-00025143-00025414": "with anna or anna's going to feel even", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00115-00025415-00025655": "more alone and then still their mother", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00116-00025656-00025894": "can't teach them everything", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00117-00025895-00026078": "they would still need lessons after", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00118-00026079-00026279": "their parents died", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00119-00026280-00026535": "so who picked up the training then we", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00120-00026536-00026735": "see and do you want to build a snowman", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00121-00026736-00026999": "that anna has a lot", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00122-00027000-00027255": "of free time", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00123-00027256-00027527": "she really shouldn't she's a princess", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00124-00027527-00027758": "she should be at lessons or at her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00125-00027760-00027974": "embroidery frame", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00126-00027975-00028199": "oh that's apparently thing i didn't know", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00127-00028200-00028551": "embroidery frame question mark", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00128-00028552-00028783": "yes to keep the fabric", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00129-00028783-00029039": "from bunching up while you embroider", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00130-00029039-00029190": "my works always come out better when i", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00131-00029191-00029423": "use an embroidery frame", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00132-00029424-00029687": "no i i didn't realize princesses did a", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00133-00029688-00029831": "lot of embroidery", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00134-00029832-00030199": "women tended to do a lot of needle work", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00135-00030200-00030670": "both the actual noble maidens and their", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00136-00030672-00030767": "female", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00137-00030768-00030967": "servants slash retainer", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00138-00030968-00031151": "entourage", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00139-00031152-00031239": "well", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00140-00031239-00031446": "the more you know all right question", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00141-00031447-00031743": "number four how can elsa make living", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00142-00031744-00031958": "creatures this one", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00143-00031960-00032183": "i'm not quite sure about because the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00144-00032183-00032423": "snowman she first created wasn't living", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00145-00032424-00032743": "maybe somehow her power has evolved to", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00146-00032744-00032879": "be able to", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00147-00032880-00033079": "imbued life into things because", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00148-00033080-00033279": "subconsciously she was lonely when she", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00149-00033280-00033390": "started playing around with her powers", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00150-00033391-00033487": "that's why", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00151-00033488-00033662": "when she created that snowman he became", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00152-00033663-00033887": "alive later and then when she created", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00153-00033888-00033959": "the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00154-00033960-00034087": "behemoth", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00155-00034088-00034231": "she was afraid for her life and needed a", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00156-00034232-00034639": "protector so his name's marshmallow", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00157-00034640-00034767": "what", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00158-00034768-00034990": "his name's marshmallow how do you not", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00159-00034991-00035159": "know this", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00160-00035160-00035351": "because apparently i wasn't paying", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00161-00035352-00035702": "attention to that", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00162-00035703-00035911": "okay marshmallow", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00163-00035912-00036327": "the big terrifying marshmallow", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00164-00036328-00036495": "and i'm thinking she created him because", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00165-00036496-00036759": "you know protect her she needed someone", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00166-00036760-00036983": "so subconsciously she somehow gave it", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00167-00036984-00037146": "life i'm not quite sure about the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00168-00037147-00037462": "technicalities or the um logistics of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00169-00037463-00037679": "how she did it but i'm thinking it comes", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00170-00037680-00037911": "out of a subconscious thing", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00171-00037912-00038111": "olaf loneliness", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00172-00038112-00038255": "marshmallow", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00173-00038256-00038518": "fear needing a protector", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00174-00038519-00038727": "but it's completely out of line with the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00175-00038728-00038974": "rest of her powers all of her powers", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00176-00038975-00039287": "have been ice and snow and cold", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00177-00039288-00039671": "so all of a sudden she's able to create", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00178-00039672-00039830": "living creatures because they're not", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00179-00039831-00040135": "just automatons because we see distinct", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00180-00040136-00040295": "personalities", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00181-00040296-00040430": "well maybe it has something to do with", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00182-00040431-00040687": "the fact that even though it's cold and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00183-00040688-00040927": "snow and ice like that it is water and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00184-00040928-00041071": "water is one of the elements that's", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00185-00041072-00041271": "usually associated with the with life or", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00186-00041272-00041543": "creation of life or healing all true but", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00187-00041544-00041830": "i still say it doesn't make sense", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00188-00041831-00042030": "question number five", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00189-00042031-00042318": "how does kristoff not recognize anna", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00190-00042319-00042630": "yeah so christoph witnesses the original", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00191-00042631-00042751": "healing", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00192-00042752-00043102": "of anna all those years ago then he runs", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00193-00043103-00043462": "into a girl that's the exact right age", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00194-00043463-00043823": "to be anna same hair color has the white", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00195-00043824-00044127": "streak in her hair that's so incredibly", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00196-00044128-00044487": "unusual has a sister that is an ice", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00197-00044488-00044599": "queen", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00198-00044600-00044823": "i know they play kristoff as a little", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00199-00044824-00045102": "dense but i would be drawing parallels", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00200-00045103-00045351": "there i think it boils down to his age", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00201-00045352-00045518": "actually because", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00202-00045519-00045862": "i think he's probably at most five six", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00203-00045863-00046055": "if you're really stretching 10", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00204-00046056-00046230": "and i barely remember anything from back", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00205-00046231-00046558": "when i was that young unless it like", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00206-00046559-00046758": "was a traumatic event and even then you", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00207-00046759-00046943": "would block it out but", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00208-00046944-00047223": "i don't think you know he really retains", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00209-00047224-00047327": "that much", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00210-00047328-00047471": "though the fact that he's around the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00211-00047472-00047646": "trolls might have something to do with", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00212-00047647-00047758": "it i don't know", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00213-00047759-00047846": "well", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00214-00047847-00048055": "when kristoff goes to take anna to the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00215-00048056-00048246": "rock trolls he says i know they can help", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00216-00048247-00048518": "because i've seen them do it before so", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00217-00048519-00048807": "he at least remembers the event he may", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00218-00048808-00049030": "not remember the details of them because", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00219-00049031-00049271": "memories get fuzzy and change over time", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00220-00049272-00049439": "i think this is probably one of our", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00221-00049440-00049639": "weaker questions but", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00222-00049640-00049830": "you know from our outside perspective", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00223-00049831-00050015": "it's like come on how can you not", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00224-00050016-00050158": "realize that", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00225-00050159-00050335": "you saw this you're dealing with the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00226-00050336-00050655": "same girl reasons plot", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00227-00050656-00050799": "all right and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00228-00050800-00051023": "staying with kristoff but moving on to", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00229-00051024-00051246": "question number six if kristoff lives", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00230-00051247-00051399": "with the rock trolls", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00231-00051400-00051742": "why does he need a job and speaking of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00232-00051744-00051935": "um living with the rock trolls how did", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00233-00051936-00052087": "that kind of happen was he like an", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00234-00052088-00052270": "orphan", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00235-00052271-00052511": "but moving on to the actual question um", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00236-00052512-00052711": "i'm thinking he just just because he", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00237-00052712-00052911": "needs his own spending money to be able", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00238-00052912-00053182": "to go into town and get stuff like", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00239-00053183-00053335": "veggies and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00240-00053336-00053566": "other things for him and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00241-00053567-00053726": "his reindeer because i don't think the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00242-00053727-00053903": "rock trolls can provide him with cash", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00243-00053904-00054111": "for that well i'm sure they can't but", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00244-00054112-00054335": "the rock trolls had to be able to", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00245-00054336-00054535": "provide him with all of the necessities", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00246-00054536-00054742": "in order to raise him", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00247-00054744-00055063": "so obviously they were able to provide", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00248-00055064-00055279": "food clothing and shelter up to the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00249-00055279-00055463": "point that kristoff was old enough to", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00250-00055464-00055735": "work well maybe he just likes working", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00251-00055736-00056015": "well he was trying to imitate the ice", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00252-00056016-00056263": "collectors when he was a boy and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00253-00056264-00056503": "stumbled across the rock trolls which", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00254-00056504-00056654": "makes it more", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00255-00056655-00056830": "sound like a hobby", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00256-00056832-00056999": "which then makes you wonder well why is", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00257-00057000-00057311": "he so upset about the prices when he", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00258-00057312-00057566": "goes to get his supplies if it's kind of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00259-00057567-00057854": "just a hobby and he doesn't really", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00260-00057855-00058135": "need any necessities maybe like most", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00261-00058136-00058287": "people doesn't like the fact that things", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00262-00058288-00058542": "cost more or less well i like when they", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00263-00058544-00058742": "cost less", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00264-00058744-00058966": "most people like lowered prices if", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00265-00058967-00059254": "they're the buyer i'm saying if it's not", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00266-00059255-00059511": "needful if uh who am i kidding if the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00267-00059512-00059694": "price of my hobby went up i'd be annoyed", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00268-00059695-00060094": "too", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00269-00060095-00060326": "question number seven the song", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00270-00060327-00060623": "fixer-upper did disney just advocate", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00271-00060624-00060726": "cheating", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00272-00060727-00060919": "really sounded like it", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00273-00060920-00061166": "get the fiance out of the way and then", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00274-00061167-00061471": "the whole thing's good to go", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00275-00061472-00061559": "yeah", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00276-00061560-00061894": "i mean just like okay she's engaged to", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00277-00061895-00062126": "someone even though there's no ring she", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00278-00062127-00062382": "says it so", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00279-00062383-00062694": "that they basically just went hey you're", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00280-00062695-00062999": "with another guy dump him come with ours", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00281-00063000-00063150": "what", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00282-00063151-00063319": "i mean by the end of the song there's", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00283-00063320-00063503": "like the whole thing you're getting", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00284-00063504-00063687": "married i'm like what", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00285-00063688-00063854": "what do you have the power of annulment", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00286-00063855-00063942": "i mean", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00287-00063944-00064079": "geez", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00288-00064079-00064279": "i know the whole song kind of relies on", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00289-00064279-00064535": "the fact that the audience knows", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00290-00064536-00064887": "that something's going on with those two", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00291-00064888-00065166": "and that she is not really quote unquote", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00292-00065167-00065311": "in love", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00293-00065312-00065391": "with", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00294-00065391-00065543": "hans but", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00295-00065544-00065631": "yeah", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00296-00065632-00065831": "if you take it in the context of what's", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00297-00065832-00066006": "actually going on in the world you like", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00298-00066007-00066159": "did they just", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00299-00066160-00066382": "advocate", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00300-00066383-00066487": "okay", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00301-00066488-00066759": "no and it wasn't even like oh the guy", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00302-00066760-00066975": "you're dating is bad for you you should", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00303-00066976-00067206": "be dating this guy instead which is", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00304-00067207-00067526": "plausible you know try to convince her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00305-00067527-00067750": "that she's made a bad choice which they", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00306-00067751-00067894": "don't know", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00307-00067895-00068159": "the fiance they just know one exists but", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00308-00068160-00068391": "to just go oh so she's a bit of a", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00309-00068392-00068615": "fixer-upper let's get rid of the fiance", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00310-00068616-00068982": "and we're good to go yeah that just does", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00311-00068983-00069126": "not sound right", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00312-00069127-00069303": "i mean basically", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00313-00069304-00069535": "the trolls don't know who hans is and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00314-00069536-00069703": "the audience hasn't been led to believe", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00315-00069704-00069894": "that hans is a bad guy either they've", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00316-00069895-00070015": "actually been led to believe that he's a", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00317-00070016-00070247": "really nice guy", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00318-00070248-00070575": "yeah i mean it was a whirlwind courtship", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00319-00070576-00070671": "of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00320-00070672-00070894": "anna on a left him in charge of the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00321-00070895-00070991": "kingdom", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00322-00070992-00071335": "you know he was taking very good care of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00323-00071336-00071519": "the citizens passing out blankets", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00324-00071520-00071719": "sending him to the castle you know", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00325-00071720-00071959": "making arrangements", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00326-00071960-00072294": "he was being a really responsible person", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00327-00072295-00072447": "he was like okay i'm doing all this", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00328-00072448-00072615": "stuff for the woman i love", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00329-00072616-00072791": "and this kingdom needs someone to take", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00330-00072792-00072935": "care of it right now because they have", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00331-00072936-00073159": "we have to figure out a way to stop this", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00332-00073160-00073399": "and then when he goes off to stuff like", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00333-00073400-00073582": "that i mean they even lead you to", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00334-00073583-00073926": "believe that he really cares about elsa", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00335-00073927-00074143": "in that one scene in the dungeon", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00336-00074144-00074487": "yeah so you know all along he looks like", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00337-00074488-00074638": "a pretty", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00338-00074639-00074759": "great guy", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00339-00074760-00074943": "and sometimes you can like go through a", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00340-00074944-00075126": "whirlwind courtship and actually do love", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00341-00075127-00075423": "the person so this song just kind of it", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00342-00075424-00075638": "basically it's out of context in its own", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00343-00075639-00075879": "world without even realizing it all", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00344-00075880-00076126": "right number eight isn't kristoff", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00345-00076127-00076238": "leaving", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00346-00076239-00076359": "and or", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00347-00076360-00076662": "him coming back an act of true love i", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00348-00076663-00077071": "mean he cares about anna but he left her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00349-00077072-00077255": "with her fiance", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00350-00077256-00077550": "so that she could be saved by an act of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00351-00077551-00077894": "true love and then when he goes oh wait", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00352-00077895-00078143": "i really do care about her i have to", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00353-00078144-00078311": "care about her more than her fiance i'm", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00354-00078312-00078471": "going back and i'm going to make sure", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00355-00078472-00078782": "she's okay yeah", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00356-00078783-00079119": "i'm thinking what's really going on is", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00357-00079120-00079462": "the actor truly has to be directly by", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00358-00079463-00079767": "her or something directly to her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00359-00079768-00079935": "basically something directly connected", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00360-00079936-00080182": "to her not it for him it's an act of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00361-00080183-00080423": "true love but not for her it only", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00362-00080424-00080567": "becomes an act of true love lair when", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00363-00080568-00080815": "she kind of realizes oh", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00364-00080816-00080943": "she only becomes an act i should say", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00365-00080944-00081150": "it's an act of love later it's not an", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00366-00081151-00081319": "act of true love because she's semi", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00367-00081320-00081591": "doing it for herself at that point when", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00368-00081592-00081791": "she realizes oh i love", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00369-00081792-00082119": "him i need to go and find him to get", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00370-00082120-00082303": "myself that's kind of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00371-00082304-00082567": "semi greedy so it's not an act of true", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00372-00082568-00082894": "love it's an act of love and desperation", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00373-00082895-00083062": "she thinks about it first then does it", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00374-00083063-00083255": "so i think that's what's going on here", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00375-00083256-00083431": "and that's why her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00376-00083432-00083679": "protecting her sister instinctively is", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00377-00083680-00083887": "an act of true love because it's without", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00378-00083888-00084167": "question i'm not arguing the act of true", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00379-00084168-00084382": "love that actually took place", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00380-00084383-00084703": "i'm just going hmm these are other you", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00381-00084704-00084911": "know brave and heroic acts of putting", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00382-00084912-00085111": "someone else ahead of yourself she has", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00383-00085112-00085303": "to be more directly affected by it for", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00384-00085304-00085494": "it to be an act that will do something", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00385-00085495-00085815": "for her and by her choosing to do that", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00386-00085816-00085982": "stuff but instinctively going after her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00387-00085983-00086215": "sister is the actual you know thing that", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00388-00086216-00086423": "triggers the cure well she had time to", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00389-00086424-00086638": "make that choice too", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00390-00086639-00086806": "you know she was running towards", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00391-00086807-00087135": "kristoff to save herself and then she", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00392-00087136-00087335": "saw that hans was going to harm her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00393-00087336-00087503": "sister and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00394-00087504-00087767": "you know went back i mean that was still", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00395-00087768-00088079": "a choice she also had the choice of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00396-00088080-00088294": "trying to reach kristoff in time and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00397-00088295-00088494": "then once she had all her strength back", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00398-00088495-00088711": "going and strangling hans her going for", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00399-00088712-00088999": "kristoff is a choice for herself her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00400-00089000-00089206": "going for her sister is a choice for her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00401-00089207-00089423": "sister that's the big difference has to", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00402-00089424-00089591": "be a choice not of yourself but for", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00403-00089592-00089767": "someone else", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00404-00089768-00090135": "question 9 why is hans such a bad actor", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00405-00090136-00090343": "after anna dies", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00406-00090344-00090647": "up until the point where anna and hans", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00407-00090648-00090999": "are alone together and hans is going", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00408-00091000-00091303": "too bad nobody loves you and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00409-00091304-00091511": "you know dumps water over the fire and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00410-00091512-00091679": "leaves her there to die", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00411-00091680-00091887": "we've mostly thought he's a pretty great", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00412-00091888-00092038": "guy", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00413-00092039-00092279": "which means he's a really good actor", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00414-00092280-00092518": "and then after he succeeds suddenly he's", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00415-00092519-00092703": "like i'm hamming this up", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00416-00092704-00093023": "oh she's dead oh", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00417-00093024-00093318": "oh she died i really had time to say her", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00418-00093319-00093671": "vows", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00419-00093672-00093982": "as my first act as king i must order the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00420-00093983-00094247": "execution of queen elsa for the murder", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00421-00094248-00094455": "of princess anna", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00422-00094456-00094879": "might as well just go mwahaha", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00423-00094880-00094991": "because it's like it's something went", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00424-00094992-00095071": "from", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00425-00095072-00095318": "really good to why are you hamming it up", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00426-00095319-00095574": "you're acting like you're acting", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00427-00095575-00095718": "i think what happened is up to that", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00428-00095719-00096023": "point even the actor playing hans", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00429-00096024-00096182": "thought he was a good guy and then he", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00430-00096183-00096318": "got to that point the scripture went i'm", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00431-00096319-00096438": "a bad guy", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00432-00096439-00096623": "okay", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00433-00096624-00096943": "so the actor started over acting to act", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00434-00096944-00097247": "like he's acting", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00435-00097248-00097559": "which kind of made that point go okay", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00436-00097560-00097782": "why doesn't anyone's niece feel this is", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00437-00097783-00098094": "suspicious he's acting odd even for", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00438-00098095-00098367": "someone you know with grief", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00439-00098368-00098671": "well they are partially blinded by their", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00440-00098672-00098838": "own grief because", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00441-00098839-00099238": "one princess is dead and their queen", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00442-00099239-00099518": "apparently is responsible but seriously", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00443-00099519-00099735": "who believes unwitness wedding vows", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00444-00099736-00099903": "you're just going to let this guy from", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00445-00099904-00100167": "some kingdom you know the youngest of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00446-00100168-00100423": "what is it 12 brothers inherit your", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00447-00100424-00100647": "whole kingdom i think it was well i", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00448-00100648-00100823": "think you're right it is 12. that's at", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00449-00100824-00100967": "some points i thought it was 13 but oh", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00450-00100968-00101062": "well", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00451-00101063-00101294": "but yeah suspicious", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00452-00101295-00101526": "and even if you believe", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00453-00101527-00101855": "hans and are stricken with grief your", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00454-00101856-00102159": "princess is dead in the other room is", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00455-00102160-00102382": "nobody gonna go lay her body out in", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00456-00102383-00102671": "state either in her own room or i don't", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00457-00102672-00102951": "know in the chapel you know rigor mortis", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00458-00102952-00103215": "and everything and respect for the dead", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00459-00103216-00103551": "and hello that's your princess huh", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00460-00103552-00103775": "i don't know i'm thinking no one would", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00461-00103776-00104039": "do it that quickly so hans has time to", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00462-00104040-00104215": "take care of stuff and i don't think", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00463-00104216-00104351": "anyone like i said would take care of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00464-00104352-00104551": "the body that quickly yeah but if they", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00465-00104552-00104782": "go to take care of the body later anna's", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00466-00104783-00104999": "not there because she left with olaf", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00467-00105000-00105263": "well no one knows that at this point so", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00468-00105264-00105551": "all right so question number 10", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00469-00105552-00105854": "why does everyone clap when anna punches", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00470-00105855-00106183": "hans yeah because at this point", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00471-00106183-00106486": "no one has seen how bad hans is no one", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00472-00106488-00106710": "realizes that hans is a bad guy other", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00473-00106711-00106990": "than the sisters and kristoff and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00474-00106991-00107175": "there's a blizzard going on so no one", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00475-00107176-00107327": "from that vantage point at the end of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00476-00107328-00107607": "the movie could see that he almost tried", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00477-00107608-00107758": "to kill her and even at that point they", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00478-00107759-00107927": "could have justified that he was killing", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00479-00107928-00108207": "her to stop the blizzard or you know the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00480-00108208-00108358": "sister because maybe they wouldn't have", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00481-00108359-00108575": "been able to see the sister but still by", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00482-00108576-00108758": "the point that they're on the ship no", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00483-00108759-00109063": "one knows that hans is a bad guy so why", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00484-00109064-00109231": "are they still clapping seeing one of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00485-00109232-00109454": "the princesses punch him yeah because i", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00486-00109455-00109590": "mean even if you've taken the fact that", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00487-00109591-00109902": "they suddenly go wait our princess is", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00488-00109903-00110263": "alive and our queen is with her yay", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00489-00110264-00110534": "you still don't know that hans is a jerk", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00490-00110535-00110854": "and an evil villain so you still don't", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00491-00110855-00111175": "have any reason for them to applaud anna", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00492-00111176-00111390": "punching him other than the fact that", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00493-00111391-00111590": "they're grateful their princess is alive", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00494-00111591-00111807": "the only thing i can really think of", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00495-00111808-00111927": "myself", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00496-00111928-00112047": "is", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00497-00112048-00112223": "maybe they think she's punching him", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00498-00112224-00112478": "because he left her thinking she was", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00499-00112479-00112647": "dead or something", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00500-00112648-00112815": "because really", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00501-00112816-00112958": "but i'm thinking it's mostly for the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00502-00112959-00113151": "audiences because audiences always like", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00503-00113152-00113366": "to see people in the show clap first and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00504-00113367-00113502": "then they react to it you know that's", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00505-00113503-00113631": "the reasons we have things like laugh", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00506-00113632-00113807": "tracks and clapping stuff like that and", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00507-00113808-00114095": "sitcoms but at least in those situations", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00508-00114096-00114254": "you know it's something that the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00509-00114255-00114486": "characters in what you're watching", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00510-00114488-00114678": "aren't hearing you know unless you're", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00511-00114679-00114919": "doing a fourth wall breaking episode the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00512-00114920-00115166": "characters never hear the laugh track", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00513-00115167-00115415": "this has been our 10 questions on the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00514-00115416-00115647": "movie frozen do you have any of your own", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00515-00115648-00115871": "do you have answers to our own questions", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00516-00115872-00116039": "please leave them in the comments please", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00517-00116040-00116295": "be nice we really do love the movie if", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00518-00116296-00116447": "you like my art please visit me at", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00519-00116448-00116663": "deviantart and tumblr if you want more", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00520-00116664-00116902": "information on what lux and i are up to", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00521-00116903-00117110": "you can follow us on tumblr", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00522-00117111-00117343": "really like lux's art and would maybe", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00523-00117344-00117510": "like some of your own he's currently", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00524-00117511-00117710": "accepting commissions links in the", "HCuXNeIWAt0-00525-00117711-00117983": "description"}}, {"audio_id": "HCBPwoiKMro", "text": {"HCBPwoiKMro-00000-00000343-00000503": "hello viewers", "HCBPwoiKMro-00001-00000504-00000862": "you see me back again and this time with", "HCBPwoiKMro-00002-00000863-00001254": "a new co-author that we have mr vishal", "HCBPwoiKMro-00003-00001255-00001423": "bulani", "HCBPwoiKMro-00004-00001424-00001655": "and he is from ahmedabad", "HCBPwoiKMro-00005-00001655-00001879": "he is a tedx speaker", "HCBPwoiKMro-00006-00001880-00002087": "he's a lot more", "HCBPwoiKMro-00007-00002088-00002295": "um and um", "HCBPwoiKMro-00008-00002296-00002399": "yes", "HCBPwoiKMro-00009-00002400-00002607": "he is also", "HCBPwoiKMro-00010-00002608-00002726": "someone", "HCBPwoiKMro-00011-00002727-00002975": "who is going to give wings to your", "HCBPwoiKMro-00012-00002976-00003110": "mindset", "HCBPwoiKMro-00013-00003111-00003295": "with his chapter", "HCBPwoiKMro-00014-00003296-00003647": "let's get into a nice conversation", "HCBPwoiKMro-00015-00003647-00003959": "with vishal and talk about what his", "HCBPwoiKMro-00016-00003960-00004183": "chapter has to offer us", "HCBPwoiKMro-00017-00004184-00004375": "what should we look", "HCBPwoiKMro-00018-00004376-00004606": "to you know forward to you know reading", "HCBPwoiKMro-00019-00004607-00004767": "in his chapter", "HCBPwoiKMro-00020-00004768-00004975": "and what is the most interesting thing", "HCBPwoiKMro-00021-00004976-00005111": "about", "HCBPwoiKMro-00022-00005112-00005215": "his", "HCBPwoiKMro-00023-00005216-00005447": "topic and chapter", "HCBPwoiKMro-00024-00005448-00005683": "so vishal welcome to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00025-00005684-00005934": "insights thank you very much", "HCBPwoiKMro-00026-00005935-00006111": "and i'm happy that you're part of this", "HCBPwoiKMro-00027-00006112-00006406": "series wherein we talk about caterpillar", "HCBPwoiKMro-00028-00006408-00006583": "to butterfly", "HCBPwoiKMro-00029-00006584-00006742": "each co-author", "HCBPwoiKMro-00030-00006743-00006846": "is", "HCBPwoiKMro-00031-00006847-00007070": "welcome on this uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00032-00007072-00007303": "platform is invited and you have", "HCBPwoiKMro-00033-00007304-00007591": "graciously accepted my invite", "HCBPwoiKMro-00034-00007592-00007870": "and uh i'm very excited to hear about", "HCBPwoiKMro-00035-00007872-00007991": "your chapter", "HCBPwoiKMro-00036-00007992-00008278": "it's a pleasure to be here thank you", "HCBPwoiKMro-00037-00008279-00008463": "such as having you", "HCBPwoiKMro-00038-00008464-00008935": "uh so vishal first thing first", "HCBPwoiKMro-00039-00008936-00009206": "was becoming an author", "HCBPwoiKMro-00040-00009207-00009455": "a dream come true or it just happened", "HCBPwoiKMro-00041-00009456-00010031": "because you were with us", "HCBPwoiKMro-00042-00010032-00010423": "okay so if i have to put it um", "HCBPwoiKMro-00043-00010424-00010614": "i would say", "HCBPwoiKMro-00044-00010615-00010791": "growing up it was", "HCBPwoiKMro-00045-00010792-00010974": "even reading a book was a challenge with", "HCBPwoiKMro-00046-00010975-00011151": "me okay", "HCBPwoiKMro-00047-00011152-00011351": "i would hardly read even a textbook in a", "HCBPwoiKMro-00048-00011352-00011551": "school or a college right", "HCBPwoiKMro-00049-00011552-00011767": "but over the years of course", "HCBPwoiKMro-00050-00011768-00012006": "if i have to put it in real terms for", "HCBPwoiKMro-00051-00012007-00012231": "the last two three years i really wanted", "HCBPwoiKMro-00052-00012232-00012438": "to become an author", "HCBPwoiKMro-00053-00012439-00012631": "and the entire", "HCBPwoiKMro-00054-00012632-00012910": "agenda behind becoming an author was", "HCBPwoiKMro-00055-00012911-00013111": "never making money out of it and i still", "HCBPwoiKMro-00056-00013112-00013255": "don't know how much money an author", "HCBPwoiKMro-00057-00013256-00013343": "makes", "HCBPwoiKMro-00058-00013344-00013471": "but", "HCBPwoiKMro-00059-00013472-00013729": "unless you are you know a bumper officer", "HCBPwoiKMro-00060-00013730-00013951": "[Music]", "HCBPwoiKMro-00061-00013952-00014263": "right so uh the under agenda behind", "HCBPwoiKMro-00062-00014263-00014455": "becoming an author was", "HCBPwoiKMro-00063-00014456-00014630": "today whatever i am whatever i have", "HCBPwoiKMro-00064-00014631-00014822": "learned", "HCBPwoiKMro-00065-00014823-00015086": "it has been given to me by", "HCBPwoiKMro-00066-00015087-00015327": "other people in terms of mentoring me in", "HCBPwoiKMro-00067-00015328-00015550": "terms of the books that i read and i", "HCBPwoiKMro-00068-00015551-00015735": "think this was the one of the ways of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00069-00015736-00016015": "giving it back to the society whatever", "HCBPwoiKMro-00070-00016016-00016247": "and the other reason behind becoming an", "HCBPwoiKMro-00071-00016247-00016375": "author was that", "HCBPwoiKMro-00072-00016376-00016591": "you know you can still continue to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00073-00016592-00016855": "teach people even after you're not there", "HCBPwoiKMro-00074-00016856-00017030": "so long after that you're gone you can", "HCBPwoiKMro-00075-00017031-00017199": "still continue to add value to people's", "HCBPwoiKMro-00076-00017200-00017422": "time so so you know that was your agenda", "HCBPwoiKMro-00077-00017423-00017583": "why i wanted to become an author in the", "HCBPwoiKMro-00078-00017584-00017719": "first place", "HCBPwoiKMro-00079-00017720-00018030": "you leave a legacy behind absolutely", "HCBPwoiKMro-00080-00018031-00018283": "just beyond your life", "HCBPwoiKMro-00081-00018284-00018567": "lifetime ah just imagine you know", "HCBPwoiKMro-00082-00018568-00018847": "your great grand", "HCBPwoiKMro-00083-00018848-00019158": "daughter a son or a child yeah", "HCBPwoiKMro-00084-00019159-00019447": "they're holding your book in their hands", "HCBPwoiKMro-00085-00019448-00019630": "right how proud would that be", "HCBPwoiKMro-00086-00019631-00019943": "so yeah that's the reason being you know", "HCBPwoiKMro-00087-00019944-00020383": "i already have goosebumps", "HCBPwoiKMro-00088-00020384-00020663": "yes i keep telling my uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00089-00020664-00020903": "children and i also tell my clients this", "HCBPwoiKMro-00090-00020904-00021103": "because i have this author success", "HCBPwoiKMro-00091-00021104-00021263": "program as well", "HCBPwoiKMro-00092-00021264-00021494": "wonderful yeah so i have people becoming", "HCBPwoiKMro-00093-00021495-00021735": "authors and this is exactly what i tell", "HCBPwoiKMro-00094-00021736-00021999": "them and that program is known as time", "HCBPwoiKMro-00095-00022000-00022207": "to be the legacy", "HCBPwoiKMro-00096-00022208-00022519": "that's the last bit of my uh you know", "HCBPwoiKMro-00097-00022520-00022671": "the chain of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00098-00022672-00022886": "programs that i have to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00099-00022887-00023255": "um empower someone with their english", "HCBPwoiKMro-00100-00023256-00023414": "yeah so somebody who's challenged with", "HCBPwoiKMro-00101-00023415-00023694": "their english ends up becoming an author", "HCBPwoiKMro-00102-00023695-00023883": "sounds good", "HCBPwoiKMro-00103-00023884-00024055": "absolutely", "HCBPwoiKMro-00104-00024056-00024135": "yeah", "HCBPwoiKMro-00105-00024136-00024391": "yeah coming back to you uh leaving me", "HCBPwoiKMro-00106-00024392-00024503": "aside", "HCBPwoiKMro-00107-00024504-00024647": "um", "HCBPwoiKMro-00108-00024648-00025030": "how was your entry into this uh group", "HCBPwoiKMro-00109-00025031-00025294": "where all these authors were thinking of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00110-00025295-00025439": "writing", "HCBPwoiKMro-00111-00025440-00025702": "you know you are part of an anthology", "HCBPwoiKMro-00112-00025704-00025983": "how are you a part of it", "HCBPwoiKMro-00113-00025983-00026206": "i think for me the journey was really", "HCBPwoiKMro-00114-00026207-00026470": "smooth uh for a couple of reasons of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00115-00026472-00026711": "course in the first place", "HCBPwoiKMro-00116-00026712-00026902": "all the authors you know is coming up", "HCBPwoiKMro-00117-00026904-00027167": "with so much experience behind your back", "HCBPwoiKMro-00118-00027168-00027407": "that made my life a little easier", "HCBPwoiKMro-00119-00027408-00027679": "because uh i only have to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00120-00027680-00027895": "have to follow you guys in the way of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00121-00027895-00028111": "the chapters so it was easier and also i", "HCBPwoiKMro-00122-00028112-00028302": "think you know before becoming a part of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00123-00028304-00028535": "this i also wrote an ebook which made it", "HCBPwoiKMro-00124-00028536-00028839": "a little more easier for me to you know", "HCBPwoiKMro-00125-00028839-00029062": "give my thoughts on this book as well", "HCBPwoiKMro-00126-00029063-00029262": "how easy it is is it to put your", "HCBPwoiKMro-00127-00029263-00029367": "thoughts", "HCBPwoiKMro-00128-00029368-00029511": "into words", "HCBPwoiKMro-00129-00029512-00029711": "for others to read", "HCBPwoiKMro-00130-00029712-00029943": "what's your take on it", "HCBPwoiKMro-00131-00029944-00030151": "very very honestly", "HCBPwoiKMro-00132-00030152-00030318": "to begin with i thought it would be very", "HCBPwoiKMro-00133-00030319-00030407": "easy", "HCBPwoiKMro-00134-00030408-00030623": "it would be very easy because", "HCBPwoiKMro-00135-00030624-00030862": "you know being a touch speaker being a", "HCBPwoiKMro-00136-00030863-00031151": "keynote speaker i thought it is easy you", "HCBPwoiKMro-00137-00031152-00031262": "know", "HCBPwoiKMro-00138-00031263-00031470": "to put out things but then i realized", "HCBPwoiKMro-00139-00031472-00031543": "that", "HCBPwoiKMro-00140-00031544-00031831": "speaking is far different than writing", "HCBPwoiKMro-00141-00031832-00032014": "because when you're speaking your body", "HCBPwoiKMro-00142-00032016-00032255": "is also speaking right you have facial", "HCBPwoiKMro-00143-00032256-00032383": "expressions you have gestures and", "HCBPwoiKMro-00144-00032383-00032646": "posters right while writing i mean it's", "HCBPwoiKMro-00145-00032647-00032879": "only writing there's nothing else", "HCBPwoiKMro-00146-00032880-00033071": "right through writing you have to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00147-00033072-00033215": "express everything that you want to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00148-00033216-00033423": "express so", "HCBPwoiKMro-00149-00033424-00033646": "as i said i thought it would be easy but", "HCBPwoiKMro-00150-00033647-00033846": "it wasn't it wasn't this was only one", "HCBPwoiKMro-00151-00033847-00034007": "chapter", "HCBPwoiKMro-00152-00034008-00034215": "yeah of course but as i said", "HCBPwoiKMro-00153-00034216-00034487": "i wrote an ebook then i became a part of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00154-00034488-00034718": "this uh book where i had to just give", "HCBPwoiKMro-00155-00034719-00034927": "one chapter and now that i'm writing a", "HCBPwoiKMro-00156-00034928-00035095": "full book it is helping me writing an", "HCBPwoiKMro-00157-00035096-00035239": "entire book as well", "HCBPwoiKMro-00158-00035240-00035415": "yes yes yes", "HCBPwoiKMro-00159-00035416-00035662": "so we'll come back to your book uh after", "HCBPwoiKMro-00160-00035663-00035895": "we've spoken about your chapter here", "HCBPwoiKMro-00161-00035896-00036127": "what is the name of the chapter which is", "HCBPwoiKMro-00162-00036128-00036318": "written in the book caterpillar to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00163-00036319-00036599": "butterfly 14 ways to give ways to your", "HCBPwoiKMro-00164-00036600-00036743": "mindset", "HCBPwoiKMro-00165-00036744-00036902": "which mindset are you", "HCBPwoiKMro-00166-00036903-00037127": "touching which mindset are you touching", "HCBPwoiKMro-00167-00037128-00037327": "and what's the name of the chapter", "HCBPwoiKMro-00168-00037328-00037559": "the chapter is called uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00169-00037560-00037911": "and i found gratitude", "HCBPwoiKMro-00170-00037912-00038135": "yeah so you know it's touching that part", "HCBPwoiKMro-00171-00038136-00038374": "of your mindset of being grateful for", "HCBPwoiKMro-00172-00038375-00038559": "the things that you have", "HCBPwoiKMro-00173-00038560-00038879": "wow wow and i found gratitude", "HCBPwoiKMro-00174-00038880-00039127": "how lovely is this", "HCBPwoiKMro-00175-00039128-00039327": "and why did you think of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00176-00039328-00039551": "this topic", "HCBPwoiKMro-00177-00039552-00039887": "for you know as your contribution", "HCBPwoiKMro-00178-00039888-00040046": "so uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00179-00040047-00040287": "you know everything i'm sure that we all", "HCBPwoiKMro-00180-00040288-00040479": "have written in the book comes from our", "HCBPwoiKMro-00181-00040480-00040607": "own experience", "HCBPwoiKMro-00182-00040608-00040718": "and", "HCBPwoiKMro-00183-00040719-00040990": "about five seven years back i did not", "HCBPwoiKMro-00184-00040991-00041143": "realize small things happening in my", "HCBPwoiKMro-00185-00041144-00041327": "life for it for very small example if i", "HCBPwoiKMro-00186-00041328-00041502": "have to share with you i was never", "HCBPwoiKMro-00187-00041503-00041743": "grateful for the bad that i sleep on", "HCBPwoiKMro-00188-00041744-00041974": "or the mattress for that matter which", "HCBPwoiKMro-00189-00041975-00042167": "gave me comfort the entire night right", "HCBPwoiKMro-00190-00042168-00042327": "you're never", "HCBPwoiKMro-00191-00042328-00042495": "grateful for such small things now for", "HCBPwoiKMro-00192-00042496-00042735": "our parents for that matter i mean", "HCBPwoiKMro-00193-00042736-00043039": "fully taken for granted", "HCBPwoiKMro-00194-00043040-00043207": "i'm sure", "HCBPwoiKMro-00195-00043208-00043383": "for that matter every relationship that", "HCBPwoiKMro-00196-00043384-00043551": "we have you know over a period of time", "HCBPwoiKMro-00197-00043552-00043743": "we start taking it for granted yeah", "HCBPwoiKMro-00198-00043744-00043871": "unfortunately", "HCBPwoiKMro-00199-00043872-00044023": "and uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00200-00044024-00044158": "and when i learned that what you", "HCBPwoiKMro-00201-00044159-00044399": "appreciate appreciates right", "HCBPwoiKMro-00202-00044400-00044655": "and i i realized that how important it", "HCBPwoiKMro-00203-00044656-00044855": "is to be grateful for everything that", "HCBPwoiKMro-00204-00044856-00045167": "you actually have and uh very honestly i", "HCBPwoiKMro-00205-00045168-00045311": "read it somewhere it says that you know", "HCBPwoiKMro-00206-00045312-00045535": "if you have a good house to go back to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00207-00045536-00045815": "if you have a stable business or a job", "HCBPwoiKMro-00208-00045816-00045951": "if you have a bank account if you have a", "HCBPwoiKMro-00209-00045952-00046279": "mobile phone and a family to go back to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00210-00046280-00046511": "you are probably in the top two percent", "HCBPwoiKMro-00211-00046512-00046702": "of the human population", "HCBPwoiKMro-00212-00046703-00046807": "really", "HCBPwoiKMro-00213-00046808-00047111": "just i am in the two top two percent not", "HCBPwoiKMro-00214-00047112-00047367": "in the top two percent wow", "HCBPwoiKMro-00215-00047368-00047574": "yeah so just imagine and we never", "HCBPwoiKMro-00216-00047575-00048230": "realized this we never", "HCBPwoiKMro-00217-00048231-00048455": "but at the same time everything that we", "HCBPwoiKMro-00218-00048456-00048679": "have today you know at some point in", "HCBPwoiKMro-00219-00048680-00049083": "time in past we decided that we had that", "HCBPwoiKMro-00220-00049084-00049295": "yeah of are always looking forward and", "HCBPwoiKMro-00221-00049296-00049855": "not looking back and kind of just", "HCBPwoiKMro-00222-00049856-00050046": "a very simple example if i have to give", "HCBPwoiKMro-00223-00050047-00050430": "you you know we often uh hear people on", "HCBPwoiKMro-00224-00050431-00050655": "a zoom meeting for that matter say that", "HCBPwoiKMro-00225-00050656-00050862": "my internet is shitty today or it is", "HCBPwoiKMro-00226-00050863-00051086": "giving me problems today right but that", "HCBPwoiKMro-00227-00051087-00051246": "happens like once in a fortnight or", "HCBPwoiKMro-00228-00051247-00051390": "maybe once in a month that your internet", "HCBPwoiKMro-00229-00051391-00051599": "is not stable i haven't ever heard", "HCBPwoiKMro-00230-00051600-00051742": "anyone saying that my internet is not", "HCBPwoiKMro-00231-00051744-00052679": "working wonderful today", "HCBPwoiKMro-00232-00052679-00052919": "it's like you know having a plain sheet", "HCBPwoiKMro-00233-00052920-00053191": "and uh if you put in a dot with a pencil", "HCBPwoiKMro-00234-00053191-00053542": "all you see is a dot the entire sheet", "HCBPwoiKMro-00235-00053544-00053671": "white sheet", "HCBPwoiKMro-00236-00053672-00053942": "uh goes unnoticed it's just taken for", "HCBPwoiKMro-00237-00053944-00054142": "granted you only see the black dot there", "HCBPwoiKMro-00238-00054144-00054279": "yeah", "HCBPwoiKMro-00239-00054279-00054375": "oh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00240-00054376-00054542": "i have to thank my internet every year", "HCBPwoiKMro-00241-00054544-00054750": "now", "HCBPwoiKMro-00242-00054751-00054838": "because", "HCBPwoiKMro-00243-00054839-00055119": "what you appreciate appreciates", "HCBPwoiKMro-00244-00055120-00055407": "that thank the money which rolls in wow", "HCBPwoiKMro-00245-00055408-00055687": "i am already full of gratitude talking", "HCBPwoiKMro-00246-00055688-00055871": "to you vishal", "HCBPwoiKMro-00247-00055872-00056135": "but just imagine uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00248-00056136-00056342": "you know we met", "HCBPwoiKMro-00249-00056344-00056559": "because somebody invented zoom for that", "HCBPwoiKMro-00250-00056560-00056694": "matter we have never", "HCBPwoiKMro-00251-00056695-00056935": "met physically to each other right yeah", "HCBPwoiKMro-00252-00056936-00057103": "i mean we should be grateful for someone", "HCBPwoiKMro-00253-00057104-00057294": "invented this today we are part of our", "HCBPwoiKMro-00254-00057295-00057463": "community", "HCBPwoiKMro-00255-00057464-00057726": "because of zoom per se", "HCBPwoiKMro-00256-00057727-00057894": "right so you know we should be grateful", "HCBPwoiKMro-00257-00057895-00058230": "for such small things happening", "HCBPwoiKMro-00258-00058232-00058479": "your life might be so beautiful huh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00259-00058479-00058735": "expressing so much gratitude", "HCBPwoiKMro-00260-00058736-00058966": "wow actually able to do it it's it's not", "HCBPwoiKMro-00261-00058967-00059182": "a very difficult thing to do but it's", "HCBPwoiKMro-00262-00059183-00059366": "not a priority", "HCBPwoiKMro-00263-00059367-00059550": "absolutely for most of us so", "HCBPwoiKMro-00264-00059551-00059750": "okay so and since you mentioned about it", "HCBPwoiKMro-00265-00059751-00059991": "i'll tell you uh that in the chapter the", "HCBPwoiKMro-00266-00059991-00060279": "last bit it talks about a small exercise", "HCBPwoiKMro-00267-00060279-00060438": "which takes about four minutes", "HCBPwoiKMro-00268-00060439-00060623": "and not more and where you know which", "HCBPwoiKMro-00269-00060624-00060782": "teaches you about how to be grateful for", "HCBPwoiKMro-00270-00060783-00061006": "things and it just takes four minutes i", "HCBPwoiKMro-00271-00061007-00061230": "mean imagine four minutes and 24 hours i", "HCBPwoiKMro-00272-00061232-00061526": "mean it's just that simple but again as", "HCBPwoiKMro-00273-00061527-00061687": "you said it should become a priority it", "HCBPwoiKMro-00274-00061688-00061926": "should come in as", "HCBPwoiKMro-00275-00061927-00062119": "as a disciplinary action that we should", "HCBPwoiKMro-00276-00062120-00062438": "you know do it every single day", "HCBPwoiKMro-00277-00062439-00062742": "i remember in school you know vishal uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00278-00062744-00062854": "in school", "HCBPwoiKMro-00279-00062855-00063038": "our friends usually used to be thank you", "HCBPwoiKMro-00280-00063039-00063279": "for the bread we had thank you for the", "HCBPwoiKMro-00281-00063279-00063519": "thank you for that thank you and", "HCBPwoiKMro-00282-00063520-00063719": "it was just rattling", "HCBPwoiKMro-00283-00063720-00063911": "we used to just rattle it off because we", "HCBPwoiKMro-00284-00063912-00064047": "wanted to go home", "HCBPwoiKMro-00285-00064048-00064350": "or just go for the break", "HCBPwoiKMro-00286-00064351-00064591": "but all of this was you know innately", "HCBPwoiKMro-00287-00064591-00064815": "ingrained into us", "HCBPwoiKMro-00288-00064816-00065087": "which we just need to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00289-00065088-00065279": "touch it again that's it", "HCBPwoiKMro-00290-00065279-00065454": "yeah so since you mentioned about it i", "HCBPwoiKMro-00291-00065455-00065663": "would say you know when even while", "HCBPwoiKMro-00292-00065664-00065823": "eating food we should actually be", "HCBPwoiKMro-00293-00065824-00066031": "grateful for the entire supply chain", "HCBPwoiKMro-00294-00066032-00066215": "right from the farmers", "HCBPwoiKMro-00295-00066216-00066431": "to the entire supply chain to the person", "HCBPwoiKMro-00296-00066432-00066606": "cooking the food for you", "HCBPwoiKMro-00297-00066607-00066743": "right", "HCBPwoiKMro-00298-00066744-00066863": "you know if you actually look at the", "HCBPwoiKMro-00299-00066864-00067055": "entire process it's a very very lengthy", "HCBPwoiKMro-00300-00067056-00067431": "process right us it comes very easily", "HCBPwoiKMro-00301-00067432-00067526": "and", "HCBPwoiKMro-00302-00067527-00067687": "you know the moment we start being", "HCBPwoiKMro-00303-00067688-00067887": "grateful for it i think i'm sure", "HCBPwoiKMro-00304-00067888-00068294": "uh as i said before it appreciates", "HCBPwoiKMro-00305-00068295-00068391": "yes", "HCBPwoiKMro-00306-00068392-00068894": "i cannot imagine doing a farmer's job", "HCBPwoiKMro-00307-00068895-00069159": "yeah i can imagine cooking", "HCBPwoiKMro-00308-00069160-00069375": "uh but", "HCBPwoiKMro-00309-00069376-00069743": "not a farmer's job at all", "HCBPwoiKMro-00310-00069744-00069838": "yeah", "HCBPwoiKMro-00311-00069839-00069999": "ah", "HCBPwoiKMro-00312-00070000-00070294": "god you have already transformed me", "HCBPwoiKMro-00313-00070295-00070567": "i wonder what your chapter is going to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00314-00070568-00070847": "do for our viewers and our leaders", "HCBPwoiKMro-00315-00070848-00071143": "uh and all of us because at the end of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00316-00071144-00071391": "it all of us have contributed to be a", "HCBPwoiKMro-00317-00071392-00071494": "part of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00318-00071495-00071679": "this wonderful wonderful book which is", "HCBPwoiKMro-00319-00071680-00071862": "going to hit the stands very very soon", "HCBPwoiKMro-00320-00071863-00072103": "on 29th of april", "HCBPwoiKMro-00321-00072104-00072182": "um", "HCBPwoiKMro-00322-00072183-00072487": "but we are also going to be readers", "HCBPwoiKMro-00323-00072488-00072575": "and we", "HCBPwoiKMro-00324-00072576-00072671": "there is", "HCBPwoiKMro-00325-00072672-00072919": "you know there's no way that 14 of us", "HCBPwoiKMro-00326-00072920-00073319": "are not going to touch the book", "HCBPwoiKMro-00327-00073320-00073662": "and the moment we touch the book", "HCBPwoiKMro-00328-00073663-00073871": "our chapter is something which we", "HCBPwoiKMro-00329-00073872-00074159": "will just go and see okay where is it", "HCBPwoiKMro-00330-00074160-00074303": "and the next thing we are going to do is", "HCBPwoiKMro-00331-00074304-00074487": "read others chapters because you know", "HCBPwoiKMro-00332-00074488-00074735": "your own chapters so well", "HCBPwoiKMro-00333-00074736-00074991": "and um also for a fact that we know who", "HCBPwoiKMro-00334-00074992-00075287": "other 13 authors are and we also know", "HCBPwoiKMro-00335-00075288-00075455": "that they can bring to the table", "HCBPwoiKMro-00336-00075456-00075775": "yeah so i'm sure plus you're", "HCBPwoiKMro-00337-00075776-00075959": "yeah plus you're getting all the teasers", "HCBPwoiKMro-00338-00075960-00076167": "in the inside series that", "HCBPwoiKMro-00339-00076168-00076487": "um that's happening right now", "HCBPwoiKMro-00340-00076488-00076606": "so", "HCBPwoiKMro-00341-00076607-00076838": "yeah lovely love would you want to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00342-00076839-00077231": "read a part of your chapter or tell us i", "HCBPwoiKMro-00343-00077232-00077431": "did mention about the exercise though", "HCBPwoiKMro-00344-00077432-00077767": "but would you want to read a piece of uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00345-00077768-00077887": "so uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00346-00077888-00078071": "i would i would rather put it in a", "HCBPwoiKMro-00347-00078072-00078223": "different way uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00348-00078224-00078519": "my favorite part of the chapter is", "HCBPwoiKMro-00349-00078520-00078655": "when", "HCBPwoiKMro-00350-00078656-00078991": "i'm talking about that law of vibration", "HCBPwoiKMro-00351-00078992-00079206": "comes before the law of attraction", "HCBPwoiKMro-00352-00079207-00079455": "and i'm sure most of us know not even", "HCBPwoiKMro-00353-00079456-00079567": "know about it", "HCBPwoiKMro-00354-00079568-00079782": "right we have heard so much about law of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00355-00079783-00079943": "attraction and visualization of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00356-00079944-00080231": "formations and this and that right but", "HCBPwoiKMro-00357-00080232-00080319": "uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00358-00080320-00080471": "it is a research which says that law of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00359-00080472-00080719": "a branch uh law of vibration comes", "HCBPwoiKMro-00360-00080720-00080950": "before the law of attraction which means", "HCBPwoiKMro-00361-00080951-00081206": "good wives and bad wives i'm not getting", "HCBPwoiKMro-00362-00081207-00081511": "good vibes from your eye", "HCBPwoiKMro-00363-00081512-00081806": "correct now now having said this how do", "HCBPwoiKMro-00364-00081807-00082031": "you how do you raise your vibration", "HCBPwoiKMro-00365-00082032-00082135": "right", "HCBPwoiKMro-00366-00082136-00082343": "it is very simple", "HCBPwoiKMro-00367-00082344-00082662": "you cannot be grateful and sad at the", "HCBPwoiKMro-00368-00082663-00082894": "same time can you be can you be can you", "HCBPwoiKMro-00369-00082895-00083055": "say that oh i'm grateful for my parents", "HCBPwoiKMro-00370-00083056-00083271": "and be sad at the same time", "HCBPwoiKMro-00371-00083272-00083399": "you cannot", "HCBPwoiKMro-00372-00083400-00083631": "at the same time you cannot about", "HCBPwoiKMro-00373-00083632-00084294": "things and be happy at the same time", "HCBPwoiKMro-00374-00084295-00084526": "so the moment you are grateful for", "HCBPwoiKMro-00375-00084527-00084606": "things", "HCBPwoiKMro-00376-00084607-00084687": "your", "HCBPwoiKMro-00377-00084688-00084911": "frequency increases", "HCBPwoiKMro-00378-00084912-00085150": "right and the moment your frequency", "HCBPwoiKMro-00379-00085151-00085350": "increases as i say like attracts like", "HCBPwoiKMro-00380-00085351-00085487": "right the moment your frequency", "HCBPwoiKMro-00381-00085488-00085671": "increases you start attracting more of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00382-00085672-00085871": "that", "HCBPwoiKMro-00383-00085872-00086038": "right so so", "HCBPwoiKMro-00384-00086039-00086199": "when you're grateful for things you get", "HCBPwoiKMro-00385-00086200-00086455": "more chances to be grateful for things", "HCBPwoiKMro-00386-00086456-00086599": "and it is that simple", "HCBPwoiKMro-00387-00086600-00086726": "ah", "HCBPwoiKMro-00388-00086727-00086959": "right but", "HCBPwoiKMro-00389-00086960-00087215": "i'm glad i'm happy that at least people", "HCBPwoiKMro-00390-00087216-00087415": "know about law of attraction and they", "HCBPwoiKMro-00391-00087416-00087543": "practice that and they become more", "HCBPwoiKMro-00392-00087544-00087726": "successful and more prosperous and", "HCBPwoiKMro-00393-00087727-00087918": "better relationships but at the same", "HCBPwoiKMro-00394-00087919-00088159": "time i think it is law of vibration", "HCBPwoiKMro-00395-00088160-00088350": "which we need to practice more than the", "HCBPwoiKMro-00396-00088351-00088582": "law of attraction because understand you", "HCBPwoiKMro-00397-00088583-00088679": "know when you're talking about", "HCBPwoiKMro-00398-00088680-00088806": "visualization and talking about", "HCBPwoiKMro-00399-00088807-00088975": "affirmations these are the things that", "HCBPwoiKMro-00400-00088976-00089159": "you want in your life", "HCBPwoiKMro-00401-00089160-00089318": "you know i might", "HCBPwoiKMro-00402-00089319-00089494": "so i wanted to become a best-selling", "HCBPwoiKMro-00403-00089495-00089647": "author and hence it was on the vision", "HCBPwoiKMro-00404-00089648-00089743": "board", "HCBPwoiKMro-00405-00089744-00089982": "right but now before i go there and", "HCBPwoiKMro-00406-00089983-00090167": "fetch that i should be grateful for the", "HCBPwoiKMro-00407-00090168-00090367": "things that i already have", "HCBPwoiKMro-00408-00090368-00090535": "right the moment i'm grateful for things", "HCBPwoiKMro-00409-00090536-00090791": "that i have i started", "HCBPwoiKMro-00410-00090792-00091079": "so so that's that's my favorite part", "HCBPwoiKMro-00411-00091080-00091303": "in that chapter you know because i think", "HCBPwoiKMro-00412-00091304-00091438": "more and more people should know about", "HCBPwoiKMro-00413-00091439-00091687": "it and start practicing that in order to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00414-00091688-00091815": "you know achieve everything that they", "HCBPwoiKMro-00415-00091816-00092071": "want i had no idea about law of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00416-00092072-00092279": "vibration i had heard about law of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00417-00092280-00092423": "attraction", "HCBPwoiKMro-00418-00092424-00092703": "thanks to youtube and um", "HCBPwoiKMro-00419-00092704-00093023": "so much and receive the avenues", "HCBPwoiKMro-00420-00093024-00093215": "yeah i had no idea about law of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00421-00093216-00093455": "vibration but i do know about good", "HCBPwoiKMro-00422-00093456-00093623": "rights and bad vibes and", "HCBPwoiKMro-00423-00093624-00093823": "feel comfortable in somebody's presence", "HCBPwoiKMro-00424-00093824-00094159": "or yes the moment you enter a", "HCBPwoiKMro-00425-00094160-00094382": "temple at times", "HCBPwoiKMro-00426-00094383-00094631": "a particular temple you feel really good", "HCBPwoiKMro-00427-00094632-00094879": "you can get into meditation in a second", "HCBPwoiKMro-00428-00094880-00094974": "there", "HCBPwoiKMro-00429-00094975-00095103": "immediately", "HCBPwoiKMro-00430-00095104-00095343": "and at times you can try", "HCBPwoiKMro-00431-00095344-00095662": "as hard as you can and just not get into", "HCBPwoiKMro-00432-00095663-00095855": "the meditative state", "HCBPwoiKMro-00433-00095856-00096023": "i i guess that has got", "HCBPwoiKMro-00434-00096024-00096255": "a lot to do with their vibrations", "HCBPwoiKMro-00435-00096256-00096479": "absolutely absolutely and honestly or", "HCBPwoiKMro-00436-00096480-00096687": "what you rightly mentioned uh this is", "HCBPwoiKMro-00437-00096688-00096847": "what the chapter also talks about so", "HCBPwoiKMro-00438-00096848-00097038": "actually the top the chapter is about a", "HCBPwoiKMro-00439-00097039-00097391": "story of two friends you know wherein uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00440-00097392-00097615": "they have grown up together but because", "HCBPwoiKMro-00441-00097616-00097847": "of the work and that they want to become", "HCBPwoiKMro-00442-00097848-00097935": "rich", "HCBPwoiKMro-00443-00097936-00098199": "you know about the age of 20 25 they", "HCBPwoiKMro-00444-00098200-00098374": "pass their ways and one of them goes to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00445-00098375-00098462": "us", "HCBPwoiKMro-00446-00098463-00098703": "gets a job in a best i.t company the", "HCBPwoiKMro-00447-00098704-00098879": "other one stays back in india are you", "HCBPwoiKMro-00448-00098880-00099279": "giving out the entire chapter here", "HCBPwoiKMro-00449-00099280-00099623": "but when i'm just creating your city", "HCBPwoiKMro-00450-00099624-00099950": "i was very fascinated about it and uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00451-00099951-00100247": "so i started planning for it way way", "HCBPwoiKMro-00452-00100248-00100574": "before even i i knew about this book and", "HCBPwoiKMro-00453-00100575-00100791": "and i knew all the 13 authors that i", "HCBPwoiKMro-00454-00100792-00100879": "have", "HCBPwoiKMro-00455-00100880-00101167": "so uh yeah i think the best of the", "HCBPwoiKMro-00456-00101168-00101374": "lessons that i learned in the history", "HCBPwoiKMro-00457-00101375-00101494": "also are", "HCBPwoiKMro-00458-00101495-00102343": "in the in the way of conversation", "HCBPwoiKMro-00459-00102344-00102542": "it is a conversation between two people", "HCBPwoiKMro-00460-00102543-00102718": "and hence you know keeping that in mind", "HCBPwoiKMro-00461-00102719-00102854": "the entire chapter has been written in", "HCBPwoiKMro-00462-00102855-00103030": "the form of a convertation", "HCBPwoiKMro-00463-00103031-00103151": "please go ahead", "HCBPwoiKMro-00464-00103152-00103327": "yeah yeah", "HCBPwoiKMro-00465-00103328-00103542": "and you know come to think of praise", "HCBPwoiKMro-00466-00103543-00103766": "vishal you wanted to be", "HCBPwoiKMro-00467-00103767-00103966": "an author a best-selling author he was", "HCBPwoiKMro-00468-00103967-00104206": "going to launch this book in january", "HCBPwoiKMro-00469-00104207-00104382": "come pandemic", "HCBPwoiKMro-00470-00104383-00104702": "and this got deferred and you stepped in", "HCBPwoiKMro-00471-00104703-00104782": "yeah", "HCBPwoiKMro-00472-00104783-00104990": "as one of the co-authors now see all", "HCBPwoiKMro-00473-00104991-00105263": "these pieces are falling into place", "HCBPwoiKMro-00474-00105264-00105334": "with", "HCBPwoiKMro-00475-00105335-00105527": "your chapter as well you had to be a", "HCBPwoiKMro-00476-00105528-00105654": "part of it", "HCBPwoiKMro-00477-00105655-00105895": "i never knew about this before so thank", "HCBPwoiKMro-00478-00105896-00106039": "you for telling me that you know this", "HCBPwoiKMro-00479-00106040-00106254": "happened because i attracted this in my", "HCBPwoiKMro-00480-00106255-00106343": "life", "HCBPwoiKMro-00481-00106344-00106454": "yeah", "HCBPwoiKMro-00482-00106455-00106647": "you attracted this you made us there for", "HCBPwoiKMro-00483-00106648-00107239": "our launch", "HCBPwoiKMro-00484-00107240-00107486": "okay so i forgot that i was an", "HCBPwoiKMro-00485-00107488-00107623": "interviewer i was", "HCBPwoiKMro-00486-00107624-00107839": "you know rapidly listening to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00487-00107840-00108039": "what you were saying", "HCBPwoiKMro-00488-00108040-00108134": "um", "HCBPwoiKMro-00489-00108135-00108431": "and uh we have talked about your journey", "HCBPwoiKMro-00490-00108432-00108519": "um", "HCBPwoiKMro-00491-00108520-00108743": "what did you what do you think are your", "HCBPwoiKMro-00492-00108744-00109039": "plans are you going uh for the lunch", "HCBPwoiKMro-00493-00109040-00109207": "oh yes uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00494-00109208-00109454": "i am going to launch this as you said it", "HCBPwoiKMro-00495-00109455-00109647": "is on 29th of april", "HCBPwoiKMro-00496-00109648-00109886": "this year we're going to meet", "HCBPwoiKMro-00497-00109888-00110027": "we need for the first time", "HCBPwoiKMro-00498-00110028-00110183": "[Laughter]", "HCBPwoiKMro-00499-00110183-00110366": "i'm going to meet so many people for the", "HCBPwoiKMro-00500-00110367-00110623": "first time this is going to be my first", "HCBPwoiKMro-00501-00110624-00110847": "book launch i'm super excited", "HCBPwoiKMro-00502-00110848-00111015": "uh for a couple of reasons as i said", "HCBPwoiKMro-00503-00111016-00111223": "before i was never even into reading and", "HCBPwoiKMro-00504-00111224-00111375": "today writing a book and launching", "HCBPwoiKMro-00505-00111376-00111583": "publishing and now uh launching a book", "HCBPwoiKMro-00506-00111583-00111775": "which is a dream come true", "HCBPwoiKMro-00507-00111776-00111943": "that's super exciting", "HCBPwoiKMro-00508-00111944-00112175": "it's kind of a block in the mind because", "HCBPwoiKMro-00509-00112176-00112327": "in um", "HCBPwoiKMro-00510-00112328-00112502": "two years back if somebody would have", "HCBPwoiKMro-00511-00112503-00112686": "told me in december", "HCBPwoiKMro-00512-00112688-00112934": "uh that's up now you're going to be an", "HCBPwoiKMro-00513-00112935-00113207": "author next year i would be like you are", "HCBPwoiKMro-00514-00113208-00113423": "totally totally out of my mind this is", "HCBPwoiKMro-00515-00113424-00113807": "not even in my uh farthest orbit because", "HCBPwoiKMro-00516-00113808-00113966": "i don't think i'm cut out for something", "HCBPwoiKMro-00517-00113967-00114078": "like this", "HCBPwoiKMro-00518-00114079-00114199": "and see", "HCBPwoiKMro-00519-00114200-00114495": "where i am so in my case uh it's not law", "HCBPwoiKMro-00520-00114496-00114654": "of attraction", "HCBPwoiKMro-00521-00114655-00114895": "i think it just it just fell into my lap", "HCBPwoiKMro-00522-00114896-00115119": "probably was somewhere there behind but", "HCBPwoiKMro-00523-00115120-00115510": "i didn't think it was ever possible", "HCBPwoiKMro-00524-00115511-00115823": "so um it's just happened and", "HCBPwoiKMro-00525-00115824-00115927": "one book", "HCBPwoiKMro-00526-00115928-00116127": "already launched second", "HCBPwoiKMro-00527-00116128-00116375": "as an anthology third in my head ready", "HCBPwoiKMro-00528-00116376-00116623": "to be launched in india and i'm going to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00529-00116624-00116854": "announce that in uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00530-00116855-00117095": "so wow okay yeah yeah i'm going to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00531-00117096-00117278": "announce the next one there", "HCBPwoiKMro-00532-00117279-00117519": "so we're very very pleased with how my", "HCBPwoiKMro-00533-00117520-00117871": "life is going but i certainly um", "HCBPwoiKMro-00534-00117872-00118095": "i think i wished for all of this", "HCBPwoiKMro-00535-00118096-00118215": "absolutely i did", "HCBPwoiKMro-00536-00118216-00118551": "some somewhere deep down it was there", "HCBPwoiKMro-00537-00118552-00118663": "uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00538-00118664-00118839": "i mean i i really don't want to talk", "HCBPwoiKMro-00539-00118840-00119031": "about myself much but i just can't help", "HCBPwoiKMro-00540-00119032-00119310": "doing that uh i", "HCBPwoiKMro-00541-00119311-00119558": "i you know it's like a mother's journey", "HCBPwoiKMro-00542-00119559-00119839": "so i was professionally", "HCBPwoiKMro-00543-00119840-00120031": "into a career and you know study", "HCBPwoiKMro-00544-00120032-00120166": "professionally", "HCBPwoiKMro-00545-00120167-00120390": "working and then of course you know how", "HCBPwoiKMro-00546-00120391-00120639": "a woman's life changes", "HCBPwoiKMro-00547-00120640-00120775": "okay if you've got married it's all", "HCBPwoiKMro-00548-00120776-00120975": "right but the moment you have one kid", "HCBPwoiKMro-00549-00120976-00121102": "second kid", "HCBPwoiKMro-00550-00121103-00121471": "your career takes a big big back", "HCBPwoiKMro-00551-00121472-00121775": "yeah huge back step so i think i took", "HCBPwoiKMro-00552-00121776-00122031": "her he had his", "HCBPwoiKMro-00553-00122032-00122278": "willingly happily and", "HCBPwoiKMro-00554-00122279-00122543": "but at the back of my mind i knew years", "HCBPwoiKMro-00555-00122544-00122758": "were going and i was kind of getting", "HCBPwoiKMro-00556-00122759-00122943": "stale i thought", "HCBPwoiKMro-00557-00122944-00123047": "you know", "HCBPwoiKMro-00558-00123048-00123247": "who would want me i would be competing", "HCBPwoiKMro-00559-00123248-00123551": "with freshers and people with", "HCBPwoiKMro-00560-00123552-00123814": "you know latest knowledge and all of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00561-00123815-00124047": "that so i never thought i would be able", "HCBPwoiKMro-00562-00124048-00124151": "to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00563-00124152-00124310": "compete with them", "HCBPwoiKMro-00564-00124311-00124566": "into this you know professional world", "HCBPwoiKMro-00565-00124567-00124695": "but i", "HCBPwoiKMro-00566-00124696-00124975": "really wanted uh you know a good", "HCBPwoiKMro-00567-00124976-00125207": "career of mine and um", "HCBPwoiKMro-00568-00125208-00125439": "yes after this long hiatus after i", "HCBPwoiKMro-00569-00125440-00125686": "finished all of that i had to do", "HCBPwoiKMro-00570-00125688-00125943": "uh with my kids and all i", "HCBPwoiKMro-00571-00125944-00126166": "i am my priority", "HCBPwoiKMro-00572-00126167-00126502": "absolutely my job so i think again", "HCBPwoiKMro-00573-00126503-00126814": "this is something which i really wanted", "HCBPwoiKMro-00574-00126815-00127063": "yeah yeah yeah um", "HCBPwoiKMro-00575-00127064-00127166": "so uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00576-00127167-00127423": "so so wonderful talking to you vishal i", "HCBPwoiKMro-00577-00127424-00127966": "mean i", "HCBPwoiKMro-00578-00127967-00128366": "um yeah tell me um tell our viewers what", "HCBPwoiKMro-00579-00128367-00128647": "coach are you", "HCBPwoiKMro-00580-00128648-00128886": "okay so uh in the first place i'm an", "HCBPwoiKMro-00581-00128888-00129183": "entrepreneur and uh", "HCBPwoiKMro-00582-00129183-00129334": "working on an education technology", "HCBPwoiKMro-00583-00129335-00129510": "startup", "HCBPwoiKMro-00584-00129511-00129671": "which will have the best of coaches from", "HCBPwoiKMro-00585-00129672-00129902": "across the globe and training on people", "HCBPwoiKMro-00586-00129903-00129990": "on", "HCBPwoiKMro-00587-00129991-00130247": "things like mindfulness meditations", "HCBPwoiKMro-00588-00130248-00130502": "parenting storytelling", "HCBPwoiKMro-00589-00130503-00130647": "right so we say you know things that you", "HCBPwoiKMro-00590-00130648-00130831": "cannot delegate we help you master those", "HCBPwoiKMro-00591-00130832-00131078": "kids right so for example your your", "HCBPwoiKMro-00592-00131079-00131319": "marketing your hr your production your", "HCBPwoiKMro-00593-00131320-00131519": "uh accounts you can", "HCBPwoiKMro-00594-00131520-00131663": "outsource or you can delegate to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00595-00131664-00131863": "somebody else your parenting you cannot", "HCBPwoiKMro-00596-00131864-00132102": "delegate your public speaking and story", "HCBPwoiKMro-00597-00132103-00132383": "telling you cannot ask someone else", "HCBPwoiKMro-00598-00132384-00132583": "and meditation right so everything that", "HCBPwoiKMro-00599-00132584-00132751": "you cannot delegate we help you master", "HCBPwoiKMro-00600-00132752-00132911": "those skills", "HCBPwoiKMro-00601-00132912-00133014": "and", "HCBPwoiKMro-00602-00133015-00133159": "since i have been practicing", "HCBPwoiKMro-00603-00133160-00133343": "manifestation since over six seven years", "HCBPwoiKMro-00604-00133344-00133447": "and the kind of results that i've", "HCBPwoiKMro-00605-00133448-00133719": "received from myself i approach people", "HCBPwoiKMro-00606-00133720-00133943": "from interesting things also", "HCBPwoiKMro-00607-00133944-00134151": "right are you a manifestation coach what", "HCBPwoiKMro-00608-00134152-00134375": "do you call yourself yeah so i'm a", "HCBPwoiKMro-00609-00134376-00134511": "manifestation", "HCBPwoiKMro-00610-00134512-00134839": "ah okay he actually led me on to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00611-00134840-00135151": "say so", "HCBPwoiKMro-00612-00135152-00135431": "so wonderful connecting with you on this", "HCBPwoiKMro-00613-00135432-00135678": "i am so happy that caterpillar butterfly", "HCBPwoiKMro-00614-00135679-00135783": "happened", "HCBPwoiKMro-00615-00135784-00136111": "and we get to talk on this level uh with", "HCBPwoiKMro-00616-00136112-00136223": "each other", "HCBPwoiKMro-00617-00136224-00136502": "and uh discover each other's niche you", "HCBPwoiKMro-00618-00136503-00136623": "know", "HCBPwoiKMro-00619-00136624-00136959": "so and then and we we can now not only", "HCBPwoiKMro-00620-00136960-00137166": "learn from each other but we can learn", "HCBPwoiKMro-00621-00137167-00137511": "from each other's niche speciality", "HCBPwoiKMro-00622-00137512-00137695": "their", "HCBPwoiKMro-00623-00137696-00137814": "deported", "HCBPwoiKMro-00624-00137815-00138119": "you know we can benefit from them and", "HCBPwoiKMro-00625-00138120-00138351": "i'm sure our readers are going to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00626-00138352-00138623": "benefit as well a lot", "HCBPwoiKMro-00627-00138624-00138727": "i'm sure", "HCBPwoiKMro-00628-00138728-00138983": "i'm sure i'm sure i mean it is going to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00629-00138984-00139295": "it is a wonderful compilation of", "HCBPwoiKMro-00630-00139296-00139439": "international", "HCBPwoiKMro-00631-00139440-00139671": "uh you know people coaches coming", "HCBPwoiKMro-00632-00139672-00139871": "together with their 40 and with their", "HCBPwoiKMro-00633-00139872-00140159": "expertise and look at all that he has to", "HCBPwoiKMro-00634-00140160-00140407": "share in this series it is an insight", "HCBPwoiKMro-00635-00140408-00140654": "for me", "HCBPwoiKMro-00636-00140655-00140766": "as well", "HCBPwoiKMro-00637-00140767-00141063": "so thank you vishal for taking out time", "HCBPwoiKMro-00638-00141064-00141143": "and", "HCBPwoiKMro-00639-00141144-00141383": "talking to me and sharing your thoughts", "HCBPwoiKMro-00640-00141384-00141654": "about your journey about your book", "HCBPwoiKMro-00641-00141655-00141863": "and i'm going to see you very very soon", "HCBPwoiKMro-00642-00141864-00142159": "in less than a fortnight inside", "HCBPwoiKMro-00643-00142160-00142478": "thank you so much for having me", "HCBPwoiKMro-00644-00142479-00142726": "good luck with the rest of the episodes", "HCBPwoiKMro-00645-00142727-00142999": "thank you so much bye have a great great", "HCBPwoiKMro-00646-00143000-00143332": "great day"}}, {"audio_id": "HCPuZr-UTPy", "text": {"HCPuZr-UTPy-00000-00000017-00000272": "the Golden Age of Islam saw a", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00001-00000273-00000607": "flourishing of Islamic science notably", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00002-00000608-00000844": "mathematics in astronomy especially", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00003-00000846-00001560": "during the 9th and 10th centuries", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00004-00001561-00002095": "topic history", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00005-00002096-00002341": "for the best part of a millennium from", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00006-00002342-00002506": "the Seleucid era and through to the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00007-00002507-00002680": "Sassanid period there had been an", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00008-00002681-00002854": "exchange of scholarship between the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00009-00002855-00003040": "Greek Persian and Indian cultural", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00010-00003041-00003325": "spheres the origin of the number zero", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00011-00003326-00003559": "and the place value system notably falls", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00012-00003560-00003676": "into this period", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00013-00003677-00003871": "it's early use originates in Indian", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00014-00003872-00004075": "mathematics of the fifth century la", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00015-00004076-00004288": "curva Varga influencing sassanid era", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00016-00004289-00004465": "Persian scholars during the sixth", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00017-00004466-00004686": "century the sudden Islamic conquest of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00018-00004687-00004893": "Persia in the six 40s drove a wedge", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00019-00004894-00005086": "between the Mediterranean and Indian", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00020-00005087-00005308": "traditions but scholarly transfer soon", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00021-00005309-00005521": "resumed with translations of both Greek", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00022-00005522-00005731": "and Sanskrit works into Arabic during", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00023-00005732-00005971": "the eighth century this triggered the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00024-00005972-00006163": "flourishing of Abbasid era scholarship", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00025-00006164-00006352": "centered in Baghdad in the 9th century", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00026-00006353-00006534": "and the eventual resumption of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00027-00006536-00006733": "transmission to the West via Muslim", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00028-00006734-00006916": "Spain and Sicily by the 10th century", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00029-00006917-00007120": "there was continuing contact between", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00030-00007120-00007333": "Indian and perso-arabic scholarship", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00031-00007334-00007555": "during the 9th to 11th centuries while", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00032-00007556-00007726": "the Muslim conquest of India was", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00033-00007727-00008052": "temporarily halted al-biruni in the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00034-00008053-00008271": "early 11th century traveled widely in", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00035-00008272-00008476": "India and became an important source of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00036-00008477-00008664": "knowledge about India in the Islamic", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00037-00008665-00008824": "world during that time with the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00038-00008825-00009031": "establishment of the Delhi Sultanate in", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00039-00009032-00009256": "the 13th century northern India fell", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00040-00009257-00009445": "under perso-arabic dominance and the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00041-00009446-00009616": "native Indian tradition fell into", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00042-00009617-00009823": "decline while it and about the same time", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00043-00009824-00010146": "the Golden Age of Islam of the Arab", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00044-00010147-00010363": "caliphates gave way to Turco Mongol", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00045-00010364-00010560": "dominance leading to the flourishing of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00046-00010561-00010935": "a secondary Golden Age of Turco Persian", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00047-00010936-00011155": "literary tradition during the 13th to", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00048-00011156-00011401": "16th centuries exemplified on either", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00049-00011402-00011623": "side of Timur at Persia by the Ottoman", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00050-00011624-00011821": "Empire in the West and the Mughal Empire", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00051-00011822-00012421": "in the east", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00052-00012422-00013108": "topic astronomy the mathematical", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00053-00013109-00013304": "astronomy text Brahma Siddhanta of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00054-00013305-00013766": "brahmagupta 598 - 668 was received in", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00055-00013766-00014336": "the court of Almanza 753 - 774 it was", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00056-00014337-00014588": "translated by alpha sari into Arabic as", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00057-00014588-00014908": "azz elicina al-arab popularly called sin", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00058-00014909-00015224": "hind this translation was the means by", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00059-00015225-00015368": "which the Hindu numerals were", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00060-00015369-00015550": "transmitted from the Sanskrit to the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00061-00015551-00015847": "Arabic tradition according to al-biruni", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00062-00015848-00016157": "as Sindh was under the actual rule of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00063-00016158-00016652": "the Khalif Mansur ad 753 - 774 there", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00064-00016653-00016838": "came embassies from that part of India", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00065-00016839-00017042": "to Baghdad and among M scholars who", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00066-00017043-00017222": "brought with him two books with the help", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00067-00017223-00017453": "of these Pandits alphas re perhaps also", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00068-00017454-00017786": "Jakob eben Tariq translated them both", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00069-00017787-00017993": "works have been largely used and have", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00070-00017994-00018311": "exercised a great influence it was on", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00071-00018312-00018478": "this occasion that the Arabs first", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00072-00018479-00018674": "became acquainted with a scientific", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00073-00018675-00018934": "system of astronomy they learned from", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00074-00018935-00019197": "Brahma Gupta earlier than Ptolemy", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00075-00019198-00019442": "al-biruni 's translator and editor", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00076-00019443-00019730": "edward Sekou wrote it is Brahma Gupta", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00077-00019731-00019972": "who taught Arabs mathematics before they", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00078-00019973-00020428": "got acquainted with Greek science alphas", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00079-00020429-00020672": "re also translated the can decayed yucca", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00080-00020673-00020875": "Eric and of brahmagupta through the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00081-00020876-00021083": "resulting Arabic translations of sin", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00082-00021084-00021284": "tined and eric and the use of Indian", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00083-00021285-00021467": "numerals became established in the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00084-00021468-00022076": "Islamic world", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00085-00022077-00022657": "topic mathematics", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00086-00022658-00023023": "the etymology of the word sign comes", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00087-00023024-00023209": "from the Latin mistranslation of the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00088-00023210-00023370": "word giba which is an Arabic", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00089-00023371-00023599": "transliteration of the sanskrit word for", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00090-00023600-00023677": "half the chord", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00091-00023678-00024061": "jya ardha the sin and cos functions of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00092-00024062-00024298": "trigonometry were important mathematical", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00093-00024299-00024493": "concepts imported from the Gupta period", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00094-00024494-00024724": "of Indian astronomy namely the gyre and", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00095-00024725-00024991": "koti gyre functions via translation of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00096-00024992-00025222": "texts like the I of Atia Surya Siddhanta", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00097-00025223-00025465": "from Sanskrit to Arabic and then from", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00098-00025466-00025672": "Arabic to Latin to Europe much of the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00099-00025673-00025852": "Hindu approach to mathematics was", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00100-00025852-00026022": "certainly conveyed to Western Europe", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00101-00026023-00026295": "through Arabs the algebraic method", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00102-00026297-00026461": "formerly considered to have been", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00103-00026462-00026683": "invented by alcoa regime II can now be", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00104-00026683-00026911": "seen to stem from Hindu sources in the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00105-00026912-00027100": "rest of mathematical science or in", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00106-00027101-00027316": "trigonometry where the Arabs pupils of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00107-00027317-00027493": "the Hindus and still more of the Greeks", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00108-00027494-00027712": "but not without important devices of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00109-00027713-00028069": "their own for over 500 years Arabic", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00110-00028070-00028264": "writers and others continued to apply to", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00111-00028264-00028530": "works on arithmetic the name Indian", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00112-00028531-00028777": "another important early treatise that", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00113-00028777-00029017": "publicized decimal numbers was iranian", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00114-00029018-00029208": "mathematician and astronomer cushier", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00115-00029210-00029479": "eben Laban's kitab feiyu sul hissa Bell", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00116-00029480-00029701": "hind principles of Hindu reckoning a", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00117-00029702-00030079": "leading arithmetic book Abu Hassan luq", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00118-00030080-00030262": "Ledisi a scholar in the Abbasid", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00119-00030263-00030529": "Caliphate wrote al fusil file his Sibel", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00120-00030530-00030910": "hindi chapters in indian calculation to", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00121-00030911-00031123": "address the difficulty in procedures for", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00122-00031124-00031291": "calculation from the Euclid's elements", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00123-00031292-00031492": "and endorsed the use of Indian", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00124-00031493-00031777": "calculation he highlighted its ease of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00125-00031777-00032047": "use speed fewer requirements of memory", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00126-00032048-00032767": "and the focused scope on the subject", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00127-00032768-00033365": "topic medical texts", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00128-00033366-00033623": "monka an indian physician at the court", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00129-00033624-00033815": "of harun al-rashid is said to have", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00130-00033816-00034034": "translated the Sushruta the classical", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00131-00034035-00034304": "gupta era Sanskrit text on medicine into", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00132-00034305-00034640": "Persian al-razi xel-há we lie per", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00133-00034641-00034943": "countenance of see 900 is said to", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00134-00034944-00035303": "contain much Indian knowledge from texts", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00135-00035304-00035960": "such as the susruta samhita", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00136-00035961-00036511": "topic philosophy", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00137-00036512-00036757": "the Hindu philosophical notions of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00138-00036758-00037003": "reincarnation and cyclic time and karma", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00139-00037004-00037152": "are an integral part of the Islamic", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00140-00037153-00037378": "metaphysical system and were part of ish", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00141-00037379-00037714": "Maile doctrines from an early stage the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00142-00037715-00037915": "metaphysics mentioned is implied to be", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00143-00037916-00038121": "the essence of the sanatana-dharma of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00144-00038122-00038715": "Hinduism", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00145-00038716-00039249": "topic religion", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00146-00039250-00039483": "in sin the idea of the Redeemer was", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00147-00039484-00039702": "closely connected to the incarnations of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00148-00039703-00039942": "Vishnu the - avatar is considered one of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00149-00039943-00040640": "the canons of modern ismaelis", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00150-00040641-00041201": "topic geography", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00151-00041202-00041432": "the indian geographical knowledge that", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00152-00041433-00041639": "was transmitted and influenced the arabs", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00153-00041640-00041840": "included the view of aya varta that the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00154-00041841-00042035": "apparent daily rotation of the heavens", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00155-00042036-00042210": "was caused by the rotation of the earth", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00156-00042211-00042428": "on its own axis the idea that the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00157-00042429-00042581": "proportion of land and sea on the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00158-00042582-00042758": "surface of the earth was half-and-half", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00159-00042759-00042977": "and the land masses being dome shaped", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00160-00042978-00043310": "and covered on all sides by water the", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00161-00043311-00043541": "arabs utilized the indian cartographic", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00162-00043542-00043688": "system in which the northern hemisphere", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00163-00043689-00043913": "was considered to be the inhabited part", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00164-00043914-00044105": "of the earth and divided into nine parts", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00165-00044106-00044339": "it's four geographical limits were jama", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00166-00044340-00044582": "cut in the east ram in the west salon is", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00167-00044583-00044918": "the cupola dome and sid / Indians", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00168-00044919-00045116": "believed that the Prime Meridian passes", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00169-00045117-00045293": "through Ujjain and calculated their", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00170-00045294-00045539": "longitudes from salón the Arabs adopted", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00171-00045540-00045758": "this idea of Salons being the cupola of", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00172-00045759-00045956": "the earth but later mistakenly believed", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00173-00045957-00046624": "Ujjain to be the cupola", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00174-00046625-00047171": "topic C also", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00175-00047172-00047546": "Indian Science and Technology Indian", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00176-00047547-00047993": "mathematics Hindu astronomy back Sharlee", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00177-00047994-00048343": "manuscript back Sharlee approximation", "HCPuZr-UTPy-00178-00048344-00048668": "bomber kids"}}, {"audio_id": "HD2b63jQKQg", "text": {"HD2b63jQKQg-00000-00000048-00000428": "Puri Puri PIR our epi are re often", "HD2b63jQKQg-00001-00000429-00000634": "hyphenated or as one word and with", "HD2b63jQKQg-00002-00000635-00000850": "variant spellings Perry Perry or pilly", "HD2b63jQKQg-00003-00000851-00001082": "pilly also called Birds Eye chili is a", "HD2b63jQKQg-00004-00001083-00001336": "cultivar of capsicum frutescens a chili", "HD2b63jQKQg-00005-00001337-00001540": "pepper that grows both wild and as a", "HD2b63jQKQg-00006-00001541-00001748": "crop it is a small member of the genus", "HD2b63jQKQg-00007-00001748-00002023": "capsicum the cultivar was developed from", "HD2b63jQKQg-00008-00002025-00002231": "the Malaga de pepper originally from the", "HD2b63jQKQg-00009-00002232-00002450": "Caribbean in southeastern Africa and was", "HD2b63jQKQg-00010-00002451-00002627": "spread by the Portuguese to their Indian", "HD2b63jQKQg-00011-00002628-00003317": "territories of Gujarat in Goa", "HD2b63jQKQg-00012-00003318-00003850": "topic etymology", "HD2b63jQKQg-00013-00003851-00004129": "Perry Perry is Swahili for pepper pepper", "HD2b63jQKQg-00014-00004130-00004342": "or strong peppered the reduplication of", "HD2b63jQKQg-00015-00004343-00004570": "the word as an intensifier other", "HD2b63jQKQg-00016-00004571-00004813": "romanization z' include pili pili in the", "HD2b63jQKQg-00017-00004814-00005022": "Democratic Republic of the Congo or", "HD2b63jQKQg-00018-00005023-00005239": "Perry Perry in Malawi deriving from the", "HD2b63jQKQg-00019-00005240-00005436": "various pronunciations of the word in", "HD2b63jQKQg-00020-00005437-00005659": "different parts of Bantu speaking Africa", "HD2b63jQKQg-00021-00005660-00005950": "Perry Perry is also the spelling used as", "HD2b63jQKQg-00022-00005951-00006106": "a loanword in the Portuguese language", "HD2b63jQKQg-00023-00006107-00006331": "especially in the Portuguese speaking", "HD2b63jQKQg-00024-00006332-00006604": "Mozambican community the piri piri", "HD2b63jQKQg-00025-00006605-00006826": "spelling is common in English eg in", "HD2b63jQKQg-00026-00006827-00007045": "reference to African style chili sauces", "HD2b63jQKQg-00027-00007045-00007296": "the Oxford Dictionary of English records", "HD2b63jQKQg-00028-00007297-00007509": "piri piri as a foreign word meaning a", "HD2b63jQKQg-00029-00007511-00007752": "very hot sauce made with red chili", "HD2b63jQKQg-00030-00007753-00008044": "peppers and gives its ultimate origin as", "HD2b63jQKQg-00031-00008045-00008329": "the word for pepper presumably in the", "HD2b63jQKQg-00032-00008330-00008521": "native African sense in the wrong the", "HD2b63jQKQg-00033-00008522-00009178": "language of southern Mozambique", "HD2b63jQKQg-00034-00009179-00009767": "topic plant characteristics", "HD2b63jQKQg-00035-00009768-00010031": "plants are usually very bushy and grow", "HD2b63jQKQg-00036-00010032-00010403": "in height 245 to 120 centimeters 18 to", "HD2b63jQKQg-00037-00010404-00010799": "47 in with leaves 4 to 7 centimeters 1.6", "HD2b63jQKQg-00038-00010800-00011174": "to 2.8 in long and 1.3 to 1.5", "HD2b63jQKQg-00039-00011175-00011663": "centimeters 0.512 0.59 and wide the", "HD2b63jQKQg-00040-00011664-00011855": "fruits are generally tapered to a blunt", "HD2b63jQKQg-00041-00011856-00012026": "point and measure up to two to three", "HD2b63jQKQg-00042-00012027-00012425": "centimeters 0.8 to one in long immature", "HD2b63jQKQg-00043-00012426-00012638": "pod color is green mature color is", "HD2b63jQKQg-00044-00012639-00012896": "bright red or purple some bird's eye", "HD2b63jQKQg-00045-00012897-00013199": "chili varieties measure up to 175", "HD2b63jQKQg-00046-00013200-00013869": "thousand Scoville heat units", "HD2b63jQKQg-00047-00013870-00014405": "topic cultivation", "HD2b63jQKQg-00048-00014406-00014672": "like all Chili Peppers Puri Puri is", "HD2b63jQKQg-00049-00014673-00014870": "descended from plants from the Americas", "HD2b63jQKQg-00050-00014871-00015036": "but it has grown in the wild in Africa", "HD2b63jQKQg-00051-00015037-00015258": "for centuries and is now cultivated", "HD2b63jQKQg-00052-00015259-00015488": "commercially in Zambia Uganda Malawi", "HD2b63jQKQg-00053-00015488-00015836": "Zimbabwe and Rwanda it grows mainly in", "HD2b63jQKQg-00054-00015837-00016149": "Malawi Zambia South Africa Ghana Nigeria", "HD2b63jQKQg-00055-00016150-00016491": "Zimbabwe and Mozambique it is cultivated", "HD2b63jQKQg-00056-00016492-00016697": "for both commercial food processing and", "HD2b63jQKQg-00057-00016698-00016964": "the pharmaceutical industry cultivation", "HD2b63jQKQg-00058-00016965-00017646": "of piri piri is labor-intensive", "HD2b63jQKQg-00059-00017647-00018200": "topic piri piri sauce", "HD2b63jQKQg-00060-00018201-00018500": "sauce made from piri piri chilies used", "HD2b63jQKQg-00061-00018501-00018729": "as a seasoning or marinade is Portuguese", "HD2b63jQKQg-00062-00018730-00018942": "in origin and is also especially", "HD2b63jQKQg-00063-00018943-00019272": "prevalent in Angola Namibia Mozambique", "HD2b63jQKQg-00064-00019273-00019572": "and South Africa it is made from crushed", "HD2b63jQKQg-00065-00019573-00019850": "chillies citrus peel onion pepper garlic", "HD2b63jQKQg-00066-00019851-00020100": "salt lemon juice bay leaves", "HD2b63jQKQg-00067-00020101-00020367": "paprika pimiento basil oregano and", "HD2b63jQKQg-00068-00020368-00020594": "tarragon recipes vary from region to", "HD2b63jQKQg-00069-00020595-00020787": "region but the common ingredients are", "HD2b63jQKQg-00070-00020788-00021542": "chili lemon oil and red bell peppers", "HD2b63jQKQg-00071-00021543-00022068": "topic C also", "HD2b63jQKQg-00072-00022069-00022478": "BRR bear list of capsicum cultivars", "HD2b63jQKQg-00073-00022479-00022734": "Nando's an international restaurant", "HD2b63jQKQg-00074-00022735-00023172": "chain specializing in piri-piri dishes"}}, {"audio_id": "HDkmFICfHOk", "text": {"HDkmFICfHOk-00000-00000053-00000374": "Nature Reviews genetics as a monthly", "HDkmFICfHOk-00001-00000375-00000646": "reviewed journal in genetics and covers", "HDkmFICfHOk-00002-00000647-00001022": "the full breadth of modern genetics the", "HDkmFICfHOk-00003-00001023-00001316": "journal publishes review and perspective", "HDkmFICfHOk-00004-00001317-00001573": "articles written by experts in the field", "HDkmFICfHOk-00005-00001574-00001910": "subject to peer review and copy editing", "HDkmFICfHOk-00006-00001911-00002174": "to provide a Thorat ativ coverage of", "HDkmFICfHOk-00007-00002175-00002609": "topics each issue also contains research", "HDkmFICfHOk-00008-00002610-00002873": "highlight articles short summaries", "HDkmFICfHOk-00009-00002874-00003107": "written by the editors that describe", "HDkmFICfHOk-00010-00003108-00003499": "recent research papers", "HDkmFICfHOk-00011-00003500-00003765": "coverage includes", "HDkmFICfHOk-00012-00003767-00004059": "genomics genome projects genome", "HDkmFICfHOk-00013-00004060-00004500": "sequencing bioinformatics functional", "HDkmFICfHOk-00014-00004501-00004813": "genomics transcript profiling mutant", "HDkmFICfHOk-00015-00004814-00005263": "screens bioinformatics evolutionary", "HDkmFICfHOk-00016-00005264-00005456": "genetics evo-devo", "HDkmFICfHOk-00017-00005457-00005793": "comparative genomics population genetics", "HDkmFICfHOk-00018-00005794-00006070": "Philo genetics", "HDkmFICfHOk-00019-00006071-00006397": "multifactorial genetics complex disease", "HDkmFICfHOk-00020-00006398-00006718": "disease susceptibility resistant", "HDkmFICfHOk-00021-00006719-00007184": "Association studies technology disease", "HDkmFICfHOk-00022-00007184-00007546": "disease gene identification relationship", "HDkmFICfHOk-00023-00007547-00007862": "between genotype and phenotype molecular", "HDkmFICfHOk-00024-00007863-00008288": "pathology of genetic disease chromosome", "HDkmFICfHOk-00025-00008289-00008685": "biology telomeres centromere transposons", "HDkmFICfHOk-00026-00008686-00008969": "artificial chromosomes chromosome", "HDkmFICfHOk-00027-00008970-00009200": "stability", "HDkmFICfHOk-00028-00009201-00009550": "epigenetics DNA methylation histone", "HDkmFICfHOk-00029-00009551-00009793": "modification chromatin structure", "HDkmFICfHOk-00030-00009794-00010202": "imprinting chromatin remodeling", "HDkmFICfHOk-00031-00010203-00010491": "developmental biology reproductive", "HDkmFICfHOk-00032-00010492-00010791": "technology patterning differentiation", "HDkmFICfHOk-00033-00010792-00011348": "evo-devo gene expression DNA elements", "HDkmFICfHOk-00034-00011349-00011738": "LCR's insulators enhancers silencers", "HDkmFICfHOk-00035-00011739-00012206": "broad perspectives on gene regulation", "HDkmFICfHOk-00036-00012207-00012555": "technology new techniques experimental", "HDkmFICfHOk-00037-00012556-00012891": "strategies therapy applied genetics and", "HDkmFICfHOk-00038-00012891-00013637": "genomics computational biology", "HDkmFICfHOk-00039-00013638-00014262": "topic external links", "HDkmFICfHOk-00040-00014263-00014650": "Nature Reviews genetics website", "HDkmFICfHOk-00041-00014651-00014968": "Nature Reviews website", "HDkmFICfHOk-00042-00014969-00015418": "National Library of Medicine"}}, {"audio_id": "HDmlcj3kKJI", "text": {"HDmlcj3kKJI-00000-00000330-00000704": "queuing theory is mainly mathematics the", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00001-00000705-00000882": "standard approach is to model the", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00002-00000883-00001070": "evolution of a time of the number of", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00003-00001071-00001283": "customers in the system as a random", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00004-00001284-00001532": "process the mean performance of the", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00005-00001533-00001775": "system is then obtained from an analysis", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00006-00001776-00001971": "of the steady-state regime of this", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00007-00001972-00002250": "random process the first step of this", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00008-00002251-00002472": "modelling is to characterize a system", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00009-00002473-00002807": "the system has different characteristics", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00010-00002808-00003174": "first of all we have to characterize the", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00011-00003175-00003417": "arrival process of customers in other", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00012-00003418-00003714": "words the way customers arrive in the", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00013-00003715-00004071": "system the customer arrival process is", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00014-00004072-00004601": "often modeled as a Poisson process then", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00015-00004602-00004902": "we have to characterize the service", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00016-00004903-00005190": "duration meaning the time which is", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00017-00005191-00005393": "required to serve each client", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00018-00005394-00005712": "note that the service duration is often", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00019-00005713-00006108": "modeled as an exponential loop it's also", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00020-00006109-00006381": "necessary to specify the number of", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00021-00006382-00006695": "servers since different servers can work", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00022-00006696-00006888": "in parallel and take on different", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00023-00006889-00007364": "customers customers can wait in a buffer", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00024-00007365-00007742": "if all the servers are busy so we have", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00025-00007743-00007991": "to define the total maximum number of", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00026-00007992-00008231": "clients in the system including the", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00027-00008232-00008463": "clients that are being served and the", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00028-00008464-00008856": "waiting clients and finally we have to", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00029-00008857-00009224": "clarify the scaling policy or the order", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00030-00009225-00009506": "in which customers access service the", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00031-00009507-00009764": "most common policy being FIFO", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00032-00009765-00009998": "first in first out meaning that", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00033-00009999-00010253": "customers access the servers in the", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00034-00010254-00010476": "order in which they arrived in other", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00035-00010477-00010941": "words first-come first-served let's go", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00036-00010942-00011153": "back to the characterization of customer", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00037-00011154-00011430": "rivals the arrival process is a point", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00038-00011431-00011694": "process meaning a set of points on the", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00039-00011695-00012035": "timeline each point denoted as T I on", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00040-00012036-00012263": "this graph represents your rival time of", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00041-00012264-00012545": "customer number I the inter arrival time", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00042-00012546-00012752": "denotes the time between two consecutive", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00043-00012753-00013194": "customers it's noted here as UI which is", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00044-00013194-00013438": "equal to TI plus 1 minus t", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00045-00013438-00013696": "I and represents the interval between", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00046-00013697-00013941": "the arrival of customer I and the", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00047-00013943-00014293": "arrival of customer I plus one in simple", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00048-00014294-00014541": "models it is assumed that the successive", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00049-00014543-00014971": "inter arrival times or u 1 u 2 u 3 etc", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00050-00014972-00015286": "are mutually independent and that they", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00051-00015287-00015546": "follow the same probability distribution", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00052-00015547-00015871": "in this case the customer arrival", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00053-00015872-00016108": "process is therefore fully characterized", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00054-00016109-00016459": "by the law of inter arrival times it's", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00055-00016460-00016693": "very often assumed that the law of", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00056-00016694-00016909": "successive inter arrival times is an", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00057-00016910-00017179": "exponential distribution whose parameter", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00058-00017180-00017638": "is classically denoted as lambda the", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00059-00017639-00017896": "probability that the inter arrival time", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00060-00017897-00018181": "UI is greater than a given threshold new", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00061-00018182-00018469": "it does equal to the exponential of", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00062-00018470-00018900": "minus lambda u in this case when the", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00063-00018901-00019147": "inter arrival times are independent and", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00064-00019148-00019414": "identically distributed according to an", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00065-00019415-00019621": "exponential distribution with parameter", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00066-00019622-00019950": "lambda the arrival process is said to be", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00067-00019951-00020416": "a Poisson process of rate lambda lambda", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00068-00020417-00020821": "is called the arrival rate it represents", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00069-00020822-00021061": "an average number of customer arrivals", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00070-00021062-00021369": "per time unit so it's unit is the", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00071-00021370-00021600": "inverse of the time unit for example", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00072-00021601-00022021": "customers per second reciprocal the", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00073-00022022-00022183": "average time between two consecutive", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00074-00022184-00022513": "arrivals equals 1 divided by lambda and", "HDmlcj3kKJI-00075-00022514-00023014": "is stated in for example seconds"}}, {"audio_id": "HDmVw3H4ue8", "text": {"HDmVw3H4ue8-00000-00000084-00000353": "well it's 4 30 and I do think I will", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00001-00000354-00000574": "call this session to order", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00002-00000575-00000935": "it's a pleasure to welcome", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00003-00000936-00001199": "Professor Martin Morgan of the Roswell", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00004-00001200-00001408": "Park Comprehensive Cancer Center State", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00005-00001409-00001763": "University of New York at Buffalo", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00006-00001764-00002345": "to bio C 2022", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00007-00002346-00002455": "Martin", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00008-00002456-00002802": "has led the bioconductor", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00009-00002803-00003095": "project for quite some time", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00010-00003096-00003467": "and step down from leading the core just", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00011-00003468-00003629": "a couple of years ago", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00012-00003629-00003917": "and at that time Wolfgang Hoover made a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00013-00003918-00004054": "nice slide", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00014-00004055-00004295": "detailing how the project had changed", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00015-00004296-00004486": "under his leadership", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00016-00004487-00004756": "and there were great many changes such", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00017-00004757-00004967": "as a vast increase in the number of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00018-00004968-00005122": "packages", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00019-00005123-00005452": "number of users quantity of data being", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00020-00005453-00005693": "shipped out", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00021-00005694-00006268": "size of the bill to Amazon web services", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00022-00006269-00006641": "um and uh really important changes to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00023-00006642-00006946": "governance and Community uh engagement", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00024-00006947-00007163": "so um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00025-00007164-00007414": "you heard also from from air vapage", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00026-00007415-00007577": "today", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00027-00007578-00007798": "uh when he received his bio conductor", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00028-00007800-00008045": "award for 2022", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00029-00008045-00008417": "uh just uh how effective a leader Martin", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00030-00008418-00008560": "has been", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00031-00008561-00008842": "and so um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00032-00008843-00009131": "I welcome you and I thank you and take", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00033-00009132-00009310": "it away Martin he's going to speak about", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00034-00009311-00009539": "the human cell Atlas and the many", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00035-00009540-00009833": "interesting functions he has written to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00036-00009834-00010271": "help us explore that resource", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00037-00010272-00010637": "all right all right thanks Vince it's of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00038-00010638-00010859": "course strange talking to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00039-00010860-00011314": "uh people over over The Ether waves", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00040-00011315-00011645": "knowing that some of you are actually uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00041-00011646-00011819": "present in the same room so I'm going to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00042-00011820-00011999": "share my screen", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00043-00012000-00012167": "and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00044-00012168-00012460": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00045-00012461-00012688": "very confusing here", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00046-00012689-00013072": "Google Chrome here we go so I hope that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00047-00013073-00013277": "I hope that you can see my screen is", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00048-00013278-00013630": "that uh not looking good for people", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00049-00013631-00013955": "maybe a thumbs up or something", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00050-00013956-00014338": "we can see it right perfect thanks Mark", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00051-00014340-00014758": "right uh yeah so um great um I wanted to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00052-00014759-00014980": "talk about uh accessing human cell Atlas", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00053-00014981-00015275": "data uh locally and on the anvil cloud", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00054-00015276-00015580": "and I'm going to uh use this amazing", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00055-00015581-00015893": "Orchestra technology as well as package", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00056-00015894-00016055": "down so I hope that you'll follow along", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00057-00016056-00016319": "the uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00058-00016319-00016607": "um the package that I'm using is", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00059-00016608-00016894": "documented here and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00060-00016895-00017285": "and I'm going to use Orchestra here I'm", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00061-00017286-00017489": "going to find for some reason it shows", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00062-00017490-00017735": "up for me um pretty much at the top with", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00063-00017736-00017975": "a ton of launches already but accessing", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00064-00017976-00018155": "human cell Atlas data you could search", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00065-00018156-00018379": "for like human or something like that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00066-00018380-00018647": "accessing human cell Atlas data locally", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00067-00018648-00018905": "on the anvil cloud and I hope you", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00068-00018906-00019205": "clicked on that and follow along and get", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00069-00019206-00019439": "yourself in our studio session", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00070-00019440-00019980": "that opens in the package", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00071-00019981-00020255": "directory totally amazing technology", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00072-00020256-00020441": "that's a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00073-00020442-00020729": "so so impressed with that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00074-00020730-00020999": "um yes so I'm going to talk about uh the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00075-00021000-00021371": "human cell Atlas and celex Gene", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00076-00021372-00021539": "two different sources of single cell", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00077-00021540-00021857": "data and uh the booths on the groundwork", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00078-00021858-00022067": "have been done by uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00079-00022068-00022535": "Kayla and yubo and I just get to claim", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00080-00022536-00022930": "uh the the glory here", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00081-00022931-00023158": "um I'm going to follow these vignettes", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00082-00023159-00023369": "and I'm going to start with this first", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00083-00023370-00023599": "vignette the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00084-00023600-00023843": "ahca.rmd and again I hope you're", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00085-00023844-00023969": "following along", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00086-00023970-00024328": "uh I'll go so guys listening to the uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00087-00024329-00024641": "tidy transcriptomics presentation and uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00088-00024642-00024880": "the presenter was totally awesome he did", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00089-00024881-00025036": "a way better job of presenting than I've", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00090-00025037-00025186": "ever done so", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00091-00025187-00025355": "um I hope that you'll follow along and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00092-00025356-00025655": "uh we'll spend about uh 20 minutes on", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00093-00025656-00025949": "this vignette and maybe uh 15 minutes on", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00094-00025950-00026146": "the B vignette and a few more minutes on", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00095-00026147-00026405": "the Steven yet", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00096-00026406-00026651": "um I wanted to start with thinking about", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00097-00026652-00026939": "bioconductor and single cell and I'll", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00098-00026939-00027305": "just go to the bioconductor.org", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00099-00027306-00027599": "uh website and visit", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00100-00027600-00027749": "the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00101-00027750-00028079": "um 2140 software packages and type in a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00102-00028080-00028193": "single", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00103-00028194-00028312": "cell", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00104-00028313-00028602": "and find out that actually there are um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00105-00028604-00028990": "213 packages that have been tagged as uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00106-00028991-00029237": "as single cell and I'm sure you know", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00107-00029238-00029464": "this but if you drill down on any one of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00108-00029466-00029645": "these packages you get information about", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00109-00029645-00029873": "how frequently it's been downloaded the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00110-00029874-00030196": "amount of times it's been asked about", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00111-00030197-00030455": "support on the support site and of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00112-00030456-00030689": "course these amazing vignettes which can", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00113-00030689-00030923": "totally blow blow you away with the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00114-00030924-00031127": "richness of these resources", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00115-00031127-00031429": "so the first point is there's a ton of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00116-00031430-00031835": "resources individual packages that allow", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00117-00031836-00032105": "us to work with single cell data and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00118-00032106-00032381": "then an amazing secondary resource for", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00119-00032382-00032717": "single cell data is this book called", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00120-00032718-00032896": "Oscar", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00121-00032897-00033029": "books", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00122-00033030-00033335": "Oscar orchestrating single cell analysis", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00123-00033336-00033802": "with a bioconductor several authors I", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00124-00033803-00033923": "was just going to jump down to the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00125-00033924-00034199": "workflows and there are 14 different", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00126-00034200-00034423": "workflows that walk through particular", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00127-00034424-00034840": "analyzes this this last one grabbed some", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00128-00034841-00035093": "human cell Atlas human bone marrow data", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00129-00035094-00035362": "and imports it with a few lines of code", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00130-00035363-00035581": "and then walks through a typical", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00131-00035582-00035987": "analysis with the rich vignette and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00132-00035988-00036262": "amazing um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00133-00036263-00036533": "integrated graphics and so on", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00134-00036534-00036785": "um so the point the second point then is", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00135-00036786-00037079": "that uh that the Oscar is an amazing", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00136-00037080-00037295": "resource for learning about single cell", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00137-00037296-00037523": "analysis", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00138-00037524-00037762": "so what I wanted to do though was", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00139-00037763-00037895": "um actually", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00140-00037896-00038009": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00141-00038010-00038296": "explore uh some of the Single Cell", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00142-00038297-00038524": "resources that come from the human cell", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00143-00038525-00038627": "Atlas", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00144-00038628-00038915": "and I wanted to start I'm a big fan of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00145-00038916-00039124": "the Tidy verse type of approach to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00146-00039125-00039365": "things and so I wanted to start just", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00147-00039366-00039629": "with a quick refresher and load up this", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00148-00039630-00039977": "deep plier package and start with a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00149-00039978-00040324": "familiar example that empty cars", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00150-00040325-00040667": "Motor Trend cars data set", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00151-00040668-00041057": "um which has I know some number of rows", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00152-00041058-00041296": "and cars and of different sorts and I", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00153-00041297-00041471": "just wanted to represent it as a tibble", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00154-00041472-00041927": "and then display it here as a tibble uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00155-00041928-00042149": "just to kind of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00156-00042150-00042437": "see what we've got we've got cars and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00157-00042438-00042683": "miles per gallon and so on and and then", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00158-00042684-00043049": "this pipe the native pipe takes uh from", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00159-00043050-00043295": "base our clicks uh whatever's on the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00160-00043296-00043523": "left hand side and use it as an argument", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00161-00043524-00043762": "on the right hand side so this says show", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00162-00043763-00044105": "us only the six cylinder cars and only", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00163-00044106-00044371": "um select the car miles per gallon", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00164-00044372-00044662": "displacement and horsepower are columns", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00165-00044663-00044957": "and then update things a little bit with", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00166-00044958-00045118": "uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00167-00045119-00045208": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00168-00045209-00045449": "um uh some metric unit liters per 100", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00169-00045450-00045671": "kilometers and you can see just how", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00170-00045672-00045874": "expressive this kind of Tidy framework", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00171-00045875-00045952": "is", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00172-00045953-00046252": "so I'm totally enthusiastic about that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00173-00046253-00046390": "and that's going to kind of form the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00174-00046391-00046733": "basis of how uh we're going to access", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00175-00046734-00047140": "human cell Atlas data", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00176-00047141-00047296": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00177-00047297-00047680": "so uh what about the human cell Atlas so", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00178-00047681-00047958": "I wanted to go to the data portal", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00179-00047959-00048293": "humancell atlas.org I could just uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00180-00048294-00048617": "human cell Atlas", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00181-00048618-00048767": "portal", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00182-00048768-00048989": "gets us there", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00183-00048990-00049145": "and uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00184-00049146-00049399": "this is um the human cell Atlas is", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00185-00049400-00049630": "sponsored by the Chan Zuckerberg", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00186-00049631-00049967": "initiative a number of um individual", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00187-00049968-00050230": "projects that collect cell level", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00188-00050231-00050518": "resolution expression data", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00189-00050519-00050849": "um they're currently 267 projects and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00190-00050850-00051107": "you can see that you can navigate these", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00191-00051108-00051292": "and find a particular", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00192-00051294-00051713": "um uh experiment and learn about it and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00193-00051714-00051887": "um then download", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00194-00051888-00051973": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00195-00051974-00052319": "matrices the processed expression values", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00196-00052320-00052492": "that you could then use in your own", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00197-00052494-00052625": "analysis", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00198-00052626-00052816": "so like that's the website but", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00199-00052817-00053057": "perversely enough I'm I'm not so", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00200-00053058-00053213": "interested in the website because this", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00201-00053214-00053471": "is um this sort of graphical thing this", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00202-00053472-00053765": "kind of navigating through and clicking", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00203-00053766-00054113": "on things is really um error prone and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00204-00054114-00054341": "um you know I actually clicked on some", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00205-00054341-00054587": "arbitrary thing I I don't even know for", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00206-00054588-00054826": "two minutes ago which one I I clicked on", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00207-00054827-00055079": "and um there might be many reasons why", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00208-00055079-00055265": "I'd want to be do something that was", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00209-00055266-00055541": "more reproducible and rigorous maybe", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00210-00055541-00055744": "even you know systematically search for", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00211-00055745-00056075": "studies that um investigated say um the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00212-00056076-00056273": "brain or something like that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00213-00056274-00056653": "so I've written a package with uh Maya", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00214-00056654-00057016": "called HCA so I'm going through this a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00215-00057017-00057425": "HCA data set vignette so I'm going to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00216-00057426-00057730": "load HCA and another package this guy", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00217-00057732-00057982": "Daniel van clisk and I uh worked on", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00218-00057983-00058121": "together as well as single cell", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00219-00058122-00058313": "experiment so I'm just going to load", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00220-00058314-00058547": "those guys into my R session", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00221-00058548-00058769": "I think I didn't load them all I just", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00222-00058770-00059026": "loaded one there I've loaded them loaded", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00223-00059027-00059225": "them all into my R session", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00224-00059226-00059482": "and um instead of going to the website", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00225-00059483-00059735": "and exploring things that way I'm going", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00226-00059736-00060107": "to enter this command projects and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00227-00060108-00060329": "that'll do the comparable thing it'll", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00228-00060329-00060557": "visit the website or the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00229-00060558-00060766": "API the application programming", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00230-00060767-00061007": "interface that underlies the website and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00231-00061008-00061211": "it'll page through the projects collect", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00232-00061212-00061397": "all of the information and Report the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00233-00061398-00061769": "data back to my R session and so now I", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00234-00061770-00061888": "have", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00235-00061889-00061954": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00236-00061955-00062387": "in my R session I have a tibble", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00237-00062388-00062550": "with um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00238-00062551-00062861": "267 projects and 14 different columns", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00239-00062862-00062992": "worth of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00240-00062994-00063166": "worth of information that I could then", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00241-00063167-00063449": "process using standard um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00242-00063450-00063719": "standard deep plier types of techniques", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00243-00063720-00063923": "so these are the these are the projects", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00244-00063924-00064091": "that we saw on the website just", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00245-00064091-00064282": "presented in a different way", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00246-00064283-00064565": "you'll notice that um many of these", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00247-00064566-00064913": "columns are list columns and uh for", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00248-00064914-00065092": "instance this genus species you can see", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00249-00065094-00065176": "that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00250-00065177-00065399": "some of these projects have just a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00251-00065400-00065681": "single genus Homo sapiens I guess but", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00252-00065682-00065903": "this particular project actually has two", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00253-00065904-00066256": "species Madison man and Madison human", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00254-00066257-00066635": "and so um the entire representation is a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00255-00066636-00066856": "is a a list column where each of the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00256-00066857-00067000": "elements of the list are in fact", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00257-00067001-00067235": "character vectors of zero one or more", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00258-00067236-00067426": "elements", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00259-00067427-00067709": "and that can be a little bit uh tricky", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00260-00067710-00067900": "to work with it can help to pull out", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00261-00067901-00068111": "individual columns or to use this uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00262-00068112-00068521": "tidy function called glimpse which", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00263-00068522-00068776": "provides you with a little overview of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00264-00068777-00068938": "what the um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00265-00068939-00069221": "what the table looks like or pulling out", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00266-00069222-00069425": "a single column the head of a single", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00267-00069426-00069725": "column and pulling pulling that column", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00268-00069726-00070043": "and seeing that the first row was of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00269-00070044-00070355": "this specimen organ part was cortex for", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00270-00070356-00070606": "the first experiment and the second", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00271-00070607-00070865": "experiment had two specimen organ parts", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00272-00070866-00071063": "and the third experiment and fourth", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00273-00071064-00071393": "experiment had zero um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00274-00071394-00071609": "um specimen organ parts", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00275-00071610-00071832": "so we're discovering how to navigate", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00276-00071833-00072215": "these uh data resources there's also a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00277-00072216-00072599": "neat function called HCA view which um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00278-00072600-00072821": "when you invoke it", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00279-00072822-00073282": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00280-00073283-00073559": "produces a little tibble that you can", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00281-00073560-00073919": "navigate through here and uh search for", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00282-00073920-00074087": "instance for all of the studies that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00283-00074088-00074309": "involve the brain for instance and uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00284-00074310-00074669": "choose these studies and uh and then", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00285-00074670-00075065": "when you're done Ma is now the tibble", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00286-00075066-00075281": "that contains the two studies that you", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00287-00075282-00075521": "selected so very easy to navigate", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00288-00075522-00075863": "through and interact", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00289-00075864-00076025": "um with um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00290-00076026-00076579": "these large data sets", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00291-00076580-00076888": "uh let's see", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00292-00076889-00077147": "so um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00293-00077148-00077435": "when we were on the website we saw that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00294-00077436-00077644": "there were like you know you can kind of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00295-00077645-00077788": "count the number of columns they're like", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00296-00077789-00078088": "10 or 12 columns here but actually these", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00297-00078089-00078293": "experiments are incredibly rich", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00298-00078294-00078682": "and they're represented uh as Json lists", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00299-00078683-00078982": "and you can actually request not just", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00300-00078983-00079205": "the 10 or 15 columns that are displayed", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00301-00079206-00079582": "in the project table on the website but", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00302-00079583-00079859": "all of the data so um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00303-00079860-00080044": "so um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00304-00080045-00080482": "end up with uh the 267 hits and uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00305-00080483-00080771": "each of the hits contains a certain", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00306-00080772-00081000": "number of elements and each of those", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00307-00081001-00081359": "elements contains these subsets that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00308-00081360-00081785": "expand into different components", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00309-00081786-00081959": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00310-00081960-00082331": "describing uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00311-00082332-00082511": "you can see how fun it is right to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00312-00082512-00082781": "navigate these things describing in very", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00313-00082782-00083141": "rich detail the experiment", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00314-00083142-00083435": "um I did want to mention uh so so it's", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00315-00083436-00083585": "just useful to know", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00316-00083586-00083909": "um that uh um there's a really rich uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00317-00083910-00084155": "uh data out there", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00318-00084156-00084497": "um and yeah uh instead of um sort of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00319-00084498-00084719": "pulling down all of the data and uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00320-00084720-00084976": "navigating it through it um as we've", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00321-00084977-00085156": "done here or there's this amazing", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00322-00085157-00085462": "package called list viewer I think list", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00323-00085463-00085585": "viewer", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00324-00085586-00085906": "uh Json edit", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00325-00085907-00086159": "list View", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00326-00086160-00086621": "uh Json edit I'm I'm going off script so", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00327-00086622-00086800": "I've lost track of a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00328-00086801-00087143": "uh of the command but uh something like", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00329-00087144-00087491": "that um that um this viewer I'm pretty", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00330-00087492-00087647": "sure", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00331-00087648-00087971": "that allows us to uh okay uh allows us", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00332-00087972-00088073": "to navigate", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00333-00088074-00088403": "um these uh lists um comprehensively but", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00334-00088404-00088571": "instead of sort of retrieving all of the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00335-00088572-00088973": "data it often makes sense to query uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00336-00088974-00089261": "the projects for things that you're", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00337-00089262-00089543": "interested in in particular for instance", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00338-00089544-00089956": "maybe you have a an interest in in liver", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00339-00089957-00090232": "and uh you'd like to find all of the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00340-00090233-00090485": "projects that study liver maybe you're", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00341-00090486-00090671": "going to start a meta-analysis or", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00342-00090672-00090893": "something along those lines so you can", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00343-00090894-00091103": "specify a filter", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00344-00091104-00091426": "that says uh specimore specimen organ", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00345-00091427-00091673": "um is liver and it could be a more", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00346-00091674-00091787": "complicated", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00347-00091788-00092087": "um filter and then when you query", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00348-00092088-00092356": "projects with the liver filter you don't", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00349-00092357-00092500": "end up with", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00350-00092501-00092861": "um 267 projects you end up with 23", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00351-00092862-00093088": "projects where the liver has been", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00352-00093089-00093323": "mentioned as one of the specimen organs", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00353-00093324-00093582": "so it's a very useful way of finding", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00354-00093583-00093838": "data that you're particularly interested", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00355-00093839-00094079": "in", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00356-00094080-00094487": "so when you look through the HCA package", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00357-00094488-00094615": "you'll see", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00358-00094616-00095044": "projects bundles samples and files are", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00359-00095045-00095291": "the main entry points", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00360-00095292-00095638": "and uh the um queries", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00361-00095639-00095800": "um generally return a finite number of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00362-00095801-00096049": "resources and frequently you want to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00363-00096050-00096365": "page through the results that so you get", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00364-00096366-00096532": "a thousand files and then you want to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00365-00096533-00096694": "see the next thousand files and so on", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00366-00096695-00097037": "and you can use HCA next or HCA preview", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00367-00097038-00097726": "to page through these larger data sets", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00368-00097727-00097900": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00369-00097901-00098344": "so that's uh where I'm at so far uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00370-00098345-00098735": "I can see I don't see anyone's faces or", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00371-00098736-00098909": "anything like that I don't see a chat", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00372-00098910-00099173": "box but if you're if you do have a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00373-00099174-00099712": "question feel free to let me know", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00374-00099713-00099826": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00375-00099827-00100061": "what I'm going to do is um one of the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00376-00100062-00100312": "great things actually about the HCA the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00377-00100313-00100553": "human cell analysis data portal", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00378-00100554-00100744": "and unfortunately they're they're not", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00379-00100745-00100906": "going to continue on with this so it was", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00380-00100907-00101135": "a once great thing was that they applied", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00381-00101136-00101371": "a standard analysis protocols so", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00382-00101372-00101638": "contributors would give a fast few files", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00383-00101639-00101856": "and then the HCA developed a standard", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00384-00101857-00102149": "analysis workflow so that all of the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00385-00102150-00102329": "fastq files were processed in the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00386-00102330-00102544": "standardized way to to account Matrix", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00387-00102545-00102760": "and then the count Matrix is made", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00388-00102761-00103127": "available as a as a loom file which", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00389-00103128-00103390": "um fit which can be easily incorporated", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00390-00103391-00103625": "into bioconductor and say at the start", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00391-00103626-00103780": "of one of those workflows that we saw in", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00392-00103781-00104003": "the Oscar book so that was totally", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00393-00104004-00104134": "amazing they've stopped doing that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00394-00104135-00104351": "apparently but they're about 77 files", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00395-00104352-00104597": "that are currently available so here I", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00396-00104598-00104908": "say um this is a little example a little", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00397-00104909-00105089": "bit more complicated filter I'm saying", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00398-00105090-00105427": "hey I'm interested in all of the um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00399-00105428-00105660": "standard Loom files that have been", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00400-00105661-00105916": "processed using the standard Pipeline", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00401-00105917-00106210": "and that have integrated the samples", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00402-00106211-00106481": "within a single experiment so I'll", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00403-00106482-00106777": "evaluate this and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00404-00106778-00107128": "Vary for those files and I find that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00405-00107129-00107539": "there are", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00406-00107540-00107801": "that there are", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00407-00107802-00107975": "79", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00408-00107976-00108028": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00409-00108029-00108275": "of these standard processed Loom files", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00410-00108276-00108407": "which represents a wonderful starting", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00411-00108408-00108595": "point for you know", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00412-00108596-00108947": "tutorials or student training or for", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00413-00108948-00109204": "comparative studies and what I'm going", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00414-00109205-00109427": "to do is I'm going to um look for the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00415-00109428-00109913": "loom files that um are also of liver so", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00416-00109914-00110069": "I'm going to take my liver projects and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00417-00110070-00110260": "I'm going to do an inner join with the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00418-00110261-00110693": "loom files using the um project ID and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00419-00110694-00110945": "project title um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00420-00110946-00111347": "uh to to do that uh formatting and then", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00421-00111348-00111616": "uh it turns out that there are 11", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00422-00111617-00111886": "projects", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00423-00111888-00112025": "uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00424-00112026-00112463": "that study liver and that had these", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00425-00112464-00112708": "cells samples processed in a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00426-00112709-00113015": "standardized a standardized way some of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00427-00113016-00113190": "the projects had", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00428-00113191-00113578": "maybe there were um maybe there were", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00429-00113579-00113707": "multiple", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00430-00113708-00114034": "samples different types of samples that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00431-00114035-00114365": "were involved in this particular project", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00432-00114366-00114521": "but what I'm going to do is I'm going to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00433-00114522-00114833": "grab one of these projects uh this one", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00434-00114833-00114923": "here", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00435-00114924-00115199": "and I'm going to grab its Loom file and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00436-00115200-00115301": "I'm going to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00437-00115302-00115595": "um take a look at this so let's see", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00438-00115596-00115858": "so uh this is the this is the cell I'm", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00439-00115859-00116045": "just going to focus on the second the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00440-00116046-00116290": "human liver cellular landscape by blah", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00441-00116291-00116560": "blah blah Homo sapiens cut it lobe with", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00442-00116561-00117019": "the liver 10x3 Prime V2 single cell data", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00443-00117020-00117286": "processed in this standard processing", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00444-00117288-00117628": "way adult human cells and a loom file", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00445-00117629-00117847": "and this is when it was was generated", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00446-00117848-00118066": "and so what I'm going to do is I'm going", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00447-00118067-00118139": "to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00448-00118140-00118199": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00449-00118200-00118469": "identify that particular file", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00450-00118470-00118775": "and then I'm going to this file as you", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00451-00118776-00119039": "can see here I'm going to actually", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00452-00119040-00119440": "retrieve the data from the HCA", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00453-00119441-00119621": "I guess this is going pretty quickly", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00454-00119622-00119716": "which is great right because", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00455-00119717-00119902": "everything's in the cloud orchestras in", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00456-00119903-00120178": "the cloud HCA is in the cloud so we've", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00457-00120179-00120408": "downloaded this uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00458-00120409-00121027": "this Loom file containing uh the um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00459-00121028-00121247": "single cell data from that particular", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00460-00121248-00121625": "experiment and we've saved it locally on", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00461-00121626-00121823": "disk in a cache so if we were to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00462-00121824-00122039": "evaluate this command again it would be", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00463-00122040-00122225": "cheap we don't have to re-download the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00464-00122226-00122375": "file", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00465-00122376-00122584": "and what I'd like to do is uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00466-00122585-00122825": "take that file it's great that it's on", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00467-00122826-00123004": "disk but we like to be able to import it", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00468-00123005-00123334": "into into bioconductor so I'll use the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00469-00123335-00123673": "loom experiment package and I'll import", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00470-00123674-00123995": "the loom file from the location that I", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00471-00123996-00124366": "saved it on disk so this is uh in real", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00472-00124367-00124715": "time and now I've got um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00473-00124716-00124954": "a single cell a loom experiment which is", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00474-00124955-00125273": "like a single cell experiment uh 58 000", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00475-00125274-00125560": "genes which is the sort of the genes", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00476-00125561-00125795": "that are used in there the HCA standard", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00477-00125796-00126071": "processing Pipeline and 332", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00478-00126072-00126227": "000 cells so actually quite a bit of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00479-00126228-00126401": "data here", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00480-00126402-00126569": "um you actually get quite a bit of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00481-00126570-00126778": "useful information from the metadata on", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00482-00126779-00127084": "the loom you get uh information about", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00483-00127085-00127463": "um uh when um the file was created the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00484-00127464-00127552": "the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00485-00127553-00127936": "um the inputs the samples that were used", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00486-00127938-00128369": "um and the um pipeline version and and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00487-00128370-00128765": "so on so tons of uh useful data", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00488-00128766-00128993": "the thing about this Loom file which is", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00489-00128994-00129221": "a little bit disappointing but um turns", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00490-00129222-00129623": "out to be uh uh can easily remedied it", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00491-00129624-00129778": "has tons of information on the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00492-00129779-00130036": "individual cells this call data these 43", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00493-00130038-00130408": "columns but these 43 columns are all", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00494-00130409-00130702": "like uh QC metrics", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00495-00130703-00130973": "um like reads unmapped and spliced reads", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00496-00130974-00131189": "and so on and nothing about the biology", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00497-00131190-00131387": "so we don't know if they were males or", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00498-00131388-00131561": "females in this study what their ages", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00499-00131562-00131639": "were", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00500-00131640-00131819": "anything like that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00501-00131820-00131957": "but it turns out that that information", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00502-00131958-00132143": "is buried", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00503-00132144-00132514": "in the HCA and you can retrieve uh that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00504-00132515-00132713": "information with this um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00505-00132714-00132977": "Optimus Loom annotation function it", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00506-00132978-00133204": "takes the loom file and figures out from", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00507-00133205-00133469": "the metadata where the samples came from", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00508-00133470-00133751": "and collects the information about the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00509-00133752-00133919": "samples like the biologically", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00510-00133920-00134273": "interesting information and then um adds", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00511-00134274-00134590": "that so now we've got 98 columns instead", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00512-00134591-00134699": "of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00513-00134700-00135097": "instead of 43 98 columns that include", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00514-00135098-00135659": "biologically interesting columns uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00515-00135660-00136061": "so 55 new columns so for instance we can", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00516-00136062-00136414": "take the column data of a annotated Loom", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00517-00136415-00136721": "and figure out that there are actually", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00518-00136722-00137057": "in these 330 000 cells there are um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00519-00137058-00137489": "actually five separate samples uh four", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00520-00137490-00137783": "of them are male and one is female they", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00521-00137784-00138059": "range in age from 21 to 65 years of age", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00522-00138060-00138263": "and then this is the number of cells in", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00523-00138264-00138419": "each of the samples", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00524-00138420-00138628": "so it shows that there's actually a very", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00525-00138629-00138881": "rich set of data that's available in the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00526-00138882-00139145": "HCA and it's extremely accessible from", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00527-00139146-00139373": "within bioconductor so there are all", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00528-00139374-00139607": "kinds of interesting things that one can", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00529-00139608-00139823": "do to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00530-00139824-00140333": "um uh get going uh as a pedagogical tool", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00531-00140334-00140633": "and fitting directly into the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00532-00140634-00140819": "um the orchestrating Single Cell", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00533-00140820-00140957": "analysis", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00534-00140958-00141293": "um book that we are um saw at the very", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00535-00141294-00141857": "beginning", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00536-00141858-00142085": "um so I'm gonna switch gears but maybe", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00537-00142086-00142252": "I'll just pause and take any questions", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00538-00142253-00143345": "or anyone have any thoughts", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00539-00143346-00143519": "is this thing on okay it takes a second", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00540-00143520-00143669": "doesn't it anybody here have any", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00541-00143670-00144569": "questions for Martin", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00542-00144570-00144664": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00543-00144665-00144947": "why was there a need for Loom experiment", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00544-00144948-00145247": "sorry this is Leonardo um hi Martin", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00545-00145248-00145463": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00546-00145464-00145823": "from what I see like you end up passing", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00547-00145824-00146087": "it into single cell experiments so", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00548-00146088-00146459": "um I don't understand why what's", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00549-00146460-00146752": "different in Loom experiment yeah", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00550-00146753-00147016": "so the loom format supports in", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00551-00147017-00147383": "particular this row and column graphs so", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00552-00147384-00147599": "um sort of hierarchical structuring of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00553-00147600-00147799": "the rows and columns", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00554-00147800-00148073": "and that's part of the Loom format which", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00555-00148074-00148307": "didn't fit in uh well with this single", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00556-00148308-00148673": "cell experiment class so it's a that's", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00557-00148674-00149075": "kind of a lightweight extension", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00558-00149076-00149501": "but that's the main reason", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00559-00149502-00149759": "I'll I'll mention that these assays are", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00560-00149760-00150119": "delayed the the loom format is in hdf5", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00561-00150120-00150364": "um file format so it's an on disk format", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00562-00150365-00150647": "and when I loaded this uh loaded this", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00563-00150648-00150761": "file", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00564-00150762-00151013": "uh it loaded really quickly because", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00565-00151014-00151204": "actually it didn't load at all the most", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00566-00151205-00151499": "of the data is still still on on disk um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00567-00151500-00151637": "and so this object is actually quite", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00568-00151638-00151745": "lightweight", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00569-00151746-00151978": "which also makes it easy to convert to a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00570-00151979-00152314": "single cell experiment", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00571-00152315-00152614": "um thank you Martin so but this", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00572-00152615-00152897": "particular object that you loaded had no", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00573-00152898-00153197": "um bro and call graphs right it was Zero", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00574-00153198-00153490": "yeah is that the case for all of the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00575-00153491-00153797": "human cell Atlas I think so yes I think", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00576-00153798-00153952": "that none of the humans sell out of this", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00577-00153953-00154247": "data actually they produce Loom files", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00578-00154248-00154487": "but the loom files don't contain the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00579-00154488-00154697": "distinctive characteristic of column", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00580-00154698-00154816": "grass", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00581-00154817-00155207": "all right awesome thank you yeah", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00582-00155208-00155657": "pretty interesting", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00583-00155658-00155939": "all right maybe I'll switch to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00584-00155940-00156125": "celex Gene", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00585-00156126-00156587": "so cell extreme I have a question yes uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00586-00156588-00156797": "so the so the loom experiment class is", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00587-00156798-00156940": "basically a single cell experiment", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00588-00156941-00157151": "subclass with a few extra Fields added", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00589-00157152-00157349": "in that's correct yeah", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00590-00157350-00157763": "okay thank you", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00591-00157764-00158147": "I kind of think that when uh if we if we", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00592-00158148-00158351": "were to drill down and go a little bit", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00593-00158352-00158626": "um off-piste we'd find that uh I think", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00594-00158627-00158849": "that we can actually import", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00595-00158850-00159197": "when we imported this um file as a loom", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00596-00159198-00159352": "file I bet we could import it as a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00597-00159353-00159604": "single cell experiment directly", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00598-00159605-00159875": "um which is you know it advertises", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00599-00159876-00160078": "itself as Loom but loomises", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00600-00160079-00160216": "is a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00601-00160217-00160475": "is a single cell experiment plus so we", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00602-00160476-00161237": "can just import the relevant parts", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00603-00161238-00161554": "all right let me talk about the cell X", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00604-00161555-00161854": "Gene I this is really um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00605-00161855-00162119": "select screen is really a pretty neat", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00606-00162120-00162202": "little", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00607-00162203-00162425": "um endeavor", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00608-00162426-00162766": "also sponsored by the czi", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00609-00162767-00163078": "and uh in many ways it's uh similar to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00610-00163079-00163343": "the human cell atlas there are a number", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00611-00163344-00163613": "of different uh experiments uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00612-00163614-00163781": "collections are like individual", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00613-00163782-00164123": "experiments and data sets are data sets", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00614-00164124-00164297": "within an experiment", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00615-00164298-00164525": "um so maybe one lab does an experiment", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00616-00164526-00164687": "that has several data sets and so", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00617-00164688-00164873": "there's a collection that has several", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00618-00164874-00165223": "data sets and then you can find the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00619-00165224-00165557": "study that you're interested in", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00620-00165558-00165823": "um Alzheimer's disease from Seattle", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00621-00165824-00166121": "appropriately enough", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00622-00166122-00166307": "and find out a little bit of information", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00623-00166308-00166504": "about it and then when you", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00624-00166505-00166987": "click on this it actually um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00625-00166988-00167164": "uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00626-00167165-00167345": "uh it does something that I wasn't quite", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00627-00167346-00167543": "expecting oh I didn't want to click on", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00628-00167544-00167926": "it I'll I'll go back here and uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00629-00167927-00168239": "I'll um so we drilled down a bunch of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00630-00168240-00168437": "additional information I wanted to click", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00631-00168438-00168766": "on this um Explorer icon here", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00632-00168767-00169223": "and um what it does is it uh the um when", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00633-00169224-00169504": "the investigator submitted the data set", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00634-00169505-00192845": "they also provided", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00635-00192846-00193175": "data sets to 21. so now I know that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00636-00193176-00193499": "there are 21 data sets in cell extreme", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00637-00193500-00193759": "that contain African-American females", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00638-00193760-00194014": "who were studied with this particular", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00639-00194015-00194188": "protocol", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00640-00194189-00194369": "which I actually find it interesting in", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00641-00194370-00194561": "and of itself it's a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00642-00194562-00194752": "provides us with a quantitative way of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00643-00194753-00194890": "assessing", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00644-00194891-00195166": "um about diversity and inclusion types", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00645-00195167-00195395": "of metrics within um within the project", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00646-00195396-00195737": "in a in a contemporary project", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00647-00195738-00195851": "so I'm going to grab the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00648-00195852-00196223": "African-American female data sets and uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00649-00196224-00196516": "I'm going to find the files that are", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00650-00196517-00196781": "associated with that with those uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00651-00196782-00197081": "studies and again these are files so", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00652-00197082-00197333": "there's 63 files associated with these", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00653-00197334-00197483": "21 studies", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00654-00197484-00197711": "and these are files provided by the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00655-00197712-00198011": "project you'll notice that the 63", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00656-00198012-00198304": "divided by 21 is equal to 3 right and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00657-00198305-00198616": "there are three types of files h5ad this", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00658-00198617-00198959": "and data format RDS which sounds totally", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00659-00198960-00199216": "promising but is a bit of a Boondock", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00660-00199217-00199511": "list those are Sera objects and in", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00661-00199512-00199937": "general RDS files are terrible for", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00662-00199938-00200040": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00663-00200041-00200338": "maintaining just because of versioning", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00664-00200339-00200650": "types of issues and cxg is the internal", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00665-00200651-00200878": "Celexa", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00666-00200879-00201245": "celex Gene data format so I'm going to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00667-00201246-00201383": "grab this file", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00668-00201384-00201695": "and instead of visualizing it through", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00669-00201696-00201952": "the browser I'm going to invoke the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00670-00201953-00202193": "browser from R and visualize that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00671-00202194-00202402": "particular data set", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00672-00202403-00202745": "um from R so I", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00673-00202746-00203050": "I evaluated this set of commands and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00674-00203051-00203357": "chose that file and sent it", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00675-00203358-00203416": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00676-00203417-00203723": "to the browser and here's my", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00677-00203724-00203993": "it's my window where'd my window go here", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00678-00203994-00204283": "here's here's that data set here", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00679-00204284-00204593": "colored by a cell type", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00680-00204594-00204844": "but it'd be way cooler to download that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00681-00204846-00204958": "file", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00682-00204959-00205246": "to the local", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00683-00205248-00205510": "my local disk and then do all kinds of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00684-00205511-00205858": "fun things independent of cell X Gene so", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00685-00205859-00206107": "again I'm downloading this file", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00686-00206108-00206488": "from cell extreme to wherever Orchestra", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00687-00206489-00206698": "is running pretty quick because it's", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00688-00206700-00206914": "running in the cloud and now I'm going", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00689-00206915-00207227": "to read it in this is using uh Zell", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00690-00207228-00207473": "converter I'm going to read the h5ad", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00691-00207473-00207784": "file from disk into r", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00692-00207785-00208132": "and then uh have a quick peek at it and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00693-00208133-00208325": "you can see um that it's a single cell", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00694-00208326-00208840": "experiment we've got 33 000 genes and 31", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00695-00208841-00209021": "000 cells", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00696-00209021-00209290": "and then we can just integrate that into", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00697-00209291-00209555": "a standard workflow so trivially what", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00698-00209556-00209875": "I'm going to do is I'm just going to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00699-00209876-00210191": "create a ggplot", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00700-00210192-00210317": "that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00701-00210317-00210671": "is the same as what we generated", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00702-00210671-00211013": "online", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00703-00211014-00211127": "um but of course we've done it", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00704-00211128-00211313": "interactively and so now we have", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00705-00211314-00211463": "complete control", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00706-00211464-00211703": "over uh this object and it fits directly", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00707-00211704-00212105": "into the standard um uh bioconductor", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00708-00212106-00212248": "workflows", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00709-00212250-00212477": "those cell X genes the select Gene", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00710-00212478-00212710": "package turns out to be a wonderful way", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00711-00212711-00212987": "of uh reproducibly retrieving the data", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00712-00212988-00213263": "and then introducing it into into a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00713-00213264-00213473": "workflow that we might be interested in", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00714-00213473-00214475": "doing", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00715-00214476-00214708": "all right I'm going to stop there for a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00716-00214709-00215098": "another second or so", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00717-00215100-00215255": "foreign", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00718-00215256-00215573": "happy to take any questions", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00719-00215573-00215879": "okay", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00720-00215880-00216017": "uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00721-00216017-00216155": "Thanks Martin", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00722-00216156-00216382": "um Leonard Leonardo again so I'm going", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00723-00216383-00216551": "to ask you some questions that I get for", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00724-00216552-00216832": "Recon so two of them are", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00725-00216833-00216923": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00726-00216923-00217127": "um my impression of looking at the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00727-00217128-00217379": "object is you can actually combine the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00728-00217380-00217627": "data across different", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00729-00217628-00218056": "Loom objects or SE objects I saw that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00730-00218057-00218213": "the call data you're using character", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00731-00218214-00218458": "columns instead of factor columns so I'm", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00732-00218459-00218591": "a correcting guessing that you can", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00733-00218592-00218819": "combine all of them together into a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00734-00218819-00219082": "single very large object", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00735-00219083-00219473": "uh yes and in principle you could yeah", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00736-00219473-00219587": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00737-00219588-00219755": "I mean that there's sort of like issues", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00738-00219756-00219923": "of uh batch correction and so on but", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00739-00219923-00220210": "yeah that no no but like just the the C", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00740-00220211-00220391": "Vine part of it before you analyze it", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00741-00220392-00220684": "yeah yeah absolutely and then the second", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00742-00220685-00221032": "one is if I have my own data set can I", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00743-00221033-00221321": "uh process it in a comparable way", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00744-00221321-00221560": "uh to compare against", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00745-00221561-00221932": "um the hea or is that not easy to do I", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00746-00221933-00222221": "don't know yeah yeah that's uh the next", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00747-00222221-00222592": "part of my talk so uh and uh it's great", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00748-00222594-00223132": "I said yeah yeah absolutely", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00749-00223133-00223444": "uh shall I go there", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00750-00223446-00223571": "please", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00751-00223571-00223715": "okay", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00752-00223716-00224069": "yeah so uh Leonardo asked a great uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00753-00224069-00224242": "question and I'll just go back to the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00754-00224244-00224632": "the HCA data portal and uh you'll notice", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00755-00224633-00224848": "that there's this um so we were under", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00756-00224850-00225137": "this explore tab where we had all of the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00757-00225138-00225341": "data sets but then there are these", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00758-00225342-00225521": "Pipelines", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00759-00225521-00225827": "and um the HCA came up with some", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00760-00225828-00226217": "standard analysis uh workflows for", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00761-00226217-00226565": "instance this Optimus workflow", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00762-00226566-00226991": "um for 10x uh V2 and V3 gene expression", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00763-00226992-00227542": "assays and um uh they formalized these", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00764-00227544-00227723": "workflows so this this is the sort of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00765-00227723-00227951": "like the heavy lifting right of um going", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00766-00227952-00228287": "from Fast Q files to account Matrix I", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00767-00228288-00228479": "mean that's a part of the heavy lifting", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00768-00228480-00228658": "anyway anyway that's a that is a heavy", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00769-00228659-00228760": "lift", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00770-00228761-00229001": "um big data to moderate data", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00771-00229002-00229234": "um and they standardized that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00772-00229235-00229571": "transformation the steps from uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00773-00229571-00229979": "from up from the fastq files to um the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00774-00229980-00230219": "expression assays and they've actually", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00775-00230219-00230494": "done a great I you know all things", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00776-00230496-00230705": "considered a great job", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00777-00230706-00230867": "um documenting", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00778-00230867-00231131": "um what they've done and the um process", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00779-00231132-00231479": "has been written as uh a series of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00780-00231480-00231682": "formal workflows", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00781-00231683-00232037": "um in wdl workflow description language", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00782-00232038-00232301": "and you can kind of parse through here", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00783-00232302-00232534": "you can see that it takes a bunch of a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00784-00232535-00232708": "couple of fast queue files it's going to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00785-00232709-00233027": "use the star aligner it's going to do us", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00786-00233028-00233303": "use a particular reference it's got a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00787-00233304-00233531": "you know a version on the pipeline so", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00788-00233532-00233813": "that's really great and this is a formal", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00789-00233814-00233998": "description of the steps that are", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00790-00234000-00234310": "involved including parallel computation", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00791-00234311-00234706": "to transform the fastq files to account", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00792-00234707-00234982": "Matrix so Leonardo you could take your", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00793-00234983-00235241": "data your fastq files from your own", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00794-00235242-00235546": "experiment and apply this pipeline if", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00795-00235548-00235771": "it's you know the appropriate", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00796-00235771-00236158": "data format and uh come up with", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00797-00236159-00236315": "um you know an equivalent starting point", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00798-00236316-00236525": "for your study as for any of the other", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00799-00236526-00236644": "studies", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00800-00236646-00236794": "and I think that's totally amazing", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00801-00236796-00236963": "that's really great", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00802-00236964-00237232": "um reproducible and of course um you", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00803-00237233-00237484": "know you and I can disagree or have", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00804-00237485-00237713": "conversations about the relative merits", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00805-00237714-00237965": "of different um steps in the workflow", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00806-00237966-00238175": "maybe we just disagree with one choice", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00807-00238176-00238325": "of parameters or they should have done", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00808-00238326-00238517": "something else but at least we know what", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00809-00238517-00238792": "we're talking about and that's super", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00810-00238794-00238906": "useful", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00811-00238907-00239146": "um and super exciting", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00812-00239148-00239482": "and then um the other so workflow", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00813-00239483-00239723": "description language Optimus", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00814-00239723-00239992": "um standard analysis pipeline that's", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00815-00239994-00240196": "totally great and then the only thing is", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00816-00240198-00240317": "that you actually need to compute", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00817-00240317-00240592": "resources to run the workflow right so", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00818-00240594-00240773": "it's all all well and good to have a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00819-00240773-00241019": "workflow but if you can't run it then uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00820-00241019-00241331": "then that's uh unfortunate and I just", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00821-00241332-00241456": "wanted to mention", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00822-00241457-00241792": "um the Anvil project which we've been", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00823-00241794-00241948": "involved with", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00824-00241950-00242177": "um which provides us with that type of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00825-00242178-00242448": "resource so I've actually opened an", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00826-00242450-00242825": "anvil anvil.terror.io anvilproject.org", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00827-00242826-00243071": "it's in the it's in the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00828-00243071-00243251": "in the uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00829-00243252-00243634": "the the third uh uh vignette", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00830-00243635-00243929": "um and I've opened a particular um it's", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00831-00243930-00244258": "called a workspace and uh the workspace", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00832-00244259-00244606": "um is uh cloned from something produced", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00833-00244607-00245075": "by the HCA uh that um illustrates how to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00834-00245076-00245237": "use that pipeline that we were just", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00835-00245238-00245537": "looking at to analyze data so you have", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00836-00245538-00246053": "uh data 10 samples with fastq files mice", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00837-00246054-00246196": "and humans so they're sort of like two", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00838-00246198-00246484": "subsets of data and then the idea is", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00839-00246485-00246767": "that you choose the workflow that you're", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00840-00246767-00247187": "interested in", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00841-00247188-00247492": "and uh provide inputs including", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00842-00247494-00247789": "references", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00843-00247790-00248063": "cloud-based references to the fastq", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00844-00248064-00248387": "files so the these fastq files are", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00845-00248388-00248656": "actually in the Google Cloud they're not", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00846-00248657-00248848": "local", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00847-00248850-00249108": "um and therefore access to them is fast", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00848-00249109-00249394": "in the Google cloud and then when you're", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00849-00249396-00249677": "ready you click the Run analysis button", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00850-00249678-00250037": "and it will launch Marshall uh the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00851-00250038-00250217": "compute resources required to run the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00852-00250217-00250558": "workflow run the workflow and produce", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00853-00250559-00250853": "outputs that are available within the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00854-00250854-00251092": "workspace including for instance the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00855-00251094-00251410": "loom file and then you could incorporate", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00856-00251411-00251621": "the loom file into an interactive", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00857-00251621-00251969": "analysis using rstudio", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00858-00251969-00252160": "um so that's really just a very quick", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00859-00252161-00252341": "tour of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00860-00252342-00252605": "um Anvil under connection between the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00861-00252606-00252827": "HCA and these", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00862-00252828-00253151": "um well documented well-defined", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00863-00253152-00253487": "um workflows and the compute resources", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00864-00253488-00253696": "that are provided by Anvil", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00865-00253698-00253871": "um to allow you to do the types of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00866-00253871-00254146": "analyzes where you know like like", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00867-00254148-00254446": "Leonardo said with recount like you", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00868-00254448-00254710": "really like to do the same analysis on a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00869-00254711-00254896": "whole bunch of different data and this", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00870-00254898-00255046": "provides you with a formal way of doing", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00871-00255048-00255292": "that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00872-00255294-00255575": "um so I think actually I'll stop there I", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00873-00255576-00255821": "think I'm at the end of my 45 minutes of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00874-00255821-00256103": "uh of Fame but I'm happy to take any any", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00875-00256104-00256421": "questions or uh delve into more detail", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00876-00256421-00257651": "on any anything I've been talking about", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00877-00257652-00258148": "any questions", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00878-00258150-00258455": "is it on", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00879-00258456-00258725": "takes a little time hi", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00880-00258726-00258929": "um you mentioned something about a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00881-00258930-00259192": "discontinuation of this process can you", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00882-00259194-00259498": "say anything more about that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00883-00259500-00259769": "yeah so there's a slack channel that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00884-00259769-00259973": "human cell Atlas has a slack Channel", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00885-00259973-00260153": "where they announce new data sets that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00886-00260154-00260482": "are added in and I I just noticed uh the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00887-00260483-00260771": "other day last week that uh they were", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00888-00260771-00260987": "adding new data sets but no more Loom", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00889-00260988-00261341": "files and so I uh I asked about that and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00890-00261342-00261725": "that I guess they've decided not to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00891-00261726-00262180": "perform the standard analyzes anymore", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00892-00262181-00262632": "partly because of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00893-00262633-00263056": "I guess the the public explanation was", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00894-00263057-00263506": "that uh uh sort of answer uh lack of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00895-00263507-00263741": "consensus about what the right analysis", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00896-00263742-00263932": "was", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00897-00263933-00264208": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00898-00264209-00264460": "for a particular workflow", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00899-00264461-00264580": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00900-00264581-00264977": "so pretty interesting", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00901-00264978-00266008": "foreign", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00902-00266009-00266249": "I think it'd be great to do the wrong", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00903-00266250-00266495": "the wrong analysis consistently you know", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00904-00266496-00266729": "right tell the same lie", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00905-00266730-00266908": "um yeah that seems like it would be a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00906-00266909-00267041": "little bit more useful to the world than", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00907-00267042-00267277": "not doing anything yeah", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00908-00267278-00267551": "or for each of us doing our own thing", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00909-00267552-00267767": "and telling our own lines this is one of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00910-00267768-00267977": "those situations where even even doing", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00911-00267978-00268103": "the wrong thing might be better than", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00912-00268104-00268505": "doing nothing maybe yeah", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00913-00268506-00268877": "at least learn something yeah", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00914-00268878-00269134": "I guess it opens the door for some for a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00915-00269135-00269579": "project uh for one of us to take up", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00916-00269580-00269884": "I guess", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00917-00269885-00270167": "well one other thing that came up a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00918-00270168-00270515": "little while ago uh with your metadata", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00919-00270516-00270832": "was the list viewer and somehow I think", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00920-00270833-00271103": "that package was not installed", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00921-00271104-00271379": "and I know your list of lists uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00922-00271380-00271567": "structures", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00923-00271568-00271882": "uh also have this reflection in James", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00924-00271883-00272032": "path", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00925-00272033-00272356": "is that something that you think more", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00926-00272357-00272525": "people should understand and take", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00927-00272526-00272669": "advantage of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00928-00272670-00272860": "yeah", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00929-00272861-00272947": "yeah", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00930-00272948-00273215": "uh so I kind of I kind of it's too bad", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00931-00273216-00273491": "that was it is it list it's list viewer", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00932-00273492-00273713": "I think you just need to install it I", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00933-00273714-00273919": "see manager", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00934-00273920-00274217": "this viewer", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00935-00274218-00274541": "yeah so uh list viewer is totally um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00936-00274542-00274775": "amazing", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00937-00274776-00274858": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00938-00274859-00275075": "a way of navigating these complicated", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00939-00275076-00275380": "lists list list list structures", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00940-00275381-00275615": "um what did I have here I think I called", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00941-00275616-00275897": "it", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00942-00275898-00276239": "PL", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00943-00276240-00276755": "IST viewer", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00944-00276756-00277013": "Json edit which seems like an unlikely", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00945-00277014-00277379": "name for a function but um it provides", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00946-00277380-00277589": "so this was this a list of list of lists", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00947-00277590-00277930": "of lists of lists that I um downloaded", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00948-00277931-00278230": "it's taking just a second to open up uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00949-00278231-00278519": "but here's here's the viewer and you can", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00950-00278520-00278753": "see uh you can see that it's really", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00951-00278754-00278932": "straightforward to you know these are", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00952-00278933-00279256": "the 267 different projects and each of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00953-00279257-00279401": "the projects has", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00954-00279402-00279455": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00955-00279456-00279665": "uh a title", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00956-00279666-00279839": "um and you can sort of Imagine", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00957-00279840-00280091": "navigating down uh through that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00958-00280092-00280391": "but there's also a language so that this", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00959-00280392-00280625": "little widget is great um it allows you", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00960-00280626-00280858": "to explore these things", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00961-00280859-00281105": "um in a way that's way better than uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00962-00281106-00281339": "Alternatives but there's also a language", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00963-00281340-00281530": "for making these queries it's called", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00964-00281531-00281860": "James path jmes path which is probably", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00965-00281861-00282113": "like totally familiar to um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00966-00282114-00282425": "to the Java East does out there but you", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00967-00282426-00282791": "can say um hey I want um for all of the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00968-00282792-00283060": "objects I want to find the hits", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00969-00283061-00283463": "that um correspond to uh that have a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00970-00283464-00283613": "object", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00971-00283614-00283763": "um projects", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00972-00283764-00283946": "um let's see what have we got here", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00973-00283947-00284069": "[Music]", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00974-00284070-00284273": "I have to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00975-00284274-00284537": "let's see uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00976-00284538-00284771": "so again I'm going off", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00977-00284772-00285125": "off piece so wait let's see yeah let's", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00978-00285126-00285460": "start this again here so here's our hits", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00979-00285461-00285647": "transform", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00980-00285648-00285929": "hits so all of these hits we want to", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00981-00285930-00286549": "find Project", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00982-00286550-00286906": "titles projects", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00983-00286907-00287123": "there's projects in each project there", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00984-00287124-00287303": "are a bunch of projects", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00985-00287304-00287806": "and each project has a project title", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00986-00287807-00288029": "and those are the sort of queries into", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00987-00288030-00288395": "the look kind of like XML XPath you", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00988-00288396-00288689": "query into the the Json object so this", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00989-00288690-00288899": "is the title of the first project and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00990-00288900-00289121": "the second project and so on so this is", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00991-00289122-00289613": "called uh James bath James path and uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00992-00289614-00289858": "actually the celex gene DB package", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00993-00289859-00290075": "there's a very useful function it should", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00994-00290076-00290393": "be exposed more more broadly", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00995-00290394-00290573": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00996-00290574-00290891": "uh called uh James pack which will allow", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00997-00290892-00291413": "you to query a list object or um a a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00998-00291414-00291797": "uh so these are Json objects the Json", "HDmVw3H4ue8-00999-00291798-00292073": "object uh query it for things like", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01000-00292074-00292384": "project title so providing a very", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01001-00292385-00292613": "convenient way of extracting data from", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01002-00292614-00293080": "these complicated structures", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01003-00293081-00293801": "foreign", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01004-00293802-00294358": "thanks for that quick tutorial Let's uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01005-00294359-00294515": "something we're running into a lot more", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01006-00294516-00294667": "often the Json", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01007-00294668-00294917": "metadata so it's good to have", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01008-00294918-00295145": "yeah yeah I think you introducing the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01009-00295146-00295384": "events to uh this list viewer that's a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01010-00295385-00296255": "really great little tool", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01011-00296256-00296549": "all right I've overspent over overstayed", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01012-00296550-00297106": "my welcome so I'll uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01013-00297107-00297275": "this is a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01014-00297276-00297341": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01015-00297342-00297527": "the Leo again sorry", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01016-00297528-00297701": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01017-00297702-00297982": "like looking at the metadata of your um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01018-00297983-00298151": "any of your objects", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01019-00298152-00298319": "um I see that there's a lot of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01020-00298320-00298619": "information there but um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01021-00298620-00298691": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01022-00298692-00298960": "and I saw the Optimus", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01023-00298961-00299027": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01024-00299028-00299273": "documentation lists like what version of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01025-00299274-00299447": "gen code was used for example what", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01026-00299448-00299710": "version of The genome reference was used", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01027-00299711-00299945": "um I know that I saw that that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01028-00299946-00300197": "information is missing from the metadata", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01029-00300198-00300256": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01030-00300257-00300665": "so maybe that's a an area that could uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01031-00300666-00300841": "or Improvement there", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01032-00300842-00301163": "based on what Mike love has worked on", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01033-00301164-00301415": "right like sometimes finding The", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01034-00301416-00301553": "annotation of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01035-00301554-00301865": "of a file is really complicated", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01036-00301866-00301925": "um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01037-00301926-00302219": "but the other thing is like I see that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01038-00302220-00302506": "my guess is that every single study is", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01039-00302507-00302806": "only available in one version of Optimus", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01040-00302807-00303005": "um or is", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01041-00303006-00303329": "or are there duplicated studies and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01042-00303330-00303508": "I mean can we just mentioned that maybe", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01043-00303509-00303737": "they're deprecating some of this but uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01044-00303738-00303958": "with the new version of The genome are", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01045-00303959-00304108": "you gonna have to redo all of this with", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01046-00304109-00304313": "like a new version of it", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01047-00304314-00304456": "because that's going to change all the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01048-00304457-00304721": "coordinates and all of that yeah", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01049-00304722-00305032": "yeah absolutely so um", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01050-00305033-00305345": "yeah you're right that uh that these", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01051-00305346-00305632": "were run there's only one loom file at", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01052-00305633-00305915": "most one loom file one", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01053-00305916-00306191": "one uh actually the loom files are", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01054-00306192-00306377": "generated on individual samples and then", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01055-00306378-00306617": "the samples are aggregated into a loom", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01056-00306618-00306815": "file that represents the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01057-00306816-00307079": "collection of samples within a within a", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01058-00307080-00307217": "data set", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01059-00307218-00307439": "um so but there's only one loom file per", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01060-00307440-00307630": "data set and there's a particular", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01061-00307631-00307823": "version of the Optimus pipeline that was", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01062-00307824-00308141": "used to generate that and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01063-00308142-00308410": "um and that also implies a particular", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01064-00308411-00308579": "reference genome", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01065-00308580-00308747": "um I'm not sure that the reference", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01066-00308748-00309089": "genome is actually referenced", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01067-00309090-00309413": "um here it could be uh could be that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01068-00309414-00309617": "we've lost some of that in", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01069-00309618-00309773": "in the", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01070-00309774-00310469": "provenance of the object", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01071-00310470-00310693": "foreign", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01072-00310694-00310913": "thank you for sharing with us this was", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01073-00310914-00311153": "great", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01074-00311154-00311315": "my pleasure I always learn something", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01075-00311316-00311554": "when you when you teach so still still", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01076-00311555-00311723": "going on", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01077-00311724-00312010": "years and years later", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01078-00312011-00312227": "that's good I'm glad I haven't uh", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01079-00312228-00312413": "graduated to the negative learning Camp", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01080-00312414-00312641": "of teaching", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01081-00312642-00312815": "so I think this is the last session of", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01082-00312816-00313037": "the day so I'm going to wrap it up and", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01083-00313038-00313187": "um I want to remind everybody that", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01084-00313188-00313510": "tomorrow we're starting up here rather", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01085-00313511-00313715": "than in the building here so be sure not", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01086-00313716-00313901": "to go over there tomorrow", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01087-00313902-00314039": "coming here", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01088-00314040-00314225": "and thanks again Martin that was", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01089-00314226-00314339": "terrific", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01090-00314340-00314584": "thank you any verifies", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01091-00314585-00314951": "[Applause]", "HDmVw3H4ue8-01092-00314952-00315326": "give you some digital Applause too"}}, {"audio_id": "HDn5Uig7RfM", "text": {"HDn5Uig7RfM-00000-00000988-00001254": "welcome to this activity summary of", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00001-00001255-00001454": "blood-stained evidence documentation", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00002-00001455-00001726": "this learning activity as a summary of", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00003-00001727-00001935": "the critical steps described in detail", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00004-00001936-00002124": "in an earlier learning activity", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00005-00002125-00002340": "documentation of blood stain evidence", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00006-00002341-00002620": "the purpose of all documentation is to", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00007-00002621-00002835": "allow for outside analysis without", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00008-00002836-00003076": "proper documentation court appearances", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00009-00003077-00003244": "and subsequent verdicts will be", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00010-00003245-00003511": "challenged", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00011-00003512-00003718": "five recording methods need to be used", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00012-00003719-00003877": "to preserve blood-stained evidence", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00013-00003878-00004009": "during an investigation", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00014-00004010-00004291": "they are note-taking sketching", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00015-00004292-00004600": "photography videotaping and report", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00016-00004601-00005009": "writing", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00017-00005010-00005141": "in blood-stained patterns is to", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00018-00005142-00005345": "accurately show the evidence as it was", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00019-00005346-00005564": "initially found", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00020-00005565-00005792": "note-taking provides general information", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00021-00005793-00006051": "notes supplement or complement", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00022-00006052-00006308": "photographs they do not replace them", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00023-00006309-00006558": "sketches and diagrams show the overall", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00024-00006559-00006801": "layout of a scene photographs of", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00025-00006802-00006966": "bloodstains need to be taken before", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00026-00006967-00007211": "evidence is altered or collected a", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00027-00007212-00007458": "videotaping provides an overlap for", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00028-00007459-00007692": "photographs and may document information", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00029-00007693-00008105": "that was missed in the photos", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00030-00008106-00008249": "best ways to document blood-stained", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00031-00008250-00008449": "patterns is through photography all", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00032-00008450-00008609": "blood-stained patterns need to be", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00033-00008610-00008855": "photographed showing overall medium", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00034-00008856-00009212": "close-up and specific views enough", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00035-00009213-00009395": "photographs should be taken for a third", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00036-00009396-00009608": "party to understand and comprehend the", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00037-00009609-00009796": "patterns and their association to the", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00038-00009797-00010187": "scene and the persons involved", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00039-00010188-00010427": "when documenting blood stain evidence it", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00040-00010428-00010624": "is important to use criminologist Toby", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00041-00010625-00010787": "Wilson's Road mapping method or a", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00042-00010788-00011099": "similar procedure Road mapping uses", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00043-00011100-00011314": "photographs along with labels and scales", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00044-00011315-00011488": "for reference so the viewer is never", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00045-00011489-00011753": "lost it allows others to properly", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00046-00011754-00011918": "analyze blood stain patterns without", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00047-00011919-00012145": "ever being present at the scene", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00048-00012146-00012344": "investigators must complete processing", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00049-00012345-00012512": "of the scene before Road mapping blood", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00050-00012513-00012734": "stain patterns because documenting blood", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00051-00012735-00012893": "stain evidence can be an intrusive", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00052-00012894-00013136": "process that can destroy other evidence", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00053-00013137-00013637": "in the vicinity", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00054-00013638-00013886": "roadmapping is an integral part of scene", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00055-00013887-00014111": "documentation and provides an accurate", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00056-00014112-00014303": "representation of blood-shedding events", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00057-00014304-00014561": "each blood stain pattern is identified", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00058-00014562-00014801": "with a label a letter or number is", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00059-00014802-00015035": "placed by each stain and a scale as", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00060-00015036-00015275": "adjacent to each different pattern once", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00061-00015276-00015431": "all labels and other road signs are in", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00062-00015432-00015704": "place overall medium and close-up", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00063-00015705-00015902": "photographs are taken of each different", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00064-00015903-00016191": "pattern", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00065-00016191-00016377": "roadmapping takes the analyst from an", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00066-00016378-00016566": "overall view of the blood stain to the", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00067-00016567-00016764": "pattern and finally to an individual", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00068-00016765-00017043": "stain here are a few rules to follow", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00069-00017044-00017322": "when creating a road map choose stains", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00070-00017323-00017607": "that show directionality use smaller", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00071-00017608-00017913": "stains rather than larger stains finally", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00072-00017914-00018102": "select eight to twelve stains for a", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00073-00018103-00018565": "proper reconstruction", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00074-00018566-00018784": "the final report is the reference tool", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00075-00018785-00018955": "that can be used years after an", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00076-00018956-00019234": "investigation it displays the collective", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00077-00019235-00019381": "wealth of information and results", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00078-00019382-00019585": "gathered from analysis performed on the", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00079-00019586-00019843": "evidence all documentation should be", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00080-00019844-00020092": "written as concisely completely and", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00081-00020093-00020362": "objectively as possible no matter how", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00082-00020363-00020566": "well-intentioned an investigation may be", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00083-00020567-00020764": "in the end it will be judged on the", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00084-00020765-00021077": "analysts documentation", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00085-00021078-00021251": "congratulations you have completed this", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00086-00021252-00021488": "activity summary of blood stain evidence", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00087-00021489-00022317": "documentation", "HDn5Uig7RfM-00088-00022318-00022523": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "HDvPM9oiLuI", "text": {"HDvPM9oiLuI-00000-00000046-00000335": "physics outreach encompasses facets of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00001-00000336-00000559": "science outreach and physics education", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00002-00000560-00000776": "and is an umbrella term for a variety of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00003-00000777-00000989": "activities by schools research", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00004-00000990-00001262": "institutes universities clubs and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00005-00001263-00001490": "institutions such as science museums", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00006-00001491-00001684": "aimed at broadening the audience for an", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00007-00001685-00001912": "awareness and understanding of physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00008-00001913-00002195": "while the general public may sometimes", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00009-00002196-00002447": "be the focus of such activities physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00010-00002448-00002675": "outreach often centers on developing and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00011-00002676-00002835": "providing resources and making", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00012-00002836-00003118": "presentations to students educators in", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00013-00003119-00003304": "other disciplines and in some cases", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00014-00003305-00003529": "researchers within different areas of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00015-00003530-00004118": "physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00016-00004119-00004656": "topic history", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00017-00004657-00004875": "ongoing efforts to expand the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00018-00004876-00005064": "understanding of physics to a wider", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00019-00005065-00005262": "audience have been undertaken by", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00020-00005263-00005499": "individuals and institutions since the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00021-00005500-00005871": "early 19th century historic works such", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00022-00005872-00006084": "as the dialogue concerning the two chief", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00023-00006085-00006342": "world-systems and two new sciences by", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00024-00006343-00006543": "Galileo Galilei sought to present", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00025-00006544-00006738": "revolutionary knowledge in astronomy", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00026-00006739-00007023": "frames of reference and kinematics in a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00027-00007023-00007194": "manner that a general audience could", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00028-00007195-00007530": "understand with great effect in the mid", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00029-00007531-00007781": "1800s English physicist and chemist", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00030-00007783-00008073": "Michael Faraday gave a series of 19", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00031-00008073-00008289": "lectures aimed towards young adults with", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00032-00008290-00008474": "the hopes of conveying scientific", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00033-00008475-00008763": "phenomena his intentions were to raise", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00034-00008764-00008979": "awareness inspire them and generate", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00035-00008980-00009291": "revenue of the Royal Institution this", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00036-00009292-00009477": "series became known as the Christmas", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00037-00009478-00009828": "lectures and still continues today by", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00038-00009829-00010062": "the early 20th century the public", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00039-00010063-00010296": "notoriety of physicists such as Albert", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00040-00010297-00010542": "Einstein and Marie Curie and inventions", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00041-00010543-00010758": "such as radio led to a growing interest", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00042-00010759-00011193": "in physics in 1921 in the United States", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00043-00011194-00011403": "the establishment of Sigma Pi Sigma", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00044-00011404-00011673": "Physics Honor Society at universities", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00045-00011674-00011898": "was instrumental in the expanding number", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00046-00011899-00012123": "of physics presentations and led to the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00047-00012124-00012336": "creation of physics clubs open to all", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00048-00012337-00012594": "students museums were an important form", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00049-00012595-00012795": "of outreach but most early science", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00050-00012796-00012987": "museums were generally focused on", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00051-00012988-00013344": "Natural History some specialized museums", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00052-00013344-00013550": "such as the Cavendish Museum at", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00053-00013551-00013791": "University of Cambridge housed many of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00054-00013791-00013980": "the historically important pieces of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00055-00013981-00014199": "apparatus that contributed to the major", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00056-00014200-00014421": "discoveries by Maxwell Thomson", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00057-00014422-00014775": "Rutherford etc however such venues", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00058-00014776-00015015": "provided little opportunity for hands-on", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00059-00015016-00015397": "learning or demonstrations in August", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00060-00015398-00015756": "1969 Frank Oppenheimer dedicated his new", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00061-00015757-00016035": "Exploratorium in San Francisco primarily", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00062-00016036-00016247": "to interactive science exhibits that", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00063-00016248-00016572": "demonstrated principles in physics the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00064-00016573-00016806": "Exploratorium published the details of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00065-00016807-00017010": "their own exhibits in cookbooks that", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00066-00017011-00017219": "served as an inspiration to many other", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00067-00017220-00017447": "museums around the world and since then", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00068-00017448-00017669": "has diversified into many outreach", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00069-00017670-00017771": "programs", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00070-00017772-00018072": "Oppenheimer had researched Europeans", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00071-00018073-00018282": "Science Museum's while on a Guggenheim", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00072-00018283-00018699": "Fellowship in 1965 he noted that three", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00073-00018700-00018942": "museums served as important influences", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00074-00018943-00019167": "on the Exploratorium the palais de la", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00075-00019168-00019389": "découverte which displayed models to", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00076-00019390-00019614": "teach scientific concepts and employed", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00077-00019615-00019857": "students as demonstrators a practice", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00078-00019858-00020091": "that directly inspired the Exploratorium", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00079-00020092-00020303": "much-lauded high school explain the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00080-00020304-00020544": "program the South Kensington Museum of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00081-00020545-00020763": "Science and art which Oppenheimer and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00082-00020764-00020961": "his wife visited frequently and the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00083-00020962-00021183": "Deutsche's Museum in Munich the world's", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00084-00021184-00021390": "largest science museum which had a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00085-00021391-00021588": "number of interactive displays that", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00086-00021589-00021758": "impressed the Oppenheimer's in the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00087-00021759-00021972": "ensuing years physics outreach and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00088-00021973-00022143": "science outreach more generally", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00089-00022144-00022347": "continued to expand and took on new", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00090-00022348-00022553": "popular forms including highly", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00091-00022554-00022758": "successful television shows such as", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00092-00022759-00023061": "cosmos a personal voyage first broadcast", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00093-00023062-00023475": "in 1980 as a form of outreach within the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00094-00023476-00023718": "physics education community for teachers", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00095-00023719-00024053": "and students in 1997 the US National", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00096-00024054-00024344": "Science Foundation NSF and department of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00097-00024345-00024615": "energy USDOE established coordinate a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00098-00024616-00024849": "professional teacher development program", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00099-00024850-00025227": "in 2012 the University of not Redang", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00100-00025228-00025530": "received a 6.1 million dollars five-year", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00101-00025531-00025769": "grant to support a nationwide expansion", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00102-00025770-00026193": "of the quad net program also in 1997 the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00103-00026194-00026430": "European particle physics outreach group", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00104-00026431-00026700": "led by Christopher Llewellyn Smith FRS", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00105-00026701-00026949": "and director general of CERN was formed", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00106-00026950-00027146": "to create a community of scientists", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00107-00027147-00027417": "science educators and communication", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00108-00027418-00027651": "specialists in science education and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00109-00027652-00027881": "public outreach for particle physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00110-00027882-00028149": "this group became the international", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00111-00028150-00028340": "particle physics outreach group", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00112-00028341-00028692": "IPP OG in 2011 after the start-up of the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00113-00028693-00029108": "LHC topic innovation many contemporary", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00114-00029109-00029304": "initiatives in physics outreach have", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00115-00029305-00029523": "begun to shift focus transcending", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00116-00029524-00029760": "traditional field boundaries seeking to", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00117-00029761-00029949": "engage students and the public by", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00118-00029950-00030174": "integrating elements of aesthetic design", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00119-00030175-00030450": "and popular culture the goal has been", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00120-00030451-00030665": "not only to push physics out of a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00121-00030666-00030918": "strictly science education framework but", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00122-00030919-00031121": "also to draw in professionals and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00123-00031122-00031314": "students from other fields to bring", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00124-00031314-00031443": "their perspectives on", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00125-00031444-00031739": "physical phenomena such work includes", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00126-00031741-00031950": "artists creating sculptures using", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00127-00031951-00032195": "ferrofluids and art photography using", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00128-00032197-00032388": "high speed and ultra-high speed", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00129-00032389-00032667": "photography other efforts such as", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00130-00032668-00032907": "university of Cambridge's physics at", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00131-00032908-00033153": "work program have created annual events", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00132-00033154-00033375": "to demonstrate to secondary students", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00133-00033376-00033600": "uses of physics in everyday life and a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00134-00033601-00033894": "senior physics challenge seeing the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00135-00033895-00034119": "importance these initiatives Cambridge", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00136-00034120-00034320": "has established a full-time physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00137-00034321-00034560": "outreach organization an educational", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00138-00034561-00034797": "outreach office and aspirations for a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00139-00034798-00034980": "center of physics and expanded", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00140-00034981-00035157": "industrial partnerships that would", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00141-00035158-00035319": "include a well-equipped core team of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00142-00035320-00035520": "outreach offices dedicated to", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00143-00035521-00035745": "demonstrating the real-life applications", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00144-00035746-00035955": "of physics showing that physics is an", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00145-00035956-00036168": "accessible and relevant subject the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00146-00036169-00036411": "French research group lef Izzy Coromant", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00147-00036412-00036651": "physics reimagined of the laboratory a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00148-00036652-00036882": "physique des Sala DS works on research", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00149-00036883-00037074": "about new ways to present modern", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00150-00037075-00037287": "solid-state physics and to engage the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00151-00037288-00037653": "general public in 2013 physics today", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00152-00037654-00037836": "covered this group in an article", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00153-00037837-00038055": "entitled quantum physics for everyone", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00154-00038056-00038268": "one which discussed how with the help of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00155-00038269-00038417": "designers and unconventional", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00156-00038418-00038652": "demonstrations the project sought out", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00157-00038653-00038883": "and succeeded to engage people who never", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00158-00038884-00039081": "thought of themselves as interested in", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00159-00039082-00039265": "science the science and entertainment", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00160-00039266-00039543": "exchange was developed by the United", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00161-00039544-00039801": "States National Academy of Sciences NARS", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00162-00039802-00040023": "to increase public awareness knowledge", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00163-00040024-00040233": "and understanding of science and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00164-00040234-00040443": "advanced science technology through its", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00165-00040444-00040680": "representation in television film and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00166-00040681-00041001": "other media it was officially launched", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00167-00041002-00041262": "in 2008 as a partnership between the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00168-00041263-00041571": "NARS and Hollywood the exchanged is", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00169-00041572-00042281": "based in Los Angeles California", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00170-00042282-00042605": "topic museums and public venues", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00171-00042606-00043242": "primarily focused on physical phenomena", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00172-00043243-00043605": "you", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00173-00043606-00044310": "topic Canada Montreal Science Centre", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00174-00044311-00044601": "Montreal Quebec displays many hands-on", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00175-00044602-00044826": "activities involving various physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00176-00044827-00045386": "phenomena", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00177-00045387-00045904": "topic Finland", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00178-00045905-00046243": "Heureka Helsinki is an NPO science", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00179-00046244-00046474": "center run by the Finnish Science Centre", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00180-00046475-00046671": "foundation with a broad spectrum of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00181-00046672-00047334": "physics related exhibits", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00182-00047335-00048069": "topic France seat des Sciences a de", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00183-00048070-00048324": "l'industrie Paris is the largest French", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00184-00048325-00048573": "science museum and contains permanent", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00185-00048574-00048942": "exhibits and hands-on experiments palais", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00186-00048943-00049179": "de la découverte paris contains", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00187-00049180-00049389": "permanent exhibits and interactive", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00188-00049390-00049587": "experiments with commentaries by", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00189-00049588-00049854": "lecturers it includes a Zeiss", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00190-00049855-00050175": "planetarium with 15 meter dome it was", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00191-00050176-00050505": "created in 1937 by the French Nobel", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00192-00050506-00050807": "Prize physicist Jean Baptiste Perrin", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00193-00050808-00051186": "musee des Arts a Matias Paris focuses on", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00194-00051187-00051360": "the preservation of scientific", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00195-00051361-00051726": "instruments and inventions other science", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00196-00051727-00051929": "museums that are part of the cultural", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00197-00051930-00052133": "center of science technology and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00198-00052134-00052492": "Industry CC STI exist all across France", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00199-00052494-00052800": "asbestos Sciences Rennes low casemate", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00200-00052801-00053591": "Grenoble the seat de l'espace to lose", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00201-00053591-00054103": "topic Germany", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00202-00054104-00054361": "deutsche snooze IAM munich is the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00203-00054362-00054640": "world's largest science museum one of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00204-00054641-00054807": "the most popular events is the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00205-00054808-00055038": "high-voltage demonstration of a Faraday", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00206-00055039-00055281": "cage as part of the series on electric", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00207-00055282-00055827": "power", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00208-00055828-00056461": "topic Islamic Republic of Iran", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00209-00056462-00056703": "Iran Science and Technology Museum", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00210-00056704-00057019": "Tehran is the largest science museum in", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00211-00057020-00057361": "Iran this museum by holding varied", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00212-00057362-00057583": "scientific and educational programs", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00213-00057584-00057820": "provides the required situation for", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00214-00057821-00058054": "creation and propagation of scientific", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00215-00058054-00058329": "thought in the society one of these", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00216-00058330-00058983": "programs is the physics show", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00217-00058984-00059521": "topic Netherlands", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00218-00059522-00059829": "Nimmo Amsterdam is the largest Science", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00219-00059830-00060030": "Centre in the Netherlands with hands-on", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00220-00060031-00060687": "science exhibitions", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00221-00060688-00061322": "topic United States", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00222-00061323-00061604": "Exploratorium San Francisco is one of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00223-00061605-00061833": "the United States for most interactive", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00224-00061834-00062070": "science and art museums dedicated to", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00225-00062071-00062253": "exploring how the world works and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00226-00062254-00062459": "consists of interactive exhibits", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00227-00062460-00062825": "experiences and curious exploration the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00228-00062826-00063179": "Exploratorium was opened in 1969 and now", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00229-00063180-00063357": "attracts over a million visitors", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00230-00063358-00063690": "annually the American Museum of Natural", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00231-00063691-00063945": "History in New York City is both a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00232-00063946-00064239": "museum and a research facility as a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00233-00064240-00064500": "museum it focuses on educating the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00234-00064501-00064698": "public in the sciences and has many", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00235-00064699-00064911": "interactive programs and lectures all", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00236-00064912-00065502": "year round", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00237-00065503-00065853": "topic scientific institutions and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00238-00065854-00066504": "societies with physics outreach programs", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00239-00066505-00066870": "you", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00240-00066871-00067545": "topic Canada Perimeter Institute for", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00241-00067546-00067845": "Theoretical Physics was founded in 1999", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00242-00067846-00068190": "in Waterloo Ontario Canada the Institute", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00243-00068191-00068376": "is a center for scientific research", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00244-00068377-00068625": "training and educational outreach in", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00245-00068626-00068976": "theoretical physics located in Vancouver", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00246-00068977-00069342": "British Columbia T RI u M F is Canada's", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00247-00069343-00069549": "national laboratory for particle and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00248-00069550-00069762": "nuclear physics and accelerator based", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00249-00069763-00070062": "science in addition to its science", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00250-00070063-00070278": "mission the laboratory is committed to", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00251-00070279-00070494": "physics outreach offering public tours", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00252-00070495-00070722": "of its facilities public talks an", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00253-00070723-00070962": "artist-in-residence program student", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00254-00070963-00071331": "fellowships and other opportunities the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00255-00071332-00071604": "Canadian Association of physicists cap", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00256-00071605-00071874": "or in French Association Canadian des", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00257-00071875-00072141": "physicians a physician's ACP is a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00258-00072142-00072366": "Canadian professional society that", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00259-00072367-00072591": "focuses on creating awareness amongst", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00260-00072592-00072822": "Canadians and Canadian legislators of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00261-00072823-00073029": "physics issues sponsoring physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00262-00073030-00073134": "related events", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00263-00073135-00073365": "physics outreach and publishes physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00264-00073366-00073940": "in Canada", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00265-00073941-00074471": "topic France", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00266-00074472-00074771": "French physics society has a specific", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00267-00074772-00074956": "section devoted to outreach and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00268-00074957-00075349": "popularization of science the European", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00269-00075350-00075661": "Physical Society EPS is based in France", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00270-00075662-00075866": "but works to promote physics and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00271-00075867-00076501": "physicists in Europe", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00272-00076502-00077019": "topic Germany", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00273-00077020-00077343": "Deutsche Physik Alicia gazelle shaft DPG", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00274-00077344-00077612": "German physical society is the world's", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00275-00077613-00077957": "largest organization of physicists the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00276-00077958-00078204": "DPG actively participates in", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00277-00078205-00078413": "communication between physics and the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00278-00078414-00078621": "general public with several popular", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00279-00078622-00078867": "scientific publications and events such", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00280-00078868-00079200": "as their highlights of physics which is", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00281-00079201-00079412": "an annual physics festival organized", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00282-00079413-00079650": "jointly by the DPG in the federal", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00283-00079651-00079971": "ministry of education and research this", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00284-00079972-00080211": "festival is the largest of its kind in", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00285-00080212-00080456": "Germany and attracts about 30,000", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00286-00080457-00081076": "visitors every year", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00287-00081077-00081661": "topic united kingdom", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00288-00081662-00081931": "Institute of Physics is an international", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00289-00081932-00082130": "charitable institution that aims to", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00290-00082131-00082387": "advance physics education research and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00291-00082388-00082981": "application", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00292-00082982-00083571": "topic United States", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00293-00083572-00083797": "American Association for the Advancement", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00294-00083798-00084214": "of science American Association of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00295-00084215-00084553": "physics teachers American Institute of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00296-00084554-00084676": "Physics AIP", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00297-00084677-00084889": "has an outreach program focused on", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00298-00084890-00085126": "advocating science policy to the US", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00299-00085127-00085483": "Congress in the general public American", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00300-00085484-00085780": "Physical Society ApS has a program", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00301-00085781-00086044": "dedicated to communicating the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00302-00086045-00086311": "excitement and importance of physics to", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00303-00086312-00086716": "everyone the International Society for", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00304-00086717-00087001": "the Arts science and technology Leonardo", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00305-00087002-00087325": "is ast is a nonprofit organization that", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00306-00087326-00087496": "serves the global network of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00307-00087497-00087687": "distinguished scholars artists", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00308-00087688-00088051": "scientists researchers and thinkers the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00309-00088052-00088264": "institution focuses on interdisciplinary", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00310-00088265-00088618": "work creative output and innovation the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00311-00088619-00088861": "leonardo journal is published by MIT", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00312-00088862-00089481": "press", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00313-00089482-00090087": "topic media and Internet", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00314-00090088-00090454": "you", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00315-00090455-00090956": "topic media", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00316-00090957-00091217": "Big Bang Theory is an American sitcom", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00317-00091218-00091559": "created in 2007 and revolves around the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00318-00091560-00091787": "lives of scientists at the California", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00319-00091788-00092114": "Institute of Technology this show has", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00320-00092115-00092327": "been widely recognized for popularizing", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00321-00092328-00092591": "science and noted by the New York Times", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00322-00092592-00092911": "as helping physics and fiction collide", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00323-00092912-00093287": "in 2014 the program was the most popular", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00324-00093288-00093524": "sitcom and most popular non sports", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00325-00093525-00093758": "program on American TV with an average", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00326-00093759-00094028": "of 20 million viewers however the show", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00327-00094029-00094220": "has been criticized for sometimes", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00328-00094221-00094427": "portraying the scientific community", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00329-00094428-00094781": "inaccurately say pass or seer is a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00330-00094782-00095024": "French educational television program", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00331-00095025-00095269": "that originally aired from November 5th", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00332-00095270-00095663": "1994 to present 20 shows dealt with", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00333-00095664-00095933": "astronomy and space topics and 13 about", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00334-00095934-00096317": "physics particle fever is a 2013", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00335-00096318-00096542": "documentary film that provides an", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00336-00096543-00096719": "intimate and accessible view of the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00337-00096720-00096908": "first experiments at the Large Hadron", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00338-00096909-00097121": "Collider from the perspectives of the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00339-00097122-00097370": "experimental physicists at CERN who run", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00340-00097371-00097538": "the experiments as well as the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00341-00097539-00097739": "theoretical physicists who attempt to", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00342-00097740-00097961": "provide a conceptual framework for the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00343-00097962-00098327": "LHC's results reviewers praised the film", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00344-00098328-00098546": "for making theoretical arguments seem", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00345-00098547-00098770": "comprehensible for making scientific", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00346-00098771-00098984": "experiments seem thrilling and for", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00347-00098985-00099271": "making particle physicists seem human", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00348-00099272-00099524": "through the wormhole is an American", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00349-00099525-00099724": "science documentary television series", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00350-00099725-00099974": "narrated and hosted by American actor", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00351-00099975-00100163": "Morgan Freeman and has featured", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00352-00100164-00100376": "physicists such as such as Michio Kaku", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00353-00100377-00101090": "and Brian Cox physicist", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00354-00101091-00101611": "topic internet", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00355-00101612-00101826": "minitor physics is a series of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00356-00101827-00102093": "educational videos created by Henry", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00357-00102094-00102271": "Reich and disseminated through its", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00358-00102272-00102589": "YouTube channel it displays a series of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00359-00102590-00102855": "pedagogical short videos about various", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00360-00102856-00103201": "physics phenomena and theories physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00361-00103202-00103450": "world publication run by the institute", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00362-00103451-00103699": "of physics started explaining scientific", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00363-00103700-00103947": "concepts through its youtube channel", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00364-00103948-00104251": "universe science TV is a french channel", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00365-00104252-00104457": "hosted by universe science which", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00366-00104458-00104652": "displays various interviews about", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00367-00104653-00104973": "science and more especially physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00368-00104974-00105247": "uniseal you tube channel is a series of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00369-00105248-00105489": "French educational videos created by", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00370-00105490-00105888": "French universities veritasium is a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00371-00105889-00106152": "series of educational videos created by", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00372-00106153-00106369": "Derek Muller and disseminated through", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00373-00106370-00106699": "its YouTube channel it displays a series", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00374-00106700-00106906": "of pedagogical short videos about", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00375-00106907-00107631": "science including physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00376-00107632-00108267": "topic prominent individuals", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00377-00108268-00108632": "you", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00378-00108633-00109138": "topic Austria", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00379-00109139-00109366": "Fritjof Capra is an austrian-born", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00380-00109367-00109603": "American physicist who attended the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00381-00109604-00109825": "University of Vienna where he earned his", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00382-00109826-00110311": "PhD in theoretical physics in 1966 he is", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00383-00110312-00110503": "a founding director of the center for", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00384-00110504-00110770": "eco literacy in Berkeley California and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00385-00110771-00111036": "is on the faculty of Schumacher College", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00386-00111037-00111286": "Capra is the author of several books", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00387-00111287-00111661": "including the tower physics 1975 and has", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00388-00111662-00112399": "also done research in Paris and London", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00389-00112400-00112928": "topic France", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00390-00112929-00113153": "Camille Flammarion was a French", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00391-00113154-00113354": "astronomer author of many popular", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00392-00113355-00113723": "science books Etienne Klein is a French", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00393-00113724-00113891": "physicist and philosopher of science", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00394-00113892-00114128": "involved in outreach efforts about", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00395-00114129-00114479": "particle and quantum physics roland", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00396-00114480-00114725": "Lihue is a french astrophysicist known", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00397-00114726-00114932": "for his outreach efforts especially in", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00398-00114933-00115139": "relationship with fiction and science", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00399-00115140-00115264": "fiction", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00400-00115265-00115528": "Hubert Reeves is a french-canadian", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00401-00115529-00115754": "astrophysicist and popularizer of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00402-00115755-00116292": "science", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00403-00116293-00117066": "topic United Kingdom Brian Cox physicist", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00404-00117067-00117318": "is a British physicist and musician best", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00405-00117319-00117509": "known to the public as the presenter of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00406-00117510-00117714": "a number of science programmes for the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00407-00117715-00118143": "BBC when DJ Sadler promotes science and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00408-00118144-00118338": "engineering as part of popular culture", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00409-00118339-00118578": "creating science made simple an", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00410-00118579-00118818": "educational spin-off company of Cardiff", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00411-00118819-00119049": "University that has reached over half a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00412-00119050-00119190": "million students through live", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00413-00119191-00119315": "presentations", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00414-00119316-00119609": "she also trains scientists and engineers", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00415-00119610-00119880": "to improve their communication skills to", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00416-00119881-00120078": "enable them to extend their research", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00417-00120079-00120426": "across a broader audience Sadler was the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00418-00120427-00120659": "IOP young professional physicist of the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00419-00120660-00121083": "year in 2005 Robert Matthews is a fellow", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00420-00121083-00121308": "of the Royal statistical society a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00421-00121308-00121515": "chartered physicist a member of the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00422-00121516-00121736": "institute of physics and a fellow of the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00423-00121738-00122100": "Royal Astronomical Society Matthews is a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00424-00122101-00122307": "distinguished science journalist", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00425-00122308-00122529": "he is currently anchorman for the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00426-00122530-00122802": "science magazine BBC focus and a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00427-00122803-00123015": "freelance columnist for the Financial", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00428-00123016-00123359": "Times in the past he has been science", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00429-00123360-00123770": "correspondent for The Sunday Telegraph", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00430-00123771-00124077": "topic united states richard fineman was", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00431-00124078-00124347": "a Nobel Prize theoretical physicist also", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00432-00124348-00124605": "known as a science popularizers books", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00433-00124606-00124800": "and lectures ranging from physics topics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00434-00124801-00125086": "quantum physics nano physics to", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00435-00125088-00125424": "autobiographical essays George Gamow was", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00436-00125425-00125607": "a theoretical physicist and cosmologist", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00437-00125608-00125904": "who also wrote popular books on science", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00438-00125905-00126096": "some of which is still in print more", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00439-00126097-00126318": "than a half-century after their original", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00440-00126319-00126495": "publication Brian Greene is a", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00441-00126496-00126702": "theoretical physicist involved in", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00442-00126703-00126963": "various outreach activities books TV", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00443-00126964-00127283": "shows he co-founded the World Science", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00444-00127284-00127709": "Festival in 2008 clifford victor johnson", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00445-00127710-00127938": "is a theoretical physicist involved in", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00446-00127939-00128208": "various outreach activities blog TV", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00447-00128208-00128532": "shows Michio Kaku is a theoretical", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00448-00128533-00128754": "physicist who is a futurist and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00449-00128755-00129032": "communicator and popularizer of physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00450-00129033-00129330": "he is most well known for his 3 New York", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00451-00129331-00129608": "Times bestsellers on physics physics of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00452-00129609-00129685": "the impossible", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00453-00129686-00130050": "2008 physics of the future 2011 and the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00454-00130051-00130409": "future of the mind 2014 Lawrence M", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00455-00130410-00130572": "Krauss is an American theoretical", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00456-00130573-00130821": "physicist and cosmologist who is", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00457-00130822-00131004": "foundation professor of the school of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00458-00131005-00131247": "Earth and space exploration at Arizona", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00459-00131248-00131460": "State University and is known as an", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00460-00131461-00131667": "advocate of the public understanding of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00461-00131668-00131928": "science of public policy based on sound", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00462-00131929-00132189": "empirical data of scientific skepticism", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00463-00132190-00132438": "and of science education and works to", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00464-00132439-00132648": "reduce the impact of superstition and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00465-00132649-00132872": "religious dogma in pop culture", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00466-00132873-00133137": "Jennifer willette is the former director", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00467-00133138-00133302": "of the science and entertainment", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00468-00133303-00133524": "exchange an initiative of the National", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00469-00133525-00133782": "Academy of Sciences nas designed to", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00470-00133783-00133947": "connect entertainment industry", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00471-00133948-00134169": "professionals with top scientists and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00472-00134170-00134349": "engineers to help the creators of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00473-00134350-00134646": "television shows films video games and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00474-00134647-00134847": "other productions incorporate science", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00475-00134848-00134973": "into their work", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00476-00134974-00135228": "she is currently a freelance writer", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00477-00135229-00135432": "contributing to a physics outreach", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00478-00135433-00135660": "dialogue with articles in a variety of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00479-00135661-00135873": "publications such as physics world", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00480-00135874-00136173": "Discover Magazine New Scientist physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00481-00136174-00136479": "today and the Wall Street Journal Carl", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00482-00136480-00136737": "Sagan was an astrophysicist and science", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00483-00136738-00136947": "popularizer one of his important", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00484-00136948-00137229": "contributions being the 1980 television", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00485-00137230-00137499": "series cosmos a personal voyage Neil", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00486-00137500-00137745": "deGrasse Tyson is an astrophysicist and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00487-00137746-00138012": "science communicator who participated to", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00488-00138013-00138240": "TV and radio shows and wrote various", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00489-00138241-00138588": "outreach books Gel Walker is a physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00490-00138589-00138840": "professor at Cleveland State University", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00491-00138841-00139107": "he wrote the amateur scientist column in", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00492-00139108-00139464": "Scientific American from 78 to 88 and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00493-00139465-00139644": "authored the popular science book The", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00494-00139645-00140336": "Flying Circus of physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00495-00140337-00140950": "topic funding sources", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00496-00140951-00141251": "American Physical Society Awards grants", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00497-00141252-00141551": "up to $10,000 to help ApS members", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00498-00141552-00141901": "develop new physics outreach activities", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00499-00141902-00142199": "Institute for complex adaptive matter -", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00500-00142200-00142448": "ic am provides grants and fellowships", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00501-00142449-00142805": "for physics outreach Wellcome Trust", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00502-00142806-00143051": "while mostly focused on Biological", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00503-00143052-00143312": "Sciences the Wellcome Trust also touches", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00504-00143313-00143507": "on physics and encourages physics", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00505-00143508-00143828": "outreach they aim to improve biology", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00506-00143829-00144211": "chemistry and physics a-levels in the UK", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00507-00144212-00144587": "Institute of Physics IOP the IOP aims to", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00508-00144588-00144758": "provide positive and compelling", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00509-00144759-00144968": "experiences of physics for public", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00510-00144969-00145145": "audiences through engaging and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00511-00145146-00145411": "entertaining activities and events the", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00512-00145412-00145664": "public engagement grant scheme is", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00513-00145665-00145901": "designed to give financial support of up", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00514-00145902-00146210": "to 1,500 pounds to individuals and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00515-00146211-00146393": "organizations running physics-based", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00516-00146394-00146642": "events and activities in the UK and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00517-00146643-00147223": "Ireland", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00518-00147224-00147782": "topic Awards", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00519-00147783-00148063": "Kalinga prize for the popularization of", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00520-00148064-00148300": "science is an award given by UNESCO for", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00521-00148301-00148496": "exceptional skill in presenting", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00522-00148497-00148856": "scientific ideas to laypeople clost", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00523-00148857-00149140": "Eggman Ord is presented by the American", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00524-00149141-00149350": "Association of physics teachers and", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00525-00149351-00149551": "given in memory of the physicist Polly", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00526-00149552-00149887": "Klaas Tech Kelvin Prize is awarded by", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00527-00149888-00150107": "the Institute of physics to acknowledge", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00528-00150108-00150313": "outstanding contributions to the public", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00529-00150314-00150748": "understanding of physics michael faraday", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00530-00150749-00151039": "prize for communicating science to a UK", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00531-00151040-00151441": "audience Royal Society Prejean Perrin", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00532-00151442-00151706": "for popularization in physics attributed", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00533-00151707-00152045": "by the French physics society equals", "HDvPM9oiLuI-00534-00152046-00152362": "equals see also"}}, {"audio_id": "HD_7ue6f0OU", "text": {"HD_7ue6f0OU-00000-00000000-00000199": "content warning this podcast is intended", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00001-00000200-00000375": "for a mature audience contains graphic", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00002-00000376-00000551": "descriptions of violence and explicit", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00003-00000552-00000799": "language", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00004-00000800-00000991": "hello and thanks so much for tuning in", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00005-00000992-00001262": "to pods of the multiverse season 2 this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00006-00001263-00001663": "our penultimate episode my name is scala", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00007-00001664-00001830": "i will be portraying the world of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00008-00001832-00002183": "ravnica and with me are my three friends", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00009-00002184-00002350": "portraying the characters who are", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00010-00002351-00002647": "navigating that world", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00011-00002648-00002855": "jeffy is your name i know i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00012-00002856-00003095": "had it also you didn't say we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00013-00003096-00003327": "play dungeons and dragons", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00014-00003328-00003535": "oh yes i'm legally obligated to say that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00015-00003536-00003719": "we're an unofficial dungeons and dragons", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00016-00003720-00003919": "podcast and we play 5th edition dungeons", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00017-00003920-00004052": "and dragons there you go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00018-00004053-00004175": "[Music]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00019-00004176-00004399": "up just got off the phone with legal and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00020-00004400-00004743": "we saved it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00021-00004744-00005031": "my name is jeppy i play illapal who has", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00022-00005032-00005175": "finally learned how to use the sleep", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00023-00005176-00005286": "spell", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00024-00005287-00005486": "i'm jimmy i play clork the is it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00025-00005487-00005775": "engineer goblin who is friend to all", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00026-00005776-00005951": "elements i guess", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00027-00005952-00006151": "except for like ice though i don't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00028-00006152-00006318": "really have too much association with", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00029-00006319-00006518": "ice these days", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00030-00006519-00006703": "really you're just friends with um", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00031-00006704-00006798": "fire", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00032-00006800-00007078": "and lightning that's right right those", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00033-00007079-00007191": "are the most important lot of other a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00034-00007192-00007319": "lot of other elements that you're not", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00035-00007320-00007534": "friends with anyways beat up some earth", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00036-00007536-00007831": "elemental yeah or less", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00037-00007831-00008134": "heart here i i got it i got it i'm andy", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00038-00008136-00008367": "and i play alwyn i am a friend to ice", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00039-00008368-00008487": "and earth", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00040-00008488-00008807": "uh alwyn is a friend of ice and earth", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00041-00008808-00009071": "and also really glad illapal finally", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00042-00009072-00009239": "learned how to use that sleep spell", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00043-00009240-00009455": "there you go yes is that one captain", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00044-00009456-00009687": "planet uh no", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00045-00009688-00009942": "unofficially yes we are legally allowed", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00046-00009943-00010191": "to say unofficially yes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00047-00010192-00010431": "he's a golgari druid i'll say no more", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00048-00010432-00010551": "okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00049-00010552-00010719": "i don't know why you would after that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00050-00010720-00010919": "shameful display but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00051-00010920-00011263": "if you are enjoying our content", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00052-00011264-00011551": "wow please engage with us", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00053-00011552-00011687": "uh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00054-00011688-00011942": "come rate us and review us and hang out", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00055-00011943-00012183": "with us on our social media platforms", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00056-00012184-00012414": "because that'll help more people listen", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00057-00012415-00012638": "to this fun little show we have here and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00058-00012639-00012838": "without further ado let's begin that fun", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00059-00012839-00012966": "little show", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00060-00012967-00013143": "this time for real this time for real", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00061-00013144-00013247": "what are you talking about this is the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00062-00013247-00013471": "only time that it happened yeah take one", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00063-00013472-00013703": "take one let's get into it with our", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00064-00013704-00013951": "recap quiz show where the game was last", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00065-00013952-00014158": "week and the points could get you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00066-00014159-00014319": "advantage we kicked the out of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00067-00014319-00014479": "bippo correct", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00068-00014480-00014663": "you did take the out of pippa", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00069-00014663-00014830": "that's it that's all i want to say", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00070-00014831-00014983": "that's all i'm gonna say i get all the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00071-00014984-00015150": "points okay that's all that matters", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00072-00015151-00015399": "after meeting with zytha she told us", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00073-00015400-00015558": "that a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00074-00015559-00015886": "sub-power station which clork may or may", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00075-00015887-00016103": "not have recognized the description of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00076-00016104-00016319": "was having some suspicious activity", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00077-00016319-00016622": "reported around we were tasked to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00078-00016623-00016879": "investigate in return for the favor of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00079-00016880-00017127": "them potentially helping us against the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00080-00017128-00017415": "arresters cool yes correct", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00081-00017416-00017591": "um since we're going backwards just", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00082-00017592-00017871": "before that we uh camped out clork made", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00083-00017872-00018103": "friends with the fire fire oh yeah and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00084-00018104-00018375": "you gave it a hammer yeah right yes it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00085-00018376-00018647": "wanted to destroy the trappings of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00086-00018648-00018927": "modern society and so i gave it a hammer", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00087-00018928-00019207": "we also ran into a boros checkpoint", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00088-00019208-00019430": "outside of kennen's shop correct we're", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00089-00019431-00019719": "able to sneak past it talk to kennen get", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00090-00019720-00019935": "some information about goings on in the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00091-00019936-00020271": "area and also the directions to design", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00092-00020272-00020367": "this group", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00093-00020368-00020567": "there was also an ettin who had a bad", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00094-00020568-00020855": "bad riddle i saw that a bad riddle that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00095-00020856-00021030": "jeffy solved because everybody else is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00096-00021031-00021239": "dumb i mean i also felt dumb for not", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00097-00021240-00021471": "solving it sooner", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00098-00021472-00021583": "um", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00099-00021584-00021799": "vietnam has a sixth intelligence it's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00100-00021800-00022030": "not gonna be the best fit middles okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00101-00022031-00022247": "what else happened oh we kicked the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00102-00022248-00022471": "out of bippo yes he said and we've come", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00103-00022472-00022647": "full circle right uh we're on the run", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00104-00022648-00022894": "from the law well we have that too yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00105-00022895-00023158": "potomac is now our uh officially", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00106-00023159-00023391": "designated legal council right going all", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00107-00023392-00023486": "the way back to the beginning of the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00108-00023487-00023863": "episode we were in a bind atomic cut us", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00109-00023864-00024127": "out really quick but we're in a bind", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00110-00024128-00024266": "again it came full circle", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00111-00024267-00024447": "[Music]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00112-00024448-00024614": "it's a pattern we seem to end most", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00113-00024615-00024807": "episodes in the bind we may or may not", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00114-00024808-00024967": "be surrounded i'm not really sure yet", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00115-00024968-00025119": "probably are you didn't make your", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00116-00025120-00025230": "perception", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00117-00025231-00025422": "nope that one's got no clue yeah let's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00118-00025423-00025591": "let's get right into that andy you had", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00119-00025592-00025806": "three points to everyone else's two you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00120-00025807-00026031": "can take an inspiration d20", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00121-00026032-00026127": "yes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00122-00026127-00026279": "philapelle you'll be able to act in the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00123-00026280-00026590": "surprise round you see a small group of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00124-00026591-00026879": "vayashino surround your party creeping", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00125-00026880-00027135": "out from behind pieces of rubble to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00126-00027136-00027423": "ambush you with some short swords drawn", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00127-00027424-00027623": "so let's everyone roll an issue", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00128-00027624-00027935": "at a 16. eight eleven all right fashion", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00129-00027936-00028135": "number one how's everybody looking for", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00130-00028136-00028287": "hit points", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00131-00028288-00028487": "well let's just say uh i know what i'll", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00132-00028488-00028718": "be using my surprise round to do and it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00133-00028719-00028935": "will be healing okay i'm all right i'm", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00134-00028936-00029151": "almost at full okay cool", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00135-00029152-00029390": "and what scala is like okay illa pelvey", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00136-00029391-00029790": "target you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00137-00029791-00030239": "alwyn 20 hits you yes of course okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00138-00030239-00030439": "you take eight points of piercing damage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00139-00030439-00030735": "oh as a lizard man comes out of nowhere", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00140-00030736-00030807": "and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00141-00030808-00031111": "knifes you with a knife or um", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00142-00031112-00031327": "short swords with a short sword", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00143-00031327-00031502": "where did you come from i think it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00144-00031503-00031711": "shorts you with a sword shorts you with", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00145-00031712-00032070": "a sword and then swings again 23. yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00146-00032072-00032287": "for another four points of piercing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00147-00032288-00032518": "damage wow not looking great anymore", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00148-00032519-00032783": "vaishina number two clork", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00149-00032784-00033039": "you should still have mage armor up yes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00150-00033040-00033231": "i think so yes yeah that lasts eight", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00151-00033232-00033495": "hours so", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00152-00033496-00033743": "uh but two seventeens", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00153-00033744-00033959": "plus four is going to hit", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00154-00033960-00034199": "yeah for seven points of slashing damage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00155-00034200-00034439": "and then with their offhand", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00156-00034440-00034702": "19 to hit for", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00157-00034703-00034902": "eight points of slashing damage illapal", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00158-00034903-00035223": "you're up my word in ambush i'm going to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00159-00035224-00035487": "cast healing work on myself very", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00160-00035488-00035718": "magnanimous of you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00161-00035719-00035830": "yup", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00162-00035831-00036118": "i heal for seven so that's looking a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00163-00036119-00036367": "little bit better i guess for my action", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00164-00036368-00036462": "uh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00165-00036463-00036711": "where are these little shits there's two", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00166-00036712-00036959": "with two swords in each of your friends", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00167-00036960-00037230": "okay and there's one still hiding behind", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00168-00037231-00037495": "a rock slow on the draw any way for me", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00169-00037496-00037639": "to put them asleep before i put my", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00170-00037640-00037799": "friends asleep with good positioning", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00171-00037800-00037967": "they are standing right next to your", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00172-00037968-00038079": "allies", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00173-00038080-00038335": "probably one of them but you wouldn't be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00174-00038336-00038511": "able to get both of them pretty low", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00175-00038512-00038751": "already yeah all right is there a way to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00176-00038752-00038911": "get one of them without getting any", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00177-00038912-00039174": "friends correct okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00178-00039175-00039318": "all right cool i wanted to make sure but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00179-00039319-00039543": "you can't cast two spells in a turn yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00180-00039544-00039790": "uh i was just asking yeah i i don't want", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00181-00039791-00039974": "to do it i just wanted to see if i could", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00182-00039975-00040159": "um if i could guess", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00183-00040160-00040335": "clerk can do it because he has quicken", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00184-00040336-00040743": "spell but you cannot cool all right uh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00185-00040744-00040927": "all right i'll just go up to one", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00186-00040928-00041095": "i'll have advantage on my attack right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00187-00041096-00041302": "because they're engaged i'm gonna say", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00188-00041303-00041502": "your friends are not really posing a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00189-00041503-00041695": "threat to these vayashino they're", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00190-00041696-00041879": "surprised okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00191-00041880-00042190": "yeah all right cool all right wow brutal", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00192-00042191-00042343": "absolutely brutal i think we're supposed", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00193-00042344-00042471": "to die in this encounter i'm going to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00194-00042472-00042783": "jump off a cliff no i'm just kidding", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00195-00042784-00043023": "there are no cliffs around oh my god", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00196-00043024-00043207": "okay i take the sword and harikari", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00197-00043208-00043518": "myself no uh we can scrap that good you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00198-00043519-00043646": "already said it it's happening you'll", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00199-00043647-00043871": "attack against yourself you can't retake", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00200-00043872-00044062": "your action i'm being a real hard ass", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00201-00044063-00044383": "tonight seriously all right 15 to hit 15", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00202-00044384-00044567": "absolutely hits may i ask are you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00203-00044568-00044758": "attacking the one who's attacking alwyn", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00204-00044759-00045023": "or clork the one that attacked clark", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00205-00045024-00045246": "did more damage so illapalox sees that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00206-00045247-00045455": "that was a bigger blow and is coming", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00207-00045456-00045630": "into eight clerk", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00208-00045631-00045887": "that is uh nine points of piercing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00209-00045888-00046087": "damage all right third voyagino's gonna", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00210-00046088-00046279": "go for you you are not surprised so it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00211-00046280-00046439": "does not get advantage on these attack", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00212-00046440-00046799": "rolls but uh 16 plus four is gonna hit", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00213-00046800-00047023": "for six points of piercing damage and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00214-00047024-00047102": "then", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00215-00047103-00047343": "off hand two plus four is not gonna hit", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00216-00047344-00047551": "am i surprised anymore at the beginning", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00217-00047552-00047718": "of the next initiative round which is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00218-00047719-00048046": "now no okay so these attacks against you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00219-00048047-00048215": "that the first vive chino is making are", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00220-00048216-00048374": "not going to be with advantage okay i'm", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00221-00048375-00048790": "gonna spores them okay cool con save", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00222-00048791-00049135": "16 plus one passes first attack is 11", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00223-00049136-00049351": "not gonna hit nope and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00224-00049352-00049711": "18 plus four will yeah yikes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00225-00049712-00049895": "for three points of piercing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00226-00049896-00050111": "elwyn you are up i think i've had enough", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00227-00050112-00050327": "of this i'm gonna action", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00228-00050328-00050607": "symbiotic entity gain all my temporary", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00229-00050608-00050879": "hit points okay bonus action i'm going", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00230-00050880-00050958": "to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00231-00050959-00051238": "hey lapel how are you looking a bad blow", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00232-00051239-00051463": "will end me okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00233-00051464-00051735": "illapal looking hurt alwyn would", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00234-00051736-00051950": "probably never admit this directly but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00235-00051951-00052038": "through", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00236-00052039-00052230": "getting to know illapal a little more", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00237-00052232-00052430": "they have rubbed off on him and so alan", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00238-00052432-00052742": "will bonus action healing word", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00239-00052744-00052959": "well you're always saying we can do it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00240-00052960-00053254": "together right here goes nothing and a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00241-00053255-00053519": "healing word a lapel", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00242-00053520-00053854": "for eight health max roll on that okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00243-00053855-00054111": "sweet oh no nine i have a wisdom out of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00244-00054112-00054359": "five now you do i think that's my turn", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00245-00054360-00054623": "okay alwyn that's your turn vayashino", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00246-00054624-00054879": "number two has two potential targets", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00247-00054879-00055079": "it's going to take one swing at illapal", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00248-00055079-00055238": "one swing at cork", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00249-00055239-00055382": "since it was already my turn i'm gonna", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00250-00055383-00055511": "go ahead and interrupt that with the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00251-00055512-00055807": "spores again okay sure kan say", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00252-00055808-00056047": "nine plus one is not gonna do it like i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00253-00056048-00056126": "said", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00254-00056127-00056254": "i've had enough", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00255-00056255-00056487": "and they take six necrotic damage they", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00256-00056488-00056694": "drop so they're going to take no actions", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00257-00056695-00056871": "and make no attacks illapal you're up", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00258-00056872-00057142": "you see my necrotic spikes shoot through", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00259-00057144-00057335": "his legs and bring him to the ground was", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00260-00057336-00057550": "that the one i also attacked yes that is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00261-00057551-00057766": "the one you also attacked all right i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00262-00057767-00057942": "will cast dissonant whispers on the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00263-00057944-00058159": "other okay it makes a wisdom save", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00264-00058160-00058454": "correct yes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00265-00058455-00058782": "it did roll a dirty 20. succeeds but it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00266-00058783-00059182": "will still take half damage from this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00267-00059183-00059566": "half of 14 is seven psychic damage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00268-00059567-00059838": "okay clork we are over to you hold on i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00269-00059839-00060030": "want to use my bonus action to bardic", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00270-00060032-00060319": "inspiration clork very good well then be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00271-00060320-00060511": "on with it end this sooner for us will", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00272-00060512-00060742": "you it'd be my pleasure and i'm going to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00273-00060744-00060991": "shock and grasp the other one okay very", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00274-00060991-00061126": "good", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00275-00061127-00061591": "14 to hit 14 is there ac nice very cool", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00276-00061591-00061799": "and that's six lightning damage okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00277-00061800-00062199": "this one drops okay and i'm going to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00278-00062200-00062406": "back away from the action okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00279-00062407-00062703": "very good the third vayashino seeing his", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00280-00062704-00063079": "compatriots fall is going to determine", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00281-00063079-00063406": "that you guys are not as easy prey as", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00282-00063407-00063663": "they may have initially surmised going", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00283-00063664-00064015": "to use his action to disengage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00284-00064016-00064215": "how far can they get around 30 feet is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00285-00064216-00064479": "their speed 30 feet away okay if you'd", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00286-00064479-00064766": "like to attempt to pursue they seem to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00287-00064767-00065047": "scramble over this ruined terrain a bit", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00288-00065048-00065287": "more adeptly than you do so you might", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00289-00065288-00065471": "have to make some sort of sure physical", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00290-00065472-00065703": "check to pursue them if you would like", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00291-00065704-00065943": "to it is your turn it's my turn cool i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00292-00065944-00066055": "just sort of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00293-00066056-00066287": "very coldly look at a lapel as i begin", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00294-00066288-00066559": "to conjure an ice knife in my hand and i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00295-00066560-00066775": "just go is it even worth it at this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00296-00066776-00067055": "point i suspect there's a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00297-00067056-00067279": "wide variety of reasons they'd be after", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00298-00067280-00067638": "us none worth our time or effort but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00299-00067639-00067871": "if you seek to dispose of this rabble be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00300-00067872-00068079": "on with it glad i have your permission", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00301-00068080-00068279": "and i chuck an ice knife at him okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00302-00068280-00068575": "roll your attack allen feeling like he's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00303-00068576-00068735": "kind of had enough of being caught off", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00304-00068736-00068967": "guard this whole adventure is not really", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00305-00068968-00069231": "going to spare any anything here", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00306-00069232-00069526": "that is a 16 plus mod and they need to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00307-00069527-00069911": "make a deck save okay deck save is a 21.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00308-00069912-00070087": "okay that passes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00309-00070088-00070479": "so just the initial blast of seven", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00310-00070480-00070767": "piercings okay they stagger but do not", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00311-00070768-00070967": "fall illappella it's your turn i've", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00312-00070968-00071262": "spent till i care too it's up to you now", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00313-00071263-00071503": "personally i think you should do it all", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00314-00071504-00071719": "right let's go ahead and blow up my last", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00315-00071720-00072006": "spell slot on a dissonant whispers", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00316-00072007-00072206": "what could go wrong okay we're not gonna", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00317-00072207-00072462": "need that no we're not let's have some", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00318-00072463-00072743": "fun he fails his savings bro so you love", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00319-00072744-00072943": "to see that it's highly improbable he", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00320-00072944-00073111": "lives at this point", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00321-00073112-00073343": "indeed it is because i got almost a max", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00322-00073344-00073759": "roll six six and five for 17. holy", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00323-00073760-00073871": "you see", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00324-00073872-00074103": "from a distance green blood just flows", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00325-00074104-00074415": "out of their ears as they wail horribly", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00326-00074416-00074631": "and drop to the ground mentally", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00327-00074632-00074855": "destroyed by your spell i didn't realize", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00328-00074856-00075047": "my words were that annoying okay we're", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00329-00075048-00075319": "glad to have them nice work fellas well", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00330-00075320-00075503": "all right we can't be much further now", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00331-00075504-00075623": "back to camp", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00332-00075624-00075975": "i am quite tired let's be on our way", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00333-00075976-00076215": "very good make for me if you will one", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00334-00076216-00076431": "last group survival check to make it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00335-00076432-00076788": "back to boar's head park", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00336-00076789-00076999": "[Applause]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00337-00077000-00077175": "why can't i do this math right now oh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00338-00077176-00077423": "god okay there we go 15. that's the same", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00339-00077424-00077606": "thing i had 15.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00340-00077607-00077759": "nine i knew years were going to be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00341-00077760-00077967": "single digit you had to look like you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00342-00077968-00078087": "felt bad", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00343-00078088-00078343": "okay yeah average of 13 but you've been", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00344-00078344-00078655": "at this a while you're close i just want", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00345-00078656-00078847": "to get on with this adventure there you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00346-00078848-00079119": "go the most powerful dc of all you make", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00347-00079120-00079511": "it successfully to zyphus camp", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00348-00079512-00079694": "well how'd it go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00349-00079695-00079911": "we disposed of the problem", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00350-00079912-00080143": "good run into any other troubles we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00351-00080144-00080335": "might want to look out for out there we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00352-00080336-00080550": "disposed of the problem permanently bit", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00353-00080551-00080782": "of a vice chino ambush we disposed of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00354-00080783-00081038": "them as well yeah those slizzed clan", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00355-00081039-00081271": "folk like to prey on the unwary", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00356-00081272-00081519": "wandering through here well it seems", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00357-00081520-00081767": "we've held up our end of the arrangement", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00358-00081768-00081967": "so you have so i guess i'm gonna need", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00359-00081968-00082231": "some more logistical details from you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00360-00082232-00082559": "about where and when you want us to make", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00361-00082560-00082847": "a scene allen looks back to the group we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00362-00082848-00083062": "don't really know that yet do we no", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00363-00083063-00083262": "guess not always a good time for a scene", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00364-00083263-00083423": "you look pretty beat up why don't you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00365-00083424-00083606": "stay here with us tonight i can probably", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00366-00083607-00083831": "find a spare tent for at least one of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00367-00083832-00084015": "you give you some time to sleep on it we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00368-00084016-00084223": "can talk details in the morning sounds", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00369-00084224-00084455": "great hey by the way you got any hot", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00370-00084456-00084647": "dogs", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00371-00084648-00084750": "here we go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00372-00084751-00084982": "[Laughter]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00373-00084983-00085294": "allen winks to illapal ah yes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00374-00085295-00085526": "famous hot dogs", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00375-00085527-00085782": "this is a mixed company we get all sorts", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00376-00085783-00085991": "here we've got some goblins but even i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00377-00085992-00086229": "think that's kind of a barbaric practice", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00378-00086230-00086647": "[Laughter]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00379-00086648-00086935": "so good now cat on the other hand", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00380-00086936-00087094": "oh of course", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00381-00087095-00087318": "of course there's just too many of them", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00382-00087319-00087503": "you know and where did you say the tent", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00383-00087504-00087687": "was again well dig one out of storage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00384-00087688-00087959": "and you can set it up yourself ah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00385-00087960-00088175": "i appreciate you i look forward to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00386-00088176-00088326": "whatever food you have to serve that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00387-00088327-00088535": "isn't cat or dog", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00388-00088536-00088782": "or cat dog i just sort of pat them on", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00389-00088783-00088975": "their shoulder they're there hey lapel i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00390-00088976-00089159": "think you'll be all right we've got lots", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00391-00089160-00089471": "of pigeon there's always more pigeons", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00392-00089472-00089687": "it all sounds good unless you guys want", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00393-00089688-00089911": "to do anything amongst yourselves", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00394-00089912-00090231": "nothing this short rest wait long rest", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00395-00090232-00090462": "or short rest sorry long rest no i'm", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00396-00090463-00090679": "taking the lr", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00397-00090680-00090862": "yeah this is gonna be a long rest okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00398-00090863-00091271": "so before i go to bed i want to cast", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00399-00091272-00091606": "ritually animal messenger i sort of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00400-00091607-00091815": "look around the area the dark", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00401-00091816-00092062": "night beyond the light of the flame and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00402-00092063-00092431": "i try and reach out to a spider or some", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00403-00092432-00092671": "other small insect that i know will be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00404-00092672-00092894": "able to navigate through the undercity i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00405-00092895-00093199": "described to them my mother rena this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00406-00093200-00093494": "tremendous force of a gorgon woman and i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00407-00093495-00093759": "described stonehaven this enormous", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00408-00093760-00094047": "underground castle in the undercity and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00409-00094048-00094318": "i speak these words as the message we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00410-00094319-00094543": "are being haunted by compromised", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00411-00094544-00094926": "arresters stone heaven could be a target", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00412-00094927-00095231": "we need to talk ready our defenses and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00413-00095232-00095438": "watch for my coming and that's the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00414-00095439-00095662": "message very good this little black", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00415-00095663-00095926": "shells beetle it has answered your call", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00416-00095927-00096103": "a bit and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00417-00096104-00096423": "flips out its wings beneath its", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00418-00096424-00096662": "tightness back and takes off into the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00419-00096663-00096926": "night with this message so what time of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00420-00096927-00097191": "day will i get the key roon back you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00421-00097192-00097494": "used it in the middle of the night so", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00422-00097495-00097679": "midday i would say", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00423-00097680-00098015": "because it's 36 hours okay you settle", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00424-00098016-00098279": "down at zytus camp you gain the benefits", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00425-00098280-00098438": "of a long rest you wake up in the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00426-00098439-00098694": "morning what would you like to do i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00427-00098695-00098926": "think i've got an idea of a symbol a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00428-00098927-00099167": "sign of turk we can give them but i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00429-00099168-00099326": "don't know how much longer we have how", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00430-00099327-00099550": "many more allies we can find i think our", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00431-00099551-00099726": "friends in the undercity are definitely", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00432-00099727-00099903": "who we should go to next i don't know", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00433-00099904-00100118": "how long it'll take those arresters to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00434-00100119-00100287": "make their way that far but i should be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00435-00100288-00100487": "able to beat them there i know no better", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00436-00100488-00100726": "guy than you i wish i could say i could", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00437-00100727-00100967": "offer someone to aid us but the reality", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00438-00100968-00101206": "is besides a few drunk patrons at the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00439-00101207-00101462": "violet rules really there's no one", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00440-00101463-00101735": "alvin i think our safety and security", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00441-00101736-00101903": "and the fate of our mission with the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00442-00101904-00102167": "guilt pact lies in your hands cloak is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00443-00102168-00102350": "the anyone at the league who could be of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00444-00102351-00102663": "assistance i could be of assistance you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00445-00102664-00102975": "hear a voice call off from behind no", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00446-00102976-00103206": "i think i know who this is don't say it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00447-00103207-00103430": "don't say it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00448-00103431-00103775": "is this silas no oh man", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00449-00103776-00104094": "you see an old brass scaled vyashinu", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00450-00104095-00104327": "sort of just saunter into this camp", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00451-00104328-00104623": "whereas if they woke up there", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00452-00104624-00104910": "they've got is it blue and red jumpsuit", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00453-00104911-00105215": "walking stick in the shape of a power", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00454-00105216-00105527": "coil and a number of lenses that can", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00455-00105528-00105710": "flip over their eye allen you would", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00456-00105711-00105919": "recognize this gentleman as vim the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00457-00105920-00106190": "person who originally recruited you oh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00458-00106191-00106286": "yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00459-00106288-00106631": "hell yeah allen sort of gives a stare", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00460-00106632-00106823": "into the distance towards them and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00461-00106824-00106953": "focuses his eyes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00462-00106954-00107071": "[Music]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00463-00107072-00107223": "master green wolf", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00464-00107224-00107310": "hello", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00465-00107311-00107399": "and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00466-00107400-00107566": "clark", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00467-00107567-00107790": "where did you come from how did you find", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00468-00107791-00107951": "us", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00469-00107952-00108254": "i have my ways my methods", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00470-00108255-00108510": "and um", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00471-00108511-00108734": "it is good to see you all", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00472-00108735-00109063": "oh i have some important information he", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00473-00109064-00109334": "met the whole party right am i he just", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00474-00109335-00109519": "met you okay i was gonna say he wasn't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00475-00109520-00109663": "at the office", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00476-00109664-00109854": "after the teleportation nope good to see", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00477-00109855-00110071": "me whole why would i be in parts and how", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00478-00110072-00110223": "do you know my name", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00479-00110224-00110575": "i know many things your name is just a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00480-00110576-00110783": "small fraction of them sure that doesn't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00481-00110783-00111119": "answer my question how lapel this is vim", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00482-00111120-00111439": "the vigorous he is the one responsible", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00483-00111440-00111734": "for bringing me into this little party", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00484-00111735-00112007": "them i am most grateful for your keen", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00485-00112008-00112239": "selection of my dear friend alvin but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00486-00112240-00112463": "perhaps you can still explain how you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00487-00112464-00112775": "know who i am and with vigor", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00488-00112776-00112990": "that is the method that i prefer to go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00489-00112991-00113271": "about things in brief the guild pact has", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00490-00113272-00113607": "many uh contacts still within the league", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00491-00113608-00114015": "and has appointed the most depth and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00492-00114016-00114254": "intelligence of them to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00493-00114255-00114471": "keep a watchful eye and he sort of flips", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00494-00114472-00114719": "some of his lenses down on the projects", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00495-00114720-00115015": "that are of importance to him and so i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00496-00115016-00115239": "have been monitoring your exploits", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00497-00115240-00115495": "that's an innocuous enough explanation", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00498-00115496-00115710": "for me surely because you flattered me a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00499-00115711-00116015": "little bit there i'm not blind to it but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00500-00116016-00116231": "in any event i am satisfied with that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00501-00116232-00116471": "explanation vim what services might you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00502-00116472-00116743": "offer information the greatest service", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00503-00116744-00117039": "of all and on that we can agree clerk", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00504-00117040-00117302": "rolls his eyes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00505-00117303-00117702": "your adversary has secured himself yes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00506-00117703-00117990": "within the spire of the centuries a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00507-00117991-00118319": "leave watchtower within the heart of the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00508-00118320-00118702": "second precinct he has assembled a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00509-00118703-00118983": "considerable force there while this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00510-00118983-00119271": "rabble that you've aroused to yourselves", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00511-00119272-00119423": "may be uh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00512-00119424-00119727": "useful in perhaps penetrating a single", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00513-00119728-00120007": "line of defense there are multiple and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00514-00120008-00120254": "having another ally i think is quite", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00515-00120255-00120486": "prudent and what does your allyship", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00516-00120488-00120878": "offer oh no not me my ally ship is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00517-00120879-00120999": "purely", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00518-00121000-00121233": "logistical another tormek if you will", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00519-00121233-00121471": "[Laughter]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00520-00121472-00121623": "while i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00521-00121624-00121871": "somewhat resent the comparison", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00522-00121872-00122207": "yes thoroughly proficient at his", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00523-00122208-00122447": "particular line of work on that we can", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00524-00122448-00122719": "woefully agree so the spoil", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00525-00122720-00122854": "is there anything you can tell us about", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00526-00122855-00123095": "the inside best way to climb it what", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00527-00123096-00123334": "could be waiting i suggest you climb it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00528-00123335-00123558": "from the inside i believe scaling the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00529-00123559-00123807": "outside may put you at the mercy of sky", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00530-00123808-00124278": "nights or other such aerial combatants", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00531-00124279-00124686": "angels though the inside will have wards", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00532-00124688-00124847": "and i would suspect", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00533-00124848-00125207": "a handful of enchanted defenses", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00534-00125208-00125575": "spirits constructs things of that sort", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00535-00125576-00125863": "alwyn hears enchantments", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00536-00125864-00125983": "and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00537-00125983-00126143": "tries to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00538-00126144-00126343": "hide his reaction as his mind", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00539-00126344-00126583": "immediately jumps to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00540-00126583-00126695": "edric", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00541-00126696-00126943": "very well would you happen to know other", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00542-00126944-00127031": "than", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00543-00127032-00127214": "setting in this great defense that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00544-00127215-00127527": "they've built how strong is their force", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00545-00127528-00127719": "what i mean to say i know they're", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00546-00127720-00127910": "searching for us but do you know", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00547-00127911-00128086": "anything about their parties but their", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00548-00128088-00128366": "numbers moving about the city it's been", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00549-00128367-00128439": "a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00550-00128440-00128647": "difficult situation to monitor in its", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00551-00128648-00128934": "entirety there are many moving pieces i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00552-00128935-00129158": "will say they likely know you are out", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00553-00129159-00129478": "here but do not deem you worth the risk", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00554-00129479-00129919": "to send for you in this ruined terrain i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00555-00129920-00130095": "sort of look to clark and lapel so", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00556-00130096-00130327": "they're expecting us to come sounds that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00557-00130328-00130566": "way could very well just be a trap", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00558-00130567-00130807": "several of them exactly what they want", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00559-00130808-00130990": "but they don't know that we know that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00560-00130991-00131190": "they think it's a trap i don't think", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00561-00131191-00131375": "that changes the particular", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00562-00131376-00131631": "circumstances so if they set a trap for", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00563-00131632-00131927": "us but they're expecting us to figure", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00564-00131928-00132183": "out that it's a trap so then they know", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00565-00132184-00132383": "that we know it's a trap what do they do", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00566-00132384-00132751": "next uh they probably trap us trap us", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00567-00132752-00132943": "well then they'd probably just expect us", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00568-00132944-00133295": "to attack them head-on right i suppose", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00569-00133296-00133390": "yes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00570-00133391-00133599": "okay do you think that's a good plan", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00571-00133600-00133863": "cloak it depends do they know that we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00572-00133864-00134102": "know that we think we know that they", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00573-00134103-00134271": "think it's a trap i don't know if we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00574-00134272-00134375": "know", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00575-00134376-00135095": "i don't know i know you don't know", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00576-00135096-00135359": "[Music]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00577-00135360-00135543": "holy", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00578-00135544-00135678": "clark", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00579-00135679-00135959": "it's the only person who could possibly", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00580-00135960-00136375": "pull this pr like pulling this hard", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00581-00136376-00136559": "oh my god", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00582-00136560-00136839": "clock again i can't further", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00583-00136840-00137111": "the depth of deductive knowledge i'm", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00584-00137112-00137359": "speechless that's why i'm the leader i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00585-00137360-00137727": "give the most obvious wink to illapal as", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00586-00137728-00137975": "i say this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00587-00137976-00138207": "i feel quite the same i mean i'm trying", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00588-00138208-00138343": "my best to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00589-00138344-00138566": "break this down to its most logical", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00590-00138567-00138814": "lowest common denominator wow truly", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00591-00138815-00139014": "brilliant work so you're saying correct", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00592-00139015-00139143": "me if i'm wrong that we should just go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00593-00139144-00139423": "to the undercity and find allies and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00594-00139424-00139639": "continue with the plan i think so yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00595-00139640-00139871": "great at this point zyta has wandered", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00596-00139872-00140175": "into this conversation", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00597-00140176-00140463": "sofa i think i have a way a plan powder", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00598-00140464-00140823": "inform your merry band here as to the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00599-00140824-00140999": "attack on", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00600-00141000-00141311": "this spire of the centuries all right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00601-00141312-00141599": "let's hear it well the past few days", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00602-00141600-00141854": "i've been meditating during my resting", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00603-00141855-00142126": "on a couple of rituals i've overlooked", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00604-00142127-00142326": "in my druid training one of them i was", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00605-00142327-00142559": "able to use to send word to stonehaven", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00606-00142560-00142911": "but another a skyright spell i could", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00607-00142912-00143143": "conjure a message in the sky you'd have", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00608-00143144-00143390": "to react to it quickly it doesn't last", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00609-00143391-00143590": "that long but i could cast it high", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00610-00143591-00143799": "enough where any horde adus would be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00611-00143800-00143935": "able to see it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00612-00143936-00144087": "so we'll have to be in position", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00613-00144088-00144359": "beforehand waiting for your signal", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00614-00144360-00144559": "all right getting past the legion", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00615-00144560-00144790": "barricade might take us some time i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00616-00144791-00144926": "expect we'll probably have to start", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00617-00144927-00145239": "moving now if you want to launch this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00618-00145240-00145526": "assault in the next few days", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00619-00145527-00145759": "not a moment later very good we'll", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00620-00145760-00145959": "probably move out shortly after you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00621-00145960-00146135": "we'll wait for your signal i sort of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00622-00146136-00146487": "turned to illapal well masterwood smith", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00623-00146488-00146759": "if you could come up with a phrase a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00624-00146760-00147095": "short one a signal something to stir the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00625-00147096-00147375": "hearts the souls of those who would", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00626-00147376-00147719": "stand with us against this evil what be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00627-00147720-00147975": "those words hopefully you'll permit this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00628-00147976-00148223": "i think for once in my life", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00629-00148224-00148487": "words won't do and then i will use press", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00630-00148488-00148751": "to digitization to create like a small", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00631-00148752-00149014": "little glitch in the air of the guild", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00632-00149015-00149223": "pack symbol very good you make the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00633-00149224-00149407": "symbol of the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00634-00149408-00149623": "10 icons of the guild", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00635-00149624-00149943": "surrounding this stylized silhouette of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00636-00149944-00150047": "a dragon", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00637-00150048-00150166": "would i be able to use that with", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00638-00150167-00150319": "skywrite let me look at the text of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00639-00150320-00150799": "skyrim text does say 10 words or less", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00640-00150800-00151063": "it's cool let's go with it okay you'll", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00641-00151064-00151263": "send up the dragon signal", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00642-00151264-00151431": "that's how they'll know i can think of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00643-00151432-00151759": "none better myself very well zyther look", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00644-00151760-00152063": "for this symbol sounds like a plan", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00645-00152064-00152295": "and uh the lot of you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00646-00152296-00152678": "looking to get to stonehaven yes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00647-00152679-00152871": "it's been a long time since i've been", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00648-00152872-00152975": "there but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00649-00152976-00153151": "i think i've got a clear enough picture", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00650-00153152-00153478": "in my mind that i could convey you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00651-00153479-00153678": "been there vim", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00652-00153679-00153902": "you didn't mention this when we met oh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00653-00153903-00154431": "i've i've been many places my dear", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00654-00154432-00154526": "friend", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00655-00154527-00154743": "he's been many places he knows many", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00656-00154744-00154990": "things he's met many people", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00657-00154991-00155175": "no point really in explaining any of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00658-00155176-00155414": "that to us", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00659-00155415-00155663": "this one has the correct idea of things", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00660-00155664-00155895": "come let us go gather around me join", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00661-00155896-00156087": "hands you know pretend like you like", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00662-00156088-00156311": "each other i kind of look down to clark", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00663-00156312-00156511": "to see what he does", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00664-00156512-00156854": "who's pretending", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00665-00156855-00157063": "no one looks at a lapel i avoid looking", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00666-00157064-00157214": "at it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00667-00157215-00157502": "illapal will take hands they will clasp", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00668-00157503-00157623": "hands and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00669-00157624-00157878": "get into it no i look right at the lapel", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00670-00157879-00158119": "all right let's do it you class fans", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00671-00158120-00158287": "there is a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00672-00158288-00158599": "hum of of electrical current gathering", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00673-00158600-00158935": "in the air a static charge builds into", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00674-00158936-00159231": "this portal that opens swallowing your", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00675-00159232-00159407": "group", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00676-00159408-00159719": "and you appear in the mossy courtyard of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00677-00159720-00160054": "stonehaven with its many life-like stone", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00678-00160055-00160407": "statues one of which is of your brother", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00679-00160408-00160814": "that one takes a deep breath", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00680-00160815-00161054": "smells like home i look around look for", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00681-00161055-00161390": "anybody yours is standing guard of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00682-00161391-00161671": "course", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00683-00161672-00161878": "a little surprised by your arrival", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00684-00161879-00162135": "forgive our entry yoge i guess i was", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00685-00162136-00162407": "expecting you another way well so was i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00686-00162408-00162647": "to be honest well means i won't have to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00687-00162648-00162807": "charge out the under the bridge to help", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00688-00162808-00163007": "you i immediately look towards the gates", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00689-00163008-00163183": "in the bridge at that keep your head", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00690-00163184-00163295": "down", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00691-00163296-00163575": "you got my message then hi we did we're", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00692-00163576-00163887": "being watched just one arrester camping", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00693-00163888-00164102": "out in the cavern somewhere out there in", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00694-00164103-00164399": "the darkness just one just one for now", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00695-00164400-00164671": "keeping a watch making sure you don't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00696-00164672-00164975": "try and hide out here well we've got vim", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00697-00164976-00165302": "here for that ah yes hello uh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00698-00165303-00165447": "good to meet you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00699-00165448-00165551": "you're", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00700-00165552-00165807": "good to meet you you're i'm them in the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00701-00165808-00166014": "vigorous as they called me when i was", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00702-00166015-00166383": "younger i am an ally to your young alwyn", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00703-00166384-00166590": "here and liaison to the guild pact you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00704-00166591-00166911": "need not fear me i may wish to excuse", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00705-00166912-00167143": "myself now that you are all here thank", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00706-00167144-00167207": "you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00707-00167208-00167463": "could not jump without you ah it is my", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00708-00167464-00167823": "pleasure to be of assistance and as he", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00709-00167824-00167990": "says that his", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00710-00167991-00168431": "wizardy form shrinks into a little tiny", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00711-00168432-00168607": "mute and he just scurries through the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00712-00168608-00168807": "bars of the portcullis and off across", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00713-00168808-00168926": "the bridge", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00714-00168927-00169071": "that's amazing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00715-00169072-00169231": "all right let's go and i immediately", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00716-00169232-00169390": "start heading towards the great hall", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00717-00169391-00169687": "towards rena yeah your mother is sitting", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00718-00169688-00169935": "on her rootwood throne her", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00719-00169936-00170207": "wolves at her feet i walk in and bow", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00720-00170208-00170495": "same habit of a routine as i would", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00721-00170496-00170711": "always give upon returning it's good to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00722-00170712-00171014": "see your home son and your friends as", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00723-00171015-00171254": "well be welcome in stonehaven", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00724-00171255-00171326": "so", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00725-00171327-00171526": "you're being hunted is that the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00726-00171527-00171871": "situation as i'm to understand it our", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00727-00171872-00172087": "business with the guild pact has brought", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00728-00172088-00172399": "us to a great conflict as it were a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00729-00172400-00172671": "group called the rujeva if it means", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00730-00172672-00172895": "anything to you sort of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00731-00172896-00173166": "secret group of azorius and others she", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00732-00173167-00173519": "spits do you know them i that i do the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00733-00173520-00173790": "senate has always treated us as less", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00734-00173791-00174078": "than because we don't conform to their", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00735-00174079-00174351": "idea of what order should be we have our", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00736-00174352-00174623": "own order the natural order and they", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00737-00174624-00175078": "would impose their unnatural order on us", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00738-00175079-00175359": "or her snake-like tendrils are twisting", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00739-00175360-00175695": "agitatedly as she says this i see her", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00740-00175696-00175854": "starting to get riled up and i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00741-00175855-00176231": "get riled up too i'm like", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00742-00176232-00176351": "and none", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00743-00176352-00176551": "are more stubborn than those", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00744-00176552-00176702": "traditionalists", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00745-00176703-00177023": "their faction holds us in the greatest", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00746-00177024-00177302": "contempt you don't need to convince me", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00747-00177303-00177447": "to send", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00748-00177448-00177743": "yours and some soldiers to aid you in", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00749-00177744-00177943": "whatever you might need we're grateful", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00750-00177944-00178190": "for the help but you know our ways all", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00751-00178191-00178526": "things grow from death i they do and as", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00752-00178527-00178911": "all life requires death so service", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00753-00178912-00179151": "requires sacrifice", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00754-00179152-00179383": "after the invasion a great number of the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00755-00179384-00179695": "invading corpses were collected by our", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00756-00179696-00180014": "sworn and held to be mother are you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00757-00180015-00180223": "speaking of the eternals", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00758-00180224-00180519": "i am i look to lapel like we have a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00759-00180520-00180759": "mutual friend who's getting up to some", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00760-00180760-00181087": "have any gone missing of late are", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00761-00181088-00181359": "the numbers not adding up yes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00762-00181360-00181526": "several of the vaults where they were", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00763-00181527-00181775": "being held have been emptied and there's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00764-00181776-00181966": "another we believe will be emptied", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00765-00181967-00182175": "tonight i can't promise that all the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00766-00182176-00182423": "numbers will add up but i may have an", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00767-00182424-00182614": "idea as to where they're going i can at", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00768-00182615-00182799": "least account for one right now you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00769-00182800-00183087": "familiar with the wilted petal vaguely", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00770-00183088-00183375": "it's a halfway house in between", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00771-00183376-00183599": "territories it's a small tavern on the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00772-00183600-00183799": "way out of the undercity mother we may", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00773-00183800-00184102": "have run into a part of this problem a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00774-00184103-00184438": "sort of result of these", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00775-00184439-00184543": "missing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00776-00184544-00184766": "bodies halfway house is an astute", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00777-00184767-00184919": "observation it is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00778-00184920-00185111": "rather dingy that proprietor knows", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00779-00185112-00185247": "nothing about running a proper", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00780-00185248-00185335": "establishment", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00781-00185336-00185502": "[Laughter]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00782-00185503-00185783": "in any events the proprietor is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00783-00185784-00186023": "what is of concern her name is arnold", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00784-00186024-00186238": "gast i will be make the constitution", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00785-00186239-00186502": "safe", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00786-00186503-00186695": "and likely i really thought you weren't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00787-00186696-00186919": "gonna say it well no but well remember", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00788-00186920-00187135": "also illapal i mean i up as a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00789-00187136-00187326": "player but illapal also has not figured", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00790-00187327-00187590": "this out yet so yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00791-00187591-00187735": "okay uh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00792-00187736-00187847": "it's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00793-00187848-00188087": "it is a 17. i remember it being high", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00794-00188088-00188295": "last time when i barely saved get him", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00795-00188296-00188678": "get his ass as you say on it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00796-00188679-00189014": "you feel your windpipe close up and you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00797-00189015-00189214": "struggle for breath you're staggered", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00798-00189215-00189566": "make another constitution safe", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00799-00189567-00189695": "cool", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00800-00189696-00189871": "this time i have a 19 i have a 16 on the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00801-00189872-00190126": "dice plus 3. that'll just do it you feel", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00802-00190127-00190343": "as if all of the air is about to be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00803-00190344-00190607": "squeezed out of you but you managed to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00804-00190608-00190902": "fight through and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00805-00190903-00191190": "intake a large breath little bell what", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00806-00191191-00191550": "was that and you feel a low resonance in", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00807-00191551-00191775": "the ring around your fingers and you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00808-00191776-00192063": "hear in your mind i told you to keep my", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00809-00192064-00192359": "name out of your mouth and there she is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00810-00192360-00192543": "my apologies", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00811-00192544-00192750": "the lapel will kind of put themselves", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00812-00192751-00192926": "back together a little bit the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00813-00192927-00193311": "proprietor an evil woman may have some", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00814-00193312-00193478": "involvement but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00815-00193479-00193766": "more upsetting still may have been may", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00816-00193767-00193919": "have been partially or wholly", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00817-00193920-00194071": "responsible for what happened with", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00818-00194072-00194319": "yidric they speak the truth", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00819-00194320-00194678": "i've seen the lettuce myself rena stands", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00820-00194679-00194935": "whatever is going on here is certainly", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00821-00194936-00195135": "concerning they call themselves the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00822-00195136-00195463": "consortium this unaugust and one dr", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00823-00195464-00195726": "taganti or the combine they're involved", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00824-00195727-00195911": "we don't know if there are others but we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00825-00195912-00196190": "can assume as much she calls her steward", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00826-00196191-00196559": "over pella have words sent to karozda of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00827-00196560-00196790": "these goings-on vraska and the rest of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00828-00196791-00196999": "the ruling council deserve to know", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00829-00197000-00197335": "mother the rujeva the consortium all of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00830-00197336-00197638": "these secret organizations at every turn", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00831-00197639-00197847": "you're the strongest person i know what", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00832-00197848-00198111": "are we to do against these forces who", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00833-00198112-00198390": "for all my life i've known how to keep", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00834-00198391-00198614": "an eye over my shoulder and now at every", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00835-00198615-00198702": "turn", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00836-00198703-00198926": "we take it in the teeth she walks over", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00837-00198927-00199126": "to you she puts a hand on your shoulder", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00838-00199127-00199454": "and she pushes you down with her to the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00839-00199455-00199663": "floor of this room and puts a hand on", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00840-00199664-00199950": "the floor feel that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00841-00199951-00200283": "look around you my son time", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00842-00200284-00200623": "swallows the hubris and arrogance of all", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00843-00200624-00200919": "those who seek to raise themselves above", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00844-00200920-00201190": "the natural order i know these times are", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00845-00201191-00201454": "trying but the stone", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00846-00201455-00201726": "is patient i ask you to be patient as", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00847-00201727-00202014": "well helen just takes a deep breath very", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00848-00202015-00202302": "quietly as they're both sitting on the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00849-00202303-00202559": "floor we endure", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00850-00202560-00202871": "beyond all else we endure", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00851-00202872-00203078": "then she rises i shall provide you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00852-00203079-00203287": "directions to the vault i just ask you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00853-00203288-00203502": "to stand guard over it tonight and if", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00854-00203503-00203719": "you do that your sacrifice will be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00855-00203720-00204047": "honored and we shall sacrifice in kind i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00856-00204048-00204238": "get up and nod", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00857-00204239-00204566": "thank you she returns to her throne she", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00858-00204567-00204654": "pets", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00859-00204655-00204934": "mulch a little bit behind the ears i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00860-00204935-00205206": "need to speak to edric she nods yeah we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00861-00205207-00205438": "can end that scene here great", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00862-00205439-00205734": "good stuff god damn thank you you're in", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00863-00205735-00206006": "the audience hall of stonehaven what", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00864-00206007-00206303": "next do you do allen looks at", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00865-00206304-00206703": "two undead wolves before the throne", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00866-00206704-00206879": "friends there's something i think i need", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00867-00206880-00207158": "to do that will help us forgive me but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00868-00207159-00207334": "will you wait for me here where are you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00869-00207335-00207606": "going alwyn has provided us much aid i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00870-00207607-00207814": "don't think he owes us an explanation", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00871-00207815-00208006": "it's alright little bill look i'm going", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00872-00208007-00208206": "to speak to edric he's being kept in his", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00873-00208207-00208431": "chambers okay probably shouldn't be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00874-00208432-00208614": "there for that anyway you'd prefer to go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00875-00208615-00208703": "alone", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00876-00208704-00208934": "for the time being it won't be long all", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00877-00208935-00209238": "right you can easily enough find etric's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00878-00209239-00209494": "room the door is shut i approach the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00879-00209496-00209582": "door", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00880-00209583-00209671": "and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00881-00209671-00209927": "stop for a moment and then i without", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00882-00209928-00210031": "knocking", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00883-00210032-00210239": "enter okay as you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00884-00210240-00210591": "walk in you see edric standing on a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00885-00210592-00210687": "chair", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00886-00210688-00211015": "a book in hand a piece of chalk in the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00887-00211016-00211198": "other vigorously", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00888-00211200-00211542": "writing on the stone walls some sort of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00889-00211544-00211975": "magical formula muttering", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00890-00211976-00212334": "what's in all the undead gods beneath", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00891-00212335-00212663": "this earth are you doing well so we're", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00892-00212664-00212887": "talking again are we get done from there", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00893-00212888-00213055": "you could kill yourself", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00894-00213056-00213213": "you look ridiculous", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00895-00213214-00213406": "[Laughter]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00896-00213407-00213663": "oh we're joking again are we you shut up", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00897-00213664-00213815": "and sit down", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00898-00213816-00214094": "we're still arguing though still arguing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00899-00214096-00214310": "all right i can't make any sense of any", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00900-00214311-00214582": "of this anyhow slams the chalk down on a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00901-00214583-00214855": "desk as he steps down from the chair", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00902-00214856-00215046": "shuts the book angrily and throws it on", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00903-00215048-00215415": "his bed so have your last few weeks been", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00904-00215416-00215631": "i'll be the one asking the questions", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00905-00215632-00215871": "i'll start with a simple one all right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00906-00215871-00216103": "now tell me true when you picked up that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00907-00216104-00216398": "gyre was it your thought or its", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00908-00216400-00216663": "to take it to the combine i don't think", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00909-00216664-00216991": "i was enchanted by it sort of ponders", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00910-00216992-00217294": "for a moment but i did feel with it a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00911-00217296-00217446": "sort of pull", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00912-00217448-00217663": "but it was my own choice to do what i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00913-00217664-00217871": "did i thought if i brought it where it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00914-00217871-00218110": "wanted to go it would be easier to get", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00915-00218111-00218358": "the answers but uh he sort of looks at", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00916-00218359-00218623": "the scratching all over his walls i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00917-00218623-00218782": "should have known it was never going to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00918-00218783-00219055": "be easy to get the answers allen looks", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00919-00219056-00219182": "down at the floor", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00920-00219183-00219479": "trying to keep up the stern face", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00921-00219480-00219742": "from what is quickly fading to sullen", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00922-00219744-00220031": "after hearing that response", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00923-00220032-00220327": "this business you've gotten us into i've", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00924-00220328-00220494": "recently learned that it's got a lot", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00925-00220496-00220791": "more to do the great many things in this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00926-00220792-00221103": "city he sort of looks confused at you my", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00927-00221104-00221334": "business with the guild pact keeps", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00928-00221335-00221671": "bringing me back to taganti to this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00929-00221671-00221991": "consortium to all of this dark business", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00930-00221992-00222239": "in the corners of the darkness in this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00931-00222240-00222479": "undercity the thought", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00932-00222480-00222663": "foolishly perhaps", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00933-00222664-00222942": "maybe they just twisted your ear i don't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00934-00222944-00223103": "know what i expected", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00935-00223104-00223398": "i'm sorry i'm confused i don't know", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00936-00223400-00223631": "anything about anything you just said i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00937-00223632-00223846": "mean taganti yes but can i make it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00938-00223848-00224079": "inside yeah go ahead", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00939-00224080-00224319": "23. he seems pretty bewildered by what", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00940-00224319-00224542": "you're saying i don't know of any", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00941-00224544-00224782": "consortium", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00942-00224783-00225061": "hang on let me you roll me history check", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00943-00225062-00225279": "[Music]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00944-00225280-00225551": "they were all crime syndicate thieves", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00945-00225552-00225734": "sort of an offshoot of the dimmer or", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00946-00225735-00225934": "something like this proficient", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00947-00225935-00226182": "history i should have known this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00948-00226183-00226463": "well they haven't been active in years", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00949-00226464-00226694": "so you know who they are i mean", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00950-00226696-00227006": "rumors and such they say the the farmer", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00951-00227007-00227294": "living guild pact used to work for him", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00952-00227296-00227375": "but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00953-00227376-00227646": "again that's not confirmed and possibly", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00954-00227648-00227782": "propaganda", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00955-00227783-00227967": "they were here and then they weren't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00956-00227967-00228223": "likely stamped out by their competitors", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00957-00228223-00228494": "or absorbed into the dimmer well i've", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00958-00228496-00228742": "got an ally downstairs who was nearly", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00959-00228744-00229015": "choked by some foul magic", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00960-00229016-00229263": "just by saying one of their names well i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00961-00229264-00229431": "won't say that's out of character for", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00962-00229432-00229742": "them perhaps someone trying to use their", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00963-00229744-00229855": "mystique", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00964-00229856-00230158": "to start another operation make no", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00965-00230159-00230423": "mistake when i say this i'm still mad as", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00966-00230423-00230591": "hell's you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00967-00230592-00230823": "but the fight i'm about to get into", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00968-00230823-00231046": "the fight that we're about to get into i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00969-00231048-00231279": "saw you down there when that gyre", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00970-00231280-00231575": "abomination attacked i may hate you for", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00971-00231576-00231767": "what you did but i'm not gonna call you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00972-00231767-00232023": "a bad fighter idric i don't know what's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00973-00232023-00232287": "going on with you any sort of gestures", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00974-00232288-00232551": "to the whole room yeah this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00975-00232552-00232863": "quest you're on this transformation we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00976-00232864-00233191": "may need your help real persuasion", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00977-00233192-00233415": "is that no", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00978-00233416-00233710": "that's a flat three", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00979-00233711-00233871": "patrick looks at you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00980-00233871-00233951": "and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00981-00233952-00234158": "his eyebrows narrow", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00982-00234159-00234239": "and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00983-00234240-00234534": "he raises his voice you're", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00984-00234535-00234798": "unhappy with me how do you think i feel", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00985-00234800-00234982": "i'm trying to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00986-00234983-00235279": "make amends but you took everything i'd", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00987-00235280-00235527": "been working on from me i was making", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00988-00235528-00235871": "progress in the sanctum and now it's all", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00989-00235871-00236158": "just a jumble i'm not saying i was close", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00990-00236159-00236327": "i'm not saying i was close it's not a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00991-00236328-00236551": "problem you can never really be close to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00992-00236552-00236855": "solving but at least to the next", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00993-00236856-00237015": "question that will get you to the next", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00994-00237016-00237358": "question i was making a breakthrough the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00995-00237359-00237719": "primordial enigma the i interrupt what", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00996-00237719-00238063": "he's saying by taking him in both hands", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00997-00238064-00238246": "and slamming him up against the wall", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00998-00238248-00238510": "alwyn is bigger than edric yeah go ahead", "HD_7ue6f0OU-00999-00238511-00238958": "and make an athletics check", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01000-00238959-00239310": "oh no yeah oh my god", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01001-00239311-00239415": "i thought", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01002-00239416-00239719": "i thought i could pull this off well i i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01003-00239719-00239879": "you do have your inspiration die if this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01004-00239880-00240046": "moment isn't i'm gonna use it because", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01005-00240048-00240287": "that was a one", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01006-00240288-00240582": "that was a one", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01007-00240583-00240741": "i know", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01008-00240742-00240967": "[Music]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01009-00240967-00241206": "holy", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01010-00241207-00241423": "did it did it go from a one to a two or", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01011-00241423-00241575": "something like that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01012-00241576-00241767": "it went to a six", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01013-00241767-00241894": "okay that's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01014-00241896-00242158": "which is a total which is a total of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01015-00242159-00242255": "seven", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01016-00242256-00242439": "that's kind of funny", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01017-00242440-00242694": "your brother also rolled the one oh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01018-00242696-00243071": "my god", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01019-00243071-00243310": "get the out you slam him against", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01020-00243311-00243551": "the wall and it's not gracefully at all", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01021-00243552-00243903": "it's like how two teenage boys would", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01022-00243904-00244127": "would rough house right you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01023-00244128-00244358": "you first bar fight like", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01024-00244359-00244591": "his shoulders and he stumbles back into", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01025-00244592-00244758": "the wall i'll be having none of that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01026-00244759-00244991": "from you i dragged you out of that foul", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01027-00244992-00245255": "place for your own life not to save it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01028-00245256-00245463": "for you but to save it for mother and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01029-00245464-00245663": "don't you forget that i don't give a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01030-00245664-00245942": "damn about your research about this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01031-00245944-00246246": "sick quest i care about this family i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01032-00246248-00246527": "care about her about this house i didn't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01033-00246528-00246710": "abandon it the first drop of some", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01034-00246711-00246846": "trinket", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01035-00246848-00247030": "i'm asking you for help not because i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01036-00247031-00247334": "want to but because we have to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01037-00247335-00247582": "i could have known secrets about the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01038-00247583-00247919": "nature of life itself and part of that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01039-00247919-00248206": "you took from me and it hurts there's an", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01040-00248207-00248327": "emptiness", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01041-00248328-00248606": "not just in my mind where the questions", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01042-00248607-00248894": "still swirl but in my heart because you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01043-00248896-00249063": "couldn't understand", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01044-00249064-00249191": "i've tried", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01045-00249192-00249319": "i have", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01046-00249319-00249591": "i know i'm not ungrateful", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01047-00249592-00249903": "i am to some extent glad that i'm home", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01048-00249904-00250198": "but there's something missing that's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01049-00250200-00250351": "gnawing at me", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01050-00250352-00250671": "maybe it'll be quiet someday but not yet", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01051-00250671-00250919": "and i'm not ready to forgive you besides", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01052-00250919-00251158": "mother won't let me out of the house so", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01053-00251159-00251303": "i'm afraid you'll have to fight this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01054-00251304-00251630": "fight on your own", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01055-00251631-00251967": "yeah well i could still take your throws", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01056-00251967-00252082": "don't you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01057-00252083-00252519": "forget ah so we're joking again are we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01058-00252519-00252710": "dude if we make it out of this thing we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01059-00252711-00252910": "gotta get your head looked at", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01060-00252911-00253023": "[Music]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01061-00253023-00253423": "ah maybe you're right maybe he goes back", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01062-00253423-00253734": "sits on his bed opens the book up again", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01063-00253735-00253855": "can i leave", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01064-00253856-00254103": "okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01065-00254104-00254471": "so how'd it go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01066-00254471-00254734": "oh my god", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01067-00254735-00255063": "what", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01068-00255064-00255334": "we used a foolish favor to a foolish boy", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01069-00255335-00255606": "we'd ask you to move on hmm that good", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01070-00255607-00255927": "huh clork yeah is there any way your", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01071-00255928-00256006": "great", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01072-00256007-00256263": "dragon master would be able to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01073-00256264-00256558": "know if someone's mind not their", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01074-00256559-00256927": "memories but their intentions have been", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01075-00256928-00257223": "tempered with yeah without doubt", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01076-00257223-00257415": "firemind can do whatever he wants i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01077-00257416-00257623": "suspect this isn't the end of our", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01078-00257623-00257919": "encounter with dr taganti and those foul", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01079-00257919-00258175": "gyres done below you planning something", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01080-00258176-00258375": "he's himself but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01081-00258376-00258510": "sort of bent", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01082-00258511-00258839": "skewed somehow to some extreme part of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01083-00258840-00259110": "himself i can't make sense of it cork", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01084-00259111-00259391": "you can make an insight check here okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01085-00259392-00259615": "i have very little like player knowledge", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01086-00259616-00259782": "of what is possibly going on here and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01087-00259783-00259998": "this is just alwyn grasping at stars", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01088-00260000-00260287": "well here goes uh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01089-00260288-00260623": "a flat 18. clark you hear the way that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01090-00260623-00260863": "allen is sort of describing his brother", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01091-00260864-00261127": "and it sort of rings a bit of a bell for", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01092-00261128-00261215": "you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01093-00261216-00261527": "you've been a lab assistant long enough", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01094-00261528-00261782": "to know when someone is just obsessed", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01095-00261783-00262039": "with a problem and that's kind of what", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01096-00262040-00262310": "this sounds like clerk furrows his brow", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01097-00262311-00262623": "hmm you think maybe he's just uh really", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01098-00262624-00262758": "into what he's doing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01099-00262759-00262975": "part of me honestly is afraid of that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01100-00262976-00263167": "and what would that mean for you i'm not", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01101-00263168-00263382": "sure like i said he's always been like", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01102-00263383-00263551": "this but i mean", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01103-00263552-00263775": "i think a little bit of curiosity or", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01104-00263776-00264015": "sometimes a lot of curiosity can be a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01105-00264016-00264215": "good thing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01106-00264216-00264455": "why it can cloak your font of wisdom", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01107-00264456-00264767": "never ceases to amaze me thank you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01108-00264768-00265143": "you're welcome", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01109-00265144-00265327": "i was being sincere", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01110-00265328-00265471": "the fact that clerk didn't know what to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01111-00265472-00265687": "do with it yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01112-00265688-00266023": "it's so good", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01113-00266024-00266239": "incredible all right so if there's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01114-00266240-00266455": "nothing else you want to do here a few", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01115-00266456-00266727": "hours will pass before renault will be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01116-00266728-00266879": "like it's time", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01117-00266880-00267006": "you'll want to leave through the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01118-00267007-00267334": "dungeons if you don't want the watch to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01119-00267335-00267558": "see you here's probably the best route", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01120-00267559-00267815": "handsy a rolled up parchment as she's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01121-00267816-00268015": "giving this to us i do kind of want to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01122-00268016-00268391": "just briefly mention because alwyn", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01123-00268392-00268623": "didn't connect these the last time we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01124-00268624-00268743": "were here", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01125-00268744-00269047": "mother on our travels as of late we've", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01126-00269048-00269295": "run into a gorgon very fine woman by the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01127-00269296-00269558": "name of lana she said she knew you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01128-00269559-00269927": "from a long time ago i we've been close", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01129-00269928-00270006": "for", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01130-00270007-00270303": "centuries i'd say but she's got her", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01131-00270304-00270551": "little patch of ground still talk to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01132-00270552-00270695": "each other you know she told me you were", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01133-00270696-00270927": "quite helpful to her i wonder if she'd", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01134-00270928-00271230": "be able to help us in any way she's a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01135-00271231-00271479": "fiercely skilled botanist i'll say", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01136-00271480-00271687": "that's not the only thing she's fiercely", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01137-00271688-00271943": "skilled that i thought as much could you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01138-00271944-00272343": "send a message i can be safe my child i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01139-00272344-00272599": "don't know what might be coming for you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01140-00272600-00272815": "through those tunnels tonight i'll be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01141-00272816-00273030": "sure did you pack a late night snack", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01142-00273031-00273503": "i've got sausages of dubious origin", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01143-00273504-00273727": "oh my favorite i'm sure clark would love", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01144-00273728-00273863": "some ah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01145-00273864-00274103": "our good friend here does love dodgy", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01146-00274104-00274199": "meats", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01147-00274200-00274510": "she like sends a servant to go get some", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01148-00274511-00274687": "brings you like a little bag full of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01149-00274688-00274982": "these sausages ah it's great okay get", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01150-00274983-00275351": "used to that oh yeah all right okay you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01151-00275352-00275671": "head down through the lower levels of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01152-00275672-00275958": "stonehaven out a secret door in the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01153-00275959-00276055": "dungeon", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01154-00276056-00276151": "into", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01155-00276152-00276334": "another network of tunnels within the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01156-00276335-00276591": "undercity with this map i'm going to say", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01157-00276592-00276775": "alwyn just roll me survival with", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01158-00276776-00277119": "advantage to lead the party okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01159-00277120-00277263": "i haven't traveled these puzzles in", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01160-00277264-00277351": "years", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01161-00277352-00277487": "that's a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01162-00277488-00277775": "22. with ease you can find the vault she", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01163-00277776-00277910": "spoke of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01164-00277911-00278151": "vault is sort of a generous descriptor", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01165-00278152-00278367": "nothing like the elaborately", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01166-00278368-00278567": "shaped and consecrated vaults you were", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01167-00278568-00278903": "in just a few nights ago you come to a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01168-00278904-00279151": "large archway that leads into another", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01169-00279152-00279567": "cavern and it's got a makeshift door of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01170-00279568-00279879": "heavy wooden slats sort of built over it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01171-00279880-00280206": "but this looks to be the place there is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01172-00280207-00280279": "a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01173-00280280-00280534": "path leading off the way you came and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01174-00280535-00280871": "then another path leading deeper into", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01175-00280872-00281175": "the undercity both of these large", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01176-00281176-00281423": "worm tunnels and you think the cavern", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01177-00281424-00281782": "beyond might also be a similarly immense", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01178-00281783-00281967": "holding area where perhaps a worm", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01179-00281968-00282158": "hibernated you can tell that these", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01180-00282159-00282358": "tunnels are probably", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01181-00282359-00282687": "20 by 20 in all directions could be all", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01182-00282688-00282895": "manner of creatures down here not just", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01183-00282896-00283158": "our enemies watch your step friends i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01184-00283159-00283334": "mean if this if this seems like kind of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01185-00283335-00283615": "the entrance to this structure i will go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01186-00283616-00283958": "ahead and cast pass that trace okay you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01187-00283959-00284199": "cast pass without chase are you going to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01188-00284200-00284399": "try and like hide and maybe set up an", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01189-00284400-00284582": "ambush yeah i guess that was like my", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01190-00284583-00284775": "intention sure everyone go ahead and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01191-00284776-00284958": "roll me stealth no then let's not do", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01192-00284959-00285263": "this like those boros up in the wastes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01193-00285264-00285463": "yeah we should hide we should prepare", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01194-00285464-00285599": "what if that's what they're expecting us", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01195-00285600-00285682": "to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01196-00285683-00286006": "do i love this 5d chess clerk that's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01197-00286007-00286254": "emerging tonight", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01198-00286255-00286463": "i just look right back at clerk and i go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01199-00286464-00286575": "and what if that's what they're", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01200-00286576-00286823": "expecting us to expect them to do oh my", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01201-00286824-00287334": "god you're right we gotta hide", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01202-00287335-00287495": "i won't get ill pal", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01203-00287496-00287663": "and just in case they're expecting us", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01204-00287664-00287975": "let's hide very well i roll the 16. is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01205-00287976-00288334": "that including the plus 10 no that's 26.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01206-00288335-00288758": "17. 29. all very good rolls you blend", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01207-00288759-00289087": "into the shadows along the cavern wall", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01208-00289088-00289406": "let's see if any of these comes up 20.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01209-00289407-00289687": "if i also have time before whatever", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01210-00289688-00289967": "happens happens you do you don't know", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01211-00289968-00290167": "how much time though less than eight", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01212-00290168-00290343": "hours i'm sure i'm gonna put up mage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01213-00290344-00290567": "armor very good that's not worth it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01214-00290568-00290927": "never mind so after about", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01215-00290928-00291182": "30 minutes of you lying in ambush", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01216-00291183-00291406": "everyone roll me perception", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01217-00291407-00291743": "i would definitely also have chileli up", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01218-00291744-00291863": "and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01219-00291864-00292215": "hold entity for like the first sign of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01220-00292216-00292487": "action okay have it like ready to take", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01221-00292488-00292815": "form yeah sure so perception i got a nat", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01222-00292816-00293119": "20 for a total of 22. nice allen's only", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01223-00293120-00293230": "got a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01224-00293231-00293447": "12. i got a 2.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01225-00293448-00293639": "okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01226-00293640-00293806": "everyone but clark", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01227-00293807-00293958": "hears", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01228-00293959-00294151": "alarm bells", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01229-00294152-00294319": "squelching", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01230-00294320-00294406": "of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01231-00294407-00294575": "feet through", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01232-00294576-00294806": "wet dirt approaching you clark is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01233-00294807-00295054": "chewing on sausage lapel you can look", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01234-00295055-00295391": "and see in the distance coming towards", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01235-00295392-00295791": "this doorway a group of skeletons with", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01236-00295792-00296134": "spears and behind them a couple more", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01237-00296135-00296463": "skeletons with bows advancing in a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01238-00296464-00296734": "military manner i'll look to alan and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01239-00296735-00296934": "clark and just gesture them like you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01240-00296935-00297047": "know stay low", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01241-00297048-00297223": "stay hidden i'll do a gesture of like", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01242-00297224-00297382": "you know turning my head back and forth", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01243-00297383-00297567": "side to side like it doesn't look good", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01244-00297568-00297767": "get down come moving what", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01245-00297768-00297943": "what are you waving at what are you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01246-00297944-00298103": "doing shh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01247-00298104-00298343": "quiet yourself quiet yourself right now", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01248-00298344-00298599": "i don't see anything would always think", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01249-00298600-00298823": "that skeletons are", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01250-00298824-00299063": "friends yeah or would from what rennet", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01251-00299064-00299215": "told me would i just assume these are", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01252-00299216-00299495": "the perpetrators we're only like a flat", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01253-00299496-00299767": "wisdom check cool", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01254-00299768-00300047": "well this dice that gave me uh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01255-00300048-00300327": "seven nat 20s in one game has so far", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01256-00300328-00300534": "given me three nat ones in this game so", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01257-00300535-00300791": "that's six sometimes in under city", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01258-00300792-00301079": "skeletons good sometimes in undercity", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01259-00301080-00301319": "skeleton's bad you don't no you can't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01260-00301320-00301551": "assume they're just people man yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01261-00301552-00301791": "profiling is bad dude don't do it okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01262-00301792-00302006": "all right i just stay low and throw up", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01263-00302007-00302167": "entity i don't know what's happening", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01264-00302168-00302375": "okay anyone else doing anything as these", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01265-00302376-00302558": "skeletons march down the corridor", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01266-00302559-00302871": "continuing to shush clork what skeleton", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01267-00302872-00303151": "did we even look in the vault do we know", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01268-00303152-00303430": "that there's eternals in there i mean", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01269-00303431-00303687": "your mom told you there were right but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01270-00303688-00303895": "is it a situation where like they could", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01271-00303896-00304006": "i don't know i don't know what's going", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01272-00304007-00304167": "on i roll the six", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01273-00304168-00304527": "okay these skeletons come to the vault", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01274-00304528-00304806": "door and they begin banging on it with", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01275-00304807-00305095": "the butts of their spears well that's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01276-00305096-00305287": "not a great sign okay are they all kind", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01277-00305288-00305495": "of close together you said it's sort of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01278-00305496-00305679": "like a formation right yeah there's like", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01279-00305680-00305982": "four of them standing arm to arm across", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01280-00305983-00306151": "the length of this tunnel and then", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01281-00306152-00306406": "there's two of them behind with bows i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01282-00306407-00306582": "sort of look at lapel and kind of shrug", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01283-00306583-00306767": "and be like is this it do you really", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01284-00306768-00306958": "want to engage i mean i'm the only one", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01285-00306959-00307103": "who would know this and i don't know", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01286-00307104-00307415": "this so i guess we're doing it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01287-00307416-00307606": "alwyn's gonna throw out an entangle on", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01288-00307607-00307806": "as many as he can get okay cool everyone", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01289-00307807-00308087": "let's roll initiative great", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01290-00308088-00308375": "one of the skeletons did get in that 20.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01291-00308376-00308647": "so did i on its perception check so one", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01292-00308648-00308806": "of them will get to go in the surprise", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01293-00308807-00309071": "round okay i got an 18 initiative i got", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01294-00309072-00309375": "a dirty 20. i got a 20 with a three is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01295-00309376-00309519": "23.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01296-00309520-00309751": "all right illapal you're up first", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01297-00309752-00309839": "all right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01298-00309840-00310063": "i'm going to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01299-00310064-00310254": "hit as many of them as i can with fairy", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01300-00310255-00310751": "fire uh okay oh yeah uh deck saves", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01301-00310752-00311063": "oh well one of them got an 18 i've got a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01302-00311064-00311406": "5 10 and four on three more of them", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01303-00311407-00311575": "yeah so it looks like two of them pass", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01304-00311576-00311791": "and the rest of them fail there's six", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01305-00311792-00311991": "total right correct", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01306-00311992-00312279": "cool i will use bonus action", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01307-00312280-00312479": "to alwyn i will say", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01308-00312480-00312695": "i've illuminated them for you your", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01309-00312696-00312927": "courage should do the rest i give a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01310-00312928-00313206": "daring nod okay skeleton number one is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01311-00313207-00313510": "up next it made its perception check it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01312-00313511-00313719": "gets to go in the surprise round it's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01313-00313720-00314039": "going to raise its spear and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01314-00314040-00314271": "attempt to stab illapal", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01315-00314272-00314510": "with a 22 to hit", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01316-00314511-00314767": "for maximum of 10 points of piercing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01317-00314768-00314967": "damage yikes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01318-00314968-00315247": "cool good way to start the new rest", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01319-00315248-00315367": "cycle", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01320-00315368-00315623": "okay clerk you're up all right right off", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01321-00315624-00315799": "the bat let's do a second level chaos", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01322-00315800-00316199": "bolt nice just write it uh oh yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01323-00316200-00316303": "one of these", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01324-00316304-00316534": "are there entangled ones now i don't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01325-00316535-00316734": "think i got that off yet yeah alvin", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01326-00316735-00316999": "hasn't gone yet uh okay got it okay but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01327-00317000-00317230": "there are fairy fired ones yes there are", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01328-00317231-00317495": "four of them four of them okay i'm gonna", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01329-00317496-00317630": "fire up the chaos bolt at one of the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01330-00317631-00317903": "fairy fired ones great", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01331-00317904-00318167": "14 to hit with advantage with advantage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01332-00318168-00318303": "actually this matters are you attacking", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01333-00318304-00318510": "one of the spearmen or one of the bowmen", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01334-00318511-00318647": "i guess the spearmint because they were", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01335-00318648-00318854": "closer to the unfortunately that is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01336-00318855-00319158": "gonna miss spearman they have shields", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01337-00319159-00319423": "okay i'm so sorry that's all right are", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01338-00319424-00319567": "you adding your proficiency to your", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01339-00319568-00319791": "attack rolls yeah of course i rolled a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01340-00319792-00320006": "three and a nine and i added five", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01341-00320007-00320191": "it's it's crazy because like it's not", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01342-00320192-00320447": "like the die is weighted badly cuz like", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01343-00320448-00320679": "the low numbers are on all sides of the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01344-00320680-00320982": "die", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01345-00320983-00321175": "it just comes up with any any number", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01346-00321176-00321454": "below 10. always clark is very much a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01347-00321455-00321815": "tragic figure here yep yeah your chaos", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01348-00321816-00321982": "bolt grazes off the shield of this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01349-00321983-00322206": "skeleton", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01350-00322207-00322391": "okay hold on maybe i should do something", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01351-00322392-00322639": "else um", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01352-00322640-00322830": "it i'm gonna try again", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01353-00322831-00323030": "all right you got this all right same", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01354-00323031-00323367": "thing second level chaos bolt right at", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01355-00323368-00323887": "this time one of the archers okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01356-00323888-00324158": "it's a 15. 15 hits", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01357-00324159-00324519": "thank god all right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01358-00324520-00324799": "that's really good damage that's 21", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01359-00324800-00325239": "lightning damage jesus it explodes in a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01360-00325240-00325551": "shower of bone fragments elder", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01361-00325552-00325806": "scroll style just oh yeah it does", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01362-00325807-00325991": "good that was worth two second level", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01363-00325992-00326134": "spell slots", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01364-00326135-00326358": "kill one skeleton all right here", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01365-00326359-00326396": "we go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01366-00326397-00326599": "[Laughter]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01367-00326600-00326823": "okay alwyn you're up i'm gonna do what i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01368-00326824-00326967": "was gonna do i'm gonna cast and tangle", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01369-00326968-00327199": "on as many as i can get that's a 20 foot", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01370-00327200-00327439": "20 foot square okay yeah that's a deck", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01371-00327440-00327639": "save from all of them that's a strength", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01372-00327640-00327839": "save from all of them", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01373-00327840-00328199": "okay uh what's your dc my dc is now a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01374-00328200-00328654": "15. 15. okay so two passes two fails", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01375-00328655-00328854": "three fails cool", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01376-00328855-00329151": "uh so they're restrained okay hopefully", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01377-00329152-00329295": "the ones that failed were the ones that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01378-00329296-00329558": "were away from clergy and then i'm gonna", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01379-00329559-00329743": "tank in front of as many of these guys", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01380-00329744-00329967": "that are not restrained as possible okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01381-00329968-00330151": "well the rest of them are surprised we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01382-00330152-00330327": "go back to the top illapal i think i'm", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01383-00330328-00330534": "gonna just melee the one attacking us", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01384-00330535-00330710": "the one attack that attacked me", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01385-00330711-00330919": "okay very good", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01386-00330920-00331119": "is that one of the fairy fired ones or", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01387-00331120-00331382": "no that one is saved against everything", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01388-00331383-00331615": "cool this guy get him", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01389-00331616-00331927": "oh i'm gonna with an at 20.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01390-00331928-00332134": "i'm sorry that rule's too good you miss", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01391-00332135-00332471": "you love to see it i do love to see it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01392-00332472-00332575": "six", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01393-00332576-00332903": "and seven um we'll just call it 17 then", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01394-00332904-00333103": "piercing damage even with it being a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01395-00333104-00333295": "bony creature and piercing weapons", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01396-00333296-00333623": "passing through it you manage to stab it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01397-00333624-00333967": "knock its head clean off this one falls", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01398-00333968-00334254": "skeleton number three is fairy fired not", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01399-00334255-00334510": "entangled it's going to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01400-00334511-00334815": "run up to alwyn and take a stab i'll go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01401-00334816-00335030": "ahead and have this one make the spore", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01402-00335031-00335310": "save 16 on the con save yeah that passes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01403-00335311-00335495": "okay just passes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01404-00335496-00335895": "uh and uh 19 on the to hit yep 58 for", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01405-00335896-00336015": "the sphere", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01406-00336016-00336271": "do your worst it's worst is five points", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01407-00336272-00336439": "of piercing damage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01408-00336440-00336663": "cork we are back to you all right i'm", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01409-00336664-00336871": "gonna use lightning lore on one of these", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01410-00336872-00337167": "are any hurt no you've both one shot two", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01411-00337168-00337343": "of them", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01412-00337344-00337519": "there are none injured there's one who", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01413-00337520-00337671": "just ran up to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01414-00337672-00337878": "al and there's another three that are", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01415-00337879-00338119": "caught in this sort of entangling vines", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01416-00338120-00338310": "are there any within melee range", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01417-00338311-00338503": "available you could make one be within", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01418-00338504-00338743": "melee range of lfl i could pull one past", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01419-00338744-00338991": "the lapel yeah all right i'm gonna do", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01420-00338992-00339151": "that i'm gonna use lightning lord to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01421-00339152-00339375": "pull one of them past lapel and that is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01422-00339376-00339671": "gonna be a strength save", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01423-00339672-00339895": "it rolled at 12 on its strength save i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01424-00339896-00340247": "imagine that fails that does fail", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01425-00340248-00340551": "because i believe my yeah my save is 13.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01426-00340552-00340767": "okay so it's going to pass through lapel", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01427-00340768-00340943": "space and the lapel is going to take an", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01428-00340944-00341215": "attack of opportunity sure", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01429-00341216-00341447": "17 17 hits", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01430-00341448-00341719": "and that is seven piercings", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01431-00341720-00341887": "okay and as i pull it the rest of the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01432-00341888-00342143": "way towards me it's gonna take eight", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01433-00342144-00342310": "lightning damage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01434-00342311-00342678": "nice okay this one explodes in a shower", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01435-00342679-00342975": "of bones i put up my hand like for a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01436-00342976-00343263": "high five towards a philapel", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01437-00343264-00343630": "gives a polite nod and then after a half", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01438-00343631-00343958": "second does an air high five back yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01439-00343959-00344199": "ellen you're up awesome are there any", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01440-00344200-00344334": "still", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01441-00344335-00344639": "standing that are not entangled there's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01442-00344640-00344895": "the one right in your face okay great", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01443-00344896-00345063": "i'm gonna hit it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01444-00345064-00345287": "that's a nineteen that hits this with", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01445-00345288-00345543": "gavel this is chile lead that's nine", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01446-00345544-00345823": "bludgeoning and three necrotic okay yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01447-00345824-00346054": "this one crumples to the ground", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01448-00346055-00346287": "this one's gone awesome this feels too", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01449-00346288-00346623": "easy this can't be all i'm gonna step", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01450-00346624-00346910": "towards the next nearest and swing again", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01451-00346911-00347023": "okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01452-00347024-00347206": "and because they're entangled still an", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01453-00347207-00347471": "advantage that is a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01454-00347472-00347791": "19 plus mod yes hits", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01455-00347792-00348078": "on chile lead", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01456-00348079-00348382": "that is six bludgeoning three night okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01457-00348383-00348751": "its bones are cracked and broken but it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01458-00348752-00349015": "still seems to retain some fighting", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01459-00349016-00349167": "spirit it's going to direct that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01460-00349168-00349375": "fighting spirit towards you hell yeah i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01461-00349376-00349527": "just kind of spit in its face and go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01462-00349528-00349751": "who's you knowing that skeletons can't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01463-00349752-00349991": "talk back it's restrained so", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01464-00349992-00350254": "disadvantage on this it would have hit", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01465-00350255-00350510": "with a 19 but the disadvantaged roll is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01466-00350511-00350903": "in that one yeah get out of the car", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01467-00350904-00351110": "and the other one going to launch an", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01468-00351111-00351271": "arrow at you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01469-00351272-00351703": "15 hits 15 just hits you take six points", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01470-00351704-00351919": "of piercing damage cool cool let me go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01471-00351920-00352167": "ahead and con save i passed the first", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01472-00352168-00352391": "one let me just make another one for the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01473-00352392-00352558": "five damage they took before they roll", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01474-00352559-00352791": "four and i passed the other one okay you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01475-00352792-00353015": "retain concentration on your entangle", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01476-00353016-00353287": "illapel we return to you all right it's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01477-00353288-00353471": "funny because i'm trying to save my", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01478-00353472-00353782": "spell slots i would did allen not just", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01479-00353783-00353967": "kill the one that he went after", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01480-00353968-00354206": "no it's still standing still standing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01481-00354207-00354303": "looking", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01482-00354304-00354551": "hurt on a scale of one to twelve it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01483-00354552-00354847": "seems to be a three all right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01484-00354848-00354999": "i'm just gonna attack the nearest one", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01485-00355000-00355310": "yeah do you have to make a save as you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01486-00355311-00355543": "enter the entanglement no saves only on", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01487-00355544-00355687": "cast and then it's difficult to reign", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01488-00355688-00355887": "thereafter okay it's difficult terrain", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01489-00355888-00356078": "but these tunnels aren't so wide that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01490-00356079-00356319": "you can't get to this creature okay i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01491-00356320-00356439": "probably have advantage because there is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01492-00356440-00356647": "ferry fire on it still right yes my", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01493-00356648-00356871": "first roll was a 14 for a dirty 20 so i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01494-00356872-00357006": "don't think i need it but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01495-00357007-00357310": "yeah dirty 20. yup you hit and seven on", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01496-00357311-00357519": "the diet plus four is eleven this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01497-00357520-00357727": "did", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01498-00357728-00358047": "okay this one is bone dust one archer", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01499-00358048-00358287": "remains cork it's your turn all right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01500-00358288-00358478": "these guys don't seem very strong so i'm", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01501-00358479-00358639": "gonna run up in lightning lower this one", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01502-00358640-00358839": "now okay that's a strength save strength", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01503-00358840-00359087": "safe right that's me rolling a die seven", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01504-00359088-00359271": "plus nothing ain't gonna do it no it's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01505-00359272-00359534": "not so i'm gonna pull him towards me", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01506-00359535-00359719": "and he's gonna take two lightning damage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01507-00359720-00359887": "okay and then i'm gonna disengage as a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01508-00359888-00360167": "bonus action very good yeah elwyn your", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01509-00360168-00360406": "turn okay yeah gonna hit him", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01510-00360407-00360687": "that's a 18 hits", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01511-00360688-00361039": "that should do that's 10 bludgeoning 65.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01512-00361040-00361254": "more than sufficient the last skeleton", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01513-00361255-00361527": "is no more well as you said it was", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01514-00361528-00361743": "perhaps too easy someone must have sent", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01515-00361744-00362030": "them either as a first assault or i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01516-00362031-00362271": "suspect maybe even a destruction or a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01517-00362272-00362471": "way to lure us out i'll start like", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01518-00362472-00362719": "looking around sure role perception or", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01519-00362720-00362967": "investigation are we being watched was", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01520-00362968-00363254": "that group like being followed being", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01521-00363255-00363495": "steered or something", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01522-00363496-00363758": "that is going to be a18. you don't see", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01523-00363759-00364039": "anyone else in these tunnels as far as", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01524-00364040-00364271": "you can send your dancing lights out and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01525-00364272-00364623": "the the door to this vault is closed", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01526-00364624-00364806": "correct they were banging on it with the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01527-00364807-00364975": "butts of their spears trying to break it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01528-00364976-00365215": "down is there any way i can look inside", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01529-00365216-00365454": "without opening these doors or do i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01530-00365455-00365623": "think i can open them and then close", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01531-00365624-00365887": "them or are they like big stone once", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01532-00365888-00366063": "they're open they're open it's wooden", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01533-00366064-00366391": "it's like a makeshift wooden door it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01534-00366392-00366591": "does appear locked though do you think", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01535-00366592-00366847": "they could already be inside", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01536-00366848-00367015": "i don't know if you want to make me roll", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01537-00367016-00367254": "for this but i'm having a thought here", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01538-00367255-00367567": "where i could wild shape into a tiny", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01539-00367568-00367806": "spider and go inside and look around and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01540-00367807-00367991": "come back out yeah i did say they're", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01541-00367992-00368215": "just slats of wood thrown together so", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01542-00368216-00368415": "you could probably find a little space", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01543-00368416-00368671": "between them to slip through as a spider", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01544-00368672-00368854": "i could wild shape and go inside and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01545-00368855-00369119": "have a look around see if perhaps", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01546-00369120-00369351": "they've already had their way but i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01547-00369352-00369551": "would need to take a rest after that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01548-00369552-00369743": "if we're to expect another encounter", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01549-00369744-00369878": "does this feel like a safe place where", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01550-00369879-00370127": "we could rest yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01551-00370128-00370351": "as safe as any worm tunnel in the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01552-00370352-00370519": "undercity is but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01553-00370520-00370799": "you feel like you can expect to be able", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01554-00370800-00370951": "to short rest", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01555-00370952-00371191": "very well keep an eye out if anything", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01556-00371192-00371447": "goes wrong i'll probably start hollering", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01557-00371448-00371775": "or something and i wild shape into a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01558-00371776-00371991": "poisonous spider cool make me an", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01559-00371992-00372206": "acrobatics check just to get through", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01560-00372207-00372478": "these slots love it let me go ahead and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01561-00372479-00372695": "look at the stat block quick", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01562-00372696-00372847": "great", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01563-00372848-00373006": "awesome um", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01564-00373007-00373382": "x plus three that's a 14. 14 yeah that's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01565-00373383-00373599": "fine you're a tiny spider you can", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01566-00373600-00373854": "squeeze your way through the gaps", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01567-00373855-00374054": "between these planks of wood", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01568-00374055-00374454": "you go into this large cylindrical", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01569-00374455-00374830": "cavern and you do see heaps upon heaps", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01570-00374831-00375175": "of blue encased corpses", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01571-00375176-00375439": "and actually go ahead and make me", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01572-00375440-00375630": "an investigation check while you're oh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01573-00375631-00375806": "of course", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01574-00375807-00376054": "a flat 18. oh wait", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01575-00376055-00376327": "no hold on this is the spider's stats", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01576-00376328-00376575": "minus four no i think you keep your", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01577-00376576-00376719": "mental stats oh yeah no you're right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01578-00376720-00376815": "you're right you're right you're right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01579-00376816-00377223": "i'm sorry okay so flat 18. g6", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01580-00377224-00377527": "18 yeah that's pretty good i think i'll", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01581-00377528-00377702": "give you this oh boy", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01582-00377703-00377982": "underneath these heaps and heaps of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01583-00377983-00378391": "corpses you see what looks like towards", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01584-00378392-00378806": "the back of this chasm no a long sharp", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01585-00378807-00379134": "bill sticking out of the pile", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01586-00379135-00379454": "like a waterfowl's beak i sort of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01587-00379455-00379775": "chitter to myself like what the i'm", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01588-00379776-00379999": "not gonna get close but i'm i'm not", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01589-00380000-00380223": "gonna get extremely close but i'll get", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01590-00380224-00380423": "closer okay i just wanna see if it's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01591-00380424-00380727": "like breathing alive inanimate what's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01592-00380728-00380871": "going on with this thing go ahead and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01593-00380872-00381175": "roll me one more investigation check", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01594-00381176-00381575": "it's flat 14. everything in here seems", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01595-00381576-00381895": "completely inanimate okay if things look", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01596-00381896-00382102": "quiet i'll return to the rest of the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01597-00382103-00382358": "group okay make me one more acrobatics", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01598-00382359-00382551": "check to sort of slip out sure get", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01599-00382552-00382806": "stuck in here yeah um yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01600-00382807-00383087": "that's a dirty 20. yeah no problem you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01601-00383088-00383310": "squeeze out between the gaps and the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01602-00383311-00383615": "planks i squeeze back out i drop my", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01603-00383616-00383951": "spider form you see alwyn appear before", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01604-00383952-00384071": "you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01605-00384072-00384278": "seemed quite enough all other bodies", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01606-00384279-00384495": "that's for sure and one", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01607-00384496-00384806": "one big one with a big sort of bird's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01608-00384807-00384902": "bill", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01609-00384903-00385119": "massive thing all the way in the back of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01610-00385120-00385319": "the room like a samick is this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01611-00385320-00385654": "recognizable at all everyone can roll me", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01612-00385655-00385999": "history as alwyn describes this could i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01613-00386000-00386151": "and uh clork you can roll this with", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01614-00386152-00386263": "advantage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01615-00386264-00386343": "good", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01616-00386344-00386695": "this couldn't fall under nature no no", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01617-00386696-00386847": "12.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01618-00386848-00387071": "it actually could fall under religion", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01619-00387072-00387230": "ain't got that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01620-00387231-00387510": "dirty 20 on history i've got a 6.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01621-00387511-00387839": "illapal reads some more newspapers than", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01622-00387840-00388167": "everyone else sure illapal", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01623-00388168-00388334": "hearing this description", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01624-00388335-00388647": "thinks big sharp bill there were like", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01625-00388648-00388775": "four", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01626-00388776-00389047": "like really big no", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01627-00389048-00389295": "andy no", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01628-00389296-00389505": "oh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01629-00389506-00389647": "[Music]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01630-00389648-00389839": "none of that's usable audio", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01631-00389840-00389999": "go ahead oh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01632-00390000-00390175": "no", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01633-00390176-00390415": "let him freak the out go ahead and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01634-00390416-00390606": "do your thing andy and then stella take", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01635-00390607-00390767": "that from the top whenever he's done", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01636-00390768-00390902": "with this thing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01637-00390903-00391039": "there are these four", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01638-00391040-00391367": "really big eternals that participated in", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01639-00391368-00391615": "the invasion these undead gods from", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01640-00391616-00391871": "another world two of them were just like", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01641-00391872-00392199": "disintegrated completely but two of them", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01642-00392200-00392551": "were incapacitated a great ibis-headed", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01643-00392552-00392727": "god and a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01644-00392728-00392958": "cobra man", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01645-00392959-00393191": "do you think you think that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01646-00393192-00393302": "like", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01647-00393303-00393543": "that might fit the bill if you'll pardon", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01648-00393544-00393623": "the pun", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01649-00393624-00393934": "eww ill", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01650-00393935-00394215": "no one will pardon the punitives ah well", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01651-00394216-00394415": "it would appear that not only is the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01652-00394416-00394615": "sheer volume of corpses presenting us", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01653-00394616-00394895": "with an ill-tiding but this may be an", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01654-00394896-00395167": "undead god it was part of the invasion", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01655-00395168-00395415": "if i remember correctly this cannot be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01656-00395416-00395734": "reanimated we would be in grave danger", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01657-00395735-00395878": "the fact that we are so close to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01658-00395879-00396095": "stonehaven concerns me what do you mean", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01659-00396096-00396423": "a god something beyond the rest of the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01660-00396424-00396663": "eternals something far more powerful", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01661-00396664-00396887": "this may not be the only one i have no", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01662-00396888-00397063": "way of knowing if the other one is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01663-00397064-00397310": "housed here as well but even one is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01664-00397311-00397551": "plenty dangerous clerk is illapal is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01665-00397552-00397727": "recounting all this information to you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01666-00397728-00397839": "you remember", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01667-00397840-00398039": "that it was something of a point of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01668-00398040-00398351": "pride after the invasion that this bird", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01669-00398352-00398447": "god", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01670-00398448-00398775": "was knocked out of the sky by", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01671-00398776-00398991": "is it ingenuity yeah we had something to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01672-00398992-00399263": "do with that what did we do shot a big", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01673-00399264-00399415": "bolt of lightning at it from the top of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01674-00399416-00399654": "mivix blew its arm off it was very", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01675-00399655-00399847": "dramatic", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01676-00399848-00400015": "is that something i would have had any", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01677-00400016-00400254": "involvement with", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01678-00400255-00400447": "not you personally", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01679-00400448-00400734": "a fascinating tale terrifying one i'd", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01680-00400735-00400951": "hate to think what would happen if that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01681-00400952-00401263": "thing should rise again what concerns me", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01682-00401264-00401406": "alwyn is that it's so close to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01683-00401407-00401630": "stonehaven no if", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01684-00401631-00401854": "our suspicions are correct and the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01685-00401855-00402047": "threat has not yet passed", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01686-00402048-00402239": "this evening if you're leaving is the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01687-00402240-00402567": "wrong choice but we must warn them the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01688-00402568-00402839": "moment we can if that thing wakes up i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01689-00402840-00402991": "think what it does to stonehaven is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01690-00402992-00403167": "gonna be the least of our concerns you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01691-00403168-00403454": "could very well be right very good and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01692-00403455-00403663": "from here your party can take a short", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01693-00403664-00403910": "rest as you wait for whatever comes next", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01694-00403911-00404143": "would i have a sense of how long we've", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01695-00404144-00404367": "been down here after this short rest", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01696-00404368-00404775": "i'll say maybe four hours okay so kind", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01697-00404776-00404943": "of halfway through the night", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01698-00404944-00405151": "i think there is an adequate reason to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01699-00405152-00405351": "fear what stirs behind that wooden", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01700-00405352-00405630": "barricade but i believe that we can", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01701-00405631-00405878": "overcome whatever it is or better yet", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01702-00405879-00406110": "stop it from happening at all we've done", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01703-00406111-00406358": "so much already with that i will just", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01704-00406359-00406534": "prepare a song of rest and heli i'm", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01705-00406535-00406743": "going to use a hit die for sure very", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01706-00406744-00406830": "good", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01707-00406831-00407143": "man bird's rule can i go ahead and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01708-00407144-00407406": "ritually cast animal messenger again as", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01709-00407407-00407654": "part of our short rest yeah absolutely i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01710-00407655-00407823": "sort of say to illapel well i don't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01711-00407824-00408047": "think it wise we leave ourselves i may", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01712-00408048-00408295": "be able to send the message in our stood", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01713-00408296-00408671": "and sort of find some small beast of the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01714-00408672-00408902": "earth you see a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01715-00408903-00409127": "little mute wriggling through the dirt i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01716-00409128-00409454": "sort of reach out to it you'll do", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01717-00409455-00409743": "i'm a lizard hi a good one it's not vim", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01718-00409743-00410022": "the vigorous", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01719-00410023-00410214": "not this time but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01720-00410215-00410422": "lizard noises i look down to this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01721-00410423-00410670": "creature and i say we found a sleeping", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01722-00410671-00410895": "god from the invasion within this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01723-00410896-00411166": "vulture guarding if there to take it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01724-00411167-00411391": "more than stonehaven will be in danger", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01725-00411392-00411655": "okay you send this message on its way", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01726-00411656-00411951": "and as this short rest comes to a close", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01727-00411952-00412166": "everyone make me a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01728-00412167-00412414": "perception", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01729-00412415-00412718": "13 21 21 as well", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01730-00412719-00412870": "all of you hear", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01731-00412871-00413222": "loud padding footsteps coming down the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01732-00413223-00413478": "tunnel sounds like round two i don't see", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01733-00413479-00413766": "a reason why we don't just hide again", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01734-00413767-00413959": "go ahead and roll me stealth everyone", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01735-00413960-00414214": "unfortunately might be a poor use of my", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01736-00414215-00414526": "lust more powerful spell i'm afraid we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01737-00414527-00414687": "won't have the shadows working for us", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01738-00414688-00414847": "this time", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01739-00414847-00415087": "yeah you can say that again oh no we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01740-00415088-00415399": "shall do our best i rolled a 14. three", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01741-00415400-00415687": "dirty 20. okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01742-00415688-00415839": "i don't know if i'm gonna pass but if i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01743-00415839-00416014": "like it doesn't matter clerk's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01744-00416015-00416263": "up for all he's gonna sit there in the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01745-00416264-00416447": "open he's fiddling with his key", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01746-00416447-00416639": "ring thinking about sausage dogs or", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01747-00416639-00416774": "whatever", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01748-00416775-00417014": "you hear a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01749-00417015-00417151": "groan", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01750-00417152-00417287": "of wood", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01751-00417288-00417687": "cracking and of metal twisting and with", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01752-00417688-00417830": "a loud", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01753-00417831-00418070": "bang the door nearby you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01754-00418071-00418151": "is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01755-00418152-00418374": "flung off its hinges", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01756-00418375-00418734": "into the room wait like as if whatever", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01757-00418735-00418951": "it was was like invisible or something", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01758-00418952-00419118": "there doesn't seem to be anyone standing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01759-00419119-00419351": "beside it if you'd like to take a peek", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01760-00419352-00419695": "down the tunnel oh i'm gonna entity", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01761-00419696-00419839": "and take a peek", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01762-00419839-00420103": "okay that's a nat 20. this is what you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01763-00420104-00420287": "see you see", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01764-00420288-00420527": "by the light of your dancing lights a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01765-00420528-00420635": "large", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01766-00420635-00421022": "blue-plated lion-like creature with a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01767-00421023-00421318": "pointed scorpion's tail", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01768-00421319-00421599": "striding down the corridor and mounted", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01769-00421600-00422007": "upon it another blue skeleton in a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01770-00422008-00422359": "fine robe extending a hand towards the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01771-00422360-00422647": "door everyone roll initiative is this an", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01772-00422647-00422983": "eternal riding a manticore yes it is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01773-00422984-00423287": "holy that's cool", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01774-00423288-00423422": "14.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01775-00423423-00423814": "that's a 21 on a natural 19. dirty 20.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01776-00423815-00424055": "ellen you see this vizier", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01777-00424056-00424366": "psychically knock this door down you're", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01778-00424367-00424566": "up first in initiative what do you do", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01779-00424567-00424791": "boy that's more like it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01780-00424792-00424910": "i'm gonna", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01781-00424912-00425159": "maybe against my better judgment here", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01782-00425160-00425455": "i'm gonna run up an attack okay which", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01783-00425456-00425639": "creature are you attacking i'm gonna see", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01784-00425639-00425831": "if i can get close enough to attack the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01785-00425832-00426166": "mage okay yeah sure first hits", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01786-00426167-00426759": "um that's a 15 15 is the vizier's ac", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01787-00426760-00426927": "so it's going to be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01788-00426928-00427518": "12 bludgeoning and too necrotic okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01789-00427519-00427799": "needs to make a concentration check", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01790-00427800-00428014": "he does succeed at his concentration", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01791-00428015-00428310": "check to maintain focus on telekinesis", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01792-00428312-00428647": "ah interesting um okay so as i swing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01793-00428647-00428903": "first with the gavel i'm going to swing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01794-00428904-00429079": "now with the mallet", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01795-00429080-00429279": "and that's going to be a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01796-00429280-00429591": "another 15. yup and this is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01797-00429592-00429799": "gonna be three bludgeoning and five", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01798-00429800-00430070": "negroni okay seems to take somewhat less", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01799-00430071-00430335": "damage from the non-magical weapon", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01800-00430335-00430622": "that's my turn okay illapal you're up", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01801-00430623-00430879": "fairy fire manticore ferry fire the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01802-00430880-00431103": "magikarp deck save", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01803-00431104-00431335": "i'll probably hit both won't it oh yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01804-00431335-00431463": "we will hit both", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01805-00431464-00431735": "both of them make a saving throw", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01806-00431735-00432063": "both of them fail the highest oh yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01807-00432064-00432270": "cool so they are both illumined by this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01808-00432271-00432559": "fairy fire now the vizier goes elwyn", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01809-00432560-00432718": "could you make me a strength saving", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01810-00432719-00432959": "throat please oh um", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01811-00432960-00433255": "sure", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01812-00433256-00433510": "strength safe", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01813-00433512-00433831": "okay okay that's in that 20.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01814-00433832-00434199": "come on", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01815-00434200-00434414": "no fun man when i need it from the blue", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01816-00434415-00434679": "dice the blue dice gives it yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01817-00434680-00434799": "sorry", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01818-00434800-00435047": "no it's five it's five oh excuse me this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01819-00435047-00435359": "is not a saving throw it's a check oh so", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01820-00435360-00435599": "the vizier gets to oppose this the dc is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01821-00435600-00435943": "going to be 21. oh that is a 21. zazir", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01822-00435943-00436159": "is going to roll his spell casting", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01823-00436160-00436383": "ability", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01824-00436384-00436703": "does not succeed you feel as if you are", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01825-00436704-00436951": "trying to be telekinetically hoisted", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01826-00436952-00437255": "into the air and away from this vizier", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01827-00437256-00437439": "oh wild", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01828-00437439-00437727": "but he does not do so you see in my", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01829-00437728-00437831": "entity", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01830-00437832-00438127": "state the thorns and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01831-00438128-00438407": "vines around my legs and cloak dig into", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01832-00438408-00438639": "the ground and hold me in place", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01833-00438639-00438943": "and that is going to be his turn then", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01834-00438943-00439166": "the manticore goes and you are right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01835-00439167-00439439": "there and it's yeah yeah i am manticore", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01836-00439439-00439622": "face so it's going to make three attacks", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01837-00439623-00439743": "against you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01838-00439743-00439863": "okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01839-00439864-00439999": "yo", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01840-00440000-00440263": "it's savage jaws open and it attempts to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01841-00440264-00440559": "bite you 16 plus five it's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01842-00440560-00440791": "for sure so you take", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01843-00440792-00440959": "four points of piercing damage the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01844-00440960-00441318": "absolute minimum okay it's sharp claws", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01845-00441319-00441527": "rake at you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01846-00441528-00441870": "eleven to hit will not successes and its", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01847-00441871-00442191": "jagged scorpion tail comes swinging at", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01848-00442192-00442431": "you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01849-00442432-00442670": "thirteen will not hit you'll have to do", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01850-00442671-00442895": "better than that we going out of court", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01851-00442896-00443014": "all right i'm going to blast it with", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01852-00443015-00443383": "chaos bolt okay the manticore very good", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01853-00443384-00443766": "it's 14 to hit 14 is the manta cars ac", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01854-00443767-00443927": "so go ahead and roll your chaos bolt", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01855-00443928-00444263": "damage all right here we go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01856-00444264-00444470": "well that's gonna be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01857-00444471-00444766": "seven fire damage okay not a good roll", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01858-00444767-00445007": "it does take all of it though this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01859-00445008-00445318": "leonine creature growls and singes as", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01860-00445319-00445631": "this chaotic entity burns away at its", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01861-00445632-00445903": "lazatap flesh that's clork back to the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01862-00445904-00446247": "top alwyn i'm gonna keep swinging okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01863-00446247-00446503": "that's a dirty 20. you hit", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01864-00446504-00446791": "that's going to be seven bludgeoning and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01865-00446792-00447031": "three necrotic", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01866-00447032-00447231": "passes his concentration check that's my", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01867-00447232-00447359": "bonus action i'm gonna think about", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01868-00447360-00447551": "casting a spell but i'm just gonna swing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01869-00447552-00447647": "it again", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01870-00447647-00447895": "okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01871-00447896-00448127": "that's a 24", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01872-00448128-00448343": "24 will hit that's five bludgeoning two", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01873-00448343-00448447": "negronic", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01874-00448447-00448639": "okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01875-00448639-00448887": "maintains concentration okay illapal", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01876-00448888-00449095": "you're up yeah i'm gonna use catapult", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01877-00449096-00449279": "i'm gonna try and throw one of the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01878-00449280-00449566": "eternal corpses in the vault at this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01879-00449567-00449999": "thing oh okay you do this you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01880-00450000-00450303": "lift the eternal corpse off the ground", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01881-00450304-00450607": "and you suddenly feel your connection", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01882-00450608-00450927": "to this magic disappear", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01883-00450928-00451231": "as the vizier casts counterspell and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01884-00451232-00451518": "counters your spell oh hold on can", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01885-00451519-00451703": "we uh just some quick rules of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01886-00451704-00451870": "adjudication is that what counterspell", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01887-00451871-00452095": "does counterspell counters a spell", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01888-00452096-00452439": "yes weird okay i just want to make sure", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01889-00452439-00452607": "i'll allow it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01890-00452608-00452822": "it's fine", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01891-00452823-00453159": "it feels bad doesn't it it feels not fun", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01892-00453160-00453318": "yeah now you know how i feel against", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01893-00453319-00453551": "andromeda cool as my bonus action i will", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01894-00453552-00453918": "just use a level two spell okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01895-00453919-00454007": "okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01896-00454008-00454247": "i wanted someone to see your reaction", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01897-00454247-00454463": "that's all uh that's my turn", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01898-00454464-00454639": "i mean like there's some second level", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01899-00454639-00454807": "spells that you can cast as bonus action", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01900-00454808-00454975": "but you oh there probably are i don't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01901-00454976-00455191": "have any of them i don't have them you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01902-00455192-00455383": "could give somebody bardic inspiration", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01903-00455384-00455583": "no they're not gonna use it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01904-00455584-00455855": "no i'm not doing it i'm down i'm down to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01905-00455856-00456047": "charge or two here i'm not no i'm not", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01906-00456047-00456175": "doing it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01907-00456176-00456343": "all right okay if i missed it's your", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01908-00456343-00456807": "fault it literally isn't all right fine", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01909-00456808-00456966": "pull my arm", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01910-00456967-00457247": "fine all right hold on", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01911-00457247-00457487": "find myself deeply wanting to inspire", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01912-00457488-00457879": "you once again please do they though aim", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01913-00457880-00458222": "that clock bolt true i feel so inspired", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01914-00458223-00458503": "then off with it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01915-00458504-00458839": "come on", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01916-00458839-00459055": "we'll see we'll see what happens", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01917-00459056-00459222": "both monsters have to have their turns", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01918-00459223-00459414": "first yeah both monsters are about to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01919-00459415-00459679": "have their turns the vizier who's gonna", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01920-00459680-00460095": "make a con save please oh okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01921-00460096-00460359": "10 is not gonna do six necrotic damage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01922-00460360-00460663": "from the halo of spores okay uh the zero", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01923-00460664-00460903": "is going to reach out and touch you okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01924-00460904-00461318": "i don't consent to this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01925-00461319-00461622": "yeah great", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01926-00461623-00461951": "great god damn it these dice you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01927-00461952-00462079": "hate to see it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01928-00462080-00462431": "yeah whiffs four plus not enough if only", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01929-00462432-00462663": "this guy had a bardic inspiration hmm", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01930-00462664-00462814": "yeah or you know it sounds like your", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01931-00462815-00463287": "dice did a counterspell on you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01932-00463288-00463527": "okay jeffy one day you'll play a with", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01933-00463528-00463687": "counter spell and you'll you'll know", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01934-00463688-00463951": "that wonderful blue magic okay here come", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01935-00463952-00464239": "three manticore attacks okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01936-00464239-00464599": "dirty 20 on the bike yeah that hits", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01937-00464600-00464910": "10 points of piercing damage okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01938-00464912-00465295": "10 on the claw nope", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01939-00465296-00465551": "14 on the sting got to do better than", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01940-00465552-00465847": "that well you know sometimes the dice", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01941-00465847-00466007": "don't want to break a 10 for me but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01942-00466008-00466255": "that's good for you guys cork you're up", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01943-00466256-00466535": "okay is very fire still up yes it is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01944-00466535-00466759": "okay i'm gonna let loose another chaos", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01945-00466760-00466847": "bolt", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01946-00466847-00467047": "this manticore", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01947-00467047-00467255": "i don't need the bardic right now", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01948-00467256-00467543": "because that's gonna be a 20 to hit", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01949-00467543-00467751": "absolutely hits", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01950-00467752-00468063": "17 thunder damage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01951-00468064-00468214": "well with a deafening crack this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01952-00468215-00468543": "manticore reels again nice starts to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01953-00468543-00468870": "look at you clark with a bit of distaste", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01954-00468871-00469199": "ooh i'm gonna hide as a bonus action", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01955-00469200-00469407": "good choice", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01956-00469408-00469647": "it's a 19. okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01957-00469647-00469847": "you appear to be well hidden alan back", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01958-00469847-00470127": "to you okay let's go again i'm gonna", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01959-00470128-00470366": "keep hitting the eternal okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01960-00470367-00470510": "that isn't at 20 because of the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01961-00470512-00471014": "advantage yep so doubling these dice", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01962-00471015-00471175": "that's some good rolls", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01963-00471176-00471327": "that's going to be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01964-00471328-00471535": "13 bludgeoning", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01965-00471535-00471647": "and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01966-00471647-00471999": "eight necrotic yeah this here looking", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01967-00472000-00472214": "very injured i'm gonna take my second", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01968-00472215-00472327": "attack", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01969-00472328-00472663": "that's gonna be a 19. vizier is going to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01970-00472664-00472935": "use a shield as a reaction on this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01971-00472935-00473263": "we're over to you i will also attack", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01972-00473264-00473822": "the vizier okay that is a 22 hits", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01973-00473823-00474383": "okie dokie and that is an additional", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01974-00474384-00474687": "nine piercing switch oh you lapel that's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01975-00474688-00475007": "the way okay it's hardened coding does", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01976-00475008-00475207": "seem to make it resistant but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01977-00475208-00475663": "uh it does appear barely alive on alive", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01978-00475664-00475959": "okay it's the vizier's turn please make", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01979-00475960-00476047": "me", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01980-00476047-00476366": "a constitution saving throw yep", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01981-00476367-00476566": "also did it make one for concentration", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01982-00476567-00476863": "before oh no it didn't um", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01983-00476864-00477159": "succeeds okay it loses concentration on", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01984-00477160-00477479": "telekinesis as lapel strikes it dope and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01985-00477480-00477879": "it makes a con save uh 15 15 yeah 15 is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01986-00477880-00478222": "the dc okay it shrugs off your spores", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01987-00478223-00478566": "it utters something in a tongue from", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01988-00478567-00478718": "beyond the stars", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01989-00478719-00478807": "and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01990-00478808-00478935": "a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01991-00478935-00479095": "mass of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01992-00479096-00479351": "writhing tentacles spring from the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01993-00479352-00479583": "ground these ink treaders black", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01994-00479584-00479703": "tentacles", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01995-00479704-00480047": "grasp and grab at you lot both of you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01996-00480047-00480343": "make me a dexterity save", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01997-00480343-00480647": "23 16. you're not restrained by these", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01998-00480647-00480879": "tentacles now the mint court just", "HD_7ue6f0OU-01999-00480880-00481079": "attacks as i'm reading this they stay in", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02000-00481080-00481295": "the area though correct they stay in the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02001-00481296-00481407": "area", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02002-00481408-00481679": "alwyn it's coming at you all right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02003-00481680-00481870": "fight misses with a seven", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02004-00481871-00482207": "four hits with a 21 yep", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02005-00482208-00482479": "four six points of slashing damage just", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02006-00482480-00482766": "broke through the temporary hit points", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02007-00482767-00483047": "uh-huh 23 hits on the sting certainly", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02008-00483047-00483295": "does make me a con save please yeah okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02009-00483296-00483479": "here we go as you take 10 piercing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02010-00483480-00483727": "damage oh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02011-00483728-00484110": "con save that is going to be a 17. okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02012-00484112-00484391": "that will pass you take half of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02013-00484392-00484791": "24 poison damage so 12. holy", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02014-00484792-00485118": "as the sting of this manticore sends", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02015-00485119-00485407": "shocks of pain through your body oh i'm", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02016-00485408-00485670": "shocked in pain no actually", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02017-00485671-00485883": "i'm gonna seriously say", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02018-00485884-00486151": "uh i certainly don't feel so good cause", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02019-00486152-00486327": "now i'm actually really hurt clark we're", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02020-00486328-00486431": "over to you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02021-00486432-00486559": "you are hidden", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02022-00486560-00486727": "all right clerk's gonna swing big we're", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02023-00486728-00486975": "gonna do a twinned second level chaos", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02024-00486976-00487231": "bolt very cool targeting both of them", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02025-00487232-00487422": "you do have advantage on these rolls", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02026-00487423-00487551": "right so that's two different attack", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02027-00487552-00487735": "rules", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02028-00487735-00487991": "oh my god jimmy come on", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02029-00487992-00488255": "throw all your dice out i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02030-00488256-00488455": "i'm literally using different dice like", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02031-00488456-00488607": "all the time all right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02032-00488608-00488814": "did you use the bardic inspiration i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02033-00488815-00489055": "didn't yet hold on because it might not", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02034-00489056-00489270": "even help uh i just want to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02035-00489271-00489487": "say that this first one is against the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02036-00489488-00489759": "manticore okay okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02037-00489760-00490014": "yeah okay so that's going to be 12 to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02038-00490015-00490303": "hit 12 will not hit i shouldn't have", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02039-00490304-00490543": "wasted that bardic oh that's with the i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02040-00490543-00490870": "should have lied jimmy come on", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02041-00490871-00491103": "i rolled a three and a four all right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02042-00491104-00491255": "that's rough all right so here's the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02043-00491256-00491462": "other attack against the vizier what do", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02044-00491463-00491710": "you get against the vizier", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02045-00491712-00492031": "that's a 17 to hit 17 will hit okay all", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02046-00492032-00492262": "right here we go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02047-00492263-00492351": "ah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02048-00492352-00492447": "okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02049-00492447-00492662": "will you allow this is it gonna jump it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02050-00492663-00492935": "is gonna jump i think the ruling i made", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02051-00492935-00493183": "was if it's twinned you can't have it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02052-00493184-00493327": "jump to something that's already been", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02053-00493328-00493607": "targeted by a chaos ball this round", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02054-00493608-00493703": "right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02055-00493704-00493895": "no double dipping okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02056-00493896-00494239": "why well technically you can't twin a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02057-00494239-00494407": "spell that is capable of targeting more", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02058-00494408-00494583": "than one creature and so we're already", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02059-00494584-00494799": "bending by allowing me to twin the chaos", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02060-00494800-00495095": "fault oh because twins spell is single", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02061-00495096-00495462": "target and chaos fault is weird yeah i'm", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02062-00495463-00495727": "allowing it to happen with that caveat", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02063-00495728-00495862": "got it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02064-00495863-00496118": "right so it was already alms for the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02065-00496119-00496295": "poor for jimmy and it didn't even go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02066-00496296-00496462": "well", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02067-00496463-00496710": "anyway anyway roll your damage i did", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02068-00496712-00496879": "roll my damage that's the problem that's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02069-00496880-00497031": "why we're having this conversation uh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02070-00497032-00497239": "that's 10 cold damage do you want to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02071-00497239-00497479": "like kill this vizier in any special way", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02072-00497480-00497599": "oh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02073-00497600-00497791": "do you want to end his sad miserable", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02074-00497792-00498175": "life on life uh yeah sure so i like i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02075-00498176-00498447": "always do point my wrench at this thing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02076-00498447-00498710": "and it looks like that is not gonna hit", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02077-00498712-00498870": "it and then it just kind of suddenly at", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02078-00498871-00499095": "the last second curves to actually hit", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02079-00499096-00499439": "him and as this chaos bull hits him ice", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02080-00499439-00499727": "creeps along his body and he shatters", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02081-00499728-00500039": "and collapses into shards of ice awesome", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02082-00500039-00500199": "very cool", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02083-00500200-00500391": "very cool you were a very bad", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02084-00500392-00500647": "spellcaster plaza temp fazir", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02085-00500647-00500895": "i'm ashamed of you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02086-00500896-00501031": "didn't grab anyone with your black", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02087-00501032-00501239": "tentacles didn't telekinetically throw", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02088-00501239-00501575": "anyone i hate you got killed by clork", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02089-00501576-00501799": "owen you're up okay let's go taking", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02090-00501800-00501999": "swings at this manicore", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02091-00502000-00502343": "still fairy fired yes that's a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02092-00502343-00502535": "19 hits", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02093-00502535-00502847": "that's six bludgeoning and six necrotics", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02094-00502847-00503047": "okay swinging again", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02095-00503047-00503303": "oh a foreign is six for a total of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02096-00503304-00503679": "thirteen misses unfortunately okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02097-00503680-00503927": "illapal we are over to you i'm just", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02098-00503928-00504366": "gonna just gonna attack okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02099-00504367-00504479": "[Music]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02100-00504480-00504783": "oh no oh boy this manicor could get the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02101-00504784-00505079": "last lap on me uh oh we'll get you up if", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02102-00505080-00505239": "it's looking injured at all just go for", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02103-00505239-00505527": "it don't hold back i'll be fine it's a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02104-00505528-00505710": "16 to hit that will hit", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02105-00505712-00505999": "seven piercing damage okay now it is the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02106-00506000-00506255": "manticore's term um", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02107-00506256-00506462": "unless you would like to make use of the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02108-00506463-00506687": "bonus action i'm going to yeah i'm going", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02109-00506688-00506991": "to use unsettling words as a reverse", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02110-00506992-00507159": "bardic inspiration", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02111-00507160-00507375": "against the manticore okay so the next", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02112-00507376-00507607": "time it saves you roll a die and it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02113-00507608-00507783": "subtracts that from its stage i thought", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02114-00507784-00507991": "it was any role i can just use a d6", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02115-00507992-00508159": "against it i was under the impression", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02116-00508160-00508351": "that it's a saving throw let me take a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02117-00508352-00508518": "look and is there any stipulation that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02118-00508519-00508766": "you need to share a language next saving", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02119-00508767-00508935": "through yeah it's just next save it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02120-00508935-00509110": "makes before the start of your next turn", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02121-00509112-00509366": "nothing about language okay cool your", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02122-00509367-00509655": "creepy words transcend the language", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02123-00509656-00509807": "barrier", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02124-00509808-00509983": "these lessons in rosetta stone have", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02125-00509984-00510359": "proven quite you know um", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02126-00510360-00510575": "sponsored by rosetta yeah exactly now", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02127-00510576-00510766": "you can get a a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02128-00510767-00510999": "dillard l fish for your next larp what", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02129-00511000-00511166": "would i say to a man", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02130-00511167-00511318": "i mean it doesn't matter the words you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02131-00511319-00511591": "choose it's more about how you say them", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02132-00511592-00511831": "your end approaches", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02133-00511832-00512055": "i just say some like that hell yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02134-00512056-00512262": "so edgy all right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02135-00512263-00512447": "halo time", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02136-00512447-00512783": "okay it got a 14. already fails that's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02137-00512784-00513166": "max damage eight necrotic damage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02138-00513167-00513327": "halo pierces", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02139-00513328-00513766": "through it cool it doesn't like that uh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02140-00513767-00514110": "18 to hit on the bite it's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02141-00514112-00514199": "for", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02142-00514200-00514583": "five points of piercing damage okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02143-00514584-00514954": "on the clock just hits ac 50 four", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02144-00514955-00515087": "[Music]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02145-00515088-00515399": "seven slashing damage okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02146-00515400-00515670": "24 to hit on the tail absolutely hits", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02147-00515671-00515895": "there's no way i'm not going down", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02148-00515896-00516151": "i have three hit points left", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02149-00516152-00516255": "okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02150-00516256-00516351": "you take", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02151-00516352-00516575": "six points of piercing damage okay down", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02152-00516576-00516951": "make me a constitution savings okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02153-00516952-00517199": "it's gonna be a 12", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02154-00517200-00517599": "the dc is 13. yikes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02155-00517600-00517799": "okay it's a lot of dice i just", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02156-00517800-00518070": "heard what's your max hit points without", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02157-00518071-00518399": "the entity additional it's 41.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02158-00518400-00518631": "okay you simply fail a death saving", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02159-00518632-00518870": "though okay clerk we are over to you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02160-00518871-00519079": "clerk is looking back and forth between", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02161-00519080-00519222": "alwyn", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02162-00519223-00519399": "and the manticore", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02163-00519400-00519639": "i will help him fell this beast you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02164-00519639-00519791": "really think i can do that you have a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02165-00519792-00519999": "lot of faith in me i've always believed", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02166-00520000-00520118": "in you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02167-00520119-00520351": "one more bardic inspiration it's not", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02168-00520352-00520527": "your turn oh wait it's not my turn i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02169-00520528-00520799": "can't do that oh man how much flavor", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02170-00520800-00520951": "that would have been well uh you're on", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02171-00520952-00521138": "your own", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02172-00521139-00521422": "[Laughter]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02173-00521423-00521599": "well i'll pretend i have bardic all", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02174-00521600-00521855": "right here we go my last spell slot well", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02175-00521856-00522007": "it's gonna be a chaos bolt against the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02176-00522008-00522310": "manticore alright here it goes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02177-00522312-00522566": "and it still is fairy fire correct", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02178-00522567-00522831": "sorcerer cass chaos", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02179-00522832-00523407": "16 hits that does hell yeah get his ass", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02180-00523408-00523614": "here we go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02181-00523615-00523879": "that's 11 fire damage okay this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02182-00523880-00524207": "manticore looking very wounded oh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02183-00524208-00524462": "would four more damage done it no okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02184-00524463-00524639": "can i do you want to use your fury of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02185-00524640-00524918": "the small i do never use fury this small", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02186-00524919-00525375": "okay cool 15 fire damage it is closer to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02187-00525376-00525622": "death as we go to alwyn please make a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02188-00525623-00525814": "death saving throw oh no", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02189-00525815-00526014": "there's a one in 20 chance i die right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02190-00526015-00526262": "here guys five percent chance you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02191-00526263-00526462": "die here we go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02192-00526463-00526799": "that is a seven okay you fail another", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02193-00526800-00527031": "death savings go but you are still", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02194-00527032-00527351": "clinging to life philosophy but barely", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02195-00527352-00527591": "bleeding out in a pile of my own", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02196-00527592-00527855": "spores casting healing word healing word", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02197-00527856-00528047": "healing word healing word oh healing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02198-00528048-00528231": "words bonus actually yeah correct", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02199-00528232-00528599": "yeah we're gonna do that it's gonna be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02200-00528600-00529103": "seven healing to you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02201-00529104-00529343": "hit it with the sword yeah i plan to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02202-00529344-00529566": "fork thank you okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02203-00529567-00529975": "all right so the 18 i hit and i will do", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02204-00529976-00530383": "oh maximum damage well here's the damage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02205-00530384-00530647": "because of fury of the small", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02206-00530648-00530951": "hell yeah oh would you like to add some", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02207-00530952-00531191": "flourish to this killing blow sure so i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02208-00531192-00531462": "will throw out my healing word to alwyn", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02209-00531463-00531751": "and then i will run up with my rapier", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02210-00531752-00531999": "and get under the manticore and just", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02211-00532000-00532359": "stab up through its chin and up into its", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02212-00532360-00532814": "skull make a deck save for no no", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02213-00532815-00532927": "19.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02214-00532928-00533222": "as you stab the manticore it sort of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02215-00533223-00533535": "slumps forward but you're able to deftly", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02216-00533536-00533839": "pirouette and stand before it as it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02217-00533840-00534135": "falls dead onto the ground okay and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02218-00534136-00534407": "we'll exit initiative there oh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02219-00534408-00534703": "oh once again a lapel i would not be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02220-00534704-00534935": "alive if it weren't for your words", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02221-00534936-00535047": "well done", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02222-00535048-00535327": "anything for a friend lapel as this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02223-00535328-00535631": "fight concludes you hear a voice in your", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02224-00535632-00536022": "mind very familiar voice i suggest you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02225-00536023-00536343": "leave a little something behind", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02226-00536344-00536662": "so i can find this place", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02227-00536663-00536918": "and you think that's the greatest idea", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02228-00536919-00537087": "you've ever had", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02229-00537088-00537303": "what the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02230-00537304-00537591": "you really want to just leave a marker", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02231-00537592-00537895": "in this chamber before you go all right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02232-00537896-00538087": "i'm gonna try something and i don't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02233-00538088-00538247": "think you're gonna allow me to do it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02234-00538248-00538422": "what are you going to do i'm going to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02235-00538423-00538991": "try and cast suggestion on myself okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02236-00538992-00539083": "okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02237-00539084-00539255": "okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02238-00539256-00539511": "i want to see where this goes go ahead", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02239-00539512-00539711": "can half elves be charmed yes i believe", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02240-00539712-00539918": "so i have advantage on saving throws", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02241-00539919-00540151": "against being charmed", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02242-00540152-00540327": "that's a 13", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02243-00540328-00540543": "and i presume let's just say i get is it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02244-00540544-00540743": "technically a charm suggestion is a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02245-00540744-00540879": "charm effect", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02246-00540880-00541143": "okay then i technically get advantage", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02247-00541144-00541351": "the other role was a four plus two is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02248-00541352-00541639": "six so i would fail this role okay what", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02249-00541640-00541862": "are you suggesting to yourself i would", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02250-00541863-00542103": "suggest that i keep this power as we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02251-00542104-00542383": "move forward okay you suggest that to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02252-00542384-00542575": "yourself you think that's also a very", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02253-00542576-00542839": "good idea you still feel like the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02254-00542840-00543151": "greatest idea you've ever had is to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02255-00543152-00543255": "leave", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02256-00543256-00543527": "some token behind so this place can be", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02257-00543528-00543791": "found wow do i see ilpel over there", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02258-00543792-00544095": "talking to themselves starting to sweat", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02259-00544096-00544479": "roll perception", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02260-00544480-00544951": "well i got a 26.", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02261-00544952-00545175": "okay yeah you you hear lapel muttering", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02262-00545176-00545383": "to themself the illapal would probably", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02263-00545384-00545599": "be staring back at that vault and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02264-00545600-00545783": "looking down at their person kind of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02265-00545784-00546014": "repeatedly hello pal what are you doing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02266-00546015-00546207": "illapal will raise up their hand kind of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02267-00546208-00546311": "like uh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02268-00546312-00546479": "leave me alone leaving my thoughts stop", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02269-00546480-00546759": "stop stop clearly very unable to focus", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02270-00546760-00546879": "on anything other than what they're", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02271-00546880-00547127": "staring at i'll like look towards what", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02272-00547128-00547431": "they're staring at okay uh illapal will", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02273-00547432-00547607": "shake their head and say it was nothing", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02274-00547608-00547831": "it was nothing uh let us be on and i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02275-00547832-00548014": "will slowly take my ring off and just", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02276-00548015-00548199": "drop it on the ground you attempt to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02277-00548200-00548711": "pull it off it is fused to your flesh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02278-00548712-00548918": "little power what's wrong it's fine it's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02279-00548919-00549143": "nothing it's it's nothing all right i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02280-00549144-00549318": "guess i'll just drop a zib they've", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02281-00549319-00549591": "convinced me it's a good idea but i'm", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02282-00549592-00549695": "not going to give them more than they", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02283-00549696-00549975": "need okay roll me sleight of hand as you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02284-00549976-00550143": "do this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02285-00550144-00550599": "19 okay you slip a zib into the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02286-00550600-00550711": "cavern", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02287-00550712-00551062": "full of eternalized corpses two things", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02288-00551063-00551222": "one would the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02289-00551223-00551683": "vizier have left any remains any robes", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02290-00551684-00551991": "weapons relics he does seem to have a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02291-00551992-00552343": "fine robe there's a dagger on his belt a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02292-00552344-00552511": "spell book in a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02293-00552512-00552814": "language completely alien to this world", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02294-00552815-00553039": "hmm i mean i'll take all of it i'm not", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02295-00553040-00553191": "going to worry about casting detect", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02296-00553192-00553383": "magic right now but i get the sense that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02297-00553384-00553591": "all of this kind of looks pretty high", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02298-00553592-00553855": "quality yeah and again if you weren't on", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02299-00553856-00554007": "the run from the law right now there is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02300-00554008-00554295": "a finder's fee for anyone who is selling", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02301-00554296-00554503": "things from other worlds i mean i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02302-00554504-00554727": "already didn't want to sell the kopesh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02303-00554728-00554918": "to azorius i'm not gonna sell", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02304-00554919-00555118": "any of this stuff either yeah there", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02305-00555119-00555279": "might be a black market for it as well", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02306-00555280-00555479": "if you wanted to take some time perhaps", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02307-00555480-00555670": "to seek it out secondly i do kind of go", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02308-00555671-00555831": "to clerk i'm like look there's something", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02309-00555832-00556047": "wrong with the lapel this i didn't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02310-00556048-00556335": "notice a difference and can i roll", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02311-00556336-00556614": "something else like insider or anything", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02312-00556615-00556847": "you can roll insight or perception are", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02313-00556848-00556991": "you guys going to make any attempt to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02314-00556992-00557191": "repair the door well now that you ask", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02315-00557192-00557375": "probably should yeah we've seen clerk", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02316-00557376-00557566": "use many before right mending yeah but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02317-00557567-00557703": "anyways yeah i'm gonna roll inside", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02318-00557704-00558007": "because i alwyn has tried every possible", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02319-00558008-00558447": "time to trust illapel but cannot", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02320-00558448-00558783": "on insight that's a 17 plus seven 24", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02321-00558784-00558983": "total just real quick i feel like allen", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02322-00558984-00559303": "would make a great suburban stay-at-home", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02323-00559304-00559495": "dad just getting in all the neighbors", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02324-00559496-00559679": "business all the time he's got", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02325-00559680-00559959": "to be rolling in sight and perception", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02326-00559960-00560103": "doesn't know you know he's got to get in", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02327-00560104-00560311": "there the lapel roll deception for me", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02328-00560312-00560399": "please", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02329-00560400-00560703": "oh wow for the first time ever", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02330-00560704-00560935": "you beat me i got a 22. yeah and right", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02331-00560936-00561295": "at the most valuable time too you see", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02332-00561296-00561566": "lapel shaking their head and scrunching", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02333-00561567-00561862": "up their face you think that something", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02334-00561863-00562095": "might be exerting some sort of mental", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02335-00562096-00562375": "influence over them lapel i don't know", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02336-00562376-00562599": "what you keep trying to hide from us and", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02337-00562600-00562855": "i would think that all the way down here", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02338-00562856-00563039": "you would respect your friends enough to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02339-00563040-00563239": "be honest with us you said there's", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02340-00563240-00563470": "nothing wrong but i know that's clearly", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02341-00563471-00563759": "not true it is not out of disrespect", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02342-00563760-00563983": "that i say it", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02343-00563984-00564247": "and it's not inherently a lie either", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02344-00564248-00564439": "i simply don't know what is wrong", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02345-00564440-00564614": "there's no use in putting fear in all of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02346-00564615-00564918": "your minds this is my burden for now let", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02347-00564919-00565079": "it be my burden", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02348-00565080-00565231": "i see how it is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02349-00565232-00565462": "very well and allen will still keep an", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02350-00565463-00565679": "eye on them but otherwise just help", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02351-00565680-00565991": "clark fix the door okay with your", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02352-00565992-00566222": "combination of spells you can replace", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02353-00566223-00566511": "the door without issue and the rest of", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02354-00566512-00566799": "your watch passes uneventfully you think", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02355-00566800-00567014": "that perhaps this was the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02356-00567015-00567407": "extent of the forces set against this", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02357-00567408-00567662": "fault a couple buddies just fixing the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02358-00567663-00567759": "door", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02359-00567760-00568231": "you guys are resting outside this fault", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02360-00568232-00568439": "is lapel asleep that's up to hilla pal", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02361-00568440-00568614": "we took a long rest you were about to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02362-00568615-00568879": "take a long rest i believe i mean yeah", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02363-00568880-00569151": "that's what we do when we rest okay alan", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02364-00569152-00569310": "did you want to wake me up and talk", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02365-00569311-00569575": "about something i sort of gruffly wake", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02366-00569576-00569839": "illapal up in the middle of the night", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02367-00569840-00570118": "okay our conversation's not done yet", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02368-00570119-00570327": "wake up ah it's a pleasure to see you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02369-00570328-00570551": "too what would you like to discuss when", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02370-00570552-00570903": "you invited me back to your violet rose", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02371-00570904-00571103": "you told me very plainly perhaps the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02372-00571104-00571262": "most plain you'd ever said anything to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02373-00571263-00571439": "me that if you were going to become a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02374-00571440-00571679": "problem for this outfit that i shouldn't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02375-00571680-00571935": "hesitate to end that problem i don't", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02376-00571936-00572183": "have an investigative mind illapal but i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02377-00572184-00572391": "see you're playing with that ring i see", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02378-00572392-00572614": "her pacing back and forth around that", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02379-00572615-00572847": "vault door i see you talking to people", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02380-00572848-00573110": "who aren't there i'm perceptive but i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02381-00573111-00573399": "don't know why you're doing these things", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02382-00573400-00573647": "is this a problem that we have to put an", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02383-00573648-00573743": "end to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02384-00573744-00573991": "it shouldn't have to be your burden i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02385-00573992-00574110": "can't say", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02386-00574111-00574366": "in a promise to you that it's not a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02387-00574367-00574614": "problem or that it won't become one but", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02388-00574615-00574743": "i'd like to think it's one that i can", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02389-00574744-00574887": "handle on my own", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02390-00574888-00575175": "dm will you remind me how big the kopesh", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02391-00575176-00575255": "is", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02392-00575256-00575383": "is it a one-handed weapon or a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02393-00575384-00575535": "two-handed weapon it's a one-handed", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02394-00575536-00575647": "weapon okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02395-00575648-00575814": "from beneath my cloak", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02396-00575815-00576039": "after they finish saying that i draw the", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02397-00576040-00576470": "kopesh and running it along my hand i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02398-00576471-00576727": "say i think we both know that's the last", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02399-00576728-00576887": "warning you're gonna get it'll pow i", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02400-00576888-00577055": "don't want to hurt you and i know you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02401-00577056-00577231": "don't want to hurt us but i think we're", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02402-00577232-00577447": "at a point where that's not up to either", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02403-00577448-00577727": "one of us anymore are you threatening me", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02404-00577728-00577975": "i sort of look out past the darkness", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02405-00577976-00578135": "towards the vaults", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02406-00578136-00578239": "no", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02407-00578240-00578455": "no i'm just assuring a friend that a", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02408-00578456-00578655": "promise is a promise", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02409-00578656-00578862": "may i see the blade and i hold out my", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02410-00578863-00579110": "hand i'll give it okay and dm if you", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02411-00579111-00579255": "will allow me i would like to attempt to", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02412-00579256-00579439": "cut my finger off", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02413-00579440-00579622": "holy", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02414-00579623-00579703": "okay", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02415-00579704-00579866": "let's end here", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02416-00579867-00581895": "[Music]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02417-00581896-00582055": "pods of the multiverse is produced by", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02418-00582056-00582262": "jimmy of arigato that's me with music by", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02419-00582263-00582479": "andy berger and art by alexa riley", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02420-00582480-00582622": "subscribe to this feed to get a new", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02421-00582623-00582791": "episode every monday check out the links", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02422-00582792-00582966": "in the show notes you can support us by", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02423-00582967-00583166": "visiting our patreon joining our discord", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02424-00583167-00583351": "or sharing this episode with a friend we", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02425-00583352-00583495": "want to give a special shout out to our", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02426-00583496-00583839": "holy avengers jake may and chris for 10", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02427-00583840-00584031": "a month on our patreon you too can", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02428-00584032-00584222": "become a holy avenger thanks for", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02429-00584223-00584337": "listening", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02430-00584338-00588359": "[Music]", "HD_7ue6f0OU-02431-00588360-00588567": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "HDG4iVqBvmc", "text": {"HDG4iVqBvmc-00000-00000082-00000292": "expansionist nationalism as an", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00001-00000293-00000451": "aggressive and radical form of", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00002-00000452-00000682": "nationalism that incorporates autonomous", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00003-00000683-00000877": "patriotic sentiments with a belief in", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00004-00000878-00001150": "expansionism the term was coined during", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00005-00001151-00001406": "the late 19th century as European powers", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00006-00001407-00001616": "indulged in the Scramble for Africa in", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00007-00001617-00001817": "the name of national glory but has been", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00008-00001818-00001988": "most associated with militarist", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00009-00001989-00002180": "governments during the 20th century", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00010-00002181-00002443": "including fascist Italy Nazi Germany the", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00011-00002444-00002672": "Japanese Empire in the Balkans countries", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00012-00002673-00002870": "of Albania greater Albania Bulgaria", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00013-00002871-00003184": "greater Bulgaria Croatia greater Croatia", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00014-00003185-00003461": "Hungary greater Hungary Romania greater", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00015-00003461-00004195": "Romania and Serbia greater Serbia", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00016-00004196-00004553": "topic ideology", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00017-00004554-00004734": "you", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00018-00004735-00004947": "what distinguishes expansionist", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00019-00004948-00005177": "nationalism from liberal nationalism as", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00020-00005178-00005397": "its acceptance of chauvinism a belief in", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00021-00005398-00005697": "superiority or dominance nations are", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00022-00005698-00005838": "thus not thought to be equal to their", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00023-00005839-00006047": "right to self-determination rather some", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00024-00006048-00006168": "nations are believed to possess", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00025-00006169-00006393": "characteristics or qualities that make", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00026-00006394-00006674": "them superior to others expansionist", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00027-00006675-00006867": "nationalism therefore asserts the", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00028-00006868-00007052": "state's right to increase its borders at", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00029-00007053-00007687": "the expense of its neighbors", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00030-00007688-00008224": "topic see also", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00031-00008225-00008690": "irredentism generalplan asked integral", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00032-00008691-00009163": "nationalism jingoism manifest destiny", "HDG4iVqBvmc-00033-00009164-00009833": "knots ISM pan-germanism pan-slavism"}}, {"audio_id": "HE14YCz1pj0", "text": {"HE14YCz1pj0-00000-00001700-00001982": "thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00001-00001984-00007655": "[Music]", "HE14YCz1pj0-00002-00007656-00009335": "trial", "HE14YCz1pj0-00003-00009336-00009610": "hi all this is Michael just testing for", "HE14YCz1pj0-00004-00009611-00009778": "interpreters to make sure you can hear", "HE14YCz1pj0-00005-00009779-00010078": "the source clearly just let me know in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00006-00010079-00010264": "your language chats that you can hear", "HE14YCz1pj0-00007-00010265-00010499": "the source clearly", "HE14YCz1pj0-00008-00010500-00010763": "testing one two one two just making sure", "HE14YCz1pj0-00009-00010764-00010960": "the interpreters are clearly hearing the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00010-00010961-00011374": "source", "HE14YCz1pj0-00011-00011375-00011692": "I come here properly", "HE14YCz1pj0-00012-00011693-00016055": "awesome thank you yeah", "HE14YCz1pj0-00013-00016056-00020513": "hahaha", "HE14YCz1pj0-00014-00020514-00021677": "thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00015-00021678-00021814": "very much", "HE14YCz1pj0-00016-00021815-00025967": "I'll be fine", "HE14YCz1pj0-00017-00025968-00029111": "foreign", "HE14YCz1pj0-00018-00029112-00031945": "here", "HE14YCz1pj0-00019-00031945-00032196": "but it was funny because", "HE14YCz1pj0-00020-00032197-00033959": "it's so cool", "HE14YCz1pj0-00021-00033960-00038081": "foreign", "HE14YCz1pj0-00022-00038082-00039568": "foreign", "HE14YCz1pj0-00023-00039569-00044267": "foreign", "HE14YCz1pj0-00024-00044268-00047008": "thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00025-00047009-00062026": "foreign", "HE14YCz1pj0-00026-00062027-00062237": "notepads ready to take notes for", "HE14YCz1pj0-00027-00062238-00062357": "questions", "HE14YCz1pj0-00028-00062358-00062579": "so today", "HE14YCz1pj0-00029-00062579-00062776": "we're going to look at governing data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00030-00062777-00063161": "and protecting privacy reality versus on", "HE14YCz1pj0-00031-00063162-00063719": "paper a deep dive into the data system", "HE14YCz1pj0-00032-00063720-00063916": "so we'll be looking at", "HE14YCz1pj0-00033-00063917-00063971": "um", "HE14YCz1pj0-00034-00063972-00064180": "themes today from each one of our", "HE14YCz1pj0-00035-00064182-00064475": "panelists things like privacy and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00036-00064476-00064625": "protection from a stake a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00037-00064626-00064865": "multi-stakeholder perspective", "HE14YCz1pj0-00038-00064866-00065273": "what is being protected people or data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00039-00065274-00065530": "what is the collective understanding of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00040-00065532-00065669": "data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00041-00065670-00065915": "the opportunities and threats in the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00042-00065916-00066161": "midst of deriving value", "HE14YCz1pj0-00043-00066162-00066455": "successes and setbacks of legal", "HE14YCz1pj0-00044-00066456-00066767": "framework on the data ecosystem we have", "HE14YCz1pj0-00045-00066768-00067031": "put together a dynamic and exciting", "HE14YCz1pj0-00046-00067032-00067379": "panel for you today we have online", "HE14YCz1pj0-00047-00067380-00067667": "pillar for harness who is the lead", "HE14YCz1pj0-00048-00067668-00068231": "author of digital economy report 2021", "HE14YCz1pj0-00049-00068232-00068543": "she's she has been working as economic", "HE14YCz1pj0-00050-00068544-00068806": "Affairs officer at the digital economy", "HE14YCz1pj0-00051-00068807-00069071": "policy research section in the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00052-00069072-00069317": "e-commerce and digital economy branch of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00053-00069318-00069509": "the division of technology and Logistics", "HE14YCz1pj0-00054-00069510-00069761": "at the UN conference and trade and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00055-00069762-00069881": "development", "HE14YCz1pj0-00056-00069882-00070175": "we have also joining us online is Arturo", "HE14YCz1pj0-00057-00070176-00070619": "muente kurigami modernization of the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00058-00070620-00070811": "state lead specialists at the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00059-00070812-00070961": "inter-american Development Bank", "HE14YCz1pj0-00060-00070962-00071165": "currently working on digital government", "HE14YCz1pj0-00061-00071166-00071376": "Innovation projects and knowledge", "HE14YCz1pj0-00062-00071377-00071656": "coordinating the digital identity agenda", "HE14YCz1pj0-00063-00071657-00071885": "and data policies for the public sector", "HE14YCz1pj0-00064-00071886-00072094": "at the inter-american Development Bank", "HE14YCz1pj0-00065-00072095-00072491": "we have with us Mr bengastrezan who is", "HE14YCz1pj0-00066-00072492-00072737": "the executive director of Paradigm", "HE14YCz1pj0-00067-00072738-00072994": "initiative a pan-african social", "HE14YCz1pj0-00068-00072995-00073288": "Enterprise working on digital inclusion", "HE14YCz1pj0-00069-00073289-00073744": "digital rights he's also a member of the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00070-00073745-00073906": "un's high level", "HE14YCz1pj0-00071-00073907-00074171": "um leadership panel and we have", "HE14YCz1pj0-00072-00074172-00074543": "Ambassador Nathaniel Fick who was just", "HE14YCz1pj0-00073-00074544-00074723": "recently sworn in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00074-00074724-00075100": "this year as the U.S ambassador at large", "HE14YCz1pj0-00075-00075101-00075538": "for cyber space and digital policy we", "HE14YCz1pj0-00076-00075539-00075821": "have with a semba mazaboo", "HE14YCz1pj0-00077-00075822-00076115": "who is the cyber security professional", "HE14YCz1pj0-00078-00076116-00076499": "and currently senior manager I.T Analyst", "HE14YCz1pj0-00079-00076500-00076750": "at the information regulator of South", "HE14YCz1pj0-00080-00076751-00076888": "Africa", "HE14YCz1pj0-00081-00076889-00077117": "we have Peggy Hicks director of the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00082-00077118-00077369": "Thematic engagement special procedures", "HE14YCz1pj0-00083-00077370-00077579": "and rights of Development Division of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00084-00077580-00078012": "the UN Human Rights office", "HE14YCz1pj0-00085-00078013-00078311": "women's rights program Association for", "HE14YCz1pj0-00086-00078312-00078575": "Progressive Communications and right up", "HE14YCz1pj0-00087-00078576-00078832": "and now she's coordinating the our", "HE14YCz1pj0-00088-00078833-00079162": "voices of our futures project", "HE14YCz1pj0-00089-00079163-00079438": "and last but not least we have Florian", "HE14YCz1pj0-00090-00079439-00079667": "Marcus project manager proud Engineers", "HE14YCz1pj0-00091-00079668-00079859": "he has supported governments on the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00092-00079860-00080117": "political and legal structural changes", "HE14YCz1pj0-00093-00080118-00080326": "Florian has worked on projects to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00094-00080327-00080569": "rejuvenate digital transformation", "HE14YCz1pj0-00095-00080570-00080782": "efforts throughout the workshop in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00096-00080783-00080909": "several countries", "HE14YCz1pj0-00097-00080910-00081097": "so the panel will give their brief", "HE14YCz1pj0-00098-00081098-00081400": "intervention and then we will entertain", "HE14YCz1pj0-00099-00081401-00081653": "questions and conversations so let's", "HE14YCz1pj0-00100-00081654-00082949": "keep it Lively thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00101-00082950-00083831": "we'll now have pillar", "HE14YCz1pj0-00102-00083832-00084149": "hello can you hit me", "HE14YCz1pj0-00103-00084150-00084623": "okay uh good afternoon everybody I thank", "HE14YCz1pj0-00104-00084624-00084905": "the organizers to have invited to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00105-00084906-00085300": "participate in this meeting I will uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-00106-00085301-00085600": "present the findings for the teleconomy", "HE14YCz1pj0-00107-00085601-00085829": "report that we focus on transported data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00108-00085830-00086099": "flows and development because we found", "HE14YCz1pj0-00109-00086100-00086206": "that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00110-00086207-00086441": "it was quite important to focus on data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00111-00086442-00086669": "governance given the importance that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00112-00086670-00087167": "data have acquired as an economic and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00113-00087168-00087467": "strategic resource data can generate", "HE14YCz1pj0-00114-00087468-00087737": "private profits but also significant", "HE14YCz1pj0-00115-00087738-00087941": "social value for development", "HE14YCz1pj0-00116-00087942-00088229": "beyond their economic Dimension data can", "HE14YCz1pj0-00117-00088230-00088517": "bring immense benefits to society", "HE14YCz1pj0-00118-00088518-00088793": "but also carry risk in relation for", "HE14YCz1pj0-00119-00088794-00088973": "example to privacy and other human", "HE14YCz1pj0-00120-00088974-00089291": "rights and peace and security", "HE14YCz1pj0-00121-00089292-00089568": "data need to be shared but with", "HE14YCz1pj0-00122-00089569-00089975": "guarantees that human rights and other", "HE14YCz1pj0-00123-00089976-00090499": "particular concerns", "HE14YCz1pj0-00124-00090500-00090779": "data can help us overcome some of our", "HE14YCz1pj0-00125-00090780-00090976": "Global development challenges such as", "HE14YCz1pj0-00126-00090977-00091199": "climate change and pandemic but if they", "HE14YCz1pj0-00127-00091200-00091475": "are badly handled handle they can lead", "HE14YCz1pj0-00128-00091476-00091709": "to the infringement of Human Rights", "HE14YCz1pj0-00129-00091710-00091973": "generate an equal development outcomes", "HE14YCz1pj0-00130-00091974-00092212": "and add them undermined", "HE14YCz1pj0-00131-00092213-00092423": "the functioning of Internet", "HE14YCz1pj0-00132-00092424-00092656": "our common actions therefore matter", "HE14YCz1pj0-00133-00092657-00092849": "greatly for the achievement of the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00134-00092850-00093088": "sustainable development goals we have", "HE14YCz1pj0-00135-00093089-00093359": "seen in Richard gears how the amount of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00136-00093360-00093617": "data flowing around the world has been", "HE14YCz1pj0-00137-00093618-00093994": "exploded increased exponentially but at", "HE14YCz1pj0-00138-00093995-00094199": "the same time the data-driven digital", "HE14YCz1pj0-00139-00094200-00094487": "economy is evolving fast against the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00140-00094488-00094675": "backdrop of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00141-00094676-00095038": "huge digital divides and imbalances in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00142-00095039-00095243": "the world economy", "HE14YCz1pj0-00143-00095244-00095597": "a huge amount of the population of the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00144-00095598-00095806": "world population Still Remains offline", "HE14YCz1pj0-00145-00095807-00096011": "and in the least developed countries", "HE14YCz1pj0-00146-00096012-00096293": "only one in five people you choose the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00147-00096294-00096526": "internet moreover the benefits of the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00148-00096527-00096791": "data digital economy or the data-driven", "HE14YCz1pj0-00149-00096792-00097012": "digital economy have so far been", "HE14YCz1pj0-00150-00097013-00097217": "unevenly distributed", "HE14YCz1pj0-00151-00097218-00097529": "two countries stand out to harness most", "HE14YCz1pj0-00152-00097530-00097768": "of the benefits from the data the United", "HE14YCz1pj0-00153-00097769-00098225": "States and China which have huge", "HE14YCz1pj0-00154-00098226-00098506": "control over the main database", "HE14YCz1pj0-00155-00098507-00098621": "Technologies", "HE14YCz1pj0-00156-00098622-00098962": "and also most of the largest digital", "HE14YCz1pj0-00157-00098963-00099155": "platforms that are in a privileged", "HE14YCz1pj0-00158-00099156-00099400": "position to benefit for the data come", "HE14YCz1pj0-00159-00099401-00099706": "from this from these countries are based", "HE14YCz1pj0-00160-00099707-00099905": "in these countries and these large", "HE14YCz1pj0-00161-00099906-00100303": "digital platforms are", "HE14YCz1pj0-00162-00100304-00100576": "their dominant positions along the whole", "HE14YCz1pj0-00163-00100577-00100931": "world or global data value chain many", "HE14YCz1pj0-00164-00100932-00101068": "developing countries are therefore", "HE14YCz1pj0-00165-00101069-00101381": "concerned that they will become mer", "HE14YCz1pj0-00166-00101382-00101693": "providers of raw data to Global", "HE14YCz1pj0-00167-00101694-00102053": "platforms while having to rely on the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00168-00102054-00102299": "foreign knowledge that is produced from", "HE14YCz1pj0-00169-00102300-00102575": "those data that are taken from their", "HE14YCz1pj0-00170-00102576-00102694": "countries", "HE14YCz1pj0-00171-00102695-00102940": "at the same time the global data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00172-00102941-00103168": "governance landscape is highly", "HE14YCz1pj0-00173-00103169-00103486": "fragmented governance approaches but but", "HE14YCz1pj0-00174-00103488-00103756": "I am on the main players in the digital", "HE14YCz1pj0-00175-00103757-00104092": "economy if we can speak in a rough", "HE14YCz1pj0-00176-00104093-00104339": "manner in the United States they", "HE14YCz1pj0-00177-00104340-00104566": "approach focuses on control of the data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00178-00104567-00104821": "by the private sector the Chinese model", "HE14YCz1pj0-00179-00104822-00105113": "Empires emphasizes the control of data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00180-00105114-00105257": "by the government", "HE14YCz1pj0-00181-00105258-00105449": "I know you were the European Union", "HE14YCz1pj0-00182-00105450-00105721": "emphasis control of data by individuals", "HE14YCz1pj0-00183-00105722-00106043": "and these approaches are also taken into", "HE14YCz1pj0-00184-00106044-00106499": "the expansion to get more data in uh in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00185-00106500-00106733": "the world economy and this means that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00186-00106733-00106966": "the current context is one of tensions", "HE14YCz1pj0-00187-00106967-00107266": "among these Realms these data realves", "HE14YCz1pj0-00188-00107267-00107495": "what do we see with the current", "HE14YCz1pj0-00189-00107496-00107747": "situation on the data remembers is that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00190-00107748-00108004": "this soil-oriented data-driven digital", "HE14YCz1pj0-00191-00108005-00108269": "economy goes against the original Spirit", "HE14YCz1pj0-00192-00108270-00108569": "of the internet as a free decentralized", "HE14YCz1pj0-00193-00108570-00108715": "and open network", "HE14YCz1pj0-00194-00108716-00108934": "fragmentation hampers technological", "HE14YCz1pj0-00195-00108935-00109223": "progress reduces competition and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00196-00109224-00109439": "opportunities for collaboration among", "HE14YCz1pj0-00197-00109440-00109708": "jurisdictions this is likely to have", "HE14YCz1pj0-00198-00109709-00109943": "significant negative impacts for more", "HE14YCz1pj0-00199-00109944-00110278": "developing countries", "HE14YCz1pj0-00200-00110279-00110543": "there are we have reviewed a number of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00201-00110544-00110765": "national and international and Regional", "HE14YCz1pj0-00202-00110766-00110939": "agreements or regulatory Frameworks in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00203-00110940-00111178": "relation to data but the conclusion that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00204-00111179-00111563": "comes is that the global data governance", "HE14YCz1pj0-00205-00111564-00111983": "landscape is a patchwork of national and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00206-00111983-00112240": "Regional and international rules", "HE14YCz1pj0-00207-00112241-00112523": "that complicate their relations in the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00208-00112524-00112757": "digital economy and particularly", "HE14YCz1pj0-00209-00112758-00112943": "Regional and international regulatory", "HE14YCz1pj0-00210-00112944-00113165": "Frameworks tend to be either too narrow", "HE14YCz1pj0-00211-00113166-00113404": "in a scope for example they focus only", "HE14YCz1pj0-00212-00113405-00113693": "on the trade area or Focus only on", "HE14YCz1pj0-00213-00113694-00113915": "privacy and they fail to look at the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00214-00113916-00114239": "multi-dimensional uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-00215-00114240-00114545": "nature of data or there are too limited", "HE14YCz1pj0-00216-00114546-00114766": "geographically and data are really a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00217-00114767-00114940": "global challenge they need to be", "HE14YCz1pj0-00218-00114941-00115199": "addressed at starting from the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00219-00115200-00115445": "international level at different levels", "HE14YCz1pj0-00220-00115446-00115865": "too so this regimes fail to enable", "HE14YCz1pj0-00221-00115866-00116057": "cross-border data flows with an", "HE14YCz1pj0-00222-00116058-00116243": "equitable sharing of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00223-00116244-00116663": "foreign", "HE14YCz1pj0-00224-00116664-00117084": "[Music]", "HE14YCz1pj0-00225-00117085-00117551": "would she on the way forward is that we", "HE14YCz1pj0-00226-00117552-00117766": "see an urgent need to develop a more", "HE14YCz1pj0-00227-00117767-00117995": "balanced Approach to Global data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00228-00117996-00118277": "governance so as to find a common ground", "HE14YCz1pj0-00229-00118278-00118540": "for data to work for people on the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00230-00118541-00118763": "planet this is important to avoid", "HE14YCz1pj0-00231-00118764-00119008": "further fragmentation in the digital", "HE14YCz1pj0-00232-00119009-00119363": "space to enable global data sharing to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00233-00119364-00119651": "mitigate widening inequalities to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00234-00119652-00119908": "enhance trust in the digital economy to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00235-00119909-00120240": "deal with the dominant role of some", "HE14YCz1pj0-00236-00120241-00120521": "large digital platforms and to account", "HE14YCz1pj0-00237-00120522-00120658": "for the impact of some national", "HE14YCz1pj0-00238-00120659-00120989": "regulations billing over other countries", "HE14YCz1pj0-00239-00120990-00121252": "ultimately we think that the goal should", "HE14YCz1pj0-00240-00121253-00121577": "be to enable data to flow as freely as", "HE14YCz1pj0-00241-00121578-00121847": "necessary and possible while being able", "HE14YCz1pj0-00242-00121848-00122039": "to address various developmental", "HE14YCz1pj0-00243-00122040-00122249": "objectives", "HE14YCz1pj0-00244-00122250-00122621": "in this context we see several policy", "HE14YCz1pj0-00245-00122622-00122927": "areas that could be addressed through", "HE14YCz1pj0-00246-00122928-00123173": "data performance which may include", "HE14YCz1pj0-00247-00123174-00123401": "agreeing on definitions and taxonomies", "HE14YCz1pj0-00248-00123402-00123551": "for establishing intensive access", "HE14YCz1pj0-00249-00123552-00123793": "depending on the type of data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00250-00123794-00124021": "strengthening the measurement of data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00251-00124022-00124319": "data flows under value dealing with data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00252-00124320-00124601": "as a public good exploring new forms of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00253-00124602-00124865": "data governance agreeing on rights and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00254-00124866-00125249": "principle developing standards and also", "HE14YCz1pj0-00255-00125250-00125501": "increasing International cooperation on", "HE14YCz1pj0-00256-00125502-00125663": "the governance of the digital platform", "HE14YCz1pj0-00257-00125664-00125878": "for example on Taxation and competition", "HE14YCz1pj0-00258-00125879-00126028": "policies", "HE14YCz1pj0-00259-00126029-00126319": "in this", "HE14YCz1pj0-00260-00126320-00126599": "approach we think that the United", "HE14YCz1pj0-00261-00126600-00126989": "Nations needs to play a role because at", "HE14YCz1pj0-00262-00126990-00127151": "the at this moment there is a lack of a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00263-00127152-00127301": "holistic treatment of data and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00264-00127302-00127571": "discussions remain in silos the United", "HE14YCz1pj0-00265-00127572-00127847": "Nations is the most inclusive forum and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00266-00127848-00128113": "we see that many countries still remain", "HE14YCz1pj0-00267-00128114-00128416": "marginalized in the negotiations on data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00268-00128417-00128531": "Overland", "HE14YCz1pj0-00269-00128532-00128831": "so we also point to the need of a new", "HE14YCz1pj0-00270-00128832-00129040": "United Nations coordinating body or", "HE14YCz1pj0-00271-00129041-00129275": "mechanism for data governance", "HE14YCz1pj0-00272-00129276-00129527": "but we are living this open to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00273-00129528-00129731": "discussion among the countries and the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00274-00129732-00129983": "different stakeholders we think that the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00275-00129983-00130157": "global governance approach should be", "HE14YCz1pj0-00276-00130158-00130416": "multilateral multi-stakeholder and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00277-00130417-00130597": "multi-dimensional", "HE14YCz1pj0-00278-00130598-00130895": "to account for the multi-dimensionality", "HE14YCz1pj0-00279-00130896-00131381": "of data and I would leave it with that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00280-00131382-00131573": "because we think that the discussion", "HE14YCz1pj0-00281-00131574-00131854": "should go from there on having some", "HE14YCz1pj0-00282-00131855-00132047": "Innovative thinking of what kind of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00283-00132048-00132401": "governance we could have from our our", "HE14YCz1pj0-00284-00132402-00132647": "research thank you very much thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00285-00132648-00133151": "Fila", "HE14YCz1pj0-00286-00133152-00133409": "yes thank you uh Carol I want to start", "HE14YCz1pj0-00287-00133410-00133654": "thanking you for invitation can you hear", "HE14YCz1pj0-00288-00133655-00133973": "me", "HE14YCz1pj0-00289-00133974-00134297": "hello yes okay so uh I'll jump straight", "HE14YCz1pj0-00290-00134298-00134489": "to it I have a couple of slides I want", "HE14YCz1pj0-00291-00134490-00134752": "to share and I hope I won't um consume", "HE14YCz1pj0-00292-00134753-00134969": "the time we have been allotted", "HE14YCz1pj0-00293-00134970-00135214": "um so uh I want to start uh thanking you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00294-00135215-00135454": "for the invitation of course and uh to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00295-00135455-00135647": "participate in this panel I'm gonna", "HE14YCz1pj0-00296-00135648-00135839": "share a little bit what we've done in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00297-00135840-00136049": "Latin America and some of our uh at", "HE14YCz1pj0-00298-00136050-00136325": "least lessons or recommendations", "HE14YCz1pj0-00299-00136326-00136481": "um that that we're drawing from from the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00300-00136482-00136697": "work we're starting to do here", "HE14YCz1pj0-00301-00136698-00136949": "um so I want to start with this", "HE14YCz1pj0-00302-00136950-00137345": "um map I use uh just to Showcase what", "HE14YCz1pj0-00303-00137346-00137602": "has been happening I use it as a visual", "HE14YCz1pj0-00304-00137603-00137825": "probe but basically what we are seeing", "HE14YCz1pj0-00305-00137826-00138107": "is that these different agendas or", "HE14YCz1pj0-00306-00138108-00138340": "topics that are related to data have", "HE14YCz1pj0-00307-00138341-00138545": "been appearing and popping up you know", "HE14YCz1pj0-00308-00138546-00138845": "uh in response to different uh phenomena", "HE14YCz1pj0-00309-00138846-00139078": "that we've been seeing uh so governments", "HE14YCz1pj0-00310-00139079-00139235": "are starting to create groups around", "HE14YCz1pj0-00311-00139236-00139504": "open data actually come from the open", "HE14YCz1pj0-00312-00139505-00139811": "data kind of camp we have the data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00313-00139812-00140039": "security camp we have the data sharing", "HE14YCz1pj0-00314-00140040-00140254": "interoperability we have the access to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00315-00140255-00140435": "information which even sometimes", "HE14YCz1pj0-00316-00140436-00140621": "confused with the open data one we have", "HE14YCz1pj0-00317-00140622-00140759": "of course the data protection the one", "HE14YCz1pj0-00318-00140760-00140933": "that's bringing us here taking", "HE14YCz1pj0-00319-00140934-00141095": "enthusiasts working with new", "HE14YCz1pj0-00320-00141096-00141257": "technologies all Based on data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00321-00141258-00141497": "particularly artificial intelligence Etc", "HE14YCz1pj0-00322-00141498-00141785": "and all these different sort of agendas", "HE14YCz1pj0-00323-00141786-00142019": "are starting to grow and they're", "HE14YCz1pj0-00324-00142020-00142289": "starting to um you know step on each", "HE14YCz1pj0-00325-00142290-00142528": "other's toes and what we're not seeing", "HE14YCz1pj0-00326-00142529-00142661": "yet and that's one of the things that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00327-00142662-00142901": "we're trying to work with is to create a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00328-00142902-00143116": "coordinated I guess a similar in in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00329-00143117-00143357": "nature to the recommendations that the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00330-00143358-00143645": "previous speaker has shared a a layer of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00331-00143646-00143771": "coordination among these different", "HE14YCz1pj0-00332-00143772-00143999": "agendas because that will help I think", "HE14YCz1pj0-00333-00144000-00144145": "we think", "HE14YCz1pj0-00334-00144146-00144383": "address some of the concerns that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00335-00144384-00144593": "actually you've raised us Topics in this", "HE14YCz1pj0-00336-00144594-00144869": "panel so what we've done", "HE14YCz1pj0-00337-00144870-00145354": "we've um made a comparison around the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00338-00145355-00145571": "data protection legislation available in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00339-00145572-00145775": "the region uh the inter-american", "HE14YCz1pj0-00340-00145776-00146021": "Development Bank works with 26 countries", "HE14YCz1pj0-00341-00146022-00146219": "in South America Central America and the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00342-00146220-00146477": "Caribbean out of those 26 countries 17", "HE14YCz1pj0-00343-00146478-00146669": "countries have", "HE14YCz1pj0-00344-00146670-00146861": "um data protection they use the personal", "HE14YCz1pj0-00345-00146862-00147028": "data protection legislation that's", "HE14YCz1pj0-00346-00147029-00147323": "approximately 65 percent which is a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00347-00147324-00147481": "little bit around the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00348-00147482-00147754": "percentage that was included in the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00349-00147755-00147864": "report", "HE14YCz1pj0-00350-00147865-00148097": "we have two or three countries we're", "HE14YCz1pj0-00351-00148098-00148295": "actually helping with their draft", "HE14YCz1pj0-00352-00148296-00148595": "legislation and of course the rest do", "HE14YCz1pj0-00353-00148596-00148889": "not have an active legislation the thing", "HE14YCz1pj0-00354-00148890-00149201": "to to consider here is uh that it's not", "HE14YCz1pj0-00355-00149202-00149357": "a binary", "HE14YCz1pj0-00356-00149358-00149590": "um you know uh variable whether you have", "HE14YCz1pj0-00357-00149591-00149789": "or not legislation it does help a lot", "HE14YCz1pj0-00358-00149790-00149945": "but we have countries that have", "HE14YCz1pj0-00359-00149946-00150125": "legislation that's more than 20 years", "HE14YCz1pj0-00360-00150126-00150395": "old that is in need for a very urgent", "HE14YCz1pj0-00361-00150396-00150790": "update that's not been sort of made for", "HE14YCz1pj0-00362-00150791-00151049": "the digital economy some of them are pre", "HE14YCz1pj0-00363-00151050-00151289": "gdpr and and you know whether we like", "HE14YCz1pj0-00364-00151290-00151493": "you know gdpr has set up our against", "HE14YCz1pj0-00365-00151494-00151685": "many countries are measuring themselves", "HE14YCz1pj0-00366-00151686-00151799": "with", "HE14YCz1pj0-00367-00151800-00152033": "um so what we've done is this comparison", "HE14YCz1pj0-00368-00152034-00152464": "uh with the inter um either American", "HE14YCz1pj0-00369-00152465-00152711": "um data protection standards basically", "HE14YCz1pj0-00370-00152712-00152902": "there's an even American data protection", "HE14YCz1pj0-00371-00152903-00153202": "Network that consists of authorities in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00372-00153203-00153454": "charge of uh enforcing data protection", "HE14YCz1pj0-00373-00153455-00153640": "in some of the countries in the region", "HE14YCz1pj0-00374-00153641-00153845": "plus Spain Portugal and a couple of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00375-00153846-00154097": "other countries in Europe uh the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00376-00154098-00154331": "standards are pretty much aligned with", "HE14YCz1pj0-00377-00154332-00154751": "gdpr they were issued in 2017-17 and we", "HE14YCz1pj0-00378-00154752-00154985": "are comparing those with um", "HE14YCz1pj0-00379-00154986-00155254": "with the legislation that we have in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00380-00155255-00155633": "place in the region so um we did that uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-00381-00155634-00155981": "there's the QR for the website uh if you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00382-00155982-00156125": "can see it", "HE14YCz1pj0-00383-00156126-00156251": "um", "HE14YCz1pj0-00384-00156252-00156569": "yeah uh we also in the same web page", "HE14YCz1pj0-00385-00156570-00156785": "you're going to find a survey within uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-00386-00156786-00156976": "to 10 000 people in the region", "HE14YCz1pj0-00387-00156977-00157283": "representing 10 countries", "HE14YCz1pj0-00388-00157284-00157523": "um so we would just wanted to know about", "HE14YCz1pj0-00389-00157524-00157811": "Awareness on data protection and whether", "HE14YCz1pj0-00390-00157812-00158081": "they knew what exactly personal data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00391-00158082-00158314": "protection was and then we also analyzed", "HE14YCz1pj0-00392-00158315-00158573": "some of the initiatives that appear in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00393-00158574-00158735": "response to the pandemic and how they", "HE14YCz1pj0-00394-00158736-00159023": "were treating personal data from the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00395-00159024-00159263": "citizens that were using those different", "HE14YCz1pj0-00396-00159264-00159652": "in most cases apps so", "HE14YCz1pj0-00397-00159653-00159923": "um what did we learn like I said 17 out", "HE14YCz1pj0-00398-00159924-00160199": "of 26 countries uh that we work with and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00399-00160200-00160366": "and I want to emphasize that because I", "HE14YCz1pj0-00400-00160367-00160576": "think there are approximately uh other", "HE14YCz1pj0-00401-00160577-00160871": "five or or so countries mostly in the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00402-00160872-00161014": "Caribbean that we're not working with", "HE14YCz1pj0-00403-00161015-00161285": "but 17 out of 26 that we work with have", "HE14YCz1pj0-00404-00161286-00161464": "a personal data protection legislation", "HE14YCz1pj0-00405-00161465-00161771": "in place uh like I said some of them are", "HE14YCz1pj0-00406-00161772-00162137": "you know even from 1999 so they need an", "HE14YCz1pj0-00407-00162138-00162490": "urgent update uh down to uh Belize I", "HE14YCz1pj0-00408-00162491-00162731": "think approved its personal data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00409-00162732-00163001": "protection legislation 2021 we have", "HE14YCz1pj0-00410-00163002-00163151": "Jamaica", "HE14YCz1pj0-00411-00163152-00163325": "um", "HE14YCz1pj0-00412-00163326-00163499": "um Ecuador", "HE14YCz1pj0-00413-00163500-00163816": "um 2020 I think Barbados 2019 so you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00414-00163817-00164111": "know there's been also a sort of wave of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00415-00164112-00164261": "countries approving data protection", "HE14YCz1pj0-00416-00164262-00164531": "legislation in the last couple of years", "HE14YCz1pj0-00417-00164532-00164675": "um so the American data protection", "HE14YCz1pj0-00418-00164676-00164921": "standards the data protection standards", "HE14YCz1pj0-00419-00164922-00165113": "include uh general rules for", "HE14YCz1pj0-00420-00165114-00165352": "international transfers of data and and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00421-00165353-00165563": "one of the things that we've seen is", "HE14YCz1pj0-00422-00165564-00165778": "that difference that you were mentioning", "HE14YCz1pj0-00423-00165779-00165989": "at the beginning of the panel between on", "HE14YCz1pj0-00424-00165990-00166337": "paper and reality and basically even if", "HE14YCz1pj0-00425-00166338-00166571": "the legislation that we have in place in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00426-00166572-00166816": "our countries uh is pretty much aligned", "HE14YCz1pj0-00427-00166817-00166997": "with the principles behind the standards", "HE14YCz1pj0-00428-00166998-00167147": "which like I said are pretty much", "HE14YCz1pj0-00429-00167148-00167311": "aligned with the principle behind the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00430-00167312-00167521": "European regulation", "HE14YCz1pj0-00431-00167522-00167764": "there's a lot to be done in terms of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00432-00167765-00167897": "enforcement", "HE14YCz1pj0-00433-00167898-00168214": "um most of the legislation allows", "HE14YCz1pj0-00434-00168215-00168473": "exchange of data with providers in other", "HE14YCz1pj0-00435-00168474-00168671": "countries as long as they have an", "HE14YCz1pj0-00436-00168672-00168923": "adequate data protection or similar data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00437-00168924-00169102": "protection environment or legislation as", "HE14YCz1pj0-00438-00169103-00169361": "a country the host country but who's", "HE14YCz1pj0-00439-00169362-00169697": "defining adequacy who's betting whether", "HE14YCz1pj0-00440-00169698-00169921": "those different providers", "HE14YCz1pj0-00441-00169922-00170411": "vendors all countries data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00442-00170412-00170711": "legislation uh it's something that's", "HE14YCz1pj0-00443-00170712-00170926": "left a little bit to the actual uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-00444-00170927-00171143": "company that's making the or entity", "HE14YCz1pj0-00445-00171144-00171563": "that's making the data processing", "HE14YCz1pj0-00446-00171564-00171904": "um governments in some cases also have a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00447-00171905-00172163": "trouble with using cloud services", "HE14YCz1pj0-00448-00172164-00172402": "there's one or two countries where", "HE14YCz1pj0-00449-00172403-00172733": "they're actually decided that all uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-00450-00172734-00172993": "information from government must be", "HE14YCz1pj0-00451-00172994-00173243": "stored within the territory of the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00452-00173244-00173495": "country who enforces this legislation", "HE14YCz1pj0-00453-00173496-00173837": "how well is it done and as I mentioned", "HE14YCz1pj0-00454-00173838-00174052": "at the beginning what we are seeing", "HE14YCz1pj0-00455-00174053-00174389": "overall is this need for a strong and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00456-00174390-00174749": "coordinated institutional framework out", "HE14YCz1pj0-00457-00174750-00175066": "of the 17 countries and and we need to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00458-00175067-00175271": "also understand like I said that many of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00459-00175272-00175493": "these legislations are relatively new", "HE14YCz1pj0-00460-00175494-00175799": "but I would say it's about eight to ten", "HE14YCz1pj0-00461-00175800-00176051": "including a couple of Commissioners in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00462-00176052-00176285": "the Caribbean that are have been", "HE14YCz1pj0-00463-00176286-00176483": "actually uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-00464-00176484-00176747": "created to enforce the legislation there", "HE14YCz1pj0-00465-00176748-00176914": "are some countries where despite having", "HE14YCz1pj0-00466-00176915-00177226": "the legal framework don't have an entity", "HE14YCz1pj0-00467-00177227-00177431": "that in charge of enforcing and even", "HE14YCz1pj0-00468-00177432-00177688": "then there are like several layers right", "HE14YCz1pj0-00469-00177689-00177857": "so you have the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00470-00177858-00178102": "um attributes that the law gives the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00471-00178103-00178301": "entity then you have the actual", "HE14YCz1pj0-00472-00178302-00178625": "resources that the entity has and one of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00473-00178626-00178804": "those attributes sorry uh going back", "HE14YCz1pj0-00474-00178805-00179137": "about independence about the capacity to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00475-00179138-00179363": "make decisions", "HE14YCz1pj0-00476-00179364-00179614": "um uh independently that has a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00477-00179615-00179776": "Collegiate collegial", "HE14YCz1pj0-00478-00179777-00180047": "um", "HE14YCz1pj0-00479-00180048-00180299": "um leadership uh it's something that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00480-00180300-00180540": "we're also looking at and also the uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-00481-00180541-00180904": "sorry we're going to have to come back", "HE14YCz1pj0-00482-00180905-00181193": "to you so keep those thoughts thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00483-00181194-00181363": "very much", "HE14YCz1pj0-00484-00181364-00181895": "just stay with us thanks", "HE14YCz1pj0-00485-00181896-00182159": "all right thank you and thank you uh I'm", "HE14YCz1pj0-00486-00182160-00182302": "sure we'll get back to you soon I'll try", "HE14YCz1pj0-00487-00182303-00182638": "to save some time so that uh so when we", "HE14YCz1pj0-00488-00182639-00182819": "talk about data governance and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00489-00182820-00183047": "protecting privacy one thing that comes", "HE14YCz1pj0-00490-00183048-00183263": "to mind for me is is Trust", "HE14YCz1pj0-00491-00183264-00183502": "because trust is at the center of all", "HE14YCz1pj0-00492-00183503-00183809": "this and unfortunately whatever he wrote", "HE14YCz1pj0-00493-00183810-00184109": "trust uh violations he wrote trust and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00494-00184110-00184264": "whatever he wrote trust as a community", "HE14YCz1pj0-00495-00184265-00184613": "we need to condemn one number that comes", "HE14YCz1pj0-00496-00184614-00184871": "to mind for me is 1.9 billion", "HE14YCz1pj0-00497-00184872-00185104": "that's the number of people who were", "HE14YCz1pj0-00498-00185105-00185338": "caught off from the internet in the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00499-00185339-00185507": "first half of 2022", "HE14YCz1pj0-00500-00185508-00185945": "not unconnected but Disconnected by", "HE14YCz1pj0-00501-00185946-00186190": "deliberate shutdowns like the one going", "HE14YCz1pj0-00502-00186191-00186454": "on in Tigre in Ethiopia right now and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00503-00186455-00186557": "I'm saying that because we're in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00504-00186558-00186881": "Ethiopia discussing the internet", "HE14YCz1pj0-00505-00186882-00187073": "and I think it's important to have these", "HE14YCz1pj0-00506-00187074-00187283": "conversations because we can keep", "HE14YCz1pj0-00507-00187284-00187540": "talking about governance we can keep", "HE14YCz1pj0-00508-00187541-00187823": "talking about protecting privacy but if", "HE14YCz1pj0-00509-00187824-00188063": "we don't address the violations we will", "HE14YCz1pj0-00510-00188064-00188302": "keep eroding trust and the people the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00511-00188303-00188525": "stakeholders we need to work with will", "HE14YCz1pj0-00512-00188526-00188759": "know that we're just having a talk shop", "HE14YCz1pj0-00513-00188760-00188963": "and we'll have all that all those", "HE14YCz1pj0-00514-00188964-00189149": "conversations and leave the place and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00515-00189150-00189299": "say we'll see you again next year and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00516-00189300-00189449": "and I think it's it's really important", "HE14YCz1pj0-00517-00189450-00189664": "uh to talk about this", "HE14YCz1pj0-00518-00189665-00189899": "and and that's that's one of the reasons", "HE14YCz1pj0-00519-00189900-00190223": "why uh you know talking talking about", "HE14YCz1pj0-00520-00190224-00190414": "the the region we're in today which is", "HE14YCz1pj0-00521-00190415-00190721": "you know which is Africa we have a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00522-00190722-00191051": "framework that you know has been", "HE14YCz1pj0-00523-00191052-00191309": "in place since 2014 the malabo", "HE14YCz1pj0-00524-00191310-00191416": "convention", "HE14YCz1pj0-00525-00191417-00191597": "and I think that a number of you know", "HE14YCz1pj0-00526-00191598-00191740": "sessions that this igf has talked about", "HE14YCz1pj0-00527-00191741-00192083": "it uh and how how worrying it is that we", "HE14YCz1pj0-00528-00192084-00192347": "have only uh eight you know signatures", "HE14YCz1pj0-00529-00192348-00192647": "so far uh we need 15 uh you know one of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00530-00192648-00192845": "the earlier panels someone compared the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00531-00192846-00192971": "number of signatures we have which is", "HE14YCz1pj0-00532-00192972-00193133": "eight uh to the number of countries on", "HE14YCz1pj0-00533-00193134-00193433": "the continent uh over 50. uh and that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00534-00193434-00193828": "that points for me to how we prioritize", "HE14YCz1pj0-00535-00193829-00194075": "when we have conversations we prioritize", "HE14YCz1pj0-00536-00194076-00194302": "these topics but when it comes to action", "HE14YCz1pj0-00537-00194303-00194549": "we don't prioritize them and that's very", "HE14YCz1pj0-00538-00194550-00194825": "worrying because if our talk and our", "HE14YCz1pj0-00539-00194826-00195143": "action don't align then we may as well", "HE14YCz1pj0-00540-00195144-00195359": "just not waste our time to jump on", "HE14YCz1pj0-00541-00195360-00195616": "planes and jump on Zoom to have this you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00542-00195617-00195875": "know conversations and invest time uh in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00543-00195876-00196019": "them so", "HE14YCz1pj0-00544-00196020-00196271": "and having said this uh I know that you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00545-00196272-00196457": "know privacy and governance must", "HE14YCz1pj0-00546-00196458-00196804": "definitely uh be deliberate when we talk", "HE14YCz1pj0-00547-00196805-00197038": "about data governance uh there are", "HE14YCz1pj0-00548-00197039-00197195": "institutions there are many institutions", "HE14YCz1pj0-00549-00197196-00197423": "involved thankfully where the igf which", "HE14YCz1pj0-00550-00197424-00197561": "is multi-stakeholders so there are many", "HE14YCz1pj0-00551-00197562-00197723": "institutions we've got the Academia", "HE14YCz1pj0-00552-00197724-00197993": "Civil Society uh government the private", "HE14YCz1pj0-00553-00197994-00198275": "sector but one Central institution that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00554-00198276-00198509": "plays a prominent role in data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00555-00198510-00198652": "governance", "HE14YCz1pj0-00556-00198653-00198899": "um are data protection authorities", "HE14YCz1pj0-00557-00198900-00199102": "or whatever name you call them in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00558-00199103-00199325": "various constituences and this you know", "HE14YCz1pj0-00559-00199326-00199649": "this this dpas one of the things that in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00560-00199650-00199811": "our own work at Paradigm initiative and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00561-00199812-00200081": "we did a study of the last 20 years uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-00562-00200082-00200369": "the last 20 years of data protection uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-00563-00200370-00200578": "on the continent looking specifically of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00564-00200579-00200800": "30 countries uh looking at those of them", "HE14YCz1pj0-00565-00200801-00201083": "who got data protection laws uh but", "HE14YCz1pj0-00566-00201084-00201214": "don't have data protection authorities", "HE14YCz1pj0-00567-00201215-00201407": "those who have prediction laws and have", "HE14YCz1pj0-00568-00201408-00201652": "interpretation authorities but one of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00569-00201653-00201857": "the things that we found in our report", "HE14YCz1pj0-00570-00201858-00202295": "is that as we have a lot more data you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00571-00202296-00202547": "know Mass data collection projects in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00572-00202548-00202823": "many countries unfortunately we don't", "HE14YCz1pj0-00573-00202824-00203171": "have legal Frameworks to protect us and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00574-00203172-00203423": "and that that also erodes trust and I", "HE14YCz1pj0-00575-00203424-00203590": "can give many examples of many countries", "HE14YCz1pj0-00576-00203591-00203825": "where people have to give biometric", "HE14YCz1pj0-00577-00203826-00204004": "information to multiple government", "HE14YCz1pj0-00578-00204005-00204328": "agencies and there is no legal framework", "HE14YCz1pj0-00579-00204329-00204502": "to protect that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00580-00204503-00204676": "one of the things you know we find in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00581-00204677-00204844": "the study is also the fact that you know", "HE14YCz1pj0-00582-00204846-00205144": "covered was a period where we really", "HE14YCz1pj0-00583-00205146-00205271": "needed Trust", "HE14YCz1pj0-00584-00205271-00205427": "uh and there was a lot of data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00585-00205428-00205612": "collection you know for the purpose of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00586-00205613-00205816": "fighting the virus killing the virus and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00587-00205817-00206021": "things like that uh and hopefully who", "HE14YCz1pj0-00588-00206021-00206219": "announces very soon that it's over we're", "HE14YCz1pj0-00589-00206219-00206386": "looking forward to that uh but one of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00590-00206387-00206584": "the things that we also saw and you know", "HE14YCz1pj0-00591-00206585-00206753": "documented in the report is the fact", "HE14YCz1pj0-00592-00206754-00207023": "that many governments while you know", "HE14YCz1pj0-00593-00207023-00207371": "investing heavily in data collection", "HE14YCz1pj0-00594-00207371-00207803": "have not invested equally in protecting", "HE14YCz1pj0-00595-00207804-00208042": "the data in fact one of the major things", "HE14YCz1pj0-00596-00208044-00208234": "that we found was that there were", "HE14YCz1pj0-00597-00208235-00208558": "violations by agencies that were", "HE14YCz1pj0-00598-00208559-00208834": "supposed to protect data and that of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00599-00208835-00208973": "course led to many scenarios where", "HE14YCz1pj0-00600-00208973-00209219": "citizens refused and then government had", "HE14YCz1pj0-00601-00209219-00209381": "to literally force them and say that you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00602-00209382-00209555": "know what if you don't do this by this", "HE14YCz1pj0-00603-00209556-00209657": "particular date you're going to be", "HE14YCz1pj0-00604-00209658-00209777": "caught off banking or you're going to be", "HE14YCz1pj0-00605-00209778-00209939": "cut off you know certain services and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00606-00209940-00210160": "that that you know uh is not where we're", "HE14YCz1pj0-00607-00210161-00210334": "supposed to be if we're talking about", "HE14YCz1pj0-00608-00210335-00210508": "you know governance if we're talking", "HE14YCz1pj0-00609-00210509-00210731": "about protection then we have to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00610-00210732-00210898": "strengthen institutions", "HE14YCz1pj0-00611-00210900-00211175": "we saw uh the needs are obvious uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-00612-00211176-00211403": "identified a lot of gaps but one of the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00613-00211404-00211582": "beautiful things we saw across the 30", "HE14YCz1pj0-00614-00211583-00211810": "countries we looked at is the fact that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00615-00211811-00212087": "all stakeholders uh Now understand the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00616-00212088-00212363": "place of data and are willing to commit", "HE14YCz1pj0-00617-00212364-00212555": "time and resources to working together", "HE14YCz1pj0-00618-00212556-00212771": "and I think this is the good news that I", "HE14YCz1pj0-00619-00212771-00213029": "have as far as data governance and you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00620-00213030-00213179": "know and and protecting privacy is", "HE14YCz1pj0-00621-00213180-00213371": "concerned that gone are the days where", "HE14YCz1pj0-00622-00213371-00213527": "it was just the remit of maybe", "HE14YCz1pj0-00623-00213528-00213706": "governments and dpas to talk about this", "HE14YCz1pj0-00624-00213707-00213977": "but now including users all stakeholders", "HE14YCz1pj0-00625-00213978-00214205": "are willing to chip in and get us to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00626-00214206-00214384": "move forward because trust is at the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00627-00214385-00214571": "center of all this and we all need to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00628-00214571-00214739": "contribute to making sure that doesn't", "HE14YCz1pj0-00629-00214740-00214919": "get eroded through violations and other", "HE14YCz1pj0-00630-00214919-00215308": "things thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00631-00215309-00215506": "thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00632-00215507-00215884": "ambassador", "HE14YCz1pj0-00633-00215885-00216094": "can you hear me you're a very hard act", "HE14YCz1pj0-00634-00216096-00216329": "to follow that's uh eloquent I could", "HE14YCz1pj0-00635-00216330-00216473": "listen all day", "HE14YCz1pj0-00636-00216473-00216706": "um thank you very much for uh for having", "HE14YCz1pj0-00637-00216707-00216887": "me it's a pleasure and an honor to be", "HE14YCz1pj0-00638-00216888-00217060": "both at the igf and on this important", "HE14YCz1pj0-00639-00217061-00217337": "panel today and I'm going to begin my", "HE14YCz1pj0-00640-00217338-00217577": "remarks uh with a short explanation of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00641-00217578-00217877": "uh how we at the U.S Department of State", "HE14YCz1pj0-00642-00217878-00218201": "view data privacy and data governance", "HE14YCz1pj0-00643-00218202-00218579": "so data protection is a key geopolitical", "HE14YCz1pj0-00644-00218580-00218831": "issue Central to our strategic interests", "HE14YCz1pj0-00645-00218832-00219023": "it's Central to our efforts to promote", "HE14YCz1pj0-00646-00219023-00219275": "meaningful connectivity to an open", "HE14YCz1pj0-00647-00219276-00219467": "interoperable secure and reliable", "HE14YCz1pj0-00648-00219467-00219706": "internet into a stable stable cyberspace", "HE14YCz1pj0-00649-00219707-00219827": "overall", "HE14YCz1pj0-00650-00219828-00220115": "I would be remiss to take the floor", "HE14YCz1pj0-00651-00220116-00220355": "today without commenting briefly on the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00652-00220356-00220505": "importance of access to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00653-00220506-00220721": "telecommunications the internet and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00654-00220721-00220889": "digital Technologies and promoting and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00655-00220890-00221171": "protecting the exercise of Human Rights", "HE14YCz1pj0-00656-00221171-00221351": "and fundamental freedoms in modern", "HE14YCz1pj0-00657-00221352-00221482": "societies", "HE14YCz1pj0-00658-00221483-00221734": "governments should facilitate that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00659-00221735-00221956": "access and refrain from shutting down", "HE14YCz1pj0-00660-00221957-00222196": "telecommunications and the internet to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00661-00222198-00222389": "isolate regions and inhibit information", "HE14YCz1pj0-00662-00222390-00222581": "and free expression online", "HE14YCz1pj0-00663-00222582-00222875": "and here in Ethiopia we applaud the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00664-00222876-00223079": "Pretoria agreement and call on the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00665-00223080-00223225": "government to restore full services", "HE14YCz1pj0-00666-00223226-00223553": "including internet access to all areas", "HE14YCz1pj0-00667-00223554-00223769": "affected by the conflict", "HE14YCz1pj0-00668-00223769-00224075": "data governance and data privacy are", "HE14YCz1pj0-00669-00224076-00224441": "Central to this call uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-00670-00224442-00224729": "to put forward a compelling and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00671-00224730-00224975": "affirmative vision for the future of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00672-00224976-00225221": "technology and we seek to work with a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00673-00225221-00225382": "community of like-minded Partners to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00674-00225383-00225634": "develop shared approaches and to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00675-00225635-00225803": "demonstrate that we can develop policy", "HE14YCz1pj0-00676-00225804-00226091": "solutions that reflect our commitment to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00677-00226092-00226355": "strong and effective privacy protections", "HE14YCz1pj0-00678-00226356-00226637": "while simultaneously facilitating the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00679-00226638-00226891": "cross-border data flows that open", "HE14YCz1pj0-00680-00226892-00227194": "market-led economies and societies", "HE14YCz1pj0-00681-00227196-00227506": "depend upon so just with that as", "HE14YCz1pj0-00682-00227507-00227806": "background uh let me lay out three", "HE14YCz1pj0-00683-00227807-00228071": "underlying principles on privacy and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00684-00228071-00228371": "data governance from our perspective", "HE14YCz1pj0-00685-00228371-00228713": "first we don't see a zero-sum trade-off", "HE14YCz1pj0-00686-00228714-00228917": "between protecting privacy and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00687-00228917-00229169": "facilitating cross-border data flows we", "HE14YCz1pj0-00688-00229169-00229360": "can and must support both objectives", "HE14YCz1pj0-00689-00229361-00229510": "simultaneously", "HE14YCz1pj0-00690-00229511-00229727": "we know that cross-border data flows are", "HE14YCz1pj0-00691-00229728-00229882": "the lifeblood of the modern global", "HE14YCz1pj0-00692-00229883-00230141": "economy vital not just for large", "HE14YCz1pj0-00693-00230142-00230417": "technology companies but for companies", "HE14YCz1pj0-00694-00230417-00230644": "and organizations of all sizes across", "HE14YCz1pj0-00695-00230646-00230758": "all sectors", "HE14YCz1pj0-00696-00230759-00230956": "data flows are critical for", "HE14YCz1pj0-00697-00230957-00231137": "international cooperation on scientific", "HE14YCz1pj0-00698-00231138-00231346": "research law enforcement National", "HE14YCz1pj0-00699-00231348-00231610": "Security transportation and ensuring", "HE14YCz1pj0-00700-00231611-00231856": "people-to-people ties around the globe", "HE14YCz1pj0-00701-00231857-00232025": "but we also know that people communities", "HE14YCz1pj0-00702-00232026-00232151": "and governments", "HE14YCz1pj0-00703-00232152-00232294": "around the world they're rightfully", "HE14YCz1pj0-00704-00232296-00232492": "demanding stronger and more effective", "HE14YCz1pj0-00705-00232494-00232756": "data privacy protections without strong", "HE14YCz1pj0-00706-00232757-00233044": "privacy protections people lose trust in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00707-00233046-00233206": "cross-border data flows and I agree", "HE14YCz1pj0-00708-00233207-00233513": "trust is the currency", "HE14YCz1pj0-00709-00233514-00233734": "we do not accept the view that effective", "HE14YCz1pj0-00710-00233735-00233951": "privacy protections must necessarily", "HE14YCz1pj0-00711-00233952-00234221": "impede cross-border data flows rather we", "HE14YCz1pj0-00712-00234221-00234419": "view privacy protections as contributing", "HE14YCz1pj0-00713-00234419-00234617": "to a safer more prosperous Global", "HE14YCz1pj0-00714-00234617-00234760": "digital economy", "HE14YCz1pj0-00715-00234761-00234982": "the second Principle as already", "HE14YCz1pj0-00716-00234983-00235271": "mentioned earlier is we need to focus on", "HE14YCz1pj0-00717-00235271-00235529": "privacy protections as implemented on", "HE14YCz1pj0-00718-00235530-00235792": "the ground and not just in the abstract", "HE14YCz1pj0-00719-00235794-00235996": "as we see more and more countries around", "HE14YCz1pj0-00720-00235998-00236194": "the world adopting new or updated", "HE14YCz1pj0-00721-00236196-00236477": "privacy legislation the Gap can grow", "HE14YCz1pj0-00722-00236478-00236698": "between the rules on the books and the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00723-00236700-00236860": "implementation and practice", "HE14YCz1pj0-00724-00236861-00237089": "with inconsistent enforcement and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00725-00237090-00237251": "significant confusion among businesses", "HE14YCz1pj0-00726-00237252-00237467": "and other entities on what exactly is", "HE14YCz1pj0-00727-00237467-00237665": "required to comply with the law", "HE14YCz1pj0-00728-00237666-00237827": "and to build trust in the digital", "HE14YCz1pj0-00729-00237828-00238048": "economy we need to to ensure not only", "HE14YCz1pj0-00730-00238050-00238253": "that effective privacy laws are on the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00731-00238254-00238469": "books but also the market participants", "HE14YCz1pj0-00732-00238469-00238721": "understand and follow them and that's", "HE14YCz1pj0-00733-00238721-00238931": "why data governance policies should be", "HE14YCz1pj0-00734-00238932-00239098": "developed with input from the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00735-00239100-00239284": "multi-stakeholder community who", "HE14YCz1pj0-00736-00239285-00239531": "understand not only the abstract legal", "HE14YCz1pj0-00737-00239532-00239746": "debates around privacy but also the real", "HE14YCz1pj0-00738-00239748-00239903": "world challenges of implementing", "HE14YCz1pj0-00739-00239904-00240160": "effective data privacy Solutions", "HE14YCz1pj0-00740-00240161-00240334": "that brings me to the third and final", "HE14YCz1pj0-00741-00240335-00240448": "principle", "HE14YCz1pj0-00742-00240450-00240629": "which is the need for interoperability", "HE14YCz1pj0-00743-00240630-00240946": "between countries data privacy regimes", "HE14YCz1pj0-00744-00240948-00241096": "when we focus on the real world", "HE14YCz1pj0-00745-00241098-00241331": "implementation of data protection it", "HE14YCz1pj0-00746-00241332-00241573": "clear that there will be no single", "HE14YCz1pj0-00747-00241573-00241775": "one-size-fits-all approach", "HE14YCz1pj0-00748-00241776-00241955": "countries have their own histories", "HE14YCz1pj0-00749-00241956-00242291": "cultures legal traditions and Regulatory", "HE14YCz1pj0-00750-00242292-00242542": "structures they will thus develop", "HE14YCz1pj0-00751-00242544-00242758": "privacy protections consistent with", "HE14YCz1pj0-00752-00242759-00242944": "their own local contexts and the need to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00753-00242946-00243106": "protect human rights", "HE14YCz1pj0-00754-00243107-00243281": "as countries develop their own tailored", "HE14YCz1pj0-00755-00243282-00243563": "approaches to data privacy some level of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00756-00243564-00243791": "consistency and interoperability between", "HE14YCz1pj0-00757-00243792-00244096": "approaches is necessary to ensure that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00758-00244098-00244301": "as data moves across borders it ensures", "HE14YCz1pj0-00759-00244302-00244498": "effective protections", "HE14YCz1pj0-00760-00244500-00244691": "so in closing let me use this", "HE14YCz1pj0-00761-00244692-00244901": "opportunity to highlight one such effort", "HE14YCz1pj0-00762-00244902-00245123": "to promote interoperability about which", "HE14YCz1pj0-00763-00245123-00245417": "the U.S is particularly excited the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00764-00245417-00245621": "global cross-border privacy rules or", "HE14YCz1pj0-00765-00245621-00245806": "cbpr system", "HE14YCz1pj0-00766-00245807-00246046": "the CBR BPR system is based on a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00767-00246048-00246232": "voluntary data privacy certification", "HE14YCz1pj0-00768-00246233-00246425": "that helps companies demonstrate", "HE14YCz1pj0-00769-00246426-00246569": "compliance with internationally", "HE14YCz1pj0-00770-00246569-00246875": "recognized data privacy standards the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00771-00246876-00247169": "cppr system was developed under Apec but", "HE14YCz1pj0-00772-00247169-00247456": "current cbpr member economies", "HE14YCz1pj0-00773-00247457-00247810": "are launching a global cbpr forum to all", "HE14YCz1pj0-00774-00247811-00247984": "jurisdictions that share its objectives", "HE14YCz1pj0-00775-00247985-00248110": "and its purpose", "HE14YCz1pj0-00776-00248111-00248296": "with a unique approach founded on", "HE14YCz1pj0-00777-00248298-00248555": "creating practical compliance tools the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00778-00248556-00248831": "global cbpr forum will facilitate trade", "HE14YCz1pj0-00779-00248832-00249125": "internet international data flows while", "HE14YCz1pj0-00780-00249126-00249287": "building on our shared data privacy", "HE14YCz1pj0-00781-00249288-00249401": "values", "HE14YCz1pj0-00782-00249402-00249748": "to this end we hope many economies many", "HE14YCz1pj0-00783-00249750-00249989": "countries will join the new forum and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00784-00249990-00250223": "that many companies will pursue cbpr", "HE14YCz1pj0-00785-00250223-00250415": "certification if you're interested in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00786-00250416-00250613": "learning more about the program you can", "HE14YCz1pj0-00787-00250614-00251027": "check it out it's a globalcbpr.org", "HE14YCz1pj0-00788-00251028-00251213": "so thanks again for the opportunity to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00789-00251214-00251477": "be here", "HE14YCz1pj0-00790-00251478-00252658": "thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-00791-00252659-00253042": "foreign", "HE14YCz1pj0-00792-00253044-00253301": "so thank you for this opportunity Carol", "HE14YCz1pj0-00793-00253302-00253589": "and to my panelists I don't know you'll", "HE14YCz1pj0-00794-00253590-00253744": "be a hard act to follow as well after", "HE14YCz1pj0-00795-00253746-00253913": "Tenga", "HE14YCz1pj0-00796-00253914-00254105": "so um", "HE14YCz1pj0-00797-00254106-00254398": "for my Approach we need to look at data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00798-00254400-00254627": "as the new currency because in trying to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00799-00254628-00254806": "answer the question of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00800-00254807-00255071": "who we are protecting is it the people", "HE14YCz1pj0-00801-00255071-00255527": "or the data it it needs to be said that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00802-00255528-00255689": "this data that we're talking about", "HE14YCz1pj0-00803-00255690-00255941": "drives the digital world all the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00804-00255942-00256132": "internet applications that we use on a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00805-00256133-00256306": "daily basis", "HE14YCz1pj0-00806-00256307-00256565": "and it also has a major role to play in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00807-00256566-00256787": "the economic growth especially on our", "HE14YCz1pj0-00808-00256788-00256906": "continent", "HE14YCz1pj0-00809-00256907-00257165": "the use of data has grown exponentially", "HE14YCz1pj0-00810-00257166-00257453": "and the data being aggregated and shared", "HE14YCz1pj0-00811-00257454-00257729": "amongst the highest consumers especially", "HE14YCz1pj0-00812-00257730-00258010": "in the marketing and insurance Fields", "HE14YCz1pj0-00813-00258011-00258329": "um has um opened a door", "HE14YCz1pj0-00814-00258330-00258737": "somewhat for illegal collections of data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00815-00258738-00259019": "just to enhance the profit and the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00816-00259019-00259403": "bottom line of these huge companies", "HE14YCz1pj0-00817-00259404-00259667": "and as noted the enriched data sales", "HE14YCz1pj0-00818-00259667-00259871": "have become a more important revenue", "HE14YCz1pj0-00819-00259871-00260387": "streams in many organizations", "HE14YCz1pj0-00820-00260388-00260627": "so we need to look at how now the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00821-00260628-00260819": "security compromises or the data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00822-00260819-00261071": "breaches that result from this really", "HE14YCz1pj0-00823-00261071-00261401": "affect how they affect the people that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00824-00261402-00261689": "um actually are the data subjects so", "HE14YCz1pj0-00825-00261690-00261989": "it's the people who own the data and um", "HE14YCz1pj0-00826-00261990-00262289": "for our purposes in South Africa our", "HE14YCz1pj0-00827-00262290-00262619": "data regulations stem from our Bill of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00828-00262620-00262805": "Rights which um", "HE14YCz1pj0-00829-00262806-00263063": "say that everyone has a right to privacy", "HE14YCz1pj0-00830-00263064-00263327": "so if people have the right to privacy", "HE14YCz1pj0-00831-00263328-00263705": "their data is part of what they they", "HE14YCz1pj0-00832-00263706-00263903": "need to keep private", "HE14YCz1pj0-00833-00263904-00264113": "and no one will put the data subject", "HE14YCz1pj0-00834-00264114-00264317": "first as long as the regulations that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00835-00264318-00264547": "are being implemented are only on paper", "HE14YCz1pj0-00836-00264548-00264827": "so from what we have observed as a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00837-00264828-00265139": "regulator in South Africa is that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00838-00265140-00265487": "a lot of the compromises we've seen", "HE14YCz1pj0-00839-00265488-00265756": "in assessing the companies we find that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00840-00265757-00266039": "they have the measures in place they", "HE14YCz1pj0-00841-00266040-00266308": "have the policies they have", "HE14YCz1pj0-00842-00266309-00266537": "um the the way that they are doing the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00843-00266538-00266795": "procedures but the implementation is", "HE14YCz1pj0-00844-00266796-00267106": "just not there I mean", "HE14YCz1pj0-00845-00267107-00267365": "we are Outsourcing our development", "HE14YCz1pj0-00846-00267366-00267589": "efforts are we also associate", "HE14YCz1pj0-00847-00267590-00267845": "Outsourcing the ethical role that we", "HE14YCz1pj0-00848-00267846-00268108": "have in protecting the privacy of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00849-00268109-00268223": "individuals", "HE14YCz1pj0-00850-00268224-00268469": "I think um it's a very important", "HE14YCz1pj0-00851-00268470-00268708": "question that we need to answer in terms", "HE14YCz1pj0-00852-00268709-00268984": "of what is the broad spectrum of the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00853-00268985-00269177": "ethics that we're talking about who who", "HE14YCz1pj0-00854-00269178-00269434": "do they depend on is it dependent on me", "HE14YCz1pj0-00855-00269435-00269663": "who is making the profit or is it", "HE14YCz1pj0-00856-00269664-00270041": "dependent on the right thing to do", "HE14YCz1pj0-00857-00270042-00270234": "um so", "HE14YCz1pj0-00858-00270235-00270455": "I'm sorry about that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00859-00270456-00270634": "um so in implementing", "HE14YCz1pj0-00860-00270635-00270856": "um privacy by Design and systems for", "HE14YCz1pj0-00861-00270857-00270977": "instance", "HE14YCz1pj0-00862-00270978-00271397": "we need to be able to monitor the the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00863-00271398-00271606": "people who are actually", "HE14YCz1pj0-00864-00271607-00271751": "um implementing", "HE14YCz1pj0-00865-00271752-00272008": "um this these designs what happens when", "HE14YCz1pj0-00866-00272009-00272195": "the Privacy rights of the individual", "HE14YCz1pj0-00867-00272196-00272399": "which could be posted by adding", "HE14YCz1pj0-00868-00272400-00272639": "encryption trash with the developers", "HE14YCz1pj0-00869-00272640-00272945": "money to achieve low latency on the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00870-00272946-00273208": "system so we want faster systems but we", "HE14YCz1pj0-00871-00273209-00273473": "know that by adding encryption", "HE14YCz1pj0-00872-00273474-00273623": "um we will lose a lot of time in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00873-00273624-00273730": "processing", "HE14YCz1pj0-00874-00273731-00273977": "so the inability to deliver bad news to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00875-00273978-00274199": "management as well especially if it", "HE14YCz1pj0-00876-00274200-00274373": "affects the bottom line is an indication", "HE14YCz1pj0-00877-00274374-00274637": "of how we see this disjoint between the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00878-00274638-00274853": "security measures on paper and the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00879-00274854-00275087": "actual Security implementations on live", "HE14YCz1pj0-00880-00275088-00275249": "systems", "HE14YCz1pj0-00881-00275250-00275567": "so we need we do need a global framework", "HE14YCz1pj0-00882-00275568-00275884": "I know that there is a lot of cultural", "HE14YCz1pj0-00883-00275885-00276227": "differences a lot of differences within", "HE14YCz1pj0-00884-00276228-00276460": "countries in terms of their regulations", "HE14YCz1pj0-00885-00276461-00276775": "but in order for us to facilitate the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00886-00276776-00277121": "cross-border data flows we do need an", "HE14YCz1pj0-00887-00277122-00277403": "equal paying field in terms of the data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00888-00277404-00277684": "privacy regulations that said these", "HE14YCz1pj0-00889-00277685-00277895": "private regulations should be aligned", "HE14YCz1pj0-00890-00277896-00278110": "with each other if we are to achieve a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00891-00278111-00278303": "situation where we can continue to use", "HE14YCz1pj0-00892-00278304-00278651": "the data to grow the economies that are", "HE14YCz1pj0-00893-00278652-00278956": "desperately in need of the opportunities", "HE14YCz1pj0-00894-00278957-00279355": "that come with information processing", "HE14YCz1pj0-00895-00279356-00279551": "so", "HE14YCz1pj0-00896-00279552-00279760": "um in Saving Time and ensuring that we", "HE14YCz1pj0-00897-00279761-00279965": "can have more discussions later I will", "HE14YCz1pj0-00898-00279966-00280445": "pass on to my next colleague", "HE14YCz1pj0-00899-00280446-00280595": "thank you so much happy to be here with", "HE14YCz1pj0-00900-00280596-00280732": "you and I'm really looking forward to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00901-00280733-00280882": "picking up a number of the great points", "HE14YCz1pj0-00902-00280883-00281134": "that have been made so far I'd start off", "HE14YCz1pj0-00903-00281135-00281389": "though by by placing this conversation", "HE14YCz1pj0-00904-00281390-00281729": "in a framework of Human Rights", "HE14YCz1pj0-00905-00281730-00281956": "um we are talking about data protection", "HE14YCz1pj0-00906-00281957-00282227": "data privacy not as a matter of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00907-00282228-00282491": "convenience or as a good practice but", "HE14YCz1pj0-00908-00282492-00282739": "because people have a right to privacy", "HE14YCz1pj0-00909-00282740-00283097": "and the in fact data protection affects", "HE14YCz1pj0-00910-00283098-00283373": "a broad range of other rights it affects", "HE14YCz1pj0-00911-00283374-00283529": "the rights to equal treatment and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00912-00283530-00283780": "non-discrimination access to the rights", "HE14YCz1pj0-00913-00283781-00284027": "to health and education for example and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00914-00284028-00284237": "also fundamental access to democratic", "HE14YCz1pj0-00915-00284238-00284417": "rights including free expression and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00916-00284418-00284717": "free association as Government access to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00917-00284718-00284951": "personal data increases", "HE14YCz1pj0-00918-00284952-00285125": "um I'd also underline the points made by", "HE14YCz1pj0-00919-00285126-00285353": "my colleagues on internet access and how", "HE14YCz1pj0-00920-00285354-00285563": "while we we look at the right side of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00921-00285564-00285875": "this we also know that the data uh flow", "HE14YCz1pj0-00922-00285876-00286127": "and data as a currency as as has been", "HE14YCz1pj0-00923-00286128-00286391": "said is is essential and so we agree", "HE14YCz1pj0-00924-00286392-00286589": "entirely with the need to end internet", "HE14YCz1pj0-00925-00286590-00286853": "shutdowns in this context", "HE14YCz1pj0-00926-00286854-00286991": "um the scale of the challenge we face", "HE14YCz1pj0-00927-00286992-00287260": "with regards to data is immense uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-00928-00287261-00287434": "social media and search engines uh main", "HE14YCz1pj0-00929-00287435-00287584": "source of information of course and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00930-00287585-00287849": "incomes uh stems from track tracking", "HE14YCz1pj0-00931-00287850-00288106": "based advertising relying on collection", "HE14YCz1pj0-00932-00288107-00288365": "and monetization of massive amounts of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00933-00288366-00288593": "data in The Internet of Things is of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00934-00288594-00288755": "course a growing source of data being", "HE14YCz1pj0-00935-00288756-00289049": "collected shared and analyzed so in that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00936-00289050-00289229": "context we need to really look at where", "HE14YCz1pj0-00937-00289230-00289391": "we stand and we've already heard quite a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00938-00289392-00289606": "bit about the legal Frameworks that are", "HE14YCz1pj0-00939-00289607-00289780": "in place", "HE14YCz1pj0-00940-00289781-00289997": "um the good news is we've really had a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00941-00289998-00290129": "lot of work done on what are some of the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00942-00290130-00290434": "minimum requirements for Effective data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00943-00290435-00290669": "protection legislation and obviously", "HE14YCz1pj0-00944-00290670-00290921": "convention 108 and 108 plus are are key", "HE14YCz1pj0-00945-00290922-00291197": "examples there our office did a report", "HE14YCz1pj0-00946-00291198-00291484": "on the right to privacy in 2018 that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00947-00291485-00291713": "really pointed to the key elements of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00948-00291714-00291910": "that legislation you know requirements", "HE14YCz1pj0-00949-00291911-00292121": "such as having a legal basis for", "HE14YCz1pj0-00950-00292122-00292397": "processing data the necessity and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00951-00292398-00292606": "proportionality of processing data a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00952-00292607-00292865": "point that pillar made as well having a", "HE14YCz1pj0-00953-00292866-00293003": "well-defined purpose within that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00954-00293004-00293249": "legislation and important points around", "HE14YCz1pj0-00955-00293250-00293482": "the limited scope duration of data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00956-00293483-00293729": "retention and processing data accuracy", "HE14YCz1pj0-00957-00293730-00293915": "data security and adequate security", "HE14YCz1pj0-00958-00293916-00294173": "measures the range of data subjects that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00959-00294174-00294425": "are involved and the obligations of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00960-00294426-00294658": "entities processing data and the", "HE14YCz1pj0-00961-00294659-00294893": "institutional safeguards that exist", "HE14YCz1pj0-00962-00294894-00295079": "fundamentally and this is a point that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00963-00295080-00295247": "others have raised as well it comes back", "HE14YCz1pj0-00964-00295248-00295475": "to the role of independent oversight", "HE14YCz1pj0-00965-00295476-00295751": "bodies for these activities as well and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00966-00295752-00295906": "not only creating those bodies but", "HE14YCz1pj0-00967-00295907-00296080": "resourcing them in a way that they can", "HE14YCz1pj0-00968-00296081-00296267": "do those jobs effectively", "HE14YCz1pj0-00969-00296268-00296495": "so with all that as background where do", "HE14YCz1pj0-00970-00296496-00296608": "we need to head what are the key", "HE14YCz1pj0-00971-00296609-00296789": "challenges in the area of data", "HE14YCz1pj0-00972-00296790-00297017": "protection and privacy first as we've", "HE14YCz1pj0-00973-00297018-00297227": "said we need better laws in a lot of", "HE14YCz1pj0-00974-00297228-00297443": "places to make this work we we have seen", "HE14YCz1pj0-00975-00297444-00297773": "progress there but as Arturo pointed out", "HE14YCz1pj0-00976-00297774-00297947": "um even when we have laws there's", "HE14YCz1pj0-00977-00297948-00298247": "sometimes work to be done and um we need", "HE14YCz1pj0-00978-00298248-00298439": "of course as the Ambassador has said as", "HE14YCz1pj0-00979-00298440-00298697": "well and multi-stakeholder approach to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00980-00298698-00298882": "to making sure that those laws are truly", "HE14YCz1pj0-00981-00298883-00299032": "responsive to the needs of all", "HE14YCz1pj0-00982-00299033-00299279": "communities so engagement by Civil", "HE14YCz1pj0-00983-00299280-00299615": "Society there as well we also wanted to", "HE14YCz1pj0-00984-00299616-00299830": "point out that one of the key flaws in", "HE14YCz1pj0-00985-00299831-00300077": "some of the existing legislation is an", "HE14YCz1pj0-00986-00300078-00300377": "absence of or weak requirements for", "HE14YCz1pj0-00987-00300378-00300556": "handling of data by public authorities", "HE14YCz1pj0-00988-00300557-00300760": "and this is an area where substantial", "HE14YCz1pj0-00989-00300761-00301079": "human rights concerns arise as benga has", "HE14YCz1pj0-00990-00301080-00301177": "said", "HE14YCz1pj0-00991-00301178-00301480": "we really also recognize though that", "HE14YCz1pj0-00992-00301481-00301637": "even if we started from a good", "HE14YCz1pj0-00993-00301638-00301853": "foundation on data protection we're", "HE14YCz1pj0-00994-00301854-00302080": "facing increasing in new threats in this", "HE14YCz1pj0-00995-00302081-00302489": "area as we develop New Uses of AI and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00996-00302490-00302813": "data intensive Technologies increase and", "HE14YCz1pj0-00997-00302814-00303101": "so what we need to think is a more", "HE14YCz1pj0-00998-00303102-00303347": "accelerated and expanded scope for how", "HE14YCz1pj0-00999-00303348-00303497": "we're looking at data protection and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01000-00303498-00303749": "privacy thinking along the lines of data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01001-00303750-00303947": "Justice rather than just data protection", "HE14YCz1pj0-01002-00303948-00304193": "and looking at elements and approaches", "HE14YCz1pj0-01003-00304194-00304456": "that will prevent and mitigate data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01004-00304457-00304804": "related harms more broadly and my", "HE14YCz1pj0-01005-00304805-00304913": "colleagues have given me tons of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01006-00304914-00305177": "examples of this but just a couple along", "HE14YCz1pj0-01007-00305178-00305429": "the lines of anti-discrimination impacts", "HE14YCz1pj0-01008-00305430-00305627": "on marginalized peoples we know that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01009-00305628-00305801": "those are some of the areas where we've", "HE14YCz1pj0-01010-00305802-00306106": "seen huge problems with data legislation", "HE14YCz1pj0-01011-00306107-00306371": "and fraud detection tools being used in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01012-00306372-00306658": "Social benefits systems as an example of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01013-00306659-00306869": "that where it's gone horribly wrong", "HE14YCz1pj0-01014-00306870-00307204": "we're also concerned about automated", "HE14YCz1pj0-01015-00307205-00307403": "decision making and the minimum rights", "HE14YCz1pj0-01016-00307404-00307654": "that people have to to understanding how", "HE14YCz1pj0-01017-00307655-00307799": "their rights are being affected by it", "HE14YCz1pj0-01018-00307800-00308141": "and transparency around its use and and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01019-00308142-00308303": "systems around inferring information", "HE14YCz1pj0-01020-00308304-00308584": "based on existing data and how we could", "HE14YCz1pj0-01021-00308585-00308854": "regulate those areas as well and as I", "HE14YCz1pj0-01022-00308855-00309089": "said oversight bodies are a key element", "HE14YCz1pj0-01023-00309090-00309299": "to making all of that work more", "HE14YCz1pj0-01024-00309300-00309551": "effectively I too wanted to bring up the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01025-00309552-00309743": "issues of cross-border data flows and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01026-00309744-00309937": "localization requirements which I agree", "HE14YCz1pj0-01027-00309938-00310265": "we need to find a way to to square those", "HE14YCz1pj0-01028-00310266-00310439": "issues within the context of Human", "HE14YCz1pj0-01029-00310440-00310708": "Rights we want data flows to go across", "HE14YCz1pj0-01030-00310709-00310906": "borders but we and we know that data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01031-00310907-00311201": "localization has many pitfalls in a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01032-00311202-00311453": "variety of ways one it increases", "HE14YCz1pj0-01033-00311454-00311675": "government power over data and puts", "HE14YCz1pj0-01034-00311676-00311813": "pressure points on companies that are", "HE14YCz1pj0-01035-00311814-00312058": "perhaps not as useful if further", "HE14YCz1pj0-01036-00312059-00312304": "fragmentize fragmentizes the internet", "HE14YCz1pj0-01037-00312305-00312556": "and has tensions with the right to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01038-00312557-00312749": "freedom of expression and can be", "HE14YCz1pj0-01039-00312750-00312995": "economically burdensome so we agree we", "HE14YCz1pj0-01040-00312996-00313163": "need Frameworks that allow for personal", "HE14YCz1pj0-01041-00313164-00313403": "data to be transferred across States but", "HE14YCz1pj0-01042-00313404-00313577": "we would like to see those Frameworks", "HE14YCz1pj0-01043-00313578-00313780": "protected at least by the level required", "HE14YCz1pj0-01044-00313781-00314008": "under international human rights law and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01045-00314009-00314254": "so we of course look to the gdpr which", "HE14YCz1pj0-01046-00314255-00314513": "permits transfers of data with a level", "HE14YCz1pj0-01047-00314514-00314723": "adequate level of protection in another", "HE14YCz1pj0-01048-00314724-00315130": "state and also we're going to flag as as", "HE14YCz1pj0-01049-00315131-00315334": "the Ambassador has the gloss Global", "HE14YCz1pj0-01050-00315335-00315599": "cross-border privacy rules forum", "HE14YCz1pj0-01051-00315600-00315803": "one final word would be on the law", "HE14YCz1pj0-01052-00315804-00316006": "enforcement side where uh law", "HE14YCz1pj0-01053-00316007-00316217": "enforcement access to user data is a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01054-00316218-00316493": "particular area of Human Rights risk and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01055-00316494-00316637": "so we want to make sure that minimum", "HE14YCz1pj0-01056-00316638-00316793": "safeguards are in place for those", "HE14YCz1pj0-01057-00316794-00317032": "systems for a transfer of data including", "HE14YCz1pj0-01058-00317033-00317273": "requirements around dual criminality for", "HE14YCz1pj0-01059-00317274-00317513": "oversight again for less invasive", "HE14YCz1pj0-01060-00317514-00317693": "measures and limiting these these", "HE14YCz1pj0-01061-00317694-00317884": "transfers to particularly grave crimes", "HE14YCz1pj0-01062-00317885-00318101": "and to make sure that we have the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01063-00318102-00318256": "relevant public authorities in place", "HE14YCz1pj0-01064-00318257-00318497": "where direct access to data held by", "HE14YCz1pj0-01065-00318498-00318713": "companies is sought as well thanks very", "HE14YCz1pj0-01066-00318714-00318960": "much", "HE14YCz1pj0-01067-00318961-00319349": "thank you Sheena", "HE14YCz1pj0-01068-00319350-00319649": "yeah I'm stumped", "HE14YCz1pj0-01069-00319650-00319871": "it's a bit hard to follow after", "HE14YCz1pj0-01070-00319872-00320063": "everything that everyone has said so I", "HE14YCz1pj0-01071-00320064-00320345": "will say what", "HE14YCz1pj0-01072-00320346-00320434": "um", "HE14YCz1pj0-01073-00320435-00320680": "what what I want to say but maybe it'll", "HE14YCz1pj0-01074-00320681-00320956": "be similar but said differently", "HE14YCz1pj0-01075-00320957-00321167": "I'm I think it's important to locate", "HE14YCz1pj0-01076-00321168-00321280": "myself", "HE14YCz1pj0-01077-00321281-00321563": "as a member of Civil Society I work at", "HE14YCz1pj0-01078-00321564-00321947": "the intersection of human rights in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01079-00321948-00322223": "particular women's rights lgbtiq rights", "HE14YCz1pj0-01080-00322224-00322541": "and technology and where I work is also", "HE14YCz1pj0-01081-00322542-00322721": "situated around using a feminist", "HE14YCz1pj0-01082-00322722-00322889": "framework to try and understand what's", "HE14YCz1pj0-01083-00322890-00322997": "going on", "HE14YCz1pj0-01084-00322998-00323260": "so it's understandable for people like", "HE14YCz1pj0-01085-00323261-00323482": "me and people and the communities that I", "HE14YCz1pj0-01086-00323483-00323621": "work with who come to a space like this", "HE14YCz1pj0-01087-00323622-00323789": "it's a bit overwhelming because there's", "HE14YCz1pj0-01088-00323790-00324167": "all these references to documents that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01089-00324168-00324251": "um", "HE14YCz1pj0-01090-00324252-00324467": "we we don't know about right and so", "HE14YCz1pj0-01091-00324468-00324701": "there's something about data governance", "HE14YCz1pj0-01092-00324702-00324827": "and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01093-00324828-00324995": "um protecting privacy that's a bit", "HE14YCz1pj0-01094-00324996-00325199": "obscure there's something about the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01095-00325200-00325523": "space that is also a bit siled and I", "HE14YCz1pj0-01096-00325524-00325793": "really like what you said about how we", "HE14YCz1pj0-01097-00325794-00325997": "cannot look at the work of data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01098-00325998-00326260": "governance and protecting privacy in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01099-00326261-00326471": "isolation as its own little space that's", "HE14YCz1pj0-01100-00326472-00326687": "located around technology because when", "HE14YCz1pj0-01101-00326688-00326903": "we do ask for data protection laws to be", "HE14YCz1pj0-01102-00326904-00327145": "instituted in countries and states and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01103-00327146-00327406": "contexts where they're already existing", "HE14YCz1pj0-01104-00327407-00327623": "laws that are not being respected it", "HE14YCz1pj0-01105-00327624-00327797": "creates an issue of what benga said", "HE14YCz1pj0-01106-00327798-00327917": "Trust", "HE14YCz1pj0-01107-00327918-00328132": "So when you say that you want to put in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01108-00328133-00328367": "place better laws when the already", "HE14YCz1pj0-01109-00328368-00328679": "existing laws are not being respected", "HE14YCz1pj0-01110-00328680-00328763": "um", "HE14YCz1pj0-01111-00328764-00329080": "we the Civil Society are scared we just", "HE14YCz1pj0-01112-00329081-00329195": "think that it's going to be another law", "HE14YCz1pj0-01113-00329196-00329404": "that's going to come and seek us out", "HE14YCz1pj0-01114-00329405-00329663": "especially if you are a decriminalized", "HE14YCz1pj0-01115-00329664-00330004": "identity if you um work in a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01116-00330005-00330149": "criminalized", "HE14YCz1pj0-01117-00330150-00330460": "um uh labor if your labor is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01118-00330461-00330660": "criminalized for example", "HE14YCz1pj0-01119-00330661-00330910": "when the government comes and says and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01120-00330911-00331169": "often by force there's the option of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01121-00331170-00331379": "choice never exists in a lot of these", "HE14YCz1pj0-01122-00331380-00331777": "kinds of spaces and often you find that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01123-00331778-00332045": "laws that are put in place", "HE14YCz1pj0-01124-00332046-00332260": "become quickly insufficient especially", "HE14YCz1pj0-01125-00332261-00332579": "if the focus is more around", "HE14YCz1pj0-01126-00332580-00332884": "the data for example and not the people", "HE14YCz1pj0-01127-00332885-00333173": "and you find that how what data is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01128-00333174-00333371": "shifts very quickly", "HE14YCz1pj0-01129-00333372-00333575": "what data can look like looks very", "HE14YCz1pj0-01130-00333576-00333880": "different like for instance we have the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01131-00333881-00334073": "Kenya data protection act that was put", "HE14YCz1pj0-01132-00334074-00334271": "in place in 2019", "HE14YCz1pj0-01133-00334272-00334469": "of course after a pandemic that looks", "HE14YCz1pj0-01134-00334470-00334667": "very different so now we have to go back", "HE14YCz1pj0-01135-00334668-00334901": "and see well is it sufficient given that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01136-00334902-00335213": "we had a pandemic in the government used", "HE14YCz1pj0-01137-00335214-00335525": "a lot of force to collect information", "HE14YCz1pj0-01138-00335526-00335897": "out of its citizenship without the right", "HE14YCz1pj0-01139-00335898-00336084": "protections without any kind of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01140-00336085-00336413": "consultation without any kind of right", "HE14YCz1pj0-01141-00336414-00336689": "to say no which infringes on other", "HE14YCz1pj0-01142-00336690-00337008": "fundamental human rights of the people", "HE14YCz1pj0-01143-00337009-00337234": "I think another important thing to speak", "HE14YCz1pj0-01144-00337235-00337403": "speak about is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01145-00337404-00337571": "um and I think very many other people", "HE14YCz1pj0-01146-00337572-00337780": "have spoken about protecting privacy", "HE14YCz1pj0-01147-00337781-00338039": "which is especially important for", "HE14YCz1pj0-01148-00338040-00338243": "communities that find Safe Haven and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01149-00338244-00338563": "digital platforms online on social media", "HE14YCz1pj0-01150-00338564-00338832": "when we put in place", "HE14YCz1pj0-01151-00338833-00339130": "laws that flout the right to privacy", "HE14YCz1pj0-01152-00339131-00339287": "then we find that these species are no", "HE14YCz1pj0-01153-00339288-00339491": "longer safe and there aren't any", "HE14YCz1pj0-01154-00339492-00339660": "additional spaces for people to gather", "HE14YCz1pj0-01155-00339661-00340030": "and these criminalized identities are", "HE14YCz1pj0-01156-00340031-00340223": "further criminalized both online and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01157-00340224-00340475": "offline and the same kinds of violence", "HE14YCz1pj0-01158-00340476-00340739": "that we experience offline for having", "HE14YCz1pj0-01159-00340740-00340979": "particular bodies across class race", "HE14YCz1pj0-01160-00340980-00341201": "sexuality gender the same kind of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01161-00341202-00341458": "violence finds itself replicated in the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01162-00341459-00341675": "online space", "HE14YCz1pj0-01163-00341676-00341980": "as well and in previous conversations", "HE14YCz1pj0-01164-00341981-00342167": "that I've had with other members of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01165-00342168-00342365": "Civil Society", "HE14YCz1pj0-01166-00342366-00342604": "um the trust issue is quite big because", "HE14YCz1pj0-01167-00342605-00342941": "you find that a lot of people don't", "HE14YCz1pj0-01168-00342942-00343295": "understand and some of the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01169-00343296-00343589": "um data protection language is vague by", "HE14YCz1pj0-01170-00343590-00343913": "Design so who is it protecting is it", "HE14YCz1pj0-01171-00343914-00344177": "protecting this state because chances", "HE14YCz1pj0-01172-00344178-00344434": "are if there's a data protection act of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01173-00344435-00344693": "sorts and then my data is leaked say", "HE14YCz1pj0-01174-00344694-00344945": "through an act of non-consensual", "HE14YCz1pj0-01175-00344946-00345247": "distribution of intimate images", "HE14YCz1pj0-01176-00345248-00345671": "my right to recourse is less than let's", "HE14YCz1pj0-01177-00345672-00345917": "say the ruling class the political class", "HE14YCz1pj0-01178-00345918-00346193": "who can get a blogger arrested for", "HE14YCz1pj0-01179-00346194-00346445": "calling out something and using the same", "HE14YCz1pj0-01180-00346446-00346715": "laws that are supposed to protect a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01181-00346716-00346913": "young woman who has experienced violence", "HE14YCz1pj0-01182-00346914-00347267": "online are then used to silence and to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01183-00347268-00347501": "subjugate citizenships", "HE14YCz1pj0-01184-00347502-00347717": "uh yeah", "HE14YCz1pj0-01185-00347718-00348065": "um I think another thing worth saying", "HE14YCz1pj0-01186-00348066-00348173": "um", "HE14YCz1pj0-01187-00348174-00348406": "here", "HE14YCz1pj0-01188-00348407-00348641": "is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01189-00348642-00349054": "sorry", "HE14YCz1pj0-01190-00349055-00349169": "um", "HE14YCz1pj0-01191-00349170-00349589": "yeah and so I think I would close yeah", "HE14YCz1pj0-01192-00349590-00349882": "again I would close with", "HE14YCz1pj0-01193-00349883-00350008": "um", "HE14YCz1pj0-01194-00350009-00350201": "language that a lot of feminists and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01195-00350202-00350375": "women's rights movements use which is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01196-00350376-00350669": "the language of intersectionality", "HE14YCz1pj0-01197-00350670-00350819": "um in understanding that there isn't a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01198-00350820-00350963": "single issue", "HE14YCz1pj0-01199-00350964-00351293": "issue and when we do come here and we", "HE14YCz1pj0-01200-00351294-00351508": "say that it is important to save you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01201-00351509-00351677": "know the internet is an important space", "HE14YCz1pj0-01202-00351678-00352030": "and that we need to strengthen uh legal", "HE14YCz1pj0-01203-00352031-00352282": "or legislative Frameworks that make sure", "HE14YCz1pj0-01204-00352283-00352523": "that the internet is free", "HE14YCz1pj0-01205-00352524-00352834": "these laws still exist within contexts", "HE14YCz1pj0-01206-00352835-00353080": "where so many other rights and freedoms", "HE14YCz1pj0-01207-00353081-00353327": "are being infringed upon and therefore", "HE14YCz1pj0-01208-00353328-00353506": "when you say that I should be allowed to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01209-00353507-00353854": "be who I am online in the context of uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-01210-00353855-00354143": "of a political reality where I am not", "HE14YCz1pj0-01211-00354144-00354371": "allowed to be who I am offline it", "HE14YCz1pj0-01212-00354372-00354569": "creates a contradiction and I think", "HE14YCz1pj0-01213-00354570-00354832": "there needs to be I think it called it", "HE14YCz1pj0-01214-00354833-00355127": "interlopability yeah there needs to be", "HE14YCz1pj0-01215-00355128-00355493": "an interoperability a more intentional", "HE14YCz1pj0-01216-00355494-00355745": "um seeking out of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01217-00355746-00356045": "um uh different actors across the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01218-00356046-00356273": "various human rights spaces and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01219-00356274-00356465": "Frameworks to see", "HE14YCz1pj0-01220-00356466-00356758": "um how can we lend more solidarity how", "HE14YCz1pj0-01221-00356759-00357023": "can we share more resources towards", "HE14YCz1pj0-01222-00357024-00357251": "ensuring that we're not trying to see", "HE14YCz1pj0-01223-00357252-00357545": "this as a single issue uh space or a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01224-00357546-00357810": "situation and how how do we strengthen", "HE14YCz1pj0-01225-00357811-00358180": "all human rights for all people in all", "HE14YCz1pj0-01226-00358181-00358582": "spaces both online and offline", "HE14YCz1pj0-01227-00358583-00358949": "oh", "HE14YCz1pj0-01228-00358950-00359213": "um I would like to start by saying thank", "HE14YCz1pj0-01229-00359214-00359447": "you so much to the igf 2022 for for the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01230-00359448-00359560": "organization of course for the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01231-00359561-00359753": "invitation as well in the same breath I", "HE14YCz1pj0-01232-00359754-00359951": "have to say that in my opinion this is a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01233-00359952-00360184": "truly awful awful panel", "HE14YCz1pj0-01234-00360185-00360371": "um simply because we have plenty of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01235-00360372-00360532": "experts and plenty of important topics", "HE14YCz1pj0-01236-00360533-00360730": "in only 90 minutes so I think deserves", "HE14YCz1pj0-01237-00360731-00360965": "its own conference in the future", "HE14YCz1pj0-01238-00360966-00361063": "um", "HE14YCz1pj0-01239-00361064-00361456": "if we if I think we we can start with", "HE14YCz1pj0-01240-00361457-00361606": "what was mentioned before with with the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01241-00361607-00361793": "area of trust", "HE14YCz1pj0-01242-00361794-00361949": "um I am a German I've been living in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01243-00361950-00362104": "Estonia for the last seven years so I've", "HE14YCz1pj0-01244-00362105-00362375": "got sort of different experiences in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01245-00362376-00362608": "that that area", "HE14YCz1pj0-01246-00362609-00362758": "um if we're being honest", "HE14YCz1pj0-01247-00362759-00362927": "probably also in this room and also", "HE14YCz1pj0-01248-00362928-00363101": "those watching via Zoom", "HE14YCz1pj0-01249-00363102-00363293": "um if we're being honest most", "HE14YCz1pj0-01250-00363294-00363575": "governments and most companies today do", "HE14YCz1pj0-01251-00363576-00363797": "not deserve our trust when it comes to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01252-00363798-00364073": "the way that our data is being handled", "HE14YCz1pj0-01253-00364074-00364247": "um I mean we can", "HE14YCz1pj0-01254-00364248-00364517": "throw manure at the private sector all", "HE14YCz1pj0-01255-00364518-00364732": "day long we can do the same for the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01256-00364733-00364954": "public sector as well when I hear that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01257-00364955-00365153": "there are still countries not just in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01258-00365154-00365369": "Africa also in Europe just everywhere", "HE14YCz1pj0-01259-00365370-00365573": "around the world", "HE14YCz1pj0-01260-00365574-00365789": "um that duplicate citizens data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01261-00365790-00366047": "biometric data no less that is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01262-00366048-00366232": "absolutely unacceptable and this sort of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01263-00366233-00366449": "brings me to to the two points that I", "HE14YCz1pj0-01264-00366450-00366563": "want to come to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01265-00366564-00366778": "which were also mentioned by by Carol", "HE14YCz1pj0-01266-00366779-00366941": "with the introduction", "HE14YCz1pj0-01267-00366942-00367247": "um what is the what is the on paper", "HE14YCz1pj0-01268-00367248-00367463": "situation and what is the the real life", "HE14YCz1pj0-01269-00367464-00367613": "situation", "HE14YCz1pj0-01270-00367614-00367769": "um well the first thing that we have to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01271-00367770-00367984": "do is fix the on paper situation do you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01272-00367985-00368201": "have something like the gdpr some kind", "HE14YCz1pj0-01273-00368202-00368375": "of data protection regulation", "HE14YCz1pj0-01274-00368376-00368573": "um the answer for many countries is uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-01275-00368574-00368801": "yes not all but we're getting there", "HE14YCz1pj0-01276-00368802-00368897": "um", "HE14YCz1pj0-01277-00368898-00369106": "but I also heard the previous panelists", "HE14YCz1pj0-01278-00369107-00369341": "discuss already about the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01279-00369342-00369593": "um the desirability perhaps of a of a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01280-00369594-00369803": "global framework of recommendations for", "HE14YCz1pj0-01281-00369804-00370043": "privacy I want to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01282-00370044-00370193": "um I don't want to shut the lid on that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01283-00370194-00370439": "but I I definitely want to put a damper", "HE14YCz1pj0-01284-00370440-00370589": "on this because", "HE14YCz1pj0-01285-00370590-00370793": "um you know looking at the EU where we", "HE14YCz1pj0-01286-00370794-00371015": "do have a gdpr with 27 member states", "HE14YCz1pj0-01287-00371016-00371206": "that have signed up to it", "HE14YCz1pj0-01288-00371207-00371351": "um I can tell you that we're not all", "HE14YCz1pj0-01289-00371352-00371627": "following the gdpr in the same way and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01290-00371628-00371927": "that is not because one country is is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01291-00371928-00372137": "super smart and one country is really", "HE14YCz1pj0-01292-00372138-00372382": "rude it's it's just because due to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01293-00372383-00372539": "different cultures we have very", "HE14YCz1pj0-01294-00372540-00372695": "different interpretations of the same", "HE14YCz1pj0-01295-00372696-00372904": "legislation so even if we have a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01296-00372905-00373084": "globally agreed upon framework which", "HE14YCz1pj0-01297-00373085-00373289": "will not happen we will not come to an", "HE14YCz1pj0-01298-00373290-00373463": "agreement there but even if we did we", "HE14YCz1pj0-01299-00373464-00373637": "would not execute that framework in the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01300-00373638-00373751": "same way", "HE14YCz1pj0-01301-00373752-00374045": "um very very simple Baseline example in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01302-00374046-00374327": "Estonia we've got multi-story car parks", "HE14YCz1pj0-01303-00374328-00374513": "with the tiny barriers in front and they", "HE14YCz1pj0-01304-00374514-00374687": "can read your license plate stone is not", "HE14YCz1pj0-01305-00374688-00374801": "the only country in the world that does", "HE14YCz1pj0-01306-00374802-00375028": "that perfectly fine in Germany for the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01307-00375029-00375215": "longest time that was illegal because of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01308-00375216-00375515": "gdpr concerns and so estonians were", "HE14YCz1pj0-01309-00375516-00375641": "saying you know", "HE14YCz1pj0-01310-00375642-00375856": "we've got the gdpr so why can we make", "HE14YCz1pj0-01311-00375857-00376025": "these barriers work with the license", "HE14YCz1pj0-01312-00376026-00376247": "plate recognition and why can't you and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01313-00376248-00376451": "so and this is the the tiniest example", "HE14YCz1pj0-01314-00376452-00376643": "and we can scale that up to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01315-00376644-00376930": "biometrical storage or fingerprints or", "HE14YCz1pj0-01316-00376931-00377297": "Healthcare data exchange across uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-01317-00377298-00377549": "borders so so there's a there's a myriad", "HE14YCz1pj0-01318-00377550-00377663": "of topics", "HE14YCz1pj0-01319-00377664-00377830": "um that we number one we will not come", "HE14YCz1pj0-01320-00377831-00378041": "to an agreement to and even if we do we", "HE14YCz1pj0-01321-00378042-00378293": "want to execute them in the same way and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01322-00378294-00378503": "perhaps I would want to finish on on one", "HE14YCz1pj0-01323-00378504-00378760": "point uh about data privacy and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01324-00378761-00379006": "governance from from Estonia and number", "HE14YCz1pj0-01325-00379007-00379282": "one on paper number two in practice", "HE14YCz1pj0-01326-00379283-00379469": "um in Estonia we have something called", "HE14YCz1pj0-01327-00379470-00379708": "The Once only policy a very simple rule", "HE14YCz1pj0-01328-00379709-00379858": "says that across all the different", "HE14YCz1pj0-01329-00379859-00380087": "government agencies only one government", "HE14YCz1pj0-01330-00380088-00380273": "Authority can store a particular point", "HE14YCz1pj0-01331-00380274-00380441": "of data so", "HE14YCz1pj0-01332-00380442-00380699": "um if the population registry has stored", "HE14YCz1pj0-01333-00380700-00380819": "your data because that's you know", "HE14YCz1pj0-01334-00380820-00380951": "they're the ones responsible for that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01335-00380952-00381184": "the other agencies cannot ask you for", "HE14YCz1pj0-01336-00381185-00381328": "the same data point they have to ask", "HE14YCz1pj0-01337-00381329-00381593": "from that Authority boom done and the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01338-00381594-00381910": "second point is not just about privacy", "HE14YCz1pj0-01339-00381911-00382049": "sort of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01340-00382050-00382434": "um enforcement but also about the how", "HE14YCz1pj0-01341-00382435-00382684": "realizable is it per se how from from", "HE14YCz1pj0-01342-00382685-00382901": "the citizens point of view in Estonia as", "HE14YCz1pj0-01343-00382902-00383171": "an example there is a uh there's a sort", "HE14YCz1pj0-01344-00383172-00383369": "of data tracker where I can see every", "HE14YCz1pj0-01345-00383370-00383549": "single time uh where the government", "HE14YCz1pj0-01346-00383550-00383897": "looked at my data when and why and based", "HE14YCz1pj0-01347-00383898-00384082": "on that I can then head to the data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01348-00384083-00384232": "protection inspector so it's very well", "HE14YCz1pj0-01349-00384233-00384551": "that we have a myriad of of dpas around", "HE14YCz1pj0-01350-00384552-00384730": "the world that have some kind of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01351-00384731-00384923": "enforcement capability and but the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01352-00384924-00385132": "question is are citizens actually aware", "HE14YCz1pj0-01353-00385133-00385397": "of their rights being uh you know", "HE14YCz1pj0-01354-00385398-00385565": "infringed upon and so I think this is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01355-00385566-00385673": "something that we also have to deal with", "HE14YCz1pj0-01356-00385674-00385949": "thanks so much", "HE14YCz1pj0-01357-00385950-00386182": "thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01358-00386183-00386410": "um I told you we had an exciting panel", "HE14YCz1pj0-01359-00386411-00386734": "and I think that they've given you a lot", "HE14YCz1pj0-01360-00386735-00386897": "of food for thought and I'm sure we have", "HE14YCz1pj0-01361-00386898-00387178": "some questions uh piece anything online", "HE14YCz1pj0-01362-00387179-00387634": "for us today", "HE14YCz1pj0-01363-00387635-00388030": "peace", "HE14YCz1pj0-01364-00388031-00388360": "okay whilst piece is looking we have a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01365-00388361-00388697": "few well we have quite a lot here so", "HE14YCz1pj0-01366-00388698-00388882": "we're gonna start with the gentleman at", "HE14YCz1pj0-01367-00388883-00389069": "the back and we're going to quickly make", "HE14YCz1pj0-01368-00389070-00389267": "our way over so we're going to ask you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01369-00389268-00389375": "please", "HE14YCz1pj0-01370-00389376-00389693": "don't give us multiple questions in one", "HE14YCz1pj0-01371-00389694-00390010": "so just give us one question not with a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01372-00390011-00390239": "hundred parts so thank you gentlemen at", "HE14YCz1pj0-01373-00390240-00390545": "the back", "HE14YCz1pj0-01374-00390546-00390784": "identify yourself please", "HE14YCz1pj0-01375-00390785-00390958": "if you wish", "HE14YCz1pj0-01376-00390959-00391151": "okay", "HE14YCz1pj0-01377-00391152-00391451": "thank you uh very much I appreciate all", "HE14YCz1pj0-01378-00391452-00391804": "the presenters my name is from Ethiopia", "HE14YCz1pj0-01379-00391805-00392008": "I'm working with the ministry of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01380-00392009-00392267": "innovation technology so I have no", "HE14YCz1pj0-01381-00392268-00392554": "question but I have an opinion it is my", "HE14YCz1pj0-01382-00392555-00392777": "interest towards open here so according", "HE14YCz1pj0-01383-00392778-00393125": "to my opinion we need Ethiopians it's a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01384-00393126-00393347": "capacity building of a knowledge sharing", "HE14YCz1pj0-01385-00393348-00393604": "program scholarship program regarding", "HE14YCz1pj0-01386-00393605-00393784": "through digitalization and good", "HE14YCz1pj0-01387-00393785-00394015": "governance and we need collaboration", "HE14YCz1pj0-01388-00394016-00394217": "cooperation and coordination in the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01389-00394218-00394408": "multi-stakeholder capabilities in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01390-00394409-00394708": "Ethiopia so I will appreciate if you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01391-00394709-00395153": "have any kind of moo regarding your", "HE14YCz1pj0-01392-00395154-00395410": "interest so we are open to our office", "HE14YCz1pj0-01393-00395411-00395734": "and I will you're welcome so uh young", "HE14YCz1pj0-01394-00395735-00396047": "researchers must be you know advocated", "HE14YCz1pj0-01395-00396048-00396280": "in different sector of research", "HE14YCz1pj0-01396-00396281-00396617": "Technology Innovation so young", "HE14YCz1pj0-01397-00396618-00396904": "youngsters and children's must be you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01398-00396905-00397199": "know Advocate or encourage uh regarding", "HE14YCz1pj0-01399-00397200-00397337": "it to Innovation and technology in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01400-00397338-00397541": "Ethiopia so if you have interest we", "HE14YCz1pj0-01401-00397542-00397745": "collaborate in particular in terms of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01402-00397746-00397930": "Technology Innovation and project and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01403-00397931-00398195": "other other interests thank you very", "HE14YCz1pj0-01404-00398196-00398417": "much thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01405-00398418-00398704": "okay so at the front here and then we've", "HE14YCz1pj0-01406-00398705-00398873": "got to move to the back go ahead sir", "HE14YCz1pj0-01407-00398874-00399082": "okay thank you thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01408-00399083-00399467": "uh I'm from Senegal my name is Yaga from", "HE14YCz1pj0-01409-00399468-00399706": "Civil Society organization", "HE14YCz1pj0-01410-00399707-00400030": "I I like to make a comment on data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01411-00400031-00400325": "protection in Africa please give me a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01412-00400326-00400619": "couple of minutes one minute one minute", "HE14YCz1pj0-01413-00400620-00400960": "please data protection and privacy", "HE14YCz1pj0-01414-00400961-00401177": "reality", "HE14YCz1pj0-01415-00401178-00401363": "or on paper", "HE14YCz1pj0-01416-00401364-00401591": "in Africa it's even", "HE14YCz1pj0-01417-00401592-00401830": "it's not even on paper", "HE14YCz1pj0-01418-00401831-00402227": "we have 55 country in Africa only 25", "HE14YCz1pj0-01419-00402228-00402497": "have a data protection act", "HE14YCz1pj0-01420-00402498-00402682": "the first African countries that have", "HE14YCz1pj0-01421-00402683-00402928": "enacted a data protection is the island", "HE14YCz1pj0-01422-00402929-00403258": "of capoe verde in 2001. the second one", "HE14YCz1pj0-01423-00403259-00403625": "Burkina Faso in 2004 and next from 2008", "HE14YCz1pj0-01424-00403626-00403852": "was a country like Senegal have anything", "HE14YCz1pj0-01425-00403853-00404134": "they allow on data protection make note", "HE14YCz1pj0-01426-00404135-00404356": "since 2001", "HE14YCz1pj0-01427-00404357-00404717": "the island of Cabo Vera don't have does", "HE14YCz1pj0-01428-00404718-00405023": "not have a data protection authority", "HE14YCz1pj0-01429-00405024-00405275": "this to let you know that out of this", "HE14YCz1pj0-01430-00405276-00405580": "2520 only 14 have a data protection", "HE14YCz1pj0-01431-00405581-00405982": "authority and most of the time just weak", "HE14YCz1pj0-01432-00405983-00406337": "data protection authority an example in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01433-00406338-00406613": "15 years any of these data protection", "HE14YCz1pj0-01434-00406614-00406930": "Auto has never taken any decision", "HE14YCz1pj0-01435-00406931-00407128": "on Tech Giant", "HE14YCz1pj0-01436-00407129-00407375": "because they don't have the capacity", "HE14YCz1pj0-01437-00407376-00407710": "on top of that politically is a scare", "HE14YCz1pj0-01438-00407711-00407902": "because that's American interest Twitter", "HE14YCz1pj0-01439-00407903-00408065": "and Facebook", "HE14YCz1pj0-01440-00408066-00408401": "so that means that we have to learn from", "HE14YCz1pj0-01441-00408402-00408628": "what Europe is doing", "HE14YCz1pj0-01442-00408629-00408923": "looking as one voice because our human", "HE14YCz1pj0-01443-00408924-00409145": "and Tiny country", "HE14YCz1pj0-01444-00409146-00409445": "have difficulty dealing with Tech Giant", "HE14YCz1pj0-01445-00409446-00409841": "small country like Senegal Gambia Benny", "HE14YCz1pj0-01446-00409842-00410087": "in Rwanda what can they do against this", "HE14YCz1pj0-01447-00410088-00410345": "thing nothing else so the issue has to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01448-00410346-00410495": "be titled on the African Union", "HE14YCz1pj0-01449-00410496-00410782": "commission and there too we have some", "HE14YCz1pj0-01450-00410783-00411137": "issue first", "HE14YCz1pj0-01451-00411138-00411472": "digital right you see are not listed on", "HE14YCz1pj0-01452-00411473-00411676": "the agenda of the African Commission on", "HE14YCz1pj0-01453-00411677-00411982": "human and people right nothing on it we", "HE14YCz1pj0-01454-00411983-00412180": "don't have a resolution we don't have a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01455-00412181-00412409": "working group nothing on digital right", "HE14YCz1pj0-01456-00412410-00412643": "on the African Commission on human and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01457-00412643-00412751": "people right", "HE14YCz1pj0-01458-00412752-00413105": "so we need more voices to advocate", "HE14YCz1pj0-01459-00413106-00413320": "so African commission can at least", "HE14YCz1pj0-01460-00413321-00413489": "create a working group on data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01461-00413489-00413809": "protection and privacy", "HE14YCz1pj0-01462-00413810-00414028": "convention on data protection and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01463-00414029-00414370": "privacy elaborated in 2014", "HE14YCz1pj0-01464-00414371-00414563": "so far", "HE14YCz1pj0-01465-00414564-00414893": "sign it by 14 countries ratified but by", "HE14YCz1pj0-01466-00414893-00415066": "eight countries and we need 15 to have", "HE14YCz1pj0-01467-00415067-00415355": "it enforce it so there's a need for", "HE14YCz1pj0-01468-00415356-00415601": "advocacy in each country to push for", "HE14YCz1pj0-01469-00415602-00415882": "government to ratify to sign first and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01470-00415883-00416203": "ratify the data is the Malibu convention", "HE14YCz1pj0-01471-00416204-00416513": "that means we need to bring more voices", "HE14YCz1pj0-01472-00416514-00416801": "at the African Union Commission for", "HE14YCz1pj0-01473-00416802-00417059": "human and people right and there we have", "HE14YCz1pj0-01474-00417060-00417203": "another difficulty we have few", "HE14YCz1pj0-01475-00417204-00417437": "organizations that work on digital", "HE14YCz1pj0-01476-00417438-00417653": "rights that have observable status as", "HE14YCz1pj0-01477-00417654-00417995": "the African commission so they we agree", "HE14YCz1pj0-01478-00417996-00418187": "with you and you the panelists", "HE14YCz1pj0-01479-00418188-00418307": "especially", "HE14YCz1pj0-01480-00418308-00418666": "um benga did go into some details with", "HE14YCz1pj0-01481-00418667-00418889": "regards to that and we do need to sit", "HE14YCz1pj0-01482-00418889-00419189": "down and come up with a solution to that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01483-00419189-00419368": "so thank you very much for your input", "HE14YCz1pj0-01484-00419369-00419603": "and we will include it in our report", "HE14YCz1pj0-01485-00419604-00420101": "thank you gentlemen at the back", "HE14YCz1pj0-01486-00420102-00420377": "yeah thank you chair for the floor I", "HE14YCz1pj0-01487-00420378-00421881": "will processing foreign", "HE14YCz1pj0-01488-00421882-00425195": "[Music]", "HE14YCz1pj0-01489-00425196-00427239": "foreign", "HE14YCz1pj0-01490-00427241-00428968": "[Music]", "HE14YCz1pj0-01491-00428969-00430125": "foreign", "HE14YCz1pj0-01492-00430126-00431987": "[Music]", "HE14YCz1pj0-01493-00431988-00432641": "[Music]", "HE14YCz1pj0-01494-00432642-00432899": "okay thank you just before we go to the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01495-00432900-00433181": "next question I would like to ask the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01496-00433182-00433564": "panel if they have any comments on the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01497-00433565-00433714": "um interventions so far from the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01498-00433715-00435199": "audience thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01499-00435200-00435491": "now yeah I just wanted to thank the the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01500-00435492-00435731": "the comments on uh the African", "HE14YCz1pj0-01501-00435732-00435857": "perspective", "HE14YCz1pj0-01502-00435858-00436037": "um I do we didn't talk as much about the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01503-00436038-00436222": "regional level obviously with gdpr and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01504-00436223-00436403": "the European initiative it's it's very", "HE14YCz1pj0-01505-00436404-00436643": "much on the plate but um the role of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01506-00436643-00436799": "regional organizations in this is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01507-00436800-00436913": "something that I think is really", "HE14YCz1pj0-01508-00436914-00437116": "interesting to pursue uh further as well", "HE14YCz1pj0-01509-00437117-00437272": "thanks", "HE14YCz1pj0-01510-00437273-00437431": "foreign", "HE14YCz1pj0-01511-00437432-00437681": "thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01512-00437682-00437939": "um I just have a supporting comment to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01513-00437939-00438395": "Jagger's um comments in terms of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01514-00438396-00438575": "the laws that we have and the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01515-00438576-00438772": "regulations and how difficult it is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01516-00438773-00439114": "really to implement it against the big", "HE14YCz1pj0-01517-00439115-00439289": "Tech Giants I mean", "HE14YCz1pj0-01518-00439289-00439564": "there is no real physical address where", "HE14YCz1pj0-01519-00439565-00439816": "we can deliver and notice in South", "HE14YCz1pj0-01520-00439817-00440105": "Africa for for meta for example we have", "HE14YCz1pj0-01521-00440106-00440272": "to travel all around the world chasing", "HE14YCz1pj0-01522-00440273-00440531": "them down just to get comment or", "HE14YCz1pj0-01523-00440532-00440777": "whatever it would be the same for", "HE14YCz1pj0-01524-00440778-00441089": "Twitter Tick Tock and it's it's it's a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01525-00441089-00441275": "real problem and it's something that we", "HE14YCz1pj0-01526-00441276-00441575": "really need to look at thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01527-00441576-00441899": "and he comments from Arturo or pillar", "HE14YCz1pj0-01528-00441900-00442499": "online", "HE14YCz1pj0-01529-00442500-00442768": "yes thank you I found the comments very", "HE14YCz1pj0-01530-00442769-00442966": "interesting but I would like to react to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01531-00442967-00443177": "the last intervention from the floor", "HE14YCz1pj0-01532-00443178-00443543": "because uh really actually I did speak", "HE14YCz1pj0-01533-00443543-00443668": "about the question of the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01534-00443669-00443872": "multi-dimensionality of data and that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01535-00443873-00444263": "data and economic and economic resource", "HE14YCz1pj0-01536-00444264-00444460": "and is really a factor for development", "HE14YCz1pj0-01537-00444462-00444929": "so that's why we are really focusing on", "HE14YCz1pj0-01538-00444930-00445247": "the on the report and on our analysis in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01539-00445247-00445445": "the multi-dimensionality of data we have", "HE14YCz1pj0-01540-00445446-00445679": "to look at data as an economic resource", "HE14YCz1pj0-01541-00445680-00445907": "and also the non-economic dimension of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01542-00445908-00446110": "data that we have discussed here in this", "HE14YCz1pj0-01543-00446112-00446309": "also the human rights and that's why", "HE14YCz1pj0-01544-00446310-00446537": "there is a need to have a holistic view", "HE14YCz1pj0-01545-00446538-00446813": "in relation addition to data balance", "HE14YCz1pj0-01546-00446814-00446999": "because data are more than an economic", "HE14YCz1pj0-01547-00447000-00447155": "resource and more than a human rights", "HE14YCz1pj0-01548-00447156-00447389": "they are really involving many", "HE14YCz1pj0-01549-00447389-00447509": "dimensions", "HE14YCz1pj0-01550-00447510-00447707": "thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01551-00447708-00447905": "okay we're going to move to the middle", "HE14YCz1pj0-01552-00447906-00448079": "panel then here then we're going to come", "HE14YCz1pj0-01553-00448080-00448313": "back remember please there are lots of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01554-00448314-00448553": "hands lots of questions anything online", "HE14YCz1pj0-01555-00448554-00448883": "for us as yet um okay we're gonna take", "HE14YCz1pj0-01556-00448884-00449122": "one online and then we go to middle and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01557-00449123-00449309": "then decide and then back here so please", "HE14YCz1pj0-01558-00449310-00449585": "keep it short exciting topics thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01559-00449585-00449789": "very much okay thank you you can we have", "HE14YCz1pj0-01560-00449789-00450066": "one online question", "HE14YCz1pj0-01561-00450067-00450307": "the the the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01562-00450308-00450581": "participant is asked is wondering if", "HE14YCz1pj0-01563-00450582-00450766": "there isn't time to form a legally", "HE14YCz1pj0-01564-00450767-00450935": "binding framework", "HE14YCz1pj0-01565-00450935-00451187": "for cross-border data governance within", "HE14YCz1pj0-01566-00451188-00451439": "the United Nations to prevent strategic", "HE14YCz1pj0-01567-00451439-00451835": "misuse of data National Big Data from", "HE14YCz1pj0-01568-00451835-00452087": "countries and it's wondering if this", "HE14YCz1pj0-01569-00452088-00452279": "framework could be this kind of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01570-00452280-00452507": "framework could help digital trust and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01571-00452508-00452729": "transparency at the international level", "HE14YCz1pj0-01572-00452730-00452914": "and could help the formation of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01573-00452915-00453172": "unaccountable framework", "HE14YCz1pj0-01574-00453173-00453479": "so he's basically asking her about the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01575-00453480-00454031": "cross-border data transfer thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01576-00454032-00455245": "hello could I could I jump", "HE14YCz1pj0-01577-00455246-00455531": "go ahead", "HE14YCz1pj0-01578-00455532-00455770": "thank you very much for giving me the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01579-00455771-00455866": "flow", "HE14YCz1pj0-01580-00455867-00456029": "uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-01581-00456030-00456293": "can you hear me bro", "HE14YCz1pj0-01582-00456293-00456445": "yes", "HE14YCz1pj0-01583-00456446-00456689": "thank you very much hello everyone and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01584-00456689-00456868": "this English analyst I would like to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01585-00456869-00457247": "thank you for organizing this uh time", "HE14YCz1pj0-01586-00457247-00457445": "release session I'm Andrew McAfee from", "HE14YCz1pj0-01587-00457446-00457657": "Iranian Academy Community", "HE14YCz1pj0-01588-00457658-00458099": "uh isn't time to form a legally binding", "HE14YCz1pj0-01589-00458100-00458381": "framework for transporter data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01590-00458382-00458603": "governance within the United Nations to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01591-00458604-00458933": "prevent strategic misuses of national", "HE14YCz1pj0-01592-00458934-00459241": "Big Data of country for illegitimate", "HE14YCz1pj0-01593-00459242-00459581": "cross proposed by some dominant", "HE14YCz1pj0-01594-00459582-00459809": "government and international digital", "HE14YCz1pj0-01595-00459810-00460114": "platform this framework could help", "HE14YCz1pj0-01596-00460115-00460445": "digital Trust and transparency at", "HE14YCz1pj0-01597-00460446-00460625": "International level and could help", "HE14YCz1pj0-01598-00460626-00460897": "formation of an accountability framework", "HE14YCz1pj0-01599-00460897-00461279": "for dominant experts in internet and it", "HE14YCz1pj0-01600-00461280-00461597": "could also guarantee development rights", "HE14YCz1pj0-01601-00461597-00461831": "the rights to development of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01602-00461832-00462113": "developing countries and fundamental", "HE14YCz1pj0-01603-00462114-00462455": "rights of user and prevent formation of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01604-00462456-00462791": "new data colonialism my question is that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01605-00462792-00463043": "what would be the contribution of global", "HE14YCz1pj0-01606-00463043-00463193": "digital compact", "HE14YCz1pj0-01607-00463193-00463516": "to address this critical issue and to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01608-00463517-00463805": "establish drafting process of United", "HE14YCz1pj0-01609-00463806-00464249": "Nations convention and data serenity at", "HE14YCz1pj0-01610-00464250-00464579": "the end I would like to thank you thank", "HE14YCz1pj0-01611-00464580-00464866": "you hello sorry we'll just have to take", "HE14YCz1pj0-01612-00464867-00465166": "the first part of your your question and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01613-00465167-00465377": "then move on my apologies", "HE14YCz1pj0-01614-00465378-00465545": "uh yeah thank you I would like to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01615-00465546-00465757": "request my comments below", "HE14YCz1pj0-01616-00465758-00465977": "thank you very much for giving me the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01617-00465978-00466301": "support", "HE14YCz1pj0-01618-00466302-00466468": "um okay I'll I'll just very quickly", "HE14YCz1pj0-01619-00466469-00466589": "shoot this down I don't think this will", "HE14YCz1pj0-01620-00466589-00466697": "ever happen", "HE14YCz1pj0-01621-00466697-00466907": "um I think I alluded to this in in my in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01622-00466908-00467272": "my first uh introduction as well", "HE14YCz1pj0-01623-00467273-00467489": "um very simple reason we will never be", "HE14YCz1pj0-01624-00467489-00467764": "able to agree on this uh also anything", "HE14YCz1pj0-01625-00467765-00467927": "that comes from the from the U.N General", "HE14YCz1pj0-01626-00467928-00468160": "Assembly or any of those bodies will not", "HE14YCz1pj0-01627-00468162-00468347": "be binding anyway", "HE14YCz1pj0-01628-00468347-00468605": "um and if we look at I mean even much", "HE14YCz1pj0-01629-00468606-00468839": "much less controversial topics like", "HE14YCz1pj0-01630-00468839-00469127": "disability accessibility throughout the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01631-00469128-00469337": "world there are some of the biggest", "HE14YCz1pj0-01632-00469338-00469457": "nations in the world that have not", "HE14YCz1pj0-01633-00469458-00469660": "signed up to this today even though it's", "HE14YCz1pj0-01634-00469662-00469853": "been enforced for like 40 years now so", "HE14YCz1pj0-01635-00469854-00470110": "this will not happen in my opinion", "HE14YCz1pj0-01636-00470112-00470909": "okay we'll take oh sorry", "HE14YCz1pj0-01637-00470910-00471113": "just wanted to add there I'm not", "HE14YCz1pj0-01638-00471114-00471316": "disputing whether or not a legally", "HE14YCz1pj0-01639-00471317-00471575": "binding treaty is achievable but I think", "HE14YCz1pj0-01640-00471576-00471809": "the point was also around the need for", "HE14YCz1pj0-01641-00471810-00472085": "uh Global you know a global look at", "HE14YCz1pj0-01642-00472085-00472222": "these issues and especially giving", "HE14YCz1pj0-01643-00472223-00472391": "cross-border transfers I think that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01644-00472392-00472529": "makes sense I mean", "HE14YCz1pj0-01645-00472530-00472739": "um and we heard so many of the comments", "HE14YCz1pj0-01646-00472739-00473003": "talking about the need for approaches", "HE14YCz1pj0-01647-00473004-00473207": "that take into account local context but", "HE14YCz1pj0-01648-00473208-00473345": "there are fundamental principles in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01649-00473346-00473597": "human rights at stake where the idea of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01650-00473597-00473722": "having", "HE14YCz1pj0-01651-00473723-00473879": "um set principles that we want", "HE14YCz1pj0-01652-00473880-00474143": "incorporated into laws and making those", "HE14YCz1pj0-01653-00474143-00474401": "principles clearly articulated at a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01654-00474402-00474616": "global level I think can be very", "HE14YCz1pj0-01655-00474617-00474839": "influential in making sure that we have", "HE14YCz1pj0-01656-00474839-00475066": "the right types of data protection in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01657-00475067-00475247": "you know across the globe from region to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01658-00475247-00475447": "region and coherence across those", "HE14YCz1pj0-01659-00475447-00475685": "approaches as well so", "HE14YCz1pj0-01660-00475685-00475870": "um I agree uh probably not the time to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01661-00475871-00476051": "push for the legally binding treaty but", "HE14YCz1pj0-01662-00476052-00476297": "I I do think that there is room to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01663-00476297-00476572": "continue work on uh Global uh key", "HE14YCz1pj0-01664-00476573-00476789": "principles that can be agreed and used", "HE14YCz1pj0-01665-00476789-00477010": "in of protection legislation and for", "HE14YCz1pj0-01666-00477012-00477197": "oversight and other mechanisms of that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01667-00477197-00477377": "sort", "HE14YCz1pj0-01668-00477378-00477622": "thank you Arturo", "HE14YCz1pj0-01669-00477623-00477827": "yes I know I wanted to say something", "HE14YCz1pj0-01670-00477828-00478066": "pretty similar is that we may not be", "HE14YCz1pj0-01671-00478067-00478260": "able to have binding instruments but", "HE14YCz1pj0-01672-00478262-00478625": "Frameworks uh agreements uh I mean the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01673-00478626-00478787": "initiative that the Ambassador shared is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01674-00478788-00479003": "global cppr I'm actually going to take a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01675-00479004-00479255": "a very deep look at it these kind of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01676-00479256-00479435": "instruments are the ones that can help", "HE14YCz1pj0-01677-00479435-00479753": "create that as the speaker as a person", "HE14YCz1pj0-01678-00479754-00479933": "that raised a question said data compact", "HE14YCz1pj0-01679-00479934-00480203": "or or some kind of framework and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01680-00480204-00480395": "initiative so that's something that that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01681-00480396-00480655": "can happen on governance we have the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01682-00480656-00480875": "intra-institutional governance which is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01683-00480876-00481120": "required inter-institutional governance", "HE14YCz1pj0-01684-00481121-00481295": "within governments that is required", "HE14YCz1pj0-01685-00481296-00481607": "those two can be mandated within of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01686-00481608-00481918": "course a country but the inter country", "HE14YCz1pj0-01687-00481919-00482122": "the international kind of governance", "HE14YCz1pj0-01688-00482123-00482459": "that needs to be uh you know something", "HE14YCz1pj0-01689-00482460-00482783": "that that you know requires uh uh sort", "HE14YCz1pj0-01690-00482784-00482999": "of a process that that may be a little", "HE14YCz1pj0-01691-00483000-00483268": "longer and and will probably require the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01692-00483269-00483563": "countries to be looking forward to it so", "HE14YCz1pj0-01693-00483564-00483743": "so I I think that these kind of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01694-00483743-00483877": "initiatives are", "HE14YCz1pj0-01695-00483878-00484199": "definitely needed but I don't see them", "HE14YCz1pj0-01696-00484200-00484475": "as the previous panel they said as", "HE14YCz1pj0-01697-00484476-00484679": "binding and enforceable", "HE14YCz1pj0-01698-00484680-00484925": "thank you now we'll start with this the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01699-00484926-00485159": "middle section here", "HE14YCz1pj0-01700-00485160-00485405": "um", "HE14YCz1pj0-01701-00485406-00485893": "okay young lady in white", "HE14YCz1pj0-01702-00485893-00486131": "from Innova Bridge foundation in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01703-00486132-00486370": "Switzerland and I just wanted to build", "HE14YCz1pj0-01704-00486371-00486631": "on what was previously mentioned", "HE14YCz1pj0-01705-00486632-00486845": "and it is evident that different", "HE14YCz1pj0-01706-00486846-00487085": "countries are at different stages of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01707-00487085-00487355": "development and Adoption of data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01708-00487356-00487607": "protection measures and on a practical", "HE14YCz1pj0-01709-00487608-00488045": "note could you recommend any", "HE14YCz1pj0-01710-00488046-00488233": "um let's say", "HE14YCz1pj0-01711-00488234-00488477": "self-assessments how countries can", "HE14YCz1pj0-01712-00488478-00488722": "proceed or start to assess themselves", "HE14YCz1pj0-01713-00488723-00488945": "where they stand on the data protection", "HE14YCz1pj0-01714-00488946-00489268": "and data privacy in their own Journeys I", "HE14YCz1pj0-01715-00489269-00489514": "know that for example EU has the gdpr", "HE14YCz1pj0-01716-00489515-00489803": "checklist for sales assessment and I", "HE14YCz1pj0-01717-00489804-00489935": "think that'll be really useful if you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01718-00489935-00490072": "know of any other resources that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01719-00490073-00490337": "countries could use to self-assess and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01720-00490338-00490570": "start to look at the issue at more sort", "HE14YCz1pj0-01721-00490571-00490883": "of standardized way thanks", "HE14YCz1pj0-01722-00490884-00491243": "I think that's a good request of anybody", "HE14YCz1pj0-01723-00491243-00491459": "knows of any toolkits that persons can", "HE14YCz1pj0-01724-00491460-00492599": "use to make assessments on the panel", "HE14YCz1pj0-01725-00492600-00492935": "um I I think what you have mentioned is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01726-00492935-00493199": "the gdpr checklist would be something", "HE14YCz1pj0-01727-00493200-00493451": "that most regulators and countries are", "HE14YCz1pj0-01728-00493452-00493583": "using", "HE14YCz1pj0-01729-00493584-00493666": "um because", "HE14YCz1pj0-01730-00493667-00493943": "um it is the one that we all are all", "HE14YCz1pj0-01731-00493943-00494159": "trying to align and be comparable with", "HE14YCz1pj0-01732-00494160-00494543": "in order for us to you know have um and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01733-00494543-00495005": "that's why maybe in totally dismissing", "HE14YCz1pj0-01734-00495006-00495341": "um the attempt to go for a more a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01735-00495342-00495587": "broader framework um that a lot of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01736-00495588-00495733": "countries can", "HE14YCz1pj0-01737-00495734-00496222": "uh maybe subscribe to is maybe a bit", "HE14YCz1pj0-01738-00496223-00496607": "harsh but maybe trying and finding the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01739-00496608-00496793": "places where we are failing and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01740-00496793-00497081": "rectifying and going again in an", "HE14YCz1pj0-01741-00497082-00497309": "iterative manner because a lot of the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01742-00497310-00497477": "things we are talking about today may", "HE14YCz1pj0-01743-00497478-00497639": "not be for the benefit of the people", "HE14YCz1pj0-01744-00497639-00497951": "sitting here it may be for a benefit of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01745-00497952-00498220": "future generations and we have to keep", "HE14YCz1pj0-01746-00498221-00498443": "attempting thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01747-00498443-00498695": "anybody else on the panel like to make a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01748-00498696-00498910": "comment", "HE14YCz1pj0-01749-00498912-00499397": "gentlemen at the back very back", "HE14YCz1pj0-01750-00499397-00499522": "okay", "HE14YCz1pj0-01751-00499523-00499835": "um my name is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01752-00499835-00500141": "okay I have a question in regards to uh", "HE14YCz1pj0-01753-00500142-00500405": "countries like The Gambia that doesn't", "HE14YCz1pj0-01754-00500406-00500645": "have any data regulation data practice", "HE14YCz1pj0-01755-00500646-00500945": "on regulation at hand but still they are", "HE14YCz1pj0-01756-00500946-00501181": "still collecting data regards to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01757-00501182-00501557": "digital IDs biometric informations and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01758-00501558-00501827": "so on so forth so I'm asking well died", "HE14YCz1pj0-01759-00501828-00502072": "what are the approaches that we could", "HE14YCz1pj0-01760-00502073-00502427": "use you know either at un level or Civil", "HE14YCz1pj0-01761-00502428-00502649": "Society level to actually you know", "HE14YCz1pj0-01762-00502650-00502870": "fasten the process of those governments", "HE14YCz1pj0-01763-00502871-00503099": "coming up with these regulations", "HE14YCz1pj0-01764-00503100-00503314": "so because I think they're not going to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01765-00503315-00503543": "stop collecting the data and with lack", "HE14YCz1pj0-01766-00503543-00504125": "of Regulation is a problem thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01767-00504126-00504437": "perhaps a very quick word on on Civic", "HE14YCz1pj0-01768-00504438-00504610": "action and participation even though", "HE14YCz1pj0-01769-00504612-00504833": "that's not my sector absolutely", "HE14YCz1pj0-01770-00504834-00505072": "um what I've what I've seen in in the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01771-00505073-00505385": "past around the world is that um in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01772-00505385-00505643": "election time we all vote on taxes or", "HE14YCz1pj0-01773-00505643-00505937": "education uh or on defense policy or", "HE14YCz1pj0-01774-00505938-00506116": "anything like that and perhaps we should", "HE14YCz1pj0-01775-00506117-00506351": "rather consider the digital angle of all", "HE14YCz1pj0-01776-00506352-00506591": "of these different topics", "HE14YCz1pj0-01777-00506592-00506813": "um so one of the things that that I", "HE14YCz1pj0-01778-00506814-00506945": "would encourage you and everyone else in", "HE14YCz1pj0-01779-00506946-00507151": "the room to do myself very much included", "HE14YCz1pj0-01780-00507152-00507377": "next time that we go to the polling", "HE14YCz1pj0-01781-00507378-00507472": "station", "HE14YCz1pj0-01782-00507473-00507659": "um we we think not just about specialist", "HE14YCz1pj0-01783-00507660-00507820": "topics but also about the digital", "HE14YCz1pj0-01784-00507821-00508001": "implications and if you feel like there", "HE14YCz1pj0-01785-00508002-00508168": "is a political party or anything like", "HE14YCz1pj0-01786-00508169-00508420": "that or a movement that that drives data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01787-00508421-00508583": "protection privacy more strongly than", "HE14YCz1pj0-01788-00508584-00508810": "others then that might very well be one", "HE14YCz1pj0-01789-00508812-00509035": "support worth supporting", "HE14YCz1pj0-01790-00509035-00510227": "bang gun then Peggy thanks", "HE14YCz1pj0-01791-00510228-00510533": "oh it's working now uh so just reacting", "HE14YCz1pj0-01792-00510534-00510725": "to to Gambia I think there are two you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01793-00510726-00510881": "know key things I want to say number one", "HE14YCz1pj0-01794-00510882-00511085": "is and I hope you're aware there's an", "HE14YCz1pj0-01795-00511085-00511360": "ongoing process uh the reality is that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01796-00511362-00511516": "gov there are governments who", "HE14YCz1pj0-01797-00511517-00511745": "deliberately do not prioritize data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01798-00511746-00512027": "protection uh because what that means is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01799-00512028-00512279": "then they admitting that many of the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01800-00512280-00512555": "processes they instituted become illegal", "HE14YCz1pj0-01801-00512556-00512764": "uh I mean I've given many examples I", "HE14YCz1pj0-01802-00512765-00513005": "gave some examples uh early and there's", "HE14YCz1pj0-01803-00513006-00513137": "so many examples in the report we put", "HE14YCz1pj0-01804-00513138-00513413": "together at least 11 countries uh where", "HE14YCz1pj0-01805-00513414-00513689": "they do know that their Mass biometric", "HE14YCz1pj0-01806-00513689-00513929": "data collection is illegal I mean it's", "HE14YCz1pj0-01807-00513930-00514157": "not proportionate it's not legal it's", "HE14YCz1pj0-01808-00514158-00514414": "not necessary so there's no incentive to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01809-00514415-00514601": "put together you know legislation to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01810-00514602-00514775": "call themselves criminals I mean why", "HE14YCz1pj0-01811-00514776-00514955": "would you want to do that uh that's one", "HE14YCz1pj0-01812-00514956-00515285": "but the second thing is I think uh you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01813-00515285-00515435": "as a citizen", "HE14YCz1pj0-01814-00515435-00515675": "regardless of the sector you're in you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01815-00515676-00515897": "need to hook up with other people in the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01816-00515897-00516016": "country and I'm not speaking just of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01817-00516017-00516262": "Gambia now it is our responsibility as", "HE14YCz1pj0-01818-00516263-00516557": "data owners to push back", "HE14YCz1pj0-01819-00516558-00516803": "um you know this is why I I say that you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01820-00516804-00516922": "know we're gonna it's gonna get more", "HE14YCz1pj0-01821-00516923-00517085": "complex we're going to look at more data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01822-00517085-00517216": "we're talking AI where we don't even", "HE14YCz1pj0-01823-00517217-00517385": "know what we're going to talk about next", "HE14YCz1pj0-01824-00517385-00517595": "right we're going to get more data and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01825-00517596-00517822": "we need to push back and ask for data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01826-00517823-00518110": "minimalization we need to stop giving", "HE14YCz1pj0-01827-00518112-00518339": "data that is not necessary some of it", "HE14YCz1pj0-01828-00518339-00518507": "would mean that you have to ask more", "HE14YCz1pj0-01829-00518508-00518741": "questions uh but I would encourage that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01830-00518742-00518914": "please you know link up with other", "HE14YCz1pj0-01831-00518915-00519083": "people in The Gambia specifically since", "HE14YCz1pj0-01832-00519084-00519268": "you asked we're working I give one", "HE14YCz1pj0-01833-00519269-00519364": "project and others we're working", "HE14YCz1pj0-01834-00519365-00519635": "Paradise working on that you know data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01835-00519635-00519833": "protection so that the process can move", "HE14YCz1pj0-01836-00519834-00520120": "on and we need to make it obvious uh to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01837-00520121-00520307": "governments why this is also a win for", "HE14YCz1pj0-01838-00520308-00520547": "them uh you know politicians will do the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01839-00520547-00520751": "things that would help them win the next", "HE14YCz1pj0-01840-00520752-00520912": "election and you have that opportunity", "HE14YCz1pj0-01841-00520913-00521159": "in The Gambia particularly", "HE14YCz1pj0-01842-00521160-00521531": "Peggy just picking up on benga's point", "HE14YCz1pj0-01843-00521532-00521710": "um absolutely I was going to emphasize", "HE14YCz1pj0-01844-00521712-00521975": "that you you do have to look at why the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01845-00521976-00522209": "data protection uh regulations and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01846-00522210-00522425": "bodies aren't in place", "HE14YCz1pj0-01847-00522426-00522622": "um and and address those those barriers", "HE14YCz1pj0-01848-00522623-00522814": "sometimes it is and we talked about", "HE14YCz1pj0-01849-00522815-00523037": "needing good models having the resources", "HE14YCz1pj0-01850-00523038-00523241": "to put these things in place and you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01851-00523242-00523379": "know we should all support that to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01852-00523380-00523618": "happen but the reality is there are", "HE14YCz1pj0-01853-00523619-00523751": "other barriers", "HE14YCz1pj0-01854-00523752-00523895": "um and sometimes they can be political", "HE14YCz1pj0-01855-00523896-00524105": "as has been talked about but I want to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01856-00524106-00524320": "emphasize that even when National laws", "HE14YCz1pj0-01857-00524321-00524507": "aren't in place international human", "HE14YCz1pj0-01858-00524508-00524753": "rights obligations still apply and that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01859-00524754-00524993": "means that when governments or others", "HE14YCz1pj0-01860-00524994-00525172": "are collecting and using data in ways", "HE14YCz1pj0-01861-00525173-00525341": "that violate the right to privacy we", "HE14YCz1pj0-01862-00525342-00525557": "have a human rights abuse that can and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01863-00525558-00525743": "should be taken up by international", "HE14YCz1pj0-01864-00525744-00525916": "human rights bodies and just two", "HE14YCz1pj0-01865-00525917-00526151": "examples of how that might be done one", "HE14YCz1pj0-01866-00526152-00526318": "is through the universal periodic review", "HE14YCz1pj0-01867-00526319-00526505": "where each country is reviewed by the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01868-00526506-00526745": "Human Rights Council questions can be", "HE14YCz1pj0-01869-00526746-00526937": "asked by other states about you know", "HE14YCz1pj0-01870-00526938-00527093": "what is the status of your data", "HE14YCz1pj0-01871-00527094-00527266": "Protection Law and you know how are you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01872-00527267-00527489": "how are you moving forward on these", "HE14YCz1pj0-01873-00527490-00527818": "issues and that's proved a useful way to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01874-00527819-00528083": "push for legislative reform on a number", "HE14YCz1pj0-01875-00528084-00528316": "of issues in various countries the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01876-00528317-00528551": "second uh thing I'd mention is is the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01877-00528552-00528737": "special procedure system for example", "HE14YCz1pj0-01878-00528738-00528905": "there's a special rapid Tour on the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01879-00528906-00529157": "right to privacy and Communications and", "HE14YCz1pj0-01880-00529158-00529349": "other interventions can be set talking", "HE14YCz1pj0-01881-00529350-00529547": "about violations of the right to privacy", "HE14YCz1pj0-01882-00529548-00529793": "within a state to which if the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01883-00529794-00529991": "rapporteur picks it up then the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01884-00529992-00530170": "government will need to respond to that", "HE14YCz1pj0-01885-00530171-00530375": "as well so there are a variety of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01886-00530376-00530512": "different mechanisms using international", "HE14YCz1pj0-01887-00530513-00530843": "human rights law that might be useful", "HE14YCz1pj0-01888-00530844-00531227": "thank you very much usually we ask each", "HE14YCz1pj0-01889-00531228-00531503": "panel um each panelists to give a wrap", "HE14YCz1pj0-01890-00531504-00531839": "up but I think we've had a good", "HE14YCz1pj0-01891-00531840-00532162": "report going on and the conversation the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01892-00532163-00532391": "dialogue is being good so I'm gonna let", "HE14YCz1pj0-01893-00532392-00532739": "the one last patient question from the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01894-00532740-00533093": "young lady here and uh it has to be like", "HE14YCz1pj0-01895-00533094-00533405": "30 seconds yes thank you actually um my", "HE14YCz1pj0-01896-00533406-00533566": "question has been asked about others but", "HE14YCz1pj0-01897-00533567-00533789": "uh just a quick question actually do you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01898-00533790-00534059": "think the current fdas could be set up", "HE14YCz1pj0-01899-00534060-00534311": "as a basis to develop the global", "HE14YCz1pj0-01900-00534312-00534587": "framework for transporter data flow is", "HE14YCz1pj0-01901-00534588-00534862": "that an accurate uh enough or if you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01902-00534863-00535133": "should it be a base foundation for us to", "HE14YCz1pj0-01903-00535134-00535475": "build on for Global framework at the", "HE14YCz1pj0-01904-00535476-00535739": "ftas and the WTO negotiation yeah that's", "HE14YCz1pj0-01905-00535740-00536020": "my question thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01906-00536021-00536249": "anybody wants to get that in the last 30", "HE14YCz1pj0-01907-00536250-00536518": "seconds", "HE14YCz1pj0-01908-00536519-00536818": "I want to thank my panelists for a", "HE14YCz1pj0-01909-00536819-00537101": "fantastic job and the audience both", "HE14YCz1pj0-01910-00537102-00537461": "online and on site uh you've kept", "HE14YCz1pj0-01911-00537462-00537629": "everything going I think a lot of you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01912-00537630-00537941": "have a lot of", "HE14YCz1pj0-01913-00537942-00538289": "takeaways that you can use and I think", "HE14YCz1pj0-01914-00538290-00538577": "the biggest takeaway that we can can go", "HE14YCz1pj0-01915-00538578-00538925": "with is that we ourselves we the owners", "HE14YCz1pj0-01916-00538926-00539170": "need to make the difference with regards", "HE14YCz1pj0-01917-00539171-00539429": "to data governments and protecting our", "HE14YCz1pj0-01918-00539430-00539668": "privacy so thank you very much thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01919-00539669-00539849": "panelists", "HE14YCz1pj0-01920-00539850-00540022": "thank you", "HE14YCz1pj0-01921-00540023-00540539": "[Applause]", "HE14YCz1pj0-01922-00540540-00540845": "um can we have the online persons just", "HE14YCz1pj0-01923-00540846-00541031": "stay on so we can take a picture thank", "HE14YCz1pj0-01924-00541032-00543149": "you very much", "HE14YCz1pj0-01925-00543150-00543421": "tonight"}}]