[{"audio_id": "QF2SBSfBKBE", "text": {"QF2SBSfBKBE-00000-00000050-00000359": "this short video is going to help you", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00001-00000360-00000494": "understand how you'll be able to take", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00002-00000495-00001087": "attendance in blackboard after you've", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00003-00001088-00001502": "logged into your course we can add a", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00004-00001503-00001684": "page that the students will be able to", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00005-00001685-00002009": "see their attendance as well so if we go", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00006-00002010-00002483": "to make sure the edit mode is on go to", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00007-00002484-00002732": "the plus sign on the left hand side of", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00008-00002733-00003338": "the page look to add a tool link call", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00009-00003339-00004304": "this tool link attendance and underneath", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00010-00004305-00004763": "the type we will scroll down to look how", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00011-00004764-00005095": "we can take attendance online and we", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00012-00005096-00005425": "will select the online attendance tool", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00013-00005426-00005747": "you can make it available to users we", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00014-00005748-00006224": "can hit submit this will add a page we", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00015-00006225-00006454": "can move up and put wherever we would", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00016-00006455-00006796": "like when you click on this page you'll", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00017-00006797-00007034": "be directed to a page to help you set up", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00018-00007034-00007406": "your attendance you will be able to do", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00019-00007406-00007898": "the date set up you can pick the", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00020-00007898-00008402": "starting date of your course you can", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00021-00008403-00008732": "pick the ending date and you'll be able", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00022-00008733-00009088": "to walk through the steps on how to", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00023-00009089-00009413": "select a course for say Monday Wednesday", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00024-00009414-00009769": "Friday you can save your settings and", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00025-00009770-00010142": "from there once they're set you'll be", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00026-00010143-00010696": "able to go and remove individual dates", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00027-00010697-00010996": "you'll be able to go in and pick the", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00028-00010997-00011627": "dates for our spring break if there's a", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00029-00011628-00012023": "holiday you'll be able to remove the", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00030-00012024-00012497": "dates from the attendance", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00031-00012498-00013019": "and from here you'll be able to take", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00032-00013019-00013694": "your attendance information about the", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00033-00013694-00013969": "attendance tool can be found on the help", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00034-00013971-00014338": "page in the queue on the blackboard", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00035-00014340-00014816": "learn information page is an area will", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00036-00014816-00015056": "have a link to this video that I'm", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00037-00015057-00015679": "creating and also as a hand out of a PDF", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00038-00015680-00015991": "PowerPoint that was produced by baylor", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00039-00015993-00016328": "university that shows how to use the", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00040-00016329-00016610": "attendance tool and how to set up the", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00041-00016611-00016913": "attendance tool if you're having", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00042-00016914-00017093": "technical difficulties using attendance", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00043-00017094-00017650": "tool please email help at qcc msed you", "QF2SBSfBKBE-00044-00017651-00017966": "thank you"}}, {"audio_id": "QF36CTSNkOk", "text": {"QF36CTSNkOk-00000-00000012-00003142": "foreign", "QF36CTSNkOk-00001-00003143-00005885": "foreign", "QF36CTSNkOk-00002-00005886-00007691": "foreign", "QF36CTSNkOk-00003-00007692-00007801": "Hallelujah", "QF36CTSNkOk-00004-00007802-00008177": "[Applause]", "QF36CTSNkOk-00005-00008178-00010067": "Hallelujah", "QF36CTSNkOk-00006-00010068-00010727": "um", "QF36CTSNkOk-00007-00010728-00014879": "foreign", "QF36CTSNkOk-00008-00014880-00015180": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "QF9dhCPDddA", "text": {"QF9dhCPDddA-00000-00001338-00001614": "sometimes I believe that love is a poem", "QF9dhCPDddA-00001-00001616-00002118": "or a song sometimes I think that love is", "QF9dhCPDddA-00002-00002119-00002815": "a physical experience occasionally I", "QF9dhCPDddA-00003-00002816-00003042": "feel that love is an echo social psycho", "QF9dhCPDddA-00004-00003043-00003565": "ethnic arrangement but mostly I don't", "QF9dhCPDddA-00005-00003565-00003742": "really believe there's actually such a", "QF9dhCPDddA-00006-00003743-00004357": "thing as love sometimes I believe that", "QF9dhCPDddA-00007-00004358-00004657": "God is a bird or a flower sometimes I", "QF9dhCPDddA-00008-00004658-00005010": "think that God is a good vibration", "QF9dhCPDddA-00009-00005011-00005275": "occasionally I feel that God is a cosmic", "QF9dhCPDddA-00010-00005276-00005524": "intelligence or talented sculptor or", "QF9dhCPDddA-00011-00005525-00005992": "amateur sociologist but mostly I don't", "QF9dhCPDddA-00012-00005993-00006712": "believe in God sometimes I believe that", "QF9dhCPDddA-00013-00006713-00006865": "I am an electric particle of matter", "QF9dhCPDddA-00014-00006866-00007023": "charge through with potential and", "QF9dhCPDddA-00015-00007025-00007555": "kinetic energy sometimes I think I'm a", "QF9dhCPDddA-00016-00007556-00007773": "character at a universal nightmare", "QF9dhCPDddA-00017-00007773-00007956": "occasionally I feel my deep", "QF9dhCPDddA-00018-00007958-00008139": "multi-layered puzzle package that is", "QF9dhCPDddA-00019-00008140-00008296": "constantly in the process of being", "QF9dhCPDddA-00020-00008297-00008932": "opened but mostly I don't feel like", "QF9dhCPDddA-00021-00008933-00009422": "anything special", "QF9dhCPDddA-00022-00009423-00009642": "sometimes I believe that reality is a", "QF9dhCPDddA-00023-00009643-00010067": "question that no one is really asking", "QF9dhCPDddA-00024-00010068-00010272": "sometimes I think that reality is a", "QF9dhCPDddA-00025-00010273-00010443": "collection of our most painful", "QF9dhCPDddA-00026-00010444-00010800": "experiences occasionally I feel that", "QF9dhCPDddA-00027-00010801-00011006": "reality is what I can see with my eyes", "QF9dhCPDddA-00028-00011007-00011574": "and I can touch with my hands but really", "QF9dhCPDddA-00029-00011575-00011811": "I don't have the slightest idea of what", "QF9dhCPDddA-00030-00011812-00012681": "reality is some believe that the beauty", "QF9dhCPDddA-00031-00012682-00012905": "in life is found in trees and sunshine", "QF9dhCPDddA-00032-00012906-00013122": "something that the beauty in life is", "QF9dhCPDddA-00033-00013122-00014941": "when you stop asking there's but what if", "QF9dhCPDddA-00034-00014943-00015183": "what if there is something in life that", "QF9dhCPDddA-00035-00015184-00015477": "can make a difference what if there are", "QF9dhCPDddA-00036-00015478-00015783": "such things as love beauty and believing", "QF9dhCPDddA-00037-00015784-00016038": "with perfect faith not just sometimes", "QF9dhCPDddA-00038-00016038-00016575": "but always I'd want to know wouldn't you", "QF9dhCPDddA-00039-00016576-00016879": "[Laughter]", "QF9dhCPDddA-00040-00016880-00017697": "[Music]", "QF9dhCPDddA-00041-00017698-00018013": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "QFgD26G6ODM", "text": {"QFgD26G6ODM-00000-00000002-00000262": "here we're given a graph we're asked to", "QFgD26G6ODM-00001-00000263-00000484": "review the graph and then use it to", "QFgD26G6ODM-00002-00000485-00000833": "answer the questions below so let's take", "QFgD26G6ODM-00003-00000834-00001048": "a look at the graph very carefully and", "QFgD26G6ODM-00004-00001049-00001466": "identify the important features first of", "QFgD26G6ODM-00005-00001467-00001721": "all I have an axis running this way", "QFgD26G6ODM-00006-00001722-00002132": "called the horizontal axis the quantity", "QFgD26G6ODM-00007-00002133-00002326": "that's represented there is the speed of", "QFgD26G6ODM-00008-00002327-00002681": "a car in miles per hour the vertical", "QFgD26G6ODM-00009-00002682-00002999": "axis is here represents stopping", "QFgD26G6ODM-00010-00003000-00003397": "distance in feet the values on the", "QFgD26G6ODM-00011-00003397-00003809": "horizontal running from 0 to 80 miles an", "QFgD26G6ODM-00012-00003810-00004208": "hour the values on the vertical axis run", "QFgD26G6ODM-00013-00004209-00004733": "from 0 to 500 feet so let's take a look", "QFgD26G6ODM-00014-00004734-00005009": "at the questions and see how I can", "QFgD26G6ODM-00015-00005010-00005225": "address them using the information in", "QFgD26G6ODM-00016-00005226-00005588": "the graph so this says Part A what is", "QFgD26G6ODM-00017-00005589-00005861": "the horizontal axis represent including", "QFgD26G6ODM-00018-00005862-00006331": "units so the horizontal axis represents", "QFgD26G6ODM-00019-00006332-00006956": "the speed of a car in miles per hour so", "QFgD26G6ODM-00020-00006956-00007139": "very important to understand the", "QFgD26G6ODM-00021-00007140-00007400": "quantities that are represented on each", "QFgD26G6ODM-00022-00007401-00007781": "part of our graph Part B says what does", "QFgD26G6ODM-00023-00007781-00008189": "the vertical axis represent and the", "QFgD26G6ODM-00024-00008190-00008498": "vertical axis represents the stopping", "QFgD26G6ODM-00025-00008499-00009428": "distance of the car in feet it is the", "QFgD26G6ODM-00026-00009429-00009760": "graph increasing or decreasing I read", "QFgD26G6ODM-00027-00009761-00010060": "graphs from left to right just like I", "QFgD26G6ODM-00028-00010061-00010580": "read text on a page so as I am traveling", "QFgD26G6ODM-00029-00010581-00010831": "along the horizontal axis from left to", "QFgD26G6ODM-00030-00010832-00011276": "right if the values on the vertical axis", "QFgD26G6ODM-00031-00011277-00011687": "are getting larger then we say that the", "QFgD26G6ODM-00032-00011688-00012026": "graph is increasing so in this case I'm", "QFgD26G6ODM-00033-00012027-00012323": "traveling this direction on the", "QFgD26G6ODM-00034-00012324-00012553": "horizontal as the numbers get bigger on", "QFgD26G6ODM-00035-00012554-00012880": "the horizontal axis the numbers do get", "QFgD26G6ODM-00036-00012881-00013163": "bigger on the vertical axis therefore", "QFgD26G6ODM-00037-00013163-00013361": "this graph is", "QFgD26G6ODM-00038-00013362-00013930": "increasing Part D provide an overall", "QFgD26G6ODM-00039-00013931-00014249": "statement of what the graph represents", "QFgD26G6ODM-00040-00014250-00014561": "and there's a lot of different ways to", "QFgD26G6ODM-00041-00014562-00014889": "describe this it's important to use the", "QFgD26G6ODM-00042-00014890-00015231": "units and the quantities that were given", "QFgD26G6ODM-00043-00015232-00015946": "so the graph shows the distance", "QFgD26G6ODM-00044-00015947-00016705": "necessary in feet for a car to stop", "QFgD26G6ODM-00045-00016706-00017678": "depending on the speed the car is", "QFgD26G6ODM-00046-00017679-00018317": "traveling in miles per hour so basically", "QFgD26G6ODM-00047-00018318-00018524": "we're just summarizing the information", "QFgD26G6ODM-00048-00018525-00019009": "that we're given with the horizontal and", "QFgD26G6ODM-00049-00019010-00019250": "vertical axis those are the quantities", "QFgD26G6ODM-00050-00019251-00019583": "that are going to be described the the", "QFgD26G6ODM-00051-00019584-00020036": "information in the graph so Part II asks", "QFgD26G6ODM-00052-00020037-00020327": "if the vehicle speed is 60 miles per", "QFgD26G6ODM-00053-00020328-00020740": "hour how many feet does it take to stop", "QFgD26G6ODM-00054-00020741-00021047": "so the graph is connecting the", "QFgD26G6ODM-00055-00021048-00021425": "quantities of speed and distance so when", "QFgD26G6ODM-00056-00021426-00021722": "I'm given a number I need to understand", "QFgD26G6ODM-00057-00021723-00021971": "if that number represents the speed or a", "QFgD26G6ODM-00058-00021972-00022378": "distance so for Part II I'm given a", "QFgD26G6ODM-00059-00022379-00022609": "speed which means what I'm going to do", "QFgD26G6ODM-00060-00022610-00023036": "is track here on the horizontal to a", "QFgD26G6ODM-00061-00023037-00023500": "speed of 60 and then I'm going to travel", "QFgD26G6ODM-00062-00023501-00024147": "up and see where the graph lies and", "QFgD26G6ODM-00063-00024148-00024599": "where then that intersects with the", "QFgD26G6ODM-00064-00024600-00025118": "vertical axis so if my in this case I", "QFgD26G6ODM-00065-00025119-00025411": "can call it my input or my horizontal", "QFgD26G6ODM-00066-00025412-00025777": "axis value is 60 if my speed is 60 that", "QFgD26G6ODM-00067-00025777-00026179": "corresponds to a stopping distance of", "QFgD26G6ODM-00068-00026180-00026687": "300 feet", "QFgD26G6ODM-00069-00026688-00026930": "so if you think about it 60 miles per", "QFgD26G6ODM-00070-00026931-00027170": "hour is a pretty common speed on a", "QFgD26G6ODM-00071-00027171-00027590": "freeway and to come to a complete stop", "QFgD26G6ODM-00072-00027591-00027827": "it would take 300 feet if I was", "QFgD26G6ODM-00073-00027828-00028043": "traveling 60 miles per hour in my car", "QFgD26G6ODM-00074-00028044-00028560": "that's quite a distance part f it asks", "QFgD26G6ODM-00075-00028561-00028833": "if 400 feet are required to stop about", "QFgD26G6ODM-00076-00028833-00029198": "how fast is the vehicle traveling so the", "QFgD26G6ODM-00077-00029199-00029580": "400 here that is a stopping distance so", "QFgD26G6ODM-00078-00029581-00029733": "what I'm gonna do is I'm gonna go to my", "QFgD26G6ODM-00079-00029733-00029939": "vertical axis and I'm going to look at", "QFgD26G6ODM-00080-00029940-00030285": "400 I'm gonna trace that over to see", "QFgD26G6ODM-00081-00030286-00030573": "where that corresponds on the graph I'm", "QFgD26G6ODM-00082-00030574-00030839": "gonna draw a point right there and I'm", "QFgD26G6ODM-00083-00030840-00031196": "going to trace that back to the input or", "QFgD26G6ODM-00084-00031197-00031592": "the horizontal axis so these tick marks", "QFgD26G6ODM-00085-00031593-00032102": "are in blocks of 10 so 6070 it would be", "QFgD26G6ODM-00086-00032103-00032376": "a little bit bigger than 70 so I'm going", "QFgD26G6ODM-00087-00032377-00032679": "to say if 400 feet are required to stop", "QFgD26G6ODM-00088-00032680-00032961": "about how fast is the vehicle traveling", "QFgD26G6ODM-00089-00032962-00033498": "and so 71 miles per hour is a rough", "QFgD26G6ODM-00090-00033499-00033752": "estimate for how fast the vehicle was", "QFgD26G6ODM-00091-00033753-00033971": "traveling"}}, {"audio_id": "QFyI02e5z4g", "text": {"QFyI02e5z4g-00000-00000562-00000872": "hello key are everyone excited to share", "QFyI02e5z4g-00001-00000873-00001193": "my story with you so my story begins", "QFyI02e5z4g-00002-00001194-00001453": "with my father he was a chief of staff", "QFyI02e5z4g-00003-00001454-00001643": "of the National Security Council for", "QFyI02e5z4g-00004-00001644-00001832": "President Reagan this is his birthday on", "QFyI02e5z4g-00005-00001832-00002143": "Air Force one his claim to fame was", "QFyI02e5z4g-00006-00002144-00002357": "bringing email to the White House", "QFyI02e5z4g-00007-00002358-00002708": "pretty incredible my claim to fame was", "QFyI02e5z4g-00008-00002709-00002914": "bringing fashion to the White House", "QFyI02e5z4g-00009-00002915-00003175": "let's just get a little closer look here", "QFyI02e5z4g-00010-00003176-00003503": "notice the collar notice the shorts you", "QFyI02e5z4g-00011-00003504-00003706": "can't even see the shoes here but really", "QFyI02e5z4g-00012-00003707-00003977": "an impressive outfit overall so about 15", "QFyI02e5z4g-00013-00003978-00004217": "years after this photo was taken I was", "QFyI02e5z4g-00014-00004218-00004328": "home for spring break", "QFyI02e5z4g-00015-00004329-00004508": "and my dad said let's go out to lunch", "QFyI02e5z4g-00016-00004509-00004649": "let's get some lunch Nick", "QFyI02e5z4g-00017-00004650-00004904": "so got in the car and we started driving", "QFyI02e5z4g-00018-00004905-00005234": "across the river into Virginia I started", "QFyI02e5z4g-00019-00005235-00005372": "to get a little bit concerned as we", "QFyI02e5z4g-00020-00005373-00005681": "headed towards a specific exit and it", "QFyI02e5z4g-00021-00005682-00005870": "turns out that my father had set up an", "QFyI02e5z4g-00022-00005871-00006113": "interview for me with three of his", "QFyI02e5z4g-00023-00006114-00006685": "friends at the CIA so on this very seal", "QFyI02e5z4g-00024-00006686-00006835": "right here we proceeded to have a", "QFyI02e5z4g-00025-00006836-00007195": "father-son fight I said dad I don't want", "QFyI02e5z4g-00026-00007197-00007391": "to be a spy I want to be a teacher and", "QFyI02e5z4g-00027-00007392-00007616": "by the way I'm going to New Zealand to", "QFyI02e5z4g-00028-00007617-00008303": "study poetry and Maori education so he", "QFyI02e5z4g-00029-00008304-00008585": "said in his angry voice how will you", "QFyI02e5z4g-00030-00008586-00008803": "make a living as a teacher poet person", "QFyI02e5z4g-00031-00008804-00008989": "whatever and then sort of confusion set", "QFyI02e5z4g-00032-00008990-00009331": "in New Zealand what is that all about", "QFyI02e5z4g-00033-00009332-00009608": "sure enough I turned down the CIA and I", "QFyI02e5z4g-00034-00009609-00010085": "came to your beautiful country and I", "QFyI02e5z4g-00035-00010086-00010295": "immersed myself in New Zealand poetry", "QFyI02e5z4g-00036-00010296-00010448": "anybody know who wrote this poem right", "QFyI02e5z4g-00037-00010449-00010598": "here any any New Zealand poets in the", "QFyI02e5z4g-00038-00010599-00011021": "house this is an Alan Curnow poem one of", "QFyI02e5z4g-00039-00011022-00011144": "my favorite poets here we'll do an", "QFyI02e5z4g-00040-00011145-00011299": "open-space on New Zealand poetry for all", "QFyI02e5z4g-00041-00011300-00011446": "you Kiwis later", "QFyI02e5z4g-00042-00011447-00011756": "and immerse myself in Maori education", "QFyI02e5z4g-00043-00011757-00011935": "when my favorite movies here Whale Rider", "QFyI02e5z4g-00044-00011936-00012170": "and I had a little bit of fun as well", "QFyI02e5z4g-00045-00012171-00012388": "this is me falling down the mountain", "QFyI02e5z4g-00046-00012389-00012776": "Mount Taranaki here but I came back to", "QFyI02e5z4g-00047-00012777-00012952": "Washington DC several years later and I", "QFyI02e5z4g-00048-00012953-00013144": "couldn't find a job and I started to", "QFyI02e5z4g-00049-00013145-00013369": "wonder was dead right", "QFyI02e5z4g-00050-00013371-00013688": "was my obscure knowledge of New Zealand", "QFyI02e5z4g-00051-00013690-00013854": "poetry and Maori education making it", "QFyI02e5z4g-00052-00013855-00014007": "hard for me to get a job in Washington", "QFyI02e5z4g-00053-00014008-00014403": "DC so I teamed up with a group of fellow", "QFyI02e5z4g-00054-00014404-00014553": "nerds and we were all really excited", "QFyI02e5z4g-00055-00014554-00014741": "about the fact that 30% the role had", "QFyI02e5z4g-00056-00014743-00015012": "access to Internet 90% had access to", "QFyI02e5z4g-00057-00015013-00015240": "mobile phones but even more than that we", "QFyI02e5z4g-00058-00015241-00015402": "looked out across the world we saw all", "QFyI02e5z4g-00059-00015403-00015669": "these people working in disaster Human", "QFyI02e5z4g-00060-00015669-00015869": "Rights food education who were hungry", "QFyI02e5z4g-00061-00015871-00016146": "for new types of skills and generally", "QFyI02e5z4g-00062-00016147-00016332": "these folks don't have access to", "QFyI02e5z4g-00063-00016333-00016503": "graduate schools too expensive and it's", "QFyI02e5z4g-00064-00016504-00016716": "quite expensive to put also trainers on", "QFyI02e5z4g-00065-00016717-00016926": "planes to go reach them so we asked", "QFyI02e5z4g-00066-00016927-00017177": "ourselves as a group what about online", "QFyI02e5z4g-00067-00017178-00017583": "learning as a group we took hundreds of", "QFyI02e5z4g-00068-00017584-00017811": "courses Khan Academy code Academy", "QFyI02e5z4g-00069-00017812-00018096": "Coursera udemy Udacity you name it we", "QFyI02e5z4g-00070-00018097-00018291": "took it and we tried to build a better", "QFyI02e5z4g-00071-00018292-00018549": "model for how online education could be", "QFyI02e5z4g-00072-00018550-00018695": "done so we got together practitioners", "QFyI02e5z4g-00073-00018696-00019032": "with animators educators and programmers", "QFyI02e5z4g-00074-00019033-00019377": "and we built my company tech change 10", "QFyI02e5z4g-00075-00019378-00019479": "years later we've reached a hundred", "QFyI02e5z4g-00076-00019480-00019689": "thousand folks in almost every country", "QFyI02e5z4g-00077-00019690-00019830": "of the world and one of the largest", "QFyI02e5z4g-00078-00019831-00020052": "providers of e-learning for the social", "QFyI02e5z4g-00079-00020053-00020348": "sector working with all kinds of", "QFyI02e5z4g-00080-00020349-00020595": "phenomenal organizations large and small", "QFyI02e5z4g-00081-00020596-00020850": "and every corner of the world on things", "QFyI02e5z4g-00082-00020851-00021096": "like responding to Ebola or climate", "QFyI02e5z4g-00083-00021097-00021411": "change or refugee resettlement so what", "QFyI02e5z4g-00084-00021412-00021735": "is our special sauce well at the heart", "QFyI02e5z4g-00085-00021736-00021891": "of our model is this idea that we want", "QFyI02e5z4g-00086-00021892-00022047": "to co-create the learning experience", "QFyI02e5z4g-00087-00022048-00022215": "with our communities and that means", "QFyI02e5z4g-00088-00022216-00022419": "where others are trying to scale a", "QFyI02e5z4g-00089-00022420-00022593": "lecture into something that's self-paced", "QFyI02e5z4g-00090-00022594-00022812": "we look at the workshop and we think how", "QFyI02e5z4g-00091-00022813-00022992": "do we get the workshop all its", "QFyI02e5z4g-00092-00022993-00023220": "interactivity and community to scale and", "QFyI02e5z4g-00093-00023221-00023361": "that's what we call web shop so that's", "QFyI02e5z4g-00094-00023362-00023655": "where we live for us that means a really", "QFyI02e5z4g-00095-00023656-00023928": "robust training platform great content", "QFyI02e5z4g-00096-00023929-00024273": "and really strong facilitation we also", "QFyI02e5z4g-00097-00024274-00024429": "believe that building relationships", "QFyI02e5z4g-00098-00024430-00024663": "along skyed side skills is the key most", "QFyI02e5z4g-00099-00024664-00024810": "of the time you take an online course", "QFyI02e5z4g-00100-00024811-00025005": "you're getting better at skills for us", "QFyI02e5z4g-00101-00025006-00025152": "it's about creating community and small", "QFyI02e5z4g-00102-00025153-00025557": "groups like this we're also very keen to", "QFyI02e5z4g-00103-00025558-00025794": "ensure that pedagogy shapes technology", "QFyI02e5z4g-00104-00025795-00025932": "not the other way around pedagogy", "QFyI02e5z4g-00105-00025933-00026195": "meaning how we teach too often it's the", "QFyI02e5z4g-00106-00026197-00026418": "technology that determines it so for us", "QFyI02e5z4g-00107-00026419-00026639": "that means creating our own platform to", "QFyI02e5z4g-00108-00026641-00026720": "allow for that", "QFyI02e5z4g-00109-00026722-00026907": "and doing really neat things so this is", "QFyI02e5z4g-00110-00026908-00027093": "of course we taught on blockchain for", "QFyI02e5z4g-00111-00027094-00027222": "International Development I know there's", "QFyI02e5z4g-00112-00027223-00027435": "some crypto enthusiasts in the house and", "QFyI02e5z4g-00113-00027436-00027681": "we gave everybody a wallet to crypto", "QFyI02e5z4g-00114-00027682-00027902": "wallet and we used a token called", "QFyI02e5z4g-00115-00027904-00028077": "sterile lumens to actually exchange", "QFyI02e5z4g-00116-00028077-00028289": "value between and among participants", "QFyI02e5z4g-00117-00028291-00028514": "when they saw a comment they liked or", "QFyI02e5z4g-00118-00028516-00028725": "they attended an event and so forth so", "QFyI02e5z4g-00119-00028726-00028911": "new ways of thinking about how we can", "QFyI02e5z4g-00120-00028912-00029270": "engage people in courses day to day to", "QFyI02e5z4g-00121-00029272-00029397": "day to let the data drive", "QFyI02e5z4g-00122-00029398-00029645": "decision-making for us we are capturing", "QFyI02e5z4g-00123-00029647-00029808": "data on everything that's happening", "QFyI02e5z4g-00124-00029808-00029952": "inside of a course and we're using that", "QFyI02e5z4g-00125-00029952-00030255": "to inform what content to show how to", "QFyI02e5z4g-00126-00030256-00030417": "connect people more intentionally and", "QFyI02e5z4g-00127-00030418-00030561": "we're getting really clever about", "QFyI02e5z4g-00128-00030562-00030795": "actually mapping the social fabric of an", "QFyI02e5z4g-00129-00030795-00030987": "online learning community and giving", "QFyI02e5z4g-00130-00030988-00031158": "things like empathy scores to try and", "QFyI02e5z4g-00131-00031158-00031332": "get at some of those soft skills that", "QFyI02e5z4g-00132-00031333-00031599": "are so important so the last thing I'll", "QFyI02e5z4g-00133-00031600-00031701": "mention here is that good online", "QFyI02e5z4g-00134-00031702-00031935": "teaching really matters we're working", "QFyI02e5z4g-00135-00031936-00032136": "hard to actually train more digital", "QFyI02e5z4g-00136-00032137-00032433": "teachers out there in the world today so", "QFyI02e5z4g-00137-00032433-00032580": "why am I here I'm here to reconnect with", "QFyI02e5z4g-00138-00032581-00032754": "this incredible country to learn from", "QFyI02e5z4g-00139-00032755-00032976": "you all and to find collaborators who", "QFyI02e5z4g-00140-00032977-00033183": "are excited about the model for online", "QFyI02e5z4g-00141-00033184-00033477": "learning that we bring and and hoping to", "QFyI02e5z4g-00142-00033478-00033624": "build some of the best online courses", "QFyI02e5z4g-00143-00033625-00033813": "the world has ever seen and in case", "QFyI02e5z4g-00144-00033814-00034050": "you're wondering dear old dad tech", "QFyI02e5z4g-00145-00034051-00034271": "change super student has taken and", "QFyI02e5z4g-00146-00034272-00034587": "completed eight courses he's also paid", "QFyI02e5z4g-00147-00034588-00034781": "for them which is important", "QFyI02e5z4g-00148-00034782-00034986": "entrepreneurs I did not give any free", "QFyI02e5z4g-00149-00034987-00035285": "courses and he loves New Zealand so", "QFyI02e5z4g-00150-00035286-00035550": "there you have it thank you all enjoy", "QFyI02e5z4g-00151-00035551-00035764": "your coffee break", "QFyI02e5z4g-00152-00035765-00036899": "you", "QFyI02e5z4g-00153-00036900-00037106": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "QFzOXBOa7YQ", "text": {"QFzOXBOa7YQ-00000-00000049-00000330": "this is a list of PC games for personal", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00001-00000331-00000546": "computers including Microsoft Windows", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00002-00000547-00000783": "Mac OS and Linux that have sold or", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00003-00000784-00001065": "shipped at least 1 million copies if a", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00004-00001066-00001223": "game was released on multiple platforms", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00005-00001224-00001523": "the sales figures listed are only for PC", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00006-00001524-00001779": "sales this list is not comprehensive", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00007-00001780-00001980": "because sales figures are not always", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00008-00001980-00002322": "publicly available subscription figures", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00009-00002323-00002534": "for massively multiplayer online games", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00010-00002535-00002768": "such as World of Warcraft or lineage and", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00011-00002769-00002924": "number of accounts from free-to-play", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00012-00002925-00003134": "games such as hearthstone are not taken", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00013-00003135-00003290": "into account as they do not necessarily", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00014-00003290-00003959": "correspond to sales", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00015-00003960-00004443": "topic list", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00016-00004444-00004810": "you", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00017-00004811-00005325": "topic see also", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00018-00005326-00005674": "list of PC games list of best-selling", "QFzOXBOa7YQ-00019-00005675-00006214": "video games equals equals notes"}}, {"audio_id": "QFZ2I5prUyu", "text": {"QFZ2I5prUyu-00000-00000046-00000319": "several universities have designed", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00001-00000320-00000559": "interdisciplinary courses with a focus", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00002-00000560-00000790": "on human biology at the undergraduate", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00003-00000791-00001124": "level there is a wide variation in", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00004-00001125-00001385": "emphasis ranging from business social", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00005-00001386-00001646": "studies public policy health care and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00006-00001647-00002324": "pharmaceutical research", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00007-00002325-00002902": "topic Americas", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00008-00002903-00003220": "you", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00009-00003221-00003611": "topic human biology major at Stanford", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00010-00003611-00004417": "University Palo Alto since 1970", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00011-00004418-00004724": "Stanford's human biology program as an", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00012-00004725-00004970": "undergraduate major it integrates the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00013-00004971-00005231": "natural and Social Sciences in the study", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00014-00005232-00005513": "of human beings it is interdisciplinary", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00015-00005514-00005842": "and policy oriented and was founded in", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00016-00005843-00006140": "1970 by a group of Stanford faculty", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00017-00006141-00006428": "professors Dornish Ehrlich Hamburg paste", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00018-00006429-00006701": "or f-- kennedy Kretchmer Lederberg and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00019-00006702-00007052": "pitt on dry it is a very popular major", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00020-00007053-00007306": "an alumni have gone to postgraduate", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00021-00007308-00007589": "education medical school law business", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00022-00007590-00008075": "and government topic human and social", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00023-00008076-00008339": "biology Caribbean human and social", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00024-00008340-00008627": "biology as a level four and five subject", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00025-00008628-00008785": "in the secondary and post-secondary", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00026-00008786-00009062": "schools in the Caribbean and as optional", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00027-00009063-00009299": "for the Caribbean secondary education", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00028-00009300-00009506": "certification CSEC", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00029-00009507-00009749": "which is equivalent to ordinary level Oh", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00030-00009750-00009996": "level under the British school system", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00031-00009997-00010301": "the syllabus centers on structure and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00032-00010302-00010491": "functioning anatomy physiology", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00033-00010492-00010802": "biochemistry of human body and the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00034-00010803-00011017": "relevance to human health with Caribbean", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00035-00011018-00011366": "specific experience the syllabus has", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00036-00011367-00011573": "organized under five main sections", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00037-00011574-00011766": "living organisms and the environment", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00038-00011767-00012106": "life processes heredity and variation", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00039-00012107-00012364": "disease and its impact on humans the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00040-00012365-00012595": "impact of human activities on the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00041-00012596-00013105": "environment topic human biology program", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00042-00013106-00013385": "at University of Toronto the University", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00043-00013386-00013594": "of Toronto offers an undergraduate", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00044-00013596-00013916": "program in human biology that is jointly", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00045-00013916-00014116": "offered by the Faculty of Arts and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00046-00014118-00014447": "Science and the Faculty of Medicine the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00047-00014447-00014672": "program offers several major and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00048-00014672-00014882": "specialist options in human biology", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00049-00014883-00015218": "neuroscience health and disease Global", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00050-00015219-00015443": "Health and fundamental genetics and it's", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00051-00015444-00016068": "applications", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00052-00016069-00016610": "topic Asia", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00053-00016611-00016926": "you", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00054-00016927-00017440": "topic B SC honors human biology at All", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00055-00017441-00017758": "India Institute of Medical Sciences New", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00056-00017759-00018503": "Delhi 1980 to 2002", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00057-00018504-00018966": "BSC honours human biology at AI IMS New", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00058-00018967-00019278": "Delhi India was started in 1980 with a", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00059-00019279-00019491": "goal to bridge the gap between research", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00060-00019492-00019773": "performed at molecular cellular level in", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00061-00019774-00020022": "vitro or in lower animal models and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00062-00020023-00020234": "clinical research creating a pool of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00063-00020235-00020421": "scientists with a greater understanding", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00064-00020422-00020697": "of human physiology and tools to", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00065-00020698-00020937": "incorporate the big picture while still", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00066-00020938-00021135": "taking a reductionist approach to", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00067-00021136-00021501": "scientific research as such it provided", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00068-00021502-00021756": "a stepping-stone for advanced career in", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00069-00021757-00022086": "research and allied fields candidates", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00070-00022087-00022368": "for the maximum of 25 open seats were", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00071-00022369-00022736": "selected via a nationwide entrance exam", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00072-00022737-00022913": "origin", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00073-00022914-00023451": "professor Prakash Chandra B 1952 D point", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00074-00023452-00023985": "to 0:06 who was Dean at AI IMS from 1979", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00075-00023986-00024351": "to 1984 undertook the task of revising", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00076-00024352-00024552": "the undergraduate curriculum and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00077-00024553-00024849": "initiated the BSC hons courses in", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00078-00024850-00025233": "nursing and in human biology among the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00079-00025234-00025491": "founders of human biology program was", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00080-00025492-00025802": "dr. BS Noreen a well renowned educator", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00081-00025804-00026049": "at that time whose contributions are now", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00082-00026050-00026355": "recognised as dr. BS snoring memorial", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00083-00026356-00026598": "prize awarded to the best undergraduate", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00084-00026599-00026957": "in biochemistry at a IIM s course work", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00085-00026958-00027237": "first phase during the first phase", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00086-00027238-00027477": "students were exposed to the basic", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00087-00027477-00027699": "medical sciences human anatomy", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00088-00027700-00028070": "physiology and biochemistry this phase", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00089-00028072-00028383": "was run together with first-year MBBS", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00090-00028383-00028623": "medical students who also followed the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00091-00028624-00029001": "same curriculum human anatomy gross", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00092-00029002-00029295": "cadaver cadaver dissections osteology", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00093-00029295-00029564": "and kinesiology micro Natta me of all", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00094-00029566-00029712": "systems of the body", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00095-00029713-00029949": "neuroanatomy of brain and spinal cord", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00096-00029950-00030168": "it's connections and function with", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00097-00030169-00030392": "demonstration of cut brain sections", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00098-00030393-00030669": "embryology development of human embryo", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00099-00030670-00030924": "normal and abnormal study of various", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00100-00030925-00031164": "stages of microscopic and gross level", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00101-00031164-00031557": "and genetics physiology a complete", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00102-00031558-00031773": "review of the functional aspects of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00103-00031774-00031848": "human fizz", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00104-00031849-00032133": "theology neurophysiology respiratory", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00105-00032133-00032412": "physiology get the SPECIAL senses", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00106-00032413-00032614": "skeletal and smooth muscles", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00107-00032616-00032877": "cardiovascular system excretory and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00108-00032878-00033252": "reproductive systems biochemistry an", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00109-00033253-00033501": "introduction to biochemistry and allied", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00110-00033502-00033743": "fields at the molecular cellular and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00111-00033744-00034136": "system level biomolecules enzymology", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00112-00034137-00034374": "metabolism and specialization in the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00113-00034375-00034658": "tissues immunology biochemical genetics", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00114-00034659-00034983": "second phase the phase two was designed", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00115-00034984-00035177": "to provide as broad and exposure", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00116-00035178-00035433": "scientific fundamentals and to various", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00117-00035434-00035670": "facets of research areas and basic", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00118-00035671-00036039": "concepts as possible each chosen subject", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00119-00036040-00036246": "matter was spread over three to five", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00120-00036247-00036496": "weeks and included lectures tutorials", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00121-00036497-00036812": "discussion sessions and labs", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00122-00036813-00037110": "biomathematics differentiation and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00123-00037111-00037346": "integration partial differentiation", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00124-00037347-00037620": "equations special functions integral", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00125-00037621-00038024": "transforms biostatistics measures of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00126-00038025-00038246": "location and dispersion sampling", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00127-00038247-00038526": "probability statistical distribution", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00128-00038527-00038774": "tests of significance correlation and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00129-00038775-00039168": "regression analysis of variance chemical", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00130-00039169-00039486": "basis of biology concept in organic and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00131-00039487-00039732": "physical chemistry nature of bonds", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00132-00039733-00039971": "non-bonded interactions quantum", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00133-00039972-00040398": "chemistry physical basis of biology laws", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00134-00040399-00040696": "of inertia gravitation relativity", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00135-00040697-00041027": "electrodynamics quantum physics", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00136-00041028-00041264": "biochemical basis of biology", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00137-00041265-00041540": "organization of genes viruses and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00138-00041541-00041795": "plasmids biochemical evolution the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00139-00041796-00042132": "organization of DNA replication the code", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00140-00042133-00042399": "molecular basis of differentiation and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00141-00042400-00042787": "morphogenesis molecular basis of cancer", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00142-00042788-00043139": "biophysical basis of biology principles", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00143-00043140-00043287": "of structure and function of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00144-00043288-00043545": "macromolecules nucleic acids and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00145-00043546-00043854": "proteins small molecules organization of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00146-00043855-00044087": "macromolecular assemblies lipids and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00147-00044088-00044358": "membranes phase diagrams structure", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00148-00044359-00044643": "activity relationships in drugs computer", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00149-00044644-00044982": "modeling principles of genetics and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00150-00044983-00045224": "evolution heredity and variation", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00151-00045225-00045501": "multifactorial inheritance molecular", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00152-00045502-00045907": "genetics chromosomal disorders", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00153-00045908-00046245": "pharmacology microbiology and pathology", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00154-00046246-00046617": "concepts instrumentation and techniques", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00155-00046618-00046793": "in Experimental Biology", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00156-00046794-00047064": "principles of animal care and aesthetic", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00157-00047065-00047315": "agents surgical skills perfusion", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00158-00047316-00047618": "techniques experimental design by OSA", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00159-00047619-00047795": "techniques", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00160-00047796-00048115": "ecology and environmental biology types", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00161-00048116-00048317": "of ecosystem adaptation to the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00162-00048318-00048557": "environment physiological changes in", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00163-00048558-00048985": "response to hypo hyperthermia in humans", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00164-00048986-00049252": "reproductive biology and experimental", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00165-00049253-00049499": "endocrinology the endocrinology of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00166-00049500-00049757": "reproduction human contraceptives the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00167-00049758-00049976": "animal models for studying hormonal", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00168-00049977-00050377": "control of reproduction bioenergetics", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00169-00050378-00050674": "and bio cybernetics basic thermodynamics", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00170-00050675-00050942": "chemical kinetics far from equilibrium", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00171-00050943-00051173": "thermodynamics introduction to bio", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00172-00051174-00051563": "cybernetics techniques in experimental", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00173-00051564-00051787": "biochemistry colorimetry", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00174-00051788-00052037": "spectrophotometry spectrofluorometer e", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00175-00052038-00052348": "pH determination gel electrophoresis", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00176-00052349-00052579": "chromatography third phase the third", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00177-00052580-00052855": "year was devoted to specialization in a", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00178-00052857-00053128": "chosen field of anatomy biochemistry", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00179-00053129-00053537": "biophysics Physiology or pharmacology it", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00180-00053538-00053762": "involved in depth instruction in the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00181-00053763-00053996": "chosen field reviews of relevant", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00182-00053997-00054244": "research literature seminars and term", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00183-00054245-00054587": "papers since the first phase of the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00184-00054588-00054805": "course work was executed together with", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00185-00054807-00055040": "the incoming class of medical students", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00186-00055041-00055241": "this program was unique in its", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00187-00055241-00055567": "similarity to the present-day MD PhD", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00188-00055569-00055916": "programs in US universities the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00189-00055916-00056194": "experience of this unique program format", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00190-00056195-00056471": "has inspired similar programs at j-word", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00191-00056472-00056733": "in pure and Singapore", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00192-00056734-00057120": "history the first class graduated in", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00193-00057121-00057507": "1983 however with the establishment of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00194-00057508-00057950": "new masters level programs such as MSC", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00195-00057951-00058284": "biotechnology in 1986 and the shifting", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00196-00058285-00058539": "focus of the Institute in late 80s and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00197-00058540-00058794": "early 90s the undergraduate human", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00198-00058795-00059084": "biology program lost its core support", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00199-00059085-00059415": "the last batch of students was accepted", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00200-00059416-00059772": "for this course in 2002 several", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00201-00059773-00059991": "components of the second phase are now", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00202-00059991-00060329": "incorporated into the MSC or in biotech", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00203-00060330-00060929": "curriculum at a IIM s topic BSC honours", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00204-00060930-00061260": "human biology at University of Sri je", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00205-00061261-00061571": "warden pura no G goda sri lanka since", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00206-00061572-00061967": "1994 BSC human biology degree program", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00207-00061969-00062298": "was initiated in 1994 at the faulty of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00208-00062299-00062520": "Medical Sciences with the intention of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00209-00062521-00062727": "fulfilling the need to provide human", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00210-00062728-00062913": "resources for medical and health", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00211-00062914-00063129": "sciences faculties to those departments", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00212-00063129-00063426": "finding it difficult to recruit MBBS", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00213-00063427-00063602": "graduates with practical skills", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00214-00063603-00063900": "specially intended for pharmacy medical", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00215-00063901-00064119": "laboratory technology and medical", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00216-00064120-00064454": "laboratory sciences courses also to", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00217-00064455-00064701": "provide research institutes private", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00218-00064702-00064965": "sector institutions involved in food and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00219-00064966-00065190": "nutrition public and private sector", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00220-00065191-00065397": "diagnostic institutions and health", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00221-00065398-00065604": "policy making institutions with", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00222-00065605-00065847": "individuals with necessary knowledge and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00223-00065848-00066126": "skills the human biology special degree", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00224-00066127-00066414": "course involves 3.5 nine-and-a-half", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00225-00066415-00066690": "terms years of study in the Faculty of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00226-00066691-00066948": "Medical Sciences and comprises three", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00227-00066949-00067347": "parts similar to the program at AI IMS", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00228-00067348-00067650": "human biology students follow the part 1", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00229-00067651-00067878": "and part 2 of their degree course with", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00230-00067879-00068202": "the medical undergraduates part 1 and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00231-00068203-00068499": "part 2 comprise 12 units from anatomy", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00232-00068500-00068811": "physiology biochemistry and four units", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00233-00068812-00069104": "from general pathology parasitology", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00234-00069105-00069308": "microbiology and pharmacology", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00235-00069309-00069672": "respectively part 3 of the course as the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00236-00069673-00069930": "specialization year in a chosen field", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00237-00069931-00070088": "biochemistry food", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00238-00070089-00070388": "nutrition microbiology genetics", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00239-00070389-00070641": "pharmacology or microbiology the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00240-00070642-00070838": "curriculum is designed so that the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00241-00070839-00071075": "students are exposed to gain advanced", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00242-00071076-00071815": "knowledge in the selected specialization", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00243-00071816-00072229": "topic vs human biology at Katmandu", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00244-00072230-00072980": "university Nepal since 2006", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00245-00072981-00073313": "Katmandu University initiated human", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00246-00073314-00074047": "biology course since 2006", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00247-00074048-00074431": "topic BS life sciences at National", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00248-00074432-00074957": "University of Singapore", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00249-00074958-00075287": "bs life sciences at National University", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00250-00075288-00075885": "of Singapore", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00251-00075886-00076587": "topic Australia and New Zealand", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00252-00076588-00076880": "topic v biomed Sookie Bachelor of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00253-00076881-00077150": "biomedical sciences at University of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00254-00077151-00077511": "Otago Christchurch since 2002 a degree", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00255-00077512-00077817": "in biomedical sciences be bio med ski at", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00256-00077818-00078056": "Otago as complementary to traditional", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00257-00078057-00078461": "discipline-based majors eg anatomy", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00258-00078462-00078791": "biochemistry genetics human nutrition", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00259-00078792-00079063": "microbiology pharmacology physiology", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00260-00079064-00079313": "currently offered within The Bachelor of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00261-00079314-00079643": "Science BSC degree but allows a wider", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00262-00079644-00079893": "diversity of health-related papers to be", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00263-00079894-00080212": "taken YouTube it provides a suitable", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00264-00080213-00080468": "qualification for graduate entry into", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00265-00080469-00080663": "medicine and other professional health", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00266-00080664-00080912": "science programs as well as increasing", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00267-00080913-00081110": "the range of career opportunities", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00268-00081111-00081486": "accessible to graduates this degree aims", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00269-00081487-00081741": "at producing graduates with a sound and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00270-00081742-00081932": "comprehensive grounding in the key", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00271-00081933-00082118": "principles underpinning modern", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00272-00082119-00082353": "biological and medical research and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00273-00082354-00082536": "their potential applications in", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00274-00082537-00082884": "biotechnology students completing the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00275-00082885-00083121": "first year health sciences course will", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00276-00083122-00083351": "have met the requirements to advance to", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00277-00083352-00083574": "200 level in the biomedical sciences", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00278-00083575-00083942": "degree the degree structure is of a", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00279-00083943-00084171": "standard three year bachelor's degree", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00280-00084172-00084429": "program enabling students to graduate", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00281-00084430-00084672": "with a Bachelor of biomedical science", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00282-00084673-00084996": "degree biomedical sciences as a", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00283-00084997-00085199": "combination of subject areas that", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00284-00085200-00085467": "promotes understanding of the scientific", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00285-00085468-00085772": "basis of health and disease in humans", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00286-00085773-00085982": "students have the opportunity of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00287-00085983-00086243": "majoring in one of six subject areas", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00288-00086244-00086432": "offered drugs and human health", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00289-00086433-00086721": "functional human biology infection and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00290-00086722-00086975": "immunity molecular basis of health and", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00291-00086976-00087228": "disease nutrition and metabolism in", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00292-00087229-00087407": "human health reproduction", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00293-00087408-00087753": "genetics and development a postgraduate", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00294-00087754-00088041": "honours degree in biomedical sciences is", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00295-00088042-00088254": "also available to students who have", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00296-00088255-00088473": "completed the requirements for the B bio", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00297-00088474-00088700": "mickie degree with an average grade of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00298-00088701-00088937": "at least B+ for the appropriate", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00299-00088938-00089605": "300-level papers", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00300-00089606-00090001": "topic Bachelor of human biology honors", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00301-00090002-00090692": "University of Auckland New Zealand", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00302-00090693-00091020": "you", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00303-00091021-00091313": "topic programs at Australian", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00304-00091314-00091752": "universities", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00305-00091753-00092069": "Bachelor of Science major human biology", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00306-00092070-00092376": "University of Notre Dame", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00307-00092377-00092607": "Bachelor of Applied Science Chinese", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00308-00092608-00092856": "medicine Bachelor of Applied Science", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00309-00092857-00093102": "human biology Royal Melbourne Institute", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00310-00093103-00093497": "of Technology University RMIT", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00311-00093498-00093837": "Bachelor of Science human biology Edith", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00312-00093838-00094197": "Cowan University Bachelor of Science", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00313-00094198-00094437": "human biology preclinical Curtin", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00314-00094438-00094776": "University of Technology Bachelor of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00315-00094777-00095018": "Applied Science in human biology", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00316-00095019-00095364": "University of Canberra Bachelor of", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00317-00095365-00095630": "Science anatomy and human biology", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00318-00095631-00096293": "University of Western Australia", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00319-00096294-00096891": "topic united kingdom", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00320-00096892-00097106": "British universities are at the", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00321-00097107-00097334": "forefront of providing a broad-based", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00322-00097335-00097550": "undergraduate curriculum in all major", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00323-00097551-00097784": "aspects of human biology although", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00324-00097785-00098107": "courses differ widely in their emphasis", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00325-00098108-00098438": "for example sheffield hallam combines", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00326-00098439-00098684": "Business Studies - Biosciences", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00327-00098685-00098996": "healthcare and pharmaceutical sciences", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00328-00098997-00099431": "BSC honours human biology at Kingston", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00329-00099432-00099926": "University BSC honours human biology at", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00330-00099927-00100268": "Queen Margaret University ba", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00331-00100269-00100625": "B SC honors human biology and psychology", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00332-00100626-00101035": "at University of Hartford chur B SC", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00333-00101036-00101351": "honors anatomy and human biology at", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00334-00101352-00101900": "University of Liverpool BSC human bio", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00335-00101901-00102247": "Sciences at roehampton university London", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00336-00102248-00102767": "B SC human bio Sciences at Northumbria", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00337-00102768-00103238": "University Newcastle BSC honours human", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00338-00103239-00103640": "biology at Sheffield Hallam University B", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00339-00103641-00104090": "SC honors human Biosciences at Plymouth", "QFZ2I5prUyu-00340-00104091-00104315": "University"}}, {"audio_id": "QGas_7-X4jk", "text": {"QGas_7-X4jk-00000-00000527-00000782": "and with those words i would like to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00001-00000783-00000927": "once again thank you everyone for", "QGas_7-X4jk-00002-00000927-00001079": "joining and welcome the participants and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00003-00001080-00001527": "give the word to marina and lara", "QGas_7-X4jk-00004-00001528-00001751": "thank you elasmus", "QGas_7-X4jk-00005-00001752-00001839": "so", "QGas_7-X4jk-00006-00001839-00002151": "welcome to our presentation um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00007-00002152-00002439": "i'm marina bruna and i present today", "QGas_7-X4jk-00008-00002440-00002718": "with my colleague laura", "QGas_7-X4jk-00009-00002719-00002983": "and the research findings of our eu", "QGas_7-X4jk-00010-00002984-00003166": "project inclusive", "QGas_7-X4jk-00011-00003167-00003343": "with the name stronger together towards", "QGas_7-X4jk-00012-00003344-00003503": "inclusive student engagement of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00013-00003504-00003686": "non-traditional students in professional", "QGas_7-X4jk-00014-00003688-00004183": "higher education", "QGas_7-X4jk-00015-00004184-00004270": "so", "QGas_7-X4jk-00016-00004271-00004583": "to talk about our structure um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00017-00004584-00004791": "first of all i want to introduce our", "QGas_7-X4jk-00018-00004792-00005063": "team to you then the inclusive project", "QGas_7-X4jk-00019-00005064-00005351": "our research focus and methodology the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00020-00005352-00005631": "research findings give you an outlook", "QGas_7-X4jk-00021-00005632-00005831": "and show you our next steps because we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00022-00005832-00006086": "have a lot planned for the future and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00023-00006087-00006527": "then we have some time for discussion", "QGas_7-X4jk-00024-00006528-00006798": "so who are we we are", "QGas_7-X4jk-00025-00006800-00006975": "a group of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00026-00006976-00007198": "researchers from the corporate state", "QGas_7-X4jk-00027-00007200-00007327": "university", "QGas_7-X4jk-00028-00007328-00007470": "bob ruttenberg", "QGas_7-X4jk-00029-00007472-00007670": "maybe to say so we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00030-00007672-00007919": "speak english in this presentation but", "QGas_7-X4jk-00031-00007920-00008407": "you can also ask questions in german and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00032-00008408-00008646": "we are working together with", "QGas_7-X4jk-00033-00008647-00008831": "ulf daniel elas", "QGas_7-X4jk-00034-00008832-00009046": "in the area education management and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00035-00009047-00009214": "lifelong learning", "QGas_7-X4jk-00036-00009215-00009471": "and our focus are primarily on", "QGas_7-X4jk-00037-00009472-00009646": "transformation of educational", "QGas_7-X4jk-00038-00009647-00009935": "organizations and processes teaching and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00039-00009936-00010231": "learning and lifelong learning processes", "QGas_7-X4jk-00040-00010232-00010519": "in and digitized world", "QGas_7-X4jk-00041-00010520-00010703": "and we also have", "QGas_7-X4jk-00042-00010704-00010999": "different projects um for on the future", "QGas_7-X4jk-00043-00011000-00011271": "of higher education on a national or", "QGas_7-X4jk-00044-00011272-00011583": "european level and you can find our", "QGas_7-X4jk-00045-00011584-00011823": "finances i see laura already posted it", "QGas_7-X4jk-00046-00011824-00012031": "on our next education website and you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00047-00012032-00012599": "have an overview of all our projects", "QGas_7-X4jk-00048-00012600-00012783": "to talk a little bit more about our", "QGas_7-X4jk-00049-00012784-00013279": "project so um uh one basement of our uh", "QGas_7-X4jk-00050-00013280-00013463": "studies are the next skills that is", "QGas_7-X4jk-00051-00013463-00013799": "conducted by of daniel elas you can also", "QGas_7-X4jk-00052-00013800-00013927": "download", "QGas_7-X4jk-00053-00013928-00014083": "them on", "QGas_7-X4jk-00054-00014084-00014327": "nextskills.org and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00055-00014328-00014638": "based on this research we started", "QGas_7-X4jk-00056-00014640-00014879": "a global future skill project laura will", "QGas_7-X4jk-00057-00014880-00015079": "also tell you something about this later", "QGas_7-X4jk-00058-00015080-00015183": "on", "QGas_7-X4jk-00059-00015184-00015350": "or at least where you can find the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00060-00015351-00015575": "information and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00061-00015576-00015935": "we have two we have two um podcasts one", "QGas_7-X4jk-00062-00015936-00016166": "is next normal we study at home and the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00063-00016168-00016375": "other is uh studium in shutdown", "QGas_7-X4jk-00064-00016376-00016543": "yesterday", "QGas_7-X4jk-00065-00016544-00016775": "and these two podcasts were developed", "QGas_7-X4jk-00066-00016776-00017015": "during the corona pandemic to give us a", "QGas_7-X4jk-00067-00017016-00017286": "student perspective how it is to study", "QGas_7-X4jk-00068-00017287-00017422": "at home and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00069-00017423-00017567": "what would change and we also have a", "QGas_7-X4jk-00070-00017568-00017871": "talk about uh this so maybe you will", "QGas_7-X4jk-00071-00017872-00018063": "also want to join that talk but laura", "QGas_7-X4jk-00072-00018064-00018327": "will also tell you about this later and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00073-00018328-00018694": "we have various eu projects and um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00074-00018695-00018967": "also one project with regional funding", "QGas_7-X4jk-00075-00018968-00019327": "and this project today is one of our eu", "QGas_7-X4jk-00076-00019328-00019583": "projects", "QGas_7-X4jk-00077-00019584-00019871": "yeah what marina announced also hello to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00078-00019872-00020039": "everybody happy to be here at the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00079-00020040-00020230": "university future festival my name is", "QGas_7-X4jk-00080-00020231-00020399": "laura aikman and i'm also a member of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00081-00020400-00020630": "the next education research team and a", "QGas_7-X4jk-00082-00020631-00020822": "dear colleague of marina and we're", "QGas_7-X4jk-00083-00020823-00021030": "really excited to present to you the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00084-00021031-00021230": "findings of our first inclusive report", "QGas_7-X4jk-00085-00021231-00021494": "today but as announced you can see more", "QGas_7-X4jk-00086-00021495-00021686": "of the team and of our research that", "QGas_7-X4jk-00087-00021687-00021943": "we're doing so just after this session", "QGas_7-X4jk-00088-00021944-00022150": "today we have another session which will", "QGas_7-X4jk-00089-00022151-00022399": "be about findings from our podcast", "QGas_7-X4jk-00090-00022400-00022686": "sessions uh we did some research on that", "QGas_7-X4jk-00091-00022687-00022767": "and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00092-00022768-00022894": "some findings", "QGas_7-X4jk-00093-00022895-00023078": "higher education from a student's point", "QGas_7-X4jk-00094-00023079-00023278": "of view tomorrow there will be a session", "QGas_7-X4jk-00095-00023279-00023486": "on future skills self-assessment and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00096-00023487-00023686": "also as marina announced we are", "QGas_7-X4jk-00097-00023687-00023863": "introducing our new project the global", "QGas_7-X4jk-00098-00023864-00024071": "future skills project looking for", "QGas_7-X4jk-00099-00024072-00024319": "exciting uh future skills approaches", "QGas_7-X4jk-00100-00024320-00024527": "from all over the world so uh happy to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00101-00024528-00024663": "have you there at the lightning talk", "QGas_7-X4jk-00102-00024664-00024983": "session and wolf will be at the meet the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00103-00024984-00025150": "author's session on", "QGas_7-X4jk-00104-00025151-00025503": "thursday to see you there so i'll hand", "QGas_7-X4jk-00105-00025504-00025743": "back to marina or we're actually handing", "QGas_7-X4jk-00106-00025744-00025902": "back to all of you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00107-00025904-00026158": "yeah because we thought we should maybe", "QGas_7-X4jk-00108-00026160-00026358": "make our introduction a little bit", "QGas_7-X4jk-00109-00026360-00026599": "interactive so we have a question for", "QGas_7-X4jk-00110-00026600-00026743": "you um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00111-00026744-00026999": "maybe you can answer when have you not", "QGas_7-X4jk-00112-00027000-00027183": "felt like an integrational part of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00113-00027183-00027446": "student community or when your studying", "QGas_7-X4jk-00114-00027447-00027670": "time is a little bit far away maybe you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00115-00027672-00027935": "observed someone else not feeling part", "QGas_7-X4jk-00116-00027936-00028207": "of it and our question is what was the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00117-00028208-00028414": "reason for that so what is the reason", "QGas_7-X4jk-00118-00028416-00028631": "that someone don't feel like a part of a", "QGas_7-X4jk-00119-00028632-00028895": "student community and to answer that we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00120-00028895-00029087": "thought maybe you can give us your", "QGas_7-X4jk-00121-00029088-00029311": "answers in our mentimeter you can on the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00122-00029312-00029574": "one side scan the code the query code or", "QGas_7-X4jk-00123-00029575-00029870": "you can follow the link that we post in", "QGas_7-X4jk-00124-00029872-00030135": "the chat laura maybe or i can also post", "QGas_7-X4jk-00125-00030136-00030479": "it in the chat", "QGas_7-X4jk-00126-00030480-00030711": "or you go to mendy.com and insert the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00127-00030712-00030895": "code", "QGas_7-X4jk-00128-00030895-00031055": "and we'll give you a few seconds to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00129-00031056-00031174": "think about", "QGas_7-X4jk-00130-00031175-00031374": "like uh yeah when you have not felt like", "QGas_7-X4jk-00131-00031375-00031502": "an integral part of the student", "QGas_7-X4jk-00132-00031503-00031758": "community and what were the reasons for", "QGas_7-X4jk-00133-00031760-00032014": "it or uh when you have observed somebody", "QGas_7-X4jk-00134-00032016-00032111": "else", "QGas_7-X4jk-00135-00032112-00032343": "not feeling like it and we will display", "QGas_7-X4jk-00136-00032344-00032614": "the results in", "QGas_7-X4jk-00137-00032616-00032815": "a couple of moments give you a little", "QGas_7-X4jk-00138-00032816-00033583": "time to think", "QGas_7-X4jk-00139-00033584-00033831": "okay i will already check if somebody", "QGas_7-X4jk-00140-00033832-00033999": "has", "QGas_7-X4jk-00141-00034000-00034246": "contributed okay so here we have the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00142-00034247-00034431": "first answer which is not living on", "QGas_7-X4jk-00143-00034432-00035055": "campus", "QGas_7-X4jk-00144-00035056-00035239": "being a parent and studies elder", "QGas_7-X4jk-00145-00035240-00036295": "students", "QGas_7-X4jk-00146-00036296-00037751": "being a first semester student", "QGas_7-X4jk-00147-00037752-00038055": "of course we have some coronavirus", "QGas_7-X4jk-00148-00038056-00038527": "influence here as well fern only", "QGas_7-X4jk-00149-00038528-00038743": "studies", "QGas_7-X4jk-00150-00038744-00039118": "okay", "QGas_7-X4jk-00151-00039119-00039271": "ah that's i think that's also just an", "QGas_7-X4jk-00152-00039272-00039567": "education i think where you get student", "QGas_7-X4jk-00153-00039568-00040151": "okay", "QGas_7-X4jk-00154-00040152-00040479": "so you you can feel free to uh answer", "QGas_7-X4jk-00155-00040480-00040559": "this", "QGas_7-X4jk-00156-00040560-00040735": "question also during tip maybe we can", "QGas_7-X4jk-00157-00040736-00040943": "have a look at it later on", "QGas_7-X4jk-00158-00040944-00041046": "yes", "QGas_7-X4jk-00159-00041047-00041199": "so just little", "QGas_7-X4jk-00160-00041200-00041295": "what", "QGas_7-X4jk-00161-00041296-00041367": "oh", "QGas_7-X4jk-00162-00041368-00041543": "get some movement", "QGas_7-X4jk-00163-00041544-00041767": "yeah leftist opinions okay so politics", "QGas_7-X4jk-00164-00041768-00042007": "might be a subject as well and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00165-00042008-00042246": "somebody being more critical on topics", "QGas_7-X4jk-00166-00042247-00042439": "or chronic illness so there's some", "QGas_7-X4jk-00167-00042440-00042607": "topics that we will find also in our", "QGas_7-X4jk-00168-00042608-00042815": "report so thanks for contributing and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00169-00042816-00042974": "feel free to contribute more because we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00170-00042975-00043302": "can maybe have a look at it later again", "QGas_7-X4jk-00171-00043303-00043743": "so um back to you marina", "QGas_7-X4jk-00172-00043744-00043958": "okay so thank you for that i think you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00173-00043959-00044223": "got an idea what we are talking about", "QGas_7-X4jk-00174-00044224-00044423": "when we talk about student uh", "QGas_7-X4jk-00175-00044424-00044615": "communities and this is what our project", "QGas_7-X4jk-00176-00044616-00044879": "inclusive is about so first of all what", "QGas_7-X4jk-00177-00044880-00045143": "means inclusive inclusive means", "QGas_7-X4jk-00178-00045144-00045343": "inclusive student engagement of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00179-00045344-00045511": "non-traditional students in professional", "QGas_7-X4jk-00180-00045512-00045711": "higher education so in the beginning", "QGas_7-X4jk-00181-00045712-00045999": "this is first of all a lot of words we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00182-00046000-00046302": "maybe have to explain so first of all we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00183-00046303-00046479": "want to explain professional higher", "QGas_7-X4jk-00184-00046480-00046751": "education institutions so our university", "QGas_7-X4jk-00185-00046752-00046958": "the corporate state university of ban", "QGas_7-X4jk-00186-00046959-00047199": "vimback for example is a professional", "QGas_7-X4jk-00187-00047200-00047446": "higher education university", "QGas_7-X4jk-00188-00047447-00047567": "and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00189-00047568-00047751": "professional higher education institutes", "QGas_7-X4jk-00190-00047752-00048086": "focus more on um authentical practical", "QGas_7-X4jk-00191-00048087-00048351": "experience for example we have a dual", "QGas_7-X4jk-00192-00048352-00048623": "study modern uh model where", "QGas_7-X4jk-00193-00048624-00048911": "our turning territory and practice", "QGas_7-X4jk-00194-00048912-00049239": "phases rotate so the students are three", "QGas_7-X4jk-00195-00049240-00049446": "months in university and then they work", "QGas_7-X4jk-00196-00049447-00049711": "with their business partner um three", "QGas_7-X4jk-00197-00049712-00049935": "months outside of university so that", "QGas_7-X4jk-00198-00049936-00050102": "they can integrate what they learned", "QGas_7-X4jk-00199-00050103-00050423": "already in their practical working life", "QGas_7-X4jk-00200-00050424-00050702": "and student models like this attract a", "QGas_7-X4jk-00201-00050703-00050990": "very diverse range of students", "QGas_7-X4jk-00202-00050991-00051214": "one reason for this is you earn money", "QGas_7-X4jk-00203-00051215-00051414": "besides studying and this is really", "QGas_7-X4jk-00204-00051415-00051575": "attracting for a lot of people who maybe", "QGas_7-X4jk-00205-00051576-00051758": "cannot finance just studying by", "QGas_7-X4jk-00206-00051759-00051894": "themselves", "QGas_7-X4jk-00207-00051895-00052046": "so um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00208-00052047-00052190": "professional higher education", "QGas_7-X4jk-00209-00052191-00052487": "institutions have the um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00210-00052488-00052847": "the the big task to include these people", "QGas_7-X4jk-00211-00052848-00053063": "we when we talk about these diverse", "QGas_7-X4jk-00212-00053064-00053254": "students we talk about non-traditional", "QGas_7-X4jk-00213-00053255-00053479": "students so students who will probably", "QGas_7-X4jk-00214-00053479-00053630": "not", "QGas_7-X4jk-00215-00053632-00053919": "are the minority in normal higher", "QGas_7-X4jk-00216-00053920-00054103": "education institutions", "QGas_7-X4jk-00217-00054104-00054254": "and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00218-00054255-00054463": "to for professional higher education to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00219-00054464-00054663": "be as inclusive as possible the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00220-00054664-00054838": "non-traditional students need to be", "QGas_7-X4jk-00221-00054839-00055159": "visible so they must be seen and their", "QGas_7-X4jk-00222-00055160-00055471": "needs must be heard and the problem is", "QGas_7-X4jk-00223-00055472-00055742": "that many of these needs are not", "QGas_7-X4jk-00224-00055744-00055959": "represented anywhere", "QGas_7-X4jk-00225-00055960-00056238": "and one way for non-traditional students", "QGas_7-X4jk-00226-00056239-00056471": "to be visible is to participate in", "QGas_7-X4jk-00227-00056472-00056679": "student organizations so student", "QGas_7-X4jk-00228-00056679-00056823": "organizations", "QGas_7-X4jk-00229-00056824-00057063": "represent the study study body of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00230-00057064-00057271": "institutions and sometimes they are also", "QGas_7-X4jk-00231-00057272-00057526": "called the voice of the students so it's", "QGas_7-X4jk-00232-00057527-00057647": "really important for these", "QGas_7-X4jk-00233-00057648-00057863": "non-traditional students that they are a", "QGas_7-X4jk-00234-00057864-00058191": "part of the student communities", "QGas_7-X4jk-00235-00058191-00058503": "so and this is what inclusive is aiming", "QGas_7-X4jk-00236-00058504-00058775": "for so the inclusive project intends to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00237-00058776-00058991": "contribute to a more inclusive student", "QGas_7-X4jk-00238-00058991-00059223": "environment by raising awareness for", "QGas_7-X4jk-00239-00059224-00059415": "full student inclusion and providing", "QGas_7-X4jk-00240-00059416-00059623": "professional higher education and their", "QGas_7-X4jk-00241-00059624-00059863": "student organizations with concrete", "QGas_7-X4jk-00242-00059864-00060206": "ideas tool and guidance on how to make", "QGas_7-X4jk-00243-00060207-00060559": "student engagement fully exclusive", "QGas_7-X4jk-00244-00060560-00060911": "inclusive sorry", "QGas_7-X4jk-00245-00060912-00061279": "so um to see so we started this project", "QGas_7-X4jk-00246-00061279-00061647": "uh in january so and we did a lot of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00247-00061648-00061791": "different research steps in the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00248-00061791-00061959": "beginning we identified the different", "QGas_7-X4jk-00249-00061960-00062142": "types of non-traditional students so", "QGas_7-X4jk-00250-00062144-00062366": "about who are we talking at the moment", "QGas_7-X4jk-00251-00062367-00062647": "um then we identified the challenges and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00252-00062648-00062942": "barriers we identified best practices", "QGas_7-X4jk-00253-00062944-00063215": "for inclusive student engagement we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00254-00063216-00063503": "talked about the different dimensions um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00255-00063504-00063663": "we also collected a different", "QGas_7-X4jk-00256-00063664-00063894": "perspective so we talked with", "QGas_7-X4jk-00257-00063895-00064111": "students we talked with students", "QGas_7-X4jk-00258-00064112-00064454": "councils we talked with professors with", "QGas_7-X4jk-00259-00064455-00064742": "a very broad target group to get as many", "QGas_7-X4jk-00260-00064744-00064942": "different perspectives as possible and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00261-00064944-00065254": "we also try to adapt some ideas from", "QGas_7-X4jk-00262-00065255-00065703": "product society", "QGas_7-X4jk-00263-00065704-00065999": "so who are we we are eight different", "QGas_7-X4jk-00264-00066000-00066311": "partners uh in europe we have partners", "QGas_7-X4jk-00265-00066312-00066638": "in spain belgium um and croatia and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00266-00066639-00066847": "malta and in germany", "QGas_7-X4jk-00267-00066848-00067071": "and we have on one side these", "QGas_7-X4jk-00268-00067072-00067294": "professional higher education institutes", "QGas_7-X4jk-00269-00067295-00067582": "like ourselves and we have um these", "QGas_7-X4jk-00270-00067583-00067703": "international", "QGas_7-X4jk-00271-00067704-00067879": "organizations like the european", "QGas_7-X4jk-00272-00067880-00068071": "association of institutions in higher", "QGas_7-X4jk-00273-00068072-00068367": "education urushi or the european student", "QGas_7-X4jk-00274-00068368-00068703": "union is to give us this broader", "QGas_7-X4jk-00275-00068704-00068863": "student perspective and this", "QGas_7-X4jk-00276-00068864-00069150": "international view", "QGas_7-X4jk-00277-00069151-00069399": "so now i want to give you some", "QGas_7-X4jk-00278-00069400-00069575": "definitions", "QGas_7-X4jk-00279-00069576-00069838": "and some explanations of the terms we're", "QGas_7-X4jk-00280-00069839-00070087": "using for our project", "QGas_7-X4jk-00281-00070088-00070263": "so first of all student engagement", "QGas_7-X4jk-00282-00070264-00070479": "student engagement is a very broad term", "QGas_7-X4jk-00283-00070480-00070767": "so it can be um described as a process", "QGas_7-X4jk-00284-00070768-00070991": "of collaboration between higher", "QGas_7-X4jk-00285-00070992-00071238": "education institutes and students to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00286-00071239-00071423": "shape decision-making structures", "QGas_7-X4jk-00287-00071424-00071638": "cultures in higher education so as you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00288-00071639-00071823": "can see it's a co-creation process", "QGas_7-X4jk-00289-00071824-00072071": "between the students and the institution", "QGas_7-X4jk-00290-00072072-00072223": "and on the right side you can see that", "QGas_7-X4jk-00291-00072224-00072415": "it has many different levels so we have", "QGas_7-X4jk-00292-00072416-00072623": "for example the european student union", "QGas_7-X4jk-00293-00072624-00072719": "that", "QGas_7-X4jk-00294-00072720-00073006": "operates on a really international level", "QGas_7-X4jk-00295-00073007-00073287": "and we also have student engagement on", "QGas_7-X4jk-00296-00073288-00073582": "the course level on a student level", "QGas_7-X4jk-00297-00073583-00073791": "also student engagement can be really", "QGas_7-X4jk-00298-00073792-00073967": "broad so we can have student engagement", "QGas_7-X4jk-00299-00073968-00074159": "and teaching and learning but we want to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00300-00074160-00074406": "talk today about student engagement in", "QGas_7-X4jk-00301-00074407-00074591": "student organizations", "QGas_7-X4jk-00302-00074592-00074823": "and student organizations are traumatic", "QGas_7-X4jk-00303-00074824-00075023": "or political associations of students", "QGas_7-X4jk-00304-00075024-00075238": "who come together in groups outside of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00305-00075239-00075471": "their lectures so we want really not to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00306-00075472-00075711": "talk about a student's", "QGas_7-X4jk-00307-00075712-00075926": "engagement in the classrooms we want to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00308-00075927-00076094": "talk about student engagement outside of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00309-00076095-00076343": "the classroom", "QGas_7-X4jk-00310-00076344-00076550": "and when we talk about non-traditional", "QGas_7-X4jk-00311-00076551-00076679": "students we also have to talk about", "QGas_7-X4jk-00312-00076680-00076926": "diversity because this is the big topic", "QGas_7-X4jk-00313-00076927-00077103": "over these non-traditional students and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00314-00077104-00077391": "in the beginning um we discussed a lot", "QGas_7-X4jk-00315-00077392-00077594": "how do we want to describe", "QGas_7-X4jk-00316-00077595-00077759": "non-traditional students because we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00317-00077760-00077991": "didn't want to label them with one", "QGas_7-X4jk-00318-00077992-00078175": "characteristic and saying this is all", "QGas_7-X4jk-00319-00078176-00078415": "you are and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00320-00078416-00078615": "so we thought maybe we can make it a", "QGas_7-X4jk-00321-00078616-00078911": "little bit more diverse and we use this", "QGas_7-X4jk-00322-00078912-00079199": "diversity wheel um with the different", "QGas_7-X4jk-00323-00079200-00079479": "diversity characteristics on one side um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00324-00079480-00079750": "so we have four different dimensions we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00325-00079751-00079999": "have first the personality so the way a", "QGas_7-X4jk-00326-00080000-00080223": "person interacts we have the internal", "QGas_7-X4jk-00327-00080224-00080415": "dimension um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00328-00080416-00080606": "these are characteristics the individual", "QGas_7-X4jk-00329-00080607-00080815": "cannot self select something like age", "QGas_7-X4jk-00330-00080816-00081143": "gender or sexual orientation so", "QGas_7-X4jk-00331-00081144-00081375": "something you cannot change then we have", "QGas_7-X4jk-00332-00081376-00081535": "the external dimensions these are the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00333-00081536-00081750": "results of life events and decisions", "QGas_7-X4jk-00334-00081751-00082031": "made by your or by your parents for", "QGas_7-X4jk-00335-00082032-00082367": "example your location um or your", "QGas_7-X4jk-00336-00082368-00082550": "religion and then we have this", "QGas_7-X4jk-00337-00082551-00082806": "organizational dimension that includes", "QGas_7-X4jk-00338-00082807-00082950": "elements that are", "QGas_7-X4jk-00339-00082951-00083191": "dependent on the position you have in", "QGas_7-X4jk-00340-00083192-00083399": "the institution for example your field", "QGas_7-X4jk-00341-00083400-00083679": "of study or your duration of studies", "QGas_7-X4jk-00342-00083680-00083799": "so", "QGas_7-X4jk-00343-00083800-00083967": "with this different diversity", "QGas_7-X4jk-00344-00083968-00084215": "characteristics we try to map our", "QGas_7-X4jk-00345-00084216-00084399": "non-traditional students and don't talk", "QGas_7-X4jk-00346-00084400-00084559": "about", "QGas_7-X4jk-00347-00084560-00084767": "them at all but talk about the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00348-00084768-00084991": "characteristics and the barriers that", "QGas_7-X4jk-00349-00084992-00085175": "come with different combinations of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00350-00085176-00085359": "characteristics", "QGas_7-X4jk-00351-00085360-00085615": "so non-traditional students are very", "QGas_7-X4jk-00352-00085616-00086006": "broad term we found many different", "QGas_7-X4jk-00353-00086007-00086294": "definitions but we found one that is", "QGas_7-X4jk-00354-00086295-00086518": "kind of inclusive", "QGas_7-X4jk-00355-00086519-00086775": "and this is um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00356-00086776-00086911": "the three different group", "QGas_7-X4jk-00357-00086912-00087159": "underrepresented students disadvantaged", "QGas_7-X4jk-00358-00087160-00087462": "touch students and vulnerable students", "QGas_7-X4jk-00359-00087463-00087662": "um i want to start at the top so the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00360-00087663-00087903": "under percentage students", "QGas_7-X4jk-00361-00087904-00088111": "are students that are underrepresented", "QGas_7-X4jk-00362-00088112-00088399": "in relation to different characteristics", "QGas_7-X4jk-00363-00088400-00088615": "and for example gender", "QGas_7-X4jk-00364-00088616-00088799": "and they are really", "QGas_7-X4jk-00365-00088800-00089094": "context dependent so you can be", "QGas_7-X4jk-00366-00089095-00089287": "underrepresented in", "QGas_7-X4jk-00367-00089288-00089567": "some contexts for example as a female", "QGas_7-X4jk-00368-00089568-00089767": "gender in", "QGas_7-X4jk-00369-00089768-00089982": "ict class where", "QGas_7-X4jk-00370-00089983-00090175": "most of the other students are male", "QGas_7-X4jk-00371-00090176-00090318": "gender", "QGas_7-X4jk-00372-00090319-00090487": "but as a male", "QGas_7-X4jk-00373-00090488-00090711": "gender you can also be underrepresented", "QGas_7-X4jk-00374-00090712-00090879": "for example in education management", "QGas_7-X4jk-00375-00090880-00091126": "where there are more people with female", "QGas_7-X4jk-00376-00091127-00091238": "gender", "QGas_7-X4jk-00377-00091239-00091415": "and then we have the disadvantaged", "QGas_7-X4jk-00378-00091416-00091615": "students these are students who face", "QGas_7-X4jk-00379-00091616-00091815": "specific challenges because of their", "QGas_7-X4jk-00380-00091816-00092038": "characteristics for example students", "QGas_7-X4jk-00381-00092039-00092303": "with disabilities or financial problems", "QGas_7-X4jk-00382-00092304-00092518": "or mental health issues", "QGas_7-X4jk-00383-00092519-00092679": "and um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00384-00092680-00092855": "these are", "QGas_7-X4jk-00385-00092856-00093006": "sometimes also", "QGas_7-X4jk-00386-00093007-00093335": "temporal issues so you can be um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00387-00093336-00093526": "for example mental health during corona", "QGas_7-X4jk-00388-00093527-00093694": "we had an in", "QGas_7-X4jk-00389-00093695-00094062": "strong increase in mental health issues", "QGas_7-X4jk-00390-00094063-00094406": "for some students and for them they", "QGas_7-X4jk-00391-00094407-00094606": "became disadvantaged students in the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00392-00094607-00094799": "time in our point of view they became", "QGas_7-X4jk-00393-00094800-00095023": "non-traditional students and then we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00394-00095024-00095359": "have the vulnerable students and they um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00395-00095360-00095615": "also face specific challenges but in", "QGas_7-X4jk-00396-00095616-00095918": "addition they also need protection", "QGas_7-X4jk-00397-00095919-00096238": "because they are not always able to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00398-00096239-00096503": "ensure their own well-being for example", "QGas_7-X4jk-00399-00096504-00096638": "students who are on risk of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00400-00096639-00096806": "discrimination", "QGas_7-X4jk-00401-00096807-00097038": "so with this in mind we created our own", "QGas_7-X4jk-00402-00097039-00097294": "definition um and we said in the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00403-00097295-00097511": "inclusive project context every student", "QGas_7-X4jk-00404-00097512-00097726": "who does not feel like the integration", "QGas_7-X4jk-00405-00097727-00097926": "part of this of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00406-00097927-00098143": "the student and institutional community", "QGas_7-X4jk-00407-00098144-00098374": "and or who due to their specific", "QGas_7-X4jk-00408-00098375-00098574": "circumstances does not have the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00409-00098575-00098799": "opportunity to get involved in student", "QGas_7-X4jk-00410-00098800-00099006": "engagement during their studies as a", "QGas_7-X4jk-00411-00099007-00099303": "non-traditional student even if only to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00412-00099304-00099535": "a small extent and now laura will show", "QGas_7-X4jk-00413-00099536-00099782": "you our research questions", "QGas_7-X4jk-00414-00099783-00099991": "exactly so from this and from also from", "QGas_7-X4jk-00415-00099992-00100199": "the aim of our inclusive project we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00416-00100200-00100399": "derived the questions of what are the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00417-00100400-00100582": "charistics of non-traditional students", "QGas_7-X4jk-00418-00100583-00100911": "and professional higher education but", "QGas_7-X4jk-00419-00100912-00101071": "most importantly what barriers and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00420-00101072-00101318": "challenges do they face particularly in", "QGas_7-X4jk-00421-00101319-00101503": "the area of engagement within students", "QGas_7-X4jk-00422-00101504-00101711": "organizations but also within other", "QGas_7-X4jk-00423-00101712-00101935": "domains of higher education and what", "QGas_7-X4jk-00424-00101936-00102143": "good practices and strategies could help", "QGas_7-X4jk-00425-00102144-00102343": "us to increase the student engagement of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00426-00102344-00102527": "non-traditional students in professional", "QGas_7-X4jk-00427-00102528-00102702": "higher education", "QGas_7-X4jk-00428-00102703-00102982": "so we conducted some research and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00429-00102983-00103175": "i want to briefly show you how we did", "QGas_7-X4jk-00430-00103176-00103366": "that first of all we did some desk", "QGas_7-X4jk-00431-00103367-00103654": "research and based on that we did some", "QGas_7-X4jk-00432-00103655-00103871": "qualitative expert service within the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00433-00103872-00104086": "institutions in our project from germany", "QGas_7-X4jk-00434-00104088-00104318": "croatia belgium spain and malta to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00435-00104319-00104582": "detect like first hint of challenges and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00436-00104583-00104734": "barriers that non-traditional students", "QGas_7-X4jk-00437-00104735-00104975": "might face based on that we did some", "QGas_7-X4jk-00438-00104976-00105223": "focus group research so we did focus", "QGas_7-X4jk-00439-00105224-00105471": "group in institutions of professional", "QGas_7-X4jk-00440-00105472-00105654": "higher education for example at our own", "QGas_7-X4jk-00441-00105655-00105927": "institution but also at the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00442-00105928-00106086": "involved institutions in malta spain", "QGas_7-X4jk-00443-00106088-00106302": "belgium and germany and all over we had", "QGas_7-X4jk-00444-00106303-00106607": "28 experts that participated and then we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00445-00106608-00106775": "also had one international focus group", "QGas_7-X4jk-00446-00106776-00106966": "which has was conducted by the european", "QGas_7-X4jk-00447-00106967-00107127": "students union", "QGas_7-X4jk-00448-00107128-00107375": "and the members that of these focus", "QGas_7-X4jk-00449-00107376-00107534": "groups were either", "QGas_7-X4jk-00450-00107535-00107654": "students with a non-traditional", "QGas_7-X4jk-00451-00107655-00107863": "background or representative of the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00452-00107864-00108086": "student organization they could be have", "QGas_7-X4jk-00453-00108088-00108247": "a professional background as a student", "QGas_7-X4jk-00454-00108248-00108478": "support staff for example counselors or", "QGas_7-X4jk-00455-00108479-00108695": "be a institutional leader", "QGas_7-X4jk-00456-00108696-00108910": "we then analyze the findings and the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00457-00108911-00109215": "material that we found and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00458-00109216-00109390": "clustered them to different diversity", "QGas_7-X4jk-00459-00109391-00109590": "dimensions and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00460-00109591-00109878": "we most importantly we identified", "QGas_7-X4jk-00461-00109879-00110054": "various barriers for non-traditional", "QGas_7-X4jk-00462-00110055-00110190": "students", "QGas_7-X4jk-00463-00110191-00110319": "and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00464-00110320-00110527": "these we want to show you now briefly", "QGas_7-X4jk-00465-00110528-00110743": "and you can have a closer look at it in", "QGas_7-X4jk-00466-00110744-00111143": "our report which is available online so", "QGas_7-X4jk-00467-00111144-00111431": "um before we already collected some in", "QGas_7-X4jk-00468-00111432-00111663": "the mentimeter we collected some hints", "QGas_7-X4jk-00469-00111664-00111790": "and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00470-00111791-00111975": "of course this is not complete or", "QGas_7-X4jk-00471-00111976-00112166": "finished here because as we said like", "QGas_7-X4jk-00472-00112167-00112390": "the the term non-traditional students", "QGas_7-X4jk-00473-00112391-00112519": "it's kind of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00474-00112520-00112695": "moving and it can really be context", "QGas_7-X4jk-00475-00112696-00113031": "dependent so we could name students with", "QGas_7-X4jk-00476-00113032-00113215": "disabilities and migration background", "QGas_7-X4jk-00477-00113216-00113486": "mature students so a bit older than", "QGas_7-X4jk-00478-00113488-00113702": "the average student", "QGas_7-X4jk-00479-00113703-00113871": "as marina said", "QGas_7-X4jk-00480-00113872-00114127": "for example female students in a very", "QGas_7-X4jk-00481-00114128-00114454": "more male-dominated field of studies and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00482-00114455-00114719": "gender identity and sexual orientation", "QGas_7-X4jk-00483-00114720-00114943": "but in the external dimension we have we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00484-00114944-00115102": "might have the socio-economic background", "QGas_7-X4jk-00485-00115103-00115263": "of the parental home", "QGas_7-X4jk-00486-00115264-00115495": "and caretaking responsibilities you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00487-00115496-00115654": "might have the international background", "QGas_7-X4jk-00488-00115655-00115815": "students who have to work", "QGas_7-X4jk-00489-00115816-00115927": "as well", "QGas_7-X4jk-00490-00115928-00116110": "students have an alternative education", "QGas_7-X4jk-00491-00116111-00116319": "path that don't come directly to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00492-00116320-00116519": "university after their a-levels or", "QGas_7-X4jk-00493-00116520-00116807": "re-entering students and of uh what we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00494-00116808-00117015": "really want to stress here is that this", "QGas_7-X4jk-00495-00117016-00117158": "all doesn't mean", "QGas_7-X4jk-00496-00117159-00117351": "that this makes you non-traditional", "QGas_7-X4jk-00497-00117352-00117727": "students but this might mean that you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00498-00117728-00117919": "um you might", "QGas_7-X4jk-00499-00117920-00118134": "face more challenges and barriers for", "QGas_7-X4jk-00500-00118135-00118415": "full um inclusive student engagement", "QGas_7-X4jk-00501-00118416-00118734": "um but we we really saw that we want to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00502-00118735-00118895": "focus on these on the challenges and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00503-00118896-00119207": "barriers and work on these in order to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00504-00119208-00119407": "to really become inclusive", "QGas_7-X4jk-00505-00119408-00119607": "so what we found were that there are", "QGas_7-X4jk-00506-00119608-00119902": "five main problems related to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00507-00119903-00120143": "non-traditional students in relation to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00508-00120144-00120295": "their student engagement for example in", "QGas_7-X4jk-00509-00120296-00120502": "student organizations a time problem", "QGas_7-X4jk-00510-00120503-00120695": "visibility problem identification", "QGas_7-X4jk-00511-00120696-00120910": "problem image problem accessibility", "QGas_7-X4jk-00512-00120911-00121007": "problem", "QGas_7-X4jk-00513-00121008-00121239": "so of course if you if you have to work", "QGas_7-X4jk-00514-00121240-00121375": "in order to finance your studies there", "QGas_7-X4jk-00515-00121376-00121623": "might be less time to get engaged", "QGas_7-X4jk-00516-00121624-00121823": "also if you want to go abroad for", "QGas_7-X4jk-00517-00121824-00122071": "example or do an internship it might be", "QGas_7-X4jk-00518-00122072-00122239": "harder for you to commit to long-term", "QGas_7-X4jk-00519-00122240-00122471": "engagement and there might be a fear of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00520-00122472-00122671": "the workload which is not", "QGas_7-X4jk-00521-00122672-00122863": "compatible with your study workload this", "QGas_7-X4jk-00522-00122864-00123047": "is really true for our students at our", "QGas_7-X4jk-00523-00123048-00123214": "institution because because they have a", "QGas_7-X4jk-00524-00123215-00123454": "very heavy workload already in their", "QGas_7-X4jk-00525-00123455-00123607": "normal studies", "QGas_7-X4jk-00526-00123608-00123695": "there", "QGas_7-X4jk-00527-00123696-00123927": "might be a visibility problem that", "QGas_7-X4jk-00528-00123928-00124127": "student engagement student organizations", "QGas_7-X4jk-00529-00124128-00124295": "they're not really visible or it's not", "QGas_7-X4jk-00530-00124296-00124575": "really clear what they are for and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00531-00124576-00124758": "what they are changing for students and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00532-00124759-00124910": "also about what", "QGas_7-X4jk-00533-00124911-00125110": "students can do in order to get engaged", "QGas_7-X4jk-00534-00125111-00125231": "with them", "QGas_7-X4jk-00535-00125232-00125471": "there might be an identification problem", "QGas_7-X4jk-00536-00125472-00125686": "so that you cannot uh you do not find", "QGas_7-X4jk-00537-00125688-00125910": "that you the organization relates to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00538-00125911-00126102": "your own challenges in everyday life or", "QGas_7-X4jk-00539-00126103-00126414": "identity also on a broader level the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00540-00126415-00126647": "whole institution the way it represents", "QGas_7-X4jk-00541-00126648-00126966": "a self and students of example on in pr", "QGas_7-X4jk-00542-00126967-00127254": "materials it might be very stereotyped", "QGas_7-X4jk-00543-00127255-00127519": "and one dimensional not very diverse", "QGas_7-X4jk-00544-00127520-00127751": "and also there might be", "QGas_7-X4jk-00545-00127752-00127958": "a fear of not having the right skills to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00546-00127959-00128175": "participate in a student organization", "QGas_7-X4jk-00547-00128176-00128334": "this is closely related to an image", "QGas_7-X4jk-00548-00128335-00128534": "which might a student organization might", "QGas_7-X4jk-00549-00128535-00128686": "have", "QGas_7-X4jk-00550-00128688-00128910": "like maybe a student organization might", "QGas_7-X4jk-00551-00128911-00129054": "have the reputation of having a very", "QGas_7-X4jk-00552-00129055-00129239": "heavy drinking culture which is not for", "QGas_7-X4jk-00553-00129240-00129431": "everybody also there might be a", "QGas_7-X4jk-00554-00129432-00129623": "selection and election process for", "QGas_7-X4jk-00555-00129624-00129863": "specific roles which might scare away", "QGas_7-X4jk-00556-00129864-00130254": "some more of the shire students or they", "QGas_7-X4jk-00557-00130255-00130439": "might perceive that there are political", "QGas_7-X4jk-00558-00130440-00130558": "gains being played in student", "QGas_7-X4jk-00559-00130559-00130766": "organizations and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00560-00130767-00130990": "really last but really not least is of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00561-00130991-00131166": "course the accessibility problem so", "QGas_7-X4jk-00562-00131167-00131423": "there might be language barriers um or", "QGas_7-X4jk-00563-00131424-00131683": "mobility barriers to access student", "QGas_7-X4jk-00564-00131684-00131887": "organizations the good", "QGas_7-X4jk-00565-00131888-00132175": "news is that we also could identify some", "QGas_7-X4jk-00566-00132176-00132463": "potentials and ideas to get rid of or to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00567-00132464-00132687": "start to get rid of these barriers and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00568-00132688-00132902": "challenges for students because that's", "QGas_7-X4jk-00569-00132903-00133127": "really our aim that we not only", "QGas_7-X4jk-00570-00133128-00133335": "recognize and find them but also that we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00571-00133336-00133678": "try to to um get rid of them so to offer", "QGas_7-X4jk-00572-00133679-00133871": "a broad range of different participation", "QGas_7-X4jk-00573-00133872-00134078": "opportunities so that everybody can find", "QGas_7-X4jk-00574-00134079-00134375": "something participation to make this a", "QGas_7-X4jk-00575-00134376-00134647": "diversity more visible to create some", "QGas_7-X4jk-00576-00134648-00134823": "support system for different student", "QGas_7-X4jk-00577-00134824-00135031": "needs and also for different engagement", "QGas_7-X4jk-00578-00135032-00135271": "needs to establish more contact points", "QGas_7-X4jk-00579-00135272-00135454": "between student organizations and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00580-00135455-00135719": "non-traditional students to make more", "QGas_7-X4jk-00581-00135720-00135935": "networking between the different levels", "QGas_7-X4jk-00582-00135936-00136127": "of student organizations that we showed", "QGas_7-X4jk-00583-00136128-00136239": "you before", "QGas_7-X4jk-00584-00136240-00136335": "to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00585-00136336-00136671": "also really censor sensible eyes and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00586-00136672-00136847": "inform professionalized teachers for", "QGas_7-X4jk-00587-00136848-00137071": "different student needs to make teaching", "QGas_7-X4jk-00588-00137072-00137319": "and learning also more inclusive but", "QGas_7-X4jk-00589-00137320-00137511": "also to set up some guidelines and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00590-00137512-00137654": "policies and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00591-00137655-00137895": "what we found very promising and there's", "QGas_7-X4jk-00592-00137896-00138214": "already some good examples for is um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00593-00138215-00138454": "the time problem might be tackled by", "QGas_7-X4jk-00594-00138455-00138663": "paying students first student organ", "QGas_7-X4jk-00595-00138664-00138902": "organization student engagement or to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00596-00138903-00139095": "include these in the curricula and make", "QGas_7-X4jk-00597-00139096-00139439": "them accepted as study relevant", "QGas_7-X4jk-00598-00139440-00139647": "so the next steps this has only been the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00599-00139648-00139878": "very first step of our inclusive project", "QGas_7-X4jk-00600-00139879-00140111": "and we will build upon that we will try", "QGas_7-X4jk-00601-00140112-00140343": "to detect more good and novel practices", "QGas_7-X4jk-00602-00140344-00140502": "of inclusive student engagement and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00603-00140503-00140702": "professional higher education but of", "QGas_7-X4jk-00604-00140703-00140927": "course also for other types of higher", "QGas_7-X4jk-00605-00140928-00141143": "education we will", "QGas_7-X4jk-00606-00141144-00141335": "set up some strategies and guidelines", "QGas_7-X4jk-00607-00141336-00141575": "for that and provide an online toolkit", "QGas_7-X4jk-00608-00141576-00141814": "and training resources", "QGas_7-X4jk-00609-00141815-00141927": "and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00610-00141928-00142159": "if you're interested in the report it's", "QGas_7-X4jk-00611-00142160-00142423": "already online on our website and you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00612-00142424-00142599": "can also", "QGas_7-X4jk-00613-00142600-00142839": "get it with a qr code", "QGas_7-X4jk-00614-00142840-00143102": "marina will type in the link into our", "QGas_7-X4jk-00615-00143103-00143343": "chat and of course there you will get", "QGas_7-X4jk-00616-00143344-00143511": "some more detailed information on our", "QGas_7-X4jk-00617-00143512-00143783": "research but also we are really really", "QGas_7-X4jk-00618-00143784-00143951": "looking forward to get in touch with you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00619-00143952-00144223": "so feel free to send us an email and or", "QGas_7-X4jk-00620-00144224-00144431": "to go on our website and contact us on", "QGas_7-X4jk-00621-00144432-00144631": "the project we also have other members", "QGas_7-X4jk-00622-00144632-00144799": "of the project team who are really", "QGas_7-X4jk-00623-00144800-00144975": "excited to talk to you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00624-00144976-00145111": "and um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00625-00145112-00145351": "now we have five minutes left for some", "QGas_7-X4jk-00626-00145352-00145535": "questions and discussion", "QGas_7-X4jk-00627-00145536-00145790": "um some impulses might be what are your", "QGas_7-X4jk-00628-00145791-00146014": "experiences concerning inclusive student", "QGas_7-X4jk-00629-00146015-00146175": "engagement", "QGas_7-X4jk-00630-00146176-00146335": "maybe we have forgotten about barriers", "QGas_7-X4jk-00631-00146336-00146575": "and challenges students might face", "QGas_7-X4jk-00632-00146576-00146799": "and maybe you have some good practices", "QGas_7-X4jk-00633-00146800-00146959": "that you can share which would be really", "QGas_7-X4jk-00634-00146960-00147326": "interesting for us so i will", "QGas_7-X4jk-00635-00147327-00147599": "finish the screen share", "QGas_7-X4jk-00636-00147600-00147678": "and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00637-00147679-00147871": "thank you for your attention", "QGas_7-X4jk-00638-00147872-00148399": "thank you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00639-00148400-00148799": "i actually checked the menti meter again", "QGas_7-X4jk-00640-00148800-00149047": "and we have some", "QGas_7-X4jk-00641-00149048-00149151": "more", "QGas_7-X4jk-00642-00149152-00149471": "um so like studying and a full-time job", "QGas_7-X4jk-00643-00149472-00149583": "um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00644-00149584-00149839": "and we also have", "QGas_7-X4jk-00645-00149840-00149999": "being a parent and studies but i think", "QGas_7-X4jk-00646-00150000-00150190": "we already had that before", "QGas_7-X4jk-00647-00150191-00150423": "and no online student groups so that's", "QGas_7-X4jk-00648-00150424-00150678": "also like a accessibility problem", "QGas_7-X4jk-00649-00150679-00151031": "i think", "QGas_7-X4jk-00650-00151032-00152599": "do we have any questions", "QGas_7-X4jk-00651-00152600-00152735": "if you have questions you can type them", "QGas_7-X4jk-00652-00152736-00154175": "in the chat", "QGas_7-X4jk-00653-00154176-00154351": "i think also if you have comments you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00654-00154352-00154471": "can type them in the chat some of you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00655-00154472-00154671": "already made comments by", "QGas_7-X4jk-00656-00154672-00154823": "showing the thumbs up or something but a", "QGas_7-X4jk-00657-00154824-00155935": "questions comments very welcome", "QGas_7-X4jk-00658-00155936-00156343": "i think we have one uh", "QGas_7-X4jk-00659-00156344-00156614": "um one comma and we got one comment in", "QGas_7-X4jk-00660-00156615-00156863": "the beginning when i talked about gender", "QGas_7-X4jk-00661-00156864-00157095": "as a construct of course of the internal", "QGas_7-X4jk-00662-00157096-00157423": "damage of course we can change um gender", "QGas_7-X4jk-00663-00157424-00157639": "it's more about the biological gender", "QGas_7-X4jk-00664-00157640-00157839": "you are born with in the beginning and", "QGas_7-X4jk-00665-00157840-00158126": "you cannot self-select when you are born", "QGas_7-X4jk-00666-00158127-00158447": "but of course later on um gender is", "QGas_7-X4jk-00667-00158448-00158702": "something you can change was it probably", "QGas_7-X4jk-00668-00158703-00158887": "more uh", "QGas_7-X4jk-00669-00158888-00159478": "easy than other characteristics like age", "QGas_7-X4jk-00670-00159479-00159735": "you're muted laura", "QGas_7-X4jk-00671-00159736-00159863": "sorry", "QGas_7-X4jk-00672-00159864-00160135": "so we we took that um source", "QGas_7-X4jk-00673-00160136-00160295": "from from another source but it's", "QGas_7-X4jk-00674-00160296-00160447": "actually thanks for the comment because", "QGas_7-X4jk-00675-00160448-00160631": "that's something um to be discussed i", "QGas_7-X4jk-00676-00160632-00160863": "think yeah it's of course something to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00677-00160864-00161039": "keep in mind when you want to make an", "QGas_7-X4jk-00678-00161040-00161263": "inclusive project that you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00679-00161264-00162247": "have an inclusive approach", "QGas_7-X4jk-00680-00162248-00162575": "any good practices", "QGas_7-X4jk-00681-00162576-00162751": "i hope there are", "QGas_7-X4jk-00682-00162752-00162959": "you can also share some links if you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00683-00162960-00163407": "have something um", "QGas_7-X4jk-00684-00163408-00163678": "we always we have a database uh so we", "QGas_7-X4jk-00685-00163679-00163919": "want to develop a database with", "QGas_7-X4jk-00686-00163920-00164199": "different best practices like guidelines", "QGas_7-X4jk-00687-00164200-00164454": "or student organizations who are focused", "QGas_7-X4jk-00688-00164455-00164543": "on", "QGas_7-X4jk-00689-00164544-00164854": "including um different non-traditional", "QGas_7-X4jk-00690-00164855-00165038": "students and students with different", "QGas_7-X4jk-00691-00165039-00165175": "characteristics", "QGas_7-X4jk-00692-00165176-00165535": "and we are always happy to get uh", "QGas_7-X4jk-00693-00165536-00165799": "new ideas best practices so even", "QGas_7-X4jk-00694-00165800-00165990": "afterwards you can just send them to us", "QGas_7-X4jk-00695-00165991-00166166": "for a mail", "QGas_7-X4jk-00696-00166167-00166311": "what we also what you can find in the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00697-00166312-00166535": "report is like we also put a corona", "QGas_7-X4jk-00698-00166536-00166790": "focus because that it was impossible not", "QGas_7-X4jk-00699-00166791-00167047": "to include the subject because we felt", "QGas_7-X4jk-00700-00167048-00167175": "like the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00701-00167176-00167375": "corona situation and the digital", "QGas_7-X4jk-00702-00167376-00167631": "teaching and learning has changed the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00703-00167632-00167911": "situation for some students so some who", "QGas_7-X4jk-00704-00167912-00168119": "might have had challenges before i might", "QGas_7-X4jk-00705-00168120-00168447": "even have had faced bigger challenges", "QGas_7-X4jk-00706-00168448-00168663": "and but there's also some like for", "QGas_7-X4jk-00707-00168664-00168823": "mobility", "QGas_7-X4jk-00708-00168824-00168999": "um issues for example there might be", "QGas_7-X4jk-00709-00169000-00169166": "some advantages for some students as", "QGas_7-X4jk-00710-00169167-00169399": "well so there's more information on that", "QGas_7-X4jk-00711-00169400-00169975": "also in the report", "QGas_7-X4jk-00712-00169976-00170119": "oh wait there's one maybe last comment", "QGas_7-X4jk-00713-00170120-00170302": "there", "QGas_7-X4jk-00714-00170303-00170526": "from an sophie", "QGas_7-X4jk-00715-00170527-00170863": "oh yeah", "QGas_7-X4jk-00716-00170864-00171111": "thank you and sophie you can sell it to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00717-00171112-00171447": "us maybe", "QGas_7-X4jk-00718-00171448-00171671": "yeah apart from that uh i think that", "QGas_7-X4jk-00719-00171672-00171823": "will be the end of the session so thank", "QGas_7-X4jk-00720-00171824-00171943": "you very much to the speakers to", "QGas_7-X4jk-00721-00171944-00172087": "marinate lara thank you all the", "QGas_7-X4jk-00722-00172088-00172247": "participants", "QGas_7-X4jk-00723-00172248-00172431": "i hope you have enjoyed it also a", "QGas_7-X4jk-00724-00172432-00172663": "reminder there are more sessions later", "QGas_7-X4jk-00725-00172664-00172814": "tonight and also tomorrow and on", "QGas_7-X4jk-00726-00172815-00173007": "thursday if you are interested in them", "QGas_7-X4jk-00727-00173008-00173254": "feel free to check them out so thank you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00728-00173255-00173526": "and have a nice evening", "QGas_7-X4jk-00729-00173527-00174047": "thank you", "QGas_7-X4jk-00730-00174048-00174255": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "QGazHq2vsB4", "text": {"QGazHq2vsB4-00000-00000218-00006722": "[Music]", "QGazHq2vsB4-00001-00006723-00008167": "[Music]", "QGazHq2vsB4-00002-00008168-00008375": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "QHBmAw32wF8", "text": {"QHBmAw32wF8-00000-00000000-00000224": "hi friends today we'll be doing my plan", "QHBmAw32wF8-00001-00000225-00000488": "with me for the week of March 16th", "QHBmAw32wF8-00002-00000488-00001149": "through the 22nd", "QHBmAw32wF8-00003-00001150-00001441": "as mentioned previously", "QHBmAw32wF8-00004-00001442-00001714": "my sister was ordering me a couple of", "QHBmAw32wF8-00005-00001716-00001885": "things from the happy planner and she", "QHBmAw32wF8-00006-00001886-00002192": "also ordered me this beautiful gold", "QHBmAw32wF8-00007-00002193-00002534": "cover for my classic happy planner so", "QHBmAw32wF8-00008-00002535-00002723": "everything is on nice and neat and", "QHBmAw32wF8-00009-00002724-00002837": "pretty in here", "QHBmAw32wF8-00010-00002838-00003074": "so let's get in here and get started I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00011-00003075-00003293": "haven't gotten anything set up on the", "QHBmAw32wF8-00012-00003294-00003458": "inside yet I haven't really done a whole", "QHBmAw32wF8-00013-00003459-00003754": "lot with it I just have my book in here", "QHBmAw32wF8-00014-00003755-00004004": "and at some point I'll get some stickers", "QHBmAw32wF8-00015-00004004-00004231": "or something to put in here to make it", "QHBmAw32wF8-00016-00004232-00004520": "more functional for now we just have the", "QHBmAw32wF8-00017-00004521-00004916": "usual so let's go to last week", "QHBmAw32wF8-00018-00004917-00005186": "this is last week as you can tell didn't", "QHBmAw32wF8-00019-00005187-00005351": "really accomplish a whole lot this week", "QHBmAw32wF8-00020-00005352-00005735": "only finished one Scene didn't edit the", "QHBmAw32wF8-00021-00005736-00006140": "TBR tour still I didn't read a couple of", "QHBmAw32wF8-00022-00006141-00006484": "books I got some videos filmed YouTube", "QHBmAw32wF8-00023-00006486-00006623": "schedule went as planned", "QHBmAw32wF8-00024-00006623-00006835": "other than the productivity sprint that", "QHBmAw32wF8-00025-00006836-00007028": "will have went up on Sunday you wouldn't", "QHBmAw32wF8-00026-00007029-00007292": "have seen that one Saturday but no it's", "QHBmAw32wF8-00027-00007293-00007378": "fine", "QHBmAw32wF8-00028-00007379-00007658": "Saturday ended up being an adventure I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00029-00007659-00007934": "have went to work and then I went to do", "QHBmAw32wF8-00030-00007934-00008126": "like my regular grocery shopping but", "QHBmAw32wF8-00031-00008127-00008353": "because everyone is pandemic shopping I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00032-00008354-00008558": "had to go to three stores instead of my", "QHBmAw32wF8-00033-00008559-00008723": "usual one to get the things I needed for", "QHBmAw32wF8-00034-00008724-00008917": "the week but it's fine so I just didn't", "QHBmAw32wF8-00035-00008918-00009044": "get as much done yesterday as I had", "QHBmAw32wF8-00036-00009045-00009388": "originally planned last week it's here I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00037-00009389-00009910": "used it as I usually do not as this week", "QHBmAw32wF8-00038-00009911-00010160": "was not my best week let's put it that", "QHBmAw32wF8-00039-00010161-00010231": "way okay", "QHBmAw32wF8-00040-00010232-00010466": "moving forward let's go ahead and take", "QHBmAw32wF8-00041-00010467-00010899": "out next week and I'll put this aside", "QHBmAw32wF8-00042-00010900-00011381": "these are the clear dividers that", "QHBmAw32wF8-00043-00011382-00011591": "Melissa got me this is the one I have", "QHBmAw32wF8-00044-00011592-00011816": "set up for my regular planner that I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00045-00011817-00012019": "don't show you guys my wife planner", "QHBmAw32wF8-00046-00012020-00012385": "taste smell awful they still smell awful", "QHBmAw32wF8-00047-00012386-00012512": "she brought him over I think on like", "QHBmAw32wF8-00048-00012513-00012749": "Tuesday maybe Oh", "QHBmAw32wF8-00049-00012750-00012932": "they still smell horrible they're just", "QHBmAw32wF8-00050-00012933-00013096": "they are rank they", "QHBmAw32wF8-00051-00013097-00013630": "awful Oh like I mean it is what it is", "QHBmAw32wF8-00052-00013631-00014530": "alright these are the ones for this most", "QHBmAw32wF8-00053-00014531-00014686": "of the stickers that I'm using this week", "QHBmAw32wF8-00054-00014687-00015153": "come from this lol seasonal book this is", "QHBmAw32wF8-00055-00015154-00015430": "the paper studio which I believe is a", "QHBmAw32wF8-00056-00015431-00015691": "Hobby Lobby brand but they have like a", "QHBmAw32wF8-00057-00015693-00016036": "page for each month so I chose the March", "QHBmAw32wF8-00058-00016037-00016310": "page because it is st. Patrick's Day", "QHBmAw32wF8-00059-00016311-00016571": "themed so that seems like a fun thing to", "QHBmAw32wF8-00060-00016572-00016978": "do I've got my plans ready to go let's", "QHBmAw32wF8-00061-00016979-00017353": "do this now I did these a few days ago", "QHBmAw32wF8-00062-00017354-00017630": "so I honestly don't know how difficult", "QHBmAw32wF8-00063-00017631-00017886": "or easy these are gonna be to get off of", "QHBmAw32wF8-00064-00017887-00018293": "the sheets it may be a pain but we're", "QHBmAw32wF8-00065-00018294-00018653": "gonna find out together I guess I did", "QHBmAw32wF8-00066-00018654-00018818": "some sticker surgery this week with my", "QHBmAw32wF8-00067-00018819-00019247": "stickers as I occasionally do these ones", "QHBmAw32wF8-00068-00019248-00019378": "that you'll see here that I'm using to", "QHBmAw32wF8-00069-00019379-00019615": "do my typical covering with we're", "QHBmAw32wF8-00070-00019616-00019956": "actually a large box sticker that I cut", "QHBmAw32wF8-00071-00019957-00020300": "into three pieces to cover the top", "QHBmAw32wF8-00072-00020301-00020497": "categories that I usually cover I really", "QHBmAw32wF8-00073-00020498-00020656": "want to cover one of those this week and", "QHBmAw32wF8-00074-00020657-00020840": "just go a little high and it'll be fine", "QHBmAw32wF8-00075-00020841-00021602": "I did not get a coordinating color to go", "QHBmAw32wF8-00076-00021603-00021931": "with here so I need to do that it's like", "QHBmAw32wF8-00077-00021932-00022081": "y'all are gonna get a view of my washi", "QHBmAw32wF8-00078-00022082-00022780": "tape collection I'm gonna use a small", "QHBmAw32wF8-00079-00022781-00024128": "one a green one blue then green stuck it", "QHBmAw32wF8-00080-00024129-00024311": "together I might be able to get this", "QHBmAw32wF8-00081-00024312-00025055": "apart maybe haha I'll use this one", "QHBmAw32wF8-00082-00025056-00025370": "something that matches", "QHBmAw32wF8-00083-00025371-00025730": "so things we can talk about this week", "QHBmAw32wF8-00084-00025731-00026153": "let's just guess some things that I have", "QHBmAw32wF8-00085-00026154-00026637": "decided if you were here last week you", "QHBmAw32wF8-00086-00026638-00026862": "know that last week I had a group chat", "QHBmAw32wF8-00087-00026863-00027255": "with my friends Becca Emily", "QHBmAw32wF8-00088-00027256-00028095": "Phoebe Kate all linked down below and we", "QHBmAw32wF8-00089-00028095-00028287": "basically talked a little bit about well", "QHBmAw32wF8-00090-00028288-00028427": "everything going on on everybody's lies", "QHBmAw32wF8-00091-00028429-00028656": "cuz we're all just we haven't caught up", "QHBmAw32wF8-00092-00028657-00028877": "in a while other than I mean we talk", "QHBmAw32wF8-00093-00028879-00029102": "daily but we haven't really caught up in", "QHBmAw32wF8-00094-00029104-00029439": "a while if that makes sense so we were", "QHBmAw32wF8-00095-00029439-00029613": "just kind of talking about projects and", "QHBmAw32wF8-00096-00029614-00029745": "things that you know are just a little", "QHBmAw32wF8-00097-00029745-00029919": "hard to just like type out and talk", "QHBmAw32wF8-00098-00029920-00030141": "about and so we talked about my projects", "QHBmAw32wF8-00099-00030142-00030279": "a little bit and what I have going on", "QHBmAw32wF8-00100-00030280-00030486": "and kind of where I'm stuck at with", "QHBmAw32wF8-00101-00030487-00030801": "warriors and what I'm wanting to do with", "QHBmAw32wF8-00102-00030802-00031358": "it because it does need it's kind of at", "QHBmAw32wF8-00103-00031360-00031704": "this precipice of is it going to be why", "QHBmAw32wF8-00104-00031705-00031881": "is it gonna be a dull and yes most", "QHBmAw32wF8-00105-00031882-00032022": "people would decide that ahead of time", "QHBmAw32wF8-00106-00032023-00032345": "but it is a high fantasy and so it is", "QHBmAw32wF8-00107-00032347-00032517": "kind of just hard to figure out what", "QHBmAw32wF8-00108-00032518-00032864": "exactly you want to do with it and I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00109-00032865-00033249": "think what I've decided is to go the", "QHBmAw32wF8-00110-00033250-00033417": "adult route because I'm putting a lot", "QHBmAw32wF8-00111-00033418-00033600": "more work into the world building not to", "QHBmAw32wF8-00112-00033601-00033870": "say that why a books don't have that", "QHBmAw32wF8-00113-00033871-00034005": "amount of world-building but it's just", "QHBmAw32wF8-00114-00034006-00034146": "something that you typically find more", "QHBmAw32wF8-00115-00034147-00034833": "in adult than in why a sticker ripped a", "QHBmAw32wF8-00116-00034834-00035112": "bit so it's gonna need some glue all", "QHBmAw32wF8-00117-00035113-00035385": "right well that worked out just fine", "QHBmAw32wF8-00118-00035386-00035810": "didn't it anyway it has a lot of", "QHBmAw32wF8-00119-00035811-00036069": "world-building in it and so it's going", "QHBmAw32wF8-00120-00036070-00036742": "to need", "QHBmAw32wF8-00121-00036743-00036948": "a lot more work than what it has", "QHBmAw32wF8-00122-00036949-00037402": "previously had to it and so I really", "QHBmAw32wF8-00123-00037403-00037636": "just feel like I'm gonna have to you I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00124-00037637-00037822": "mean I already knew I was gonna have to", "QHBmAw32wF8-00125-00037823-00038083": "restart from scratch but I'm just kind", "QHBmAw32wF8-00126-00038084-00038224": "of in a position where I don't know if I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00127-00038225-00038446": "want to continue the round of revisions", "QHBmAw32wF8-00128-00038447-00038725": "that I'm doing and and work on those or", "QHBmAw32wF8-00129-00038726-00038899": "if I want to just completely start over", "QHBmAw32wF8-00130-00038900-00039295": "I think I have decided to just continue", "QHBmAw32wF8-00131-00039296-00039520": "the round of revisions that I'm on I'm", "QHBmAw32wF8-00132-00039521-00039877": "about halfway through and at this point", "QHBmAw32wF8-00133-00039878-00040225": "what I'm really doing is knowing what I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00134-00040226-00040507": "plan to do in the future I'm kind of", "QHBmAw32wF8-00135-00040508-00040699": "working that into the notes that I'm", "QHBmAw32wF8-00136-00040700-00041035": "making so I'm kind of doing things to", "QHBmAw32wF8-00137-00041036-00041251": "fold because now instead of like making", "QHBmAw32wF8-00138-00041252-00041452": "the changes that I was making before I'm", "QHBmAw32wF8-00139-00041453-00041716": "looking at changing the entire world and", "QHBmAw32wF8-00140-00041717-00041992": "when I started the book it was set in", "QHBmAw32wF8-00141-00041993-00042319": "our world kind of adjacent to okay", "QHBmAw32wF8-00142-00042320-00042499": "sticker could you go just a smidge more", "QHBmAw32wF8-00143-00042500-00042649": "straight I don't know that that's what I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00144-00042650-00042796": "want to continue in the future and", "QHBmAw32wF8-00145-00042797-00042928": "that's kind of thing that I'm deciding", "QHBmAw32wF8-00146-00042929-00043156": "is how much I want to be in our world", "QHBmAw32wF8-00147-00043157-00043522": "and how much I want to have in other", "QHBmAw32wF8-00148-00043523-00043726": "worlds I guess if that's the way you", "QHBmAw32wF8-00149-00043727-00043840": "want to put it so I'm just learning how", "QHBmAw32wF8-00150-00043841-00044094": "much of it I want to actually have set", "QHBmAw32wF8-00151-00044095-00044392": "in our world how connected I want it to", "QHBmAw32wF8-00152-00044393-00044515": "be to our world", "QHBmAw32wF8-00153-00044516-00044668": "well we've encountered our first problem", "QHBmAw32wF8-00154-00044669-00045046": "her legs just ripped clean off her nice", "QHBmAw32wF8-00155-00045047-00045310": "legs it's fine I'll just put something", "QHBmAw32wF8-00156-00045311-00045508": "at the bottom or just put her right here", "QHBmAw32wF8-00157-00045509-00045673": "at the bottom so that it looks like it", "QHBmAw32wF8-00158-00045674-00046260": "was intentional we meant to do that", "QHBmAw32wF8-00159-00046261-00046540": "she doesn't need legs yeah so if you're", "QHBmAw32wF8-00160-00046541-00046840": "using these instead of the wax paper", "QHBmAw32wF8-00161-00046841-00047178": "don't recommend that you do it a week", "QHBmAw32wF8-00162-00047179-00047416": "four days ahead of time and then try to", "QHBmAw32wF8-00163-00047417-00047599": "get them on here because it's they're", "QHBmAw32wF8-00164-00047600-00047743": "not coming off of here great let's put", "QHBmAw32wF8-00165-00047744-00047890": "that way I'm trying to be gentle but", "QHBmAw32wF8-00166-00047891-00048151": "they're they're not not doing great", "QHBmAw32wF8-00167-00048152-00048430": "it's basically we had her chat we kind", "QHBmAw32wF8-00168-00048431-00048748": "of just talked about what I want to do", "QHBmAw32wF8-00169-00048749-00048988": "moving forward and and you know getting", "QHBmAw32wF8-00170-00048989-00049201": "the advice of my friends who kind of", "QHBmAw32wF8-00171-00049202-00049516": "don't be well enough and have heard me", "QHBmAw32wF8-00172-00049517-00049648": "ramble about my story enough that I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00173-00049649-00049828": "think they kind of get a grasp of what", "QHBmAw32wF8-00174-00049829-00050074": "I'm trying to do so we're just", "QHBmAw32wF8-00175-00050075-00050236": "just making plans for the future and I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00176-00050237-00050392": "that's definitely what I want to work on", "QHBmAw32wF8-00177-00050393-00050659": "during camp Nanna which I will talk", "QHBmAw32wF8-00178-00050660-00051088": "about more in my video I'm gonna do a", "QHBmAw32wF8-00179-00051089-00051232": "plan with me later this week", "QHBmAw32wF8-00180-00051233-00051424": "for camp and I'm going to talk about", "QHBmAw32wF8-00181-00051425-00051642": "exactly what I'm doing with that then", "QHBmAw32wF8-00182-00051644-00051852": "rather than now so if you want to loo", "QHBmAw32wF8-00183-00051853-00052102": "that then you know hang around for that", "QHBmAw32wF8-00184-00052103-00052314": "I will be doing at camp plan with", "QHBmAw32wF8-00185-00052315-00052650": "meeting so look forward to that as well", "QHBmAw32wF8-00186-00052651-00052882": "no I don't know if those stuck because", "QHBmAw32wF8-00187-00052883-00053077": "they're you know not happy planner", "QHBmAw32wF8-00188-00053078-00053326": "stickers or whatever the case may be but", "QHBmAw32wF8-00189-00053327-00053616": "they stuck pretty good to that so not", "QHBmAw32wF8-00190-00053617-00053878": "the intention but what happened so I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00191-00053879-00053974": "definitely think that have a planner", "QHBmAw32wF8-00192-00053975-00054103": "stickers are coming off a lot easier", "QHBmAw32wF8-00193-00054104-00054397": "than what the others were these that I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00194-00054398-00054565": "cut down that were the big green boxes", "QHBmAw32wF8-00195-00054566-00054763": "were happy planner those are coming off", "QHBmAw32wF8-00196-00054764-00054964": "pretty easy these flags were happy", "QHBmAw32wF8-00197-00054965-00055227": "planner they're coming off pretty easy", "QHBmAw32wF8-00198-00055228-00055564": "this big box happy planner came right", "QHBmAw32wF8-00199-00055565-00055903": "off so maybe it's just whatever the", "QHBmAw32wF8-00200-00055904-00056130": "other brands did with their sticker", "QHBmAw32wF8-00201-00056132-00056604": "backing it's just a little stickier", "QHBmAw32wF8-00202-00056604-00056839": "that's really all I have to talk about", "QHBmAw32wF8-00203-00056840-00057076": "writing-related wise cuz that's pretty", "QHBmAw32wF8-00204-00057077-00057337": "much all I did this week was just work", "QHBmAw32wF8-00205-00057338-00057616": "on the one scene that I want which", "QHBmAw32wF8-00206-00057616-00057792": "branded that scene that I did was like a", "QHBmAw32wF8-00207-00057794-00057976": "50 some page scene that was broken down", "QHBmAw32wF8-00208-00057977-00058641": "into three more scenes but I just don't", "QHBmAw32wF8-00209-00058641-00058882": "know what else really I could talk about", "QHBmAw32wF8-00210-00058883-00059089": "with that it's gonna be much shorter day", "QHBmAw32wF8-00211-00059090-00059344": "than usual I imagine because you know", "QHBmAw32wF8-00212-00059345-00059599": "I'm probably not going to film writing", "QHBmAw32wF8-00213-00059600-00059737": "on here this week just because my", "QHBmAw32wF8-00214-00059738-00059916": "battery is dying and it is very similar", "QHBmAw32wF8-00215-00059917-00060766": "every week that sticker just ripped like", "QHBmAw32wF8-00216-00060766-00060966": "40 okay those are just ripping so I'm", "QHBmAw32wF8-00217-00060967-00061107": "not he's gonna I'm gonna take those off", "QHBmAw32wF8-00218-00061108-00061266": "later you can put them on here I will", "QHBmAw32wF8-00219-00061267-00061525": "need another box for Saturday Kate is", "QHBmAw32wF8-00220-00061526-00061854": "doing an experiment on Saturday", "QHBmAw32wF8-00221-00061855-00062077": "she's have an experiment day so I think", "QHBmAw32wF8-00222-00062078-00062239": "we're gonna do some live Sprint's that", "QHBmAw32wF8-00223-00062240-00062379": "day just to kind of help me get over my", "QHBmAw32wF8-00224-00062380-00062611": "monetization hump cuz yesterday I hit", "QHBmAw32wF8-00225-00062612-00062836": "monetization hours like I hit my four", "QHBmAw32wF8-00226-00062837-00062977": "thousand but today I'm back down to", "QHBmAw32wF8-00227-00062978-00063097": "three thousand nine hundred and ninety", "QHBmAw32wF8-00228-00063098-00063274": "nine so it took me off of the", "QHBmAw32wF8-00229-00063275-00063484": "monetization so I have to like", "QHBmAw32wF8-00230-00063485-00063709": "so basically a live stream is needed to", "QHBmAw32wF8-00231-00063710-00063934": "kind of help me boost some hours so I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00232-00063935-00064038": "think we're going to try to do that on", "QHBmAw32wF8-00233-00064039-00064285": "Saturday but the usual Tuesday live", "QHBmAw32wF8-00234-00064286-00064442": "stream with Becca and Hannah and", "QHBmAw32wF8-00235-00064444-00064753": "Thursday's with Laura and Kevin so this", "QHBmAw32wF8-00236-00064754-00064968": "looks like it usually does so let's get", "QHBmAw32wF8-00237-00064969-00065535": "these babies back on the disk", "QHBmAw32wF8-00238-00065536-00065929": "so let's you know next week about how I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00239-00065930-00066298": "feel about these plastic sheet things", "QHBmAw32wF8-00240-00066299-00066669": "versus what we've been doing with the", "QHBmAw32wF8-00241-00066670-00067042": "paper because like I said some of them", "QHBmAw32wF8-00242-00067043-00067182": "stuck to it and I had to throw them out", "QHBmAw32wF8-00243-00067183-00067530": "it has cat hair all over it okay some of", "QHBmAw32wF8-00244-00067531-00067741": "them stuck to it and and ruined some", "QHBmAw32wF8-00245-00067742-00068062": "stickers but again those weren't happy", "QHBmAw32wF8-00246-00068063-00068199": "planner stickers so I don't know if that", "QHBmAw32wF8-00247-00068200-00068349": "has anything to do with it or if it's", "QHBmAw32wF8-00248-00068350-00068698": "because I set that up on Wednesday and", "QHBmAw32wF8-00249-00068699-00068880": "today fun day and I thought about", "QHBmAw32wF8-00250-00068881-00069057": "something to do with it here is your", "QHBmAw32wF8-00251-00069058-00069436": "view of this beauteous maximus planner", "QHBmAw32wF8-00252-00069437-00069618": "setup that we have for st. patrick's day", "QHBmAw32wF8-00253-00069619-00069862": "hope everybody is staying safe out there", "QHBmAw32wF8-00254-00069863-00070048": "that you're practicing your social", "QHBmAw32wF8-00255-00070049-00070430": "distancing if you are an author or a", "QHBmAw32wF8-00256-00070431-00070680": "booktuber and you're interested in doing", "QHBmAw32wF8-00257-00070681-00071169": "a virtual book con type thing", "QHBmAw32wF8-00258-00071170-00071341": "check out beautifully bookish Bethany's", "QHBmAw32wF8-00259-00071342-00071694": "channel she is trying to get together a", "QHBmAw32wF8-00260-00071695-00071919": "group of people she has on her Twitter a", "QHBmAw32wF8-00261-00071920-00072162": "link to sign up for helping with the", "QHBmAw32wF8-00262-00072163-00072312": "program I will link that down below I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00263-00072313-00072484": "don't know any full details yet and I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00264-00072485-00072598": "don't believe Bethany does either it's", "QHBmAw32wF8-00265-00072599-00072726": "just kind of a plan she started a couple", "QHBmAw32wF8-00266-00072727-00072835": "of days ago I just thought that's", "QHBmAw32wF8-00267-00072836-00072940": "something that we've been talking about", "QHBmAw32wF8-00268-00072941-00073246": "with the climate of social distancing", "QHBmAw32wF8-00269-00073247-00073447": "that we've been trying to accomplish I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00270-00073448-00073696": "hope everyone is doing well that is all", "QHBmAw32wF8-00271-00073697-00073887": "I have for today I post reading writing", "QHBmAw32wF8-00272-00073888-00074080": "book and planner related videos Mondays", "QHBmAw32wF8-00273-00074081-00074266": "Wednesdays and bonus videos on the", "QHBmAw32wF8-00274-00074267-00074416": "weekends if you don't miss anything I", "QHBmAw32wF8-00275-00074417-00074538": "have fun in the future make sure you", "QHBmAw32wF8-00276-00074539-00074692": "subscribe and until then I will see you", "QHBmAw32wF8-00277-00074693-00075208": "guys next time", "QHBmAw32wF8-00278-00075209-00076384": "[Music]", "QHBmAw32wF8-00279-00076385-00077042": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "QHGN_oKcm8U", "text": {"QHGN_oKcm8U-00000-00000053-00000345": "New Guinea Tok Pisin New Guinea Dutch", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00001-00000346-00000558": "New Guinea German New Guinea ax", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00002-00000559-00000861": "Indonesian Papua historically Arion is a", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00003-00000862-00001032": "large island off the continent of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00004-00001033-00001287": "Australia it is the world's second", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00005-00001288-00001503": "largest island after Greenland covering", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00006-00001504-00001954": "a land area of 780 5753 square", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00007-00001955-00002407": "kilometres 300 3381 square miles and the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00008-00002408-00002581": "largest wholly or partly within the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00009-00002582-00002869": "southern hemisphere in Oceania the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00010-00002870-00003049": "eastern half of the island as the major", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00011-00003050-00003240": "landmass of the independent state of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00012-00003241-00003504": "Papua New Guinea the western half", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00013-00003505-00003690": "referred to as western New Guinea or", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00014-00003692-00003954": "West Papua are simply Papua formerly a", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00015-00003955-00004206": "Dutch colony was annexed by Indonesia in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00016-00004207-00004450": "1962 and has been administered by it", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00017-00004451-00004804": "since then", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00018-00004805-00005311": "topic names", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00019-00005312-00005626": "topic the island has been known by", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00020-00005627-00005953": "various names the name Papua was used to", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00021-00005954-00006103": "refer to parts of the island before", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00022-00006104-00006411": "contact with the West its etymology is", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00023-00006412-00006606": "unclear one theory states that it is", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00024-00006608-00006790": "from t'adore the language used by the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00025-00006791-00006973": "Sultanate of t'adore which controlled", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00026-00006973-00007258": "parts of the island s coastal region the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00027-00007259-00007513": "name came from Papo to unite and woo at", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00028-00007514-00007756": "negation which means not united or", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00029-00007756-00008014": "territory that geographically is far", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00030-00008015-00008278": "away and thus not United plug reports", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00031-00008279-00008496": "that the word Papua is often said to", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00032-00008497-00008716": "derive from the malay word Papua or", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00033-00008717-00008923": "Papua meaning Frizzle II haired", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00034-00008924-00009135": "referring to the highly curly hair of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00035-00009136-00009333": "the inhabitants of these areas", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00036-00009334-00009628": "another possibility put forward by", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00037-00009629-00009982": "Sullivan junkie in 1993 is that it comes", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00038-00009983-00010216": "from the biack phrase sup by Papua which", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00039-00010217-00010534": "means the land below the sunset and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00040-00010535-00010855": "refers to the islands west of the bird s", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00041-00010856-00011143": "head as far as halmahera whatever its", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00042-00011144-00011344": "origin the name Papua came to be", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00043-00011345-00011530": "associated with this area and more", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00044-00011531-00011716": "especially with halmahera which was", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00045-00011717-00011871": "known to the Portuguese by this name", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00046-00011872-00012069": "during the era of their colonization in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00047-00012070-00012301": "this part of the world when the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00048-00012302-00012523": "Portuguese and Spanish explorers arrived", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00049-00012524-00012724": "in the island via the Spice Islands they", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00050-00012725-00012935": "also referred to the island as Papua", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00051-00012936-00013194": "however the name New Guinea was later", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00052-00013195-00013375": "used by Westerners starting with the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00053-00013376-00013655": "Spanish explorer amigo Ortiz dorita's in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00054-00013656-00013918": "1545 referring to the similarities of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00055-00013919-00014107": "the indigenous peoples appearance with", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00056-00014108-00014244": "the natives of the Guinea region of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00057-00014245-00014482": "Africa the name is one of several", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00058-00014483-00014704": "toponyms sharing similar etymologies", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00059-00014705-00015007": "ultimately meaning land of the blacks or", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00060-00015008-00015219": "similar meanings in reference to the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00061-00015220-00015483": "dark-skinned of the inhabitants the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00062-00015484-00015685": "Dutch who arrived later under Jacob", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00063-00015686-00015877": "lemare and Willem schouten called it", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00064-00015878-00016078": "Shagun Island but later this name was", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00065-00016079-00016266": "used only to refer to islands off the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00066-00016268-00016477": "north coast of Papua proper the shoutin", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00067-00016478-00016747": "islands or biack island when the Dutch", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00068-00016748-00016957": "colonized it as part of Netherlands East", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00069-00016958-00017152": "Indies they called it New Guinea the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00070-00017153-00017344": "name iron was used in the Indonesian", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00071-00017345-00017508": "language to refer to the island an", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00072-00017509-00017755": "Indonesian province s Irie and jaya", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00073-00017756-00018127": "province the name was promoted in 1945", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00074-00018128-00018270": "by Marcos Cacioppo", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00075-00018271-00018450": "brother of the future governor Franz", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00076-00018451-00018744": "Kasyapa it is taken from the BIA", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00077-00018745-00018975": "language of biack island and means to", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00078-00018976-00019416": "rise or rising spirit Aryan as the name", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00079-00019417-00019583": "used in the biack language and other", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00080-00019584-00019854": "languages such as suruí maracas and war", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00081-00019855-00020175": "open the name was used until 2001 when", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00082-00020176-00020379": "the name Papua was again used for the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00083-00020380-00020655": "island in the province the name Aryan", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00084-00020656-00020853": "which was originally favored by natives", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00085-00020854-00021054": "is now considered to be a name imposed", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00086-00021055-00021549": "by the authority of Jakarta", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00087-00021550-00022029": "topic geography", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00088-00022030-00022359": "topic New Guinea is an island to the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00089-00022360-00022536": "north of Australia but south of the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00090-00022537-00022821": "Equator it is isolated by the air for a", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00091-00022822-00023034": "sea to the west and the Torres Strait in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00092-00023035-00023277": "Coral Sea to the east sometimes", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00093-00023278-00023478": "considered to be the easternmost island", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00094-00023479-00023673": "of the Indonesian archipelago it lies", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00095-00023674-00023910": "north of Australia's top end the Gulf of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00096-00023911-00024132": "Carpentaria and Cape York Peninsula and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00097-00024133-00024348": "west of the Bismarck Archipelago and the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00098-00024349-00024744": "Solomon Islands archipelago politically", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00099-00024745-00024960": "the western half of the island comprises", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00100-00024961-00025173": "two provinces of Indonesia Papua and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00101-00025174-00025473": "West Papua the eastern half forms the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00102-00025474-00025641": "mainland of the country of Papua New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00103-00025642-00025692": "Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00104-00025693-00026033": "PNG the shape of New Guinea is often", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00105-00026035-00026192": "compared to that of a bird of paradise", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00106-00026193-00026394": "indigenous to the island and this", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00107-00026395-00026583": "results in the usual names for the two", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00108-00026583-00026823": "extremes of the island the bird s head", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00109-00026824-00027089": "Peninsula in the northwest Vogel cop in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00110-00027091-00027372": "Dutch capela burring in Indonesian also", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00111-00027373-00027567": "known as the Dober eye peninsula and the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00112-00027568-00027933": "bird s tail peninsula in the southeast", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00113-00027933-00028163": "also known as the pop one peninsula a", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00114-00028164-00028422": "spine of east-west mountains the New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00115-00028423-00028641": "Guinea Highlands dominates the geography", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00116-00028642-00028926": "of New Guinea stretching over 1,600", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00117-00028927-00029226": "kilometres 1000 miles from the head to", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00118-00029227-00029577": "the tail of the island with many high", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00119-00029577-00029907": "mountains over 4,000 metres 13,000 100", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00120-00029908-00030164": "feet the western half of the island of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00121-00030166-00030318": "New Guinea contains the highest", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00122-00030319-00030705": "mountains in Oceania rising up to 4884", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00123-00030706-00031052": "metres 16,000 24 feet high which is even", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00124-00031054-00031208": "higher than Mont Blanc in Europe", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00125-00031210-00031407": "ensuring a steady supply of rain from", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00126-00031408-00031680": "the equatorial atmosphere the treeline", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00127-00031681-00032016": "does around 4,000 metres 13100 feet", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00128-00032017-00032241": "elevation and the tallest peaks contain", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00129-00032242-00032499": "permanent equatorial glaciers which have", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00130-00032500-00032762": "been retreating since at least 1936", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00131-00032763-00033015": "various other smaller mountain ranges", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00132-00033016-00033219": "occur both north and west of the central", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00133-00033220-00033531": "ranges except in high elevations most", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00134-00033532-00033747": "areas possess a warm humid climate", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00135-00033748-00033906": "throughout the year with some seasonal", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00136-00033907-00034113": "variation associated with the Northeast", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00137-00034114-00034422": "Monsoon season the highest peaks on the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00138-00034423-00034719": "island of New Guinea are blinchik Jaya", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00139-00034720-00034944": "sometimes known by its former Dutch name", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00140-00034945-00035163": "Carstensz pyramid is a mist covered", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00141-00035164-00035310": "limestone mountain peak on the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00142-00035311-00035397": "Indonesian Tsai", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00143-00035398-00035952": "the border at 4884 meters 16000 24 feet", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00144-00035953-00036150": "punch on Jaya makes New Guinea the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00145-00036151-00036357": "world's fourth highest landmass after", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00146-00036358-00036632": "afro-eurasia America and Antarctica", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00147-00036633-00036927": "punch shock mandala also located in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00148-00036928-00037152": "Papua is the second highest peak on the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00149-00037153-00037487": "island at 4,000 760 meters", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00150-00037488-00037926": "15600 17 feet punch auch try kora also", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00151-00037927-00038457": "in Papua is 4,000 750 meters 15500 84", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00152-00038458-00038769": "feet mount Wilhelm is the highest peak", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00153-00038770-00038982": "on the PNG side of the border at four", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00154-00038983-00039150": "thousand five hundred nine meters", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00155-00039151-00039336": "fourteen thousand seven hundred ninety", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00156-00039337-00039606": "three feet it's granite peak is the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00157-00039607-00039815": "highest point of the Bismarck range", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00158-00039816-00040083": "mount Gil for thousand three hundred", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00159-00040084-00040305": "sixty eight meters fourteen thousand", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00160-00040306-00040497": "three hundred thirty one feet is the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00161-00040498-00040815": "second highest summit in PNG it is also", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00162-00040816-00041087": "the highest volcanic peak in Oceania", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00163-00041088-00041346": "another major habitat feature as the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00164-00041347-00041537": "vast southern and northern lowlands", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00165-00041538-00041766": "stretching for hundreds of kilometers", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00166-00041767-00041955": "these include lowland rainforests", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00167-00041956-00042204": "extensive wetlands savanna grasslands", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00168-00042205-00042387": "and some of the largest expanses of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00169-00042388-00042621": "mangrove forests in the world the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00170-00042622-00042762": "southern lowlands are the site of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00171-00042763-00043011": "lorentz National Park also a UNESCO", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00172-00043012-00043242": "World Heritage Site the northern", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00173-00043243-00043425": "lowlands are drained principally by the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00174-00043426-00043593": "member' amo River and it's tributaries", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00175-00043594-00043839": "on the Indonesian side and by the Sepik", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00176-00043840-00044043": "on the PNG side the more extensive", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00177-00044044-00044268": "southern lowlands by a larger number of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00178-00044269-00044451": "rivers principally the de goal on the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00179-00044452-00044658": "Indonesian side and the fly on the PNG", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00180-00044659-00044946": "side these are the islands major river", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00181-00044947-00045135": "systems draining roughly northwest", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00182-00045136-00045348": "northeast Southwest and southeast", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00183-00045349-00045651": "respectively many have broad areas of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00184-00045652-00045864": "meander and result in large areas of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00185-00045865-00046158": "lakes and freshwater swamps the largest", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00186-00046159-00046389": "island offshore dalek Frederick Hendrik", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00187-00046390-00046653": "Yasu darsow lies near the deagle estuary", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00188-00046654-00046875": "separated by a strait so narrow it has", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00189-00046876-00047123": "been named a creek", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00190-00047124-00047351": "New Guinea contains many of the world's", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00191-00047352-00047591": "ecosystem types glacial alpine tundra", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00192-00047592-00047849": "savanna Montaigne and lowland rainforest", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00193-00047850-00048065": "mangroves wetlands lake and river", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00194-00048066-00048311": "ecosystems sea grasses and some of the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00195-00048312-00048778": "richest coral reefs on the planet", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00196-00048779-00049357": "topic relation to surroundings", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00197-00049358-00049717": "topic the island of New Guinea lies to", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00198-00049718-00049906": "the east of the Malay Archipelago with", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00199-00049907-00050074": "which it is sometimes included as part", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00200-00050075-00050379": "of a greater indo-australian archipelago", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00201-00050380-00050590": "geologically it is a part of the same", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00202-00050591-00050884": "tectonic plate as Australia when world", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00203-00050885-00051085": "sea levels were low the two shared", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00204-00051086-00051379": "shorelines which now lie 100 to 140", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00205-00051379-00051598": "metres below sea level and combined with", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00206-00051599-00051802": "lands now inundated into the tectonic", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00207-00051803-00052029": "continent of Sahul also known as Greater", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00208-00052030-00052317": "Australia the two land masses became", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00209-00052319-00052522": "separated when the area now known as the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00210-00052523-00052699": "Torres Strait flooded after the end of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00211-00052700-00052932": "the last glacial period", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00212-00052933-00053110": "anthropologically New Guinea is", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00213-00053111-00053320": "considered part of Melanesia New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00214-00053321-00053545": "as differentiated from its drier flatter", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00215-00053546-00053742": "and less fertile southern counterpart", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00216-00053744-00053941": "Australia by it's much higher rainfall", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00217-00053941-00054202": "in its active volcanic geology with its", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00218-00054203-00054277": "highest point", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00219-00054278-00054566": "punch akhiya reaching an elevation of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00220-00054567-00055036": "4884 meters 16,000 23 feet yet the two", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00221-00055037-00055254": "land masses share a similar animal fauna", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00222-00055255-00055495": "with marsupials including Wallabies and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00223-00055496-00055687": "opossums and the egg-laying monotreme", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00224-00055688-00055963": "the echidna other than bats and some two", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00225-00055964-00056161": "dozen indigenous Road in general there", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00226-00056162-00056365": "are no pre human indigenous placental", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00227-00056366-00056679": "mammals pigs several additional species", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00228-00056680-00056860": "of rats and the ancestor of the New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00229-00056861-00057049": "Guinea singing dog were introduced with", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00230-00057050-00057429": "human colonization prior to the 1970s", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00231-00057429-00057607": "archeologists called the single", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00232-00057608-00057778": "Pleistocene landmass by the name", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00233-00057779-00057976": "Australasia although this word is most", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00234-00057977-00058171": "often used for a wider region that", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00235-00058172-00058396": "includes lands such as New Zealand which", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00236-00058397-00058594": "are not on the same continental shelf in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00237-00058595-00058917": "the early 1970s they introduced the term", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00238-00058919-00059116": "Greater Australia for the Pleistocene", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00239-00059116-00059488": "continent then at a 1975 conference and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00240-00059489-00059707": "consequent publication they extended the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00241-00059708-00059908": "name Sahul from its previous use for", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00242-00059909-00060066": "just the Sahul shelf to cover the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00243-00060067-00060413": "continent", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00244-00060414-00060952": "topic human presence", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00245-00060953-00061297": "topic the human presence on the island", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00246-00061298-00061537": "dates back at least 40,000 years to the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00247-00061538-00061738": "oldest Homo sapiens migrations Out of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00248-00061739-00062004": "Africa research indicates that the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00249-00062005-00062191": "Highlands were an early and independent", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00250-00062191-00062391": "center of Agriculture with evidence of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00251-00062392-00062616": "irrigation going back at least 10,000", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00252-00062617-00062872": "years because of the time depth of its", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00253-00062873-00063058": "inhabitation and its highly fractured", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00254-00063059-00063295": "landscape an unusually high number of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00255-00063296-00063490": "languages are spoken on the island with", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00256-00063491-00063712": "some 1,000 languages a figure higher", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00257-00063713-00063895": "than that of most continents having been", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00258-00063896-00064089": "cataloged out of an estimated worldwide", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00259-00064090-00064357": "pre-columbian total of more than 7,000", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00260-00064358-00064530": "currently spoken human languages", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00261-00064532-00064759": "according to ethnologue most are", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00262-00064760-00064960": "classified as poppelen languages a", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00263-00064961-00065202": "generally accepted geographical term a", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00264-00065203-00065452": "number of Austronesian languages are", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00265-00065453-00065605": "spoken on the coast and on offshore", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00266-00065606-00065947": "islands in the 16th century Spanish", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00267-00065948-00066154": "explorers arrived at the island and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00268-00066155-00066406": "called it nueva Guinea in recent history", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00269-00066407-00066640": "western New Guinea was included in the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00270-00066641-00066910": "Dutch East Indies colony the Germans", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00271-00066911-00067063": "annexed the northern coast of the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00272-00067064-00067264": "eastern half of the island as German New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00273-00067265-00067468": "Guinea in their pre-world War one effort", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00274-00067469-00067648": "to establish themselves as a colonial", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00275-00067649-00067861": "power whilst the southeastern portion", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00276-00067862-00068037": "was reluctantly claimed by Britain", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00277-00068038-00068290": "following the Treaty of Versailles the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00278-00068291-00068503": "German portion was awarded to Australia", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00279-00068504-00068674": "which was already governing the British", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00280-00068675-00068902": "claim named the territory of Papua as a", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00281-00068903-00069169": "League of Nations mandate the eastern", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00282-00069170-00069319": "half of the island was granted", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00283-00069320-00069619": "independence from Australia in 1975 as", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00284-00069620-00069916": "Papua New Guinea the western half gained", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00285-00069917-00070207": "independence from the Dutch in 1961 but", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00286-00070208-00070420": "became part of Indonesia soon afterwards", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00287-00070421-00070953": "in controversial circumstances", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00288-00070954-00071468": "topic political divisions", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00289-00071469-00071786": "topic the island of New Guinea is", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00290-00071787-00072007": "divided politically into roughly equal", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00291-00072008-00072290": "halves across a north-south line the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00292-00072291-00072461": "western portion of the island located", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00293-00072462-00072740": "west of 141 degrees east longitude", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00294-00072741-00073004": "except for a small section of territory", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00295-00073005-00073168": "to the east of the fly River which", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00296-00073169-00073397": "belongs to Papua New Guinea was formerly", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00297-00073398-00073565": "a Dutch colony part of the Dutch East", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00298-00073566-00073831": "Indies after the Dutch New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00299-00073832-00073999": "dispute it is now two Indonesian", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00300-00074000-00074366": "provinces West Papua with manokwari as", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00301-00074367-00074650": "its capital popular with the city of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00302-00074651-00074999": "Jaya para as its capital the eastern", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00303-00075000-00075187": "part forms the mainland of Papua New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00304-00075188-00075380": "Guinea which has been an independent", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00305-00075381-00075734": "country since 1975 it was formerly the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00306-00075735-00075919": "territory of Papua and New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00307-00075920-00076150": "governed by Australia consisting of the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00308-00076151-00076292": "Trust Territory of New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00309-00076293-00076547": "northeastern quarter formerly German New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00310-00076548-00076732": "Guinea and the territory of Papua", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00311-00076733-00076987": "southeastern quarter the country", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00312-00076988-00077273": "consists of four regions Papua", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00313-00077274-00077569": "consisting of Western Gulf central Oro", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00314-00077570-00077815": "northern and Milne Bay provinces", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00315-00077816-00078029": "highlands consisting of southern", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00316-00078030-00078284": "highlands HeLa province G waka province", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00317-00078285-00078530": "anga province western highlands Simbu", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00318-00078531-00078836": "and Eastern Highlands provinces mo maize", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00319-00078837-00079130": "consisting of Moro Madang East Sepik and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00320-00079131-00079472": "sand on West's epic provinces islands", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00321-00079473-00079679": "consisting of Manas West New Britain", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00322-00079680-00079835": "East New Britain and New Ireland", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00323-00079836-00080005": "provinces and the Bougainville", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00324-00080006-00080478": "autonomous province", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00325-00080479-00080915": "topic people", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00326-00080916-00081242": "topic the current population of the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00327-00081243-00081463": "island of New Guinea is about 11 million", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00328-00081464-00081740": "many believe human habitation on the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00329-00081741-00082004": "island dates to as early as 50,000 BC", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00330-00082005-00082199": "and first settlement possibly dating", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00331-00082200-00082421": "back to 60,000 years ago has been", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00332-00082422-00082676": "proposed the island is presently", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00333-00082677-00082883": "populated by almost a thousand different", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00334-00082884-00083087": "tribal groups and a near equivalent", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00335-00083088-00083288": "number of separate languages which makes", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00336-00083289-00083423": "New Guinea the most linguistically", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00337-00083424-00083615": "diverse area in the world", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00338-00083616-00083993": "ethanol logs 14th edition lists 826", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00339-00083994-00084323": "languages of Papua New Guinea in 257", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00340-00084324-00084626": "languages of Irie and Jaya total 1073", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00341-00084627-00084857": "languages with 12 languages overlapping", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00342-00084858-00085136": "they fall into one of two groups the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00343-00085137-00085310": "poppelen languages in the Austronesian", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00344-00085311-00085652": "languages the separation was not merely", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00345-00085653-00085904": "linguistic warfare among societies was a", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00346-00085905-00086081": "factor in the evolution of the men's", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00347-00086082-00086279": "house separate housing of groups of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00348-00086280-00086501": "adult men from the single-family houses", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00349-00086502-00086675": "of the women and children for mutual", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00350-00086676-00086951": "protection from other tribal groups pig", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00351-00086952-00087146": "based trade between the groups and pig", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00352-00087147-00087344": "based feasts are a common theme with the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00353-00087345-00087530": "other peoples of Southeast Asia and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00354-00087531-00087821": "Oceania most societies practice", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00355-00087822-00088040": "agriculture supplemented by hunting and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00356-00088041-00088307": "gathering the great variety of the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00357-00088308-00088580": "island s indigenous populations has", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00358-00088581-00088802": "frequently assigned to one of two main", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00359-00088803-00089012": "ethnological divisions based on", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00360-00089013-00089270": "archaeological linguistic and genetic", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00361-00089271-00089507": "evidence the papua NAND Austronesian", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00362-00089508-00089726": "groups current evidence indicates that", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00363-00089727-00089930": "the pop ones who constitute the majority", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00364-00089931-00090293": "of the island s peoples are descended", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00365-00090294-00090476": "from the earliest human inhabitants of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00366-00090477-00090755": "New Guinea these original inhabitants", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00367-00090756-00090947": "first arrived in New Guinea at a time", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00368-00090948-00091166": "either side of the last glacial maximum", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00369-00091167-00091442": "approximately 21,000 years ago when the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00370-00091443-00091622": "island was connected to the Australian", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00371-00091623-00091829": "continent via land bridge forming the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00372-00091830-00092102": "landmass known as Sahul these peoples", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00373-00092103-00092294": "had made the shortened sea crossing from", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00374-00092295-00092498": "the islands of Wallacea and sundale in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00375-00092499-00092705": "the present malay archipelago by at", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00376-00092706-00092966": "least 40,000 years ago subsequent to the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00377-00092967-00093185": "dispersal of peoples from africa circa", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00378-00093186-00093611": "50,000 to 70,000 years ago the ancestral", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00379-00093612-00093782": "Austronesian peoples are believed to", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00380-00093783-00093938": "have arrived considerably later", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00381-00093939-00094232": "approximately 3500 years ago", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00382-00094233-00094479": "as part of a gradual seafaring migration", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00383-00094480-00094712": "from Southeast Asia possibly originating", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00384-00094713-00095012": "in Taiwan Austronesian speaking people's", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00385-00095013-00095219": "colonized many of the offshore islands", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00386-00095220-00095423": "to the north and east of New Guinea such", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00387-00095424-00095594": "as New Ireland and New Britain with", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00388-00095595-00095796": "settlements also on the coastal fringes", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00389-00095797-00096060": "of the main island in places human", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00390-00096061-00096269": "habitation of New Guinea over tens of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00391-00096270-00096453": "thousands of years has led to a great", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00392-00096454-00096636": "deal of diversity which was further", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00393-00096637-00096818": "increased by the later arrival of the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00394-00096819-00096962": "austronesians and the more recent", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00395-00096963-00097193": "history of European and Asian settlement", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00396-00097194-00097457": "through events like transmigration about", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00397-00097458-00097698": "half of the 2.4 million inhabitants of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00398-00097699-00097947": "Indonesian Papua are Javanese migrants", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00399-00097948-00098156": "large areas of New Guinea are yet to be", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00400-00098157-00098306": "explored by scientists and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00401-00098307-00098606": "anthropologists the Indonesian province", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00402-00098607-00098882": "of West Papua is home to an estimated 44", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00403-00098883-00099409": "uncontacted tribal groups", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00404-00099410-00099976": "epic biodiversity and ecology", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00405-00099977-00100420": "topic with some 786 thousand square", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00406-00100421-00100684": "kilometers of tropical land less than", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00407-00100685-00101100": "1/2 of 1% 0.5% of the earth s surface", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00408-00101101-00101416": "New Guinea has an immense biodiversity", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00409-00101417-00101644": "containing between five and ten percent", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00410-00101645-00101968": "of the total species on the planet this", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00411-00101969-00102187": "percentage is about the same amount as", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00412-00102188-00102376": "that found in the United States or", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00413-00102377-00102679": "Australia a high percentage of New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00414-00102680-00102946": "Guinea s species are endemic and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00415-00102947-00103138": "thousands are still unknown to science", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00416-00103139-00103386": "probably well over 200 thousand species", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00417-00103388-00103693": "of insect between 11,000 and 20,000", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00418-00103694-00103996": "plant species and over 650 resident bird", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00419-00103997-00104293": "species most of these species are shared", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00420-00104294-00104452": "at least in their origin with the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00421-00104453-00104658": "continent of Australia which was until", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00422-00104659-00104890": "fairly recent geological times part of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00423-00104891-00105088": "the same landmass see Australia New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00424-00105089-00105355": "Guinea for an overview the island is so", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00425-00105356-00105556": "large that it is considered nearly a", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00426-00105557-00105792": "continent in terms of its biological", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00427-00105793-00106195": "distinctiveness in the period from 1998", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00428-00106196-00106468": "to 2008 conservationists identified", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00429-00106469-00106717": "1,000 60 new species in New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00430-00106718-00107109": "including 218 plants 43 reptiles 12", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00431-00107110-00107500": "mammals 580 invertebrates 134 amphibians", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00432-00107501-00107914": "2 Birds and 71 fish bio geographically", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00433-00107915-00108130": "New Guinea is part of Australasia rather", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00434-00108131-00108319": "than the Indo Malayan realm although new", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00435-00108320-00108520": "Guineas flora has many more affinities", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00436-00108521-00108688": "with Asia than its fauna which is", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00437-00108689-00108970": "overwhelmingly Australian botanically", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00438-00108971-00109138": "New Guinea is considered part of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00439-00109139-00109375": "Malaysia a floristic region that extends", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00440-00109376-00109522": "from the Malay Peninsula across", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00441-00109523-00109699": "Indonesia to New Guinea in the East", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00442-00109700-00109972": "Melanesian islands the flora of New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00443-00109973-00110149": "Guinea as a mixture of many tropical", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00444-00110150-00110395": "rainforest species with origins in Asia", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00445-00110396-00110602": "together with typically Australasian", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00446-00110603-00110890": "flora typical southern hemisphere flora", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00447-00110891-00111115": "include the conifers Podocarpus and the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00448-00111116-00111322": "rainforests emergency route caria and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00449-00111323-00111529": "agathis as well as tree ferns and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00450-00111530-00111850": "several species of eucalyptus New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00451-00111851-00112192": "has 284 species and 6 orders of mammals", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00452-00112193-00112405": "monotremes three orders of marsupials", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00453-00112406-00112563": "rodents and bats", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00454-00112564-00112915": "195 of the mammal species 69% are", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00455-00112916-00113317": "endemic New Guinea has 578 species of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00456-00113318-00113359": "breed", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00457-00113360-00113668": "birds of which 324 species are endemic", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00458-00113669-00113929": "the islands frogs are one of the most", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00459-00113930-00114140": "poorly known vertebrate groups totalling", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00460-00114141-00114433": "282 species but this number is expected", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00461-00114434-00114610": "to double or even triple when all", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00462-00114611-00114875": "species have been documented New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00463-00114876-00115123": "has a rich diversity of coral life and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00464-00115124-00115378": "1,200 species of fish have been found", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00465-00115379-00115739": "also about 600 species of reef building", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00466-00115740-00116053": "coral the latter equal to 75% of the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00467-00116054-00116329": "world's known total the entire coral", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00468-00116330-00116566": "area covers 18 million hectares off a", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00469-00116567-00117113": "peninsula in northwest New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00470-00117114-00117610": "topic ecoregions", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00471-00117611-00117960": "topic", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00472-00117961-00118426": "topic Terrestrial", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00473-00118427-00118836": "topic according to the WWF New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00474-00118838-00119041": "can be divided into 12 terrestrial", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00475-00119042-00119338": "ecoregions central range montane rain", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00476-00119339-00119653": "forests central range sub-alpine", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00477-00119654-00119989": "grasslands huan peninsula montane rain", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00478-00119990-00120433": "forests New Guinea mangroves northern", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00479-00120433-00120616": "New Guinea lowland rain and freshwater", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00480-00120617-00120904": "swamp forests northern New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00481-00120905-00121264": "montane rain forests southeastern Papua", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00482-00121265-00121540": "name forests southern New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00483-00121541-00121860": "freshwater swamp forests southern New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00484-00121861-00122179": "Guinea lowland rainforests trans fly", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00485-00122180-00122527": "savanna and grasslands Vogel Kop montane", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00486-00122528-00122854": "rain forests Vogel kappa ruww lowland", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00487-00122855-00123202": "rain forests", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00488-00123203-00123686": "topic freshwater", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00489-00123688-00124125": "topic the WWF and Nature Conservancy", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00490-00124126-00124338": "divide New Guinea into five freshwater", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00491-00124339-00124788": "ecoregions Vogel cop Bambara New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00492-00124789-00125171": "North Coast New Guinea central mountains", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00493-00125172-00125461": "Southwest New Guinea trans fly lowland", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00494-00125463-00125890": "pop when potential a", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00495-00125891-00126375": "topic marine", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00496-00126376-00126809": "topic the WWF and Nature Conservancy", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00497-00126810-00127041": "identify several marine ecoregions in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00498-00127042-00127379": "the seas bordering New Guinea Papua", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00499-00127380-00127883": "Bismarck sea Solomon sea southeast Papua", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00500-00127884-00128610": "New Guinea Gulf of Papua era for a seat", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00501-00128611-00129154": "topic history", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00502-00129155-00129522": "topic", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00503-00129523-00130027": "topic early history", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00504-00130028-00130359": "topic the first inhabitants of New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00505-00130360-00130555": "Guinea arrived at least fifty thousand", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00506-00130556-00130720": "years ago having traveled through the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00507-00130721-00130990": "Southeast Asian Peninsula these first", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00508-00130991-00131170": "inhabitants from whom the pop when", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00509-00131171-00131398": "people are probably descended adapted to", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00510-00131399-00131581": "the range of ecologies and in time", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00511-00131582-00131737": "developed one of the earliest known", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00512-00131738-00131986": "Agriculture's remains of this", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00513-00131987-00132178": "agricultural system in the form of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00514-00132179-00132352": "ancient irrigation systems in the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00515-00132353-00132547": "Highlands of Papua New Guinea are being", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00516-00132548-00132850": "studied by archaeologists this work is", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00517-00132851-00133048": "still in its early stages so there is", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00518-00133049-00133261": "still uncertainty as to precisely what", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00519-00133262-00133450": "crop was being grown or when where a", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00520-00133451-00133792": "grigora rose sugarcane was cultivated", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00521-00133793-00133972": "for the first time in New Guinea around", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00522-00133973-00134233": "6000 BC the gardens of the New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00523-00134234-00134446": "Highlands are ancient intensive permit", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00524-00134447-00134650": "cultures adapted to high population", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00525-00134651-00134902": "densities very high rainfalls as high as", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00526-00134903-00135166": "10,000 millimeters per year 400 in per", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00527-00135167-00135205": "year", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00528-00135206-00135418": "earthquakes hilly land and occasional", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00529-00135419-00135778": "frost complex mulches crop rotations and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00530-00135779-00135955": "tillage azar used in rotation on", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00531-00135956-00136212": "terraces with complex irrigation systems", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00532-00136213-00136441": "Western agronomist still do not", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00533-00136442-00136651": "understand all of the practices and it", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00534-00136652-00136828": "has been noted that native gardeners are", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00535-00136829-00137029": "as or even more successful than most", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00536-00137030-00137239": "scientific farmers in raising certain", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00537-00137240-00137497": "crops there is evidence that New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00538-00137498-00137716": "gardeners invented crop rotation well", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00539-00137717-00137980": "before Western Europeans a unique", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00540-00137981-00138184": "feature of New Guinea permaculture as", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00541-00138185-00138424": "the Silva culture of casually Godin at", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00542-00138425-00138670": "all sturdy native Ironwood tree suited", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00543-00138671-00138853": "to use for timber and fuel with root", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00544-00138854-00139165": "nodules that fix nitrogen pollen studies", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00545-00139166-00139321": "show that it was adopted during an", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00546-00139322-00139525": "ancient period of extreme deforestation", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00547-00139526-00139855": "in more recent millennia another wave of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00548-00139856-00140011": "people arrived on the shores of New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00549-00140012-00140059": "Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00550-00140060-00140320": "these were the Austronesian people who", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00551-00140321-00140503": "had spread down from Taiwan through the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00552-00140504-00140731": "Southeast Asian archipelago colonizing", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00553-00140732-00140956": "many of the islands on the way the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00554-00140957-00141175": "Austronesian people had technology and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00555-00141176-00141403": "skills extremely well adapted to ocean", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00556-00141404-00141583": "voyage in an Austronesian language", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00557-00141584-00141775": "speaking people are present along much", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00558-00141776-00141976": "of the coastal areas and islands of New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00559-00141977-00142243": "Guinea these Austronesian migrants are", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00560-00142244-00142450": "considered the ancestors of most people", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00561-00142451-00142684": "in insular Southeast Asia from Sumatra", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00562-00142685-00142941": "and Java to Borneo and Sulawesi as well", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00563-00142942-00143334": "as coastal New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00564-00143335-00143891": "topic pre-colonial history", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00565-00143892-00144239": "topic the western part of the island was", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00566-00144240-00144440": "in contact with kingdoms in other parts", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00567-00144441-00144698": "of modern-day Indonesia the mega ray", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00568-00144699-00144893": "Curto Gama mentioned the region of 1 in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00569-00144894-00145070": "in eastern nusantara as part of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00570-00145071-00145370": "majapahit s tributary this has been", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00571-00145371-00145625": "identified with the onin Peninsula part", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00572-00145626-00145808": "of the Bambara insula and near the city", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00573-00145809-00146144": "of fake FAC the Sultans of t'adore in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00574-00146145-00146378": "Maluku islands claimed sovereignty over", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00575-00146379-00146617": "various coastal parts of the island", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00576-00146618-00147008": "during to doar s rule the main exports", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00577-00147009-00147170": "of the island during this period were", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00578-00147171-00147407": "resins spices slaves and the highly", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00579-00147408-00147625": "priced feathers of the bird of paradise", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00580-00147626-00147908": "Sultan nuku one of the most famous to", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00581-00147909-00148091": "d'Or Sultan's who rebelled against Dutch", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00582-00148092-00148358": "colonization called himself Sultan of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00583-00148359-00148655": "Tagore and Papua during his revolt in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00584-00148656-00148949": "1780s he commanded loyalty from both", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00585-00148950-00149186": "Moluccan and pop winch efz especially", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00586-00149187-00149468": "those of Raja Ampat Islands following", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00587-00149469-00149666": "two-doors defeat much of the territory", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00588-00149667-00149849": "it claimed in western part of New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00589-00149850-00150050": "came under Dutch rule as part of Dutch", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00590-00150051-00150576": "East Indies", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00591-00150577-00150947": "in contact", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00592-00150948-00151303": "topic the first European contact with", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00593-00151304-00151489": "New Guinea was by Portuguese and Spanish", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00594-00151490-00151990": "sailors in the 16th century in 1526 227", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00595-00151991-00152191": "the Portuguese explorer jorge de", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00596-00152192-00152389": "mayonnaises saw the western tip of New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00597-00152390-00152582": "Guinea and maimed a tillis dos papayas", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00598-00152583-00152972": "in 1528 the Spanish navigator Alvaro de", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00599-00152973-00153185": "Saavedra also recorded its sighting when", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00600-00153186-00153352": "trying to return from t'adore to New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00601-00153353-00153763": "Spain in 1545 the Spaniard amigo Ortiz", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00602-00153764-00153962": "de Reed sailed along the north coast of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00603-00153963-00154148": "New Guinea as far as the man Brahmo", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00604-00154149-00154358": "River near which he landed on the 20th", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00605-00154359-00154614": "of June naming the island nueva Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00606-00154615-00154888": "the first map showing the whole island", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00607-00154889-00155147": "as an island was published in 1600 and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00608-00155148-00155606": "chose it as Nova Guinea in 1606 luís Vaz", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00609-00155607-00155834": "de Torres explored the southern coast of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00610-00155835-00156025": "New Guinea from Milne Bay to the Gulf of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00611-00156026-00156248": "Papua including orangerie Bay which he", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00612-00156249-00156500": "named Bahia de San Lorenzo his", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00613-00156501-00156712": "expedition also discovered busalacchi", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00614-00156713-00156913": "Island naming it Tierra de San", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00615-00156914-00157112": "Buenaventura which he claimed for Spain", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00616-00157113-00157528": "in July 1606 on the 18th of October his", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00617-00157529-00157724": "expedition reached the western part of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00618-00157725-00157922": "the island in present-day Indonesia and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00619-00157923-00158113": "also claimed the territory for the king", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00620-00158114-00158425": "of Spain a successive European claim", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00621-00158426-00158669": "occurred in 1828 when the Netherlands", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00622-00158670-00158846": "formally claimed the western half of the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00623-00158847-00159175": "island as Netherlands New Guinea in 1883", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00624-00159176-00159356": "following a short-lived French", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00625-00159357-00159569": "annexation of new Ireland the British", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00626-00159570-00159814": "colony of Queensland and ex southeastern", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00627-00159815-00160073": "New Guinea however the Queensland", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00628-00160074-00160271": "Government's Superior's in the United", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00629-00160272-00160477": "Kingdom revoked the claim and formally", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00630-00160478-00160775": "assumed direct responsibility in 1884", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00631-00160776-00160978": "when Germany claimed northeastern New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00632-00160979-00161164": "Guinea as the Protectorate of German New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00633-00161165-00161398": "Guinea also called Kaiser Wilhelm's land", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00634-00161399-00161669": "the first Dutch government posts were", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00635-00161670-00161936": "established in 1898 and in 1902", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00636-00161937-00162281": "manokwari on the north coast fak fak in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00637-00162282-00162482": "the West and Muraki in the south at the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00638-00162483-00162722": "border with British New Guinea the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00639-00162723-00162908": "German Dutch and British colonial", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00640-00162909-00163075": "administrators each attempted to", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00641-00163076-00163276": "suppress the still widespread practices", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00642-00163277-00163477": "of inter village warfare and headhunting", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00643-00163478-00163723": "within their respective territories in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00644-00163724-00164000": "1905 the British government transferred", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00645-00164001-00164186": "some administrative responsibilities", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00646-00164187-00164324": "over Southeast New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00647-00164325-00164524": "to Australia which renamed the area", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00648-00164525-00164888": "territory of Papua and in 1906", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00649-00164889-00165019": "transferred all remaining", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00650-00165020-00165293": "responsibilities to Australia during", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00651-00165294-00165551": "World War one Australian forces seized", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00652-00165552-00165815": "German New Guinea which in 1920 became", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00653-00165816-00165983": "the territory of New Guinea to be", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00654-00165984-00166181": "administered by Australia under a League", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00655-00166182-00166469": "of Nations mandate the territories under", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00656-00166470-00166655": "Australian administration became", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00657-00166656-00166859": "collectively known as the territories of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00658-00166860-00167230": "Papua and New Guinea until February 1942", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00659-00167231-00167567": "before about 1930 European maps showed", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00660-00167568-00167765": "the Highlands as uninhabited forests", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00661-00167766-00167993": "when first flown over by aircraft", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00662-00167994-00168227": "numerous settlements with agricultural", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00663-00168228-00168512": "terraces and stockades were observed the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00664-00168513-00168731": "most startling discovery took place on", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00665-00168732-00168992": "the 4th of August 1938 when Richard", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00666-00168993-00169187": "Archibald discovered the Grand Valley of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00667-00169188-00169427": "the volume River which had 50,000 yet", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00668-00169428-00169634": "undiscovered Stone Age farmers living in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00669-00169635-00169907": "orderly villages the people known as the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00670-00169908-00170132": "Doni were the last Society of its size", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00671-00170133-00170324": "to make first contact with the rest of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00672-00170325-00170637": "the world", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00673-00170638-00171166": "Topic World War two", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00674-00171167-00171496": "topic Netherlands New Guinea and the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00675-00171497-00171703": "Australian territories were invaded in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00676-00171704-00172054": "1942 by the Japanese the Australian", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00677-00172055-00172231": "territories were put under military", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00678-00172232-00172426": "administration and were known simply as", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00679-00172427-00172699": "New Guinea the highlands northern and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00680-00172700-00172900": "eastern parts of the island became key", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00681-00172901-00173083": "battlefields in the southwest Pacific", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00682-00173084-00173320": "Theatre of World War two pop wounds", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00683-00173321-00173497": "often gave vital assistance to the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00684-00173498-00173695": "Allies fighting alongside Australian", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00685-00173696-00173878": "troops and carrying equipment and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00686-00173879-00174081": "injured men across New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00687-00174082-00174286": "approximately two hundred sixteen", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00688-00174287-00174511": "thousand Japanese Australian and US", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00689-00174512-00174730": "soldiers sailors and airmen died during", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00690-00174731-00175125": "the New Guinea campaign", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00691-00175126-00175676": "topic since World War two", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00692-00175677-00175981": "topic following the return to", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00693-00175982-00176312": "civilization after ww2 the Australian", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00694-00176313-00176501": "section was known as the territory of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00695-00176502-00176870": "Papua New Guinea from 1945 to 1949 and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00696-00176871-00177062": "then as territory of Papua and New", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00697-00177063-00177290": "Guinea although the rest of the Dutch", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00698-00177291-00177485": "East Indies achieved independence as", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00699-00177486-00177785": "Indonesia on the 27th of December 1949", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00700-00177786-00177971": "the Netherlands regained control of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00701-00177972-00178349": "western New Guinea during the 1950's the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00702-00178350-00178487": "Dutch government began to prepare", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00703-00178488-00178654": "Netherlands New Guinea for full", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00704-00178655-00178843": "independence and allowed elections in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00705-00178844-00179135": "1959 the elected New Guinea Council took", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00706-00179136-00179477": "office on the 5th of april 1961 the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00707-00179478-00179669": "council decided on the name of West", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00708-00179670-00179876": "Papua for the territory along with an", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00709-00179877-00180083": "emblem flag and anthem to complement", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00710-00180084-00180320": "those of the Netherlands on the 1st of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00711-00180321-00180616": "October 1962 the Dutch handed over the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00712-00180617-00180766": "territory to the United Nations", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00713-00180767-00181016": "temporary executive authority until the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00714-00181017-00181301": "1st of May 1963 when Indonesia took", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00715-00181302-00181619": "control the territory was renamed West I", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00716-00181620-00181931": "rien and then I rien de a-- in 1969", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00717-00181932-00182213": "Indonesia under the 1962 New York", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00718-00182214-00182423": "agreement organized a referendum named", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00719-00182424-00182585": "the act of free choice in which", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00720-00182586-00182795": "hand-picked poplin tribal elders reached", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00721-00182796-00182996": "a consensus to continue the union with", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00722-00182997-00183200": "Indonesia there has been resistance to", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00723-00183201-00183404": "Indonesian integration and occupation", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00724-00183405-00183629": "both through civil disobedience such as", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00725-00183630-00183841": "morningstar flag raising ceremony", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00726-00183842-00184049": "and via the formation of the organizati", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00727-00184050-00184379": "Papua Merdeka OPM or free Papua movement", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00728-00184380-00184741": "in 1965 Amnesty International has", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00729-00184742-00185003": "estimated more than 100,000 pop wins", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00730-00185004-00185231": "1/6 of the population have died as a", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00731-00185232-00185411": "result of government sponsored violence", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00732-00185412-00185891": "against West Papua 1971 the name Papua", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00733-00185892-00186083": "New Guinea was used for the Australian", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00734-00186084-00186470": "territory on the 16th of September 1975", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00735-00186471-00186707": "Australia granted full independence to", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00736-00186708-00187073": "Papua New Guinea in 2000 area and Jaya", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00737-00187074-00187298": "was formally renamed the province of", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00738-00187299-00187607": "Papua and a lon special autonomy was", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00739-00187608-00187940": "passed in 2001 the law established a", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00740-00187941-00188186": "poplin People's Assembly MRP with", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00741-00188187-00188315": "representatives of the different", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00742-00188316-00188675": "indigenous cultures of Papua the MRP was", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00743-00188676-00188872": "empowered to protect the rights of Papua", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00744-00188873-00189061": "nice of women in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00745-00189062-00189247": "puah and to ease religious tensions in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00746-00189248-00189436": "Papua block grants were given for the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00747-00189437-00189763": "implementation of the law as much as 266", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00748-00189764-00190102": "million dollars in 2004 the Indonesian", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00749-00190103-00190252": "courts enforcement of the law and", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00750-00190253-00190447": "special autonomy blocked further", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00751-00190448-00190651": "creation of subdivisions of Papua", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00752-00190652-00190824": "although president Megawati Sukarnoputri", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00753-00190825-00191104": "was able to create a separate West Papua", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00754-00191105-00191328": "province in 2003 as a fait accompli", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00755-00191329-00191593": "plans for a third province on western", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00756-00191594-00191778": "New Guinea were blocked by the courts", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00757-00191779-00192007": "critics argue that the Indonesian", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00758-00192008-00192148": "government has been reluctant to", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00759-00192149-00192361": "establish or issue various government", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00760-00192362-00192541": "implementing regulations so that the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00761-00192542-00192741": "legal provisions of special autonomy", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00762-00192742-00192910": "could be put into practice and as a", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00763-00192911-00193144": "result special autonomy in Papua has", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00764-00193145-00193477": "failed", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00765-00193478-00193991": "topic religions", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00766-00193992-00194688": "topic see religion in Papua New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00767-00194689-00195213": "topic see also", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00768-00195214-00195669": "topic Papua conflict West New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00769-00195670-00196242": "dispute Papua unification", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00770-00196243-00196844": "topic notes and references", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00771-00196845-00197239": "topic", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00772-00197240-00197779": "topic bibliography", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00773-00197780-00198184": "topic Jared Diamond Guns Germs and Steel", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00774-00198185-00198421": "a short history of everybody for the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00775-00198422-00198985": "last 13 thousand years 1997", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00776-00198986-00199533": "topic external links", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00777-00199534-00199925": "topic facsimile of material from the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00778-00199926-00200078": "discovery of New Guinea", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00779-00200079-00200453": "by George Collingridge scientists hailed", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00780-00200454-00200663": "discovery of hundreds of new species in", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00781-00200664-00201179": "remote New Guinea Papua New Guinea the", "QHGN_oKcm8U-00782-00201180-00201621": "new students reference work 1914"}}, {"audio_id": "QHQwjiLBJ8U", "text": {"QHQwjiLBJ8U-00000-00000064-00000206": "hey everyone welcome back to another", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00001-00000208-00000503": "video today i'm today", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00002-00000504-00000751": "we are we are like playing we are", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00003-00000752-00000950": "playing a game called", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00004-00000951-00001183": "like we're playing this game called like", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00005-00001184-00001399": "so today we're playing", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00006-00001400-00001751": "we're playing this game called uh", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00007-00001752-00002134": "someone's and lab blah blah dot zip comp", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00008-00002135-00002350": "entry", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00009-00002351-00002455": "so", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00010-00002456-00002567": "let's", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00011-00002568-00002791": "let's get into the video", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00012-00002792-00003063": "okay here we are if before we head into", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00013-00003064-00003254": "the video guys i just want to say one", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00014-00003255-00003335": "thing", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00015-00003336-00003527": "i want to get the heads out i want to", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00016-00003528-00003806": "get the 10 000 subscribers and i need", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00017-00003807-00004079": "all of your help and i need 1 000 watch", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00018-00004079-00004303": "hours and i need all of your help so", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00019-00004304-00004495": "make sure you smash subscribe by hit the", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00020-00004496-00004663": "bell icon to be notified when i upload a", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00021-00004664-00004927": "new video", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00022-00004928-00005311": "all that let's get to the video okay", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00023-00005312-00005591": "okay guys here we are today let's speed", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00024-00005592-00005711": "this first", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00025-00005712-00005902": "book and quell", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00026-00005903-00006070": "hello and welcome to the end for", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00027-00006071-00006318": "minecraft story mode this is an entry", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00028-00006319-00006670": "for law dot zips com competition", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00029-00006672-00006910": "like kind of like the map like a map and", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00030-00006911-00007083": "kinda", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00031-00007084-00007287": "nah and", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00032-00007288-00007487": "you basically just have to explore the", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00033-00007488-00007695": "end step on gold pads to see what jesse", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00034-00007695-00007863": "has to say about that", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00035-00007864-00008014": "enjoy", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00036-00008015-00008207": "and enjoy", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00037-00008208-00008258": "all right", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00038-00008259-00008391": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00039-00008392-00008535": "all right", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00040-00008536-00008719": "let's go", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00041-00008720-00009199": "speed of the information", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00042-00009200-00009406": "until they did defeat the dragon they", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00043-00009407-00010119": "must must be the oil back", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00044-00010120-00010238": "wow", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00045-00010239-00010359": "look at this", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00046-00010360-00010574": "all right graphing spelling and crafting", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00047-00010575-00010799": "on the go cool", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00048-00010800-00011006": "eyes one freaking cool bridge", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00049-00011007-00011246": "okay", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00050-00011247-00011406": "i'm gonna fly with it there we go let's", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00051-00011407-00011806": "fly over there", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00052-00011807-00012391": "let's go", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00053-00012392-00012487": "okay", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00054-00012488-00012599": "next up", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00055-00012600-00012863": "so many steps", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00056-00012863-00012927": "yeah fun", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00057-00012928-00013286": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00058-00013287-00013527": "okay guys", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00059-00013528-00013607": "so", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00060-00013608-00013807": "here we are", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00061-00013808-00014022": "i still hold that's good", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00062-00014023-00014375": "this must be we have to do it layout lab", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00063-00014376-00014655": "house", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00064-00014656-00014881": "all right let's go and head up here", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00065-00014882-00015415": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00066-00015416-00015591": "wow", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00067-00015593-00015822": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00068-00015823-00016071": "full boiled pipes on", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00069-00016072-00016286": "how it", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00070-00016287-00016503": "this much it's the most amazing thing", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00071-00016504-00016750": "i've ever seen", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00072-00016751-00016975": "i should probably explore real world and", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00073-00016976-00017119": "there's a lot more things it's always", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00074-00017120-00017232": "built", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00075-00017233-00018079": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00076-00018080-00018511": "wow this is a really cool place", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00077-00018512-00018775": "i need to get that open", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00078-00018776-00018975": "nope not gonna work okay we need the", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00079-00018976-00019018": "leather", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00080-00019019-00019980": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00081-00019981-00021143": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00082-00021144-00021584": "let's set all the levels off", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00083-00021585-00022622": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00084-00022623-00022750": "all right", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00085-00022751-00023247": "we got", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00086-00023248-00023558": "okay that won't work", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00087-00023559-00023750": "oh there we go there's one", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00088-00023751-00024439": "the next one on", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00089-00024440-00024567": "now let's go ahead and see what else we", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00090-00024568-00024830": "got here", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00091-00024831-00024983": "yep oh", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00092-00024984-00025457": "we have left this is this one", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00093-00025458-00026535": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00094-00026536-00026708": "is", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00095-00026708-00028166": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00096-00028167-00029039": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00097-00029039-00029937": "go", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00098-00029938-00030614": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00099-00030616-00030758": "again", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00100-00030760-00031007": "this is awesome", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00101-00031008-00031452": "all right", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00102-00031454-00032345": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00103-00032345-00033646": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00104-00033647-00034390": "that", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00105-00034391-00037826": "yeah guys just a heads up", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00106-00037827-00037943": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00107-00037944-00038607": "okay yeah let's just go for finally", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00108-00038608-00038887": "holy crap", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00109-00038888-00040015": "oh my god", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00110-00040016-00040255": "oh", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00111-00040256-00040487": "oh my god", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00112-00040488-00041102": "it actually worked", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00113-00041103-00041246": "but the whole thing is", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00114-00041247-00041518": "look it's gone it's gone for two more", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00115-00041519-00041839": "look i look so cool in the end of that", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00116-00041840-00042062": "okay yeah let's just put all this back", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00117-00042063-00042143": "now", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00118-00042144-00042343": "because yeah let's just it's a good idea", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00119-00042344-00042687": "for all this back though because", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00120-00042688-00042862": "well because like there's someone might", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00121-00042863-00043055": "find that i still wasn't going to he", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00122-00043056-00043215": "probably could be on it because the", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00123-00043216-00043415": "other one's always gone", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00124-00043416-00043655": "all right let's put this back because he", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00125-00043656-00043815": "might think i still let him never call", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00126-00043816-00043927": "the police i mean", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00127-00043928-00044230": "anyway i'm just kidding guys okay guys", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00128-00044231-00044535": "another one", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00129-00044536-00045151": "really cool to be honest though", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00130-00045152-00045367": "wow this is awesome guys everyone knows", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00131-00045368-00045527": "probably down in the description down", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00132-00045528-00046174": "below", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00133-00046175-00046502": "heavy really good yeah", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00134-00046503-00046718": "come on", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00135-00046719-00046911": "only five please", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00136-00046912-00047271": "very good for the halloween season", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00137-00047272-00047415": "all right", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00138-00047416-00048011": "let's head back", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00139-00048012-00048743": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00140-00048744-00048843": "go open", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00141-00048844-00050383": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00142-00050384-00050567": "wow this place is really used to be", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00143-00050568-00050783": "honest", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00144-00050784-00050999": "all right let's head down back to so", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00145-00051000-00051494": "many stacks", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00146-00051495-00051782": "well i just hit my ankle right now", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00147-00051783-00051950": "yeah i might need it for the hospital", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00148-00051951-00052326": "i'm blessed with you guys", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00149-00052327-00052524": "there's so many stuff i know", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00150-00052525-00052735": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00151-00052736-00052894": "guys if you i used to play my personal", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00152-00052895-00053782": "personality", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00153-00053783-00054319": "here try these", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00154-00054320-00054519": "thinking what's the matter okay why are", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00155-00054520-00054703": "you staring me like that", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00156-00054704-00054999": "nothing what's wrong nothing", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00157-00055000-00055607": "sure", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00158-00055608-00057023": "how do you like them good girlfriend", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00159-00057024-00057238": "all right", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00160-00057239-00057430": "okay guys", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00161-00057432-00057807": "so here we are", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00162-00057808-00058007": "yeah this is really cool", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00163-00058008-00058199": "whoever's watching who the creative if", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00164-00058200-00058487": "you are watching this i really want you", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00165-00058488-00058639": "i really gotta thank you for this", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00166-00058640-00058775": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00167-00058776-00058871": "where are you", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00168-00058872-00059338": "making the video", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00169-00059339-00060359": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00170-00060360-00060703": "okay guys that's all for today's video", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00171-00060704-00061006": "please put all this on", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00172-00061007-00061140": "yeah guys so today", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00173-00061141-00061287": "[Music]", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00174-00061288-00061550": "hey guys if you have enjoyed the video", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00175-00061551-00062063": "subscribe to the channel if you want me", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00176-00062064-00062247": "okay that will wrap up today's tutorial", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00177-00062248-00062503": "guys let me first take off all this off", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00178-00062504-00062615": "now", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00179-00062616-00062823": "i won't be needing this now if you ever", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00180-00062824-00062950": "do the video guys", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00181-00062951-00063126": "make sure you subscribe to my channel", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00182-00063127-00063303": "get me the one", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00183-00063304-00063494": "mention watch all my videos and get me", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00184-00063495-00063694": "the 4 000 watch hours and get me the", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00185-00063695-00063903": "1000 subscribers", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00186-00063904-00064094": "and i want 50 000 likes on this video", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00187-00064095-00064191": "alright", "QHQwjiLBJ8U-00188-00064191-00064572": "see you next time goodbye"}}, {"audio_id": "QHVIjIpM--g", "text": {"QHVIjIpM--g-00000-00000048-00000214": "all right that's all for today as a", "QHVIjIpM--g-00001-00000215-00000407": "reminder uh two important riders no", "QHVIjIpM--g-00002-00000408-00000526": "homework problem today", "QHVIjIpM--g-00003-00000527-00000799": "that's intentional to give you a chance", "QHVIjIpM--g-00004-00000800-00000966": "to practice for tomorrow's midterm", "QHVIjIpM--g-00005-00000967-00001158": "um i wish you the best of luck on the", "QHVIjIpM--g-00006-00001159-00001287": "midterm um", "QHVIjIpM--g-00007-00001288-00001511": "take time review the practice midterm", "QHVIjIpM--g-00008-00001512-00001687": "review the homework problems", "QHVIjIpM--g-00009-00001688-00001855": "go back do a couple make sure that you", "QHVIjIpM--g-00010-00001855-00002118": "can do them under some time pressure", "QHVIjIpM--g-00011-00002119-00002295": "um and in a way that allows you to", "QHVIjIpM--g-00012-00002296-00002455": "recover from mistakes", "QHVIjIpM--g-00013-00002456-00002710": "um again i can't say enough check out", "QHVIjIpM--g-00014-00002711-00002871": "the practice exam that's very similar to", "QHVIjIpM--g-00015-00002872-00003023": "what to be encountering tomorrow", "QHVIjIpM--g-00016-00003024-00003158": "uh get a good night's sleep show up", "QHVIjIpM--g-00017-00003159-00003335": "tomorrow ready to go and you will do", "QHVIjIpM--g-00018-00003336-00003399": "great", "QHVIjIpM--g-00019-00003400-00003838": "so can't wait uh see you then um and uh", "QHVIjIpM--g-00020-00003839-00004112": "that's all"}}, {"audio_id": "QHYYq2VjCNu", "text": {"QHYYq2VjCNu-00000-00000046-00000333": "this list of cultural icons of France is", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00001-00000334-00000503": "a list of links to potential cultural", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00002-00000504-00001137": "icons of France", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00003-00001138-00001660": "topic animals", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00004-00001661-00001984": "abundance cattle alsace hamster one Aria", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00005-00001985-00002317": "schwa a brac cattle basque shepherd dog", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00006-00002318-00002572": "Basset artesian Normand basset bleu de", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00007-00002573-00002791": "Gascogne Basset folk de Bretagne", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00008-00002792-00002971": "beauceron Berger Picard", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00009-00002972-00003204": "Bronto Vern Brock do Bourbonnais breast", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00010-00003206-00003561": "chicken Bryan kemar horse Cheryl a", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00011-00003563-00003970": "cattle blue Picardy spaniel Tavor Elle's", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00012-00003971-00004257": "chicken french bulldog french spaniel", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00013-00004258-00004584": "grande bleu de Gascogne great pyrenees", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00014-00004585-00004900": "hudan chicken la flesche main Anjou", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00015-00004901-00005254": "cattle Wesen sheep petite basset griffon", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00016-00005255-00005521": "vendian Picardy spaniel Pyrenean", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00017-00005522-00005719": "Shepherd ruined", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00018-00005720-00006156": "duck", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00019-00006157-00006885": "topic art craft Francoise Busha Bernard", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00020-00006886-00007279": "buffet to Paul says an 3gen baptist", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00021-00007280-00007494": "camille corot Gustave Courbet", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00022-00007495-00007789": "jacques-louis David Edgard Agha for", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00023-00007790-00008062": "Eugene Delacroix Robert de l'année andré", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00024-00008063-00008362": "Derain Marcel Duchamp Jean Andre", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00025-00008363-00008784": "Fragonard Paul Gauguin five giverny six", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00026-00008785-00009106": "Rene Lalique seven liqueur Buchi a fern", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00027-00009107-00009451": "and Lachey Edouard Manet onry Matisse", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00028-00009452-00009788": "Mona Lisa Claude Monet Camille Pissarro", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00029-00009789-00010174": "Nicolas Poussin pierre-auguste renoir a", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00030-00010175-00010537": "GU strode an eight niki de st. foul nine", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00031-00010538-00010821": "George Syrah on readed toulouse-lautrec", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00032-00010822-00011320": "jorge de Latour Maurice Utrillo Antoine", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00033-00011321-00011825": "Watteau 10", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00034-00011826-00012418": "topic buildings and structures", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00035-00012419-00012796": "arc de triomphe centre pompidou 11", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00036-00012797-00013030": "chateau de chambord chateau guard", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00037-00013031-00013504": "chignon eiffel tower 12 13 French", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00038-00013505-00013960": "architecture G la défense 14 less", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00039-00013961-00014290": "invalid louvre louvre pyramid montz on", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00040-00014291-00014650": "michel news a dorsey Notre Dame demeans", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00041-00014651-00014908": "Notre Dame de char trees note redeem de", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00042-00014909-00015235": "Paris notre-dame Durant's palace of", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00043-00015236-00015444": "versailles palais des papes punt in", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00044-00015446-00015751": "Normandy Saint Denis Basilica st.", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00045-00015752-00016462": "Chapelle viaduc de millau 15", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00046-00016463-00017008": "topic dress fashion", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00047-00017009-00017389": "Pierre Balmain Coco Chanel 1617", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00048-00017390-00017711": "couturier Christian Dior 18 jean-paul", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00049-00017712-00017969": "Gaultier Hubert de Givenchy Christian", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00050-00017970-00018181": "Lacroix Thierry Mugler Sonia Rykiel", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00051-00018182-00018580": "eve-san Laurent 1920 philippe starck 21", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00052-00018581-00019173": "louis vuitton Lacoste", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00053-00019174-00019901": "topic emblems and symbols flag of France", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00054-00019902-00020608": "fleur de lys Marianne", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00055-00020609-00021123": "topic festivals", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00056-00021124-00021821": "Bastille Day revel on", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00057-00021822-00022363": "topic food and drink", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00058-00022364-00022723": "epilation door regime control a bistro", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00059-00022724-00023119": "Raymond Blanc 22 Paul Bocuse 23 Bordeaux", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00060-00023120-00023620": "wine 24 Bourgogne wine camembert 25 26", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00061-00023621-00023920": "champagne wine crepe croissant cuisine", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00062-00023921-00024448": "of France 27 Alain Ducasse 28 a goose", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00063-00024449-00024869": "Escoffier 29 galette 30 guide michelin", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00064-00024870-00025368": "oak cuisine jean-christophe Novelli 31", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00065-00025369-00025938": "Albert rue Michel Roux 32 tapenade 33", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00066-00025939-00026454": "cognac", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00067-00026455-00026954": "topic government", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00068-00026955-00027257": "Armada Terra Armada lair gender marine", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00069-00027258-00027578": "nationale a marine nationale a lesion", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00070-00027579-00027847": "eight Ranger communes of France", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00071-00027848-00028106": "constitution of France Constitutional", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00072-00028107-00028384": "Council of France Court of Cassation", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00073-00028385-00028601": "Declaration of the Rights of Man and of", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00074-00028602-00028790": "the citizen departments of France", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00075-00028791-00029188": "deputy elections in France Elysee Palace", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00076-00029189-00029435": "French Economic and Social Council", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00077-00029436-00029786": "French Republic Journal oficial de la", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00078-00029787-00030046": "république française justice in France", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00079-00030047-00030514": "law of France municipalities of France", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00080-00030515-00030767": "Napoleonic Code National Assembly of", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00081-00030768-00031079": "France Parliament of France political", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00082-00031080-00031265": "parties in France president of the", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00083-00031266-00031496": "French Republic 34 Prime Minister of", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00084-00031497-00031886": "France regions of France Senate of", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00085-00031887-00032345": "France", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00086-00032347-00032914": "topic history and legend", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00087-00032915-00033265": "ancient regime Auld Alliance Battle of", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00088-00033266-00033629": "Waterloo 35 Bourbon restoration Hugh", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00089-00033630-00033814": "Capet Capetian cardinal richelieu", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00090-00033815-00034126": "Charlemagne 36 Clovis Gen Baptist", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00091-00034127-00034529": "Kolbert Empress Josephine field of the", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00092-00034530-00034615": "cloth-of-gold", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00093-00034616-00034840": "5th Republic French Revolution first", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00094-00034841-00035167": "Empire Fourth Republic Charles de Gaulle", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00095-00035168-00035647": "37 House of Bourbon House of Valois Joan", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00096-00035648-00036168": "of Arc July monarchy louis xiv louis xvi", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00097-00036169-00036635": "napoleon bonaparte second empire third", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00098-00036636-00037198": "republic Treaty of Verdun", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00099-00037199-00037713": "topic holidays", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00100-00037714-00038294": "holidays in France", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00101-00038295-00038818": "topic industry", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00102-00038819-00039319": "Air France Airbus Airbus a400m andre", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00103-00039320-00039676": "citroen EDF électricité de France", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00104-00039677-00040263": "38 Gaz de France 39 Armand pooja 40", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00105-00040264-00041002": "Marcel Renault France Telecom", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00106-00041003-00041514": "topic language", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00107-00041515-00041931": "academi Francaise 41:42 Alsatian Basque", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00108-00041932-00042287": "Breton Catala Corsa Francophonie 43", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00109-00042288-00042492": "French international francophone", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00110-00042493-00042732": "organisation long diak Occitan", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00111-00042733-00043386": "provençale romance Toobin law", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00112-00043387-00044112": "topic literature newspapers comics", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00113-00044113-00044406": "Alain robbe-grillet 44 along Fournier", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00114-00044407-00044664": "Jeana nuit Guillaume Apollinaire Louis", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00115-00044665-00044939": "Aragon Asterix 45 honoré de Balzac", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00116-00044940-00045216": "charles baudelaire 46 pierre", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00117-00045217-00045522": "beaumarchais simone de beauvoir 47 48", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00118-00045523-00045780": "Cyrano de Bergerac George burn a nose", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00119-00045781-00046137": "Andre Breton Albert Camus led canard and", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00120-00046138-00046392": "Jane a louis ferdinand Celine chansons", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00121-00046393-00046623": "de Geste pretty ended Troy's Pierre", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00122-00046624-00046973": "chodri laws delay close Paul Claudel jmg", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00123-00046974-00047358": "LeClair 49 Jean Cocteau Colette Pierre", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00124-00047359-00047435": "Corneille", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00125-00047436-00047754": "Rene Descartes Denis Diderot Alexandre", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00126-00047755-00048036": "Dumas Alexandre Dumas fills Marguerite", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00127-00048037-00048312": "Duras bless a chose paul eluard", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00128-00048313-00048747": "L'Express george fado la Figaro Gustave", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00129-00048748-00048993": "Flaubert Jean de la Fontaine Anatole", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00130-00048994-00049371": "France Roman Gary Te'o field go da g m--", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00131-00049372-00049680": "janae Andre Gide Jean giono James your", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00132-00049681-00049989": "adieu renege of shiney jean ed inhaler", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00133-00049990-00050436": "Victor Hugo 50 Eugene ionesco Jean de la", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00134-00050437-00050685": "Fontaine Alphonse de Lamartine Lieber", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00135-00050686-00051123": "asean 51 stéphane mallarmé andre malroux", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00136-00051124-00051360": "Guy de Maupassant Francois mouriak", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00137-00051361-00051789": "Moliere 52 Lamont man in the iron mask", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00138-00051790-00052055": "Marcel Pagnell Blaise Pascal Charles", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00139-00052057-00052277": "Perrault Jacques Prevert Marcel Proust", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00140-00052278-00052532": "led nouvel Observateur", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00141-00052533-00052944": "look petit Prince Prix Goncourt Francois", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00142-00052945-00053172": "Rabelais Jean Racine Arthur Rimbaud", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00143-00053173-00053457": "Roman de la Rose Roman de Renard Reynard", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00144-00053458-00053574": "Edmond Rostand", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00145-00053575-00053970": "jean-jacques rousseau Francois Seguin 53", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00146-00053971-00054162": "jean-paul Sartre the Song of Roland", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00147-00054163-00054473": "Antoine de saint-exupery Stendhal", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00148-00054474-00055029": "tristan and isolde albert uderzo 54 paul", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00149-00055029-00055154": "Valeri paul verlaine", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00150-00055155-00055442": "jules verne boris vian Francois Villon", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00151-00055444-00056251": "Voltaire 55 emile zola 56", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00152-00056252-00056757": "topic music", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00153-00056758-00057113": "music of France richard anthony charles", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00154-00057114-00057435": "aznavour daniel balavoine Barbara", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00155-00057436-00057557": "Gilbert buco", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00156-00057558-00057879": "Michel burger Berlioz 57 georges bizet", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00157-00057879-00058140": "pierre boulez lucci and Boyer georges", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00158-00058141-00058509": "brassens Jacques Brel 58 marc-antoine", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00159-00058510-00058779": "Charpentier maurice chevalier Francois", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00160-00058779-00058988": "Cooper and Delita", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00161-00058989-00059361": "Claude Debussy 59 sasha de Stael 60 Paul", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00162-00059362-00059673": "Dukas jacques du tron gabriel fauré", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00163-00059674-00060021": "Claude Francois say Tsar Franck Serge", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00164-00060022-00060230": "Gainsbourg France gall Stephane", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00165-00060232-00060442": "Grappelli 61 jean-jacques Goldman", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00166-00060444-00060851": "Juliette Greco Johnny Hallyday françoise", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00167-00060852-00060929": "Hardy", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00168-00060929-00061417": "Jean Michel Jarre 62 Maurice Jarre 63", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00169-00061419-00061580": "michel legrand", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00170-00061582-00061841": "gen baptist Lully Mireille Mathieu", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00171-00061842-00062121": "olivier messiaen darius milhaud miss", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00172-00062122-00062435": "ting wit eve montant Yannick Noah", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00173-00062436-00062910": "Jacques Offenbach Eddie Piaf 64 Francis", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00174-00062911-00063240": "Poulenc jean-philippe Remo maurice ravel", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00175-00063241-00063576": "65 Tino Rossi Claude Joseph rouget de", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00176-00063577-00063917": "Lisle Jean Sablin Camille saint-saens on", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00177-00063919-00064236": "reefs Alva door 66 Eric sati alan", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00178-00064237-00064461": "stivell Charles Trenet", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00179-00064462-00064959": "67 troubadour true ver Sylvie Vartan yay", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00180-00064960-00065665": "yay Hector Zazu 68", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00181-00065666-00066157": "topic people", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00182-00066158-00066526": "list of French people obey Pierre Pierre", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00183-00066527-00066862": "a Ballard Yann Arthus Bertrand Raymond", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00184-00066863-00067126": "bar Simone de Beauvoir onry Bergson", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00185-00067127-00067234": "Bernard of Clairvaux", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00186-00067235-00067513": "Louis Blair you Leon Blum Louis Braille", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00187-00067514-00067912": "pascal bruckner Enric Arden 69 on", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00188-00067913-00068149": "ricardio bresson Charlemagne Jacques", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00189-00068150-00068374": "Chirac Georges Clemenceau Eve King", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00190-00068375-00068641": "garlic or busi a Marie Curie Pierre", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00191-00068642-00068950": "Curie Jacques Dolores Jacques Derrida", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00192-00068951-00069046": "Rene Descartes", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00193-00069047-00069400": "Alfred Dreyfus Marguerite Durand Gustave", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00194-00069401-00069714": "Eiffel Laurent Fabius Pierre de Fermat", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00195-00069715-00070069": "franco-belgian comics Charles de Gaulle", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00196-00070070-00070420": "Valeri Giscard d'Estaing Giselle Holly", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00197-00070421-00070708": "me Baron Haussmann Pierre John Durr a", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00198-00070709-00070972": "gene Joe Ray's frédéric joliot-curie", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00199-00070973-00071410": "Lionel Jospin Roger lands 70 on read as", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00200-00071411-00071646": "rail Andrew Jack Lang Antoine Lavoisier", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00201-00071647-00072019": "jean-marie Le Pen 71 a GU stand Louis", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00202-00072020-00072298": "lumière Jules hard when man's art", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00203-00072299-00072517": "jean-paul merit Pierre Mendes France", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00204-00072518-00072796": "Francois Mitterrand Jean Monnet Michel", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00205-00072797-00073033": "de Montaigne Montesquieu Montgolfier", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00206-00073034-00073381": "brothers Maurice Papon Blaise Pascal", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00207-00073382-00073723": "Louis Pasteur Philippe Peyton say Tsar", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00208-00073724-00073998": "it's Jean Rostand ségolène royal a", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00209-00073999-00074320": "goosed Sabatier Odette Sansom Nicolas", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00210-00074321-00074724": "Sarkozy sir Emmanuel 72 Violette Szabo", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00211-00074725-00074983": "Charles maurice de Talleyrand Pierre", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00212-00074984-00075118": "Teilhard de Chardin", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00213-00075119-00075535": "Germaine Tilian 73 Jacques Toobin boban", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00214-00075536-00075804": "Dominique de Villepin verson jet uruk's", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00215-00075805-00076367": "Simone Weil", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00216-00076368-00076878": "topic places", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00217-00076879-00077385": "alt Brittany kemar Carcassonne cévennes", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00218-00077386-00077711": "cities of France Corsica cote d'azur", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00219-00077712-00078087": "gardens of france Garron lakes of France", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00220-00078088-00078528": "Lille lawar Lourdes 74 Lyon Marseille", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00221-00078529-00078840": "massive central Mediterranean Mont Blanc", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00222-00078841-00079386": "75 not nice Normandy Paris Pyrenees", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00223-00079387-00079802": "puy-de-dôme Bronx Rhone rivers of France", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00224-00079803-00080376": "same 76 to lose World Heritage Sites in", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00225-00080377-00080835": "France", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00226-00080836-00081400": "topic shopping money", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00227-00081401-00082169": "crédit Agricole 77 galleries Lafayette", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00228-00082170-00082802": "topic sport Fabien Barthez", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00229-00082803-00083156": "boule Philippe candle or Oh Eric Cantona", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00230-00083157-00083497": "Pierre de Coubertin Emile delahaye", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00231-00083498-00084061": "French Open Grand Prix tre honoree", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00232-00084062-00084496": "jean-claude Killy Laura man ado Lamont's", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00233-00084497-00084890": "Yannick Noah parkour gwendal pesarattu", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00234-00084891-00085183": "pétanque a Michel Platini Alain Prost", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00235-00085184-00085658": "Roland Garros staad de France Tour de", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00236-00085659-00086029": "France David Trezeguet Patrick Vieira", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00237-00086030-00086165": "arsene wenger", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00238-00086166-00086850": "78 zinedine zidane", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00239-00086851-00087574": "topic television radio film theater", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00240-00087575-00087934": "Anouk ma Charles Aznavour Brigitte", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00241-00087935-00088293": "Bardot 79 jean-paul Belmondo Luc Besson", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00242-00088294-00088668": "Juliette Binoche Charles Boyer Canal+", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00243-00088669-00088950": "Ken Film Festival ad Marcel carné", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00244-00088951-00089226": "jean-pierre castle Laetitia Casta Claude", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00245-00089227-00089428": "Chabrol cinema of France", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00246-00089429-00089748": "Clotilde corral Comedie Francaise 81", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00247-00089749-00090061": "jean de lanois 82 alain delon", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00248-00090062-00090312": "catherine deneuve 83 Gerard Depardieu", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00249-00090313-00090755": "Guillaume Depardieu 84 Jean de Sayle 85", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00250-00090756-00091165": "Bridget Fauci luis de Funes Jean Gabin", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00251-00091166-00091498": "Lyon comment any Gerardo jean-luc Godard", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00252-00091499-00091836": "sacha guitry isabelle huppert", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00253-00091837-00092074": "jean-pierre laio Claude Lelouch", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00254-00092075-00092449": "Augusto Lumiere Louis lumière Luis mal", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00255-00092450-00092728": "Marcel Marceau Sophie Marceau Jean", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00256-00092729-00092971": "Marais George melis miss ting wit Eve", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00257-00092972-00093324": "Mont and Jean Moreau 86 Michelle Morgan", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00258-00093325-00093715": "Nouvelle Vague Marcel Pagnell Patrick", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00259-00093716-00094017": "poivre Darfur 87 Charles pave but they", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00260-00094018-00094380": "frères Girard Philippe jean Reno Jean", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00261-00094381-00094763": "Renoir Ilan resume Simone Signoret", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00262-00094764-00095076": "Jacques Tati Audrey Tautou jean-louis", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00263-00095077-00095418": "Trintignant Francois Truffaut Roger", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00264-00095419-00095890": "Vadim", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00265-00095891-00096413": "topic transport", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00266-00096414-00096890": "Air France Airbus a400m Canal du Midi", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00267-00096891-00097144": "Channel Tunnel 88 Charles de Gaulle", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00268-00097145-00097531": "Airport Citroen Eurostar get link 89", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00269-00097532-00098096": "Eurotunnel shuttle Orly Puzo Renault Roy", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00270-00098097-00098521": "C s and C F Mont Blanc Express 90", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00271-00098522-00099251": "valleys TGV train Grande Vytas", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00272-00099252-00099785": "topic see also", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00273-00099786-00100268": "cultural icon culture of France list of", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00274-00100269-00100559": "cultural icons of England list of", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00275-00100560-00100856": "cultural icons of Germany list of", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00276-00100857-00101168": "cultural icons of Italy list of cultural", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00277-00101169-00101453": "icons of the Netherlands list of", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00278-00101454-00101768": "cultural icons of Northern Ireland list", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00279-00101769-00102077": "of cultural icons of Russia list of", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00280-00102078-00102377": "cultural icons of Scotland list of", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00281-00102378-00102544": "cultural icons of Spain", "QHYYq2VjCNu-00282-00102545-00102995": "list of cultural icons of Wales"}}, {"audio_id": "QIlayDx5Oq0", "text": {"QIlayDx5Oq0-00000-00000186-00000437": "so the choose-your-own-adventure", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00001-00000438-00000671": "probably pretty familiar sounding theme", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00002-00000672-00000833": "I'm talking about how I've been eating", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00003-00000834-00001019": "flexible pathways and proficiency based", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00004-00001020-00001203": "learning in my classroom over the last", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00005-00001204-00001335": "few years in a particular what I've", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00006-00001336-00001707": "found to be successful so the reason", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00007-00001707-00001887": "I've got the x-77 three pillars of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00008-00001888-00002034": "personalized learning graphic on there", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00009-00002035-00002391": "is that insurance I'm honored to be an", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00010-00002392-00002715": "educator in Vermont x-77 as a law is", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00011-00002716-00002889": "what kind of I think nudging a lot of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00012-00002890-00003036": "educators to be more progressive and", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00013-00003037-00003240": "take more healthy risks in our practice", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00014-00003240-00003413": "and so I'm thankful that it's been a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00015-00003414-00003561": "part of what it's really kind of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00016-00003561-00003722": "reinvented my practice over the last few", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00017-00003723-00003947": "years so that's why I kind of under act", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00018-00003948-00004118": "77 we're going to be talking about", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00019-00004119-00004295": "proficiency-based learning that's why", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00020-00004296-00004463": "you've got them learning target on there", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00021-00004464-00004650": "we're going to be talking about flexible", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00022-00004651-00004809": "pathways service learning it's one of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00023-00004810-00004979": "the the you know the avenues through", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00024-00004980-00005141": "which we'd use it and of course we'll be", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00025-00005142-00005279": "talking about this year even how we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00026-00005280-00005552": "address the election this fall and of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00027-00005553-00005750": "course resources and then the student", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00028-00005751-00005855": "panel I can get out of their way and let", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00029-00005856-00006120": "these guys talk so background of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00030-00006121-00006356": "proficiency based learning again keeping", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00031-00006357-00006521": "it short it's been quite a journey the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00032-00006522-00006753": "past few years the learning targets on", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00033-00006754-00006909": "the Left kind of even though you know", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00034-00006909-00007056": "it's going to be too much to unpack and", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00035-00007056-00007256": "look through those in short it's that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00036-00007257-00007473": "you know three years ago I was using the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00037-00007473-00007638": "Vermont GES for those of you that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00038-00007639-00007866": "remember those and common core standards", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00039-00007867-00008078": "and basing learning targets off of those", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00040-00008079-00008306": "and having a lot of grandiose failures", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00041-00008307-00008513": "in doing so but learning about how", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00042-00008514-00008670": "learning targets at the core of what you", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00043-00008671-00009002": "do can work even last year I had moved", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00044-00009003-00009209": "to districts based learning targets", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00045-00009210-00009417": "within social studies we call them five", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00046-00009418-00009699": "inquiry skills for social studies and it", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00047-00009700-00009795": "was kind of a step in the right", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00048-00009796-00009894": "direction but they were still very", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00049-00009895-00010131": "content based so this year I've had a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00050-00010132-00010259": "lot of success in moving to true", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00051-00010260-00010476": "transferable skills sharing them out", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00052-00010477-00010737": "amongst my colleagues across content", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00053-00010738-00010962": "areas all of them connected to within", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00054-00010963-00011117": "our district the five transferable", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00055-00011118-00011316": "skills but kind of the same transferable", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00056-00011317-00011469": "standards as a percent from us putting", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00057-00011470-00011616": "out we have the informed and integrated", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00058-00011617-00011838": "thinking you know responsible", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00059-00011839-00012170": "citizenship self directions so you know", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00060-00012171-00012416": "my own evolution has kind of been making", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00061-00012417-00012617": "those more articulate but in practice", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00062-00012618-00012801": "for growing independence that's where", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00063-00012802-00012957": "I've also made a lot of strides you know", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00064-00012958-00013113": "I think again going back to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00065-00013113-00013305": "years ago I became good at making", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00066-00013306-00013515": "learning targets because slapping them", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00067-00013516-00013719": "on an assignment and that's great null", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00068-00013719-00013887": "and you feel like you're communicating", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00069-00013888-00014091": "what the expectations are but it's not", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00070-00014091-00014286": "really enough you're not really you know", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00071-00014287-00014421": "kind of helping students develop skills", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00072-00014422-00014709": "last year I worked really hard at making", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00073-00014710-00014841": "the learning targets and the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00074-00014841-00015000": "expectations connected to them very", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00075-00015001-00015194": "articulate so I could put work in front", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00076-00015195-00015378": "of these students and say guys it's so", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00077-00015379-00015488": "clear what you have to do to be", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00078-00015490-00015647": "successful I'm going to such a good job", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00079-00015649-00015825": "of supporting you from last thing on", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00080-00015826-00015954": "this slide I want to point out is down", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00081-00015955-00016143": "the bottom right over by Rory escape", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00082-00016144-00016383": "you've got me it says you we ought five", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00083-00016384-00016617": "that might sound like some strange", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00084-00016618-00016983": "jargon but really that model encapsulate", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00085-00016984-00017205": "what it's like this format of practicing", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00086-00017206-00017487": "so that you refers to this guy usually", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00087-00017488-00017703": "when we look at a new skill say patterns", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00088-00017704-00017922": "and trends for example I will model the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00089-00017923-00018078": "skill and kind of show them what it", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00090-00018079-00018237": "means to get a one two three or four in", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00091-00018238-00018489": "a learning target the we you guys are", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00092-00018490-00018729": "familiar with this is when as a group we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00093-00018730-00018900": "will practice this skill in a formative", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00094-00018901-00019092": "way nothing formal nothing that goes in", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00095-00019093-00019218": "the books but the opportunity to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00096-00019219-00019350": "practice the skill get some group", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00097-00019351-00019593": "feedback same with the US the S is", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00098-00019594-00019764": "usually more like partners or small", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00099-00019765-00019911": "groups where again they're practicing", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00100-00019912-00020130": "again trying to refine their skill which", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00101-00020131-00020313": "finally goes down to the eye where the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00102-00020314-00020597": "students themselves do things for you", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00103-00020598-00020808": "know an independent summative grade that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00104-00020809-00021044": "will be formally of the best big picture", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00105-00021045-00021180": "with all this one thing that I've taken", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00106-00021181-00021318": "away from my learning last few years", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00107-00021319-00021660": "more feedback less gratings you guys", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00108-00021661-00021780": "don't have any great that book is here I", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00109-00021781-00021894": "haven't remained complaints about it by", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00110-00021895-00022164": "the way but the idea being that by the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00111-00022165-00022335": "time something's actually a set in a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00112-00022336-00022547": "summative way most of these students", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00113-00022548-00022775": "have had the chance to master it and", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00114-00022776-00023003": "those that don't will have more", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00115-00023004-00023153": "opportunities to do so because these are", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00116-00023154-00023412": "year long really in most cases these are", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00117-00023413-00023600": "middle school long transferable skills", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00118-00023601-00023793": "the thing that changed is the complexity", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00119-00023794-00023958": "of the content through which we apply", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00120-00023959-00024131": "the skills you notice the eyes the last", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00121-00024132-00024344": "step where it's I the students doing the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00122-00024345-00024447": "work and doing these things", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00123-00024448-00024572": "independently we used to have a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00124-00024573-00024717": "backwards where the I was the teacher", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00125-00024718-00024900": "and it was a student who finally gave me", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00126-00024901-00025047": "the light bulb moment said wait mister", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00127-00025048-00025086": "Nelson", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00128-00025087-00025406": "shouldn't I be like me but okay so", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00129-00025407-00025539": "background flex will pathway it's kind", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00130-00025540-00025737": "of same story you know a lot of bumps", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00131-00025738-00025814": "along the road", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00132-00025816-00025970": "sakes made love that stuff that's called", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00133-00025972-00026268": "learning so over the past three years I", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00134-00026269-00026418": "have found you know I thought how", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00135-00026419-00026627": "successful is time students have choice", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00136-00026629-00026838": "and voice in the curriculum and when you", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00137-00026839-00027075": "make curriculum a conversation not a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00138-00027076-00027330": "mandate and so service-learning is up", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00139-00027331-00027456": "there because for those of you that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00140-00027457-00027567": "aren't familiar with the service", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00141-00027568-00027693": "learning model you can do a whole", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00142-00027694-00027843": "session you can do a whole day on", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00143-00027844-00028083": "service learning but it really puts", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00144-00028083-00028344": "student choice and wanting to connect to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00145-00028345-00028473": "the community in an authentic audience", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00146-00028474-00028641": "with the core of what you do and you got", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00147-00028642-00028788": "to be flexible because what these guys", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00148-00028789-00028970": "will be able to tell you about for the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00149-00028972-00029114": "seventh graders that we got to do this", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00150-00029116-00029349": "last year it's tough it takes a lot of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00151-00029350-00029610": "negotiation and sometimes even take me", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00152-00029611-00029727": "getting into a little bit of trouble", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00153-00029727-00029889": "kind of connecting the community members", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00154-00029889-00030129": "so all really good press aren't you I", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00155-00030130-00030264": "have some through a service-learning", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00156-00030264-00030531": "last year we did kind of a mini unit on", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00157-00030532-00030906": "it and I was in a group where we did we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00158-00030907-00031189": "were focusing on saving the ocean asset", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00159-00031191-00031491": "so we ended up going and presenting to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00160-00031492-00031794": "most of the elementary school and we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00161-00031795-00032025": "also have like an article in the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00162-00032026-00032349": "newspaper so it just in a connected way", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00163-00032350-00032535": "like you know the Google Doc down below", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00164-00032536-00032694": "says go and drain this just an example", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00165-00032695-00032907": "of how I love my role as a teacher", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00166-00032908-00033114": "becomes really charting and tracking the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00167-00033115-00033273": "conversation there's a ton of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00168-00033274-00033471": "student-led discussions and I mean", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00169-00033472-00033639": "student-led where I literally remove", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00170-00033640-00033849": "myself from the discussion sit on the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00171-00033850-00034056": "outskirts and just track the discussion", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00172-00034057-00034284": "digitally some pretty quick keyboardist", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00173-00034285-00034509": "so those are really powerful when the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00174-00034510-00034767": "students even struggle at times with", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00175-00034768-00034968": "conducting their own discussion and", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00176-00034969-00035139": "struggle with facilitation of talking", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00177-00035140-00035355": "over each other and sometimes I sit back", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00178-00035356-00035526": "and let them struggle because they learn", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00179-00035527-00035688": "through that and what's inspiring is", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00180-00035689-00035859": "that by the end of the year they", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00181-00035860-00035982": "actually can't wait for me to get out of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00182-00035983-00036102": "the way because they want to just have a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00183-00036103-00036228": "student-led discussion where I'm doing", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00184-00036229-00036399": "nothing but again tracking it so when we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00185-00036400-00036558": "can come back to it I've got kind of a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00186-00036559-00036888": "log of their notes connected to that you", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00187-00036889-00037020": "know I mentioned student voice and", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00188-00037021-00037233": "choice it's a huge part of this just", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00189-00037234-00037415": "over the last few years experimenting", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00190-00037416-00037527": "with different things from having", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00191-00037528-00037686": "students help me design what's an actual", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00192-00037687-00037929": "assessment is going to look like to unit", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00193-00037930-00038226": "long student design curriculum where we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00194-00038227-00038306": "kind of talk", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00195-00038307-00038435": "what the overall themes are going to be", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00196-00038436-00038555": "but they help me design what are we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00197-00038556-00038681": "going to explore what they're learning", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00198-00038682-00038846": "didn't look like what's the product of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00199-00038847-00038987": "our learning going to look like again", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00200-00038988-00039236": "always student-led always track by me", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00201-00039237-00039416": "and really making it a conversation and", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00202-00039417-00039674": "then the picture mounted bottom is an", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00203-00039675-00039809": "example where a student actually asked", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00204-00039810-00039977": "me if she could teach a lesson I'm sure", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00205-00039978-00040091": "many of you are familiar with the fact", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00206-00040092-00040370": "that Hamilton the rage is like kids like", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00207-00040371-00040583": "take it over the country which of course", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00208-00040584-00040793": "in social sites teacher I'm so into so", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00209-00040794-00040964": "she asked when we were doing an American", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00210-00040965-00041138": "Revolution and if she could do a lesson", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00211-00041139-00041372": "on Hamilton she taught on every student", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00212-00041373-00041609": "on her whole team and it was it was so", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00213-00041610-00041744": "inspiring where I could sit in the back", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00214-00041745-00041888": "and be a student and just take pictures", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00215-00041889-00042113": "and track what she did so um it's all", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00216-00042114-00042470": "there and then finally the SPC which is", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00217-00042471-00042656": "FCC is napping in the stands for student", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00218-00042657-00042869": "planning committee some of our panel", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00219-00042870-00043049": "members they are on the sixth and", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00220-00043050-00043094": "seventh grade", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00221-00043095-00043337": "SDC totally a new thing this year that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00222-00043338-00043583": "I've started where we meet usually every", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00223-00043584-00043778": "week or at least every other week and we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00224-00043779-00044009": "talk curriculum and I told them up front", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00225-00044010-00044222": "that those that want to be up Lotus they", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00226-00044223-00044354": "volunteer I told them what they're", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00227-00044355-00044414": "getting into", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00228-00044415-00044600": "at best they might get a little bit of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00229-00044601-00044714": "chocolate out of it but there aren't a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00230-00044715-00044822": "lot of frills", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00231-00044823-00045122": "doing Mormon but we meet and they help", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00232-00045123-00045281": "inform my instruction and the thing I", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00233-00045282-00045455": "promise them is that I wouldn't sit them", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00234-00045456-00045623": "down listen to their ideas say guys", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00235-00045624-00045833": "that's so cute and then do nothing to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00236-00045834-00046217": "change they've had actual like marked", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00237-00046218-00046406": "changes within our curriculum in the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00238-00046407-00046586": "sense that even on the the docudrama", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00239-00046587-00046859": "film projects we just entirely put on by", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00240-00046860-00047012": "students none of that would have been my", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00241-00047013-00047150": "idea more jump in yeah someone", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00242-00047151-00047348": "recommended it while we were talking", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00243-00047349-00047617": "about like how you can learn about um", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00244-00047618-00047900": "like information about the revolutions", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00245-00047901-00048320": "and so mr. Nelson took on aparment that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00246-00048321-00048599": "idea and he decided to make unit about", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00247-00048600-00049043": "um like information about um about a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00248-00049044-00049211": "revolution that we choose or that we're", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00249-00049212-00049677": "interested in and on mine was on 15", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00250-00049678-00049931": "pollution and I've learned so much from", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00251-00049932-00050304": "them thank you", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00252-00050305-00050451": "we'll talk about that too okay so again", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00253-00050452-00050637": "trying to be really quick all right", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00254-00050638-00050940": "so talking about this year we did start", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00255-00050941-00051114": "this all six seven and eight grade on", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00256-00051115-00051249": "the winter teen shelter community school", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00257-00051250-00051498": "we looked at the election I'm going to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00258-00051499-00051641": "keep this brief but you can see on the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00259-00051642-00051825": "left side you've got note-taking and on", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00260-00051826-00051954": "the right side we've got discipline", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00261-00051954-00052130": "specific vocabulary those are the only", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00262-00052132-00052338": "two transferable skills that we actually", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00263-00052339-00052632": "practice used in exploring the election", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00264-00052633-00052821": "and these students were graded in a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00265-00052822-00053066": "formal summative manner but we explored", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00266-00053067-00053279": "so much and we did a lot of different", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00267-00053280-00053429": "we've looked at a lot of different stuff", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00268-00053430-00053637": "I think the challenge that people have", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00269-00053638-00053724": "is wrapping their heads around", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00270-00053725-00053865": "transferable skills and maybe", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00271-00053866-00054096": "proficiency based learning in general is", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00272-00054097-00054234": "where does the content go well I can", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00273-00054235-00054384": "tell you first hand he's got a control a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00274-00054385-00054542": "building I had we looked at a ton of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00275-00054544-00054737": "content with a selection so in short", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00276-00054738-00055002": "with note-taking kind of the method of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00277-00055003-00055280": "practice was again me modeling the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00278-00055282-00055515": "behavior giving them a resource where it", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00279-00055516-00055653": "shows different types of notes note", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00280-00055654-00055887": "chemical and take the shape of a lot of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00281-00055888-00056040": "different things having them work in", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00282-00056041-00056187": "groups give each other feedback then", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00283-00056188-00056316": "having them practice you guys remember", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00284-00056316-00056445": "note-taking bingo", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00285-00056446-00056630": "we had a bingo board where there were", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00286-00056632-00056928": "different major issues connected to the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00287-00056929-00057036": "election it might be things like", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00288-00057037-00057321": "immigration women's rights gun control", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00289-00057322-00057482": "they kind of work their way through a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00290-00057483-00057654": "bingo board but in doing so they have to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00291-00057654-00057960": "try all four of the note-taking", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00292-00057961-00058200": "strategies that we were practicing all", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00293-00058201-00058386": "that practice all of it ungraded there", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00294-00058387-00058557": "with a lot of really good feedback so", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00295-00058558-00058710": "that by the time they did their", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00296-00058711-00058892": "political platform some of the projects", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00297-00058894-00059025": "and they had to have notes connected to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00298-00059026-00059216": "the research these guys were all masters", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00299-00059217-00059397": "and it was really again it was inspiring", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00300-00059398-00059712": "for me to see how successful you know", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00301-00059713-00059904": "all students for six days grade were in", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00302-00059904-00060090": "tracking those and making them you know", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00303-00060091-00060204": "detail in nuance", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00304-00060204-00060453": "really insightful this one specific", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00305-00060454-00060654": "vocabulary was similar we had vocabulary", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00306-00060654-00060840": "we rolled it out to practice it in a few", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00307-00060841-00060996": "ways before anything went into the books", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00308-00060997-00061280": "and even using tech tools like Quizlet", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00309-00061282-00061461": "was fantastic as Quizlet not only is", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00310-00061462-00061619": "that an engaging and fun way to practice", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00311-00061620-00061815": "something like vocab especially when", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00312-00061816-00062028": "it's uncreated it becomes more like that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00313-00062029-00062180": "game based learning thing where you can", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00314-00062182-00062426": "attach a score to it keep a scoreboard", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00315-00062427-00062724": "going and get these guys motivated to to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00316-00062725-00062855": "learn and try to master when they don't", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00317-00062857-00063048": "have to worry about Tom and failing", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00318-00063049-00063216": "having a nasty grade in the book that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00319-00063216-00063488": "looks awful so in Quigley works nicely", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00320-00063489-00063663": "to an F you could set up four different", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00321-00063664-00063788": "love yous that you kind of work your way", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00322-00063789-00064013": "up from starting stepping up pro status", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00323-00064014-00064311": "is great and then of course ninja level", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00324-00064312-00064451": "so those of you that are really nailing", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00325-00064452-00064773": "it that all built up again to things", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00326-00064774-00064925": "they had to use that discipline specific", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00327-00064926-00065129": "vocabulary in their political platform", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00328-00065130-00065330": "project so those platform projects", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00329-00065332-00065504": "themselves a lot of student voice and", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00330-00065505-00065750": "choice there on what they could be what", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00331-00065751-00066006": "they were based on was election issues", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00332-00066007-00066141": "but again they could look like anything", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00333-00066142-00066438": "people made PSA infomercial posters", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00334-00066439-00066693": "people wrote letters tons of different", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00335-00066694-00066819": "ways that they could basically express", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00336-00066820-00067104": "their understanding about major election", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00337-00067105-00067326": "issues so super successful and again the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00338-00067327-00067467": "whole authentic audience piece at the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00339-00067468-00067647": "end was that we connected with a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00340-00067648-00067893": "different team one of whom teacher here", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00341-00067894-00068085": "broadband is on that team where we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00342-00068086-00068315": "actually swap so everyone on our team", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00343-00068316-00068547": "laid out there you know in a gallery", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00344-00068548-00068772": "their political platform projects we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00345-00068773-00068919": "went over to hold anywhere there's we're", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00346-00068920-00069081": "set up and then we have a little voting", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00347-00069082-00069206": "sheet so there's a little bit more of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00348-00069207-00069344": "that authentic audience piece and even", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00349-00069345-00069506": "simulating a little bit of the election", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00350-00069507-00069684": "the only other things all throughout", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00351-00069685-00069822": "there is yeah you know on top of all", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00352-00069823-00069978": "this we looked closely at the electoral", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00353-00069979-00070263": "college we did electoral geography game", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00354-00070264-00070509": "here was one of the two students you're", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00355-00070510-00070657": "comfortable in sharing", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00356-00070658-00070792": "yeah you're right so much you did oh", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00357-00070793-00071074": "yeah so we had Metro college test work", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00358-00071075-00071325": "we had names a certain amount of states", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00359-00071326-00071557": "with all with their capitals in their", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00360-00071558-00071710": "electoral college votes and made the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00361-00071711-00071893": "place in their place and you could start", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00362-00071894-00072160": "from starting to stepping up to process", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00363-00072161-00072500": "and enjoy level and so I studied and I", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00364-00072501-00072769": "thought and I thought I could do ninja", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00365-00072770-00073318": "level and so I um the day after like we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00366-00073319-00073656": "it are we found out our results I found", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00367-00073657-00073881": "out that I got all the answers right so", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00368-00073882-00074056": "you get a certain amount points for", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00369-00074057-00074224": "assuming the correct Electoral College", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00370-00074225-00074475": "roots of the state capitals and they're", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00371-00074476-00074953": "created state it using present so just", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00372-00074954-00075091": "you know just to put it out there like", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00373-00075092-00075292": "every single state on a map every state", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00374-00075293-00075496": "capitol in every electoral college vote", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00375-00075497-00075691": "in here no matter how many Electoral", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00376-00075692-00076404": "College out there though it has", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00377-00076405-00076626": "impressive stuff right and again like", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00378-00076627-00076800": "close it none of it graded all really", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00379-00076801-00076954": "just kind of game base we had kind of a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00380-00076955-00077157": "leaderboard going the only challenge of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00381-00077158-00077307": "time because like it would take a whole", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00382-00077308-00077554": "45-minute class which he gave to fill", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00383-00077555-00077851": "out a whole map so as always like time", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00384-00077852-00078013": "became the challenge but okay I'm just", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00385-00078014-00078160": "giving me the guys we're moving on we're", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00386-00078161-00078301": "going to talk about on the other major", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00387-00078302-00078466": "unit that has kind of combined", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00388-00078467-00078663": "proficiency-based learning and flexible", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00389-00078664-00078793": "tablets and it's our new one that we're", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00390-00078794-00078944": "living now you say you want a revolution", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00391-00078945-00079285": "look at it revolutions through times got", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00392-00079286-00079429": "some learning targets up here citing", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00393-00079430-00079618": "sources and participation you know", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00394-00079619-00079759": "you've got kind of a habit of learning", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00395-00079760-00079924": "there versus a patient or a soft skills", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00396-00079925-00080110": "people call it citing sources of course", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00397-00080111-00080281": "a very fundamental skill to things that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00398-00080282-00080431": "would practice formatively citing", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00399-00080432-00080554": "sources you guys have a book that's", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00400-00080555-00080761": "going great stone in the book patterns", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00401-00080762-00080956": "and trends is what most recently we have", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00402-00080957-00081148": "really I did in with their tea tree but", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00403-00081149-00081494": "had very fun time rolling out the see", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00404-00081495-00081760": "you we upside you want explain the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00405-00081761-00082092": "flower patterns and trends", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00406-00082093-00082274": "I just noticed because this is the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00407-00082275-00082596": "flower that migrant made the stem was", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00408-00082597-00082935": "where you put in the trend like for us", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00409-00082936-00083180": "specifically like our trend was that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00410-00083181-00083322": "every person in our group started", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00411-00083323-00083519": "gradually listening to our music since", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00412-00083520-00083756": "the beginning of the school year and we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00413-00083757-00084054": "specified in each of the leaves like the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00414-00084055-00084236": "patterns like with each of us pointing", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00415-00084237-00084557": "like who we listen to and then like how", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00416-00084558-00084887": "we listen to it and then the dirt or", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00417-00084888-00085704": "yeah sister was um put in as like what", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00418-00085705-00086160": "you do and maybe what some of the not so", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00419-00086161-00086316": "great things about it's looking at it", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00420-00086317-00086555": "from both sides some of ours", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00421-00086556-00086762": "it helps us for link it's a hobby", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00422-00086763-00086987": "entertainment and sometimes currently", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00423-00086988-00087230": "myself it helps like relieve stress just", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00424-00087231-00087366": "when you're having a hard time just", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00425-00087367-00087648": "listening to music and then some of the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00426-00087649-00087804": "things that we're not so great is that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00427-00087805-00088010": "you plug your headphones and you tune", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00428-00088011-00088574": "yourself out and the top is just what", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00429-00088575-00088791": "your prediction is so what you think", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00430-00088792-00088941": "might happen in our prediction was", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00431-00088942-00089156": "musics become more involved in our", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00432-00089157-00089571": "society and then you say I suggest this", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00433-00089572-00089861": "to some people like I used to jest to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00434-00089862-00090194": "unclog more often or even listen to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00435-00090195-00090348": "music without my headphones with a group", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00436-00090349-00090599": "of friends or a school dance like listen", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00437-00090600-00090773": "to music with a group of people see", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00438-00090774-00091124": "you're not Club like not plugged in when", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00439-00091125-00091313": "you're with people doing it and in the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00440-00091314-00091552": "world at the same time", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00441-00091553-00091876": "so yeah I would say the reason that I as", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00442-00091877-00092044": "a teacher liked it but I certainly", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00443-00092045-00092254": "really enjoying the students get it and", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00444-00092255-00092461": "comprehend what's going on is that it's", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00445-00092462-00092701": "a four step project these lovely flowers", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00446-00092702-00093001": "but each step in the flower project is", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00447-00093002-00093175": "one step on the learning target to you", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00448-00093176-00093406": "you can't get a more tangible and clear", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00449-00093407-00093664": "look at what it means to be a one two", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00450-00093665-00093802": "three or four on this patterns and", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00451-00093803-00094042": "trends learning target and again some", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00452-00094043-00094192": "people kind of felt failed on this one", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00453-00094193-00094426": "but it was a it was the you know is the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00454-00094427-00094615": "use the week so like it was in a group", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00455-00094616-00094849": "and we'll be practicing again moving", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00456-00094850-00094975": "towards independence so helpful", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00457-00094976-00095182": "resources some of this might look really", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00458-00095183-00095341": "familiar but you know there's the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00459-00095342-00095485": "project-based learning book powered the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00460-00095486-00095698": "adolescent brain by Thomas unbelievable", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00461-00095699-00095860": "so totally into the brain based learning", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00462-00095861-00096052": "piece and it's very inspiring me", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00463-00096053-00096154": "thinking about how you want to roll at", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00464-00096155-00096331": "content these guys the excitable", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00465-00096332-00096517": "learning Burke book by by Marjorie", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00466-00096518-00096685": "Ginsburg was kind of what inspired me to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00467-00096686-00096856": "bring on the SPC because that student", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00468-00096857-00097006": "planning community again having them", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00469-00097007-00097168": "that connected close that closely", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00470-00097169-00097432": "connected to what we're doing is so", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00471-00097433-00097570": "helpful I'm never going to not have that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00472-00097571-00097864": "again then of course CV you learn hair", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00473-00097865-00098071": "blog because man they're good and just", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00474-00098072-00098275": "like putting out the net taking the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00475-00098276-00098382": "coolest things going on the state and", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00476-00098383-00098503": "then putting it out there and win so", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00477-00098504-00098704": "much from this to do PLP", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00478-00098705-00099096": "pathways okay there's your plug so yes", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00479-00099097-00099379": "hollinger flow was your flower part of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00480-00099380-00099603": "the revolution it was up to different", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00481-00099604-00100036": "well we wanted to do both we were doing", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00482-00100037-00100402": "the flowers that that was the in the US", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00483-00100403-00100954": "I that was kind of like the form of that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00484-00100955-00101143": "if that was our small group those groups", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00485-00101144-00101473": "in three or four and because when we do", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00486-00101474-00101764": "so we all made these docudramas about", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00487-00101765-00102037": "each revolution is what they were called", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00488-00102038-00102152": "uncle Thomas", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00489-00102153-00102491": "and so next week we're going to have a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00490-00102492-00102901": "film festival of sorts enduring that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00491-00102902-00103144": "everyone's good like at the very end of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00492-00103145-00103397": "of seeing every single video you're", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00493-00103398-00103538": "gonna be able that you're going to sit", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00494-00103539-00103727": "down by yourself and say here's what", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00495-00103728-00103946": "here's the powder not really although", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00496-00103947-00104182": "that all these revolute early hands that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00497-00104183-00104434": "all these revolutions had and then like", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00498-00104435-00104630": "what like what your prediction is like", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00499-00104631-00104882": "these happen my copy is apart from these", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00500-00104883-00105041": "reasons I wonder if this will happen", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00501-00105042-00105308": "again I suggest this maybe not have it", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00502-00105308-00105568": "happen or something like your own flower", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00503-00105569-00105947": "means based on the terms of yes God", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00504-00105948-00106040": "thank you", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00505-00106041-00106370": "how has this changed like this type of", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00506-00106371-00106607": "learning changed your relationship with", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00507-00106608-00106778": "school like seems like you all are like", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00508-00106779-00106967": "super excited about what you're doing", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00509-00106968-00107267": "and being the class and Mikey was coming", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00510-00107268-00107594": "here like how do you feel about school", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00511-00107595-00107920": "now differently than maybe previously", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00512-00107921-00108239": "Sophie wheeler can get a jump on them I", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00513-00108240-00108572": "guess I think it's easier with like", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00514-00108573-00108878": "first instead of just handing you were", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00515-00108879-00109139": "kissing like Spears targets do it easier", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00516-00109140-00109352": "when you kind of like show us a little", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00517-00109353-00109550": "more examples of how to do it and we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00518-00109551-00109793": "kind of work together in the class to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00519-00109794-00110035": "kind of learn more about it either way", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00520-00110036-00110270": "in and then kind of go off on our own", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00521-00110271-00110474": "it that just handed the work thanks do", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00522-00110475-00110831": "it I building off that I definitely", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00523-00110832-00111076": "enjoy a choice to be able to create", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00524-00111077-00111451": "something that's not just select you're", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00525-00111452-00111679": "answering questions or something like", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00526-00111680-00112447": "that years if you're creating something", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00527-00112448-00112759": "for me I like the standards based", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00528-00112760-00113051": "learning more because up like before", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00529-00113052-00113231": "when we would take tests and stuff if we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00530-00113232-00113338": "would have a question a great teacher", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00531-00113339-00113635": "they could really answer it because", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00532-00113636-00113788": "they're like well how do I answer this", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00533-00113789-00114158": "without giving you like telling you what", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00534-00114158-00114458": "to do and with the standard it makes a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00535-00114458-00114608": "lot clearer what you have to do because", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00536-00114608-00114835": "it pretty much tells you exactly how to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00537-00114836-00115165": "do like step by step and then you just", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00538-00115166-00115408": "print it out to do the work sounds like", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00539-00115409-00115733": "she said feel less stressed out when", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00540-00115733-00116048": "summative come along I think the hard", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00541-00116049-00116329": "thing is that I know a lot of people", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00542-00116330-00116590": "that will try to connect a grade average", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00543-00116591-00117076": "to base standards oh yeah three is 85 to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00544-00117077-00117379": "75 like that's not or 75 to 85 that's", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00545-00117380-00117604": "not really how it works it not can get", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00546-00117605-00117845": "really hard to try and explain like like", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00547-00117846-00118078": "a mom saying oh yeah you only got it to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00548-00118079-00118271": "what's wrong like you can get up to a", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00549-00118272-00118579": "four but that means you just need you", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00550-00118580-00118808": "need one more practice before you change", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00551-00118808-00118994": "with some you need one more practice and", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00552-00118995-00119188": "then you can get the three or", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00553-00119189-00119357": "potentially even the floor and the floor", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00554-00119358-00119689": "is he receiving like you understand that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00555-00119690-00119935": "you could do it whenever to any topic", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00556-00119936-00120233": "but in just something I did you see", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00557-00120233-00120529": "Jesus is difficult sometimes just with", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00558-00120530-00120910": "that we are one", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00559-00120911-00121142": "like with the students for waterways", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00560-00121143-00121598": "making learning target it introduced me", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00561-00121599-00121769": "to a lot and you could hear just so much", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00562-00121770-00122027": "more time to practice and you are a lot", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00563-00122028-00122342": "more ready for the summative than you", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00564-00122343-00122513": "would be if you had it like right at", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00565-00122514-00123131": "mission yeah helps me talk about my", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00566-00123132-00123326": "problems meetings work if you want with", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00567-00123327-00123794": "you so we kind of like mr. Nelson", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00568-00123795-00124007": "generally has some sort of agenda we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00569-00124008-00124483": "don't stick you but is like a Jenner", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00570-00124484-00124718": "like you've got some ideas for projects", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00571-00124719-00124984": "or so and then we discuss it and like", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00572-00124985-00125168": "say what we agree with and when we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00573-00125169-00125456": "disagree with like but sometimes also", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00574-00125457-00125597": "there's something that he's doing that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00575-00125598-00125726": "we really don't like we're going to do", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00576-00125727-00125983": "it you're boring us with it please can", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00577-00125984-00126256": "we change it and do something else and", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00578-00126257-00126566": "generally we have some sex idea and we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00579-00126567-00126842": "help to make sense of things more for", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00580-00126843-00127976": "other students yeah ready people this", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00581-00127977-00128354": "one's going to drop", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00582-00128355-00129260": "[Music]", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00583-00129261-00129558": "it's time to exceed the standards with", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00584-00129559-00131010": "this one oh yeah here we go with my", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00585-00131011-00131695": "learning target I'm about to teach you", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00586-00131696-00132051": "all something very important that", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00587-00132052-00132556": "standards so here's an introduction to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00588-00132557-00132763": "standards based learning a chance to", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00589-00132764-00132910": "answer all those questions you have", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00590-00132911-00133096": "learning different then means there's", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00591-00133097-00133306": "100 point scale to understand the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00592-00133307-00133513": "difference now just listen to my tale it", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00593-00133514-00133711": "all starts with standards as I call them", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00594-00133712-00133906": "skills if learning is like money the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00595-00133907-00134101": "standards are the skills practice makes", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00596-00134102-00134170": "perfect", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00597-00134171-00134401": "through in through the way we do this is", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00598-00134402-00134734": "with ice cream I means me the teacher", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00599-00134735-00134998": "that is the we means we practice teacher", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00600-00134999-00135214": "and kiss the first few is partners", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00601-00135215-00135448": "working side by side the final you is", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00602-00135449-00135628": "independent skills are going slide now", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00603-00135629-00135799": "let's do some feminine voice that we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00604-00135800-00136066": "communicate what comes as boy touches on", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00605-00136067-00136351": "time relate on any given task students", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00606-00136352-00136615": "demonstrate the ability to produce for", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00607-00136616-00138013": "to create standard number one to a whole", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00608-00138014-00138217": "letter grades don't matter for", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00609-00138218-00138549": "matters : standard", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00610-00138550-00139012": "and we'll discuss to grow the number one", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00611-00139013-00139195": "to a four letter grades don't matter", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00612-00139196-00139618": "because he matters more even in elbows", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00613-00139619-00139849": "what MA anyway would really count to do", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00614-00139850-00141271": "to throw he knows what's up he always", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00615-00141272-00141555": "ends used to follow up the stainless", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00616-00141556-00141943": "basement baby pay really itself and help", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00617-00141944-00142498": "your brain did you achieve a standard", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00618-00142499-00142828": "class more Ont fifty yards over the chat", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00619-00142829-00142984": "and I think you know that cancer you", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00620-00142985-00143389": "even need from a one to a whole letter", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00621-00143390-00143596": "grades don't matter because he matters", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00622-00143597-00144025": "more even you have those what na and we", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00623-00144026-00144244": "will become students grow through the", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00624-00144245-00144511": "number one to a four letter grades don't", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00625-00144512-00144853": "matter because he matters more to be", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00626-00144854-00145042": "many hello MA", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00627-00145043-00145225": "anyway would really come to do to grow", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00628-00145226-00145965": "your time is Eastern Standard Time", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00629-00145966-00146392": "I'm not just memorizing facts I'm a bath", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00630-00146393-00146784": "tub without sending skills enough nada", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00631-00146785-00147160": "we're talking sand offensive through her", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00632-00147161-00147569": "in the helm", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00633-00147570-00149798": "[Music]", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00634-00149799-00150156": "learning you play target learning target", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00635-00150157-00150501": "learning okay nice aim chemistry you say", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00636-00150502-00150903": "efficiency devastate demonstration", "QIlayDx5Oq0-00637-00150904-00152306": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "QIsqaTEawPU", "text": {"QIsqaTEawPU-00000-00000041-00000340": "and welcome to the module for video on", "QIsqaTEawPU-00001-00000341-00000626": "how to make alpha carbon nucleophiles", "QIsqaTEawPU-00002-00000627-00000817": "and we're going to do that using emails", "QIsqaTEawPU-00003-00000818-00001141": "or enolate so the first thing is to make", "QIsqaTEawPU-00004-00001142-00001418": "a definition of tolerance so tautomers", "QIsqaTEawPU-00005-00001419-00001721": "are easily interconverted constitutional", "QIsqaTEawPU-00006-00001722-00002075": "isomers so one example would be if we", "QIsqaTEawPU-00007-00002076-00002312": "look at the keto enol equilibrium over", "QIsqaTEawPU-00008-00002313-00002654": "here on the right in a keto form which", "QIsqaTEawPU-00009-00002655-00002926": "is the form for any kind of carbonyl", "QIsqaTEawPU-00010-00002927-00003220": "like an aldehyde ketone or even esters", "QIsqaTEawPU-00011-00003221-00003506": "notice that there's in fact two protons", "QIsqaTEawPU-00012-00003507-00003770": "on this alpha carbon but to convert over", "QIsqaTEawPU-00013-00003771-00003970": "to the enol form which is the tautomeric", "QIsqaTEawPU-00014-00003971-00004226": "form that proton has been removed and", "QIsqaTEawPU-00015-00004227-00004490": "then another proton not necessarily the", "QIsqaTEawPU-00016-00004491-00004694": "same one has been added over on the", "QIsqaTEawPU-00017-00004695-00004970": "alcohol side on the oxygen side and", "QIsqaTEawPU-00018-00004971-00005081": "notice that there's been a rearrangement", "QIsqaTEawPU-00019-00005082-00005465": "of the double bond position so these two", "QIsqaTEawPU-00020-00005466-00005711": "the keto and enol form are tautomeric", "QIsqaTEawPU-00021-00005712-00006133": "forms they are tautomers of each other", "QIsqaTEawPU-00022-00006134-00006329": "missing over on the right is called an", "QIsqaTEawPU-00023-00006330-00006539": "enol because it's formed us in our teams", "QIsqaTEawPU-00024-00006540-00007028": "and an alcohol and there are two ways to", "QIsqaTEawPU-00025-00007029-00007373": "make an enol under acidic conditions or", "QIsqaTEawPU-00026-00007373-00007616": "under basic conditions so first we're", "QIsqaTEawPU-00027-00007617-00007828": "going to look at the mechanism for enol", "QIsqaTEawPU-00028-00007829-00008353": "formation under acidic conditions so we", "QIsqaTEawPU-00029-00008354-00008708": "take some keto form some acids does not", "QIsqaTEawPU-00030-00008709-00008996": "have to be HCl note this is an", "QIsqaTEawPU-00031-00008997-00009263": "equilibrium and the first step just like", "QIsqaTEawPU-00032-00009264-00009517": "usual is an acid-base reaction we have a", "QIsqaTEawPU-00033-00009518-00010367": "protonation of the carbonyl", "QIsqaTEawPU-00034-00010368-00010644": "so now we have an activated electrophile", "QIsqaTEawPU-00035-00010645-00010953": "and the next thing that can happen is a", "QIsqaTEawPU-00036-00010954-00011298": "deprotonation step now it could be", "QIsqaTEawPU-00037-00011299-00011493": "protonate over on the proton on the", "QIsqaTEawPU-00038-00011494-00011679": "oxygen to go back to starting material", "QIsqaTEawPU-00039-00011680-00011913": "that can and does happen the other", "QIsqaTEawPU-00040-00011914-00012164": "possibility though is protonation at the", "QIsqaTEawPU-00041-00012165-00012546": "alpha carbon to give us a double bond", "QIsqaTEawPU-00042-00012547-00012788": "between carbon and carbon and the oxygen", "QIsqaTEawPU-00043-00012789-00013029": "gets a pair of electrons to neutralize", "QIsqaTEawPU-00044-00013030-00013968": "it", "QIsqaTEawPU-00045-00013969-00014351": "so by these two steps we've made an enol", "QIsqaTEawPU-00046-00014352-00014715": "net Ino has an alpha carbon which we're", "QIsqaTEawPU-00047-00014716-00014961": "going to see is a nucleophile so this is", "QIsqaTEawPU-00048-00014962-00015381": "a nucleophilic alpha carbon now we can", "QIsqaTEawPU-00049-00015382-00015585": "also make an email under Basic", "QIsqaTEawPU-00050-00015586-00015855": "Conditions so we start with the exact", "QIsqaTEawPU-00051-00015856-00016080": "same starting material or this time I", "QIsqaTEawPU-00052-00016081-00016311": "use a base such as sodium hydroxide many", "QIsqaTEawPU-00053-00016312-00016560": "bases are possible again in equilibrium", "QIsqaTEawPU-00054-00016561-00016914": "so again a reaction in equilibrium now", "QIsqaTEawPU-00055-00016915-00017091": "here's a first edited deprotonation", "QIsqaTEawPU-00056-00017092-00017355": "because for under basic conditions we", "QIsqaTEawPU-00057-00017356-00017544": "deprotonate at the alpha carbon", "QIsqaTEawPU-00058-00017545-00017742": "electrons from the hydrogen carbon bond", "QIsqaTEawPU-00059-00017743-00017931": "flow towards the Delta positive carbon", "QIsqaTEawPU-00060-00017932-00018243": "and electrons from the PI bond go up", "QIsqaTEawPU-00061-00018244-00018447": "into that more electronegative oxygen", "QIsqaTEawPU-00062-00018448-00018860": "and what we made here is an E of 8", "QIsqaTEawPU-00063-00018861-00019107": "alkene and what would be an alcohol", "QIsqaTEawPU-00064-00019108-00019278": "except that it has a negative charge so", "QIsqaTEawPU-00065-00019279-00019509": "we put the 8 on the end of that word to", "QIsqaTEawPU-00066-00019510-00019929": "indicate that negative charge the alpha", "QIsqaTEawPU-00067-00019930-00020244": "carbon of an enol 8 is also nucleophilic", "QIsqaTEawPU-00068-00020245-00020492": "at the next step of this reaction", "QIsqaTEawPU-00069-00020493-00020715": "starting from this enolate the best", "QIsqaTEawPU-00070-00020716-00020856": "resonance structure with a negative", "QIsqaTEawPU-00071-00020857-00020973": "charge from the more electronegative", "QIsqaTEawPU-00072-00020974-00021267": "atoms lone pair goes towards a proton", "QIsqaTEawPU-00073-00021268-00021521": "source kicking out the electrons and", "QIsqaTEawPU-00074-00021522-00021825": "then the email that we form to exact", "QIsqaTEawPU-00075-00021826-00022191": "exact same one as we formed before we've", "QIsqaTEawPU-00076-00022192-00022416": "regenerated the base which acts as a", "QIsqaTEawPU-00077-00022417-00022662": "catalyst"}}, {"audio_id": "QIXywS7W7Fg", "text": {"QIXywS7W7Fg-00000-00000054-00000565": "[Music]", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00001-00000566-00000794": "you guys ready for a game that will make", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00002-00000795-00000950": "for the worst video of all time that", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00003-00000951-00001133": "looks like Bugs Bunny doing blackface", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00004-00001134-00002156": "what the hell is a shit", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00005-00002157-00002808": "okay great what happened here you might", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00006-00002809-00003549": "want to reach with nice huh there's just", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00007-00003550-00003779": "a chi minh flip the table and absolutely", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00008-00003780-00004059": "jonard alright here's how this game", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00009-00004060-00004211": "works you ready this is a very weird", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00010-00004212-00004413": "game and it involves absolutely no", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00011-00004414-00004796": "talking whatsoever so there are 100", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00012-00004797-00005217": "cards here so we are all on the team and", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00013-00005218-00005468": "we all have to non-verbally try to", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00014-00005469-00005841": "achieve the goal the goal is I'm gonna", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00015-00005842-00006011": "deal each of us a card right now don't", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00016-00006012-00006156": "say what your card is you can never say", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00017-00006157-00006591": "what your card is why aren't I or to see", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00018-00006592-00007189": "all right here's how it works we have to", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00019-00007190-00007506": "play our cards we have currently one", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00020-00007506-00007680": "card each we have to play them in the", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00021-00007681-00008199": "center here one at a time in no turn", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00022-00008200-00008385": "order and you have to go from lowest to", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00023-00008386-00008625": "highest so right now one of us for", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00024-00008626-00008802": "obviously has the lowest number card 1 3", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00025-00008803-00009036": "100 and the way it works is basically", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00026-00009037-00009234": "and again it's better in person but it's", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00027-00009235-00009672": "still fun on tabletop um you sort of", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00028-00009673-00009918": "just show however you can without", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00029-00009919-00010194": "talking that you're confident that you", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00030-00010195-00010359": "have the lowest card which I know sounds", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00031-00010360-00010644": "hard and it's awkward but you basically", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00032-00010645-00010791": "let yeah if you like zip it to the", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00033-00010792-00010968": "middle you're saying like I'm very", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00034-00010969-00011139": "confident that I have it and if you kind", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00035-00011140-00011526": "of like sheepishly and shit closer like", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00036-00011527-00011754": "this you're saying like I might have it", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00037-00011755-00011877": "but if somebody seems more confident", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00038-00011878-00012042": "than me you might want to go and put", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00039-00012043-00012225": "yours down first and then once it's", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00040-00012226-00012543": "dropped you flip it over and if anybody", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00041-00012544-00012753": "has one that's lower okay we messed up", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00042-00012754-00012896": "then they call it out right away and we", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00043-00012897-00013139": "lose one of these five lives and then", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00044-00013140-00013364": "that's level one in each level you get", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00045-00013365-00013578": "an additional card so it gets kind of", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00046-00013579-00013643": "crazy", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00047-00013644-00013940": "are you Slayer", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00048-00013941-00021061": "oh my god I just explained that to Bach", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00049-00021062-00022474": "let's put my card up there now going on", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00050-00022475-00022934": "hey oh wait what nice perfect", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00051-00022935-00023318": "fuck you teased an 86 to start no isn't", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00052-00023319-00025439": "I'm the 91 okay 27 scripted yeah we're", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00053-00025440-00025619": "gonna leave the 99 bucks gonna get that", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00054-00025620-00025845": "so she see 27 flipped up don't freak out", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00055-00025847-00027955": "okay and go", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00056-00027956-00037623": "oh damn it please life", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00057-00037624-00038967": "nice yeah you gotta put it oh yeah sorry", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00058-00038968-00039892": "just look good yep are you get three", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00059-00039893-00040225": "cards why do you have three cards", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00060-00040226-00040705": "I didn't reduce one I don't know I", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00061-00040706-00045193": "didn't have one last card either", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00062-00045194-00050104": "[Music]", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00063-00050105-00053547": "[Laughter]", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00064-00053548-00053788": "don't you do anything we're all frozen", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00065-00053789-00054271": "solid I thought nobody was moving a", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00066-00054272-00054969": "shake and adamantly no over my that's", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00067-00054970-00055406": "tough yeah that's odd that's my cart", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00068-00055407-00055576": "yeah I agree", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00069-00055577-00055810": "no but you were very adamant well I", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00070-00055811-00056205": "wasn't sure I figured maybe you were in", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00071-00056207-00062296": "the 20s the twenties right away", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00072-00062297-00064467": "Kasey's dose of two quarts left because", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00073-00064469-00064774": "you have left course none see you you", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00074-00064775-00064936": "can't even see my cards I'm done", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00075-00064937-00065200": "Oh everyone's done but me yeah go yeah", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00076-00065201-00065983": "great okay", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00077-00065984-00068119": "yeah hey clean it up you know you always", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00078-00068120-00068302": "put them on sideways on purpose and then", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00079-00068303-00068458": "you say what's going on here with us", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00080-00068459-00069584": "talk to each other", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00081-00069585-00071741": "ready-set-go that for immediately dead", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00082-00071742-00071958": "how do you let anybody do anything", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00083-00071959-00073089": "before four Wow art well then they would", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00084-00073090-00073370": "have flipped it immediately Wow", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00085-00073371-00073848": "hey what's going on here Casey one at a", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00086-00073849-00074103": "time that's not ever gonna work it never", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00087-00074104-00074303": "has and never will", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00088-00074304-00074565": "no it doesn't you have to shake him up", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00089-00074566-00075781": "here to do that are we lost", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00090-00075782-00076450": "[Music]", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00091-00076451-00078202": "[Music]", "QIXywS7W7Fg-00092-00078203-00078409": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "QJf8lGxh1Su", "text": {"QJf8lGxh1Su-00000-00000102-00001123": "[Music]", "QJf8lGxh1Su-00001-00001124-00001497": "thank you", "QJf8lGxh1Su-00002-00001498-00002957": "[Music]", "QJf8lGxh1Su-00003-00002958-00004745": "Hello friends any foreign", "QJf8lGxh1Su-00004-00004746-00007631": "foreign", "QJf8lGxh1Su-00005-00007631-00011621": "foreign", "QJf8lGxh1Su-00006-00011622-00014788": "foreign", "QJf8lGxh1Su-00007-00014790-00019883": "foreign", "QJf8lGxh1Su-00008-00019884-00021247": "Orange", "QJf8lGxh1Su-00009-00021248-00021994": "fruits foreign", "QJf8lGxh1Su-00010-00021995-00023650": "foreign", "QJf8lGxh1Su-00011-00023651-00025553": "[Music]", "QJf8lGxh1Su-00012-00025554-00028552": "subscribe", "QJf8lGxh1Su-00013-00028554-00028868": "thanks for watching"}}, {"audio_id": "QJ-LRtD9Z60", "text": {"QJ-LRtD9Z60-00000-00001096-00001270": "oh it's going to overheal the [__] oh he", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00001-00001271-00001487": "died he died to a random [__]", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00002-00001488-00001791": "when the [__] the random kiss come on", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00003-00001792-00001918": "haven't they always been on knuckle top", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00004-00001919-00002079": "yeah no they got removed like [__]", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00005-00002080-00002439": "forever ago because [__] benny", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00006-00002440-00002599": "i'm too addicted", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00007-00002600-00002734": "anyways", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00008-00002735-00002918": "[__]", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00009-00002919-00003247": "dane hates them he's like what the [__]", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00010-00003247-00003367": "is this [__]", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00011-00003368-00003638": "[__] out of here", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00012-00003639-00003870": "[__] save me man", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00013-00003871-00004022": "i don't [__] i'll park it you got", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00014-00004023-00004454": "them", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00015-00004455-00004606": "he said crispy and chat", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00016-00004607-00004767": "let's go", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00017-00004768-00005063": "go no benny get killed let's go let's go", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00018-00005064-00005879": "are you shooting on them", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00019-00005880-00005991": "you got something to get out of your", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00020-00005992-00006328": "system huh", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00021-00006329-00007327": "[Music]", "QJ-LRtD9Z60-00022-00007328-00007679": "holy [__]"}}, {"audio_id": "QJ_65ouEJxM", "text": {"QJ_65ouEJxM-00000-00000053-00000334": "michael levine is an american", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00001-00000335-00000623": "developmental and cell biologist at", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00002-00000624-00000896": "princeton university where he is the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00003-00000897-00001181": "director of the lewis Seigler institute", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00004-00001182-00001448": "for integrative genomics and a professor", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00005-00001449-00001805": "of molecular biology levine previously", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00006-00001805-00002085": "held appointments at the University of", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00007-00002086-00002429": "California Berkeley the University of", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00008-00002430-00002755": "California San Diego and Columbia", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00009-00002756-00003127": "University he is notable for Co", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00010-00003128-00003509": "discovering the homeobox in 1983 and for", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00011-00003510-00003776": "discovering the organization of the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00012-00003777-00004052": "regulatory regions of developmental", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00013-00004053-00004670": "genes", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00014-00004671-00005254": "topic biography", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00015-00005255-00005567": "Levine was born in West Hollywood and", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00016-00005568-00005867": "raised in Los Angeles Levine studied", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00017-00005868-00006131": "biology as an undergraduate at UC", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00018-00006132-00006457": "Berkeley studying biology with Alan", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00019-00006458-00006995": "Wilson and graduating in 1976 he went on", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00020-00006995-00007280": "to graduate studies at Yale where he", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00021-00007281-00007588": "studied with Alan Guerin and in 1981", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00022-00007589-00007921": "received a PhD in molecular biophysics", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00023-00007922-00008239": "and biochemistry Levine joined the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00024-00008240-00008588": "Princeton faculty in 2015 and had been a", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00025-00008589-00008923": "professor at UC Berkeley after leaving", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00026-00008924-00009723": "UCSD in 1996", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00027-00009724-00010291": "topic discoveries", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00028-00010292-00010620": "you", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00029-00010621-00011251": "topic homeobox discovery", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00030-00011252-00011605": "Levine was a postdoc with Walter Goering", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00031-00011606-00012145": "in Switzerland from 1982 to 1983 there", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00032-00012146-00012481": "Iko discovered the homeobox with ernst", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00033-00012482-00012717": "hafen and fellow postdoc William", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00034-00012718-00013033": "McGinnis after learning that", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00035-00013034-00013377": "ultrabithorax a gene that specifies the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00036-00013378-00013690": "development of wings showed a localized", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00037-00013691-00013947": "pattern of expression similar to that of", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00038-00013948-00014278": "antennae pedia they decided to revisit", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00039-00014279-00014766": "the classic papers of Edie Lewis in 1978", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00040-00014768-00015022": "Lewis had proposed that all these", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00041-00015022-00015294": "homeotic genes the ones that tell", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00042-00015295-00015559": "animals where to put a wing and where to", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00043-00015560-00015855": "put a leg and so on arose from a common", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00044-00015856-00016252": "ancestral gene so McGinnis carved up the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00045-00016253-00016530": "antennae pedia gene and using those", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00046-00016531-00016867": "pieces as probes the trio identified", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00047-00016868-00017130": "eight genes which turned out to be the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00048-00017131-00017430": "eight homeotic genes in flies that", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00049-00017431-00017842": "pissed off a lot of people says Lavigne", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00050-00017843-00018228": "the homeotic genes were the trophies of", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00051-00018229-00018600": "the drosophila genome and we got em all", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00052-00018601-00018894": "I mean we got em all", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00053-00018895-00019297": "far from being humble Levine says we", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00054-00019298-00019549": "were like we kicked your ass pretty good", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00055-00019550-00020344": "didn't we baby those were the days", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00056-00020345-00020734": "topic discovery of the eve stripe 2", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00057-00020735-00021419": "enhancer Levine briefly returned to UC", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00058-00021420-00021697": "Berkeley as a postdoctoral fellow with", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00059-00021698-00021922": "Jerry Rubin he then joined the faculty", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00060-00021923-00022333": "of Columbia University where he led the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00061-00022334-00022687": "discovery of the modular organization of", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00062-00022688-00023020": "the regulatory regions of developmental", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00063-00023021-00023489": "genes after isolating the even skipped", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00064-00023490-00023819": "Eve gene Levine's team determined that", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00065-00023820-00024077": "each of the seven stripes was produced", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00066-00024078-00024439": "by separate enhances with further study", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00067-00024440-00024725": "they discovered that both a set of", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00068-00024726-00024980": "activators and a set of repressors", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00069-00024981-00025225": "worked together to shape the expression", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00070-00025226-00025442": "of Eve in the second stripe and", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00071-00025443-00025702": "determined that the repressors shut down", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00072-00025703-00025993": "only the binding enhances leaving other", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00073-00025994-00026371": "enhances free of repression Joseph", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00074-00026372-00026648": "Corbeau said of the work before Levine's", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00075-00026649-00026951": "studies of even skipped stripe - it", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00076-00026952-00027245": "wasn't clear how you generated spatially", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00077-00027245-00027462": "restricted patterns of gene expression", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00078-00027463-00027806": "from initially broad crude gradients of", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00079-00027807-00027917": "Morpho genes", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00080-00027918-00028283": "I think that the even skipped stripe two", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00081-00028283-00028558": "studies were the defining studies that", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00082-00028559-00028817": "showed how an organism can interpret", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00083-00028818-00029036": "those gradients and turn them into", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00084-00029037-00029456": "specific patterns of gene expression to", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00085-00029457-00030161": "me that's Mike's crowning achievement", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00086-00030162-00030904": "topic discoveries in the acid' ciona", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00087-00030905-00031212": "after earning tenure in only four years", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00088-00031213-00031708": "at Columbia Levine moved to UCSD in 1991", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00089-00031708-00031908": "where he added the sea squirt", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00090-00031909-00032304": "ciona intestinalis to his repertoire", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00091-00032305-00032646": "although much of Levine's work including", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00092-00032647-00032955": "his homeobox studies has been done in", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00093-00032956-00033189": "Drosophila Levine's team is also", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00094-00033190-00033465": "prominent in work with the sea squirt", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00095-00033466-00033823": "Fiona intestinalis an invertebrate that", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00096-00033824-00034189": "facilitates study of development for", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00097-00034190-00034521": "example this work included insights into", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00098-00034522-00034777": "classical Myo determinants and the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00099-00034778-00035005": "composition of the notochord the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00100-00035006-00035792": "defining tissue of the caudate phylum", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00101-00035793-00036374": "topic Awards", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00102-00036375-00036743": "1982 Janne coffin child's postdoctoral", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00103-00036744-00037269": "fellowship 1985 soul scholars research", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00104-00037270-00037749": "fellowship 1985 Alfred P Sloan", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00105-00037750-00038289": "fellowship 1996 nas award in molecular", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00106-00038290-00038657": "biology for his insightful contributions", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00107-00038658-00039036": "to our understanding of gene regulation", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00108-00039037-00039276": "networks and molecular mechanisms", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00109-00039277-00039645": "governing the development of organisms", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00110-00039646-00040115": "with a segmented body plan", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00111-00040116-00040521": "1998 elected to United States National", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00112-00040522-00040871": "Academy of Sciences in cellular and", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00113-00040872-00041337": "developmental biology section utilizing", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00114-00041338-00041592": "an elegant blend of in vitro and in vivo", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00115-00041593-00041952": "studies Levine carried out insightful", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00116-00041953-00042192": "and complete analysis of regulatory", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00117-00042193-00042486": "events that govern segmentation and", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00118-00042487-00042809": "dorsal-ventral polarity in Drosophila", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00119-00042810-00043229": "his work provided a dramatic example of", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00120-00043230-00043512": "combinatorial regulation at a complex", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00121-00043513-00043815": "enhancer and established new paradigms", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00122-00043816-00044442": "for transcriptional control 2009 Wilbur", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00123-00044443-00045194": "cross medal Yale Alumni Association", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00124-00045195-00045845": "topic professional relations", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00125-00045846-00046175": "Levine cites as a significant influence", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00126-00046176-00046499": "his instructor fred wilt taking his", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00127-00046500-00046850": "developmental biology class was probably", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00128-00046851-00047258": "the single most galvanizing experience I", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00129-00047259-00047609": "had in terms of defining my future goals", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00130-00047610-00048020": "and sites fellow scientists Eric", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00131-00048021-00048338": "Davidson Peter Lawrence and Christiana", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00132-00048339-00048974": "saline Vall Hadas mentors and friends", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00133-00048975-00049355": "over the years on choosing to become a", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00134-00049356-00049667": "research biologist he described some", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00135-00049668-00049917": "family pressure to become a doctor", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00136-00049918-00050198": "coming from a modest background", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00137-00050199-00050474": "particularly a Jewish family the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00138-00050475-00050873": "pressure to become a doctor was intense", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00139-00050874-00051245": "fellow biologists Sean Carroll said of", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00140-00051246-00051614": "Levine Mike's work has done for animal", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00141-00051615-00051869": "development what the work on the lac", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00142-00051870-00052162": "operon and phage lambda did for", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00143-00052163-00052503": "understanding gene regulation in simpler", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00144-00052504-00052825": "organisms", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00145-00052826-00053142": "those two big discoveries had a very", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00146-00053144-00053457": "large conceptual significance for", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00147-00053458-00053766": "developmental biology and by extension", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00148-00053767-00054289": "for evolutionary biology Levine is well", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00149-00054290-00054604": "known within academic biologist circles", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00150-00054604-00054874": "for his unconventional sense of humor", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00151-00054875-00055147": "including an incident in which he lit a", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00152-00055148-00055582": "ring of fire around a postdoc the most", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00153-00055583-00055929": "famous thing I ever did is I torched one", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00154-00055930-00056434": "of my postdocs says Levine Joseph", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00155-00056435-00056776": "Corbeau was there at the time Mike got a", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00156-00056777-00057082": "squirt bottle of ethanol unbeknownst to", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00157-00057083-00057400": "this hapless postdoc who was sitting at", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00158-00057401-00057847": "his bench minding his own business says", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00159-00057848-00058183": "Corbeau Levine shot a ring of ethanol", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00160-00058184-00058435": "around the young man's seat and trailed", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00161-00058436-00058813": "a wick into the hallway then he lit it", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00162-00058814-00059170": "so this tongue of flames snaked into the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00163-00059171-00059614": "lab and encircled this post doc says", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00164-00059615-00059965": "Corbeau my technique was a little off", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00165-00059966-00060216": "and I put a little too much ethanol", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00166-00060217-00060705": "around his bench so it's true he was", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00167-00060707-00060985": "temporarily enveloped in a curtain of", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00168-00060986-00061495": "fire says Levine but the fire receded", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00169-00061496-00062122": "and he was okay", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00170-00062123-00062680": "topic training", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00171-00062682-00062980": "Levine has trained researchers in", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00172-00062982-00063238": "developmental biology and molecular", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00173-00063239-00063595": "biology they include Steven's small", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00174-00063596-00063874": "professor of biology at New York", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00175-00063875-00064241": "University and David Hendricks assistant", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00176-00064241-00064565": "professor at Oregon State University and", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00177-00064566-00064694": "Albert arives", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00178-00064695-00065000": "associate professor at University of", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00179-00065001-00065612": "Iowa topic notable papers McGinnis W", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00180-00065613-00065893": "Levine MS half an e", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00181-00065894-00066539": "kuroiwa a Goering WJ 1984 a conserved", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00182-00066540-00066899": "DNA sequence in homeotic genes of the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00183-00066900-00067169": "drosophila antennae pedia and bithorax", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00184-00067170-00068137": "complex --is nature 308 5,000 958 428", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00185-00068138-00068998": "233 bib code 1984 nature point 308 428 m", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00186-00068999-00069434": "DOI 10.1 Oh three eight three oh eight", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00187-00069435-00069935": "four two eight a zero pmid six million", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00188-00069936-00070205": "three hundred and twenty three thousand", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00189-00070206-00070562": "nine hundred and ninety two the homeobox", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00190-00070563-00070970": "paper han q hyung levine michael s", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00191-00070971-00071515": "Manley James L 1989 synergistic", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00192-00071516-00071711": "activation and repression of", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00193-00071712-00072008": "transcription by Drosophila homeobox", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00194-00072009-00073079": "proteins cell 56 4 573 283 DOI 10.1 oh", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00195-00073080-00073442": "one six zero nine two eight six seven", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00196-00073443-00073739": "four eight nine nine oh five eight oh", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00197-00073740-00074231": "one pmid two million five hundred and", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00198-00074232-00074498": "sixty-three thousand six hundred and", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00199-00074499-00075121": "seventy three small s Blair a levine m", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00200-00075122-00075623": "1992 regulation of even skipped stripe -", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00201-00075624-00075941": "in the drosophila embryo the embo", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00202-00075942-00076075": "journal a", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00203-00076076-00077422": "7:11 4047 - 57 PMC 550 6915 pmid 1", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00204-00077423-00077672": "million three hundred and twenty seven", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00205-00077673-00077991": "thousand seven hundred and fifty six", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00206-00077992-00078766": "Aurora K Levine Ms O'Connor MB 1994 the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00207-00078767-00079036": "screw gene encodes a ubiquitously", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00208-00079037-00079387": "expressed member of the tgf-beta family", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00209-00079388-00079687": "required for specification of dorsal", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00210-00079688-00080001": "cell fates in the Drosophila embryo", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00211-00080002-00080260": "genes and development", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00212-00080261-00081340": "8:21 2588 DOI 10.1 101 GAD August 21st", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00213-00081341-00082056": "2588 KY Heine Levine Michael 1995", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00214-00082057-00082309": "modulation of enhancer promoter", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00215-00082310-00082594": "interactions by insulators in the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00216-00082595-00083155": "Drosophila embryo nature 376 six", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00217-00083156-00083431": "thousand five hundred and forty five", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00218-00083432-00083874": "hundred and thirty three to six bib code", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00219-00083875-00084418": "1995 nature point three seven six 533", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00220-00084419-00084647": "see DOI", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00221-00084648-00084967": "ten point one oh three eight three seven", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00222-00084968-00085303": "six five three three a zero", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00223-00085304-00085642": "pmid seven million six hundred and", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00224-00085643-00085910": "thirty seven thousand seven hundred and", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00225-00085911-00086524": "eighty nine honesty DN Barolo s Levine M", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00226-00086525-00087138": "small s 1996 the Eve stripe 2 enhancer", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00227-00087139-00087405": "employs multiple modes of", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00228-00087406-00087935": "transcriptional synergy development 122", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00229-00087936-00088561": "one 205 214 pmid eight million five", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00230-00088562-00088828": "hundred and sixty-five thousand eight", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00231-00088829-00089337": "hundred and thirty-one Joe J Barolo s", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00232-00089338-00089450": "Samantha", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00233-00089451-00090029": "key P Levine M 1996 the Fab seven", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00234-00090030-00090271": "element of the bithorax complex", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00235-00090272-00090526": "attenuates enhancer promoter", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00236-00090527-00090853": "interactions in the Drosophila embryo", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00237-00090854-00091868": "genes and development 1024 3195 DOI 10.1", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00238-00091869-00092561": "101 GAD October 24 31 95 Naboo", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00239-00092562-00092951": "Yutaka shang halen badge or air were", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00240-00092952-00093368": "Barolo scott small stephen levine", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00241-00093369-00093937": "michael 1998 DC tbp mediates", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00242-00093938-00094175": "transcriptional repression by nurbs", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00243-00094176-00094475": "kruppel and snail in the Drosophila", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00244-00094476-00095288": "embryo the embo journal 1723 7009 - 20", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00245-00095289-00096208": "do i 10-point 109 3 in boy 17.2 3.7 oo9", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00246-00096209-00097067": "pmc 1 million 170 1049 pmid nine million", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00247-00097068-00097316": "eight hundred and forty three thousand", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00248-00097317-00097705": "five hundred and seven oat tsuki s", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00249-00097706-00098218": "levine m KY h n nineteen ninety eight", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00250-00098219-00098501": "different core promoters possessed", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00251-00098502-00098804": "distinct regulatory activities in the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00252-00098805-00099152": "Drosophila embryo genes and development", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00253-00099153-00100169": "12 for 547 256 DOI 10.1 101 GAD twelve", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00254-00100170-00100774": "point four point five four seven pmc", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00255-00100775-00101791": "316,000 525 pmid nine million 470 2023", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00256-00101792-00102403": "Manovich M Naboo why Shang H Levine M", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00257-00102404-00102851": "1999 transcriptional coagulator", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00258-00102852-00103867": "in development science 284 5414 606 to 9", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00259-00103868-00104405": "DOI 10.1 1 to 6 science point two eight", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00260-00104406-00104741": "four point five four one four point six", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00261-00104742-00104905": "zero six", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00262-00104906-00105215": "pmid ten million two hundred and", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00263-00105216-00105440": "thirteen thousand six hundred and", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00264-00105441-00105899": "seventy seven marks team Michele Mark's", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00265-00105900-00106250": "team Peter mark Steen Vicki Levine", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00266-00106251-00106841": "Michael s 2002 genome-wide analysis of", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00267-00106842-00107085": "clustered dorsal binding sites", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00268-00107086-00107432": "identifies putative target genes in the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00269-00107433-00107804": "Drosophila embryo Proceedings of the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00270-00107805-00108467": "National Academy of Sciences 99 to 763", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00271-00108468-00109007": "to 8-bit code 200 to PNAS point nine", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00272-00109008-00109889": "nine 763 m DOI 10.1 o-73 PNAS point zero", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00273-00109890-00110283": "one two five nine one one nine nine", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00274-00110284-00110657": "JSTOR three million fifty seven thousand", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00275-00110658-00111170": "six hundred and thirty nine PMC 117", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00276-00111171-00111510": "thousand three hundred and seventy nine", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00277-00111511-00111854": "pmid eleven million seven hundred and", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00278-00111855-00112204": "fifty two thousand four hundred and six", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00279-00112205-00112873": "stay focus Anja like Levine Michael 2002", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00280-00112874-00113158": "dorsal gradient networks in the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00281-00113159-00113677": "Drosophila embryo developmental biology", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00282-00113678-00114547": "246 157 267 DOI 10-point 100 six DBI", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00283-00114548-00115196": "0.200 2.0 six five two pmid 12 million", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00284-00115197-00115618": "27 thousand four hundred and thirty-four", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00285-00115619-00116099": "cycling uh Julia Stark Alexander Kelly's", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00286-00116100-00116249": "man Alice", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00287-00116250-00116699": "jung-woo Nechayev Sergei Adelman Karen", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00288-00116700-00117365": "Levine Michael Young Richard a 2007 RNA", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00289-00117366-00117650": "polymerase stalling at developmental", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00290-00117651-00117899": "control genes in the Drosophila", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00291-00117900-00118445": "melanogaster embryo Nature Genetics 39", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00292-00118446-00118730": "12 15 12 to 6", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00293-00118731-00119222": "do I TenPoint 103 8 per nanograms point", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00294-00119223-00119780": "200 7.26 pmc two million eight hundred", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00295-00119781-00120032": "and twenty four thousand nine hundred", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00296-00120033-00120535": "and twenty one pmid seventy million nine", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00297-00120536-00121378": "hundred and ninety four thousand and 19", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00298-00121379-00122305": "topic notes", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00299-00122306-00122943": "topic external links", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00300-00122944-00123426": "Levine lab website search results for", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00301-00123427-00123761": "author Levine M on PubMed seminars and", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00302-00123763-00124111": "talks Michael Levine's seminar series", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00303-00124113-00124340": "transcriptional precision in the", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00304-00124341-00124764": "Drosophila embryo interviews print and", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00305-00124765-00125083": "video video interview with Levine", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00306-00125084-00125635": "evolution great transformations WGBH", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00307-00125636-00126198": "2001 Levine interviewed in what Darwin", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00308-00126199-00126842": "never knew PBS Nova December 21st 2011", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00309-00126843-00127200": "video interview with Levine by Andrea", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00310-00127201-00127715": "Andersen the biology of genomes 2008", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00311-00127716-00128607": "sigh V April 8 2009 Levine M 2003 Mike", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00312-00128608-00129518": "Levine Current Biology 1314 our 545 DOI", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00313-00129519-00130408": "10.1 o16 so9 609 8 to 200 300 4-6 6-4", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00314-00130409-00130995": "pmid 12 million 860 7042", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00315-00130996-00131513": "profile shopkin Karen March 1st 2007", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00316-00131514-00132268": "firefly the scientist 21 358", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00317-00132269-00132653": "25 years of homeodomain homeobox", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00318-00132654-00133444": "discovery evo-devo hawks May 10 2008 fly", "QJ_65ouEJxM-00319-00133445-00134238": "guy science matters UC Berkeley 1:7"}}, {"audio_id": "QJDTuc3mv7g", "text": {"QJDTuc3mv7g-00000-00000008-00000231": "old ministry um you might hear people", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00001-00000231-00000423": "talking about this especially in newer", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00002-00000424-00000799": "christian circles um and the idea is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00003-00000800-00000935": "what they mean when they bring up the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00004-00000936-00001095": "fightful ministry what they actually", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00005-00001096-00001223": "mean is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00006-00001224-00001527": "um apostles are coming back apostles and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00007-00001528-00001695": "prophets are coming back and you see", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00008-00001696-00001942": "like uh bethel church talks about this a", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00009-00001943-00002326": "lot you all right buddy", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00010-00002327-00002558": "important not to inhale the water it's", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00011-00002559-00002783": "very important uh but anyways and so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00012-00002784-00002999": "what they really mean is not a not a", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00013-00003000-00003175": "five-fold ministry what they really mean", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00014-00003176-00003375": "is apostles and prophets are coming back", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00015-00003376-00003519": "and i'm one of them because i said that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00016-00003520-00003838": "i was and i'm you know come to you know", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00017-00003839-00004022": "basically they just want to say i have", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00018-00004023-00004222": "authority that's above the bible and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00019-00004223-00004438": "above tradition so i can just kind of", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00020-00004439-00004583": "make up whatever weird things that i", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00021-00004584-00004759": "want and everybody just has to go along", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00022-00004760-00005006": "with it which this is based on so many", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00023-00005007-00005206": "different false conceptions", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00024-00005207-00005463": "so um before we get going there's kind", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00025-00005464-00005631": "of a debate as to whether or not", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00026-00005632-00005863": "apostles are still a thing or not", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00027-00005864-00006254": "so i'll try to offer a balanced look to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00028-00006255-00006375": "where you can", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00029-00006376-00006606": "believe whichever view you want i'm not", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00030-00006608-00006742": "trying to push you into one view or", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00031-00006743-00006934": "another i'm just trying to offer some", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00032-00006936-00007095": "clarity so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00033-00007095-00007206": "we'll we'll start off looking at", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00034-00007208-00007406": "ephesians 4 11 through 15 because that's", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00035-00007408-00007631": "typically where they look at", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00036-00007631-00007814": "and uh we're talking about this because", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00037-00007815-00008006": "we were talking about the false uh", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00038-00008008-00008183": "leaders and whatnot or false teachers", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00039-00008184-00008391": "and false doctrine all that stuff so and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00040-00008392-00008623": "he himself gave some to the apostles the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00041-00008624-00008839": "question being he who is he himself", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00042-00008840-00008951": "christ", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00043-00008952-00009183": "christ gave some to be apostles some", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00044-00009184-00009351": "prophets some evangelists and pastors", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00045-00009352-00009551": "and teachers to equip the saints for the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00046-00009552-00009767": "work of ministry to build up the body of", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00047-00009768-00009959": "christ until we all reach unity in the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00048-00009960-00010110": "faith and then", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00049-00010111-00010319": "and in the knowledge of god's son", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00050-00010320-00010495": "growing into major maturity with the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00051-00010496-00010710": "stature measured by christ's fullness", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00052-00010711-00010831": "then we will no longer be little", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00053-00010832-00010999": "children tossed by the waves and blown", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00054-00011000-00011223": "around by every wind of doc of teaching", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00055-00011224-00011391": "but human cunning with cleverness and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00056-00011392-00011670": "the techniques of deceit i'm sorry bye", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00057-00011671-00011855": "bye human cunning with cleverness in the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00058-00011856-00012070": "uh techniques of deceit but speaking the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00059-00012071-00012263": "truth and love let us grow in every way", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00060-00012264-00012551": "into him who is the head christ so the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00061-00012552-00012663": "first thing that i kind of want to point", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00062-00012664-00012879": "out before we can get going on this is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00063-00012880-00013046": "that uh it's very common in these", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00064-00013047-00013238": "circles to say things along the lines of", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00065-00013240-00013471": "this jesus could only do what he did by", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00066-00013472-00013622": "the empowerment of the holy spirit", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00067-00013623-00013855": "therefore we can do the same things that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00068-00013856-00014135": "christ did and even more so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00069-00014136-00014255": "no", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00070-00014256-00014383": "no", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00071-00014384-00014703": "first off this is this is kind of a poor", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00072-00014704-00014951": "idea of the trinity", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00073-00014952-00015319": "uh second off christ really didn't", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00074-00015319-00015527": "christ was not dependent on the holy", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00075-00015528-00015799": "spirit he was god himself", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00076-00015800-00016022": "that kind of makes sense so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00077-00016023-00016183": "there's that first issue and then the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00078-00016184-00016366": "second thing i want to point out is he", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00079-00016368-00016567": "just said there he himself gave some to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00080-00016568-00016783": "the apostles who gave", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00081-00016784-00016975": "not the holy spirit", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00082-00016976-00017247": "christ gave some to be apostles and some", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00083-00017248-00017471": "to be prophets that's kind of important", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00084-00017472-00017607": "because they always want to discredit", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00085-00017608-00017863": "jesus lower him to us and then exalt the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00086-00017864-00018135": "holy spirit and then make us like", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00087-00018136-00018255": "like god", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00088-00018256-00018375": "and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00089-00018376-00018527": "that's why they they kind of lean", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00090-00018528-00018719": "strongly on those vague passages like", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00091-00018720-00018894": "when we looked at i think was last week", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00092-00018895-00019167": "we were talking about um being little", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00093-00019168-00019279": "gods", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00094-00019280-00019543": "it it's always about our us being", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00095-00019544-00019750": "elevated it's not about as depending on", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00096-00019751-00020022": "god it's about us um you know like joyce", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00097-00020023-00020158": "meyer was talking about our power", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00098-00020159-00020375": "consciousness because", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00099-00020376-00020567": "kind of becoming aware of who we are and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00100-00020568-00020735": "that kind of stuff it's not about", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00101-00020736-00020950": "the holy spirit doing a work in us or", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00102-00020951-00021135": "depending on god it's about us and what", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00103-00021136-00021286": "we already are we just have to realize", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00104-00021287-00021543": "it um just totally different totally", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00105-00021544-00021719": "different um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00106-00021720-00021871": "and bethel church says this a lot where", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00107-00021872-00022094": "they'll say okay so you can do the same", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00108-00022095-00022303": "things as christ because he only did it", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00109-00022304-00022422": "by the power of the holy spirit without", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00110-00022423-00022527": "the holy spirit he couldn't have done", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00111-00022528-00022822": "those things and so you too can do the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00112-00022823-00023030": "same things even more so it's like you", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00113-00023031-00023175": "know that's just that's just not true so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00114-00023176-00023367": "let's look at this", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00115-00023368-00023591": "is this for today or should we discredit", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00116-00023592-00023822": "it well as far as i can tell now once", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00117-00023823-00023950": "again i'm not trying to sway you one", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00118-00023951-00024142": "another this is what i believe based off", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00119-00024143-00024350": "of my study of the bible", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00120-00024351-00024558": "i don't see anywhere where it says that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00121-00024559-00024983": "the apostleship has been discontinued", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00122-00024984-00025135": "and i feel like that's kind of an", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00123-00025136-00025294": "important point to me because paul said", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00124-00025295-00025519": "okay there's something made to be", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00125-00025520-00025783": "apostles and then he said he didn't say", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00126-00025783-00026039": "like for a limited time", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00127-00026039-00026206": "so there is that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00128-00026207-00026431": "um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00129-00026432-00026695": "the idea being that as so long as god is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00130-00026695-00026902": "doing work he could potentially still", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00131-00026904-00027095": "raise up apostles", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00132-00027095-00027302": "um there are some parts and we'll we'll", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00133-00027304-00027543": "look at that so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00134-00027544-00027735": "another thing is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00135-00027736-00028046": "it gets very complicated because paul", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00136-00028047-00028279": "did not invent the word", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00137-00028280-00028518": "apostolos apostle", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00138-00028519-00028590": "he", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00139-00028591-00028855": "there was a language that paul already", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00140-00028856-00029079": "knew and spoke called greek", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00141-00029080-00029302": "and he took some borrowed some of these", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00142-00029304-00029574": "terms to use for things in", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00143-00029575-00029783": "the bible so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00144-00029783-00029990": "when he was writing his letters so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00145-00029991-00030183": "there's the same word just used", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00146-00030183-00030287": "differently", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00147-00030288-00030558": "apostle is sometimes used in the sense", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00148-00030560-00030718": "of", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00149-00030719-00030983": "sorry about that guys uh sammy really", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00150-00030983-00031302": "has some strong lungs to him um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00151-00031303-00031543": "so there's the he uses the the word", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00152-00031544-00031735": "apostle for instance as", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00153-00031736-00032031": "the apostles but also as a general term", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00154-00032032-00032414": "meaning apostle so let's just and this", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00155-00032416-00032558": "isn't the only word that he does this", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00156-00032560-00032646": "with", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00157-00032647-00032927": "but uh so let me kind of try to clarify", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00158-00032928-00033143": "what that is the apostles would be like", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00159-00033144-00033374": "the 12 the 12 apostles who followed", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00160-00033375-00033687": "jesus um they would be eyewitnesses to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00161-00033688-00033895": "jesus's life when he was actually here", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00162-00033896-00034023": "on earth", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00163-00034024-00034159": "they did have authority they had", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00164-00034160-00034374": "authority to establish the church um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00165-00034375-00034567": "absolutely", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00166-00034568-00034743": "excuse me but um something to keep in", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00167-00034744-00034887": "mind is that the church is already", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00168-00034888-00035111": "established at this point today we don't", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00169-00035112-00035359": "really need more apostles to establish", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00170-00035360-00035630": "it it's already established and then the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00171-00035631-00035871": "idea of well what about um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00172-00035872-00036199": "uh what we believe can a self-proclaimed", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00173-00036200-00036318": "apostle", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00174-00036319-00036543": "say something you know and just declare", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00175-00036544-00036743": "it and that's the way it is well only if", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00176-00036744-00036951": "it matches up with the bible", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00177-00036952-00037055": "um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00178-00037056-00037311": "and not even apostles back then had the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00179-00037312-00037535": "ability to discredit scripture", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00180-00037536-00037807": "um for first corinthians 9 1 paul says", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00181-00037808-00037911": "this and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00182-00037912-00038062": "this makes it sound like paul is saying", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00183-00038063-00038230": "that he is an apostle definitely am i", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00184-00038231-00038511": "not free am i not an apostle it's a it's", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00185-00038512-00038646": "a rhetorical question he's saying he's", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00186-00038647-00038862": "an apostle so it sounds like he's saying", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00187-00038863-00039111": "that he's one of the apostles not just", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00188-00039112-00039359": "an apostle but one of the apostles so he", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00189-00039360-00039599": "wasn't one of the twelve obviously um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00190-00039600-00039799": "but he did", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00191-00039800-00040030": "see jesus okay so he says have i not", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00192-00040031-00040311": "seen jesus our lord the question being", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00193-00040312-00040567": "is he implying that in order to be a", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00194-00040568-00040846": "part an apostle you had to see jesus i", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00195-00040847-00041023": "don't know it's a little bit vague he", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00196-00041024-00041439": "says have i not seen jesus our lord but", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00197-00041440-00041630": "he also says are you not my work in the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00198-00041631-00041718": "lord", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00199-00041719-00041887": "so is he saying that in order to be an", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00200-00041888-00042118": "apostle you have to have seen jesus in", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00201-00042119-00042318": "when he was alive here on earth i don't", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00202-00042319-00042430": "know", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00203-00042431-00042607": "that's a really good question but i just", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00204-00042608-00042735": "don't know", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00205-00042736-00043062": "another thing is he says um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00206-00043063-00043223": "he says elsewhere", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00207-00043224-00043374": "um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00208-00043375-00043567": "how he's an apostle he says and i'm one", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00209-00043568-00043783": "and i'm the least of these", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00210-00043784-00044023": "now some people have taken that to mean", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00211-00044024-00044207": "that he's saying that he is the last", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00212-00044208-00044407": "apostle", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00213-00044408-00044623": "but it sounds like in the context that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00214-00044624-00044918": "he's saying that he is he feels like", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00215-00044919-00045079": "he is not", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00216-00045080-00045327": "the most adequate for the job i'm the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00217-00045328-00045543": "least of these see what i mean", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00218-00045544-00045662": "that's what it sounds like to me it", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00219-00045663-00045815": "doesn't sound like he's saying i'm the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00220-00045816-00046046": "last that there will ever be", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00221-00046047-00046207": "and so you know", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00222-00046208-00046495": "you take that for however but it just", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00223-00046496-00046662": "doesn't seem like that to me", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00224-00046663-00046927": "um it seems like when people say that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00225-00046928-00047086": "well paul said that he was the last", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00226-00047087-00047302": "apostle it sounds like they're trying to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00227-00047303-00047471": "make it say something that it wasn't", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00228-00047472-00047727": "saying i could be wrong so in second", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00229-00047728-00047958": "corinthians 12 12 paul wrote this the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00230-00047959-00048151": "signs of an apostle were performed with", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00231-00048152-00048383": "unfailing endurance among you so he's", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00232-00048384-00048502": "saying right there that there are", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00233-00048503-00048743": "certain signs that a an apostle performs", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00234-00048744-00048990": "and check this out including signs and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00235-00048991-00049215": "wonders and miracles", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00236-00049216-00049286": "so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00237-00049287-00049567": "apostles evidently had the ability to do", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00238-00049568-00049790": "signs and wonders and miracles this is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00239-00049791-00050095": "kind of an important point", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00240-00050096-00050374": "um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00241-00050375-00050455": "and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00242-00050456-00050607": "as we're gonna as we read there in", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00243-00050608-00050751": "ephesians and we'll look at it again", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00244-00050752-00050886": "there's another passage in ephesians", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00245-00050887-00051007": "chapter two", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00246-00051008-00051270": "um he makes it absolutely clear that the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00247-00051271-00051494": "apostles were established by christ in", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00248-00051495-00051735": "order to establish the church", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00249-00051736-00051830": "so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00250-00051832-00052063": "um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00251-00052064-00052238": "by and large the church doesn't really", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00252-00052239-00052471": "need to be established anymore it is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00253-00052472-00052671": "established in the world um it was", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00254-00052672-00052838": "important during the first you know", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00255-00052839-00052991": "generation or two after jesus that it", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00256-00052991-00053142": "was established because it didn't exist", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00257-00053144-00053271": "before", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00258-00053272-00053430": "but with that being said are there", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00259-00053432-00053638": "places in the world where the church is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00260-00053639-00053807": "not", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00261-00053808-00053966": "yes", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00262-00053967-00054135": "so doesn't that mean that there could", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00263-00054136-00054350": "hypothetically at least be apostles", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00264-00054351-00054566": "because apostles are", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00265-00054567-00054735": "part of what establishes the church in", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00266-00054736-00055047": "an area it seems like yes", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00267-00055048-00055230": "um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00268-00055232-00055342": "and i already mentioned the way that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00269-00055344-00055559": "paul may have been the last technical of", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00270-00055560-00055823": "the apostles not an apostle general and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00271-00055824-00055926": "you might say so what's the difference", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00272-00055927-00056119": "between the apostle and an apostle and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00273-00056120-00056287": "i'll explain that in just a second", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00274-00056288-00056454": "but it's important to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00275-00056455-00056623": "to point out the facts and this is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00276-00056624-00056759": "something that even like roman", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00277-00056760-00056966": "catholicism tries to do there's no such", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00278-00056967-00057159": "thing as an apostle line", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00279-00057160-00057326": "right like authority handed down from", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00280-00057327-00057542": "apostle to apostle that's we've seen no", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00281-00057544-00057815": "examples of that in the bible um we see", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00282-00057816-00058087": "peter was an apostle right or you know", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00283-00058088-00058230": "one of the apostles he was one of the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00284-00058232-00058382": "twelve", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00285-00058383-00058559": "and then what happens", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00286-00058560-00058766": "well did he hand his authority down well", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00287-00058767-00059007": "the roman church likes to pretend but no", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00288-00059008-00059111": "he didn't", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00289-00059112-00059311": "he didn't say okay here's my bishop", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00290-00059312-00059535": "prick and i'm handing my bishop-ness", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00291-00059536-00059719": "down to the next guy and so now we have", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00292-00059720-00059823": "the pope", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00293-00059824-00060063": "no no no no no the bible actually never", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00294-00060064-00060238": "teaches that that's something that was", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00295-00060239-00060415": "invented a lot later and they tried to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00296-00060416-00060550": "justify it", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00297-00060551-00060775": "which i think is extremely historically", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00298-00060776-00060959": "dishonest but whatever", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00299-00060960-00061047": "um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00300-00061048-00061230": "so one thing to keep in mind with all", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00301-00061232-00061391": "these things is regardless of whether", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00302-00061391-00061606": "apostles are still", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00303-00061607-00061791": "being used today or are not so beings", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00304-00061791-00061991": "today they are they have limited", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00305-00061991-00062230": "authority now i this is what paul says", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00306-00062232-00062423": "about peter now remember peter was an", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00307-00062424-00062703": "apostle right paul was an apostle but", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00308-00062704-00062903": "when kephas that's peter", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00309-00062904-00063206": "came to antioch i being paul opposed him", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00310-00063207-00063447": "to his face because he stood condemned", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00311-00063448-00063623": "what the implication there being that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00312-00063624-00063830": "peter was wrong", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00313-00063832-00064063": "paul just said that peter was wrong", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00314-00064064-00064254": "therefore an apostle does not have", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00315-00064255-00064550": "complete authority and he can be wrong", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00316-00064551-00064838": "um titus 2 15 another thing that the the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00317-00064839-00064991": "apostles of modern day upon", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00318-00064991-00065206": "self-proclaimed apostles they proclaim", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00319-00065207-00065375": "themselves apostles", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00320-00065376-00065519": "then they just kind of roll with it i am", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00321-00065520-00065631": "an apostle", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00322-00065632-00065847": "says who says me", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00323-00065848-00066023": "um so you know they proclaim themselves", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00324-00066024-00066182": "apostles and one thing that's important", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00325-00066183-00066399": "is they do this so that they can have", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00326-00066400-00066638": "power struggles with with the pastor", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00327-00066639-00066815": "i'm an apostle so therefore the pastor", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00328-00066816-00067038": "has to listen to me well look what paul", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00329-00067039-00067303": "wrote to titus who was a pastor proclaim", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00330-00067304-00067543": "these things encourage and rebuke with", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00331-00067544-00067815": "all authority so who had authority in", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00332-00067816-00067935": "the church", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00333-00067936-00068063": "the pastor", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00334-00068064-00068319": "paul just said that the pastor had the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00335-00068320-00068519": "authority and this is an apostle i'm", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00336-00068520-00068791": "sorry an apostle talking to a pastor he", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00337-00068792-00068991": "says you have complete authority in the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00338-00068992-00069126": "church", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00339-00069127-00069287": "so kind of an important point for these", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00340-00069288-00069455": "people who are trying to just usurp the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00341-00069456-00069599": "pastor's authority", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00342-00069600-00069799": "and then it says let no one disregard or", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00343-00069800-00069919": "despise you", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00344-00069920-00070119": "pastors are not subject to modern day", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00345-00070120-00070399": "so-called prophets or apostles", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00346-00070400-00070559": "in no way or shape or form and neither", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00347-00070560-00070838": "is the bible", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00348-00070839-00071055": "and another little thing that they that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00349-00071056-00071231": "they don't really like to point out here", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00350-00071232-00071359": "is that god won't contradict him and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00351-00071360-00071550": "contradict himself", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00352-00071551-00071791": "so if and a prophet or apostle says", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00353-00071792-00072006": "something that's against the bible well", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00354-00072007-00072126": "then it's wrong and another thing that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00355-00072127-00072262": "they say and i'll look at this in just a", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00356-00072263-00072535": "minute is it's not bible it's not father", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00357-00072536-00072782": "son and holy bible well yes but if the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00358-00072783-00072943": "bible was given with the inspiration of", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00359-00072944-00073087": "the holy spirit well then he's not going", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00360-00073088-00073238": "to contradict himself because he doesn't", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00361-00073239-00073615": "lie", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00362-00073616-00073919": "god does still give spiritual gifts", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00363-00073920-00074150": "where and when they are needed to those", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00364-00074151-00074319": "he decides", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00365-00074320-00074599": "does god still send people now now this", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00366-00074600-00074847": "this", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00367-00074848-00075087": "i'm going to go talk about the slide", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00368-00075088-00075238": "that i'm going to go to because it's", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00369-00075239-00075487": "kind of important the word apostle comes", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00370-00075488-00075679": "from the greek word apostolos and what", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00371-00075680-00075879": "it means is a messenger", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00372-00075880-00076231": "or someone who is sent", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00373-00076232-00076447": "so we are god's ambassadors", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00374-00076448-00076679": "we are all in a sense", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00375-00076680-00076894": "apostles in a sense", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00376-00076895-00077150": "we're sent by god", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00377-00077151-00077247": "okay", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00378-00077248-00077494": "all right but there is a distinction in", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00379-00077495-00077687": "scripture between the apostles someone", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00380-00077688-00077894": "who has a position", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00381-00077895-00077975": "and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00382-00077976-00078303": "generally speaking someone who is sent", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00383-00078304-00078503": "so peter for instance was one of the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00384-00078504-00078743": "apostles paul was", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00385-00078744-00078959": "one of the apostles but then there were", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00386-00078960-00079343": "other people that it says was sent", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00387-00079344-00079591": "in a general term everywhere so remember", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00388-00079592-00079815": "the greek language existed before paul", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00389-00079816-00080023": "wrote the bible rather than in the parts", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00390-00080024-00080206": "of the new testament i should say", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00391-00080207-00080294": "um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00392-00080295-00080511": "and so when he says apostle he sometimes", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00393-00080512-00080655": "means it in the sense of the greek", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00394-00080656-00080855": "language the one who is sent", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00395-00080856-00081006": "and sometimes he means it in the sense", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00396-00081007-00081238": "that he borrowed it", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00397-00081239-00081543": "uh someone who is has a specific role", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00398-00081544-00081750": "for however long", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00399-00081751-00081918": "um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00400-00081919-00082118": "so does god still send people does god", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00401-00082119-00082350": "still have apostles well and i'm gonna", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00402-00082351-00082526": "argue this i'm gonna say that there are", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00403-00082527-00082671": "still apostles we just call them", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00404-00082672-00082838": "missionaries", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00405-00082839-00083055": "that's going to be my", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00406-00083056-00083287": "my take on this i think that the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00407-00083288-00083518": "position of the apostles no longer", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00408-00083519-00083638": "exists", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00409-00083639-00083806": "because i think that they had to have", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00410-00083807-00084006": "those signs and miracles that they had", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00411-00084007-00084126": "that they had authority that they", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00412-00084127-00084318": "established you know a lot of the things", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00413-00084319-00084455": "in the new testament scripture and that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00414-00084456-00084591": "kind of stuff okay", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00415-00084592-00084759": "that they um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00416-00084760-00084918": "you know had they were head over the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00417-00084919-00085087": "church and that kind of stuff until they", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00418-00085088-00085223": "until they raised up pastors and that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00419-00085224-00085431": "kind of stuff but it seems like that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00420-00085432-00085647": "position did in fact go away", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00421-00085648-00085911": "but the general position of an apostle", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00422-00085912-00086118": "is still exists in the person of", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00423-00086119-00086367": "missionaries", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00424-00086368-00086591": "so does god still send people absolutely", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00425-00086592-00086767": "do they have to have the same authority", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00426-00086768-00087094": "as the apostles no missionaries can go", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00427-00087095-00087223": "and tell people about jesus and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00428-00087224-00087406": "establish a church without having to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00429-00087407-00087638": "have authority to establish new doctrine", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00430-00087639-00087831": "they don't have to have that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00431-00087832-00087950": "so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00432-00087951-00088103": "that's something worth considering so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00433-00088104-00088231": "let's look at apostles real quick it", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00434-00088232-00088462": "just it's just an apostles a greek word", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00435-00088463-00088615": "meaning messenger and voice someone who", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00436-00088616-00088743": "has sent", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00437-00088744-00088943": "the apostles are separate from apostles", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00438-00088944-00089167": "that's my that's my takeaway from this", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00439-00089168-00089382": "um it paul never specifically says that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00440-00089383-00089591": "he never says by the way", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00441-00089592-00089815": "the apostles are not apostles he never", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00442-00089816-00090055": "says that this is just from my time", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00443-00090056-00090335": "studying what i believe paul is saying", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00444-00090336-00090591": "um if there are modern day apostles they", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00445-00090592-00090775": "do not have authority to establish new", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00446-00090776-00090975": "doctrine they do not have authority over", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00447-00090976-00091111": "churches", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00448-00091112-00091287": "they cannot contradict what what paul", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00449-00091288-00091518": "and peter and the other 12 established", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00450-00091519-00091655": "they can't go against what the bible", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00451-00091656-00091735": "says", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00452-00091736-00091975": "um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00453-00091976-00092294": "so there's that and so then remember at", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00454-00092295-00092406": "the beginning of the lesson we we", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00455-00092407-00092615": "started reading a passage from ephesians", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00456-00092616-00092767": "4 that talked about the five-fold", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00457-00092768-00092935": "ministry you know apostles and prophets", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00458-00092936-00093087": "and all those different things right the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00459-00093088-00093374": "evangelists uh pastors and teachers and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00460-00093375-00093559": "whatnot", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00461-00093560-00093735": "so then that takes us to ephesians 2 20", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00462-00093736-00093911": "which is two chapters before that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00463-00093912-00094174": "passage and it says specifically", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00464-00094175-00094382": "built on the foundations", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00465-00094383-00094591": "of the apostles and prophets with christ", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00466-00094592-00094831": "jesus himself as a cornerstone it seems", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00467-00094832-00094991": "like paul is talking about the order", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00468-00094992-00095215": "that the church was established jesus", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00469-00095216-00095431": "was the cornerstone and then apostles", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00470-00095432-00095615": "were sent with prophets and then", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00471-00095616-00095855": "evangelists and then teachers and pre", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00472-00095856-00096006": "preachers and teachers", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00473-00096007-00096159": "it seems like that he's he's just", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00474-00096160-00096406": "talking about the the the way that the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00475-00096407-00096567": "church was built", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00476-00096568-00096711": "so then what would be the difference", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00477-00096712-00096999": "between an apostle a prophet and a", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00478-00097000-00097238": "evangelist", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00479-00097239-00097479": "to be honest i'm not quite sure i spent", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00480-00097480-00097606": "a lot of time studying this and i'm", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00481-00097607-00097838": "still not entirely sure and then to make", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00482-00097839-00097967": "it worse it seems like everybody has", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00483-00097968-00098071": "their own opinion that they want to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00484-00098072-00098223": "create across and it seems like", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00485-00098224-00098326": "sometimes", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00486-00098327-00098894": "paul used words that were real similar", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00487-00098895-00099143": "to talk about um somebody's el how", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00488-00099144-00099311": "somebody might be a little bit gifted in", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00489-00099312-00099543": "a different area over another area", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00490-00099544-00099726": "so is he talking about a prophet is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00491-00099727-00099959": "someone who tells the future or is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00492-00099960-00100167": "someone who tells somebody about their", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00493-00100168-00100438": "sin", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00494-00100439-00100567": "if you read for instance the books of", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00495-00100568-00100687": "the prophets that's what the prophets", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00496-00100688-00100791": "did they said", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00497-00100792-00101087": "you know nineveh repent", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00498-00101088-00101318": "um and so apostle would be someone who", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00499-00101319-00101518": "is sent to someone this would be like", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00500-00101519-00101750": "paul in the book of acts a prophet would", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00501-00101751-00101926": "be someone who either", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00502-00101927-00102111": "told the future like the the guy that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00503-00102112-00102255": "said hey there's a famine coming once", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00504-00102256-00102502": "again in the book of acts um or it could", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00505-00102503-00102751": "be someone who tells someone um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00506-00102752-00102910": "you know they're you know", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00507-00102911-00103094": "as sin and how god wants them to repent", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00508-00103095-00103254": "so then what's an evangelist well an", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00509-00103255-00103478": "evangelist comes from the word yuan", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00510-00103479-00103734": "gaelian which is good news or gospel so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00511-00103735-00104023": "uh an evangelist would be someone who", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00512-00104024-00104254": "gives the good news", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00513-00104255-00104454": "so how is that different than an apostle", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00514-00104455-00104615": "i'm not sure", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00515-00104616-00104823": "i'm just not sure i know what a pastor", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00516-00104824-00104990": "and a teacher is i know those things are", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00517-00104991-00105175": "obvious but i i don't know what the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00518-00105176-00105415": "distinction is between those two things", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00519-00105416-00105543": "um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00520-00105544-00105751": "my view is that apostles are modern-day", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00521-00105752-00105910": "and missionaries they establish the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00522-00105911-00106071": "church in areas where that doesn't exist", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00523-00106072-00106190": "absolutely", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00524-00106191-00106302": "um and i already mentioned this the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00525-00106303-00106454": "order of the church existing the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00526-00106455-00106647": "creation stage the one who has sent", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00527-00106648-00106863": "apostle prophets being is it", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00528-00106864-00107015": "is he talking about a spiritual gift or", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00529-00107016-00107183": "is he talking about someone who corrects", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00530-00107183-00107383": "somebody then those who give the good", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00531-00107383-00107575": "news evangelists and then there's the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00532-00107576-00107815": "growth stage the church is there it's", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00533-00107816-00108095": "just being grown those who solidify and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00534-00108096-00108263": "grow pastors and teachers they they", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00535-00108264-00108463": "teach about god's word they they help", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00536-00108464-00108751": "equip the uh the church and then if you", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00537-00108752-00108943": "notice", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00538-00108944-00109231": "at the end of all these things and the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00539-00109232-00109407": "at the very first verse that we looked", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00540-00109408-00109478": "at", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00541-00109479-00109686": "ephesians 4 after he goes through", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00542-00109688-00109831": "talking about the five-fold ministry", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00543-00109832-00110110": "okay he gave jesus gave some to be", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00544-00110111-00110271": "apostles some prophets some evangelists", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00545-00110272-00110454": "and pastors and teachers he's talking", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00546-00110455-00110647": "about the order that it's created the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00547-00110648-00110807": "the order the church is created and then", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00548-00110808-00111078": "the final stage is that the saints the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00549-00111079-00111239": "church is equipped for the work of", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00550-00111240-00111366": "ministry", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00551-00111367-00111615": "so the pastors and teachers exist", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00552-00111616-00111823": "for the sake of raising the church up to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00553-00111824-00111983": "minister", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00554-00111983-00112175": "so it seems like he's very much so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00555-00112176-00112351": "talking about a stage that began with", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00556-00112352-00112454": "jesus", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00557-00112455-00112631": "and then the apostles and ends with", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00558-00112632-00112783": "pastors equipping", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00559-00112783-00113023": "the church and the church going out and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00560-00113024-00113207": "raising up more", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00561-00113208-00113375": "that's that's the pattern that paul", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00562-00113376-00113686": "seems to be establishing in ephesians um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00563-00113688-00113863": "which when i this is the first time i've", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00564-00113864-00114134": "ever done a a a serious study", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00565-00114135-00114334": "on the fivefold ministry and i think", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00566-00114335-00114575": "i've learned a lot myself", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00567-00114576-00114783": "um so then the the end result is of the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00568-00114783-00114943": "churches equipped one of the big", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00569-00114944-00115110": "problems with modern day apostles", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00570-00115111-00115319": "self-proclaimed apostles and prophets is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00571-00115320-00115478": "that they seem to be in it for their own", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00572-00115479-00115734": "glory and for just getting a name and a", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00573-00115735-00115910": "position they don't really seem to be", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00574-00115911-00116151": "trying to equip people from ministry", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00575-00116152-00116415": "they're not trying to hand off authority", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00576-00116416-00116607": "trying to raise up other people trying", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00577-00116608-00116815": "to establish something they're trying to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00578-00116816-00117039": "establish themselves", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00579-00117040-00117286": "and that's one of the problems i have", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00580-00117288-00117471": "like people like these televangelists", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00581-00117472-00117647": "like joyce meyer they're okay with", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00582-00117648-00117790": "selling these books and everything to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00583-00117791-00118039": "where you're dependent on them but", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00584-00118040-00118223": "they're not really wanting you to grow", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00585-00118224-00118495": "and mature and and go on they're wanting", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00586-00118496-00118671": "you to be dependent on them that's not", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00587-00118672-00118886": "what an apostle does an apostle raises", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00588-00118888-00119151": "up the church so the pastors they're", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00589-00119152-00119375": "working together for a common goal to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00590-00119376-00119566": "establish the church and i'm not saying", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00591-00119567-00119734": "that in these modern day self-proclaimed", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00592-00119735-00119863": "apostles", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00593-00119864-00120119": "so the question should be are these", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00594-00120120-00120302": "people apostles not", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00595-00120303-00120527": "are there apostles and i think that some", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00596-00120528-00120895": "people ins are in such a such a hurry to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00597-00120896-00121071": "say that these people are not apostles", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00598-00121072-00121214": "that they go to the extreme and say that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00599-00121215-00121343": "there are no such thing as apostles", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00600-00121344-00121558": "anymore and i just don't think i don't", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00601-00121559-00121799": "think that that level of", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00602-00121800-00122119": "extremism is overly helpful so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00603-00122120-00122358": "let's look at first john 4 1-6 where he", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00604-00122359-00122614": "talks about um how", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00605-00122615-00122847": "you should test the spirits many people", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00606-00122848-00122983": "say that they're prophets that they have", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00607-00122983-00123207": "a word from god and they'll even shake", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00608-00123208-00123283": "and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00609-00123283-00123527": "oh like i had this one guy a couple", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00610-00123528-00123783": "months ago he comes up and you i have a", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00611-00123783-00123975": "i i have a word from you and he said", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00612-00123976-00124199": "this thing and he's like", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00613-00124200-00124310": "powerful", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00614-00124311-00124519": "i was just like if you say so buddy but", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00615-00124520-00124671": "i felt the holy spirit before and i'm", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00616-00124672-00124863": "not feeling anything right now as i'm", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00617-00124864-00125047": "just throwing that there", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00618-00125048-00125127": "uh", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00619-00125128-00125390": "so you know with these prophets it's", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00620-00125391-00125527": "important to remember that they are", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00621-00125528-00125671": "subject to the bible and everything that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00622-00125672-00125775": "they say", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00623-00125776-00125943": "has to be subject to the bible oh i have", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00624-00125944-00126166": "this this special revelation god has", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00625-00126167-00126351": "this this special assignment for you", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00626-00126352-00126631": "that's found nowhere in scripture", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00627-00126632-00126758": "okay", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00628-00126759-00127095": "dear friends do not believe every spirit", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00629-00127096-00127286": "don't believe everything that you hear", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00630-00127288-00127431": "that you see just don't don't believe it", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00631-00127432-00127678": "all but test the spirits to see if they", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00632-00127679-00127839": "are from god", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00633-00127840-00128039": "even if somebody comes into our church", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00634-00128040-00128199": "and gives a message don't just believe", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00635-00128200-00128478": "it listen and weigh it", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00636-00128479-00128702": "don't just believe every spirit because", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00637-00128703-00128886": "many false prophets have gone out into", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00638-00128888-00129063": "the world this is how you know the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00639-00129064-00129286": "spirit of god so he's going to tell us", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00640-00129288-00129447": "how we can distinguish the false from", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00641-00129448-00129647": "the truth the first thing every spirit", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00642-00129648-00129807": "that confesses that jesus christ has", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00643-00129808-00130007": "come in the flesh is from god", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00644-00130008-00130254": "that's the first thing", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00645-00130255-00130558": "we are from god anyone who knows god", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00646-00130559-00130751": "that's the second thing listens to us", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00647-00130752-00130958": "that's the third and fourth thing anyone", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00648-00130959-00131102": "who is not from god does not listen to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00649-00131103-00131254": "us this is how we know the spirit of", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00650-00131255-00131559": "truth and the spirit of deception so now", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00651-00131560-00131719": "let me kind of break these down in case", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00652-00131720-00131854": "you didn't get what he was saying so the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00653-00131855-00131966": "first thing", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00654-00131967-00132311": "uh a spirit who accepts and proclaims", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00655-00132312-00132495": "jesus and his nature", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00656-00132496-00132671": "see to confess that jesus has come in", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00657-00132672-00132902": "the flesh is not to just to say oh in", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00658-00132903-00133071": "the name of jesus at the end of some", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00659-00133072-00133471": "wackadoo prophecy it's not to say", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00660-00133472-00133743": "um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00661-00133744-00133871": "let's see that what's another one that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00662-00133872-00134087": "they do they'll say some crazy thing and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00663-00134088-00134343": "then they'll say jesus so and and thus", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00664-00134344-00134502": "says the lord and stuff and it's like", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00665-00134503-00134671": "well that doesn't mean anything or", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00666-00134672-00134799": "they'll just", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00667-00134800-00134935": "like as a tag", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00668-00134936-00135183": "jesus is god and it's like well that's", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00669-00135184-00135351": "not really what he's talking about he's", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00670-00135352-00135678": "not saying uttering the words jesus is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00671-00135679-00135759": "god", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00672-00135760-00135951": "that's not what he's saying confesses", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00673-00135952-00136127": "that jesus christ has come in the flesh", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00674-00136128-00136607": "this is first off accepting jesus", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00675-00136608-00136807": "that he is who he said he is it's", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00676-00136808-00137039": "proclaiming jesus", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00677-00137040-00137295": "or the word of jesus and what not", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00678-00137296-00137575": "and lastly it's proclaiming his nature", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00679-00137576-00137775": "it doesn't say confesses that jesus is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00680-00137776-00137975": "christ it says confesses that jesus", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00681-00137976-00138311": "christ has come in the flesh so it's an", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00682-00138312-00138535": "acceptance and a proclamation of jesus", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00683-00138536-00138775": "and his nature that's the first thing", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00684-00138776-00138919": "there's a lot of times where people will", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00685-00138920-00139143": "give these prophecies and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00686-00139144-00139287": "they don't actually believe that jesus", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00687-00139288-00139414": "is god", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00688-00139415-00139590": "could jesus have sinned and they'll say", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00689-00139591-00139766": "yes absolutely it was only by the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00690-00139767-00139966": "empowerment of the holy spirit", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00691-00139967-00140199": "okay pause that means that i can be", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00692-00140200-00140366": "sinless with the empowerment of the holy", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00693-00140367-00140511": "spirit and the bible already said that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00694-00140512-00140687": "if i say that i don't have sin i'm a", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00695-00140688-00140790": "liar", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00696-00140791-00140975": "so that means it is impossible for me to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00697-00140976-00141175": "live on this earth without sin which", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00698-00141176-00141407": "means also that the holy spirit doesn't", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00699-00141408-00141559": "do that which means that it couldn't", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00700-00141560-00141959": "have possibly been effort for jesus", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00701-00141960-00142175": "and the bible clearly says that god", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00702-00142176-00142326": "cannot sin", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00703-00142327-00142678": "so if jesus is god he cannot sin", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00704-00142679-00142854": "end of discussion", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00705-00142855-00142951": "so there's a lot of these people who", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00706-00142952-00143078": "give these prophecies and they get real", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00707-00143079-00143239": "into mystical in the holy spirit oh i", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00708-00143240-00143447": "feel this and i feel this but then at", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00709-00143448-00143639": "the end of the day they're proclaiming a", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00710-00143640-00143871": "false jesus and saying false things", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00711-00143872-00144214": "about jesus benny hen did this", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00712-00144215-00144431": "and i forget the name of the book that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00713-00144432-00144583": "specifically he said this in but he", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00714-00144584-00144871": "actually wrote this before the edit", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00715-00144872-00145111": "jesus could not have done to have done", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00716-00145112-00145263": "what he did without the holy spirit the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00717-00145264-00145511": "editors made him reword it to this", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00718-00145512-00145711": "he probably couldn't have done it", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00719-00145712-00145935": "without the holy spirit", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00720-00145936-00146071": "i don't know why they made them make", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00721-00146072-00146271": "that small event you know it's whatever", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00722-00146272-00146471": "um so then the next thing", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00723-00146472-00146695": "we are from god anyone who knows god", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00724-00146696-00146854": "that's the second thing", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00725-00146855-00146983": "knows god we're talking about a", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00726-00146984-00147287": "relationship with god not simply saying", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00727-00147288-00147439": "a clever prayer", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00728-00147440-00147678": "doing doing a good good part didn't", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00729-00147679-00147839": "jesus himself say that many are going to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00730-00147840-00148039": "say hey lord lord but i'm going to say", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00731-00148040-00148223": "depart from me i never knew you", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00732-00148224-00148463": "he said that himself so we know that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00733-00148464-00148631": "when he says knows god he's not talking", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00734-00148632-00148814": "about knowing about god oh i know a", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00735-00148815-00148959": "bunch of interesting facts about the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00736-00148960-00149054": "bible", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00737-00149055-00149166": "good for you", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00738-00149167-00149463": "oh i know uh you know i know uh all", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00739-00149464-00149614": "these different names of god and all", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00740-00149615-00149759": "these different prayers and these words", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00741-00149760-00149966": "of power and these different things and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00742-00149967-00150087": "i know all the right things to bring", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00743-00150088-00150239": "about a healing and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00744-00150240-00150535": "good for you it said knows god not knows", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00745-00150536-00150726": "how to put on a show not knows how to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00746-00150727-00150887": "make things look a certain way none of", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00747-00150888-00151087": "that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00748-00151088-00151271": "it doesn't it also doesn't say anyone", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00749-00151272-00151526": "who performs a miracle or actually says", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00750-00151527-00151735": "a word of prophecy that's true it says", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00751-00151736-00152023": "who knows god so then that brings us to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00752-00152024-00152326": "the third things the third thing listens", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00753-00152327-00152543": "to us now this is a two-fold point the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00754-00152544-00152663": "first thing", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00755-00152664-00152966": "is it's an acceptance of the apostles", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00756-00152967-00153159": "the leaders of the church the ones who", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00757-00153160-00153343": "established the church it's an", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00758-00153344-00153511": "acceptance of them john was one of the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00759-00153512-00153711": "twelve", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00760-00153712-00153895": "and it's an agreement with them it's an", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00761-00153896-00154102": "agreement with the ones who went before", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00762-00154103-00154343": "so if a modern-day apostle or prophet", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00763-00154344-00154551": "says something that is not", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00764-00154552-00154759": "is not listening to them is not an", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00765-00154760-00154926": "agreement with them", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00766-00154927-00155231": "then they are a false spirit test the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00767-00155232-00155390": "spirit is this", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00768-00155391-00155654": "from someone who is proclaiming jesus", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00769-00155655-00155863": "and his nature that's the first thing is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00770-00155864-00156271": "this from someone who knows god", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00771-00156272-00156471": "is this from someone who is in agreement", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00772-00156472-00156726": "with what the apostles taught", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00773-00156727-00156887": "three things right there the fourth", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00774-00156888-00157247": "thing the last thing very important", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00775-00157248-00157511": "by agreeing with the apostles you are by", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00776-00157512-00157711": "necessity agreeing with the bible", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00777-00157712-00158054": "because the apostles stood on the bible", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00778-00158055-00158366": "they pointed to the bible they and jesus", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00779-00158367-00158543": "talked about the way that it was not", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00780-00158544-00158839": "even a word can pass away from this", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00781-00158840-00159126": "so by necessity to listen to the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00782-00159127-00159390": "apostles is to listen to the bible", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00783-00159391-00159599": "so prophets are and apostles are", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00784-00159600-00159887": "therefore subject to the bible", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00785-00159888-00160263": "could peter himself one of the apostles", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00786-00160264-00160439": "could he have proclaimed something", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00787-00160440-00160654": "contrary to what scripture said", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00788-00160655-00160743": "no", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00789-00160744-00160990": "he did not have the authority", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00790-00160991-00161247": "he only had the authority so much", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00791-00161248-00161463": "as he agreed with what christ", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00792-00161464-00161583": "established", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00793-00161584-00161831": "the instant that he if he tried to he", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00794-00161832-00162014": "didn't but if he had tried to establish", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00795-00162015-00162119": "something", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00796-00162120-00162311": "aside he would not have had the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00797-00162312-00162519": "authority he only had the authority so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00798-00162520-00162663": "long as he was submitted to his", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00799-00162664-00162911": "authority that's how authority works", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00800-00162912-00163007": "everybody thinks that they have", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00801-00163008-00163166": "authority but you only have authority so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00802-00163167-00163519": "much as it is borrowed right so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00803-00163520-00163726": "prophets themselves are subject if you", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00804-00163727-00163919": "read first corinthians 12 10 to another", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00805-00163920-00164071": "the performing of miracles to another", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00806-00164072-00164343": "prophecy to another distinguishing", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00807-00164344-00164638": "between spirits which means that the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00808-00164639-00164966": "prophet is not above reproach it is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00809-00164967-00165190": "necessary to distinguish which means it", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00810-00165191-00165519": "can have fault just because somebody", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00811-00165520-00165638": "says that they're a prophet doesn't mean", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00812-00165639-00165743": "that they are", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00813-00165744-00165943": "so then obviously like bethel and others", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00814-00165944-00166126": "will bethel church and others will say", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00815-00166127-00166263": "it's not the father the son of the holy", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00816-00166264-00166407": "spirit yes but", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00817-00166408-00166599": "what is the standard of truth if not", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00818-00166600-00166871": "god's revelation of himself how do we", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00819-00166872-00166983": "know", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00820-00166984-00167247": "as a christian what we should believe", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00821-00167248-00167526": "if god's revelation of himself is not", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00822-00167527-00167775": "the standard of truth", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00823-00167776-00167975": "what is then", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00824-00167976-00168135": "so people like bethel church they'll say", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00825-00168136-00168278": "well it's not the father center holy", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00826-00168279-00168519": "holy bible so then they'll teach strange", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00827-00168520-00168807": "doctrine not based on the bible", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00828-00168808-00169014": "and why should i believe you", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00829-00169015-00169166": "johnson bill johnson why should i", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00830-00169167-00169359": "believe you", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00831-00169360-00169535": "what what gives you the authority over", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00832-00169536-00169687": "if i'm not gonna listen to the bible why", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00833-00169688-00169999": "in the heck do i listen to you", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00834-00170000-00170238": "because of emotions maybe because", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00835-00170239-00170438": "he says in a way that i like", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00836-00170439-00170623": "no", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00837-00170624-00170863": "second timothy 3 16 says this all", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00838-00170864-00171151": "scripture all of the bible is inspired", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00839-00171152-00171359": "by god and is profitable for teaching", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00840-00171360-00171543": "for rebuking for correcting for training", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00841-00171544-00171807": "in righteousness", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00842-00171808-00171966": "and then jesus himself said that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00843-00171967-00172351": "scripture cannot be broken", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00844-00172352-00172559": "that's a very important lesson because", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00845-00172560-00172814": "modern-day apostles and prophets always", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00846-00172815-00173007": "degrade the place of the bible they make", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00847-00173008-00173319": "jesus like us and then exalt themselves", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00848-00173320-00173519": "because of self-realization and what i", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00849-00173520-00173726": "can do and look at look at what what i", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00850-00173727-00173926": "can do it's like oh yeah by the way we", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00851-00173927-00174175": "need the holy spirit to establish us as", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00852-00174176-00174319": "christ and it's like", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00853-00174320-00174478": "what", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00854-00174479-00174663": "what and we already looked at that last", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00855-00174664-00174887": "week with the whole little gods so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00856-00174888-00175159": "here's the thing", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00857-00175160-00175431": "if somebody proclaims a special mystical", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00858-00175432-00175671": "hidden meaning in the bible", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00859-00175672-00175902": "it does not trump the clear meaning of", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00860-00175903-00176063": "what scripture says", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00861-00176064-00176247": "those theories are great", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00862-00176248-00176502": "conspiracy theories are fine about trump", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00863-00176503-00176631": "being in prophecy and all these", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00864-00176632-00176751": "different things", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00865-00176752-00176926": "uh you know or you know all these", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00866-00176927-00177078": "different things about how the bible is", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00867-00177079-00177231": "actually when it says to go to the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00868-00177232-00177407": "nations it's actually talking about how", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00869-00177408-00177599": "we need to establish you know a", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00870-00177600-00177823": "christian nation among all the whatever", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00871-00177824-00178031": "nonsense those are called mystical", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00872-00178032-00178175": "hidden teachings", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00873-00178176-00178390": "any mystical hidden teaching cannot", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00874-00178391-00178599": "trump what the what scripture clearly", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00875-00178600-00178783": "says when jesus says to go to all", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00876-00178784-00179047": "nations he clearly and obviously means", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00877-00179048-00179390": "to go to all peoples especially in light", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00878-00179391-00179583": "of the fact that the word translated as", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00879-00179584-00179695": "nations", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00880-00179696-00179831": "is the same", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00881-00179832-00180278": "as uh as um oh jeez i it's my mind just", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00882-00180279-00180463": "went blank i believe it's um in the", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00883-00180464-00180607": "greek i believe it's called i believe", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00884-00180608-00180683": "it's", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00885-00180684-00181135": "ethnos nations people groups um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00886-00181136-00181295": "races", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00887-00181296-00181583": "uh", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00888-00181584-00181678": "right there", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00889-00181679-00181911": "it's more than just the idea of a nation", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00890-00181912-00182078": "when we think of a nation nowadays we", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00891-00182079-00182247": "think of like united states it's a", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00892-00182248-00182383": "nation right", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00893-00182384-00182599": "but that's not what the greek word meant", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00894-00182600-00182831": "and meant more of a people group", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00895-00182832-00183190": "go therefore to all the people groups", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00896-00183191-00183351": "so you know", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00897-00183352-00183638": "don't don't allow somebody's oh that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00898-00183639-00183847": "that sounded so good to trump with cl", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00899-00183848-00184014": "what scripture clearly says when you're", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00900-00184015-00184183": "listening to a televangelist or reading", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00901-00184184-00184366": "a christian book and they say oh look", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00902-00184367-00184607": "with this by go to the bible in a", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00903-00184608-00184790": "translation you understand", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00904-00184791-00185159": "that's as accurate as you can understand", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00905-00185160-00185278": "and", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00906-00185279-00185551": "read what it says in context everything", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00907-00185552-00185775": "around it and then say is this", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00908-00185776-00185854": "it", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00909-00185855-00186007": "is this what it", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00910-00186008-00186326": "what it appears to mean", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00911-00186327-00186535": "and then go from there", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00912-00186536-00186750": "so some good some good translations to", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00913-00186751-00186878": "start with would be", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00914-00186879-00187031": "um uh", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00915-00187032-00187159": "nasb", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00916-00187160-00187295": "esv", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00917-00187296-00187423": "niv", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00918-00187424-00187663": "nlt nkjv", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00919-00187664-00187902": "try one of those five first if you can't", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00920-00187903-00188238": "understand any of those five", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00921-00188239-00188438": "it's going to be hard", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00922-00188439-00188590": "to get", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00923-00188591-00188814": "a reliable translation", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00924-00188815-00188926": "um", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00925-00188927-00189175": "those are really which", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00926-00189176-00189359": "um the one the five specifically i", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00927-00189360-00189863": "mentioned to start with nasb esv niv nlt", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00928-00189864-00190150": "nkjv start with those five see if you", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00929-00190151-00190319": "understand it if you don't", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00930-00190320-00190487": "it's gonna be really hard", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00931-00190488-00190799": "to get close", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00932-00190800-00190926": "you could learn greek but that's going", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00933-00190927-00191335": "to take you a couple years", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00934-00191336-00191535": "you could ask for help i guess so any", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00935-00191536-00191823": "questions on any of that", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00936-00191824-00191902": "i", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00937-00191903-00192119": "was completely blind to the fivefold", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00938-00192120-00192287": "ministry i had no idea i didn't know", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00939-00192288-00192519": "what i believed either and uh so this", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00940-00192520-00192719": "was a very uh very interesting one for", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00941-00192720-00192823": "me and i wish that people would have", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00942-00192824-00192990": "talked about it in the in in the church", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00943-00192991-00193175": "so i'm hoping that i'm teaching it", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00944-00193176-00193471": "before you actually ever need this so", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00945-00193472-00193750": "yeah no questions", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00946-00193751-00193871": "it looks like you're about to add", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00947-00193872-00193990": "something though", "QJDTuc3mv7g-00948-00193991-00194403": "comments no okay all right"}}, {"audio_id": "QJLvxAIENjM", "text": {"QJLvxAIENjM-00000-00000008-00000454": "allah", "QJLvxAIENjM-00001-00000455-00001498": "[Music]", "QJLvxAIENjM-00002-00001499-00002926": "[Music]", "QJLvxAIENjM-00003-00002927-00003543": "respected brothers and sisters", "QJLvxAIENjM-00004-00003544-00003783": "here is an opportunity to fix", "QJLvxAIENjM-00005-00003784-00004070": "how we think of our children", "QJLvxAIENjM-00006-00004071-00004311": "when we get them up and prepare them to", "QJLvxAIENjM-00007-00004312-00004567": "send for rigorous training", "QJLvxAIENjM-00008-00004568-00004831": "for duke of edinburgh award or school", "QJLvxAIENjM-00009-00004832-00004967": "scouts", "QJLvxAIENjM-00010-00004968-00005279": "we as parents take great pride fair", "QJLvxAIENjM-00011-00005280-00005406": "enough", "QJLvxAIENjM-00012-00005407-00005551": "however", "QJLvxAIENjM-00013-00005552-00005806": "when it comes to prayers and educating", "QJLvxAIENjM-00014-00005807-00005975": "our children to start their regular", "QJLvxAIENjM-00015-00005976-00006199": "prayers from the age of 11", "QJLvxAIENjM-00016-00006200-00006542": "we don't even feel what they miss out", "QJLvxAIENjM-00017-00006543-00006798": "we understand how anything routine will", "QJLvxAIENjM-00018-00006800-00007046": "make children greatly disciplined", "QJLvxAIENjM-00019-00007047-00007223": "but we have miserably failed to show", "QJLvxAIENjM-00020-00007223-00007439": "them the value of prayers and the", "QJLvxAIENjM-00021-00007440-00007639": "routines", "QJLvxAIENjM-00022-00007640-00007774": "time and again", "QJLvxAIENjM-00023-00007775-00008023": "we have felt in our personal lives", "QJLvxAIENjM-00024-00008023-00008278": "how almighty is help made", "QJLvxAIENjM-00025-00008279-00008535": "as the real human beings we are today", "QJLvxAIENjM-00026-00008536-00008791": "but we have not passed down this lineage", "QJLvxAIENjM-00027-00008792-00009142": "to our most beloved children", "QJLvxAIENjM-00028-00009143-00009431": "proudly presents fajr nights", "QJLvxAIENjM-00029-00009432-00009727": "inviting our future leaders to pray fajr", "QJLvxAIENjM-00030-00009728-00010046": "salah with jamaat in our masjid during", "QJLvxAIENjM-00031-00010047-00010271": "this december school term holidays that", "QJLvxAIENjM-00032-00010272-00010631": "is 18th of december to 2nd of january", "QJLvxAIENjM-00033-00010632-00010878": "it culminates with a prize giveaway a", "QJLvxAIENjM-00034-00010879-00011110": "way to encourage them beyond the holiday", "QJLvxAIENjM-00035-00011111-00011206": "period", "QJLvxAIENjM-00036-00011207-00011495": "this is from the masjid pod as parents", "QJLvxAIENjM-00037-00011496-00011727": "can we play the parent part and ensure", "QJLvxAIENjM-00038-00011728-00011983": "the masjid is full for fajr salah during", "QJLvxAIENjM-00039-00011984-00012095": "this month", "QJLvxAIENjM-00040-00012096-00012374": "please check al-hidayah croydon.org for", "QJLvxAIENjM-00041-00012375-00012638": "full details zhaokumullaharan assalamu", "QJLvxAIENjM-00042-00012639-00012919": "alaikum"}}, {"audio_id": "QJTkSurlv_E", "text": {"QJTkSurlv_E-00000-00001488-00001561": "slay", "QJTkSurlv_E-00001-00001562-00002647": "[Music]", "QJTkSurlv_E-00002-00002648-00002792": "slay", "QJTkSurlv_E-00003-00002793-00006291": "[Music]", "QJTkSurlv_E-00004-00006292-00007265": "[Music]", "QJTkSurlv_E-00005-00007266-00012815": "[Music]", "QJTkSurlv_E-00006-00012816-00013288": "is", "QJTkSurlv_E-00007-00013288-00013319": "[Music]", "QJTkSurlv_E-00008-00013321-00013718": "[Applause]", "QJTkSurlv_E-00009-00013719-00019071": "[Music]", "QJTkSurlv_E-00010-00019072-00019302": "is", "QJTkSurlv_E-00011-00019303-00019935": "[Music]", "QJTkSurlv_E-00012-00019936-00020144": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "QKkeXw5KYOu", "text": {"QKkeXw5KYOu-00000-00000002-00000248": "hi Dave Jack here super incented a", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00001-00000249-00000380": "funkier County Public Schools with", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00002-00000381-00000797": "another addition checking in perhaps my", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00003-00000798-00001028": "favorite checking in thus far this is a", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00004-00001029-00001204": "question that came to me after the", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00005-00001205-00001623": "elementary school choir choral festival", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00006-00001625-00002059": "last week and the question was about", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00007-00002060-00002312": "several of students groups singing", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00008-00002313-00002592": "groups saying saying religious songs", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00009-00002593-00003116": "religious Christmas songs and and there", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00010-00003117-00003379": "was even a couple of Jewish songs", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00011-00003380-00003533": "religious songs saying", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00012-00003534-00003790": "related to the holidays Christmas and", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00013-00003792-00004004": "Hanukkah and so the question came up", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00014-00004004-00004336": "after the event about was that were they", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00015-00004337-00004463": "allowed to do that and the answer is yes", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00016-00004464-00005093": "their schools school choirs etcetera", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00017-00005094-00005384": "bands they're not forbidden from playing", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00018-00005385-00005663": "songs about Christmas and they're not", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00019-00005664-00005840": "forbidden from flying songs about", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00020-00005841-00006395": "Hanukkah or Kwanzaa that they're not", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00021-00006396-00006573": "that's a misconception out there about", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00022-00006575-00006812": "what is and isn't allowed in schools but", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00023-00006813-00007123": "it goes even further and Christmas trees", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00024-00007125-00007352": "they are allowed in schools you might", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00025-00007353-00007580": "get some pushback from the local fire", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00026-00007581-00007739": "marshal about the kind of lights you use", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00027-00007740-00007973": "but Christmas trees are allowed in our", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00028-00007973-00008287": "plan our public schools students and and", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00029-00008288-00008573": "teachers using the expression Merry", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00030-00008574-00008858": "Christmas that is also allowed in our", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00031-00008859-00009077": "schools that's not that's not forbidden", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00032-00009078-00009545": "speech and to go even further you know", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00033-00009546-00009892": "student prayer in schools is protected", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00034-00009893-00010283": "as long as it doesn't erupt disrupt the", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00035-00010284-00010492": "school environment or if there's no", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00036-00010493-00010963": "proselytize ation taking place it is it", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00037-00010964-00011239": "is a loud speech so there's a lot of", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00038-00011240-00011360": "misconceptions out there and they", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00039-00011361-00011560": "usually pop up around Christmas time but", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00040-00011561-00011909": "Merry Christmas happy Kwanzaa happy", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00041-00011910-00012037": "Chanukah those are those are all", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00042-00012038-00012281": "protected expressions between teachers", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00043-00012282-00012470": "and teachers and teachers teaching", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00044-00012471-00012835": "students students to students religious", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00045-00012836-00013313": "Christmas oriented songs relative to the", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00046-00013313-00013344": "Kris", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00047-00013346-00013666": "religion Jewish religion they are those", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00048-00013666-00013913": "are protected Christmas trees protected", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00049-00013915-00014313": "so but this you know this issue goes way", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00050-00014315-00014485": "back to when I was a principal and and", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00051-00014486-00014719": "that people you know they they just have", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00052-00014719-00015019": "a misconception about what is it was is", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00053-00015019-00015196": "and isn't allowed public schools and", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00054-00015197-00015513": "those those pieces are allowed so that", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00055-00015515-00015862": "being said Merry Christmas Happy", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00056-00015863-00016099": "Hanukkah happy Kwanzaa happy holidays to", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00057-00016100-00016297": "everyone and hopefully we'll see you", "QKkeXw5KYOu-00058-00016297-00016717": "back in checking in next week"}}, {"audio_id": "QKtVh1DSQt0", "text": {"QKtVh1DSQt0-00000-00000024-00000202": "I think it's a family time for member", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00001-00000204-00000653": "statements", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00002-00000654-00001181": "the member from the marketing room", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00003-00001182-00001474": "thank you speaker", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00004-00001475-00001787": "thank you speaker on October 16th I was", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00005-00001788-00002155": "pleased to hold my very first annual", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00006-00002156-00002542": "community family barbecue and corn roast", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00007-00002543-00002879": "the rain held off and it was a great", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00008-00002880-00003005": "success", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00009-00003006-00003503": "as a new MPP I was thrilled to host more", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00010-00003504-00003935": "than 500 of my constituents outside at", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00011-00003936-00004181": "the Riverwalk Commons in downtown New", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00012-00004182-00004295": "Market", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00013-00004296-00004565": "there was live entertainment by the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00014-00004566-00004847": "great George Saint Kitts delicious food", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00015-00004848-00005188": "face painting for the kitties a photo", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00016-00005189-00005513": "booth for fun family pictures and some", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00017-00005514-00005843": "great giveaways I must thank my dear", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00018-00005844-00006251": "friend Teresa Cruz for managing the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00019-00006252-00006605": "entire event with her master event", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00020-00006606-00006892": "planning skills at the home the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00021-00006893-00007223": "residents of Newmarket Aurora had a fun", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00022-00007223-00007546": "time for the entire family thank you to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00023-00007547-00007746": "all the volunteers", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00024-00007747-00008110": "including my husband Ivan and my son", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00025-00008111-00008495": "Robert as well as my entire constituency", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00026-00008496-00008927": "staff along with another 15 volunteers", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00027-00008928-00009191": "who gave up four hours of their Sunday", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00028-00009192-00009485": "afternoon to help make my first", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00029-00009486-00009899": "constituency event a great success thank", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00030-00009900-00010295": "you I also would like to thank the many", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00031-00010296-00010571": "families that came out it was great to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00032-00010572-00010877": "have so many families there families who", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00033-00010878-00011099": "came up to speak to me just to thank me", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00034-00011100-00011405": "and also to have a conversation", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00035-00011406-00011656": "and I would like to thank all the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00036-00011657-00011903": "residents who brought a non-perishable", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00037-00011904-00012269": "food item to the event I'm pleased to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00038-00012270-00013361": "say that we collected 10 full boxes", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00039-00013362-00013753": "[Applause]", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00040-00013754-00014105": "[Music]", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00041-00014106-00014291": "Orleans", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00042-00014291-00014555": "thank you thank you very much Madam", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00043-00014556-00014735": "speaker I'd like to take a moment to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00044-00014736-00014938": "address the growing challenge of level", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00045-00014940-00015143": "zero sometimes code black here in", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00046-00015144-00015430": "Ontario this is the complete absence of", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00047-00015431-00015725": "ambulances available to respond to 9-1-1", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00048-00015726-00016019": "calls in 2021", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00049-00016019-00016247": "Ottawa paramedics spent more than 49 000", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00050-00016247-00016522": "hours in offload delay at area hospitals", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00051-00016523-00016877": "this resulted in 750 incidents of level", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00052-00016878-00017129": "zero now the 90th percentile Hospital", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00053-00017130-00017422": "offload delay was 97 minutes which far", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00054-00017423-00017711": "exceeds the 30 minute Benchmark this", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00055-00017712-00017872": "means that paramedics are waiting for", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00056-00017873-00018065": "over an hour and a half to transfer", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00057-00018066-00018293": "their patients to hospital two", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00058-00018294-00018521": "paramedics and an ambulance stuck at the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00059-00018522-00018658": "hospital because the hospital is too", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00060-00018659-00018905": "backlogged to take them", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00061-00018906-00019199": "in the first seven months of 2022 the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00062-00019200-00019343": "Ottawa paramedic service experienced", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00063-00019344-00019543": "more than 1", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00064-00019544-00019936": "125 instances of level zero in some", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00065-00019937-00020339": "cases Ottawa had 11 consecutive uh level", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00066-00020340-00020657": "zero hours 11 hours of consecutive level", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00067-00020658-00020908": "zero Madam speaker and and some low", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00068-00020909-00021077": "Acuity patients waiting more than seven", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00069-00021078-00021341": "hours before being transported to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00070-00021342-00021580": "hospitals level zero isn't just a", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00071-00021581-00021707": "problem in Ottawa of course it's", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00072-00021708-00021917": "happening right across the province The", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00073-00021918-00022097": "Province and municipalities pay for", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00074-00022098-00022258": "paramedics to be assisting residents", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00075-00022259-00022577": "needing urgent medical attention they do", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00076-00022578-00022858": "not pay them to wait at the hospital to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00077-00022859-00023080": "offload their patients it's imperative", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00078-00023081-00023255": "that the government provides the funding", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00079-00023256-00023417": "necessary to municipalities in", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00080-00023418-00023567": "particular the monies requested by the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00081-00023568-00023764": "city of Ottawa to hire the paramedics", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00082-00023765-00023986": "needed to end level zero events and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00083-00023987-00024155": "better serve our friends and neighbors", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00084-00024156-00024611": "thank you madam speaker", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00085-00024612-00024880": "a member from", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00086-00024881-00025067": "Ottawa center", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00087-00025068-00025186": "good morning speaker good morning", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00088-00025187-00025313": "colleagues", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00089-00025314-00025541": "the people of Ottawa and got to know are", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00090-00025542-00025727": "preparing a protest unlike anything", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00091-00025727-00025967": "you've ever seen speaker we will be", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00092-00025968-00026194": "using an iconic item you see everywhere", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00093-00026195-00026411": "in Canadian society and I'm not talking", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00094-00026412-00026645": "about hockey sticks I'm not talking", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00095-00026645-00026861": "about Donuts speaker I'm not even", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00096-00026862-00027077": "talking about duct tape I'm talking", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00097-00027077-00027299": "about electrical cords", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00098-00027300-00027520": "you heard me right speaker electrical", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00099-00027522-00027761": "cords on November 5th the people of", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00100-00027762-00027881": "Ottawa and gets you know will gather", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00101-00027882-00028168": "together with extension cords electrical", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00102-00028169-00028331": "cords the same thing that powers", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00103-00028332-00028577": "backyard barbecues Halloween decorations", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00104-00028577-00028799": "and holiday lights and why are we going", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00105-00028800-00029099": "to be doing that because speaker at a", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00106-00029100-00029279": "time when we need to double Ontario's", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00107-00029280-00029561": "electrical capacity this government has", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00108-00029562-00029723": "decided to rip up its energy agreement", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00109-00029724-00030035": "with Quebec it makes no sense", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00110-00030036-00030358": "we could continue to import Quebec power", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00111-00030360-00030587": "for five cents a kilowatt hour it's", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00112-00030588-00030701": "affordable", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00113-00030702-00030911": "and it makes sense but instead we're", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00114-00030912-00031133": "pledging to fire up gas-fired", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00115-00031133-00031289": "electricity that will cost at least", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00116-00031289-00031558": "twice as much balloon our admissions and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00117-00031560-00031696": "ruin our attempts to deal with our", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00118-00031697-00031901": "climate emergency the only people who", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00119-00031902-00032177": "win speaker are gas industry Executives", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00120-00032177-00032405": "and lobbyists so folks back home are", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00121-00032406-00032537": "going to show the government with people", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00122-00032538-00032795": "power a different way we're going to run", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00123-00032796-00033017": "extension cords from Quebec to Ontario", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00124-00033018-00033251": "for a family friendly event and I invite", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00125-00033252-00033431": "all members of this house to join me as", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00126-00033432-00033677": "we celebrate how we bring clean power to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00127-00033678-00033874": "Ontario and fight for our kids future", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00128-00033875-00034067": "stay tuned for details about the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00129-00034068-00034227": "electrical Court protest", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00130-00034228-00034829": "[Applause]", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00131-00034830-00035062": "member state", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00132-00035063-00035483": "the member from Perth Wellington", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00133-00035484-00035735": "thank you speaker earlier this fall I", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00134-00035736-00035921": "had the opportunity to attend Stratford", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00135-00035922-00036131": "Optimus police women's shelter's 40th", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00136-00036132-00036371": "anniversary celebrations Optimist Place", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00137-00036372-00036581": "provides an integral service to our", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00138-00036582-00036815": "community they offer shelter counseling", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00139-00036816-00036977": "and protection for women and children in", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00140-00036978-00037217": "abusive or precarious situations at", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00141-00037218-00037390": "their anniversary celebrations they also", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00142-00037391-00037517": "marked the official groundbreaking", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00143-00037518-00037835": "ceremony of their 7 000 square foot 18", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00144-00037836-00038117": "bed Expansion Project this Expansion", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00145-00038118-00038339": "Project will add 10 new bedrooms seven", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00146-00038340-00038602": "new washrooms three laundry rooms a new", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00147-00038603-00038824": "playground two counseling offices a", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00148-00038825-00038993": "multi-purpose meeting space and a", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00149-00038994-00039185": "kitchenette through private donors", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00150-00039186-00039401": "governments and in-kind support they've", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00151-00039402-00039635": "already raised 80 percent of their five", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00152-00039636-00039887": "million dollar capital budget Mr Speaker", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00153-00039888-00040085": "I'm pleased to announce they will they", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00154-00040086-00040289": "also received over one hundred thousand", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00155-00040290-00040462": "dollars through the Ontario trillium's", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00156-00040463-00040739": "resilient Community Fund they plan to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00157-00040740-00040889": "use this funding to support additional", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00158-00040890-00041117": "staff programming and the development of", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00159-00041118-00041327": "an Optimum social Enterprise initiative", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00160-00041328-00041561": "this physical expansion in the new", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00161-00041562-00041771": "social Enterprise initiative will allow", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00162-00041772-00041962": "Optimist place to help more women and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00163-00041963-00042101": "children in our communities", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00164-00042102-00042377": "congratulations again to Jasmine and the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00165-00042378-00042539": "entire team thank you for everything you", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00166-00042540-00042707": "do in our community", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00167-00042708-00043501": "[Applause]", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00168-00043502-00043733": "member statements the member for London", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00169-00043734-00043985": "West thank you very much speaker speaker", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00170-00043986-00044261": "I'm wearing purple today to show my", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00171-00044262-00044471": "support for the education workers the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00172-00044472-00044711": "education assistants custodians Early", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00173-00044712-00044957": "Childhood Educators school secretaries", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00174-00044958-00045179": "and other schools support staff who", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00175-00045180-00045412": "provide vital supports to students yet", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00176-00045413-00045599": "are the lowest paid workers in the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00177-00045600-00045845": "school system parents in London West and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00178-00045846-00046030": "across the province know the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00179-00046031-00046229": "contributions of these workers to the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00180-00046230-00046468": "success and safety of their children and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00181-00046469-00046685": "they want to see them fairly compensated", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00182-00046686-00046930": "they also want more supports for", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00183-00046931-00047171": "struggling students in schools instead", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00184-00047172-00047362": "of direct payments to parents for an", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00185-00047363-00047590": "hour of or two of tutoring which won't", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00186-00047591-00047789": "do anything to help students catch up", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00187-00047790-00048017": "and requires parents to try to track", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00188-00048018-00048305": "down a tutor CBC London shared some", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00189-00048306-00048593": "comments from parents one said you can't", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00190-00048594-00048808": "have a government at the table saying we", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00191-00048809-00049007": "have no money to give education workers", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00192-00049008-00049246": "then provide all these random payments", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00193-00049247-00049367": "to parents", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00194-00049368-00049595": "another asked wouldn't it just be a", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00195-00049596-00049835": "better decision to take that money and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00196-00049836-00050086": "hire EA's that way the so-called", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00197-00050087-00050333": "catch-up plan could be a plan that helps", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00198-00050334-00050524": "teachers support our students and not", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00199-00050525-00050801": "put the burden back on parents a third", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00200-00050802-00051040": "said this feels a little more like a", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00201-00051041-00051358": "bribe to parents and I'd rather have", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00202-00051359-00051557": "that money go back into the education", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00203-00051558-00051682": "system", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00204-00051683-00052108": "speaker instead of a 365 million dollar", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00205-00052109-00052342": "catch-up program why won't this", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00206-00052344-00052571": "government invest in the supports that", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00207-00052572-00052811": "would really help kids catch up the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00208-00052812-00053080": "education workers who support students", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00209-00053082-00053178": "in our schools", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00210-00053179-00053766": "[Applause]", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00211-00053767-00054047": "a member for Kitchener Conestoga well", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00212-00054048-00054275": "thank you very much Mr Speaker and uh", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00213-00054276-00054425": "it's great to be back here in the house", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00214-00054426-00054629": "after a busy and productive month", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00215-00054629-00054826": "working in our ridings and it was uh", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00216-00054827-00055019": "nice to get out to some fall fairs that", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00217-00055020-00055235": "took place especially my favorite", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00218-00055236-00055535": "Oktoberfest Mr Speaker which is one uh", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00219-00055536-00055721": "big day for Waterloo Region and of", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00220-00055722-00055913": "course my riding of Kitchener Conestoga", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00221-00055914-00056176": "and speaking of promoting local events", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00222-00056177-00056344": "we've just celebrated Small Business", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00223-00056345-00056561": "Week here in the province where I had an", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00224-00056562-00056723": "opportunity to highlight just a few of", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00225-00056724-00056891": "the countless local businesses in my", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00226-00056891-00057191": "community over 400 000 small businesses", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00227-00057191-00057454": "are the backbone of communities across", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00228-00057455-00057623": "this province fueling the economy and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00229-00057624-00057865": "employing more than 2 million people", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00230-00057866-00058163": "businesses like Morty's Pub Mr Speaker a", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00231-00058164-00058300": "must-off for wings if you're in the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00232-00058301-00058523": "region and the Maryhill market for", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00233-00058524-00058732": "Kawartha Dairy ice cream and homemade", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00234-00058733-00059009": "sandwiches as well as a famous St Jacobs", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00235-00059010-00059087": "Market", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00236-00059088-00059363": "that is host to a ton of local Crafters", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00237-00059364-00059650": "Artisans farmers and More Mr Speaker so", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00238-00059651-00059837": "with the holiday season just around the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00239-00059838-00060059": "corner I want to encourage everyone to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00240-00060060-00060244": "support local businesses it is a great", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00241-00060245-00060430": "way to get unique gifts and products for", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00242-00060432-00060653": "yourselves and loved ones not just at", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00243-00060654-00060826": "Christmas but year round thank you very", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00244-00060827-00061541": "much Mr Speaker", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00245-00061541-00061763": "member for Hamilton West and Castor", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00246-00061764-00062021": "Dundas thanks speaker there's a", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00247-00062022-00062141": "frightening crisis in children's", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00248-00062141-00062399": "hospitals across Ontario children are", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00249-00062400-00062626": "waiting days in emergency rooms facing", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00250-00062627-00062885": "facing canceled procedures and for what", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00251-00062886-00063161": "must be every parent's nightmare they", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00252-00063162-00063341": "are being sent across the province to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00253-00063341-00063616": "find care beds Bruce Squires who's the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00254-00063617-00063742": "president of mcmaster's Children", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00255-00063744-00064007": "Hospital is sounding the alarm our", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00256-00064008-00064235": "pediatric Critical Care capacity is so", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00257-00064236-00064499": "limited that critically ill children are", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00258-00064500-00064654": "having to be transferred outside of", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00259-00064655-00064859": "their local area to be admitted to an", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00260-00064860-00065147": "ICU this is a situation that he calls", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00261-00065148-00065459": "extremely concerning critically ill", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00262-00065460-00065650": "children from Hamilton have been sent as", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00263-00065651-00065938": "far away as Ottawa to find a bed in a", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00264-00065939-00066197": "pediatric unit as of Thursday there were", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00265-00066198-00066394": "11 patients in the ER who had been", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00266-00066395-00066593": "admitted to hospital but were still", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00267-00066594-00066863": "waiting for a bed some for 30 hours or", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00268-00066864-00067091": "more gray who's up four-year-old boy", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00269-00067092-00067343": "from Ancaster waited five days for", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00270-00067344-00067685": "emergency elbow surgery now his mom is", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00271-00067686-00067931": "warning other parents that the system is", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00272-00067932-00068159": "a disaster and people need to know what", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00273-00068160-00068369": "to expect it should be our highest", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00274-00068370-00068597": "priority to care for sick injured or", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00275-00068598-00068825": "dying children but instead hospitals are", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00276-00068826-00068981": "being slowly starved by this", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00277-00068982-00069185": "government's disastrous plan to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00278-00069186-00069431": "privatize health care we need more", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00279-00069432-00069575": "investments in our struggling Health", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00280-00069576-00069809": "Care system not a profits over people", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00281-00069810-00070103": "approach we have the solutions we need", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00282-00070104-00070300": "to implement them now to make things", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00283-00070301-00070594": "better for children across Ontario thank", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00284-00070595-00070979": "you", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00285-00070980-00071111": "foreign", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00286-00071112-00071843": "the member for Eglinton Lawrence", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00287-00071844-00072035": "of students within my riding and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00288-00072036-00072263": "Eglinton of Eglinton Lawrence and around", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00289-00072264-00072550": "Ontario and across Canada Pathways to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00290-00072551-00072809": "education I fully support Pathways", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00291-00072810-00073061": "mission to help high school students who", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00292-00073062-00073229": "face barriers to reach their full", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00293-00073230-00073463": "potential through education Pathways", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00294-00073464-00073619": "focuses on supporting students from", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00295-00073620-00073787": "low-income households who might", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00296-00073788-00074015": "otherwise struggle to finish secondary", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00297-00074016-00074249": "school or even drop out Pathways", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00298-00074250-00074494": "provides lots of practical support even", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00299-00074495-00074776": "bus tickets for participants to get to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00300-00074777-00075041": "school essentially it provides them with", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00301-00075042-00075256": "what they need to finish their education", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00302-00075257-00075394": "so that they can have all the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00303-00075395-00075623": "possibilities that that opens a few", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00304-00075624-00075869": "weeks ago Owen heinzy and the rest of", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00305-00075870-00076079": "the pathways team at Lawrence Heights", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00306-00076080-00076355": "invited me to Once Again Tour their", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00307-00076356-00076661": "pathway facilities in my riding I", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00308-00076662-00076853": "enjoyed meeting the students who were", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00309-00076854-00076985": "busy working on their homework", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00310-00076986-00077321": "assignments supported by peers and by", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00311-00077322-00077681": "other mentors volunteer mentors Pathways", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00312-00077682-00077981": "boasts over 8 100 volunteers who should", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00313-00077982-00078232": "be commended for their over twenty six", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00314-00078233-00078503": "thousand volunteer hours with over", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00315-00078504-00078653": "nineteen thousand students having", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00316-00078654-00078923": "benefited from Pathways since 2001 and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00317-00078924-00079156": "over six thousand currently in the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00318-00079157-00079450": "program 78 percent graduate from school", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00319-00079451-00079817": "and uh 69 go on to post-secondary", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00320-00079818-00080056": "education it's a true success story", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00321-00080057-00080291": "along with the minister of colleges and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00322-00080292-00080476": "universities I attended their grad ball", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00323-00080477-00080711": "recently as well to celebrate with them", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00324-00080712-00080909": "and continue to support all of their", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00325-00080910-00081071": "efforts", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00326-00081072-00081388": "thank you", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00327-00081389-00081544": "I didn't want to interrupt the member", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00328-00081545-00081767": "for Eglinton Lawrence but the volume of", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00329-00081768-00081976": "the private conversations collectively", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00330-00081977-00082205": "is at a level where it must be difficult", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00331-00082206-00082438": "for members to concentrate on their", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00332-00082439-00082576": "presentation so it asks members to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00333-00082577-00082888": "please quieten down", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00334-00082889-00083021": "next member statement the member for", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00335-00083022-00083279": "Thornhill", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00336-00083280-00083500": "thank you", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00337-00083501-00083735": "thank you Mr Speaker last month I had", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00338-00083736-00083932": "the honor of being part of the 25th", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00339-00083933-00084131": "anniversary ride for Kayla's in support", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00340-00084132-00084406": "of Kayla's Children's Center Kayla's or", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00341-00084407-00084731": "KCC has deep roots in Thornhill known as", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00342-00084732-00084923": "a place where children of all abilities", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00343-00084924-00085175": "can shine Kayla's mission is to deliver", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00344-00085176-00085462": "Innovative educational therapeutic and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00345-00085463-00085661": "recreational programs for children and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00346-00085662-00085876": "youth with disabilities and complex", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00347-00085877-00086105": "medical needs this year's bike ride", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00348-00086106-00086375": "involved over 200 cyclists who came out", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00349-00086376-00086615": "to Sugar support for KCC specialized", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00350-00086616-00086855": "programs programs that enable children", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00351-00086856-00087059": "to flourish academically socially", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00352-00087060-00087371": "emotionally including a licensed daycare", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00353-00087372-00087565": "and school on-site Therapy Center", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00354-00087566-00087893": "adaptive Sports and life skill programs", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00355-00087894-00088259": "for teens KCC offers supports and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00356-00088260-00088468": "respite for parents siblings and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00357-00088469-00088685": "grandparents giving them the much needed", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00358-00088686-00088894": "time to run errands or spend time with", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00359-00088895-00089068": "their other children one of the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00360-00089069-00089255": "organization's most recent and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00361-00089256-00089459": "substantial accomplishments was the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00362-00089460-00089747": "state of the your hydrotherapy Center in", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00363-00089748-00089968": "the warm Waters children with mobility", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00364-00089969-00090299": "issues can be independent flexible and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00365-00090300-00090425": "free", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00366-00090426-00090647": "one of the long-standing supporters of", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00367-00090648-00090850": "the ride for Kayla is Hershey Weinberg", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00368-00090851-00091115": "who rides under the team name of zadie", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00369-00091116-00091385": "Hershey Hershey's dedication and support", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00370-00091386-00091582": "along with so many other organizers", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00371-00091583-00091817": "including the staff and instructors have", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00372-00091818-00092062": "helped build KCC as a state-of-the-art", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00373-00092063-00092356": "facility and by the way Mr Speaker zadie", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00374-00092357-00092609": "is the Yiddish word for grandfather I", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00375-00092610-00092843": "want to thank KCC staff for their", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00376-00092844-00093053": "dedication to the success of every child", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00377-00093054-00093317": "providing childhood experiences that", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00378-00093318-00093581": "otherwise would not exist in Thornhill", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00379-00093582-00093767": "Mr Speaker we support our", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00380-00093768-00094000": "not-for-profits because they support us", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00381-00094001-00094199": "and I'm truly looking forward to next", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00382-00094200-00094444": "year's ride thank you very much", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00383-00094445-00094679": "thank you", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00384-00094680-00094925": "so once again I'm going to ask members", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00385-00094926-00095111": "to please keep the volume of their", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00386-00095112-00095326": "private conversations lower", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00387-00095327-00095500": "I can barely hear the member who has the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00388-00095501-00096418": "floor", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00389-00096419-00096581": "thank you", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00390-00096582-00096767": "member statements the member for Carlton", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00391-00096768-00097121": "thank you Mr Speaker", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00392-00097122-00097411": "Mr Speaker 40 days ago on September 16", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00393-00097412-00097871": "2022 a young 2022 year old Iranian", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00394-00097872-00098182": "Kurdish woman massagina amini was", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00395-00098183-00098381": "brutally murdered by the morality police", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00396-00098382-00098573": "of the terrorist and illegitimate", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00397-00098574-00098897": "Islamic regime in Iran since then the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00398-00098898-00099053": "brave people of Iran have been", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00399-00099054-00099406": "protesting protesting 43 years of a", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00400-00099407-00099635": "brutal dictatorship this is the same", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00401-00099636-00099856": "dictatorship that almost three years ago", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00402-00099857-00100265": "shot down Ukraine flight ps752 killing", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00403-00100266-00100517": "over 50 Canadians and I would like to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00404-00100518-00100726": "thank Premier Ford for taking Swift", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00405-00100727-00101135": "action back in January of 2020 by siding", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00406-00101136-00101291": "with the people of Iran and announcing", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00407-00101292-00101476": "scholarships to honor every single", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00408-00101477-00101681": "Canadian murder during that plane crash", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00409-00101682-00102017": "Mr Speaker hundreds if not thousands of", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00410-00102018-00102244": "Iranians have been arrested murdered", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00411-00102245-00102473": "tortured and killed by the brutal and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00412-00102474-00102671": "terrorist illegitimate Islamic regime in", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00413-00102672-00102965": "Iran and Mr Speaker for Iranians", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00414-00102966-00103163": "mourning someone's passing the 40th Day", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00415-00103164-00103432": "is incredibly significant and it's not", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00416-00103433-00103660": "just massagina I mean his family that is", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00417-00103661-00103913": "mourning all of the people of Iran are", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00418-00103914-00104147": "mourning Iranians around the world are", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00419-00104148-00104315": "mourning and the world is mourning with", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00420-00104316-00104399": "them", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00421-00104400-00104639": "there are nationwide strikes happening", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00422-00104640-00104866": "and while pro-islamic regime Lobby", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00423-00104867-00105023": "groups like the Iranian Canadian", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00424-00105024-00105269": "Congress have tried to apologize for the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00425-00105270-00105581": "regime the world has opened its eyes the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00426-00105582-00105760": "regime has shut down the internet to", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00427-00105761-00105971": "prevent the voices of the people of Iran", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00428-00105972-00106163": "being heard but they are asking the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00429-00106164-00106415": "world for one simple thing to be their", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00430-00106416-00106619": "voice to share their stories and to make", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00431-00106620-00106852": "them heard I have several hundred", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00432-00106853-00107057": "constituents in my riding who just like", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00433-00107058-00107404": "me are of Iranian origin and today I", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00434-00107405-00107584": "want to let the people of Iran know that", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00435-00107585-00107777": "they are not alone in their fight for", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00436-00107778-00108047": "freedom and democracy here in Canada we", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00437-00108048-00108227": "are blessed to live in a free and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00438-00108228-00108460": "Democratic Society the people of Iran", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00439-00108461-00108560": "deserve the same", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00440-00108561-00109445": "[Applause]", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00441-00109446-00109498": "thank you", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00442-00109499-00110297": "[Applause]", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00443-00110298-00110640": "thank you very much", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00444-00110641-00110927": "point of order the member for Carlton I", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00445-00110928-00111089": "would like to seek unanimous consent", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00446-00111090-00111281": "from the house for a moment of silence", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00447-00111282-00111569": "in honor of all of the Iranians who have", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00448-00111570-00111839": "been murdered and brutally murdered and", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00449-00111840-00111977": "tortured at the hands of the", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00450-00111978-00112127": "illegitimate and terrorist Islamic", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00451-00112128-00112360": "regime in Iran", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00452-00112361-00112571": "and for Carlton is seeking unanimous", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00453-00112572-00112745": "consent for a moment's silence at this", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00454-00112746-00112852": "time", "QKtVh1DSQt0-00455-00112853-00113383": "agreed agreed members of please rise"}}, {"audio_id": "QKJ5UFz04NQ", "text": {"QKJ5UFz04NQ-00000-00000031-00000466": "[Music]", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00001-00000467-00000716": "the outreach program is a really unique", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00002-00000717-00000881": "part of what we do at Girl Scouts heart", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00003-00000882-00001075": "of Michigan it's our way of making sure", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00004-00001076-00001225": "that all girls and our community have", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00005-00001226-00001453": "access to Girl Scouting and leadership", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00006-00001454-00001636": "experiences that come with that so that", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00007-00001637-00001889": "means we take the classic experience", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00008-00001889-00002000": "that you might think of in a troop", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00009-00002001-00002171": "setting we bring it to the girls right", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00010-00002172-00002312": "where they are so that means we go and", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00011-00002313-00002509": "at lunch times after school and we're", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00012-00002510-00002701": "working on badges the girls are selling", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00013-00002702-00002864": "cookies are doing everything that Girl", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00014-00002865-00003047": "Scouts do just in a different setting in", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00015-00003048-00003242": "a different environment our programs we", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00016-00003243-00003494": "focus a lot on leadership skills being", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00017-00003495-00003617": "able to work together", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00018-00003618-00003959": "we've also with MSU nutrition club do a", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00019-00003960-00004138": "cooking class with us which the girls", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00020-00004139-00004352": "would really love and enjoy we went to", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00021-00004353-00004601": "the kitchen it was like I imagined like", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00022-00004602-00004997": "actual ovens we ended up cooking quiche", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00023-00004998-00005272": "it was really good I look forward to", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00024-00005273-00005468": "different kinds of foods that we do", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00025-00005469-00005672": "don't like give you engineering go stuff", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00026-00005673-00005872": "is really fun we were learning about", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00027-00005873-00006101": "building cars and stuff it's not all", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00028-00006102-00006304": "about like Sun cookies you can learn", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00029-00006305-00006559": "other things we're preparing girls to", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00030-00006561-00006719": "take an equal place in society and we're", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00031-00006720-00006835": "not saying that that starts when she's", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00032-00006836-00006998": "at a certain age or when she's an adult", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00033-00006998-00007135": "like that's right now that's when she's", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00034-00007136-00007262": "in kindergarten or fourth grade or fifth", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00035-00007263-00007466": "grade and helping her understand her", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00036-00007467-00007667": "power and the potential she has to", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00037-00007668-00007828": "really change the world to be able to", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00038-00007829-00008087": "see that growth is incredibly powerful", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00039-00008088-00008321": "as we go through the program in each", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00040-00008322-00008576": "session they gain more confidence there", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00041-00008577-00008807": "you start working with others they're", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00042-00008808-00009059": "speaking up seeing their confidence", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00043-00009060-00009331": "build it's it's a great thing I'm", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00044-00009332-00009512": "actually a Girl Scout troop leader as", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00045-00009513-00009701": "well as a former Girl Scout and so it", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00046-00009702-00009869": "was my passion to have Girl Scouts come", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00047-00009870-00010042": "to the Boys and Girls Club some of our", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00048-00010043-00010156": "girls this is the only program that", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00049-00010157-00010385": "they're actually involved in so just", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00050-00010386-00010505": "letting these girls know that they can", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00051-00010506-00010658": "do anything and be part of a sisterhood", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00052-00010659-00010864": "the kids a lot of times don't have the", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00053-00010865-00011017": "support system that they wish they did", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00054-00011018-00011195": "or don't realize that they don't have a", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00055-00011196-00011381": "full support system and when they come", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00056-00011382-00011585": "here they have a mentor and they look", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00057-00011586-00011710": "after them and everything and they'll", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00058-00011711-00011873": "discipline them all in the same you know", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00059-00011874-00012098": "breath I know that I couldn't cross my", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00060-00012099-00012331": "troop leader but I knew that if I was", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00061-00012332-00012478": "ever in trouble if I needed to talk that", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00062-00012479-00012617": "I could always start my troop leader and", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00063-00012618-00012758": "she definitely have some good advice so", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00064-00012759-00012926": "it impacts the community with support", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00065-00012927-00013316": "guest gets helped me open up life", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00066-00013318-00013469": "make me feel better one time so it's", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00067-00013470-00013719": "wrong the way that I think about Girl", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00068-00013719-00013919": "Scouts they're like my family when I'm", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00069-00013920-00014085": "not home every lunch", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00070-00014086-00014352": "um week I come here and I think of them", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00071-00014353-00014597": "as my family so they made a lot to me I", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00072-00014598-00015815": "want to be a Girl Scout forever", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00073-00015816-00016035": "the girls that we serve through the", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00074-00016036-00016161": "outreach program they're the leaders", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00075-00016162-00016397": "that we can't wait to have step into", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00076-00016398-00016584": "these roles and so just know that what", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00077-00016585-00016772": "we do in Girl Scouts it's like changing", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00078-00016773-00016863": "we're changing lives", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00079-00016864-00017046": "the girls change our lives every single", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00080-00017047-00017398": "day when we get to work with them", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00081-00017399-00017660": "[Music]", "QKJ5UFz04NQ-00082-00017661-00017867": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "QKJIylf94do", "text": {"QKJIylf94do-00000-00000035-00000432": "Kyodo my name's Johnny and I'm very gay", "QKJIylf94do-00001-00000433-00000739": "do you have a morning routine", "QKJIylf94do-00002-00000740-00001124": "not really it's usually just get up have", "QKJIylf94do-00003-00001125-00001183": "some toast", "QKJIylf94do-00004-00001184-00001358": "maybe brush my teeth maybe have a shower", "QKJIylf94do-00005-00001359-00001525": "depending on how manky I'm feeling and", "QKJIylf94do-00006-00001526-00001705": "then get my clothes on trying to find", "QKJIylf94do-00007-00001707-00001998": "some clean clothes and go out the door", "QKJIylf94do-00008-00002000-00002249": "how would you describe the city that you", "QKJIylf94do-00009-00002250-00002429": "live in", "QKJIylf94do-00010-00002430-00002817": "I would describe Wellington as quite", "QKJIylf94do-00011-00002818-00003020": "geographically small so everything's", "QKJIylf94do-00012-00003021-00003220": "kind of easier to get to doesn't take", "QKJIylf94do-00013-00003221-00003361": "too long to get anywhere particularly", "QKJIylf94do-00014-00003363-00003575": "because I live right in the middle and", "QKJIylf94do-00015-00003576-00003715": "then like getting up to places like", "QKJIylf94do-00016-00003717-00004040": "Newtown and things you can usually get a", "QKJIylf94do-00017-00004040-00004488": "bus most of the time yeah so close", "QKJIylf94do-00018-00004489-00004936": "what's the weather like today tell you", "QKJIylf94do-00019-00004937-00005086": "what I'm not wearing the right clothes", "QKJIylf94do-00020-00005087-00005513": "for it I'm wearing I'm wearing gendell's", "QKJIylf94do-00021-00005514-00005977": "and shorts and it's a bit nippy where's", "QKJIylf94do-00022-00005978-00006400": "your favorite place to go to eat well I", "QKJIylf94do-00023-00006401-00006725": "I get free coffee from customs because", "QKJIylf94do-00024-00006726-00007183": "my cousin works there so I enjoyed that", "QKJIylf94do-00025-00007184-00007645": "otherwise some peers got cheap sushi", "QKJIylf94do-00026-00007647-00007971": "baby oh yeah", "QKJIylf94do-00027-00007972-00008367": "does your family have any traditions I", "QKJIylf94do-00028-00008368-00008662": "don't know if we really have any", "QKJIylf94do-00029-00008663-00008987": "traditions properly I mean we've always", "QKJIylf94do-00030-00008988-00009317": "big on having like meals always kind of", "QKJIylf94do-00031-00009318-00009473": "a big thing so I like we have a family", "QKJIylf94do-00032-00009474-00009631": "gathering you run or bring something or", "QKJIylf94do-00033-00009632-00009959": "there'll be a big fade I like especially", "QKJIylf94do-00034-00009960-00010166": "with my mum's family so my grandma died", "QKJIylf94do-00035-00010167-00010523": "recently so we've sort of have started", "QKJIylf94do-00036-00010524-00010789": "having these sort of annual family meet", "QKJIylf94do-00037-00010790-00010952": "ups which a really good lot of Jen lot", "QKJIylf94do-00038-00010953-00011177": "of a lot of whiskey and Jameson drunk", "QKJIylf94do-00039-00011178-00011456": "and stuff like that so yeah it's mostly", "QKJIylf94do-00040-00011457-00011735": "sort of based around annual food like", "QKJIylf94do-00041-00011736-00012010": "Christmas drinking just getting", "QKJIylf94do-00042-00012011-00012445": "absolutely destroyed yeah what do you", "QKJIylf94do-00043-00012446-00012783": "think is special about New Zealand", "QKJIylf94do-00044-00012784-00013443": "how we speak I don't I don't have any", "QKJIylf94do-00045-00013444-00013791": "particular national sentiment about New", "QKJIylf94do-00046-00013791-00014088": "Zealand I think and it's kind of weird", "QKJIylf94do-00047-00014088-00014277": "not I've never really lived outside of", "QKJIylf94do-00048-00014278-00014430": "New Zealand so I don't have a great", "QKJIylf94do-00049-00014431-00014588": "comparison but I guess one of the things", "QKJIylf94do-00050-00014590-00014769": "that people bring up and comes up a lot", "QKJIylf94do-00051-00014769-00015075": "for me because I'm very gay it's like", "QKJIylf94do-00052-00015076-00015372": "how everyone knows each other like like", "QKJIylf94do-00053-00015372-00015582": "in the gay community like almost", "QKJIylf94do-00054-00015583-00015732": "everyone knows each other but even in", "QKJIylf94do-00055-00015733-00015882": "New Zealand like I can just go to a", "QKJIylf94do-00056-00015883-00016041": "party girl oh you know so and so are", "QKJIylf94do-00057-00016041-00016086": "they", "QKJIylf94do-00058-00016087-00016247": "you know went to my school and then went", "QKJIylf94do-00059-00016248-00016365": "up to your school and came back and", "QKJIylf94do-00060-00016366-00016764": "stuff like that yeah what is your most", "QKJIylf94do-00061-00016765-00017166": "annoying habit I do this I'm sure", "QKJIylf94do-00062-00017167-00017300": "there's one worse than this but I do", "QKJIylf94do-00063-00017301-00017466": "this terrible thing which I can't", "QKJIylf94do-00064-00017467-00017708": "control where I burp like when you", "QKJIylf94do-00065-00017709-00017936": "variety like come into a room so there's", "QKJIylf94do-00066-00017937-00018171": "like this thing I've got older school", "QKJIylf94do-00067-00018172-00018303": "it's kind of special name is like when", "QKJIylf94do-00068-00018304-00018555": "you when someone goes from like a dark", "QKJIylf94do-00069-00018556-00018797": "space to a really bright space like", "QKJIylf94do-00070-00018798-00018927": "coming out of a movie theater they'll", "QKJIylf94do-00071-00018928-00018986": "sneeze", "QKJIylf94do-00072-00018987-00019253": "so it's this automatic reaction but I", "QKJIylf94do-00073-00019254-00019400": "have that with like burping whatever I", "QKJIylf94do-00074-00019401-00019539": "crush it across the threshold", "QKJIylf94do-00075-00019540-00019683": "like I'll just burp and I just can't", "QKJIylf94do-00076-00019684-00020081": "control it what's your favorite quality", "QKJIylf94do-00077-00020082-00020427": "about yourself just how amazing", "QKJIylf94do-00078-00020428-00021044": "I am really I don't know I like to think", "QKJIylf94do-00079-00021045-00021369": "I'm kind or at least try to be yeah", "QKJIylf94do-00080-00021370-00021581": "that's something that's important to me", "QKJIylf94do-00081-00021582-00021693": "I don't know if I pull it off all the", "QKJIylf94do-00082-00021694-00022031": "time but to her guest what's your", "QKJIylf94do-00083-00022032-00022440": "favorite New Zealand slang word or swear", "QKJIylf94do-00084-00022441-00022930": "word like New Zealand in particular yeah", "QKJIylf94do-00085-00022931-00023361": "I don't know if there's any New Zealand", "QKJIylf94do-00086-00023362-00023672": "particular ones oh I've always liked", "QKJIylf94do-00087-00023673-00023874": "Monta munters always been a good like", "QKJIylf94do-00088-00023875-00024339": "slang word or breather I am I am a fan", "QKJIylf94do-00089-00024340-00024615": "of calling people munters though yeah so", "QKJIylf94do-00090-00024616-00024843": "a Munter I can't explain it without", "QKJIylf94do-00091-00024844-00025184": "using Museum and slay this whole", "QKJIylf94do-00092-00025185-00025788": "cosmology so it's basically so someone", "QKJIylf94do-00093-00025789-00026006": "who gets on the perceiver we can really", "QKJIylf94do-00094-00026007-00026196": "drunk just", "QKJIylf94do-00095-00026197-00026485": "you know drugs alcohol just getting", "QKJIylf94do-00096-00026486-00026749": "completely wasted and sort of that's a", "QKJIylf94do-00097-00026750-00026889": "big part what they're there for and", "QKJIylf94do-00098-00026891-00027043": "they're just like getting munted you", "QKJIylf94do-00099-00027044-00027252": "know so munted like a few monkey car you", "QKJIylf94do-00100-00027253-00027424": "really badly like crash it'll it up", "QKJIylf94do-00101-00027425-00027637": "right so that's like the human", "QKJIylf94do-00102-00027638-00027837": "equivalent they just go and hard heading", "QKJIylf94do-00103-00027838-00028077": "things swerving all over the road of", "QKJIylf94do-00104-00028078-00028602": "life yeah thanks for listening see you", "QKJIylf94do-00105-00028603-00028770": "next time on an introduction to New", "QKJIylf94do-00106-00028772-00029433": "Zealand swearing Kyoto my name is Johnny", "QKJIylf94do-00107-00029434-00029845": "and I'm very gay do you have a morning", "QKJIylf94do-00108-00029845-00029973": "routine", "QKJIylf94do-00109-00029974-00030355": "not really it's usually just get up have", "QKJIylf94do-00110-00030356-00030418": "some toast", "QKJIylf94do-00111-00030419-00030589": "maybe brush my teeth maybe have a shower", "QKJIylf94do-00112-00030589-00030757": "depending on how manky I'm feeling and", "QKJIylf94do-00113-00030758-00030939": "then get my clothes on trying to find", "QKJIylf94do-00114-00030941-00031233": "some clean clothes and go out the door", "QKJIylf94do-00115-00031233-00031480": "how would you describe the city that you", "QKJIylf94do-00116-00031481-00031560": "live in", "QKJIylf94do-00117-00031561-00032052": "I would describe Wellington as quite", "QKJIylf94do-00118-00032052-00032251": "geographically small so everything's", "QKJIylf94do-00119-00032252-00032455": "kind of easier to get to doesn't take", "QKJIylf94do-00120-00032456-00032595": "too long to get anywhere particularly", "QKJIylf94do-00121-00032597-00032806": "because I live right in the middle and", "QKJIylf94do-00122-00032807-00032946": "then like getting up to places like", "QKJIylf94do-00123-00032947-00033274": "Newtown and things you can usually get a", "QKJIylf94do-00124-00033275-00033720": "bus most of the time yeah so close", "QKJIylf94do-00125-00033721-00034171": "what's the weather like today tell you", "QKJIylf94do-00126-00034172-00034321": "what I'm not wearing the right clothes", "QKJIylf94do-00127-00034322-00034746": "for it I'm wearing I'm wearing gendell's", "QKJIylf94do-00128-00034747-00035212": "and shorts and it's a bit nippy where's", "QKJIylf94do-00129-00035213-00035635": "your favorite place to go to eat well I", "QKJIylf94do-00130-00035636-00035964": "I get free coffee from customs because", "QKJIylf94do-00131-00035965-00036417": "my cousin works there so I enjoyed that", "QKJIylf94do-00132-00036418-00036877": "otherwise some peers got cheap sushi", "QKJIylf94do-00133-00036878-00037411": "baby oh yeah does your family have any", "QKJIylf94do-00134-00037412-00037752": "traditions I don't know if we really", "QKJIylf94do-00135-00037753-00038179": "have any traditions properly I mean", "QKJIylf94do-00136-00038180-00038482": "we've always big on having like meals", "QKJIylf94do-00137-00038483-00038656": "always kind of a big thing so like we", "QKJIylf94do-00138-00038657-00038808": "have a family gathering you run or bring", "QKJIylf94do-00139-00038809-00039073": "something or there'd be a big feed I", "QKJIylf94do-00140-00039074-00039321": "like especially with my mum's family so", "QKJIylf94do-00141-00039322-00039517": "my grandma died recently so we've sort", "QKJIylf94do-00142-00039518-00039553": "of", "QKJIylf94do-00143-00039554-00039913": "I have started having these sort of", "QKJIylf94do-00144-00039914-00040084": "annual family meet ups which are really", "QKJIylf94do-00145-00040085-00040294": "good lot of gin lot of lot of whiskey", "QKJIylf94do-00146-00040295-00040563": "and Jameson drunk and stuff like that so", "QKJIylf94do-00147-00040564-00040815": "yeah it's mostly sort of based around", "QKJIylf94do-00148-00040816-00041212": "annual food like Christmas drinking just", "QKJIylf94do-00149-00041213-00041559": "getting absolutely destroyed yeah", "QKJIylf94do-00150-00041560-00041818": "what do you think is special about New", "QKJIylf94do-00151-00041819-00042628": "Zealand how we speak I don't I don't", "QKJIylf94do-00152-00042629-00042967": "have any particular national sentiment", "QKJIylf94do-00153-00042968-00043297": "about New Zealand I think and it's kind", "QKJIylf94do-00154-00043298-00043444": "of weird not I've never really lived", "QKJIylf94do-00155-00043445-00043633": "outside of New Zealand so I don't have a", "QKJIylf94do-00156-00043634-00043810": "great comparison but I guess one of the", "QKJIylf94do-00157-00043811-00043981": "things that people bring up and comes up", "QKJIylf94do-00158-00043982-00044293": "a lot for me because I'm very gay it's", "QKJIylf94do-00159-00044294-00044505": "like how everyone knows each other like", "QKJIylf94do-00160-00044506-00044809": "like in the gay community like almost", "QKJIylf94do-00161-00044810-00044962": "everyone knows each other but even in", "QKJIylf94do-00162-00044963-00045115": "New Zealand like I can just go to a", "QKJIylf94do-00163-00045116-00045298": "party go oh you know so and so are they", "QKJIylf94do-00164-00045299-00045487": "you know went to my school and went up", "QKJIylf94do-00165-00045488-00045616": "to your school and came back and stuff", "QKJIylf94do-00166-00045617-00045825": "at there yeah", "QKJIylf94do-00167-00045826-00046270": "what is your most annoying habit I do", "QKJIylf94do-00168-00046271-00046480": "this I'm sure there's one worse than", "QKJIylf94do-00169-00046481-00046648": "this but I do this terrible thing which", "QKJIylf94do-00170-00046649-00046894": "I can't control where I burp like", "QKJIylf94do-00171-00046895-00047152": "whenever I like come into a room so", "QKJIylf94do-00172-00047153-00047389": "there's like this thing I've got older", "QKJIylf94do-00173-00047390-00047497": "school it's kind of special neighbours", "QKJIylf94do-00174-00047498-00047665": "like when you when someone goes from", "QKJIylf94do-00175-00047666-00047977": "like a dark space to a really bright", "QKJIylf94do-00176-00047978-00048109": "space like coming out of the movie", "QKJIylf94do-00177-00048110-00048220": "theatre they'll sneeze", "QKJIylf94do-00178-00048221-00048487": "so it's this automatic reaction but I", "QKJIylf94do-00179-00048488-00048634": "have that with like burping whenever I", "QKJIylf94do-00180-00048635-00048811": "cross across a threshold like I just", "QKJIylf94do-00181-00048812-00049207": "burp and I just can't control it what's", "QKJIylf94do-00182-00049208-00049461": "your favorite quality about yourself", "QKJIylf94do-00183-00049462-00049965": "just how amazing I am really I", "QKJIylf94do-00184-00049966-00050431": "don't know I like to think I'm kind or", "QKJIylf94do-00185-00050432-00050698": "at least try to be yeah that's something", "QKJIylf94do-00186-00050699-00050866": "that's important to me I don't know if I", "QKJIylf94do-00187-00050867-00051001": "pull it off all the time but I do have", "QKJIylf94do-00188-00051002-00051451": "this what's your favourite New Zealand", "QKJIylf94do-00189-00051452-00051886": "slang word or swear word like New", "QKJIylf94do-00190-00051887-00052408": "Zealand in particular yeah I don't know", "QKJIylf94do-00191-00052409-00052633": "if there's any New Zealand particular", "QKJIylf94do-00192-00052634-00052945": "ones oh I've always liked Mun", "QKJIylf94do-00193-00052946-00053142": "to munters always been a good like slang", "QKJIylf94do-00194-00053144-00053572": "word or breather I am I am a fan of", "QKJIylf94do-00195-00053573-00053866": "calling people munters though yeah so am", "QKJIylf94do-00196-00053866-00054097": "under I can't explain it without using", "QKJIylf94do-00197-00054098-00054786": "Museum and slay this whole cosmology so", "QKJIylf94do-00198-00054787-00055120": "it's basically so someone who gets on", "QKJIylf94do-00199-00055121-00055416": "the periphery we can really drunk just", "QKJIylf94do-00200-00055416-00055716": "you know drugs alcohol just getting", "QKJIylf94do-00201-00055717-00055980": "completely wasted and sort of that's a", "QKJIylf94do-00202-00055982-00056119": "big part what they're there for and", "QKJIylf94do-00203-00056120-00056278": "they're just like getting munted you", "QKJIylf94do-00204-00056279-00056470": "know so munted like a few month your car", "QKJIylf94do-00205-00056471-00056635": "you really badly like crash it'll", "QKJIylf94do-00206-00056636-00056869": "it up right so that's like the human", "QKJIylf94do-00207-00056870-00057073": "equivalent they just go and hard heading", "QKJIylf94do-00208-00057074-00057310": "things swerving all over the road of", "QKJIylf94do-00209-00057311-00057835": "life yeah thanks for listening see you", "QKJIylf94do-00210-00057836-00058003": "next time on on introduction to new", "QKJIylf94do-00211-00058004-00058669": "zealand swearing kyoto my name's johnny", "QKJIylf94do-00212-00058670-00059086": "and i'm very gay do you have a morning", "QKJIylf94do-00213-00059087-00059204": "routine", "QKJIylf94do-00214-00059205-00059590": "not really it's usually just get up have", "QKJIylf94do-00215-00059591-00059653": "some toast", "QKJIylf94do-00216-00059654-00059817": "maybe brush my teeth maybe have a shower", "QKJIylf94do-00217-00059819-00059991": "depending on how manky i'm feeling and", "QKJIylf94do-00218-00059992-00060169": "then get my clothes on trying to find", "QKJIylf94do-00219-00060170-00060465": "some clean clothes and go out the door", "QKJIylf94do-00220-00060466-00060715": "how would you describe the city that you", "QKJIylf94do-00221-00060716-00060795": "live in", "QKJIylf94do-00222-00060796-00061284": "I would describe Wellington as quite", "QKJIylf94do-00223-00061285-00061483": "geographically small so everything's", "QKJIylf94do-00224-00061484-00061687": "kind of easier to get to doesn't take", "QKJIylf94do-00225-00061688-00061828": "too long to get anywhere particularly", "QKJIylf94do-00226-00061829-00062038": "because I live right in the middle and", "QKJIylf94do-00227-00062039-00062179": "then like getting up to places like", "QKJIylf94do-00228-00062179-00062505": "Newtown and things you can usually get a", "QKJIylf94do-00229-00062507-00062952": "bus most of the time yeah so close", "QKJIylf94do-00230-00062953-00063403": "what's the weather like today tell you", "QKJIylf94do-00231-00063404-00063553": "what I'm not wearing the right clothes", "QKJIylf94do-00232-00063554-00063979": "for it I'm wearing I'm wearing gendell's", "QKJIylf94do-00233-00063979-00064444": "and shorts and it's a bit nippy where's", "QKJIylf94do-00234-00064445-00064864": "your favorite place to go to eat uh well", "QKJIylf94do-00235-00064865-00065191": "I I get free coffee from customs because", "QKJIylf94do-00236-00065191-00065635": "my cousin works the earth so I enjoyed", "QKJIylf94do-00237-00065636-00066085": "that otherwise some peers got cheap", "QKJIylf94do-00238-00066086-00066244": "sushi baby", "QKJIylf94do-00239-00066245-00066646": "oh yeah does your family have any", "QKJIylf94do-00240-00066647-00066985": "traditions I don't know if we really", "QKJIylf94do-00241-00066986-00067413": "have any traditions properly I mean", "QKJIylf94do-00242-00067414-00067717": "we've always big on having like meals", "QKJIylf94do-00243-00067718-00067887": "always kind of a big thing so like we", "QKJIylf94do-00244-00067888-00068019": "have a family gathering your own or", "QKJIylf94do-00245-00068020-00068140": "bringing something or there'd be a big", "QKJIylf94do-00246-00068141-00068491": "feed I like especially with my mum's", "QKJIylf94do-00247-00068492-00068712": "family so my grandma died recently so", "QKJIylf94do-00248-00068713-00069042": "we've sort of have started having these", "QKJIylf94do-00249-00069043-00069306": "sort of annual family meet ups which are", "QKJIylf94do-00250-00069307-00069501": "really good we'll have Jen lot of lot of", "QKJIylf94do-00251-00069502-00069721": "whiskey and Jameson drunk and stuff like", "QKJIylf94do-00252-00069722-00070006": "that so yeah it's mostly sort of based", "QKJIylf94do-00253-00070007-00070268": "around annual food like Christmas", "QKJIylf94do-00254-00070269-00070522": "drinking just getting absolutely", "QKJIylf94do-00255-00070523-00070956": "destroyed yeah what do you think is", "QKJIylf94do-00256-00070957-00071529": "special about New Zealand how we speak I", "QKJIylf94do-00257-00071530-00072038": "don't I don't have any particular", "QKJIylf94do-00258-00072039-00072322": "national sentiment about New Zealand I", "QKJIylf94do-00259-00072323-00072604": "think and it's kind of weird not I've", "QKJIylf94do-00260-00072605-00072756": "never really lived outside of New", "QKJIylf94do-00261-00072757-00072894": "Zealand so I don't have a great", "QKJIylf94do-00262-00072895-00073044": "comparison but I guess one of the things", "QKJIylf94do-00263-00073045-00073234": "that people bring up and comes up a lot", "QKJIylf94do-00264-00073235-00073540": "for me because I'm very gay it's like", "QKJIylf94do-00265-00073541-00073837": "how everyone knows each other like like", "QKJIylf94do-00266-00073838-00074041": "in the gay community like almost", "QKJIylf94do-00267-00074042-00074197": "everyone knows each other but even in", "QKJIylf94do-00268-00074198-00074347": "New Zealand like I can just go to a", "QKJIylf94do-00269-00074348-00074509": "party girl oh you know so and so are", "QKJIylf94do-00270-00074510-00074694": "they you know went to my school and then", "QKJIylf94do-00271-00074695-00074830": "went up to your school and came back and", "QKJIylf94do-00272-00074831-00075078": "stuff like that yeah", "QKJIylf94do-00273-00075079-00075519": "what is your most annoying habit I do", "QKJIylf94do-00274-00075520-00075714": "this I've sure there's one worse than", "QKJIylf94do-00275-00075715-00075879": "this but I do this terrible thing which", "QKJIylf94do-00276-00075880-00076128": "I can't control where I burp like", "QKJIylf94do-00277-00076129-00076383": "whenever I like come into a room so", "QKJIylf94do-00278-00076384-00076617": "there's like this thing I've got old", "QKJIylf94do-00279-00076618-00076728": "school it's kind of special neighbors", "QKJIylf94do-00280-00076729-00076896": "like when you when someone goes from", "QKJIylf94do-00281-00076897-00077208": "like a dark space to a really bright", "QKJIylf94do-00282-00077209-00077364": "space like coming out of a movie theater", "QKJIylf94do-00283-00077365-00077454": "they'll sneeze", "QKJIylf94do-00284-00077455-00077721": "so it's this automatic reaction but I", "QKJIylf94do-00285-00077722-00077862": "have that with like burping whatever I", "QKJIylf94do-00286-00077863-00078036": "crush it across the threshold like I", "QKJIylf94do-00287-00078037-00078177": "just burped and I'm just can't control", "QKJIylf94do-00288-00078178-00078338": "it", "QKJIylf94do-00289-00078339-00078570": "what's your favorite quality about", "QKJIylf94do-00290-00078571-00078912": "yourself just how amazing I am", "QKJIylf94do-00291-00078913-00079572": "really I don't know I like to think I'm", "QKJIylf94do-00292-00079573-00079908": "kind or at least try to be yeah that's", "QKJIylf94do-00293-00079909-00080067": "something that's important to me I don't", "QKJIylf94do-00294-00080068-00080208": "know if I pull it off all the time but I", "QKJIylf94do-00295-00080209-00080375": "do my best", "QKJIylf94do-00296-00080376-00080706": "what's your favorite New Zealand slang", "QKJIylf94do-00297-00080707-00081168": "word or swear word like New Zealand in", "QKJIylf94do-00298-00081169-00081669": "particular yeah I don't know if there's", "QKJIylf94do-00299-00081670-00082095": "any New Zealand particular ones oh I've", "QKJIylf94do-00300-00082096-00082293": "always liked Monta munters always been a", "QKJIylf94do-00301-00082294-00082758": "good like slang word or breather I am I", "QKJIylf94do-00302-00082759-00082905": "am a fan of calling people munters", "QKJIylf94do-00303-00082906-00083271": "though yeah so a Munter I can't explain", "QKJIylf94do-00304-00083272-00083652": "it without using Museum and slay hole", "QKJIylf94do-00305-00083653-00084252": "cosmology so it's basically so someone", "QKJIylf94do-00306-00084253-00084468": "who gets on the perceiver we can really", "QKJIylf94do-00307-00084469-00084912": "drunk just you know drugs alcohol just", "QKJIylf94do-00308-00084913-00085185": "getting completely wasted and sort of", "QKJIylf94do-00309-00085186-00085308": "that's a big part of what they're there", "QKJIylf94do-00310-00085309-00085482": "for and they're just like getting munted", "QKJIylf94do-00311-00085483-00085671": "you know so munted like a few months", "QKJIylf94do-00312-00085672-00085824": "your car you really badly like crash", "QKJIylf94do-00313-00085825-00086061": "it'll it up right so that's like", "QKJIylf94do-00314-00086062-00086202": "the human equivalent they just go and", "QKJIylf94do-00315-00086203-00086475": "hard heading things swerving all over", "QKJIylf94do-00316-00086476-00086866": "the road of life yes", "QKJIylf94do-00317-00086867-00087107": "thanks for listening see you next time", "QKJIylf94do-00318-00087108-00087239": "on an introduction to New Zealand", "QKJIylf94do-00319-00087240-00087950": "swearing Kyoto my name is Gianni and I'm", "QKJIylf94do-00320-00087951-00088129": "very gay", "QKJIylf94do-00321-00088130-00088438": "do you have a morning routine", "QKJIylf94do-00322-00088439-00088820": "not really it's usually just get up have", "QKJIylf94do-00323-00088821-00088883": "some toast", "QKJIylf94do-00324-00088884-00089054": "maybe brush my teeth maybe have a shower", "QKJIylf94do-00325-00089055-00089222": "depending on how manky I'm feeling and", "QKJIylf94do-00326-00089223-00089402": "then get my clothes on trying to find", "QKJIylf94do-00327-00089403-00089698": "some clean clothes and go out the door", "QKJIylf94do-00328-00089699-00089945": "how would you describe the city that you", "QKJIylf94do-00329-00089946-00090122": "live in", "QKJIylf94do-00330-00090123-00090517": "I would describe Wellington as quite", "QKJIylf94do-00331-00090518-00090716": "geographically small so everything's", "QKJIylf94do-00332-00090717-00090920": "kind of easier to get to doesn't take", "QKJIylf94do-00333-00090921-00091061": "too long to get anywhere particularly", "QKJIylf94do-00334-00091062-00091274": "because I live right in the middle and", "QKJIylf94do-00335-00091275-00091412": "then like getting up to places like", "QKJIylf94do-00336-00091413-00091739": "Newtown and things you can usually get a", "QKJIylf94do-00337-00091740-00092185": "bus most of the time yeah so close", "QKJIylf94do-00338-00092186-00092627": "what's the weather like today ah tell", "QKJIylf94do-00339-00092628-00092756": "you what I'm not wearing the right", "QKJIylf94do-00340-00092757-00093113": "clothes for it I'm wearing I'm wearing", "QKJIylf94do-00341-00093114-00093434": "gendell's and shorts and it's a bit", "QKJIylf94do-00342-00093435-00093803": "nippy where's your favorite place to go", "QKJIylf94do-00343-00093804-00094343": "to eat well I I get free coffee from", "QKJIylf94do-00344-00094344-00094826": "customs because my cousin works there so", "QKJIylf94do-00345-00094827-00095291": "I enjoyed that otherwise some peers got", "QKJIylf94do-00346-00095292-00095668": "cheap sushi baby oh yeah", "QKJIylf94do-00347-00095669-00096064": "does your family have any traditions I", "QKJIylf94do-00348-00096065-00096358": "don't know if we really have any", "QKJIylf94do-00349-00096359-00096686": "traditions properly I mean we've always", "QKJIylf94do-00350-00096687-00097016": "big on having like meals always kind of", "QKJIylf94do-00351-00097017-00097169": "a big thing so like we have a family", "QKJIylf94do-00352-00097170-00097328": "gathering you run or bring something or", "QKJIylf94do-00353-00097329-00097655": "there'll be a big feed I like especially", "QKJIylf94do-00354-00097656-00097862": "with my mum's family so my grandma died", "QKJIylf94do-00355-00097863-00098222": "recently so we've sort of have started", "QKJIylf94do-00356-00098223-00098486": "having these sort of annual family meet", "QKJIylf94do-00357-00098487-00098624": "ups which are really good lot of djenne", "QKJIylf94do-00358-00098625-00098876": "lot of lot of whiskey and Jameson drunk", "QKJIylf94do-00359-00098877-00099152": "and stuff like that so yeah it's mostly", "QKJIylf94do-00360-00099153-00099434": "sort of based around annual food like", "QKJIylf94do-00361-00099435-00099710": "Christmas drinking just getting", "QKJIylf94do-00362-00099711-00100145": "absolutely destroyed yeah what do you", "QKJIylf94do-00363-00100146-00100181": "think", "QKJIylf94do-00364-00100182-00100657": "official about New Zealand how we speak", "QKJIylf94do-00365-00100658-00101269": "I don't I don't have any particular", "QKJIylf94do-00366-00101270-00101555": "national sentiment about New Zealand I", "QKJIylf94do-00367-00101556-00101837": "think and it's kind of weird not I've", "QKJIylf94do-00368-00101838-00101987": "never really lived outside of New", "QKJIylf94do-00369-00101988-00102128": "Zealand so I don't have a great", "QKJIylf94do-00370-00102129-00102287": "comparison but I guess one of the things", "QKJIylf94do-00371-00102288-00102469": "that people bring up and comes up a lot", "QKJIylf94do-00372-00102470-00102773": "for me because I'm very gay it's like", "QKJIylf94do-00373-00102774-00103069": "how everyone knows each other like like", "QKJIylf94do-00374-00103070-00103274": "in the gay community like almost", "QKJIylf94do-00375-00103275-00103427": "everyone knows each other but even in", "QKJIylf94do-00376-00103428-00103580": "New Zealand like I can just go to a", "QKJIylf94do-00377-00103581-00103739": "party girl oh you know so and so are", "QKJIylf94do-00378-00103740-00103783": "they", "QKJIylf94do-00379-00103784-00103955": "you know went to my school and went up", "QKJIylf94do-00380-00103956-00104081": "to your school and came back and stuff", "QKJIylf94do-00381-00104082-00104509": "up there yeah what is your most annoying", "QKJIylf94do-00382-00104510-00104888": "habit I do this I'm sure there's one", "QKJIylf94do-00383-00104889-00105068": "worse than this but I do this terrible", "QKJIylf94do-00384-00105069-00105275": "thing which I can't control where I burp", "QKJIylf94do-00385-00105276-00105521": "like when you variety like come into a", "QKJIylf94do-00386-00105522-00105835": "room so there's like this thing I've got", "QKJIylf94do-00387-00105836-00105923": "older school it's kind of special", "QKJIylf94do-00388-00105924-00106060": "neighbours like when you when someone", "QKJIylf94do-00389-00106061-00106394": "goes from like a dark space to a really", "QKJIylf94do-00390-00106395-00106577": "bright space like coming out of a movie", "QKJIylf94do-00391-00106578-00106724": "theater they'll sneeze so it's an", "QKJIylf94do-00392-00106725-00107008": "automatic reaction but I have that with", "QKJIylf94do-00393-00107009-00107180": "like burping whenever I cross across the", "QKJIylf94do-00394-00107181-00107243": "threshold", "QKJIylf94do-00395-00107244-00107381": "like I just burp and I just can't", "QKJIylf94do-00396-00107382-00107780": "control it what's your favorite quality", "QKJIylf94do-00397-00107781-00108101": "about yourself just how amazing", "QKJIylf94do-00398-00108102-00108743": "I am really I don't know I like to think", "QKJIylf94do-00399-00108744-00109067": "I'm kind or at least try to be yeah", "QKJIylf94do-00400-00109068-00109280": "that's something that's important to me", "QKJIylf94do-00401-00109281-00109391": "I don't know if I pull it off all the", "QKJIylf94do-00402-00109392-00109606": "time but I do my best", "QKJIylf94do-00403-00109607-00109936": "what's your favourite New Zealand slang", "QKJIylf94do-00404-00109938-00110402": "word or swear word like New Zealand in", "QKJIylf94do-00405-00110403-00110903": "particular yeah I don't know if there's", "QKJIylf94do-00406-00110904-00111326": "any New Zealand particular ones oh I've", "QKJIylf94do-00407-00111327-00111524": "always liked Munter munters always been", "QKJIylf94do-00408-00111525-00111947": "a good like slang word or breather I am", "QKJIylf94do-00409-00111948-00112139": "I am a fan of calling people munters", "QKJIylf94do-00410-00112140-00112502": "though yeah so a Munter I can't explain", "QKJIylf94do-00411-00112503-00112823": "it without using Museum and slay this", "QKJIylf94do-00412-00112824-00113426": "whole cosmology so it's basically so", "QKJIylf94do-00413-00113427-00113566": "someone who gear", "QKJIylf94do-00414-00113567-00113736": "on the perceiver we can really drunk", "QKJIylf94do-00415-00113738-00114181": "just you know drugs alcohol just getting", "QKJIylf94do-00416-00114182-00114445": "completely wasted and sort of that's a", "QKJIylf94do-00417-00114446-00114589": "big part what they're there for and", "QKJIylf94do-00418-00114590-00114742": "they're just like getting munted you", "QKJIylf94do-00419-00114743-00114913": "know so munted like a few months your", "QKJIylf94do-00420-00114914-00115081": "car you really badly like crash it'll", "QKJIylf94do-00421-00115082-00115300": "it up right so that's like the", "QKJIylf94do-00422-00115301-00115453": "human equivalent they just go and hard", "QKJIylf94do-00423-00115454-00115738": "heading things swerving all over the", "QKJIylf94do-00424-00115739-00116251": "road of life yeah thanks for listening", "QKJIylf94do-00425-00116252-00116446": "see you next time on on introduction to", "QKJIylf94do-00426-00116447-00116746": "New Zealand swearing"}}, {"audio_id": "QKRd8BQ2rRg", "text": {"QKRd8BQ2rRg-00000-00000000-00000247": "just to stay around in this one", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00001-00000248-00000611": "Dak protected so well Gilmore with the", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00002-00000612-00000724": "pick", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00003-00000725-00000958": "no Flags fans wanted it there was a lot", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00004-00000959-00001127": "of contact", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00005-00001128-00001516": "get 20. and down at the 19-yard line", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00006-00001517-00001714": "eight to go", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00007-00001716-00001913": "Ryan backside pressure comes hit as he", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00008-00001914-00002134": "throws it it's intercepted Stefan", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00009-00002135-00002399": "Gilmore in his first game as a panther", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00010-00002400-00003058": "has a pick that should Sultan away", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00011-00003059-00003329": "stepping off and throwing and it is", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00012-00003329-00003443": "knocked down", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00013-00003444-00003965": "more", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00014-00003965-00004325": "surveys good protection slides fires", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00015-00004326-00004738": "broken up in the end zone Gilmore on", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00016-00004739-00005104": "Sutton so the decor", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00017-00005105-00005393": "will send to the end zone and it's", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00018-00005394-00005554": "intercepted", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00019-00005555-00005667": "by Gilmore", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00020-00005668-00005795": "[Applause]", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00021-00005796-00006070": "not first and 15", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00022-00006071-00006406": ". Gilmore down the sideline see you", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00023-00006408-00006606": "later", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00024-00006608-00006989": "touchdown New England second pick of the", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00025-00006990-00007403": "day for Stefan Gilmore", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00026-00007404-00007619": "guard at Camp he's now the starter at", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00027-00007620-00007889": "left tackle Fitzpatrick Sprint out and", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00028-00007890-00008273": "interrupted and good bye", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00029-00008274-00008483": "Stefan Gill", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00030-00008484-00009085": "touchdown on a pick six", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00031-00009086-00009383": "and he burned his foot really smart he's", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00032-00009384-00009628": "got the perfect demeanor very calm", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00033-00009629-00009856": "Watson throwing off his back foot it's", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00034-00009857-00009983": "intercepted", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00035-00009984-00010264": "Stefan Gilmore and Gilmore's got", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00036-00010265-00010553": "blockers in front of him Gilmore puts it", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00037-00010554-00010685": "up field", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00038-00010686-00010924": "huge turnover that's been an issue the", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00039-00010925-00011267": "last on second and seven Jones", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00040-00011268-00011459": "intercepted in the middle of the field", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00041-00011460-00011728": "that is Gilmore Stefan Gilmore inside", "QKRd8BQ2rRg-00042-00011729-00012146": "the 35 to the 33-yard line"}}, {"audio_id": "QLvK5duYtrk", "text": {"QLvK5duYtrk-00000-00000000-00000318": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00001-00000319-00002326": "come on", "QLvK5duYtrk-00002-00002327-00004542": "uh", "QLvK5duYtrk-00003-00004543-00005932": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00004-00005933-00006591": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00005-00006592-00006863": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00006-00006864-00007054": "boys", "QLvK5duYtrk-00007-00007055-00008119": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00008-00008120-00008547": "oh", "QLvK5duYtrk-00009-00008548-00009167": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00010-00009168-00009580": "foreign", "QLvK5duYtrk-00011-00009581-00014251": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00012-00014252-00015047": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00013-00015047-00015522": "oh", "QLvK5duYtrk-00014-00015522-00015705": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00015-00015706-00016269": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00016-00016271-00016471": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00017-00016472-00016911": "is", "QLvK5duYtrk-00018-00016912-00017501": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00019-00017502-00019503": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00020-00019504-00021067": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00021-00021068-00025767": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00022-00025768-00025919": "my", "QLvK5duYtrk-00023-00025920-00030007": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00024-00030008-00030452": "my", "QLvK5duYtrk-00025-00030452-00031118": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00026-00031119-00031233": "hello", "QLvK5duYtrk-00027-00031235-00032999": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00028-00033000-00033362": "oh", "QLvK5duYtrk-00029-00033363-00033918": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00030-00033919-00035462": "yes", "QLvK5duYtrk-00031-00035463-00036044": "so", "QLvK5duYtrk-00032-00036045-00038091": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00033-00038092-00041116": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00034-00041117-00043295": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00035-00043296-00044094": "please", "QLvK5duYtrk-00036-00044095-00045794": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00037-00045795-00046455": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00038-00046456-00046700": "wow", "QLvK5duYtrk-00039-00046701-00047975": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00040-00047976-00049273": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00041-00049274-00050311": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00042-00050312-00050485": "oh", "QLvK5duYtrk-00043-00050486-00051103": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00044-00051104-00052979": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00045-00052980-00053586": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00046-00053587-00054187": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00047-00054188-00054442": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00048-00054444-00054691": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00049-00054692-00056111": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00050-00056112-00057072": "foreign", "QLvK5duYtrk-00051-00057073-00057773": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00052-00057774-00058438": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00053-00058439-00058683": "yes", "QLvK5duYtrk-00054-00058684-00058746": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00055-00058747-00059042": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00056-00059044-00061025": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00057-00061026-00062196": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00058-00062197-00064273": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00059-00064274-00065511": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00060-00065512-00065568": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00061-00065569-00065807": "[Laughter]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00062-00065808-00066806": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00063-00066807-00067750": "it looks good", "QLvK5duYtrk-00064-00067751-00068028": "yes", "QLvK5duYtrk-00065-00068029-00074461": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00066-00074462-00075935": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00067-00075936-00076226": "oh", "QLvK5duYtrk-00068-00076227-00077750": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00069-00077751-00079902": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00070-00079903-00081853": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00071-00081854-00082400": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00072-00082401-00085478": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00073-00085479-00085750": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00074-00085751-00085954": "yes", "QLvK5duYtrk-00075-00085955-00087873": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00076-00087874-00091310": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00077-00091311-00091671": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00078-00091672-00091909": "wow", "QLvK5duYtrk-00079-00091910-00092978": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00080-00092979-00093347": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00081-00093348-00093655": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00082-00093656-00093743": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00083-00093744-00095377": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00084-00095378-00095887": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00085-00095888-00096381": "oh", "QLvK5duYtrk-00086-00096382-00096978": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00087-00096979-00098679": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00088-00098680-00098911": "oh", "QLvK5duYtrk-00089-00098912-00100687": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00090-00100688-00100919": "oh", "QLvK5duYtrk-00091-00100920-00104048": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00092-00104049-00104830": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00093-00104831-00105376": "i know", "QLvK5duYtrk-00094-00105377-00105886": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00095-00105888-00107057": "you", "QLvK5duYtrk-00096-00107058-00110327": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00097-00110328-00112727": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00098-00112728-00112838": "me", "QLvK5duYtrk-00099-00112839-00113654": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00100-00113655-00114476": "i died", "QLvK5duYtrk-00101-00114477-00115517": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00102-00115518-00117302": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00103-00117303-00118054": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00104-00118055-00119933": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00105-00119933-00121275": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00106-00121276-00121928": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00107-00121929-00122558": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00108-00122558-00123218": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00109-00123219-00124063": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00110-00124064-00125049": "um", "QLvK5duYtrk-00111-00125050-00125623": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00112-00125624-00125844": "foreign", "QLvK5duYtrk-00113-00125845-00128649": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00114-00128650-00129054": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00115-00129055-00130763": "sure", "QLvK5duYtrk-00116-00130764-00131190": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00117-00131191-00131512": "why do you want to be a smile", "QLvK5duYtrk-00118-00131513-00132948": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00119-00132949-00134012": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00120-00134013-00134995": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00121-00134996-00136502": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00122-00136503-00137429": "i", "QLvK5duYtrk-00123-00137430-00138047": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00124-00138048-00138387": "oh", "QLvK5duYtrk-00125-00138388-00139551": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00126-00139552-00139658": "is", "QLvK5duYtrk-00127-00139659-00140695": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00128-00140696-00141121": "foreign", "QLvK5duYtrk-00129-00141122-00141631": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00130-00141632-00141880": "foreign", "QLvK5duYtrk-00131-00141881-00142602": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00132-00142603-00145226": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00133-00145227-00145683": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00134-00145684-00146161": "oh my god", "QLvK5duYtrk-00135-00146162-00149135": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00136-00149136-00150935": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00137-00150936-00151177": "why", "QLvK5duYtrk-00138-00151178-00152726": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00139-00152727-00153255": "this", "QLvK5duYtrk-00140-00153256-00153903": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00141-00153904-00154983": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00142-00154984-00155346": "wow", "QLvK5duYtrk-00143-00155347-00156435": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00144-00156436-00156814": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00145-00156815-00158751": "oh", "QLvK5duYtrk-00146-00158752-00159794": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00147-00159795-00162217": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00148-00162218-00163883": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00149-00163884-00164710": "um me", "QLvK5duYtrk-00150-00164711-00166493": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00151-00166494-00167076": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00152-00167077-00167589": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00153-00167590-00168605": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00154-00168606-00168911": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00155-00168912-00169695": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00156-00169696-00169973": "oh", "QLvK5duYtrk-00157-00169974-00170039": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00158-00170040-00171212": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00159-00171213-00174135": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00160-00174136-00175303": "ah", "QLvK5duYtrk-00161-00175304-00177957": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00162-00177958-00178102": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00163-00178103-00179344": "wow", "QLvK5duYtrk-00164-00179345-00179831": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00165-00179832-00180275": "wow", "QLvK5duYtrk-00166-00180276-00182399": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00167-00182400-00182513": "yes", "QLvK5duYtrk-00168-00182514-00184492": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00169-00184493-00185238": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00170-00185239-00185986": "tonight", "QLvK5duYtrk-00171-00185987-00186999": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00172-00187000-00187304": "right", "QLvK5duYtrk-00173-00187305-00189166": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00174-00189167-00189658": "good", "QLvK5duYtrk-00175-00189659-00190772": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00176-00190773-00190884": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00177-00190885-00191695": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00178-00191696-00191821": "my", "QLvK5duYtrk-00179-00191822-00193380": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00180-00193381-00194003": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00181-00194004-00194688": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00182-00194689-00195333": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00183-00195334-00195883": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00184-00195884-00196494": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00185-00196495-00197207": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00186-00197208-00197432": "what's up", "QLvK5duYtrk-00187-00197433-00198386": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00188-00198387-00199423": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00189-00199424-00200061": "hello", "QLvK5duYtrk-00190-00200062-00201022": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00191-00201023-00202496": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00192-00202497-00203178": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00193-00203179-00203887": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00194-00203888-00204463": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00195-00204464-00205623": "yo", "QLvK5duYtrk-00196-00205623-00206119": "foreign", "QLvK5duYtrk-00197-00206119-00206580": "i'm", "QLvK5duYtrk-00198-00206581-00207887": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00199-00207888-00208006": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00200-00208007-00208130": "foreign", "QLvK5duYtrk-00201-00208131-00209712": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00202-00209713-00210551": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00203-00210552-00210742": "is", "QLvK5duYtrk-00204-00210742-00211571": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00205-00211571-00212159": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00206-00212160-00213111": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00207-00213112-00214503": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00208-00214504-00215142": "is", "QLvK5duYtrk-00209-00215144-00215985": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00210-00215986-00216784": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00211-00216785-00217671": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00212-00217671-00218496": "is", "QLvK5duYtrk-00213-00218498-00219006": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00214-00219007-00219248": "oh", "QLvK5duYtrk-00215-00219250-00219806": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00216-00219807-00220365": "wow wow", "QLvK5duYtrk-00217-00220366-00221356": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00218-00221357-00221710": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00219-00221711-00222016": "foreign", "QLvK5duYtrk-00220-00222017-00223542": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00221-00223544-00224129": "anymore", "QLvK5duYtrk-00222-00224130-00225111": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00223-00225112-00227646": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00224-00227648-00227815": "what's your name", "QLvK5duYtrk-00225-00227816-00228921": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00226-00228923-00230091": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00227-00230092-00230198": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00228-00230200-00230641": "foreign", "QLvK5duYtrk-00229-00230642-00232296": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00230-00232296-00233232": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00231-00233233-00233567": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00232-00233567-00234341": "wow", "QLvK5duYtrk-00233-00234342-00235942": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00234-00235944-00236991": "is", "QLvK5duYtrk-00235-00236992-00238004": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00236-00238005-00240191": "[Laughter]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00237-00240192-00242027": "wow", "QLvK5duYtrk-00238-00242028-00243660": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00239-00243661-00246513": "[Laughter]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00240-00246514-00247209": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00241-00247210-00249087": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00242-00249088-00249376": "nice", "QLvK5duYtrk-00243-00249377-00250238": "[Applause]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00244-00250239-00251010": "[Music]", "QLvK5duYtrk-00245-00251011-00251269": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "QLwCRuo4bDY", "text": {"QLwCRuo4bDY-00000-00000000-00000375": "[Music]", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00001-00000376-00000591": "norman didn't do it", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00002-00000592-00000686": "yes", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00003-00000687-00000823": "he did", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00004-00000824-00001623": "by ryan t higgins", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00005-00001623-00001918": "norman was a porcupine", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00006-00001919-00002310": "norman's best friend was mildred", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00007-00002311-00002679": "mildred was a tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00008-00002680-00002942": "norman and mildred did everything", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00009-00002943-00003110": "together", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00010-00003111-00003254": "strike one", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00011-00003255-00003463": "bounce", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00012-00003464-00003735": "chip", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00013-00003736-00004022": "you're right mildred it is a little", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00014-00004023-00004295": "yellow-bellied sap sucker", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00015-00004296-00004670": "guy love playing tree together", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00016-00004671-00005111": "hey you win", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00017-00005112-00005343": "norman was happy with the way things", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00018-00005344-00005535": "were", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00019-00005536-00005911": "okay one more chapter then it's lights", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00020-00005912-00006079": "out mildred", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00021-00006080-00006279": "norman and mildred", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00022-00006280-00006583": "mildred and norman", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00023-00006584-00006710": "just", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00024-00006711-00007134": "the two of them", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00025-00007136-00007255": "until", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00026-00007256-00007466": "one day", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00027-00007467-00007742": "[Music]", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00028-00007743-00008046": "there was someone else", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00029-00008047-00008351": "and who is that", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00030-00008352-00008942": "it was another tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00031-00008943-00009055": "suddenly", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00032-00009056-00009471": "it was no longer just norman and mildred", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00033-00009472-00009799": "now it was norman and mildred", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00034-00009800-00010071": "and the other tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00035-00010072-00010399": "this did not sit well", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00036-00010400-00010687": "with norman", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00037-00010688-00010919": "norman began to worry", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00038-00010920-00011110": "what if the other tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00039-00011111-00011414": "wanted to be friends with mildred", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00040-00011415-00011599": "what if mildred", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00041-00011600-00011863": "liked the other tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00042-00011864-00012238": "what if mildred liked the other tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00043-00012239-00012902": "more than she liked norman", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00044-00012903-00013046": "norman kept", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00045-00013047-00013383": "a careful eye on the other tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00046-00013384-00013558": "whoosh", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00047-00013559-00013799": "he watched as mildred and the other tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00048-00013800-00014055": "grew closer", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00049-00014056-00014279": "bounce bounce", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00050-00014280-00014758": "and closer", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00051-00014759-00014958": "thigh", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00052-00014959-00015175": "and closer", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00053-00015176-00015436": "you're playing tree without me", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00054-00015437-00015558": "[Music]", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00055-00015559-00015919": "life wasn't the same", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00056-00015919-00016358": "fine you win", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00057-00016359-00016486": "then", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00058-00016487-00016664": "it happened", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00059-00016665-00016903": "[Music]", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00060-00016904-00017135": "the worst thing", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00061-00017136-00017327": "possible", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00062-00017328-00017511": "touch", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00063-00017512-00017830": "mildred and the other tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00064-00017831-00018214": "grew too close together", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00065-00018215-00018486": "it was the last straw", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00066-00018487-00018822": "this is the last straw", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00067-00018823-00019007": "even though in this case there were no", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00068-00019008-00019343": "straws just branches", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00069-00019344-00019622": "norman could not lose his best friend", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00070-00019623-00019935": "not to the other tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00071-00019936-00020367": "something had to be done", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00072-00020368-00020543": "norman planned", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00073-00020544-00020735": "and he planned", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00074-00020736-00021486": "until his plan was just right", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00075-00021487-00021791": "then under the cover of night", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00076-00021792-00021919": "norman", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00077-00021920-00022199": "dug up the other tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00078-00022200-00022350": "and took it", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00079-00022351-00022493": "far away", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00080-00022494-00022694": "[Music]", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00081-00022695-00022783": "very", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00082-00022784-00023145": "far away", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00083-00023146-00023303": "[Music]", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00084-00023304-00023455": "very", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00085-00023456-00023575": "very", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00086-00023576-00024350": "far away", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00087-00024351-00024630": "to a place where the other tree would", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00088-00024631-00024927": "never come between norman and mildred", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00089-00024928-00025222": "ever again", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00090-00025223-00025439": "and just like that", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00091-00025440-00025646": "the other tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00092-00025647-00026022": "was gone", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00093-00026023-00026374": "norman and mildred were back together", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00094-00026375-00026687": "just the two of them", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00095-00026688-00026974": "but it wasn't the same", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00096-00026975-00027511": "other tree what other tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00097-00027512-00027870": "that other tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00098-00027872-00028031": "guy you don't know what happened to the", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00099-00028032-00028414": "other tree i didn't do anything maybe it", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00100-00028416-00028743": "went on vacation maybe it moved", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00101-00028744-00028958": "how should i know", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00102-00028960-00029214": "there there mildred", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00103-00029216-00029783": "you still have me", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00104-00029783-00030046": "soon norman started to think about", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00105-00030047-00030190": "mildred", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00106-00030191-00030439": "without her new friend", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00107-00030439-00030662": "norman started to think about", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00108-00030663-00030846": "the other tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00109-00030847-00031095": "all alone out there", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00110-00031095-00031311": "norman started to think", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00111-00031312-00031502": "about himself", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00112-00031503-00031774": "and what he did", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00113-00031775-00031951": "what if", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00114-00031952-00032246": "someone had seen him", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00115-00032247-00032527": "let's think there was the moon there", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00116-00032527-00032815": "were the stars there was the grass", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00117-00032816-00032975": "and the trees", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00118-00032976-00033190": "[Music]", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00119-00033191-00033511": "oh no the trees what if they saw me what", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00120-00033512-00033687": "if one tree tells another tree who tells", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00121-00033688-00033935": "another tree who tells another tree who", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00122-00033936-00034295": "tells mildred what am i going to do", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00123-00034296-00034655": "what have i done", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00124-00034656-00034895": "[Music]", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00125-00034896-00035015": "what if", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00126-00035016-00035207": "digging up your friend's friend in the", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00127-00035208-00035399": "middle of the night and taking that", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00128-00035400-00035727": "friend very very far away", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00129-00035728-00035967": "was not the right thing to do", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00130-00035968-00036118": "what if", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00131-00036119-00036455": "it was the wrong thing to do", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00132-00036456-00036790": "stop staring at me mildred", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00133-00036791-00036990": "tripp", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00134-00036991-00037159": "thud", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00135-00037160-00037527": "norman had hit rock bottom", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00136-00037528-00037655": "i", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00137-00037656-00037983": "have hit rock", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00138-00037984-00038471": "something had to be done", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00139-00038472-00038830": "norman planned and he planned", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00140-00038831-00038879": "again", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00141-00038880-00039079": "[Music]", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00142-00039080-00039207": "then", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00143-00039208-00039479": "he went back", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00144-00039480-00039671": "to where he had left", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00145-00039672-00039786": "the other tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00146-00039787-00040367": "[Music]", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00147-00040368-00040862": "to try and undo what he had done", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00148-00040863-00040951": "yes", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00149-00040952-00041351": "you're right i went a little overboard", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00150-00041352-00041590": "but in my defense you were touching", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00151-00041591-00041693": "branches", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00152-00041694-00042102": "[Music]", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00153-00042103-00042318": "norman knew life was going to be", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00154-00042319-00042471": "different", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00155-00042472-00042943": "look who's back mildred", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00156-00042944-00043079": "and that", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00157-00043080-00043479": "was okay", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00158-00043480-00043758": "he might even like it", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00159-00043759-00043879": "norman", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00160-00043880-00044046": "and mildred", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00161-00044047-00044630": "and the other tree", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00162-00044631-00044774": "just", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00163-00044775-00045301": "the three of them", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00164-00045302-00046374": "[Music]", "QLwCRuo4bDY-00165-00046375-00046796": "and who is that"}}, {"audio_id": "QLe8iz4QJy8", "text": {"QLe8iz4QJy8-00000-00000076-00000750": "[Music]", "QLe8iz4QJy8-00001-00000751-00001073": "garlic tapa is here thank you so much", "QLe8iz4QJy8-00002-00001074-00001518": "it's a very yummy", "QLe8iz4QJy8-00003-00001519-00001925": "it's a yummy in here", "QLe8iz4QJy8-00004-00001926-00002171": "this one is tapa", "QLe8iz4QJy8-00005-00002172-00002465": "yeah", "QLe8iz4QJy8-00006-00002466-00002758": "onions", "QLe8iz4QJy8-00007-00002759-00003263": "yummy", "QLe8iz4QJy8-00008-00003264-00003515": "it's a very nice", "QLe8iz4QJy8-00009-00003515-00003856": "guys", "QLe8iz4QJy8-00010-00003857-00004169": "yeah let's try this", "QLe8iz4QJy8-00011-00004170-00004758": "is", "QLe8iz4QJy8-00012-00004759-00005117": "[Music]", "QLe8iz4QJy8-00013-00005118-00005953": "again", "QLe8iz4QJy8-00014-00005954-00006172": "[Music]", "QLe8iz4QJy8-00015-00006173-00006523": "yummy yummy"}}, {"audio_id": "QLR67Sdxen0", "text": {"QLR67Sdxen0-00000-00000234-00000557": "my apron flower has finally grown it was", "QLR67Sdxen0-00001-00000558-00001175": "all thanks to trimmick it for helping me", "QLR67Sdxen0-00002-00001176-00002593": "my apron flowers", "QLR67Sdxen0-00003-00002594-00002800": "[Applause]", "QLR67Sdxen0-00004-00002801-00004936": "[Music]", "QLR67Sdxen0-00005-00004937-00006580": "thank you", "QLR67Sdxen0-00006-00006581-00006814": "[Music]", "QLR67Sdxen0-00007-00006815-00007492": "my apron flowers", "QLR67Sdxen0-00008-00007493-00009660": "foreign", "QLR67Sdxen0-00009-00009661-00009971": "flower has finally grown it was all", "QLR67Sdxen0-00010-00009972-00010583": "thanks to tremica for helping me", "QLR67Sdxen0-00011-00010584-00010895": "my apron flower has finally grown it was", "QLR67Sdxen0-00012-00010896-00011285": "all things to make it for helping me", "QLR67Sdxen0-00013-00011286-00011542": "ABS media demo", "QLR67Sdxen0-00014-00011543-00012602": "all right", "QLR67Sdxen0-00015-00012603-00013397": "[Music]", "QLR67Sdxen0-00016-00013397-00013715": "my apron flower has finally grown it was", "QLR67Sdxen0-00017-00013716-00014453": "all thanks to terrific for helping me", "QLR67Sdxen0-00018-00014454-00014575": "foreign", "QLR67Sdxen0-00019-00014576-00015152": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "QLVpRLooutE", "text": {"QLVpRLooutE-00000-00000014-00000383": "Ayer Illinois flight 710 crashed due to", "QLVpRLooutE-00001-00000384-00000644": "an electrical problem near Pinckneyville", "QLVpRLooutE-00002-00000645-00000994": "Illinois all 10 passengers and crew were", "QLVpRLooutE-00003-00000996-00001657": "killed in the accident", "QLVpRLooutE-00004-00001659-00001911": "topic accident sequence", "QLVpRLooutE-00005-00001912-00002292": "[Music]", "QLVpRLooutE-00006-00002293-00002530": "the flight flew from Chicago to", "QLVpRLooutE-00007-00002531-00002784": "Springfield Illinois uneventful II but", "QLVpRLooutE-00008-00002785-00002965": "when it touched down at Springfield", "QLVpRLooutE-00009-00002966-00003220": "Airport the flight had been delayed by", "QLVpRLooutE-00010-00003221-00003667": "45 minutes at 20:20 local time the", "QLVpRLooutE-00011-00003668-00003921": "aircraft took off from Springfield", "QLVpRLooutE-00012-00003922-00004291": "roughly 1.5 minutes after takeoff the", "QLVpRLooutE-00013-00004292-00004516": "crew reported a slight electrical", "QLVpRLooutE-00014-00004517-00004707": "problem and would keep air traffic", "QLVpRLooutE-00015-00004708-00005179": "control advised the NTSB concluded that", "QLVpRLooutE-00016-00005180-00005379": "the first officer then mistakenly", "QLVpRLooutE-00017-00005380-00005656": "isolated the right generator instead of", "QLVpRLooutE-00018-00005657-00005884": "the left as the right generator had a", "QLVpRLooutE-00019-00005885-00006253": "history of maintenance issues 12 minutes", "QLVpRLooutE-00020-00006254-00006541": "after takeoff the first officer reported", "QLVpRLooutE-00021-00006542-00006745": "to the captain that the left generator", "QLVpRLooutE-00022-00006745-00006967": "was totally dead and that the right", "QLVpRLooutE-00023-00006968-00007216": "generator was producing voltage but", "QLVpRLooutE-00024-00007217-00007555": "wouldn't stay on line roughly 20 minutes", "QLVpRLooutE-00025-00007556-00007809": "after takeoff the crew shut off excess", "QLVpRLooutE-00026-00007811-00008041": "lights in the cabin that had failed to", "QLVpRLooutE-00027-00008042-00008308": "reduce overall electrical load on the", "QLVpRLooutE-00028-00008309-00008605": "aircraft's battery ultimately the", "QLVpRLooutE-00029-00008606-00008869": "battery was depleted resulting in the", "QLVpRLooutE-00030-00008870-00009034": "failure of the aircraft's flight", "QLVpRLooutE-00031-00009035-00009264": "instruments and communication and", "QLVpRLooutE-00032-00009265-00009735": "navigation radios at 2052 the captain", "QLVpRLooutE-00033-00009736-00010105": "decided to descend to 2,400 feet from", "QLVpRLooutE-00034-00010106-00010356": "there the aircraft slowly descended into", "QLVpRLooutE-00035-00010357-00010666": "a hilly pasture area as the copilot used", "QLVpRLooutE-00036-00010667-00010891": "a flashlight to determine the location", "QLVpRLooutE-00037-00010892-00011209": "of the plane the crew may have attempted", "QLVpRLooutE-00038-00011210-00011458": "a forced landing before the aircraft", "QLVpRLooutE-00039-00011459-00011748": "crashed or a disoriented pilot mistook", "QLVpRLooutE-00040-00011749-00011983": "strip lighting at a mindful approach", "QLVpRLooutE-00041-00011984-00012339": "lights at Carbondale Airport all 10:00", "QLVpRLooutE-00042-00012340-00012591": "on board perished the aircraft was heard", "QLVpRLooutE-00043-00012592-00012904": "by mr. John Fisher and his wife circling", "QLVpRLooutE-00044-00012905-00013272": "over the property a couple of times mrs.", "QLVpRLooutE-00045-00013274-00013483": "Fisher said that it had been raining", "QLVpRLooutE-00046-00013484-00013813": "pretty hard at the time of impact she", "QLVpRLooutE-00047-00013813-00014104": "also said the aircraft circled two times", "QLVpRLooutE-00048-00014105-00014440": "it made a lot more noise the second time", "QLVpRLooutE-00049-00014441-00014686": "I ran to the back porch", "QLVpRLooutE-00050-00014687-00014994": "I saw one flash and heard a lot of noise", "QLVpRLooutE-00051-00014994-00015358": "John and I could smell gas and fuel the", "QLVpRLooutE-00052-00015359-00015622": "flash was reported to have been a brief", "QLVpRLooutE-00053-00015622-00015676": "flash", "QLVpRLooutE-00054-00015677-00015891": "fire from the spewing fuel and no", "QLVpRLooutE-00055-00015893-00016249": "explosion had taken place the various", "QLVpRLooutE-00056-00016250-00016432": "victims were strewn across a", "QLVpRLooutE-00057-00016433-00016710": "quarter-mile radius of the crash site", "QLVpRLooutE-00058-00016711-00017029": "the largest recoverable section of the", "QLVpRLooutE-00059-00017030-00017296": "aircraft was the baggage compartment and", "QLVpRLooutE-00060-00017297-00017602": "the landing gear wheel section cap", "QLVpRLooutE-00061-00017603-00017895": "captain foe first officer depp", "QLVpRLooutE-00062-00017896-00018301": "springfield departure control KCC kansas", "QLVpRLooutE-00063-00018302-00019005": "city control at cabin attendant", "QLVpRLooutE-00064-00019006-00019608": "topic investigation", "QLVpRLooutE-00065-00019609-00019903": "accident investigators determined the", "QLVpRLooutE-00066-00019904-00020172": "probable cause to be the captain's", "QLVpRLooutE-00067-00020173-00020439": "decision to continue the flight toward", "QLVpRLooutE-00068-00020440-00020697": "the more distant destination Airport", "QLVpRLooutE-00069-00020698-00021061": "after the loss of d.c electrical power", "QLVpRLooutE-00070-00021062-00021394": "from both aircraft generators instead of", "QLVpRLooutE-00071-00021395-00021636": "returning to the nearby departure", "QLVpRLooutE-00072-00021637-00021978": "Airport the captain's decision was", "QLVpRLooutE-00073-00021979-00022296": "adversely affected by self-imposed", "QLVpRLooutE-00074-00022297-00022561": "psychological factors which led him to", "QLVpRLooutE-00075-00022562-00022828": "assess inadequately the aircraft's", "QLVpRLooutE-00076-00022829-00023080": "battery endurance after the loss of", "QLVpRLooutE-00077-00023081-00023368": "generator power and the magnitude of the", "QLVpRLooutE-00078-00023369-00023617": "risks involved in continuing to the", "QLVpRLooutE-00079-00023618-00024006": "destination Airport contributing to the", "QLVpRLooutE-00080-00024007-00024264": "accident was the airline management's", "QLVpRLooutE-00081-00024265-00024592": "failure to provide and the FAA sale yer", "QLVpRLooutE-00082-00024593-00024880": "to assure an adequate company recurrent", "QLVpRLooutE-00083-00024881-00025117": "flight crew training program which", "QLVpRLooutE-00084-00025118-00025399": "contributed to the captain's inability", "QLVpRLooutE-00085-00025400-00025683": "to assess properly the battery endurance", "QLVpRLooutE-00086-00025685-00025930": "of the aircraft before making the", "QLVpRLooutE-00087-00025931-00026184": "decision to continue and led to the", "QLVpRLooutE-00088-00026185-00026404": "inability of the captain and the first", "QLVpRLooutE-00089-00026405-00026710": "officer to cope promptly and correctly", "QLVpRLooutE-00090-00026711-00026923": "with the aircraft's electrical", "QLVpRLooutE-00091-00026924-00027373": "malfunction the investigation revealed", "QLVpRLooutE-00092-00027374-00027708": "the captain considered an average pilot", "QLVpRLooutE-00093-00027709-00028120": "was a one-man operation and did not", "QLVpRLooutE-00094-00028120-00028371": "welcome input from the copilot and was", "QLVpRLooutE-00095-00028372-00028660": "in a hurry to return to Carbondale after", "QLVpRLooutE-00096-00028661-00029011": "being on duty all day the report said", "QLVpRLooutE-00097-00029012-00029251": "the captain had a habit of violating", "QLVpRLooutE-00098-00029252-00029533": "safety regulations in order to arrive on", "QLVpRLooutE-00099-00029533-00029848": "time even disabling safety devices in", "QLVpRLooutE-00100-00029849-00030067": "order to over speed the aircraft", "QLVpRLooutE-00101-00030068-00030339": "one investigator Patricia a Goldman", "QLVpRLooutE-00102-00030340-00030642": "filed a concurring dissenting statement", "QLVpRLooutE-00103-00030643-00030933": "while the accident report correctly", "QLVpRLooutE-00104-00030934-00031168": "identifies training and surveillance I", "QLVpRLooutE-00105-00031169-00031452": "believe that inclusion of these items in", "QLVpRLooutE-00106-00031453-00031683": "the probable cause statement obscures", "QLVpRLooutE-00107-00031684-00031930": "and detracts from the basic reason the", "QLVpRLooutE-00108-00031931-00032145": "accident occurred and the attendant", "QLVpRLooutE-00109-00032147-00032458": "safety lesson the pilot should never", "QLVpRLooutE-00110-00032458-00032632": "have continued the flight to the", "QLVpRLooutE-00111-00032633-00032839": "destination Airport but should have", "QLVpRLooutE-00112-00032840-00032986": "returned to the nearby", "QLVpRLooutE-00113-00032987-00033310": "Airport on realizing that electrical d.c", "QLVpRLooutE-00114-00033311-00033646": "power had been lost", "QLVpRLooutE-00115-00033647-00034009": "equals equals notes"}}, {"audio_id": "QLXuYwP-3u8", "text": {"QLXuYwP-3u8-00000-00000058-00000332": "patriarchy Theophilus - redirects here", "QLXuYwP-3u8-00001-00000333-00000586": "it can also refer to Theophilus - of", "QLXuYwP-3u8-00002-00000587-00000928": "jerusalem ruled 14 17 to 14 24", "QLXuYwP-3u8-00003-00000930-00001160": "Theophilus served as greek patriarch of", "QLXuYwP-3u8-00004-00001161-00001439": "alexandria between 1010 and 1020 doing", "QLXuYwP-3u8-00005-00001440-00001625": "the persecution of the Christians under", "QLXuYwP-3u8-00006-00001626-00002100": "the Fatimid caliph al Hakim", "QLXuYwP-3u8-00007-00002101-00002622": "topic references", "QLXuYwP-3u8-00008-00002623-00003122": "topic thia Philo's to 1010 to 1020 a", "QLXuYwP-3u8-00009-00003123-00003383": "fish alweather the greek orthodox", "QLXuYwP-3u8-00010-00003384-00003609": "patriarchate of alexandria and all", "QLXuYwP-3u8-00011-00003610-00003854": "africa retrieved the 7th of February", "QLXuYwP-3u8-00012-00003856-00004149": "2011"}}, {"audio_id": "QLYpEXMFeK8", "text": {"QLYpEXMFeK8-00000-00001003-00001375": "doctors and healers today we realize", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00001-00001376-00001547": "health is becoming more and more", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00002-00001548-00001829": "precious to us more and more we", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00003-00001830-00001997": "experience the need in a medical a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00004-00001998-00002258": "healing service we hear all kinds of", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00005-00002259-00002491": "feedback of different treatments in heal", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00006-00002492-00002789": "but what is right for us what is better", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00007-00002790-00003109": "or worse it is not easy answer these", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00008-00003110-00003356": "questions to ascend you have created a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00009-00003357-00003565": "unique video project reality show", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00010-00003567-00003947": "doctors news watch carefully have your", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00011-00003947-00004322": "own conclusions see you is right for you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00012-00004323-00004658": "it was not show involves real people", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00013-00004659-00004897": "real healers from numerologists to an", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00014-00004898-00007418": "acupuncturist", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00015-00007419-00007709": "hello Jamie my name's Gary please Tim", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00016-00007711-00008307": "it's nice to meet you have a seat I work", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00017-00008308-00008655": "with an energy I you can call it lie", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00018-00008656-00008895": "trees or energy readings but I work with", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00019-00008896-00009111": "the holy spirit the the the highest", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00020-00009112-00009333": "level I can so whatever we're going to", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00021-00009334-00009507": "do is all these for the highest good", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00022-00009508-00009879": "okay so i keep my ego out of it and i", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00023-00009880-00010056": "work with you you're your own your own", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00024-00010057-00010353": "spirit to my spirit and I see what comes", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00025-00010354-00010560": "forward for you for your highest good", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00026-00010561-00010871": "and I'm always surprised myself so it's", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00027-00010872-00011099": "good because I keep out of the way so we", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00028-00011100-00011316": "can begin and then I'll see how we move", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00029-00011317-00011487": "around I could be sitting down it can be", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00030-00011488-00011658": "standing up but then i may ask you a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00031-00011659-00011895": "question i mean that but feel free to be", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00032-00011896-00012069": "at ease and we'll see what goes on i'm", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00033-00012070-00012309": "gonna call the light first okay so i go", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00034-00012310-00012582": "father mother God we ask him to lighter", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00035-00012583-00012805": "the holy spirit to be with us today with", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00036-00012806-00013190": "myself and your name Jane Jane and Gary", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00037-00013191-00013434": "so that whatever comes forward is going", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00038-00013435-00013596": "to be for our highest good it would be", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00039-00013597-00013758": "physically emotionally mentally or", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00040-00013759-00014028": "spiritually and we only ask for the", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00041-00014029-00014301": "support of the highest levels possible", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00042-00014302-00014547": "for the highest good Sofia ok so may I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00043-00014547-00014871": "have this hand here mm-hmm thank you put", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00044-00014872-00015180": "over here so this is just a focus point", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00045-00015181-00015347": "I know but we need the whole ahem but", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00046-00015349-00015633": "helping focus and then see what the", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00047-00015634-00015807": "energy comes for it i may move around a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00048-00015808-00016374": "little bit ok so let's see so spirit", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00049-00016375-00016619": "saying to me Jane you're a bright spirit", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00050-00016620-00016917": "well we know that right bright light and", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00051-00016918-00017103": "wherever you go you can bring that light", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00052-00017104-00017268": "to help other people you know that right", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00053-00017269-00017430": "sometimes you are sometimes you have a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00054-00017431-00017658": "community for people you don't know why", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00055-00017659-00018023": "because that's that light you're right", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00056-00018024-00018234": "sometimes you can be a little hard on", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00057-00018235-00018372": "yourself so I want you to be a little", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00058-00018373-00018577": "easier yourself you know you care about", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00059-00018578-00018814": "people right but also it's important to", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00060-00018815-00019053": "occur by yourself so gentle be gentle", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00061-00019054-00019417": "gentle as gently as gentle be okay says", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00062-00019418-00020164": "lkv gent with your son", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00063-00020165-00020405": "says you're moving in a new direction", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00064-00020406-00020778": "okay where you're kind of moving it is", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00065-00020779-00020902": "kind of training a little bit anything", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00066-00020903-00021061": "you've got to be open to it though okay", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00067-00021062-00021283": "so while you is it okay to be open to", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00068-00021284-00021558": "new directions do you like change I mean", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00069-00021559-00021802": "I don't mind it okay good it doesn't", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00070-00021803-00022027": "mind either you have a great smile by", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00071-00022028-00022283": "the way okay thank you good so uh", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00072-00022284-00022539": "direction wise you know like you know", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00073-00022540-00022659": "has its way of giving you different", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00074-00022660-00022828": "opportunities but you have to cooperate", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00075-00022829-00023088": "with it some people complain but", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00076-00023089-00023612": "cooperate that's all you have to do", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00077-00023613-00023808": "energetically it says your Energy's", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00078-00023809-00024000": "pretty good but it can use a little", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00079-00024001-00024319": "another kind of little like a jump jump", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00080-00024320-00024469": "a little bit so do you mind if I do", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00081-00024470-00024711": "something yeah okay fit so hold on a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00082-00024712-00025257": "second let's see what we get", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00083-00025258-00025689": "hey expression it says here so be able", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00084-00025691-00026241": "to express yourself more freely okay", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00085-00026242-00026439": "and they interview the heart area is a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00086-00026439-00026714": "little teen way so you can clear that a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00087-00026716-00026954": "little bit to breathe in and breathe out", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00088-00026955-00027464": "let go give any limitations okay and", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00089-00027466-00027624": "bringing that loving energy to your", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00090-00027625-00028547": "heart okay you're very lovable person", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00091-00028548-00029227": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00092-00029227-00029618": "hope your eyes see that wasn't that was", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00093-00029619-00029900": "easy wasn't it yeah yeah so again for", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00094-00029901-00030047": "you I think the key one of the big", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00095-00030048-00030350": "cheese's receiving that loving that", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00096-00030351-00030662": "energy from people from spirit and then", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00097-00030663-00030895": "we'll as you receive energy bring it out", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00098-00030895-00031899": "into the great joyful person you are", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00099-00031900-00032088": "I'm kind of getting your in connection", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00100-00032089-00032256": "with your mother mm-hmm how's your", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00101-00032257-00032535": "cancer with your mom I mean it's glad I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00102-00032536-00032835": "sank gosh I just don't understand a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00103-00032836-00033066": "whole spiritual thing right yeah yeah", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00104-00033067-00033294": "well you know you know guys and her as", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00105-00033295-00033498": "well as you were right mm-hmm so even", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00106-00033499-00033678": "though she may not understand it you can", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00107-00033679-00033885": "always love her unconditionally you know", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00108-00033886-00034323": "it's your mom right okay doesn't mean", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00109-00034324-00034482": "you have to agree with everything but", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00110-00034483-00034782": "he's loving at a distance you but she", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00111-00034783-00035034": "thinks very highly of you mm-hmm okay", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00112-00035035-00035452": "she really cares quite a bit much", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00113-00035453-00035712": "there's some unfinished business that", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00114-00035713-00035949": "you need a complete if you want to you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00115-00035950-00036162": "know completing things helps your energy", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00116-00036163-00036312": "mm-hmm so if there's something hanging", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00117-00036313-00036498": "out there for you that you may leave a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00118-00036499-00036668": "cryptic rats maybe you might want to go", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00119-00036669-00036885": "what can I do to kind of either finish", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00120-00036886-00037043": "it up or say you know what it's done in", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00121-00037044-00037254": "my mind one of the two it'll help you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00122-00037255-00037649": "get more energy ok you have some gifts", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00123-00037650-00037995": "isn't that nice what was that great", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00124-00037996-00038427": "smile good do you smile enough yeah good", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00125-00038428-00038633": "and like that I like that good don't", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00126-00038634-00038933": "know that one of the gifts i'm picking", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00127-00038934-00039123": "up is you can see things ahead of time", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00128-00039124-00039393": "you can't have an intuition you but you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00129-00039394-00039558": "have to trust it mm-hmm sometimes you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00130-00039559-00039765": "don't you go yeah buddy but you trust", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00131-00039766-00039918": "your heart and if you move forward", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00132-00039919-00040146": "you'll kind of feel and lean into it and", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00133-00040147-00040473": "go yes or no okay and also about people", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00134-00040474-00040689": "you have a good intuition trusted also", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00135-00040690-00041012": "mm-hmm because some people may not be as", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00136-00041013-00041039": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00137-00041040-00041330": "likely as you are they may have other", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00138-00041331-00041586": "ideas but your ideas are trusting in", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00139-00041587-00041937": "here okay let's see patch like anything", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00140-00041938-00042329": "let's see for you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00141-00042330-00042615": "something about norway norwegian I don't", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00142-00042616-00042757": "know why that's coming up it would never", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00143-00042758-00042957": "thought of that but somehow in that area", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00144-00042958-00043176": "of ever been there no okay well it's", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00145-00043177-00043464": "something with the Nordic area okay", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00146-00043465-00043662": "Russia's little norik in some way and", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00147-00043663-00043998": "that quite for the deal so you were", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00148-00043999-00044220": "whatever the area was you were kind of", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00149-00044221-00044554": "like under the servant or subservient to", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00150-00044555-00044907": "people and you went with it but he", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00151-00044908-00045073": "didn't like it because you're a strong", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00152-00045074-00045387": "spirit ok so this lifetime there's", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00153-00045388-00045585": "anybody that tries to put you down or", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00154-00045586-00045921": "control you no way okay because your", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00155-00045922-00046212": "neck and allow that okay make sense yeah", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00156-00046213-00046748": "good good good let's see", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00157-00046749-00047183": "and it says speak freely is that ok", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00158-00047184-00047330": "speak do you always be freely to", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00159-00047331-00047579": "sometimes whole things but I try but not", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00160-00047580-00047833": "always ok looks ok you know give", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00161-00047834-00047990": "yourself permission say you know what I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00162-00047991-00048349": "could say what's on my mind my heart I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00163-00048350-00048515": "don't wanna hurt anybody but certainly I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00164-00048516-00049005": "want to be feeling feel free to speak ok", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00165-00049006-00049565": "we're coming to coldstone see any", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00166-00049566-00049777": "questions let me know on that if i can", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00167-00049778-00050417": "help you i will regard it says", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00168-00050418-00050624": "interesting spread has little humor says", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00169-00050625-00050887": "use it or lose it so in other words if", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00170-00050888-00051173": "you have some gifts or talents or", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00171-00051174-00051442": "expression use it unless it becomes", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00172-00051444-00051599": "dormant like a muscle unless you've", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00173-00051600-00051820": "exercised it ok do you know what area", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00174-00051821-00052010": "may be talking about that you might be", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00175-00052011-00052307": "where you can use it more I guess I'm", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00176-00052308-00052642": "still trying to find that out good so in", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00177-00052644-00052853": "other words when I not sure what", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00178-00052854-00053032": "direction to go I say hey god I can use", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00179-00053033-00053387": "some help here I'm open you ask and you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00180-00053388-00053651": "receive says in the Bible be asking you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00181-00053652-00053897": "shall receive so don't feel free you can", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00182-00053898-00054110": "either write it down and tear it up you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00183-00054111-00054251": "know sometimes our writer a red-letter", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00184-00054252-00054440": "the spirit of gotta say hey here's what", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00185-00054441-00054638": "I need I tear it up and I burn it then", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00186-00054639-00054947": "it's called Lenny go let it go okay but", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00187-00054948-00055085": "you everyone has the way of doing things", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00188-00055086-00055306": "some people call prayer some people call", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00189-00055307-00055594": "it meditation so if you're not sure say", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00190-00055595-00055792": "hey every morning I like I call the", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00191-00055794-00056029": "light god I call the like hey I can use", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00192-00056030-00056285": "some direction and you start moving it's", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00193-00056286-00056605": "kind of a partnership mm-hmm okay", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00194-00056607-00056873": "and its finality for this for this this", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00195-00056874-00056992": "is something else you need to know and", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00196-00056994-00057425": "co it says again you're a strong spirit", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00197-00057426-00057667": "your strength is in your gentle and", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00198-00057669-00057902": "you're loving this okay that's reader", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00199-00057903-00058121": "real strength is loving yourself no", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00200-00058122-00058436": "matter what okay and then helping other", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00201-00058437-00058685": "people gain the spirit of magnificent", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00202-00058686-00058940": "that they are what you do and more and", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00203-00058941-00059186": "more okay and services the highest form", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00204-00059187-00059366": "of consciousness on the planet so being", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00205-00059366-00059732": "of service to who you and others yeah", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00206-00059733-00060004": "and being open to Spirit of God also", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00207-00060005-00060314": "write together so yeah so we want to", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00208-00060315-00060626": "thank you spirit was very happy we're", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00209-00060627-00060940": "here today I'm happy you're here Jane", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00210-00060941-00061247": "and I just keep that joyful way about", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00211-00061248-00061616": "you and just be walking one step at a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00212-00061616-00061811": "time and it thinks will open up like the", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00213-00061812-00062123": "Red Sea for you with love and light okay", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00214-00062124-00062566": "god bless you thanks for me okay you're", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00215-00062567-00063413": "welcome hi how are you my name's Gary", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00216-00063414-00063674": "you are nice to meet you Natalie nice to", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00217-00063675-00064105": "meet you too have a seat [__] so Natalie", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00218-00064107-00064394": "my name is Gary as we said and what I do", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00219-00064395-00064879": "is I work with energy the light energy", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00220-00064880-00065198": "healing work with the spirit okay I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00221-00065199-00065357": "always try to work at the highest level", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00222-00065358-00065573": "i call it the Holy Spirit so whatever I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00223-00065574-00065768": "work with you and your spirit it's", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00224-00065769-00065951": "always for the highest good so I don't", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00225-00065952-00066188": "get in the way ok so my egos out of the", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00226-00066189-00066410": "way here so whatever spirit tells me I'm", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00227-00066411-00066596": "trying to help you and your spirit to", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00228-00066597-00066809": "move into that higher level of", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00229-00066810-00067043": "consciousness loving for yourself okay", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00230-00067044-00067301": "so I'm always gonna be surprised with", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00231-00067302-00067538": "you okay you have a great smile that way", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00232-00067539-00067760": "okay so when I hand this hand to start", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00233-00067761-00068054": "out with okay man I'll put it here is", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00234-00068055-00068387": "that ok mm-hmm yes sir so I'll usually", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00235-00068388-00068585": "use the hand as I gotta focus point out", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00236-00068586-00068768": "with the energy but don't have to do", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00237-00068769-00068900": "that but we'll start with it okay", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00238-00068901-00069728": "so spear so let's see Natalie well says", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00239-00069729-00069956": "you're very uh you have a very", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00240-00069957-00070148": "cooperative spirit you like to cooperate", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00241-00070149-00070403": "with life which is great some people", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00242-00070404-00070733": "fight has to be my way Wow when it rains", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00243-00070734-00070931": "what do you do thank you an umbrella", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00244-00070932-00071189": "right right yeah you did what along", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00245-00071190-00071540": "great so cooperation is key in life for", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00246-00071541-00071738": "a lot of things okay you can't that", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00247-00071739-00072284": "ability okay I the spirit ask me say", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00248-00072285-00072494": "they want you to think more highly of", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00249-00072495-00072749": "yourself too I mean you're a wonderful", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00250-00072750-00073064": "spirit you know that right now you do", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00251-00073065-00073445": "know I more more so the reason people", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00252-00073446-00073685": "God put more than one person on the", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00253-00073686-00073868": "planets they can help each other see", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00254-00073869-00074051": "things then they may not be able to see", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00255-00074052-00074506": "themselves how can we help each other ok", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00256-00074507-00074894": "so love yourself no matter what no", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00257-00074895-00075089": "matter what goes on you can't lose with", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00258-00075090-00075398": "that one now why is that so important do", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00259-00075399-00075776": "you know why mmm I'm not sure maybe you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00260-00075777-00075986": "can tell okay well you'll probably do", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00261-00075987-00076148": "but loving yourself no matter what", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00262-00076149-00076460": "actually I was build you up so if you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00263-00076461-00076565": "have something you don't like about", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00264-00076566-00076733": "yourself for a judgment you know what", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00265-00076734-00076922": "doesn't help you does it just bring you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00266-00076923-00077207": "now so even if you're there's anger or", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00267-00077208-00077498": "judgment or a problem love it that'll", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00268-00077499-00077660": "always keep building the energy up for", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00269-00077661-00077942": "you you can't lose simple right they say", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00270-00077943-00078125": "in the Bible all the new testament god", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00271-00078126-00078566": "is love if that's true then the more you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00272-00078567-00078818": "love the more you're closer to what god", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00273-00078819-00079190": "ok mr. insect so", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00274-00079191-00079455": "it also says in the Bible become like a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00275-00079456-00079710": "child and enter the kingdom so when", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00276-00079711-00079914": "you're open like a child so we're like", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00277-00079915-00080253": "open right so be that openness of will", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00278-00080254-00080397": "help you bring that more loving for", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00279-00080398-00080925": "yourself see what else here well aren't", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00280-00080926-00081180": "we all have challenges right problem", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00281-00081181-00081426": "sometimes yeah sure we're human this is", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00282-00081427-00081900": "life like yeah so you know each problem", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00283-00081901-00082071": "that comes your way is really an", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00284-00082072-00082389": "opportunity to learn and grow so every", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00285-00082390-00082530": "time I ever probably go thank you for", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00286-00082531-00082797": "the blessing cut it may take me a day it", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00287-00082798-00082950": "may take me a few hours depends but", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00288-00082951-00083142": "thank you for the blessing because we", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00289-00083143-00083312": "don't always see that at the time right", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00290-00083313-00083526": "but if you can remember that everything", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00291-00083527-00083775": "is a blessing does that make sense yeah", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00292-00083776-00083976": "I think you're doing this and you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00293-00083977-00084213": "imagine my view that's what we're here", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00294-00084214-00084888": "right okay um how's your health I wish", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00295-00084889-00085074": "it could be little bit better okay let's", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00296-00085075-00085206": "see we can do here give you some", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00297-00085207-00085353": "information okay go on all this for", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00298-00085354-00085692": "singing see dude so some of its", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00299-00085693-00085899": "emotional whether it looks physical but", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00300-00085900-00086380": "some of this emotional hold on", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00301-00086381-00086687": "something around 10 years old something", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00302-00086688-00086810": "happened and most should you remember", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00303-00086811-00087119": "that far back 10 which is affecting you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00304-00087120-00087429": "now you know what it may be I know what", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00305-00087430-00087710": "if you share a little bit a little bit", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00306-00087711-00087974": "little okay but it's personal it's", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00307-00087975-00088151": "personal but you know what I'm talking", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00308-00088152-00088385": "about yes okay so here's your key right", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00309-00088386-00088637": "Gia's forget put your hand by your heart", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00310-00088638-00088860": "go ahead break there listen yeah that's", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00311-00088861-00089099": "right they say I forgive myself go ahead", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00312-00089100-00089385": "I forgive listen for not knowing what to", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00313-00089386-00089666": "do well not knowing what to do for being", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00314-00089667-00089954": "upset or angry or disappointed home", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00315-00089955-00090198": "being upset or angry or disappointed and", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00316-00090199-00090392": "I forgive the other situation or person", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00317-00090393-00090635": "as best I can and I forgive the", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00318-00090636-00090848": "situation or the person the best I can", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00319-00090849-00091023": "and here's the last piece I forgive", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00320-00091024-00091328": "myself I forgive myself for forgetting", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00321-00091329-00091659": "for what forgetting forgetting i am", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00322-00091660-00092054": "divine I am do I yes see so when you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00323-00092055-00092267": "remember that you your divine everything", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00324-00092268-00092648": "is easier to forgive okay okay good good", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00325-00092649-00093182": "si si love conquers all no matter what", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00326-00093183-00093398": "see when you're forgive inside yourself", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00327-00093399-00093621": "you're free which is the most important", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00328-00093622-00093901": "thing right", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00329-00093902-00094228": "forgiving yourself not tear your", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00330-00094229-00094547": "forgiving all other people probably", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00331-00094548-00094772": "cause you can't do that but of the key", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00332-00094773-00094994": "is I forgiveness over the judgment on", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00333-00094995-00095198": "the church judgment that I'm bad or you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00334-00095199-00095441": "can done better so any judgments get in", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00335-00095442-00095696": "the way of your loving yourself God", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00336-00095697-00095870": "doesn't judge you you know spirit", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00337-00095871-00096026": "doesn't judge you you judge yourself I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00338-00096027-00096278": "chased out so people loving yourself see", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00339-00096279-00096617": "very nice way to go champ thank you I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00340-00096618-00096899": "percentage of cake do this I'm not gonna", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00341-00096900-00097040": "touch it it's gonna put in my hand back", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00342-00097041-00097232": "there just you cook your handle no no", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00343-00097233-00097418": "you're just the energy in this gonna", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00344-00097419-00097544": "feel where there might be to the other", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00345-00097545-00098009": "blocks okay you can pretty beat one two", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00346-00098010-00098213": "three four five okay expression here", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00347-00098214-00098453": "another one for you expressing yourself", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00348-00098454-00098885": "as clearly as you can okay it's okay to", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00349-00098886-00099188": "speak your truth I can feel with a wolf", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00350-00099189-00099506": "yeah yeah throw a check the warmth sure", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00351-00099507-00099713": "that's like energy motivators and you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00352-00099714-00100006": "can hear that right yes very sensitive", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00353-00100007-00100415": "you're like a flower you know that can", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00354-00100416-00100747": "read it", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00355-00100748-00101205": "and take a deep breath and let go ah", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00356-00101206-00102118": "good job good job so key for you again", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00357-00102119-00102553": "reminder is keep warming yourself no", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00358-00102554-00102840": "matter what in the situation's let them", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00359-00102841-00103131": "go as best you can and as you do that", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00360-00103132-00103321": "you'll gain more wisdom you know", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00361-00103322-00103844": "discerning and learning like you know", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00362-00103845-00104181": "and it's okay to speak clearly your", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00363-00104182-00104548": "truth is ok say no it's ok to say yes ok", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00364-00104549-00104713": "to say what you want to say whatever you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00365-00104714-00105033": "do ensure it's your life please yourself", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00366-00105034-00105658": "ok it's ok to please your soon good so", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00367-00105658-00106059": "am i okay so say it out loud I it's okay", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00368-00106060-00106294": "for me to please myself go ahead it's ok", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00369-00106295-00106515": "with me to please myself how's that feel", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00370-00106516-00107173": "great really Russian uh oh my goodness", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00371-00107174-00107602": "great ok i learned i work a while back a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00372-00107603-00107806": "word called lublu Zach I'm center", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00373-00107807-00108003": "creating equity means i love you write", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00374-00108004-00108400": "something like that so great good so in", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00375-00108401-00108933": "conclusion a good energy you're learning", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00376-00108934-00109278": "to or trust more trust yourself trust", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00377-00109279-00109696": "light and there's no ending till your", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00378-00109697-00109939": "road the road keeps expanding as you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00379-00109940-00110166": "expand and the way you expand is staying", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00380-00110167-00110466": "open like a child right I mean loving", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00381-00110467-00110713": "loving at all loving the situations that", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00382-00110714-00110979": "you can part the Red Sea so to speak and", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00383-00110980-00111247": "you can move through it love so you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00384-00111248-00111457": "never go wrong by loving at all ever", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00385-00111458-00111703": "okay that's that's the magic wand for", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00386-00111704-00111982": "you okay and standing tall in your", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00387-00111983-00112254": "spirit so the Spirit says you know you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00388-00112255-00112458": "were you have a strength like a tree", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00389-00112458-00112613": "okay", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00390-00112614-00112790": "and if you just kind of open your arms", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00391-00112791-00113054": "like the branches life will come to you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00392-00113055-00113273": "and give you what you need then thanks", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00393-00113274-00113438": "for being a wonderful special spirit god", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00394-00113439-00113897": "bless you okay we're done thank you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00395-00113898-00114794": "thank you baby oh so are you here the", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00396-00114795-00115064": "two sessions that we just work with with", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00397-00115065-00115394": "Jane and Natalia and its similarity in", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00398-00115395-00115607": "many ways and yet some uniqueness the", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00399-00115608-00115775": "similarity is what they both need to", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00400-00115776-00115979": "keep loving themselves in greater ways", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00401-00115980-00116372": "and emphasize thank you for them they", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00402-00116373-00116617": "have different energies different paths", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00403-00116618-00116948": "but they all seem to be open to the", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00404-00116949-00117227": "ideas of spur thinking forward so the", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00405-00117228-00117523": "work I do is really the work of spirit", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00406-00117524-00117953": "my main intention is to listen to what", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00407-00117954-00118186": "the inner spirit says to their inner", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00408-00118188-00118499": "spirit and give guidance that will help", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00409-00118500-00118694": "them in their life move forward in a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00410-00118695-00118967": "positive productive way I keep my ego", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00411-00118968-00119185": "out of the way and i don't i don't know", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00412-00119186-00119399": "i don't say i know what goes on i just", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00413-00119400-00119654": "opened and listening and i trust that", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00414-00119655-00119852": "the spirit has the best answers for them", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00415-00119853-00120182": "i also try to work with the hands either", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00416-00120183-00120392": "the hand or the energy around them", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00417-00120393-00120647": "whatever comes forward that would be of", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00418-00120648-00120989": "use to these clients so they like to be", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00419-00120990-00121232": "productive anyway I'm very thankful for", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00420-00121233-00121435": "the grace of spirit to work with me in", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00421-00121436-00121783": "my life and help others be better light", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00422-00121784-00122066": "workers and productive citizens and", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00423-00122067-00122243": "family members so we can all have a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00424-00122244-00122423": "better planet peace be with you god", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00425-00122424-00123239": "bless you school excellent", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00426-00123240-00123743": "i I'm the Jane nice to meet you a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00427-00123744-00124199": "message why is here today I have a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00428-00124200-00124478": "problem with my knee sometimes it hurts", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00429-00124479-00124829": "when I do some sports or when I go like", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00430-00124830-00125279": "downhill so I've been like doing some", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00431-00125280-00125540": "work you know like physical therapy and", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00432-00125541-00125831": "x-rays and members in spine but it just", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00433-00125832-00126061": "keeps bothering me and then I have pain", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00434-00126063-00126326": "in this finger over here and gained in", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00435-00126327-00126968": "too much but it hurts sometimes", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00436-00126969-00127495": "justice join ya", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00437-00127496-00128035": "where does it hurt most um when I lived", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00438-00128036-00128348": "some sykes mostly mm-hmm or when I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00439-00128349-00128540": "abandoned yeah when I lived sang so he's", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00440-00128541-00128785": "it hurting now no but it was herded like", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00441-00128786-00129446": "several hours before you know like", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00442-00129447-00129809": "how long did hedid donned a nice like", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00443-00129810-00130085": "almost like [__] of the monster sure", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00444-00130086-00130551": "he did come and go oh yeah comes and", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00445-00130552-00130794": "goes but then when I looked inside like", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00446-00130795-00131128": "it's alright it's always it where is it", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00447-00131129-00131204": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00448-00131205-00131565": "I always think it's um I'm not really", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00449-00131566-00131829": "sure I think it's on the sides here but", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00450-00131830-00132045": "it's like the whole me know the Syrian", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00451-00132046-00132291": "starts but more different setting I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00452-00132292-00132693": "think it's a frontier friend lateral and", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00453-00132694-00133011": "medial sit here and here yes it's kind", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00454-00133012-00133227": "of hard because it only happens when I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00455-00133228-00133590": "ski or when I go downhill it means now", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00456-00133591-00133917": "you cannot just do the certain movement", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00457-00133918-00134256": "that would make it hooked no not really", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00458-00134257-00134493": "i think when i bend it a stir in wait", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00459-00134494-00134814": "like I wasn't it now I mean it does i", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00460-00134815-00135054": "think it's when I do like when I did", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00461-00135055-00135327": "specifically arup user or some exercises", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00462-00135328-00135546": "they made me doing that I could fill it", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00463-00135547-00135735": "but it's not even pains of pain is", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00464-00135736-00136014": "usually its attention one I when I do", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00465-00136015-00136209": "something when I ski for several hours", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00466-00136210-00136491": "and then it starts to her is it the same", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00467-00136492-00136785": "playing both sides like even here when", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00468-00136786-00137130": "it hurts it is insane I think it as it's", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00469-00137131-00137343": "like [__] machines are already you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00470-00137344-00137637": "know like now I don't I know what you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00471-00137638-00137942": "should do more his heart", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00472-00137943-00138131": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00473-00138132-00138471": "okay they said some muscles on both", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00474-00138472-00138687": "sides of singing are not strong enough", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00475-00138688-00138921": "and that's what it makes like a puppy", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00476-00138922-00139314": "when you blow on the table with anything", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00477-00139315-00139956": "else any eggs a kadai clinic waiting not", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00478-00139957-00140394": "really really just finger yeah is it any", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00479-00140395-00140670": "numbness do you feel any numbness or", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00480-00140671-00141000": "just plain just okay Mia is it worse", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00481-00141001-00141282": "when you when you put something warm oh", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00482-00141283-00141609": "it's worse than busy cold I don't think", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00483-00141610-00142023": "it matters you know you may be okay you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00484-00142024-00142425": "you don't know yeah I don't try to put", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00485-00142426-00142758": "an innocent comment so but maybe just a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00486-00142759-00143649": "hot shower no okay this if you could", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00487-00143650-00143933": "fool Europeans just take yourselves off", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00488-00143934-00144363": "and show full of your browser I could", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00489-00144364-00145149": "reach just the right one yes but that", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00490-00145150-00145404": "one also just any home again", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00491-00145405-00147399": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00492-00147400-00147744": "so good yes a little bit quiet a little", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00493-00147745-00148083": "bit huh yeah this is good if it's not", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00494-00148084-00148434": "tight isn't all of the turkey even with", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00495-00148435-00148812": "you just can't they just wanna get if", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00496-00148813-00150902": "you could have you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00497-00150903-00153527": "I will be some units for the oxidation I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00498-00153528-00153841": "will pop it a little bit of great uni", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00499-00153842-00154427": "touch", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00500-00154428-00154713": "I'm it's like hard to tell me you don't", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00501-00154714-00155535": "feel anything nothing no no baby I'm", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00502-00155536-00156493": "dollars simon yo gave notice site okay", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00503-00156494-00157252": "yeah I come over right here and here", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00504-00157253-00157613": "just want to just okay it's mostly as", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00505-00157614-00157982": "this site could you bend it we will see", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00506-00157983-00158219": "it happens just bend it is it for so is", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00507-00158220-00158840": "better come yeah I mean I don't feel", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00508-00158841-00159017": "anything right now but I know what I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00509-00159018-00159361": "found it like I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00510-00159362-00160077": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00511-00160078-00160976": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00512-00160977-00161637": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00513-00161638-00162046": "Michael um I will book with someone's", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00514-00162047-00162378": "here we will frighten to form his", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00515-00162379-00162486": "attention", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00516-00162487-00164909": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00517-00164910-00165174": "zeljko is a mirror of your knee that's", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00518-00165175-00165546": "why I local food they eat it around your", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00519-00165547-00166553": "elbow just just the same it hurts a", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00520-00166554-00167271": "little right here Hamid ok see you yeah", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00521-00167272-00168744": "I don't leave until", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00522-00168745-00169575": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00523-00169576-00169797": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00524-00169798-00172164": "there's a lot of dollars", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00525-00172165-00172886": "Gemma", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00526-00172887-00175602": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00527-00175603-00176150": "you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00528-00176151-00177654": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00529-00177655-00179587": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00530-00179588-00180146": "you do it yeah not not so much nah mean", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00531-00180147-00180521": "i'll try i wasn't sure i will not hurt", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00532-00180522-00182586": "you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00533-00182587-00183414": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00534-00183415-00184516": "patek needles for relaxation let me know", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00535-00184517-00184682": "if it's not comfortable should be", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00536-00184683-00185776": "comfortable okay huh ok now could you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00537-00185777-00186248": "please our band the read a couple of", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00538-00186249-00187046": "times do feel anything like pain no pain", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00539-00187047-00187842": "and I Beatrice I'm uncomfortable hello", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00540-00187843-00190526": "looking back", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00541-00190527-00191475": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00542-00191476-00192639": "okay now been any better yeah Young is", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00543-00192640-00193000": "it easy to bend it yeah because i always", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00544-00193001-00193201": "get some fennel and comfortable telling", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00545-00193202-00193534": "when it goes no um it's much better", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00546-00193535-00193987": "young any discomfort still it long I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00547-00193988-00194242": "think it's just because of the Middle's", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00548-00194243-00194649": "I feel like you know yeah moving mm-hmm", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00549-00194650-00194953": "because even when I do yoga I can fill", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00550-00194954-00196287": "out some tight you know Vietnam no", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00551-00196288-00196989": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00552-00196990-00197845": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00553-00197846-00197874": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00554-00197875-00201148": "I can take it up uh-uh bracelets", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00555-00201149-00201550": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00556-00201551-00202444": "okay okay Hugo stay visa needles muso", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00557-00202445-00202897": "jamias oh come I comfortable I relax me", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00558-00202898-00203422": "happy okay okay don't need a blanket I", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00559-00203423-00203611": "have a special blanket to cover your", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00560-00203612-00204592": "chilly out maybe i will check on you and", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00561-00204593-00205032": "I believe in a couple of times", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00562-00205033-00205708": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00563-00205709-00206181": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00564-00206182-00206557": "yeah yeah now it's fine yeah they always", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00565-00206558-00206880": "feel like there's something there", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00566-00206881-00210613": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00567-00210614-00210819": "[Music]", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00568-00210821-00210928": "you", "QLYpEXMFeK8-00569-00210929-00211305": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "QMv2D4ug7X4", "text": {"QMv2D4ug7X4-00000-00000000-00000254": "I want to welcome everyone to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00001-00000254-00000428": "cooper-hewitt Smithsonian Design Museum", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00002-00000429-00000716": "I am Andrea Lips associate curator of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00003-00000717-00001043": "contemporary design and we are excited", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00004-00001044-00001256": "to spend a bit of time together tonight", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00005-00001257-00001616": "to dig into public design and art", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00006-00001617-00001960": "installations with our esteemed guests", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00007-00001961-00002275": "and as I mentioned we're doing this", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00008-00002276-00002459": "within a tight timeframe so I'm going to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00009-00002460-00002699": "keep us as our moderator and our host", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00010-00002700-00003179": "very punctual but I do just want to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00011-00003180-00003479": "start out and say that cooper-hewitt was", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00012-00003479-00003674": "the curatorial partner for this year's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00013-00003675-00003940": "Times Square Valentine heart competition", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00014-00003942-00004147": "which is organized by Time Square arts", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00015-00004148-00004420": "and so our partnership and Times", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00016-00004421-00004733": "Square's competition was the impetus for", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00017-00004734-00004997": "tonight's conversation to celebrate and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00018-00004998-00005393": "to probe the process and the importance", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00019-00005394-00005618": "of public design installations within", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00020-00005619-00005888": "our cities so following a brief", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00021-00005889-00006179": "introduction our speakers will provide a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00022-00006180-00006478": "succinct presentation of their work on", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00023-00006479-00006728": "public design and art installations and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00024-00006729-00007094": "then they will join me back on stage for", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00025-00007095-00007439": "a conversation so to introduce our", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00026-00007440-00007789": "speakers tonight the designers of the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00027-00007790-00008017": "Times Square heart installation I am", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00028-00008018-00008255": "pleased to welcome Jean Cooney director", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00029-00008256-00009146": "of Times Square arts to the stage thank", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00030-00009147-00009392": "you it's nice to be here", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00031-00009393-00009631": "so I'm Jean Cooney director of Times", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00032-00009632-00009853": "Square arts I oversee the public art", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00033-00009854-00010163": "program in Times Square and so as Andrea", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00034-00010164-00010409": "mentioned every well for 12 years", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00035-00010410-00010646": "running now we've hosted this valentine", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00036-00010647-00010871": "heart design competition and it's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00037-00010872-00011056": "intended for the city's emerging and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00038-00011057-00011310": "mid-career architects and designers", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00039-00011311-00011539": "first and foremost to have a chance to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00040-00011540-00011738": "take on something that hopefully is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00041-00011739-00011969": "freeing from the constraints that's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00042-00011970-00012217": "conventional to their field but also to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00043-00012218-00012455": "imagine a symbol of love for New York", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00044-00012456-00012854": "City and so while we're you know more or", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00045-00012855-00013108": "less experts on Times Square we're by no", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00046-00013109-00013305": "means experts on design and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00047-00013306-00013446": "sure if you've visited Times Square", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00048-00013447-00013808": "lately could use a little design work", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00049-00013809-00014213": "but you know so in that sense the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00050-00014215-00014463": "success of this competition does very", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00051-00014463-00014658": "much depend on the vision and the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00052-00014659-00014891": "expertise of our partner so we're very", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00053-00014893-00015036": "grateful to be working with", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00054-00015037-00015233": "cooper-hewitt I want to specifically", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00055-00015234-00015585": "thank Andrea if anyone has not gotten a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00056-00015586-00015777": "tour from Andrea here on any topic", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00057-00015778-00016146": "please get that and I also want to thank", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00058-00016147-00016578": "Ruth Starr Pam horn Kym Robledo diga and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00059-00016579-00017010": "Alexa Griffith and this year we were", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00060-00017011-00017255": "also very lucky to be working with modu", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00061-00017256-00017450": "and Eric Foreman the designers behind", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00062-00017451-00017907": "Hart squared we were very excited to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00063-00017908-00018161": "receive what we feel is a delightful", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00064-00018162-00018471": "expansive accessible inclusive vision", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00065-00018472-00018696": "for what love could look like in Times", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00066-00018697-00018935": "Square so I'll briefly introduce you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00067-00018936-00019242": "with your esteemed BIOS and then I'll", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00068-00019243-00019397": "turn the stage over to you all to have", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00069-00019398-00019532": "this conversation", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00070-00019533-00020067": "so fou Wong Andra hailey Rotem founded", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00071-00020068-00020322": "their architecture practice modu in 2012", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00072-00020323-00020606": "they were awarded the esteemed founders", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00073-00020607-00020883": "Rome prize in architecture in 2017", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00074-00020884-00021080": "followed by the us-japan creative", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00075-00021081-00021411": "artists fellowship from the NEA in 2018", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00076-00021412-00021855": "and the emerging voices award from the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00077-00021856-00022065": "architectural League of New York in 2019", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00078-00022066-00022278": "in addition to their award-winning", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00079-00022279-00022446": "practice they teach at Columbia's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00080-00022447-00022622": "Graduate School of Architecture and at", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00081-00022623-00022812": "Rhode Island School of Design and they", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00082-00022813-00023043": "both received a master's of architecture", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00083-00023044-00023427": "from Columbia University Eric Foreman is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00084-00023428-00023628": "an artist and designer working at the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00085-00023629-00023830": "intersections of fine art design", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00086-00023831-00024117": "architecture and new technology he have", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00087-00024118-00024356": "founded he founded his eponymous Eric", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00088-00024357-00024705": "Foreman studio in 2003 and in 2012 was a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00089-00024706-00024959": "founding member of the really fantastic", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00090-00024960-00025205": "new lab at the Brooklyn Navy Yard in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00091-00025206-00025362": "addition to developing interactive", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00092-00025363-00025452": "experiences", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00093-00025453-00025617": "Eric is head of innovation at the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00094-00025618-00026000": "interaction design MFA program at SVA he", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00095-00026001-00026277": "received his master's in 2002 from NYU's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00096-00026277-00026507": "interactive telecommunications program", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00097-00026508-00026737": "so I hope you enjoy the conversation", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00098-00026738-00027865": "tonight good evening thank you for the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00099-00027866-00028142": "introduction thank you Time Square arts", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00100-00028143-00028460": "and cooper-hewitt for this and the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00101-00028461-00028696": "experience of building something in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00102-00028697-00028927": "Times Square which is doesn't happen", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00103-00028928-00029060": "every day and I spent so many hours", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00104-00029061-00029371": "there also not expected murder is an", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00105-00029372-00029639": "architecture and design firm based in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00106-00029639-00029882": "Brooklyn if we talk about there behind", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00107-00029883-00030101": "us the scene behind the scene is us", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00108-00030102-00030374": "communicating and this is made by a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00109-00030375-00030689": "catalogue of terms that represent", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00110-00030689-00030868": "different ideas they're usually", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00111-00030869-00031058": "contradiction because we kind of think", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00112-00031058-00031301": "of different differently on every", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00113-00031302-00031877": "possible issue so outdoor room indoor", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00114-00031877-00032221": "urbanism what else your open", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00115-00032222-00032414": "architecture all these things that blur", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00116-00032414-00032649": "inside and outside and question what is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00117-00032650-00032896": "private and what is public and who is it", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00118-00032897-00033418": "who is it for I was born in Israel flew", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00119-00033419-00033793": "in Saigon Vietnam which means that will", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00120-00033794-00033949": "not only speak a different language from", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00121-00033950-00034133": "right to left enough to write we also", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00122-00034134-00034517": "think that way so it's a logic therefore", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00123-00034518-00034811": "those terms actually are have multi", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00124-00034812-00035135": "directions one of them that you can read", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00125-00035136-00035486": "below actually represent both objective", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00126-00035487-00035911": "way of thinking but also super personal", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00127-00035912-00036179": "way of thinking about these terms or", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00128-00036180-00036361": "they are both subjective and highly", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00129-00036362-00036743": "personal we think of it as a disruptive", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00130-00036744-00036911": "language that artificial intelligent", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00131-00036912-00037189": "will never be able to truly understand", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00132-00037190-00037402": "cloud seeding our first project for", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00133-00037403-00037811": "today is invited competition we in Tel", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00134-00037812-00038140": "Aviv we were invited to try to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00135-00038141-00038429": "revitalize a huge square in front of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00136-00038430-00038714": "this amazing museum by vana rod which is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00137-00038715-00038926": "actually unused and if you have been in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00138-00038927-00039151": "that area in the Middle East you would", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00139-00039152-00039437": "know that extremely hard very reflect", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00140-00039438-00039656": "we're very reflective and basically", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00141-00039657-00039826": "there is no shade in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00142-00039827-00040132": "in that square so we propose a shade", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00143-00040133-00040414": "structure made of 30,000 balls from", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00144-00040415-00040732": "three different sizes basically raised", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00145-00040733-00041056": "landscape on top of green roof structure", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00146-00041057-00041452": "which is both local and global okay so", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00147-00041453-00041749": "the idea is that basically to create", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00148-00041750-00042088": "shade that is not only based on the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00149-00042089-00042295": "movement of the Sun and the changing of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00150-00042296-00042526": "that movement but actually shaded is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00151-00042527-00042792": "based on the breeze connecting to the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00152-00042793-00043192": "environment the local environment which", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00153-00043193-00043411": "basically kind of flashed the city of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00154-00043412-00043704": "breeze coming from the Mediterranean Sea", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00155-00043705-00043960": "creating this landscape of multiple", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00156-00043961-00044344": "endless possibilities and scenarios of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00157-00044345-00044548": "how every time you would go to this site", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00158-00044549-00044794": "you would basically experience a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00159-00044795-00045121": "different weather for us these ideas to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00160-00045122-00045349": "create connection and a sense of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00161-00045350-00045565": "belonging to a place through connecting", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00162-00045566-00045718": "to something bigger than you which is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00163-00045719-00045982": "the environment and social interactions", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00164-00045983-00046312": "as architect we always try to determine", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00165-00046313-00046519": "what's gonna be underneath what program", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00166-00046520-00046843": "but who actually owns this space is it", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00167-00046844-00047064": "the public is the museum who funded it", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00168-00047065-00047548": "can it be a room in the city is it a bed", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00169-00047549-00047800": "or is it a lounge and so on so for us", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00170-00047801-00048088": "actually to not create a program that is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00171-00048089-00048256": "too descriptive is something that we", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00172-00048257-00048597": "were kind of was very important for us", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00173-00048598-00048898": "and slowly through time you can see that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00174-00048899-00049096": "different things started to happen and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00175-00049097-00049306": "people incorporated this space as part", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00176-00049307-00049498": "of their daily routine which of course", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00177-00049499-00049777": "you know makes us really happy in that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00178-00049778-00049996": "sense architecture is never complete", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00179-00049997-00050176": "without the people who are engaging with", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00180-00050177-00050701": "it so yeah final kind of few images of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00181-00050702-00051013": "this kind of landscape floating", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00182-00051014-00051403": "landscape and luckily we didn't lose the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00183-00051404-00051727": "balls I'm sure it when the questions is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00184-00051728-00051922": "like how the balls didn't move but like", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00185-00051923-00052359": "a few details here reveal later", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00186-00052360-00052594": "so competitions are important to our", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00187-00052595-00052759": "practice because it allows us to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00188-00052760-00052992": "speculate but we also launched our own", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00189-00052994-00053142": "initiatives because they also allow", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00190-00053144-00053194": "suspect", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00191-00053195-00053452": "but it also allows us to to seek", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00192-00053453-00053674": "organizations that have the line with", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00193-00053675-00053875": "our particular core values especially", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00194-00053876-00054091": "what we call indoor urbanism which", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00195-00054091-00054262": "essentially is asking a question how can", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00196-00054263-00054415": "we live in cities better", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00197-00054416-00054625": "we need to redraw both our environmental", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00198-00054626-00054913": "and our social boundaries and cities can", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00199-00054914-00055072": "be simultaneously more connected and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00200-00055073-00055455": "more personal as Rome price fellows in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00201-00055457-00055663": "architecture at the American Academy in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00202-00055664-00055837": "Rome we researched 30 years of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00203-00055838-00056050": "incomplete architecture in Italy jumping", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00204-00056051-00056316": "fences crossing into these kinds of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00205-00056317-00056932": "incomplete buildings and the what we", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00206-00056933-00057229": "learned was that there was 600 of 600 of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00207-00057229-00057373": "these cities and towns that had", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00208-00057374-00057760": "incomplete structures the incomplete our", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00209-00057761-00057937": "modern ruins there found spaces urban", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00210-00057938-00058171": "leftovers without futures but there are", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00211-00058172-00058380": "space also spaces of indoor urbanism", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00212-00058382-00058629": "indoor outdoor for public engagement", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00213-00058629-00058876": "when we returned back to the US the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00214-00058877-00059055": "incomplete in Italy got translated into", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00215-00059057-00059275": "the abandon in the US focusing on", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00216-00059276-00059452": "post-industrial cities we're currently", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00217-00059453-00059665": "doing work in Newburgh New York which", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00218-00059666-00059932": "has a very large amount of vacant", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00219-00059933-00060325": "properties this is a using design to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00220-00060326-00060565": "mobilize it to reimagine these abandoned", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00221-00060566-00060829": "buildings as interim publics these are", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00222-00060829-00060946": "many buildings within buildings", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00223-00060947-00061165": "lightweight modular structures that are", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00224-00061166-00061648": "see to occupy larger buildings the line", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00225-00061649-00061866": "is a mini building that would be help", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00226-00061867-00062023": "for activities to grow from during the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00227-00062024-00062215": "spring summer and fall during the winter", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00228-00062216-00062575": "the trees are contracted because it's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00229-00062576-00062809": "passively heated for from solar hot", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00230-00062810-00063079": "water and essentially what we're saying", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00231-00063079-00063226": "is that they can be used by small", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00232-00063227-00063436": "businesses or Community Programs as a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00233-00063437-00063676": "bridge to permanent occupancy once that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00234-00063677-00063895": "occurs that the mini building can be", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00235-00063896-00064246": "dismantled and taken to another site so", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00236-00064247-00064441": "I'm gonna end with actually where we", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00237-00064441-00064621": "began this is a 10 year old project it", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00238-00064622-00064798": "was the first project that Hayley and I", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00239-00064799-00064992": "collaborated on together before we", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00240-00064994-00065434": "launched module it's it was for Art", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00241-00065435-00065644": "Basel Miami Beach and the Contemporary", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00242-00065645-00065920": "Art Fair we designed the project in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00243-00065921-00066055": "which performance artists could choose", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00244-00066056-00066235": "their own locations in the site without", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00245-00066236-00066504": "any formal stages it was a kind of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00246-00066505-00066816": "territory environment they combine urban", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00247-00066817-00067008": "design with environment with the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00248-00067009-00067416": "performers and with the audience it was", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00249-00067417-00067623": "had a series of rope towers we use seven", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00250-00067624-00067815": "miles of rope hung from steel structures", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00251-00067816-00068010": "rope was a great material cause it's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00252-00068011-00068184": "both sustainable but also moves with the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00253-00068185-00068496": "wind it was a two phase competition and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00254-00068497-00068703": "curated by the public arts foundation", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00255-00068704-00068946": "creative time and organized by Art Basel", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00256-00068947-00069159": "Miami Beach what we were designing is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00257-00069160-00069312": "basically the public face for the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00258-00069313-00069624": "private art fair the wind change with", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00259-00069625-00069936": "the environment and it each night was a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00260-00069937-00070104": "different experience sometimes gentle", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00261-00070105-00070332": "swaying and sometimes dynamic movement", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00262-00070333-00070602": "we use technology to basically calibrate", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00263-00070603-00070845": "the wind movement to the lighting", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00264-00070846-00071076": "basically connecting human senses to the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00265-00071077-00071481": "visual and as an ending image one", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00266-00071482-00071619": "important consideration for all these", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00267-00071620-00071889": "public installations is the afterlife as", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00268-00071890-00072120": "an environmental consideration so from", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00269-00072121-00072309": "the beginning we or we designed the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00270-00072310-00072489": "concrete footings so that they'd be", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00271-00072490-00072728": "conducive to coral reefs we had the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00272-00072729-00073140": "footings sank into the ocean we imagine", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00273-00073141-00073521": "the kind of growing RiRi reincarnation", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00274-00073522-00073740": "of our project and we worked on this", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00275-00073741-00073962": "project the collaboration was with a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00276-00073963-00074223": "marine biologist who helped us with this", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00277-00074224-00074457": "kind of first of this shrimp who is our", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00278-00074458-00074900": "first multi species audience thank you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00279-00074901-00075539": "[Applause]", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00280-00075540-00075825": "hello everyone and thanks for having me", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00281-00075826-00076050": "here it's so much fun to be getting to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00282-00076051-00076392": "share some work of my own and also to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00283-00076393-00076560": "share with you later about this really", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00284-00076561-00076821": "exciting collaboration with modo my", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00285-00076822-00077013": "studio practice usually revolves around", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00286-00077014-00077190": "a combination of fine art design and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00287-00077191-00077388": "technology I'm just going to show a few", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00288-00077389-00077691": "works that are distinctly public art and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00289-00077692-00077844": "ending with one that's on the boundary", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00290-00077845-00078096": "of public art and architecture this", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00291-00078097-00078294": "project from 2014 that's called radio", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00292-00078295-00078714": "scape is an array of old tripod some of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00293-00078715-00078846": "them 100 years old that were all", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00294-00078847-00079089": "discarded and then brought back to life", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00295-00079090-00079546": "by woodworkers meaning me by myself on", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00296-00079547-00079736": "top of these", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00297-00079737-00079988": "kind of discarded a form of Technology", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00298-00079989-00080246": "in a way our car radio antennas that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00299-00080247-00080492": "themselves were also thrown out FM", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00300-00080493-00080810": "radios are ubiquitous of were ubiquitous", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00301-00080811-00081011": "at one point hardly use it all anymore", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00302-00081012-00081218": "as listening has become a more atomized", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00303-00081219-00081509": "experience it used to be collective most", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00304-00081510-00081737": "people now have headphones iPods iPhones", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00305-00081738-00082010": "etc and this work that was in a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00306-00082011-00082160": "sculpture park in Minnesota which is a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00307-00082161-00082385": "rural area that does not have a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00308-00082386-00082544": "population that's usually exposed to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00309-00082545-00082811": "public art got a chance to and gets a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00310-00082812-00083009": "chance with this park being open", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00311-00083010-00083321": "year-round for free the chance to see", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00312-00083322-00083519": "things they might not normally see so", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00313-00083520-00083684": "this particular installation has a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00314-00083685-00083873": "kinetic component it's like it's a type", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00315-00083874-00084086": "of kinetic sculpture all of these", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00316-00084087-00084226": "antennas are the type that used to go up", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00317-00084227-00084392": "and down by themselves when you turn the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00318-00084393-00084607": "car radio on that kids may not remember", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00319-00084608-00084941": "but the older ones here do so there were", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00320-00084942-00085139": "sensors at the bottom of each of these", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00321-00085140-00085349": "tripods that detected when people walked", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00322-00085350-00085532": "in around and through this sculpture and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00323-00085533-00085718": "the antennas would go up in response to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00324-00085719-00085991": "this motion so you could hear the sound", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00325-00085992-00086201": "of the motors you could walk around", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00326-00086202-00086417": "freely as you liked but it was a quite a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00327-00086418-00086780": "mysterious type of feeling it wasn't", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00328-00086781-00087011": "intended to be and I don't think public", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00329-00087012-00087341": "art needs to be super user-friendly or", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00330-00087342-00087641": "super clear especially when you have a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00331-00087642-00087776": "population that usually doesn't", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00332-00087777-00087956": "encounter art like these bikers were", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00333-00087957-00088214": "some of my biggest fans by walking", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00334-00088215-00088349": "around and first giving them something", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00335-00088350-00088535": "that has a kinetic element that draws", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00336-00088536-00088721": "your attention in and then perhaps if", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00337-00088722-00088922": "you spend more time looking at it you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00338-00088923-00089069": "start figuring out it's responding to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00339-00089070-00089294": "you are they watching you are they", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00340-00089295-00089407": "listening to you maybe they're", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00341-00089408-00089696": "broadcasting to each other it's for some", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00342-00089697-00089879": "people a little eerie and uncanny for", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00343-00089880-00090104": "other people it's fun but I think having", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00344-00090105-00090290": "those layers of experience in public art", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00345-00090291-00090446": "and in my own art practice is really", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00346-00090447-00090650": "important something that draws people in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00347-00090651-00091046": "at first and then something that they", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00348-00091047-00091211": "can figure out more of if they spend", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00349-00091212-00091378": "more time of so a second level of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00350-00091379-00091649": "engagement and reward and then maybe a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00351-00091650-00091849": "third level they think more these are", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00352-00091850-00092099": "obsolete technologies in some sense", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00353-00092100-00092288": "tripods are only used by camera", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00354-00092289-00092447": "professionals now soon they might not be", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00355-00092448-00092723": "needed at all car that kid doesn't get", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00356-00092724-00092902": "better than that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00357-00092903-00093123": "and if you look at it for", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00358-00093124-00093363": "longer than that you might also start", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00359-00093364-00093597": "thinking about how technology is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00360-00093598-00093776": "shifting what we do with obsolete", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00361-00093777-00094011": "technologies and how they can be", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00362-00094012-00094188": "recombined and repurposed into something", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00363-00094189-00094350": "that's sort of alien or perhaps has a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00364-00094351-00094599": "second life and like this guy for", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00365-00094600-00094763": "example who was watching for long enough", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00366-00094764-00095001": "started to realize eventually that the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00367-00095002-00095217": "antennas after they were all triggered", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00368-00095218-00095409": "to go up by his movement would then go", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00369-00095410-00095598": "down in the order that he had walked", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00370-00095599-00095813": "through them so you'll see one of the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00371-00095814-00095985": "antennas on the right starts to go down", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00372-00095986-00096563": "and he notices that this is a totally", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00373-00096564-00096797": "different type of piece this is from", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00374-00096798-00097101": "2004 originally this is the the oldest", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00375-00097102-00097344": "piece of public art that I directly", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00376-00097345-00097572": "created it was recreated about 10 years", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00377-00097573-00097744": "later in Montreal this is another", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00378-00097745-00098016": "instance where people walking by at", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00379-00098017-00098235": "first had no idea what it was as is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00380-00098236-00098448": "often the case of public art so this was", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00381-00098449-00098628": "a kind of quasi ritual that I would ask", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00382-00098629-00098894": "strangers to engage in for people would", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00383-00098895-00099063": "stand in a circle and marks on the on", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00384-00099064-00099251": "the ground and take turns looking at", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00385-00099252-00099309": "each other", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00386-00099310-00099687": "for exactly 60 seconds each with no", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00387-00099688-00100221": "talking allowed after 60 seconds a bell", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00388-00100222-00100443": "would ring and the viewer who's the guy", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00389-00100444-00100613": "with the band on his forehead would then", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00390-00100614-00100923": "look at the next person meanwhile the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00391-00100924-00101081": "point of view of the viewers being", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00392-00101082-00101265": "projected behind him on a screen he's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00393-00101266-00101403": "actually wearing a tiny surveillance", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00394-00101404-00101655": "camera on his head so part of it is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00395-00101656-00101862": "about human connection and these cycles", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00396-00101863-00102101": "of first self-consciousness nervousness", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00397-00102102-00102409": "awkwardness that eventually give way to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00398-00102410-00102648": "something that's more open perhaps", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00399-00102649-00102816": "everyone engaged with a different way", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00400-00102817-00103014": "also time passes very differently when", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00401-00103015-00103181": "you're staring at somebody so I would", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00402-00103182-00103304": "interview people afterwards", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00403-00103305-00103544": "how long did 60 seconds feel to you for", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00404-00103545-00103839": "some people felt like 10 minutes but", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00405-00103840-00104100": "also whenever there's a video image and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00406-00104101-00104241": "that was the other layer the piece of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00407-00104242-00104397": "people had more time to think about it", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00408-00104398-00104708": "we're so entranced by a video image that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00409-00104709-00104889": "I was also checking and the performance", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00410-00104890-00105033": "was about were people looking at the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00411-00105033-00105153": "viewer or were they looking at the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00412-00105154-00105357": "person being viewed or we're looking at", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00413-00105358-00105588": "what the viewer saw even though they", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00414-00105589-00105710": "could see the person right in front of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00415-00105711-00105876": "them and many people would stare at the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00416-00105877-00106010": "screen even though the person was right", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00417-00106011-00106125": "there", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00418-00106126-00106229": "but one of the amazing things about", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00419-00106230-00106391": "public art and this piece was having", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00420-00106392-00106483": "people who normally", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00421-00106483-00106665": "encounter her at all don't encounter", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00422-00106666-00106815": "each other at all like this girl and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00423-00106816-00107044": "these guys here starting to open up with", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00424-00107045-00107277": "each other and share a moment that they", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00425-00107278-00107616": "might normally not have had and this", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00426-00107617-00107821": "last project is a more recent piece I", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00427-00107822-00108033": "had the amazing opportunity to work on a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00428-00108034-00108210": "tiny island in the Arctic Circle in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00429-00108211-00108461": "Norway it really does look like this", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00430-00108463-00108690": "this has been a fishing community for", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00431-00108691-00108936": "thousands of years and it's incredibly", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00432-00108938-00109099": "beautiful but there is some crumbling", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00433-00109100-00109399": "and derelict architecture there so this", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00434-00109400-00109771": "is a participatory design process where", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00435-00109772-00109975": "we involve the community this is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00436-00109976-00110131": "basically everyone who lives in the town", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00437-00110132-00110374": "so we were invited to come and make", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00438-00110375-00110553": "something new out of an unused space but", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00439-00110554-00110776": "rather than drop in as artists we", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00440-00110777-00111058": "thought and knew you have to involve the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00441-00111058-00111333": "local population so we had students from", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00442-00111334-00111510": "three different countries presenting two", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00443-00111511-00111757": "panels of locals and locals themselves", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00444-00111758-00111931": "contributing their ideas about what they", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00445-00111932-00112224": "needed then getting everyone together to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00446-00112225-00112450": "volunteer together to do the physical", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00447-00112451-00112608": "labor themselves we turned an outdoor", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00448-00112609-00112965": "space into a kind of public shared space", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00449-00112966-00113166": "because they didn't have very many here", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00450-00113167-00113439": "we did the unglamorous labour with them", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00451-00113440-00113727": "refinishing buildings are falling apart", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00452-00113728-00114049": "and we ended up making an outdoor space", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00453-00114050-00114325": "where people could gather on this island", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00454-00114326-00114504": "there were only two places to gather", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00455-00114505-00114903": "there was a bar and a cafe that was only", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00456-00114904-00115329": "open for three hours a week so in the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00457-00115330-00115672": "winter especially it's dark it's in the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00458-00115673-00115870": "Arctic Circle so it's dark for sometimes", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00459-00115871-00116068": "three months at a time so they would", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00460-00116069-00116374": "never go outside so although there was", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00461-00116375-00116535": "this very user friendly and obvious", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00462-00116536-00116818": "layer of the this kind of like public", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00463-00116819-00116964": "gathering space with a BBQ and whatever", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00464-00116965-00117135": "we also wanted to create something a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00465-00117136-00117349": "little bit weirder more artsy so to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00466-00117350-00117595": "speak on the inside that they can engage", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00467-00117596-00117729": "with in the winter during the dark", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00468-00117730-00117901": "months so they went inside the building", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00469-00117902-00118128": "there's a mysterious door with a yellow", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00470-00118129-00118375": "circle on it and inside there we made", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00471-00118376-00118716": "this intense light sauna so you're using", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00472-00118717-00118983": "full spectrum light and crazy yellow", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00473-00118984-00119211": "saturated walls and it was just a place", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00474-00119213-00119395": "for people to hang out in the winter to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00475-00119396-00119668": "be warm but also to reset their", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00476-00119669-00119831": "physiological", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00477-00119832-00120136": "systems because you know people can we", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00478-00120138-00120325": "know even in New York in the winter you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00479-00120326-00120541": "can get so-called sad seasonal affective", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00480-00120542-00120695": "disorder from being too dark too long so", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00481-00120696-00120850": "being three months in the dark you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00482-00120851-00121114": "really do need that kind of light so", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00483-00121115-00121274": "like all public art the best part is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00484-00121275-00121435": "when people start to use it these are", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00485-00121436-00121622": "people hanging out at the outdoor space", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00486-00121623-00121858": "and these are people hanging out in the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00487-00121859-00122099": "indoor space just talking and feeling", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00488-00122100-00122399": "artificial sunlight on them and that's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00489-00122400-00122549": "really the best part of all public art", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00490-00122550-00122776": "is seeing the unexpected ways and the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00491-00122777-00122914": "ways that people become open with each", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00492-00122915-00122976": "other", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00493-00122977-00124165": "thank you is this on yeah great thanks", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00494-00124166-00124424": "and to keep us honest I'm keeping my", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00495-00124425-00124694": "phone here only for looking at the time", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00496-00124695-00124924": "I am NOT checking my texts or anything", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00497-00124925-00125437": "so thanks to all of you for you know", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00498-00125438-00125677": "just providing us with a bit of shared", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00499-00125678-00125849": "language around your own studio", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00500-00125850-00126293": "practices and how public design and art", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00501-00126294-00126473": "installations have played within those I", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00502-00126474-00126613": "mean one thing which is interesting is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00503-00126614-00126850": "to look for a Holly and foo at your", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00504-00126851-00127129": "practice and you see so much so many of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00505-00127130-00127513": "these ideas and themes around you know", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00506-00127514-00127759": "almost like weather related or you know", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00507-00127760-00127984": "this responsiveness to thermal", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00508-00127985-00128185": "conditions in the environment as well as", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00509-00128186-00128500": "some interactivity playing out and then", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00510-00128501-00128734": "Eric and yours you know you really see", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00511-00128735-00128959": "these themes of almost an often this", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00512-00128960-00129139": "technologically enabled interactivity", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00513-00129140-00129344": "although in the last project in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00514-00129345-00129490": "particular I wasn't I was intrigued by", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00515-00129491-00129811": "kind of how both I that was which is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00516-00129812-00130121": "cool you know and I think what's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00517-00130122-00130249": "interesting about all of that though is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00518-00130250-00130549": "you see those themes collectively", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00519-00130550-00130890": "manifest within the time square project", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00520-00130891-00131285": "so really just to begin before we dive", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00521-00131286-00131554": "into Times Square entirely I just want", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00522-00131555-00131944": "to ask each of these teams here why are", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00523-00131945-00132253": "public design and art installations", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00524-00132254-00132497": "important in your practice overall", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00525-00132498-00132725": "because you each have partaken in them", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00526-00132726-00132928": "in your own ways so do you guys want to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00527-00132929-00133147": "start boo and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00528-00133148-00133330": "I mean I think for us it plays an", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00529-00133331-00133558": "important role of of building our", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00530-00133559-00133837": "research we as a practice we believe", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00531-00133838-00134095": "very much in research as a form of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00532-00134096-00134433": "design research so these installations", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00533-00134434-00134787": "because they are inherently temporary", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00534-00134788-00135139": "there are certain liberties that you can", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00535-00135140-00135511": "take in the process and we have a lot of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00536-00135512-00135706": "our ideas have come through not just", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00537-00135707-00135952": "designing them but experiencing them and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00538-00135953-00136141": "watching how people experience living", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00539-00136142-00136743": "space in a way it's a rebellion against", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00540-00136744-00137140": "how the profession became indoor right", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00541-00137141-00137590": "architecture is it's very clear", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00542-00137591-00137950": "boundaries of the wall and I just think", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00543-00137951-00138159": "that you want to design beyond the wall", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00544-00138160-00138502": "that you can connect to the city so it's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00545-00138503-00138739": "not about not just about architecture", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00546-00138740-00139048": "and landscape and urbanism and how you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00547-00139049-00139515": "build or in in psychology and in social", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00548-00139516-00139966": "sociology sociology in a way you want to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00549-00139967-00140232": "create this cross-disciplinary way of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00550-00140233-00140437": "experiencing the world but the hardest", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00551-00140438-00140647": "part of it well I thought it was really", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00552-00140648-00140779": "interesting to when you guys were", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00553-00140780-00141025": "talking who in particular you said it", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00554-00141026-00141324": "also allows you room to speculate and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00555-00141325-00141676": "why is that important as an architect", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00556-00141677-00141940": "and as a designer I think especially for", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00557-00141941-00142072": "architects because so much of our", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00558-00142073-00142237": "discipline is about providing solutions", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00559-00142238-00142453": "providing answers it's it's I think a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00560-00142454-00142780": "lot of our training is that and often", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00561-00142781-00143110": "it's not only about asking questions but", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00562-00143111-00143257": "knowing what is the right question to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00563-00143258-00143461": "ask so that I think that's the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00564-00143462-00144003": "importance of speculation questions", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00565-00144004-00144232": "solutions yeah I mean those drive then", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00566-00144233-00144496": "even better solutions ultimately I mean", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00567-00144497-00144709": "how about for you Eric I mean talk about", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00568-00144710-00144892": "public art installations overall in your", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00569-00144893-00145204": "practice you know yeah I think that it's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00570-00145205-00145531": "critical for any artist who's who works", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00571-00145532-00145753": "sometimes in a fine art context or a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00572-00145754-00145912": "gallery context and sometimes in a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00573-00145913-00146173": "public art context just to let people", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00574-00146174-00146458": "keep you honest and by honest I mean", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00575-00146459-00146527": "making", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00576-00146528-00146749": "that you are communicating an idea and a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00577-00146750-00147034": "feeling in a way that is can be shared", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00578-00147035-00147250": "and can be experienced by anybody", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00579-00147251-00147499": "without unnecessary obfuscation and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00580-00147500-00147718": "jargon on top of it it doesn't mean that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00581-00147719-00147970": "you need to you know simply oversimplify", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00582-00147971-00148156": "it you could still have complex ideas", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00583-00148157-00148444": "but in the rarefied gallery world it's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00584-00148445-00148687": "very easy to get lost in a dark", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00585-00148688-00148936": "exclusive tunnel you know so I think", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00586-00148937-00149179": "that when you when you make public art", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00587-00149180-00149434": "you seeing how people react to it you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00588-00149435-00149695": "really get to the heart of the purpose", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00589-00149696-00149875": "of art which is to communicate a feeling", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00590-00149876-00150072": "and an idea and to make people think and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00591-00150073-00150325": "it shouldn't just be for a tiny", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00592-00150326-00150634": "percentage well and also one thing that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00593-00150635-00150742": "you said which I thought was really", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00594-00150743-00150997": "interesting is that oftentimes when a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00595-00150998-00151348": "public comes upon a public art", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00596-00151349-00151558": "installation they have no idea what", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00597-00151559-00151747": "they're looking at or what's expected of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00598-00151748-00152008": "them you know so I mean just even that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00599-00152009-00152371": "immediate interaction is must be really", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00600-00152372-00152476": "interesting I mean for your own", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00601-00152477-00152713": "understanding and practice as well yeah", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00602-00152714-00152935": "definitely and and that's why I like the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00603-00152936-00153175": "combination of art and design meet the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00604-00153176-00153391": "both of those disciplines which are", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00605-00153392-00153547": "traditionally kind of separate have", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00606-00153548-00153730": "things that they're really good at and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00607-00153731-00153850": "one of the things that design is very", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00608-00153851-00154006": "good at an interaction design in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00609-00154007-00154234": "particular is looking very specifically", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00610-00154235-00154456": "and it was a very clear eyes at how", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00611-00154457-00154690": "people actually see and react to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00612-00154691-00154894": "something not how you wish they would as", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00613-00154895-00155101": "an artist or designer and the same goes", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00614-00155102-00155275": "for architecture of course you have to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00615-00155276-00155485": "see you design it it looks beautiful in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00616-00155486-00155665": "a model but then you have to watch what", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00617-00155666-00155836": "do people actually do and you need to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00618-00155837-00156285": "respond to that there's the real world", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00619-00156286-00156709": "so I want to talk a bit then about what", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00620-00156710-00157120": "brings us all here tonight and that of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00621-00157121-00157315": "course is the time square valentine", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00622-00157316-00157645": "heart design competition which you can", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00623-00157646-00157915": "all see now until Sunday it closes", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00624-00157916-00158284": "Sunday right it's crazy it's been up for", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00625-00158285-00158461": "days I know time flies it's been up for", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00626-00158462-00158695": "three weeks so you can go see it in the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00627-00158696-00158974": "heart of Times Square and and father", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00628-00158975-00159352": "Duffy Plaza so let's just even you know", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00629-00159353-00159493": "start from the beginning I mean how did", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00630-00159494-00159910": "the opportunity come to you guys", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00631-00159911-00160390": "we were invited by time scorer thank you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00632-00160391-00160690": "for you it to be a team that competes", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00633-00160691-00161077": "against others for us thinking about", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00634-00161078-00161332": "inclusivity that was kind of the word", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00635-00161333-00161649": "that caught our attention with the brief", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00636-00161650-00161893": "we thought that the process should be", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00637-00161894-00162416": "part of that kind of inclusive way of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00638-00162417-00162721": "practicing and we wanted to invite Eric", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00639-00162722-00163021": "Foreman to be part of it we worked", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00640-00163022-00163341": "before and we appreciate how he thinks", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00641-00163342-00163663": "about interactivity and doing public art", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00642-00163664-00163971": "I think the idea of combining multiple", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00643-00163972-00164389": "perspectives is extremely important in a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00644-00164390-00164691": "sense it enhanced democracy when you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00645-00164692-00164916": "allow for multiple voices to be heard in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00646-00164917-00165244": "the public sphere so for us it was very", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00647-00165245-00165528": "important to do it that way and we look", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00648-00165529-00165721": "at our fabricator new projects that are", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00649-00165722-00165966": "here and the structure engineer wherever", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00650-00165967-00166270": "we work with as a collaborator right in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00651-00166271-00166744": "in kind of making that can come to life", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00652-00166745-00166984": "right you know and the one thing to to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00653-00166985-00167212": "clarify is that this is not an open", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00654-00167213-00167511": "competition you know an open competition", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00655-00167512-00167959": "particularly in architecture is most of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00656-00167960-00168163": "the time like in ideas competition which", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00657-00168164-00168511": "anyone is free to enter this is a closed", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00658-00168512-00168790": "competition in which there is a select", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00659-00168791-00169101": "group that has been edited of of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00660-00169102-00169321": "architecture firms and designers that we", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00661-00169322-00169501": "wanted to approach and thus there was an", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00662-00169502-00169779": "RFP a request for proposal then that was", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00663-00169780-00170218": "put out to you guys and and you know", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00664-00170219-00170386": "just tell us a little bit about you know", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00665-00170387-00170790": "how you even you know really come to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00666-00170791-00170860": "rectify this", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00667-00170861-00171153": "you know submitting and participating in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00668-00171154-00171340": "requests for proposals do you ever", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00669-00171341-00171628": "participate in just open competitions at", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00670-00171629-00171879": "all and how do you balance that out with", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00671-00171880-00172482": "your practice we do we we refer to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00672-00172483-00172681": "participate and invited competitions", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00673-00172682-00172936": "obviously right there we also", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00674-00172937-00173128": "participate in some open ones I think", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00675-00173129-00173185": "it's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00676-00173186-00173425": "just as a practice and for the people in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00677-00173426-00173739": "the in our team that we are doing some", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00678-00173740-00173916": "competitions every once in a while it's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00679-00173917-00174477": "kind of like mental gymnastics and we", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00680-00174478-00174738": "sometimes we just did one recently that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00681-00174739-00174951": "we spent 10 days on you know and that's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00682-00174952-00175135": "like really intense and it's really", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00683-00175136-00175338": "invigorating kind of like getting the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00684-00175339-00175693": "blood going and this Time Square wonder", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00685-00175694-00175854": "it was more of closer to a month so it's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00686-00175855-00176040": "more like you have time you test options", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00687-00176041-00176202": "it's like each one of them we do", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00688-00176203-00176518": "differently but even if they're not one", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00689-00176519-00176841": "which is right part of reality I think", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00690-00176842-00177276": "it presented self in a different project", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00691-00177277-00177600": "later on so it's in a way to build IDs", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00692-00177601-00177925": "yeah yeah I think that our artists and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00693-00177926-00178116": "designers of course deal with that all", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00694-00178117-00178300": "the time you're often proposing stuff", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00695-00178301-00178507": "you don't know like for a residency are", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00696-00178508-00178941": "for public installation you have to know", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00697-00178942-00179281": "a that not being selected doesn't mean", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00698-00179282-00179458": "failure it means an excuse to push", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00699-00179459-00179620": "yourself to develop something else and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00700-00179621-00179990": "it's all R&D in a sense so I think you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00701-00179991-00180240": "for both of us probably when we look at", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00702-00180241-00180465": "competitions we we make a calculation or", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00703-00180466-00180760": "ahead is this interesting will it push", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00704-00180761-00180902": "us to do something different", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00705-00180903-00181101": "also if there's like one in a million", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00706-00181102-00181287": "chance maybe you're not worth doing but", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00707-00181288-00181450": "it was anything like number one in a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00708-00181451-00181762": "thousand probably is worth doing as long", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00709-00181763-00182112": "as there's something that is that really", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00710-00182113-00182395": "pushes either a tool or a method a way", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00711-00182396-00182596": "of thinking or a use of technology or a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00712-00182597-00182790": "material yeah then it's worth it and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00713-00182791-00182959": "matter what yeah so it becomes a very", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00714-00182960-00183145": "valuable part of your own practice and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00715-00183146-00183387": "research that you really can you know", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00716-00183388-00183591": "push your thinking and experimentation", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00717-00183592-00183835": "and whatnot and potentially some of it", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00718-00183836-00184215": "in a later project so tell me about your", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00719-00184216-00184510": "own collaboration how did you guys work", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00720-00184511-00184756": "together you know where was the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00721-00184757-00185001": "complementarity is that even a word I", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00722-00185002-00185485": "don't think it is between you and I we", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00723-00185486-00185758": "have this rule where if we are not happy", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00724-00185759-00186111": "with the design it does not come up so", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00725-00186112-00186445": "we basically was critiquing one another", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00726-00186446-00186565": "which I think it's very", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00727-00186566-00187057": "as our workmanship and I felt that in in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00728-00187058-00187408": "this kind of when we work together with", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00729-00187409-00187636": "Eric Foreman I also felt in that sense", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00730-00187637-00187984": "that if Eric would not be appreciative", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00731-00187985-00188215": "of one direction or us it would not go", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00732-00188216-00188458": "forward so in that respect we respected", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00733-00188459-00188785": "each other but I also what I do like", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00734-00188786-00189037": "about collaboration it's additive", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00735-00189038-00189379": "process in that sense that one ID in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00736-00189380-00189622": "tango with the other and built up and it", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00737-00189623-00189820": "doesn't matter in the in estate at the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00738-00189821-00189984": "end of the day it's it's kind of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00739-00189985-00190456": "holistic collaboration it's always a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00740-00190457-00190756": "great sign when when a project finally", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00741-00190757-00190984": "is released if it was a collaboration if", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00742-00190985-00191134": "you can't remember which parts you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00743-00191135-00191293": "thought of it was probably good", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00744-00191294-00191533": "collaboration it's all mixed together we", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00745-00191534-00191785": "work together so intimately in the whole", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00746-00191786-00192043": "proposal process every day almost we", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00747-00192044-00192265": "were meeting and going through ideas and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00748-00192266-00192496": "iterating and discarding things and it", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00749-00192497-00192712": "was very organic one thing I can", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00750-00192713-00192904": "remember though is that it occurred over", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00751-00192905-00193651": "three cities which is the nature of with", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00752-00193652-00193846": "our contemporary practices so you know", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00753-00193847-00193999": "it began in New York and then there was", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00754-00194000-00194320": "some time spent working remotely with", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00755-00194321-00194488": "each other in Rome and then to Tel", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00756-00194489-00194844": "Aviv's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00757-00194845-00195148": "calculation Time Square is the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00758-00195149-00195541": "crossroads oh well and so and so", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00759-00195542-00195841": "ultimately you submitted the proposal it", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00760-00195842-00196093": "was the winning submission you know then", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00761-00196094-00196384": "you begin moving into making this thing", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00762-00196385-00196684": "a reality and into fabrication and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00763-00196685-00196831": "whatnot I mean tell us a little bit", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00764-00196832-00197149": "about that part of the process that was", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00765-00197150-00197416": "it's always exciting when it gets to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00766-00197417-00197587": "that stage finding out we want of course", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00767-00197588-00197821": "is exciting then you're like oh we have", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00768-00197822-00198073": "to make it we were really lucky to find", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00769-00198074-00198310": "new projects of whose members are here", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00770-00198311-00198541": "today a great local brooklyn-based", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00771-00198542-00198874": "fabricator and they worked with us", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00772-00198875-00199099": "really hard I think we pushed each other", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00773-00199100-00199297": "in a positive way to figure out how to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00774-00199298-00199513": "solve these problems in a small amount", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00775-00199514-00199874": "of time that have to fit a very long", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00776-00199875-00200141": "and and serious list of constraints of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00777-00200142-00200402": "site of public engagement of safety of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00778-00200403-00200675": "engineering and of course of concept and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00779-00200676-00200888": "interactivity and we added accessibility", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00780-00200889-00201440": "to all of that to this and I would we", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00781-00201441-00201665": "also like their cross-disciplinary", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00782-00201666-00201962": "way of thinking where some the owner is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00783-00201963-00202268": "an artist himself so for us again we", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00784-00202269-00202466": "said he that everyone can do multiple", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00785-00202467-00202637": "thing or think of different operation is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00786-00202638-00203069": "important I when did the idea of these", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00787-00203070-00203309": "surviving in Times Square or 300", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00788-00203310-00203630": "thousand people a day so it needs to be", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00789-00203631-00203959": "very resilient and for us as a design", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00790-00203960-00204168": "collaborators for us it was really", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00791-00204169-00204395": "important to make it feel as thin and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00792-00204396-00204716": "almost nothing in an environment that is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00793-00204717-00205094": "in in a way very tough and for that I", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00794-00205096-00205414": "really you know it took a long time to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00795-00205415-00205721": "understand how we make it work", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00796-00205723-00205994": "which were very happy with I mean that's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00797-00205996-00206371": "what to me was so effective about it and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00798-00206373-00206673": "and I would again encourage people to go", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00799-00206673-00206789": "out and see it but I mean just the a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00800-00206790-00207110": "Theory ality of its it's strange to say", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00801-00207111-00207266": "something kind of you know ethereal and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00802-00207267-00207629": "almost quiet can exist in the heart of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00803-00207630-00207836": "Times Square but it really does and I", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00804-00207837-00208165": "mean really kind of you know the only", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00805-00208166-00208494": "kind of movement that you see on the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00806-00208494-00208698": "piece is this reflection of Times Square", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00807-00208698-00208994": "back to you which is what's interesting", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00808-00208994-00209324": "yeah I think that was a guiding design", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00809-00209325-00209474": "principle for us even it wasn't", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00810-00209475-00209726": "explicitly stated but not just the the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00811-00209727-00209954": "balance of structure and air and people", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00812-00209955-00210203": "in the city but also something that is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00813-00210204-00210530": "both spectacular and subtle at the same", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00814-00210531-00210998": "time that's I'm actually kind of amazed", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00815-00211000-00211623": "that it worked as well yeah there was", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00816-00211623-00211863": "this idea about from the beginning like", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00817-00211864-00212148": "how can we do something something that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00818-00212148-00212252": "we Kelly and I have been interesting", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00819-00212253-00212425": "very long time which is about strength", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00820-00212426-00212723": "through air or like strength versus", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00821-00212725-00213131": "resilience so the steel structure", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00822-00213132-00213419": "is multiplied through thousands of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00823-00213419-00213769": "members but can they don't do this but", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00824-00213771-00214265": "can be climbed on like as a result it's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00825-00214266-00214723": "still 99% air and that's that was", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00826-00214723-00215075": "driving principle and as you walk around", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00827-00215076-00215221": "it and we encourage people to walk", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00828-00215223-00215342": "around it that's where you can have", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00829-00215342-00215671": "experienced the air yeah so I guess in a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00830-00215673-00215903": "way how we work together was really", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00831-00215904-00216181": "understanding the core values which was", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00832-00216182-00216371": "interacting with the environment or", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00833-00216371-00216626": "implementing the environment and the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00834-00216627-00216917": "idea of surrounding ourself to that in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00835-00216917-00217265": "that kind of way they dictated our", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00836-00217266-00217589": "choice design choices yeah well in and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00837-00217590-00217832": "something else which is really stuck", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00838-00217833-00217964": "with me actually both of you guys", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00839-00217965-00218231": "commented on this during your", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00840-00218232-00218528": "presentation so and I had I had to write", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00841-00218529-00218639": "them down because I thought it was", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00842-00218640-00218858": "interesting so who you were saying that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00843-00218859-00218987": "like architecture is never complete", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00844-00218988-00219125": "without the people who are engaging with", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00845-00219126-00219482": "it or maybe were you said it and Eric", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00846-00219483-00219641": "you were saying again this idea of you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00847-00219642-00219767": "know when people are walking by", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00848-00219767-00219941": "something you know they never know", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00849-00219942-00220160": "necessarily what to expect or how to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00850-00220161-00220325": "interact with it so it mean it's just I", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00851-00220326-00220514": "love this idea about how something", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00852-00220515-00220781": "really becomes what it's supposed to be", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00853-00220782-00221096": "with a user with the public with an", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00854-00221096-00221612": "audience so now that this piece this", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00855-00221613-00221869": "installation has been up for three weeks", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00856-00221871-00222242": "how have people been using it has there", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00857-00222242-00222563": "been anything that surprised you in the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00858-00222564-00222896": "life of this installation personally I", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00859-00222896-00223094": "feel when you create something for the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00860-00223094-00223304": "public you surrender and it's no longer", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00861-00223305-00223613": "yours someone else owns it even if it's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00862-00223614-00223771": "for five seconds engagement or", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00863-00223773-00223982": "one-minute engagement so it's theirs", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00864-00223983-00224267": "and yes of course they surprise you it's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00865-00224267-00224564": "just really fun to watch and see how", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00866-00224565-00224681": "people engage with it", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00867-00224682-00224960": "and the longer you spend with the piece", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00868-00224961-00225311": "as Eric was saying the longer they're", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00869-00225312-00225563": "more layers are there to be revealed", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00870-00225564-00225881": "which which is for us part part of the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00871-00225882-00226151": "fun my family's in Tel Aviv and they've", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00872-00226152-00226361": "been watching livestream from Times", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00873-00226362-00226466": "Square", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00874-00226467-00226759": "making sure the piece is okay and the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00875-00226760-00226984": "times I get this phone call it's like", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00876-00226985-00227335": "watch now these guys aren't dancing so", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00877-00227336-00227567": "yeah I have the monitor system at night", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00878-00227567-00227816": "which is the hour gap between here in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00879-00227817-00228251": "New York watching I think we were really", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00880-00228252-00228437": "wanted people to interact with each", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00881-00228438-00228646": "other not just with the with the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00882-00228648-00228907": "installation itself and we thought that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00883-00228908-00229076": "would happen but we you can't predict", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00884-00229077-00229388": "until it's actually out there and I was", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00885-00229389-00229684": "very happy to see just to hang back from", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00886-00229685-00229928": "the side and see people sharing it with", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00887-00229929-00230104": "each other or sometimes explaining it to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00888-00230105-00230312": "each other which is amazing for public", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00889-00230313-00230519": "art where they eat each person kind of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00890-00230519-00230663": "figures it out get something out of it", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00891-00230664-00230803": "and then feels like they are the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00892-00230804-00230980": "ambassador to the next round of yours", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00893-00230981-00231244": "and you see people pass it on oh look", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00894-00231246-00231398": "it's this it's about this you have to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00895-00231398-00231742": "stand in this spot whatever and it was", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00896-00231744-00231985": "interesting because we debated having", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00897-00231986-00232178": "what we called the sweet spot there's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00898-00232179-00232348": "one spot that you stand in front where", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00899-00232350-00232490": "all the mirrors are perfectly", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00900-00232491-00232657": "computationally aligned to form the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00901-00232658-00232954": "heart we thought at first it's got to be", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00902-00232955-00233230": "a giant pink marker on the ground that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00903-00233231-00233410": "everyone can see and nobody will miss is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00904-00233411-00233584": "a billion billion people none of them", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00905-00233585-00233773": "have any time but we ended up not", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00906-00233775-00234046": "needing that at all people just they", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00907-00234048-00234181": "come from the side or from the back", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00908-00234182-00234350": "they're interested in it they start", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00909-00234351-00234523": "exploring they see the reflections they", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00910-00234525-00234694": "realize something's happening either", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00911-00234696-00234839": "they figure out themselves or someone", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00912-00234840-00235155": "explains it and just wasn't necessary I", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00913-00235156-00235357": "think that also has to do with the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00914-00235358-00235769": "unique both challenges but also benefits", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00915-00235769-00235919": "of designing something for Times Square", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00916-00235919-00236128": "you know over 300,000 people pass", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00917-00236129-00236291": "through the square in a day so there's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00918-00236292-00236567": "always going to be a bunch of people who", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00919-00236567-00236762": "are around it looking for the spot you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00920-00236763-00236927": "know we've done work in other places", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00921-00236928-00237164": "where you know like that density of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00922-00237165-00237505": "people you wouldn't have communication", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00923-00237506-00238060": "it's unique it almost benefits and the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00924-00238061-00238148": "thing which I thought was really", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00925-00238148-00238306": "interesting for those of you who saw the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00926-00238307-00238633": "video that was playing at the beginning", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00927-00238634-00238925": "there was a bird there was a bird that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00928-00238926-00239155": "was in the center of it I mean a bird in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00929-00239156-00239419": "Times Square I don't know if ever really", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00930-00239419-00239654": "creating an ecosystem", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00931-00239655-00240224": "the multi submission worker that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00932-00240225-00240427": "literally found the center of the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00933-00240428-00240800": "structure and where we cannot be reached", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00934-00240801-00241169": "from any direction and went to sleep in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00935-00241170-00241301": "the middle of Times Square I don't know", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00936-00241302-00241553": "how many people or species or animals", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00937-00241554-00241791": "will have that experience but she found", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00938-00241792-00242204": "that perfect so we only have a few", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00939-00242205-00242429": "minutes left I want to open it up to our", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00940-00242430-00242717": "audience here if anyone has a question", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00941-00242718-00243029": "for our guests this evening", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00942-00243030-00243425": "please feel free raise your hand you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00943-00243426-00244109": "have a mic any questions okay we have a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00944-00244110-00244515": "couple it's mine so now that you guys", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00945-00244516-00244796": "have you know done a good amount of work", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00946-00244797-00244958": "with these public works and looking at", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00947-00244959-00245180": "this do you have any favorites from", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00948-00245181-00245372": "other people or any other examples that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00949-00245373-00245618": "have inspired you or that you think are", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00950-00245619-00245908": "really impressive and creative", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00951-00245909-00246710": "specifically for arts well for public", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00952-00246711-00247346": "art you're asking where are you I'm a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00953-00247347-00247716": "big fan of Oliver Allison I first of all", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00954-00247717-00247887": "he works between art and architecture", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00955-00247888-00248269": "which is appropriate for right now also", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00956-00248270-00248507": "he combines science and art which i", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00957-00248508-00248816": "think is amazing but his experiences are", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00958-00248817-00249110": "sometimes completely immersive really", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00959-00249111-00249548": "intense and quite complex but almost", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00960-00249549-00249789": "anybody as soon as they walk in are", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00961-00249790-00249987": "already drawn in no matter what they", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00962-00249988-00250097": "understand it doesn't matter if they", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00963-00250098-00250217": "have an art background a science", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00964-00250218-00250400": "background or whatever so he creates a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00965-00250401-00250643": "spectacle that is accessible at all and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00966-00250644-00250788": "also has incredibly complicated", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00967-00250789-00251108": "intellectual ideas underneath it well I", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00968-00251109-00251391": "think art is an inspiration to me period", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00969-00251392-00251589": "in the sense that an artist is always", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00970-00251590-00251795": "part of society and outside of society", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00971-00251796-00252035": "and allows you for multiple perspectives", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00972-00252036-00252312": "so a big fan", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00973-00252313-00252799": "my favorite is in columnar where she", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00974-00252800-00253010": "documents people in different", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00975-00253011-00253221": "period of time and she multiplied them", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00976-00253221-00253526": "make them very very tiny as a video and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00977-00253527-00253842": "project them into different architecture", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00978-00253842-00254346": "or archaeological objects and I just", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00979-00254346-00254555": "find so she creates a extra small", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00980-00254556-00254954": "architecture through a medium digital", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00981-00254955-00255376": "media of video class an object or space", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00982-00255377-00256583": "she's a great inspiration the sky in", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00983-00256584-00256917": "Times Square and The Naked Cowboy ran up", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00984-00256917-00257317": "and and we have his business card yeah", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00985-00257319-00258312": "we had another question back here my", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00986-00258313-00258591": "question is did you guys start when you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00987-00258592-00258734": "guys start designing do you guys start", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00988-00258735-00258971": "with the heart first or did you guys", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00989-00258973-00259391": "start with a specific element first I", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00990-00259392-00259922": "think it depends design options some", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00991-00259923-00260231": "started with the heart and some did not", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00992-00260232-00260477": "but I think that all of the options was", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00993-00260478-00260864": "about not making the heart an immediate", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00994-00260865-00261131": "immediately found I think so that's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00995-00261132-00261291": "something that connected all the ideas", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00996-00261292-00261506": "that we had together which was this idea", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00997-00261507-00261752": "of drawing people into it and it's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00998-00261753-00261917": "something that we wanted to do to react", "QMv2D4ug7X4-00999-00261919-00262121": "maybe to do something differently than", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01000-00262123-00262422": "past years and kind of we use a lot of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01001-00262423-00262802": "the word surprise or discover I would", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01002-00262803-00263006": "say we started with stripping down our", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01003-00263007-00263340": "cynicism as New Yorkers you know you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01004-00263341-00263650": "think about a heart in our Times Square", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01005-00263651-00264012": "it's not the it I think you really need", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01006-00264013-00264195": "to understand the impact of Times Square", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01007-00264196-00264425": "right it is the heart of New York it has", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01008-00264426-00264642": "a big message behind it you can forget", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01009-00264643-00264663": "it", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01010-00264664-00264872": "because as New Yorkers you maybe avoid", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01011-00264873-00265202": "the locomotion the day to day locomotion", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01012-00265203-00265580": "there and then heart or how do you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01013-00265581-00265767": "really connect to someone's heart I", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01014-00265768-00265896": "think that's when you know that the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01015-00265897-00266156": "piece is really working so it's not as", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01016-00266157-00266400": "simple the symbol of a heart but really", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01017-00266401-00266649": "connect to something bigger you know", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01018-00266650-00266922": "inclusive for us it was the collective", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01019-00266923-00267111": "heart in the sense that New York is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01020-00267112-00267414": "really a place from everyone around the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01021-00267415-00267639": "world and you can feel the comfortable", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01022-00267640-00267870": "of being yourself in a public sphere", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01023-00267871-00268074": "among other were different in you I find", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01024-00268075-00268395": "it be very unique and rare support for", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01025-00268396-00268629": "me that was where I Street my seasoned", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01026-00268630-00268869": "cynicism and say this is really", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01027-00268870-00269460": "important heart and I have one last", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01028-00269461-00270105": "question I'm interested in this idea of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01029-00270106-00270555": "a civic value of public design and art", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01030-00270556-00270759": "installations I mean what do you think", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01031-00270760-00271106": "is the value and our shared landscape I", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01032-00271107-00271389": "mean number number one is I think", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01033-00271390-00271629": "obvious but needs to be repeated", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01034-00271630-00271851": "constantly which is that art is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01035-00271852-00272169": "essential for civic life and whether", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01036-00272170-00272502": "it's rural or urban and providing art", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01037-00272503-00272955": "for free is just fundamental to engaging", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01038-00272956-00273330": "with a in a society you know that you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01039-00273331-00273600": "need to have those moments of not just", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01040-00273601-00273768": "imagination that something is outside of", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01041-00273769-00274083": "the ordinary some even if it's troubling", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01042-00274084-00274248": "it should be something that takes you", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01043-00274249-00274500": "outside of your normal perspective so", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01044-00274501-00274770": "for public art especially I mean that is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01045-00274771-00275001": "its its mission astiz to give art to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01046-00275002-00275175": "everybody so I think it's critical for", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01047-00275176-00276060": "the life of any place yeah I but saying", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01048-00276061-00276255": "I think that for us with with the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01049-00276256-00276528": "project there what what what art can do", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01050-00276529-00276840": "in the Civic space is reframe how we", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01051-00276841-00277059": "experience that space and I think that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01052-00277060-00277236": "for us one of the kind of great", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01053-00277237-00277371": "pleasures of heart squared was that it's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01054-00277372-00277545": "not just about the piece it's about how", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01055-00277546-00277863": "that piece re-calibrate and reimagined", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01056-00277864-00278220": "this very large urban space and one", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01057-00278221-00278382": "thing that I think that we were actually", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01058-00278383-00278610": "also you know this idea of surprise we", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01059-00278611-00278877": "were also surprised by how that all the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01060-00278878-00279153": "mirrors fragment the Billboard so you no", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01061-00279154-00279393": "longer are seeing the advertising the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01062-00279394-00279624": "Billboard but just snippets of color and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01063-00279625-00279777": "it's constantly changing and", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01064-00279778-00280023": "it's like basically the essence of Times", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01065-00280024-00280460": "Square abstracted right", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01066-00280461-00280767": "comment don't say that 87 percent of our", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01067-00280768-00281049": "time they spent indoors which is", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01068-00281050-00281244": "privatized especially super privatized", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01069-00281245-00281589": "especially in New York City so we have", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01070-00281590-00281799": "so little time in the public spare that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01071-00281800-00282228": "actually free in in in dots and public", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01072-00282229-00282528": "art or emphasizing how this space of the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01073-00282529-00282821": "outdoor is extremely important to", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01074-00282822-00283221": "democracy as a sense of a sphere that as", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01075-00283222-00283554": "a public we can enjoy and we can set the", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01076-00283555-00284105": "rules of engagement is really important", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01077-00284106-00284436": "fantastic so with that we actually gonna", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01078-00284437-00284715": "have to wrap up our conversation I want", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01079-00284716-00285045": "to thank our guests for being here this", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01080-00285046-00285225": "evening I want to thank all of you for", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01081-00285226-00285504": "joining us and the museum does have a", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01082-00285505-00285687": "couple exhibitions that are opening on", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01083-00285688-00285891": "Friday we have another exhibition that's", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01084-00285892-00286170": "opening on March 13th so do come back", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01085-00286171-00286501": "and visit us and with that", "QMv2D4ug7X4-01086-00286502-00287148": "[Applause]"}}, {"audio_id": "QM-rh_vWCzY", "text": {"QM-rh_vWCzY-00000-00000180-00000303": "neoliberalism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00001-00000304-00000630": "stalinism it is jointly hosted by the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00002-00000631-00000774": "school of humanities and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00003-00000775-00000975": "english departments of the ateneo de", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00004-00000976-00001143": "manila university", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00005-00001144-00001415": "and the faculty of creative and cultural", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00006-00001416-00001726": "industries the university of portsmouth", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00007-00001727-00001918": "i'd like to thank the staff of both", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00008-00001919-00002102": "universities who have made this event", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00009-00002103-00002215": "possible", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00010-00002216-00002583": "in particular tom sykes who initiated it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00011-00002584-00002815": "i am roderick galam and i am pleased to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00012-00002816-00003087": "be chairing this panel discussion", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00013-00003088-00003343": "i will try to make my introductory talk", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00014-00003344-00003527": "as short as possible", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00015-00003528-00003759": "to give more time for our speakers to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00016-00003760-00003879": "present", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00017-00003879-00004222": "their ideas and allow for more", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00018-00004223-00004670": "time for more q a in 2015 maria reza", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00019-00004671-00004951": "noted that rodrigo duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00020-00004952-00005238": "and i quote is brazen in what he plans", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00021-00005239-00005286": "to do", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00022-00005287-00005670": "if he wins establish a dictatorship that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00023-00005671-00005918": "would discipline filipinos", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00024-00005919-00006183": "that would establish law and order that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00025-00006184-00006302": "would eradicate", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00026-00006303-00006575": "corruption and that would bring growth", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00027-00006576-00006783": "and development", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00028-00006784-00006983": "five years on since this election in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00029-00006984-00007142": "2016", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00030-00007143-00007375": "and although duterte has succeeded in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00031-00007376-00007631": "imposing a dictatorship or", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00032-00007631-00007998": "fascist government corruption is rampant", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00033-00008000-00008231": "the economy is in bad shape to put it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00034-00008232-00008319": "mildly", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00035-00008320-00008655": "and his idea of law and order his drug", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00036-00008656-00008855": "war has resulted in the killing of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00037-00008856-00008910": "almost", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00038-00008911-00009327": "30 000 filipinos without ever making a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00039-00009328-00009414": "dent", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00040-00009415-00009791": "on the drugs problem he has utterly", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00041-00009792-00009959": "failed to deliver on many", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00042-00009960-00010278": "if not all of his campaign promises from", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00043-00010279-00010495": "putting an end to contractual labor", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00044-00010496-00010703": "to solving metro manila's horrific", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00045-00010704-00010855": "traffic problem", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00046-00010856-00011183": "to personally riding a jet ski and plant", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00047-00011184-00011342": "the philippine flag in this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00048-00011343-00011663": "bradley islands or scarborough", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00049-00011664-00011838": "shoal and defend the country's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00050-00011839-00011999": "sovereignty", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00051-00012000-00012351": "from china's encroachment", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00052-00012352-00012559": "filipinos are suffering from the calvin", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00053-00012560-00012719": "19 pandemic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00054-00012720-00012935": "to which duterte has shown deliberate", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00055-00012936-00013063": "obtuseness", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00056-00013063-00013399": "and ineptitude community countries that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00057-00013400-00013519": "are providing relief", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00058-00013519-00013783": "thousands of hungry citizens are being", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00059-00013784-00013975": "red tight", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00060-00013976-00014222": "a commenter wrote on a post promoting", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00061-00014223-00014415": "this webinar in the philippine studies", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00062-00014416-00014447": "group", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00063-00014447-00014919": "facebook page", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00064-00014919-00015230": "well duterte is truly modeled he is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00065-00015231-00015358": "incoherent", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00066-00015359-00015663": "as richard heydarian has noted following", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00067-00015663-00015783": "the tortoise", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00068-00015784-00016111": "long-winded speeches often resembling", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00069-00016112-00016238": "faulknerian", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00070-00016240-00016471": "stream of consciousness if not freudian", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00071-00016472-00016663": "free association", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00072-00016664-00016958": "rather than the business as usual stream", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00073-00016959-00017247": "statesmen like sloganeering", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00074-00017248-00017615": "is to say the least a formidable task", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00075-00017616-00017975": "requiring utmost patience and diligence", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00076-00017976-00018283": "on the part of any conscientious", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00077-00018284-00018567": "researcher what the presenters will", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00078-00018568-00018758": "certainly demonstrate today", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00079-00018759-00018975": "is their ability to make sense of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00080-00018976-00019175": "morass that is duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00081-00019176-00019422": "and the context that makes it possible", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00082-00019423-00019671": "for a figure like him to emerge", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00083-00019672-00019983": "and dominate philippine politics as the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00084-00019984-00020222": "abstract for this panel states", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00085-00020223-00020486": "the academic analysis and journalistic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00086-00020487-00020727": "reporting of rodrigo duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00087-00020728-00021030": "has often failed to engage with several", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00088-00021031-00021335": "important material determinants of his", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00089-00021336-00021414": "rise", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00090-00021415-00021655": "amongst them the recent complicity of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00091-00021656-00021822": "stalinist groups", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00092-00021823-00022078": "inside the philippines the long-term", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00093-00022079-00022247": "impacts of western", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00094-00022248-00022455": "neo-liberal economic policy on", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00095-00022456-00022622": "philippine society", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00096-00022623-00023007": "and the legacies of u.s colonialism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00097-00023008-00023271": "the four scholars on this panel will", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00098-00023272-00023358": "provide", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00099-00023359-00023694": "a corrective to these oversights", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00100-00023695-00023935": "let me then introduce to you the four", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00101-00023936-00024375": "speakers", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00102-00024376-00024942": "first one vp dr oscar campomanes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00103-00024943-00025342": "will present on dutertismo", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00104-00025343-00025711": "empire's veritable wet dream or perfumed", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00105-00025712-00026062": "nightmare dr oster campomanes is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00106-00026063-00026190": "associate professor", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00107-00026191-00026407": "in the department of english ateneo de", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00108-00026408-00026574": "manila university", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00109-00026575-00026807": "where he also holds the francisco c", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00110-00026808-00027079": "delgado professorial chair", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00111-00027080-00027270": "he was a visiting scholar in the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00112-00027272-00027462": "department of cultural and religious", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00113-00027463-00027718": "studies the chinese university", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00114-00027719-00028111": "of hong kong and a and was also a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00115-00028112-00028318": "distinguished visiting professor at the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00116-00028319-00028518": "vietnam national university in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00117-00028519-00028814": "hanoi he has held teaching appointments", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00118-00028816-00029070": "in various american universities", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00119-00029072-00029279": "such as the university of california san", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00120-00029280-00029527": "diego new york university", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00121-00029527-00029718": "university of california berkeley where", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00122-00029719-00029879": "he held it's a new track", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00123-00029880-00030183": "position williams college", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00124-00030183-00030574": "and yale university he obtained his ba", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00125-00030575-00030807": "from the university of the philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00126-00030808-00031095": "and his ma and phd degrees in american", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00127-00031095-00031351": "civilization from brown university", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00128-00031352-00031570": "where he wrote on figures of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00129-00031572-00031727": "unassimilable", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00130-00031727-00031987": "american empire philippine-american", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00131-00031988-00032127": "post-coloniality", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00132-00032127-00032423": "and the u.s philippine war of 1898 to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00133-00032424-00032623": "1910s", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00134-00032624-00032879": "he is a pioneer in the application of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00135-00032880-00033118": "the transdisciplinary and translocal", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00136-00033119-00033407": "discipline of nestology on american", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00137-00033408-00033590": "empire studies and filipino", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00138-00033591-00033807": "post-colonial critique", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00139-00033808-00034231": "or the island forms of american empire", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00140-00034232-00034407": "and filipino post-colonial", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00141-00034408-00034683": "conceptuality his work on this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00142-00034684-00034831": "conceptualizes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00143-00034832-00035095": "a distinctly filipino and vernacular", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00144-00035096-00035167": "strain", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00145-00035168-00035487": "of global nestology which he calls", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00146-00035488-00035790": "philippine archipelagic marathon studies", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00147-00035791-00036023": "and has led to a course he teaches at", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00148-00036024-00036215": "ateneo called imperial", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00149-00036216-00036823": "and post-colonial nestology", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00150-00036824-00037374": "he will be followed by joseph scalise", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00151-00037375-00037662": "who is a postdoctoral researcher at the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00152-00037663-00037871": "nanyang technological university", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00153-00037872-00038215": "in singapore the heart of his", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00154-00038216-00038430": "scholarship is a transnational approach", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00155-00038431-00038635": "to revolutionary movements and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00156-00038636-00038918": "authoritarianism in southeast asia", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00157-00038919-00039111": "grounded in the postwar political", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00158-00039112-00039439": "history of the philippines his", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00159-00039440-00039679": "forthcoming book the drama of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00160-00039680-00039807": "dictatorship", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00161-00039808-00040023": "martial law and the communist parties of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00162-00040024-00040167": "the philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00163-00040168-00040487": "is forthcoming in 2022 from the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00164-00040488-00040807": "university of wisconsin press", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00165-00040808-00041127": "and this book analyzes the events", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00166-00041128-00041351": "leading up to the declaration of martial", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00167-00041352-00041727": "law by ferdinand marcos in 1972", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00168-00041728-00041999": "it uncovers the prominent role played by", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00169-00042000-00042167": "two communist parties", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00170-00042168-00042574": "the pkp and the cpp in this affair", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00171-00042575-00042774": "using the previously unexamined", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00172-00042775-00042918": "contemporary", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00173-00042919-00043107": "written record produced by these", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00174-00043108-00043246": "organizations", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00175-00043247-00043646": "it demonstrates that the rival parties", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00176-00043647-00043999": "allied with rival factions of the elite", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00177-00044000-00044255": "who were engaged in a furious struggle", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00178-00044256-00044399": "to be in power", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00179-00044400-00044902": "prior to the imposition of military rule", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00180-00044903-00045167": "joseph obtained all his degrees from the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00181-00045168-00045358": "university of california berkeley where", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00182-00045359-00045567": "he was recognized for his teaching", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00183-00045568-00045695": "excellence", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00184-00045696-00045951": "and he has also taught at the san", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00185-00045952-00046039": "francisco", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00186-00046040-00046527": "state university his research interests", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00187-00046528-00046758": "include the sino-soviet split in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00188-00046759-00046895": "southeast asia", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00189-00046896-00047111": "global maoism and recovering the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00190-00047112-00047335": "forgotten struggles of the working-class", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00191-00047336-00047535": "and peasantry in the philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00192-00047536-00047879": "as well as tagalog literature he speaks", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00193-00047880-00048062": "very fluent tagalog", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00194-00048063-00048255": "and that's because his family moved to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00195-00048256-00048486": "manila when he was five years old", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00196-00048487-00048815": "and lived there for many years he also", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00197-00048816-00049143": "spent several years as an adult in rural", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00198-00049144-00049623": "central luzon", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00199-00049624-00049935": "our third speaker is tom sykes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00200-00049936-00050318": "who is a widely published author editor", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00201-00050319-00050574": "journalist and literary historian with", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00202-00050575-00050783": "interests in travel writing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00203-00050784-00051030": "creative non-fiction international", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00204-00051031-00051158": "relations", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00205-00051159-00051366": "radical politics post-colonial", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00206-00051367-00051579": "literature historiography", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00207-00051579-00051854": "psychogeography and historical", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00208-00051855-00051966": "materialism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00209-00051967-00052342": "as well as community journalism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00210-00052344-00052623": "he recently launched his book imagining", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00211-00052624-00052711": "manila", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00212-00052712-00053094": "literature empire and orientalism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00213-00053095-00053335": "which is a critique of western literary", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00214-00053336-00053566": "representations of manila's urban", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00215-00053567-00053694": "topography", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00216-00053695-00053991": "and social ethnic communities and the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00217-00053991-00054230": "relationship between these constructions", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00218-00054232-00054503": "and the colonial and post-colonial", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00219-00054504-00054663": "histories of europe", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00220-00054664-00054903": "the united states the philippines and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00221-00054904-00054975": "wider", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00222-00054976-00055326": "asia prior to imagining manila", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00223-00055327-00055638": "he published the realm of the punisher", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00224-00055639-00055838": "which is a political travelogue of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00225-00055839-00055942": "philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00226-00055944-00056279": "which according to the times literary", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00227-00056279-00056375": "supplement", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00228-00056376-00056638": "conveys in an affectionate and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00229-00056639-00056799": "patronizing tone", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00230-00056800-00057079": "the many layers of injustice that run", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00231-00057079-00057223": "through the philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00232-00057224-00057487": "and uses interviews and site visits to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00233-00057488-00057623": "try to explain", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00234-00057624-00057879": "the eccentric ways and popular appeal of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00235-00057879-00057982": "its more", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00236-00057983-00058303": "muscular leaders", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00237-00058304-00058575": "tom's journalism has appeared in private", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00238-00058576-00058623": "eye", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00239-00058624-00058966": "new statesman the scotsman the telegraph", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00240-00058967-00059350": "new internationalist monocle new african", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00241-00059351-00059671": "red pepper travel africa southeast asia", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00242-00059672-00059838": "globe and numerous print", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00243-00059839-00060206": "and digital media around the world", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00244-00060207-00060415": "tom obtained his ba from the university", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00245-00060416-00060638": "of east anglia and his phd from the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00246-00060639-00060894": "goldsmith's college university of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00247-00060895-00061199": "london we would we should have a fourth", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00248-00061200-00061335": "speaker", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00249-00061336-00061606": "um walden value and i will introduce him", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00250-00061607-00061711": "when he", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00251-00061712-00062159": "joins us hopefully", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00252-00062160-00062503": "so we'll have um oscar first", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00253-00062504-00062815": "oscar the screen is yours", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00254-00062816-00063015": "thank you derek for the generous", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00255-00063016-00063175": "introduction i just wanted to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00256-00063176-00063494": "check um if my audio and video", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00257-00063495-00063887": "are coming across all right thank you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00258-00063888-00064230": "um i wanted to screen share", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00259-00064232-00064559": "and just for an instant", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00260-00064560-00064975": "flash this meme which i downloaded", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00261-00064976-00065375": "from fb stream um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00262-00065376-00065703": "without uh here flashing it without", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00263-00065704-00066319": "any commentary or exegesis", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00264-00066320-00066550": "and you can treat it as the visual", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00265-00066551-00066638": "epigram", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00266-00066639-00067079": "right for my remarks today", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00267-00067080-00067311": "good evening to everyone and hi from", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00268-00067312-00067575": "manila the philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00269-00067576-00067999": "what else is there to say about duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00270-00068000-00068367": "frankly speaking i'm not interested", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00271-00068368-00068682": "in duterte i find it almost", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00272-00068683-00069006": "pointless to dwell on his obviously", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00273-00069007-00069406": "calculated political iconoclasm", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00274-00069407-00069759": "what tom sykes our roundtable organizer", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00275-00069760-00070135": "calls his aberrant brutality", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00276-00070136-00070487": "his unabashed misogyny", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00277-00070488-00070787": "and his admittedly most quotable", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00278-00070788-00071038": "mealy-mouthed pronouncements", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00279-00071039-00071526": "about all sorts of things under the sun", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00280-00071527-00071831": "karoska interviewed for publishers", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00281-00071832-00071903": "weekly", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00282-00071904-00072359": "in 1988 upon the release of her debut", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00283-00072360-00072743": "supra realist novel state of war", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00284-00072744-00073031": "that's the term she uses to describe her", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00285-00073032-00073111": "style", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00286-00073112-00073359": "that it's not magical realism but super", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00287-00073360-00073535": "realism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00288-00073536-00073831": "was asked if the character of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00289-00073832-00073926": "commander", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00290-00073927-00074271": "in the novel is an allusion", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00291-00074272-00074575": "to the erstwhile dictator ferdinand", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00292-00074576-00074799": "marcus", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00293-00074800-00075119": "her reply in essence marcus", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00294-00075120-00075631": "holds no interest for me whatsoever", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00295-00075632-00075935": "paraphrased quite wildly", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00296-00075936-00076399": "the rest of her statement goes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00297-00076400-00076743": "marcus and his ilk bore me", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00298-00076744-00077231": "to tears but this is the exact quote", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00299-00077232-00077526": "marcos is just another dictator and we", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00300-00077527-00077694": "all know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00301-00077695-00078111": "what happens to dictators and poets", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00302-00078112-00078447": "even if they arise prevail for what", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00303-00078448-00078711": "seems like an eternity", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00304-00078712-00079287": "they ultimately and eventually fall", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00305-00079288-00079599": "i will say of duterte what roska has", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00306-00079600-00079782": "said about marcus", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00307-00079783-00080094": "he bores me to tears he holds no", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00308-00080095-00080462": "interest for me at all like all", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00309-00080463-00080894": "would-be dictators he is bound to fall", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00310-00080895-00081271": "so my remarks today do not concern him", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00311-00081272-00081503": "as a personage", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00312-00081504-00081918": "at all an approach toward my subject", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00313-00081919-00082206": "that i wish to take today", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00314-00082207-00082526": "borrows from an experimental but i", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00315-00082527-00082759": "believe productive form of writing and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00316-00082760-00082967": "critique", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00317-00082968-00083279": "developed by my leading colleagues in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00318-00083280-00083399": "the asia", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00319-00083400-00083743": "theories network or apn", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00320-00083744-00084047": "a transnational group of critical", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00321-00084048-00084499": "and cultural theorists which is jointly", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00322-00084500-00084799": "coordinated from national taiwan", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00323-00084800-00084943": "university", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00324-00084944-00085126": "and the university of california", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00325-00085127-00085326": "humanities research", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00326-00085327-00085671": "institute it is a network in which i", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00327-00085672-00085767": "have been", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00328-00085768-00086094": "active for the past few years", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00329-00086095-00086455": "since its founding we have given the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00330-00086456-00086494": "name", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00331-00086495-00086911": "provocation or provocations", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00332-00086912-00087238": "sometimes thought peace", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00333-00087239-00087606": "to this form of discourse", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00334-00087607-00087903": "its chief technique is having the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00335-00087904-00088055": "provocateur", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00336-00088056-00088582": "or speaker surrender epistemic privilege", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00337-00088583-00088862": "and it's a term i borrow from caroline", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00338-00088863-00088950": "howe's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00339-00088951-00089326": "magisterial study of philippine elite", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00340-00089327-00089726": "and illustrated formations as well as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00341-00089727-00090031": "literary and social understandings and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00342-00090032-00090215": "representations of them", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00343-00090216-00090559": "in modern philippine culture", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00344-00090560-00091047": "in surrendering this epistemic privilege", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00345-00091048-00091359": "the speaker is really interested", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00346-00091360-00091662": "in provoking or actively eliciting", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00347-00091663-00092055": "animated exchanges and deliberations in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00348-00092056-00092206": "our workshops", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00349-00092207-00092535": "about the questions at hand", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00350-00092536-00092855": "the provocation may take any form", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00351-00092856-00093262": "images formulations", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00352-00093263-00093615": "rhetorical questions handy quotes from", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00353-00093616-00093759": "strategically selected", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00354-00093760-00094287": "texts etc or any combinations of them", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00355-00094288-00094494": "so my first provocation is actually that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00356-00094495-00094655": "meme right", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00357-00094656-00094959": "that i flash at the beginning with no", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00358-00094960-00095103": "exegesis", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00359-00095104-00095403": "or commentary about the images of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00360-00095404-00095559": "authoritarianism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00361-00095560-00095943": "that it juxtaposes and i will leave it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00362-00095944-00096150": "for your critical consideration during", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00363-00096151-00096279": "the forum", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00364-00096280-00096662": "to discuss what it tells us", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00365-00096663-00097087": "as an image my second provocation", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00366-00097088-00097415": "consists in a set of formulations", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00367-00097416-00097759": "which speak to my own intent", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00368-00097760-00098082": "to express the call for a radically new", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00369-00098083-00098206": "language", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00370-00098207-00098543": "in which to conduct our conversations", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00371-00098544-00098743": "and critiques", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00372-00098744-00099135": "about the problem at hand", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00373-00099136-00099335": "one that seeks to move beyond", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00374-00099336-00099487": "orientalist", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00375-00099488-00099691": "and imperialist rhetoric and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00376-00099692-00099855": "representations", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00377-00099856-00100150": "and might enable us to think about our", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00378-00100151-00100215": "present", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00379-00100216-00100638": "problematic on duterte or deutertismo", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00380-00100639-00101182": "in alternative ways so here it goes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00381-00101183-00101423": "when tom first invited me along with", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00382-00101424-00101503": "walden", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00383-00101504-00101806": "josef and derrick to participate", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00384-00101807-00102118": "in this round table a few weeks ago i", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00385-00102119-00102262": "must admit", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00386-00102263-00102606": "that i hesitated about saying yes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00387-00102607-00102918": "even as i enthusiastically", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00388-00102919-00103199": "i wish to apologize for my dogs i have", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00389-00103200-00103351": "four of them and they're making", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00390-00103352-00103694": "background noise um even as i", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00391-00103695-00103823": "enthusiastically", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00392-00103824-00104158": "welcomed and endorsed his idea for it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00393-00104159-00104494": "particularly the way his first draft", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00394-00104495-00104854": "for the roundtable abstract framed its", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00395-00104855-00105023": "problematic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00396-00105024-00105390": "to it that the proper name duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00397-00105391-00105719": "would not so much designate the real", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00398-00105720-00105871": "historical figure", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00399-00105872-00106278": "who bears it as delineate", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00400-00106279-00106578": "an entire discursive formation", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00401-00106579-00106766": "dutertismo", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00402-00106767-00107086": "which as i understood then was not going", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00403-00107088-00107231": "to be limited", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00404-00107232-00107543": "to a critical exposition of the highly", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00405-00107544-00107783": "controversial political style of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00406-00107783-00107910": "governance", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00407-00107911-00108263": "associated with duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00408-00108264-00108615": "or to which it has been distilled", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00409-00108616-00108854": "in the hands of the neo-orientalist", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00410-00108855-00108999": "pundits", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00411-00109000-00109454": "whose recent reportage on the phenomenon", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00412-00109455-00109766": "of the thertismo is the main critical", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00413-00109767-00109831": "object", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00414-00109832-00110215": "of chapter six titled call of duty", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00415-00110216-00110510": "kasich despotism and western neoliberal", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00416-00110511-00110639": "crisis", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00417-00110640-00110943": "of toms recently launched and released", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00418-00110944-00111015": "book", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00419-00111016-00111358": "imagining manila this discourse and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00420-00111359-00111439": "practice", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00421-00111440-00111775": "of the thirtismos i took it could thus", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00422-00111776-00112199": "be posed as a matter of formation", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00423-00112200-00112510": "or formations not the forms there's a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00424-00112511-00112815": "crucial difference between the two", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00425-00112816-00113007": "the initial descript roundable", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00426-00113008-00113207": "description to my mind", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00427-00113208-00113534": "offered a certain promise calling or", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00428-00113535-00113647": "hailing us", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00429-00113648-00113951": "the prospective participants to consider", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00430-00113952-00114263": "doing and to attempt to do something", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00431-00114264-00114358": "different", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00432-00114359-00114663": "which is to avoid treating duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00433-00114664-00115039": "and the thertismo itself as ultimately", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00434-00115040-00115375": "reducible to this real historical", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00435-00115376-00115447": "figures", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00436-00115448-00115847": "quote gruesome necro politics", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00437-00115848-00116215": "and sociopathic personality unquote", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00438-00116216-00116527": "which is the default mode emphasized and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00439-00116528-00116671": "elaborated", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00440-00116672-00117031": "by his many and multitudinous critics", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00441-00117032-00117343": "neo and neo-orientalists and concerned", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00442-00117344-00117415": "locals", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00443-00117416-00117766": "in the philippines alike", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00444-00117767-00117983": "in the eventually revised formulation", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00445-00117983-00118239": "for this round tables mandate", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00446-00118240-00118502": "i personally resonated with the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00447-00118503-00118758": "productive proposition that duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00448-00118759-00119110": "or more actually now the theratism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00449-00119111-00119527": "is the product of both quote long-term", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00450-00119528-00119902": "and short-term determinants", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00451-00119903-00120207": "hence the main topical title determining", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00452-00120208-00120343": "the third tip", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00453-00120344-00120647": "or what we in culture of studies would", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00454-00120648-00120702": "call", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00455-00120703-00120978": "over determination or multiple", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00456-00120979-00121190": "determinations", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00457-00121191-00121654": "economic political historical", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00458-00121655-00121966": "cultural or in a word", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00459-00121967-00122310": "social i would urge people to read", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00460-00122311-00122647": "the third chapter of tom's book", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00461-00122648-00122966": "for there he proposes and this is why we", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00462-00122967-00123190": "cannot expect to derive", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00463-00123191-00123454": "any enlightenment from the rather", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00464-00123455-00123614": "predictable", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00465-00123615-00123878": "mentally slothful and thus", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00466-00123879-00124110": "intellectually impoverished", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00467-00124111-00124431": "repertorial and critical writing banned", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00468-00124432-00124471": "by", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00469-00124472-00124799": "authors who are implicitly", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00470-00124800-00125119": "or often unwittingly operating from", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00471-00125120-00125502": "classic and neo-orientalist premises", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00472-00125503-00125863": "and paradigms in that chapter", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00473-00125864-00126127": "tom names some of these long-term", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00474-00126128-00126254": "determinants", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00475-00126255-00126575": "of the seemingly insoluble problem", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00476-00126576-00126783": "an interminable phenomenon of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00477-00126783-00126902": "thertismo", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00478-00126903-00127231": "with which we are confronted or if you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00479-00127232-00127334": "lied", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00480-00127335-00127751": "cursed critiquing establishmentarian", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00481-00127752-00128063": "and liberal journalists like jonathan", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00482-00128064-00128158": "miller", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00483-00128159-00128534": "with his 2018 volume duterte harry", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00484-00128535-00128886": "or james fenton and his recent reporting", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00485-00128888-00129039": "on our subject", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00486-00129040-00129351": "for the new york review of books tom", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00487-00129352-00129702": "points out that quote absent", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00488-00129703-00130007": "from their registers are terms", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00489-00130008-00130334": "such as neo-liberalism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00490-00130335-00130719": "u.s imperialism and western propaganda", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00491-00130720-00130871": "biases", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00492-00130872-00131295": "towards the non-western world and quote", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00493-00131296-00131559": "here it is important to note that these", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00494-00131560-00131687": "terms", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00495-00131688-00131990": "neoliberalism which i expect", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00496-00131991-00132278": "professor velio to discuss extensively", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00497-00132279-00132311": "or", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00498-00132312-00132639": "u.s imperialism for examples are not", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00499-00132640-00132678": "just", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00500-00132679-00132983": "terms to describe the larger and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00501-00132984-00133135": "historical", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00502-00133136-00133463": "as well as contemporary determinants", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00503-00133464-00133814": "of the turtus rise to power and that of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00504-00133815-00133943": "his not so distant", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00505-00133944-00134254": "forebear marcus and their", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00506-00134255-00134535": "commonly authoritarian style of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00507-00134536-00134702": "governance", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00508-00134703-00135007": "these terms can set the very", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00509-00135008-00135375": "terms for critical and more nuanced", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00510-00135376-00135695": "discourse making and representations", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00511-00135696-00135959": "of the philippines linked colonial", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00512-00135960-00136095": "predicaments", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00513-00136096-00136399": "under such regimes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00514-00136400-00136711": "my own term for duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00515-00136712-00137127": "is that he is only the latest", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00516-00137128-00137414": "although iconoclastic spawn so that's my", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00517-00137415-00137471": "term", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00518-00137472-00137854": "spawn of the political culture", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00519-00137855-00138047": "to which we give the name kasich", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00520-00138048-00138214": "democracy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00521-00138215-00138551": "a glaring oxymoron if there is one", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00522-00138552-00138775": "and it is a term coined by the late", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00523-00138776-00138951": "benedict anderson", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00524-00138952-00139359": "in a highly influential article", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00525-00139360-00139727": "i prefer actually the term", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00526-00139728-00140014": "formulated by the filipina historian", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00527-00140015-00140166": "ruby", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00528-00140167-00140543": "colonial democracy again", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00529-00140544-00140871": "a contradiction in terms", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00530-00140872-00141190": "the kind of political culture therefore", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00531-00141191-00141519": "fostered by the usa in the philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00532-00141520-00141727": "as a consequence of its pragmatic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00533-00141728-00141854": "decision", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00534-00141855-00142087": "during its formal rule over the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00535-00142088-00142271": "archipelago", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00536-00142272-00142607": "to develop and rely heavily", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00537-00142608-00143014": "on a comprador elite to serve as his", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00538-00143015-00143343": "administrative surrogates given its", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00539-00143344-00143463": "inability as an", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00540-00143464-00143743": "empire following general american", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00541-00143744-00143887": "disenchantment", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00542-00143888-00144151": "with this one and major experiment of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00543-00144152-00144326": "the powerful nation", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00544-00144327-00144639": "in imperial hegemony to recruit and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00545-00144640-00144719": "deploy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00546-00144720-00145278": "enough pro councils to do the job", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00547-00145279-00145583": "from the ranks of its own citizenry", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00548-00145584-00145887": "interestingly tom in his chapter hires", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00549-00145888-00146047": "the related", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00550-00146048-00146399": "but extremely suggestive strain", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00551-00146400-00146631": "so this can bring us back to the meme", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00552-00146632-00146783": "you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00553-00146784-00147078": "um duterte is merely a strain of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00554-00147079-00147214": "original virus", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00555-00147215-00147502": "right to do the work of critical", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00556-00147503-00147654": "description", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00557-00147655-00147990": "of our object in this respect it was in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00558-00147991-00148239": "the context of citing in is the third", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00559-00148240-00148607": "chapter an effort that yours", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00560-00148608-00148902": "of philippine political economy under", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00561-00148903-00149159": "the u.s directed", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00562-00149160-00149487": "neo-liberal turn characterizing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00563-00149488-00149799": "the late 20th century", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00564-00149800-00150183": "this is a black quote from the book", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00565-00150184-00150502": "as that jar cogently observes it was", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00566-00150503-00150839": "precisely the unintended consequences", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00567-00150840-00151095": "of self-interested western policy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00568-00151096-00151254": "towards the third world", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00569-00151255-00151575": "in the late 20th century that laid", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00570-00151576-00151943": "the groundwork for filipino politicians", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00571-00151944-00152239": "of duterte's strain there you go the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00572-00152240-00152351": "word", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00573-00152352-00152671": "and here citing that they are quote", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00574-00152672-00152966": "the rise of a strongman regime was a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00575-00152967-00153223": "world bank endorsed response", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00576-00153224-00153575": "to the growing and intensifying crises", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00577-00153576-00153814": "felt in the nation that is to say the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00578-00153815-00153926": "philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00579-00153927-00154199": "as a result of the political and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00580-00154200-00154366": "economic system", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00581-00154367-00154695": "installed by u.s colonization", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00582-00154696-00155047": "here being was pushed to its limits", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00583-00155048-00155399": "by the acceleration of global capital", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00584-00155400-00155711": "end quote in some", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00585-00155712-00156014": "my own provocation here boils down to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00586-00156015-00156447": "a question of political culture", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00587-00156448-00156751": "when we can speaking of spawns and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00588-00156752-00156847": "strains", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00589-00156848-00157163": "think in alternative ways of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00590-00157164-00157311": "over-determination", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00591-00157312-00157583": "with respect to the dirty smooth this is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00592-00157584-00157783": "of course in addition to the question", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00593-00157784-00158143": "of neoliberal political economy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00594-00158144-00158454": "suggested by tom's citation of the dr's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00595-00158455-00158735": "critique", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00596-00158736-00158999": "yet another aspect and i'm concluding of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00597-00159000-00159095": "this larger", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00598-00159096-00159319": "and long-term determinants of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00599-00159320-00159559": "problem and phenomenon we are examining", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00600-00159560-00159878": "as well concerns what tom", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00601-00159879-00160302": "terms quote the totalitarian drift", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00602-00160303-00160607": "in philippine politics as duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00603-00160608-00160847": "embodies and represents it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00604-00160848-00161102": "and relates to tedious critique", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00605-00161103-00161271": "assignment", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00606-00161272-00161554": "the blind spot commonly shared by", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00607-00161555-00161807": "neo-orientalist commentators", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00608-00161808-00162119": "which prevents them from recognizing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00609-00162120-00162431": "that their own classic and neo-liberal", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00610-00162432-00162559": "ideology", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00611-00162560-00162926": "has been to borrow from pankaj mishra's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00612-00162927-00163023": "formulary", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00613-00163024-00163419": "quote an incubator of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00614-00163420-00163702": "authoritarianism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00615-00163703-00164247": "thank you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00616-00164248-00164535": "um thank you oscar for that fascinating", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00617-00164536-00164631": "um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00618-00164632-00164999": "talk um let me now just um introduce um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00619-00165000-00165214": "professor walden belgium", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00620-00165215-00165575": "um who will um speak um next", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00621-00165576-00165838": "um professor walden belgium will talk", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00622-00165839-00166038": "about the political economy of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00623-00166039-00166471": "an authoritarian insurgency", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00624-00166472-00166726": "belgium is currently the international", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00625-00166727-00166935": "adjunct professor of sociology", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00626-00166936-00167223": "at the state university of new york at", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00627-00167224-00167399": "binghamton", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00628-00167400-00167647": "and co-chairperson of the bangkok-based", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00629-00167648-00167719": "research", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00630-00167720-00168038": "and advocacy institute focused on", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00631-00168039-00168395": "the global south which he co-founded in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00632-00168396-00168743": "1995", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00633-00168744-00169063": "um he served um as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00634-00169064-00169366": "a member of the house of representatives", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00635-00169367-00169526": "in the philippines from", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00636-00169527-00169975": "2009 to 2016.", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00637-00169976-00170231": "as a human rights activist since the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00638-00170232-00170502": "marcos era he is currently", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00639-00170503-00170783": "active in opposing the anti-human rights", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00640-00170784-00171023": "policies of the administration of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00641-00171024-00171326": "president rodrigo duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00642-00171327-00171575": "as a human rights and peace campaigner", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00643-00171576-00171699": "academic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00644-00171700-00171935": "environmentalists and journalists and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00645-00171936-00172135": "through a combination of courage", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00646-00172136-00172431": "as a dissident with an extraordinary", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00647-00172432-00172671": "breadth of published output and personal", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00648-00172672-00172775": "charisma", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00649-00172776-00173047": "he has made a major contribution to the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00650-00173048-00173214": "international case against", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00651-00173215-00173951": "corporate driven globalization", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00652-00173952-00174295": "um he was awarded south korea's susan", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00653-00174296-00174526": "don price in 2001", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00654-00174527-00174783": "and in 2003 he was given the right", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00655-00174784-00174943": "livelihood award", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00656-00174944-00175231": "also known as the alternative nobel", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00657-00175232-00175319": "prize", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00658-00175320-00175559": "for outstanding efforts in educating", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00659-00175560-00175702": "civil society", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00660-00175703-00175871": "about the effects of corporate", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00661-00175872-00176014": "globalization", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00662-00176015-00176295": "and how alternatives to it can be", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00663-00176296-00176447": "implemented", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00664-00176448-00176719": "the belgian newspaper lesoir called", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00665-00176720-00176907": "bellio the most respected", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00666-00176908-00177199": "anti-globalization thinker in asia", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00667-00177200-00177447": "and the canadian author naomi klein has", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00668-00177448-00177607": "called him the world's leading", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00669-00177608-00177871": "no-nonsense revolutionary", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00670-00177872-00178166": "chalmers johnson has hailed him as the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00671-00178167-00178295": "world's best guide", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00672-00178296-00178638": "to american exploitation of the globe's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00673-00178639-00179014": "poor and defenseless delia is the author", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00674-00179015-00179351": "and co-author of 25 books i'm not going", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00675-00179352-00179599": "to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00676-00179600-00180014": "list them down here he is a prolific", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00677-00180015-00180271": "thinker and author and he obtained his", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00678-00180272-00180495": "phd in sociology from princeton", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00679-00180496-00180663": "university", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00680-00180664-00180871": "with a dissertation on the roots and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00681-00180872-00181026": "dynamics of revolution and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00682-00181027-00181143": "counter-revolution", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00683-00181144-00181463": "in chile there he lived in shanky towns", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00684-00181464-00181726": "following salvador allende's rise to the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00685-00181727-00181863": "presidency", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00686-00181864-00182207": "and before he joined the philippine", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00687-00182208-00182302": "congress", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00688-00182303-00182471": "he was a full professor at the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00689-00182472-00182783": "university of the philippines at tiliman", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00690-00182784-00183087": "until 2009 when he retired from", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00691-00183088-00183423": "teaching at the university and previous", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00692-00183424-00183614": "to that he also taught at the university", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00693-00183615-00184038": "of um california berkeley", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00694-00184039-00184495": "so well done", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00695-00184496-00186766": "you your screen is yours", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00696-00186767-00187007": "okay thank you uh thank you very much", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00697-00187008-00187078": "for that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00698-00187079-00187335": "generous introduction professor galam i", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00699-00187336-00187683": "uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00700-00187684-00187902": "i have tried", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00701-00187903-00188359": "to that was sort of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00702-00188360-00188687": "as a kind of a cv that was prepared for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00703-00188688-00188831": "elections", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00704-00188832-00189166": "so i've been trying to get that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00705-00189167-00189487": "out of my website uh but uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00706-00189488-00189790": "so far unsuccessfully uh but uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00707-00189791-00190063": "tom i i guess i i gave you a very short", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00708-00190064-00190102": "one", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00709-00190103-00190423": "tom and i uh in any event", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00710-00190424-00190854": "thanks uh okay um let me begin by saying", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00711-00190855-00190950": "we are now", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00712-00190951-00191366": "uh uh close to a million infections", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00713-00191367-00191847": "uh in in terms of scholars 19", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00714-00191848-00192190": "and uh the uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00715-00192191-00192495": "fatalities rate has", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00716-00192496-00192831": "moved to uh over 15", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00717-00192832-00193199": "000 um people we", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00718-00193200-00193543": "have had a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00719-00193544-00193743": "second wave that has been quite", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00720-00193744-00193935": "devastating", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00721-00193936-00194287": "and as professor galam said to you from", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00722-00194288-00194390": "the very start", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00723-00194391-00194695": "at the very start the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00724-00194696-00194911": "duterte administration just doesn't know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00725-00194912-00195063": "what to do it's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00726-00195064-00195471": "running around as one of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00727-00195472-00195631": "broadcasters here that used to be", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00728-00195632-00195790": "sympathetic to him", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00729-00195791-00196199": "uh like a headless chicken as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00730-00196200-00196759": "that was the description of mr tulfa", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00731-00196760-00196959": "now will this make a difference in terms", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00732-00196960-00197102": "of uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00733-00197103-00197614": "mr duterte's popularity", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00734-00197615-00197966": "not sure and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00735-00197967-00198375": "um my whole presentation here", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00736-00198376-00198814": "is uh in fact", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00737-00198815-00199111": "discusses or goes to the roots of why", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00738-00199112-00199295": "i'm not sure", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00739-00199296-00199654": "uh why if this will have an impact", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00740-00199655-00199999": "on duterte's popularity uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00741-00200000-00200526": "in uh two months into the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00742-00200527-00200854": "presidency of of duterte i", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00743-00200855-00201263": "um i used the f-word for him", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00744-00201264-00201599": "in um discussion at the ateneo dominion", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00745-00201600-00201775": "university", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00746-00201776-00202190": "and um describing myself fascists then", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00747-00202191-00202654": "uh did evoke some um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00748-00202655-00203038": "disagreements from friends", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00749-00203039-00203311": "if that was in fact uh an appropriate", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00750-00203312-00203559": "description of the man", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00751-00203560-00203871": "um well uh five years", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00752-00203872-00204190": "and some 27", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00753-00204191-00204623": "000 fatalities later in the uh the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00754-00204624-00204726": "dirtiest", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00755-00204727-00205055": "so-called anti-drug war uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00756-00205056-00205446": "you know where the um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00757-00205448-00205894": "um actually judicial execution", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00758-00205896-00206246": "has been um pretty much", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00759-00206248-00206575": "uh seen by both local", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00760-00206576-00206814": "and foreign observers you know as uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00761-00206815-00206879": "having been", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00762-00206880-00207119": "you know the key method in accounting", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00763-00207119-00207246": "for this vast number", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00764-00207248-00207719": "of people who've been killed", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00765-00207719-00208036": "others would prefer to have more", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00766-00208037-00208182": "[Music]", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00767-00208183-00208614": "terms for him like a serial killer", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00768-00208615-00208886": "or mass murderer you know which would be", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00769-00208887-00209023": "you know sort of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00770-00209023-00209375": "uh be a bit more you know extreme", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00771-00209376-00209566": "than you know what i originally", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00772-00209567-00209734": "described him to be as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00773-00209735-00210071": "you know a fascist okay uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00774-00210071-00210431": "well uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00775-00210432-00210767": "so what is what you know what what", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00776-00210767-00211215": "accounted for the 30 coming to power uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00777-00211216-00211615": "well uh senator de lima", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00778-00211616-00212039": "who is uh you know probably his", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00779-00212040-00212463": "his um principal um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00780-00212464-00212719": "opponent at this point uh in terms of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00781-00212719-00212798": "her carriage", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00782-00212800-00213142": "in in in in opposing him from", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00783-00213144-00213558": "you know her uh being isolated in cam", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00784-00213559-00213639": "kramer", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00785-00213640-00213998": "the police headquarters characterized", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00786-00214000-00214303": "the 30th um one", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00787-00214304-00214631": "issue candidate uh you know that he", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00788-00214632-00214815": "basically", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00789-00214816-00215134": "uh rode on the drugs", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00790-00215135-00215479": "and peace and order issue", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00791-00215480-00215871": "now um i both agree and disagree with", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00792-00215871-00216110": "senator lima", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00793-00216111-00216391": "i agree in the sense that it was", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00794-00216392-00216542": "duterte's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00795-00216544-00216934": "genius so to speak that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00796-00216935-00217334": "made him pick on an issue that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00797-00217335-00217558": "practically all other major philippine", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00798-00217559-00217855": "politicians running for office", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00799-00217856-00218182": "would not take on because of a sense", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00800-00218183-00218215": "that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00801-00218216-00218615": "it wouldn't work or they would be seen", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00802-00218616-00218751": "as somehow", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00803-00218752-00219179": "um uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00804-00219180-00219446": "anti-poor uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00805-00219448-00219791": "or anti-liberal if", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00806-00219792-00220158": "if they took it on the the favorite", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00807-00220159-00220446": "political platform of course of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00808-00220448-00220623": "candidates for office in the philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00809-00220623-00220671": "has", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00810-00220671-00220951": "always been populism populism in the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00811-00220952-00221127": "sense of i can obtain", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00812-00221128-00221431": "more material goods for you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00813-00221432-00221663": "and it is on this basis that they have", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00814-00221664-00221767": "mobilized", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00815-00221767-00222087": "you know uh communities of the urban", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00816-00222088-00222198": "poor", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00817-00222200-00222615": "uh and other constituencies okay", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00818-00222616-00222879": "and uh that's been the classical", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00819-00222880-00223055": "philippine", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00820-00223056-00223391": "um politicians approach has been", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00821-00223392-00223703": "populism ut turkey was not a populist", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00822-00223704-00224191": "in fact uh his um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00823-00224192-00224534": "his running for office uh he made a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00824-00224535-00224734": "number a really brazen statement saying", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00825-00224735-00224839": "for instance that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00826-00224840-00225071": "you know what he was going to do is to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00827-00225071-00225223": "fill", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00828-00225223-00225415": "the waters of manila bay with the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00829-00225416-00225527": "cadavers", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00830-00225528-00225798": "of criminals you know so he was almost", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00831-00225800-00226023": "being deliberately provocative", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00832-00226023-00226446": "you know uh in terms of his incendiary", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00833-00226448-00226687": "law and order rhetoric and you know so", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00834-00226688-00226791": "that's not", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00835-00226792-00227119": "you know people like binay and others", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00836-00227119-00227591": "avoided that kind of of rhetoric", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00837-00227592-00227942": "well uh now", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00838-00227944-00228198": "there was certainly certain sectors of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00839-00228200-00228334": "the population that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00840-00228335-00228646": "that appealed to including assectors of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00841-00228648-00228919": "the urban poor", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00842-00228919-00229391": "and informal settlers who", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00843-00229392-00229710": "were bothered with the drug problem", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00844-00229711-00230063": "in their communities uh but principally", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00845-00230064-00230198": "the appeal was to the elite in the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00846-00230200-00230287": "middle classes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00847-00230288-00230623": "you know the sense of security that that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00848-00230623-00230871": "that this is something that had not been", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00849-00230871-00230942": "addressed", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00850-00230944-00231327": "by many politicians but duterte put it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00851-00231328-00231663": "in the forefront and comparatively", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00852-00231664-00231775": "speaking", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00853-00231776-00232071": "uh we can also see that other people of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00854-00232071-00232246": "duterte's tried to have done this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00855-00232248-00232967": "successfully for instance in brazil", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00856-00232967-00233455": "but uh i think though that um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00857-00233456-00233767": "the support for the turkey really", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00858-00233767-00233882": "stemmed", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00859-00233883-00234175": "from people projecting", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00860-00234176-00234510": "into him what they wanted him to be", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00861-00234511-00234855": "okay and uh and this is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00862-00234856-00235134": "a very important in terms of the psycho", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00863-00235135-00235327": "social psychology of movements", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00864-00235328-00235606": "including you know extreme right", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00865-00235607-00235663": "movements", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00866-00235664-00236015": "or fascist movements that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00867-00236016-00236358": "um basically my sense", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00868-00236359-00236727": "is that they saw the iron hand", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00869-00236728-00237031": "that he projected", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00870-00237032-00237358": "as a patriarch", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00871-00237359-00237694": "okay as a disciplinarian that he would", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00872-00237696-00237831": "have exercised against", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00873-00237832-00238175": "criminals okay they saw that iron hand", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00874-00238176-00238198": "as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00875-00238200-00238615": "something that he would also uh use", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00876-00238616-00239046": "against corrupt politicians", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00877-00239048-00239391": "uh against sectors of the elite", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00878-00239392-00239742": "okay uh and you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00879-00239744-00240063": "basically uh especially when it came to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00880-00240064-00240327": "corruption there was just tremendous", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00881-00240328-00240510": "you know dissatisfaction throughout", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00882-00240511-00240719": "philippine society and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00883-00240719-00241015": "although that was not his major platform", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00884-00241016-00241110": "it did seem", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00885-00241111-00241430": "like his disciplinary approach", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00886-00241431-00241727": "sort of resonated with people's desire", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00887-00241728-00241775": "you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00888-00241776-00242087": "for a con you know to deal with with", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00889-00242088-00242342": "with corruption", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00890-00242344-00242694": "and of course he was seen by many", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00891-00242696-00243039": "as the person who would finally write", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00892-00243040-00243342": "you know all the wrongs that had been", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00893-00243344-00243430": "experienced", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00894-00243431-00243742": "you know over the last several decades", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00895-00243744-00244055": "in terms of political promises you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00896-00244056-00244398": "for advancement prosperity but", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00897-00244400-00244719": "where you know over 30 years", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00898-00244719-00244975": "you know the so-called edsa republic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00899-00244976-00245223": "that was founded in 1986", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00900-00245223-00245575": "had foundered and had not delivered", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00901-00245576-00245823": "and i will go into that more at the end", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00902-00245823-00246119": "of this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00903-00246119-00246551": "well so", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00904-00246552-00246719": "another thing that i would like to bring", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00905-00246719-00246855": "up here is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00906-00246856-00247206": "um you know that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00907-00247207-00247542": "um whether we like it or not the guy is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00908-00247544-00247727": "charismatic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00909-00247728-00248055": "okay now he is he doesn't have the same", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00910-00248056-00248215": "kind of charisma as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00911-00248216-00248575": "modi which is a more inspirational sort", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00912-00248576-00248951": "okay um but he is charismatic in his own", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00913-00248952-00249006": "way", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00914-00249007-00249327": "in fact his brazenness", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00915-00249328-00249582": "and the way that he deliberately you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00916-00249583-00249687": "know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00917-00249688-00250094": "you know be misogynistic uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00918-00250096-00250398": "and provocative uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00919-00250400-00250839": "and um anti-god", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00920-00250840-00251271": "uh you know somehow", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00921-00251271-00251663": "that mix goes into you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00922-00251664-00251927": "you know a charisma that i think", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00923-00251928-00251991": "accounts", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00924-00251992-00252327": "for according to the surveys back in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00925-00252328-00252406": "november", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00926-00252407-00252742": "something like an 89 to 90", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00927-00252744-00253063": "approval rating so there is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00928-00253064-00253327": "you know there is something in his", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00929-00253328-00253423": "appeal that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00930-00253423-00253846": "cuts across glasses and cuts across", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00931-00253848-00254191": "sectors and again when we look at", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00932-00254192-00254358": "charisma", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00933-00254359-00254575": "we must always remember what max weber", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00934-00254576-00254791": "said that we're not just", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00935-00254792-00255030": "this is not just an innate trait in a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00936-00255031-00255215": "personality", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00937-00255216-00255615": "but charisma is also dependent on", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00938-00255616-00255991": "the viewer the one you know that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00939-00255992-00256198": "he relates to that the charismatic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00940-00256200-00256342": "person relates to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00941-00256344-00256719": "okay and i think that is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00942-00256719-00256991": "very important in terms of understanding", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00943-00256992-00257119": "duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00944-00257119-00257487": "the social construction of charisma", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00945-00257488-00257855": "in a context of many extremely", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00946-00257856-00258215": "dissatisfied resentful and angry", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00947-00258216-00258527": "people because of the failures of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00948-00258528-00258671": "previous political", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00949-00258671-00259079": "regime so among other things i think", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00950-00259080-00259158": "what", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00951-00259159-00259503": "charisma does is you know something very", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00952-00259504-00259623": "interesting", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00953-00259623-00259798": "you know from my talks and interviews", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00954-00259800-00260063": "with people", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00955-00260064-00260375": "they may not agree with everything the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00956-00260376-00260430": "guy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00957-00260431-00260639": "says or represents in fact they may", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00958-00260640-00260798": "disagree", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00959-00260800-00261142": "with say his you know policies", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00960-00261144-00261694": "on um due process and human rights", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00961-00261696-00261967": "but they're willing to give them the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00962-00261967-00262079": "benefit of the doubt", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00963-00262080-00262327": "because they agree strongly on certain", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00964-00262328-00262423": "points", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00965-00262424-00262799": "okay now for instance let me just", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00966-00262800-00263110": "you know it has been remarked that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00967-00263111-00263487": "you know quite a number of people", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00968-00263488-00264103": "um who had been on the left", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00969-00264104-00264415": "joined duterte and in fact", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00970-00264416-00264839": "became partisans of his", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00971-00264840-00265199": "i will not mention names but uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00972-00265200-00265623": "when you asked them why", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00973-00265624-00266047": "they had a sense that okay yeah the guys", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00974-00266048-00266239": "we don't agree with what he's doing in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00975-00266240-00266439": "terms of the drug war", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00976-00266440-00266727": "he's killing people with extra digital", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00977-00266728-00266871": "methods but", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00978-00266872-00267175": "he does represent a possibility for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00979-00267176-00267247": "reform", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00980-00267248-00267543": "of social reform now in the first year", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00981-00267544-00267830": "or second year of the third day", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00982-00267831-00268110": "you met you met ex-progressives that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00983-00268111-00268199": "thought that way", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00984-00268200-00268591": "that you know you know they didn't agree", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00985-00268592-00268967": "with his extrajudicial methods", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00986-00268968-00269271": "but when it came to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00987-00269272-00269903": "the possibility of reform social reform", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00988-00269904-00270119": "you know to make the philippines less of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00989-00270120-00270303": "an elitist system", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00990-00270304-00270519": "that's what they were banking on and why", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00991-00270520-00270639": "they were willing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00992-00270640-00271006": "to to sort of swallow some of their", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00993-00271007-00271103": "doubts", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00994-00271104-00271479": "about uh and his", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00995-00271480-00271863": "and his methods", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00996-00271864-00272271": "so um uh the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00997-00272272-00272487": "last thing that i would just like to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00998-00272488-00272655": "mention here", "QM-rh_vWCzY-00999-00272656-00273082": "is has to do with the um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01000-00273083-00273327": "dissatisfaction uh with", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01001-00273328-00273639": "the uh 30 year old", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01002-00273640-00273958": "um edsa", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01003-00273959-00274303": "people's power regime that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01004-00274304-00274623": "uh you know in 2016", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01005-00274624-00275151": "it was its 30th year i think that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01006-00275152-00275423": "there was a great deal of across the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01007-00275424-00275551": "board", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01008-00275552-00275910": "you know um happiness", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01009-00275911-00276215": "relief when marcos got out", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01010-00276216-00276575": "and uh what we had", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01011-00276576-00276975": "was basically um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01012-00276976-00277319": "you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01013-00277320-00277687": "a democratic republic that was reborn as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01014-00277688-00278015": "uh as it were with", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01015-00278016-00278279": "you know a human rights constitution one", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01016-00278280-00278358": "of the most", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01017-00278359-00278582": "advanced human rights constitutions in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01018-00278583-00278999": "the world if you if you read it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01019-00279000-00279327": "but as the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01020-00279328-00279782": "30-year history unfolded", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01021-00279783-00280127": "what we had was one disappointment", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01022-00280128-00280471": "after another okay um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01023-00280472-00280806": "corey aquino promises land reform", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01024-00280807-00280982": "then she's the first to go back in it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01025-00280983-00281206": "because her family", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01026-00281207-00281471": "um you know she doesn't want to land", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01027-00281472-00281671": "reform the family estate", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01028-00281672-00282110": "the you know the uh hacienda louisita", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01029-00282111-00282430": "um and that was you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01030-00282431-00282887": "a big big big setback okay uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01031-00282888-00283143": "ramos comes to power fidel ramos and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01032-00283144-00283310": "what he does is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01033-00283311-00283639": "he basically um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01034-00283640-00283919": "becomes the local agent of neoliberal", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01035-00283920-00283991": "policy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01036-00283992-00284310": "i mean if you look at it all the tna", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01037-00284311-00284399": "liberal policies", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01038-00284400-00284727": "were set up under ramas okay uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01039-00284728-00284975": "including the entry into the world trade", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01040-00284976-00285158": "organization", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01041-00285159-00285415": "the tariff reductions that has that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01042-00285416-00285503": "destroyed", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01043-00285504-00285854": "our manufacturing and of course", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01044-00285855-00286199": "you know the all the measures", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01045-00286200-00286510": "that were imposed by the wto that has", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01046-00286511-00286606": "destroyed", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01047-00286607-00286958": "our agriculture um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01048-00286959-00287310": "and and then we had under joseph strada", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01049-00287311-00287703": "and um gloria capagal arroyo um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01050-00287704-00288047": "um uh the reign of corruption", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01051-00288048-00288367": "especially under gloria um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01052-00288368-00288767": "and so there was just this sense", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01053-00288768-00289139": "that uh when it came to the elections of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01054-00289140-00289279": "2010", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01055-00289280-00289630": "we had um somebody running for president", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01056-00289631-00289967": "who seemed to have captured", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01057-00289968-00290310": "the pulse of the masses", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01058-00290311-00290854": "with his slogan", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01059-00290855-00291223": "which said", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01060-00291224-00291551": "there are no poor people where", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01061-00291552-00291754": "you know there are no corrupt", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01062-00291755-00291895": "politicians", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01063-00291896-00292206": "okay this was nina aquino the son of of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01064-00292207-00292439": "corey akina", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01065-00292440-00292854": "okay so he comes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01066-00292855-00293023": "you know this administration comes to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01067-00293024-00293158": "power in fact my", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01068-00293159-00293471": "former a former party", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01069-00293472-00293767": "aligned with it and i was initially one", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01070-00293768-00293887": "of the supporters", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01071-00293888-00294230": "of the administration", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01072-00294231-00294606": "as a representative of my former party", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01073-00294607-00294934": "in the house of representatives", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01074-00294935-00295567": "but what happens is you know that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01075-00295568-00295799": "we begin to see the practice of global", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01076-00295800-00295910": "standards", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01077-00295911-00296206": "you know the regime or the aquino", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01078-00296207-00296406": "administration goes after its enemies", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01079-00296407-00296623": "one with the anti-corruption platform", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01080-00296624-00296710": "but protects", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01081-00296711-00297054": "its people who are also you know seen", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01082-00297055-00297358": "as engaging in corruption okay and the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01083-00297359-00297423": "big", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01084-00297424-00297767": "big big scandal of the akina period was", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01085-00297768-00298215": "the um disbursement acceleration program", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01086-00298216-00298510": "and which was caught up by his budget", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01087-00298511-00298654": "minister", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01088-00298655-00299015": "but which really involved you know using", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01089-00299016-00299454": "um um political funds presidential funds", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01090-00299455-00299575": "budgetary funds", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01091-00299576-00299871": "okay uh in order to punish his enemies", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01092-00299872-00300015": "and to reward his", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01093-00300016-00300415": "followers and um there also was", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01094-00300416-00300643": "the refusal to accept command", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01095-00300644-00300815": "responsibility", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01096-00300816-00301167": "uh for what was known as the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01097-00301168-00301423": "mama's happening massacre okay where", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01098-00301424-00301630": "akina ordered", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01099-00301631-00301975": "the police to go after uh uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01100-00301976-00302230": "a quote-unquote terrorist at the behest", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01101-00302231-00302382": "of the united states and when that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01102-00302383-00302463": "failed", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01103-00302464-00302663": "he refused to accept responsibility for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01104-00302664-00303030": "it and put it down the line", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01105-00303031-00303310": "in terms of uh just a personal note here", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01106-00303311-00303503": "that's when i decided that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01107-00303504-00303782": "i couldn't no longer remain in the house", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01108-00303783-00304039": "of representatives", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01109-00304040-00304391": "a party that had allied with athena", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01110-00304392-00304975": "and that's why i resigned back in 2015", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01111-00304976-00305303": "um because it was just untenable", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01112-00305304-00305719": "you know morally speaking uh to support", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01113-00305720-00306063": "uh presidency that was practicing global", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01114-00306064-00306271": "standards now the reason i go", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01115-00306272-00306639": "in some detail into this is i think that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01116-00306640-00306903": "sets up the stage for the appeal of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01117-00306904-00307015": "duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01118-00307016-00307271": "that it was one of the big factors you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01119-00307272-00307358": "know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01120-00307359-00307687": "uh that um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01121-00307688-00307895": "i think we also saw it in the case of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01122-00307896-00307991": "brazil", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01123-00307992-00308375": "okay now in the case of brazil", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01124-00308376-00308782": "the previous regimes before um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01125-00308783-00309199": "the workers party of lula and bedilma", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01126-00309200-00309534": "were far more corrupt you know than", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01127-00309535-00309823": "when the workers party took office but", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01128-00309824-00309999": "okay", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01129-00310000-00310310": "the thing is they were", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01130-00310311-00310687": "um they didn't", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01131-00310688-00311015": "they did not have this moralistic image", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01132-00311016-00311327": "that they were going to tame corruption", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01133-00311328-00311639": "okay uh and i think this was the same", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01134-00311640-00311751": "thing that happened", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01135-00311752-00312191": "with aquino and his people like rojas", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01136-00312192-00312495": "and that sort of thing that uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01137-00312496-00312847": "you know when when double standards", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01138-00312848-00313191": "begin to operate then i think hypocrisy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01139-00313192-00313527": "you know has greater wages", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01140-00313528-00313847": "in terms of what it it it accepts", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01141-00313848-00314175": "than outright you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01142-00314176-00314551": "dishonesty okay uh so", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01143-00314552-00314863": "let me just say therefore that um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01144-00314864-00315191": "two things one is uh when you look at", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01145-00315192-00315319": "the ideals", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01146-00315320-00315710": "of the 1987 constitution", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01147-00315711-00316175": "and its political social economic ideals", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01148-00316176-00316358": "and compare that to in fact what", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01149-00316359-00316558": "happened okay", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01150-00316559-00316791": "uh and the record so that by the end of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01151-00316792-00316910": "the government uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01152-00316911-00317223": "of aquino um 28", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01153-00317224-00317527": "of filipinos were still in poverty", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01154-00317528-00317839": "the inequality rate like genetic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01155-00317840-00317934": "coefficient was", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01156-00317935-00318254": "one of the highest in in in asia", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01157-00318255-00318495": "and practically all social reform", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01158-00318496-00318582": "initiatives", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01159-00318583-00318895": "had failed that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01160-00318896-00319358": "sort of is very important in explaining", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01161-00319359-00319710": "why duterte appealed", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01162-00319711-00319934": "the final thing that i would like to end", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01163-00319935-00320095": "up with is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01164-00320096-00320399": "in 1986", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01165-00320400-00320606": "many of the people in the barricades on", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01166-00320607-00320879": "the forefront of the ed's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01167-00320880-00321215": "revolution as it was called or at", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01168-00321216-00321591": "uprising came from the middle class", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01169-00321592-00321951": "okay came from the middle class both", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01170-00321952-00322239": "you know the the middle middle class as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01171-00322240-00322327": "well as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01172-00322328-00322703": "what christophe jafarila the the the the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01173-00322704-00323054": "french uh economists uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01174-00323055-00323319": "uh describing india would call the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01175-00323320-00323679": "aspiring middle class", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01176-00323680-00324015": "those sectors um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01177-00324016-00324406": "largely went for duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01178-00324407-00324734": "in 2016 and i would say that they", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01179-00324735-00325047": "continued to be the backbone of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01180-00325048-00325343": "the support for him because the middle", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01181-00325344-00325606": "class and the aspiring middle class", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01182-00325607-00325791": "people not necessarily middle class and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01183-00325792-00325991": "income but aspiring to be", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01184-00325992-00326254": "these are also what someone called the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01185-00326255-00326375": "chattering classes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01186-00326376-00326519": "you know they're the ones that form", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01187-00326520-00326695": "public opinion okay", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01188-00326696-00326958": "and they're the ones that have been", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01189-00326959-00327054": "actively", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01190-00327055-00327375": "creating a consensus for the turkey okay", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01191-00327376-00327758": "and uh the poorer people", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01192-00327759-00328095": "the lower classes i think to use gramsci", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01193-00328096-00328630": "they would be more of i would say", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01194-00328631-00328951": "uh passive consensus okay i mean these", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01195-00328952-00329047": "are imperfect", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01196-00329048-00329263": "terms but this you know we grapple for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01197-00329264-00329375": "these terms at this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01198-00329376-00329710": "at this point in time so let me just end", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01199-00329711-00329767": "by", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01200-00329768-00330239": "saying you know that um um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01201-00330240-00330878": "we hope that people will finally", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01202-00330879-00331239": "realize that this is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01203-00331240-00331503": "a fascist regime that has led the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01204-00331504-00331882": "country to nowhere", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01205-00331883-00332175": "but uh at the same time we must realize", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01206-00332176-00332351": "that the factors that have", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01207-00332352-00332654": "helped create it are very strong and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01208-00332655-00332703": "will not", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01209-00332704-00333078": "easily you know go away", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01210-00333079-00333391": "my last word here is two things one is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01211-00333392-00333439": "you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01212-00333440-00333775": "um as an", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01213-00333776-00333951": "activist i think that there are two", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01214-00333952-00334110": "things that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01215-00334111-00334406": "we really must hold on to first of all", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01216-00334407-00334606": "we must hold the line on human rights", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01217-00334607-00334982": "and due process um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01218-00334983-00335319": "that may not be as popular today", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01219-00335320-00335671": "as before but", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01220-00335672-00335910": "i i think that at some point a new", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01221-00335911-00335999": "generation", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01222-00336000-00336303": "will respect the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01223-00336304-00336606": "for the focus that we put on it okay and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01224-00336607-00336687": "that i am", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01225-00336688-00336854": "quite confident that this coming", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01226-00336855-00336991": "generation of filipinos", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01227-00336992-00337295": "in fact will really", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01228-00337296-00337599": "go back to our you know our concerns and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01229-00337600-00337934": "values and human rights", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01230-00337935-00338278": "the second thing is um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01231-00338279-00338687": "i think that especially in 2022", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01232-00338688-00339078": "any opposition to duterte cannot just", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01233-00339079-00339391": "be offering a return to the old not just", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01234-00339392-00339791": "offering hey let's uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01235-00339792-00340078": "you know a return or what is perceived", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01236-00340079-00340230": "to be elite democracy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01237-00340231-00340415": "because that's just going to be", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01238-00340416-00340599": "perceived as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01239-00340600-00340991": "a return to the yellow democracy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01240-00340992-00341303": "because as you know the color yellow has", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01241-00341304-00341510": "now become so pejorative because of its", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01242-00341511-00341647": "association", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01243-00341648-00342006": "with elite hypocrisy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01244-00342007-00342327": "uh but we do have to really offer a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01245-00342328-00342399": "vision", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01246-00342400-00342727": "of a progressive vision that really puts", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01247-00342728-00342895": "equality", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01248-00342896-00343134": "in the realization of equality at the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01249-00343135-00343391": "center of things", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01250-00343392-00343854": "and um and participatory democracy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01251-00343855-00344039": "and that is the challenge i think to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01252-00344040-00344319": "progressives that is the challenge to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01253-00344320-00344630": "the left and unless we can make that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01254-00344631-00344815": "vision more attractive", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01255-00344816-00345191": "than the kind of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01256-00345192-00345519": "charismatic kind of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01257-00345520-00345887": "populist", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01258-00345888-00346199": "vision a populist meaning you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01259-00346200-00346454": "not the sort of material i give you well", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01260-00346455-00346527": "you know but", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01261-00346528-00346910": "the kind of the dirty populist vision uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01262-00346911-00347263": "we might have a successor regime", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01263-00347264-00347582": "you know that will in fact continue", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01264-00347583-00347919": "the transformation of the philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01265-00347920-00348303": "into an authoritarian uh polity", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01266-00348304-00348663": "so 2022 is going to be very decisive", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01267-00348664-00348871": "it cannot be fought on the terrain of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01268-00348872-00348975": "personalities", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01269-00348976-00349143": "it really has to be fought on the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01270-00349144-00349343": "terrain of visions", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01271-00349344-00349647": "and programs and there are of course", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01272-00349648-00349734": "people that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01273-00349735-00350006": "say oh you know filipinos don't", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01274-00350007-00350158": "appreciate programs", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01275-00350159-00350375": "you know they you know you know they", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01276-00350376-00350471": "just", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01277-00350472-00350647": "go with personalities and that sort of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01278-00350648-00350967": "thing i fully disagree with that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01279-00350968-00351351": "position i think continuing the same", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01280-00351352-00351599": "sort of personalistic politics", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01281-00351600-00351967": "is going to doom us into", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01282-00351968-00352303": "a prolonged era of personalist", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01283-00352304-00352839": "dictatorship thank you very much", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01284-00352840-00353023": "thank you professor walden belly for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01285-00353024-00353175": "that um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01286-00353176-00353478": "very insightful and rich um presentation", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01287-00353479-00353551": "i think", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01288-00353552-00353734": "there will be plenty there that we could", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01289-00353735-00353934": "um discuss", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01290-00353935-00354278": "um in the q a let me just remind the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01291-00354279-00354430": "audience here that if you have any", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01292-00354431-00354671": "questions please use the chat", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01293-00354672-00354919": "box to write them down and we will read", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01294-00354920-00355158": "them later on during the q a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01295-00355159-00355463": "we'll now move on to joseph", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01296-00355464-00355782": "for your presentation", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01297-00355783-00356087": "yes uh thank you derek uh just one", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01298-00356088-00356558": "moment while i share my screen here", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01299-00356559-00356887": "everyone should now be able to see uh my", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01300-00356888-00357175": "slides uh can i get a nod from you tom", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01301-00357176-00357287": "if you can", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01302-00357288-00357543": "all right great thank you uh thanks very", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01303-00357544-00357695": "much for organizing this this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01304-00357696-00357887": "is a really fascinating and i think", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01305-00357888-00358078": "important uh panel", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01306-00358079-00358319": "uh dealing with a critical uh political", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01307-00358320-00358482": "question uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01308-00358483-00358815": "the presidency of rodrigo duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01309-00358816-00359039": "its origins its trajectory and its", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01310-00359040-00359134": "implications", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01311-00359135-00359454": "uh my talk this uh this meeting morning", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01312-00359455-00359678": "afternoon evening evening my time", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01313-00359679-00359927": "is uh embracing a fascist how the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01314-00359928-00360095": "communist party of the philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01315-00360096-00360327": "facilitated and endorsed duterte's rise", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01316-00360328-00360430": "to power", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01317-00360431-00360695": "uh i i wish i could share professor", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01318-00360696-00360863": "campomana's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01319-00360864-00361167": "feeling of boredom with duterte uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01320-00361168-00361303": "i understand what he's attempting to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01321-00361304-00361519": "articulate but this the feelings that i", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01322-00361520-00361582": "have", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01323-00361583-00361982": "are simultaneously one of horror", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01324-00361983-00362358": "and of outrage and i want to lay talk", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01325-00362359-00362687": "a facet of what made possible uh the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01326-00362688-00362806": "rise to power", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01327-00362807-00363015": "of duterte in the philippines uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01328-00363016-00363167": "professor bellio has laid out some", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01329-00363168-00363254": "really important", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01330-00363255-00363439": "that i i think are helpful and i will", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01331-00363440-00363582": "build off of some of them", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01332-00363583-00363839": "uh in particular uh the statement that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01333-00363840-00363887": "uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01334-00363888-00364095": "duterte's appeal was principally to the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01335-00364096-00364199": "elite and the middle class", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01336-00364200-00364423": "i think that is correct i think that is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01337-00364424-00364623": "the sociological basis", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01338-00364624-00364854": "of sort of the the core of support for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01339-00364855-00364943": "duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01340-00364944-00365310": "um and second the outline of sort of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01341-00365311-00365615": "elite democracy uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01342-00365616-00365903": "since 1986 was very useful and i will be", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01343-00365904-00366078": "i will be building on that as well", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01344-00366079-00366391": "i think we can't understand the rise of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01345-00366392-00366575": "duterte in the philippines as a national", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01346-00366576-00366639": "phenomenon", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01347-00366640-00366806": "certainly there are all sorts of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01348-00366807-00367087": "national peculiarities but we cannot", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01349-00367088-00367319": "overlook the fact that he emerges in the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01350-00367320-00367510": "context of a rising tide of global", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01351-00367511-00367615": "authoritarianism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01352-00367616-00367871": "that he shares a common geopolitical dna", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01353-00367872-00368006": "of social dna", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01354-00368007-00368415": "with trump and bolsonaro and the afd in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01355-00368416-00368719": "germany and so on that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01356-00368720-00368903": "whatever their difference is there is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01357-00368904-00369078": "nonetheless an unmistakable", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01358-00369079-00369382": "and concurrent rise of the far right", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01359-00369383-00369606": "um it expresses conditions of social", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01360-00369607-00369695": "crisis", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01361-00369696-00369839": "it expresses preparations for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01362-00369840-00370095": "authoritarian rule the question for us", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01363-00370096-00370295": "is why is this emerging why is it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01364-00370296-00370558": "specifically emerging in the philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01365-00370559-00370887": "uh and what facilitated this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01366-00370888-00371151": "now for my talk i want to talk about the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01367-00371152-00371206": "the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01368-00371207-00371695": "role played in this by stalinism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01369-00371696-00371967": "at its outset in order to be able to do", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01370-00371968-00372071": "this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01371-00372072-00372302": "i have to address the question of red", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01372-00372303-00372478": "tagging which has become", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01373-00372479-00372799": "a sort of mccarthyism under the duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01374-00372800-00372999": "administration particularly over the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01375-00373000-00373102": "last year", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01376-00373103-00373310": "uh it is the assertion that anyone who", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01377-00373311-00373415": "is putting forward", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01378-00373416-00373630": "an oppositional perspective or is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01379-00373631-00373991": "associated with a political organization", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01380-00373992-00374230": "that is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01381-00374231-00374423": "opposed the current social order or to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01382-00374424-00374567": "the duterte administration", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01383-00374568-00374823": "is de facto a communist and that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01384-00374824-00375054": "therefore they should be subject to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01385-00375055-00375430": "uh harassment etc both uh harassment by", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01386-00375431-00375663": "non-state actors online and in person", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01387-00375664-00375839": "and by the police and military and make", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01388-00375840-00376071": "no mistake this has led to a mounting", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01389-00376072-00376310": "death toll people killed in their homes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01390-00376311-00376567": "and police raids etc", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01391-00376568-00376854": "um and it is necessary therefore to be", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01392-00376855-00376958": "explicit", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01393-00376959-00377095": "that when you are examining the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01394-00377096-00377382": "political line of evolved", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01395-00377383-00377695": "and of the stalinist party and of what", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01396-00377696-00377815": "we will term", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01397-00377816-00378071": "uh the broad national democratic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01398-00378072-00378151": "movement", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01399-00378152-00378391": "i am not in any way associating any of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01400-00378392-00378543": "these organizations directly with the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01401-00378544-00378671": "new people's army", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01402-00378672-00378871": "one feels compelled to return to the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01403-00378872-00379087": "fact that it is in fact you're leaving", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01404-00379088-00379406": "in the philippines um and that what is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01405-00379407-00379775": "going on a assault on civil liberties", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01406-00379776-00380095": "um that said it is simultaneously", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01407-00380096-00380278": "necessary to bear in mind", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01408-00380279-00380510": "that there is nonetheless coherent", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01409-00380511-00380882": "political perspective that is shared", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01410-00380883-00381039": "abroad", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01411-00381040-00381247": "known as national democratic movement", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01412-00381248-00381430": "that shares a common political line with", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01413-00381431-00381623": "the communist party of the philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01414-00381624-00381910": "an orientation a national democratic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01415-00381911-00382039": "revolution", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01416-00382040-00382334": "and carrying of that out by means of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01417-00382335-00382702": "various social mechanisms of alliances", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01418-00382703-00382851": "with what they have termed the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01419-00382852-00383030": "progressive section", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01420-00383031-00383334": "of the national bourgeoisie this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01421-00383335-00383558": "then is the programmatic underpinning", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01422-00383559-00383734": "for the historical material that i'm", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01423-00383735-00384310": "about to lay out", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01424-00384311-00384615": "it was given by the cpe and by the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01425-00384616-00384958": "national democratic movement", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01426-00384959-00385239": "was brought behind the platform of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01427-00385240-00385358": "duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01428-00385359-00385734": "because of the perspective of stalinism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01429-00385735-00385951": "now when people think of felonism they", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01430-00385952-00386078": "will almost certainly and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01431-00386079-00386406": "correctly think of show trials", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01432-00386407-00386710": "purges uh falsification of historians", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01433-00386711-00386910": "and all of the many", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01434-00386911-00387223": "brutal expressences of the stalinist", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01435-00387224-00387415": "bureaucracy that we know from the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01436-00387416-00387606": "history of the 20th century", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01437-00387607-00387927": "that is not incorrect but it is i argue", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01438-00387928-00388287": "an epiphenomenon it is the organic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01439-00388288-00388519": "outgrowth of the essence of the matter", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01440-00388520-00388799": "the essence of stalinism is a political", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01441-00388800-00388934": "program that serves", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01442-00388935-00389102": "certain economic interests the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01443-00389103-00389271": "privileged", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01444-00389272-00389478": "it's of the bureaucracy in moscow and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01445-00389479-00389575": "beijing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01446-00389576-00389878": "as well as certain layers within", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01447-00389879-00390063": "the countries where communist parties", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01448-00390064-00390310": "operated what was that program", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01449-00390311-00390447": "now i've gone into this in greater", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01450-00390448-00390615": "length and i don't have that much time", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01451-00390616-00390687": "now", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01452-00390688-00390895": "so i'm going to go into it in this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01453-00390896-00391095": "somewhat rudimentary fashion", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01454-00391096-00391254": "if you're interested i would encourage", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01455-00391255-00391406": "you to watch a talk i gave", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01456-00391407-00391687": "last year it's available on youtube uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01457-00391688-00391895": "it's called first is tragedy second is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01458-00391896-00392102": "farce and i explore this in more detail", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01459-00392103-00392223": "there", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01460-00392224-00392591": "at its essence stalinism is a program", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01461-00392592-00392902": "of nationalism and it dresses up this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01462-00392903-00393263": "nationalism in the language of marxism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01463-00393264-00393534": "but it puts forward the argument that in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01464-00393535-00393710": "countries of belated capitalist", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01465-00393711-00393791": "development", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01466-00393792-00394006": "the tasks of the revolution confronting", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01467-00394007-00394167": "the working class the peasantry the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01468-00394168-00394319": "oppressed masses", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01469-00394320-00394639": "is not yet socialist it is national and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01470-00394640-00394815": "democratic in character", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01471-00394816-00395110": "land reform et cetera and that because", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01472-00395111-00395375": "these tasks are not yet socialist", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01473-00395376-00395615": "a section of the national bourgeoisie", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01474-00395616-00395767": "this is the term used the pambansan", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01475-00395768-00395902": "borgesia", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01476-00395903-00396158": "is going to play a progressive role and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01477-00396159-00396447": "should allied with", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01478-00396448-00396663": "and the history of stalinism around the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01479-00396664-00396775": "world", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01480-00396776-00396943": "including in the philippines is a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01481-00396944-00397199": "history of a series of attempts to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01482-00397200-00397463": "form tactical alliances with sections of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01483-00397464-00397534": "the elite", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01484-00397535-00397719": "in the name of the national democratic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01485-00397720-00397975": "revolution the alliance with duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01486-00397976-00398223": "was a particularly vicious example of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01487-00398224-00398430": "this political program", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01488-00398431-00398599": "dressing up a relationship with a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01489-00398600-00398782": "section of the elite in the language", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01490-00398783-00399167": "of marxism the next", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01491-00399168-00399382": "prerequisite for understanding this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01492-00399383-00399502": "phenomena", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01493-00399503-00399927": "is recognizing that rodrigo duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01494-00399928-00400230": "was a known political type", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01495-00400231-00400647": "long before his rise to the presidency", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01496-00400648-00400871": "it is not as if the kindly mayor of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01497-00400872-00401071": "davao was miraculously", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01498-00401072-00401391": "transferred to a fascistic figure", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01499-00401392-00401734": "when he was elected to office in 2016.", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01500-00401735-00401943": "duterte was the head of death squads", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01501-00401944-00402119": "paramilitary organizations", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01502-00402120-00402487": "a vulgar fascistic figure from the 1980s", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01503-00402488-00402902": "until 2016. it was his political", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01504-00402903-00402982": "character", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01505-00402983-00403206": "he shared it with a great many local", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01506-00403207-00403367": "mayors to be blunt", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01507-00403368-00403510": "but he was the mayor of a more", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01508-00403511-00403727": "influential city davao", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01509-00403728-00403910": "and he was brought onto the national", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01510-00403911-00404110": "stage in the 2010s", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01511-00404111-00404334": "until he became a viable presidential", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01512-00404335-00404551": "candidate 2015", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01513-00404552-00404871": "2016. this then is the character of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01514-00404872-00404967": "duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01515-00404968-00405206": "there was no mystery as to what he", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01516-00405207-00405319": "represented", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01517-00405320-00405623": "it was a fascistic and authoritarian", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01518-00405624-00406082": "figure who was being brought to the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01519-00406083-00406367": "fore the communist party of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01520-00406368-00406454": "philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01521-00406455-00406719": "and its allied organizations or its or", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01522-00406720-00406806": "organizations that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01523-00406807-00407182": "share a common political line with it uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01524-00407183-00407478": "bayern and company cultivated relations", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01525-00407479-00407775": "with duterte in davao over the course", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01526-00407776-00408054": "of decades i am going to go through", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01527-00408055-00408127": "their role", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01528-00408128-00408463": "in facilitating his rise to nationalism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01529-00408464-00408758": "of his presidency in a very quick", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01530-00408759-00408902": "fashion", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01531-00408903-00409167": "but they cultivated relations with him", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01532-00409168-00409382": "electoral relations over the course of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01533-00409383-00409527": "multiple decades", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01534-00409528-00409839": "from it here you can see duterte in 2015", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01535-00409839-00409878": "and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01536-00409879-00410207": "davao speaking at the wake of the an npa", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01537-00410208-00410374": "commander leoncio pipao", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01538-00410375-00410534": "he's been given the stage by the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01539-00410535-00410695": "communist party of the philippines the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01540-00410696-00411070": "banner behind him reads", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01541-00411071-00411222": "you can see him standing in front of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01542-00411223-00411439": "hammer and sickle flag bear in mind this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01543-00411439-00411682": "is the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01544-00411683-00411799": "red", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01545-00411800-00412078": "over the course of the 2016 election the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01546-00412079-00412247": "communist party of the philippines and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01547-00412247-00412447": "its various affiliated organizations", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01548-00412447-00412655": "threw themselves behind the duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01549-00412656-00412759": "candidacy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01550-00412760-00412926": "they had in fact formally allied", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01551-00412927-00413078": "themselves with the candidates", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01552-00413079-00413295": "foe but in the southern islands of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01553-00413296-00413463": "visayas and in the now", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01554-00413464-00413887": "organizations such as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01555-00413888-00414095": "campaign for duterte they did not in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01556-00414096-00414374": "fact campaign respon", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01557-00414375-00414647": "uh when duterte was elected the office", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01558-00414647-00414839": "the bayern muna representatives", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01559-00414839-00415110": "uh uh nagpawis etc from the southern", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01560-00415112-00415182": "philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01561-00415183-00415407": "public wrote a public declaration", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01562-00415408-00415607": "pledging their full support for duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01563-00415608-00415782": "duterte offered the cpp cabinet", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01564-00415783-00415910": "positions the cpps", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01565-00415912-00416118": "we can't enter your cabinet but let me", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01566-00416119-00416278": "put forward the more progressive", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01567-00416279-00416455": "representatives that we select", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01568-00416456-00416734": "to fulfill cabinet level positions joe", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01569-00416735-00416918": "masison head of the communist party of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01570-00416919-00417095": "the philippines began punctuating his", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01571-00417096-00417247": "declarations on facebook", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01572-00417247-00417430": "with the statement mabuhay president", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01573-00417431-00417678": "duterte long-lived president duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01574-00417679-00418022": "this image of csun and by season on", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01575-00418023-00418343": "facebook", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01576-00418343-00418622": "it went beyond that in one of the most", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01577-00418623-00418678": "vicious", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01578-00418679-00418863": "aspects of this the communist party of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01579-00418864-00418999": "the philippines and the various", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01580-00419000-00419166": "organizations affiliated with this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01581-00419167-00419303": "political line", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01582-00419304-00419551": "openly declared duterte's war on drugs", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01583-00419552-00419710": "now make no mistake people knew what", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01584-00419712-00419887": "this was going to be duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01585-00419888-00420087": "as professor berlio correctly pointed", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01586-00420088-00420270": "out was very explicit", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01587-00420271-00420510": "he was very brazen in his statements", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01588-00420512-00420679": "during his campaign a hundred thousand", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01589-00420680-00420847": "dead bodies floating in the bay", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01590-00420847-00421103": "etc uh these things were passed off as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01591-00421104-00421263": "if they were somehow jokes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01592-00421264-00421455": "as if they were hyperbole not simply by", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01593-00421456-00421566": "the mass me", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01594-00421567-00421839": "other politicians but by the various", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01595-00421839-00422014": "organizations of the national democratic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01596-00422015-00422103": "movement", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01597-00422104-00422414": "anak bayan issued a statement in july", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01598-00422415-00422663": "we believe that duterte this campaign", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01599-00422664-00422895": "against dangerous drugs and crime is a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01600-00422896-00423214": "to the poor uh joe masison declared", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01601-00423215-00423495": "cnn that the npa would carry out", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01602-00423496-00423687": "revolutionary justice in duterte's war", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01603-00423688-00423855": "on drugs because duterte had issued an", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01604-00423856-00423975": "appeal to the armed forces of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01605-00423976-00424039": "philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01606-00424039-00424366": "that the npa joined in the war on drugs", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01607-00424367-00424655": "csun responded on cnn that they would do", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01608-00424656-00424807": "so it would exact", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01609-00424808-00425087": "revolutionary justice the cpp published", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01610-00425088-00425247": "a statement communist party of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01611-00425247-00425399": "philippines that the npa", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01612-00425400-00425631": "the new people's army is willing to give", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01613-00425632-00425799": "battle with any who resist arrest with", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01614-00425800-00425895": "armed violence", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01615-00425896-00426143": "this is revolutionary this is the same", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01616-00426143-00426366": "strategy that is being pursued by the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01617-00426367-00426543": "the police and paramilitary", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01618-00426543-00426703": "organizations of duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01619-00426704-00426910": "and the cpp was offering to do so as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01620-00426912-00427166": "well bear in mind that the cpp", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01621-00427167-00427366": "had but months before this declared that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01622-00427367-00427535": "they were resurrecting their urban hit", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01623-00427535-00427870": "squads", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01624-00427871-00428159": "relations between duterte and the cpp", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01625-00428160-00428247": "however", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01626-00428247-00428631": "were not to last they soured to a large", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01627-00428632-00428735": "extent", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01628-00428735-00428927": "the breakdown in relations between the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01629-00428928-00429135": "cpp and duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01630-00429135-00429391": "did not originate with duterte and did", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01631-00429392-00429559": "not originate with the cpp", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01632-00429560-00429759": "there was a straining on the part of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01633-00429760-00429959": "cpp to retain", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01634-00429960-00430335": "the alliance to remain in the cabinet", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01635-00430335-00430631": "the military however with the threats of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01636-00430632-00430670": "coup", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01637-00430671-00430999": "except several times with this pp", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01638-00431000-00431143": "relations soured", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01639-00431143-00431343": "uh it's a complex phenomenon but", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01640-00431343-00431575": "nonetheless the impetus behind the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01641-00431576-00431751": "salary of relations largely seems to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01642-00431752-00431791": "have been", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01643-00431792-00432191": "in the afp the cpp and the various", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01644-00432192-00432422": "organizations of the national democratic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01645-00432423-00432607": "movement insisted on remaining in the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01646-00432608-00432855": "cabinet and as late as late 2017 we're", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01647-00432856-00432999": "demanding that they be approved to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01648-00433000-00433191": "remain in the duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01649-00433192-00433439": "over the course of 2017 the cpp moved", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01650-00433439-00433663": "from enthusiastic support to expressions", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01651-00433664-00433822": "of public ambivalence", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01652-00433823-00434039": "these are the effigy actually it's one", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01653-00434039-00434135": "effigy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01654-00434135-00434407": "of duterte that was being carried around", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01655-00434408-00434535": "uh in protests", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01656-00434535-00434687": "during the second state of the nation", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01657-00434688-00434887": "address of the duterte administration", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01658-00434888-00435063": "the first entirely", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01659-00435064-00435327": "friend on the part of the cpp the second", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01660-00435328-00435399": "however", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01661-00435400-00435679": "carried this extraordinary image on one", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01662-00435680-00435735": "side", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01663-00435735-00436022": "you see duterte the military raised the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01664-00436023-00436143": "militant salute", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01665-00436143-00436431": "on the other side duterte is hitler this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01666-00436432-00436599": "is their public ambivalence", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01667-00436600-00436863": "he might be a revolutionary he might be", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01668-00436864-00437127": "we're not sure yet let's pressure", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01669-00437128-00437414": "him let's criticize him let's see what", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01670-00437415-00438159": "comes about", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01671-00438160-00438503": "now the cpp was thus instrumental", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01672-00438504-00438663": "securing behind", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01673-00438664-00438975": "this sort of middle class and enthusiasm", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01674-00438976-00439063": "for dictator", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01675-00439064-00439399": "the illusion that this figure", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01676-00439400-00439695": "this fascistic figure who has now racked", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01677-00439696-00439951": "up a body count of nearly 30 000 people", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01678-00439952-00440159": "and is overseeing an apparatus", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01679-00440160-00440375": "of both malign neglect in response to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01680-00440376-00440614": "covid as well as a war on drugs that is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01681-00440615-00440799": "a campaign of mass murder against the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01682-00440800-00440879": "poor", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01683-00440880-00441087": "they whipped up enthusiasm for this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01684-00441088-00441255": "figure to the best of their ability in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01685-00441256-00441391": "the working class the peasantry and the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01686-00441392-00441470": "poor", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01687-00441471-00441631": "to the extent that those layers were", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01688-00441632-00442103": "passive uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01689-00442104-00442247": "that passivity was something that the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01690-00442247-00442487": "cpp sought to dissipate", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01691-00442488-00442759": "behind this figure bringing all of that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01692-00442760-00442791": "uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01693-00442792-00443007": "energy back behind duterte creating", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01694-00443008-00443199": "illusions in this figure", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01695-00443200-00443399": "they were not however alone in bringing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01696-00443400-00443718": "duterte onto the national stage", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01697-00443719-00444031": "in this process the elite opposition of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01698-00444032-00444118": "today", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01699-00444119-00444375": "uh were in fact responsible a great many", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01700-00444376-00444599": "of the ruling elite were responsible for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01701-00444600-00444918": "bringing duterte forward as a viable", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01702-00444919-00445199": "national political figure not because", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01703-00445200-00445383": "they were unaware of his character but", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01704-00445384-00445575": "precisely because of it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01705-00445576-00445783": "as social heightened it was necessary to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01706-00445784-00446014": "begin cultivating relations with sort of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01707-00446015-00446391": "populist but aryan figures", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01708-00446392-00446775": "birthday was the davao chair of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01709-00446776-00447087": "from 2009 to 2015. and it wasn't", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01710-00447088-00447287": "in fact a liberal you can see him here", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01711-00447288-00447407": "quite chummy with no", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01712-00447408-00447791": "nue aquino in 2013 uh that first", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01713-00447792-00447983": "brought duterte forward as a national", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01714-00447984-00448214": "political figure it must be said", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01715-00448215-00448414": "on while the liberal party was in an", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01716-00448415-00448575": "alliance with akbayan", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01717-00448576-00448855": "similarly a party of the left well you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01718-00448856-00449055": "professor bellio were a representative", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01719-00449056-00449166": "of akbayan", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01720-00449167-00449407": "there is a similar sort of support for a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01721-00449408-00449614": "section of the elite that spirals into", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01722-00449615-00450063": "making this possible", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01723-00450064-00450335": "it brings me then to what i regard as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01724-00450335-00450407": "the critical", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01725-00450408-00450799": "historical question what is the response", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01726-00450800-00450943": "to this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01727-00450943-00451191": "why was it that we saw the succession of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01728-00451192-00451422": "disillusionment because professor bellio", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01729-00451423-00451670": "outlined of aquino and then ramos and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01730-00451671-00451759": "estrada", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01731-00451760-00452070": "and then arroyo and then aquino", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01732-00452071-00452431": "and now duterte and duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01733-00452432-00452695": "precisely because of this long line of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01734-00452696-00453031": "disillusionment", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01735-00453032-00453231": "the result of the fact that many of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01736-00453232-00453431": "these figures had been trumpeted", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01737-00453432-00453814": "as being candidates of reform by the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01738-00453815-00454079": "politics of stalinism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01739-00454080-00454375": "uh the illusions in aquino did not", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01740-00454376-00454687": "simply stem from the energy of 1986", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01741-00454688-00454943": "but rather all the energy that the cpp", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01742-00454943-00455207": "invested in the year 1986 and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01743-00455208-00455375": "cultivating the possibility", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01744-00455376-00455535": "that she could be a candidate of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01745-00455535-00455735": "left they hailed her it was not", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01746-00455735-00456039": "until the mangiola massacre of 1980", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01747-00456039-00456303": "soured similarly there was support for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01748-00456304-00456487": "arroyo as she took office", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01749-00456488-00456710": "and facilitating the removal of estrada", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01750-00456712-00456847": "from power", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01751-00456847-00457295": "um the bion and company attempted to act", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01752-00457296-00457559": "2009 2010 and failed and therefore", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01753-00457560-00457679": "backed billiard", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01754-00457680-00457918": "in every single one of these instances", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01755-00457919-00458055": "these figures have been", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01756-00458056-00458422": "promoted by the politics of stalinism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01757-00458423-00458687": "the politics of using the program of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01758-00458688-00458799": "nationalism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01759-00458800-00459087": "as a means of endorsing a section of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01760-00459088-00459239": "elite", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01761-00459239-00459527": "then is what makes possible the rise of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01762-00459528-00459647": "a fascistic figure", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01763-00459647-00459903": "like duterte this is what makes possible", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01764-00459904-00460087": "the rise of fascistic figures the world", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01765-00460088-00460151": "over", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01766-00460152-00460479": "it is the failure of the lack", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01767-00460480-00460718": "i agree with professor conception that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01768-00460719-00460870": "what is necessary", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01769-00460871-00461110": "is not a return to the old but a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01770-00461112-00461270": "programmatic alternative", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01771-00461271-00461422": "that is not however what we currently", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01772-00461423-00461566": "see on the landscape we see in the two", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01773-00461567-00461687": "images on the slide here", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01774-00461688-00461918": "one people waiting in line eight for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01775-00461919-00462110": "cold", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01776-00462112-00462439": "um uh and we see a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01777-00462439-00462783": "a catastroph grip the working class", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01778-00462784-00462983": "poor and peasantry in the philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01779-00462984-00463127": "today but the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01780-00463128-00463279": "political opposition isn't being", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01781-00463280-00463439": "organized at present", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01782-00463439-00463751": "uh behind the group's design there may", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01783-00463752-00463991": "be some new", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01784-00463992-00464318": "but by and there is a coalition", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01785-00464319-00464551": "that is presenting a united opposition", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01786-00464552-00464663": "to duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01787-00464664-00464831": "to be frank on the basis of holy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01788-00464832-00465047": "politics they are putting forward a list", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01789-00465047-00465247": "of possible candidates for president", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01790-00465247-00465414": "some of those candidates for president", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01791-00465415-00465622": "are closely tied to duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01792-00465623-00465959": "isco moreno as one of the possible", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01793-00465960-00466135": "but isco moreno was part of duterte's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01794-00466135-00466310": "cabinet until 2019", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01795-00466312-00466495": "when he became mayor of manila he", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01796-00466496-00466687": "defended the war drugs", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01797-00466688-00466943": "another candidate of zambian is uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01798-00466943-00467079": "antonio trillanes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01799-00467080-00467222": "who was responsible for multiple", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01800-00467223-00467391": "military coup attempts", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01801-00467392-00467710": "democratic figures and yet isambayan has", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01802-00467712-00467822": "received the support", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01803-00467823-00468151": "of bayern muna and la", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01804-00468152-00468383": "masa of which professor value you are", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01805-00468384-00468518": "national", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01806-00468519-00468870": "would argue that he", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01807-00468871-00469047": "has put forward the perspective of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01808-00469047-00469199": "political independence of the working", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01809-00469200-00469255": "class", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01810-00469256-00469543": "and not in alliance with the side i", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01811-00469543-00469614": "think that is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01812-00469615-00469847": "a critical component of what has made", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01813-00469847-00469959": "duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01814-00469960-00470999": "possible thank you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01815-00471000-00471231": "thank you joseph for that fascinating um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01816-00471232-00471343": "presentation", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01817-00471343-00471527": "hopefully we will have questions about", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01818-00471528-00471679": "your talk", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01819-00471680-00472270": "from the audience um tom it's your turn", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01820-00472271-00472518": "thank you derek um i can't i don't", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01821-00472519-00472655": "profess to have the same", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01822-00472656-00472839": "um anything like the depth of knowledge", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01823-00472839-00472983": "about um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01824-00472984-00473143": "the domestic political situation the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01825-00473143-00473287": "philippines as my colleagues who you've", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01826-00473288-00473422": "just heard from but", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01827-00473423-00473599": "i'm what i am interested in what i've", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01828-00473600-00473863": "been researching for some time", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01829-00473864-00474031": "is the ways in which duterte has been", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01830-00474032-00474183": "represented um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01831-00474184-00474335": "in the western media so that's what i'm", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01832-00474335-00474510": "going to talk about now", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01833-00474512-00474710": "um since 2016 and the election of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01834-00474712-00474927": "duterte a relatively small number of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01835-00474928-00475103": "western authors and journalists have", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01836-00475104-00475303": "laudably tried to educate the largely", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01837-00475304-00475503": "blase western public", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01838-00475504-00475751": "about the duterte regime rightly drawing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01839-00475752-00476014": "attention to its faux left populism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01840-00476015-00476239": "state authoritarianism or we may as well", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01841-00476239-00476391": "just call it fascism i think", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01842-00476392-00476631": "cynical nationalism toxic masculinity", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01843-00476632-00476822": "and perhaps most appalling of all its", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01844-00476823-00476991": "extrajudicial slaughter", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01845-00476992-00477199": "of narcotic suspects and political", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01846-00477200-00477414": "adversaries", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01847-00477415-00477607": "however this coverage is hampered by a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01848-00477608-00477814": "good deal of confusion hypocrisy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01849-00477815-00478079": "inaccuracy and omission in my view not", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01850-00478080-00478239": "least because its exponents", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01851-00478239-00478470": "occupy points on a very narrow political", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01852-00478471-00478575": "spectrum", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01853-00478576-00478831": "conservative at one extreme through to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01854-00478832-00478966": "left liberal on the other", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01855-00478967-00479175": "that is delimited and informed by", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01856-00479176-00479383": "neo-liberal market forces", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01857-00479384-00479599": "these include dwindling funds available", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01858-00479600-00479822": "for rigorous fourth estate reporting", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01859-00479823-00480031": "especially of foreign affairs the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01860-00480032-00480247": "financial incentivising of superficial", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01861-00480247-00480335": "click bait", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01862-00480335-00480662": "and journalism content and the sobering", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01863-00480663-00480775": "fact that in the us", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01864-00480776-00480966": "just 15 billionaires with not", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01865-00480967-00481143": "particularly progressive political views", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01866-00481143-00481239": "let's be honest", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01867-00481239-00481470": "own almost the entire corporate media", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01868-00481471-00481575": "ecosystem", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01869-00481576-00481822": "and in the uk just three large companies", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01870-00481823-00481951": "own 83", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01871-00481952-00482087": "of mainstream outlets and it's going to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01872-00482088-00482359": "be mostly about british and american", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01873-00482360-00482527": "journalists and other sorts of writers", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01874-00482528-00482703": "that i'm going to be talking about", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01875-00482704-00482975": "um when i say west it's a somewhat", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01876-00482976-00483079": "homogenizing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01877-00483080-00483399": "term maybe um one of the consequences of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01878-00483400-00483575": "this political economy of the media is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01879-00483576-00483639": "that most", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01880-00483639-00483855": "so-called journals of note in the west", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01881-00483856-00483943": "offer partial", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01882-00483943-00484135": "unreliable explanations for how", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01883-00484135-00484391": "duterte's philippines came to be", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01884-00484392-00484583": "and their vocabulary is bereft of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01885-00484584-00484718": "certain important factors that have", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01886-00484719-00484903": "already been alluded to by walden and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01887-00484904-00485014": "oscar and others", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01888-00485015-00485295": "um neoliberalism u.s imperialism then", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01889-00485296-00485414": "and now", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01890-00485415-00485639": "um and certain kind of western", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01891-00485639-00485879": "ethnocentric ideas about", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01892-00485880-00486007": "not just the philippines but about the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01893-00486008-00486191": "non-western world", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01894-00486192-00486527": "and let alone any awareness about", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01895-00486528-00486831": "the certain kinds of um western state", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01896-00486832-00487070": "corporate media biases towards the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01897-00487071-00487262": "non-western world which are", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01898-00487263-00487439": "long-standing and you might say even", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01899-00487439-00488039": "legendary but not not for good reasons", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01900-00488039-00488247": "the british channel 4 news foreign", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01901-00488247-00488487": "correspondent jonathan miller's 2018", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01902-00488488-00488527": "book", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01903-00488528-00488703": "duterte harry is an intensively", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01904-00488704-00488887": "researched blend of biography and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01905-00488888-00489007": "reportage", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01906-00489008-00489222": "that provides a multi-fronted critique", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01907-00489223-00489455": "of duterte's gruesome necropolitics and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01908-00489456-00489662": "sociopathic personality", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01909-00489663-00489855": "while to his credit miller acknowledges", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01910-00489856-00490087": "that poverty and inequality contributed", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01911-00490088-00490279": "to the popular disaffection that helped", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01912-00490280-00490351": "win", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01913-00490352-00490687": "uh duterte win the 2016 election", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01914-00490688-00490935": "miller's preference for a global trade", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01915-00490935-00491143": "system that disproportionately benefits", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01916-00491143-00491310": "western economies", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01917-00491312-00491470": "as part of that sort of expression of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01918-00491471-00491655": "that preference he warns that duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01919-00491656-00491751": "challenges", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01920-00491752-00492014": "i think that bit a bit of an", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01921-00492015-00492166": "exaggeration this but he warns that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01922-00492167-00492303": "duterte challenges", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01923-00492304-00492527": "the very stability of that uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01924-00492528-00492662": "international system", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01925-00492663-00492862": "may explain why miller does not address", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01926-00492863-00492966": "a key material", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01927-00492967-00493295": "cause of deuterotysmal um and as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01928-00493296-00493518": "you know sir walden said who spoke", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01929-00493519-00493607": "earlier", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01930-00493608-00493951": "um he has asserted that in the uh 1980s", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01931-00493952-00494183": "and 90s the u.s dominated world bank and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01932-00494184-00494239": "imf", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01933-00494239-00494431": "plunged the philippines into extreme", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01934-00494432-00494639": "debt and massive poverty", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01935-00494639-00494879": "by imposing free market trade industry", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01936-00494880-00495070": "land and spending reforms", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01937-00495071-00495255": "alienated from this economic and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01938-00495256-00495487": "political order swathes of filipinos", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01939-00495488-00495687": "voted for duterte's heady populism and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01940-00495688-00495799": "walden gave you a kind of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01941-00495800-00496007": "more detailed explanation of that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01942-00496008-00496222": "particular historical context just now", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01943-00496223-00496310": "so i won't", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01944-00496312-00496503": "won't sort of uh go on too much about", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01945-00496504-00496751": "that um but suffice to face to say you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01946-00496752-00496862": "won't read that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01947-00496863-00497103": "in the sort of hegemonic western media", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01948-00497104-00497262": "texts that i'm talking about", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01949-00497263-00497431": "and nor has there been any mainstream", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01950-00497432-00497599": "mention outside of one", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01951-00497600-00497903": "new statesman article from may 2018", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01952-00497904-00498062": "of the ways in which the west has more", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01953-00498063-00498239": "recently and directly aided", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01954-00498239-00498551": "duterte's ascent over the last", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01955-00498552-00498895": "four years the british government has", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01956-00498896-00499175": "approved 87 million pounds worth of arms", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01957-00499176-00499422": "exports to the philippines this is some", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01958-00499423-00499607": "stats from the campaign against the arms", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01959-00499608-00499799": "trade you can see some other relevant", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01960-00499800-00499879": "statistics", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01961-00499880-00500214": "that sort of tell us about um britain's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01962-00500215-00500414": "sort of uh relationship financial", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01963-00500415-00500559": "relationships with the philippines when", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01964-00500560-00500783": "it comes to arms and weapons", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01965-00500784-00501039": "um and uh from the sort of american", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01966-00501039-00501118": "perspective", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01967-00501119-00501375": "uh president joe biden hailed i think by", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01968-00501376-00501622": "over optimistic centrists as a major", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01969-00501623-00501766": "improvement on donald trump who of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01970-00501767-00501943": "course got him famously with duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01971-00501943-00502055": "when he was in power", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01972-00502056-00502270": "is in the process right now if what we", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01973-00502271-00502439": "read is to be believed", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01974-00502439-00502679": "um offending two billion dollars worth", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01975-00502680-00502847": "of assault helicopters to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01976-00502847-00503203": "the duterte regime by", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01977-00503204-00503455": "exercising these economic and historical", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01978-00503456-00503559": "contexts", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01979-00503560-00503751": "miller and other western writers", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01980-00503752-00503935": "representations of duterte as the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01981-00503935-00504118": "aberrant bogeyman leader", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01982-00504119-00504270": "would seem to be misleading if not", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01983-00504271-00504566": "hypocritical hypocrisy also distorts the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01984-00504567-00504766": "moral calculus that miller and others", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01985-00504767-00504959": "apply to duterte's misdemeanors", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01986-00504960-00505231": "encapsulated in noam chomsky's overism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01987-00505232-00505414": "when they do it it's a crime when we do", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01988-00505415-00505559": "it it's not", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01989-00505560-00505814": "a may 2016 think peace in the guardian", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01990-00505815-00505991": "makes the highly tendentious point that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01991-00505992-00506070": "duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01992-00506071-00506303": "is more of a threat to the world than", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01993-00506304-00506518": "then u.s president trump", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01994-00506519-00506735": "while duterte has slaughtered perhaps 30", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01995-00506735-00506943": "000 filipinos he is incapable of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01996-00506943-00507183": "attacking people beyond his own borders", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01997-00507184-00507391": "whereas u.s military actions have killed", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01998-00507392-00507575": "up to 4 million in the middle east alone", "QM-rh_vWCzY-01999-00507576-00507727": "since 1990", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02000-00507728-00507879": "these actions have included and people", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02001-00507880-00508070": "will people in the meeting like this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02002-00508071-00508351": "will know this these actions have", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02003-00508352-00508399": "included", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02004-00508400-00508583": "in some cases continue to include the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02005-00508584-00508807": "extra extrajudicial drone strike", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02006-00508808-00509022": "killings in asia and north africa", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02007-00509023-00509199": "and of course the wars on iraq and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02008-00509200-00509375": "afghanistan that made a mockery of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02009-00509376-00509503": "international law", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02010-00509504-00509918": "and normalized torture and kidnapping", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02011-00509919-00510214": "as you'll know duterte himself has", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02012-00510215-00510439": "lambasted such interventions", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02013-00510439-00510743": "um he's specifically named libya panama", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02014-00510743-00510814": "and iraq", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02015-00510815-00511127": "uh in the press um and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02016-00511128-00511407": "uh you know miller uh other writers like", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02017-00511408-00511470": "jonathan", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02018-00511471-00511743": "jonathan m katz of the atlantic magazine", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02019-00511743-00511966": "um have rightly i think called duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02020-00511967-00512103": "out for what a baptism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02021-00512104-00512279": "or what is more formally termed the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02022-00512280-00512455": "tuquoque fallacy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02023-00512456-00512855": "in which um a uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02024-00512856-00513047": "in which an argument consists in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02025-00513047-00513279": "retorting a charge upon one's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02026-00513280-00513535": "accuser duterte's ham-fisted strategy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02027-00513535-00513662": "here is to cynically rebuff", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02028-00513663-00513847": "scrutiny of his own crimes by appealing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02029-00513847-00513983": "to vulgar nationalism and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02030-00513984-00514143": "anti-americanism as if the fact that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02031-00514143-00514318": "americans slaying poor people", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02032-00514319-00514518": "all over the world somehow justifies him", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02033-00514519-00514759": "slaying poor people in his own country", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02034-00514760-00514991": "however attempts by western liberals to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02035-00514992-00515166": "level the two quote way charge ring", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02036-00515167-00515214": "hollow", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02037-00515215-00515383": "due to their almost pathological", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02038-00515384-00515614": "inability to recognize that as mentioned", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02039-00515615-00515679": "earlier", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02040-00515680-00515862": "western governments themselves have much", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02041-00515863-00516118": "more egregious records of violence", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02042-00516119-00516310": "as the philosopher andrew spear argues", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02043-00516312-00516503": "to quote grey can be used legitimately", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02044-00516504-00516679": "to question whether a particular moral", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02045-00516680-00516799": "principle is in fact", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02046-00516800-00517022": "one we endorse and if so whether", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02047-00517023-00517295": "everyone is consistently following it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02048-00517296-00517527": "and another issue on which duterte has", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02049-00517528-00517710": "played the two quote quote card", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02050-00517712-00517895": "is the international criminal court", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02051-00517896-00518231": "icc's investigation into him which began", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02052-00518232-00518535": "in february 2018 while we should again", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02053-00518535-00518695": "seriously doubt the sincerity of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02054-00518696-00518839": "duterte's complaint", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02055-00518839-00519047": "it does nonetheless speak to a pressing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02056-00519047-00519175": "practical problem", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02057-00519176-00519503": "how can duterte and leaders like him um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02058-00519504-00519662": "in the post-colonial world developing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02059-00519663-00519831": "world whatever to call it be reasonably", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02060-00519832-00520055": "brought to justice when notable lawyers", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02061-00520056-00520255": "academics and un officials even have", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02062-00520256-00520414": "repeatedly exoriated", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02063-00520415-00520679": "the icc's erratic treatment of western", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02064-00520680-00520887": "and non-western state crimes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02065-00520888-00521087": "after examining the us's lack of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02066-00521088-00521295": "liability for its actions in vietnam", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02067-00521296-00521487": "amongst other colonial wars", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02068-00521488-00521687": "and stating that western corporate", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02069-00521688-00521839": "impunity remains right", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02070-00521839-00522007": "the secretary general of the european", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02071-00522008-00522199": "center for constitutional and human", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02072-00522200-00522295": "rights", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02073-00522296-00522535": "wolfgang calic concludes that the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02074-00522535-00522695": "practice of double standards will have", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02075-00522696-00522895": "to be addressed to protect the icc", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02076-00522896-00523127": "against erosion of legitimacy and global", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02077-00523128-00523239": "endorsement", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02078-00523239-00523375": "needless to say there is no", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02079-00523376-00523599": "consideration of the uneven", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02080-00523600-00523822": "uneven moral landscape of international", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02081-00523823-00524070": "law in miller's half-page disquisition", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02082-00524071-00524175": "on the icc", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02083-00524176-00524447": "nor in any of the other any of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02084-00524448-00524647": "dozens of reports on the topic by other", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02085-00524648-00524807": "western pundits", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02086-00524808-00524983": "it is not in their interests to raise", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02087-00524984-00525127": "the subject for they would have to admit", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02088-00525128-00525311": "that the case against duterte is in part", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02089-00525312-00525503": "driven by a conception of human rights", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02090-00525504-00525703": "as so the filipino historian vicente", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02091-00525704-00525831": "raphael holds", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02092-00525832-00526118": "essentially a form of imperialism the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02093-00526119-00526318": "west dictating to the non-west the norms", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02094-00526319-00526422": "of proper conduct", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02095-00526423-00526607": "these norms are particularly problematic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02096-00526608-00526783": "continues raphael because the u.n", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02097-00526784-00526966": "reporters are lecturing the philippine", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02098-00526967-00527159": "president about human rights", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02099-00527160-00527359": "from a location that is historically", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02100-00527360-00527679": "responsible for their daily violation", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02101-00527680-00527895": "when michael peel of the financial times", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02102-00527896-00528031": "argues that another reasons for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02103-00528032-00528239": "duterte's success is his mining", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02104-00528240-00528543": "of a seam of anti-us sentiment peel only", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02105-00528544-00528759": "briefly and uncritically mentions", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02106-00528760-00529151": "acts of u.s imperialism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02107-00529152-00529383": "that might have fueled this sentiment", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02108-00529384-00529599": "similarly miller remarks on a rich vein", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02109-00529600-00529783": "of unresolved colonial angst in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02110-00529784-00529943": "philippine society but does not", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02111-00529944-00530151": "elaborate on the potential rationales", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02112-00530152-00530303": "for this angst", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02113-00530304-00530503": "the philippines was the american's first", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02114-00530504-00530727": "overseas colony he writes nonchalantly", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02115-00530728-00530911": "acquired from the spanish after a short", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02116-00530912-00531047": "war in 1898", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02117-00531048-00531279": "for 20 million u.s dollars his", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02118-00531280-00531455": "deployment of the euphemism acquired", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02119-00531456-00531647": "would lead the less informed reader", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02120-00531648-00531839": "to believe that the u.s conquest of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02121-00531840-00531991": "philippines did not require", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02122-00531992-00532199": "the grisly racist genocide of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02123-00532200-00532391": "philippine-american war", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02124-00532392-00532622": "by contrast the filipino historian esan", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02125-00532623-00532711": "juan junior", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02126-00532712-00532951": "as well as other colleagues here oscar", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02127-00532952-00533135": "has sort of written about this too", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02128-00533136-00533399": "and very eloquently have pinpointed", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02129-00533400-00533575": "continuities between these u.s", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02130-00533576-00533695": "aggressions in the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02131-00533696-00533903": "late victorian period and its present", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02132-00533904-00534143": "day counter-insurgency maneuvers against", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02133-00534144-00534335": "both islamist and maoist rebels around", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02134-00534336-00534503": "the archipelago", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02135-00534504-00534670": "us troops are recolonizing the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02136-00534671-00534855": "philippines right san juan junior to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02137-00534856-00535047": "preserve its eroded world hegemony", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02138-00535048-00535287": "post-cold war and post 9 11.", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02139-00535288-00535487": "unfortunately miller is as ignorant of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02140-00535488-00535679": "these latest abuses by the american", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02141-00535680-00535759": "empire as he", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02142-00535760-00536111": "is of those from 1898 to 1902 or even", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02143-00536112-00536351": "into the 1910s if we talk about the full", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02144-00536352-00536399": "extent", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02145-00536400-00536711": "of the philippine american war", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02146-00536712-00536935": "his only comment on such matters is u.s", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02147-00536936-00537143": "forces were operating in mindanao in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02148-00537144-00537239": "support", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02149-00537240-00537479": "of philippine army operations against", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02150-00537480-00537687": "the jihadist abu sayyaf group", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02151-00537688-00537855": "miller's assessment is typical of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02152-00537856-00538070": "observers bedazzled by the rhetoric of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02153-00538071-00538279": "the romantic relationship to using the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02154-00538280-00538439": "30 tadiar's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02155-00538440-00538718": "metaphor between the us and the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02156-00538719-00538814": "philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02157-00538815-00539087": "millers claimed that american military", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02158-00539088-00539262": "support for the philippine state against", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02159-00539263-00539351": "a common enemy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02160-00539352-00539607": "implies equal democratic partnership as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02161-00539608-00539735": "tadia would put it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02162-00539736-00539951": "but san juan junior's description gets", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02163-00539952-00540135": "closer to the material truth", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02164-00540136-00540327": "of the matter the philippines is yet", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02165-00540328-00540527": "another sovereign nation that the u.s is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02166-00540528-00540599": "manipulating", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02167-00540600-00540822": "as a battlefront in the so-called war on", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02168-00540823-00541039": "terror", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02169-00541040-00541399": "this western media discourse imposes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02170-00541400-00541639": "similarly discordant ethical principles", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02171-00541640-00541759": "on duterte's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02172-00541760-00542039": "pivot to china the guardian laments that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02173-00542040-00542207": "surging chinese investment in the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02174-00542208-00542318": "philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02175-00542319-00542551": "and an apparent climb down by duterte in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02176-00542552-00542759": "a dispute with beijing over territories", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02177-00542760-00542911": "in the south china sea", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02178-00542912-00543143": "is tantamount to a surrender of the us", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02179-00543144-00543239": "alliance", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02180-00543240-00543383": "not in the better interests of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02181-00543384-00543543": "filipino people", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02182-00543544-00543718": "but this case excludes some vital", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02183-00543719-00543918": "nuances while it is true that beijing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02184-00543919-00544062": "has poured money into the philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02185-00544063-00544247": "this does not mean duterte has turned", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02186-00544248-00544359": "his back on the u.s", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02187-00544360-00544683": "however anti-american his faustian can", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02188-00544684-00544799": "be", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02189-00544800-00545031": "um the us is erecting new military", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02190-00545032-00545166": "facilities in the archipelago and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02191-00545167-00545359": "remains a more valuable trading partner", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02192-00545360-00545559": "to the philippines than china just about", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02193-00545560-00545670": "if you look at these", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02194-00545671-00546022": "this latest um table of uh top", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02195-00546023-00546287": "trading partners according to um the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02196-00546288-00546470": "criterion of uh countries that imported", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02197-00546471-00546639": "the most filipino shipments by dollar", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02198-00546640-00546847": "value during 2020.", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02199-00546848-00547062": "um and at any rate duterte is not the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02200-00547063-00547199": "first president to play what's been", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02201-00547200-00547351": "called a cat and mouse game of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02202-00547352-00547543": "maintaining good relations with the us", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02203-00547544-00547718": "while improving relations with china and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02204-00547719-00547870": "again my colleagues here would be much", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02205-00547871-00548039": "better equipped to me to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02206-00548040-00548287": "talk about the sort of long history of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02207-00548288-00548414": "um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02208-00548415-00548639": "you know filipino leaders marcos in the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02209-00548640-00548879": "70s signing a joint agreement with", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02210-00548880-00549159": "beijing and other sort of overtures made", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02211-00549160-00549207": "to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02212-00549208-00549414": "to china while simultaneously trying to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02213-00549415-00549511": "retain", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02214-00549512-00549862": "food relations with the us", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02215-00549863-00550031": "even supposing western fears about", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02216-00550032-00550270": "realignment with china are well-founded", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02217-00550271-00550422": "they'll nevertheless predicated on a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02218-00550423-00550607": "hypocritical assumption that china is a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02219-00550608-00550847": "singular threat to asian peace", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02220-00550848-00551039": "miller makes much of beijing's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02221-00551040-00551247": "remorseless militarization of the south", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02222-00551248-00551359": "china sea", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02223-00551360-00551566": "while staying silent on the far larger", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02224-00551567-00551727": "and more provocative cordon", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02225-00551728-00551975": "of 400 american bases and countries", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02226-00551976-00552103": "surrounding china", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02227-00552104-00552295": "some equipped with long-range missile", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02228-00552296-00552422": "capabilities", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02229-00552423-00552614": "more to the point unlike china u.s armed", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02230-00552615-00552831": "forces are currently operating in 17", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02231-00552832-00552951": "asian countries including the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02232-00552952-00553118": "philippines while the official", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02233-00553119-00553262": "justification for this is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02234-00553263-00553503": "once again the war on terror teddy r", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02235-00553504-00553647": "perceives the real agenda as the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02236-00553648-00553847": "imposition of global martial law to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02237-00553848-00554047": "ensure the obedience of crony states", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02238-00554048-00554191": "like the philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02239-00554192-00554479": "furthermore as mge kelly avers while we", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02240-00554480-00554679": "should be suspicious of chinese pledges", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02241-00554680-00554879": "not to interfere in the internal affairs", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02242-00554880-00555022": "of other countries", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02243-00555023-00555270": "by contrast the us arrogates a right to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02244-00555271-00555543": "global interference in almost everything", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02245-00555544-00555766": "apparently it is not militarization of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02246-00555767-00555991": "southeast asia per se that bothers", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02247-00555992-00556070": "miller at", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02248-00556071-00556335": "al just the chinese militarization of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02249-00556336-00556511": "southeast asia", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02250-00556512-00556891": "so this new military and economics based", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02251-00556892-00557214": "cyanophobia has redrawn the textual map", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02252-00557215-00557295": "of manila", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02253-00557296-00557607": "too a may 2018 bloomberg news article", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02254-00557608-00557831": "offers a snapshot of the daily realities", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02255-00557832-00558166": "of duterte's faustian pact with china", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02256-00558167-00558366": "restaurants serving chinese hotpots and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02257-00558367-00558607": "dumplings and mandarin broadcasts at the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02258-00558608-00558839": "mall of asia are catering for 100", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02259-00558840-00559039": "000 recent chinese immigrants according", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02260-00559040-00559151": "to this story", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02261-00559152-00559327": "whose arrival in manila has profited", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02262-00559328-00559566": "several local common companies", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02263-00559567-00559783": "however in keeping with the hoary old", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02264-00559784-00560022": "cliche about chinese avarice which again", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02265-00560023-00560103": "people will know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02266-00560104-00560351": "is um long-standing people like carolyn", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02267-00560352-00560455": "howe have", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02268-00560456-00560655": "written about this in in great detail", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02269-00560656-00560799": "long standing within the philippines but", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02270-00560800-00560935": "it's also a kind of stereotype that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02271-00560936-00561070": "exists beyond", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02272-00561071-00561407": "the philippine context this human deluge", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02273-00561408-00561566": "which is the word this writer uses has", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02274-00561567-00561599": "also", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02275-00561600-00561783": "contributed to soaring house prices", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02276-00561784-00561935": "which is a source of worry for one", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02277-00561936-00562087": "manilano at least", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02278-00562088-00562239": "i hope they become an asset to the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02279-00562240-00562414": "community he says of these new chinese", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02280-00562415-00562495": "arrivals", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02281-00562496-00562759": "and not just out to make money in a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02282-00562760-00562959": "further signifier of problematic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02283-00562960-00563118": "cupidity the bloomberg", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02284-00563119-00563311": "piece states that dozens of chinese", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02285-00563312-00563503": "gambling operations are setting up shop", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02286-00563504-00563703": "in the city producing a boom that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02287-00563704-00563975": "won't last forever it is instructive to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02288-00563976-00564055": "compare this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02289-00564056-00564295": "foreboding representation of chinese", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02290-00564296-00564495": "investment with the celebratory tone of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02291-00564496-00564662": "a 2013 bbc", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02292-00564663-00564951": "report on how innovative technology is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02293-00564952-00565055": "driving manila's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02294-00565056-00565391": "amazing uh call centers and bpos", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02295-00565392-00565679": "business processing outsourcing concerns", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02296-00565680-00565822": "that are contracted to british and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02297-00565823-00565959": "american firms", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02298-00565960-00566159": "rather than as per the bloomberg story", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02299-00566160-00566295": "highlighting the risks of this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02300-00566296-00566447": "burgeoning sector", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02301-00566448-00566607": "call centers are presented as an", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02302-00566608-00566775": "unalloyed success that are fully", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02303-00566776-00566862": "sustainable", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02304-00566863-00567070": "thanks to government tax breaks fast", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02305-00567071-00567311": "track permits and other perks", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02306-00567312-00567518": "whereas bloomberg paints the expatriate", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02307-00567519-00567711": "chinese workers and business people as a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02308-00567712-00567918": "deluge that is culturally reshaping", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02309-00567919-00568143": "manila and stoking anxiety among its", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02310-00568144-00568262": "indigenes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02311-00568263-00568470": "no such concerns are raised by several", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02312-00568471-00568703": "recent media accounts of western retail", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02313-00568704-00568887": "chains opening branches", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02314-00568888-00569118": "in manila for example this one rule for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02315-00569119-00569262": "the west another rule for china", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02316-00569263-00569487": "discrepancy is conspicuous in miller's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02317-00569488-00569583": "work too", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02318-00569584-00569799": "swift to admonish duterte's spending", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02319-00569800-00569910": "program for leaving the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02320-00569911-00570159": "philippines in debt bondage to china his", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02321-00570160-00570231": "phrase", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02322-00570232-00570439": "miller has as i mentioned earlier", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02323-00570440-00570614": "nothing to say about the world bank", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02324-00570615-00570791": "and imf's crippling loans to the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02325-00570792-00571031": "philippines in the uh last stage of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02326-00571032-00571159": "20th century", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02327-00571160-00571327": "um i think it's really important because", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02328-00571328-00571566": "i've had criticisms for this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02329-00571567-00571847": "um in the past um i really think it's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02330-00571848-00572031": "important to assert that the criticisms", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02331-00572032-00572118": "i've just made", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02332-00572119-00572310": "of these sort of western distortions", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02333-00572311-00572510": "these western mediations of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02334-00572511-00572679": "uh the current chinese philippine", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02335-00572680-00572895": "relations do not and should not", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02336-00572896-00573135": "um suggest a contra position that in any", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02337-00573136-00573335": "way exonerates chinese", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02338-00573336-00573510": "exploitation of the philippines i think", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02339-00573511-00573759": "all forms of capitalist exploitation", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02340-00573760-00573966": "imperial exploitation are wrong", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02341-00573967-00574166": "wherever whether it's america or china", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02342-00574167-00574375": "or whoever else is practicing this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02343-00574376-00574591": "um but that said while there is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02344-00574592-00574695": "certainly truth", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02345-00574696-00574895": "to the allegations that duterte has sold", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02346-00574896-00575079": "out his country to chinese interest i", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02347-00575080-00575231": "think there's some truth in that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02348-00575232-00575414": "as with the two quote way issue i", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02349-00575415-00575559": "mentioned earlier", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02350-00575560-00575735": "when such allegations come from these", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02351-00575736-00575879": "western observers they", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02352-00575880-00576022": "i don't think they can be taken all that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02353-00576023-00576262": "seriously so just to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02354-00576263-00576607": "to finish off then really um ultimately", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02355-00576608-00576747": "this this discourse of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02356-00576748-00576895": "misrepresentations that i've been", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02357-00576896-00577055": "talking about um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02358-00577056-00577222": "i think speak to and this kind of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02359-00577223-00577359": "relates to what joseph was", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02360-00577360-00577518": "saying ver he said very briefly at the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02361-00577519-00577718": "beginning of his talk about", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02362-00577719-00578031": "these sort of um wider international", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02363-00578032-00578135": "dimensions", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02364-00578136-00578422": "um that we have to understand in order", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02365-00578423-00578535": "to really appreciate", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02366-00578536-00578783": "um duterte's rise and i think so i think", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02367-00578784-00578991": "this this discourse speaks to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02368-00578992-00579166": "a sort of liberal a western liberal", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02369-00579167-00579375": "stroke neoliberal worldview that is in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02370-00579376-00579462": "crisis", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02371-00579463-00579695": "um though these writers castigate the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02372-00579696-00579887": "duterte regime for its brutality and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02373-00579888-00580055": "brutal it certainly is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02374-00580056-00580270": "they deny any western responsibility for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02375-00580271-00580487": "this totalitarian drift", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02376-00580488-00580759": "in philippine politics nor did these", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02377-00580760-00580870": "critics accept", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02378-00580871-00581055": "that their own ideology despite its", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02379-00581056-00581199": "ostensible support of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02380-00581200-00581407": "human rights and rules-based", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02381-00581408-00581559": "international relations that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02382-00581560-00581799": "term always makes me want to laugh or", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02383-00581800-00582047": "cry i don't know perhaps simultaneously", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02384-00582048-00582270": "because it's so ridiculous has as the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02385-00582271-00582518": "indian essayist pankaj mishra puts it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02386-00582519-00582775": "being an incubator for authoritarianism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02387-00582776-00582943": "i know oscar mentioned this earlier as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02388-00582944-00583007": "well", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02389-00583008-00583262": "across the post-colonial world and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02390-00583263-00583439": "advocated for the occupation and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02391-00583440-00583655": "subjugation of other people's territory", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02392-00583656-00583743": "and culture", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02393-00583744-00583903": "as a wonderful instrument of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02394-00583904-00585231": "civilization i thank you for listening", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02395-00585232-00585479": "okay um thank you to all the um thank", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02396-00585480-00585583": "you tom for that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02397-00585584-00585951": "um really interesting um take on", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02398-00585952-00586270": "um um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02399-00586271-00586527": "we now we we have time for a few", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02400-00586528-00586622": "questions", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02401-00586623-00586839": "so i'm going to read from the chat box", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02402-00586840-00587014": "um there's one here from", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02403-00587015-00587375": "indirjid parmar um he says thank you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02404-00587376-00587455": "thank you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02405-00587456-00587703": "for two very interesting talks um you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02406-00587704-00587822": "both alluded to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02407-00587823-00588014": "comparisons between duterte and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02408-00588015-00588247": "bolsonaro and modley", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02409-00588248-00588503": "i think this refers to oscars and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02410-00588504-00588599": "walden's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02411-00588600-00588910": "presentations there is a clear", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02412-00588911-00589143": "post-imperial and neo-liberal element to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02413-00589144-00589214": "the rise", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02414-00589215-00589439": "i wonder if you could address any", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02415-00589440-00589559": "comparisons with", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02416-00589560-00589862": "orban in hungary and poland studa", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02417-00589863-00590175": "is neoliberalism the key to the rise or", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02418-00590176-00590239": "perhaps", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02419-00590240-00590599": "post-soviet imperial legacies", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02420-00590600-00590935": "thanks would like to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02421-00590936-00591607": "um answer that question", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02422-00591608-00591951": "walden professor rebelio would you like", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02423-00591952-00592199": "to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02424-00592200-00593087": "respond to that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02425-00593088-00593335": "or any one of the of the speakers would", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02426-00593336-00593447": "like to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02427-00593448-00594975": "give it a go", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02428-00594976-00595330": "sorry go ahead i no please i i was muted", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02429-00595331-00595566": "[Laughter]", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02430-00595567-00596055": "would you like to go ahead oscar please", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02431-00596056-00596462": "oscar you are on mute", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02432-00596463-00596679": "there you go oh my god this is a common", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02433-00596680-00596887": "zoom melody", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02434-00596888-00597031": "all right first of all i just want to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02435-00597032-00597175": "declare i do not wish to be", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02436-00597176-00597343": "misunderstood", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02437-00597344-00597662": "about my expression of boredom with the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02438-00597663-00597839": "theater about duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02439-00597840-00598110": "um actually as a professor of literature", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02440-00598111-00598166": "i was", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02441-00598167-00598510": "attempting to be ironic um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02442-00598511-00598783": "concerning um that expression of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02443-00598784-00598862": "sentiment", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02444-00598863-00599183": "no um um to express", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02445-00599184-00599359": "also something of the sense of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02446-00599360-00599559": "exhaustion right that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02447-00599560-00599822": "many of us feel not only about the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02448-00599823-00599999": "mindless iterations of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02449-00600000-00600318": "neo-int orientalist discoursing right", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02450-00600319-00600670": "about the political epidemic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02451-00600671-00601047": "that's been ravaging the philippines as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02452-00601048-00601310": "walden has actually shown through this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02453-00601311-00601518": "quick succession of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02454-00601519-00601775": "post marcus and even post-independence", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02455-00601776-00601910": "um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02456-00601911-00602255": "political reader leaders and regimes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02457-00602256-00602518": "but but also it was although granted", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02458-00602519-00602599": "that it was", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02459-00602600-00602903": "more strong a strongly worded attempt", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02460-00602904-00603095": "to produce what i've been calling a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02461-00603096-00603214": "provocation", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02462-00603215-00603631": "um what i mean by that is that um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02463-00603632-00603991": "i wanted um the discourse making the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02464-00603992-00604143": "shift", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02465-00604144-00604391": "away from right like the right the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02466-00604392-00604518": "formulaic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02467-00604519-00604879": "and really rather unhelpful um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02468-00604880-00605118": "sorts of social political analysis and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02469-00605119-00605366": "commentary that precisely come", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02470-00605367-00605655": "in his presentation this evening and in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02471-00605656-00605862": "the duterte chapter that i i made", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02472-00605863-00606047": "extensive reference", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02473-00606048-00606399": "transcendently critiques right for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02474-00606400-00606575": "a good number of things from their moral", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02475-00606576-00606703": "cupidity", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02476-00606704-00607014": "to their uh hypocrisy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02477-00607015-00607351": "um but maybe my provocation is working", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02478-00607352-00607447": "because", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02479-00607448-00607814": "um joseph actually refers", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02480-00607815-00608083": "in internationally or globally", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02481-00608084-00608231": "contextualizing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02482-00608232-00608422": "the rights of duterte and that is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02483-00608423-00608543": "talking about", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02484-00608544-00608966": "the stalinist strain of support", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02485-00608967-00609343": "from what's left of the philippine left", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02486-00609344-00609662": "uh as embodied by the cpp npa", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02487-00609663-00609975": "uh which to him facilitated the rise of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02488-00609976-00610110": "duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02489-00610111-00610351": "despite the eventual breakdown in their", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02490-00610352-00610647": "previously amicable relations", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02491-00610648-00610983": "um that this kind of uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02492-00610984-00611303": "leads me to leads me back right like to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02493-00611304-00611583": "this um desire or call that i've", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02494-00611584-00611695": "expressed for a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02495-00611696-00612022": "radically new language uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02496-00612023-00612383": "new terms um maybe uh that we", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02497-00612384-00612791": "can mobilize um to produce", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02498-00612792-00613118": "what we i think they've all uh it's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02499-00613119-00613447": "been aspiring together as panelists as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02500-00613448-00613839": "more nuanced um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02501-00613840-00614143": "analysis and more informative and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02502-00614144-00614318": "critically enlightening", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02503-00614319-00614703": "analysis of this problem and phenomenon", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02504-00614704-00614751": "that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02505-00614752-00615039": "the 30 small represent so i'm a good", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02506-00615040-00615222": "example of that was like joseph", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02507-00615223-00615555": "and for example um internationally", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02508-00615556-00615710": "contextualizing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02509-00615711-00616070": "um the the totality totalitarian trip", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02510-00616071-00616327": "in philippine politics very", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02511-00616328-00616535": "interestingly used the terms", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02512-00616536-00616862": "um dna and rna right", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02513-00616863-00617375": "to uh describe a certain reproducibility", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02514-00617376-00617679": "uh off right like um um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02515-00617680-00618022": "this strain or um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02516-00618023-00618470": "vital or bacterial right", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02517-00618471-00618799": "um basis in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02518-00618800-00619383": "liberalism itself classic or neo", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02519-00619384-00619751": "that manifests itself as manifested", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02520-00619752-00619831": "itself", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02521-00619832-00620214": "very concretely in real terms", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02522-00620215-00620407": "not only in the philippines but in all", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02523-00620408-00620607": "these other places", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02524-00620608-00620943": "that he refers to right okay um so", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02525-00620944-00621262": "by by a radically novel or maybe", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02526-00621263-00621559": "alternative language and terms for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02527-00621560-00621662": "analysis", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02528-00621663-00621943": "i mean something like perhaps extending", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02529-00621944-00622047": "the metaphor", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02530-00622048-00622431": "that is suggested by the meme i flash to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02531-00622432-00622479": "you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02532-00622480-00622695": "right like where marcus is the virus", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02533-00622696-00622862": "right and then", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02534-00622863-00623270": "um the third is just a mutation", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02535-00623271-00623622": "of the original one uh meaning to say", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02536-00623623-00623831": "that what we really do need is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02537-00623832-00624022": "okay extending the metaphor it's a new", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02538-00624023-00624199": "ideology if like if", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02539-00624200-00624455": "the therapism is a disease right like", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02540-00624456-00624743": "our current raging pandemic is actually", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02541-00624744-00624822": "furnishing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02542-00624823-00625143": "us an alternative language for thinking", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02543-00625144-00625310": "about and analyzing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02544-00625311-00625622": "the thirties if it's a disease right", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02545-00625623-00625966": "we need to produce a good ethiology of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02546-00625967-00626055": "it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02547-00626056-00626414": "so that we can then search for right", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02548-00626415-00626879": "the vaccinations or the vaccines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02549-00626880-00627239": "no that that we might require to address", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02550-00627240-00627447": "the problem and in other words what i'm", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02551-00627448-00627543": "saying is again", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02552-00627544-00627791": "extending it analogically too is the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02553-00627792-00628103": "metaphor is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02554-00628104-00628487": "before the pandemic a political epidemic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02555-00628488-00628743": "has been ravaging the philippines and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02556-00628744-00628870": "globally ii", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02557-00628871-00629070": "beyond the philippines since at least", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02558-00629071-00629191": "the cold war", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02559-00629192-00629479": "when the u.s empire entered into a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02560-00629480-00629551": "series of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02561-00629552-00629887": "partnerships with dictators right", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02562-00629888-00630391": "from charizard asha", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02563-00630392-00630839": "in the 1950s to uh agusta pinochet", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02564-00630840-00631087": "in the 1970s from marcus of course in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02565-00631088-00631222": "the philippines to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02566-00631223-00631527": "miguel noriega in panama right", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02567-00631528-00631862": "um and so it's a kind of global", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02568-00631863-00632127": "political epidemic it's been with us for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02569-00632128-00632335": "quite some time and what i mean by", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02570-00632336-00632631": "constructing a new etiology is precisely", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02571-00632632-00632755": "posing this question of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02572-00632756-00632870": "over-determination", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02573-00632871-00633247": "right there's multiple determinants", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02574-00633248-00633551": "and tom joseph uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02575-00633552-00633807": "i really appreciate it uh also the kind", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02576-00633808-00633999": "of short term determinant the tactical", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02577-00634000-00634039": "one", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02578-00634040-00634414": "right that uh cpp npa support", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02579-00634415-00634743": "for an endorsement of duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02580-00634744-00635087": "um explain", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02581-00635088-00635318": "for our sake so i guess that's what i'm", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02582-00635319-00635439": "saying i'm", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02583-00635440-00636414": "actually i'm bored with", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02584-00636415-00636559": "we have a common interest in this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02585-00636560-00636687": "because you know we've talked about this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02586-00636688-00636855": "before and i think maybe a step towards", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02587-00636856-00636983": "that new", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02588-00636984-00637231": "um new sort of language or new kind of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02589-00637232-00637422": "discourse for understanding", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02590-00637423-00637687": "uh the you know the these sorts of very", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02591-00637688-00637887": "complex phenomena is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02592-00637888-00638039": "you know it's precisely to acknowledge", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02593-00638040-00638191": "that there are all these different", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02594-00638192-00638431": "um determinants i mean i mean that's you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02595-00638432-00638551": "know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02596-00638552-00638670": "that's nothing new i mean that's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02597-00638671-00638910": "historical materialism isn't it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02598-00638911-00639207": "which essentially yeah but but maybe you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02599-00639208-00639375": "know obviously that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02600-00639376-00639703": "there are um new sort of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02601-00639704-00639959": "developments in in the you know in sort", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02602-00639960-00640095": "of new", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02603-00640096-00640391": "uh strains as you say of uh you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02604-00640392-00640535": "factors and drivers", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02605-00640536-00640703": "in someone like duterte and i suppose", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02606-00640704-00640903": "this is what um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02607-00640904-00641166": "this is what uh one of the reasons i got", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02608-00641167-00641262": "interested in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02609-00641263-00641479": "analyzing this kind of for a very narrow", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02610-00641480-00641695": "sort of liberal", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02611-00641696-00641903": "um western sort of reporting on the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02612-00641904-00642110": "philippines is that it's very monocausal", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02613-00642111-00642470": "in its analysis precisely and it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02614-00642471-00642655": "and it attaches itself to these", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02615-00642656-00642822": "time-worn sort of as you call it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02616-00642823-00642927": "neo-orientalist", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02617-00642928-00643222": "cliches about there being something", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02618-00643223-00643375": "innately and essentially", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02619-00643376-00643662": "culturally problematic about filipinos", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02620-00643663-00643751": "you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02621-00643752-00644062": "uh that means that they all bow down to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02622-00644063-00644391": "some uh sort of demagogue like duterte", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02623-00644392-00644495": "and that it's something", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02624-00644496-00644662": "in the in the genes almost you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02625-00644663-00644814": "which is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02626-00644815-00645047": "it's a horrific sort of a social", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02627-00645048-00645231": "darwinist idea but it's not actually you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02628-00645232-00645270": "know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02629-00645271-00645607": "the people but but it sort of survived", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02630-00645608-00645895": "and and has been expressed more subtly", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02631-00645896-00645991": "you could say you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02632-00645992-00646287": "by um some of these writers i didn't i", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02633-00646288-00646414": "only mentioned really a couple of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02634-00646415-00646599": "writers that i look at in the book", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02635-00646600-00646855": "so i think moving away from that sort of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02636-00646856-00647014": "monocausal analysis", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02637-00647015-00647375": "moving away from um personalizing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02638-00647376-00647543": "this again that is that sort of again", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02639-00647544-00647695": "another liberal fallacy isn't it the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02640-00647696-00647847": "great man theory of history that it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02641-00647848-00648014": "comes down to these big personalities", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02642-00648015-00648159": "and of course duterte is a big", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02643-00648160-00648383": "personality and he gets the headlines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02644-00648384-00648479": "when he um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02645-00648480-00648710": "you know uses you know he kind of spouts", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02646-00648711-00648895": "off his obscenities and turns up late", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02647-00648896-00649047": "for his press conferences", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02648-00649048-00649287": "that it's easy to individualize that for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02649-00649288-00649399": "uh for uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02650-00649400-00649551": "well not just the western media but", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02651-00649552-00649679": "probably for the philippine media as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02652-00649680-00649766": "well and sort of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02653-00649767-00650055": "you know uh construct that as a kind of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02654-00650056-00650327": "good story a good journalistic story but", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02655-00650328-00650575": "again it would be too you know it's far", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02656-00650576-00650847": "too narrow an analysis to assert that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02657-00650848-00650903": "you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02658-00650904-00651175": "duterte became you know who he is and is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02659-00651176-00651318": "wreaking the havoc that he's wreaking", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02660-00651319-00651479": "simply because of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02661-00651480-00651718": "you know his individual personality or", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02662-00651719-00651822": "certain kind of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02663-00651823-00652159": "um actions that he took without", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02664-00652160-00652518": "understanding that those wider contexts", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02665-00652519-00652910": "if i could just jump in here briefly", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02666-00652911-00653183": "uh originally and we've sort of i think", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02667-00653184-00653303": "the discussion has gone interesting", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02668-00653304-00653407": "direction but the question originally", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02669-00653408-00653543": "was about i think victor urban", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02670-00653544-00653883": "in hungary and if that was a specific", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02671-00653884-00654270": "map", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02672-00654271-00654510": "and i think the answer is absolutely he", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02673-00654511-00654751": "with the declaration of emergency powers", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02674-00654752-00654935": "in hungary in 2020", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02675-00654936-00655166": "which was granted by parliament was a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02676-00655167-00655343": "response to massive inequality", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02677-00655344-00655607": "in the uh sort of stalinist hungary uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02678-00655608-00655791": "in the context of global capitalist", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02679-00655792-00655887": "price", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02680-00655888-00656151": "and a similar sort of complicity from", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02681-00656152-00656270": "other sections", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02682-00656271-00656679": "of the ostensibly democratic elite", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02683-00656680-00656951": "facilitating the rise of figures like", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02684-00656952-00657014": "orban", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02685-00657015-00657414": "or duterte or bolsonaro", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02686-00657415-00657718": "has shades of the moment of making", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02687-00657719-00657958": "hitler chancellor in 1933", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02688-00657959-00658135": "in which the bourgeoisie effectively", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02689-00658136-00658479": "abdicate political leadership and say", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02690-00658480-00658814": "fine the nazis can do it um and in that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02691-00658815-00658943": "sense dealing with this question of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02692-00658944-00659199": "ideology of its origins", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02693-00659200-00659391": "the strain that it represents is a very", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02694-00659392-00659558": "valuable question because it highlights", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02695-00659559-00659639": "the sort of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02696-00659640-00659918": "the recurring nature of dictatorship in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02697-00659919-00660062": "the 20th century and the character of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02698-00660063-00660214": "u.s imperialism which", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02699-00660215-00660479": "tom's talk on the nature of the u.s role", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02700-00660480-00660655": "in all of this was absolutely", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02701-00660656-00660966": "useful in this um but one must", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02702-00660967-00661158": "also ask the question not just of its", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02703-00661159-00661279": "historical roots", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02704-00661280-00661583": "but of its contemporary simultaneity", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02705-00661584-00661870": "why is it all coming back now why is it", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02706-00661871-00661975": "all in the last", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02707-00661976-00662279": "eight years that we are looking at and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02708-00662280-00662462": "massively sharpened with the covet 19", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02709-00662463-00662662": "pandemic and i think the question has to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02710-00662663-00662855": "deal with the crisis of capitalism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02711-00662856-00663095": "that has never recovered from 2008", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02712-00663096-00663366": "massive social inequality", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02713-00663367-00663687": "the emergence of forms of social unrest", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02714-00663688-00663839": "that cannot be constrained within", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02715-00663840-00664055": "traditional democratic forms of rule", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02716-00664056-00664335": "and authoritarianism as in the arsenal", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02717-00664336-00664510": "as you correctly point out our oscar", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02718-00664511-00664599": "they're bringing this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02719-00664600-00664766": "this is something they've used many", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02720-00664767-00664983": "times but this is coming back", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02721-00664984-00665366": "around the world in a way that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02722-00665367-00665575": "has to have a commons it's not", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02723-00665576-00665807": "accidental", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02724-00665808-00666118": "can i um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02725-00666119-00666495": "come in at this point and contribute to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02726-00666496-00666791": "this fascinating discussion by the three", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02727-00666792-00666862": "of you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02728-00666863-00667231": "um with respect to the original question", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02729-00667232-00667607": "um uh in terms of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02730-00667608-00668055": "uh neoliberalism across uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02731-00668056-00668366": "europe and uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02732-00668367-00668703": "asia um i think", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02733-00668704-00669007": "one important difference between", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02734-00669008-00669503": "uh right-wing regimes like", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02735-00669504-00669887": "orban and right-wing parties", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02736-00669888-00670270": "like the um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02737-00670271-00670718": "french rally of marine le pen", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02738-00670719-00671047": "is that uh they", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02739-00671048-00671391": "uh have basically cherry picked", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02740-00671392-00671751": "um traditional social democratic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02741-00671752-00671847": "positions", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02742-00671848-00672151": "welfare positions on", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02743-00672152-00672510": "uh globalization on", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02744-00672511-00672951": "um welfare and you know basically", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02745-00672952-00673247": "i think that if you look at um if you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02746-00673248-00673295": "look at", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02747-00673296-00673743": "both hungary uh as well as um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02748-00673744-00674079": "the program of uh le pen what", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02749-00674080-00674447": "basically they say is yes it's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02750-00674448-00674791": "it's this writes for you so long as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02751-00674792-00675127": "you are of the same stock the same", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02752-00675128-00675399": "color the same language you know so it's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02753-00675400-00675631": "a sort of a welfare chauvinism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02754-00675632-00675935": "that you find there", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02755-00675936-00676343": "whereas duterte and modi", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02756-00676344-00676695": "are more at this point um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02757-00676696-00677014": "espousing or tolerating or", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02758-00677015-00677335": "promoting uh um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02759-00677336-00677558": "the old neoliberalism i think it's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02760-00677559-00677647": "significant", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02761-00677648-00677958": "that when the turkey came to power one", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02762-00677959-00678151": "of the things he said about his economic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02763-00678152-00678366": "policy was that it would be", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02764-00678367-00678727": "you know continuous with aquino's policy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02765-00678728-00678791": "so there's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02766-00678792-00679083": "in fact been if you look at economic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02767-00679084-00679199": "policies", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02768-00679200-00679479": "there has been no change and um for all", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02769-00679480-00679687": "intents and purposes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02770-00679688-00679999": "it is his economic technocrats that run", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02771-00680000-00680039": "that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02772-00680040-00680247": "because as he said he doesn't understand", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02773-00680248-00680391": "economics so", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02774-00680392-00680710": "he has given the uh you know he's given", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02775-00680711-00680839": "full control", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02776-00680840-00681143": "when it comes to economic policy to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02777-00681144-00681575": "his technocrats like um dominguez", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02778-00681576-00681743": "and all of these are very very new", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02779-00681744-00681879": "liberal people so there's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02780-00681880-00682214": "that's one difference the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02781-00682215-00682399": "the second point i think i'd like to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02782-00682400-00682575": "make is that while", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02783-00682576-00683014": "joseph has", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02784-00683015-00683343": "pointed to the role of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02785-00683344-00683839": "traditional left in the philippines um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02786-00683840-00683991": "and i have no disagreement with the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02787-00683992-00684166": "general characterization", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02788-00684167-00684495": "um i think that we", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02789-00684496-00684799": "also must see that the left", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02790-00684800-00685135": "has played a role in in europe", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02791-00685136-00685527": "uh in the united states uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02792-00685528-00685791": "i mean we are talking about social", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02793-00685792-00685966": "democrats", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02794-00685967-00686270": "uh tony blair", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02795-00686271-00686575": "francois hollande you know the whole", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02796-00686576-00686775": "social democratic tradition in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02797-00686776-00687079": "europe bought into neoliberalism", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02798-00687080-00687414": "and uh in fact this is uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02799-00687415-00687591": "and and of course if you look at the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02800-00687592-00687775": "democratic party in the states as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02801-00687776-00688079": "sort of a broad-left party it also", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02802-00688080-00688118": "bought", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02803-00688119-00688447": "into the reaganos uh alternative", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02804-00688448-00688783": "and you know so so that when it comes", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02805-00688784-00689207": "to the west i think we're not just", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02806-00689208-00689583": "talking about elites", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02807-00689584-00690047": "sort of endorsing these people", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02808-00690048-00690318": "we're talking about the traditional", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02809-00690319-00690479": "parties of the working class", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02810-00690480-00690751": "abandoning the working class by going", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02811-00690752-00690958": "for neoliberalism and therefore", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02812-00690959-00691118": "making them vulnerable to being", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02813-00691119-00691262": "recruited by", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02814-00691263-00691599": "the uh by this new", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02815-00691600-00691910": "right-wing fascist uh parties", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02816-00691911-00692222": "so i think that's um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02817-00692223-00692503": "you know so i think that's one place", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02818-00692504-00692566": "where there's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02819-00692567-00692975": "a an interesting sort of uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02820-00692976-00693327": "um you know uh similarity", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02821-00693328-00693822": "and of course when you look at india uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02822-00693823-00694151": "i think that that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02823-00694152-00694518": "you know the rise with the bjp and", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02824-00694519-00694727": "the crisis of the left are also very", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02825-00694728-00694870": "much related", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02826-00694871-00695022": "especially when you look at what", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02827-00695023-00695310": "happened in bengal", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02828-00695311-00695703": "uh you know the whole", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02829-00695704-00696007": "way that the the ruling left there made", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02830-00696008-00696079": "a pact", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02831-00696080-00696422": "with you know very big uh indian", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02832-00696423-00696822": "um family grouping the tata grouping", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02833-00696823-00697166": "uh to create this big export processing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02834-00697167-00697270": "zone", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02835-00697271-00697607": "or you know that that basically", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02836-00697608-00697983": "you know uh caused it eventually the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02837-00697984-00698303": "appeal of uh you know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02838-00698304-00698607": "the masses in in in in bengal and led to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02839-00698608-00698655": "the loss", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02840-00698656-00698966": "of power of the indian left", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02841-00698967-00699303": "in in large parts of india so", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02842-00699304-00699599": "you know so uh yes you know in terms of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02843-00699600-00699751": "the role of the left", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02844-00699752-00699975": "the you know we shouldn't just look at", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02845-00699976-00700166": "say the case in the philippines but also", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02846-00700167-00700287": "india", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02847-00700288-00700639": "the role of the social", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02848-00700640-00700927": "um the workers party in brazil i mean", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02849-00700928-00700991": "that's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02850-00700992-00701295": "got to be brought in uh the crisis of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02851-00701296-00701422": "the democratic party", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02852-00701423-00701735": "where it's now been it has been seen to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02853-00701736-00701895": "have abundant it's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02854-00701896-00702118": "large parts of its base and of course in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02855-00702119-00702207": "europe too so", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02856-00702208-00702439": "i think we should bring in the the role", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02857-00702440-00702631": "of the left as a factor here", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02858-00702632-00702799": "um the only other thing i would like to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02859-00702800-00703143": "make is a clarification", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02860-00703144-00703455": "because joseph did raise this well first", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02861-00703456-00703503": "of all", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02862-00703504-00703935": "you know yes you know when akbayan", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02863-00703936-00704283": "which saw itself as a social democratic", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02864-00704284-00704439": "formation uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02865-00704440-00704727": "in a new sense uh allied with the aquino", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02866-00704728-00704847": "administration", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02867-00704848-00705327": "back in um 2010 it was seen as sort", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02868-00705328-00705655": "of a situation whereby", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02869-00705656-00706039": "that would be you know an alliance in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02870-00706040-00706135": "which we would", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02871-00706136-00706422": "push from the left in order to be able", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02872-00706423-00706510": "to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02873-00706511-00706918": "gain the progressive reforms", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02874-00706919-00707303": "that would be possible at that point as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02875-00707304-00707414": "well as", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02876-00707415-00707751": "move the philippines to a more", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02877-00707752-00708135": "independent position in foreign policy", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02878-00708136-00708487": "now as i said in my talk that did not", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02879-00708488-00708918": "in fact succeed and um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02880-00708919-00709303": "basically and the reason you know why i", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02881-00709304-00709703": "left congress was was because uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02882-00709704-00709991": "i got very different in terms of my", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02883-00709992-00710191": "positions on aquino than my", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02884-00710192-00710495": "my former uh party uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02885-00710496-00710791": "the second point is more like um the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02886-00710792-00711014": "lebanon masa of which i'm the national", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02887-00711015-00711055": "chair", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02888-00711056-00711487": "person at this point is not part of uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02889-00711488-00711855": "zambayan uh in fact we've been quite", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02890-00711856-00712039": "critical of the way that it has been", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02891-00712040-00712335": "formed uh and said that we", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02892-00712336-00712551": "you know it's it comes at the end of a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02893-00712552-00712703": "process", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02894-00712704-00712943": "it it it should it's beginning at what", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02895-00712944-00713135": "should be the end of a process rather", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02896-00713136-00713455": "than a beginning which is a contention", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02897-00713456-00713487": "of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02898-00713488-00713855": "programs rather than this sort of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02899-00713856-00713927": "backroom", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02900-00713928-00714262": "filling of positions by personality so", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02901-00714263-00714439": "i just wanted to make that clear joseph", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02902-00714440-00714591": "that we're i don't", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02903-00714592-00714710": "i don't know whether you said we were", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02904-00714711-00714951": "part of sort of i i got that but no", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02905-00714952-00715239": "we have definitely been quite been quite", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02906-00715240-00715391": "critical of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02907-00715392-00715647": "the way isambayan has been formed at", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02908-00715648-00715951": "this point in time", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02909-00715952-00716287": "okay um i think um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02910-00716288-00716510": "we can i mean we can continue this", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02911-00716511-00716614": "discussion", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02912-00716615-00716903": "as long as you um we have um enough", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02913-00716904-00717151": "participants i can stay until half past", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02914-00717152-00717270": "one", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02915-00717271-00717439": "um because there are many other", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02916-00717440-00717614": "questions here that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02917-00717615-00718079": "um i i think we would be interesting for", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02918-00718080-00718439": "these speakers to respond to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02919-00718440-00718662": "um sorry derek can i just say i'm gonna", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02920-00718663-00718839": "have to leave at 1 15. i'm afraid", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02921-00718840-00718983": "because i've got another meeting but i'm", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02922-00718984-00719222": "quite happy if people want to carry on", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02923-00719223-00719503": "the recording will go on and then be um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02924-00719504-00719631": "saved at the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02925-00719632-00719903": "portsmouth uh sort of archives and we'll", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02926-00719904-00720031": "upload that video", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02927-00720032-00720287": "to youtube um you know in due course", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02928-00720288-00720462": "i'll have to go to it because i'm", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02929-00720463-00720670": "in another zoom right you know in a few", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02930-00720671-00720775": "minutes okay", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02931-00720776-00721127": "yeah so i i would i would opportunity to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02932-00721128-00721270": "respond to some of the points that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02933-00721271-00721414": "professor bellio just raised a second", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02934-00721415-00721455": "ago", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02935-00721456-00721679": "walden made i think a really good point", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02936-00721680-00721775": "about the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02937-00721776-00721991": "role of the left universally not just in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02938-00721992-00722079": "the philippines", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02939-00722080-00722239": "and i had hoped that was clear from my", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02940-00722240-00722422": "presentation but i'm glad that he", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02941-00722423-00722510": "brought that forward", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02942-00722511-00722822": "it is decidedly not simplified", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02943-00722823-00723079": "phenomenon uh this is a question that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02944-00723080-00723199": "you mentioned orlando", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02945-00723200-00723607": "company", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02946-00723608-00723879": "around the globe the shift by forces", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02947-00723880-00723999": "ostensibly left", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02948-00724000-00724247": "into the camp of and that is just", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02949-00724248-00724366": "something the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02950-00724367-00724591": "capitalist reforms being dictated by", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02951-00724592-00724870": "finance cap", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02952-00724871-00725070": "has been a critical fact facilitating", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02953-00725071-00725191": "the rise of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02954-00725192-00725407": "the far right which has been able to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02955-00725408-00725614": "gain populist ground as a result", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02956-00725615-00725814": "uh and i did not mean to imply that that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02957-00725815-00726007": "was legal in fact my entire argument is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02958-00726008-00726143": "that this is bound up with global", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02959-00726144-00726270": "developments and the function of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02960-00726271-00726310": "left", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02961-00726311-00726487": "is of a similar character around the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02962-00726488-00726655": "globe um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02963-00726656-00726951": "the only other point uh i was not saying", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02964-00726952-00727014": "that", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02965-00727015-00727287": "uh la bano masa was a founding member of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02966-00727288-00727422": "isambayan which i know", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02967-00727423-00727807": "includes as well as the right-wing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02968-00727808-00727895": "magdalo", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02969-00727896-00728158": "which is a party of sort of uh", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02970-00728159-00728303": "originally found that out of", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02971-00728304-00728583": "coup oriented sections of the military", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02972-00728584-00728718": "but i know that la", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02973-00728719-00728958": "masa did at least term isambayan a", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02974-00728959-00729151": "breath of fresh air", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02975-00729152-00729327": "and that you issued a statement that the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02976-00729328-00729558": "comparison of various programs", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02977-00729559-00729966": "in a sort of primary sensibility would", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02978-00729967-00730175": "lead to the formation of a biden-like", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02979-00730176-00730351": "candidate", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02980-00730352-00730518": "you made the analogy to the elections in", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02981-00730519-00730662": "the united states which", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02982-00730663-00730918": "i don't see that as a way forward at all", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02983-00730919-00731070": "and my call for the independence of the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02984-00731071-00731191": "working class is", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02985-00731192-00731399": "antithetical to such a conception just", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02986-00731400-00731743": "to clarify", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02987-00731744-00731943": "okay thank you joseph and thanks", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02988-00731944-00732158": "everybody i i do have to run", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02989-00732159-00732503": "and it was a very fascinating discussion", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02990-00732504-00732703": "thank you thank you sorry about the", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02991-00732704-00732879": "mix-up earlier i gave you the wrong time", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02992-00732880-00733110": "that's my bad", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02993-00733111-00733399": "it's okay i will have to go to because", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02994-00733400-00733683": "i'm attending to a family emergency", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02995-00733684-00733822": "actually", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02996-00733823-00734127": "yeah i don't time about this but thank", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02997-00734128-00734262": "you so much", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02998-00734263-00734647": "thank you so much okay so i think tom we", "QM-rh_vWCzY-02999-00734648-00734687": "can", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03000-00734688-00735014": "we can end the the webinar now okay so", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03001-00735015-00735247": "thank you very much to all of you who", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03002-00735248-00735375": "stayed on", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03003-00735376-00735727": "um we went well past the time but", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03004-00735728-00735918": "thank you for your patience and interest", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03005-00735919-00736062": "so um", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03006-00736063-00736239": "wait for the recording to be made", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03007-00736240-00736399": "available to you", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03008-00736400-00736599": "thank you derek for doing a superb job", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03009-00736600-00736862": "of chairing", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03010-00736863-00737022": "and thank you to joseph thank you to", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03011-00737023-00737231": "denise as well our assistant um who's", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03012-00737232-00737310": "been", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03013-00737311-00737510": "helping with this so hopefully we can do", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03014-00737511-00737710": "something like this again be great", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03015-00737711-00739439": "thanks everyone's terrific bye", "QM-rh_vWCzY-03016-00739440-00739648": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "QM-Sw0c8mlM", "text": {"QM-Sw0c8mlM-00000-00000000-00000211": "hey guys so I'm checking out Milton we", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00001-00000212-00000467": "are usually out in the community filming", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00002-00000468-00000770": "local businesses parks and different", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00003-00000771-00001025": "neighborhoods so with the current state", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00004-00001026-00001349": "of the world right now we're unable to", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00005-00001350-00001577": "do that but I do have some footage that", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00006-00001578-00001772": "I had shot previously that just hadn't", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00007-00001773-00002045": "been edited yet so I want to share with", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00008-00002046-00002201": "you today", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00009-00002202-00002410": "an amazing store friend it's called", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00010-00002411-00002718": "grope for it so I had the opportunity to", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00011-00002719-00003050": "go into the store and have a great", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00012-00003051-00003458": "interview with the owner and so I wanted", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00013-00003459-00003572": "to share that with you guys", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00014-00003572-00003856": "today she does have an Etsy shop there", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00015-00003857-00004129": "are things available to order online and", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00016-00004130-00004340": "she is doing local pickups I'm a", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00017-00004341-00004565": "notorious plant killer if you know me", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00018-00004566-00004838": "you know that but I'm trying I'm always", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00019-00004839-00005120": "trying because I love plants they just", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00020-00005121-00005443": "don't always look three-pack but Lucy I", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00021-00005444-00005716": "picked up this I think it's the monstera", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00022-00005717-00005963": "deliciosa Lucy you will correct me if", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00023-00005964-00006145": "I'm saying that wrong I'm showing", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00024-00006146-00006343": "butchering it but I just love this", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00025-00006344-00006620": "little plant and it's growing so quickly", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00026-00006620-00006889": "so I just feel like you know I'm doing", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00027-00006890-00007048": "my best to really take care of it right", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00028-00007050-00007381": "now I need a new pot but other than that", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00029-00007383-00007639": "it's it's growing really nice and it's", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00030-00007640-00007727": "so pretty", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00031-00007728-00008009": "I'm trying to be a plant person anyways", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00032-00008009-00008192": "she's got a lot of really great things", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00033-00008193-00008384": "in her store so check out this video", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00034-00008385-00008599": "give them some love on Instagram give", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00035-00008600-00008774": "them a like on Facebook if you shop", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00036-00008775-00009053": "there give them a review let's do all we", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00037-00009054-00009214": "can to support our local business at", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00038-00009215-00009499": "this time so check out this week's video", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00039-00009500-00009770": "and thanks for watching", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00040-00009771-00010030": "[Music]", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00041-00010031-00010283": "thank you so much for coming in I really", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00042-00010284-00010370": "appreciate it", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00043-00010371-00010709": "so go for it started because I love", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00044-00010710-00011156": "plants and i have the slogan embrace the", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00045-00011157-00011338": "plant built life and that's really what", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00046-00011339-00011609": "I started to do and notice that there's", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00047-00011610-00011767": "other people who want to do the same", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00048-00011768-00012152": "thing and plants really bring life into", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00049-00012153-00012458": "a space and makes people feel happy", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00050-00012459-00012808": "plants do make you feel happy right like", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00051-00012809-00013060": "there's something like I don't know", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00052-00013061-00013225": "maybe I think it's about being in nature", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00053-00013226-00013421": "there or something like that right like", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00054-00013422-00013558": "they have healing properties too don't", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00055-00013559-00013769": "they like for your air and yeah they do", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00056-00013769-00014003": "a lot of plants like the peace lily for", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00057-00014004-00014300": "example and even the snake plant to get", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00058-00014301-00014581": "high on NASA's list for air purifying so", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00059-00014582-00014840": "lots of benefits not just that they look", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00060-00014841-00015074": "pretty but they're also beneficial well", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00061-00015075-00015419": "very close and so within the store I", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00062-00015419-00015538": "like to have variety", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00063-00015540-00015728": "because I know variety is the spice of", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00064-00015729-00016049": "life yeah so we've got succulents over", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00065-00016050-00016597": "here so very easy care I know it just", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00066-00016598-00016787": "needs bright light and you water", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00067-00016788-00017050": "infrequently and then I've got some of", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00068-00017051-00017353": "the other plants that are very", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00069-00017354-00017647": "sought-after so this is the rapid áfourá", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00070-00017648-00018994": "tetris perma oh wow that's a really well", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00071-00018995-00019330": "it is very pretty nature has so much", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00072-00019331-00019633": "design that's amazing mm-hmm and then", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00073-00019634-00019969": "speaking of split leaf design we've got", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00074-00019970-00020146": "this one with just the monstera", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00075-00020147-00020444": "deliciosa oh this is like a very trendy", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00076-00020445-00020702": "plant right it is and it makes such a", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00077-00020703-00020950": "statement in the space so you'll notice", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00078-00020951-00021221": "that the leaves here are kind of solid", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00079-00021222-00021449": "leaf yeah but then as the plant matures", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00080-00021450-00021764": "and you're gonna get these splits or", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00081-00021765-00021869": "fenestrations", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00082-00021870-00022105": "oh I'm not really cool that's really", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00083-00022106-00022265": "neat and they get really big too don't", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00084-00022266-00022558": "they that's why it's monster sized", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00085-00022559-00022643": "that's", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00086-00022644-00022880": "Anthony the name is pretty cool so", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00087-00022881-00023159": "monstera deliciou says so in the wild or", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00088-00023160-00023444": "I guess outdoors when conditions are", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00089-00023445-00023726": "appropriated actually fruits oh wow", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00090-00023727-00024092": "really Alicia's fruits no way that's", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00091-00024093-00024158": "awesome", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00092-00024159-00024902": "a little espanol bear are unique so", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00093-00024903-00025208": "we've got this jewel orchid oh yeah", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00094-00025209-00025496": "discolored so Wow yeah I'll show", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00095-00025497-00025874": "actually one with them when you look at", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00096-00025875-00026381": "the leaves here beautiful gorgeous", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00097-00026382-00027495": "yeah and then there's ones that are also", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00098-00027495-00027812": "this one here looks like almost like", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00099-00027813-00028220": "like wow it's so pretty it's so", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00100-00028222-00028540": "intricate like art almost yes exactly", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00101-00028541-00028823": "gorgeous are they hard to take care of", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00102-00028824-00029226": "humidity and a tremendous amount of", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00103-00029227-00029442": "light which is pretty doable for those", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00104-00029443-00029757": "people within the store there's other", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00105-00029758-00030083": "items too that help you kind of embrace", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00106-00030085-00030464": "that plant life so we've got art on the", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00107-00030466-00030720": "up on the boutique side there's some", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00108-00030720-00031635": "pottery there so my earring yeah those", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00109-00031636-00032004": "are awesome and these are some results", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00110-00032005-00032445": "from oh wow very very pretty that's", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00111-00032445-00033248": "awesome you are seeing the plant light", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00112-00033249-00033726": "people want to come in should they check", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00113-00033727-00033951": "you out on your Instagram - okay so", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00114-00033952-00034337": "please check me out if Instagram okay", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00115-00034338-00035043": "you are oh okay perfect okay so one okay", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00116-00035044-00035100": "awesome", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00117-00035101-00035367": "grow fruit is an awesome little local", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00118-00035368-00035586": "plant shop with not just plants but", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00119-00035587-00035768": "think of all the things for the plant", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00120-00035769-00036051": "lover in your life from the trendy", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00121-00036052-00036321": "plants like the fiddly fig to the rare", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00122-00036322-00036612": "plants Lucy and Grover have a large", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00123-00036613-00036879": "variety for now you can visit them", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00124-00036880-00037149": "online at grow for it dot life to order", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00125-00037150-00037392": "your plants we can't wait for them to", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00126-00037393-00037662": "reopen and visit Lucy and her shop on", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00127-00037663-00037937": "Charles Street thank you so much for", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00128-00037938-00038136": "watching and be sure to check out grow", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00129-00038137-00038418": "for it on Instagram and Facebook see you", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00130-00038419-00038907": "next week Milton", "QM-Sw0c8mlM-00131-00038908-00039113": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "QMED3HF1GRU", "text": {"QMED3HF1GRU-00000-00000000-00000320": "a biopsy is a medical test commonly", "QMED3HF1GRU-00001-00000321-00000539": "performed by a surgeon interventional", "QMED3HF1GRU-00002-00000540-00000730": "radiologist or an interventional", "QMED3HF1GRU-00003-00000731-00000944": "cardiologist involving extraction of", "QMED3HF1GRU-00004-00000944-00001178": "sample cells or tissues for examination", "QMED3HF1GRU-00005-00001179-00001382": "to determine the presence or extent of a", "QMED3HF1GRU-00006-00001383-00001691": "disease the tissue is generally examined", "QMED3HF1GRU-00007-00001692-00001918": "under a microscope by a pathologist and", "QMED3HF1GRU-00008-00001919-00002234": "can also be analyzed chemically when an", "QMED3HF1GRU-00009-00002235-00002447": "entire lump or suspicious area is", "QMED3HF1GRU-00010-00002448-00002639": "removed the procedure is called an", "QMED3HF1GRU-00011-00002640-00002926": "excisional biopsy an incisional biopsy", "QMED3HF1GRU-00012-00002927-00003224": "or core biopsy samples a portion of the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00013-00003225-00003425": "abnormal tissue without attempting to", "QMED3HF1GRU-00014-00003426-00003728": "remove the entire lesion or tumor when a", "QMED3HF1GRU-00015-00003729-00003931": "sample of tissue or fluid is removed", "QMED3HF1GRU-00016-00003932-00004142": "with a needle in such a way that cells", "QMED3HF1GRU-00017-00004143-00004304": "are removed without preserving the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00018-00004305-00004502": "histological architecture of the tissue", "QMED3HF1GRU-00019-00004503-00004709": "cells the procedure is called a needle", "QMED3HF1GRU-00020-00004710-00005042": "aspiration biopsy biopsies are most", "QMED3HF1GRU-00021-00005043-00005225": "commonly performed for insight into", "QMED3HF1GRU-00022-00005226-00005426": "possible cancerous and inflammatory", "QMED3HF1GRU-00023-00005427-00005987": "conditions", "QMED3HF1GRU-00024-00005988-00006687": "topic history the arab physician abacus", "QMED3HF1GRU-00025-00006688-00007011": "10:13 to 11:07 developed one of the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00026-00007012-00007344": "earliest diagnostic biopsies he used a", "QMED3HF1GRU-00027-00007345-00007512": "needle to puncture a goiter and then", "QMED3HF1GRU-00028-00007513-00008125": "characterized the material", "QMED3HF1GRU-00029-00008126-00008834": "topic etymology the term biopsy reflects", "QMED3HF1GRU-00030-00008835-00009215": "the Greek words bios bios life and OPS's", "QMED3HF1GRU-00031-00009216-00009554": "OPS's aside the French dermatologist", "QMED3HF1GRU-00032-00009555-00009812": "Ernest Bosnia introduced the word biopsy", "QMED3HF1GRU-00033-00009813-00010582": "to the medical community in 1879", "QMED3HF1GRU-00034-00010583-00011455": "topic medical use", "QMED3HF1GRU-00035-00011456-00012121": "topic cancer when cancer is suspected a", "QMED3HF1GRU-00036-00012122-00012339": "variety of biopsy techniques can be", "QMED3HF1GRU-00037-00012340-00012643": "applied an excisional biopsy is an", "QMED3HF1GRU-00038-00012644-00012910": "attempt to remove an entire lesion when", "QMED3HF1GRU-00039-00012911-00013153": "the specimen is evaluated in addition to", "QMED3HF1GRU-00040-00013154-00013354": "diagnosis the amount of uninvolved", "QMED3HF1GRU-00041-00013355-00013569": "tissue around the lesion the surgical", "QMED3HF1GRU-00042-00013570-00013777": "margin of the specimen is examined to", "QMED3HF1GRU-00043-00013778-00013951": "see if the disease has spread beyond the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00044-00013952-00014388": "area biopsied clear margins or negative", "QMED3HF1GRU-00045-00014390-00014688": "margins means that no disease was found", "QMED3HF1GRU-00046-00014690-00014887": "at the edges of the biopsy specimen", "QMED3HF1GRU-00047-00014888-00015225": "positive margins means that disease was", "QMED3HF1GRU-00048-00015226-00015463": "found and a wider excision may be needed", "QMED3HF1GRU-00049-00015463-00015816": "depending on the diagnosis when intact", "QMED3HF1GRU-00050-00015818-00016015": "removal is not indicated for a variety", "QMED3HF1GRU-00051-00016016-00016243": "of reasons a wedge of tissue may be", "QMED3HF1GRU-00052-00016244-00016569": "taken in an incisional biopsy in some", "QMED3HF1GRU-00053-00016570-00016786": "cases a sample can be collected by", "QMED3HF1GRU-00054-00016787-00017169": "devices that bite a sample a variety of", "QMED3HF1GRU-00055-00017170-00017394": "sizes of needle can collect tissue in", "QMED3HF1GRU-00056-00017395-00017749": "the lumen core biopsy smaller diameter", "QMED3HF1GRU-00057-00017750-00017962": "needles collect cells in cell clusters", "QMED3HF1GRU-00058-00017963-00018253": "fine needle aspiration biopsy pathologic", "QMED3HF1GRU-00059-00018254-00018472": "examination of a biopsy can determine", "QMED3HF1GRU-00060-00018473-00018643": "whether a lesion is benign or malignant", "QMED3HF1GRU-00061-00018644-00018853": "and can help differentiate between", "QMED3HF1GRU-00062-00018854-00019177": "different types of cancer in contrast to", "QMED3HF1GRU-00063-00019178-00019425": "a biopsy that merely samples a lesion a", "QMED3HF1GRU-00064-00019426-00019630": "larger excisional specimen called a", "QMED3HF1GRU-00065-00019631-00019794": "resection may come to a pathologist", "QMED3HF1GRU-00066-00019795-00020028": "typically from a surgeon attempting to", "QMED3HF1GRU-00067-00020029-00020244": "eradicate an only j'en from a patient", "QMED3HF1GRU-00068-00020245-00020542": "for example a pathologist would examine", "QMED3HF1GRU-00069-00020543-00020803": "a mastectomy specimen even if a previous", "QMED3HF1GRU-00070-00020804-00021009": "non excisional breast biopsy had already", "QMED3HF1GRU-00071-00021010-00021214": "established the diagnosis of breast", "QMED3HF1GRU-00072-00021215-00021490": "cancer examination of the full", "QMED3HF1GRU-00073-00021491-00021700": "mastectomy specimen would confirm the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00074-00021701-00021892": "exact nature of the cancer sub", "QMED3HF1GRU-00075-00021893-00022125": "classification of tumor and histologic", "QMED3HF1GRU-00076-00022126-00022425": "grading and reveal the extent of its", "QMED3HF1GRU-00077-00022426-00023113": "spread pathologic staging", "QMED3HF1GRU-00078-00023114-00023774": "topic liquid biopsy there are two types", "QMED3HF1GRU-00079-00023775-00023993": "of liquid biopsy which is not really a", "QMED3HF1GRU-00080-00023994-00024197": "biopsy as they are blood tests that do", "QMED3HF1GRU-00081-00024198-00024379": "not require a biopsy of tissue", "QMED3HF1GRU-00082-00024380-00024605": "circulating tumor cell essays or", "QMED3HF1GRU-00083-00024606-00024883": "cell-free circulating tumor DNA tests", "QMED3HF1GRU-00084-00024884-00025145": "these methods provide a non-invasive", "QMED3HF1GRU-00085-00025146-00025409": "alternative to repeat invasive biopsies", "QMED3HF1GRU-00086-00025410-00025645": "to evaluate the mutations in cancer and", "QMED3HF1GRU-00087-00025647-00025916": "plan individualized treatments in", "QMED3HF1GRU-00088-00025917-00026089": "addition because cancer is a", "QMED3HF1GRU-00089-00026091-00026282": "heterogeneous genetic disease and", "QMED3HF1GRU-00090-00026283-00026501": "excisional biopsy spre vide only a", "QMED3HF1GRU-00091-00026502-00026711": "snapshot in time of some of the rapid", "QMED3HF1GRU-00092-00026712-00026933": "dynamic genetic changes occurring in", "QMED3HF1GRU-00093-00026933-00027161": "tumors liquid biopsies provides some", "QMED3HF1GRU-00094-00027162-00027377": "advantages over tissue biopsy based", "QMED3HF1GRU-00095-00027377-00027715": "genomic testing in addition excisional", "QMED3HF1GRU-00096-00027716-00027932": "biopsy s are invasive can't be used", "QMED3HF1GRU-00097-00027933-00028118": "repeatedly and are ineffective in", "QMED3HF1GRU-00098-00028119-00028313": "understanding the dynamics of tumor", "QMED3HF1GRU-00099-00028314-00028625": "progression and metastasis by detecting", "QMED3HF1GRU-00100-00028626-00028870": "and quantifying genomic alterations in", "QMED3HF1GRU-00101-00028872-00029170": "CTC s and cell-free DNA in blood liquid", "QMED3HF1GRU-00102-00029172-00029381": "biopsy can provide real-time information", "QMED3HF1GRU-00103-00029382-00029552": "on the stage of tumor progression", "QMED3HF1GRU-00104-00029552-00029792": "treatment effectiveness and cancer", "QMED3HF1GRU-00105-00029793-00030049": "metastasis risk this technological", "QMED3HF1GRU-00106-00030050-00030257": "development could make it possible to", "QMED3HF1GRU-00107-00030258-00030502": "diagnose and manage cancer from repeated", "QMED3HF1GRU-00108-00030504-00030644": "blood tests rather than from a", "QMED3HF1GRU-00109-00030645-00030883": "traditional biopsy circulating tumor", "QMED3HF1GRU-00110-00030885-00031106": "cell tests are under development by epic", "QMED3HF1GRU-00111-00031107-00031433": "sciences the tests analyzed circulating", "QMED3HF1GRU-00112-00031433-00031745": "tumor cells ctc's analysis of individual", "QMED3HF1GRU-00113-00031745-00031994": "CT sees demonstrated a high level of", "QMED3HF1GRU-00114-00031995-00032189": "heterogeneity seen at the single cell", "QMED3HF1GRU-00115-00032189-00032414": "level for both protein expression and", "QMED3HF1GRU-00116-00032414-00032651": "protein localization and the CT sees", "QMED3HF1GRU-00117-00032652-00032873": "reflected both the primary biopsy and", "QMED3HF1GRU-00118-00032874-00033175": "the changes seen in the metastatic sites", "QMED3HF1GRU-00119-00033176-00033446": "analysis of cell free circulating tumor", "QMED3HF1GRU-00120-00033447-00033746": "DNA CF DNA has an advantage over", "QMED3HF1GRU-00121-00033747-00033974": "circulating tumor cells essays in that", "QMED3HF1GRU-00122-00033975-00034181": "there is approximately 100 times more", "QMED3HF1GRU-00123-00034182-00034436": "cell-free DNA than there is DNA in", "QMED3HF1GRU-00124-00034437-00034745": "circulating tumor cells these tests", "QMED3HF1GRU-00125-00034746-00035000": "analyze fragments of tumor cell DNA that", "QMED3HF1GRU-00126-00035001-00035201": "are continuously shared by tumors into", "QMED3HF1GRU-00127-00035202-00035495": "the blood stream companies offering CF", "QMED3HF1GRU-00128-00035496-00035762": "DNA next generation sequencing testing", "QMED3HF1GRU-00129-00035763-00036005": "include personal genome diagnostics and", "QMED3HF1GRU-00130-00036006-00036271": "guar and health these tests are moving", "QMED3HF1GRU-00131-00036272-00036383": "into widespread", "QMED3HF1GRU-00132-00036384-00036611": "when a tissue biopsy has insufficient", "QMED3HF1GRU-00133-00036612-00036836": "material for DNA testing or when it is", "QMED3HF1GRU-00134-00036837-00037049": "not safe to do an invasive biopsy", "QMED3HF1GRU-00135-00037050-00037235": "procedure according to a recent report", "QMED3HF1GRU-00136-00037236-00037520": "of results on over 15,000 advanced", "QMED3HF1GRU-00137-00037521-00037690": "cancer patients sequenced with the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00138-00037691-00037964": "Guarin health test a 2014 study of the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00139-00037965-00038261": "blood of 846 patients with 15 different", "QMED3HF1GRU-00140-00038262-00038543": "types of cancer in 24 institutions was", "QMED3HF1GRU-00141-00038544-00038714": "able to detect the presence of cancer", "QMED3HF1GRU-00142-00038715-00039098": "DNA in the body they found tumor DNA in", "QMED3HF1GRU-00143-00039099-00039272": "the blood of more than 80 percent of", "QMED3HF1GRU-00144-00039273-00039461": "patients with metastatic cancers in", "QMED3HF1GRU-00145-00039462-00039769": "about 47% of those with localized tumors", "QMED3HF1GRU-00146-00039770-00040046": "the test does not indicate the tumor", "QMED3HF1GRU-00147-00040047-00040237": "sites or other information about the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00148-00040238-00040520": "tumor the tests did not produce false", "QMED3HF1GRU-00149-00040521-00040751": "positives such tests may also be useful", "QMED3HF1GRU-00150-00040752-00040976": "to assess whether malignant cells remain", "QMED3HF1GRU-00151-00040977-00041132": "in patients whose tumors have been", "QMED3HF1GRU-00152-00041133-00041474": "surgically removed up to 30% are", "QMED3HF1GRU-00153-00041475-00041675": "expected to relapse because some tumor", "QMED3HF1GRU-00154-00041676-00041954": "cells remain initial studies identified", "QMED3HF1GRU-00155-00041955-00042170": "about half the patients who later", "QMED3HF1GRU-00156-00042171-00042401": "relapsed again without false positives", "QMED3HF1GRU-00157-00042402-00042602": "and other potential uses to track the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00158-00042603-00042886": "specific DNA mutations driving a tumor", "QMED3HF1GRU-00159-00042887-00043163": "many new cancer medications block", "QMED3HF1GRU-00160-00043164-00043471": "specific molecular processes such tests", "QMED3HF1GRU-00161-00043472-00043676": "could allow easier targeting of therapy", "QMED3HF1GRU-00162-00043677-00044162": "to tumor", "QMED3HF1GRU-00163-00044163-00044844": "topic precancerous conditions for easily", "QMED3HF1GRU-00164-00044845-00045021": "detected and accessed sites any", "QMED3HF1GRU-00165-00045022-00045272": "suspicious lesions may be assessed", "QMED3HF1GRU-00166-00045273-00045531": "originally this was skin or superficial", "QMED3HF1GRU-00167-00045532-00045912": "masses x-ray then later CT MRI and", "QMED3HF1GRU-00168-00045913-00046164": "ultrasound along with endoscopy extended", "QMED3HF1GRU-00169-00046165-00046679": "the range", "QMED3HF1GRU-00170-00046680-00047287": "topic inflammatory conditions", "QMED3HF1GRU-00171-00047288-00047515": "a biopsy of the temporal arteries is", "QMED3HF1GRU-00172-00047516-00047782": "often performed for suspected vasculitis", "QMED3HF1GRU-00173-00047783-00048083": "in inflammatory bowel disease Crohn's", "QMED3HF1GRU-00174-00048084-00048326": "disease and ulcerative colitis frequent", "QMED3HF1GRU-00175-00048327-00048499": "biopsies are taken to assess the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00176-00048500-00048670": "activity of disease and to assess", "QMED3HF1GRU-00177-00048671-00048920": "changes that precede malignancy biopsy", "QMED3HF1GRU-00178-00048921-00049139": "specimens are often taken from part of a", "QMED3HF1GRU-00179-00049140-00049301": "lesion when the cause of a disease is", "QMED3HF1GRU-00180-00049302-00049511": "uncertain or its extent or exact", "QMED3HF1GRU-00181-00049512-00049832": "character is in doubt vasculitis for", "QMED3HF1GRU-00182-00049833-00050164": "instance is usually diagnosed on biopsy", "QMED3HF1GRU-00183-00050165-00050455": "kidney disease biopsy and fluorescence", "QMED3HF1GRU-00184-00050456-00050683": "microscopy are key in the diagnosis of", "QMED3HF1GRU-00185-00050684-00050967": "alterations of renal function the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00186-00050968-00051170": "immunofluorescence plays vital role in", "QMED3HF1GRU-00187-00051171-00051350": "the diagnosis of crescentus", "QMED3HF1GRU-00188-00051351-00051688": "glomerulonephritis infectious disease", "QMED3HF1GRU-00189-00051689-00051913": "lymph node enlargement may be due to a", "QMED3HF1GRU-00190-00051914-00052136": "variety of infectious or autoimmune", "QMED3HF1GRU-00191-00052137-00052468": "diseases metabolic disease some", "QMED3HF1GRU-00192-00052469-00052661": "conditions affect the whole body but", "QMED3HF1GRU-00193-00052662-00052876": "certain sites are selectively biopsied", "QMED3HF1GRU-00194-00052877-00053116": "because they are easily accessed", "QMED3HF1GRU-00195-00053116-00053321": "amyloidosis is a condition where", "QMED3HF1GRU-00196-00053322-00053537": "degraded proteins accumulate in body", "QMED3HF1GRU-00197-00053538-00053828": "tissues in order to make the diagnosis", "QMED3HF1GRU-00198-00053829-00054226": "the gingival transplantation biopsies of", "QMED3HF1GRU-00199-00054227-00054418": "transplanted organs are performed in", "QMED3HF1GRU-00200-00054419-00054575": "order to determine that they are not", "QMED3HF1GRU-00201-00054576-00054761": "being rejected or that the disease that", "QMED3HF1GRU-00202-00054762-00055078": "necessitated transplant has not recurred", "QMED3HF1GRU-00203-00055079-00055385": "fertility a testicular biopsy is used", "QMED3HF1GRU-00204-00055386-00055598": "for evaluating the fertility of men and", "QMED3HF1GRU-00205-00055599-00055766": "find out the cause of a possible", "QMED3HF1GRU-00206-00055766-00056050": "infertility eg when sperm quality is low", "QMED3HF1GRU-00207-00056051-00056228": "but hormone levels still are within", "QMED3HF1GRU-00208-00056229-00056826": "normal ranges", "QMED3HF1GRU-00209-00056827-00057748": "topic biopsied sites", "QMED3HF1GRU-00210-00057749-00058413": "topic analysis of biopsied material", "QMED3HF1GRU-00211-00058414-00058700": "after the biopsy is performed the sample", "QMED3HF1GRU-00212-00058701-00058850": "of tissue that was removed from the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00213-00058851-00059028": "patient is sent to the pathology", "QMED3HF1GRU-00214-00059029-00059363": "laboratory a pathologist specializes in", "QMED3HF1GRU-00215-00059364-00059616": "diagnosing diseases such as cancer by", "QMED3HF1GRU-00216-00059616-00059934": "examining tissue under a microscope when", "QMED3HF1GRU-00217-00059935-00060174": "the laboratory see histology receives", "QMED3HF1GRU-00218-00060175-00060366": "the biopsy sample the tissue is", "QMED3HF1GRU-00219-00060366-00060566": "processed in an extremely thin slice of", "QMED3HF1GRU-00220-00060567-00060776": "tissue is removed from the sample and", "QMED3HF1GRU-00221-00060777-00061079": "attached to a glass slide any remaining", "QMED3HF1GRU-00222-00061080-00061311": "tissue is saved for use in later studies", "QMED3HF1GRU-00223-00061312-00061623": "if required the slide with the tissue", "QMED3HF1GRU-00224-00061624-00061841": "attached is treated with dyes that stain", "QMED3HF1GRU-00225-00061842-00062046": "the tissue which allows the individual", "QMED3HF1GRU-00226-00062047-00062229": "cells in the tissue to be seen more", "QMED3HF1GRU-00227-00062229-00062507": "clearly the slide is then given to the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00228-00062508-00062700": "pathologist who examines the tissue", "QMED3HF1GRU-00229-00062701-00062904": "under a microscope looking for any", "QMED3HF1GRU-00230-00062904-00063219": "abnormal findings the pathologist then", "QMED3HF1GRU-00231-00063220-00063378": "prepares a report that lists any", "QMED3HF1GRU-00232-00063379-00063605": "abnormal or important findings from the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00233-00063607-00063885": "biopsy this report is sent to the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00234-00063886-00064074": "physician who originally performed the", "QMED3HF1GRU-00235-00064075-00064696": "biopsy on the patient", "QMED3HF1GRU-00236-00064697-00065249": "topic see also", "QMED3HF1GRU-00237-00065250-00065634": "interventional radiology"}}, {"audio_id": "QMVGqPrM40c", "text": {"QMVGqPrM40c-00000-00000479-00000591": "hi everyone and", "QMVGqPrM40c-00001-00000592-00000871": "welcome to my talk on our paper devising", "QMVGqPrM40c-00002-00000872-00001070": "career recommendations with new welfare", "QMVGqPrM40c-00003-00001071-00001215": "collaborative filtering", "QMVGqPrM40c-00004-00001216-00001535": "it's a joint work with cameroon jk dr", "QMVGqPrM40c-00005-00001536-00001574": "pan", "QMVGqPrM40c-00006-00001575-00001918": "and my mentor dr fols this talk is about", "QMVGqPrM40c-00007-00001919-00002063": "fairness in machine learning", "QMVGqPrM40c-00008-00002064-00002295": "which is the concern that the biases", "QMVGqPrM40c-00009-00002296-00002447": "inherent in data", "QMVGqPrM40c-00010-00002448-00002655": "can lead the behavior of machine", "QMVGqPrM40c-00011-00002656-00002758": "learning algorithms", "QMVGqPrM40c-00012-00002759-00002918": "to discriminate against certain", "QMVGqPrM40c-00013-00002919-00003166": "populations let's look into some real", "QMVGqPrM40c-00014-00003167-00003431": "world examples of unfairness", "QMVGqPrM40c-00015-00003432-00003711": "there was a very influential article", "QMVGqPrM40c-00016-00003711-00003790": "published in", "QMVGqPrM40c-00017-00003792-00004095": "propublica in 2016 on", "QMVGqPrM40c-00018-00004096-00004263": "a system called compass it's an", "QMVGqPrM40c-00019-00004264-00004470": "algorithmic tool for predicting risk of", "QMVGqPrM40c-00020-00004471-00004583": "reoffending", "QMVGqPrM40c-00021-00004584-00004751": "and used for bail and sentencing", "QMVGqPrM40c-00022-00004752-00004951": "decisions across the u.s", "QMVGqPrM40c-00023-00004952-00005143": "the pro publica study found that the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00024-00005144-00005286": "compass system is biased", "QMVGqPrM40c-00025-00005287-00005470": "since the algorithm predict more than", "QMVGqPrM40c-00026-00005471-00005775": "twice higher risk to african american", "QMVGqPrM40c-00027-00005776-00006159": "but actually they did not reoffend", "QMVGqPrM40c-00028-00006160-00006399": "another example is a news on ai", "QMVGqPrM40c-00029-00006400-00006591": "recruiting tool which was developed by", "QMVGqPrM40c-00030-00006592-00006663": "amazon", "QMVGqPrM40c-00031-00006664-00007023": "the idea was to use this tool to select", "QMVGqPrM40c-00032-00007023-00007270": "applicants automatically um based on", "QMVGqPrM40c-00033-00007272-00007406": "their resumes", "QMVGqPrM40c-00034-00007408-00007614": "but they found that the tool is biased", "QMVGqPrM40c-00035-00007615-00007734": "against two men", "QMVGqPrM40c-00036-00007736-00007934": "uh the good thing is amazon realized", "QMVGqPrM40c-00037-00007936-00008087": "this was happening and they never", "QMVGqPrM40c-00038-00008088-00008183": "deployed this tool", "QMVGqPrM40c-00039-00008184-00008495": "in the real world system gender device", "QMVGqPrM40c-00040-00008496-00008799": "job platform gene which is similar to", "QMVGqPrM40c-00041-00008800-00008903": "linkedin", "QMVGqPrM40c-00042-00008904-00009159": "is uh found to rank less qualified male", "QMVGqPrM40c-00043-00009160-00009239": "candidates", "QMVGqPrM40c-00044-00009240-00009487": "uh higher than more qualified female", "QMVGqPrM40c-00045-00009488-00009623": "candidates", "QMVGqPrM40c-00046-00009624-00009783": "inequality and education is another", "QMVGqPrM40c-00047-00009784-00009967": "motivation of our work", "QMVGqPrM40c-00048-00009968-00010167": "an earlier study illustrated that the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00049-00010168-00010335": "screening process of a medical school in", "QMVGqPrM40c-00050-00010336-00010438": "london was", "QMVGqPrM40c-00051-00010439-00010687": "highly biased against minorities in a", "QMVGqPrM40c-00052-00010688-00010942": "more recent work women accounted", "QMVGqPrM40c-00053-00010943-00011183": "for only 18 percent of the bachelor", "QMVGqPrM40c-00054-00011184-00011310": "degrees", "QMVGqPrM40c-00055-00011311-00011670": "in computer science and", "QMVGqPrM40c-00056-00011671-00011887": "in a separate study even hold a", "QMVGqPrM40c-00057-00011888-00012063": "disproportionately low share of esteem", "QMVGqPrM40c-00058-00012064-00012135": "degrees", "QMVGqPrM40c-00059-00012136-00012431": "particularly in engineering field to", "QMVGqPrM40c-00060-00012432-00012614": "grease this gap our interventions are", "QMVGqPrM40c-00061-00012615-00012767": "crucial to support the economic", "QMVGqPrM40c-00062-00012768-00012863": "competitiveness", "QMVGqPrM40c-00063-00012863-00013183": "and level of innovation our goal is to", "QMVGqPrM40c-00064-00013184-00013358": "address the disparities in ai based", "QMVGqPrM40c-00065-00013359-00013486": "career counselling", "QMVGqPrM40c-00066-00013487-00013783": "recovery systems can reinforce the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00067-00013784-00013983": "disparities or potentially help to", "QMVGqPrM40c-00068-00013984-00014143": "mitigate them", "QMVGqPrM40c-00069-00014144-00014391": "since a growing proportion of human", "QMVGqPrM40c-00070-00014391-00014535": "interactions are digitized", "QMVGqPrM40c-00071-00014536-00014719": "social media data is readily available", "QMVGqPrM40c-00072-00014719-00014903": "to support personalized recommendations", "QMVGqPrM40c-00073-00014904-00015047": "as long as the bias issues are", "QMVGqPrM40c-00074-00015047-00015143": "adequately", "QMVGqPrM40c-00075-00015144-00015391": "corrected we envision an able-based", "QMVGqPrM40c-00076-00015391-00015558": "career counseling tool that makes", "QMVGqPrM40c-00077-00015559-00015694": "personalized data-driven", "QMVGqPrM40c-00078-00015695-00015871": "recommendations regarding important", "QMVGqPrM40c-00079-00015872-00016015": "career choices and", "QMVGqPrM40c-00080-00016016-00016191": "ensures that the recommendations do not", "QMVGqPrM40c-00081-00016191-00016479": "make harmful stereotypes", "QMVGqPrM40c-00082-00016480-00016622": "the recommender system research", "QMVGqPrM40c-00083-00016623-00016863": "community has begun to consider", "QMVGqPrM40c-00084-00016864-00017183": "fairness issues for example extranet at", "QMVGqPrM40c-00085-00017184-00017311": "all analyze the popularity and", "QMVGqPrM40c-00086-00017312-00017486": "demographic biases of recommender", "QMVGqPrM40c-00087-00017487-00017567": "systems", "QMVGqPrM40c-00088-00017568-00017783": "yaw at all proposed fair recommendation", "QMVGqPrM40c-00089-00017784-00017950": "model by penalizing", "QMVGqPrM40c-00090-00017951-00018199": "the algorithm for display distribution", "QMVGqPrM40c-00091-00018200-00018311": "kamishima at all", "QMVGqPrM40c-00092-00018312-00018471": "try to ensure fairness by making", "QMVGqPrM40c-00093-00018472-00018671": "recommended items independent from", "QMVGqPrM40c-00094-00018672-00018830": "protected attributes", "QMVGqPrM40c-00095-00018831-00019047": "unlike previous works we specifically", "QMVGqPrM40c-00096-00019048-00019255": "study bias and career recommendations", "QMVGqPrM40c-00097-00019256-00019319": "and develop", "QMVGqPrM40c-00098-00019320-00019527": "a method for fair collaborative", "QMVGqPrM40c-00099-00019528-00019703": "filtering on social media", "QMVGqPrM40c-00100-00019704-00020007": "our contributions were we investigate", "QMVGqPrM40c-00101-00020008-00020247": "gender bias in collaborative filtering", "QMVGqPrM40c-00102-00020248-00020350": "model", "QMVGqPrM40c-00103-00020351-00020599": "trained on social media data we develop", "QMVGqPrM40c-00104-00020600-00020839": "neural fair collaborative filtering", "QMVGqPrM40c-00105-00020840-00021078": "method it's a practical technique to", "QMVGqPrM40c-00106-00021079-00021319": "mitigate gender bias and sensitive item", "QMVGqPrM40c-00107-00021320-00021511": "such as college measure or career", "QMVGqPrM40c-00108-00021512-00021647": "recommendations", "QMVGqPrM40c-00109-00021648-00021903": "it achieves accurate predictions while", "QMVGqPrM40c-00110-00021904-00022103": "addressing sensitive data especially", "QMVGqPrM40c-00111-00022104-00022407": "for example typically users have only", "QMVGqPrM40c-00112-00022408-00022543": "one or two college measures or", "QMVGqPrM40c-00113-00022544-00022703": "reputations", "QMVGqPrM40c-00114-00022704-00022919": "finally we perform extensive experiments", "QMVGqPrM40c-00115-00022920-00023103": "to show both fairness and accuracy", "QMVGqPrM40c-00116-00023104-00023230": "benefits", "QMVGqPrM40c-00117-00023231-00023407": "before moving into more details on our", "QMVGqPrM40c-00118-00023408-00023591": "method let's discuss the problem", "QMVGqPrM40c-00119-00023592-00023686": "statement", "QMVGqPrM40c-00120-00023687-00023855": "the objective function of implicit", "QMVGqPrM40c-00121-00023856-00023999": "feedback problem can be", "QMVGqPrM40c-00122-00024000-00024247": "defined using this object uh this uh", "QMVGqPrM40c-00123-00024248-00024335": "equation", "QMVGqPrM40c-00124-00024336-00024575": "where chi represents the interaction", "QMVGqPrM40c-00125-00024576-00024783": "between user and item and chi minus", "QMVGqPrM40c-00126-00024784-00024894": "represent", "QMVGqPrM40c-00127-00024895-00025158": "uh negative instances um which can be", "QMVGqPrM40c-00128-00025159-00025350": "all unobserved interactions or a subset", "QMVGqPrM40c-00129-00025351-00025550": "of unobserved interactions", "QMVGqPrM40c-00130-00025551-00025934": "ah why ui is the predicted output of the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00131-00025935-00025983": "model", "QMVGqPrM40c-00132-00025983-00026231": "which is one when there is a interaction", "QMVGqPrM40c-00133-00026232-00026399": "otherwise zero", "QMVGqPrM40c-00134-00026400-00026646": "our assumptions are items can be divided", "QMVGqPrM40c-00135-00026647-00026814": "into non-sensitive and sensitive", "QMVGqPrM40c-00136-00026816-00027023": "non-sensitive items can be facebook", "QMVGqPrM40c-00137-00027024-00027223": "pages where user preferences may be", "QMVGqPrM40c-00138-00027224-00027327": "reasonably", "QMVGqPrM40c-00139-00027327-00027631": "influenced by their gender or races this", "QMVGqPrM40c-00140-00027632-00027839": "part of the data is typically large", "QMVGqPrM40c-00141-00027839-00028070": "on the other hand sensitive items may be", "QMVGqPrM40c-00142-00028072-00028255": "the user's occupation provided in their", "QMVGqPrM40c-00143-00028256-00028470": "social media profiles", "QMVGqPrM40c-00144-00028472-00028670": "typically every user may be associated", "QMVGqPrM40c-00145-00028672-00028918": "with only a single occupation", "QMVGqPrM40c-00146-00028919-00029158": "and sensitive item recommendations", "QMVGqPrM40c-00147-00029160-00029311": "should be unrelated to the user's", "QMVGqPrM40c-00148-00029312-00029446": "protected attribute", "QMVGqPrM40c-00149-00029447-00029614": "here the big challenge is data", "QMVGqPrM40c-00150-00029616-00029799": "especially in the observed user", "QMVGqPrM40c-00151-00029800-00030190": "sensitive item interactions", "QMVGqPrM40c-00152-00030191-00030455": "he at all proposed um dual collaborative", "QMVGqPrM40c-00153-00030456-00030583": "filtering method", "QMVGqPrM40c-00154-00030583-00030783": "which replaces the matrix factorization", "QMVGqPrM40c-00155-00030783-00030958": "with a multi-layer neural network", "QMVGqPrM40c-00156-00030960-00031207": "where user and item are one hot encoded", "QMVGqPrM40c-00157-00031208-00031399": "and mapped into embedding layer to learn", "QMVGqPrM40c-00158-00031400-00031431": "the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00159-00031432-00031695": "their latent space finally underlying", "QMVGqPrM40c-00160-00031695-00031839": "dna model", "QMVGqPrM40c-00161-00031839-00032118": "use the user and item latent vectors to", "QMVGqPrM40c-00162-00032119-00032287": "predict the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00163-00032288-00032558": "implicit feedback it shows a", "QMVGqPrM40c-00164-00032560-00032702": "state-of-the-art recommendation", "QMVGqPrM40c-00165-00032703-00032790": "performance", "QMVGqPrM40c-00166-00032791-00032990": "but there is no fairness interventions", "QMVGqPrM40c-00167-00032991-00033159": "in the model", "QMVGqPrM40c-00168-00033160-00033359": "we consider two fairness matrix first", "QMVGqPrM40c-00169-00033360-00033551": "one is differential fairness which was", "QMVGqPrM40c-00170-00033552-00033846": "proposed by our group previously", "QMVGqPrM40c-00171-00033847-00034271": "in this metric an ai or ml systems is", "QMVGqPrM40c-00172-00034272-00034446": "epsilon differential if they are", "QMVGqPrM40c-00173-00034447-00034662": "in a framework with protected attributes", "QMVGqPrM40c-00174-00034663-00034871": "and data distributions", "QMVGqPrM40c-00175-00034872-00035199": "if it satisfy uh these ratios", "QMVGqPrM40c-00176-00035200-00035455": "where pm theta you know are the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00177-00035456-00035623": "probabilities with respect to", "QMVGqPrM40c-00178-00035624-00035887": "data and the mechanism the key idea is", "QMVGqPrM40c-00179-00035888-00036095": "the ratios of probabilities of outcomes", "QMVGqPrM40c-00180-00036096-00036318": "bounded for any pair of values of", "QMVGqPrM40c-00181-00036319-00036559": "protected attributes", "QMVGqPrM40c-00182-00036560-00036774": "absolute unfairness is the other", "QMVGqPrM40c-00183-00036775-00036959": "fairness metric we have used", "QMVGqPrM40c-00184-00036960-00037159": "uh it measures the differences in", "QMVGqPrM40c-00185-00037160-00037295": "absolute estimation error", "QMVGqPrM40c-00186-00037296-00037615": "across uh disadvantages and advantage", "QMVGqPrM40c-00187-00037616-00037799": "users", "QMVGqPrM40c-00188-00037800-00037943": "this is our proposed neural fair", "QMVGqPrM40c-00189-00037944-00038118": "collaborative filtering method", "QMVGqPrM40c-00190-00038119-00038335": "with uh which we use to mitigate gender", "QMVGqPrM40c-00191-00038336-00038551": "bias in career recommendation", "QMVGqPrM40c-00192-00038552-00039007": "the main components are an ncf model", "QMVGqPrM40c-00193-00039008-00039295": "retaining user and non-sensitive item", "QMVGqPrM40c-00194-00039296-00039502": "embeddings", "QMVGqPrM40c-00195-00039503-00039759": "and then devising the user embeddings", "QMVGqPrM40c-00196-00039760-00039951": "finally", "QMVGqPrM40c-00197-00039952-00040135": "we fine tune the model for sensitive", "QMVGqPrM40c-00198-00040136-00040343": "item recommendations with a", "QMVGqPrM40c-00199-00040344-00040671": "fairness penalty term the dnm", "QMVGqPrM40c-00200-00040672-00040871": "under this model is defined as similar", "QMVGqPrM40c-00201-00040872-00041030": "as the neural collaborative filtering", "QMVGqPrM40c-00202-00041031-00041102": "model", "QMVGqPrM40c-00203-00041103-00041311": "we will show the value of each component", "QMVGqPrM40c-00204-00041312-00041679": "with an ablation stability", "QMVGqPrM40c-00205-00041680-00041935": "in the first step of our method ncf is", "QMVGqPrM40c-00206-00041936-00042039": "trained", "QMVGqPrM40c-00207-00042040-00042223": "to predict users interactions with", "QMVGqPrM40c-00208-00042224-00042343": "non-sensitive items", "QMVGqPrM40c-00209-00042344-00042615": "via back propagation um no fairness", "QMVGqPrM40c-00210-00042616-00042846": "interventions in this step", "QMVGqPrM40c-00211-00042847-00043062": "this leverages plentiful non-sensitive", "QMVGqPrM40c-00212-00043063-00043255": "data to learn user embeddings of the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00213-00043256-00043535": "user's preferences and network waves", "QMVGqPrM40c-00214-00043536-00043807": "but it may also introduce demographic", "QMVGqPrM40c-00215-00043808-00043943": "bias due to correlations with", "QMVGqPrM40c-00216-00043944-00044079": "demographics", "QMVGqPrM40c-00217-00044080-00044287": "such as liking the orbital page", "QMVGqPrM40c-00218-00044288-00044471": "typically correlates with users", "QMVGqPrM40c-00219-00044472-00044711": "gender our aim is to leverage the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00220-00044712-00044967": "variable signal of users differences for", "QMVGqPrM40c-00221-00044968-00045199": "improved sensitive item recommendations", "QMVGqPrM40c-00222-00045200-00045415": "but we also want to address the problems", "QMVGqPrM40c-00223-00045416-00045615": "with it regarding bias", "QMVGqPrM40c-00224-00045616-00045799": "in the second step the pre-end user", "QMVGqPrM40c-00225-00045800-00046039": "embeddings from step 1 are devised", "QMVGqPrM40c-00226-00046040-00046239": "for this task we adopt a very recent", "QMVGqPrM40c-00227-00046240-00046399": "work of attenuating bias", "QMVGqPrM40c-00228-00046400-00046727": "in word vectors by dave at all first we", "QMVGqPrM40c-00229-00046728-00046790": "compute", "QMVGqPrM40c-00230-00046791-00046999": "group specific bias direction for female", "QMVGqPrM40c-00231-00047000-00047190": "users by taking average all the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00232-00047191-00047462": "female users vectors we do same thing", "QMVGqPrM40c-00233-00047463-00047599": "for the main users", "QMVGqPrM40c-00234-00047600-00047839": "then compute overall gender bias vector", "QMVGqPrM40c-00235-00047840-00047927": "using", "QMVGqPrM40c-00236-00047928-00048127": "uh the difference between the female and", "QMVGqPrM40c-00237-00048128-00048230": "male vector", "QMVGqPrM40c-00238-00048231-00048543": "finally we devise each user embedding by", "QMVGqPrM40c-00239-00048544-00048711": "subtracting their component to the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00240-00048712-00048871": "direction of the bias vector", "QMVGqPrM40c-00241-00048872-00049318": "b b in the third step we transfer the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00242-00049319-00049543": "device user embeddings and pretend dna", "QMVGqPrM40c-00243-00049544-00049727": "parameters to a model for recommending", "QMVGqPrM40c-00244-00049728-00049846": "sensitive items", "QMVGqPrM40c-00245-00049847-00050143": "the model is fine tuned for this task", "QMVGqPrM40c-00246-00050144-00050343": "with the added fairness penalty to the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00247-00050344-00050439": "objective function", "QMVGqPrM40c-00248-00050440-00050695": "to address the second source of bias", "QMVGqPrM40c-00249-00050696-00050855": "which is demographic bias in the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00250-00050856-00050983": "sensitive items", "QMVGqPrM40c-00251-00050984-00051174": "we construct fairness penalty by", "QMVGqPrM40c-00252-00051175-00051423": "completing the power sensitive items", "QMVGqPrM40c-00253-00051424-00051670": "differential fairness finally we use", "QMVGqPrM40c-00254-00051671-00051863": "back propagation to fine tune the model", "QMVGqPrM40c-00255-00051864-00052102": "by minimizing this objective function", "QMVGqPrM40c-00256-00052103-00052311": "where l is the typical loss function of", "QMVGqPrM40c-00257-00052312-00052447": "implicit feedback", "QMVGqPrM40c-00258-00052448-00052726": "r is the fairness penalty term lambda", "QMVGqPrM40c-00259-00052727-00052903": "represents tuning parameter", "QMVGqPrM40c-00260-00052904-00053142": "that balances between the accuracy and", "QMVGqPrM40c-00261-00053144-00053359": "fairness of the model", "QMVGqPrM40c-00262-00053360-00053550": "this is the pseudo code of our method", "QMVGqPrM40c-00263-00053551-00053742": "the most of the part of this", "QMVGqPrM40c-00264-00053744-00053911": "algorithm i have already discussed in", "QMVGqPrM40c-00265-00053912-00054142": "previous slides so i will not go over it", "QMVGqPrM40c-00266-00054144-00054287": "again", "QMVGqPrM40c-00267-00054288-00054511": "we also consider two variants which are", "QMVGqPrM40c-00268-00054512-00054719": "simplifications of our method", "QMVGqPrM40c-00269-00054720-00054926": "as a baseline to show the benefit of", "QMVGqPrM40c-00270-00054927-00055087": "each component in", "QMVGqPrM40c-00271-00055088-00055471": "our nfcf model first one is nfcf embed", "QMVGqPrM40c-00272-00055472-00055742": "this variant only device user embeddings", "QMVGqPrM40c-00273-00055744-00055959": "and since there is no additional", "QMVGqPrM40c-00274-00055960-00056111": "fairness penalty this algorithm", "QMVGqPrM40c-00275-00056112-00056287": "converges faster", "QMVGqPrM40c-00276-00056288-00056454": "second variant is projection based", "QMVGqPrM40c-00277-00056455-00056599": "collaborative filtering", "QMVGqPrM40c-00278-00056600-00056903": "and ncf model is trained and then we", "QMVGqPrM40c-00279-00056904-00056950": "devise", "QMVGqPrM40c-00280-00056951-00057207": "user embeddings and finally we use a", "QMVGqPrM40c-00281-00057208-00057438": "classifier", "QMVGqPrM40c-00282-00057439-00057630": "on the device user embeddings to predict", "QMVGqPrM40c-00283-00057632-00057799": "the sensitive items", "QMVGqPrM40c-00284-00057800-00058054": "um here there are no fine tuning to", "QMVGqPrM40c-00285-00058055-00058223": "address overfitting or fairness penalty", "QMVGqPrM40c-00286-00058224-00058294": "based by", "QMVGqPrM40c-00287-00058295-00058623": "correction for experiments we use public", "QMVGqPrM40c-00288-00058624-00058799": "data mobiles where", "QMVGqPrM40c-00289-00058800-00059007": "movies are the non-sensitive item and", "QMVGqPrM40c-00290-00059008-00059159": "users occupations", "QMVGqPrM40c-00291-00059160-00059407": "are the sensitive items we also use the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00292-00059408-00059494": "facebook data", "QMVGqPrM40c-00293-00059495-00059694": "which was collected for my personality", "QMVGqPrM40c-00294-00059695-00059887": "project with user sponsor", "QMVGqPrM40c-00295-00059888-00060103": "their facebook pages are non-sensitive", "QMVGqPrM40c-00296-00060104-00060271": "data and", "QMVGqPrM40c-00297-00060272-00060494": "pre-regular uh college measures of the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00298-00060495-00060671": "users are the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00299-00060672-00061206": "sensitive uh items", "QMVGqPrM40c-00300-00061207-00061391": "we use several baseline as typical", "QMVGqPrM40c-00301-00061391-00061606": "baseline we use mf without", "QMVGqPrM40c-00302-00061607-00061838": "without pretend ncf with or without", "QMVGqPrM40c-00303-00061839-00062103": "pretend we use also a classifier based", "QMVGqPrM40c-00304-00062104-00062415": "uh method finally we used bayesian", "QMVGqPrM40c-00305-00062416-00062503": "probabilistic", "QMVGqPrM40c-00306-00062504-00062806": "matrix factorization via mcmc as fair", "QMVGqPrM40c-00307-00062807-00062975": "baselines we use", "QMVGqPrM40c-00308-00062976-00063206": "yao at all proposed matrix factorization", "QMVGqPrM40c-00309-00063207-00063342": "with epsilon", "QMVGqPrM40c-00310-00063344-00063550": "absolute unfairness based uh penalty", "QMVGqPrM40c-00311-00063551-00063671": "term uh", "QMVGqPrM40c-00312-00063672-00063975": "we also use resampling for balance where", "QMVGqPrM40c-00313-00063976-00064238": "we basically gender balance the trained", "QMVGqPrM40c-00314-00064239-00064479": "data", "QMVGqPrM40c-00315-00064479-00064615": "before learning the collaborative", "QMVGqPrM40c-00316-00064616-00064911": "filtering models", "QMVGqPrM40c-00317-00064912-00065199": "at first we validate our model choices", "QMVGqPrM40c-00318-00065200-00065366": "um", "QMVGqPrM40c-00319-00065367-00065623": "first we compare the retaining task", "QMVGqPrM40c-00320-00065624-00065726": "performance", "QMVGqPrM40c-00321-00065727-00065959": "ncf had substantially and consistently", "QMVGqPrM40c-00322-00065960-00066255": "showed better performance compared to mf", "QMVGqPrM40c-00323-00066256-00066487": "on the retaining task in fine-tuning", "QMVGqPrM40c-00324-00066488-00066599": "performance", "QMVGqPrM40c-00325-00066600-00066959": "in terms of the ranking score in dcg", "QMVGqPrM40c-00326-00066960-00067255": "we find that the ncf with pretend had", "QMVGqPrM40c-00327-00067256-00067431": "the best performance over the other", "QMVGqPrM40c-00328-00067432-00067519": "baselines", "QMVGqPrM40c-00329-00067520-00067663": "and our proposed method performed", "QMVGqPrM40c-00330-00067664-00067863": "approximately similarly to", "QMVGqPrM40c-00331-00067864-00068271": "uh this to this baseband model", "QMVGqPrM40c-00332-00068272-00068431": "we also visualize the embedding of", "QMVGqPrM40c-00333-00068432-00068687": "devices here we show the pca projections", "QMVGqPrM40c-00334-00068688-00068799": "of the male and female", "QMVGqPrM40c-00335-00068800-00068967": "vectors defined after the linear", "QMVGqPrM40c-00336-00068968-00069143": "projection phase depressing", "QMVGqPrM40c-00337-00069144-00069391": "embedding methods we can see that male", "QMVGqPrM40c-00338-00069392-00069487": "and female", "QMVGqPrM40c-00339-00069488-00069759": "were very different in their direction", "QMVGqPrM40c-00340-00069760-00069919": "and magnitude before", "QMVGqPrM40c-00341-00069920-00070279": "the devicing but after devising", "QMVGqPrM40c-00342-00070280-00070606": "male and female shows similar nature in", "QMVGqPrM40c-00343-00070607-00070871": "their direction and magnitudes", "QMVGqPrM40c-00344-00070872-00071215": "we also conduct an abduct ablation study", "QMVGqPrM40c-00345-00071216-00071606": "by removing each component of the method", "QMVGqPrM40c-00346-00071607-00071847": "our findings are a large degradation of", "QMVGqPrM40c-00347-00071848-00072038": "the performance of nfcf when", "QMVGqPrM40c-00348-00072039-00072238": "retaining was removed or ncf was", "QMVGqPrM40c-00349-00072239-00072375": "replaced by", "QMVGqPrM40c-00350-00072376-00072647": "matrix factorization removing the device", "QMVGqPrM40c-00351-00072648-00072799": "embedding method led to", "QMVGqPrM40c-00352-00072800-00073094": "better escorts but it increase the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00353-00073095-00073215": "gender bias", "QMVGqPrM40c-00354-00073216-00073550": "we get similar uh results uh when", "QMVGqPrM40c-00355-00073551-00073791": "we learn the model without fairness", "QMVGqPrM40c-00356-00073792-00073903": "penalty", "QMVGqPrM40c-00357-00073904-00074223": "um finally", "QMVGqPrM40c-00358-00074224-00074550": "compare our math proposed method", "QMVGqPrM40c-00359-00074551-00074935": "for mitigating gender bias", "QMVGqPrM40c-00360-00074936-00075103": "in the first experiment we compare our", "QMVGqPrM40c-00361-00075104-00075238": "proposed method with all the", "QMVGqPrM40c-00362-00075239-00075567": "fair baselines in terms of ndcg it shows", "QMVGqPrM40c-00363-00075568-00075671": "that our method", "QMVGqPrM40c-00364-00075672-00075926": "clearly outperform all other baselines", "QMVGqPrM40c-00365-00075927-00076055": "share baselines", "QMVGqPrM40c-00366-00076056-00076335": "and the second best was uh the another", "QMVGqPrM40c-00367-00076336-00076399": "variant", "QMVGqPrM40c-00368-00076400-00076711": "projection based cf in this table we", "QMVGqPrM40c-00369-00076712-00076862": "show career recommendations some movie", "QMVGqPrM40c-00370-00076863-00076903": "lens", "QMVGqPrM40c-00371-00076904-00077135": "and say nfcf was the fairest recommender", "QMVGqPrM40c-00372-00077136-00077382": "model in terms of both fairness metric", "QMVGqPrM40c-00373-00077383-00077623": "uh nfcf with pre-trained perform based", "QMVGqPrM40c-00374-00077624-00077806": "in the ranking metrics", "QMVGqPrM40c-00375-00077807-00078111": "our proposed model was as good", "QMVGqPrM40c-00376-00078112-00078447": "as nfcf with pre-trained model in terms", "QMVGqPrM40c-00377-00078448-00078671": "of ranking metrics it also", "QMVGqPrM40c-00378-00078672-00079047": "mitigates gender bias we get similar", "QMVGqPrM40c-00379-00079048-00079206": "trend of result on", "QMVGqPrM40c-00380-00079207-00079535": "a facebook data set in this experiment", "QMVGqPrM40c-00381-00079536-00079679": "we show the disparity", "QMVGqPrM40c-00382-00079680-00079967": "in general distributions for 10 example", "QMVGqPrM40c-00383-00079968-00080111": "carriers and college lasers", "QMVGqPrM40c-00384-00080112-00080335": "um for data sets and top 1", "QMVGqPrM40c-00385-00080336-00080479": "recommendations by nfc", "QMVGqPrM40c-00386-00080480-00080775": "model we found that nfc have decreased", "QMVGqPrM40c-00387-00080776-00080903": "the percentage of women", "QMVGqPrM40c-00388-00080904-00081271": "from home women for home maker from 97", "QMVGqPrM40c-00389-00081272-00081494": "percent to 50 percent on movie lens", "QMVGqPrM40c-00390-00081495-00081719": "and it increased percentage of women", "QMVGqPrM40c-00391-00081720-00081991": "from 27 percent to 48 percent for", "QMVGqPrM40c-00392-00081992-00082303": "computer science on facebook data in a", "QMVGqPrM40c-00393-00082304-00082455": "qualitative experiment", "QMVGqPrM40c-00394-00082456-00082831": "uh we show that the top one carrier and", "QMVGqPrM40c-00395-00082832-00083015": "callers measure", "QMVGqPrM40c-00396-00083016-00083303": "to each test male and female user via", "QMVGqPrM40c-00397-00083304-00083375": "nfcf", "QMVGqPrM40c-00398-00083376-00083679": "and a typical model nfc was found to", "QMVGqPrM40c-00399-00083680-00083903": "recommend similar carriers to both male", "QMVGqPrM40c-00400-00083904-00084094": "and female users on average", "QMVGqPrM40c-00401-00084095-00084311": "the typical model encoded societal", "QMVGqPrM40c-00402-00084312-00084535": "stereotypes in its recommendation", "QMVGqPrM40c-00403-00084536-00084703": "for example it recommends computer", "QMVGqPrM40c-00404-00084704-00084943": "science to male and nursing to female on", "QMVGqPrM40c-00405-00084944-00085023": "facebook", "QMVGqPrM40c-00406-00085024-00085375": "and recommends executive occupation", "QMVGqPrM40c-00407-00085376-00085782": "to mail and customer service to female", "QMVGqPrM40c-00408-00085783-00086055": "we investigated gender bias in social", "QMVGqPrM40c-00409-00086056-00086215": "media based collaborative filtering in", "QMVGqPrM40c-00410-00086216-00086303": "this work", "QMVGqPrM40c-00411-00086304-00086471": "we develop a practical solution to", "QMVGqPrM40c-00412-00086472-00086615": "mitigate gender bias", "QMVGqPrM40c-00413-00086616-00086782": "and achieve better performance and", "QMVGqPrM40c-00414-00086783-00086967": "fairness compared to an area of", "QMVGqPrM40c-00415-00086968-00087150": "state-of-the-art design models", "QMVGqPrM40c-00416-00087151-00087343": "the main limitation of our apples is", "QMVGqPrM40c-00417-00087344-00087494": "that it is designed", "QMVGqPrM40c-00418-00087495-00087679": "and evaluate for a single protected", "QMVGqPrM40c-00419-00087680-00087911": "attribute in future work we plan to", "QMVGqPrM40c-00420-00087912-00088055": "address this limitation with an", "QMVGqPrM40c-00421-00088056-00088182": "adversarial network", "QMVGqPrM40c-00422-00088183-00088518": "included in the fine-tuning step", "QMVGqPrM40c-00423-00088519-00088671": "by making the recommendations", "QMVGqPrM40c-00424-00088672-00088862": "independent from the multiple protected", "QMVGqPrM40c-00425-00088863-00089191": "attributes simultaneously", "QMVGqPrM40c-00426-00089192-00089455": "so that's it thank you and please feel", "QMVGqPrM40c-00427-00089456-00089983": "free to ask any questions"}}, {"audio_id": "QN0tlPIAJv4", "text": {"QN0tlPIAJv4-00000-00000006-00000434": "we are looking at a peacock loca a frog", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00001-00000434-00000746": "this tree for Maria I have not any work", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00002-00000747-00001174": "on it and others time I took a closer", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00003-00001175-00002078": "look at it and started sorting it out", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00004-00002079-00002427": "[Music]", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00005-00002428-00002951": "it was part exchanged for a chunky field", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00006-00002952-00003386": "maple that I had it's been wired and a", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00007-00003386-00003911": "lot of the wire branches are dead and", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00008-00003911-00004236": "dying so I'm going to remove all the", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00009-00004237-00004592": "wires and also the trunk is a bit their", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00010-00004593-00004906": "small cellar sweat so trying to ID that", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00011-00004907-00005250": "up as well also remove all these weeds", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00012-00005251-00005578": "every trunk is very very wet that's a", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00013-00005579-00006235": "bad sign also couldn't quite see not", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00014-00006236-00006416": "quite sure what subsoil is under there", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00015-00006417-00006677": "but it's very very wet it may need", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00016-00006678-00006856": "reporting but I'm going to be not gonna", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00017-00006858-00006928": "do it now", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00018-00006929-00007406": "you'll have to wait till March has not", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00019-00007406-00007606": "taking taking any chances in this race", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00020-00007608-00007976": "really substantial tree and I don't know", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00021-00007977-00008231": "what I'm going to find in there so it's", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00022-00008232-00008624": "best to wait it's the first thing I'm", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00023-00008625-00008903": "going to do is take off these wires", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00024-00008904-00009337": "which are going around the pot and I", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00025-00009338-00009578": "don't think the wise have done it any", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00026-00009579-00010160": "good if anything I have found that at", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00027-00010161-00010414": "many times the Y branches are the ones", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00028-00010415-00010802": "that die back and that's happened in", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00029-00010803-00012006": "this case", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00030-00012007-00012268": "I'm going to remove all these wires and", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00031-00012269-00012555": "we'll catch up shortly well today I have", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00032-00012556-00012982": "just about managed to clean the part all", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00033-00012983-00013276": "the weeds and all the other rubbish that", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00034-00013277-00013710": "was in here and also polished the pot", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00035-00013711-00013984": "and remove all the wires of a fair", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00036-00013985-00014191": "amount of dead wood some of the branches", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00037-00014191-00014686": "which were wired have died and I've", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00038-00014687-00015205": "removed all the wires and that's as far", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00039-00015206-00015508": "as I can go today with this tree I'll", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00040-00015509-00016006": "give it a quick turn and I prefer this", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00041-00016007-00016263": "natural look as opposed to having a", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00042-00016265-00016987": "wired self approach and the way I not", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00043-00016988-00017469": "quite sure how long I was in but there's", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00044-00017470-00017725": "just one brown chair up top over here", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00045-00017726-00017928": "which has been wild which is marked by", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00046-00017929-00018156": "the wires so they must have been in for", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00047-00018157-00018592": "quite some time and all right if it", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00048-00018593-00019128": "another great turn and we're back to any", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00049-00019129-00019459": "started thank you for watching", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00050-00019460-00019738": "to watch more please subscribe the", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00051-00019739-00020785": "signal con for big bonsai in West London", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00052-00020786-00021097": "now for the afterthought", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00053-00021098-00021500": "there were these two plaits in Game", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00054-00021501-00021808": "Reserve in Kenya they wandering around", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00055-00021809-00022105": "and they see a lion and they just freeze", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00056-00022106-00022405": "in their tracks and Ryan sees them and", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00057-00022406-00022700": "everyone is still for a moment and one", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00058-00022701-00022972": "of the guys gets his running shoes out", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00059-00022973-00023158": "of his backpack and starts putting them", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00060-00023159-00023608": "on and his friend looks at him and says", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00061-00023609-00024053": "you know can outrun the line and the", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00062-00024054-00024215": "other chap turns around and says well", "QN0tlPIAJv4-00063-00024216-00024509": "I'm gonna outrun you"}}]