[{"audio_id": "TuFngeUxXSM", "text": {"TuFngeUxXSM-00000-00001055-00001215": "in the name of allah", "TuFngeUxXSM-00001-00001216-00002883": "most gracious most merciful", "TuFngeUxXSM-00002-00002884-00005399": "foreign", "TuFngeUxXSM-00003-00005400-00005702": "and listens to its lord and it", "TuFngeUxXSM-00004-00005703-00006031": "must do so and when the earth is", "TuFngeUxXSM-00005-00006032-00006431": "stretched out and has cast out what was", "TuFngeUxXSM-00006-00006431-00006734": "within it and became empty", "TuFngeUxXSM-00007-00006736-00007070": "and listens to its lord and it must do", "TuFngeUxXSM-00008-00007072-00012139": "so", "TuFngeUxXSM-00009-00012140-00012406": "[Music]", "TuFngeUxXSM-00010-00012407-00012623": "indeed you are returning towards your", "TuFngeUxXSM-00011-00012624-00012742": "lord", "TuFngeUxXSM-00012-00012743-00013247": "are sure returning so you will meet him", "TuFngeUxXSM-00013-00013247-00013558": "then as for him who is given his record", "TuFngeUxXSM-00014-00013559-00013871": "in his right hand he shall then be", "TuFngeUxXSM-00015-00013872-00014215": "judged with an easy recording", "TuFngeUxXSM-00016-00014216-00014494": "and he shall return to his family", "TuFngeUxXSM-00017-00014495-00014647": "rejoicing", "TuFngeUxXSM-00018-00014647-00014943": "and as for him who is given his record", "TuFngeUxXSM-00019-00014944-00015094": "behind his back", "TuFngeUxXSM-00020-00015095-00015438": "he shall call for death and he shall", "TuFngeUxXSM-00021-00015440-00017921": "enter to burn in a blazing fire", "TuFngeUxXSM-00022-00017922-00018283": "[Music]", "TuFngeUxXSM-00023-00018284-00020343": "foreign", "TuFngeUxXSM-00024-00020344-00020694": "indeed he had been among his family", "TuFngeUxXSM-00025-00020695-00021055": "in joy indeed he thought that he would", "TuFngeUxXSM-00026-00021056-00021367": "never return to allah but yes", "TuFngeUxXSM-00027-00021368-00021758": "indeed his lord was ever watching him", "TuFngeUxXSM-00028-00021759-00022111": "so no i swear by the twilight", "TuFngeUxXSM-00029-00022112-00022407": "and the night and what it gathers and", "TuFngeUxXSM-00030-00022408-00022471": "the moon", "TuFngeUxXSM-00031-00022472-00022791": "when it becomes full then", "TuFngeUxXSM-00032-00022792-00023883": "you will surely embark upon state after", "TuFngeUxXSM-00033-00023884-00025367": "state", "TuFngeUxXSM-00034-00025368-00025655": "then what is the matter with them they", "TuFngeUxXSM-00035-00025656-00025806": "do not believe", "TuFngeUxXSM-00036-00025807-00026158": "and when the quran is recited to them", "TuFngeUxXSM-00037-00026160-00026487": "they do not fall prostrate", "TuFngeUxXSM-00038-00026488-00028233": "but those who disbelieve they deny", "TuFngeUxXSM-00039-00028235-00029483": "[Music]", "TuFngeUxXSM-00040-00029483-00029614": "foreign", "TuFngeUxXSM-00041-00029616-00029967": "best what they are gathering so", "TuFngeUxXSM-00042-00029968-00030239": "and give them the tidings of a painful", "TuFngeUxXSM-00043-00030239-00030374": "punishment", "TuFngeUxXSM-00044-00030375-00030662": "except for those who believe and", "TuFngeUxXSM-00045-00030663-00030823": "righteous deeds", "TuFngeUxXSM-00046-00030824-00031627": "for them is a reward", "TuFngeUxXSM-00047-00031627-00031927": "uninterrupted"}}, {"audio_id": "TuQKiHAZLJQ", "text": {"TuQKiHAZLJQ-00000-00000272-00000455": "so good morning everyone", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00001-00000456-00000623": "this is the imperio teaching and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00002-00000624-00000815": "learning call for april 7th", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00003-00000816-00001119": "i'm charles bristow from illinois state", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00004-00001120-00001431": "um and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00005-00001432-00001743": "let's see announcements um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00006-00001744-00002039": "wilma who is usually our queen of", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00007-00002039-00002279": "announcements isn't here today", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00008-00002280-00002407": "so i'm just going to throw a couple", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00009-00002408-00002726": "things out there that i am aware of", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00010-00002727-00003063": "um that have happened since we last got", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00011-00003064-00003118": "together", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00012-00003119-00003503": "number one is that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00013-00003504-00004063": "version 21.0 has been released", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00014-00004064-00004454": "so that's a good thing", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00015-00004455-00004638": "and the other thing i wanted to point", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00016-00004639-00004822": "out is that they have", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00017-00004823-00005247": "extended the um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00018-00005248-00005751": "call for proposals for open aperio 2021", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00019-00005752-00006095": "until april 9th which is the day after", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00020-00006096-00006254": "tomorrow", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00021-00006255-00006575": "so get your proposals in there", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00022-00006576-00007110": "and if i can find the link", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00023-00007111-00007302": "where's that email", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00024-00007303-00007510": "[Music]", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00025-00007511-00008151": "that's not the right one", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00026-00008152-00008519": "there it is", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00027-00008520-00008791": "i'm gonna post it in the chat and the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00028-00008792-00008903": "ether notes", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00029-00008904-00009610": "so", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00030-00009611-00010655": "um oops", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00031-00010656-00010871": "sorry i'm having trouble talking and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00032-00010872-00011183": "typing notes at the same time here", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00033-00011184-00011759": "to april", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00034-00011760-00012958": "does anybody else have any announcements", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00035-00012959-00014083": "okay so we're all very quiet this", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00036-00014084-00014222": "morning", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00037-00014223-00014591": "i'm assuming everyone can hear me okay", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00038-00014591-00014919": "i can hear you charles thanks adam i was", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00039-00014919-00015483": "starting to feel like i was talking to a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00040-00015484-00015999": "vacuum", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00041-00016000-00016358": "thank you ferris um alrighty", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00042-00016359-00016591": "if there are no other announcements or", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00043-00016592-00016758": "updates", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00044-00016759-00017150": "let's go ahead and move on to our jiras", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00045-00017151-00017409": "for today", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00046-00017410-00017630": "[Music]", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00047-00017631-00017943": "thanks eric heather", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00048-00017944-00018399": "i'm going to copy this in", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00049-00018400-00018863": "and i don't know if we have anybody", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00050-00018864-00019158": "from the core team present on this call", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00051-00019159-00019367": "to talk about this because this is one", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00052-00019368-00019583": "this is a new one by me i'm not familiar", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00053-00019584-00020014": "with this", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00054-00020015-00021083": "disable instance wide option to share", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00055-00021084-00021958": "rubrics", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00056-00021959-00022247": "so i'm not exactly sure what the core", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00057-00022248-00022447": "team wanted", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00058-00022448-00022783": "the tnl group to weigh", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00059-00022784-00023678": "in on", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00060-00023679-00024367": "so feature request to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00061-00024368-00024686": "allow people to kind of restrict how", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00062-00024687-00025071": "their rubrics are shared", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00063-00025072-00025350": "because right now if you share a rubric", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00064-00025351-00025750": "everybody can see it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00065-00025751-00025934": "so there's a suggestion to create a new", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00066-00025935-00026111": "property", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00067-00026112-00026327": "where they can either be shared with", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00068-00026327-00026567": "visible to everyone", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00069-00026568-00026870": "as it is by now by default", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00070-00026872-00027207": "shared only to site members", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00071-00027208-00027423": "and also to the owner in any other site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00072-00027424-00027631": "to be able to copy it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00073-00027632-00027927": "and none shared rubrics are visible only", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00074-00027927-00028127": "to the owner in the site or in any other", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00075-00028127-00030207": "site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00076-00030208-00030495": "generally speaking i think having more", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00077-00030495-00030695": "control is a good thing", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00078-00030695-00031007": "but i'm also wondering", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00079-00031008-00031167": "about what the situation is where", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00080-00031168-00031335": "someone wants to share a rubric with", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00081-00031336-00031487": "just a few people", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00082-00031488-00031718": "and a bunch of people they don't want to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00083-00031719-00031927": "share it with are just seen there", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00084-00031927-00032167": "waiting to pounce on it um that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00085-00032168-00032351": "[Music]", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00086-00032352-00032727": "i'm having trouble picturing this", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00087-00032727-00033246": "right um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00088-00033247-00033439": "i mean in some ways i'm almost thinking", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00089-00033440-00034279": "if it would be", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00090-00034280-00034590": "sorry i started thinking to myself um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00091-00034591-00034823": "so i'm i'm thinking that the the one", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00092-00034824-00035071": "kind of analogous thing i can think of", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00093-00035072-00035374": "in sakai is", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00094-00035375-00035862": "question pools and how they're shared", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00095-00035863-00036159": "and right now the only way you can share", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00096-00036160-00036318": "a question pool", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00097-00036319-00036559": "to someone else who is a member of the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00098-00036560-00036687": "site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00099-00036688-00037455": "that you are currently working in", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00100-00037456-00037655": "and to be honest the sharing of question", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00101-00037656-00037783": "pools trips up", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00102-00037784-00038127": "a number of my instructors really pretty", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00103-00038128-00038318": "good about navigating other sky", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00104-00038319-00038551": "things yeah so i'm not sure i want to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00105-00038552-00038743": "add this to rubrics", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00106-00038744-00039055": "yeah well i guess the the thing with", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00107-00039056-00039215": "the big difference with question pools", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00108-00039216-00039383": "is they're tied to the user not to the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00109-00039384-00039455": "site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00110-00039456-00039607": "which which i think is what really", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00111-00039608-00039774": "throws people off", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00112-00039775-00040127": "and rubrics are tied to a site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00113-00040128-00040327": "so it would it would actually work", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00114-00040328-00040702": "somewhat differently", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00115-00040703-00040879": "and i could also see an argument for", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00116-00040880-00041111": "having analogous sharing", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00117-00041112-00041415": "properties across a number of tools just", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00118-00041416-00041495": "so", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00119-00041496-00041687": "people can figure out this is how stuff", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00120-00041688-00041839": "is shared in sakai", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00121-00041840-00042030": "that there's a solid argument to be made", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00122-00042031-00042423": "for that yeah", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00123-00042424-00042743": "i mean i think the idea of being able to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00124-00042744-00043483": "limit sharing is a good one certainly", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00125-00043484-00044287": "um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00126-00044288-00044630": "sorry i need to get logged in here", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00127-00044631-00045839": "oh good", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00128-00045840-00046095": "anybody else have any comments about", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00129-00046096-00047639": "this or thoughts", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00130-00047640-00047958": "well yeah it's definitely messy um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00131-00047959-00048246": "because right now since you know anybody", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00132-00048247-00048439": "that shares a rubric", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00133-00048440-00048783": "um there's now just we've we've got this", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00134-00048784-00048927": "going on we've kind of been encouraging", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00135-00048928-00048967": "people", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00136-00048968-00049158": "not to necessarily share rubrics but", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00137-00049159-00049311": "they've done it anyway", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00138-00049312-00049558": "they never listened to us so now we have", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00139-00049559-00049639": "this huge", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00140-00049640-00049911": "mass of shared rubrics and they're not", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00141-00049912-00050071": "even sorted in a reasonable way it's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00142-00050072-00050574": "hard to find anything in that list", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00143-00050575-00051039": "so it's definitely an issue", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00144-00051040-00051230": "that will only get worse with time as", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00145-00051232-00051342": "more people share", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00146-00051344-00051742": "rubrics um even if they just want even", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00147-00051744-00051911": "if their only intent is to share it with", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00148-00051912-00052063": "themselves so they can copy it to a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00149-00052064-00052302": "different course", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00150-00052303-00052615": "of their own it still ends up sitting", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00151-00052616-00052735": "out there and they don't necessarily", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00152-00052736-00052959": "then retract the sharing so that it just", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00153-00052960-00054630": "stays sitting out there for everyone", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00154-00054632-00054911": "like i said since no one was from the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00155-00054912-00055030": "core team", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00156-00055032-00055335": "coracol group is here it's hard to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00157-00055336-00055638": "say exactly what they wanted us to to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00158-00055639-00055687": "weigh", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00159-00055688-00058382": "in on", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00160-00058383-00058559": "yeah right there's no search either", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00161-00058560-00058719": "there's no search and there's no real", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00162-00058720-00059094": "sorting possible on the shared rubrics", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00163-00059095-00060054": "page", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00164-00060055-00060382": "so i guess what the the question i would", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00165-00060383-00060463": "ask is", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00166-00060464-00061038": "is what kind of um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00167-00061039-00061682": "levels of of sharing do you think are", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00168-00061683-00064482": "appropriate", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00169-00064483-00064919": "anybody", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00170-00064920-00065119": "matter tiffany were you on the court", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00171-00065120-00065438": "call", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00172-00065439-00065975": "it talked about this particular jira", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00173-00065976-00066119": "no i don't remember hearing about this", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00174-00066120-00066655": "jira okay", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00175-00066656-00066926": "because in the ether pad notes it it's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00176-00066927-00067087": "labeled as", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00177-00067088-00067806": "core team so", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00178-00067807-00068143": "yeah i haven't heard about this at all", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00179-00068144-00069015": "okay hmm", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00180-00069016-00069367": "i mean to to my way of thinking", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00181-00069368-00069694": "i'm trying to think um you know it would", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00182-00069695-00070087": "make sense for me to be able to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00183-00070088-00070535": "share a rubric just with myself", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00184-00070536-00070871": "so that i can use it in my other courses", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00185-00070872-00070935": "but not", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00186-00070936-00071687": "necessarily share it with anybody else", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00187-00071688-00071943": "share obviously share it with everyone", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00188-00071944-00072038": "should still be an", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00189-00072039-00072279": "option and then there's probably ought", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00190-00072280-00072343": "to be something", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00191-00072344-00072511": "somewhere intermediate in there but", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00192-00072512-00072750": "exactly how to define that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00193-00072751-00073150": "is kind of where i'm i'm not quite sure", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00194-00073151-00073319": "i mean i could see two options one", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00195-00073320-00073535": "option would be to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00196-00073536-00073799": "share it with everyone else that's in", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00197-00073800-00073894": "the course", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00198-00073895-00074103": "which i think is what's suggested in the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00199-00074104-00074206": "note and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00200-00074207-00074559": "we're in the site or", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00201-00074560-00074847": "to be able to individually just name", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00202-00074848-00074911": "someone", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00203-00074912-00075231": "to share it with so", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00204-00075232-00075447": "what's the current behavior it shares it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00205-00075448-00075682": "system wide with everybody", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00206-00075683-00076015": "yes see i would think that you'd want", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00207-00076016-00076238": "features more like tests and quizzes", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00208-00076239-00076447": "where tests and quizzes you can go", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00209-00076448-00076767": "into your site for question pools and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00210-00076768-00076847": "specify", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00211-00076848-00077023": "users that you want to share your pool", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00212-00077024-00077199": "with um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00213-00077200-00077375": "and so you could share it with everyone", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00214-00077376-00077543": "in the site or you could share it with", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00215-00077544-00077759": "just a particular instructor or other t", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00216-00077760-00078015": "you know other instructor or ta", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00217-00078016-00078182": "right but but they do have to be a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00218-00078183-00078350": "member of the site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00219-00078351-00078503": "right they do have to be a member of the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00220-00078504-00078687": "site and i think that would be fine i", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00221-00078688-00078735": "mean", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00222-00078736-00079111": "yeah if if you need to share it with", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00223-00079112-00079238": "your colleagues you could create a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00224-00079239-00079294": "project", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00225-00079295-00079615": "site that you add the tool to and add", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00226-00079616-00079887": "your colleagues to that site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00227-00079888-00080150": "yeah a good point a course site as long", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00228-00080151-00080247": "as there's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00229-00080248-00080662": "a way for the users to specify who", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00230-00080663-00081282": "um gets to access the rubric after it's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00231-00081283-00082711": "shared", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00232-00082712-00082926": "and i think having the model from", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00233-00082927-00083079": "question pools would be", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00234-00083080-00083399": "a good place to start because that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00235-00083400-00083615": "already exists", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00236-00083616-00083726": "so that could be something that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00237-00083727-00083935": "developers could potentially look at for", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00238-00083936-00083975": "a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00239-00083976-00085791": "inspiration to how to develop this", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00240-00085792-00086062": "i would think that it would be better i", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00241-00086063-00086126": "mean this", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00242-00086127-00086638": "this um jira is talking about", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00243-00086639-00086918": "an institution-wide property i would", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00244-00086919-00087167": "prefer it to be", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00245-00087168-00087591": "a user chosen property so a check box", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00246-00087592-00087799": "when i create a rubric", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00247-00087800-00087911": "share it with everyone at the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00248-00087912-00088094": "institution or share it with just", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00249-00088095-00088255": "specific people", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00250-00088256-00089294": "in my sight right and i think", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00251-00089295-00090199": "yeah it's not clear to me", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00252-00090200-00090406": "if they mean this to be something that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00253-00090407-00090671": "the user can select", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00254-00090672-00090982": "um well that's not what it sounds like", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00255-00090983-00091271": "from 42956", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00256-00091272-00091518": "sounds like institutions do not want", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00257-00091519-00091718": "instructors to be able to share their", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00258-00091719-00091815": "rubrics", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00259-00091816-00092215": "so they want to block sharing", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00260-00092216-00092575": "uh global sharing", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00261-00092576-00092943": "for their institution", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00262-00092944-00093167": "but i think it would be nice if the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00263-00093168-00093343": "instructors could control that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00264-00093344-00093687": "so when you go to create right", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00265-00093688-00093847": "or whatever you have a check box that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00266-00093848-00093999": "says i want to share this", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00267-00094000-00094279": "with uh instructors in this site and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00268-00094280-00094318": "then", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00269-00094319-00094574": "then the option even finer grain who you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00270-00094575-00094687": "want to share it with", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00271-00094688-00094894": "right and then the other option would be", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00272-00094895-00095031": "i want to share it with everyone", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00273-00095032-00095335": "at the university um irubric", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00274-00095336-00095526": "has sort of a similar thing where they", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00275-00095527-00095847": "have like a a global rubrics repository", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00276-00095848-00095999": "that people can share", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00277-00096000-00096206": "either at their university or in fact", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00278-00096207-00096438": "with all universities using the tool in", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00279-00096439-00096567": "the world", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00280-00096568-00096879": "um and i think they can also", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00281-00096880-00097167": "sort of share it among individual users", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00282-00097168-00097318": "as well i i'm not", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00283-00097319-00097494": "positive on that uh because i haven't", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00284-00097495-00097655": "looked at that recently but", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00285-00097656-00097838": "i know there's definitely like a rubric", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00286-00097839-00098062": "repository that people can share", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00287-00098063-00099482": "right rubrics both institutionally and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00288-00099483-00100294": "globally", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00289-00100295-00100487": "but i think if there were a site-wide", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00290-00100488-00100694": "sharing option", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00291-00100695-00100871": "for users to do that would cover the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00292-00100872-00101006": "departmental use case", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00293-00101007-00101231": "as well because the department could", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00294-00101232-00101503": "create a site that contains all of their", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00295-00101504-00101718": "instructors and then they would simply", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00296-00101719-00104127": "share with that site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00297-00104128-00105119": "yep that makes sense", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00298-00105120-00105334": "so maybe this needs to be broken out", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00299-00105335-00105510": "into a couple of jiras", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00300-00105511-00105854": "so feature request number one", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00301-00105855-00106151": "allow option for instructors to share", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00302-00106152-00106310": "with a particular", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00303-00106311-00106663": "uh site hold on course or project", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00304-00106664-00107047": "site and then step two", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00305-00107048-00107390": "allow institutions to specify", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00306-00107391-00107743": "um via a property", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00307-00107744-00108166": "which type of sharing is possible", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00308-00108167-00108575": "either a global", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00309-00108576-00109063": "site or", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00310-00109064-00109423": "or neither i guess i mean", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00311-00109424-00109663": "but a check box for the user to select", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00312-00109664-00109775": "when they go to share", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00313-00109776-00110039": "that it would be either site or", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00314-00110040-00110247": "institution", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00315-00110248-00110534": "okay can you add that as a comment to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00316-00110535-00110683": "the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00317-00110683-00111015": "jira", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00318-00111016-00111254": "i mean i just put one in about the tnl", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00319-00111255-00111334": "review but", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00320-00111335-00111510": "i didn't kept i wasn't able to capture", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00321-00111511-00111639": "all of what you just said if you could", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00322-00111640-00112351": "put that in that would be useful", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00323-00112352-00114607": "and appreciated", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00324-00114608-00116283": "any other comments on that one", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00325-00116283-00117127": "foreign", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00326-00117128-00117551": "okay", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00327-00117552-00117710": "sorry i'm just looking at the list if", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00328-00117711-00118199": "there's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00329-00118200-00118686": "anything in particular that we want to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00330-00118688-00118839": "i'm not sure why this one's listed in", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00331-00118840-00119047": "this carry over to the 14th that's weird", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00332-00119048-00119102": "they're", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00333-00119103-00120134": "not meeting next week", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00334-00120135-00120483": "well i guess we can just keep going in", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00335-00120483-00122790": "order", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00336-00122791-00123054": "so this next one is a feature request", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00337-00123055-00123286": "for some ago to improve assessment type", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00338-00123288-00123783": "functionality", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00339-00123783-00124119": "tiffany this was", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00340-00124120-00124319": "this was a conversation we were having a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00341-00124320-00124423": "while back", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00342-00124424-00124695": "that we had sort of a to be continued on", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00343-00124696-00124863": "because uh it got", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00344-00124864-00125231": "quite complicated um and i think that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00345-00125232-00125423": "wilma was leading that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00346-00125424-00125647": "uh wanted to continue leading that i", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00347-00125648-00125790": "don't know", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00348-00125791-00125943": "okay she's still interested in", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00349-00125944-00126158": "participating in that discussion", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00350-00126159-00126366": "all right then maybe we should let that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00351-00126367-00126799": "one go for the moment", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00352-00126800-00127143": "since she is not here today right that's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00353-00127144-00127910": "what i was thinking", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00354-00127911-00128127": "you know what let's bring i think let's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00355-00128128-00128295": "bring up", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00356-00128296-00129127": "this other one", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00357-00129128-00129486": "okay 43155 work log tab", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00358-00129488-00130407": "in assignments", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00359-00130408-00130999": "hello yes", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00360-00131000-00131399": "i was about to show this vr here today", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00361-00131400-00131743": "but sadly i had to to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00362-00131744-00132102": "move it to the next meeting because uh", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00363-00132103-00132454": "i i kind of had", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00364-00132455-00132814": "a database uh error today", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00365-00132815-00133207": "an hour ago more or less okay", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00366-00133208-00133502": "i cannot make the presentation properly", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00367-00133503-00133559": "so", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00368-00133560-00133878": "it would be hard for everyone to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00369-00133879-00134214": "make it another week okay you've said", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00370-00134215-00134302": "previously that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00371-00134303-00134727": "next week we are going to have a meeting", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00372-00134728-00134975": "and uh well well it would be the 21st it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00373-00134976-00135127": "wouldn't be the 14th", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00374-00135128-00135511": "okay thank you i will fix that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00375-00135512-00135927": "i'll put it back where it was okay", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00376-00135928-00136535": "fair enough sorry no that's okay", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00377-00136536-00136911": "i didn't realize that the owner had been", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00378-00136912-00137078": "the one that pushed it down there that's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00379-00137079-00137166": "fine", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00380-00137167-00137511": "okay let's see", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00381-00137512-00138047": "in that case we'll move on to 44906", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00382-00138048-00138351": "add other groups availability when", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00383-00138352-00139287": "joined a group", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00384-00139288-00140454": "here you can create channels", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00385-00140455-00140695": "oh okay so this is associated with", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00386-00140696-00140975": "joinable groups", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00387-00140976-00141311": "um and if a student wants to might want", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00388-00141312-00141478": "to change to another group but doesn't", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00389-00141479-00141671": "know if the other", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00390-00141672-00141902": "groups are full until they unjoin the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00391-00141903-00142071": "one that they are already", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00392-00142072-00142495": "in so that does actually kind of make", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00393-00142496-00142671": "sense", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00394-00142672-00144039": "because potentially they could", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00395-00144040-00144319": "so their comments about on the jira", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00396-00144320-00144478": "about whether this could potentially be", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00397-00144479-00144839": "confusing to students", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00398-00144840-00145207": "as to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00399-00145208-00146119": "what they're seeing um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00400-00146120-00146390": "when they look at that if they would see", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00401-00146391-00146631": "so you could", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00402-00146632-00147223": "maybe some way to have like um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00403-00147224-00147551": "a i don't know a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00404-00147552-00147726": "closed section i mean the problem is", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00405-00147727-00147887": "that groups you can join is already", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00406-00147888-00148483": "closed section right so", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00407-00148484-00148599": "um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00408-00148600-00149047": "i was thinking some way of saying like", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00409-00149048-00149335": "prior to unjoining or if you click the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00410-00149336-00149543": "unjoin button maybe it would pop up it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00411-00149544-00149814": "could pop up a little window that says", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00412-00149815-00150126": "you're about to unjoin this group if you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00413-00150127-00150183": "do", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00414-00150184-00150359": "here are some other groups you could", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00415-00150360-00150814": "join instead", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00416-00150815-00150959": "because right now i think you just you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00417-00150960-00151102": "click the unjoined button and you're", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00418-00151103-00151287": "you're unjoined", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00419-00151288-00151559": "right and then it brings you back to the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00420-00151560-00151751": "the page with the list of groups that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00421-00151752-00151926": "are available to join", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00422-00151927-00152183": "right so maybe upon clicking the unjoin", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00423-00152184-00152343": "button instead of just", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00424-00152344-00152726": "automatically unjoining we get a dialog", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00425-00152727-00153095": "that says you're about to unjoin", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00426-00153096-00153390": "group one you could now join group if", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00427-00153391-00153607": "you do this you can join group two or", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00428-00153608-00153783": "group three but not group four or five", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00429-00153784-00153999": "because group four and five are full", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00430-00154000-00154214": "you know something like that right well", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00431-00154215-00154454": "so here's what i'm thinking when", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00432-00154455-00154775": "i'm trying to remember what what the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00433-00154776-00154902": "page looks like", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00434-00154903-00155239": "um so i'm looking at the images that are", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00435-00155240-00155351": "associated with the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00436-00155352-00155575": "with the jiren they have the the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00437-00155576-00155775": "screenshot of", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00438-00155776-00155943": "before you've joined anything in the set", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00439-00155944-00156159": "it says groups you can join", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00440-00156160-00156343": "and it just lists them but i'm not sure", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00441-00156344-00156519": "how it displays", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00442-00156520-00156751": "does it just not display ones that are", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00443-00156752-00156878": "already full", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00444-00156879-00157087": "or does it display them and they say", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00445-00157088-00157214": "full", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00446-00157215-00157414": "no it doesn't display them at all so if", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00447-00157415-00157575": "you look at that third image", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00448-00157576-00157887": "there the number three image is showing", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00449-00157888-00158047": "you how it looks when you've", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00450-00158048-00158263": "once you've joined you don't see", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00451-00158264-00158423": "anything else to do with the other", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00452-00158424-00158583": "groups you're just using your own", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00453-00158584-00158839": "group but i'm i'm looking at image too", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00454-00158840-00158966": "what does it display", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00455-00158967-00159190": "does it just not display the group if if", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00456-00159191-00159302": "say there was a set", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00457-00159303-00159583": "three that was full is that displayed", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00458-00159584-00159663": "and it says", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00459-00159664-00160039": "full or it's just not displayed at all", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00460-00160040-00160271": "it's just not displayed i think here let", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00461-00160272-00160471": "me verify that but i think it it's just", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00462-00160472-00160614": "not displayed at all", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00463-00160615-00160766": "anymore because there's not there's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00464-00160767-00160919": "nothing joinable so it's just", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00465-00160920-00161254": "gone from that list okay", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00466-00161255-00161502": "so because here's what i'm thinking", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00467-00161503-00161607": "would it make more", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00468-00161608-00161919": "sense to just on this page", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00469-00161920-00162463": "just to always display all the groups", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00470-00162464-00162711": "with information okay either a join", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00471-00162712-00162775": "button", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00472-00162776-00163151": "or a full label no", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00473-00163152-00163454": "if i've joined one then i see an", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00474-00163455-00163607": "unjoined button for the one that i'm a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00475-00163608-00163783": "member of", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00476-00163784-00163975": "i don't think and the other joint", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00477-00163976-00164190": "buttons are disabled but i can still see", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00478-00164191-00164295": "what's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00479-00164296-00164543": "available well i don't think it's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00480-00164544-00164671": "appropriate to show all", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00481-00164672-00165063": "groups in a list on the page", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00482-00165064-00165254": "if students aren't members of them and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00483-00165255-00165447": "the reason for that is that you can have", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00484-00165448-00165719": "groups that are made for accommodations", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00485-00165720-00165935": "and quizzes and assignments", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00486-00165936-00166183": "where there may be students with", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00487-00166184-00166343": "disabilities and you'd be revealing", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00488-00166344-00166511": "their disabilities to reveal the name of", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00489-00166512-00166566": "the group", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00490-00166567-00166759": "and potentially membership of the group", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00491-00166760-00166902": "inadvertently", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00492-00166903-00167231": "um so i don't i don't think it should be", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00493-00167232-00167375": "displaying groups that you're", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00494-00167376-00168326": "not able to join or a member of um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00495-00168327-00168502": "i mean maybe for joinable groups it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00496-00168503-00168638": "would be okay to just display the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00497-00168639-00168790": "joinable groups because at some point", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00498-00168791-00168863": "you could just", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00499-00168864-00169014": "that's what i was that's what i was", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00500-00169015-00169223": "thinking okay i was just thinking about", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00501-00169224-00169359": "the joinable groups", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00502-00169360-00169726": "gotcha okay", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00503-00169727-00169854": "i wasn't necessarily i wasn't even", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00504-00169855-00169983": "thinking about the other groups i was", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00505-00169984-00170159": "just thinking of it in terms of joinable", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00506-00170160-00170254": "groups", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00507-00170255-00170614": "gotcha okay makes sense", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00508-00170615-00170871": "where for you know for each joinable set", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00509-00170872-00171007": "it actually lists all", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00510-00171008-00171383": "of the the groups for that set", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00511-00171384-00171695": "and it's j it it there's on the right", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00512-00171696-00171838": "in the right hand column there's either", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00513-00171839-00172054": "a join button if i haven't joined", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00514-00172055-00172287": "anything there's a join button for those", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00515-00172288-00172431": "that are available", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00516-00172432-00172807": "a label that just says full if it's full", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00517-00172808-00173014": "and then once i've joined one of those", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00518-00173015-00173119": "then i'm going to see", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00519-00173120-00173423": "either unjoin", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00520-00173424-00173823": "for the one i'm in a grayed out join", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00521-00173824-00173943": "button", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00522-00173944-00174375": "uh or full does that make sense", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00523-00174376-00174575": "but if you've got a lot of joinable", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00524-00174576-00174847": "groups a lot of joinable sets", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00525-00174848-00175126": "for different projects or whatever you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00526-00175127-00175311": "could potentially have a very long list", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00527-00175312-00175478": "here that's no longer relevant to the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00528-00175479-00175583": "student right", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00529-00175584-00175854": "that's why i was thinking about do it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00530-00175855-00176095": "kind of when you click the unjoin button", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00531-00176096-00176238": "to have", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00532-00176239-00176502": "that list available so it's like hey", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00533-00176503-00176711": "you're going to unjoin this group", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00534-00176712-00176919": "if you do this here's the other groups", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00535-00176920-00177063": "available to join or", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00536-00177064-00177366": "not as the case may be in this set", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00537-00177367-00177678": "in this set right so if you'll have a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00538-00177679-00177911": "confirm like just a confirmation pop-up", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00539-00177912-00177999": "basically so it'll", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00540-00178000-00178199": "say you click on join and then it gives", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00541-00178200-00178390": "you a dialogue that says", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00542-00178391-00178743": "hey you're on joining group one uh", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00543-00178744-00178926": "if you do this group two and group three", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00544-00178927-00179087": "is available group four is not", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00545-00179088-00179511": "or something like that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00546-00179512-00179702": "you know these are the other options", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00547-00179703-00179951": "that you'll have available to join", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00548-00179952-00180183": "assuming you choose to unjoin this and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00549-00180184-00180351": "then you'd have you you'd say okay", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00550-00180352-00180566": "i see there's some places that i can", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00551-00180567-00180783": "join so i'll unjoin this one and then i", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00552-00180784-00181263": "can go join the other one", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00553-00181264-00181583": "is there a confirmation screen now for", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00554-00181584-00181759": "when you click on unjoin or does it just", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00555-00181760-00182023": "do it i think it just does it i'm i'm", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00556-00182024-00182254": "just right now checking i'm looking for", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00557-00182255-00182487": "a joinable group in one of my sites", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00558-00182488-00182863": "that has uh members that are", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00559-00182864-00183175": "able to unjoin hold on a sec yeah it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00560-00183176-00183487": "just unjoins", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00561-00183488-00184326": "i'm playing with it now on nightly", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00562-00184327-00184495": "yeah like you can create joinable sets", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00563-00184496-00184663": "and what someone joins a group from that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00564-00184664-00184766": "set", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00565-00184767-00184943": "the all the other sets go away it shows", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00566-00184944-00185487": "you the size of the beginning", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00567-00185488-00185631": "i really think these this is these are", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00568-00185632-00185799": "all in accordions now", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00569-00185800-00185926": "i feel like the easiest thing to do", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00570-00185927-00186166": "would be just to add another accordion", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00571-00186167-00186471": "says like all groups or something and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00572-00186472-00186511": "then", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00573-00186512-00186719": "just displays a static list without any", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00574-00186720-00186814": "action on", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00575-00186815-00186975": "it kind of displays the original list", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00576-00186976-00187414": "with the the max size and whatever again", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00577-00187415-00187583": "so you can kind of preview and see", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00578-00187584-00187902": "what's there before you enjoy", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00579-00187903-00188199": "and not do anything on that list it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00580-00188200-00188263": "seems", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00581-00188264-00188535": "easy to implement that i mean that's why", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00582-00188536-00188671": "i was thinking a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00583-00188672-00188831": "dialogue would be better because then it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00584-00188832-00189071": "wouldn't give you all this unnecessary", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00585-00189072-00189231": "information that could be", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00586-00189232-00189614": "potentially confusing or overwhelming", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00587-00189615-00189838": "you know just give you the information", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00588-00189839-00190166": "when you click on join", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00589-00190167-00190423": "and then it gives you sort of a separate", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00590-00190424-00190599": "confirmation that says", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00591-00190600-00190863": "hey if you do this you'll be able to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00592-00190864-00191047": "join these other groups and then display", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00593-00191048-00191199": "that list in that little", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00594-00191200-00191414": "you know i don't know if it would be a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00595-00191415-00191607": "modal that might be inaccessible maybe a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00596-00191608-00191678": "separate window", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00597-00191679-00191838": "you know separate page if it takes you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00598-00191839-00191966": "to a separate page or something like", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00599-00191967-00192038": "that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00600-00192039-00192199": "just some kind of confirmation because", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00601-00192200-00192399": "it wouldn't be terrible", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00602-00192400-00192638": "to like just click on join again if you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00603-00192639-00192790": "get to that page and you're like i don't", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00604-00192791-00192975": "care if i have to join another group or", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00605-00192976-00193047": "not", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00606-00193048-00193566": "i'm just going to do it right", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00607-00193567-00194023": "right now this page is in", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00608-00194024-00194223": "i know this page is an accordion so it's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00609-00194224-00194335": "not really", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00610-00194336-00194654": "a problem they're there but", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00611-00194655-00194775": "it doesn't look like these accordions", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00612-00194776-00195071": "are capable", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00613-00195072-00195414": "of another issue oh yeah", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00614-00195415-00195654": "that's a problem so students who are", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00615-00195655-00195759": "using a keyboard can't", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00616-00195760-00195950": "actually join any groups they can't join", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00617-00195951-00196199": "or unjoin any groups enjoyed or unjoined", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00618-00196200-00196263": "oh great", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00619-00196264-00196671": "okay well yeah now there's another juror", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00620-00196672-00196983": "yeah yeah that's that's not good you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00621-00196984-00197023": "can't", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00622-00197024-00197223": "open the accordion so they can they can", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00623-00197224-00197414": "join or unjoin if somebody opens the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00624-00197415-00197887": "accordion for them with a mouse", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00625-00197888-00198502": "oh gosh that's that's not good okay", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00626-00198503-00198663": "but yeah well it's it would kind of like", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00627-00198664-00198823": "be a decision between whether it's going", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00628-00198824-00198983": "to be a modal or just an accordion", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00629-00198984-00199095": "that's there", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00630-00199096-00199302": "with that information in it and it could", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00631-00199303-00199495": "be both it could be", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00632-00199496-00199871": "either i um i think the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00633-00199872-00200078": "accordion and fixing the accordions", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00634-00200079-00200271": "would be actually easier than", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00635-00200272-00200590": "having a accessible pop-up but i don't", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00636-00200591-00200847": "know", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00637-00200848-00201038": "yeah i'm just thinking about when is it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00638-00201039-00201231": "relevant to the student right like", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00639-00201232-00201478": "is it gonna be relevant to me to have to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00640-00201479-00201711": "open yet a different accordion to see", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00641-00201712-00201814": "this information", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00642-00201815-00202031": "before i go to unjoin the group that i'm", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00643-00202032-00202119": "in", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00644-00202120-00202335": "like how is that helpful to me like do", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00645-00202336-00202519": "you want to preview it before you enjoy", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00646-00202520-00202726": "or do you want to click no you have to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00647-00202727-00202887": "click the unjoin button before you're", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00648-00202888-00202990": "going to know", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00649-00202991-00203287": "if you can or not join another group the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00650-00203288-00203350": "students", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00651-00203351-00203526": "wouldn't know before clicking on join if", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00652-00203527-00203799": "they're going to see this dialogue", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00653-00203800-00203935": "well maybe we should just have a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00654-00203936-00204175": "separate button like preview groups next", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00655-00204176-00204295": "to unjoin", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00656-00204296-00204471": "like uh you know where you would click", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00657-00204472-00204623": "on preview preview", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00658-00204624-00204806": "joinable groups or something like that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00659-00204807-00204934": "and if you click on that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00660-00204935-00205142": "it'll show you that information and then", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00661-00205144-00205471": "you don't know that before", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00662-00205471-00205614": "so just have it as a separate button", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00663-00205615-00205823": "adjacent to the unjoin yeah maybe that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00664-00205823-00205910": "sounds better", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00665-00205911-00206079": "i think you know yeah i wouldn't want it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00666-00206080-00206390": "to be like a surprise to the students", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00667-00206391-00206551": "that they had no need to click on join", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00668-00206552-00206655": "to see this they", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00669-00206656-00207006": "having it explicit that they can toggle", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00670-00207007-00207198": "you know somehow toggle these and see", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00671-00207200-00207455": "these other groups", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00672-00207456-00207662": "yeah i feel like having it as a button", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00673-00207663-00207838": "might be good because right now if you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00674-00207839-00207919": "have the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00675-00207919-00208142": "if you allow students to see membership", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00676-00208144-00208271": "of a group there's a link", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00677-00208271-00208479": "next to the group that's like membership", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00678-00208480-00208638": "or something", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00679-00208639-00209055": "um yeah so maybe have it as like a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00680-00209056-00209406": "preview preview joinable groups or", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00681-00209407-00209614": "preview", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00682-00209615-00209839": "other preview other groups in this set", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00683-00209840-00211127": "something like that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00684-00211128-00211303": "i mean again that i think that pulls up", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00685-00211304-00211463": "a modal that little link", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00686-00211464-00211719": "to show the membership pulls up a little", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00687-00211719-00211855": "window", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00688-00211856-00212255": "for it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00689-00212256-00212398": "and i haven't tested that for", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00690-00212400-00212615": "accessibility but hopefully it is an", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00691-00212616-00212687": "accessible", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00692-00212688-00212942": "little window i don't think it's a modal", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00693-00212944-00213110": "i think it's actually a window", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00694-00213111-00215682": "not positive", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00695-00215683-00216367": "ah any other comments on that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00696-00216367-00216727": "any other thoughts", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00697-00216728-00217806": "button versus a confirmation screen", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00698-00217807-00218006": "i like the button idea you can add that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00699-00218007-00218167": "as a comment and um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00700-00218167-00218303": "yeah there's a comment and create an", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00701-00218304-00218598": "accessibility issue about those about", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00702-00218600-00218742": "those accordions they don't work for the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00703-00218744-00218887": "instructor either so", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00704-00218888-00219175": "it's the same whatever this component is", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00705-00219176-00219239": "it's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00706-00219240-00220503": "bad it should just be changed", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00707-00220504-00221094": "yeah it looks like when the um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00708-00221096-00221327": "when the little membership link is", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00709-00221328-00221527": "clicked the thing that it opens appears", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00710-00221528-00221751": "to be keyboard accessible", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00711-00221752-00221975": "um it's just a matter of getting the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00712-00221976-00222119": "accordion open first", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00713-00222119-00222287": "so you can actually interact with these", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00714-00222288-00222503": "things", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00715-00222504-00222903": "okay yeah so i mean i", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00716-00222904-00223094": "it wouldn't matter to me if the preview", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00717-00223096-00223246": "is a button or", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00718-00223248-00223391": "something like the membership where it's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00719-00223392-00223639": "a link", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00720-00223640-00223927": "i feel like a button would be more", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00721-00223928-00224134": "visible and easier to use and maybe", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00722-00224135-00224431": "membership should be a button too", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00723-00224432-00224551": "yeah there are a lot of places where i", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00724-00224552-00224727": "think links should not be used that are", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00725-00224728-00225791": "being used as links instead of buttons", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00726-00225792-00225934": "i feel that link should take you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00727-00225935-00226239": "somewhere and buttons should you know", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00728-00226240-00226423": "cause some action to happen which is", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00729-00226423-00226623": "what this is doing", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00730-00226623-00226806": "that the membership should probably be a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00731-00226807-00227015": "button and i see where that membership", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00732-00227016-00227246": "is and it looks like that would be a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00733-00227248-00227439": "good solution if it showed like", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00734-00227440-00227615": "rather than just membership of that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00735-00227616-00227758": "group it showed um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00736-00227759-00228039": "you know all the group of like kind of", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00737-00228040-00228175": "um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00738-00228176-00228519": "group sizes and such a summary of that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00739-00228519-00228767": "joinable set", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00740-00228767-00228919": "well the problem is that different", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00741-00228919-00229223": "groups in a joinable set can", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00742-00229223-00229479": "have the ability to show membership or", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00743-00229480-00229534": "not", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00744-00229535-00229942": "so like i could create a a joinable set", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00745-00229944-00230319": "with several groups that allow", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00746-00230319-00230558": "users to see the membership and several", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00747-00230559-00230703": "others that don't", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00748-00230704-00230991": "um and you can see membership sometimes", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00749-00230992-00231127": "before joining the group", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00750-00231128-00231431": "or after joining the group or both so", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00751-00231432-00231631": "because those things are configurable i", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00752-00231632-00231806": "don't think it should be the same link i", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00753-00231807-00235591": "think it should be a separate one", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00754-00235592-00235863": "okay well if one of you could add a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00755-00235864-00236903": "comment to that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00756-00236904-00242055": "i lost my tab i wanted", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00757-00242056-00242558": "okay so this next one", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00758-00242559-00242871": "i had to read over it to see what it was", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00759-00242871-00243206": "is regarding to um what assignments are", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00760-00243207-00243406": "displayed", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00761-00243407-00243942": "in the finder when you're adding a link", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00762-00243944-00244439": "in the editor", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00763-00244440-00244782": "so when you have assignments", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00764-00244783-00244942": "i'm trying to figure out which ones do", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00765-00244944-00245287": "not show", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00766-00245288-00245567": "so assignments said in the past are not", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00767-00245567-00245639": "listed", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00768-00245640-00246046": "in the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00769-00246048-00246806": "in the finder when you go to add links", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00770-00246807-00246975": "yeah that's silly the server browser", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00771-00246976-00247119": "should just show all the assignments in", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00772-00247119-00247567": "the current site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00773-00247567-00247782": "so the question so that there's a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00774-00247783-00248030": "comment in the juror that says question", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00775-00248031-00248175": "for the group", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00776-00248176-00248398": "are there cases for closed assignments", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00777-00248400-00248615": "to be linked to somewhere in sakai", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00778-00248616-00249110": "after they've closed", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00779-00249111-00249463": "i'd say if you are importing", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00780-00249464-00249671": "from a previous site and you haven't", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00781-00249671-00249903": "edited the assignments yet", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00782-00249904-00250230": "and also if let's say you decide", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00783-00250231-00250375": "halfway through the course that you have", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00784-00250376-00250558": "too many assignments and you wanted to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00785-00250559-00250646": "link", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00786-00250648-00250910": "a couple of old ones on lessons to let", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00787-00250911-00251103": "students see the feedback and just", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00788-00251104-00251255": "clean up your tool menu and take", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00789-00251256-00251415": "assignments out of there", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00790-00251416-00251598": "then you might still want to link to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00791-00251600-00251782": "those old ones so students can answer", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00792-00251783-00253151": "the feedback from it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00793-00253152-00254591": "come on", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00794-00254592-00254871": "any disagreement that told assignment", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00795-00254871-00254998": "should be displayed", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00796-00255000-00255142": "i would agree with that i think they", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00797-00255144-00255358": "should be but", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00798-00255359-00255606": "i i commented that this was whoever just", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00799-00255607-00255767": "decided this i don't know how far back", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00800-00255767-00255894": "this goes but this was an initial", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00801-00255896-00256063": "decision of the finder", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00802-00256064-00256342": "we just never revisited but i don't know", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00803-00256344-00256406": "if like", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00804-00256407-00256623": "it also mentioned draft assignments are", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00805-00256623-00256758": "not linkable", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00806-00256759-00257142": "um like i don't know if", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00807-00257144-00257342": "i don't maybe there's a case for that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00808-00257344-00257519": "too i don't know if you'd want to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00809-00257519-00257767": "indicate that somehow in el finder that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00810-00257767-00257998": "assignments are closed or draft i don't", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00811-00258000-00258358": "know what that would look like either", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00812-00258359-00258687": "well i mean you can link to a draft", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00813-00258688-00258855": "assignment", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00814-00258856-00259182": "currently again by import and so i think", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00815-00259183-00259319": "again", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00816-00259319-00259527": "there is a use case to link to draft", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00817-00259528-00259758": "assignments to draft content because you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00818-00259759-00259942": "maybe don't have that content ready to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00819-00259944-00260158": "publish yet but you want to set up your", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00820-00260159-00260623": "lessons or whatever um and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00821-00260623-00260855": "and link to them because would you want", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00822-00260856-00260998": "to have it like", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00823-00261000-00261119": "do you want to have a distinguish like", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00824-00261119-00261230": "would you want to have it separated", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00825-00261231-00261334": "because like right now if you see that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00826-00261335-00261510": "screenshot it says like type sakai", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00827-00261511-00261623": "assignments", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00828-00261623-00261823": "would you want to have it like say like", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00829-00261823-00261958": "open assignments or would you want to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00830-00261959-00261998": "have it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00831-00262000-00262310": "say um you know close assignments would", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00832-00262311-00262415": "you want to have it like show to the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00833-00262416-00262471": "instructor", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00834-00262472-00262847": "on this screen somehow that it's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00835-00262848-00263055": "you know i don't know i don't think", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00836-00263056-00263206": "that's necessary", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00837-00263207-00263551": "i mean it it doesn't", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00838-00263552-00263719": "there's that's not possible for tests", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00839-00263720-00263871": "and quizzes because you can't have a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00840-00263872-00264023": "working copy linked", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00841-00264024-00264255": "you have to have it published first so i", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00842-00264256-00264399": "guess it's not a problem there", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00843-00264400-00264663": "but assignments that are in draft form", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00844-00264664-00264799": "have draft in the title", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00845-00264800-00265030": "i mean wouldn't they appear with that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00846-00265031-00265223": "draft in the title anyway", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00847-00265224-00265551": "in the finder i mean it doesn't tell you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00848-00265552-00265606": "when the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00849-00265607-00265895": "due date is or anything in that ui i", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00850-00265896-00266175": "don't think it's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00851-00266176-00266287": "i necessary the instructor is going to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00852-00266288-00266495": "find out when they click on the link or", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00853-00266496-00266623": "the students going to find out when they", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00854-00266624-00266782": "click on the link that they can't", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00855-00266783-00267199": "access it if it's in the past", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00856-00267200-00267879": "and not released and all that okay", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00857-00267880-00268199": "i mean in lessons can't you link to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00858-00268200-00268447": "any assignment like using the lessons", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00859-00268448-00268623": "add link to an assignment", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00860-00268624-00268863": "add content link to an assignment i", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00861-00268864-00269143": "don't know", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00862-00269144-00269287": "because i would expect the behavior to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00863-00269288-00269503": "be similar where you know you can link", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00864-00269504-00269606": "to anything", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00865-00269607-00269767": "and if it's not ready yet or it's in", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00866-00269768-00270055": "draft form then", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00867-00270056-00270439": "link just doesn't work yeah", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00868-00270440-00270575": "it wouldn't when it wouldn't give the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00869-00270576-00270727": "student to give the students a kind of", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00870-00270728-00270823": "error if they tried to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00871-00270824-00271006": "use it yeah i would just say it's not", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00872-00271007-00271143": "ready yet or not available", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00873-00271144-00272230": "to you something like that has a message", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00874-00272231-00272430": "but yeah fixing this isn't a big deal i", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00875-00272431-00272630": "think it actually explicitly", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00876-00272631-00272982": "filters out certain assignments so", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00877-00272983-00273182": "before fixing this i wouldn't want any", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00878-00273183-00273558": "potential issues to come up with that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00879-00273559-00273743": "we could look to see if the assignments", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00880-00273744-00273919": "would start draft have draft in the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00881-00273920-00274143": "title", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00882-00274144-00274510": "linking it i don't know what it would", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00883-00274511-00274879": "look like", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00884-00274880-00275127": "i mean again the question is how much", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00885-00275128-00275247": "does it matter right", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00886-00275248-00275606": "like if you if you right now import use", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00887-00275607-00275815": "import from site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00888-00275816-00276151": "to import assignments as drafts to a new", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00889-00276152-00276327": "site and those assignments have been", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00890-00276328-00276558": "linked in ck editor the links are still", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00891-00276559-00276982": "there um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00892-00276983-00277295": "so", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00893-00277296-00277582": "you know i don't know that it would be a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00894-00277583-00277727": "problem to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00895-00277728-00277999": "make those possible to be established in", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00896-00278000-00278158": "a current site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00897-00278159-00284463": "since you can get them by import", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00898-00284464-00285534": "no", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00899-00285535-00286775": "any other thoughts", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00900-00286776-00288006": "all assignments should be displayed", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00901-00288007-00288567": "okay no other comments", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00902-00288568-00289703": "we've got time to squeeze in one more", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00903-00289704-00289958": "adding more than one grade book to a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00904-00289959-00290487": "site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00905-00290488-00290719": "i don't like that idea i think that is", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00906-00290720-00290975": "just so confusing would be so confusing", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00907-00290976-00291103": "for students", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00908-00291104-00291375": "i think instructors should just be", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00909-00291376-00291599": "managing", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00910-00291600-00291958": "entering grades themselves", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00911-00291959-00292334": "uh yeah if they need to create different", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00912-00292335-00292567": "categories and weights for each item", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00913-00292568-00292815": "then create a different site for each", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00914-00292816-00292958": "section", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00915-00292959-00293334": "this just seems like no end of confusion", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00916-00293335-00293767": "and difficulty in the database", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00917-00293768-00294127": "to untangle the mess of", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00918-00294128-00294358": "where these grades are going yeah it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00919-00294359-00294447": "just", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00920-00294448-00294515": "no", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00921-00294516-00294775": "[Music]", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00922-00294776-00295071": "yeah well i i think if you were going to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00923-00295072-00295158": "implement this", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00924-00295159-00295319": "and and i'm not convinced it's a good", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00925-00295320-00295543": "idea don't don't get me wrong here", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00926-00295544-00295879": "i'm just kind of thinking out loud at", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00927-00295880-00296110": "the moment", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00928-00296111-00296295": "i think if you were going to have", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00929-00296296-00296591": "multiple grade books within a site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00930-00296592-00296879": "then a student should only be able to be", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00931-00296880-00297079": "in one of those grade books", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00932-00297080-00297527": "and that's the only one they would see", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00933-00297528-00297743": "yeah but see the problem is that the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00934-00297744-00297927": "database structure", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00935-00297928-00298254": "would be very hard to make", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00936-00298255-00298599": "work because you'd have to have", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00937-00298600-00298967": "several database entries i", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00938-00298968-00299071": "you know i don't even know how that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00939-00299072-00299247": "would be possible to have multiple", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00940-00299248-00299447": "gradebooks associated with different", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00941-00299448-00299591": "weights and different", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00942-00299592-00299847": "categories and and everything with the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00943-00299848-00299951": "same site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00944-00299952-00300358": "because yeah i it just", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00945-00300359-00300534": "well i don't know either but that's not", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00946-00300535-00300671": "my job that doesn't", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00947-00300672-00301082": "yeah that just doesn't seem like a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00948-00301083-00301367": "reasonable and worthwhile thing to do", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00949-00301368-00301639": "it seems to me like in this case you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00950-00301640-00301934": "need to create a couple different sites", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00951-00301935-00302263": "for those different groups and you know", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00952-00302264-00302463": "maybe have a parent you know", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00953-00302464-00302687": "another site for the lecture but have", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00954-00302688-00302943": "your individual section sites for the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00955-00302944-00303134": "grade books for the grading process for", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00956-00303135-00303215": "each of these", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00957-00303216-00303567": "entirely different grade books right", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00958-00303568-00303943": "okay i have to to say uh", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00959-00303944-00304327": "and i'm going to explain why we", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00960-00304328-00304679": "are facing the need to implement this", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00961-00304680-00305015": "uh within a site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00962-00305016-00305495": "which is attached to a signature", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00963-00305496-00305815": "we have different groups and each one of", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00964-00305816-00305982": "those groups", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00965-00305983-00306319": "can be driven by", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00966-00306320-00306654": "a different teacher and each one", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00967-00306655-00307015": "of those teachers might want", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00968-00307016-00307479": "to wait differently", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00969-00307480-00307782": "the the the items", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00970-00307783-00308487": "the degrading items available uh", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00971-00308488-00308815": "so we cannot create", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00972-00308816-00309119": "a different site for each one of those", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00973-00309120-00309391": "teachers because all those students", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00974-00309392-00309543": "belong to the same site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00975-00309544-00309975": "to the same signature", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00976-00309976-00310303": "and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00977-00310304-00310703": "teachers cannot wait differently", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00978-00310704-00311223": "as they want as you say", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00979-00311224-00311551": "each student belongs one to two to one", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00980-00311552-00311751": "and only one group", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00981-00311752-00312054": "so this gradebook", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00982-00312055-00312367": "would be attached to a teacher", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00983-00312368-00312679": "and the groups", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00984-00312680-00312982": "that they teach to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00985-00312983-00313391": "i don't know if i'm making myself myself", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00986-00313392-00313734": "understand yeah i mean that's clear but", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00987-00313735-00313830": "the problem", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00988-00313831-00314158": "is that there's so much technical", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00989-00314159-00314382": "difficulty associated with this", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00990-00314383-00314687": "and it seems that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00991-00314688-00314991": "really you know you can create multiple", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00992-00314992-00315175": "sites for the same group so you can have", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00993-00315176-00315247": "your", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00994-00315248-00315463": "your site where the students are doing", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00995-00315464-00315639": "the course and you could even have a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00996-00315640-00315799": "separate site where it just has a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00997-00315800-00315879": "gradebook", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00998-00315880-00316119": "and the associated students in it and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-00999-00316120-00316215": "you could", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01000-00316216-00316423": "import and export the grades from the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01001-00316424-00316630": "different sites so if you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01002-00316631-00316847": "have the students in in the gradebook", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01003-00316848-00317030": "that's you know in the main site where", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01004-00317031-00317191": "it's weighted differently and you just", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01005-00317192-00317351": "export all of those items", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01006-00317352-00317510": "you could import them into the gradebook", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01007-00317511-00317743": "that's appropriate for that group", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01008-00317744-00318054": "um in a separate site and i think that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01009-00318055-00318206": "probably would be the best way of", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01010-00318207-00318303": "handling it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01011-00318304-00318727": "in this case so that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01012-00318728-00319079": "there's not so much i mean", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01013-00319080-00319254": "i'm just thinking of the nightmare that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01014-00319255-00319439": "this would be for testing", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01015-00319440-00319791": "like the qa testing mess that this would", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01016-00319792-00319887": "create", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01017-00319888-00320103": "beyond above and beyond the programming", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01018-00320104-00320263": "mess that it would create of having", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01019-00320264-00320439": "separate structures of gradebook in the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01020-00320440-00320558": "same site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01021-00320559-00320799": "and what happens when you import it and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01022-00320800-00320967": "i yeah i just don't know", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01023-00320968-00321199": "i don't know either it's like the the ui", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01024-00321200-00321303": "the gradebook id", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01025-00321304-00321543": "is the course id that's like how it was", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01026-00321544-00321671": "established", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01027-00321672-00322006": "and so if you're going to have", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01028-00322007-00322263": "a second gradebook id and a course you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01029-00322264-00322358": "would have to have", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01030-00322359-00322654": "an id that you have to know that there's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01031-00322655-00322830": "you know", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01032-00322831-00323023": "there's two ids associated with that you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01033-00323024-00323230": "know and then every tool that's linked", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01034-00323231-00323399": "to the gradebook would have to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01035-00323400-00323687": "also be modified to like like what", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01036-00323688-00323830": "assignment would be linked to what grade", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01037-00323831-00323895": "book", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01038-00323896-00324151": "would it be a link to the student or", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01039-00324152-00324247": "every in the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01040-00324248-00324534": "external tools i i i don't it just keeps", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01041-00324535-00324639": "going", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01042-00324640-00324943": "yeah yeah this seems like just", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01043-00324944-00325287": "a nightmare to to develop and test", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01044-00325288-00325567": "i i think that the solution here would", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01045-00325568-00325743": "be to create separate sites", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01046-00325744-00326071": "we have plenty of courses where you know", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01047-00326072-00326247": "an instructor creates", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01048-00326248-00326487": "a a site for the course that they do", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01049-00326488-00326647": "most of the work in", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01050-00326648-00326887": "and the students participate in and then", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01051-00326888-00327006": "they create a site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01052-00327007-00327263": "for their lecture or discussions for the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01053-00327264-00327447": "individual discussion sections", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01054-00327448-00327599": "and the gradebook happens in the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01055-00327600-00327751": "discussion section site", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01056-00327752-00327943": "and maybe nothing else happens there it", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01057-00327944-00328119": "might just be the grading", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01058-00328120-00328463": "um and you know the students in some", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01059-00328464-00328527": "cases", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01060-00328528-00328671": "if the students don't need to see the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01061-00328672-00328903": "grade book that grading site can be", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01062-00328904-00329023": "unpublished", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01063-00329024-00329158": "and the instructor can just do the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01064-00329159-00329310": "grading in there and then at the end", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01065-00329311-00329487": "they release the grades of student", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01066-00329488-00329791": "you know i mean there's there's lots of", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01067-00329792-00329943": "interesting workarounds i think around", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01068-00329944-00329991": "that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01069-00329992-00330119": "like you can even have like you can even", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01070-00330120-00330295": "have the site as a sub site like", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01071-00330296-00330503": "so it appears in the navigation you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01072-00330504-00330599": "could add the you could", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01073-00330600-00330751": "possibly add the other site as an", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01074-00330752-00330943": "external like an lti tool", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01075-00330944-00331271": "in your original site and you know", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01076-00331272-00331599": "if you wanted to make it unpublished um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01077-00331600-00331791": "i feel like there's like hacks with", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01078-00331792-00331958": "insect high that would work better than", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01079-00331959-00332103": "hacking the gradebook right", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01080-00332104-00332334": "well christina also had added a comment", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01081-00332335-00332543": "about using postum", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01082-00332544-00332934": "um to provide grades and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01083-00332935-00333295": "and and you know calculated and those", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01084-00333296-00333519": "you know if you're not in the the right", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01085-00333520-00333751": "one then you don't see it so", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01086-00333752-00333919": "um that would be that's another work", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01087-00333920-00334119": "around that that could", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01088-00334120-00334351": "that would alleviate the need to create", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01089-00334352-00334447": "separate sites if", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01090-00334448-00334575": "if you really didn't want to go the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01091-00334576-00334751": "separate site route um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01092-00334752-00335087": "you can use post em instead um", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01093-00335088-00335254": "and then just transfer a final grade", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01094-00335255-00335558": "into the you know", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01095-00335559-00335991": "so i'm not saying there isn't a solution", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01096-00335992-00336191": "i know adrian's working on something to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01097-00336192-00336351": "like have just a better", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01098-00336352-00336654": "like grade book and maybe he has", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01099-00336655-00336791": "maybe he's working on something too", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01100-00336792-00337071": "there to like they would help this out", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01101-00337072-00337406": "but you know i think whatever's if those", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01102-00337407-00337510": "aren't together", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01103-00337511-00337887": "then that's going to be a problem too", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01104-00337888-00338206": "so for me for me to understand or or", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01105-00338207-00338310": "just", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01106-00338311-00338623": "to to ask openly uh", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01107-00338624-00338975": "for for the solution that any other one", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01108-00338976-00339295": "is applying to the situation let's", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01109-00339296-00339615": "let's see a group where", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01110-00339616-00339895": "students are offered the possibility to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01111-00339896-00339943": "to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01112-00339944-00340519": "be evaluated", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01113-00340520-00340927": "we think within a final exam", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01114-00340928-00341206": "okay okay i'm going to say it this way", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01115-00341207-00341454": "we have assignments and a final exam", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01116-00341455-00341863": "and depending on the amount of work", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01117-00341864-00342182": "that they are facing this this semester", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01118-00342183-00342495": "and they are offered", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01119-00342496-00342830": "the possibility to to to wait", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01120-00342831-00343199": "differently the assignments and the exam", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01121-00343200-00343647": "if they are going to be", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01122-00343648-00344039": "able to work in a day-by-day basis", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01123-00344040-00344278": "they are offered the the possibility to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01124-00344279-00344415": "to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01125-00344416-00344839": "to accept the continuous assessment", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01126-00344840-00345110": "and if they are not and they are willing", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01127-00345111-00345151": "to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01128-00345152-00345406": "to face a final exam uh those", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01129-00345407-00345510": "assessments", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01130-00345511-00345895": "will those assignments sorry will weight", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01131-00345896-00346143": "less than the final exam but they will", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01132-00346144-00346223": "do the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01133-00346224-00346558": "same final exam", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01134-00346559-00347527": "how do you solve this situation", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01135-00347528-00347830": "so i think that hostile is a good way to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01136-00347831-00347919": "do that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01137-00347920-00348143": "um because you can then display", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01138-00348144-00348278": "whichever", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01139-00348279-00348503": "uh grades i mean then you'd be doing the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01140-00348504-00348654": "calculations in excel", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01141-00348655-00348967": "or similar program", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01142-00348968-00349182": "and then the other possibility as we", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01143-00349183-00349375": "mentioned is to create", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01144-00349376-00349599": "two sub sites that you could link to the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01145-00349600-00349758": "parent site one for each", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01146-00349759-00350078": "group of students and in your individual", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01147-00350079-00350206": "sub subsite you would create", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01148-00350207-00350534": "the gradebook uh where you put in the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01149-00350535-00350582": "weights", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01150-00350583-00350791": "and you could if you needed to you could", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01151-00350792-00350999": "send all the grades from the items to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01152-00351000-00351119": "the gradebook in the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01153-00351120-00351351": "parent site and just not weight them", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01154-00351352-00351447": "there you could then", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01155-00351448-00351758": "export that gradebook from that site and", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01156-00351759-00351999": "import it into the child site that has", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01157-00352000-00352103": "the gradebook that", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01158-00352104-00352471": "will be graded so you don't have to do", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01159-00352472-00352575": "anything", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01160-00352576-00352799": "manually to the grades you just export", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01161-00352800-00352999": "them from the site where they exist", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01162-00353000-00353158": "and import them into the site where the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01163-00353159-00353334": "grading will happen", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01164-00353335-00353647": "um yeah just use sites just with a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01165-00353648-00353767": "gradebook and have", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01166-00353768-00353999": "link them to the parent site yeah yeah", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01167-00354000-00354134": "and there's no other tools in the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01168-00354135-00354654": "subside just the gradebook", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01169-00354655-00354839": "and there's insight managed insight info", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01170-00354840-00354967": "there's a set there's a", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01171-00354968-00355143": "link that says link to parent site where", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01172-00355144-00355343": "you can those with sites would appear on", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01173-00355344-00355399": "the", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01174-00355400-00355534": "on the site you just add the students", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01175-00355535-00355678": "that are associated with that gradebook", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01176-00355679-00355999": "into those sub sites", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01177-00356000-00356287": "okay we need to check because i don't", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01178-00356288-00356430": "think that we are able to create", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01179-00356431-00356551": "subsites", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01180-00356552-00356910": "in our institution so we have to check", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01181-00356911-00357582": "thank you", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01182-00357583-00357854": "all right on that note we were actually", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01183-00357855-00358006": "over time here and i have another", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01184-00358007-00358223": "meeting i need to go to so i am going to", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01185-00358224-00358482": "put a stop to this", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01186-00358483-00358734": "um we don't", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01187-00358735-00358943": "have a particular topic for our next", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01188-00358944-00359182": "meeting if anybody has", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01189-00359183-00359591": "anything um let either i or wilma know", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01190-00359592-00359678": "otherwise we'll", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01191-00359679-00360206": "we'll take a look at some more jiras", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01192-00360207-00360478": "so i will stop the recording now thanks", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01193-00360479-00360575": "all", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01194-00360576-00360830": "thanks and have a good next couple of", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01195-00360831-00360903": "weeks", "TuQKiHAZLJQ-01196-00360904-00361488": "you're welcome ciao"}}, {"audio_id": "TuQWrJxv6-g", "text": {"TuQWrJxv6-g-00000-00000000-00000199": "what up peeps so the road trip is", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00001-00000200-00000407": "beginning i'm with my dad we are on our", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00002-00000408-00000455": "way", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00003-00000456-00000671": "to visit my brother st louis here we", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00004-00000672-00000759": "come it says", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00005-00000760-00001079": "we are gonna arrive at 4 a.m i'm gonna", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00006-00001080-00001223": "try and knock it down a little bit when", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00007-00001224-00001287": "i drive", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00008-00001288-00001462": "i told her not to drive too fast while", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00009-00001463-00001639": "i'm sleeping my dad taught me how to", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00010-00001639-00001823": "drive and he complains that i drive", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00011-00001823-00002575": "too fast but i learned from you", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00012-00002576-00002799": "that's what i like to hear my road rage", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00013-00002800-00003007": "dad is coming back now", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00014-00003008-00003175": "that's how i learned how to drive with", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00015-00003176-00003319": "the anger and rage", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00016-00003320-00003527": "this big truck caught him off i'm gonna", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00017-00003528-00003670": "take my first", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00018-00003671-00003983": "nap", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00019-00003984-00004215": "for 36 miles it wasn't talking to me it", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00020-00004216-00004359": "wasn't telling me what to", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00021-00004360-00004686": "do it did i'm sitting here editing a", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00022-00004687-00004831": "little bit and the sun's setting", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00023-00004832-00005038": "it's really pretty this weird gas", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00024-00005039-00005215": "station market that has", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00025-00005216-00005415": "mcdonald's how much is gas for you guys", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00026-00005416-00005591": "live it was like 219 here", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00027-00005592-00005783": "in ohio i haven't gotten mcdonald's in", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00028-00005784-00005983": "so long i forgot how small like look how", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00029-00005984-00006167": "thin this cheeseburger is", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00030-00006168-00006343": "it's so little it's like all it's all", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00031-00006344-00006567": "bun i got the two", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00032-00006568-00006831": "cheeseburger combo back to driving i'm", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00033-00006831-00007070": "taking the wheel and my dad said i'm not", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00034-00007072-00007384": "allowed to film and drive", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00035-00007384-00007710": "[Music]", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00036-00007711-00007998": "my legs are so sore my dad is off the", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00037-00008000-00008039": "wall", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00038-00008040-00008319": "annoying and he won't leave me alone i", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00039-00008320-00008503": "like to take this off", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00040-00008504-00008759": "he's a backseat driver screaming at me", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00041-00008760-00008863": "like every", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00042-00008864-00009142": "five seconds literally he's sleeping and", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00043-00009143-00009174": "he's", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00044-00009175-00009342": "putting his hands up like waking up as", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00045-00009343-00009542": "if he's gonna put the brakes on i can't", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00046-00009543-00009719": "take it and i'm not even driving it i'm", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00047-00009720-00009846": "going fast but", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00048-00009847-00010295": "not crazy oh my god my legs hurt", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00049-00010296-00010559": "you're annoying you are annoying i'm", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00050-00010560-00010791": "talking about how annoying you are oh", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00051-00010792-00011014": "let's put this back well we're probably", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00052-00011015-00011167": "not going to wear a mask in my brother's", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00053-00011168-00011342": "house but in the car we're still close", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00054-00011343-00011455": "to each other", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00055-00011456-00011670": "so i wanted to at least wear it you've", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00056-00011671-00011814": "got it he's talking about getting a", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00057-00011815-00011974": "coffee you're not getting coffee you", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00058-00011975-00012199": "need to go to bed it's my job to teach", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00059-00012200-00012223": "you", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00060-00012224-00012559": "you're so annoying what's going on", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00061-00012560-00012879": "are you afraid you're doing pretty good", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00062-00012880-00013094": "not the way you're acting we have an", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00063-00013095-00013230": "hour and a half left", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00064-00013231-00013479": "i want to finish the drive he was", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00065-00013480-00013575": "supposed to go to sleep", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00066-00013576-00013799": "this is bedtime he used to bed at like", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00067-00013800-00013975": "nine o'clock or something crazy like", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00068-00013976-00014007": "that", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00069-00014008-00014222": "anyway i'm just gonna go pee real quick", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00070-00014223-00014383": "we made it and i wanted to show you guys", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00071-00014384-00014479": "something we saved an", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00072-00014480-00014791": "hour and a half i'm so excited i'm here", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00073-00014791-00015199": "what's up peeps jason i made carrot cake", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00074-00015200-00015335": "and i brought it to my brother's house", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00075-00015336-00015519": "that's so good i'm having seconds", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00076-00015519-00015686": "she said she's bringing it to jason but", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00077-00015687-00015830": "yeah i think she made it for herself", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00078-00015831-00016022": "she's going to eat it all", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00079-00016023-00016271": "it's really good 3 a.m i'm gonna have", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00080-00016272-00016503": "sweet dreams", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00081-00016504-00016758": "helping my brother do his garage we're", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00082-00016759-00016847": "cleaning it out", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00083-00016848-00017079": "we might burn that chair for the", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00084-00017080-00017294": "cheerleader", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00085-00017295-00017430": "can i show you a dope car we're", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00086-00017431-00017583": "definitely going to burn the chair jason", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00087-00017584-00017711": "got this dope new car", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00088-00017712-00017935": "brand new it's a what dodge challenger", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00089-00017936-00018022": "charger", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00090-00018023-00018247": "it's really nice i love it the side but", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00091-00018248-00018414": "yeah we are probably going to burn", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00092-00018415-00018711": "this chair later angle of this car it's", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00093-00018712-00018822": "really dope but yeah we're basically", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00094-00018823-00018967": "cleaning out the garage because he wants", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00095-00018968-00019111": "to eventually be able to park his car in", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00096-00019112-00019222": "here", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00097-00019223-00019519": "you should have a haunted house my", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00098-00019520-00019711": "brother just made some steaks on the", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00099-00019712-00019871": "grill it smells so good", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00100-00019872-00020103": "thank you jay you're welcome i used to", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00101-00020104-00020711": "say genku", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00102-00020712-00020878": "look at this yummy dinner my brother", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00103-00020879-00021063": "made for us my brother knows how to cook", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00104-00021064-00021247": "too if you guys didn't know", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00105-00021248-00021391": "you know you really our whole family we", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00106-00021392-00021535": "all know how to cook it's yummy my", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00107-00021536-00021591": "brother has", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00108-00021592-00021775": "one firework leftover from fourth of", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00109-00021776-00022047": "july yeah so we're going to blow it up", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00110-00022048-00022271": "why do you have to get sweet in the gas", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00111-00022272-00022455": "can for what", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00112-00022456-00022671": "for the fireworks oh no we have to wait", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00113-00022672-00022894": "for dad we could do another one tomorrow", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00114-00022895-00023071": "are you serious there's a lot of [__] to", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00115-00023072-00023230": "burn let me see it all right ready i'm", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00116-00023231-00023391": "not gonna put the gas on the floor you", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00117-00023392-00023463": "look like a", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00118-00023464-00023847": "psycho oh my god", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00119-00023848-00024663": "this has a punching bag in his garage", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00120-00024664-00025283": "he was like do it do it do it just punch", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00121-00025284-00025430": "it", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00122-00025431-00025694": "oh my god you got my leg a little bit i", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00123-00025695-00025774": "smell the smoke", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00124-00025775-00026055": "can i see those yeah these are the crazy", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00125-00026056-00026127": "snacks", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00126-00026127-00026223": "i don't know if you guys know the", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00127-00026224-00026439": "difference i'm gonna get you now haha", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00128-00026439-00026967": "get me no don't throw them", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00129-00026968-00027174": "i had to get you back most of this is", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00130-00027175-00027351": "extra materials that he had", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00131-00027352-00027551": "extra wood in his garage that were just", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00132-00027552-00027711": "burning how often do you like these", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00133-00027712-00027902": "crazy fires with gasoline", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00134-00027904-00028102": "it's not that unusual i thought people", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00135-00028104-00028351": "light fires with just a match", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00136-00028352-00028687": "do i have to run", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00137-00028688-00028846": "that happened you're about to burn your", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00138-00028847-00029007": "neighbor's tree though in the back don't", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00139-00029008-00029207": "like", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00140-00029208-00030743": "it's like half in your neighbor's yard", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00141-00030744-00030927": "it's kind of cool though look at that it", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00142-00030927-00031038": "looks so pretty", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00143-00031039-00031439": "[Music]", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00144-00031439-00031711": "he's going to get the hose it's going up", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00145-00031712-00032127": "into the tree", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00146-00032127-00032279": "good thing my dad's sleeping i have to", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00147-00032280-00032687": "turn the hose on", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00148-00032688-00034151": "like the view it's like this gigantic", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00149-00034152-00034380": "wow it's crazy", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00150-00034381-00034590": "[Music]", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00151-00034591-00034790": "oh my god that's so funny you know the", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00152-00034791-00034943": "like handle that you would pull", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00153-00034944-00035583": "to recline it that's right there", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00154-00035584-00037340": "that's the back of the recliner", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00155-00037341-00037662": "[Music]", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00156-00037663-00038015": "all right come back", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00157-00038016-00038407": "[Music]", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00158-00038408-00038830": "who me i know he's like she's so happy", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00159-00038831-00038999": "that's true is this crazy because it", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00160-00039000-00039159": "kind of makes you think we literally", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00161-00039160-00039287": "threw a chair", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00162-00039288-00039551": "in there and how quickly it blew up into", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00163-00039552-00039718": "flames and now it's literally like", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00164-00039719-00039918": "gone and how quick a house could blow up", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00165-00039919-00040095": "in flames you know what i mean", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00166-00040096-00040262": "our house when we grew up our house was", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00167-00040263-00040455": "on fire and then the firemen came we had", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00168-00040456-00040599": "two cats and a dog we had to get the", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00169-00040600-00040679": "animals out", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00170-00040680-00041039": "it was crazy", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00171-00041040-00041358": "no no jeez push it", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00172-00041359-00042199": "in not pull it out", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00173-00042200-00042471": "was just gonna do that you were gonna", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00174-00042472-00042558": "get me back", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00175-00042559-00042735": "that was so quick how did you grab it", "TuQWrJxv6-g-00176-00042736-00043775": "out of the bag that fast"}}, {"audio_id": "TuR7QkowsEQ", "text": {"TuR7QkowsEQ-00000-00000028-00000254": "throughout the history of the Soviet", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00001-00000254-00000419": "Union tens of millions of people", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00002-00000420-00000634": "suffered political repression which was", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00003-00000635-00000788": "an instrument of the state since the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00004-00000789-00001073": "october revolution it culminated during", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00005-00001074-00001256": "the Stalin era then declined but", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00006-00001257-00001502": "continued to exist during the Khrushchev", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00007-00001503-00001784": "thaw followed by increased persecution", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00008-00001785-00001979": "of Soviet dissidents during the Brezhnev", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00009-00001980-00002156": "stagnation and did not cease to exist", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00010-00002157-00002809": "during Mikhail Gorbachev's perestroika", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00011-00002810-00003344": "origins and early Soviet times", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00012-00003345-00003590": "early on the Leninist view of the class", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00013-00003590-00003785": "conflict and the resulting notion of the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00014-00003786-00004001": "dictatorship of the proletariat provided", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00015-00004002-00004202": "the theoretical basis of the repressions", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00016-00004203-00004499": "its legal basis was formalized into the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00017-00004500-00004739": "article 58 in the code of russian sfsr", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00018-00004740-00004994": "and similar articles for other soviet", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00019-00004995-00005197": "republics at times the repressed were", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00020-00005198-00005368": "called the enemies of the people", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00021-00005369-00005582": "punishments by the state included", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00022-00005583-00005807": "summary executions sending innocent", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00023-00005808-00006022": "people to gulag forced resettlement and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00024-00006023-00006296": "stripping of citizens rights at certain", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00025-00006297-00006536": "times all members of a family including", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00026-00006537-00006773": "children were punished as traitor of the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00027-00006773-00007096": "motherland family members repression was", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00028-00007097-00007253": "conducted by the Cheka and its", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00029-00007254-00007465": "successors and other state organs", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00030-00007466-00007696": "periods of the increased repression", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00031-00007697-00007934": "include red terror collectivization the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00032-00007934-00008159": "great purges the doctors plot and others", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00033-00008159-00008438": "the secret police forces conducted", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00034-00008439-00008603": "massacres of prisoners on numerous", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00035-00008604-00008867": "occasions repression took place in the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00036-00008868-00009077": "Soviet republics and in the territories", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00037-00009078-00009281": "occupied by the Soviet Army during World", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00038-00009282-00009530": "War two including the Baltic States in", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00039-00009531-00009835": "Eastern Europe state repression led to", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00040-00009836-00010021": "incidents of resistance such as the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00041-00010022-00010396": "Tambov rebellion 1920 1921 the Kronstadt", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00042-00010397-00010720": "rebellion 1921 and the Vorkuta uprising", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00043-00010721-00010994": "1953 the soviet authorities suppressed", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00044-00010995-00011141": "such resistance with overwhelming", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00045-00011142-00011413": "military force during the Tambov", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00046-00011414-00011663": "rebellion Tukhachevsky chief red army", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00047-00011664-00011837": "commander in the area allegedly", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00048-00011838-00012094": "authorized Bolshevik military forces to", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00049-00012095-00012280": "use chemical weapons against villages", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00050-00012281-00012479": "with civilian population and rebels", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00051-00012480-00012698": "according to witnesses accounts chemical", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00052-00012699-00012857": "weapons were never actually used", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00053-00012858-00013049": "prominent citizens of villages were", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00054-00013050-00013286": "often taken as hostages and executed if", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00055-00013287-00013424": "the resistance fighters did not", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00056-00013425-00013774": "surrender", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00057-00013775-00014463": "topic Red Terror red terror in Soviet", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00058-00014465-00014677": "Russia was the campaign of mass arrests", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00059-00014678-00014836": "and executions conducted by the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00060-00014837-00015100": "Bolshevik government the Red Terror was", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00061-00015101-00015301": "officially announced on September 2nd", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00062-00015302-00015574": "1918 by Yakov Sverdlov and ended in", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00063-00015575-00015757": "about October 1918", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00064-00015758-00016047": "however sergei merinov applies this term", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00065-00016049-00016231": "to repressions for the whole period of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00066-00016232-00016596": "the Russian Civil War 1918 to 1920 -", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00067-00016597-00016840": "estimates for the total number of people", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00068-00016841-00017035": "executed during the initial phase red", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00069-00017036-00017268": "terror are at least 10,000 with roughly", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00070-00017269-00017488": "28,000 executed per year between", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00071-00017489-00017944": "December 1917 and February 1922 the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00072-00017945-00018169": "totals lives lost during this period are", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00073-00018170-00018758": "between 100,000 and 200,000", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00074-00018759-00019298": "topic collectivization", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00075-00019299-00019521": "collectivization in the soviet union was", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00076-00019522-00019878": "a policy pursued between 1928 and 1933", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00077-00019879-00020142": "to consolidate individual land and labor", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00078-00020143-00020370": "into collective farms Russian coal youth", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00079-00020371-00020688": "coal cause plural coal Kazi the Soviet", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00080-00020689-00020826": "leaders were confident that the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00081-00020827-00021036": "replacement of individual peasant farms", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00082-00021037-00021234": "by coal Kazi would immediately increase", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00083-00021235-00021399": "food supplies for the urban population", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00084-00021400-00021633": "the supply of raw materials for", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00085-00021634-00021837": "processing industry and agricultural", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00086-00021838-00022131": "exports generally collectivization was", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00087-00022132-00022311": "thus regarded as the solution to the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00088-00022312-00022521": "crisis and agricultural distribution", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00089-00022522-00022698": "mainly in grain deliveries that had", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00090-00022699-00022959": "developed since 1927 and was becoming", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00091-00022960-00023157": "more acute as the Soviet Union pressed", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00092-00023158-00023268": "ahead with its ambitious", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00093-00023269-00023529": "industrialization program as the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00094-00023530-00023700": "peasantry with the exception of the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00095-00023701-00023844": "poorest part resisted the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00096-00023845-00024051": "collectivization policy the Soviet", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00097-00024052-00024240": "government resorted to harsh measures to", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00098-00024241-00024507": "force the farmers to collectivise in his", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00099-00024508-00024702": "conversation with Winston Churchill", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00100-00024703-00024879": "Stalin gave his estimate of the number", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00101-00024880-00024993": "of kulaks", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00102-00024994-00025239": "who were repressed for resisting Soviet", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00103-00025240-00025392": "collectivization as ten million", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00104-00025393-00025709": "including those forcibly deported recent", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00105-00025710-00025914": "historians have estimated the death toll", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00106-00025914-00026464": "in the range of 6 to 13 million", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00107-00026464-00026930": "topic Great Purge", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00108-00026931-00027212": "the Great Purge Russian bolsa Siska", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00109-00027213-00027427": "transliterated bolshaya chica was a", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00110-00027429-00027608": "series of campaigns of political", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00111-00027608-00027818": "repression and persecution in the soviet", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00112-00027819-00028037": "union orchestrated by joseph stalin in", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00113-00028038-00028436": "1937 1938 it involved the purge of the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00114-00028437-00028637": "Communist Party of the Soviet Union", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00115-00028638-00028874": "repression of peasants deportations of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00116-00028875-00029095": "ethnic minorities and the persecution of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00117-00029097-00029324": "unaffiliated persons characterized by", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00118-00029325-00029458": "widespread police surveillance", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00119-00029460-00029764": "widespread suspicion of saboteurs", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00120-00029764-00030026": "imprisonment and killings estimates of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00121-00030027-00030206": "the number of deaths associated with the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00122-00030207-00030407": "Great Purge run from the official figure", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00123-00030408-00031187": "of 680 1692 to nearly 2 million", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00124-00031188-00031421": "topic genocide ethnic cleansing and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00125-00031422-00031902": "population transfers", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00126-00031902-00032175": "in Soviet Union political repressions", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00127-00032176-00032424": "targeted not only individual persons but", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00128-00032425-00032661": "also whole ethnic social religious and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00129-00032662-00032888": "other categories of population", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00130-00032889-00033171": "population transfer in the Soviet Union", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00131-00033172-00033345": "may be classified into the following", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00132-00033346-00033624": "broad categories deportations of anti", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00133-00033625-00033927": "Soviet categories of population often", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00134-00033928-00034208": "classified as enemies of workers", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00135-00034209-00034443": "deportations of nationalities labor", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00136-00034444-00034680": "force transfer and organized migrations", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00137-00034681-00034842": "in opposite directions to fill the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00138-00034843-00035121": "ethnically cleansed territories in most", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00139-00035122-00035313": "cases their destinations were under", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00140-00035314-00035532": "populated remote areas see involuntary", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00141-00035533-00035871": "settlements in the Soviet Union entire", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00142-00035872-00036030": "nations and ethnic groups were", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00143-00036031-00036201": "collectively punished by the Soviet", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00144-00036202-00036378": "government for alleged collaboration", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00145-00036379-00036576": "with the enemy during World War two", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00146-00036577-00036815": "at least nine distinct ethnic linguistic", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00147-00036816-00037086": "groups including ethnic Germans ethnic", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00148-00037087-00037320": "Greeks ethnic poles Crimean Tatars", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00149-00037321-00037569": "balkars Chechens and kalmyks were", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00150-00037570-00037800": "deported to remote unpopulated areas of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00151-00037801-00038084": "Siberia see cyber AK and Kazakhstan", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00152-00038085-00038310": "population transfer in the Soviet Union", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00153-00038311-00038499": "led to millions of deaths from the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00154-00038500-00038754": "inflicted hardships Koreans and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00155-00038755-00038979": "Romanians were also deported mass", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00156-00038980-00039221": "operations of the NKVD were needed to", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00157-00039222-00039428": "deport hundreds of thousands of people", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00158-00039429-00039870": "the Soviet Famine of 1932-1933 was", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00159-00039871-00040062": "severely aggravated by the actions of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00160-00040063-00040260": "the government of the Soviet Union such", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00161-00040261-00040473": "as the confiscation of food the lack of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00162-00040474-00040671": "meat plan delivery limitations that", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00163-00040672-00040824": "ignored the famine blocking the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00164-00040825-00041034": "migration of its starving population and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00165-00041035-00041199": "the suppression of the information about", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00166-00041200-00041390": "the famine all of which prevented any", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00167-00041391-00041646": "organized relief effort this led to", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00168-00041647-00041817": "deaths of millions of people in the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00169-00041818-00042089": "affected area the overall number of the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00170-00042090-00042480": "1932-1933 famine victims Soviet wide as", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00171-00042481-00042759": "variously estimated as 6 to 7 million or", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00172-00042760-00043158": "6 to 8 million", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00173-00043159-00043654": "topic gulag", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00174-00043655-00043927": "the gulag was the branch of the state", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00175-00043928-00044140": "security that operated the penal system", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00176-00044141-00044428": "of forced labor camps and associated", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00177-00044429-00044682": "detention and transit camps in prisons", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00178-00044683-00044968": "while these camps housed criminals of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00179-00044969-00045220": "all types the gulag system has become", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00180-00045221-00045424": "primarily known as a place for political", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00181-00045425-00045631": "prisoners and as a mechanism for", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00182-00045632-00045865": "repressing political opposition to the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00183-00045866-00046183": "Soviet state Russian author and former", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00184-00046184-00046387": "prisoner Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn wrote", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00185-00046388-00046597": "extensively about the gulag in its", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00186-00046598-00046801": "history in his series of books the gulag", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00187-00046802-00047198": "archipelago", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00188-00047199-00047838": "topic repressions in and ex territories", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00189-00047839-00048078": "during the early years of World War two", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00190-00048079-00048261": "Soviet Union and next several", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00191-00048262-00048435": "territories in East Europe as the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00192-00048436-00048633": "consequence of the German Soviet pact", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00193-00048634-00049101": "and its secret Additional Protocol", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00194-00049102-00049609": "topic Baltic states", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00195-00049610-00049834": "in the Baltic countries of Estonia", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00196-00049835-00050080": "Latvia and Lithuania repressions and the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00197-00050081-00050251": "mass deportations were carried out by", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00198-00050252-00050557": "the Soviets the cero of instructions on", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00199-00050558-00050773": "the procedure for carrying out the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00200-00050774-00051040": "deportation of anti Soviet elements from", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00201-00051041-00051429": "Lithuania Latvia and Estonia contained", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00202-00051430-00051640": "detailed procedures and protocols to", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00203-00051641-00051840": "observe in the deportation of Baltic", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00204-00051841-00052155": "nationals public tribunals were also set", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00205-00052157-00052375": "up to punish traitors to the people", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00206-00052376-00052570": "those who had fallen short of that", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00207-00052571-00052870": "political Duty of voting their countries", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00208-00052871-00053113": "into the USSR in the first year of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00209-00053114-00053425": "Soviet occupation from June 1940 to June", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00210-00053426-00053704": "1941 the number confirmed executed", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00211-00053704-00053935": "conscripted or deported as estimated at", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00212-00053936-00054211": "a minimum of 124 thousand four hundred", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00213-00054212-00054499": "sixty-seven to 59 thousand seven hundred", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00214-00054500-00054784": "thirty-two in Estonia 34 thousand two", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00215-00054785-00054970": "hundred fifty in Latvia and thirty", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00216-00054971-00055357": "thousand 485 in Lithuania this included", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00217-00055358-00055542": "eight former heads of state and thirty", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00218-00055544-00055735": "eight ministers from Estonia three", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00219-00055736-00055917": "former heads of state and fifteen", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00220-00055919-00056077": "ministers from Latvia and the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00221-00056078-00056269": "then-president five prime ministers and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00222-00056270-00056839": "24 other ministers from Lithuania", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00223-00056840-00057241": "topic Poland", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00224-00057242-00057742": "topic Romania", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00225-00057744-00058552": "topic post Stalin era 1953 to 1991", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00226-00058553-00058791": "after Stalin's death the suppression of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00227-00058792-00058980": "dissent was dramatically reduced and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00228-00058982-00059254": "took new forms the internal critics of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00229-00059254-00059425": "the system were convicted for anti", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00230-00059426-00059677": "Soviet agitation anti Soviet slander", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00231-00059678-00060013": "Oris social parasites others were", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00232-00060014-00060223": "labeled as mentally ill having sluggish", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00233-00060224-00060417": "schizophrenia and incarcerated in", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00234-00060419-00060772": "tsukushi cos ie mental hospitals used by", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00235-00060773-00060964": "the Soviet authorities as prisons a", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00236-00060965-00061165": "number of notable dissidents including", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00237-00061166-00061420": "Alexander Solzhenitsyn Vladimir Bukovsky", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00238-00061421-00061600": "and Andrei Sakharov", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00239-00061601-00062130": "were sent to internal or external exile", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00240-00062132-00062658": "topic loss of life", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00241-00062659-00062910": "the exact number of victims may never be", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00242-00062911-00063066": "known and remains a matter of debate", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00243-00063066-00063341": "among historians the published results", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00244-00063342-00063549": "vary depending on the time when the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00245-00063550-00063747": "estimate was made on the criteria and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00246-00063748-00063917": "methods used for the estimates and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00247-00063919-00064197": "sources available for estimates some", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00248-00064198-00064374": "historians attempt to make separate", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00249-00064375-00064554": "estimates for different periods of the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00250-00064554-00064857": "Soviet history for example the number of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00251-00064858-00065030": "victims under Joseph Stalin's regime", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00252-00065032-00065480": "vary from 640 2,980 to 61 million", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00253-00065482-00065673": "according to Declassified Soviet", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00254-00065674-00066114": "archives in 1937 in 1938 the NKVD", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00255-00066115-00066282": "arrested more than one and a half", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00256-00066283-00066705": "million people of whom 680 1692 were", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00257-00066706-00066993": "shot over those two years that averages", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00258-00066994-00067326": "to over 1000 executions a day according", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00259-00067327-00067628": "to historian Jeffrey Hosking", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00260-00067629-00067930": "excess deaths during the 1930s as a", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00261-00067931-00068155": "whole were in the range of 10 to 11", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00262-00068156-00068473": "million historian Timothy D Schneider", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00263-00068474-00068707": "claims that archival evidence suggests a", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00264-00068708-00068935": "maximum excess mortality of 9 million", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00265-00068936-00069244": "during the entire Stalin era historian", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00266-00069245-00069440": "and archival researcher Stephen G", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00267-00069441-00069659": "Wheatcroft asserts Stalin can be charged", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00268-00069660-00069997": "with the purpose of deaths of something", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00269-00069998-00070271": "in the order of a million people he also", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00270-00070272-00070507": "notes that the purpose of deaths caused", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00271-00070508-00070741": "by Hitler fit more closely into the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00272-00070742-00070969": "category of murder while those caused by", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00273-00070970-00071227": "Stalin fit more closely the category of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00274-00071228-00071701": "execution", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00275-00071702-00072336": "topic difficulties encounter repressed", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00276-00072337-00072622": "Russian writer Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00277-00072623-00072744": "who deeply studied this problem", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00278-00072745-00073036": "considers that 66 million seven hundred", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00279-00073037-00073257": "thousand people became victims to state", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00280-00073258-00073522": "repression and terrorism from 1917 to", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00281-00073523-00073936": "1959 an analogous figure of over 66", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00282-00073937-00074092": "million people was announced by", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00283-00074093-00074301": "Alexander Nikolaevich yakovlev the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00284-00074302-00074431": "chairman of the Commission for", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00285-00074432-00074590": "rehabilitation of the victims of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00286-00074591-00074854": "political repression according to Viktor", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00287-00074855-00075073": "Luna of actual struggle against dissent", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00288-00075074-00075223": "was many fold larger than it was", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00289-00075224-00075424": "registered in sentences and we do not", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00290-00075425-00075610": "know how many persons were kept under", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00291-00075611-00075811": "surveillance of Secret Service's held", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00292-00075812-00076026": "criminally liable arrested sent to", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00293-00076027-00076225": "psychiatric hospitals expelled from", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00294-00076226-00076384": "their work restricted in their rights", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00295-00076385-00076657": "every way no objective counting of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00296-00076658-00076837": "repressed persons as possible without", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00297-00076838-00077041": "fundamental analysis of archival", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00298-00077042-00077319": "documents the difficulty of this method", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00299-00077320-00077509": "is that the required data are diverse", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00300-00077510-00077769": "and are not in one archive they are in", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00301-00077770-00077917": "the state archive of the Russian", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00302-00077918-00078103": "Federation in the archive of the gaas", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00303-00078104-00078325": "ComStat of Russia in the archives of the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00304-00078326-00078592": "mvd of Russia the FSB of Russia the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00305-00078593-00078769": "general Prosecutor's Office of the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00306-00078770-00078943": "Russian Federation in the Russian", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00307-00078944-00079147": "military and historical archive in", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00308-00079148-00079360": "archives of constituent entities of the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00309-00079361-00079543": "Russian Federation in urban and regional", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00310-00079544-00079776": "archives as well as in archives of the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00311-00079777-00079975": "former Soviet republics that now are", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00312-00079976-00080106": "independent countries of the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00313-00080107-00080287": "Commonwealth of Independent States in", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00314-00080288-00080563": "the Baltics where for example can one", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00315-00080564-00080740": "determine the number of people shot in", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00316-00080741-00080965": "the second half of the 1930s and in the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00317-00080966-00081259": "early 1940s in the Kapiti whole estimate", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00318-00081260-00081547": "for them as from 30 to 100,000 people or", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00319-00081548-00081780": "by some estimates up to 200,000 people", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00320-00081781-00082105": "only in Belarus the same can be said of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00321-00082106-00082306": "other mass shootings and other forms of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00322-00082307-00082494": "repression of victims of Soviet regime", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00323-00082495-00082825": "by the request of NS Khrushchev in", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00324-00082826-00083125": "February 1954 a report about the number", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00325-00083126-00083317": "of repressed people was prepared and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00326-00083318-00083532": "signed by general prosecutor Attorney", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00327-00083533-00083842": "General of the USSR our rudenko Interior", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00328-00083843-00084121": "Minister of the USSR s Krug law Justice", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00329-00084122-00084426": "Minister of the USSR k Gore Shannon the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00330-00084427-00084640": "report listed the total number of people", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00331-00084641-00084841": "prosecuted for counter-revolutionary", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00332-00084842-00085090": "crimes during the period from 1920", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00333-00085091-00085483": "to February 1st 1954 during that period", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00334-00085484-00085852": "the Collegium OG PU NKVD troika's", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00335-00085853-00086146": "Special Counsel of the NKVD courts and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00336-00086147-00086365": "military courts indicted three million", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00337-00086366-00086656": "seven hundred seventy seven thousand 380", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00338-00086657-00086995": "individuals including 642 thousand nine", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00339-00086996-00087154": "hundred eighty who received the death", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00340-00087155-00087391": "penalty two million three hundred sixty", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00341-00087392-00087583": "nine thousand two hundred twenty with", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00342-00087584-00087790": "sentences of up to twenty five years and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00343-00087791-00088006": "seven hundred sixty-five thousand one", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00344-00088007-00088294": "hundred eighty exiled or deported at the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00345-00088295-00088486": "time of the report it further stated", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00346-00088487-00088657": "there were four hundred sixty seven", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00347-00088658-00088885": "thousand nine hundred forty six people", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00348-00088886-00089092": "in the labor camps and prisons convicted", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00349-00089093-00089284": "for counter-revolutionary crimes and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00350-00089285-00089476": "sixty two thousand four hundred sixty", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00351-00089477-00089797": "two former prisoners in exile topic", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00352-00089798-00089950": "remembering the victims a day of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00353-00089951-00090142": "remembrance for the victims of political", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00354-00090143-00090385": "repression denpa ma teaser TV politics", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00355-00090386-00090583": "kira presage has been officially held on", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00356-00090584-00090870": "the 30th of October in Russia since 1991", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00357-00090871-00091183": "it is also marked in other former Soviet", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00358-00091184-00091375": "republics with the exception of Ukraine", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00359-00091376-00091528": "which has its own annual Day of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00360-00091529-00091699": "Remembrance for the victims of political", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00361-00091700-00091930": "repressions by the Soviet regime held", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00362-00091931-00092118": "each year on the third Sunday of May", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00363-00092119-00092374": "members of the memorial society have", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00364-00092375-00092524": "taken an active part in such", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00365-00092525-00092836": "commemorative meetings since 2007", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00366-00092837-00093043": "memorial has also organized the day-long", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00367-00093044-00093295": "restoring the names ceremony at the Sala", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00368-00093296-00093550": "vets Keystone in Moscow every the 29th", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00369-00093551-00093787": "of October the wall of grief in Moscow", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00370-00093788-00094096": "inaugurated in October 2017 is Russia's", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00371-00094097-00094306": "first monument ordered by presidential", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00372-00094307-00094459": "decree for people killed during the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00373-00094460-00094642": "Stalinist repressions in the Soviet", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00374-00094643-00094915": "Union topics see also active measures", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00375-00094916-00095097": "human rights in the soviet union", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00376-00095098-00095377": "rehabilitation soviet soviet political", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00377-00095378-00095614": "system soviet law soviet repression in", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00378-00095615-00095875": "belarus goleo tok Hitler Youth", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00379-00095876-00096106": "conspiracy mass killings under communist", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00380-00096107-00096396": "regimes USSR anti-religious campaign", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00381-00096397-00096841": "1970s - 1990 the black book of communism", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00382-00096842-00097087": "topic references topic notes topic", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00383-00097088-00097483": "bibliography conquest robert 1986 the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00384-00097484-00097645": "harvest of sorrow soviet", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00385-00097646-00097840": "collectivization and the terror famine", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00386-00097841-00098230": "oxford university press ISBN o one nine", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00387-00098231-00098488": "five oh five one eight oh seven", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00388-00098489-00098896": "court wants to fajn at all Eadie's 1999", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00389-00098897-00099166": "the black book of communism crimes", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00390-00099167-00099466": "terror repression harvard university", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00391-00099467-00099799": "press ISBN oh six seven four oh seven", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00392-00099800-00099952": "six zero eight seven", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00393-00099953-00100249": "CS one main uses editors parameter link", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00394-00100250-00100666": "Figgis Orlando 2007 the whispers private", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00395-00100667-00101020": "life in Stalin's Russia macmillan ISBN o", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00396-00101021-00101452": "805 oh seven four six one nine Lindy and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00397-00101453-00101809": "liftin Robert J 2001 beyond invisible", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00398-00101810-00102061": "walls the psychological legacy of Soviet", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00399-00102062-00102271": "trauma East European therapists and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00400-00102272-00102598": "their patients psychology press ISBN", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00401-00102599-00102868": "nine seven eight one five eight three", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00402-00102869-00103129": "nine one three one eight five Cs one", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00403-00103130-00103399": "main uses authors parameter link New", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00404-00103400-00103633": "Directions in gulag studies a roundtable", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00405-00103633-00103924": "discussion Canadian Slavonic papers 59", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00406-00103925-00104488": "no 3-2 for 2017 no Alec 1993 victims of", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00407-00104489-00104800": "Stalinism how many in Getty J arch and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00408-00104801-00105040": "Manning Roberta T Stalinist terror new", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00409-00105041-00105309": "perspectives cambridge university press", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00410-00105310-00105745": "ISBN oh five to one four four six seven", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00411-00105746-00106021": "oh eight CS one main uses editors", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00412-00106022-00106399": "parameter link ryan james 2012 Lennon's", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00413-00106400-00106648": "terror the ideological origins of early", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00414-00106649-00106941": "Soviet state violence London route llege", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00415-00106942-00107290": "ISBN 978 one one three eight eight one", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00416-00107291-00107697": "five six eight one week Croft Stephen", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00417-00107698-00108033": "1996 the scale and nature of German and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00418-00108034-00108283": "Soviet repression and mass killings 19", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00419-00108283-00108889": "32 45 PDF Europe Asia studies 48 8 13 19", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00420-00108890-00109246": "to 13 53 doy ten point one zero eight", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00421-00109247-00109552": "zero oh nine six six eight one three", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00422-00109553-00109873": "nine six oh eight four one two four one", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00423-00109874-00110629": "five JSTOR 150 2781 Lynne viola new", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00424-00110630-00110835": "sources on Soviet perpetrators of mass", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00425-00110836-00111064": "repression a research note Canadian", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00426-00111065-00111400": "Slavonic papers 60 no three to four 2018", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00427-00111401-00111694": "topic further reading Brooks Jeffrey mm", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00428-00111695-00111864": "Thank You comrade", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00429-00111865-00112069": "Stalin Soviet public culture from", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00430-00112070-00112318": "revolution to Cold War princeton", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00431-00112319-00112629": "university press ISBN 978", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00432-00112630-00113133": "o-69 100 4 1 1 2 davies robert", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00433-00113134-00113435": "Wheatcroft stephen 2009 the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00434-00113436-00113697": "industrialization of Soviet Russia vol 5", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00435-00113698-00113936": "the years of hunger Soviet agriculture", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00436-00113937-00114191": "1931 to 1933", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00437-00114192-00114585": "Palgrave Macmillan UK ISBN nine seven", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00438-00114586-00114808": "eight oh two three oh two seven three", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00439-00114808-00114933": "nine seven nine", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00440-00114933-00115333": "Elmen michael November 2002 Soviet", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00441-00115333-00115546": "repression statistics some comments", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00442-00115547-00115851": "Europe Asia studies fifty four seven", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00443-00115852-00116281": "eleven fifty one to 1172 joy ten point", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00444-00116282-00116535": "one zero eight zero oh nine six six", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00445-00116536-00116908": "eight one 302 two oooo one seventy one", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00446-00116908-00117271": "seventy seven era Mina Larissa Regan ski", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00447-00117272-00117552": "arseny Larissa era Mena arseny Regan ski", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00448-00117553-00118002": "2002 rostral nice pisky Moskva 1937 to", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00449-00118003-00118329": "1940 one communica butovo puma", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00450-00118330-00118563": "teaser TV paula disky repressive shot", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00451-00118564-00119001": "lists moscow 1937 to 1940 one comeon", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00452-00119002-00119245": "arca butovo the book for commemoration", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00453-00119246-00119424": "of political repression victims in", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00454-00119425-00119806": "russian moscow memorial ISBN five", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00455-00119807-00119991": "billion seven hundred eighty seven", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00456-00119992-00120256": "million five hundred ninety five Cs one", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00457-00120257-00120525": "mayn't multiple names authors list link", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00458-00120526-00120600": "air amina", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00459-00120601-00120900": "larisa regan ski arseny larisa air amina", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00460-00120901-00121236": "arseny regan ski 2005 rostral nice pisky", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00461-00121237-00121671": "Moskva 1935 to 1953 dance coke lad buys", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00462-00121672-00121938": "Donskoy Crematory Chenega palma teaser", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00463-00121939-00122194": "TV paula disky represses shot lists", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00464-00122195-00122652": "moscow 1935 to 1953 the Donskoy cemetery", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00465-00122653-00122874": "the Donskoy crematorium the book for", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00466-00122875-00123031": "commemoration of political repression", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00467-00123032-00123465": "victims in russian moscow memorial ISBN", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00468-00123466-00123711": "five billion seven hundred eighty seven", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00469-00123712-00123960": "million eight hundred eleven cs1 mayn't", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00470-00123961-00124266": "multiple names authors list link john's", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00471-00124267-00124662": "michael fall 1987 70 years of evil", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00472-00124663-00124886": "soviet crimes from lenin to Gorbachev", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00473-00124887-00125242": "policy review 10 to 23", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00474-00125243-00125596": "George 1981 the Cheka Lenin's political", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00475-00125597-00126007": "police Oxford Clarendon press is B&O one", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00476-00126008-00126308": "nine eight two two eight six two seven", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00477-00126309-00126676": "Medvedev Roy Aleksandrovich 1985 on", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00478-00126677-00126958": "Soviet descent columbia university press", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00479-00126958-00127318": "ISBN nine seven eight oh two three one", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00480-00127319-00127648": "oh four eight one three two rows field", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00481-00127649-00127969": "Steven 2009 red Holocaust", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00482-00127970-00128296": "Taylor & Francis ISBN nine seven eight", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00483-00128297-00128581": "oh four one five seven seven seven five", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00484-00128582-00129043": "seven five Sam Eden Marie 1980 droits de", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00485-00129044-00129253": "l'homme at repression and you are SS", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00486-00129254-00129534": "lapper l at les victims human rights and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00487-00129535-00129781": "repression in the USSR mechanism and", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00488-00129782-00130174": "victims in French Paris SOI ISBN two", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00489-00130175-00130381": "billion twenty million fifty seven", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00490-00130382-00130686": "thousand fifty sure David are two", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00491-00130688-00130978": "thousand nine policing Stalin socialism", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00492-00130979-00131170": "repression and social order in the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00493-00131171-00131590": "Soviet Union 1924 to 1953 yale", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00494-00131591-00131980": "university press ISBN 978 Oh three", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00495-00131981-00132246": "hundred one four nine two five eight", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00496-00132247-00132688": "Solomon Peter H 1996 Soviet Criminal", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00497-00132689-00132886": "Justice under Stalin cambridge", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00498-00132887-00133198": "university press ISBN nine seven eight", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00499-00133199-00133507": "oh five two one five six four five one", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00500-00133508-00133921": "nine win Trobe ronald 2000 the political", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00501-00133922-00134143": "economy of dictatorship cambridge", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00502-00134144-00134458": "university press ISBN nine seven eight", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00503-00134459-00134749": "oh five two one seven nine four four", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00504-00134750-00135142": "nine seven alexandra pod rabbinic 2015", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00505-00135143-00135388": "NASA Campania Zhou amnesty you are", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00506-00135389-00135670": "campaign for amnesty savez de in Russian", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00507-00135671-00135988": "for retrieved the 2nd of September 2015", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00508-00135989-00136276": "Jean bossa nova Albina Albina zen bossa", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00509-00136277-00136564": "nova 2013 paulo disky repressive", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00510-00136565-00136960": "assessor 1920 to 1950 GG i story KO", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00511-00136961-00137197": "statistic s KO ISIL Devaney political", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00512-00137198-00137560": "repression in the USSR 1920 to 1950 s", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00513-00137561-00137892": "historical and statistical research PDF", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00514-00137893-00138268": "european researcher in russian 45 4 2 1", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00515-00138269-00138571": "811 to 822", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00516-00138572-00138853": "archived PDF from the original on the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00517-00138854-00139077": "15th of November 2015", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00518-00139078-00139369": "political repressions in the USSR the", "TuR7QkowsEQ-00519-00139370-00139852": "Andrei Sakharov museum and public center"}}, {"audio_id": "TuZLdgsnGJI", "text": {"TuZLdgsnGJI-00000-00000008-00000206": "good evening ladies and gentlemen my", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00001-00000208-00000447": "name is", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00002-00000448-00000599": "randy willards", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00003-00000600-00000935": "and today we're having the interview the", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00004-00000936-00001039": "interview", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00005-00001040-00001247": "with kevin from kevin weir 11. that's", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00006-00001248-00001399": "right ladies and gentlemen kevin we're", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00007-00001400-00001614": "11 coming at you we have an interview", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00008-00001616-00001888": "today and let's get started shall we", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00009-00001889-00003351": "[Music]", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00010-00003352-00003631": "and your first question is", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00011-00003632-00003903": "what inspired you to become a youtuber", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00012-00003904-00004222": "my inspiration came from", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00013-00004223-00004495": "from seeing other people", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00014-00004496-00004591": "uh", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00015-00004592-00004791": "doing it and thinking", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00016-00004792-00004959": "it sounds fun", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00017-00004960-00005143": "it looks fun so", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00018-00005144-00005486": "i did it", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00019-00005487-00005647": "your second question", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00020-00005648-00005847": "what video are you planning to release", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00021-00005848-00005951": "next", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00022-00005952-00006199": "my next video idea is", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00023-00006200-00006406": "this is this one being recorded right", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00024-00006408-00006575": "now hi", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00025-00006576-00006687": "um", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00026-00006688-00006791": "yeah", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00027-00006792-00006887": "that's", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00028-00006888-00007159": "that's my plan is taking footage from", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00029-00007159-00007278": "this", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00030-00007279-00007375": "and", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00031-00007376-00007655": "popping into my youtube channel", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00032-00007656-00007910": "of course you are", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00033-00007911-00008103": "third question", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00034-00008104-00008351": "what was the latest last movie you", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00035-00008352-00008487": "watched", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00036-00008488-00008823": "the last movie i watched was free guy of", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00037-00008824-00009167": "available on youtube and", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00038-00009168-00009478": "other platforms that i forgot", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00039-00009479-00009606": "free guy", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00040-00009607-00009871": "nice good movie", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00041-00009872-00010063": "uh next question", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00042-00010064-00010342": "how many pairs of shoes do you have", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00043-00010343-00010599": "why is that relevant to the", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00044-00010600-00010919": "interview neither do i", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00045-00010920-00011159": "next question", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00046-00011160-00011359": "do you have any equipment", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00047-00011360-00011646": "recommendations for the newcomers", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00048-00011647-00011783": "um", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00049-00011784-00012103": "just a simple phone or", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00050-00012104-00012423": "grandma's computer", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00051-00012424-00012631": "would you marry a celebrity", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00052-00012632-00013030": "it depends on the celebrity", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00053-00013031-00013358": "and how did you grow your channel", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00054-00013359-00013638": "it was the most simplest thing i grew it", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00055-00013640-00013815": "from zero", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00056-00013816-00014151": "all the way up to 100.", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00057-00014152-00014366": "wow that's amazing", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00058-00014368-00014527": "and that", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00059-00014528-00014793": "is our list for today", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00060-00014794-00015783": "[Music]", "TuZLdgsnGJI-00061-00015784-00015991": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "TvjhYpkOzEk", "text": {"TvjhYpkOzEk-00000-00000299-00000559": "hey everybody and welcome to Barnes take", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00001-00000560-00000773": "out my name is Martha Lucy I'm deputy", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00002-00000774-00000970": "director for research interpretation and", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00003-00000971-00001172": "education at the Barnes Foundation and", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00004-00001173-00001352": "I'm excited to talk to you today about", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00005-00001353-00001639": "this work by Omni Matisse called la bono", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00006-00001641-00002005": "de vivre it was painted between 1905 and", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00007-00002005-00002410": "1906 and here it is hanging at the barns", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00008-00002411-00002630": "on the second floor just off of the", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00009-00002631-00003080": "balcony and you can see here that it's", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00010-00003081-00003331": "got a wall to itself which is unusual", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00011-00003332-00003653": "for the barns usually paintings are", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00012-00003654-00003840": "surrounded by lots of different objects", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00013-00003842-00004163": "you can also see here I think you can", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00014-00004164-00004325": "tell that this it's a big painting it's", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00015-00004326-00004697": "about eight by six feet which is which", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00016-00004698-00004927": "is much larger than what Matisse had", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00017-00004928-00005372": "been had been producing the bounnam de", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00018-00005373-00005552": "vivre is one of those watershed", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00019-00005553-00005783": "paintings in the history of art in the", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00020-00005784-00006056": "history of modern European art I should", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00021-00006057-00006304": "say it's one of those paintings that", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00022-00006305-00006683": "kind of changes everything that that the", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00023-00006684-00006863": "other members of the avant garde at the", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00024-00006864-00007189": "time kind of sort of take notice of and", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00025-00007190-00007342": "say like wait a minute", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00026-00007343-00007595": "and and one of the best examples of this", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00027-00007595-00008074": "is when Picasso saw this work it was one", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00028-00008075-00008335": "of the things that prompted him to start", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00029-00008336-00008642": "work on his on his watershed they", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00030-00008643-00008753": "Demoiselles d'Avignon", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00031-00008754-00009283": "at MoMA this work was exhibited at the", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00032-00009284-00009746": "salon des on the condo in 1906 in Paris", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00033-00009747-00009977": "and that was an under Ede exhibition and", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00034-00009978-00010280": "it was the only work that Matisse showed", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00035-00010281-00010606": "that exhibition and this happened about", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00036-00010607-00010942": "six months after the famous exhibition", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00037-00010943-00011348": "in 1905 at the Salon de pomme also in", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00038-00011349-00011627": "Paris where the word fove had been", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00039-00011628-00011899": "coined to describe the kind of beastly", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00040-00011900-00012323": "work of Matisse and his colleagues so it", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00041-00012324-00012506": "was a derogatory term so as you can", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00042-00012507-00012818": "imagine that had happened in 1905 and in", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00043-00012819-00012958": "1906 so", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00044-00012959-00013135": "so there were a lot of there was a lot", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00045-00013136-00013372": "of kind of curiosity about what Matisse", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00046-00013372-00013605": "was gonna do in 1906 at this exhibition", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00047-00013606-00013918": "and as it turned out it was the scandal", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00048-00013919-00014371": "of the 1906 show and so what I want to", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00049-00014372-00014680": "do is you know there's so much to say", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00050-00014681-00015088": "about this work I want to focus on what", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00051-00015088-00015343": "some of the things that bothered the", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00052-00015344-00015533": "critics because it's a good way of", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00053-00015534-00015999": "getting at what Matisse was doing in", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00054-00016000-00016308": "1905 oh six that was so different from", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00055-00016309-00016683": "what had come before him before we get", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00056-00016684-00016931": "into that I want to let you know that", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00057-00016932-00017197": "not everybody hated this painting when", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00058-00017198-00017494": "it was first done you know a lot of", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00059-00017495-00017981": "artists were we're very taken by it", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00060-00017982-00018247": "Gertrude and Leo Stein the great", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00061-00018248-00018508": "American collectors who were living in", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00062-00018509-00018796": "Paris they bought this out of the show", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00063-00018797-00019075": "and they hung it in their apartment at", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00064-00019076-00019519": "27 Rue de Fleurus now the other thing to", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00065-00019520-00019956": "know is that their apartment in Paris", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00066-00019957-00020259": "was the was the first place that barns", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00067-00020260-00020449": "would have really looked closely at", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00068-00020450-00020899": "Matisse he traveled to Paris and saw the", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00069-00020900-00021333": "stein collection in 1912 and in fact his", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00070-00021334-00021633": "first two Matisse purchases were from", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00071-00021634-00021852": "the Stein's", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00072-00021853-00022319": "so what's going on here the the subject", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00073-00022320-00022594": "Matisse is representing here some sort", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00074-00022595-00022936": "of it's it's an earthly paradise or a", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00075-00022937-00023319": "mythic Golden Age sometimes we refer to", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00076-00023320-00023649": "these kinds of subjects as Arcadian and", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00077-00023650-00024037": "the term Arcadia or Arcadian dates back", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00078-00024038-00024436": "to antiquity in Greek mythology Arcadia", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00079-00024437-00024728": "was an earthly paradise inhabited by", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00080-00024729-00025080": "gods and nymphs but more generally", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00081-00025081-00025387": "Arcadia conjures a vision of a lost", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00082-00025388-00025820": "state of innocence a state that is", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00083-00025821-00025944": "irrecoverable", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00084-00025945-00026175": "so what you see here what Matisse is", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00085-00026176-00026390": "giving us here is it's an unspoiled", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00086-00026391-00026699": "landscape there there's no hint of", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00087-00026700-00027079": "modernity in sight it's hard to sort of", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00088-00027080-00027583": "determine what where this where this is", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00089-00027583-00027795": "happening or or when it's kind of", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00090-00027797-00028210": "timeless you see people in harmony with", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00091-00028211-00028440": "nature kind of just lying in the grass", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00092-00028441-00028645": "sort of without a care in the world", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00093-00028645-00028804": "you know looking very comfortable very", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00094-00028805-00029343": "relaxed there's music this figure here", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00095-00029344-00029752": "this sort of shepherd like figure", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00096-00029752-00030090": "playing pipes this Shepherd like figure", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00097-00030091-00030414": "playing the flute and then there are", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00098-00030416-00030685": "kind of these amorous couples all over", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00099-00030686-00030973": "the place so it's it's a painting that", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00100-00030974-00031290": "celebrates sensuality the pleasures of", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00101-00031291-00031693": "the body the freedom in nature it's a", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00102-00031694-00031920": "vision of a time when when pleasures", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00103-00031922-00032182": "were simple and sensual and expressed", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00104-00032183-00032431": "through the body and you can you know", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00105-00032432-00032548": "when you start looking at this you", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00106-00032549-00032749": "realize that many of the senses are", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00107-00032750-00032992": "engaged it's not just vision but it's", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00108-00032993-00033202": "also it's also your sense of hearing", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00109-00033203-00033577": "right the music the sense of touch that", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00110-00033578-00033880": "happens with with this little moment", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00111-00033881-00034306": "over here maybe even smell maybe you", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00112-00034307-00034468": "sort of imagine what a scene like this", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00113-00034469-00034839": "kind of smells like paintings like this", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00114-00034840-00035077": "nudes in the landscape scenes of the", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00115-00035078-00035283": "Golden Age these they had been popular", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00116-00035284-00035499": "during the Renaissance but the the", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00117-00035500-00035799": "subject really picked up steam for", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00118-00035800-00035998": "European painters in the early 20th", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00119-00035999-00036283": "century everybody was kind of producing", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00120-00036284-00036574": "these these these Arcadian these sort of", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00121-00036575-00037048": "pastoral kind of idyllic scenes and it", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00122-00037049-00037320": "was probably a reaction to modernity and", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00123-00037321-00037570": "technology and industrialization you", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00124-00037571-00037812": "know this kind of longing for a time", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00125-00037813-00038254": "that was kind of pre-modern when when", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00126-00038255-00038739": "the body was in harmony with nature and", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00127-00038740-00038901": "it's got all the traditional iconography", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00128-00038902-00039243": "of these scenes the pipe players", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00129-00039244-00039627": "the nudes the dancers our historians", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00130-00039628-00039795": "have done a lot of detective work trying", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00131-00039796-00040167": "to uncover sources for this painting you", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00132-00040168-00040371": "know who was Matisse looking at who were", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00133-00040372-00040584": "the older painters that would have", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00134-00040585-00040941": "inspired something like this and there", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00135-00040942-00041160": "are you know there there are definitely", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00136-00041161-00041469": "quotes from artists like Aang or an", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00137-00041470-00041787": "Titian his co-star Sean Petra so it's", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00138-00041788-00041988": "it's a painting that's traditional and", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00139-00041989-00042144": "subject and that makes all these", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00140-00042145-00042453": "references to classicism but here's", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00141-00042454-00042648": "where it gets really interesting because", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00142-00042649-00042978": "what he does is he gives you this very", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00143-00042979-00043200": "kind of traditional subject with all", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00144-00043201-00043383": "these classical references you know that", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00145-00043384-00043638": "that traditional iconography but then he", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00146-00043639-00043965": "turns everything on its head through his", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00147-00043966-00044184": "use of color and line and space and", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00148-00044185-00044381": "through his representation of the body", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00149-00044382-00044703": "so looking first at space you can see", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00150-00044704-00044895": "that there are these bizarre shifts and", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00151-00044896-00045156": "scale you know when you start to look at", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00152-00045157-00045453": "these different bodies and these", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00153-00045454-00045690": "different kind of passages they don't", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00154-00045691-00045948": "all kind of quite add up to a single", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00155-00045949-00046245": "coherent space this figure should be", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00156-00046246-00046458": "larger it's in the foreground than these", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00157-00046459-00046752": "figures there seems to be a really", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00158-00046753-00047106": "drastic kind of shift back here these", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00159-00047107-00047364": "figures seem sort of too small so that's", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00160-00047365-00047660": "just kind of one thing that unsettled", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00161-00047661-00048033": "critics you will probably not be", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00162-00048034-00048288": "surprised to hear that it was color that", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00163-00048289-00048561": "was Matisse's use of color that was that", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00164-00048562-00048882": "was the most shocking here I mean just", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00165-00048883-00049203": "look at these pad these bright yellows", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00166-00049204-00049548": "and hot oranges and reds and these", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00167-00049549-00049761": "lavenders and greens and they all just", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00168-00049762-00049905": "kind of come together and they're", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00169-00049906-00050184": "they're sort of clashing into each other", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00170-00050185-00050478": "there's no subtle kind of gradation from", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00171-00050479-00050727": "from lavender into green it's just it", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00172-00050728-00050928": "they just bump up right against each", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00173-00050929-00051251": "other and this was not this was this was", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00174-00051252-00051502": "this was not the way that it was done", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00175-00051503-00051948": "traditionally and also just the way that", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00176-00051949-00052232": "you know what is this form here what are", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00177-00052233-00052391": "these colors describing you know these", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00178-00052392-00052453": "colors", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00179-00052454-00052731": "don't belong to specific objects you", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00180-00052732-00052897": "can't look at this and say oh this is", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00181-00052898-00053187": "you know the trunk of a tree you don't", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00182-00053188-00053485": "really know what it is the other", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00183-00053486-00053773": "interesting thing is that is the way", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00184-00053774-00054093": "that Matisse uses color and line", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00185-00054094-00054330": "together here or I should say the way", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00186-00054331-00054685": "that he pulls these things apart what I", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00187-00054686-00054987": "mean is that traditionally color in line", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00188-00054988-00055368": "in western illusionism were used", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00189-00055369-00055776": "together to create the illusion of a", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00190-00055777-00056082": "solid form in space here he's kind of", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00191-00056083-00056335": "pulling these things apart right", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00192-00056336-00056635": "I mean look here at this passage there's", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00193-00056636-00056899": "just this line this color here opens up", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00194-00056900-00057228": "into this line it's it's just very", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00195-00057229-00057567": "really interesting and bizarre and then", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00196-00057569-00057715": "there's so many little details of the", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00197-00057716-00057871": "way that he's using color here look how", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00198-00057872-00058360": "this tree changes colors as the trunk", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00199-00058361-00058788": "goes up another thing to know about the", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00200-00058789-00059067": "color is that you can see that there are", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00201-00059069-00059388": "a lot of yellows but there were even", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00202-00059389-00059722": "more yellows originally Matisse used a", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00203-00059723-00060141": "kind of yellow called cadmium sulfide", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00204-00060141-00060432": "and it produced these really vivid", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00205-00060433-00060816": "yellows and but over time some of the", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00206-00060817-00061000": "area is where he used the cadmium", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00207-00061001-00061401": "sulfide started to degrade and this is", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00208-00061402-00061617": "one of them right up here see how it's", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00209-00061619-00061837": "kind of brownish gray and then also", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00210-00061838-00062088": "underneath these figures and our", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00211-00062089-00062428": "conservation team has has studied this", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00212-00062429-00062722": "in depth and we have taken measures to", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00213-00062723-00063054": "make sure that the the degradation kind", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00214-00063055-00063478": "of arrests where it is but the point is", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00215-00063479-00063717": "that just imagine originally this thing", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00216-00063718-00063996": "would have been even brighter", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00217-00063997-00064299": "bright bright yellows you know no kind", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00218-00064300-00064528": "of areas where you your eyes sort of", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00219-00064529-00064713": "gets to rest from color the way that it", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00220-00064714-00064818": "does now", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00221-00064819-00065055": "now the bodies were another thing that", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00222-00065056-00065296": "critics pointed to critics", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00223-00065297-00065440": "said you know the scale doesn't make", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00224-00065441-00065596": "sense I don't understand what's supposed", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00225-00065597-00065751": "to be going on in this painting its", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00226-00065752-00065987": "incoherent it doesn't hang together and", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00227-00065988-00066484": "what's with these figures a figure like", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00228-00066485-00066790": "this was simply too androgynous for", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00229-00066791-00067200": "critics in 1906 you know it's it's it", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00230-00067201-00067324": "looks like it's supposed to be a male", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00231-00067325-00067528": "Shepard but it's also kind of curvy and", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00232-00067529-00067792": "this was upsetting this figure here what", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00233-00067793-00068035": "is this pose the critics said these", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00234-00068036-00068329": "bodies look kind of just sort of emptied", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00235-00068330-00068647": "out and then over here you know this", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00236-00068648-00069069": "figures this woman's head and this male", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00237-00069070-00069217": "figures head look like they're kind of", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00238-00069218-00069381": "melding together so are these there are", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00239-00069382-00069650": "these kind of strange anatomical", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00240-00069651-00069861": "distortions and I think that one of the", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00241-00069862-00070105": "most interesting things to think about", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00242-00070106-00070236": "when you're looking at this painting", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00243-00070237-00070542": "again is the way that Matisse gives you", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00244-00070543-00070863": "he kind of hooks you with these pieces", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00245-00070864-00071128": "of tradition you know these these these", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00246-00071129-00071323": "bits of sort of iconography that are", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00247-00071324-00071493": "recognizable like oh yeah this is a", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00248-00071494-00071734": "pastoral this isn't an Arcadian painting", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00249-00071735-00072160": "but then he he just kind of he just kind", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00250-00072161-00072421": "of pulls the rug out from under you and", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00251-00072422-00072861": "and kind of denies all of the the other", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00252-00072862-00073029": "elements that that traditionally go", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00253-00073030-00073471": "along with that subject so it's a really", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00254-00073472-00073903": "complicated painting it is a it is", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00255-00073904-00074288": "lyrical it is big and airy and beautiful", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00256-00074289-00074706": "and there's so much to look at please", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00257-00074707-00075040": "come look at it when we reopen on July", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00258-00075041-00075276": "25th just stand in front of it and sort", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00259-00075277-00075681": "of get lost in it and remember how", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00260-00075682-00076143": "upsetting it was to audiences in 1906", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00261-00076144-00076569": "thank you I'm Tom Collins Neubauer", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00262-00076570-00076761": "family executive director of the Barnes", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00263-00076762-00076980": "Foundation I hope you enjoyed Barnes", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00264-00076981-00077274": "take out subscribe and make sure your", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00265-00077275-00077503": "post notifications are on to get daily", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00266-00077504-00077775": "servings of art thanks for watching and", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00267-00077776-00077935": "for your support of the Barnes", "TvjhYpkOzEk-00268-00077936-00078150": "Foundation"}}, {"audio_id": "TvJr0dM9Rny", "text": {"TvJr0dM9Rny-00000-00000032-00000206": "all right well good morning everybody", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00001-00000208-00000407": "and happy patient safety awareness week", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00002-00000408-00000615": "i am really pleased to be the moderator", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00003-00000616-00000734": "for today's webinar", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00004-00000735-00000902": "um my name is sarah miller i am our", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00005-00000903-00001070": "director of partnerships here", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00006-00001071-00001207": "at the patient safety movement", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00007-00001208-00001454": "foundation and today's webinar will be", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00008-00001455-00001639": "family caregivers caring for yourself", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00009-00001639-00001839": "and your loved ones", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00010-00001839-00001998": "so before we get started i'm going to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00011-00002000-00002191": "walk through a quick agenda and we will", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00012-00002192-00002399": "start by introducing our lovely", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00013-00002400-00002615": "panelists for today's discussion", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00014-00002616-00002831": "um spend a few minutes defining what a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00015-00002832-00003031": "family caregiver is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00016-00003032-00003215": "and then you know a great discussion", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00017-00003215-00003375": "talking about the different experiences", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00018-00003376-00003583": "that our panelists have had and then", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00019-00003584-00003751": "at the very end we will have a question", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00020-00003752-00003943": "and answer session and for those of you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00021-00003944-00004095": "that have joined today", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00022-00004096-00004327": "you will be unable to share your video", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00023-00004328-00004535": "and or unmute yourself so if at any", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00024-00004536-00004719": "point during the presentation you have a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00025-00004720-00004911": "question for one of our panelists", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00026-00004912-00005143": "there is a q a submission at the bottom", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00027-00005144-00005247": "of your zoom", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00028-00005248-00005447": "and we would really encourage you all to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00029-00005448-00005679": "um communicate via the chat if you guys", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00030-00005680-00005847": "want to talk to your fellow", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00031-00005848-00006222": "attendees as well", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00032-00006223-00006470": "so moving on to the objectives um i will", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00033-00006472-00006639": "quickly go through these before i pass", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00034-00006640-00006783": "it off to our", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00035-00006784-00006991": "panel moderator and the first one is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00036-00006992-00007191": "differentiating family caregiver from", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00037-00007192-00007383": "other members of healthcare team", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00038-00007384-00007591": "the second is discussing the benefits", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00039-00007592-00007855": "experiences and challenges of caregiving", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00040-00007856-00008006": "understand the signs of stress and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00041-00008008-00008199": "burnout and how it impacts overall", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00042-00008200-00008287": "health", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00043-00008288-00008487": "recognizing the psychological changes", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00044-00008488-00008687": "that transpire when one is no longer a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00045-00008688-00008887": "caregiver and finally identifying", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00046-00008888-00009046": "actions that caregivers can take to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00047-00009047-00009183": "remain healthy", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00048-00009184-00009399": "so with that said i'm happy to pass it", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00049-00009400-00009574": "over to carol humbergaard our moderator", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00050-00009575-00009823": "for today's webinar", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00051-00009824-00010135": "good morning everyone we are very happy", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00052-00010136-00010206": "to hear you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00053-00010207-00010591": "have you here today my name is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00054-00010592-00010783": "and i am going to be monitoring the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00055-00010784-00010903": "panel and i am", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00056-00010904-00011231": "a patient advocate um i'm going to start", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00057-00011232-00011463": "and want all the panelists to introduce", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00058-00011464-00011551": "themselves so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00059-00011552-00011814": "um teresa if you will introduce yourself", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00060-00011815-00011951": "please", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00061-00011952-00012270": "hi my name is teresa gentry and i have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00062-00012271-00012527": "been a caregiver for both of my parents", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00063-00012528-00012791": "and for my husband for the late last", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00064-00012792-00012871": "eight years", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00065-00012872-00013158": "after he suffered suffered a spinal cord", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00066-00013159-00013351": "injury", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00067-00013352-00013638": "thank you teresa alyssa will you please", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00068-00013640-00013815": "introduce yourself", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00069-00013816-00014030": "thank you carol my name is alyssa kavan", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00070-00014031-00014271": "i'm based in san jose california", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00071-00014272-00014486": "and i've had experiences in caregiving", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00072-00014487-00014583": "for my mother", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00073-00014584-00014894": "my younger brother as well as my father", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00074-00014895-00015199": "she recovered from a stroke as well", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00075-00015200-00015447": "thank you alyssa and stephen will you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00076-00015447-00015630": "please introduce yourselves", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00077-00015631-00016079": "good morning steven coffey i am a uh", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00078-00016080-00016279": "caregiver for my son stevens who had a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00079-00016280-00016391": "libertarian friend", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00080-00016392-00016943": "and they're very age of eight weeks old", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00081-00016944-00017294": "thank you stephen", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00082-00017295-00017447": "sarah if you'll go to the next slide", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00083-00017448-00017958": "please", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00084-00017959-00018255": "so i want to open this up today sort of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00085-00018256-00018422": "trying to frame", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00086-00018423-00018750": "what is a caregiver and that's a very", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00087-00018751-00019007": "difficult thing to actually address", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00088-00019008-00019214": "because caregivers come in all shapes", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00089-00019215-00019358": "and sizes", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00090-00019359-00019663": "they can be a spouse", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00091-00019664-00019983": "a partner they can be a child", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00092-00019984-00020367": "a parent a grandparent relatives", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00093-00020368-00020694": "friends and sometimes even pay", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00094-00020695-00020935": "for the services of a caregiver and it", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00095-00020936-00021263": "may be also a combination of those", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00096-00021264-00021519": "there is no time frame for a caregiver", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00097-00021520-00021583": "either", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00098-00021584-00021871": "you can be a caregiver for a couple days", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00099-00021872-00021943": "weeks", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00100-00021944-00022399": "months years and even a lifetime", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00101-00022400-00022558": "and the other thing is the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00102-00022559-00022791": "responsibility of a caregiver", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00103-00022792-00022999": "some caregivers may be there just to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00104-00023000-00023158": "make sure their loved one gets their", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00105-00023159-00023350": "meals their medications", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00106-00023351-00023783": "they're safe and it ranges the spectrum", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00107-00023784-00024063": "where some people have to do everything", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00108-00024064-00024430": "for their loved one to care for them", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00109-00024431-00024758": "caregivers it can be an amazingly", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00110-00024759-00024903": "gratifying job", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00111-00024904-00025263": "it can be an exhausting job", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00112-00025264-00025599": "and it's also also a humbling job", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00113-00025600-00025983": "to do we have the great fortune today", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00114-00025983-00026311": "with teresa stephen and alyssa to have a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00115-00026312-00026399": "combination", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00116-00026400-00026614": "of all of those things that i just", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00117-00026616-00026831": "talked about", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00118-00026832-00027062": "but before we move on to the panel i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00119-00027063-00027199": "want you to realize", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00120-00027200-00027527": "that caregivers have sort of rights of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00121-00027527-00027599": "their own", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00122-00027600-00027839": "and that is why we have on the screen", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00123-00027839-00028014": "here today is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00124-00028016-00028190": "you know caregivers have to take care of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00125-00028191-00028358": "themselves as well", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00126-00028360-00028702": "and oftentimes they get lost in", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00127-00028704-00028935": "um the mire of taking care of their", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00128-00028936-00029039": "loved ones", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00129-00029039-00029214": "and that's why we're really here today", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00130-00029216-00029423": "is to be very frank about what are some", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00131-00029424-00029662": "of the things caregivers go through", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00132-00029663-00029911": "how do they take care of themselves and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00133-00029912-00030007": "what are some of those", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00134-00030008-00030351": "highs and lows of caregiving", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00135-00030352-00030646": "so i'm going to start and open up the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00136-00030647-00030783": "panel", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00137-00030783-00030967": "and one of the first questions i'm going", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00138-00030968-00031118": "to ask our panelists", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00139-00031119-00031495": "is how do they get into caregiving", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00140-00031495-00031751": "and you know what is sort of their role", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00141-00031752-00031902": "in the caregiving do they", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00142-00031903-00032118": "do it all the time are there certain", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00143-00032119-00032311": "things do they have assistance", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00144-00032312-00032679": "so it will just start to frame our panel", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00145-00032680-00032935": "so i'm going to open it up and let's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00146-00032936-00033167": "start with stephen stephen can you tell", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00147-00033168-00033199": "us", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00148-00033200-00033487": "a little bit about you know your role as", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00149-00033488-00033590": "the caregiver and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00150-00033591-00033911": "how you view yourself in that role yeah", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00151-00033912-00034135": "thank you so much so much you know i'll", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00152-00034136-00034271": "tell you i'll tell you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00153-00034272-00034583": "this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00154-00034584-00034807": "was going to be what life would be this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00155-00034808-00034927": "was not something i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00156-00034928-00035287": "ever thought was going to be what life", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00157-00035288-00035455": "would be for me as a brand new parent as", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00158-00035456-00035607": "an electronically old child changed my", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00159-00035608-00035655": "life", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00160-00035656-00035902": "you know and i thought my role you know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00161-00035903-00036102": "as a new father was going to be", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00162-00036103-00036383": "teach your son how to be a respectful", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00163-00036384-00036455": "young man", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00164-00036456-00036759": "teach him how to do those those", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00165-00036760-00036895": "things that would make him a good", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00166-00036896-00037095": "citizen but when he had his liver", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00167-00037096-00037174": "transplant", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00168-00037175-00037551": "at eight weeks old what i found myself", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00169-00037552-00037911": "being thrust into was this role of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00170-00037912-00038118": "not only just teaching him life skills", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00171-00038119-00038327": "in terms of manners and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00172-00038328-00038535": "work ethic but i also have now teach him", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00173-00038536-00038646": "about medical", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00174-00038647-00038799": "life skills and that's something that i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00175-00038800-00038974": "had to learn also um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00176-00038975-00039111": "because i'm not from a medical", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00177-00039112-00039295": "background you know i i'm a military", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00178-00039296-00039399": "officer and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00179-00039400-00039590": "i've been been in the military for over", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00180-00039591-00039743": "20 years now and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00181-00039744-00040023": "learning about this new language of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00182-00040024-00040183": "medicine learning about", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00183-00040184-00040399": "this new culture of medicine learning", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00184-00040400-00040599": "about what it means to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00185-00040600-00040958": "have my son be okay with uh", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00186-00040959-00041183": "his his conditions with having had a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00187-00041184-00041295": "liver transplant", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00188-00041296-00041415": "you know it's interesting when i think", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00189-00041416-00041607": "about taking him out to the pool in the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00190-00041608-00041695": "summertime", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00191-00041696-00042023": "pre-covered you know he gets", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00192-00042024-00042239": "self-conscious about wearing about not", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00193-00042240-00042367": "wearing a shirt", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00194-00042368-00042558": "in the swimming pool because he has a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00195-00042559-00042799": "scar so not only did i find myself of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00196-00042800-00042958": "teaching him those kind of life skills", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00197-00042959-00043055": "those basic", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00198-00043056-00043207": "skills of being kind of being", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00199-00043208-00043430": "responsible but now i find", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00200-00043431-00043655": "myself in caring for him to teach him", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00201-00043656-00043758": "other skills that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00202-00043759-00043895": "i didn't think i'd have to about", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00203-00043896-00044015": "learning how to navigate his own", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00204-00044016-00044102": "healthcare", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00205-00044103-00044318": "and that's a new place for me uh it's a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00206-00044319-00044455": "new place for my family", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00207-00044456-00044687": "and so it's changed me it really changed", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00208-00044688-00044943": "me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00209-00044944-00045183": "alyssa tell us a little bit about how", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00210-00045184-00045302": "you got into this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00211-00045303-00045615": "and how you see your role sure", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00212-00045616-00045911": "so my mother was diagnosed with breast", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00213-00045912-00046015": "cancer when i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00214-00046016-00046327": "was um just finishing high school so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00215-00046328-00046527": "going into college um i knew she would", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00216-00046528-00046599": "be going through", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00217-00046600-00046790": "treatment she wanted me to still", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00218-00046791-00046902": "continue um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00219-00046903-00047118": "in pursuing my education so i did go off", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00220-00047119-00047215": "to college", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00221-00047216-00047439": "which was about 300 miles away from", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00222-00047440-00047574": "where we lived", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00223-00047575-00047758": "and when i came back that following", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00224-00047759-00048007": "summer her disease had progressed so i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00225-00048008-00048062": "did", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00226-00048063-00048327": "become involved with being a caregiver", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00227-00048328-00048455": "for her during", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00228-00048456-00048662": "that summer period before i went back to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00229-00048663-00048815": "school again", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00230-00048816-00049023": "and that she was very independent for", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00231-00049024-00049143": "quite some time", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00232-00049144-00049311": "she had a lot of pride in wanting to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00233-00049312-00049502": "continue going to work through treatment", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00234-00049503-00049807": "but as the radiation and chemotherapy", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00235-00049808-00049958": "combination treatments", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00236-00049959-00050286": "became really rigorous she did become", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00237-00050287-00050607": "eventually disabled from her legs below", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00238-00050608-00050671": "so that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00239-00050672-00050951": "did elevate her care to um you know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00240-00050952-00051023": "level of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00241-00051024-00051254": "a wheelchair my younger brother and i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00242-00051255-00051407": "would use a hoyer lift which was a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00243-00051408-00051614": "device i had never heard of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00244-00051615-00051830": "and you you become really involved as", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00245-00051832-00052023": "care when there's disability at that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00246-00052024-00052079": "point", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00247-00052079-00052270": "similarly my younger brother was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00248-00052271-00052414": "diagnosed with", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00249-00052415-00052863": "wilms tumor pediatric cancer in 2014", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00250-00052864-00053207": "i believe yes and i um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00251-00053208-00053526": "after i graduated college i um did", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00252-00053527-00053823": "have a job and i i did uh quit my job to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00253-00053824-00053942": "become a caregiver", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00254-00053944-00054182": "um with my father for my younger brother", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00255-00054183-00054535": "um that scenario was different it was um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00256-00054536-00054838": "he was capable to some degree but um we", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00257-00054839-00054982": "we were caregiving for him", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00258-00054983-00055223": "um until the end of life at that point", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00259-00055224-00055326": "um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00260-00055327-00055550": "last part of my caregiver story would be", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00261-00055551-00055654": "for my father", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00262-00055655-00055903": "a few years ago as he had a second", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00263-00055904-00055966": "stroke", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00264-00055967-00056230": "um so that was more of a family team", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00265-00056232-00056319": "effort", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00266-00056320-00056630": "with other people as well um and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00267-00056632-00056950": "that is my story thank you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00268-00056951-00057423": "and teresa will round it out with you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00269-00057424-00057671": "so i'm and listening to the other", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00270-00057672-00057775": "panelists i think", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00271-00057776-00058079": "one of the things i think of how i feel", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00272-00058079-00058335": "is sometimes i'm paving the way", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00273-00058336-00058663": "um i'm my background is i'm a nurse so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00274-00058664-00058879": "in my family with my other siblings with", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00275-00058879-00059142": "my parents i was always looked at as", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00276-00059144-00059407": "the caregiver or who would make a lot of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00277-00059408-00059494": "the health", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00278-00059495-00059694": "and medical decisions and get things", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00279-00059695-00059830": "organized", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00280-00059832-00060126": "and with my husband it was the same as a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00281-00060127-00060294": "nurse he looked to me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00282-00060295-00060511": "to kind of figure out what all the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00283-00060512-00060654": "medical jargon meant", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00284-00060655-00060838": "and make sure the right things were", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00285-00060839-00061047": "happening so we still", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00286-00061048-00061311": "do that to this day so i think there's a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00287-00061312-00061399": "place", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00288-00061400-00061726": "as elissa said where you find where do", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00289-00061727-00061806": "you fit in", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00290-00061807-00061991": "in the family if you have other people", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00291-00061991-00062175": "to help um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00292-00062176-00062406": "what is your role and then with your", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00293-00062407-00062535": "spouse", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00294-00062536-00062766": "because that's the person that you're", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00295-00062767-00062911": "with all the time", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00296-00062912-00063071": "you are the main person and it does", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00297-00063072-00063375": "become a lot of a shared", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00298-00063376-00063687": "um caregiving i guess shared decision", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00299-00063688-00063799": "making", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00300-00063800-00064175": "which is interesting because you're", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00301-00064176-00064511": "trying to teach that person as well as", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00302-00064512-00064599": "you're trying to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00303-00064600-00064823": "hope that you are making the right", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00304-00064824-00064942": "decisions", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00305-00064944-00065326": "and there is a lot of pressure i think", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00306-00065327-00065623": "in figuring out who's the right person", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00307-00065624-00065743": "what's the right thing", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00308-00065744-00066063": "who do i talk to who else do i ask do i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00309-00066064-00066094": "let", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00310-00066095-00066311": "this person make the decision do i kind", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00311-00066312-00066399": "of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00312-00066400-00066694": "weigh in on the decision and it was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00313-00066695-00066838": "interesting watching", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00314-00066839-00067159": "other health care providers and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00315-00067160-00067438": "how they when they found out i was a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00316-00067439-00067567": "nurse", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00317-00067568-00067887": "immediately would start to look to me to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00318-00067888-00068079": "give me the information because they", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00319-00068080-00068215": "were more comfortable", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00320-00068216-00068582": "speaking my language and i would have to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00321-00068583-00068782": "get near the person they were supposed", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00322-00068783-00068943": "to be speaking to so they would look at", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00323-00068944-00069094": "them but also", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00324-00069095-00069326": "i wanted them to decipher the language", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00325-00069327-00069431": "because i'm not", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00326-00069432-00069703": "just the nurse i am the wife the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00327-00069704-00069806": "daughter", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00328-00069807-00070135": "and so there's a there's a lot of roles", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00329-00070136-00070319": "in there but i felt like", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00330-00070320-00070606": "paving or going down the center and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00331-00070607-00070782": "trying to figure things out was one of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00332-00070783-00071031": "those roles", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00333-00071032-00071231": "so i want to stay on that theme that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00334-00071232-00071462": "teresa just introduced and that is sort", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00335-00071463-00071494": "of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00336-00071495-00071799": "that decision making so you know teresa", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00337-00071800-00072006": "was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00338-00072007-00072391": "based on a spouse and for her parents", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00339-00072392-00072638": "but elissa it had to be different for", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00340-00072639-00072726": "you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00341-00072727-00073126": "because here you are the sister", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00342-00073127-00073382": "and the daughter and talk a little bit", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00343-00073383-00073462": "like did you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00344-00073463-00073750": "feel you had power didn't have power how", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00345-00073751-00073815": "did you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00346-00073816-00074111": "what was that experience like for you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00347-00074112-00074182": "yes it was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00348-00074183-00074462": "unique in both scenarios um you know i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00349-00074463-00074615": "think it's fantastic teresa had", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00350-00074616-00074838": "a medical background i unfortunately do", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00351-00074839-00075047": "not or did not at that point", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00352-00075048-00075247": "i like to think that i've had some", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00353-00075248-00075399": "experience in that now", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00354-00075400-00075662": "but um with my mother um she was able to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00355-00075663-00075855": "make a lot of her decisions herself", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00356-00075856-00076167": "um and maybe you know it was also just", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00357-00076168-00076326": "communicating to others", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00358-00076327-00076662": "uh that at points although i was quite", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00359-00076663-00076719": "young", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00360-00076720-00076911": "you know i think it was just showing", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00361-00076912-00077143": "that my father is not here maybe at this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00362-00077144-00077199": "moment", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00363-00077200-00077375": "and i'm the one speaking on behalf of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00364-00077376-00077647": "her and trying to find that confidence", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00365-00077648-00077982": "and communication style with whatever", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00366-00077983-00078126": "member of the health care team i was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00367-00078127-00078319": "communicating with that was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00368-00078320-00078615": "really made me very nervous so i think", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00369-00078616-00078655": "that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00370-00078656-00078831": "was the experience with my mother with", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00371-00078832-00079094": "my brother um he was diagnosed", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00372-00079095-00079447": "right um after he turned 18. so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00373-00079448-00079655": "the i think the experience my father and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00374-00079656-00079782": "i had was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00375-00079783-00080071": "he may be of age technically but he", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00376-00080072-00080215": "still was having a hard time", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00377-00080216-00080591": "making those big decisions for his care", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00378-00080592-00080799": "and my father was really the one that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00379-00080800-00080911": "spearheaded", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00380-00080912-00081182": "you know doing research and deciding the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00381-00081183-00081311": "best path for his care", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00382-00081312-00081543": "explaining it to my brother and myself", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00383-00081544-00081638": "and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00384-00081639-00081838": "you know us as a family coming together", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00385-00081839-00082206": "to make the right decisions for him", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00386-00082207-00082406": "and stephen i'm going to ask the same", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00387-00082407-00082526": "question to you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00388-00082527-00082831": "you know here you are brand new", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00389-00082832-00083191": "father um just early into your marriage", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00390-00083192-00083494": "as well to your wife what was that like", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00391-00083495-00083806": "for you you know that is a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00392-00083807-00084326": "very interesting question that is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00393-00084327-00084535": "i was so surprised you know and in the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00394-00084536-00084791": "military i'm very used to being able to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00395-00084792-00085150": "control things and i recall when when", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00396-00085151-00085367": "my wife had we had our baby i went back", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00397-00085368-00085471": "to my office", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00398-00085472-00085735": "and the reason i went back is because i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00399-00085736-00085862": "sat there in my chair and everyone's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00400-00085863-00086031": "like hey why are you here", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00401-00086032-00086262": "because i knew i could control what i do", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00402-00086263-00086359": "at work", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00403-00086360-00086615": "but i couldn't control being a dad that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00404-00086616-00086831": "was such a new thing for me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00405-00086832-00087023": "and what i found after he had his", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00406-00087024-00087271": "transplant was that i had to learn how", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00407-00087272-00087343": "to become", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00408-00087344-00087606": "comfortable in the middle of chaos and i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00409-00087607-00087655": "had to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00410-00087656-00087894": "become very comfortable living in this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00411-00087895-00088023": "gray area", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00412-00088024-00088287": "knowing that this normal that we have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00413-00088288-00088399": "not a new normal this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00414-00088400-00088743": "normal that is for us was okay", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00415-00088744-00088935": "and so you know i go back to one of the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00416-00088936-00089135": "things that teresa had pointed out of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00417-00089136-00089367": "how you had the engagement between", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00418-00089368-00089615": "providers and us as patients and how", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00419-00089616-00089806": "they sometimes didn't want to talk to me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00420-00089807-00090135": "because i'm the dad and in actuality", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00421-00090136-00090311": "what we forced him to do is to talk to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00422-00090312-00090543": "both of us because it's a shared", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00423-00090544-00090694": "uh it's a partnership it's a partnership", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00424-00090695-00090871": "in raising your child but it's also a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00425-00090872-00090950": "partnership", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00426-00090951-00091223": "in how we do decision making for medical", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00427-00091224-00091271": "care", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00428-00091272-00091462": "and so that was one of those big things", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00429-00091463-00091623": "that i really had to get comfortable", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00430-00091624-00091671": "with is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00431-00091672-00091799": "how do you get comfortable in the midst", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00432-00091800-00091975": "of chaos how to get comfortable", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00433-00091976-00092175": "when you're out of your comfort zone", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00434-00092176-00092526": "because this is now my reality", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00435-00092527-00092750": "right and and i'm glad you brought that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00436-00092751-00092918": "up stephen um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00437-00092919-00093199": "because when my daughter was sick and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00438-00093200-00093350": "they knew i had some healthcare", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00439-00093351-00093455": "background", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00440-00093456-00093679": "they would always wait to talk to me and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00441-00093680-00093847": "not my husband and it was very", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00442-00093848-00093999": "frustrating to him because", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00443-00094000-00094271": "he's like i am part of this too and when", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00444-00094272-00094311": "i'm", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00445-00094312-00094559": "here with our daughter i need to be", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00446-00094560-00094774": "receiving the same information", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00447-00094775-00095079": "so i think sometimes that bias of well", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00448-00095080-00095159": "you know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00449-00095160-00095487": "the mom the wife whatever is the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00450-00095488-00095631": "one that's going to be doing a lot of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00451-00095632-00095871": "the caregiving we have to dispel", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00452-00095872-00096182": "that and it has to be talking to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00453-00096183-00096415": "who's ever there in the room at that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00454-00096416-00096671": "time because that may be the caregiver", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00455-00096672-00096974": "for the moment absolutely", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00456-00096975-00097182": "so one of the other questions and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00457-00097183-00097367": "stephen we'll we'll start with you with", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00458-00097368-00097447": "this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00459-00097448-00097647": "suddenly you're thrown into being a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00460-00097648-00097894": "caregiver you know sometimes it evolves", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00461-00097895-00098006": "slowly over time", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00462-00098007-00098335": "sometimes it's within 24 hours", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00463-00098336-00098623": "how did you manage trying to figure out", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00464-00098624-00098711": "all of this stuff", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00465-00098712-00098982": "you talk about it in the midst of chaos", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00466-00098983-00099150": "and then suddenly you realize you have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00467-00099151-00099311": "to exit the cocoon", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00468-00099312-00099471": "so in other words you know you get", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00469-00099472-00099631": "locked in this mindset", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00470-00099632-00099847": "i've got to carry i gotta care and then", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00471-00099848-00100079": "you're like but i gotta pay the bills", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00472-00100080-00100255": "i gotta make sure if there's other", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00473-00100256-00100431": "family members at home or", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00474-00100432-00100662": "you know i can't just be locked in the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00475-00100663-00100735": "hospital", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00476-00100736-00100999": "i have to engage in the world again so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00477-00101000-00101247": "tell us a little bit about that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00478-00101248-00101511": "you know one of the things that um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00479-00101512-00101662": "happens when you have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00480-00101663-00101991": "a major event like caring for a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00481-00101992-00102150": "chronically ill patient", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00482-00102151-00102350": "or any family member rather or anything", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00483-00102351-00102558": "like that it causes you to focus", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00484-00102559-00102871": "on that thing right and so what i found", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00485-00102872-00102927": "myself", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00486-00102928-00103166": "and my wife focusing on was his care", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00487-00103167-00103318": "certainly when he was so young", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00488-00103319-00103502": "i mean you think about it the medical", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00489-00103503-00103751": "miracle and the science and the skill of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00490-00103752-00103878": "those doctors", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00491-00103879-00104094": "and clinicians to take a seven-year-old", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00492-00104095-00104318": "liver and put it in a two-month-old body", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00493-00104319-00104518": "and he's now eight years old so he's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00494-00104519-00104686": "doing fantastically well because of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00495-00104688-00104830": "continuity of care and because of the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00496-00104831-00104919": "partnership", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00497-00104920-00105175": "that we have with his providers but one", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00498-00105176-00105343": "of the things that my wife and i did is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00499-00105344-00105495": "we were focused so much on him that we", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00500-00105496-00105654": "didn't get a chance to focus on other", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00501-00105655-00105734": "things", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00502-00105735-00105975": "and so i want to address it in two ways", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00503-00105976-00106095": "one how did i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00504-00106096-00106366": "start to focus on things that were not", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00505-00106367-00106439": "about him", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00506-00106440-00106710": "is one i had to realize that the world", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00507-00106711-00106766": "is still", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00508-00106767-00107047": "moving and revolving and turning even", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00509-00107048-00107102": "when", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00510-00107103-00107310": "we're in the hospital and i have to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00511-00107311-00107486": "still be a part of that world", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00512-00107488-00107734": "so one was realizing that and making a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00513-00107735-00107886": "conscious decision", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00514-00107888-00108175": "to still be engaged i remember when i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00515-00108176-00108278": "was uh", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00516-00108279-00108599": "it was a few years ago i missed a major", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00517-00108600-00108775": "milestone birthday", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00518-00108776-00109086": "because i was so focused on my son", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00519-00109088-00109254": "and i think it was a year or so later", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00520-00109255-00109383": "had friends who said hey man you didn't", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00521-00109383-00109590": "do anything for this big milestone", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00522-00109591-00109807": "why and i had to think and step back and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00523-00109808-00109927": "say you know what", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00524-00109928-00110175": "i can't let my life stop because i have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00525-00110176-00110286": "to care for my son", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00526-00110288-00110543": "it is a part of my life it is not my all", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00527-00110544-00110734": "my life it doesn't consume all of me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00528-00110735-00110847": "and then the second part of that is i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00529-00110848-00111031": "look about the relationship and as you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00530-00111032-00111231": "mentioned earlier my wife and i were", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00531-00111232-00111423": "newlyweds we celebrated our first", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00532-00111424-00111543": "wedding anniversary", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00533-00111544-00111831": "in the hospital and so you think about", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00534-00111832-00111927": "how", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00535-00111928-00112134": "challenges and adversities can draw you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00536-00112135-00112399": "closer but in actuality there's also a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00537-00112400-00112543": "part where it could draw you apart", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00538-00112544-00112734": "because you're focused on", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00539-00112735-00112927": "the issues and the challenges and you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00540-00112928-00113086": "don't get enough time to focus on each", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00541-00113088-00113134": "other", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00542-00113135-00113390": "so my wife and i had to reconnect when", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00543-00113391-00113575": "stephen got to a place where his health", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00544-00113576-00113623": "was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00545-00113624-00113863": "on a good glide path up that we had to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00546-00113864-00114015": "reconnect as a family", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00547-00114016-00114166": "so that we could not only be strong for", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00548-00114167-00114295": "each other but that we could be strong", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00549-00114296-00114631": "for him", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00550-00114632-00114883": "teresa i'm going to ask you that same", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00551-00114883-00115031": "question", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00552-00115032-00115302": "so i found exactly what you said carol", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00553-00115303-00115486": "that and steve that when you're", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00554-00115488-00115831": "in the hospital and the crisis is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00555-00115832-00115886": "happening", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00556-00115888-00116095": "you're very involved there you're very", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00557-00116096-00116190": "focused there", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00558-00116191-00116447": "and you basically have to just keep", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00559-00116448-00116607": "putting one foot in front of the other", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00560-00116608-00116686": "because there's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00561-00116688-00117023": "so much new is what i would say so much", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00562-00117024-00117119": "new happening", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00563-00117120-00117366": "so much happening fast and so much of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00564-00117367-00117510": "the unknown", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00565-00117511-00117775": "that many times it's very difficult to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00566-00117776-00117990": "go outside that little box you're in", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00567-00117991-00118207": "and it's not comfortable it becomes a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00568-00118208-00118310": "real kind of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00569-00118311-00118478": "safety net you're in there you're", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00570-00118479-00118686": "focusing on that that's all you have to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00571-00118688-00118758": "worry about", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00572-00118759-00119039": "at the time and i found that after a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00573-00119040-00119199": "couple weeks i did have to come", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00574-00119200-00119358": "home and i did have to start thinking", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00575-00119359-00119558": "about the bills", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00576-00119559-00119815": "and different things and i found it very", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00577-00119816-00119902": "uncomfortable", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00578-00119903-00120214": "very difficult when i would call", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00579-00120215-00120375": "people on the phone that i needed to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00580-00120376-00120575": "call about things i would be crying", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00581-00120576-00120734": "because i would be telling part of the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00582-00120735-00120886": "story that had happened", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00583-00120888-00121239": "so there was a lot of emotional pieces", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00584-00121240-00121478": "that came back together with that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00585-00121479-00121783": "and i didn't feel", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00586-00121783-00122023": "i guess comfortable leaving the bedside", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00587-00122024-00122271": "either myself for quite a while", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00588-00122272-00122543": "knowing that there were so many things", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00589-00122544-00122599": "that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00590-00122600-00122847": "kind of depended on either decision", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00591-00122848-00122910": "making", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00592-00122911-00123271": "or people depending on me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00593-00123272-00123510": "so eventually when i did go out the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00594-00123511-00123758": "first time with friends i met them", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00595-00123759-00124078": "and it was very difficult", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00596-00124079-00124399": "basically we went for coffee uh i think", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00597-00124400-00124599": "i cried most of the time and i felt", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00598-00124600-00124695": "guilty", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00599-00124696-00124990": "because i could leave and i could go do", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00600-00124991-00125119": "that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00601-00125120-00125423": "and my husband could not so there's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00602-00125424-00125766": "a whole lot of emotions in there", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00603-00125767-00126023": "that you have to put together and when", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00604-00126024-00126223": "there is a crisis", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00605-00126224-00126414": "it does focus everything but when it", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00606-00126415-00126590": "starts to calm down", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00607-00126591-00126807": "then you have to like steve said figure", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00608-00126808-00127031": "out now how do i fit into the rest of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00609-00127032-00127199": "the world because i was spending 12", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00610-00127200-00127375": "hours a day at the hospital", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00611-00127376-00127654": "then i would drive home basically you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00612-00127655-00127695": "know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00613-00127696-00127943": "get ready to go back again the next day", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00614-00127944-00128031": "so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00615-00128032-00128254": "that's where most of your attention is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00616-00128255-00128366": "that's where you want", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00617-00128367-00128575": "your attention to be but there's these", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00618-00128576-00128799": "other things pulling at you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00619-00128800-00129199": "that you know you have to come back to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00620-00129200-00129423": "so alyssa i want to take a little spin", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00621-00129424-00129647": "of of what teresa started", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00622-00129648-00129990": "to allude to and that is guilt you know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00623-00129991-00130302": "you you feel guilty for", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00624-00130303-00130551": "you know missing out on other things you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00625-00130552-00130734": "feel guilty for there but then there's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00626-00130735-00131102": "also survivors guilt that you know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00627-00131103-00131399": "your brother passed away and you get to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00628-00131400-00131623": "do things or experiencing things he", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00629-00131624-00131831": "didn't so just tell me about", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00630-00131832-00132127": "you know your experience with just guilt", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00631-00132128-00132302": "in general survivor skill you know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00632-00132303-00132631": "whatever you want to share with everyone", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00633-00132632-00132895": "thank you for the question um anything", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00634-00132896-00133039": "to teresa's point there's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00635-00133040-00133214": "those types of feelings you have during", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00636-00133215-00133366": "the caregiving process and then there's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00637-00133367-00133566": "the post-caregiving process so that's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00638-00133567-00133727": "what i'll focus on because that's where", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00639-00133728-00133902": "i'm living now um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00640-00133903-00134127": "and i think there's two types of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00641-00134128-00134407": "emotions that i feel with", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00642-00134408-00134775": "survivors remorse one scenario is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00643-00134776-00135071": "when i'm at um like the highs of my life", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00644-00135072-00135111": "um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00645-00135112-00135319": "a really happy moment i'm celebrating", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00646-00135320-00135423": "something", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00647-00135424-00135727": "i'm achieving new successes", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00648-00135728-00135999": "um those are moments where you i am", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00649-00136000-00136143": "excited but then", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00650-00136144-00136327": "the first person i would typically call", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00651-00136328-00136535": "would be my mom or would be my brother i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00652-00136536-00136663": "mean my dad is still here so of course", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00653-00136664-00136790": "he is the first person", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00654-00136791-00137111": "but um i'm like oh they're not here", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00655-00137112-00137447": "um how is it that you know they", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00656-00137448-00137702": "are i became so lucky to be here and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00657-00137703-00137823": "unfortunately", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00658-00137824-00138054": "um how in how in the universe did they", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00659-00138055-00138231": "you know these are large questions that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00660-00138232-00138359": "you ask yourself in this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00661-00138360-00138654": "emotional stage of how how did they end", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00662-00138655-00138719": "up", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00663-00138720-00138927": "having cancer and not surviving it how", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00664-00138928-00139071": "did how did that happen", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00665-00139072-00139383": "um and that it can really bring you down", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00666-00139384-00139590": "um you go through this sort of rabbit", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00667-00139591-00139695": "hole of an emotion", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00668-00139696-00140031": "thinking okay um you know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00669-00140032-00140199": "i did everything i could for them but", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00670-00140200-00140335": "then you back up and you think", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00671-00140336-00140535": "did i do enough for them because i was a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00672-00140536-00140751": "caregiver their life", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00673-00140752-00140999": "was in my hands for a point with my", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00674-00141000-00141095": "father right", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00675-00141096-00141366": "um and that's where the survivor's bill", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00676-00141367-00141439": "comes in", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00677-00141440-00141735": "did i do enough um how is it that i'm", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00678-00141736-00141919": "less so lucky to be here i wish they", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00679-00141920-00142031": "were here", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00680-00142032-00142375": "uh that is the emotion um and i am so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00681-00142376-00142566": "lucky i have supported people in my life", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00682-00142567-00142823": "to still celebrate and enjoy", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00683-00142824-00143014": "and you know i will get married someday", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00684-00143015-00143190": "i will wish they were here and that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00685-00143191-00143447": "emotion will probably come up um but i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00686-00143448-00143551": "think even just", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00687-00143552-00143966": "you know in the everyday life it's um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00688-00143967-00144343": "i remember i think of them and i i just", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00689-00144344-00144551": "always i remind myself that i did the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00690-00144552-00144663": "best i could", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00691-00144664-00144919": "um but it can really arise some very", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00692-00144920-00145159": "difficult feelings", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00693-00145160-00145375": "and my guess is sometimes it hits you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00694-00145376-00145511": "and you're not prepared for it", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00695-00145512-00145687": "it's an unknown you don't know when", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00696-00145688-00145951": "those emotions are going to percolate up", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00697-00145952-00146135": "and if people don't understand that they", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00698-00146136-00146271": "don't understand", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00699-00146272-00146471": "you know sometimes why you are a little", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00700-00146472-00146678": "blue or suddenly something comes on and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00701-00146679-00146854": "it's a trigger", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00702-00146855-00147111": "i think that's only something caregivers", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00703-00147112-00147383": "can relate and understand too", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00704-00147384-00147647": "stephen same thing alyssa did you want", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00705-00147648-00147887": "to add on to that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00706-00147888-00148311": "okay stephen your thoughts", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00707-00148312-00148631": "you know i think the uh the challenge", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00708-00148632-00148807": "that oftentimes arises", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00709-00148808-00149095": "uh in terms of survivor remorse if you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00710-00149096-00149126": "will", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00711-00149127-00149375": "now you know stephen survived his", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00712-00149376-00149647": "transplant and i thank god for that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00713-00149648-00149871": "but i do often times think about his", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00714-00149872-00150023": "donor family", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00715-00150024-00150326": "and there are times that i want my son", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00716-00150327-00150502": "and i want to reach out to them just", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00717-00150503-00150702": "to just say thank you i am a huge", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00718-00150703-00150935": "proponent of donate life", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00719-00150936-00151190": "but i also have to think about in their", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00720-00151191-00151247": "gift of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00721-00151248-00151471": "life where they saved my son and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00722-00151472-00151766": "potentially seven to eight other people", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00723-00151767-00152054": "they still lost a loved one they lost a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00724-00152055-00152214": "seven-year-old child", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00725-00152215-00152487": "and so i think about that and you know i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00726-00152488-00152623": "look at my son and i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00727-00152624-00152887": "i'll tell you very tender moment i i was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00728-00152888-00153014": "given a bath one day", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00729-00153015-00153326": "and i kind of traced his scar on his", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00730-00153327-00153431": "stomach", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00731-00153432-00153663": "and as i was thinking about that i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00732-00153664-00153854": "reflected on not only the fact that this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00733-00153855-00153902": "family", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00734-00153903-00154207": "gave a gift of life but it also reminded", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00735-00154208-00154399": "me that my son has a second chance at", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00736-00154400-00154495": "life", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00737-00154496-00154766": "and so that is something that i don't", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00738-00154767-00154871": "take for granted", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00739-00154872-00155071": "and i pray that my son doesn't take for", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00740-00155072-00155214": "granted um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00741-00155215-00155423": "so when you think about it yeah even", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00742-00155424-00155566": "with a surviving", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00743-00155567-00155799": "child there's still a little bit of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00744-00155800-00155975": "survivor's remorse not necessarily for", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00745-00155976-00156063": "my son", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00746-00156064-00156302": "but for that donor family and so what i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00747-00156303-00156543": "also often find is i talk with a lot of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00748-00156544-00156702": "people in the hospital", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00749-00156703-00156919": "i sit with patient and family advisory", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00750-00156920-00157007": "councils and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00751-00157008-00157319": "specific liver uh support groups at", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00752-00157320-00157663": "our hospital and i've seen and talked", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00753-00157664-00157743": "with parents", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00754-00157744-00157990": "who their children are at all stages", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00755-00157991-00158054": "from", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00756-00158055-00158263": "their pre-op they're you know waiting", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00757-00158264-00158390": "i've seen the ones that have been", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00758-00158391-00158559": "transplanted and unfortunately the ones", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00759-00158560-00158735": "that have lost their child", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00760-00158736-00159119": "and it's it's a very", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00761-00159120-00159375": "very touching moment to be able to share", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00762-00159376-00159454": "with them", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00763-00159455-00159726": "and sometimes i feel like asking why am", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00764-00159727-00159911": "i so lucky", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00765-00159912-00160095": "and and that's hard because i'm very", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00766-00160096-00160319": "thankful but i often ask why am i so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00767-00160320-00160359": "lucky", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00768-00160360-00160590": "why were we so lucky that we found a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00769-00160591-00160678": "donor", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00770-00160679-00160983": "in five days and my son was transplanted", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00771-00160984-00161231": "in seven days after being listed", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00772-00161232-00161463": "why are we so lucky because i know not", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00773-00161464-00161631": "everyone has that same", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00774-00161632-00162063": "luck if you will", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00775-00162064-00162287": "so oftentimes you know when you're", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00776-00162288-00162726": "thrown into a caregiver role friendships", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00777-00162727-00162935": "relationships change they can change", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00778-00162936-00163159": "within your immediate family", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00779-00163160-00163439": "um people outside that you know just", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00780-00163440-00163702": "can't understand why you can't be there", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00781-00163703-00164007": "or you know if there's a loss of life", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00782-00164008-00164247": "they want you to be who you were again", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00783-00164248-00164575": "so teresa talk a little bit just about", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00784-00164576-00164751": "those relationships from", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00785-00164752-00165054": "maybe your own children your", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00786-00165055-00165383": "family friends like whatever you really", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00787-00165384-00165471": "feel", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00788-00165472-00165687": "changed when you really had to jump into", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00789-00165688-00165966": "the full caregiver role", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00790-00165967-00166254": "so when i got into the caregiver role i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00791-00166255-00166311": "think", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00792-00166312-00166735": "the other main people who were affected", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00793-00166736-00166814": "i do have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00794-00166815-00167159": "three children and i have brothers and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00795-00167160-00167359": "sisters and my husband also has a lot of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00796-00167360-00167495": "brothers and sisters", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00797-00167496-00167751": "so everybody was sort of floundering as", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00798-00167752-00167799": "to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00799-00167800-00168087": "what do we do what is our role can we", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00800-00168088-00168238": "help can't we help", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00801-00168239-00168438": "and it was interesting to see different", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00802-00168439-00168638": "people over the years", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00803-00168639-00168895": "how they have changed how they adapted", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00804-00168896-00169166": "in one way and then change to another", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00805-00169167-00169487": "i can say that um recently", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00806-00169488-00169743": "there my husband had a hospitalization", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00807-00169744-00169951": "and each of my children played", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00808-00169952-00170231": "a different role they've been very since", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00809-00170232-00170431": "the very beginning of his spinal cord", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00810-00170432-00170511": "injury", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00811-00170512-00170823": "it was always we have this don't worry", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00812-00170824-00171007": "about it when you ask us to do something", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00813-00171008-00171166": "we're good if you want to come visit us", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00814-00171167-00171326": "we'll get dad in the house", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00815-00171327-00171495": "if we have to carry him it doesn't", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00816-00171496-00171726": "matter we are there we're going to do", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00817-00171727-00171887": "this we're going to be", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00818-00171888-00172166": "we're going to survive this so one of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00819-00172167-00172238": "them", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00820-00172239-00172502": "is a rational person and he will say and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00821-00172503-00172878": "this sort of alludes to what alyssa said", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00822-00172879-00173214": "there is no good or bad decision mom", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00823-00173215-00173526": "there is the best decision you made at", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00824-00173527-00173614": "the time", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00825-00173615-00173887": "with the best information that you had", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00826-00173888-00173951": "and that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00827-00173952-00174247": "was really very extremely helpful to me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00828-00174248-00174399": "because you're going through so much", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00829-00174400-00174543": "pressure at the time", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00830-00174544-00174863": "then i have one who is a little bit more", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00831-00174864-00175054": "of the caring and mom i hope you're", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00832-00175055-00175175": "going to sit in the car and eat lunch", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00833-00175176-00175199": "with", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00834-00175200-00175375": "me and not just grab the lunch and go", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00835-00175376-00175535": "back to the room that you're going to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00836-00175536-00175726": "come outside and realize there is a real", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00837-00175727-00175887": "world out here", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00838-00175888-00176135": "and take a few minutes and take a break", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00839-00176136-00176335": "and then the other one is also a medical", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00840-00176336-00176551": "person so he became the person", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00841-00176552-00176766": "i could call and bounce some things off", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00842-00176767-00176878": "of and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00843-00176879-00177223": "ask how how do i you know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00844-00177224-00177414": "instead of me being on the ceiling he", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00845-00177415-00177559": "could pull me back down and say well", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00846-00177560-00177759": "these are realistic things", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00847-00177760-00177959": "with friends friends have always been", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00848-00177960-00178126": "there to support but i found in the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00849-00178127-00178326": "beginning when something happens", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00850-00178327-00178526": "you just want to go into your own", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00851-00178527-00178719": "special", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00852-00178720-00178895": "sort of shell by yourself you don't have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00853-00178896-00179102": "the energy for other people", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00854-00179103-00179335": "and so some friends backed off totally", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00855-00179336-00179502": "and didn't know what to do with that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00856-00179503-00179743": "some friends would text incessantly", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00857-00179744-00179959": "thinking well she's not answering why", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00858-00179960-00180471": "not and so finally i had to explain", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00859-00180472-00180719": "uh somebody brought it to me like you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00860-00180720-00180807": "have to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00861-00180808-00181063": "like a wounded animal you have to go in", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00862-00181064-00181207": "you kind of have to lick your wounds for", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00863-00181208-00181254": "a while", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00864-00181255-00181559": "and then you can come out and rejoin and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00865-00181560-00181671": "be with people", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00866-00181672-00181871": "so that was interesting to see how", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00867-00181872-00182087": "different people were able to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00868-00182088-00182583": "adapt to that alyssa for you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00869-00182584-00182911": "your experience is so unique and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00870-00182912-00183078": "and in some ways i hear and i'm like did", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00871-00183079-00183278": "you feel like you were cheated you know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00872-00183279-00183478": "this is happening with your mom in high", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00873-00183479-00183599": "school and then", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00874-00183600-00183759": "you know you're trying to go off and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00875-00183760-00183990": "live the college experience like all of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00876-00183991-00184087": "these", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00877-00184088-00184414": "monumental moments", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00878-00184415-00184590": "what was that like but then like who", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00879-00184591-00184814": "were your friends who could even relate", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00880-00184815-00184911": "to you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00881-00184912-00185254": "um who was your support system", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00882-00185255-00185438": "thank you for the question i think i'll", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00883-00185439-00185671": "first address when my mom was ill", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00884-00185672-00185950": "um i think the first discussion we had", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00885-00185951-00186071": "when i was going through", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00886-00186072-00186343": "after i had graduated was i had you know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00887-00186344-00186487": "accepted an offer to go", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00888-00186488-00186823": "to school 300 miles away um i said mom", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00889-00186824-00186895": "should i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00890-00186896-00187199": "just tend a different school closer um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00891-00187200-00187431": "she's like no you got into the school", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00892-00187432-00187543": "you're going", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00893-00187544-00187783": "and i was like okay i mean i can just", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00894-00187784-00187926": "look into ops and she's like no", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00895-00187927-00188150": "you're going to this school and so that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00896-00188151-00188287": "was her wish for me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00897-00188288-00188559": "and i'm grateful for that although i was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00898-00188560-00188614": "unsure", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00899-00188615-00188775": "i still look back should i have just", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00900-00188776-00188950": "stayed closer um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00901-00188951-00189207": "but you know i'm glad i achieved her", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00902-00189208-00189343": "wish for me and i did that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00903-00189344-00189519": "i was still able to come back during", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00904-00189520-00189750": "summer times and at her end of life", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00905-00189751-00190102": "and i know she's proud of me so i um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00906-00190103-00190335": "i don't i i achieved her wish with that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00907-00190336-00190487": "with my brother was different", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00908-00190488-00190807": "um this story um this part of the story", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00909-00190808-00191038": "was when i was abroad actually in london", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00910-00191039-00191319": "i was on a train from paris back to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00911-00191320-00191511": "london where i was staying", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00912-00191512-00191678": "and i had a missed call from my dad but", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00913-00191679-00191926": "i didn't have service so i called him", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00914-00191927-00192119": "when i got back i had this feeling that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00915-00192120-00192287": "something was off i just had a feeling", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00916-00192288-00192350": "in my gut", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00917-00192351-00192543": "and that's when i found out my brother", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00918-00192544-00192775": "um was diagnosed with cancer i was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00919-00192776-00192847": "abroad", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00920-00192848-00193135": "and so i quit my study abroad program i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00921-00193136-00193254": "came on back", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00922-00193255-00193590": "um and i you know just took a little bit", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00923-00193591-00193766": "of time off of school to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00924-00193767-00193959": "just be with my family as he got his", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00925-00193960-00194078": "resection and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00926-00194079-00194350": "was recovering from surgeries that was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00927-00194351-00194463": "difficult for me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00928-00194464-00194719": "um because at that point i felt okay is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00929-00194720-00194959": "my education going to be set off now", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00930-00194960-00195214": "um and then when i did get my degree and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00931-00195215-00195390": "i started a job as i mentioned i quit", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00932-00195391-00195487": "that job", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00933-00195488-00195814": "and that was my decision but", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00934-00195815-00196087": "i sometimes felt ah like i was really", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00935-00196088-00196254": "excited to start my career", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00936-00196255-00196535": "i'm gonna set this off a little bit so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00937-00196536-00196671": "there were points where i felt i was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00938-00196672-00196838": "getting set back but it was the right", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00939-00196839-00196935": "decision", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00940-00196936-00197223": "for my family i look back on it now and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00941-00197224-00197254": "it", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00942-00197255-00197471": "i have no regrets with that but in the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00943-00197472-00197590": "moment", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00944-00197591-00197838": "you're right carol you you wonder if", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00945-00197839-00198047": "you're missing out or getting set back", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00946-00198048-00198311": "and those were difficult feelings to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00947-00198312-00198350": "have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00948-00198351-00198775": "at the time and stephen with you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00949-00198776-00199135": "you know here you are new dad", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00950-00199136-00199350": "family you know your wife and you have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00951-00199351-00199526": "gone through this pregnancy", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00952-00199527-00199847": "did you find that friendships changed", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00953-00199848-00200223": "because steven junior or deuce like all", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00954-00200224-00200399": "for the first couple years you really", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00955-00200400-00200575": "couldn't connect you were always worried", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00956-00200576-00200695": "about him", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00957-00200696-00200943": "how did that impact your relationships", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00958-00200944-00201054": "yeah absolutely", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00959-00201055-00201438": "uh you know the thing that i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00960-00201439-00201783": "that i was not prepared for was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00961-00201784-00202063": "how people thought that this liver", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00962-00202064-00202190": "transplant", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00963-00202191-00202471": "was an isolated incident it's an", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00964-00202472-00202590": "isolated thing an", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00965-00202591-00202838": "operation so once you stick the organ in", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00966-00202839-00202990": "and it's transplanted in a couple of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00967-00202991-00203095": "months afterwards", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00968-00203096-00203335": "there's no more issues life goes back to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00969-00203336-00203414": "normal", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00970-00203415-00203654": "and so i didn't realize that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00971-00203655-00203799": "transplantation", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00972-00203800-00204119": "is a lifelong endeavor and that's what", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00973-00204120-00204238": "my friends didn't realize", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00974-00204239-00204390": "and so i had friends that were you know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00975-00204391-00204599": "they were absolutely by my side", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00976-00204600-00204903": "during those those crucial initial days", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00977-00204904-00205071": "and weeks and months and even you know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00978-00205071-00205255": "year or so and then they were like hey", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00979-00205256-00205431": "why can't you come out and do this why", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00980-00205432-00205606": "can't you go out and do that why don't", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00981-00205607-00205758": "you hang out with us more", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00982-00205759-00206014": "you should do this and i i have to kind", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00983-00206015-00206182": "of explain to them that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00984-00206183-00206382": "things have changed so when we go to a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00985-00206383-00206527": "birthday party", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00986-00206528-00206742": "you know this is well before kovid hand", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00987-00206744-00206886": "hygiene was a huge", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00988-00206887-00207175": "thing for my family you know steve when", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00989-00207176-00207271": "you come in from school", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00990-00207271-00207494": "wash your hands immediately because", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00991-00207496-00207694": "that's what we have to do to protect him", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00992-00207696-00207910": "and and oh you can't eat this so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00993-00207911-00208062": "stephen's condition that caused his", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00994-00208063-00208238": "liver transplants called galactosemia", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00995-00208239-00208390": "and what that means is that his body", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00996-00208391-00208494": "can't break down", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00997-00208496-00208727": "galactose found in human and animal milk", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00998-00208728-00208903": "so when we go to a birthday party", "TvJr0dM9Rny-00999-00208904-00209142": "and you have pizza and ice cream he", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01000-00209144-00209271": "can't eat", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01001-00209271-00209462": "and so there's a there's a difference", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01002-00209463-00209623": "there of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01003-00209623-00209806": "telling my friends hey i'm not trying to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01004-00209807-00209998": "be mean i'm not trying to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01005-00210000-00210215": "stun your party but i'm gonna feed my", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01006-00210216-00210358": "son before", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01007-00210359-00210558": "and then the other part was to have them", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01008-00210559-00210727": "understand that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01009-00210728-00210927": "i don't want you to have to feel like", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01010-00210928-00211134": "you have to stop your plans", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01011-00211135-00211358": "because we're coming because what i find", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01012-00211359-00211446": "is sometimes", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01013-00211448-00211671": "they don't want to invite you and that's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01014-00211671-00211815": "something that was something we had to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01015-00211816-00211951": "work with with friends and explain to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01016-00211952-00212110": "them that you know my son is normal he", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01017-00212111-00212206": "can come to your party", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01018-00212207-00212375": "he can do these types of things we will", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01019-00212376-00212558": "take care of him but it was hard for me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01020-00212559-00212758": "to get my friends to understand that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01021-00212759-00212998": "my life is different and while my child", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01022-00213000-00213223": "is very normal in my eyes", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01023-00213223-00213479": "he still has chronic conditions he takes", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01024-00213480-00213615": "anti-rejection medicine", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01025-00213616-00213879": "twice a day every 12 hours on those", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01026-00213880-00213998": "12-hour marks", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01027-00214000-00214151": "every single day and will do so for the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01028-00214152-00214342": "rest of his life so my child is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01029-00214344-00214398": "different", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01030-00214400-00214534": "and trying to get them to understand", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01031-00214535-00214687": "that you know one of the things that i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01032-00214688-00214903": "had to contend with in the military", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01033-00214904-00215246": "was that my my career changed", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01034-00215248-00215446": "so the military we generally do not like", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01035-00215448-00215639": "to have people stay in the same place", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01036-00215640-00215871": "for longer than two to three years", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01037-00215871-00215998": "well we have this thing called an", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01038-00216000-00216191": "exceptional family member program", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01039-00216192-00216327": "where the military does take into", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01040-00216328-00216503": "account the special needs that our", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01041-00216504-00216598": "families have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01042-00216600-00216846": "across the services and so my assignment", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01043-00216848-00217063": "team said hey we really want you to go", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01044-00217064-00217334": "to another place outside of the dc metro", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01045-00217335-00217406": "area", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01046-00217407-00217631": "and i had to push back and said i really", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01047-00217632-00217751": "don't want to do that because there's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01048-00217752-00217887": "continuity of care", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01049-00217888-00218031": "there are things that are set up for my", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01050-00218032-00218231": "son so not only did it change", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01051-00218232-00218446": "with my friends and having to get them", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01052-00218448-00218558": "to understand", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01053-00218559-00218806": "here's what my life means now it also", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01054-00218807-00219015": "was an educational part for my", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01055-00219016-00219294": "career to let them know that there are", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01056-00219296-00219463": "things that i have to do here and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01057-00219464-00219655": "and i am actually coming to this this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01058-00219656-00219775": "crossroads", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01059-00219776-00219998": "uh really soon with do you want to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01060-00220000-00220191": "continue in military service or they may", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01061-00220192-00220246": "send me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01062-00220248-00220487": "to another place that's outside of this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01063-00220488-00220606": "dc area", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01064-00220607-00220855": "or do you want to retire and it's scary", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01065-00220856-00221039": "it is absolutely scary", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01066-00221040-00221223": "but when the time comes and i will", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01067-00221223-00221439": "absolutely make the right decision", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01068-00221440-00221631": "i know that i would have educated the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01069-00221632-00221775": "military more on", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01070-00221776-00222094": "what this efmp program means and they do", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01071-00222096-00222206": "the right thing for my son", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01072-00222207-00222382": "but it is absolutely an educational part", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01073-00222383-00222542": "not just on a personal level", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01074-00222544-00222934": "but also on a professional level", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01075-00222935-00223167": "so i want to close up with two questions", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01076-00223167-00223294": "before we open it", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01077-00223296-00223671": "for qna and the first one is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01078-00223671-00224087": "briefly tell me in the audience", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01079-00224088-00224382": "what you've done to care for yourself", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01080-00224383-00224494": "like what are those", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01081-00224496-00224694": "you know little tips or what it did you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01082-00224696-00224951": "finally figure out you needed to do", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01083-00224952-00225303": "to keep yourself sane healthy", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01084-00225304-00225463": "um you know when you're you're a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01085-00225464-00225671": "caregiver sometimes", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01086-00225671-00225942": "half the day all the day again days", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01087-00225944-00226087": "weeks months years", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01088-00226088-00226423": "so list i want to start with you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01089-00226423-00226734": "sure i think um when being", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01090-00226735-00226975": "a caregiver at first in learning what", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01091-00226976-00227158": "that meant for my father and i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01092-00227159-00227471": "you know we are so proud of the efforts", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01093-00227471-00227551": "that we made", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01094-00227552-00227751": "for for our loved ones and we wanted to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01095-00227752-00227942": "be there every single minute i'm sure as", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01096-00227944-00228055": "teresa and steven", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01097-00228056-00228279": "have felt as well and the stories they", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01098-00228280-00228367": "have shared too", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01099-00228367-00228558": "um you want to just be there when you're", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01100-00228559-00228710": "anything could come out at any moment", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01101-00228711-00228887": "you just want to be by the bedside you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01102-00228888-00229031": "want to be with them at home wherever", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01103-00229032-00229127": "they may be", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01104-00229128-00229431": "um and i think the evolution of that was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01105-00229432-00229487": "learning", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01106-00229488-00229646": "of the burnout that can happen and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01107-00229648-00229871": "feeling the effects of the burnout", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01108-00229871-00230206": "and my coping wise i think we're just", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01109-00230207-00230367": "learning to communicate", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01110-00230367-00230639": "to my my support group my family my", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01111-00230640-00230710": "friends", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01112-00230711-00230927": "what what what was helpful for me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01113-00230928-00231094": "sometimes i took time for myself", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01114-00231096-00231279": "to do something that i would consider", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01115-00231280-00231431": "normal that maybe i wasn't doing every", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01116-00231432-00231463": "day", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01117-00231464-00231782": "grabbing my favorite latte um just like", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01118-00231783-00232039": "walking to get a coffee that was like", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01119-00232040-00232375": "extraordinary like magical normal moment", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01120-00232376-00232591": "or blow drying my hair which i like", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01121-00232592-00232742": "probably stopped doing", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01122-00232744-00232894": "um i would just stop and say oh this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01123-00232896-00233119": "feels really nice um but then also", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01124-00233119-00233239": "communicating to my friends", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01125-00233240-00233463": "i think my best support group members", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01126-00233464-00233567": "would ask me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01127-00233567-00233839": "what do you need for like do you want to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01128-00233840-00233975": "vent and talk", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01129-00233976-00234239": "do you want to laugh like what what is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01130-00234240-00234391": "best and i think", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01131-00234392-00234575": "being able to communicate all right i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01132-00234576-00234775": "would love to have a lunch date where we", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01133-00234776-00234831": "just", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01134-00234832-00235103": "talk about something silly or i would", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01135-00235104-00235255": "like to really have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01136-00235256-00235446": "a personal moment in the backyard where", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01137-00235448-00235663": "we i would like to share what's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01138-00235664-00235887": "going on with the care of my loved one", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01139-00235888-00235975": "and so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01140-00235976-00236206": "that really helped me in asking for help", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01141-00236207-00236334": "learning to ask", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01142-00236335-00236582": "people hey you know actually my brother", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01143-00236583-00236719": "probably doesn't want to see me every", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01144-00236719-00236751": "day", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01145-00236752-00236910": "maybe he would like to see someone else", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01146-00236911-00237215": "would you like to step in and spend", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01147-00237216-00237503": "half a day with my brother or my mom and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01148-00237504-00237639": "have that quality time with them and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01149-00237640-00237727": "that would", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01150-00237728-00238015": "essentially also give me a moment to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01151-00238016-00238103": "step away", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01152-00238104-00238327": "and so those are the types of decisions", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01153-00238328-00238527": "i started to evolve into but it took", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01154-00238528-00238758": "time to get there", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01155-00238759-00239134": "theresa what about you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01156-00239135-00239423": "so some of the things that i do is are", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01157-00239423-00239542": "the same as alyssa", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01158-00239544-00239806": "the connection with friends and family", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01159-00239807-00239998": "and i found especially this last time we", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01160-00240000-00240223": "were in the hospital", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01161-00240223-00240519": "while i was in there it was over 30 days", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01162-00240519-00240582": "and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01163-00240583-00240767": "there was a lot of texting going on with", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01164-00240767-00240927": "people because that was the easiest", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01165-00240928-00241046": "thing to do", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01166-00241048-00241223": "because of all the isolation that you're", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01167-00241223-00241510": "in there and one of the doctors came in", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01168-00241511-00241758": "and said to me are you staying connected", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01169-00241759-00241982": "to other people and i said", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01170-00241983-00242246": "yes i said i'm texting and she said no", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01171-00242248-00242375": "she said you need to face", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01172-00242376-00242534": "time or you need to call people and i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01173-00242535-00242687": "was stunned and i thought", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01174-00242688-00242839": "this is what they're learning how you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01175-00242840-00243015": "need to take care of yourself", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01176-00243016-00243191": "and stay connected in the hospital", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01177-00243192-00243351": "because they're in there with all these", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01178-00243352-00243446": "patients", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01179-00243448-00243639": "who are so ill and can't have visitors", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01180-00243640-00243839": "because of covet at this point", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01181-00243840-00244142": "so that helped me expand how", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01182-00244144-00244391": "i was keeping in touch and keeping", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01183-00244392-00244446": "myself", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01184-00244448-00244782": "going i did some i like to do some", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01185-00244783-00244927": "meditation", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01186-00244928-00245119": "i like to take a walk just getting", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01187-00245119-00245279": "outside being out", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01188-00245280-00245591": "in the fresh air as you said maybe i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01189-00245592-00245767": "treated myself to a latte in the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01190-00245767-00245910": "hospital also", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01191-00245911-00246151": "so just little things that you don't", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01192-00246152-00246319": "think about all the time", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01193-00246319-00246671": "but really for me it is a lot of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01194-00246671-00247015": "personal connection or just sitting down", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01195-00247016-00247310": "and being able to read a page in a book", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01196-00247311-00247446": "or", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01197-00247448-00247798": "color a picture or lay down and get to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01198-00247800-00247903": "take a nap", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01199-00247904-00248079": "if you're able to have the time to be", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01200-00248080-00248271": "able to take a nap during the day", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01201-00248271-00248534": "and just do something that helps to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01202-00248535-00248671": "rejuvenate you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01203-00248671-00248975": "because i do find the better i take care", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01204-00248976-00249094": "of myself", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01205-00249096-00249351": "the better i am for the people i take", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01206-00249352-00249446": "care of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01207-00249448-00249646": "and it takes a while to realize that and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01208-00249648-00249839": "sometimes you think you're doing great", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01209-00249840-00250094": "but really your gas tank is pretty empty", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01210-00250096-00250255": "and once you fill that up", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01211-00250256-00250534": "you can come back with a renewed joy and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01212-00250535-00250671": "a renewed caring", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01213-00250671-00250919": "that you don't have when it starts to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01214-00250919-00250982": "get low", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01215-00250983-00251271": "if i'm honest with myself and if you can", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01216-00251271-00251463": "really be honest with yourself you can", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01217-00251464-00251567": "look back and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01218-00251567-00251855": "objectively say gee it's much better", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01219-00251856-00251919": "here", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01220-00251919-00252319": "than it is here so stephen i'm going to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01221-00252319-00252687": "start with our last question with you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01222-00252688-00252998": "what has been sometimes we always think", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01223-00253000-00253303": "um the glass is half empty but", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01224-00253304-00253542": "there are special moments or great", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01225-00253544-00253782": "things about being the caregiver", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01226-00253783-00254039": "tell me you know share just what are", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01227-00254040-00254191": "those positives or", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01228-00254192-00254351": "what whatever you want to share that has", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01229-00254352-00254655": "been a benefit of being a caregiver", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01230-00254656-00254942": "you know i think um out of stephen's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01231-00254944-00255030": "pain", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01232-00255031-00255223": "i found some purpose you know i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01233-00255223-00255334": "oftentimes say", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01234-00255335-00255639": "when your vocation what you're paid to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01235-00255640-00255703": "do", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01236-00255704-00255991": "and your advocation what you love to do", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01237-00255992-00256103": "intersect", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01238-00256104-00256294": "you find purpose and happiness and so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01239-00256296-00256406": "out of stephen's pain", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01240-00256407-00256679": "i found this this new passion and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01241-00256680-00256839": "purpose for my life", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01242-00256840-00257103": "post-military career that you know i'm", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01243-00257104-00257327": "excited i've just gotten my master's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01244-00257328-00257391": "degree", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01245-00257392-00257534": "in clinical quality safety and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01246-00257535-00257734": "leadership and matter of fact my degree", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01247-00257735-00257806": "frame is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01248-00257807-00258134": "in and i can pick it up today uh so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01249-00258135-00258382": "that kind of passion happened because of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01250-00258383-00258455": "my son", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01251-00258456-00258655": "and what i found is that i look forward", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01252-00258656-00258871": "to helping patients to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01253-00258871-00259055": "find their voice to know they have a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01254-00259056-00259279": "voice and really transforming", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01255-00259280-00259591": "how we deliver care moving forward how", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01256-00259592-00259742": "we can take the things that i've learned", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01257-00259744-00259910": "in 20 years of military service", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01258-00259911-00260134": "in this high reliability organization", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01259-00260135-00260230": "called the military", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01260-00260231-00260527": "and bring that to bear in medicine", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01261-00260528-00260679": "that's one of the most", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01262-00260680-00260830": "you know gratifying things that i've", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01263-00260831-00261119": "learned um in this whole experience", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01264-00261119-00261287": "the other thing that uh and i want to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01265-00261288-00261430": "touch really quickly on what you said", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01266-00261431-00261575": "from the last question and i would be", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01267-00261576-00261639": "very brief", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01268-00261640-00261782": "there's three things that i do because i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01269-00261783-00261951": "think prescriptions are important", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01270-00261952-00262230": "one is i talk to people and so i've done", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01271-00262231-00262327": "that with", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01272-00262328-00262487": "you know these these groups that i'm in", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01273-00262488-00262647": "these advisory councils and just talking", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01274-00262648-00262823": "to other people have shared experiences", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01275-00262824-00263063": "number two is right and so what i've", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01276-00263064-00263206": "learned is that sometimes you have to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01277-00263207-00263319": "unplug", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01278-00263320-00263655": "to recharge and the last thing i do is i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01279-00263656-00263710": "ride", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01280-00263711-00264055": "so i'm a peloton fan i've got a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01281-00264056-00264367": "tribe of people that if you look up", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01282-00264368-00264703": "united for safe care we ride", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01283-00264704-00264879": "and that's what helps me so those are", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01284-00264880-00265095": "some positive things that i've gotten", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01285-00265096-00265319": "out of this very traumatic experience", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01286-00265320-00265447": "but it's given me purpose", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01287-00265448-00265623": "and it's given me a renewed sense of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01288-00265624-00265799": "life", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01289-00265800-00266167": "thanks stephen", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01290-00266168-00266334": "thank alyssa for sharing stephen that's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01291-00266335-00266551": "fantastic congratulations on your degree", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01292-00266552-00266615": "as well", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01293-00266616-00266839": "um yeah for me i guess it's there's a", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01294-00266840-00266975": "personal benefit", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01295-00266976-00267199": "career benefits similar to steven and my", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01296-00267200-00267423": "new career path that i have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01297-00267424-00267591": "but also some skills that i gained so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01298-00267592-00267710": "maybe i'll start with the skills i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01299-00267711-00267782": "gained", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01300-00267783-00268039": "um you know i'd say most of my life", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01301-00268040-00268158": "before caregiving", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01302-00268159-00268334": "was not good at making decisions not", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01303-00268335-00268575": "good in urgency emergencies", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01304-00268576-00268791": "now i think i was in so many of those", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01305-00268792-00269079": "scenarios that i feel more comfortable", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01306-00269080-00269319": "when an urgent situation comes up i know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01307-00269320-00269415": "how to navigate", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01308-00269416-00269575": "just what is that mental process what", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01309-00269576-00269758": "are things to think about", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01310-00269759-00269999": "or i can prioritize and realize all", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01311-00270000-00270151": "right maybe something that i thought was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01312-00270152-00270303": "so stressful in the past", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01313-00270304-00270495": "you know i can think about it and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01314-00270496-00270743": "reframe it be less stressed", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01315-00270744-00270951": "know that there are better days to come", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01316-00270952-00271055": "so i think that's just", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01317-00271056-00271423": "skill set mentality for my career i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01318-00271424-00271695": "studied finance and i started working", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01319-00271696-00271879": "for a pharmaceutical company in finance", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01320-00271880-00271934": "but", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01321-00271935-00272103": "found i really was good at project", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01322-00272104-00272319": "management so i joined medical affairs", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01323-00272320-00272367": "and now", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01324-00272368-00272575": "i'm a little bit closer to you know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01325-00272576-00272710": "supporting um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01326-00272711-00272910": "the medical affairs side of a business", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01327-00272911-00273119": "and have um you know i'm going to be", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01328-00273120-00273319": "evolving in that space with a new role", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01329-00273320-00273375": "soon", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01330-00273376-00273647": "so i found that i can stay connected to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01331-00273648-00273799": "supporting oncology", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01332-00273800-00274030": "um through my my work and my school set", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01333-00274031-00274255": "and that's really exciting for me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01334-00274256-00274510": "so that's great and then the last part", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01335-00274511-00274687": "was personally", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01336-00274688-00274887": "like benefits from being a caregiver", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01337-00274888-00275015": "that i look back on", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01338-00275016-00275239": "um some of my greatest memories were", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01339-00275240-00275391": "also when i was caregiving for my", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01340-00275392-00275558": "brother and my mom there were times", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01341-00275559-00275599": "where", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01342-00275600-00275815": "you know there were such funny moments", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01343-00275816-00275967": "that i don't know how they were able to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01344-00275968-00276167": "be light-hearted through difficult times", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01345-00276168-00276223": "but", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01346-00276224-00276479": "i look back on those and i laugh cry", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01347-00276480-00276575": "laugh right", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01348-00276576-00276823": "there were moments of joy and difficult", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01349-00276824-00276927": "times and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01350-00276928-00277191": "um because i was a caregiver with my dad", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01351-00277192-00277367": "and we could all be together", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01352-00277368-00277695": "we have those memories and teresa", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01353-00277696-00278039": "i'll end it with you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01354-00278040-00278263": "well i have to agree with stephen and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01355-00278264-00278463": "elisa that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01356-00278464-00278799": "you do become closer to the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01357-00278800-00279095": "person you're taking care of i think and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01358-00279096-00279271": "you learn a lot about the world about", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01359-00279272-00279382": "you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01360-00279383-00279687": "um i found that for jack and i we built", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01361-00279688-00279791": "a trust", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01362-00279792-00280030": "so there's a big trust there because", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01363-00280031-00280127": "you're making", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01364-00280128-00280358": "so many decisions and so many things are", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01365-00280359-00280471": "so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01366-00280472-00280719": "important and then i also found that i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01367-00280720-00280830": "got closer", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01368-00280831-00281110": "to my family and my husband's family", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01369-00281111-00281343": "this latest hospitalization", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01370-00281344-00281615": "they were going to set up making meals", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01371-00281616-00281695": "for jack", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01372-00281696-00282015": "and he couldn't eat at the time and when", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01373-00282016-00282182": "i told my sister-in-law she goes no", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01374-00282183-00282415": "we're talking about you we want to cook", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01375-00282416-00282575": "for you and bring it to you and i was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01376-00282576-00282719": "like wow that's really", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01377-00282720-00282910": "amazing and great but it's hard to ask", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01378-00282911-00283071": "for that on your own", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01379-00283072-00283271": "it can be hard to ask for that help and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01380-00283272-00283430": "my family is always there", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01381-00283431-00283663": "as the backup or the go-to or to talk to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01382-00283664-00283830": "and my friends", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01383-00283831-00284175": "have been incredible i think there's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01384-00284176-00284463": "uh like a deeper richer side to the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01385-00284464-00284575": "friendship", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01386-00284576-00284839": "um where you can talk about things as", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01387-00284840-00285006": "alyssa said what kind of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01388-00285007-00285158": "what do you want today do you want fun", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01389-00285159-00285358": "do you want sad do you want serious do", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01390-00285359-00285430": "you want", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01391-00285431-00285799": "nothing um so that's been extremely", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01392-00285800-00285958": "helpful and the fact that sometimes", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01393-00285959-00286191": "they'll push well this is what we want", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01394-00286192-00286358": "to do for you so when do you want it", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01395-00286359-00286551": "we're not going to take no for an answer", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01396-00286552-00286710": "we think you need it we're going to do", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01397-00286711-00286951": "this so let us know when", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01398-00286952-00287215": "or where but we won't take no for an", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01399-00287216-00287454": "answer and sometimes that's absolutely", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01400-00287455-00287710": "perfect and you don't realize what you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01401-00287711-00287775": "need", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01402-00287776-00288015": "but they may be realizing what you need", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01403-00288016-00288119": "and also through", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01404-00288120-00288519": "i have to say the pmsf family", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01405-00288520-00288782": "i have met the most wonderful group of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01406-00288783-00288887": "people", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01407-00288888-00289239": "and we always say my friend here", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01408-00289240-00289439": "carol always said it's a group that we", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01409-00289440-00289671": "don't necessarily want to belong to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01410-00289672-00289934": "but we're here and so we have met", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01411-00289935-00290143": "wonderful people who we've grown to know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01412-00290144-00290382": "and love and have just we've supported", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01413-00290383-00290463": "each other", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01414-00290464-00290687": "through so many things and it's just", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01415-00290688-00290767": "such a rich", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01416-00290768-00291079": "rich relationship to be able to do that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01417-00291080-00291430": "and we're here for others", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01418-00291431-00291743": "great way to end it theresa um so what", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01419-00291744-00291927": "we're going to do is we want to open it", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01420-00291928-00292119": "up because we know many people", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01421-00292120-00292310": "that are watching this right now are", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01422-00292311-00292447": "caregivers as well", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01423-00292448-00292791": "and have questions so there is one last", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01424-00292792-00293030": "slide and it's just some resources we", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01425-00293031-00293230": "felt it was really important to make", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01426-00293231-00293367": "sure that people know there are", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01427-00293368-00293551": "resources out there", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01428-00293552-00293758": "um and these are well validated", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01429-00293759-00293982": "resources from the nih", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01430-00293983-00294303": "mayo clinic harvard on how to take care", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01431-00294304-00294447": "of yourself and they're", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01432-00294448-00294679": "there they're simple tips that i think", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01433-00294680-00294751": "sometimes", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01434-00294752-00294919": "we just forget because we're so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01435-00294920-00295143": "overwhelmed as caregivers", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01436-00295144-00295319": "so sarah i'm gonna turn it to you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01437-00295320-00295495": "because i know you've been monitoring", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01438-00295496-00295551": "the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01439-00295552-00295863": "q a in chat um are there questions out", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01440-00295864-00295910": "there", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01441-00295911-00296071": "that people have that the panel can", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01442-00296072-00296287": "answer", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01443-00296288-00296495": "of course yeah it looks like we have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01444-00296496-00296727": "three questions that were submitted and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01445-00296728-00296903": "it's actually one question for each of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01446-00296904-00297191": "you and the first one is for alyssa", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01447-00297192-00297415": "um the attendee asked how has this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01448-00297416-00297623": "experience change your friends thoughts", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01449-00297624-00297791": "about the culture of having a role in", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01450-00297792-00297999": "patient safety is there any impact on", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01451-00298000-00298215": "your personal life", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01452-00298216-00298399": "yeah i'm just thank you for the question", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01453-00298400-00298551": "um messiah", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01454-00298552-00298734": "i appreciate it i see your question in", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01455-00298735-00298958": "the chat here and um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01456-00298959-00299215": "yeah it has impacted my personal life i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01457-00299216-00299367": "think i've been able to bring", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01458-00299368-00299519": "everyone being part of this panel thank", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01459-00299520-00299687": "you for inviting me sarah", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01460-00299688-00299958": "um to give some voice to this but i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01461-00299959-00300134": "would say you know through social media", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01462-00300135-00300199": "through", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01463-00300200-00300503": "um interactions and in person when that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01464-00300504-00300639": "was something that we did i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01465-00300640-00300887": "i do bring up what my experience is like", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01466-00300888-00301087": "and i i don't pretend that it didn't", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01467-00301088-00301175": "happen", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01468-00301176-00301310": "because it's something a lot of people", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01469-00301311-00301591": "in my life don't know about so i think", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01470-00301592-00301919": "as far as like change in friendships um", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01471-00301920-00302071": "you know people are really supportive", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01472-00302072-00302367": "they are comfortable asking me now about", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01473-00302368-00302527": "my experience i'm more comfortable", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01474-00302528-00302599": "talking about", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01475-00302600-00302958": "it and bringing some voice and attention", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01476-00302959-00303054": "to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01477-00303055-00303343": "what this role is um to at least the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01478-00303344-00303503": "people in my life and my", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01479-00303504-00303782": "my um you know network and group of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01480-00303783-00303903": "professional and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01481-00303904-00304191": "personal friends i think that that's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01482-00304192-00304399": "something that has changed over time", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01483-00304400-00304534": "at first i wasn't very comfortable", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01484-00304535-00304734": "talking about it now i am", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01485-00304735-00304999": "um so that and i think also just", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01486-00305000-00305095": "recognizing", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01487-00305096-00305351": "when people are in a similar scenario to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01488-00305352-00305447": "that i was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01489-00305448-00305679": "um i now know how to respond to that i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01490-00305680-00305806": "know you know maybe", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01491-00305807-00305975": "what they might what could be helpful", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01492-00305976-00306134": "for them depending on what they're going", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01493-00306135-00306167": "through", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01494-00306168-00306343": "so that has changed my relationship with", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01495-00306344-00306630": "friends and the culture around me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01496-00306631-00307230": "great thanks alyssa and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01497-00307231-00307495": "the next question is for steven um so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01498-00307496-00307647": "the question is how did you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01499-00307648-00307847": "work in caregiving change the culture of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01500-00307848-00308047": "your work community", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01501-00308048-00308263": "yeah great question and i'll tell you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01502-00308264-00308367": "the first thing", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01503-00308368-00308679": "that it caused my work community to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01504-00308680-00308934": "take a step back because oftentimes in", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01505-00308935-00309071": "the military we're very", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01506-00309072-00309399": "hard charging go go go go and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01507-00309400-00309623": "what i found is that i had leadership", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01508-00309624-00309727": "that was very", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01509-00309728-00310006": "empathetic to what was going on and so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01510-00310007-00310247": "when i told them steven's story", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01511-00310248-00310454": "and helped them to understand that this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01512-00310455-00310654": "was not an isolated incident", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01513-00310655-00310967": "one and done they were very open to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01514-00310968-00311175": "allowing me to have that space", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01515-00311176-00311439": "to be an effective caregiver for my son", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01516-00311440-00311503": "so that meant", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01517-00311504-00311647": "hey if i've got to leave work in the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01518-00311648-00311791": "middle of the day to take him to an", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01519-00311792-00311943": "appointment because that was the only", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01520-00311944-00311999": "time", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01521-00312000-00312206": "that we could get it done they were okay", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01522-00312207-00312358": "with that but it took a lot of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01523-00312359-00312543": "communication between me", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01524-00312544-00312854": "and my my leadership team to understand", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01525-00312855-00313134": "uh what was going on that last little", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01526-00313135-00313303": "vignette you know i remember when we", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01527-00313304-00313487": "initially had our uh", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01528-00313488-00313767": "our transplant we were transported from", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01529-00313768-00313903": "langley virginia where i was stationed", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01530-00313904-00314143": "to georgetown hospital up in dc", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01531-00314144-00314463": "and my boss came to my house and packed", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01532-00314464-00314534": "up clothes", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01533-00314535-00314823": "and drove up to dc with bags in hand to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01534-00314824-00314910": "give to us", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01535-00314911-00315175": "and so it was that kind of just", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01536-00315176-00315295": "understanding", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01537-00315296-00315487": "that help them to realize what we're", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01538-00315488-00315647": "going through the second part of this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01539-00315648-00315782": "from an institutional", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01540-00315783-00316039": "standpoint in a sense that my advocacy", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01541-00316040-00316206": "through the patient and family advisory", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01542-00316207-00316351": "councils that i've sat on", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01543-00316352-00316567": "and really pushing at the defense health", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01544-00316568-00316679": "agency to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01545-00316680-00316879": "really collectively look at how we have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01546-00316880-00317023": "patients to get a voice", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01547-00317024-00317230": "um they've taken those things in into", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01548-00317231-00317327": "heart and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01549-00317328-00317495": "we're making positive changes so that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01550-00317496-00317734": "institutionally we recognize when we", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01551-00317735-00317854": "have caregivers that we have to make", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01552-00317855-00318015": "some special exceptions", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01553-00318016-00318182": "so they're able to do things for their", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01554-00318183-00318358": "family as well as continue to do their", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01555-00318359-00318399": "job", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01556-00318400-00318567": "so it was a hard mix but the mix was", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01557-00318568-00318791": "made easier or transitions made easier", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01558-00318792-00319119": "because of communication", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01559-00319120-00319367": "great thank you steven um and then the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01560-00319368-00319527": "last question is for theresa", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01561-00319528-00319703": "um the question is did you think of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01562-00319704-00319871": "writing your guidelines of how to take", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01563-00319872-00320054": "care of your patients as you care for", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01564-00320055-00320167": "your three people", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01565-00320168-00320375": "in your family and i assume that is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01566-00320376-00320471": "related to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01567-00320472-00320734": "your career in nursing can you read that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01568-00320735-00320823": "again i'm sorry", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01569-00320824-00321087": "i couldn't hear yeah did you think of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01570-00321088-00321303": "writing guidelines of how to take care", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01571-00321304-00321487": "of your patients as you care for the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01572-00321488-00322087": "three people in your family", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01573-00322088-00322303": "um actually i hate to say this i'm not", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01574-00322304-00322582": "sure what that means if you can", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01575-00322583-00322839": "that's okay um makaya i think you had", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01576-00322840-00323047": "submitted that question if you have any", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01577-00323048-00323119": "additional", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01578-00323120-00323295": "clarifying questions that you'd like to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01579-00323296-00323482": "pop into the chat that would be greatly", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01580-00323483-00323623": "appreciated", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01581-00323624-00323863": "and in the meantime we can definitely", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01582-00323864-00324054": "take your question offline and ensure", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01583-00324055-00324247": "that all of our panelists answer them", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01584-00324248-00324630": "appropriately so teresa i almost wonder", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01585-00324631-00324782": "if she's sort of saying you you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01586-00324783-00324982": "as a nurse you've done this and now", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01587-00324983-00325191": "you've done it for several people like", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01588-00325192-00325430": "what would be those suggestions here's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01589-00325431-00325495": "my", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01590-00325496-00325799": "maybe top five things i would suggest", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01591-00325800-00325991": "caregivers do maybe it's like", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01592-00325992-00326334": "you um have a tracking list of meds i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01593-00326335-00326567": "i don't know i'm okay you could think of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01594-00326568-00326782": "you know to decipher", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01595-00326783-00327087": "well i guess is she on", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01596-00327088-00327254": "verify that that's what she she's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01597-00327255-00327399": "referring to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01598-00327400-00327734": "so i guess one of the things is", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01599-00327735-00327943": "advanced preparation if you can so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01600-00327944-00328103": "questions that you have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01601-00328104-00328382": "that you need answered um yes some", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01602-00328383-00328599": "medications a medication list that you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01603-00328600-00328782": "would always have with you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01604-00328783-00329263": "the list of what your diagnoses are and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01605-00329264-00329495": "preparing i know they start preparing", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01606-00329496-00329671": "for", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01607-00329672-00329871": "the end at the beginning whether it's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01608-00329872-00330103": "discharge or whether it's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01609-00330104-00330303": "the end of the visit and what comes next", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01610-00330304-00330415": "or whatever", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01611-00330416-00330782": "so having people that you know", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01612-00330783-00331103": "are dependable that may help you and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01613-00331104-00331358": "being able to ask those people", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01614-00331359-00331567": "for specific things i know when i came", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01615-00331568-00331727": "home from the hospital the first time", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01616-00331728-00331887": "when jack had his injury", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01617-00331888-00332023": "i'm a nurse i thought i was all", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01618-00332024-00332199": "organized we had had the house different", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01619-00332200-00332351": "things fixed up", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01620-00332352-00332575": "the first by the first night i had", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01621-00332576-00332743": "everything strewn around the floor", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01622-00332744-00332927": "medications everywhere i couldn't find", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01623-00332928-00333134": "anything and i'm thinking how", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01624-00333135-00333367": "am i ever going to do this so the next", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01625-00333368-00333503": "day i was on the phone with", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01626-00333504-00333782": "resources helping me family members etc", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01627-00333783-00333839": "but", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01628-00333840-00334023": "having some of those people and having", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01629-00334024-00334191": "some things", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01630-00334192-00334527": "prepared ahead of time and the person", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01631-00334528-00334671": "that you're with", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01632-00334672-00334934": "talking to them and seeing what do they", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01633-00334935-00335110": "want you to do", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01634-00335111-00335319": "do they want you to back off today and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01635-00335320-00335503": "they want to take front and center", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01636-00335504-00335654": "do they want you to take front and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01637-00335655-00335854": "center do they need you to ask the", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01638-00335855-00336047": "questions do they want to ask and have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01639-00336048-00336310": "you clarify do they want you to be there", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01640-00336311-00336471": "do they not want you to be there so i", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01641-00336472-00336606": "think there's", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01642-00336607-00336927": "that piece too which is really important", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01643-00336928-00337158": "and respecting that person and that they", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01644-00337159-00337287": "really are", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01645-00337288-00337734": "front and center", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01646-00337735-00338103": "thank you so sarah i'll let you", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01647-00338104-00338303": "um wrap it up because we're coming to", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01648-00338304-00338495": "the top of the hour", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01649-00338496-00338727": "yeah so um thank you all so much for", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01650-00338728-00338943": "sharing such powerful stories", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01651-00338944-00339167": "i know that carol you briefly went", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01652-00339168-00339303": "through this but for those of you that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01653-00339304-00339454": "are looking at my screen", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01654-00339455-00339751": "carol did provide a few really useful", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01655-00339752-00339975": "resources for family caregivers and we", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01656-00339976-00340223": "will be uploading this pdf version of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01657-00340224-00340382": "our powerpoint presentation on our", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01658-00340383-00340495": "website so", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01659-00340496-00340654": "i would really encourage you all to take", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01660-00340655-00340927": "a look obviously we've highlighted a few", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01661-00340928-00341119": "main points for some of these resources", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01662-00341120-00341230": "but there is a lot of", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01663-00341231-00341447": "information on the link so i would again", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01664-00341448-00341654": "encourage you all to take a look", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01665-00341655-00341830": "but i know we have just a few minutes", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01666-00341831-00342047": "but again thank you all so much we", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01667-00342048-00342334": "we have a lot of really um moving things", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01668-00342335-00342495": "in the chat i know that there are a few", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01669-00342496-00342606": "people that have", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01670-00342607-00342830": "lost children themselves at a young age", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01671-00342831-00343095": "to pediatric cancer for example and", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01672-00343096-00343287": "i will just echo all of these stories", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01673-00343288-00343495": "really speak volumes so thank you again", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01674-00343496-00343758": "um very very brave of you all to share", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01675-00343759-00343919": "your stories with us and we hope that", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01676-00343920-00343975": "this", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01677-00343976-00344134": "is a really helpful narrative to push", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01678-00344135-00344271": "forward while you do what we do here at", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01679-00344272-00344382": "the foundation", "TvJr0dM9Rny-01680-00344383-00344783": "so thank you again"}}, {"audio_id": "TvU1-gzXu30", "text": {"TvU1-gzXu30-00000-00000038-00000250": "and these problems were asked to", "TvU1-gzXu30-00001-00000252-00000440": "subtract and write our answer in", "TvU1-gzXu30-00002-00000441-00000733": "simplest form I have common denominator", "TvU1-gzXu30-00003-00000734-00001127": "5/8 minus 1/8 I can look at this", "TvU1-gzXu30-00004-00001128-00001424": "subtraction as five copies of 1/8 minus", "TvU1-gzXu30-00005-00001425-00001850": "one copy of 1/8 that would leave us for", "TvU1-gzXu30-00006-00001851-00002300": "copies of 1/8 which is 4 or 8 I should", "TvU1-gzXu30-00007-00002301-00002720": "reduce that using common factors so the", "TvU1-gzXu30-00008-00002721-00003034": "numerator is 1 times 4 the denominator", "TvU1-gzXu30-00009-00003035-00003458": "is 2 times 4 I'm going to remove 4 over", "TvU1-gzXu30-00010-00003459-00003756": "for leaving me with the final result of", "TvU1-gzXu30-00011-00003757-00004625": "1/2 in Part B I have 11 copies of 1 12-7", "TvU1-gzXu30-00012-00004626-00004751": "copies of 1/12", "TvU1-gzXu30-00013-00004752-00005234": "that leaves me for copies of 1/12 again", "TvU1-gzXu30-00014-00005235-00005729": "I can use common factors 4 is 4 times 1", "TvU1-gzXu30-00015-00005730-00006334": "over 12 which is 4 times 3 remove the", "TvU1-gzXu30-00016-00006335-00006628": "common factor and I have left my final", "TvU1-gzXu30-00017-00006629-00007015": "result of 1/3"}}, {"audio_id": "TvWr24fKcug", "text": {"TvWr24fKcug-00000-00000077-00009467": "[Music]", "TvWr24fKcug-00001-00009468-00009502": "[Applause]", "TvWr24fKcug-00002-00009503-00011283": "[Music]", "TvWr24fKcug-00003-00011284-00012802": "so", "TvWr24fKcug-00004-00012803-00015483": "[Music]", "TvWr24fKcug-00005-00015484-00016436": "so", "TvWr24fKcug-00006-00016437-00018783": "[Music]", "TvWr24fKcug-00007-00018784-00018992": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "TvYCJzbLHgU", "text": {"TvYCJzbLHgU-00000-00000000-00000098": "foreign", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00001-00000099-00000841": "[Music]", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00002-00000842-00001091": "from the UK's Royal United Services", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00003-00001092-00001258": "Institute for defense and Security", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00004-00001259-00001499": "Services thank you for joining me today", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00005-00001500-00001601": "Joelle", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00006-00001602-00001787": "thank you for having me Andrew could you", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00007-00001788-00002002": "kind of give us an overview of where you", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00008-00002003-00002302": "think Libya sits today with regard to", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00009-00002303-00002597": "its instability and the issues that we", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00010-00002598-00002833": "see in the divisions around the country", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00011-00002834-00003118": "and tell us how you think foreign", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00012-00003119-00003335": "interventions are playing into that yeah", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00013-00003336-00003653": "this is a a strange moment because I", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00014-00003654-00003749": "think the first thing I should", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00015-00003750-00003959": "acknowledge is there's no hot War", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00016-00003960-00004267": "there's no conflict per se there's no", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00017-00004268-00004517": "large-scale violence people are not", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00018-00004518-00004727": "dying every day like they used to during", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00019-00004728-00004954": "for instance the last bout of the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00020-00004955-00005129": "internationalized Civil War that", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00021-00005130-00005452": "happened between April 2019 and June", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00022-00005453-00005567": "2020", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00023-00005568-00005867": "it's been more than 27 or 28 months now", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00024-00005868-00006070": "that hasn't been except a few Exceptions", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00025-00006071-00006256": "there has been a few", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00026-00006257-00006569": "very violent days here and there but", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00027-00006570-00006923": "there's no war per se uh there is of", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00028-00006923-00007253": "course a situation where Libya is a", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00029-00007254-00007546": "textbook case of fragility and and lack", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00030-00007547-00007841": "of stability the the country is very", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00031-00007842-00008183": "much divided this huge amounts of", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00032-00008184-00008495": "political and governance dysfunction", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00033-00008496-00008760": "to rival Prime Ministers", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00034-00008761-00009142": "a legal conflict happening big", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00035-00009143-00009353": "disagreements", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00036-00009354-00009563": "um and of course a very divided uh", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00037-00009564-00009946": "country with not only the East and West", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00038-00009947-00010199": "divide that everybody kind of is aware", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00039-00010200-00010463": "of but you have now a more and more", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00040-00010464-00010846": "Vivid division within the Northwestern", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00041-00010847-00011092": "part of of Libya the part that is", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00042-00011093-00011392": "supposed to be entirely and", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00043-00011393-00011651": "monolithically uh in favor of turkey", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00044-00011652-00011869": "turkey is is of course a military", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00045-00011870-00012113": "militarily present in the northwest of", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00046-00012114-00012419": "Libya but there's a some factions that", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00047-00012420-00012623": "are that considered turkey friendly and", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00048-00012624-00012916": "others that that basically Harbor a very", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00049-00012917-00013216": "anti-turkey sentiment so the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00050-00013218-00013493": "Northwestern part of Libya the one that", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00051-00013494-00013769": "thought has just won peace against the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00052-00013769-00013972": "rebel commander based in the east by the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00053-00013973-00014386": "name of uh field Marshall haftar the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00054-00014387-00014608": "Northwestern part of Libya we remember", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00055-00014609-00014986": "it as being relatively cohesive in 2019", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00056-00014987-00015358": "to 2020 now the big the big development", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00057-00015359-00015641": "over the last several months is that it", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00058-00015641-00015838": "has become very very divided so you have", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00059-00015840-00016025": "the division within Northwestern Libya", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00060-00016026-00016133": "and then you have the east and west", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00061-00016134-00016336": "division", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00062-00016337-00016672": "and of course a lack of stability across", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00063-00016673-00016967": "the entire territory even though the two", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00064-00016968-00017225": "styles of governance the one centered on", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00065-00017226-00017519": "Benghazi and ProBook is very different", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00066-00017520-00017813": "from the one centered on mistrata and", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00067-00017814-00018108": "Tripoli so big division", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00068-00018109-00018461": "actors that haven't abandoned the idea", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00069-00018462-00018736": "of Waging War there could be a relapse", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00070-00018737-00019222": "into Civil War almost any week now but I", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00071-00019223-00019444": "must acknowledge that that hasn't there", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00072-00019445-00019739": "has been a form of a very approximate", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00073-00019740-00020063": "very rough piece over the last two years", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00074-00020064-00020350": "or so and and Corruption has been", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00075-00020351-00020567": "growing this function has been growing", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00076-00020568-00020903": "fragmentation has been deepening with no", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00077-00020904-00021208": "real solution or any Prospect for", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00078-00021209-00021430": "elections within the foreseeable future", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00079-00021431-00021617": "to go back to the foreign States the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00080-00021618-00021785": "foreign states are still present I", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00081-00021786-00022199": "mentioned turkey but you have still as I", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00082-00022200-00022549": "speak to you roughly 2000 Russian", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00083-00022550-00022972": "Personnel present on Libyan soil you", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00084-00022973-00023213": "know keeping a low profile not trying to", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00085-00023214-00023447": "draw attention except a few incidents", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00086-00023448-00023675": "which we can discuss if you wish and", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00087-00023676-00023897": "then you have a very active very", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00088-00023898-00024178": "aggressive Egypt not so much militarily", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00089-00024179-00024436": "but in terms of interfering with the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00090-00024437-00024743": "diplomacy interfering with the internal", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00091-00024744-00025121": "politics of Libya you have a France that", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00092-00025122-00025378": "is very close to Egypt", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00093-00025379-00025643": "that used to be close to the UAE but", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00094-00025644-00025828": "today France tends to work hand in hand", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00095-00025829-00026081": "with with Egypt that happens to be on", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00096-00026082-00026345": "the same side of Russia and yes we have", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00097-00026345-00026543": "a NATO member that happens to be on the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00098-00026544-00026777": "same side of Russia in Libya and then", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00099-00026777-00026974": "one uh other thing that I should mention", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00100-00026975-00027262": "is the fact that the UAE that used to be", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00101-00027263-00027557": "the most consequential interfere in", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00102-00027558-00027868": "Libya particularly during the years 2014", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00103-00027869-00028170": "all the way to 2020 today", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00104-00028172-00028589": "is much more pragmatic careful prudent", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00105-00028589-00028870": "and and not so much on the side of", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00106-00028872-00029155": "Eastern Libya there's a form of sympathy", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00107-00029156-00029555": "with the government in Tripoli oddly", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00108-00029556-00029812": "enough between the UAE and uh and the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00109-00029813-00030046": "current situation so it's things are", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00110-00030047-00030317": "kind of moving you have constants that", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00111-00030318-00030568": "feel familiar but you have also", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00112-00030569-00030958": "differences and all those states are not", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00113-00030960-00031162": "pursuing you know very aggressive", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00114-00031163-00031373": "policies but all of this could get", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00115-00031374-00031667": "survived within a couple of weeks if the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00116-00031668-00031996": "libyans themselves resume War", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00117-00031997-00032249": "Could you actually as you offered give", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00118-00032250-00032399": "me a little bit more about the the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00119-00032400-00032681": "Russian presence in Libya where are they", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00120-00032682-00032987": "and what does their presence mean", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00121-00032988-00033179": "well it's a it's a little bit of a", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00122-00033180-00033599": "contradictory uh stance because uh by", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00123-00033600-00033899": "now there's a mountain of evidence that", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00124-00033900-00034321": "the Russians do not obey their main host", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00125-00034322-00034589": "the main host of course is Field Marshal", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00126-00034590-00034823": "haftar and his sons those are the actors", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00127-00034824-00035099": "that brought Russia in", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00128-00035100-00035387": "um several years ago now Russia", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00129-00035388-00035674": "basically feels home it's happy to have", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00130-00035675-00035921": "this clandestine presence especially", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00131-00035922-00036251": "when the price doesn't cover it uh and", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00132-00036252-00036479": "the relationship is uh is contradictory", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00133-00036480-00036712": "because on the one hand there's huge", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00134-00036713-00037115": "pressure on the part of this mercenary", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00135-00037116-00037396": "Mission if you will that demands to be", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00136-00037397-00037690": "paid uh there's huge pressure on on", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00137-00037691-00037985": "Marshall haftar to to pay uh for the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00138-00037986-00038159": "bills there was a moment when the UAE", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00139-00038160-00038351": "was happy to pay at least part of this", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00140-00038352-00038627": "bill particularly in the years 2019-2020", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00141-00038628-00038945": "but now there are a few Clues and", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00142-00038946-00039190": "indications that that there's a kind of", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00143-00039191-00039509": "a tab accumulating on the side of of", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00144-00039510-00039755": "hafta or vis-a-vis the the Russian", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00145-00039756-00040127": "friends that he thinks that he has so", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00146-00040128-00040301": "um they don't obey they basically do", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00147-00040302-00040511": "whatever they want there's no", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00148-00040512-00040715": "relationship of uh you know client", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00149-00040716-00040967": "provider but but they still still", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00150-00040968-00041302": "provide and vital protection for for", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00151-00041303-00041590": "haftar and his entire structure which", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00152-00041591-00041868": "exists in the East also in the southwest", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00153-00041869-00042185": "and if you if you were to draw a map you", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00154-00042186-00042499": "would see the Russian Mission presence", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00155-00042500-00042851": "in cities like cert which is smack in", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00156-00042852-00043109": "the middle in terms of the actual coast", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00157-00043110-00043349": "of Libya they're present in juffra", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00158-00043350-00043607": "they're present in the military Camp of", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00159-00043608-00043937": "brakashati which is uh in the fazan and", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00160-00043938-00044087": "then you have more and more talk of", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00161-00044088-00044351": "additional points of presence uh rush so", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00162-00044352-00044507": "basically it amounts to a line of", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00163-00044508-00044837": "defense that uh if it were to disappear", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00164-00044838-00045137": "this um if this line of defense were to", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00165-00045138-00045461": "disappear then the vulnerability of the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00166-00045462-00045743": "film martial halves are after armed", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00167-00045744-00045952": "Coalition would increase dramatically", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00168-00045953-00046057": "because", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00169-00046058-00046343": "turkey and its Libyan friends are still", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00170-00046344-00046595": "present of course in Northwestern Libya", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00171-00046596-00046787": "so they would be all of a sudden much", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00172-00046788-00046961": "more likely to conduct a military", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00173-00046962-00047302": "campaign pain to grab let's say the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00174-00047303-00047555": "Strategic oil facilities of the coast", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00175-00047556-00048073": "for instance so Russia is vital to hafta", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00176-00048074-00048407": "buttar of course is not vital at all to", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00177-00048408-00048593": "to Russia so you have this very", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00178-00048594-00048917": "symmetrical very dysfunctional uh", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00179-00048918-00049223": "relationship that exists and um and and", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00180-00049224-00049457": "the dependencies is definitely on on One", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00181-00049458-00049618": "Direction in One Direction the one that", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00182-00049619-00049883": "I highlighted what about turkey's role", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00183-00049884-00050123": "with the government of national Unity", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00184-00050124-00050357": "I've seen recent news lately about an", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00185-00050358-00050693": "mou signed um could you explain more", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00186-00050694-00050974": "about this relationship and and and", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00187-00050975-00051202": "um and and more about what it means", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00188-00051203-00051485": "today yeah I mean something that was uh", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00189-00051486-00052030": "very clear even before uh the 2019 uh", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00190-00052032-00052426": "War the the April fourth War as Legends", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00191-00052427-00052601": "call it even before that there were", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00192-00052602-00052942": "there were clear indications that uh", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00193-00052944-00053380": "turkey wanted uh to utilize its", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00194-00053382-00053794": "relationship with Tripoli and misrata uh", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00195-00053795-00053999": "for very selfish reasons and very", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00196-00054000-00054244": "material reasons", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00197-00054245-00054491": "um and one aspect the other aspect you", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00198-00054491-00054635": "know that have that have to do with", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00199-00054636-00054875": "nationalism and assertiveness and", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00200-00054876-00055138": "expansionism but there's another very", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00201-00055139-00055444": "very important driver or motivation it's", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00202-00055445-00055744": "just this idea of recovering the 20", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00203-00055745-00056026": "billion dollar piece of business that", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00204-00056027-00056380": "turkey saw suspended in February 2011", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00205-00056382-00056723": "when the day uprisings began against uh", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00206-00056724-00057011": "Gaddafi turkey I'm talking about turkey", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00207-00057012-00057316": "key of erdogan the same leader as we", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00208-00057317-00057432": "have now", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00209-00057433-00057838": "even you know in those years 2008 2000", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00210-00057839-00058235": "over maybe as early as 2005 until 2011.", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00211-00058236-00058487": "there was a love affair between Muammar", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00212-00058488-00058859": "Gaddafi and the turkey of erdogan and", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00213-00058860-00059116": "that very concretely speaking gave rise", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00214-00059117-00059549": "to a whole series of contracts signed", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00215-00059550-00059704": "between the two of course you know", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00216-00059705-00059909": "Olivia was making a lot of money at the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00217-00059910-00060113": "time because hydrocarbon prices were", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00218-00060114-00060335": "high and it was using a big portion of", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00219-00060336-00060611": "its money to um to order constructions", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00220-00060612-00060925": "of infrastructure you know", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00221-00060926-00061211": "obtaining potentially energy contracts", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00222-00061212-00061450": "and building airports and so on and so", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00223-00061451-00061613": "forth and a lot of those contracts", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00224-00061614-00061871": "basically became suspended in February", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00225-00061872-00062182": "2011 and when turkey came back in force", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00226-00062183-00062603": "in 2019 it was with the explicit goal of", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00227-00062604-00062730": "really", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00228-00062732-00063113": "pressuring this uh supposed friend in", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00229-00063114-00063365": "Tripoli to revive all that all of that", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00230-00063366-00063694": "business and here we are in October 2022", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00231-00063695-00063857": "and", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00232-00063858-00064079": "um the pro-turkey Prime Minister", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00233-00064079-00064307": "currently in place in Tripoli hasn't", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00234-00064308-00064666": "really delivered much so what we saw uh", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00235-00064667-00064975": "earlier this month was basically turkey", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00236-00064976-00065254": "uh pounding on the table and say wake up", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00237-00065255-00065537": "you know we need to get paid we you know", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00238-00065538-00065782": "we're not here because we are altruistic", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00239-00065783-00066011": "we're not Mother Teresa we need our", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00240-00066012-00066197": "money and we're talking about billions", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00241-00066198-00066419": "and billions so", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00242-00066420-00066556": "um of course that comes with the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00243-00066557-00066809": "maritime Dimension that is very", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00244-00066810-00067061": "important uh especially knowing that", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00245-00067062-00067432": "erdogan has to face those historic uh", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00246-00067433-00067732": "elections in June 2023 so this there's", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00247-00067733-00067931": "also a need to please the nationalistic", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00248-00067932-00068213": "currents within turkey itself but the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00249-00068214-00068453": "money aspect is is something that I", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00250-00068454-00068753": "cannot overemphasize the Turks have", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00251-00068754-00069035": "every intention of not just being happy", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00252-00069036-00069238": "with the few billion dollars that", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00253-00069239-00069376": "they've received over the last couple of", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00254-00069377-00069700": "years they want more they want like you", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00255-00069701-00069856": "know recover or something at least you", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00256-00069857-00069988": "know 15 billion dollars over the next", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00257-00069989-00070253": "few years and uh and that's what you saw", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00258-00070254-00070625": "in the form of that mou what about uh", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00259-00070626-00071015": "the Berlin process and the more sort of", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00260-00071016-00071321": "uh internationally supported process for", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00261-00071322-00071638": "for peace is that completely stalled is", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00262-00071639-00071825": "there any hope for it to continue in the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00263-00071826-00072197": "future it is stalled uh but I'm still", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00264-00072198-00072521": "hopeful uh and actually that's that has", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00265-00072522-00072749": "to do with the the United States because", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00266-00072750-00073006": "you know you heard me speak you know I I", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00267-00073007-00073211": "never mentioned the United States and", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00268-00073212-00073343": "that it's not because the United States", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00269-00073344-00073613": "cannot make a difference because", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00270-00073614-00073835": "over the last several years it has kind", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00271-00073836-00074081": "of you know we are all heard of the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00272-00074082-00074356": "moment when the White House gave a green", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00273-00074357-00074675": "light to the UAE backed offensive uh in", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00274-00074676-00075023": "April 2019 we had of the moment when", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00275-00075024-00075293": "turkey was able to interfere in a", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00276-00075294-00075571": "massive way uh exactly two years ago", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00277-00075572-00075826": "this wouldn't have been possible without", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00278-00075827-00076144": "a modicum of coordination approval from", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00279-00076145-00076337": "uh from Washington", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00280-00076338-00076655": "so but but now I think we are uh the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00281-00076656-00076841": "verge of a moment when when maybe", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00282-00076842-00077032": "potentially Washington could actually", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00283-00077033-00077338": "start making a difference directly you", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00284-00077339-00077723": "know this it could we could see it play", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00285-00077724-00078059": "more leadership role um and I think it", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00286-00078060-00078281": "would make sense in terms of the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00287-00078282-00078587": "fragility theme of your series", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00288-00078588-00078767": "um so one one thing we could see for", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00289-00078768-00079103": "example uh would be a salvo of sanctions", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00290-00079104-00079517": "against a bunch of uh Libyan spoilers so", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00291-00079518-00079732": "that could if it's carefully calibrated", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00292-00079733-00080117": "if it's designed decently it could scare", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00293-00080118-00080453": "this uh ruling Elite that kind of is", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00294-00080454-00080747": "enjoying this moment of unaccountability", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00295-00080748-00080981": "for the last two years especially during", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00296-00080982-00081305": "uh in in peace circumstances it's easy", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00297-00081306-00081532": "to kind of forget that there will ever", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00298-00081533-00081712": "be a punishment for for all the money", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00299-00081713-00081988": "you stole and you can just kind of enjoy", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00300-00081989-00082271": "the moment all of this could actually be", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00301-00082272-00082565": "disrupted uh in a very constructive way", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00302-00082566-00082859": "if uh if the US were to play a more sort", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00303-00082860-00083044": "of role and it didn't doesn't take much", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00304-00083045-00083206": "so", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00305-00083207-00083482": "um uh if if such a scare could be", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00306-00083483-00083825": "instilled in the ruling Elite that is", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00307-00083826-00084011": "largely responsible for preventing", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00308-00084012-00084203": "elections last year", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00309-00084204-00084431": "what we could see is an opening towards", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00310-00084432-00084779": "maybe a a a more", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00311-00084780-00085079": "um you know a more realistic attempt at", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00312-00085080-00085282": "uh at elections one that actually", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00313-00085283-00085612": "reflects all the Lessons Learned uh last", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00314-00085613-00085787": "year but you need to scare the libyans", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00315-00085788-00085955": "and only the United States could do that", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00316-00085956-00086309": "so if you do this you would scare the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00317-00086310-00086537": "libyans but you would also send the", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00318-00086538-00086765": "signal to the foreign interference", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00319-00086766-00086944": "behind them because every meaningful", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00320-00086945-00087299": "Elite in Libya has of course uh friends", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00321-00087300-00087479": "in high places outside you know in", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00322-00087480-00087761": "foreign capitals so it's it would be it", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00323-00087762-00088000": "would be a good way to say look this", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00324-00088001-00088241": "cannot go on forever and we don't like", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00325-00088242-00088403": "corruption we don't like what you're", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00326-00088404-00088655": "doing we we're we're not going to let", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00327-00088656-00088912": "you rule Libya Forever Without a mandate", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00328-00088913-00089165": "without legitimacy without structures", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00329-00089166-00089417": "without a legal framework why don't we", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00330-00089418-00089626": "just cool off a little bit so this is", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00331-00089627-00089825": "the kind of hope hope that I have that", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00332-00089826-00090082": "I'm currently harboring uh visibility", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00333-00090083-00090317": "well thank you so much for that I mean", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00334-00090318-00090706": "we we see this this constant pivot from", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00335-00090707-00091012": "cynicism to Hope and cynicism to Hope in", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00336-00091013-00091337": "Libya and uh it's good to to end on a", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00337-00091338-00091655": "hopeful note I I too hope that Libya can", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00338-00091656-00091876": "find more stability in the Libyan people", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00339-00091877-00092171": "can can transition finally out of this", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00340-00092172-00092465": "this this period of cycles of of war and", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00341-00092466-00092681": "and insecurity", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00342-00092682-00092806": "um but thank you for your insights", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00343-00092807-00092993": "they've been really really helpful and", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00344-00092994-00093173": "and I appreciate it thank you for coming", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00345-00093174-00093347": "thank you for being here", "TvYCJzbLHgU-00346-00093348-00093648": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "Tvb5pZ-BVqy", "text": {"Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00000-00000042-00000371": "take that cancer and welcome this is", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00001-00000372-00000730": "Renee and this will be your May 2023", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00002-00000731-00000994": "reading so we'll take a look and see", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00003-00000996-00001691": "what is going on for you in May okay so", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00004-00001692-00001889": "let's go ahead and jump in we're going", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00005-00001889-00002176": "to take a look at Love and Money", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00006-00002177-00002491": "and what other General messages come out", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00007-00002492-00002752": "I will also take a look at what's", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00008-00002753-00002968": "challenging you this month and get some", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00009-00002969-00003383": "advice okay now I will be pulling a", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00010-00003384-00003688": "fortune Oracle so stay tuned to the end", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00011-00003689-00003983": "when I give you the extended meeting for", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00012-00003984-00004111": "that", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00013-00004112-00004529": "and I'll be pulling your angel number", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00014-00004530-00005015": "okay so stay tuned for the ends", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00015-00005016-00005320": "okay cancer Let's see we have a stay", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00016-00005321-00005668": "optimistic about your love life positive", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00017-00005669-00005849": "thinking and faith will bring you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00018-00005850-00005999": "Romance", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00019-00006000-00006347": "okay so I feel like when it comes to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00020-00006348-00006460": "romance", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00021-00006461-00006748": "whether you're connected or not", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00022-00006750-00007037": "my beautiful cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00023-00007038-00007403": "stay optimistic keep yourself in a", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00024-00007404-00007745": "positive High vibration", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00025-00007745-00007996": "and as long as you're in that high", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00026-00007997-00008177": "vibration good things are going to come", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00027-00008178-00008405": "to you they're going to be drawn to you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00028-00008406-00008674": "okay so let's go ahead and take a look", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00029-00008675-00008939": "and see what is going on with Cancer's", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00030-00008940-00009089": "money", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00031-00009090-00009287": "what do we have for cancerous money", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00032-00009288-00009485": "please", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00033-00009486-00009749": "we have be bold and make the first move", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00034-00009750-00009928": "so if there's something that you've been", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00035-00009929-00010192": "thinking about doing cancer if there's", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00036-00010193-00010385": "something that has been on your mind", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00037-00010386-00010655": "that you've been wanting to start now is", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00038-00010656-00010942": "the time to take that move you know just", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00039-00010943-00011213": "get something out there just put", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00040-00011214-00011446": "something together if you want them to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00041-00011447-00011746": "start a business test the waters you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00042-00011747-00011914": "know see if you're going to have any", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00043-00011915-00012353": "takers for your service okay if it's", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00044-00012354-00012533": "starting a YouTube channel or starting", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00045-00012534-00012796": "something similar to that you know go", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00046-00012797-00013055": "ahead and just do it you know the faster", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00047-00013056-00013229": "you do something the faster you start", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00048-00013230-00013415": "something the faster you're going to get", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00049-00013416-00013588": "results", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00050-00013590-00013853": "okay and I feel like me is going to be", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00051-00013854-00014135": "the most opportune time for you to start", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00052-00014136-00014338": "okay we have the number eight the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00053-00014340-00014530": "dragonfly", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00054-00014531-00014813": "have confidence during this time of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00055-00014813-00015113": "great joy renewal and connection to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00056-00015113-00015227": "Spirit", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00057-00015228-00015485": "okay so like I said stay tuned to the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00058-00015486-00015743": "end and I will read that the extended", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00059-00015744-00015941": "message", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00060-00015941-00016175": "for that card", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00061-00016176-00016553": "okay let's get into the tarot", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00062-00016554-00016889": "what do we have for cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00063-00016890-00017027": "first of all we're going to take a look", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00064-00017028-00017536": "at love", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00065-00017537-00018005": "give me a message on Cancer's love life", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00066-00018006-00018311": "during the month of May", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00067-00018312-00018677": "what is going on with Cancer's love life", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00068-00018678-00018922": "in the month of May please", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00069-00018923-00019408": "another", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00070-00019409-00019769": "message for cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00071-00019770-00020086": "the month of May 2023", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00072-00020087-00020453": "okay we have the King of Swords", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00073-00020454-00020800": "okay we have the three of swords", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00074-00020801-00020963": "wow", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00075-00020964-00021311": "okay more messages for cancer please", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00076-00021312-00021749": "more messages for cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00077-00021750-00022030": "and what is going on in May", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00078-00022031-00023147": "2023", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00079-00023148-00023417": "okay we have the two excuse me the page", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00080-00023418-00024394": "of cups", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00081-00024395-00024814": "we have the page of Wait no that's the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00082-00024815-00025287": "Knight of Pentacles", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00083-00025288-00026044": "[Applause]", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00084-00026045-00026273": "okay and we have the page of Pentacles", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00085-00026274-00026501": "and the Knight of Pentacles and the page", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00086-00026502-00026729": "of Pentacles are both in refers", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00087-00026730-00027029": "okay at the bottom we have the Queen of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00088-00027030-00027443": "Swords energy so I feel like if this is", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00089-00027444-00027664": "a love interaction I feel like you and", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00090-00027666-00027857": "this person really need to talk you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00091-00027858-00028037": "really need to speak your truth someone", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00092-00028038-00028343": "needs to tell you something something is", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00093-00028344-00028618": "going to come out or be revealed okay", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00094-00028619-00028967": "someone this King of Swords wants to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00095-00028968-00029333": "deliver the truth to you right", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00096-00029333-00029767": "um I feel like it's going to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00097-00029768-00030083": "bring some discouragement", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00098-00030083-00030251": "okay there is going to be some", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00099-00030252-00030496": "discouragement here but your overall", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00100-00030497-00030767": "energy you have a love offer or an", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00101-00030768-00031049": "apology so if you're currently in a", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00102-00031050-00031181": "relationship I feel like you're", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00103-00031182-00031462": "significant other may need to reveal", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00104-00031463-00031846": "something to you okay but there is an", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00105-00031847-00032189": "apology this person is very apologetic", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00106-00032189-00032399": "you know", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00107-00032400-00032561": "um", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00108-00032562-00032783": "and they just want to get things off of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00109-00032784-00032909": "their chest", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00110-00032910-00033149": "you know this is for you or the person", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00111-00033150-00033359": "that you're dealing with if you're not", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00112-00033360-00033539": "dealing with anybody at the moment I", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00113-00033540-00033724": "feel like you've been alone for a very", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00114-00033725-00033983": "long time and that's leaving you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00115-00033984-00034229": "discouraged but I feel like there is a", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00116-00034230-00034540": "love offer here for some of you there is", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00117-00034541-00034990": "someone who's offering you some kind of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00118-00034991-00035374": "um offer today to go out to get to know", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00119-00035375-00035837": "each other or so forth okay now for the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00120-00035838-00036107": "Knight of Pentacles", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00121-00036108-00036418": "and the page of Pentacles in reverse", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00122-00036419-00036689": "I feel like you know with this Knight of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00123-00036690-00036881": "Pentacles in Reverse someone really", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00124-00036882-00037289": "wants someone may be very obsessive", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00125-00037290-00037667": "you know there may be someone who is", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00126-00037668-00037979": "maybe with this love offer here someone", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00127-00037980-00038230": "is kind of obsessing over you they're", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00128-00038231-00038549": "thinking about you a lot you know", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00129-00038550-00038812": "um but I feel like you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00130-00038813-00039173": "cancer you're kind of feeling like", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00131-00039174-00039455": "you're not even", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00132-00039456-00039743": "seeing what this person is doing okay", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00133-00039744-00040174": "you have a lack of desire as to even", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00134-00040175-00040307": "notice", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00135-00040308-00040655": "that this person is obsessing over you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00136-00040656-00040852": "this person may be looking at your", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00137-00040853-00041080": "social media they may be looking at your", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00138-00041081-00041279": "you know", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00139-00041280-00041585": "um", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00140-00041586-00042046": "other Medias or maybe just watching you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00141-00042047-00042305": "from afar from a distance", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00142-00042306-00042623": "okay but I feel like someone is very", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00143-00042624-00042887": "interested someone's actually trying to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00144-00042888-00043343": "show a great interest in you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00145-00043344-00043702": "and I feel like at this moment you may", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00146-00043703-00043918": "be concentrating on your career on your", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00147-00043919-00044117": "money on other things maybe you're going", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00148-00044118-00044321": "to school you know you may be", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00149-00044322-00044507": "concentrating on other things and you're", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00150-00044508-00044824": "not even noticing that this person is", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00151-00044825-00045287": "you know really taking a strong interest", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00152-00045288-00045418": "in you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00153-00045419-00045707": "okay because I'm not sure if they're", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00154-00045708-00045952": "making it obvious to you or not you know", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00155-00045953-00046187": "we have the Queen of Pentacles and we", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00156-00046188-00046408": "have the Eight of Cups", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00157-00046409-00046901": "excuse me that's the Queen of Swords", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00158-00046902-00047195": "yeah I feel like you know you may not", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00159-00047196-00047458": "even notice this person", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00160-00047459-00047740": "you may have a clear head a clear mind", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00161-00047741-00047902": "at the moment and you're not even", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00162-00047903-00048107": "noticing", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00163-00048108-00048401": "um you may have just let this person go", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00164-00048402-00048658": "you may have just walked away from this", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00165-00048659-00048821": "person and this person really wants to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00166-00048822-00049049": "communicate with you it very well may be", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00167-00049050-00049205": "someone from the past", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00168-00049206-00049462": "someone who still holds an interest", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00169-00049463-00049751": "right but I feel like you have your", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00170-00049752-00050074": "intentions on other things you are you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00171-00050075-00050285": "know making your mind up that other", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00172-00050286-00050530": "things are more important than whatever", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00173-00050531-00051023": "this person is doing in the background", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00174-00051024-00051196": "because I feel like", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00175-00051197-00051430": "and I simply feel like you don't have", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00176-00051432-00051742": "any interest that you're moving forward", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00177-00051744-00052102": "right uh you may have left this person", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00178-00052103-00052444": "behind for one reason or another", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00179-00052445-00052625": "you know because we see the Eight of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00180-00052626-00052859": "Cups here you know so you walked away", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00181-00052860-00053063": "from this person or you walked away from", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00182-00053064-00053182": "this energy", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00183-00053183-00053459": "you just said that you you really don't", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00184-00053460-00053669": "have time for it you don't have time for", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00185-00053670-00053873": "that nonsense right", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00186-00053874-00054161": "so let's go ahead and", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00187-00054162-00054779": "let's take a look at your finances", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00188-00054779-00054959": "okay", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00189-00054960-00055235": "and then we'll go ahead and clarify", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00190-00055236-00055469": "see you're coming", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00191-00055470-00055823": "and get some advice", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00192-00055824-00056237": "okay messages for cancers", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00193-00056238-00056549": "finances what do we have in the month of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00194-00056550-00056716": "May", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00195-00056717-00057292": "for Kansas finances", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00196-00057294-00057497": "what do we have in the month of May for", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00197-00057498-00057803": "cancer finances", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00198-00057804-00058319": "message for cancer please", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00199-00058320-00058776": "anyone for cancer the month of May", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00200-00058777-00059650": "[Applause]", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00201-00059651-00059909": "okay the seven of Pentacles", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00202-00059910-00060269": "okay for your overall energy we have the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00203-00060270-00060550": "four of Wands in reverse", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00204-00060551-00060923": "we have the tower in reverse", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00205-00060924-00062411": "okay let's see what else", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00206-00062412-00062692": "okay the Knight of Wands in Reverse for", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00207-00062694-00062866": "real", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00208-00062867-00063166": "I think the world in Reverse okay so the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00209-00063167-00063323": "only one that's upright is the seven of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00210-00063324-00063599": "Pentacles so I feel like you're working", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00211-00063600-00063880": "really hard cancer during the month of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00212-00063882-00064085": "May", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00213-00064086-00064361": "um but I feel like you are not wanting", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00214-00064362-00064582": "to change a certain situation you are", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00215-00064583-00064829": "kind of avoiding this change at all", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00216-00064829-00065111": "costs because we kind of see the tower", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00217-00065112-00065392": "in reverse and the world in Reverse so", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00218-00065394-00065609": "whatever the situation is it could be", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00219-00065610-00066137": "some money issues with you and you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00220-00066138-00066287": "really", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00221-00066288-00066599": "are kind of avoiding changing a certain", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00222-00066600-00066875": "situation I feel like maybe you could be", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00223-00066876-00067138": "overspending in certain areas of your", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00224-00067139-00067529": "life and I feel like you've become kind", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00225-00067530-00067775": "of accustomed to it you've become very", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00226-00067776-00068063": "comfortable and whatever you're spending", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00227-00068064-00068309": "your money on and you're really trying", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00228-00068310-00068591": "to avoid making any changes but you've", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00229-00068592-00068879": "seen that by putting in a little bit", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00230-00068880-00069113": "more effort with your finances you'll be", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00231-00069114-00069317": "able to save more you'd be able to make", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00232-00069318-00069635": "more money now this could also be a job", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00233-00069636-00069856": "that you really enjoy doing but you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00234-00069857-00070025": "really don't want to lose you really", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00235-00070026-00070241": "don't want to leave this job but you may", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00236-00070242-00070505": "have another opportunity that's just", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00237-00070506-00070685": "ahead of you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00238-00070686-00070943": "now the message is for some of you okay", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00239-00070944-00071237": "but I feel like there's definitely some", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00240-00071238-00071453": "kind of activity that you're doing that", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00241-00071454-00071687": "you definitely are trying to avoid some", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00242-00071688-00071950": "kind of change from happening and you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00243-00071951-00072388": "you are kind of resisting moving forward", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00244-00072389-00072761": "okay we have the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00245-00072762-00073085": "the four wands energy in Reverse you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00246-00073086-00073379": "know maybe you feel like there's", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00247-00073380-00073637": "something that's", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00248-00073638-00073894": "is making you feel like there's a lack", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00249-00073895-00074063": "of support like you don't have enough", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00250-00074064-00074626": "coming in right you don't have", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00251-00074627-00074819": "the full amount that you need to make", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00252-00074820-00074938": "ends meet", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00253-00074939-00075131": "okay", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00254-00075132-00075232": "um", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00255-00075233-00075803": "with the seven of Pentacles", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00256-00075804-00076019": "you're working hard and you're being", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00257-00076020-00076259": "persistent", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00258-00076260-00076588": "you know but I feel like when it comes", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00259-00076589-00076876": "to this summon of Pentacles energy and", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00260-00076877-00077093": "you you really needing to put a little", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00261-00077094-00077356": "bit more effort into building up your", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00262-00077357-00077567": "Pinnacles you know I feel like you're", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00263-00077568-00077837": "kind of satisfied with where they are", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00264-00077838-00078076": "now but you can actually be making more", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00265-00078077-00078400": "you can actually be spending less so", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00266-00078401-00078838": "that you have more in reserve right", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00267-00078839-00079085": "um and I feel like that's something that", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00268-00079086-00079253": "you really don't want to pursue at the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00269-00079254-00079450": "moment because maybe you have too many", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00270-00079451-00079691": "bills or maybe you have too many", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00271-00079692-00080212": "responsibilities you know but I'm I'm", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00272-00080213-00080453": "letting you know that if you look at", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00273-00080454-00080621": "your finances", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00274-00080622-00080831": "if you look at your finances more", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00275-00080832-00081281": "clearly you may see opportunities to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00276-00081282-00081791": "grow your reserve okay there's always an", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00277-00081792-00082091": "opportunity to grow your reserve even if", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00278-00082092-00082450": "you don't see it at the moment but right", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00279-00082451-00082762": "now I feel like you're you know not", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00280-00082763-00083015": "really wanting to take that action you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00281-00083016-00083362": "may be doing a lot of impulse spending", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00282-00083363-00083583": "at the moment right", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00283-00083584-00083638": "[Music]", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00284-00083639-00083950": "um", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00285-00083951-00084299": "and that you can actually kind of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00286-00084300-00084575": "withdraw yourself from", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00287-00084576-00084876": "kind of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00288-00084877-00085241": "gets away from doing that you know it's", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00289-00085242-00085444": "time to move forward it's time to move", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00290-00085445-00085631": "forward with your finances heal your", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00291-00085632-00085937": "finances you know", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00292-00085938-00086261": "um start saving more put some money in a", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00293-00086262-00086561": "reserve so that you have that for a", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00294-00086562-00086861": "rainy day you know and I understand that", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00295-00086862-00087059": "you may be in your comfort zone when it", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00296-00087060-00087406": "comes to your spending but being out of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00297-00087407-00087562": "your comfort zone for a little while", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00298-00087563-00087803": "will actually give you the savings that", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00299-00087804-00088091": "you need at the moment you know", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00300-00088092-00088444": "um so yeah let's go ahead and take a", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00301-00088445-00088735": "look at", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00302-00088736-00089243": "your challenge", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00303-00089244-00089512": "then we'll go ahead and clarify", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00304-00089513-00089735": "so what's going to be challenging cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00305-00089736-00090017": "in the month of May what's going to be", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00306-00090018-00090526": "challenging cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00307-00090527-00090923": "what is the challenge", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00308-00090924-00091294": "okay the Eight of Cups", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00309-00091295-00091871": "the Knight of Cups", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00310-00091872-00092400": "and the hangman", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00311-00092401-00092741": "okay we have the six of Wands at the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00312-00092742-00092825": "bottom", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00313-00092826-00093262": "okay so cancer would I see that your", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00314-00093263-00093388": "challenges", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00315-00093389-00093641": "your challenge is actually letting go of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00316-00093642-00093850": "things that you know really don't serve", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00317-00093851-00094109": "you you know really isn't really aren't", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00318-00094110-00094361": "bringing you pleasure maybe this is in", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00319-00094362-00094565": "love maybe this is in finances maybe", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00320-00094566-00094841": "this is in your life in general but", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00321-00094842-00095021": "there's things that you're holding on to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00322-00095022-00095344": "that you know are not serving your", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00323-00095345-00095812": "highest good right so it's time to go", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00324-00095813-00096131": "ahead and follow your heart follow your", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00325-00096132-00096323": "intuition when it comes to this", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00326-00096324-00096587": "situation and get a better perspective", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00327-00096588-00096856": "you know this is a time to be", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00328-00096857-00097144": "enlightened about the situation because", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00329-00097145-00097349": "I feel like looking at things from a", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00330-00097350-00097529": "different perspective is going to bring", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00331-00097530-00097903": "you a lot more success a lot more", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00332-00097904-00098315": "influence a lot more guidance see we", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00333-00098316-00098579": "have the six of Wands the three of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00334-00098580-00098794": "Pentacles so this is going to bring you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00335-00098795-00098999": "a lot more support stability and", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00336-00099000-00099341": "happiness right and then you'll be able", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00337-00099342-00099676": "to really pursue something that really", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00338-00099677-00099881": "gives you a lot more support really", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00339-00099882-00100241": "gives you a lot more stability and may", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00340-00100242-00100517": "put yourself in a better situation when", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00341-00100518-00100835": "it comes to your life in general you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00342-00100836-00100967": "know", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00343-00100968-00101026": "um", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00344-00101027-00101297": "so definitely", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00345-00101298-00101459": "this is going to bring you more", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00346-00101460-00101668": "stability", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00347-00101669-00101843": "okay", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00348-00101844-00102161": "so let's go ahead and get some advice", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00349-00102162-00102394": "for cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00350-00102395-00102634": "let's get some advice for cancer what", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00351-00102635-00103042": "should cancer do to overcome this", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00352-00103043-00103192": "challenge", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00353-00103193-00103463": "what should cancer do to overcome this", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00354-00103464-00103660": "challenge", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00355-00103661-00103855": "messages for cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00356-00103856-00104194": "[Applause]", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00357-00104195-00104536": "okay the Queen of Swords open yourself", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00358-00104538-00104789": "up to communication and ask for support", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00359-00104790-00105119": "if you need it you know and I feel like", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00360-00105120-00105407": "being honest with yourself and with the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00361-00105408-00105652": "situation is going to bring you a total", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00362-00105653-00105928": "transformation it's going to totally", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00363-00105929-00106216": "transform the situation and also bring", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00364-00106217-00106708": "you spiritually into a situation to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00365-00106709-00107152": "where you will be able to win right", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00366-00107153-00107393": "um the Five of Swords this is this is", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00367-00107394-00107825": "can be the card of winning at all costs", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00368-00107826-00108316": "you know and I feel like by you know", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00369-00108317-00108490": "being honest with yourself in the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00370-00108491-00108610": "situation", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00371-00108611-00108947": "also maybe getting support or getting", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00372-00108948-00109295": "some advice when it comes to what is", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00373-00109296-00109534": "putting you into the situation is going", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00374-00109535-00109739": "to be very helpful for you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00375-00109740-00110075": "right the three of Cups this could be a", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00376-00110076-00110340": "card of friendship connection Community", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00377-00110341-00110602": "you know getting that guidance being", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00378-00110603-00110957": "around your soul tribe okay", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00379-00110958-00111263": "um but I feel like you know by getting", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00380-00111264-00111515": "that guidance that advice you are going", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00381-00111516-00111899": "to totally transform your situation and", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00382-00111900-00112045": "you're going to be in a better position", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00383-00112046-00112283": "you know you're going to become more", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00384-00112283-00112715": "organized you're gonna be able to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00385-00112716-00112997": "um be more spiritually guided you know", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00386-00112998-00113266": "by using your intuition in the situation", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00387-00113267-00113543": "as well you know", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00388-00113544-00113854": "um", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00389-00113855-00114340": "okay let's go ahead and clarify", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00390-00114341-00114934": "for cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00391-00114935-00115493": "hey", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00392-00115494-00115781": "Spirit give me a message for cancer why", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00393-00115782-00115954": "is the king of swords and the Three of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00394-00115955-00116184": "Swords here give me a message for cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00395-00116185-00116507": "why is the king of swords and the Three", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00396-00116508-00117371": "of Swords here", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00397-00117372-00117797": "the Five of Swords in reverse", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00398-00117798-00118102": "in the Ace of Pentacles well", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00399-00118103-00118313": "cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00400-00118314-00118686": "okay", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00401-00118688-00118973": "there's something that needs to come out", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00402-00118974-00119183": "like I said this is a truth that needs", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00403-00119183-00119836": "to be revealed right and I feel like", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00404-00119838-00120166": "if this is a person coming forward", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00405-00120167-00120449": "this person has a desire to reconcile", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00406-00120450-00120707": "the situation to start over to have some", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00407-00120708-00120971": "kind of new beginning to make it better", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00408-00120972-00121475": "than before okay to provide more value", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00409-00121476-00121823": "and more stability to the situation so", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00410-00121824-00122045": "if this is a person this person wants to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00411-00122046-00122513": "fully commit to a situation now we do", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00412-00122514-00122813": "have the three of cups in reverse on the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00413-00122814-00122989": "bottom", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00414-00122990-00123316": "so I feel like there may have been some", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00415-00123317-00123527": "kind of isolation there may have been", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00416-00123528-00123754": "some kind of separation between you and", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00417-00123755-00124019": "this person or there may have been a lot", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00418-00124020-00124307": "of Gossip between", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00419-00124308-00124601": "um some kind of friend area right there", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00420-00124602-00124966": "may have been a lot of words spoken", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00421-00124967-00125477": "um maybe there was a lot of Silence", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00422-00125478-00125836": "um after this gossip or isolation the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00423-00125838-00126125": "separation you know but this person is", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00424-00126126-00126328": "lost without you we have the nine of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00425-00126329-00126563": "Pentacles you know this person is lost", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00426-00126564-00126904": "without you they they're like in this", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00427-00126905-00127216": "dream world where you know they need", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00428-00127217-00127499": "this to be revealed or else they just", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00429-00127500-00127834": "can't move on and they just can't", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00430-00127835-00128128": "um see being without you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00431-00128129-00128471": "right so and I feel like this person", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00432-00128472-00128878": "really wants to reconcile the situation", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00433-00128879-00129233": "okay so give me a message", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00434-00129233-00129545": "Spirit why is the United Pentacles in", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00435-00129546-00129808": "reverse now why is the page of Pentacles", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00436-00129809-00130019": "in reverse", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00437-00130020-00130240": "why has the knot of Pentacles in reverse", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00438-00130241-00130714": "and the page of Pentacles in reverse", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00439-00130715-00131008": "the lovers yes someone's not taking any", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00440-00131009-00131213": "action because they're heartbroken they", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00441-00131214-00131561": "miss you they love you you know they can", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00442-00131562-00131764": "only see themselves with you this person", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00443-00131765-00132125": "is going through healing okay they're", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00444-00132126-00132364": "they're trying to figure out which way", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00445-00132365-00132623": "to go you know they just want a new", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00446-00132624-00132959": "beginning they want a second chance", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00447-00132960-00133211": "um cancer they they want you to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00448-00133212-00133643": "recognize that whatever they did they're", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00449-00133644-00133816": "apologizing", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00450-00133817-00134104": "they're very sorry for the way that they", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00451-00134105-00134363": "acted and now they want to just clear", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00452-00134364-00134627": "the air and start over", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00453-00134628-00135113": "okay and yeah that they feel", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00454-00135114-00135383": "they feel lost without you we have the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00455-00135384-00135581": "Six of Pentacles in reverse and the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00456-00135582-00135899": "hierophant this may may be someone that", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00457-00135900-00136090": "you were engaged to someone that you're", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00458-00136091-00136319": "married to some kind of Separation that", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00459-00136320-00136619": "you're going through but this person is", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00460-00136620-00136804": "very distraught", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00461-00136805-00137119": "that they feel like they can't", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00462-00137120-00137495": "move ahead without you accepting their", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00463-00137496-00137663": "apology", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00464-00137664-00137885": "you know", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00465-00137886-00138107": "um they feel like", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00466-00138108-00138683": "there's no moving forward", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00467-00138684-00138983": "like they just can't", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00468-00138984-00139240": "gain", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00469-00139241-00139445": "any balance", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00470-00139446-00139787": "okay this person may have been being", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00471-00139788-00139914": "stingy", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00472-00139915-00140201": "or there might have been some kind of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00473-00140202-00140387": "power", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00474-00140388-00140861": "um", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00475-00140862-00141107": "might have been some kind of power back", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00476-00141108-00141352": "and forth you know but I feel like this", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00477-00141353-00141695": "person is very apologetic you know they", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00478-00141696-00141977": "want to tell you that they're sorry", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00479-00141978-00142271": "they want to give you this apology and", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00480-00142272-00142504": "hope that you reconcile with them that", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00481-00142505-00142775": "you listen to what they have to say", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00482-00142776-00142973": "okay because they really want to deliver", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00483-00142974-00143207": "some kind of Truth to you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00484-00143208-00143423": "they want to let you know how they feel", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00485-00143424-00143801": "yeah they feel like you know you don't", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00486-00143802-00144023": "even see them anymore you don't even", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00487-00144024-00144299": "notice them you know they can't even", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00488-00144300-00144635": "focus on what they need to do what they", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00489-00144636-00144923": "need to say because this person is so", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00490-00144924-00145193": "distraught you know the five of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00491-00145194-00145378": "Pentacles in reverse the four of swords", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00492-00145379-00145702": "in reverse the page of swords in reverse", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00493-00145703-00145883": "you know", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00494-00145884-00146087": "um yeah this person is very distraught", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00495-00146088-00146428": "over the thought of losing you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00496-00146429-00146740": "okay so let's go ahead and take a look", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00497-00146741-00146964": "at", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00498-00146965-00147377": "cancers money situation that that may be", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00499-00147378-00147607": "due to the situation here actually", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00500-00147608-00147983": "for the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00501-00147984-00148199": "for the four of Wands in the tower in", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00502-00148200-00148427": "Reverse we have the star", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00503-00148428-00148649": "so I feel like something is going to be", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00504-00148650-00148877": "recovered you're going to make a", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00505-00148878-00149302": "recovery in this situation okay so you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00506-00149303-00149573": "will kind of rebuild your finances", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00507-00149574-00149963": "during the month of May", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00508-00149964-00150221": "what else do we have", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00509-00150222-00150814": "what else spirit", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00510-00150815-00151109": "the Hermits and I I feel like you're", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00511-00151110-00151354": "kind of moving away from this spending", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00512-00151355-00151997": "time alone or spending money alone right", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00513-00151998-00152273": "um because I I feel like you know this", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00514-00152274-00152452": "may be emotional spending that you're", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00515-00152453-00152602": "doing", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00516-00152603-00152789": "you know you may be spending money", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00517-00152790-00153052": "because you're sad you're heartbroken", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00518-00153053-00153293": "you're discouraged you know that may be", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00519-00153294-00153454": "the time when you really need to watch", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00520-00153455-00153616": "your pennies when you really need to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00521-00153617-00153769": "watch what you do with your money", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00522-00153770-00154183": "because you feel some kind of rejection", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00523-00154184-00154487": "so you tend to spend more money during", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00524-00154488-00154823": "that time instead of putting your money", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00525-00154824-00155261": "where you know you need to and focusing", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00526-00155262-00155531": "on you know building up your savings", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00527-00155532-00155957": "saving your coins you know investing you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00528-00155958-00156295": "know and it's time for that restoration", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00529-00156296-00156671": "okay so Spirit give me a message why is", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00530-00156672-00157061": "the Knight of Wands in the world here in", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00531-00157062-00157216": "reverse", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00532-00157217-00157433": "why is the Knight of Wands in the world", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00533-00157434-00158302": "here in reverse", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00534-00158303-00158483": "the stream card", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00535-00158484-00158693": "yeah you know what you need to do to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00536-00158694-00159059": "build up your finances you know and I I", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00537-00159060-00159197": "feel like you're going to be moving", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00538-00159198-00159395": "forward on that you do have the strength", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00539-00159396-00159616": "card and the page of ones", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00540-00159617-00160102": "so you know exactly what it takes to you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00541-00160103-00160487": "know bring your finances back into order", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00542-00160488-00160793": "okay and I feel like there's just some", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00543-00160794-00161116": "impulsive spending going on with this", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00544-00161117-00161440": "page of Wands in Reverse you know", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00545-00161441-00161861": "there's a feeling of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00546-00161862-00162226": "not knowing which way to go you know and", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00547-00162227-00162376": "if you feel like you don't know how to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00548-00162377-00162659": "make the first step get some advice get", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00549-00162660-00162839": "some advice so that you can move forward", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00550-00162840-00163078": "into a better position because you have", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00551-00163079-00163451": "that ability you know you may feel like", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00552-00163452-00163631": "it's kind of impossible at the moment", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00553-00163632-00163973": "but you do have that ability you know", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00554-00163974-00164387": "you do have that that ability to do that", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00555-00164388-00164711": "but I feel like there is this negative", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00556-00164712-00164921": "energy that you need to overcome there's", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00557-00164922-00165197": "some kind of addiction that you need to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00558-00165198-00165413": "overcome when it comes to your money", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00559-00165414-00165773": "your finances and your spending okay so", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00560-00165774-00166139": "yeah take a look at that", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00561-00166140-00166481": "my lovely cancer and of course take it", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00562-00166482-00166690": "as a resonates if this doesn't resonate", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00563-00166691-00166913": "with you don't accept it it's not for", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00564-00166914-00167266": "you but if this message resonates you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00565-00167267-00167447": "know put it into action", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00566-00167448-00167873": "okay so let's go ahead and get an", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00567-00167874-00168059": "outcome", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00568-00168060-00168376": "for my lovely cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00569-00168377-00168737": "let's get an outcome for the month of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00570-00168738-00169073": "May", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00571-00169074-00169493": "and outcome please for the month of May", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00572-00169494-00169889": "okay so we have the 10 of excuse me the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00573-00169890-00170237": "seven of Wands the nine of Pentacles in", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00574-00170238-00170657": "reverse and the temperance in reverse", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00575-00170658-00170921": "Okay so", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00576-00170922-00171137": "cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00577-00171138-00171443": "at the bottom we have the eight of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00578-00171444-00171647": "Pentacles in reverse and the nine of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00579-00171648-00171976": "Wands the page of Wands and the two of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00580-00171977-00172187": "Swords so there's definitely some kind", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00581-00172188-00172378": "of situation there is going to be some", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00582-00172379-00172637": "choices that you need to make there is", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00583-00172638-00172895": "going to be some rebuilding", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00584-00172896-00173513": "um there is going to be you know taking", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00585-00173514-00173663": "action", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00586-00173664-00173921": "you know you are gonna have to take it", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00587-00173922-00174347": "action on your situation during the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00588-00174348-00174766": "month of May whether this is in your", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00589-00174767-00175121": "love your finances or in your life in", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00590-00175122-00175487": "general okay so there is a need to take", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00591-00175488-00175823": "action to move out of this defensive", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00592-00175824-00175978": "energy", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00593-00175979-00176302": "okay you may be feeling very defensive", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00594-00176303-00176519": "right now you know you may be standing", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00595-00176520-00176878": "your ground or trying very hard to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00596-00176879-00177119": "maintain control", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00597-00177120-00177647": "okay but I feel like with this", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00598-00177648-00177971": "nine of Pentacles in Reverse you feel", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00599-00177972-00178163": "like there may be some kind of lack of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00600-00178164-00178397": "resources", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00601-00178398-00178528": "um", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00602-00178529-00178793": "okay you may feel like you just don't", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00603-00178794-00179063": "have enough at the moment you know and", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00604-00179064-00179311": "you just don't have the patience", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00605-00179312-00179740": "to keep pushing on you know but that is", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00606-00179741-00179963": "exactly what it's going to have to take", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00607-00179964-00180101": "as patience", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00608-00180102-00180238": "you're going to have to take the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00609-00180239-00180551": "patience to take the next steps to you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00610-00180552-00180754": "know make the first move", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00611-00180755-00181013": "okay that goes back to that to making", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00612-00181014-00181181": "the first move", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00613-00181182-00181421": "okay so let's go ahead and take a look", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00614-00181422-00181769": "at the dragonfly", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00615-00181770-00182057": "what does the dragonfly mean the number", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00616-00182058-00182597": "eight for cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00617-00182598-00182899": "okay the dragonfly the dragonfly", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00618-00182900-00183251": "represents renewal a deeper way of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00619-00183252-00183551": "living is opening up for you as you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00620-00183552-00183940": "become incredibly more spiritual in your", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00621-00183941-00184211": "outlook and understanding your intuition", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00622-00184212-00184433": "will be stronger your dreams more", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00623-00184434-00184751": "intense and your messages from deceased", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00624-00184752-00184949": "loved ones through dreams will be", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00625-00184950-00185149": "uplifting and beautiful", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00626-00185150-00185566": "your aura will become electric this card", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00627-00185567-00185695": "also", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00628-00185696-00186028": "symbolizes change you may find yourself", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00629-00186029-00186401": "in New Perspectives on what you want in", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00630-00186402-00186533": "your future life", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00631-00186534-00186826": "there will be time spent soul searching", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00632-00186827-00187349": "in walks down memory lane can help make", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00633-00187350-00187678": "some life-changing decisions", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00634-00187679-00188021": "have confidence you will be a force to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00635-00188022-00188213": "be reckoned with", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00636-00188214-00188519": "okay your personal relationships there", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00637-00188520-00188681": "will be good news concerning your", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00638-00188682-00188945": "relationship and innermost desire our", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00639-00188946-00189269": "Newfound Faith your intuition will guide", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00640-00189270-00189623": "you towards a like-minded friendship old", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00641-00189624-00189907": "friends from the past may also return", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00642-00189908-00190283": "reunions Moon large and family", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00643-00190284-00190625": "celebrations are in store these will be", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00644-00190626-00190883": "an enjoyable and may even be filled with", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00645-00190884-00191069": "some incredible secrets that could", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00646-00191070-00191285": "completely change how you feel about", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00647-00191286-00191452": "certain people", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00648-00191453-00191843": "okay your career and money there will be", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00649-00191844-00192035": "a constant change but you will", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00650-00192036-00192281": "accomplish your goals with ease", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00651-00192282-00192485": "self-doubts about your future will", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00652-00192486-00192809": "disappear and Newfound strength and", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00653-00192810-00193043": "confidence will shine through remember", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00654-00193044-00193369": "the dragonfly represents adaptability", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00655-00193370-00193690": "call upon your power of the dragonfly", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00656-00193691-00194038": "whenever you feel stuck and can't make a", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00657-00194039-00194154": "decision", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00658-00194155-00194501": "life will be like a roller coaster at", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00659-00194502-00194740": "times you may experience mini twists and", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00660-00194741-00195061": "turns as well as Thrills along the way", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00661-00195062-00195335": "know when to take a break from the ride", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00662-00195336-00195611": "so that you can avoid burnout", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00663-00195612-00196054": "okay and your power tip", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00664-00196055-00196343": "wear a dragonfly necklace or place a", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00665-00196344-00196690": "charm on a key ring as a reminder of", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00666-00196691-00196966": "exciting times ahead to bring great joy", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00667-00196967-00197351": "and enhanced connection to your true", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00668-00197352-00197452": "self", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00669-00197453-00197807": "okay so that is the true meaning of the", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00670-00197808-00198016": "dragonfly", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00671-00198017-00198257": "so my lovely cancer let's go ahead and", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00672-00198258-00198504": "get your angel number", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00673-00198505-00198947": "see what we have for you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00674-00198948-00199361": "okay so cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00675-00199362-00199943": "your angel number is 11 11 intuition I", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00676-00199944-00200237": "love this number cancer", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00677-00200238-00200597": "I really do I love this number 11 11.", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00678-00200598-00201064": "this is the most Angelic number", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00679-00201065-00201478": "of numerology okay trust in yourself", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00680-00201479-00201737": "your inner whisper is working hard to", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00681-00201738-00202007": "let you know that it is guiding you", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00682-00202008-00202426": "listen in what is it saying feel it", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00683-00202427-00202726": "where is it telling you to go next", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00684-00202727-00203140": "see it close your eyes and allow trust", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00685-00203141-00203435": "the path that you're on your affirmation", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00686-00203436-00203909": "my intuition speaks to me and I listen I", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00687-00203910-00204143": "trust that all things are happening for", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00688-00204144-00204281": "a purpose", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00689-00204282-00204683": "okay so my beautiful cancer this is your", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00690-00204684-00204916": "reading so if this reading resonates", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00691-00204917-00205186": "please like And subscribe if it doesn't", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00692-00205187-00205384": "take a look at your other placements", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00693-00205385-00205564": "they may be speaking to you more at this", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00694-00205565-00205846": "time okay and", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00695-00205848-00206075": "um until your next reading my beautiful", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00696-00206076-00206519": "cancer many blessings to you love and", "Tvb5pZ-BVqy-00697-00206519-00206773": "light"}}, {"audio_id": "Tw0byv0Pyc4", "text": {"Tw0byv0Pyc4-00000-00000186-00000518": "I promised another annual report for", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00001-00000519-00000956": "Center what a year it's been first of", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00002-00000957-00001450": "all we had gdpr or gin Dubonnet rum and", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00003-00001451-00001871": "Prosecco as we came to call it here what", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00004-00001872-00002255": "Apple although it turns out Santa is not", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00005-00002256-00002612": "in the EU so he's the third country when", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00006-00002613-00002891": "it comes to data processing you won't", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00007-00002892-00003121": "believe the difficulties we had", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00008-00003122-00003392": "persuading the EU that you could trust", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00009-00003393-00003659": "your children's data with us Indian", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00010-00003660-00003851": "though we're going to sort it out", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00011-00003852-00004145": "we created an elf shield which is a", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00012-00004146-00004397": "super elf magic premises shield that", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00013-00004398-00004672": "makes all your problems go away", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00014-00004673-00004934": "but it didn't get rid of the problem of", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00015-00004935-00005264": "parental consent we can't hold", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00016-00005265-00005522": "children's data without the parents", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00017-00005523-00005852": "kissing it wasn't too tricky with the", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00018-00005853-00006119": "nice list we just sent the old phone and", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00019-00006120-00006403": "they agreed straight away and signed up", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00020-00006404-00006658": "and posting the notes of the chili the", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00021-00006659-00006970": "problem was with the naughty list the", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00022-00006972-00007156": "parents didn't want their children on", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00023-00007158-00007247": "the naughty list", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00024-00007248-00007565": "so we've had to change the way that we", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00025-00007566-00007766": "do things now we don't have a naughty", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00026-00007767-00008129": "list and a nice list we only have a nice", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00027-00008130-00008432": "list so if you're on the nice list or", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00028-00008433-00008639": "better present and if you're not on any", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00029-00008640-00009095": "list at all I'm afraid you won't it was", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00030-00009096-00009293": "at the end of our legal difficulties", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00031-00009294-00009593": "though we had terrible problems with the", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00032-00009594-00009935": "snowmen or the snow people as I have to", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00033-00009936-00010019": "call them now", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00034-00010020-00010292": "first of all people complained that they", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00035-00010293-00010535": "were all one gender and then other", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00036-00010536-00010736": "people complained that you can't tell", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00037-00010737-00011009": "the gender of a snow person even when", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00038-00011010-00011261": "they're transitioning if that wasn't", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00039-00011262-00011459": "complicated enough we had a lot of", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00040-00011460-00011714": "complaints that the snow people are", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00041-00011715-00012119": "always white we've had some difficulty", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00042-00012120-00012380": "creating multicolored snow but we", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00043-00012381-00012596": "promise you that by next year we'll have", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00044-00012597-00012869": "it all sorted out and rainbow snow", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00045-00012869-00013372": "people will be the norm and then the tax", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00046-00013372-00013657": "gamer's a lot of trouble they st. says", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00047-00013658-00013947": "something called international reindeer", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00048-00013948-00014521": "35 or ir35 to you and I and they said", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00049-00014522-00014744": "that because we tell the reindeer", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00050-00014745-00015043": "exactly when to work on Christmas Eve", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00051-00015044-00015403": "and exactly which houses to go to they", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00052-00015404-00015760": "not really self-employed so we have to", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00053-00015761-00015966": "deduct tax from the reindeers that", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00054-00015968-00016228": "invoices through their company and put", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00055-00016229-00016591": "the rest on payers um the reindeer ORP", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00056-00016592-00016630": "gnomes", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00057-00016631-00016861": "they don't like this international", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00058-00016862-00017150": "reindeer directive but the government is", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00059-00017151-00017539": "adamant that made it no longer to be", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00060-00017540-00017914": "viewed as self-employment we have our", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00061-00017915-00018277": "difficulties in Santa's land we've", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00062-00018278-00018475": "always tried to comply with", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00063-00018476-00018828": "international law but dare I mention", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00064-00018829-00019333": "brexit so many people had to be taken", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00065-00019334-00019621": "off the nice list as a result of all the", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00066-00019622-00019915": "shenanigans around that at least we've", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00067-00019916-00020212": "got a much smaller distribution Aesir", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00068-00020213-00020556": "but I promise you that you're on the", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00069-00020557-00020934": "nice list if your compiler gdpr and if", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00070-00020935-00021196": "you're struggling with the international", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00071-00021197-00021493": "reindeer directive I'd like to take this", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00072-00021494-00021753": "opportunity to wish you a very happy", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00073-00021754-00022012": "Christmas and New Year and you know", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00074-00022013-00022230": "we'll be working you with you wherever", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00075-00022231-00022566": "you are as soon as the new year starts", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00076-00022567-00022891": "lots of love from all the coffee klatch", "Tw0byv0Pyc4-00077-00022892-00023148": "elves"}}, {"audio_id": "Twk0ERM_qmk", "text": {"Twk0ERM_qmk-00000-00000038-00000428": "st. Stephen's Green Irish fascist I", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00001-00000429-00000740": "Avner is a city centre public park in", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00002-00000741-00001148": "Dublin Ireland the current landscape of", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00003-00001149-00001385": "the park was designed by William", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00004-00001386-00001697": "Sheppard it was officially reopened to", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00005-00001698-00002039": "the public on Tuesday the 27th of July", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00006-00002039-00002306": "1880 by Lord odda lawn", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00007-00002307-00002633": "the park is adjacent to one of Dublin's", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00008-00002634-00002966": "main shopping streets Grafton Street and", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00009-00002967-00003247": "to a shopping centre named for it while", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00010-00003248-00003458": "on its surrounding streets are the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00011-00003459-00003743": "offices of a number of public bodies as", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00012-00003744-00004028": "well as a stop on one of Dublin's Lewes", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00013-00004029-00004429": "tram lines it is often informally called", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00014-00004430-00004856": "stephen's green at 22 acres eighty-nine", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00015-00004857-00005147": "thousand square metres it is the largest", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00016-00005148-00005452": "of the parks in Dublin's main Georgian", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00017-00005453-00005845": "garden squares others include nearby", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00018-00005846-00006281": "Marion Square and Fitzwilliam Square the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00019-00006282-00006563": "park is rectangular surrounded by", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00020-00006564-00006842": "streets that once formed major traffic", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00021-00006843-00007048": "arteries through Dublin city centre", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00022-00007050-00007358": "although traffic management changes", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00023-00007359-00007745": "implemented in 2004 during the course of", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00024-00007745-00008006": "the Lewis works have greatly reduced the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00025-00008006-00008357": "volume of traffic these four bordering", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00026-00008358-00008671": "streets are called respectively st.", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00027-00008672-00008953": "stephen's green north st. Stephen's", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00028-00008954-00009281": "Green South st. Stephen's Green East and", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00029-00009282-00010026": "st. Stephen's Green West", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00030-00010027-00010582": "topic history", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00031-00010583-00011014": "until 1663 st. Stephen's Green was a", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00032-00011015-00011311": "marshy common on the edge of Dublin used", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00033-00011312-00011650": "for grazing in that year Dublin", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00034-00011651-00011953": "corporation seeing an opportunity to", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00035-00011954-00012250": "raise much-needed revenue decided to", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00036-00012251-00012505": "enclose the center of the common and to", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00037-00012506-00012742": "sell land around the perimeter for", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00038-00012743-00013084": "building the park was enclosed with a", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00039-00013085-00013566": "wall in 1664 the houses built around the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00040-00013568-00013828": "green were rapidly replaced by new", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00041-00013829-00014107": "buildings in the georgian style and by", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00042-00014108-00014377": "the end of the 18th century the green", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00043-00014378-00014650": "was a place of resort for the better off", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00044-00014651-00014968": "of the city much of the present-day", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00045-00014969-00015291": "landscape of the square comprises modern", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00046-00015293-00015574": "buildings some in a replica Georgian", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00047-00015575-00015850": "style and relatively little survives", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00048-00015851-00016423": "from the 18th and 19th centuries in 1814", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00049-00016424-00016747": "control of st. Stephen's Green passed to", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00050-00016748-00017002": "commissioners for the local householders", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00051-00017003-00017272": "who redesigned its layout and replaced", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00052-00017273-00017547": "the walls with railings after the death", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00053-00017548-00017797": "of Prince Albert Queen Victoria", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00054-00017798-00018097": "suggested that st. Stephen's Green be", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00055-00018098-00018361": "renamed Albert green and have a statue", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00056-00018362-00018646": "of Albert at its centre a suggestion", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00057-00018647-00018957": "rejected with indignation by the Dublin", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00058-00018958-00019207": "corporation and the people of the city", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00059-00019208-00019516": "to the Queen's Chadron access to the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00060-00019517-00019785": "green was restricted to local residents", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00061-00019786-00020227": "until 1877 when Parliament passed an act", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00062-00020228-00020524": "to reopened st. Stephen's Green to the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00063-00020525-00020822": "public at the initiative of Sir AE", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00064-00020823-00021072": "Guinness a member of the Guinness", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00065-00021073-00021355": "Brewing family who lived at st. Ann's", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00066-00021356-00021778": "Park Rohini and at Ashford Castle he", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00067-00021779-00022003": "later paid for the laying out of the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00068-00022004-00022264": "green in approximately its current form", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00069-00022265-00022615": "which took place in 1880 and gave it to", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00070-00022616-00022912": "the corporation as representatives of", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00071-00022913-00023266": "the people by way of thanks the city", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00072-00023267-00023580": "commissioned a statue of him which faces", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00073-00023581-00023827": "the College of Surgeons", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00074-00023828-00024130": "his brother Edward lived at ivy house", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00075-00024131-00024493": "which his descendants gave in 1939 to", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00076-00024494-00024805": "the Department of External Affairs now", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00077-00024806-00025234": "the Department of Foreign Affairs during", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00078-00025235-00025585": "the Easter Rising of 1916 a group of", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00079-00025586-00025867": "insurgents made up mainly of members of", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00080-00025868-00026119": "the Irish citizen army under the command", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00081-00026120-00026395": "of commandant Michel Malan his", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00082-00026395-00026632": "second-in-command kit Poole and", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00083-00026633-00026917": "Constance Markovic established a", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00084-00026918-00027286": "position in st. Stephen's Green they", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00085-00027287-00027712": "numbered between 200 and 250 they", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00086-00027713-00028045": "confiscated motor vehicles to establish", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00087-00028045-00028302": "roadblocks on the streets that surround", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00088-00028304-00028614": "the park and dug defensive positions in", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00089-00028616-00028755": "the park itself", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00090-00028756-00029029": "this approach differed from that of", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00091-00029030-00029380": "taking up positions in buildings adopted", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00092-00029381-00029550": "elsewhere in the city", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00093-00029551-00029872": "it proved to have been unwise when", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00094-00029873-00030118": "elements of the British Army took up", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00095-00030119-00030424": "positions in the Shelbourne Hotel at the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00096-00030425-00030679": "northeastern corner of st. Stephen's", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00097-00030680-00030943": "Green overlooking the park from which", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00098-00030944-00031135": "they could shoot down into the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00099-00031136-00031515": "entrenchments finding themselves in a", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00100-00031516-00031831": "weak position the volunteers withdrew to", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00101-00031832-00032080": "the Royal College of Surgeons on the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00102-00032081-00032433": "west side of the green during the rising", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00103-00032435-00032761": "fire was temporarily halted to allow the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00104-00032762-00033001": "Parkes groundsman to feed the local", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00105-00033002-00033304": "ducks the park is now operated by the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00106-00033305-00033615": "Office of Public Works on behalf of the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00107-00033616-00034230": "Irish State", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00108-00034231-00034870": "topic evolution of design", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00109-00034871-00035122": "the landscaping of the park has", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00110-00035123-00035425": "undergone three major changes since its", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00111-00035426-00035770": "inception its first major change", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00112-00035771-00036185": "occurred in 1670 two rows of lime trees", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00113-00036186-00036418": "were planted around the perimeter", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00114-00036419-00036772": "functioning as its first enclosure at", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00115-00036773-00037051": "this time the park was only accessible", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00116-00037052-00037348": "to the wealthy residents who owned plots", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00117-00037349-00037693": "around the park in 1815 the park was", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00118-00037694-00037981": "redesigned by the Dublin City surveyor", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00119-00037982-00038398": "Arthur Neville in his redesign he added", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00120-00038399-00038779": "winding pathways and iron fences at this", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00121-00038780-00039073": "time the park was still closed to the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00122-00039074-00039457": "public during the 1860s the campaign to", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00123-00039458-00039710": "make the park publicly accessible was", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00124-00039711-00040045": "underway and the city engineer George W", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00125-00040046-00040366": "hem ins proposed a new design to make", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00126-00040367-00040561": "the park as walkable and thus", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00127-00040562-00040918": "functionally practical as possible this", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00128-00040919-00041206": "included creating four gates at each", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00129-00041207-00041446": "corner of the park that would be linked", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00130-00041447-00041735": "by the extant pathways designed by", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00131-00041736-00042036": "Neville this plan was eventually", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00132-00042037-00042364": "abandoned most likely due to the fact", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00133-00042365-00042629": "that Hemmings was employed by Dublin", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00134-00042630-00043006": "corporation however many of Hemmings", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00135-00043007-00043270": "designs like the addition of the gates", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00136-00043271-00043579": "and connecting pathways were included in", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00137-00043580-00043855": "the final plans submitted by William", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00138-00043856-00044091": "Sheppard the principal designer", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00139-00044092-00044344": "responsible for the landscape of the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00140-00044345-00044715": "park as we know it today an engineer al", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00141-00044716-00045172": "cousins sponsored by Lord Arda lawn Arda", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00142-00045173-00045433": "lawn also played a significant role in", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00143-00045434-00045697": "the planning and importing of the exotic", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00144-00045698-00045967": "trees and plants that would be installed", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00145-00045968-00046609": "in the park", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00146-00046610-00047205": "topic park layout", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00147-00047206-00047508": "while the central park of st. stephen's", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00148-00047509-00047799": "green is one of three ancient Commons in", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00149-00047800-00048072": "the city its current layout owes much to", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00150-00048073-00048423": "the restorations of the 1800s see", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00151-00048424-00048825": "history above the grounds are roughly", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00152-00048826-00049245": "rectangular measuring approximately 550", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00153-00049246-00049626": "by 450 meters and are centered on a", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00154-00049627-00050015": "formal garden one of the more unusual", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00155-00050016-00050298": "aspects of the park lies on the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00156-00050299-00050592": "northwest corner of this central area a", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00157-00050593-00050847": "garden for the blind with scented plants", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00158-00050848-00051141": "which can withstand handling and are", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00159-00051142-00051537": "labeled in Braille further north again", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00160-00051538-00051767": "and spanning much of the length of the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00161-00051769-00052142": "park is a large lake home to darks", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00162-00052144-00052470": "another waterfowl the lake is fed by an", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00163-00052471-00052754": "artificial waterfall spanned by", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00164-00052755-00053004": "O'Connell bridge and fronted by an", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00165-00053004-00053382": "ornamental gazebo the lakes in the park", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00166-00053383-00053595": "are fed from the Grand Canal at", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00167-00053596-00053795": "Portobello", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00168-00053796-00054079": "to the south side of the main garden", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00169-00054080-00054376": "circle is more open heath surrounding a", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00170-00054377-00054665": "Bandstand and often frequented by", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00171-00054666-00054926": "lunching students workers and shoppers", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00172-00054927-00055417": "on Dublin's sunnier days there is also a", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00173-00055419-00055736": "playground separated into junior and", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00174-00055737-00056029": "senior areas which was refurbished in", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00175-00056030-00056616": "2010 other notable features include the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00176-00056617-00056905": "Fusiliers arch at the Grafton street", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00177-00056907-00057142": "corner which commemorates the Royal", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00178-00057144-00057463": "Dublin Fusiliers who died in the second", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00179-00057464-00057563": "Boer War", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00180-00057564-00057929": "a fountain representing the three faiths", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00181-00057929-00058279": "inside the lease and Street gate the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00182-00058280-00058616": "statue was designed by Joseph wakil in", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00183-00058616-00059090": "bronze in 1956 it was a gift from the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00184-00059091-00059375": "German people in thanks for Irish help", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00185-00059376-00059657": "to refugee children following World War", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00186-00059658-00060029": "Two up to 500 children found foster", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00187-00060029-00060296": "homes in Ireland in a project named", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00188-00060297-00060740": "Operation shamrock a seated statue of", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00189-00060741-00061030": "Lord odda lawn on the western side the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00190-00061032-00061253": "man who gave the green to the city", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00191-00061254-00061516": "facing the Royal College of Surgeons", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00192-00061517-00061832": "which he also sponsored again see", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00193-00061833-00062266": "history above the Yates memorial garden", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00194-00062267-00062684": "with a sculpture by Henry Moore a bust", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00195-00062685-00062950": "of James Joyce facing his former", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00196-00062951-00063428": "University at Newman house a memorial to", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00197-00063429-00063551": "the Fenian leader", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00198-00063552-00063824": "Jeremiah o'donovan rossa near the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00199-00063825-00064226": "Grafton Street entrance a bronze statue", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00200-00064227-00064519": "at the Marion row corner of Theobald", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00201-00064520-00064838": "Wolfe Tone the leader of the 1798", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00202-00064839-00065269": "rebellion a memorial to the great famine", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00203-00065270-00065888": "of 1845 to 1850 by Edward Delaney a bust", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00204-00065889-00066181": "of Constance Markovic on the south of", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00205-00066182-00066556": "the central garden see history above a", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00206-00066557-00066926": "statue of Robert Emmet standing opposite", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00207-00066927-00067169": "his birthplace now demolished", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00208-00067170-00067751": "at number 124 a memorial bust of Thomas", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00209-00067752-00068077": "kettle fatality of the Great Wall the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00210-00068078-00068324": "attempt to erect a commemorative", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00211-00068325-00068635": "portrait bust of kettle was beset by", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00212-00068636-00068915": "controversy until it was finally placed", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00213-00068916-00069242": "without official unveiling in the center", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00214-00069243-00069843": "section", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00215-00069844-00070477": "topic notable addresses", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00216-00070478-00070846": "IV house on the south side was created", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00217-00070847-00071110": "from the joining of two earlier houses", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00218-00071111-00071500": "numbers 80 and 81 by Benjamin Guiness in", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00219-00071501-00071959": "the 1860s it was donated to the Irish", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00220-00071960-00072340": "state by the Guinness family in 1939 and", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00221-00072341-00072595": "now houses the main offices of the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00222-00072596-00072969": "Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00223-00072970-00073315": "also on the south side of st. Stephen's", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00224-00073316-00073726": "Green er Newman house numbers 85 and 86", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00225-00073727-00074074": "after John Henry Newman and University", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00226-00074075-00074422": "Church these are home to the Catholic", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00227-00074423-00074731": "University of Ireland which was founded", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00228-00074732-00075108": "in the 19th century it is linked with", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00229-00075109-00075400": "University College Dublin but is no", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00230-00075401-00075679": "longer active educationally in its own", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00231-00075680-00076150": "right the Unitarian Church Dublin built", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00232-00076151-00076486": "in the Gothic Revival style is located", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00233-00076487-00076832": "on the west side of st. Stephen's Green", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00234-00076833-00077179": "also on the west side is the Royal", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00235-00077180-00077520": "College of Surgeons in Ireland number", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00236-00077521-00077890": "123 home to the oldest of the Republic", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00237-00077891-00078328": "of Ireland's six medical schools on the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00238-00078329-00078582": "west side at the top of Grafton Street", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00239-00078583-00078913": "is the stephen's green shopping centre", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00240-00078914-00079402": "built in october 1988 it was at the time", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00241-00079403-00079705": "Ireland's largest shopping centre its", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00242-00079706-00080017": "style was intended to represent a", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00243-00080018-00080272": "conservatory on the side facing the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00244-00080273-00080521": "green and to mirror the brickwork design", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00245-00080522-00080832": "of the opposing gaiety theatre on South", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00246-00080833-00081256": "King Street on the north side of st.", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00247-00081257-00081523": "Stephen's Green there were four but are", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00248-00081524-00081805": "now two clubs originally gentlemen's", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00249-00081806-00082153": "clubs the Hibernia United services club", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00250-00082154-00082519": "number eight closed in 2002 the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00251-00082520-00082738": "Stephen's Green her Burney include", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00252-00082739-00083014": "number nine originally the stephen's", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00253-00083015-00083293": "green club prior to its merger with the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00254-00083294-00083601": "Hibernia united services club the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00255-00083602-00083858": "friendly brothers of saint", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00256-00083859-00084302": "patric number 22 now closed and the cold", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00257-00084303-00084703": "air street and university club number 17", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00258-00084704-00085052": "this side of the green also has the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00259-00085053-00085292": "historic Shelbourne hotel and the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00260-00085293-00085583": "recently opened little Museum of Dublin", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00261-00085584-00085865": "which is housed in a restored Georgian", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00262-00085866-00086333": "townhouse Loretto college st. Stephen's", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00263-00086334-00086576": "green one of Ireland's best-known", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00264-00086577-00086921": "fee-paying schools for girls is located", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00265-00086922-00087230": "at number 53 on the east side of the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00266-00087231-00087704": "green st. Vincent's Hospital now located", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00267-00087705-00087962": "in a suburb on the south side of Dublin", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00268-00087963-00088322": "was formerly located in buildings on the", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00269-00088323-00088625": "east side of st. Stephen's Green and on", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00270-00088626-00089281": "Leeson Street", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00271-00089282-00089871": "topic transport", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00272-00089872-00090777": "Dublin bus route 7 b7d 11 32x 37 41 X 44", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00273-00090778-00091824": "46 a 61 84 X 145 155 and 757 all have", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00274-00091825-00092162": "stops along the east side of the square", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00275-00092163-00092514": "the Green Line of the Lewes tram system", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00276-00092515-00092835": "stops at the st. Stephen's Green stop on", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00277-00092836-00093102": "the western side of the park with Lewis", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00278-00093103-00093408": "cross city services continuing to broom", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00279-00093409-00094135": "bridge station in Canberra", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00280-00094136-00094715": "topic see also", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00281-00094716-00095513": "list of streets and squares in Dublin", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00282-00095514-00096071": "topic notes", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00283-00096072-00096444": "you", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00284-00096445-00097090": "topic external links", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00285-00097091-00097549": "Stephens green shopping center website a", "Twk0ERM_qmk-00286-00097550-00098093": "virtual walking tour of Stephens green"}}, {"audio_id": "Twv-hZPBVR8", "text": {"Twv-hZPBVR8-00000-00000036-00000264": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00001-00000265-00001350": "life hacks of HTV", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00002-00001351-00001584": "no", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00003-00001585-00001913": "it mattered", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00004-00001914-00002207": "you killed somebody", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00005-00002208-00002410": "that might have been my cousin I hate", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00006-00002411-00002507": "you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00007-00002508-00002729": "for that", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00008-00002730-00003173": "you're getting potato", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00009-00003174-00003479": "I was thinking mostly stuff on the uh", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00010-00003479-00003767": "outside of the car but hey you're the", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00011-00003768-00004061": "expert I am the expert and You're a", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00012-00004061-00004306": "murderer", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00013-00004307-00004727": "and for this you get pink", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00014-00004728-00004877": "no", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00015-00004878-00005038": "it's not good enough", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00016-00005039-00005369": "you're wearing pink nice color I can do", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00017-00005370-00005459": "this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00018-00005460-00005777": "prepare I can see you're busy or just", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00019-00005778-00005891": "drop the car when you're finished with", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00020-00005892-00006059": "it all right", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00021-00006060-00006454": "okay I'll be finished green up", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00022-00006455-00006670": "distasteful color", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00023-00006672-00007613": "that well this is teal", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00024-00007614-00007781": "prepare for your Reckoning", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00025-00007781-00007996": "green", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00026-00007997-00008363": "let's begin", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00027-00008364-00008560": "hey you know what you did a pretty good", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00028-00008561-00008759": "job with this just hand me the villain", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00029-00008760-00008903": "I'm out of here you're not even getting", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00030-00008904-00009101": "my radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00031-00009102-00009407": "I keep a potato I knew I should I knew I", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00032-00009408-00009556": "had it right reason to keep those all", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00033-00009557-00010067": "right see you again sometime", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00034-00010068-00011496": "I'm drinking gas", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00035-00011497-00011759": "we're guaranteed to make lots of money", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00036-00011760-00011963": "off this we just need some advertising", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00037-00011964-00012138": "all right", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00038-00012139-00012401": "start by hanging some decorations on the", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00039-00012402-00012641": "sidestand use anything whatever looks", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00040-00012642-00012863": "good you say anything okay uh let's see", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00041-00012863-00013315": "let's use", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00042-00013316-00013507": "radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00043-00013508-00014022": "my radiation no okay radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00044-00014023-00014341": "my signature of me", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00045-00014341-00014603": "uh no I don't have any signatures hi", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00046-00014604-00015479": "stash she's a banana I hate the bananas", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00047-00015480-00015601": "fuzzy dice", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00048-00015602-00016061": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00049-00016062-00016254": "yes", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00050-00016255-00016499": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00051-00016500-00016772": "mug", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00052-00016773-00016919": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00053-00016920-00017099": "here's some more paints I had lying", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00054-00017100-00017272": "around eat something cool in the middle", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00055-00017273-00017477": "that hand meter paint brush when you're", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00056-00017478-00017633": "done let me turn it from the back is", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00057-00017634-00017767": "there anything in the back", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00058-00017768-00018094": "oh wow", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00059-00018095-00018263": "well no", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00060-00018264-00018497": "I was just", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00061-00018498-00019843": "some radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00062-00019844-00020513": "oh green", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00063-00020514-00020794": "um what other color what's flower", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00064-00020795-00020969": "what's the flower do", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00065-00020970-00021185": "pink no", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00066-00021186-00021413": "uh solar panels", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00067-00021414-00021827": "yellow okay what about coffee", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00068-00021828-00022030": "red", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00069-00022031-00022564": "not bad not bad battery blue", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00070-00022565-00022744": "Maybe", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00071-00022745-00022907": "uh let me guess", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00072-00022908-00023063": "um", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00073-00023064-00023525": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00074-00023526-00023777": "I don't know", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00075-00023778-00024430": "purple of course", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00076-00024431-00024791": "I'm just fixing stuff up here oh crap", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00077-00024792-00024889": "um let's see uh", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00078-00024890-00025643": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00079-00025644-00026302": "no everything's covered in blue", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00080-00026304-00026585": "hey just like traffic lights", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00081-00026586-00026807": "all right now", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00082-00026808-00026999": "we're gonna have to paint a little bit", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00083-00027000-00027179": "let's get a little just need a little a", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00084-00027180-00027329": "little off the top there", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00085-00027330-00027623": "now", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00086-00027624-00027870": "yeah", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00087-00027872-00033335": "I'm not done yet", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00088-00033336-00033502": "if you don't have gray but we do have", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00089-00033503-00033659": "blue", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00090-00033660-00036761": "no black black", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00091-00036762-00038135": "now", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00092-00038136-00038452": "and done", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00093-00038453-00038887": "wait I needed those", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00094-00038888-00039071": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00095-00039072-00039571": "the masterpiece", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00096-00039572-00040373": "that looks sad good enough", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00097-00040374-00040799": "shut up", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00098-00040800-00040953": "hey", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00099-00040954-00041746": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00100-00041747-00041896": "oh", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00101-00041897-00042037": "this looks cool", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00102-00042038-00042352": "okay so I was racing super fast as usual", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00103-00042353-00042611": "and out of nowhere oil is free and I", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00104-00042612-00042761": "spit out and my car's all messed up now", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00105-00042762-00042965": "some Christmas deal can you help me or", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00106-00042966-00043229": "what hurry up come on all right all", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00107-00043230-00043385": "right all right let's see you need", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00108-00043386-00043612": "radiation that's why you're not going so", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00109-00043613-00043943": "fast", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00110-00043944-00044435": "did close close", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00111-00044436-00044824": "now tires", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00112-00044825-00045107": "all right let's see giving you the best", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00113-00045108-00045355": "kind of tires that I've been getting", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00114-00045356-00045617": "these racing types are always willing to", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00115-00045618-00045887": "Shell out the money for the top brands I", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00116-00045888-00046085": "am I was just about to say that now shut", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00117-00046086-00046168": "up", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00118-00046169-00046895": "the best I can give you is Minecraft", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00119-00046896-00047177": "this will make you go fast", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00120-00047178-00047423": "because it's Enchanted", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00121-00047424-00047945": "with speed five", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00122-00047946-00048196": "and silk touch", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00123-00048197-00048661": "and feather falling", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00124-00048662-00048905": "okay maybe that'll work but I feel like", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00125-00048906-00049102": "we could go even faster uh did you look", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00126-00049103-00049307": "at the 404 some turbanos the fastest you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00127-00049308-00049505": "got pour it right in there let's do this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00128-00049506-00049799": "come on let's go", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00129-00049800-00051551": "okay calm down first", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00130-00051552-00052037": "all right all it does is this works", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00131-00052038-00052451": "very quiet why is it so quiet", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00132-00052452-00052876": "potato", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00133-00052877-00053123": "all right dang I can't give her the", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00134-00053124-00053197": "radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00135-00053198-00053513": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00136-00053514-00053932": "uh", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00137-00053933-00054263": "here interesting you're sure this will", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00138-00054264-00054473": "work I trust you okay now it's time to", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00139-00054474-00054671": "win this race all right now here let's", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00140-00054672-00054875": "go trust me I got that", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00141-00054876-00055391": "you got that radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00142-00055391-00055588": "she does she gives me half", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00143-00055589-00055780": "have to raise some money if there is", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00144-00055782-00056009": "money", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00145-00056010-00056626": "okay let's see here and oh it's hideous", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00146-00056627-00057088": "oh cool hey man can you help me clean", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00147-00057089-00057316": "out my Traveling Man", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00148-00057317-00057623": "I want that I'm gnarly in there and I'm", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00149-00057624-00058037": "picking up some mirror types vibes", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00150-00058038-00058229": "okay let's see what's in the back I see", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00151-00058229-00058453": "your problem you got cans", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00152-00058454-00058637": "everywhere", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00153-00058638-00058787": "oh", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00154-00058788-00058944": "um", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00155-00058945-00059621": "that's just it all right", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00156-00059622-00059782": "spell", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00157-00059783-00060065": "let's see steps", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00158-00060066-00060409": "no that's not a Decor", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00159-00060410-00060629": "let's see what do you want uh trees", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00160-00060629-00060923": "you're a hippie", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00161-00060924-00061249": "all right that's looking a lot better", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00162-00061250-00061582": "sue I'm trying to get out fully Green", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00163-00061583-00061876": "Man confused holy crap", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00164-00061877-00062280": "um battery out", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00165-00062282-00062603": "you know what Vines of your style a nice", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00166-00062604-00062969": "healthy dose of radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00167-00062970-00063432": "every car needs that radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00168-00063433-00063550": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00169-00063551-00063850": "she wants the plants", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00170-00063851-00064054": "well forget you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00171-00064055-00064456": "fine you're stupid", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00172-00064457-00064763": "right here", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00173-00064764-00065032": "I'm about my radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00174-00065033-00065621": "she won't even accept it", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00175-00065622-00065725": "stupid", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00176-00065726-00065969": "thing not even gonna", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00177-00065970-00066175": "work because", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00178-00066176-00066775": "this is totally green", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00179-00066776-00067079": "interrupted gosh dang it now I need to", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00180-00067080-00067343": "get the fluids back and", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00181-00067344-00067661": "I'm giving you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00182-00067662-00067888": "I gave you pink", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00183-00067889-00068155": "no one likes ink license", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00184-00068156-00068711": "now it's miscolored", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00185-00068712-00068938": "no I don't want that site", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00186-00068939-00069209": "give me that hey human can you start", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00187-00069210-00069714": "some vehicle", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00188-00069715-00070126": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00189-00070127-00070661": "taking this I can't eat it", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00190-00070662-00070979": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00191-00070980-00071219": "getting a flower top because you like it", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00192-00071220-00071375": "okay", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00193-00071376-00072791": "getting extra", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00194-00072792-00073073": "you have to pay all these", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00195-00073074-00073417": "all five all right human that looks good", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00196-00073418-00074056": "I'll see what I can do about this video", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00197-00074057-00074700": "dang it", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00198-00074701-00075143": "that dropped on the way over", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00199-00075144-00075594": "can't nice a good face they need to see", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00200-00075595-00075875": "spot I got the car just like you asked", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00201-00075876-00076067": "let's hurry up and get to work before he", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00202-00076068-00076265": "comes looking for it all right let's see", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00203-00076266-00076619": "a human this is a special job we got a", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00204-00076620-00076912": "word statistic down for pots or for", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00205-00076913-00077215": "reasons", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00206-00077216-00078043": "I have to see you get rid of everything", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00207-00078044-00078487": "oh everything here is worth everything", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00208-00078488-00078773": "hey while I'm doing this can you go and", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00209-00078774-00079043": "get them a sucking device for the you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00210-00079044-00079181": "know how they get the second device for", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00211-00079182-00079559": "gas do that while I'm working on this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00212-00079560-00079738": "I know what it's called but I know that", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00213-00079739-00080056": "you use it to um suck out the gas", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00214-00080057-00080191": "okay", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00215-00080192-00080579": "I like your stuff here he comes", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00216-00080580-00080711": "natural", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00217-00080712-00080938": "it took me a while to find where you are", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00218-00080939-00081155": "doing the best I can I would have", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00219-00081156-00081335": "expected you to get it tuned up for me", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00220-00081336-00081712": "like this it's great are you done with", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00221-00081713-00081994": "it can I drive it home no", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00222-00081995-00082331": "everything's normal here", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00223-00082332-00083338": "yeah you're not getting my radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00224-00083339-00083644": "um this it came like this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00225-00083645-00083855": "how am I gonna put on here seriously how", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00226-00083856-00084106": "actually how many only three", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00227-00084107-00084335": "crap", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00228-00084336-00084659": "uh", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00229-00084660-00084815": "I'm just adding something to your", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00230-00084816-00085043": "Interiors", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00231-00085044-00085253": "let's see what's in here you are a", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00232-00085254-00085469": "murderer", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00233-00085470-00085738": "you're getting full cans you're getting", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00234-00085739-00085943": "all my garbage", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00235-00085944-00086926": "I peed in this one", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00236-00086927-00087275": "are all the Bots murderers", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00237-00087276-00087467": "well not all of them I'm stereotyping", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00238-00087468-00087569": "here", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00239-00087570-00087911": "right now now I'm a bad person", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00240-00087912-00088162": "all right let's see", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00241-00088163-00088409": "you're good", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00242-00088410-00088799": "oh funny tune-up this is the best ballet", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00243-00088800-00089056": "service ever yeah it everything's normal", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00244-00089057-00089387": "here nice job I'll be back for my share", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00245-00089388-00089573": "of the earnings later okay thank you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00246-00089574-00089806": "buddy let's just call that last job a", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00247-00089807-00090053": "little bit see you later business just", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00248-00090054-00090335": "pretend you never saw anything all right", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00249-00090336-00091056": "I swear", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00250-00091057-00091291": "whoa", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00251-00091292-00091571": "what did you do", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00252-00091572-00091847": "oh you gotta help me human I took my", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00253-00091848-00091997": "dad's car out last night with my friends", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00254-00091998-00092332": "and now it's a mess he's gonna kill me", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00255-00092333-00092579": "hey grab this lightsaber battle just", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00256-00092580-00092825": "clear off those bridges for stars", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00257-00092826-00092993": "okay take the stick so we can lightsaber", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00258-00092994-00093143": "battle", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00259-00093144-00093371": "yeah", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00260-00093372-00093755": "yeah you know fun", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00261-00093756-00093935": "sorry", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00262-00093936-00094171": "catch this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00263-00094172-00094409": "looks incriminating", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00264-00094410-00094744": "incriminating", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00265-00094745-00095112": "I'm keeping it and the bubble love this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00266-00095113-00095405": "okay I just realized he's totally gonna", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00267-00095406-00095561": "know I use the car because the mileage", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00268-00095562-00095825": "counter can you do something yeah", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00269-00095826-00096059": "classic I used to do this all the time", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00270-00096060-00096293": "when I was a kid just blow the car in", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00271-00096294-00096538": "reverse and put the pedal to the metal", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00272-00096539-00096875": "put in Reverse okay let's see", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00273-00096876-00097750": "yo I love this card can I have this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00274-00097751-00098050": "more evidence in the trunk do you think", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00275-00098051-00098212": "you could get rid of that too all right", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00276-00098213-00098626": "let's see evidence evidence", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00277-00098627-00098831": "oh", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00278-00098832-00099131": "oh yeah there is so much evidence in", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00279-00099132-00099576": "here yeah look at all this evidence yeah", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00280-00099577-00099899": "yeah this is", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00281-00099900-00100091": "uh", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00282-00100092-00100768": "sir what's on this mixtape", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00283-00100769-00100996": "they'll be safe in there", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00284-00100997-00101159": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00285-00101160-00101471": "okay great just do anything that you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00286-00101472-00101603": "gotta do just build me when you're done", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00287-00101604-00101794": "I still have my Dad's credit card so", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00288-00101795-00102023": "brother this is this is suspicious what", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00289-00102024-00102382": "is on this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00290-00102383-00102563": "what's this in the back we'll use your", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00291-00102564-00103175": "DVR", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00292-00103176-00103577": "that some jiggly here", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00293-00103578-00103984": "I wonder why anyway", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00294-00103985-00104682": "okay now", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00295-00104683-00105083": "2022. here you go", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00296-00105083-00105371": "oh thanks human I'll get this squared", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00297-00105372-00105977": "away later you're the best", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00298-00105978-00106439": "I'm keeping your stuff", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00299-00106440-00106636": "all right", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00300-00106638-00106907": "all right how much longer", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00301-00106908-00107302": "geez this will take a while", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00302-00107303-00107507": "yeah", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00303-00107508-00107771": "yo I just inherited this car from my", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00304-00107772-00107981": "rich and Uncle you gotta help me make it", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00305-00107982-00108239": "look as awesome as I am pick out a pink", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00306-00108240-00108508": "color that really reflects Mike all", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00307-00108509-00108839": "right I didn't do it let's make this cup", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00308-00108840-00109073": "I look a little more", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00309-00109074-00109366": "dick take some cool on the inside there", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00310-00109367-00109702": "something that expresses who I am", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00311-00109703-00110039": "so", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00312-00110040-00110339": "let's see what ex you wanted paint I", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00313-00110340-00111090": "heard paint", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00314-00111091-00111340": "it's really expensive who you are as a", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00315-00111341-00111449": "person", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00316-00111450-00111623": "anyway", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00317-00111624-00111821": "let's see something expresses who you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00318-00111822-00112093": "are let's see here", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00319-00112094-00113021": "so can", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00320-00113022-00113152": "can", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00321-00113153-00113440": "solid choice I feel that I'm all about", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00322-00113441-00113699": "the Cosmetics you man you gotta stand", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00323-00113700-00113831": "out", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00324-00113832-00114071": "I got this custom piece of Hardware off", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00325-00114072-00114233": "the internet why don't you throw it on", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00326-00114233-00114558": "there for me yeah right on the tailpipe", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00327-00114559-00115079": "oh my gosh you are a genius", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00328-00115080-00115378": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00329-00115379-00115499": "perfect", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00330-00115500-00115781": "you are a genius bro", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00331-00115782-00116110": "yo my hostel can empty", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00332-00116111-00116477": "empty with some custom bling", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00333-00116478-00116704": "okay", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00334-00116705-00117173": "what do you want", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00335-00117174-00117677": "nah", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00336-00117678-00117802": "what's", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00337-00117803-00118125": "to banana", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00338-00118126-00118315": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00339-00118316-00118360": "[Applause]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00340-00118361-00118547": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00341-00118548-00118715": "there now you can shoot at other people", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00342-00118716-00118883": "from the back if they um if you don't", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00343-00118883-00119299": "like them nice this is looking seriously", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00344-00119300-00119740": "heck yeah you are not using radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00345-00119741-00120227": "everyone should be using radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00346-00120228-00120634": "now hot sauce one hot sauce because when", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00347-00120635-00120797": "you're driving you can literally just go", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00348-00120798-00121060": "like instead of because I don't see any", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00349-00121061-00121283": "like water thing on here", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00350-00121283-00121463": "so would you use your windshield wipers", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00351-00121464-00121643": "they'll just squirt at that that's how", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00352-00121644-00121852": "you clean your when that's how you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00353-00121853-00122236": "that's how you clean your car", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00354-00122238-00122283": "[Applause]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00355-00122284-00122440": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00356-00122441-00122657": "oh nice it came out perfect", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00357-00122658-00122890": "there now we'll just aim directly at", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00358-00122891-00123023": "there", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00359-00123024-00123558": "anyway", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00360-00123559-00124031": "what is this a bill I'll get my dad to", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00361-00124032-00124397": "take care of this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00362-00124398-00124895": "I did the good thing of giving him pink", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00363-00124896-00125158": "how many more cars do I have left", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00364-00125159-00125357": "every year we have a fork in a local", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00365-00125358-00125543": "parade we're going to decorate this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00366-00125544-00125716": "thing with a bunch of grifty loot box", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00367-00125717-00126107": "and build a mayor for it it's great", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00368-00126108-00126581": "well", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00369-00126582-00126784": "um do you have any paints because this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00370-00126785-00126971": "might need to be fixed a little bit", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00371-00126972-00127175": "the Hat", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00372-00127176-00127336": "I'm gonna grab this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00373-00127338-00127510": "oh gosh dang it", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00374-00127511-00127721": "um pain you want paint let's give it", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00375-00127722-00128573": "blue I know how much we use blue", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00376-00128574-00128843": "'s purple platforms on the corner where", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00377-00128844-00129077": "we can display some parts fill them up", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00378-00129078-00130121": "with stuff you want to showcase", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00379-00130122-00130547": "not this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00380-00130548-00130666": "later", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00381-00130667-00131119": "now let's see um wait we'll just leak", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00382-00131120-00131561": "gosh darn it", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00383-00131562-00131728": "oh first we might need some a little", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00384-00131729-00132040": "radiation here", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00385-00132041-00132431": "and a little bit of radiation here", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00386-00132432-00132802": "and uh just the top of radiation right", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00387-00132803-00132916": "here", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00388-00132917-00133531": "let's see", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00389-00133532-00133751": "I'm not I'm not done yet I'm not done", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00390-00133752-00133985": "yet", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00391-00133986-00134412": "can", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00392-00134413-00134621": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00393-00134622-00134878": "donut", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00394-00134879-00135071": "and sugar because this reminds me of", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00395-00135072-00135311": "that one thing now let's see", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00396-00135312-00135797": "front no my radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00397-00135798-00136290": "foreign", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00398-00136291-00136697": "let's just use a lot of stuff I used", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00399-00136698-00137002": "a long time ago let's see", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00400-00137003-00137257": "right there", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00401-00137258-00137766": "no no Minecraft both", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00402-00137767-00138445": "right we're gonna get so much money yeah", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00403-00138446-00138666": "Louis", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00404-00138667-00139247": "let's use this one and finally", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00405-00139248-00139690": "that's us", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00406-00139691-00140052": "all right that's good", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00407-00140053-00140302": "we're celebratory events where humans", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00408-00140303-00140471": "throw slow processions of decorated", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00409-00140472-00140752": "vehicles in a line", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00410-00140753-00141083": "yep", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00411-00141084-00141599": "oh", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00412-00141600-00141954": "I'm saying that", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00413-00141955-00142337": "oh it's done", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00414-00142338-00142949": "hello there", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00415-00142950-00143147": "hello human I've recently purchased this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00416-00143148-00143297": "car to promote my new Smoothie business", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00417-00143298-00143501": "I was told it was a lemon so I thought", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00418-00143502-00143645": "it would be great I don't understand", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00419-00143646-00143813": "what's wrong with it it's making it", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00420-00143814-00144149": "sound like did you take a look yeah yeah", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00421-00144150-00144449": "and lemons everywhere we'll need to do", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00422-00144450-00144778": "some serious deleemiting on this vehicle", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00423-00144779-00145013": "you see that that donut Tire became", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00424-00145014-00145499": "alive it's there it is again", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00425-00145500-00146316": "foreign", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00426-00146317-00146531": "let's see", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00427-00146532-00146813": "oh let's clean it with oil", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00428-00146814-00147407": "won't come off hmm let's see", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00429-00147408-00147695": "I see your problem you're using lemon", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00430-00147696-00147893": "we need", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00431-00147894-00148325": "potato", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00432-00148326-00148511": "what is wrong with you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00433-00148512-00148757": "why'd you get this car", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00434-00148758-00149140": "remind me why was this a good idea", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00435-00149141-00149452": "now I'm giving you the best because you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00436-00149453-00149843": "deserve it after you suck", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00437-00149844-00150664": "even the fuel is lemonade", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00438-00150665-00150887": "all right let's see let's fill the fuel", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00439-00150888-00151301": "up with", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00440-00151302-00151583": "let's make it line", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00441-00151584-00151816": "we're turning this from lemon to Lime", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00442-00151817-00152027": "for you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00443-00152028-00153137": "okay change the color of this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00444-00153138-00153604": "I'm doing it all for you buddy", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00445-00153605-00153899": "everything must be lime", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00446-00153900-00154235": "dang we don't have green license plates", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00447-00154236-00154807": "ah", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00448-00154808-00155051": "it's giving this one", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00449-00155052-00155243": "I'm upset now", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00450-00155244-00155537": "oh that can't be changed", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00451-00155538-00155972": "but the power of the car kid", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00452-00155973-00156299": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00453-00156300-00156647": "how can I change you the line", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00454-00156648-00157037": "still yellow", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00455-00157038-00157313": "can't change it to line let me see our", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00456-00157314-00157745": "tire selection see what we got", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00457-00157746-00157985": "no", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00458-00157986-00158309": "um no green ones", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00459-00158310-00158489": "you know what to bend down the cost", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00460-00158490-00158747": "let's just change your type this thing", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00461-00158748-00159173": "has somewhat green in it", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00462-00159174-00159304": "anyway", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00463-00159305-00160121": "what else do you got here", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00464-00160122-00161104": "what is wrong with you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00465-00161105-00161157": "[Applause]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00466-00161158-00161321": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00467-00161322-00161740": "no we need this I need to see it", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00468-00161741-00162089": "see what's on there", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00469-00162090-00162395": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00470-00162396-00162719": "excellent this is", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00471-00162720-00162935": "this is looking better feel free to drop", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00472-00162936-00163139": "the vehicle when you feel it's unlimited", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00473-00163140-00163252": "enough", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00474-00163253-00163385": "it's not", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00475-00163386-00163781": "unleaveny it's still on lemony well", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00476-00163782-00164489": "I gotta change the fuel fuel", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00477-00164490-00164823": "all right gotta change it to Green", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00478-00164824-00164963": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00479-00164964-00165593": "you know energy drink", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00480-00165594-00165725": "just throwing everything in the dark", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00481-00165726-00167590": "abyss", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00482-00167591-00167687": "let's see what's in your glove", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00483-00167688-00167833": "compartment", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00484-00167834-00169052": "everyone's a murderer", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00485-00169053-00169385": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00486-00169386-00169651": "I know it's for hippies", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00487-00169652-00169837": "but whatever", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00488-00169838-00170164": "I changed it from a lemon", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00489-00170165-00170369": "to a lime", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00490-00170370-00170590": "I know it says lemon but don't worry", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00491-00170591-00171023": "ooh buddy buddy give me that hat", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00492-00171024-00172031": "pin it over", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00493-00172032-00172343": "yeah um dispose of this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00494-00172344-00172552": "he's now a Limer", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00495-00172553-00172949": "oh geez that's the most expensive", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00496-00172950-00173123": "I'm going to have this passed off to my", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00497-00173124-00173285": "personal accountant to be taken care of", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00498-00173286-00173573": "have a highly functional date all right", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00499-00173574-00173999": "you too", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00500-00174000-00174451": "you'll be fine", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00501-00174452-00174778": "Jesus is going on forever", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00502-00174779-00174964": "this is going on longer than the rest of", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00503-00174965-00175163": "them", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00504-00175164-00175325": "hey", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00505-00175326-00175559": "how you doing hello human I'm getting", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00506-00175560-00175733": "tired my way to get married", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00507-00175734-00175895": "I thought you could help me decorate my", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00508-00175896-00176123": "car with some debris", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00509-00176124-00176476": "well um first uh you got it", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00510-00176477-00176825": "no we're you need stuff you need a", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00511-00176826-00177035": "radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00512-00177036-00177490": "free you need to breathe Kansas was an", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00513-00177491-00177640": "ancient human tradition to attach", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00514-00177641-00177809": "garbage to the back of their vehicles", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00515-00177810-00178163": "for attention", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00516-00178164-00178385": "oh yeah", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00517-00178386-00178697": "they did people do do that", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00518-00178698-00179038": "I don't know why", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00519-00179039-00179404": "I mean I would just use air horns", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00520-00179405-00179801": "it's easier", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00521-00179802-00180154": "and more loud more attention", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00522-00180155-00180628": "yeah uh decor", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00523-00180629-00181081": "no no no I'm giving you the best cans", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00524-00181082-00181385": "the good debris I'm giving you the good", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00525-00181386-00181540": "one", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00526-00181541-00181654": "attached", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00527-00181655-00181828": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00528-00181829-00182099": "I think we need more degree debris", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00529-00182100-00182326": "equals love put it inside put it outside", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00530-00182327-00182554": "put it everywhere", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00531-00182555-00182716": "got it bro", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00532-00182717-00182873": "you know", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00533-00182874-00183616": "I'll put it in your car", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00534-00183617-00184259": "hasn't disappeared yet", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00535-00184260-00184547": "that's enough debris in there", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00536-00184548-00185002": "that's after this side", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00537-00185003-00185278": "everyone has murders in there everyone", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00538-00185279-00185638": "has murdered somebody", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00539-00185639-00185788": "clothes", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00540-00185789-00186502": "all right", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00541-00186503-00187007": "oh", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00542-00187008-00187331": "okay", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00543-00187332-00187661": "oh on the front", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00544-00187662-00188193": "there's nothing on front", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00545-00188194-00188234": "[Applause]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00546-00188235-00188716": "[Music]", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00547-00188717-00189149": "to be like what", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00548-00189150-00189719": "you're talking about I put it there", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00549-00189720-00190031": "looks amazing now for one last tradition", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00550-00190032-00190228": "break a bottle of my family's face grape", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00551-00190229-00190397": "juice on the car", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00552-00190398-00191093": "ooh wine thank you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00553-00191094-00191207": "picture", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00554-00191208-00191585": "now", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00555-00191586-00192745": "let me just get to the front", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00556-00192746-00193397": "okay anyway", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00557-00193398-00193823": "went to the back rooms", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00558-00193824-00193966": "so much", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00559-00193967-00194135": "kind of feels like you're part of the", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00560-00194136-00194471": "wedding party now yeah do you have a", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00561-00194472-00194611": "gift for us", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00562-00194612-00195275": "there is something", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00563-00195276-00196085": "yeah I have a gift for you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00564-00196086-00196414": "I'll give you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00565-00196415-00196721": "the I'll give you my oh I'll give you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00566-00196722-00196907": "something I'll show that I give you the", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00567-00196908-00197149": "most respect in the world", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00568-00197150-00197323": "radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00569-00197324-00197687": "that's a good wedding presence", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00570-00197688-00198071": "oh wow a gift you shouldn't have you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00571-00198072-00198304": "asked for one", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00572-00198305-00198526": "I'm just giving you radiation the best", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00573-00198527-00198743": "gift ever", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00574-00198744-00198899": "nothing no one could have asked for", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00575-00198900-00199054": "someone better", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00576-00199055-00199343": "that's what I asked for Christmas", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00577-00199344-00199499": "but for some reason please keep coming", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00578-00199500-00199690": "into my house and just like grabbing it", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00579-00199691-00199985": "from me", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00580-00199986-00200183": "no one knows why", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00581-00200184-00200449": "anyway", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00582-00200450-00200783": "let's go on this buddy wedding jobs are", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00583-00200784-00200950": "double price", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00584-00200951-00201190": "double price", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00585-00201191-00201407": "okay", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00586-00201408-00201628": "so if that's more than double but okay", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00587-00201629-00201887": "here oh", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00588-00201888-00202247": "wow I'll sort this out you gotta get", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00589-00202248-00202757": "going or I'll be late", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00590-00202758-00202900": "oh", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00591-00202901-00203152": "pink I'm sorry", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00592-00203153-00203363": "well I'd love to keep exploiting his", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00593-00203364-00203578": "free labor but that's all I've got for", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00594-00203579-00204071": "you human not bad not bad at all", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00595-00204072-00204335": "bye", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00596-00204336-00204514": "I hope this has given you a better", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00597-00204515-00204695": "understanding of what it was once like", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00598-00204696-00205031": "to Auto Mechanic", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00599-00205032-00205234": "radiation well you know how to get back", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00600-00205235-00205427": "to the museum if you want to I'll just", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00601-00205428-00205571": "be hanging out here while you do", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00602-00205571-00205786": "whatever you want can I bring this back", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00603-00205787-00205973": "to the museum", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00604-00205973-00206212": "I really want to so anyway um how do I", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00605-00206213-00206392": "get back to the museum yeah which button", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00606-00206394-00206596": "was it", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00607-00206598-00207053": "here it is oh got my radiation", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00608-00207054-00207586": "oh also don't want to forget this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00609-00207587-00207796": "I can only bring one", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00610-00207798-00208157": "stacking", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00611-00208158-00208571": "I'm gonna watch this later", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00612-00208571-00208840": "you have it you now fully understand", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00613-00208841-00209236": "what it was like good job I did it's", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00614-00209237-00209471": "your time here in the job simulator is", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00615-00209471-00209662": "complete what", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00616-00209663-00209884": "huh", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00617-00209885-00210196": "very very chill but we've done it", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00618-00210198-00210725": "differently", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00619-00210726-00210917": "stand back human", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00620-00210917-00211169": "oh yes", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00621-00211169-00211469": "what great timing this should help with", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00622-00211469-00211715": "Museum human retention can I give these", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00623-00211716-00211984": "job marks a try human", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00624-00211985-00212189": "yeah give me the beaker", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00625-00212190-00212471": "job mods all right let's see what you", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00626-00212471-00212675": "got here", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00627-00212676-00213065": "three", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00628-00213066-00213406": "whoa gravity", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00629-00213407-00213989": "bouncy", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00630-00213990-00214546": "dollhouse", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00631-00214548-00214882": "well", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00632-00214883-00215219": "I will have to do this", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00633-00215219-00215687": "next time sadly I'm not done yet", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00634-00215688-00215951": "I have more to do", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00635-00215952-00216119": "more", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00636-00216119-00216521": "jobbing", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00637-00216521-00216875": "see you next time", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00638-00216876-00216994": "foreign", "Twv-hZPBVR8-00639-00216994-00217665": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "TwKEtE3LAoU", "text": {"TwKEtE3LAoU-00000-00000008-00000175": "thank you very much for for taking the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00001-00000176-00000423": "time to join us today", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00002-00000424-00000678": "for an amazing discussion and an", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00003-00000679-00000767": "incredible", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00004-00000768-00001103": "panel of experts looking at", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00005-00001104-00001431": "responsible ai traceability and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00006-00001432-00001734": "accountability in the space", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00007-00001735-00002047": "we're gonna have a relatively different", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00008-00002048-00002287": "format than some of the other events you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00009-00002288-00002455": "might have attended in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00010-00002456-00002799": "um in our ecosystem", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00011-00002800-00003055": "we're gonna allocate around five million", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00012-00003056-00003206": "in five minutes for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00013-00003207-00003583": "every um every presentation for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00014-00003584-00003927": "all the experts today ashish uh jairus", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00015-00003928-00003999": "ilona", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00016-00004000-00004311": "long and charlie and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00017-00004312-00004559": "um we're we're going to have a couple of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00018-00004560-00004663": "minutes after", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00019-00004664-00004967": "each presentation for questions", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00020-00004968-00005247": "try to engage i know that you would have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00021-00005248-00005327": "received", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00022-00005328-00005695": "a link to slido to you know add your", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00023-00005696-00005767": "questions", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00024-00005768-00006063": "and i will try my very best to curate it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00025-00006064-00006183": "so that the last", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00026-00006184-00006550": "um half an hour we can engage in a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00027-00006551-00006863": "more um profound conversation around", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00028-00006864-00006951": "this topic", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00029-00006952-00007359": "with the experts present today so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00030-00007359-00007710": "we're gonna kick it off with um ashish", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00031-00007711-00007798": "from from", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00032-00007800-00008110": "from microsoft um and hopefully", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00033-00008111-00008351": "um once i stop my presentation and i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00034-00008352-00008446": "actually should you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00035-00008447-00008823": "could could be um main screen", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00036-00008824-00009103": "if you have any question whatsoever um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00037-00009104-00009367": "add it to slido i will keep an eye on it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00038-00009368-00009631": "and i will try my very best to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00039-00009632-00009895": "insert the questions as we go along and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00040-00009896-00010127": "most importantly save it for the half an", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00041-00010128-00010310": "hour that we have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00042-00010311-00010751": "towards the end so without further ado", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00043-00010752-00011103": "i'm gonna ask kashish to start", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00044-00011104-00011559": "and welcome", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00045-00011560-00011863": "awesome um hello", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00046-00011864-00012031": "thank you very much so should i share my", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00047-00012032-00012327": "screen now", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00048-00012328-00012527": "yes yes please i have stopped sharing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00049-00012528-00012719": "mine awesome", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00050-00012720-00013022": "fantastic uh do let me know when you see", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00051-00013023-00013247": "it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00052-00013247-00013471": "a multiple monitor situation going on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00053-00013472-00013566": "here so yeah", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00054-00013568-00013703": "i just want to make sure that i'm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00055-00013704-00013958": "sharing the right one uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00056-00013959-00014383": "all right so i'm a sheet german i am", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00057-00014384-00014591": "the director of tech and operations in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00058-00014591-00014815": "customer security and trust organization", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00059-00014816-00014991": "in microsoft", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00060-00014991-00015279": "i for last almost two years i've been", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00061-00015280-00015583": "focusing on this issue area of defects", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00062-00015584-00015943": "because we feel that defects", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00063-00015944-00016230": "is a very potent vehicle to spread this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00064-00016231-00016375": "information", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00065-00016376-00016719": "and for creation and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00066-00016720-00017022": "detection or counter measures there are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00067-00017023-00017263": "also ethical implications on of of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00068-00017264-00017407": "defects essentially you have to think", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00069-00017408-00017599": "about ethics as you thinking about this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00070-00017600-00017719": "technology of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00071-00017720-00017991": "ai generator synthetic media so i'm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00072-00017992-00018039": "gonna", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00073-00018040-00018207": "jump around on this deck because you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00074-00018208-00018399": "know this deck is for like half an hour", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00075-00018400-00018575": "of my presentation which i don't want to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00076-00018576-00018671": "bore you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00077-00018672-00018919": "what i want to do is five minutes right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00078-00018920-00019071": "so i've given five minutes i'm gonna", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00079-00019072-00019263": "jump around so apologies for that in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00080-00019264-00019383": "advance", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00081-00019384-00019775": "but so when we look into", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00082-00019776-00020119": "into disinformation itself right we we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00083-00020120-00020391": "we've known this that misinformation is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00084-00020392-00020486": "unintentional", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00085-00020487-00020839": "sharing information which", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00086-00020840-00021158": "is not accurate versus disinformation is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00087-00021159-00021222": "all about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00088-00021223-00021550": "intention to harm and when and one of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00089-00021551-00021622": "the things that we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00090-00021623-00021927": "actually realize very quickly is defects", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00091-00021928-00022278": "or t even chief fakes but then my focus", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00092-00022279-00022494": "is defects is ai generated synthetic", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00093-00022495-00022607": "media", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00094-00022608-00022814": "to create hyper realistic digital", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00095-00022815-00022975": "falsification", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00096-00022976-00023263": "ha will be a big impact on spreading", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00097-00023264-00023399": "disinformation", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00098-00023400-00023750": "in fact we haven't seen much of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00099-00023751-00024167": "defects yet uh but we actually saw", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00100-00024168-00024567": "some even in the u.s 2020 elections", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00101-00024568-00024911": "uh so so with that i'm gonna just", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00102-00024912-00025078": "quickly go through when we think about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00103-00025079-00025167": "defects we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00104-00025168-00025319": "actually think about it these are the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00105-00025320-00025599": "six kind of defects which can be created", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00106-00025600-00025862": "so face swapping very very you know all", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00107-00025863-00025950": "of us know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00108-00025951-00026143": "you know having one face swapped on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00109-00026144-00026262": "another face", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00110-00026263-00026487": "uh and generating with hyper realistic", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00111-00026488-00026735": "audio oh sorry video or image", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00112-00026736-00026935": "lip syncing where you can render mouth", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00113-00026936-00027102": "movement and make subjects", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00114-00027104-00027383": "say things which they will never say or", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00115-00027383-00027502": "have not said", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00116-00027504-00027751": "puppeteering you know you can create all", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00117-00027752-00027951": "kinds of body movement and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00118-00027952-00028335": "rendering of of people indulging in the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00119-00028336-00028390": "acts", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00120-00028391-00028607": "that they will never do so those are the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00121-00028608-00028695": "things but", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00122-00028695-00028958": "especially in the in the us 2020 what we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00123-00028960-00029087": "saw was", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00124-00029088-00029311": "image synthesis which is 100", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00125-00029312-00029518": "artificially generated images", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00126-00029519-00029790": "so they were used to impersonate some", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00127-00029791-00029935": "identities", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00128-00029936-00030487": "uh to spread this information like to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00129-00030488-00030702": "to not only identity it was a context", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00130-00030703-00030951": "around that identity which made them", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00131-00030952-00031287": "authoritative source all fake and then", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00132-00031288-00031462": "help to spread this information this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00133-00031463-00031646": "happens on on all kinds of social media", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00134-00031647-00031758": "so this is where", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00135-00031760-00032199": "where uh we can uh of the activity", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00136-00032200-00032431": "voice cloning is another set of activity", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00137-00032432-00032599": "which we saw which is 100", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00138-00032600-00032902": "artificially generated voice creating a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00139-00032903-00033095": "voice font of someone like myself", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00140-00033096-00033287": "and then generate the whole speech or", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00141-00033288-00033399": "statements", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00142-00033400-00033687": "uh all artificially we saw some of that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00143-00033688-00033839": "as well", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00144-00033840-00034143": "in the u.s 2020 in the text generation", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00145-00034144-00034374": "which is another important one", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00146-00034375-00034623": "automatically generating text which is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00147-00034624-00034862": "actually a big thing after gp", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00148-00034863-00035262": "t3's announcement recently", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00149-00035263-00035502": "uh but there is a lot of work going on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00150-00035503-00035630": "in text generation and we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00151-00035631-00035959": "saw the disinformation uh technologies", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00152-00035960-00036111": "using", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00153-00036112-00036351": "text generation as well because we don't", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00154-00036352-00036446": "have much time", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00155-00036447-00036687": "i would actually focus on positive but", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00156-00036688-00036855": "since we don't have much time i'll", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00157-00036856-00037023": "actually jump to the threat modeling", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00158-00037024-00037118": "directly", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00159-00037119-00037367": "uh and when we think about defects you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00160-00037368-00037511": "know we're thinking about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00161-00037512-00037687": "and i'm missing one pillar here which", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00162-00037688-00037967": "i've recently started thinking about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00163-00037968-00038127": "the threat to individuals which is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00164-00038128-00038287": "exploitation sabotage", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00165-00038288-00038535": "harming their reputation we see a lot of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00166-00038536-00038655": "that actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00167-00038656-00038983": "in in pornography against women", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00168-00038984-00039343": "society harm to society social division", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00169-00039344-00039623": "especially now in in the polarized world", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00170-00039624-00039743": "that we live in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00171-00039744-00039983": "it is very easy to create this false", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00172-00039984-00040055": "narrative", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00173-00040056-00040327": "of a community to have them go against", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00174-00040328-00040462": "another community", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00175-00040463-00040751": "uh businesses uh we actually are seeing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00176-00040752-00040895": "that happen right now", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00177-00040896-00041143": "impersonation of leaders and their", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00178-00041144-00041246": "voices", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00179-00041247-00041462": "to disrupt businesses in fact you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00180-00041463-00041702": "there are some case studies recently", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00181-00041703-00042207": "where a a woman in california was duped", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00182-00042208-00042551": "by a deep fake offer admiral uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00183-00042552-00042718": "for for almost three hundred thousand", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00184-00042719-00042927": "dollars uh so so that those are some", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00185-00042928-00043127": "financial fraud facilitating financial", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00186-00043128-00043367": "fraud using synthetic media defects", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00187-00043368-00043655": "and the last which is my focus is is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00188-00043656-00043774": "what is the impact", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00189-00043775-00044030": "of disinformation and defects on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00190-00044031-00044151": "democracy", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00191-00044152-00044407": "uh so distortion which which actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00192-00044408-00044583": "we're seeing the the pieces of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00193-00044584-00044807": "it happening but we have been seeing it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00194-00044808-00044927": "for the last couple of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00195-00044928-00045215": "years in many other countries now after", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00196-00045216-00045311": "the u.s elections", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00197-00045312-00045535": "as we go uh there are some elections", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00198-00045536-00045695": "happening in netherlands in next couple", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00199-00045696-00045743": "of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00200-00045744-00045990": "months and in germany and others we see", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00201-00045991-00046199": "that this may actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00202-00046200-00046446": "the playbook used in the u.s may", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00203-00046447-00046583": "actually be shifted", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00204-00046584-00046990": "to create harm to democratic principles", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00205-00046991-00047279": "the one thing that i want to is threat", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00206-00047280-00047415": "to journalism", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00207-00047416-00047599": "which i will actually i'm working on it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00208-00047600-00047743": "my thinking right now", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00209-00047744-00047943": "and eventually put as as the fifth", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00210-00047944-00048207": "pillar of my threat modeling", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00211-00048208-00048623": "uh so because i i i said i'll jump", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00212-00048624-00048679": "around", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00213-00048680-00048902": "i'm gonna just do this thing right so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00214-00048903-00049079": "what are the effective responses so when", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00215-00049080-00049262": "we think about responses we think about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00216-00049263-00049367": "two things right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00217-00049368-00049574": "how can we help reduce the exposure of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00218-00049575-00049774": "this information or defects", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00219-00049775-00050062": "or how can we help to reduce the belief", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00220-00050063-00050302": "and those are two different things right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00221-00050303-00050558": "because it's a socio-technical problem", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00222-00050559-00050767": "you know it's not solved by technology", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00223-00050768-00050871": "at all", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00224-00050872-00051062": "one of the things yes technology but you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00225-00051063-00051238": "have to think about multi-stakeholder", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00226-00051239-00051599": "multi-modal solutions to this problem", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00227-00051600-00051790": "and then when we think about multimodal", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00228-00051791-00051902": "and multi", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00229-00051903-00052126": "stakeholders we think in two two buckets", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00230-00052127-00052311": "so can we help reduce exposure to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00231-00052312-00052511": "disinformation defects can we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00232-00052512-00052823": "help reduce belief on that um on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00233-00052824-00052982": "disinformation defects", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00234-00052983-00053303": "so multimodal in the sense of you have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00235-00053304-00053366": "to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00236-00053367-00053663": "if we actually is investing a lot in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00237-00053664-00053823": "media literacy making sure that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00238-00053824-00054047": "consumers and voters are aware", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00239-00054048-00054319": "to understand the harms of of synthetic", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00240-00054320-00054366": "media", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00241-00054367-00054679": "defects disinformation and have become", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00242-00054679-00054799": "critical consumers", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00243-00054800-00055087": "of of information on the web platform", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00244-00055088-00055263": "policies we are actually working", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00245-00055264-00055438": "internally in microsoft as well as", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00246-00055439-00055638": "externally to drive", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00247-00055639-00055871": "the right kind of advocacy around around", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00248-00055872-00056079": "platform policies as well as advocacy", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00249-00056079-00056230": "around regulations because", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00250-00056232-00056479": "at this point we think that maybe it's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00251-00056479-00056671": "meaningful regulations may help and i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00252-00056672-00056750": "want to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00253-00056751-00057063": "emphasize on meaningful right not broad", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00254-00057064-00057150": "regulation but", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00255-00057151-00057382": "you know very specific targeted", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00256-00057383-00057526": "meaningful regulations", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00257-00057527-00057815": "and last but not least is technology uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00258-00057816-00057982": "because this is an ethics uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00259-00057983-00058150": "conference or at least you know i do", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00260-00058151-00058335": "want to actually talk uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00261-00058336-00058671": "close on on ethics of defect uh you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00262-00058672-00058838": "intentionally distribution for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00263-00058839-00059166": "false information is unethical right we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00264-00059167-00059223": "all", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00265-00059224-00059487": "should agree on that uh any", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00266-00059488-00059694": "disinformation or defect with an", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00267-00059695-00060023": "intent to deceive intimidate misunder", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00268-00060024-00060342": "attribution on inflict arm is unethical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00269-00060344-00060438": "as well", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00270-00060439-00060654": "uh and then the last thing which i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00271-00060655-00060854": "actually do want to call out", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00272-00060855-00061094": "one of the things that we are we think", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00273-00061095-00061294": "is will be used when we think about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00274-00061295-00061575": "defects is what we call liar's dividend", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00275-00061576-00061950": "where a rightful a truth actually can be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00276-00061951-00062206": "very well discounted that it is a fake", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00277-00062207-00062542": "right so a a leader or or a person", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00278-00062544-00062791": "may do a bad act and then say no this is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00279-00062791-00062887": "actually because", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00280-00062888-00063054": "the technology is there they may say no", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00281-00063055-00063191": "this was mighty defect", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00282-00063191-00063375": "right so that's another ethical you have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00283-00063376-00063550": "to start thinking about the ethical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00284-00063551-00063750": "considerations there since i only had", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00285-00063751-00063863": "five minutes i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00286-00063864-00064103": "would actually close out here and open", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00287-00064104-00064294": "for questions uh as we go into this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00288-00064295-00064559": "panel", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00289-00064560-00064766": "very much uh actually so i think this is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00290-00064767-00064894": "a fantastic", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00291-00064895-00065199": "um start for our conversation", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00292-00065200-00065511": "um i think that i'm gonna go on on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00293-00065512-00065663": "technology because i think that the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00294-00065664-00065759": "audience is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00295-00065760-00065991": "is mostly formed of entrepreneurs and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00296-00065992-00066094": "people that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00297-00066095-00066406": "work within the technology space", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00298-00066407-00066567": "what do you think is really the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00299-00066568-00066806": "responsibility of um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00300-00066807-00067063": "not only the the founders but in general", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00301-00067064-00067282": "those that are building technologies and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00302-00067283-00067431": "integrations um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00303-00067432-00067735": "and um are at the sort of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00304-00067736-00067967": "forefront of capturing the data and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00305-00067968-00068063": "providing the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00306-00068064-00068359": "the best mediums for such content to be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00307-00068360-00068535": "distributed", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00308-00068536-00068750": "so you know i think we have to start", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00309-00068751-00068887": "thinking about what what we call", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00310-00068888-00068999": "responsible ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00311-00069000-00069182": "in microsoft so we have this office of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00312-00069183-00069303": "responsible ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00313-00069304-00069615": "stood up i think five years back", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00314-00069616-00069894": "uh and and we have six principles and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00315-00069895-00069959": "again", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00316-00069960-00070167": "i just want to share what we do so that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00317-00070168-00070335": "it can at least become some kind of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00318-00070336-00070438": "framework or", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00319-00070439-00070687": "thought process as the founders and the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00320-00070688-00070887": "new startups actually come around and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00321-00070888-00071038": "start thinking about data", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00322-00071039-00071279": "privacy issues ethics around data", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00323-00071280-00071487": "collection data usage", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00324-00071488-00071711": "data analysis and and and creating", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00325-00071712-00071847": "applications", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00326-00071848-00072150": "uh so we have six principles and and i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00327-00072151-00072326": "don't want to forget i do remember them", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00328-00072327-00072471": "but i don't want to forget so i want to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00329-00072472-00072567": "actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00330-00072568-00072838": "make sure that i read them as well so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00331-00072839-00073047": "perfectly fine fairness", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00332-00073048-00073326": "right and again fairness is important", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00333-00073327-00073438": "accountability", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00334-00073439-00073775": "transparency inclusiveness reliability", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00335-00073776-00074047": "and safety and privacy and security", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00336-00074048-00074231": "those are our six principles", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00337-00074232-00074406": "and we can go one at a time right so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00338-00074407-00074591": "fairness is all about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00339-00074592-00074894": "making sure that we are not withholding", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00340-00074895-00075115": "or allocating opportunities", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00341-00075116-00075247": "disproportionately", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00342-00075248-00075487": "right so how do we do that we want to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00343-00075488-00075687": "make sure that all our six principles", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00344-00075688-00075894": "actually what we have created is arms", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00345-00075895-00075991": "framework", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00346-00075992-00076303": "which is potential risks around the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00347-00076304-00076431": "technology", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00348-00076432-00076655": "and all microsoft products as they go", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00349-00076656-00076815": "through their life cycle of software", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00350-00076816-00077015": "development life cycle which with", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00351-00077016-00077303": "most of the technical folks would know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00352-00077304-00077494": "how it happens right from", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00353-00077495-00077799": "iteration from design to deployment uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00354-00077800-00078023": "we want to make sure that responsible ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00355-00078024-00078223": "is the first class citizen it is not a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00356-00078224-00078359": "bolt-on it is not", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00357-00078360-00078623": "an afterthought so we have this harms", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00358-00078624-00078806": "framework and a checklist", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00359-00078807-00079038": "and we want to encourage every product", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00360-00079039-00079247": "manager to start thinking about not only", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00361-00079248-00079423": "the current harm the potential", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00362-00079424-00079655": "under the technology and this committee", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00363-00079656-00079919": "that we have a responsible ai committee", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00364-00079920-00080191": "has a seat at the table from the design", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00365-00080192-00080359": "phase of the technology i think we have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00366-00080360-00080543": "to do that as a technologist", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00367-00080544-00080838": "i'm a technology so i build products i i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00368-00080839-00081031": "was part of startups back in my career", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00369-00081032-00081150": "as well", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00370-00081151-00081406": "we have to make sure that that we are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00371-00081407-00081599": "responsibly treating", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00372-00081600-00081831": "the technology because of the harms that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00373-00081832-00081959": "it can create especially", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00374-00081960-00082359": "when we talk about data and ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00375-00082360-00082623": "that that that is fantastic um we have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00376-00082624-00082879": "um a couple of questions coming through", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00377-00082880-00083199": "so i um in the interest of allocating", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00378-00083200-00083431": "uh time for every speaker i know ashish", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00379-00083432-00083550": "we're gonna come to this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00380-00083551-00083855": "um in in the q a section so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00381-00083856-00084111": "thank you so much for such an amazing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00382-00084112-00084199": "presentation and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00383-00084200-00084511": "for your very complete response we're", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00384-00084512-00084567": "gonna move", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00385-00084568-00084831": "next and we're gonna have uh juris from", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00386-00084832-00084967": "volksbank", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00387-00084968-00085231": "joris if you're able to share your", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00388-00085232-00085455": "screen", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00389-00085456-00085743": "yes i'm gonna share it welcome um i'm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00390-00085744-00085991": "very keen to hear your presentation", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00391-00085992-00086406": "um five minutes we'll start now", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00392-00086407-00086735": "perfect thank you very much um i hope", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00393-00086736-00087038": "the slides are visible for everyone", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00394-00087039-00087294": "yep okay good yeah i think actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00395-00087295-00087375": "that's a nice", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00396-00087376-00087543": "bridge from the microsoft principles to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00397-00087544-00087775": "the research i'm doing because i'm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00398-00087776-00087847": "interested in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00399-00087848-00088135": "operationalizing responsible ai and i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00400-00088136-00088255": "thought it would be nice to start off", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00401-00088256-00088382": "with what i'm actually doing at", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00402-00088383-00088567": "volkswagen", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00403-00088568-00088806": "because i have a position at volkswagen", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00404-00088807-00088926": "as an ethics officer", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00405-00088927-00089087": "volkswagen is a dutch bank it has about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00406-00089088-00089359": "three and a half million customers", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00407-00089360-00089662": "and we recently created this position of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00408-00089663-00089831": "ethics officer", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00409-00089832-00090135": "to discuss the ethics of algorithms", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00410-00090136-00090303": "within the bank", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00411-00090304-00090455": "i worked there for one and a half year", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00412-00090456-00090662": "now and together with my position at the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00413-00090663-00090759": "volkswagen i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00414-00090760-00091031": "started a phd on ai and ethics and it's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00415-00091032-00091238": "basically a project where the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00416-00091239-00091559": "two should reinforce each other um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00417-00091560-00091782": "so we have this practical aspect of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00418-00091783-00091982": "operationalizing ethical principles in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00419-00091983-00092094": "the context of the bank", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00420-00092095-00092255": "and i have this academic work that i'm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00421-00092256-00092471": "doing um on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00422-00092472-00092799": "researching how these ethical principles", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00423-00092800-00093118": "should be operationalized", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00424-00093119-00093279": "so basically that's the the two", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00425-00093280-00093423": "positions i hold", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00426-00093424-00093759": "and it's not like a 50 50 a division", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00427-00093760-00093935": "between them sometimes i'm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00428-00093936-00094079": "going off for the academic work", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00429-00094080-00094238": "sometimes i'm working more", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00430-00094239-00094462": "at the bank so it depends but the main", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00431-00094463-00094591": "aim of the project is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00432-00094592-00094838": "how can we actually operationalize these", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00433-00094839-00095006": "high level and abstract ethical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00434-00095007-00095111": "principles", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00435-00095112-00095318": "in a real and specific artificial", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00436-00095319-00095415": "intelligence", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00437-00095416-00095799": "context and my my main question there", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00438-00095800-00096038": "is how can we actually have or get to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00439-00096039-00096103": "have these", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00440-00096104-00096391": "ethical aspects to have practical impact", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00441-00096392-00096623": "on an organizational level", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00442-00096624-00096806": "because what i found actually when i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00443-00096807-00096991": "started at the position one and a half", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00444-00096992-00097071": "year ago", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00445-00097072-00097382": "is that um we have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00446-00097383-00097718": "um a lot of ethical principles um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00447-00097719-00098062": "i believe in 2019 the count was up to 84", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00448-00098063-00098455": "frameworks of ethical principles for ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00449-00098456-00098623": "so there are a lot of ethical principles", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00450-00098624-00098815": "most of them converging towards the same", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00451-00098816-00099023": "sort of principles but there are a lot", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00452-00099024-00099174": "of framework of proliferation of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00453-00099175-00099343": "framework you could say", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00454-00099344-00099518": "and on the other hand we have these", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00455-00099519-00099703": "value sensitive design methods for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00456-00099704-00099926": "actually implementing them on a design", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00457-00099927-00100271": "level but what lacking in my opinion or", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00458-00100272-00100462": "underdeveloped was the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00459-00100463-00100671": "gray area between the two between the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00460-00100672-00100823": "abstract principles and the very", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00461-00100824-00101055": "specific design methods", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00462-00101056-00101438": "which is the organizational dimension", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00463-00101439-00101694": "ultimately ethics needs to have a place", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00464-00101695-00101823": "needs to be implemented on an", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00465-00101824-00102015": "organizational level in organizational", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00466-00102016-00102111": "processes", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00467-00102112-00102374": "before it can actually have an impact on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00468-00102375-00102558": "this organizational level", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00469-00102559-00102863": "and i learned this when i started at the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00470-00102864-00102958": "bank", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00471-00102959-00103175": "and i came in and we had a discussion on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00472-00103176-00103286": "fairness", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00473-00103288-00103566": "and most of the data scientists will", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00474-00103567-00103766": "probably recognize this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00475-00103767-00103982": "to me coming from an economic psychology", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00476-00103983-00104151": "and philosophy background it was new but", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00477-00104152-00104327": "i said we should do something with", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00478-00104328-00104486": "fairness what are we doing with fairness", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00479-00104488-00104630": "and what i got back was", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00480-00104631-00104886": "well there are actually 21 mathematical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00481-00104888-00105023": "definitions of fairness", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00482-00105024-00105231": "which one do you want us to choose for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00483-00105232-00105390": "for example our credit risk scoring", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00484-00105391-00105471": "model", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00485-00105472-00105607": "and i thought well that's interesting i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00486-00105608-00105823": "mean that's a real ethical question", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00487-00105824-00106063": "uh we all agree that ethics is important", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00488-00106064-00106183": "we all agree", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00489-00106183-00106351": "that fairness is important the privacy", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00490-00106352-00106502": "is important but actually these", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00491-00106503-00106615": "trade-offs are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00492-00106616-00106743": "where it gets interesting these", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00493-00106744-00106878": "trade-offs between for example the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00494-00106879-00107007": "performance of a model", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00495-00107008-00107199": "and the explainability of a model the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00496-00107200-00107366": "trade-off between fairness constraints", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00497-00107367-00107566": "and the performance of a model", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00498-00107567-00107727": "and so i got interested in this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00499-00107728-00107902": "organizational dimension how can you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00500-00107903-00107958": "make", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00501-00107959-00108134": "the decision and how can you motivate a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00502-00108135-00108358": "decision for a certain type of model", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00503-00108359-00108463": "given these", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00504-00108464-00108758": "ethical impacts and so from an academic", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00505-00108759-00108886": "perspective i start", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00506-00108888-00109071": "started to study this from a critical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00507-00109072-00109263": "theory perspective", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00508-00109264-00109431": "and critical theory i will not tell you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00509-00109432-00109639": "the whole history but it's concerned", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00510-00109640-00109783": "with the relationship between the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00511-00109783-00109983": "structure of technology and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00512-00109983-00110302": "human beings and in critical theory the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00513-00110303-00110366": "author", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00514-00110367-00110623": "andrew feinberg has coined the term", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00515-00110624-00110727": "technical code", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00516-00110728-00111015": "and technical code basically describes", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00517-00111016-00111166": "background of assumptions values", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00518-00111167-00111247": "definitions", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00519-00111248-00111478": "and roles guiding design decisions and i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00520-00111479-00111599": "thought hey this is interesting and this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00521-00111600-00111790": "is something i could work with", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00522-00111791-00112007": "because we have to design methods we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00523-00112008-00112166": "have the principles but we are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00524-00112167-00112375": "insufficiently looking at design", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00525-00112376-00112527": "contexts", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00526-00112528-00112766": "and if we get a grip on the interest at", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00527-00112767-00112943": "play in these contexts we can get a grip", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00528-00112944-00113102": "on how these trade-offs are made and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00529-00113103-00113254": "whether they are made in a way", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00530-00113255-00113615": "we think is ethically correct", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00531-00113616-00113863": "um so taking this to a practical level i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00532-00113864-00114054": "started at the bank this this ethics", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00533-00114055-00114166": "office and we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00534-00114167-00114415": "launched a mandatory uh ethical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00535-00114416-00114543": "governance framework", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00536-00114544-00114734": "for each algorithm being developed in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00537-00114735-00115007": "the bank whether that's ai or not where", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00538-00115008-00115254": "we actually provide guidance phase of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00539-00115255-00115454": "model development", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00540-00115455-00115766": "up to the deployment of a model and we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00541-00115767-00115854": "basically", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00542-00115855-00116110": "provide ethical advice ethical guidance", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00543-00116111-00116254": "to the developers", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00544-00116255-00116558": "and try to get a feel for the ethical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00545-00116559-00116727": "implications and the ethical impact a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00546-00116728-00116910": "certain algorithm will have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00547-00116911-00117143": "and we try to give them advice and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00548-00117144-00117319": "guidance on how they should mitigate the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00549-00117320-00117495": "possible ethical risks", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00550-00117496-00117790": "present in their algorithms so that's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00551-00117791-00117871": "basically", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00552-00117872-00118054": "uh where i stand today so i'm i'm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00553-00118055-00118231": "exploring this organizational dimension", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00554-00118232-00118302": "i would love to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00555-00118303-00118607": "hear your input on that and i would love", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00556-00118608-00118783": "to hear how you would operationalize", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00557-00118783-00118943": "these ethical principles", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00558-00118944-00119271": "um so uh yeah i would say uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00559-00119272-00119415": "i think i'm still within the five", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00560-00119416-00119615": "minutes that was given to me so uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00561-00119616-00119847": "let's talk and let's have a discussion i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00562-00119848-00119927": "i think george", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00563-00119928-00120190": "this this has been an amazing um amazing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00564-00120191-00120383": "presentation you've touched on so many", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00565-00120383-00120454": "valuable", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00566-00120455-00120775": "um points and i'm gonna you know i'm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00567-00120776-00120895": "gonna ask a question that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00568-00120896-00121214": "one of our um speakers has", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00569-00121215-00121543": "has mentioned um and then nikita", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00570-00121544-00121799": "if you wanna say something then please", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00571-00121800-00121878": "do", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00572-00121879-00122199": "um the the role of transparency in a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00573-00122200-00122278": "competitive", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00574-00122279-00122551": "environment obviously work for wolfsbank", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00575-00122552-00122631": "it's it's a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00576-00122632-00122910": "highly competitive you know ecosystem", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00577-00122911-00122951": "for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00578-00122952-00123231": "financial institutions um what do you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00579-00123232-00123271": "think", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00580-00123272-00123654": "the role should be of access to data", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00581-00123655-00123990": "and sharing the heart of ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00582-00123991-00124310": "in in that sort of scenario can we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00583-00124311-00124614": "have transparency and fairness if", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00584-00124615-00124847": "we hold on to our proprietary", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00585-00124848-00124990": "technologies or", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00586-00124991-00125127": "what do you think is is the right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00587-00125128-00125414": "approach yeah that's a fair point", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00588-00125415-00125639": "and i mean i think it also depends on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00589-00125640-00125799": "who you want to be transparent to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00590-00125800-00126014": "because we have these external oversight", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00591-00126015-00126119": "agencies", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00592-00126120-00126358": "and i think they should be able to judge", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00593-00126359-00126543": "the algorithms that we use in the models", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00594-00126544-00126583": "we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00595-00126583-00126783": "we develop do you also want to be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00596-00126783-00126927": "transparent towards your customers i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00597-00126928-00127119": "would say but that's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00598-00127120-00127447": "my personal you do maybe more than money", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00599-00127448-00127575": "banks are about trust", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00600-00127576-00127823": "and trust is elemental to the financial", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00601-00127824-00128014": "services into financial industries", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00602-00128015-00128319": "as it is elemental to democracy and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00603-00128320-00128551": "democratic organizations so i think", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00604-00128552-00128678": "transparency is a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00605-00128679-00128847": "key point there if it's not in your", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00606-00128848-00128999": "short term uh for your short-term", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00607-00129000-00129151": "profits than it is for your long-term", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00608-00129152-00129271": "existence because", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00609-00129272-00129454": "if you do not get the trust and the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00610-00129455-00129583": "trustworthiness", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00611-00129583-00129814": "of your applications from customers or", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00612-00129815-00129975": "from society or from a societal", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00613-00129976-00130086": "perspective", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00614-00130088-00130327": "um i think you will lose out in the long", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00615-00130328-00130566": "term", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00616-00130567-00130839": "that's a very very good point nikita you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00617-00130840-00130878": "you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00618-00130879-00131119": "you wanted to say something yeah i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00619-00131120-00131231": "wanted to ask", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00620-00131232-00131551": "a brief question to juris uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00621-00131552-00131823": "in light of transparency again given", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00622-00131824-00131854": "we're", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00623-00131855-00132031": "we're building this open transparency", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00624-00132032-00132263": "framework", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00625-00132264-00132551": "the question is you said that you have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00626-00132552-00132623": "this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00627-00132624-00132887": "internal supervisory board and you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00628-00132888-00132975": "oversee all", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00629-00132976-00133343": "algorithms and models that you build", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00630-00133344-00133702": "uh in the bank uh the question is how do", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00631-00133703-00133854": "you make sure that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00632-00133855-00134231": "the ethics that you have in your bank", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00633-00134232-00134639": "coincide or is collinear uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00634-00134640-00134959": "and the same as of your customers so how", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00635-00134960-00135095": "do you make sure that this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00636-00135096-00135631": "two uh sets of values align", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00637-00135632-00135751": "yeah that's so that's a very good", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00638-00135752-00136007": "question um and the honest answer", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00639-00136008-00136231": "is we still have to find that out we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00640-00136232-00136495": "started", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00641-00136496-00136654": "well we now have a mandatory structure", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00642-00136655-00136854": "for developers and we do want to have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00643-00136855-00137087": "some form of an external panel so to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00644-00137088-00137159": "speak or", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00645-00137160-00137407": "external representation which can", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00646-00137408-00137663": "actually help us", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00647-00137664-00137895": "get a feel for the values that are in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00648-00137896-00138031": "society and how", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00649-00138032-00138231": "people in society for example consumers", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00650-00138232-00138471": "would evaluate our decisions", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00651-00138472-00138663": "but i think the first step for us and i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00652-00138664-00138799": "think for every organization", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00653-00138800-00139031": "out there is actually get a grip on the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00654-00139032-00139278": "ethical aspects of algorithm development", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00655-00139279-00139566": "signaling and letting algorithm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00656-00139567-00139711": "developers signal", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00657-00139712-00139878": "when their algorithms and how their", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00658-00139879-00140078": "algorithms will have an ethical or moral", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00659-00140079-00140166": "impact", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00660-00140167-00140454": "and then taking the responsibility of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00661-00140455-00140614": "documenting that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00662-00140615-00140847": "is a first step actually in starting to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00663-00140848-00141031": "evaluate those decisions and starting to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00664-00141032-00141231": "evaluate", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00665-00141232-00141527": "the the ethical aspects of an algorithm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00666-00141528-00141566": "so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00667-00141567-00141783": "we started i hate the word we started in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00668-00141784-00141935": "an agile way", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00669-00141936-00142263": "in just getting to get started and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00670-00142264-00142639": "learning about how how the ethics could", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00671-00142640-00142743": "be implemented", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00672-00142744-00142975": "in not just a specific use case or a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00673-00142976-00143126": "discussion you have on a specific use", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00674-00143127-00143311": "case but i'm really on an organizational", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00675-00143312-00143431": "process level", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00676-00143432-00143631": "and we need to expand and we need to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00677-00143632-00143807": "extend this approach and i agree with", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00678-00143808-00143878": "you that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00679-00143879-00144087": "we have to check with other stakeholders", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00680-00144088-00144223": "whether we're on the right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00681-00144224-00144447": "track but i think and maybe i should", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00682-00144448-00144583": "should mention this as well", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00683-00144584-00144766": "the forks bank is a state-owned bank in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00684-00144767-00144911": "the netherlands um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00685-00144912-00145271": "so it has sort of the duty to be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00686-00145272-00145407": "literally translated it means the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00687-00145408-00145575": "people's bank it has a duty to be in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00688-00145576-00145831": "touch with", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00689-00145832-00146039": "absent values but i think the first step", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00690-00146040-00146214": "um of this ethical process is to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00691-00146215-00146287": "actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00692-00146288-00146487": "get a grip and start documenting the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00693-00146488-00146614": "decision to make", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00694-00146615-00146902": "uh on specific algorithms and models and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00695-00146903-00147047": "motivating these decisions", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00696-00147048-00147351": "so whether uh how however it turns out", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00697-00147352-00147502": "you can always say look we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00698-00147503-00147766": "uh aspects we looked at transparency we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00699-00147767-00147959": "looked at how explainable the model is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00700-00147960-00148111": "we looked at the impact it could have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00701-00148112-00148254": "and based on all that information we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00702-00148255-00148359": "decided this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00703-00148360-00148535": "and maybe it's the wrong choice and then", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00704-00148536-00148766": "we should take responsibility for that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00705-00148767-00148951": "but at least we have a starting point to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00706-00148952-00149207": "build uh what we call morris prudence", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00707-00149208-00149399": "uh so you have jurisprudence which is of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00708-00149400-00149623": "course of all legal decisions being made", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00709-00149624-00149759": "and morris prudence is all the moral", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00710-00149760-00149863": "decisions we made", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00711-00149864-00150071": "when it comes to our algorithms so we're", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00712-00150072-00150383": "building that uh now", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00713-00150384-00150559": "thank you very much juris this is this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00714-00150560-00150751": "is an amazing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00715-00150752-00151135": "um you know presentation and an answer", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00716-00151136-00151335": "i know that we're going to have more to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00717-00151336-00151463": "to touch on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00718-00151464-00151735": "um in the half an hour saved for uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00719-00151736-00151895": "questions and the questions are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00720-00151896-00152271": "kind of gathering um please do use the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00721-00152272-00152366": "facility to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00722-00152367-00152687": "to ask away i'm gonna ask ilana to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00723-00152688-00153031": "share your presentation and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00724-00153032-00153278": "potentially you know provide a an", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00725-00153279-00153414": "introduction to yourself", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00726-00153415-00153790": "and to the topic", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00727-00153791-00154126": "are you with us i am can you hear me", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00728-00154127-00154454": "yes i can hear you okay can you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00729-00154455-00154647": "share my s can you see my screen or have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00730-00154648-00154887": "you given me permission", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00731-00154888-00155126": "you should be able to share it there's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00732-00155127-00155743": "nobody here", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00733-00155744-00156159": "um i'm trying to share but i don't see", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00734-00156160-00156223": "the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00735-00156224-00156631": "button here uh it says", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00736-00156632-00156926": "right here yep yep there we go it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00737-00156927-00156999": "changed", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00738-00157000-00157271": "on the screen here okay click the button", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00739-00157272-00157366": "to share", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00740-00157367-00157583": "so while i'm doing this and just a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00741-00157584-00157687": "little bit about me", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00742-00157688-00158014": "um i am alana cody i am a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00743-00158015-00158247": "past president of arma international", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00744-00158248-00158390": "which is the uh leading", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00745-00158391-00158847": "organization um for uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00746-00158848-00159071": "records and information management uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00747-00159072-00159239": "within uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00748-00159240-00159454": "probably globally there's other groups", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00749-00159455-00159559": "too but i'm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00750-00159560-00159919": "former un and uh i've been doing this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00751-00159920-00160135": "goodness for 25 some odd years i'm also", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00752-00160136-00160239": "uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00753-00160240-00160535": "in my final year of completing my uh phd", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00754-00160536-00160671": "in cyber security", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00755-00160672-00161007": "uh so i've like i said i've been", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00756-00161008-00161231": "extensively working on this area for for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00757-00161232-00161343": "quite some time but", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00758-00161344-00161623": "a lot of the conversation that we have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00759-00161624-00161799": "right and how do we do this even if", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00760-00161800-00161959": "you're creating algorithms or doing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00761-00161960-00162095": "things it comes down", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00762-00162096-00162311": "to essentially you're creating records", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00763-00162312-00162478": "now i thought that i originally had 10", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00764-00162479-00162631": "minutes but i have five so we're going", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00765-00162632-00162743": "to skip through this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00766-00162744-00163023": "pretty quickly today but understanding", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00767-00163024-00163087": "you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00768-00163088-00163263": "what is a record right we don't always", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00769-00163264-00163390": "use the term record", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00770-00163391-00163590": "anymore right you'll hear data", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00771-00163591-00163735": "information", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00772-00163736-00164078": "content and so forth but technically uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00773-00164079-00164271": "you know i've just defined record as a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00774-00164272-00164519": "notation that a transaction has occurred", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00775-00164520-00164687": "and this is really important because", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00776-00164688-00164875": "sometimes you'll remember the term like", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00777-00164876-00165047": "non-records or", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00778-00165048-00165311": "official record but a judge in the age", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00779-00165312-00165495": "of you know e-discovery and forensics", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00780-00165496-00165671": "honestly isn't going to care whether or", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00781-00165672-00165847": "not you checked a box and declared a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00782-00165848-00165951": "rackbird", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00783-00165952-00166143": "so this is something that's just really", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00784-00166144-00166278": "important and typically", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00785-00166279-00166438": "records you know you may think of like", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00786-00166439-00166647": "boxes and off-site storage", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00787-00166648-00166951": "but you have electronic records as well", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00788-00166952-00167135": "and when you manage these together it's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00789-00167136-00167414": "known as hybrid records management", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00790-00167415-00167502": "typically", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00791-00167503-00167678": "i've been teaching the electronic", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00792-00167679-00167831": "records course at the university", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00793-00167832-00168071": "of dundee in scotland now for almost 10", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00794-00168072-00168166": "years", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00795-00168167-00168535": "so i i cover this on a regular basis", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00796-00168536-00168751": "frequently as well in addition to being", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00797-00168752-00168878": "a practitioner", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00798-00168879-00169175": "but metadata is also really key here and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00799-00169176-00169383": "as well as taxonomies so when you think", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00800-00169384-00169607": "of hybrid record-keeping systems", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00801-00169608-00169814": "you have this but like i said without", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00802-00169815-00169951": "the record keeping", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00803-00169952-00170078": "you wouldn't know if you've been", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00804-00170079-00170254": "compliant you know with the ethics in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00805-00170255-00170359": "some cases", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00806-00170360-00170551": "now some of you may have seen this right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00807-00170552-00170735": "i know that we have a lot of you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00808-00170736-00170847": "engineers uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00809-00170848-00171183": "on the call but in this case you can see", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00810-00171184-00171231": "right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00811-00171232-00171454": "and this goes on you you may also refer", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00812-00171455-00171663": "to some of this as like a data map", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00813-00171664-00171838": "right so if that's a more familiar term", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00814-00171839-00172007": "to you fine uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00815-00172008-00172263": "but we go into inventories and just", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00816-00172264-00172399": "keeping track of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00817-00172400-00172575": "of records as well and there are some", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00818-00172576-00172743": "best practices especially if you have a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00819-00172744-00172863": "lot of pii", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00820-00172864-00173078": "within your organization right you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00821-00173079-00173254": "should be doing this because the fines", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00822-00173255-00173383": "are really high", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00823-00173384-00173559": "but one of the things that i realized", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00824-00173560-00173838": "too especially in my research when i was", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00825-00173839-00174071": "doing privacy by design", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00826-00174072-00174319": "it was the fact that uh it's not the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00827-00174320-00174407": "fact that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00828-00174408-00174687": "right the engineers didn't want to do", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00829-00174688-00174823": "privacy by design", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00830-00174824-00175151": "it's a a lot of us we didn't train you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00831-00175152-00175366": "guys on how to do this or what you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00832-00175367-00175575": "the privacy requirements were", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00833-00175576-00175823": "or the laws right so when we said oh do", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00834-00175824-00175966": "pbd", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00835-00175967-00176126": "you know the light bulb finally went off", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00836-00176127-00176302": "right in doing my research was that hey", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00837-00176303-00176487": "we never told you what this was and the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00838-00176488-00176663": "same concept applies to even like", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00839-00176664-00176871": "records management basics", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00840-00176872-00177063": "right so so if you're there and you're", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00841-00177064-00177190": "like well i don't understand what", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00842-00177191-00177366": "retention there is or how to apply it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00843-00177367-00177519": "that's not your fault because", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00844-00177520-00177663": "you probably haven't gone through the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00845-00177664-00177895": "training but typically there's over you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00846-00177896-00178063": "know fifty thousand retention laws in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00847-00178064-00178207": "the us alone and several hundred", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00848-00178208-00178263": "thousand", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00849-00178264-00178590": "regularly in globally so and they change", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00850-00178591-00178711": "on a daily basis", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00851-00178712-00178823": "and that's one of the things and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00852-00178824-00178966": "components as well but that's why it's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00853-00178967-00179111": "up to records managers and other", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00854-00179112-00179335": "professionals in the organization", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00855-00179336-00179575": "to make sure that they stay up to date", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00856-00179576-00179783": "on it and that you can apply it but over", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00857-00179784-00179951": "retention as i mentioned has", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00858-00179952-00180151": "you know very serious consequences", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00859-00180152-00180399": "because the litigation and the fines", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00860-00180400-00180583": "they can be you know in the millions of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00861-00180584-00180799": "dollars as well as reputational", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00862-00180800-00181031": "damage but one of the things that i also", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00863-00181032-00181102": "say too", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00864-00181103-00181254": "is you need to be the master of your", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00865-00181255-00181423": "data universe right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00866-00181424-00181566": "and with that you have to start", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00867-00181567-00181775": "shrinking your universe to only", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00868-00181776-00182007": "maintain and manage what's relevant so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00869-00182008-00182175": "if you have all of these extensive", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00870-00182176-00182247": "security", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00871-00182248-00182599": "protocols and parameters in place great", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00872-00182600-00182807": "but why are you maintaining data that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00873-00182808-00182990": "you didn't need to in the first place", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00874-00182991-00183175": "because that would make it more secure", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00875-00183176-00183343": "and let alone with pii", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00876-00183344-00183502": "if you're over retaining data you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00877-00183503-00183678": "shouldn't you could also be fined for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00878-00183679-00183799": "that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00879-00183800-00184031": "so here's just you know a screenshot of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00880-00184032-00184223": "just how much data there is there's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00881-00184224-00184295": "almost", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00882-00184296-00184543": "three like zettabytes of data in in the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00883-00184544-00184726": "world right this grows on a regular", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00884-00184727-00184847": "basis", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00885-00184848-00185031": "you can see here with the fines of about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00886-00185032-00185207": "10 million some odd euros", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00887-00185208-00185399": "uh the data breach this is from the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00888-00185400-00185566": "ponymon institute here", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00889-00185567-00185823": "on average it's about 3.86 million right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00890-00185824-00185966": "so whenever there's something there", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00891-00185967-00186207": "the litigation can be very very", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00892-00186208-00186319": "expensive when you're", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00893-00186320-00186526": "almost it's definitely in millions of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00894-00186527-00186766": "dollars and then you go into healthcare", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00895-00186767-00187047": "with this as well and then hacking is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00896-00187048-00187126": "really important", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00897-00187127-00187390": "right so one of the things too that i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00898-00187391-00187447": "found", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00899-00187448-00187775": "was you had from the itfs the i.t", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00900-00187776-00187871": "frameworks", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00901-00187872-00188063": "in a lot of cases especially when you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00902-00188064-00188231": "look at likeness and some of the risk", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00903-00188232-00188302": "management", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00904-00188303-00188519": "you'll see a lot of them have identify", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00905-00188520-00188711": "which is what that inventory is about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00906-00188712-00188863": "for your records", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00907-00188864-00189071": "but in my opinion i don't think you can", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00908-00189072-00189271": "do either privacy or security well", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00909-00189272-00189463": "without knowing what data you have on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00910-00189464-00189519": "hand", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00911-00189520-00189726": "who has access to that content and where", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00912-00189727-00189919": "that data is stored", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00913-00189920-00190287": "so as you can see here nista didn't have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00914-00190288-00190447": "that and they went to classify right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00915-00190448-00190614": "because without identifying it's really", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00916-00190615-00190807": "hard to classify first classification", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00917-00190808-00190999": "can be a secondary step", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00918-00191000-00191214": "iapp which is the international", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00919-00191215-00191414": "association of privacy professionals", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00920-00191415-00191583": "they did this and they did more", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00921-00191584-00191790": "frameworks as well so i think it's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00922-00191791-00191935": "really important to try to integrate", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00923-00191936-00192078": "that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00924-00192079-00192399": "also start thinking of information as a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00925-00192400-00192502": "liability", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00926-00192503-00192711": "right especially and that's why we have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00927-00192712-00192838": "cyber insurance", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00928-00192839-00193054": "so information can also be an asset and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00929-00193055-00193335": "add value but at the same point in time", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00930-00193336-00193519": "you need to really start quantifying the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00931-00193520-00193726": "levels of risk in your organizations and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00932-00193727-00193887": "if any of you are going through mergers", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00933-00193888-00194047": "and acquisitions i always say don't", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00934-00194048-00194199": "acquire dirty data", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00935-00194200-00194399": "because then that goes into also you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00936-00194400-00194583": "know the ethics and compliance issues as", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00937-00194584-00194647": "well", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00938-00194648-00194847": "in some cases if you can avoid that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00939-00194848-00194999": "because you didn't do it in the first", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00940-00195000-00195054": "place", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00941-00195055-00195359": "definitely try to do that um the other", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00942-00195360-00195638": "point i know i'm about to go over here", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00943-00195639-00195702": "but uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00944-00195703-00195983": "if you it's about decision rights and a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00945-00195984-00196126": "lot of times in the past records", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00946-00196127-00196295": "managers weren't given those decision", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00947-00196296-00196423": "rights but i think it's because we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00948-00196424-00196550": "didn't explain to it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00949-00196551-00196775": "properly what we were trying to do it's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00950-00196776-00196959": "not like we tried to infringe", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00951-00196960-00197111": "we just didn't explain hey there's a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00952-00197112-00197295": "bunch of these laws and regulations that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00953-00197296-00197463": "you have to really adhere to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00954-00197464-00197671": "but if you start automating a lot of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00955-00197672-00197814": "these processes", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00956-00197815-00198047": "you can really enforce and automate", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00957-00198048-00198159": "decision rights", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00958-00198160-00198478": "as well too so we we always say you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00959-00198479-00198678": "there's really no artificial nai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00960-00198679-00198847": "right you still need manual intervention", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00961-00198848-00199031": "and system training in addition to the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00962-00199032-00199199": "people training for now", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00963-00199200-00199383": "but that's okay you know you can get", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00964-00199384-00199623": "there it does take a little bit of time", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00965-00199624-00199790": "but also if you think of retention", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00966-00199791-00199959": "schedules as policies", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00967-00199960-00200199": "i think that will also help as well", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00968-00200200-00200447": "because policy management and then this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00969-00200448-00200614": "is just a listing of uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00970-00200615-00200775": "you know who may have roles in the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00971-00200776-00201078": "organization as well", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00972-00201079-00201238": "and just some insights as i said you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00973-00201239-00201495": "know if you have the information here", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00974-00201496-00201711": "and it's digital it's a lot easier to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00975-00201712-00201823": "manage in some cases", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00976-00201824-00201966": "on the other hand if you're in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00977-00201967-00202190": "litigation it's a lot easier to find", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00978-00202191-00202566": "right so that's one of the things um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00979-00202567-00202799": "remember right tactical versus strategic", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00980-00202800-00203007": "too right before all these data breaches", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00981-00203008-00203102": "and everything", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00982-00203103-00203263": "you could have thought the auditors and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00983-00203264-00203407": "the cyber security people were", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00984-00203408-00203526": "interfering but now", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00985-00203527-00203687": "try to work with them a little bit more", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00986-00203688-00203854": "too because we're really here to protect", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00987-00203855-00204047": "the organization", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00988-00204048-00204263": "and then just you know some next steps", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00989-00204264-00204535": "on screen here that you can see", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00990-00204536-00204735": "but otherwise think of multiple tiers of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00991-00204736-00204951": "potentially implementing retention", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00992-00204952-00205223": "purge records but keep logs right build", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00993-00205223-00205471": "purge mechanisms into your software code", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00994-00205471-00205727": "during the sdlc or at least as early as", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00995-00205728-00205879": "possible in the beginning", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00996-00205880-00206110": "use metadata automate as much as you can", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00997-00206111-00206271": "and train staff", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00998-00206271-00206438": "and then one of the things too that i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-00999-00206439-00206582": "always say is you know sometimes", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01000-00206583-00206806": "these systems can be expensive but just", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01001-00206807-00207014": "get started you know even if it's manual", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01002-00207015-00207142": "on a shared drive or if you're just", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01003-00207144-00207294": "developing policies", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01004-00207296-00207631": "just go ahead and start doing it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01005-00207632-00207871": "okay thank you thank you very much uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01006-00207871-00207942": "ilana", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01007-00207944-00208262": "i i think one of the you know going from", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01008-00208263-00208486": "your retention laws and of course the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01009-00208487-00208719": "liability of having dirty data", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01010-00208719-00209062": "or exposing yourself to data hacking and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01011-00209063-00209110": "and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01012-00209111-00209431": "therefore um having a system that is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01013-00209432-00209655": "regulated through the courts", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01014-00209656-00209887": "i i guess what i'm interesting given", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01015-00209888-00209958": "your", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01016-00209959-00210206": "um you know so many years working with", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01017-00210207-00210303": "governments and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01018-00210304-00210591": "international institutions how are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01019-00210592-00210694": "government", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01020-00210696-00210927": "how is government regulation looking at", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01021-00210928-00211031": "and regulate", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01022-00211032-00211287": "and implementing new rules for ethical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01023-00211288-00211479": "aspects of ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01024-00211480-00211751": "and what are you seeing um because", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01025-00211752-00211871": "clearly this is about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01026-00211871-00212142": "record maintenance it's about you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01027-00212144-00212358": "private litigation in vast majority of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01028-00212359-00212439": "cases", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01029-00212440-00212775": "but what is the government um in doing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01030-00212776-00213094": "in this respect do we have any sort of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01031-00213096-00213439": "framework that this can be built on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01032-00213440-00213703": "so i think that california is leading", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01033-00213704-00213903": "this here with the ccpa which is the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01034-00213904-00214055": "california consumer", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01035-00214056-00214415": "privacy act which is putting mechanisms", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01036-00214416-00214646": "into place to really enhance you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01037-00214648-00214727": "what data", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01038-00214728-00214887": "especially is collected about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01039-00214888-00215063": "individuals now", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01040-00215064-00215294": "other states are following this where", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01041-00215296-00215479": "for example with like biometrics", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01042-00215480-00215615": "collection i know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01043-00215616-00215951": "new york has several", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01044-00215952-00216119": "rules that they're trying to put into", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01045-00216119-00216334": "place but ccpa", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01046-00216335-00216671": "will be enacted here shortly i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01047-00216671-00216855": "with the government now some of those", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01048-00216856-00217023": "are being adopted as well", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01049-00217023-00217223": "but you know unfortunately with the us", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01050-00217223-00217334": "we're not quite", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01051-00217335-00217687": "as uh as the eu or canada", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01052-00217688-00217927": "new zealand australia and many other", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01053-00217928-00218023": "countries right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01054-00218023-00218334": "they um they just don't think of it in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01055-00218335-00218406": "the past", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01056-00218407-00218679": "uh personal data has been collected like", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01057-00218680-00218855": "in florida for example", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01058-00218856-00219063": "and sold you know from driver's license", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01059-00219064-00219167": "information", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01060-00219167-00219375": "and that was about 75 million dollars", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01061-00219376-00219503": "several years ago", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01062-00219504-00219751": "so they see pii as being you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01063-00219752-00219910": "revenue generating", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01064-00219911-00220127": "so i think that you know the government", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01065-00220128-00220319": "does have to do more enactments but", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01066-00220319-00220655": "i think it's at the state level as well", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01067-00220656-00220806": "and you know again it's one thing to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01068-00220807-00220998": "write a policy but it's another to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01069-00221000-00221079": "enforce it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01070-00221080-00221263": "and that's why if there's something with", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01071-00221264-00221398": "automation or tracking", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01072-00221400-00221646": "or you know a system that can check if", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01073-00221648-00221727": "if uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01074-00221728-00221982": "code is up to par with what privacy", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01075-00221983-00222110": "requirements there are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01076-00222111-00222294": "but personally i think the us has a long", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01077-00222296-00222487": "way to go", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01078-00222488-00222710": "that's that's um an important point now", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01079-00222711-00222879": "i agree with you that ccps is an", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01080-00222880-00222998": "important piece of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01081-00223000-00223319": "legislation coming um and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01082-00223319-00223471": "thank you so much for for your", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01083-00223471-00223710": "presentation there are so many questions", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01084-00223711-00223742": "that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01085-00223744-00224134": "um some of the attendees are already", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01086-00224135-00224471": "um you know he's is trust me", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01087-00224471-00224687": "it's a very important list i'm mindful", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01088-00224688-00224791": "of time", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01089-00224792-00225055": "and i think that naturally where um the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01090-00225056-00225167": "next speaker", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01091-00225167-00225494": "uh long thumb from all four eu", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01092-00225496-00225719": "um is going to continue exactly on this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01093-00225719-00225846": "line looking", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01094-00225848-00226175": "at how governments are intervening here", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01095-00226176-00226223": "in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01096-00226223-00226567": "in europe so long are you still with us", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01097-00226567-00226998": "i am here hi um can i please ask you to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01098-00227000-00227342": "share your screen", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01099-00227344-00227855": "okay um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01100-00227856-00228255": "ilana if you could um potentially", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01101-00228256-00229063": "stop sharing yeah that's perfect", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01102-00229064-00229375": "long have you been able to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01103-00229376-00229703": "to share you know it's on the right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01104-00229704-00229910": "so you're there is a button with the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01105-00229911-00230006": "cross on the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01106-00230007-00230279": "on the screen close to the leave button", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01107-00230280-00230351": "for sure", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01108-00230352-00230655": "okay got it yeah perfect thank you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01109-00230656-00231342": "okay now i can share fabulous", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01110-00231344-00231663": "can you see my screen", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01111-00231664-00231991": "not yet okay all right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01112-00231992-00232310": "so well right you're trying to share", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01113-00232311-00232446": "your presentation", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01114-00232448-00232751": "i will ask everyone still with us please", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01115-00232752-00232887": "do add your questions", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01116-00232888-00233087": "i'm seeing everything that comes comes", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01117-00233088-00233223": "through and i'll um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01118-00233223-00233471": "find the right way to engage with a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01119-00233471-00233542": "panel", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01120-00233544-00233910": "in the half an hour we have allocated", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01121-00233911-00234191": "so please do uh write your questions", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01122-00234192-00234319": "there are some that are so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01123-00234319-00234646": "amazing um i can't wait", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01124-00234648-00234903": "to to have an opportunity to to put them", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01125-00234904-00235239": "forward", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01126-00235240-00236015": "are you able", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01127-00236016-00236367": "hello i'm back yep sorry", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01128-00236367-00237703": "can you share i think i can share", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01129-00237704-00238082": "can you see it now", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01130-00238083-00238839": "no okay just hang on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01131-00238840-00239103": "always having um technical challenge", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01132-00239104-00239167": "okay", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01133-00239167-00239494": "yeah can you see it now", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01134-00239496-00239823": "it's coming through yes yes i can see", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01135-00239823-00240142": "it okay it's okay sorry", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01136-00240144-00240542": "yeah over here sorry for uh the um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01137-00240544-00240934": "technical hiccup okay so um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01138-00240935-00241239": "uh i am with the ai for eu", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01139-00241240-00241558": "as you see on the screen uh so it is a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01140-00241559-00241879": "platform for ai on demand", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01141-00241880-00242175": "and uh it is supported by the european", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01142-00242176-00242287": "um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01143-00242288-00242591": "unit uh and we are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01144-00242592-00242927": "horizon 2020 projects uh worth", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01145-00242928-00243230": "uh 20 million uh it's a lot of money so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01146-00243231-00243271": "uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01147-00243271-00243591": "basically that we are trying to mobilize", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01148-00243592-00243623": "the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01149-00243623-00244046": "entire european ai community to make ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01150-00244048-00244382": "real in our society as well as in the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01151-00244383-00244487": "economy", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01152-00244488-00244719": "and we are trying to get that in a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01153-00244719-00244846": "collaborative", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01154-00244848-00245223": "ai european platform which is we already", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01155-00245223-00245271": "have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01156-00245271-00245598": "physical platforms that are available", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01157-00245600-00245903": "online and after this i encourage", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01158-00245904-00246158": "all of the participants to actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01159-00246159-00246271": "check us out", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01160-00246271-00246655": "and see if you want to be a member", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01161-00246656-00246871": "on that and we also have later on you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01162-00246871-00247127": "will see a lot of things to offer to you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01163-00247128-00247182": "but", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01164-00247183-00247551": "today's topic is actually on the um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01165-00247552-00247910": "the ethical part where as you see here", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01166-00247911-00248182": "is our project is focusing on five", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01167-00248183-00248319": "research area which is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01168-00248319-00248542": "just only one part of what we are trying", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01169-00248544-00248623": "to do", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01170-00248623-00248919": "and here you will see about the um the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01171-00248919-00249030": "very", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01172-00249031-00249358": "verifiable ai explainable ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01173-00249359-00249671": "and as well as the physical ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01174-00249671-00249958": "and uh all of those are actually um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01175-00249959-00250094": "surrounding the human", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01176-00250096-00250342": "centers uh ais that we are driving", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01177-00250344-00250430": "towards", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01178-00250431-00250663": "and those are actually being done", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01179-00250664-00250751": "through", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01180-00250752-00251046": "the six uh the eight pilots experiments", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01181-00251048-00251127": "that we have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01182-00251128-00251351": "in all of those areas that i'm not going", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01183-00251352-00251479": "to go into", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01184-00251480-00251767": "in details but as you know that we are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01185-00251767-00251975": "trying to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01186-00251976-00252246": "explore all of the ethical aspect in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01187-00252248-00252319": "those", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01188-00252319-00252671": "application areas that we are trying", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01189-00252671-00252967": "and bring it on to the platform as an", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01190-00252967-00253206": "example as well as the learning lessons", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01191-00253207-00253319": "that we can share", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01192-00253319-00253687": "with our community on that and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01193-00253688-00254030": "we have around 81 members and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01194-00254031-00254391": "we also have companies that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01195-00254392-00254727": "are joining us from large company to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01196-00254728-00255103": "sme and also we have um ancient", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01197-00255104-00255430": "social um organization just like the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01198-00255431-00255751": "um the organization uh open ethics that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01199-00255752-00256015": "you are driving toward and again we also", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01200-00256016-00256087": "have the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01201-00256088-00256342": "three million cascade funding available", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01202-00256344-00256415": "for those", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01203-00256416-00256767": "smes and startups and if any of you are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01204-00256767-00256815": "here", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01205-00256816-00257134": "interested we would highly recommend you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01206-00257135-00257327": "to come up and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01207-00257328-00257591": "check out the available resources for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01208-00257592-00257671": "you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01209-00257671-00258006": "and as you see here i just another", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01210-00258007-00258327": "way of looking into it what we are uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01211-00258328-00258606": "comprising of but we are not just only", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01212-00258607-00258671": "oh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01213-00258671-00258951": "those um communities that you are seeing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01214-00258952-00259127": "here we are more than that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01215-00259128-00259439": "and here is the snapshot of those um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01216-00259440-00259727": "work packages that we are having but as", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01217-00259728-00259846": "you see here", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01218-00259848-00260079": "on the left is the worker package five", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01219-00260080-00260151": "which is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01220-00260152-00260455": "what is actually i would like to focus", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01221-00260456-00260519": "more on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01222-00260519-00260830": "in this presentation so which is the uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01223-00260831-00261071": "promoting european ethical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01224-00261071-00261342": "legal cultural and social economic", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01225-00261344-00261479": "values", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01226-00261480-00261679": "and those are actually being done", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01227-00261680-00261815": "through the um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01228-00261816-00262087": "or package seven where we identifying", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01229-00262088-00262206": "the technological", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01230-00262207-00262519": "gaps where we also run through the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01231-00262520-00262815": "um technological transfer activity which", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01232-00262816-00262855": "is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01233-00262856-00263063": "actually the three million cascade", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01234-00263064-00263182": "funding for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01235-00263183-00263543": "sme to actually doing those applications", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01236-00263544-00263687": "and developing those", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01237-00263688-00264039": "applications and also from the ecosystem", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01238-00264040-00264303": "development as well as from the pilots", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01239-00264304-00264439": "that we are running", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01240-00264440-00264655": "so we are learning about those and we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01241-00264656-00264758": "are sharing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01242-00264759-00265023": "those learning in ethical and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01243-00265024-00265255": "trustworthy of ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01244-00265256-00265487": "using all the principles as you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01245-00265488-00265775": "from the the guidelines that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01246-00265776-00266175": "issued by the uh the european commission", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01247-00266176-00266503": "and by the way by in 2021 next year we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01248-00266504-00266558": "will see", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01249-00266559-00266815": "actually a legal framework going to come", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01250-00266816-00266895": "forward", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01251-00266896-00267151": "based on those so i think that we would", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01252-00267152-00267279": "have a lot to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01253-00267280-00267510": "ramp up to that and learning to share", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01254-00267511-00267655": "there and here is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01255-00267656-00267879": "just another way of looking into that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01256-00267880-00268110": "and you see that what we are trying to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01257-00268111-00268143": "get", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01258-00268144-00268406": "out of and all of these will be able to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01259-00268407-00268687": "share with you on our platform", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01260-00268688-00269071": "and we as a as you see here", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01261-00269072-00269327": "how we position ourselves is actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01262-00269328-00269510": "that we are a platform", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01263-00269511-00269823": "that we're trying to enable to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01264-00269824-00270199": "empower and to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01265-00270200-00270571": "help all of those different", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01266-00270572-00270879": "institutions as well as initiative", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01267-00270880-00271191": "in europe as well as projects and also", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01268-00271192-00271415": "different stakeholders that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01269-00271416-00271695": "already out there and concerning about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01270-00271696-00271830": "ai and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01271-00271831-00272239": "and um and every other aspect of ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01272-00272240-00272503": "we are not going to answers to or going", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01273-00272504-00272767": "into very deep level of every single", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01274-00272768-00272815": "part", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01275-00272816-00273071": "but what we are trying to do is that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01276-00273072-00273143": "it's like", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01277-00273144-00273487": "electric city um as you already know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01278-00273488-00273767": "they talk a lot about ai with the uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01279-00273768-00273919": "similar to the invention of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01280-00273920-00274263": "electricity so it it has a different", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01281-00274264-00274567": "aspect from the demand size to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01282-00274568-00274855": "due to the supply size and it has a lot", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01283-00274856-00275023": "of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01284-00275024-00275255": "issues that need to be addressed and one", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01285-00275256-00275439": "of those as we are talking", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01286-00275440-00275758": "about today is ethical and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01287-00275759-00275999": "those would be based on the trust with", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01288-00276000-00276127": "the ais that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01289-00276128-00276430": "we have um ability", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01290-00276431-00276782": "to to do that and help our um what we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01291-00276783-00276847": "call", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01292-00276848-00277182": "ecosystem to to do that as well so we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01293-00277183-00277287": "are having this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01294-00277288-00277695": "uh here as the ecosystem", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01295-00277696-00277958": "you can learn more about this and as you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01296-00277959-00278063": "see here", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01297-00278064-00278327": "your organization here and all of your", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01298-00278328-00278447": "community would fall", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01299-00278448-00278943": "into those eventually or", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01300-00278944-00279247": "and then we also wanted to to let you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01301-00279248-00279310": "know that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01302-00279311-00279639": "we have the resources available for you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01303-00279640-00279879": "uh in terms of the knowledge also in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01304-00279880-00279967": "terms of the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01305-00279968-00280351": "um resources that and also", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01306-00280352-00280582": "financial resources that available", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01307-00280583-00280782": "through our open course that we would", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01308-00280783-00280863": "soon", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01309-00280864-00281215": "launched and i would like all of you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01310-00281216-00281534": "to if you can take a snapshot of this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01311-00281535-00281751": "one and you can check it out it is the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01312-00281752-00282103": "um the ethic topics on our platform at", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01313-00282104-00282175": "the moment", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01314-00282176-00282439": "and we have the observatory right here", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01315-00282440-00282503": "and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01316-00282504-00282943": "just today we have the whole day um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01317-00282944-00283230": "workshops on the trustworthy ai made in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01318-00283231-00283295": "europe", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01319-00283296-00283599": "from principles to practices so we have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01320-00283600-00283710": "quite a bit of that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01321-00283711-00283967": "uh we will be able to share with you and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01322-00283968-00284223": "we also have the experiment part of the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01323-00284224-00284463": "platforms that you if you have any", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01324-00284464-00284734": "algorithm you want to test you want to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01325-00284735-00284934": "kind of doing some experiment we would", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01326-00284935-00285054": "welcome you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01327-00285055-00285239": "and we would welcome you to check them", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01328-00285240-00285471": "out and if you do have any question", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01329-00285472-00285703": "come back to me let me know how i can", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01330-00285704-00285943": "help you with and we also have the ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01331-00285944-00286191": "resources as you see here", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01332-00286192-00286487": "we have the local rule-based explanation", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01333-00286488-00286543": "which is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01334-00286544-00286791": "explainable ai would be something", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01335-00286792-00286934": "challenging at the moment", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01336-00286935-00287271": "but we starting to crack", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01337-00287272-00287599": "down on those so i'm not going to go", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01338-00287600-00287943": "any further i am working for university", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01339-00287944-00288063": "college core", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01340-00288064-00288287": "where we have the insight center for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01341-00288288-00288430": "data analysis", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01342-00288431-00288663": "and we actually have the assessment list", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01343-00288664-00288806": "for trustworthy", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01344-00288807-00289143": "ai uh that is actually we work with the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01345-00289144-00289199": "um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01346-00289200-00289519": "the ai alliance from the european", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01347-00289520-00289758": "commissions to do that and i highly", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01348-00289759-00289934": "recommend you to check it out", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01349-00289935-00290247": "and there's a seven major point", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01350-00290248-00290463": "rather than six from microsoft as you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01351-00290464-00290567": "see earlier", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01352-00290568-00290799": "so that you can actually see that how", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01353-00290800-00290910": "you could actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01354-00290911-00291247": "develop that and familiar yourself with", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01355-00291248-00291399": "that before it become", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01356-00291400-00291703": "a legal framework and you don't have to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01357-00291704-00292063": "kind of go into any um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01358-00292064-00292367": "litigation process later on hopefully", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01359-00292368-00292591": "but we are learning together and that's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01360-00292592-00292743": "what we are here", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01361-00292744-00293063": "for and that's it for me i'm sorry i run", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01362-00293064-00293310": "through a few minutes but i hope that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01363-00293311-00293454": "it's okay", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01364-00293455-00293710": "no worries well long i i think that that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01365-00293711-00293815": "was an uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01366-00293816-00294006": "you know quite an insightful", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01367-00294007-00294215": "presentation and i i have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01368-00294216-00294558": "um a question in two parts", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01369-00294559-00294823": "um there have been some ai related uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01370-00294824-00295063": "resolution packages introduced uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01371-00295064-00295439": "this year and you know one of the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01372-00295440-00295639": "the first question is do you think that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01373-00295640-00295839": "that is an adequate response for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01374-00295840-00296071": "our ecosystem where we are now and where", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01375-00296072-00296206": "are we heading", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01376-00296207-00296503": "um and the second the second part of the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01377-00296504-00296615": "question is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01378-00296616-00296958": "what are the steps that a company has to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01379-00296959-00297039": "take", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01380-00297040-00297287": "to ensure that they are building", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01381-00297288-00297487": "responsible ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01382-00297488-00297647": "and i know we're going to delve them", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01383-00297648-00297903": "into more um you know more on this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01384-00297904-00298167": "in the q a but i think that this this is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01385-00298168-00298271": "your", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01386-00298272-00298503": "um your specialty so it would be really", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01387-00298504-00298839": "great to understand what you're thinking", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01388-00298840-00299239": "i'm sure i uh for i need to clarify", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01389-00299240-00299447": "something here i am even though that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01390-00299448-00299830": "in policy policy analysis as", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01391-00299831-00300182": "what i studied before ai has been", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01392-00300183-00300558": "my home for the past 18 months", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01393-00300559-00300903": "or so since i joined the ai for eu", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01394-00300904-00301158": "projects as the community managers for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01395-00301159-00301287": "the project", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01396-00301288-00301654": "and what i see uh from uh last year", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01397-00301655-00301910": "when we was actually having the first", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01398-00301911-00301958": "car", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01399-00301959-00302206": "the second conference not the first", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01400-00302207-00302295": "conference to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01401-00302296-00302527": "this year is the second one on the the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01402-00302528-00302727": "ai alliance organized by", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01403-00302728-00302967": "by the european commission we already", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01404-00302968-00303030": "see", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01405-00303031-00303447": "quite a bit of recommendations and the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01406-00303448-00303839": "the kind of the active participation of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01407-00303840-00304191": "all different um stakeholders that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01408-00304192-00304647": "are actually in and the respond uh from", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01409-00304648-00304982": "european commission in terms of the um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01410-00304983-00305310": "in terms of the the uh paving the way", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01411-00305311-00305399": "towards the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01412-00305400-00305695": "legal framework is actually already have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01413-00305696-00305967": "the white papers that was actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01414-00305968-00306271": "issued earlier and get", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01415-00306272-00306534": "more than a thousand respawn from", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01416-00306535-00306663": "companies from", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01417-00306664-00307023": "organizations from ordinary people", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01418-00307024-00307351": "on whatever that they are concerning", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01419-00307352-00307719": "in ai so i think that gradually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01420-00307720-00307982": "we would see that and along that side", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01421-00307983-00308230": "you see from microsoft you see from", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01422-00308231-00308534": "any other industry they are also", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01423-00308535-00308791": "aligned together siemens which is one of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01424-00308792-00308903": "our", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01425-00308904-00309206": "stakeholders as well they are mobilizing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01426-00309207-00309534": "the the um the resources the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01427-00309535-00309839": "base to really addressing those trusts", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01428-00309840-00309967": "with the ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01429-00309968-00310223": "are we there i don't think we are there", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01430-00310224-00310358": "um because", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01431-00310359-00310671": "that's why the the um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01432-00310672-00310943": "last month the european commission", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01433-00310944-00310999": "actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01434-00311000-00311295": "launched a new uh way of pursuing with", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01435-00311296-00311351": "ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01436-00311352-00311599": "is actually that building ecosystem of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01437-00311600-00311671": "trust", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01438-00311672-00311999": "and ecosystem of knowledge the knowledge", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01439-00312000-00312223": "is actually based on the excellence", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01440-00312224-00312543": "in science in technologies", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01441-00312544-00312982": "in skills and also in in the basic of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01442-00312983-00313054": "the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01443-00313055-00313382": "ai is which is data if you don't have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01444-00313383-00313519": "the reliable data", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01445-00313520-00313767": "good quality data you are not going to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01446-00313768-00313879": "be able to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01447-00313880-00314182": "to have the the qualities um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01448-00314183-00314567": "ai all trustworthy ai so i think that we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01449-00314568-00314639": "are not there", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01450-00314640-00314847": "but we are working toward there and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01451-00314848-00314958": "there's quite a bit", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01452-00314959-00315343": "of initiative as well as um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01453-00315344-00315679": "a resourcefully um kind of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01454-00315680-00315958": "on the way and in the pipeline to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01455-00315959-00316319": "address that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01456-00316320-00316479": "thank you very much long i really", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01457-00316480-00316719": "appreciate your your detailed response", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01458-00316720-00317071": "um we're reaching the final", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01459-00317072-00317423": "speaker today charlie can i ask you to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01460-00317424-00317775": "share your screen", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01461-00317776-00318247": "sure let me uh yes", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01462-00318248-00318558": "hi charlie hi let me just try and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01463-00318559-00318927": "is that gone up yes yes it has", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01464-00318928-00319423": "fantastic well i'm gonna leave you to um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01465-00319424-00319758": "present your your part and uh then we'll", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01466-00319759-00320023": "swing straight into the q a how long", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01467-00320024-00320175": "have i got", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01468-00320176-00320447": "i'm i think five ten minutes it should", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01469-00320448-00320682": "be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01470-00320683-00320815": "perfect", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01471-00320816-00321039": "okay i'll try and keep it short so i i'm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01472-00321040-00321191": "good there's been quite a lot of talk", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01473-00321192-00321495": "uh on this session about uh transparency", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01474-00321496-00321639": "one way or another and that's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01475-00321640-00321934": "great to hear um i'm gonna talk a little", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01476-00321935-00322271": "bit more about transparency", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01477-00322272-00322495": "and i guess what i'm going to do here is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01478-00322496-00322671": "offer more of a kind of outside in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01479-00322672-00322863": "perspective joris particularly talked", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01480-00322864-00323127": "i think from an inside out perspective", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01481-00323128-00323287": "uh and it was really good to hear", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01482-00323288-00323510": "actually about how governance you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01483-00323511-00323679": "is actually operating within", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01484-00323680-00323854": "organizations and that's really really", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01485-00323855-00323967": "important", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01486-00323968-00324327": "however um uh you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01487-00324328-00324551": "so maybe a disclaimer first off you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01488-00324552-00324671": "i'm no ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01489-00324672-00324975": "expert um i'm not a coder or anything", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01490-00324976-00324999": "like", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01491-00325000-00325223": "that uh but uh my background is in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01492-00325224-00325310": "politics", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01493-00325311-00325703": "uh and in communications and uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01494-00325704-00326015": "lately in crisis management um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01495-00326016-00326239": "so so i'm gonna come at this from a kind", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01496-00326240-00326471": "of outside-in perspective", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01497-00326472-00326799": "um and and have a look a little bit at", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01498-00326800-00327127": "you know what people think about ai um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01499-00327128-00327454": "and uh and then and then just quickly", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01500-00327455-00327663": "lay out some sort of overarching", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01501-00327664-00327903": "principles and practices", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01502-00327904-00328247": "um which can help build trust", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01503-00328248-00328495": "um so that leads into this whole area of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01504-00328496-00328647": "trustworthy ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01505-00328648-00328799": "there's a lot of jargon in this area is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01506-00328800-00328991": "one thing i'm finding out", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01507-00328992-00329334": "um so you know in terms of top line", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01508-00329335-00329463": "perceptions you know there are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01509-00329464-00329647": "very contrasting views out there a bad", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01510-00329648-00329823": "ai however", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01511-00329824-00330047": "one thing that's pretty true is that you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01512-00330048-00330191": "know whilst awareness amongst the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01513-00330192-00330382": "general public is high", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01514-00330383-00330791": "understanding of it is low um and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01515-00330792-00330975": "partly as a result of that there are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01516-00330976-00331158": "widespread concerns about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01517-00331159-00331447": "issues like privacy cyber uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01518-00331448-00331558": "manipulation", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01519-00331559-00331758": "um uh ashish we're talking about deep", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01520-00331759-00331978": "fakes that's what i've missed", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01521-00331979-00332127": "disinformation", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01522-00332128-00332303": "you know equality and human rights and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01523-00332304-00332430": "and and also", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01524-00332431-00332678": "unemployment or you know impact", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01525-00332679-00332734": "certainly", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01526-00332735-00333039": "on employment um now", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01527-00333040-00333358": "you know why is trust low well there are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01528-00333359-00333582": "all sorts of reasons here are a few um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01529-00333583-00333734": "first of all clearly", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01530-00333735-00333927": "you know sister ai systems tend to be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01531-00333928-00334110": "pretty opaque", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01532-00334111-00334263": "you can't see them you don't know how", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01533-00334264-00334415": "they work", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01534-00334416-00334599": "and you don't really know why you're", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01535-00334600-00334806": "being delivered the results that you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01536-00334807-00335182": "are there's very little understanding of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01537-00335183-00335527": "the functionality um the competence", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01538-00335528-00335847": "risks and limitations of ai and that's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01539-00335848-00336023": "true not just for the general public but", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01540-00336024-00336206": "also technology journalists you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01541-00336207-00336375": "most technology journalists do not", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01542-00336376-00336591": "understand ai that's very clear and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01543-00336592-00336647": "they're not", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01544-00336648-00336951": "and and they're not allowed to test the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01545-00336952-00337015": "um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01546-00337016-00337239": "the uh or actually have a look at the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01547-00337240-00337334": "code", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01548-00337335-00337647": "so um you know resort", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01549-00337648-00337903": "you know even people who are meant to be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01550-00337904-00338110": "closely involved in the industry", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01551-00338111-00338463": "don't really have much view of this um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01552-00338464-00338678": "we also see a lot of sensationalist and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01553-00338679-00338839": "sort of alarmist", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01554-00338840-00339015": "media coverage around things like", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01555-00339016-00339191": "unemployment surveillance", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01556-00339192-00339415": "killer robots and so on you know and all", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01557-00339416-00339599": "of this leads to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01558-00339600-00339934": "low trust that is shot through", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01559-00339935-00340254": "with myths and misconceptions um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01560-00340255-00340599": "and um you know unfortunately we're", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01561-00340600-00340751": "seeing a lot of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01562-00340752-00341095": "um ai uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01563-00341096-00341319": "programs or products and services you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01564-00341320-00341447": "want to call them that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01565-00341448-00341678": "that are misfiring um and here are one", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01566-00341679-00341830": "or two in here in the uk", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01567-00341831-00342087": "we've had a very high profile example", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01568-00342088-00342223": "recently", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01569-00342224-00342519": "um around uh student exam grading which", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01570-00342520-00342551": "uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01571-00342552-00342830": "badly be backfired on the uh on the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01572-00342831-00342991": "government", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01573-00342992-00343327": "so you know there's a changing landscape", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01574-00343328-00343454": "and i think the general shift and i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01575-00343455-00343582": "won't read through all of these but the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01576-00343583-00343775": "general shift is towards", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01577-00343776-00344087": "um greater accountability uh and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01578-00344088-00344367": "and transparency uh and in my view", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01579-00344368-00344406": "that's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01580-00344407-00344751": "that's a very good thing um um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01581-00344752-00345015": "and indeed you know some components of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01582-00345016-00345119": "what you might term", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01583-00345120-00345391": "trustworthy ai are starting to emerge i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01584-00345392-00345510": "think you know there is a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01585-00345511-00345663": "there is a greater emphasis on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01586-00345664-00345895": "governance and ethics", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01587-00345896-00346143": "um and and that's great you know that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01588-00346144-00346271": "helps", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01589-00346272-00346575": "um um you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01590-00346576-00346919": "increase some sense of accountability um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01591-00346920-00347127": "and and it make and things like", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01592-00347128-00347319": "traceability and explainability", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01593-00347320-00347703": "help systems help make systems safer and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01594-00347704-00347815": "fairer", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01595-00347816-00348039": "as well as you know organizations and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01596-00348040-00348206": "engineers and experts actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01597-00348207-00348319": "understand", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01598-00348320-00348630": "the decision making of ai however", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01599-00348631-00348871": "from the outside in perspective you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01600-00348872-00349039": "from the consumer the general public", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01601-00349040-00349191": "perspective", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01602-00349192-00349495": "algorithms remain or ai uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01603-00349496-00349654": "driven algorithms at least remain", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01604-00349655-00349999": "fundamentally apparent and confusing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01605-00350000-00350354": "um and and perceived accountability of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01606-00350355-00350630": "organizations um you know and you might", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01607-00350631-00350815": "think of facebook in this regard", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01608-00350816-00351127": "remains very low um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01609-00351128-00351375": "so you know what what might be some", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01610-00351376-00351671": "principles of ai transparency", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01611-00351672-00351958": "um and you know i come at this for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01612-00351959-00352063": "chiefly from a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01613-00352064-00352239": "a reputational and communications", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01614-00352240-00352463": "perspective as i mentioned earlier", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01615-00352464-00352623": "um so i'm not going to talk so much", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01616-00352624-00352815": "about the governance aspect", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01617-00352816-00353087": "nonetheless governance is critical it's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01618-00353088-00353151": "core", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01619-00353152-00353439": "to transparency so you know putting", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01620-00353440-00353654": "values ethics and transparency at the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01621-00353655-00353799": "center of ai governance", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01622-00353800-00354095": "i think is very very important involving", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01623-00354096-00354223": "directly impacted", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01624-00354224-00354463": "impacted stakeholders in ai design and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01625-00354464-00354527": "testing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01626-00354528-00354687": "i mean if the british government had", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01627-00354688-00354903": "decided to that they wanted actually to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01628-00354904-00355078": "involve students", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01629-00355079-00355319": "in its exam grade algorithm i think they", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01630-00355320-00355423": "would have come out with a very", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01631-00355424-00355591": "different solution", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01632-00355592-00355791": "monitoring and strengthening ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01633-00355792-00356103": "governance and technology continuously", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01634-00356104-00356358": "you know making sure that you're always", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01635-00356359-00356647": "improving and that you're responding to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01636-00356648-00356958": "both internal and external", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01637-00356959-00357287": "um uh pressures um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01638-00357288-00357606": "communicating clearly honestly", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01639-00357607-00357854": "consistently and regularly right from", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01640-00357855-00357975": "the start", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01641-00357976-00358167": "uh is i think fundamentals of you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01642-00358168-00358358": "communication good communication is a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01643-00358359-00358543": "fundamental tenet of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01644-00358544-00358791": "transparency and being able to think", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01645-00358792-00358895": "laterally about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01646-00358896-00359119": "unexpected consequences again not just", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01647-00359120-00359303": "from a technological perspective but", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01648-00359304-00359447": "also from a societal", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01649-00359448-00359895": "cultural and values based uh perspective", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01650-00359896-00360206": "um so what does ai transparency mean in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01651-00360207-00360303": "practice well", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01652-00360304-00360543": "you know on the communication side and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01653-00360544-00360630": "again i'm not going to talk about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01654-00360631-00360927": "governance per se or ethics per se", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01655-00360928-00361182": "here but you know the governor if you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01656-00361183-00361358": "know what is going on in the governance", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01657-00361359-00361406": "area", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01658-00361407-00361734": "needs to be communicated um and i think", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01659-00361735-00361951": "giving insight into the processes", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01660-00361952-00362271": "and strategy and the people involved um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01661-00362272-00362487": "as well as you know perhaps opens open", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01662-00362488-00362663": "sourcing data sets and toolkits and so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01663-00362664-00362710": "on is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01664-00362711-00363063": "is is is very important equally of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01665-00363064-00363206": "course around the actual", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01666-00363207-00363415": "products or service or system whatever", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01667-00363416-00363543": "you want to call it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01668-00363544-00363703": "uh you know what is this thing trying to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01669-00363704-00363863": "do what are the objectives", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01670-00363864-00364223": "in what context is it being run", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01671-00364224-00364439": "um you know some information about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01672-00364440-00364687": "technology itself data processing you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01673-00364688-00364910": "know what are the outcomes can they be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01674-00364911-00365078": "improved somehow", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01675-00365079-00365303": "um as well as of course around some of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01676-00365304-00365558": "the risks notably around", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01677-00365559-00365878": "excuse me human oversight uh uh i i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01678-00365879-00366030": "think it's very and privacy is very", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01679-00366031-00366134": "important", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01680-00366135-00366375": "and then finally you know around", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01681-00366376-00366551": "incident crisis management i mean what", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01682-00366552-00366639": "happens when", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01683-00366640-00366951": "if and when these things backfire", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01684-00366952-00367278": "so uh preparing for that uh learning", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01685-00367279-00367439": "and understanding how to respond", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01686-00367440-00367615": "appropriately", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01687-00367616-00367887": "rather than just shutting up um or", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01688-00367888-00368054": "pulling the algorithm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01689-00368055-00368487": "um you know how do you recover", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01690-00368488-00368719": "properly and making sure you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01691-00368720-00368903": "linking to recovery", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01692-00368904-00369158": "that you're learning and acting up and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01693-00369159-00369406": "being seen to act upon the lessons", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01694-00369407-00369551": "learned", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01695-00369552-00369791": "um there are of course dangers around ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01696-00369792-00369887": "transparency", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01697-00369888-00370143": "uh there could be potential loss of ip", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01698-00370144-00370263": "there could be potential loss of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01699-00370264-00370447": "competitive advantage", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01700-00370448-00370782": "um uh you know you're you're trying to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01701-00370783-00370830": "create", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01702-00370831-00371054": "higher expectations amongst your various", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01703-00371055-00371143": "stakeholders", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01704-00371144-00371343": "but you fail to meet those that could be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01705-00371344-00371463": "a problem and of course there's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01706-00371464-00371647": "reputational damage", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01707-00371648-00371895": "so you know transparency is not a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01708-00371896-00372015": "one-way street", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01709-00372016-00372239": "it has two sides and you've got to find", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01710-00372240-00372423": "the right kind of balance here", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01711-00372424-00372551": "but i think these are the kinds of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01712-00372552-00372734": "things that i argue you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01713-00372735-00372910": "i see i see communication as a kind of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01714-00372911-00373078": "layer it's it's critical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01715-00373079-00373367": "it's a core part of what you might call", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01716-00373368-00373478": "ethical ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01717-00373479-00373782": "but it's also a layer over it um as i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01718-00373783-00373871": "see it and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01719-00373872-00374110": "um and you and you need to try and try", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01720-00374111-00374206": "and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01721-00374207-00374606": "um find ways of connecting persuading", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01722-00374607-00374910": "and engaging and ideally involving", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01723-00374911-00375119": "audiences because of course involving", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01724-00375120-00375254": "people in something is the best", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01725-00375255-00375430": "communication of all", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01726-00375431-00375734": "okay thank you thank you very much", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01727-00375735-00375871": "charlie", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01728-00375872-00376119": "i i think that we've received quite a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01729-00376120-00376206": "record number", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01730-00376207-00376510": "of of questions and just looking at the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01731-00376511-00376582": "time we're", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01732-00376583-00376734": "probably not going to be able to delve", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01733-00376735-00376895": "into them so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01734-00376896-00377134": "while you were presenting i thought of a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01735-00377135-00377206": "way of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01736-00377207-00377551": "kind of tackling them by themes", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01737-00377552-00377919": "um and the best approach that i i think", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01738-00377920-00377999": "we should take", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01739-00378000-00378191": "is first of all let's look who's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01740-00378192-00378478": "responsible who's actually building", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01741-00378479-00378615": "there are a few questions in this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01742-00378616-00378927": "respect um then about the data", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01743-00378928-00379134": "then around the enterprise and applying", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01744-00379135-00379295": "those principles and i know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01745-00379296-00379551": "joris and ashish will have quite a lot", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01746-00379552-00379599": "to say", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01747-00379600-00379854": "as well and we're going to come back to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01748-00379855-00379991": "ethical controls and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01749-00379992-00380199": "and you know do we have real problems", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01750-00380200-00380399": "that warrant ai and how do we actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01751-00380400-00380487": "do it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01752-00380488-00380791": "so i'm going to start with um two", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01753-00380792-00380927": "questions that uh have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01754-00380928-00381110": "come through and they're i think very", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01755-00381111-00381430": "important um and they tie up together", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01756-00381431-00381702": "what is the responsibility that is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01757-00381703-00381791": "shared by", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01758-00381792-00382078": "those you know developers of machine", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01759-00382079-00382282": "learning modules", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01760-00382283-00382623": "and um what does hiring", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01761-00382624-00382910": "what the what role does hiring from a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01762-00382911-00382991": "diverse", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01763-00382992-00383334": "and inclusive background play um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01764-00383335-00383623": "in especially when you're building ai um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01765-00383624-00383902": "especially when we have inherent biases", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01766-00383903-00384078": "that we have to deal with", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01767-00384079-00384391": "so is diversity and inclusion the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01768-00384392-00384630": "solution to ensure that whenever we're", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01769-00384631-00384727": "building", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01770-00384728-00385054": "um and who actually builds the modules", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01771-00385055-00385391": "is that a defending defensibility system", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01772-00385392-00385671": "that we can put in place", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01773-00385672-00385887": "if i can um you know ask any of the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01774-00385888-00386071": "speakers to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01775-00386072-00386382": "unmute yourself and ask ask", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01776-00386383-00386615": "you know answer the question that would", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01777-00386616-00386910": "be really great", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01778-00386911-00387167": "i can i can just just add my my thoughts", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01779-00387168-00387223": "there is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01780-00387224-00387558": "is absolutely right absolutely diversity", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01781-00387559-00387734": "so again we go back into this whole", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01782-00387735-00387871": "principle of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01783-00387872-00388063": "you know there will be argument and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01784-00388064-00388239": "there is argument that hey", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01785-00388240-00388423": "technology is technology it doesn't have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01786-00388424-00388671": "bias right but that is applaud argument", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01787-00388672-00388734": "right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01788-00388735-00388902": "it is a flawed argument because at the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01789-00388903-00389039": "end of the day technology", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01790-00389040-00389399": "is created by humans and all of us", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01791-00389400-00389710": "have biases right uh we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01792-00389711-00389943": "you know we have these these implicit", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01793-00389944-00390063": "biases that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01794-00390064-00390287": "uh those are just our survival", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01795-00390288-00390375": "mechanisms", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01796-00390376-00390615": "it's like it has it does it is genetic", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01797-00390616-00390767": "right at the end of the day", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01798-00390768-00391006": "so what do we do to actually make sure", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01799-00391007-00391110": "that not only we are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01800-00391111-00391310": "aware of those biases but we are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01801-00391311-00391543": "actually working against them", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01802-00391544-00391743": "and diversity and inclusion actually is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01803-00391744-00391943": "the biggest solution there which is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01804-00391944-00392206": "you know bringing alternate viewpoints", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01805-00392207-00392367": "right so i can tell you this right you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01806-00392368-00392447": "know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01807-00392448-00392782": "if you have a lot of mail", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01808-00392783-00393047": "sit around create a technology which is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01809-00393048-00393223": "working for women", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01810-00393224-00393391": "you know obviously we have not the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01811-00393392-00393591": "capacity and capability to think that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01812-00393592-00393695": "point of view", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01813-00393696-00394039": "right so you have to include all of us", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01814-00394040-00394295": "together to build a solution and that's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01815-00394296-00394454": "where i think your point", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01816-00394455-00394702": "is diversity and inclusion from my", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01817-00394703-00394839": "perspective and from microsoft", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01818-00394840-00394910": "perspective", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01819-00394911-00395230": "is i think the best any antidote to this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01820-00395231-00395302": "whole", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01821-00395303-00395606": "problem of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01822-00395607-00395934": "bias in technology do you think i should", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01823-00395935-00396006": "start you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01824-00396007-00396382": "the you know hiring of um ethnic", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01825-00396383-00396487": "minorities", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01826-00396488-00396775": "blacks it has a is an important you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01827-00396776-00397047": "how is it tackled in our industry", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01828-00397048-00397430": "well so so you know i'll say yes it is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01829-00397431-00397630": "it is very very important right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01830-00397631-00397830": "from the basic principle of that hey you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01831-00397831-00398006": "know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01832-00398007-00398206": "all kind of point of views are important", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01833-00398207-00398334": "as you start building the next", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01834-00398335-00398495": "generation of technology but to your", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01835-00398496-00398582": "point", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01836-00398583-00398854": "uh it is the right thing to do not just", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01837-00398855-00399039": "from a technology perspective but", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01838-00399040-00399310": "also making sure that and at the end of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01839-00399311-00399454": "the day and this is the reason right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01840-00399455-00399487": "which", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01841-00399488-00399758": "i think very very strongly about is your", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01842-00399759-00399863": "consumers", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01843-00399864-00400087": "are not one set of customers your", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01844-00400088-00400271": "consumers are diverse your customers are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01845-00400272-00400358": "diverse", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01846-00400359-00400575": "so the builders of the technology have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01847-00400576-00400678": "to be diverse", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01848-00400679-00400934": "as well so so it is not just the right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01849-00400935-00401134": "thing to do it is also the business", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01850-00401135-00401254": "imperative", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01851-00401255-00401599": "to do it right so so so yes it is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01852-00401600-00401830": "that's how we should build and there", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01853-00401831-00402030": "have been problems we are not there yet", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01854-00402031-00402182": "but i think we are making", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01855-00402183-00402471": "steps in the right direction the quickly", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01856-00402472-00402591": "we reach there", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01857-00402592-00402758": "the better we will be in a position to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01858-00402759-00403063": "solve these problems", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01859-00403064-00403254": "no that's that that's a very that's a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01860-00403255-00403430": "very good point", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01861-00403431-00403823": "i i know that we we don't have um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01862-00403824-00404023": "you know sufficient time to delve very", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01863-00404024-00404230": "deeply into into this i think it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01864-00404231-00404439": "warrants actually nikita a completely", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01865-00404440-00404639": "different session to discuss it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01866-00404640-00404919": "it's it's so imperative to to just do", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01867-00404920-00405006": "that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01868-00405007-00405247": "um and and to have an understanding of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01869-00405248-00405551": "um biases diversity inclusion and what", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01870-00405552-00405719": "is the real impact of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01871-00405720-00406078": "technology now i'm gonna swing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01872-00406079-00406463": "to the issues around data and how do we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01873-00406464-00406654": "actually control this process", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01874-00406655-00406910": "and one of the questions was around if", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01875-00406911-00407030": "we're capturing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01876-00407031-00407334": "data from users without permissions", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01877-00407335-00407767": "um is that an unethical um scenario", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01878-00407768-00408327": "um how do we approach that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01879-00408328-00408606": "i i have some thoughts here if yeah go", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01880-00408607-00408710": "for it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01881-00408711-00409078": "so so again it depends on obviously", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01882-00409079-00409247": "your country or your jurisdiction for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01883-00409248-00409454": "one if it's illegal or not depending on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01884-00409455-00409607": "what part of the world", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01885-00409608-00409791": "you're in it's not necessarily illegal", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01886-00409792-00409982": "is it ethically wrong", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01887-00409983-00410255": "no but there was a study i believe by", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01888-00410256-00410463": "mit several years ago which said that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01889-00410464-00410782": "i don't necessarily need information", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01890-00410783-00411007": "you know your name or identifying", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01891-00411008-00411103": "information", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01892-00411104-00411326": "i can just capture other things and then", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01893-00411327-00411470": "there's what's known as the data", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01894-00411471-00411678": "aggregates so a lot of advertisers will", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01895-00411679-00411710": "take", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01896-00411712-00411934": "different data points it could be an ip", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01897-00411935-00412239": "address it could be a geo location", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01898-00412239-00412559": "even like preferences or email addresses", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01899-00412560-00412751": "or things like that and then you lump", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01900-00412752-00412903": "those into", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01901-00412904-00413214": "case so i obviously i think this is how", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01902-00413215-00413422": "a lot of the you know larger social", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01903-00413423-00413559": "media platforms", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01904-00413560-00413799": "uh make their money right is gathering", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01905-00413800-00414030": "and aggregating that data from us", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01906-00414031-00414207": "but in some cases too there is now", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01907-00414208-00414391": "what's known as aggregate data in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01908-00414392-00414463": "general", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01909-00414464-00414687": "so if i have several points from you i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01910-00414688-00414895": "can generate new information", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01911-00414896-00415143": "that you may not even know of or what", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01912-00415143-00415326": "you know certain traits are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01913-00415327-00415534": "and capture that type of information as", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01914-00415535-00415655": "well so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01915-00415656-00416007": "again not illegal yet in some cases", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01916-00416008-00416247": "but this is what the disclosure comes to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01917-00416247-00416326": "is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01918-00416327-00416470": "and at that same point do you give up", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01919-00416471-00416630": "trade secrets and what you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01920-00416631-00416926": "are collecting about people and how you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01921-00416927-00417110": "do that and then certainly how you use", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01922-00417112-00417143": "and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01923-00417143-00417430": "you disseminate that information to uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01924-00417431-00417943": "especially third parties", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01925-00417943-00418199": "that that is that is a you know a very", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01926-00418200-00418391": "good point", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01927-00418392-00418678": "then um you know the next question is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01928-00418679-00418726": "and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01929-00418727-00418903": "again we're coming back to kind of the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01930-00418904-00419103": "production of and then bringing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01931-00419104-00419439": "technology to market how can we ensure", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01932-00419439-00419670": "especially around deep fakes how do we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01933-00419671-00419783": "identify", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01934-00419784-00420199": "track and um you know manage the fake", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01935-00420200-00420422": "what tools do do companies have right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01936-00420423-00420487": "now", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01937-00420488-00420775": "in the ecosystems especially um startups", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01938-00420776-00420855": "especially", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01939-00420856-00421143": "um you know very young companies looking", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01940-00421143-00421191": "to bring", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01941-00421192-00421766": "new products to the market", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01942-00421767-00422055": "um so when we think about technology", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01943-00422056-00422247": "solutions right we think about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01944-00422247-00422518": "short term right now and long term you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01945-00422519-00422575": "know that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01946-00422576-00422783": "eventually i think is the right way to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01947-00422784-00422895": "tackle these", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01948-00422896-00423222": "short term detection of defects", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01949-00423223-00423543": "uh may help now detection is super hard", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01950-00423543-00423687": "right you know even the facebook", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01951-00423688-00423918": "detection challenge the best algorithms", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01952-00423919-00424310": "were able to get 65 percent off accuracy", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01953-00424312-00424566": "so even the detection is too hard it is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01954-00424567-00424735": "a cat and mouse game", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01955-00424735-00424959": "uh but we have to keep on thinking about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01956-00424960-00425175": "that right and and then it can come into", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01957-00425176-00425343": "various forms and i've i've actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01958-00425343-00425518": "written a bit about this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01959-00425519-00425855": "on on in a couple of blog posts on a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01960-00425856-00425951": "long term", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01961-00425952-00426199": "as you think about the right solution to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01962-00426200-00426422": "misinformation disinformation or even", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01963-00426423-00426535": "defects", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01964-00426535-00426766": "is authoritative source behind that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01965-00426767-00426966": "piece of medium so authentication and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01966-00426967-00427070": "provenance", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01967-00427071-00427351": "can you prove that this piece of media", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01968-00427352-00427599": "is coming from an authoritative source", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01969-00427600-00427895": "and has not been tampered with when it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01970-00427896-00427991": "goes to the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01971-00427992-00428247": "distribution end point so youtube player", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01972-00428247-00428543": "or facebook player or whoever right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01973-00428543-00428766": "and and and what what it and also you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01974-00428767-00428975": "can you prove the origins of this media", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01975-00428976-00429135": "right where it is coming from", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01976-00429135-00429327": "authoritative source non-authoritative", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01977-00429328-00429566": "source and has not been tempered", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01978-00429567-00429839": "so the technology which we actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01979-00429839-00429910": "trying to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01980-00429912-00430231": "get to is something which we think akin", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01981-00430232-00430270": "to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01982-00430271-00430551": "what ssl is right all of us know that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01983-00430552-00430639": "padlock", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01984-00430639-00430879": "the secured socket layer technology", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01985-00430880-00431047": "which is certificate based", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01986-00431047-00431222": "and you know we know that end-to-end", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01987-00431223-00431422": "encryption happens between browser", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01988-00431423-00431647": "and if you have something of similar", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01989-00431647-00431910": "technology where a piece of media can be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01990-00431912-00432255": "somehow have a signal that can", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01991-00432256-00432495": "flow across that piece of media as it is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01992-00432496-00432614": "going through this pipeline of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01993-00432615-00432799": "compression decompression", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01994-00432800-00433127": "and and and what not an endpoint can say", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01995-00433128-00433183": "okay", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01996-00433184-00433414": "i know because this has a signal now i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01997-00433415-00433559": "don't know what the signal", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01998-00433560-00433766": "look will look like eventually but there", "TwKEtE3LAoU-01999-00433767-00433959": "is some work that microsoft is doing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02000-00433960-00434103": "adobe is doing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02001-00434104-00434414": "uh even google is is working on uh with", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02002-00434415-00434527": "what we call", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02003-00434528-00434718": "what we call project origin adobe is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02004-00434719-00434959": "calling content", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02005-00434960-00435222": "authenticity initiative google has", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02006-00435223-00435327": "content id", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02007-00435328-00435518": "but the concept is the same where you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02008-00435519-00435679": "have authentication and prominence", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02009-00435680-00436303": "mechanism and piece of media", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02010-00436304-00436543": "that is that is a very very good point", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02011-00436543-00436663": "um jars", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02012-00436664-00437055": "there are some questions for for you and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02013-00437056-00437487": "um but i i just first first thinks first", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02014-00437488-00437863": "um we had two questions uh around", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02015-00437864-00438151": "diversity one from was from women one", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02016-00438152-00438351": "was from on blacks and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02017-00438352-00438599": "i'm just gonna come out there and say it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02018-00438600-00438663": "wasn't", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02019-00438664-00438991": "intended i have added the element", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02020-00438992-00439207": "um and i haven't tried to distort the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02021-00439208-00439295": "meaning", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02022-00439296-00439687": "the meaning of the question it's um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02023-00439688-00439895": "honestly it was my intention to ask this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02024-00439896-00440055": "and to potentially", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02025-00440056-00440414": "um open the discussion in a way and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02026-00440415-00440487": "potentially", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02027-00440488-00440743": "even cover it in a whole event i think", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02028-00440743-00440831": "it's it's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02029-00440832-00441070": "um it's very important to have that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02030-00441071-00441407": "frank approach", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02031-00441408-00441751": "okay joris um the point", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02032-00441752-00441991": "that uh there are several questions so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02033-00441992-00442231": "i'm gonna start with the first one", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02034-00442232-00442470": "um many many people have had questions", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02035-00442471-00442670": "around the examples of introducing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02036-00442671-00442743": "fairness", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02037-00442743-00443079": "into algorithms and products and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02038-00443080-00443310": "most importantly how do you select the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02039-00443312-00443487": "different principles that you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02040-00443488-00443918": "are um you are you are introducing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02041-00443919-00444199": "into your framework because when you're", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02042-00444200-00444351": "building technologies", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02043-00444352-00444614": "picking the right principle or specific", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02044-00444615-00444735": "principles", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02045-00444735-00445014": "um can have a completely different", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02046-00445015-00445079": "impact", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02047-00445080-00445303": "so how you know how are you approaching", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02048-00445304-00445422": "this in your", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02049-00445423-00445822": "organization yeah that's a that's a very", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02050-00445823-00445951": "good question and i think", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02051-00445952-00446239": "that's a challenge every organization is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02052-00446239-00446327": "facing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02053-00446328-00446566": "how can we motivate the principles we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02054-00446567-00446703": "pick and the decisions we make in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02055-00446704-00446807": "interpreting these", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02056-00446808-00447031": "principles because as i mentioned", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02057-00447032-00447199": "earlier the principles are fine and no", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02058-00447200-00447295": "one is against", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02059-00447296-00447495": "world peace we all want them to be fair", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02060-00447496-00447655": "and we all want them", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02061-00447656-00447895": "to be explainable but what happens when", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02062-00447896-00448022": "there's actually a prize", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02063-00448023-00448239": "to this implementation of fairness and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02064-00448239-00448366": "what happens when there's actually a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02065-00448367-00448503": "price to this implementation of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02066-00448504-00448614": "explainability", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02067-00448615-00448870": "i think that's the interesting question", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02068-00448871-00448966": "and when we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02069-00448967-00449359": "look at fairness i mean algorithms", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02070-00449360-00449663": "elementary are used to discriminate", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02071-00449664-00449999": "their sole purpose is to order people or", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02072-00450000-00450263": "to place them in specific bins", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02073-00450264-00450591": "so the algorithms we use we know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02074-00450592-00450743": "there there's bias and we know there's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02075-00450743-00450935": "discrimination the question is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02076-00450935-00451135": "how can we correct or re-bias this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02077-00451135-00451366": "algorithm actually", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02078-00451367-00451791": "so that it fits with what we think is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02079-00451792-00451975": "justifiable or what we think is is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02080-00451976-00452095": "ethical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02081-00452096-00452279": "and the fairness definitions you have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02082-00452280-00452439": "there i mean that's an open discussion", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02083-00452439-00452607": "and that's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02084-00452608-00452918": "i'm a bit averse of the self-assessments", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02085-00452919-00453151": "and of those sort of lists i mean we did", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02086-00453152-00453255": "some trials with them", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02087-00453256-00453559": "especially european self-assessment for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02088-00453560-00453879": "ethical ai and what you find is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02089-00453880-00454191": "that well first of all they are assuming", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02090-00454192-00454231": "that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02091-00454232-00454479": "all the ai applications have equal", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02092-00454480-00454559": "ethical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02093-00454560-00454822": "risk and for example just looking at the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02094-00454823-00454983": "practical use case of the bank", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02095-00454984-00455270": "we have an ai that is checking whether", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02096-00455271-00455375": "we should", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02097-00455376-00455622": "reach out to someone via email or via a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02098-00455623-00455735": "letter", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02099-00455735-00455910": "and when i started this ethical impact", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02100-00455912-00456055": "assessment with the data scientists", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02101-00456056-00456207": "developing that model", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02102-00456208-00456327": "the first question of the impact", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02103-00456328-00456510": "assessment was did you perform a human", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02104-00456512-00456687": "rights impact assessment and they", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02105-00456688-00456943": "were looking at me like are you serious", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02106-00456943-00457007": "for a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02107-00457008-00457231": "type of model do we need to do an", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02108-00457232-00457414": "ethical or a human rights impact", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02109-00457415-00457495": "assessment", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02110-00457496-00457647": "so there are different forms and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02111-00457647-00457903": "different different gravity of ethical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02112-00457904-00458070": "risks and i think when it comes to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02113-00458071-00458255": "fairness we we do check the high stake", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02114-00458256-00458447": "decision algorithms and you have the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02115-00458447-00458614": "credit risk scoring which is the most", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02116-00458615-00458839": "obvious example for for every bank", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02117-00458839-00459063": "and i mean it's an ongoing discussion", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02118-00459064-00459263": "it's a deliberative process", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02119-00459264-00459439": "where actually you find that these", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02120-00459439-00459631": "values these ethical values are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02121-00459632-00459831": "are conflicting and we can say well we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02122-00459832-00460014": "can say we want equal", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02123-00460015-00460207": "equal parity so to speak we want to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02124-00460208-00460431": "treat each group the same way", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02125-00460432-00460687": "but that means that the accuracy for the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02126-00460688-00460863": "predictions of each group", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02127-00460864-00461007": "are becoming less so these are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02128-00461008-00461175": "trade-offs that are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02129-00461176-00461318": "really difficult and we make them in a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02130-00461319-00461527": "deliberative way and we revise them once", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02131-00461528-00461622": "we think", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02132-00461623-00461766": "we didn't choose the right way so it's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02133-00461767-00461983": "an ongoing process and it's not statical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02134-00461984-00462151": "and it's not a one-size-fits-all so it's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02135-00462152-00462279": "not that we say we choose this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02136-00462280-00462463": "definition of fairness", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02137-00462464-00462655": "and then that will define what is fair", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02138-00462656-00462855": "for all the models we use", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02139-00462856-00463014": "it's really context dependent and i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02140-00463015-00463183": "think that's the most important part and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02141-00463184-00463287": "that's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02142-00463288-00463518": "a bit of the trouble i'm having with all", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02143-00463519-00463727": "the frameworks out there", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02144-00463728-00464031": "i mean it's so context specific and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02145-00464032-00464263": "um i mean the contacts matter so much", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02146-00464264-00464439": "that it's really difficult to get to a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02147-00464439-00464614": "general interpretation of fairness for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02148-00464615-00464687": "example", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02149-00464688-00464918": "so the best you can do is motivate the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02150-00464919-00464999": "decision to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02151-00465000-00465135": "when it comes to fairness and signal", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02152-00465135-00465318": "that for example a credit risk scoring", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02153-00465319-00465366": "model", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02154-00465367-00465639": "will have an impact on uh different", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02155-00465639-00465783": "groups and on different subgroups", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02156-00465784-00465927": "differently", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02157-00465928-00466103": "but you cannot come up with a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02158-00466104-00466263": "one-size-fits-all or", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02159-00466264-00466422": "aesthetical definition of fairness that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02160-00466423-00466591": "will suit all your algorithms or that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02161-00466592-00466639": "will", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02162-00466639-00466799": "stay with you in the long term i mean", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02163-00466800-00467007": "you have to monitor revise and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02164-00467008-00467479": "deliberate", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02165-00467480-00467670": "thank you very much george that that's a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02166-00467671-00467966": "very um you know very detailed response", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02167-00467967-00468175": "and and let me let me just dig a little", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02168-00468176-00468270": "bit deeper", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02169-00468271-00468510": "what does it mean um to have an", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02170-00468512-00468655": "explainable ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02171-00468656-00468991": "as an enterprise um what what", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02172-00468992-00469231": "you know what does it mean in practice", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02173-00469232-00469359": "this is one of the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02174-00469360-00469591": "questions that appears in several", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02175-00469592-00469695": "formats", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02176-00469696-00470055": "um throughout our um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02177-00470056-00470431": "um through our our", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02178-00470432-00470951": "slido application", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02179-00470952-00471127": "yeah so what i i can tell you what it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02180-00471128-00471351": "means for us it means that we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02181-00471352-00471591": "can provide the explanation to each of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02182-00471592-00471918": "the stakeholders that is relevant", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02183-00471919-00472087": "you will you want to have a different", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02184-00472088-00472303": "explanation for consumers who don't want", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02185-00472304-00472487": "to be overload with all sort of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02186-00472488-00472814": "information about models and statistics", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02187-00472815-00473031": "and so you want to have an explanation", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02188-00473032-00473231": "that's tailored to their", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02189-00473232-00473366": "level of understanding so they know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02190-00473367-00473566": "because they want to know why is my", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02191-00473567-00473639": "application", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02192-00473639-00473927": "uh approved or why wasn't it approved", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02193-00473928-00474070": "that's the type of explanation they want", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02194-00474071-00474151": "and that differs", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02195-00474152-00474335": "significantly from the explanation you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02196-00474335-00474591": "give to external oversight agencies for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02197-00474592-00474695": "example", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02198-00474696-00474927": "so for us an explainable model means", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02199-00474928-00475014": "that we can", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02200-00475015-00475255": "explain the results and the outcomes uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02201-00475256-00475439": "to the different stakeholders that we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02202-00475439-00475879": "have to answer", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02203-00475880-00476095": "that's that's fine would you agree that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02204-00476096-00476303": "um when you were thinking about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02205-00476304-00476583": "um explainable we're thinking about the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02206-00476584-00476703": "way we build", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02207-00476704-00476903": "governance and you know the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02208-00476904-00477031": "consideration that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02209-00477032-00477463": "we um you know we have um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02210-00477464-00477718": "at that level so should we start with", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02211-00477719-00477910": "thinking about the importance of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02212-00477912-00478039": "explainable ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02213-00478039-00478359": "and ethics at a governance level and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02214-00478360-00478391": "then", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02215-00478392-00478607": "have the real the sort of ethical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02216-00478608-00478695": "controls", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02217-00478696-00478903": "as we build the products and i know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02218-00478904-00479079": "maybe ashish and ilona you could you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02219-00479080-00479151": "could um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02220-00479152-00479431": "you know step in and provide your views", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02221-00479432-00479759": "in this in this respect", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02222-00479760-00479935": "sure so one of the things right and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02223-00479935-00480103": "privacy by design uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02224-00480104-00480470": "by ann kavokian who was the former uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02225-00480471-00480839": "canadian uh privacy uh governor", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02226-00480839-00481143": "so our officer there and she uh she came", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02227-00481143-00481239": "up with the pbd", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02228-00481239-00481543": "concept in the mid 90s and it was just", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02229-00481543-00481655": "essentially to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02230-00481656-00481999": "integrate privacy by design into", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02231-00482000-00482222": "the software development life cycle", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02232-00482223-00482366": "which is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02233-00482367-00482535": "you know you're like yes that makes", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02234-00482535-00482679": "sense but here we are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02235-00482680-00482887": "you know almost 20 some odd years later", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02236-00482888-00483062": "and we still haven't really gotten a lot", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02237-00483063-00483231": "of traction with that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02238-00483232-00483422": "because i think that we have skipped", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02239-00483423-00483591": "through you know some of the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02240-00483592-00483822": "people components of that right and this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02241-00483823-00483999": "is where change management is so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02242-00484000-00484095": "critical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02243-00484096-00484335": "and just educating people and you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02244-00484335-00484543": "simply having a basic conversation", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02245-00484543-00484622": "explaining", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02246-00484623-00484935": "what you're trying to do and you know so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02247-00484935-00485143": "it could be a variety of things you know", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02248-00485143-00485343": "just the the culture of an", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02249-00485343-00485591": "organization the communication within", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02250-00485592-00485759": "that organization as well", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02251-00485760-00485918": "what is the communication with your", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02252-00485919-00486175": "customers and just making sure that you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02253-00486176-00486287": "level set", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02254-00486288-00486551": "are on that same page but i think if you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02255-00486552-00486647": "are a company", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02256-00486647-00486791": "and you do start out with good", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02257-00486792-00486991": "intentions that's really you know what", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02258-00486992-00487207": "matters and to have that ethics and that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02259-00487208-00487262": "culture", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02260-00487263-00487503": "interjected throughout on a daily basis", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02261-00487504-00487655": "no matter what you do", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02262-00487656-00487862": "right technically it shouldn't just be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02263-00487863-00488079": "by design it should just be by", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02264-00488080-00488359": "you know by your own ethical procedures", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02265-00488360-00488518": "that you would do anyway", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02266-00488519-00488662": "so i think that's the other thing we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02267-00488663-00488822": "have to do is trying to get", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02268-00488823-00489087": "people in organizations in general and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02269-00489088-00489247": "our value system within", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02270-00489247-00489503": "companies to have people just think", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02271-00489504-00489583": "about the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02272-00489584-00490239": "impact of what you do on a daily basis", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02273-00490239-00490535": "thank you very much ilana um ashley i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02274-00490535-00490807": "don't know whether you're still with us", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02275-00490808-00490991": "i would be very interested in getting", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02276-00490992-00491483": "your viewpoint on on that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02277-00491484-00491710": "question", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02278-00491712-00491903": "i think my shish was disconnected just", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02279-00491904-00492127": "for a moment um i i just came back i'm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02280-00492128-00492495": "sorry i don't know what happened", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02281-00492496-00492895": "don't worry", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02282-00492896-00493159": "did you manage to get a question yeah", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02283-00493160-00493231": "yeah i i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02284-00493232-00493703": "i did and i also i thought uh alona's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02285-00493704-00493991": "response to it so i'm gonna just uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02286-00493992-00494191": "quickly say this that we do have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02287-00494192-00494510": "uh in in the responsibility uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02288-00494512-00494759": "office of responsible ai business uh not", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02289-00494760-00494855": "business but", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02290-00494856-00495135": "uh the the the team that we have we have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02291-00495135-00495222": "what we call", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02292-00495223-00495543": "an either committee which is essentially", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02293-00495543-00495918": "it's a it's a committee with with the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02294-00495919-00496166": "responsible ai team microsoft research", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02295-00496167-00496335": "and product teams", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02296-00496335-00496647": "and and the basic idea there is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02297-00496647-00496903": "that we do responsibly ai by design", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02298-00496904-00497095": "right so that ether committee has a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02299-00497096-00497287": "responsibility as a governance board", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02300-00497288-00497487": "across microsoft on each and every", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02301-00497488-00497591": "product team", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02302-00497592-00497766": "has to actually go to them in fact i'd", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02303-00497767-00497903": "give you an example", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02304-00497904-00498207": "so we my team actually produced this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02305-00498208-00498318": "technology", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02306-00498319-00498503": "called authentication or video", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02307-00498504-00498703": "authenticator which was for defect", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02308-00498704-00498766": "detection", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02309-00498767-00499014": "and even if it was for defect detection", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02310-00499015-00499247": "but the models the technology models", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02311-00499247-00499566": "were trained on face facial uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02312-00499567-00499743": "recognition technology because you have", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02313-00499743-00499799": "to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02314-00499800-00500039": "for detection of face swap you have to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02315-00500039-00500175": "train the algorithm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02316-00500176-00500422": "to figure out where the face is so even", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02317-00500423-00500631": "the technology was for detection", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02318-00500632-00500975": "but we had to go through a process of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02319-00500976-00501207": "the going through the ether committee", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02320-00501208-00501351": "getting an approval", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02321-00501352-00501543": "and they have this checklist saying okay", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02322-00501543-00501751": "have you trained it for", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02323-00501752-00501991": "like have you tested it for bias right", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02324-00501992-00502118": "what are the intentional", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02325-00502119-00502310": "what are the unexpected harm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02326-00502312-00502479": "unintentional harm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02327-00502480-00502679": "this technology may produce even though", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02328-00502680-00502895": "this technology for detection", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02329-00502896-00503118": "which is not but but still we had to go", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02330-00503119-00503231": "through so i'm just", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02331-00503232-00503407": "making it a point that we are taking", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02332-00503408-00503614": "that step in the right direction i don't", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02333-00503615-00503783": "think that we are there yet as a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02334-00503784-00504062": "technology company but i'm hoping that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02335-00504063-00504287": "we'll be there soon where you have this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02336-00504288-00504670": "this ingrained you know responsible ai", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02337-00504671-00504783": "is not a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02338-00504784-00505110": "step on right it has to go from the sdlc", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02339-00505112-00505287": "from the basic design", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02340-00505288-00505870": "time till the process of deployment", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02341-00505871-00506103": "that is that is fantastic thank you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02342-00506104-00506207": "thank you very much", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02343-00506208-00506670": "nikita you can you can come in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02344-00506671-00507039": "yeah my question that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02345-00507039-00507383": "that is targeting um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02346-00507384-00507799": "actually any one of the speakers uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02347-00507800-00508135": "to the term of responsible ai and then i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02348-00508135-00508318": "don't think that we are in the position", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02349-00508319-00508399": "of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02350-00508400-00508735": "uh assigning a responsibility to a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02351-00508735-00508831": "machine", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02352-00508832-00509135": "and my question is who should be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02353-00509135-00509239": "responsible", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02354-00509239-00509518": "so if for example if in the case of a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02355-00509519-00509727": "technology company there is a mistake", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02356-00509728-00509799": "there is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02357-00509800-00510055": "an error in the design or in the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02358-00510056-00510255": "construction in the development in the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02359-00510256-00510335": "deployment", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02360-00510335-00510631": "or in the use of the system who should", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02361-00510632-00510670": "be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02362-00510671-00510975": "taken responsible and so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02363-00510976-00511303": "if for example we take a shish who is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02364-00511304-00511503": "assigning this responsibility in your", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02365-00511504-00511718": "ethics team and to whom", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02366-00511719-00511935": "right who is going to who is going to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02367-00511935-00512039": "answer", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02368-00512039-00512487": "if something will go wrong", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02369-00512488-00512639": "so i just pasted the link on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02370-00512639-00512807": "unresponsible innovation", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02371-00512808-00513022": "uh that we just recently published which", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02372-00513023-00513214": "we call the harms framework but nikita", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02373-00513215-00513375": "to your question", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02374-00513376-00513599": "as a technology company the creators are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02375-00513600-00513807": "responsible for it so we i think are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02376-00513808-00513975": "responsible and we are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02377-00513976-00514270": "also if if unintentional harms are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02378-00514271-00514487": "created by it and there is an example", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02379-00514488-00514551": "there", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02380-00514552-00514751": "right where we were we're trying to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02381-00514752-00514870": "acquire a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02382-00514871-00515199": "a facial recognition company uh and and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02383-00515200-00515295": "quickly", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02384-00515296-00515599": "realized that it was used by some", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02385-00515600-00515710": "governments", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02386-00515712-00516087": "for for recognizing faces and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02387-00516088-00516335": "the bias was there in the technology and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02388-00516335-00516622": "we took a step to not actually engage", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02389-00516623-00516814": "we have also made some decisions which", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02390-00516815-00516959": "are very public on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02391-00516960-00517166": "what we would do in terms of engaging", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02392-00517167-00517359": "with which governments and which which", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02393-00517360-00517566": "you know we will not right so again we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02394-00517567-00517735": "are responsible i think we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02395-00517735-00517935": "we have to make sure that as a creator", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02396-00517935-00518047": "of technology", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02397-00518047-00518262": "we not only are responsible while", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02398-00518263-00518527": "creating but we are also responsible and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02399-00518528-00518679": "take corrective actions", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02400-00518680-00518931": "when it is deployed and used as", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02401-00518932-00519079": "unintentionally", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02402-00519080-00519407": "uh to create harm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02403-00519408-00519743": "can i add an answer um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02404-00519743-00520079": "because we uh have the same discussion", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02405-00520080-00520239": "of who should be responsible", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02406-00520239-00520431": "um and we define the question in who's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02407-00520432-00520559": "responsible for the outcomes of an", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02408-00520560-00520670": "algorithm and who's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02409-00520671-00520839": "responsible for the consequences of the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02410-00520839-00521014": "outcome of an algorithm", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02411-00521015-00521183": "and basically the sole reason the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02412-00521184-00521343": "project i'm doing now started was", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02413-00521343-00521399": "because", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02414-00521400-00521535": "the data scientists didn't feel", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02415-00521535-00521766": "comfortable with being ultimately", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02416-00521767-00521959": "responsible for the ethical decisions", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02417-00521960-00522070": "they were making", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02418-00522071-00522399": "and that's why i came in actually at the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02419-00522400-00522527": "bank is because they said well we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02420-00522528-00522662": "shouldn't be the one even though we're", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02421-00522663-00522807": "the most knowledgeable we shouldn't be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02422-00522808-00522903": "the ones", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02423-00522904-00523127": "taking this these decisions uh we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02424-00523128-00523262": "shouldn't decide what is fair and what", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02425-00523263-00523399": "is not fair even though we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02426-00523400-00523583": "do know that the most about algorithms", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02427-00523584-00523751": "and about data we shouldn't be the ones", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02428-00523752-00523862": "making these ethical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02429-00523863-00524166": "decisions so uh with us the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02430-00524167-00524351": "data scientists are responsible as well", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02431-00524352-00524487": "we have the model developer and the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02432-00524488-00524551": "mobile owner", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02433-00524552-00524670": "ultimately the model owner is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02434-00524671-00524918": "responsible there and we all agree", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02435-00524919-00525022": "but it shouldn't be the sole", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02436-00525023-00525175": "responsibility of the model owner to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02437-00525176-00525366": "implement these ethical principles", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02438-00525367-00525527": "and that's why we started the ethics", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02439-00525528-00525670": "office that's why we started the ethics", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02440-00525671-00525807": "committee", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02441-00525808-00526022": "it is because we should support and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02442-00526023-00526143": "provide guidance to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02443-00526144-00526327": "model owners and model developers to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02444-00526328-00526479": "make sure that the decisions they are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02445-00526480-00526711": "making in relation to ethical principles", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02446-00526712-00526839": "and the ethical impact of their", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02447-00526840-00526943": "algorithms", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02448-00526944-00527111": "is backed up by the organization and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02449-00527112-00527214": "that they have the support of the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02450-00527215-00527359": "organization and not", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02451-00527360-00527614": "just have to fare on their own gut", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02452-00527615-00527759": "feeling about what is fair and what is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02453-00527760-00528175": "not fair", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02454-00528176-00528391": "i would just wanted to add something", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02455-00528392-00528583": "here is actually that it has", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02456-00528584-00528918": "all uh ethical framework uh you will", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02457-00528919-00529118": "probably already know about different", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02458-00529119-00529303": "frameworks out there", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02459-00529304-00529631": "from the ethics by design and by default", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02460-00529632-00529855": "from the design to development to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02461-00529856-00529966": "implementation", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02462-00529967-00530287": "and then to the usage of those", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02463-00530288-00530639": "application so within within each of the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02464-00530640-00530751": "application", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02465-00530752-00530991": "you probably would i wanted to define", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02466-00530992-00531247": "the user's needs first and then", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02467-00531248-00531535": "you would find out about data collection", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02468-00531536-00531718": "and then the security of that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02469-00531719-00531911": "and then the algorithm development of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02470-00531912-00532111": "that and then the profiles", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02471-00532112-00532303": "and our interference of that and then", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02472-00532304-00532591": "the impacts in users life", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02473-00532592-00532814": "so all of those you already have the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02474-00532815-00532951": "framework out there", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02475-00532952-00533199": "if you follow that and if you can define", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02476-00533200-00533439": "those kind of different roles", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02477-00533440-00533655": "for different teams because it's not", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02478-00533656-00533895": "going to be just only one team because", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02479-00533896-00534118": "in one bank we already know that it is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02480-00534119-00534239": "not just only the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02481-00534240-00534487": "the data scientists who develop those", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02482-00534488-00534614": "algorithm or", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02483-00534615-00534895": "those application but it is going to be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02484-00534896-00535062": "involved with business", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02485-00535063-00535279": "people that will be uh need to be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02486-00535280-00535487": "involved and then the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02487-00535488-00535799": "the owners of that project for example", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02488-00535800-00536055": "so uh it would be it's a learning", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02489-00536056-00536118": "process", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02490-00536119-00536422": "and we can learn from other", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02491-00536423-00536743": "um kind of industry", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02492-00536744-00537014": "uh to actually apply it on this here and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02493-00537015-00537087": "then uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02494-00537088-00537366": "together with that we probably would see", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02495-00537367-00537462": "also", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02496-00537463-00537799": "the different kind of um regulation will", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02497-00537800-00537862": "be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02498-00537863-00538214": "introduced uh gradually and by then we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02499-00538215-00538591": "would also not just only relying on", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02500-00538592-00539047": "purely or heavily unethical but we also", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02501-00539048-00539327": "relies on the compliance of all those", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02502-00539328-00539487": "regulations that are coming out", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02503-00539488-00539791": "as well so um together uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02504-00539792-00540151": "i think that we are evolving and we are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02505-00540152-00540422": "learning uh on the way and i think that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02506-00540423-00540527": "um", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02507-00540528-00540783": "we don't want to be all the time as the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02508-00540784-00540870": "the american", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02509-00540871-00541207": "innovates and then the china the chinese", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02510-00541208-00541439": "copies and then the european regulates", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02511-00541440-00541566": "we don't want to be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02512-00541567-00541879": "in that kind of monologue but we wanted", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02513-00541880-00542183": "to see that what is the right balance", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02514-00542184-00542470": "how are we going to strike it so that we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02515-00542471-00542575": "can adopt", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02516-00542576-00542879": "and we can actually promote the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02517-00542880-00543103": "the usage of ai not everything would", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02518-00543104-00543231": "need ai anyway", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02519-00543232-00543662": "but like if we do and wanted to leverage", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02520-00543663-00544079": "the um the positive impacts of ais", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02521-00544080-00544462": "on um on our peoples on the market", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02522-00544463-00544807": "in the on the economy then we need to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02523-00544808-00545151": "not only hold the grudge to some things", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02524-00545152-00545183": "that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02525-00545184-00545518": "is already kind of like um our way of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02526-00545519-00545583": "doing it", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02527-00545584-00545807": "we need to be open and we need to be", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02528-00545808-00545903": "adopted as", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02529-00545904-00546199": "you already many of the speakers already", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02530-00546200-00546239": "share", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02531-00546240-00546455": "so i think that it's it's a it's a", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02532-00546456-00546662": "journey it's not a destination that's", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02533-00546663-00546775": "why we are here", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02534-00546776-00547014": "and that's why we are um kind of trying", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02535-00547015-00547151": "to pull together", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02536-00547152-00547391": "uh all of different thoughts and i think", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02537-00547392-00547462": "that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02538-00547463-00547727": "i appreciate and learn quite a bit from", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02539-00547728-00547847": "our speaker today", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02540-00547848-00548070": "as well as from the questions so thank", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02541-00548071-00548262": "you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02542-00548263-00548511": "yes thank you very much everyone um we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02543-00548512-00548583": "have gone", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02544-00548584-00548887": "seven minutes over over our time", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02545-00548888-00549055": "allocating time thank you very much", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02546-00549056-00549231": "ashish jaris", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02547-00549232-00549566": "ilana um long and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02548-00549567-00549822": "charlie it has been an absolute pleasure", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02549-00549823-00549999": "and thank you for covering so many of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02550-00550000-00550143": "the questions", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02551-00550144-00550359": "um and thank you everyone attending or", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02552-00550360-00550447": "joining us", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02553-00550448-00550735": "and um you know introducing your", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02554-00550736-00550935": "opinions in the discussion", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02555-00550936-00551231": "and asking questions is it's just part", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02556-00551232-00551414": "of the dialogue we have to continue", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02557-00551415-00551487": "doing this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02558-00551488-00551766": "to get to a point where we're a lot", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02559-00551767-00551831": "clearer", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02560-00551832-00552087": "and and have a sense of direction both", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02561-00552088-00552135": "on the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02562-00552136-00552462": "investment side on the company side", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02563-00552463-00552735": "regulation and across the whole", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02564-00552736-00552847": "ecosystem", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02565-00552848-00553022": "it's an exercise that we will have to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02566-00553023-00553183": "continue to do", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02567-00553184-00553511": "irrespective how difficult it is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02568-00553512-00553695": "nikita do you want to say a few last", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02569-00553696-00553895": "words", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02570-00553896-00554247": "yes i i want to say the words", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02571-00554248-00554518": "of appreciation for an amazing", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02572-00554519-00554687": "moderation of the session", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02573-00554688-00554959": "i want to say thank you to all the", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02574-00554960-00555175": "speakers who", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02575-00555176-00555495": "agreed to join us today and have this", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02576-00555496-00555614": "conversation", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02577-00555615-00555895": "i want to say thank you to all of those", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02578-00555896-00555966": "who", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02579-00555967-00556191": "attended and ask their questions these", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02580-00556192-00556407": "questions are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02581-00556408-00556718": "are a fuel they are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02582-00556719-00557022": "helping us to build the structures of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02583-00557023-00557166": "our discussion", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02584-00557167-00557487": "they help us to understand where which", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02585-00557488-00557639": "other problems that are", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02586-00557640-00557855": "not addressed and specifically i want to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02587-00557856-00558031": "thank those people who were", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02588-00558032-00558239": "talking about black people involvement", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02589-00558240-00558462": "or female involvement in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02590-00558463-00558679": "algorithm development i want to add that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02591-00558680-00558807": "we don't need to only", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02592-00558808-00558991": "talk about development but also about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02593-00558992-00559183": "the data collection", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02594-00559184-00559599": "and and how we how we label this data so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02595-00559600-00559879": "one of the project that we're running in", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02596-00559880-00560022": "in open ethics", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02597-00560023-00560343": "is about uh assigning", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02598-00560344-00560662": "the metadata to those uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02599-00560663-00560991": "to to those training data sets", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02600-00560992-00561295": "so if you're interested in fighting", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02601-00561296-00561607": "uh inviting problems with with bias", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02602-00561608-00561783": "specifically racial bias", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02603-00561784-00562055": "or a gender bias or any other bias that", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02604-00562056-00562111": "is", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02605-00562112-00562327": "introduced throughout because of our", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02606-00562328-00562439": "historical", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02607-00562440-00562751": "uh ways of making decisions i want to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02608-00562752-00563039": "invite you to well first explore uh", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02609-00563040-00563199": "explore and learn a little bit about", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02610-00563200-00563383": "what we're doing it's an open", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02611-00563384-00563655": "uh source community and not a non-profit", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02612-00563656-00563743": "so", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02613-00563744-00564047": "feel free to feel free to explore and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02614-00564048-00564335": "join us the series is the educational", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02615-00564336-00564399": "piece that we're", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02616-00564400-00564703": "doing but on the back end we're building", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02617-00564704-00565039": "uh we're building a technology that we", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02618-00565040-00565103": "can open", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02619-00565104-00565422": "and allow developers give them", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02620-00565423-00565559": "something in their hands so that they", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02621-00565560-00565727": "can disclose", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02622-00565728-00566047": "uh how their apps are operating uh and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02623-00566048-00566166": "how to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02624-00566167-00566431": "uh how to and to build this bridge of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02625-00566432-00566639": "transparency between the end user", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02626-00566640-00566862": "or a consumer that will that will use", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02627-00566863-00566975": "the application", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02628-00566976-00567327": "and the company the product so uh feel", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02629-00567328-00567414": "free to join", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02630-00567415-00567718": "uh what i will do uh the next week i", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02631-00567719-00567862": "guess i'm going to upload", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02632-00567863-00568199": "uh the video from this session into our", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02633-00568200-00568510": "youtube channel so feel free to return", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02634-00568511-00568783": "to it i will ask", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02635-00568784-00568943": "all of our respected speakers and", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02636-00568944-00569095": "panelists today to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02637-00569096-00569279": "upload their presentations and maybe", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02638-00569280-00569399": "some of the resources", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02639-00569400-00569655": "into a discord so you can always join", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02640-00569656-00569822": "discord using this link", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02641-00569823-00570239": "and in in episode 5", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02642-00570240-00570462": "channel you will see you will see all", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02643-00570463-00570591": "the presentations", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02644-00570592-00570895": "you know in an hour or in a couple of", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02645-00570896-00570959": "hours", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02646-00570960-00571214": "so that's uh that's the idea big big", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02647-00571215-00571407": "thank you for all of you", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02648-00571408-00571735": "i had a i had a great learning session", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02649-00571736-00572070": "this evening and i i hope", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02650-00572071-00572327": "all of you as well please feel free to", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02651-00572328-00572422": "contact me", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02652-00572423-00572655": "either on linkedin or or send me an", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02653-00572656-00572766": "email", "TwKEtE3LAoU-02654-00572767-00573856": "open to this as well"}}, {"audio_id": "TwaayJ7a6M0", "text": {"TwaayJ7a6M0-00000-00000042-00000451": "foreign", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00001-00000451-00003682": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00002-00003683-00004711": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00003-00004712-00005416": "thank you", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00004-00005417-00006305": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00005-00006306-00006445": "[Applause]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00006-00006447-00009301": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00007-00009302-00009985": "thank you", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00008-00009986-00010929": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00009-00010930-00012071": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00010-00012072-00013532": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00011-00013533-00014058": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00012-00014059-00014277": "oh wow", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00013-00014278-00014413": "[Applause]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00014-00014415-00015430": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00015-00015431-00016663": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00016-00016664-00017819": "thank you", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00017-00017820-00019422": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00018-00019423-00020203": "very sexiest", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00019-00020204-00022225": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00020-00022226-00024387": "thank you", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00021-00024388-00026752": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00022-00026752-00027808": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00023-00027810-00030256": "foreign", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00024-00030257-00031170": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00025-00031170-00032485": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00026-00032486-00032592": "thank you", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00027-00032593-00034841": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00028-00034842-00035017": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00029-00035018-00035221": "[Applause]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00030-00035222-00036551": "[Music]", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00031-00036552-00036640": "foreign", "TwaayJ7a6M0-00032-00036641-00037232": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "TxkPC7eV7eI", "text": {"TxkPC7eV7eI-00000-00000064-00000199": "okay", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00001-00000200-00000582": "um now let's kick off the uh i am and we", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00002-00000583-00000966": "are i construction session of the um the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00003-00000967-00001374": "15th design conference so time to start", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00004-00001375-00001582": "um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00005-00001583-00001743": "special session one", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00006-00001744-00002055": "so after the opening remarks of uh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00007-00002056-00002318": "audrey tan and then that's followed by a", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00008-00002319-00002550": "cuban day style discussion", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00009-00002551-00002799": "first i would like to introduce two", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00010-00002800-00002926": "panelists", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00011-00002927-00003158": "so first panelist is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00012-00003159-00003392": "from tohoku university", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00013-00003393-00003654": "[Music]", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00014-00003655-00003854": "and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00015-00003855-00004135": "so the professor for mihiko imamura", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00016-00004136-00004391": "specialized in tsunami engineering at", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00017-00004392-00004686": "the tohoku university he's going to join", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00018-00004687-00004951": "online so please give him the big round", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00019-00004952-00005151": "of applause", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00020-00005152-00005222": "so", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00021-00005223-00005454": "the heat specialized in the fluid wave", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00022-00005455-00005647": "motion numerical computation or the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00023-00005648-00005927": "disaster science of tsunami history", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00024-00005928-00006159": "seismic wave traces investigation", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00025-00006160-00006414": "outside inside and outside the country", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00026-00006415-00006670": "and evacuation simulation are cognitive", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00027-00006672-00006942": "by psychology that analyzes the memory", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00028-00006943-00007142": "at the time of the refuge and human", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00029-00007143-00007455": "action etc and and the trackings the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00030-00007456-00007703": "researching the connection with tsunami", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00031-00007704-00007942": "disaster prevention and he's also the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00032-00007943-00008134": "foreign made advisor very pleased to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00033-00008136-00008577": "meet you thank you very much", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00034-00008578-00008887": "[Music]", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00035-00008888-00009191": "and the second panelist uh is the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00036-00009192-00009431": "professor edwin r gabria", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00037-00009432-00009542": "from", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00038-00009543-00009806": "a fire safety engineering group of the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00039-00009807-00010071": "university greenwich he's joining online", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00040-00010072-00010263": "so give him a big round of applause", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00041-00010264-00010391": "please", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00042-00010392-00010655": "professor gallia is the founder of the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00043-00010656-00010967": "fire safety engineering group fseg of", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00044-00010968-00011255": "the university of greece the uk and this", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00045-00011256-00011463": "is the place where the highly accurate", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00046-00011464-00011791": "evacuation analysis software exodus was", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00047-00011792-00012031": "developed it is also a major source of", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00048-00012032-00012270": "many prominent papers and published", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00049-00012271-00012567": "works regarding evacuation analysis", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00050-00012568-00012742": "while also", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00051-00012743-00012958": "staring numerous times in major", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00052-00012959-00013311": "companies such as bbc and avc so mr", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00053-00013312-00013694": "gallia welcome", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00054-00013695-00013943": "and the moderator", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00055-00013944-00014215": "is the mr yota ea", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00056-00014216-00014503": "please come up to the stage", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00057-00014504-00014765": "so big round of applause for him please", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00058-00014766-00014911": "[Applause]", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00059-00014912-00015199": "so um he is an enthusiastic", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00060-00015200-00015415": "architectural id journalist who", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00061-00015416-00015558": "transmits the latest news and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00062-00015559-00015799": "information on his blog to provide", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00063-00015800-00016119": "proposals or solutions using beam eye", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00064-00016119-00016350": "construction and iot to solve many", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00065-00016351-00016558": "business challenges that the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00066-00016559-00016791": "construction industry often faces such", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00067-00016792-00017007": "as the productivity growth global", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00068-00017008-00017294": "environmental protection and the um the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00069-00017295-00017494": "internationalization", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00070-00017495-00017694": "and he said he", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00071-00017695-00017927": "listened to you 24 7", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00072-00017928-00018158": "and he keeps himself so busy for", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00073-00018159-00020233": "consulting and also the lecturegiving", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00074-00020234-00020494": "[Music]", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00075-00020495-00020655": "to join us", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00076-00020656-00021083": "and i will ask her her opening", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00077-00021084-00021399": "remarks i asked her", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00078-00021400-00021494": "to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00079-00021495-00021878": "join online today please give the winner", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00080-00021879-00022397": "give her big hands", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00081-00022398-00022750": "[Music]", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00082-00022751-00022967": "is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00083-00022968-00023094": "that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00084-00023095-00023383": "playing the role in the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00085-00023384-00023599": "the taiwan national development", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00086-00023600-00023727": "commission", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00087-00023728-00023847": "and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00088-00023848-00024230": "in private area uh in apple company he", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00089-00024231-00024830": "he she was recognizing consultant", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00090-00024831-00025014": "and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00091-00025015-00025327": "and social with social attacks", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00092-00025328-00025799": "he she is working in as the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00093-00025800-00025958": "colloquium", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00094-00025960-00026270": "remember", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00095-00026272-00026414": "the award", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00096-00026416-00027031": "is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00097-00027032-00027167": "he is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00098-00027168-00027335": "focusing on", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00099-00027336-00027679": "the government zero that's a social", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00100-00027680-00028083": "uh realizing a creation to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00101-00028083-00028607": "mr minister tan would you please join us", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00102-00028608-00028718": "good luck", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00103-00028719-00028990": "everyone this is audrey taiwan's digital", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00104-00028991-00029223": "minister in charge of social innovation", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00105-00029224-00029551": "it is my great pleasure and honor to be", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00106-00029552-00029807": "here virtually and share some thoughts", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00107-00029808-00029967": "with you about taiwan's digital", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00108-00029968-00030095": "democracy", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00109-00030095-00030335": "but first as digital minister of taiwan", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00110-00030336-00030518": "i suppose it makes sense for me to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00111-00030519-00030679": "travel digitally", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00112-00030680-00030895": "across the time zone and talk to you", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00113-00030895-00031046": "however i believe", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00114-00031047-00031207": "many of you would also agree when i say", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00115-00031208-00031446": "it is a pity that pam dami made it", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00116-00031447-00031727": "difficult for me to join you in person", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00117-00031727-00031951": "because i remember at the time before", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00118-00031952-00032207": "the pandemic when i traveled to tokyo", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00119-00032208-00032462": "kyoto and many beautiful cities before", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00120-00032463-00032702": "the pandemic i had the opportunity to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00121-00032703-00032911": "have face-to-face discussions with so", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00122-00032912-00033190": "many top-notch experts and scholars and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00123-00033191-00033383": "shook hands which is a pre-pandemic", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00124-00033384-00033471": "thing", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00125-00033472-00033702": "with friends from all over the world and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00126-00033703-00033943": "so as the covenanting pandemic through", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00127-00033944-00034174": "the world off balance and broad drastic", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00128-00034175-00034502": "changes we've seen symptoms around many", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00129-00034503-00034767": "parts of the world of democracy and the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00130-00034768-00035023": "trust and democracy in backslide some", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00131-00035024-00035223": "authoritarian regimes have tried to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00132-00035224-00035462": "justify measures of state restrictions", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00133-00035463-00035695": "in the name of public health", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00134-00035696-00035895": "and of course there is never an easy way", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00135-00035896-00036151": "to tackle emerging disasters and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00136-00036152-00036471": "challenges but i see opportunities arise", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00137-00036472-00036727": "among the biggest global crisis of our", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00138-00036728-00036951": "time so when we are faced with this", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00139-00036952-00037230": "shared challenge in taiwan in particular", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00140-00037231-00037495": "i see digital social innovation continue", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00141-00037496-00037823": "to accelerate democracy and deepen the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00142-00037824-00038062": "collaboration across sectors", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00143-00038063-00038151": "and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00144-00038152-00038399": "so how do we start to bring ourselves to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00145-00038400-00038679": "work with the people not just for the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00146-00038680-00038935": "people well for me the answer is really", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00147-00038936-00039327": "simple is to trust our citizens because", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00148-00039328-00039687": "to give no trust is to get no trust and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00149-00039688-00039927": "that is why in taiwan we have dedicated", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00150-00039928-00040207": "ourselves to bring technology into the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00151-00040208-00040487": "spaces where citizens are rather than", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00152-00040488-00040751": "expect citizens to adapt to the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00153-00040752-00041062": "creations of the technologists", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00154-00041063-00041415": "our contact tracing system 1922 sms is a", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00155-00041416-00041735": "case in point is a solution proposed not", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00156-00041736-00041935": "by the government by the civic tech", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00157-00041936-00042318": "community g0v gap zero to ensure both", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00158-00042319-00042567": "privacy protection and efficient contact", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00159-00042568-00042823": "tracing when we face our real first and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00160-00042824-00043127": "only wave in may which is you know gone", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00161-00043128-00043327": "now in the past couple months we've had", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00162-00043328-00043623": "zero confirmed cases uh essentially but", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00163-00043624-00043846": "in may the governor community the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00164-00043847-00044007": "decentralized group of civic", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00165-00044008-00044335": "technologists swung into action and they", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00166-00044336-00044535": "enthusiastically discussed how to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00167-00044536-00044807": "improve existing registration systems", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00168-00044808-00045071": "and inspired by their discussions uh we", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00169-00045072-00045311": "did not use any app at all you just use", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00170-00045312-00045558": "your built-in smartphone camera to scan", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00171-00045559-00045790": "the qr code it sends a text message to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00172-00045791-00046087": "toll-free number 1922 and the check-in", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00173-00046088-00046318": "records a quarter billion has been sent", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00174-00046319-00046599": "so far are created and stored with no", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00175-00046600-00046871": "need again of an app download and only", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00176-00046872-00047118": "when necessary do the contact tracers", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00177-00047119-00047343": "retrieve the data piece together the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00178-00047344-00047639": "puzzle of the multiple security stored", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00179-00047640-00047958": "and privacy preserving pieces into", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00180-00047959-00048199": "effective contact tracing so we reduce", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00181-00048200-00048495": "the time it takes for an average case", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00182-00048496-00048823": "of more than 24 hours into less than 24", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00183-00048824-00049055": "minutes and the system was deployed to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00184-00049056-00049327": "millions of venues within just three", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00185-00049328-00049551": "days and this would not be possible", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00186-00049552-00049830": "without a robust partnership between the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00187-00049831-00050118": "social sector the public sector and the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00188-00050119-00050255": "private sector", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00189-00050256-00050439": "and when we talk about private sector i", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00190-00050440-00050639": "want to especially thank the line", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00191-00050640-00050886": "corporation from japan for agreeing to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00192-00050887-00051118": "use to change their codes to use the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00193-00051119-00051326": "main qr code scanner of adding law in", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00194-00051327-00051679": "france uh to contribute to 192 sms which", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00195-00051679-00051982": "doubtlessly contribute to the popularity", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00196-00051983-00052238": "so um to to conclude i think the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00197-00052239-00052511": "masquerading map the vaccine reservation", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00198-00052512-00052726": "system and the contact tracing system", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00199-00052727-00052959": "that i introduced is just some of the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00200-00052960-00053166": "ideas that we can learn", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00201-00053167-00053415": "by trusting the citizens much like how", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00202-00053416-00053638": "the tip of taiwan the ushan jade", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00203-00053639-00053966": "mountain raises two or three centimeters", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00204-00053967-00054166": "each year because precisely of", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00205-00054167-00054407": "earthquakes from the clashing tectonic", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00206-00054408-00054694": "plates if we have a resilient democratic", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00207-00054695-00054959": "infrastructure to invite innovations", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00208-00054960-00055150": "from completely different ends of the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00209-00055151-00055350": "spectrum from the social sector", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00210-00055351-00055607": "charities social innovators but also", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00211-00055608-00055863": "large corporations companies and so on", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00212-00055864-00056094": "then when we come to the same virtual", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00213-00056095-00056438": "table to discuss we can also co-create", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00214-00056439-00056766": "our way through resilience to a better", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00215-00056767-00057079": "digitally enabled social infrastructure", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00216-00057079-00057247": "and that's my opening remark thank you", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00217-00057248-00059759": "for listening", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00218-00059760-00059911": "end of switch", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00219-00059912-00060063": "yes", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00220-00060064-00060479": "thank you very much", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00221-00060479-00060726": "thank you very much", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00222-00060727-00061054": "we have welcomed", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00223-00061055-00061311": "minister audrey who is very busy", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00224-00061312-00061566": "and it was a very valuable time shared", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00225-00061567-00061726": "with us thank you very much we", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00226-00061727-00062111": "appreciate it so much thank you", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00227-00062112-00062391": "and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00228-00062391-00062647": "mr audrey is very busy and don't have", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00229-00062648-00062759": "time to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00230-00062760-00063182": "sleep how many hours do you sleep a day", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00231-00063183-00063535": "eight hours always more than eight hours", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00232-00063536-00063854": "if i get very busy that is to say if i", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00233-00063855-00064175": "have to think uh beyond the existing", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00234-00064176-00064415": "positions of which there are many then i", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00235-00064416-00064742": "work overtime i sleep for 9 hours or 10", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00236-00064744-00064911": "hours at most", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00237-00064912-00065230": "because i really do the creative work in", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00238-00065232-00065375": "my sleep", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00239-00065376-00065655": "and which is why i believe that the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00240-00065656-00066006": "resilience also of the our internal", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00241-00066007-00066263": "mindset of accepting that better", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00242-00066264-00066559": "solutions exist of overcoming the not", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00243-00066560-00066855": "invented here syndrome rests in", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00244-00066856-00067135": "sufficient rest because if we do not", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00245-00067136-00067367": "have sufficient sleep ample sleep then", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00246-00067368-00067638": "we tend to continue whatever habits of", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00247-00067639-00067919": "solution that we were used to business", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00248-00067920-00068047": "as usual", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00249-00068048-00068279": "in the previous day but when i have", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00250-00068280-00068519": "sufficient amount of sleep i always", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00251-00068520-00068623": "wake up", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00252-00068624-00068887": "with some new ideas that's incorporated", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00253-00068888-00069182": "by listening attentively to various", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00254-00069183-00069350": "other people across various other", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00255-00069351-00069606": "sectors in the previous day so i often", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00256-00069607-00069806": "say that sleep is the time that i", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00257-00069807-00070038": "actually do my work", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00258-00070039-00070279": "and so just a um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00259-00070280-00070655": "procedural uh feedback um i i cut the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00260-00070656-00070879": "opening remark short not because i have", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00261-00070880-00071126": "to run i have nothing for the next hour", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00262-00071127-00071382": "but because i want to focus more on the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00263-00071383-00071599": "real-time question analysis answers", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00264-00071600-00072423": "and in the panel and with the panel", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00265-00072424-00072759": "thank you very much", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00266-00072760-00073038": "we can sleep more than eight hours it is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00267-00073039-00073319": "very surprising that you can sleep", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00268-00073320-00073575": "you are expert in time management i", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00269-00073576-00073806": "guess", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00270-00073807-00074294": "now get into the topic of today", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00271-00074295-00074550": "today we welcome each panelists and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00272-00074551-00074999": "raised six topics to cover today", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00273-00075000-00075182": "and two each", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00274-00075183-00075303": "uh they're", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00275-00075304-00075687": "relative topics uh to each", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00276-00075688-00076031": "topic first number two is at the time of", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00277-00076032-00076311": "disaster like tsunami", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00278-00076312-00076567": "how the government should deal with it", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00279-00076568-00076879": "and respond to it and prepare for it", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00280-00076880-00077335": "uh looking back the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00281-00077336-00077575": "looking back the past experience we'd", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00282-00077576-00077862": "like to talk about it", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00283-00077863-00078175": "with each other with uh dr imamura and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00284-00078176-00078582": "dr garia", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00285-00078583-00078806": "introducing uh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00286-00078807-00079062": "research results of each gentleman i", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00287-00079063-00079319": "would like to have a comment from", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00288-00079320-00079623": "mr audrey on those two gentlemen's", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00289-00079624-00081294": "results first imam murasan", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00290-00081295-00082671": "dr imamura's voice", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00291-00082672-00083182": "this the microphone on teams", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00292-00083183-00083399": "to hear you hey", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00293-00083400-00083911": "you're me", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00294-00083912-00086806": "thank you", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00295-00086807-00087326": "going forward", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00296-00087327-00087582": "today we'd like to talk about these", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00297-00087583-00087918": "important issues together", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00298-00087919-00088620": "let me share the document", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00299-00088621-00089406": "[Music]", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00300-00089407-00089963": "images", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00301-00089964-00092518": "[Music]", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00302-00092519-00092918": "high tidal white tsunami wave happened", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00303-00092919-00093015": "and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00304-00093016-00093174": "in the coastal", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00305-00093175-00093606": "area there came a very big stream", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00306-00093607-00093735": "in the past", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00307-00093736-00094279": "this area had a big tsunami", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00308-00094280-00094518": "and there's a protective", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00309-00094519-00094862": "bank that was perpetrating bank", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00310-00094863-00095167": "but it was totally broken", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00311-00095168-00095282": "so big", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00312-00095283-00095615": "disaster it was brought", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00313-00095616-00095950": "in order to protect the lives of people", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00314-00095951-00096455": "from tsunami there's a warning system", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00315-00096456-00096735": "japan has 60 years of the history of a", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00316-00096736-00097023": "tsunami warning system", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00317-00097024-00097335": "when earthquake happens within one", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00318-00097336-00097662": "minute we give out a warning", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00319-00097663-00097911": "with what magnitude what level of", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00320-00097912-00098223": "magnitude and locations it happened if", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00321-00098224-00098455": "it's in the sea", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00322-00098456-00098735": "due to the seven or higher", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00323-00098736-00099103": "then there is a chance of tsunami", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00324-00099104-00099374": "so tsunami switch quickly to tsunami", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00325-00099375-00099647": "warning and in 33 minutes", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00326-00099648-00099991": "it ends the warning ends", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00327-00099992-00100167": "so within three minutes information", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00328-00100168-00100487": "comes so 2011", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00329-00100488-00100567": "yet", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00330-00100568-00100918": "information came on at that day", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00331-00100919-00101215": "on the left is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00332-00101216-00101479": "14 49", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00333-00101480-00101711": "three minutes after the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00334-00101712-00101838": "outbreak", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00335-00101839-00102150": "the first morning came in miyagi six", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00336-00102151-00102318": "meters", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00337-00102319-00102470": "fukushima 3 meters", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00338-00102471-00102606": "[Music]", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00339-00102607-00102815": "but actually", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00340-00102816-00103094": "went up to 30 meters", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00341-00103095-00103382": "why this has so much", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00342-00103383-00103630": "gap that first", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00343-00103631-00103894": "came the underestimation", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00344-00103895-00104182": "within one minute the magnitude was", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00345-00104183-00104271": "seven", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00346-00104272-00104566": "but in reality", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00347-00104567-00104686": "nine", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00348-00104688-00104782": "hundred", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00349-00104783-00105063": "it was underestimated by a hundred times", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00350-00105064-00105343": "in terms of energy so unfortunately the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00351-00105344-00105734": "forecast was not good enough", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00352-00105735-00105910": "but in this", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00353-00105911-00106166": "area as is on the right bottom there's", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00354-00106167-00106631": "uh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00355-00106632-00106943": "there's a gps sensor attached in the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00356-00106944-00107239": "location and catch the tsunami", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00357-00107240-00107575": "the first wave came around three o'clock", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00358-00107576-00107831": "and with the height of six meters", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00359-00107832-00108327": "but the off coast offshore is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00360-00108328-00108631": "this much but as it gets closer it gets", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00361-00108632-00108854": "higher", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00362-00108855-00109071": "so it already passed", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00363-00109072-00109263": "18 meters", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00364-00109264-00109534": "so as a result at the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00365-00109535-00109783": "1514", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00366-00109783-00110151": "came up to six meters", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00367-00110152-00110319": "six meters", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00368-00110320-00110583": "and the information updated", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00369-00110583-00110878": "the information has become updated", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00370-00110879-00111207": "as time goes then the accuracy was good", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00371-00111208-00111295": "but", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00372-00111296-00111543": "at that time the first wave of tsunami", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00373-00111544-00111702": "already came", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00374-00111703-00111831": "arrived", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00375-00111832-00112263": "so it was too late to evacuate", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00376-00112264-00112495": "so what it means what it", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00377-00112496-00112766": "tells us is that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00378-00112767-00112966": "immediate the information immediately", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00379-00112967-00113278": "after the break is difficult to obtain", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00380-00113279-00113463": "and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00381-00113464-00113543": "so", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00382-00113544-00113766": "quick information", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00383-00113767-00113966": "need to be captured", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00384-00113967-00114054": "and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00385-00114055-00114343": "as we analyze more and more the accuracy", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00386-00114344-00114486": "becomes", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00387-00114488-00114902": "better but as time passes the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00388-00114903-00115190": "it is very difficult to evacuate so", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00389-00115191-00115502": "there's comes a trade-off", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00390-00115503-00115766": "so we have to understand the reality", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00391-00115767-00116054": "very clearly", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00392-00116055-00116127": "but", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00393-00116128-00116358": "and have come have to come up with the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00394-00116359-00116566": "counter measures like this that was a", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00395-00116567-00116847": "big lesson learned", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00396-00116848-00116927": "so", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00397-00116928-00117078": "in order to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00398-00117079-00117334": "i would like you to understand the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00399-00117335-00117551": "situation", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00400-00117552-00117895": "that was", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00401-00117896-00118151": "all from my side", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00402-00118152-00118366": "first topic", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00403-00118367-00118583": "next we'd like to welcome", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00404-00118583-00119063": "mr garria", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00405-00119064-00119519": "please", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00406-00119520-00119719": "so professor galway", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00407-00119720-00119910": "thank you very much and it's a great", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00408-00119911-00120078": "pleasure to be here i only wish i could", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00409-00120079-00120383": "be in tokyo with you in person", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00410-00120383-00120590": "as tokyo is one of my favorite places in", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00411-00120591-00120783": "the world and um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00412-00120783-00121158": "the the people and friends from 408", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00413-00121159-00121310": "are very dear to me so i wish i was", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00414-00121311-00121510": "there with you but", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00415-00121511-00121710": "technology allows us to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00416-00121711-00121910": "communicate in this way which is i think", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00417-00121911-00122134": "very useful and i was very impressed", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00418-00122135-00122278": "with audrey tang", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00419-00122279-00122510": "understanding that she gets eight hours", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00420-00122511-00122734": "sleep and does the most creative", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00421-00122735-00122966": "thinking in the sleep that's fantastic", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00422-00122967-00123271": "uh right now it's um 1 30 in the morning", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00423-00123272-00123502": "here in london and so i'm suffering from", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00424-00123503-00123647": "lack of sleep", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00425-00123648-00123839": "so maybe my brain is a little bit slow", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00426-00123840-00124095": "and not as creative as it should be", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00427-00124096-00124166": "but", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00428-00124167-00124454": "it was very interesting uh presentation", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00429-00124455-00124758": "and i think when we're talking about", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00430-00124759-00124927": "natural disasters or in fact any", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00431-00124928-00125086": "disaster", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00432-00125088-00125502": "i like to keep in mind a a proverb a", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00433-00125503-00125743": "very wise proverb", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00434-00125744-00125823": "that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00435-00125824-00125919": "chance", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00436-00125920-00126166": "favors the prepared mind", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00437-00126167-00126366": "and so", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00438-00126367-00126751": "the way we enhance our resilience to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00439-00126752-00127023": "natural disasters is through", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00440-00127024-00127263": "planning robust planning", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00441-00127264-00127351": "and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00442-00127352-00127519": "and as part of that planning that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00443-00127520-00127758": "includes the education and training", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00444-00127759-00127983": "of the population", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00445-00127983-00128086": "and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00446-00128088-00128254": "through the planning", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00447-00128255-00128575": "we have to take into consideration um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00448-00128576-00128758": "or we can", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00449-00128759-00129231": "use simulation to uh to help us create", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00450-00129232-00129471": "robust plans", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00451-00129472-00129639": "but it's very important to also", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00452-00129640-00129790": "understand and this is something that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00453-00129791-00130102": "often engineers and technologists", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00454-00130103-00130223": "often", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00455-00130224-00130599": "overlook and forget is that the public", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00456-00130600-00130902": "does not necessarily respond the way the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00457-00130903-00131047": "engineer", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00458-00131048-00131247": "or the technologist or the government", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00459-00131248-00131359": "official", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00460-00131360-00131478": "would like", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00461-00131479-00131743": "and so we have to understand the human", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00462-00131744-00131839": "dimension", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00463-00131840-00132151": "and the way humans are likely to respond", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00464-00132152-00132447": "to these natural disasters", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00465-00132448-00132639": "if our plans are going to be", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00466-00132640-00133014": "sufficiently robust uh to accommodate", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00467-00133015-00133295": "these sorts of um these sorts of issues", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00468-00133296-00133511": "so this is where a lot of my work comes", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00469-00133512-00133887": "in understanding the psychology of um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00470-00133888-00134199": "human response in disaster situations", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00471-00134200-00134407": "and understanding um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00472-00134408-00134487": "uh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00473-00134488-00134711": "the nature of the behavioral response", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00474-00134712-00134966": "and how we can include that in our", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00475-00134967-00135183": "planning and simulation", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00476-00135184-00136566": "so i think that's a that's key", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00477-00136567-00137407": "thank you", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00478-00137408-00137647": "well i think is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00479-00137648-00137990": "that those disasters so we never uh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00480-00137991-00138295": "anticipated when that happens", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00481-00138296-00138527": "so", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00482-00138528-00138775": "it's just like a trade-off for", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00483-00138776-00139095": "issue we have no time to think about so", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00484-00139096-00139390": "we have to be prepared", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00485-00139391-00139751": "mentally it's very important and one", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00486-00139752-00139935": "more point is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00487-00139936-00140214": "now everything doesn't go like we", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00488-00140215-00140311": "thought", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00489-00140312-00140495": "so for this uh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00490-00140496-00140695": "coveted 19", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00491-00140696-00141143": "pandemic exam 2 it started last year", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00492-00141144-00141478": "and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00493-00141479-00141695": "in japan the mask", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00494-00141696-00141783": "is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00495-00141784-00142102": "very popular so everyone purchased those", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00496-00142103-00142199": "masks", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00497-00142200-00142502": "in japan we are trying to provide those", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00498-00142503-00142926": "masks", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00499-00142927-00143183": "and that's the same on", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00500-00143184-00143607": "mr orderly too you are actively", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00501-00143608-00143895": "participating that and you are", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00502-00143896-00143990": "doing", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00503-00143991-00144199": "very well so would you please give me", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00504-00144200-00144399": "your idea", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00505-00144400-00144535": "how to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00506-00144536-00144926": "protect them", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00507-00144927-00145071": "yes", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00508-00145072-00145423": "the mass creation map of course", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00509-00145424-00145719": "is well known in japan is based on what", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00510-00145720-00146039": "we call a public infrastructure in the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00511-00146040-00146239": "digital realm or digital public", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00512-00146240-00146383": "infrastructure", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00513-00146384-00146623": "that already was built before the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00514-00146624-00146902": "pandemic based on the air quality", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00515-00146903-00147143": "measurements from the middle schools", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00516-00147144-00147366": "primary schools and so on into a", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00517-00147367-00147599": "distributed ledger maintained by our", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00518-00147600-00147823": "national academy and held by our", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00519-00147824-00147966": "national center of high-speed", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00520-00147967-00148239": "computation and it's part of our", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00521-00148240-00148519": "educational effort so that the students", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00522-00148520-00148726": "are not just learning about media", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00523-00148727-00149054": "literacy or data literacy but rather", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00524-00149055-00149375": "media and digital competence", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00525-00149376-00149583": "literacy is when we just consume", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00526-00149584-00149871": "information competence is when we remix", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00527-00149872-00150175": "and make information for the public good", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00528-00150176-00150407": "so the primary schoolers that measures", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00529-00150408-00150751": "air quality like two pm 2.5 in their", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00530-00150752-00151014": "school yard or back at home with open", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00531-00151015-00151295": "hardware in their balcony all contribute", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00532-00151296-00151559": "to for example their neighbors and their", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00533-00151560-00151790": "family members before they go to jog", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00534-00151791-00151999": "will actually check the air quality", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00535-00152000-00152254": "level before they go and that data came", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00536-00152255-00152471": "from the student curated", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00537-00152472-00152871": "data steward device the air box and the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00538-00152872-00153078": "civo iot", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00539-00153079-00153383": "system that uh the air box is one part", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00540-00153384-00153671": "of provides the kind of trust-based", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00541-00153672-00153951": "infrastructure so people can write to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00542-00153952-00154214": "this distributed ledger while not", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00543-00154215-00154439": "worrying about the cyber security that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00544-00154440-00154719": "this information the trolls and so on", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00545-00154720-00155039": "dutch pollutes more anti-social corners", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00546-00155040-00155311": "of social media and it's thanks to this", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00547-00155312-00155583": "mutual accountability mechanism can we", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00548-00155584-00155919": "build the masquerading map in just three", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00549-00155920-00156214": "days again from the help of zero people", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00550-00156215-00156535": "as well as also extend that for example", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00551-00156536-00156854": "to the earthquake monitoring system that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00552-00156855-00157095": "has this hybrid platform on the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00553-00157096-00157366": "simulation rooms but also again in the k", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00554-00157367-00157671": "to 12 school campuses um science parks", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00555-00157672-00157887": "firefighting departments kindergartens", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00556-00157888-00158159": "and so on so that people can not just", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00557-00158160-00158335": "participate in the drills but also", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00558-00158336-00158447": "participate", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00559-00158448-00158711": "in how to get those warnings and reduce", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00560-00158712-00158943": "the time it takes from earthquake being", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00561-00158944-00159247": "detected to actual evacuation", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00562-00159248-00159390": "instructions", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00563-00159391-00159575": "with the people not just from the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00564-00159576-00159814": "government designing for the people and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00565-00159815-00160031": "it was really successful", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00566-00160032-00160302": "in just a few years like four years time", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00567-00160303-00160663": "of the civil iot we have uh reduced uh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00568-00160664-00160911": "the warning alerts through this hybrid", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00569-00160912-00161159": "fashion previously is close to 20", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00570-00161160-00161454": "seconds and now it's issued in less than", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00571-00161455-00161814": "10 seconds after the shaking is detected", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00572-00161815-00162502": "thanks to this hybrid collaboration", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00573-00162503-00162711": "all right so that's uh end of my remark", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00574-00162712-00162878": "thank you i understand now i have to say", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00575-00162879-00163463": "it thank you", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00576-00163464-00163695": "so as you just mentioned", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00577-00163696-00163883": "believe trust in", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00578-00163884-00164038": "infrastructure", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00579-00164039-00164319": "you just said four years ago there came", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00580-00164320-00164599": "a warning system so as a result the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00581-00164600-00164759": "people", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00582-00164760-00165143": "could evacuate smoothly move smoothly", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00583-00165144-00165287": "because of that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00584-00165288-00165495": "dr imamura", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00585-00165496-00165838": "this is related to topic three and four", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00586-00165839-00166183": "in order for even one more people to be", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00587-00166184-00166399": "able to evacuate it", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00588-00166400-00166559": "and be safe", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00589-00166560-00166790": "what can we do", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00590-00166791-00167135": "people what should be prepared and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00591-00167136-00167335": "trustworthy infrastructure should be", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00592-00167336-00167478": "built as well", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00593-00167479-00167743": "from your past experience of the tsunami", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00594-00167744-00167911": "what should", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00595-00167912-00168014": "japan", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00596-00168015-00168311": "do or japan is doing could you tell us", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00597-00168312-00168607": "some examples experience", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00598-00168608-00168951": "thank you very much", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00599-00168952-00169126": "can you hear me", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00600-00169127-00169343": "yes", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00601-00169344-00170151": "okay good thank you", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00602-00170152-00170638": "in order to cope with the disaster", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00603-00170639-00170799": "incident", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00604-00170800-00171071": "well in advance", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00605-00171072-00171343": "we need preparation", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00606-00171344-00171583": "like education", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00607-00171584-00172702": "meaning that to the children", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00608-00172703-00172871": "and so education", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00609-00172872-00173207": "is very important", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00610-00173208-00173438": "so i'd like to introduce education", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00611-00173439-00173590": "system", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00612-00173591-00173831": "in japan", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00613-00173832-00173943": "that is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00614-00173944-00174183": "evacuation", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00615-00174184-00174454": "so here it's", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00616-00174455-00174711": "led by students", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00617-00174712-00174990": "that elementary school students", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00618-00174991-00175159": "actually", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00619-00175160-00175614": "when the warning happened", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00620-00175615-00175814": "elementary school students", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00621-00175815-00176014": "themselves led", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00622-00176015-00176214": "the group", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00623-00176215-00176414": "and supported", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00624-00176415-00176814": "by themselves amongst themselves", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00625-00176815-00177031": "at the time of earthquake", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00626-00177032-00177375": "and tsunami", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00627-00177376-00177614": "so learn about the past history of", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00628-00177615-00177935": "tsunami and do the drill", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00629-00177936-00178102": "in doing the drill", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00630-00178103-00178183": "and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00631-00178184-00178647": "ran up to the high place and was", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00632-00178648-00178783": "safe", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00633-00178784-00178871": "so", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00634-00178872-00179071": "there's", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00635-00179072-00179278": "even a designated place had a big", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00636-00179279-00179487": "tsunami", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00637-00179488-00179654": "but", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00638-00179655-00179783": "with the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00639-00179784-00179919": "gathering", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00640-00179920-00180087": "[Music]", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00641-00180088-00180478": "and second tsunami also came", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00642-00180479-00180583": "so", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00643-00180584-00180814": "understand", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00644-00180815-00181095": "the students understood the information", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00645-00181096-00181319": "in a correct manner", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00646-00181320-00181551": "at that time though we have a lot of", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00647-00181552-00181766": "casualties", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00648-00181767-00181878": "but", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00649-00181879-00182175": "students themselves", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00650-00182176-00182383": "the group to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00651-00182384-00182614": "help them evacuate", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00652-00182615-00183038": "so it was a very good example in japan", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00653-00183039-00183375": "thank you very much", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00654-00183376-00183471": "that is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00655-00183472-00183647": "disaster education", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00656-00183648-00183975": "to the children saved the adults because", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00657-00183976-00184287": "of so many experience in that area", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00658-00184288-00184678": "so by teaching students we could avoid", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00659-00184679-00184883": "the disaster", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00660-00184884-00185214": "so all reason in taiwan", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00661-00185215-00185407": "how about the education in taiwan to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00662-00185408-00185831": "school students", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00663-00185832-00186087": "data competence is something that's", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00664-00186088-00186414": "almost impossible to teach but very easy", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00665-00186415-00186535": "to learn", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00666-00186536-00186838": "once you operate one of those air boxes", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00667-00186839-00187119": "and so on and the community have also", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00668-00187120-00187438": "moved on to water boxes which measures", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00669-00187439-00187671": "the water pollution level and link it to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00670-00187672-00187966": "the agricultural studies so that people", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00671-00187967-00188214": "can understand the water that they're", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00672-00188215-00188471": "drinking how exactly did they flow and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00673-00188472-00188750": "learn important points about conserving", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00674-00188751-00188887": "not just", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00675-00188888-00189102": "everyday water resources but also", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00676-00189103-00189383": "actively inventing uh in the water", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00677-00189384-00189814": "system and so on again this um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00678-00189815-00190071": "this idea of making a collaborative", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00679-00190072-00190350": "ledger of the environment around us is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00680-00190351-00190678": "preparing our students for a even more", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00681-00190679-00190919": "complex system like greenhouse gas", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00682-00190920-00191183": "accounting which is very important if we", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00683-00191184-00191478": "are to plant the carbon sinks the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00684-00191479-00191743": "planting areas together and maintain", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00685-00191744-00191999": "them as a community so it's like the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00686-00192000-00192263": "training wheels that people can", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00687-00192264-00192502": "in their primary school first learn", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00688-00192503-00192590": "about", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00689-00192591-00192838": "air quality water quality and so on and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00690-00192839-00193063": "then gradually about the complex", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00691-00193064-00193343": "interplay with the atmospheric and other", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00692-00193344-00193623": "environmental systems i want to also", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00693-00193624-00193895": "highlight that's the participatory", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00694-00193896-00194078": "nature of it", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00695-00194079-00194271": "there's a popular app", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00696-00194272-00194623": "inspired actually by a japanese", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00697-00194624-00194783": "invention i believe it's called mai", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00698-00194784-00195038": "mitsu uh which shows their drinking", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00699-00195039-00195311": "fountains uh near the school uh but in", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00700-00195312-00195590": "taiwan the civic technologists extended", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00701-00195591-00195902": "that into a pokemon go-like game where", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00702-00195903-00196143": "children can collect coins", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00703-00196144-00196407": "for checking in to learn about the local", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00704-00196408-00196647": "histories and local environments just", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00705-00196648-00196887": "like pokemon go by bringing their", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00706-00196888-00197150": "bottles and refill at those fountains", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00707-00197151-00197335": "and it also pushes", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00708-00197336-00197631": "the notifications whenever they detect", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00709-00197632-00197935": "that their uh local heat", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00710-00197936-00198278": "damage may occur out of the wind and the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00711-00198279-00198599": "sun's angle and so on so that people can", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00712-00198600-00198887": "learn to evacuate a little bit from the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00713-00198888-00199175": "heat and and drinking plenty of water so", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00714-00199176-00199502": "none of this is particularly disastrous", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00715-00199503-00199790": "but making this a coordinated action and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00716-00199791-00200063": "notification contribution a habit in a", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00717-00200064-00200335": "participatory way prepares us for the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00718-00200336-00200702": "larger disasters in the future", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00719-00200703-00200935": "thank you", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00720-00200936-00201047": "i said that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00721-00201048-00201343": "remark", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00722-00201344-00201559": "with the participatory type of", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00723-00201560-00201863": "application teaches you right", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00724-00201864-00202135": "well i was impressed by listening to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00725-00202136-00202302": "your experience", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00726-00202303-00202471": "by enjoying", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00727-00202472-00202678": "kids can learn", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00728-00202679-00203095": "how about mr gadia professor garia", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00729-00203096-00203390": "uh in the yeah earlier i i'd like to ask", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00730-00203391-00203463": "you", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00731-00203464-00203871": "about the there's some", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00732-00203872-00204159": "at the time of uh fire disaster", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00733-00204160-00204390": "uh you have the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00734-00204391-00204726": "experience in that evacuation from your", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00735-00204727-00204951": "past experience", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00736-00204952-00205103": "countermeasures", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00737-00205104-00205327": "and preparation", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00738-00205328-00205566": "and what is the point that you're", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00739-00205567-00205798": "focusing on and what is improving in", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00740-00205800-00205934": "your study", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00741-00205935-00206327": "in those areas", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00742-00206328-00206406": "well", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00743-00206407-00206558": "i mean there's", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00744-00206559-00206727": "let me let me jump back a little bit", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00745-00206728-00206919": "before i address that questions i think", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00746-00206919-00207071": "there's a lot of interesting discussion", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00747-00207071-00207262": "just uh just now and i want to go back", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00748-00207263-00207510": "to a couple of things and some of this", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00749-00207511-00207855": "i'll be bringing up in my talk later on", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00750-00207856-00207942": "but", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00751-00207944-00208206": "the issue of mask wearing for example", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00752-00208207-00208414": "really very important and a very simple", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00753-00208415-00208551": "mitigation", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00754-00208552-00208790": "process that can be very very effective", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00755-00208791-00208966": "but in the west", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00756-00208967-00209255": "we really made a mess of mask wearing", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00757-00209256-00209446": "and i think this is one of the reasons", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00758-00209448-00209671": "we had such a high death rate from", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00759-00209671-00209975": "covert at least early in the pandemic", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00760-00209976-00210255": "and the problem was that um uh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00761-00210256-00210534": "the the messaging from the government", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00762-00210535-00210831": "from from the from our political leaders", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00763-00210832-00211079": "and their scientific advisers", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00764-00211080-00211415": "uh was that mask wearing was actually", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00765-00211416-00211710": "useless pointless and in fact the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00766-00211711-00211910": "messaging was that basque wearing is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00767-00211911-00212263": "actually counterproductive and dangerous", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00768-00212264-00212558": "and this was this was in the face", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00769-00212559-00212927": "of the evidence before our very eyes", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00770-00212928-00213255": "of what was happening in taiwan in japan", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00771-00213256-00213510": "and in korea where people were wearing", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00772-00213511-00213703": "masks and it was proving very very", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00773-00213704-00213815": "effective", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00774-00213816-00214006": "and then and then this led to and then", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00775-00214007-00214231": "when the government changed their mind", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00776-00214232-00214606": "and started to recommend mask wearing", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00777-00214607-00215031": "um we then had the fake news um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00778-00215032-00215319": "uh uh phenomena where people were", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00779-00215319-00215510": "starting to write and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00780-00215511-00215887": "uh um you know that uh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00781-00215888-00216119": "masks uh are bad don't wear them the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00782-00216119-00216279": "government said first they were bad now", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00783-00216280-00216431": "they're saying they're good we can't", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00784-00216432-00216663": "trust the government so the messaging", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00785-00216664-00216815": "becomes very very important and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00786-00216816-00216934": "understanding", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00787-00216935-00217191": "uh the evidence base becomes very very", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00788-00217192-00217367": "important and really government should", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00789-00217367-00217567": "and government advisors should really", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00790-00217567-00217823": "take into account the evidence base not", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00791-00217823-00218134": "just from your local experts but be", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00792-00218135-00218446": "prepared to look beyond your borders", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00793-00218448-00218598": "look what your neighbors are doing look", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00794-00218600-00218775": "what other citizens around the world are", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00795-00218776-00218982": "doing what's the experience what can we", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00796-00218983-00219182": "learn from all these other cultures and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00797-00219183-00219471": "societies uh that have faced", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00798-00219471-00219567": "uh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00799-00219567-00219798": "not only the the current crisis but", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00800-00219800-00219998": "similar crises in the past that we", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00801-00220000-00220191": "should be learning from so this is very", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00802-00220192-00220310": "very important i think and it's", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00803-00220311-00220431": "something that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00804-00220432-00220567": "certainly western governments and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00805-00220567-00220751": "certainly the government in the uk", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00806-00220752-00221046": "and in the united states failed dismally", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00807-00221048-00221463": "uh in the early parts of the pandemic", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00808-00221464-00221598": "um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00809-00221600-00221694": "the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00810-00221696-00221855": "the other point that was interesting is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00811-00221856-00222198": "the uh point about alarms and having uh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00812-00222200-00222391": "that this is something that we have in", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00813-00222392-00222510": "in the fire", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00814-00222511-00222823": "safety uh arena is having an alarm but", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00815-00222823-00223094": "an alarm is useless if people don't", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00816-00223096-00223351": "understand the message of the alarm and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00817-00223352-00223582": "so the alarm has to be simple and people", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00818-00223583-00223846": "have to become familiar with the message", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00819-00223848-00224006": "of the alarm", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00820-00224007-00224206": "if they don't understand what the alarm", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00821-00224207-00224527": "is they will waste precious time", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00822-00224528-00224694": "wondering oh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00823-00224696-00224863": "what is that sound what does that mean", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00824-00224864-00224958": "is that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00825-00224959-00225182": "so for example if you have a tsunami", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00826-00225183-00225303": "alarm", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00827-00225304-00225455": "what the hell is a tsunami alarm what", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00828-00225456-00225631": "does that mean what does it sound like", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00829-00225632-00225831": "what's the message is telling me if i'm", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00830-00225832-00226134": "a tourist in your city and the tsunami", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00831-00226135-00226358": "alarm goes off i'm going to say well", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00832-00226359-00226591": "what is that i've never heard it before", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00833-00226592-00226910": "and so you're going to create potential", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00834-00226911-00227182": "confusion and this is where the training", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00835-00227183-00227415": "comes in and the education comes in you", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00836-00227416-00227663": "need to inform and educate and train", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00837-00227664-00227910": "people how to respond similarly with", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00838-00227911-00228294": "signage i've seen wonderful signage", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00839-00228296-00228479": "cropping up all around the world for a", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00840-00228480-00228606": "tsunami", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00841-00228607-00228687": "now", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00842-00228688-00228855": "you have a nice", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00843-00228856-00229110": "tsunami wave and a sign point what does", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00844-00229111-00229382": "that sign mean to the uninformed does", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00845-00229383-00229575": "that mean that's the direction of the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00846-00229576-00229727": "surf beach if you want to go and see the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00847-00229728-00229967": "surf go in that direction", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00848-00229967-00230110": "is that is that what it means or does it", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00849-00230111-00230334": "mean there's a place of safety from the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00850-00230335-00230658": "tsunami okay so the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00851-00230659-00230823": "comprehensibility", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00852-00230823-00231087": "of your message to the public and again", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00853-00231088-00231310": "this is the point i made earlier on", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00854-00231311-00231471": "it's important that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00855-00231471-00231710": "technologists and governments", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00856-00231711-00231894": "don't assume", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00857-00231896-00232198": "that the public understand your message", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00858-00232200-00232367": "you need to measure", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00859-00232367-00232575": "that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00860-00232576-00232806": "okay and we have this issue with", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00861-00232807-00232991": "emergency signage for fire and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00862-00232992-00233287": "evacuation uh lots of new concepts being", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00863-00233288-00233551": "developed like dynamic signage again", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00864-00233552-00233679": "i'll be talking about this in my", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00865-00233680-00233887": "presentation but do people actually", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00866-00233888-00234087": "comprehend and understand", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00867-00234088-00234382": "what these dynamic signage messages mean", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00868-00234383-00234598": "and and so do they react", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00869-00234600-00234775": "appropriately so this is really very", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00870-00234776-00235127": "important to understand the human side", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00871-00235128-00235282": "of all of these", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00872-00235283-00235503": "technological um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00873-00235504-00235758": "solutions and and uh training", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00874-00235759-00235887": "um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00875-00235888-00236255": "i think it was an issue that was raised", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00876-00236256-00236519": "later a few minutes ago about the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00877-00236519-00236727": "importance of training children and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00878-00236728-00237023": "educating children this is really vital", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00879-00237023-00237287": "and we've seen this in history", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00880-00237288-00237487": "in lots of cases", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00881-00237488-00237679": "where", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00882-00237680-00237967": "important training of youngsters", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00883-00237967-00238246": "can actually make a big difference in", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00884-00238248-00238551": "the outcomes in um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00885-00238552-00238710": "in in", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00886-00238711-00238903": "in disasters this isn't rocket science", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00887-00238904-00239151": "we've got lots of very good evidence of", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00888-00239152-00239446": "this uh so for for example", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00889-00239448-00239694": "during the second world war", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00890-00239696-00239879": "in the uk", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00891-00239880-00239967": "uh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00892-00239967-00240319": "children in primary elementary school", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00893-00240319-00240775": "were trained how to put on the gas mask", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00894-00240776-00241030": "so it wasn't we were just expecting the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00895-00241031-00241191": "adults to know how to do this and then", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00896-00241192-00241327": "the adults will take care of the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00897-00241328-00241487": "children", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00898-00241488-00241719": "we taught the children how to do this", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00899-00241719-00241967": "and in fact the children taught the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00900-00241967-00242151": "adults um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00901-00242152-00242415": "how to respond so uh that's a simple", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00902-00242416-00242703": "example from the 1930s", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00903-00242704-00242982": "of how important it is to educate", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00904-00242983-00243230": "children another example more recently", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00905-00243231-00243398": "is children at school certainly in the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00906-00243400-00243694": "uk are being taught first aid and the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00907-00243696-00243958": "importance of identifying underst", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00908-00243959-00244158": "understanding if for example", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00909-00244159-00244398": "an adult has collapsed what to do you", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00910-00244400-00244742": "know call 999 in the uk uh and and this", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00911-00244744-00245055": "has saved a number of lives um through", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00912-00245056-00245446": "the education of children um as early as", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00913-00245448-00245646": "elementary school so all of these things", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00914-00245648-00245863": "are really very very important and the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00915-00245864-00246103": "the sooner we begin to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00916-00246104-00246191": "um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00917-00246192-00246503": "educate and inform uh the uh the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00918-00246504-00246742": "youngsters that the more resilient a", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00919-00246744-00246894": "society um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00920-00246896-00247110": "uh we we will have", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00921-00247111-00247246": "um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00922-00247248-00247423": "i think uh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00923-00247423-00247694": "i'm not sure if i've answered", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00924-00247696-00247806": "or", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00925-00247807-00247975": "addressed the point that was made to me", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00926-00247976-00248206": "i can't remember what that point was um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00927-00248207-00248342": "so perhaps", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00928-00248344-00248527": "perhaps i finished for now unless", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00929-00248528-00248798": "there's another question or discussion", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00930-00248800-00248958": "thank you very much", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00931-00248959-00249134": "thank you very much", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00932-00249135-00249494": "as i heard dr garia communicate the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00933-00249496-00249663": "correct information", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00934-00249664-00249919": "like the meaning of alarm what it all", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00935-00249919-00250215": "means the sound", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00936-00250216-00250575": "and also learn from the children", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00937-00250576-00250927": "like gas mask example", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00938-00250928-00251167": "taught children then children taught", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00939-00251167-00251367": "parents and like", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00940-00251367-00251598": "dr imamura said at the time of", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00941-00251600-00251751": "evacuation", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00942-00251752-00252094": "pupils led that vietnam evacuation", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00943-00252096-00252334": "yeah so education", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00944-00252335-00252727": "involved children to help evacuate and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00945-00252728-00252958": "prepare for the disaster that is very", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00946-00252959-00253110": "significant", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00947-00253111-00253319": "and this", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00948-00253319-00253487": "arteries and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00949-00253488-00253687": "they have a lot of interviews with the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00950-00253688-00253815": "children", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00951-00253816-00253991": "and the communication with the children", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00952-00253992-00254206": "right", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00953-00254207-00254479": "i heard i've read the article", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00954-00254480-00254742": "and in that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00955-00254744-00254991": "what you can learn from children if you", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00956-00254992-00255239": "have any comments of on that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00957-00255240-00255527": "what you learned from children", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00958-00255528-00255775": "yeah just after this talk i'm going to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00959-00255776-00256063": "visit the donghua middle school for a", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00960-00256064-00256503": "conversation so indeed it's my job as", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00961-00256504-00256767": "the minister in charge of youth", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00962-00256767-00257087": "engagement to engage the youth as early", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00963-00257088-00257255": "as possible", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00964-00257256-00257534": "and what we have learned is that the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00965-00257535-00257727": "younger people the people younger than", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00966-00257728-00257991": "18 people before they get the voting", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00967-00257992-00258255": "right really are actually much more", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00968-00258256-00258471": "passionate about the innovative", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00969-00258471-00258775": "solutions when it comes to environmental", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00970-00258776-00258982": "and disaster mitigation and things like", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00971-00258983-00259198": "that they're also very well connected", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00972-00259200-00259527": "internationally all they like is a stage", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00973-00259528-00259734": "for their innovations to be taken", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00974-00259735-00259975": "seriously because they don't have a vote", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00975-00259976-00260342": "right they can't vote themselves in so", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00976-00260344-00260639": "in taiwan we have this national platform", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00977-00260640-00260839": "where people can raise citizen", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00978-00260840-00261119": "initiatives and after collecting 5 000", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00979-00261119-00261358": "signatures online from citizens or", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00980-00261359-00261615": "residents anyone with a sms number", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00981-00261616-00261719": "really", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00982-00261719-00261951": "we must respond from a ministry of", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00983-00261952-00262239": "possessions and if it's inter agency i", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00984-00262240-00262543": "personally collaborate with the social", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00985-00262544-00262767": "sector twice a month", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00986-00262768-00263015": "now the point is that more than a", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00987-00263016-00263255": "quarter of those initiatives are", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00988-00263256-00263567": "proposed by people younger than 18 so", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00989-00263568-00263863": "they are the most active age segments", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00990-00263864-00264151": "they came up with this idea of banning", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00991-00264152-00264439": "plastic straws from the taking out of", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00992-00264440-00264719": "our national drink the bubble tea", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00993-00264720-00264982": "replacing it with circular material or", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00994-00264983-00265239": "reusable material and actually charted", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00995-00265240-00265495": "out a transitioning plant with the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00996-00265496-00265839": "business sector and so on and with this", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00997-00265840-00266110": "joint platform their idea became reality", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00998-00266111-00266423": "in just a few months so these are just", "TxkPC7eV7eI-00999-00266424-00266710": "some of the idea of reverse mentorship", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01000-00266711-00266991": "if we give them the stage they actually", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01001-00266992-00267255": "connect much better to the senior", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01002-00267256-00267639": "generation people who are 17 years old", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01003-00267640-00267823": "are the perfect partner of people who", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01004-00267824-00268143": "are 70 years old because those age", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01005-00268144-00268358": "groups have more time on their hands", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01006-00268359-00268591": "care more about the long term and also", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01007-00268592-00268855": "organize passionately in the social", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01008-00268856-00269127": "sector so that's our experience in just", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01009-00269128-00269343": "touring around taiwan to listen to the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01010-00269344-00269519": "middle schoolers what they feel what", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01011-00269520-00269823": "they think when they complete their data", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01012-00269824-00270039": "competence education when they", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01013-00270040-00270287": "fact-check the presidential candidates", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01014-00270288-00270575": "to put an end to this information", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01015-00270576-00270830": "when they fact check the local weather", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01016-00270831-00271047": "stations right and things like that what", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01017-00271048-00271230": "else would they like to do and that's", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01018-00271231-00271479": "when i learned the most", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01019-00271480-00272497": "thank you very much", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01020-00272498-00272639": "[Music]", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01021-00272640-00272879": "who doesn't have any voting", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01022-00272880-00272975": "right", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01023-00272976-00273599": "so you are working focusing on those", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01024-00273600-00273719": "area", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01025-00273720-00273943": "this is do", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01026-00273944-00274206": "because because due to the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01027-00274207-00274327": "digital", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01028-00274328-00274447": "era", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01029-00274448-00274655": "that will be very important", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01030-00274656-00275039": "i have about uh on uh eight minutes i", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01031-00275040-00275327": "would like to ask you the question", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01032-00275328-00275479": "this is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01033-00275480-00275734": "from the person who is engaged in this", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01034-00275735-00276167": "video engineering area in japan", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01035-00276168-00276439": "now we are doing to promote", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01036-00276440-00276519": "the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01037-00276520-00276655": "digital", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01038-00276656-00276991": "system", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01039-00276992-00277143": "it's in", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01040-00277144-00277279": "that one", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01041-00277280-00277503": "at", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01042-00277504-00277887": "your experience would you please help us", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01043-00277888-00278334": "and tell me where we have to focus on", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01044-00278335-00278847": "for the digital situation", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01045-00278848-00278934": "yeah", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01046-00278935-00279239": "as i mentioned the focus should be", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01047-00279240-00279582": "on trusting the citizens to come up with", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01048-00279583-00279719": "innovations", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01049-00279720-00280006": "rather than working for the citizens we", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01050-00280007-00280327": "need to work with the citizens", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01051-00280328-00280630": "and the key idea of nothing about us", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01052-00280631-00280982": "without us tells us when we design for", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01053-00280983-00281255": "example the contact rating system the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01054-00281256-00281543": "mass creation system we work together", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01055-00281544-00281823": "with the frontline pharmacists with the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01056-00281824-00282087": "senior people who don't want to use an", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01057-00282088-00282423": "atm to wire anything out because to them", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01058-00282424-00282687": "it's too dangerous they use the atm only", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01059-00282688-00282958": "to withdraw cash and they prefer to pay", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01060-00282959-00283287": "in cash and so on we need to let them", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01061-00283288-00283623": "come up with the models that we deliver", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01062-00283624-00283895": "those digital services so that even in", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01063-00283896-00284199": "convenience store in taiwan for example", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01064-00284200-00284406": "you still use the national health card", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01065-00284407-00284639": "without entering password or involving", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01066-00284640-00284871": "money to pre-order the mosque and then", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01067-00284872-00285119": "you pay cash at a counter of course you", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01068-00285120-00285327": "can also pay using mobile payment but", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01069-00285328-00285615": "the point is that if the senior people", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01070-00285616-00285830": "if the people were disadvantaged", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01071-00285831-00285991": "actually come up with the solution", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01072-00285992-00286247": "themselves and you implement them to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01073-00286248-00286527": "augment existing solutions they become", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01074-00286528-00286767": "passionate opinion leaders that's", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01075-00286768-00286958": "because they co-invented it will", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01076-00286959-00287247": "convince everyone in their community how", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01077-00287248-00287567": "to enroll into this and for example when", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01078-00287568-00287871": "we did vaccine reservation people over", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01079-00287872-00288206": "the age of 65 overwhelmingly say they", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01080-00288207-00288471": "don't want to pre-register because they", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01081-00288472-00288679": "have a lot of free time on their hands", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01082-00288680-00288943": "just tell them when and where to go they", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01083-00288944-00289239": "will just go there saving one extra", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01084-00289240-00289495": "transaction of appointments but people", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01085-00289496-00289703": "of the working age of course they have", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01086-00289704-00289975": "to take a days off work and so what they", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01087-00289976-00290295": "prefer to schedule by their own volition", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01088-00290296-00290630": "so in taiwan uh over 65 years old of", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01089-00290631-00290854": "people do not have to register for", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01090-00290855-00291143": "vaccines it's appointed directly but", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01091-00291144-00291382": "people under 64", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01092-00291383-00291639": "have to register but they can do so with", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01093-00291640-00291854": "the help of a local district officer to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01094-00291855-00292063": "their local pharmacy with a local", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01095-00292064-00292254": "convenience store or just calling a", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01096-00292255-00292463": "local support line so it's very", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01097-00292464-00292695": "diversified and the reason why we take", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01098-00292696-00292910": "such diversified way to deliver the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01099-00292911-00293151": "public services because these are", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01100-00293152-00293415": "created by the people those innovations", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01101-00293416-00293639": "are by the people themselves closest to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01102-00293640-00293951": "the pain we just empower them", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01103-00293952-00294310": "thank you very much", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01104-00294311-00294534": "so thank you very much the elderly", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01105-00294535-00294727": "people have difficulty using a", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01106-00294728-00295015": "registration system but", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01107-00295016-00295110": "trust", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01108-00295111-00295351": "citizens and work together that is very", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01109-00295352-00295606": "important like with the a in the age of", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01110-00295607-00295919": "sns this can be possible", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01111-00295920-00296151": "sorry we are running out of time we have", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01112-00296152-00296399": "only four minutes left lastly we'd i'd", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01113-00296400-00296558": "like to have a", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01114-00296559-00296775": "uh dr imam", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01115-00296776-00297006": "dr gary dr tan", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01116-00297007-00297382": "one short comment from each gentleman", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01117-00297383-00297703": "dr imam", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01118-00297704-00298279": "thank you very much", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01119-00298280-00298591": "we didn't have enough time but uh we it", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01120-00298592-00298943": "was great to have a talk with uh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01121-00298944-00299175": "dr gary and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01122-00299176-00299399": "dr tan", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01123-00299400-00299682": "and communication with this", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01124-00299683-00299919": "civilians and the government people is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01125-00299920-00300023": "important", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01126-00300024-00300351": "like a disaster or coveted", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01127-00300352-00300639": "there are some areas that people do not", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01128-00300640-00300934": "follow exactly so double check on the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01129-00300935-00301039": "effects", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01130-00301040-00301263": "with the government and the citizens", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01131-00301264-00301551": "it's important and if it is effective uh", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01132-00301552-00301782": "we need to take actions", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01133-00301783-00302047": "people find it's effective", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01134-00302048-00302415": "so actions or many majors", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01135-00302416-00302558": "need to be taken", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01136-00302559-00302734": "and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01137-00302735-00302982": "maybe we should make a standard", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01138-00302983-00303167": "internationally", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01139-00303168-00303271": "to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01140-00303272-00303447": "work", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01141-00303448-00303839": "and by sharing the experience from many", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01142-00303840-00304047": "people from many parts of the world", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01143-00304048-00304263": "that would be great thank you very much", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01144-00304264-00304534": "for sharing the information today", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01145-00304535-00304934": "uh dr guardia", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01146-00304935-00305110": "thanks very much it's been look it's", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01147-00305111-00305303": "been a very interesting discussion um", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01148-00305304-00305391": "and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01149-00305392-00305703": "i think i i just finish up by saying", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01150-00305704-00305999": "i think the public is often viewed as", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01151-00306000-00306215": "part of the problem and in fact the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01152-00306216-00306430": "public is part of the solution", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01153-00306431-00306727": "in most cases in most disasters the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01154-00306728-00306951": "first responders are not the official", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01155-00306952-00307199": "police and the firefight they are the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01156-00307200-00307447": "public and so we have to trust the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01157-00307448-00307791": "public uh to react and to build our", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01158-00307792-00307975": "resilience and to do that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01159-00307976-00308254": "we need to educate train and provide the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01160-00308255-00308487": "information and listen to what the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01161-00308488-00308687": "public is telling us", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01162-00308688-00308879": "about how they will are likely to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01163-00308880-00309054": "respond we have to listen to that and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01164-00309055-00309295": "take that into account in our planning", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01165-00309296-00309367": "so", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01166-00309368-00309582": "just to finish off what i started off", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01167-00309583-00309887": "saying chance favors the prepared mind", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01168-00309888-00310110": "and that's something i it's a motto i", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01169-00310111-00310415": "live by and and and i and i wish", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01170-00310416-00310751": "society would do the same", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01171-00310752-00312310": "thank you very much", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01172-00312311-00312567": "what dr gallia has said", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01173-00312568-00312854": "i think in taiwan the most wearing", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01174-00312855-00313110": "communication was so effective precisely", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01175-00313111-00313327": "because it's not", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01176-00313328-00313534": "based on something that's top-down", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01177-00313535-00313854": "that's scholarly or sounds professional", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01178-00313855-00314110": "it's from a very cute spokes dog shiba", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01179-00314111-00314319": "inu actually that we", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01180-00314320-00314575": "invited people to remix we just put this", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01181-00314576-00314847": "very cute message of ashiba inu the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01182-00314848-00315063": "spokesdog putting the food to their", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01183-00315064-00315158": "mouths", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01184-00315159-00315439": "and saying no but the message around", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01185-00315440-00315687": "that particular picture people including", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01186-00315688-00315927": "children are free to innovate and we", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01187-00315928-00316191": "just look at what was really popular", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01188-00316192-00316487": "back then is this message where a must", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01189-00316488-00316775": "to prevent you from touching your own", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01190-00316776-00317103": "face with your unwashed hand and that is", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01191-00317104-00317287": "so beautiful because at the time the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01192-00317288-00317654": "scientific evidence of mosques used in", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01193-00317655-00317823": "preventing the virus is still being", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01194-00317824-00318047": "gathered but this message of course", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01195-00318048-00318287": "everyone can verify for themselves right", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01196-00318288-00318495": "it's a reminder of harm washing", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01197-00318496-00318758": "essentially um and so by basing on", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01198-00318759-00318951": "things that uh adult people or", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01199-00318952-00319182": "professional people would simply not", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01200-00319183-00319415": "look at right would simply ignore and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01201-00319416-00319671": "taking the children's perspective we", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01202-00319672-00319879": "actually massively popularized that", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01203-00319880-00320175": "message and measured the hand wash water", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01204-00320176-00320487": "use in the waterways uh in the water", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01205-00320488-00320847": "system uh in in taiwan and it really did", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01206-00320848-00321079": "result in longer hand washing time as", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01207-00321080-00321382": "well as musk use so this simple anecdote", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01208-00321383-00321695": "i believe is one of the ideas", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01209-00321696-00321951": "that is so important when we look at the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01210-00321952-00322295": "people public private partnerships where", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01211-00322296-00322527": "the people ordinary citizens come up", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01212-00322528-00322806": "with these ideas and norms and so on and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01213-00322807-00323047": "the public sector far from fighting them", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01214-00323048-00323303": "just amplify them and the private sector", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01215-00323304-00323606": "helped to scale it out and scale it up", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01216-00323607-00323806": "thank you that's my contribution it's", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01217-00323807-00323967": "really nice adam", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01218-00323968-00324279": "thank you very much", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01219-00324280-00324647": "yeah thank you very much so um japan", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01220-00324648-00324967": "um the the government distributed two", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01221-00324968-00325158": "masks per head", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01222-00325159-00325334": "but the we should have listened to the", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01223-00325335-00325519": "voice of the children like you did in", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01224-00325520-00325758": "taiwan then it could have been a cooler", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01225-00325759-00325863": "design", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01226-00325864-00326167": "anyway um well thank you very much and", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01227-00326168-00326391": "um yeah i would like to i have to say", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01228-00326392-00326606": "goodbye and a big round of applause to", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01229-00326607-00326847": "audrey tan and minister and thank you so", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01230-00326848-00327245": "much today thank you", "TxkPC7eV7eI-01231-00327246-00327561": "[Applause]"}}, {"audio_id": "Txx15Rvy4kg", "text": {"Txx15Rvy4kg-00000-00000003-00000377": "so when I came to Australia in 1995 we", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00001-00000378-00000605": "could look back in time because we had", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00002-00000606-00000757": "the new equipment and I'll talk about", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00003-00000758-00001028": "that in a second so the idea was to", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00004-00001029-00001279": "figure out if the universe was following", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00005-00001280-00001502": "the trajectory of the dotted line where", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00006-00001503-00001657": "there's not much stuff in it we're", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00007-00001659-00001955": "following the the grey line where the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00008-00001955-00002129": "universe has so much stuff in it that", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00009-00002130-00002396": "the universe stops expanding in the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00010-00002397-00002765": "future goes into reverse so you can", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00011-00002766-00002912": "think about how you might do this if you", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00012-00002913-00003263": "couldn't look back in time by looking at", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00013-00003264-00003518": "more and more distant objects so for", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00014-00003519-00003754": "example if the universe is going to", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00015-00003755-00004034": "eventually stop that galaxies in the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00016-00004035-00004229": "past if I look at further and further", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00017-00004230-00004499": "objects I will be able to measure the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00018-00004500-00004804": "scale factor from the redshift and I'm", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00019-00004805-00005006": "gonna be able to measure their distances", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00020-00005007-00005285": "and that will tell me essentially", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00021-00005286-00005510": "the trajectory of the universe back in", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00022-00005511-00005718": "time and you get a slightly different", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00023-00005719-00006034": "distance and scale factor relation in", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00024-00006035-00006341": "the past if the universe is going to", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00025-00006342-00006610": "keep on expanding forever another way to", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00026-00006611-00006950": "think about it is looking through and", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00027-00006951-00007217": "measuring the universe's past expansion", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00028-00007218-00007523": "rate go through and you measure how fast", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00029-00007523-00007727": "the universe is expanding now we call", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00030-00007728-00008039": "that the Hubble constant and so if the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00031-00008040-00008270": "universe for example is just coasting it", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00032-00008271-00008489": "has almost nothing in it then the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00033-00008490-00008705": "expansion rate the average expansion", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00034-00008706-00008824": "rate of the universe isn't going to", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00035-00008825-00009085": "change over time but there's a", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00036-00009086-00009464": "trajectory a trajectory that defines", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00037-00009465-00009749": "where the universe has what we say has", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00038-00009750-00009964": "critical mass it's that dividing line", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00039-00009965-00010202": "where when you throw the ball up the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00040-00010203-00010385": "universe goes the the ball goes on", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00041-00010386-00010685": "forever or the unit the ball comes back", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00042-00010686-00011006": "to earth and so that dividing line here", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00043-00011007-00011192": "tells you that if the universe was", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00044-00011193-00011464": "expanding faster in the past and it", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00045-00011465-00011744": "slows down quicker than this line that", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00046-00011745-00012167": "is a line which defines where gravity", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00047-00012168-00012556": "wins and gravity loses we can figure out", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00048-00012557-00012808": "the future of the universe as well as", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00049-00012809-00013091": "how much it weighs so imagine when I", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00050-00013091-00013301": "look back in time my galaxies lie", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00051-00013302-00013396": "exactly", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00052-00013397-00013609": "that line then I know the universe is", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00053-00013610-00013903": "right on that edge where we're not sure", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00054-00013904-00014143": "what its ultimate future is on the other", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00055-00014144-00014377": "hand if the universe is slowing down", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00056-00014378-00014791": "slower the galaxies lie in this part of", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00057-00014791-00015097": "the diagram then we know that the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00058-00015097-00015397": "universe is going to exist forever so to", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00059-00015397-00015619": "measure the universe we need to look", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00060-00015619-00015868": "back in time but when we look back in", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00061-00015869-00016057": "time we're looking far away which means", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00062-00016058-00016258": "we're looking to things that are going", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00063-00016259-00016498": "to appear much much fainter than they do", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00064-00016499-00016813": "nearby so we need something bright and", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00065-00016814-00017143": "the brightest thing that we know of in", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00066-00017144-00017380": "the nearby universe are type 1a", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00067-00017381-00017863": "supernovae these are exploding stars now", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00068-00017864-00018085": "to understand them let's look at the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00069-00018086-00018412": "life of a star like our Sun our Sun and", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00070-00018413-00018616": "about five billion years is going to", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00071-00018617-00018889": "puff up as it finishes using all of its", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00072-00018890-00019119": "nuclear power and will collapse down to", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00073-00019120-00019291": "a tiny little star known as a white", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00074-00019292-00019555": "dwarf white dwarfs about the size of the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00075-00019556-00019813": "earth but the mass of the Sun but if our", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00076-00019814-00020107": "Sun was instead formed in a binary star", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00077-00020108-00020475": "that same process happens for the larger", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00078-00020476-00020755": "of the two stars it collapses down forms", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00079-00020756-00021004": "a white dwarf and then the second star", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00080-00021005-00021169": "can go through that same process and", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00081-00021170-00021382": "make this white dwarf star become", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00082-00021383-00021694": "heavier and heavier now something", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00083-00021695-00021859": "amazing happens when it reaches one", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00084-00021860-00022087": "point three eight times the mass of the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00085-00022088-00022405": "Sun becomes unstable - gravitational", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00086-00022406-00022663": "collapse but instead of forming a black", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00087-00022664-00022888": "hole it explodes as a giant", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00088-00022889-00023250": "thermonuclear bomb these are type 1a", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00089-00023251-00023485": "supernovae and when we look at them", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00090-00023486-00023719": "they're explosions that reach five", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00091-00023720-00024075": "billion times brighter than our Sun take", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00092-00024076-00024274": "about 20 days to reach that brightness", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00093-00024275-00024580": "and they fade away into oblivion these", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00094-00024581-00024850": "objects form more than two-thirds of the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00095-00024851-00025068": "iron in the universe", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00096-00025069-00025363": "they were figured out how to be used by", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00097-00025364-00025644": "a team in chewie a team that I went and", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00098-00025645-00025987": "visited during my PhD thesis and these", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00099-00025988-00026283": "people went out and used modern digital", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00100-00026284-00026464": "detectors to go out for the first time", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00101-00026464-00026683": "and figure out how bright these", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00102-00026683-00026783": "exploding stars", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00103-00026785-00027036": "were and to calibrate how many watts", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00104-00027037-00027285": "there were when they were doing this", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00105-00027286-00027539": "work in 1990 and here we see Jose Massa", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00106-00027541-00027764": "from the University of Chile they would", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00107-00027766-00027989": "go through and take a photograph because", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00108-00027991-00028185": "we didn't have big digital cameras at", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00109-00028186-00028392": "the time and they would put a photograph", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00110-00028393-00028707": "here and a photograph here there's a", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00111-00028708-00028863": "little lever they could move back and", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00112-00028864-00029037": "forth and they would use their brain", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00113-00029038-00029193": "because we didn't have big computers", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00114-00029194-00029481": "either at the time to find the new", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00115-00029482-00029837": "exploding stars when I visited them in", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00116-00029838-00030204": "1990 they really were kind of depressed", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00117-00030205-00030504": "they were depressed because their first", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00118-00030505-00030758": "few exploding stars seemed to be very", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00119-00030760-00030942": "different from each other and one of the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00120-00030943-00031133": "hopes was if you're gonna figure out how", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00121-00031135-00031332": "bright these were you're gonna calibrate", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00122-00031333-00031560": "how many watts they were you wanted to", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00123-00031561-00031854": "be almost all the same so they showed me", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00124-00031855-00032100": "this this figure and they realized that", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00125-00032101-00032373": "this supernovae given the glorious name", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00126-00032374-00032772": "of 1990 AF was fading more quickly and", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00127-00032773-00033102": "was fainter than the more normal objects", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00128-00033103-00033432": "that they typically found within a year", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00129-00033433-00033600": "or two though they had come up with the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00130-00033601-00034005": "solution that this trend was always in", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00131-00034006-00034164": "all the object they looked at that the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00132-00034165-00034491": "bright supernova took a long time to", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00133-00034492-00034689": "reach their maximum brightness and fade", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00134-00034690-00034929": "away where the faint one did that whole", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00135-00034930-00035166": "process more quickly and we really", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00136-00035167-00035355": "understand this is how much iron they", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00137-00035356-00035640": "make today and so when they were able to", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00138-00035641-00035918": "calibrate their data for the first time", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00139-00035919-00036159": "this is when one of the young", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00140-00036160-00036384": "researchers Mario hem we came up to", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00141-00036385-00036612": "Harvard and showed us their data this is", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00142-00036613-00036873": "what their data looked like every", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00143-00036874-00037275": "supernova here measures a measure of the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00144-00037276-00037494": "scale factor the redshift and measures", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00145-00037495-00037809": "the distance and you can see that you", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00146-00037810-00038064": "get this beautiful relationship where", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00147-00038065-00038409": "everything lies on the line of expansion", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00148-00038410-00038613": "and that's because their method of", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00149-00038614-00038823": "measuring distances was really really", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00150-00038824-00038882": "good", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00151-00038883-00039279": "now it wasn't just their ideas that", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00152-00039280-00039429": "allowed us to do this experiment it was", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00153-00039430-00039717": "also technology and that technology came", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00154-00039718-00039900": "in the form of new modern digital", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00155-00039901-00040167": "detectors which allowed us to", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00156-00040168-00040443": "scan for these exploding stars which", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00157-00040444-00040749": "turned out to be very very rare only", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00158-00040750-00041034": "every several hundred years in a galaxy", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00159-00041035-00041256": "like the Milky Way so these new", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00160-00041257-00041699": "detectors 2 megapixel detectors so that", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00161-00041700-00041901": "doesn't sound that big now but it was", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00162-00041902-00042231": "big back then we're coming online and so", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00163-00042232-00042429": "we could take pictures with large", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00164-00042430-00042735": "telescopes two very very faint levels of", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00165-00042736-00042993": "a big enough region of the sky to", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00166-00042994-00043290": "hopefully find one of these objects the", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00167-00043291-00043490": "other piece of technology were bigger", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00168-00043491-00043874": "telescopes in 1994 the Keck telescopes", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00169-00043875-00044183": "that 10 meter telescopes first started", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00170-00044184-00044465": "looking at the sky and it was these", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00171-00044466-00044793": "telescopes that were big enough to allow", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00172-00044794-00045015": "us to gather the information we needed", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00173-00045016-00045348": "to for example measure the redshift to", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00174-00045349-00045726": "these exploding stars so ideas and", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00175-00045727-00045921": "technology are what allowed this", "Txx15Rvy4kg-00176-00045922-00046266": "experiment to go forth"}}, {"audio_id": "Tx_dD9kI4su", "text": {"Tx_dD9kI4su-00000-00000055-00000388": "[Applause]", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00001-00000389-00001050": "sleep my baby is sleeping", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00002-00001051-00001294": "[Music]", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00003-00001295-00001542": "she's been knocked out the whole time so", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00004-00001543-00001937": "today's video we are going to be doing a", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00005-00001938-00002126": "grocery haul so we're gonna show you", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00006-00002127-00002417": "what we got at Lucky's market just like", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00007-00002418-00002540": "guys know we've been hitting the gym", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00008-00002541-00002606": "lately", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00009-00002607-00002825": "Austin's gettin swole this is swallow", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00010-00002826-00003259": "season so yeah stay tuned for what we", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00011-00003260-00003415": "got so now I'm gonna sit back and just", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00012-00003417-00003742": "watch us and put all the bags in the car", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00013-00003743-00004006": "okay guys so we are home now", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00014-00004007-00004235": "Austin is taking a nap he has to go to", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00015-00004236-00004456": "work and I'm gonna do the hall so I'm", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00016-00004457-00005369": "gonna show you what we got all right so", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00017-00005370-00005528": "I laid everything out on the table and", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00018-00005529-00005768": "I'm just gonna go one by one quickly of", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00019-00005769-00006004": "what I got I'm gonna start off with two", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00020-00006005-00006233": "pineapples because we eat these very", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00021-00006234-00006587": "quick we got organic eggs we got kale", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00022-00006588-00006778": "because I want to make some juices so I", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00023-00006779-00006934": "got some Fiji apples we got some", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00024-00006936-00007241": "asparagus two plantains got an onion we", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00025-00007242-00007475": "always never have enough onions like we", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00026-00007476-00007781": "love onions tomatoes some bell pepper", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00027-00007781-00007952": "because I'm gonna be making some curry", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00028-00007953-00008234": "and last time I made curry I didn't put", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00029-00008235-00008399": "pepper and it didn't have that flavor", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00030-00008400-00008560": "I was wondering what's missing and often", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00031-00008561-00009032": "said peppers so I got I got her first", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00032-00009033-00009338": "it's got bananas Ella loves bananas got", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00033-00009339-00009571": "quinoa organic quinoa and you can", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00034-00009572-00009842": "actually like pour as much as you want", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00035-00009843-00010099": "and it was only 99 a pound this was four", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00036-00010100-00010274": "dollars and 38 cents for all of this", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00037-00010275-00010469": "versus one of those little packs whoo", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00038-00010470-00010742": "you barely get any crazy this amount of", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00039-00010743-00010924": "quinoa for four dollars we got some", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00040-00010925-00011255": "lemon I got four mangos I got six", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00041-00011256-00011617": "avocados we love avocados love avocados", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00042-00011618-00011803": "love Oh God", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00043-00011804-00012160": "just got some look come look just got", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00044-00012161-00012364": "some little red potatoes I usually like", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00045-00012365-00012566": "to cut them up like thinly put them in", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00046-00012567-00012727": "the pan with some butter salt and pepper", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00047-00012728-00013033": "Austin got a rib eye and he got some", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00048-00013034-00013379": "chicken I got dr. Prager 'he's super", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00049-00013380-00013610": "dreams of veggie burgers this was on", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00050-00013611-00013922": "sale by alba it's kid sunscreen so we're", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00051-00013922-00014165": "gonna try it out i got bamboo shoots for", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00052-00014166-00014422": "the curry and some garbanzo beans for", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00053-00014423-00014516": "the curry as well", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00054-00014516-00014807": "organic whole grain rice and wild rice", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00055-00014808-00015025": "garlic and basil these were on sale", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00056-00015026-00015225": "there were three four five nannies", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00057-00015226-00015497": "macaronis so hella doesn't really ever", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00058-00015497-00015746": "eat macaroni and cheese so I said I'm", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00059-00015747-00016055": "gonna try it I got my vegan butter by", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00060-00016056-00016300": "Earth Balance I love this it's great for", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00061-00016301-00016463": "baking great for cooking it's awesome I", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00062-00016464-00016603": "love it it tastes just like regular", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00063-00016604-00016825": "butter as non-gmo it's vegan it's", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00064-00016826-00016880": "awesome", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00065-00016881-00017047": "I got Ella's some coconut water got a", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00066-00017048-00017285": "baguette because it was 99 cents and why", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00067-00017286-00017435": "not but that's our awesome some", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00068-00017436-00017683": "tortillas I love to use got iron some", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00069-00017684-00018031": "veggie sticks so I picked up some orange", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00070-00018032-00018224": "chicken sauce for Austin I'm gonna take", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00071-00018225-00018365": "some chicken bread it made some make", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00072-00018366-00018521": "some orange chicken for him picked up a", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00073-00018522-00018691": "tomato basil sauce I've got this amazing", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00074-00018692-00018922": "coffee drink it is the best thing in the", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00075-00018923-00019165": "world it's cold brew by Khalid Khalifa", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00076-00019166-00019424": "it's so good almond milk was on sale for", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00077-00019425-00019669": "two for five grab some organic animal", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00078-00019670-00020084": "wrap Ella some Annie's organic chocolate", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00079-00020085-00020359": "chip graham crackers that she is", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00080-00020360-00020543": "currently eating right now loving the", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00081-00020544-00020753": "life I fell in love with this creamy day", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00082-00020754-00020894": "today I got the small one and it was", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00083-00020895-00021109": "gone in three days so dairy-free creamer", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00084-00021110-00021475": "vanilla we got our cat moves some cat", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00085-00021476-00021706": "food so we're gonna see if she likes it", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00086-00021707-00021890": "she doesn't then we just won't get her", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00087-00021891-00022075": "get this again but it was on sale so", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00088-00022076-00022174": "we're like", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00089-00022175-00022438": "try it it's called it's called I think I", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00090-00022439-00022897": "love I know I and love you guys I don't", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00091-00022898-00023377": "know I and love and you so we were a", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00092-00023378-00023614": "little bad and we got some ramen noodles", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00093-00023615-00023866": "but it says made with organic noodles no", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00094-00023867-00024190": "MSG added and they're vegan so so that's", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00095-00024191-00024466": "what we got at Lucky's market I hope", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00096-00024467-00024598": "this wasn't too boring I don't know I", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00097-00024599-00024778": "really wanted to do this I made a poll", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00098-00024779-00024894": "on Twitter and see if you guys wanted to", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00099-00024895-00025165": "see and a couple people said yes so why", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00100-00025166-00025210": "not", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00101-00025211-00025393": "so guys I wanted to do something a", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00102-00025394-00025600": "little nice because we hit our 500", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00103-00025601-00025809": "subscriber mark I'm so happy you might", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00104-00025810-00026014": "be still $4.99 but I'm hoping by now", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00105-00026014-00026200": "when I'm posted video will be a 500 but", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00106-00026201-00026383": "if not then it's okay 500 let's just say", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00107-00026383-00026650": "I want to do a toy giveaway so they are", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00108-00026651-00026863": "used toys but they're not dirty I", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00109-00026864-00027124": "promise these little books are washed I", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00110-00027125-00027345": "would love to help some Mama's out there", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00111-00027347-00027658": "that want toys I'm gonna pick five moms", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00112-00027658-00027915": "or dads whoever aunts uncles I'm gonna", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00113-00027916-00028156": "pick picked five people to give away", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00114-00028157-00028483": "toys to I have like so many baby books", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00115-00028483-00028906": "and toys and just like DVDs and and like", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00116-00028907-00029236": "just more and hold on there's more guys", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00117-00029237-00029527": "it's a whole bag so comment down below I", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00118-00029527-00029808": "want to win if you want to win maybe", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00119-00029810-00030250": "possibly some toys if I see that I still", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00120-00030251-00030382": "have toys left over because I don't want", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00121-00030383-00030592": "to just send somebody one toy so if I", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00122-00030593-00030757": "see that there's still some toys left", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00123-00030758-00030952": "over I'll give it out to more moms you", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00124-00030952-00031042": "know what I'm saying or more and more", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00125-00031043-00031264": "more people I don't mean to say mom I'm", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00126-00031264-00031393": "just used to saying moms and sorry guys", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00127-00031394-00031545": "sorry dad sorry aunts uncles cousins", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00128-00031547-00031807": "nephews aunts whatever so comment down", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00129-00031808-00031948": "below if you want to win I know it's not", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00130-00031949-00032200": "much but um if I could buy you guys", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00131-00032201-00032377": "brand new toys right now I would but", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00132-00032377-00032545": "it's just not in my budget right now I", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00133-00032545-00032662": "apologize", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00134-00032663-00032809": "so y'all comment down below if you want", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00135-00032810-00032971": "to win give this video a thumbs up", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00136-00032972-00033240": "because we're at 500 subscribers give", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00137-00033241-00033370": "this video a thumbs up for all the", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00138-00033371-00033532": "amazing food that I just got and we're", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00139-00033533-00033733": "so blessed that we're able to you know", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00140-00033734-00033928": "buy our groceries it's just an amazing", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00141-00033929-00034069": "feeling to just buy your own groceries", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00142-00034070-00034336": "and like make your own food and stuff oh", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00143-00034337-00034525": "yeah I hope you enjoyed it and I hope", "Tx_dD9kI4su-00144-00034526-00034918": "you guys have an awesome day Bibles"}}, {"audio_id": "Txb545UnPkc", "text": {"Txb545UnPkc-00000-00000003-00000340": "so section 4.5 is now finally combining", "Txb545UnPkc-00001-00000341-00000607": "unlike fractions together so we have", "Txb545UnPkc-00002-00000608-00000815": "different denominators we need to make", "Txb545UnPkc-00003-00000816-00000970": "them common before we can actually", "Txb545UnPkc-00004-00000971-00001223": "combine so we're using the skills from", "Txb545UnPkc-00005-00001224-00001394": "four point four so if you haven't", "Txb545UnPkc-00006-00001395-00001630": "watched that video yet go back and watch", "Txb545UnPkc-00007-00001632-00001805": "it's a very important skill that we're", "Txb545UnPkc-00008-00001805-00001979": "going to use in the rest of the sections", "Txb545UnPkc-00009-00001980-00002293": "in Chapter four so let's take that first", "Txb545UnPkc-00010-00002294-00002434": "example we want to add together", "Txb545UnPkc-00011-00002435-00002692": "three-fourths and 1/6", "Txb545UnPkc-00012-00002693-00002959": "we don't have common denominators and we", "Txb545UnPkc-00013-00002960-00003434": "need common denominators so let's first", "Txb545UnPkc-00014-00003435-00003763": "work at figuring out well what is the", "Txb545UnPkc-00015-00003764-00004085": "least common between 4 and 6 so how do", "Txb545UnPkc-00016-00004086-00004379": "we do it we're gonna take 4 break it", "Txb545UnPkc-00017-00004380-00004691": "into its primes and we're gonna take 6", "Txb545UnPkc-00018-00004692-00005147": "and break it into its prime at that", "Txb545UnPkc-00019-00005148-00005441": "point now we can start building our LCD", "Txb545UnPkc-00020-00005442-00005792": "has to be divisible by what by 4 so I", "Txb545UnPkc-00021-00005793-00006092": "need to take into account a factor 2 and", "Txb545UnPkc-00022-00006093-00006392": "another factor of 2 and what is our LCD", "Txb545UnPkc-00023-00006393-00006944": "missing that 6 has a factor of 3 so the", "Txb545UnPkc-00024-00006945-00007316": "least common multiple between 4 & 6 and", "Txb545UnPkc-00025-00007317-00007528": "they happen to live in the denominators", "Txb545UnPkc-00026-00007529-00007735": "the least common denominators are gonna", "Txb545UnPkc-00027-00007736-00008217": "be what 2 times 2 is 4 4 times 3 is 12", "Txb545UnPkc-00028-00008218-00008467": "so we know what the smallest common", "Txb545UnPkc-00029-00008468-00008798": "multiple between 4 & 6 is let's build", "Txb545UnPkc-00030-00008799-00009152": "those 2 this common multiple now so to", "Txb545UnPkc-00031-00009153-00009509": "turn 4 into 12 what do we have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00032-00009510-00009928": "multiply by 3 and whatever we do to the", "Txb545UnPkc-00033-00009929-00010241": "bottom we have to do to the top because", "Txb545UnPkc-00034-00010242-00010531": "in reality what are we multiplying by 1", "Txb545UnPkc-00035-00010532-00010685": "we're just changing what it looks like", "Txb545UnPkc-00036-00010686-00010981": "so now our equivalent fraction is going", "Txb545UnPkc-00037-00010982-00011314": "to turn into what 3/4 is going to become", "Txb545UnPkc-00038-00011315-00011767": "3 times 3 which is 9 over 3 times 4", "Txb545UnPkc-00039-00011768-00012053": "which is 12 so they're still equivalent", "Txb545UnPkc-00040-00012054-00012302": "but now we have this denominator that we", "Txb545UnPkc-00041-00012303-00012556": "know we can build 6 to share in common", "Txb545UnPkc-00042-00012557-00012808": "with we're going to do the same thing to", "Txb545UnPkc-00043-00012809-00013196": "6 to turn 6 into 12 what do we have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00044-00013197-00013340": "multiply by", "Txb545UnPkc-00045-00013341-00013574": "- and whatever we do to the bottom we", "Txb545UnPkc-00046-00013575-00013829": "have to do to the top so we're adding on", "Txb545UnPkc-00047-00013830-00014084": "to this the equivalent fraction of one", "Txb545UnPkc-00048-00014085-00014378": "six and what is it turning into one", "Txb545UnPkc-00049-00014379-00014684": "times two gives us two and six times two", "Txb545UnPkc-00050-00014685-00014996": "gives us twelve so now that we have", "Txb545UnPkc-00051-00014997-00015218": "those common denominators we know what", "Txb545UnPkc-00052-00015219-00015596": "to do keep the same denominator and add", "Txb545UnPkc-00053-00015597-00015896": "across the top nine and two together", "Txb545UnPkc-00054-00015897-00016187": "gives us eleven and eleven twelve does", "Txb545UnPkc-00055-00016188-00016622": "not reduce so we know we're done okay", "Txb545UnPkc-00056-00016623-00016838": "we're going to do the same thing in the", "Txb545UnPkc-00057-00016839-00017111": "last of these examples before we move on", "Txb545UnPkc-00058-00017112-00017270": "to subtraction so let's take the next", "Txb545UnPkc-00059-00017271-00017573": "one four and fifteen are the", "Txb545UnPkc-00060-00017574-00017744": "denominators that were working with", "Txb545UnPkc-00061-00017745-00018134": "we need them to become a common multiple", "Txb545UnPkc-00062-00018135-00018374": "so let's take each of them and break", "Txb545UnPkc-00063-00018375-00018668": "them into their primes five is prime it", "Txb545UnPkc-00064-00018669-00018947": "can't be broken up but fifteen can be", "Txb545UnPkc-00065-00018948-00019337": "broken up into five and three both of", "Txb545UnPkc-00066-00019338-00019757": "which are prime so our LCD then it has", "Txb545UnPkc-00067-00019758-00020132": "to be divisible by what by five and it", "Txb545UnPkc-00068-00020133-00020426": "has to be divisible by 15 so what is our", "Txb545UnPkc-00069-00020427-00020954": "LCD missing that 15 has factor of three", "Txb545UnPkc-00070-00020955-00021377": "so our least common denominator is 15", "Txb545UnPkc-00071-00021378-00021689": "just happens to be one of the", "Txb545UnPkc-00072-00021690-00021950": "denominators that's already present so", "Txb545UnPkc-00073-00021951-00022112": "the second one we don't have to alter", "Txb545UnPkc-00074-00022113-00022307": "because it already shares that common", "Txb545UnPkc-00075-00022308-00022661": "denominator but the first one to turn 5", "Txb545UnPkc-00076-00022662-00023026": "into 15 what do we have to multiply by 3", "Txb545UnPkc-00077-00023027-00023303": "and whatever we do to the bottom we have", "Txb545UnPkc-00078-00023304-00023405": "to do to the top", "Txb545UnPkc-00079-00023406-00023696": "so our equivalent expression let's see", "Txb545UnPkc-00080-00023697-00023978": "what we're looking at 3 times 2 gives us", "Txb545UnPkc-00081-00023979-00024605": "6 over 3 times 5 is 15 and we're adding", "Txb545UnPkc-00082-00024606-00024836": "on to that for 15 we didn't have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00083-00024837-00025043": "alter that one because it already shared", "Txb545UnPkc-00084-00025044-00025369": "the common denominator now that we do", "Txb545UnPkc-00085-00025370-00025541": "have matching denominators let's add", "Txb545UnPkc-00086-00025542-00025847": "across the top and keep the same", "Txb545UnPkc-00087-00025848-00026282": "denominator 6 and 4 together gives us 10", "Txb545UnPkc-00088-00026283-00026610": "over 15 which we can reduce", "Txb545UnPkc-00089-00026611-00026937": "they both share one in common a-five and", "Txb545UnPkc-00090-00026938-00027144": "if we want to break up and see the", "Txb545UnPkc-00091-00027145-00027357": "factors we can if you can reduce it", "Txb545UnPkc-00092-00027358-00027651": "without doing so fine Tenma can break up", "Txb545UnPkc-00093-00027652-00028050": "into five and two 15 five and three so", "Txb545UnPkc-00094-00028051-00028245": "we can take out that common factor and", "Txb545UnPkc-00095-00028245-00028727": "this reduces down to two thirds all", "Txb545UnPkc-00096-00028729-00029151": "right same story with these last two we", "Txb545UnPkc-00097-00029152-00029280": "want to find the least common", "Txb545UnPkc-00098-00029281-00029877": "denominator between 15 and 10 she will", "Txb545UnPkc-00099-00029877-00030123": "take each of them and break them into", "Txb545UnPkc-00100-00030124-00030452": "their primes 15 we can break up into 5 &", "Txb545UnPkc-00101-00030454-00031020": "3 both of which are prime 10 2 & 5 5 & 2", "Txb545UnPkc-00102-00031020-00031248": "order doesn't matter both of which are", "Txb545UnPkc-00103-00031249-00031656": "prime so let's build our LCD has to be", "Txb545UnPkc-00104-00031657-00031887": "divisible by both of them so choose one", "Txb545UnPkc-00105-00031888-00032172": "I'm gonna start with 15 because it came", "Txb545UnPkc-00106-00032173-00032451": "first we took all of those factors and", "Txb545UnPkc-00107-00032452-00032790": "what is our LCD missing that 10 has a", "Txb545UnPkc-00108-00032791-00033114": "factor of 2 so our least common", "Txb545UnPkc-00109-00033115-00033420": "denominator is gonna be what 5 times 3", "Txb545UnPkc-00110-00033421-00034101": "is 15 15 times 2 is 30 so the smallest", "Txb545UnPkc-00111-00034102-00034362": "common denominator between 15 and 10 is", "Txb545UnPkc-00112-00034363-00034421": "30", "Txb545UnPkc-00113-00034422-00034611": "let's build to that common denominator", "Txb545UnPkc-00114-00034612-00035052": "then to turn 15 into 30 we have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00115-00035053-00035367": "multiply by 2 and whatever we do to the", "Txb545UnPkc-00116-00035368-00035546": "bottom we have to do to the top", "Txb545UnPkc-00117-00035547-00035796": "so what is our equivalent fraction", "Txb545UnPkc-00118-00035797-00036177": "coming out in this case 2 times 2x gives", "Txb545UnPkc-00119-00036178-00036638": "us 4x up top and down below 2 times 15", "Txb545UnPkc-00120-00036639-00037020": "30 our common denominator we want to do", "Txb545UnPkc-00121-00037021-00037287": "the same thing on our second fraction to", "Txb545UnPkc-00122-00037288-00037521": "turn 10 into 30 what do we have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00123-00037522-00037932": "multiply by 3 and whatever we do to the", "Txb545UnPkc-00124-00037933-00038205": "bottom we have to do to the top so", "Txb545UnPkc-00125-00038206-00038382": "across the top what do we have 3 times", "Txb545UnPkc-00126-00038383-00039071": "3x gives us 9 X and 10 times 3 is 30 so", "Txb545UnPkc-00127-00039072-00039264": "we have our common denominator now so", "Txb545UnPkc-00128-00039265-00039451": "we'll keep that same denominator", "Txb545UnPkc-00129-00039452-00040060": "and add across the top 9x + 4 X together", "Txb545UnPkc-00130-00040061-00040681": "gives us what 13 X's all over 30 13 is", "Txb545UnPkc-00131-00040682-00040954": "prime so we can't simplify it at all so", "Txb545UnPkc-00132-00040955-00041374": "we're done and the last one in this case", "Txb545UnPkc-00133-00041375-00041668": "we've got a negative on our first", "Txb545UnPkc-00134-00041669-00041851": "fraction we can give that negative to", "Txb545UnPkc-00135-00041852-00042028": "the 1 so we don't have to deal with it", "Txb545UnPkc-00136-00042029-00042229": "in the denominator so I'm going to go", "Txb545UnPkc-00137-00042230-00042406": "ahead and make note of that right now", "Txb545UnPkc-00138-00042407-00042621": "I'm gonna give the negative to the 1 so", "Txb545UnPkc-00139-00042622-00042952": "we can consider the denominator at 6", "Txb545UnPkc-00140-00042953-00043341": "just to keep it positive so 16 - we want", "Txb545UnPkc-00141-00043342-00043603": "smallest common multiple between those", "Txb545UnPkc-00142-00043604-00044038": "two 2 is prime but 6 can break up into 3", "Txb545UnPkc-00143-00044039-00044254": "& 2 you can probably already tell what's", "Txb545UnPkc-00144-00044255-00044479": "gonna happen our least common", "Txb545UnPkc-00145-00044480-00044860": "denominator has to be divisible by 6 so", "Txb545UnPkc-00146-00044861-00045025": "we'll take all of those factors into", "Txb545UnPkc-00147-00045026-00045274": "account and are we missing anything in", "Txb545UnPkc-00148-00045275-00045631": "our LCD that this other factor has no", "Txb545UnPkc-00149-00045632-00045844": "that are you lives inside of there so", "Txb545UnPkc-00150-00045845-00046192": "the least common denominator is 6 so the", "Txb545UnPkc-00151-00046193-00046402": "first one already has that common", "Txb545UnPkc-00152-00046403-00046693": "denominator so we don't have to alter it", "Txb545UnPkc-00153-00046694-00047110": "we're gonna get negative 1 over 6 but", "Txb545UnPkc-00154-00047111-00047302": "we'll add on to that we're gonna have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00155-00047303-00047587": "change this one's for so they return 2", "Txb545UnPkc-00156-00047588-00047974": "into 6 we have to multiply by 3 whatever", "Txb545UnPkc-00157-00047975-00048175": "we do to the bottom we have to do to the", "Txb545UnPkc-00158-00048176-00048472": "top and across the top what do we get 1", "Txb545UnPkc-00159-00048473-00048952": "times 3 is 3 & 2 times 3 is 6 down below", "Txb545UnPkc-00160-00048953-00049270": "we have our common denominator so we'll", "Txb545UnPkc-00161-00049271-00049690": "just add across the top in between those", "Txb545UnPkc-00162-00049691-00049825": "two which one holds more weight the", "Txb545UnPkc-00163-00049826-00050068": "positive or the negative the positive", "Txb545UnPkc-00164-00050069-00050392": "value and the difference between them is", "Txb545UnPkc-00165-00050393-00050919": "2 + 2 6 can reduce down to what", "Txb545UnPkc-00166-00050920-00051307": "one-third so 2 goes into 2 once and 2", "Txb545UnPkc-00167-00051308-00051595": "goes into 6 three times to reduce down", "Txb545UnPkc-00168-00051596-00051856": "to a third so it's pretty much the same", "Txb545UnPkc-00169-00051857-00052045": "story with subtraction as well but we", "Txb545UnPkc-00170-00052046-00052258": "might as well get some more practice so", "Txb545UnPkc-00171-00052259-00052441": "in our first example when we're", "Txb545UnPkc-00172-00052442-00052649": "subtracting these two we need to have", "Txb545UnPkc-00173-00052650-00052733": "common denominators", "Txb545UnPkc-00174-00052734-00053084": "Nader's so as we build three is prime", "Txb545UnPkc-00175-00053085-00053369": "and eleven is prime so as we build our", "Txb545UnPkc-00176-00053370-00053663": "LCD we have to take into account what", "Txb545UnPkc-00177-00053664-00054065": "factor of three and a factor of 11 so", "Txb545UnPkc-00178-00054066-00054209": "our least common denominator between", "Txb545UnPkc-00179-00054210-00054596": "these two is 33 so we're gonna have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00180-00054597-00054932": "alter both of them to turn 3 into our", "Txb545UnPkc-00181-00054933-00055265": "LCD we have to multiply by 11 and", "Txb545UnPkc-00182-00055266-00055504": "whatever I do to the bottom we have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00183-00055505-00055591": "do to the top", "Txb545UnPkc-00184-00055592-00055879": "so our equivalent fraction coming out of", "Txb545UnPkc-00185-00055880-00056135": "our first term is going to be what 11", "Txb545UnPkc-00186-00056136-00056541": "times 2 is 22 over 11 times 3 which is", "Txb545UnPkc-00187-00056542-00056957": "33 and we'll do the same over here to", "Txb545UnPkc-00188-00056958-00057362": "turn 11 into 33 we have to multiply by 3", "Txb545UnPkc-00189-00057363-00057596": "and whatever we do to the bottom we have", "Txb545UnPkc-00190-00057597-00057812": "to do to the top so we're subtracting", "Txb545UnPkc-00191-00057813-00058295": "off 10 times 3 is 30 up top and 11 times", "Txb545UnPkc-00192-00058296-00058571": "3 33 were just double-checking to make", "Txb545UnPkc-00193-00058572-00058838": "sure we get our common denominator now", "Txb545UnPkc-00194-00058839-00059107": "that we do have that common denominator", "Txb545UnPkc-00195-00059108-00059462": "we can just subtract across the top keep", "Txb545UnPkc-00196-00059463-00059765": "the same denominator and as we combine", "Txb545UnPkc-00197-00059766-00059929": "those numerators which one holds more", "Txb545UnPkc-00198-00059930-00060257": "weight the positive or the negative the", "Txb545UnPkc-00199-00060258-00060464": "negative and what's the difference", "Txb545UnPkc-00200-00060465-00061085": "between 30 and 22 we get minus 8 over 33", "Txb545UnPkc-00201-00061086-00061429": "and can they reduce that down nope so", "Txb545UnPkc-00202-00061430-00061729": "we're done moving on to the next one we", "Txb545UnPkc-00203-00061730-00062159": "want a common denominator between 4 14", "Txb545UnPkc-00204-00062160-00062528": "and 7 so let's take each of those and", "Txb545UnPkc-00205-00062529-00062822": "break them into their primes 4 can be", "Txb545UnPkc-00206-00062823-00063122": "broken up into 2 & 2 both of which are", "Txb545UnPkc-00207-00063123-00063638": "prime 14 can be broken up into 2 & 7", "Txb545UnPkc-00208-00063639-00064040": "both of which are prime and 7 are T is", "Txb545UnPkc-00209-00064041-00064397": "prime so when we build our LCD it has to", "Txb545UnPkc-00210-00064398-00064595": "be divisible by what I'm just going to", "Txb545UnPkc-00211-00064596-00064889": "start with 4 so we'll take two twos into", "Txb545UnPkc-00212-00064890-00065153": "account and it also has to be divisible", "Txb545UnPkc-00213-00065154-00065530": "by 14 so what is our LCD missing that 14", "Txb545UnPkc-00214-00065532-00065870": "has a factor of 7 and are we missing", "Txb545UnPkc-00215-00065871-00066098": "anything in our LCD that this last term", "Txb545UnPkc-00216-00066099-00066140": "has", "Txb545UnPkc-00217-00066141-00066340": "nope we've already got that into account", "Txb545UnPkc-00218-00066341-00066781": "so 2 times 2 is 4 and 4 times 7 we get", "Txb545UnPkc-00219-00066782-00067204": "28 our common denominator so each of", "Txb545UnPkc-00220-00067205-00067498": "those we want to rewrite with that", "Txb545UnPkc-00221-00067499-00067735": "common denominator of 28 and we'll", "Txb545UnPkc-00222-00067736-00067954": "assign the negative to the numerator so", "Txb545UnPkc-00223-00067955-00068146": "we don't have to deal with any negatives", "Txb545UnPkc-00224-00068147-00068605": "down below so to turn 4 into 28 what do", "Txb545UnPkc-00225-00068606-00068998": "we have to multiply by 7 and whatever we", "Txb545UnPkc-00226-00068999-00069205": "do to the bottom we have to do to the", "Txb545UnPkc-00227-00069206-00069226": "top", "Txb545UnPkc-00228-00069227-00069652": "so our equivalent fraction negative 3/4", "Txb545UnPkc-00229-00069653-00070075": "is the same as what 7 times negative 3", "Txb545UnPkc-00230-00070076-00070843": "gives us negative 21 over 28 to turn 14", "Txb545UnPkc-00231-00070844-00071187": "into 28 we have to multiply by 2", "Txb545UnPkc-00232-00071188-00071476": "whatever we do to the bottom we have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00233-00071477-00071566": "do to the top", "Txb545UnPkc-00234-00071567-00072037": "so we've got negative 1 times 2 which", "Txb545UnPkc-00235-00072038-00072521": "will give us that negative 2 over 28 and", "Txb545UnPkc-00236-00072522-00072754": "then it turns 7 into 28 we have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00237-00072755-00073084": "multiply by 4 whatever we do to the", "Txb545UnPkc-00238-00073085-00073327": "bottom we have to do to the top so we're", "Txb545UnPkc-00239-00073328-00073489": "adding on oh because that one was", "Txb545UnPkc-00240-00073490-00073776": "positive 6 times 4 is 24", "Txb545UnPkc-00241-00073777-00074212": "7 times 4 28 so we have that common", "Txb545UnPkc-00242-00074213-00074431": "denominator everywhere and again the", "Txb545UnPkc-00243-00074432-00074560": "negatives will just give it to the", "Txb545UnPkc-00244-00074561-00074746": "numerator so all of the denominators", "Txb545UnPkc-00245-00074747-00075049": "will match so we keep our common", "Txb545UnPkc-00246-00075050-00075253": "denominator of 28 and we're combining", "Txb545UnPkc-00247-00075254-00075814": "together negative 21 minus 2 plus 24 so", "Txb545UnPkc-00248-00075815-00076168": "as we work from left to right we've got", "Txb545UnPkc-00249-00076169-00076402": "two negatives together so that will give", "Txb545UnPkc-00250-00076403-00076774": "us a negative more negative and the sum", "Txb545UnPkc-00251-00076775-00077107": "of those two gives us 23 and we still", "Txb545UnPkc-00252-00077108-00077290": "have to add 24 onto that", "Txb545UnPkc-00253-00077291-00077497": "so which one holds more weight between", "Txb545UnPkc-00254-00077498-00077623": "these two the positive or the negative", "Txb545UnPkc-00255-00077624-00077905": "the positive and the difference between", "Txb545UnPkc-00256-00077906-00078453": "them is 1 so all of that reduces down to", "Txb545UnPkc-00257-00078454-00078880": "128 and we're gonna do the same on our", "Txb545UnPkc-00258-00078881-00079160": "last example here before you try a few", "Txb545UnPkc-00259-00079161-00079591": "and number two we don't have a", "Txb545UnPkc-00260-00079592-00079850": "traditional fraction so we could always", "Txb545UnPkc-00261-00079851-00080312": "put two over what over one if we need to", "Txb545UnPkc-00262-00080313-00080537": "see it like that and then what is our", "Txb545UnPkc-00263-00080538-00080786": "least common denominator between one and", "Txb545UnPkc-00264-00080787-00081149": "three three so we only have to alter", "Txb545UnPkc-00265-00081150-00081410": "this first one and to turn one into", "Txb545UnPkc-00266-00081411-00081664": "three we have to multiply by three", "Txb545UnPkc-00267-00081665-00081929": "whatever I do to the bottom we have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00268-00081930-00082181": "do to the top so what is our equivalent", "Txb545UnPkc-00269-00082182-00082505": "fraction we've got 3 times 2 which is 6", "Txb545UnPkc-00270-00082506-00082787": "and 3 times 1 which is 3", "Txb545UnPkc-00271-00082788-00083066": "and we can always double check is 6", "Txb545UnPkc-00272-00083067-00083405": "divided by 3 really - yeah and then our", "Txb545UnPkc-00273-00083406-00083615": "other one you already have that common", "Txb545UnPkc-00274-00083616-00083927": "denominator so since we have the common", "Txb545UnPkc-00275-00083928-00084188": "denominator we keep that and we add or", "Txb545UnPkc-00276-00084189-00084434": "subtract across the top and those two", "Txb545UnPkc-00277-00084435-00084656": "are not like terms so we're simplified", "Txb545UnPkc-00278-00084657-00084980": "we can't go any farther so there's three", "Txb545UnPkc-00279-00084981-00085235": "for you to try combine these guys", "Txb545UnPkc-00280-00085236-00085292": "together", "Txb545UnPkc-00281-00085293-00085748": "and in Part A what's our LCD between 7", "Txb545UnPkc-00282-00085749-00086513": "and 21 the LCD is 21 to turn 7 into 21", "Txb545UnPkc-00283-00086514-00086825": "what do we have to multiply by 3 and", "Txb545UnPkc-00284-00086826-00087089": "whatever we do to the bottom we have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00285-00087090-00087191": "do to the top", "Txb545UnPkc-00286-00087192-00087461": "so our equivalent fraction is now going", "Txb545UnPkc-00287-00087462-00087836": "to become a lot 3 times 2 is 6", "Txb545UnPkc-00288-00087837-00088229": "3 times 7 is 21 and we didn't have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00289-00088230-00088547": "alter the second one so now that we have", "Txb545UnPkc-00290-00088548-00088793": "common denominators we keep the same", "Txb545UnPkc-00291-00088794-00089156": "denominator and add across the top so 6", "Txb545UnPkc-00292-00089157-00089440": "and 8 together is going to give us what", "Txb545UnPkc-00293-00089441-00090089": "14 both of these share 1 in common a 7 7", "Txb545UnPkc-00294-00090090-00090497": "goes into 14 how many times twice and 7", "Txb545UnPkc-00295-00090498-00090833": "goes into 21 how many times 3 times so", "Txb545UnPkc-00296-00090834-00091340": "this will reduce down to 2/3 and in Part", "Txb545UnPkc-00297-00091341-00092135": "B LCD between 5 and 20 is 20 and with", "Txb545UnPkc-00298-00092136-00092285": "our negative we'll assign it to the", "Txb545UnPkc-00299-00092286-00092416": "numerator", "Txb545UnPkc-00300-00092417-00092712": "5 into 20 what do we have to multiply by", "Txb545UnPkc-00301-00092713-00093049": "4 whatever we do to the bottom we have", "Txb545UnPkc-00302-00093050-00093343": "to do to the top so I've got 4 times", "Txb545UnPkc-00303-00093344-00093664": "negative 1 which will give me negative 4", "Txb545UnPkc-00304-00093665-00094132": "all over 4 times 5 which is 20 plus 9", "Txb545UnPkc-00305-00094133-00094429": "twentieths so we have our common", "Txb545UnPkc-00306-00094430-00094669": "denominator we keep it and we add across", "Txb545UnPkc-00307-00094670-00095074": "the top negative 4 plus 9 which one", "Txb545UnPkc-00308-00095075-00095221": "holds more weight between those two of", "Txb545UnPkc-00309-00095222-00095422": "the positive or the negative the", "Txb545UnPkc-00310-00095423-00095623": "positive and what's the difference", "Txb545UnPkc-00311-00095624-00096030": "between 9 and 4 we get 5 over 20 and", "Txb545UnPkc-00312-00096031-00096409": "they both share one in common of 5 so 5", "Txb545UnPkc-00313-00096410-00096766": "goes into 5 once and 5 goes into 20 four", "Txb545UnPkc-00314-00096767-00097189": "times so that reduces down to 1/4 and", "Txb545UnPkc-00315-00097190-00097612": "then in Part C the LCD might be a little", "Txb545UnPkc-00316-00097613-00097885": "bit larger so let's break these ones", "Txb545UnPkc-00317-00097886-00098164": "down we want to take 8 and break it into", "Txb545UnPkc-00318-00098165-00098731": "the primes 3 + 12 3 is already prime so", "Txb545UnPkc-00319-00098732-00099010": "the ones that require work are 8 12 8", "Txb545UnPkc-00320-00099011-00099391": "can break up into 4 + 2 + 4 breaks up", "Txb545UnPkc-00321-00099392-00099775": "into 2 into 12 it doesn't matter how we", "Txb545UnPkc-00322-00099776-00100438": "start 6 + 2 & 6 breaks up into 3 & 2 so", "Txb545UnPkc-00323-00100439-00100594": "we have all of our primes and let's", "Txb545UnPkc-00324-00100595-00101032": "build that LCD so that LCD has to be", "Txb545UnPkc-00325-00101033-00101296": "divisible by what by 8 so we'll take all", "Txb545UnPkc-00326-00101297-00101554": "of those factors into account and what", "Txb545UnPkc-00327-00101555-00101908": "is our LCD MSE not 3 has a factor of 3", "Txb545UnPkc-00328-00101909-00102235": "and are we missing anything here that 12", "Txb545UnPkc-00329-00102236-00102529": "has no we've taken all of those into", "Txb545UnPkc-00330-00102530-00102838": "account so I've got 2 times 2 is 4 times", "Txb545UnPkc-00331-00102839-00103447": "another 2 is 8 and 8 times 3 is 24 so we", "Txb545UnPkc-00332-00103448-00103648": "have our common denominator to work with", "Txb545UnPkc-00333-00103649-00104053": "let's use that to alter all of these so", "Txb545UnPkc-00334-00104054-00104302": "to turn 18 to 24 what do we have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00335-00104303-00104827": "multiply by 3 top and bottom and I'm", "Txb545UnPkc-00336-00104828-00104977": "going to make a little bit more room for", "Txb545UnPkc-00337-00104978-00105304": "myself right here to turn 3 into 24 what", "Txb545UnPkc-00338-00105305-00105658": "do we have to multiply by 8 whenever we", "Txb545UnPkc-00339-00105658-00105746": "do to the bottom", "Txb545UnPkc-00340-00105747-00106001": "we have to do to the top and then to", "Txb545UnPkc-00341-00106002-00106414": "turn 12 into 24 we have to multiply by 2", "Txb545UnPkc-00342-00106415-00106667": "so let's write down our equivalent", "Txb545UnPkc-00343-00106668-00106889": "fractions that we're working with all", "Txb545UnPkc-00344-00106890-00107138": "the way on the left 3 times 5 gives us", "Txb545UnPkc-00345-00107139-00107813": "15 24 and we're subtracting off 8 24 and", "Txb545UnPkc-00346-00107814-00108191": "we're subtracting off to 24 so now that", "Txb545UnPkc-00347-00108192-00108401": "we have that common denominator we'll", "Txb545UnPkc-00348-00108402-00108692": "keep it and we'll just add across the", "Txb545UnPkc-00349-00108693-00109258": "top I've got 15 minus 8 minus 2 I'd like", "Txb545UnPkc-00350-00109259-00109507": "to see what we get in the end our total", "Txb545UnPkc-00351-00109508-00109925": "15 minus 8 is going to give us what 5 6", "Txb545UnPkc-00352-00109926-00110642": "7 8 7 7 minus 2 we get 5 and can I", "Txb545UnPkc-00353-00110643-00110972": "reduce that any farther no 5 and 24", "Txb545UnPkc-00354-00110973-00111194": "don't share anything in common so we", "Txb545UnPkc-00355-00111195-00111443": "also need the LCD for more concepts like", "Txb545UnPkc-00356-00111444-00111583": "when we're trying to compare two", "Txb545UnPkc-00357-00111584-00111830": "fractions for example if we want to", "Txb545UnPkc-00358-00111831-00112205": "compare 3/4 and 9/11 to talk about which", "Txb545UnPkc-00359-00112206-00112445": "one is larger or smaller they have to be", "Txb545UnPkc-00360-00112446-00112654": "divided into the same number of pieces", "Txb545UnPkc-00361-00112655-00113357": "so what is our LCD between 4 and 11 so", "Txb545UnPkc-00362-00113358-00113693": "11 is prime and 4 has factors of 2", "Txb545UnPkc-00363-00113694-00113939": "living inside of it so they don't share", "Txb545UnPkc-00364-00113940-00114245": "any common factors so our LCD we're", "Txb545UnPkc-00365-00114246-00114419": "gonna have to take into account a factor", "Txb545UnPkc-00366-00114420-00114971": "of 4 and a factor of 11 so 44 is our", "Txb545UnPkc-00367-00114972-00115439": "common denominator so to turn 4 into our", "Txb545UnPkc-00368-00115440-00115585": "common denominator we have to multiply", "Txb545UnPkc-00369-00115586-00116008": "by what 11 and whatever we do to the", "Txb545UnPkc-00370-00116009-00116180": "bottom we have to do to the top", "Txb545UnPkc-00371-00116181-00116536": "so our equivalent fraction to 3/4 is", "Txb545UnPkc-00372-00116538-00117158": "what 33 over 44 we've just scaled it up", "Txb545UnPkc-00373-00117158-00117557": "and to turn 11 into 44 we have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00374-00117558-00118060": "multiply by 4 so across the top 9 times", "Txb545UnPkc-00375-00118061-00118403": "4 we get 36 and across the bottom", "Txb545UnPkc-00376-00118404-00118783": "11 times 4 we get 44 so now we can", "Txb545UnPkc-00377-00118784-00118982": "actually compare between the two since", "Txb545UnPkc-00378-00118983-00119117": "they're divided into the", "Txb545UnPkc-00379-00119118-00119342": "number of pieces so which of these is", "Txb545UnPkc-00380-00119343-00119699": "larger 36 is larger than 33", "Txb545UnPkc-00381-00119700-00120314": "so we could say 33 44 is less than 36 44", "Txb545UnPkc-00382-00120315-00120684": "and since we didn't flip-flop any sides", "Txb545UnPkc-00383-00120685-00120929": "that inequality is still going to hold", "Txb545UnPkc-00384-00120930-00121301": "for our reduced fractions as well so", "Txb545UnPkc-00385-00121302-00121525": "we're going to do the same thing in B", "Txb545UnPkc-00386-00121526-00121745": "first we have to find common", "Txb545UnPkc-00387-00121746-00121916": "denominators and we'll give the", "Txb545UnPkc-00388-00121917-00122198": "negatives to the numerator so our LCD", "Txb545UnPkc-00389-00122199-00122597": "has to be divisible by what by 7 and it", "Txb545UnPkc-00390-00122598-00122942": "also has to be divisible by 3 so the", "Txb545UnPkc-00391-00122943-00123314": "least common between those two is 21 so", "Txb545UnPkc-00392-00123315-00123566": "that turns 7 into 21 we have to multiply", "Txb545UnPkc-00393-00123567-00123926": "by 3 and whatever we do to the bottom we", "Txb545UnPkc-00394-00123927-00124163": "have to do to the top so across the top", "Txb545UnPkc-00395-00124164-00124406": "what do we get negative 2 times 3 is", "Txb545UnPkc-00396-00124407-00124763": "negative 6 and down below 7 times 3 is", "Txb545UnPkc-00397-00124764-00124874": "21", "Txb545UnPkc-00398-00124875-00125311": "and to turn 3 into 21 we have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00399-00125313-00125729": "multiply by 7 top and bottom so across", "Txb545UnPkc-00400-00125730-00125975": "the top what do we get negative 1 times", "Txb545UnPkc-00401-00125976-00126577": "7 is negative 7 and then 3 times 7 is 21", "Txb545UnPkc-00402-00126578-00127079": "so which of those is larger negative 6", "Txb545UnPkc-00403-00127080-00127486": "or negative 7 so I always like to draw a", "Txb545UnPkc-00404-00127488-00127727": "little number line to get adjust of what", "Txb545UnPkc-00405-00127728-00127925": "we're talking about in this case when", "Txb545UnPkc-00406-00127926-00128138": "our numbers are negative so if zeros", "Txb545UnPkc-00407-00128139-00128498": "here negative 6 is to the left of that", "Txb545UnPkc-00408-00128499-00128756": "value and negative 7 is just a little", "Txb545UnPkc-00409-00128757-00129098": "bit more to the left of that value so as", "Txb545UnPkc-00410-00129099-00129266": "we move through the Ray it gets larger", "Txb545UnPkc-00411-00129267-00129563": "and more positive so negative 6 is", "Txb545UnPkc-00412-00129564-00129977": "larger than negative 7 so negative 6 out", "Txb545UnPkc-00413-00129978-00130183": "of 21 is gonna have to be larger then", "Txb545UnPkc-00414-00130184-00130472": "you just 7 out of 21 which means again", "Txb545UnPkc-00415-00130473-00130583": "we can go all the way back to our", "Txb545UnPkc-00416-00130583-00130838": "reduced fractions and that inequality is", "Txb545UnPkc-00417-00130839-00131111": "still going to hold all right we can", "Txb545UnPkc-00418-00131112-00131450": "also evaluate an expression when we have", "Txb545UnPkc-00419-00131451-00131660": "different denominators like this and", "Txb545UnPkc-00420-00131661-00131852": "we'll have to make common denominators", "Txb545UnPkc-00421-00131853-00132110": "to combine them together so if we want", "Txb545UnPkc-00422-00132111-00132458": "to evaluate X minus y when x", "Txb545UnPkc-00423-00132459-00132800": "is equal to 7/18 so we'll just start", "Txb545UnPkc-00424-00132801-00133121": "plugging in and our Y value is two", "Txb545UnPkc-00425-00133122-00133511": "ninths so we want to be able to combine", "Txb545UnPkc-00426-00133512-00133781": "those two together so what is the least", "Txb545UnPkc-00427-00133782-00133988": "common denominator that we're working", "Txb545UnPkc-00428-00133989-00134590": "with 18 since 9 is a factor inside of 18", "Txb545UnPkc-00429-00134591-00134843": "so we don't have to touch this one but 9", "Txb545UnPkc-00430-00134844-00135059": "we're gonna have to multiply by what to", "Txb545UnPkc-00431-00135060-00135410": "get us to 18 to whatever we do to the", "Txb545UnPkc-00432-00135411-00135659": "bottom we have to do to the top so our", "Txb545UnPkc-00433-00135660-00135976": "equivalent fraction we've got 7/18 -", "Txb545UnPkc-00434-00135977-00136414": "what 2 times 2 is 4 and 9 times 2 is 18", "Txb545UnPkc-00435-00136415-00136694": "we're just double-checking making sure", "Txb545UnPkc-00436-00136695-00136976": "we have the correct denominator and we", "Txb545UnPkc-00437-00136977-00137428": "do and as we subtract across the top 7", "Txb545UnPkc-00438-00137429-00138011": "minus 4 gives us left 3 over 18 both of", "Txb545UnPkc-00439-00138012-00138224": "those share a 3 in common so we can", "Txb545UnPkc-00440-00138225-00138589": "reduce it down even farther 3 goes into", "Txb545UnPkc-00441-00138590-00139025": "3 how many times once and 3 goes into 18", "Txb545UnPkc-00442-00139026-00139414": "how many times 6 so that guy can reduce", "Txb545UnPkc-00443-00139415-00139826": "down to 1/6 so the last thing is for you", "Txb545UnPkc-00444-00139827-00140144": "to try compare these two by first making", "Txb545UnPkc-00445-00140145-00140618": "a common denominator so let's take 8 our", "Txb545UnPkc-00446-00140619-00140882": "first denominator in 20 and break them", "Txb545UnPkc-00447-00140883-00141200": "up into the primes so 8 we can break up", "Txb545UnPkc-00448-00141201-00141575": "into 4 and 2 2 is prime for can keep", "Txb545UnPkc-00449-00141576-00141944": "going and we're done there 20 we can", "Txb545UnPkc-00450-00141945-00142337": "break up into 4 and 5 5 is prime but", "Txb545UnPkc-00451-00142338-00142763": "four keeps breaking up so our LCD has to", "Txb545UnPkc-00452-00142764-00142922": "be divisible by one of them so I'm going", "Txb545UnPkc-00453-00142923-00143225": "to take all of my twos from 8 into", "Txb545UnPkc-00454-00143226-00143486": "account and what is our LCD missing that", "Txb545UnPkc-00455-00143487-00143909": "20 has a factor of 5 so the least common", "Txb545UnPkc-00456-00143910-00144287": "denominator between 8 and 20 is what so", "Txb545UnPkc-00457-00144288-00144545": "I've got 5 times 2 is 10 times another 2", "Txb545UnPkc-00458-00144546-00145094": "is 20 times another 2 is 40 so to turn 8", "Txb545UnPkc-00459-00145095-00145365": "into 40 what did you have to multiply by", "Txb545UnPkc-00460-00145366-00145793": "5 over 5 what we do to the bottom when", "Txb545UnPkc-00461-00145794-00145810": "you", "Txb545UnPkc-00462-00145811-00146104": "to do to the top and to turn 20 into our", "Txb545UnPkc-00463-00146105-00146557": "LCD we have to multiply by two so what", "Txb545UnPkc-00464-00146558-00146701": "are our equivalent fractions that were", "Txb545UnPkc-00465-00146702-00146992": "working with five times five is 25", "Txb545UnPkc-00466-00146993-00147352": "eight times five is forty eight and over", "Txb545UnPkc-00467-00147353-00147520": "here eleven times two we get twenty two", "Txb545UnPkc-00468-00147521-00147874": "and twenty times two we got 40 so we've", "Txb545UnPkc-00469-00147875-00148180": "got our common denominators and 25 is", "Txb545UnPkc-00470-00148181-00148519": "larger than 22 and if we go up to our", "Txb545UnPkc-00471-00148520-00148711": "reduced fraction that inequality is", "Txb545UnPkc-00472-00148712-00148882": "still going to hold so the last two", "Txb545UnPkc-00473-00148883-00149050": "examples in this section are just", "Txb545UnPkc-00474-00149051-00149287": "application problems we'll have to build", "Txb545UnPkc-00475-00149288-00149497": "the expression and combine it from there", "Txb545UnPkc-00476-00149498-00149812": "so very first we've got a semi and it's", "Txb545UnPkc-00477-00149813-00150244": "got 1/4 of a ton of computers one-third", "Txb545UnPkc-00478-00150245-00150565": "of a ton of televisions and 3/8 of a ton", "Txb545UnPkc-00479-00150566-00150853": "of small appliances and we want to find", "Txb545UnPkc-00480-00150854-00151198": "the total weight of the load so that", "Txb545UnPkc-00481-00151199-00151471": "word total implies what operation", "Txb545UnPkc-00482-00151472-00151717": "addition we're just combining them all", "Txb545UnPkc-00483-00151718-00151996": "together so the first example what do we", "Txb545UnPkc-00484-00151997-00152218": "want to combine the first weight that", "Txb545UnPkc-00485-00152219-00152650": "they gave us was 1/4 of a ton and we're", "Txb545UnPkc-00486-00152651-00152815": "adding on to that the second weight", "Txb545UnPkc-00487-00152816-00153271": "which was one-third of a ton and the", "Txb545UnPkc-00488-00153272-00153664": "last one was three-eighths of a ton so", "Txb545UnPkc-00489-00153665-00153802": "we want to be able to combine all of", "Txb545UnPkc-00490-00153803-00154078": "those together to find the total so we", "Txb545UnPkc-00491-00154079-00154423": "have to find the LCD between what four", "Txb545UnPkc-00492-00154424-00154849": "three and eight so off on the side let's", "Txb545UnPkc-00493-00154850-00155194": "break up four into its primes two and", "Txb545UnPkc-00494-00155195-00155764": "two and three is already prime and eight", "Txb545UnPkc-00495-00155765-00156064": "can break up into four and two and four", "Txb545UnPkc-00496-00156065-00156394": "can break up into two into so we've got", "Txb545UnPkc-00497-00156395-00156622": "all of the primes present and what is", "Txb545UnPkc-00498-00156623-00156964": "our LCD going to be has to be divisible", "Txb545UnPkc-00499-00156965-00157258": "by four so we'll take two factors of two", "Txb545UnPkc-00500-00157259-00157510": "into account it also has to be divisible", "Txb545UnPkc-00501-00157511-00157732": "by three so what are we missing down", "Txb545UnPkc-00502-00157733-00158086": "here that three has factor of three and", "Txb545UnPkc-00503-00158087-00158359": "what is our LCD missing that eight has", "Txb545UnPkc-00504-00158360-00158803": "another factor of two so our LCD between", "Txb545UnPkc-00505-00158804-00159082": "all three of these is going to be 1/2", "Txb545UnPkc-00506-00159083-00159170": "times 2 is", "Txb545UnPkc-00507-00159171-00159913": "4 times 3 is 12 times 2 is 24 so the", "Txb545UnPkc-00508-00159914-00160226": "least common multiple between 4 3 & 8 is", "Txb545UnPkc-00509-00160227-00160564": "24 so let's build our equivalent", "Txb545UnPkc-00510-00160565-00160963": "fractions to turn 4 into 24 we have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00511-00160964-00161375": "multiply by what 6 whatever we do to the", "Txb545UnPkc-00512-00161376-00161566": "bottom we have to do to the top", "Txb545UnPkc-00513-00161567-00161902": "and to turn 3 into 24 we have to", "Txb545UnPkc-00514-00161903-00162362": "multiply by 8 top and bottom and to turn", "Txb545UnPkc-00515-00162363-00162884": "8 into 24 we have to multiply by 3 so", "Txb545UnPkc-00516-00162885-00163078": "what is our equivalent expression", "Txb545UnPkc-00517-00163079-00163373": "looking like first term is now going to", "Txb545UnPkc-00518-00163374-00163823": "become 6 over 24 and we're adding on to", "Txb545UnPkc-00519-00163824-00164243": "that each over 24 and we're adding on to", "Txb545UnPkc-00520-00164244-00164783": "that 9 over 24 so now that we have that", "Txb545UnPkc-00521-00164784-00165020": "common denominator let's just add across", "Txb545UnPkc-00522-00165021-00165563": "the top got 6 8 & 9 together and that's", "Txb545UnPkc-00523-00165564-00165952": "all over 24 so as we combine from left", "Txb545UnPkc-00524-00165953-00166307": "to right everything is positive 6 & 8", "Txb545UnPkc-00525-00166308-00166685": "together gives us what 14 and we've got", "Txb545UnPkc-00526-00166686-00166990": "14 and 9 that we're adding together for", "Txb545UnPkc-00527-00166991-00167389": "our numerator so 9 + 4 gives us 13 carry", "Txb545UnPkc-00528-00167390-00168113": "the 1 1 in 1 we get 23 24 and what are", "Txb545UnPkc-00529-00168114-00168304": "the units on this thing we found the", "Txb545UnPkc-00530-00168305-00168725": "total weight of the semis load and those", "Txb545UnPkc-00531-00168726-00169093": "units were reported in tons so we have", "Txb545UnPkc-00532-00169094-00169709": "23 years twenty-fourths of a ton total", "Txb545UnPkc-00533-00169710-00170219": "weight super-heavy okay next one similar", "Txb545UnPkc-00534-00170220-00170510": "story we've got a flight from Tucson to", "Txb545UnPkc-00535-00170511-00170882": "Phoenix Arizona and it requires 5/12 of", "Txb545UnPkc-00536-00170883-00171178": "an hour and if a plane has been flying", "Txb545UnPkc-00537-00171179-00171560": "for 1/4 of an hour so far find how much", "Txb545UnPkc-00538-00171561-00172037": "time remains before landing so the", "Txb545UnPkc-00539-00172038-00172385": "entire flight requires how much time 5", "Txb545UnPkc-00540-00172386-00172530": "12", "Txb545UnPkc-00541-00172531-00172827": "of an hour so that's what we're starting", "Txb545UnPkc-00542-00172828-00173172": "with and we're removing off the amount", "Txb545UnPkc-00543-00173173-00173382": "that it's already flown and it's already", "Txb545UnPkc-00544-00173383-00173540": "flown for how long", "Txb545UnPkc-00545-00173541-00173874": "1/4 of an hour so the time remaining", "Txb545UnPkc-00546-00173875-00174048": "what's left over it's gonna be the", "Txb545UnPkc-00547-00174049-00174282": "difference between those two so our", "Txb545UnPkc-00548-00174283-00174624": "total length for the flight minus the", "Txb545UnPkc-00549-00174625-00174807": "amount that it's already been in the air", "Txb545UnPkc-00550-00174808-00175239": "for will give us their remaining so we", "Txb545UnPkc-00551-00175240-00175563": "want to find the LCD between 12 and 4", "Txb545UnPkc-00552-00175564-00176106": "and what is our LCD 12 so we already", "Txb545UnPkc-00553-00176107-00176352": "have our common denominator over here to", "Txb545UnPkc-00554-00176353-00176720": "turn 4 into 12 we have to multiply by 3", "Txb545UnPkc-00555-00176721-00177015": "top and bottom so our equivalent", "Txb545UnPkc-00556-00177016-00177645": "expression we've got 5 12 minus 3 12 now", "Txb545UnPkc-00557-00177646-00177791": "that we have the common denominator", "Txb545UnPkc-00558-00177792-00178095": "we'll just subtract across the top and", "Txb545UnPkc-00559-00178096-00178758": "what is 5 minus 3 we get to 212 which", "Txb545UnPkc-00560-00178759-00179145": "reduces down to what so 2 goes into 2", "Txb545UnPkc-00561-00179146-00179556": "once and 2 goes into 12 6 times", "Txb545UnPkc-00562-00179557-00180023": "so how much time is remaining 1/6 of", "Txb545UnPkc-00563-00180024-00180507": "what unit time an hour so I've got 1/6", "Txb545UnPkc-00564-00180508-00181245": "of an hour remaining but usually we", "Txb545UnPkc-00565-00181246-00181470": "don't talk in those terms we could say a", "Txb545UnPkc-00566-00181471-00181737": "half an hour remaining but we usually", "Txb545UnPkc-00567-00181738-00181986": "don't break it into sixths so what is", "Txb545UnPkc-00568-00181987-00182436": "1/6 of an hour an hour is worth how many", "Txb545UnPkc-00569-00182437-00182826": "minutes 60 minutes so 1 hour is 60", "Txb545UnPkc-00570-00182827-00183186": "minutes so if we take 60 minutes and", "Txb545UnPkc-00571-00183187-00183465": "divide it into six different pieces how", "Txb545UnPkc-00572-00183466-00183795": "much time do we have left another way to", "Txb545UnPkc-00573-00183796-00184429": "say it or 10 minutes remaining", "Txb545UnPkc-00574-00184430-00184636": "a little bit more practical for everyday", "Txb545UnPkc-00575-00184637-00184864": "life"}}, {"audio_id": "TyhPkNDonWk", "text": {"TyhPkNDonWk-00000-00002257-00003023": "[Music]", "TyhPkNDonWk-00001-00003024-00003311": "[Applause]", "TyhPkNDonWk-00002-00003313-00005201": "[Music]", "TyhPkNDonWk-00003-00005202-00006659": "[Music]", "TyhPkNDonWk-00004-00006659-00007759": "[Music]", "TyhPkNDonWk-00005-00007761-00008753": "[Music]", "TyhPkNDonWk-00006-00008754-00009925": "[Music]", "TyhPkNDonWk-00007-00009926-00010583": "[Music]", "TyhPkNDonWk-00008-00010584-00010884": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "TyB7_LASMyo", "text": {"TyB7_LASMyo-00000-00000752-00001140": "welcome back to edge chat interactive", "TyB7_LASMyo-00001-00001141-00001399": "it's great to be here Mitch coming at", "TyB7_LASMyo-00002-00001400-00001692": "you from a some random hotel room and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00003-00001693-00001942": "bitter cold Newark New Jersey if I open", "TyB7_LASMyo-00004-00001943-00002089": "up my windows you see a nice parking", "TyB7_LASMyo-00005-00002090-00002323": "garage so thanks for those few issues", "TyB7_LASMyo-00006-00002324-00002539": "there's I worked with some air some", "TyB7_LASMyo-00007-00002540-00002740": "Wi-Fi here at the hotel so we we are", "TyB7_LASMyo-00008-00002741-00002916": "good to go ready to share and thanks for", "TyB7_LASMyo-00009-00002917-00003159": "having me back okay yeah and you know", "TyB7_LASMyo-00010-00003160-00003334": "Newark really isn't that far from from", "TyB7_LASMyo-00011-00003335-00003457": "where we are if I'd known you were in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00012-00003458-00003624": "Newark I could have come and pick you up", "TyB7_LASMyo-00013-00003625-00004107": "you could have been here and it's and by", "TyB7_LASMyo-00014-00004108-00004381": "the way it's it's only about 40 degrees", "TyB7_LASMyo-00015-00004382-00004932": "I mean bitter cold is East is 15 were", "TyB7_LASMyo-00016-00004933-00005095": "you from uh you know I should I should", "TyB7_LASMyo-00017-00005096-00005485": "know this where you from I'll do a quick", "TyB7_LASMyo-00018-00005486-00005656": "intro so everybody if I have a mentions", "TyB7_LASMyo-00019-00005657-00005920": "I currently in Pennsylvania I work out", "TyB7_LASMyo-00020-00005921-00006192": "of Washington DC so Gordon raised in New", "TyB7_LASMyo-00021-00006193-00006414": "York but spent some time in in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00022-00006415-00006570": "Pennsylvania so just again just very", "TyB7_LASMyo-00023-00006572-00006717": "quick perspective because this is not", "TyB7_LASMyo-00024-00006718-00007095": "about me tonight I spent 14 years in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00025-00007097-00007341": "public school and as a teacher as an", "TyB7_LASMyo-00026-00007342-00007485": "elementary principal as a middle school", "TyB7_LASMyo-00027-00007486-00007695": "principal it also spent some time that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00028-00007696-00007837": "district office and then as a tech", "TyB7_LASMyo-00029-00007838-00008002": "director I like to say I obviously", "TyB7_LASMyo-00030-00008003-00008188": "couldn't hold a job so now I work out of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00031-00008189-00008398": "DC and so part of my role I work with", "TyB7_LASMyo-00032-00008399-00008517": "the Senate the Congress the White House", "TyB7_LASMyo-00033-00008518-00008719": "the Department of Ed I'm in a bipartisan", "TyB7_LASMyo-00034-00008720-00008923": "way so yes I will continue to do so", "TyB7_LASMyo-00035-00008924-00009123": "in the next few months and years and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00036-00009124-00009363": "continuing to do but then also is", "TyB7_LASMyo-00037-00009364-00009523": "running Futurity schools and that's what", "TyB7_LASMyo-00038-00009524-00009709": "I'm excited to share I actually spend", "TyB7_LASMyo-00039-00009710-00009862": "all day running Futurity New Jersey", "TyB7_LASMyo-00040-00009863-00010051": "today here in Newark at about 50", "TyB7_LASMyo-00041-00010052-00010239": "district teams all totally free events", "TyB7_LASMyo-00042-00010240-00010392": "and I'm excited to dive in share with", "TyB7_LASMyo-00043-00010393-00010545": "you today everything going to be sharing", "TyB7_LASMyo-00044-00010546-00010770": "today is totally free there is no catch", "TyB7_LASMyo-00045-00010771-00010945": "at all so thanks for investing the time", "TyB7_LASMyo-00046-00010946-00011127": "tonight I know you're all exhausted I'm", "TyB7_LASMyo-00047-00011128-00011284": "sure you all had really long workdays I", "TyB7_LASMyo-00048-00011285-00011352": "know that feeling", "TyB7_LASMyo-00049-00011353-00011595": "even 50 districts today and excited to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00050-00011596-00011703": "be with you all tonight share some", "TyB7_LASMyo-00051-00011704-00011880": "jewels share some resources share some", "TyB7_LASMyo-00052-00011881-00012094": "content but also I built in throughout", "TyB7_LASMyo-00053-00012095-00012295": "the slide deck a number of questions as", "TyB7_LASMyo-00054-00012296-00012420": "well get your thoughts get your feedback", "TyB7_LASMyo-00055-00012421-00012609": "and so you know I'll share for a little", "TyB7_LASMyo-00056-00012610-00012787": "bit I posed a question have you guys", "TyB7_LASMyo-00057-00012788-00012994": "kind of connect share a little bit more", "TyB7_LASMyo-00058-00012994-00013168": "content so on and so forth right up", "TyB7_LASMyo-00059-00013169-00013338": "until about nine o'clock so thanks for", "TyB7_LASMyo-00060-00013340-00013486": "being here and I'm Tom very glad to be", "TyB7_LASMyo-00061-00013487-00013781": "your host tonight", "TyB7_LASMyo-00062-00013782-00014001": "I'm gonna just roll Mitch I'll just keep", "TyB7_LASMyo-00063-00014002-00014178": "going all right next slide keep rolling", "TyB7_LASMyo-00064-00014179-00014421": "through go ahead next slide so to kick", "TyB7_LASMyo-00065-00014422-00014559": "off I do want to start with a thank you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00066-00014560-00014778": "you know I get the opportunity to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00067-00014779-00015057": "present and share alongside audiences", "TyB7_LASMyo-00068-00015058-00015188": "around the country virtually every week", "TyB7_LASMyo-00069-00015190-00015381": "and I will never I promise myself", "TyB7_LASMyo-00070-00015382-00015693": "whether it's it's 3,000 people last week", "TyB7_LASMyo-00071-00015694-00015876": "or whether it's you know just a handful", "TyB7_LASMyo-00072-00015877-00016074": "of people tonight I will never start any", "TyB7_LASMyo-00073-00016075-00016266": "sort of presentation even conversation", "TyB7_LASMyo-00074-00016266-00016455": "about a true thank you thanks for the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00075-00016456-00016596": "work you do every day thanks for loving", "TyB7_LASMyo-00076-00016597-00016809": "kids thanks for being on an edchat", "TyB7_LASMyo-00077-00016810-00017079": "interactive at 8 o'clock at night while", "TyB7_LASMyo-00078-00017080-00017208": "you're home hopefully in your PJs", "TyB7_LASMyo-00079-00017209-00017337": "hopefully with a glass of wine or a beer", "TyB7_LASMyo-00080-00017338-00017532": "often we get to say that during PD right", "TyB7_LASMyo-00081-00017533-00017724": "but truly thanks for all the work that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00082-00017725-00018050": "you're doing every day go ahead next", "TyB7_LASMyo-00083-00018051-00018278": "so I want you to write down two websites", "TyB7_LASMyo-00084-00018279-00018446": "because I don't want you to get to nine", "TyB7_LASMyo-00085-00018447-00018628": "o'clock and oh shoot was the website two", "TyB7_LASMyo-00086-00018629-00018830": "things here one first one future-ready", "TyB7_LASMyo-00087-00018831-00018980": "org so the things that I want to be", "TyB7_LASMyo-00088-00018981-00019124": "sharing are available that's kind of our", "TyB7_LASMyo-00089-00019125-00019385": "home site our main site the second is", "TyB7_LASMyo-00090-00019386-00019522": "actually a resource we share at our", "TyB7_LASMyo-00091-00019523-00019763": "Futurity events and it's so it's bitly", "TyB7_LASMyo-00092-00019764-00019868": "and remember bittley's are case", "TyB7_LASMyo-00093-00019869-00020125": "sensitive so jot down at least FRS for", "TyB7_LASMyo-00094-00020126-00020414": "Futurity schools and then - DW it just", "TyB7_LASMyo-00095-00020415-00020547": "stands for one of the dashboards or", "TyB7_LASMyo-00096-00020548-00020774": "workshops we ran what you're gonna find", "TyB7_LASMyo-00097-00020775-00020918": "on there's a lot of downloadables things", "TyB7_LASMyo-00098-00020919-00021092": "you can share I get every day I'm", "TyB7_LASMyo-00099-00021093-00021280": "Twitter Email those kinds of things but", "TyB7_LASMyo-00100-00021281-00021419": "something I can use with my district but", "TyB7_LASMyo-00101-00021420-00021500": "something I can send to my", "TyB7_LASMyo-00102-00021501-00021665": "superintendent so we've got a lot of our", "TyB7_LASMyo-00103-00021666-00021805": "downloadables there and you're welcome", "TyB7_LASMyo-00104-00021806-00022003": "to use those and anything on those sites", "TyB7_LASMyo-00105-00022004-00022159": "you're welcome to use and be able to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00106-00022160-00022316": "share that stuff as well now don't go", "TyB7_LASMyo-00107-00022317-00022466": "selling it because Futurity is", "TyB7_LASMyo-00108-00022467-00022622": "trademarked by the Alliance for", "TyB7_LASMyo-00109-00022623-00022763": "excellent education but everything", "TyB7_LASMyo-00110-00022764-00022925": "that's downloadable there and whatnot we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00111-00022926-00023265": "encourage you to share next slide", "TyB7_LASMyo-00112-00023266-00023617": "so keep going let's go ahead so welcome", "TyB7_LASMyo-00113-00023618-00023845": "to the future let's talk about I'm gonna", "TyB7_LASMyo-00114-00023846-00023971": "move through these kind of very quickly", "TyB7_LASMyo-00115-00023972-00024163": "here Mitch taking a look and you know we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00116-00024164-00024340": "are seeing this disruptive innovation in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00117-00024341-00024496": "every sector let's hit a couple of these", "TyB7_LASMyo-00118-00024497-00024694": "just got a big picture even step outside", "TyB7_LASMyo-00119-00024695-00024892": "of Education for literally two minutes", "TyB7_LASMyo-00120-00024893-00025018": "you know look at these things there are", "TyB7_LASMyo-00121-00025019-00025228": "these yellow things and I fly literally", "TyB7_LASMyo-00122-00025229-00025432": "every week I took 120 flights last year", "TyB7_LASMyo-00123-00025433-00025513": "in 2016", "TyB7_LASMyo-00124-00025514-00025695": "every week no matter where I fly in I", "TyB7_LASMyo-00125-00025697-00025839": "remember only a couple years ago", "TyB7_LASMyo-00126-00025841-00026044": "standing on a street corner waiting for", "TyB7_LASMyo-00127-00026045-00026254": "these yellow things to pull up and very", "TyB7_LASMyo-00128-00026255-00026416": "rarely I think in the past year and a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00129-00026417-00026641": "half I think I've taken one taxi that's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00130-00026642-00026877": "it what is totally disrupted to space", "TyB7_LASMyo-00131-00026879-00027010": "and look at the next slide there Mitch", "TyB7_LASMyo-00132-00027011-00027195": "taking a look at that what is totally", "TyB7_LASMyo-00133-00027197-00027307": "disrupt this place you're already saying", "TyB7_LASMyo-00134-00027308-00027564": "it uber lyft those kinds of things as we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00135-00027566-00027805": "look at things such as uber or lyft and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00136-00027806-00027988": "just just uber and lyft and we think", "TyB7_LASMyo-00137-00027989-00028257": "about how it totally disrupted the space", "TyB7_LASMyo-00138-00028258-00028537": "go ahead next slide Mitch I told you I'm", "TyB7_LASMyo-00139-00028538-00028735": "going quick look at the disruption in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00140-00028736-00028918": "those areas look at just some of the the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00141-00028919-00029145": "numbers that you can see in such a short", "TyB7_LASMyo-00142-00029147-00029410": "time period that's the first five years", "TyB7_LASMyo-00143-00029411-00029664": "of uber think of that as a growth rate", "TyB7_LASMyo-00144-00029666-00029962": "for that industry looks like as we look", "TyB7_LASMyo-00145-00029963-00030181": "at that look at this it's already being", "TyB7_LASMyo-00146-00030182-00030337": "disrupted and maybe some of you have", "TyB7_LASMyo-00147-00030338-00030547": "seen this now I reside in Pennsylvania", "TyB7_LASMyo-00148-00030548-00030682": "that's kind of what I live at least a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00149-00030683-00030826": "couple days a week I like the joke but", "TyB7_LASMyo-00150-00030827-00030988": "taking a look at that that's already", "TyB7_LASMyo-00151-00030989-00031230": "disrupting uber what is it it is a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00152-00031231-00031510": "self-driving car that does the exact", "TyB7_LASMyo-00153-00031511-00031714": "same thing yes they're testing it you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00154-00031714-00031882": "know that this isn't new you're seeing", "TyB7_LASMyo-00155-00031883-00032017": "this and that's outside of Pittsburgh", "TyB7_LASMyo-00156-00032018-00032200": "that's an article we saw so even the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00157-00032201-00032458": "disrupter of only a few to go is already", "TyB7_LASMyo-00158-00032458-00032664": "disrupting itself and already changing", "TyB7_LASMyo-00159-00032666-00032797": "so it's gonna work in the same way we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00160-00032798-00032974": "pull up the app we do all those things", "TyB7_LASMyo-00161-00032975-00033127": "we click the button and now the car", "TyB7_LASMyo-00162-00033128-00033315": "shows up now I like to joke and say you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00163-00033316-00033415": "know I'm getting these things every week", "TyB7_LASMyo-00164-00033416-00033568": "I'm not getting in a self-driving one", "TyB7_LASMyo-00165-00033569-00033799": "not yet no way not yet not until they've", "TyB7_LASMyo-00166-00033800-00033985": "perfected that right go ahead in the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00167-00033986-00034240": "next slide as we think through the uber", "TyB7_LASMyo-00168-00034241-00034432": "look at this industry I'm just funny cuz", "TyB7_LASMyo-00169-00034433-00034531": "I'm sitting in one of those buildings", "TyB7_LASMyo-00170-00034532-00034789": "right now that industry as we started to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00171-00034790-00034990": "get disrupted next slide was even a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00172-00034991-00035161": "number of years ago when we started to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00173-00035162-00035287": "think about all these this is going back", "TyB7_LASMyo-00174-00035288-00035506": "15 years ago first time you hopped on", "TyB7_LASMyo-00175-00035507-00035725": "like Priceline or Expedia or any of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00176-00035726-00035974": "those sites there it gave you as the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00177-00035975-00036148": "person that was actually taking a look", "TyB7_LASMyo-00178-00036149-00036327": "at gave you power because you could say", "TyB7_LASMyo-00179-00036328-00036493": "hey I'm looking at Newark New Jersey and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00180-00036494-00036526": "I pull", "TyB7_LASMyo-00181-00036527-00036712": "it up there's 200 hotels right there", "TyB7_LASMyo-00182-00036713-00036979": "with a never X radius nobody cares what", "TyB7_LASMyo-00183-00036980-00037153": "Marriott says about itself", "TyB7_LASMyo-00184-00037154-00037297": "nobody cares anymore what the Hilton", "TyB7_LASMyo-00185-00037298-00037546": "says about itself why because the power", "TyB7_LASMyo-00186-00037547-00037726": "comes from what people are saying about", "TyB7_LASMyo-00187-00037727-00037909": "it but people are talking about the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00188-00037910-00038143": "story gave you as the consumer choice it", "TyB7_LASMyo-00189-00038144-00038341": "gave you as the consumer the opportunity", "TyB7_LASMyo-00190-00038342-00038476": "to say look at all these different areas", "TyB7_LASMyo-00191-00038477-00038770": "totally started to disrupt that space as", "TyB7_LASMyo-00192-00038771-00039028": "years ago next slide now look at this", "TyB7_LASMyo-00193-00039029-00039289": "Airbnb anybody occurs zeros been here", "TyB7_LASMyo-00194-00039290-00039517": "and an Airbnb totally disrupting that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00195-00039518-00039721": "space oh the next we look at something", "TyB7_LASMyo-00196-00039722-00039898": "like Airbnb here's just quickly out", "TyB7_LASMyo-00197-00039899-00040081": "started two roommates are out in San", "TyB7_LASMyo-00198-00040082-00040415": "Francisco they got two", "TyB7_LASMyo-00199-00040416-00040595": "together there was actually a conference", "TyB7_LASMyo-00200-00040596-00040773": "coming to town and they said you know", "TyB7_LASMyo-00201-00040774-00040880": "they're having a hard time paying the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00202-00040881-00041021": "rent they said what if we allowed people", "TyB7_LASMyo-00203-00041022-00041298": "to stay in our our little condo here and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00204-00041299-00041514": "they brought in their air bed and we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00205-00041515-00041699": "gave them breakfast for like 30 bucks", "TyB7_LASMyo-00206-00041700-00041855": "and actually that's a screenshot that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00207-00041856-00042105": "you're looking at from the first Airbnb", "TyB7_LASMyo-00208-00042106-00042311": "and it was air bed-and-breakfast but", "TyB7_LASMyo-00209-00042312-00042510": "guess what it's totally done next slide", "TyB7_LASMyo-00210-00042511-00042717": "it's really started to disrupt the space", "TyB7_LASMyo-00211-00042718-00042780": "again", "TyB7_LASMyo-00212-00042781-00042986": "if you think it's by chance that when", "TyB7_LASMyo-00213-00042987-00043173": "you pull into a Marriott or a Hilton and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00214-00043174-00043305": "they're like oh here's your free cookie", "TyB7_LASMyo-00215-00043306-00043514": "go get your free soda here's our free", "TyB7_LASMyo-00216-00043515-00043676": "breakfast well no they're meeting your", "TyB7_LASMyo-00217-00043677-00043889": "demand better why so you don't go stay", "TyB7_LASMyo-00218-00043890-00044073": "at an Airbnb so you still choose them", "TyB7_LASMyo-00219-00044074-00044261": "it's forcing them to innovate forcing", "TyB7_LASMyo-00220-00044262-00044393": "them to do it differently look at that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00221-00044394-00044667": "growth rate I don't think that Marriott", "TyB7_LASMyo-00222-00044668-00044837": "and Hilton have taken notice of Airbnb", "TyB7_LASMyo-00223-00044838-00045299": "it's fascinating in 2017 Airbnb is the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00224-00045300-00045573": "largest hotel chain in the world and it", "TyB7_LASMyo-00225-00045574-00045786": "doesn't own any properties the largest", "TyB7_LASMyo-00226-00045787-00046032": "content provider in the world Facebook", "TyB7_LASMyo-00227-00046033-00046265": "it doesn't provide any content the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00228-00046266-00046467": "largest taxi service in the world it", "TyB7_LASMyo-00229-00046468-00046852": "doesn't own any human driven taxis", "TyB7_LASMyo-00230-00046853-00047183": "that's boomer that the largest movie", "TyB7_LASMyo-00231-00047184-00047495": "cinema in the world it doesn't own any", "TyB7_LASMyo-00232-00047496-00047780": "cinemas that's Netflix completely", "TyB7_LASMyo-00233-00047781-00047980": "contrasting 10 or 15 years ago", "TyB7_LASMyo-00234-00047981-00048186": "fascinating we think about that next", "TyB7_LASMyo-00235-00048187-00048426": "slide let me take a look at and we look", "TyB7_LASMyo-00236-00048427-00048611": "at this industry just all these", "TyB7_LASMyo-00237-00048612-00048804": "companies that you're looking at 10", "TyB7_LASMyo-00238-00048805-00049086": "years ago didn't even exist and within", "TyB7_LASMyo-00239-00049087-00049352": "10 years are worth over a billion", "TyB7_LASMyo-00240-00049353-00049767": "dollars think about that some of us are", "TyB7_LASMyo-00241-00049768-00049905": "looking like Pinterest and those kinds", "TyB7_LASMyo-00242-00049906-00050067": "thing as time you spend on these kinds", "TyB7_LASMyo-00243-00050068-00050246": "of Twitter Facebook all these types of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00244-00050247-00050465": "things in a daily basis and for those", "TyB7_LASMyo-00245-00050466-00050595": "the ones you're looking at 10 years ago", "TyB7_LASMyo-00246-00050596-00050895": "didn't exist next slide as we look at", "TyB7_LASMyo-00247-00050896-00051101": "the moving forward let's then talk about", "TyB7_LASMyo-00248-00051102-00051290": "us talk about all the other stuff", "TyB7_LASMyo-00249-00051291-00051561": "outside of us as long as we want but", "TyB7_LASMyo-00250-00051562-00051821": "what about inside what about us what", "TyB7_LASMyo-00251-00051822-00052004": "about when we look in the mirror what", "TyB7_LASMyo-00252-00052005-00052299": "about educational innovation you see", "TyB7_LASMyo-00253-00052300-00052446": "having had the opportunity I've had the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00254-00052447-00052599": "opportunity truly to work with probably", "TyB7_LASMyo-00255-00052600-00052785": "700 district teams in the past year and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00256-00052786-00052947": "a half I've been to dozens and dozens", "TyB7_LASMyo-00257-00052948-00053103": "hundreds of schools probably in the past", "TyB7_LASMyo-00258-00053104-00053291": "two years thousands of school leaders", "TyB7_LASMyo-00259-00053292-00053448": "here's what I can tell you when we talk", "TyB7_LASMyo-00260-00053449-00053657": "about innovation in education we've got", "TyB7_LASMyo-00261-00053658-00053768": "amazing innovation", "TyB7_LASMyo-00262-00053769-00053918": "I'll be the first one to tell you that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00263-00053919-00054134": "having been from Atlanta to Seattle", "TyB7_LASMyo-00264-00054135-00054326": "California to New York she's going on in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00265-00054327-00054782": "our schools in pockets how do I know you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00266-00054783-00054962": "guys know how to this is when I get to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00267-00054963-00055134": "do school visits the principal meets me", "TyB7_LASMyo-00268-00055135-00055296": "often at the door and they want to take", "TyB7_LASMyo-00269-00055297-00055511": "me to two or three classrooms the two or", "TyB7_LASMyo-00270-00055512-00055643": "three classrooms that whoever comes to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00271-00055644-00055821": "visit next same two or three classrooms", "TyB7_LASMyo-00272-00055822-00056121": "how do we scale that up how do we scale", "TyB7_LASMyo-00273-00056122-00056366": "so the norm is innovation in our schools", "TyB7_LASMyo-00274-00056367-00056790": "what about us next slide mint taking a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00275-00056791-00056909": "look and I like to show these if you've", "TyB7_LASMyo-00276-00056910-00057009": "heard me speak before you've probably", "TyB7_LASMyo-00277-00057010-00057182": "seen me even use this slide let me take", "TyB7_LASMyo-00278-00057183-00057365": "a look and I'll use this an FPT scene", "TyB7_LASMyo-00279-00057366-00057569": "I'll give a shout to FVCC there too one", "TyB7_LASMyo-00280-00057570-00057698": "of the things I like to do occasionally", "TyB7_LASMyo-00281-00057699-00057917": "is just encourage you to Google to play", "TyB7_LASMyo-00282-00057918-00058265": "classrooms of a hundred years ago 1917", "TyB7_LASMyo-00283-00058266-00058469": "see what kind of pictures pop up and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00284-00058470-00058688": "then Google classrooms were brand new to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00285-00058689-00058973": "2017 so nineteen or twenty sixteen let's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00286-00058974-00059348": "see what kind of classrooms pop up", "TyB7_LASMyo-00287-00059349-00059551": "it's playing the image search what's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00288-00059552-00059806": "fascinating they're almost identical", "TyB7_LASMyo-00289-00059807-00060043": "you've got teacher-centric environment", "TyB7_LASMyo-00290-00060044-00060274": "students facing forward equidistant from", "TyB7_LASMyo-00291-00060275-00060661": "each other next slide Mitch and taking a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00292-00060662-00060787": "look when we when we push them together", "TyB7_LASMyo-00293-00060788-00061048": "we really got this environment now let", "TyB7_LASMyo-00294-00061049-00061229": "me show you another study we look at", "TyB7_LASMyo-00295-00061229-00061346": "this I'm not sure if you've seen this", "TyB7_LASMyo-00296-00061347-00061501": "this comes from the Gallup survey that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00297-00061502-00061675": "that came out this past year the end", "TyB7_LASMyo-00298-00061676-00061807": "number I know the numbers pretty small", "TyB7_LASMyo-00299-00061808-00061922": "it's about nine hundred and twenty eight", "TyB7_LASMyo-00300-00061923-00062179": "thousand so they surveyed over almost a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00301-00062180-00062366": "million kids nationwide coast-to-coast", "TyB7_LASMyo-00302-00062366-00062579": "urban rural they wanted to get the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00303-00062579-00062822": "demographics of course across the US and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00304-00062823-00063016": "here's what it shows the red line has", "TyB7_LASMyo-00305-00063017-00063166": "shout-out to my friend Scott McCloud if", "TyB7_LASMyo-00306-00063167-00063319": "you know Scott had created this actual", "TyB7_LASMyo-00307-00063320-00063521": "image toad from our schools nationwide", "TyB7_LASMyo-00308-00063522-00063848": "in fifth grade 75% of the kids", "TyB7_LASMyo-00309-00063849-00064018": "identified as being engaged", "TyB7_LASMyo-00310-00064019-00064196": "self-identified they said we're pretty", "TyB7_LASMyo-00311-00064197-00064340": "engaged in school three out of four of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00312-00064341-00064529": "our fifth graders nationwide and it goes", "TyB7_LASMyo-00313-00064529-00064666": "down in sixth grade down in seventh", "TyB7_LASMyo-00314-00064667-00064801": "grade down in eighth grade down in ninth", "TyB7_LASMyo-00315-00064802-00064930": "grade down in eleventh grade", "TyB7_LASMyo-00316-00064931-00065179": "bottoms out at less than one in three of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00317-00065180-00065410": "our 11th graders nationwide are saying", "TyB7_LASMyo-00318-00065411-00065585": "they're engaged in school less than one", "TyB7_LASMyo-00319-00065586-00065842": "in three then it ticks up senior year", "TyB7_LASMyo-00320-00065843-00066031": "which I attribute do like oh shoot I", "TyB7_LASMyo-00321-00066032-00066292": "gotta graduate or be like I think I'm", "TyB7_LASMyo-00322-00066293-00066685": "going to my prom I love school but put", "TyB7_LASMyo-00323-00066686-00067036": "it this way no longer we have them the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00324-00067037-00067285": "less engaged they become my good friend", "TyB7_LASMyo-00325-00067286-00067432": "George Perrot is one of the questions he", "TyB7_LASMyo-00326-00067433-00067576": "often ask and I love when he asked this", "TyB7_LASMyo-00327-00067577-00067847": "question is often like if kids leave us", "TyB7_LASMyo-00328-00067848-00067985": "like it's more of a statement but when", "TyB7_LASMyo-00329-00067986-00068244": "kids leave us if they leave us less", "TyB7_LASMyo-00330-00068245-00068623": "curious then when they came to us we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00331-00068624-00069088": "failed so next next one meant take a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00332-00069089-00069203": "look at this image and I'll just hit", "TyB7_LASMyo-00333-00069204-00069418": "this one quick the blue line in the last", "TyB7_LASMyo-00334-00069419-00069586": "seven days I've learned something fun in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00335-00069587-00069746": "school I'm sorry in the last time David", "TyB7_LASMyo-00336-00069747-00069860": "learned something interesting in school", "TyB7_LASMyo-00337-00069861-00070016": "look at the green line they said this", "TyB7_LASMyo-00338-00070017-00070196": "one hits home as a dad a little girl in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00339-00070197-00070340": "in a public school right now take a look", "TyB7_LASMyo-00340-00070341-00070629": "at the Green Line I have fun in school", "TyB7_LASMyo-00341-00070630-00071017": "less than one in five one in five of our", "TyB7_LASMyo-00342-00071018-00071161": "high school kids nationwide are saying", "TyB7_LASMyo-00343-00071162-00071441": "schools any fun look at the red line at", "TyB7_LASMyo-00344-00071442-00071578": "this school I get to do what I do best", "TyB7_LASMyo-00345-00071579-00071761": "every day and when you take a look at", "TyB7_LASMyo-00346-00071762-00071915": "that one and that red line that you see", "TyB7_LASMyo-00347-00071916-00072130": "there too I start to get to personalize", "TyB7_LASMyo-00348-00072131-00072250": "learn in that personal piece because you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00349-00072251-00072371": "all know in your schools", "TyB7_LASMyo-00350-00072372-00072538": "you've got the kid that shows up every", "TyB7_LASMyo-00351-00072539-00072689": "day be just because of chorus", "TyB7_LASMyo-00352-00072690-00072818": "just because of bad just because of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00353-00072819-00072962": "football just cuz of math whatever it", "TyB7_LASMyo-00354-00072963-00073139": "might be their interests or passions so", "TyB7_LASMyo-00355-00073140-00073651": "how do we leverage that next slide", "TyB7_LASMyo-00356-00073652-00073882": "so let's talk about future ready because", "TyB7_LASMyo-00357-00073883-00074098": "all that I showed you is that world of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00358-00074099-00074278": "work why we're trying to do what we're", "TyB7_LASMyo-00359-00074279-00074494": "trying to do number one that guy shared", "TyB7_LASMyo-00360-00074495-00074767": "nothing I'm about to share costs", "TyB7_LASMyo-00361-00074768-00075031": "anything number two who is that possible", "TyB7_LASMyo-00362-00075032-00075238": "number two let me share just a quick", "TyB7_LASMyo-00363-00075239-00075475": "piece to a quick history so Futurity org", "TyB7_LASMyo-00364-00075476-00075574": "as you see there is one of the very", "TyB7_LASMyo-00365-00075575-00075697": "quick resources that I share that's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00366-00075698-00075892": "gonna be the hub of the home of where we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00367-00075893-00076026": "release stuff what's the amount of stuff", "TyB7_LASMyo-00368-00076027-00076198": "out there so for the past two years", "TyB7_LASMyo-00369-00076199-00076375": "we've partnered with the US Department", "TyB7_LASMyo-00370-00076376-00076579": "of Education next slide as you can see", "TyB7_LASMyo-00371-00076580-00076719": "there's been very supportive of the work", "TyB7_LASMyo-00372-00076720-00076885": "the president actually kicked it off", "TyB7_LASMyo-00373-00076886-00077059": "himself President Obama kicked it off", "TyB7_LASMyo-00374-00077060-00077284": "two years ago but it's meant to be a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00375-00077285-00077451": "very bipartisan thing and you can see", "TyB7_LASMyo-00376-00077452-00077605": "that moving forward created what's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00377-00077606-00077761": "called the future ready district pledge", "TyB7_LASMyo-00378-00077762-00077929": "so for those of you whatever districts", "TyB7_LASMyo-00379-00077930-00078213": "you're in we've had about 3,000 district", "TyB7_LASMyo-00380-00078214-00078412": "superintendents nationwide 3,000", "TyB7_LASMyo-00381-00078413-00078613": "Senate's to do the same thing 3,000", "TyB7_LASMyo-00382-00078614-00078766": "superintendents nationwide they actually", "TyB7_LASMyo-00383-00078767-00078988": "represent 19 million children nationwide", "TyB7_LASMyo-00384-00078989-00079156": "have signed the pledge that you're", "TyB7_LASMyo-00385-00079157-00079300": "looking at so one of the things I would", "TyB7_LASMyo-00386-00079301-00079456": "encourage you to do is is if you've got", "TyB7_LASMyo-00387-00079457-00079654": "a few charity work slash pledge send", "TyB7_LASMyo-00388-00079655-00079798": "that to your superintendent I'm not sure", "TyB7_LASMyo-00389-00079799-00079921": "I know some of you might be in massive", "TyB7_LASMyo-00390-00079922-00080038": "districts and maybe you don't know him", "TyB7_LASMyo-00391-00080039-00080110": "personally", "TyB7_LASMyo-00392-00080111-00080313": "but check that out you can also check", "TyB7_LASMyo-00393-00080314-00080473": "right there has your superintendent sign", "TyB7_LASMyo-00394-00080474-00080601": "the pledge you can actually check that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00395-00080602-00080751": "out but we put that out publicly on", "TyB7_LASMyo-00396-00080752-00080869": "whether they've signed they're not they", "TyB7_LASMyo-00397-00080870-00081016": "know that but things like they're", "TyB7_LASMyo-00398-00081017-00081136": "looking at for instance creating that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00399-00081137-00081261": "culture of digital learning", "TyB7_LASMyo-00400-00081262-00081436": "transitioning families to high-speed", "TyB7_LASMyo-00401-00081437-00081676": "connectivity professional learning", "TyB7_LASMyo-00402-00081677-00081874": "opportunities then access for all", "TyB7_LASMyo-00403-00081875-00082123": "students to quality devices high quality", "TyB7_LASMyo-00404-00082124-00082344": "digital content family week of families", "TyB7_LASMyo-00405-00082345-00082468": "reach higher that's at college and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00406-00082469-00082644": "career readiness piece and then the last", "TyB7_LASMyo-00407-00082645-00082885": "piece is on also helping them transition", "TyB7_LASMyo-00408-00082886-00083119": "that mentor how do we break down what", "TyB7_LASMyo-00409-00083120-00083244": "the biggest goal is a few journey how do", "TyB7_LASMyo-00410-00083245-00083386": "we break down the traditional silos", "TyB7_LASMyo-00411-00083387-00083560": "we've got to get to the point in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00412-00083561-00083757": "education where I care just about that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00413-00083758-00083974": "as much about the kids across the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00414-00083975-00084178": "highway is about as I do about the kids", "TyB7_LASMyo-00415-00084179-00084292": "that are sitting in front of me", "TyB7_LASMyo-00416-00084293-00084576": "go ahead Mitch next one", "TyB7_LASMyo-00417-00084577-00084708": "so when we take a look let me just give", "TyB7_LASMyo-00418-00084709-00084876": "you some perspective here see", "TyB7_LASMyo-00419-00084877-00085086": "future-ready is not just the Alliance", "TyB7_LASMyo-00420-00085087-00085209": "for excellent education you know", "TyB7_LASMyo-00421-00085210-00085329": "supported by the US Department of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00422-00085330-00085392": "Education", "TyB7_LASMyo-00423-00085393-00085683": "it is a coalition of your organization's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00424-00085684-00085803": "I don't say that lightly it's the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00425-00085804-00085947": "organization's so if you're a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00426-00085948-00086121": "superintendent a SA if you're a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00427-00086122-00086376": "principal and a ESPN ESS P if you're on", "TyB7_LASMyo-00428-00086377-00086631": "the tech side SD Kosan you can see just", "TyB7_LASMyo-00429-00086632-00086811": "a snapshot the National School Boards", "TyB7_LASMyo-00430-00086812-00087045": "Association from a teacher side the aft", "TyB7_LASMyo-00431-00087046-00087237": "Teach for America they're all partners", "TyB7_LASMyo-00432-00087238-00087390": "in this work and they all support it in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00433-00087391-00087474": "various ways", "TyB7_LASMyo-00434-00087475-00087681": "next next slide but it's a huge", "TyB7_LASMyo-00435-00087682-00087891": "coalition working to support it they", "TyB7_LASMyo-00436-00087892-00088011": "briefly mentioned the President himself", "TyB7_LASMyo-00437-00088012-00088194": "but I know we're going through a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00438-00088195-00088344": "transition here quite a transition we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00439-00088345-00088503": "can all say kicked it off at the White", "TyB7_LASMyo-00440-00088504-00088536": "House", "TyB7_LASMyo-00441-00088537-00088710": "a hundred superintendents came to the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00442-00088711-00088875": "White House to kick this off because we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00443-00088876-00089151": "are focused on leadership why even", "TyB7_LASMyo-00444-00089152-00089307": "though we have lots of teacher unions", "TyB7_LASMyo-00445-00089308-00089406": "and those kinds of things because we've", "TyB7_LASMyo-00446-00089407-00089679": "got to get the leadership on board and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00447-00089680-00089865": "modeling the way in greeting cultures of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00448-00089866-00090075": "innovation and powering teachers for any", "TyB7_LASMyo-00449-00090076-00090201": "of this to work and so we're really", "TyB7_LASMyo-00450-00090202-00090378": "focused on that leadership piece the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00451-00090379-00090669": "president kicked off back on and 2014", "TyB7_LASMyo-00452-00090670-00090810": "that was kind of that initial phase one", "TyB7_LASMyo-00453-00090811-00091137": "next slide Mitch you can see across the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00454-00091138-00091302": "disk across the country and you can", "TyB7_LASMyo-00455-00091303-00091413": "actually see when you go in there how", "TyB7_LASMyo-00456-00091414-00091611": "many superintendents in your state have", "TyB7_LASMyo-00457-00091612-00091782": "signed that pledge now I'll be the first", "TyB7_LASMyo-00458-00091783-00091977": "person to tell you signing a pledge in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00459-00091978-00092112": "and of itself for your district doesn't", "TyB7_LASMyo-00460-00092113-00092289": "do anything I'll be the first to say", "TyB7_LASMyo-00461-00092290-00092502": "that it but it's a public way to take a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00462-00092503-00092688": "stand to say we believe in this stuff", "TyB7_LASMyo-00463-00092689-00092901": "and we're moving in this direction but", "TyB7_LASMyo-00464-00092902-00093021": "sure a district could sign the pledge", "TyB7_LASMyo-00465-00093022-00093219": "and not change a darn thing it was just", "TyB7_LASMyo-00466-00093220-00093420": "a waste of that few seconds of time and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00467-00093421-00093639": "so it's just it's taking a stand a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00468-00093640-00093768": "public way to be able to say we believe", "TyB7_LASMyo-00469-00093769-00093894": "in this is the direction that we're", "TyB7_LASMyo-00470-00093895-00094230": "going next slide so the Futurity", "TyB7_LASMyo-00471-00094231-00094377": "framework is one of the things I really", "TyB7_LASMyo-00472-00094378-00094482": "want you to get out of here so I'm gonna", "TyB7_LASMyo-00473-00094483-00094629": "share a handful of pieces of framework", "TyB7_LASMyo-00474-00094630-00094713": "but I'm also going to pose some", "TyB7_LASMyo-00475-00094714-00094902": "questions so we can chat and we can talk", "TyB7_LASMyo-00476-00094903-00095046": "and some of these look in the different", "TyB7_LASMyo-00477-00095047-00095235": "areas so this is a research-based", "TyB7_LASMyo-00478-00095236-00095466": "framework to support really a more", "TyB7_LASMyo-00479-00095467-00095667": "personalized approach especially to high", "TyB7_LASMyo-00480-00095668-00095853": "quality digital learning this is all", "TyB7_LASMyo-00481-00095854-00096015": "focused on so today when I would I", "TyB7_LASMyo-00482-00096016-00096177": "shared a few minutes ago it's been today", "TyB7_LASMyo-00483-00096178-00096357": "with 50 school districts from primarily", "TyB7_LASMyo-00484-00096358-00096540": "New Jersey but district leadership teams", "TyB7_LASMyo-00485-00096541-00096705": "50 superintendents and so on and so", "TyB7_LASMyo-00486-00096706-00096858": "forth and just about an hour ago", "TyB7_LASMyo-00487-00096859-00096996": "somebody said you know Tom my biggest", "TyB7_LASMyo-00488-00096997-00097146": "surprise is I thought there's going to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00489-00097147-00097329": "be so much about technology it's really", "TyB7_LASMyo-00490-00097330-00097563": "about teaching and learning teaching and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00491-00097564-00097800": "learning is the focus of this work when", "TyB7_LASMyo-00492-00097801-00097940": "you see people talking about", "TyB7_LASMyo-00493-00097941-00098149": "getting to leading with technology we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00494-00098150-00098293": "run the other way because we could chase", "TyB7_LASMyo-00495-00098294-00098461": "technology all we want", "TyB7_LASMyo-00496-00098462-00098693": "technology is an amazing accelerant I", "TyB7_LASMyo-00497-00098694-00099007": "love a deck when it's used well when I", "TyB7_LASMyo-00498-00099008-00099197": "did", "TyB7_LASMyo-00499-00099198-00099365": "it's not used well it's a total waste of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00500-00099366-00099611": "money and so the framework is gonna help", "TyB7_LASMyo-00501-00099612-00099761": "us be able to do it so let's dive into", "TyB7_LASMyo-00502-00099762-00099965": "this a little bit to see all the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00503-00099966-00100127": "different ways that districts have", "TyB7_LASMyo-00504-00100128-00100295": "gotten really have to focus and have", "TyB7_LASMyo-00505-00100296-00100466": "their support and I apologies my voice", "TyB7_LASMyo-00506-00100467-00100592": "is going a little bit here been doing a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00507-00100593-00100760": "lot of talking today next slide there", "TyB7_LASMyo-00508-00100761-00100904": "Mitch so first we're gonna hit", "TyB7_LASMyo-00509-00100905-00101075": "curriculum instruction assessment I'm", "TyB7_LASMyo-00510-00101076-00101210": "gonna pose a question in just a moment", "TyB7_LASMyo-00511-00101211-00101336": "but this is the heart and soul of what", "TyB7_LASMyo-00512-00101337-00101573": "we do what is it and I love asking", "TyB7_LASMyo-00513-00101574-00101693": "districts I get to work with leadership", "TyB7_LASMyo-00514-00101694-00101849": "teams all over the country even just", "TyB7_LASMyo-00515-00101850-00102044": "dynamic teams kind of morning consulting", "TyB7_LASMyo-00516-00102045-00102215": "it one of the questions I want up to ask", "TyB7_LASMyo-00517-00102216-00102338": "and love to start with them is really", "TyB7_LASMyo-00518-00102339-00102542": "that vision again what is it that we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00519-00102543-00102755": "want tea classrooms to look like what", "TyB7_LASMyo-00520-00102756-00103006": "are we even building toller's what is it", "TyB7_LASMyo-00521-00103007-00103202": "that we want to get to what when I walk", "TyB7_LASMyo-00522-00103203-00103360": "into a classroom five years from now in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00523-00103361-00103550": "my district the district does it what do", "TyB7_LASMyo-00524-00103551-00103735": "I want it to look like next slide so", "TyB7_LASMyo-00525-00103736-00103823": "let's focus on that curriculum", "TyB7_LASMyo-00526-00103824-00104017": "instruction and assessment side here so", "TyB7_LASMyo-00527-00104018-00104300": "I do want us to take a few minutes to do", "TyB7_LASMyo-00528-00104301-00104477": "this and just because this o'clock let's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00529-00104478-00104654": "only take about I'd love for you to pair", "TyB7_LASMyo-00530-00104655-00104900": "up with one person and ask this question", "TyB7_LASMyo-00531-00104901-00105038": "each spent a minute or two quick real", "TyB7_LASMyo-00532-00105039-00105239": "quick introductions what is it that we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00533-00105240-00105371": "want teaching and learning to look like", "TyB7_LASMyo-00534-00105372-00105614": "in our schools because if we can't start", "TyB7_LASMyo-00535-00105615-00105806": "to identify where we're going three to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00536-00105807-00105983": "five years from now how in the world are", "TyB7_LASMyo-00537-00105983-00106151": "we going to get there we're just going", "TyB7_LASMyo-00538-00106152-00106308": "to spin our week", "TyB7_LASMyo-00539-00106309-00106602": "feels and so what is it so you can pose", "TyB7_LASMyo-00540-00106603-00106734": "the question that you see on the screen", "TyB7_LASMyo-00541-00106735-00106915": "there or you can look at it like this if", "TyB7_LASMyo-00542-00106916-00107119": "I were to walk into whatever classroom", "TyB7_LASMyo-00543-00107120-00107233": "my brothers would have position them in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00544-00107233-00107497": "five years from now this is this is what", "TyB7_LASMyo-00545-00107498-00107668": "I really would want to see teaching and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00546-00107669-00107872": "learning look like so looking at my", "TyB7_LASMyo-00547-00107873-00108094": "clock here it's I have 829 on the East", "TyB7_LASMyo-00548-00108095-00108322": "Coast I encourage you let's let's take", "TyB7_LASMyo-00549-00108323-00108490": "four minutes because it's kind of one of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00550-00108491-00108654": "the the bigger questions two minutes", "TyB7_LASMyo-00551-00108655-00108834": "apiece pair up with somebody will jump", "TyB7_LASMyo-00552-00108835-00109072": "back in at 8:33 and pair up with", "TyB7_LASMyo-00553-00109073-00109189": "somebody if you would answer that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00554-00109190-00109300": "question what do you on teaching", "TyB7_LASMyo-00555-00109301-00109450": "learning to look like but say a quick", "TyB7_LASMyo-00556-00109451-00109570": "hello go ahead and pair up with somebody", "TyB7_LASMyo-00557-00109571-00110275": "see in a few minutes okay and if you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00558-00110276-00110541": "don't have a webcam again move your", "TyB7_LASMyo-00559-00110542-00110725": "cursor over your avatar and open up the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00560-00110726-00111019": "IM window and start interacting with", "TyB7_LASMyo-00561-00111020-00111264": "people in the IM window about what you'd", "TyB7_LASMyo-00562-00111265-00111547": "like to you'd like to see if you cheat", "TyB7_LASMyo-00563-00111548-00111682": "and learning in your schools in the next", "TyB7_LASMyo-00564-00111683-00111952": "five years and then and answer some of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00565-00111953-00112174": "their questions so I'll bring myself", "TyB7_LASMyo-00566-00112175-00112375": "down and we may be asking for some", "TyB7_LASMyo-00567-00112376-00112663": "volunteers also to share with the group", "TyB7_LASMyo-00568-00112664-00113293": "you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00569-00113294-00133768": "you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00570-00133769-00134066": "so so you know I I looked at the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00571-00134067-00134329": "question I was thinking about it and I", "TyB7_LASMyo-00572-00134330-00134491": "guess one of the things that I've been", "TyB7_LASMyo-00573-00134492-00134669": "thinking is that I'd like to see the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00574-00134670-00135029": "first few years of school where we use", "TyB7_LASMyo-00575-00135030-00135227": "in order to give kids a basic background", "TyB7_LASMyo-00576-00135228-00135644": "and to get them psyched to become auto", "TyB7_LASMyo-00577-00135645-00135962": "didactics to become in charge of their", "TyB7_LASMyo-00578-00135963-00136139": "own learning and then from about fifth", "TyB7_LASMyo-00579-00136140-00136352": "sixth grade on and certainly by eighth", "TyB7_LASMyo-00580-00136353-00136565": "or ninth grade to see them really put in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00581-00136566-00136700": "charge with their learning the teachers", "TyB7_LASMyo-00582-00136701-00137021": "become really more counselors rather", "TyB7_LASMyo-00583-00137022-00137216": "than teachers that's that that would be", "TyB7_LASMyo-00584-00137217-00137540": "my vision", "TyB7_LASMyo-00585-00137541-00137732": "I'm sure thanks for sharing that one of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00586-00137733-00137846": "the things that's really interesting I", "TyB7_LASMyo-00587-00137847-00138077": "so I'm my good friend of anybody knows", "TyB7_LASMyo-00588-00138078-00138188": "Eric Shannon or Eric and I are", "TyB7_LASMyo-00589-00138189-00138404": "publishing a book for ascd and kind of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00590-00138405-00138656": "in our final editing stages and one of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00591-00138657-00138785": "the kind of the cases that we make", "TyB7_LASMyo-00592-00138786-00138971": "really in our intro is if we're really", "TyB7_LASMyo-00593-00138972-00139154": "gonna be preparing kids for their world", "TyB7_LASMyo-00594-00139155-00139304": "of work we've got to start to identify", "TyB7_LASMyo-00595-00139305-00139469": "what is their world of work the best we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00596-00139470-00139679": "can predict actually going to look like", "TyB7_LASMyo-00597-00139680-00139970": "and it's or not the world of work that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00598-00139971-00140228": "we all grew up with when you look at", "TyB7_LASMyo-00599-00140229-00140435": "automation when you look at robots and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00600-00140436-00140606": "you look at the overtaking of those", "TyB7_LASMyo-00601-00140607-00140840": "types of things when you look at so and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00602-00140841-00140981": "having worked with the White House and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00603-00140982-00141101": "the White House Economic Council a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00604-00141102-00141269": "little the the White House Economic", "TyB7_LASMyo-00605-00141270-00141455": "Council made a prediction about a year", "TyB7_LASMyo-00606-00141456-00141812": "ago that 83 percent of jobs that make", "TyB7_LASMyo-00607-00141813-00142127": "under $20 an hour will eventually be", "TyB7_LASMyo-00608-00142128-00142361": "phased out great because when you look", "TyB7_LASMyo-00609-00142362-00142688": "at you can be replaced by a computer you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00610-00142689-00142916": "can be replaced by a robot that can do", "TyB7_LASMyo-00611-00142917-00143276": "it better and cheaper over time you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00612-00143277-00143516": "probably will be and so sometimes people", "TyB7_LASMyo-00613-00143517-00143642": "will say what are you saying teachers", "TyB7_LASMyo-00614-00143643-00143777": "will be replaced by computers and robots", "TyB7_LASMyo-00615-00143778-00144038": "that be like if you can be replaced as a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00616-00144039-00144296": "teacher by a computer and a robot I say", "TyB7_LASMyo-00617-00144297-00144476": "this tongue-in-cheek like you probably", "TyB7_LASMyo-00618-00144477-00144689": "should be because all the great teachers", "TyB7_LASMyo-00619-00144690-00144839": "that I know there's no way in the world", "TyB7_LASMyo-00620-00144840-00145109": "they can be replaced by a computer by a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00621-00145110-00145361": "robot and so why because they build", "TyB7_LASMyo-00622-00145362-00145571": "relationships they love kids the empathy", "TyB7_LASMyo-00623-00145572-00145823": "like all the the things that teachers do", "TyB7_LASMyo-00624-00145824-00146069": "or admin do no robots gonna come in no", "TyB7_LASMyo-00625-00146070-00146198": "computers gonna commit because this", "TyB7_LASMyo-00626-00146199-00146330": "isn't just about like I worked my way", "TyB7_LASMyo-00627-00146331-00146567": "through content and so when we take a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00628-00146568-00146690": "look at that though what are the types", "TyB7_LASMyo-00629-00146691-00146912": "of jobs out there that we need to be", "TyB7_LASMyo-00630-00146913-00147041": "preparing kids for what are the jobs", "TyB7_LASMyo-00631-00147042-00147233": "that are disappearing when you look at", "TyB7_LASMyo-00632-00147234-00147422": "things like your factories it just last", "TyB7_LASMyo-00633-00147423-00147653": "year in China the first unmanned Factory", "TyB7_LASMyo-00634-00147654-00147893": "actually got unleashed they had 625", "TyB7_LASMyo-00635-00147894-00148130": "workers throughout the factory and over", "TyB7_LASMyo-00636-00148131-00148472": "a six month period they now have three", "TyB7_LASMyo-00637-00148473-00148766": "the productivity of that Factory is up", "TyB7_LASMyo-00638-00148767-00148985": "twice when when people actually work", "TyB7_LASMyo-00639-00148986-00149186": "there those three people now actually", "TyB7_LASMyo-00640-00149187-00149372": "just monitor the computers that monitor", "TyB7_LASMyo-00641-00149373-00149570": "the robots and robots never actually", "TyB7_LASMyo-00642-00149571-00149741": "asked for time off they don't ask for a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00643-00149742-00149912": "coffee break they don't ask for a raise", "TyB7_LASMyo-00644-00149913-00150017": "and they're gonna get better and cheaper", "TyB7_LASMyo-00645-00150018-00150239": "over time people just don't and so when", "TyB7_LASMyo-00646-00150240-00150365": "you look at that like what are the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00647-00150366-00150533": "industries and what are the jobs were", "TyB7_LASMyo-00648-00150534-00150734": "preparing to doubt the flipside to that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00649-00150735-00150920": "are what are the growth rates", "TyB7_LASMyo-00650-00150921-00151037": "because this isn't all doom and gloom", "TyB7_LASMyo-00651-00151038-00151313": "things like helper up double it's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00652-00151314-00151484": "predicted for the next 15 years why", "TyB7_LASMyo-00653-00151485-00151639": "because people are living longer getting", "TyB7_LASMyo-00654-00151640-00151688": "older", "TyB7_LASMyo-00655-00151689-00151913": "well what skills do people need to be in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00656-00151914-00152099": "the healthcare field in that age another", "TyB7_LASMyo-00657-00152100-00152318": "one computer science double digits next", "TyB7_LASMyo-00658-00152319-00152479": "to that probably 15 years or so for", "TyB7_LASMyo-00659-00152480-00152681": "directions so computer type skills", "TyB7_LASMyo-00660-00152682-00152854": "definitely important but how do we teach", "TyB7_LASMyo-00661-00152855-00152987": "kids to be able to problem-solve to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00662-00152988-00153122": "critically think and I like to be able", "TyB7_LASMyo-00663-00153123-00153289": "to say how do we teach kids and give", "TyB7_LASMyo-00664-00153290-00153427": "them the skills so that they can create", "TyB7_LASMyo-00665-00153428-00153686": "new industries it's not just these", "TyB7_LASMyo-00666-00153687-00153913": "industries are going away 15 years from", "TyB7_LASMyo-00667-00153914-00154013": "now there's gonna be industries that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00668-00154014-00154226": "exist that just don't exist yet but if", "TyB7_LASMyo-00669-00154227-00154358": "kids are sitting in our schools right", "TyB7_LASMyo-00670-00154359-00154556": "now how are we preparing them for that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00671-00154557-00154816": "creation engine collaborate cross", "TyB7_LASMyo-00672-00154817-00155089": "culture but I'll bring myself down and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00673-00155090-00155360": "I'll get your slides back up let's just", "TyB7_LASMyo-00674-00155361-00155479": "let me add a couple things here and then", "TyB7_LASMyo-00675-00155480-00155612": "they will do one or two more discussion", "TyB7_LASMyo-00676-00155613-00155795": "topics I know a couple people chatted", "TyB7_LASMyo-00677-00155796-00156026": "which was good but certainly I want to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00678-00156027-00156226": "force anything here as well so jumping", "TyB7_LASMyo-00679-00156227-00156437": "back over kind of the slides one of the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00680-00156438-00156557": "things I want to point out and I'll go", "TyB7_LASMyo-00681-00156558-00156695": "through these quickly very quickly there", "TyB7_LASMyo-00682-00156696-00156872": "Mitch noticing here these are what we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00683-00156873-00157022": "call elements so each one of the gears", "TyB7_LASMyo-00684-00157023-00157145": "and I'll go through these quickly I have", "TyB7_LASMyo-00685-00157146-00157204": "what are called", "TyB7_LASMyo-00686-00157205-00157366": "elements these are the research-based", "TyB7_LASMyo-00687-00157367-00157588": "areas so for instance this is curriculum", "TyB7_LASMyo-00688-00157589-00157789": "instruction assessment the first element", "TyB7_LASMyo-00689-00157790-00158120": "there that 21st century learning that's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00690-00158121-00158353": "that's a very research-based area and so", "TyB7_LASMyo-00691-00158354-00158554": "these also we variety of tools and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00692-00158555-00158681": "metrics that I'll kind of hit towards", "TyB7_LASMyo-00693-00158682-00158916": "the end there that can be very much", "TyB7_LASMyo-00694-00158917-00159154": "measured in your district all free tools", "TyB7_LASMyo-00695-00159155-00159577": "next slide so where do we begin with", "TyB7_LASMyo-00696-00159578-00159845": "this stuff go ahead next slide again and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00697-00159846-00160007": "we got all of this stuff that's out", "TyB7_LASMyo-00698-00160008-00160109": "there you know when I was a tech", "TyB7_LASMyo-00699-00160110-00160313": "director in my last year that picture", "TyB7_LASMyo-00700-00160314-00160426": "right there it's not a real picture for", "TyB7_LASMyo-00701-00160427-00160586": "my office but that's kind of what it", "TyB7_LASMyo-00702-00160587-00160772": "would look like because we know the tech", "TyB7_LASMyo-00703-00160773-00160886": "stuffs out there we're really not", "TyB7_LASMyo-00704-00160887-00161041": "getting these questions of like I don't", "TyB7_LASMyo-00705-00161042-00161179": "think there's any value to technology", "TyB7_LASMyo-00706-00161180-00161314": "like occasionally once in a blue moon", "TyB7_LASMyo-00707-00161315-00161387": "you get it", "TyB7_LASMyo-00708-00161388-00161543": "but what districts are doing right now", "TyB7_LASMyo-00709-00161544-00161732": "is essentially what we're seeing is", "TyB7_LASMyo-00710-00161733-00161854": "they're buying all the stuff", "TyB7_LASMyo-00711-00161855-00162076": "Chromebooks iPads they're all great", "TyB7_LASMyo-00712-00162077-00162287": "devices on how it's used you're buying", "TyB7_LASMyo-00713-00162288-00162427": "all this stuff or putting it out there", "TyB7_LASMyo-00714-00162428-00162604": "put in card quit and always putting out", "TyB7_LASMyo-00715-00162605-00162790": "there and then really saying like now", "TyB7_LASMyo-00716-00162791-00162923": "what do we do with it like now that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00717-00162924-00163114": "we've got 3,000 Chromebooks how do we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00718-00163115-00163235": "change our curriculum now that we have a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00719-00163236-00163385": "thousand iPads how do we change our", "TyB7_LASMyo-00720-00163386-00163562": "assessments it's the way we're operating", "TyB7_LASMyo-00721-00163563-00163673": "that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00722-00163674-00163844": "it's not gonna make a difference you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00723-00163845-00164285": "know when I was a a tech director in my", "TyB7_LASMyo-00724-00164286-00164486": "very last board meeting it often tell a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00725-00164487-00164669": "story my school board president looked", "TyB7_LASMyo-00726-00164670-00164866": "at me and said you know ten by the way", "TyB7_LASMyo-00727-00164867-00165001": "this is not why it was my last board", "TyB7_LASMyo-00728-00165002-00165206": "meeting I was already going to DC it was", "TyB7_LASMyo-00729-00165207-00165388": "the budget meeting and he said so Tom if", "TyB7_LASMyo-00730-00165389-00165521": "we're gonna spend this additional seven", "TyB7_LASMyo-00731-00165522-00165683": "hundred thousand dollars in technology", "TyB7_LASMyo-00732-00165684-00165851": "well student achievement increased next", "TyB7_LASMyo-00733-00165852-00166076": "year it's actually a really good", "TyB7_LASMyo-00734-00166077-00166240": "question coming from a board member I", "TyB7_LASMyo-00735-00166241-00166438": "didn't think so necessarily then I", "TyB7_LASMyo-00736-00166439-00166576": "thought maybe just drunk now they trying", "TyB7_LASMyo-00737-00166577-00166726": "to get under my skin what is the case", "TyB7_LASMyo-00738-00166727-00166898": "here and but when we're thinking about", "TyB7_LASMyo-00739-00166899-00167069": "it if I'm signing my name I don't heard", "TyB7_LASMyo-00740-00167070-00167318": "that any taxpayer bunny and we're gonna", "TyB7_LASMyo-00741-00167319-00167413": "buy stuff", "TyB7_LASMyo-00742-00167414-00167585": "we'd better be able to say like this is", "TyB7_LASMyo-00743-00167586-00167764": "what the stuff's impact is this is what", "TyB7_LASMyo-00744-00167765-00168002": "it's looking at next slide", "TyB7_LASMyo-00745-00168003-00168272": "what actually works and let me hit this", "TyB7_LASMyo-00746-00168273-00168416": "a little bit because to answer the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00747-00168417-00168606": "question that I was just posing we have", "TyB7_LASMyo-00748-00168607-00168803": "to know what actually works and so my", "TyB7_LASMyo-00749-00168804-00168918": "challenge for you one of the things I'd", "TyB7_LASMyo-00750-00168919-00169134": "ask you is like when you're buying all", "TyB7_LASMyo-00751-00169135-00169301": "this stuff and putting it in classrooms", "TyB7_LASMyo-00752-00169302-00169707": "what actually is improving learning we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00753-00169708-00169821": "get that question all the time that's a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00754-00169822-00169990": "good question like what would you say", "TyB7_LASMyo-00755-00169991-00170237": "you see here's the thing if I put my", "TyB7_LASMyo-00756-00170238-00170465": "principal hat back on I can walk into a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00757-00170466-00170675": "classroom I see 30 kids sitting on", "TyB7_LASMyo-00758-00170676-00170871": "thirty device 30 Chromebooks iPad I care", "TyB7_LASMyo-00759-00170872-00171185": "the devices they could be learning", "TyB7_LASMyo-00760-00171186-00171509": "incredible high levels or learning", "TyB7_LASMyo-00761-00171510-00171701": "absolutely nothing sometimes I'll see", "TyB7_LASMyo-00762-00171702-00171827": "districts and principals they got the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00763-00171828-00171947": "little walkthrough checklist they're all", "TyB7_LASMyo-00764-00171948-00172136": "in it yep kids are on devices this is", "TyB7_LASMyo-00765-00172137-00172313": "great this is awesome that is no", "TyB7_LASMyo-00766-00172314-00172443": "different than walking into a classroom", "TyB7_LASMyo-00767-00172444-00172593": "and saying yep the lights are on yep", "TyB7_LASMyo-00768-00172594-00172790": "they're learning like it being on the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00769-00172791-00173033": "device tells you nothing about learning", "TyB7_LASMyo-00770-00173034-00173333": "how the device is used is everything", "TyB7_LASMyo-00771-00173334-00173510": "about learning why cuz you can have the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00772-00173511-00173678": "exact same infrastructure exact same", "TyB7_LASMyo-00773-00173679-00173915": "content exactly everything and in one", "TyB7_LASMyo-00774-00173916-00174156": "one side of the hallway it's used for", "TyB7_LASMyo-00775-00174157-00174341": "very high levels on the other side of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00776-00174342-00174503": "the hallway it's a waste of money", "TyB7_LASMyo-00777-00174504-00174713": "so what actually works so what you're", "TyB7_LASMyo-00778-00174714-00174858": "seeing there's a slide you can see the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00779-00174859-00175046": "URL it's probably the longest shortened", "TyB7_LASMyo-00780-00175047-00175250": "URL I've ever created so we worked with", "TyB7_LASMyo-00781-00175251-00175391": "dr. Linda darling-hammond she's on our", "TyB7_LASMyo-00782-00175392-00175521": "team at the era I'm sorry she's on our", "TyB7_LASMyo-00783-00175522-00175700": "board at the Alliance well the top-down", "TyB7_LASMyo-00784-00175701-00175883": "researchers in the country throw the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00785-00175884-00176021": "curriculum side you've done any research", "TyB7_LASMyo-00786-00176022-00176252": "you know Linda darling-hammond is really", "TyB7_LASMyo-00787-00176253-00176426": "really well respected well known he", "TyB7_LASMyo-00788-00176427-00176568": "spent about a year looking about every", "TyB7_LASMyo-00789-00176569-00176757": "70 ed tech reviews her team did it", "TyB7_LASMyo-00790-00176758-00177026": "Stanford on what actually works with", "TyB7_LASMyo-00791-00177027-00177197": "that tech what works fran spend the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00792-00177198-00177287": "money we've gotta be able to answer", "TyB7_LASMyo-00793-00177288-00177464": "physically works and what are the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00794-00177465-00177650": "practices virtual total waste the money", "TyB7_LASMyo-00795-00177651-00177884": "here's what it boiled down to number one", "TyB7_LASMyo-00796-00177885-00178115": "is the learning interactive so when", "TyB7_LASMyo-00797-00178116-00178308": "learning is interactive like we're", "TyB7_LASMyo-00798-00178309-00178478": "seeing a lot of adaptive types of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00799-00178479-00178671": "technologies that's showing promise", "TyB7_LASMyo-00800-00178672-00178889": "that's showing worth the value the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00801-00178890-00179106": "national EdTech plan called that active", "TyB7_LASMyo-00802-00179107-00179399": "use active uses I'm exploring designing", "TyB7_LASMyo-00803-00179400-00179646": "like I'm creating that type of thing as", "TyB7_LASMyo-00804-00179647-00179900": "opposed to consumption base use my three", "TyB7_LASMyo-00805-00179901-00180207": "year olds can use his iPad he can hop on", "TyB7_LASMyo-00806-00180208-00180398": "Netflix he does a lot of consumption he", "TyB7_LASMyo-00807-00180399-00180575": "just does a lot of watching he watches", "TyB7_LASMyo-00808-00180576-00180812": "his little TV shows there's not an Heron", "TyB7_LASMyo-00809-00180813-00181008": "tier on but he's only gonna get low", "TyB7_LASMyo-00810-00181009-00181154": "level learning out of that it's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00811-00181155-00181391": "consumption based versus active", "TyB7_LASMyo-00812-00181392-00181551": "the national attack was that the digital", "TyB7_LASMyo-00813-00181552-00181764": "use divided the second thing the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00814-00181765-00181908": "interactive learning and this is key", "TyB7_LASMyo-00815-00181909-00182229": "it's the use of technology to it", "TyB7_LASMyo-00816-00182230-00182595": "for to design and to create and when the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00817-00182596-00182784": "when text being used for that that's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00818-00182785-00183003": "worth every penny you know what's not is", "TyB7_LASMyo-00819-00183004-00183213": "what I'd probably say in my opinion is", "TyB7_LASMyo-00820-00183214-00183375": "the most prevalent practice in her", "TyB7_LASMyo-00821-00183376-00183543": "country when it comes to tech and that's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00822-00183544-00183747": "the digital drilling kill the digital", "TyB7_LASMyo-00823-00183748-00183897": "drill and kill where we take the let's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00824-00183898-00184062": "say the old worksheet so to say it's now", "TyB7_LASMyo-00825-00184063-00184254": "scanned as a PDF online and we're just", "TyB7_LASMyo-00826-00184255-00184371": "doing like kind of problem after problem", "TyB7_LASMyo-00827-00184372-00184476": "after problem everybody's doing the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00828-00184477-00184659": "exact same thing that's not showing any", "TyB7_LASMyo-00829-00184660-00184899": "impact you know I was with today they", "TyB7_LASMyo-00830-00184900-00185073": "sponsor a summer today they do amazing", "TyB7_LASMyo-00831-00185074-00185121": "stuff", "TyB7_LASMyo-00832-00185122-00185274": "amazing work they'd awesome releases", "TyB7_LASMyo-00833-00185275-00185400": "today to help personal a little bit more", "TyB7_LASMyo-00834-00185401-00185571": "this is not a knock on them I want to be", "TyB7_LASMyo-00835-00185572-00185751": "clear on that but something like Google", "TyB7_LASMyo-00836-00185752-00185988": "Drive it's an amazing tool it's awesome", "TyB7_LASMyo-00837-00185989-00186285": "however if I use Google Drive it's very", "TyB7_LASMyo-00838-00186286-00186462": "simple Google Drive could simply be", "TyB7_LASMyo-00839-00186463-00186702": "electronic version of the packet of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00840-00186703-00186879": "papers in the folder that used to be in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00841-00186880-00187056": "the desk is now sitting on my Chromebook", "TyB7_LASMyo-00842-00187057-00187391": "with no pedagogical difference now again", "TyB7_LASMyo-00843-00187392-00187536": "that's not a knock on dried and it", "TyB7_LASMyo-00844-00187537-00187740": "doesn't have to be used by that but just", "TyB7_LASMyo-00845-00187741-00187890": "because we're now using Google and it's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00846-00187891-00188037": "now in Drive and it's now electronic", "TyB7_LASMyo-00847-00188038-00188204": "sometimes we're patting ourselves on the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00848-00188205-00188319": "back like wow we're doing all this", "TyB7_LASMyo-00849-00188320-00188529": "amazing learning no it's just now on a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00850-00188530-00188664": "computer and it's not here at your desk", "TyB7_LASMyo-00851-00188665-00188874": "if that's all we're changing we're", "TyB7_LASMyo-00852-00188875-00189036": "spending a lot of money and not getting", "TyB7_LASMyo-00853-00189037-00189231": "anything for it again hear me clear not", "TyB7_LASMyo-00854-00189232-00189390": "a knock on Google they're awesome drive", "TyB7_LASMyo-00855-00189391-00189552": "to that stuff can be great it's a good", "TyB7_LASMyo-00856-00189553-00189690": "collaboration tools and those kinds of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00857-00189691-00189894": "thing how do we get to explore design", "TyB7_LASMyo-00858-00189895-00190119": "and create not just the digital drill", "TyB7_LASMyo-00859-00190120-00190308": "and kill the other piece to that is the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00860-00190309-00190485": "right blend of teachers and technology I", "TyB7_LASMyo-00861-00190486-00190611": "encourage you to take a look at that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00862-00190612-00190791": "study it's only seven or eight pages a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00863-00190792-00190998": "synopsis of it but it also gets to start", "TyB7_LASMyo-00864-00190999-00191118": "to highlight some of the things what are", "TyB7_LASMyo-00865-00191119-00191256": "we doing common practice is that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00866-00191257-00191478": "honestly you're a waste of money", "TyB7_LASMyo-00867-00191479-00191574": "like we're not spending all this time", "TyB7_LASMyo-00868-00191575-00191864": "and it's just not doing it next slide", "TyB7_LASMyo-00869-00191865-00192146": "so explore design and create a really", "TyB7_LASMyo-00870-00192147-00192191": "key", "TyB7_LASMyo-00871-00192192-00192369": "keep going Mitch", "TyB7_LASMyo-00872-00192370-00192556": "so I mentioned that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00873-00192557-00192739": "keep going that digital use divided", "TyB7_LASMyo-00874-00192740-00193002": "piece", "TyB7_LASMyo-00875-00193003-00193290": "so if we had more time if we had more", "TyB7_LASMyo-00876-00193291-00193437": "than 17 minutes I would ask you to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00877-00193438-00193560": "wrestle with this and I started to pose", "TyB7_LASMyo-00878-00193561-00193716": "it but I do want you to ponder it after", "TyB7_LASMyo-00879-00193717-00193869": "tonight you walk through your schools", "TyB7_LASMyo-00880-00193870-00194007": "tomorrow I may be your classroom teacher", "TyB7_LASMyo-00881-00194008-00194193": "you know what does that successful", "TyB7_LASMyo-00882-00194194-00194394": "infusion look like just because we're", "TyB7_LASMyo-00883-00194395-00194559": "all using tech or it goes really well", "TyB7_LASMyo-00884-00194560-00194772": "doesn't actually mean it's a levels of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00885-00194773-00194976": "learning if you use that Webb's depth of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00886-00194977-00195147": "knowledge or Bloom's taxonomy how do we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00887-00195148-00195399": "still get to those higher ends not just", "TyB7_LASMyo-00888-00195400-00195612": "now again it's not narrowly bad just", "TyB7_LASMyo-00889-00195613-00195777": "because I'm logging on a computer to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00890-00195778-00195936": "watch a video we don't want to look at", "TyB7_LASMyo-00891-00195937-00196038": "and say oh that's a bad use of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00892-00196039-00196197": "technology no it's just that's gonna be", "TyB7_LASMyo-00893-00196198-00196425": "a low level use of technology so how do", "TyB7_LASMyo-00894-00196426-00196617": "we get to those higher ends next one", "TyB7_LASMyo-00895-00196618-00196837": "there Mitch", "TyB7_LASMyo-00896-00196838-00197008": "let me get this one quickly as well this", "TyB7_LASMyo-00897-00197009-00197161": "is personalized professional learning", "TyB7_LASMyo-00898-00197162-00197287": "and I'll try and sum it up and just to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00899-00197288-00197461": "go ahead just a couple moments my very", "TyB7_LASMyo-00900-00197462-00197620": "first book was on this topic and I'm", "TyB7_LASMyo-00901-00197621-00197782": "fascinated by this notion of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00902-00197783-00197986": "professional learning partially because", "TyB7_LASMyo-00903-00197987-00198303": "we spend billions of dollars a year in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00904-00198304-00198547": "this area and we've got a Hester cell", "TyB7_LASMyo-00905-00198548-00198688": "with billions of dollars a year being", "TyB7_LASMyo-00906-00198689-00198978": "spent how much actually changes so it's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00907-00198979-00199108": "another area that Eric and I really", "TyB7_LASMyo-00908-00199109-00199423": "really dove into and look when you look", "TyB7_LASMyo-00909-00199424-00199546": "at personalized personal learning when", "TyB7_LASMyo-00910-00199547-00199681": "you look at this area kind of the one", "TyB7_LASMyo-00911-00199682-00199912": "way I'll put it the one statement is the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00912-00199913-00200484": "top-down one-size-fits-all sit and get", "TyB7_LASMyo-00913-00200485-00200824": "hours based accountability which I will", "TyB7_LASMyo-00914-00200825-00201076": "say is prevalent has been prevalent it's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00915-00201077-00201264": "really shifted a lot in the past five or", "TyB7_LASMyo-00916-00201265-00201475": "six years but has been ten years ago", "TyB7_LASMyo-00917-00201476-00201702": "that was the norm 99.9% of schools you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00918-00201703-00201906": "find any research out there on that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00919-00201907-00202102": "shows it really doesn't show any it", "TyB7_LASMyo-00920-00202103-00202290": "doesn't really make any impact like", "TyB7_LASMyo-00921-00202291-00202435": "we're all horrified because that's all", "TyB7_LASMyo-00922-00202436-00202648": "what we've always done but show research", "TyB7_LASMyo-00923-00202649-00202870": "out there that shows other than that you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00924-00202871-00203011": "have to see what does work how do we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00925-00203012-00203206": "make learning more personal next slide", "TyB7_LASMyo-00926-00203207-00203386": "there Mitch", "TyB7_LASMyo-00927-00203387-00203547": "you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00928-00203548-00203736": "so some of the element can see there", "TyB7_LASMyo-00929-00203737-00203910": "that shared ownership shared", "TyB7_LASMyo-00930-00203911-00204132": "responsibility that 21st century skill", "TyB7_LASMyo-00931-00204133-00204314": "set that more personalized approach what", "TyB7_LASMyo-00932-00204315-00204468": "does that even look like and also that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00933-00204469-00204633": "broad-based participate of evaluation", "TyB7_LASMyo-00934-00204634-00204779": "those are again the elements from future", "TyB7_LASMyo-00935-00204780-00204971": "ready that are research-based and go", "TyB7_LASMyo-00936-00204973-00205311": "ahead match next slide", "TyB7_LASMyo-00937-00205312-00205476": "I'm gonna keep rolling here keep going", "TyB7_LASMyo-00938-00205477-00205638": "how do we make that way more time how do", "TyB7_LASMyo-00939-00205639-00205764": "we make it more personalized we could", "TyB7_LASMyo-00940-00205765-00205959": "get into what it how do we personalize", "TyB7_LASMyo-00941-00205960-00206130": "how do you take ownership of your own", "TyB7_LASMyo-00942-00206131-00206340": "learning ultimately from a school and", "TyB7_LASMyo-00943-00206341-00206484": "how do we get teachers to take ownership", "TyB7_LASMyo-00944-00206485-00206598": "of their own learning", "TyB7_LASMyo-00945-00206600-00206773": "you guys all obviously do this is 8:45", "TyB7_LASMyo-00946-00206773-00207006": "on a Thursday night or whatever nights a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00947-00207007-00207075": "Wednesday night", "TyB7_LASMyo-00948-00207076-00207216": "we're all having this conversation when", "TyB7_LASMyo-00949-00207217-00207378": "we could all be sleeping right and so", "TyB7_LASMyo-00950-00207379-00207630": "how do we make that the normal misete I", "TyB7_LASMyo-00951-00207631-00207789": "wish we had a lot of time we could dive", "TyB7_LASMyo-00952-00207790-00207960": "into things like PLC's and things that", "TyB7_LASMyo-00953-00207961-00208080": "research actually show it's actually", "TyB7_LASMyo-00954-00208081-00208299": "works how do you have our people the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00955-00208300-00208434": "other thing is you know having been a", "TyB7_LASMyo-00956-00208435-00208573": "longtime district administrator I know", "TyB7_LASMyo-00957-00208573-00208725": "what it's like to be the person that's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00958-00208726-00208854": "always up front always doing the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00959-00208855-00209111": "training how do we get our teachers to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00960-00209112-00209398": "empower teachers so they're sharing", "TyB7_LASMyo-00961-00209398-00209613": "their genius on a daily basis weekly", "TyB7_LASMyo-00962-00209614-00209823": "basis so much of professional learning", "TyB7_LASMyo-00963-00209825-00210013": "to me is also cultural that cultural", "TyB7_LASMyo-00964-00210014-00210316": "mindset for our admin here and also part", "TyB7_LASMyo-00965-00210317-00210448": "of it when we work with add minutes is", "TyB7_LASMyo-00966-00210448-00210651": "how do you model you see like from an", "TyB7_LASMyo-00967-00210652-00210807": "administrative men this isn't just what", "TyB7_LASMyo-00968-00210808-00210991": "everybody else has to do this isn't what", "TyB7_LASMyo-00969-00210992-00211134": "you just have to lead this is about you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00970-00211135-00211329": "like how do you grow professionally how", "TyB7_LASMyo-00971-00211330-00211492": "do you grow on a daily basis how do you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00972-00211492-00211704": "model that for your staff for our admin", "TyB7_LASMyo-00973-00211705-00211830": "that might be here how do you run", "TyB7_LASMyo-00974-00211831-00211996": "faculty meetings how do you run in", "TyB7_LASMyo-00975-00211996-00212188": "service days you know are they a direct", "TyB7_LASMyo-00976-00212189-00212307": "reflection for what you're asking", "TyB7_LASMyo-00977-00212308-00212451": "teachers to do in the classroom if", "TyB7_LASMyo-00978-00212452-00212665": "they're not a guide be honest that's", "TyB7_LASMyo-00979-00212666-00212802": "hypocritical if you're gonna ask for", "TyB7_LASMyo-00980-00212803-00212967": "teachers to do it in the classroom with", "TyB7_LASMyo-00981-00212969-00213075": "kids we need to be doing those things", "TyB7_LASMyo-00982-00213076-00213271": "with our teachers whatever it may be the", "TyB7_LASMyo-00983-00213271-00213399": "next year here let me hit this one", "TyB7_LASMyo-00984-00213400-00213544": "quickly this is budget and resources", "TyB7_LASMyo-00985-00213544-00213712": "Mitch let's go let's go through this", "TyB7_LASMyo-00986-00213713-00213831": "quickly this in one word is", "TyB7_LASMyo-00987-00213832-00213967": "sustainability we could spend a lot of", "TyB7_LASMyo-00988-00213967-00214167": "time on that if we're buying stuff or", "TyB7_LASMyo-00989-00214169-00214323": "buying iPads Chromebooks three four or", "TyB7_LASMyo-00990-00214325-00214467": "five years from now and we have to", "TyB7_LASMyo-00991-00214469-00214629": "replace those where's the money come", "TyB7_LASMyo-00992-00214630-00214881": "from if we can't answer that we're gonna", "TyB7_LASMyo-00993-00214882-00215130": "be in a really bad spot and so how do we", "TyB7_LASMyo-00994-00215131-00215349": "get that sustainability piece is really", "TyB7_LASMyo-00995-00215350-00215614": "key next slide there Mitch", "TyB7_LASMyo-00996-00215615-00215925": "keep on", "TyB7_LASMyo-00997-00215926-00216132": "next one Community Partnerships this", "TyB7_LASMyo-00998-00216133-00216317": "next gear of the framework how do you", "TyB7_LASMyo-00999-00216319-00216483": "partner with your community you know", "TyB7_LASMyo-01000-00216484-00216606": "when I was an elementary principal I", "TyB7_LASMyo-01001-00216607-00216753": "think I did a really good job working", "TyB7_LASMyo-01002-00216754-00216927": "with parents communicating with parents", "TyB7_LASMyo-01003-00216928-00217107": "I think it did a little job", "TyB7_LASMyo-01004-00217108-00217332": "partnering with my businesses the things", "TyB7_LASMyo-01005-00217333-00217452": "that I could have done you see most of", "TyB7_LASMyo-01006-00217453-00217602": "our businesses every single business", "TyB7_LASMyo-01007-00217603-00217788": "fathom is for a minute every single", "TyB7_LASMyo-01008-00217789-00218060": "business in the United States falls in", "TyB7_LASMyo-01009-00218061-00218181": "the districts of a school districts", "TyB7_LASMyo-01010-00218182-00218292": "falls in the boundary of a school", "TyB7_LASMyo-01011-00218292-00218544": "district how do we partner with them how", "TyB7_LASMyo-01012-00218544-00218706": "do we compatibly connect with businesses", "TyB7_LASMyo-01013-00218707-00218883": "now sure a lot of businesses might not", "TyB7_LASMyo-01014-00218884-00219162": "be remotely interested but guess what so", "TyB7_LASMyo-01015-00219163-00219284": "many times especially of our small", "TyB7_LASMyo-01016-00219285-00219462": "businesses small businesses the backbone", "TyB7_LASMyo-01017-00219463-00219681": "of our country where do those owners", "TyB7_LASMyo-01018-00219682-00219927": "kids go to school quite often it's in", "TyB7_LASMyo-01019-00219928-00220104": "our own district and we partner with", "TyB7_LASMyo-01020-00220105-00220275": "businesses what can we do when we see", "TyB7_LASMyo-01021-00220276-00220500": "things like community Wi-Fi happening", "TyB7_LASMyo-01022-00220501-00220685": "places like that X live minutes let's", "TyB7_LASMyo-01023-00220686-00220796": "talk about partner community", "TyB7_LASMyo-01024-00220798-00220946": "partnerships here for a minute you can", "TyB7_LASMyo-01025-00220948-00221232": "see some of the the different elements", "TyB7_LASMyo-01026-00221233-00221580": "that are there next slide", "TyB7_LASMyo-01027-00221581-00221717": "I I created this when I was a tech", "TyB7_LASMyo-01028-00221719-00221846": "director actually and this talks about", "TyB7_LASMyo-01029-00221848-00221985": "the communication side and don't", "TyB7_LASMyo-01030-00221986-00222111": "misunderstand it when you read it and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01031-00222112-00222261": "hopefully get a little bit of juggle you", "TyB7_LASMyo-01032-00222262-00222396": "know I can't wait to go home and check", "TyB7_LASMyo-01033-00222396-00222600": "the School District web page said no", "TyB7_LASMyo-01034-00222601-00222879": "parent ever you know I'm a parent my", "TyB7_LASMyo-01035-00222880-00222996": "daughters in school I gotta be honest I", "TyB7_LASMyo-01036-00222996-00223094": "don't think I checked this School", "TyB7_LASMyo-01037-00223096-00223341": "District webpage in doing what I do and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01038-00223342-00223557": "probably a month now that is not a knock", "TyB7_LASMyo-01039-00223558-00223721": "against district webpages let me say", "TyB7_LASMyo-01040-00223723-00223767": "this", "TyB7_LASMyo-01041-00223767-00224244": "it's 2017 it's our job to have robust", "TyB7_LASMyo-01042-00224244-00224430": "websites because what business do we", "TyB7_LASMyo-01043-00224431-00224535": "work with that doesn't have a robust", "TyB7_LASMyo-01044-00224536-00224687": "website it's really just an expectation", "TyB7_LASMyo-01045-00224688-00224892": "it's just an expectation but it's not", "TyB7_LASMyo-01046-00224892-00225066": "fool ourselves let's not think that our", "TyB7_LASMyo-01047-00225067-00225198": "parents are driving home we talk about", "TyB7_LASMyo-01048-00225198-00225375": "community engagement let's not think", "TyB7_LASMyo-01049-00225376-00225519": "about our parents are driving home being", "TyB7_LASMyo-01050-00225519-00225692": "like I can't wait to check the district", "TyB7_LASMyo-01051-00225694-00225882": "website to see if they uploaded a new", "TyB7_LASMyo-01052-00225883-00226140": "forum today like nobody's doing that so", "TyB7_LASMyo-01053-00226141-00226317": "how do we do this let's go through these", "TyB7_LASMyo-01054-00226317-00226494": "quickly here Mitch how do we start to", "TyB7_LASMyo-01055-00226494-00226698": "when we talk about I've mentioned my", "TyB7_LASMyo-01056-00226698-00226833": "good friend George Krause and what he", "TyB7_LASMyo-01057-00226834-00226973": "does I love how he talks about this", "TyB7_LASMyo-01058-00226975-00227144": "notion that you know we need to make the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01059-00227146-00227417": "positives so loud that the negative", "TyB7_LASMyo-01060-00227419-00227621": "becomes hard to hear you know every one", "TyB7_LASMyo-01061-00227623-00227778": "of our every day and every one of our", "TyB7_LASMyo-01062-00227779-00228225": "schools amazing things every day yet", "TyB7_LASMyo-01063-00228226-00228351": "when I picked up the newspaper and when", "TyB7_LASMyo-01064-00228352-00228486": "I looked online and I look on the news", "TyB7_LASMyo-01065-00228487-00228692": "I'm not typically seeing the awesome", "TyB7_LASMyo-01066-00228694-00228777": "things that are happening in your", "TyB7_LASMyo-01067-00228778-00228936": "schools every day right we see the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01068-00228937-00229067": "negative we see the news we see we", "TyB7_LASMyo-01069-00229069-00229275": "constantly all get attacked we not but", "TyB7_LASMyo-01070-00229276-00229476": "we know today with 250 school", "TyB7_LASMyo-01071-00229477-00229665": "administrators forty-five minutes to", "TyB7_LASMyo-01072-00229666-00229854": "share amazing things and all the schools", "TyB7_LASMyo-01073-00229855-00230058": "that are going on how do we partner with", "TyB7_LASMyo-01074-00230059-00230235": "our community how do we share our story", "TyB7_LASMyo-01075-00230236-00230427": "tell our story and all the great ways", "TyB7_LASMyo-01076-00230428-00230517": "and all the great things we're doing", "TyB7_LASMyo-01077-00230517-00230883": "next slide Mitch", "TyB7_LASMyo-01078-00230884-00231181": "let me get one other piece here that's a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01079-00231182-00231298": "that's a yeah we're gonna go through", "TyB7_LASMyo-01080-00231300-00231473": "this quickly Mitch but that's a map of", "TyB7_LASMyo-01081-00231473-00231694": "Mount Everest that's actually the Wi-Fi", "TyB7_LASMyo-01082-00231696-00231856": "map I want you to look if you can see", "TyB7_LASMyo-01083-00231857-00232025": "quickly that see this statistic in the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01084-00232026-00232231": "bottom left I work with the FCC and the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01085-00232232-00232376": "people they're related to II rate and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01086-00232377-00232580": "lifeline modernization when you look at", "TyB7_LASMyo-01087-00232581-00232759": "those things do you realize that five", "TyB7_LASMyo-01088-00232760-00233000": "million of our nation's children when", "TyB7_LASMyo-01089-00233001-00233330": "they leave us at school five million of", "TyB7_LASMyo-01090-00233331-00233576": "them go home to no internet access or no", "TyB7_LASMyo-01091-00233577-00233830": "connectivity next slide I want to talk", "TyB7_LASMyo-01092-00233831-00233996": "about partnering with the community let", "TyB7_LASMyo-01093-00233996-00234173": "me give you a couple quick examples so", "TyB7_LASMyo-01094-00234173-00234292": "that's Russell Booker he was the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01095-00234294-00234446": "superintendent of the year last year", "TyB7_LASMyo-01096-00234446-00234605": "believe in South Carolina you know what", "TyB7_LASMyo-01097-00234606-00234740": "they started to do talk about partnering", "TyB7_LASMyo-01098-00234741-00234971": "with the community they created and they", "TyB7_LASMyo-01099-00234971-00235148": "were doing this digital initiative they", "TyB7_LASMyo-01100-00235148-00235304": "Russell and his team reached out to all", "TyB7_LASMyo-01101-00235305-00235514": "the businesses in his community and what", "TyB7_LASMyo-01102-00235515-00235805": "those businesses said was they said to", "TyB7_LASMyo-01103-00235806-00235928": "the businesses say this is what we're", "TyB7_LASMyo-01104-00235929-00236150": "doing but inside our community many of", "TyB7_LASMyo-01105-00236151-00236429": "these kids do not have Wi-Fi at home as", "TyB7_LASMyo-01106-00236430-00236630": "a business and they started with", "TyB7_LASMyo-01107-00236631-00236857": "Starbucks McDonald's Public Library", "TyB7_LASMyo-01108-00236858-00236980": "places that already do with it already", "TyB7_LASMyo-01109-00236981-00237173": "have it would you be willing to let our", "TyB7_LASMyo-01110-00237173-00237305": "kids come after school that don't have", "TyB7_LASMyo-01111-00237306-00237460": "connectivity at home would you let them", "TyB7_LASMyo-01112-00237461-00237650": "hop on and they created the map that you", "TyB7_LASMyo-01113-00237651-00237808": "can see there quickly but they didn't", "TyB7_LASMyo-01114-00237809-00237962": "share with kids hey if you go home and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01115-00237963-00238103": "you don't have access here's all the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01116-00238104-00238292": "places in our community that you can go", "TyB7_LASMyo-01117-00238292-00238444": "hop online totally for free and you're", "TyB7_LASMyo-01118-00238446-00238630": "welcome to work Russell I talked to him", "TyB7_LASMyo-01119-00238631-00238748": "a couple months ago he always said he", "TyB7_LASMyo-01120-00238748-00238930": "said there was a business that called", "TyB7_LASMyo-01121-00238931-00239230": "him up and said you know we like when a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01122-00239231-00239330": "couple's you're coming here this is", "TyB7_LASMyo-01123-00239331-00239489": "really pretty cool and these are our", "TyB7_LASMyo-01124-00239490-00239696": "kids our families our community we had a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01125-00239696-00239867": "really good year this left last year as", "TyB7_LASMyo-01126-00239867-00240077": "a business as a district is there", "TyB7_LASMyo-01127-00240078-00240266": "anything else we can help you with what", "TyB7_LASMyo-01128-00240267-00240371": "can we get for you what do you need", "TyB7_LASMyo-01129-00240371-00240631": "that's partnering with the community", "TyB7_LASMyo-01130-00240632-00240859": "that's partnering also if I'm if I'm one", "TyB7_LASMyo-01131-00240860-00241064": "of those families how does that make me", "TyB7_LASMyo-01132-00241065-00241238": "feel that's building a relationship", "TyB7_LASMyo-01133-00241239-00241403": "you're showing them that matters by the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01134-00241404-00241604": "way that didn't really cost Russell and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01135-00241605-00241805": "his team anything but time and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01136-00241806-00242294": "relationship building next slide", "TyB7_LASMyo-01137-00242294-00242446": "a couple other quick examples this is", "TyB7_LASMyo-01138-00242448-00242639": "Kent School District in Washington they", "TyB7_LASMyo-01139-00242640-00242833": "create these Wi-Fi kiosks and where are", "TyB7_LASMyo-01140-00242834-00242990": "they putting them in church and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01141-00242991-00243184": "synagogues and mosques and laundromat", "TyB7_LASMyo-01142-00243185-00243385": "broadcasting Wi-Fi from the district and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01143-00243386-00243559": "all these basically huge hot spots", "TyB7_LASMyo-01144-00243560-00243740": "throughout the community so kids and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01145-00243741-00243869": "families can go and they can work", "TyB7_LASMyo-01146-00243869-00244042": "actually share with families and say you", "TyB7_LASMyo-01147-00244044-00244219": "know what if you're a parent and you", "TyB7_LASMyo-01148-00244221-00244408": "want to apply for a job and you want to", "TyB7_LASMyo-01149-00244409-00244604": "hop on our Wi-Fi to do that we encourage", "TyB7_LASMyo-01150-00244605-00244792": "you to do that in relationships next", "TyB7_LASMyo-01151-00244794-00245065": "slide", "TyB7_LASMyo-01152-00245066-00245341": "so this notion of storytelling and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01153-00245342-00245634": "branding we had more time I'd again get", "TyB7_LASMyo-01154-00245635-00245773": "us together to be able to talk about", "TyB7_LASMyo-01155-00245773-00245815": "this", "TyB7_LASMyo-01156-00245816-00245994": "how are you telling your story how are", "TyB7_LASMyo-01157-00245996-00246214": "you leveraging social media how are you", "TyB7_LASMyo-01158-00246215-00246378": "communicating how do you communicate", "TyB7_LASMyo-01159-00246379-00246523": "with those that don't have internet", "TyB7_LASMyo-01160-00246523-00246726": "access sometimes we put it online and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01161-00246727-00246898": "magic number being an elementary", "TyB7_LASMyo-01162-00246898-00247080": "principal and saying to my secretary you", "TyB7_LASMyo-01163-00247081-00247294": "know I sent it home one time I put it on", "TyB7_LASMyo-01164-00247294-00247482": "the website how come nobody knows and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01165-00247483-00247671": "shame on me for just thinking that", "TyB7_LASMyo-01166-00247673-00247809": "everybody was magically gonna be", "TyB7_LASMyo-01167-00247810-00247932": "attracted to that how do you leverage", "TyB7_LASMyo-01168-00247933-00248157": "digital tools we've got to meet parents", "TyB7_LASMyo-01169-00248158-00248638": "where they are next slide couple more", "TyB7_LASMyo-01170-00248639-00248788": "gotta go real quick here because it's", "TyB7_LASMyo-01171-00248789-00248976": "time we mentioned this one quickly data", "TyB7_LASMyo-01172-00248977-00249099": "and privacy at the opportunity to", "TyB7_LASMyo-01173-00249100-00249225": "testify in front of Congress about two", "TyB7_LASMyo-01174-00249226-00249426": "years ago on the privacy issue", "TyB7_LASMyo-01175-00249427-00249753": "if data privacy is not on your radar it", "TyB7_LASMyo-01176-00249754-00249969": "needs to be next slide let me show you I", "TyB7_LASMyo-01177-00249971-00250248": "think I've got this in here let's keep", "TyB7_LASMyo-01178-00250250-00250584": "going mich next slide so take a look at", "TyB7_LASMyo-01179-00250585-00250798": "that that was last year twenty eight", "TyB7_LASMyo-01180-00250798-00251030": "laws related to privacy were enacted a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01181-00251031-00251358": "hundred and eighty eight bills in 47", "TyB7_LASMyo-01182-00251359-00251596": "states related to student data privacy", "TyB7_LASMyo-01183-00251596-00251784": "if you don't think this is on the radar", "TyB7_LASMyo-01184-00251785-00251998": "federally we work with Republicans and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01185-00251998-00252217": "Democrats in DC that's federal now and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01186-00252217-00252456": "I'm telling you on both sides of aisle", "TyB7_LASMyo-01187-00252457-00252675": "this is an issue this this all do we", "TyB7_LASMyo-01188-00252676-00252892": "expend FERPA do we open up FERPA does", "TyB7_LASMyo-01189-00252892-00253050": "your average teacher have an idea of", "TyB7_LASMyo-01190-00253051-00253317": "what their obligations are under FERPA", "TyB7_LASMyo-01191-00253319-00253667": "or CIPA under Coppa", "TyB7_LASMyo-01192-00253667-00253912": "PPRA legally but it's our responsibility", "TyB7_LASMyo-01193-00253913-00254227": "but do they know and so how do we make", "TyB7_LASMyo-01194-00254228-00254396": "sure how do we work with our staff how", "TyB7_LASMyo-01195-00254396-00254548": "do we train our staff most importantly", "TyB7_LASMyo-01196-00254550-00254731": "though how do we keep kids safe so how", "TyB7_LASMyo-01197-00254732-00254900": "do we balance though let's get them the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01198-00254901-00255062": "great tools that they need the great", "TyB7_LASMyo-01199-00255063-00255251": "digital tools yeah we need to make sure", "TyB7_LASMyo-01200-00255252-00255478": "we are protecting every single aspect we", "TyB7_LASMyo-01201-00255479-00255671": "can and also teaching kids about their", "TyB7_LASMyo-01202-00255671-00255794": "digital footprint and digital", "TyB7_LASMyo-01203-00255794-00256262": "citizenship next slide", "TyB7_LASMyo-01204-00256263-00256471": "I'm gonna keep going there just from a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01205-00256473-00256709": "time standpoint", "TyB7_LASMyo-01206-00256710-00257037": "keep going keep going - sometime", "TyB7_LASMyo-01207-00257038-00257256": "keep going", "TyB7_LASMyo-01208-00257257-00257409": "let's hit the next one robust", "TyB7_LASMyo-01209-00257410-00257544": "infrastructure let me talk about this", "TyB7_LASMyo-01210-00257545-00257839": "for just a couple moments success do we", "TyB7_LASMyo-01211-00257840-00258013": "in our schools have that ear eighths", "TyB7_LASMyo-01212-00258014-00258267": "helped a lot we we help support that", "TyB7_LASMyo-01213-00258268-00258417": "with the FCC and help to bring that out", "TyB7_LASMyo-01214-00258418-00258669": "how do we have that ubiquitous access", "TyB7_LASMyo-01215-00258670-00258841": "what what does that look like the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01216-00258842-00259063": "connectivity things like refresh rate", "TyB7_LASMyo-01217-00259064-00259197": "three fresh plans the amount of times", "TyB7_LASMyo-01218-00259198-00259368": "I'll talk to an administrator and yeah", "TyB7_LASMyo-01219-00259369-00259572": "we're one-to-one this is awesome and I", "TyB7_LASMyo-01220-00259573-00259687": "talked to the teacher and they're like", "TyB7_LASMyo-01221-00259688-00259983": "yeah but my one to one cart our nine", "TyB7_LASMyo-01222-00259984-00260301": "year old computers that take 27 minutes", "TyB7_LASMyo-01223-00260302-00260358": "to boot", "TyB7_LASMyo-01224-00260359-00260550": "well that's like that refresh side of", "TyB7_LASMyo-01225-00260551-00260841": "things we just make sure that it's it's", "TyB7_LASMyo-01226-00260842-00261021": "that you have it good as connectivity is", "TyB7_LASMyo-01227-00261022-00261183": "really their jump to the last the next", "TyB7_LASMyo-01228-00261184-00261573": "year Mitch this is the use of space and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01229-00261574-00261768": "the use of time and so go ahead to the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01230-00261769-00261960": "next one when we take a look at say the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01231-00261961-00262203": "use of the use of space and the use of", "TyB7_LASMyo-01232-00262204-00262350": "time I really believe we're teaching", "TyB7_LASMyo-01233-00262351-00262527": "what's called what I coined the net I'm", "TyB7_LASMyo-01234-00262528-00262734": "sorry that coin what I call the Netflix", "TyB7_LASMyo-01235-00262735-00263103": "generation of kids you know my daughter", "TyB7_LASMyo-01236-00263104-00263367": "at six years old really has no concept", "TyB7_LASMyo-01237-00263368-00263568": "of what it's like to have to wait until", "TyB7_LASMyo-01238-00263569-00263784": "next Tuesday at seven o'clock to watch", "TyB7_LASMyo-01239-00263785-00263965": "your favorite TV show what do our kids", "TyB7_LASMyo-01240-00263966-00264120": "today that are growing up those with", "TyB7_LASMyo-01241-00264121-00264357": "access what were they doing they get", "TyB7_LASMyo-01242-00264358-00264627": "their content on demand when they want", "TyB7_LASMyo-01243-00264628-00264807": "it right then and there that's the world", "TyB7_LASMyo-01244-00264808-00264972": "my three-year-old lives every day", "TyB7_LASMyo-01245-00264973-00265173": "those kids are coming through our", "TyB7_LASMyo-01246-00265174-00265317": "schools this wave is coming through our", "TyB7_LASMyo-01247-00265318-00265530": "schools a wave of kids that are used to", "TyB7_LASMyo-01248-00265531-00265765": "content on demand well uh puts us in a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01249-00265766-00265977": "really interesting spot is it not so how", "TyB7_LASMyo-01250-00265978-00266127": "do we do this Anytime Anywhere learning", "TyB7_LASMyo-01251-00266128-00266325": "what who are you partnering with for", "TyB7_LASMyo-01252-00266326-00266532": "high quality content that kids can get", "TyB7_LASMyo-01253-00266533-00266931": "on a Saturday on a July 12 what does", "TyB7_LASMyo-01254-00266932-00267250": "that look like where can they get that", "TyB7_LASMyo-01255-00267251-00267616": "right Mitch excellent", "TyB7_LASMyo-01256-00267617-00267759": "there are some of the elements you can", "TyB7_LASMyo-01257-00267760-00267988": "see related to that so I took two images", "TyB7_LASMyo-01258-00267989-00268147": "think about the space side so that's", "TyB7_LASMyo-01259-00268148-00268288": "kind of learning anytime anywhere or a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01260-00268289-00268489": "bit of it but then there's the space and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01261-00268490-00268639": "there's been a really growing interest", "TyB7_LASMyo-01262-00268640-00268753": "in this area in the past couple years", "TyB7_LASMyo-01263-00268754-00268908": "walk into the high school and whatever", "TyB7_LASMyo-01264-00268909-00269055": "district here and I'm gonna pick on high", "TyB7_LASMyo-01265-00269056-00269215": "school for a minute walk into the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01266-00269216-00269355": "average classroom the average high", "TyB7_LASMyo-01267-00269356-00269527": "school in the average part of America", "TyB7_LASMyo-01268-00269528-00269671": "whatever that even might be probably", "TyB7_LASMyo-01269-00269672-00269788": "made no sense and I apologize about that", "TyB7_LASMyo-01270-00269789-00269910": "but you know I'm saying like the average", "TyB7_LASMyo-01271-00269911-00270135": "high school in our country picture a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01272-00270136-00270316": "high school classroom you have an image", "TyB7_LASMyo-01273-00270317-00270487": "in your head and it probably looks like", "TyB7_LASMyo-01274-00270488-00270613": "thought like the screen you're looking", "TyB7_LASMyo-01275-00270614-00270744": "at", "TyB7_LASMyo-01276-00270745-00271065": "if we're gonna shift pedagogy we've got", "TyB7_LASMyo-01277-00271066-00271232": "to shift the space that it takes in", "TyB7_LASMyo-01278-00271233-00271488": "think about this how can we in good", "TyB7_LASMyo-01279-00271489-00271689": "thing say that we're problem-solving", "TyB7_LASMyo-01280-00271690-00271968": "we're collaborating all these 21st", "TyB7_LASMyo-01281-00271969-00272129": "century skills by the way we're", "TyB7_LASMyo-01282-00272130-00272298": "seventeen years into that just throwing", "TyB7_LASMyo-01283-00272299-00272571": "that out there all these skills yet when", "TyB7_LASMyo-01284-00272572-00272769": "we walk into the average classroom in", "TyB7_LASMyo-01285-00272770-00273045": "many places it's still teacher upfront", "TyB7_LASMyo-01286-00273046-00273312": "kids are all islands unto themselves I", "TyB7_LASMyo-01287-00273313-00273474": "like to coin that kind of that cemetery", "TyB7_LASMyo-01288-00273475-00273755": "effect piece if we're gonna shift the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01289-00273756-00274017": "pedagogy we've got to shift the space", "TyB7_LASMyo-01290-00274018-00274173": "there's a lot of research out there on", "TyB7_LASMyo-01291-00274174-00274328": "learning space design Eric and I", "TyB7_LASMyo-01292-00274329-00274503": "actually outline it in the book that", "TyB7_LASMyo-01293-00274504-00274776": "we're doing for a SUV and um and taking", "TyB7_LASMyo-01294-00274777-00274899": "a look at like all the different things", "TyB7_LASMyo-01295-00274900-00275135": "that impact the brain and impact how", "TyB7_LASMyo-01296-00275136-00275373": "people learn learning spaces impact", "TyB7_LASMyo-01297-00275374-00275571": "learning shifting pedagogy shifting", "TyB7_LASMyo-01298-00275572-00275810": "spaces so how does this become reality", "TyB7_LASMyo-01299-00275811-00276048": "go ahead Mitch and we're coming down in", "TyB7_LASMyo-01300-00276049-00276233": "time here so that's the framework and I", "TyB7_LASMyo-01301-00276234-00276366": "know I'm talking as quick as I can and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01302-00276367-00276498": "trying to get us to interact a little", "TyB7_LASMyo-01303-00276499-00276666": "bit but flying through there though", "TyB7_LASMyo-01304-00276667-00276864": "those are just snapshots of the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01305-00276865-00276987": "different areas of the framework", "TyB7_LASMyo-01306-00276988-00277176": "snapshots of the area now I'll tell you", "TyB7_LASMyo-01307-00277177-00277377": "them I didn't tell you anything new like", "TyB7_LASMyo-01308-00277378-00277527": "these are all areas that you're aware of", "TyB7_LASMyo-01309-00277528-00277685": "or something out there but they're all", "TyB7_LASMyo-01310-00277686-00277896": "research based essentially big bucket", "TyB7_LASMyo-01311-00277897-00278103": "that we as districts have to work on but", "TyB7_LASMyo-01312-00278104-00278250": "what you'll notice around the outside is", "TyB7_LASMyo-01313-00278251-00278499": "collaborative leadership you see in", "TyB7_LASMyo-01314-00278500-00278735": "schools without dynamic leadership", "TyB7_LASMyo-01315-00278736-00279216": "without a school culture that's that as", "TyB7_LASMyo-01316-00279217-00279387": "empowering or engaging or innovative", "TyB7_LASMyo-01317-00279388-00279620": "like this stuff doesn't happen let me", "TyB7_LASMyo-01318-00279621-00279891": "put it this way in a toxic school", "TyB7_LASMyo-01319-00279892-00280031": "environment you're not going to get", "TyB7_LASMyo-01320-00280032-00280205": "innovative things happening it's not", "TyB7_LASMyo-01321-00280206-00280278": "going to happen", "TyB7_LASMyo-01322-00280279-00280503": "teachers need that ability to take risks", "TyB7_LASMyo-01323-00280504-00280677": "teachers need that ability to try", "TyB7_LASMyo-01324-00280678-00280835": "something it doesn't go as well it tried", "TyB7_LASMyo-01325-00280836-00280920": "a little bit differently", "TyB7_LASMyo-01326-00280921-00281232": "go ahead and Mitch next next slide", "TyB7_LASMyo-01327-00281233-00281457": "let me share a couple resources that we", "TyB7_LASMyo-01328-00281458-00281589": "start to wind down here and I started to", "TyB7_LASMyo-01329-00281590-00281733": "want to be respectful of everybody's", "TyB7_LASMyo-01330-00281734-00281781": "time", "TyB7_LASMyo-01331-00281782-00281952": "so the Futurity dashboard is the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01332-00281953-00282093": "resource that you're looking at their", "TyB7_LASMyo-01333-00282094-00282387": "dashboard Futurity schools org it is", "TyB7_LASMyo-01334-00282388-00282606": "linked off of the two resources that I", "TyB7_LASMyo-01335-00282607-00282879": "shared earlier next slide this is a tool", "TyB7_LASMyo-01336-00282880-00283151": "that we created it is research-based", "TyB7_LASMyo-01337-00283152-00283356": "districts own their own data", "TyB7_LASMyo-01338-00283357-00283539": "go ahead lots of information about the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01339-00283540-00283863": "framework we have in there over 500 free", "TyB7_LASMyo-01340-00283864-00284181": "resources mich next slide over 500 free", "TyB7_LASMyo-01341-00284182-00284430": "resources from if you take a look some", "TyB7_LASMyo-01342-00284431-00284559": "examples there all of your", "TyB7_LASMyo-01343-00284560-00284753": "organization's it's the alphabet soup", "TyB7_LASMyo-01344-00284754-00285117": "Asin ESP and the SSP ISTE we pull all", "TyB7_LASMyo-01345-00285118-00285288": "those resources together all the free", "TyB7_LASMyo-01346-00285289-00285537": "runs the free ones that tie from the PD", "TyB7_LASMyo-01347-00285538-00285735": "framework and we put them in there for", "TyB7_LASMyo-01348-00285736-00285999": "you for free and so when you look at the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01349-00286000-00286170": "different areas dashboard Futurity", "TyB7_LASMyo-01350-00286171-00286365": "schools that org look at the resources", "TyB7_LASMyo-01351-00286366-00286548": "you'll see featured resources that's", "TyB7_LASMyo-01352-00286549-00286731": "quick screenshot of it but if you scroll", "TyB7_LASMyo-01353-00286732-00287016": "underneath you'll actually then see some", "TyB7_LASMyo-01354-00287017-00287190": "additional resources where you can sort", "TyB7_LASMyo-01355-00287191-00287415": "show-me case studies show me research", "TyB7_LASMyo-01356-00287416-00287535": "show me online tools", "TyB7_LASMyo-01357-00287536-00287745": "show me webinars that kind of stuff all", "TyB7_LASMyo-01358-00287746-00287910": "totally free to help support you in this", "TyB7_LASMyo-01359-00287911-00288204": "work next slide sorry guys it's really", "TyB7_LASMyo-01360-00288205-00288423": "losing my voice we also have a five-step", "TyB7_LASMyo-01361-00288424-00288705": "process to help districts go through the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01362-00288706-00288921": "Futurity dashboard over winter break I", "TyB7_LASMyo-01363-00288922-00289206": "actually created video tutorials through", "TyB7_LASMyo-01364-00289207-00289419": "YouTube a YouTube playlist to walk", "TyB7_LASMyo-01365-00289420-00289659": "districts through step by step by step", "TyB7_LASMyo-01366-00289660-00289887": "how to do this from forming a leadership", "TyB7_LASMyo-01367-00289888-00290067": "team in their district to taking this", "TyB7_LASMyo-01368-00290068-00290238": "assessment that I'll share just a moment", "TyB7_LASMyo-01369-00290239-00290424": "so then how do we get some other", "TyB7_LASMyo-01370-00290425-00290622": "stakeholder input and how do we create a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01371-00290623-00291086": "plan for transformation next slide", "TyB7_LASMyo-01372-00291087-00291341": "so taking a look that's just a quick", "TyB7_LASMyo-01373-00291342-00291488": "example the district assessment that's", "TyB7_LASMyo-01374-00291489-00291650": "there that's a screenshot of it by the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01375-00291651-00291815": "way there's been a thousand school", "TyB7_LASMyo-01376-00291816-00292046": "district teams roughly nationwide that", "TyB7_LASMyo-01377-00292047-00292208": "have used what I'm talking about that", "TyB7_LASMyo-01378-00292209-00292382": "was in different district teams so this", "TyB7_LASMyo-01379-00292383-00292559": "isn't some like fly-by-night type of", "TyB7_LASMyo-01380-00292560-00292667": "thing that's gone tomorrow", "TyB7_LASMyo-01381-00292668-00293147": "thousand district teams go ahead match", "TyB7_LASMyo-01382-00293148-00293429": "see in there you get a variety of scores", "TyB7_LASMyo-01383-00293430-00293666": "for all the different framework areas so", "TyB7_LASMyo-01384-00293667-00293843": "each of the different gear areas gets a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01385-00293844-00294005": "set of scores each of the different", "TyB7_LASMyo-01386-00294006-00294206": "elements also gets a set of scores go", "TyB7_LASMyo-01387-00294207-00294588": "ahead and X lime inch", "TyB7_LASMyo-01388-00294589-00294693": "those are some of the different examples", "TyB7_LASMyo-01389-00294694-00294858": "for elements it helps districts keep", "TyB7_LASMyo-01390-00294859-00295113": "going it gets very very specific and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01391-00295114-00295236": "it's hard to show you in a quick webinar", "TyB7_LASMyo-01392-00295237-00295383": "in quick screenshots like this but as", "TyB7_LASMyo-01393-00295384-00295566": "you drill down see for instance what", "TyB7_LASMyo-01394-00295567-00295713": "you're seeing is a screenshot there of", "TyB7_LASMyo-01395-00295714-00296046": "every single element area every single", "TyB7_LASMyo-01396-00296047-00296316": "every gear area every element area then", "TyB7_LASMyo-01397-00296317-00296577": "actually has specific gaps and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01398-00296578-00296841": "strategies customized from your district", "TyB7_LASMyo-01399-00296842-00297024": "what we did is we worked with about 40", "TyB7_LASMyo-01400-00297025-00297318": "practitioners nationwide that for a few", "TyB7_LASMyo-01401-00297319-00297579": "months that this district saw what are", "TyB7_LASMyo-01402-00297580-00297812": "the shoes you would do as a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01403-00297813-00298065": "superintendent is a tech director what", "TyB7_LASMyo-01404-00298066-00298293": "are the strategies that you would use to", "TyB7_LASMyo-01405-00298294-00298581": "close those gaps so districts get scores", "TyB7_LASMyo-01406-00298582-00298893": "gaps strategies all for free all", "TyB7_LASMyo-01407-00298894-00299220": "customized totally for them no cost and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01408-00299221-00299364": "they own their own data", "TyB7_LASMyo-01409-00299365-00299535": "check out the privacy policy it's really", "TyB7_LASMyo-01410-00299536-00299643": "important districts on their own data", "TyB7_LASMyo-01411-00299644-00299850": "with all of this as well you can see", "TyB7_LASMyo-01412-00299851-00299997": "that you can also get other stakeholder", "TyB7_LASMyo-01413-00299998-00300177": "input when you look at the stakeholder", "TyB7_LASMyo-01414-00300178-00300321": "input you know we could survey our", "TyB7_LASMyo-01415-00300322-00300495": "teachers we can survey our admin those", "TyB7_LASMyo-01416-00300496-00300648": "kinds of things to get although user", "TyB7_LASMyo-01417-00300649-00300991": "feedback go ahead Mitch", "TyB7_LASMyo-01418-00300992-00301350": "excitement right keep going", "TyB7_LASMyo-01419-00301351-00301535": "the other piece to that I encourage you", "TyB7_LASMyo-01420-00301536-00301752": "to check out on future-ready org is our", "TyB7_LASMyo-01421-00301753-00302013": "leadership hub ongoing webinars and all", "TyB7_LASMyo-01422-00302014-00302199": "totally free for district leaders to", "TyB7_LASMyo-01423-00302200-00302406": "keep them connected to get showcase", "TyB7_LASMyo-01424-00302407-00302631": "districts great work districts are doing", "TyB7_LASMyo-01425-00302632-00302805": "here's the bottom line with all of that", "TyB7_LASMyo-01426-00302806-00303030": "number one does to sum it up future", "TyB7_LASMyo-01427-00303031-00303201": "Eddie's totally free there's no sales", "TyB7_LASMyo-01428-00303202-00303498": "pitch with it at all number two the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01429-00303499-00303731": "resources and the tools can help and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01430-00303732-00303906": "support your district moving forward", "TyB7_LASMyo-01431-00303907-00304181": "from implementation number three our", "TyB7_LASMyo-01432-00304182-00304374": "coalition partners that you've all heard", "TyB7_LASMyo-01433-00304375-00304566": "of all across the board their tools", "TyB7_LASMyo-01434-00304567-00304832": "there are resources under one spot under", "TyB7_LASMyo-01435-00304833-00304956": "one umbrella to help you move forward", "TyB7_LASMyo-01436-00304957-00305166": "with this I will tell you that we are", "TyB7_LASMyo-01437-00305167-00305367": "going to launch phase three of future", "TyB7_LASMyo-01438-00305368-00305531": "ready in the next couple of weeks we", "TyB7_LASMyo-01439-00305532-00305718": "will be doing a lot more locations in", "TyB7_LASMyo-01440-00305719-00305817": "2017", "TyB7_LASMyo-01441-00305818-00305981": "can also give you a sneak peek we're", "TyB7_LASMyo-01442-00305982-00306198": "also going to have a strand launched our", "TyB7_LASMyo-01443-00306199-00306444": "strand for librarians back in st this", "TyB7_LASMyo-01444-00306445-00306720": "past years of its Facebook group that in", "TyB7_LASMyo-01445-00306721-00306921": "the past we can have half about almost a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01446-00306922-00307143": "thousand librarians join we're almost up", "TyB7_LASMyo-01447-00307144-00307320": "to two thousand in the first couple of", "TyB7_LASMyo-01448-00307321-00307581": "weeks of people that are communicating", "TyB7_LASMyo-01449-00307582-00307770": "and connecting we're gonna be launching", "TyB7_LASMyo-01450-00307771-00307979": "a Futurity principal strand and we have", "TyB7_LASMyo-01451-00307980-00308243": "constantly in strands for principals", "TyB7_LASMyo-01452-00308244-00308558": "that one of our tech oriented one that's", "TyB7_LASMyo-01453-00308559-00308730": "more for instructional coaches or lead", "TyB7_LASMyo-01454-00308731-00308892": "teachers and then one for", "TyB7_LASMyo-01455-00308893-00308973": "superintendents assistant", "TyB7_LASMyo-01456-00308974-00309153": "superintendents kind of high-level admin", "TyB7_LASMyo-01457-00309154-00309387": "that's all coming this year in the next", "TyB7_LASMyo-01458-00309388-00309557": "few weeks you'll be seeing some things", "TyB7_LASMyo-01459-00309558-00309690": "put out on that keep checking back at", "TyB7_LASMyo-01460-00309691-00309837": "the website I do want to give a shout", "TyB7_LASMyo-01461-00309838-00310050": "out to fvtc I know for me personally", "TyB7_LASMyo-01462-00310051-00310563": "I'll be at Fe T C McCall ice QTc EA m e", "TyB7_LASMyo-01463-00310564-00310880": "CA n ETA where we also a lot of these", "TyB7_LASMyo-01464-00310881-00311070": "places whether it's myself or other", "TyB7_LASMyo-01465-00311071-00311271": "people are doing a variety of strands", "TyB7_LASMyo-01466-00311272-00311534": "and so at fvtc in particular we have a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01467-00311535-00311724": "full strand of Futurity sessions we", "TyB7_LASMyo-01468-00311725-00311898": "encourage you to check them out around", "TyB7_LASMyo-01469-00311899-00312090": "these different gear areas it's not all", "TyB7_LASMyo-01470-00312091-00312284": "about future ready it's all about", "TyB7_LASMyo-01471-00312285-00312516": "different gear areas what districts are", "TyB7_LASMyo-01472-00312517-00312669": "doing to really implement that I", "TyB7_LASMyo-01473-00312670-00312825": "encourage you to check out those two", "TyB7_LASMyo-01474-00312826-00312996": "areas there's my personal contact stuff", "TyB7_LASMyo-01475-00312997-00313194": "online I apologize for going a few", "TyB7_LASMyo-01476-00313195-00313302": "minutes over and starting to lose my", "TyB7_LASMyo-01477-00313303-00313532": "voice the end and I hope that was", "TyB7_LASMyo-01478-00313533-00313749": "helpful but again there's no sales pitch", "TyB7_LASMyo-01479-00313750-00313914": "there's really nothing here that's left", "TyB7_LASMyo-01480-00313915-00314151": "to lose it all so thanks for investing", "TyB7_LASMyo-01481-00314152-00314377": "this time thanks for your late at night", "TyB7_LASMyo-01482-00314378-00314638": "so how does it feel to know that you've", "TyB7_LASMyo-01483-00314639-00314906": "affected a thousand districts", "TyB7_LASMyo-01484-00314907-00315041": "and all the kids that are associated", "TyB7_LASMyo-01485-00315042-00315310": "with those districts so I", "TyB7_LASMyo-01486-00315311-00315517": "so my first thing would say it's not me", "TyB7_LASMyo-01487-00315518-00315751": "it's not about me I am very blessed to", "TyB7_LASMyo-01488-00315752-00316027": "help head up some of this but the impact", "TyB7_LASMyo-01489-00316028-00316249": "and the effect is that's from", "TyB7_LASMyo-01490-00316250-00316420": "organizations across the board that's", "TyB7_LASMyo-01491-00316421-00316609": "thousands of people working to culminate", "TyB7_LASMyo-01492-00316610-00316822": "that work that's from even the president", "TyB7_LASMyo-01493-00316823-00316939": "kicking it off himself", "TyB7_LASMyo-01494-00316940-00317142": "it's a thousands of districts nationwide", "TyB7_LASMyo-01495-00317143-00317371": "doing incredible incredible stuff", "TyB7_LASMyo-01496-00317372-00317590": "working their tails off every day for", "TyB7_LASMyo-01497-00317591-00317806": "kids those are the people that really", "TyB7_LASMyo-01498-00317807-00317953": "should feel thing we're moving the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01499-00317954-00318127": "needle hey to help create something like", "TyB7_LASMyo-01500-00318128-00318406": "this sure it I enjoy it I feel like", "TyB7_LASMyo-01501-00318407-00318565": "that's that's my way you know I'm it for", "TyB7_LASMyo-01502-00318566-00318736": "me it's hard for me to not be at a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01503-00318737-00318967": "school anymore it's hard for me to not", "TyB7_LASMyo-01504-00318968-00319132": "walk down in my kindergarten class and", "TyB7_LASMyo-01505-00319133-00319336": "hang out with five-year-olds so for my", "TyB7_LASMyo-01506-00319337-00319537": "personal gratis faction I get to feel", "TyB7_LASMyo-01507-00319538-00319807": "like I'm impacting other districts other", "TyB7_LASMyo-01508-00319808-00319972": "places other areas by supporting them", "TyB7_LASMyo-01509-00319973-00320167": "but I miss being with five year old six", "TyB7_LASMyo-01510-00320168-00320266": "year old seven year olds you know I'm", "TyB7_LASMyo-01511-00320267-00320455": "doing that so sure it's a great feeling", "TyB7_LASMyo-01512-00320456-00320602": "but I certainly don't want to take any", "TyB7_LASMyo-01513-00320603-00320773": "credit personally credit goes to the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01514-00320774-00320983": "thousands of people nationwide that have", "TyB7_LASMyo-01515-00320984-00321166": "made all that all the things across the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01516-00321167-00321316": "board possible and I don't say that", "TyB7_LASMyo-01517-00321317-00321622": "lightly I mean that well good well I", "TyB7_LASMyo-01518-00321623-00321913": "hope you continue to have a huge impact", "TyB7_LASMyo-01519-00321914-00322198": "in 2017 and I'll see you down in Florida", "TyB7_LASMyo-01520-00322199-00322485": "in a couple weeks", "TyB7_LASMyo-01521-00322486-00322720": "all right thanks Mitch thanks everybody", "TyB7_LASMyo-01522-00322721-00322864": "thanks for investing the time hopefully", "TyB7_LASMyo-01523-00322865-00323032": "that was helpful you got something out", "TyB7_LASMyo-01524-00323033-00323179": "of it so thank you Mitch thanks for the", "TyB7_LASMyo-01525-00323180-00323572": "opportunity okay and thank you for me", "TyB7_LASMyo-01526-00323573-00323815": "this is Mitch Berg I'm signing off for a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01527-00323816-00324070": "chat interactive and hope to see a", "TyB7_LASMyo-01528-00324071-00324313": "number of you tomorrow night and down an", "TyB7_LASMyo-01529-00324314-00324493": "Fe TC in about a week and a half", "TyB7_LASMyo-01530-00324494-00324727": "take care", "TyB7_LASMyo-01531-00324728-00325341": "you", "TyB7_LASMyo-01532-00325342-00325548": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "TyaQZLQJpZo", "text": {"TyaQZLQJpZo-00000-00000096-00000396": "biological integrity as associated with", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00001-00000397-00000808": "how pristine an environment as in its", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00002-00000809-00001057": "function relative to the potential or", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00003-00001058-00001344": "original state of an ecosystem before", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00004-00001345-00001677": "human alterations were imposed", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00005-00001678-00001954": "biological integrity is built on the", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00006-00001955-00002209": "assumption that a decline in the values", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00007-00002210-00002497": "of an ecosystems functions are primarily", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00008-00002498-00002818": "caused by human activity or alterations", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00009-00002819-00003170": "the more an environment and its original", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00010-00003171-00003402": "processes are altered the less", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00011-00003403-00003675": "biological integrity it holds for the", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00012-00003676-00003813": "community as a whole", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00013-00003814-00004186": "if these processes were to change over", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00014-00004187-00004470": "time naturally without human influence", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00015-00004471-00004738": "the integrity of the ecosystem would", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00016-00004739-00005077": "remain intact the integrity of the", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00017-00005078-00005322": "ecosystem relies heavily on the", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00018-00005323-00005571": "processes that occur within it because", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00019-00005572-00005805": "those determine what organisms can", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00020-00005806-00006066": "inhabit an area and the complexities of", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00021-00006067-00006744": "their interactions", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00022-00006745-00007296": "topic history", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00023-00007297-00007584": "the concept of biological integrity", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00024-00007586-00007984": "first appeared in the 1972 amendments to", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00025-00007984-00008214": "the u.s. federal Water Pollution Control", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00026-00008215-00008577": "Act also known as the Clean Water Act", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00027-00008578-00008830": "the United States Environmental", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00028-00008831-00009241": "Protection Agency EPA had used the term", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00029-00009242-00009484": "as a way to gauge the standards to which", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00030-00009485-00009727": "water should be maintained but the", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00031-00009728-00010017": "vocabulary instigated years of debate", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00032-00010018-00010270": "about the implications of not only the", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00033-00010271-00010549": "meaning of biological integrity but also", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00034-00010550-00010855": "how it can be measured the first", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00035-00010856-00011088": "conference about the term occurred in", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00036-00011089-00011556": "March 1975 called the integrity of water", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00037-00011557-00011851": "and provided the first accepted", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00038-00011852-00012163": "definition of biological integrity see", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00039-00012164-00012708": "below in 1981 EPA assembled a field of", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00040-00012709-00012991": "experts from the US Fish and Wildlife", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00041-00012991-00013308": "Service academia and its own staff to", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00042-00013309-00013519": "further refine the definition and", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00043-00013519-00013731": "identify key indicators to", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00044-00013732-00013975": "quantitatively measure biological", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00045-00013976-00014311": "integrity the conference not only", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00046-00014312-00014599": "identified a definition but also methods", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00047-00014600-00014850": "to evaluate the community and they", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00048-00014851-00015100": "established that multiple sites should", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00049-00015101-00015325": "be used to determine the condition of", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00050-00015326-00015869": "the environment", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00051-00015870-00016430": "topic definition", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00052-00016431-00016805": "today the accepted definition us the", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00053-00016806-00017117": "capability of supporting and maintaining", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00054-00017118-00017469": "a balanced integrated adaptive community", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00055-00017470-00017724": "of organisms having a species", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00056-00017725-00018058": "composition diversity and functional", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00057-00018059-00018324": "organization comparable to that of the", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00058-00018325-00018702": "natural habitat of the region this", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00059-00018703-00019136": "definition was adapted from Frey 1977", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00060-00019137-00019452": "the implications of this definition are", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00061-00019453-00019700": "that living systems have a variety of", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00062-00019701-00020000": "scales relative to which they exist that", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00063-00020001-00020267": "one can quantify the parts that sustain", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00064-00020268-00020534": "or contribute to a systems functioning", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00065-00020535-00020792": "and that all systems must be seen in the", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00066-00020793-00021005": "context of their environments and", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00067-00021006-00021399": "evolutionary history this term primarily", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00068-00021400-00021696": "refers to aquatic environment because", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00069-00021697-00021975": "the vocabulary is derived from the Clean", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00070-00021976-00022208": "Water Act but the concepts can be", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00071-00022209-00022965": "applied to other ecosystems", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00072-00022966-00023624": "topic evaluation methods", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00073-00023625-00023942": "in order to quantify and evaluate the", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00074-00023943-00024227": "biological integrity of a system the", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00075-00024228-00024605": "index of biological integrity ibi was", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00076-00024606-00024970": "created in this index the baseline", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00077-00024971-00025262": "biological integrity its function before", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00078-00025263-00025484": "human influence and the current", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00079-00025485-00025736": "functions of an eco system are measured", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00080-00025737-00025991": "against one another to evaluate how much", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00081-00025992-00026252": "of ecosystems function has been", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00082-00026252-00026677": "preserved the ibi evaluates the eco", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00083-00026679-00026977": "system by utilizing bio surveys and", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00084-00026979-00027260": "comparing species richness indicator", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00085-00027261-00027739": "taxa hybrids and invasive species Ibis", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00086-00027741-00028045": "are used primarily to evaluate aquatic", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00087-00028047-00028268": "ecosystems even though one could", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00088-00028269-00028502": "technically apply any measurement of", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00089-00028502-00028792": "biological integrity to any natural", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00090-00028793-00029070": "ecosystem", "TyaQZLQJpZo-00091-00029071-00029502": "equals equals see also"}}, {"audio_id": "TycCMMKtpSg", "text": {"TycCMMKtpSg-00000-00000000-00000311": "I don't get it how can you be talking to", "TycCMMKtpSg-00001-00000312-00000833": "us if he took your soul not mine", "TycCMMKtpSg-00002-00000834-00001129": "it's all my fault", "TycCMMKtpSg-00003-00001130-00001523": "come back", "TycCMMKtpSg-00004-00001524-00001813": "it should have been me not him", "TycCMMKtpSg-00005-00001814-00002185": "it's not fair"}}, {"audio_id": "Tzv3ZtcxJPY", "text": {"Tzv3ZtcxJPY-00000-00000051-00000374": "in mathematical physics space times", "Tzv3ZtcxJPY-00001-00000375-00000590": "are Lorentzian manifolds admitting a", "Tzv3ZtcxJPY-00002-00000591-00000817": "geodesic null congruence with vanishing", "Tzv3ZtcxJPY-00003-00000818-00001127": "optical scalars expansion twists and", "Tzv3ZtcxJPY-00004-00001128-00001432": "shear a well-known member of class", "Tzv3ZtcxJPY-00005-00001433-00001576": "as PP wave", "Tzv3ZtcxJPY-00006-00001577-00001864": "Richey flat pace x in arbitrary", "Tzv3ZtcxJPY-00007-00001866-00002120": "dimension are algebraically special in", "Tzv3ZtcxJPY-00008-00002121-00002423": "four dimensions Richey flat metrics", "Tzv3ZtcxJPY-00009-00002424-00002683": "of petra of type 3 and n are completely", "Tzv3ZtcxJPY-00010-00002684-00003113": "known all vsi space x belong to a subset", "Tzv3ZtcxJPY-00011-00003114-00003443": "of the constants"}}, {"audio_id": "TzM0ccz-1kQ", "text": {"TzM0ccz-1kQ-00000-00000053-00000312": "The Odyssey Greek Odyssey a disea", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00001-00000313-00000763": "pronounced ody with acute SS ejj in", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00002-00000764-00000961": "classical attic is one of two major", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00003-00000961-00001186": "ancient Greek epic poems attributed to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00004-00001187-00001470": "Homer it is in part a sequel to the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00005-00001471-00001664": "Iliad the other work ascribed to Homer", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00006-00001666-00001951": "the Odyssey is fundamental to the modern", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00007-00001952-00002155": "Western Canon it is the second oldest", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00008-00002156-00002359": "extant work of Western literature while", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00009-00002360-00002638": "the Iliad is the oldest scholars believe", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00010-00002639-00002835": "the Odyssey was composed near the end of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00011-00002836-00003079": "the eighth century BC somewhere in Ionia", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00012-00003080-00003328": "the Greek coastal region of Anatolia the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00013-00003329-00003531": "poem mainly focuses on the Greek hero", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00014-00003532-00003786": "Odysseus known as Ulysses in Roman myths", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00015-00003788-00003979": "king of Ithaca and his journey home", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00016-00003979-00004279": "after the fall of Troy it takes Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00017-00004280-00004459": "10 years to reach Ithaca after the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00018-00004460-00004783": "ten-year Trojan War in his absence it is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00019-00004784-00005004": "assumed Odysseus has died and his wife", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00020-00005005-00005229": "Penelope and son Telemachus must deal", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00021-00005230-00005434": "with a group of unruly suitors the misc", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00022-00005435-00005683": "tears Greek Mis tears are Pro Chi who", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00023-00005684-00005886": "compete for Penelope's hand in marriage", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00024-00005887-00006154": "the Odyssey continues to be read in the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00025-00006155-00006363": "Homeric Greek and translated into modern", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00026-00006364-00006667": "languages around the world many scholars", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00027-00006668-00006867": "believe the original poem was composed", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00028-00006868-00007170": "in an oral tradition by an AO idos epic", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00029-00007172-00007353": "poet singer perhaps a rap Zoet", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00030-00007354-00007539": "professional performer and was more", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00031-00007540-00007708": "likely intended to be heard than read", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00032-00007709-00007951": "the details of the ancient oral", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00033-00007952-00008139": "performance and the stories conversion", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00034-00008140-00008335": "to a written work inspire continual", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00035-00008336-00008610": "debate among scholars The Odyssey was", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00036-00008611-00008827": "written in a poetic dialect of Greek a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00037-00008828-00009178": "literary amalgam of aeo LIC Greek ionic", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00038-00009179-00009370": "Greek and other ancient Greek dialects", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00039-00009371-00009601": "and comprises twelve thousand one", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00040-00009602-00009824": "hundred ten lines of dactylic hexameter", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00041-00009825-00010071": "among the most noteworthy elements of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00042-00010072-00010276": "the text are its nonlinear plot and the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00043-00010277-00010464": "influence on events of choices made by", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00044-00010465-00010585": "women and slaves", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00045-00010586-00010774": "besides the actions of fighting men in", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00046-00010775-00011017": "the English language as well as many", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00047-00011018-00011209": "others the word Odyssey has come to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00048-00011210-00011521": "refer to an epic voyage the Odyssey has", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00049-00011522-00011737": "a Lost sequel the telegin II which was", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00050-00011738-00011998": "not written by Homer it was usually", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00051-00011999-00012223": "attributed in antiquity to sinneth on of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00052-00012224-00012481": "Sparta in one source the telegin II was", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00053-00012482-00012670": "said to have been stolen from musaeus of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00054-00012671-00012871": "Athens by either Yuga man or you gamin", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00055-00012872-00013363": "of Cyrene II C cyclic poets", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00056-00013365-00013882": "topic synopsis", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00057-00013883-00014375": "topic exposition", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00058-00014376-00014608": "The Odyssey begins after the end of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00059-00014609-00014819": "ten-year Trojan War the subject of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00060-00014819-00014993": "Iliad and Odysseus has still not", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00061-00014994-00015163": "returned home from the war because he", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00062-00015165-00015449": "angered the god Poseidon Odysseus son", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00063-00015450-00015668": "Telemachus as about twenty years old and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00064-00015669-00015866": "is sharing his absent father's house on", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00065-00015866-00016013": "the island of Ithaca with his mother", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00066-00016013-00016286": "Penelope and a crowd of 108 boisterous", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00067-00016287-00016558": "young men the suitors whose aim is to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00068-00016559-00016757": "persuade Penelope to marry one of them", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00069-00016758-00016933": "all the while reveling in Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00070-00016934-00017122": "palace and eating up his wealth", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00071-00017123-00017389": "Odysseus protectress the goddess Athena", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00072-00017390-00017666": "requests to Zeus king of the gods to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00073-00017667-00017869": "finally allow Odysseus to return home", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00074-00017870-00018074": "when Odysseus enemy the god of the sea", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00075-00018075-00018299": "Poseidon is absent from Mount Olympus to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00076-00018300-00018580": "accept a sacrifice in Ethiopia then", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00077-00018581-00018791": "disguised as at apheon chieftain named", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00078-00018792-00019019": "mentes she visits Telemachus to urge him", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00079-00019020-00019261": "to search for news of his father he", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00080-00019262-00019466": "offers her hospitality they observed the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00081-00019467-00019649": "suitors dining roundly while the bard", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00082-00019650-00019850": "fee meais performs a narrative poem for", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00083-00019851-00020125": "them penelope objects to femi assist", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00084-00020126-00020428": "theme the return from Troy because it", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00085-00020429-00020615": "reminds her of her missing husband but", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00086-00020616-00020786": "Telemachus rebuts her objections", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00087-00020787-00020947": "asserting his role as head of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00088-00020948-00021265": "household that night Athena disguised as", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00089-00021266-00021481": "Telemachus finds a ship and crew for the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00090-00021482-00021755": "true Prince the next morning Telemachus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00091-00021756-00021974": "calls an assembly of citizens of Ithaca", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00092-00021975-00022139": "to discuss what should be done with the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00093-00022140-00022403": "suitors Telemachus is scoffed by the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00094-00022404-00022615": "insolent suitors particularly by their", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00095-00022616-00022850": "leaders Antinous your amicus and leah", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00096-00022851-00023131": "curtis accompanied by Athena now", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00097-00023132-00023342": "disguised as mentor he departs for the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00098-00023343-00023519": "Greek mainland and the household of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00099-00023520-00023711": "nestor most venerable of the Greek", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00100-00023712-00023939": "warriors at Troy who resided in pylos", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00101-00023940-00024172": "after the war from there", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00102-00024173-00024397": "Telemachus rides overland the company by", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00103-00024398-00024622": "Nestor's son paisa Stratos to Sparta", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00104-00024623-00024827": "where he finds Menelaus and Helen who", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00105-00024828-00025090": "are now reconciled while helen laments", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00106-00025091-00025261": "the fit of lest brought on by Aphrodite", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00107-00025262-00025462": "that sent her to Troy with Paris", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00108-00025463-00025661": "Menelaus recounts how she betrayed the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00109-00025662-00025825": "Greeks by attempting to imitate the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00110-00025826-00026006": "voices of the soldiers wives while they", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00111-00026007-00026176": "were inside the Trojan horse", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00112-00026177-00026456": "Telemachus also hears from Helen who is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00113-00026457-00026633": "the first to recognize him that she", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00114-00026633-00026804": "pities him because Odysseus was not", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00115-00026805-00026968": "there for him in his childhood because", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00116-00026969-00027139": "he went to Troy to fight for her and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00117-00027141-00027332": "also about his exploit of stealing the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00118-00027333-00027533": "Palladium or the luck of Troy where she", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00119-00027533-00027727": "was the only one to recognize him", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00120-00027729-00028027": "menelaus meanwhile also praises Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00121-00028029-00028202": "as an approachable comrade and friend", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00122-00028202-00028388": "lamenting the fact that they were not", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00123-00028389-00028616": "only unable to return together from Troy", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00124-00028617-00028907": "but that Odysseus is yet to return both", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00125-00028908-00029120": "Helen and Menelaus also say that they", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00126-00029120-00029302": "returned to Sparta after a long voyage", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00127-00029304-00029597": "by way of Egypt there on the island of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00128-00029598-00029827": "Pharos Menelaus encountered the old sea", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00129-00029829-00030026": "god Proteus who told him that Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00130-00030027-00030274": "was a captive of the nymph Calypso", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00131-00030275-00030518": "incidentally Telemachus learns the fate", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00132-00030519-00030749": "of Menelaus brother Agamemnon king of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00133-00030750-00030956": "Mycenae and leader of the Greeks at Troy", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00134-00030957-00031151": "he was murdered on his return home by", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00135-00031152-00031333": "his wife Clytemnestra and her lover", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00136-00031335-00031633": "aegisthus the story briefly shifts to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00137-00031635-00031793": "the suitors who have only just now", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00138-00031794-00032087": "realized that Telemachus is gone angry", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00139-00032088-00032302": "they formulate a plan to ambush his ship", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00140-00032304-00032506": "and kill him as he sails back home", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00141-00032507-00032732": "penelope overhears their plot and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00142-00032733-00033157": "worries for her son's safety", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00143-00033158-00033709": "topic escaped to the fee Asians", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00144-00033710-00033943": "the second part recounts the story of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00145-00033944-00034168": "Odysseus in the course of his seven", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00146-00034169-00034375": "years in captivity on okay gia the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00147-00034376-00034597": "island of Calypso she has fallen deeply", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00148-00034598-00034759": "in love with him even though he has", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00149-00034760-00034915": "consistently spurned her offer of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00150-00034916-00035101": "immortality as her husband and still", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00151-00035102-00035323": "mourns for home she is ordered to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00152-00035324-00035515": "release him by the messenger god Hermes", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00153-00035516-00035758": "who has been sent by Zeus in response to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00154-00035759-00036073": "Athena's plea Odysseus builds a raft and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00155-00036074-00036268": "is given clothing food and drink by", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00156-00036269-00036532": "Calypso when Poseidon learns that", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00157-00036533-00036742": "Odysseus has escaped he wrecks the raft", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00158-00036743-00036946": "but helped by a veil given by the sea", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00159-00036947-00037153": "nymph ino odysseus swims ashore on", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00160-00037154-00037365": "cherie the island of the fie a shion's", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00161-00037366-00037642": "naked and exhausted he hides in a pile", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00162-00037643-00037909": "of leaves and falls asleep the next", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00163-00037910-00038080": "morning awakened by the laughter of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00164-00038081-00038296": "girls he sees the young Nausicaa who has", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00165-00038297-00038461": "gone to the seashore with her maids to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00166-00038462-00038662": "wash clothes after Athena told her in a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00167-00038663-00038929": "dream to do so he appeals to her for", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00168-00038930-00039142": "help she encourages him to seek the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00169-00039143-00039355": "hospitality of her parents a reed and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00170-00039356-00039637": "Alcinous or Alchemist Odysseus is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00171-00039638-00039832": "welcomed and is not at first asked for", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00172-00039833-00040012": "his name but Alcinous promises to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00173-00040013-00040186": "provide him a ship to return him to his", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00174-00040187-00040459": "home country he remains for several days", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00175-00040460-00040666": "and is goaded into taking part in a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00176-00040667-00040861": "discus throw by the taunts of Euryalus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00177-00040862-00041023": "impressing the fie a shion's with his", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00178-00041024-00041308": "incredible athletic ability afterwards", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00179-00041309-00041491": "he hears the blind singer Demodocus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00180-00041492-00041785": "performed two narrative poems the first", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00181-00041786-00041980": "is an otherwise obscure incident of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00182-00041981-00042262": "Trojan War the quarrel of Odysseus and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00183-00042263-00042541": "Achilles the second is the amusing tale", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00184-00042542-00042742": "of a love affair between two Olympian", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00185-00042743-00043105": "gods Ares and Aphrodite finally Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00186-00043106-00043327": "asks Demodocus to return to the Trojan", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00187-00043328-00043531": "War theme and tell of the Trojan horse a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00188-00043532-00043747": "stratagem in which Odysseus had played a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00189-00043748-00044041": "leading role unable to hide his emotion", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00190-00044042-00044191": "as he relives this episode", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00191-00044192-00044503": "Odysseus at last reveals his identity he", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00192-00044504-00044668": "then begins to tell the story of his", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00193-00044669-00045118": "return from Troy", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00194-00045119-00045742": "topic Odysseus account of his adventures", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00195-00045743-00046021": "Odysseus goes back in time and recounts", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00196-00046022-00046264": "his story to the FIH Asians after a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00197-00046265-00046480": "failed piratical raid on his murrow's in", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00198-00046481-00046690": "the land of the chicken A's Odysseus and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00199-00046691-00046870": "his twelve ships were driven off course", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00200-00046871-00046957": "by storms", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00201-00046958-00047236": "Odysseus visited the lethargic Lotus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00202-00047237-00047421": "Eaters who gave his men their fruit that", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00203-00047422-00047557": "would have caused them to forget their", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00204-00047558-00047758": "homecoming had Odysseus not dragged them", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00205-00047759-00047921": "back to the ship by force", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00206-00047922-00048205": "afterwards Odysseus and his men landed", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00207-00048206-00048390": "on the lush uninhabited island near the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00208-00048391-00048687": "land of the Cyclopes the men then landed", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00209-00048688-00048840": "on shore and entered the cave of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00210-00048841-00049009": "Polyphemus where they found all the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00211-00049010-00049258": "cheese's and meat they desired upon", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00212-00049259-00049459": "returning home Polyphemus sealed the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00213-00049460-00049621": "entrance with a massive Boulder and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00214-00049622-00049792": "proceeded to eat Odysseus men", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00215-00049793-00050086": "Odysseus devised an escape plan in which", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00216-00050087-00050425": "he identifying himself as nobody plied", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00217-00050426-00050629": "Polyphemus with wine and blinded him", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00218-00050630-00050854": "with a wooden stake when Polyphemus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00219-00050855-00051031": "cried out his neighbors left after", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00220-00051032-00051321": "Polyphemus claimed that nobody had", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00221-00051322-00051504": "attacked him Odysseus and his men", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00222-00051505-00051717": "finally left the cave by hiding on the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00223-00051719-00051870": "under bellies of the Sheep as they were", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00224-00051871-00052077": "let out of the cave while they were", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00225-00052078-00052144": "escaping", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00226-00052145-00052365": "however Odysseus foolishly taunted", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00227-00052366-00052516": "Polyphemus and revealed his true", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00228-00052516-00052779": "identity recalling that had been", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00229-00052780-00052963": "prophesied by appeals to his father", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00230-00052964-00053232": "Poseidon Poseidon then cursed Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00231-00053233-00053430": "to wander the sea for ten years during", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00232-00053432-00053596": "which he would lose all his crew and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00233-00053597-00053766": "return home through the aid of others", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00234-00053766-00054051": "after the escape Odysseus and his crew", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00235-00054052-00054250": "stayed with Ellis a king endowed by the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00236-00054251-00054369": "gods with the winds", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00237-00054370-00054598": "he gave Odysseus a leather bag", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00238-00054599-00054807": "containing all the winds except the west", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00239-00054808-00054982": "wind a gift that should have ensured a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00240-00054983-00055261": "safe return home just as Ithaca came", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00241-00055262-00055471": "into sight the greedy sailors naively", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00242-00055472-00055654": "opened the bag while Odysseus slept", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00243-00055654-00055912": "thinking it contained gold all of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00244-00055913-00056104": "winds flew out and the resulting storm", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00245-00056104-00056269": "drove the ships back the way they had", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00246-00056270-00056599": "come Ellis recognizing that Odysseus has", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00247-00056600-00056791": "drawn the ire of the gods refused to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00248-00056791-00057030": "further assist him the men then", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00249-00057032-00057187": "reembarked and encountered the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00250-00057188-00057426": "cannibalistic Lester go nians all of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00251-00057427-00057634": "Odysseus ships except his own entered", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00252-00057635-00057835": "the harbor of the last ergo nians island", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00253-00057836-00058090": "and were immediately destroyed he sailed", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00254-00058091-00058291": "on and reached the island of aiiow where", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00255-00058291-00058441": "he visited the witch goddess Circe", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00256-00058441-00058726": "daughter of the Sun God Helios she", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00257-00058727-00058924": "turned half of his men into swine after", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00258-00058925-00059107": "feeding them drugged cheese and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00259-00059108-00059379": "hermès warned Odysseus about Circe and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00260-00059380-00059584": "gave Odysseus and herb called moly which", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00261-00059585-00059816": "gave him resistance to Circe's magic", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00262-00059817-00060061": "Odysseus forced the now powerless Circe", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00263-00060062-00060235": "to change his men back to their human", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00264-00060236-00060451": "form and was subsequently seduced by her", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00265-00060452-00060703": "they remained with her on the island for", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00266-00060704-00060903": "one year while they feasted and drank", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00267-00060904-00061174": "finally guided by Circe's instructions", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00268-00061175-00061411": "Odysseus and his crew crossed the ocean", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00269-00061412-00061582": "and reached a Harbor at the western edge", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00270-00061583-00061791": "of the world where Odysseus sacrificed", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00271-00061792-00062038": "to the dead he first encountered the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00272-00062039-00062224": "spirit of el penor a crewman who had", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00273-00062225-00062419": "gotten drunk and fallen from a roof to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00274-00062420-00062707": "his death on I aya Eleanor's ghost told", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00275-00062708-00062955": "Odysseus to bury his body which Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00276-00062957-00063244": "promised to do Odysseus then summoned", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00277-00063245-00063451": "the spirit of the prophet Tiresias for", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00278-00063452-00063654": "advice on how to appease beside and upon", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00279-00063655-00063847": "his return home and was told that he may", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00280-00063848-00063997": "return home if he is able to stay", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00281-00063998-00064183": "himself and his crew from eating the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00282-00064184-00064414": "sacred livestock of Helios on the island", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00283-00064415-00064617": "of throne Asia and that failure to do so", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00284-00064619-00064798": "would result in the loss of his ship and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00285-00064799-00065091": "his entire crew next Odysseus met the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00286-00065092-00065311": "spirit of his own mother antic Lea who", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00287-00065312-00065452": "had died of grief during his long", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00288-00065453-00065743": "absence from her he got his first news", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00289-00065744-00065914": "of his own household threatened by the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00290-00065915-00066193": "greed of the suitors finally he met the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00291-00066194-00066451": "spirits of famous men and women notably", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00292-00066452-00066655": "he encountered the spirit of Agamemnon", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00293-00066656-00066826": "of whose murder he now learned and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00294-00066827-00067012": "Achilles who lamented the woes of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00295-00067013-00067192": "land of the dead but was comforted in", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00296-00067193-00067372": "hearing of the success of his son me", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00297-00067373-00067582": "autonomous for Odysseus encounter with", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00298-00067583-00067909": "the dead see also new Kuya returning to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00299-00067910-00067969": "I aya", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00300-00067970-00068134": "they buried Alpen ore and were advised", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00301-00068135-00068344": "by Circe on the remaining stages of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00302-00068345-00068578": "journey they skirted the land of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00303-00068579-00068794": "sirens who sang an enchanting song that", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00304-00068795-00069010": "normally caused passing sailors to steer", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00305-00069011-00069193": "toward the rocks only to hit them and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00306-00069194-00069442": "sink all of the sailors had their ears", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00307-00069443-00069595": "plugged up with beeswax", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00308-00069596-00069799": "except for Odysseus who was tied to the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00309-00069800-00070054": "mast as he wanted to hear the song he", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00310-00070055-00070261": "told his sailors not to untie him as it", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00311-00070262-00070387": "would only make him want to drown", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00312-00070388-00070444": "himself", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00313-00070445-00070687": "they then passed between the six-headed", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00314-00070688-00070867": "monster Scylla and the Whirlpool", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00315-00070868-00071092": "Charybdis narrowly avoiding death even", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00316-00071093-00071377": "though Skylar's snatched up six men next", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00317-00071378-00071539": "they landed on the island of Draenei", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00318-00071540-00071692": "shiah with the crew overriding", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00319-00071693-00071863": "Odysseus's wishes to remain away from", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00320-00071864-00072136": "the island Zeus caused a storm which", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00321-00072137-00072325": "prevented them leaving causing them to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00322-00072326-00072544": "deplete the food given to them by Sir", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00323-00072545-00072805": "while Odysseus was away prey his men", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00324-00072806-00073004": "ignored the warnings of Tiresias and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00325-00073005-00073192": "serfs and hunted the sacred cattle of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00326-00073193-00073492": "Helios the Sun God insisted that Zeus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00327-00073493-00073741": "punished the men for this sacrilege they", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00328-00073742-00073906": "suffered a shipwreck as they were driven", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00329-00073907-00074176": "towards Charybdis all but Odysseus were", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00330-00074177-00074236": "drowned", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00331-00074237-00074455": "Odysseus clung to a fig tree above", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00332-00074456-00074707": "Charybdis washed ashore on the island of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00333-00074708-00074909": "Ogygia he was compelled to remain there", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00334-00074910-00075134": "as Calypso's lover bored homesick and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00335-00075135-00075319": "trapped on her small island until she", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00336-00075320-00075521": "was ordered by Zeus via Hermes to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00337-00075522-00075817": "release Odysseus Odysseus did not", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00338-00075818-00075988": "realize how long it would take to get", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00339-00075989-00076419": "home to his family", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00340-00076420-00076879": "topic returned to Ithaca", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00341-00076880-00077097": "having listened with rapt attention to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00342-00077098-00077272": "his story the fee Asians agreed to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00343-00077273-00077466": "provide Odysseus with more treasure than", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00344-00077467-00077619": "he would have received from the spoils", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00345-00077620-00077884": "of Troy they deliver him at night while", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00346-00077885-00078079": "he is fast asleep to a hidden harbour on", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00347-00078080-00078369": "Ithaca Poseidon offended that the fee", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00348-00078370-00078541": "Asians have returned Odysseus home", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00349-00078542-00078715": "destroys the fee Asian ship on its", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00350-00078716-00078966": "return voyage and the city sacrifices to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00351-00078967-00079128": "Poseidon and agrees to stop giving", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00352-00079129-00079332": "escorts to strangers to appease him", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00353-00079333-00079599": "Odysseus awakens and believes that he", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00354-00079600-00079747": "has been dropped on a distant land", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00355-00079748-00079962": "before Athena appears to him and reveals", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00356-00079963-00080217": "that he is indeed on Ithaca she then", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00357-00080218-00080428": "hides his treasure in a nearby cave and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00358-00080429-00080647": "disguises him as an elderly beggar so he", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00359-00080648-00080791": "can see how things stand in his", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00360-00080792-00081054": "household he finds his way to the hut of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00361-00081055-00081235": "one of his own slaves the swineherd", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00362-00081236-00081460": "Eumaeus who treats him hospitably and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00363-00081461-00081729": "speaks favorably of Odysseus after", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00364-00081730-00081954": "dinner the disguised Odysseus tells the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00365-00081955-00082147": "farm laborers a fictitious tale of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00366-00082148-00082360": "himself he was born in Crete had led a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00367-00082361-00082522": "party of cretins to fight alongside", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00368-00082523-00082743": "other Greeks in the Trojan War and had", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00369-00082744-00082911": "then spent seven years at the court of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00370-00082912-00083013": "the king of Egypt", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00371-00083014-00083191": "finally ship-wrecking and Bess brochure", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00372-00083192-00083341": "and crossing from there to Ithaca", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00373-00083342-00083574": "he further promises the man of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00374-00083575-00083787": "return of Odysseus but his promises are", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00375-00083788-00084097": "wearily discounted by the man meanwhile", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00376-00084098-00084298": "Telemachus sails home from Sparta", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00377-00084299-00084588": "evading an ambush set by the suitors he", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00378-00084589-00084786": "disembarks on the coast of Ithaca and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00379-00084787-00085038": "makes for Eumaeus his Hut father and son", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00380-00085039-00085285": "meet Odysseus identifies himself to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00381-00085286-00085498": "Telemachus but still not to Eumaeus and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00382-00085499-00085660": "they decide that the suitors must be", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00383-00085661-00085712": "killed", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00384-00085713-00086001": "Telemachus goes home first accompanied", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00385-00086002-00086241": "by Eumaeus Odysseus returns to his own", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00386-00086242-00086435": "house still pretending to be a beggar", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00387-00086436-00086751": "when Odysseus dog who was a puppy before", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00388-00086752-00086799": "he left", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00389-00086800-00087006": "saw him he becomes so excited that he", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00390-00087007-00087291": "dies he is ridiculed by the suitors in", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00391-00087292-00087523": "his own home especially by one extremely", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00392-00087524-00087855": "impertinent man named Antinous Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00393-00087856-00088072": "meets Penelope and tests her intentions", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00394-00088073-00088307": "by saying he once met Odysseus in Crete", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00395-00088308-00088557": "closely questioned he adds that he had", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00396-00088558-00088740": "recently been in thest brochure and had", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00397-00088741-00088905": "learned something their abode is his", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00398-00088906-00089250": "recent wanderings Odysseus's identity is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00399-00089251-00089430": "discovered by the housekeeper your eye", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00400-00089431-00089655": "clayey when she recognizes an old scar", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00401-00089656-00089925": "as she is washing his feet your eye Clea", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00402-00089926-00090126": "tries to tell Penelope about the beggars", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00403-00090127-00090266": "true identity but at", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00404-00090267-00090487": "makes sure that Penelope cannot hear her", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00405-00090488-00090752": "Odysseus thence where's your Ike Leia to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00406-00090753-00091087": "secrecy", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00407-00091088-00091630": "topic slaying of the suitors", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00408-00091631-00091867": "the next day at Athena's prompting", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00409-00091868-00092065": "vanellope manoeuvres the suitors into", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00410-00092066-00092232": "competing for her hand with an archery", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00411-00092233-00092532": "competition using Odysseus bow the man", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00412-00092533-00092700": "who can string the bow and shoot it", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00413-00092701-00092874": "through a dozen axe heads would win", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00414-00092875-00093103": "Odysseus takes part in the competition", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00415-00093104-00093351": "himself he alone is strong enough to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00416-00093352-00093496": "string the bow and shoot it through the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00417-00093497-00093784": "dozen axe heads making him the winner he", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00418-00093785-00093957": "then throws off his rags and kills", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00419-00093958-00094246": "Antinous with his next arrow then with", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00420-00094247-00094354": "the help of Athena", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00421-00094355-00094579": "Odysseus Telemachus Eumaeus and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00422-00094580-00094767": "fallacious the cowherd he kills the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00423-00094768-00094950": "other suitors first using the rest of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00424-00094951-00095122": "the arrows and then by swords and spears", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00425-00095123-00095416": "once both sides armed themselves once", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00426-00095417-00095505": "the battle is won", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00427-00095506-00095751": "Odysseus and Telemachus also hang twelve", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00428-00095752-00095937": "of their household maids who muri clayey", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00429-00095938-00096097": "identifies as guilty of betraying", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00430-00096098-00096340": "Penelope or having sex with the suitors", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00431-00096341-00096567": "they mutilate and killed a goatherd", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00432-00096568-00096778": "melanthius who had mocked and abused", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00433-00096779-00096985": "Odysseus and brought weapons and armor", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00434-00096986-00097236": "to the suitors now at last", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00435-00097237-00097465": "Odysseus identifies himself to Penelope", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00436-00097466-00097735": "she is hesitant but recognizes him when", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00437-00097736-00097897": "he mentions that he made their bed from", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00438-00097898-00098106": "an olive tree still rooted to the ground", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00439-00098107-00098371": "many modern and ancient scholars take", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00440-00098372-00098536": "this to be the original ending of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00441-00098537-00098679": "Odyssey and the rest to be an", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00442-00098680-00098959": "interpolation the next day he and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00443-00098960-00099166": "Telemachus visit the country farm of his", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00444-00099167-00099405": "old father Laertes who likewise accepts", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00445-00099406-00099555": "his identity only when Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00446-00099556-00099742": "correctly describes the orchard that", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00447-00099743-00100062": "Laertes had previously given him the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00448-00100063-00100234": "citizens of Ithaca have followed", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00449-00100235-00100435": "Odysseus on the road planning to avenge", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00450-00100436-00100604": "the killing of the suitors their sons", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00451-00100605-00100849": "their leader points out that Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00452-00100850-00101031": "has now caused the deaths of two", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00453-00101032-00101238": "generations of the men of Ithaca his", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00454-00101239-00101463": "sailors not one of whom survived and the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00455-00101464-00101686": "suitors who he has now executed albeit", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00456-00101687-00101979": "rightly Athena intervenes in a diya ex", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00457-00101980-00102204": "machina and persuades both sides to give", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00458-00102205-00102492": "up the vendetta after this ethica is at", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00459-00102493-00103064": "peace once more concluding the Odyssey", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00460-00103065-00103585": "topic character of Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00461-00103586-00103951": "Odysseus name means trouble in Greek", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00462-00103952-00104104": "referring to both the giving and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00463-00104105-00104329": "receiving of trouble as is often the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00464-00104330-00104626": "case in his wanderings an early example", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00465-00104627-00104782": "of this is the boar hunt that gave", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00466-00104783-00104989": "Odysseus the scar by which year I clayey", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00467-00104990-00105095": "recognizes him", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00468-00105096-00105263": "Odysseus as injured by the boar and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00469-00105264-00105409": "responds by killing it", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00470-00105410-00105703": "Odysseus heroic trade as his matey or", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00471-00105704-00106013": "cunning intelligence he is often", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00472-00106014-00106294": "described as the peer of Zeus in Council", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00473-00106295-00106528": "this intelligence is most often", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00474-00106529-00106733": "manifested by his use of disguise and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00475-00106733-00107033": "deceptive speech his disguises take", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00476-00107033-00107222": "forms both physical altering his", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00477-00107223-00107423": "appearance and verbal such as telling", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00478-00107424-00107626": "the Cyclops Polyphemus that his name is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00479-00107627-00107908": "outis nobody then escaping after", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00480-00107909-00108170": "blinding Polyphemus when asked by other", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00481-00108171-00108340": "Cyclopes why he is screaming", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00482-00108341-00108596": "Polyphemus replies that nobody is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00483-00108597-00108853": "hurting him so the others assume that if", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00484-00108854-00109138": "alone as you are Polyphemus none uses", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00485-00109139-00109373": "violence on you why there is no avoiding", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00486-00109374-00109609": "the sickness sent by great Zeus so you", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00487-00109610-00109816": "had better pray to your father the Lord", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00488-00109817-00110140": "Poseidon the most evident flaw that", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00489-00110141-00110341": "Odysseus sports is that of his arrogance", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00490-00110342-00110641": "and his pride or hubris as he sails away", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00491-00110642-00110833": "from the island of the Cyclopes he", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00492-00110834-00111016": "shouts his name and boasts that nobody", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00493-00111017-00111316": "can defeat the great Odysseus the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00494-00111317-00111526": "Cyclops then throws the top half of a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00495-00111527-00111695": "mountain at him and prays to his father", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00496-00111696-00111913": "Poseidon saying that Odysseus has", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00497-00111914-00112175": "blinded him this enrages Poseidon", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00498-00112176-00112363": "causing the God to thwart Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00499-00112364-00112956": "homecoming for a very long time", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00500-00112957-00113340": "structure", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00501-00113341-00113544": "The Odyssey is written in dactylic", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00502-00113545-00113834": "hexameter it opens in medias res in the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00503-00113835-00114030": "middle of the overall story with prior", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00504-00114031-00114236": "events described through flashbacks or", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00505-00114238-00114546": "storytelling this device is also used by", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00506-00114547-00114785": "later authors of literary epics such as", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00507-00114786-00115014": "Virgil in the Aeneid luís de camões in", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00508-00115015-00115248": "Oz Lucia dis and Alexander Pope in the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00509-00115249-00115542": "rape of the lock the first four books of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00510-00115543-00115743": "the poem traced Telemachus efforts to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00511-00115744-00115944": "assert control of the household and then", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00512-00115945-00116166": "at Athena's advice his efforts to search", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00513-00116167-00116430": "for news of his long-lost father then", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00514-00116431-00116628": "the scene shifts Odysseus has been a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00515-00116629-00116781": "captive of the beautiful nymph Calypso", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00516-00116782-00117027": "with whom he has spent seven of his 10", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00517-00117028-00117297": "Lost years released by the intercession", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00518-00117298-00117501": "of his patroness Athena through the aid", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00519-00117502-00117720": "of Hermes he departs but his raft is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00520-00117721-00117933": "destroyed by his divine enemy poseidon", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00521-00117933-00118146": "who is angry because odysseus blinded", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00522-00118147-00118473": "his son Polyphemus when odysseus washes", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00523-00118474-00118698": "up on Shuri home to the fee Asians he is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00524-00118699-00118881": "assisted by the young Nausicaa and is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00525-00118882-00119151": "treated hospitably in return he", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00526-00119152-00119367": "satisfies the faaaa shuns curiosity", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00527-00119368-00119556": "telling them and the reader of all his", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00528-00119557-00119826": "adventures since departing from Troy the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00529-00119827-00120027": "shipbuilding creations then loaned him a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00530-00120028-00120213": "ship to return to Ithaca where he is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00531-00120214-00120405": "aided by the swineherd Eumaeus meets", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00532-00120406-00120606": "Telemachus regains his household by", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00533-00120607-00120792": "killing the suitors and is reunited with", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00534-00120793-00121109": "his faithful wife Penelope all ancient", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00535-00121110-00121314": "and nearly all modern editions and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00536-00121315-00121515": "translations of the Odyssey are divided", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00537-00121516-00121800": "into 24 books this division is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00538-00121801-00122001": "convenient but it may not be original", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00539-00122002-00122232": "many scholars believe it was developed", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00540-00122233-00122424": "by Alexandrian editors of the 3rd", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00541-00122425-00122691": "century BC in the Classical period", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00542-00122692-00122885": "moreover several of the books", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00543-00122886-00123081": "individually and in groups were given", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00544-00123082-00123279": "their own titles the first four books", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00545-00123280-00123492": "focusing on Telemachus are commonly", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00546-00123493-00123744": "known as the dilemma key Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00547-00123745-00123983": "narrative book 9 featuring his encounter", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00548-00123984-00124155": "with the Cyclops Polyphemus is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00549-00124156-00124428": "traditionally called the cyclopia book", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00550-00124429-00124650": "11 the section describing his meeting", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00551-00124651-00124806": "with the spirits of the dead as known as", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00552-00124807-00125121": "the new kouya books 9 through 12 wherein", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00553-00125122-00125331": "Odysseus recalls his adventures for his", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00554-00125332-00125499": "fee a ssin hosts are collectively", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00555-00125500-00125652": "referred to as the Apollo", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00556-00125653-00126045": "Odysseus stories book 22 wherein", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00557-00126046-00126255": "Odysseus kills all the suitors has been", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00558-00126256-00126399": "given the title in the stair afonya", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00559-00126400-00126626": "slaughter of the suitors", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00560-00126627-00126836": "this concludes the Greek epic cycle", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00561-00126837-00126973": "though fragments remain of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00562-00126974-00127274": "alternative ending of sorts known as the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00563-00127275-00127703": "telegin II telegin II aside the last 548", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00564-00127704-00127910": "lines of the Odyssey corresponding to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00565-00127911-00128171": "book 24 are believed by many scholars to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00566-00128172-00128381": "have been added by a slightly later poet", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00567-00128382-00128660": "several passages in earlier books seem", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00568-00128661-00128870": "to be setting up the events of book 24", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00569-00128871-00129081": "so if it were indeed a later edition the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00570-00129082-00129233": "offending editor would seem to have", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00571-00129234-00129500": "changed earlier text as well for more", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00572-00129501-00129677": "about varying views on the origin", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00573-00129678-00129884": "authorship and unity of the poem see", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00574-00129885-00130349": "Homeric scholarship", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00575-00130350-00130888": "topic geography of the Odyssey", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00576-00130889-00131103": "the events in the main sequence of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00577-00131104-00131326": "Odyssey excluding Odysseus embedded", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00578-00131327-00131509": "narrative of his wanderings take place", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00579-00131510-00131677": "in the peloponnesian in what are now", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00580-00131678-00131920": "called the Ionian islands there are", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00581-00131921-00132112": "difficulties in the apparently simple", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00582-00132113-00132328": "identification of Ithaca the homeland of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00583-00132329-00132520": "Odysseus which may or may not be the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00584-00132521-00132700": "same island that is now called awake", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00585-00132701-00132937": "I think the wanderings of Odysseus is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00586-00132938-00133138": "told to the FIH Asians and the location", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00587-00133139-00133297": "of the faaaa Sean's own island of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00588-00133298-00133513": "scheria posed more fundamental problems", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00589-00133514-00133753": "if geography is to be applied scholars", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00590-00133754-00133969": "both ancient and modern are divided as", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00591-00133970-00134143": "to whether or not any of the places", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00592-00134144-00134350": "visited by Odysseus after his murrow's", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00593-00134351-00134866": "and before his return to Ithaca are real", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00594-00134867-00135468": "topic influences on the Odyssey", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00595-00135469-00135708": "scholars have seen strong influences", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00596-00135709-00135863": "from Near Eastern mythology and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00597-00135864-00136127": "literature in the Odyssey Martin west", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00598-00136128-00136344": "has noted substantial parallels between", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00599-00136345-00136547": "the epic of gilgamesh and the Odyssey", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00600-00136548-00136829": "both Odysseus and Gilgamesh are known", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00601-00136830-00136983": "for travelling to the ends of the earth", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00602-00136984-00137165": "and on their journeys go to the land of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00603-00137166-00137433": "the dead on his voyage to the underworld", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00604-00137434-00137643": "Odysseus follows instructions given to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00605-00137644-00137996": "him by Circe her Island aya is located", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00606-00137997-00138168": "at the edges of the world and seems to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00607-00138169-00138350": "have close associations with the Sun", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00608-00138351-00138665": "like Odysseus Gilgamesh gets directions", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00609-00138666-00138800": "on how to reach the Land of the Dead", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00610-00138801-00139034": "from a divine helper in this case the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00611-00139035-00139245": "goddess Suder II who likes Hurst wells", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00612-00139246-00139482": "by the sea at the ends of the earth her", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00613-00139483-00139691": "home is also associated with the Sun", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00614-00139692-00139910": "Gilgamesh reaches surgeries house by", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00615-00139911-00140048": "passing through a tunnel underneath", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00616-00140049-00140256": "Mount masu the high mountain from which", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00617-00140257-00140556": "the Sun comes into the sky West argues", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00618-00140557-00140747": "that the similarity of Odysseus and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00619-00140748-00140921": "Gilgamesh is journeys to the edges of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00620-00140922-00141050": "the earth are the result of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00621-00141051-00141254": "influence of the Gilgamesh epic upon the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00622-00141255-00141686": "Odyssey in 1914 paleontologists otha mio", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00623-00141687-00141923": "Abel surmised the origins of the Cyclops", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00624-00141924-00142083": "to be the result of ancient Greeks", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00625-00142084-00142352": "finding an elephant skull the enormous", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00626-00142353-00142523": "nasal passage in the middle of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00627-00142524-00142661": "forehead could have looked like the eye", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00628-00142662-00142869": "socket of a giant to those who had never", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00629-00142870-00143121": "seen a living elephant classical", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00630-00143122-00143307": "scholars on the other hand have long", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00631-00143308-00143498": "realized that the story of the Cyclops", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00632-00143499-00143714": "was originally a Greek folk tale which", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00633-00143715-00143931": "existed independently of the Odyssey and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00634-00143932-00144096": "which only became embedded in it at a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00635-00144097-00144383": "later date similar stories are found in", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00636-00144384-00144543": "cultures across Europe and the Middle", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00637-00144544-00144836": "East according to this explanation the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00638-00144837-00145079": "Cyclops was originally simply a giant or", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00639-00145080-00145283": "ogre much like Humbaba in the epic of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00640-00145284-00145569": "gilgamesh the detail about it having one", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00641-00145570-00145754": "I was simply invented in order to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00642-00145755-00145934": "explain how the creature was so easily", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00643-00145935-00146296": "blinded", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00644-00146297-00146793": "topic themes", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00645-00146794-00147264": "topic homecoming", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00646-00147265-00147492": "an important factor to consider about", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00647-00147493-00147675": "Odysseus homecoming as the hint at", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00648-00147676-00147867": "potential endings to the epic by using", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00649-00147868-00148062": "other characters as parallels for his", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00650-00148063-00148335": "journey for instance one example is that", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00651-00148336-00148533": "of Agamemnon's homecoming versus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00652-00148534-00148812": "Odysseus homecoming upon Agamemnon's", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00653-00148813-00149031": "return his wife Clytemnestra and her", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00654-00149032-00149364": "lover Aegisthus kill Agamemnon Agamemnon", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00655-00149365-00149592": "son Orestes out of vengeance for his", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00656-00149593-00149862": "father's death kills Aegisthus this", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00657-00149863-00150030": "parallel compares the death of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00658-00150031-00150216": "suitors to the death of Aegisthus and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00659-00150217-00150399": "sets Orestes up as an example for", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00660-00150400-00150717": "Telemachus also because Odysseus knows", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00661-00150718-00150945": "about Clytemnestra is betrayal Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00662-00150946-00151149": "returns home in disguise in order to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00663-00151150-00151302": "test the loyalty of his own wife", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00664-00151303-00151623": "Penelope later agamemnon praises", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00665-00151624-00151878": "Penelope for not killing Odysseus it is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00666-00151879-00152088": "because of Penelope that Odysseus has", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00667-00152089-00152352": "Fame and a successful homecoming this", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00668-00152353-00152577": "successful homecoming is unlike Achilles", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00669-00152578-00152811": "who has fame but is dead and Agamemnon", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00670-00152812-00153000": "who had an unsuccessful homecoming", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00671-00153001-00153378": "resulting in his death", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00672-00153379-00153857": "topic wandering", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00673-00153858-00154118": "only two of Odysseus's adventures are", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00674-00154119-00154325": "described by the poet the rest of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00675-00154326-00154511": "Odysseus adventures are recounted by", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00676-00154512-00154784": "Odysseus himself the two scenes that the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00677-00154785-00155021": "poet describes are Odysseus on Calypso's", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00678-00155022-00155219": "Island and Odysseus encounter with the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00679-00155220-00155462": "fee Asians these scenes are told by the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00680-00155463-00155636": "poet to represent an important", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00681-00155637-00155831": "transition in Odysseus journey being", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00682-00155832-00156107": "concealed to returning home Calypso's", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00683-00156108-00156506": "name means concealer or one who conceals", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00684-00156507-00156749": "and that is exactly what she does with", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00685-00156750-00157004": "Odysseus Calypso keeps Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00686-00157005-00157187": "concealed from the world and unable to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00687-00157188-00157454": "return home after leaving Calypso's", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00688-00157455-00157664": "island the poet describes Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00689-00157665-00157880": "encounters with the fie a shion's those", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00690-00157881-00158243": "who convoy without hurt to all man which", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00691-00158244-00158426": "represents his transition from not", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00692-00158427-00158669": "returning home to returning home also", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00693-00158670-00158885": "during Odysseus journey he encounters", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00694-00158886-00159070": "many beings that are close to the gods", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00695-00159071-00159308": "these encounters are useful in", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00696-00159309-00159497": "understanding that Odysseus is in a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00697-00159498-00159710": "world beyond man and that influences the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00698-00159711-00159992": "fact he cannot return home these beings", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00699-00159993-00160172": "that are close to the gods include the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00700-00160173-00160385": "FIH Asians who lived near Cyclopes whose", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00701-00160386-00160610": "King Alcinous is the great-grandson of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00702-00160611-00160793": "the king of the Giants Yura Medan and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00703-00160794-00161048": "the grandson of Poseidon some of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00704-00161049-00161183": "other characters that Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00705-00161184-00161408": "encounters are Polyphemus who is the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00706-00161409-00161645": "Cyclops son of Poseidon god of oceans", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00707-00161646-00161849": "sirs who is the sorceress daughter of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00708-00161850-00161993": "the son that turns men into animals", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00709-00161994-00162239": "Calypso who is a goddess and the last", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00710-00162240-00162731": "ergo nians who are cannibalistic giants", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00711-00162732-00163328": "topic guests friendship throughout the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00712-00163329-00163538": "course of the epic Odysseus encounters", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00713-00163539-00163748": "several examples of Xenia guests", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00714-00163749-00164006": "friendship which provide models of how", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00715-00164007-00164234": "hosts should and should not act the fee", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00716-00164235-00164429": "Asians demonstrate exemplary guests", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00717-00164430-00164639": "friendship by feeding Odysseus giving", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00718-00164640-00164822": "him a place to sleep and granting him a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00719-00164823-00165017": "safe voyage home which are all things a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00720-00165018-00165263": "good host should do Polyphemus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00721-00165264-00165506": "demonstrates poor guests friendship his", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00722-00165507-00165818": "only gift to Odysseus says that he will", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00723-00165819-00166076": "eat him last Calypso also exemplifies", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00724-00166077-00166286": "poor guests friendship because she does", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00725-00166287-00166483": "not allow Odysseus to leave her island", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00726-00166484-00166718": "another important factor to guests", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00727-00166719-00166895": "friendship is that kingship implies", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00728-00166896-00167174": "generosity it is assumed that a king has", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00729-00167175-00167369": "the means to be a generous host and is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00730-00167370-00167633": "more generous with his own property this", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00731-00167634-00167870": "is best seen when Odysseus disguised as", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00732-00167871-00168068": "a beggar begs Antinous one of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00733-00168069-00168299": "suitors for food and Antinous denies his", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00734-00168300-00168368": "request", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00735-00168369-00168626": "Odysseus essentially says that while", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00736-00168627-00168848": "Anton OS may look like a king he is far", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00737-00168849-00169307": "from a king since he is not generous", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00738-00169308-00169778": "topic testing", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00739-00169779-00169994": "another theme throughout the Odyssey is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00740-00169995-00170249": "testing this occurs in two distinct ways", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00741-00170250-00170534": "Odysseus tests the loyalty of others and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00742-00170535-00170819": "others test Odysseus identity an example", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00743-00170820-00171014": "of Odysseus testing the loyalties of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00744-00171015-00171278": "others as when he returns home instead", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00745-00171279-00171497": "of immediately revealing his identity he", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00746-00171498-00171683": "arrives disguised as a beggar and then", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00747-00171684-00171857": "proceeds to determine who in his house", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00748-00171858-00172031": "has remained loyal to him and who has", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00749-00172032-00172280": "helped the suitors after Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00750-00172281-00172499": "reveals his true identity the characters", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00751-00172500-00172709": "test Odysseus identity to see if he", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00752-00172710-00172979": "really is who he says he is for instance", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00753-00172980-00173210": "Penelope tests Odysseus identity by", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00754-00173211-00173372": "saying that she will move the bed into", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00755-00173373-00173573": "the other room for him this is a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00756-00173574-00173771": "difficult task since it is made out of a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00757-00173772-00173966": "living tree that would require being cut", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00758-00173967-00174191": "down a fact that only the real Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00759-00174192-00174473": "would know thus proving his identity for", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00760-00174474-00174653": "more information on the progression of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00761-00174654-00175215": "testing type scenes read more below", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00762-00175216-00175607": "omens", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00763-00175608-00175811": "omens occur frequently throughout the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00764-00175812-00176050": "Odyssey as well as in many other epochs", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00765-00176051-00176312": "within the Odyssey omens frequently", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00766-00176313-00176551": "involve Birds it is important to note", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00767-00176552-00176708": "who receives the omens and what these", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00768-00176709-00176894": "omens mean to the characters and to the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00769-00176895-00176989": "epic as a whole", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00770-00176990-00177224": "for instance bird omens are shown to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00771-00177225-00177478": "Telemachus Penelope Odysseus and the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00772-00177479-00177785": "suitors Telemachus and Penelope received", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00773-00177786-00177959": "their omens as well in the form of words", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00774-00177960-00178125": "sneezes and dreams", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00775-00178126-00178390": "however Odysseus is the only character", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00776-00178391-00178591": "who receives thunder or lightning as an", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00777-00178592-00178808": "omen this is important to note because", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00778-00178809-00179021": "the Thunder came from Zeus the king of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00779-00179022-00179081": "the gods", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00780-00179082-00179360": "this direct relationship between Zeus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00781-00179361-00179566": "and Odysseus represents the kingship of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00782-00179567-00180023": "Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00783-00180024-00180530": "topic scenes", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00784-00180531-00181028": "topic finding scenes", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00785-00181029-00181290": "finding scenes occur in the Odyssey when", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00786-00181291-00181485": "a character discovers another character", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00787-00181486-00181764": "within the epoch finding scenes proceed", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00788-00181765-00182061": "is followed the character encounters or", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00789-00182062-00182349": "finds another character the encountered", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00790-00182350-00182582": "character is identified and described", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00791-00182583-00182826": "the character approaches and then", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00792-00182827-00183024": "converses with the found character these", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00793-00183025-00183246": "finding scenes can be identified several", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00794-00183247-00183414": "times throughout the epoch including", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00795-00183415-00183612": "when Telemachus and 'pizza Stratus find", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00796-00183613-00183861": "Menelaus when Calypso finds Odysseus on", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00797-00183862-00184023": "the beach and when the suitor anthem'", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00798-00184024-00184488": "Eden finds Agamemnon in Hades", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00799-00184489-00185004": "topic guests friendship", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00800-00185005-00185244": "guest friendship is also a theme in the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00801-00185245-00185424": "Odyssey but it too follows a very", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00802-00185425-00185781": "specific pattern this pattern is the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00803-00185782-00186079": "arrival and the reception of the guests", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00804-00186080-00186280": "bathing or providing fresh clothes to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00805-00186281-00186571": "the guests providing food and drink to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00806-00186572-00186880": "the guests questions may be asked of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00807-00186881-00187033": "guests and entertainment should be", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00808-00187034-00187309": "provided by the host the guests should", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00809-00187310-00187504": "be given a place to sleep and both the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00810-00187505-00187798": "guest and host retire for the night the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00811-00187799-00188011": "guest and host exchange gifts the guest", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00812-00188012-00188203": "is granted a safe journey home in two", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00813-00188204-00188419": "parts another important factor of guests", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00814-00188420-00188572": "friendship is not keeping the guest", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00815-00188573-00188773": "longer than they wish and also promising", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00816-00188774-00188905": "their safety while they are a guest", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00817-00188906-00189352": "within the hosts home", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00818-00189353-00189759": "topic testing", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00819-00189760-00189987": "while testing is a theme with the epic", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00820-00189988-00190215": "it also has a very specific type scene", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00821-00190216-00190443": "that accompanies it as well throughout", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00822-00190444-00190652": "the epic the testing of others follows a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00823-00190653-00191049": "typical pattern this pattern is Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00824-00191050-00191247": "is hesitant to question the loyalties of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00825-00191248-00191327": "others", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00826-00191328-00191598": "Odysseus tests the loyalties of others", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00827-00191599-00191901": "by questioning them the characters reply", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00828-00191902-00192079": "to Odysseus questions", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00829-00192080-00192395": "Odysseus proceeds to reveal his identity", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00830-00192396-00192722": "the characters test Odysseus identity", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00831-00192723-00193016": "there is a rise of emotions associated", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00832-00193017-00193248": "with Odysseus recognition usually lament", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00833-00193249-00193587": "or joy finally the reconciled characters", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00834-00193588-00193938": "work together", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00835-00193939-00194424": "topic omens", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00836-00194425-00194685": "omens are another example of a type seen", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00837-00194686-00194937": "in the Odyssey two important parts of an", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00838-00194938-00195117": "omen type seen are the recognition of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00839-00195118-00195327": "the omen and then the interpretation in", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00840-00195328-00195543": "the Odyssey specifically there are", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00841-00195544-00195807": "several omens involving Birds all of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00842-00195808-00196023": "bird omens with the exception of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00843-00196024-00196260": "first one in the epic she'll large birds", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00844-00196261-00196536": "attacking smaller birds accompanying", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00845-00196537-00196719": "each omen as a wish which can be either", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00846-00196720-00197028": "explicitly stated or only implied for", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00847-00197029-00197235": "example Telemachus wishes for vengeance", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00848-00197236-00197469": "and for Odysseus to be home Penelope", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00849-00197470-00197655": "wishes for Odysseus returned and the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00850-00197656-00197825": "suitors wish for the death of Telemachus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00851-00197826-00198117": "the omens seen in the Odyssey are also a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00852-00198118-00198584": "recurring theme throughout the epic", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00853-00198585-00199134": "topic cultural impact", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00854-00199135-00199359": "The Odyssey is regarded as one of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00855-00199360-00199545": "most important foundational works of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00856-00199546-00199806": "Western literature it is widely regarded", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00857-00199807-00200013": "by Western literary critics as a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00858-00200014-00200277": "timeless classic straightforward", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00859-00200278-00200430": "retellings of the Odyssey have", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00860-00200431-00200639": "flourished ever since the Middle Ages", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00861-00200640-00201012": "muruga yulux ma icc lear DS on the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00862-00201013-00201348": "wandering of ulysses son of laertes is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00863-00201349-00201561": "an eccentric old irish version of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00864-00201562-00201780": "material the work exists in a 12th", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00865-00201781-00202008": "century ad manuscript which linguists", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00866-00202009-00202176": "believe is based on an eighth century", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00867-00202177-00202494": "original ill ritorno Dooley's in patria", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00868-00202495-00202788": "first performed in 1640 is an opera by", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00869-00202789-00202995": "claudio monteverdi based on the second", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00870-00202996-00203283": "half of Homer's Odyssey the first canto", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00871-00203284-00203592": "of ezra pound's the cantos 1917 is both", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00872-00203593-00203760": "a translation and a retelling of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00873-00203761-00204012": "Odysseus journey to the underworld the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00874-00204013-00204378": "poem Ulysses by Alfred Lord Tennyson is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00875-00204379-00204573": "narrated by an aged Ulysses who is", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00876-00204574-00204735": "determined to continue to live life to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00877-00204736-00205080": "the fullest The Odyssey 1997 a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00878-00205081-00205302": "made-for-tv movie directed by Andrei", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00879-00205303-00205536": "Konchalovsky is a slightly abbreviated", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00880-00205537-00205830": "version of the epic other authors have", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00881-00205831-00206046": "composed more creative reworkings of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00882-00206046-00206211": "poem often updated to address", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00883-00206212-00206419": "contemporary themes and concerns", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00884-00206421-00206691": "Cyclops by Euripides the only fully", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00885-00206692-00206919": "extant satyr play retells the episode", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00886-00206919-00207098": "involving Polyphemus with a humorous", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00887-00207100-00207414": "twist a true story written by lucien of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00888-00207415-00207663": "sam asada in the second century AD is a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00889-00207664-00207858": "satire on the Odyssey and on ancient", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00890-00207859-00208059": "travel tales describing a journey", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00891-00208060-00208244": "sailing westward Beyond The Pillars of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00892-00208246-00208461": "Hercules into the moon the first known", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00893-00208462-00208611": "text that could be called science", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00894-00208612-00208908": "fiction James Joyce's modernist novel", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00895-00208909-00209217": "Ulysses 1922 is a retelling of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00896-00209217-00209481": "Odyssey set in modern-day Dublin each", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00897-00209482-00209667": "chapter in the book has an assigned", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00898-00209667-00209867": "theme technique and correspondences", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00899-00209869-00210033": "between its characters and those of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00900-00210034-00210285": "Homer's Odyssey Homer's daughter by", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00901-00210286-00210504": "Robert Graves as a novel imagining how", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00902-00210505-00210642": "the version we have might have been", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00903-00210642-00210936": "invented out of older tales the Japanese", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00904-00210937-00211317": "French anime Ulysses 31 1981 updates the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00905-00211317-00211515": "ancient setting into a 31st century", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00906-00211516-00211932": "space opera a marrows 1991 an epic poem", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00907-00211933-00212166": "by derek walcott is in part a retelling", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00908-00212167-00212340": "of the Odyssey set on the Caribbean", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00909-00212341-00212496": "island of st. Lucia", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00910-00212496-00212862": "the film Ulysses gays 1995 directed by", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00911-00212863-00213063": "Theo Angela police has many of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00912-00213064-00213257": "elements of the Odyssey set against the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00913-00213258-00213465": "backdrop of the most recent in previous", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00914-00213466-00213719": "Balkan Wars Daniel Wallace's big fish a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00915-00213721-00214031": "novel of mythic proportions 1998 adapts", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00916-00214032-00214215": "the epic to the American South while", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00917-00214216-00214425": "also incorporating tall tales into its", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00918-00214426-00214610": "first person narrative much as Odysseus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00919-00214611-00214842": "does in the apology books nine to twelve", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00920-00214842-00215127": "the Coen brothers 2000 film o brother", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00921-00215128-00215373": "where art thou is loosely based on", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00922-00215373-00215700": "Homer's poem Margaret Atwood's 2005", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00923-00215701-00215901": "novella the Penelope as an ironic", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00924-00215902-00216114": "rewriting of the Odyssey from Penelope's", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00925-00216115-00216194": "perspective", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00926-00216194-00216441": "Zachary Masons the lost books of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00927-00216442-00216705": "Odyssey 2007 is a series of short", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00928-00216706-00216888": "stories that rework Homer's original", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00929-00216889-00217092": "plot in a contemporary style reminiscent", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00930-00217092-00217388": "of Italo Calvino the Heroes of Olympus", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00931-00217389-00217719": "2010 to 2014 by Rick Riordan is based", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00932-00217719-00217953": "entirely on Greek mythology and includes", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00933-00217954-00218151": "many aspects and characters from the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00934-00218152-00218196": "Odyssey", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00935-00218196-00218360": "authors have sought to imagine new", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00936-00218361-00218676": "endings for the Odyssey in canto 26 of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00937-00218677-00218867": "the inferno Dante Alighieri meets", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00938-00218869-00219059": "Odysseus in the eighth circle of Hell", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00939-00219060-00219264": "where Odysseus himself appends a new", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00940-00219265-00219444": "ending to the Odyssey in which he never", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00941-00219444-00219669": "returns to Ithaca and instead continues", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00942-00219669-00219900": "his Restless adventuring nikos", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00943-00219901-00220155": "kazantzakis aspires to continue the poem", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00944-00220156-00220362": "and explore more modern concerns in his", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00945-00220363-00220596": "epic poem The Odyssey a modern sequel", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00946-00220596-00220848": "which was first published in 1938 in", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00947-00220848-00221159": "modern Greek in 2018 BBC culture pulled", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00948-00221160-00221348": "experts around the world to nominate the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00949-00221350-00221565": "stories they felt had shaped mindsets or", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00950-00221566-00221831": "influenced history Odyssey topped the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00951-00221832-00222235": "list", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00952-00222236-00222746": "topic English translations", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00953-00222748-00222998": "this is a partial list of translations", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00954-00223000-00223302": "into English of Homer's Odyssey George", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00955-00223303-00223937": "Chapman 1616 couplets thomas hobbes 1675", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00956-00223938-00224396": "alexander pope 1725 - 1726 I am back", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00957-00224398-00224589": "bent ammeter couplets Project Gutenberg", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00958-00224590-00225017": "Edition Gutenberg org William Cowper", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00959-00225017-00225381": "1791 blank verse an audio CD recording", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00960-00225382-00225591": "abridged by Perry kingly side and read", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00961-00225592-00225873": "by Anton lesser as available ISBN nine", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00962-00225873-00226212": "billion 626 million three hundred forty", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00963-00226213-00226396": "five thousand three hundred fourteen", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00964-00226398-00226794": "1995 Samuel Henry butcher and Andrew", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00965-00226794-00227091": "Lang 1879 prose Project Gutenberg", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00966-00227092-00227541": "edition William Cullen Bryant 1871 blank", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00967-00227542-00227988": "verse mordant Roger Barnard 1876 blank", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00968-00227989-00228510": "verse William Morris 1887 Samuel Butler", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00969-00228511-00228852": "1898 prose Project Gutenberg addition or", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00970-00228853-00229142": "Perseus project odd point one point one", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00971-00229142-00229571": "Padraic colum 1918 prose Bartleby calm", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00972-00229571-00230004": "80 Murray revised by Georgi Dimmick 1919", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00973-00230005-00230352": "Loeb classical library ISBN oh six seven", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00974-00230353-00230596": "four nine nine five six one nine", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00975-00230598-00230979": "available online here George Herbert", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00976-00230980-00231402": "Palmer 1921 prose an audio CD recording", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00977-00231403-00231621": "read by Norman Dietz as available ISBN", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00978-00231621-00232296": "one 402 5 2 3 2 5 4 1989 te Shaw TE", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00979-00232296-00232644": "Lawrence 1932 ISBN one eight five three", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00980-00232644-00233205": "two six oh two five eight whd rouse 1937", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00981-00233206-00233682": "prose Evie Ryu 1945 prose later revised", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00982-00233683-00234119": "in 1991 by DCH ryu for increased literal", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00983-00234121-00234584": "accuracy and his Reese 1960 Random House", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00984-00234585-00235008": "Robert Fitzgerald 1963 unrhymed poetry", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00985-00235009-00235275": "with varied lengths lines is B and O six", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00986-00235276-00235500": "seven nine seven two eight one three", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00987-00235501-00235791": "nine an audio CD recording read by John", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00988-00235792-00236040": "Lee as available ISBN one", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00989-00236041-00236356": "four one five nine three six oh five six", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00990-00236357-00236889": "2006 Richmond Lattimore 1965 poetry ISBN", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00991-00236890-00237390": "oo 609 three one nine five seven albert", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00992-00237391-00237687": "cooked 1967 morton critical edition", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00993-00237688-00237894": "poetry very accurate line by line", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00994-00237894-00238373": "version walter shearing 1980 is B&O one", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00995-00238375-00238590": "nine two eight three three seven five", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00996-00238591-00238815": "eight oxford university press oxford", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00997-00238816-00239190": "world's classics pros alan Mandelbaum", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00998-00239191-00239552": "1990 verse translation robert fagles", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-00999-00239553-00240101": "poetry 1996 is B&O one 402 six eight", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01000-00240102-00240326": "eight six three an unabridged audio", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01001-00240327-00240533": "reporting by Ian McKellen is also", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01002-00240534-00241060": "available ISBN 0 - 1408 6 4 3 Oh X", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01003-00241061-00241283": "Stanley Lombardo Hackett publishing", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01004-00241284-00241839": "company 2000 ISBN Oh 8 7 - 2 O 4 8 4 7", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01005-00241840-00242108": "an audio CD recording read by the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01006-00242109-00242298": "translator is also available", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01007-00242298-00242892": "ISBN 193 oh nine 7206 7 Martin Hammond", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01008-00242892-00243291": "mm prose Rodney Merrill University of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01009-00243292-00243734": "Michigan press 2002 ISBN 978 oh four", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01010-00243735-00243987": "seven two one one two three one nine", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01011-00243988-00244221": "Merrill's translation not only renders", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01012-00244221-00244389": "the work in English verse like the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01013-00244390-00244604": "dactylic hexameter of the original but", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01014-00244605-00244829": "also conveys the oral formulaic nature", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01015-00244830-00245027": "of the epic song to which that musical", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01016-00245028-00245344": "meter gives full value edward McCrory", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01017-00245346-00245988": "2004 ISBN doe 801 8 8 2 6 7 - Barry B", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01018-00245989-00246676": "Powell 2014 ISBN 978 a 1 9 9 3 6 0 3 1 4", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01019-00246677-00247116": "Emily Wilson 2017 ISBN nine seven eight", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01020-00247117-00247481": "oh three nine 308 905 nine I ambach", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01021-00247482-00247655": "pentameter the first complete", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01022-00247656-00248148": "translation into English by a woman", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01023-00248150-00248723": "topic see also", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01024-00248723-00249038": "Oh dizzy and God's parallels between", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01025-00249039-00249263": "Virgil's Aeneid and Homer's Iliad and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01026-00249264-00249623": "Odyssey", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01027-00249625-00250169": "topic references", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01028-00250171-00250688": "topic further reading", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01029-00250689-00250925": "Austen and archery at the dark of the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01030-00250926-00251191": "moon poetic problems in Homer's Odyssey", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01031-00251192-00251506": "Berkeley University of California Press", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01032-00251507-00251957": "1975 Clayton VA Penelope and poetics", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01033-00251958-00252119": "reweaving the feminine in Homer's", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01034-00252119-00252538": "Odyssey lanham Lexington books 2004", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01035-00252539-00252923": "Clayton B Polyphemus and Odysseus in the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01036-00252923-00253242": "nursery mother's milk in the cyclopia", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01037-00253244-00253909": "Arethusa vol 44 number 3 2011 255 to 277", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01038-00253910-00254210": "Bakr EJ the meaning of meat and the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01039-00254211-00254489": "structure of the Odyssey Cambridge New", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01040-00254490-00254912": "York Cambridge University Press 2013 bar", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01041-00254913-00255014": "now Jay", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01042-00255015-00255301": "Odysseus hero of practical intelligence", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01043-00255302-00255509": "deliberation and signs in Homer's", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01044-00255510-00255844": "Odyssey Lanham MD University Press of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01045-00255846-00256241": "America 2004 Doherty see the raft of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01046-00256242-00256490": "Odysseus the ethnographic imagination of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01047-00256491-00256721": "Homer's Odyssey New York", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01048-00256721-00257123": "Oxford University Press 2001 fennec B", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01049-00257123-00257369": "studies in the Odyssey Hermes is all", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01050-00257369-00257446": "shriveled", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01051-00257448-00257875": "beasts Baden West Germany Steiner 1974", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01052-00257876-00258263": "Griffin J Homer The Odyssey landmarks in", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01053-00258264-00258494": "world literature Cambridge Cambridge", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01054-00258494-00258932": "University Press 1987 Loudon B Homer's", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01055-00258933-00259157": "Odyssey in the Near East Cambridge New", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01056-00259158-00259208": "York", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01057-00259209-00259580": "Cambridge University Press 2011 Loudon", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01058-00259581-00259846": "be the Odyssey structure narration and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01059-00259848-00260060": "meaning Baltimore the Johns Hopkins", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01060-00260061-00260552": "University Press 1999 mention II the", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01061-00260553-00260861": "expression of sarcasm in the Odyssey", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01062-00260862-00261121": "quote quote Mnemosyne", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01063-00261123-00261700": "fourth series 63 number 4 2010 533 256", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01064-00261701-00262079": "Muller WG from Homer's Odyssey to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01065-00262080-00262331": "Joyce's Ulysses theory and practice of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01066-00262332-00262877": "an ethical neurology Arcadia 50.1 2015 9", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01067-00262878-00263082": "to 36", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01068-00263083-00263337": "said s homer in the Odyssey originally", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01069-00263338-00263730": "published 1998 Oxford New York Oxford", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01070-00263731-00264123": "University Press 2011 Terkel table D", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01071-00264124-00264351": "Penelope's stout hand and odissey and", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01072-00264352-00264600": "humor the Journal of Hellenic studies", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01073-00264601-00265341": "volume 134 2014 103 to 119 West II sirs", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01074-00265342-00265590": "Calypso hidimba the journal of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01075-00265591-00266105": "indo-european studies 42.1 2014 144 to", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01076-00266106-00266507": "174", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01077-00266508-00267056": "topic external links", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01078-00267057-00267360": "Odyssey on Perseus project", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01079-00267361-00267654": "ancient Greek English translation by", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01080-00267655-00268131": "Samuel Butler 1900 translation by a team", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01081-00268132-00268543": "early 1919 Homer's Odyssey a commentary", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01082-00268544-00268755": "by Denton Jacques Schneider on Project", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01083-00268756-00269253": "Gutenberg BBC audio file in our time BBC", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01084-00269254-00269595": "Radio 4 discussion programme 45 minutes", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01085-00269596-00269848": "the meaning of tradition in Homer's", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01086-00269849-00270183": "Odyssey in English The Odyssey comics a", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01087-00270184-00270394": "detailed retelling an explanation of", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01088-00270395-00270637": "Homer's Odyssey in comic strip format by", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01089-00270638-00271117": "Greek myth comics Nureyev / pena 2008 la", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01090-00271118-00271348": "script is de la Kritika veinte Licht", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01091-00271349-00271773": "horas de la OD saya Madrid Gredos The", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01092-00271774-00271980": "Odyssey public domain audiobook at", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01093-00271981-00272287": "LibriVox images of scenes from Homer's", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01094-00272288-00272456": "The Odyssey", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01095-00272457-00272788": "The Odyssey annotated text and analyses", "TzM0ccz-1kQ-01096-00272789-00273159": "aligned to common core standards"}}, {"audio_id": "TzbielGHKGu", "text": {"TzbielGHKGu-00000-00000079-00000311": "hello everyone thank you for supporting", "TzbielGHKGu-00001-00000312-00000447": "kpop strings", "TzbielGHKGu-00002-00000448-00000671": "my name is forever no and i am the", "TzbielGHKGu-00003-00000672-00000751": "producer of", "TzbielGHKGu-00004-00000752-00001054": "m string i'll be showcasing on online", "TzbielGHKGu-00005-00001055-00001119": "class", "TzbielGHKGu-00006-00001120-00001407": "how to arrange k-pop strings including", "TzbielGHKGu-00007-00001408-00001511": "my own orange", "TzbielGHKGu-00008-00001512-00001782": "song and my know-how hope you join me", "TzbielGHKGu-00009-00001784-00002007": "and you will get to see a special", "TzbielGHKGu-00010-00002007-00002199": "project that i have worked on", "TzbielGHKGu-00011-00002200-00003027": "with vts see you online", "TzbielGHKGu-00012-00003028-00005206": "[Music]", "TzbielGHKGu-00013-00005207-00005416": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "T-0LBvySLSE", "text": {"T-0LBvySLSE-00000-00000011-00000142": "[Music]", "T-0LBvySLSE-00001-00000143-00000175": "foreign", "T-0LBvySLSE-00002-00000176-00001209": "[Music]", "T-0LBvySLSE-00003-00001210-00002396": "[Music]", "T-0LBvySLSE-00004-00002397-00003599": "[Music]", "T-0LBvySLSE-00005-00003600-00003822": "foreign", "T-0LBvySLSE-00006-00003824-00007031": "[Music]", "T-0LBvySLSE-00007-00007031-00007259": "foreign", "T-0LBvySLSE-00008-00007261-00009649": "[Music]", "T-0LBvySLSE-00009-00009650-00010774": "[Music]", "T-0LBvySLSE-00010-00010775-00011154": "foreign", "T-0LBvySLSE-00011-00011155-00012079": "[Music]", "T-0LBvySLSE-00012-00012080-00013333": "[Music]", "T-0LBvySLSE-00013-00013334-00014551": "[Music]", "T-0LBvySLSE-00014-00014552-00015372": "[Music]", "T-0LBvySLSE-00015-00015373-00015854": "could this be", "T-0LBvySLSE-00016-00015855-00017161": "[Music]", "T-0LBvySLSE-00017-00017162-00017765": "hard could this be", "T-0LBvySLSE-00018-00017766-00018197": "foreign", "T-0LBvySLSE-00019-00018198-00020727": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "T-2dc5vUwcy", "text": {"T-2dc5vUwcy-00000-00000128-00000390": "in this demo i'll show the basic", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00001-00000391-00000711": "open lmis stock management features", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00002-00000712-00001015": "and then a few more powerful features", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00003-00001016-00001278": "for covid vaccine rollouts there's a", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00004-00001279-00001470": "high demand for more frequent", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00005-00001471-00001782": "trustworthy data for a few key data", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00006-00001784-00002007": "points such as how many vaccine vials", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00007-00002007-00002047": "are", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00008-00002048-00002391": "consumed and remaining stock on hand", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00009-00002392-00002558": "and with widespread rollout of", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00010-00002559-00002742": "vaccinations there's a need for a simple", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00011-00002743-00002831": "workflow", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00012-00002832-00003095": "to track this data frequently so the", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00013-00003096-00003254": "stock management workflow", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00014-00003255-00003670": "is one easy starting point i'll start on", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00015-00003671-00003863": "my android tablet", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00016-00003864-00004191": "i'll open the chrome browser and", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00017-00004192-00005702": "log in as a vaccine health worker", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00018-00005703-00006063": "so here on my open lmis dashboard", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00019-00006064-00006247": "the menu items are determined by my", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00020-00006248-00006463": "account and my roles", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00021-00006464-00006695": "and i'm going to show one of the most", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00022-00006695-00006814": "basic stock", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00023-00006815-00007063": "management workflows that can support", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00024-00007064-00007223": "covid vaccine rollouts", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00025-00007223-00007503": "so i'll go to stock management physical", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00026-00007504-00007655": "inventory", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00027-00007656-00007951": "it knows the facility i'm at i'll click", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00028-00007952-00008039": "start", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00029-00008040-00008278": "and it shows the products that i have at", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00030-00008279-00008446": "my facility", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00031-00008447-00008614": "and the stock on hand that was last", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00032-00008615-00008774": "recorded", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00033-00008775-00009031": "this page is designed to make it quick", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00034-00009032-00009151": "and easy", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00035-00009152-00009478": "to record the stock i have so i'll fill", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00036-00009479-00009710": "in my current amounts here at the end of", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00037-00009711-00009823": "the day", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00038-00009824-00010231": "um gloves yeah we had", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00039-00010232-00010678": "ten boxes left uh the masks", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00040-00010679-00010999": "each we had five left", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00041-00011000-00011263": "the syringes oh i'm gonna say we use", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00042-00011264-00011503": "them all", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00043-00011504-00011831": "and oh the syringes yeah and", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00044-00011832-00012383": "vaccines i'm going to say that we had", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00045-00012384-00012719": "one vial left with 10 doses", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00046-00012720-00013102": "so i could save and submit this", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00047-00013103-00013471": "now but i also", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00048-00013472-00013751": "could go back and provide the reasons", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00049-00013752-00013919": "it's optional", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00050-00013919-00014199": "but it's a great way to account for", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00051-00014200-00014366": "exactly what was used and", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00052-00014368-00014527": "especially people want to know kind of", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00053-00014528-00014686": "what was consumed", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00054-00014687-00015022": "and what remains left so i'm going to go", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00055-00015023-00015103": "back", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00056-00015104-00015455": "and add reasons for", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00057-00015456-00015807": "these unaccounted quantities here", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00058-00015808-00016247": "so we used 90 and i'm going to show", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00059-00016247-00016550": "that yep that 90 were consumed", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00060-00016551-00017079": "and that's why", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00061-00017080-00017479": "uh masks same thing", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00062-00017480-00017807": "you know but maybe some of the masks", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00063-00017808-00018175": "we had to waste", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00064-00018176-00018543": "say two of them", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00065-00018544-00019063": "but all the others", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00066-00019064-00019527": "let's say 88 others were used", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00067-00019528-00019911": "so um ah it was warning me there are", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00068-00019912-00019983": "still some", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00069-00019984-00020271": "unaccounted for so you know we say we", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00070-00020272-00020447": "have five masks remaining", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00071-00020448-00021083": "something is still off by 88. let's go", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00072-00021084-00021894": "look", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00073-00021895-00022255": "there we go so there's two reasons those", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00074-00022256-00022422": "masks were used", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00075-00022423-00022686": "the syringes yep they were all used for", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00076-00022687-00022991": "the day", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00077-00022992-00023847": "we consumed all 500", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00078-00023848-00024158": "and those vaccine vials", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00079-00024159-00025183": "same thing", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00080-00025184-00025503": "so now it shows me unaccounted zero", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00081-00025504-00025727": "so i've now accounted for and given", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00082-00025727-00025839": "reasons for", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00083-00025839-00026094": "all these changes in quantities so", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00084-00026095-00026206": "that's optional", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00085-00026207-00026527": "but can help improve the quality of data", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00086-00026527-00026743": "especially when people want timely", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00087-00026744-00027158": "trustworthy data so i'll submit", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00088-00027160-00027423": "this is an optional feature i can add a", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00089-00027424-00027518": "signature", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00090-00027519-00027814": "it does also save what user account i", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00091-00027816-00027958": "was using", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00092-00027960-00028190": "and once it's saved it shows me all the", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00093-00028191-00028399": "lists of products and", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00094-00028400-00028687": "what i have left i could drill in to see", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00095-00028688-00028967": "any products in the history of my usage", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00096-00028968-00029287": "over time so that is the most", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00097-00029288-00029655": "basic openlmis stock management workflow", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00098-00029656-00029758": "just to record", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00099-00029760-00029967": "what are the quantities i have and if i", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00100-00029968-00030087": "want to record", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00101-00030088-00030311": "those reasons what was consumed versus", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00102-00030312-00030462": "what might have been wasted", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00103-00030463-00030862": "lost or damaged or other reasons that", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00104-00030863-00030958": "are configurable", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00105-00030960-00031231": "so that's all it takes to get data", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00106-00031232-00031311": "flowing", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00107-00031312-00031511": "to help build visibility and", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00108-00031512-00031646": "transparency", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00109-00031647-00032031": "and trust also", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00110-00032032-00032174": "there are some more powerful features", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00111-00032175-00032358": "for vaccines that i'm going to show", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00112-00032360-00032783": "so i'll jump over to a laptop here", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00113-00032784-00033111": "and", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00114-00033112-00033327": "in my firefox browser i'm going to log", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00115-00033328-00033439": "in now as", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00116-00033440-00033815": "a warehouse clerk", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00117-00033816-00034143": "and i'm going to show", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00118-00034144-00034471": "how open lmis can track lots expiration", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00119-00034472-00034535": "dates", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00120-00034536-00034879": "and even the vvm status of vaccine vials", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00121-00034880-00035127": "so in a warehouse one of the more", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00122-00035128-00035231": "frequent tasks", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00123-00035232-00035551": "is issuing out vaccines", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00124-00035552-00035895": "so i'll go to issue make an issue and", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00125-00035896-00036127": "in this setup i'm actually dealing with", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00126-00036128-00036430": "a variety of vaccines in my warehouse", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00127-00036431-00036583": "but i'm going to add you know the", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00128-00036584-00036735": "product that i'm shipping out", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00129-00036736-00037071": "the rotavirus vaccine and", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00130-00037072-00037318": "in this case i have lot tracking for", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00131-00037319-00037423": "this product", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00132-00037424-00037639": "so i'm going to ship out some of this", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00133-00037640-00037774": "lot that ends in", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00134-00037775-00038127": "b um yeah we have eight of them left", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00135-00038128-00038462": "and i'm going to issue out all of them", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00136-00038463-00038702": "all these locations and regions are", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00137-00038703-00038830": "configurable", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00138-00038831-00039118": "i'm going to issue out the entire eight", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00139-00039119-00039174": "and", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00140-00039175-00039407": "you can also track vvm status for", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00141-00039408-00039487": "vaccines", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00142-00039488-00039783": "to know okay was this vaccine still", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00143-00039784-00039918": "flagged as good", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00144-00039919-00040199": "i'm shipping these out today and i'll", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00145-00040200-00040311": "click submit so", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00146-00040312-00040623": "i've just issued out my last eight", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00147-00040624-00040927": "of that lot b and i can see", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00148-00040928-00041262": "the status for every single lot and the", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00149-00041263-00041335": "total", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00150-00041336-00041543": "that i still have on hand and for any", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00151-00041544-00041671": "one of these lots", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00152-00041672-00042007": "i can go and view the history of", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00153-00042008-00042327": "when that was used and by whom", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00154-00042328-00042646": "so those are basic", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00155-00042647-00042911": "stock management features that make it", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00156-00042912-00043095": "easy to start tracking vaccines for", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00157-00043096-00043199": "covid", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00158-00043200-00043551": "and in other demo videos we'll also show", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00159-00043552-00043935": "simple report and requisition workflows", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00160-00043936-00044246": "we will show how report and requisition", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00161-00044247-00044390": "can work with stock management", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00162-00044391-00044471": "seamlessly", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00163-00044472-00044662": "the stock management can auto populate", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00164-00044663-00044862": "the requisition to easily create an", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00165-00044863-00045079": "order with the push of a button and we", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00166-00045080-00045239": "also have other demo videos", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00167-00045240-00045471": "showing the cce management and other", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00168-00045472-00045583": "features", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00169-00045584-00045855": "basically open lmis has lots of ways to", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00170-00045856-00045887": "get", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00171-00045888-00046174": "started tracking covid vaccines easily", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00172-00046175-00046399": "with the most important data points and", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00173-00046400-00046471": "then grow", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00174-00046472-00046702": "over time to fit lots of more advanced", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00175-00046703-00047002": "supply chain processes", "T-2dc5vUwcy-00176-00047003-00047303": "thanks"}}]