[{"audio_id": "T-UWBM9wl-I", "text": {"T-UWBM9wl-I-00000-00000056-00000289": "firebugs is a racing video game", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00001-00000290-00000497": "developed by attention to detail and", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00002-00000498-00000713": "published by Sony Computer Entertainment", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00003-00000714-00001364": "exclusively for PlayStation", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00004-00001365-00001884": "topic gameplay", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00005-00001885-00002112": "the game modes include 1 player mode", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00006-00002113-00002360": "where the player can race on 25 tracks", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00007-00002361-00002637": "in five distinct worlds there is 2", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00008-00002638-00002814": "player mode which consists of the same", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00009-00002815-00003144": "basics as in 1 player mode weapons and", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00010-00003145-00003333": "defenses are used to help the player win", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00011-00003334-00003600": "races there are 5 pilots to choose from", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00012-00003601-00003732": "with each having a different background", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00013-00003733-00004343": "from one another", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00014-00004344-00004868": "topic soundtrack", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00015-00004869-00005093": "the game's soundtrack includes music", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00016-00005094-00005366": "from hip-hop group bum funk emcees whose", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00017-00005367-00005771": "songs we are atomic and put yo hands up", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00018-00005772-00006002": "are featured these are of note because", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00019-00006003-00006218": "the album burnin sneakers was not", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00020-00006219-00006436": "released in the UK and so the songs have", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00021-00006437-00006638": "correlation to this game for many UK", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00022-00006639-00007192": "fans", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00023-00007193-00007852": "topic critical reception firebugs", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00024-00007853-00008068": "received positive reviews in the evening", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00025-00008069-00008266": "Chronicle the Birmingham Mail and the", "T-UWBM9wl-I-00026-00008267-00008548": "Waikato Times"}}, {"audio_id": "T_rel1RXoR8", "text": {"T_rel1RXoR8-00000-00015230-00015466": "okay good evening councilors ladies and", "T_rel1RXoR8-00001-00015468-00015641": "gentlemen and welcome to the first", "T_rel1RXoR8-00002-00015641-00015899": "cabinet meeting of the year so we'll go", "T_rel1RXoR8-00003-00015900-00016199": "straight in with apologies for absence", "T_rel1RXoR8-00004-00016200-00016475": "I believe we're all present uh minutes", "T_rel1RXoR8-00005-00016476-00016679": "of the previous meeting I your wishlist", "T_rel1RXoR8-00006-00016680-00016913": "your record on your mover cancer", "T_rel1RXoR8-00007-00016914-00017135": "Pritchard has moved I have a second", "T_rel1RXoR8-00008-00017136-00017393": "cancer Farrell has seconded", "T_rel1RXoR8-00009-00017394-00017603": "all those in favor", "T_rel1RXoR8-00010-00017604-00017800": "okay thank you we'll get a signed copy", "T_rel1RXoR8-00011-00017801-00018058": "of those uh item three decorations of", "T_rel1RXoR8-00012-00018059-00018239": "interest does anybody have any", "T_rel1RXoR8-00013-00018240-00018407": "prejudicial", "T_rel1RXoR8-00014-00018408-00018580": "or pecuniary interest they need to", "T_rel1RXoR8-00015-00018581-00018797": "declare", "T_rel1RXoR8-00016-00018798-00018994": "nope excellent in that case we'll move", "T_rel1RXoR8-00017-00018995-00019253": "to a gender item four which is uh", "T_rel1RXoR8-00018-00019254-00019439": "questions from members of the public I'm", "T_rel1RXoR8-00019-00019440-00019594": "not aware of any questions being", "T_rel1RXoR8-00020-00019595-00019864": "submitted nope okay so we'll move", "T_rel1RXoR8-00021-00019865-00020027": "straight into item five which is matters", "T_rel1RXoR8-00022-00020028-00020272": "referred to Cabinet in accordance with", "T_rel1RXoR8-00023-00020273-00020422": "overview and screwing your procedurals", "T_rel1RXoR8-00024-00020423-00020705": "and we have a report from the chair of", "T_rel1RXoR8-00025-00020706-00020921": "corporate corporate screening committee", "T_rel1RXoR8-00026-00020922-00021121": "uh councilor Jay", "T_rel1RXoR8-00027-00021122-00021358": "thank you very much", "T_rel1RXoR8-00028-00021359-00021580": "um so it's quite a simple report to", "T_rel1RXoR8-00029-00021581-00021743": "update cabinet and to make", "T_rel1RXoR8-00030-00021744-00021994": "recommendations following consideration", "T_rel1RXoR8-00031-00021995-00022144": "of the asset management strategy and", "T_rel1RXoR8-00032-00022145-00022343": "related documentation by the corporate", "T_rel1RXoR8-00033-00022344-00022564": "scrutiny committee meeting on the 8th of", "T_rel1RXoR8-00034-00022565-00022680": "December", "T_rel1RXoR8-00035-00022681-00022847": "2022.", "T_rel1RXoR8-00036-00022848-00023086": "we saw it and received clarifications in", "T_rel1RXoR8-00037-00023087-00023291": "respect of various aspects of the", "T_rel1RXoR8-00038-00023292-00023443": "documentation", "T_rel1RXoR8-00039-00023444-00023800": "and we approved the amount the asset", "T_rel1RXoR8-00040-00023801-00024047": "management strategy and accompanied", "T_rel1RXoR8-00041-00024048-00024197": "um the documentation with eight", "T_rel1RXoR8-00042-00024198-00024430": "recommendations which was set out in the", "T_rel1RXoR8-00043-00024431-00024550": "report", "T_rel1RXoR8-00044-00024551-00024730": "I can of course read them all but I", "T_rel1RXoR8-00045-00024731-00025067": "propose to just uh take them as red and", "T_rel1RXoR8-00046-00025068-00025313": "hand back over to you thank you", "T_rel1RXoR8-00047-00025314-00025469": "okay thank you very much are there any", "T_rel1RXoR8-00048-00025470-00025667": "questions or comments from cabinet", "T_rel1RXoR8-00049-00025668-00025889": "members", "T_rel1RXoR8-00050-00025889-00026020": "nope", "T_rel1RXoR8-00051-00026022-00026218": "in that case as there are eight", "T_rel1RXoR8-00052-00026219-00026477": "recommendations uh what I was going to", "T_rel1RXoR8-00053-00026477-00026729": "suggest was that we take those away as", "T_rel1RXoR8-00054-00026730-00026981": "cabinet and report back on each one", "T_rel1RXoR8-00055-00026982-00027329": "direct to your screening committee uh in", "T_rel1RXoR8-00056-00027330-00027517": "in due time", "T_rel1RXoR8-00057-00027518-00027802": "is everybody happy with that as a", "T_rel1RXoR8-00058-00027804-00028073": "direction of travel on those yep so Rod", "T_rel1RXoR8-00059-00028074-00028289": "pressure seconded all those in favor", "T_rel1RXoR8-00060-00028289-00028445": "okay that's Carriage so thank you very", "T_rel1RXoR8-00061-00028445-00028595": "much and we'll get back to you on each", "T_rel1RXoR8-00062-00028595-00028751": "of those individually as soon as we can", "T_rel1RXoR8-00063-00028752-00029677": "thank you councilor Jay", "T_rel1RXoR8-00064-00029677-00029962": "so that brings us on to a gender item", "T_rel1RXoR8-00065-00029963-00030305": "six of the agenda which is the draft", "T_rel1RXoR8-00066-00030306-00030455": "budget and medium term Financial", "T_rel1RXoR8-00067-00030456-00030851": "strategy uh 2023", "T_rel1RXoR8-00068-00030852-00031307": "to uh 2023-24 so this is a report of my", "T_rel1RXoR8-00069-00031308-00031517": "own uh just waiting for my computer to", "T_rel1RXoR8-00070-00031518-00031817": "catch up so this um this evening we will", "T_rel1RXoR8-00071-00031818-00032081": "consider the draft budget want a better", "T_rel1RXoR8-00072-00032082-00032339": "phrase and the recommendation is that we", "T_rel1RXoR8-00073-00032339-00032518": "approve the package of proposals in", "T_rel1RXoR8-00074-00032519-00032812": "there and we refer these to Joint budget", "T_rel1RXoR8-00075-00032813-00033040": "scrutiny which will take place next", "T_rel1RXoR8-00076-00033041-00033174": "Wednesday", "T_rel1RXoR8-00077-00033175-00033473": "so members of cabinet have been heavily", "T_rel1RXoR8-00078-00033474-00033785": "involved in the uh in the creation of", "T_rel1RXoR8-00079-00033786-00034024": "this of this budget and this medium term", "T_rel1RXoR8-00080-00034025-00034283": "Financial strategy and if members look", "T_rel1RXoR8-00081-00034284-00034571": "on the next page on the uh page 14 of", "T_rel1RXoR8-00082-00034572-00034859": "the document uh the executive summary", "T_rel1RXoR8-00083-00034860-00035152": "the highlights are are explicit in there", "T_rel1RXoR8-00084-00035153-00035479": "a general fund net cost of service of", "T_rel1RXoR8-00085-00035480-00035818": "9.6 million pounds a transfer from", "T_rel1RXoR8-00086-00035819-00036161": "reserves of uh 1.7 million", "T_rel1RXoR8-00087-00036162-00036551": "band D council tax to increase by around", "T_rel1RXoR8-00088-00036552-00037067": "10 pence per week uh HRA sorry housing", "T_rel1RXoR8-00089-00037068-00037324": "revenue account will require around a", "T_rel1RXoR8-00090-00037325-00037583": "million pounds from balances uh to see", "T_rel1RXoR8-00091-00037584-00037883": "at the period uh and in terms of the", "T_rel1RXoR8-00092-00037884-00038171": "general fund we're looking at uh 10.8", "T_rel1RXoR8-00093-00038172-00038507": "million pound spend on Capital and in", "T_rel1RXoR8-00094-00038508-00038783": "the housing accounts we're looking at 38", "T_rel1RXoR8-00095-00038784-00038999": "million pounds worth of spend they are", "T_rel1RXoR8-00096-00039000-00039196": "the highlights uh the report goes into", "T_rel1RXoR8-00097-00039197-00039377": "full details as to all the proposed", "T_rel1RXoR8-00098-00039378-00039730": "polish changes or the other uh", "T_rel1RXoR8-00099-00039731-00039952": "potential changes and impacts on our", "T_rel1RXoR8-00100-00039953-00040145": "income and expenditure that we can", "T_rel1RXoR8-00101-00040146-00040302": "predict over the next few years", "T_rel1RXoR8-00102-00040303-00040571": "obviously we can't see too far into the", "T_rel1RXoR8-00103-00040572-00040751": "future when we're in a volatile markets", "T_rel1RXoR8-00104-00040752-00041015": "at the moment but this is a", "T_rel1RXoR8-00105-00041016-00041273": "this is as accurate as we can get at", "T_rel1RXoR8-00106-00041274-00041524": "this present stage so does anybody have", "T_rel1RXoR8-00107-00041525-00041807": "any questions or comments on the mtfs", "T_rel1RXoR8-00108-00041808-00042190": "before we refer it to scrutiny", "T_rel1RXoR8-00109-00042191-00042521": "no in that case I'll move uh the motion", "T_rel1RXoR8-00110-00042522-00042646": "that's cabinet approved the draft", "T_rel1RXoR8-00111-00042647-00042851": "package of budget proposals including", "T_rel1RXoR8-00112-00042852-00043102": "the proposed policy changes included", "T_rel1RXoR8-00113-00043103-00043445": "within the documents and that we refer", "T_rel1RXoR8-00114-00043446-00043589": "this to Joint British excretion on the", "T_rel1RXoR8-00115-00043590-00043877": "25th of January for those to consider", "T_rel1RXoR8-00116-00043878-00044033": "the budget proposals within the report", "T_rel1RXoR8-00117-00044034-00044224": "do I have a second cancer Pritchard", "T_rel1RXoR8-00118-00044225-00044423": "seconds all those in favor", "T_rel1RXoR8-00119-00044424-00044668": "that is unanimous that is carried thank", "T_rel1RXoR8-00120-00044669-00044801": "you very much", "T_rel1RXoR8-00121-00044802-00045017": "we will now move on to agenda item seven", "T_rel1RXoR8-00122-00045018-00045185": "which is the review of temporary", "T_rel1RXoR8-00123-00045186-00045371": "reserves retained funds and Provisions", "T_rel1RXoR8-00124-00045372-00045868": "and this is councilor Bailey's report", "T_rel1RXoR8-00125-00045869-00046151": "thank you so the purpose of the report", "T_rel1RXoR8-00126-00046152-00046385": "is to advise members on the levels of", "T_rel1RXoR8-00127-00046386-00046540": "reserves and to seek approval to", "T_rel1RXoR8-00128-00046541-00046762": "repurpose unspent reserves following the", "T_rel1RXoR8-00129-00046763-00046937": "recent review by the Executive Director", "T_rel1RXoR8-00130-00046938-00047207": "of Finance the main issues to note are", "T_rel1RXoR8-00131-00047208-00047449": "as detailed in the report reserves are", "T_rel1RXoR8-00132-00047450-00047824": "reviewed robustly in detail in March and", "T_rel1RXoR8-00133-00047825-00048029": "in October for consideration by cabinet", "T_rel1RXoR8-00134-00048030-00048280": "to inform the budget process the report", "T_rel1RXoR8-00135-00048281-00048455": "details reserves which are no longer", "T_rel1RXoR8-00136-00048456-00048611": "required and will be returned to", "T_rel1RXoR8-00137-00048612-00048887": "balances and identifies 50k to be", "T_rel1RXoR8-00138-00048888-00049102": "repurposed to create a new Reserve fund", "T_rel1RXoR8-00139-00049103-00049301": "for the creation of defenses to assist", "T_rel1RXoR8-00140-00049302-00049589": "in deterring illegal incumbents any", "T_rel1RXoR8-00141-00049590-00049799": "balances returned to help to reduce the", "T_rel1RXoR8-00142-00049800-00050117": "current predicted deficit on the mtfs so", "T_rel1RXoR8-00143-00050118-00050368": "the recommendations to approve as", "T_rel1RXoR8-00144-00050369-00050549": "detailed in the report and I'm happy to", "T_rel1RXoR8-00145-00050550-00050818": "move them thank you", "T_rel1RXoR8-00146-00050819-00051023": "thank you Castle Bailey are there any", "T_rel1RXoR8-00147-00051024-00051155": "questions or comments from cabinet", "T_rel1RXoR8-00148-00051156-00051473": "members", "T_rel1RXoR8-00149-00051474-00051646": "no I'd just like to say I'm quite", "T_rel1RXoR8-00150-00051647-00051904": "pleased with the uh with the creation of", "T_rel1RXoR8-00151-00051905-00052132": "the new Reserve to fund juventuses", "T_rel1RXoR8-00152-00052133-00052408": "against illegal encampments we've been", "T_rel1RXoR8-00153-00052409-00052541": "blighted by those over the last couple", "T_rel1RXoR8-00154-00052541-00052775": "of years so uh having this additional", "T_rel1RXoR8-00155-00052776-00052985": "money available uh", "T_rel1RXoR8-00156-00052986-00053237": "to to do something reactively I think uh", "T_rel1RXoR8-00157-00053238-00053471": "I think is a positive move and well done", "T_rel1RXoR8-00158-00053472-00053704": "to all those involved in organizing that", "T_rel1RXoR8-00159-00053705-00053915": "if there are no further questions or", "T_rel1RXoR8-00160-00053916-00054191": "comments uh Council Bailey has moved", "T_rel1RXoR8-00161-00054191-00054503": "those do I have a secondary", "T_rel1RXoR8-00162-00054504-00054766": "cancel it I can't see you're all leaning", "T_rel1RXoR8-00163-00054767-00054953": "forward councilor Clements has seconded", "T_rel1RXoR8-00164-00054954-00055187": "those all those in favor", "T_rel1RXoR8-00165-00055188-00055415": "okay that is carried as well thank you", "T_rel1RXoR8-00166-00055416-00055523": "very much", "T_rel1RXoR8-00167-00055524-00055853": "and that brings us on to agenda item", "T_rel1RXoR8-00168-00055854-00056092": "eight which is the business rates income", "T_rel1RXoR8-00169-00056094-00056926": "forecast again councilor Bailey", "T_rel1RXoR8-00170-00056927-00057449": "3 and 23 24 as included within the nndr1", "T_rel1RXoR8-00171-00057450-00057809": "return to dlhuhc which will also inform", "T_rel1RXoR8-00172-00057810-00057971": "the councils and it's", "T_rel1RXoR8-00173-00057972-00058354": "receptors budget projections for 23.24", "T_rel1RXoR8-00174-00058355-00058492": "there is always an element of", "T_rel1RXoR8-00175-00058494-00058637": "uncertainty with business rates", "T_rel1RXoR8-00176-00058638-00058847": "forecasting due to the demand LED nature", "T_rel1RXoR8-00177-00058848-00059087": "of the appeals process especially", "T_rel1RXoR8-00178-00059088-00059230": "following the national business rates", "T_rel1RXoR8-00179-00059232-00059519": "revaluation exercise which means that", "T_rel1RXoR8-00180-00059520-00059692": "while we're asking cabinet to approve", "T_rel1RXoR8-00181-00059694-00059866": "the forecast it is subject to any", "T_rel1RXoR8-00182-00059867-00060119": "changes arising before the 31st of", "T_rel1RXoR8-00183-00060120-00060353": "January where any developments before", "T_rel1RXoR8-00184-00060354-00060611": "then should material amendments be", "T_rel1RXoR8-00185-00060612-00060892": "required to the forecast nndr1 cabinet", "T_rel1RXoR8-00186-00060894-00061054": "are recommended to authorize the", "T_rel1RXoR8-00187-00061055-00061247": "Executive Director of Finance in", "T_rel1RXoR8-00188-00061248-00061379": "consultation with the leader of the", "T_rel1RXoR8-00189-00061379-00061600": "council to make such required amendments", "T_rel1RXoR8-00190-00061601-00061763": "as necessary", "T_rel1RXoR8-00191-00061764-00062044": "the estimated net yield of Thirteen five", "T_rel1RXoR8-00192-00062045-00062273": "eight one two seven one retained by the", "T_rel1RXoR8-00193-00062274-00062387": "council", "T_rel1RXoR8-00194-00062388-00062699": "is held within the collection fund this", "T_rel1RXoR8-00195-00062700-00062903": "is reduced by the Tariff payable of 10", "T_rel1RXoR8-00196-00062904-00063041": "million six hundred and eighty six", "T_rel1RXoR8-00197-00063041-00063323": "thousand eight hundred and fifty in 2023", "T_rel1RXoR8-00198-00063324-00063629": "and 24 and the 50 levy on business rates", "T_rel1RXoR8-00199-00063629-00063850": "in excess of the government assessed", "T_rel1RXoR8-00200-00063851-00064025": "Baseline", "T_rel1RXoR8-00201-00064026-00064516": "a net increase in funding of 634 539 is", "T_rel1RXoR8-00202-00064517-00064811": "reported when compared to the draft mtfs", "T_rel1RXoR8-00203-00064812-00064961": "forecast", "T_rel1RXoR8-00204-00064962-00065476": "increased S31 Grant income of 2 483 923", "T_rel1RXoR8-00205-00065477-00065741": "pounds is reported offset by the", "T_rel1RXoR8-00206-00065742-00065897": "associated reduced collectible business", "T_rel1RXoR8-00207-00065898-00066161": "rates income of one million two hundred", "T_rel1RXoR8-00208-00066162-00066293": "and fifteen thousand nine hundred and", "T_rel1RXoR8-00209-00066294-00066485": "twenty nine and an increased Levy", "T_rel1RXoR8-00210-00066486-00066965": "payment of 633 997 pounds in addition a", "T_rel1RXoR8-00211-00066966-00067294": "deficit of 260 300 is forecast for", "T_rel1RXoR8-00212-00067295-00067456": "twenty twenty three", "T_rel1RXoR8-00213-00067457-00067888": "sorry 20 22 23 which is 539 lower than", "T_rel1RXoR8-00214-00067889-00068182": "the mtfs forecast and I'm happy to move", "T_rel1RXoR8-00215-00068183-00068423": "thank you", "T_rel1RXoR8-00216-00068424-00068650": "thank you thank you councilor Bailey", "T_rel1RXoR8-00217-00068651-00068831": "does anybody have any questions or", "T_rel1RXoR8-00218-00068832-00069149": "comments on this report", "T_rel1RXoR8-00219-00069150-00069419": "no so you've moved those do I have a", "T_rel1RXoR8-00220-00069420-00069526": "seconder", "T_rel1RXoR8-00221-00069527-00069713": "councilor Pritchard has seconded all", "T_rel1RXoR8-00222-00069714-00069899": "those in favor", "T_rel1RXoR8-00223-00069900-00070150": "again unanimous so that is carried thank", "T_rel1RXoR8-00224-00070151-00070282": "you very much", "T_rel1RXoR8-00225-00070283-00070619": "and that brings me on to a gender item", "T_rel1RXoR8-00226-00070620-00070871": "nine which is the exclusion of press of", "T_rel1RXoR8-00227-00070872-00071087": "public so in accordance with the", "T_rel1RXoR8-00228-00071088-00071231": "provisions of the local authorities", "T_rel1RXoR8-00229-00071232-00071423": "executive Arrangements meetings access", "T_rel1RXoR8-00230-00071424-00071776": "to information England regulation 2012", "T_rel1RXoR8-00231-00071777-00072215": "and section 100 A4 of the local at 1972", "T_rel1RXoR8-00232-00072216-00072413": "the present public be excluded for the", "T_rel1RXoR8-00233-00072414-00072593": "meeting during the consideration of the", "T_rel1RXoR8-00234-00072594-00072713": "following business on the grounds this", "T_rel1RXoR8-00235-00072714-00072971": "involves the likely disclosure of exempt", "T_rel1RXoR8-00236-00072972-00073163": "information as defined in paragraph", "T_rel1RXoR8-00237-00073164-00073426": "three of part one of the schedule 12a of", "T_rel1RXoR8-00238-00073427-00073565": "the Act and the public interest in", "T_rel1RXoR8-00239-00073566-00073715": "withholding the information outweighs", "T_rel1RXoR8-00240-00073716-00073876": "the public interest in disclosing the", "T_rel1RXoR8-00241-00073877-00074093": "information to the public ISO move", "T_rel1RXoR8-00242-00074094-00074297": "as I pushed out seconds all those in", "T_rel1RXoR8-00243-00074298-00074399": "favor", "T_rel1RXoR8-00244-00074400-00074650": "versus carried so thank you very much if", "T_rel1RXoR8-00245-00074651-00074776": "any members of the public could leave", "T_rel1RXoR8-00246-00074777-00075145": "and if we could turn the webcast off"}}, {"audio_id": "T_FuOvlziJY", "text": {"T_FuOvlziJY-00000-00000071-00000423": "hi recording and live transcript", "T_FuOvlziJY-00001-00000424-00000567": "thank you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00002-00000568-00000815": "uh so if if you're interested in anybody", "T_FuOvlziJY-00003-00000816-00001127": "interested in in facilitating next week", "T_FuOvlziJY-00004-00001128-00001262": "question", "T_FuOvlziJY-00005-00001263-00001478": "anybody", "T_FuOvlziJY-00006-00001479-00001614": "it's usually pretty straightforward", "T_FuOvlziJY-00007-00001616-00001798": "again we offer support", "T_FuOvlziJY-00008-00001800-00001951": "it's a good way to get involved in the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00009-00001952-00002063": "project", "T_FuOvlziJY-00010-00002064-00002326": "or this working group", "T_FuOvlziJY-00011-00002327-00002575": "and we have a guide to help you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00012-00002576-00002815": "like a little page of documentation on", "T_FuOvlziJY-00013-00002816-00003079": "how to facilitate", "T_FuOvlziJY-00014-00003080-00003559": "very nice", "T_FuOvlziJY-00015-00003560-00003790": "i'm a professor so i can just live with", "T_FuOvlziJY-00016-00003792-00004335": "awkward silence for a long", "T_FuOvlziJY-00017-00004336-00004559": "i'm not time if you can hear me but i", "T_FuOvlziJY-00018-00004560-00004670": "can do it", "T_FuOvlziJY-00019-00004671-00005279": "excellent thank you christy", "T_FuOvlziJY-00020-00005280-00005479": "it's about your name there we go got it", "T_FuOvlziJY-00021-00005480-00005647": "and christy like i said i can i'll help", "T_FuOvlziJY-00022-00005648-00005854": "with um like agenda setting and all that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00023-00005855-00006054": "kind of stuff like if you have there's", "T_FuOvlziJY-00024-00006055-00006183": "things that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00025-00006184-00006414": "that maybe we should talk about", "T_FuOvlziJY-00026-00006415-00006606": "all right well great um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00027-00006608-00006783": "see some some new people on the call so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00028-00006784-00006959": "i'd just like to say welcome to to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00029-00006959-00007295": "newcomers it's great to have you here", "T_FuOvlziJY-00030-00007295-00007431": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00031-00007431-00007646": "feel free to speak up feel free to just", "T_FuOvlziJY-00032-00007647-00007751": "listen in", "T_FuOvlziJY-00033-00007752-00007903": "you can have your camera on you can have", "T_FuOvlziJY-00034-00007904-00008199": "your camera off um all sorts of options", "T_FuOvlziJY-00035-00008200-00008510": "for you for this this dei meeting", "T_FuOvlziJY-00036-00008511-00008759": "all right so let's um last time we", "T_FuOvlziJY-00037-00008760-00008967": "didn't really get to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00038-00008968-00009359": "uh pull requests and our issues so let's", "T_FuOvlziJY-00039-00009360-00009503": "why don't we take a look at those i'll", "T_FuOvlziJY-00040-00009504-00010014": "share my screen here", "T_FuOvlziJY-00041-00010015-00010231": "all right so we can take a look at pull", "T_FuOvlziJY-00042-00010232-00010406": "requests and see if we have anything", "T_FuOvlziJY-00043-00010407-00010623": "that really requires attention i don't", "T_FuOvlziJY-00044-00010624-00010967": "have a huge agenda today so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00045-00010968-00011010": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00046-00011011-00011135": "[Music]", "T_FuOvlziJY-00047-00011136-00011303": "code of conduct", "T_FuOvlziJY-00048-00011304-00011583": "and event demographics and i think we", "T_FuOvlziJY-00049-00011584-00011983": "had", "T_FuOvlziJY-00050-00011984-00012142": "kevin was also going to take a look at", "T_FuOvlziJY-00051-00012143-00012342": "time inclusion for virtual events like", "T_FuOvlziJY-00052-00012343-00012551": "this is under pull requests and sean was", "T_FuOvlziJY-00053-00012552-00012655": "going to take a look at family", "T_FuOvlziJY-00054-00012656-00012879": "friendliness", "T_FuOvlziJY-00055-00012880-00013166": "we merged we merged time inclusion for", "T_FuOvlziJY-00056-00013168-00013479": "uh events uh last week", "T_FuOvlziJY-00057-00013480-00013751": "uh code of conduct is my current action", "T_FuOvlziJY-00058-00013752-00013838": "item", "T_FuOvlziJY-00059-00013840-00014015": "okay uh the pull request that there", "T_FuOvlziJY-00060-00014016-00014279": "that's there currently is only a", "T_FuOvlziJY-00061-00014280-00014583": "only partially resolves the uh review it", "T_FuOvlziJY-00062-00014584-00014775": "uh it handles a formatting issue with", "T_FuOvlziJY-00063-00014776-00014927": "the uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00064-00014928-00015175": "uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00065-00015176-00015358": "bullet points", "T_FuOvlziJY-00066-00015359-00015503": "so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00067-00015504-00015830": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00068-00015831-00016111": "so kevin d is it do you think we should", "T_FuOvlziJY-00069-00016112-00016319": "merge this one just to take care of that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00070-00016319-00016527": "and then do another one", "T_FuOvlziJY-00071-00016528-00016694": "for content stuff or", "T_FuOvlziJY-00072-00016695-00016871": "uh we could i mean this this just", "T_FuOvlziJY-00073-00016872-00017158": "resolves a formatting issue so it uh it", "T_FuOvlziJY-00074-00017159-00017375": "doesn't handle any of the content i do", "T_FuOvlziJY-00075-00017376-00017607": "have an action item to do the content", "T_FuOvlziJY-00076-00017608-00017894": "okay uh i don't think there would be", "T_FuOvlziJY-00077-00017895-00018103": "i don't think there's any issue with", "T_FuOvlziJY-00078-00018104-00018486": "with merging this now okay uh however", "T_FuOvlziJY-00079-00018487-00018767": "uh i think in the past we about about", "T_FuOvlziJY-00080-00018768-00018958": "the process we had we had stated some", "T_FuOvlziJY-00081-00018959-00019135": "desire to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00082-00019136-00019391": "kind of do it all together", "T_FuOvlziJY-00083-00019392-00019679": "but it doesn't matter to me", "T_FuOvlziJY-00084-00019680-00020094": "thoughts from anybody else", "T_FuOvlziJY-00085-00020095-00020183": "why don't we", "T_FuOvlziJY-00086-00020184-00020375": "let's go my action item to the next uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00087-00020376-00020622": "meeting i will take care of that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00088-00020623-00020711": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00089-00020712-00020943": "um kevin let for that point then we'll", "T_FuOvlziJY-00090-00020944-00021175": "just keep this open you know what i mean", "T_FuOvlziJY-00091-00021176-00021686": "and you can work off of that one", "T_FuOvlziJY-00092-00021687-00021903": "so sorry i missed that so the time", "T_FuOvlziJY-00093-00021904-00022094": "inclusion for virtual events was merged", "T_FuOvlziJY-00094-00022095-00022558": "into what", "T_FuOvlziJY-00095-00022559-00022911": "uh the the change request was accepted", "T_FuOvlziJY-00096-00022912-00023183": "oh oh it's murdered it was done", "T_FuOvlziJY-00097-00023184-00023519": "sorry that merged into something else", "T_FuOvlziJY-00098-00023520-00023735": "okay yeah so that one actually has been", "T_FuOvlziJY-00099-00023736-00024007": "reviewed uh okay we we should have made", "T_FuOvlziJY-00100-00024008-00024303": "a note of that in the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00101-00024304-00024478": "minute uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00102-00024479-00024663": "well it should have been we should have", "T_FuOvlziJY-00103-00024664-00024903": "made a note of that in the uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00104-00024904-00025014": "the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00105-00025015-00025119": "uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00106-00025120-00025311": "table as well the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00107-00025312-00025622": "metrics table yeah we can do that uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00108-00025623-00025887": "and then the other action item on that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00109-00025888-00026270": "is that we needed to let the translation", "T_FuOvlziJY-00110-00026272-00026535": "people know that that one changed", "T_FuOvlziJY-00111-00026536-00026614": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00112-00026616-00026846": "uh and that one might actually this is", "T_FuOvlziJY-00113-00026847-00027031": "updated we're good", "T_FuOvlziJY-00114-00027032-00027151": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00115-00027152-00027343": "at least here anyway", "T_FuOvlziJY-00116-00027344-00027823": "it's a remark", "T_FuOvlziJY-00117-00027824-00027902": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00118-00027904-00028062": "so we do need to let the translation", "T_FuOvlziJY-00119-00028063-00028302": "people know but i don't know what the we", "T_FuOvlziJY-00120-00028304-00028455": "haven't really talked about that process", "T_FuOvlziJY-00121-00028456-00028639": "do we want to do i want to let them know", "T_FuOvlziJY-00122-00028639-00028855": "each time one gets done or do we want to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00123-00028856-00029102": "let them know after the process is", "T_FuOvlziJY-00124-00029104-00029327": "completed it's a good question", "T_FuOvlziJY-00125-00029327-00029470": "yeah", "T_FuOvlziJY-00126-00029472-00029695": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00127-00029695-00029927": "i guess my my initial thought was just", "T_FuOvlziJY-00128-00029927-00030095": "one at a time but now that when you say", "T_FuOvlziJY-00129-00030095-00030446": "it like maybe it's a little bit more uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00130-00030447-00030767": "uh like thoughtful to just do one p or", "T_FuOvlziJY-00131-00030768-00030895": "one issue", "T_FuOvlziJY-00132-00030895-00031087": "that says here are the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00133-00031088-00031227": "menu", "T_FuOvlziJY-00134-00031229-00031462": "[Applause]", "T_FuOvlziJY-00135-00031463-00031670": "here are the metrics that need", "T_FuOvlziJY-00136-00031672-00031895": "to be revisited i think that was the two", "T_FuOvlziJY-00137-00031895-00032135": "options you were kind of proposing", "T_FuOvlziJY-00138-00032136-00032318": "yeah and there's there's a little bit of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00139-00032319-00032567": "distinction too with whether some of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00140-00032568-00032767": "these metrics that we are revisiting may", "T_FuOvlziJY-00141-00032768-00032999": "be sent back to review", "T_FuOvlziJY-00142-00033000-00033151": "so that would be a little bit different", "T_FuOvlziJY-00143-00033152-00033439": "as well okay so i", "T_FuOvlziJY-00144-00033440-00033559": "don't know what other people's thoughts", "T_FuOvlziJY-00145-00033560-00033759": "are but at least my inclination is for", "T_FuOvlziJY-00146-00033760-00033983": "the metrics", "T_FuOvlziJY-00147-00033984-00036118": "that are not", "T_FuOvlziJY-00148-00036119-00036483": "uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00149-00036484-00036695": "once i don't know something something", "T_FuOvlziJY-00150-00036696-00036839": "like that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00151-00036840-00036951": "yeah", "T_FuOvlziJY-00152-00036952-00037439": "and then metrics", "T_FuOvlziJY-00153-00037440-00037639": "that are going", "T_FuOvlziJY-00154-00037640-00037718": "back", "T_FuOvlziJY-00155-00037719-00038007": "under review", "T_FuOvlziJY-00156-00038008-00038302": "a single issue", "T_FuOvlziJY-00157-00038303-00038702": "per metric", "T_FuOvlziJY-00158-00038703-00039143": "i like it okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00159-00039144-00039527": "so we should probably then like for for", "T_FuOvlziJY-00160-00039528-00039735": "our own", "T_FuOvlziJY-00161-00039736-00040015": "well-being", "T_FuOvlziJY-00162-00040016-00040151": "probably", "T_FuOvlziJY-00163-00040152-00040430": "we need to track", "T_FuOvlziJY-00164-00040431-00040702": "what we'll be in you're muted kevin but", "T_FuOvlziJY-00165-00040703-00040943": "we needed to track", "T_FuOvlziJY-00166-00040944-00041167": "like all of the metrics that would be in", "T_FuOvlziJY-00167-00041168-00041343": "that one issue", "T_FuOvlziJY-00168-00041344-00041479": "so we should be tracking that in the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00169-00041480-00041599": "table", "T_FuOvlziJY-00170-00041600-00042055": "so we can do that so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00171-00042056-00042295": "so this would be like maybe a remark", "T_FuOvlziJY-00172-00042296-00042455": "could be", "T_FuOvlziJY-00173-00042456-00042815": "included in", "T_FuOvlziJY-00174-00042816-00042852": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00175-00042853-00042990": "[Music]", "T_FuOvlziJY-00176-00042991-00043302": "what should we call it not review", "T_FuOvlziJY-00177-00043303-00043630": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00178-00043631-00043727": "is there", "T_FuOvlziJY-00179-00043728-00043887": "is there some way we could just mark", "T_FuOvlziJY-00180-00043888-00044079": "that date of last review", "T_FuOvlziJY-00181-00044080-00044383": "like put a t there", "T_FuOvlziJY-00182-00044384-00044543": "what would that mean", "T_FuOvlziJY-00183-00044544-00045118": "translate oh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00184-00045119-00045152": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00185-00045153-00045279": "[Music]", "T_FuOvlziJY-00186-00045280-00045511": "or something along those lines just to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00187-00045512-00047223": "make it super easy", "T_FuOvlziJY-00188-00047224-00047327": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00189-00047328-00047518": "so basically at this point", "T_FuOvlziJY-00190-00047519-00047783": "the way i would read this is these three", "T_FuOvlziJY-00191-00047784-00048079": "metrics and i think only those three", "T_FuOvlziJY-00192-00048080-00048279": "at this point", "T_FuOvlziJY-00193-00048280-00048574": "would be in a single issue", "T_FuOvlziJY-00194-00048575-00048711": "given to the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00195-00048712-00048958": "translation or put into the translation", "T_FuOvlziJY-00196-00048959-00049086": "repo", "T_FuOvlziJY-00197-00049087-00049367": "that says time inclusion or i'm sorry", "T_FuOvlziJY-00198-00049368-00049671": "inclusive experience at event has been", "T_FuOvlziJY-00199-00049672-00049855": "minorly modified", "T_FuOvlziJY-00200-00049856-00050086": "please see changes same for this and", "T_FuOvlziJY-00201-00050087-00050483": "same for this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00202-00050484-00050662": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00203-00050663-00050783": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00204-00050784-00051463": "any other thoughts on that from people", "T_FuOvlziJY-00205-00051464-00051614": "so just so people know", "T_FuOvlziJY-00206-00051615-00051807": "basically again we're", "T_FuOvlziJY-00207-00051808-00052079": "the green rows here represent released", "T_FuOvlziJY-00208-00052079-00052287": "chaos metrics", "T_FuOvlziJY-00209-00052288-00052582": "and some of these metrics are pretty old", "T_FuOvlziJY-00210-00052583-00052750": "meaning like a couple years old and", "T_FuOvlziJY-00211-00052751-00052942": "we're spending time", "T_FuOvlziJY-00212-00052944-00053150": "really during the summer", "T_FuOvlziJY-00213-00053151-00053230": "to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00214-00053232-00053479": "review some of those older metrics and", "T_FuOvlziJY-00215-00053479-00053687": "so how this reads is", "T_FuOvlziJY-00216-00053688-00053903": "inclusive experience that event has been", "T_FuOvlziJY-00217-00053904-00054135": "reviewed and any of those suggested", "T_FuOvlziJY-00218-00054136-00054526": "changes have been merged into the metric", "T_FuOvlziJY-00219-00054527-00054671": "we just need to make sure that any of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00220-00054672-00055038": "those changes are now also translated", "T_FuOvlziJY-00221-00055039-00055254": "into chinese", "T_FuOvlziJY-00222-00055255-00055550": "all right good thank you kevin", "T_FuOvlziJY-00223-00055551-00055775": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00224-00055776-00056230": "i need to make sure", "T_FuOvlziJY-00225-00056232-00056942": "i need to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00226-00056944-00057247": "right", "T_FuOvlziJY-00227-00057248-00057342": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00228-00057344-00057487": "um and then sean you said you were going", "T_FuOvlziJY-00229-00057488-00057630": "to take a look at family friendliness", "T_FuOvlziJY-00230-00057632-00057823": "for me yeah yeah i made a note in my", "T_FuOvlziJY-00231-00057824-00058199": "planner this time okay great thank you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00232-00058200-00058471": "all right uh let's any other comments on", "T_FuOvlziJY-00233-00058472-00059759": "any let's do we have any other prs", "T_FuOvlziJY-00234-00059760-00060063": "where's my brain oh there it is", "T_FuOvlziJY-00235-00060064-00061087": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00236-00061088-00061430": "did we look at this one last time", "T_FuOvlziJY-00237-00061432-00062015": "an issue template", "T_FuOvlziJY-00238-00062016-00062294": "uh so the this this file was edited in", "T_FuOvlziJY-00239-00062295-00062366": "the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00240-00062367-00062623": "value working group", "T_FuOvlziJY-00241-00062624-00062759": "uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00242-00062760-00062959": "and the changes were reviewed", "T_FuOvlziJY-00243-00062960-00063166": "so i could replace it right now if you'd", "T_FuOvlziJY-00244-00063167-00063311": "like", "T_FuOvlziJY-00245-00063312-00063447": "uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00246-00063448-00063630": "however i wasn't sure on that process so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00247-00063632-00063703": "we", "T_FuOvlziJY-00248-00063704-00064006": "we were in the uh in the community repo", "T_FuOvlziJY-00249-00064007-00064263": "we were gonna add these templates to the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00250-00064264-00064471": "uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00251-00064472-00064566": "there", "T_FuOvlziJY-00252-00064567-00064806": "yeah as that as that single point of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00253-00064807-00064942": "truth", "T_FuOvlziJY-00254-00064944-00065142": "uh and then at that point we either need", "T_FuOvlziJY-00255-00065144-00065326": "to go and", "T_FuOvlziJY-00256-00065327-00065438": "uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00257-00065439-00065638": "copy it from there into all of the repos", "T_FuOvlziJY-00258-00065639-00065887": "or ask each of the working groups to uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00259-00065888-00066167": "to update it go grab it uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00260-00066168-00066303": "it's not a", "T_FuOvlziJY-00261-00066304-00066438": "it wouldn't be terribly difficult to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00262-00066439-00066615": "just go through and make all the changes", "T_FuOvlziJY-00263-00066616-00066750": "ourselves", "T_FuOvlziJY-00264-00066751-00066967": "uh if that's the case we could just i", "T_FuOvlziJY-00265-00066968-00067294": "could just take that uh i think the uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00266-00067295-00067559": "the template that's in value right now", "T_FuOvlziJY-00267-00067560-00067838": "is the is the one that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00268-00067839-00068038": "uh is the most up-to-date", "T_FuOvlziJY-00269-00068039-00068159": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00270-00068160-00068382": "and so this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00271-00068383-00068487": "template", "T_FuOvlziJY-00272-00068488-00068567": "is", "T_FuOvlziJY-00273-00068568-00068863": "this is a pr i'm not even really sure", "T_FuOvlziJY-00274-00068864-00069038": "what this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00275-00069039-00069231": "it's a pr against an old template so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00276-00069232-00069511": "like we should probably just close this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00277-00069512-00069711": "pr without merging", "T_FuOvlziJY-00278-00069712-00069911": "oh i'm sorry yeah i didn't", "T_FuOvlziJY-00279-00069912-00070111": "oh it was this the this was the pr that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00280-00070112-00070294": "uh i'm sorry i thought you were i", "T_FuOvlziJY-00281-00070295-00070591": "thought you were looking at the uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00282-00070592-00070671": "uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00283-00070672-00070791": "i didn't realize you were looking at pr", "T_FuOvlziJY-00284-00070792-00070919": "i thought you were reading that off of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00285-00070920-00071119": "the uh no", "T_FuOvlziJY-00286-00071120-00071335": "the meeting minutes", "T_FuOvlziJY-00287-00071336-00071519": "so in the media minutes there's there's", "T_FuOvlziJY-00288-00071520-00071775": "a line about the template as well okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00289-00071776-00071959": "well this one this one this is a pr that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00290-00071960-00072167": "has a bunch going on in it anyway so it", "T_FuOvlziJY-00291-00072168-00072406": "has metrics release", "T_FuOvlziJY-00292-00072407-00072806": "candidate", "T_FuOvlziJY-00293-00072807-00073223": "uh so i would i would say no on", "T_FuOvlziJY-00294-00073224-00073406": "accepting this pull request well it's", "T_FuOvlziJY-00295-00073407-00073606": "got a couple things too i don't", "T_FuOvlziJY-00296-00073607-00073815": "normally from a pull request perspective", "T_FuOvlziJY-00297-00073816-00074126": "i only like it against one", "T_FuOvlziJY-00298-00074127-00074806": "markdown you know what i mean", "T_FuOvlziJY-00299-00074807-00074919": "uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00300-00074920-00075135": "so so ideally this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00301-00075136-00075391": "if once this uh once this template is in", "T_FuOvlziJY-00302-00075392-00075511": "community", "T_FuOvlziJY-00303-00075512-00075687": "i mean ideally that's where that pull", "T_FuOvlziJY-00304-00075688-00075926": "request would occur for edits of this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00305-00075927-00077015": "sort", "T_FuOvlziJY-00306-00077016-00077231": "okay so i had made a request a couple", "T_FuOvlziJY-00307-00077232-00077382": "weeks ago to break it into three", "T_FuOvlziJY-00308-00077383-00077606": "different pr's this is there were kind", "T_FuOvlziJY-00309-00077607-00077791": "of like two things going on here one is", "T_FuOvlziJY-00310-00077792-00078015": "the template update which is what you're", "T_FuOvlziJY-00311-00078016-00078159": "talking about kevin", "T_FuOvlziJY-00312-00078160-00078294": "and i don't think we should merge it for", "T_FuOvlziJY-00313-00078295-00078455": "that reason", "T_FuOvlziJY-00314-00078456-00078679": "alone but then there's also this three", "T_FuOvlziJY-00315-00078680-00078806": "pr's", "T_FuOvlziJY-00316-00078807-00079271": "it's kind of like three pr's into one", "T_FuOvlziJY-00317-00079272-00079415": "is there anything in there that needs to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00318-00079416-00079631": "be done that we should maybe that that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00319-00079632-00079926": "we absolutely need to maybe pull out and", "T_FuOvlziJY-00320-00079927-00080079": "put in the pulley against ourselves", "T_FuOvlziJY-00321-00080080-00080191": "there was", "T_FuOvlziJY-00322-00080192-00080759": "let's see provide the github issue link", "T_FuOvlziJY-00323-00080760-00081303": "on the revising metric template", "T_FuOvlziJY-00324-00081304-00081591": "and it was changed to provide the name", "T_FuOvlziJY-00325-00081592-00081767": "of the metric", "T_FuOvlziJY-00326-00081768-00082047": "and the website link", "T_FuOvlziJY-00327-00082048-00082255": "yeah so the the actual actually the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00328-00082256-00082415": "github issue link is the one that we", "T_FuOvlziJY-00329-00082416-00082582": "want yeah", "T_FuOvlziJY-00330-00082583-00082759": "so that change is actually that change", "T_FuOvlziJY-00331-00082760-00082871": "is bad", "T_FuOvlziJY-00332-00082872-00082975": "so then", "T_FuOvlziJY-00333-00082976-00083238": "this is good but just updating copyright", "T_FuOvlziJY-00334-00083239-00083518": "stuff but yeah", "T_FuOvlziJY-00335-00083519-00083775": "and then this i'm not sure oh it's", "T_FuOvlziJY-00336-00083776-00084071": "removal", "T_FuOvlziJY-00337-00084072-00084415": "so this is a this is a removal of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00338-00084416-00084518": "this is like", "T_FuOvlziJY-00339-00084519-00084799": "template text yeah that's template text", "T_FuOvlziJY-00340-00084800-00084935": "yeah", "T_FuOvlziJY-00341-00084936-00085047": "so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00342-00085048-00085615": "and this is in event accessibility", "T_FuOvlziJY-00343-00085616-00085775": "which is going to go through", "T_FuOvlziJY-00344-00085776-00085943": "it'll go through the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00345-00085944-00086111": "revision process", "T_FuOvlziJY-00346-00086112-00086431": "at one point okay maybe we can just", "T_FuOvlziJY-00347-00086432-00086671": "if maybe we can create the issue right", "T_FuOvlziJY-00348-00086672-00087038": "now for event accessibility yeah update", "T_FuOvlziJY-00349-00087039-00089135": "and", "T_FuOvlziJY-00350-00089136-00089479": "right okay and then also", "T_FuOvlziJY-00351-00089480-00090006": "just overall update", "T_FuOvlziJY-00352-00090007-00090150": "you know what i mean", "T_FuOvlziJY-00353-00090151-00090335": "but but we want to we want to send it", "T_FuOvlziJY-00354-00090336-00090479": "through the revision process completely", "T_FuOvlziJY-00355-00090480-00090559": "right", "T_FuOvlziJY-00356-00090560-00090838": "the event accessibility yeah", "T_FuOvlziJY-00357-00090839-00091055": "probably so here it is yeah i mean it's", "T_FuOvlziJY-00358-00091056-00091191": "going to go through anyway so it's one", "T_FuOvlziJY-00359-00091192-00091318": "of the top ones we might as well just", "T_FuOvlziJY-00360-00091319-00091526": "make that uh yeah make it an action item", "T_FuOvlziJY-00361-00091527-00091862": "to send that one through revision", "T_FuOvlziJY-00362-00091863-00092118": "well and i'm doing dei stuff too so i i", "T_FuOvlziJY-00363-00092119-00092191": "was", "T_FuOvlziJY-00364-00092192-00092359": "planning on getting back to reviewing", "T_FuOvlziJY-00365-00092360-00092511": "these now that we've been through a few", "T_FuOvlziJY-00366-00092512-00092806": "so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00367-00092807-00093038": "okay so i'll take a i'll go with that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00368-00093039-00093223": "sounds good", "T_FuOvlziJY-00369-00093224-00093623": "all right um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00370-00093624-00094079": "so i'm going to close this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00371-00094080-00096231": "whoops", "T_FuOvlziJY-00372-00096232-00097518": "don't", "T_FuOvlziJY-00373-00097519-00098847": "so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00374-00098848-00099207": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00375-00099208-00099482": "[Music]", "T_FuOvlziJY-00376-00099483-00099750": "alrighty then", "T_FuOvlziJY-00377-00099751-00100631": "event demographic changes", "T_FuOvlziJY-00378-00100632-00100918": "so we're just doing", "T_FuOvlziJY-00379-00100919-00101159": "that was event no we just did event", "T_FuOvlziJY-00380-00101160-00101911": "accessibility okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00381-00101912-00102055": "so this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00382-00102056-00102454": "would be", "T_FuOvlziJY-00383-00102455-00102663": "so this is one that has an open issue", "T_FuOvlziJY-00384-00102664-00102902": "associated with it so i had taken a look", "T_FuOvlziJY-00385-00102903-00103682": "at that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00386-00103683-00104015": "one you know what i mean like i had", "T_FuOvlziJY-00387-00104016-00104430": "there was this issue", "T_FuOvlziJY-00388-00104431-00104534": "does it", "T_FuOvlziJY-00389-00104535-00104782": "well does it solve all the requested", "T_FuOvlziJY-00390-00104783-00105095": "issues we don't know", "T_FuOvlziJY-00391-00105096-00105334": "so i had speaker and volunteer was one", "T_FuOvlziJY-00392-00105335-00105543": "of them or attendee speaker and", "T_FuOvlziJY-00393-00105544-00105654": "volunteer", "T_FuOvlziJY-00394-00105655-00105831": "i don't know could somebody kind of take", "T_FuOvlziJY-00395-00105832-00106110": "a look at this one too", "T_FuOvlziJY-00396-00106111-00106286": "it doesn't look like it does resolve all", "T_FuOvlziJY-00397-00106288-00106551": "the issues", "T_FuOvlziJY-00398-00106552-00106734": "date of last reviewed", "T_FuOvlziJY-00399-00106735-00106910": "fourth point and the objectives is", "T_FuOvlziJY-00400-00106911-00107047": "redundant", "T_FuOvlziJY-00401-00107048-00107831": "check out the spreadsheet remark", "T_FuOvlziJY-00402-00107832-00108039": "could somebody take a look at this to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00403-00108040-00108327": "see if", "T_FuOvlziJY-00404-00108328-00108575": "so the request here is if somebody could", "T_FuOvlziJY-00405-00108576-00108895": "take a look at", "T_FuOvlziJY-00406-00108896-00109286": "the way that this is working is", "T_FuOvlziJY-00407-00109288-00109471": "this is", "T_FuOvlziJY-00408-00109472-00109886": "a metric", "T_FuOvlziJY-00409-00109888-00110639": "this is weird", "T_FuOvlziJY-00410-00110640-00110831": "oh no that's right okay so this is an", "T_FuOvlziJY-00411-00110832-00111271": "issue that's opened", "T_FuOvlziJY-00412-00111272-00111583": "where these changes have been requested", "T_FuOvlziJY-00413-00111583-00111790": "to be made", "T_FuOvlziJY-00414-00111791-00112015": "on the old event demographics metric or", "T_FuOvlziJY-00415-00112016-00112654": "on the current event demographics metric", "T_FuOvlziJY-00416-00112655-00113039": "this pull request", "T_FuOvlziJY-00417-00113040-00113319": "is meant to attend to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00418-00113320-00113758": "those suggestions", "T_FuOvlziJY-00419-00113759-00113943": "and so could somebody would somebody", "T_FuOvlziJY-00420-00113944-00114127": "like to take the action item to just", "T_FuOvlziJY-00421-00114128-00114454": "kind of confirm that this pull request", "T_FuOvlziJY-00422-00114455-00114734": "files changed", "T_FuOvlziJY-00423-00114735-00114951": "that this pull request", "T_FuOvlziJY-00424-00114952-00115119": "does indeed", "T_FuOvlziJY-00425-00115120-00115286": "attend to these four", "T_FuOvlziJY-00426-00115288-00115439": "things", "T_FuOvlziJY-00427-00115440-00115583": "would somebody be willing to take a look", "T_FuOvlziJY-00428-00115583-00115799": "at that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00429-00115800-00115919": "i can do that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00430-00115920-00116423": "okay that'd be great", "T_FuOvlziJY-00431-00116424-00116790": "okay so then", "T_FuOvlziJY-00432-00116791-00116910": "yeah", "T_FuOvlziJY-00433-00116911-00117207": "thanks elizabeth", "T_FuOvlziJY-00434-00117208-00117447": "thank you elizabeth to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00435-00117448-00117854": "kind of confirm that pr changes", "T_FuOvlziJY-00436-00117855-00118047": "on the event", "T_FuOvlziJY-00437-00118048-00118454": "demographics", "T_FuOvlziJY-00438-00118455-00119654": "are", "T_FuOvlziJY-00439-00119655-00119775": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00440-00119776-00120183": "okay great thank you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00441-00120183-00120351": "does anybody have any questions as to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00442-00120352-00120534": "kind of what we're doing here", "T_FuOvlziJY-00443-00120535-00120671": "just seeing i know", "T_FuOvlziJY-00444-00120672-00120831": "some of you may or may not have seen", "T_FuOvlziJY-00445-00120832-00121063": "this workflow before so i'm just making", "T_FuOvlziJY-00446-00121064-00121239": "sure this all makes sense and if you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00447-00121240-00121534": "have questions", "T_FuOvlziJY-00448-00121535-00121727": "below i have", "T_FuOvlziJY-00449-00121728-00122014": "just a single question", "T_FuOvlziJY-00450-00122015-00122295": "the pr contains the four steps isn't", "T_FuOvlziJY-00451-00122296-00122863": "that that pr too big or complicated", "T_FuOvlziJY-00452-00122864-00123166": "this pr", "T_FuOvlziJY-00453-00123167-00123447": "i don't know the limit", "T_FuOvlziJY-00454-00123448-00123831": "yeah to recognize the bigger pr or small", "T_FuOvlziJY-00455-00123832-00123943": "pr", "T_FuOvlziJY-00456-00123944-00124054": "so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00457-00124055-00124223": "is there that okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00458-00124224-00124454": "i think in this case yeah i know there's", "T_FuOvlziJY-00459-00124455-00124639": "a good question so the way i understand", "T_FuOvlziJY-00460-00124640-00124790": "the question taiway is is it okay to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00461-00124791-00125134": "have a pr with four changes yes", "T_FuOvlziJY-00462-00125135-00125399": "and i think in this case it is okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00463-00125400-00125623": "because sometimes it's simply just", "T_FuOvlziJY-00464-00125624-00125766": "updating", "T_FuOvlziJY-00465-00125767-00126175": "a little bit of text or adding a date", "T_FuOvlziJY-00466-00126176-00126302": "you know what i mean so the items are", "T_FuOvlziJY-00467-00126303-00126471": "pretty small", "T_FuOvlziJY-00468-00126472-00126671": "um yeah but i think so i think in a lot", "T_FuOvlziJY-00469-00126672-00126863": "of these reviews it's okay to just have", "T_FuOvlziJY-00470-00126864-00127039": "a single pr", "T_FuOvlziJY-00471-00127040-00127351": "against the suggested changes", "T_FuOvlziJY-00472-00127352-00127719": "but thanks for that question", "T_FuOvlziJY-00473-00127720-00128086": "because i see the pr you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00474-00128088-00128214": "you closed", "T_FuOvlziJY-00475-00128215-00128366": "just now", "T_FuOvlziJY-00476-00128367-00128710": "uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00477-00128711-00128854": "that should be", "T_FuOvlziJY-00478-00128855-00129199": "split up right yeah so that one so that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00479-00129200-00129286": "that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00480-00129288-00129878": "would be good yes okay so that one", "T_FuOvlziJY-00481-00129879-00130454": "wherever it was", "T_FuOvlziJY-00482-00130455-00131702": "closed captioning not", "T_FuOvlziJY-00483-00131703-00132014": "one available but it was a pr that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00484-00132015-00132423": "was trying to change this document", "T_FuOvlziJY-00485-00132424-00132614": "and a different document", "T_FuOvlziJY-00486-00132615-00132847": "and another", "T_FuOvlziJY-00487-00132848-00133083": "and a fourth layer", "T_FuOvlziJY-00488-00133084-00133343": "so and i would add i would add that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00489-00133344-00133535": "those changes are not related to each", "T_FuOvlziJY-00490-00133536-00133702": "other", "T_FuOvlziJY-00491-00133703-00133895": "so if the if the changes were all", "T_FuOvlziJY-00492-00133896-00134078": "related to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00493-00134079-00134175": "uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00494-00134176-00134414": "the revision process for for that one", "T_FuOvlziJY-00495-00134415-00134511": "metric", "T_FuOvlziJY-00496-00134512-00134831": "then then maybe this would be acceptable", "T_FuOvlziJY-00497-00134832-00134975": "uh but these are", "T_FuOvlziJY-00498-00134976-00135190": "this is seemingly kind of four kind of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00499-00135191-00135375": "random changes", "T_FuOvlziJY-00500-00135376-00135695": "in different files", "T_FuOvlziJY-00501-00135696-00136214": "yeah thank you second camera and a", "T_FuOvlziJY-00502-00136215-00136414": "the recommendation would be to issue one", "T_FuOvlziJY-00503-00136415-00136863": "pr for this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00504-00136864-00137063": "one pr for this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00505-00137064-00137278": "one pr for this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00506-00137279-00137551": "and one for this so and kevin's point is", "T_FuOvlziJY-00507-00137552-00137702": "was well taken as well sometimes there", "T_FuOvlziJY-00508-00137703-00137854": "are", "T_FuOvlziJY-00509-00137855-00138039": "times when one pull request will touch", "T_FuOvlziJY-00510-00138040-00138278": "two documents but it's it's when those", "T_FuOvlziJY-00511-00138279-00138463": "two documents when the pr is related", "T_FuOvlziJY-00512-00138464-00138695": "across those two documents so thank you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00513-00138696-00139407": "taiway good question", "T_FuOvlziJY-00514-00139408-00139839": "any other questions from folks", "T_FuOvlziJY-00515-00139840-00139966": "all right", "T_FuOvlziJY-00516-00139967-00140375": "take a look at our issues really fast", "T_FuOvlziJY-00517-00140376-00140702": "and i did just submit the uh pull the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00518-00140703-00141119": "change request for the revising the uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00519-00141120-00141639": "issue template oh okay cool thank you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00520-00141640-00141935": "um so i think i don't think much has", "T_FuOvlziJY-00521-00141936-00142302": "changed here", "T_FuOvlziJY-00522-00142303-00142543": "time inclusion for virtual events do we", "T_FuOvlziJY-00523-00142544-00142823": "want to update this kevin", "T_FuOvlziJY-00524-00142824-00143047": "from last week", "T_FuOvlziJY-00525-00143048-00143599": "should be good", "T_FuOvlziJY-00526-00143600-00143759": "you want to add a final comment like", "T_FuOvlziJY-00527-00143760-00143999": "this has been completed oh yeah i need", "T_FuOvlziJY-00528-00144000-00144223": "to double check the uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00529-00144224-00144375": "i'm gonna put that on my action item", "T_FuOvlziJY-00530-00144376-00144511": "list i actually need to i need to double", "T_FuOvlziJY-00531-00144512-00144671": "check those check boxes just to make", "T_FuOvlziJY-00532-00144672-00144751": "sure", "T_FuOvlziJY-00533-00144752-00144847": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00534-00144848-00145111": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00535-00145112-00145278": "so i'll i'll take another look at that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00536-00145279-00145543": "and double check those check boxes okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00537-00145544-00146095": "uh thank you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00538-00146096-00146247": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00539-00146248-00146519": "i think there's really nothing", "T_FuOvlziJY-00540-00146520-00146831": "um kind of conduct ideas i think we can", "T_FuOvlziJY-00541-00146832-00147126": "close these at this point our code of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00542-00147127-00147375": "conduct google summer of code", "T_FuOvlziJY-00543-00147376-00148559": "ideas", "T_FuOvlziJY-00544-00148560-00149078": "matt are you on right now", "T_FuOvlziJY-00545-00149079-00149343": "yes i am sorry i got a call what's up", "T_FuOvlziJY-00546-00149344-00149566": "so looking at issues this was one that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00547-00149567-00149766": "you had opened", "T_FuOvlziJY-00548-00149767-00149951": "can i close this oh yeah go ahead and", "T_FuOvlziJY-00549-00149952-00150102": "close it this is something that we had", "T_FuOvlziJY-00550-00150103-00150287": "not put into practice because we focus", "T_FuOvlziJY-00551-00150288-00151071": "on the bot instead i think okay thanks", "T_FuOvlziJY-00552-00151072-00151711": "all right", "T_FuOvlziJY-00553-00151712-00151831": "kevin", "T_FuOvlziJY-00554-00151832-00152471": "should we be closing the release notes", "T_FuOvlziJY-00555-00152472-00152559": "yes", "T_FuOvlziJY-00556-00152560-00152695": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00557-00152696-00153166": "yeah those those get closed and uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00558-00153167-00153414": "you should you should create a uh a new", "T_FuOvlziJY-00559-00153415-00153671": "release notes okay issue when you close", "T_FuOvlziJY-00560-00153672-00153766": "this one", "T_FuOvlziJY-00561-00153767-00154175": "with the uh with the next date okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00562-00154176-00154439": "let me go ahead and do that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00563-00154440-00154607": "looks like we had some housekeeping to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00564-00154608-00154925": "do", "T_FuOvlziJY-00565-00154926-00155702": "[Music]", "T_FuOvlziJY-00566-00155703-00156014": "ah", "T_FuOvlziJY-00567-00156015-00156278": "where is my", "T_FuOvlziJY-00568-00156279-00156551": "this is that can be other feedback", "T_FuOvlziJY-00569-00156552-00158111": "maybe", "T_FuOvlziJY-00570-00158112-00158326": "what would the date be on that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00571-00158327-00158566": "22-10", "T_FuOvlziJY-00572-00158567-00158663": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00573-00158664-00158783": "good", "T_FuOvlziJY-00574-00158784-00158935": "and then usually i like to put a little", "T_FuOvlziJY-00575-00158936-00159175": "text this this issue was created to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00576-00159176-00159278": "capture", "T_FuOvlziJY-00577-00159279-00159671": "the release notes for uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00578-00159672-00159751": "yeah", "T_FuOvlziJY-00579-00159752-00160039": "for release 2020", "T_FuOvlziJY-00580-00160040-00161239": "20 22 10.", "T_FuOvlziJY-00581-00161240-00161454": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00582-00161455-00161702": "thank you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00583-00161703-00162483": "i don't think it needs", "T_FuOvlziJY-00584-00162484-00163071": "triage all right", "T_FuOvlziJY-00585-00163072-00163207": "it probably does need the metrics", "T_FuOvlziJY-00586-00163208-00163399": "release tag though", "T_FuOvlziJY-00587-00163400-00163702": "yeah i don't oh my gosh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00588-00163703-00164055": "if i can do that if you want to keep", "T_FuOvlziJY-00589-00164056-00164223": "[Laughter]", "T_FuOvlziJY-00590-00164224-00164383": "trying to run the meeting and", "T_FuOvlziJY-00591-00164384-00164807": "do do the things yeah it's hard", "T_FuOvlziJY-00592-00164808-00165047": "all right um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00593-00165048-00165159": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00594-00165160-00165663": "so let's go back to issues again", "T_FuOvlziJY-00595-00165664-00165919": "i think all of these revising metrics", "T_FuOvlziJY-00596-00165920-00166278": "are good", "T_FuOvlziJY-00597-00166279-00167151": "project burnout maintainer wellness", "T_FuOvlziJY-00598-00167152-00167351": "does anybody remember this conversation", "T_FuOvlziJY-00599-00167352-00167502": "i mean it's basically", "T_FuOvlziJY-00600-00167503-00167654": "i think it's", "T_FuOvlziJY-00601-00167655-00167823": "revisiting the name", "T_FuOvlziJY-00602-00167824-00168007": "project burnout that we have for the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00603-00168008-00168287": "metric is that correct", "T_FuOvlziJY-00604-00168288-00168551": "and moving towards maintainer wellness", "T_FuOvlziJY-00605-00168552-00168687": "yeah that's correct", "T_FuOvlziJY-00606-00168688-00169423": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00607-00169424-00170014": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00608-00170015-00170214": "my okay so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00609-00170215-00170359": "i haven't i'll be honest i haven't", "T_FuOvlziJY-00610-00170360-00170566": "really thought about this much", "T_FuOvlziJY-00611-00170567-00170831": "since this conversation", "T_FuOvlziJY-00612-00170832-00170983": "and we'll put something in a couple", "T_FuOvlziJY-00613-00170984-00171175": "weeks ago", "T_FuOvlziJY-00614-00171176-00171343": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00615-00171344-00171471": "we", "T_FuOvlziJY-00616-00171472-00171719": "we use the term project burnout quite a", "T_FuOvlziJY-00617-00171720-00171887": "bit quite a bit", "T_FuOvlziJY-00618-00171888-00172143": "and in fact as an example i think ruth", "T_FuOvlziJY-00619-00172144-00172295": "isn't the stuff you're doing i don't", "T_FuOvlziJY-00620-00172296-00172495": "know if you're on ruth", "T_FuOvlziJY-00621-00172496-00172654": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00622-00172655-00172895": "isn't the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00623-00172896-00173102": "github maintainer month remember that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00624-00173103-00173295": "one", "T_FuOvlziJY-00625-00173296-00173511": "isn't that about burnout", "T_FuOvlziJY-00626-00173512-00173878": "it is ruth had to drop off um but yes it", "T_FuOvlziJY-00627-00173879-00174102": "is", "T_FuOvlziJY-00628-00174103-00174383": "i guess i'm just a little hesitant to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00629-00174384-00174614": "to make a change when", "T_FuOvlziJY-00630-00174615-00174935": "to be honest it seems like burnout is a", "T_FuOvlziJY-00631-00174936-00175063": "topic that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00632-00175064-00175223": "gets talked about a lot and pretty", "T_FuOvlziJY-00633-00175224-00175366": "easily", "T_FuOvlziJY-00634-00175367-00175814": "and what other people's thoughts are", "T_FuOvlziJY-00635-00175815-00176054": "i feel like it came up because", "T_FuOvlziJY-00636-00176055-00176423": "someone wasn't certain that that phrase", "T_FuOvlziJY-00637-00176424-00176654": "burnout would be", "T_FuOvlziJY-00638-00176655-00176831": "like universal", "T_FuOvlziJY-00639-00176832-00176951": "okay i think", "T_FuOvlziJY-00640-00176952-00177151": "if i recall yeah i was about to say the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00641-00177152-00177271": "same thing", "T_FuOvlziJY-00642-00177272-00177423": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00643-00177424-00177511": "so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00644-00177512-00177735": "one sec", "T_FuOvlziJY-00645-00177736-00177966": "so we had a um we had this burnout", "T_FuOvlziJY-00646-00177967-00178207": "metric but it doesn't necessarily cover", "T_FuOvlziJY-00647-00178208-00178478": "all like we have a psychological safety", "T_FuOvlziJY-00648-00178479-00178671": "metric which is like for crisis", "T_FuOvlziJY-00649-00178672-00178814": "prevention and a lot of things like that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00650-00178815-00179199": "as i understand but then we also have a", "T_FuOvlziJY-00651-00179200-00179471": "burnout which only kind of covers from a", "T_FuOvlziJY-00652-00179472-00179638": "negative perspective it covers how", "T_FuOvlziJY-00653-00179639-00179726": "people", "T_FuOvlziJY-00654-00179727-00179919": "interact with their projects and how it", "T_FuOvlziJY-00655-00179920-00180087": "affects their wellness", "T_FuOvlziJY-00656-00180088-00180207": "uh i think", "T_FuOvlziJY-00657-00180208-00180407": "for me it would be like a shift from", "T_FuOvlziJY-00658-00180408-00180638": "like a from like a negative person like", "T_FuOvlziJY-00659-00180639-00180847": "a prevention perspective", "T_FuOvlziJY-00660-00180848-00180951": "to a", "T_FuOvlziJY-00661-00180952-00181047": "how do we", "T_FuOvlziJY-00662-00181048-00181247": "how do we improve the wellness of the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00663-00181248-00181399": "people that are working here kind of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00664-00181400-00181502": "thing", "T_FuOvlziJY-00665-00181503-00181783": "um or help foster that wellness within", "T_FuOvlziJY-00666-00181784-00181887": "those people", "T_FuOvlziJY-00667-00181888-00181975": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00668-00181976-00182175": "and then also yeah like like you said", "T_FuOvlziJY-00669-00182176-00182295": "elizabeth", "T_FuOvlziJY-00670-00182296-00182478": "someone had come and said", "T_FuOvlziJY-00671-00182479-00182631": "bernard doesn't necessarily cover all", "T_FuOvlziJY-00672-00182632-00182751": "aspects of wellness and we don't have", "T_FuOvlziJY-00673-00182752-00182895": "another metric that covers that right", "T_FuOvlziJY-00674-00182896-00182990": "now", "T_FuOvlziJY-00675-00182991-00183223": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00676-00183224-00183502": "um i think that's that's well said that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00677-00183503-00183783": "i agree that burnout is about", "T_FuOvlziJY-00678-00183784-00183943": "kind of a negative connotation and", "T_FuOvlziJY-00679-00183944-00184254": "wellness is definitely more positive", "T_FuOvlziJY-00680-00184255-00184551": "yes i would say so um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00681-00184552-00184671": "all right so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00682-00184672-00185071": "i don't", "T_FuOvlziJY-00683-00185072-00185471": "3.99", "T_FuOvlziJY-00684-00185472-00185687": "i would really like to hear uh ruth's", "T_FuOvlziJY-00685-00185688-00185863": "input on this though since this kind of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00686-00185864-00186063": "was like her you know she was the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00687-00186064-00186278": "inspiration for this whole metric so i'd", "T_FuOvlziJY-00688-00186279-00186487": "really like to hear her perspective okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00689-00186488-00186623": "maybe we could", "T_FuOvlziJY-00690-00186624-00186847": "wait till next week to talk about it was", "T_FuOvlziJY-00691-00186848-00187999": "good yep", "T_FuOvlziJY-00692-00188000-00188087": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00693-00188088-00188254": "yeah because you you are right it was", "T_FuOvlziJY-00694-00188255-00188431": "ruth that had brought the metric forward", "T_FuOvlziJY-00695-00188432-00188575": "and the burnout metric forward in the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00696-00188576-00188814": "first place", "T_FuOvlziJY-00697-00188815-00188999": "yeah and if if we are going to change we", "T_FuOvlziJY-00698-00189000-00189150": "probably want to wait till after that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00699-00189151-00189343": "session just to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00700-00189344-00189654": "like not confuse everybody", "T_FuOvlziJY-00701-00189655-00189823": "it's totally fair", "T_FuOvlziJY-00702-00189824-00190111": "okay great thank you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00703-00190112-00190278": "um maybe we'll do one more issue then", "T_FuOvlziJY-00704-00190279-00190366": "we'll", "T_FuOvlziJY-00705-00190367-00190471": "move on", "T_FuOvlziJY-00706-00190472-00190775": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00707-00190776-00190999": "matt do you wanna i don't know if you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00708-00191000-00191119": "have", "T_FuOvlziJY-00709-00191120-00191343": "any comments about this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00710-00191344-00191511": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00711-00191512-00191775": "i think this is still good uh we haven't", "T_FuOvlziJY-00712-00191776-00192063": "had much movement on it um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00713-00192064-00192271": "this is something i just wanted to to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00714-00192272-00192535": "add as its own section to the metrics", "T_FuOvlziJY-00715-00192536-00192743": "checklist my only concern is that the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00716-00192744-00192950": "metrics checklist has gotten pretty long", "T_FuOvlziJY-00717-00192951-00193063": "at this point", "T_FuOvlziJY-00718-00193064-00193283": "so it might be something to do like", "T_FuOvlziJY-00719-00193284-00193607": "after like as part of the review process", "T_FuOvlziJY-00720-00193608-00193775": "rather than the checklist for releasing", "T_FuOvlziJY-00721-00193776-00194183": "a metric", "T_FuOvlziJY-00722-00194184-00194319": "but i think it's i think it's important", "T_FuOvlziJY-00723-00194320-00194463": "that we go over this because", "T_FuOvlziJY-00724-00194464-00194647": "now that i know the list and i'm", "T_FuOvlziJY-00725-00194648-00194966": "familiar with the list i see these words", "T_FuOvlziJY-00726-00194967-00195295": "quite often", "T_FuOvlziJY-00727-00195296-00195407": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00728-00195408-00195566": "we can", "T_FuOvlziJY-00729-00195567-00195750": "go ahead sorry", "T_FuOvlziJY-00730-00195751-00195926": "i was just gonna say i also had a", "T_FuOvlziJY-00731-00195927-00196135": "recommended um someone i can't remember", "T_FuOvlziJY-00732-00196136-00196335": "who it was someone was looking for a way", "T_FuOvlziJY-00733-00196336-00196607": "to contribute through the documentation", "T_FuOvlziJY-00734-00196608-00196759": "but they weren't part of any of our", "T_FuOvlziJY-00735-00196760-00197014": "mentorship programs and just wanted to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00736-00197015-00197183": "participate in like an unofficial", "T_FuOvlziJY-00737-00197184-00197383": "capacity and this was something i think", "T_FuOvlziJY-00738-00197384-00197631": "i sent them to as a way that they could", "T_FuOvlziJY-00739-00197632-00197863": "contribute by just looking through our", "T_FuOvlziJY-00740-00197864-00198102": "documents you know at their leisure it's", "T_FuOvlziJY-00741-00198103-00198223": "you know", "T_FuOvlziJY-00742-00198224-00198487": "um and i showed them the list of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00743-00198488-00198590": "terms", "T_FuOvlziJY-00744-00198591-00198838": "so i don't know if we want to maybe", "T_FuOvlziJY-00745-00198839-00199054": "just an idea to like maybe put this as a", "T_FuOvlziJY-00746-00199055-00199238": "good first issue for someone that just", "T_FuOvlziJY-00747-00199239-00199423": "wants a kind of a lightweight", "T_FuOvlziJY-00748-00199424-00199783": "way to contribute um i don't know", "T_FuOvlziJY-00749-00199784-00199895": "but i don't know if we wanted it to be", "T_FuOvlziJY-00750-00199896-00200063": "more structured and like keep track of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00751-00200064-00200343": "like what documents we've looked for and", "T_FuOvlziJY-00752-00200344-00200511": "you know all of that or looked through", "T_FuOvlziJY-00753-00200512-00200719": "and all of that so i'm just throwing", "T_FuOvlziJY-00754-00200720-00201063": "that out there", "T_FuOvlziJY-00755-00201064-00201238": "so i i was going to say we should", "T_FuOvlziJY-00756-00201239-00201454": "definitely add this to the revision", "T_FuOvlziJY-00757-00201455-00201766": "checklist and the review checklist", "T_FuOvlziJY-00758-00201767-00201959": "and i know that that list is getting", "T_FuOvlziJY-00759-00201960-00202214": "longer but i think one", "T_FuOvlziJY-00760-00202215-00202478": "one check box with just pointing to the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00761-00202479-00202647": "document", "T_FuOvlziJY-00762-00202648-00202735": "uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00763-00202736-00202990": "describing what the inclusive naming is", "T_FuOvlziJY-00764-00202991-00203543": "would be enough", "T_FuOvlziJY-00765-00203544-00203735": "i believe that the if i'm not mistaken", "T_FuOvlziJY-00766-00203736-00204054": "the inclusive naming um initiative has a", "T_FuOvlziJY-00767-00204055-00204175": "linter", "T_FuOvlziJY-00768-00204176-00204311": "that you can run through but i don't", "T_FuOvlziJY-00769-00204312-00204471": "know the specifics of it so that might", "T_FuOvlziJY-00770-00204472-00204590": "be something else to look through so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00771-00204591-00204743": "we're not manually", "T_FuOvlziJY-00772-00204744-00204879": "looking through all these documents", "T_FuOvlziJY-00773-00204880-00205023": "trying to remember all the words and", "T_FuOvlziJY-00774-00205023-00205151": "looking for them", "T_FuOvlziJY-00775-00205152-00205310": "um so that might be something else that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00776-00205311-00205494": "somebody could work on if they wanted", "T_FuOvlziJY-00777-00205496-00205694": "just to look at that linter and how that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00778-00205696-00205886": "affects our docs or how we could use", "T_FuOvlziJY-00779-00205887-00206086": "that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00780-00206087-00206327": "could you if you have that elizabeth", "T_FuOvlziJY-00781-00206328-00206527": "could you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00782-00206528-00206782": "yeah i'll have to dig it up um but i'll", "T_FuOvlziJY-00783-00206783-00206990": "look for that for sure", "T_FuOvlziJY-00784-00206991-00207198": "thank you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00785-00207200-00207310": "all right", "T_FuOvlziJY-00786-00207311-00207503": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00787-00207504-00207727": "stop on issues", "T_FuOvlziJY-00788-00207728-00207982": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00789-00207983-00208182": "let's see let's go to badging we have", "T_FuOvlziJY-00790-00208183-00208382": "about 10 minutes", "T_FuOvlziJY-00791-00208383-00208590": "i'm gonna go down to this one first so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00792-00208591-00208790": "event badging somebody had put that in", "T_FuOvlziJY-00793-00208791-00208982": "there", "T_FuOvlziJY-00794-00208983-00209223": "yeah i did i was just gonna mention just", "T_FuOvlziJY-00795-00209223-00209438": "so everybody knows we are um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00796-00209439-00209631": "indoctrinating three new reviewers", "T_FuOvlziJY-00797-00209632-00209791": "tomorrow we're on boarding them through", "T_FuOvlziJY-00798-00209792-00209951": "a training session so we'll have three", "T_FuOvlziJY-00799-00209952-00210206": "more reviewers to our team hooray hooray", "T_FuOvlziJY-00800-00210207-00210479": "and um just a reminder everyone is", "T_FuOvlziJY-00801-00210480-00210671": "invited to this event badge reviewer", "T_FuOvlziJY-00802-00210671-00210855": "appreciation appreciation event which", "T_FuOvlziJY-00803-00210856-00211071": "happens on june 16th it's just going to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00804-00211071-00211263": "be an informal fun event where we kind", "T_FuOvlziJY-00805-00211264-00211439": "of um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00806-00211440-00211775": "recognize our uh reviewers um welcome", "T_FuOvlziJY-00807-00211776-00211991": "our new reviewers um give a little", "T_FuOvlziJY-00808-00211992-00212294": "history of the badging program and like", "T_FuOvlziJY-00809-00212296-00212439": "what the next steps are gonna be where", "T_FuOvlziJY-00810-00212440-00212606": "we're going with it in the future so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00811-00212607-00212863": "it'll be fun not a big deal like nothing", "T_FuOvlziJY-00812-00212864-00213094": "you know just a little carve that out a", "T_FuOvlziJY-00813-00213096-00213223": "little fun part of your day if you would", "T_FuOvlziJY-00814-00213223-00213367": "like to come everybody's welcome and", "T_FuOvlziJY-00815-00213367-00213846": "there's a link there to register", "T_FuOvlziJY-00816-00213848-00214055": "cool thank you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00817-00214056-00214279": "elizabeth and just if people aren't", "T_FuOvlziJY-00818-00214280-00214519": "familiar we have a an event badging", "T_FuOvlziJY-00819-00214519-00214679": "program where we", "T_FuOvlziJY-00820-00214680-00214887": "provide", "T_FuOvlziJY-00821-00214888-00214991": "dei", "T_FuOvlziJY-00822-00214992-00215406": "badges for events that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00823-00215407-00215606": "go through the process and as part of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00824-00215607-00215863": "that process part of that review process", "T_FuOvlziJY-00825-00215864-00216134": "there are individuals who take a look at", "T_FuOvlziJY-00826-00216135-00216351": "really the things that the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00827-00216352-00216455": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00828-00216456-00216615": "conferences claim to be doing with", "T_FuOvlziJY-00829-00216616-00216863": "respect to dei and just kind of review", "T_FuOvlziJY-00830-00216864-00217006": "to ensure that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00831-00217007-00217279": "there's there's truth to those claims", "T_FuOvlziJY-00832-00217280-00217591": "i think each review of a conference", "T_FuOvlziJY-00833-00217592-00217839": "maybe takes 10 minutes", "T_FuOvlziJY-00834-00217840-00218142": "elizabeth i mean 15 minutes", "T_FuOvlziJY-00835-00218144-00218398": "30 minutes it's not terrible", "T_FuOvlziJY-00836-00218400-00218487": "maybe", "T_FuOvlziJY-00837-00218488-00218791": "15 is a good yeah okay it kind of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00838-00218792-00219031": "depends on the event but yeah a lot of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00839-00219032-00219327": "them are um know the badging", "T_FuOvlziJY-00840-00219328-00219534": "project well so they know", "T_FuOvlziJY-00841-00219535-00219703": "exactly you know what we're looking for", "T_FuOvlziJY-00842-00219704-00219855": "and they point us directly to what we're", "T_FuOvlziJY-00843-00219856-00220015": "so we don't have to search very hard is", "T_FuOvlziJY-00844-00220016-00220175": "what i'm saying", "T_FuOvlziJY-00845-00220176-00220382": "so if you're interested in in becoming a", "T_FuOvlziJY-00846-00220383-00220582": "reviewer and kind of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00847-00220583-00220806": "joining the chaos community that way", "T_FuOvlziJY-00848-00220807-00220967": "that would be wonderful", "T_FuOvlziJY-00849-00220967-00221151": "um i don't know is the easiest way just", "T_FuOvlziJY-00850-00221152-00221431": "to reach out to you on slack elizabeth", "T_FuOvlziJY-00851-00221432-00221591": "just dropped a link for the reviewer", "T_FuOvlziJY-00852-00221592-00221798": "sign up form", "T_FuOvlziJY-00853-00221800-00221982": "oh okay and that should be the best way", "T_FuOvlziJY-00854-00221983-00222198": "i'm going to drop it in the notes too", "T_FuOvlziJY-00855-00222200-00222406": "thank you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00856-00222407-00222527": "all right great", "T_FuOvlziJY-00857-00222528-00222694": "that's great that three new reviewers", "T_FuOvlziJY-00858-00222696-00222894": "are joining i mean", "T_FuOvlziJY-00859-00222896-00223046": "that's getting to be a pretty good group", "T_FuOvlziJY-00860-00223048-00223367": "of people i think which is really nice", "T_FuOvlziJY-00861-00223367-00223567": "yeah it's it's really good because some", "T_FuOvlziJY-00862-00223567-00223751": "people have um like their availability", "T_FuOvlziJY-00863-00223752-00224023": "has kind of dropped off so we just want", "T_FuOvlziJY-00864-00224023-00224206": "to always make sure we have new people", "T_FuOvlziJY-00865-00224207-00224423": "coming in so that the burden is not", "T_FuOvlziJY-00866-00224423-00224623": "always on the same people all the time", "T_FuOvlziJY-00867-00224623-00224703": "so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00868-00224704-00225006": "great that's a great update thank you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00869-00225007-00225175": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00870-00225176-00225415": "so i just with respect to the badging", "T_FuOvlziJY-00871-00225416-00225703": "updates for project badging there was a", "T_FuOvlziJY-00872-00225704-00226023": "if you recall there's a giant sandwich", "T_FuOvlziJY-00873-00226023-00226198": "there's", "T_FuOvlziJY-00874-00226200-00226375": "there's a uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00875-00226376-00226519": "there were a lot of really great", "T_FuOvlziJY-00876-00226519-00226758": "suggestions that came from the meeting", "T_FuOvlziJY-00877-00226759-00226998": "last time and i part of my action item", "T_FuOvlziJY-00878-00227000-00227223": "is to include a lot of that commentary", "T_FuOvlziJY-00879-00227223-00227431": "into the project badging program i", "T_FuOvlziJY-00880-00227432-00227639": "haven't done that yet i will say that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00881-00227640-00227894": "one of the things that was done and this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00882-00227896-00228175": "was in response to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00883-00228176-00228303": "matt", "T_FuOvlziJY-00884-00228304-00228591": "you had suggested using github", "T_FuOvlziJY-00885-00228592-00228910": "as a way to do the application process", "T_FuOvlziJY-00886-00228911-00229142": "is that that's right i think", "T_FuOvlziJY-00887-00229144-00229558": "and so ayush had put this together", "T_FuOvlziJY-00888-00229559-00229782": "just as don't worry about the content at", "T_FuOvlziJY-00889-00229783-00229919": "the moment that'll this will have to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00890-00229919-00230103": "change a little bit", "T_FuOvlziJY-00891-00230104-00230303": "you know what i mean just in terms of", "T_FuOvlziJY-00892-00230304-00230519": "what the things are", "T_FuOvlziJY-00893-00230519-00230694": "but is this kind of what you were what", "T_FuOvlziJY-00894-00230696-00230871": "you had in mind", "T_FuOvlziJY-00895-00230871-00231039": "when you were talking", "T_FuOvlziJY-00896-00231040-00231158": "so one", "T_FuOvlziJY-00897-00231159-00231342": "form it just kind of turns it into a", "T_FuOvlziJY-00898-00231344-00231463": "markdown", "T_FuOvlziJY-00899-00231464-00231782": "um it it translates it into that's", "T_FuOvlziJY-00900-00231783-00231951": "beautiful that's what we were trying to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00901-00231952-00232134": "do with the with the forum on the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00902-00232135-00232382": "website uh but that was difficult to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00903-00232383-00232655": "accomplish smoothly so this is beautiful", "T_FuOvlziJY-00904-00232656-00232919": "okay cool so the first reaction is", "T_FuOvlziJY-00905-00232919-00233046": "positive", "T_FuOvlziJY-00906-00233048-00233231": "from kind of where you were at from the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00907-00233232-00233510": "event matching perspective and what this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00908-00233511-00233687": "this could be all right great well just", "T_FuOvlziJY-00909-00233688-00233951": "so you know it's it's here in the issue", "T_FuOvlziJY-00910-00233952-00234182": "templates so if you ever wanted to take", "T_FuOvlziJY-00911-00234183-00234423": "a look at that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00912-00234423-00234591": "yeah it's your first opportunity for", "T_FuOvlziJY-00913-00234592-00234782": "upstream contribution from the project", "T_FuOvlziJY-00914-00234783-00235006": "badging initiative that sounds great", "T_FuOvlziJY-00915-00235007-00235223": "it's pretty cool so matt would the would", "T_FuOvlziJY-00916-00235223-00235446": "the hope be or elizabeth would the hope", "T_FuOvlziJY-00917-00235448-00235679": "be for event badging", "T_FuOvlziJY-00918-00235680-00235942": "to move away from the web form", "T_FuOvlziJY-00919-00235944-00236175": "and to just something like this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00920-00236176-00236351": "yes is there is there a reason we can't", "T_FuOvlziJY-00921-00236352-00236542": "do that like sooner than later matt", "T_FuOvlziJY-00922-00236544-00236679": "let's do it like", "T_FuOvlziJY-00923-00236680-00236855": "as soon as possible", "T_FuOvlziJY-00924-00236856-00237094": "so elizabeth you know and some other", "T_FuOvlziJY-00925-00237096-00237342": "people probably know too that the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00926-00237344-00237519": "right now the um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00927-00237519-00237758": "form is created in html with inline", "T_FuOvlziJY-00928-00237759-00237967": "javascript and there is no scripts to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00929-00237967-00238094": "update it so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00930-00238096-00238303": "it is uh the way we could get it", "T_FuOvlziJY-00931-00238304-00238567": "established was very hard to update so", "T_FuOvlziJY-00932-00238567-00238775": "as soon as we can get this in and update", "T_FuOvlziJY-00933-00238776-00238942": "it into the um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00934-00238944-00239134": "the issue form so that that would be", "T_FuOvlziJY-00935-00239135-00239271": "perfect", "T_FuOvlziJY-00936-00239271-00239542": "it would be easier for the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00937-00239544-00239710": "applicants as well because this the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00938-00239711-00239991": "process is a little um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00939-00239992-00240167": "uh what's the word i want", "T_FuOvlziJY-00940-00240167-00240367": "yeah it could be a lot smoother so um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00941-00240367-00240463": "this would", "T_FuOvlziJY-00942-00240464-00240710": "fix a lot of that okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00943-00240711-00240887": "so just uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00944-00240888-00241127": "i'm not uh i'm not suggesting you do it", "T_FuOvlziJY-00945-00241128-00241287": "differently but i did just want to let", "T_FuOvlziJY-00946-00241288-00241455": "you know that it is it is possible to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00947-00241456-00241598": "create web forms", "T_FuOvlziJY-00948-00241600-00241734": "on the website", "T_FuOvlziJY-00949-00241735-00242023": "without uh html code", "T_FuOvlziJY-00950-00242023-00242358": "so we have a we have plugins for that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00951-00242359-00242503": "okay", "T_FuOvlziJY-00952-00242504-00242606": "oh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00953-00242607-00242951": "hello cat can anyone share the links i'm", "T_FuOvlziJY-00954-00242952-00243182": "interested in it", "T_FuOvlziJY-00955-00243183-00243375": "are you interested in that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00956-00243376-00243471": "yeah yeah", "T_FuOvlziJY-00957-00243471-00243710": "um do you want the links to like this", "T_FuOvlziJY-00958-00243711-00243855": "issue template here", "T_FuOvlziJY-00959-00243856-00244039": "yes yes thank you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00960-00244040-00244198": "yeah could somebody grab that and just", "T_FuOvlziJY-00961-00244200-00244567": "drop it into the chat in the minutes", "T_FuOvlziJY-00962-00244567-00244694": "it's actually it's i think it's in the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00963-00244696-00245023": "minutes it's right here", "T_FuOvlziJY-00964-00245023-00245767": "anyway", "T_FuOvlziJY-00965-00245767-00245967": "yeah matt and elizabeth like you can", "T_FuOvlziJY-00966-00245967-00246215": "just head over here if you want to at", "T_FuOvlziJY-00967-00246216-00246367": "least", "T_FuOvlziJY-00968-00246367-00246606": "have some preliminary", "T_FuOvlziJY-00969-00246607-00246830": "framework preliminary framework for the", "T_FuOvlziJY-00970-00246831-00247167": "event badging side of things", "T_FuOvlziJY-00971-00247167-00247255": "and yes", "T_FuOvlziJY-00972-00247256-00247519": "just to coordinate too we'll probably", "T_FuOvlziJY-00973-00247519-00247615": "want to", "T_FuOvlziJY-00974-00247616-00247887": "update the uh the website page instead", "T_FuOvlziJY-00975-00247888-00248071": "of having submit your event and then you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00976-00248071-00248230": "go through the application there we'll", "T_FuOvlziJY-00977-00248231-00248455": "just have like a link to the issue once", "T_FuOvlziJY-00978-00248456-00248646": "that's done yeah", "T_FuOvlziJY-00979-00248648-00248894": "yep yep agreed", "T_FuOvlziJY-00980-00248896-00249110": "okay and agreed elizabeth thank you", "T_FuOvlziJY-00981-00249111-00249215": "ayush", "T_FuOvlziJY-00982-00249216-00249727": "for doing this this is great", "T_FuOvlziJY-00983-00249728-00249830": "all right", "T_FuOvlziJY-00984-00249831-00250030": "maybe that uh maybe that page that has", "T_FuOvlziJY-00985-00250031-00250303": "the link could have some uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00986-00250304-00250406": "uh", "T_FuOvlziJY-00987-00250407-00250598": "kind of knowledge uh some information", "T_FuOvlziJY-00988-00250600-00250927": "and kind of facts about the badging", "T_FuOvlziJY-00989-00250928-00251079": "program in general so maybe we could", "T_FuOvlziJY-00990-00251080-00251255": "build out that page a little bit more", "T_FuOvlziJY-00991-00251256-00251423": "yeah that sounds good yeah because right", "T_FuOvlziJY-00992-00251423-00251694": "now it has uh information but it still", "T_FuOvlziJY-00993-00251696-00251958": "says diversity in inclusion like with", "T_FuOvlziJY-00994-00251959-00252191": "the ampersand which make which is a big", "T_FuOvlziJY-00995-00252192-00252423": "signal that it's old information", "T_FuOvlziJY-00996-00252423-00252639": "at this point", "T_FuOvlziJY-00997-00252640-00252830": "yep totally can do that", "T_FuOvlziJY-00998-00252831-00252919": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-00999-00252919-00253334": "right on thank you for that", "T_FuOvlziJY-01000-00253335-00253455": "yeah", "T_FuOvlziJY-01001-00253456-00253646": "okay my microphone just doesn't seem to", "T_FuOvlziJY-01002-00253648-00253727": "be", "T_FuOvlziJY-01003-00253728-00254063": "activating nope here you just fight", "T_FuOvlziJY-01004-00254064-00254471": "in terms of project badging", "T_FuOvlziJY-01005-00254471-00254775": "can have we figured out i was gone last", "T_FuOvlziJY-01006-00254776-00255039": "week i was on vacation and no", "T_FuOvlziJY-01007-00255040-00255198": "communications", "T_FuOvlziJY-01008-00255200-00255319": "so", "T_FuOvlziJY-01009-00255319-00255430": "i'm", "T_FuOvlziJY-01010-00255431-00255655": "wondering if we had changed the date of", "T_FuOvlziJY-01011-00255656-00255830": "the badging meeting in order to start", "T_FuOvlziJY-01012-00255831-00255998": "planning some of this so that we could", "T_FuOvlziJY-01013-00256000-00256119": "do it", "T_FuOvlziJY-01014-00256119-00256446": "alternating weeks with event badging", "T_FuOvlziJY-01015-00256448-00256623": "and project reaching yeah we haven't", "T_FuOvlziJY-01016-00256623-00256823": "done that so yeah we were gonna wait", "T_FuOvlziJY-01017-00256823-00256991": "until after the", "T_FuOvlziJY-01018-00256992-00257358": "reviewer event happened and then i think", "T_FuOvlziJY-01019-00257359-00257527": "changed that cadence", "T_FuOvlziJY-01020-00257528-00257863": "i think that's what we decided", "T_FuOvlziJY-01021-00257864-00258094": "all right i just wanted to", "T_FuOvlziJY-01022-00258096-00258303": "check on that i feel like i've missed a", "T_FuOvlziJY-01023-00258304-00258494": "lot in the last week", "T_FuOvlziJY-01024-00258496-00258758": "well last katie last week if you go into", "T_FuOvlziJY-01025-00258759-00258879": "the minutes", "T_FuOvlziJY-01026-00258880-00259094": "we did spend quite a bit of time on just", "T_FuOvlziJY-01027-00259096-00259263": "kind of talking through it in this", "T_FuOvlziJY-01028-00259264-00259382": "meeting", "T_FuOvlziJY-01029-00259383-00259567": "so there this is", "T_FuOvlziJY-01030-00259567-00259727": "what you see i don't know if you can see", "T_FuOvlziJY-01031-00259728-00259934": "my screen but what you see like below", "T_FuOvlziJY-01032-00259935-00260030": "here", "T_FuOvlziJY-01033-00260031-00260294": "this is certainly not like must be put", "T_FuOvlziJY-01034-00260296-00260494": "into practice these were just a lot of", "T_FuOvlziJY-01035-00260496-00260663": "comments and really good ideas that", "T_FuOvlziJY-01036-00260664-00260982": "people had last week", "T_FuOvlziJY-01037-00260983-00261151": "yeah it looks great i will take another", "T_FuOvlziJY-01038-00261152-00261446": "look at that okay thanks", "T_FuOvlziJY-01039-00261448-00261615": "you can also watch the recording too", "T_FuOvlziJY-01040-00261616-00261703": "katie", "T_FuOvlziJY-01041-00261704-00261894": "i can link that", "T_FuOvlziJY-01042-00261896-00262182": "i tried to be on this but i did not have", "T_FuOvlziJY-01043-00262183-00262415": "enough cell phone reception", "T_FuOvlziJY-01044-00262416-00262671": "in the middle of a campground to", "T_FuOvlziJY-01045-00262672-00262927": "even get out a text message so i said oh", "T_FuOvlziJY-01046-00262928-00263143": "well and i put my phone away for seven", "T_FuOvlziJY-01047-00263144-00263655": "days that sounds way better", "T_FuOvlziJY-01048-00263656-00263871": "i hope it was a good camping trip oh it", "T_FuOvlziJY-01049-00263872-00264182": "was wonderful", "T_FuOvlziJY-01050-00264183-00264367": "nice", "T_FuOvlziJY-01051-00264368-00264591": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-01052-00264592-00264751": "and you can learn why there's a sandwich", "T_FuOvlziJY-01053-00264752-00264967": "here too if you go back to the village", "T_FuOvlziJY-01054-00264968-00265215": "so", "T_FuOvlziJY-01055-00265216-00265487": "um badgers in the last meeting before", "T_FuOvlziJY-01056-00265488-00265687": "that so", "T_FuOvlziJY-01057-00265688-00265895": "we're just picking a new picture now", "T_FuOvlziJY-01058-00265896-00266119": "sandwiches and badgers yes that's right", "T_FuOvlziJY-01059-00266120-00266367": "we must be driven by", "T_FuOvlziJY-01060-00266368-00266534": "strange imagery", "T_FuOvlziJY-01061-00266535-00266679": "um", "T_FuOvlziJY-01062-00266680-00266887": "and then just kind of a last note here", "T_FuOvlziJY-01063-00266888-00267134": "there is a burnout and mental health", "T_FuOvlziJY-01064-00267135-00267503": "session", "T_FuOvlziJY-01065-00267504-00267727": "yeah ruth wanted me to just uh or wanted", "T_FuOvlziJY-01066-00267728-00267958": "us to just remind everybody that um that", "T_FuOvlziJY-01067-00267959-00268119": "that was happening and it's you have to", "T_FuOvlziJY-01068-00268120-00268327": "scroll down a little bit um", "T_FuOvlziJY-01069-00268328-00268471": "and this this page was actually really", "T_FuOvlziJY-01070-00268472-00268679": "confusing for me the date is like listed", "T_FuOvlziJY-01071-00268680-00268895": "above it which i totally missed", "T_FuOvlziJY-01072-00268896-00269055": "the first time i saw it see the june", "T_FuOvlziJY-01073-00269056-00269343": "17th there we go um i missed that the", "T_FuOvlziJY-01074-00269344-00269495": "first time i saw that but um anyway", "T_FuOvlziJY-01075-00269496-00269727": "that's where you can register uh for the", "T_FuOvlziJY-01076-00269728-00269895": "event and then i also put a link to the", "T_FuOvlziJY-01077-00269896-00270134": "agenda in the minute meeting", "T_FuOvlziJY-01078-00270135-00270439": "meeting minutes the minute meeting um so", "T_FuOvlziJY-01079-00270440-00270575": "that if you're curious and you want to", "T_FuOvlziJY-01080-00270576-00270734": "see what we're going to be talking about", "T_FuOvlziJY-01081-00270735-00271263": "that's that's what it is that's yeah", "T_FuOvlziJY-01082-00271264-00271510": "is this on the chaos calendar yet", "T_FuOvlziJY-01083-00271511-00271682": "it is", "T_FuOvlziJY-01084-00271683-00272095": "awesome another question um is anybody", "T_FuOvlziJY-01085-00272096-00272415": "from this call going to be at", "T_FuOvlziJY-01086-00272416-00272575": "open source summit", "T_FuOvlziJY-01087-00272576-00272967": "in austin this month yes", "T_FuOvlziJY-01088-00272968-00273406": "yes yes i will be", "T_FuOvlziJY-01089-00273407-00273797": "some many yeses many many yeses", "T_FuOvlziJY-01090-00273798-00273951": "[Music]", "T_FuOvlziJY-01091-00273952-00274127": "it would be good to find a time maybe if", "T_FuOvlziJY-01092-00274128-00274279": "we could all meet up", "T_FuOvlziJY-01093-00274280-00274510": "for our lunch or something i live right", "T_FuOvlziJY-01094-00274511-00274687": "up the street from it so i will be there", "T_FuOvlziJY-01095-00274688-00274823": "for sure", "T_FuOvlziJY-01096-00274824-00274975": "so you're local also i'm in new", "T_FuOvlziJY-01097-00274976-00275095": "braunfels", "T_FuOvlziJY-01098-00275096-00275223": "all right yeah", "T_FuOvlziJY-01099-00275224-00275575": "i'm north austin okay cool", "T_FuOvlziJY-01100-00275576-00275719": "right on", "T_FuOvlziJY-01101-00275720-00275830": "that's probably something we should talk", "T_FuOvlziJY-01102-00275831-00276015": "about in the community meeting too like", "T_FuOvlziJY-01103-00276016-00276127": "a", "T_FuOvlziJY-01104-00276128-00276358": "some larger chaos event because we don't", "T_FuOvlziJY-01105-00276359-00276519": "have chaos con", "T_FuOvlziJY-01106-00276520-00276719": "larger event meaning like a get-together", "T_FuOvlziJY-01107-00276720-00276871": "you know what i mean like lunch or", "T_FuOvlziJY-01108-00276872-00277079": "dinner or something like or underground", "T_FuOvlziJY-01109-00277080-00277406": "tours", "T_FuOvlziJY-01110-00277407-00277582": "like that underground and awesome but", "T_FuOvlziJY-01111-00277583-00277815": "there are two ghost tours", "T_FuOvlziJY-01112-00277816-00277967": "okay well that sounds", "T_FuOvlziJY-01113-00277968-00278191": "that sounds pretty cool", "T_FuOvlziJY-01114-00278192-00278558": "um all right well we do the the bat tour", "T_FuOvlziJY-01115-00278559-00278791": "well definitely the bat tour the night", "T_FuOvlziJY-01116-00278792-00279039": "at the bat bridge oh yeah bats and", "T_FuOvlziJY-01117-00279040-00279223": "ghosts", "T_FuOvlziJY-01118-00279224-00279471": "i'm not familiar with these traditions", "T_FuOvlziJY-01119-00279472-00279639": "you don't know the bat bridge", "T_FuOvlziJY-01120-00279640-00279799": "no", "T_FuOvlziJY-01121-00279800-00279975": "youtube", "T_FuOvlziJY-01122-00279976-00280375": "yeah you need to look that up", "T_FuOvlziJY-01123-00280376-00280591": "we usually do the bat bridge and then go", "T_FuOvlziJY-01124-00280592-00280799": "to chewie's down the road", "T_FuOvlziJY-01125-00280800-00281006": "for dinner", "T_FuOvlziJY-01126-00281007-00281230": "it's like the local tex-mex place that's", "T_FuOvlziJY-01127-00281231-00281487": "the all to do in austin that sounds like", "T_FuOvlziJY-01128-00281488-00281751": "we've just planned the uh the", "T_FuOvlziJY-01129-00281752-00281967": "there you go chaos get together event", "T_FuOvlziJY-01130-00281968-00282382": "bats and chewies", "T_FuOvlziJY-01131-00282383-00282543": "all right everybody we made it through", "T_FuOvlziJY-01132-00282544-00282799": "the agenda last call if anybody oh no", "T_FuOvlziJY-01133-00282800-00283151": "christie called never mind", "T_FuOvlziJY-01134-00283152-00283391": "there's a dog all right thank you thank", "T_FuOvlziJY-01135-00283392-00283740": "you thanks everybody"}}, {"audio_id": "T_YvQbIAR9k", "text": {"T_YvQbIAR9k-00000-00000000-00000511": "great marks is your truth shared", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00001-00000512-00000727": "it's something that you need to ingrain", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00002-00000728-00001195": "and bring businesses", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00003-00001196-00002498": "that's what you", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00004-00002499-00002833": "and today I want to talk to you about", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00005-00002834-00003114": "brochures and that's an interesting", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00006-00003115-00003309": "thing to talk about because normally I", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00007-00003310-00003663": "don't advocate them at all because too", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00008-00003664-00004038": "often in the past your default position", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00009-00004039-00004287": "after you got your logo done and after", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00010-00004288-00004416": "you got your website or maybe even", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00011-00004417-00004599": "before you got your website he reckoned", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00012-00004600-00004709": "you had to have a brochure because", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00013-00004710-00005025": "that's what was always done but I always", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00014-00005026-00005304": "questioned this I always wonder are you", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00015-00005305-00005502": "sure you're doing it for the right", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00016-00005503-00005816": "reasons because it's I'm always worried", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00017-00005817-00006104": "about making strategic marketing", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00018-00006105-00006300": "decisions based on what was done before", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00019-00006301-00006570": "it should never be based on the decision", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00020-00006570-00006768": "of what was done in the past because", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00021-00006769-00007089": "we're creating a new future and in the", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00022-00007090-00007269": "age that we're in which is a digital age", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00023-00007270-00007434": "and we're so used to getting things", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00024-00007434-00007683": "digitally I do ask the question of the", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00025-00007684-00007913": "need for the brochure because it often", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00026-00007914-00008301": "dates and dates very quickly but I at", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00027-00008302-00008676": "the same time I also like the idea and I", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00028-00008677-00008916": "a quick nod to Martin Neumayer here", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00029-00008917-00009146": "which is when they Zig you zag so very", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00030-00009147-00009324": "buddy else isn't sending brochures then", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00031-00009325-00009531": "it's time to consider it but once you", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00032-00009532-00009821": "consider it it's because it makes sense", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00033-00009822-00010038": "as a connection point to your customer", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00034-00010039-00010341": "and the reason I bring this up today is", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00035-00010342-00010563": "in the mayor love getting stuff in the", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00036-00010564-00010853": "mail in the mail I got a parcel okay", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00037-00010854-00011148": "just a simple envelope and it came from", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00038-00011149-00011303": "one of the people on the get strategic", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00039-00011304-00011583": "get results program and this is a shout", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00040-00011584-00011867": "out to quarry field and Michael", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00041-00011868-00012198": "Daugherty whose business it is he sent", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00042-00012199-00012371": "me this okay and I know you probably", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00043-00012372-00012659": "can't see it because it's embossed but", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00044-00012660-00012981": "this is an example of a choice that was", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00045-00012982-00013344": "made for a brochure that was something", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00046-00013344-00013605": "special because what quarry field does", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00047-00013606-00013803": "is something special", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00048-00013804-00014202": "it's horse breeders and Michael wanted", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00049-00014203-00014508": "to do something special to show what", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00050-00014509-00014624": "they did", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00051-00014625-00014936": "to tell a story and so this is not a", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00052-00014937-00015016": "brochure", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00053-00015018-00015344": "this is Volume one of a story and I", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00054-00015344-00015563": "loved that he took that approach this is", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00055-00015563-00015854": "a unique approach to doing brochures and", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00056-00015855-00016235": "sharing people the story and so when you", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00057-00016236-00016622": "get it it's very beautifully done in a", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00058-00016623-00016910": "really unusual size but it's also quite", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00059-00016911-00017231": "and it's embossed with the name and the", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00060-00017232-00017510": "brand of quarry fields and underneath it", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00061-00017511-00017903": "you can just see Volume one he wanted to", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00062-00017904-00018062": "do something special because he wanted a", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00063-00018063-00018230": "story town and I really liked that he", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00064-00018231-00018539": "did that and let me read for you a piece", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00065-00018540-00018698": "on the inside of the brochure because", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00066-00018699-00019135": "it's a way of doing it differently so", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00067-00019136-00019412": "it's all about the mayor is how he", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00068-00019413-00019589": "starts us and there's a beautiful", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00069-00019590-00019985": "picture of a mayor and the harness on", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00070-00019986-00020132": "the head of the mayor which I know I'm", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00071-00020133-00020513": "calling it incorrectly but let me read", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00072-00020514-00020774": "for you each new mayor in the life of a", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00073-00020775-00020942": "breeder takes you on a different path", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00074-00020943-00021244": "and brings new learnings they introduce", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00075-00021245-00021455": "you to new approaches new people and new", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00076-00021456-00021743": "markets the birth of a foal creates", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00077-00021744-00022040": "great suspense and instantly opens up a", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00078-00022041-00022286": "new world of possibilities in an", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00079-00022287-00022478": "industry where stallion brochures are", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00080-00022479-00022697": "abundant I felt it was time for a", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00081-00022698-00023047": "brochure dedicated solely to mayor's the", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00082-00023048-00023306": "mayors of quarry field without mayors", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00083-00023307-00023569": "there are no breeders these mayors do so", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00084-00023570-00023810": "much for us as breeders and therefore I", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00085-00023811-00024011": "feel it's fitting to profile them in", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00086-00024012-00024299": "this manner sincerely Michael Dougherty", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00087-00024300-00024788": "and he goes on to share these beautiful", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00088-00024789-00025202": "images in this beautiful book of the", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00089-00025203-00025574": "names of these amazing horses these", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00090-00025575-00025969": "amazing mares that help you understand", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00091-00025970-00026507": "the work of quarry field and if you were", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00092-00026508-00026749": "somebody who is interesting and buying", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00093-00026750-00027077": "from a breeder I think you'd be", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00094-00027077-00027362": "interested in this brochure and this is", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00095-00027363-00027821": "a wonderful way of tackling", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00096-00027822-00028161": "that whole area of dated because this is", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00097-00028162-00028395": "volume one which means there's more of", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00098-00028395-00028833": "the story to ten so how can you look at", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00099-00028833-00029136": "your printed materials differently in a", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00100-00029137-00029420": "way that tells a story that has meaning", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00101-00029421-00029792": "that has humanity that can connect with", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00102-00029793-00030030": "who you're trying to reach and tells it", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00103-00030031-00030233": "in a way that will tug at their", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00104-00030234-00030395": "heartstrings and yes ultimately we", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00105-00030396-00030582": "wanted to target the purse strings too", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00106-00030583-00030851": "but that tells a story that can build a", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00107-00030852-00031098": "brand that's what I want you to think", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00108-00031099-00031376": "about today thank you for your time and", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00109-00031377-00031523": "thank you Michael for sharing this", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00110-00031524-00031854": "wonderful book with us have a great day", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00111-00031855-00032061": "and if you want to see more and hear", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00112-00032062-00032301": "more from me and how great marketing", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00113-00032302-00032535": "works subscribe by hitting on the red", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00114-00032536-00032685": "button just in the bottom right hand", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00115-00032686-00033593": "corner how great day if you like this", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00116-00033594-00033801": "video hit the like button below and", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00117-00033802-00034017": "share it with your friends and be sure", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00118-00034018-00034185": "to subscribe and I'll see you in the", "T_YvQbIAR9k-00119-00034186-00034484": "next video"}}, {"audio_id": "TAlbuutAKgg", "text": {"TAlbuutAKgg-00000-00000056-00000305": "Victoria Jackson ran the cosmetics", "TAlbuutAKgg-00001-00000306-00000542": "business Victoria Jackson cosmetics for", "TAlbuutAKgg-00002-00000543-00000866": "many years in 2008 after her daughter", "TAlbuutAKgg-00003-00000867-00001033": "was diagnosed with neural myelitis", "TAlbuutAKgg-00004-00001034-00001303": "opteka and Mo Jackson and her husband", "TAlbuutAKgg-00005-00001304-00001457": "established the gutter Jackson", "TAlbuutAKgg-00006-00001458-00001657": "Charitable Foundation funding research", "TAlbuutAKgg-00007-00001659-00002075": "into nmo treatment and cures in 2017 she", "TAlbuutAKgg-00008-00002076-00002249": "was inducted into the National Women's", "TAlbuutAKgg-00009-00002250-00002524": "Hall of Fame in Seneca Falls New York", "TAlbuutAKgg-00010-00002525-00002774": "Jackson has written several books the", "TAlbuutAKgg-00011-00002775-00002977": "power of rare a blueprint for a medical", "TAlbuutAKgg-00012-00002978-00003293": "revolution regan arts 2017 saving each", "TAlbuutAKgg-00013-00003294-00003340": "other", "TAlbuutAKgg-00014-00003342-00003542": "a mother-daughter love story vanguard", "TAlbuutAKgg-00015-00003543-00003860": "press 2012 redefining beauty discovering", "TAlbuutAKgg-00016-00003861-00004054": "your individual beauty enhancing your", "TAlbuutAKgg-00017-00004055-00004372": "self-esteem warner books 1993 and make", "TAlbuutAKgg-00018-00004373-00004583": "up your life every woman's guide to the", "TAlbuutAKgg-00019-00004584-00005032": "power of makeup HarperCollins 2000"}}, {"audio_id": "TAr_4H0wERu", "text": {"TAr_4H0wERu-00000-00000092-00000908": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00001-00000909-00002445": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00002-00002446-00003327": "[Laughter]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00003-00003328-00005210": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00004-00005211-00005850": "[Applause]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00005-00005851-00007045": "[Laughter]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00006-00007047-00007256": "make sure you get everything make sure", "TAr_4H0wERu-00007-00007256-00007627": "you get the whole your whole body and it", "TAr_4H0wERu-00008-00007628-00007840": "works out great", "TAr_4H0wERu-00009-00007841-00008110": "no just make sure you know that", "TAr_4H0wERu-00010-00008111-00010355": "especially back he really", "TAr_4H0wERu-00011-00010356-00011721": "[Applause]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00012-00011722-00016537": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00013-00016538-00017872": "[Applause]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00014-00017873-00018187": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00015-00018188-00018464": "Robert got a little sunburned with his", "TAr_4H0wERu-00016-00018465-00018744": "hat on today put your head down Robert", "TAr_4H0wERu-00017-00018745-00019017": "it's a peace sign maybe the British flag", "TAr_4H0wERu-00018-00019018-00019464": "up there we're not sure let me see the", "TAr_4H0wERu-00019-00019465-00019670": "top of his hat see it follows the", "TAr_4H0wERu-00020-00019671-00021008": "pattern on his hat oh my gosh", "TAr_4H0wERu-00021-00021009-00023166": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00022-00023167-00025355": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00023-00025356-00025452": "Oh", "TAr_4H0wERu-00024-00025453-00026093": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00025-00026094-00026686": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00026-00026687-00028077": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00027-00028079-00028361": "[Applause]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00028-00028362-00029552": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00029-00029554-00033223": "[Laughter]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00030-00033224-00034554": "Oh", "TAr_4H0wERu-00031-00034555-00035083": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00032-00035084-00040060": "[Applause]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00033-00040061-00040430": "what would you like to say Luke", "TAr_4H0wERu-00034-00040431-00041642": "[Laughter]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00035-00041643-00043523": "[Laughter]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00036-00043524-00044584": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00037-00044585-00045488": "move Emmy daddy's gonna hurt you", "TAr_4H0wERu-00038-00045489-00047801": "[Laughter]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00039-00047802-00048792": "[Laughter]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00040-00048793-00050296": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00041-00050297-00050623": "[Laughter]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00042-00050624-00052632": "I told you", "TAr_4H0wERu-00043-00052633-00054104": "[Laughter]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00044-00054105-00054123": "[Laughter]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00045-00054124-00054876": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00046-00054877-00056313": "[Applause]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00047-00056314-00058203": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00048-00058204-00060039": "[Laughter]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00049-00060040-00060446": "[Laughter]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00050-00060447-00061200": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00051-00061201-00061474": "Robert got a little sunburned with his", "TAr_4H0wERu-00052-00061475-00061768": "hat on today put your head down Robert", "TAr_4H0wERu-00053-00061769-00062055": "if the peace sign maybe the British flag", "TAr_4H0wERu-00054-00062057-00062154": "[Applause]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00055-00062154-00062965": "[Laughter]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00056-00062966-00063329": "[Laughter]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00057-00063329-00063466": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00058-00063466-00063564": "[Applause]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00059-00063565-00064253": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00060-00064254-00066770": "[Laughter]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00061-00066771-00066906": "[Applause]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00062-00066907-00069192": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00063-00069193-00069979": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00064-00069980-00071004": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00065-00071005-00072999": "[Applause]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00066-00073000-00073270": "don't step on that waterfall", "TAr_4H0wERu-00067-00073271-00074835": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00068-00074836-00075675": "[Applause]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00069-00075676-00076228": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00070-00076229-00076789": "[Applause]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00071-00076790-00077756": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00072-00077757-00080408": "Oh", "TAr_4H0wERu-00073-00080409-00081807": "right the book was kind of dark too", "TAr_4H0wERu-00074-00081808-00085453": "[Music]", "TAr_4H0wERu-00075-00085454-00085660": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "TAA0rUx_EU8", "text": {"TAA0rUx_EU8-00000-00000254-00000526": "okay guys this is what the hair is", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00001-00000527-00000692": "looking like I've had it for about two", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00002-00000693-00000872": "weeks now and your girl has been wearing", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00003-00000873-00001160": "it out so it's developed a couple of", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00004-00001161-00001378": "snags and a couple of tangles and it's", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00005-00001379-00001556": "gotten a little bit drier so we're just", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00006-00001557-00001922": "gonna go ahead and wash this thing", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00007-00001923-00004242": "[Music]", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00008-00004243-00004513": "so for washing it today I'm going to be", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00009-00004514-00004708": "using this Co wash and I talked about it", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00010-00004709-00004990": "in one of my other videos and I love", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00011-00004991-00005152": "this call wash I use it on my bundles", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00012-00005153-00005359": "and on my hair because it just makes the", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00013-00005360-00005536": "hair so easy to get through and just so", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00014-00005537-00006803": "soft", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00015-00006804-00008489": "[Music]", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00016-00008490-00008742": "so instead of using a wide tooth comb to", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00017-00008743-00008931": "detangle today I just opted to use my", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00018-00008932-00009096": "hands because you know why else would I", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00019-00009097-00009501": "have these claws um but no I used my", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00020-00009502-00009635": "hands because when I was using at home", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00021-00009636-00009882": "it was being super harsh on the hair and", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00022-00009883-00010182": "it was really pulling at it and I did", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00023-00010183-00010314": "use the glue method if you guys remember", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00024-00010315-00010593": "to make this wig so I wanted to be as", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00025-00010594-00010839": "gentle as possible so no tracks came out", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00026-00010840-00011133": "and you will see a little bit on that a", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00027-00011134-00011358": "track did kind of slip out but it was", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00028-00011359-00011559": "little so I just clipped it but you want", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00029-00011560-00011799": "to be careful that no like full track", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00030-00011800-00013236": "falls out of the way", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00031-00013237-00013932": "you", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00032-00013933-00016640": "[Music]", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00033-00016641-00017007": "so I'm tangling again and I'm making", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00034-00017008-00017280": "sure to really get in the nape of the", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00035-00017281-00017448": "wig and if you're not sure with the nape", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00036-00017449-00017670": "is it's where the hair meets your neck", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00037-00017671-00017961": "and I know for me I sweat a lot sorry if", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00038-00017962-00018105": "that's you know TMI", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00039-00018106-00018255": "so that part tends to get the most", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00040-00018256-00018483": "tangled so I really took my time working", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00041-00018484-00018735": "the tangles out of that", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00042-00018736-00019436": "[Music]", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00043-00019437-00021277": "[Music]", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00044-00021278-00021608": "so now I'm going in with this shame once", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00045-00021609-00021860": "you're deep treatment mask and it's an", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00046-00021861-00022072": "eisley a leaving conditioner but I", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00047-00022073-00022283": "figure what's the harm you know like", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00048-00022284-00022541": "it's a wig huh and I just like the way", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00049-00022542-00022961": "it makes my hair feel so now we're gonna", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00050-00022962-00023161": "go in with this cam to twist along jail", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00051-00023162-00023435": "and of course it is but when you're", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00052-00023436-00023699": "twisting your hair or locking it but I", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00053-00023700-00023869": "found that it's the most efficient and", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00054-00023870-00024439": "keeping my girls super defined", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00055-00024440-00025356": "[Music]", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00056-00025357-00025644": "lastly I'm going in with this eco styler", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00057-00025645-00025885": "gel and this is literally the only line", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00058-00025886-00026064": "of gel gyu's in them like I can't get", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00059-00026066-00026224": "with any other bottle like for real", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00060-00026225-00026437": "um so when I'm putting this on the hair", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00061-00026438-00026608": "I'm not gonna rake it through like I did", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00062-00026608-00026776": "the other products I'm gonna take the", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00063-00026777-00027102": "hair from the bottom and scrunch up", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00064-00027104-00027819": "[Music]", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00065-00027820-00028126": "detangling with a actual brush this time", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00066-00028127-00028437": "just one last time and then this is how", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00067-00028438-00028693": "the hair is looking as you can see it's", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00068-00028694-00028927": "much shinier and there's no tangles in", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00069-00028927-00029133": "it so I just let that sit overnight and", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00070-00029135-00029317": "I will be right back to show you guys", "TAA0rUx_EU8-00071-00029318-00029557": "how I"}}, {"audio_id": "TBmXDvj6ts8", "text": {"TBmXDvj6ts8-00000-00000179-00000430": "Venezuelans sign language or VSL", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00001-00000431-00000730": "language Acehnese venez Ilana are lsv is", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00002-00000731-00000916": "the National deaf sign language of", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00003-00000917-00001270": "Venezuela the term Venezuelan sign", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00004-00001271-00001556": "language began to be used in the 1930s", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00005-00001557-00001862": "it is widely used and Venezuela has a", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00006-00001863-00002101": "national bilingual education program for", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00007-00002102-00002350": "VSL and Spanish though the language used", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00008-00002351-00002509": "by adults differs from that of the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00009-00002510-00002767": "classroom there is a large VSL", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00010-00002768-00002983": "dictionary published by the Federation", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00011-00002984-00003331": "venez Alana disorders ESL has been used", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00012-00003332-00003704": "in schools since 1937", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00013-00003705-00004272": "origin the first known references to a", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00014-00004273-00004441": "deaf community which used a sign", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00015-00004442-00004629": "language in Venezuela date from the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00016-00004630-00005013": "1930s in 1935 the first school for", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00017-00005014-00005224": "children with hearing difficulties the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00018-00005225-00005481": "instituto venez hola no de CA goes why", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00019-00005482-00005721": "Sordo mu dos Venezuelan blind and deaf", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00020-00005722-00006010": "institute was founded in caracas that", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00021-00006011-00006213": "school served as the cradle for a small", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00022-00006214-00006438": "community of signers who created a sign", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00023-00006439-00006624": "language out of many signs which the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00024-00006625-00006883": "children had used at home a few years", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00025-00006884-00007045": "later the administration of the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00026-00007045-00007234": "Institute decided to separate the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00027-00007234-00007438": "instruction of blind and deaf students", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00028-00007439-00007654": "and created the escuela taller disorder", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00029-00007655-00007837": "mu dos workshop school for the pre", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00030-00007838-00008113": "lingually deaf this school hired hearing", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00031-00008114-00008287": "teachers trained in Spain who knew", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00032-00008288-00008545": "Spanish sign language the mingling of", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00033-00008546-00008743": "the system developed by the students and", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00034-00008744-00008928": "the language used by the teachers seems", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00035-00008929-00009370": "to be the origin of what is today BSL in", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00036-00009371-00009676": "1950 the first generation of alumni of", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00037-00009677-00009891": "the schools founded the Association", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00038-00009892-00010087": "disorder Muto's de carajás death", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00039-00010088-00010291": "Association of Caracas under the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00040-00010292-00010498": "direction of Jose arquero Urbano", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00041-00010499-00010660": "an immigrant who had been a leader of", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00042-00010661-00010878": "the deaf community in Madrid the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00043-00010879-00011049": "influence of the signs brought by our", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00044-00011050-00011349": "Cairo further transformed BSL according", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00045-00011350-00011538": "to recollections collected from people", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00046-00011539-00011688": "involved in that period of the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00047-00011689-00011926": "association because of this many", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00048-00011927-00012142": "Venezuelan deaf people assume that our", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00049-00012143-00012574": "Cairo was the creator of ESL legal", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00050-00012575-00013191": "status in 1999 after intensive lobbying", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00051-00013193-00013438": "by the deaf associations of Venezuela", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00052-00013438-00013650": "the Constituent Assembly included two", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00053-00013651-00013852": "references to LSB in the current", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00054-00013853-00014152": "constitution of Venezuela article 81", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00055-00014153-00014377": "recognizes the right of deaf people to", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00056-00014378-00014644": "communicate through LSB and article 101", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00057-00014644-00014850": "establishes that deaf people have the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00058-00014851-00015009": "right to be informed in their language", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00059-00015010-00015366": "through public and private television", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00060-00015366-00015681": "lsv nevertheless retains a lower legal", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00061-00015682-00015850": "status than the language officially", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00062-00015851-00016155": "recognized by the Constitution article 9", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00063-00016156-00016402": "grants the status event official", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00064-00016403-00016642": "language to Spanish throughout the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00065-00016643-00016837": "nation and to native languages in the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00066-00016838-00017013": "ancestral territories", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00067-00017014-00017260": "lsv does not receive such recognition", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00068-00017261-00017530": "the Constitution only recognizes the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00069-00017531-00018391": "right to use LSB lsv studies studies on", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00070-00018392-00018628": "lsv indicate that the language has the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00071-00018629-00018832": "same structural elements described in", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00072-00018833-00019044": "other sign languages such as the use of", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00073-00019045-00019267": "directional signs the use of signs with", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00074-00019268-00019497": "classifiers changes in the form of the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00075-00019498-00019719": "sign to indicate mood and aspect and a", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00076-00019720-00019905": "strong pragmatical dependence in", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00077-00019906-00020200": "defining argument roles in addition as a", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00078-00020201-00020452": "result of Studies on the grammar of LSB", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00079-00020453-00020644": "there has also been research into the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00080-00020645-00020893": "psycholinguistics sociolinguistics and", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00081-00020894-00021078": "ethnolinguistics of the deaf community", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00082-00021079-00021294": "in the country", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00083-00021295-00021964": "number of lsv users included among the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00084-00021965-00022189": "users of LSB are both the Deaf who use", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00085-00022190-00022369": "the language as their principal means of", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00086-00022370-00022555": "communication and hearing people who", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00087-00022556-00022972": "have a range of fluency in lsv the", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00088-00022973-00023260": "number of users is unknown there are 1.2", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00089-00023261-00023484": "million deaf in Venezuela but most lost", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00090-00023485-00023712": "their hearing late in life there were", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00091-00023713-00023974": "over 3,000 deaf children in the national", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00092-00023975-00024250": "public school system in 2004 and around", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00093-00024251-00024519": "9,000 members of deaf associations with", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00094-00024520-00024799": "around 0.2 percent of children typically", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00095-00024800-00024947": "born deaf there are an estimated", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00096-00024948-00025216": "congenitally 15,000 deaf people in", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00097-00025217-00025509": "Venezuela however it is not known how", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00098-00025510-00026039": "many of them speak VSL", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00099-00026039-00026968": "references external links vocabulary", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00100-00026969-00027083": "list in BSL", "TBmXDvj6ts8-00101-00027083-00027364": "in spanish"}}, {"audio_id": "TBuZWHzY1uU", "text": {"TBuZWHzY1uU-00000-00000425-00001470": "[Music]", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00001-00001471-00001519": "i'm", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00002-00001520-00001823": "general gangish khan schmitz", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00003-00001823-00002142": "i scare children out of their wits", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00004-00002143-00002375": "but you'll see it's a glance sir my", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00005-00002376-00002583": "school's the answer for", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00006-00002584-00003110": "sure and dreamers and twits", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00007-00003111-00003495": "and in this case i'd say the", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00008-00003496-00003854": "shoe face", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00009-00003855-00004206": "ten hot feet together chin up eyes on", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00010-00004207-00004870": "the prize", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00011-00004871-00005143": "the military academy is the place where", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00012-00005144-00005270": "he should be set", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00013-00005271-00005470": "we'll drill the silliness from his head", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00014-00005471-00005663": "i'm sure we'll make a dent", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00015-00005664-00006151": "we'll teach", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00016-00006152-00006831": "[Music]", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00017-00006831-00007223": "the military", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00018-00007223-00008663": "on it", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00019-00008664-00008959": "all boys believe in the rights of every", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00020-00008960-00009046": "hoot to", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00021-00009047-00009446": "eat their bread butter stand up", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00022-00009447-00009710": "one thing we trust on this fragile speck", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00023-00009711-00009791": "of dust", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00024-00009792-00010214": "is entangled", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00025-00010215-00010423": "and as for those who like their butter", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00026-00010424-00010606": "down", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00027-00010607-00011455": "we'll go to the mouth of town", "TBuZWHzY1uU-00028-00011456-00011664": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "TBwm28V4jMu", "text": {"TBwm28V4jMu-00000-00000008-00000206": "hello everyone and welcome to this", "TBwm28V4jMu-00001-00000208-00000471": "week's tomorrow news so glad to have you", "TBwm28V4jMu-00002-00000472-00000511": "here", "TBwm28V4jMu-00003-00000512-00000655": "we've got ryan who's going to be talking", "TBwm28V4jMu-00004-00000656-00000886": "a little bit about spacex hopping around", "TBwm28V4jMu-00005-00000888-00001070": "i'm going to be discussing commercial", "TBwm28V4jMu-00006-00001071-00001287": "crew at nasa and some", "TBwm28V4jMu-00007-00001288-00001519": "things that may not be settled quite", "TBwm28V4jMu-00008-00001520-00001751": "just yet and we've got our weekly space", "TBwm28V4jMu-00009-00001752-00001839": "weather with dr", "TBwm28V4jMu-00010-00001839-00002039": "tamatha scove and before we get started", "TBwm28V4jMu-00011-00002039-00002183": "of course just want to remind you that", "TBwm28V4jMu-00012-00002184-00002367": "if you like what we do here at tomorrow", "TBwm28V4jMu-00013-00002368-00002431": "don't forget", "TBwm28V4jMu-00014-00002432-00002639": "to subscribe to us hit the notification", "TBwm28V4jMu-00015-00002640-00002815": "bell like this video and share it", "TBwm28V4jMu-00016-00002816-00002999": "everywhere you can because every little", "TBwm28V4jMu-00017-00003000-00003222": "bit helps in getting us in front of", "TBwm28V4jMu-00018-00003223-00003359": "folks in order to tell", "TBwm28V4jMu-00019-00003360-00003503": "everybody about the universe and", "TBwm28V4jMu-00020-00003504-00003663": "everything that's happening in it", "TBwm28V4jMu-00021-00003664-00003895": "so let's go ahead and get started with", "TBwm28V4jMu-00022-00003896-00004135": "your tomorrow news for august 7th", "TBwm28V4jMu-00023-00004136-00004415": "2020 and ryan let's go ahead and get", "TBwm28V4jMu-00024-00004416-00004551": "hopping", "TBwm28V4jMu-00025-00004552-00004783": "they're home doug hurley and bob benkin", "TBwm28V4jMu-00026-00004784-00005079": "both smashed down at exactly 1848 and", "TBwm28V4jMu-00027-00005080-00005295": "six seconds coordinated universal time", "TBwm28V4jMu-00028-00005296-00005431": "on the second of august", "TBwm28V4jMu-00029-00005432-00005631": "ending their historic two-month-long", "TBwm28V4jMu-00030-00005632-00005822": "mission to the international space", "TBwm28V4jMu-00031-00005823-00005918": "station", "TBwm28V4jMu-00032-00005919-00006231": "to which it was docked to for over 63", "TBwm28V4jMu-00033-00006232-00006302": "days", "TBwm28V4jMu-00034-00006303-00006606": "and nine hours nasa astronauts bob and", "TBwm28V4jMu-00035-00006608-00006646": "doug", "TBwm28V4jMu-00036-00006647-00006863": "half of the spacex and nasa teams", "TBwm28V4jMu-00037-00006864-00007039": "welcome back to planet earth and thanks", "TBwm28V4jMu-00038-00007040-00007319": "for flying spacex", "TBwm28V4jMu-00039-00007320-00007559": "it should also be noted that a number of", "TBwm28V4jMu-00040-00007559-00007767": "private boats were a round dragon at", "TBwm28V4jMu-00041-00007768-00007959": "this time which could have led to some", "TBwm28V4jMu-00042-00007959-00008183": "less than ideal situations", "TBwm28V4jMu-00043-00008184-00008455": "as because of dragon's hypergolic fuels", "TBwm28V4jMu-00044-00008456-00008663": "a lot of people could have been exposed", "TBwm28V4jMu-00045-00008664-00008942": "to hazardous chemicals this has then led", "TBwm28V4jMu-00046-00008943-00009159": "to the coast guard releasing a statement", "TBwm28V4jMu-00047-00009160-00009423": "on the whole ordeal who has said that", "TBwm28V4jMu-00048-00009424-00009623": "the development of lessons learned will", "TBwm28V4jMu-00049-00009624-00009759": "be our priority", "TBwm28V4jMu-00050-00009760-00010031": "moving forward i wonder exactly how long", "TBwm28V4jMu-00051-00010032-00010206": "it will take for the next crew", "TBwm28V4jMu-00052-00010207-00010487": "to fly spacex because spacex and nasa", "TBwm28V4jMu-00053-00010488-00010687": "have said no earlier than late september", "TBwm28V4jMu-00054-00010688-00010727": "but", "TBwm28V4jMu-00055-00010728-00010974": "we just want a date this is an enormous", "TBwm28V4jMu-00056-00010975-00011174": "accomplishment for the entire spacex", "TBwm28V4jMu-00057-00011175-00011374": "team and commercial crew program and so", "TBwm28V4jMu-00058-00011375-00011551": "the first time in history a commercial", "TBwm28V4jMu-00059-00011552-00011614": "entity", "TBwm28V4jMu-00060-00011615-00011838": "has designed manufactured launched and", "TBwm28V4jMu-00061-00011839-00012038": "landed their own spacecraft with humans", "TBwm28V4jMu-00062-00012039-00012135": "inside", "TBwm28V4jMu-00063-00012136-00012319": "and at the same time everything launched", "TBwm28V4jMu-00064-00012320-00012470": "apart from the second stage and the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00065-00012471-00012519": "trunk", "TBwm28V4jMu-00066-00012520-00012846": "has been completely recovered amazing", "TBwm28V4jMu-00067-00012847-00013007": "and the other reusable vehicle that", "TBwm28V4jMu-00068-00013008-00013175": "spacex are currently developing", "TBwm28V4jMu-00069-00013176-00013391": "starship has just completed a static", "TBwm28V4jMu-00070-00013391-00013686": "fire in the form of its sn5 version", "TBwm28V4jMu-00071-00013687-00013855": "the raptor fired for only a couple", "TBwm28V4jMu-00072-00013856-00014758": "seconds but oh my it does sound powerful", "TBwm28V4jMu-00073-00014759-00014958": "the old fins that were attached to the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00074-00014959-00015166": "mark one starship vehicle has just been", "TBwm28V4jMu-00075-00015168-00015294": "picked up and worked on", "TBwm28V4jMu-00076-00015295-00015511": "as they could be used on sn5 or any", "TBwm28V4jMu-00077-00015512-00017055": "other future generation of starship", "TBwm28V4jMu-00078-00017056-00017327": "as well as a static fire sn5 has also", "TBwm28V4jMu-00079-00017328-00017511": "gone slightly further", "TBwm28V4jMu-00080-00017512-00017743": "firing its single raptor engine the 9", "TBwm28V4jMu-00081-00017744-00017967": "meter wide stainless steel pipe made its", "TBwm28V4jMu-00082-00017968-00018207": "way up to 150 meters", "TBwm28V4jMu-00083-00018208-00018430": "whilst translating itself over towards", "TBwm28V4jMu-00084-00018431-00018519": "the ocean", "TBwm28V4jMu-00085-00018520-00018694": "on its way back down you can see the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00086-00018695-00018911": "little landing legs flipping out just in", "TBwm28V4jMu-00087-00018912-00019127": "time for its smooth touchdown", "TBwm28V4jMu-00088-00019128-00019319": "this comes after a year of waiting", "TBwm28V4jMu-00089-00019320-00019503": "between flights in boca chica", "TBwm28V4jMu-00090-00019504-00019663": "so let's hope the next one comes a", "TBwm28V4jMu-00091-00019664-00019839": "little bit quicker the different", "TBwm28V4jMu-00092-00019840-00020047": "sections of serial number eight are also", "TBwm28V4jMu-00093-00020048-00020135": "coming together", "TBwm28V4jMu-00094-00020136-00020391": "as construction of sn8 is getting well", "TBwm28V4jMu-00095-00020392-00020558": "underway in the southern texas", "TBwm28V4jMu-00096-00020559-00020622": "settlement", "TBwm28V4jMu-00097-00020623-00020863": "thanks ryan it's been about a month", "TBwm28V4jMu-00098-00020864-00021094": "since an anomaly on board of a rocket", "TBwm28V4jMu-00099-00021095-00021303": "lab electron ended its flight", "TBwm28V4jMu-00100-00021304-00021494": "on july 4th and the company says that", "TBwm28V4jMu-00101-00021495-00021703": "they now have found the root of the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00102-00021704-00021758": "problem", "TBwm28V4jMu-00103-00021759-00021967": "unlike most rockets electron uses", "TBwm28V4jMu-00104-00021968-00022150": "battery powered electrically driven", "TBwm28V4jMu-00105-00022151-00022247": "turbo pumps", "TBwm28V4jMu-00106-00022248-00022519": "to move fuel and oxidizer into its", "TBwm28V4jMu-00107-00022520-00022663": "rutherford engines", "TBwm28V4jMu-00108-00022664-00022855": "five and a half minutes in the ascent an", "TBwm28V4jMu-00109-00022856-00023055": "electrical connector that supplied power", "TBwm28V4jMu-00110-00023056-00023255": "from the battery to the turbo pumps of", "TBwm28V4jMu-00111-00023256-00023439": "electron's second stage engine", "TBwm28V4jMu-00112-00023440-00023527": "disconnected", "TBwm28V4jMu-00113-00023528-00023703": "that killed the power and caused a", "TBwm28V4jMu-00114-00023704-00023903": "premature shutdown of the engine", "TBwm28V4jMu-00115-00023904-00024094": "now having not yet achieved orbital", "TBwm28V4jMu-00116-00024095-00024327": "velocity the second stage along with its", "TBwm28V4jMu-00117-00024328-00024471": "seven satellite payload", "TBwm28V4jMu-00118-00024472-00024799": "peaked at 195 kilometers then re-entered", "TBwm28V4jMu-00119-00024800-00024991": "the earth's atmosphere and broke apart", "TBwm28V4jMu-00120-00024992-00025175": "likely burning up before it hit the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00121-00025176-00025335": "ocean now there was 25", "TBwm28V4jMu-00122-00025336-00025511": "000 channels of telemetry coming from", "TBwm28V4jMu-00123-00025512-00025718": "the electron rocket and it continued", "TBwm28V4jMu-00124-00025719-00025974": "to downlink all of that even after the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00125-00025975-00026070": "premature engine", "TBwm28V4jMu-00126-00026072-00026279": "shutdown so that actually allowed", "TBwm28V4jMu-00127-00026280-00026423": "engineers at rocket lab", "TBwm28V4jMu-00128-00026424-00026623": "to zero in on the problem very very", "TBwm28V4jMu-00129-00026624-00026743": "quickly and figure out", "TBwm28V4jMu-00130-00026744-00026902": "what was the next step to take", "TBwm28V4jMu-00131-00026904-00027118": "pre-flight testing procedures did not", "TBwm28V4jMu-00132-00027119-00027262": "catch the problem that caused the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00133-00027263-00027383": "electrical connector", "TBwm28V4jMu-00134-00027383-00027639": "to disconnect material that helps secure", "TBwm28V4jMu-00135-00027639-00027823": "the connector from vibration", "TBwm28V4jMu-00136-00027824-00028079": "also did not secure it from vibration", "TBwm28V4jMu-00137-00028080-00028279": "and there was also a higher resistance", "TBwm28V4jMu-00138-00028280-00028431": "at one of the connectors joints", "TBwm28V4jMu-00139-00028432-00028607": "and higher resistance generates more", "TBwm28V4jMu-00140-00028608-00028807": "heat and those high temperatures finally", "TBwm28V4jMu-00141-00028808-00028927": "did the connector in", "TBwm28V4jMu-00142-00028927-00029102": "the rocket lab was able to recreate the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00143-00029104-00029302": "issue on the ground because of all the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00144-00029304-00029455": "great data that they had", "TBwm28V4jMu-00145-00029456-00029655": "so now the engineers know precisely what", "TBwm28V4jMu-00146-00029656-00029846": "to look for during the pre-flight checks", "TBwm28V4jMu-00147-00029847-00030031": "to make sure this doesn't happen again", "TBwm28V4jMu-00148-00030032-00030214": "and rocket lab is looking at doing its", "TBwm28V4jMu-00149-00030216-00030383": "return to flight mission sometime this", "TBwm28V4jMu-00150-00030383-00030431": "month", "TBwm28V4jMu-00151-00030432-00030639": "and next month in september they're", "TBwm28V4jMu-00152-00030639-00030823": "looking at doing their first mission out", "TBwm28V4jMu-00153-00030824-00030943": "of wallops island", "TBwm28V4jMu-00154-00030944-00031207": "in virginia in a nice surprise rocket", "TBwm28V4jMu-00155-00031208-00031318": "lab announced that", "TBwm28V4jMu-00156-00031319-00031558": "thanks to newer battery technologies", "TBwm28V4jMu-00157-00031560-00031623": "delivering", "TBwm28V4jMu-00158-00031624-00031814": "improved performance their electron", "TBwm28V4jMu-00159-00031816-00032007": "rocket is now capable of lifting", "TBwm28V4jMu-00160-00032008-00032287": "more to orbit originally putting 150", "TBwm28V4jMu-00161-00032288-00032518": "kilograms into a 500 kilometer sun", "TBwm28V4jMu-00162-00032519-00032614": "synchronous orbit", "TBwm28V4jMu-00163-00032616-00032943": "electron is now capable of a solid 200", "TBwm28V4jMu-00164-00032944-00033111": "kilograms to sun synchronous", "TBwm28V4jMu-00165-00033112-00033446": "and improves from 225 kilograms in lower", "TBwm28V4jMu-00166-00033447-00033502": "orbits", "TBwm28V4jMu-00167-00033503-00033767": "to a hefty 300 kilograms of payload into", "TBwm28V4jMu-00168-00033768-00033862": "those orbits", "TBwm28V4jMu-00169-00033863-00034023": "rocket lab wasn't the only company", "TBwm28V4jMu-00170-00034024-00034239": "dealing with an anomaly virgin orbits", "TBwm28V4jMu-00171-00034240-00034446": "launcher one in its first test flight", "TBwm28V4jMu-00172-00034447-00034759": "really didn't run very long", "TBwm28V4jMu-00173-00034760-00034974": "but there was a lot of data gathered", "TBwm28V4jMu-00174-00034975-00035079": "during that test", "TBwm28V4jMu-00175-00035080-00035415": "and a lot of success and on may 25th", "TBwm28V4jMu-00176-00035416-00035630": "virgin orbit conducted the first test", "TBwm28V4jMu-00177-00035631-00035815": "flight of their launcher 1 rocket", "TBwm28V4jMu-00178-00035816-00036062": "successfully deploying it from their 747", "TBwm28V4jMu-00179-00036063-00036174": "cosmic girl", "TBwm28V4jMu-00180-00036175-00036374": "engine ignition went smoothly but", "TBwm28V4jMu-00181-00036375-00036502": "shortly after", "TBwm28V4jMu-00182-00036503-00036718": "a high pressure feed line broke the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00183-00036719-00036911": "engine was starved of liquid oxygen", "TBwm28V4jMu-00184-00036912-00037167": "and shut down as per safety rules the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00185-00037168-00037374": "launcher one's flight was terminated", "TBwm28V4jMu-00186-00037375-00037559": "but virgin orbit noted that their", "TBwm28V4jMu-00187-00037560-00037711": "countdown went smoothly", "TBwm28V4jMu-00188-00037712-00037895": "that their work in determining the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00189-00037896-00038143": "aerodynamics interactions and control", "TBwm28V4jMu-00190-00038144-00038207": "systems", "TBwm28V4jMu-00191-00038208-00038455": "was verified as accurately modeled that", "TBwm28V4jMu-00192-00038456-00038630": "the newton 3 main engine", "TBwm28V4jMu-00193-00038631-00038902": "ignited and that the rocket began its", "TBwm28V4jMu-00194-00038903-00039039": "planned trajectory", "TBwm28V4jMu-00195-00039040-00039223": "the company already has a second", "TBwm28V4jMu-00196-00039224-00039367": "launcher one vehicle going through", "TBwm28V4jMu-00197-00039368-00039511": "integration and they expect", "TBwm28V4jMu-00198-00039512-00039702": "one more test flight before the end of", "TBwm28V4jMu-00199-00039703-00039927": "2020 so hopefully they have some good", "TBwm28V4jMu-00200-00039928-00040118": "success then and virgin orbit isn't the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00201-00040119-00040246": "only part of the virgin brand that's", "TBwm28V4jMu-00202-00040247-00040407": "undergoing test flights at the moment", "TBwm28V4jMu-00203-00040408-00040590": "virgin galactic is about to start", "TBwm28V4jMu-00204-00040591-00040799": "a campaign of its own thanks to delays", "TBwm28V4jMu-00205-00040800-00041007": "from the covid19 pandemic virgin", "TBwm28V4jMu-00206-00041008-00041143": "galactic now says", "TBwm28V4jMu-00207-00041144-00041295": "that the first commercial flights for", "TBwm28V4jMu-00208-00041296-00041518": "their spaceship 2 suborbital space plane", "TBwm28V4jMu-00209-00041519-00041799": "will begin in 2021 which is about six", "TBwm28V4jMu-00210-00041800-00041895": "months out", "TBwm28V4jMu-00211-00041896-00042111": "two power test flights the first from", "TBwm28V4jMu-00212-00042112-00042311": "spaceport america and new mexico will be", "TBwm28V4jMu-00213-00042312-00042383": "conducted", "TBwm28V4jMu-00214-00042384-00042558": "the first of those test flights will", "TBwm28V4jMu-00215-00042559-00042783": "have two pilots along with payloads from", "TBwm28V4jMu-00216-00042784-00043015": "nasa's flight opportunities program", "TBwm28V4jMu-00217-00043016-00043246": "the second test flight will be much more", "TBwm28V4jMu-00218-00043247-00043327": "ambitious", "TBwm28V4jMu-00219-00043328-00043615": "two pilots and four mission specialists", "TBwm28V4jMu-00220-00043616-00043702": "whose job", "TBwm28V4jMu-00221-00043703-00043927": "it will be to evaluate the newly", "TBwm28V4jMu-00222-00043928-00044015": "unveiled", "TBwm28V4jMu-00223-00044016-00044351": "customer cabin inside of spaceship two", "TBwm28V4jMu-00224-00044352-00044615": "gosh i mean i really want to take a ride", "TBwm28V4jMu-00225-00044616-00044830": "on a rocket to space as a part of my job", "TBwm28V4jMu-00226-00044831-00045055": "if all goes well a third powered test", "TBwm28V4jMu-00227-00045056-00045279": "flight will occur in early 2021", "TBwm28V4jMu-00228-00045280-00045462": "and that will have sir richard branson", "TBwm28V4jMu-00229-00045463-00045702": "abort i do wonder though who will be", "TBwm28V4jMu-00230-00045703-00045951": "on that fourth powered flight would you", "TBwm28V4jMu-00231-00045952-00046046": "take that ride", "TBwm28V4jMu-00232-00046047-00046199": "would you put something on that ride", "TBwm28V4jMu-00233-00046200-00046383": "like a memento or an experiment that", "TBwm28V4jMu-00234-00046384-00046495": "you'd want to fly", "TBwm28V4jMu-00235-00046496-00046679": "personally i'd put myself there it", "TBwm28V4jMu-00236-00046680-00046823": "sounds like a really good adventure if", "TBwm28V4jMu-00237-00046824-00046895": "you ask me", "TBwm28V4jMu-00238-00046896-00047055": "let me know what you do in the comments", "TBwm28V4jMu-00239-00047056-00047230": "below gosh there's been a lot of test", "TBwm28V4jMu-00240-00047231-00047358": "flights hasn't there you know crew", "TBwm28V4jMu-00241-00047359-00047590": "dragon endeavor virgin galactic virgin", "TBwm28V4jMu-00242-00047591-00047671": "orbit", "TBwm28V4jMu-00243-00047672-00047967": "boeing starliner and yeah starliner", "TBwm28V4jMu-00244-00047968-00048143": "remember that", "TBwm28V4jMu-00245-00048144-00048415": "yeah it's back and uh yeah we're going", "TBwm28V4jMu-00246-00048416-00048735": "to be talking safety about it again", "TBwm28V4jMu-00247-00048736-00048911": "it just seems to be a never-ending", "TBwm28V4jMu-00248-00048912-00049127": "stream of bad news for boeing's capsule", "TBwm28V4jMu-00249-00049128-00049374": "there's almost always a now what and how", "TBwm28V4jMu-00250-00049375-00049486": "much more is it going to cost", "TBwm28V4jMu-00251-00049487-00049686": "dread sweeping across whenever i hear", "TBwm28V4jMu-00252-00049687-00049807": "starliner uttered", "TBwm28V4jMu-00253-00049808-00050023": "and nasa's aerospace safety advisory", "TBwm28V4jMu-00254-00050024-00050143": "panel has both", "TBwm28V4jMu-00255-00050144-00050407": "praise and grievances in a report", "TBwm28V4jMu-00256-00050408-00050574": "released by the panel they note that", "TBwm28V4jMu-00257-00050575-00050823": "boeing has made real tangible progress", "TBwm28V4jMu-00258-00050824-00050999": "in fixing starliner's issues", "TBwm28V4jMu-00259-00051000-00051190": "but that lingering concerns regarding", "TBwm28V4jMu-00260-00051191-00051390": "quality control are still present", "TBwm28V4jMu-00261-00051391-00051590": "one example was the parachute failure", "TBwm28V4jMu-00262-00051591-00051735": "that occurred during last year's", "TBwm28V4jMu-00263-00051736-00051807": "successful", "TBwm28V4jMu-00264-00051808-00052046": "starliner pad abort test its cause was", "TBwm28V4jMu-00265-00052047-00052207": "traced to a missing pin", "TBwm28V4jMu-00266-00052208-00052607": "a missing pin of all things geez", "TBwm28V4jMu-00267-00052608-00052823": "even though boeing was decidedly the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00268-00052824-00053015": "focus of that report", "TBwm28V4jMu-00269-00053016-00053223": "spacex did not exactly get out of it", "TBwm28V4jMu-00270-00053224-00053326": "scot-free i mean", "TBwm28V4jMu-00271-00053327-00053550": "they got their feet held to the fire a", "TBwm28V4jMu-00272-00053551-00053750": "little bit it was only just a few weeks", "TBwm28V4jMu-00273-00053751-00053975": "ago that nasa announced a reversal of", "TBwm28V4jMu-00274-00053976-00054191": "their decision on spacex's crew dragon", "TBwm28V4jMu-00275-00054191-00054279": "operations", "TBwm28V4jMu-00276-00054279-00054454": "saying that they would now allow for", "TBwm28V4jMu-00277-00054455-00054591": "reuse of crew dragon", "TBwm28V4jMu-00278-00054591-00054815": "and falcon 9 stage ones for commercial", "TBwm28V4jMu-00279-00054816-00054911": "crew flights", "TBwm28V4jMu-00280-00054912-00055135": "the panel noted that nasa would now have", "TBwm28V4jMu-00281-00055136-00055335": "to adapt their human certification", "TBwm28V4jMu-00282-00055336-00055454": "requirements for this", "TBwm28V4jMu-00283-00055455-00055654": "and for spacex's philosophy of", "TBwm28V4jMu-00284-00055655-00055847": "incremental upgrades to vehicles", "TBwm28V4jMu-00285-00055848-00056054": "meaning safety related processes that", "TBwm28V4jMu-00286-00056055-00056230": "require a large amount of time", "TBwm28V4jMu-00287-00056232-00056487": "budget and oversight could be strained", "TBwm28V4jMu-00288-00056488-00056582": "consider it a", "TBwm28V4jMu-00289-00056583-00056815": "word of advice from the panel to nasa", "TBwm28V4jMu-00290-00056816-00056999": "that the agency should make sure that it", "TBwm28V4jMu-00291-00057000-00057238": "is prepared to take on the consequences", "TBwm28V4jMu-00292-00057239-00057471": "of what these changes entail across the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00293-00057472-00057679": "board i do genuinely hope to start", "TBwm28V4jMu-00294-00057679-00057815": "hearing more positive", "TBwm28V4jMu-00295-00057816-00058038": "updates coming out of boeing and in", "TBwm28V4jMu-00296-00058039-00058126": "addition to that", "TBwm28V4jMu-00297-00058127-00058366": "some details from nasa about their reuse", "TBwm28V4jMu-00298-00058367-00058430": "with", "TBwm28V4jMu-00299-00058432-00058623": "spacex and there are some updates that i", "TBwm28V4jMu-00300-00058624-00058791": "bet you're particularly interested in", "TBwm28V4jMu-00301-00058791-00058950": "and it would be our launches", "TBwm28V4jMu-00302-00058951-00059230": "in this week's space traffic lifting off", "TBwm28V4jMu-00303-00059232-00059487": "on july 30th at 11 50 universal time", "TBwm28V4jMu-00304-00059488-00059735": "from slick 41 at the cape canaveral air", "TBwm28V4jMu-00305-00059736-00059838": "force station", "TBwm28V4jMu-00306-00059839-00060111": "nasa's next mars rover perseverance and", "TBwm28V4jMu-00307-00060112-00060166": "the first", "TBwm28V4jMu-00308-00060167-00060454": "mars helicopter ingenuity left earth for", "TBwm28V4jMu-00309-00060455-00060542": "good with the help", "TBwm28V4jMu-00310-00060544-00060782": "of the united launch alliance atlas 5", "TBwm28V4jMu-00311-00060783-00060999": "and the 541 configuration", "TBwm28V4jMu-00312-00061000-00061215": "meaning the atlas 5 was flown with a 5", "TBwm28V4jMu-00313-00061216-00061342": "meter payload fairing", "TBwm28V4jMu-00314-00061344-00061559": "four solid strap-on motors attached to", "TBwm28V4jMu-00315-00061560-00061647": "the first stage", "TBwm28V4jMu-00316-00061648-00061919": "and a single engine centaur upper stage", "TBwm28V4jMu-00317-00061920-00062103": "around 20 minutes before launch a", "TBwm28V4jMu-00318-00062104-00062382": "magnitude 4.2 earthquake occurred here", "TBwm28V4jMu-00319-00062383-00062599": "in the southern california region i felt", "TBwm28V4jMu-00320-00062600-00062726": "it sitting and watching the launch", "TBwm28V4jMu-00321-00062727-00062782": "coverage", "TBwm28V4jMu-00322-00062783-00062982": "as did the folks at perseverance's", "TBwm28V4jMu-00323-00062983-00063087": "mission control", "TBwm28V4jMu-00324-00063088-00063247": "at the jet propulsion laboratory in", "TBwm28V4jMu-00325-00063248-00063503": "pasadena but that's not a particularly", "TBwm28V4jMu-00326-00063504-00063694": "large earthquake so all went ahead as", "TBwm28V4jMu-00327-00063695-00063775": "planned", "TBwm28V4jMu-00328-00063776-00064015": "a pitcher perfect launch saw the rover", "TBwm28V4jMu-00329-00064016-00064142": "and its cruise stage", "TBwm28V4jMu-00330-00064144-00064415": "released after a second burn put it on", "TBwm28V4jMu-00331-00064416-00064663": "course for mars at 11 kilometers a", "TBwm28V4jMu-00332-00064664-00064719": "second", "TBwm28V4jMu-00333-00064720-00064942": "but almost immediately after separation", "TBwm28V4jMu-00334-00064944-00065111": "from the centaur upper stage", "TBwm28V4jMu-00335-00065112-00065326": "perseverance snapped into safe mode it", "TBwm28V4jMu-00336-00065327-00065543": "took roughly a day to coax perseverance", "TBwm28V4jMu-00337-00065544-00065582": "back", "TBwm28V4jMu-00338-00065583-00065815": "out to regular operations and no harm", "TBwm28V4jMu-00339-00065816-00065903": "had occurred", "TBwm28V4jMu-00340-00065904-00066079": "engineers suspect that the deployment of", "TBwm28V4jMu-00341-00066080-00066303": "perseverance in the shadow of the earth", "TBwm28V4jMu-00342-00066304-00066567": "caused it to cool to a temperature low", "TBwm28V4jMu-00343-00066568-00066606": "enough", "TBwm28V4jMu-00344-00066607-00066847": "to trip into safe mode the radio", "TBwm28V4jMu-00345-00066848-00067055": "transmitters on board of perseverance", "TBwm28V4jMu-00346-00067056-00067287": "also momentarily overwhelm the deep", "TBwm28V4jMu-00347-00067288-00067447": "space network's antennas", "TBwm28V4jMu-00348-00067448-00067719": "literally too loud but ground teams", "TBwm28V4jMu-00349-00067720-00067823": "resolved the issue", "TBwm28V4jMu-00350-00067824-00068079": "and perseverance with ingenuity are now", "TBwm28V4jMu-00351-00068080-00068143": "the third", "TBwm28V4jMu-00352-00068144-00068391": "and final mission on the way to mars and", "TBwm28V4jMu-00353-00068392-00068559": "if you'd like to know more about the two", "TBwm28V4jMu-00354-00068560-00068711": "previously launched missions", "TBwm28V4jMu-00355-00068712-00068935": "check out last week's tomorrow news", "TBwm28V4jMu-00356-00068936-00069150": "popping over to the baikonur cosmodrome", "TBwm28V4jMu-00357-00069151-00069263": "in kazakhstan", "TBwm28V4jMu-00358-00069264-00069575": "later that day at 2125 universal time a", "TBwm28V4jMu-00359-00069576-00069767": "russian proton rocket leapt", "TBwm28V4jMu-00360-00069768-00070038": "up above site 200 and roared into the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00361-00070039-00070150": "clouds to deliver", "TBwm28V4jMu-00362-00070151-00070382": "two russian communication satellites", "TBwm28V4jMu-00363-00070383-00070615": "express 80 and express 103.", "TBwm28V4jMu-00364-00070616-00070887": "several burns over 18 hours conducted by", "TBwm28V4jMu-00365-00070888-00070967": "the breeze m", "TBwm28V4jMu-00366-00070968-00071182": "upper stage led to a successful", "TBwm28V4jMu-00367-00071183-00071335": "deployment where the two express", "TBwm28V4jMu-00368-00071336-00071494": "satellites will be used for tv and", "TBwm28V4jMu-00369-00071495-00071623": "mobile communications", "TBwm28V4jMu-00370-00071624-00071767": "high-speed internet and data", "TBwm28V4jMu-00371-00071768-00072015": "transmission and here are your upcoming", "TBwm28V4jMu-00372-00072016-00072102": "launches", "TBwm28V4jMu-00373-00072103-00072775": "[Music]", "TBwm28V4jMu-00374-00072776-00072919": "and for this week's space weather here's", "TBwm28V4jMu-00375-00072920-00073119": "dr tana the scope", "TBwm28V4jMu-00376-00073120-00073343": "space weather this week is definitely", "TBwm28V4jMu-00377-00073344-00073487": "beginning to pick up and", "TBwm28V4jMu-00378-00073488-00073638": "all of the news is in the northern", "TBwm28V4jMu-00379-00073639-00073823": "hemisphere as we switch to our front", "TBwm28V4jMu-00380-00073824-00073903": "side sun", "TBwm28V4jMu-00381-00073904-00074079": "we have a coronal hole in the north", "TBwm28V4jMu-00382-00074080-00074231": "that's rotating in through the earth", "TBwm28V4jMu-00383-00074232-00074311": "strike zone", "TBwm28V4jMu-00384-00074312-00074494": "it's been sending us some fast solar", "TBwm28V4jMu-00385-00074495-00074726": "wind over the past 24 hours and it's", "TBwm28V4jMu-00386-00074727-00074903": "even brought aurora down to mid", "TBwm28V4jMu-00387-00074904-00074991": "latitudes", "TBwm28V4jMu-00388-00074992-00075206": "and it could easily continue to do that", "TBwm28V4jMu-00389-00075207-00075399": "over the next 24 hours", "TBwm28V4jMu-00390-00075400-00075591": "on top of that we also have a coronal", "TBwm28V4jMu-00391-00075592-00075719": "hole a smaller one", "TBwm28V4jMu-00392-00075720-00075919": "that's more equatorial that will also", "TBwm28V4jMu-00393-00075920-00076135": "rotate into the earth strike zone here", "TBwm28V4jMu-00394-00076136-00076367": "in the next three or four days so we", "TBwm28V4jMu-00395-00076368-00076511": "could easily be having", "TBwm28V4jMu-00396-00076512-00076799": "unsettled to disturbed conditions in", "TBwm28V4jMu-00397-00076800-00076855": "through", "TBwm28V4jMu-00398-00076856-00077023": "i don't know the end of the week or so", "TBwm28V4jMu-00399-00077024-00077159": "before things settle down", "TBwm28V4jMu-00400-00077160-00077326": "but believe it or not that's not even", "TBwm28V4jMu-00401-00077327-00077535": "the biggest story have you looked at the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00402-00077536-00077694": "northern hemisphere and the bright", "TBwm28V4jMu-00403-00077695-00077815": "lights you see there", "TBwm28V4jMu-00404-00077816-00078062": "look at that bam bam bam can you say", "TBwm28V4jMu-00405-00078063-00078319": "hello solar cycle 25", "TBwm28V4jMu-00406-00078320-00078599": "these are all solar cycle 25 sunspots", "TBwm28V4jMu-00407-00078600-00078647": "they're", "TBwm28V4jMu-00408-00078648-00078847": "at high latitudes and every single one", "TBwm28V4jMu-00409-00078848-00079023": "of these regions have been numbered", "TBwm28V4jMu-00410-00079024-00079247": "including the latest region that's", "TBwm28V4jMu-00411-00079248-00079479": "region 2770.", "TBwm28V4jMu-00412-00079480-00079703": "now as we switch to our far-sighted sun", "TBwm28V4jMu-00413-00079704-00079879": "this is stereo a and it's looking at the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00414-00079880-00079911": "sun", "TBwm28V4jMu-00415-00079912-00080111": "pretty much from the side you can see", "TBwm28V4jMu-00416-00080112-00080238": "those three regions", "TBwm28V4jMu-00417-00080239-00080550": "far better in this view and that last", "TBwm28V4jMu-00418-00080551-00080823": "region that one has been firing off some", "TBwm28V4jMu-00419-00080824-00080967": "b-class flares so it's", "TBwm28V4jMu-00420-00080968-00081215": "not a lot of radio noise it wasn't", "TBwm28V4jMu-00421-00081216-00081311": "enough to cause", "TBwm28V4jMu-00422-00081312-00081559": "any issues for the dragon splashdown the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00423-00081560-00081791": "other day just in case you wondered that", "TBwm28V4jMu-00424-00081792-00081959": "thank goodness things are still quiet", "TBwm28V4jMu-00425-00081960-00082143": "but i'm telling you we're going to start", "TBwm28V4jMu-00426-00082144-00082382": "seeing things pick up here pretty soon", "TBwm28V4jMu-00427-00082383-00082631": "on top of that look at the bright region", "TBwm28V4jMu-00428-00082632-00082815": "rotating into stereo's view in the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00429-00082816-00083159": "south yet another solar cycle 25", "TBwm28V4jMu-00430-00083160-00083462": "bright region so how can we say solar", "TBwm28V4jMu-00431-00083463-00083759": "cycle 25 is finally beginning to ramp up", "TBwm28V4jMu-00432-00083760-00083991": "it's here and right now we're dealing", "TBwm28V4jMu-00433-00083992-00084159": "with pretty quiet space", "TBwm28V4jMu-00434-00084160-00084415": "calms for space traffic but you never", "TBwm28V4jMu-00435-00084416-00084567": "know we're gonna have to start really", "TBwm28V4jMu-00436-00084568-00084750": "being on our toes", "TBwm28V4jMu-00437-00084751-00084935": "for more details on this week's space", "TBwm28V4jMu-00438-00084936-00085111": "weather including how those bright", "TBwm28V4jMu-00439-00085112-00085294": "regions will affect dayside radio", "TBwm28V4jMu-00440-00085295-00085399": "communications", "TBwm28V4jMu-00441-00085400-00085579": "come check out my channel or see me at", "TBwm28V4jMu-00442-00085580-00085735": "spaceweatherwoman.com", "TBwm28V4jMu-00443-00085736-00085943": "now the upcoming ariane 5 launch that", "TBwm28V4jMu-00444-00085944-00086135": "you saw on our earth departures board", "TBwm28V4jMu-00445-00086136-00086287": "it's going to be more than just a simple", "TBwm28V4jMu-00446-00086288-00086471": "chuck your comstats into the proper", "TBwm28V4jMu-00447-00086472-00086599": "transfer orbit no", "TBwm28V4jMu-00448-00086600-00086735": "they're actually going to be doing some", "TBwm28V4jMu-00449-00086736-00086911": "pretty big tests in order", "TBwm28V4jMu-00450-00086912-00087079": "to make sure that when the james webb", "TBwm28V4jMu-00451-00087080-00087335": "space telescope flies on the ariane 5", "TBwm28V4jMu-00452-00087336-00087550": "everything goes according to plan now", "TBwm28V4jMu-00453-00087551-00087726": "the james webb space telescope is a", "TBwm28V4jMu-00454-00087727-00087926": "delicate yet massive behemoth of a", "TBwm28V4jMu-00455-00087927-00088191": "spacecraft the rm5 is a potent heavy", "TBwm28V4jMu-00456-00088192-00088287": "launch vehicle", "TBwm28V4jMu-00457-00088288-00088494": "and the only one with a payload fairing", "TBwm28V4jMu-00458-00088495-00088623": "large enough to fit", "TBwm28V4jMu-00459-00088624-00088918": "an already origami folded j-dub inside", "TBwm28V4jMu-00460-00088919-00088967": "of it", "TBwm28V4jMu-00461-00088968-00089199": "making sure jdub makes it to space", "TBwm28V4jMu-00462-00089200-00089367": "safely is the priority", "TBwm28V4jMu-00463-00089368-00089535": "and a new payload fairing is being", "TBwm28V4jMu-00464-00089536-00089743": "tested to assure that that happens", "TBwm28V4jMu-00465-00089744-00089935": "nasa had concerns about the potential", "TBwm28V4jMu-00466-00089936-00090094": "build up of air between the thin", "TBwm28V4jMu-00467-00090095-00090287": "sheets of silver cap on that will help", "TBwm28V4jMu-00468-00090288-00090462": "shield the telescope from the sun", "TBwm28V4jMu-00469-00090463-00090662": "keeping it ultra cold and that buildup", "TBwm28V4jMu-00470-00090663-00090831": "of air could rip the cap down when the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00471-00090832-00090982": "payload fairing deploys", "TBwm28V4jMu-00472-00090983-00091199": "so they've got to manage the removal of", "TBwm28V4jMu-00473-00091200-00091382": "air pressure in a way that keeps those", "TBwm28V4jMu-00474-00091383-00091503": "layers of kapton", "TBwm28V4jMu-00475-00091504-00091791": "intact earlier this year the ariane 5", "TBwm28V4jMu-00476-00091792-00091831": "flew", "TBwm28V4jMu-00477-00091832-00092015": "with a modified payload fairing", "TBwm28V4jMu-00478-00092016-00092215": "containing vents that allowed for", "TBwm28V4jMu-00479-00092216-00092415": "improvement with the air pressure inside", "TBwm28V4jMu-00480-00092416-00092550": "and this upcoming launch", "TBwm28V4jMu-00481-00092551-00092838": "will see larger vents used in addition a", "TBwm28V4jMu-00482-00092839-00093015": "new vehicle equipment bay will be", "TBwm28V4jMu-00483-00093016-00093182": "employed with this upcoming launch", "TBwm28V4jMu-00484-00093183-00093343": "its lighter weight will actually help", "TBwm28V4jMu-00485-00093344-00093559": "increase the ariane 5's payload capacity", "TBwm28V4jMu-00486-00093560-00093703": "by 85 kilograms", "TBwm28V4jMu-00487-00093704-00093943": "we've also got a test of a base system", "TBwm28V4jMu-00488-00093944-00094126": "for autonomous flight termination", "TBwm28V4jMu-00489-00094127-00094303": "and to wrap up this week's tomorrow news", "TBwm28V4jMu-00490-00094304-00094455": "i want to thank all of you citizens who", "TBwm28V4jMu-00491-00094456-00094599": "helped contribute to the shows", "TBwm28V4jMu-00492-00094600-00094782": "here at tomorrow i always say that we", "TBwm28V4jMu-00493-00094783-00094991": "are truly appreciative of all of our", "TBwm28V4jMu-00494-00094992-00095191": "citizens of tomorrow and that sentiment", "TBwm28V4jMu-00495-00095192-00095359": "is held by every single one of us who", "TBwm28V4jMu-00496-00095360-00095559": "are on this channel you help", "TBwm28V4jMu-00497-00095560-00095774": "make all of this possible without you we", "TBwm28V4jMu-00498-00095775-00095935": "don't have the ability to take the time", "TBwm28V4jMu-00499-00095936-00096087": "to make these shows we don't have the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00500-00096088-00096231": "equipment we don't have the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00501-00096232-00096462": "ability to get it to you so we are", "TBwm28V4jMu-00502-00096463-00096679": "forever appreciative that you citizens", "TBwm28V4jMu-00503-00096680-00096871": "have contributed to help make the shows", "TBwm28V4jMu-00504-00096872-00097031": "of tomorrow possible and if you're", "TBwm28V4jMu-00505-00097032-00097174": "interested in joining in with your", "TBwm28V4jMu-00506-00097175-00097367": "fellow citizens of tomorrow head on over", "TBwm28V4jMu-00507-00097368-00097543": "to youtube.com", "TBwm28V4jMu-00508-00097544-00097799": "tmro slash join and check out all of the", "TBwm28V4jMu-00509-00097800-00098006": "levels and rewards that you can get", "TBwm28V4jMu-00510-00098007-00098199": "and that's cico 9 for this edition of", "TBwm28V4jMu-00511-00098200-00098367": "tomorrow news thank you so much for", "TBwm28V4jMu-00512-00098368-00098511": "joining us and until the next one", "TBwm28V4jMu-00513-00098512-00098582": "remember", "TBwm28V4jMu-00514-00098583-00099482": "stay safe stay healthy and keep", "TBwm28V4jMu-00515-00099483-00099783": "exploring"}}, {"audio_id": "TBJkYfF-UtU", "text": {"TBJkYfF-UtU-00000-00000135-00001015": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00001-00001016-00001131": "absolutely", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00002-00001132-00001366": "sensational start brilliant defending", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00003-00001367-00001574": "from muhammad al-munir they're off the", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00004-00001575-00001614": "line", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00005-00001616-00002030": "rolando all the way out", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00006-00002032-00002350": "across the goal", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00007-00002351-00002534": "but he hit that post hard and now he's", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00008-00002535-00002671": "grabbing his shin", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00009-00002672-00002855": "forward here for bowdoin early and kevin", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00010-00002856-00003277": "molina", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00011-00003278-00003886": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00012-00003887-00004175": "sebastian fernandez sebastian fernandez", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00013-00004176-00004373": "can he get along the line", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00014-00004374-00007045": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00015-00007047-00008241": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00016-00008242-00009867": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00017-00009868-00010687": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00018-00010688-00011395": "off the line", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00019-00011396-00011582": "[Music]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00020-00011583-00012470": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00021-00012471-00013127": "deflected clear off the line", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00022-00013128-00014119": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00023-00014119-00014455": "from new england revolution", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00024-00014456-00015022": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00025-00015023-00015161": "watch out alex", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00026-00015162-00015422": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00027-00015423-00015822": "the goal line clearance doyle", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00028-00015823-00016172": "now the rebound oh my gosh my heart", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00029-00016174-00016567": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00030-00016568-00016830": "sending it in dave rosario all day", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00031-00016831-00016911": "rosario", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00032-00016912-00017191": "tonight how can that be that's what he's", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00033-00017192-00017367": "saying", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00034-00017368-00017822": "it's nagel open goal", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00035-00017823-00018103": "saves off the line once and twice are", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00036-00018104-00019239": "you kidding", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00037-00019240-00019439": "save the header again and it'll be safe", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00038-00019440-00019558": "again", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00039-00019559-00019894": "three goal line saves and wallace", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00040-00019895-00020207": "knows that that could have gone inside", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00041-00020208-00020503": "sam setting it in at all saved at the", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00042-00020504-00020639": "back post birdbot", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00043-00020640-00020927": "keeping it alive now another save off", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00044-00020928-00021039": "the line", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00045-00021040-00021175": "by graham", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00046-00021176-00022178": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00047-00022179-00022543": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00048-00022544-00022863": "wrestles in rounds the keeper off the", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00049-00022864-00022991": "line again", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00050-00022992-00023383": "by andrew fell back it comes from", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00051-00023384-00023599": "eric havillar towards ryan johnson's", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00052-00023600-00023783": "spaceship for ryan johnson saved by", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00053-00023784-00024335": "kenny and grin off the", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00054-00024336-00024494": "massive opportunity for the union to", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00055-00024495-00024639": "score the opening goal", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00056-00024640-00024950": "what a clearance that is", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00057-00024951-00025142": "absolutely incredible effort for miles", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00058-00025143-00025327": "robinson that's why you don't give up on", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00059-00025328-00025519": "a play", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00060-00025520-00025822": "it's keen for la over the top it goes", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00061-00025823-00026343": "and off the line shad marshall", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00062-00026344-00026655": "morris and the follower from dempsey did", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00063-00026656-00026895": "it cross the line i don't think it did", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00064-00026895-00027190": "a goal saving goal line clearance", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00065-00027191-00027311": "nicholas ludero", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00066-00027312-00027574": "jordan morris on side here morris for", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00067-00027575-00027735": "seattle can he finish", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00068-00027736-00028102": "jordan morris well somehow", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00069-00028104-00028448": "it's a recurring nightmare for morris", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00070-00028449-00028774": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00071-00028775-00029014": "that flag's gonna stay down and save off", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00072-00029016-00029127": "the line", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00073-00029127-00029414": "matt hedge is making the run back let's", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00074-00029416-00029614": "get on the turbo skater could be for", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00075-00029616-00029935": "dallas oh see marco light clearance", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00076-00029936-00030183": "fantastic from the captain lacrosse", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00077-00030183-00030383": "stars", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00078-00030383-00030558": "and he looked like it went over the end", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00079-00030560-00031508": "by santos no call by sir", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00080-00031510-00032283": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00081-00032283-00032437": "felipe", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00082-00032438-00032563": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00083-00032564-00033055": "[Music]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00084-00033056-00033351": "here they come again robbie keane tries", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00085-00033352-00033511": "to slide it through for himself", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00086-00033512-00033603": "donovan", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00087-00033604-00034318": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00088-00034319-00035095": "[Applause]", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00089-00035096-00035327": "again off the line towards goal not once", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00090-00035328-00035415": "not twice", "TBJkYfF-UtU-00091-00035416-00036103": "but three or four times away"}}, {"audio_id": "TBXmaFjNTUI", "text": {"TBXmaFjNTUI-00000-00000608-00001027": "good morning everyone", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00001-00001028-00001199": "[Music]", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00002-00001200-00001589": "first of all uh I'd like to thank", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00003-00001590-00001967": "exchange for media for organizing", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00004-00001968-00002375": "um this event India brands conclave and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00005-00002376-00002692": "thanks to Dr anurag batra", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00006-00002693-00002891": "and um", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00007-00002892-00003306": "to all of you for attending it here", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00008-00003307-00003779": "the topic which we're going to discuss", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00009-00003779-00004097": "is about", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00010-00004098-00004427": "Brands all about Brands today and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00011-00004428-00004517": "tomorrow", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00012-00004518-00004763": "it's a very wide topic today and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00013-00004764-00005020": "tomorrow I mean tomorrow is going to", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00014-00005021-00005309": "come and today covers what was there in", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00015-00005310-00005633": "the past and continues", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00016-00005634-00005927": "and what I have to talk about is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00017-00005928-00006143": "celebrating Choice delighting with", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00018-00006144-00006460": "experience availability and value the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00019-00006461-00006767": "very wide topic so it can be anything", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00020-00006768-00007073": "can be talked under this umbrella all", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00021-00007073-00007177": "that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00022-00007178-00007613": "which leads to making Brands continuing", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00023-00007614-00007870": "them in the minds of the customer from a", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00024-00007872-00008177": "recall perspective and growing them for", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00025-00008178-00008477": "the future of business", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00026-00008478-00008717": "um primary lines I've been told that you", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00027-00008718-00008933": "can make and you should make specific", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00028-00008934-00009233": "references to our company uh so that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00029-00009234-00009563": "people know about it but", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00030-00009564-00009874": "I guess everybody knows about our Brands", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00031-00009875-00010205": "and its happy customers all of you I'm", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00032-00010206-00010492": "sure there will be nobody in this Hall", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00033-00010493-00010871": "and anywhere who is not being associated", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00034-00010872-00011206": "with any of the Reliance brands in terms", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00035-00011207-00011578": "of what or continuing to buy at some", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00036-00011579-00011717": "point or the other", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00037-00011718-00012155": "but nonetheless I will just say that how", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00038-00012156-00012431": "we think and how we believe and how we", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00039-00012432-00012793": "work for our customers and stakeholders", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00040-00012794-00013121": "I'll just try to bring up some key", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00041-00013122-00013493": "points which are relevant for the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00042-00013494-00013672": "discussion obviously everybody is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00043-00013673-00014005": "knowledgeable and knows and um", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00044-00014006-00014208": "Reliance retail", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00045-00014209-00014651": "we actually in terms of organizing our", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00046-00014652-00015005": "businesses we do specific formats and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00047-00015006-00015535": "verticals and those formats are", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00048-00015536-00015916": "are living to the ethos of why they are", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00049-00015918-00016361": "formed when I say format it means what", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00050-00016362-00016571": "was mentioned about Reliance smart so", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00051-00016572-00016919": "with Reliance smart Superstore which", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00052-00016920-00017183": "actually deals in groceries and general", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00053-00017184-00017458": "merchandise and the day-to-day", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00054-00017459-00017693": "necessities of groceries in the value", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00055-00017694-00018011": "segment we have Reliance Trends which is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00056-00018012-00018191": "the value segment apparel we have", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00057-00018192-00018341": "Reliance Digital which is in the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00058-00018342-00018713": "electronics then we have our furniture", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00059-00018714-00019043": "chain Urban ladder then we have a", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00060-00019044-00019264": "fashion and lifestyle it's too deep for", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00061-00019265-00019583": "us in terms of being present in each of", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00062-00019584-00019930": "the particular class of the customers", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00063-00019931-00020230": "requirement right from the mass to the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00064-00020231-00020525": "very very premium so where we have a", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00065-00020526-00020830": "joint venture Partnerships with name the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00066-00020831-00021030": "international brand", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00067-00021031-00021521": "diesel pollen shark Brook Brothers Steve", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00068-00021522-00021772": "Madden super dry and the list can go on", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00069-00021773-00021935": "and on and we have Partnerships with", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00070-00021936-00022271": "marks and Spencer we have hamleys in the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00071-00022272-00022619": "toy segment and in Furniture as I said", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00072-00022620-00022793": "we have Urban ladder in the laundry", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00073-00022794-00023153": "segment we have zivame clovia Amante so", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00074-00023154-00023357": "I can go on reciting the names of the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00075-00023358-00023686": "brands and the and online of course our", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00076-00023687-00024011": "Geo geomart they are there", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00077-00024012-00024335": "but the key to it is why so many Brands", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00078-00024336-00024617": "and what what goes behind thinking like", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00079-00024618-00024989": "this why not have just one Amazon or one", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00080-00024990-00025297": "Walmart and bring everything under one", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00081-00025298-00025584": "what we understand is that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00082-00025585-00025943": "customers in India definitely", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00083-00025944-00026225": "differentiate between different", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00084-00026226-00026620": "necessities of theirs and they need to", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00085-00026622-00026789": "identify", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00086-00026789-00027023": "their shopping need for that particular", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00087-00027024-00027481": "purpose and making it into different", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00088-00027482-00027779": "classifications and different shopping", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00089-00027780-00028090": "Journeys makes it far more for purpose", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00090-00028091-00028499": "it enables reach and scale in terms of", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00091-00028500-00028708": "reaching to different places with", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00092-00028710-00028912": "different formats giving it in smaller", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00093-00028913-00029218": "modular situation so for example if", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00094-00029219-00029446": "somebody wants to shop Electronics they", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00095-00029447-00029620": "relate to a Reliance Digital shop", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00096-00029622-00029833": "instead of a very large", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00097-00029833-00030299": "huge place and then inside there is a", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00098-00030300-00030551": "digital offering somewhere we believe", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00099-00030552-00030851": "that a digital store separately makes", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00100-00030852-00031157": "lot of sense for the customer it enables", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00101-00031158-00031427": "the real estate to be available for that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00102-00031427-00031714": "particular unit which is to the size and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00103-00031716-00031937": "purpose and nearby you can have another", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00104-00031938-00032189": "Trend store you have a grocery store and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00105-00032189-00032458": "all of them give identity to the the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00106-00032460-00032729": "customers recall and recollection so", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00107-00032730-00032999": "that's the a fundamental understanding", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00108-00033000-00033329": "behind making separate verticals and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00109-00033330-00033629": "store formats as per the consumption", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00110-00033630-00033839": "basket when it comes to joint ventures", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00111-00033840-00034087": "there are specific", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00112-00034088-00034390": "what you call nuances of the particular", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00113-00034391-00034757": "brand which comes in from abroad they", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00114-00034758-00034918": "need their identity they have their", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00115-00034919-00035201": "ethos and it cannot be mixed a diesel", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00116-00035202-00035417": "will be in in a premium place and it", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00117-00035418-00035711": "will not just go in any smaller place or", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00118-00035712-00036118": "town similarly a small format which is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00119-00036119-00036359": "in the mass say 7-Eleven is one of our", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00120-00036360-00036677": "formats right now in 7-Eleven will go in", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00121-00036678-00036952": "in us anywhere which is a neighborhood", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00122-00036953-00037193": "convenience and it will belong in large", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00123-00037194-00037315": "numbers", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00124-00037316-00037702": "is what is our experience so living up", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00125-00037703-00037895": "to the ethos of the format just because", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00126-00037896-00038099": "it is under one umbrella doesn't mean", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00127-00038100-00038285": "that you can mix and match is a very", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00128-00038286-00038579": "important takeaway when we say in terms", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00129-00038580-00038699": "of", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00130-00038700-00039023": "about Brands so living the brand and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00131-00039024-00039274": "respecting the brand and its values is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00132-00039275-00039568": "very important that that's what goes in", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00133-00039569-00039929": "segregation again online uh also if we", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00134-00039930-00040109": "mix up everything there is a particular", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00135-00040110-00040349": "way of understanding yes you mix up and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00136-00040350-00040511": "there the search is possible to do", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00137-00040512-00040780": "everything but again in that also the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00138-00040781-00040967": "categorization is extremely important", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00139-00040968-00041212": "otherwise what is on the top really", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00140-00041213-00041417": "remains on the top and where there is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00141-00041418-00041651": "marketing happening uh those sales will", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00142-00041652-00041977": "happen and rest of it will not really", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00143-00041978-00042280": "reach the fruition what it is supposed", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00144-00042281-00042462": "to reach", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00145-00042463-00042762": "as far as building brands of Tomorrow", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00146-00042763-00043024": "there are certain very important things", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00147-00043025-00043362": "which everybody will talk about digital", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00148-00043363-00043721": "Revolution and digital uh understanding", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00149-00043722-00043955": "of the customer and digitally reaching", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00150-00043956-00044333": "to the customers AIML and but all that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00151-00044334-00044657": "is like what everybody does is relying", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00152-00044658-00044737": "on certain", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00153-00044738-00045071": "search capabilities of the large service", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00154-00045072-00045407": "provider and no harm in naming Google", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00155-00045408-00045749": "Facebook and meta what they are", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00156-00045750-00045983": "providing inherently the ability to", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00157-00045984-00046301": "Market and everybody plugs into that but", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00158-00046302-00046565": "really we believe that the winning comes", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00159-00046566-00046871": "from your own understanding of your", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00160-00046872-00047218": "universe of the customer for a small d2c", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00161-00047219-00047489": "brand it can be a very small Universe of", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00162-00047490-00047818": "people whom they have really transacted", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00163-00047819-00048065": "with or they they are able to reach", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00164-00048066-00048311": "everybody doesn't open all the PIN codes", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00165-00048312-00048635": "and just try to do with Courier Services", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00166-00048636-00048935": "otherwise you end up earning to pay the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00167-00048936-00049307": "delivery Courier situation but otherwise", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00168-00049308-00049487": "it is extremely important that you", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00169-00049488-00049762": "understand your customer segment and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00170-00049763-00049873": "really", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00171-00049874-00050267": "talk to them communicate with them in", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00172-00050268-00050512": "the language which we have set for that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00173-00050513-00050836": "particular brand so d2c when it comes it", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00174-00050837-00051208": "looks very very lucrative scenario but", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00175-00051209-00051485": "really it's very difficult for all those", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00176-00051486-00051763": "who are in that particular", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00177-00051764-00052042": "activity will understand that how", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00178-00052044-00052216": "difficult it is and how quickly the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00179-00052217-00052432": "money blows up if you do wrong marketing", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00180-00052433-00052721": "and you're not knowing your customer the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00181-00052722-00052997": "sales conversion is the art which is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00182-00052998-00053353": "very important to be mastered before", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00183-00053354-00053741": "really getting into the uh the marketing", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00184-00053741-00054100": "in a big way so somewhere or the other", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00185-00054101-00054311": "when we say brands of today tomorrow and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00186-00054312-00054497": "what needs to be done I'll just quickly", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00187-00054498-00054754": "I mean I I noted down some pointers and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00188-00054755-00055019": "there's a big thesis it cannot be a 10", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00189-00055020-00055235": "minute session cannot do justice to that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00190-00055236-00055511": "but all these pointers in terms of", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00191-00055512-00055865": "having some uniqueness some kind of left", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00192-00055866-00056094": "out space which we are trying to occupy", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00193-00056095-00056465": "is is a very important consideration in", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00194-00056466-00056680": "making a brand just copying something", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00195-00056682-00056891": "thing where already there is a big crowd", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00196-00056891-00057119": "doesn't lead to anything there has to be", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00197-00057120-00057329": "a price proposition everybody gets", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00198-00057329-00057485": "carried away in terms of giving discount", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00199-00057486-00057629": "discount discount discount if you are", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00200-00057629-00057929": "trying to do but that discount really is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00201-00057929-00058115": "a very short-lived one if somebody else", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00202-00058116-00058349": "comes and gives a higher discount people", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00203-00058350-00058637": "forget about it unless you have a really", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00204-00058638-00058919": "a good price proposition along with the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00205-00058920-00059194": "recall of the product which uniqueness", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00206-00059195-00059453": "you are bringing in there is quality", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00207-00059454-00059766": "definitely at the base of it in terms of", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00208-00059767-00060142": "customer will not be fooled by just a", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00209-00060144-00060382": "fancy brand name or a marketing they", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00210-00060383-00060641": "will understand the quality and recall", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00211-00060641-00060850": "based on the quality what they have", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00212-00060851-00061030": "experienced if anything is wrong in", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00213-00061032-00061282": "quality definitely be very punished by", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00214-00061283-00061511": "the customer and even for the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00215-00061512-00061726": "established Brands there is newness", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00216-00061727-00061942": "which is very much required otherwise a", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00217-00061944-00062242": "stale scenario if we look at the I mean", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00218-00062244-00062404": "the classic example which can be very", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00219-00062405-00062782": "easily understood is about the cars uh", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00220-00062783-00062969": "the best brands in the world also have", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00221-00062970-00063185": "to bring in newer models they cannot", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00222-00063186-00063413": "continue with the old model even though", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00223-00063414-00063557": "they'll change something on the shape", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00224-00063558-00063791": "but it constantly keeps to be moving", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00225-00063791-00063994": "similarly the products which are in the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00226-00063995-00064259": "fmcg or the consumer space need to be", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00227-00064260-00064529": "constantly moving and inherently we", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00228-00064529-00064780": "don't experience it but the brands are", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00229-00064782-00064997": "doing it with some kind of a plus extra", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00230-00064998-00065242": "or some new new something is always", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00231-00065244-00065476": "written so that's important even for", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00232-00065477-00065717": "very large Brands to bring refreshing", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00233-00065718-00066029": "scenario maintaining ethos is extremely", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00234-00066030-00066281": "important we can't just waver from just", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00235-00066282-00066455": "because the brand name is there do", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00236-00066456-00066749": "everything it kills the brand impression", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00237-00066750-00066965": "if it's a premium brand it has to be the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00238-00066966-00067132": "premium scenario I mean there are", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00239-00067133-00067276": "certain things which we should not make", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00240-00067277-00067493": "mistakes when we are building Brands and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00241-00067494-00067787": "nurturing Our Brands for future and um", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00242-00067788-00068032": "as anurag they said about sustainability", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00243-00068033-00068363": "and really the people have become very", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00244-00068364-00068555": "conscious about the planet so", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00245-00068556-00068825": "sustainability cannot be for button at", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00246-00068826-00069094": "the base of it in terms of when we are", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00247-00069095-00069317": "doing marketing it has to be connected", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00248-00069318-00069526": "with the stocks otherwise we would have", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00249-00069527-00069725": "just done a huge amount of marketing and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00250-00069726-00069917": "we don't have anything to supply that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00251-00069918-00070205": "money goes off really the unit economics", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00252-00070206-00070493": "in terms of whatever we are selling has", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00253-00070494-00070787": "earning people just spend money but they", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00254-00070788-00070925": "forget that we are here for making", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00255-00070926-00071267": "profit and choosing the right medium of", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00256-00071268-00071497": "communication is extremely important", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00257-00071498-00071803": "otherwise also it is it's really", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00258-00071804-00072119": "difficult in terms of making uh I'll", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00259-00072120-00072293": "give you just example which we will all", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00260-00072294-00072515": "relate to in this all just now", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00261-00072516-00072593": "um", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00262-00072594-00072917": "there was a channel Masti which was we", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00263-00072918-00073132": "saw all Shahrukh Khan everybody Amitabh", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00264-00073133-00073517": "Bachchan before this how many people had", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00265-00073518-00073865": "known about the brand Channel I mean can", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00266-00073866-00074044": "everybody raise their hand they're known", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00267-00074045-00074315": "about Masti Channel and after seeing it", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00268-00074316-00074494": "here how many people became aware that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00269-00074495-00074950": "there is this Masti Channel", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00270-00074951-00075203": "so one two three four", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00271-00075204-00075406": "right so", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00272-00075407-00075676": "after now everybody in this Hall knows", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00273-00075677-00075863": "about this Mercy chance so what exactly", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00274-00075864-00076111": "happened in the process is that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00275-00076112-00076481": "localized basis and this is for the mass", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00276-00076482-00076643": "Channel but I'm saying from a store", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00277-00076644-00076900": "perspective or uh or a retail", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00278-00076901-00077135": "perspective what really happened is a", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00279-00077136-00077362": "small audience really got to know about", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00280-00077363-00077669": "the subject with a limited reach so what", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00281-00077670-00077950": "is most important is the catchment or", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00282-00077951-00078167": "the class of the customer if they are", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00283-00078168-00078473": "all made aware in a very effective and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00284-00078474-00078725": "low cost manner so it can be as low as a", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00285-00078726-00078953": "holding in the locality but if it is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00286-00078954-00079187": "done then everybody understands have you", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00287-00079188-00079385": "heard about the brand yes have you heard", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00288-00079386-00079582": "about the brand so that's what they may", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00289-00079583-00079876": "not shop at this point of time I mean my", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00290-00079877-00080069": "bully was another next one actually", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00291-00080070-00080393": "right that's a Marathi situation but we", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00292-00080394-00080555": "got to know that yes it is there so", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00293-00080556-00080788": "these kind of you know small uh", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00294-00080789-00081119": "situations but the analyst Community the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00295-00081120-00081287": "media Community they should at least", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00296-00081288-00081599": "somehow be you know whole ecosystem of", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00297-00081600-00081881": "these you know people who are really", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00298-00081882-00082109": "important should really be aware of your", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00299-00082110-00082367": "brand then quickly one can make a brand", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00300-00082368-00082588": "similarly the customers in the locality", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00301-00082589-00082871": "or the relevant customers and definitely", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00302-00082872-00083075": "using the right agency is extremely", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00303-00083076-00083261": "important everything we try to do on our", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00304-00083262-00083525": "own it it may be vision and concept we", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00305-00083526-00083705": "give but definitely the right people who", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00306-00083706-00083921": "are doing it all the time is extremely", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00307-00083922-00084179": "important in terms of and look I mean", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00308-00084180-00084353": "last thing I just want to you know close", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00309-00084354-00084544": "it by the customer is very important", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00310-00084545-00084785": "looking at the customer feedback", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00311-00084786-00085031": "understanding the customer feedback all", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00312-00085032-00085247": "the time and being close to the customer", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00313-00085248-00085600": "being open and you know modifying based", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00314-00085601-00085762": "on what is relevant comments everybody", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00315-00085763-00085967": "will have a comment if you ask but", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00316-00085968-00086165": "really filtering it out and what matters", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00317-00086166-00086411": "is extremely important we ourselves", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00318-00086412-00086626": "pushing things without understanding the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00319-00086627-00086819": "customer really finally we are making", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00320-00086820-00086993": "everything for the customer and trying", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00321-00086994-00087185": "to reach to the customer so I've just", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00322-00087186-00087503": "told that I'll just you know close my", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00323-00087504-00087803": "talk with this but any q a I need to", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00324-00087804-00088126": "stay back and just take any questions so", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00325-00088127-00088331": "I'll be very happy I am you know", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00326-00088332-00088571": "available just now you can ask any", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00327-00088572-00089112": "questions if anybody would like to ask", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00328-00089113-00089362": "you mentioned about learnings from", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00329-00089363-00089638": "Global Brands and understanding the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00330-00089639-00089843": "Indian customer when you get your", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00331-00089844-00090143": "catchment studies to understand uh what", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00332-00090144-00090359": "is the Indian customer wants my question", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00333-00090360-00090725": "is how do you relate to the findings", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00334-00090726-00091037": "from the demographics versus the culture", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00335-00091038-00091343": "that eventually you get to see here", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00336-00091344-00091637": "and second when we are swayed very", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00337-00091638-00091967": "easily by discounts how do you once you", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00338-00091968-00092153": "have formulated a strategy", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00339-00092154-00092399": "how do you then move", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00340-00092400-00092699": "to counter that competition discount and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00341-00092700-00092841": "that side of the equation", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00342-00092842-00092968": "[Music]", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00343-00092969-00093215": "so uh I think the second question is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00344-00093216-00093382": "very easy to answer first I'll answer", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00345-00093383-00093685": "that we don't get swayed with discounts", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00346-00093686-00094150": "we give only customary whatever it is so", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00347-00094151-00094456": "the whole um I mean whoever are doing", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00348-00094457-00094685": "discounting also the large organizations", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00349-00094686-00095117": "uh it is a misnomer that um you know", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00350-00095118-00095399": "only they are doing discounting actually", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00351-00095400-00095585": "so", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00352-00095586-00095891": "um what what happens is really the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00353-00095892-00096131": "creation of the impulse in the mind of", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00354-00096132-00096568": "the customer by certain loss leader or a", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00355-00096569-00096797": "discounted item usually I mean I'm", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00356-00096798-00097006": "talking about those who understand and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00357-00097007-00097235": "do it well actually otherwise some", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00358-00097236-00097397": "people may only understand discounting", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00359-00097398-00097594": "is a way of life then I cannot talk", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00360-00097595-00097894": "about them but those who do it well they", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00361-00097895-00098267": "really bring some lost leader and you", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00362-00098268-00098435": "know some kind of discounting on the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00363-00098436-00098717": "item where there are already a huge", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00364-00098718-00098938": "margin available by way of a talk with", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00365-00098939-00099287": "the the manufacturer who would like to", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00366-00099288-00099497": "promote they are doing the investing in", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00367-00099498-00099791": "the brand or the product so really it", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00368-00099792-00100037": "becomes a collaboration that there is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00369-00100038-00100265": "this kind of uh you know money in the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00370-00100266-00100565": "game and that brings people on the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00371-00100566-00100865": "platform if it is online platform or to", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00372-00100866-00101141": "the store and thereafter impulse takes", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00373-00101142-00101338": "over so once you are especially in a", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00374-00101339-00101597": "physical store if you are entering a", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00375-00101598-00101843": "store you never end up only buying that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00376-00101844-00102076": "item which was advertised and which was", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00377-00102077-00102293": "shown as a discount there is a lot more", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00378-00102294-00102503": "in the store which people just pick up", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00379-00102504-00102742": "on impulse and you know a whole basket", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00380-00102743-00102977": "is full most of the time because the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00381-00102978-00103199": "person already spent about you know two", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00382-00103200-00103432": "three hours going to the place and they", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00383-00103433-00103654": "are not just going for that you know 20", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00384-00103655-00104003": "rupees 50 rupees 50 percent off on a you", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00385-00104004-00104242": "know discount scenario so really that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00386-00104243-00104465": "that's the high low game what it is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00387-00104466-00104716": "called in terms of the discounting so we", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00388-00104717-00104927": "don't believe in discounting for loss", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00389-00104928-00105113": "and losing money we are the most", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00390-00105114-00105384": "profitable company in the retail space", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00391-00105385-00105719": "so that's that's the philosophy on not", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00392-00105720-00105895": "discounting and getting carried away", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00393-00105896-00106133": "because everybody is doing there is end", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00394-00106133-00106295": "of season sale and all which is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00395-00106296-00106516": "customary but that is actually money in", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00396-00106517-00106810": "that those are only you know mediums of", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00397-00106811-00107039": "reaching to the customer and you know", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00398-00107040-00107278": "factoring in what was already factored", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00399-00107279-00107554": "in kind of a margin earning uh the other", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00400-00107555-00107752": "part of it is in terms of the catchment", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00401-00107753-00108160": "study as you said see India is a is a", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00402-00108161-00108419": "very very unique country where at every", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00403-00108420-00108778": "200 kilometers the the preferences The", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00404-00108779-00109133": "Taste the the way of living culture of", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00405-00109133-00109360": "the people keeps changing actually so", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00406-00109361-00109595": "even in the place where we are I mean", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00407-00109596-00109804": "there are I mean very easy to describe", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00408-00109805-00110015": "Mumbai actually all of us are that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00409-00110016-00110260": "number people will be from Mumbai that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00410-00110261-00110495": "what happens in the South Mumbai what", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00411-00110496-00110807": "happens in you know bandra area about", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00412-00110808-00111016": "the thought process of the customer the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00413-00111017-00111257": "class of the customer so if we look at", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00414-00111258-00111449": "the shopping happening at Palladium if", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00415-00111450-00111569": "you look at the shopping which is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00416-00111570-00111916": "happening in the mall say our new mall", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00417-00111917-00112258": "jwd Geo World Drive it's the second big", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00418-00112259-00112486": "mall and then you go to the malls in", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00419-00112488-00112816": "Andheri and Navi Mumbai Mumbai side and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00420-00112817-00113069": "then take it further to acai virar and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00421-00113070-00113321": "palghar to the outskirts of Mumbai", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00422-00113322-00113573": "Kalyan dombivali I mean it's not 200", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00423-00113574-00113849": "kilometers but really I mean if you look", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00424-00113850-00114071": "at just the catchments as they are", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00425-00114072-00114175": "changing", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00426-00114176-00114713": "you would not put a very very you know a", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00427-00114714-00114947": "brand would not want to come and just", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00428-00114948-00115210": "sell something which is really not", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00429-00115211-00115427": "relevant to that catchment right so", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00430-00115428-00115619": "inherently it is the study which happens", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00431-00115620-00116033": "and otherwise one learns with experience", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00432-00116033-00116345": "you put in the products and you know", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00433-00116346-00116501": "three months six months later the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00434-00116502-00116802": "product will become stale and out of", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00435-00116803-00117077": "manufactured date and and obviously it", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00436-00117078-00117293": "will get out then at that time you have", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00437-00117294-00117527": "a choice to sit and think oh let's look", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00438-00117528-00117833": "at now or you start a well that look at", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00439-00117833-00118043": "what is selling in the nearby stores and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00440-00118044-00118295": "nearby shops of the same you know type", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00441-00118296-00118504": "and understand the market research", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00442-00118505-00118757": "luckily there are lots of agencies and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00443-00118758-00118978": "people who are doing research so doing", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00444-00118979-00119158": "the good homework in the beginning is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00445-00119159-00119651": "how we understand and we do it and I", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00446-00119652-00119849": "mean this was Mumbai but when you go to", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00447-00119850-00120133": "say even further buldana", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00448-00120133-00120407": "you need to have really really different", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00449-00120408-00120760": "product which is their taste actually so", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00450-00120761-00121157": "that that's very inevitable but it's not", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00451-00121158-00121499": "so easy to do also at the same time when", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00452-00121500-00121889": "we want to do it it can be done with", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00453-00121890-00122123": "with you know very quick situation it's", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00454-00122124-00122375": "it can be as simple as sending our few", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00455-00122376-00122584": "people so what we usually do is before a", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00456-00122585-00122825": "new store opens in a geography", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00457-00122826-00123023": "um 15 days one month before before we", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00458-00123024-00123173": "hire the people and they go around in", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00459-00123174-00123389": "the catchment and that's how we build", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00460-00123390-00123634": "the assortment and we used to do it like", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00461-00123635-00123886": "I mean from 2006 we are in retail now in", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00462-00123888-00124090": "India so we used to do it in the earlier", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00463-00124091-00124283": "time now of course we have our own you", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00464-00124283-00124523": "know stores everywhere so we just have", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00465-00124524-00124751": "to multiply the same assortment and all", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00466-00124752-00125045": "but effort is required for everything", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00467-00125046-00125351": "and nowadays it's more important from an", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00468-00125352-00125584": "online perspective because all PIN codes", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00469-00125585-00125854": "become open at all the time immediately", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00470-00125855-00126143": "so really which pin code among the 19", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00471-00126144-00126431": "000 PIN codes of India really", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00472-00126432-00126569": "um you know what is happening is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00473-00126570-00126845": "extremely The Next Step which is our", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00474-00126846-00127066": "learnings every day right so to be", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00475-00127067-00127283": "successful that's the question good", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00476-00127283-00127481": "morning sir great Insight through your", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00477-00127482-00127804": "session I have a simple question here we", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00478-00127805-00128039": "spoke about sustainable brands", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00479-00128040-00128321": "so when it comes to Reliance brand what", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00480-00128322-00128536": "does it do when it comes to sustainable", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00481-00128538-00128771": "because when you say joint ventures of", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00482-00128772-00129010": "different brands coming together do you", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00483-00129011-00129227": "analyze whether they have a sustainable", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00484-00129228-00129466": "approach or can you just give us that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00485-00129467-00129833": "idea yeah it is far easier when we say", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00486-00129833-00130019": "Reliance Brands which is the global", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00487-00130020-00130314": "brand because from their perspective", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00488-00130315-00130690": "they are you know really I would not say", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00489-00130691-00130960": "we are not conscious we are you know", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00490-00130961-00131128": "India has always been very conscious", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00491-00131129-00131423": "about you know we are the Pioneers about", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00492-00131424-00131752": "nature and our all of those things are I", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00493-00131753-00132023": "mean our our culture and our handicrafts", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00494-00132024-00132275": "and all are definitely you know from", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00495-00132276-00132533": "ages but when it comes in the current", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00496-00132534-00132731": "context of your talking about the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00497-00132732-00132983": "manufacturer Brands and the you know", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00498-00132984-00133277": "situation what we experience is that", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00499-00133278-00133535": "they are already ahead in this thinking", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00500-00133536-00133847": "and the whole concepts are coming in", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00501-00133848-00134116": "from a lot of", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00502-00134117-00134323": "um you know countries which are already", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00503-00134324-00134675": "thinking about sustainability and making", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00504-00134676-00135011": "laws which are very relevant for that so", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00505-00135012-00135233": "when we look at um you know what is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00506-00135234-00135377": "coming from the brand there is already", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00507-00135378-00135701": "all of that uh you know", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00508-00135702-00135989": "which which comes in already inherently", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00509-00135990-00136199": "from what they are doing recycled", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00510-00136200-00136552": "material usage what they are you know", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00511-00136553-00136775": "trying to think about even the packaging", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00512-00136776-00137021": "for that matter actually International", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00513-00137022-00137254": "brand will immediately I mean even", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00514-00137255-00137543": "before the laws were made for the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00515-00137544-00137764": "single-use plastic uh stringent City", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00516-00137765-00138004": "they already were in you know paper and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00517-00138005-00138239": "recycle and all of that actually and", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00518-00138240-00138539": "with the advisories of uh you know not", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00519-00138540-00138875": "not being away and inherently in the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00520-00138876-00139216": "product the material used is is", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00521-00139217-00139469": "increasingly increasingly on the", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00522-00139470-00139733": "sustainable side actually so recycle I", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00523-00139734-00139925": "mean everybody you will see that there", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00524-00139926-00140123": "is a whole ranges which are coming in", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00525-00140124-00140393": "from the Recycled land which are easy to", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00526-00140394-00140645": "recycle scenarios so from their", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00527-00140646-00140795": "perspective it is that in India", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00528-00140796-00141119": "definitely uh you know there is uh in in", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00529-00141120-00141371": "in the newer product development", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00530-00141372-00141616": "everybody is extremely conscious about", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00531-00141617-00141877": "this is going to come it's just you know", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00532-00141878-00142151": "how much time is everybody's guess in", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00533-00142152-00142409": "which product segment but definitely it", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00534-00142410-00142690": "is going to move in that direction much", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00535-00142691-00142931": "sooner than we all believe will happen", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00536-00142932-00143273": "Okay so thank you very much for giving", "TBXmaFjNTUI-00537-00143274-00143750": "me this opportunity to be here thank you"}}, {"audio_id": "TC_BQcrYXgE", "text": {"TC_BQcrYXgE-00000-00000166-00000447": "[Music]", "TC_BQcrYXgE-00001-00000448-00000638": "it's over anakin", "TC_BQcrYXgE-00002-00000639-00000886": "i have the high ground bam i've knocked", "TC_BQcrYXgE-00003-00000888-00001070": "him onto the ledge this is huge the", "TC_BQcrYXgE-00004-00001071-00001231": "reach you can hit people from begins at", "TC_BQcrYXgE-00005-00001232-00001383": "the player's eyes so when dream is a", "TC_BQcrYXgE-00006-00001384-00001543": "block higher than me it's much easier", "TC_BQcrYXgE-00007-00001544-00001687": "for me to hit his feet than for him to", "TC_BQcrYXgE-00008-00001688-00001847": "hit my head because the base of a right", "TC_BQcrYXgE-00009-00001848-00002047": "triangle is shorter than the hypotenuse", "TC_BQcrYXgE-00010-00002048-00002223": "stay in school kids it makes you better", "TC_BQcrYXgE-00011-00002224-00003270": "at pvp", "TC_BQcrYXgE-00012-00003271-00003515": "[Applause]"}}, {"audio_id": "TCA1tBdccQA", "text": {"TCA1tBdccQA-00000-00000300-00000726": "[Music]", "TCA1tBdccQA-00001-00000727-00000886": "welcome to eco sy", "TCA1tBdccQA-00002-00000888-00001111": "today we have an idea episode where we", "TCA1tBdccQA-00003-00001112-00001287": "talk about a new topic for many of our", "TCA1tBdccQA-00004-00001288-00001415": "listeners and it's called", "TCA1tBdccQA-00005-00001416-00001679": "what is machine as a service so to help", "TCA1tBdccQA-00006-00001680-00001855": "us walk through this conversation we", "TCA1tBdccQA-00007-00001855-00001895": "have", "TCA1tBdccQA-00008-00001896-00002199": "mr mike chromakey who is the founder and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00009-00002200-00002526": "ceo at steam chain so welcome mike", "TCA1tBdccQA-00010-00002527-00002758": "thanks chris how you doing today man", "TCA1tBdccQA-00011-00002759-00002950": "yeah we're doing great up here in uh in", "TCA1tBdccQA-00012-00002951-00003023": "milwaukee", "TCA1tBdccQA-00013-00003024-00003206": "i got a little winter weather outside", "TCA1tBdccQA-00014-00003207-00003351": "but i've heard you guys have the same", "TCA1tBdccQA-00015-00003352-00003447": "thing down south", "TCA1tBdccQA-00016-00003447-00003663": "yeah just down for some reason down here", "TCA1tBdccQA-00017-00003664-00003806": "it comes down in ice and i", "TCA1tBdccQA-00018-00003807-00004022": "i don't like ice unless it's uh sitting", "TCA1tBdccQA-00019-00004023-00004159": "in some bourbon but you know that's for", "TCA1tBdccQA-00020-00004160-00004343": "a different show i guess you know", "TCA1tBdccQA-00021-00004344-00004647": "absolutely but but man i'm glad we were", "TCA1tBdccQA-00022-00004648-00004751": "able to connect with you man", "TCA1tBdccQA-00023-00004752-00005054": "it's a pretty cool topic and we were", "TCA1tBdccQA-00024-00005055-00005206": "brainstorming on together you really", "TCA1tBdccQA-00025-00005207-00005399": "opened my eyes to what machine as a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00026-00005400-00005527": "service is but there's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00027-00005528-00005663": "probably a lot of listeners out there", "TCA1tBdccQA-00028-00005664-00005847": "mike who just don't know", "TCA1tBdccQA-00029-00005848-00006038": "you know what that is when they hear", "TCA1tBdccQA-00030-00006039-00006222": "that so you know could you break that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00031-00006223-00006391": "down how would you define machine as a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00032-00006392-00006503": "service", "TCA1tBdccQA-00033-00006504-00006631": "so machine is a service and i think", "TCA1tBdccQA-00034-00006631-00006855": "there's a lot of misinterpretation of it", "TCA1tBdccQA-00035-00006856-00007087": "uh but really when you boil it down to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00036-00007088-00007231": "its fundamentals", "TCA1tBdccQA-00037-00007231-00007534": "it's any business model that uses the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00038-00007536-00007606": "data", "TCA1tBdccQA-00039-00007608-00007823": "from the machinery to inform a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00040-00007823-00007998": "contractual relationship", "TCA1tBdccQA-00041-00008000-00008142": "between the people that are supplying", "TCA1tBdccQA-00042-00008143-00008295": "that equipment or technology and the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00043-00008296-00008495": "people that are operating it", "TCA1tBdccQA-00044-00008496-00008783": "so the the concept of it as a service", "TCA1tBdccQA-00045-00008784-00008871": "means that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00046-00008872-00009142": "some element of that asset you're paying", "TCA1tBdccQA-00047-00009143-00009183": "for", "TCA1tBdccQA-00048-00009184-00009383": "as you're using it another way to look", "TCA1tBdccQA-00049-00009384-00009551": "at it is really performance-based", "TCA1tBdccQA-00050-00009552-00009623": "payments or", "TCA1tBdccQA-00051-00009624-00009919": "managed service contracts which are very", "TCA1tBdccQA-00052-00009920-00009983": "popular", "TCA1tBdccQA-00053-00009984-00010231": "in in other industries uh but are a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00054-00010232-00010431": "really new concept in manufacturing", "TCA1tBdccQA-00055-00010432-00010623": "i mean when you like think through the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00056-00010624-00010846": "traditional concept of manufacturing", "TCA1tBdccQA-00057-00010847-00011038": "you know what what does that really look", "TCA1tBdccQA-00058-00011039-00011263": "like right now", "TCA1tBdccQA-00059-00011264-00011423": "the the traditional concept of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00060-00011424-00011687": "manufacturing is uh is a classic capital", "TCA1tBdccQA-00061-00011688-00011870": "asset sales process", "TCA1tBdccQA-00062-00011871-00012183": "right and so uh you generally pay", "TCA1tBdccQA-00063-00012184-00012431": "uh up front uh to contract somebody to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00064-00012432-00012591": "build you the equipment that you need", "TCA1tBdccQA-00065-00012592-00012631": "and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00066-00012632-00012902": "you make progress payments as you uh", "TCA1tBdccQA-00067-00012903-00012991": "move forward", "TCA1tBdccQA-00068-00012991-00013158": "uh through the process of getting that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00069-00013159-00013327": "delivered and set up in your facility", "TCA1tBdccQA-00070-00013328-00013455": "and then there's some kind of final", "TCA1tBdccQA-00071-00013456-00013551": "payment", "TCA1tBdccQA-00072-00013552-00013799": "uh at which point the the risk is owned", "TCA1tBdccQA-00073-00013800-00013975": "by the person that acquired the asset", "TCA1tBdccQA-00074-00013976-00014158": "and the capital is transferred to the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00075-00014159-00014358": "organization that supplied it", "TCA1tBdccQA-00076-00014359-00014599": "uh and you know that that is uh that's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00077-00014600-00014766": "an effective way to manage", "TCA1tBdccQA-00078-00014768-00015086": "uh the the acquisition of capital assets", "TCA1tBdccQA-00079-00015087-00015135": "it's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00080-00015136-00015422": "historically been used but uh you you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00081-00015423-00015527": "know as as", "TCA1tBdccQA-00082-00015528-00015847": "you know we sit here in 2021 with", "TCA1tBdccQA-00083-00015847-00016071": "all this data and information that's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00084-00016072-00016183": "available from these", "TCA1tBdccQA-00085-00016184-00016471": "industrial machines nowadays it seems to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00086-00016472-00016575": "not use", "TCA1tBdccQA-00087-00016576-00016807": "that information in the contractual", "TCA1tBdccQA-00088-00016808-00016999": "relationship between counterparties for", "TCA1tBdccQA-00089-00017000-00017343": "these these large uh industrial assets", "TCA1tBdccQA-00090-00017344-00017591": "is really a missed opportunity right", "TCA1tBdccQA-00091-00017592-00017727": "right no doubt man", "TCA1tBdccQA-00092-00017728-00017927": "but i'm sure with some of this you're", "TCA1tBdccQA-00093-00017928-00018135": "trying to overcome some thinking", "TCA1tBdccQA-00094-00018136-00018358": "with that traditional model you know", "TCA1tBdccQA-00095-00018359-00018550": "what is what is that big shift that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00096-00018551-00018703": "you're trying to get people past when", "TCA1tBdccQA-00097-00018704-00018758": "they start", "TCA1tBdccQA-00098-00018759-00019063": "exploring machine as a service yeah", "TCA1tBdccQA-00099-00019064-00019343": "you know the the the model that's being", "TCA1tBdccQA-00100-00019344-00019591": "used by 99.9 percent", "TCA1tBdccQA-00101-00019592-00019814": "of uh suppliers of machinery and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00102-00019815-00019983": "technology in this industry", "TCA1tBdccQA-00103-00019984-00020199": "it really dates back to the industrial", "TCA1tBdccQA-00104-00020200-00020311": "revolution right", "TCA1tBdccQA-00105-00020312-00020678": "in industry 1.0 uh and and so", "TCA1tBdccQA-00106-00020679-00020839": "there's a lot of inertia behind it and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00107-00020840-00021055": "there's just the status quo of how we've", "TCA1tBdccQA-00108-00021056-00021278": "always done it uh and and people have", "TCA1tBdccQA-00109-00021279-00021430": "built their businesses around these", "TCA1tBdccQA-00110-00021431-00021630": "concepts right it's it's how an oem", "TCA1tBdccQA-00111-00021631-00021847": "manages their their cash flow", "TCA1tBdccQA-00112-00021848-00022022": "how they manage their investments are", "TCA1tBdccQA-00113-00022023-00022263": "all tied into the idea that they get a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00114-00022264-00022447": "down payment and that down payment", "TCA1tBdccQA-00115-00022448-00022703": "funds the machinery the the cost of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00116-00022704-00022886": "goods sold that they're building", "TCA1tBdccQA-00117-00022887-00023071": "and then they get progress payments that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00118-00023072-00023191": "they as they go", "TCA1tBdccQA-00119-00023192-00023399": "and they deliver and then they move on", "TCA1tBdccQA-00120-00023400-00023527": "to the next customer", "TCA1tBdccQA-00121-00023528-00023758": "and and so so it it's worked", "TCA1tBdccQA-00122-00023759-00023878": "traditionally", "TCA1tBdccQA-00123-00023879-00024119": "reasonably well but we think there's a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00124-00024120-00024311": "lot of room to optimize it", "TCA1tBdccQA-00125-00024312-00024542": "the the big issue with it is it's really", "TCA1tBdccQA-00126-00024543-00024775": "a one-size-fits-all solution", "TCA1tBdccQA-00127-00024776-00024958": "everybody does it fundamentally the same", "TCA1tBdccQA-00128-00024959-00025167": "way everybody's used to the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00129-00025168-00025486": "that methodology and that's the inertia", "TCA1tBdccQA-00130-00025487-00025711": "but when you start to break that down", "TCA1tBdccQA-00131-00025712-00025878": "and really understand the value", "TCA1tBdccQA-00132-00025879-00025999": "proposition", "TCA1tBdccQA-00133-00026000-00026231": "people aren't buying machines because", "TCA1tBdccQA-00134-00026232-00026414": "they want an industrial asset they're", "TCA1tBdccQA-00135-00026416-00026495": "buying", "TCA1tBdccQA-00136-00026495-00026735": "those machines because they want some", "TCA1tBdccQA-00137-00026736-00026862": "kind of outcome", "TCA1tBdccQA-00138-00026863-00027158": "and that outcome takes place over time", "TCA1tBdccQA-00139-00027160-00027399": "uh and so the more", "TCA1tBdccQA-00140-00027400-00027607": "and it's not just the machine that they", "TCA1tBdccQA-00141-00027608-00027839": "need to produce that outcome", "TCA1tBdccQA-00142-00027839-00028031": "right they also need the skilled labor", "TCA1tBdccQA-00143-00028032-00028199": "to support it they need the training", "TCA1tBdccQA-00144-00028200-00028431": "they need the the maintenance department", "TCA1tBdccQA-00145-00028432-00028502": "they need", "TCA1tBdccQA-00146-00028504-00028735": "the operators they they need other", "TCA1tBdccQA-00147-00028736-00028951": "auxiliary technologies", "TCA1tBdccQA-00148-00028952-00029183": "so there's this whole kind of package of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00149-00029183-00029439": "value that really comes into play", "TCA1tBdccQA-00150-00029439-00029758": "to get them the desired outcome uh", "TCA1tBdccQA-00151-00029760-00030031": "and today the machinery manufacturers", "TCA1tBdccQA-00152-00030032-00030183": "are generally supplying one piece of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00153-00030183-00030358": "that and it's up to each individual", "TCA1tBdccQA-00154-00030360-00030511": "end user to try and put that all", "TCA1tBdccQA-00155-00030512-00030743": "together and in in today's environment a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00156-00030744-00030911": "lot of end users", "TCA1tBdccQA-00157-00030912-00031095": "they would love to do more automation", "TCA1tBdccQA-00158-00031095-00031246": "they'd love to have more automated", "TCA1tBdccQA-00159-00031247-00031351": "equipment", "TCA1tBdccQA-00160-00031352-00031623": "the problem isn't buying it the problem", "TCA1tBdccQA-00161-00031624-00031655": "is", "TCA1tBdccQA-00162-00031656-00031839": "all the things that come after you buy", "TCA1tBdccQA-00163-00031839-00032070": "it to actually get the results that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00164-00032072-00032174": "you're looking for is", "TCA1tBdccQA-00165-00032175-00032414": "is where they really struggle and having", "TCA1tBdccQA-00166-00032416-00032479": "better", "TCA1tBdccQA-00167-00032480-00032695": "partnerships with their oem to deliver", "TCA1tBdccQA-00168-00032695-00032879": "more of that value proposition we think", "TCA1tBdccQA-00169-00032880-00032974": "is a very", "TCA1tBdccQA-00170-00032975-00033295": "uh a very good idea for both parties no", "TCA1tBdccQA-00171-00033296-00033343": "doubt", "TCA1tBdccQA-00172-00033344-00033590": "i mean i really it resonated so much", "TCA1tBdccQA-00173-00033591-00033774": "from things you said right there around", "TCA1tBdccQA-00174-00033775-00033918": "you know what the buyer what the buyer", "TCA1tBdccQA-00175-00033919-00034039": "really needs they're not trying to buy", "TCA1tBdccQA-00176-00034040-00034190": "the equipment they just they want that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00177-00034191-00034271": "outcome", "TCA1tBdccQA-00178-00034272-00034407": "you know we used to do in the be in the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00179-00034408-00034583": "motor world and and i used to tell", "TCA1tBdccQA-00180-00034584-00034639": "people", "TCA1tBdccQA-00181-00034640-00034823": "you really don't want a motor you just", "TCA1tBdccQA-00182-00034824-00034943": "need a shaft turning to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00183-00034944-00035167": "to be able to you know move your line or", "TCA1tBdccQA-00184-00035168-00035343": "wherever that motor is connected to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00185-00035344-00035479": "it doesn't matter what moves it you just", "TCA1tBdccQA-00186-00035480-00035662": "need something to be moving it", "TCA1tBdccQA-00187-00035663-00035799": "just has the electric motor that's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00188-00035800-00036015": "moving it right yeah it gets back to the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00189-00036016-00036055": "old", "TCA1tBdccQA-00190-00036056-00036287": "you know do you want a drill or do you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00191-00036288-00036502": "want a hole exactly right", "TCA1tBdccQA-00192-00036503-00036799": "and and so any opportunity to to meet", "TCA1tBdccQA-00193-00036800-00036967": "your customer where they're really at", "TCA1tBdccQA-00194-00036968-00037367": "and supply uh you know a broader scope", "TCA1tBdccQA-00195-00037368-00037599": "of services and solutions that that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00196-00037600-00037759": "encompass both the machinery", "TCA1tBdccQA-00197-00037760-00038079": "and the other auxiliary services", "TCA1tBdccQA-00198-00038080-00038302": "and and technology that's necessary to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00199-00038303-00038551": "get optimized performance out of that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00200-00038552-00038751": "uh we believe is a better value", "TCA1tBdccQA-00201-00038752-00038951": "proposition and certainly a stronger", "TCA1tBdccQA-00202-00038952-00039095": "business for that oem", "TCA1tBdccQA-00203-00039096-00039415": "right no doubt you also mentioned", "TCA1tBdccQA-00204-00039416-00039590": "you know the business model the old", "TCA1tBdccQA-00205-00039591-00039759": "model versus where things are going now", "TCA1tBdccQA-00206-00039760-00039830": "so if you're", "TCA1tBdccQA-00207-00039831-00040007": "if you're trying to coach leaders in", "TCA1tBdccQA-00208-00040008-00040143": "business right now", "TCA1tBdccQA-00209-00040144-00040430": "to start trying to to utilize some of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00210-00040431-00040462": "these", "TCA1tBdccQA-00211-00040463-00040630": "these technology advancements and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00212-00040631-00040815": "adoption you know what are you telling", "TCA1tBdccQA-00213-00040816-00040862": "them", "TCA1tBdccQA-00214-00040863-00041023": "how you trying to get them there to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00215-00041024-00041207": "start thinking this way", "TCA1tBdccQA-00216-00041208-00041446": "yeah a lot of our oems are really", "TCA1tBdccQA-00217-00041447-00041607": "forward looking in this space and they", "TCA1tBdccQA-00218-00041608-00041751": "understand", "TCA1tBdccQA-00219-00041752-00042023": "that that the opportunity is to help", "TCA1tBdccQA-00220-00042024-00042207": "their customers deliver the results that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00221-00042208-00042390": "they're looking for", "TCA1tBdccQA-00222-00042391-00042695": "and so you know and this this can be", "TCA1tBdccQA-00223-00042696-00042887": "done in a way that's helpful to the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00224-00042888-00043062": "oem's business as well it's really about", "TCA1tBdccQA-00225-00043063-00043279": "increasing your scope of supply", "TCA1tBdccQA-00226-00043280-00043439": "increasing your value to that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00227-00043440-00043599": "organization and becoming a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00228-00043600-00043855": "partner to them not just to deliver the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00229-00043856-00043990": "big hunk of metal", "TCA1tBdccQA-00230-00043991-00044190": "right or the motor in your in your", "TCA1tBdccQA-00231-00044191-00044446": "scenario but to deliver the results and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00232-00044447-00044607": "have accountability", "TCA1tBdccQA-00233-00044608-00044879": "for uh the the the results that you're", "TCA1tBdccQA-00234-00044880-00045095": "producing you know i spent many years", "TCA1tBdccQA-00235-00045096-00045262": "as you know chris working for rockwell", "TCA1tBdccQA-00236-00045263-00045423": "automation and and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00237-00045424-00045623": "at rockwell just like a lot of companies", "TCA1tBdccQA-00238-00045624-00045727": "in this space", "TCA1tBdccQA-00239-00045728-00045918": "in the sales organization there's lots", "TCA1tBdccQA-00240-00045919-00046046": "of discussions about", "TCA1tBdccQA-00241-00046047-00046367": "value selling right you you you don't", "TCA1tBdccQA-00242-00046368-00046471": "want to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00243-00046472-00046711": "talk about features and functionality", "TCA1tBdccQA-00244-00046712-00046830": "you want to talk about how those", "TCA1tBdccQA-00245-00046831-00046990": "features and functionality", "TCA1tBdccQA-00246-00046991-00047207": "support your customer right you want to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00247-00047208-00047374": "you want to pitch the value how this", "TCA1tBdccQA-00248-00047375-00047558": "improves their business", "TCA1tBdccQA-00249-00047559-00047862": "and and so that's you know rockwell's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00250-00047863-00048023": "not unique in that and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00251-00048024-00048302": "certainly oems tell the same story and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00252-00048303-00048415": "it's about the value that they're", "TCA1tBdccQA-00253-00048416-00048671": "creating but at the end of the day", "TCA1tBdccQA-00254-00048672-00048855": "everybody's still billing for the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00255-00048856-00049086": "machine not the value the machine", "TCA1tBdccQA-00256-00049087-00049215": "provides", "TCA1tBdccQA-00257-00049216-00049399": "right and so there's a disconnection", "TCA1tBdccQA-00258-00049400-00049558": "between what people are selling and how", "TCA1tBdccQA-00259-00049559-00049799": "they're monetizing that sale", "TCA1tBdccQA-00260-00049800-00049958": "and machine as a service is a great", "TCA1tBdccQA-00261-00049959-00050151": "mechanism that can be used to align", "TCA1tBdccQA-00262-00050152-00050279": "those interests", "TCA1tBdccQA-00263-00050280-00050502": "so that when you're out there selling", "TCA1tBdccQA-00264-00050503-00050718": "the ability to help your customer", "TCA1tBdccQA-00265-00050719-00050895": "achieve the performance", "TCA1tBdccQA-00266-00050896-00051111": "and your margin and financial", "TCA1tBdccQA-00267-00051112-00051279": "performance is linked to that it's a lot", "TCA1tBdccQA-00268-00051279-00051319": "more", "TCA1tBdccQA-00269-00051320-00051607": "credible sales process because you can", "TCA1tBdccQA-00270-00051608-00051830": "clearly draw the lines between", "TCA1tBdccQA-00271-00051832-00051990": "the improvements that you're making at", "TCA1tBdccQA-00272-00051991-00052150": "that customer and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00273-00052151-00052399": "and and the promises that you've made to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00274-00052400-00052487": "help them", "TCA1tBdccQA-00275-00052488-00052742": "right it really puts both those parties", "TCA1tBdccQA-00276-00052744-00052942": "on the same side of the table", "TCA1tBdccQA-00277-00052944-00053135": "everybody's most profitable when the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00278-00053136-00053375": "machine meets or exceeds", "TCA1tBdccQA-00279-00053376-00053599": "its expectations right and there's so", "TCA1tBdccQA-00280-00053600-00053735": "many opportunities", "TCA1tBdccQA-00281-00053736-00053959": "to bundle in the service that's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00282-00053960-00054071": "necessary", "TCA1tBdccQA-00283-00054072-00054254": "upgrades to that equipment or other", "TCA1tBdccQA-00284-00054255-00054407": "equipment that help achieve those", "TCA1tBdccQA-00285-00054408-00054582": "performance levels", "TCA1tBdccQA-00286-00054583-00054766": "over the life of that contract because", "TCA1tBdccQA-00287-00054767-00054982": "there's a built-in mechanism", "TCA1tBdccQA-00288-00054983-00055263": "to monetize that right that's directly", "TCA1tBdccQA-00289-00055264-00055326": "linked", "TCA1tBdccQA-00290-00055327-00055575": "to the economics that the end user faces", "TCA1tBdccQA-00291-00055576-00055735": "you're basically saying bring in all the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00292-00055736-00055894": "service people you want because if you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00293-00055895-00056103": "believe you can improve my process", "TCA1tBdccQA-00294-00056104-00056247": "the money is already built into the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00295-00056248-00056430": "contract right help me", "TCA1tBdccQA-00296-00056432-00056735": "help me help you right help", "TCA1tBdccQA-00297-00056736-00056999": "help us all win together and and you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00298-00057000-00057166": "know of course the flip side of that is", "TCA1tBdccQA-00299-00057167-00057375": "we all share the same risks", "TCA1tBdccQA-00300-00057376-00057550": "right we're all accountable to work", "TCA1tBdccQA-00301-00057551-00057711": "together and we're all better", "TCA1tBdccQA-00302-00057712-00057959": "when we work together because we all get", "TCA1tBdccQA-00303-00057960-00058038": "paid", "TCA1tBdccQA-00304-00058039-00058223": "uh based on the performance of the asset", "TCA1tBdccQA-00305-00058224-00058375": "when you just set that point of risk", "TCA1tBdccQA-00306-00058376-00058430": "that that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00307-00058432-00058654": "brought something to mind so is this", "TCA1tBdccQA-00308-00058655-00058854": "shifting that risk profile with this", "TCA1tBdccQA-00309-00058855-00059063": "type of mindset", "TCA1tBdccQA-00310-00059064-00059350": "yeah absolutely right i'd say hidden", "TCA1tBdccQA-00311-00059351-00059519": "cost of automation", "TCA1tBdccQA-00312-00059520-00059830": "or resistance to automate or is really", "TCA1tBdccQA-00313-00059832-00059942": "risk it's not", "TCA1tBdccQA-00314-00059944-00060199": "it's not the capital it's not do i have", "TCA1tBdccQA-00315-00060200-00060342": "the money up front", "TCA1tBdccQA-00316-00060344-00060599": "right it's it's the implied risk that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00317-00060600-00060735": "when i give you that money", "TCA1tBdccQA-00318-00060736-00060894": "that there's a delay between the time i", "TCA1tBdccQA-00319-00060895-00061023": "give you that money and the time i", "TCA1tBdccQA-00320-00061024-00061230": "realize the performance", "TCA1tBdccQA-00321-00061232-00061454": "and there's both technical risks there's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00322-00061455-00061606": "commercial risk there's all sorts of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00323-00061607-00061887": "different elements of risk and so", "TCA1tBdccQA-00324-00061888-00062103": "working together with a supplier that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00325-00062104-00062215": "understands", "TCA1tBdccQA-00326-00062216-00062559": "your your industry your business", "TCA1tBdccQA-00327-00062560-00062742": "understands the economics and is willing", "TCA1tBdccQA-00328-00062744-00063015": "to share in that risk with you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00329-00063016-00063206": "we think is a very effective model both", "TCA1tBdccQA-00330-00063207-00063382": "for the oem and the end user", "TCA1tBdccQA-00331-00063383-00063630": "no doubt no doubt you know we were", "TCA1tBdccQA-00332-00063632-00063782": "talking earlier too about", "TCA1tBdccQA-00333-00063783-00063966": "data and you mentioned that there's so", "TCA1tBdccQA-00334-00063967-00064150": "much data now available", "TCA1tBdccQA-00335-00064151-00064366": "and sometimes these manufacturers aren't", "TCA1tBdccQA-00336-00064367-00064575": "you know capturing that available data", "TCA1tBdccQA-00337-00064576-00064775": "or utilizing it the best because", "TCA1tBdccQA-00338-00064776-00064926": "they just they don't have the resources", "TCA1tBdccQA-00339-00064927-00065094": "so when you when you think through who", "TCA1tBdccQA-00340-00065095-00065271": "gains the most with them from a data", "TCA1tBdccQA-00341-00065272-00065406": "standpoint", "TCA1tBdccQA-00342-00065407-00065550": "you know how would you address that i", "TCA1tBdccQA-00343-00065551-00065759": "mean what what would be the the answer", "TCA1tBdccQA-00344-00065760-00065815": "to the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00345-00065816-00066023": "to the plant manager out there to really", "TCA1tBdccQA-00346-00066024-00066223": "consider this type of uh", "TCA1tBdccQA-00347-00066224-00066519": "business model to to help them utilize", "TCA1tBdccQA-00348-00066520-00066647": "data better", "TCA1tBdccQA-00349-00066648-00066894": "yeah the data is really the key right", "TCA1tBdccQA-00350-00066895-00067015": "and i think everybody's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00351-00067016-00067287": "heard that message for for many years", "TCA1tBdccQA-00352-00067288-00067447": "you've been in this industry a long time", "TCA1tBdccQA-00353-00067448-00067550": "chris as a buy", "TCA1tBdccQA-00354-00067551-00067743": "this industrial internet of things", "TCA1tBdccQA-00355-00067744-00067975": "revolution or industry 4.0 revolution is", "TCA1tBdccQA-00356-00067976-00068135": "about the slowest revolution i've ever", "TCA1tBdccQA-00357-00068136-00068319": "seen come down the pipe", "TCA1tBdccQA-00358-00068320-00068575": "um you know it it's been talked about", "TCA1tBdccQA-00359-00068576-00068750": "for many years and of course everybody", "TCA1tBdccQA-00360-00068751-00068911": "is investing in", "TCA1tBdccQA-00361-00068912-00069071": "the hardware and the technology to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00362-00069072-00069231": "collect that data so there's been a lot", "TCA1tBdccQA-00363-00069232-00069263": "of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00364-00069264-00069567": "progress that's made it easier more", "TCA1tBdccQA-00365-00069568-00069655": "secure", "TCA1tBdccQA-00366-00069656-00069879": "more available to everybody but what", "TCA1tBdccQA-00367-00069880-00070119": "hasn't kept pace chris is", "TCA1tBdccQA-00368-00070120-00070438": "the why what do you do with it right and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00369-00070439-00070487": "so", "TCA1tBdccQA-00370-00070488-00070679": "great dashboards are are wonderful and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00371-00070680-00070903": "it helps you understand your operation", "TCA1tBdccQA-00372-00070904-00071231": "but what does that drive in terms of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00373-00071232-00071511": "response or improvements or performance", "TCA1tBdccQA-00374-00071512-00071726": "and we think the secret sauce", "TCA1tBdccQA-00375-00071727-00071950": "is really making sure that everybody in", "TCA1tBdccQA-00376-00071951-00072167": "the value chain that contributes to your", "TCA1tBdccQA-00377-00072168-00072255": "success", "TCA1tBdccQA-00378-00072256-00072543": "has a stake in that success and has", "TCA1tBdccQA-00379-00072544-00072662": "clarity", "TCA1tBdccQA-00380-00072663-00073071": "that the the goal is you know xyz", "TCA1tBdccQA-00381-00073072-00073247": "and we all understand that we're working", "TCA1tBdccQA-00382-00073248-00073415": "together to achieve that goal and we all", "TCA1tBdccQA-00383-00073416-00073582": "understand our businesses do best when", "TCA1tBdccQA-00384-00073583-00073767": "we're able to work together to achieve", "TCA1tBdccQA-00385-00073768-00073847": "that goal", "TCA1tBdccQA-00386-00073848-00074087": "right so what we we like to use the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00387-00074088-00074438": "terminology manage service contracts uh", "TCA1tBdccQA-00388-00074439-00074591": "you know which is which is popular in", "TCA1tBdccQA-00389-00074592-00074750": "the it space", "TCA1tBdccQA-00390-00074751-00074982": "but it's it's co-managed objectives", "TCA1tBdccQA-00391-00074983-00075135": "enabled by", "TCA1tBdccQA-00392-00075136-00075319": "uh the technology so that the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00393-00075320-00075471": "organization that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00394-00075472-00075743": "has sold you the equipment uh whether", "TCA1tBdccQA-00395-00075744-00075799": "you bought", "TCA1tBdccQA-00396-00075800-00076143": "it on a traditional sale or not has", "TCA1tBdccQA-00397-00076144-00076423": "an economic incentive to help you be", "TCA1tBdccQA-00398-00076424-00076615": "successful with it and help you solve", "TCA1tBdccQA-00399-00076616-00076703": "problems because", "TCA1tBdccQA-00400-00076704-00076926": "if those problems are left unsolved", "TCA1tBdccQA-00401-00076927-00077126": "right in it impacts obviously the end", "TCA1tBdccQA-00402-00077127-00077271": "users", "TCA1tBdccQA-00403-00077272-00077494": "economics right in their financial", "TCA1tBdccQA-00404-00077495-00077575": "situation", "TCA1tBdccQA-00405-00077576-00077743": "but it should also have an impact to the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00406-00077744-00077967": "oem or create an incentive for the oem", "TCA1tBdccQA-00407-00077968-00078103": "to stay engaged", "TCA1tBdccQA-00408-00078104-00078247": "one of the things that we hear most", "TCA1tBdccQA-00409-00078248-00078431": "often from end users", "TCA1tBdccQA-00410-00078432-00078703": "lack of engagement you know i get the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00411-00078704-00078831": "machine but when i have", "TCA1tBdccQA-00412-00078832-00079126": "issues when i have questions they want", "TCA1tBdccQA-00413-00079127-00079319": "to charge me for service that you know", "TCA1tBdccQA-00414-00079320-00079462": "it's hard to get in touch with the right", "TCA1tBdccQA-00415-00079463-00079735": "people and that's fundamentally a factor", "TCA1tBdccQA-00416-00079736-00079975": "of how the economic incentives are set", "TCA1tBdccQA-00417-00079976-00080079": "up today", "TCA1tBdccQA-00418-00080080-00080391": "right those businesses run very lean", "TCA1tBdccQA-00419-00080392-00080711": "margins are very tight right and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00420-00080712-00080935": "you know yes they're trying to sell you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00421-00080936-00081135": "post sales service packages and other", "TCA1tBdccQA-00422-00081136-00081223": "things", "TCA1tBdccQA-00423-00081224-00081526": "but ultimately without some mechanism to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00424-00081527-00081719": "understand what the goals are", "TCA1tBdccQA-00425-00081720-00081991": "that's just a give me a bunch of money", "TCA1tBdccQA-00426-00081992-00082126": "and when things go wrong we'll see what", "TCA1tBdccQA-00427-00082127-00082215": "we can do to help", "TCA1tBdccQA-00428-00082216-00082511": "right solution right and so so that's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00429-00082512-00082543": "not", "TCA1tBdccQA-00430-00082544-00082750": "really effective and in most cases", "TCA1tBdccQA-00431-00082751-00082950": "nobody buys those solutions", "TCA1tBdccQA-00432-00082951-00083255": "if you compare and contrast that with", "TCA1tBdccQA-00433-00083256-00083479": "you know hey we're we're getting a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00434-00083480-00083671": "fraction of the performance of the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00435-00083672-00083726": "machine", "TCA1tBdccQA-00436-00083727-00083991": "as long as we're above a certain level", "TCA1tBdccQA-00437-00083992-00084055": "or", "TCA1tBdccQA-00438-00084056-00084247": "you know the availability of the asset", "TCA1tBdccQA-00439-00084248-00084503": "can be maintained at xyz", "TCA1tBdccQA-00440-00084504-00084703": "uh you know where they're taking some", "TCA1tBdccQA-00441-00084704-00084871": "risk and they're providing", "TCA1tBdccQA-00442-00084872-00085199": "service and support to to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00443-00085200-00085399": "help them fund those performance", "TCA1tBdccQA-00444-00085400-00085535": "initiatives we think that's a much", "TCA1tBdccQA-00445-00085536-00085662": "healthier opportunity", "TCA1tBdccQA-00446-00085663-00085911": "and it's the transparency uh that is", "TCA1tBdccQA-00447-00085912-00086015": "created", "TCA1tBdccQA-00448-00086016-00086191": "when you gathering that data from the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00449-00086192-00086343": "machine real time that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00450-00086344-00086511": "enables those kinds of business models", "TCA1tBdccQA-00451-00086512-00086718": "to exist no doubt and it sounds like", "TCA1tBdccQA-00452-00086719-00086882": "that's an opportunity to strengthen", "TCA1tBdccQA-00453-00086883-00087038": "partnerships you know", "TCA1tBdccQA-00454-00087039-00087326": "to to levels unheard of from an oem to a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00455-00087327-00087438": "manufacturer", "TCA1tBdccQA-00456-00087439-00087679": "you know and as well it gives that oem", "TCA1tBdccQA-00457-00087680-00087847": "if i'm hearing this correctly", "TCA1tBdccQA-00458-00087848-00088055": "there may be some some recurring you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00459-00088056-00088262": "know funding coming in on a regular", "TCA1tBdccQA-00460-00088263-00088415": "basis that they may not be", "TCA1tBdccQA-00461-00088416-00088718": "you know capturing right now yeah i i", "TCA1tBdccQA-00462-00088719-00088935": "think it helps weed out the oems that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00463-00088936-00089215": "make promises and struggle to deliver", "TCA1tBdccQA-00464-00089216-00089375": "right", "TCA1tBdccQA-00465-00089376-00089631": "because it changes the model it's not", "TCA1tBdccQA-00466-00089632-00089750": "just about", "TCA1tBdccQA-00467-00089751-00089967": "selling that next machine to that next", "TCA1tBdccQA-00468-00089968-00090175": "customer right which is what drives them", "TCA1tBdccQA-00469-00090176-00090255": "today", "TCA1tBdccQA-00470-00090256-00090462": "right and so if you're not getting good", "TCA1tBdccQA-00471-00090463-00090687": "response times from your oems it's it's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00472-00090688-00090815": "because their business", "TCA1tBdccQA-00473-00090816-00091047": "is run based on their ability to sell a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00474-00091048-00091150": "new machine", "TCA1tBdccQA-00475-00091151-00091367": "not necessarily to support the machines", "TCA1tBdccQA-00476-00091368-00091526": "that they have in place", "TCA1tBdccQA-00477-00091527-00091767": "right and so if you're not getting the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00478-00091768-00091926": "response times you're looking for there", "TCA1tBdccQA-00479-00091927-00091967": "might", "TCA1tBdccQA-00480-00091968-00092247": "be the incentives in place right and so", "TCA1tBdccQA-00481-00092248-00092431": "shifting that model to create some post", "TCA1tBdccQA-00482-00092432-00092487": "sales", "TCA1tBdccQA-00483-00092488-00092743": "incentives based on performance that are", "TCA1tBdccQA-00484-00092744-00092894": "objectively", "TCA1tBdccQA-00485-00092895-00093150": "measured and distributed right what that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00486-00093151-00093326": "does is create that tight relationship", "TCA1tBdccQA-00487-00093327-00093487": "where the performance of the oem's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00488-00093488-00093718": "business and their ability to invest in", "TCA1tBdccQA-00489-00093719-00093831": "helping you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00490-00093832-00093991": "is increased because they have a reason", "TCA1tBdccQA-00491-00093992-00094191": "to do so today they do not", "TCA1tBdccQA-00492-00094192-00094518": "right oems should benefit from the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00493-00094519-00094735": "the the performance of their installed", "TCA1tBdccQA-00494-00094736-00094823": "base", "TCA1tBdccQA-00495-00094824-00095006": "not their ability to sell new machines", "TCA1tBdccQA-00496-00095007-00095247": "to new customers we believe that oem's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00497-00095248-00095367": "businesses", "TCA1tBdccQA-00498-00095368-00095687": "run best when their financial", "TCA1tBdccQA-00499-00095688-00095774": "performance is", "TCA1tBdccQA-00500-00095775-00095935": "linked to the performance of their", "TCA1tBdccQA-00501-00095936-00096094": "installed base", "TCA1tBdccQA-00502-00096095-00096350": "not just their ability to sell another", "TCA1tBdccQA-00503-00096351-00096511": "customer on a new machine", "TCA1tBdccQA-00504-00096512-00096694": "right but for a listener out there the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00505-00096695-00096918": "oem or the machine builder", "TCA1tBdccQA-00506-00096919-00097087": "can you really break down some brass", "TCA1tBdccQA-00507-00097088-00097311": "tacks on the process of what entering", "TCA1tBdccQA-00508-00097312-00097494": "machine as a service would look like you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00509-00097495-00097638": "know there may be certain things that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00510-00097639-00097815": "are that are common from performance to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00511-00097816-00098023": "contracts payments things like that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00512-00098024-00098199": "that may help someone really understand", "TCA1tBdccQA-00513-00098200-00098382": "how to walk this forward", "TCA1tBdccQA-00514-00098383-00098647": "yeah absolutely so fundamentally machine", "TCA1tBdccQA-00515-00098648-00098847": "as a service implies that you're", "TCA1tBdccQA-00516-00098848-00099079": "gathering data from the industrial asset", "TCA1tBdccQA-00517-00099080-00099271": "and of course there's lots of options", "TCA1tBdccQA-00518-00099272-00099482": "for doing that today we have a reference", "TCA1tBdccQA-00519-00099483-00099599": "architecture", "TCA1tBdccQA-00520-00099600-00099903": "that we use but we're more than capable", "TCA1tBdccQA-00521-00099904-00100038": "of integrating with whatever", "TCA1tBdccQA-00522-00100039-00100262": "iot package or gateway device that you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00523-00100263-00100543": "currently have installed on your machine", "TCA1tBdccQA-00524-00100544-00100694": "and so step one is just the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00525-00100695-00100871": "acknowledgement that that this works", "TCA1tBdccQA-00526-00100872-00101006": "very well if you have", "TCA1tBdccQA-00527-00101007-00101174": "some sort of automated way to collect", "TCA1tBdccQA-00528-00101175-00101335": "the data off the asset", "TCA1tBdccQA-00529-00101336-00101559": "the second part is the the more", "TCA1tBdccQA-00530-00101560-00101718": "important part", "TCA1tBdccQA-00531-00101719-00101982": "uh and that is the design the business", "TCA1tBdccQA-00532-00101983-00102118": "model", "TCA1tBdccQA-00533-00102119-00102294": "lots of lots of people when they hear", "TCA1tBdccQA-00534-00102295-00102551": "machine as a service they assume", "TCA1tBdccQA-00535-00102552-00102851": "that the the business model is a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00536-00102852-00102966": "pay-per-use", "TCA1tBdccQA-00537-00102967-00103294": "or pay-per-unit uh construct and it very", "TCA1tBdccQA-00538-00103295-00103486": "much is that and a lot of our customers", "TCA1tBdccQA-00539-00103488-00103599": "do just that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00540-00103600-00103839": "but it's not just that right it doesn't", "TCA1tBdccQA-00541-00103840-00103975": "have to be that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00542-00103976-00104158": "some of our clients still sell the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00543-00104159-00104358": "machine as a capital asset", "TCA1tBdccQA-00544-00104359-00104623": "they may adjust the upfront sales price", "TCA1tBdccQA-00545-00104624-00104694": "and then", "TCA1tBdccQA-00546-00104695-00105039": "have an ongoing payment based on", "TCA1tBdccQA-00547-00105040-00105239": "performance measurements and so", "TCA1tBdccQA-00548-00105240-00105390": "understanding the business model and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00549-00105391-00105463": "specifically", "TCA1tBdccQA-00550-00105464-00105766": "what are the kpis what are the key", "TCA1tBdccQA-00551-00105767-00105839": "performance", "TCA1tBdccQA-00552-00105840-00106078": "indices that that that really represent", "TCA1tBdccQA-00553-00106079-00106334": "the financial performance of your asset", "TCA1tBdccQA-00554-00106335-00106615": "right in in many cases that's units", "TCA1tBdccQA-00555-00106616-00106663": "right", "TCA1tBdccQA-00556-00106664-00106863": "how many units did the machine produce", "TCA1tBdccQA-00557-00106864-00107095": "but it's also the availability of that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00558-00107096-00107190": "machine", "TCA1tBdccQA-00559-00107191-00107390": "right a machine that is highly available", "TCA1tBdccQA-00560-00107391-00107575": "is more valuable than a machine that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00561-00107576-00107910": "struggles to be available also uh can be", "TCA1tBdccQA-00562-00107911-00108351": "very specific uh application metrics", "TCA1tBdccQA-00563-00108352-00108615": "right so i like to use the the orange", "TCA1tBdccQA-00564-00108616-00108751": "juice analogy", "TCA1tBdccQA-00565-00108752-00109071": "right if if i'm producing orange juice", "TCA1tBdccQA-00566-00109072-00109351": "and and i'm charging you know a dollar", "TCA1tBdccQA-00567-00109352-00109407": "for every", "TCA1tBdccQA-00568-00109408-00109583": "gallon of orange juice that the machine", "TCA1tBdccQA-00569-00109583-00109847": "produces uh that's great i produce 100", "TCA1tBdccQA-00570-00109848-00110031": "gallons of orange juice i made a hundred", "TCA1tBdccQA-00571-00110032-00110151": "dollars but is that the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00572-00110152-00110454": "is that the entirety of the economics no", "TCA1tBdccQA-00573-00110455-00110671": "how many how many pounds of oranges did", "TCA1tBdccQA-00574-00110672-00110886": "it take you to produce that orange juice", "TCA1tBdccQA-00575-00110888-00111086": "right and so that's an example of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00576-00111088-00111286": "application specific metric", "TCA1tBdccQA-00577-00111288-00111486": "it's not how much orange juice did you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00578-00111488-00111631": "produce it's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00579-00111632-00111863": "how what is your conversion rate from", "TCA1tBdccQA-00580-00111864-00112078": "raw oranges to orange juice", "TCA1tBdccQA-00581-00112079-00112390": "right how efficient is that process so", "TCA1tBdccQA-00582-00112391-00112575": "and i use that just to illustrate the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00583-00112576-00112815": "point for every application there's a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00584-00112816-00112871": "different", "TCA1tBdccQA-00585-00112872-00113223": "set of metrics that really", "TCA1tBdccQA-00586-00113224-00113423": "determine the economic performance of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00587-00113424-00113599": "the asset and of course the end users", "TCA1tBdccQA-00588-00113600-00113886": "know what those what those economics are", "TCA1tBdccQA-00589-00113888-00114063": "and the better they partner with their", "TCA1tBdccQA-00590-00114064-00114175": "oem", "TCA1tBdccQA-00591-00114176-00114471": "to say hey what we want to pay for is", "TCA1tBdccQA-00592-00114472-00114702": "results we want to pay for your ability", "TCA1tBdccQA-00593-00114703-00114775": "to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00594-00114776-00115102": "deliver technology that helps us", "TCA1tBdccQA-00595-00115103-00115390": "technology and service solutions that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00596-00115391-00115510": "helps us", "TCA1tBdccQA-00597-00115511-00115807": "achieve those results the the less risk", "TCA1tBdccQA-00598-00115808-00116031": "that that end user is taking", "TCA1tBdccQA-00599-00116032-00116183": "right when they acquire advanced", "TCA1tBdccQA-00600-00116183-00116407": "automation and if you bundle", "TCA1tBdccQA-00601-00116408-00116727": "with that a support package so that the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00602-00116728-00116919": "expectations are that you're not just", "TCA1tBdccQA-00603-00116920-00117039": "delivering the machine", "TCA1tBdccQA-00604-00117040-00117334": "and the services you're in some cases", "TCA1tBdccQA-00605-00117335-00117495": "some of our clients actually deliver the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00606-00117496-00117647": "operators", "TCA1tBdccQA-00607-00117648-00117999": "on-site ready to go uh you know and they", "TCA1tBdccQA-00608-00118000-00118151": "contract with the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00609-00118152-00118334": "with the oem or the supplier of the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00610-00118335-00118519": "technology so there's lots of different", "TCA1tBdccQA-00611-00118520-00118575": "ways", "TCA1tBdccQA-00612-00118576-00118758": "to look at machine as a service that's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00613-00118759-00118983": "my number one takeaway for you guys", "TCA1tBdccQA-00614-00118983-00119166": "we essentially execute those", "TCA1tBdccQA-00615-00119167-00119383": "transactions and set up that business", "TCA1tBdccQA-00616-00119383-00119478": "logic", "TCA1tBdccQA-00617-00119479-00119727": "we're not promoting that one way to do", "TCA1tBdccQA-00618-00119728-00119943": "it versus another way to do it is right", "TCA1tBdccQA-00619-00119944-00120263": "we're promoting the idea that before you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00620-00120264-00120590": "only had one way to deliver and now we", "TCA1tBdccQA-00621-00120591-00120623": "can", "TCA1tBdccQA-00622-00120624-00120902": "customize that in almost infinite", "TCA1tBdccQA-00623-00120903-00121086": "complexity because it's all software", "TCA1tBdccQA-00624-00121088-00121190": "driven", "TCA1tBdccQA-00625-00121191-00121463": "fully automated able to access any data", "TCA1tBdccQA-00626-00121464-00121678": "that's in your control architecture", "TCA1tBdccQA-00627-00121679-00122023": "and set up performance based contracts", "TCA1tBdccQA-00628-00122024-00122223": "to solve whatever business challenges", "TCA1tBdccQA-00629-00122224-00122407": "your end users does", "TCA1tBdccQA-00630-00122408-00122686": "uh to make it easier to sell to create", "TCA1tBdccQA-00631-00122688-00122743": "better", "TCA1tBdccQA-00632-00122744-00122966": "alignment in terms of the goals of the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00633-00122967-00123078": "project", "TCA1tBdccQA-00634-00123079-00123407": "uh and and just a more manageable way", "TCA1tBdccQA-00635-00123408-00123702": "to deploy automation faster more", "TCA1tBdccQA-00636-00123703-00123895": "aggressively and with the support of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00637-00123896-00123927": "your", "TCA1tBdccQA-00638-00123928-00124127": "oem in a way that's measured and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00639-00124128-00124263": "controllable", "TCA1tBdccQA-00640-00124264-00124519": "that's awesome i mean it just sounds", "TCA1tBdccQA-00641-00124520-00124678": "like ultimate flexibility", "TCA1tBdccQA-00642-00124679-00124847": "i mean that that really what i'm hearing", "TCA1tBdccQA-00643-00124848-00125078": "is so much flexibility and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00644-00125079-00125343": "and opportunity for for all parties and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00645-00125344-00125519": "just i like the the partnerships and the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00646-00125520-00125663": "ability to improve", "TCA1tBdccQA-00647-00125664-00125878": "you know but it there there are people", "TCA1tBdccQA-00648-00125879-00126007": "listening mike ari", "TCA1tBdccQA-00649-00126008-00126151": "tell me the bad you know what are some", "TCA1tBdccQA-00650-00126152-00126334": "headwinds that people may face when", "TCA1tBdccQA-00651-00126335-00126543": "they're trying to go this way so", "TCA1tBdccQA-00652-00126544-00126719": "anything that you've learned you know", "TCA1tBdccQA-00653-00126720-00126854": "working with the many companies that you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00654-00126855-00127039": "have that you'd like to share here", "TCA1tBdccQA-00655-00127040-00127254": "yeah yeah yeah i'd say the biggest thing", "TCA1tBdccQA-00656-00127255-00127463": "is is that change management right and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00657-00127464-00127607": "it's the complexity", "TCA1tBdccQA-00658-00127608-00127847": "right as soon as you start saying you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00659-00127848-00127975": "know we can do", "TCA1tBdccQA-00660-00127976-00128143": "we can measure anything and we can set", "TCA1tBdccQA-00661-00128144-00128343": "up any construct", "TCA1tBdccQA-00662-00128344-00128631": "right it get it gets people thinking but", "TCA1tBdccQA-00663-00128632-00128831": "but then it's okay but which one should", "TCA1tBdccQA-00664-00128832-00128943": "we choose", "TCA1tBdccQA-00665-00128944-00129223": "right and you know what what's the best", "TCA1tBdccQA-00666-00129224-00129310": "for us so", "TCA1tBdccQA-00667-00129311-00129639": "so getting over that uh that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00668-00129640-00129910": "change is the hardest thing right and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00669-00129911-00130031": "thinking about", "TCA1tBdccQA-00670-00130032-00130319": "you know how do the economics work you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00671-00130320-00130495": "know what is the best model for us what", "TCA1tBdccQA-00672-00130496-00130702": "do our customers value", "TCA1tBdccQA-00673-00130703-00130958": "and you know you you've got to recognize", "TCA1tBdccQA-00674-00130959-00131014": "that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00675-00131015-00131183": "yes you can do anything but you should", "TCA1tBdccQA-00676-00131184-00131359": "probably start with something simple and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00677-00131360-00131502": "then expand", "TCA1tBdccQA-00678-00131503-00131663": "so that you're not you know measuring", "TCA1tBdccQA-00679-00131664-00131847": "500 variables", "TCA1tBdccQA-00680-00131848-00132175": "you know at millisecond accuracy because", "TCA1tBdccQA-00681-00132176-00132366": "everything does play a role", "TCA1tBdccQA-00682-00132367-00132639": "it's boiling that down to its essence", "TCA1tBdccQA-00683-00132640-00132671": "and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00684-00132672-00132887": "and really focusing on you know what we", "TCA1tBdccQA-00685-00132888-00133078": "can do to help", "TCA1tBdccQA-00686-00133079-00133223": "um and and for everybody that's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00687-00133224-00133399": "different and that's why we start all of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00688-00133400-00133454": "our", "TCA1tBdccQA-00689-00133455-00133663": "we start all of our engagements really", "TCA1tBdccQA-00690-00133664-00133775": "with a consulting", "TCA1tBdccQA-00691-00133776-00133983": "kind of an upfront consulting program", "TCA1tBdccQA-00692-00133984-00134087": "right where we", "TCA1tBdccQA-00693-00134088-00134335": "we talk to you know the business leaders", "TCA1tBdccQA-00694-00134336-00134399": "first", "TCA1tBdccQA-00695-00134400-00134671": "uh ultimately we we get involved with", "TCA1tBdccQA-00696-00134672-00134735": "the people that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00697-00134736-00135007": "you know uh deploy technology on these", "TCA1tBdccQA-00698-00135008-00135135": "assets we also", "TCA1tBdccQA-00699-00135136-00135311": "we we get heavily involved with the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00700-00135312-00135471": "sales teams", "TCA1tBdccQA-00701-00135472-00135663": "right so what is the value to the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00702-00135664-00135871": "customer how do you sell it", "TCA1tBdccQA-00703-00135872-00136031": "and how does that change your sales", "TCA1tBdccQA-00704-00136032-00136271": "model right how does that change", "TCA1tBdccQA-00705-00136272-00136511": "sales compensation is a subject that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00706-00136512-00136702": "comes up frequently these are all things", "TCA1tBdccQA-00707-00136703-00136863": "that you know we've done this for long", "TCA1tBdccQA-00708-00136864-00137007": "enough now and work with enough", "TCA1tBdccQA-00709-00137008-00137111": "customers", "TCA1tBdccQA-00710-00137112-00137366": "that that we you know that's it the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00711-00137367-00137454": "questions and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00712-00137455-00137599": "the challenges are becoming fairly", "TCA1tBdccQA-00713-00137600-00137775": "predictable for us", "TCA1tBdccQA-00714-00137776-00137975": "uh and and you know every now and again", "TCA1tBdccQA-00715-00137976-00138151": "we see something new or a new twist", "TCA1tBdccQA-00716-00138152-00138327": "uh but but yeah we've been pretty", "TCA1tBdccQA-00717-00138328-00138495": "successful helping people make that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00718-00138496-00138614": "conversion and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00719-00138615-00138799": "thinking about the financial uh", "TCA1tBdccQA-00720-00138800-00138959": "economics of it that's one of the big", "TCA1tBdccQA-00721-00138960-00139071": "headwinds is", "TCA1tBdccQA-00722-00139072-00139463": "hey mike uh hard to get my head around", "TCA1tBdccQA-00723-00139464-00139719": "i have to i used to get a down payment", "TCA1tBdccQA-00724-00139720-00139895": "to cover my cost", "TCA1tBdccQA-00725-00139896-00140031": "right so that i could build the machine", "TCA1tBdccQA-00726-00140032-00140183": "so i could deliver it so i could get my", "TCA1tBdccQA-00727-00140184-00140335": "margin on the back end", "TCA1tBdccQA-00728-00140336-00140519": "as soon as i you know sign off on the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00729-00140520-00140743": "machine install their facility", "TCA1tBdccQA-00730-00140744-00140999": "how do i do that if i'm extending that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00731-00141000-00141183": "time period out over the life cycle of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00732-00141184-00141319": "the asset", "TCA1tBdccQA-00733-00141320-00141623": "right and and that's probably", "TCA1tBdccQA-00734-00141624-00141943": "uh the the area of biggest concern", "TCA1tBdccQA-00735-00141944-00142231": "we do have uh we we do have financing", "TCA1tBdccQA-00736-00142232-00142390": "partners that work with us", "TCA1tBdccQA-00737-00142391-00142566": "that help put together vendor-based", "TCA1tBdccQA-00738-00142567-00142702": "financing programs", "TCA1tBdccQA-00739-00142703-00142966": "specifically for machine as a service uh", "TCA1tBdccQA-00740-00142967-00143151": "and so that's one way we we can solve it", "TCA1tBdccQA-00741-00143152-00143254": "the other way is", "TCA1tBdccQA-00742-00143255-00143423": "just to get people to understand that it", "TCA1tBdccQA-00743-00143424-00143687": "doesn't necessarily imply that you don't", "TCA1tBdccQA-00744-00143688-00143799": "get paid", "TCA1tBdccQA-00745-00143800-00144047": "uh some of that money up front right one", "TCA1tBdccQA-00746-00144048-00144319": "one way to think of that is", "TCA1tBdccQA-00747-00144320-00144495": "maybe it's your margin dollars that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00748-00144496-00144623": "instead of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00749-00144624-00144871": "uh you know a two-week uh site", "TCA1tBdccQA-00750-00144872-00144966": "acceptance", "TCA1tBdccQA-00751-00144967-00145254": "you're extending out over months if not", "TCA1tBdccQA-00752-00145255-00145351": "years", "TCA1tBdccQA-00753-00145352-00145702": "right but the the payment is", "TCA1tBdccQA-00754-00145703-00145919": "you know multiples of what it used to be", "TCA1tBdccQA-00755-00145920-00146102": "because it's inclusive of service it's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00756-00146103-00146319": "inclusive of break fix", "TCA1tBdccQA-00757-00146320-00146607": "uh it in some cases it's inclusive of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00758-00146608-00146790": "consumables", "TCA1tBdccQA-00759-00146791-00147039": "right where you're you're creating new", "TCA1tBdccQA-00760-00147040-00147207": "revenue opportunities", "TCA1tBdccQA-00761-00147208-00147351": "right because you you're again you're", "TCA1tBdccQA-00762-00147352-00147543": "not just selling the machine", "TCA1tBdccQA-00763-00147544-00147847": "you're delivering the solutions that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00764-00147848-00147951": "they need", "TCA1tBdccQA-00765-00147952-00148271": "over the life cycle of the assets so the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00766-00148272-00148511": "higher revenue opportunities over time", "TCA1tBdccQA-00767-00148512-00148647": "and how you bundle that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00768-00148648-00148878": "really play a big role in how to get", "TCA1tBdccQA-00769-00148879-00149007": "these things off the ground and that's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00770-00149008-00149087": "what we help with", "TCA1tBdccQA-00771-00149088-00149302": "no doubt man that sounds awesome i i", "TCA1tBdccQA-00772-00149303-00149423": "just love", "TCA1tBdccQA-00773-00149424-00149590": "first of all your passion behind this i", "TCA1tBdccQA-00774-00149591-00149743": "mean definitely", "TCA1tBdccQA-00775-00149744-00149999": "i'm sure you've helped so many people", "TCA1tBdccQA-00776-00150000-00150166": "learn this and get through those those", "TCA1tBdccQA-00777-00150167-00150311": "hurdles because those headwinds you just", "TCA1tBdccQA-00778-00150312-00150447": "you just went through a reel", "TCA1tBdccQA-00779-00150448-00150623": "and i can only imagine that culture and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00780-00150624-00150759": "just trying to work through some", "TCA1tBdccQA-00781-00150760-00150895": "management and then get in alignment", "TCA1tBdccQA-00782-00150896-00151054": "with all those teams on what's important", "TCA1tBdccQA-00783-00151055-00151214": "what we want to measure man that's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00784-00151215-00151575": "it's got to be tough it's uh yeah uh", "TCA1tBdccQA-00785-00151576-00151863": "it's a it's a complex uh business to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00786-00151864-00151919": "lead", "TCA1tBdccQA-00787-00151920-00152175": "uh you know there's no road map right", "TCA1tBdccQA-00788-00152176-00152263": "this is", "TCA1tBdccQA-00789-00152264-00152566": "very novel in our industry um but", "TCA1tBdccQA-00790-00152567-00152887": "you know it it's it's not a new idea", "TCA1tBdccQA-00791-00152888-00153175": "uh it it certainly has impacted other", "TCA1tBdccQA-00792-00153176-00153254": "industries", "TCA1tBdccQA-00793-00153255-00153583": "very dramatically uh in recent memory", "TCA1tBdccQA-00794-00153584-00153790": "right whether that's it hardware or the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00795-00153791-00153975": "jet engine business or you know going", "TCA1tBdccQA-00796-00153976-00154214": "back a little ways office printers right", "TCA1tBdccQA-00797-00154215-00154271": "there's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00798-00154272-00154535": "there are there's a there's a a long", "TCA1tBdccQA-00799-00154536-00154663": "track record", "TCA1tBdccQA-00800-00154664-00154902": "of these being very successful business", "TCA1tBdccQA-00801-00154903-00154983": "models", "TCA1tBdccQA-00802-00154984-00155223": "uh it's it's more complex in", "TCA1tBdccQA-00803-00155224-00155390": "manufacturing which is why it's probably", "TCA1tBdccQA-00804-00155391-00155623": "showed up here later than others", "TCA1tBdccQA-00805-00155624-00155766": "because the environment is so much more", "TCA1tBdccQA-00806-00155767-00155951": "complex the diversity", "TCA1tBdccQA-00807-00155952-00156175": "of machinery types and styles and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00808-00156176-00156287": "suppliers", "TCA1tBdccQA-00809-00156288-00156535": "is so much more complex than jet engines", "TCA1tBdccQA-00810-00156536-00156711": "or office printers", "TCA1tBdccQA-00811-00156712-00156911": "or i.t hardware for that matter it", "TCA1tBdccQA-00812-00156912-00157087": "requires a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00813-00157088-00157271": "significant amount of automation well it", "TCA1tBdccQA-00814-00157272-00157414": "turns out that's what we're good at in", "TCA1tBdccQA-00815-00157415-00157526": "this industry right", "TCA1tBdccQA-00816-00157527-00157775": "right and and so we're really extending", "TCA1tBdccQA-00817-00157776-00157871": "the automation", "TCA1tBdccQA-00818-00157872-00158175": "from the machine itself into the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00819-00158176-00158359": "business model and how those machines", "TCA1tBdccQA-00820-00158360-00158487": "are managed", "TCA1tBdccQA-00821-00158488-00158726": "in order to solve for that complexity", "TCA1tBdccQA-00822-00158727-00158919": "and be able to deploy this at scale", "TCA1tBdccQA-00823-00158920-00159066": "but understand that it's not a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00824-00159067-00159239": "one-size-fits-all solution not", "TCA1tBdccQA-00825-00159240-00159447": "every machine is the same even if it", "TCA1tBdccQA-00826-00159448-00159623": "even if it's the same industry even if", "TCA1tBdccQA-00827-00159624-00159711": "it's the same", "TCA1tBdccQA-00828-00159712-00159999": "style of machine for every end user", "TCA1tBdccQA-00829-00160000-00160175": "there might be a different contract and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00830-00160176-00160311": "there needs to be a way to manage that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00831-00160312-00160471": "complexity and that's what steam chain", "TCA1tBdccQA-00832-00160472-00160535": "provides", "TCA1tBdccQA-00833-00160536-00160751": "that is awesome that's awesome i might", "TCA1tBdccQA-00834-00160752-00160887": "so if you're talking to someone right", "TCA1tBdccQA-00835-00160888-00161031": "now and you're trying to give them the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00836-00161032-00161095": "why", "TCA1tBdccQA-00837-00161096-00161254": "you know why do you feel this machine as", "TCA1tBdccQA-00838-00161255-00161423": "a service could be that game changer", "TCA1tBdccQA-00839-00161424-00161478": "concept", "TCA1tBdccQA-00840-00161479-00161590": "as you look in the future for", "TCA1tBdccQA-00841-00161591-00161831": "manufacturing yeah i'm pretty passionate", "TCA1tBdccQA-00842-00161832-00161975": "about this chris because i actually", "TCA1tBdccQA-00843-00161976-00162166": "believe this is how we accelerate the", "TCA1tBdccQA-00844-00162167-00162335": "adoption of advanced manufacturing", "TCA1tBdccQA-00845-00162336-00162623": "technology across the entire industry", "TCA1tBdccQA-00846-00162624-00162783": "and and i think it's critically", "TCA1tBdccQA-00847-00162784-00162935": "important right now", "TCA1tBdccQA-00848-00162936-00163271": "uh that we begin to think about you know", "TCA1tBdccQA-00849-00163272-00163511": "not just hey we need to automate but how", "TCA1tBdccQA-00850-00163512-00163607": "do we", "TCA1tBdccQA-00851-00163608-00163854": "make sure that investments in automation", "TCA1tBdccQA-00852-00163855-00164063": "are getting the payback they need", "TCA1tBdccQA-00853-00164064-00164366": "uh that their provable outcomes", "TCA1tBdccQA-00854-00164367-00164559": "and not just selling another machine and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00855-00164560-00164719": "asking the customer to take the risk on", "TCA1tBdccQA-00856-00164720-00164911": "advanced automation technology this is", "TCA1tBdccQA-00857-00164912-00165166": "good for suppliers of automation", "TCA1tBdccQA-00858-00165167-00165278": "technology", "TCA1tBdccQA-00859-00165279-00165463": "right it's probably the best thing for", "TCA1tBdccQA-00860-00165464-00165599": "them uh", "TCA1tBdccQA-00861-00165600-00165814": "because you're you're you're beginning", "TCA1tBdccQA-00862-00165815-00165975": "to put your money where your mouth", "TCA1tBdccQA-00863-00165976-00166199": "is and saying we're we're selling you a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00864-00166200-00166319": "result", "TCA1tBdccQA-00865-00166320-00166526": "and everybody needs these results i", "TCA1tBdccQA-00866-00166527-00166654": "don't think it's any", "TCA1tBdccQA-00867-00166655-00166871": "uh surprise to anybody that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00868-00166872-00167007": "manufacturing has been", "TCA1tBdccQA-00869-00167008-00167326": "a sector of the us economy that's seen", "TCA1tBdccQA-00870-00167327-00167599": "dramatic under investment over the last", "TCA1tBdccQA-00871-00167600-00167838": "20 to 30 years", "TCA1tBdccQA-00872-00167839-00168223": "and the the answer to that isn't uh", "TCA1tBdccQA-00873-00168224-00168399": "you know isn't everybody needs to start", "TCA1tBdccQA-00874-00168400-00168566": "you know throwing down big piles of cash", "TCA1tBdccQA-00875-00168567-00168759": "and putting new machines out there", "TCA1tBdccQA-00876-00168760-00169054": "right it's that that's the old model if", "TCA1tBdccQA-00877-00169055-00169095": "you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00878-00169096-00169311": "want people to take risks on advanced", "TCA1tBdccQA-00879-00169312-00169478": "manufacturing technology", "TCA1tBdccQA-00880-00169479-00169631": "you need to offer them a value", "TCA1tBdccQA-00881-00169632-00169823": "proposition where they feel like you've", "TCA1tBdccQA-00882-00169824-00169959": "got skin in the game", "TCA1tBdccQA-00883-00169960-00170087": "that they've got a partner that's going", "TCA1tBdccQA-00884-00170088-00170302": "to stand by it that it's a long-term", "TCA1tBdccQA-00885-00170303-00170414": "relationship where", "TCA1tBdccQA-00886-00170415-00170743": "everybody is invested and and you need a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00887-00170744-00170887": "business model that supports that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00888-00170888-00171047": "concept and we believe machine as a", "TCA1tBdccQA-00889-00171048-00171247": "service is that business model and can", "TCA1tBdccQA-00890-00171248-00171551": "manage the complexity of these things", "TCA1tBdccQA-00891-00171552-00171878": "in a way that that helps make it easier", "TCA1tBdccQA-00892-00171879-00171999": "and more efficient", "TCA1tBdccQA-00893-00172000-00172159": "to take those risks on advanced", "TCA1tBdccQA-00894-00172160-00172319": "automation technology in a way that it's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00895-00172320-00172399": "supported", "TCA1tBdccQA-00896-00172400-00172583": "and you're not just solving the problem", "TCA1tBdccQA-00897-00172584-00172751": "of how to sell more machines", "TCA1tBdccQA-00898-00172752-00172887": "you're solving the problem of how to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00899-00172888-00173126": "produce more results for your customers", "TCA1tBdccQA-00900-00173127-00173375": "that's it mike this has been great now", "TCA1tBdccQA-00901-00173376-00173551": "for people that want to connect with you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00902-00173552-00173671": "and understand more", "TCA1tBdccQA-00903-00173672-00173871": "or learn more about stain chain what's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00904-00173872-00174023": "the best way for them to do that", "TCA1tBdccQA-00905-00174024-00174335": "you can find us at steam chain dot io on", "TCA1tBdccQA-00906-00174336-00174390": "the web", "TCA1tBdccQA-00907-00174391-00174687": "of course uh we're very active on", "TCA1tBdccQA-00908-00174688-00174775": "linkedin so", "TCA1tBdccQA-00909-00174776-00174951": "you know anybody out there that's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00910-00174952-00175126": "listening feel free to", "TCA1tBdccQA-00911-00175127-00175399": "to send me a linkedin invitation uh you", "TCA1tBdccQA-00912-00175400-00175559": "can always find me there and hit me up", "TCA1tBdccQA-00913-00175560-00175687": "there and uh", "TCA1tBdccQA-00914-00175688-00175887": "my telephone number and our corporate", "TCA1tBdccQA-00915-00175888-00176007": "numbers are all on", "TCA1tBdccQA-00916-00176008-00176151": "on the website as well if you're not", "TCA1tBdccQA-00917-00176152-00176278": "seeing us out there you're not looking", "TCA1tBdccQA-00918-00176279-00176423": "very hard we're very easy to get a hold", "TCA1tBdccQA-00919-00176424-00176487": "of", "TCA1tBdccQA-00920-00176488-00176631": "absolutely and we'll put in the show", "TCA1tBdccQA-00921-00176632-00176847": "notes for our listeners uh direct link", "TCA1tBdccQA-00922-00176848-00177063": "to steam chain to mike as well", "TCA1tBdccQA-00923-00177064-00177295": "uh and other resources that he mentioned", "TCA1tBdccQA-00924-00177296-00177390": "that we can", "TCA1tBdccQA-00925-00177391-00177599": "find helpful and just make sure it's", "TCA1tBdccQA-00926-00177600-00177759": "super easy for you listeners to get in", "TCA1tBdccQA-00927-00177760-00177943": "touch with mike's man this has been", "TCA1tBdccQA-00928-00177944-00178111": "it's been great i've learned a lot about", "TCA1tBdccQA-00929-00178112-00178287": "machine as a service i love what you're", "TCA1tBdccQA-00930-00178288-00178366": "doing and", "TCA1tBdccQA-00931-00178367-00178583": "you know wish the best to steam chain in", "TCA1tBdccQA-00932-00178584-00178735": "the future sir", "TCA1tBdccQA-00933-00178736-00178871": "thank you chris appreciate it thanks for", "TCA1tBdccQA-00934-00178872-00179223": "having me on your show", "TCA1tBdccQA-00935-00179224-00179511": "thank you for listening to ecosy this", "TCA1tBdccQA-00936-00179512-00179678": "show is supported ad free", "TCA1tBdccQA-00937-00179679-00179926": "by electrical equipment company eco is", "TCA1tBdccQA-00938-00179927-00180111": "redefining the expectations of an", "TCA1tBdccQA-00939-00180112-00180238": "electrical distributor", "TCA1tBdccQA-00940-00180239-00180454": "by placing people and ideas before", "TCA1tBdccQA-00941-00180455-00180566": "products", "TCA1tBdccQA-00942-00180567-00180726": "please subscribe and share with your", "TCA1tBdccQA-00943-00180727-00180878": "colleagues and friends", "TCA1tBdccQA-00944-00180879-00181151": "also leave comments feedback and any new", "TCA1tBdccQA-00945-00181152-00181335": "topics that you would like to hear", "TCA1tBdccQA-00946-00181336-00181566": "to learn more or to share your insights", "TCA1tBdccQA-00947-00181567-00181799": "visit ecosy.com", "TCA1tBdccQA-00948-00181800-00182326": "that's e-e-c-o a-s-k-s", "TCA1tBdccQA-00949-00182327-00183264": "dot com"}}, {"audio_id": "TDVQCMq9LHk", "text": {"TDVQCMq9LHk-00000-00000031-00000620": "okay or do I start i'm making this video", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00001-00000621-00001052": "to try to maybe clarify to you why I", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00002-00001053-00001387": "think our fundamental misunderstandings", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00003-00001388-00001700": "on your part of what Eckhart Tolle tries", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00004-00001701-00002099": "to explain in these teachings you start", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00005-00002100-00002526": "by criticizing him because the only", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00006-00002527-00003037": "teaches liberation from suffering but", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00007-00003038-00003415": "like that's not enough you know you have", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00008-00003417-00003785": "to have something more well I really", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00009-00003786-00004161": "this the problem is you make the jump", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00010-00004162-00004513": "before you're ready to try to live with", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00011-00004514-00004795": "other beings from something while you're", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00012-00004796-00005206": "not liver and yet you think weight on", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00013-00005207-00005366": "your shoulders then you shouldn't have", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00014-00005367-00005681": "to deal with yet there is this quote", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00015-00005682-00006031": "which I really love and it states that", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00016-00006032-00006416": "you have no responsibility to save the", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00017-00006417-00006820": "world the only other responsibility to", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00018-00006822-00007345": "yourself and to keep clean this little", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00019-00007347-00007699": "corner of the universal news and doing", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00020-00007700-00008162": "this the universe healed so", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00021-00008163-00008760": "so why peel is a problem dinner in that", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00022-00008761-00009138": "you haven't actually tried to integrate", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00023-00009139-00009449": "the court all these teachings into your", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00024-00009450-00009841": "lifestyle you don't really you don't you", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00025-00009842-00010094": "haven't lived with them you doing", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00026-00010095-00010585": "understand them quite well with us and a", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00027-00010586-00010955": "few you know a few exceptions that your", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00028-00010956-00011209": "ego doesn't want you to understand but", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00029-00011210-00011483": "it's only intellectual you have not", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00030-00011484-00011663": "actually child to see what it's talking", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00031-00011664-00012192": "about because you say that it's only", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00032-00012193-00012476": "self-interested enlightened it okay in", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00033-00012477-00012721": "that case let's say that Eckhart Tolle", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00034-00012722-00013021": "is actually a self enlightened but in a", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00035-00013022-00013408": "self-interested way master why the [__]", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00036-00013409-00013630": "would you actually be spending his time", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00037-00013631-00013916": "you know trying to help other people", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00038-00013916-00014093": "become free from them from their", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00039-00014094-00014360": "suffering you know the guy is blissful", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00040-00014361-00014627": "okay so it's gonna just you know kick it", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00041-00014628-00014918": "back in a resort in a luxury resort", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00042-00014919-00015130": "somewhere and you know drink a couple", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00043-00015131-00015466": "drinks you know and enjoy life the guy", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00044-00015468-00015688": "is liberated from suffering why should", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00045-00015690-00016202": "he care because enlightenment is not", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00046-00016203-00016658": "what you think it is enlightenment you", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00047-00016659-00016978": "know liberation from self-created", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00048-00016979-00017327": "sockarang of your own mind in front of", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00049-00017328-00017839": "from the conceptual violence that you", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00050-00017840-00018369": "invoke upon existence for your judgment", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00051-00018370-00018594": "it's pure bliss", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00052-00018595-00019125": "okay from nearly reaching orgasm just by", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00053-00019126-00019472": "a cheese seeing you know the flight of a", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00054-00019473-00019936": "bird or hearing the sound of rain but", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00055-00019937-00020430": "it's also pure suffering because you", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00056-00020431-00020958": "have this deep fundamental empathy that", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00057-00020959-00021287": "reaches into the car core of your heart", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00058-00021288-00021611": "when you see other being some suffering", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00059-00021612-00021944": "and you feel for them and the only one", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00060-00021945-00022283": "to liberate them which is actually the", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00061-00022284-00022700": "essence of Bodhisattva it's when an", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00062-00022701-00023033": "enlightened Buddha decides to stay of", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00063-00023034-00023510": "this world that is to keep aware", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00064-00023511-00023831": "constantly faced suffering because it", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00065-00023832-00024181": "wants to liberate other beings from it", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00066-00024182-00024882": "how is that self-interested", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00067-00024883-00025195": "doesn't work you know but your ego", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00068-00025196-00025531": "doesn't want to do this okay it's not", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00069-00025532-00025806": "you're not ready to start caring about", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00070-00025807-00026094": "other people yet because you don't even", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00071-00026095-00026439": "understand you don't know yourself yeah", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00072-00026439-00026830": "but the ego is afraid of being revealed", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00073-00026831-00027211": "for the cansada that it is so instead of", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00074-00027212-00027483": "actually making the jump and trying to", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00075-00027485-00027852": "live this truth legal says this is not", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00076-00027854-00028132": "the way to be I have my solution and", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00077-00028133-00028423": "it's dis solution eckart tolle should be", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00078-00028424-00028695": "like this because this is what I think", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00079-00028697-00028999": "well this is identification with thought", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00080-00029000-00029233": "the only reason you really oppose", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00081-00029233-00029533": "Eckhart Tolle it seems and because you", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00082-00029533-00029776": "have your own idea of what solution is", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00083-00029777-00030169": "right what solution is right your system", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00084-00030170-00030489": "equal money okay I haven't studied it", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00085-00030491-00030751": "okay I mean the song it sounds great", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00086-00030752-00031126": "just from name you know but thing is", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00087-00031127-00031462": "you're trying to solve suffering through", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00088-00031463-00031789": "a system what you haven't seen is that", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00089-00031789-00032047": "all suffering that exists right now is", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00090-00032048-00032254": "because of the system actually you stay", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00091-00032255-00032536": "put in the video but you you state that", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00092-00032537-00032764": "trend suffering comes from you know the", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00093-00032764-00033076": "in the industrial economical system that", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00094-00033077-00033601": "we live in um I nearly agreed you've", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00095-00033602-00033886": "just not made the next jump what creates", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00096-00033887-00034459": "the system the system actually arises", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00097-00034460-00034944": "out of ego out of the wish to control", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00098-00034945-00035396": "out of the wish to judge to be right", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00099-00035397-00035770": "because of identification with thought", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00100-00035771-00036088": "you say well I am the solution it's the", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00101-00036089-00036445": "list system okay your system might be", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00102-00036446-00036751": "awesome and everything but that's just", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00103-00036752-00037165": "entertaining this idea what I don't want", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00104-00037166-00037429": "the mere system what are you going to do", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00105-00037430-00037630": "imposing on me", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00106-00037631-00038160": "I'm pretty hair right so the solution is", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00107-00038161-00038591": "to go beyond systems you know I would be", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00108-00038592-00039097": "actually I will not be insulted but I", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00109-00039098-00039425": "would think it's funny you know that you", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00110-00039426-00039743": "believe I shows actually act according", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00111-00039744-00040079": "to your system for me to be right you", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00112-00040080-00040481": "know what if I believe that love doesn't", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00113-00040482-00040817": "need a system that just by being loving", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00114-00040818-00041219": "the universe heals itself why should I", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00115-00041220-00041552": "subscribe to your ideas why should I", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00116-00041553-00041747": "subscribe to the view that you believe", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00117-00041748-00042179": "is true such as this equal money system", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00118-00042180-00042731": "I don't need this to be loving and to be", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00119-00042732-00042965": "sharing and to be caring about other", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00120-00042966-00043343": "people you know the proof being I didn't", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00121-00043344-00043490": "need to make this video I could just", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00122-00043491-00043895": "sell my ass and you know do whatever the", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00123-00043896-00044387": "[__] I want and be blissful but what", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00124-00044388-00044606": "listening to you actually I could", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00125-00044607-00044783": "actually could feel how close you were", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00126-00044784-00045032": "to understanding this point but just", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00127-00045033-00045245": "being stuff you know always saying oh I", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00128-00045246-00045458": "agree with him with him with him but", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00129-00045459-00045710": "he'll be helping poor kids in the street", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00130-00045711-00046115": "first well look at it this way he's", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00131-00046116-00046388": "spreading enlightenment he's friday is", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00132-00046389-00046778": "spreading an existence style that is", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00133-00046779-00047060": "beyond ego and once you have this you", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00134-00047061-00047390": "start helping other people and your", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00135-00047391-00047648": "awareness which develops by itself", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00136-00047649-00047927": "actually keeps you from doing all all of", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00137-00047928-00048266": "this guy's [__] out of this violence", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00138-00048267-00048581": "that you and just even imposing a system", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00139-00048582-00048817": "on other people is violence by the way", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00140-00048818-00049118": "so once you're in consciousness he", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00141-00049119-00049310": "stopped doing this and then you stopped", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00142-00049311-00049532": "not only creating suffering for yourself", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00143-00049533-00049710": "but you stop creating suffering for", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00144-00049711-00049881": "others", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00145-00049882-00050265": "and this is when the utility you to help", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00146-00050266-00050649": "your starts not by some abstract system", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00147-00050650-00051084": "that people have to subscribe to okay so", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00148-00051085-00051554": "I just want to really recommend you", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00149-00051555-00051933": "actually integrate this truth in your", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00150-00051934-00052338": "life and actually try to live it and you", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00151-00052339-00052914": "will see how deep it regions and you", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00152-00052915-00053129": "will actually feel the truth of your", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00153-00053130-00053504": "deeper being and you will also", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00154-00053505-00053816": "understand how spontaneously you want to", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00155-00053817-00054155": "have other people the solution is not", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00156-00054157-00054516": "judging and saying a cartoony your", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00157-00054516-00054704": "philosophy is wrong you need to be doing", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00158-00054705-00055103": "this the guy is helping how we can okay", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00159-00055104-00055497": "so just follow your own path let him", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00160-00055498-00056075": "follow his and the universe fields", "TDVQCMq9LHk-00161-00056076-00056376": "itself"}}, {"audio_id": "TDYGNjM31wU", "text": {"TDYGNjM31wU-00000-00000000-00000784": "okay", "TDYGNjM31wU-00001-00000785-00001769": "[Music]", "TDYGNjM31wU-00002-00001770-00002751": "[Music]", "TDYGNjM31wU-00003-00002752-00003055": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "TEkv3_zmVaY", "text": {"TEkv3_zmVaY-00000-00000078-00000234": "times", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00001-00000235-00003606": "[Music]", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00002-00003607-00003803": "thank you", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00003-00003804-00003915": "foreign", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00004-00003917-00007753": "[Music]", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00005-00007754-00008360": "strong house", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00006-00008361-00010396": "[Music]", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00007-00010397-00010594": "thank you", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00008-00010595-00012301": "[Music]", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00009-00012302-00012575": "thank you", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00010-00012576-00013157": "[Music]", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00011-00013158-00013411": "sweetie", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00012-00013412-00014416": "[Music]", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00013-00014418-00014569": "foreign", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00014-00014569-00017422": "[Music]", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00015-00017423-00017482": "foreign", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00016-00017483-00021258": "[Music]", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00017-00021259-00021562": "thank you", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00018-00021563-00025027": "[Music]", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00019-00025028-00025334": "thank you", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00020-00025335-00026789": "[Music]", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00021-00026789-00026962": "foreign", "TEkv3_zmVaY-00022-00026963-00027660": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "TEOKUGwM0Pg", "text": {"TEOKUGwM0Pg-00000-00000074-00000364": "messenger the hey there one Sarah Goblin", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00001-00000365-00000641": "yeah the messenger and will how will it", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00002-00000642-00000761": "announce yeah we're just saying that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00003-00000762-00001043": "we're at vuten Shore so yeah last time", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00004-00001044-00001283": "we started DLC and sandwiched between", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00005-00001284-00001541": "like fairly long cutscenes we played", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00006-00001542-00001776": "some battle toad", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00007-00001777-00002207": "as you do and uh do they hurt me they do", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00008-00002208-00002423": "not hurt me oh all right well sorry", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00009-00002424-00002650": "about all that surround this place the", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00010-00002651-00002975": "fancy place oh this looks really cool on", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00011-00002976-00003293": "the Genesis oh look at that frog it's a", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00012-00003294-00003604": "frog now plants are here", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00013-00003605-00004013": "good need more plants all right so I had", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00014-00004014-00004222": "something in mind that I wanted to say", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00015-00004223-00004499": "that didn't really work out", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00016-00004500-00004691": "I forgot you know what okay well here", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00017-00004692-00004865": "I'm gonna have the time change oh and", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00018-00004866-00005009": "actually well okay you can fall through", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00019-00005010-00005309": "the sky at any point here some things", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00020-00005310-00005602": "going to happen if you die and there's", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00021-00005603-00005933": "the local iguana man oh dude it takes a", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00022-00005934-00006175": "lot of slices just will not die", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00023-00006176-00006563": "shoot all right well now look at that it", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00024-00006564-00006814": "stopped raining and it's feeling fine", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00025-00006815-00007120": "all right there's totally something here", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00026-00007122-00007441": "it's called money at the end of a cliff", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00027-00007442-00007951": "yeah accurate gotta love our clip money", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00028-00007952-00008333": "I guess hey everybody here we go", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00029-00008334-00008545": "plan is there you've got to be careful", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00030-00008546-00008885": "okay so yeah so I barely played the game", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00031-00008886-00009137": "yesterday it wasn't very oh wow okay so", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00032-00009138-00009299": "it's just like the weird", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00033-00009300-00009581": "plant life barrier that you just kind of", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00034-00009582-00009785": "cut okay gotta cut all the orbs uh", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00035-00009786-00010055": "that's how you get a hole going all", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00036-00010056-00010277": "right that makes a lot of sense", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00037-00010278-00010577": "all right iguana man is doing his best", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00038-00010578-00010937": "iguana impression it's very impressive", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00039-00010938-00011159": "and then you can just kind of dance like", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00040-00011160-00011242": "this", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00041-00011243-00011471": "all right so here there's clearly", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00042-00011472-00011651": "something up there but I need to change", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00043-00011652-00012013": "time will I have a chance to change time", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00044-00012014-00012346": "will I have a chance to change limes I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00045-00012347-00012460": "don't know if you have to change your", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00046-00012461-00012670": "lines very often yeah I can't like I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00047-00012671-00012838": "don't need to attack you like you are", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00048-00012839-00013144": "just a thing that exists there chilling", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00049-00013145-00013558": "dancing having fun relaxing chillaxing", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00050-00013559-00013853": "eating gum I hope not it's kind of bad", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00051-00013854-00014015": "all right well I don't know what's", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00052-00014016-00014213": "happening here but we're changing time", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00053-00014213-00014507": "completely got a big chunk of platform", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00054-00014508-00014753": "that guys throwing projectiles all", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00055-00014754-00015065": "around right we're here all the plants", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00056-00015066-00015316": "grew back and so did a big Crystal thing", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00057-00015318-00015611": "just appeared how about that yeah that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00058-00015612-00015761": "is pretty weird oh yeah the plant", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00059-00015762-00016049": "platform pattern seems different too", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00060-00016050-00016547": "that's fun to be sliced in the face if", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00061-00016548-00016900": "you don't mind to share with me the the", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00062-00016901-00017117": "face slashing I guess this is what I'm", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00063-00017118-00017339": "implying I don't know what I'm saying", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00064-00017340-00017543": "all right I'm gonna go here it's like a", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00065-00017544-00017783": "little maze it's made out of wood and", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00066-00017784-00018065": "it's not glazed yeah this is not a", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00067-00018066-00018343": "glazed donut in spite of all appearances", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00068-00018344-00018671": "has very little to do with desserts or", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00069-00018672-00019007": "pastries in general really would you eat", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00070-00019008-00019367": "a rainy pastry maybe I don't know that's", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00071-00019368-00019607": "a weird question I was not ready to", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00072-00019608-00019775": "answer this I'm sorry oh I'm gonna be", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00073-00019776-00019972": "looking at the map a lot because there's", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00074-00019973-00020230": "important things to find oh geez your", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00075-00020231-00020494": "Hammer's like shattered yeah you are", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00076-00020495-00020977": "like deluxe enemies", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00077-00020978-00021425": "do you have a song for me iguana man and", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00078-00021426-00021671": "is it just repeating the words iguana", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00079-00021672-00022030": "ma'am I'm no not judging it wouldn't", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00080-00022031-00022291": "really be any better", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00081-00022292-00022721": "oh you look so sad I can fly across the", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00082-00022722-00023089": "world like I'm a Ziploc bag the most", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00083-00023090-00023428": "high-flying of all things", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00084-00023429-00023735": "we're at a cutscene there's a knot", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00085-00023736-00024053": "probably at least to something what up", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00086-00024054-00024341": "all right grape oh look at that bird", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00087-00024342-00024544": "they're so much prettier when they're", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00088-00024545-00024989": "not a skeleton weird right so oh okay I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00089-00024990-00025506": "kind of see what is go when not me", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00090-00025507-00025750": "there we go I'm gonna repeat that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00091-00025751-00026027": "probably hanging skulls", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00092-00026027-00026608": "uh I'm not sure how this is going to go", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00093-00026610-00026957": "so I think that being able to attack", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00094-00026958-00027455": "projectile is a is an upgrade right", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00095-00027456-00027635": "shoe like it's not something you can", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00096-00027636-00027935": "just do naturally all right what if I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00097-00027936-00028324": "did that no hmm how do you go further up", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00098-00028325-00028439": "here", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00099-00028439-00028829": "I mean here I made it okay what if oh", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00100-00028830-00029177": "well oh shoot if I was not in glide mode", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00101-00029177-00029524": "think I would have been okay", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00102-00029525-00029740": "oh man okay", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00103-00029741-00030131": "um", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00104-00030132-00030367": "here we go thank you for your help", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00105-00030368-00030695": "little blue frogs", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00106-00030695-00031073": "very happy to have your assistance all", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00107-00031074-00031289": "right this one seems a bit more basic", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00108-00031289-00031495": "it's physically", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00109-00031495-00031877": "there you go and check it out it's peas", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00110-00031877-00032099": "in a pod no it's a piece of a mask all", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00111-00032100-00032302": "right this guy is just kind of crushing", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00112-00032303-00032590": "me with his rocks but it's fine I'm", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00113-00032591-00032818": "invisible", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00114-00032819-00033011": "it's just me was their little smile and", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00115-00033012-00033202": "that purple blast maybe it was just an", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00116-00033203-00033527": "illusion human brains are fantastic at", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00117-00033528-00033857": "finding faces if anything do you like", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00118-00033858-00034096": "did you update the content of your", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00119-00034097-00034379": "speech yeah I didn't think so but for", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00120-00034380-00034655": "some reason I felt important to me it's", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00121-00034656-00035033": "Jeff and so I did I did it open here I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00122-00035034-00035411": "can't all right open no what is your", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00123-00035412-00035615": "story Little mask length so you do that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00124-00035616-00035777": "and that opens up The Path here then you", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00125-00035778-00035987": "get here and it's like check it out I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00126-00035988-00036359": "got an elevator that's beautiful oh", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00127-00036360-00036671": "that's a smart all right there's a", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00128-00036672-00037049": "portal Over Yonder here through passage", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00129-00037050-00037235": "somewhere", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00130-00037236-00037577": "all right yeah this just goes down and", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00131-00037578-00037979": "now I am up hey there buddy with your", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00132-00037980-00038309": "wavy Project Style it's pretty scary I'm", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00133-00038310-00038543": "going to do a thing then the world is", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00134-00038544-00038890": "going to change all around me whoosh", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00135-00038891-00039227": "lose all the details we don't need that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00136-00039228-00039455": "now it's not clear where also the", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00137-00039456-00039767": "elevator's gone all right there it is", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00138-00039768-00039952": "I'm gonna hit all these things and drink", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00139-00039953-00040174": "all this juice that's right", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00140-00040175-00040396": "hit this thing and then you end up", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00141-00040397-00040559": "somewhere okay I see what's going on", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00142-00040560-00040657": "here", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00143-00040658-00041045": "so we're gonna use", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00144-00041046-00041261": "okay I can just go up here probably you", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00145-00041262-00041399": "know what you need to be dead though", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00146-00041400-00041633": "you're gonna be in the way while I try", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00147-00041634-00041945": "to formulate plans yeah I don't need the", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00148-00041946-00042221": "elevator at all this is a lot clearer", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00149-00042222-00042521": "and a lot faster than whatever might", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00150-00042522-00042880": "have been planned for the New Horizon", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00151-00042881-00043229": "all right cool here's all the lanterns", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00152-00043230-00043493": "that we set out for you to be", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00153-00043494-00043795": "appreciated at a later time and space", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00154-00043796-00044165": "that's right lizard cut oh these", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00155-00044166-00044443": "objectives floating there that's weird", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00156-00044444-00044879": "well these guys are having fun have fun", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00157-00044880-00045071": "without me all right I can just jump", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00158-00045072-00045395": "down perfect I'm assuming that I don't", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00159-00045396-00045724": "want to be in that sand because I don't", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00160-00045725-00045901": "know why", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00161-00045902-00046223": "there we go I say shoot but like I did", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00162-00046224-00046349": "it yeah", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00163-00046350-00046846": "what'd I do man all right so one whoa I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00164-00046847-00047146": "you know I did exactly what I wanted so", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00165-00047147-00047465": "why was I surprised when I went flying", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00166-00047466-00047740": "it's a question for smarter people than", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00167-00047741-00047849": "me", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00168-00047850-00048035": "all right so we do a little bit of this", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00169-00048036-00048268": "then we do it a little bit backwards and", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00170-00048269-00048418": "check it out we got ourselves a tiny", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00171-00048419-00048761": "coffin no it's not it's a mass it's like", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00172-00048762-00049021": "a coffin for your face while it's alive", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00173-00049022-00049373": "yeah fall down this pit and hopefully", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00174-00049374-00049711": "don't die lizard iguana man", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00175-00049712-00050068": "okay I was gonna say please give me the", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00176-00050069-00050458": "health that I so wish to have I didn't", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00177-00050459-00050846": "get that sadly that's fine", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00178-00050847-00051275": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00179-00051276-00051526": "yeah", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00180-00051527-00051688": "let's go in the sand here this is not", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00181-00051689-00051923": "scary like I bet that in the future", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00182-00051924-00052151": "though which is either like spikes or", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00183-00052152-00052373": "something and it's a lot scarier but", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00184-00052374-00052654": "that's just not the case now oh geez I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00185-00052655-00052823": "just threw you all right well hey you", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00186-00052824-00053069": "blow up in the sand that's weird to", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00187-00053070-00053471": "probably avoid doing that of what what's", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00188-00053472-00053771": "going on here all right I can stand on", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00189-00053772-00054065": "you oh you're so sad I feel bad and yet", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00190-00054066-00054353": "here I go slicing you again I'm a", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00191-00054354-00054575": "monster I'm sorry so yeah there's enough", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00192-00054576-00055525": "there but I don't have access to it", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00193-00055526-00055769": "man your little projectiles are really", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00194-00055770-00055966": "annoying all right so I think see what I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00195-00055967-00056182": "need to do here is clear out a certain", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00196-00056183-00056494": "height yeah that's right I can hear you", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00197-00056495-00056741": "cry then you go faster as there's less", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00198-00056741-00057011": "of you yeah tracks all right I would", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00199-00057012-00057142": "love that juice but I don't think I'm", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00200-00057144-00057419": "getting it all right okay no I need to", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00201-00057420-00057653": "remove one more layer of you there you", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00202-00057654-00057961": "go I can hitch a ride no problem", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00203-00057962-00058265": "I guess the Strat would be to just take", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00204-00058266-00058441": "a hit and then I would be able to play", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00205-00058442-00058619": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00206-00058620-00058829": "um like get into that drink and heal up", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00207-00058829-00058966": "what I want the damage I would have", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00208-00058967-00059219": "taken from that but clearly I didn't do", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00209-00059220-00059573": "that so no point wondering about those", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00210-00059574-00059842": "Mysteries why yeah oh oh no there's no", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00211-00059844-00060076": "up here there is no up here only", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00212-00060077-00060238": "branches", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00213-00060239-00060694": "welcome to egg salad where I like to", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00214-00060695-00061049": "when I was so sad I can do that you can", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00215-00061050-00061153": "do that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00216-00061154-00061379": "don't stand underneath the door because", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00217-00061379-00061565": "it's gonna open up and you're gonna have", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00218-00061566-00061835": "a bad time you want to avoid bad times", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00219-00061836-00062194": "if you can help at time all right I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00220-00062195-00062447": "guess we're going down don't worry about", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00221-00062448-00062704": "it I'm now in the past the future I was", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00222-00062705-00062975": "in the past for a while oh that is I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00223-00062976-00063137": "think you're supposed to like jump like", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00224-00063138-00063299": "that yeah like there was that little", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00225-00063300-00063461": "ledge with a little bit of sand I was", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00226-00063462-00063797": "like oh but no yeah Zara took some", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00227-00063798-00064103": "damage in a weird way that might confuse", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00228-00064104-00064237": "and", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00229-00064238-00064559": "perspire you that's fine you know what", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00230-00064560-00064853": "sometimes a little bit of perspiration I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00231-00064854-00065075": "mean our body does it for a reason Keeps", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00232-00065076-00065494": "Us healthy we got fruits Bush just kind", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00233-00065495-00065819": "of looking at me and judging but I kind", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00234-00065820-00066076": "of messed that one out but I am just", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00235-00066077-00066425": "absolutely not punished for it", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00236-00066426-00066629": "oh geez but if you could maintain your", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00237-00066630-00066953": "momentum you'd be flying here and it'd", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00238-00066954-00067123": "be super cool", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00239-00067124-00067585": "instead we saw the lame way through", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00240-00067586-00067926": "something somewhere is needed", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00241-00067927-00068399": "is that you oh that's a track I gotta", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00242-00068400-00068561": "put that there so that the elevator", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00243-00068562-00068903": "follows the track that's beautiful", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00244-00068904-00069132": "go underwater", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00245-00069133-00069532": "now there's under water Smashers look at", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00246-00069533-00069676": "that there's a little bit of a there's", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00247-00069677-00069917": "some like nautiluses inside embedded in", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00248-00069918-00070085": "the Rock oh I saw that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00249-00070086-00070438": "all right it's kind of little face to", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00250-00070439-00070744": "living and it's not all pumpkins are", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00251-00070745-00071081": "peaceful oh you're so sad", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00252-00071082-00071309": "but is it possible now because yeah I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00253-00071310-00071567": "can't use you anymore but I can go up", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00254-00071568-00071782": "here", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00255-00071783-00072047": "which is kind of all you really need to", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00256-00072048-00072323": "do it turns out all right you know what", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00257-00072324-00072641": "I'm not old you guys are kind of jerks", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00258-00072642-00072779": "though when you're like above like that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00259-00072780-00073006": "like what am I gonna do about it right", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00260-00073007-00073247": "all right well I'm here I'm looking", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00261-00073248-00073505": "forward to a tree that I can look at it", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00262-00073506-00073744": "with I'll falling in the Glee is that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00263-00073745-00073985": "good though falling in the Glee implies", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00264-00073986-00074273": "a Happy Time welcome to the healing Cove", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00265-00074274-00074513": "The Cove with a bottle oh there's a down", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00266-00074514-00074831": "there's a down maybe we want to fall", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00267-00074832-00074947": "down", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00268-00074948-00075365": "but there's a mask is like over there no", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00269-00075366-00075587": "you hear the down is gonna kill you like", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00270-00075588-00075815": "it has that texture but there's a down", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00271-00075816-00076103": "door okay it might be like a specific", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00272-00076104-00076261": "place", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00273-00076262-00076529": "like over somewhere like on the other", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00274-00076530-00076865": "side of this mountain region I don't", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00275-00076866-00077041": "know I'm seeing the death pixels man", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00276-00077042-00077262": "like you know what I'm talking about", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00277-00077263-00077512": "these little like dark pixels that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00278-00077513-00077711": "indicate that if you follow the line", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00279-00077712-00078017": "here you're gonna have a bad time", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00280-00078018-00078197": "compared to the other places where it", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00281-00078198-00078400": "can fall down and you normally have a", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00282-00078401-00078676": "good time but do you think changing the", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00283-00078677-00078971": "timeline is what helps that out", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00284-00078972-00079306": "all right it's worth checking actually", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00285-00079307-00079600": "get out I'm now in the past you can tell", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00286-00079601-00079961": "because my color adapt is very poor but", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00287-00079962-00080303": "that face is having a blast", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00288-00080304-00080579": "no sweat about that all right like this", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00289-00080580-00080759": "am I gonna be here and feeling both", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00290-00080760-00081035": "Maybe", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00291-00081036-00081311": "sit down somewhere", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00292-00081312-00081671": "I break this can I break this", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00293-00081672-00082029": "my brake is this block", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00294-00082030-00082175": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00295-00082176-00082426": "yeah I'm not seeing it because you can't", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00296-00082427-00082691": "can't phone off these", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00297-00082692-00082903": "could die if you do", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00298-00082904-00083285": "I'm a little confused like I'm not gonna", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00299-00083286-00083735": "cry like the game has been like as meta", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00300-00083736-00084041": "as it gets it is always on us and it", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00301-00084042-00084376": "follows its own code", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00302-00084377-00084694": "I can't even do anything here so why is", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00303-00084695-00084953": "there this time change then", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00304-00084954-00085211": "I don't know", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00305-00085212-00085529": "I really don't what all right it's a", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00306-00085530-00085787": "great shoe that blows up you gotta", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00307-00085788-00086038": "really like buzz The Rock otherwise it's", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00308-00086039-00086249": "gonna have it oh that's where it stops", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00309-00086250-00086506": "and then there's this up here it's not", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00310-00086507-00086700": "it of course", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00311-00086701-00087155": "point point there we go", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00312-00087156-00087556": "these are gonna crumble around this big", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00313-00087557-00087905": "old building type of thing don't do that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00314-00087906-00088331": "don't throw things at me that's mean", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00315-00088332-00088818": "and I'm maybe we'll return around them", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00316-00088819-00089117": "gotta be careful here there's like lots", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00317-00089118-00089512": "of nonsense really is what it whoa good", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00318-00089513-00089747": "response no okay this is uh they're", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00319-00089748-00089897": "responding on a platform that does not", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00320-00089898-00090071": "exist anymore and you don't seem to be", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00321-00090072-00090437": "able to realize that buddy please be", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00322-00090438-00090587": "more aware of your surroundings when you", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00323-00090588-00090941": "respawn that's all I ask just a down on", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00324-00090942-00091121": "the other side but it's nowhere near", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00325-00091122-00091379": "masks and stuff so", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00326-00091380-00091582": "like what does that mean well this is", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00327-00091583-00091859": "cool oh shoot I messed it up", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00328-00091860-00092165": "but it's cool though like it's not cool", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00329-00092166-00092482": "and I you'd last like five seconds all", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00330-00092483-00092650": "right you know what it's all right it's", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00331-00092651-00093049": "all right it's all right it's all right", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00332-00093050-00093365": "yeah but like mask here mask here and", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00333-00093366-00093587": "those are the last masks so like what do", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00334-00093588-00093803": "I know well check it out that's the", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00335-00093804-00094387": "whole universe 10 masks", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00336-00094388-00094771": "oh there's another is that my homeland", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00337-00094772-00095050": "that's my homeland", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00338-00095051-00095315": "three out of ten masks so what's up with", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00339-00095316-00095705": "that okay so", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00340-00095706-00096065": "so Santa was like five what happened to", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00341-00096066-00096287": "that I don't know", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00342-00096288-00096568": "I just do not know all right but here I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00343-00096569-00096899": "am not no way so like I don't know if", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00344-00096900-00097097": "this is gonna be like I kind of use like", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00345-00097098-00097432": "areas of specific sizes I'm not sure", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00346-00097433-00097685": "what to expect here actually this is", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00347-00097686-00097943": "gonna be like one huge area okay you can", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00348-00097944-00098447": "stand with them whoa within the columns", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00349-00098448-00098556": "really good to know", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00350-00098557-00098699": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00351-00098700-00099011": "okay you oh shoot I somehow failed to", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00352-00099012-00099412": "notice extremely important detail that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00353-00099413-00099676": "uh yeah the the north closes down on", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00354-00099677-00100103": "spikes not on floor floor is good but we", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00355-00100104-00100306": "don't got those all right we got", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00356-00100307-00100691": "ourselves an elevator so", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00357-00100692-00100973": "okay so maybe I want this well I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00358-00100974-00101167": "absolutely want this", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00359-00101168-00101441": "and I want you to be the other way and", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00360-00101442-00101626": "that's gonna go there now it looks all", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00361-00101627-00101803": "right I mean I don't know the full Road", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00362-00101804-00102047": "I didn't look the whole thing I just", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00363-00102048-00102197": "kind of looked at these three I was like", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00364-00102198-00102347": "Ah that's fine", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00365-00102348-00102599": "I was right so what are you gonna do", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00366-00102600-00103006": "about it it's all flooded now welcome to", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00367-00103007-00103349": "the very short underwater path", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00368-00103350-00103582": "there's a thing here", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00369-00103583-00103727": "open up", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00370-00103728-00103978": "maybe I need to be in the other time", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00371-00103979-00104165": "there's not a time portal for a little", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00372-00104166-00104401": "bit looks like", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00373-00104402-00104651": "uh and you might need to be there from", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00374-00104652-00104910": "the other side", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00375-00104911-00105215": "ah keep looking on a map welcome to map", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00376-00105216-00105358": "gameplay", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00377-00105359-00105599": "where we look at maps all day it's all", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00378-00105600-00105757": "we do", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00379-00105758-00105995": "all right just like a whole bunch of", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00380-00105996-00106277": "just like particles everywhere just", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00381-00106278-00106469": "stinking up the joint it's very", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00382-00106470-00106901": "distracting we stopped oh shoot let's", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00383-00106902-00107110": "slice this man this lizard man is there", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00384-00107111-00107290": "anything oh there was a top dang it it", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00385-00107291-00107365": "wasn't on top", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00386-00107366-00107501": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00387-00107502-00107915": "well I'll go back and I'll do this again", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00388-00107916-00108215": "cool there's nothing here though so what", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00389-00108216-00108478": "does that mean", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00390-00108479-00108808": "not sure what that means well we're", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00391-00108809-00109019": "gonna change time and we're going to go", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00392-00109020-00109349": "back probably right oh shoot well okay I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00393-00109350-00109652": "played that it's really bad", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00394-00109653-00110358": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00395-00110359-00110566": "thank you", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00396-00110567-00111877": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00397-00111878-00112163": "he's done with all these people are", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00398-00112164-00112373": "having too much fun there", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00399-00112374-00112763": "and the old running ground", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00400-00112764-00113081": "Zone I don't know what I'm saying but", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00401-00113082-00113351": "now I've released the Hound it's pretty", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00402-00113352-00113608": "good please don't Smack me smush me", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00403-00113609-00113854": "anything you want whoa I'm above the HUD", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00404-00113855-00114131": "wacky open there's a thing down I cannot", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00405-00114132-00114275": "go down yeah we're going to be doing", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00406-00114276-00114769": "some time travel and use parrots or good", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00407-00114770-00115078": "that's my take here", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00408-00115079-00115408": "quality parrot with a with a bone thick", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00409-00115409-00115584": "that's fine man", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00410-00115585-00115883": "carrots are known for their spite no one", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00411-00115883-00116231": "just has a log log me up that whoa that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00412-00116232-00116381": "one has a spider bone that's scary all", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00413-00116382-00116531": "right these animals can live all right", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00414-00116532-00116795": "and we're doing all this rides be able", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00415-00116796-00116954": "to change time once again", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00416-00116955-00117552": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00417-00117553-00117947": "it's now Stormy in the parrot is in HD", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00418-00117948-00118319": "well not really miss sing still some", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00419-00118320-00118625": "quality so that's okay I wanna kill the", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00420-00118626-00118901": "froggy I missed all right give me your", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00421-00118902-00119104": "give me a rock", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00422-00119105-00119507": "there we go give me your rock and here", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00423-00119508-00119783": "we go cause there's one a man that's", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00424-00119783-00120160": "going in the spikes dead he will not", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00425-00120161-00120419": "live I think I just want to go down for", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00426-00120420-00120677": "a mask okay yes there's a mask", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00427-00120678-00120995": "we got laser bats", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00428-00120996-00121258": "and Laser bats and Friends", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00429-00121259-00121534": "okay what is going on here well laser", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00430-00121535-00121925": "bat and bats of laser so we got", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00431-00121926-00122189": "ourselves a little bit of a conundrum", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00432-00122190-00122471": "where see here I want to have that ride", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00433-00122472-00122831": "going and here I need to have that ride", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00434-00122832-00122945": "going", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00435-00122946-00123239": "but that one's incorrect so I have to do", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00436-00123240-00123575": "this maybe if I do this because then I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00437-00123576-00124045": "can have like these", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00438-00124046-00124633": "I need to kind of Offset you now", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00439-00124633-00125765": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00440-00125766-00125933": "um", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00441-00125934-00126485": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00442-00126486-00127019": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00443-00127020-00127971": "okay", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00444-00127972-00130266": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00445-00130267-00130692": "thank you", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00446-00130693-00131845": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00447-00131846-00132190": "I did not expect this logic puzzle here", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00448-00132191-00132490": "I am sorry no I don't actually know what", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00449-00132491-00132616": "path I want", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00450-00132617-00132797": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00451-00132798-00132959": "because this looks like it'd be good", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00452-00132960-00133493": "here it's not good oh well here we go I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00453-00133494-00133590": "have", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00454-00133591-00133866": "what am I trying to do", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00455-00133867-00134135": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00456-00134136-00134578": "I go here and I can go in this thing I'm", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00457-00134579-00134837": "gonna go beep beep beep beep beep check", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00458-00134838-00135137": "that out it's my ride oh I accidentally", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00459-00135138-00135557": "did it well not accidentally I put some", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00460-00135558-00135737": "thoughts into this to get these massive", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00461-00135738-00136216": "novelty teeth but I I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00462-00136217-00136439": "I think I was trying to do the wrong", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00463-00136440-00136769": "thing for a while and I kind of lucked", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00464-00136770-00136985": "into something that eventually worked", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00465-00136986-00137183": "I'm gonna be real", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00466-00137184-00137416": "how is this gonna work", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00467-00137417-00137783": "um oh I can jump down here yeah that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00468-00137784-00138071": "that would fix that problem that little", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00469-00138072-00138275": "I might be stuck here forever problem", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00470-00138276-00138551": "you're not stuck forever that's that's", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00471-00138552-00138737": "the problem all right so here I can go", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00472-00138738-00138904": "uh", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00473-00138905-00139121": "and there's a save so I think I want to", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00474-00139122-00139414": "get the mask first though and then I'm", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00475-00139415-00139727": "going to go into a world of infinite", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00476-00139728-00140261": "sorrow that is on top there thanks for", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00477-00140262-00140633": "if I can just buy a lot well no way wow", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00478-00140634-00140963": "there we go is this a windmill like oh", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00479-00140964-00141251": "this is a return trip is that I'm not", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00480-00141252-00141437": "seeing a door here", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00481-00141438-00141595": "can't get that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00482-00141596-00141869": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00483-00141870-00142114": "um", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00484-00142115-00142397": "yeah oh no there's a way back from the", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00485-00142398-00142595": "other side", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00486-00142596-00142854": "all right let's handle that real quick", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00487-00142855-00143152": "and here there's a k that doesn't cave", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00488-00143153-00143404": "anywhere that's pretty good hey", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00489-00143405-00143783": "everybody how's it going today I messed", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00490-00143784-00143987": "up I didn't do that right I don't know", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00491-00143988-00144323": "if you noticed it's subtle I mean yeah", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00492-00144324-00144539": "like you can't just stand to buy them", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00493-00144540-00144869": "they're very oh it's uh it's gonna stop", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00494-00144870-00145240": "you so no actually I have to commit this", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00495-00145241-00145714": "violence I'm sorry it is mandated by the", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00496-00145715-00146051": "law of Bushido I'm making that one up", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00497-00146052-00146537": "I'm sorry okay so all this exists", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00498-00146538-00146807": "whoops for the purpose of missing that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00499-00146808-00147083": "up completely yeah see because like I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00500-00147084-00147269": "lost the intense momentum that I'm", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00501-00147270-00147490": "supposed to have so I can't clear it", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00502-00147491-00147839": "108.", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00503-00147840-00148252": "oh well all right", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00504-00148253-00148589": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00505-00148590-00148835": "no you're supposed to slash", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00506-00148836-00149255": "to maintain momentum ah yes", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00507-00149256-00149933": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00508-00149934-00150275": "it's like you rope first", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00509-00150276-00150485": "well", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00510-00150486-00150640": "well oh and you're supposed to like you", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00511-00150641-00150863": "know still do the whole shebang here", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00512-00150864-00151025": "well I", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00513-00151026-00151325": "am terrible I'm so sorry", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00514-00151326-00151564": "oh sorry", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00515-00151565-00151752": "absolutely", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00516-00151753-00152093": "agonizing that was all right well that", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00517-00152094-00152393": "was my run it was the high quality and", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00518-00152394-00152578": "extra speed", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00519-00152579-00152728": "all right I need to return over there", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00520-00152729-00152909": "well you know what let's do that next", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00521-00152910-00153089": "time so yeah this was all like a little", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00522-00153090-00153269": "detour just for this purpose this still", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00523-00153270-00153497": "bugs me the slower door here maybe we'll", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00524-00153498-00153683": "return there we'll do like a big loop", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00525-00153684-00153884": "around the Universe I don't know", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00526-00153885-00154121": "[Music]", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00527-00154122-00154283": "I don't know where I am here so here", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00528-00154284-00154516": "it's five out of five but there's so", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00529-00154517-00154673": "there's another place that's going to be", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00530-00154674-00154835": "another five so this is a little bit", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00531-00154836-00155140": "bigger than I thought good great good", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00532-00155141-00155309": "good great so yeah next time we'll", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00533-00155310-00155459": "return there and it'll keep on our", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00534-00155460-00155585": "pathway", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00535-00155586-00155890": "oh man like it looks super cool to go", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00536-00155891-00156059": "super fast with a spike and I just", "TEOKUGwM0Pg-00537-00156060-00156350": "cannot nail it"}}, {"audio_id": "TEWPd-XEQ6u", "text": {"TEWPd-XEQ6u-00000-00000544-00000734": "guide us", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00001-00000735-00000927": "to the straight", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00002-00000927-00001087": "path", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00003-00001088-00001431": "now this is a supplication", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00004-00001432-00001767": "this is a supplication after glorifying", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00005-00001768-00002126": "after praising allah in the initial", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00006-00002127-00002415": "verses and then making a pact and", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00007-00002416-00002647": "promise with allah", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00008-00002648-00002855": "now the reciter", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00009-00002856-00004511": "is", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00010-00004512-00004654": "means what", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00011-00004655-00004854": "the straight path", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00012-00004855-00005086": "what is this", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00013-00005087-00005431": "now as you can see", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00014-00005432-00005606": "between dunya", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00015-00005607-00005831": "and between jannah", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00016-00005832-00005999": "the shortest", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00017-00006000-00006167": "the straightest", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00018-00006168-00006383": "the easiest", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00019-00006384-00006470": "and", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00020-00006472-00006831": "the surest path from dunya to directly", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00021-00006831-00006975": "to jannah", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00022-00006976-00007255": "is", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00023-00007256-00007455": "there might be other roots", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00024-00007456-00007631": "but they might be longer they might be", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00025-00007631-00007887": "risky and it might not be sure that they", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00026-00007888-00008167": "might lead us to jannah but the shortest", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00027-00008168-00008399": "easiest sure is and even the most", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00028-00008400-00008542": "convenient", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00029-00008543-00009014": "route from dunya to jannah is what it is", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00030-00009015-00009271": "so after glorifying and praising allah", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00031-00009272-00009487": "and making a promise we make a dua and", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00032-00009488-00009759": "we request for guidance to jannah we", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00033-00009760-00010103": "make a dua that guide us to spend our", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00034-00010104-00010367": "lives on a path which surely leads to", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00035-00010368-00010663": "our desired destination of jannah", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00036-00010664-00010942": "the reciter of surah fatiha asks the", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00037-00010943-00011287": "hadi rub himself directly for guidance", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00038-00011288-00011599": "and it is it is the best supplication", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00039-00011600-00011774": "any believer can make and that is why", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00040-00011775-00012103": "swara fatiha is also called", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00041-00012104-00012351": "but now before i go ahead with the next", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00042-00012352-00012438": "verse", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00043-00012439-00012670": "i would uh highlight one thing we need", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00044-00012671-00012983": "to remember that although we know that", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00045-00012984-00013166": "this is", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00046-00013168-00013486": "and after glorifying allah and reciting", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00047-00013487-00013811": "surah fatiha when we're going to ask", "TEWPd-XEQ6u-00048-00013812-00014304": "foreign will be heard and accepted"}}, {"audio_id": "TF0a23azjty", "text": {"TF0a23azjty-00000-00000003-00000749": "you're anyway pick up everything I", "TF0a23azjty-00001-00000750-00002553": "[Music]", "TF0a23azjty-00002-00002554-00002740": "[Music]", "TF0a23azjty-00003-00002741-00004870": "literally know our College close t-shirt", "TF0a23azjty-00004-00004871-00005531": "bill t-shirt my babe I moved here", "TF0a23azjty-00005-00005532-00005986": "October around Halloween 2003 Obama's", "TF0a23azjty-00006-00005987-00007229": "new giggles bunny nationhood why we use", "TF0a23azjty-00007-00007230-00007375": "[Applause]", "TF0a23azjty-00008-00007376-00007869": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "TFppsw0H_7u", "text": {"TFppsw0H_7u-00000-00001333-00001672": "welcome back in the last few lectures we", "TFppsw0H_7u-00001-00001673-00001876": "talked about some of the basic concepts", "TFppsw0H_7u-00002-00001877-00002192": "in which we started we recognized", "TFppsw0H_7u-00003-00002193-00002470": "arguments and we could recognize", "TFppsw0H_7u-00004-00002471-00002623": "arguments only when there are some", "TFppsw0H_7u-00005-00002624-00002770": "premise indicators or conclusion", "TFppsw0H_7u-00006-00002771-00002985": "indicators suppose if these premises and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00007-00002986-00003187": "conclusion indicators are missing then", "TFppsw0H_7u-00008-00003188-00003340": "we are looking for some kind of a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00009-00003340-00003556": "factual claim if it is a it's well and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00010-00003557-00003840": "good and then we said that for", "TFppsw0H_7u-00011-00003840-00004138": "identifying recognizing an argument what", "TFppsw0H_7u-00012-00004139-00004369": "is most important is the inferential", "TFppsw0H_7u-00013-00004370-00004681": "claim so if you can find the inferential", "TFppsw0H_7u-00014-00004682-00004897": "claim then you can say that there seems", "TFppsw0H_7u-00015-00004898-00005059": "to be some kind of argument present in a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00016-00005060-00005397": "given english-language passage and once", "TFppsw0H_7u-00017-00005398-00005574": "we identify the arguments then we", "TFppsw0H_7u-00018-00005575-00005788": "identified that based on how the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00019-00005789-00005947": "conclusion follows from the premises", "TFppsw0H_7u-00020-00005948-00006190": "we identified that a particular kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00021-00006191-00006367": "argument is a deductive argument in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00022-00006368-00006559": "which conclusion necessarily follows", "TFppsw0H_7u-00023-00006559-00006739": "from the premises and there is no new", "TFppsw0H_7u-00024-00006740-00006883": "information in the conclusion which is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00025-00006884-00007123": "not stated in the premises and then it's", "TFppsw0H_7u-00026-00007123-00007450": "not considered to be AmpliTube exit", "TFppsw0H_7u-00027-00007451-00007651": "trial and we identified some of the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00028-00007652-00007884": "other arguments in which the conclusion", "TFppsw0H_7u-00029-00007886-00008130": "only probably follows from the premises", "TFppsw0H_7u-00030-00008131-00008442": "and there is always some kind of new", "TFppsw0H_7u-00031-00008443-00008620": "information in the conclusion which is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00032-00008621-00008884": "not there in the premises in all so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00033-00008885-00009055": "these are what we call it as inductive", "TFppsw0H_7u-00034-00009056-00009277": "arguments and then we also said", "TFppsw0H_7u-00035-00009278-00009580": "something about non arguments such as", "TFppsw0H_7u-00036-00009581-00009727": "you know somebody is giving just a piece", "TFppsw0H_7u-00037-00009728-00010066": "of advice or suggestion or is just", "TFppsw0H_7u-00038-00010067-00010333": "giving some kind of explanation or", "TFppsw0H_7u-00039-00010334-00010581": "expository passages etc there are all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00040-00010582-00010756": "non inferential passages hence we", "TFppsw0H_7u-00041-00010757-00011178": "treated them as non arguments so then we", "TFppsw0H_7u-00042-00011179-00011553": "talked about one example with which one", "TFppsw0H_7u-00043-00011554-00011763": "method with which we could find out", "TFppsw0H_7u-00044-00011764-00011964": "whether a given argument is invalid", "TFppsw0H_7u-00045-00011965-00012153": "etcetera and all that method is called", "TFppsw0H_7u-00046-00012154-00012520": "as counter example method so then we", "TFppsw0H_7u-00047-00012521-00012730": "spoke about one particular model of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00048-00012731-00012927": "argumentation which is due to Stephen", "TFppsw0H_7u-00049-00012928-00013082": "Toulmin and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00050-00013083-00013268": "which you could find out what", "TFppsw0H_7u-00051-00013269-00013571": "constitutes whatever tis what is what do", "TFppsw0H_7u-00052-00013572-00013862": "you mean by an effective argument at all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00053-00013863-00014036": "so there is a model which we have", "TFppsw0H_7u-00054-00014037-00014258": "presented and then there we have seen", "TFppsw0H_7u-00055-00014259-00014501": "that there are at least a few components", "TFppsw0H_7u-00056-00014502-00014747": "of an argument or a layout of an", "TFppsw0H_7u-00057-00014747-00014930": "argument which are important that is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00058-00014931-00015203": "data and a claim and data and claim are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00059-00015204-00015538": "supported by some kind of warrants and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00060-00015540-00015755": "warrant needs to be supported by further", "TFppsw0H_7u-00061-00015756-00016040": "backed up statements and then suppose if", "TFppsw0H_7u-00062-00016041-00016294": "we come up with any claim each claim", "TFppsw0H_7u-00063-00016296-00016547": "needs to be having some kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00064-00016548-00016901": "qualifier and then it will have it every", "TFppsw0H_7u-00065-00016902-00017042": "argument should have some kind of a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00066-00017043-00017312": "rebuttal and so this is what we have", "TFppsw0H_7u-00067-00017313-00017537": "done so far and then now what we will do", "TFppsw0H_7u-00068-00017538-00017876": "is this that once we identified that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00069-00017877-00017969": "they are deductive and inductive", "TFppsw0H_7u-00070-00017970-00018338": "arguments and then both deductive and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00071-00018339-00018635": "inductive arguments can be fallacious so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00072-00018636-00018830": "in this lecture we will be talking about", "TFppsw0H_7u-00073-00018831-00019175": "what we mean by fallacy and what kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00074-00019176-00019400": "fallacies that we commonly come across", "TFppsw0H_7u-00075-00019401-00019658": "in day-to-day discourse or when the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00076-00019659-00019886": "arguer is said to be making some kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00077-00019887-00020090": "mistakes in the argumentation after all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00078-00020091-00020330": "fallacy is nothing but a mistake or", "TFppsw0H_7u-00079-00020331-00020558": "error or defect in the argumentation at", "TFppsw0H_7u-00080-00020559-00020990": "all so why the argue does this mistakes", "TFppsw0H_7u-00081-00020991-00021209": "and all because simply because of this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00082-00021210-00021557": "that all these fallacies are some kind", "TFppsw0H_7u-00083-00021558-00021842": "of persuasive mechanisms you know so we", "TFppsw0H_7u-00084-00021843-00022085": "all the time want others to accept our", "TFppsw0H_7u-00085-00022086-00022403": "claims and all in the process sometimes", "TFppsw0H_7u-00086-00022404-00022604": "will be logical sometimes we may not be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00087-00022605-00022928": "logical we make some mistakes etc and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00088-00022929-00023060": "that is what we are going to study in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00089-00023061-00023327": "this lecture and also in this lecture I", "TFppsw0H_7u-00090-00023328-00023693": "will be focusing on two kinds of two", "TFppsw0H_7u-00091-00023694-00024014": "different kinds of fallacies so these", "TFppsw0H_7u-00092-00024015-00024224": "formal fallacies and informal fallacies", "TFppsw0H_7u-00093-00024225-00024437": "and then I will talk a little bit about", "TFppsw0H_7u-00094-00024438-00024761": "formal fallacies first and then we will", "TFppsw0H_7u-00095-00024762-00025052": "move on to informal fallacies informal", "TFppsw0H_7u-00096-00025053-00025487": "fallacies arises because of some kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00097-00025488-00025747": "problem of relevance and then I will", "TFppsw0H_7u-00098-00025748-00025939": "talk about fallacies of weak induction", "TFppsw0H_7u-00099-00025941-00026276": "and apart from this thing there are some", "TFppsw0H_7u-00100-00026277-00026445": "kind of fallacies", "TFppsw0H_7u-00101-00026445-00026673": "which arises out of ambiguity in the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00102-00026674-00026921": "language because English language is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00103-00026922-00027276": "vague because for example a simple word", "TFppsw0H_7u-00104-00027277-00027539": "such as a predicate like tall can be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00105-00027541-00027702": "represented in so many different ways", "TFppsw0H_7u-00106-00027702-00028056": "and also Romi's tall for example if you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00107-00028057-00028218": "say that thing and the next question", "TFppsw0H_7u-00108-00028219-00028487": "that comes to us is how tall he is this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00109-00028488-00028695": "is the case that a 6.8 is considered to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00110-00028695-00028862": "be should be considered to be tall or", "TFppsw0H_7u-00111-00028863-00029114": "5.8 is to be considered to be tall or", "TFppsw0H_7u-00112-00029116-00029292": "what will happen to those cases in which", "TFppsw0H_7u-00113-00029293-00029624": "which falls between 5.8 definitely you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00114-00029625-00029840": "know we considered that they are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00115-00029841-00030048": "definitely you know taller and all and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00116-00030049-00030252": "those cases in which you know they fall", "TFppsw0H_7u-00117-00030252-00030633": "between 5.8 and 6.2 etc so English", "TFppsw0H_7u-00118-00030633-00030929": "language is a little bit vague and also", "TFppsw0H_7u-00119-00030930-00031145": "we might make some mistakes in the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00120-00031147-00031554": "argumentation especially when we shift", "TFppsw0H_7u-00121-00031555-00031776": "the meaning of the words that you that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00122-00031777-00032039": "you that we use in the argumentation", "TFppsw0H_7u-00123-00032039-00032246": "then we talk about some kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00124-00032247-00032361": "fallacies which arises out of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00125-00032362-00032768": "grammatical errors etc and all so these", "TFppsw0H_7u-00126-00032769-00032918": "kinds of fallacies come under the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00127-00032919-00033118": "category of fallacies arising out of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00128-00033119-00033483": "ambiguity of language so then I will", "TFppsw0H_7u-00129-00033484-00033692": "discuss about detecting and avoiding", "TFppsw0H_7u-00130-00033693-00034035": "fallacies this is the program this is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00131-00034036-00034312": "the agenda for under these fallacies so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00132-00034313-00034557": "so in this lecture I will be focusing on", "TFppsw0H_7u-00133-00034558-00034827": "formal fallacies and the informal", "TFppsw0H_7u-00134-00034828-00034992": "fallacies especially the fallacies of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00135-00034993-00035535": "relevance so before I continue then let", "TFppsw0H_7u-00136-00035536-00035762": "us talk about what we mean by a fallacy", "TFppsw0H_7u-00137-00035763-00036057": "so it is used as a synonym for any kind", "TFppsw0H_7u-00138-00036058-00036389": "of position that is false or sometimes", "TFppsw0H_7u-00139-00036390-00036596": "even deceptive or sometimes it is even", "TFppsw0H_7u-00140-00036597-00036824": "applied to some kind of narrow sense to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00141-00036825-00037076": "some kind of faulty process of reasoning", "TFppsw0H_7u-00142-00037077-00037352": "so we talked about different kinds of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00143-00037353-00037493": "reasoning inductive and deductive", "TFppsw0H_7u-00144-00037494-00037989": "reasoning etcetera so if both such kind", "TFppsw0H_7u-00145-00037990-00038439": "of reasoning is defective then that is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00146-00038440-00038607": "considered to be some kind of faulty", "TFppsw0H_7u-00147-00038608-00038810": "process of reasoning you know or", "TFppsw0H_7u-00148-00038811-00039258": "sometimes it an arguer might want to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00149-00039259-00039498": "trick use some kind of tricks and all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00150-00039499-00039677": "especially to persuade the reader or", "TFppsw0H_7u-00151-00039678-00039878": "listener", "TFppsw0H_7u-00152-00039879-00040118": "mostly these are all some kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00153-00040119-00040662": "specious persuasions enough so so what", "TFppsw0H_7u-00154-00040663-00041007": "is these are all pastas you've kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00155-00041008-00041307": "mechanisms are not so but logically", "TFppsw0H_7u-00156-00041308-00041481": "speaking they're all considered to be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00157-00041482-00041691": "mistakes in the argumentation and on and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00158-00041692-00041937": "hence they are called as fallacies so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00159-00041938-00042147": "they might not be considered to be a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00160-00042148-00042429": "fallacy fallacy in the sense of in a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00161-00042430-00042633": "psychological sense except trying on all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00162-00042634-00042846": "these fallacies might be of some", "TFppsw0H_7u-00163-00042847-00043179": "importance there but as far as logic is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00164-00043180-00043320": "concerned they are all considered to be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00165-00043321-00043650": "fallacies enough so one one must note", "TFppsw0H_7u-00166-00043651-00043884": "that there are many arguments which are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00167-00043885-00044100": "very persuasive and all they're all not", "TFppsw0H_7u-00168-00044101-00044304": "good arguments enough so how to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00169-00044305-00044478": "distinguish good argument from a bad", "TFppsw0H_7u-00170-00044479-00044640": "argument etc this is the question that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00171-00044641-00044949": "will be asked in the last few lectures", "TFppsw0H_7u-00172-00044950-00045135": "as well as we'll be asking this lecture", "TFppsw0H_7u-00173-00045136-00045339": "even we will be asking this question", "TFppsw0H_7u-00174-00045340-00045723": "even in these lectures as well so mere", "TFppsw0H_7u-00175-00045724-00045918": "persuasive mechanisms will not serve as", "TFppsw0H_7u-00176-00045919-00046254": "a good or effective kind of argument so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00177-00046255-00046509": "there might be some kind of errors or", "TFppsw0H_7u-00178-00046510-00046740": "defects or mistakes in the argumentation", "TFppsw0H_7u-00179-00046741-00046971": "sometimes argue deliberately makes it", "TFppsw0H_7u-00180-00046972-00047166": "sometimes the arguer might make it out", "TFppsw0H_7u-00181-00047167-00047484": "of you know ignorant or sometimes you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00182-00047485-00047754": "know you just want to persuade his", "TFppsw0H_7u-00183-00047755-00048059": "reader or listener to accept his claims", "TFppsw0H_7u-00184-00048060-00048420": "so fallacies in a sense is nothing but", "TFppsw0H_7u-00185-00048421-00048540": "some kind of mistake in the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00186-00048541-00048750": "argumentation this mistakes might arise", "TFppsw0H_7u-00187-00048751-00048954": "in in many different ways that is what", "TFppsw0H_7u-00188-00048955-00049197": "we are trying to look into in a greater", "TFppsw0H_7u-00189-00049198-00049680": "detail so a fallacy is a defect in and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00190-00049681-00049977": "argumentation other than merely false", "TFppsw0H_7u-00191-00049978-00050286": "premises so just because an argument has", "TFppsw0H_7u-00192-00050287-00050424": "a false premise there doesn't mean that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00193-00050425-00050805": "it's a it's it is considered to be a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00194-00050806-00051000": "fallacy and on there are many arguments", "TFppsw0H_7u-00195-00051001-00051276": "which have false premises but it these", "TFppsw0H_7u-00196-00051277-00051603": "kinds of arguments are valid in all for", "TFppsw0H_7u-00197-00051604-00051900": "example if you say all squares are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00198-00051901-00052119": "circles all circles are parallelograms", "TFppsw0H_7u-00199-00052120-00052340": "all squares are parallelograms you know", "TFppsw0H_7u-00200-00052341-00052616": "so the conclusion seems to be obviously", "TFppsw0H_7u-00201-00052617-00052923": "ok for us but the premises are obviously", "TFppsw0H_7u-00202-00052924-00053049": "false that doesn't mean that there is a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00203-00053050-00053301": "mistake in that argument", "TFppsw0H_7u-00204-00053302-00053557": "but at this argument is considered to be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00205-00053558-00053746": "valid enough since we don't want these", "TFppsw0H_7u-00206-00053747-00053932": "kinds of arguments in Detroit discourse", "TFppsw0H_7u-00207-00053933-00054295": "so we do not use these kinds of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00208-00054296-00054496": "arguments so we invoke another kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00209-00054497-00054670": "property which we have seen in the last", "TFppsw0H_7u-00210-00054671-00054859": "few lectures under basic concepts that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00211-00054860-00055171": "is the concept of soundness a sound", "TFppsw0H_7u-00212-00055172-00055465": "argument is a deductive argument in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00213-00055466-00055741": "which it's a valid as well as it has", "TFppsw0H_7u-00214-00055741-00056200": "true premises so fallacy is a term the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00215-00056201-00056374": "term which is used for fallacy is non", "TFppsw0H_7u-00216-00056375-00056752": "sequitur means it does not follow other", "TFppsw0H_7u-00217-00056753-00056967": "means is invalid kind of argument is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00218-00056969-00057208": "another name for fallacy now mostly it", "TFppsw0H_7u-00219-00057209-00057490": "is used in in in the context of formal", "TFppsw0H_7u-00220-00057491-00057874": "kind of fallacies so there are two kinds", "TFppsw0H_7u-00221-00057875-00058027": "of fallacies that we commonly come", "TFppsw0H_7u-00222-00058028-00058354": "across so one particular kind of fallacy", "TFppsw0H_7u-00223-00058354-00058621": "is a little bit straightforward and on", "TFppsw0H_7u-00224-00058622-00058852": "just by seeing the form itself we can", "TFppsw0H_7u-00225-00058853-00059124": "make out that there is a mistake in the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00226-00059125-00059437": "mistake in the argumentation in all so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00227-00059438-00059635": "once you extract the form in all if it", "TFppsw0H_7u-00228-00059636-00059815": "is an invalid form obviously it is an", "TFppsw0H_7u-00229-00059816-00060007": "invalid argument in all and hence it is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00230-00060008-00060247": "a fallacy automatically all invalid", "TFppsw0H_7u-00231-00060248-00060436": "arguments are automatically considered", "TFppsw0H_7u-00232-00060437-00060709": "to be fallacious arguments so what is a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00233-00060710-00060946": "formal fallacy a formal fallacy is and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00234-00060947-00061216": "again error in error or mistake in the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00235-00061216-00061441": "reasoning that involves the explicit use", "TFppsw0H_7u-00236-00061441-00061777": "of an invalid form for example instead", "TFppsw0H_7u-00237-00061778-00062110": "of a implies B a and B follows that is a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00238-00062111-00062332": "Morris ponens rule which we have seen", "TFppsw0H_7u-00239-00062333-00062667": "earlier instead of that we use a plus B", "TFppsw0H_7u-00240-00062669-00063154": "and B and it leads to a then that that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00241-00063154-00063370": "is considered to be a mistake in the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00242-00063371-00063589": "argumentation and mistake in the way", "TFppsw0H_7u-00243-00063590-00063925": "very well use the forms now you have not", "TFppsw0H_7u-00244-00063926-00064183": "used in a valid you are not used in a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00245-00064184-00064416": "correct sense so so thats why it is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00246-00064417-00064791": "called as a formal fallacy so formal", "TFppsw0H_7u-00247-00064792-00064980": "fallacies can be identified just by", "TFppsw0H_7u-00248-00064982-00065257": "seeing the form itself if you find", "TFppsw0H_7u-00249-00065258-00065425": "invalid form obviously it is a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00250-00065426-00065749": "fallacious argument and it is a called", "TFppsw0H_7u-00251-00065750-00066047": "as formal fallacy", "TFppsw0H_7u-00252-00066048-00066296": "in formal fallacies on the other hand", "TFppsw0H_7u-00253-00066297-00066644": "are not that easy to identify so they do", "TFppsw0H_7u-00254-00066645-00066953": "not have fixed form form etc and on so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00255-00066954-00067130": "informal fallacies are errors in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00256-00067131-00067298": "reasoning that do not involve the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00257-00067299-00067604": "explicit use of an invalid form in the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00258-00067605-00067801": "day-to-day argumentation it is not it's", "TFppsw0H_7u-00259-00067802-00068068": "not easy to extract form all the time", "TFppsw0H_7u-00260-00068069-00068275": "enough it's not easy to identify what", "TFppsw0H_7u-00261-00068276-00068551": "exactly the arguer is trying to argue or", "TFppsw0H_7u-00262-00068552-00068837": "intend to claim exit from a claim is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00263-00068838-00069143": "considerably the conclusion so those", "TFppsw0H_7u-00264-00069144-00069386": "kinds of fallacies in which I mean you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00265-00069387-00069556": "can make out that there is a mistake in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00266-00069557-00069763": "argumentation only by seeing or", "TFppsw0H_7u-00267-00069764-00069943": "analyzing the content of an argument", "TFppsw0H_7u-00268-00069944-00070207": "they are called as informal fallacies", "TFppsw0H_7u-00269-00070208-00070418": "for example you know the lots of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00270-00070419-00070580": "examples we have seen already in the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00271-00070581-00070835": "last few lectures for example if you say", "TFppsw0H_7u-00272-00070836-00071062": "this room is made up of atoms items are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00273-00071063-00071330": "invisible so this room is invisible", "TFppsw0H_7u-00274-00071331-00071504": "enough suppose if you say that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00275-00071505-00071681": "particular kind of thing unless and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00276-00071682-00071851": "until you analyze the content of the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00277-00071852-00072137": "argument that means the words that you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00278-00072138-00072356": "have used in your argument there is no", "TFppsw0H_7u-00279-00072357-00072532": "way in which you can identify mistake in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00280-00072533-00072850": "the argumentation so detecting an", "TFppsw0H_7u-00281-00072851-00073088": "informal fallacy requires an examination", "TFppsw0H_7u-00282-00073089-00073393": "of arguments content in all unless until", "TFppsw0H_7u-00283-00073394-00073634": "you analyze the content of an argument", "TFppsw0H_7u-00284-00073635-00073775": "there is no way in which you can", "TFppsw0H_7u-00285-00073776-00073949": "identify the mistakes in the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00286-00073950-00074231": "argumentation so these kinds of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00287-00074232-00074399": "fallacies are called as informal", "TFppsw0H_7u-00288-00074400-00074632": "fallacies to be simple in simple terms", "TFppsw0H_7u-00289-00074633-00074850": "formal fallacies can be identified by", "TFppsw0H_7u-00290-00074851-00075088": "some what some mistake in the form and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00291-00075089-00075311": "in formal fallacies can easily be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00292-00075312-00075532": "identified by not easily but it can be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00293-00075533-00075809": "identified by analyzing the content of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00294-00075810-00076349": "the argument and all so how did we get", "TFppsw0H_7u-00295-00076350-00076712": "into this particular kind of some kind", "TFppsw0H_7u-00296-00076713-00076882": "of interest in this fallacies you know", "TFppsw0H_7u-00297-00076883-00077048": "we are saying that all fallacies are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00298-00077049-00077305": "persuasive kind of mechanisms in all at", "TFppsw0H_7u-00299-00077306-00077687": "the same time we are saying that not all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00300-00077688-00077903": "persuasive kind of arguments are good", "TFppsw0H_7u-00301-00077904-00078065": "arguments are efficient or effective", "TFppsw0H_7u-00302-00078066-00078628": "kind of arguments now so so what are the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00303-00078629-00078868": "characteristics of a good argument or", "TFppsw0H_7u-00304-00078869-00079085": "effective argument so we already said", "TFppsw0H_7u-00305-00079086-00079397": "about this thing so it has to be direct", "TFppsw0H_7u-00306-00079398-00079589": "evaluates well and good if you if it is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00307-00079590-00079748": "deductively valid or at least it should", "TFppsw0H_7u-00308-00079749-00079991": "be inductively strong in the case of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00309-00079992-00080129": "inductive arguments you can only talk", "TFppsw0H_7u-00310-00080130-00080360": "about strength of the argument so that's", "TFppsw0H_7u-00311-00080361-00080726": "right it has to be strong and of course", "TFppsw0H_7u-00312-00080727-00081014": "if it has true premises it is called as", "TFppsw0H_7u-00313-00081015-00081170": "in the case of inductive arguments it is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00314-00081171-00081380": "called as a cogent argument in the case", "TFppsw0H_7u-00315-00081381-00081593": "of deductive argument it is called as a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00316-00081594-00081842": "sound argument a sound argument is a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00317-00081843-00082061": "valid argument with true premises if", "TFppsw0H_7u-00318-00082062-00082202": "that is the case then it seems to be a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00319-00082203-00082531": "good and effective kind of argument or", "TFppsw0H_7u-00320-00082532-00082835": "it has validity and truth truth of the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00321-00082836-00083036": "premises be evident as far as possible", "TFppsw0H_7u-00322-00083037-00083243": "to the parties involved suppose two", "TFppsw0H_7u-00323-00083244-00083465": "people are arguing with each other they", "TFppsw0H_7u-00324-00083466-00083738": "know that some of the statements that an", "TFppsw0H_7u-00325-00083739-00083978": "our gear has used also happened to be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00326-00083979-00084197": "factually true as so that makes this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00327-00084198-00084500": "argument sound at home of course the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00328-00084501-00084764": "validity it doesn't require that the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00329-00084765-00084947": "truth of the premises to be actually", "TFppsw0H_7u-00330-00084948-00085223": "true and all but if there is an", "TFppsw0H_7u-00331-00085224-00085433": "inferential claim that is well and good", "TFppsw0H_7u-00332-00085434-00085808": "enough for talking about the validity at", "TFppsw0H_7u-00333-00085809-00086129": "all so both parties that means through", "TFppsw0H_7u-00334-00086130-00086297": "those over who server is engaged in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00335-00086298-00086495": "argumentation should be able to find out", "TFppsw0H_7u-00336-00086496-00086702": "that the targa vent is valid as a writer", "TFppsw0H_7u-00337-00086703-00087023": "as well as it has true premises it's", "TFppsw0H_7u-00338-00087024-00087218": "well and good so that that will", "TFppsw0H_7u-00339-00087219-00087620": "constitute a good argument and the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00340-00087621-00087923": "premises should be stated clearly using", "TFppsw0H_7u-00341-00087924-00088258": "some kind of understandable language and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00342-00088259-00088481": "making clear what the premises and the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00343-00088482-00088715": "conclusions are acceptable easy as to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00344-00088716-00088979": "nicely that means it the argument has to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00345-00088980-00089156": "be some kind of well-crafted kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00346-00089157-00089552": "argument enough so if that is the case", "TFppsw0H_7u-00347-00089553-00089813": "then if you know what premises are what", "TFppsw0H_7u-00348-00089814-00089921": "conclusions are then you will", "TFppsw0H_7u-00349-00089922-00090110": "automatically know what seems to be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00350-00090111-00090467": "supporting what exit and so you need to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00351-00090468-00090767": "avoid for a good argument you need to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00352-00090768-00091129": "mean avoid circularity ambiguity and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00353-00091130-00091400": "sometimes we will be using lot of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00354-00091401-00091721": "emotional language into the arguments", "TFppsw0H_7u-00355-00091722-00092131": "and then basically our purpose is to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00356-00092132-00092422": "to make the reader or listener accept", "TFppsw0H_7u-00357-00092423-00092848": "your our claims enough so one needs to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00358-00092849-00092992": "ensure that there is no circularity in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00359-00092993-00093214": "the argument one simple example could be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00360-00093215-00093649": "for example somebody is arguing that I", "TFppsw0H_7u-00361-00093650-00093874": "believe that God exists is true enough", "TFppsw0H_7u-00362-00093875-00094129": "suppose if you're asking why you believe", "TFppsw0H_7u-00363-00094130-00094327": "that garlic this is true enough so then", "TFppsw0H_7u-00364-00094328-00094573": "you will say that this is what Bible", "TFppsw0H_7u-00365-00094574-00094858": "says so then the next question that you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00366-00094859-00095053": "will come across is what is the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00367-00095054-00095221": "guarantee that what Bible says is true", "TFppsw0H_7u-00368-00095222-00095497": "or what Quran or ether says is true then", "TFppsw0H_7u-00369-00095498-00095836": "you will argue that God is true if he", "TFppsw0H_7u-00370-00095837-00096049": "talks of talks of only truths and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00371-00096050-00096259": "whatever he has written if the Bible is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00372-00096260-00096532": "written ether Quran are written by God", "TFppsw0H_7u-00373-00096533-00096769": "only God's words only they're obviously", "TFppsw0H_7u-00374-00096770-00097045": "true etc then again you ask her what is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00375-00097046-00097201": "the guarantee that these words are true", "TFppsw0H_7u-00376-00097202-00097360": "I mean these statements that you are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00377-00097361-00097519": "that are there in the Bible is true", "TFppsw0H_7u-00378-00097520-00097684": "again you will say that God exists", "TFppsw0H_7u-00379-00097685-00097930": "except trying on this leads to it makes", "TFppsw0H_7u-00380-00097931-00098239": "some person at each and every stage you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00381-00098240-00098521": "are there it leads to some kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00382-00098522-00098749": "circularity in an argument issue as far", "TFppsw0H_7u-00383-00098750-00098971": "as possible it should ensure that there", "TFppsw0H_7u-00384-00098972-00099346": "is no circularity in in your arguments", "TFppsw0H_7u-00385-00099347-00099676": "now and it has to be relevant to the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00386-00099677-00099943": "issue at hand at all for example if you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00387-00099944-00100078": "say two plus two is equal to four and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00388-00100079-00100321": "then and the moon is made of green", "TFppsw0H_7u-00389-00100322-00100501": "cheese and you'll infer two plus two is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00390-00100502-00100660": "equal to four there's no relevance", "TFppsw0H_7u-00391-00100661-00100846": "between moon is made up of green cheese", "TFppsw0H_7u-00392-00100847-00101026": "and two plus two is equal to four and on", "TFppsw0H_7u-00393-00101027-00101317": "although it looks like that from a and B", "TFppsw0H_7u-00394-00101318-00101575": "you are deriving B but does it it", "TFppsw0H_7u-00395-00101576-00101764": "doesn't make any sense to we don't make", "TFppsw0H_7u-00396-00101765-00102208": "such kind of claims in in logic in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00397-00102209-00102379": "particular but although it is formally", "TFppsw0H_7u-00398-00102380-00102732": "valid and it follows an on but usually", "TFppsw0H_7u-00399-00102733-00102904": "you know that is that is not considered", "TFppsw0H_7u-00400-00102905-00103123": "to be a good argument two plus two is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00401-00103124-00103342": "equal four and moon is made up of ranges", "TFppsw0H_7u-00402-00103343-00103513": "hence moody's moon is made up of green", "TFppsw0H_7u-00403-00103514-00104017": "cheese from a and B B follows so the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00404-00104018-00104242": "next question that arises in our mind is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00405-00104243-00104722": "is that how these fallacies arises so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00406-00104723-00104875": "people are often more interested in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00407-00104876-00105067": "convincing rather than seeking the truth", "TFppsw0H_7u-00408-00105068-00105304": "of the matter so we might be impatient", "TFppsw0H_7u-00409-00105305-00105483": "or we might be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00410-00105484-00105673": "we want others to accept our claims and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00411-00105674-00105924": "all so somehow we want to convince", "TFppsw0H_7u-00412-00105925-00106098": "others you know you'll forget about", "TFppsw0H_7u-00413-00106099-00106302": "whatever whether the conclusion is true", "TFppsw0H_7u-00414-00106303-00106509": "or whether conclusion follows from the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00415-00106510-00106754": "premises or is there any support of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00416-00106755-00106974": "premises to the conclusion all these", "TFppsw0H_7u-00417-00106975-00107208": "things will set it aside and then we", "TFppsw0H_7u-00418-00107209-00107596": "will we will mix up these arguments with", "TFppsw0H_7u-00419-00107597-00107947": "lot of emotions etc at all so maybe", "TFppsw0H_7u-00420-00107948-00108106": "because of that this fallacies might", "TFppsw0H_7u-00421-00108107-00108547": "arise or otherwise we often find in the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00422-00108548-00108748": "argumentation these are the some of the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00423-00108749-00109104": "arguments that you will often find it in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00424-00109105-00109333": "the arguments of advertisers in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00425-00109333-00109733": "particular an advertising agency wants", "TFppsw0H_7u-00426-00109734-00109969": "its customers to buy some particular", "TFppsw0H_7u-00427-00109970-00110083": "kind of thing", "TFppsw0H_7u-00428-00110083-00110316": "I mean people to buy some particular", "TFppsw0H_7u-00429-00110317-00110683": "kind of item they will use some good", "TFppsw0H_7u-00430-00110683-00110956": "solid advertisements and all etc and all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00431-00110957-00111108": "advocates use it in the courts", "TFppsw0H_7u-00432-00111109-00111399": "politicians try to woo the customers who", "TFppsw0H_7u-00433-00111400-00111678": "the voters in particular so then they", "TFppsw0H_7u-00434-00111679-00111898": "might use these fallacies as a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00435-00111899-00112263": "persuasive mechanism a political point", "TFppsw0H_7u-00436-00112264-00112527": "pundits might use it in analyzing who is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00437-00112528-00112747": "going to I mean political points might", "TFppsw0H_7u-00438-00112748-00112996": "use it in some sense in a broad sense", "TFppsw0H_7u-00439-00112997-00113197": "fallacy is any argument that involves", "TFppsw0H_7u-00440-00113198-00113412": "some kind of faulty reasoning as far as", "TFppsw0H_7u-00441-00113413-00113877": "logic is concerned so they may be they", "TFppsw0H_7u-00442-00113878-00114060": "may follow a psychological they might be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00443-00114061-00114244": "psychologically relevant in all but as", "TFppsw0H_7u-00444-00114245-00114445": "far as logic is concerned they're", "TFppsw0H_7u-00445-00114446-00114718": "they're all they consider to be mistakes", "TFppsw0H_7u-00446-00114719-00114975": "in the argumentation so now let us go", "TFppsw0H_7u-00447-00114976-00115231": "into the details of formal fallacies", "TFppsw0H_7u-00448-00115232-00115368": "first and then we will move on to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00449-00115369-00115841": "informal fallacies a little bit later so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00450-00115842-00116190": "two commonly these are the two commonly", "TFppsw0H_7u-00451-00116191-00116583": "found kind of fallacies in in logic that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00452-00116584-00116932": "is when these rules are used in not in a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00453-00116933-00117201": "proper way then it leads to formal kind", "TFppsw0H_7u-00454-00117202-00117438": "of fallacies in all so these fallacies", "TFppsw0H_7u-00455-00117439-00117877": "are like this the first one is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00456-00117878-00118396": "a implies B and then B then if it leads", "TFppsw0H_7u-00457-00118397-00118659": "to a then there is a mistake in the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00458-00118660-00118828": "argumentation that I'll talk about it", "TFppsw0H_7u-00459-00118829-00119061": "later and the other one which you will", "TFppsw0H_7u-00460-00119063-00119431": "commonly find is a implies B and not a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00461-00119432-00119998": "and not B so this is called as fallacy", "TFppsw0H_7u-00462-00119999-00120820": "of affirming the consequent affirming", "TFppsw0H_7u-00463-00120821-00121348": "the consequent we will talk about some", "TFppsw0H_7u-00464-00121349-00121666": "examples related to both these things so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00465-00121667-00122508": "these are called as formal fallacies and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00466-00122508-00123016": "this is called as velocity which arises", "TFppsw0H_7u-00467-00123017-00123534": "because of denial of consequent denial", "TFppsw0H_7u-00468-00123535-00124474": "of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00469-00124475-00124943": "so these are all invalid forms obviously", "TFppsw0H_7u-00470-00124944-00125278": "they're invalid arguments so we said", "TFppsw0H_7u-00471-00125279-00125450": "that all invalid arguments are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00472-00125451-00125720": "automatically fallacious or not so now", "TFppsw0H_7u-00473-00125721-00125969": "why where is what is the valid form of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00474-00125970-00126188": "this one this is the one which we should", "TFppsw0H_7u-00475-00126189-00126403": "use an alpha a implies B is the case", "TFppsw0H_7u-00476-00126404-00126583": "this is a hypothetical situation and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00477-00126584-00126908": "then if a is indeed true then we can", "TFppsw0H_7u-00478-00126908-00127220": "infer that B follows from these two", "TFppsw0H_7u-00479-00127221-00127513": "things and the other the correct usage", "TFppsw0H_7u-00480-00127514-00128014": "of this one is this a implies B and you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00481-00128015-00128243": "deny the consequent and then you need to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00482-00128244-00128611": "deny the antecedent so first of all so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00483-00128613-00129184": "this is called as antecedent so this is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00484-00129185-00129398": "a conditional statement and it is called", "TFppsw0H_7u-00485-00129399-00129650": "as antecedent and B is called as a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00486-00129651-00130046": "consequent and then that makes this a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00487-00130047-00130213": "plus B some kind of hypothetical", "TFppsw0H_7u-00488-00130214-00130571": "statement if it rains the grass is wet", "TFppsw0H_7u-00489-00130572-00130786": "so if this is assumed to be true and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00490-00130788-00130970": "then B is also assumed to be true then", "TFppsw0H_7u-00491-00130971-00131340": "we need to see whether a is 2 or false", "TFppsw0H_7u-00492-00131341-00131675": "so the correct forms are these two", "TFppsw0H_7u-00493-00131676-00131972": "things but as you see here clearly", "TFppsw0H_7u-00494-00131973-00132287": "instead of using this valid form where", "TFppsw0H_7u-00495-00132288-00132473": "we have used invalid forms you know our", "TFppsw0H_7u-00496-00132474-00132794": "invalid forms are automatically invalid", "TFppsw0H_7u-00497-00132795-00132935": "arguments so that's why there are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00498-00132936-00133097": "fallacious you know it is pretty", "TFppsw0H_7u-00499-00133098-00133314": "straightforward and simple to identify", "TFppsw0H_7u-00500-00133315-00133625": "these kinds of fellows so formal", "TFppsw0H_7u-00501-00133626-00133919": "fallacies usually grouped into two kinds", "TFppsw0H_7u-00502-00133920-00134179": "of fallacies one is fallacy of affirming", "TFppsw0H_7u-00503-00134180-00134456": "the consequent instead of affirming the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00504-00134457-00134657": "antecedent you are affirming the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00505-00134658-00134924": "consequent no of course you might say", "TFppsw0H_7u-00506-00134925-00135272": "that in day to day argumentation we will", "TFppsw0H_7u-00507-00135273-00135557": "this seems to be some kind of valid", "TFppsw0H_7u-00508-00135558-00135806": "argument there is a kind of reasoning", "TFppsw0H_7u-00509-00135807-00136175": "which we did not discuss in this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00510-00136176-00136307": "particular kind of course we do not", "TFppsw0H_7u-00511-00136308-00136448": "discuss in this particular kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00512-00136449-00136634": "course so that kind of reasoning is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00513-00136635-00137089": "called as objective reasoning so this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00514-00137090-00137836": "objective reasoning so in that what we", "TFppsw0H_7u-00515-00137837-00138196": "will do is this that this kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00516-00138197-00138565": "principle n plus B and B and then from", "TFppsw0H_7u-00517-00138566-00138679": "that it seems to be the case that a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00518-00138680-00138857": "follows from its particular kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00519-00138858-00139099": "thing so these kinds of reasonings", "TFppsw0H_7u-00520-00139100-00139297": "reasoning is the one which we are not", "TFppsw0H_7u-00521-00139298-00139556": "going to talk about and objective", "TFppsw0H_7u-00522-00139557-00139786": "inferences are also called as inference", "TFppsw0H_7u-00523-00139787-00140144": "to the best explanation cinahl so it is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00524-00140145-00140546": "like for example detectives are doctors", "TFppsw0H_7u-00525-00140547-00140722": "who are diagnosing some kind of disease", "TFppsw0H_7u-00526-00140723-00140986": "they use this kind of reasoning in all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00527-00140987-00141221": "India today discourse so there of the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00528-00141222-00141484": "viewed I mean of course a detective is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00529-00141485-00141697": "trying to find out whether or not murder", "TFppsw0H_7u-00530-00141698-00141920": "took place etcetera in a certain place", "TFppsw0H_7u-00531-00141921-00142271": "except I not so you might find you will", "TFppsw0H_7u-00532-00142272-00142471": "just hypothetically state a particular", "TFppsw0H_7u-00533-00142472-00142796": "kind of statement a implies B if murder", "TFppsw0H_7u-00534-00142797-00142987": "took place then there would be some kind", "TFppsw0H_7u-00535-00142988-00143386": "of bloodstains etc so then detective", "TFppsw0H_7u-00536-00143387-00143657": "first you will find some kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00537-00143658-00143971": "bloodstains except trying on that will", "TFppsw0H_7u-00538-00143972-00144310": "make him infer that there was some some", "TFppsw0H_7u-00539-00144311-00144494": "kind of murder took place in that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00540-00144495-00144778": "particular kind of room in it seems to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00541-00144779-00145021": "be a little bit sensible in the actual", "TFppsw0H_7u-00542-00145022-00145357": "day-to-day situations in all but this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00543-00145358-00145646": "this kind of reasoning is a kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00544-00145647-00145810": "fallacious reasoning term as far as", "TFppsw0H_7u-00545-00145811-00146071": "logic is concerned since it is not used", "TFppsw0H_7u-00546-00146072-00146270": "in a valid form and all you can always", "TFppsw0H_7u-00547-00146271-00146539": "come up with a counter example in which", "TFppsw0H_7u-00548-00146540-00146989": "a implies B is true and B is true but a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00549-00146990-00147211": "can be false enough but in digital", "TFppsw0H_7u-00550-00147212-00147431": "discourse you might find some examples", "TFppsw0H_7u-00551-00147432-00147778": "where this seems to be convincing for", "TFppsw0H_7u-00552-00147779-00148031": "you a detective might use this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00553-00148032-00148244": "particular kind of thing you know he has", "TFppsw0H_7u-00554-00148245-00148435": "an eye pathetical situation aim plus B", "TFppsw0H_7u-00555-00148436-00148804": "and then B is indeed the case in all at", "TFppsw0H_7u-00556-00148805-00149011": "least you know that evidence confirms", "TFppsw0H_7u-00557-00149012-00149227": "that this is the case and then from this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00558-00149228-00149543": "you will explain that probably a might", "TFppsw0H_7u-00559-00149544-00149854": "be the best explanation for these two", "TFppsw0H_7u-00560-00149855-00150082": "things to be true with so this is called", "TFppsw0H_7u-00561-00150083-00150459": "as inference to the best expand", "TFppsw0H_7u-00562-00150460-00150743": "so this is one not what we are trying to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00563-00150744-00150973": "use here and on objective reasoning is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00564-00150974-00151118": "not the one which we are going to talk", "TFppsw0H_7u-00565-00151119-00151406": "about so but here so these are the two", "TFppsw0H_7u-00566-00151407-00151647": "fallacies in which you know logically", "TFppsw0H_7u-00567-00151648-00151939": "invalid forms in all so that's why they", "TFppsw0H_7u-00568-00151940-00152081": "are automatically invalid kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00569-00152082-00152434": "arguments but the correct forms of this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00570-00152435-00152814": "one is these things n plus B and a and B", "TFppsw0H_7u-00571-00152815-00153138": "follows this is called as modus ponens", "TFppsw0H_7u-00572-00153139-00153729": "rule and this is called as modus tollens", "TFppsw0H_7u-00573-00153730-00154015": "so these are somewhat Latin names in all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00574-00154016-00154288": "but usually it is represented as empty", "TFppsw0H_7u-00575-00154289-00154843": "and MP modus ponens and modus tollens so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00576-00154844-00155062": "so these are the correct forms these are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00577-00155063-00155270": "the incorrect form such as they are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00578-00155271-00155420": "invalid arguments are automatically", "TFppsw0H_7u-00579-00155421-00155776": "fallacious so now we can come up with", "TFppsw0H_7u-00580-00155777-00156095": "lots of examples for these particular", "TFppsw0H_7u-00581-00156096-00156313": "kind of arguments that are there on the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00582-00156314-00156859": "top of this thing so one example could", "TFppsw0H_7u-00583-00156860-00157444": "be if 2523 is divided divisible by nine", "TFppsw0H_7u-00584-00157445-00157793": "then it has to be divisible by three and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00585-00157794-00158029": "not so that is seems to be a little bit", "TFppsw0H_7u-00586-00158030-00158260": "acceptable to us in on anything divided", "TFppsw0H_7u-00587-00158261-00158404": "by nine it should be divided by three", "TFppsw0H_7u-00588-00158405-00158773": "also and then you are saying that 2523", "TFppsw0H_7u-00589-00158774-00159097": "is divisible by three so it also", "TFppsw0H_7u-00590-00159098-00159451": "happened that 2523 is divisible by three", "TFppsw0H_7u-00591-00159452-00160082": "so then it is also divisible by nine it", "TFppsw0H_7u-00592-00160083-00160300": "may not be the case that it may be may", "TFppsw0H_7u-00593-00160301-00160486": "not be divisible by nine and not the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00594-00160487-00160643": "better examples which you can take into", "TFppsw0H_7u-00595-00160644-00161006": "consideration so this is like fallacy of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00596-00161007-00161407": "affirming the consequent of consequent", "TFppsw0H_7u-00597-00161408-00161637": "at all so this comes under the category", "TFppsw0H_7u-00598-00161638-00162235": "two sorry first one so you are affirming", "TFppsw0H_7u-00599-00162236-00162478": "the consequent and then you are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00600-00162479-00162753": "affirming the antecedent in order here", "TFppsw0H_7u-00601-00162754-00162982": "the best example could be like this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00602-00162983-00163309": "suppose if you are in Kanpur then you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00603-00163310-00163396": "are in voter Pradesh", "TFppsw0H_7u-00604-00163397-00163565": "because Kanpur is in author position", "TFppsw0H_7u-00605-00163566-00163862": "you have to be know traditionally so if", "TFppsw0H_7u-00606-00163863-00164075": "I am in Uttar Pradesh so that is also", "TFppsw0H_7u-00607-00164076-00164423": "considered to be either case then it", "TFppsw0H_7u-00608-00164424-00164603": "follows that you are in Kanpur and all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00609-00164604-00164867": "you might be in any or any part of utter", "TFppsw0H_7u-00610-00164868-00165011": "position on but doesn't mean that you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00611-00165012-00165326": "are in Kanpur not the first one I am in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00612-00165327-00165554": "Kanpur is represented as a a minute", "TFppsw0H_7u-00613-00165555-00165818": "rapid s is represented as B and then I", "TFppsw0H_7u-00614-00165819-00166141": "am in Uttar Pradesh is represented as B", "TFppsw0H_7u-00615-00166142-00166355": "uniformly we represent it with the help", "TFppsw0H_7u-00616-00166356-00166676": "of some symbols then I am in Kanpur is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00617-00166677-00166934": "the one which is which follows from", "TFppsw0H_7u-00618-00166935-00167270": "these two one is the hypothetical", "TFppsw0H_7u-00619-00167271-00167597": "statement and the other one is I mean", "TFppsw0H_7u-00620-00167598-00167852": "just the statement that I am into the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00621-00167853-00167996": "police you know you might be no third", "TFppsw0H_7u-00622-00167997-00168206": "village but it might be in Agra or you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00623-00168207-00168383": "might be in some other part of the city", "TFppsw0H_7u-00624-00168384-00168743": "maybe some other place in all Borelli or", "TFppsw0H_7u-00625-00168744-00168884": "some other place not but you need not", "TFppsw0H_7u-00626-00168885-00169058": "have to be in Kanpur enough so that is a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00627-00169059-00169277": "single counter example which shows that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00628-00169278-00169604": "this argument doesn't follow and so all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00629-00169605-00169834": "the fallacious arguments are obviously", "TFppsw0H_7u-00630-00169835-00170093": "whether they're all invalid arguments", "TFppsw0H_7u-00631-00170094-00170363": "are automatically fallacious there are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00632-00170364-00170726": "formal fallacies in all so other", "TFppsw0H_7u-00633-00170727-00170930": "examples could be the same example can", "TFppsw0H_7u-00634-00170931-00171188": "be represented in different way if I am", "TFppsw0H_7u-00635-00171189-00171506": "in Kanpur than I am in Luther Pradesh so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00636-00171507-00171929": "I am NOT in Kanpur then you are not in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00637-00171930-00172349": "with the position of so that is the one", "TFppsw0H_7u-00638-00172350-00172532": "which follows from this particular kind", "TFppsw0H_7u-00639-00172533-00172697": "of thing are you can take another", "TFppsw0H_7u-00640-00172698-00173075": "example to establish this thing that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00641-00173076-00173258": "fallacy of denial of antecedent and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00642-00173259-00173534": "fallacies of affirming the consequent", "TFppsw0H_7u-00643-00173535-00173930": "leads to mistake in the argumentation so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00644-00173931-00174206": "they are all invalid arguments in all if", "TFppsw0H_7u-00645-00174207-00174377": "you get hit by a car when you are sick", "TFppsw0H_7u-00646-00174378-00174626": "in here at six then you will die in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00647-00174627-00174878": "obviously six anyone dies is Dianne", "TFppsw0H_7u-00648-00174879-00175088": "Goldie but you are not it by the car", "TFppsw0H_7u-00649-00175089-00175343": "when you are six that doesn't mean that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00650-00175344-00175544": "you know you will not die anga now maybe", "TFppsw0H_7u-00651-00175545-00175742": "the next year or maybe next incident you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00652-00175743-00176012": "might die and all so so you could be hit", "TFppsw0H_7u-00653-00176013-00176249": "by a truck at the age of seven or maybe", "TFppsw0H_7u-00654-00176250-00176459": "some other thing might happen you might", "TFppsw0H_7u-00655-00176460-00176657": "die out of disease or some incurable", "TFppsw0H_7u-00656-00176658-00176903": "disease or something like that so what", "TFppsw0H_7u-00657-00176904-00177275": "is important here is that invalid form", "TFppsw0H_7u-00658-00177276-00177518": "means an invalid argument and invalid", "TFppsw0H_7u-00659-00177519-00177719": "arguments are automatically fallacious", "TFppsw0H_7u-00660-00177720-00177934": "enough so when an argument is invalid", "TFppsw0H_7u-00661-00177935-00178259": "there is it's always be the case that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00662-00178260-00178531": "you know you can always come up with", "TFppsw0H_7u-00663-00178532-00178853": "premises true and a conclusion false", "TFppsw0H_7u-00664-00178854-00179213": "enough so it is possible that you know", "TFppsw0H_7u-00665-00179214-00179417": "you can come up with premises true and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00666-00179418-00179567": "the conclusion false that makes this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00667-00179568-00179810": "argument invalid enough for example if", "TFppsw0H_7u-00668-00179811-00180053": "you say grass is wet if it rains the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00669-00180054-00180392": "grass is wet so then then you are saying", "TFppsw0H_7u-00670-00180393-00180701": "that grass is wet enough so just because", "TFppsw0H_7u-00671-00180702-00180875": "the grass is wet doesn't mean that if", "TFppsw0H_7u-00672-00180876-00181061": "you infer that it rained and all and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00673-00181062-00181235": "there seems to be some mistakes in the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00674-00181236-00181379": "argumentation grass might be wet in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00675-00181380-00181622": "several other ways as well a sprinkler", "TFppsw0H_7u-00676-00181623-00181820": "might be on or maybe somebody threw", "TFppsw0H_7u-00677-00181821-00182186": "poured some water there except now there", "TFppsw0H_7u-00678-00182187-00182381": "is some leakage of water from tap some", "TFppsw0H_7u-00679-00182382-00182549": "somewhere exit and all these things", "TFppsw0H_7u-00680-00182550-00182792": "might be reasons for grass being right", "TFppsw0H_7u-00681-00182793-00183224": "now so these are some of the formal then", "TFppsw0H_7u-00682-00183225-00183488": "there's some problems with the form you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00683-00183489-00183749": "say of the form so that leads to the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00684-00183750-00183929": "mistake in the argumentation they're", "TFppsw0H_7u-00685-00183930-00184157": "pretty straightforward to identify all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00686-00184158-00184341": "the things which I mentioned it here are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00687-00184342-00184541": "will come under the category of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00688-00184542-00184775": "categorical syllogisms which I'm going", "TFppsw0H_7u-00689-00184776-00184903": "to talk about a little bit later", "TFppsw0H_7u-00690-00184904-00185174": "categorical syllogisms are special kind", "TFppsw0H_7u-00691-00185175-00185435": "of arguments in which it involves only", "TFppsw0H_7u-00692-00185436-00185702": "categorical propositions and categorical", "TFppsw0H_7u-00693-00185703-00185846": "propositions are just they're", "TFppsw0H_7u-00694-00185847-00186053": "propositions but they have a special", "TFppsw0H_7u-00695-00186054-00186227": "feature that all these propositions", "TFppsw0H_7u-00696-00186228-00186665": "begin with all know some exceptional", "TFppsw0H_7u-00697-00186666-00186926": "every all these things comes under the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00698-00186927-00187232": "category of categorical propositions for", "TFppsw0H_7u-00699-00187233-00187376": "example if you say all men are mortal", "TFppsw0H_7u-00700-00187377-00187490": "some men are mortal", "TFppsw0H_7u-00701-00187491-00187766": "all men are not mortal some men are not", "TFppsw0H_7u-00702-00187767-00187958": "mortal all these things are called as", "TFppsw0H_7u-00703-00187959-00188366": "categorical propositions so now the ones", "TFppsw0H_7u-00704-00188367-00188552": "which I have stated here all these", "TFppsw0H_7u-00705-00188553-00188795": "things are invalid arguments because it", "TFppsw0H_7u-00706-00188796-00189303": "has invalid form at all as I said", "TFppsw0H_7u-00707-00189304-00189532": "said in the counterexample method", "TFppsw0H_7u-00708-00189533-00189773": "whenever you have an invalid argument", "TFppsw0H_7u-00709-00189774-00190101": "suppose if you you start with some set", "TFppsw0H_7u-00710-00190102-00190435": "which has which has all the things that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00711-00190436-00190650": "you are out you obviously know that they", "TFppsw0H_7u-00712-00190651-00190807": "are true or false except right now for", "TFppsw0H_7u-00713-00190808-00190993": "example if you say all cats are dogs and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00714-00190994-00191175": "that statement is false and all anyone", "TFppsw0H_7u-00715-00191176-00191352": "would be able to believe that the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00716-00191353-00191482": "particular kind of thing is false you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00717-00191483-00191703": "know all cats are animals seems to be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00718-00191704-00191901": "acceptable to us that is true statement", "TFppsw0H_7u-00719-00191902-00192087": "in Rome so there are certain things", "TFppsw0H_7u-00720-00192088-00192297": "which are obvious to us which nobody", "TFppsw0H_7u-00721-00192298-00192612": "could deny and all so those things which", "TFppsw0H_7u-00722-00192613-00192745": "take into consideration and then", "TFppsw0H_7u-00723-00192746-00192966": "substitute it for ABCs except try and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00724-00192967-00193149": "all and see whether you could come up", "TFppsw0H_7u-00725-00193150-00193471": "with any counter instead counter example", "TFppsw0H_7u-00726-00193472-00193621": "and all that counter example in the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00727-00193622-00193918": "sense that you have true premises and a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00728-00193919-00194114": "false conclusion", "TFppsw0H_7u-00729-00194115-00194376": "suppose if you say all es are beasts all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00730-00194377-00194675": "seas are beasts so all es are seasonal", "TFppsw0H_7u-00731-00194676-00195070": "so the actual valid form is always are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00732-00195071-00195319": "bees all bees are seeds and all ears are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00733-00195320-00195561": "seeds but here it is not used in that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00734-00195562-00195774": "particular kind of form so that's why", "TFppsw0H_7u-00735-00195775-00196219": "this is considered to be an invalid form", "TFppsw0H_7u-00736-00196220-00196509": "so that's why these are called as finish", "TFppsw0H_7u-00737-00196510-00196872": "this argument so what seems to be the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00738-00196873-00197301": "valid arguments are this thing all is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00739-00197302-00197589": "are bees", "TFppsw0H_7u-00740-00197590-00197881": "this is bees can be anything or not they", "TFppsw0H_7u-00741-00197882-00198046": "can substitute for a and can substitute", "TFppsw0H_7u-00742-00198047-00198314": "for B donkey cat it doesn't matter all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00743-00198315-00199326": "bees are C's so then all C so this is a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00744-00199327-00199575": "kind of valid kind of argument at all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00745-00199576-00199791": "it's a valid form so that's why it is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00746-00199792-00200020": "called as a valid kind of argument we", "TFppsw0H_7u-00747-00200021-00200199": "might ask how do we know that this is a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00748-00200200-00200502": "valid argument except I know then for", "TFppsw0H_7u-00749-00200503-00200673": "the definition of validity is is that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00750-00200674-00200821": "the conclusion necessarily follows from", "TFppsw0H_7u-00751-00200822-00200995": "the premises in all that means you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00752-00200996-00201177": "cannot come up with a counter example in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00753-00201178-00201370": "which the premises are true and the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00754-00201371-00201522": "conclusion is false", "TFppsw0H_7u-00755-00201523-00201789": "whatever you substitute for a is b6 a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00756-00201790-00202089": "try and all BC is etc then if these two", "TFppsw0H_7u-00757-00202090-00202176": "are assumed to be true", "TFppsw0H_7u-00758-00202177-00202401": "then the second one at the whatever", "TFppsw0H_7u-00759-00202402-00202556": "follows up from this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00760-00202557-00202880": "two things should also be true enough so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00761-00202881-00203090": "the deductive arguments the truth", "TFppsw0H_7u-00762-00203091-00203231": "preserving conclusion necessarily", "TFppsw0H_7u-00763-00203232-00203444": "follows from the premises in all so the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00764-00203445-00203741": "one which we have used here are all s", "TFppsw0H_7u-00765-00203742-00204644": "are B's it is like all is peace somewhat", "TFppsw0H_7u-00766-00204645-00205277": "like all these are all CSUN what all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00767-00205278-00206591": "these are B's so all is ESS so if you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00768-00206592-00206738": "compare these two things this is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00769-00206739-00206948": "considered to be a valid form and this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00770-00206948-00207269": "is not an invalid form in on suppose if", "TFppsw0H_7u-00771-00207269-00207373": "you are not convinced with this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00772-00207375-00207554": "particular kind of thing that when I say", "TFppsw0H_7u-00773-00207555-00207701": "that this is an invalid form that's why", "TFppsw0H_7u-00774-00207702-00207887": "it is an invalid argument it's a valid", "TFppsw0H_7u-00775-00207888-00208094": "form and it is a valid argument then", "TFppsw0H_7u-00776-00208094-00208226": "there are certain things which you are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00777-00208227-00208415": "which we know that they are obviously", "TFppsw0H_7u-00778-00208416-00208682": "true obviously false etcetera so instead", "TFppsw0H_7u-00779-00208683-00208937": "of in this one you substitute a for cat", "TFppsw0H_7u-00780-00208938-00209221": "or B for animal or C for some kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00781-00209223-00209339": "rat or something like that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00782-00209340-00209525": "then you will see whether this follows", "TFppsw0H_7u-00783-00209526-00209900": "up so the example here is this that for", "TFppsw0H_7u-00784-00209901-00210173": "SV of take into consideration dogs that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00785-00210173-00210394": "is all dogs are animals which is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00786-00210396-00210608": "obviously the case in all a dog cannot", "TFppsw0H_7u-00787-00210609-00210881": "be some other thing in all a fish have", "TFppsw0H_7u-00788-00210882-00211048": "something like that so that is satis", "TFppsw0H_7u-00789-00211050-00211256": "that is satisfying the first statement", "TFppsw0H_7u-00790-00211257-00211550": "and all these are B's here C is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00791-00211551-00211991": "considered to be cats so all cats are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00792-00211992-00212354": "also animals so from that you infer that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00793-00212355-00212633": "all these are seized for example all yes", "TFppsw0H_7u-00794-00212634-00212894": "means a means dogs and all dogs or cats", "TFppsw0H_7u-00795-00212894-00213089": "suppose if you say that particular kind", "TFppsw0H_7u-00796-00213090-00213341": "of thing although the premises the first", "TFppsw0H_7u-00797-00213342-00213539": "two premises are true that is all dogs", "TFppsw0H_7u-00798-00213540-00213703": "are animals all cats are also animals", "TFppsw0H_7u-00799-00213704-00214034": "but it if you infer that all dogs are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00800-00214035-00214433": "cats then that the conclusion is false", "TFppsw0H_7u-00801-00214434-00214658": "given the premises are true in all that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00802-00214659-00214892": "means you could easily come up with some", "TFppsw0H_7u-00803-00214892-00215084": "kind of counter example for that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00804-00215085-00215240": "particularly the counter example is is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00805-00215241-00215513": "that you come up with with the true", "TFppsw0H_7u-00806-00215514-00215678": "premises you come up with a false", "TFppsw0H_7u-00807-00215679-00215896": "conclusion all dogs are cats", "TFppsw0H_7u-00808-00215896-00216226": "cyclists all of us will be easy it will", "TFppsw0H_7u-00809-00216227-00216396": "be easy to say that all cats and dogs is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00810-00216398-00216691": "obviously false so like this whenever", "TFppsw0H_7u-00811-00216692-00216927": "you come across an invalid form you can", "TFppsw0H_7u-00812-00216928-00217071": "always come up with a counter instance", "TFppsw0H_7u-00813-00217073-00217260": "where your true premises and a false", "TFppsw0H_7u-00814-00217261-00217509": "conclusion that makes that argument in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00815-00217510-00217746": "well invalid arguments are automatically", "TFppsw0H_7u-00816-00217748-00218004": "fallacious by virtue of the form itself", "TFppsw0H_7u-00817-00218005-00218275": "because it we used an invalid form so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00818-00218276-00218673": "that say these arguments are invalid so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00819-00218675-00218934": "like this we can come across the valid", "TFppsw0H_7u-00820-00218935-00219190": "form is that one this is our valid form", "TFppsw0H_7u-00821-00219191-00219330": "and all we have used in two different", "TFppsw0H_7u-00822-00219331-00219640": "ways in all so that's why it's invalid", "TFppsw0H_7u-00823-00219641-00219801": "from their site is invalid it now", "TFppsw0H_7u-00824-00219802-00220421": "all s are B's no cz and no C is B so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00825-00220423-00220692": "whether this particular kind of argument", "TFppsw0H_7u-00826-00220694-00220971": "is valid or invalid and again you know", "TFppsw0H_7u-00827-00220973-00221119": "there are certain things which are quite", "TFppsw0H_7u-00828-00221119-00221488": "obvious to us you substitute a for cat", "TFppsw0H_7u-00829-00221489-00221973": "and B for animal and C for dog and then", "TFppsw0H_7u-00830-00221975-00222279": "see what happens here so all these are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00831-00222280-00222544": "B's instead of all every they're all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00832-00222544-00222796": "same enough one of the same so you say", "TFppsw0H_7u-00833-00222796-00223134": "all in every cat is an animal as good as", "TFppsw0H_7u-00834-00223135-00223377": "saying the same thing all cats are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00835-00223378-00223581": "animals so there is the first", "TFppsw0H_7u-00836-00223582-00223825": "preposition and the second one is no C", "TFppsw0H_7u-00837-00223826-00224205": "is a that means no dog is a cat dog can", "TFppsw0H_7u-00838-00224206-00224382": "be different from the cat and all so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00839-00224383-00224563": "that satisfies the second preposition in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00840-00224564-00224904": "the this thing and then from that no C", "TFppsw0H_7u-00841-00224905-00225262": "is B that is no dog is an animal so you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00842-00225263-00225534": "you could easily come up with a counter", "TFppsw0H_7u-00843-00225535-00225810": "example where the premises every cat is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00844-00225811-00226075": "an animal is true no cat no dog is a cat", "TFppsw0H_7u-00845-00226076-00226426": "is also true but the conclusion no dog", "TFppsw0H_7u-00846-00226427-00226791": "is an animal is false so like this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00847-00226792-00227050": "whenever you have an invalid argument I", "TFppsw0H_7u-00848-00227051-00227160": "don't want to go into the details of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00849-00227161-00227354": "other arguments and all they're all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00850-00227355-00227716": "invalid forms and all invalid arguments", "TFppsw0H_7u-00851-00227717-00227890": "and hence they're invalid arguments and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00852-00227891-00228094": "whenever you come across an invalid", "TFppsw0H_7u-00853-00228094-00228276": "argument you can substitute these", "TFppsw0H_7u-00854-00228277-00228579": "instances etcetera instead of for es B's", "TFppsw0H_7u-00855-00228580-00228810": "C's etc and all your substitute dogs", "TFppsw0H_7u-00856-00228811-00228964": "cats animal except around without", "TFppsw0H_7u-00857-00228965-00229181": "disturbing the truth value of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00858-00229182-00229396": "the prepositions and see whether he", "TFppsw0H_7u-00859-00229398-00229598": "could come across with a counterexample", "TFppsw0H_7u-00860-00229598-00229886": "I mean the car you could come across", "TFppsw0H_7u-00861-00229887-00230105": "with a false conclusion true premises", "TFppsw0H_7u-00862-00230106-00230303": "should not lead to false conclusion now", "TFppsw0H_7u-00863-00230304-00230633": "a valid deductive argument is one in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00864-00230634-00230831": "which it is impossible for the temper", "TFppsw0H_7u-00865-00230832-00231017": "amesys to be true and the conclusion is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00866-00231017-00231173": "false even if we could come up with a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00867-00231173-00231413": "single instance where your premises are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00868-00231414-00231635": "true and the conclusion is false then", "TFppsw0H_7u-00869-00231636-00231796": "that particular kind of argument is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00870-00231798-00232277": "invalid so far we have seen that you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00871-00232278-00232546": "know arguments are invalid just because", "TFppsw0H_7u-00872-00232548-00232805": "of the fact that you know there they are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00873-00232806-00233123": "having invalid forms you know a life is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00874-00233123-00233510": "not that simple and on so we need to we", "TFppsw0H_7u-00875-00233511-00233663": "need to analyze the content of the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00876-00233664-00233888": "argument to see whether there is any", "TFppsw0H_7u-00877-00233889-00234116": "mistake in the argumentation at all so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00878-00234117-00234281": "these kinds of fallacies are called as", "TFppsw0H_7u-00879-00234282-00234592": "fallacies of relevance sorry fellows is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00880-00234594-00234911": "informal fallacies and one particular", "TFppsw0H_7u-00881-00234912-00235219": "kind of fallacy which arises very", "TFppsw0H_7u-00882-00235221-00235348": "frequently in Detroit discourse", "TFppsw0H_7u-00883-00235350-00235637": "especially when to arguers are engaged", "TFppsw0H_7u-00884-00235638-00236071": "in some kind of debate or when when", "TFppsw0H_7u-00885-00236073-00236288": "arguer presents some kind of thing to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00886-00236289-00236494": "convince the reader or listener you will", "TFppsw0H_7u-00887-00236496-00236669": "find these kinds of fallacies which", "TFppsw0H_7u-00888-00236669-00236909": "arises out of the problem of relevance", "TFppsw0H_7u-00889-00236910-00237137": "you know I will talk about what we mean", "TFppsw0H_7u-00890-00237138-00237517": "by relevance X at a little bit later but", "TFppsw0H_7u-00891-00237517-00237910": "so this fallacies fallacies of relevance", "TFppsw0H_7u-00892-00237911-00238169": "arises in involve the use of premises", "TFppsw0H_7u-00893-00238169-00238415": "that are logically irrelevant to their", "TFppsw0H_7u-00894-00238416-00238669": "conclusion for an argument the basic", "TFppsw0H_7u-00895-00238671-00238811": "structure is is that you have a premise", "TFppsw0H_7u-00896-00238812-00239030": "and then premise should lead to premise", "TFppsw0H_7u-00897-00239031-00239198": "two to how some provide some kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00898-00239198-00239477": "adequate support to believe that your", "TFppsw0H_7u-00899-00239478-00239690": "conclusion to be true in home but it", "TFppsw0H_7u-00900-00239691-00239848": "doesn't provide any adequate reasons to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00901-00239850-00239996": "believe the conclusion to be true then", "TFppsw0H_7u-00902-00239996-00240319": "there seems to be some kind of problem", "TFppsw0H_7u-00903-00240319-00240598": "here the problem arises because the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00904-00240600-00240803": "premises are not logically relevant to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00905-00240804-00241042": "their conclusions in all there are some", "TFppsw0H_7u-00906-00241044-00241259": "other relevant factors which comes into", "TFppsw0H_7u-00907-00241260-00241544": "picture enough so these relevant factors", "TFppsw0H_7u-00908-00241544-00241739": "may be psychologically relevant factors", "TFppsw0H_7u-00909-00241740-00242038": "you know it might be PT it might be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00910-00242039-00242331": "anger infestation all these things are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00911-00242332-00242508": "psychologically relevant factors you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00912-00242509-00242754": "know sometimes we do you we do take into", "TFppsw0H_7u-00913-00242755-00242982": "consideration all these factors and", "TFppsw0H_7u-00914-00242983-00243153": "sometimes the argument may be a good", "TFppsw0H_7u-00915-00243154-00243439": "argument as well sometimes we invoke", "TFppsw0H_7u-00916-00243440-00243609": "some kind of patriotism and then we will", "TFppsw0H_7u-00917-00243610-00243822": "infer some kind of thing but it that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00918-00243823-00244032": "argument may be may be convincing for", "TFppsw0H_7u-00919-00244033-00244182": "all of us but it might turn out to be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00920-00244183-00244581": "fallacious for us so here the most", "TFppsw0H_7u-00921-00244582-00244789": "important feature that you need to look", "TFppsw0H_7u-00922-00244790-00244953": "for exist that are the logically", "TFppsw0H_7u-00923-00244954-00245127": "relevant or psychologically relevant at", "TFppsw0H_7u-00924-00245128-00245451": "all I'm not saying that psychological", "TFppsw0H_7u-00925-00245452-00245628": "reasons are not important or useless", "TFppsw0H_7u-00926-00245629-00245889": "except I know as far as logical", "TFppsw0H_7u-00927-00245890-00246285": "reasoning is concerned as far as", "TFppsw0H_7u-00928-00246286-00246447": "possible a good argument should be free", "TFppsw0H_7u-00929-00246448-00246744": "from all these psychological", "TFppsw0H_7u-00930-00246744-00246937": "psychologically relevant factors you", "TFppsw0H_7u-00931-00246938-00247251": "know but in day to day discourse we do", "TFppsw0H_7u-00932-00247252-00247527": "take into consideration these particular", "TFppsw0H_7u-00933-00247528-00247899": "kind of factors etcetera psychological", "TFppsw0H_7u-00934-00247900-00248217": "reasons so this here is a list of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00935-00248217-00248446": "fallacies which come under the category", "TFppsw0H_7u-00936-00248446-00248769": "of fallacies of relevance you should", "TFppsw0H_7u-00937-00248771-00248952": "note that you know there is no way in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00938-00248953-00249096": "which you can classify these fallacies", "TFppsw0H_7u-00939-00249098-00249297": "into one group or another group and all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00940-00249298-00249519": "different text text books have different", "TFppsw0H_7u-00941-00249519-00249766": "classifications and all so the book that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00942-00249767-00250039": "we are following is concise introduction", "TFppsw0H_7u-00943-00250040-00250284": "to logic by Patrick Hurley it seems that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00944-00250285-00250425": "you know these things are classified in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00945-00250426-00250642": "a very nice way and all in this book so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00946-00250642-00250806": "we are referring to that particular book", "TFppsw0H_7u-00947-00250807-00251065": "in which you know things are classified", "TFppsw0H_7u-00948-00251066-00251328": "in a very nice way so we believe that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00949-00251329-00251559": "this this is a very good kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00950-00251560-00251796": "classification and also we follow this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00951-00251798-00252060": "particular kind of thing so what are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00952-00252061-00252234": "fallacies of relevance there are", "TFppsw0H_7u-00953-00252235-00252490": "different names and also mostly you know", "TFppsw0H_7u-00954-00252491-00252646": "these kinds of fallacies are already", "TFppsw0H_7u-00955-00252646-00252862": "there right from antiquity and what that", "TFppsw0H_7u-00956-00252863-00253026": "means right from the Greeks period", "TFppsw0H_7u-00957-00253027-00253292": "onwards you will find you might have", "TFppsw0H_7u-00958-00253294-00253596": "come across from Greek period onwards", "TFppsw0H_7u-00959-00253598-00254031": "these fallacies exist and these exist", "TFppsw0H_7u-00960-00254032-00254389": "even in day today is even now also so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00961-00254390-00254754": "the first one is appealed to force this", "TFppsw0H_7u-00962-00254755-00254985": "also called as argumentum ad baculum the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00963-00254986-00255098": "latin names", "TFppsw0H_7u-00964-00255100-00255486": "and the second one is instead of arguing", "TFppsw0H_7u-00965-00255487-00255930": "the argues argument you'll attack him in", "TFppsw0H_7u-00966-00255931-00256230": "in person so ad hominem argument when", "TFppsw0H_7u-00967-00256231-00256455": "you invoke pity leads to appeal to pity", "TFppsw0H_7u-00968-00256456-00256656": "kind of fallacy the other kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00969-00256657-00256764": "fallacy which you will commonly come", "TFppsw0H_7u-00970-00256765-00257031": "across is appeal to people and fallacy", "TFppsw0H_7u-00971-00257032-00257192": "of accident missing the point", "TFppsw0H_7u-00972-00257194-00257394": "straw man fallacy and red herring", "TFppsw0H_7u-00973-00257394-00257765": "fallacy in all these fallacies what is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00974-00257766-00257996": "what is the problem is is that the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00975-00257998-00258165": "premises are not logically relevant to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00976-00258166-00258414": "the conclusion but premises may be", "TFppsw0H_7u-00977-00258415-00258540": "psychologically relevant to the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00978-00258541-00258942": "conclusions so let us look into each one", "TFppsw0H_7u-00979-00258942-00259434": "of these fallacies in some detail some", "TFppsw0H_7u-00980-00259435-00259860": "greater detail in the first one is a", "TFppsw0H_7u-00981-00259861-00260085": "simple kind of fallacy which which is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00982-00260086-00260451": "called as appeal to force appeal to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00983-00260452-00260727": "force are it is called as ad baculum", "TFppsw0H_7u-00984-00260728-00260967": "fallacy which occurs when a conclusion", "TFppsw0H_7u-00985-00260967-00261410": "is defended by some kind of threat to", "TFppsw0H_7u-00986-00261411-00261639": "the well-being of those who do not", "TFppsw0H_7u-00987-00261640-00261755": "accept it", "TFppsw0H_7u-00988-00261756-00262044": "so this threat can be sometimes explicit", "TFppsw0H_7u-00989-00262044-00262416": "sometimes it can be even implicit in all", "TFppsw0H_7u-00990-00262417-00262776": "so this argument has this particular", "TFppsw0H_7u-00991-00262777-00263103": "kind of structure so you can draw the", "TFppsw0H_7u-00992-00263104-00263345": "diagram for this particular kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-00993-00263346-00263583": "fallacy then you will come to know very", "TFppsw0H_7u-00994-00263584-00263838": "lies who is who seem to have committed", "TFppsw0H_7u-00995-00263839-00264384": "this particular kind of fallacy so now", "TFppsw0H_7u-00996-00264385-00264741": "here is the now and arguer he is", "TFppsw0H_7u-00997-00264742-00264993": "presenting some kind of argument now so", "TFppsw0H_7u-00998-00264994-00265338": "this is what is called as appeal to feel", "TFppsw0H_7u-00999-00265339-00265766": "to force", "TFppsw0H_7u-01000-00265767-00266291": "so what he does is series your reader or", "TFppsw0H_7u-01001-00266292-00266707": "listener R stands for reader or", "TFppsw0H_7u-01002-00266708-00267167": "sometimes it can be listeners also that", "TFppsw0H_7u-01003-00267168-00267338": "means you are reading a text or you are", "TFppsw0H_7u-01004-00267339-00267574": "listening to someone's argument enough", "TFppsw0H_7u-01005-00267575-00268018": "so now these arrows are important so a", "TFppsw0H_7u-01006-00268019-00268622": "threatens a threatens reader or listener", "TFppsw0H_7u-01007-00268623-00268984": "and he poses this particular kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-01008-00268985-00269782": "conclusion so he threatens reader and", "TFppsw0H_7u-01009-00269783-00270010": "listener and all and he poses a", "TFppsw0H_7u-01010-00270011-00270250": "conclusion ultimately his purpose is is", "TFppsw0H_7u-01011-00270251-00270467": "that he wants the reader or listener to", "TFppsw0H_7u-01012-00270468-00270737": "accept his claims in on so in the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01013-00270738-00270899": "process you know you might do it in", "TFppsw0H_7u-01014-00270900-00271148": "several ways and on to persuade the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01015-00271149-00271303": "reader or listener to accept his claims", "TFppsw0H_7u-01016-00271304-00271552": "in all so one way which he does in this", "TFppsw0H_7u-01017-00271553-00271801": "case is that he threatens the reader or", "TFppsw0H_7u-01018-00271802-00272050": "listener if you don't accept whatever he", "TFppsw0H_7u-01019-00272051-00272284": "says to be true in all then he will say", "TFppsw0H_7u-01020-00272285-00272407": "that there is some kind of consequence", "TFppsw0H_7u-01021-00272408-00272875": "which follows him so this particular", "TFppsw0H_7u-01022-00272876-00273199": "kind of thing is called as appeal to", "TFppsw0H_7u-01023-00273200-00273491": "force kind of fallacy you know so", "TFppsw0H_7u-01024-00273492-00273709": "basically this threatening can be some", "TFppsw0H_7u-01025-00273710-00273949": "kind of physical threat you'll directly", "TFppsw0H_7u-01026-00273950-00274051": "say that I'm going to beat you or", "TFppsw0H_7u-01027-00274052-00274345": "something like that or he might say that", "TFppsw0H_7u-01028-00274346-00274592": "some kind even pose some kind of mental", "TFppsw0H_7u-01029-00274593-00274801": "threaten you will invoke some kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-01030-00274802-00275024": "fear in you you might say that you leak", "TFppsw0H_7u-01031-00275025-00275254": "your information except right so this", "TFppsw0H_7u-01032-00275255-00275428": "kind of thing is called as appeal to", "TFppsw0H_7u-01033-00275429-00275674": "force in all here what you'll see here", "TFppsw0H_7u-01034-00275675-00276031": "is that the premises may not be relevant", "TFppsw0H_7u-01035-00276032-00276314": "to the conclusion at all so since he has", "TFppsw0H_7u-01036-00276315-00276539": "incorporated threatened threatening into", "TFppsw0H_7u-01037-00276540-00276773": "picture and all so they're all maybe", "TFppsw0H_7u-01038-00276774-00276949": "psychological factors except ion", "TFppsw0H_7u-01039-00276950-00277105": "sometimes he might use it for the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01040-00277106-00277397": "well-being of the reader or listener or", "TFppsw0H_7u-01041-00277398-00277766": "a person who is target is trying to", "TFppsw0H_7u-01042-00277767-00278213": "pursue it but not in all the cases it", "TFppsw0H_7u-01043-00278214-00278533": "might be used for the well-being of a", "TFppsw0H_7u-01044-00278534-00278846": "reader or listener at all so the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01045-00278847-00279059": "structure of this argument is is that", "TFppsw0H_7u-01046-00279060-00279209": "of course these are premises and", "TFppsw0H_7u-01047-00279210-00279476": "conclusions premises could be this you", "TFppsw0H_7u-01048-00279477-00279809": "can avoid harm by accepting this", "TFppsw0H_7u-01049-00279810-00280049": "particular kind of statement ago so", "TFppsw0H_7u-01050-00280050-00280331": "that's why this statement is true so", "TFppsw0H_7u-01051-00280332-00280682": "what he says is is that he threatens the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01052-00280683-00280835": "reader of Lisner why he threatens the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01053-00280836-00281108": "reader or listener he says that you're", "TFppsw0H_7u-01054-00281109-00281381": "going to avoid some kind of harm exit", "TFppsw0H_7u-01055-00281382-00281615": "right now if you don't do this thing you", "TFppsw0H_7u-01056-00281616-00281810": "will have to face the music and also you", "TFppsw0H_7u-01057-00281811-00282125": "have to attract some kind of fine or it", "TFppsw0H_7u-01058-00282126-00282319": "may be will be punished takes a triangle", "TFppsw0H_7u-01059-00282320-00282557": "so this is the one which we commonly", "TFppsw0H_7u-01060-00282558-00282869": "come across India today discourse also", "TFppsw0H_7u-01061-00282870-00283325": "so where what the argue is trying to do", "TFppsw0H_7u-01062-00283326-00283535": "is is that you can avoid harm by", "TFppsw0H_7u-01063-00283536-00283664": "accepting this particular kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-01064-00283665-00283832": "statement at all so what is the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01065-00283833-00284030": "statement that he wants his reader or", "TFppsw0H_7u-01066-00284031-00284288": "listener to accept a noun that is a", "TFppsw0H_7u-01067-00284289-00284429": "conclusion he's posing some kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-01068-00284430-00284651": "conclusion if you don't accept the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01069-00284652-00284918": "conclusion then he says that this", "TFppsw0H_7u-01070-00284919-00285068": "somehow is going to happen to that", "TFppsw0H_7u-01071-00285069-00285332": "particular kind of us so out of fear the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01072-00285333-00285524": "reader or listener might accept his", "TFppsw0H_7u-01073-00285525-00285836": "claim in all but here the premises are", "TFppsw0H_7u-01074-00285837-00286118": "nothing to do with the conclusion in all", "TFppsw0H_7u-01075-00286119-00286367": "so only threat is what is making him to", "TFppsw0H_7u-01076-00286368-00286739": "believe the conclusion to be true so", "TFppsw0H_7u-01077-00286740-00286889": "some examples which you take into", "TFppsw0H_7u-01078-00286890-00287108": "consideration and then we will see we", "TFppsw0H_7u-01079-00287109-00287330": "will understand this kind of fallacy in", "TFppsw0H_7u-01080-00287331-00287873": "greater detail now here the argue it's", "TFppsw0H_7u-01081-00287874-00287999": "threatening the reader or listener and", "TFppsw0H_7u-01082-00288000-00288248": "then ultimately what the intention of an", "TFppsw0H_7u-01083-00288249-00288470": "argue is is that reader or listener", "TFppsw0H_7u-01084-00288471-00288739": "accept whatever the conclusion that is", "TFppsw0H_7u-01085-00288740-00289019": "making you know he has to accept this", "TFppsw0H_7u-01086-00289020-00289181": "particular kind of statement which is", "TFppsw0H_7u-01087-00289182-00289412": "there in the conclusion so now who is", "TFppsw0H_7u-01088-00289413-00289667": "said to have committed the mistake in", "TFppsw0H_7u-01089-00289668-00289924": "the argumentation a is said to have", "TFppsw0H_7u-01090-00289925-00290607": "committed this fallacy", "TFppsw0H_7u-01091-00290608-00290833": "if somebody presents this particular", "TFppsw0H_7u-01092-00290834-00291014": "kind of argument and all then we should", "TFppsw0H_7u-01093-00291015-00291212": "be in immediately in a position to say", "TFppsw0H_7u-01094-00291213-00291515": "that since a has used threatening and", "TFppsw0H_7u-01095-00291516-00291721": "all kinds of things in all that should", "TFppsw0H_7u-01096-00291722-00292013": "not be relevant to believing this", "TFppsw0H_7u-01097-00292014-00292345": "particular kind of statement in so some", "TFppsw0H_7u-01098-00292346-00292570": "examples which we will see in greater", "TFppsw0H_7u-01099-00292571-00292798": "detail so this is a remanent reminiscent", "TFppsw0H_7u-01100-00292799-00292996": "of scenes in films about organized crime", "TFppsw0H_7u-01101-00292997-00293356": "etcetera children arguing with parents", "TFppsw0H_7u-01102-00293357-00293578": "are children arguing with each other", "TFppsw0H_7u-01103-00293579-00293809": "Exeter not with the parents one example", "TFppsw0H_7u-01104-00293810-00294193": "is like this mr. Salim you helped us", "TFppsw0H_7u-01105-00294194-00294349": "import the drugs", "TFppsw0H_7u-01106-00294350-00294535": "somebody's arguing like this somebody is", "TFppsw0H_7u-01107-00294536-00294839": "threatening salim out here for this the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01108-00294840-00295067": "boss is obviously grateful and all but", "TFppsw0H_7u-01109-00295068-00295375": "now you say you are entitled to 45% of", "TFppsw0H_7u-01110-00295376-00295616": "the profits in all so now you started", "TFppsw0H_7u-01111-00295617-00295909": "claiming a share and all now boss is", "TFppsw0H_7u-01112-00295910-00296050": "very angry on this particular kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-01113-00296051-00296182": "thing the boss says that you are", "TFppsw0H_7u-01114-00296183-00296465": "entitled to only 10% in your claiming", "TFppsw0H_7u-01115-00296466-00296692": "excessive or not although you helped us", "TFppsw0H_7u-01116-00296693-00296915": "in importing some illegal drugs etc and", "TFppsw0H_7u-01117-00296916-00297116": "all okay that's fine well and good and", "TFppsw0H_7u-01118-00297117-00297379": "all but now you are asking you deserve", "TFppsw0H_7u-01119-00297380-00297730": "only 10% but you're asking 45% in so", "TFppsw0H_7u-01120-00297731-00298000": "your boss is very angry etc this is what", "TFppsw0H_7u-01121-00298001-00298251": "you see in the organized crime in all so", "TFppsw0H_7u-01122-00298252-00298487": "the next statement is unless you see", "TFppsw0H_7u-01123-00298488-00298750": "things in boss way that means you're not", "TFppsw0H_7u-01124-00298751-00298993": "under if you don't listen to what the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01125-00298994-00299237": "boss is trying to say that is you be", "TFppsw0H_7u-01126-00299238-00299698": "happy with only 10% of the share etc so", "TFppsw0H_7u-01127-00299699-00299851": "that is what is unless you see the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01128-00299852-00300145": "things in boss way you're going to have", "TFppsw0H_7u-01129-00300146-00300298": "a very nasty kind of accidently more", "TFppsw0H_7u-01130-00300299-00300508": "boss might kill you or we might do", "TFppsw0H_7u-01131-00300509-00300670": "something or other some kind of harm is", "TFppsw0H_7u-01132-00300671-00300934": "going to happen to you a middle kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-01133-00300935-00301115": "some broker kind of person he's trying", "TFppsw0H_7u-01134-00301116-00301456": "to convince the reader or listener but", "TFppsw0H_7u-01135-00301457-00301630": "you know if you accept you know whatever", "TFppsw0H_7u-01136-00301631-00301846": "boss says that he's he's happy with the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01137-00301847-00302131": "10% in all no threat is going to happen", "TFppsw0H_7u-01138-00302132-00302465": "to him otherwise he's going to face some", "TFppsw0H_7u-01139-00302466-00302767": "kind of nasty accident you will come", "TFppsw0H_7u-01140-00302768-00302935": "across some kind of nasty accident about", "TFppsw0H_7u-01141-00302936-00303346": "so you are entitled to 10% only Sultan", "TFppsw0H_7u-01142-00303347-00303566": "Utley saying you got my point or not you", "TFppsw0H_7u-01143-00303567-00303706": "don't get my point you are going to be", "TFppsw0H_7u-01144-00303707-00303788": "punished in all", "TFppsw0H_7u-01145-00303789-00304159": "so so what is happening here is that", "TFppsw0H_7u-01146-00304160-00304496": "there is some kind of arguer here he's", "TFppsw0H_7u-01147-00304497-00304859": "arguing with salomina so salim here is a", "TFppsw0H_7u-01148-00304860-00305125": "reader or listener the arguer is someone", "TFppsw0H_7u-01149-00305126-00305503": "arguing in favor of in favor of is Boss", "TFppsw0H_7u-01150-00305504-00305861": "Big Boss down or something like that so", "TFppsw0H_7u-01151-00305862-00306035": "who is said to have committed a mistake", "TFppsw0H_7u-01152-00306036-00306416": "that argued who is arguing for this for", "TFppsw0H_7u-01153-00306417-00306638": "the boss you know who so is arguing that", "TFppsw0H_7u-01154-00306639-00306983": "you deserve only 10% etc so he seems to", "TFppsw0H_7u-01155-00306984-00307178": "be committing this particular kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-01156-00307179-00307391": "fallacy why he has committed felony", "TFppsw0H_7u-01157-00307392-00307685": "because all these things are not", "TFppsw0H_7u-01158-00307686-00307952": "relevant for this particular kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-01159-00307953-00308207": "thing that you know that whatever is", "TFppsw0H_7u-01160-00308208-00308351": "claiming that is forty-five percent", "TFppsw0H_7u-01161-00308352-00308896": "profit SEC cetera and all so instead of", "TFppsw0H_7u-01162-00308897-00309182": "here the all the relevant things are", "TFppsw0H_7u-01163-00309183-00309512": "like this that you know the broker who", "TFppsw0H_7u-01164-00309513-00309743": "is arguing in favor of the arguer is", "TFppsw0H_7u-01165-00309744-00309941": "trying to threaten the threatened salim", "TFppsw0H_7u-01166-00309942-00310187": "here so he's saying that you know", "TFppsw0H_7u-01167-00310188-00310363": "understand till you I accept bosses", "TFppsw0H_7u-01168-00310364-00310562": "whatever boss is saying then you are", "TFppsw0H_7u-01169-00310563-00310774": "going to invite some kind of problems in", "TFppsw0H_7u-01170-00310775-00311084": "so here the first one is that the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01171-00311085-00311338": "threatened nasty incident has no logical", "TFppsw0H_7u-01172-00311339-00311654": "relevance on the conclusion that Salim", "TFppsw0H_7u-01173-00311655-00311816": "is entitled to only ten percent in all", "TFppsw0H_7u-01174-00311817-00311987": "there's nothing to do with this", "TFppsw0H_7u-01175-00311988-00312107": "particular kind of thing we are only", "TFppsw0H_7u-01176-00312108-00312323": "psychologically or relevant to this", "TFppsw0H_7u-01177-00312324-00312629": "particular Canon but it this is used as", "TFppsw0H_7u-01178-00312630-00312833": "some kind of persuasive mechanism you", "TFppsw0H_7u-01179-00312834-00313313": "know if you're this can still be used as", "TFppsw0H_7u-01180-00313314-00313487": "some kind of persuasive mechanism in all", "TFppsw0H_7u-01181-00313488-00313784": "a broker who is arguing for some kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-01182-00313785-00314042": "boss and all that in ultimately is", "TFppsw0H_7u-01183-00314043-00314225": "trying to negotiate with Salim that you", "TFppsw0H_7u-01184-00314226-00314384": "know it is also need ten percent rather", "TFppsw0H_7u-01185-00314385-00314576": "than forty five positive if he claims", "TFppsw0H_7u-01186-00314577-00314807": "forty five percent then the broker is", "TFppsw0H_7u-01187-00314808-00315020": "saying that you know you Latura you will", "TFppsw0H_7u-01188-00315021-00315245": "face some kind of problems except right", "TFppsw0H_7u-01189-00315246-00315491": "now it's trying to negotiate or persuade", "TFppsw0H_7u-01190-00315492-00315749": "the reader or listener by invoking some", "TFppsw0H_7u-01191-00315750-00316118": "kind of threat so suppose in this case", "TFppsw0H_7u-01192-00316119-00316283": "the arguer is said to have committed", "TFppsw0H_7u-01193-00316284-00316445": "this particular kind of fallacy this", "TFppsw0H_7u-01194-00316446-00316601": "particular kind of fallacy is called as", "TFppsw0H_7u-01195-00316602-00317003": "appeal to force kind of fallacy so the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01196-00317004-00317105": "persuasion is", "TFppsw0H_7u-01197-00317106-00317327": "you can avoid harm by accepting this", "TFppsw0H_7u-01198-00317328-00317573": "this statement this statement is is that", "TFppsw0H_7u-01199-00317574-00317890": "you know you deserve only 10% you know", "TFppsw0H_7u-01200-00317891-00318251": "so his statements are based on threat so", "TFppsw0H_7u-01201-00318252-00318512": "and if you say is that the statement is", "TFppsw0H_7u-01202-00318513-00318770": "true then there seems to be some mistake", "TFppsw0H_7u-01203-00318771-00318953": "in the argumentation so this is what", "TFppsw0H_7u-01204-00318954-00319133": "happens here premises is is that you can", "TFppsw0H_7u-01205-00319134-00319286": "avoid harm by accepting this statement", "TFppsw0H_7u-01206-00319287-00319514": "the conclusion is that hence that", "TFppsw0H_7u-01207-00319515-00319721": "statement is true enough the premises", "TFppsw0H_7u-01208-00319722-00319931": "are irrelevant to the conclusion and", "TFppsw0H_7u-01209-00319932-00320123": "hence leads to fallacies of relevance", "TFppsw0H_7u-01210-00320124-00320432": "and this fallacy of relevance can be", "TFppsw0H_7u-01211-00320433-00320656": "further classified into the fallacies of", "TFppsw0H_7u-01212-00320657-00321008": "relevance which arises due to appeal to", "TFppsw0H_7u-01213-00321009-00321422": "force sometimes this threat arguer", "TFppsw0H_7u-01214-00321423-00321629": "threaten the reader or listener and", "TFppsw0H_7u-01215-00321630-00321842": "poses a conclusion and this particular", "TFppsw0H_7u-01216-00321843-00322094": "kind of threat can be even a", "TFppsw0H_7u-01217-00322095-00322283": "psychological threat also it can be a", "TFppsw0H_7u-01218-00322284-00322499": "mental kind of threaten so this is what", "TFppsw0H_7u-01219-00322500-00322802": "you commonly see in organizations in", "TFppsw0H_7u-01220-00322803-00323162": "particular where secretary is arguing", "TFppsw0H_7u-01221-00323163-00323444": "with his boss so he's saying this", "TFppsw0H_7u-01222-00323445-00323615": "particular kind of thing I deserve", "TFppsw0H_7u-01223-00323616-00323813": "promotions with increments etcetera all", "TFppsw0H_7u-01224-00323814-00323939": "the time you know is worried about his", "TFppsw0H_7u-01225-00323940-00324080": "increments etcetera and already God", "TFppsw0H_7u-01226-00324081-00324359": "somehow is claiming with this boss that", "TFppsw0H_7u-01227-00324360-00324575": "it should be promoted this particular", "TFppsw0H_7u-01228-00324576-00324920": "kind of ERL so he says till here it's", "TFppsw0H_7u-01229-00324921-00325118": "fine and all but his claim is based on", "TFppsw0H_7u-01230-00325119-00325286": "some other irrelevant factors you know", "TFppsw0H_7u-01231-00325287-00325670": "he goes on and says that after all you", "TFppsw0H_7u-01232-00325671-00325862": "know how friendly I am with your wife", "TFppsw0H_7u-01233-00325863-00326105": "and I am sure you would not want her to", "TFppsw0H_7u-01234-00326106-00326387": "find out what kind of affair has been", "TFppsw0H_7u-01235-00326388-00326656": "going on between you and that of yours", "TFppsw0H_7u-01236-00326657-00326921": "somehow he had some develop some kind of", "TFppsw0H_7u-01237-00326922-00327305": "religions with his wife and that she", "TFppsw0H_7u-01238-00327306-00327530": "doesn't know I know boss's wife doesn't", "TFppsw0H_7u-01239-00327531-00327935": "know so now he is threatening the the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01240-00327936-00328088": "boss that you know if you don't promote", "TFppsw0H_7u-01241-00328089-00328262": "me in all I'm going to expose everything", "TFppsw0H_7u-01242-00328263-00328547": "to your wife and all so I know you have", "TFppsw0H_7u-01243-00328548-00328772": "been lying to your wife about what you", "TFppsw0H_7u-01244-00328773-00329129": "are what is we about where you go on on", "TFppsw0H_7u-01245-00329130-00329351": "Wednesday afternoons except I know all", "TFppsw0H_7u-01246-00329352-00329527": "these things are irrelevant for the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01247-00329528-00329789": "promotion you know unless you want her", "TFppsw0H_7u-01248-00329790-00330056": "to know where you really go it's time", "TFppsw0H_7u-01249-00330057-00330239": "for you to realize that you have no", "TFppsw0H_7u-01250-00330240-00330563": "choice then rising my salary and all you", "TFppsw0H_7u-01251-00330564-00330782": "raise my salary or promote me otherwise", "TFppsw0H_7u-01252-00330783-00330953": "I'm going to leak all the information", "TFppsw0H_7u-01253-00330954-00331136": "and out so this is how kind of a", "TFppsw0H_7u-01254-00331137-00331430": "psychological threat that secretary is", "TFppsw0H_7u-01255-00331431-00331634": "trying to some kind of blackmailing he's", "TFppsw0H_7u-01256-00331635-00331915": "trying to do so here in this case", "TFppsw0H_7u-01257-00331916-00332069": "secretary seems", "TFppsw0H_7u-01258-00332070-00332414": "seem to have committed fallacy and there", "TFppsw0H_7u-01259-00332415-00332546": "is a mistake in his argumentation", "TFppsw0H_7u-01260-00332547-00332813": "because all these factors whether the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01261-00332814-00333032": "boss is having relation with someone", "TFppsw0H_7u-01262-00333033-00333263": "else etcetera all these things nothing", "TFppsw0H_7u-01263-00333264-00333398": "to do with his promotion about the", "TFppsw0H_7u-01264-00333399-00333698": "promotion what is relevant maybe has", "TFppsw0H_7u-01265-00333699-00334028": "achieved something some tears some some", "TFppsw0H_7u-01266-00334029-00334178": "other things might play a crucial role", "TFppsw0H_7u-01267-00334179-00334502": "in the promotion and all its performance", "TFppsw0H_7u-01268-00334503-00334883": "etcetera so the trick to expose the lie", "TFppsw0H_7u-01269-00334884-00335261": "in no way constitutes evidence for once", "TFppsw0H_7u-01270-00335262-00335408": "promotion or it has nothing to do with", "TFppsw0H_7u-01271-00335409-00335744": "this particular kind of thing so this is", "TFppsw0H_7u-01272-00335745-00335960": "the problem of relevance and then we", "TFppsw0H_7u-01273-00335961-00336164": "will continue with other kinds of", "TFppsw0H_7u-01274-00336165-00336602": "fallacies in the next lecture"}}, {"audio_id": "TFwtHkbQmq0", "text": {"TFwtHkbQmq0-00000-00000000-00000364": "hello everybody this time I fixed my", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00001-00000365-00000536": "microphone and I know it's going to be", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00002-00000537-00000767": "really really annoying but I have too", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00003-00000768-00001265": "much of a choice so we're about to go to", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00004-00001266-00001591": "another place which is for trying to", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00005-00001592-00002242": "this gameplay so which is what to do so", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00006-00002243-00002420": "those why I mean continuing with the", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00007-00002421-00003058": "parts the last few days I've been a", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00008-00003059-00004831": "place and now about the diameter", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00009-00004832-00005327": "come back back yes then not going that", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00010-00005328-00007965": "way wait", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00011-00007966-00008674": "one shot so let's see what we can do so", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00012-00008675-00009875": "I guess", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00013-00009876-00014085": "[__] again and my honor to store my", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00014-00014086-00014994": "house somewhere my god is going to break", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00015-00014994-00015624": "it up in pieces anymore I guess I had to", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00016-00015625-00017667": "bathe with this weapon oh yes I guess", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00017-00017668-00018517": "roof damage but oh but doesn't look gets", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00018-00018518-00021208": "a little bit like this", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00019-00021209-00021539": "look even dare come in there all right", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00020-00021540-00021902": "it's time for me to get some ammunition", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00021-00021903-00022489": "which as I can go like that this way and", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00022-00022490-00023456": "puts in this door not going that way in", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00023-00023457-00025795": "here but i guess i need to get", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00024-00025797-00026283": "all right let's me live for and we're", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00025-00026283-00026601": "getting on our way give like that oh", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00026-00026602-00029848": "there with this spotting heads", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00027-00029849-00030170": "subscribe you enjoy if you did why not", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00028-00030170-00030485": "you like this video if you like the", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00029-00030486-00030719": "common things coming down below for more", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00030-00030720-00031045": "of these videos if you are a", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00031-00031047-00031376": "professional or expert please subscribe", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00032-00031377-00031700": "campus button click on the button the", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00033-00031701-00031925": "floor and you will be an expert and you", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00034-00031926-00032174": "wish will come true even a look at the", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00035-00032175-00032411": "present or something if you see your", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00036-00032412-00032789": "birthday happy birthday and i'll see you", "TFwtHkbQmq0-00037-00032790-00033110": "on a next episode"}}, {"audio_id": "TFZDcuGu3DQ", "text": {"TFZDcuGu3DQ-00000-00000000-00000145": "cassowary", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00001-00000146-00000388": "kazurias is a genus of birds in the", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00002-00000389-00000593": "order casaria formis whose members are", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00003-00000594-00000730": "the cassowaries", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00004-00000731-00000965": "it is classified as a ratite flightless", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00005-00000966-00001181": "bird without a keel on its sternum bone", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00006-00001182-00001385": "and is native to the tropical forests of", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00007-00001386-00001558": "New Guinea Papua New Guinea and", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00008-00001559-00001798": "Indonesia aru islands and Northeastern", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00009-00001800-00001925": "Australia", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00010-00001926-00002152": "three species are extant the most common", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00011-00002153-00002351": "the southern cassowary is the third", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00012-00002352-00002555": "tallest and second heaviest living bird", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00013-00002556-00002837": "smaller only than the ostrich in emu", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00014-00002838-00003083": "the other two species are represented by", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00015-00003084-00003251": "the northern cassowary and the dwarf", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00016-00003252-00003359": "cassowary", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00017-00003360-00003593": "a fourth but extinct species is", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00018-00003594-00003838": "represented by the pygmy cassowary", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00019-00003839-00004036": "cassowaries feed mainly on fruit", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00020-00004037-00004217": "although all species are truly", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00021-00004218-00004397": "omnivorous and take a range of other", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00022-00004398-00004613": "plant Foods including shoots and grass", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00023-00004614-00004847": "seeds in addition to fungi invertebrates", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00024-00004848-00005038": "and small vertebrates", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00025-00005039-00005297": "cassowaries are very wary of humans but", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00026-00005298-00005459": "if provoked they are capable of", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00027-00005460-00005693": "inflicting serious even fatal injuries", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00028-00005694-00005885": "to both dogs and people", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00029-00005886-00006125": "the cassowary has often been labeled the", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00030-00006126-00006420": "world's most dangerous bird description", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00031-00006422-00006725": "typically all cassowaries are shy birds", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00032-00006726-00006917": "that are found in the deep forest", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00033-00006918-00007114": "they are Adept at disappearing long", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00034-00007115-00007396": "before a human knows they were there the", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00035-00007397-00007546": "southern cassowary of the far North", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00036-00007547-00007763": "Queensland rainforests is not well", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00037-00007764-00007925": "studied and the northern and dwarf", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00038-00007926-00008128": "cassowaries even less so", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00039-00008129-00008321": "females are larger and more brightly", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00040-00008322-00008489": "colored than the males", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00041-00008490-00008771": "adult Southern cassowaries are 1.5 to", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00042-00008772-00009035": "1.8 meters tall although some females", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00043-00009036-00009287": "May reach 2 meters and weigh 58.5", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00044-00009288-00009581": "kilogram all cassowaries feathers", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00045-00009582-00009851": "consist of a shaft and loose barbules", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00046-00009852-00010067": "they do not have wrecked Rices tail", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00047-00010068-00010260": "feathers or a Preen gland", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00048-00010261-00010510": "cassowaries have small wings with five", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00049-00010511-00010691": "or six large images", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00050-00010692-00010901": "these are reduced to stiff keratinous", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00051-00010902-00011146": "quills resembling porcupine quills with", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00052-00011147-00011267": "no barbs", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00053-00011268-00011501": "the furcular and coracoid are degenerate", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00054-00011502-00011681": "and their palatal bones and sphenoid", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00055-00011682-00011855": "Bones touch each other", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00056-00011856-00012064": "these along with their wedge-shaped body", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00057-00012065-00012269": "are thought to be adaptations to ward", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00058-00012270-00012503": "off fines thorns and saw edged leaves", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00059-00012504-00012688": "allowing them to run quickly through the", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00060-00012689-00012815": "rainforest", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00061-00012816-00013049": "cassowaries have three-toed feet with", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00062-00013050-00013343": "sharp claws the second toe the inner one", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00063-00013344-00013522": "in the medial position Sports a", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00064-00013523-00013763": "dagger-like claw that may be 125", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00065-00013763-00014015": "millimeters long this Claw is", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00066-00014016-00014225": "particularly fearsome since cassowaries", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00067-00014226-00014435": "sometimes kick humans and other animals", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00068-00014436-00014622": "with their powerful legs", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00069-00014623-00014825": "cassowaries can run at up to 50", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00070-00014826-00015016": "kilometers per hour through the dense", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00071-00015018-00015341": "forest and can jump up to 1.5 meters", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00072-00015341-00015551": "they are good swimmers Crossing wide", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00073-00015552-00015761": "rivers and swimming in the sea", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00074-00015762-00015983": "several functions for The Cask have been", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00075-00015984-00016091": "proposed", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00076-00016091-00016313": "one is that they are a secondary sexual", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00077-00016313-00016444": "characteristic", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00078-00016445-00016672": "other suggested functions include being", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00079-00016673-00016865": "used to batter through underbrush as a", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00080-00016866-00017057": "weapon in dominance disputes or for", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00081-00017058-00017207": "pushing aside Leaf litter during", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00082-00017208-00017327": "foraging", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00083-00017328-00017507": "the latter three are disputed by", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00084-00017508-00017711": "biologist Andrew Mack whose personal", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00085-00017712-00017891": "observation suggests that The Cask", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00086-00017892-00018100": "amplifies deep sounds", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00087-00018101-00018329": "earlier Research indicates the birds", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00088-00018330-00018527": "lower their heads when running Full Tilt", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00089-00018528-00018719": "through the vegetation brushing saplings", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00090-00018720-00018911": "aside and occasionally careening into", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00091-00018912-00019049": "small trees", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00092-00019050-00019247": "The Cask would help protect the skull", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00093-00019248-00019421": "from such collisions", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00094-00019422-00019643": "cassowaries eat Fallen fruit and", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00095-00019644-00019858": "consequently spend much time under trees", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00096-00019859-00020063": "where seeds the size of golf balls or", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00097-00020064-00020272": "larger fall from Heights up to 30 meters", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00098-00020273-00020471": "the wedge-shaped Cask may protect the", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00099-00020472-00020699": "head by deflecting Falling Fruit", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00100-00020700-00020939": "the casks Also may play a role in either", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00101-00020940-00021100": "sound reception or acoustic", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00102-00021101-00021233": "communication", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00103-00021234-00021461": "this is related to a discovery that at", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00104-00021462-00021622": "least the dwarf cassowary in southern", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00105-00021623-00021857": "cassowary produce very low frequency", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00106-00021858-00022091": "sounds which may Aid in communication in", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00107-00022092-00022235": "dense rainforest", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00108-00022236-00022493": "the boom vocalization that cassowaries", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00109-00022494-00022685": "produce is the lowest frequency bird", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00110-00022686-00022883": "call known and is at the lower limit of", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00111-00022884-00023003": "human hearing", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00112-00023004-00023225": "a cooling function for the very similar", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00113-00023226-00023443": "casks of guineafowl has been proposed", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00114-00023444-00023741": "the average lifespan of wild cassowaries", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00115-00023742-00024053": "is believed to be about 40 to 50 years", "TFZDcuGu3DQ-00116-00024054-00024362": "thanks for watching"}}, {"audio_id": "TG2YyR7HfnA", "text": {"TG2YyR7HfnA-00000-00003839-00004670": "oh", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00001-00004671-00004783": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00002-00004784-00004984": "yes", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00003-00004985-00006494": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00004-00006495-00007019": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00005-00007020-00007639": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00006-00007640-00007981": "i see them", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00007-00007981-00009485": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00008-00009486-00009797": "[Applause]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00009-00009798-00010631": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00010-00010632-00011142": "so", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00011-00011143-00012927": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00012-00012928-00012991": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00013-00012993-00013143": "[Applause]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00014-00013144-00013731": "me", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00015-00013732-00013743": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00016-00013744-00015180": "[Applause]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00017-00015181-00017232": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00018-00017233-00017694": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00019-00017695-00018032": "oh", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00020-00018033-00018550": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00021-00018551-00018668": "oh", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00022-00018669-00020584": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00023-00020585-00021407": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00024-00021408-00021976": "um", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00025-00021977-00023878": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00026-00023879-00024929": "me", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00027-00024930-00025468": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00028-00025469-00025875": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00029-00025876-00026249": "[Applause]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00030-00026250-00026757": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00031-00026758-00027401": "[Applause]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00032-00027402-00027624": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00033-00027625-00027995": "[Applause]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00034-00027997-00028247": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00035-00028248-00028445": "[Applause]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00036-00028447-00028567": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00037-00028568-00028880": "so", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00038-00028881-00029990": "[Applause]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00039-00029991-00032214": "so", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00040-00032216-00032934": "five", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00041-00032935-00033823": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00042-00033824-00034109": "wow", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00043-00034110-00034230": "[Applause]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00044-00034231-00035207": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00045-00035208-00035372": "bye-bye", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00046-00035373-00037182": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00047-00037183-00038157": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00048-00038158-00039374": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00049-00039375-00039399": "foreign", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00050-00039400-00040955": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00051-00040956-00041513": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00052-00041514-00043397": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00053-00043398-00044000": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00054-00044001-00044230": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00055-00044231-00046374": "foreign", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00056-00046375-00048455": "oh", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00057-00048456-00051259": "oh", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00058-00051260-00052457": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00059-00052458-00054147": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00060-00054148-00054467": "[Applause]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00061-00054469-00056350": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00062-00056351-00057696": "hmm", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00063-00057697-00060182": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00064-00060183-00060599": "i", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00065-00060600-00061984": "me", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00066-00061985-00063263": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00067-00063264-00063748": "foreign", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00068-00063749-00064576": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00069-00064577-00066687": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00070-00066688-00067399": "hey", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00071-00067400-00067625": "oh", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00072-00067626-00067663": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00073-00067664-00068461": "[Applause]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00074-00068462-00068959": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00075-00068960-00069278": "um", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00076-00069279-00069473": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00077-00069474-00070551": "[Applause]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00078-00070552-00075785": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00079-00075786-00078243": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00080-00078244-00079094": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00081-00079095-00079434": "uh", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00082-00079435-00080614": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00083-00080615-00081391": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00084-00081392-00081537": "uh", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00085-00081538-00083251": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00086-00083252-00083445": "[Applause]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00087-00083446-00084367": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00088-00084368-00084714": "hey", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00089-00084715-00084799": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00090-00084800-00086215": "[Applause]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00091-00086216-00086388": "wow", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00092-00086389-00087199": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00093-00087200-00087398": "hey", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00094-00087399-00088999": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00095-00089000-00090199": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00096-00090200-00090368": "hey", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00097-00090369-00090815": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00098-00090816-00091468": "[Applause]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00099-00091469-00092943": "[Music]", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00100-00092944-00095047": "so", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00101-00095048-00098718": "me", "TG2YyR7HfnA-00102-00098719-00098927": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "TGi8dJk-f3E", "text": {"TGi8dJk-f3E-00000-00000424-00000751": "hello people of mexico my name is", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00001-00000752-00000950": "tarawa", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00002-00000951-00001279": "i have visited your beautiful country", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00003-00001280-00001550": "i spent a month there traveling and it", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00004-00001551-00001647": "really", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00005-00001648-00002007": "changed my way of thinking of mexicans", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00006-00002007-00002302": "and i really love your country", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00007-00002303-00002591": "i was proud to be there", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00008-00002592-00002726": "and if", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00009-00002727-00003055": "you need my help for the kind words", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00010-00003056-00003222": "something i'm", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00011-00003223-00003454": "more than willing to say to you", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00012-00003455-00003847": "don't ever ever give up", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00013-00003847-00004103": "i follow what is happening in your", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00014-00004104-00004254": "country", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00015-00004255-00004583": "and many times we people in iceland we", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00016-00004584-00004775": "are shocked", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00017-00004776-00004886": "and we are", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00018-00004887-00005175": "very sorry what is happening and we feel", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00019-00005176-00005415": "for you", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00020-00005416-00005583": "but please", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00021-00005584-00006006": "don't ever give a hope", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00022-00006007-00006222": "don't give up", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00023-00006223-00006495": "i'm sure it's going to take time", "TGi8dJk-f3E-00024-00006495-00006988": "but we are with you in our hearts"}}, {"audio_id": "TGnfCw5HH0g", "text": {"TGnfCw5HH0g-00000-00000919-00001079": "good afternoon my name is laura", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00001-00001080-00001174": "mcculloch", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00002-00001175-00001374": "and today i'm going to be talking to you", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00003-00001375-00001599": "about suffrage and the raw holloway art", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00004-00001600-00001775": "collections", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00005-00001776-00002055": "the talk looks at artworks by or of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00006-00002056-00002255": "women engaged in the fight for women's", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00007-00002256-00002334": "suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00008-00002335-00002550": "from the mid 19th century to the early", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00009-00002551-00002710": "20th century", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00010-00002711-00002950": "we're extremely lucky at raw holloway to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00011-00002951-00003150": "have a collection so rich in artworks", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00012-00003151-00003454": "relating to these women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00013-00003455-00003670": "it is largely due to the collection of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00014-00003671-00003927": "one female artist christiana herringham", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00015-00003928-00004086": "that we have so many works of art", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00016-00004087-00004279": "relating to those involved in the fight", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00017-00004280-00004486": "for women's suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00018-00004487-00004686": "she was heavily involved in the suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00019-00004687-00004911": "movement and personal friends with many", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00020-00004912-00005070": "of the women i'm going to talk about", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00021-00005071-00005215": "today", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00022-00005216-00005495": "after herringham's death in 1929 bedford", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00023-00005496-00005686": "college was gifted half of her art", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00024-00005687-00005767": "collection", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00025-00005768-00006006": "which included works by her but also", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00026-00006007-00006118": "works by other women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00027-00006119-00006318": "artists as well as a collection of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00028-00006319-00006463": "indian miniature paintings", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00029-00006464-00006775": "chinese art japanese prints and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00030-00006776-00007151": "an indian sword these items were given", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00031-00007152-00007367": "as her husband sir wilma herringham was", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00032-00007368-00007606": "the chair of council for bedford college", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00033-00007608-00007798": "and he oversaw the distribution of her", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00034-00007800-00008031": "collection to both bedford and unum", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00035-00008031-00008103": "college", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00036-00008104-00008278": "which is where christiana had given", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00037-00008279-00008614": "khalid the college financial support", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00038-00008615-00008878": "i'm going to use these remarkable items", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00039-00008879-00008991": "in the art collection", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00040-00008992-00009159": "as the springboard to look at a number", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00041-00009160-00009319": "of women involved in the suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00042-00009320-00009478": "movement", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00043-00009479-00009678": "i'm very lucky that our former assistant", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00044-00009679-00009887": "curator dr michaela jones", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00045-00009888-00010119": "completed her phd on herringham and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00046-00010120-00010246": "co-researched with me", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00047-00010247-00010446": "a conference paper on herringham and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00048-00010447-00010646": "suffrage which uncovered a lot of what", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00049-00010647-00010838": "we know about these women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00050-00010839-00011046": "many thanks to her as without her work i", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00051-00011047-00011183": "would not be able to give this talk", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00052-00011184-00011278": "today", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00053-00011279-00011478": "i'm also indebted to elizabeth crawford", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00054-00011479-00011670": "for her research without which many of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00055-00011671-00011814": "the pieces of the jigsaw", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00056-00011815-00012223": "would not have fallen into place", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00057-00012224-00012399": "i'm actually going to start with an", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00058-00012400-00012670": "artwork which is not part of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00059-00012671-00012966": "the herringham collection it's a newly", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00060-00012967-00013166": "rediscovered portrait of millicent", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00061-00013168-00013222": "fawcett", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00062-00013223-00013415": "who was so central to the suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00063-00013416-00013575": "movement", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00064-00013576-00013799": "this portrait was originally believed to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00065-00013800-00014007": "be of emily penrose who was the first", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00066-00014008-00014247": "principal of bedford college", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00067-00014247-00014447": "this was due to a plaque attached to the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00068-00014447-00014551": "frame which", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00069-00014552-00014815": "nobody had thought to question however", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00070-00014816-00014886": "last year", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00071-00014887-00015071": "sleuthing by my former colleagues in the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00072-00015072-00015207": "art collections team", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00073-00015208-00015350": "discovered that the painting was", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00074-00015351-00015615": "actually of militant faucet", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00075-00015616-00015879": "firstly former assistant curator dr", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00076-00015880-00015991": "imogen tedbury", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00077-00015991-00016166": "managed to read the very difficult", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00078-00016168-00016335": "signature of the artist", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00079-00016336-00016503": "which you might be able to see in the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00080-00016504-00016686": "bottom right of the painting", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00081-00016687-00016871": "and she worked out that it was theodore", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00082-00016872-00016999": "blake fergman", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00083-00017000-00017199": "previously we just been calling it a", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00084-00017200-00017399": "british painter", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00085-00017400-00017615": "then our cataloguer dr allison wright", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00086-00017616-00017783": "found a reference to a gift of a", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00087-00017784-00017991": "portrait of millicent fawcett", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00088-00017992-00018286": "being given to the college and lastly", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00089-00018287-00018535": "assistant curator dr michaela jones", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00090-00018536-00018719": "found an image of the portrait in a", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00091-00018720-00018863": "digitized catalogue", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00092-00018864-00019055": "at the royal academy summer exhibition", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00093-00019056-00019255": "from 1898", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00094-00019256-00019455": "and that was able to confirm that it was", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00095-00019456-00019639": "one in the same portrait because we", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00096-00019640-00019958": "finally had an image of it", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00097-00019959-00020199": "the gift of her portrait to bedford by", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00098-00020200-00020391": "millicent's friend and fellow suffragist", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00099-00020392-00020511": "dorothea roberts", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00100-00020512-00020678": "who was also the artist's aunt by", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00101-00020679-00020919": "marriage must have been to inspire those", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00102-00020920-00021007": "studying there", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00103-00021008-00021255": "to help the cause for women's rights and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00104-00021256-00021343": "to be proud", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00105-00021344-00021535": "of their study at a higher education", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00106-00021536-00021814": "institution", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00107-00021815-00021975": "dame ellison fawcett came from a", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00108-00021976-00022143": "remarkable family", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00109-00022144-00022343": "one of her sisters was elizabeth garrett", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00110-00022344-00022494": "anderson who was the first", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00111-00022495-00022767": "qualified female doctor in britain and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00112-00022768-00022894": "one of her other sisters", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00113-00022895-00023199": "agnes who you'll hear more of later set", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00114-00023200-00023375": "up the first professional female", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00115-00023376-00023550": "interior design company with their", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00116-00023551-00023878": "cousin rosa rhoda", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00117-00023879-00024039": "fawcett was a leading night of the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00118-00024040-00024222": "women's suffrage movement and formed the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00119-00024223-00024391": "national union of women's suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00120-00024392-00024663": "societies in 1897.", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00121-00024664-00024863": "it was the largest association of its", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00122-00024864-00025078": "kind she became its president", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00123-00025079-00025375": "in 1897 and continued at the hound for", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00124-00025376-00025455": "50 years", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00125-00025456-00025783": "until finally in 1918 the representation", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00126-00025783-00025902": "of the people act", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00127-00025904-00026279": "enfranchised about six million women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00128-00026280-00026446": "ten years afterwards british women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00129-00026447-00026631": "received the vote on a basis of full", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00130-00026632-00026951": "equality with men", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00131-00026952-00027231": "millicent retired in 1919 from active", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00132-00027232-00027407": "leadership of the suffrage union", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00133-00027408-00027567": "which had been renamed the national", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00134-00027568-00027870": "union for equal citizenship", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00135-00027872-00028199": "even before women had had the vote she", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00136-00028200-00028399": "founded newnan college in cambridge", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00137-00028400-00028599": "which was planned from 1869", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00138-00028600-00028983": "and opened in 1871. she'd also", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00139-00028983-00029279": "been engaged with the running of bedford", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00140-00029280-00029351": "college", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00141-00029352-00029590": "and had sent her daughter philippa there", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00142-00029591-00029743": "she also advised", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00143-00029744-00029927": "thomas holloway when he began thinking", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00144-00029927-00030102": "about founding women's college in the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00145-00030103-00030246": "1870s", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00146-00030247-00030446": "so as well as fighting for a woman's", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00147-00030447-00030679": "right to vote she was also", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00148-00030680-00031023": "very central to the campaign for women's", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00149-00031024-00031246": "higher education", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00150-00031247-00031407": "i started with this portrait of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00151-00031408-00031590": "millicent fawcett as she is at the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00152-00031591-00031702": "center", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00153-00031703-00031895": "of the group of women who i'm going to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00154-00031895-00032055": "introduce to you today", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00155-00032056-00032223": "and it's likely that according to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00156-00032224-00032358": "elizabeth crawford", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00157-00032360-00032543": "it's through militant faucet that some", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00158-00032544-00032774": "of them came to know each other", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00159-00032775-00032999": "if she's the center of the web its", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00160-00033000-00033102": "threads are made from", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00161-00033103-00033318": "suffrage women's higher education and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00162-00033319-00033423": "art", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00163-00033424-00033574": "these are the strands that bind these", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00164-00033575-00033911": "women together around millicent faucet", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00165-00033912-00034095": "the paintings drawings and watercolors", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00166-00034096-00034255": "in the collection are proof", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00167-00034256-00034439": "that these women knew each other as", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00168-00034440-00034607": "without their personal connections to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00169-00034608-00034671": "each other", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00170-00034672-00034959": "the artworks couldn't exist so these", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00171-00034960-00035135": "artworks that i'm going to show you are", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00172-00035136-00035255": "amazing records", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00173-00035256-00035479": "of the network around medicine faucet", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00174-00035480-00035623": "and those who are fighting", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00175-00035624-00035951": "for women's suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00176-00035952-00036118": "i'm now going to turn to christiana", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00177-00036119-00036343": "herringham who owned or created many of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00178-00036344-00036502": "the works that i'm going to talk about", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00179-00036503-00036623": "today", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00180-00036624-00036862": "here are two of the 160 works by", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00181-00036863-00036974": "herringham that we have in the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00182-00036975-00037127": "collection", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00183-00037128-00037295": "on the left is the head of the madeleine", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00184-00037296-00037527": "after botticelli in tempura", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00185-00037528-00037702": "and on the right is a life drawing of a", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00186-00037703-00037830": "woman", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00187-00037831-00037983": "the first record of herringham's", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00188-00037984-00038279": "involvement with the course was in 1889", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00189-00038280-00038471": "when she signed a petition demanding the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00190-00038472-00038623": "vote for women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00191-00038624-00038815": "in the same year she became a member of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00192-00038816-00038935": "the central committee", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00193-00038936-00039111": "for the national society for women's", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00194-00039112-00039327": "suffrage which was the first national", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00195-00039328-00039502": "organization to campaign", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00196-00039503-00039839": "for a woman's right to vote herring him", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00197-00039840-00040046": "support for suffrage is likely to have", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00198-00040047-00040215": "been spurred on by her friendship with", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00199-00040216-00040462": "the leader of the nuwss", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00200-00040463-00040807": "militant faucet and her family", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00201-00040808-00041007": "but it's not clear exactly how she met", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00202-00041008-00041183": "millicent fawcett", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00203-00041184-00041358": "it does seem likely though that it was", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00204-00041359-00041574": "through her father thomas wild powell", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00205-00041575-00041862": "whose company hesseltime perlin co gave", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00206-00041863-00042030": "investment advice to the finance", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00207-00042031-00042255": "committee of the new hospital for women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00208-00042256-00042455": "run by fawcett's sister elizabeth", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00209-00042456-00042630": "garrett anderson", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00210-00042631-00042823": "thomas wild powell had strong ties with", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00211-00042824-00043046": "the arts and craft movement", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00212-00043047-00043351": "and he had richard norman shaw design a", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00213-00043352-00043495": "number of buildings", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00214-00043496-00043695": "um including his guildford home pickers", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00215-00043696-00043927": "rough which had an outdoors dining area", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00216-00043928-00043983": "featuring", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00217-00043984-00044262": "terracotta work by mary watts and i", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00218-00044263-00044430": "mentioned the arts and crafts movement", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00219-00044431-00044583": "because there are great connections", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00220-00044584-00044662": "between", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00221-00044663-00044855": "those working in that movement and the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00222-00044856-00044999": "suffrage movement", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00223-00045000-00045190": "for instance we know mary watts was", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00224-00045191-00045462": "president of the guildford", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00225-00045463-00045918": "um women's suffrage society", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00226-00045919-00046118": "so i think it's really interesting that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00227-00046119-00046287": "herringham's father", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00228-00046288-00046583": "being a major arts and craft patron", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00229-00046584-00046799": "seems to have also been very supportive", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00230-00046800-00047127": "of suffrage and initiated herringham's", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00231-00047128-00047335": "entry into meeting people who were", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00232-00047336-00047702": "working on women's suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00233-00047703-00047927": "this is a portrait by herringham of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00234-00047928-00048079": "millicent fawcett's cousin", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00235-00048080-00048367": "rhoda garrett and it signifies a close", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00236-00048368-00048527": "relationship that herringham had with", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00237-00048528-00048711": "the fawcett circle", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00238-00048712-00048935": "it is also really significant because", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00239-00048936-00049118": "it's one of only two known surviving", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00240-00049119-00049399": "portraits of rhoda", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00241-00049400-00049630": "rhoda was forced its cousin and she set", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00242-00049631-00049823": "up the first female interior design", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00243-00049824-00050102": "company with fawcett's sister agnes", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00244-00050103-00050351": "they lived together at two gower street", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00245-00050352-00050535": "which you can see in this illustration", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00246-00050536-00050630": "from their how", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00247-00050631-00050846": "from their book house decoration", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00248-00050847-00051230": "published in the 1870s", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00249-00051232-00051470": "what i like about this book is that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00250-00051471-00051590": "agnes and rhoda", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00251-00051591-00051870": "were very keen to make their design", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00252-00051871-00052111": "rules accessible to anyone", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00253-00052112-00052375": "um so it wasn't exclusive they were very", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00254-00052376-00052487": "happy to share their", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00255-00052488-00052807": "ideas and in fact their design business", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00256-00052808-00052966": "was so successful", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00257-00052967-00053191": "that they even rivaled willie morris in", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00258-00053191-00053335": "their day", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00259-00053336-00053671": "what i think is very interesting is that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00260-00053672-00053807": "although", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00261-00053808-00054111": "museums have many many pieces by william", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00262-00054112-00054182": "morris", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00263-00054183-00054430": "and that is a household name", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00264-00054432-00054623": "unfortunately their design business", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00265-00054624-00054823": "isn't really known by anyone and has", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00266-00054824-00055023": "largely been forgotten", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00267-00055024-00055319": "there is only one piece by the two", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00268-00055320-00055430": "cousins", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00269-00055432-00055742": "in the v a um in their collections and i", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00270-00055744-00055879": "think that speaks volumes", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00271-00055879-00056159": "about how it was far easier for this", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00272-00056160-00056303": "groundbreaking duo", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00273-00056304-00056487": "their work because they're women to be", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00274-00056488-00056623": "forgotten", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00275-00056624-00056830": "whereas other bigger companies run by", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00276-00056832-00057350": "men are very much household names", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00277-00057351-00057582": "tugara street also became millicent", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00278-00057583-00057838": "fawcett's home after her husband's death", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00279-00057839-00058047": "and what's really significant about it", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00280-00058048-00058175": "is it's meters away", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00281-00058176-00058438": "from 22 bedford square into which", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00282-00058439-00058663": "christiana moved with her husband wilma", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00283-00058664-00058903": "after their marriage in 1880", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00284-00058904-00059142": "so even just after she's married", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00285-00059144-00059399": "herringham is making sure that she lives", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00286-00059400-00059647": "close to that family and that she has", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00287-00059648-00059807": "ties with and that have ties to the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00288-00059808-00060191": "suffrage movement", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00289-00060191-00060430": "the portrait itself and the location of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00290-00060432-00060606": "herriam's london home suggest that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00291-00060607-00060679": "herringham", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00292-00060679-00060854": "was part of the inner circle around the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00293-00060855-00061230": "faucets by the early 1880s", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00294-00061232-00061471": "rhoda wasn't just interested in interior", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00295-00061472-00061566": "design", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00296-00061567-00061823": "she was also in fact a noted suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00297-00061824-00061982": "orator", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00298-00061983-00062159": "this is one of two images from", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00299-00062160-00062359": "newspapers that depict her speaking on", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00300-00062360-00062542": "the subject of a woman's right to vote", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00301-00062544-00062735": "in the 1870s", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00302-00062736-00062919": "she toured with agnes and other women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00303-00062920-00063111": "speakers on suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00304-00063112-00063319": "around talking about suffrage around the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00305-00063320-00063511": "country", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00306-00063512-00063719": "unlike her cousins elizabeth garrett", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00307-00063720-00063894": "anderson and millicent fawcett", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00308-00063895-00064182": "both agnes and rhoda had slightly", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00309-00064183-00064382": "different views and supported the repeal", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00310-00064383-00064566": "of the contagious diseases acts", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00311-00064567-00064782": "which saw women forcibly examined for", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00312-00064783-00064903": "sexual diseases", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00313-00064904-00065175": "against their will so even within the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00314-00065176-00065303": "same family", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00315-00065304-00065567": "um there were different uh differences", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00316-00065568-00065638": "of opinion", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00317-00065639-00065950": "around suffrage and other um", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00318-00065951-00066271": "political incidents", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00319-00066272-00066559": "concerning women and i think it's quite", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00320-00066560-00066759": "interesting that agnes and rhoda", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00321-00066760-00066982": "do differ from the rest of the family in", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00322-00066983-00067175": "that aspect", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00323-00067176-00067391": "agnes carried on the decorating business", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00324-00067392-00067703": "after rose's early death in 1882", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00325-00067704-00068006": "from typhoid um and as i say", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00326-00068007-00068238": "in its time it rivaled morrison co in", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00327-00068239-00068503": "popularity", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00328-00068504-00068711": "what's interesting about the portrait of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00329-00068712-00068838": "her", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00330-00068839-00069175": "is that it's undated um and it's not", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00331-00069176-00069343": "clear whether this portrait", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00332-00069344-00069567": "is a token of the friendship between", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00333-00069568-00069759": "herringham and rhoda garrett", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00334-00069760-00070126": "or if it's a posthumous depiction of her", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00335-00070127-00070406": "and meant to be celebrating her life", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00336-00070407-00070487": "either way", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00337-00070488-00070703": "it clearly was something that herringham", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00338-00070704-00070847": "held very dear", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00339-00070848-00071055": "i'm showing you the portrait in the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00340-00071056-00071199": "state that it is today", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00341-00071200-00071567": "and that is also after conservation", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00342-00071568-00071943": "um and it's one of the few pieces in", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00343-00071944-00072223": "the num the large number of watercolors", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00344-00072224-00072431": "and drawings that we have by herringham", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00345-00072432-00072735": "that's in this state it's very used", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00346-00072736-00072982": "um it's quite dirty if you look at the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00347-00072983-00073143": "top you can see there are a number of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00348-00073144-00073262": "pinholes", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00349-00073263-00073423": "i think what that suggests is that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00350-00073424-00073750": "herringham had it up in her studio", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00351-00073751-00073967": "so it's really something she did hold", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00352-00073968-00074079": "very dear", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00353-00074080-00074294": "and i think that also underlines the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00354-00074295-00074479": "remarkable friendship that she must have", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00355-00074480-00074631": "had with rhoda", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00356-00074632-00074775": "and so i think the state of it the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00357-00074776-00075015": "condition of it actually speaks volumes", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00358-00075016-00075682": "about the relationship between these two", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00359-00075683-00076175": "women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00360-00076176-00076343": "i'm now going to talk a little bit more", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00361-00076344-00076543": "about herring him having looked at that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00362-00076544-00076767": "close relationship with rhoda", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00363-00076768-00076967": "harrium's support of women artists is", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00364-00076968-00077191": "evident in her role as the sole managing", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00365-00077192-00077399": "director of the women's tribune", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00366-00077400-00077638": "a feminist periodical which was very", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00367-00077639-00077823": "short-lived but it's significant that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00368-00077824-00077935": "herringham", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00369-00077936-00078231": "was the sole managing director of it the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00370-00078232-00078406": "tribune was a weekly journal", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00371-00078407-00078711": "first published in may 1906 it was not", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00372-00078712-00078919": "exclusively dedicated to the suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00373-00078920-00079119": "cause but it aimed to publicize the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00374-00079120-00079303": "efforts and achievements of women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00375-00079304-00079582": "and to also provide women with a voice", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00376-00079583-00079743": "the first issue stated", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00377-00079744-00079926": "women must speak more and more", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00378-00079927-00080175": "emphatically more of them must speak", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00379-00080176-00080431": "much speech is action silence is not", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00380-00080432-00080615": "always golden", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00381-00080616-00080815": "the paper published articles by women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00382-00080816-00081031": "including the designer may morris", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00383-00081032-00081247": "also the daughter willie morris and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00384-00081248-00081447": "prominent suffragists such as francis", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00385-00081448-00081519": "balfour", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00386-00081520-00081806": "and millicent fawcett additionally it", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00387-00081807-00081982": "featured an article on women artists at", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00388-00081983-00082150": "the royal academy exhibition", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00389-00082151-00082359": "and reviewed an exhibition dedicated to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00390-00082360-00082623": "the sculptor theodore glycom", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00391-00082624-00082935": "actually uh we have two works by", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00392-00082936-00083247": "theodora's father count glycan", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00393-00083248-00083462": "in the collections at royal holloway one", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00394-00083463-00083631": "of them is the sculpture of thomas and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00395-00083632-00083671": "jane", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00396-00083672-00083975": "in the north quad in the south quad and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00397-00083976-00084199": "the other is queen victoria in the north", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00398-00084200-00084447": "quad i think it's really significant", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00399-00084448-00084543": "that this paper", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00400-00084544-00084838": "included articles about women artists", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00401-00084839-00085006": "because as a woman artist herself", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00402-00085007-00085175": "herringham knew it was very very", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00403-00085176-00085350": "difficult for women artists to get", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00404-00085351-00085455": "publicity", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00405-00085456-00085799": "or even be um talked about by critics", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00406-00085800-00085991": "so her paper was giving space to these", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00407-00085992-00086150": "women and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00408-00086151-00086415": "acknowledging um their role in the art", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00409-00086416-00086694": "world", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00410-00086695-00087031": "the paper was short-lived in august 1906", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00411-00087032-00087279": "having been set up in may 1906 the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00412-00087280-00087479": "paper's management was transferred", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00413-00087480-00087647": "and its title changed to women in", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00414-00087648-00087806": "progress", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00415-00087807-00088015": "although her own foray into publication", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00416-00088016-00088238": "was brief herringham recognized the key", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00417-00088239-00088399": "role that such publications", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00418-00088400-00088606": "could play in gathering support for the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00419-00088607-00088759": "suffrage cause", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00420-00088760-00089031": "in 1909 she donated funds to help launch", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00421-00089032-00089247": "a pro-suffrage periodical called the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00422-00089248-00089359": "english woman", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00423-00089360-00089631": "and in 1908 she pledged 200 pounds to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00424-00089632-00089838": "the women's franchise newspaper", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00425-00089839-00090191": "which published reports from the nuwss", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00426-00090192-00090399": "the men's league for women's suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00427-00090400-00090575": "and the wspu", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00428-00090576-00090718": "although the women's freedom league", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00429-00090719-00090967": "later replaced the wspu", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00430-00090968-00091143": "despite her closeness to the garrett", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00431-00091144-00091326": "family herringham emphasized that she", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00432-00091327-00091535": "was keen for all of the societies to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00433-00091536-00091694": "continue being represented in the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00434-00091695-00091894": "periodical", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00435-00091895-00092079": "although she was a dedicated supporter", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00436-00092080-00092223": "of the nuwss", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00437-00092224-00092438": "herringham also for a time subscribed to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00438-00092439-00092587": "the more militant", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00439-00092588-00092855": "wspu and donated money to the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00440-00092856-00093206": "organization as late as august 1907.", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00441-00093207-00093511": "however in september 1907 internal", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00442-00093512-00093774": "disagreements within the wspu", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00443-00093775-00094006": "came to a head and led to a split of the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00444-00094007-00094126": "organization", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00445-00094127-00094294": "the dissenting members founded the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00446-00094295-00094494": "women's freedom league", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00447-00094495-00094894": "they still um favored activism", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00448-00094895-00095159": "but they weren't in any way supporting", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00449-00095160-00095255": "the militant", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00450-00095256-00095567": "violent deeds that mrs pankhurst and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00451-00095568-00095862": "the others who had been part of the wspu", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00452-00095863-00096006": "favoured", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00453-00096007-00096182": "herringham appears to have supported the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00454-00096183-00096406": "dissenting members as she rented out her", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00455-00096407-00096599": "newspaper's old offices on buckingham", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00456-00096600-00096662": "street", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00457-00096663-00096847": "near the strand to the women's freedom", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00458-00096848-00097079": "league at a reduced rate of one pound a", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00459-00097080-00097487": "week", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00460-00097488-00097767": "in 1907 herringham was a founder member", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00461-00097768-00097943": "of the artist suffrage league", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00462-00097944-00098159": "along with mary lounde who you can see", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00463-00098160-00098350": "here", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00464-00098351-00098550": "the organization's role was to create", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00465-00098551-00098726": "propaganda for the course", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00466-00098727-00098943": "counteracting the negative stereotypes", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00467-00098944-00099094": "of feminists", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00468-00099095-00099255": "one of the league's most significant", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00469-00099256-00099447": "contributions was the creation of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00470-00099448-00099567": "numerous banners", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00471-00099568-00099750": "demonstrating women's achievements and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00472-00099751-00099950": "contributions to society", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00473-00099951-00100255": "for use in suffrage processions herring", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00474-00100256-00100431": "embroidered several of the banners", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00475-00100432-00100606": "allowing her to combine her artistic", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00476-00100607-00100903": "work with her political convictions", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00477-00100904-00101103": "herringham lounge were also the league's", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00478-00101104-00101215": "representative", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00479-00101216-00101518": "on the committee organizing the nuwss's", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00480-00101519-00101703": "great procession", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00481-00101704-00102023": "it took place on the 13th of june 1908", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00482-00102024-00102238": "10 000 women from around the country", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00483-00102239-00102415": "marched through central london", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00484-00102416-00102582": "to demonstrate mass support for the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00485-00102583-00102830": "cause carrying over 70 banners for the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00486-00102831-00103110": "occasion", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00487-00103111-00103302": "and you can see some of those banners", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00488-00103303-00103430": "here", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00489-00103431-00103599": "most of the banners were designed by", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00490-00103600-00103790": "lounge and created by members of the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00491-00103791-00103975": "artist suffrage league", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00492-00103976-00104166": "herrion contributed silk that she", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00493-00104167-00104294": "brought back from india", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00494-00104295-00104463": "which was used in banners such as the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00495-00104464-00104686": "one on the left carried by the students", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00496-00104688-00104934": "from the cambridge colleges", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00497-00104935-00105127": "and that banner is still actually in", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00498-00105128-00105302": "place at nunum college", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00499-00105303-00105583": "very fitting actually that it was newnam", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00500-00105583-00105702": "um because that's", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00501-00105703-00105951": "the college that um herringham gave some", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00502-00105952-00106247": "financial assistance to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00503-00106248-00106486": "but also crucially herringham herself", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00504-00106488-00106710": "embroidered at least two of the banners", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00505-00106711-00106902": "that for the women's writers suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00506-00106903-00107086": "league which you can see", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00507-00107088-00107302": "on the right and the artist suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00508-00107303-00107510": "league which is in the middle", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00509-00107511-00107695": "um and they're emblazoned the artist", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00510-00107696-00107863": "suffrage league banner is emblazoned", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00511-00107864-00107943": "with the words", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00512-00107944-00108334": "alliance not defiance very sadly", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00513-00108335-00108654": "um a lot of the banners are still in", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00514-00108655-00108751": "existence", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00515-00108752-00109031": "but cannot be unrolled and therefore", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00516-00109032-00109166": "photographed", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00517-00109167-00109351": "so some of the banners that herringham", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00518-00109352-00109590": "worked on we're not able to have modern", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00519-00109591-00109702": "photographs of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00520-00109703-00109847": "um the one that you can see in the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00521-00109848-00110039": "middle the artist suffrage lead", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00522-00110040-00110295": "that's actually a photograph from a 1987", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00523-00110296-00110407": "book", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00524-00110408-00110558": "and unfortunately it can't now be", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00525-00110559-00110823": "enrolled because it's deteriorated", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00526-00110824-00111127": "so much so it's really a little bit sad", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00527-00111128-00111263": "that herringham's work is", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00528-00111264-00111695": "in many ways disintegrating", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00529-00111696-00111878": "by employing the traditionally feminine", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00530-00111879-00112054": "craft of embroidery in the making of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00531-00112055-00112158": "these banners", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00532-00112159-00112327": "women such as herring were able to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00533-00112328-00112519": "combine their artistic skills and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00534-00112520-00112599": "politics", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00535-00112600-00112919": "without sacrificing their femininity", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00536-00112920-00113086": "the artist suffrage league regularly", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00537-00113088-00113310": "held competitions in which cash prizes", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00538-00113311-00113399": "were offered", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00539-00113400-00113583": "to the best propaganda and poster", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00540-00113583-00113702": "designs", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00541-00113703-00113854": "now herring him doesn't seem to have", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00542-00113855-00114054": "actually taken part in these", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00543-00114055-00114151": "competitions", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00544-00114152-00114383": "in that she hasn't contributed some to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00545-00114383-00114478": "be judged", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00546-00114479-00114727": "um but you can see how central she was", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00547-00114728-00114910": "to the artists of fridge league", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00548-00114911-00115151": "because she actually did the judging in", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00549-00115152-00115519": "at least one of the competitions", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00550-00115520-00115823": "she was also responsible in march 1908", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00551-00115824-00116039": "for funding the holloway brooch designed", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00552-00116040-00116207": "by the artist suffrage league", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00553-00116208-00116390": "to give to members of the more militant", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00554-00116391-00116575": "women's freedom league on their release", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00555-00116576-00116758": "from prison", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00556-00116759-00116927": "the same year she also sat on the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00557-00116928-00117134": "organising committee for the bazaar", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00558-00117135-00117302": "held by the women's freedom league at", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00559-00117303-00117551": "caxton hall from the 31st of march to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00560-00117552-00117719": "the 1st of april", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00561-00117720-00117910": "the bazaar included a mock holloway", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00562-00117911-00118183": "prison cell cookery demonstrations", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00563-00118183-00118415": "musical performances as well as a", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00564-00118416-00118607": "special exhibition of chinese and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00565-00118608-00118766": "japanese antiques", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00566-00118767-00118927": "the mystery donor of the objects for", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00567-00118928-00119095": "this exhibition was herringham", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00568-00119096-00119295": "who lent her own personal collection for", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00569-00119296-00119399": "the occasion", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00570-00119400-00119590": "and many of these artifacts are now in", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00571-00119591-00119807": "the collections at both royal holloway", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00572-00119808-00120166": "and union college cambridge", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00573-00120167-00120423": "in the same year herringham was also a", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00574-00120424-00120678": "founding member of may morris's women's", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00575-00120679-00120783": "guild of art", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00576-00120783-00120983": "along with many female figures from both", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00577-00120983-00121127": "the arts and crafts movement", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00578-00121128-00121295": "and members of the artists suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00579-00121296-00121558": "league now the reason that the women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00580-00121559-00121783": "were so keen to found a women's guild of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00581-00121783-00122047": "art is because the men's guild of art", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00582-00122048-00122134": "wouldn't allow", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00583-00122135-00122471": "women members um very much like the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00584-00122472-00122663": "royal academy of arts at this point", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00585-00122664-00122943": "there were no female royal academicians", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00586-00122944-00123119": "in fact there hadn't been any female", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00587-00123120-00123254": "role academicians", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00588-00123255-00123599": "since 1768 when two women helped found", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00589-00123600-00123743": "the royal academy", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00590-00123744-00123990": "um and so i guess in many ways these", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00591-00123991-00124110": "women artists were", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00592-00124111-00124407": "really feeling the glass ceiling um and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00593-00124408-00124558": "it's really significant i think that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00594-00124559-00124719": "they came together", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00595-00124720-00124975": "in order to um i guess break through", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00596-00124976-00125175": "that or if they couldn't join", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00597-00125176-00125407": "these male dominated guilds they created", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00598-00125408-00125863": "their own to give themselves a voice", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00599-00125864-00126095": "so one of the names that you'll see on", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00600-00126096-00126463": "this list that's in front of you", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00601-00126464-00126766": "is annie l swinnerton and she's about in", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00602-00126767-00127158": "the middle just under marion stokes", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00603-00127159-00127495": "and swinnerton is one of the women that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00604-00127496-00127758": "we think herring met through millicent", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00605-00127759-00127975": "fawcett", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00606-00127976-00128302": "so in this circle that fawcett", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00607-00128303-00128671": "had around her um she met harry and met", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00608-00128672-00128934": "other women artists and was actually", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00609-00128935-00129119": "able to use her independent wealth to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00610-00129120-00129310": "support them", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00611-00129311-00129495": "she commissioned annie swinneton to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00612-00129496-00129927": "paint her two sons in 1889", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00613-00129928-00130278": "and here is the portrait of jeffrey and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00614-00130279-00130719": "chris herringham painted in 1889.", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00615-00130720-00130919": "herringham's commission was very early", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00616-00130920-00131166": "on in swinnerton's career", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00617-00131167-00131335": "but elizabeth crawford has actually", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00618-00131336-00131478": "discovered that harrington wasn't the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00619-00131479-00131559": "only woman", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00620-00131560-00131719": "in the faucet circle to commission", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00621-00131720-00131990": "swinnerton so clearly this circle was", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00622-00131991-00132247": "key to swinnerton early on in her career", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00623-00132248-00132559": "and it seems as if those women who were", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00624-00132560-00132702": "involved in suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00625-00132703-00132935": "were very keen to support artists who", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00626-00132936-00133102": "were also involved in suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00627-00133103-00133302": "i think it was being able to commission", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00628-00133303-00133447": "a kindred spirit", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00629-00133448-00133751": "um to produce family portraits", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00630-00133752-00133943": "swinnerton was born near manchester and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00631-00133944-00134143": "was one of seven daughters", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00632-00134144-00134390": "in 1871 she entered the manchester", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00633-00134391-00134519": "school of art where she won a", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00634-00134520-00134607": "scholarship", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00635-00134608-00134823": "for watercolor and a gold medal for oil", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00636-00134824-00134975": "painting", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00637-00134976-00135175": "like many female artists of her date she", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00638-00135176-00135375": "was frustrated by the limitations of the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00639-00135376-00135551": "training on offer to women artists in", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00640-00135552-00135719": "britain", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00641-00135720-00136102": "for instance at this point in the 1870s", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00642-00136103-00136319": "women were allowed to go to the royal", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00643-00136320-00136439": "academy schools", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00644-00136440-00136599": "but they weren't allowed to undertake", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00645-00136600-00136871": "life drawing classes until the 1890s so", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00646-00136872-00137095": "almost 20 years later", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00647-00137096-00137351": "and life drawing was one of the key", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00648-00137352-00137414": "elements", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00649-00137415-00137654": "of an artist training at that point so", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00650-00137655-00137839": "if you're denied being able to do that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00651-00137840-00137911": "training", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00652-00137912-00138127": "then it could be argued you weren't", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00653-00138128-00138302": "allowed to fulfill your potential as an", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00654-00138303-00138559": "artist as a whole", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00655-00138560-00138807": "to supply the deficiency of her art", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00656-00138808-00138895": "education", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00657-00138896-00139151": "she traveled to rome in 1871 with her", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00658-00139152-00139295": "friend susan dhaka", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00659-00139296-00139559": "and studied there for two years and on", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00660-00139560-00139759": "her return to manchester", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00661-00139760-00140014": "susan dhaka and danny swinnetton founded", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00662-00140015-00140199": "the manchester society for women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00663-00140200-00140431": "painters in order to promote the work of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00664-00140432-00140543": "female artists", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00665-00140544-00140743": "and to offer them access to additional", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00666-00140744-00140871": "training", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00667-00140872-00141183": "by 1877 swinnerton's desire to improve", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00668-00141184-00141271": "her work", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00669-00141272-00141543": "took her and daca to paris to study at", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00670-00141544-00141599": "the academy", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00671-00141600-00141902": "julienne this was one of the leading art", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00672-00141903-00142111": "schools in france but more importantly", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00673-00142112-00142271": "for british female artists", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00674-00142272-00142502": "it offered them access to life drawing", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00675-00142503-00142702": "which was seen as essential for any", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00676-00142703-00142951": "serious painter in the 19th century", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00677-00142952-00143511": "but in england was denied to women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00678-00143512-00143687": "despite the prejudice and restraints on", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00679-00143688-00143847": "women artists swinnerton had a", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00680-00143848-00143975": "flourishing career", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00681-00143976-00144175": "her reputation led to her friendship", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00682-00144176-00144375": "with the society portrait painter john", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00683-00144376-00144502": "singer sergeant", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00684-00144503-00144678": "and it was sergeant who supported her", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00685-00144679-00144871": "election as an associate member of the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00686-00144872-00145047": "royal academy", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00687-00145048-00145366": "so in 1922 she became the first woman", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00688-00145367-00145671": "in almost 150 years to become a member", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00689-00145672-00145814": "of the royal academy", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00690-00145815-00146014": "despite the fact that as i said two", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00691-00146015-00146263": "female artists had helped family academy", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00692-00146264-00146526": "in 1768.", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00693-00146527-00146711": "swinnerton was an active campaigner for", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00694-00146712-00146831": "women's suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00695-00146832-00146983": "and like herringham she signed the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00696-00146984-00147195": "petition demanding the vote for women in", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00697-00147196-00147463": "1889", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00698-00147464-00147743": "and this signing of that petition links", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00699-00147744-00147783": "us", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00700-00147784-00148095": "to another of swinnerton's um", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00701-00148096-00148278": "artists that she commissioned female", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00702-00148279-00148454": "artists so this", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00703-00148455-00148695": "is another portrait that we have of her", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00704-00148696-00148814": "two children", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00705-00148815-00149054": "in the art collections at raw holloway", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00706-00149055-00149126": "um it's an", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00707-00149127-00149319": "earlier portrait the two boys are", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00708-00149320-00149535": "slightly younger in this picture so we", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00709-00149536-00149823": "think this dates from about 1887", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00710-00149824-00150102": "and it's by another artist who signed", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00711-00150103-00150431": "that suffrage petition in 1889", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00712-00150432-00150807": "ethel webling", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00713-00150808-00151014": "up until michaela had begun doing her", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00714-00151015-00151223": "phd on herringham", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00715-00151224-00151414": "this portrait was believed to be by an", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00716-00151415-00151599": "artist called ethel webbing", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00717-00151600-00151759": "that's certainly what the label on the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00718-00151760-00151902": "back said", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00719-00151903-00152151": "but michaela realized very quickly that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00720-00152152-00152343": "she couldn't trace any artist of that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00721-00152344-00152414": "name", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00722-00152415-00152639": "um but what she found out is it was an", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00723-00152640-00152831": "artist called effa webling", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00724-00152832-00153207": "who was a miniaturist and a portraitist", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00725-00153208-00153454": "um and the other important thing that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00726-00153455-00153535": "michaela", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00727-00153536-00153775": "found and what has led us to believe", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00728-00153776-00153839": "that this", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00729-00153840-00154087": "picture is in fact by ethel webbling is", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00730-00154088-00154302": "that ethel weblink went to the slade art", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00731-00154303-00154351": "school", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00732-00154352-00154702": "in the 1870s um and that is also where", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00733-00154703-00154863": "christiana harringham", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00734-00154864-00155183": "was training at the same time so", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00735-00155184-00155399": "it seems as if it may be that ethel", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00736-00155400-00155599": "webling and cristiana herringham", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00737-00155600-00155839": "met at the slade art school but it's", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00738-00155840-00155959": "interesting that they", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00739-00155960-00156151": "seem to share the same political beliefs", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00740-00156152-00156295": "because they both signed", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00741-00156296-00156719": "the petition in 1889", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00742-00156720-00156935": "webling was born to a well-read but not", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00743-00156936-00157047": "wealthy family", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00744-00157048-00157214": "her younger sisters went on to be", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00745-00157215-00157423": "successful actresses", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00746-00157424-00157759": "and as children gave poetry recitals", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00747-00157760-00157975": "webling's father recognized her artistic", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00748-00157976-00158087": "talent early on", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00749-00158088-00158239": "and was encouraged to send her to the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00750-00158240-00158583": "slade school of art in the late 1870s", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00751-00158584-00158790": "and in fact it was her artistic talent", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00752-00158791-00158902": "that led to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00753-00158903-00159143": "um her friendship with ruskin but in", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00754-00159144-00159326": "fact her entire family's friendship with", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00755-00159327-00159423": "ruskin", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00756-00159424-00159647": "ruskin very much took an interest in", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00757-00159648-00159814": "webling's art", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00758-00159815-00159966": "and the family went on to have this", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00759-00159967-00160239": "long-lasting friendship with ruskin", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00760-00160240-00160431": "ethel kept the painting easel that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00761-00160432-00160854": "ruskin gave her all her life", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00762-00160855-00161199": "another artist who attended", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00763-00161200-00161431": "the slade school of art was bertha", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00764-00161432-00161551": "newcomb", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00765-00161552-00161863": "it seems likely that both herringham", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00766-00161864-00162078": "and bertha newcomb were at the slade", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00767-00162079-00162414": "school in 1876", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00768-00162415-00162719": "and like webling and herringham", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00769-00162720-00162966": "bertha newcomb was also very supportive", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00770-00162967-00163078": "of the suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00771-00163079-00163495": "movement newcomb had a successful career", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00772-00163496-00163695": "as a figure and landscape painter", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00773-00163696-00163983": "and illustrator her parents were early", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00774-00163984-00164175": "supporters of the central committee of", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00775-00164176-00164390": "the national society of women's suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00776-00164391-00164575": "which actually herring was also a member", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00777-00164576-00164726": "of too", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00778-00164727-00164935": "and like herringham bertha newcomb was a", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00779-00164936-00165119": "founding member of the artist suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00780-00165120-00165366": "league in 1907.", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00781-00165367-00165535": "so as you can see with a lot of these", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00782-00165536-00165735": "women it's the artistic", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00783-00165736-00166014": "interest and the suffrage interest that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00784-00166015-00166254": "um bring these two women together", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00785-00166255-00166447": "it might have been in this case the art", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00786-00166448-00166614": "that started off the friendship", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00787-00166615-00166790": "but very quickly they must have realized", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00788-00166791-00166983": "that they both had interest in suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00789-00166984-00167199": "too", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00790-00167200-00167487": "in 1909 with herringham newcomb was the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00791-00167488-00167583": "honorary", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00792-00167584-00167823": "secretary of a committee that collected", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00793-00167824-00167911": "signatures", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00794-00167912-00168119": "of men of standing in favor of women's", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00795-00168120-00168359": "and fright and franchisement", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00796-00168360-00168543": "the society used the herringbone's home", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00797-00168544-00168735": "on whimple street as the address for the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00798-00168736-00168838": "society", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00799-00168839-00169071": "which again just underlines herringham's", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00800-00169072-00169511": "role in the suffrage movement", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00801-00169512-00169790": "also bertha newcomb created one of the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00802-00169791-00169863": "records", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00803-00169864-00170063": "of the suffrage movement now i'm not", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00804-00170064-00170183": "going to say um", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00805-00170184-00170502": "that this is a record of a particular", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00806-00170503-00170726": "moment that's actually true to that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00807-00170727-00170847": "moment", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00808-00170848-00171135": "um it was painted much after the event", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00809-00171136-00171326": "but it's really interesting that bertha", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00810-00171327-00171414": "newcomb", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00811-00171415-00171726": "in about 1910 decides to look back at", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00812-00171727-00171926": "significant moments in suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00813-00171927-00172223": "and chooses to produce this oil painting", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00814-00172224-00172414": "at the moment that john stuart mills", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00815-00172415-00172583": "receives the petition", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00816-00172584-00172831": "from emily davis and garrett elizabeth", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00817-00172832-00172926": "garrett", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00818-00172927-00173151": "and so there was an earlier petition", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00819-00173152-00173311": "before the 1889", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00820-00173312-00173671": "one that uh swinnerton", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00821-00173672-00173926": "webling and herringham sign and in some", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00822-00173927-00174119": "ways was a more significant moment", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00823-00174120-00174278": "because it was the first petition to be", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00824-00174279-00174431": "brought to parliament", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00825-00174432-00174647": "and for some reason the women didn't", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00826-00174648-00174831": "want a big fuss made of handing the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00827-00174832-00175038": "petition over to john stuart mills", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00828-00175039-00175238": "so the rumor has it that they hid it", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00829-00175239-00175454": "under an apple cart in westminster hall", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00830-00175455-00175543": "which is what", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00831-00175544-00175831": "bertha newcombe has decided um to choose", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00832-00175832-00176031": "to paint", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00833-00176032-00176254": "so in many ways it's seen as this very", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00834-00176255-00176431": "significant moment in the suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00835-00176432-00176502": "movement", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00836-00176503-00176702": "and i think she must have felt the need", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00837-00176703-00176895": "to record that moment", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00838-00176896-00177190": "um as a way of kind of reinvigorating", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00839-00177191-00177287": "the suffrage", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00840-00177288-00177663": "movement at that time", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00841-00177664-00178007": "the petition had 1499", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00842-00178008-00178295": "signatures and as i turned to my last", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00843-00178296-00178471": "woman that i'm going to look at today", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00844-00178472-00178759": "um she was one of those that signed that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00845-00178760-00179047": "petition in 1866.", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00846-00179048-00179351": "her name is annie swonick", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00847-00179352-00179726": "and she was born in 1813 to a unitarian", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00848-00179727-00179831": "family", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00849-00179832-00180119": "she was educated at home but unusually", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00850-00180120-00180366": "she wanted to carry on her education", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00851-00180367-00180614": "beyond the age that was usual for girls", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00852-00180615-00180719": "at the time", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00853-00180720-00180983": "so in fact in 1839 she went to berlin", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00854-00180984-00181183": "where she studied german and greek and", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00855-00181184-00181399": "gained a knowledge of hebrew", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00856-00181400-00181759": "when she returned to england in 1843", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00857-00181760-00181959": "she commenced translating some of the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00858-00181960-00182087": "german dramatists", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00859-00182088-00182271": "and then moved on to translating greek", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00860-00182272-00182614": "literature at the suggestion of bunsen", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00861-00182615-00182838": "she was very heavily committed to the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00862-00182839-00183038": "cause of women's education", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00863-00183039-00183238": "she was a member of the councils of both", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00864-00183239-00183423": "queens and bedford colleges", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00865-00183424-00183654": "in london and for some time she was", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00866-00183655-00183726": "president", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00867-00183727-00183926": "of bedford college at a point when there", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00868-00183927-00184223": "wasn't formally a principal", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00869-00184224-00184407": "she assisted in the founding of guertin", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00870-00184408-00184647": "college in cambridge and somerville hall", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00871-00184648-00184871": "in oxford and extending the kings", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00872-00184872-00185063": "college lectures to women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00873-00185064-00185366": "to all these institutions she subscribed", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00874-00185367-00185438": "liberally", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00875-00185439-00185702": "so um this is woman with independent", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00876-00185703-00185863": "means and like herringham", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00877-00185864-00186113": "she's giving that to support um", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00878-00186114-00186238": "[Music]", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00879-00186239-00186495": "the causes very close to her and in this", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00880-00186496-00186623": "case with annie swanick", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00881-00186624-00186878": "that's women's higher education she", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00882-00186879-00187063": "strongly advocated the study of english", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00883-00187064-00187247": "literature in universities", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00884-00187248-00187447": "and herself lectured privately on the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00885-00187448-00187607": "subject to young working men", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00886-00187608-00187807": "and women so it wasn't just women at the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00887-00187808-00187919": "middle classes", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00888-00187920-00188150": "it was the working classes as well that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00889-00188151-00188335": "she wanted to help", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00890-00188336-00188575": "um in fact such was her work that the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00891-00188576-00188783": "university of aberdeen conferred on her", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00892-00188784-00188847": "an", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00893-00188848-00189287": "honorary degree um later in her life", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00894-00189288-00189519": "so that brings us full circle and to the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00895-00189520-00189638": "end of the talk", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00896-00189639-00189871": "um annie swanick as i said was the only", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00897-00189872-00190038": "one of the women to have signed that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00898-00190039-00190166": "very early", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00899-00190167-00190535": "suffrage petition um from 1866", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00900-00190536-00190759": "but i hope that you feel that you have", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00901-00190760-00190935": "heard about a number of women that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00902-00190936-00191126": "perhaps you hadn't heard about before", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00903-00191127-00191271": "who were really important to the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00904-00191272-00191447": "suffrage movement", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00905-00191448-00191687": "as i said millicent faucet very much is", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00906-00191688-00191807": "at the center", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00907-00191808-00192078": "of those women but i hope you can see", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00908-00192079-00192166": "that women like", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00909-00192167-00192478": "herringham bertha newcomb eva webbling", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00910-00192479-00192647": "they were all part of that web and they", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00911-00192648-00192807": "were all interconnected", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00912-00192808-00193063": "the threads that held them together were", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00913-00193064-00193335": "the support for women's higher education", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00914-00193336-00193638": "women's suffrage and a woman's right to", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00915-00193639-00193807": "be an artist", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00916-00193808-00194054": "and these threads really kind of combine", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00917-00194055-00194175": "all these artworks", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00918-00194176-00194407": "um that we have in royal holloway that", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00919-00194408-00194614": "by these women", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00920-00194615-00194823": "i hope you've enjoyed that talk um it", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00921-00194824-00195054": "was part of a partner talk", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00922-00195055-00195311": "um for international women's day which", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00923-00195312-00195559": "took place on march the 8th this year", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00924-00195560-00195783": "um if you'd like to see the first of the", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00925-00195784-00195863": "two", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00926-00195864-00196078": "talks that we gave um to celebrate", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00927-00196079-00196238": "international women's day", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00928-00196239-00196438": "you can find the first one on our", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00929-00196439-00196543": "digital museum", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00930-00196544-00196899": "as well thank you very much for", "TGnfCw5HH0g-00931-00196900-00197200": "listening"}}, {"audio_id": "TGHa4SQp_2M", "text": {"TGHa4SQp_2M-00000-00000079-00001183": "[Music]", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00001-00001184-00001531": "thank you", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00002-00001532-00001775": "every year new tools and enhancements", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00003-00001776-00001955": "come from SolidWorks customer feedback", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00004-00001955-00002189": "and end up inside the software", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00005-00002190-00002381": "without all that great customer feedback", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00006-00002382-00002602": "this software wouldn't be nearly as", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00007-00002603-00002765": "powerful and user friendly as it is", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00008-00002766-00002879": "today", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00009-00002880-00003107": "let's see what's new within SolidWorks", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00010-00003108-00003365": "2023 specifically within the structure", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00011-00003365-00003617": "system and weldman's area", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00012-00003618-00003869": "the structure system tool allows you to", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00013-00003870-00004090": "select all of the 2D and 3D sketches", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00014-00004092-00004354": "with one quick Windows select so that", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00015-00004355-00004535": "you can make changes to the weldment", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00016-00004536-00004804": "profiles in bulk using the secondary", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00017-00004805-00005002": "members tool allows you to quickly add", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00018-00005003-00005327": "members to the project using planes to", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00019-00005328-00005543": "locate the weldman members", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00020-00005544-00005795": "structure system tool gives you a bunch", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00021-00005796-00005986": "of flexibility and reduction in design", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00022-00005987-00006202": "time let's take a look at what's new and", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00023-00006203-00006347": "improved within the corner management", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00024-00006348-00006472": "tool", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00025-00006473-00006701": "this tool makes quick work of trim order", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00026-00006702-00006917": "by which you can change how your", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00027-00006918-00007223": "weldmans are joined previously Each", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00028-00007223-00007481": "corner had to be updated individually a", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00029-00007481-00007864": "tedious and error prone task in 2023 the", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00030-00007865-00008159": "new group similar Corners option applies", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00031-00008159-00008405": "a corner treatment to a group saving", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00032-00008406-00008609": "tons of time and effort and ensuring", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00033-00008610-00008867": "accuracy in your design patterning has", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00034-00008868-00009059": "been improved and is now faster than", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00035-00009060-00009192": "ever before", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00036-00009193-00009424": "these big improvements come directly", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00037-00009425-00009635": "from the brand new pattern connection", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00038-00009636-00009946": "element tool where you can insert a", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00039-00009947-00010121": "connection element to all similar", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00040-00010122-00010487": "Corners with the option to skip instance", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00041-00010488-00010792": "this is another huge Time Saver lastly", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00042-00010793-00010985": "you can now change the sizes of your", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00043-00010986-00011285": "weldmans all at once and add them to a", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00044-00011286-00011524": "configuration this new Option will", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00045-00011525-00011753": "enable you to use configurations and", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00046-00011754-00011999": "experiment with your designs all while", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00047-00012000-00012173": "allowing you to work faster than ever", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00048-00012174-00012406": "before", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00049-00012407-00012617": "[Music]", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00050-00012618-00012781": "foreign", "TGHa4SQp_2M-00051-00012782-00013513": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "TGVb795CKdk", "text": {"TGVb795CKdk-00000-00000400-00000782": "[Music]", "TGVb795CKdk-00001-00000783-00000991": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "TGWp9_pzviY", "text": {"TGWp9_pzviY-00000-00000008-00000206": "and i've been doing all this what you", "TGWp9_pzviY-00001-00000208-00000327": "mentioned", "TGWp9_pzviY-00002-00000328-00000455": "you know for", "TGWp9_pzviY-00003-00000456-00000695": "some time now and", "TGWp9_pzviY-00004-00000696-00000975": "there was such insightful information", "TGWp9_pzviY-00005-00000976-00001150": "and not just", "TGWp9_pzviY-00006-00001151-00001350": "technically but also emotionally you", "TGWp9_pzviY-00007-00001351-00001574": "know because when you have that no how", "TGWp9_pzviY-00008-00001575-00001823": "do you encounter it do you go back or", "TGWp9_pzviY-00009-00001823-00002110": "you do you just leave it and move on so", "TGWp9_pzviY-00010-00002111-00002350": "there's so many things not just", "TGWp9_pzviY-00011-00002351-00002510": "the technical part of it that you know", "TGWp9_pzviY-00012-00002511-00002742": "you have to ask open-ended questions but", "TGWp9_pzviY-00013-00002743-00002934": "emotionally also that how do you connect", "TGWp9_pzviY-00014-00002935-00003158": "so it was both you know", "TGWp9_pzviY-00015-00003159-00003335": "both things coming together a full", "TGWp9_pzviY-00016-00003336-00003503": "package and you know how do you take", "TGWp9_pzviY-00017-00003504-00003790": "care of yourself and the customer both", "TGWp9_pzviY-00018-00003792-00003951": "so thank you so much for a very", "TGWp9_pzviY-00019-00003952-00004360": "meaningful and insightful session"}}, {"audio_id": "TGZOxanDmSQ", "text": {"TGZOxanDmSQ-00000-00000008-00000262": "hello everyone and welcome", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00001-00000263-00000515": "this is being live streamed on", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00002-00000516-00000711": "twitch.tv", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00003-00000712-00000886": "and hopefully will be uploaded to", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00004-00000888-00001527": "youtube at a later date", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00005-00001528-00001695": "this is my first playthrough of resident", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00006-00001696-00001926": "evil village i've already configured the", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00007-00001927-00002030": "game", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00008-00002032-00002502": "so it should be ready to go", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00009-00002503-00002631": "i'll just play through on standard", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00010-00002632-00003527": "difficulty", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00011-00003528-00003743": "long ago a young girl went with her", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00012-00003744-00003959": "mother to pick berries for her father", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00013-00003960-00004167": "who was hard at work", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00014-00004168-00004359": "but the forest greeted them with a dark", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00015-00004360-00004735": "cold silence the bushes empty", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00016-00004736-00004943": "yet determined to find the berries the", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00017-00004944-00005135": "rascal broke free from mother's grasp", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00018-00005136-00005406": "and vanished into the trees", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00019-00005407-00005638": "mothers worried cries faded fast as the", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00020-00005639-00005927": "girl ran on over vine and under branch", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00021-00005928-00006118": "and into the forest deep", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00022-00006119-00006343": "feeling strange eyes upon her the girl", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00023-00006344-00006550": "recalled mother's scary bedtime tales", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00024-00006551-00006878": "and her throat became bone dry", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00025-00006879-00007119": "then the pet lord appeared he greeted", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00026-00007120-00007463": "her warmly and bit his own wing come", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00027-00007464-00007783": "child quench your thirst he said so she", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00028-00007784-00008055": "drank the thick dark blood and smiled", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00029-00008056-00008207": "with joy", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00030-00008208-00008439": "passing through the graveyard menacing", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00031-00008440-00008767": "storm clouds loomed and the air turned", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00032-00008768-00009023": "bitingly cold the girl was shivering in", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00033-00009024-00009287": "her thin clothes then a dark weaver", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00034-00009288-00009559": "appeared and with a click of his fingers", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00035-00009560-00009951": "crafted mist into a beautiful dress come", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00036-00009952-00010287": "child warm yourself he coaxed so she", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00037-00010288-00010878": "clothed herself and smiled with joy", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00038-00010879-00011174": "across waters deep and ominous she went", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00039-00011175-00011359": "hoping a boat she found would carry her", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00040-00011360-00011487": "home", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00041-00011488-00011678": "but hunger's grip tightened and her", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00042-00011679-00012023": "heart grew heavy", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00043-00012024-00012270": "then the fish king appeared and offered", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00044-00012271-00012687": "one of his many fins come child eat your", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00045-00012688-00012927": "fill so the girl ate", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00046-00012928-00013247": "and smiled with joy once more", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00047-00013247-00013535": "continuing on she soon entered the", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00048-00013536-00013758": "forest dark heart", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00049-00013759-00014015": "then an iron steed appeared bearing a", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00050-00014016-00014319": "beautiful golden gear", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00051-00014319-00014511": "the creature said nothing as the girl", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00052-00014512-00014775": "approached and snatched what she thought", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00053-00014776-00015002": "was another gift", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00054-00015003-00015135": "[Music]", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00055-00015136-00015383": "the horse grew angry and summoned the", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00056-00015384-00015735": "other monsters", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00057-00015736-00015975": "terror filled the girl's heart as the", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00058-00015976-00016271": "wild wind rose around the beast", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00059-00016272-00016583": "suddenly a witch appeared dark", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00060-00016584-00017383": "yet regal", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00061-00017384-00017647": "gifts we gave but more you took she", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00062-00017648-00017767": "snarled", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00063-00017768-00018055": "so more in turn is due", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00064-00018056-00018343": "in a blink the girl was trapped inside a", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00065-00018344-00018743": "mirror", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00066-00018744-00018935": "there", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00067-00018936-00019199": "she's asleep", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00068-00019200-00019439": "what is with the creepy story she's only", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00069-00019440-00019639": "six months old", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00070-00019640-00019767": "woman at the store said it was", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00071-00019768-00019975": "traditional", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00072-00019976-00020239": "a local tale", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00073-00020240-00020375": "besides", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00074-00020376-00020583": "rose doesn't seem to mind", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00075-00020584-00020791": "because she doesn't understand it thank", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00076-00020792-00020903": "god", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00077-00020904-00021030": "we moved here so that she wouldn't have", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00078-00021031-00021167": "to deal with any of that remember", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00079-00021168-00021535": "there's nothing wrong with my memory", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00080-00021536-00021886": "you're just being paranoid it's not", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00081-00021887-00022127": "never mind i'm sorry", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00082-00022128-00022407": "but i'm not paranoid i'm just cautious", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00083-00022408-00022550": "then", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00084-00022551-00023167": "go cautiously take your daughter to bed", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00085-00023168-00024286": "i'll finish dinner", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00086-00024287-00024463": "it's okay rose", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00087-00024464-00024727": "your mother doesn't want to remember it", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00088-00024728-00025150": "i can't blame her", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00089-00025151-00025255": "okay", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00090-00025256-00025486": "did you say something nothing i'll put", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00091-00025487-00025814": "her down", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00092-00025816-00026158": "yeah the way he said that", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00093-00026160-00026311": "when you talk about putting your dog", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00094-00026312-00026511": "down doesn't mean the same thing as", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00095-00026512-00027174": "putting them to bed", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00096-00027175-00027958": "oh no narration", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00097-00027960-00028151": "so i get to look at stuff after i put", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00098-00028152-00028862": "the baby in bed", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00099-00028863-00030151": "oh my there's a whole house to look at", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00100-00030152-00030311": "i assume some sort of children's", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00101-00030312-00031358": "programming", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00102-00031360-00031599": "this is a fairly nice house", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00103-00031600-00032518": "looks pretty old too", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00104-00032519-00033159": "very generic photos on the wall though", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00105-00033160-00033343": "i don't even know what the hell that is", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00106-00033344-00033983": "supposed to be a photo of", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00107-00033984-00034111": "i mean it could be water but i think", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00108-00034112-00035118": "it's upside down if it's water", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00109-00035119-00035287": "i swear those are the highest quality", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00110-00035288-00036174": "pickles i've ever seen in a video game", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00111-00036175-00036318": "it's sad that they covered up all this", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00112-00036319-00036639": "detail under so much blur", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00113-00036640-00037399": "mom got you another new book", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00114-00037400-00037543": "once you're a big girl we'll have a", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00115-00037544-00037790": "drink together all right", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00116-00037791-00038271": "that's quite a few years from now", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00117-00038272-00039335": "i mean unless you're in europe", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00118-00039336-00039511": "oh mia", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00119-00039512-00040087": "what a miracle", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00120-00040088-00040239": "yeah it's surprising that either of you", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00121-00040240-00040927": "made it out of that debacle", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00122-00040928-00041495": "hurry up and put rose to sleep will you", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00123-00041496-00041655": "our taste of music's definitely improved", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00124-00041656-00041767": "over the years", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00125-00041768-00042001": "you mean mine has", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00126-00042002-00042799": "[Music]", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00127-00042800-00042958": "okay so it has a little caption if you", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00128-00042959-00043327": "press the button again", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00129-00043328-00043535": "i just assumed it played the same", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00130-00043536-00043718": "sound clip over and over", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00131-00043719-00044007": "each time you collect it", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00132-00044008-00044151": "you hungry", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00133-00044152-00044246": "no", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00134-00044247-00044455": "maybe later then", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00135-00044456-00044639": "she looks like she's asleep", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00136-00044640-00045158": "why would she be hungry", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00137-00045159-00045471": "unless you didn't feed her", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00138-00045472-00045702": "does this in office don't get your water", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00139-00045703-00045927": "out of the tap", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00140-00045928-00046071": "i guess some people do have those in", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00141-00046072-00046479": "their homes", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00142-00046480-00046711": "wait the head note to ethan", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00143-00046712-00046958": "don't give her any sugar or honey and no", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00144-00046959-00047343": "mushrooms", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00145-00047344-00048286": "really", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00146-00048287-00048439": "her birthday will be here before we know", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00147-00048440-00048695": "it they grow up fast", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00148-00048696-00048895": "let's just enjoy it while we can do you", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00149-00048896-00049686": "guys have a ton of food sitting out", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00150-00049687-00049879": "it looks like she's cooking dinner", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00151-00049880-00050399": "there's dinner sitting on the table", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00152-00050400-00050662": "okay that goes to the stairwell", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00153-00050663-00051375": "this looks like a pantry", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00154-00051376-00051502": "it's kind of hard to look at the", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00155-00051503-00051902": "shelving", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00156-00051903-00052335": "half hole flour", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00157-00052336-00052494": "mia makes everything by hand so this", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00158-00052495-00052863": "stuff keeps piling up", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00159-00052864-00053430": "what does that say oh horn of plenty", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00160-00053432-00054271": "jokes of alcohol", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00161-00054272-00054694": "so where on earth do they live now", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00162-00054695-00054982": "got photos from africa", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00163-00054983-00055215": "photos from", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00164-00055216-00055607": "some tropical island", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00165-00055608-00056311": "stock photography", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00166-00056312-00056591": "yeah really generic photos", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00167-00056591-00056982": "what on earth is that", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00168-00056983-00057142": "on earth", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00169-00057144-00057303": "there's some goop in the middle of that", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00170-00057304-00057447": "painting", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00171-00057448-00057830": "well upper right is middle", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00172-00057832-00058119": "strange", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00173-00058120-00058254": "it's difficult to look around with the", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00174-00058255-00058711": "kid in his arms", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00175-00058712-00059063": "she's going to grow up beautiful", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00176-00059064-00060191": "i assume that's a 3d render of the kid", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00177-00060191-00060606": "once things warm up we can go for a walk", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00178-00060607-00061103": "was it winter right now", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00179-00061104-00061319": "i don't know would that be ironic ironic", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00180-00061320-00062503": "since i think his name is winters", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00181-00062504-00062671": "it's like i said to your mom", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00182-00062672-00063119": "that book's too scary for you", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00183-00063120-00063311": "to be fair at her age she wouldn't", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00184-00063312-00064359": "comprehend what's being said", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00185-00064360-00065058": "your mama and i love this song so much", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00186-00065059-00065815": "[Music]", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00187-00065816-00066063": "what song was it", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00188-00066064-00066406": "i couldn't even hear it", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00189-00066407-00066494": "um", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00190-00066495-00067350": "automatic doors", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00191-00067351-00069263": "do they also have automatic toilets", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00192-00069264-00069447": "it's amazing how much texture detail", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00193-00069448-00069638": "there is with the correct sharpening", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00194-00069639-00069735": "filters", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00195-00069736-00069919": "oh is this her room maybe we should look", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00196-00069920-00070279": "at the other rooms first", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00197-00070280-00070438": "just in case we immediately go into a", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00198-00070439-00071423": "cut scene or something", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00199-00071424-00071711": "it's a little dark over here", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00200-00071712-00071967": "bubble head i even keep this around", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00201-00071968-00072199": "i should get rid of it someday", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00202-00072200-00072367": "is it the bobble heads i was shooting in", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00203-00072368-00072582": "the last game were there bobble heads in", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00204-00072583-00072815": "the last game", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00205-00072816-00073159": "i no longer remember", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00206-00073160-00073671": "i vividly remember the last game but", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00207-00073672-00073799": "i don't remember much in the way of", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00208-00073800-00074006": "details before rose starts walking", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00209-00074007-00074182": "around", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00210-00074183-00074375": "yeah that's probably a good idea this", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00211-00074376-00074759": "room is very dirty", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00212-00074760-00075287": "especially some of this furniture", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00213-00075288-00075655": "eastern european castles and keeps", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00214-00075656-00076143": "so we're in eastern europe somewhere", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00215-00076144-00076455": "so in order to escape their fears they", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00216-00076456-00077006": "move to cross an ocean", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00217-00077007-00077647": "seems a little strange", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00218-00077648-00077782": "maybe they were trying to escape more", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00219-00077783-00078023": "than their fears", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00220-00078024-00078455": "horn of plenty", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00221-00078456-00078799": "toxic gas leaks in louisiana", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00222-00078800-00079215": "in 2017.", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00223-00079216-00079399": "so the incident", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00224-00079400-00079687": "in the previous game was blamed on toxic", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00225-00079688-00079959": "gas leaks", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00226-00079960-00080359": "yep", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00227-00080360-00080471": "apparently", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00228-00080472-00080694": "ethan and his wife", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00229-00080695-00081311": "are m.i.a", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00230-00081312-00081503": "10 years before the area is it", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00231-00081504-00081743": "happenable again", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00232-00081744-00083031": "everyone's forgotten about this already", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00233-00083032-00083231": "hmm well i guess there's nothing else to", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00234-00083232-00083631": "see except the baby's room", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00235-00083632-00083759": "they can't run when we're holding the", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00236-00083760-00084199": "baby but i guess that makes sense", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00237-00084200-00084367": "don't imagine the baby would stay asleep", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00238-00084368-00084535": "if you're running around jaw splinted", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00239-00084536-00084823": "all over the place", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00240-00084824-00085031": "oh that's a photo of okay a couple of", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00241-00085032-00085199": "kids trying to figure out what i was", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00242-00085200-00085482": "looking", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00243-00085483-00085750": "at this plant doesn't look too terribly", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00244-00085751-00086326": "great", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00245-00086327-00086599": "wow biggest room in the house", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00246-00086600-00086726": "wait", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00247-00086727-00086967": "ethan and me asleep", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00248-00086968-00087206": "oh this is their room", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00249-00087207-00087575": "and the crib is just in it okay", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00250-00087576-00088335": "i mean that makes sense", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00251-00088336-00088438": "okay", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00252-00088439-00088591": "so we're at the point where it's just", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00253-00088592-00088871": "captions for stuff", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00254-00088872-00089887": "okay look at the other side of the bed", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00255-00089888-00090071": "now considering what he's been through i", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00256-00090072-00090303": "could imagine he'd be terrified every", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00257-00090304-00090526": "time he opened a door", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00258-00090527-00091135": "you know", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00259-00091136-00091982": "can i kick that yes i can", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00260-00091983-00092223": "what's that noise", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00261-00092224-00092438": "oh", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00262-00092439-00093447": "i didn't realize that those moved", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00263-00093448-00094935": "apparently she doesn't like this room", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00264-00094936-00095271": "scrapbook i guess", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00265-00095272-00095494": "like photo album scrapbook whatever i", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00266-00095495-00095943": "wish i could stay like this forever", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00267-00095944-00097838": "stuff it never stays the same ethan", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00268-00097839-00098238": "firearms manual to get you", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00269-00098239-00098879": "time for bed", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00270-00098880-00099799": "well hi there little rose", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00271-00099800-00099999": "that looks like a fairly old stereo", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00272-00100000-00100231": "except for the digital display", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00273-00100232-00100767": "i think it's just designed to look old", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00274-00100768-00101631": "bsaa", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00275-00101632-00102215": "did the bsaa put them up here", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00276-00102216-00102671": "rose is fine", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00277-00102672-00103415": "what is this", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00278-00103416-00103734": "is it a case of some sort or electronic", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00279-00103735-00103878": "device but", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00280-00103879-00104006": "it's got a power button it must be", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00281-00104007-00104342": "electronic device of some sort", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00282-00104343-00104599": "i have no clue this is a turntable", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00283-00104600-00104758": "you don't see those very often these", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00284-00104759-00105110": "days", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00285-00105111-00105975": "this is a very rugged looking laptop", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00286-00105976-00106158": "so apparently she still gets mad at him", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00287-00106159-00106302": "if he mentions what happened in the", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00288-00106303-00106471": "previous game", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00289-00106472-00106631": "okay they are saying they're in europe", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00290-00106632-00106815": "but so far not", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00291-00106816-00107902": "where in europe", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00292-00107903-00108231": "okay just a little bit of plot i guess", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00293-00108232-00108566": "nothing important", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00294-00108567-00108751": "can you keep your mother waiting she's", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00295-00108752-00109110": "scary when she's angry", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00296-00109111-00109302": "yeah", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00297-00109303-00109551": "she also cut your hand off didn't she", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00298-00109552-00109783": "there you go sweetheart", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00299-00109783-00109927": "don't you worry", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00300-00109928-00110102": "i'll be right downstairs", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00301-00110103-00110254": "daddy won't let those weird fairytale", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00302-00110255-00110415": "monsters get you", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00303-00110416-00110871": "this", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00304-00110872-00111134": "will you now", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00305-00111135-00111431": "was that a baby monitor", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00306-00111432-00111671": "probably", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00307-00111672-00111839": "i already looked at that okay so i could", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00308-00111840-00111990": "have looked at everything after putting", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00309-00111991-00112334": "her in the crib", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00310-00112335-00112558": "that's fine", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00311-00112559-00112743": "so there are only two bedrooms in this", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00312-00112744-00113023": "house", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00313-00113024-00113223": "as large as it is i expected more than", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00314-00113224-00113566": "two", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00315-00113567-00113743": "also there's a master bedroom but i", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00316-00113744-00113958": "didn't see a master bathroom of course", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00317-00113959-00114143": "this is europe's maybe that's normal", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00318-00114144-00114407": "have you finished putting her to bed yet", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00319-00114408-00114999": "is she in the bathroom now", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00320-00115000-00115190": "yeah there's a study which interestingly", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00321-00115191-00115295": "enough you have to go through the", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00322-00115296-00115934": "bedroom to get to", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00323-00115935-00116086": "although it's not the only house i've", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00324-00116088-00116334": "seen that's like that", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00325-00116335-00116566": "was she in here no must've been coming", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00326-00116567-00116863": "up the stairs", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00327-00116864-00117015": "don't have lights on one side of the", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00328-00117016-00117407": "room", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00329-00117408-00118047": "strange", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00330-00118048-00118223": "i didn't look at the door", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00331-00118224-00118439": "keep it down just making sure it's", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00332-00118440-00119199": "locked", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00333-00119200-00119383": "okay here's the cutscene i was expecting", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00334-00119383-00119519": "is she okay", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00335-00119520-00119902": "sleeping like uh well like a baby", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00336-00119903-00120127": "hmm that smells good what's that oh", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00337-00120128-00120327": "hands off mister", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00338-00120328-00120671": "it's choba de la gum it's a local recipe", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00339-00120672-00120975": "wow you've gone full native haven't you", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00340-00120976-00121199": "local wine too", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00341-00121200-00121366": "but if you're gonna keep sulking all", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00342-00121367-00121799": "evening maybe you shouldn't have any", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00343-00121800-00122183": "you really have to stop worrying", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00344-00122183-00122447": "it's just finding you in louisiana the", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00345-00122448-00122558": "pregnancy", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00346-00122559-00122719": "chris moving us here", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00347-00122720-00122863": "military training it all happened so", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00348-00122864-00123095": "fast you know well at least we're all", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00349-00123096-00123254": "together", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00350-00123255-00123343": "you", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00351-00123344-00123599": "me rose", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00352-00123600-00123727": "now", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00353-00123728-00123919": "everything's gonna seriously think we", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00354-00123920-00124071": "can just forget about what happened in", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00355-00124072-00124399": "louisiana it happened so long ago", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00356-00124400-00125047": "i just i don't understand why you are so", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00357-00125048-00126071": "mia get down", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00358-00126072-00126375": "i still shooting her", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00359-00126376-00126495": "i think they're just shooting the crap", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00360-00126496-00126671": "out of the house in general she was at", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00361-00126672-00127423": "the wrong place at the wrong time", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00362-00127424-00128078": "oh god", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00363-00128079-00128166": "chris", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00364-00128167-00128495": "what the hell sorry ethan", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00365-00128496-00128775": "no that's not chris", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00366-00128776-00128902": "what", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00367-00128903-00131199": "so what the hell is that pistol", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00368-00131200-00131390": "rose what the hell you do with my", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00369-00131391-00131478": "daughter", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00370-00131479-00131783": "package secure sir", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00371-00131784-00132039": "him away i said get your hands off her", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00372-00132040-00132143": "ethan", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00373-00132144-00132502": "no", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00374-00132503-00132770": "oh", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00375-00132771-00133519": "[Music]", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00376-00133520-00133663": "i don't think they animated the baby", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00377-00133664-00133872": "very well", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00378-00133873-00136691": "[Music]", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00379-00136692-00137351": "[Music]", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00380-00137352-00137831": "she'll see us next week", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00381-00137832-00137959": "hey now", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00382-00137960-00138214": "think positively all right", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00383-00138215-00138590": "we talked about this i know", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00384-00138591-00138943": "we hardly talk about anything else", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00385-00138944-00139190": "i keep telling you it's not rose that", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00386-00139191-00139366": "i'm worried about well then what are you", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00387-00139367-00139495": "worried about", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00388-00139496-00139583": "look", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00389-00139584-00139823": "she's gonna be fine i just know it what", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00390-00139824-00139951": "else matters", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00391-00139952-00140583": "we matter ethan", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00392-00140584-00140751": "what are you talking about", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00393-00140752-00140943": "is there something you're not telling me", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00394-00140944-00141366": "come on talk to me", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00395-00141367-00141527": "damn it", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00396-00141528-00143111": "i have to take this", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00397-00143112-00143407": "that phone interrupts a lot doesn't it", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00398-00143408-00143711": "they throw him out with the trash", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00399-00143712-00143863": "see the snow", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00400-00143864-00144095": "it doesn't look like snow", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00401-00144096-00144343": "doesn't act like snow", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00402-00144344-00146014": "jesus", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00403-00146015-00146199": "what are you talking about", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00404-00146200-00147478": "where's chris redfield and rose", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00405-00147479-00147847": "looks like they got hit", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00406-00147848-00148207": "what the hell happened here", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00407-00148208-00148495": "i might want to search for weapons ethan", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00408-00148496-00148654": "okay i have control so i'm going to", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00409-00148655-00149039": "search for weapons", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00410-00149040-00149263": "eliminate target recover bodies secure", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00411-00149264-00149719": "rosemary winters and even winters", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00412-00149720-00149919": "move the two", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00413-00149920-00150311": "winters", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00414-00150312-00150566": "to site c for further investigation that", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00415-00150567-00150743": "just looks weird", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00416-00150744-00150966": "at least two transport officers to", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00417-00150967-00151631": "accompany them", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00418-00151632-00151990": "of course it's useless it's called plot", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00419-00151991-00152359": "can i not get around this guy", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00420-00152360-00152519": "guns", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00421-00152520-00152726": "guns", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00422-00152727-00153087": "can i get in the vehicle", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00423-00153088-00153519": "no okay there's a collision mesh there", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00424-00153520-00153911": "more than likely", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00425-00153912-00154095": "do they actually call it collision mesh", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00426-00154096-00154911": "these days or in this engine", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00427-00154912-00155031": "right there i wasn't certain if the", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00428-00155032-00155214": "sound was actually synchronized properly", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00429-00155215-00155799": "with the blinking of the light", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00430-00155800-00156575": "interesting", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00431-00156576-00156807": "i'm sure chris survived", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00432-00156808-00157063": "not that it sounded like chris or", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00433-00157064-00157478": "even really looked like chris", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00434-00157479-00158159": "but i'm sure he survived", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00435-00158160-00158375": "granted chris is a lot older people do", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00436-00158376-00158502": "tend to look different when they're", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00437-00158503-00160807": "older", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00438-00160808-00161335": "but we can't stand up yet", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00439-00161336-00162031": "kind of a crappy flashlight", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00440-00162032-00162199": "rockslide", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00441-00162200-00162439": "in the snow", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00442-00162440-00163207": "someone kill a bird here", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00443-00163208-00163375": "the graphics in this game are infinitely", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00444-00163376-00164207": "better than resident evil 7.", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00445-00164208-00164596": "speaking of a bird", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00446-00164597-00164951": "[Music]", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00447-00164952-00165078": "they're actually trying to make this", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00448-00165079-00165287": "scary", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00449-00165288-00165735": "holy cow that's a lot of birds", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00450-00165736-00166902": "that's a lot more birds", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00451-00166903-00167302": "it's not dead", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00452-00167303-00167511": "it looks kind of silly flipping through", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00453-00167512-00168351": "everything now", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00454-00168352-00168566": "what is that sound", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00455-00168567-00169854": "does not sound like a bird", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00456-00169855-00170447": "oh who's that chris", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00457-00170448-00170671": "you can't really run but i doubt ethan", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00458-00170672-00170814": "is dressed for this", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00459-00170815-00171087": "so he's probably freezing", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00460-00171088-00172719": "someone killed all the fish too", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00461-00172720-00173231": "i can't see anything in there", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00462-00173232-00173414": "chain and icicles", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00463-00173415-00174166": "and a broom and a rope", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00464-00174167-00174399": "terrible flashlight", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00465-00174400-00174607": "one of the broom", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00466-00174608-00174751": "oh yeah that's it you can just leave", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00467-00174752-00174966": "that door open", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00468-00174967-00175287": "let yourself freeze to death", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00469-00175288-00175614": "someone's purse", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00470-00175615-00175814": "well you know someone's probably here or", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00471-00175815-00176047": "in the vicinity i mean how many women", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00472-00176048-00176295": "leave without their purse", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00473-00176296-00176878": "plus it's just a spare", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00474-00176879-00177095": "nothing juice in there", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00475-00177096-00177390": "oh potatoes", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00476-00177391-00177583": "please i think those are potatoes", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00477-00177584-00178071": "they look kind of rotten though", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00478-00178072-00178159": "oh", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00479-00178160-00178319": "i think whoever", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00480-00178320-00179254": "lived here hasn't been here in a while", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00481-00179255-00179999": "oh okay i'm just stopping the dripping", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00482-00180000-00180278": "there's the flashlight aimed down", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00483-00180279-00180431": "ethan do you not know how to hold a", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00484-00180432-00180687": "flashlight", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00485-00180688-00181054": "pills nasal spray", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00486-00181055-00181399": "something else", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00487-00181400-00181719": "a lot of potatoes", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00488-00181720-00182263": "nasty looking potatoes", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00489-00182264-00182902": "hmm", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00490-00182903-00183063": "hello", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00491-00183064-00183263": "is there someone else in here", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00492-00183264-00183566": "should probably look up shouldn't i", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00493-00183567-00183990": "oh this bottle fell", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00494-00183991-00184223": "can i open this", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00495-00184224-00184543": "this is where something happens isn't it", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00496-00184544-00184871": "or not", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00497-00184872-00185047": "terrible flashlight why is it pointed at", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00498-00185048-00185414": "the ground", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00499-00185415-00185566": "who points a flashlight at the ground", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00500-00185567-00185702": "when they're trying to see in front of", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00501-00185703-00186607": "them", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00502-00186608-00187126": "this goes down", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00503-00187127-00187295": "are those", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00504-00187296-00187735": "stuffed i mean that is", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00505-00187736-00187887": "judging from the fact that this is here", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00506-00187888-00188047": "i'm going to assume those are stuffed as", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00507-00188048-00188238": "well", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00508-00188239-00188407": "can we take this with us", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00509-00188408-00188966": "it's brighter than the flashlight is", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00510-00188967-00189135": "just bringing back some bad memories", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00511-00189136-00189983": "ethan", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00512-00189984-00190143": "oh garlic", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00513-00190144-00190295": "i think", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00514-00190296-00190623": "i think that's what that is", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00515-00190624-00190807": "someone hang that in here to ward off", "TGZOxanDmSQ-00516-00190808-00191276": "vampires there's a lot of it"}}, {"audio_id": "THoxIONHxrY", "text": {"THoxIONHxrY-00000-00000049-00000303": "spice cake is traditionally flavored", "THoxIONHxrY-00001-00000304-00000546": "with a mixture of spices the cake can be", "THoxIONHxrY-00002-00000547-00000803": "prepared in many varieties predominant", "THoxIONHxrY-00003-00000804-00000986": "flavorings include spices such as", "THoxIONHxrY-00004-00000988-00001260": "cinnamon cloves allspice ginger and", "THoxIONHxrY-00005-00001261-00001805": "nutmeg", "THoxIONHxrY-00006-00001807-00002343": "topic variations", "THoxIONHxrY-00007-00002344-00002592": "a maple spice cake is an American", "THoxIONHxrY-00008-00002593-00002793": "variation that adds maple syrup or", "THoxIONHxrY-00009-00002794-00003027": "flavoring the recipe was a New Hampshire", "THoxIONHxrY-00010-00003028-00003219": "specialty that started in the beginning", "THoxIONHxrY-00011-00003220-00003879": "of the nineteenth century", "THoxIONHxrY-00012-00003880-00004408": "topic see also", "THoxIONHxrY-00013-00004409-00004729": "list of cakes"}}, {"audio_id": "THsD1O5vXU0", "text": {"THsD1O5vXU0-00000-00000000-00000175": "last video was a reviewing spawn", "THsD1O5vXU0-00001-00000176-00000399": "companion three and now i'm going to be", "THsD1O5vXU0-00002-00000400-00000638": "reviewing the moonlight omnibus i just", "THsD1O5vXU0-00003-00000639-00000839": "want to say i i i've gotten used to the", "THsD1O5vXU0-00004-00000840-00001119": "way this book so you won't really hear", "THsD1O5vXU0-00005-00001120-00001814": "grunting from me um like last time", "THsD1O5vXU0-00006-00001816-00002039": "yeah that wasn't fun we've got", "THsD1O5vXU0-00007-00002039-00002231": "uh we've got plenty of time to review", "THsD1O5vXU0-00008-00002232-00002526": "this let me just say ahead", "THsD1O5vXU0-00009-00002527-00002742": "these guys did an amazing job on this", "THsD1O5vXU0-00010-00002743-00003126": "book i i longed for what i launched for", "THsD1O5vXU0-00011-00003127-00003383": "continuing moon knight now like i like", "THsD1O5vXU0-00012-00003384-00003519": "ever since i read the moon lumiere and", "THsD1O5vXU0-00013-00003520-00003775": "small collection i've just been like in", "THsD1O5vXU0-00014-00003776-00004079": "love with moon night and i can't wait to", "THsD1O5vXU0-00015-00004079-00004359": "see more especially judd mckay stuff", "THsD1O5vXU0-00016-00004360-00004559": "because his next volume is coming out", "THsD1O5vXU0-00017-00004560-00004711": "seven days after my birthday and the", "THsD1O5vXU0-00018-00004712-00004935": "next epic collection book is coming out", "THsD1O5vXU0-00019-00004936-00005159": "right on my birthday believe it or not", "THsD1O5vXU0-00020-00005160-00005415": "and i actually just can't wait to see", "THsD1O5vXU0-00021-00005416-00005591": "what they're gonna bring continuing on", "THsD1O5vXU0-00022-00005592-00005791": "moon night because the next book is", "THsD1O5vXU0-00023-00005792-00006063": "called book is called butcher's moon or", "THsD1O5vXU0-00024-00006064-00006222": "the fist of concho i think that would be", "THsD1O5vXU0-00025-00006223-00006406": "like the fifth book or something but", "THsD1O5vXU0-00026-00006408-00006542": "yeah i'm really enjoying", "THsD1O5vXU0-00027-00006543-00006727": "the moon night series so far especially", "THsD1O5vXU0-00028-00006728-00006934": "this like i really like i just started", "THsD1O5vXU0-00029-00006936-00007142": "reading it again like i like i read i", "THsD1O5vXU0-00030-00007143-00007383": "read it immediately again and i'm almost", "THsD1O5vXU0-00031-00007384-00007567": "done with it again", "THsD1O5vXU0-00032-00007568-00007751": "that's a lie no i'm not done with it", "THsD1O5vXU0-00033-00007752-00007919": "again but like i'm taking my time but i", "THsD1O5vXU0-00034-00007920-00008070": "just remember it's like this was so good", "THsD1O5vXU0-00035-00008072-00008319": "i wanted to read it again and i can't", "THsD1O5vXU0-00036-00008320-00008431": "wait to", "THsD1O5vXU0-00037-00008432-00008599": "because i know what happens it's a", "THsD1O5vXU0-00038-00008600-00008783": "really great story it goes through a lot", "THsD1O5vXU0-00039-00008784-00008951": "of great villains bringing back brings", "THsD1O5vXU0-00040-00008952-00009174": "back some classics talks about some", "THsD1O5vXU0-00041-00009175-00009455": "classics goes back to some old enemies i", "THsD1O5vXU0-00042-00009456-00009591": "love it and", "THsD1O5vXU0-00043-00009592-00009759": "they remax and they bring some really", "THsD1O5vXU0-00044-00009760-00009903": "great villains into this they bring the", "THsD1O5vXU0-00045-00009904-00010095": "thunderbolts into this shield gets", "THsD1O5vXU0-00046-00010096-00010335": "involved i love it because it's all", "THsD1O5vXU0-00047-00010336-00010438": "dealing with sort of like the", "THsD1O5vXU0-00048-00010439-00010678": "psychological and supernatural spectrum", "THsD1O5vXU0-00049-00010679-00010967": "of moon knight and", "THsD1O5vXU0-00050-00010968-00011151": "sort of like mark's relationship as he's", "THsD1O5vXU0-00051-00011152-00011310": "getting older and his relationship to", "THsD1O5vXU0-00052-00011311-00011551": "his friends and the impact they have on", "THsD1O5vXU0-00053-00011552-00011783": "him and what he has on them and what he", "THsD1O5vXU0-00054-00011784-00011999": "as moonai has to the rest of the world", "THsD1O5vXU0-00055-00012000-00012183": "and what his search for vengeance and", "THsD1O5vXU0-00056-00012184-00012455": "conscious thirst for vengeance has", "THsD1O5vXU0-00057-00012456-00012735": "driven the world to believe of moon", "THsD1O5vXU0-00058-00012736-00012855": "knight", "THsD1O5vXU0-00059-00012856-00013071": "it was really amazing the art style was", "THsD1O5vXU0-00060-00013072-00013230": "really amazing i read the first five", "THsD1O5vXU0-00061-00013231-00013366": "books which collect like issues one", "THsD1O5vXU0-00062-00013368-00013607": "through thirty moon night annual number", "THsD1O5vXU0-00063-00013608-00013894": "one and moon night silent night", "THsD1O5vXU0-00064-00013895-00014047": "those were really great and i haven't", "THsD1O5vXU0-00065-00014047-00014255": "read any of the books after that", "THsD1O5vXU0-00066-00014256-00014519": "and until now and then when i read them", "THsD1O5vXU0-00067-00014519-00014743": "i was just so in-depth into it", "THsD1O5vXU0-00068-00014744-00014838": "and", "THsD1O5vXU0-00069-00014840-00015007": "seemed like", "THsD1O5vXU0-00070-00015008-00015158": "because i haven't read any of the", "THsD1O5vXU0-00071-00015159-00015319": "shadowland books and shadowland", "THsD1O5vXU0-00072-00015319-00015447": "moonlight is in here and i want to", "THsD1O5vXU0-00073-00015447-00015686": "collect like the shadowland omnibus", "THsD1O5vXU0-00074-00015687-00015958": "um so i can read them all and but i'll", "THsD1O5vXU0-00075-00015959-00016150": "still have shaolin moon knight one", "THsD1O5vXU0-00076-00016151-00016350": "through three in here but um i want to", "THsD1O5vXU0-00077-00016351-00016663": "read like all the shadowland books", "THsD1O5vXU0-00078-00016664-00016943": "for that because i really want to see", "THsD1O5vXU0-00079-00016944-00017175": "what they do because daredevil probably", "THsD1O5vXU0-00080-00017176-00017407": "being possessed and running the hand now", "THsD1O5vXU0-00081-00017408-00017527": "it seems like a really interesting", "THsD1O5vXU0-00082-00017528-00017694": "concept and i really want to read about", "THsD1O5vXU0-00083-00017695-00017847": "it", "THsD1O5vXU0-00084-00017848-00017927": "and", "THsD1O5vXU0-00085-00017928-00018143": "seeing like conch you talk about like a", "THsD1O5vXU0-00086-00018144-00018383": "crescent like a silk like a crescent", "THsD1O5vXU0-00087-00018384-00018607": "moon made from the purest egyptian glass", "THsD1O5vXU0-00088-00018608-00018711": "and", "THsD1O5vXU0-00089-00018712-00018983": "being able to", "THsD1O5vXU0-00090-00018984-00019199": "purge any evil soul out of the body and", "THsD1O5vXU0-00091-00019200-00019303": "they're going to try and do that with", "THsD1O5vXU0-00092-00019304-00019414": "daredevil", "THsD1O5vXU0-00093-00019415-00019679": "and i just can't wait for that because i", "THsD1O5vXU0-00094-00019680-00019911": "like they all came out obviously but", "THsD1O5vXU0-00095-00019912-00020119": "like i really want to read the entire", "THsD1O5vXU0-00096-00020120-00020391": "thing so i know what's going on", "THsD1O5vXU0-00097-00020392-00020471": "but", "THsD1O5vXU0-00098-00020472-00020719": "i'm just excited to see what they bring", "THsD1O5vXU0-00099-00020720-00020943": "and prevention to the moon night issues", "THsD1O5vXU0-00100-00020944-00021175": "1 through 10 it shows mark going back", "THsD1O5vXU0-00101-00021176-00021294": "into the swing of things and his", "THsD1O5vXU0-00102-00021295-00021414": "relationship with our avengers", "THsD1O5vXU0-00103-00021415-00021607": "especially spidey they bring deadpool", "THsD1O5vXU0-00104-00021608-00021775": "into this which i thought was pretty", "THsD1O5vXU0-00105-00021776-00021958": "cool and showing like moon knight", "THsD1O5vXU0-00106-00021959-00022119": "wanting to be hero during avengers on", "THsD1O5vXU0-00107-00022120-00022271": "the moon night and like no killing", "THsD1O5vXU0-00108-00022272-00022375": "whatever", "THsD1O5vXU0-00109-00022376-00022503": "ever", "THsD1O5vXU0-00110-00022504-00022783": "no matter how bad and then seeing like i", "THsD1O5vXU0-00111-00022784-00023063": "gotta do this at some point i have to", "THsD1O5vXU0-00112-00023064-00023151": "kill", "THsD1O5vXU0-00113-00023152-00023678": "[Music]", "THsD1O5vXU0-00114-00023679-00023919": "for the good of my family and for the", "THsD1O5vXU0-00115-00023920-00024086": "good of other people", "THsD1O5vXU0-00116-00024087-00024391": "i don't have friends i got family", "THsD1O5vXU0-00117-00024392-00024567": "and they bring back randall specter from", "THsD1O5vXU0-00118-00024568-00024775": "the dead so that", "THsD1O5vXU0-00119-00024776-00025007": "he can so that he can become shadow", "THsD1O5vXU0-00120-00025008-00025158": "knights", "THsD1O5vXU0-00121-00025159-00025311": "and", "THsD1O5vXU0-00122-00025312-00025478": "it's just very heartbreaking seeing mark", "THsD1O5vXU0-00123-00025479-00025639": "fight his own brother and kill him as", "THsD1O5vXU0-00124-00025639-00025822": "well it was interesting seeing um", "THsD1O5vXU0-00125-00025823-00026014": "jeffrey wilde who becomes midnight again", "THsD1O5vXU0-00126-00026016-00026295": "and then he dies it was very interesting", "THsD1O5vXU0-00127-00026295-00026407": "um", "THsD1O5vXU0-00128-00026408-00026535": "speaking of which i don't know if my", "THsD1O5vXU0-00129-00026536-00026631": "friend i", "THsD1O5vXU0-00130-00026632-00026831": "she gave a shout out to and when i", "THsD1O5vXU0-00131-00026832-00026983": "unboxed this", "THsD1O5vXU0-00132-00026983-00027207": "had read the comics yet but um", "THsD1O5vXU0-00133-00027208-00027351": "i'm hoping they have because it's a", "THsD1O5vXU0-00134-00027352-00027487": "really great storyline if they ever want", "THsD1O5vXU0-00135-00027488-00027711": "to borrow this then yeah i'll give it to", "THsD1O5vXU0-00136-00027712-00027807": "them", "THsD1O5vXU0-00137-00027808-00027879": "but", "THsD1O5vXU0-00138-00027880-00028070": "yeah the art is amazing they have like", "THsD1O5vXU0-00139-00028072-00028239": "they have like a script in the back too", "THsD1O5vXU0-00140-00028239-00028431": "for the first issue which is moonlight", "THsD1O5vXU0-00141-00028432-00028639": "number one from 2006", "THsD1O5vXU0-00142-00028639-00028790": "and", "THsD1O5vXU0-00143-00028791-00028999": "i and it's just really amazing and", "THsD1O5vXU0-00144-00029000-00029335": "reading it is fantastic and", "THsD1O5vXU0-00145-00029336-00029495": "seeing all the work that's done it's", "THsD1O5vXU0-00146-00029495-00029702": "like a movie script but it's like you", "THsD1O5vXU0-00147-00029704-00029990": "hear everything and you image it as", "THsD1O5vXU0-00148-00029991-00030111": "they're talking", "THsD1O5vXU0-00149-00030112-00030423": "excuse me as they're talking about it", "THsD1O5vXU0-00150-00030424-00030679": "and not only that they and not only that", "THsD1O5vXU0-00151-00030680-00030902": "david finch david finch's artwork for", "THsD1O5vXU0-00152-00030903-00031143": "like the first 29 issues is just", "THsD1O5vXU0-00153-00031144-00031327": "phenomenal and i love it", "THsD1O5vXU0-00154-00031327-00031743": "and i i have david finch's batman vol 1", "THsD1O5vXU0-00155-00031744-00031911": "called i am gotham", "THsD1O5vXU0-00156-00031912-00032135": "and it was really amazing i", "THsD1O5vXU0-00157-00032136-00032335": "i am still stunned by azar even when i", "THsD1O5vXU0-00158-00032336-00032567": "look online like i try to like copy my i", "THsD1O5vXU0-00159-00032568-00032751": "don't copy my art style i'm sort of like", "THsD1O5vXU0-00160-00032752-00032927": "basing my art style off many other", "THsD1O5vXU0-00161-00032928-00033023": "artists", "THsD1O5vXU0-00162-00033024-00033295": "and one that is sort of like stupefying", "THsD1O5vXU0-00163-00033296-00033590": "me is david finch's because it looks so", "THsD1O5vXU0-00164-00033591-00033799": "real and i'm just and i'm just", "THsD1O5vXU0-00165-00033800-00034071": "fascinated by it and i love it and", "THsD1O5vXU0-00166-00034072-00034215": "and i", "THsD1O5vXU0-00167-00034216-00034446": "it's just fascinating for me it's pretty", "THsD1O5vXU0-00168-00034447-00034662": "awesome", "THsD1O5vXU0-00169-00034663-00034911": "anyway so tomaflex review this is an", "THsD1O5vXU0-00170-00034912-00035095": "amazing book i totally recommend it for", "THsD1O5vXU0-00171-00035096-00035383": "anyone although i recommend reading um", "THsD1O5vXU0-00172-00035384-00035518": "some of the moonah apple collections to", "THsD1O5vXU0-00173-00035519-00035759": "get a bases on what this all is", "THsD1O5vXU0-00174-00035760-00035959": "prior and then collect other moon eye", "THsD1O5vXU0-00175-00035960-00036143": "books sort of study like mark's", "THsD1O5vXU0-00176-00036144-00036359": "personalities and all that", "THsD1O5vXU0-00177-00036360-00036679": "and then read this book i recommend you", "THsD1O5vXU0-00178-00036680-00036871": "start doing your research on like other", "THsD1O5vXU0-00179-00036872-00037079": "moon night material and then buy books", "THsD1O5vXU0-00180-00037080-00037335": "on moon night before going into this", "THsD1O5vXU0-00181-00037336-00037455": "because you'll really build the", "THsD1O5vXU0-00182-00037456-00037590": "relationship with the characters here", "THsD1O5vXU0-00183-00037591-00037846": "but even if you haven't then you'll", "THsD1O5vXU0-00184-00037847-00038111": "understand what's going on because they", "THsD1O5vXU0-00185-00038112-00038351": "build it all off and they explain", "THsD1O5vXU0-00186-00038352-00038559": "but i find it really amazing i love it", "THsD1O5vXU0-00187-00038560-00038807": "and they really build each character up", "THsD1O5vXU0-00188-00038808-00039008": "it's amazing", "THsD1O5vXU0-00189-00039009-00039151": "[Music]", "THsD1O5vXU0-00190-00039152-00039343": "and i can't wait to see what marvel is", "THsD1O5vXU0-00191-00039344-00039479": "going to do with munai in the future", "THsD1O5vXU0-00192-00039480-00039574": "both", "THsD1O5vXU0-00193-00039575-00039807": "live action series wise with oscar isaac", "THsD1O5vXU0-00194-00039808-00040039": "and comic book wise because i because", "THsD1O5vXU0-00195-00040040-00040199": "he's such an amazing hero and i think", "THsD1O5vXU0-00196-00040200-00040590": "he's sort of my spirit animal", "THsD1O5vXU0-00197-00040591-00040774": "yeah", "THsD1O5vXU0-00198-00040775-00040895": "but anyways thank you everybody so much", "THsD1O5vXU0-00199-00040896-00041039": "for watching i hope you enjoyed this is", "THsD1O5vXU0-00200-00041040-00041318": "my review of the moon knight omnibus by", "THsD1O5vXU0-00201-00041319-00041567": "charlie huston mike benson and greg", "THsD1O5vXU0-00202-00041568-00041687": "kerwitz", "THsD1O5vXU0-00203-00041688-00041927": "those are the authors and it it's a", "THsD1O5vXU0-00204-00041928-00042135": "beautiful story i totally recommend it", "THsD1O5vXU0-00205-00042136-00042279": "10 out of 10.", "THsD1O5vXU0-00206-00042280-00042462": "it's fascinating", "THsD1O5vXU0-00207-00042463-00042671": "but read any other moon night book first", "THsD1O5vXU0-00208-00042672-00042943": "before diving into this one it's but", "THsD1O5vXU0-00209-00042944-00043158": "either way even if not it's worth it and", "THsD1O5vXU0-00210-00043159-00043335": "i totally recommend it thank everybody", "THsD1O5vXU0-00211-00043336-00043462": "so much for watching leave a like", "THsD1O5vXU0-00212-00043463-00043607": "comment down below what you'd like me to", "THsD1O5vXU0-00213-00043608-00043799": "review next hit that subscribe button", "THsD1O5vXU0-00214-00043800-00043983": "and tap the notification ball so you", "THsD1O5vXU0-00215-00043984-00044151": "never miss a video from me and until", "THsD1O5vXU0-00216-00044152-00044383": "next time i'll see you later", "THsD1O5vXU0-00217-00044384-00044508": "bye", "THsD1O5vXU0-00218-00044509-00044845": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "THxiWAWZGgu", "text": {"THxiWAWZGgu-00000-00000012-00000167": "foreign", "THxiWAWZGgu-00001-00000168-00002645": "[Music]", "THxiWAWZGgu-00002-00002646-00003333": "thank you", "THxiWAWZGgu-00003-00003334-00007717": "[Music]", "THxiWAWZGgu-00004-00007718-00007953": "thank you foreign", "THxiWAWZGgu-00005-00007954-00010931": "[Music]", "THxiWAWZGgu-00006-00010932-00013046": "foreign", "THxiWAWZGgu-00007-00013047-00016836": "[Music]", "THxiWAWZGgu-00008-00016837-00018035": "thank you", "THxiWAWZGgu-00009-00018036-00018325": "foreign", "THxiWAWZGgu-00010-00018326-00019425": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "THTvPjBZdfc", "text": {"THTvPjBZdfc-00000-00000301-00001852": "[Music]", "THTvPjBZdfc-00001-00001853-00002509": "you", "THTvPjBZdfc-00002-00002510-00003118": "you", "THTvPjBZdfc-00003-00003119-00004045": "you", "THTvPjBZdfc-00004-00004046-00010722": "[Music]", "THTvPjBZdfc-00005-00010723-00011104": "you", "THTvPjBZdfc-00006-00011105-00012158": "[Music]", "THTvPjBZdfc-00007-00012159-00012364": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "THVP30bYQmg", "text": {"THVP30bYQmg-00000-00000017-00000313": "the bombing of tokugawa in world war two", "THVP30bYQmg-00001-00000314-00000605": "leash wangkong z toyokawa dai Kyushu was", "THVP30bYQmg-00002-00000606-00000755": "part of the strategic bombing campaign", "THVP30bYQmg-00003-00000756-00001000": "waged by the United States of America", "THVP30bYQmg-00004-00001001-00001193": "against military and civilian targets", "THVP30bYQmg-00005-00001194-00001378": "and population centers during the Japan", "THVP30bYQmg-00006-00001379-00001565": "home islands campaign in the closing", "THVP30bYQmg-00007-00001566-00002237": "stages of World War two", "THVP30bYQmg-00008-00002238-00002772": "topic background", "THVP30bYQmg-00009-00002773-00003003": "although the city of toyokawa was not a", "THVP30bYQmg-00010-00003004-00003222": "major population center it had a major", "THVP30bYQmg-00011-00003222-00003426": "target of military significance the", "THVP30bYQmg-00012-00003427-00003597": "toyokawa naval Arsenal Lee Schwalm", "THVP30bYQmg-00013-00003597-00003804": "hyejeong dong Qiang one of the largest", "THVP30bYQmg-00014-00003804-00004011": "in the Empire of Japan which produced", "THVP30bYQmg-00015-00004011-00004290": "7.7 millimeters machine guns 13", "THVP30bYQmg-00016-00004291-00004512": "millimeters in 20 millimeters aircraft", "THVP30bYQmg-00017-00004513-00004734": "cannon and 25 millimeters anti-aircraft", "THVP30bYQmg-00018-00004735-00004968": "cannon and associated munitions for the", "THVP30bYQmg-00019-00004969-00005358": "Imperial Japanese Navy by February 1945", "THVP30bYQmg-00020-00005359-00005697": "the facility had 50 6,400 workers in", "THVP30bYQmg-00021-00005698-00005978": "covered an area of 330 hectares the", "THVP30bYQmg-00022-00005979-00006225": "Tokaido mainline railway connecting", "THVP30bYQmg-00023-00006226-00006456": "Tokyo with a soccer also ran through the", "THVP30bYQmg-00024-00006456-00007017": "city", "THVP30bYQmg-00025-00007018-00007556": "topic air-raids", "THVP30bYQmg-00026-00007556-00007727": "despite its obvious military", "THVP30bYQmg-00027-00007728-00007967": "significance toyokawa was not bombed", "THVP30bYQmg-00028-00007968-00008153": "until the very late stages of World War", "THVP30bYQmg-00029-00008154-00008522": "two on the 1st of November 1944 a", "THVP30bYQmg-00030-00008523-00008798": "small-scale air raid occurred this was", "THVP30bYQmg-00031-00008799-00009011": "followed on the 23rd of November by a", "THVP30bYQmg-00032-00009012-00009167": "midnight flyover by a lone", "THVP30bYQmg-00033-00009168-00009431": "camera-equipped b-29 Superfortress on a", "THVP30bYQmg-00034-00009432-00009740": "reconnaissance mission however a major", "THVP30bYQmg-00035-00009741-00009953": "air raid did not occur until the morning", "THVP30bYQmg-00036-00009954-00010298": "of the 7th of August 1945 during this", "THVP30bYQmg-00037-00010299-00010682": "attack 135 b-29 Superfortress bombers of", "THVP30bYQmg-00038-00010683-00011194": "the USAAF xx air force 58 73rd 313 and", "THVP30bYQmg-00039-00011195-00011474": "314 bombardment wings launched from Guam", "THVP30bYQmg-00040-00011475-00011813": "Saipan and Tinian they were joined by 48", "THVP30bYQmg-00041-00011814-00012083": "p-51 Mustang escort fighters deployed", "THVP30bYQmg-00042-00012084-00012365": "from Iwo Jima arriving over the target", "THVP30bYQmg-00043-00012366-00012698": "area at 10:13 a.m. 12 b-29s bombed the", "THVP30bYQmg-00044-00012699-00012875": "toyokawa naval Arsenal while the", "THVP30bYQmg-00045-00012876-00013094": "remaining bomb is concentrated on toyoko", "THVP30bYQmg-00046-00013094-00013294": "is civilian population center and the", "THVP30bYQmg-00047-00013295-00013579": "p-51 strafe targets of opportunity a", "THVP30bYQmg-00048-00013580-00014126": "total of 3,000 256 500-pound bombs 813", "THVP30bYQmg-00049-00014127-00014315": "tons was dropped on the city from an", "THVP30bYQmg-00050-00014316-00014638": "altitude of 15,000 to 17,000 feet", "THVP30bYQmg-00051-00014638-00014903": "civilian casualty estimates range from", "THVP30bYQmg-00052-00014904-00015104": "two thousand five hundred and forty four", "THVP30bYQmg-00053-00015105-00015281": "to two thousand six hundred and seventy", "THVP30bYQmg-00054-00015282-00015596": "seven people killed victims included", "THVP30bYQmg-00055-00015597-00015755": "four hundred and fifty two school", "THVP30bYQmg-00056-00015756-00015965": "children and teenage girls some of whom", "THVP30bYQmg-00057-00015966-00016136": "had been conscripted and many of whom", "THVP30bYQmg-00058-00016137-00016300": "had volunteered to work at the naval", "THVP30bYQmg-00059-00016301-00016592": "Arsenal Japanese anti-aircraft fire", "THVP30bYQmg-00060-00016593-00016916": "damaged 21 b-29s during the raid one of", "THVP30bYQmg-00061-00016917-00017096": "which crashed into the ocean near Iwo", "THVP30bYQmg-00062-00017097-00017381": "Jima there were no American fatalities", "THVP30bYQmg-00063-00017382-00017684": "another b-29 lost course and dropped its", "THVP30bYQmg-00064-00017685-00017875": "bombs on the rural village of futa Matta", "THVP30bYQmg-00065-00017876-00018260": "now part of Hama Matsu she's oka after", "THVP30bYQmg-00066-00018261-00018452": "the war a memorial monument was erected", "THVP30bYQmg-00067-00018453-00018665": "within the grounds of Toya Curran re", "THVP30bYQmg-00068-00018666-00018980": "temple several other memorials exist at", "THVP30bYQmg-00069-00018981-00019716": "various locations around toyokawa City", "THVP30bYQmg-00070-00019717-00020274": "topic see also", "THVP30bYQmg-00071-00020275-00020718": "strategic bombing during World War two"}}, {"audio_id": "TI82hSzy-ek", "text": {"TI82hSzy-ek-00000-00000039-00000214": "for this problem we want to use", "TI82hSzy-ek-00001-00000215-00000335": "transformations", "TI82hSzy-ek-00002-00000336-00000567": "and the graph of f of x equals 2 to the", "TI82hSzy-ek-00003-00000568-00000678": "x to graph", "TI82hSzy-ek-00004-00000679-00000943": "g of x equals negative 2 to the x plus", "TI82hSzy-ek-00005-00000944-00001031": "3.", "TI82hSzy-ek-00006-00001032-00001319": "g of x is equal to negative f of x plus", "TI82hSzy-ek-00007-00001320-00001366": "3.", "TI82hSzy-ek-00008-00001367-00001566": "the negative function means that we'll", "TI82hSzy-ek-00009-00001567-00001679": "be reflecting the graph", "TI82hSzy-ek-00010-00001680-00001991": "across the x-axis so our new points", "TI82hSzy-ek-00011-00001992-00002399": "are at 1 negative 2 and 2 negative 4.", "TI82hSzy-ek-00012-00002400-00002591": "connecting these points gets the graph", "TI82hSzy-ek-00013-00002592-00002783": "of negative f of x", "TI82hSzy-ek-00014-00002784-00003023": "adding 3 to x means that we will shift", "TI82hSzy-ek-00015-00003024-00003254": "this new graph 3 units to the left", "TI82hSzy-ek-00016-00003255-00003447": "so our new points are at negative 2", "TI82hSzy-ek-00017-00003447-00003567": "negative 2", "TI82hSzy-ek-00018-00003568-00003799": "and negative 1 negative 4. connecting", "TI82hSzy-ek-00019-00003800-00003870": "these points", "TI82hSzy-ek-00020-00003871-00004111": "gets the graph of g of x this is the", "TI82hSzy-ek-00021-00004112-00004432": "final answer"}}, {"audio_id": "TIhFWXvznQk", "text": {"TIhFWXvznQk-00000-00000043-00000747": "[Music]", "TIhFWXvznQk-00001-00000748-00001006": "yo what's going on guys it's your boy", "TIhFWXvznQk-00002-00001007-00001156": "Chester there's a video here today where", "TIhFWXvznQk-00003-00001157-00001275": "you guys surprising smart shimmers", "TIhFWXvznQk-00004-00001276-00001468": "episode number three and I just", "TIhFWXvznQk-00005-00001469-00001582": "appreciate the frequent support on this", "TIhFWXvznQk-00006-00001583-00001675": "series it so very much", "TIhFWXvznQk-00007-00001676-00001780": "it's always fun for the actual small", "TIhFWXvznQk-00008-00001780-00001948": "streamer but for us the community to", "TIhFWXvznQk-00009-00001948-00002080": "watch it just have them just like be", "TIhFWXvznQk-00010-00002081-00002254": "freaking super happy about it I think is", "TIhFWXvznQk-00011-00002255-00002395": "one my favorite series ever and trust me", "TIhFWXvznQk-00012-00002396-00002526": "it's not gonna stop anytime soon I'm", "TIhFWXvznQk-00013-00002527-00002802": "just gonna just gonna casually up mmm", "TIhFWXvznQk-00014-00002803-00003079": "you know uh-huh just sayin soon soon", "TIhFWXvznQk-00015-00003080-00003226": "that's all I'm gonna say I love you guys", "TIhFWXvznQk-00016-00003227-00003346": "again I hope you guys enjoyed the video", "TIhFWXvznQk-00017-00003347-00003540": "and hopefully just put you in a really", "TIhFWXvznQk-00018-00003542-00003654": "good mood man there's a lot of things", "TIhFWXvznQk-00019-00003655-00003808": "going on and I hope everyone's just kind", "TIhFWXvznQk-00020-00003809-00003975": "of like holding on all the good and just", "TIhFWXvznQk-00021-00003976-00004104": "kind of letting the positive you kind of", "TIhFWXvznQk-00022-00004105-00004263": "carry you through I know it's kind of", "TIhFWXvznQk-00023-00004264-00004386": "crazy but that's what you guys later", "TIhFWXvznQk-00024-00004387-00004549": "let's get this thing going and enjoy", "TIhFWXvznQk-00025-00004550-00004725": "okay homies our first year were asking", "TIhFWXvznQk-00026-00004726-00004849": "with my favorite small shoot matter", "TIhFWXvznQk-00027-00004850-00004999": "Tanner's yet and he goes in the name of", "TIhFWXvznQk-00028-00005000-00005197": "sight with scythe he streams daily", "TIhFWXvznQk-00029-00005198-00005350": "mainly FPS shooters and just has an", "TIhFWXvznQk-00030-00005351-00005547": "overall amazing kind of energy and it's", "TIhFWXvznQk-00031-00005548-00005673": "obviously super contagious with an", "TIhFWXvznQk-00032-00005674-00005811": "overall just literally a great vibe", "TIhFWXvznQk-00033-00005812-00007254": "that's all I got that's all I got", "TIhFWXvznQk-00034-00007255-00007600": "let's go when designing for extreme", "TIhFWXvznQk-00035-00007601-00007759": "designs I previously hovered on like an", "TIhFWXvznQk-00036-00007759-00007923": "alt account and I actually saw he was", "TIhFWXvznQk-00037-00007925-00008041": "really happy the transition screen that", "TIhFWXvznQk-00038-00008042-00008197": "he had which had this really cool sort", "TIhFWXvznQk-00039-00008198-00008293": "of awesome glitchy", "TIhFWXvznQk-00040-00008294-00008500": "and retro vibe with the concept of the", "TIhFWXvznQk-00041-00008501-00008644": "transition screen already in mind I made", "TIhFWXvznQk-00042-00008645-00008800": "it super easy kind of matched a color", "TIhFWXvznQk-00043-00008801-00008956": "scheme as well that then really simple", "TIhFWXvznQk-00044-00008957-00009097": "kind of like glitchy horizontal pattern", "TIhFWXvznQk-00045-00009098-00009262": "background and it overall just mean it's", "TIhFWXvznQk-00046-00009263-00009385": "super easy me to create a really cool", "TIhFWXvznQk-00047-00009386-00009568": "stream revamp around it compare now the", "TIhFWXvznQk-00048-00009569-00009742": "super simple yet awesome text little", "TIhFWXvznQk-00049-00009743-00009925": "actually spell out his name it honestly", "TIhFWXvznQk-00050-00009926-00010054": "made for a really fun and overall", "TIhFWXvznQk-00051-00010055-00010207": "concept that this was all inspired by", "TIhFWXvznQk-00052-00010208-00010339": "his actual transition screen and", "TIhFWXvznQk-00053-00010340-00010570": "honestly his reaction speaks for itself", "TIhFWXvznQk-00054-00010571-00010866": "and I hope you guys do enjoy", "TIhFWXvznQk-00055-00010867-00011400": "I think it's time okay it's time to", "TIhFWXvznQk-00056-00011401-00011706": "finally surprise scythe with his design", "TIhFWXvznQk-00057-00011707-00011928": "but as you can see my discourse ready to", "TIhFWXvznQk-00058-00011929-00012108": "go I ask them if they're down to help me", "TIhFWXvznQk-00059-00012109-00012312": "they're like yes yes yes so that's the", "TIhFWXvznQk-00060-00012313-00012363": "plan", "TIhFWXvznQk-00061-00012364-00012521": "regardless I'm using Microsoft edge so I", "TIhFWXvznQk-00062-00012522-00012648": "can sign into a different account so I", "TIhFWXvznQk-00063-00012649-00012795": "could be like they're simultaneously so", "TIhFWXvznQk-00064-00012796-00013080": "okay let's go okay I'm gonna say I have", "TIhFWXvznQk-00065-00013081-00013287": "a strange feeling something pretty cool", "TIhFWXvznQk-00066-00013288-00013374": "is about to happen", "TIhFWXvznQk-00067-00013375-00013584": "okay so the play here is I want to send", "TIhFWXvznQk-00068-00013585-00013761": "this actual link to the chat where", "TIhFWXvznQk-00069-00013762-00013916": "they're gonna go to his stream and be", "TIhFWXvznQk-00070-00013918-00014076": "like yo sister has a surprise for you it", "TIhFWXvznQk-00071-00014077-00014229": "worked last time I think it was a really", "TIhFWXvznQk-00072-00014230-00014505": "cool way to hype up the whole idea of it", "TIhFWXvznQk-00073-00014506-00014661": "I have a strange feeling something", "TIhFWXvznQk-00074-00014662-00014781": "pretty cool about happy okay we're gonna", "TIhFWXvznQk-00075-00014782-00015255": "send this okay you see I said over here", "TIhFWXvznQk-00076-00015256-00015408": "on my other account yeah I have a shame", "TIhFWXvznQk-00077-00015409-00015516": "feeling something pretty cool as well to", "TIhFWXvznQk-00078-00015516-00015905": "have a new I really hope not okay so", "TIhFWXvznQk-00079-00015906-00016341": "let's find a boss no okay okay oh my god", "TIhFWXvznQk-00080-00016341-00016494": "all this comes down to this bro here we", "TIhFWXvznQk-00081-00016495-00017054": "go I'm pressing send oh okay okay", "TIhFWXvznQk-00082-00017055-00017366": "says so has a surprise for you whoa", "TIhFWXvznQk-00083-00017367-00017772": "what's going on what just happened", "TIhFWXvznQk-00084-00017773-00018055": "oh my god", "TIhFWXvznQk-00085-00018056-00018229": "what's going on I don't know what's", "TIhFWXvznQk-00086-00018230-00018534": "happening oh whoa", "TIhFWXvznQk-00087-00018535-00018844": "what's going on oh [__]", "TIhFWXvznQk-00088-00018845-00019701": "Oh somebody's raid me what's going on", "TIhFWXvznQk-00089-00019702-00020005": "that's a surprise for you", "TIhFWXvznQk-00090-00020006-00020452": "OSS oh I'm sorry but here the [__]", "TIhFWXvznQk-00091-00020453-00020560": "going on right now", "TIhFWXvznQk-00092-00020561-00021571": "Oh yo designer 400 T what up oh you're", "TIhFWXvznQk-00093-00021572-00021658": "kidding", "TIhFWXvznQk-00094-00021659-00022519": "since price you what's going on oh my", "TIhFWXvznQk-00095-00022520-00023104": "god oh I'm tripping right now bro my", "TIhFWXvznQk-00096-00023105-00023822": "heart's gonna be out of my chest oh my", "TIhFWXvznQk-00097-00023823-00024352": "yo brother yo you're [__] kidding me", "TIhFWXvznQk-00098-00024353-00024655": "bro these are so [__] good", "TIhFWXvznQk-00099-00024656-00025306": "yeah they already see this no yo this is", "TIhFWXvznQk-00100-00025307-00025911": "crazy", "TIhFWXvznQk-00101-00025912-00026127": "these are fired", "TIhFWXvznQk-00102-00026128-00026502": "I've been lurking for a bit that's you", "TIhFWXvznQk-00103-00026502-00026988": "[Laughter]", "TIhFWXvznQk-00104-00026989-00027129": "[Applause]", "TIhFWXvznQk-00105-00027130-00027343": "you've been chilling in here the entire", "TIhFWXvznQk-00106-00027344-00027667": "time and I just didn't even know bro I", "TIhFWXvznQk-00107-00027668-00027838": "got baited the [__] out", "TIhFWXvznQk-00108-00027839-00028387": "I got catfished am i able to add these", "TIhFWXvznQk-00109-00028388-00028527": "right now like well it's live or do I", "TIhFWXvznQk-00110-00028528-00028858": "have to wait you finna die I am gonna", "TIhFWXvznQk-00111-00028858-00029058": "die my heart is pounding right now", "TIhFWXvznQk-00112-00029060-00029260": "there's a hundred three people here", "TIhFWXvznQk-00113-00029261-00029595": "watching me [__] myself okay", "TIhFWXvznQk-00114-00029595-00030176": "oh my god bro I love you", "TIhFWXvznQk-00115-00030177-00030483": "am I gonna do this was gonna happen", "TIhFWXvznQk-00116-00030483-00030756": "yes this time where I asked you to", "TIhFWXvznQk-00117-00030757-00030914": "advertise yourself let people know why", "TIhFWXvznQk-00118-00030916-00031220": "they should visit your channel so I was", "TIhFWXvznQk-00119-00031220-00031427": "active duty military for about five", "TIhFWXvznQk-00120-00031428-00031668": "years in literally like a halfway", "TIhFWXvznQk-00121-00031669-00031977": "through my enlistment halfway through my", "TIhFWXvznQk-00122-00031977-00032099": "enlistment I was just kind of like yeah", "TIhFWXvznQk-00123-00032100-00032274": "I want to do streaming cuz I got into", "TIhFWXvznQk-00124-00032275-00032499": "gaming cuz I really did it got over the", "TIhFWXvznQk-00125-00032500-00032618": "party phase and I was just kind of like", "TIhFWXvznQk-00126-00032619-00032832": "I wanted to focus more on like actual", "TIhFWXvznQk-00127-00032833-00033124": "like content so I started streaming", "TIhFWXvznQk-00128-00033125-00033315": "usually so obviously I started playing", "TIhFWXvznQk-00129-00033316-00033458": "for tonight kind of got over that but", "TIhFWXvznQk-00130-00033459-00033680": "then now I'm just trying to like", "TIhFWXvznQk-00131-00033681-00034251": "extrordinary cuz I've been really on", "TIhFWXvznQk-00132-00034252-00034521": "that valor grind late with says so bro", "TIhFWXvznQk-00133-00034522-00034643": "that's it wants to play with me of", "TIhFWXvznQk-00134-00034644-00034914": "course I'll play with him bro I'll", "TIhFWXvznQk-00135-00034915-00035064": "[__] kiss his feet right now if he", "TIhFWXvznQk-00136-00035065-00035454": "was here bro I like what a cry but I'd", "TIhFWXvznQk-00137-00035455-00035687": "already play dude so yeah like I'm", "TIhFWXvznQk-00138-00035688-00035865": "saying like I just been playing broader", "TIhFWXvznQk-00139-00035866-00036012": "and broader games like I just finished", "TIhFWXvznQk-00140-00036013-00036224": "Ryan", "TIhFWXvznQk-00141-00036225-00037996": "[Music]", "TIhFWXvznQk-00142-00037997-00038430": "Ted gifted subs it's like you're trying", "TIhFWXvznQk-00143-00038431-00039168": "to make me cry dude see so can I like", "TIhFWXvznQk-00144-00039169-00039348": "hug you or something is there like a way", "TIhFWXvznQk-00145-00039349-00039658": "where I can make that happen", "TIhFWXvznQk-00146-00039659-00039962": "yo Skelly gang in the house baby look at", "TIhFWXvznQk-00147-00039963-00040208": "that little skeleton bro says so thank", "TIhFWXvznQk-00148-00040209-00040586": "you though thank you so much I", "TIhFWXvznQk-00149-00040587-00040895": "to God yo guys I hope I hope please go", "TIhFWXvznQk-00150-00040896-00041111": "visit he's truly I've been watching her", "TIhFWXvznQk-00151-00041112-00041336": "for about maybe like a week or so and", "TIhFWXvznQk-00152-00041337-00041477": "before I ever pick someone I either I", "TIhFWXvznQk-00153-00041478-00041609": "always watch them for at least about an", "TIhFWXvznQk-00154-00041610-00041843": "hour so and the guys vibes just awesome", "TIhFWXvznQk-00155-00041844-00042056": "I appreciate this guy's so very much man", "TIhFWXvznQk-00156-00042057-00042262": "this guy is super dope", "TIhFWXvznQk-00157-00042263-00042470": "I love Ida please go please please", "TIhFWXvznQk-00158-00042471-00042749": "please go check him out he's [__]", "TIhFWXvznQk-00159-00042750-00042917": "awesome and he's super freaking awesome", "TIhFWXvznQk-00160-00042918-00043325": "I it's amazing this is so good", "TIhFWXvznQk-00161-00043326-00043643": "okay yup yo and [__] you're not but when", "TIhFWXvznQk-00162-00043644-00043829": "I was shake I'm not [__] come on I'm", "TIhFWXvznQk-00163-00043830-00044062": "good I'm good but like I don't know why", "TIhFWXvznQk-00164-00044063-00044330": "I was shaking hella man it's it's one of", "TIhFWXvznQk-00165-00044331-00044450": "those things that you just your heart", "TIhFWXvznQk-00166-00044451-00044654": "nurse starts going just because you got", "TIhFWXvznQk-00167-00044655-00045023": "a obviously wants to like it like oh my", "TIhFWXvznQk-00168-00045024-00046400": "god oh my god dude", "TIhFWXvznQk-00169-00046401-00046904": "this is nice on god broke on god this is", "TIhFWXvznQk-00170-00046905-00047117": "probably like the most welcomes I've", "TIhFWXvznQk-00171-00047118-00047309": "ever felt from somebody like from", "TIhFWXvznQk-00172-00047310-00047507": "dislike from anyone on twitch this is", "TIhFWXvznQk-00173-00047508-00047852": "nuts man and I know it's gonna be pagas", "TIhFWXvznQk-00174-00047853-00048365": "bro bro you're a [__] monster dude", "TIhFWXvznQk-00175-00048366-00048599": "you guys are insane all of you guys are", "TIhFWXvznQk-00176-00048600-00048946": "insane says so [__] thank you", "TIhFWXvznQk-00177-00048947-00049165": "literally thank you man cuz I've been", "TIhFWXvznQk-00178-00049166-00049390": "looking for a new overlay because I've", "TIhFWXvznQk-00179-00049391-00049612": "this overlay is like dude it's it's", "TIhFWXvznQk-00180-00049613-00049820": "[__] perfect the colors perfect the", "TIhFWXvznQk-00181-00049821-00050048": "text is perfect the [__] that the", "TIhFWXvznQk-00182-00050049-00050339": "idea behind it is perfect this is some", "TIhFWXvznQk-00183-00050340-00050564": "next-level clean design bro pay up yeah", "TIhFWXvznQk-00184-00050565-00050675": "how much do you want I'll give you my", "TIhFWXvznQk-00185-00050676-00050882": "firstborn child well it my firstborn", "TIhFWXvznQk-00186-00050883-00051026": "child this is what they deserved well", "TIhFWXvznQk-00187-00051027-00051330": "this is [__] amazing", "TIhFWXvznQk-00188-00051332-00051614": "[Music]", "TIhFWXvznQk-00189-00051615-00051852": "alright guys so our next sugar goes with", "TIhFWXvznQk-00190-00051853-00052549": "the name of gamers doing things first", "TIhFWXvznQk-00191-00052550-00052675": "for me personally nothing looks out of", "TIhFWXvznQk-00192-00052676-00052791": "the norm for this channel to like", "TIhFWXvznQk-00193-00052792-00052972": "literally right up to the surprise the", "TIhFWXvznQk-00194-00052973-00053151": "Instagram literally has 1 million", "TIhFWXvznQk-00195-00053152-00053457": "followers I swear to God I didn't even", "TIhFWXvznQk-00196-00053458-00053679": "know still it is a small stream but the", "TIhFWXvznQk-00197-00053680-00053838": "person I was behind it just enjoy some", "TIhFWXvznQk-00198-00053839-00054037": "really cool IG meme content so it is", "TIhFWXvznQk-00199-00054038-00054088": "what it is", "TIhFWXvznQk-00200-00054089-00054241": "when going ahead with helping him with", "TIhFWXvznQk-00201-00054241-00054421": "the revamp I made a super simple G local", "TIhFWXvznQk-00202-00054422-00054586": "concept in the shape of a shield to give", "TIhFWXvznQk-00203-00054587-00054688": "the letter more of a sense of like a", "TIhFWXvznQk-00204-00054689-00054910": "cool stance I end up combining the cool", "TIhFWXvznQk-00205-00054911-00055036": "shape of the logo making a really cool", "TIhFWXvznQk-00206-00055037-00055179": "pattern for the actual graphic screens", "TIhFWXvznQk-00207-00055180-00055350": "and I actually just a loudly logo to", "TIhFWXvznQk-00208-00055351-00055486": "overall carry the concept of a stream", "TIhFWXvznQk-00209-00055487-00055660": "package as for the reaction there's no", "TIhFWXvznQk-00210-00055661-00055825": "way anyone could have probably seen what", "TIhFWXvznQk-00211-00055826-00055999": "was gonna be coming oh that's all well", "TIhFWXvznQk-00212-00056000-00056163": "pretty much say I know I just hope you", "TIhFWXvznQk-00213-00056164-00057117": "guys enjoy ok", "TIhFWXvznQk-00214-00057119-00057354": "there it is the tweet is done the chat", "TIhFWXvznQk-00215-00057355-00057600": "should be starting to spam right about", "TIhFWXvznQk-00216-00057601-00057910": "wait for it oh my god what is going on", "TIhFWXvznQk-00217-00057911-00058204": "in my chat what's happening", "TIhFWXvznQk-00218-00058204-00058504": "says Oh has a gift for you oh my god", "TIhFWXvznQk-00219-00058504-00059035": "dude [__] is going on apparently we're", "TIhFWXvznQk-00220-00059036-00059313": "checking the Twitter for a surprise", "TIhFWXvznQk-00221-00059314-00059728": "what just saying check Twitter bro ok", "TIhFWXvznQk-00222-00059729-00060257": "I'm opening the Google Drive oh [__] bro", "TIhFWXvznQk-00223-00060258-00060606": "what it's like a [__] bunch of", "TIhFWXvznQk-00224-00060607-00060774": "overlay stuff", "TIhFWXvznQk-00225-00060775-00062504": "for us yeah like gamers dipped yeah bro", "TIhFWXvznQk-00226-00062504-00062882": "that's tired thank you bro like dude", "TIhFWXvznQk-00227-00062883-00063332": "these looks sake those look sick dude oh", "TIhFWXvznQk-00228-00063333-00064004": "my god says oh holy cow look at Twitter", "TIhFWXvznQk-00229-00064005-00064091": "Instagram", "TIhFWXvznQk-00230-00064092-00064766": "tik-tok gamers doing things oh my god yo", "TIhFWXvznQk-00231-00064767-00065329": "Sasso man thank you so much holy [__]", "TIhFWXvznQk-00232-00065330-00065529": "set so you just did this on your own", "TIhFWXvznQk-00233-00065529-00065801": "time just for the hell of it all right", "TIhFWXvznQk-00234-00065802-00065955": "I'm gonna Tonopah himself I'm gonna tell", "TIhFWXvznQk-00235-00065956-00066105": "him the plug himself he needs to plug", "TIhFWXvznQk-00236-00066106-00066317": "himself that's part of it that's part of", "TIhFWXvznQk-00237-00066318-00066396": "this whole thing", "TIhFWXvznQk-00238-00066397-00066686": "fullscreen and plug myself John you got", "TIhFWXvznQk-00239-00066687-00066816": "this I don't I don't even know how to", "TIhFWXvznQk-00240-00066817-00067005": "plug us you've you've probably seen us", "TIhFWXvznQk-00241-00067006-00067268": "on Instagram before we're a meme page", "TIhFWXvznQk-00242-00067269-00067722": "but I so so I don't know what to say bro", "TIhFWXvznQk-00243-00067723-00068217": "I know exactly what to do I know exactly", "TIhFWXvznQk-00244-00068218-00068486": "what to do what is", "TIhFWXvznQk-00245-00068487-00069030": "[Music]", "TIhFWXvznQk-00246-00069031-00069403": "Yosi so under don't know how to thank", "TIhFWXvznQk-00247-00069404-00069430": "you", "TIhFWXvznQk-00248-00069431-00069556": "thanks for owning what's happening", "TIhFWXvznQk-00249-00069557-00069679": "that's where all the follows and all", "TIhFWXvznQk-00250-00069680-00069714": "they get", "TIhFWXvznQk-00251-00069715-00071535": "[Music]", "TIhFWXvznQk-00252-00071536-00072672": "[Music]", "TIhFWXvznQk-00253-00072673-00073408": "[Music]", "TIhFWXvznQk-00254-00073409-00073687": "[Music]", "TIhFWXvznQk-00255-00073688-00073984": "is that one good thing he does bro I", "TIhFWXvznQk-00256-00073985-00074540": "seen that I swear okay", "TIhFWXvznQk-00257-00074541-00074843": "that was uh that was something I'm not", "TIhFWXvznQk-00258-00074844-00074906": "gonna lie", "TIhFWXvznQk-00259-00074907-00075380": "Oh guys I mean if it hasn't check about", "TIhFWXvznQk-00260-00075381-00075527": "as always guys all do that I end up", "TIhFWXvznQk-00261-00075528-00075683": "subscribing or Susie's gonna end up", "TIhFWXvznQk-00262-00075684-00075989": "surprised at can you talk ah he's in the", "TIhFWXvznQk-00263-00075990-00076124": "description if you guys like this", "TIhFWXvznQk-00264-00076125-00076340": "individual that was super freaking good", "TIhFWXvznQk-00265-00076341-00076481": "I'm happy about that", "TIhFWXvznQk-00266-00076482-00076817": "and I don't know where they came from", "TIhFWXvznQk-00267-00076818-00077072": "but I'm down to take it that was four I", "TIhFWXvznQk-00268-00077073-00077219": "was hilarious that was that was", "TIhFWXvznQk-00269-00077220-00077264": "hilarious", "TIhFWXvznQk-00270-00077265-00077507": "I'm I'm so happy with that I'm literally", "TIhFWXvznQk-00271-00077508-00077681": "starting with that all his friends need", "TIhFWXvznQk-00272-00077682-00077918": "to like the logo to okay I'm good I'll", "TIhFWXvznQk-00273-00077919-00078253": "go with that I'm so freakin good yep", "TIhFWXvznQk-00274-00078254-00078440": "alright guys it's the end the video here", "TIhFWXvznQk-00275-00078441-00078617": "today so I hope as always you guys", "TIhFWXvznQk-00276-00078618-00078884": "enjoyed the video I just like I just one", "TIhFWXvznQk-00277-00078885-00078995": "of those things it just puts a smile on", "TIhFWXvznQk-00278-00078996-00079178": "my face every single freaking time I end", "TIhFWXvznQk-00279-00079179-00079283": "up making one of these things I know a", "TIhFWXvznQk-00280-00079284-00079406": "lot of this motion was out there as well", "TIhFWXvznQk-00281-00079407-00079583": "as kindly looking for it absolutely few", "TIhFWXvznQk-00282-00079584-00079679": "guys don't know what I'm searching for", "TIhFWXvznQk-00283-00079680-00079805": "I'm visitors when someone's like", "TIhFWXvznQk-00284-00079806-00079982": "grinding every single day or at least", "TIhFWXvznQk-00285-00079983-00080123": "you know every you know every single day", "TIhFWXvznQk-00286-00080124-00080285": "kind of thing just grinding a lot and", "TIhFWXvznQk-00287-00080286-00080441": "overall just puts effort in their stream", "TIhFWXvznQk-00288-00080442-00080618": "you know if I've had any tips for a", "TIhFWXvznQk-00289-00080619-00080786": "small shooters out there it's just like", "TIhFWXvznQk-00290-00080787-00081002": "always be on you know you don't want", "TIhFWXvznQk-00291-00081003-00081143": "anyone just go and join your stream and", "TIhFWXvznQk-00292-00081144-00081251": "you're just like sitting there in a", "TIhFWXvznQk-00293-00081252-00081416": "quiet this because you have only one or", "TIhFWXvznQk-00294-00081417-00081563": "two viewers and you're so like sitting", "TIhFWXvznQk-00295-00081564-00081656": "there too quiet noise I don't want to", "TIhFWXvznQk-00296-00081657-00081824": "interact with that all I would say is", "TIhFWXvznQk-00297-00081825-00081956": "the only thing I have for you guys is", "TIhFWXvznQk-00298-00081957-00082103": "make sure guys are basically always on", "TIhFWXvznQk-00299-00082104-00082304": "having fun whether if you have zero", "TIhFWXvznQk-00300-00082305-00082436": "viewers or you have a thousand you know", "TIhFWXvznQk-00301-00082437-00082562": "whichever one kind of like floats your", "TIhFWXvznQk-00302-00082563-00082757": "boat just like match the same energy no", "TIhFWXvznQk-00303-00082758-00082883": "matter what that's all I got for you", "TIhFWXvznQk-00304-00082884-00083003": "guys I'll tell you guys later sense of", "TIhFWXvznQk-00305-00083004-00083222": "HQ out don't have to keep smiling stay", "TIhFWXvznQk-00306-00083223-00083402": "positive and stay a freaking with the", "TIhFWXvznQk-00307-00083403-00083501": "guys later", "TIhFWXvznQk-00308-00083502-00083702": "much love and yeah couple more weeks", "TIhFWXvznQk-00309-00083703-00084289": "couple more weeks later", "TIhFWXvznQk-00310-00084290-00085095": "[Music]", "TIhFWXvznQk-00311-00085096-00085473": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "TIrJRrn1Kyg", "text": {"TIrJRrn1Kyg-00000-00000008-00000303": "hello everyone greetings from cemeosan", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00001-00000304-00000519": "regional center for special educational", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00002-00000520-00000878": "needs the title of our our material is", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00003-00000880-00001062": "development of accessible disability", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00004-00001063-00001439": "inclusive education die article our team", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00005-00001440-00001647": "member for group three are", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00006-00001648-00001902": "almost high call ben amir hanzo manager", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00007-00001903-00002151": "from strategic communication unit", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00008-00002152-00002375": "phezny ofman media officer from", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00009-00002376-00002631": "strategic communication unit", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00010-00002632-00002918": "newa master binti ibrahim program", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00011-00002919-00003063": "supervisor from training and", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00012-00003064-00003263": "consultation division", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00013-00003264-00003383": "introduction", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00014-00003384-00003622": "based on the discussion group 3 chooses", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00015-00003623-00003815": "to develop a disability inclusive", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00016-00003815-00004135": "education die article the article will", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00017-00004136-00004367": "be in the form of portable document", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00018-00004368-00004743": "format pdf resource an accessible pdf", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00019-00004744-00004967": "provides the functionality that allows", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00020-00004968-00005231": "visually impaired users to comprehend", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00021-00005232-00005495": "and navigate content quickly and easily", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00022-00005496-00005638": "consideration", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00023-00005639-00005967": "font size font size is 12 point or", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00024-00005968-00006199": "higher for body text", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00025-00006200-00006486": "font size is nine point for footnotes or", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00026-00006487-00006759": "endnotes and font size can be zoomed to", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00027-00006759-00006959": "200", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00028-00006959-00007134": "organizing content", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00029-00007136-00007414": "content is organized under headings and", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00030-00007415-00007559": "subheadings", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00031-00007559-00007751": "headings and subheadings are used", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00032-00007752-00007991": "sequentially images", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00033-00007992-00008223": "images that convey information", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00034-00008224-00008503": "graphs charts and maps also include", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00035-00008504-00008814": "contextual or supporting details", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00036-00008815-00009078": "images do not rely on color", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00037-00009079-00009359": "images that are purely decorative do not", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00038-00009360-00009567": "have all text descriptions", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00039-00009568-00009663": "links", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00040-00009664-00009927": "the link text describes the destination", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00041-00009928-00010183": "of the link and does not use generic", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00042-00010184-00010527": "text such as click here or read more", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00043-00010528-00010638": "tables", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00044-00010639-00010967": "tables include row and column headers", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00045-00010968-00011214": "row and column headers have the correct", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00046-00011215-00011374": "scope assigned", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00047-00011375-00011599": "tables include a caption", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00048-00011600-00011959": "tables avoid merged or split cells", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00049-00011960-00012303": "tables have adequate cell padding", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00050-00012304-00012655": "lesson learn accessibility of oer in", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00051-00012656-00012935": "open and distance learning odl allows", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00052-00012936-00013279": "others to more effectively reuse remix", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00053-00013280-00013511": "repurpose and adapt content for local", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00054-00013512-00013766": "use and can be a game", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00055-00013768-00014063": "changer for people with disability and", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00056-00014063-00014247": "many other groups", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00057-00014247-00014391": "how to access", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00058-00014391-00014679": "the ioer content that we developed is", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00059-00014680-00015030": "available on cmeosan website our website", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00060-00015031-00015238": "can be accessed through desktop and", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00061-00015240-00015535": "mobile phone from androids or ios", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00062-00015536-00015758": "click on browser and search cemeosan", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00063-00015759-00016007": "this is our main page of cemeosan", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00064-00016008-00016335": "website click on the category icon you", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00065-00016336-00016575": "will find ioea repository aligned with", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00066-00016576-00016799": "ioea requirements especially in adopting", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00067-00016800-00017063": "creative common licensing our article", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00068-00017064-00017255": "supports the two compliance creative", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00069-00017256-00017734": "commons licenses ccby", "TIrJRrn1Kyg-00070-00017735-00018234": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "TI_n8NJRcGI", "text": {"TI_n8NJRcGI-00000-00000088-00000289": "is", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00001-00000290-00001209": "[Music]", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00002-00001210-00002895": "[Music]", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00003-00002896-00003142": "enemy think that it was meant to be", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00004-00003143-00003406": "living in a time where disease is on", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00005-00003407-00003654": "every street i won't let them fester me", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00006-00003655-00004231": "i know most of festering negativity", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00007-00004232-00004599": "no mercy all i got is working never stop", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00008-00004600-00006895": "searching never questions", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00009-00006895-00008495": "mistakes real fast", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00010-00008496-00008751": "to be iconic sipping on a gin and tonic", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00011-00008752-00008935": "got me going off and i'm on this topic", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00012-00008936-00009159": "uh if i ever play i want it you know", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00013-00009160-00009359": "that i'm always honest stay away from", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00014-00009360-00009527": "those who are toxic keep my your face no", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00015-00009528-00009727": "way you don't want it don't try to drain", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00016-00009728-00009999": "my energy the enemy is everything it's", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00017-00010000-00010255": "mentally unhealthily spreading like a", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00018-00010256-00010471": "rare disease but i won't let it get to", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00019-00010472-00010751": "me i don't need your therapy i can leave", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00020-00010752-00011071": "a legacy of leading by intensity come on", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00021-00011072-00011367": "we can fight this freedom is priceless", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00022-00011368-00011631": "french is like a virus living in a", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00023-00011632-00011927": "crisis do you feel courageous do you", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00024-00011928-00012191": "seek greatness trust me you could take", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00025-00012192-00013727": "it go on and take your aim many", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00026-00013728-00015191": "make mistakes real fast", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00027-00015191-00015455": "don't try to drain my energy the enemy", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00028-00015456-00016883": "is everything", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00029-00016884-00017294": "is like a virus living in a crisis do", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00030-00017295-00017535": "you feel courageous do you seek", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00031-00017536-00017814": "greatness trust me you can take it go on", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00032-00017815-00018003": "and take your", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00033-00018004-00019711": "aim if you take off the gas you can", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00034-00019712-00019855": "and i'm on this talk you think it's", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00035-00019856-00020111": "mentally unhealthily spreading like a", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00036-00020112-00020327": "rare disease but i won't let it get to", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00037-00020328-00020607": "me i don't need your therapy i can leave", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00038-00020608-00020927": "a legacy of leading by intensity come on", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00039-00020928-00021222": "we can fight this freedom is priceless", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00040-00021223-00021486": "french is like a virus living in a", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00041-00021487-00021783": "crisis do you feel courageous do you", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00042-00021784-00022047": "seek greatness trust me you could take", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00043-00022048-00022726": "it go on and take your aim", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00044-00022727-00023919": "[Music]", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00045-00023920-00024292": "put your foot on the gas no never", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00046-00024293-00026967": "[Music]", "TI_n8NJRcGI-00047-00026968-00027268": "bye"}}, {"audio_id": "TIXu5IxNb3c", "text": {"TIXu5IxNb3c-00000-00000000-00000323": "internet fragmentation and digital", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00001-00000324-00000749": "souvenir sovereignty so at the first", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00002-00000750-00000989": "part of our panel I would like to pass", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00003-00000990-00001354": "the floor to our online moderator Pedro", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00004-00001355-00002063": "Lana", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00005-00002064-00002249": "um I would just like there's some help", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00006-00002250-00002567": "from the technical stuff in the room", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00007-00002568-00002884": "because tipsins is trying to join us", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00008-00002885-00003274": "here in the zoom which he is saying that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00009-00003275-00003515": "it's so credentials to log in with the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00010-00003515-00003749": "general Link in general invitation link", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00011-00003750-00003965": "and he is not able to join us", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00012-00003965-00004097": "so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00013-00004098-00004433": "if it's possible to get another link", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00014-00004434-00004901": "so I can send him but since we have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00015-00004902-00005170": "a bit of time pressing issue I keep", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00016-00005171-00005429": "think we can start", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00017-00005430-00005579": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00018-00005580-00005851": "I would first", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00019-00005852-00006233": "like to say hello to everyone hope", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00020-00006234-00006484": "everyone is well healthy happy and cool", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00021-00006486-00006706": "enjoying the sidechair", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00022-00006708-00007045": "[Music]", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00023-00007045-00007378": "society and seeing so many familiar", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00024-00007379-00007601": "faces here makes me want to be there on", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00025-00007602-00007846": "site with you but I'm pretty sure the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00026-00007847-00008009": "surname is well represented by my", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00027-00008009-00008219": "younger sister Alice was navigating", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00028-00008220-00008513": "through this wonderful Forum guy in this", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00029-00008514-00008645": "wonderful City", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00030-00008646-00008963": "so uh I would like to start thanking my", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00031-00008964-00009221": "friend emila zaleska from mask and you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00032-00009222-00009395": "probably have Poland for her own side", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00033-00009396-00009659": "moderation and also just a few big words", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00034-00009660-00009845": "before the sessions begin", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00035-00009846-00010013": "first time", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00036-00010014-00010289": "first thing about time will be a scarce", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00037-00010290-00010469": "resource for us so I will try to be as", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00038-00010470-00010624": "concise as possible and avoid", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00039-00010625-00010901": "formalities in the session and this is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00040-00010902-00011123": "also why we will we will be getting", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00041-00011124-00011442": "session questions only through", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00042-00011443-00011767": "the chat in preparation", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00043-00011768-00012017": "where you can also vote in which other", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00044-00012018-00012191": "contributions I will", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00045-00012192-00012467": "share the screen here so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00046-00012468-00012713": "people can have access", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00047-00012714-00012905": "to the immense matter where they can add", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00048-00012906-00013066": "questions", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00049-00013067-00013493": "just confirm your first unit", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00050-00013494-00013661": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00051-00013662-00014119": "so please scan the QR codes or insert at", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00052-00014119-00014555": "minty.com the code here that will appear", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00053-00014556-00014735": "in your screen", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00054-00014736-00015041": "and before posing questions I would", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00055-00015041-00015305": "please ask you to write your name and if", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00056-00015306-00015503": "you would like to ask it yourself on the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00057-00015504-00015905": "Meep when you are called or else we will", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00058-00015906-00016079": "read it for you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00059-00016080-00016421": "so the title of our Workshop is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00060-00016422-00016679": "intentionally provocative as the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00061-00016680-00016843": "internet is almost by definition", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00062-00016844-00017093": "something that most of us here at the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00063-00017094-00017411": "igf not worlds even if some people who", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00064-00017412-00017711": "may present many considerations that add", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00065-00017712-00018089": "layers of complexity to this issue so by", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00066-00018090-00018353": "balance this internet is something else", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00067-00018354-00018653": "it doesn't seems like an interesting", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00068-00018654-00019019": "idea but this wordplay kinda help us", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00069-00019020-00019199": "remember that one of the hardest", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00070-00019200-00019493": "difficulties on these debates lies", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00071-00019494-00019763": "largely when it's notable semantic", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00072-00019764-00020033": "confusion people often talk about", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00073-00020034-00020194": "different things when they are seeing", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00074-00020195-00020500": "these same words and many refer to the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00075-00020501-00020819": "same ideas but with different terms that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00076-00020820-00020957": "are not fragmentations internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00077-00020958-00021317": "sovereignty etc etc to solve this many", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00078-00021318-00021539": "people are trying to build and advocate", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00079-00021540-00021763": "for more precise technical Concepts", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00080-00021764-00022049": "others take a functional approach trying", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00081-00022050-00022235": "to bypass the difficulties of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00082-00022236-00022558": "semantic confusion other things that too", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00083-00022559-00022708": "many issues are being lumped together", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00084-00022709-00023063": "under these Concepts and they are true", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00085-00023064-00023291": "eyes and make us lose precious time and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00086-00023292-00023644": "energy trying to find definitions and so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00087-00023645-00023927": "on and so on so there's nobody better", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00088-00023928-00024185": "place than a portal that is a space by", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00089-00024186-00024430": "accident as discussion discuss And", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00090-00024431-00024736": "discussing internet issues to promote uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00091-00024737-00024869": "this kind of dialogue between", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00092-00024870-00025072": "stakeholders from diverse backgrounds", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00093-00025073-00025300": "but in different perspectives into", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00094-00025301-00025541": "contacts and trying to find points of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00095-00025542-00025762": "consensus or pursuing some common", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00096-00025763-00025877": "grammar", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00097-00025877-00026189": "and of course we do this if I spice up", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00098-00026189-00026467": "you youth perspective caring for equal", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00099-00026468-00026693": "representation of this group in the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00100-00026694-00026974": "workshop that being said in considering", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00101-00026975-00027208": "I already spoke too much I would like to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00102-00027210-00027412": "briefly introducer panelists in the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00103-00027413-00027605": "order that way you will make the opening", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00104-00027606-00027862": "remarks presenting just some of their", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00105-00027863-00028120": "many qualifications speakers will have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00106-00028122-00028331": "five minutes each for opening remarks", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00107-00028332-00028564": "and then we will proceed to keep the Q a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00108-00028566-00028846": "part of our session by panelists will", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00109-00028847-00029081": "choose specific questions", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00110-00029082-00029345": "to answer during two minutes each", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00111-00029345-00029567": "when you are 30 seconds away from the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00112-00029568-00029789": "time limit we will warn you in the chat", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00113-00029789-00030137": "and Emily can tap the mic twice as well", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00114-00030138-00030502": "uh so uh you know synthetical is the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00115-00030504-00030712": "vice president and the dear government's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00116-00030713-00030983": "organization a member of isaks even a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00117-00030983-00031229": "chapter and was recently a contractor at", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00118-00031230-00031420": "Isaac working on their digital", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00119-00031422-00031657": "sovereignty projects", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00120-00031658-00031990": "is the president of their governments a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00121-00031991-00032224": "member of Isaac's Nigeria's chapter and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00122-00032225-00032477": "holds a PhD in computer science with", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00123-00032477-00033139": "research focus on cyber security", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00124-00033140-00033412": "he was a member of the icon board of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00125-00033413-00033665": "directors and a special Ambassador for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00126-00033666-00033967": "the net Munger initiative", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00127-00033968-00034211": "Stinson's is the head of sector of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00128-00034212-00034415": "Internet governance and mode stakeholder", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00129-00034416-00034801": "dialogue at the European Commission", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00130-00034802-00035111": "is an internet Society igfbf Ambassador", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00131-00035112-00035302": "that was also part of the European", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00132-00035303-00035693": "Parliament Ukraine in mutameter is a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00133-00035694-00035861": "professor at the Georgia Institute of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00134-00035862-00036052": "Technologies called School of public", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00135-00036053-00036389": "policy in the USA and a co-founder of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00136-00036390-00036635": "the non-commercial users constituency", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00137-00036636-00037187": "and I can Evan advice Service as good", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00138-00037188-00037421": "um so sorry if I spoke in if the name's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00139-00037422-00037524": "wrong", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00140-00037525-00037924": "and in a sense the floor is yours so we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00141-00037925-00038261": "can begin", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00142-00038262-00038501": "all right thank you very much Pedro uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00143-00038502-00038777": "once again my name is innocentadrico", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00144-00038778-00038980": "um besides all he has said I'm a student", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00145-00038981-00039118": "too I'm a student of international", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00146-00039119-00039412": "relations and I coordinate the Ghana", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00147-00039413-00039874": "youth igf in Uganda okay the Uganda so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00148-00039875-00039983": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00149-00039984-00040229": "just because the session starts I want", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00150-00040230-00040655": "to bring to perspective uh uh the two", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00151-00040656-00040859": "areas we are looking at digital", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00152-00040860-00041212": "sovereignty and display internet I just", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00153-00041213-00041633": "want to bring up a point on how one can", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00154-00041634-00041879": "lead to the other so we all agree that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00155-00041880-00042052": "the internet has become a central part", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00156-00042053-00042383": "of our lives uh politically economically", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00157-00042384-00042790": "socially and it has grown to be stronger", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00158-00042791-00043151": "than we ever imagined yeah uh if you had", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00159-00043152-00043390": "to ask someone from those years they", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00160-00043391-00043637": "they will tell you uh from those years", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00161-00043638-00043840": "when the internet started uh they would", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00162-00043841-00044008": "tell you they didn't expect that it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00163-00044009-00044249": "would be this big but it is so powerful", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00164-00044250-00044512": "we've seen this especially during the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00165-00044513-00044789": "pandemic and I should say this is a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00166-00044790-00045071": "reason enough for for countries to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00167-00045072-00045311": "assert some kind of authority over", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00168-00045312-00045557": "certain aspects of of the online space", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00169-00045558-00045839": "yeah just as they do in the offline", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00170-00045840-00046187": "space uh we see that governments intend", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00171-00046188-00046427": "to put in policies and Implement", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00172-00046428-00046733": "policies that give them more authority", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00173-00046734-00047089": "over how parts of the internet work yeah", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00174-00047090-00047429": "especially within their borders yeah and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00175-00047430-00047579": "this has been termed as digital", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00176-00047580-00047843": "sovereignty yeah countries have always", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00177-00047844-00048071": "defended these actions", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00178-00048072-00048268": "um the we know the actions for example", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00179-00048269-00048545": "shutdowns uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00180-00048546-00048871": "by saying for example in Uganda", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00181-00048872-00049115": "during the pause the internet was shut", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00182-00049116-00049433": "down and the reason was", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00183-00049434-00049762": "they are they shut down the the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00184-00049763-00050008": "for matters of National Security they", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00185-00050009-00050183": "were trying to see that the country", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00186-00050184-00050345": "doesn't get into conflict because", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00187-00050346-00050735": "according to them uh the internet was", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00188-00050736-00050999": "was being used to incite violence", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00189-00051000-00051155": "by", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00190-00051156-00051454": "by the voters or by the the people who", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00191-00051455-00051754": "are going to the polls yeah so at the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00192-00051755-00051911": "end of the day uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00193-00051912-00052163": "when you look at that Authority we do", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00194-00052164-00052630": "realize that it has a limit that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00195-00052632-00052949": "tends to end up in another thing yeah as", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00196-00052950-00053159": "we're going to see our my colleagues", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00197-00053160-00053303": "here are going to talk more about that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00198-00053304-00053615": "uh so digital sovereignty we do agree", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00199-00053616-00053891": "that it can actually promote a lot of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00200-00053891-00054132": "good things like Innovation flexibility", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00201-00054133-00054437": "within the borders of that country yeah", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00202-00054438-00054713": "but however we see the internet model is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00203-00054714-00054976": "a border borderless one yeah the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00204-00054977-00055265": "internet cannot exist with borders yeah", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00205-00055266-00055529": "therefore digital Sovereign deposits are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00206-00055529-00055787": "very great threat to how the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00207-00055788-00056200": "works to to how it operates and also its", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00208-00056201-00056459": "usefulness to we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00209-00056460-00056842": "the the users yeah and uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00210-00056844-00057100": "therefore this digital sovereignty can", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00211-00057101-00057288": "actually lead to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00212-00057289-00057569": "fragmenting of uh of the Internet by", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00213-00057570-00057887": "governments where they decide uh what", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00214-00057888-00058091": "parts of the internet or of the online", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00215-00058091-00058313": "space their citizens can access for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00216-00058314-00058594": "example I can give you an uh an example", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00217-00058595-00058792": "in Uganda still", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00218-00058794-00059021": "um there was a time when the government", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00219-00059022-00059188": "decided that they're going to ban", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00220-00059189-00059566": "Facebook so meaning that they are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00221-00059567-00059813": "prohibiting you from using Facebook you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00222-00059814-00060047": "can use other platforms but you had to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00223-00060048-00060269": "use uh for example for some of us who", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00224-00060270-00060521": "wanted to continue on the on Facebook we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00225-00060522-00060892": "are using vpns uh so uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00226-00060894-00061247": "these decisions uh mean that citizens", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00227-00061248-00061588": "will see and access only what their", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00228-00061589-00061792": "governments want them to see", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00229-00061794-00062111": "just imagine uh the the the the kind of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00230-00062112-00062344": "tempering it would do to the flow of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00231-00062345-00062663": "information yeah and the the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00232-00062664-00063016": "flow of networking so now this becomes a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00233-00063017-00063341": "state of let's play internet that we are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00234-00063341-00063797": "trying to also discuss here and uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00235-00063798-00064066": "so in simple terms uh what we are trying", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00236-00064067-00064282": "to bring up here is that digital", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00237-00064283-00064421": "sovereignty", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00238-00064422-00064871": "has some good parts of it yeah as I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00239-00064872-00065200": "already said but it is a threat in the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00240-00065201-00065404": "other way to the to how the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00241-00065405-00065806": "operates so at the end of the day uh it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00242-00065807-00066088": "should be something we we we take", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00243-00066089-00066431": "cautiously especially as stakeholders so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00244-00066432-00066694": "I'll just complete my statement by", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00245-00066695-00066899": "saying while the internet has remained", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00246-00066900-00067169": "reliable uh our world has become", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00247-00067170-00067315": "increasingly", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00248-00067316-00067615": "unpredictable yeah", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00249-00067616-00067967": "stakeholders from government actors to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00250-00067968-00068219": "even non-state actors have taken", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00251-00068220-00068549": "decisions that threaten the the uh the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00252-00068550-00068903": "the core the core values of how the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00253-00068904-00069203": "internet is supposed to work yeah so uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00254-00069204-00069413": "that means the biggest threat to the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00255-00069414-00069659": "internet and its functionality now is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00256-00069660-00069905": "still with the users that that created", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00257-00069906-00070288": "it so uh our big stop there for now", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00258-00070289-00070894": "thank you very much", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00259-00070895-00071141": "first input", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00260-00071142-00071303": "today and also", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00261-00071304-00071669": "play into the time and now I would like", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00262-00071670-00072041": "to invite our next speaker Emmanuel ogu", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00263-00072042-00072521": "to take the floor", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00264-00072522-00072700": "thank you Emilia good morning everyone", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00265-00072701-00072982": "from Nigeria", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00266-00072983-00073241": "um I'm Emmanuel unfortunately I cannot", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00267-00073242-00073481": "use my video due to bandwidth issues but", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00268-00073482-00073805": "um I hope you can hear me correctly", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00269-00073806-00074344": "I hope you can hear me clearly", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00270-00074345-00074467": "yes", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00271-00074468-00074747": "all right thank you so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00272-00074748-00074938": "um thank you innocent for that um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00273-00074939-00075263": "wonderful introduction uh when we talk", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00274-00075264-00075491": "about digital sovereignty you know like", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00275-00075492-00075700": "Pedro was trying to create in the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00276-00075701-00075832": "earlier remarks", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00277-00075833-00076085": "you know there is these misconception", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00278-00076086-00076325": "around the fact that uh well there is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00279-00076326-00076606": "this often one-sided Viewpoint today to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00280-00076607-00076811": "the possibility that digital sovereignty", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00281-00076812-00077087": "could only have negative and adverse", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00282-00077088-00077381": "consequences but we have seen", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00283-00077382-00077669": "um some applications or some", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00284-00077670-00077897": "experimentations of digital sovereignty", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00285-00077898-00078073": "where", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00286-00078074-00078305": "governments actually have genuine", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00287-00078306-00078461": "interests and they pursue these", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00288-00078462-00078619": "interests without", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00289-00078620-00078893": "outcomes that threaten the functionality", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00290-00078894-00079073": "of the internet and then the digital", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00291-00079074-00079391": "rights of the citizens who rely on these", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00292-00079392-00079594": "um ecosystem within their jurisdictions", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00293-00079595-00079991": "but then the the the broader consensus", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00294-00079992-00080212": "or the broader conflict that we have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00295-00080213-00080344": "rather", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00296-00080345-00080537": "around display internet which is the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00297-00080538-00080741": "other side of the debate is the fact", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00298-00080742-00080819": "that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00299-00080820-00081106": "not only do these governments do", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00300-00081107-00081281": "governments continue to implement these", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00301-00081282-00081556": "regulations in ways that threaten the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00302-00081557-00081832": "interests and the operations of other", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00303-00081833-00082055": "stakeholders who rely on the internet we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00304-00082056-00082217": "have also began to see some form of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00305-00082218-00082576": "impetus and some form of um audacity", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00306-00082577-00082865": "especially within the African space you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00307-00082866-00083119": "know that that continues to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00308-00083120-00083375": "systematically neglect the effects that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00309-00083376-00083693": "these actions of the split internet or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00310-00083694-00083903": "these actions against uh in line with", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00311-00083904-00084047": "the internet of splintering the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00312-00084048-00084497": "so to speak continue to impact", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00313-00084498-00084779": "on the citizens you know on a broad", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00314-00084780-00085156": "scale and then of course it is it is um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00315-00085157-00085361": "there are incentives for why governments", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00316-00085362-00085499": "often", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00317-00085500-00085673": "consider splintering the internet the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00318-00085674-00086075": "first has to do with uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00319-00086076-00086273": "interests of National Security you know", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00320-00086274-00086519": "like that which I'm innocent have shared", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00321-00086520-00086711": "we have seen similar incidents in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00322-00086712-00086981": "Nigeria as well where around um you know", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00323-00086982-00087244": "periods of Elections or around periods", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00324-00087245-00087682": "of political dissension you know the the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00325-00087683-00087959": "government often takes a focus on the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00326-00087960-00088156": "internet as a way of controlling how", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00327-00088157-00088385": "conversations are held and you know", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00328-00088386-00088625": "recently we just came out of the Twitter", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00329-00088626-00089009": "ban in Nigeria you know and we saw that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00330-00089010-00089500": "not only do do digital rights have have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00331-00089501-00089771": "implications for physical rights or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00332-00089772-00089981": "rights in the physical world we also saw", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00333-00089982-00090238": "that at the end of the day if no one is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00334-00090239-00090449": "able to hold government responsible for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00335-00090450-00090718": "these actions then we set a precedent", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00336-00090719-00091061": "not just in that jurisdiction but as an", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00337-00091062-00091229": "example that other jurisdictions can", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00338-00091230-00091391": "follow it matching out to the same", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00339-00091392-00091667": "consequences to individuals so basically", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00340-00091668-00091918": "when you when you block the internet or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00341-00091919-00092093": "when you Sprint at the internet you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00342-00092094-00092315": "often affect individuals rights to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00343-00092316-00092525": "access information you affects the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00344-00092526-00092741": "individuals rights to pursue economic", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00345-00092742-00092903": "livelihood you're affecting the videos", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00346-00092904-00093155": "right the freedom of Association and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00347-00093156-00093400": "then all of these you know unite within", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00348-00093401-00093682": "a framework that continues to undermine", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00349-00093683-00093881": "Democratic principles on a broad scale", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00350-00093882-00094181": "and then you know another consideration", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00351-00094182-00094397": "for governments in splintering the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00352-00094398-00094576": "internet on pursuing digital sovereignty", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00353-00094577-00094829": "in very unsustainable manners or in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00354-00094830-00095105": "various along unsustainable Pathways is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00355-00095106-00095393": "that that has to do with the conform or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00356-00095394-00095675": "cancer cultural that we see um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00357-00095676-00095956": "popularized in digital spaces these days", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00358-00095957-00096256": "so basically governments are afraid of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00359-00096257-00096467": "what happens if tomorrow the world", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00360-00096468-00096671": "expects us to behave in a certain way", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00361-00096672-00096887": "that we are unable to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00362-00096888-00097168": "um comply with or do not fix the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00363-00097169-00097379": "Sovereign interests of the country how", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00364-00097380-00097588": "do we ensure that you know our", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00365-00097589-00097859": "e-government systems our digital economy", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00366-00097860-00098194": "is not affected by uh actions that the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00367-00098195-00098435": "world may take against against", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00368-00098436-00098506": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00369-00098507-00098861": "them in this in this dispensation and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00370-00098862-00099059": "then we see the regrettable", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00371-00099060-00099323": "um and very", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00372-00099324-00099544": "unacceptable situation of Russia and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00373-00099545-00099761": "Ukraine and then other conflicts that we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00374-00099762-00100037": "see between the US and China and then", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00375-00100038-00100331": "the U.S and Iran and then we see that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00376-00100332-00100529": "you know governments begin to have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00377-00100530-00100799": "growing incentives for okay let's let's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00378-00100800-00100943": "look for ways to consolidate our", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00379-00100944-00101171": "interests our data our networks the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00380-00101172-00101309": "Transmissions that we have let's have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00381-00101310-00101524": "some control over that but then one", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00382-00101525-00101681": "recommendation that I would want to live", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00383-00101682-00101921": "which is the fact that on the backs of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00384-00101922-00102149": "display internet we do not have an", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00385-00102150-00102371": "internet anymore so by the time we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00386-00102372-00102616": "Sprint at the internet we end up with a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00387-00102617-00102727": "framework", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00388-00102728-00103066": "that not only blocks or courts start", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00389-00103067-00103210": "jurisdiction out from the rest of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00390-00103211-00103463": "world effectively you know of course", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00391-00103464-00103751": "making Transmissions more difficult to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00392-00103752-00103925": "reach for making translations more", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00393-00103926-00104278": "difficult to share across these spaces", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00394-00104279-00104513": "and across boundaries but then we also", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00395-00104514-00104789": "end up with a situation where", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00396-00104790-00105028": "digital rights or physical rights are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00397-00105029-00105257": "impacted at the same time in such a way", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00398-00105258-00105586": "that um users get to begin to or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00399-00105588-00105827": "Internet users get to get to begin to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00400-00105828-00106036": "worry about what the future of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00401-00106038-00106240": "digital ecosystem is going to be the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00402-00106241-00106439": "impact is economic in the first place", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00403-00106440-00106613": "because investors begin to lose", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00404-00106614-00106936": "confidence in the Progressive", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00405-00106938-00107134": "um or the progress of the digital", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00406-00107135-00107375": "ecosystem like we saw in Nigeria during", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00407-00107376-00107681": "the Twitter ban of 2021 and then there", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00408-00107682-00107945": "are also other implications", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00409-00107946-00108215": "to The Sovereign reputation of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00410-00108216-00108425": "country in the eyes of her Sovereign or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00411-00108426-00108599": "diplomatic neighbors and diplomatic", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00412-00108600-00108784": "counterparts I would like to drop the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00413-00108785-00108989": "floor here now and then hand over to the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00414-00108990-00109366": "next speaker thank you very much", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00415-00109367-00109739": "thank you very much Emmanuel and now I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00416-00109740-00109973": "would like to pass the floor to Vulcan", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00417-00109974-00110284": "kleinvestor horse here with us today on", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00418-00110285-00110419": "site", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00419-00110420-00110710": "thank you very much and thank you for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00420-00110711-00111181": "having me here in this endless chain of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00421-00111182-00111515": "workshops on internet fragmentation that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00422-00111516-00111815": "were in its opening remarks that you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00423-00111816-00112127": "know that there is also a risk that we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00424-00112128-00112301": "end up with more confusion than", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00425-00112302-00112660": "clarification because the terminology", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00426-00112661-00112852": "for internet fragmentation and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00427-00112853-00113219": "splendonet is now very popular and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00428-00113220-00113363": "different people have a different", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00429-00113364-00113683": "understanding and my hope is that the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00430-00113683-00113881": "igf here", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00431-00113882-00114169": "can contribute", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00432-00114170-00114490": "to bring more clarity to debate because", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00433-00114491-00114695": "it's an important debate and we have to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00434-00114696-00115043": "face challenges which come with internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00435-00115044-00115277": "fragmentation of what people what some", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00436-00115278-00115415": "people understand under internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00437-00115416-00115733": "fragmentation basically in my eyes it's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00438-00115733-00116110": "the conflict which was raised already 25", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00439-00116111-00116602": "years ago by Manuel else in his very", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00440-00116603-00116860": "good book the network society when he", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00441-00116861-00117125": "said we have States and we have Networks", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00442-00117126-00117383": "states are hierarchies", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00443-00117383-00117665": "and are based on", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00444-00117666-00117928": "State sovereignty and networks our", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00445-00117929-00118140": "networks are borderless", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00446-00118141-00118601": "and so that means we have these two", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00447-00118602-00118966": "different let's say organizations in the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00448-00118967-00119195": "world so we have networks which ignore", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00449-00119196-00119489": "borders and we have states which have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00450-00119490-00119899": "borders and this brings a conflict and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00451-00119900-00120395": "what we have now in our world is that we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00452-00120396-00120640": "have on the application layer we have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00453-00120641-00121036": "one world and 193 National jurisdictions", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00454-00121038-00121277": "but on the transport layer we still have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00455-00121278-00121577": "one worldwide internet and I think this", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00456-00121578-00122008": "is um a reality uh a contradiction we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00457-00122009-00122339": "have to face so probably the dreamers", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00458-00122340-00122590": "and forces of the internet had the idea", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00459-00122591-00122765": "that the one world one internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00460-00122766-00123095": "philosophy will move upwards and we will", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00461-00123096-00123358": "have a harmonized world one world one", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00462-00123359-00123773": "Global jurisdictions but to be realistic", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00463-00123774-00124108": "so this is not the case so the diversion", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00464-00124109-00124397": "interest economic interest politics in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00465-00124398-00124649": "the list Villages history cultural and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00466-00124650-00124919": "all this so that means we will live with", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00467-00124920-00125225": "States and National jurisdictions and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00468-00125226-00125471": "sovereignty the next 100 years state", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00469-00125472-00125728": "will not disappear so and that means we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00470-00125729-00126028": "have to face this conflict this one", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00471-00126029-00126293": "worldwide internet what I see today and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00472-00126294-00126575": "a lot of cases has been mentioned is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00473-00126576-00126947": "there isn't a risk now that the 193", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00474-00126948-00127295": "National jurisdictions will go downwards", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00475-00127296-00127601": "and try to Splinter the transport layer", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00476-00127602-00127931": "this is the this is a big risk but on", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00477-00127932-00128107": "the other hand you know", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00478-00128108-00128627": "the reality has shown that uh with all", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00479-00128628-00129016": "the attacks against the uh let's say the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00480-00129017-00129214": "transport layer the domain name system", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00481-00129215-00129508": "the gcp IB protocol the IP address", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00482-00129509-00129901": "system it's still there so that means", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00483-00129902-00130313": "it functions and as you're on mabi has", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00484-00130314-00130571": "said in one of the plenary sessions", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00485-00130572-00130925": "um you know nobody could even in the in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00486-00130926-00131177": "the pandemic time", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00487-00131178-00131435": "lament that the internet is down it has", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00488-00131436-00131693": "worked so certainly you know some", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00489-00131694-00131987": "governments have introduced shutdowns as", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00490-00131988-00132275": "we heard just now but is this really a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00491-00132276-00132473": "fragmentation of the internet in my eyes", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00492-00132474-00132761": "this is just censorship this is because", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00493-00132762-00133109": "you know you do not change the uh basic", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00494-00133110-00133409": "Protocols of the internet infrastructure", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00495-00133410-00133654": "you introduce a barrier on the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00496-00133655-00133943": "application layer and this is censorship", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00497-00133944-00134177": "this is a violation of the Human Rights", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00498-00134178-00134399": "Convention in a certain but not a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00499-00134400-00134602": "violation of the protocols of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00500-00134603-00134969": "internet so I would not say I wouldn't", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00501-00134970-00135173": "say that there are not risks also for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00502-00135174-00135443": "the protocols we have seen this over the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00503-00135444-00135664": "years you know it started in the 1990s", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00504-00135665-00135940": "with an alternate route then we had some", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00505-00135941-00136127": "ideas from the French government to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00506-00136128-00136439": "organize an object naming system for the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00507-00136440-00136661": "internet of things as an alternate to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00508-00136662-00136931": "the domain name system so we did see the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00509-00136932-00137173": "handle system and the digital object", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00510-00137174-00137459": "architecture this was also an attack you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00511-00137460-00137752": "know recently China started a debate in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00512-00137753-00138071": "the itu about new Internet Protocol and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00513-00138072-00138257": "we have now a debate about blockchain", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00514-00138258-00138569": "and the dot ath domain which is not in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00515-00138570-00138845": "the root or uh but you know it could", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00516-00138846-00139145": "offer an alternative but you know all", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00517-00139146-00139601": "these efforts to uh Splinter let's say", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00518-00139602-00139852": "the basic infrastructure have failed so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00519-00139853-00140166": "far even the Chinese proposal on new IP", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00520-00140167-00140464": "uh you know did not make its way into", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00521-00140465-00140764": "the itu planet potentiary Conference in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00522-00140765-00140999": "October last year in Bucharest so the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00523-00141000-00141251": "proposal was discussed but has no", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00524-00141252-00141533": "majority and now Chinese papers discuss", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00525-00141534-00141785": "about so-called polymorphic networks", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00526-00141786-00142127": "which are let's say nothing else than a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00527-00142128-00142499": "network on top of the DNS so it's not an", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00528-00142500-00142759": "alternative but and and complementary", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00529-00142760-00142985": "complementary thing which which is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00530-00142986-00143207": "interesting the same happened with a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00531-00143208-00143652": "French proposal for the ons in the uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00532-00143653-00143993": "2009 so we discovered Internet of Things", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00533-00143994-00144304": "is an application on top of the DNS and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00534-00144305-00144527": "not an alternative to the DNS and I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00535-00144528-00144766": "think this is important to clarify so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00536-00144767-00145043": "that you there is a need to Ring the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00537-00145044-00145252": "Alarm Bells but you should Ring the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00538-00145253-00145528": "Alarm bells in places where there is a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00539-00145529-00145877": "need internet shutdowns this is a good", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00540-00145878-00146111": "reason to Ring the Alarm Bells but to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00541-00146112-00146345": "qualify it is more as a violation of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00542-00146346-00146639": "Human Rights and not as blendering the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00543-00146640-00146873": "internet so you should be very careful", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00544-00146874-00147239": "in making this distinctions so I stop", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00545-00147240-00147431": "here but we will have a second Cloud", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00546-00147432-00147628": "that I can add some more comments thank", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00547-00147629-00147751": "you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00548-00147752-00148013": "thank you very much Wolfgang there will", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00549-00148014-00148307": "be definitely more time for both", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00550-00148308-00148528": "answering questions from the audience", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00551-00148529-00148777": "and also for the final remarks", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00552-00148778-00149189": "so now I would like to pass the floor to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00553-00149190-00149561": "our next speaker is Steve Sands who is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00554-00149562-00149813": "online with us today Steve the floor is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00555-00149814-00149975": "yours", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00556-00149976-00150275": "thank you so much and I'm sorry I joined", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00557-00150276-00150413": "a bit late I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00558-00150414-00150611": "represent here the European commission", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00559-00150612-00150816": "I'm the the head of the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00560-00150817-00151021": "governance sector", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00561-00151022-00151319": "uh so I I think I'm in a good position", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00562-00151320-00151535": "to say that uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00563-00151536-00151685": "this is something the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00564-00151686-00151871": "fragmentation is something that uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00565-00151872-00152123": "worries the EU and the Commission in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00566-00152124-00152375": "particular a lot and we dedicate a lot", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00567-00152376-00152633": "of thinking about it and we I completely", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00568-00152634-00153059": "concur with volvine that we need some", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00569-00153060-00153239": "order into this debate because it's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00570-00153240-00153485": "extremely extremely complex and and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00571-00153486-00153719": "conceptual tools and framework that can", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00572-00153720-00154001": "help us think about this are more than", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00573-00154002-00154313": "welcome and actually Wolfram himself has", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00574-00154314-00154595": "has proposed some of these tools in in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00575-00154596-00154931": "seminal papers that that we take very", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00576-00154932-00155045": "much into account", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00577-00155046-00155549": "and uh basically what we find it useful", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00578-00155550-00155969": "is indeed to to divide the to classify", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00579-00155970-00156275": "the trends that we see in terms of uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00580-00156276-00156551": "internet fragmentation or Internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00581-00156552-00156766": "openness of keeping Internet open as an", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00582-00156767-00156964": "internet Global which is in the end what", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00583-00156965-00157066": "matters", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00584-00157067-00157631": "in uh different layers and these layers", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00585-00157632-00157925": "are about you know the technical", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00586-00157926-00158116": "architecture of the internet of Wolfram", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00587-00158117-00158411": "was saying but there are also commercial", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00588-00158412-00158711": "and economic layers so you can have a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00589-00158712-00158809": "completely", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00590-00158810-00159052": "fragmented internet at the economic", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00591-00159053-00159257": "level impacting the companies that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00592-00159258-00159454": "operate in in that internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00593-00159455-00159652": "you can have a fragmentation on internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00594-00159653-00159881": "governance itself and you're going to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00595-00159882-00160157": "have a regulatory fragmentation and now", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00596-00160158-00160535": "to start from from the last point which", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00597-00160536-00160793": "is you know very visible potentially", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00598-00160794-00160985": "controversial and this is something that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00599-00160986-00161261": "the EU as such is is recognized as uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00600-00161262-00161614": "one of The Regulators of the of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00601-00161615-00161885": "let's say application layer of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00602-00161886-00162076": "internet and yesterday we had", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00603-00162077-00162263": "we organize an open Forum actually", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00604-00162264-00162461": "presenting the three of the main", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00605-00162462-00162683": "regulatory instruments that we are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00606-00162684-00162928": "implementing these days", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00607-00162929-00163361": "um the uh I think it's we need to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00608-00163362-00163552": "recognize", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00609-00163553-00163889": "as we do in many documents that deal", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00610-00163890-00164045": "with digital principles and in the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00611-00164046-00164171": "Declaration for the future of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00612-00164172-00164351": "internet Etc that there is this dark", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00613-00164352-00164621": "side of the internet and that a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00614-00164622-00164825": "completely unregulated application", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00615-00164826-00165197": "system is not um is not desirable it's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00616-00165198-00165389": "uh you know Public public", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00617-00165390-00165545": "administrations are accountable to their", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00618-00165546-00165911": "citizens and we see many things going on", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00619-00165912-00166216": "online that we did not expect at the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00620-00166217-00166378": "beginning of the internet I think that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00621-00166379-00166595": "the Green surf is a very brave in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00622-00166596-00166816": "recognizing this in every speech that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00623-00166817-00167014": "I've seen him recently and this is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00624-00167015-00167237": "something that we all should recognize", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00625-00167238-00167464": "and this requires public intervention", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00626-00167465-00167764": "and this public intervention will be", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00627-00167765-00168245": "always in relation to the values the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00628-00168246-00168611": "Democratic processes or not Democratic", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00629-00168612-00168928": "processes that are in place in a given", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00630-00168929-00169181": "uh political political Community or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00631-00169182-00169331": "political institutions", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00632-00169332-00169637": "now we don't we we do this we have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00633-00169638-00170047": "plenty of examples we have very complex", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00634-00170048-00170369": "processes to bring up legislation in the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00635-00170370-00170795": "EU that end up mixing interests and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00636-00170796-00171004": "perspectives and different cultural", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00637-00171005-00171190": "backgrounds from your member states and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00638-00171191-00171371": "generate a plus series of legislations", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00639-00171372-00171659": "that are then actually taken many times", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00640-00171660-00171875": "as blueprints across across the world", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00641-00171876-00172366": "now is this the end point of uh of uh of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00642-00172367-00172625": "uh internet fragmentation in the in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00643-00172626-00172943": "relation to regulation we think it's not", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00644-00172944-00173266": "we think that we should also be very", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00645-00173267-00173483": "careful about fragmentation and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00646-00173484-00173776": "regulation and to that end we really", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00647-00173777-00174143": "think that the common denominator of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00648-00174144-00174328": "every piece of regulation on the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00649-00174329-00174635": "internet that should be passed across", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00650-00174636-00174887": "the world is human rights", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00651-00174888-00175097": "that's the common denominator that's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00652-00175098-00175264": "something that it's very much embedded", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00653-00175265-00175487": "in the EU system every piece of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00654-00175488-00175793": "Regulation that we produce has to comply", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00655-00175794-00175973": "with the chart of the fundamental rights", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00656-00175974-00176176": "of the European Union and if it doesn't", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00657-00176177-00176452": "it can be brought to court and the court", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00658-00176453-00176740": "reconsiders the regulation human rights", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00659-00176741-00177064": "are a permanent object of discussion", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00660-00177065-00177316": "when regulation is passed and they are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00661-00177317-00177514": "the end point of end of every internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00662-00177515-00177851": "regulation in the EU", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00663-00177852-00178054": "internal relations and you strengthen", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00664-00178055-00178235": "human rights", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00665-00178236-00178475": "we think it's extremely important that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00666-00178476-00178690": "this happens across the world and this", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00667-00178691-00178973": "should be and it doesn't happen it's not", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00668-00178974-00179171": "happening now so this should be the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00669-00179172-00179369": "common denominator to avoid internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00670-00179370-00179554": "fragmentation at the level of Regulation", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00671-00179555-00179885": "and we work closely with the UN with the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00672-00179886-00180137": "tech Envoy Etc because it's you know", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00673-00180138-00180485": "it's really within the UN system that we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00674-00180486-00180640": "need to work out that common denominator", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00675-00180641-00180838": "very clearly in everything that relates", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00676-00180839-00181145": "to internet Evolution now on technical", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00677-00181146-00181307": "fragmentation", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00678-00181308-00181381": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00679-00181382-00181601": "this this is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00680-00181602-00181919": "um as Wolfe was saying this is a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00681-00181920-00182249": "you know it it has happened already we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00682-00182250-00182416": "should be clear that it has happened not", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00683-00182417-00182681": "that the level of protocols not at the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00684-00182682-00183064": "level of uh DNA DSA I'm sorry", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00685-00183065-00183371": "um I have a domain name system Etc it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00686-00183372-00183623": "happens with the little devices that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00687-00183624-00183959": "telecom companies are forced to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00688-00183960-00184252": "introduce into their Networks so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00689-00184253-00184469": "first there is a certain level of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00690-00184470-00184738": "technical fragmentation via these", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00691-00184739-00184997": "devices that go into the networks that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00692-00184998-00185159": "it's already happening some countries", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00693-00185160-00185375": "apply them some countries don't apply", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00694-00185376-00185531": "them so this is the first realization", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00695-00185532-00185683": "now", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00696-00185684-00185981": "is the technical layer of the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00697-00185982-00186163": "under threat", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00698-00186164-00186713": "our answer is that short term no midterm", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00699-00186714-00187099": "definitely yes it definitely yes we see", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00700-00187100-00187338": "extremely and this occupies", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00701-00187339-00187678": "unfortunately much of our time extremely", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00702-00187679-00188159": "well funded well thought attempts to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00703-00188160-00188447": "really transform core Protocols of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00704-00188448-00188699": "internet into something different and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00705-00188700-00188993": "and this is a this is a major risk to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00706-00188994-00189166": "avoid technical fragmentation of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00707-00189167-00189328": "internet we think it's extremely", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00708-00189329-00189701": "important to respect and build into the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00709-00189702-00189816": "consensus", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00710-00189817-00190054": "multi-stakeholder model that creates", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00711-00190055-00190252": "protocols standards and core", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00712-00190253-00190469": "infrastructures of the internet there", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00713-00190470-00190678": "needs to be a consensus Within These", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00714-00190679-00190859": "systems to make the internet evolve", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00715-00190860-00191111": "without falling into a technical", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00716-00191112-00191440": "fragmentation that we might have it on", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00717-00191441-00191707": "our plate in the igf", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00718-00191708-00192076": "2026 we might be discussing this very", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00719-00192077-00192328": "openly uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00720-00192329-00192659": "I tell you that it's really a a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00721-00192660-00192899": "prominent danger that we are fighting as", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00722-00192900-00193061": "we speak in in some standardization", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00723-00193062-00193187": "organizations", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00724-00193188-00193475": "now on the commercial and economic side", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00725-00193476-00193702": "we think that internet markets should", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00726-00193703-00193978": "remain open fair and contestable", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00727-00193979-00194273": "this is at the basis of for example the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00728-00194274-00194495": "digital markets Act of the European", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00729-00194496-00194999": "Union that puts a certain safeguards so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00730-00195000-00195151": "that the big internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00731-00195152-00195454": "corporations do not take over certain", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00732-00195455-00195652": "markets including the European one but", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00733-00195653-00195838": "also in general I think it's a it's a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00734-00195839-00196133": "framework so that local ecosystems Local", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00735-00196134-00196343": "Economic ecosystems could continue", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00736-00196344-00196619": "thriving without having big corporations", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00737-00196620-00196914": "taking over this is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00738-00196915-00197254": "something that goes hand in hand with", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00739-00197255-00197533": "the fact that we have a digital divide", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00740-00197534-00197819": "the internet is fragmented by the where", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00741-00197820-00198161": "by the mere uh fact that many people is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00742-00198162-00198395": "not connected so it's not really Global", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00743-00198396-00198587": "it's not really open there are plenty of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00744-00198588-00198797": "people who are not connected so we need", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00745-00198798-00198983": "a very strong effort as well to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00746-00198984-00199164": "disfragment the internet at that level", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00747-00199165-00199445": "but these digital transitions bringing", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00748-00199446-00199654": "everyone online should go hand in hand", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00749-00199655-00199990": "also with human rights uh we don't want", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00750-00199991-00200140": "digital transitions for the sake of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00751-00200141-00200302": "digital transitions we want digital", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00752-00200303-00200585": "transitions that are based on an open", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00753-00200586-00200843": "internet model underlying human rights", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00754-00200844-00201173": "because we will know the internet we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00755-00201174-00201478": "cannot take it as uh idealistically as", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00756-00201479-00201695": "as in the beginning it can be used for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00757-00201696-00201947": "exercising massive control over citizens", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00758-00201948-00202375": "or creating a stronger protectionist", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00759-00202376-00202595": "measures thank you very much looking", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00760-00202596-00202997": "forward to engaging the conversation", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00761-00202998-00203428": "and thank you a lot Steve and now I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00762-00203429-00203669": "would like to pass the floor to our", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00763-00203670-00203969": "speaker Katarina and Bob sunovska the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00764-00203970-00204263": "floor is yours", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00765-00204264-00204557": "thank you very much I would like to Echo", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00766-00204558-00204790": "Wolfgang that it's indeed this session", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00767-00204791-00205019": "is one of the Myriad of Internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00768-00205019-00205319": "fragmentation sessions this igf", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00769-00205319-00205588": "but during the sessions we were all", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00770-00205589-00205708": "discussing what is internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00771-00205709-00205990": "fragmentation what it is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00772-00205991-00206357": "um main examples on technical level or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00773-00206358-00206716": "is it focused on user level or Internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00774-00206717-00207034": "governance level and the main question", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00775-00207035-00207346": "remains unanswered apart from what", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00776-00207348-00207544": "exactly is internet fragmentation what", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00777-00207546-00207808": "can we do about that and as a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00778-00207809-00208103": "representative of Youth I believe that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00779-00208104-00208427": "we have at least some general idea that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00780-00208428-00208775": "these decisions made by governments they", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00781-00208776-00208979": "will continue to be made by governments", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00782-00208980-00209327": "at least for now while indeed the world", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00783-00209328-00209560": "order is based on the state sovereignty", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00784-00209561-00209848": "in the digital space digital sovereignty", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00785-00209850-00210244": "will continue to be existing and we need", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00786-00210246-00210521": "to influence the decision-making process", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00787-00210521-00210839": "that's why for example this igf is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00788-00210840-00211042": "indeed really important for us because", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00789-00211044-00211339": "it has very particular trait of being a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00790-00211340-00211679": "multi-stakeholder framework it indeed", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00791-00211680-00211891": "tries to collect all of us from", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00792-00211892-00212165": "governmental sector from private sector", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00793-00212166-00212446": "from youth from Civil Society Academia", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00794-00212448-00212596": "technical community", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00795-00212598-00212944": "and to let us talk together discuss the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00796-00212946-00213203": "critical issues that are relatable to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00797-00213204-00213539": "the global internet we face today and to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00798-00213540-00213721": "find some common Solutions together", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00799-00213721-00214103": "that's why as a youth we are very", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00800-00214104-00214384": "Dynamic group we are really affected by", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00801-00214385-00214642": "the internet and all of its good sights", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00802-00214644-00214889": "and bad sites we have the opportunities", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00803-00214890-00215141": "presented by internet and at the same", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00804-00215142-00215405": "time we're really frustrated when we are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00805-00215406-00215675": "bared from using the other opportunities", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00806-00215676-00215860": "and chances that we could have used", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00807-00215861-00216094": "without the decisions taken by someone", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00808-00216096-00216455": "else without our interests and in this", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00809-00216456-00216851": "igf and multi-stakeholder approach if", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00810-00216852-00217108": "you keep engaged if you keep youth", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00811-00217109-00217463": "engaged we are growing up and then we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00812-00217464-00217727": "are transforming into other groups we're", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00813-00217728-00217973": "becoming young professionals we go into", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00814-00217973-00218182": "government we go into private sector", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00815-00218183-00218429": "Technical Community Civil Society", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00816-00218430-00218717": "Academia and all of them and we know how", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00817-00218717-00218975": "to talk to each other already prepared", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00818-00218976-00219323": "during the youth engagement in igf in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00819-00219323-00219484": "Regional initiatives in National", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00820-00219485-00219784": "initiatives we are ready to listen to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00821-00219785-00220048": "each other having our common past as a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00822-00220050-00220325": "youth and we're ready to build common", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00823-00220326-00220684": "solutions to fight our common problems", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00824-00220685-00221021": "without infringing the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00825-00221021-00221667": "thank you very much", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00826-00221669-00222125": "[Music]", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00827-00222126-00222529": "close this first round of speakers input", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00828-00222530-00223013": "Milton Weller the floor is yours", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00829-00223014-00223187": "thank you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00830-00223188-00223246": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00831-00223248-00223565": "everybody can hear me okay I'm", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00832-00223566-00223841": "sitting here at four in the morning in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00833-00223842-00223960": "the U.S", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00834-00223961-00224065": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00835-00224066-00224434": "and um now I know how people in Asia", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00836-00224435-00224651": "feel when they are participating in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00837-00224652-00225034": "these meetings in strange time zones", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00838-00225035-00225269": "um I was a little bit", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00839-00225269-00225544": "objecting to the title of the session it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00840-00225546-00225755": "talks about a balance between digital", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00841-00225756-00226013": "sovereignty and Splinter net and as", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00842-00226014-00226282": "Pedro said this is probably deliberately", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00843-00226283-00226601": "provocative but I think there is no", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00844-00226602-00226834": "balance if you go for digital", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00845-00226835-00227177": "sovereignty you get a splintered net and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00846-00227178-00227381": "I agree with the comments of innocent", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00847-00227382-00227591": "and Emmanuel about this they already", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00848-00227592-00227831": "said it well I think it's very important", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00849-00227832-00228079": "to include these kinds of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00850-00228080-00228310": "African perspectives or developing", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00851-00228311-00228581": "country perspectives where you know the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00852-00228582-00228791": "government is really willing to just", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00853-00228792-00229103": "shut down the internet and I don't agree", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00854-00229104-00229265": "with Wolfgang that that does not", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00855-00229266-00229577": "constitute fragmentation uh the fact", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00856-00229578-00229781": "that you know there's nothing more", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00857-00229782-00230051": "fragmentary than shutting off the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00858-00230052-00230248": "internet and and refusing to let it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00859-00230250-00230353": "operate", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00860-00230354-00230687": "uh um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00861-00230688-00231142": "now I think we need to be uh to pick up", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00862-00231144-00231394": "on the semantic confusion that Pedro", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00863-00231396-00231532": "referred to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00864-00231533-00231844": "we do have a tendency to confuse the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00865-00231846-00232042": "sovereignty of states", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00866-00232044-00232294": "which does exist and will continue to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00867-00232296-00232537": "exist and in some ways is a good thing", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00868-00232538-00232948": "with sovereignty over cyberspace and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00869-00232950-00233158": "those are two very different things as", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00870-00233159-00233537": "Wolfgang said very well uh perhaps he", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00871-00233538-00233734": "was referring to my book called networks", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00872-00233735-00233987": "and States but he said it was all about", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00873-00233988-00234046": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00874-00234048-00234341": "the the other guy I can't remember his", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00875-00234342-00234473": "name", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00876-00234473-00234653": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00877-00234654-00234917": "there there is a conflict between the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00878-00234917-00235223": "territoriality of governments and the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00879-00235223-00235565": "Global Technical standards of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00880-00235566-00235834": "internet but I think one thing I want to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00881-00235835-00236075": "contribute to this discussion is that we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00882-00236076-00236369": "need to focus more productively on", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00883-00236369-00236632": "talking about the balance between the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00884-00236633-00236963": "state and the market in a globalized", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00885-00236964-00237196": "digital ecosystem because what the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00886-00237198-00237401": "internet with its Global compatibility", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00887-00237402-00237706": "does and it's not just the internet it's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00888-00237707-00238079": "all kinds of digital technologies that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00889-00238080-00238348": "have been organized on a globally", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00890-00238350-00238781": "compatible way for three decades now", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00891-00238782-00239225": "so what how do states assert authority", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00892-00239226-00239369": "over", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00893-00239369-00239671": "digital markets and Digital Services", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00894-00239671-00239915": "when their scope of authority is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00895-00239916-00240203": "Territorial and the market is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00896-00240204-00240527": "transnational uh and the technical", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00897-00240528-00240905": "ecosystem is indeed global", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00898-00240906-00241169": "so I think there's not a good", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00899-00241169-00241456": "recognition within the UN system within", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00900-00241457-00241601": "the igf", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00901-00241602-00241894": "of the importance of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00902-00241896-00242406": "the market uh in generating capital", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00903-00242407-00242698": "for example the the digital compact", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00904-00242700-00242915": "talks about giving everybody Broadband", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00905-00242916-00243232": "well it's a very nice thing to say but", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00906-00243233-00243329": "if you're going to give everybody", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00907-00243330-00243558": "Broadband you're going to be investing", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00908-00243559-00243881": "hundreds of billions of dollars in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00909-00243882-00244246": "capital uh in facilities uh and you'll", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00910-00244248-00244456": "be taking risks that that money will be", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00911-00244457-00244846": "lost or or not used efficiently so we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00912-00244848-00245123": "have to look at you know why do people", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00913-00245123-00245423": "invest how do they invest where does the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00914-00245423-00245663": "money come from and that's a market", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00915-00245664-00245860": "phenomenon", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00916-00245861-00246101": "and we need to develop self-sustaining", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00917-00246102-00246310": "and profitable Industries you know it's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00918-00246311-00246503": "one thing to complain about the fact", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00919-00246504-00246917": "that the U.S platforms are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00920-00246917-00247337": "um you know so dominant uh but the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00921-00247338-00247696": "really the only way to uh approach that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00922-00247698-00247913": "dominance there might be some regulatory", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00923-00247914-00248134": "measures but the most effective way is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00924-00248135-00248429": "to establish competing in alternative", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00925-00248430-00248806": "firms which you have seen for example uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00926-00248807-00249082": "successfully done in China and to some", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00927-00249083-00249353": "extent in India", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00928-00249354-00249448": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00929-00249450-00249629": "so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00930-00249630-00249851": "again the market phenomena become", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00931-00249852-00250091": "extremely important and also it's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00932-00250092-00250294": "clearly the market that drives", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00933-00250296-00250571": "technological innovation and development", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00934-00250571-00250834": "and efficiency now the thing about", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00935-00250835-00251056": "markets is that they do not want to be", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00936-00251057-00251482": "bound by territories they want to create", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00937-00251483-00251891": "more efficient divisions of labor uh and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00938-00251892-00252053": "if you look at something like the chip", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00939-00252054-00252358": "industry uh it has been globalized", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00940-00252359-00252613": "partly because of a World Trade", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00941-00252614-00252996": "Organization agreement the ITA which", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00942-00252998-00253396": "helps to distribute the supply chain of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00943-00253398-00253506": "chips", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00944-00253507-00253775": "uh all over the world but with an", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00945-00253776-00254015": "emphasis on East Asia", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00946-00254016-00254237": "and there was this huge division of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00947-00254238-00254639": "labor between the design uh and uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00948-00254640-00254837": "research and development aspect which is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00949-00254838-00255053": "dominated by the U.S and to some extent", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00950-00255054-00255419": "Western Europe and the manufacturing and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00951-00255419-00255755": "production uh in other countries", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00952-00255756-00256115": "so it's not an accident that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00953-00256116-00256342": "historically the most economically", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00954-00256344-00256642": "liberal countries are precisely the ones", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00955-00256644-00257027": "with the leadership in telecommunication", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00956-00257028-00257315": "Industries with the most rapid and wide", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00957-00257316-00257639": "diffusion of Telecom capabilities I'm", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00958-00257640-00257765": "talking about whether you're talking", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00959-00257766-00257842": "about", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00960-00257844-00258137": "Britain in the telegraph era the U.S and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00961-00258138-00258377": "Scandinavia and the telephone era and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00962-00258378-00258634": "the U.S with the internet it is the most", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00963-00258635-00258958": "economically liberal countries that lead", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00964-00258959-00259198": "so the role of government is largely one", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00965-00259200-00259487": "of setting rules for fair play or for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00966-00259488-00259775": "stopping Fraud and Abuse the government", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00967-00259776-00260032": "interventions however like markets can", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00968-00260033-00260158": "be abused", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00969-00260159-00260446": "and can be failures governments are not", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00970-00260448-00260801": "Gods who reach down into markets and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00971-00260802-00261053": "automatically fix them", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00972-00261054-00261334": "you know I'm sorry to inform the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00973-00261335-00261484": "European Commission of this because", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00974-00261485-00261856": "sometimes they do seem to think that way", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00975-00261857-00262265": "so digital sovereignty is an obstacle in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00976-00262266-00262451": "many cases or can be an obstacle to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00977-00262452-00262637": "development if it means that foreign", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00978-00262638-00262979": "capital and expertise and free trade and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00979-00262980-00263284": "markets with the rest of the world are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00980-00263285-00263543": "going to be blocked and impeded and it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00981-00263544-00263873": "also is an obstacle to Human Rights if", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00982-00263874-00264058": "it means that the government is in fact", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00983-00264059-00264329": "asserting control over what kind of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00984-00264330-00264743": "information people can access and this", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00985-00264744-00265055": "is an Article 19 you know a basic human", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00986-00265056-00265201": "right", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00987-00265202-00265505": "of the International System saying that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00988-00265506-00265697": "people have the right to access", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00989-00265698-00265997": "information wherever they can find it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00990-00265998-00266297": "and sovereignty is the an assertion of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00991-00266298-00266477": "exactly the opposite it says that the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00992-00266478-00266658": "government should have Supreme control", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00993-00266659-00267137": "over what information you can play", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00994-00267138-00267467": "so The Sovereign right of States should", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00995-00267468-00267671": "not get in the way of the human rights", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00996-00267672-00267917": "of people in a country and it should not", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00997-00267918-00268127": "get in the way of the economic rights", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00998-00268128-00268379": "they would have to choose the products", "TIXu5IxNb3c-00999-00268380-00268582": "and services they prefer", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01000-00268583-00268763": "so that's what I have to say look", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01001-00268764-00269337": "forward to the discussion", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01002-00269338-00269663": "[Music]", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01003-00269664-00269932": "first part of our session and now we are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01004-00269933-00270173": "moving to the other one which is the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01005-00270174-00270343": "qanda part", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01006-00270344-00270875": "so in this part firstly we will I will", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01007-00270876-00271271": "collect one question from the floor then", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01008-00271272-00271601": "Pedro will ask one question from the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01009-00271602-00271943": "chat then we will give our speakers some", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01010-00271944-00272219": "time to respond to each other if they", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01011-00272220-00272380": "would like to because we could heard", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01012-00272381-00272665": "that there were some agreements so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01013-00272666-00272945": "disagreements so it might be interesting", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01014-00272946-00273247": "to actually listen to your", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01015-00273248-00273653": "next remarks and after that if we still", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01016-00273654-00273971": "have some time we will take some more", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01017-00273972-00274180": "questions so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01018-00274181-00274577": "uh okay I see two hands", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01019-00274578-00274991": "okay working okay okay so please go", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01020-00274992-00275184": "ahead okay", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01021-00275185-00275549": "Normal University so basically I think", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01022-00275550-00275867": "we have to clarify some concept I I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01023-00275868-00276173": "think I agree with Wolfgang and some way", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01024-00276174-00276401": "I also agree with mutant but I think it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01025-00276402-00276617": "will have two concept first of all human", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01026-00276618-00276899": "rights Freedom expression okay Freedom", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01027-00276900-00277139": "twice is a conditional right it's not a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01028-00277140-00277379": "you know without any condition of course", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01029-00277380-00277565": "you can have a freedom section but the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01030-00277566-00277769": "state has a right to regulate the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01031-00277770-00278015": "content in terms of hate speech if the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01032-00278016-00278219": "polygraphy you know if it's a harm", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01033-00278220-00278477": "content of course therefore because I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01034-00278478-00278699": "started human rights sorry", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01035-00278700-00278903": "human rights Freedom special is not", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01036-00278904-00279101": "absolute right it's a conditional right", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01037-00279102-00279365": "okay so when we talk about", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01038-00279366-00279599": "the state censorship just like a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01039-00279600-00279808": "Wolfgang just mentioned you know when", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01040-00279809-00279977": "they when they shut down they shut no", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01041-00279978-00280139": "shut down the assets to the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01042-00280140-00280373": "they ears they're doing the censorship", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01043-00280374-00280582": "which means that sends out all these", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01044-00280583-00280780": "harmful content of course what", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01045-00280781-00280997": "constitute as a comfortable counter what", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01046-00280998-00281267": "constitute as a as a as a propaganda", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01047-00281268-00281608": "which is up up to debate but at least we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01048-00281609-00281795": "needed to clarify whether they are shut", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01049-00281796-00282082": "down the layer assets or just do the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01050-00282083-00282232": "filtering of the censorship of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01051-00282233-00282430": "country and as I said the content is not", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01052-00282431-00282587": "a freedom expression it's not absolutely", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01053-00282588-00282791": "right so therefore we discuss the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01054-00282792-00283037": "figmentation we have to clarify to what", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01055-00283038-00283265": "what do we exactly means because each", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01056-00283266-00283456": "jurisdiction each country has the right", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01057-00283457-00283715": "to regulate you know the contents on the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01058-00283716-00283841": "internet the internet the content", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01059-00283842-00284063": "internet is not free of the restrictions", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01060-00284064-00284332": "okay so this is my first point so I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01061-00284333-00284471": "would like to qualification from our", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01062-00284472-00284695": "panels the second thing is about", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01063-00284696-00284951": "diversity and fragmentation we'll talk", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01064-00284952-00285155": "about all these industry policy because", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01065-00285156-00285353": "we'll talk about like platforms dominate", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01066-00285354-00285677": "in Africa exactly this is actually the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01067-00285678-00285887": "kind about the industry policy in local", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01068-00285888-00286121": "you know if you want to build up your", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01069-00286122-00286265": "own industry you need to have an", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01070-00286266-00286480": "industry policy which will boost your", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01071-00286481-00286715": "local Industries okay this happened in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01072-00286716-00287087": "in 60 70s we have this free flow of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01073-00287088-00287232": "information", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01074-00287233-00287501": "reached by the U.N to help to balance", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01075-00287502-00287729": "the information flow from the south and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01076-00287730-00288029": "from from the east from the west and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01077-00288030-00288227": "North because we see there's an", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01078-00288228-00288467": "unbalance of information flow but we're", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01079-00288468-00288641": "fixing the similar situation now because", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01080-00288642-00288839": "all these datas are controlled by the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01081-00288840-00289091": "bigger platform from America and China", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01082-00289092-00289337": "and the small countries like the African", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01083-00289338-00289493": "countries they need to have their own", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01084-00289494-00289703": "platforms and how can they do it of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01085-00289704-00289895": "course they have to have the industrial", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01086-00289896-00290093": "policy to help you protect the industry", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01087-00290094-00290477": "and and also antitrust policy to uh to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01088-00290478-00290656": "to regulate those big countries so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01089-00290657-00290830": "therefore I'm asking when we talk about", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01090-00290831-00291041": "fragmentation where is the diversity", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01091-00291042-00291208": "where's the diversity in terms of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01092-00291209-00291556": "regulatory model in terms of content", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01093-00291557-00291839": "also in terms of local industry policy", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01094-00291840-00292115": "so I think we we shouldn't make the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01095-00292116-00292397": "concept segmentation so why they respite", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01096-00292398-00292679": "and also make it so blurred and hijacked", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01097-00292680-00292853": "for political different political", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01098-00292854-00293032": "purpose thank you that's my comment and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01099-00293033-00293687": "also questions", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01100-00293688-00293987": "okay so maybe to clarify is it a comment", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01101-00293988-00294329": "or question to any particular speaker or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01102-00294330-00294580": "the question to like Milton and the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01103-00294581-00294803": "Wolfgang about whether we think this is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01104-00294804-00295079": "a concept how about the diversity you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01105-00295080-00295360": "know local jurisdictions and also these", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01106-00295361-00296195": "freedoms rations you know", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01107-00296196-00296597": "okay I see that Milton has his hand up", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01108-00296598-00297095": "so Milton Place the floor is yours", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01109-00297096-00297280": "sure so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01110-00297281-00297641": "um hi there uh Yik it's good to see you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01111-00297642-00297845": "um I guess you're there on site", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01112-00297846-00297953": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01113-00297954-00298127": "I um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01114-00298128-00298373": "you know I think that this idea that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01115-00298374-00298619": "freedom of expression is conditional", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01116-00298620-00299003": "um as a factual statement uh it is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01117-00299004-00299147": "correct", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01118-00299148-00299399": "um as a normative statement I think it's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01119-00299400-00299860": "a rather bad excuse for for censorship I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01120-00299861-00300184": "mean of course different countries have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01121-00300185-00300406": "different standards some countries are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01122-00300407-00300641": "extremely repressive in what they allow", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01123-00300642-00300913": "and as you know China is one of those", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01124-00300914-00301169": "and to say that you know Freedom", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01125-00301170-00301360": "expression is conditional does not", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01126-00301361-00301619": "justify the kind of censorship that you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01127-00301620-00301756": "see in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01128-00301757-00302080": "probably about half to two-thirds of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01129-00302081-00302405": "countries in the world today", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01130-00302406-00302699": "um and and most of that censorship is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01131-00302700-00302969": "not about protecting the public interest", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01132-00302970-00303184": "it's about protecting people who are in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01133-00303185-00303437": "power and that's precisely what the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01134-00303438-00303827": "internet did was it just by accident", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01135-00303828-00304043": "almost it opened up all of these new", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01136-00304044-00304271": "channels of communication to people and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01137-00304272-00304571": "there were no mechanisms to control them", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01138-00304572-00304973": "and so suddenly people had a widened and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01139-00304974-00305213": "broadened right to access and express", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01140-00305214-00305501": "themselves and many governments and then", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01141-00305502-00305717": "in the last 20 years have started to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01142-00305718-00305999": "clamp down in various ways and this of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01143-00306000-00306251": "course leads to a more fragmented", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01144-00306252-00306647": "application environment", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01145-00306648-00306851": "um so that's that's the response I would", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01146-00306852-00307019": "make I'd be interested to hear from", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01147-00307020-00307534": "Wolfgang also", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01148-00307535-00308027": "yeah I would Echo um Milton that we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01149-00308028-00308297": "should be very careful in saying you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01150-00308298-00308537": "know it's a right of governments to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01151-00308538-00308801": "control content uh that's a very old", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01152-00308802-00309023": "story and it goes back to the invention", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01153-00309024-00309341": "of the printing press Mr Gutenberg 500", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01154-00309342-00309658": "years ago you know and when he offered", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01155-00309659-00310054": "his the opportunity to print the Bible", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01156-00310055-00310499": "this was uh seen by the pope and the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01157-00310500-00310810": "Catholic church with great enthusiasm is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01158-00310811-00311141": "that he could bring the holy word to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01159-00311142-00311471": "many people but then people started to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01160-00311472-00311675": "write pamphlets against the Catholic", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01161-00311676-00312101": "church and the pope was not amused and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01162-00312102-00312419": "the Catholic Church introduced the index", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01163-00312420-00313043": "of censorship which was by the way uh in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01164-00313044-00313375": "in a place until the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01165-00313376-00313895": "1960s so and that's a questions who has", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01166-00313896-00314123": "a capacity to decide what is right and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01167-00314124-00314399": "what is wrong uh content so that means", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01168-00314400-00314734": "and this brings an idea which has to be", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01169-00314735-00315041": "further elaborated in cyberspace about a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01170-00315042-00315341": "neutral third party so that means if", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01171-00315342-00315521": "just the government decides and said", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01172-00315522-00315760": "this is good and this is bad this would", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01173-00315761-00316115": "undermine the individual rights if we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01174-00316116-00316271": "leave it in the hand of Corporations", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01175-00316272-00316637": "with a Facebook oversight board this is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01176-00316638-00316765": "also bad", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01177-00316766-00317087": "in the democratic system we have the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01178-00317088-00317303": "ball element government and the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01179-00317304-00317567": "independent Judiciary you need an", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01180-00317568-00317813": "independent Judiciary for Content", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01181-00317814-00318191": "related cases in cyberspace I remember a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01182-00318192-00318460": "very classical case I'm from the older", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01183-00318461-00318617": "generation younger people will not", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01184-00318618-00318929": "remember that when Daniel Ellsberg from", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01185-00318930-00319021": "the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01186-00319022-00319219": "Pentagon", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01187-00319220-00319439": "disclosed the lives of the U.S", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01188-00319440-00319625": "government in the beginning of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01189-00319626-00319967": "Vietnam War and gave all the information", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01190-00319968-00320243": "to the New York Times and they published", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01191-00320244-00320489": "the so-called Pentagon papers and the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01192-00320490-00320675": "president of the United States Richard", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01193-00320676-00321041": "Nixon was very angry and he said this", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01194-00321042-00321293": "will undermine the National Security of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01195-00321294-00321484": "the United States because United States", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01196-00321485-00321749": "was in a war and he called the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01197-00321750-00321923": "editor-in-chief of the New York Times", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01198-00321924-00322127": "and said you have to stop this you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01199-00322128-00322379": "cannot publish this this is undermined", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01200-00322380-00322510": "the National Security of the United", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01201-00322511-00322865": "States but the New York Times argued we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01202-00322866-00323039": "have the first amendment in the U.S", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01203-00323040-00323273": "Constitution so so we have freedom of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01204-00323274-00323495": "press so I will publish whatever I think", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01205-00323496-00323777": "it's it's important and the case went to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01206-00323778-00323956": "the Supreme Court of the United States", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01207-00323957-00324245": "and they had a landmark decision five to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01208-00324246-00324556": "four very close where the the court", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01209-00324557-00324863": "argued that the uh right of people to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01210-00324864-00325163": "know the truth is more important than", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01211-00325164-00325469": "the interest of a government to hide its", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01212-00325470-00325745": "lives and I think this is an interesting", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01213-00325746-00325960": "case which can be", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01214-00325961-00326387": "you know helpful to start something to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01215-00326388-00326782": "develop for the cyberspace so we need", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01216-00326783-00327215": "independent uh third parties to manage a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01217-00327216-00327473": "Content related conflicts and by the way", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01218-00327474-00327653": "we had", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01219-00327654-00327917": "similar conflicts in the early days of I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01220-00327918-00328234": "can when cyber squatters you know took", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01221-00328235-00328451": "names and then it was complicated how to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01222-00328452-00328654": "handle this between Cyber Law and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01223-00328655-00329021": "trademark law and we introduced the the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01224-00329022-00329225": "so-called Universal dispute resolution", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01225-00329226-00329549": "policy with a distributed system of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01226-00329550-00329879": "so-called uh dispute resolution service", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01227-00329880-00330227": "providers with panels so probably we can", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01228-00330228-00330580": "develop such a decentralized system for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01229-00330581-00330871": "Content related cases not only for cases", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01230-00330872-00331139": "on conflicts around domain names but", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01231-00331140-00331325": "also for Content things this would be", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01232-00331326-00331565": "innovation in policy making this would", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01233-00331566-00331943": "be Innovation judicial system but it's a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01234-00331944-00332182": "long way to go but I hope with the help", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01235-00332183-00332791": "of the igf we can move forward thank you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01236-00332792-00333239": "thank you a lot Emmanuel has also raised", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01237-00333240-00333749": "his hand so Emmanuel please go ahead", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01238-00333750-00334019": "thank you Amelia I think one desirable", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01239-00334020-00334408": "in this discussion around", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01240-00334409-00334732": "what what we need to do to clarify", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01241-00334733-00335075": "Concepts is is the is the need to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01242-00335076-00335387": "separate political and geopolitical", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01243-00335388-00335758": "concerns from the operations of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01244-00335759-00336047": "internet now the the questionnaire the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01245-00336048-00336245": "question I addressed the concern about", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01246-00336246-00336551": "the freedom of speech and the fact that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01247-00336552-00336845": "governments or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01248-00336846-00337103": "Sovereign authorities would always want", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01249-00337104-00337397": "to clarify the terms around how freedom", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01250-00337398-00337553": "of spiritually boundaries around freedom", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01251-00337554-00337810": "of speech which is one desirable but", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01252-00337811-00337973": "then on the other hand is that what", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01253-00337974-00338206": "there is there is no there is no", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01254-00338207-00338651": "boundary to which uh such regulation or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01255-00338652-00338873": "such parameters are set by the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01256-00338874-00339071": "government around how they're going to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01257-00339072-00339395": "uh control free speech and how are they", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01258-00339396-00339658": "going to Define what enters Free Speech", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01259-00339659-00339856": "particularly in light of the fact that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01260-00339857-00340067": "we have seen increasingly seeing", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01261-00340068-00340504": "governments that um you know like like a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01262-00340505-00340745": "Wolfgang was trying to um illustrate", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01263-00340746-00340997": "with that very beautiful quote about uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01264-00340998-00341267": "you know the the the right of citizens", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01265-00341268-00341375": "to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01266-00341376-00341549": "um have a freedom of speech was always", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01267-00341550-00341753": "about take the interests of governments", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01268-00341754-00342010": "to hide their lives and when these two", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01269-00342011-00342299": "divide you know Clash at the center we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01270-00342300-00342503": "begin to see freedom of speaking", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01271-00342504-00342708": "fractions and I have seen the same", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01272-00342709-00343019": "arguments also around the debates about", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01273-00343020-00343337": "the right to education okay so a a a a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01274-00343338-00343553": "communist government would would likely", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01275-00343554-00343780": "not want you know", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01276-00343781-00344008": "students in their country to access to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01277-00344009-00344206": "have access to Western education even", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01278-00344207-00344429": "though there is that right implicitly or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01279-00344430-00344734": "explicitly defined by declarations and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01280-00344735-00344921": "regulations that are widely acceptable", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01281-00344922-00345149": "and probably a soviet-style government", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01282-00345150-00345395": "or a Soviet acting governments may not", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01283-00345396-00345610": "want their citizens to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01284-00345611-00345845": "um you know access Western curriculum or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01285-00345846-00346145": "learn what um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01286-00346146-00346379": "align with Western Educational Systems", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01287-00346380-00346679": "but then at the Crux of this is the fact", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01288-00346680-00346882": "that by the time we begin to bring in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01289-00346883-00347129": "all of this geopolitical and political", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01290-00347130-00347467": "considerations and interests into", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01291-00347468-00347830": "discussions around the operations and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01292-00347831-00347969": "functioning of the internet we often", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01293-00347970-00348167": "relegate the technical consideration", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01294-00348168-00348467": "that Define or should characterize what", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01295-00348468-00348641": "makes the internet the internet in the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01296-00348642-00348808": "first place and this is the challenge we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01297-00348809-00349006": "have had in Nigeria with with government", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01298-00349007-00349241": "and then we see we oftentimes see this", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01299-00349242-00349480": "coming on the backs of well-meaning", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01300-00349481-00349613": "well-intended", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01301-00349614-00349708": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01302-00349709-00349913": "the desires of government to control", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01303-00349914-00350093": "issues around hate speech to control", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01304-00350094-00350297": "issues around pornography and of course", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01305-00350298-00350429": "these are these advices that require", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01306-00350430-00350710": "Society baptisms but then by the time we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01307-00350711-00350969": "separate the technical considerations of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01308-00350970-00351251": "what how how are these uh regulations", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01309-00351252-00351467": "how are these policies going to impact", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01310-00351468-00351703": "the internet in practice in the long run", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01311-00351704-00351971": "politically in terms of digital rights", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01312-00351972-00352127": "in terms of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01313-00352128-00352456": "um the the the economic the the economic", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01314-00352457-00352673": "empowerment of the citizens and the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01315-00352674-00352906": "access to information by the time we do", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01316-00352907-00353080": "not factor in this technical", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01317-00353081-00353284": "considerations into this debate and we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01318-00353285-00353525": "focus so much on the geopolitical and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01319-00353526-00353710": "the political interests that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01320-00353711-00353878": "characterize government discussions", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01321-00353879-00354106": "around these these issues we are likely", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01322-00354107-00354353": "to always end up at this juncture where", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01323-00354354-00354563": "we are contending digital sovereignty", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01324-00354564-00354743": "and display internet and which should go", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01325-00354744-00355219": "for the honor", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01326-00355220-00355571": "uh thank you to all free speakers who", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01327-00355572-00355753": "responded to the question", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01328-00355754-00356087": "and now we would like to give an", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01329-00356088-00356395": "opportunity to online participants to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01330-00356396-00356819": "ask their questions so Pedro if you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01331-00356820-00357137": "could read the question from the chat or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01332-00357138-00357425": "let the person from the chat speak and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01333-00357426-00357610": "ask their question", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01334-00357611-00357887": "perfect we have a few questions on mint", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01335-00357888-00358313": "method that are not identified but I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01336-00358314-00358603": "will start with them and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01337-00358604-00358828": "Gene if you would like to make the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01338-00358829-00359075": "question you post there you posted in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01339-00359076-00359327": "the chat a few minutes ago you can also", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01340-00359328-00359537": "open your make or else I will print it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01341-00359538-00359687": "for you after reading the ones from an", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01342-00359688-00359795": "intermedger", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01343-00359796-00360125": "uh the first one uh there are a few", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01344-00360126-00360377": "general questions here so what do", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01345-00360378-00360653": "speakers think are our best tools to try", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01346-00360654-00360934": "to solve this technology problems so we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01347-00360935-00361091": "can start talking about the same ideas", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01348-00361092-00361301": "when using this Concepts is this", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01349-00361302-00361589": "possible I think it's more about getting", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01350-00361590-00361943": "some precise recommendation what can we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01351-00361944-00362332": "do campaigns uh making for example in an", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01352-00362333-00362477": "igf", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01353-00362478-00362753": "uh guidelines something like that I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01354-00362754-00363058": "think a bit more concrete", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01355-00363059-00363401": "um what to do to solve the semantic of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01356-00363402-00363587": "hearing", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01357-00363588-00363695": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01358-00363696-00363947": "the second question", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01359-00363948-00364141": "would be", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01360-00364142-00364378": "focusing on technical fragmentation", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01361-00364379-00364853": "alone is incomplete in my opinion uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01362-00364854-00365134": "so what does interoperability facilitate", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01363-00365135-00365477": "if Government governments can use the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01364-00365478-00365723": "tech layer they use app layer", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01365-00365724-00365958": "fragmentation to the same effects", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01366-00365959-00366197": "Gene would you like to make your", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01367-00366198-00366365": "question will you have a block of three", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01368-00366366-00366527": "questions here then pass on to the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01369-00366528-00366719": "speakers to choose which ones they would", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01370-00366720-00367073": "like to answer oh so Jin said that I can", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01371-00367074-00367510": "read it for him uh he asked him he made", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01372-00367511-00367745": "a comments with a question at the end so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01373-00367746-00367949": "digital sovereignty and the Splinter", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01374-00367950-00368104": "Nets tends to undermine the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01375-00368105-00368423": "model it is certainly a political", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01376-00368424-00368627": "question but it must be said that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01377-00368628-00368897": "depending on the horizons it can also be", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01378-00368898-00369154": "a question of ethics and this can be", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01379-00369155-00369389": "seen as differently according to local", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01380-00369390-00369503": "cultures", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01381-00369504-00369730": "so how to approach this to any questions", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01382-00369731-00370193": "what are the proposals", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01383-00370194-00370582": "so giving the for back to speakers you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01384-00370583-00370930": "can answer them all we can answer a few", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01385-00370931-00371195": "of them you can also choose not to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01386-00371196-00371537": "answer any in this block of questions so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01387-00371538-00371723": "giving a call back to you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01388-00371724-00371969": "all right thank you very much Pedro I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01389-00371970-00372149": "think uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01390-00372150-00372413": "I'll take the first question because", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01391-00372414-00372743": "it's just a clear one just but before I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01392-00372744-00373078": "answer that question uh just to clarify", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01393-00373079-00373373": "a bit on the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01394-00373374-00373667": "on the differences yeah one thing I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01395-00373668-00373882": "would like to say is that it is not a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01396-00373883-00374171": "time for us to declare a state of split", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01397-00374172-00374513": "internet yeah but um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01398-00374514-00374734": "we should rather fear that the the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01399-00374735-00375108": "series of actions by different actors", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01400-00375109-00375449": "can actually lead to the Spree internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01401-00375450-00375743": "so I think that is what we should focus", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01402-00375744-00375977": "so much on right now because I wouldn't", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01403-00375978-00376301": "I wouldn't uh I think it is not yet time", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01404-00376302-00376547": "to to say we already we already in a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01405-00376548-00376763": "state of split internet okay back to the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01406-00376764-00377141": "question uh so um uh one of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01407-00377142-00377393": "participants has asked what tools they", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01408-00377394-00377687": "can use to understand about the two", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01409-00377688-00377951": "concepts so I should say this is the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01410-00377952-00378203": "first platform I mean the fact that we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01411-00378204-00378437": "are able to organize", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01412-00378438-00378695": "um such a session where we are having", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01413-00378696-00378869": "speakers with different perspectives", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01414-00378870-00379247": "yeah uh arguing or disagreeing but of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01415-00379248-00379397": "course at the end of the day we are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01416-00379398-00379558": "going to be able to understand each", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01417-00379559-00379763": "other everyone's perspectives and be", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01418-00379764-00380021": "able to take home something new that we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01419-00380022-00380237": "never knew I think that is a good", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01420-00380238-00380447": "starting point but also", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01421-00380448-00380699": "um taking passion uh personal initiative", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01422-00380700-00380908": "like for example", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01423-00380909-00381203": "I should say there are so many articles", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01424-00381204-00381580": "that have been written by different uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01425-00381581-00381821": "stakeholders about split internet and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01426-00381822-00382078": "also about digital digital sovereignty", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01427-00382079-00382378": "so uh whereas the arguments might really", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01428-00382379-00382739": "be confusing from one side to another I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01429-00382740-00382906": "think it's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01430-00382907-00383182": "it's a start of everything yeah and I'm", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01431-00383183-00383399": "very sure at one point we shall be able", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01432-00383400-00383584": "to reach an argument that this is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01433-00383585-00383758": "actually this and that is that yeah", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01434-00383759-00384137": "thank you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01435-00384138-00384419": "if I may add to the first question as", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01436-00384420-00384695": "well there is a policy Network on", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01437-00384696-00384917": "internet fragmentation launched last", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01438-00384918-00385156": "year and they have a mandate for two", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01439-00385157-00385451": "years and coordinated by Bruno and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01440-00385452-00385739": "shital and they presented the policy", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01441-00385740-00385882": "Network yesterday", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01442-00385883-00386195": "and here also like Wolfgang is one of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01443-00386196-00386393": "the members of this policy Network and I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01444-00386394-00386693": "believe Milton as well and they are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01445-00386694-00386837": "exactly", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01446-00386838-00387151": "um debating the terminology and the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01447-00387152-00387497": "definitions used for this topic and they", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01448-00387498-00387671": "are doing their best to clarify it for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01449-00387672-00388006": "us as much as possible and if you want", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01450-00388007-00388223": "to join them in this effort you can", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01451-00388224-00388487": "always join the policy Network as it's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01452-00388488-00388780": "open and you could find it just on the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01453-00388781-00389560": "igf website thank you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01454-00389561-00389795": "okay thank you a lot in attention", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01455-00389796-00390210": "Katarina for responding the questions", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01456-00390211-00390443": "we have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01457-00390444-00390743": "something like 10 more minutes for the Q", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01458-00390744-00391217": "a part and I just think that maybe we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01459-00391218-00391463": "will connect speakers responses to each", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01460-00391464-00391715": "other with their closing remarks and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01461-00391716-00391937": "thanks to that we will have time for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01462-00391938-00392387": "some more on-site questions so uh are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01463-00392388-00392723": "there any okay I see one here", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01464-00392724-00393010": "and here's okay we will take two so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01465-00393011-00393256": "maybe yeah you can start and then we'll", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01466-00393257-00393503": "also listen to your question", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01467-00393504-00393832": "hi everybody my name is sunit um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01468-00393833-00394078": "uh I work for the Tony Blair Institute", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01469-00394079-00394499": "so my question is I think the first", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01470-00394500-00394667": "governments are not homogeneous entities", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01471-00394668-00394849": "and even within National governments", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01472-00394850-00395225": "you'll have differences of opinion about", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01473-00395226-00395447": "um what regulation or policy should look", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01474-00395448-00395656": "like so maybe the ministry of the ICT", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01475-00395657-00395860": "will feel differently from the ministry", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01476-00395861-00396113": "of Defense I think part of the challenge", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01477-00396114-00396406": "also is that governments like all actors", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01478-00396407-00396623": "are not necessarily holy bad or wholly", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01479-00396624-00396754": "good", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01480-00396755-00396965": "um and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01481-00396966-00397295": "because of the technical complexity and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01482-00397296-00397547": "the speed and I guess the the potential", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01483-00397548-00397823": "harm I think sometimes governments with", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01484-00397824-00398039": "good intentions are forced into", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01485-00398040-00398213": "utilizing blunt instruments like", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01486-00398214-00398434": "internet shutdowns okay", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01487-00398435-00398602": "um and I think part of that is because", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01488-00398603-00398999": "there isn't an ability or a capacity to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01489-00399000-00399232": "understand well what are the interim", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01490-00399233-00399515": "instruments that I can use so I can", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01491-00399516-00399743": "address the situation of harm without", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01492-00399744-00400001": "potentially causing greater harm or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01493-00400002-00400228": "undermining human rights which I think", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01494-00400229-00400463": "we all agree is important so my question", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01495-00400464-00400565": "is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01496-00400566-00400895": "um to however is happy to to to take it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01497-00400896-00401278": "is if if I if there is significant harm", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01498-00401279-00401560": "I don't want to shut down the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01499-00401561-00402017": "um what can I do to to respond to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01500-00402018-00402317": "challenges in a way that is respectful", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01501-00402318-00402569": "or fair and what should be the what", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01502-00402570-00402682": "should be the starting position for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01503-00402683-00402815": "governments in terms of understanding", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01504-00402816-00403265": "the trade-offs", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01505-00403266-00403558": "thank you I'll try to be as concerned as", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01506-00403559-00403877": "possible but I have some Reflections and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01507-00403878-00404147": "a quick question so adding to what", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01508-00404148-00404393": "Emmanuel said about the genuine interest", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01509-00404394-00404704": "is of States I would add about Mobility", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01510-00404705-00404987": "Healthcare and educational Platforms in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01511-00404988-00405095": "Brazil in the Brazilian internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01512-00405096-00405358": "steering committee we are working in the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01513-00405359-00405558": "concept of scientific autonomy", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01514-00405559-00405815": "together with digital sovereignty so I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01515-00405816-00406019": "would be glad to share this afterwards", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01516-00406020-00406373": "I'll also contribute considering other", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01517-00406374-00406619": "approaches to sovereignty such as food", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01518-00406620-00407008": "sovereignty that we bring not only the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01519-00407009-00407177": "power to the States but our to the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01520-00407178-00407369": "people like recently in Brazil the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01521-00407370-00407710": "homelands of the movement of homeless", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01522-00407711-00407969": "workers has just declared what is their", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01523-00407970-00408130": "perspective about digital Sovereign for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01524-00408131-00408497": "instance so maybe it's a good time to to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01525-00408498-00408641": "bring to the table who really should", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01526-00408642-00408851": "Define what development is in the 21st", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01527-00408852-00409175": "century and also the the title of this", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01528-00409176-00409456": "igf is resilient internet for a shared", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01529-00409457-00409666": "sustainable and common future so I'd", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01530-00409667-00409822": "like to highlight that uh for instance", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01531-00409823-00410045": "devising bow Institute in Germany it's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01532-00410046-00410195": "working with the concept of sustainable", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01533-00410196-00410482": "digital future that besides meaning for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01534-00410483-00410722": "waxes it's also taking consideration the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01535-00410723-00410860": "carbon footprint of internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01536-00410862-00411178": "communications infrastructure uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01537-00411179-00411395": "Professor Newton said that markets are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01538-00411396-00411634": "transnational but we should warn just", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01539-00411635-00411893": "last week the US has been 10 Chinese", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01540-00411893-00412120": "companies to operate in in the in the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01541-00412121-00412295": "territory", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01542-00412296-00412570": "um and finally you should bear in mind", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01543-00412571-00412774": "that this assortment is way broader than", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01544-00412775-00412907": "internet fragmentation which is the name", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01545-00412908-00413093": "of the policy Network the grief", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01546-00413093-00413237": "Professor Wolfgang that it's about", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01547-00413238-00413351": "making change in the lower level", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01548-00413352-00413597": "protocols and going to the question", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01549-00413597-00413914": "maybe to innocent and Justina", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01550-00413916-00414322": "uh the fact that the most powerful uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01551-00414323-00414691": "Tech U.S based companies are jumping", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01552-00414692-00414959": "down in the lower levels of the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01553-00414960-00415372": "owning like Fiber Optic Cables uh is it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01554-00415373-00415882": "a menace to net fragmentation thank you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01555-00415883-00416122": "and maybe we will take just one more", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01556-00416123-00416332": "question to just group them in the blog", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01557-00416333-00416951": "so also", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01558-00416952-00417178": "okay good morning thank you no as I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01559-00417179-00417370": "wanted to address that the the concept", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01560-00417371-00417563": "of sovereign Aid this is is a concept", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01561-00417564-00417839": "that was worn in Wolf and surely known", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01562-00417839-00418084": "better than I mean but around Century 16", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01563-00418085-00418468": "or something like that and it was uh the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01564-00418469-00418674": "the reason the objective", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01565-00418675-00419014": "the the the objective was to to ensure", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01566-00419016-00419170": "the the authority to protect the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01567-00419171-00419405": "authority of the states over at the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01568-00419406-00419770": "reader uh later much later it became uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01569-00419771-00420047": "I became an uh a forum to protect the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01570-00420047-00420310": "rights of the citizens but originally it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01571-00420312-00420475": "was to protect the authority the power", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01572-00420476-00420839": "and and even if it has been used as", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01573-00420839-00421097": "everybody knows as exactly with the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01574-00421097-00421231": "opposite", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01575-00421232-00421601": "interest sometimes but so in this uh in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01576-00421602-00421703": "this new", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01577-00421704-00421937": "um these are the part from the premises", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01578-00421938-00422214": "all premises that that the the the the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01579-00422215-00422410": "governments were the only", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01580-00422412-00422585": "representatives of the interest of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01581-00422585-00422825": "people but this in this war as a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01582-00422826-00423083": "describable World fund that's it have a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01583-00423084-00423472": "193 States but one network the the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01584-00423473-00423731": "rights of the of of the people not", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01585-00423732-00424013": "necessarily uh are represented or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01586-00424014-00424229": "defended by the by the governments so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01587-00424230-00424457": "the the rights of the of the people that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01588-00424458-00424751": "this quote really matters could be uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01589-00424752-00425045": "opposite opposite to the to the concept", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01590-00425046-00425237": "of sovereignty and this is something", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01591-00425238-00425441": "that the government should understand", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01592-00425442-00425639": "and this is the basis of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01593-00425639-00425770": "multi-stakeholder model that is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01594-00425771-00425927": "something that everybody here Embrace", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01595-00425928-00426275": "and the my last comment is that with", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01596-00426276-00426497": "regard to fragmentation I think that it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01597-00426497-00426670": "doesn't matter really the definition of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01598-00426671-00426851": "fermentation what is fermentation or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01599-00426852-00427097": "what is not and and the proof is that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01600-00427097-00427355": "the world fundamental disagree and on", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01601-00427356-00427613": "one specific thing if the shout down the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01602-00427614-00427853": "shutdowns are or not fermentation but", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01603-00427854-00428020": "both of both of them agree that this is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01604-00428021-00428272": "something bad so I think that we should", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01605-00428273-00428447": "concentrate our efforts in discussing", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01606-00428447-00428722": "what is right and what is and rather", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01607-00428723-00428914": "than the the concrete definitions thank", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01608-00428915-00429095": "you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01609-00429096-00429418": "thank you a lot so any of the speakers", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01610-00429419-00429791": "who would like to respond", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01611-00429792-00430037": "yes", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01612-00430038-00430216": "may I take", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01613-00430217-00430409": "the first question", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01614-00430410-00430583": "Okay so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01615-00430584-00430822": "yeah the first question was pertaining", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01616-00430823-00430968": "to how do", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01617-00430969-00431170": "well-attending governments or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01618-00431171-00431314": "governments who have good intentions how", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01619-00431315-00431435": "do they go about", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01620-00431435-00431681": "um scrutinizing the the regulatory", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01621-00431682-00432035": "policy proposals you know so that some", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01622-00432035-00432191": "of these um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01623-00432192-00432647": "uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01624-00432647-00432827": "uh I would I would like to introduce to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01625-00432828-00432964": "the floor", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01626-00432965-00433187": "um it took it provided recently", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01627-00433188-00433379": "developed by the internet Society the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01628-00433380-00433672": "internet impact assessment took it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01629-00433673-00433907": "um this took it you know basically", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01630-00433908-00434081": "provides a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01631-00434082-00434320": "a checklist of five for desirables five", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01632-00434321-00434603": "principles that have ensured that the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01633-00434604-00434783": "internet has continued to grow and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01634-00434784-00435053": "develop sustainably over the years and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01635-00435054-00435370": "with these uh toolkit governments are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01636-00435371-00435485": "able to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01637-00435485-00435755": "access the regulatory proposals you know", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01638-00435756-00436007": "in a very fast and very effective manner", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01639-00436008-00436168": "you know focusing on the technical", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01640-00436169-00436379": "considerations this toolkit has also", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01641-00436380-00436595": "been expanded to include", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01642-00436596-00436727": "um what we've called the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01643-00436728-00436931": "enablers or the enablers of an open", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01644-00436932-00437255": "internet which um focus on the more", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01645-00437256-00437551": "non-technical aspects of Internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01646-00437552-00437770": "functionality and internet development", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01647-00437771-00438005": "issues like the social cultural issues", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01648-00438006-00438287": "the the balance of participation you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01649-00438288-00438479": "know among players in the in the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01650-00438480-00438616": "internet industry and the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01651-00438617-00438791": "ecosystem and issues around digital", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01652-00438792-00438970": "rights and accountability and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01653-00438971-00439222": "transparency so all of these um I think", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01654-00439223-00439463": "this is one toolkit that is available to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01655-00439464-00439655": "governments um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01656-00439656-00439835": "almost immediately or I would say", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01657-00439835-00440075": "immediately to be able to access uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01658-00440076-00440231": "their regulatory intention to their", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01659-00440232-00440441": "policy intentions internally and we have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01660-00440442-00440543": "worked at the dear government", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01661-00440543-00440831": "organization with governments in Nigeria", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01662-00440832-00441118": "and um across West African countries", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01663-00441119-00441322": "recently we are we are beginning a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01664-00441323-00441455": "project with the standing group where", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01665-00441456-00441616": "we'll be covering West African countries", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01666-00441617-00441863": "in this regard and I think and this one", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01667-00441864-00442103": "toolkit that um you know you would find", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01668-00442104-00442301": "very useful you know if you're working", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01669-00442302-00442564": "in a governmental framework and then you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01670-00442565-00442799": "you are faced with these regulatory", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01671-00442800-00443051": "proposals that you think could undermine", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01672-00443052-00443291": "the progress and development of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01673-00443292-00443477": "internet and I think you know part of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01674-00443478-00443675": "this also answers the first question", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01675-00443676-00443903": "which um Pedro put on the slide earlier", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01676-00443904-00444131": "Latino Cent responded to you know these", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01677-00444132-00444539": "two kids also provides um very useful", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01678-00444539-00444695": "definitions", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01679-00444696-00444875": "um and very useful clarifications around", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01680-00444876-00445151": "what are some of the desirables that we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01681-00445152-00445343": "want to see in an Internet that is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01682-00445343-00445595": "inclusive and open and interconnected", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01683-00445596-00445883": "and free from jurisdiction are not", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01684-00445884-00446051": "Shackled by Jewish dictionary barriers", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01685-00446052-00446303": "and I also want to recommend to the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01686-00446304-00446585": "policy committee that Emilia talked", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01687-00446585-00446818": "about earlier a white paper that the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01688-00446819-00447101": "internet Society recently drafted on", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01689-00447102-00447353": "digital sovereignty very very insightful", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01690-00447354-00447539": "very informative white paper I think", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01691-00447539-00447760": "that committee would find it useful as", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01692-00447762-00448114": "well that is with regards to the first", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01693-00448115-00448537": "question thank you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01694-00448538-00448853": "uh thank you very much Emma I just a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01695-00448854-00449218": "quick answer to him uh okay the the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01696-00449219-00449459": "question of the tech chance I think it's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01697-00449460-00449825": "not um whether or not but I think it it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01698-00449826-00450149": "should be because I uh as I said I tried", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01699-00450150-00450353": "to rectify that uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01700-00450354-00450743": "the actions the series of actions that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01701-00450743-00451072": "the different actors uh tend to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01702-00451073-00451270": "implement are the ones that could lead", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01703-00451271-00451468": "to the spleen internet so I think it's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01704-00451469-00451733": "not a question of whether or not but a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01705-00451734-00452081": "question of what of those actions by", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01706-00452082-00452435": "those Tech Giants and how they could", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01707-00452435-00452872": "lead to as free internet yeah thank you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01708-00452873-00453185": "yeah yeah sure I'd like to address the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01709-00453185-00453275": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01710-00453276-00453509": "the speaker I think from Brazil who", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01711-00453510-00453647": "asked about", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01712-00453647-00453881": "um you know the U.S", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01713-00453882-00454372": "um China Rift uh on on exports", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01714-00454373-00454625": "um he said markets are transnational but", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01715-00454626-00454937": "what's going on with the U.S uh and uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01716-00454938-00455231": "yeah exactly that's the point uh their", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01717-00455232-00455513": "uh Market participants would be happy to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01718-00455514-00455843": "sell chips to China China would be happy", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01719-00455843-00455951": "to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01720-00455952-00456010": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01721-00456012-00456370": "sell huawei's equipment to the US but", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01722-00456371-00456568": "the interventions here are political", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01723-00456569-00456857": "they are based allegedly on National", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01724-00456858-00457109": "Security concerns uh really on sort of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01725-00457110-00457463": "geopolitical competition and this is the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01726-00457464-00457775": "reason why I emphasize this disjunction", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01727-00457776-00457897": "between", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01728-00457897-00458203": "states and the globally integrated", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01729-00458204-00458585": "digital ecosystem I think that's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01730-00458585-00458837": "that's really the the the fundamental", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01731-00458838-00459047": "thing that we're talking about I would", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01732-00459047-00459239": "also like to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01733-00459239-00459737": "uh agree with um Raul and and another", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01734-00459738-00459970": "speaker who said that you know we we do", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01735-00459971-00460139": "need to be talking more about what to do", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01736-00460139-00460325": "about these things I think it was", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01737-00460326-00460613": "Katarina uh rather than uh definitional", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01738-00460614-00460847": "questions uh definitions are important", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01739-00460847-00461063": "to to you know make sure that we're", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01740-00461064-00461231": "talking about the same thing and it's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01741-00461232-00461399": "good to have these discussions and there", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01742-00461400-00461651": "have been many of them but I think that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01743-00461652-00461885": "the the the key question is really what", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01744-00461885-00462418": "what do you do and uh I agree with uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01745-00462419-00462605": "Wolfgang and generally the people in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01746-00462606-00462863": "this environment have talked about the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01747-00462864-00463057": "formation of new international", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01748-00463058-00463360": "institutions that can take over some of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01749-00463362-00463618": "the governance problems that are posed", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01750-00463619-00463979": "by This Global digital ecosystem so uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01751-00463980-00464141": "whether it's the dispute resolution", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01752-00464142-00464435": "system for trademarks and domain names", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01753-00464435-00464693": "that I can set up or the policy making", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01754-00464693-00464981": "apparatus of the regional internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01755-00464982-00465233": "registries or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01756-00465234-00465575": "even something like the global internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01757-00465576-00465827": "forum for counterterrorism where you're", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01758-00465828-00466151": "dealing with content moderation on a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01759-00466152-00466343": "transnational basis of the Christ Church", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01760-00466343-00466489": "call", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01761-00466489-00466733": "those kinds of new institutional", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01762-00466734-00466997": "Frameworks are are the direction that we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01763-00466997-00467225": "could go and of course that is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01764-00467226-00467477": "controversial and difficult and again", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01765-00467478-00467764": "the countries that emphasize sovereignty", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01766-00467765-00468083": "will resist those initiatives because it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01767-00468084-00468472": "will be a a surrender of their", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01768-00468473-00468820": "exclusivity of power in favor of a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01769-00468821-00469164": "global institution so you can expect", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01770-00469165-00469439": "that to be a contentious issue but I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01771-00469439-00469685": "think some of these issues not every", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01772-00469685-00469853": "issue some issues can be solved", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01773-00469854-00470051": "domestically but many of these issues", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01774-00470052-00470172": "need to be", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01775-00470173-00470855": "pushing towards institutional innovation", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01776-00470856-00470970": "foreign", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01777-00470971-00471275": "I want to take the question from the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01778-00471276-00471575": "Tony Blair Institute and the unintended", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01779-00471576-00471772": "side effect from governmental regulation", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01780-00471773-00472349": "so I you know prefer to use uh smart", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01781-00472350-00472655": "regulation because you know 20 years ago", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01782-00472656-00472883": "regulations was seen as a barrier", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01783-00472884-00473207": "against Innovation and it would", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01784-00473208-00473470": "strangulate you know sinking out of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01785-00473471-00473716": "box but today we have realized we need", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01786-00473717-00473981": "regulation so in a certainly but what", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01787-00473982-00474245": "kind of Regulation and then so far you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01788-00474246-00474503": "know smart regulation which exactly", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01789-00474504-00474845": "defines what it wants to achieve is very", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01790-00474846-00475181": "important and you can find it out within", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01791-00475182-00475349": "a government with different Ministries", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01792-00475350-00475583": "and you have it's the same in every", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01793-00475584-00475843": "country that Foreign Affairs defense", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01794-00475843-00476189": "interior uh Health Ministry have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01795-00476189-00476549": "different ideas the only way to settle", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01796-00476550-00476825": "this problem and to avoid unintended", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01797-00476826-00477072": "side effects is to have a broad", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01798-00477073-00477287": "multi-stakeholder discussion before you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01799-00477288-00477539": "act so that means that you bring all", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01800-00477539-00477809": "perspectives on board a good example is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01801-00477810-00478037": "to list two directly from the European", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01802-00478038-00478277": "Union it was very understandable that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01803-00478278-00478505": "the EU said we have to enhance cyber", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01804-00478506-00478829": "security but then say went too far by", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01805-00478830-00479153": "including the root server for the DNS", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01806-00479154-00479501": "into the proposed legislation so this", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01807-00479502-00479777": "would have undermined the security of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01808-00479778-00479993": "the domain name system because this is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01809-00479993-00480322": "managed by can and in so far it was very", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01810-00480323-00480653": "wise that after consultation with icann", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01811-00480654-00480893": "uh you know this was taken out of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01812-00480893-00481120": "Institute directive so that the root", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01813-00481121-00481270": "server is managed by the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01814-00481271-00481529": "multi-stakeholder community and by I", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01815-00481530-00481697": "Cannon if governments have a problem", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01816-00481697-00481943": "with that they can use the governmental", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01817-00481943-00482260": "advisory committee and to give advice to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01818-00482262-00482483": "the eigen board how to enhance security", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01819-00482484-00482770": "of the root service system but this is a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01820-00482771-00483077": "distributed system and in so far at the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01821-00483078-00483316": "recommendation to governments is be very", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01822-00483317-00483701": "careful consult not only but bring all", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01823-00483702-00483893": "the relevant stakeholders to the table", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01824-00483893-00484193": "be aware about unintended side effects", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01825-00484193-00484559": "and act only where there is a need", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01826-00484560-00484805": "and not just to create big boxes where", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01827-00484806-00485003": "you put all the problems mine and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01828-00485004-00485291": "regulate in a top-down way this is not", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01829-00485292-00485716": "uh the tradition is good but we are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01830-00485717-00485951": "moving towards the future and need new", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01831-00485952-00486455": "innovation mechanisms", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01832-00486456-00486910": "uh thank you a lot uh two people also", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01833-00486912-00487277": "raise their hands in the zoom room so", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01834-00487278-00487618": "firstly I would like to let them also", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01835-00487619-00487931": "have their remarks so uh the first one", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01836-00487932-00488122": "would be Jorge", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01837-00488123-00488416": "ancio sorry if I pronouncing it did it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01838-00488417-00488533": "wrong", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01839-00488534-00488891": "only for 30 seconds so please be very", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01840-00488892-00489179": "brief", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01841-00489180-00489443": "yeah thank you very much for giving me", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01842-00489443-00489797": "the flow uh I think what gets lost a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01843-00489797-00489959": "little bit in the discussion is that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01844-00489960-00490325": "when there is an absence of rules and an", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01845-00490326-00490681": "absence of governance mechanisms what", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01846-00490682-00491170": "occurs is that power or might Trump's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01847-00491171-00491566": "rules and small countries or small", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01848-00491567-00491825": "societies are not in a position of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01849-00491826-00492214": "dictating rules like big Corporation or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01850-00492215-00492563": "like big economic countries or big", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01851-00492564-00493013": "economic players so uh what I think is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01852-00493014-00493489": "that the slippers and the fragmentation", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01853-00493489-00493847": "are a consequence to a large extent of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01854-00493847-00494268": "those big players imposing their will", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01855-00494269-00494681": "Without Really basing their decisions on", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01856-00494682-00495005": "an open and inclusive multicycle process", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01857-00495006-00495341": "at the global level and there's where we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01858-00495342-00495737": "have to to work to build stronger Global", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01859-00495738-00496060": "inclusive institutions that really set", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01860-00496062-00496313": "the rules for the future of digital", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01861-00496314-00496564": "cooperation so that's my calling thank", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01862-00496565-00496745": "you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01863-00496746-00496930": "thank you a lot Jorge", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01864-00496931-00497993": "[Music]", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01865-00497993-00498155": "thank you very much", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01866-00498156-00498335": "um yeah I would like to make two points", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01867-00498335-00498670": "uh one that we should make it impossible", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01868-00498671-00498881": "for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01869-00498882-00499105": "um some under", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01870-00499106-00499391": "Democratic State actors to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01871-00499392-00499666": "um to touch the infrastructure of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01872-00499667-00499751": "internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01873-00499752-00499991": "so we should all work together as", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01874-00499992-00500255": "Technical Community as private sector to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01875-00500256-00500668": "make it impossible to block shutdown or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01876-00500669-00501010": "whatever to make it impossible for users", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01877-00501012-00501370": "to use the internet in a more uh in the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01878-00501371-00501568": "way they would like to use it", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01879-00501569-00501905": "second content wise", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01880-00501906-00501970": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01881-00501971-00502295": "that's a difficult topic and I also", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01882-00502296-00502613": "heard the remark from Wolfgang maybe we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01883-00502614-00502714": "should", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01884-00502715-00503147": "mother Ray that in some way but that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01885-00503147-00503363": "would be to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01886-00503364-00503518": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01887-00503519-00503833": "um National governments for instance or", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01888-00503834-00504149": "private sector to make", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01889-00504150-00504431": "um make the content", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01890-00504432-00504629": "um that's online", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01891-00504630-00504875": "that that it doesn't", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01892-00504876-00505043": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01893-00505043-00505337": "conflict with the laws they have in the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01894-00505338-00505601": "certain country", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01895-00505602-00505889": "um third we should make possible that's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01896-00505889-00506237": "more democratic ways are in place for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01897-00506238-00506687": "those kinds of content moderation thanks", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01898-00506688-00507029": "uh thank you a lot we have ran a bit out", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01899-00507030-00507220": "of time we are very sorry for that but", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01900-00507221-00507449": "we had to start it earlier because of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01901-00507450-00507655": "some previous meetings July", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01902-00507656-00507983": "so if you could stay with us five four", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01903-00507984-00508210": "minutes speakers would make their", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01904-00508212-00508522": "closing remarks just very brief ones", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01905-00508523-00508835": "like 30 seconds one minute please and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01906-00508835-00509110": "also if you're quite if we didn't have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01907-00509112-00509297": "opportunity to listen to your question", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01908-00509297-00509579": "uh Pedro has shared the link to the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01909-00509580-00509795": "Google Document in the chat in the zoom", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01910-00509796-00510029": "room we'll also put it down in the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01911-00510030-00510341": "session report in which you can put all", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01912-00510342-00510647": "your questions and we will pass them to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01913-00510647-00510995": "speakers so they can also if they would", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01914-00510996-00511181": "like to they can also respond to them", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01915-00511182-00511529": "respond to them so in this way we would", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01916-00511530-00511781": "like to hear all of your comments and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01917-00511782-00511955": "questions because you know this format", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01918-00511956-00512268": "is very short so it looks like it look", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01919-00512269-00512651": "so starting maybe in the same order as", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01920-00512652-00512981": "previously innocent the floor is yours", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01921-00512982-00513155": "for your closing framework yeah sure", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01922-00513156-00513514": "thank you Emilia so I think we've", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01923-00513515-00513749": "discussed a lot but I think my take home", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01924-00513750-00514103": "is um how do we go beyond coming to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01925-00514104-00514301": "discuss or to understand what the spleen", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01926-00514302-00514709": "internet is to uh under okay the both", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01927-00514710-00514955": "Concepts actually we all have different", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01928-00514956-00515333": "perspectives and it's some are differing", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01929-00515334-00515722": "to the others but how do we find a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01930-00515723-00515933": "common ground to understand the two", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01931-00515934-00516227": "concepts then how do we work as", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01932-00516228-00516575": "stakeholders to find solutions to the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01933-00516576-00517301": "issues at hand thank you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01934-00517302-00517564": "yeah I think as with every other type of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01935-00517565-00517795": "relationship communication is important", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01936-00517796-00518020": "we need more communication between", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01937-00518021-00518201": "government and other stakeholders in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01938-00518202-00518399": "issues around digital sovereignty and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01939-00518400-00518597": "display internet you know because we are", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01940-00518597-00518897": "we have seen that between intention and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01941-00518897-00519089": "outcome that we see when it comes to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01942-00519089-00519341": "regulatory matters around digital", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01943-00519342-00519509": "sovereignty and display internet you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01944-00519510-00519712": "know along this Continuum there is a lot", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01945-00519713-00519929": "of love that is often lost and then", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01946-00519930-00520133": "intent by the time we begin to reconcile", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01947-00520134-00520372": "outcome with intent we we begin to see", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01948-00520373-00520559": "that the consequences are even more", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01949-00520560-00520757": "far-reaching than any of the individual", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01950-00520758-00520949": "stakeholders would have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01951-00520950-00521207": "um pre-imagined before such outcome", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01952-00521208-00521357": "manifestation so I think this", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01953-00521358-00521572": "necessitates more engagement and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01954-00521573-00521722": "um like Wolfgang suggested the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01955-00521723-00521879": "multi-stakeholder model", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01956-00521880-00522101": "um offers an approach a useful approach", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01957-00522102-00522245": "for that thank you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01958-00522246-00522691": "foreign", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01959-00522692-00523127": "yes keep the critical internet resources", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01960-00523128-00523462": "which constitute the basic layer of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01961-00523463-00523697": "internet as neutral as possible and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01962-00523697-00523925": "learn from climate change there is no", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01963-00523926-00524279": "American Air there is no Chinese air", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01964-00524280-00524662": "there is polluted air or clean air and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01965-00524663-00524939": "keep the internet clean there is no", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01966-00524940-00525239": "Chinese protocols or American protocols", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01967-00525240-00525666": "so keep it as clean as possible and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01968-00525667-00526020": "reject all efforts to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01969-00526021-00526241": "Splendor the ground layer of the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01970-00526242-00526462": "internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01971-00526463-00526805": "thank you Steve", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01972-00526806-00526985": "thank you so much for these discussions", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01973-00526986-00527195": "and for inviting me we've taken a very", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01974-00527196-00527437": "good note of course", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01975-00527438-00527662": "this is an ongoing", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01976-00527663-00527761": "um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01977-00527762-00527993": "reflection and a critical issue for the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01978-00527994-00528287": "commission and this this igf uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01979-00528288-00528455": "conversations are extremely useful for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01980-00528456-00528922": "us we just like to conclude with um", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01981-00528923-00529193": "a thought which is actually increasingly", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01982-00529194-00529339": "backed by", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01983-00529340-00529739": "empirical studies but I think it's in", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01984-00529740-00529901": "underlying this discussion and it's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01985-00529902-00530087": "underlying our intuition which is that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01986-00530088-00530255": "we're here not discussing about the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01987-00530256-00530470": "internet as such Because The Internet Is", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01988-00530471-00530764": "So embedded into the everyday life of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01989-00530765-00531029": "citizens and politics that we are really", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01990-00531030-00531262": "discussing about this and what we see we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01991-00531263-00531509": "suspect that again it's it's on the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01992-00531510-00531803": "table uh recently by some geopolitical", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01993-00531804-00532114": "studies is that the more fragmented the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01994-00532115-00532361": "internet is the different the more", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01995-00532362-00532541": "different the experience of the internet", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01996-00532542-00532835": "user is so the different content that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01997-00532836-00533122": "they encounter the more exacerbated", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01998-00533123-00533389": "become the geopolitical differences", "TIXu5IxNb3c-01999-00533390-00533764": "so a splintered internet is a splintered", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02000-00533765-00533941": "world", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02001-00533942-00534318": "two internets or two worlds two", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02002-00534319-00534749": "protocols in Africa or to Africans to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02003-00534750-00535007": "protocols in Europe or two europes", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02004-00535008-00535211": "very important that we solve this", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02005-00535212-00535427": "problem that we find consensus I think", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02006-00535428-00535637": "that human rights is really", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02007-00535638-00535859": "a very important tool that we've been", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02008-00535860-00536159": "using in many instances and we should we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02009-00536160-00536327": "should keep exploring the connection of", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02010-00536328-00536470": "human rights with the internet as much", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02011-00536471-00536795": "as possible thank you so much", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02012-00536796-00537131": "thank you Katarina", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02013-00537132-00537401": "I would like to thanks uh to think once", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02014-00537402-00537587": "again to all the participants for this", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02015-00537588-00537881": "debate and indeed we've seen that again", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02016-00537882-00538103": "it's such a complicated issue and it's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02017-00538104-00538301": "becoming even more and more complex and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02018-00538302-00538559": "it's crippling from application layer to", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02019-00538560-00538733": "the technological layer to the transport", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02020-00538734-00539147": "layer and while we are all affected by", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02021-00539148-00539416": "this issue the debate is becoming even", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02022-00539417-00539699": "even more relevant these days and we", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02023-00539700-00539957": "need to find the common ground on which", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02024-00539958-00540185": "we stand and to start finding common", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02025-00540186-00540455": "Solutions at least the direction for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02026-00540456-00540793": "that Solutions and Innovative", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02027-00540794-00540949": "institutions", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02028-00540950-00541211": "multi-stakeholder approach Can Shed a", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02029-00541212-00541487": "light on that thank you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02030-00541488-00541972": "thank you and mail them", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02031-00541973-00542225": "yes I'm just going to be uh you know", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02032-00542226-00542459": "basically ceremonial here and say that", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02033-00542460-00542711": "I'm impressed with this um organization", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02034-00542712-00542999": "of this panel by by the youth group I'm", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02035-00543000-00543257": "very happy you invited me uh we have", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02036-00543258-00543533": "been working on these kinds of issues uh", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02037-00543534-00543833": "at the internet governance project for", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02038-00543834-00544018": "um almost 20 years now", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02039-00544019-00544325": "and uh I would invite you to check out", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02040-00544326-00544666": "our site and stay in touch we regularly", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02041-00544667-00545062": "blog on issues related to what we call", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02042-00545063-00545285": "the digital political economy and the", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02043-00545286-00545651": "growing uh digital Cold War which some", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02044-00545652-00545851": "of you might call a splinter net", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02045-00545852-00546299": "uh so uh stay informed and stay", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02046-00546300-00546587": "mobilized uh in these Global", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02047-00546588-00547037": "environments thank you", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02048-00547038-00547259": "everyone thank you one more time to all", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02049-00547260-00547937": "our speakers and to our audience", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02050-00547938-00548153": "thanks everyone have a nice lunch and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02051-00548154-00548375": "good morning for those that like me and", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02052-00548376-00548531": "Professor Milton are in the America's", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02053-00548532-00548711": "time zones", "TIXu5IxNb3c-02054-00548712-00548996": "see you soon"}}, {"audio_id": "TJ9v0_TqFBQ", "text": {"TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00000-00000180-00000473": "hi I'm Sarah from Lumen and in this", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00001-00000474-00000647": "quick video I'm going to give you a", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00002-00000648-00000844": "walkthrough of what to expect in your", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00003-00000846-00001127": "Lumen one study plans you'll access your", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00004-00001128-00001283": "study plans from your introductory", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00005-00001284-00001535": "statistics course this means you'll need", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00006-00001536-00001787": "to log into your school's website and go", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00007-00001788-00001987": "to the course where you're using lumen1", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00008-00001988-00002189": "depending on your school's learning", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00009-00002190-00002392": "management system and how your", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00010-00002393-00002560": "instructor has your course organized", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00011-00002561-00002723": "your course will look different than", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00012-00002724-00002957": "this but what you'll want to look for", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00013-00002958-00003208": "are the links that start with study plan", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00014-00003209-00003515": "like this one here all study plans will", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00015-00003515-00003731": "be labeled study plan followed by the", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00016-00003732-00003965": "name of the module like this one which", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00017-00003965-00004217": "is data types and organization", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00018-00004218-00004456": "the first time that you access a study", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00019-00004457-00004756": "plan you'll see this background skills", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00020-00004757-00004979": "box which explains the skills you'll", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00021-00004980-00005231": "need to do the work in this study plan", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00022-00005232-00005513": "module if you click check your Readiness", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00023-00005514-00005741": "you can take a quick assessment that", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00024-00005742-00006004": "will help you identify any skills which", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00025-00006005-00006263": "you might need a quick refresher on you", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00026-00006264-00006484": "can click later and still have a chance", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00027-00006486-00006677": "to take the Readiness check at any point", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00028-00006678-00006898": "but we recommend taking it at the", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00029-00006900-00007084": "beginning of your study plan", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00030-00007086-00007367": "because it'll help you understand if you", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00031-00007368-00007606": "need a quick review and also because", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00032-00007608-00007877": "completion of the Readiness check counts", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00033-00007878-00008092": "toward the points you'll earn for this", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00034-00008093-00008285": "study plan let me show you what the", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00035-00008286-00008531": "Readiness check looks like it's a quick", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00036-00008532-00008735": "assessment and you'll answer each", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00037-00008736-00008969": "question and click submit", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00038-00008970-00009155": "you'll be able to see if you're getting", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00039-00009156-00012113": "your answers correct or incorrect", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00040-00012114-00012317": "and when you come to the last question", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00041-00012318-00012563": "you'll click finish", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00042-00012564-00012863": "your results page will list the skills", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00043-00012863-00013108": "that you need to review", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00044-00013109-00013325": "and when you click back to your study", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00045-00013326-00013585": "plan you'll see detailed information", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00046-00013586-00014021": "about which skills you're ready with and", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00047-00014022-00014213": "which skills need review", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00048-00014213-00014471": "click the skill to access a mini lesson", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00049-00014472-00014663": "to help you brush up", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00050-00014663-00014951": "now let's look at the content in the", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00051-00014952-00015244": "learn section of your study plan", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00052-00015245-00015508": "visit why it matters to learn why the", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00053-00015509-00015749": "concepts in this module model in matter", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00054-00015750-00016072": "in the real world the cheat sheet is a", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00055-00016073-00016265": "study Aid that provides key terms", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00056-00016266-00016558": "formulas and Concepts from this module", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00057-00016559-00016847": "and these are the topics within this", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00058-00016848-00016955": "module", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00059-00016956-00017200": "every study plan is organized the same", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00060-00017201-00017494": "way and every topic has the same", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00061-00017495-00017608": "structure", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00062-00017609-00017861": "this makes it easy for you to know what", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00063-00017862-00018071": "to expect and how to move through your", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00064-00018072-00018221": "materials", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00065-00018222-00018539": "the learn it section helps you learn the", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00066-00018540-00018761": "course content through readings videos", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00067-00018762-00019036": "and practice problems you can always", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00068-00019037-00019391": "click back to study plan to get back", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00069-00019392-00019672": "apply it help you apply what you've", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00070-00019673-00019883": "learned your instructor might ask you to", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00071-00019884-00020207": "do these in class or as homework and the", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00072-00020208-00020447": "self-check is a quick check that helps", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00073-00020448-00020608": "you gauge your understanding of the", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00074-00020609-00020861": "topic completion of these self-checks", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00075-00020862-00021089": "count toward your points for the study", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00076-00021090-00021407": "plan so make sure you do them they make", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00077-00021408-00021617": "a great study tool and you can take them", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00078-00021618-00021808": "as many times as you like", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00079-00021809-00021989": "when you're done", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00080-00021990-00022217": "you'll be able to see if there are any", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00081-00022218-00024383": "skills that you need to brush up on", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00082-00024384-00024683": "you go back to your study plan", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00083-00024684-00025042": "you'll see that your self check is done", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00084-00025043-00025385": "the Dig Deeper section has materials to", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00085-00025386-00025583": "help you learn the Big Ideas in a", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00086-00025584-00025828": "different way and these are helpful if", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00087-00025829-00026044": "your self-check results indicate that", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00088-00026045-00026327": "you still need to review this topic like", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00089-00026327-00026477": "I do here", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00090-00026477-00026758": "as you work through your study plan it", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00091-00026760-00026908": "will update to help you understand", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00092-00026910-00027190": "what's done and where you need to focus", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00093-00027191-00027329": "your time", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00094-00027330-00027611": "here's an example of a study plan where", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00095-00027612-00027862": "the Readiness check and all self-checks", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00096-00027863-00028193": "are done you can see the done label for", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00097-00028194-00028337": "each one of them", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00098-00028338-00028618": "you can also see that for some of the", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00099-00028619-00028924": "topics I need review and some of the", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00100-00028925-00029255": "topics I've achieved proficiency", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00101-00029256-00029501": "in order to get bold points for your", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00102-00029502-00029758": "study plans you must make sure that you", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00103-00029760-00030077": "see done next to each self-check and the", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00104-00030077-00030233": "Readiness check", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00105-00030233-00030407": "and once you've learned through the", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00106-00030408-00030629": "worked through the learn content of your", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00107-00030630-00030851": "study plan you'll find the practice", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00108-00030852-00031168": "problems and the quizzes the quiz for", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00109-00031169-00031414": "this module make sure you work through", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00110-00031416-00031612": "the study plan topics before you take", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00111-00031613-00031823": "your quiz so that you're prepared for it", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00112-00031824-00032158": "you have two attempts for each quiz and", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00113-00032160-00032314": "only the highest score will be counted", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00114-00032316-00032543": "and that's a quick overview of your", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00115-00032544-00032801": "Lumen one study plans we'd love to hear", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00116-00032802-00032987": "how you work through study plans so", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00117-00032988-00033196": "visit the Lumen community and let us", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00118-00033197-00033371": "know what's working and what we can", "TJ9v0_TqFBQ-00119-00033372-00033752": "improve have a great semester"}}, {"audio_id": "TJ9PbfGvyeE", "text": {"TJ9PbfGvyeE-00000-00000045-00000875": "[Music]", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00001-00000876-00001203": "hello everyone in this video I cannot", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00002-00001204-00001647": "teach all SQL queries in video as", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00003-00001648-00002139": "fastest of course I try to show all", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00004-00002140-00002580": "queries including delayed update and so", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00005-00002581-00002754": "on in one video", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00006-00002755-00003110": "my main also is preparing for my final", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00007-00003111-00003347": "exam", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00008-00003349-00004002": "oh okay let's start", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00009-00004003-00004263": "let's start with creating table and it's", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00010-00004264-00004494": "important and we should try to create", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00011-00004495-00004992": "keyword Suzanne table and then we should", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00012-00004993-00005313": "write a table named the our trade name", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00013-00005314-00005682": "will visco schools and between", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00014-00005683-00005871": "parentheses we should write our cool", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00015-00005872-00006189": "names and called type column types first", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00016-00006190-00006537": "for example ID n and type of it should", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00017-00006538-00006962": "be int numeric and name in watch our", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00018-00006963-00007535": "2055 character links this is our curry", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00019-00007536-00007920": "Andra Kasich has a screws table has been", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00020-00007920-00008577": "created the database list later we'll", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00021-00008578-00009054": "look how we can insert data into this", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00022-00009055-00009416": "table for example Raj insert into", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00023-00009417-00009867": "keyword later table name schools and we", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00024-00009868-00010020": "should write for between first", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00025-00010021-00010392": "parentheses our columns which should be", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00026-00010393-00010935": "which will be inserted and later the", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00027-00010936-00011379": "data's for relevant columns first ID and", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00028-00011380-00011835": "one and name for example 59 no that's", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00029-00011836-00011880": "wrong", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00030-00011881-00012093": "and as you can see records increased by", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00031-00012094-00012516": "one new table has been inserted which", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00032-00012517-00012653": "means", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00033-00012654-00013166": "now we look how we delete this data to", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00034-00013168-00013997": "it from screws the where again equal one", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00035-00013998-00014385": "first data it's look like just simple", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00036-00014386-00014883": "English speaking sentence until it from", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00037-00014884-00015416": "where and so on I think mmm one or two", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00038-00015418-00015778": "time practice help us help you to learn", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00039-00015779-00016293": "very well okay we looked inside now we", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00040-00016294-00016643": "should select so that aesthetics from", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00041-00016644-00017199": "schools Asterix mean old it notice of", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00042-00017200-00017898": "how of course the nori code", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00043-00017899-00018345": "now let's look how we can alter table", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00044-00018346-00018889": "columns not data columns we use outer", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00045-00018890-00019249": "keyword outer table name schools other", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00046-00019250-00019849": "schools right then Oh alter table school", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00047-00019850-00020299": "at what we will add count of four", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00048-00020300-00020596": "examples students choose a short column", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00049-00020597-00020995": "and data type will be int numeric range", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00050-00020996-00021229": "run and you have made change to the", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00051-00021230-00021610": "database this is message and there are", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00052-00021611-00021958": "not in record therefore we can see let's", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00053-00021959-00022460": "insert insert into schools", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00054-00022461-00022860": "again IDN name and this time we can", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00055-00022861-00023043": "write shouldn't count of students", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00056-00023044-00023605": "because we added this and values right", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00057-00023606-00024234": "relevant 159 no and for example account", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00058-00024235-00025016": "of students for example 60 and our data", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00059-00025017-00025527": "should be has been add hundred selected", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00060-00025528-00025970": "aesthetics from schools and as you can", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00061-00025972-00026337": "see our nude column has been added and", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00062-00026338-00027251": "our new record has been added to", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00063-00027252-00027812": "now let's look about select query to", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00064-00027813-00028258": "more deeply because it is so useful and", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00065-00028258-00028589": "widespread let's look customers table", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00066-00028589-00028799": "there are so many records we can use it", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00067-00028800-00029237": "very well for example select aesthetics", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00068-00029238-00029674": "from customers where we just write city", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00069-00029675-00030187": "city ego building and it will be shown", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00070-00030188-00030520": "just one person who's city is badly", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00071-00030522-00030960": "which is a first record", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00072-00030961-00031343": "also we can use we're close with wild", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00073-00031344-00031571": "cards what with what smart cards just", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00074-00031572-00032198": "like for example just type we write", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00075-00032199-00032708": "percentage icon and write pearl and", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00076-00032709-00033101": "percentage it means fight for me which", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00077-00033102-00033474": "whose city start with bit it can be paid", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00078-00033475-00033683": "Liam pearl and Perry Como as you can see", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00079-00033684-00034257": "it is useful to search search engines", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00080-00034258-00034667": "especially now we can change aesthetics", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00081-00034668-00035036": "trust customer name also we can use as", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00082-00035037-00035411": "aliases name it's call it and you can", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00083-00035412-00035804": "see Castro name shown name but it is not", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00084-00035805-00036192": "affected the structure of our table -", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00085-00036193-00036736": "just a represented name it is for you to", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00086-00036737-00037170": "avoid confusion when you use join and so", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00087-00037171-00037764": "on - we can write another query search", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00088-00037765-00038330": "from select asterisk from customers and", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00089-00038331-00038793": "would like to represent my data by", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00090-00038794-00039117": "alphabetical order it for example say", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00091-00039118-00039480": "for the right order by customer name and", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00092-00039481-00039949": "it should be yes you can see it should", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00093-00039950-00040392": "list it by alphabetical and you can see", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00094-00040393-00041008": "customer IDs is mix it not order it then", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00095-00041009-00041364": "update we don't you we didn't see that", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00096-00041365-00041926": "update table customers and set which", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00097-00041927-00042618": "column should be change it sit for", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00098-00042619-00042930": "example I will choose a dress Hodges", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00099-00042931-00043312": "will be for example in your dress - just", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00100-00043313-00043998": "observing where customer ID for example", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00101-00043999-00044874": "one first record", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00102-00044875-00045129": "and the others will be replaced by a new", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00103-00045130-00045192": "address", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00104-00045193-00046359": "Oh was that our error let me check it", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00105-00046360-00047205": "you", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00106-00047206-00047652": "okay I find we didn't result in fact", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00107-00047653-00048114": "table key work and our cube query should", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00108-00048115-00048557": "be has been executed and customers table", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00109-00048558-00048861": "you have to change it first record", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00110-00048862-00049796": "address changed by new address text then", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00111-00049797-00050126": "we can use group I which is other", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00112-00050127-00050649": "keyword to a select query further in my", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00113-00050650-00050913": "video has been interrupted for my code", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00114-00050914-00051279": "on take over set okay well let's", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00115-00051279-00051528": "continue I was writing group by", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00116-00051529-00052050": "statement and now I will group the", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00117-00052051-00052410": "country group data by country names so", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00118-00052411-00052805": "let's run and you can see there are just", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00119-00052807-00053316": "one copy of any country normally there", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00120-00053316-00053483": "are so many people from so many", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00121-00053484-00053901": "countries and but what by GroupMe group", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00122-00053902-00054426": "by keyboard we can we can just show one", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00123-00054427-00054791": "first one of them this is a function of", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00124-00054792-00055113": "group by normal it's used statistical", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00125-00055114-00055365": "methods how for example how many people", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00126-00055366-00055719": "from Argentina Austria or how many", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00127-00055720-00056025": "people are under 18 or over 18 and", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00128-00056026-00056574": "something like this later we can use let", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00129-00056575-00056637": "me think", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00130-00056638-00056997": "let's remove this bracket and count", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00131-00056998-00057411": "function count function is it's clear", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00132-00057412-00057791": "from the name count all result for", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00133-00057792-00058137": "example customer ID there are nine to", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00134-00058138-00058642": "one customer ID it used to account for", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00135-00058644-00058916": "example how many people as I said from", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00136-00058917-00059255": "Argentina the risk group by keywords", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00137-00059257-00059508": "it's complicated queries and average", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00138-00059509-00059855": "function average the sum of all data and", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00139-00059857-00060280": "divided by count of them this is a", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00140-00060281-00060715": "the number of our ID numbers this is 49", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00141-00060716-00061190": "foot six are they other function let me", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00142-00061191-00061721": "sink it's undeniable the minimum value", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00143-00061722-00061966": "from customer ID is one and maximum is", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00144-00061967-00062368": "the last record 91 and also I would like", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00145-00062369-00062854": "to add this functions as I said is used", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00146-00062855-00063204": "to move I the split statistical", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00147-00063205-00063687": "represent represent then let's look", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00148-00063688-00064099": "distinct select distinct it is show just", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00149-00064100-00064492": "original mass of data it's not retrieved", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00150-00064493-00064732": "the one data second time if it is the", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00151-00064733-00065056": "same absolutely the same in this table", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00152-00065057-00065524": "there are no the same data it is all of", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00153-00065525-00065950": "them is original therefore this result", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00154-00065951-00066441": "is the same with normal result then some", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00155-00066442-00066811": "some function is the action level some", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00156-00066812-00067300": "of numeric values some of customer IDs", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00157-00067301-00068110": "is 4160 86 we can use this song for", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00158-00068111-00068347": "other numeric values of course I just", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00159-00068348-00068902": "show by based on it now we have created", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00160-00068903-00069202": "table but how we can remove it or how", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00161-00069203-00069673": "can remove database this is top keyword", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00162-00069674-00070081": "we can use drop keyword to remove tables", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00163-00070082-00070444": "databases and please remember remove", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00164-00070445-00070852": "drop is to use the table or database but", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00165-00070853-00071319": "too late is to you is used to it theta", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00166-00071320-00071701": "or row drop table schools as you can see", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00167-00071702-00072135": "school's table has been removed", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00168-00072136-00072651": "but be careful vile using this keyboard", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00169-00072652-00072947": "because you can damage your database", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00170-00072948-00073372": "well I try to my best to review my", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00171-00073373-00073767": "knowledge for you I think that's enough", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00172-00073768-00074122": "for fundamental and I hope you will like", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00173-00074123-00074376": "my video and if you have any question", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00174-00074377-00074619": "you can write on comments or in social", "TJ9PbfGvyeE-00175-00074620-00074976": "media good luck"}}, {"audio_id": "TJm6cccwLOg", "text": {"TJm6cccwLOg-00000-00039284-00039584": "be"}}, {"audio_id": "TJwwZsHXofc", "text": {"TJwwZsHXofc-00000-00000017-00000364": "hey guys welcome back to the channel", "TJwwZsHXofc-00001-00000365-00000611": "we're gonna sit down today and talk with", "TJwwZsHXofc-00002-00000612-00000784": "you a little bit about what happened", "TJwwZsHXofc-00003-00000785-00001054": "when the kids went to", "TJwwZsHXofc-00004-00001055-00001258": "first day at the", "TJwwZsHXofc-00005-00001259-00001511": "end yeah give you kind of Life update", "TJwwZsHXofc-00006-00001512-00001775": "and school update", "TJwwZsHXofc-00007-00001776-00001942": "just to fill you in and let you know", "TJwwZsHXofc-00008-00001943-00002099": "where we're at", "TJwwZsHXofc-00009-00002100-00002507": "no raising kids oh my goodness", "TJwwZsHXofc-00010-00002508-00002908": "okay so yes we did not know all of the", "TJwwZsHXofc-00011-00002909-00003197": "particulars that went on in school it's", "TJwwZsHXofc-00012-00003198-00003497": "been a while because I went to a private", "TJwwZsHXofc-00013-00003497-00003845": "school but I was not expecting that to a", "TJwwZsHXofc-00014-00003846-00004138": "private or public school I apologize so", "TJwwZsHXofc-00015-00004139-00004445": "I was not expecting private school to be", "TJwwZsHXofc-00016-00004446-00004679": "this way right I thought it'd be a", "TJwwZsHXofc-00017-00004680-00004811": "little bit more controlled environment", "TJwwZsHXofc-00018-00004812-00005063": "more yes and mind you better behaved", "TJwwZsHXofc-00019-00005064-00005393": "kids mind you this is a Christian", "TJwwZsHXofc-00020-00005394-00005617": "foreign", "TJwwZsHXofc-00021-00005618-00006011": "school so oh wait", "TJwwZsHXofc-00022-00006012-00006329": "so where do we start let's start off by", "TJwwZsHXofc-00023-00006330-00006520": "okay so I picked the children up if you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00024-00006522-00006713": "have not watched that video go watch it", "TJwwZsHXofc-00025-00006714-00006941": "where you know we filmed their first day", "TJwwZsHXofc-00026-00006942-00007259": "but so they get in the car and like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00027-00007259-00007477": "right away they're like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00028-00007478-00007781": "100 miles an hour oh my telling me", "TJwwZsHXofc-00029-00007781-00008039": "everything in my eyes as you know what", "TJwwZsHXofc-00030-00008040-00008255": "parents when like your child tells you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00031-00008256-00008441": "something and you're trying not to", "TJwwZsHXofc-00032-00008442-00008609": "overreact because you don't want them", "TJwwZsHXofc-00033-00008610-00008824": "you don't want to scare them so they", "TJwwZsHXofc-00034-00008825-00009028": "can't see my reaction but I'm driving in", "TJwwZsHXofc-00035-00009029-00009214": "there telling me I'm like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00036-00009215-00009431": "the whole time meanwhile I'm at work and", "TJwwZsHXofc-00037-00009432-00009592": "I know about what time they're getting", "TJwwZsHXofc-00038-00009593-00009821": "off yeah and I'm like texting Vietnamese", "TJwwZsHXofc-00039-00009822-00010073": "so how'd it go how was it like 10 000", "TJwwZsHXofc-00040-00010074-00010373": "texts like are they okay but I want to", "TJwwZsHXofc-00041-00010374-00010546": "hear about it tell me what's going on so", "TJwwZsHXofc-00042-00010547-00010810": "I'm like okay so I had them just like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00043-00010811-00010991": "not going to details like I said in the", "TJwwZsHXofc-00044-00010992-00011224": "video I don't want to details you know", "TJwwZsHXofc-00045-00011225-00011537": "we gotta talk about this so then", "TJwwZsHXofc-00046-00011538-00011777": "um we drove home they're telling me all", "TJwwZsHXofc-00047-00011778-00012046": "this stuff we we get home and I said", "TJwwZsHXofc-00048-00012047-00012214": "y'all go inside I gotta talk to your", "TJwwZsHXofc-00049-00012215-00012319": "daddy", "TJwwZsHXofc-00050-00012320-00012635": "so then I called Jory and I think I sat", "TJwwZsHXofc-00051-00012636-00012893": "in the car for like 20 30 minutes just", "TJwwZsHXofc-00052-00012894-00013330": "going off I was like who what I did what", "TJwwZsHXofc-00053-00013331-00013543": "what", "TJwwZsHXofc-00054-00013544-00013972": "you're asking all those questions but oh", "TJwwZsHXofc-00055-00013973-00014393": "yeah so I I was I was I was disappointed", "TJwwZsHXofc-00056-00014394-00014705": "we were very disappointed", "TJwwZsHXofc-00057-00014706-00014891": "um yeah but yeah do you want to share", "TJwwZsHXofc-00058-00014891-00015322": "some of those things oh boy", "TJwwZsHXofc-00059-00015323-00015622": "so I guess what kind of stood out to me", "TJwwZsHXofc-00060-00015623-00015791": "was", "TJwwZsHXofc-00061-00015791-00015857": "um", "TJwwZsHXofc-00062-00015858-00016066": "it seemed like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00063-00016068-00016336": "the kids were able to just kind of do", "TJwwZsHXofc-00064-00016337-00016553": "whatever and there wasn't a lot of", "TJwwZsHXofc-00065-00016554-00016811": "pushback on bad behavior from the staff", "TJwwZsHXofc-00066-00016812-00017027": "now this could be due to the fact that", "TJwwZsHXofc-00067-00017028-00017261": "it was", "TJwwZsHXofc-00068-00017262-00017507": "approaching the end of the year right so", "TJwwZsHXofc-00069-00017508-00017669": "it could be due to that but yeah we", "TJwwZsHXofc-00070-00017670-00017825": "don't know that yeah and maybe the kids", "TJwwZsHXofc-00071-00017826-00017986": "found a way to like kind of get away", "TJwwZsHXofc-00072-00017987-00018263": "from where the staff are located like on", "TJwwZsHXofc-00073-00018264-00018425": "their brakes or whatever but some of the", "TJwwZsHXofc-00074-00018426-00018677": "stuff the conversations and I know I'm", "TJwwZsHXofc-00075-00018678-00018911": "pretty naive I was homeschooled but some", "TJwwZsHXofc-00076-00018912-00019043": "of the conversations and the things", "TJwwZsHXofc-00077-00019044-00019336": "especially of the kids that Bella was", "TJwwZsHXofc-00078-00019337-00019655": "around oh the girls like the that age", "TJwwZsHXofc-00079-00019656-00019925": "just it was really inappropriate yeah", "TJwwZsHXofc-00080-00019926-00020243": "and I just expected more at like a I'm", "TJwwZsHXofc-00081-00020244-00020536": "using quotes Christian School yeah", "TJwwZsHXofc-00082-00020537-00020771": "um I know a thing can't be a Christian", "TJwwZsHXofc-00083-00020772-00020897": "but", "TJwwZsHXofc-00084-00020898-00021100": "you would think that they'd have values", "TJwwZsHXofc-00085-00021101-00021299": "that would be different from the world", "TJwwZsHXofc-00086-00021300-00021605": "and I I didn't really hear that and like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00087-00021606-00021941": "literally they they went one day and the", "TJwwZsHXofc-00088-00021942-00022211": "amount of things that happened in one", "TJwwZsHXofc-00089-00022212-00022493": "day I was like what like that you're", "TJwwZsHXofc-00090-00022494-00022703": "talking about conversations these are", "TJwwZsHXofc-00091-00022704-00022894": "the like these are the things that", "TJwwZsHXofc-00092-00022895-00023164": "they're talking about and like we're not", "TJwwZsHXofc-00093-00023165-00023458": "I've how can I say this", "TJwwZsHXofc-00094-00023459-00023669": "I don't I don't want to feel like I've", "TJwwZsHXofc-00095-00023670-00023963": "sheltered my kids but I have and", "TJwwZsHXofc-00096-00023964-00024077": "sometimes they're wrong with that", "TJwwZsHXofc-00097-00024078-00024214": "sometimes I feel like for good reason", "TJwwZsHXofc-00098-00024215-00024533": "yeah like our kids are 11 and 12 and", "TJwwZsHXofc-00099-00024534-00024691": "there's a lot of stuff they don't know", "TJwwZsHXofc-00100-00024692-00025072": "that that they don't need to know no but", "TJwwZsHXofc-00101-00025073-00025180": "we don't", "TJwwZsHXofc-00102-00025181-00025307": "there are people out there that don't", "TJwwZsHXofc-00103-00025308-00025486": "raise their kids like us and they know", "TJwwZsHXofc-00104-00025487-00025577": "every", "TJwwZsHXofc-00105-00025578-00025864": "and that's okay we're not yeah sorry I", "TJwwZsHXofc-00106-00025866-00025967": "don't wanna I don't want that to come", "TJwwZsHXofc-00107-00025968-00026158": "across judgment no you're not but we're", "TJwwZsHXofc-00108-00026160-00026339": "just I guess our mindset is we're trying", "TJwwZsHXofc-00109-00026339-00026620": "to maintain innocence as long as", "TJwwZsHXofc-00110-00026622-00026896": "possible as you guys know like when you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00111-00026897-00027070": "when you become an adult you look at", "TJwwZsHXofc-00112-00027072-00027335": "yourself and go why wasn't a rush in a", "TJwwZsHXofc-00113-00027336-00027562": "rush to know all these things and you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00114-00027563-00027827": "know so like for us it's like just be a", "TJwwZsHXofc-00115-00027827-00028024": "kid you enjoy your life like because", "TJwwZsHXofc-00116-00028025-00028307": "when you become an adult life tends to", "TJwwZsHXofc-00117-00028308-00028468": "get stressed it's more complicated and", "TJwwZsHXofc-00118-00028469-00028733": "then it's extremely complicated so why", "TJwwZsHXofc-00119-00028733-00028931": "get yourself in a situation where you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00120-00028932-00029302": "start off complicated like so if we can", "TJwwZsHXofc-00121-00029304-00029549": "save them the heartache of that I don't", "TJwwZsHXofc-00122-00029550-00029699": "think there's anything wrong with that", "TJwwZsHXofc-00123-00029700-00029908": "and we're not here saying how we're", "TJwwZsHXofc-00124-00029910-00030095": "doing it is best but this is our", "TJwwZsHXofc-00125-00030095-00030329": "conviction yes as their parents right", "TJwwZsHXofc-00126-00030330-00030473": "and the older two are to the point where", "TJwwZsHXofc-00127-00030474-00030652": "they understand that there are things", "TJwwZsHXofc-00128-00030653-00030851": "we're keeping from oh they know yeah and", "TJwwZsHXofc-00129-00030852-00031067": "and we've explained to them very clearly", "TJwwZsHXofc-00130-00031068-00031337": "and I think it's healthy that we say", "TJwwZsHXofc-00131-00031338-00031667": "look there are here's the example you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00132-00031668-00031918": "wouldn't give whatever to a to us people", "TJwwZsHXofc-00133-00031919-00032129": "talk about a phone we get the example we", "TJwwZsHXofc-00134-00032130-00032249": "get", "TJwwZsHXofc-00135-00032250-00032399": "well there's a few examples that I use", "TJwwZsHXofc-00136-00032400-00032627": "when I talk about someone having", "TJwwZsHXofc-00137-00032627-00032837": "something before it's time for them to", "TJwwZsHXofc-00138-00032838-00033005": "have it yeah before they're able to", "TJwwZsHXofc-00139-00033006-00033323": "handle the Bible talks about yeah in a", "TJwwZsHXofc-00140-00033324-00033796": "intense", "TJwwZsHXofc-00141-00033797-00033989": "that perfectly defines it because I", "TJwwZsHXofc-00142-00033990-00034187": "think about like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00143-00034188-00034379": "um you wouldn't give a three-year-old a", "TJwwZsHXofc-00144-00034380-00034577": "handgun no you know what I mean they're", "TJwwZsHXofc-00145-00034578-00034745": "they're not and maybe that's a poor", "TJwwZsHXofc-00146-00034746-00035021": "example or how about keys to a car you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00147-00035022-00035177": "want to give a three-year-old keys to a", "TJwwZsHXofc-00148-00035178-00035423": "car who knows what could happen so there", "TJwwZsHXofc-00149-00035424-00035639": "are things that that can be a blessing", "TJwwZsHXofc-00150-00035640-00035921": "in their time but definitely a curse if", "TJwwZsHXofc-00151-00035922-00036239": "it's before their time right and so you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00152-00036240-00036418": "guys can probably guess what kind of", "TJwwZsHXofc-00153-00036419-00036659": "things we're talking about that the kids", "TJwwZsHXofc-00154-00036660-00036935": "in school are are bringing before our", "TJwwZsHXofc-00155-00036936-00037145": "children and we've tried so hard to", "TJwwZsHXofc-00156-00037146-00037367": "maintain their innocence and now that", "TJwwZsHXofc-00157-00037368-00037661": "they're bad kids just that you know yeah", "TJwwZsHXofc-00158-00037662-00037907": "yeah so and we also have to understand", "TJwwZsHXofc-00159-00037908-00038279": "that as parents we teach our kids one", "TJwwZsHXofc-00160-00038280-00038512": "thing and then when they go in front of", "TJwwZsHXofc-00161-00038513-00038752": "other children whatever is going on in", "TJwwZsHXofc-00162-00038753-00038968": "that household is gonna be brought up", "TJwwZsHXofc-00163-00038969-00039059": "right", "TJwwZsHXofc-00164-00039060-00039227": "um the child might even not even", "TJwwZsHXofc-00165-00039228-00039455": "understand exactly what they're saying", "TJwwZsHXofc-00166-00039456-00039796": "or the complexity of the matter but", "TJwwZsHXofc-00167-00039797-00039946": "they're just speaking what they've heard", "TJwwZsHXofc-00168-00039947-00040235": "right um so therefore other kids pick it", "TJwwZsHXofc-00169-00040236-00040552": "up we understand that aspect of things", "TJwwZsHXofc-00170-00040553-00040685": "too", "TJwwZsHXofc-00171-00040686-00040865": "um again we were just disappointed", "TJwwZsHXofc-00172-00040866-00041137": "because we", "TJwwZsHXofc-00173-00041138-00041446": "we expected more from a private school", "TJwwZsHXofc-00174-00041447-00041729": "that is very expensive", "TJwwZsHXofc-00175-00041730-00042011": "um it was it was discouraging", "TJwwZsHXofc-00176-00042012-00042196": "um so I'll just say one of the things", "TJwwZsHXofc-00177-00042197-00042383": "that they talked about was like dating", "TJwwZsHXofc-00178-00042384-00042623": "not like was like her class like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00179-00042624-00042990": "everybody was talking about dude", "TJwwZsHXofc-00180-00042991-00043217": "like and then at one point one of the", "TJwwZsHXofc-00181-00043218-00043487": "girls was like oh you know let's call", "TJwwZsHXofc-00182-00043488-00043702": "this boy Joe", "TJwwZsHXofc-00183-00043703-00043967": "hey Bella Joe gave you the look and", "TJwwZsHXofc-00184-00043968-00044195": "Bella's like what's the look and one of", "TJwwZsHXofc-00185-00044196-00044543": "the girl got up and reenacted what the", "TJwwZsHXofc-00186-00044544-00044771": "they were trying to the message they", "TJwwZsHXofc-00187-00044772-00045196": "were trying to convey to her like yes I", "TJwwZsHXofc-00188-00045197-00045568": "and bill was like whoa", "TJwwZsHXofc-00189-00045569-00045796": "um so there was that", "TJwwZsHXofc-00190-00045797-00046115": "then they mentioned the young man going", "TJwwZsHXofc-00191-00046116-00046373": "Oh I thought you know the two girls were", "TJwwZsHXofc-00192-00046374-00046601": "talking and Bella happened to walk in", "TJwwZsHXofc-00193-00046602-00046901": "and one of the girl made a comment like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00194-00046902-00047255": "Oh I thought Joe like cared about size", "TJwwZsHXofc-00195-00047256-00047723": "like and wanted the other girl was like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00196-00047724-00047999": "do you know what that means and Bella", "TJwwZsHXofc-00197-00048000-00048317": "was like yeah sure and she walks up and", "TJwwZsHXofc-00198-00048318-00048467": "she's like no I didn't want to come over", "TJwwZsHXofc-00199-00048468-00048796": "I was like a homeschooler or whatever so", "TJwwZsHXofc-00200-00048797-00049051": "I just said it but I you know", "TJwwZsHXofc-00201-00049052-00049301": "as I was walking away one of the other", "TJwwZsHXofc-00202-00049302-00049462": "girls was like oh don't worry about her", "TJwwZsHXofc-00203-00049463-00049751": "she's innocent and so she told me that", "TJwwZsHXofc-00204-00049752-00050080": "like I was hot y'all I was I was like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00205-00050081-00050418": "she should be innocent as well like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00206-00050419-00050765": "you shouldn't you shouldn't know that um", "TJwwZsHXofc-00207-00050766-00051005": "just the idea that kids are gonna shame", "TJwwZsHXofc-00208-00051006-00051250": "other kids for not knowing right yeah I", "TJwwZsHXofc-00209-00051251-00051473": "think that's what upset me the most was", "TJwwZsHXofc-00210-00051474-00051790": "like you're not gonna bully her into", "TJwwZsHXofc-00211-00051791-00051994": "feeling like because she does in no", "TJwwZsHXofc-00212-00051995-00052282": "certain things right yeah and it wasn't", "TJwwZsHXofc-00213-00052283-00052600": "like just a one-off comment she that", "TJwwZsHXofc-00214-00052601-00052894": "girl made that same comment again", "TJwwZsHXofc-00215-00052895-00053315": "um in a a different conversation which", "TJwwZsHXofc-00216-00053316-00053579": "was you know they made a hand gesture", "TJwwZsHXofc-00217-00053579-00053891": "and then did this and asked Bella do you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00218-00053891-00054088": "know what it was and she felt like no", "TJwwZsHXofc-00219-00054089-00054257": "and I don't want to know when she walks", "TJwwZsHXofc-00220-00054258-00054580": "up like oh she's innocent", "TJwwZsHXofc-00221-00054582-00054761": "um to like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00222-00054762-00055097": "my daughter Bella turned to 12 in", "TJwwZsHXofc-00223-00055098-00055438": "December so she's", "TJwwZsHXofc-00224-00055439-00055876": "truly young young like a child and like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00225-00055877-00056026": "all the rest of those kids I get it", "TJwwZsHXofc-00226-00056027-00056279": "whenever like this the high school I", "TJwwZsHXofc-00227-00056279-00056476": "went to or even the middle school I went", "TJwwZsHXofc-00228-00056477-00056800": "to I don't remember it being like this", "TJwwZsHXofc-00229-00056801-00057215": "crazy and if it was it's like okay it's", "TJwwZsHXofc-00230-00057216-00057509": "a public school with like 4 000 or a", "TJwwZsHXofc-00231-00057510-00057773": "private public school but like 2 000", "TJwwZsHXofc-00232-00057774-00058085": "plus kids all sorts of backgrounds but", "TJwwZsHXofc-00233-00058086-00058438": "this is a Christian environment so I am", "TJwwZsHXofc-00234-00058439-00058915": "just sorry it was just so overwhelming", "TJwwZsHXofc-00235-00058916-00059194": "and and sad", "TJwwZsHXofc-00236-00059195-00059416": "um Bella was really sad because she was", "TJwwZsHXofc-00237-00059417-00059597": "looking forward to like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00238-00059598-00059794": "community and some friends and just", "TJwwZsHXofc-00239-00059795-00060142": "having long-term friends but we're gonna", "TJwwZsHXofc-00240-00060144-00060382": "just bring the kids in and let them", "TJwwZsHXofc-00241-00060383-00060613": "share with you guys", "TJwwZsHXofc-00242-00060614-00060880": "Ellie's just waking up sorry", "TJwwZsHXofc-00243-00060882-00061103": "so I hear her so we're gonna bring the", "TJwwZsHXofc-00244-00061104-00061456": "kids in yeah so anyway all right then", "TJwwZsHXofc-00245-00061457-00061666": "what was your reaction to your first day", "TJwwZsHXofc-00246-00061667-00061775": "of school", "TJwwZsHXofc-00247-00061776-00061979": "um I liked it and I would probably go", "TJwwZsHXofc-00248-00061979-00062194": "back you will go back what did you like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00249-00062195-00062303": "about it", "TJwwZsHXofc-00250-00062304-00062459": "um that it was small and the teachers", "TJwwZsHXofc-00251-00062460-00062680": "were nice and there was something to do", "TJwwZsHXofc-00252-00062682-00063004": "and like every single hour or something", "TJwwZsHXofc-00253-00063005-00063221": "like like there was always something to", "TJwwZsHXofc-00254-00063222-00063449": "do did you feel weird that you were away", "TJwwZsHXofc-00255-00063450-00063588": "from us for eight hours", "TJwwZsHXofc-00256-00063589-00063719": "[Music]", "TJwwZsHXofc-00257-00063720-00063892": "yes he also mentioned that there were", "TJwwZsHXofc-00258-00063894-00064138": "animals", "TJwwZsHXofc-00259-00064139-00064361": "Miss Bella how about you what was your", "TJwwZsHXofc-00260-00064362-00064588": "reaction to your first day of school I", "TJwwZsHXofc-00261-00064589-00064697": "did not like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00262-00064698-00064949": "it um some of the things that the kids", "TJwwZsHXofc-00263-00064950-00065165": "were saying kind of freaked me out or", "TJwwZsHXofc-00264-00065166-00065309": "whatever it made me feel uncomfortable I", "TJwwZsHXofc-00265-00065310-00065416": "was", "TJwwZsHXofc-00266-00065417-00065609": "just made me feel don't understand why", "TJwwZsHXofc-00267-00065610-00065837": "we can't talk about something else okay", "TJwwZsHXofc-00268-00065838-00066100": "so did you was there someone you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00269-00066101-00066335": "gravitated towards or like things you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00270-00066336-00066515": "saw that you did enjoy was there", "TJwwZsHXofc-00271-00066516-00066682": "anything you liked not really I already", "TJwwZsHXofc-00272-00066683-00066991": "kind of felt out of", "TJwwZsHXofc-00273-00066992-00067355": "but so then that added to it and made me", "TJwwZsHXofc-00274-00067356-00067763": "just feel like okay Jaden what's your", "TJwwZsHXofc-00275-00067764-00068050": "response to what you have seen as in", "TJwwZsHXofc-00276-00068051-00068375": "your class would you go to that school", "TJwwZsHXofc-00277-00068376-00068597": "or wouldn't you go", "TJwwZsHXofc-00278-00068598-00068806": "would definitely go yeah you also know", "TJwwZsHXofc-00279-00068807-00069191": "quite a bit of people yeah", "TJwwZsHXofc-00280-00069192-00069419": "that's helpful and then he you have", "TJwwZsHXofc-00281-00069420-00069647": "choir or some of them right oh yeah", "TJwwZsHXofc-00282-00069648-00069935": "soccer one of them is going to be coming", "TJwwZsHXofc-00283-00069936-00070294": "into my choir okay so he has kids he", "TJwwZsHXofc-00284-00070295-00070594": "knows that he he goes he has choir with", "TJwwZsHXofc-00285-00070595-00070835": "yeah yeah and then he plays sports with", "TJwwZsHXofc-00286-00070836-00070979": "soccer", "TJwwZsHXofc-00287-00070980-00071219": "um how about you Miss Bella your", "TJwwZsHXofc-00288-00071220-00071538": "response to what you know what you've", "TJwwZsHXofc-00289-00071539-00071969": "encountered would you go to that school", "TJwwZsHXofc-00290-00071970-00072281": "I mean I wouldn't like it but I don't", "TJwwZsHXofc-00291-00072282-00072737": "know it's it's bearable it's just", "TJwwZsHXofc-00292-00072738-00072965": "you felt like you couldn't make any", "TJwwZsHXofc-00293-00072966-00073288": "friends yeah cause like I felt like I", "TJwwZsHXofc-00294-00073289-00073588": "was the only like the only different one", "TJwwZsHXofc-00295-00073589-00073793": "and so", "TJwwZsHXofc-00296-00073794-00073979": "yeah I don't I don't know I there was no", "TJwwZsHXofc-00297-00073980-00074129": "one I could really relate to I didn't", "TJwwZsHXofc-00298-00074130-00074362": "talk to a lot of people really it was", "TJwwZsHXofc-00299-00074363-00074519": "just kind of like a little by myself", "TJwwZsHXofc-00300-00074520-00074891": "here so jb1 was one shocking thing that", "TJwwZsHXofc-00301-00074892-00075167": "you saw they were that were like whoa", "TJwwZsHXofc-00302-00075168-00075515": "like like bad or good either one share", "TJwwZsHXofc-00303-00075516-00075719": "both if you have both", "TJwwZsHXofc-00304-00075720-00076012": "um a boy acting like a girl yeah or what", "TJwwZsHXofc-00305-00076013-00076276": "so that was okay so the thing was I", "TJwwZsHXofc-00306-00076277-00076432": "didn't know if it was just more like God", "TJwwZsHXofc-00307-00076433-00076637": "Mom Mom said it could have been God", "TJwwZsHXofc-00308-00076638-00076967": "Gothic he was dressed I don't know I say", "TJwwZsHXofc-00309-00076968-00077255": "trust your senses yeah trust your trust", "TJwwZsHXofc-00310-00077256-00077519": "your instinct so yeah there was that", "TJwwZsHXofc-00311-00077520-00077771": "that shocked you you are not used to", "TJwwZsHXofc-00312-00077772-00077915": "that", "TJwwZsHXofc-00313-00077916-00078162": "Miss Bella was oh", "TJwwZsHXofc-00314-00078163-00078437": "they let you sit", "TJwwZsHXofc-00315-00078438-00078544": "while they're", "TJwwZsHXofc-00316-00078545-00078750": "telling teaching you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00317-00078751-00079085": "and like it's just the classroom is", "TJwwZsHXofc-00318-00079086-00079282": "really small they have animals in there", "TJwwZsHXofc-00319-00079283-00079444": "so it's like more of a relaxed", "TJwwZsHXofc-00320-00079445-00079582": "environment it's not what you were", "TJwwZsHXofc-00321-00079583-00079993": "expecting yeah", "TJwwZsHXofc-00322-00079994-00080393": "all right Bella I shocked you that too I", "TJwwZsHXofc-00323-00080394-00080555": "experienced the same thing like there", "TJwwZsHXofc-00324-00080556-00080753": "are like bean bags in a classroom I", "TJwwZsHXofc-00325-00080754-00081017": "expected desks yeah bean bags and", "TJwwZsHXofc-00326-00081018-00081179": "pillows yeah", "TJwwZsHXofc-00327-00081180-00081365": "um and then some of the things the kids", "TJwwZsHXofc-00328-00081366-00081581": "were saying kind of shocked me like whoa", "TJwwZsHXofc-00329-00081582-00081803": "what was the most shocking to you do you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00330-00081804-00081959": "want to share with them", "TJwwZsHXofc-00331-00081960-00082055": "um", "TJwwZsHXofc-00332-00082056-00082325": "so it's kind of like at that sixth grade", "TJwwZsHXofc-00333-00082326-00082505": "stage where people start liking other", "TJwwZsHXofc-00334-00082506-00082750": "people people but they were intensifying", "TJwwZsHXofc-00335-00082751-00083050": "it and calling it dating and like saying", "TJwwZsHXofc-00336-00083051-00083255": "some weird stuff about who likes who and", "TJwwZsHXofc-00337-00083256-00083512": "why why likes her or whatever", "TJwwZsHXofc-00338-00083513-00083693": "um it's not just some of this like the", "TJwwZsHXofc-00339-00083694-00083843": "words they were using the terminology", "TJwwZsHXofc-00340-00083844-00084035": "and other things just kind of made me", "TJwwZsHXofc-00341-00084036-00084659": "feel awkward", "TJwwZsHXofc-00342-00084660-00084905": "so yeah we had to", "TJwwZsHXofc-00343-00084906-00085115": "we had a conversation a long", "TJwwZsHXofc-00344-00085116-00085271": "conversation with our kid I feel like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00345-00085272-00085494": "half of the day was gone just us talking", "TJwwZsHXofc-00346-00085495-00085744": "about this you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00347-00085745-00085991": "the situation and what we could do", "TJwwZsHXofc-00348-00085992-00086147": "better yeah", "TJwwZsHXofc-00349-00086148-00086453": "um but so yeah that is our school update", "TJwwZsHXofc-00350-00086454-00086818": "we are visiting other schools", "TJwwZsHXofc-00351-00086819-00087049": "um other", "TJwwZsHXofc-00352-00087050-00087256": "somebody's still working other Christian", "TJwwZsHXofc-00353-00087257-00087605": "schools and you know possibly you know", "TJwwZsHXofc-00354-00087606-00087844": "Public School the schools around here", "TJwwZsHXofc-00355-00087845-00088091": "are very like small in size it's not", "TJwwZsHXofc-00356-00088092-00088294": "like where I went to school right like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00357-00088295-00088529": "really huge they're small yeah", "TJwwZsHXofc-00358-00088530-00088625": "um", "TJwwZsHXofc-00359-00088626-00088859": "so we're gonna give you guys another", "TJwwZsHXofc-00360-00088860-00089165": "update later but that is the update for", "TJwwZsHXofc-00361-00089166-00089326": "today", "TJwwZsHXofc-00362-00089327-00089476": "um do you want to go with them or sing", "TJwwZsHXofc-00363-00089477-00089947": "thank you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00364-00089948-00090437": "thank you guys parents we had a hard job", "TJwwZsHXofc-00365-00090438-00090731": "children they also have like a heart", "TJwwZsHXofc-00366-00090732-00090935": "heart to play", "TJwwZsHXofc-00367-00090936-00091223": "because as Christian parents you want", "TJwwZsHXofc-00368-00091224-00091505": "your children to be you know a light to", "TJwwZsHXofc-00369-00091506-00091823": "the world or even better examples to", "TJwwZsHXofc-00370-00091824-00092165": "their Christian peers as well", "TJwwZsHXofc-00371-00092166-00092393": "um it made it really hard I wanted to", "TJwwZsHXofc-00372-00092394-00092687": "talk to some parents and it was a friend", "TJwwZsHXofc-00373-00092688-00092855": "of mine that I wanted to talk to but I", "TJwwZsHXofc-00374-00092856-00093185": "felt like I just couldn't say what I", "TJwwZsHXofc-00375-00093186-00093443": "needed to say because like one of their", "TJwwZsHXofc-00376-00093444-00093712": "child was involved I don't want my child", "TJwwZsHXofc-00377-00093713-00094031": "to be labeled as goodies I feel like as", "TJwwZsHXofc-00378-00094032-00094324": "Christian even as parents we've walked", "TJwwZsHXofc-00379-00094325-00094643": "down that road where people deem us go", "TJwwZsHXofc-00380-00094644-00094871": "to two shoes and so then you feel like", "TJwwZsHXofc-00381-00094872-00095056": "you have to", "TJwwZsHXofc-00382-00095057-00095465": "different to to to kind of fit in I", "TJwwZsHXofc-00383-00095466-00095662": "don't want my 12 year old or my 11 year", "TJwwZsHXofc-00384-00095663-00095956": "old to have to walk walk that as an", "TJwwZsHXofc-00385-00095957-00096035": "adult", "TJwwZsHXofc-00386-00096036-00096262": "it's a little different because I've", "TJwwZsHXofc-00387-00096263-00096629": "come to terms with this is my these are", "TJwwZsHXofc-00388-00096630-00096923": "my convictions this is how I do life if", "TJwwZsHXofc-00389-00096924-00097193": "it agitates a person we don't have to be", "TJwwZsHXofc-00390-00097194-00097493": "best friends like I I don't have to you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00391-00097494-00097637": "know come to your house you don't have", "TJwwZsHXofc-00392-00097638-00097937": "to come to mind it's it's hard when you", "TJwwZsHXofc-00393-00097938-00098338": "see Christians like belittling or", "TJwwZsHXofc-00394-00098339-00098491": "teasing one another", "TJwwZsHXofc-00395-00098492-00098843": "in in ways that they themselves should", "TJwwZsHXofc-00396-00098844-00099179": "walk like it's just kind of it's", "TJwwZsHXofc-00397-00099180-00099491": "discouraging and disheartening so we", "TJwwZsHXofc-00398-00099492-00099724": "will keep talking to our kids yeah", "TJwwZsHXofc-00399-00099725-00099965": "that's all we can do we will be talking", "TJwwZsHXofc-00400-00099966-00100187": "to other parents as well to figure out", "TJwwZsHXofc-00401-00100188-00100391": "how they're handling things in that", "TJwwZsHXofc-00402-00100392-00100643": "specific school because at the end of", "TJwwZsHXofc-00403-00100644-00100865": "the day guys I do feel more comfortable", "TJwwZsHXofc-00404-00100866-00101105": "with them going to that particular", "TJwwZsHXofc-00405-00101106-00101338": "school because it is very small yeah", "TJwwZsHXofc-00406-00101339-00101453": "yeah", "TJwwZsHXofc-00407-00101454-00101650": "um as far as safety or accountability", "TJwwZsHXofc-00408-00101651-00101837": "that way if you guys haven't already", "TJwwZsHXofc-00409-00101838-00102029": "seen where the kids had their first day", "TJwwZsHXofc-00410-00102030-00102293": "at school go check it out and keep", "TJwwZsHXofc-00411-00102294-00102548": "looking up"}}, {"audio_id": "TKCToPZ-ydo", "text": {"TKCToPZ-ydo-00000-00000052-00000287": "Acts of the Apostles ancient Greek", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00001-00000288-00000521": "practices tun apostille in praxis tun", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00002-00000522-00000774": "apostille in Latin actus apostille Oram", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00003-00000775-00001004": "often referred to simply as Acts is the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00004-00001005-00001190": "fifth book of the New Testament it tells", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00005-00001191-00001358": "of the founding of the Christian Church", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00006-00001359-00001520": "and the spread of its message to the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00007-00001521-00001727": "Roman Empire Acts in the Gospel of Luke", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00008-00001728-00001971": "make up a two-part work Luke acts by the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00009-00001972-00002199": "same anonymous author usually dated to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00010-00002200-00002525": "around 80 to 90 AD the first part the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00011-00002526-00002739": "Gospel of Luke tells how God fulfilled", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00012-00002740-00002979": "his plan for the world s salvation", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00013-00002980-00003143": "through the life death and resurrection", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00014-00003144-00003399": "of Jesus of Nazareth the promised", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00015-00003400-00003704": "Messiah acts continues the story of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00016-00003706-00003924": "Christianity in the first century", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00017-00003925-00004263": "beginning with Jesus s ascension to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00018-00004264-00004296": "heaven", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00019-00004297-00004524": "the early chapters set in Jerusalem", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00020-00004525-00004746": "describe the day of Pentecost the coming", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00021-00004747-00004920": "of the Holy Spirit and the growth of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00022-00004921-00005048": "church in Jerusalem", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00023-00005049-00005292": "initially the Jews are receptive to the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00024-00005293-00005460": "Christian message but soon they turn", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00025-00005461-00005751": "against the followers of Jesus rejected", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00026-00005752-00005925": "by the Jews under the guidance of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00027-00005926-00006123": "Apostle Peter the message is taken to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00028-00006124-00006402": "the Gentiles the later chapters tell of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00029-00006403-00006591": "Paul's conversion his mission in Asia", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00030-00006592-00006798": "Minor and the Aegean and finally his", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00031-00006798-00007008": "imprisonment in Rome where as the book", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00032-00007009-00007169": "ends he awaits trial", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00033-00007170-00007424": "Luke acts as an attempt to answer a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00034-00007425-00007623": "theological problem namely how the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00035-00007623-00007799": "Messiah of the Jews came to have an", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00036-00007800-00007998": "overwhelmingly non-jewish church the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00037-00007998-00008208": "answer it provides and its central theme", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00038-00008209-00008391": "is that the message of Christ was sent", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00039-00008392-00008552": "to the Gentiles because the Jews", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00040-00008553-00008841": "rejected it Luke acts can be also seen", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00041-00008842-00009188": "as a defense of or apology for the Jesus", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00042-00009189-00009380": "Movement addressed to the Jews the bulk", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00043-00009381-00009573": "of the speeches and sermons in acts are", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00044-00009574-00009759": "addressed to Jewish audiences with the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00045-00009760-00009956": "Romans serving as external arbiters on", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00046-00009957-00010166": "disputes concerning Jewish customs and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00047-00010167-00010352": "law on the one hand", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00048-00010353-00010545": "Luke portrays the Christians as a sect", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00049-00010546-00010734": "of the Jews and therefore entitled to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00050-00010735-00010895": "legal protection as a recognized", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00051-00010896-00011127": "religion on the other Luke seems unclear", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00052-00011128-00011327": "as to the future God intends for Jews", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00053-00011328-00011492": "and Christians celebrating the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00054-00011493-00011660": "Jewishness of Jesus and his immediate", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00055-00011661-00011859": "followers while also stressing how the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00056-00011860-00012391": "Jews had rejected God's promised Messiah", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00057-00012392-00012965": "topic composition and setting", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00058-00012966-00013332": "topic", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00059-00013333-00013611": "topic title unity of Luke acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00060-00013612-00014052": "authorship and date", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00061-00014053-00014435": "topic the title Acts of the Apostles", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00062-00014436-00014712": "Greek praxis apostille and praxis", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00063-00014713-00014952": "apostolate was first used by Irenaeus in", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00064-00014953-00015222": "the late 2nd century it is not known", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00065-00015222-00015413": "whether this was an existing title or", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00066-00015415-00015627": "one invented by Irenaeus it does seem", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00067-00015628-00015837": "clear however that it was not given by", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00068-00015838-00016032": "the author the Gospel of Luke and acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00069-00016033-00016238": "make up a two-volume work which scholars", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00070-00016240-00016565": "call Luke acts together they account for", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00071-00016566-00016875": "27.5% of the New Testament the largest", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00072-00016876-00017067": "contribution attributed to a single", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00073-00017068-00017256": "author providing the framework for both", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00074-00017257-00017460": "the church's liturgical calendar and the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00075-00017461-00017643": "historical outline into which later", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00076-00017644-00017829": "generations have fitted their idea of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00077-00017830-00018021": "the story of Jesus in the early church", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00078-00018022-00018336": "the author is not named in either volume", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00079-00018337-00018555": "according to church tradition dating", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00080-00018556-00018786": "from the 2nd century he was the Luke", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00081-00018787-00019062": "named as a companion of the Apostle Paul", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00082-00019063-00019247": "in three of the letters attributed to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00083-00019248-00019422": "Paul himself this view is still", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00084-00019423-00019656": "sometimes advanced but a critical", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00085-00019657-00019866": "consensus emphasizes the countless", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00086-00019867-00020082": "contradictions between the account in", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00087-00020083-00020292": "Acts and the authentic Pauline letters", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00088-00020293-00020667": "an example can be seen by comparing ax s", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00089-00020668-00020952": "accounts of Paul s conversion Acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00090-00020953-00021419": "chapter 9 verses 1 to 31 22 - 6 - 21 and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00091-00021420-00021837": "26 - 9 - 23 with Paul s own statement", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00092-00021838-00022022": "that he remained unknown to Christians", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00093-00022023-00022253": "in Judea after that event galatians", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00094-00022254-00022644": "chapter 1 verses 17 to 24 the author is", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00095-00022645-00022878": "an admirer of paul but does not share", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00096-00022879-00023228": "paul s own view of himself as an apostle", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00097-00023229-00023439": "his own theology is considerably", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00098-00023440-00023709": "different from paul s on key points and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00099-00023710-00023991": "does not represent paul s own views", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00100-00023992-00024291": "accurately quote he was educated a man", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00101-00024292-00024522": "of memes probably urban and someone who", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00102-00024523-00024702": "respected manual work although not a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00103-00024703-00024909": "worker himself this is significant", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00104-00024910-00025083": "because more highbrow writers of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00105-00025084-00025242": "time looked down on the artisans and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00106-00025243-00025413": "small businesspeople who made up the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00107-00025414-00025608": "early church of Paul and were presumably", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00108-00025608-00025893": "Luke s audience while no proposed date", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00109-00025894-00026078": "for the composition of Acts is", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00110-00026079-00026313": "universally accepted the most common", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00111-00026314-00026562": "scholarly position as to date Luke acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00112-00026563-00026718": "to 80 to 90 AD", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00113-00026719-00026927": "on the grounds that it uses mark as a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00114-00026928-00027150": "source looks back on the destruction of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00115-00027151-00027333": "Jerusalem and does not show any", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00116-00027333-00027426": "awareness of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00117-00027427-00027645": "letters of Paul which began circulating", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00118-00027645-00027951": "late in the first century the earliest", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00119-00027952-00028170": "possible date for the composition of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00120-00028170-00028383": "Acts as set by the events with which it", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00121-00028383-00028845": "ends Paul s imprisonment in Rome C 0.63", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00122-00028845-00029039": "ad but such an early dating is a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00123-00029041-00029349": "minority position the last possible date", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00124-00029350-00029520": "would be set by its first definite", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00125-00029520-00029730": "citation by another author but there is", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00126-00029731-00029958": "no unanimity on this some scholars find", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00127-00029958-00030306": "echoes of Acts in to work from C 95 ad", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00128-00030307-00030513": "called I Clement while others see no", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00129-00030514-00030720": "indisputable citation until the middle", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00130-00030720-00030975": "of the second century a minority of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00131-00030976-00031212": "scholars necessarily in the latter camp", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00132-00031213-00031407": "conclude that act dates to the second", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00133-00031408-00031557": "century believing that it shows", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00134-00031558-00031743": "awareness of the letters of Paul the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00135-00031744-00031938": "works of Josephus or the writings of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00136-00031939-00032264": "Marcion", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00137-00032264-00032777": "topic manuscripts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00138-00032778-00033110": "topic there are two major textual", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00139-00033111-00033323": "variants of Acts the Western text type", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00140-00033324-00033593": "in the Alexandrian the oldest complete", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00141-00033594-00033815": "Alexandrian manuscripts date from the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00142-00033816-00034001": "fourth century and the oldest Western", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00143-00034002-00034196": "ones from the 6th with fragments and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00144-00034197-00034496": "citations going back to the 3rd Western", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00145-00034497-00034868": "texts of Acts our 6.2 28.4% longer than", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00146-00034869-00035105": "Alexandrian texts the editions tending", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00147-00035106-00035282": "to enhance the Jewish rejection of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00148-00035283-00035483": "Messiah and the role of the Holy Spirit", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00149-00035484-00035654": "in ways that are stylistically different", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00150-00035655-00035930": "from the rest of Acts the majority of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00151-00035931-00036164": "scholars prefer the Alexandrian shorter", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00152-00036165-00036356": "text type over the Western as the more", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00153-00036357-00036539": "authentic but this same argument would", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00154-00036540-00036743": "favor the Western over the Alexandrian", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00155-00036744-00036935": "for the Gospel of Luke as in that case", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00156-00036936-00037124": "the Western version is the shorter the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00157-00037125-00037546": "debate therefore continues", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00158-00037547-00038254": "topic genre sources and historicism acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00159-00038255-00038634": "topic the title Acts of the Apostles", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00160-00038635-00038887": "prac C's apostolate would seem to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00161-00038888-00039073": "identify it with the genre telling of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00162-00039074-00039244": "the deeds and achievements of great men", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00163-00039245-00039481": "praxis but it was not the title given by", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00164-00039482-00039748": "the author the anonymous author aligned", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00165-00039749-00040078": "Luke acts to the narratives diet Jesus", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00166-00040079-00040291": "diet Jesus which many others had written", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00167-00040292-00040531": "and described his own work as an orderly", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00168-00040532-00040873": "account akribos calyxes thus while acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00169-00040874-00041062": "as widely thought of as a history", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00170-00041063-00041269": "it lacks exact analogies in Hellenistic", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00171-00041270-00041497": "or Jewish literature the author of Acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00172-00041498-00041704": "may have taken as his model the works of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00173-00041705-00041920": "dionysius of halicarnassus who wrote a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00174-00041921-00042124": "well known history of Rome or the Jewish", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00175-00042125-00042370": "historian Josephus author of a history", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00176-00042371-00042631": "of the Jews like them he anchors his", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00177-00042632-00042790": "history by dating the birth of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00178-00042791-00042844": "founder", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00179-00042845-00043114": "Romulus for Dionysus Moses for Josephus", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00180-00043115-00043306": "Jesus for Luke and like them he tells", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00181-00043307-00043495": "how the founder is born from God taught", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00182-00043496-00043654": "authoritative Lee and appeared to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00183-00043655-00043831": "witnesses after death before ascending", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00184-00043832-00044116": "to heaven by and large the sources for", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00185-00044117-00044281": "acts can only be guessed at but the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00186-00044282-00044437": "author would have had access to the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00187-00044438-00044638": "Septuagint a Greek translation of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00188-00044639-00044857": "Jewish Scriptures the Gospel of Mark and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00189-00044858-00045025": "either the hypothetical collection of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00190-00045026-00045355": "sayings of Jesus called the Q source or", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00191-00045356-00045598": "the Gospel of Matthew he transposed a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00192-00045599-00045865": "few incidents from mark s gospel to the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00193-00045866-00045994": "time of the Apostles", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00194-00045995-00046306": "for example the material about clean and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00195-00046307-00046600": "unclean foods in mark 7 is used in acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00196-00046601-00046975": "10 and Mark s account of the accusation", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00197-00046976-00047170": "that Jesus has attacked the temple mark", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00198-00047171-00047467": "chapter 14 verse 58 is used in a story", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00199-00047468-00047733": "about Stephen Acts chapter 6 verse 14", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00200-00047734-00048001": "there are also points of contacts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00201-00048002-00048184": "meaning suggestive parallels but", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00202-00048185-00048373": "something less than clear evidence with", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00203-00048374-00048559": "first Peter the letter to the Hebrews", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00204-00048560-00048865": "and 1 clement other sources can only be", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00205-00048866-00049078": "inferred from internal evidence the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00206-00049079-00049350": "traditional explanation of the three we", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00207-00049351-00049585": "passages for example is that they", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00208-00049586-00049852": "represent eyewitness accounts the search", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00209-00049853-00050068": "for such inferred sources was popular in", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00210-00050069-00050269": "the nineteenth century but by the mid", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00211-00050270-00050461": "twentieth it had largely been abandoned", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00212-00050462-00050671": "Acts was read as a reliable history of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00213-00050672-00050827": "the early church well into the post", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00214-00050828-00051088": "Reformation era by the 17th century", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00215-00051089-00051343": "however biblical scholars began to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00216-00051344-00051496": "notice that it was incomplete and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00217-00051497-00051622": "tendentious he", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00218-00051623-00051820": "picture of a harmonious church has quite", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00219-00051821-00052012": "at odds with that given by Paul s", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00220-00052013-00052276": "letters and it omits important events", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00221-00052277-00052453": "such as the deaths of both Peter and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00222-00052454-00052842": "Paul the mid-19th century scholar", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00223-00052844-00053083": "ferdinand bauer suggested that the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00224-00053084-00053320": "author of Acts had rewritten history to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00225-00053321-00053551": "present a United Peter and Paul and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00226-00053552-00053791": "advance a single orthodoxy against the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00227-00053791-00053878": "márcia Knights", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00228-00053879-00054139": "Marcion was a second century heretic who", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00229-00054140-00054349": "wished to cut Christianity off entirely", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00230-00054350-00054673": "from the Jews Bauer continues to have", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00231-00054674-00054891": "enormous influence but today there is", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00232-00054892-00055087": "less interest in determining the author", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00233-00055088-00055438": "of Acts historical accuracy although", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00234-00055439-00055582": "this has never died out than in", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00235-00055583-00056057": "understanding his theological program", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00236-00056058-00056641": "topic audience and authorial intent", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00237-00056642-00056951": "topic Luke was written to be read aloud", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00238-00056952-00057166": "to a group of Jesus followers gathered", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00239-00057167-00057398": "in a house to share the Lord s supper", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00240-00057399-00057653": "the author assumes an educated Greek", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00241-00057654-00057863": "speaking audience but directs his", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00242-00057864-00058066": "attention to specifically Christian", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00243-00058067-00058259": "concerns rather than to the greco-roman", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00244-00058260-00058622": "world at large he begins his gospel with", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00245-00058623-00058816": "a preface addressed to Theophilus", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00246-00058817-00059015": "informing him of his intention to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00247-00059016-00059228": "provide an ordered account of events", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00248-00059229-00059425": "which will lead his reader to certainty", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00249-00059426-00059696": "he did not write in order to provide", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00250-00059697-00059980": "Theophilus with historical justification", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00251-00059982-00060275": "did it happen but to encourage faith", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00252-00060276-00060509": "what happened and what does it all mean", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00253-00060510-00060797": "acts or Luke acts is intended as a work", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00254-00060798-00061064": "of edification edification means the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00255-00061065-00061291": "empirical demonstration that virtue is", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00256-00061292-00061579": "superior to Vice but is not all of Luke", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00257-00061579-00061910": "s purpose he also engages with the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00258-00061911-00062080": "question of a Christians proper", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00259-00062082-00062288": "relationship with the Roman Empire the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00260-00062289-00062483": "civil power of the day could a Christian", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00261-00062484-00062657": "obey God and also Caesar", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00262-00062658-00062954": "the answer is ambiguous the Romans never", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00263-00062954-00063128": "move against Jesus or his followers", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00264-00063129-00063365": "unless provoked by the Jews in the trial", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00265-00063366-00063541": "scenes the Christian missionaries are", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00266-00063542-00063710": "always cleared of charges of violating", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00267-00063711-00063965": "Roman laws and acts ends with Paul in", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00268-00063966-00064129": "Rome proclaiming the Christian message", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00269-00064130-00064364": "under Roman protection at the same time", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00270-00064365-00064559": "Luke makes clear that the Romans like", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00271-00064560-00064727": "all earthly rulers receive their", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00272-00064728-00064913": "authority from Satan while Christ is", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00273-00064914-00065430": "ruler of the kingdom of God", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00274-00065432-00065926": "pick structure and content", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00275-00065927-00066294": "topic", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00276-00066295-00066773": "topic structure", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00277-00066774-00067118": "topic ax has two key structural", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00278-00067119-00067367": "principles the first is the geographic", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00279-00067368-00067621": "movement from Jerusalem Center of God s", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00280-00067622-00067889": "covenantal people the Jews to Rome", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00281-00067890-00068171": "center of the Gentile world this", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00282-00068172-00068462": "structure reaches back to the author s", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00283-00068463-00068699": "preceding work the Gospel of Luke and is", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00284-00068700-00068909": "signaled by parallel scenes such as Paul", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00285-00068910-00069290": "s utterance in Acts chapter 19 verse 21", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00286-00069291-00069644": "which echoes Jesus s words in Luke", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00287-00069645-00069833": "chapter 9 verse 51", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00288-00069834-00070025": "Paul has Rome as his destination as", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00289-00070026-00070301": "Jesus had Jerusalem the second key", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00290-00070302-00070490": "element as the roles of Peter and Paul", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00291-00070491-00070670": "the first representing the Jewish", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00292-00070671-00070850": "Christian Church the second the mission", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00293-00070851-00071083": "to the Gentiles", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00294-00071084-00071309": "transition reprieves of the preface", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00295-00071310-00071495": "addressed to Theophilus and the closing", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00296-00071496-00071833": "events of the gospel acts 1 to 126", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00297-00071834-00072104": "p-train christianity the Jewish Church", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00298-00072105-00072365": "from Jerusalem to Antioch Acts chapter 2", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00299-00072366-00072782": "verse 1 - 12 to 25 - 2 1 - 8 - 1", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00300-00072783-00073178": "beginnings in Jerusalem 8 - 2 - 40 the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00301-00073179-00073517": "church expands to say Maria and Beyond 9", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00302-00073518-00073991": "- 1 - 31 conversion of Paul 9:30 - to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00303-00073992-00074276": "1225 the conversion of Cornelius and the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00304-00074277-00074471": "formation of the Antioch church Pauline", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00305-00074472-00074675": "Christianity the Gentile mission from", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00306-00074676-00074936": "Antioch to Rome Acts chapter 13 verse 1", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00307-00074937-00075179": "- 28 - 2113", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00308-00075180-00075506": "- 1 - 14 to 28 the Gentile mission is", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00309-00075507-00075902": "promoted from Antioch 15 to 1 minus 35", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00310-00075903-00076088": "the Gentile mission is confirmed in", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00311-00076089-00076589": "Jerusalem 1536 - 28 to 31 the Gentile", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00312-00076590-00076781": "mission climaxing in Paul's passion", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00313-00076782-00077483": "story in Rome 21 17 - 28 - 31", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00314-00077484-00077975": "topic outline", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00315-00077976-00078490": "topic dedication to Theophilus 1 - 1 - 2", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00316-00078491-00078680": "resurrection appearances", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00317-00078681-00079166": "1 2 3 great commission 1 2 4 - 8", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00318-00079167-00079559": "ascension 1 2 9 second coming prophecy 1", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00319-00079560-00080107": "10 - 11 Matthias replaced Judas 112 - 26", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00320-00080108-00080558": "the upper room 113 the Holy Spirit came", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00321-00080559-00080885": "at siob out Pentecost - 2 1 - 47", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00322-00080886-00081164": "see also Paraclete Peter healed a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00323-00081165-00081557": "crippled beggar 3 2 1 - 10 Peters speech", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00324-00081558-00081968": "at the temple 3 11 - 26 Peter and John", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00325-00081969-00082321": "before the Sanhedrin 4 to 1 minus 22", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00326-00082322-00082591": "resurrection of the Dead 4 - to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00327-00082592-00083075": "believers prayer for 23 - 31 everything", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00328-00083076-00083501": "is shared for 32 - 37 Ananias and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00329-00083502-00083749": "Sapphira 5 - 1 - 11", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00330-00083750-00084230": "signs and wonders 5 12 - 16 apostles", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00331-00084231-00084665": "before the Sanhedrin 517 - 40 - seven", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00332-00084666-00084958": "deacons appointed 6 - 1 - 7", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00333-00084959-00085322": "Stephen before the Sanhedrin 6 - 8 - 7 -", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00334-00085323-00085727": "60 the Cave of the patriarchs was", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00335-00085728-00086111": "located in Shechem 716 Moses was", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00336-00086112-00086303": "educated in all the wisdom of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00337-00086304-00086768": "Egyptians 722 first mentioning of Saul", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00338-00086769-00087173": "Paul the Apostle in the Bible 758 Paul", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00339-00087174-00087380": "the Apostle confesses his part in the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00340-00087381-00087791": "martyrdom of Stephen 758 - 60 Saul", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00341-00087792-00088043": "persecuted the Church of Jerusalem 8 - 1", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00342-00088044-00088528": "- 3 Philip the Evangelist 8 - 4 - 40", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00343-00088529-00089012": "Simon Magus 8 - 9 - 24 Ethiopian eunuch", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00344-00089013-00089459": "8 26 - 39 conversion of Paul the Apostle", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00345-00089460-00089744": "nine to one minus thirty one twenty two", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00346-00089745-00090077": "to one - twenty to twenty six to nine -", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00347-00090078-00090461": "24 Paul the Apostle confesses his active", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00348-00090462-00090733": "part in the martyrdom of Stephen 22 20", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00349-00090734-00091013": "Peter healed Aeneas and raised Tabitha", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00350-00091014-00091433": "from the dead 9:32 - 43 conversion of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00351-00091434-00091919": "Cornelius 10 - 1 - 8 24 to 48 Peter's", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00352-00091920-00092168": "vision of a sheet with animals 10 - 9 -", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00353-00092169-00092512": "twenty-three-eleven - one - 18", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00354-00092513-00092865": "Church of Antioch founded 11 19 - 30", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00355-00092866-00093415": "term Christian first used 11:26 James", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00356-00093416-00093826": "the great executed 12 - 1 - - Peters", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00357-00093827-00094249": "rescue from prison 12 - 3 - 19 death of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00358-00094250-00094747": "Herod Agrippa I in 4412 20-25 the voice", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00359-00094748-00095212": "of a god 12:22 mission of Barnabas and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00360-00095213-00095394": "Saul 13 - 14", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00361-00095395-00095874": "Saul who is also known as Paul 13 to 9", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00362-00095875-00096193": "called God's", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00363-00096194-00096675": "in human form 14:11 Council of Jerusalem", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00364-00096676-00096948": "15 to 1 - 35", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00365-00096949-00097458": "Paul separated from Barnabas 15:36 - 41", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00366-00097459-00097830": "second and third missions 16 to 20", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00367-00097831-00098566": "Areopagus sermon 1716 - 34 God dot has", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00368-00098567-00099064": "said a day 17 30 - 31 trial before", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00369-00099065-00099685": "galley OC 51 to 52 1812 - 17 trip to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00370-00099686-00100027": "Jerusalem 21 before the people and the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00371-00100028-00100477": "Sanhedrin 22 to 23 before Felix Festus", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00372-00100478-00100900": "Herod Agrippa to 24 to 26 trip to Rome", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00373-00100901-00101695": "27 to 28 call to God on Malta 28 to 6", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00374-00101696-00102175": "topic content", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00375-00102176-00102523": "topic the Gospel of Luke began with a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00376-00102524-00102717": "prologue addressed at the Ovilus acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00377-00102718-00102906": "likewise opens with an address to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00378-00102907-00103179": "Theophilus and refers to my earlier book", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00379-00103180-00103578": "almost certainly the gospel the Apostles", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00380-00103579-00103777": "and other followers of Jesus meet and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00381-00103778-00103972": "elect Matthias to replace Judas as a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00382-00103973-00104253": "member of the twelve on Pentecost the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00383-00104254-00104497": "Holy Spirit descends and confers God s", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00384-00104498-00104773": "power on them and Peter along with John", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00385-00104774-00105003": "preaches to many in Jerusalem and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00386-00105004-00105256": "performs christ-like healings casting", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00387-00105257-00105457": "out of evil spirits and raising of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00388-00105458-00105741": "dead the first believers share all", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00389-00105742-00106096": "property in common aid in each other s", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00390-00106097-00106348": "homes and worshiped together at first", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00391-00106349-00106588": "many Jews follow Christ and are baptized", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00392-00106589-00106744": "but the Christians begin to be", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00393-00106745-00106961": "increasingly persecuted by the Jews", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00394-00106963-00107224": "Stephen is arrested for blasphemy and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00395-00107225-00107452": "after a trial is found guilty and stoned", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00396-00107453-00107784": "by the Jews Stephen s death marks a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00397-00107785-00107983": "major turning point the Jews have", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00398-00107983-00108204": "rejected the message and henceforth it", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00399-00108205-00108390": "will be taken to the Gentiles the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00400-00108391-00108615": "message is taken to the Samaritans a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00401-00108616-00108840": "people rejected by Jews and to the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00402-00108841-00109207": "Gentiles Saul of Tarsus one of the Jews", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00403-00109208-00109399": "who persecuted the Christians is", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00404-00109400-00109594": "converted by a vision to become a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00405-00109595-00109831": "follower of Christ an event which Luke", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00406-00109832-00110050": "regards is so important that he relates", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00407-00110051-00110358": "it three times Peter directed by a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00408-00110359-00110620": "series of visions preaches to Cornelius", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00409-00110621-00110896": "the Centurion a Gentile God Fuhrer who", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00410-00110897-00111193": "becomes a follower of Christ the Holy", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00411-00111194-00111408": "Spirit descends on Peter and Cornelius", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00412-00111409-00111643": "thus confirming that the message of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00413-00111644-00111844": "eternal life in Christ is for all", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00414-00111845-00112128": "mankind the Gentile church is", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00415-00112129-00112363": "established in Antioch northwestern", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00416-00112364-00112590": "Syria the third-largest city of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00417-00112591-00112965": "Empire and here Christ s followers are", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00418-00112966-00113152": "first called Christians the mission to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00419-00113153-00113353": "the Gentiles is promoted from Antioch", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00420-00113354-00113548": "and confirmed at meeting in Jerusalem", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00421-00113549-00113722": "between Paul and the leadership of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00422-00113723-00114001": "Jerusalem church Paul spends the next", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00423-00114002-00114183": "few years travelling through Western", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00424-00114184-00114382": "Asia Minor in the Aegean preaching", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00425-00114383-00114591": "converting Gentiles and founding new", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00426-00114592-00114889": "churches on a visit to Jerusalem he is", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00427-00114890-00115153": "set on by a Jewish mob saved by the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00428-00115154-00115345": "Roman commander he is accused by the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00429-00115346-00115554": "Jews of being a revolutionary", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00430-00115555-00115720": "ringleader of the sect of the Nazarenes", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00431-00115721-00116088": "and imprisoned Paul asserts his right as", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00432-00116089-00116313": "a Roman citizen to be tried in Rome and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00433-00116314-00116514": "is sent by sea to Rome where he spends", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00434-00116515-00116647": "another two years under house arrest", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00435-00116648-00116869": "proclaiming the kingdom of God and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00436-00116870-00117216": "teaching the Lord Jesus Christ Acts ends", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00437-00117217-00117406": "abruptly without recording the outcome", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00438-00117407-00117833": "of Paul's legal troubles", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00439-00117833-00118355": "topic theology", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00440-00118356-00118706": "topic prior to the 1950s", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00441-00118707-00118907": "Luke ax was seen as a historical work", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00442-00118908-00119096": "written to defend Christianity before", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00443-00119097-00119255": "the Romans or Paul against his", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00444-00119256-00119458": "detractors since then however the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00445-00119459-00119633": "tendency has been to see the work as", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00446-00119633-00119945": "primarily theological Luke's theology as", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00447-00119946-00120101": "expressed primarily through his", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00448-00120102-00120310": "overarching plot the way seems themes", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00449-00120311-00120500": "and characters combined to construct his", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00450-00120501-00120889": "specific worldview his salvation history", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00451-00120890-00121091": "stretches from the creation to the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00452-00121092-00121277": "present time of his readers in three", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00453-00121278-00121526": "ages first the time of the law and the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00454-00121527-00121907": "prophets Luke chapter 16 verse 16 the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00455-00121908-00122117": "period beginning with Genesis and ending", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00456-00122118-00122255": "with the appearance of John the Baptist", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00457-00122256-00122659": "Luke chapter 1 verse 5 - 3 - 1 second", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00458-00122660-00122867": "the epoch of Jesus in which the kingdom", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00459-00122868-00123101": "of God was preached Luke chapter 3 verse", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00460-00123102-00123464": "2 - 24 - 51 and finally the period of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00461-00123465-00123644": "the church which began when the risen", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00462-00123645-00123824": "Christ was taken into heaven and would", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00463-00123825-00123941": "end with his second coming", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00464-00123942-00124193": "Luke acts as an attempt to answer a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00465-00124194-00124388": "theological problem namely how the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00466-00124389-00124589": "Messiah promised to the Jews came to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00467-00124590-00124781": "have an overwhelmingly non-jewish church", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00468-00124782-00124997": "the answer it provides and its central", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00469-00124998-00125195": "theme is that the message of Christ was", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00470-00125196-00125369": "sent to the Gentiles because the Jews", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00471-00125370-00125642": "rejected it this theme is introduced at", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00472-00125643-00125831": "the opening of the Gospel of Luke when", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00473-00125832-00126061": "Jesus rejected in Nazareth recalls that", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00474-00126063-00126272": "the prophets were rejected by Israel and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00475-00126273-00126479": "accepted by Gentiles at the end of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00476-00126480-00126668": "gospel he commands his disciples to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00477-00126669-00126797": "preach his message to all nations", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00478-00126798-00127121": "beginning from Jerusalem he repeats the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00479-00127122-00127304": "command in acts telling them to preach", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00480-00127305-00127577": "in Jerusalem in all Judea and Samaria", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00481-00127578-00127919": "and to the end of the earth they then", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00482-00127920-00128129": "proceeded to do so in the order outlined", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00483-00128130-00128375": "first Jerusalem then Judea then say", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00484-00128376-00128597": "Maria then the entire Roman world for", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00485-00128598-00128785": "Luke the Holy Spirit as the driving", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00486-00128786-00128963": "force behind the spread of the Christian", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00487-00128964-00129160": "message and he places more emphasis on", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00488-00129161-00129347": "it than do any of the other evangelists", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00489-00129348-00129743": "the spiritus poured out at Pentecost on", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00490-00129744-00129917": "the first Samaritan and Gentile", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00491-00129918-00130115": "believers and on disciples who had been", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00492-00130116-00130340": "baptized only by John the Baptist each", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00493-00130341-00130640": "time as a sign of God s approval the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00494-00130641-00130991": "Holy Spirit represents God s power at", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00495-00130992-00131183": "his ascension Jesus tells his followers", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00496-00131184-00131450": "you shall receive power when the Holy", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00497-00131451-00131693": "Spirit has come upon you", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00498-00131694-00131866": "through it the disciples are given", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00499-00131867-00132085": "speech to convert thousands in Jerusalem", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00500-00132086-00132269": "forming the first church the term is", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00501-00132270-00132487": "used for the first time in acts five one", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00502-00132488-00132673": "issue debated by scholars as Luke's", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00503-00132674-00132823": "political vision regarding the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00504-00132824-00132995": "relationship between the early church", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00505-00132996-00133252": "and the Roman Empire on the one hand", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00506-00133253-00133441": "luke generally does not portray this", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00507-00133442-00133650": "interaction as one of direct conflict", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00508-00133651-00133903": "rather there are ways in which each may", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00509-00133904-00134038": "have considered having a relationship", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00510-00134039-00134258": "with the other rather advantageous to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00511-00134259-00134521": "its own cause for example early", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00512-00134522-00134713": "Christians may have appreciated hearing", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00513-00134714-00134911": "about the protection Paul received from", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00514-00134912-00135136": "Roman officials against Gentile rioters", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00515-00135137-00135436": "in Philippi Acts chapter 16 verses 16 to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00516-00135437-00135760": "40 in Ephesus Acts chapter 19 verses 23", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00517-00135761-00136046": "to 41 and against Jewish rioters on two", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00518-00136047-00136372": "occasions Acts chapter 17 verses 1 to 17", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00519-00136373-00136665": "Acts chapter 18 verses 12 to 17", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00520-00136666-00136895": "meanwhile Roman readers may have", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00521-00136896-00137050": "approved of Paul's censure of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00522-00137051-00137233": "illegal practice of magic Acts chapter", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00523-00137234-00137558": "19 verses 17 to 19 as well as the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00524-00137559-00137761": "amicability of his rapport with Roman", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00525-00137762-00137971": "officials such as Sergius Paulus Acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00526-00137972-00138262": "chapter 13 verses 6 to 12 and Festus", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00527-00138263-00138585": "Acts chapter 26 verses 30 to 32", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00528-00138586-00138821": "furthermore Acts does not include any", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00529-00138822-00139015": "account of a struggle between Christians", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00530-00139016-00139198": "and the Roman government as a result of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00531-00139199-00139346": "the latter's imperial cult", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00532-00139347-00139612": "thus Paul is depicted as a moderating", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00533-00139613-00139769": "presence between the church and the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00534-00139770-00140002": "Roman Empire on the other hand events", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00535-00140003-00140188": "such as the imprisonment of Paul at the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00536-00140189-00140485": "hands of the Empire acts 22 to 28 as", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00537-00140486-00140686": "well as several encounters that reflect", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00538-00140687-00140875": "negatively on Roman officials for", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00539-00140876-00141103": "instance Felix's desire for a bribe from", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00540-00141104-00141391": "Paul in Acts chapter 24 verse 26", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00541-00141392-00141604": "function as concrete points of conflict", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00542-00141605-00141881": "between Rome in the early church perhaps", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00543-00141882-00142048": "the most significant point of tension", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00544-00142049-00142288": "between Roman Imperial ideology and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00545-00142289-00142486": "Luke's political vision as reflected in", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00546-00142487-00142662": "Peters speech to the Roman centurion", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00547-00142663-00143074": "Cornelius Acts chapter 10 verse 36 Peter", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00548-00143075-00143468": "states that this one who doze ie Jesus", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00549-00143469-00143860": "his lord kurios of all the title kurios", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00550-00143861-00144068": "was often ascribed to the Roman Emperor", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00551-00144069-00144281": "in antiquity rendering its use by Luke", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00552-00144282-00144490": "as an appellation for Jesus and unsubtle", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00553-00144491-00144657": "challenge to the Emperor's Authority", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00554-00144658-00144910": "thus while the overt relationship", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00555-00144911-00145082": "between Christianity and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00556-00145083-00145271": "in the book of Acts can generally be", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00557-00145272-00145502": "characterized as irenic Luke insinuates", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00558-00145503-00145682": "the inevitability of conflict between", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00559-00145683-00145868": "the two over the issue of ultimate", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00560-00145869-00146273": "allegiance", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00561-00146274-00146834": "topic comparison with other writings", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00562-00146835-00147197": "topic", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00563-00147198-00147704": "topic Gospel of Luke", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00564-00147705-00148061": "topic as the second part of the two-part", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00565-00148062-00148316": "work Luke axe axe has significant links", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00566-00148317-00148580": "to the Gospel of Luke major turning", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00567-00148581-00148751": "points in the structure of axe for", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00568-00148752-00148964": "example find parallels in Luke the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00569-00148965-00149171": "presentation of the Child Jesus in the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00570-00149172-00149387": "temple parallels the opening of acts in", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00571-00149388-00149627": "the temple Jesus's forty days of testing", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00572-00149628-00149780": "in the wilderness prior to his mission", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00573-00149781-00149990": "paralleled the forty days prior to his", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00574-00149991-00150161": "ascension in Acts the mission of Jesus", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00575-00150162-00150398": "in Saint Maria and the Decapolis the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00576-00150399-00150590": "lands of the Samaritans and Gentiles", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00577-00150591-00150785": "parallels the missions of the Apostles", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00578-00150786-00150986": "in st. Maria and the Gentile lands and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00579-00150987-00151301": "so on see Gospel of Luke these parallels", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00580-00151302-00151502": "continue through both books there are", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00581-00151503-00151715": "also differences between Luke and acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00582-00151716-00151895": "amounting at times to outright", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00583-00151896-00152186": "contradiction for example the gospel", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00584-00152187-00152369": "seems to place the Ascension on Easter", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00585-00152370-00152414": "Sunday", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00586-00152415-00152618": "immediately after the resurrection while", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00587-00152619-00152906": "acts 1 puts it 40 days later there are", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00588-00152907-00153104": "similar conflicts over the theology", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00589-00153105-00153329": "while not seriously questioning the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00590-00153330-00153515": "single authorship of Luke acts these", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00591-00153516-00153680": "differences do suggest the need for", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00592-00153681-00153911": "caution in seeking to much consistency", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00593-00153912-00154097": "in books written in essence as popular", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00594-00154098-00154428": "literature", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00595-00154429-00154960": "topic Pauline epistles", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00596-00154961-00155392": "topic ax agrees with Paul s letters on", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00597-00155393-00155716": "the major outline of Paul s career he is", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00598-00155717-00155896": "converted and becomes a Christian", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00599-00155897-00156118": "missionary and apostle establishing new", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00600-00156119-00156337": "churches in Asia Minor in the Aegean and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00601-00156338-00156511": "struggling to free Gentile Christians", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00602-00156512-00156622": "from the Jewish law", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00603-00156623-00156835": "there are also agreements on many", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00604-00156836-00157108": "incidents such as Paul s escape from", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00605-00157109-00157324": "Damascus where he has lowered down the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00606-00157325-00157636": "walls in a basket but details of these", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00607-00157637-00157858": "same incidents are frequently seen as", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00608-00157859-00158101": "contradictory for example according to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00609-00158102-00158341": "Paul it was a pagan king who was trying", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00610-00158342-00158581": "to arrest him in Damascus but according", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00611-00158582-00158764": "to Luke it was the Jews second", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00612-00158765-00159064": "Corinthians chapter 11 verse 33 in Acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00613-00159065-00159445": "chapter 9 verse 24 act speaks of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00614-00159446-00159706": "Christians and disciples but Paul never", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00615-00159707-00159934": "uses either term and it is striking that", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00616-00159935-00160180": "Acts never brings Paul into conflict", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00617-00160181-00160396": "with the Jerusalem church and places", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00618-00160397-00160564": "Paul under the authority of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00619-00160565-00160753": "Jerusalem church and its leaders", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00620-00160754-00161101": "especially James and Peter acts 15 vs.", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00621-00161102-00161467": "Galatians chapter 2 acts omits much from", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00622-00161468-00161794": "the letters notably Paul s problems with", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00623-00161795-00161986": "his congregations internal difficulties", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00624-00161987-00162157": "are said to be the fault of the Jews", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00625-00162158-00162346": "instead and his apparent final rejection", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00626-00162347-00162589": "by the church leaders in Jerusalem acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00627-00162590-00162829": "as Paul and Barnabas deliver an offering", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00628-00162830-00163018": "that is accepted a trip that has no", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00629-00163019-00163258": "mention in the letters there are also", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00630-00163259-00163462": "alleged major differences between Acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00631-00163463-00163636": "and Paul on Christology the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00632-00163637-00163798": "understanding of Christ's nature", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00633-00163799-00164068": "eschatology understanding of that last", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00634-00164069-00164591": "things an Apostleship", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00635-00164592-00165107": "topic C also", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00636-00165108-00165586": "topic acts of the apostles genre less", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00637-00165587-00166019": "acts daya potter's list of gospels list", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00638-00166020-00166334": "of omitted bible verses the lost chapter", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00639-00166335-00166493": "of the Acts of the Apostles", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00640-00166494-00166747": "also known as the sunny me manuscript", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00641-00166748-00166963": "textual variants in the Acts of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00642-00166964-00167266": "Apostles Holy Spirit in the Acts of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00643-00167267-00167641": "Apostles", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00644-00167642-00168186": "topic references", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00645-00168187-00168571": "topic", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00646-00168572-00169113": "topic bibliography", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00647-00169114-00169608": "topic Allen Oh Wesley junior 2009 Luke", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00648-00169609-00169974": "in Peterson David el-oued a male our", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00649-00169975-00170307": "theological Bible Commentary Westminster", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00650-00170308-00170741": "John Knox press ISBN nine trillion 781", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00651-00170742-00170976": "billion six hundred eleven million six", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00652-00170977-00171132": "hundred forty thousand three hundred", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00653-00171133-00171629": "four found a vide 1988 the New Testament", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00654-00171630-00171882": "in its literary environment Westminster", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00655-00171883-00172229": "John Knox press ISBN nine trillion seven", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00656-00172230-00172368": "hundred eighty billion two hundred", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00657-00172369-00172632": "twenty seven million six hundred seventy", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00658-00172633-00172926": "nine thousand one hundred four Bouch", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00659-00172927-00173441": "david l 2003 Luke in Dunn James DG", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00660-00173442-00173670": "Rogerson John William eerdmans", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00661-00173671-00173838": "commentary on the Bible", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00662-00173839-00174285": "eerdmans ISBN nine trillion 780 billion", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00663-00174286-00174428": "eight hundred two million eight hundred", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00664-00174429-00174822": "thirty seven thousand 110 boring M", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00665-00174823-00175125": "Eugene 2012 an introduction to the New", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00666-00175126-00175429": "Testament history literature theology", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00667-00175430-00175626": "Westminster John Knox press", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00668-00175627-00175932": "ISBN nine trillion seven hundred eighty", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00669-00175933-00176151": "billion six hundred sixty-four million", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00670-00176152-00176889": "250 5923 Bruce F F 1990 the Acts of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00671-00176890-00177060": "Apostles the Greek text with", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00672-00177061-00177213": "introduction and commentary", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00673-00177214-00177573": "eerdmans ISBN nine seven eight oh eight", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00674-00177574-00177975": "oh two eight oh nine 667 Buckwalter", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00675-00177976-00178328": "Douglas 1996 the character and purpose", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00676-00178329-00178557": "of Luke's Christology cambridge", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00677-00178558-00178853": "university press ISBN nine trillion", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00678-00178854-00179196": "seven hundred eighty billion 521 million", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00679-00179197-00179400": "five hundred sixty one thousand eight", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00680-00179401-00179779": "hundred eight Burkett Delbert 2002 an", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00681-00179780-00179994": "introduction to the New Testament and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00682-00179995-00180234": "the origins of Christianity cambridge", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00683-00180235-00180690": "university press ISBN 978 oh five to 100", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00684-00180691-00181122": "seven 207 Charlie's worth James H two", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00685-00181123-00181374": "thousand eight the historical Jesus an", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00686-00181375-00181737": "essential guide Abington press ISBN nine", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00687-00181738-00182010": "trillion 781 billion four hundred", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00688-00182011-00182256": "twenty-six million seven hundred twenty", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00689-00182257-00182516": "four thousand seven hundred fifty-six", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00690-00182517-00182990": "Evans Craig a 2011 Luke Baker books ISBN", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00691-00182991-00183458": "nine trillion 780 1 billion 441 million", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00692-00183459-00183866": "two hundred thirty six thousand 524 fits", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00693-00183867-00184250": "mere Joseph a 1998 the anchor Bible the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00694-00184251-00184466": "Acts of the Apostles a new translation", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00695-00184467-00184660": "with introduction and commentary", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00696-00184661-00184994": "doubleday ISBN nine seven eight oh three", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00697-00184995-00185293": "eight five four nine oh two oh seven", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00698-00185294-00185684": "Gooding David 2013 true to the faith the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00699-00185685-00185873": "Acts of the Apostles defining and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00700-00185874-00186143": "defending the gospel myrtle Fieldhouse", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00701-00186144-00186545": "green Joel 1995 the theology of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00702-00186546-00186635": "Gospel of Luke", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00703-00186636-00186991": "Cambridge University Press Green Joel", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00704-00186992-00187247": "1997 the Gospel of Luke", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00705-00187248-00187568": "eerdmans holiday Karl our 2011 a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00706-00187569-00187760": "critical introduction to the New", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00707-00187761-00187958": "Testament interpreting the message and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00708-00187959-00188240": "meaning of Jesus Christ Abington Press", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00709-00188241-00188615": "Keener Craig Gass 2012 act an exegetical", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00710-00188616-00188978": "commentary volume 1 introduction and 1-2", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00711-00188979-00189410": "1-2 247 Baker academic Matthews", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00712-00189411-00189677": "Christopher our 2011 Acts of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00713-00189678-00189977": "Apostles in Coogan Michael D the Oxford", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00714-00189978-00190187": "encyclopedia of the books of the Bible", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00715-00190188-00190448": "Oxford University Press Parsons mikheil", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00716-00190449-00190844": "C 1993 rethinking the unity of Luke and", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00717-00190845-00191246": "acts fortress press Perkins Fay May 1998", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00718-00191247-00191501": "the synoptic Gospels and the Acts of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00719-00191502-00191746": "Apostles telling the Christian story in", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00720-00191747-00192044": "Barton John the Cambridge companion to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00721-00192045-00192293": "biblical interpretation Westminster John", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00722-00192294-00192386": "Knox press", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00723-00192387-00192713": "ISBN nine seven eight oh five to one", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00724-00192714-00192937": "four eight five nine three seven", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00725-00192938-00193370": "Phillips Thomas II 2009 Paul his letters", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00726-00193371-00193697": "and acts Baker academic Pickett Raymond", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00727-00193698-00194021": "2011 Luke and Empire and introduction in", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00728-00194022-00194126": "Rhodes", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00729-00194127-00194516": "David esterline David Lee jae-won Luke", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00730-00194517-00194729": "acts and Empire essays in honour of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00731-00194730-00195056": "Robert L Brawley Wipf and stock", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00732-00195057-00195428": "publishers Powell mark Alan 2018", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00733-00195429-00195617": "introducing the New Testament a", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00734-00195618-00195845": "historical literary and theological", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00735-00195846-00195902": "survey", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00736-00195903-00196358": "2nd ed Baker academic row C Kevin 2005", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00737-00196359-00196634": "Luke acts in the imperial cult away", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00738-00196635-00196841": "through the conundrum journal for the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00739-00196842-00197314": "study of the New Testament 27 3 279 to", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00740-00197315-00197726": "300,000 gird MERS and at 1998 the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00741-00197727-00197963": "historical Jesus a comprehensive guide", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00742-00197964-00198374": "eerdmans Thompson Richard P 2010 Luke", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00743-00198375-00198581": "acts the Gospel of Luke and the Acts of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00744-00198582-00198845": "the Apostles a noun David either", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00745-00198846-00199126": "Blackwell companion to the New Testament", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00746-00199127-00199472": "wiley-blackwell Witherington Ben 1998", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00747-00199473-00199718": "the Acts of the Apostles a socio", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00748-00199719-00199871": "rhetorical commentary", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00749-00199872-00200303": "eerdmans sweep re w 2010 Christ the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00750-00200304-00200537": "spirit and a community of God essays on", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00751-00200538-00200810": "the Acts of the Apostles more Seebeck", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00752-00200811-00201059": "topic external links topic a brief", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00753-00201060-00201272": "introduction to Luke Acts book of Acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00754-00201273-00201590": "at Bible gateway NIV and KJV Tertullian", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00755-00201591-00201815": "org the Western text of the Acts of the", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00756-00201816-00202310": "Apostles 1923 JM Wilson DD texts on", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00757-00202311-00202652": "wikisource Breen Andrew Edward 1913 Acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00758-00202653-00202940": "of the Apostles Catholic Encyclopedia", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00759-00202941-00203321": "Honorine C 1913 Gospel of st. Luke", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00760-00203322-00203681": "Catholic Encyclopedia c section v st.", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00761-00203682-00203993": "Luke's accuracy Acts of the Apostles new", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00762-00203994-00204362": "international encyclopedia 1905 Acts of", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00763-00204363-00204443": "the Apostles", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00764-00204444-00204946": "the American cyclopædia 1879 Bible Acts", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00765-00204948-00205171": "public domain audiobook at LibriVox", "TKCToPZ-ydo-00766-00205173-00205454": "various versions"}}, {"audio_id": "TKD1MLjUc68", "text": {"TKD1MLjUc68-00000-00002832-00008391": "foreign", "TKD1MLjUc68-00001-00008392-00009954": "foreign", "TKD1MLjUc68-00002-00009955-00010792": "[Music]", "TKD1MLjUc68-00003-00010793-00012031": "[Music]", "TKD1MLjUc68-00004-00012032-00015575": "foreign", "TKD1MLjUc68-00005-00015576-00018343": "foreign", "TKD1MLjUc68-00006-00018344-00020322": "foreign", "TKD1MLjUc68-00007-00020323-00026995": "[Music]", "TKD1MLjUc68-00008-00026997-00027423": "[Music]", "TKD1MLjUc68-00009-00027424-00029551": "is", "TKD1MLjUc68-00010-00029552-00029989": "yes", "TKD1MLjUc68-00011-00029991-00030566": "[Music]", "TKD1MLjUc68-00012-00030567-00031788": "[Music]", "TKD1MLjUc68-00013-00031789-00032439": "[Music]", "TKD1MLjUc68-00014-00032439-00032577": "is", "TKD1MLjUc68-00015-00032577-00034862": "[Music]", "TKD1MLjUc68-00016-00034863-00035871": "that", "TKD1MLjUc68-00017-00035872-00036127": "is just like a beast", "TKD1MLjUc68-00018-00036128-00036462": "those who are devoid of anugata", "TKD1MLjUc68-00019-00036463-00038159": "they can", "TKD1MLjUc68-00020-00038160-00038327": "they are actually", "TKD1MLjUc68-00021-00038328-00038567": "just like bees or", "TKD1MLjUc68-00022-00038568-00039023": "more than beast", "TKD1MLjUc68-00023-00039024-00039255": "without taking shelter onto the lotus", "TKD1MLjUc68-00024-00039256-00039567": "feet of a", "TKD1MLjUc68-00025-00039568-00039735": "shadguru", "TKD1MLjUc68-00026-00039736-00040127": "there is no alternative", "TKD1MLjUc68-00027-00040128-00040359": "we cannot find any alternative", "TKD1MLjUc68-00028-00040360-00040599": "maybe today or tomorrow", "TKD1MLjUc68-00029-00040600-00040751": "or next life", "TKD1MLjUc68-00030-00040752-00041215": "or still next life you will have to wait", "TKD1MLjUc68-00031-00041216-00041727": "don't be in hurry to accept one", "TKD1MLjUc68-00032-00041728-00042102": "fallen guru", "TKD1MLjUc68-00033-00042103-00042407": "only an only realized soul", "TKD1MLjUc68-00034-00042408-00042687": "those who are realized soul", "TKD1MLjUc68-00035-00042688-00042887": "they can inculcate", "TKD1MLjUc68-00036-00042888-00043127": "they can impart", "TKD1MLjUc68-00037-00043128-00043483": "actual teachings of caitanya", "TKD1MLjUc68-00038-00043484-00043743": "mahaprabhu those who are realized soul", "TKD1MLjUc68-00039-00043744-00043983": "that's why very often prophet used to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00040-00043984-00044127": "say", "TKD1MLjUc68-00041-00044128-00044351": "i must ignore the countless voices of", "TKD1MLjUc68-00042-00044352-00044511": "popular wisdom", "TKD1MLjUc68-00043-00044512-00044758": "and listen only to that of the realized", "TKD1MLjUc68-00044-00044759-00045046": "soul", "TKD1MLjUc68-00045-00045047-00045383": "that is the main", "TKD1MLjUc68-00046-00045384-00045823": "syllabus very often used to say", "TKD1MLjUc68-00047-00045824-00046174": "that we the members of godiamat always", "TKD1MLjUc68-00048-00046175-00046295": "ready", "TKD1MLjUc68-00049-00046296-00046439": "to shed", "TKD1MLjUc68-00050-00046440-00046671": "to give gallons of black for the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00051-00046672-00046990": "emancipation of common devote common", "TKD1MLjUc68-00052-00046991-00047158": "people", "TKD1MLjUc68-00053-00047159-00047343": "we are ready", "TKD1MLjUc68-00054-00047344-00047583": "provided they are interested if they are", "TKD1MLjUc68-00055-00047584-00048055": "not interested then big problem", "TKD1MLjUc68-00056-00048056-00048367": "if they are not at all interested", "TKD1MLjUc68-00057-00048368-00048518": "if they are going to criticize guru", "TKD1MLjUc68-00058-00048519-00049083": "vaisnava then we have nothing to do", "TKD1MLjUc68-00059-00049084-00049279": "passive", "TKD1MLjUc68-00060-00049280-00049590": "any passive objective object", "TKD1MLjUc68-00061-00049591-00049695": "like", "TKD1MLjUc68-00062-00049696-00050071": "plastic thermocol", "TKD1MLjUc68-00063-00050072-00050199": "you cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-00064-00050200-00050351": "use it as", "TKD1MLjUc68-00065-00050352-00050599": "thermal conductor or electricity", "TKD1MLjUc68-00066-00050600-00050958": "conductor not possible", "TKD1MLjUc68-00067-00050959-00051199": "insulation is one kind of insulation", "TKD1MLjUc68-00068-00051200-00051566": "non-conductor of electric electricity", "TKD1MLjUc68-00069-00051567-00051846": "similarly", "TKD1MLjUc68-00070-00051847-00052150": "all give in sarub they are vaisnava that", "TKD1MLjUc68-00071-00052151-00052430": "we know we learn from sirabinda vanda", "TKD1MLjUc68-00072-00052432-00052607": "sakura masai", "TKD1MLjUc68-00073-00052608-00052950": "or for different sastra we know", "TKD1MLjUc68-00074-00052951-00053223": "it matters little who is taking birth in", "TKD1MLjUc68-00075-00053224-00053559": "america german italy", "TKD1MLjUc68-00076-00053560-00053815": "russia not matter", "TKD1MLjUc68-00077-00053816-00054079": "basically they are atma all", "TKD1MLjUc68-00078-00054079-00054150": "by", "TKD1MLjUc68-00079-00054151-00054566": "but now they cannot realize it", "TKD1MLjUc68-00080-00054567-00054782": "basically they are always", "TKD1MLjUc68-00081-00054783-00055175": "vaishnavi and brahman also", "TKD1MLjUc68-00082-00055176-00055407": "but due to their previous samskara due", "TKD1MLjUc68-00083-00055408-00055687": "to the influence of maya they cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-00084-00055688-00055919": "discover their own sahara that is the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00085-00055920-00056287": "main problem", "TKD1MLjUc68-00086-00056288-00056471": "that's why bhupath many times used to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00087-00056472-00056735": "say we are ready", "TKD1MLjUc68-00088-00056736-00057094": "we goryama devotees we are always ready", "TKD1MLjUc68-00089-00057095-00057326": "to share to give gallons of blood for", "TKD1MLjUc68-00090-00057327-00057703": "the emancipation of one", "TKD1MLjUc68-00091-00057704-00057903": "bonded soul or this bondage all over", "TKD1MLjUc68-00092-00057904-00058038": "this society", "TKD1MLjUc68-00093-00058039-00058335": "but still there is no guarantee", "TKD1MLjUc68-00094-00058336-00058615": "but still there is no guarantee", "TKD1MLjUc68-00095-00058616-00058863": "that i can deliver them", "TKD1MLjUc68-00096-00058864-00058975": "why", "TKD1MLjUc68-00097-00058976-00059263": "because jivas they are all fanciful they", "TKD1MLjUc68-00098-00059264-00059575": "have some liberty", "TKD1MLjUc68-00099-00059576-00059742": "both way they can go", "TKD1MLjUc68-00100-00059744-00059999": "they can take resolution i cannot go i", "TKD1MLjUc68-00101-00060000-00060230": "cannot do bhajan", "TKD1MLjUc68-00102-00060232-00060559": "i cannot do bhajan what you can do", "TKD1MLjUc68-00103-00060560-00060871": "in that case i have nothing to do", "TKD1MLjUc68-00104-00060872-00061103": "those who are", "TKD1MLjUc68-00105-00061104-00061399": "hearing harikatha are somehow going to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00106-00061400-00061591": "hear", "TKD1MLjUc68-00107-00061591-00061766": "somehow", "TKD1MLjUc68-00108-00061767-00061966": "they're going to hear harikatha and they", "TKD1MLjUc68-00109-00061967-00062191": "feel some reaction", "TKD1MLjUc68-00110-00062191-00062335": "after they", "TKD1MLjUc68-00111-00062336-00062566": "after that they like to concentrate in", "TKD1MLjUc68-00112-00062567-00062903": "harikatha then in gradual course they", "TKD1MLjUc68-00113-00062904-00063126": "can get benefit surely", "TKD1MLjUc68-00114-00063127-00063391": "no doubt again", "TKD1MLjUc68-00115-00063391-00063759": "no doubt eating they can get because", "TKD1MLjUc68-00116-00063760-00064119": "it is in bhagavatam written", "TKD1MLjUc68-00117-00064120-00064375": "idiom mahaprabhu sims mahaprabhu", "TKD1MLjUc68-00118-00064376-00066767": "sikhishna cheshan himself", "TKD1MLjUc68-00119-00066768-00067567": "foreign", "TKD1MLjUc68-00120-00067568-00067791": "so long you can do all", "TKD1MLjUc68-00121-00067792-00068231": "activities whatever as a duty of society", "TKD1MLjUc68-00122-00068232-00068567": "care to do all", "TKD1MLjUc68-00123-00068568-00068815": "how long", "TKD1MLjUc68-00124-00068816-00069087": "but", "TKD1MLjUc68-00125-00069088-00069350": "till then you will have to continue your", "TKD1MLjUc68-00126-00069351-00069655": "duty you can go on", "TKD1MLjUc68-00127-00069656-00069919": "but when you can feel", "TKD1MLjUc68-00128-00069920-00071543": "detested", "TKD1MLjUc68-00129-00071544-00071782": "in front of bhagavan not think he does", "TKD1MLjUc68-00130-00071783-00071991": "my song", "TKD1MLjUc68-00131-00071992-00072159": "he say now", "TKD1MLjUc68-00132-00072160-00072462": "realize his supreme lord", "TKD1MLjUc68-00133-00072463-00072679": "speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00134-00072680-00074279": "nirvin nanitaram boman", "TKD1MLjUc68-00135-00074280-00074750": "foreign", "TKD1MLjUc68-00136-00074751-00075023": "i was ready to supply i was ready to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00137-00075024-00075319": "supply whatever things my sense organ", "TKD1MLjUc68-00138-00075320-00075543": "demanding give me", "TKD1MLjUc68-00139-00075544-00075719": "give me fish", "TKD1MLjUc68-00140-00075720-00075887": "give me meat", "TKD1MLjUc68-00141-00075888-00076071": "give me pork", "TKD1MLjUc68-00142-00076072-00076262": "follow", "TKD1MLjUc68-00143-00076263-00076399": "beef", "TKD1MLjUc68-00144-00076400-00076511": "wine", "TKD1MLjUc68-00145-00076512-00076711": "whatever", "TKD1MLjUc68-00146-00076712-00077006": "devout not asking that i am just for in", "TKD1MLjUc68-00147-00077007-00077247": "general speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00148-00077248-00077543": "deba utima are not asking for", "TKD1MLjUc68-00149-00077544-00077775": "de baatima speaking i like to elaborate", "TKD1MLjUc68-00150-00077776-00078391": "it for common people not that devati", "TKD1MLjUc68-00151-00078392-00078847": "de baatima speaking nirvina nitoram", "TKD1MLjUc68-00152-00078848-00079015": "repeatedly", "TKD1MLjUc68-00153-00079016-00079303": "i wanted to supply with those objective", "TKD1MLjUc68-00154-00079304-00079719": "respective objective of the sense organ", "TKD1MLjUc68-00155-00079720-00079991": "all my sense of wanted to my eyes wanted", "TKD1MLjUc68-00156-00079992-00080175": "to see dirty", "TKD1MLjUc68-00157-00080176-00080326": "picture he", "TKD1MLjUc68-00158-00080327-00080543": "i wanted to hear some", "TKD1MLjUc68-00159-00080544-00080735": "dirty things", "TKD1MLjUc68-00160-00080736-00080991": "my tongue want to speak all rubbish my", "TKD1MLjUc68-00161-00080992-00081279": "mouth like to see this all sensor", "TKD1MLjUc68-00162-00081280-00081638": "my screen like to get some touch", "TKD1MLjUc68-00163-00081639-00081935": "enjoyment this way", "TKD1MLjUc68-00164-00081936-00082023": "so", "TKD1MLjUc68-00165-00082024-00082191": "devout him are speaking we should", "TKD1MLjUc68-00166-00082192-00082399": "remember this point", "TKD1MLjUc68-00167-00082400-00082575": "nirvin", "TKD1MLjUc68-00168-00082576-00085511": "bhuman", "TKD1MLjUc68-00169-00085512-00085687": "thirsty of eyes", "TKD1MLjUc68-00170-00085688-00085879": "thirsty", "TKD1MLjUc68-00171-00085880-00086047": "of ear", "TKD1MLjUc68-00172-00086048-00086287": "all this way i wanted to supply all", "TKD1MLjUc68-00173-00086288-00086567": "respective objective all the sensor and", "TKD1MLjUc68-00174-00086568-00086782": "to satisfy them", "TKD1MLjUc68-00175-00086783-00086959": "but still today", "TKD1MLjUc68-00176-00086960-00087238": "they are not going to show mercy to me", "TKD1MLjUc68-00177-00087239-00087487": "they are not going to say that is", "TKD1MLjUc68-00178-00087488-00087679": "enough of it", "TKD1MLjUc68-00179-00087680-00087855": "they are not going to steal today they", "TKD1MLjUc68-00180-00087856-00088135": "are not going to speak ok ok ok enough", "TKD1MLjUc68-00181-00088136-00088750": "of it no need not speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00182-00088751-00089038": "now i am fed up", "TKD1MLjUc68-00183-00089039-00089303": "devouting must begin now i am paid up a", "TKD1MLjUc68-00184-00089304-00089726": "bitter bitter experience i'm fed up", "TKD1MLjUc68-00185-00089727-00089999": "now you please", "TKD1MLjUc68-00186-00090000-00090191": "now you please save me", "TKD1MLjUc68-00187-00090192-00090423": "please", "TKD1MLjUc68-00188-00090424-00090687": "awesome", "TKD1MLjUc68-00189-00090688-00091015": "you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-00190-00091016-00091287": "day by day i am going to the darkness of", "TKD1MLjUc68-00191-00091288-00091718": "tama tamamine ignorance", "TKD1MLjUc68-00192-00091719-00091950": "painful experience", "TKD1MLjUc68-00193-00091951-00092231": "devatima crying and speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00194-00092232-00092503": "i thought i can get satisfaction", "TKD1MLjUc68-00195-00092504-00092799": "i thought that i someday i can get some", "TKD1MLjUc68-00196-00092800-00092974": "saturation point", "TKD1MLjUc68-00197-00092975-00093150": "but not", "TKD1MLjUc68-00198-00093151-00093567": "painful situation", "TKD1MLjUc68-00199-00093568-00093967": "same thing i wanted to speak about", "TKD1MLjUc68-00200-00093968-00094150": "the king pururava", "TKD1MLjUc68-00201-00094151-00094671": "who wanted to enjoy life with uruvashi", "TKD1MLjUc68-00202-00094672-00095087": "he don't understand his day or night", "TKD1MLjUc68-00203-00095088-00095262": "he don't understand the years after", "TKD1MLjUc68-00204-00095263-00095606": "years gone he's going to lose he's going", "TKD1MLjUc68-00205-00095607-00095838": "to lose everything all the vitals of his", "TKD1MLjUc68-00206-00095839-00095943": "life", "TKD1MLjUc68-00207-00095944-00096103": "he couldn't remember", "TKD1MLjUc68-00208-00096104-00096438": "that is a magic spell of maya", "TKD1MLjUc68-00209-00096439-00096655": "that is the magic spell of maya maya", "TKD1MLjUc68-00210-00096656-00096991": "cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-00211-00096992-00097287": "you can be busy all apparent enjoyment", "TKD1MLjUc68-00212-00097288-00097638": "and lose your life go down down down", "TKD1MLjUc68-00213-00097639-00097879": "where you can go", "TKD1MLjUc68-00214-00097880-00098094": "where you can go", "TKD1MLjUc68-00215-00098095-00098343": "patternless", "TKD1MLjUc68-00216-00098344-00098462": "people", "TKD1MLjUc68-00217-00098463-00098591": "they are going", "TKD1MLjUc68-00218-00098592-00099135": "down and down bottomless", "TKD1MLjUc68-00219-00099136-00099406": "20 000 league under the sea we can go", "TKD1MLjUc68-00220-00099407-00099559": "get some", "TKD1MLjUc68-00221-00099560-00099823": "but here patham list we are going", "TKD1MLjUc68-00222-00099824-00100199": "down and down where we can go", "TKD1MLjUc68-00223-00100200-00100455": "that's why puru river about puru ruba", "TKD1MLjUc68-00224-00100456-00100750": "same thing", "TKD1MLjUc68-00225-00100751-00101191": "pururava about puru", "TKD1MLjUc68-00226-00101192-00101487": "was so powerful that even even indra", "TKD1MLjUc68-00227-00101488-00101759": "maharaja all that they're inviting you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00228-00101760-00102126": "you please help us to fight with demons", "TKD1MLjUc68-00229-00102127-00102391": "he alone fighting and all demons are", "TKD1MLjUc68-00230-00102392-00102582": "defeated", "TKD1MLjUc68-00231-00102583-00102815": "follow", "TKD1MLjUc68-00232-00102816-00103086": "but", "TKD1MLjUc68-00233-00103088-00103351": "finally", "TKD1MLjUc68-00234-00103352-00103630": "he is in the trap of maya", "TKD1MLjUc68-00235-00103631-00103886": "urbashi", "TKD1MLjUc68-00236-00103888-00104215": "my question is that", "TKD1MLjUc68-00237-00104216-00104471": "is not there with us", "TKD1MLjUc68-00238-00104472-00104654": "long ago", "TKD1MLjUc68-00239-00104655-00104958": "i like to ask question to pururova", "TKD1MLjUc68-00240-00104959-00105302": "you like to enjoy urboshi or university", "TKD1MLjUc68-00241-00105303-00105558": "like to enjoy you who please tell me i", "TKD1MLjUc68-00242-00105559-00105815": "cannot understand", "TKD1MLjUc68-00243-00105816-00106015": "you please explain me i cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-00244-00106016-00106343": "understand my i am blockheaded", "TKD1MLjUc68-00245-00106344-00106566": "who can enjoy whom", "TKD1MLjUc68-00246-00106567-00106799": "because all matter", "TKD1MLjUc68-00247-00106800-00107015": "all matter blood and place and", "TKD1MLjUc68-00248-00107016-00107375": "you know calcium carbonate this", "TKD1MLjUc68-00249-00107376-00107566": "blood and flesh everything", "TKD1MLjUc68-00250-00107567-00107815": "who can enjoy whom", "TKD1MLjUc68-00251-00107816-00108199": "they cannot give answer", "TKD1MLjUc68-00252-00108200-00108471": "so it was written", "TKD1MLjUc68-00253-00108472-00108695": "i told you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00254-00108696-00108799": "maybe", "TKD1MLjUc68-00255-00108800-00109095": "15 days ago i was speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00256-00109096-00109231": "if you add", "TKD1MLjUc68-00257-00109232-00109551": "if you add fuel inflatable inflammable", "TKD1MLjUc68-00258-00109552-00109815": "objectives in fire", "TKD1MLjUc68-00259-00109816-00110031": "you can never expect the fire to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00260-00110032-00110423": "extinguish how you can expect", "TKD1MLjUc68-00261-00110424-00110575": "how you can expect", "TKD1MLjUc68-00262-00110576-00110766": "because you are going to add", "TKD1MLjUc68-00263-00110767-00110975": "fuel in the fire", "TKD1MLjUc68-00264-00110976-00111278": "how you can expect that it can", "TKD1MLjUc68-00265-00111279-00111695": "it's not possible same thing i told", "TKD1MLjUc68-00266-00111696-00112086": "one very vital point", "TKD1MLjUc68-00267-00112088-00112390": "that papad used to say", "TKD1MLjUc68-00268-00112391-00112663": "actually we are the post we are like", "TKD1MLjUc68-00269-00112664-00112878": "postman", "TKD1MLjUc68-00270-00112879-00113134": "we are like postman whatever message", "TKD1MLjUc68-00271-00113135-00113351": "coming from the divine", "TKD1MLjUc68-00272-00113352-00113543": "one", "TKD1MLjUc68-00273-00113544-00113758": "we just like to hand over to you i have", "TKD1MLjUc68-00274-00113759-00114119": "nothing to do don't become angry with me", "TKD1MLjUc68-00275-00114120-00114439": "don't become angry with me", "TKD1MLjUc68-00276-00114440-00114790": "don't say i'm very tough or very liberal", "TKD1MLjUc68-00277-00114791-00115158": "this kind of conception is obsolete", "TKD1MLjUc68-00278-00115159-00115407": "i have nothing to do whatever message i", "TKD1MLjUc68-00279-00115408-00115671": "am getting from my guru burger i want to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00280-00115672-00116175": "pass over to you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00281-00116176-00116283": "one", "TKD1MLjUc68-00282-00116283-00116631": "postman going door to door to supply the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00283-00116632-00116807": "letter there", "TKD1MLjUc68-00284-00116808-00117054": "in the envelope", "TKD1MLjUc68-00285-00117055-00117286": "you can open that envelope and read the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00286-00117288-00117623": "letter if there is any very fearful news", "TKD1MLjUc68-00287-00117624-00117886": "you cannot attack that postman because", "TKD1MLjUc68-00288-00117888-00118158": "postman is not responsible he is a", "TKD1MLjUc68-00289-00118159-00118271": "servant", "TKD1MLjUc68-00290-00118272-00118510": "he'll act to deliver the letter to you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00291-00118511-00118983": "whatever letter you have you take", "TKD1MLjUc68-00292-00118983-00119263": "if somebody going to attack a postman", "TKD1MLjUc68-00293-00119264-00119695": "that surely is idiot number one rascal", "TKD1MLjUc68-00294-00119696-00119990": "we have nothing to do", "TKD1MLjUc68-00295-00119991-00120239": "so pogba speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00296-00120240-00120478": "only we are going to pass", "TKD1MLjUc68-00297-00120479-00120823": "on this whatever order we are getting by", "TKD1MLjUc68-00298-00120824-00121127": "liking like mahaprabhu giving order to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00299-00121128-00122807": "haridash", "TKD1MLjUc68-00300-00122808-00122999": "day is over you can come and inform me", "TKD1MLjUc68-00301-00123000-00123158": "what happens", "TKD1MLjUc68-00302-00123159-00124710": "what happening", "TKD1MLjUc68-00303-00124711-00124951": "all they are preaching", "TKD1MLjUc68-00304-00124952-00125119": "i wanted to say", "TKD1MLjUc68-00305-00125120-00125358": "all their character all their behavior", "TKD1MLjUc68-00306-00125359-00125702": "all their efficacy it's self-pushing", "TKD1MLjUc68-00307-00125703-00125943": "you don't understand this point", "TKD1MLjUc68-00308-00125944-00126375": "many times i totally forget you think", "TKD1MLjUc68-00309-00126376-00126671": "running like a mad is called fishing", "TKD1MLjUc68-00310-00126672-00126895": "collect some money", "TKD1MLjUc68-00311-00126896-00127327": "dry philosophy without any feeling no i", "TKD1MLjUc68-00312-00127328-00127575": "i wanted to speak this way", "TKD1MLjUc68-00313-00127576-00127863": "it is not preaching", "TKD1MLjUc68-00314-00127864-00128119": "this is not pitching actually", "TKD1MLjUc68-00315-00128120-00128366": "running from one corner of the world", "TKD1MLjUc68-00316-00128367-00128654": "here there only without any education", "TKD1MLjUc68-00317-00128655-00128823": "many time i told", "TKD1MLjUc68-00318-00128824-00129158": "you cannot remember what i can do", "TKD1MLjUc68-00319-00129159-00129575": "goryo darshan is so vast", "TKD1MLjUc68-00320-00129576-00129783": "like ananta", "TKD1MLjUc68-00321-00129783-00130134": "ananta devi's infinity haryana hari rupa", "TKD1MLjUc68-00322-00130135-00130286": "anantha", "TKD1MLjUc68-00323-00130288-00130575": "how i can conceive how i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-00324-00130576-00130719": "similarly", "TKD1MLjUc68-00325-00130720-00131007": "if hari is ananta then gauria darsan is", "TKD1MLjUc68-00326-00131008-00131207": "also another", "TKD1MLjUc68-00327-00131208-00131519": "how you can grasp how you can digest", "TKD1MLjUc68-00328-00131520-00131863": "how i can assimilate", "TKD1MLjUc68-00329-00131864-00132087": "impossible", "TKD1MLjUc68-00330-00132088-00132423": "so according to our limit we like to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00331-00132424-00132663": "get the teachings of oppa if your luck", "TKD1MLjUc68-00332-00132664-00132919": "is very good you can accept otherwise", "TKD1MLjUc68-00333-00132920-00133231": "you can take trouble to criticize about", "TKD1MLjUc68-00334-00133232-00133487": "about guru vaisnava and go to hell with", "TKD1MLjUc68-00335-00133488-00133663": "all your followers", "TKD1MLjUc68-00336-00133664-00133863": "people can say you are a preacher these", "TKD1MLjUc68-00337-00133864-00134271": "days that's up to you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00338-00134272-00134502": "after death where you are going then you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00339-00134503-00134743": "can understand now you cannot realize", "TKD1MLjUc68-00340-00134744-00134983": "now you are inside your body", "TKD1MLjUc68-00341-00134984-00135287": "your body is not you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00342-00135288-00135559": "now you are inside your body you cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-00343-00135560-00135735": "realize after leaving this body where i", "TKD1MLjUc68-00344-00135736-00135927": "can go", "TKD1MLjUc68-00345-00135928-00136239": "you are not going to think", "TKD1MLjUc68-00346-00136240-00136559": "so many times prabhas used to say", "TKD1MLjUc68-00347-00136560-00136807": "to get established in the acharam of", "TKD1MLjUc68-00348-00136808-00137127": "govarangama is called preaching", "TKD1MLjUc68-00349-00137128-00137366": "how i can change the decision if you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00350-00137367-00137575": "misunderstand me simply because i am not", "TKD1MLjUc68-00351-00137576-00137935": "going to america rasia france italy", "TKD1MLjUc68-00352-00137936-00138071": "simply because", "TKD1MLjUc68-00353-00138072-00138295": "of this reason you can blame me you are", "TKD1MLjUc68-00354-00138296-00138863": "against preaching what i can do", "TKD1MLjUc68-00355-00138864-00139399": "my harikatha going somehow", "TKD1MLjUc68-00356-00139400-00139631": "so poppad used to say", "TKD1MLjUc68-00357-00139632-00139895": "to get established in the acharam of", "TKD1MLjUc68-00358-00139896-00140175": "goranga mahaprabhu", "TKD1MLjUc68-00359-00140176-00140471": "it is called idealism perfect idealism", "TKD1MLjUc68-00360-00140472-00140678": "that is called fishing", "TKD1MLjUc68-00361-00140679-00140887": "bhakti you are talking many times told", "TKD1MLjUc68-00362-00140888-00141151": "if one pure vaisnava someday in", "TKD1MLjUc68-00363-00141152-00141319": "absorbing mood", "TKD1MLjUc68-00364-00141320-00141502": "don't like to talk with you but you are", "TKD1MLjUc68-00365-00141503-00141775": "coming from long distance to meet", "TKD1MLjUc68-00366-00141776-00142111": "but that vaisnava is an in separate mode", "TKD1MLjUc68-00367-00142112-00142359": "absorbing bhajanam", "TKD1MLjUc68-00368-00142360-00142526": "don't like to talk with you about", "TKD1MLjUc68-00369-00142527-00142799": "chromatography bhakti metro speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00370-00142800-00143047": "don't try to put pressure on him", "TKD1MLjUc68-00371-00143048-00143247": "to talk with you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00372-00143248-00143502": "better you can pay randa it is more than", "TKD1MLjUc68-00373-00143503-00143607": "enough", "TKD1MLjUc68-00374-00143608-00143766": "it is more than enough that you will", "TKD1MLjUc68-00375-00143767-00143902": "look him", "TKD1MLjUc68-00376-00143903-00144111": "and paid underwater you can get enough", "TKD1MLjUc68-00377-00144112-00144351": "success provided you have hundred", "TKD1MLjUc68-00378-00144352-00144663": "percent friendly vaisnava", "TKD1MLjUc68-00379-00144664-00144895": "bhaktivedak told it if some version of", "TKD1MLjUc68-00380-00144896-00145071": "not going to talk with you don't become", "TKD1MLjUc68-00381-00145072-00145278": "angry", "TKD1MLjUc68-00382-00145279-00145431": "don't become angry this is not the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00383-00145432-00145678": "teachings what i can do i'm a bonded", "TKD1MLjUc68-00384-00145679-00145926": "soul of what i can talk with him", "TKD1MLjUc68-00385-00145927-00146207": "i can get all answer by looking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00386-00146208-00146407": "this way now", "TKD1MLjUc68-00387-00146408-00146799": "he's absorbing bhava absorbing mood", "TKD1MLjUc68-00388-00146800-00147014": "darshan", "TKD1MLjUc68-00389-00147015-00147183": "by watching a vaisnava we can become", "TKD1MLjUc68-00390-00147184-00147399": "purified", "TKD1MLjUc68-00391-00147400-00147647": "we cannot compel that vaisnava", "TKD1MLjUc68-00392-00147648-00147975": "speak with me i have come long distance", "TKD1MLjUc68-00393-00147976-00148231": "he can speak he cannot speak", "TKD1MLjUc68-00394-00148232-00148414": "i should not be angry", "TKD1MLjUc68-00395-00148415-00148678": "documentary speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00396-00148679-00148926": "from the body of vaishnav", "TKD1MLjUc68-00397-00148927-00149207": "you cannot see some light emitting", "TKD1MLjUc68-00398-00149208-00149375": "bacterometer speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00399-00149376-00149623": "just like one magnet", "TKD1MLjUc68-00400-00149624-00149847": "just like from magnet physics you've", "TKD1MLjUc68-00401-00149848-00150047": "gone through physics", "TKD1MLjUc68-00402-00150048-00150423": "otherwise you cannot understand", "TKD1MLjUc68-00403-00150424-00150583": "from magnet", "TKD1MLjUc68-00404-00150584-00150799": "there is magnetic field going out", "TKD1MLjUc68-00405-00150800-00151031": "magnetic field", "TKD1MLjUc68-00406-00151032-00151278": "magnetic field going out", "TKD1MLjUc68-00407-00151279-00151647": "and within that range if some iron bar", "TKD1MLjUc68-00408-00151648-00152126": "is there can attract", "TKD1MLjUc68-00409-00152127-00152302": "follow", "TKD1MLjUc68-00410-00152303-00152535": "but it is out of the range of the you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00411-00152536-00152631": "know", "TKD1MLjUc68-00412-00152632-00153071": "then cannot attack", "TKD1MLjUc68-00413-00153072-00153239": "the iron piece", "TKD1MLjUc68-00414-00153240-00153535": "how much weight it is also one factor", "TKD1MLjUc68-00415-00153536-00153775": "and how big the magnet is it depends", "TKD1MLjUc68-00416-00153776-00153983": "upon the gravity of that magnet should", "TKD1MLjUc68-00417-00153984-00154087": "be", "TKD1MLjUc68-00418-00154088-00154390": "higher than the object of an object to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00419-00154391-00154566": "be attractive", "TKD1MLjUc68-00420-00154567-00154799": "follow attraction", "TKD1MLjUc68-00421-00154800-00155126": "so within this magnetic field", "TKD1MLjUc68-00422-00155127-00155423": "is that a small iron bar and pull", "TKD1MLjUc68-00423-00155424-00155743": "otherwise", "TKD1MLjUc68-00424-00155744-00155959": "speaking from the body of vaisnava you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00425-00155960-00156087": "cannot see", "TKD1MLjUc68-00426-00156088-00156207": "one", "TKD1MLjUc68-00427-00156208-00156302": "you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-00428-00156303-00156478": "light coming", "TKD1MLjUc68-00429-00156479-00156711": "ray effulgence", "TKD1MLjUc68-00430-00156712-00156919": "that effulgence can", "TKD1MLjUc68-00431-00156920-00157054": "touch you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00432-00157055-00157247": "if you paid on the bhat their affection", "TKD1MLjUc68-00433-00157248-00157439": "effulgence can touch you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00434-00157440-00157678": "and an effulgence can enter into your", "TKD1MLjUc68-00435-00157679-00157871": "body", "TKD1MLjUc68-00436-00157872-00158078": "you cannot feel some reaction you can", "TKD1MLjUc68-00437-00158079-00158183": "feel", "TKD1MLjUc68-00438-00158184-00158335": "after", "TKD1MLjUc68-00439-00158336-00158559": "like i myself after watching silla", "TKD1MLjUc68-00440-00158560-00158887": "bhakti maturigashimara", "TKD1MLjUc68-00441-00158888-00159095": "feel some reaction", "TKD1MLjUc68-00442-00159096-00159302": "of course previous night when i met guru", "TKD1MLjUc68-00443-00159303-00159495": "maharaj i was", "TKD1MLjUc68-00444-00159496-00159719": "sleeping at the bank just at the bank of", "TKD1MLjUc68-00445-00159720-00159871": "ganga", "TKD1MLjUc68-00446-00159872-00160190": "that side of deva", "TKD1MLjUc68-00447-00160191-00160366": "and in the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00448-00160367-00160590": "night time always over i saw something i", "TKD1MLjUc68-00449-00160591-00160799": "cannot speak", "TKD1MLjUc68-00450-00160800-00161023": "that was my", "TKD1MLjUc68-00451-00161024-00161239": "signal that today i can get", "TKD1MLjUc68-00452-00161240-00161502": "completely clear", "TKD1MLjUc68-00453-00161503-00161823": "i get up very quickly what i see", "TKD1MLjUc68-00454-00161824-00162087": "immediately go to ganga and take bath", "TKD1MLjUc68-00455-00162088-00162247": "across the river", "TKD1MLjUc68-00456-00162248-00162359": "i", "TKD1MLjUc68-00457-00162360-00162631": "run like mad in chaitanya mate here that", "TKD1MLjUc68-00458-00162632-00162895": "your feet finally enter", "TKD1MLjUc68-00459-00162896-00163119": "and find my guru", "TKD1MLjUc68-00460-00163120-00163366": "so i believe hundred percent", "TKD1MLjUc68-00461-00163367-00163671": "according to your sincerity", "TKD1MLjUc68-00462-00163672-00163871": "according to your", "TKD1MLjUc68-00463-00163872-00163975": "prayer", "TKD1MLjUc68-00464-00163976-00164263": "how cravingly you are praying it depends", "TKD1MLjUc68-00465-00164264-00164438": "upon that tennessee", "TKD1MLjUc68-00466-00164439-00164726": "nithyanando watching everything", "TKD1MLjUc68-00467-00164727-00164902": "going to give response to you i believe", "TKD1MLjUc68-00468-00164903-00165047": "it hundred percent", "TKD1MLjUc68-00469-00165048-00165278": "yesterday when sannyas came from radha", "TKD1MLjUc68-00470-00165279-00165599": "kunda he's searching me all around", "TKD1MLjUc68-00471-00165600-00165766": "actually i cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-00472-00165767-00165935": "i cannot give time", "TKD1MLjUc68-00473-00165936-00166278": "but somebody give address", "TKD1MLjUc68-00474-00166279-00166551": "i was giving one hour time to him", "TKD1MLjUc68-00475-00166552-00166838": "he's crying i misguided everybody cheat", "TKD1MLjUc68-00476-00166839-00166966": "me", "TKD1MLjUc68-00477-00166967-00167366": "i'm what i can do", "TKD1MLjUc68-00478-00167367-00167566": "so this way i will have to give time", "TKD1MLjUc68-00479-00167567-00167823": "they don't understand", "TKD1MLjUc68-00480-00167824-00168007": "many people coming no i am not giving", "TKD1MLjUc68-00481-00168008-00168319": "address where from they get i don't know", "TKD1MLjUc68-00482-00168320-00168566": "they come i i am i'm bound to meet with", "TKD1MLjUc68-00483-00168567-00168766": "them if i don't give time", "TKD1MLjUc68-00484-00168767-00168943": "it is offensive for me", "TKD1MLjUc68-00485-00168944-00169238": "this way i lose i i am giving time after", "TKD1MLjUc68-00486-00169239-00169438": "that i will have to complete my harinam", "TKD1MLjUc68-00487-00169439-00169719": "write these that so many things so they", "TKD1MLjUc68-00488-00169720-00169911": "don't understand they become angry why", "TKD1MLjUc68-00489-00169912-00170166": "maharas talk with me", "TKD1MLjUc68-00490-00170167-00170407": "they cannot calculate even in night time", "TKD1MLjUc68-00491-00170408-00170790": "how i can sleep no time", "TKD1MLjUc68-00492-00170791-00171054": "they become angry", "TKD1MLjUc68-00493-00171055-00171463": "so bhaktivedanta speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00494-00171464-00171671": "that", "TKD1MLjUc68-00495-00171672-00171959": "by the mercy of guru vaishnav we can get", "TKD1MLjUc68-00496-00171960-00172207": "everything", "TKD1MLjUc68-00497-00172208-00172526": "so actually we are postman", "TKD1MLjUc68-00498-00172527-00172759": "so we cannot change even", "TKD1MLjUc68-00499-00172760-00172863": "dot", "TKD1MLjUc68-00500-00172864-00172990": "full stop", "TKD1MLjUc68-00501-00172991-00173175": "hyphen", "TKD1MLjUc68-00502-00173176-00173343": "we cannot change", "TKD1MLjUc68-00503-00173344-00173566": "in the writings of pogba in the writings", "TKD1MLjUc68-00504-00173567-00173775": "of you know bhaktivinoda chakur in the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00505-00173776-00174063": "writing siddhar ghosam we have no power", "TKD1MLjUc68-00506-00174064-00174375": "to change even dot full stop karma we", "TKD1MLjUc68-00507-00174376-00174631": "cannot change", "TKD1MLjUc68-00508-00174632-00174878": "they have no right that's why many times", "TKD1MLjUc68-00509-00174879-00175302": "we heard from guru patmo", "TKD1MLjUc68-00510-00175303-00175502": "also used to say", "TKD1MLjUc68-00511-00175503-00175735": "when you are we are doing kirtan you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00512-00175736-00175966": "cannot change any word", "TKD1MLjUc68-00513-00175967-00176223": "just you can repeat same word but it is", "TKD1MLjUc68-00514-00176224-00176359": "written there", "TKD1MLjUc68-00515-00176360-00176590": "we have the right to change the world of", "TKD1MLjUc68-00516-00176591-00176790": "naruto", "TKD1MLjUc68-00517-00176791-00177007": "we have no right to change the word of", "TKD1MLjUc68-00518-00177008-00177231": "bhaktivinoda", "TKD1MLjUc68-00519-00177232-00177383": "this way", "TKD1MLjUc68-00520-00177384-00177514": "by", "TKD1MLjUc68-00521-00177515-00177959": "so complicated so high sensitivity", "TKD1MLjUc68-00522-00177960-00178054": "because", "TKD1MLjUc68-00523-00178055-00178271": "if you realize best chapter that mean", "TKD1MLjUc68-00524-00178272-00178590": "already you are going to get vishnu", "TKD1MLjUc68-00525-00178591-00178799": "when you realize", "TKD1MLjUc68-00526-00178800-00179007": "that means hundred percent you are ready", "TKD1MLjUc68-00527-00179008-00179287": "now you are getting green signal", "TKD1MLjUc68-00528-00179288-00179575": "you are going to get meet with bhagwan", "TKD1MLjUc68-00529-00179576-00179775": "to meet with vaishnavin to meet with", "TKD1MLjUc68-00530-00179776-00180111": "bhagavan almost same", "TKD1MLjUc68-00531-00180112-00180263": "almost", "TKD1MLjUc68-00532-00180264-00180463": "even more because if you can realize", "TKD1MLjUc68-00533-00180464-00180902": "vaishnava guru darshan is more important", "TKD1MLjUc68-00534-00180903-00181183": "guru darshan is more important though it", "TKD1MLjUc68-00535-00181184-00181414": "is written", "TKD1MLjUc68-00536-00181415-00182063": "though it is written in upanishads", "TKD1MLjUc68-00537-00182064-00182519": "guru", "TKD1MLjUc68-00538-00182520-00182719": "if you are going to get", "TKD1MLjUc68-00539-00182720-00182919": "you know how much lobby you have for", "TKD1MLjUc68-00540-00182920-00183054": "bhagavan", "TKD1MLjUc68-00541-00183055-00183287": "respect bhakti", "TKD1MLjUc68-00542-00183288-00183463": "you will have to get the same for", "TKD1MLjUc68-00543-00183464-00183647": "gurudev or i would say", "TKD1MLjUc68-00544-00183648-00183926": "more than bhagwan", "TKD1MLjUc68-00545-00183927-00184302": "because i can love my brother anymore", "TKD1MLjUc68-00546-00184303-00184551": "naturally i am in the favor i am the and", "TKD1MLjUc68-00547-00184552-00184759": "in the party of radharani", "TKD1MLjUc68-00548-00184760-00184951": "i cannot go in the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00549-00184952-00185190": "party of krishna because i know krishna", "TKD1MLjUc68-00550-00185191-00185383": "can entertain cheat me rather and he", "TKD1MLjUc68-00551-00185384-00185583": "cannot cheat me", "TKD1MLjUc68-00552-00185584-00185783": "i'm always in favor of", "TKD1MLjUc68-00553-00185784-00185966": "if i like to fight with krishna i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-00554-00185967-00186111": "fight", "TKD1MLjUc68-00555-00186112-00186583": "this is the mood i learned from our guru", "TKD1MLjUc68-00556-00186584-00186766": "you know this is", "TKD1MLjUc68-00557-00186767-00186871": "seeking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00558-00186872-00186990": "speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00559-00186991-00187183": "if krishna coming in front of me and", "TKD1MLjUc68-00560-00187184-00187287": "speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00561-00187288-00187687": "i am krishna come to me i cannot believe", "TKD1MLjUc68-00562-00187688-00187838": "i cannot believe", "TKD1MLjUc68-00563-00187839-00188150": "but if radharani speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00564-00188151-00188559": "come to me krishna is with me i can more", "TKD1MLjUc68-00565-00188560-00188807": "with more velocity", "TKD1MLjUc68-00566-00188808-00189031": "supersonic jet", "TKD1MLjUc68-00567-00189032-00189390": "i can run", "TKD1MLjUc68-00568-00189391-00189671": "i can go more than the air", "TKD1MLjUc68-00569-00189672-00189887": "and jump into the lotus feet or rather", "TKD1MLjUc68-00570-00189888-00190095": "than because radharani can achieve when", "TKD1MLjUc68-00571-00190096-00190223": "i'm saying this", "TKD1MLjUc68-00572-00190224-00190447": "this is my prana or not", "TKD1MLjUc68-00573-00190448-00190735": "and i can believe", "TKD1MLjUc68-00574-00190736-00190983": "this is our goal", "TKD1MLjUc68-00575-00190984-00191350": "now i give i like to go back", "TKD1MLjUc68-00576-00191351-00191647": "to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00577-00191648-00191863": "discuss about you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-00578-00191864-00192023": "discussion of this", "TKD1MLjUc68-00579-00192024-00192447": "great exalted devotee gorilla devotee", "TKD1MLjUc68-00580-00192448-00192838": "papa parsa eternal parsara porpat", "TKD1MLjUc68-00581-00192839-00193102": "any amount of discussion is not", "TKD1MLjUc68-00582-00193103-00193319": "sufficient", "TKD1MLjUc68-00583-00193320-00193663": "any amount of discussion about silla", "TKD1MLjUc68-00584-00193664-00193847": "bhakti that one of them", "TKD1MLjUc68-00585-00193848-00194078": "is not sufficient", "TKD1MLjUc68-00586-00194079-00194407": "within this short compass how i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-00587-00194408-00194614": "describe their", "TKD1MLjUc68-00588-00194615-00194902": "unique you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-00589-00194903-00195031": "guru sheva", "TKD1MLjUc68-00590-00195032-00195143": "how", "TKD1MLjUc68-00591-00195144-00195559": "impossible next impossible", "TKD1MLjUc68-00592-00195560-00195699": "so bhakti", "TKD1MLjUc68-00593-00195700-00196399": "shakti show up", "TKD1MLjUc68-00594-00196400-00196599": "all so many things to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00595-00196600-00196854": "speak", "TKD1MLjUc68-00596-00196855-00197111": "when i can speak and when you can hear", "TKD1MLjUc68-00597-00197112-00197399": "that is the main question", "TKD1MLjUc68-00598-00197400-00198775": "silla bhakti hide", "TKD1MLjUc68-00599-00198776-00198999": "how i say eternal person i'm hundred", "TKD1MLjUc68-00600-00199000-00199287": "percent i can give stem", "TKD1MLjUc68-00601-00199288-00199526": "i can put a stem there is symptoms some", "TKD1MLjUc68-00602-00199527-00199671": "symptom", "TKD1MLjUc68-00603-00199672-00199926": "there is symptom we learn from guru work", "TKD1MLjUc68-00604-00199927-00200175": "or some symptom if the symptom going to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00605-00200176-00200535": "satisfy then because we can understand", "TKD1MLjUc68-00606-00200536-00200695": "no doubt", "TKD1MLjUc68-00607-00200696-00200999": "not that he is enjoying popularity", "TKD1MLjUc68-00608-00201000-00201278": "not that he is enjoying whole boat of", "TKD1MLjUc68-00609-00201279-00201454": "the whole world", "TKD1MLjUc68-00610-00201455-00201711": "not that this is not a symptom", "TKD1MLjUc68-00611-00201712-00201887": "this is not the symptom that there is", "TKD1MLjUc68-00612-00201888-00202095": "thousands of followers or lacks of", "TKD1MLjUc68-00613-00202096-00202511": "followers this is not symptom", "TKD1MLjUc68-00614-00202512-00202711": "first of all we make mistake this is the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00615-00202712-00203063": "arrangement of maya we always calculate", "TKD1MLjUc68-00616-00203064-00203143": "oh", "TKD1MLjUc68-00617-00203144-00203383": "how many people going to attend him", "TKD1MLjUc68-00618-00203384-00203702": "that's why this is not harikatha", "TKD1MLjUc68-00619-00203703-00204007": "who is going to attend sadananda prabhu", "TKD1MLjUc68-00620-00204008-00204487": "he is eternal person", "TKD1MLjUc68-00621-00204488-00204814": "who is that is that any rare", "TKD1MLjUc68-00622-00204815-00205182": "even read the article cannot understand", "TKD1MLjUc68-00623-00205183-00205406": "cannot and what is it useless", "TKD1MLjUc68-00624-00205407-00205671": "but all jails there in the writing", "TKD1MLjUc68-00625-00205671-00205910": "or power coming if you take that writing", "TKD1MLjUc68-00626-00205911-00206175": "you can see some effulgence coming", "TKD1MLjUc68-00627-00206176-00206494": "a bishop can understand a vaisnava", "TKD1MLjUc68-00628-00206496-00206775": "we cannot leave the judgment", "TKD1MLjUc68-00629-00206776-00206990": "we cannot leave the judgment into the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00630-00206991-00207294": "hand of a idiot foolish", "TKD1MLjUc68-00631-00207296-00207519": "remarkable personality", "TKD1MLjUc68-00632-00207519-00207831": "as per the opinion of this society", "TKD1MLjUc68-00633-00207832-00208127": "we cannot leave the judgment", "TKD1MLjUc68-00634-00208128-00208462": "into the hand of a foolish idiot who is", "TKD1MLjUc68-00635-00208463-00208682": "externally important person in the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00636-00208683-00209071": "society who is not vishnu he can pass", "TKD1MLjUc68-00637-00209071-00209334": "remark how he can pass remark", "TKD1MLjUc68-00638-00209335-00209527": "how he can pursue him", "TKD1MLjUc68-00639-00209528-00209758": "about who he is he himself is not", "TKD1MLjUc68-00640-00209759-00209991": "vaishnava", "TKD1MLjUc68-00641-00209992-00210182": "he himself not muslim is the whole world", "TKD1MLjUc68-00642-00210183-00210727": "going to say this is not vaishnav", "TKD1MLjUc68-00643-00210728-00210919": "let them say", "TKD1MLjUc68-00644-00210919-00211110": "let them say", "TKD1MLjUc68-00645-00211111-00211391": "what is concern to us", "TKD1MLjUc68-00646-00211392-00211710": "bhagwan approved bhagwan approved in the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00647-00211711-00211910": "registered book of bhagavan their name", "TKD1MLjUc68-00648-00211911-00212015": "is there", "TKD1MLjUc68-00649-00212016-00212198": "whereas you are preaching all over the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00650-00212200-00212398": "world your name is not there in the even", "TKD1MLjUc68-00651-00212400-00212598": "in the registered of bhagavan whole", "TKD1MLjUc68-00652-00212600-00212823": "world cannot receive you oh garland", "TKD1MLjUc68-00653-00212823-00213263": "maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-00654-00213264-00213534": "this is not the symptom main thing", "TKD1MLjUc68-00655-00213535-00213710": "this is the main disease of the whole", "TKD1MLjUc68-00656-00213711-00213958": "world", "TKD1MLjUc68-00657-00213959-00214215": "if i take birth thousands of times still", "TKD1MLjUc68-00658-00214216-00214439": "i cannot convince them they because i", "TKD1MLjUc68-00659-00214440-00214639": "can convince them that they but still", "TKD1MLjUc68-00660-00214640-00214839": "they cannot believe me", "TKD1MLjUc68-00661-00214840-00215055": "i can convince them by the by the mercy", "TKD1MLjUc68-00662-00215056-00215175": "of prophet", "TKD1MLjUc68-00663-00215176-00215351": "i can try my best", "TKD1MLjUc68-00664-00215352-00215567": "they are bound to change but they cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-00665-00215567-00215871": "change because they have some biasedness", "TKD1MLjUc68-00666-00215871-00216094": "they have some biasedness they cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-00667-00216096-00216351": "accept that is a popat cannot change a", "TKD1MLjUc68-00668-00216352-00216494": "maya body", "TKD1MLjUc68-00669-00216496-00216751": "can change but they are biasedness", "TKD1MLjUc68-00670-00216752-00217198": "i cannot accept who are you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00671-00217200-00217910": "is the main problem", "TKD1MLjUc68-00672-00217911-00218206": "is not a matter of joke", "TKD1MLjUc68-00673-00218207-00218503": "such exalted preacher", "TKD1MLjUc68-00674-00218504-00218687": "if you can show me one", "TKD1MLjUc68-00675-00218688-00218998": "in the world", "TKD1MLjUc68-00676-00219000-00219294": "in the whole world you can say one his", "TKD1MLjUc68-00677-00219296-00219623": "speech his writing", "TKD1MLjUc68-00678-00219623-00219882": "even pop-up speaking i can speak one", "TKD1MLjUc68-00679-00219883-00220191": "instead then all those who are passing", "TKD1MLjUc68-00680-00220192-00220415": "this kind of wrong remark", "TKD1MLjUc68-00681-00220416-00220598": "i'm a hundred percent here they are", "TKD1MLjUc68-00682-00220600-00221027": "going to commit by", "TKD1MLjUc68-00683-00221028-00221287": "successful in that version hundred", "TKD1MLjUc68-00684-00221288-00221487": "percent i can touch school", "TKD1MLjUc68-00685-00221488-00221646": "so much confidence", "TKD1MLjUc68-00686-00221648-00221903": "whatever position he made", "TKD1MLjUc68-00687-00221904-00222063": "have", "TKD1MLjUc68-00688-00222064-00222446": "rank that's not a big matter", "TKD1MLjUc68-00689-00222448-00224158": "his name was actually", "TKD1MLjUc68-00690-00224159-00224471": "he was from a very very bharat raj south", "TKD1MLjUc68-00691-00224471-00224839": "indian bharavraj that got to your family", "TKD1MLjUc68-00692-00224840-00225167": "so high family brahman", "TKD1MLjUc68-00693-00225167-00225455": "he was a resident of dhaka", "TKD1MLjUc68-00694-00225456-00225734": "india that time it was india", "TKD1MLjUc68-00695-00225735-00225934": "and", "TKD1MLjUc68-00696-00225935-00226279": "he was a very excellent student", "TKD1MLjUc68-00697-00226280-00226406": "in the school", "TKD1MLjUc68-00698-00226407-00226742": "he used to read in english medium", "TKD1MLjUc68-00699-00226744-00226942": "is to read in english in the in the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00700-00226944-00227039": "school", "TKD1MLjUc68-00701-00227040-00227382": "in the class okay in the class", "TKD1MLjUc68-00702-00227383-00227567": "and in the school he was a brilliant", "TKD1MLjUc68-00703-00227567-00227703": "student", "TKD1MLjUc68-00704-00227704-00227934": "and also according to his previous", "TKD1MLjUc68-00705-00227935-00228055": "sanskar", "TKD1MLjUc68-00706-00228056-00228263": "he used to read you know so many", "TKD1MLjUc68-00707-00228264-00228494": "scriptural thing everything", "TKD1MLjUc68-00708-00228496-00228775": "he never liked to take made meat fish", "TKD1MLjUc68-00709-00228776-00229055": "onion garlic anything", "TKD1MLjUc68-00710-00229056-00229255": "but all other family members they used", "TKD1MLjUc68-00711-00229256-00229327": "to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00712-00229328-00229431": "it", "TKD1MLjUc68-00713-00229432-00229687": "but his father", "TKD1MLjUc68-00714-00229688-00230046": "and he they used to follow", "TKD1MLjUc68-00715-00230048-00230158": "very", "TKD1MLjUc68-00716-00230159-00230503": "strict rules and regulation", "TKD1MLjUc68-00717-00230504-00230782": "so after when he is growing up", "TKD1MLjUc68-00718-00230783-00230934": "he become", "TKD1MLjUc68-00719-00230935-00231158": "brilliant student", "TKD1MLjUc68-00720-00231159-00231310": "so", "TKD1MLjUc68-00721-00231311-00231775": "suddenly father become very very sick", "TKD1MLjUc68-00722-00231776-00231887": "so sick", "TKD1MLjUc68-00723-00231888-00232103": "there is a life freaks can go away from", "TKD1MLjUc68-00724-00232104-00232327": "this material", "TKD1MLjUc68-00725-00232328-00232487": "in the meanwhile", "TKD1MLjUc68-00726-00232488-00232806": "he got information about", "TKD1MLjUc68-00727-00232807-00233071": "madhya guryamat", "TKD1MLjUc68-00728-00233071-00233319": "when he was small boy gradually growing", "TKD1MLjUc68-00729-00233319-00233527": "up he got the information because his", "TKD1MLjUc68-00730-00233528-00233958": "house was at dhaka a little bit distance", "TKD1MLjUc68-00731-00233959-00234239": "and the city there was maddu goryamat", "TKD1MLjUc68-00732-00234240-00234471": "madhya guriman guryamat", "TKD1MLjUc68-00733-00234471-00234751": "he used to go there", "TKD1MLjUc68-00734-00234752-00235023": "meet with devotees there", "TKD1MLjUc68-00735-00235023-00235215": "used to get some book", "TKD1MLjUc68-00736-00235216-00235510": "to read everything so this way come in", "TKD1MLjUc68-00737-00235511-00235663": "contact", "TKD1MLjUc68-00738-00235664-00235871": "finally", "TKD1MLjUc68-00739-00235871-00236271": "he took decision to come to calcutta", "TKD1MLjUc68-00740-00236271-00236423": "to meet with", "TKD1MLjUc68-00741-00236423-00236934": "bhaktisiddhanta saraswati", "TKD1MLjUc68-00742-00236935-00237191": "so in the name of collecting one very", "TKD1MLjUc68-00743-00237192-00237358": "important medicine which is not", "TKD1MLjUc68-00744-00237359-00237582": "available in dhaka", "TKD1MLjUc68-00745-00237583-00237742": "in the name of", "TKD1MLjUc68-00746-00237744-00237982": "collecting medicine", "TKD1MLjUc68-00747-00237983-00238198": "life-saving medicine which was not", "TKD1MLjUc68-00748-00238200-00238398": "available there in dhaka", "TKD1MLjUc68-00749-00238400-00238623": "he took trouble to come", "TKD1MLjUc68-00750-00238623-00238863": "in calcutta", "TKD1MLjUc68-00751-00238864-00239039": "after that", "TKD1MLjUc68-00752-00239040-00239255": "to collect medicine is not so important", "TKD1MLjUc68-00753-00239256-00239551": "he wanted to meet with prabhupada", "TKD1MLjUc68-00754-00239552-00239679": "when he", "TKD1MLjUc68-00755-00239680-00239871": "wanted to meet his mother medicine were", "TKD1MLjUc68-00756-00239871-00240206": "gone father when gone were gone no no", "TKD1MLjUc68-00757-00240207-00240503": "and a father dying who let him die", "TKD1MLjUc68-00758-00240504-00240758": "he started attending harikatha there was", "TKD1MLjUc68-00759-00240759-00240951": "some function going on proper speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00760-00240952-00241182": "continuously ericata", "TKD1MLjUc68-00761-00241183-00241375": "he took permission from gaurya mate you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00762-00241376-00241575": "know in charge i like to stay here", "TKD1MLjUc68-00763-00241576-00241830": "prophet because morning night paul was", "TKD1MLjUc68-00764-00241831-00242094": "speaking all", "TKD1MLjUc68-00765-00242096-00242382": "after that he wanted to meet with", "TKD1MLjUc68-00766-00242383-00242598": "we meet with prophet", "TKD1MLjUc68-00767-00242600-00242863": "the first sight could realize is my", "TKD1MLjUc68-00768-00242864-00243223": "eternal self i like the case of sadhana", "TKD1MLjUc68-00769-00243223-00243503": "you are my eternal person", "TKD1MLjUc68-00770-00243504-00243758": "though you took birth in german still", "TKD1MLjUc68-00771-00243759-00244023": "you are my eternal person is one kind of", "TKD1MLjUc68-00772-00244023-00244246": "you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-00773-00244248-00244406": "leelah", "TKD1MLjUc68-00774-00244407-00244710": "so this way", "TKD1MLjUc68-00775-00244711-00244967": "he started getting kippah full keeper", "TKD1MLjUc68-00776-00244967-00245087": "apropos", "TKD1MLjUc68-00777-00245088-00245375": "gradually and putting so many questions", "TKD1MLjUc68-00778-00245376-00245591": "to profit and profit giving satisfactory", "TKD1MLjUc68-00779-00245592-00245694": "answer", "TKD1MLjUc68-00780-00245696-00245919": "then he wanted to take shelter if you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00781-00245919-00246406": "could kindly give me shelter yes why not", "TKD1MLjUc68-00782-00246407-00246623": "because his sensitivity was very high", "TKD1MLjUc68-00783-00246623-00246815": "poppad could realize", "TKD1MLjUc68-00784-00246816-00247158": "then after that poppad was bound to give", "TKD1MLjUc68-00785-00247159-00247406": "harinama diksha", "TKD1MLjUc68-00786-00247407-00247567": "to him", "TKD1MLjUc68-00787-00247567-00248958": "and his name was nanda sunu prabhu", "TKD1MLjUc68-00788-00248959-00249127": "wanted to test him", "TKD1MLjUc68-00789-00249128-00249342": "one day proper speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00790-00249344-00249534": "i speak harikathana", "TKD1MLjUc68-00791-00249535-00249719": "yesterday yes", "TKD1MLjUc68-00792-00249719-00249919": "can you write", "TKD1MLjUc68-00793-00249919-00250158": "one thesis about it", "TKD1MLjUc68-00794-00250159-00250358": "if you bless me i can write", "TKD1MLjUc68-00795-00250359-00250598": "and do to write", "TKD1MLjUc68-00796-00250600-00250927": "oh what what", "TKD1MLjUc68-00797-00250928-00251046": "yesterday", "TKD1MLjUc68-00798-00251048-00251327": "he write in such a", "TKD1MLjUc68-00799-00251328-00251487": "excellent way", "TKD1MLjUc68-00800-00251488-00251655": "popat was town", "TKD1MLjUc68-00801-00251656-00251991": "let me see", "TKD1MLjUc68-00802-00251992-00252158": "is very happy", "TKD1MLjUc68-00803-00252159-00252375": "can you write one article", "TKD1MLjUc68-00804-00252376-00252623": "for gauria patrika on the basis of body", "TKD1MLjUc68-00805-00252623-00252894": "harikatha you are here if you permit me", "TKD1MLjUc68-00806-00252896-00253119": "i can do i started right", "TKD1MLjUc68-00807-00253119-00253358": "was very happy", "TKD1MLjUc68-00808-00253359-00253727": "oh so catching power like magnet", "TKD1MLjUc68-00809-00253728-00253967": "can you imagine", "TKD1MLjUc68-00810-00253967-00254175": "what kind of quality they are without", "TKD1MLjUc68-00811-00254176-00254623": "guru barga how you can criticize them", "TKD1MLjUc68-00812-00254623-00254830": "how you can criticize them i'm thinking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00813-00254831-00255103": "how is possible whereas poppad going to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00814-00255104-00255382": "give stan", "TKD1MLjUc68-00815-00255383-00255606": "very shortly popper took decision to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00816-00255607-00255863": "give sannyas to him", "TKD1MLjUc68-00817-00255864-00256087": "prophet never gives anna's before 20", "TKD1MLjUc68-00818-00256088-00256271": "years 25 years", "TKD1MLjUc68-00819-00256271-00256471": "not a matter of you nobody", "TKD1MLjUc68-00820-00256471-00256775": "nobody can dare to speak prophet can you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00821-00256776-00257023": "give me son nobody", "TKD1MLjUc68-00822-00257023-00257215": "they feed fear in front of prophet they", "TKD1MLjUc68-00823-00257216-00257367": "cannot go", "TKD1MLjUc68-00824-00257367-00257591": "no disciple can go openly to prophet", "TKD1MLjUc68-00825-00257592-00257719": "that person", "TKD1MLjUc68-00826-00257719-00257846": "can go", "TKD1MLjUc68-00827-00257848-00258263": "they they fear to enter inside a room", "TKD1MLjUc68-00828-00258264-00258351": "although", "TKD1MLjUc68-00829-00258352-00258775": "it's impossible so much power", "TKD1MLjUc68-00830-00258776-00259006": "so pauper taking decision", "TKD1MLjUc68-00831-00259007-00259206": "whom to give sannyas whom to give", "TKD1MLjUc68-00832-00259207-00259455": "brahmacharya whom to give harinama", "TKD1MLjUc68-00833-00259456-00259734": "diksha all calculation", "TKD1MLjUc68-00834-00259735-00259982": "depend upon prophet nobody can take", "TKD1MLjUc68-00835-00259983-00260142": "decision", "TKD1MLjUc68-00836-00260144-00260406": "nobody can give prescription prabhat you", "TKD1MLjUc68-00837-00260407-00260782": "can give sannyas no nobody can", "TKD1MLjUc68-00838-00260783-00261015": "so he was given sannyas", "TKD1MLjUc68-00839-00261016-00261223": "after giving sannyas what do you mean by", "TKD1MLjUc68-00840-00261223-00261406": "sannyas papa bhanti", "TKD1MLjUc68-00841-00261407-00261679": "wanted to send in different place for", "TKD1MLjUc68-00842-00261680-00261775": "fishing", "TKD1MLjUc68-00843-00261776-00262110": "because his speaking power memory all so", "TKD1MLjUc68-00844-00262111-00262215": "excellent", "TKD1MLjUc68-00845-00262216-00262519": "and especially guru anugata", "TKD1MLjUc68-00846-00262520-00262855": "which is the most vital point", "TKD1MLjUc68-00847-00262856-00263127": "which is the most vital point", "TKD1MLjUc68-00848-00263128-00263430": "if this vital point is missing and all", "TKD1MLjUc68-00849-00263431-00263630": "your quality", "TKD1MLjUc68-00850-00263631-00263823": "zero", "TKD1MLjUc68-00851-00263824-00264023": "all your quality me", "TKD1MLjUc68-00852-00264024-00264334": "you you may think i am qualified", "TKD1MLjUc68-00853-00264335-00264639": "without that quality i can give example", "TKD1MLjUc68-00854-00264640-00264927": "you can go on hearing", "TKD1MLjUc68-00855-00264928-00265247": "so one day paul was speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00856-00265248-00265406": "to the in church", "TKD1MLjUc68-00857-00265407-00265575": "who in charge", "TKD1MLjUc68-00858-00265576-00265743": "of the position", "TKD1MLjUc68-00859-00265744-00267367": "you know the brahmacharyan name of", "TKD1MLjUc68-00860-00267368-00267487": "anyway", "TKD1MLjUc68-00861-00267488-00267695": "so he asking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00862-00267696-00267951": "could you be in charge of the caitanya", "TKD1MLjUc68-00863-00267952-00268182": "you go and buy one", "TKD1MLjUc68-00864-00268183-00268367": "topmost shoe", "TKD1MLjUc68-00865-00268368-00268623": "for maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-00866-00268624-00268791": "the costly", "TKD1MLjUc68-00867-00268792-00268871": "shoe", "TKD1MLjUc68-00868-00268872-00269119": "you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-00869-00269120-00269510": "going to buy and on and on on you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-00870-00269511-00269647": "that time", "TKD1MLjUc68-00871-00269648-00270006": "it was 35 rupees costly", "TKD1MLjUc68-00872-00270007-00270334": "35 rupees means so high price even five", "TKD1MLjUc68-00873-00270335-00270527": "thousand rupees", "TKD1MLjUc68-00874-00270528-00270871": "british at the time of british", "TKD1MLjUc68-00875-00270872-00271223": "five thousand with more than we are", "TKD1MLjUc68-00876-00271224-00271503": "at 20 35 rupees", "TKD1MLjUc68-00877-00271504-00271671": "then", "TKD1MLjUc68-00878-00271672-00271839": "he is going to bring", "TKD1MLjUc68-00879-00271840-00272134": "papad i bring you gift to bon maraj and", "TKD1MLjUc68-00880-00272135-00272406": "ask him to come in front of me wearing", "TKD1MLjUc68-00881-00272407-00272527": "that su", "TKD1MLjUc68-00882-00272528-00272767": "bon mara my bone maharaj is feeling shy", "TKD1MLjUc68-00883-00272768-00273127": "how i can go in front of guru devsu", "TKD1MLjUc68-00884-00273128-00273543": "it is the instruction he cannot violate", "TKD1MLjUc68-00885-00273544-00273743": "the instruction of gurudev", "TKD1MLjUc68-00886-00273744-00274039": "what to do he is feeling shy with shu", "TKD1MLjUc68-00887-00274040-00274391": "where is prohibited for us to wear sue", "TKD1MLjUc68-00888-00274392-00275343": "pablo's feeling come", "TKD1MLjUc68-00889-00275344-00275503": "used to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00890-00275504-00275743": "he used to travel barefooted", "TKD1MLjUc68-00891-00275744-00277103": "without chapel in dhamma", "TKD1MLjUc68-00892-00277104-00277303": "they never like to use", "TKD1MLjUc68-00893-00277304-00277463": "so now", "TKD1MLjUc68-00894-00277464-00277647": "papa speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00895-00277648-00277879": "when bong was coming in front now pope", "TKD1MLjUc68-00896-00277880-00278127": "are speaking now come on", "TKD1MLjUc68-00897-00278128-00278319": "it is called", "TKD1MLjUc68-00898-00278320-00278630": "now you are in perfect reynolds order", "TKD1MLjUc68-00899-00278631-00278855": "because you are going to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00900-00278856-00279127": "you are going to renounce you are going", "TKD1MLjUc68-00901-00279128-00279495": "to renounce your renunciation", "TKD1MLjUc68-00902-00279496-00279695": "today you are going to renounce your", "TKD1MLjUc68-00903-00279696-00279982": "your renunciation for the sake of", "TKD1MLjUc68-00904-00279983-00280182": "bhagavata that is called actual", "TKD1MLjUc68-00905-00280183-00280423": "renunciation", "TKD1MLjUc68-00906-00280424-00280671": "follow your so high point and go your", "TKD1MLjUc68-00907-00280672-00280758": "mind", "TKD1MLjUc68-00908-00280759-00281030": "you can get never know where you can get", "TKD1MLjUc68-00909-00281031-00281191": "where you can get", "TKD1MLjUc68-00910-00281192-00281382": "hundred percent if you are get in touch", "TKD1MLjUc68-00911-00281383-00281695": "with paul path somehow i told the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00912-00281696-00282063": "example of electricity", "TKD1MLjUc68-00913-00282064-00282230": "5000 volt", "TKD1MLjUc68-00914-00282231-00282430": "if you get in touch", "TKD1MLjUc68-00915-00282431-00282639": "proper conductor is there then you can", "TKD1MLjUc68-00916-00282640-00282967": "get otherwise cut", "TKD1MLjUc68-00917-00282968-00283247": "your connection is totally detached from", "TKD1MLjUc68-00918-00283248-00283487": "prabhat how you can expect you can get", "TKD1MLjUc68-00919-00283488-00283799": "power preaching disciple all", "TKD1MLjUc68-00920-00283800-00284110": "one kind of exhibition going on", "TKD1MLjUc68-00921-00284111-00284271": "never mind", "TKD1MLjUc68-00922-00284272-00284454": "exhibition", "TKD1MLjUc68-00923-00284455-00284743": "exhibition and preaching is not same", "TKD1MLjUc68-00924-00284744-00284919": "platform speaker", "TKD1MLjUc68-00925-00284920-00285239": "and harikatha not same", "TKD1MLjUc68-00926-00285240-00285558": "harikata has an impact in your heart", "TKD1MLjUc68-00927-00285559-00285791": "and crush your heart", "TKD1MLjUc68-00928-00285792-00286110": "revealed your heart change your heart", "TKD1MLjUc68-00929-00286111-00286343": "it's called the nature of harikatha", "TKD1MLjUc68-00930-00286344-00286551": "so like thunderbolt", "TKD1MLjUc68-00931-00286552-00286830": "if you are demon that thunderball can go", "TKD1MLjUc68-00932-00286831-00287087": "across your heart", "TKD1MLjUc68-00933-00287088-00287271": "is the nature of harikatha powerful", "TKD1MLjUc68-00934-00287272-00287391": "harikatha", "TKD1MLjUc68-00935-00287392-00287671": "harikada coming from up i already told", "TKD1MLjUc68-00936-00287672-00287951": "message coming from", "TKD1MLjUc68-00937-00287952-00288287": "my father my my grandfather grandfather", "TKD1MLjUc68-00938-00288288-00288495": "they have no right to change him in one", "TKD1MLjUc68-00939-00288496-00288799": "word of what pope are told", "TKD1MLjUc68-00940-00288800-00289039": "intact way i have to preach", "TKD1MLjUc68-00941-00289040-00289382": "speak that is called harikatha", "TKD1MLjUc68-00942-00289383-00289606": "and one pure sadhu", "TKD1MLjUc68-00943-00289607-00289943": "we have some direct link with parampara", "TKD1MLjUc68-00944-00289944-00290167": "it is you can write you can write", "TKD1MLjUc68-00945-00290168-00290391": "hundred percent he can never make any", "TKD1MLjUc68-00946-00290392-00290654": "mistake in siddhanta", "TKD1MLjUc68-00947-00290655-00290871": "a symptom", "TKD1MLjUc68-00948-00290872-00291127": "is a vital symptom", "TKD1MLjUc68-00949-00291128-00291287": "if he is in connection with guru", "TKD1MLjUc68-00950-00291288-00291463": "parampara vitaly", "TKD1MLjUc68-00951-00291464-00291719": "there can be no mistake in his writing", "TKD1MLjUc68-00952-00291720-00291919": "speech in there no", "TKD1MLjUc68-00953-00291920-00292095": "no mistake can be there", "TKD1MLjUc68-00954-00292096-00292327": "sit down to mistake maybe type mistake", "TKD1MLjUc68-00955-00292328-00292495": "can be there", "TKD1MLjUc68-00956-00292496-00292758": "not possible if siddhanta mistake surely", "TKD1MLjUc68-00957-00292759-00293047": "he is not in parampara line", "TKD1MLjUc68-00958-00293048-00293295": "whole world foolish they cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-00959-00293296-00293503": "understand those", "TKD1MLjUc68-00960-00293504-00293623": "someday if", "TKD1MLjUc68-00961-00293624-00293839": "they can understand", "TKD1MLjUc68-00962-00293840-00294182": "those very secret points i am speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-00963-00294183-00294471": "hundred percent i can give guarantee", "TKD1MLjUc68-00964-00294472-00295079": "they can realize", "TKD1MLjUc68-00965-00295080-00295287": "they can realize hundred percent i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-00966-00295288-00295606": "give so confidence i have", "TKD1MLjUc68-00967-00295607-00295839": "so poppa speaking now come on you are", "TKD1MLjUc68-00968-00295840-00296087": "now today you are going to renounce your", "TKD1MLjUc68-00969-00296088-00296254": "renunciation", "TKD1MLjUc68-00970-00296255-00296551": "perfect this is called", "TKD1MLjUc68-00971-00296552-00296743": "so poppad used to", "TKD1MLjUc68-00972-00296744-00296895": "you know give instruction to boon", "TKD1MLjUc68-00973-00296896-00297182": "maharaj always you will have to wear", "TKD1MLjUc68-00974-00297183-00297710": "shoot pants", "TKD1MLjUc68-00975-00297711-00298023": "to go to preach", "TKD1MLjUc68-00976-00298024-00298127": "england", "TKD1MLjUc68-00977-00298128-00298447": "germany", "TKD1MLjUc68-00978-00298448-00298567": "that time", "TKD1MLjUc68-00979-00298568-00298927": "very important don't try to forget this", "TKD1MLjUc68-00980-00298928-00299167": "if you want to challenge me i can give", "TKD1MLjUc68-00981-00299168-00299423": "the book you can read", "TKD1MLjUc68-00982-00299424-00299591": "nobody", "TKD1MLjUc68-00983-00299592-00299871": "in this world can challenge if at all", "TKD1MLjUc68-00984-00299872-00300054": "the challenge you can open the book and", "TKD1MLjUc68-00985-00300055-00300367": "there the very vital point", "TKD1MLjUc68-00986-00300368-00300606": "where that rabindranath takur the", "TKD1MLjUc68-00987-00300607-00300799": "nobel laureate", "TKD1MLjUc68-00988-00300800-00300999": "he was the nobel laureate for his", "TKD1MLjUc68-00989-00301000-00301279": "philosophy i mean writings", "TKD1MLjUc68-00990-00301280-00301415": "that time", "TKD1MLjUc68-00991-00301416-00301534": "he got", "TKD1MLjUc68-00992-00301535-00301854": "night titan night night upadhi", "TKD1MLjUc68-00993-00301855-00302006": "from england", "TKD1MLjUc68-00994-00302007-00302510": "he got you know he was a nobel laureate", "TKD1MLjUc68-00995-00302511-00302830": "he just came back that time", "TKD1MLjUc68-00996-00302831-00303119": "at that time he just came back from", "TKD1MLjUc68-00997-00303120-00303510": "foreign country after you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-00998-00303511-00303882": "passing lecture different players", "TKD1MLjUc68-00999-00303883-00304191": "then by chance", "TKD1MLjUc68-01000-00304192-00304415": "by chance paupad and robin nana takur", "TKD1MLjUc68-01001-00304416-00304575": "was", "TKD1MLjUc68-01002-00304576-00304743": "in one place", "TKD1MLjUc68-01003-00304744-00304919": "by chance to meet with each other", "TKD1MLjUc68-01004-00304920-00305087": "ravenna takur", "TKD1MLjUc68-01005-00305088-00305206": "robina", "TKD1MLjUc68-01006-00305207-00306047": "tagore and", "TKD1MLjUc68-01007-00306048-00306279": "from his very young age", "TKD1MLjUc68-01008-00306280-00306463": "they had a friendship with that takuru", "TKD1MLjUc68-01009-00306464-00306654": "bharati takurvari mean", "TKD1MLjUc68-01010-00306655-00306823": "takurbar", "TKD1MLjUc68-01011-00306824-00306991": "their title", "TKD1MLjUc68-01012-00306992-00307182": "they have relationship bhaktivinoda", "TKD1MLjUc68-01013-00307183-00307430": "tagore many time used to come", "TKD1MLjUc68-01014-00307431-00307687": "from service in bali saw here you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01015-00307688-00307895": "qatar used to stay", "TKD1MLjUc68-01016-00307896-00308047": "in the house", "TKD1MLjUc68-01017-00308048-00308287": "of ravina taku because his elder brother", "TKD1MLjUc68-01018-00308288-00308558": "was a friend of bhaktivinoda taku", "TKD1MLjUc68-01019-00308559-00308751": "his elder brother was a friend of", "TKD1MLjUc68-01020-00308752-00308958": "bhaktivinoda talked about used to say", "TKD1MLjUc68-01021-00308959-00309103": "elder brother", "TKD1MLjUc68-01022-00309104-00309503": "not friend elder brother", "TKD1MLjUc68-01023-00309504-00309806": "that time uh prabhas asking to ravino", "TKD1MLjUc68-01024-00309807-00309943": "taku", "TKD1MLjUc68-01025-00309944-00310158": "could you please inform me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01026-00310159-00310327": "that what will", "TKD1MLjUc68-01027-00310328-00310479": "be the result", "TKD1MLjUc68-01028-00310480-00310743": "what will be the net result if i now at", "TKD1MLjUc68-01029-00310744-00311071": "present when you come back now if i send", "TKD1MLjUc68-01030-00311072-00311254": "some messenger", "TKD1MLjUc68-01031-00311255-00311423": "to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01032-00311424-00311751": "england german what kind of result i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01033-00311752-00312158": "expect", "TKD1MLjUc68-01034-00312159-00312471": "how could we not have speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01035-00312472-00312679": "no response you can get", "TKD1MLjUc68-01036-00312680-00312871": "especially england", "TKD1MLjUc68-01037-00312872-00313006": "because they are", "TKD1MLjUc68-01038-00313007-00313151": "because", "TKD1MLjUc68-01039-00313152-00313351": "basically england", "TKD1MLjUc68-01040-00313352-00313615": "they are dominating india indian people", "TKD1MLjUc68-01041-00313616-00313863": "so they think we are the authority", "TKD1MLjUc68-01042-00313864-00314047": "so if they are feeling we are the", "TKD1MLjUc68-01043-00314048-00314263": "authority who is going to hear from a", "TKD1MLjUc68-01044-00314264-00314454": "servant they think all indian people", "TKD1MLjUc68-01045-00314455-00314591": "they are servant", "TKD1MLjUc68-01046-00314592-00314967": "so better don't go to england", "TKD1MLjUc68-01047-00314968-00315199": "because they are not ready they are so", "TKD1MLjUc68-01048-00315200-00315463": "much false ago", "TKD1MLjUc68-01049-00315464-00315734": "german something favorable they are", "TKD1MLjUc68-01050-00315735-00315863": "going to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01051-00315864-00316054": "they are very interested about indian", "TKD1MLjUc68-01052-00316055-00316551": "philosophy", "TKD1MLjUc68-01053-00316552-00316679": "you can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01054-00316680-00316991": "but at present you don't send anybody", "TKD1MLjUc68-01055-00316992-00317367": "you cannot get result i think", "TKD1MLjUc68-01056-00317368-00317799": "then prabhas started speaking harikatha", "TKD1MLjUc68-01057-00317800-00318158": "about the vital teachings of government", "TKD1MLjUc68-01058-00318159-00318351": "in honduras", "TKD1MLjUc68-01059-00318352-00318639": "after speaking marathon speech after one", "TKD1MLjUc68-01060-00318640-00318854": "and a half hour", "TKD1MLjUc68-01061-00318855-00319127": "ravino attack speaking well", "TKD1MLjUc68-01062-00319128-00319391": "if you yourself going to any foreign", "TKD1MLjUc68-01063-00319392-00319654": "country anytime", "TKD1MLjUc68-01064-00319655-00319910": "irrespective of time factor", "TKD1MLjUc68-01065-00319911-00320247": "and space", "TKD1MLjUc68-01066-00320248-00320999": "you can get success", "TKD1MLjUc68-01067-00321000-00321310": "anytime any country", "TKD1MLjUc68-01068-00321311-00321503": "it matters little which position which", "TKD1MLjUc68-01069-00321504-00321695": "country you can go us you can come", "TKD1MLjUc68-01070-00321696-00321806": "outside", "TKD1MLjUc68-01071-00321807-00322110": "like a man like you a sadhu like you so", "TKD1MLjUc68-01072-00322111-00322303": "powerful", "TKD1MLjUc68-01073-00322304-00322519": "because many useless sadhu", "TKD1MLjUc68-01074-00322520-00322775": "because many useless sadhu", "TKD1MLjUc68-01075-00322776-00322967": "they went to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01076-00322968-00323230": "foreign country romania speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01077-00323231-00323415": "they wanted to take undue advantage", "TKD1MLjUc68-01078-00323416-00323703": "speaking all rubbish philosophy", "TKD1MLjUc68-01079-00323704-00323943": "they're getting clapping in chicago here", "TKD1MLjUc68-01080-00323944-00324223": "they are", "TKD1MLjUc68-01081-00324224-00324479": "fully serious people", "TKD1MLjUc68-01082-00324480-00324582": "chicago", "TKD1MLjUc68-01083-00324583-00324854": "passing kormi material people", "TKD1MLjUc68-01084-00324855-00325134": "kormi they are eating eating fish meat", "TKD1MLjUc68-01085-00325135-00325358": "everything they are passing lecture on", "TKD1MLjUc68-01086-00325359-00325575": "hindu dharma what they know about hindu", "TKD1MLjUc68-01087-00325576-00325695": "dharma", "TKD1MLjUc68-01088-00325696-00325967": "what they know about hindustan", "TKD1MLjUc68-01089-00325968-00326110": "when muslim", "TKD1MLjUc68-01090-00326111-00326295": "and you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01091-00326296-00326734": "hindu fighting took place about ayodhya", "TKD1MLjUc68-01092-00326735-00327030": "ayodha ram mandir and you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01093-00327031-00327151": "masjid", "TKD1MLjUc68-01094-00327152-00327406": "it was a pre-plan", "TKD1MLjUc68-01095-00327407-00327815": "so many long history", "TKD1MLjUc68-01096-00327816-00328023": "that time fighting two place", "TKD1MLjUc68-01097-00328024-00328310": "then the reporter went to their society", "TKD1MLjUc68-01098-00328311-00328510": "so what you possible", "TKD1MLjUc68-01099-00328511-00328743": "you are hindu na but they say we are not", "TKD1MLjUc68-01100-00328744-00329030": "hindu in newspaper it came out", "TKD1MLjUc68-01101-00329031-00329230": "they're saying we are not hindu that if", "TKD1MLjUc68-01102-00329231-00329375": "you are not hindu", "TKD1MLjUc68-01103-00329376-00329678": "then how you are going to pass you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01104-00329679-00329895": "lecture about hindu dharma", "TKD1MLjUc68-01105-00329896-00330206": "whereas you believe in karma gan maximum", "TKD1MLjUc68-01106-00330207-00330415": "gan not gan also", "TKD1MLjUc68-01107-00330416-00330695": "karma", "TKD1MLjUc68-01108-00330696-00331030": "in chicago when swamiji went there", "TKD1MLjUc68-01109-00331031-00331287": "and passing lecture my sisters and", "TKD1MLjUc68-01110-00331288-00331495": "brothers from america", "TKD1MLjUc68-01111-00331496-00331775": "and with this word they getting clapping", "TKD1MLjUc68-01112-00331776-00332095": "for 15 minutes all people", "TKD1MLjUc68-01113-00332096-00332351": "that was a success because american", "TKD1MLjUc68-01114-00332352-00332519": "people they are foolish and they are", "TKD1MLjUc68-01115-00332520-00332839": "foolish i am not speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01116-00332840-00333030": "i am not speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01117-00333031-00333367": "you know george washington told", "TKD1MLjUc68-01118-00333368-00333551": "one day", "TKD1MLjUc68-01119-00333552-00333687": "yes", "TKD1MLjUc68-01120-00333688-00333887": "abraham lincoln the first president", "TKD1MLjUc68-01121-00333888-00334167": "after that george washington", "TKD1MLjUc68-01122-00334168-00334495": "in a mammoth gathering he was speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01123-00334496-00334710": "an election and", "TKD1MLjUc68-01124-00334711-00334967": "after speaking is speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01125-00334968-00335263": "uh", "TKD1MLjUc68-01126-00335264-00335430": "inter population", "TKD1MLjUc68-01127-00335431-00335543": "i know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01128-00335544-00335719": "now but", "TKD1MLjUc68-01129-00335720-00336039": "50 percent of the population", "TKD1MLjUc68-01130-00336040-00336295": "50 percent of the population american", "TKD1MLjUc68-01131-00336296-00336630": "population they are foolish number one", "TKD1MLjUc68-01132-00336631-00336878": "then started education why you speak", "TKD1MLjUc68-01133-00336879-00337206": "they are started agitation", "TKD1MLjUc68-01134-00337207-00337391": "they are shouting why you say we are", "TKD1MLjUc68-01135-00337392-00337678": "police we are american people", "TKD1MLjUc68-01136-00337679-00337934": "then george was in the way way i am", "TKD1MLjUc68-01137-00337935-00338151": "mistake excuse me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01138-00338152-00338406": "what speaking 50 percent of the american", "TKD1MLjUc68-01139-00338407-00338654": "people they are wise and 50 percent of", "TKD1MLjUc68-01140-00338655-00338967": "the american people are foolish", "TKD1MLjUc68-01141-00338968-00339182": "they cannot understand that same thing", "TKD1MLjUc68-01142-00339183-00339391": "in your", "TKD1MLjUc68-01143-00339392-00339551": "same thing", "TKD1MLjUc68-01144-00339552-00339806": "so police people how we can expect they", "TKD1MLjUc68-01145-00339807-00340182": "can realize you know bhagavan", "TKD1MLjUc68-01146-00340183-00340503": "so police same thing is speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01147-00340504-00340782": "way way way way i mistake", "TKD1MLjUc68-01148-00340783-00340999": "some days same thing happen", "TKD1MLjUc68-01149-00341000-00341206": "i speak to some you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01150-00341207-00341310": "brahmos", "TKD1MLjUc68-01151-00341311-00341599": "they are there i say", "TKD1MLjUc68-01152-00341600-00341951": "you know this way i say yeah you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01153-00341952-00342358": "patapatta what i mean actually goat", "TKD1MLjUc68-01154-00342359-00342582": "you see me goat", "TKD1MLjUc68-01155-00342583-00342799": "sorry i may make mistake you are", "TKD1MLjUc68-01156-00342800-00342927": "ramchagal", "TKD1MLjUc68-01157-00342928-00343303": "ramen number one chugga ram channel one", "TKD1MLjUc68-01158-00343304-00343510": "special category of channel when you're", "TKD1MLjUc68-01159-00343511-00343734": "objecting why you speak me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01160-00343735-00344103": "chagal mean goat goat", "TKD1MLjUc68-01161-00344104-00344375": "fast only object i'm sorry i can see you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01162-00344376-00344575": "are ram chagal", "TKD1MLjUc68-01163-00344576-00344847": "ram is there oh nice now wise but", "TKD1MLjUc68-01164-00344848-00345151": "ramjakul is more you know he is inferior", "TKD1MLjUc68-01165-00345152-00345430": "then he cannot understand ram is there", "TKD1MLjUc68-01166-00345431-00345678": "so he's good", "TKD1MLjUc68-01167-00345679-00346127": "follow how to make full of you you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01168-00346128-00346343": "this way", "TKD1MLjUc68-01169-00346344-00346575": "actually they get kept clapping all in", "TKD1MLjUc68-01170-00346576-00346751": "newspaper everything preaching by what", "TKD1MLjUc68-01171-00346752-00347015": "preaching actual preaching done", "TKD1MLjUc68-01172-00347016-00347119": "if you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01173-00347120-00347367": "are in neutral position", "TKD1MLjUc68-01174-00347368-00347591": "if you have some particular then you do", "TKD1MLjUc68-01175-00347592-00347710": "come to me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01176-00347711-00347934": "if you are neutral position", "TKD1MLjUc68-01177-00347935-00348310": "i mean with prabhupada then you must say", "TKD1MLjUc68-01178-00348311-00348527": "then ravinder taku speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01179-00348528-00348647": "if a", "TKD1MLjUc68-01180-00348648-00348903": "gigantic personality like you going to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01181-00348904-00349206": "america speaking to prophet then anytime", "TKD1MLjUc68-01182-00349207-00349430": "you can come out successful", "TKD1MLjUc68-01183-00349431-00349703": "then what was the remark of papa", "TKD1MLjUc68-01184-00349704-00349910": "i can show you from book", "TKD1MLjUc68-01185-00349911-00350047": "papa speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01186-00350048-00350278": "i can send", "TKD1MLjUc68-01187-00350279-00350558": "some such a messenger who is just good", "TKD1MLjUc68-01188-00350559-00350782": "like me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01189-00350783-00350982": "follow what try to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01190-00350983-00351191": "record this point", "TKD1MLjUc68-01191-00351192-00351430": "you can publish it you know you can make", "TKD1MLjUc68-01192-00351431-00351663": "clipping", "TKD1MLjUc68-01193-00351664-00351871": "proper speaking i am going to send such", "TKD1MLjUc68-01194-00351872-00352367": "a messenger who is as good as me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01195-00352368-00352495": "and then", "TKD1MLjUc68-01196-00352496-00352647": "sending whom", "TKD1MLjUc68-01197-00352648-00352903": "sending bongo see maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-01198-00352904-00353191": "took decision to send brahmacari", "TKD1MLjUc68-01199-00353192-00353463": "took decision to send goswami maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-01200-00353464-00353782": "took decision to send bhakti pradeep", "TKD1MLjUc68-01201-00353783-00353951": "now you are going to say they are all", "TKD1MLjUc68-01202-00353952-00354158": "idiot they are not preacher i am", "TKD1MLjUc68-01203-00354159-00354478": "preacher how i can digest how i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01204-00354479-00354743": "digest please you speak me if you are in", "TKD1MLjUc68-01205-00354744-00354951": "my position what you can do", "TKD1MLjUc68-01206-00354952-00355175": "is somebody going to criticize", "TKD1MLjUc68-01207-00355176-00355430": "ah useless the only way to collect some", "TKD1MLjUc68-01208-00355431-00355654": "money and you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01209-00355655-00355919": "lead their life if i go", "TKD1MLjUc68-01210-00355920-00356119": "if binda they be permitted by guru", "TKD1MLjUc68-01211-00356120-00356271": "maharaj by me someday i can go on", "TKD1MLjUc68-01212-00356272-00356463": "discussing all in details", "TKD1MLjUc68-01213-00356464-00356767": "about my guru", "TKD1MLjUc68-01214-00356768-00357039": "maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-01215-00357040-00357215": "limitless", "TKD1MLjUc68-01216-00357216-00357606": "kripa they got from paw patrol", "TKD1MLjUc68-01217-00357607-00357854": "the limitless if i go on discussing you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01218-00357855-00357975": "can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01219-00357976-00358103": "go mad", "TKD1MLjUc68-01220-00358104-00358375": "how extensive preaching was done by", "TKD1MLjUc68-01221-00358376-00359143": "banango maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-01222-00359144-00359310": "how it is possible when probably", "TKD1MLjUc68-01223-00359311-00359630": "speaking i am going to send a messenger", "TKD1MLjUc68-01224-00359631-00359934": "just as good as me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01225-00359935-00360158": "like you can remember when", "TKD1MLjUc68-01226-00360159-00360423": "go when krishna bhagavan told", "TKD1MLjUc68-01227-00360424-00360606": "to udhab", "TKD1MLjUc68-01228-00360607-00360951": "uddhab is no less than me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01229-00360952-00361191": "i told you now you can remember udob is", "TKD1MLjUc68-01230-00361192-00361892": "no less than me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01231-00361893-00362078": "[Applause]", "TKD1MLjUc68-01232-00362079-00362399": "not like a gapping of atom", "TKD1MLjUc68-01233-00362400-00363382": "atom you know at all", "TKD1MLjUc68-01234-00363383-00363639": "even that that much difference is not", "TKD1MLjUc68-01235-00363640-00363943": "there i mean what is", "TKD1MLjUc68-01236-00363944-00364254": "that is i myself", "TKD1MLjUc68-01237-00364255-00364399": "that's me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01238-00364400-00364710": "so dear vishnu they explained", "TKD1MLjUc68-01239-00364711-00364967": "gosvami marriage is so dear to prabhat", "TKD1MLjUc68-01240-00364968-00365206": "that papad is bound to say", "TKD1MLjUc68-01241-00365207-00365471": "i am going to send", "TKD1MLjUc68-01242-00365472-00365647": "such", "TKD1MLjUc68-01243-00365648-00365751": "you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01244-00365752-00366015": "messenger who is as good at me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01245-00366016-00366151": "brahmacharya", "TKD1MLjUc68-01246-00366152-00366503": "someday i can discuss", "TKD1MLjUc68-01247-00366504-00366710": "how much love and affection", "TKD1MLjUc68-01248-00366711-00367367": "brahmacharya and mother gosh god", "TKD1MLjUc68-01249-00367368-00367615": "continuously setting tears", "TKD1MLjUc68-01250-00367616-00367775": "cannot speak", "TKD1MLjUc68-01251-00367776-00367958": "when madoka semi has gone from this", "TKD1MLjUc68-01252-00367959-00368087": "material world", "TKD1MLjUc68-01253-00368088-00368230": "in the assembly", "TKD1MLjUc68-01254-00368231-00368487": "banugashima cannot speak each and every", "TKD1MLjUc68-01255-00368488-00368575": "word", "TKD1MLjUc68-01256-00368576-00368647": "is", "TKD1MLjUc68-01257-00368648-00368799": "choked up", "TKD1MLjUc68-01258-00368800-00369182": "and said in tears", "TKD1MLjUc68-01259-00369183-00369543": "madoka mahaj gone mean we are getting", "TKD1MLjUc68-01260-00369544-00369719": "we are getting", "TKD1MLjUc68-01261-00369720-00369927": "same experience like prabhupada gone", "TKD1MLjUc68-01262-00369928-00370199": "from this material world", "TKD1MLjUc68-01263-00370200-00370454": "total idealism of prabhupada banu", "TKD1MLjUc68-01264-00370455-00370647": "simmons confessed", "TKD1MLjUc68-01265-00370648-00370878": "in a writing and speaking to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01266-00370879-00371082": "everywhere", "TKD1MLjUc68-01267-00371083-00371471": "madhukus is the perfect idealism", "TKD1MLjUc68-01268-00371472-00371671": "of the preaching", "TKD1MLjUc68-01269-00371672-00371758": "and", "TKD1MLjUc68-01270-00371759-00371927": "you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01271-00371928-00372199": "preaching and everything all adequacy or", "TKD1MLjUc68-01272-00372200-00372319": "everything", "TKD1MLjUc68-01273-00372320-00372502": "maybe you can discover mother gushing", "TKD1MLjUc68-01274-00372503-00373075": "and not gone to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01275-00373076-00373382": "foreign ready but after they had some", "TKD1MLjUc68-01276-00373383-00373543": "senior devotee", "TKD1MLjUc68-01277-00373544-00373782": "speaking maharaja prabhupada if you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01278-00373783-00373902": "never mind", "TKD1MLjUc68-01279-00373903-00374151": "it is not our instruction", "TKD1MLjUc68-01280-00374152-00374319": "it is foreign country", "TKD1MLjUc68-01281-00374320-00374558": "and why brahmachar is so nice looking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01282-00374559-00374830": "attractive", "TKD1MLjUc68-01283-00374831-00375071": "this big problem can be there because", "TKD1MLjUc68-01284-00375072-00375239": "foreign country you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01285-00375240-00375551": "america france", "TKD1MLjUc68-01286-00375552-00375847": "so nice looking hand up to this sahaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-01287-00375848-00376127": "yoga this chest", "TKD1MLjUc68-01288-00376128-00376358": "so nice", "TKD1MLjUc68-01289-00376359-00376639": "if you send some problem though mother", "TKD1MLjUc68-01290-00376640-00376871": "mother goshima", "TKD1MLjUc68-01291-00376872-00377030": "problem is that then", "TKD1MLjUc68-01292-00377031-00377247": "it happens so", "TKD1MLjUc68-01293-00377248-00377567": "many times it happens so i can come and", "TKD1MLjUc68-01294-00377568-00377806": "someday i can discuss about", "TKD1MLjUc68-01295-00377807-00378206": "you know bhakti-shodha asram maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-01296-00378207-00378399": "he used to preach in", "TKD1MLjUc68-01297-00378400-00378606": "that day i was speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01298-00378607-00378815": "popeye engaged him in cult cultivation", "TKD1MLjUc68-01299-00378816-00378975": "job i told you now he's very nice", "TKD1MLjUc68-01300-00378976-00379158": "looking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01301-00379159-00379482": "he's you know taking the sack of paddy", "TKD1MLjUc68-01302-00379483-00379782": "weight to test", "TKD1MLjUc68-01303-00379783-00379967": "you feel some you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01304-00379968-00380230": "it did it did delegate or not", "TKD1MLjUc68-01305-00380231-00380527": "after the sent to madras for pitching", "TKD1MLjUc68-01306-00380528-00380710": "in madras", "TKD1MLjUc68-01307-00380711-00380991": "you know is preaching so nice preaching", "TKD1MLjUc68-01308-00380992-00381223": "can speak different language hindi", "TKD1MLjUc68-01309-00381224-00381439": "english bengali", "TKD1MLjUc68-01310-00381440-00381743": "one and a very rich family", "TKD1MLjUc68-01311-00381744-00382063": "and is from england", "TKD1MLjUc68-01312-00382064-00382295": "that lady came husband", "TKD1MLjUc68-01313-00382296-00382439": "already", "TKD1MLjUc68-01314-00382440-00382623": "she", "TKD1MLjUc68-01315-00382624-00382758": "wanted to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01316-00382759-00383095": "arrange the marriage of her daughter", "TKD1MLjUc68-01317-00383096-00383199": "with", "TKD1MLjUc68-01318-00383200-00383430": "bhakti asrama that time he was not", "TKD1MLjUc68-01319-00383431-00383702": "sannyas brahmachari", "TKD1MLjUc68-01320-00383703-00383910": "his name was", "TKD1MLjUc68-01321-00383911-00384406": "not vermicelli that time his name was", "TKD1MLjUc68-01322-00384407-00384510": "prabhu", "TKD1MLjUc68-01323-00384511-00384702": "both of brit", "TKD1MLjUc68-01324-00384703-00384863": "you don't understand the meaning someday", "TKD1MLjUc68-01325-00384864-00385254": "i can explain about can come because it", "TKD1MLjUc68-01326-00385255-00385415": "is overlapping", "TKD1MLjUc68-01327-00385416-00385606": "some so um", "TKD1MLjUc68-01328-00385607-00385927": "at a time two or three thirty cannot get", "TKD1MLjUc68-01329-00385928-00386102": "separately or", "TKD1MLjUc68-01330-00386103-00386399": "one day before or after", "TKD1MLjUc68-01331-00386400-00386734": "he wanted to arrange the beautiful lady", "TKD1MLjUc68-01332-00386735-00386982": "girl wanted to annoy", "TKD1MLjUc68-01333-00386983-00387223": "can you marry my daughter", "TKD1MLjUc68-01334-00387224-00387447": "and go to my country i can give all my", "TKD1MLjUc68-01335-00387448-00387751": "property to you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01336-00387752-00388054": "how many pound costly", "TKD1MLjUc68-01337-00388055-00388263": "and a cost of that", "TKD1MLjUc68-01338-00388264-00388463": "but those who are enjoying kippah", "TKD1MLjUc68-01339-00388464-00389030": "prabhupada how maya can touch them", "TKD1MLjUc68-01340-00389031-00389191": "this way a high group of machary is", "TKD1MLjUc68-01341-00389192-00389415": "going to foreign country no problem i", "TKD1MLjUc68-01342-00389416-00389647": "keep from chinese you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01343-00389648-00389863": "but still popart", "TKD1MLjUc68-01344-00389864-00390151": "uh didn't like to take any risks", "TKD1MLjUc68-01345-00390152-00390295": "okay", "TKD1MLjUc68-01346-00390296-00390478": "this way", "TKD1MLjUc68-01347-00390479-00390719": "when pope are speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01348-00390720-00390991": "that they are as good as me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01349-00390992-00391247": "and if i going to pass remark", "TKD1MLjUc68-01350-00391248-00391463": "they all went to foreign country fishing", "TKD1MLjUc68-01351-00391464-00391623": "for they are useless they wanted to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01352-00391624-00391895": "collect money and keep in their bank", "TKD1MLjUc68-01353-00391896-00392082": "they have not done any guru", "TKD1MLjUc68-01354-00392083-00392351": "sheva then how much", "TKD1MLjUc68-01355-00392352-00392567": "what kind of offense i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01356-00392568-00392878": "incur that is a big problem never mind i", "TKD1MLjUc68-01357-00392879-00393127": "am neutral point i love everybody all", "TKD1MLjUc68-01358-00393128-00393399": "guru work but i will have to speak it", "TKD1MLjUc68-01359-00393400-00393582": "without that you can think whole world", "TKD1MLjUc68-01360-00393583-00393830": "can think really they are useless", "TKD1MLjUc68-01361-00393831-00394054": "so it is my target before leaving this", "TKD1MLjUc68-01362-00394055-00394191": "body", "TKD1MLjUc68-01363-00394192-00394454": "it is my turkey is my resolution", "TKD1MLjUc68-01364-00394455-00394687": "that before leaving this body i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01365-00394688-00395063": "glorify all of my guru of all men", "TKD1MLjUc68-01366-00395064-00395230": "maximum", "TKD1MLjUc68-01367-00395231-00395567": "i can try to glorify i try to project", "TKD1MLjUc68-01368-00395568-00395791": "their glories in front of the world you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01369-00395792-00395919": "see how much", "TKD1MLjUc68-01370-00395920-00396182": "you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01371-00396183-00396575": "creeper they received from pauper", "TKD1MLjUc68-01372-00396576-00396847": "if i can shout and speak i have received", "TKD1MLjUc68-01373-00396848-00397143": "full kippah gurudev", "TKD1MLjUc68-01374-00397144-00397382": "if i shout like a mat", "TKD1MLjUc68-01375-00397383-00397623": "it isn't that cannot prove that you are", "TKD1MLjUc68-01376-00397624-00397830": "enjoying kripa", "TKD1MLjUc68-01377-00397831-00398127": "it depends your activity your speech", "TKD1MLjUc68-01378-00398128-00398367": "your writing all your activity your", "TKD1MLjUc68-01379-00398368-00398510": "behavior", "TKD1MLjUc68-01380-00398511-00398710": "can prove that you are enjoying guru", "TKD1MLjUc68-01381-00398711-00398871": "keeper", "TKD1MLjUc68-01382-00398872-00399078": "gurukul is not a matter of advertisement", "TKD1MLjUc68-01383-00399079-00399167": "i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01384-00399168-00399358": "make the picture of gurudev", "TKD1MLjUc68-01385-00399359-00399615": "i gurudev enjoy not that automatically", "TKD1MLjUc68-01386-00399616-00399767": "people can know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01387-00399768-00400039": "so they are the top most saver papad", "TKD1MLjUc68-01388-00400040-00400215": "himself", "TKD1MLjUc68-01389-00400216-00400351": "sent them", "TKD1MLjUc68-01390-00400352-00400758": "in", "TKD1MLjUc68-01391-00400759-00401006": "wanted to propose", "TKD1MLjUc68-01392-00401007-00401247": "better you can first send to jama", "TKD1MLjUc68-01393-00401248-00401582": "because i'm a little bit favorable", "TKD1MLjUc68-01394-00401583-00401830": "when proper told i'm going to send such", "TKD1MLjUc68-01395-00401831-00402063": "a messenger as good as me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01396-00402064-00402319": "then rohingya is okay first of all you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01397-00402320-00402423": "can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01398-00402424-00402687": "start in german", "TKD1MLjUc68-01399-00402688-00403119": "follow but bonuses are speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01400-00403120-00403263": "if you never mind", "TKD1MLjUc68-01401-00403264-00403654": "i like to take the typical tucks fast", "TKD1MLjUc68-01402-00403655-00403878": "those are very enjoying guru keeper now", "TKD1MLjUc68-01403-00403879-00404102": "they never fear", "TKD1MLjUc68-01404-00404103-00404310": "they never fear", "TKD1MLjUc68-01405-00404311-00404471": "proper", "TKD1MLjUc68-01406-00404472-00404743": "if you never mind i like to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01407-00404744-00404927": "accept the fast", "TKD1MLjUc68-01408-00404928-00405182": "pass to talks i mean i like to preach in", "TKD1MLjUc68-01409-00405183-00405287": "england", "TKD1MLjUc68-01410-00405288-00405510": "because if i am successful in england", "TKD1MLjUc68-01411-00405511-00405727": "then surely i can get success in german", "TKD1MLjUc68-01412-00405728-00405958": "no problem but at that time there was", "TKD1MLjUc68-01413-00405959-00406119": "fighting in german", "TKD1MLjUc68-01414-00406120-00406478": "they are enemy to each other big problem", "TKD1MLjUc68-01415-00406479-00406615": "big problem", "TKD1MLjUc68-01416-00406616-00406919": "then say mahaj going to england", "TKD1MLjUc68-01417-00406920-00407023": "and", "TKD1MLjUc68-01418-00407024-00407239": "what i can speak in 10 minutes five", "TKD1MLjUc68-01419-00407240-00407519": "minutes two hours", "TKD1MLjUc68-01420-00407520-00407663": "how i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01421-00407664-00407887": "speak all about their glory it is one", "TKD1MLjUc68-01422-00407888-00408087": "kind of funny", "TKD1MLjUc68-01423-00408088-00408295": "i am making funny in front of you i", "TKD1MLjUc68-01424-00408296-00408591": "cannot speak their glory", "TKD1MLjUc68-01425-00408592-00408847": "i am joking with you all but i can speak", "TKD1MLjUc68-01426-00408848-00409206": "so long you know what they have done", "TKD1MLjUc68-01427-00409207-00409639": "so in england gone they have speeching", "TKD1MLjUc68-01428-00409639-00409774": "royal", "TKD1MLjUc68-01429-00409775-00410143": "society royal assembly", "TKD1MLjUc68-01430-00410143-00410470": "they invite one maharaja oh so nicest", "TKD1MLjUc68-01431-00410471-00410630": "lecture", "TKD1MLjUc68-01432-00410631-00410966": "one one lecture", "TKD1MLjUc68-01433-00410967-00411239": "going to change the you know mood of all", "TKD1MLjUc68-01434-00411239-00411382": "you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01435-00411383-00411630": "those who are christian basically", "TKD1MLjUc68-01436-00411631-00411799": "change", "TKD1MLjUc68-01437-00411800-00412143": "oh so nice finally i am going to cut", "TKD1MLjUc68-01438-00412143-00412334": "short very short", "TKD1MLjUc68-01439-00412335-00412791": "he was invited by the royal society", "TKD1MLjUc68-01440-00412792-00413063": "elizabeth was interested to hear", "TKD1MLjUc68-01441-00413064-00413303": "about 15 minutes not more than that", "TKD1MLjUc68-01442-00413304-00413526": "cross the dinner table", "TKD1MLjUc68-01443-00413527-00413774": "i have no time can take dinner", "TKD1MLjUc68-01444-00413775-00414022": "do you know me no they are meeting fees", "TKD1MLjUc68-01445-00414023-00414143": "they are taking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01446-00414143-00414414": "bungas no problem i am doing", "TKD1MLjUc68-01447-00414415-00414703": "i also told for the seva pro path i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01448-00414704-00414910": "come down to any level you can criticize", "TKD1MLjUc68-01449-00414912-00415055": "me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01450-00415056-00415303": "you can criticize me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01451-00415304-00415630": "that's up to you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01452-00415631-00416534": "but we should make balance like", "TKD1MLjUc68-01453-00416535-00416807": "even i don't like to give one scope to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01454-00416808-00417078": "you so that you can find one scope", "TKD1MLjUc68-01455-00417079-00417239": "to criticize me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01456-00417239-00417422": "not kidding actually i have done nothing", "TKD1MLjUc68-01457-00417423-00417639": "wrong still i cannot arrange the", "TKD1MLjUc68-01458-00417639-00417910": "situation in such a way there can be any", "TKD1MLjUc68-01459-00417912-00418095": "possibility", "TKD1MLjUc68-01460-00418096-00418382": "you can express you know doubt about my", "TKD1MLjUc68-01461-00418383-00418487": "character", "TKD1MLjUc68-01462-00418488-00418687": "that i cannot do", "TKD1MLjUc68-01463-00418688-00418895": "this way i will have to live my life", "TKD1MLjUc68-01464-00418896-00419055": "up to last", "TKD1MLjUc68-01465-00419056-00419326": "breath", "TKD1MLjUc68-01466-00419327-00419527": "this is the teachings i got from my guru", "TKD1MLjUc68-01467-00419528-00419783": "maharaja maharaj", "TKD1MLjUc68-01468-00419784-00420135": "it is you are you can criticize them or", "TKD1MLjUc68-01469-00420135-00420487": "that's up to you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01470-00420488-00420631": "when i came back", "TKD1MLjUc68-01471-00420632-00420839": "when i came", "TKD1MLjUc68-01472-00420839-00421047": "from brinda when i started writing i", "TKD1MLjUc68-01473-00421047-00421279": "told senior myself give me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01474-00421280-00421503": "i was searching who is the cheapest", "TKD1MLjUc68-01475-00421504-00421807": "types man typist man who can type very", "TKD1MLjUc68-01476-00421808-00422127": "cheap 15 rupees per page", "TKD1MLjUc68-01477-00422128-00422318": "so i have no money", "TKD1MLjUc68-01478-00422319-00422622": "without train ticket i used to go", "TKD1MLjUc68-01479-00422623-00422879": "years after years i confess them i have", "TKD1MLjUc68-01480-00422880-00423135": "no money whatever money have i have to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01481-00423135-00423295": "print book", "TKD1MLjUc68-01482-00423296-00423495": "i'm not enjoying", "TKD1MLjUc68-01483-00423496-00423799": "i used to go and cross a river and go to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01484-00423800-00424014": "karna long distance", "TKD1MLjUc68-01485-00424015-00424263": "only potato and rice", "TKD1MLjUc68-01486-00424264-00424551": "not outside not drinking water", "TKD1MLjUc68-01487-00424552-00424799": "this way you stood years after years", "TKD1MLjUc68-01488-00424800-00425014": "printing books now you see mahara", "TKD1MLjUc68-01489-00425015-00425279": "sitting in bhasasana", "TKD1MLjUc68-01490-00425280-00425575": "no", "TKD1MLjUc68-01491-00425576-00425879": "this way one day there was thunderball", "TKD1MLjUc68-01492-00425880-00426191": "in the sky total cell rain", "TKD1MLjUc68-01493-00426192-00426383": "torrent cell rain", "TKD1MLjUc68-01494-00426384-00426663": "that the tide man i am sitting in the", "TKD1MLjUc68-01495-00426664-00426935": "second floor i mean up", "TKD1MLjUc68-01496-00426935-00427207": "there is nobody he is his wife is there", "TKD1MLjUc68-01497-00427208-00427535": "down and up he and me doing", "TKD1MLjUc68-01498-00427535-00427799": "i feel sad even i go don't go i don't", "TKD1MLjUc68-01499-00427800-00428055": "like to go to bathroom also all day this", "TKD1MLjUc68-01500-00428056-00428231": "kind of nature", "TKD1MLjUc68-01501-00428232-00428407": "one day there was very taunt sir he's", "TKD1MLjUc68-01502-00428408-00428727": "speaking maharaja you stay i can come", "TKD1MLjUc68-01503-00428728-00428951": "i can come back very quickly where you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01504-00428952-00429118": "can go i can go to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01505-00429119-00429287": "catch my", "TKD1MLjUc68-01506-00429288-00429510": "boy he's in school", "TKD1MLjUc68-01507-00429512-00429679": "it's just near", "TKD1MLjUc68-01508-00429680-00429887": "ah it can take half an hour like i", "TKD1MLjUc68-01509-00429888-00430095": "cannot stay alone here", "TKD1MLjUc68-01510-00430096-00430318": "why and i cannot stay i cannot give", "TKD1MLjUc68-01511-00430319-00430535": "answer why", "TKD1MLjUc68-01512-00430535-00430727": "finally he is spitting person i mean", "TKD1MLjUc68-01513-00430728-00430927": "your wife is there down", "TKD1MLjUc68-01514-00430928-00431279": "so what so what i cannot stay", "TKD1MLjUc68-01515-00431280-00431495": "if you go away i can also go ahead from", "TKD1MLjUc68-01516-00431496-00431614": "this room", "TKD1MLjUc68-01517-00431615-00432022": "go in toronto and go to mayapura", "TKD1MLjUc68-01518-00432023-00432270": "he was down to see me you are bound to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01519-00432271-00432495": "stay he send", "TKD1MLjUc68-01520-00432496-00432807": "his wife you go", "TKD1MLjUc68-01521-00432808-00432959": "this is a", "TKD1MLjUc68-01522-00432960-00433391": "advocacy we learn from our guru work", "TKD1MLjUc68-01523-00433392-00433583": "so you can you it is your p you can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01524-00433584-00433814": "criticize me whatever you like you can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01525-00433815-00434095": "do but we cannot break our rules", "TKD1MLjUc68-01526-00434096-00434318": "follow", "TKD1MLjUc68-01527-00434319-00434543": "even we have seen", "TKD1MLjUc68-01528-00434543-00434631": "when", "TKD1MLjUc68-01529-00434632-00434870": "popat used to i know guru maharaj used", "TKD1MLjUc68-01530-00434871-00435159": "to give harinama diksha to any", "TKD1MLjUc68-01531-00435160-00435375": "you know mataji somebody watching from", "TKD1MLjUc68-01532-00435376-00435679": "london you watch me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01533-00435680-00435966": "so that nobody can get any scope", "TKD1MLjUc68-01534-00435967-00436183": "to criticize", "TKD1MLjUc68-01535-00436184-00436399": "it's very tough", "TKD1MLjUc68-01536-00436400-00436583": "common people cannot follow this", "TKD1MLjUc68-01537-00436584-00436791": "restriction", "TKD1MLjUc68-01538-00436792-00437039": "follow what i say", "TKD1MLjUc68-01539-00437039-00437191": "this way anyway", "TKD1MLjUc68-01540-00437192-00437391": "these are these are teachings we", "TKD1MLjUc68-01541-00437392-00437622": "received from madhukushima", "TKD1MLjUc68-01542-00437623-00437895": "bhaktiv", "TKD1MLjUc68-01543-00437896-00438095": "at the same time they have strong", "TKD1MLjUc68-01544-00438096-00438283": "effects", "TKD1MLjUc68-01545-00438284-00438614": "affection those matajis tremendous", "TKD1MLjUc68-01546-00438615-00438879": "affection more than", "TKD1MLjUc68-01547-00438880-00439455": "because they demand they need affection", "TKD1MLjUc68-01548-00439456-00439766": "they need affection so how much love", "TKD1MLjUc68-01549-00439767-00439991": "you know guru vaisnava you know going to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01550-00439992-00440375": "show you you are blind you cannot see", "TKD1MLjUc68-01551-00440376-00440559": "follow they're going to protect you all", "TKD1MLjUc68-01552-00440560-00440814": "the time", "TKD1MLjUc68-01553-00440815-00441127": "this way banago say mahaj used to speak", "TKD1MLjUc68-01554-00441128-00441391": "even learning elijah everywhere all", "TKD1MLjUc68-01555-00441392-00441695": "england nice preaching", "TKD1MLjUc68-01556-00441696-00441895": "finally he took decision to go to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01557-00441896-00442031": "england", "TKD1MLjUc68-01558-00442032-00442263": "i am going to german but german people", "TKD1MLjUc68-01559-00442264-00442483": "do we are less interested to hear", "TKD1MLjUc68-01560-00442484-00442831": "english we are listen and one point if", "TKD1MLjUc68-01561-00442832-00443079": "you come here you cannot go back there", "TKD1MLjUc68-01562-00443080-00443255": "because there's one", "TKD1MLjUc68-01563-00443256-00443559": "there's some political issue now", "TKD1MLjUc68-01564-00443560-00443766": "they are not allowing anybody who is", "TKD1MLjUc68-01565-00443767-00444031": "going to you know from here to there you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01566-00444032-00444166": "will have to stay here we cannot allow", "TKD1MLjUc68-01567-00444167-00444343": "you to go", "TKD1MLjUc68-01568-00444343-00444607": "be and you will have to speak in german", "TKD1MLjUc68-01569-00444608-00444831": "we are less interested to hear in", "TKD1MLjUc68-01570-00444832-00445199": "english", "TKD1MLjUc68-01571-00445200-00445366": "going to remember the lotus feet of", "TKD1MLjUc68-01572-00445367-00445495": "papad", "TKD1MLjUc68-01573-00445496-00445807": "and you know well i'm ready", "TKD1MLjUc68-01574-00445808-00446103": "well i'm ready i can swing in german how", "TKD1MLjUc68-01575-00446104-00446279": "you can do where you don't know german", "TKD1MLjUc68-01576-00446280-00446375": "okay", "TKD1MLjUc68-01577-00446376-00446631": "within six months", "TKD1MLjUc68-01578-00446632-00446855": "within six months is going to develop", "TKD1MLjUc68-01579-00446856-00447095": "this kind of proficiency", "TKD1MLjUc68-01580-00447096-00447503": "that he is a master of german language", "TKD1MLjUc68-01581-00447504-00447831": "how possible i also myself when i was a", "TKD1MLjUc68-01582-00447832-00447999": "you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01583-00448000-00448214": "a college boy high school i cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-01584-00448215-00448455": "remember college why i think i started", "TKD1MLjUc68-01585-00448456-00448607": "learning german", "TKD1MLjUc68-01586-00448608-00448927": "but after that there was some complicacy", "TKD1MLjUc68-01587-00448928-00449118": "some they are teaching the teacher and", "TKD1MLjUc68-01588-00449119-00449407": "some ladies i i leave that place", "TKD1MLjUc68-01589-00449408-00449743": "i live i got the book how to learn", "TKD1MLjUc68-01590-00449743-00449966": "i started after one two months i see", "TKD1MLjUc68-01591-00449967-00450366": "their condition is not good i live", "TKD1MLjUc68-01592-00450367-00450527": "you know in", "TKD1MLjUc68-01593-00450528-00450703": "it is in the crossing of biba khan on", "TKD1MLjUc68-01594-00450704-00450814": "the road", "TKD1MLjUc68-01595-00450815-00450999": "there is crossing in calcutta near", "TKD1MLjUc68-01596-00451000-00451135": "college street", "TKD1MLjUc68-01597-00451135-00451335": "anyway leave it", "TKD1MLjUc68-01598-00451335-00451495": "so", "TKD1MLjUc68-01599-00451496-00451831": "bonus march within six months day and", "TKD1MLjUc68-01600-00451832-00452143": "night learning german language", "TKD1MLjUc68-01601-00452143-00452351": "and", "TKD1MLjUc68-01602-00452352-00452527": "he started speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01603-00452528-00452735": "in german language of faith they are so", "TKD1MLjUc68-01604-00452735-00452910": "happy", "TKD1MLjUc68-01605-00452912-00453079": "how", "TKD1MLjUc68-01606-00453080-00453279": "nice you know german language is just", "TKD1MLjUc68-01607-00453280-00453510": "like if you write like english but", "TKD1MLjUc68-01608-00453512-00453839": "pronunciation totally difference like", "TKD1MLjUc68-01609-00453839-00454047": "english word is like english but not", "TKD1MLjUc68-01610-00454047-00454166": "english", "TKD1MLjUc68-01611-00454167-00454463": "you know pronunciation all different say", "TKD1MLjUc68-01612-00454464-00454687": "in germany preach massive", "TKD1MLjUc68-01613-00454688-00454791": "and", "TKD1MLjUc68-01614-00454792-00454991": "i'm going to cut short", "TKD1MLjUc68-01615-00454992-00455270": "repeatedly i'm speaking pardon me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01616-00455271-00455470": "i beg for pardon", "TKD1MLjUc68-01617-00455471-00455975": "so there he meet with one unique", "TKD1MLjUc68-01618-00455976-00456375": "devotee his name is sadananda prabhu", "TKD1MLjUc68-01619-00456376-00456566": "his name was no sadhananda prabhu i", "TKD1MLjUc68-01620-00456567-00456743": "cannot remember german name is very", "TKD1MLjUc68-01621-00456743-00456975": "complicated i cannot remember all name", "TKD1MLjUc68-01622-00456976-00457166": "of a guru or go whatever long i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01623-00457167-00457391": "remember by javan i cannot remember is", "TKD1MLjUc68-01624-00457392-00457710": "complicated these are these", "TKD1MLjUc68-01625-00457712-00457863": "what is the meaning and this is what i", "TKD1MLjUc68-01626-00457864-00458055": "don't know anyway", "TKD1MLjUc68-01627-00458056-00458310": "he preached all and uh charman west", "TKD1MLjUc68-01628-00458312-00458710": "yerman you know everywhere", "TKD1MLjUc68-01629-00458712-00458822": "follow", "TKD1MLjUc68-01630-00458823-00459055": "capital you know west german is there", "TKD1MLjUc68-01631-00459056-00459191": "everywhere", "TKD1MLjUc68-01632-00459192-00459614": "preaching very nicely and", "TKD1MLjUc68-01633-00459615-00459927": "so critical position", "TKD1MLjUc68-01634-00459928-00460127": "there is no money", "TKD1MLjUc68-01635-00460128-00460335": "how to pay the rent", "TKD1MLjUc68-01636-00460335-00460663": "is thinking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01637-00460664-00460918": "how what to eat what i can take", "TKD1MLjUc68-01638-00460919-00460999": "to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01639-00461000-00461207": "protect my body", "TKD1MLjUc68-01640-00461208-00461583": "is thinking and no money to pay the rent", "TKD1MLjUc68-01641-00461584-00461895": "in the meantime there is one post parcel", "TKD1MLjUc68-01642-00461896-00461991": "coming", "TKD1MLjUc68-01643-00461992-00462359": "there is one dry food big person", "TKD1MLjUc68-01644-00462360-00462622": "peak person post person", "TKD1MLjUc68-01645-00462623-00462895": "air collar", "TKD1MLjUc68-01646-00462896-00463207": "and some money also", "TKD1MLjUc68-01647-00463208-00463383": "to pay", "TKD1MLjUc68-01648-00463384-00463583": "how", "TKD1MLjUc68-01649-00463584-00463663": "a", "TKD1MLjUc68-01650-00463664-00463887": "almost every day", "TKD1MLjUc68-01651-00463888-00464110": "half fasting taking something to protect", "TKD1MLjUc68-01652-00464112-00464214": "body", "TKD1MLjUc68-01653-00464215-00464399": "but who can give money they don't know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01654-00464400-00464575": "which sadhu is that", "TKD1MLjUc68-01655-00464576-00464807": "after that", "TKD1MLjUc68-01656-00464808-00465247": "is coming back anyway", "TKD1MLjUc68-01657-00465247-00465447": "when he came back", "TKD1MLjUc68-01658-00465447-00466199": "so warm welcome was given to him", "TKD1MLjUc68-01659-00466200-00466335": "anyway", "TKD1MLjUc68-01660-00466335-00466575": "is that so many things i like to speak", "TKD1MLjUc68-01661-00466576-00466799": "but time cannot promise", "TKD1MLjUc68-01662-00466800-00467151": "after that again he went to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01663-00467152-00467383": "foreign country", "TKD1MLjUc68-01664-00467384-00467487": "northwest", "TKD1MLjUc68-01665-00467488-00467847": "everywhere austria vienna america", "TKD1MLjUc68-01666-00467847-00468031": "german", "TKD1MLjUc68-01667-00468032-00468199": "you know follow", "TKD1MLjUc68-01668-00468200-00468614": "all important city european countries", "TKD1MLjUc68-01669-00468615-00468831": "everywhere preached", "TKD1MLjUc68-01670-00468832-00468983": "where not", "TKD1MLjUc68-01671-00468984-00469083": "massive", "TKD1MLjUc68-01672-00469084-00469247": "preaching", "TKD1MLjUc68-01673-00469247-00469543": "hello in america arizona here they are", "TKD1MLjUc68-01674-00469543-00469679": "everywhere", "TKD1MLjUc68-01675-00469680-00470263": "you know washington new york", "TKD1MLjUc68-01676-00470264-00470559": "not not that he was preaching very cheap", "TKD1MLjUc68-01677-00470560-00470670": "way", "TKD1MLjUc68-01678-00470671-00470935": "his preaching was in high level", "TKD1MLjUc68-01679-00470935-00471063": "he always", "TKD1MLjUc68-01680-00471064-00471222": "used to speak", "TKD1MLjUc68-01681-00471223-00471366": "in", "TKD1MLjUc68-01682-00471367-00471518": "high level", "TKD1MLjUc68-01683-00471519-00471710": "because that was the conception of", "TKD1MLjUc68-01684-00471712-00471943": "prabha if high level people going to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01685-00471943-00472079": "accept caitanya mahaprabhu then", "TKD1MLjUc68-01686-00472080-00472279": "automatically", "TKD1MLjUc68-01687-00472280-00472495": "so why you criticize", "TKD1MLjUc68-01688-00472496-00472791": "bongasi mahaja the only man", "TKD1MLjUc68-01689-00472792-00472951": "is the only man", "TKD1MLjUc68-01690-00472952-00473239": "who was invited in oxford university to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01691-00473239-00473543": "pass lecture on all affiliated", "TKD1MLjUc68-01692-00473543-00473807": "university apprehended", "TKD1MLjUc68-01693-00473808-00474070": "affiliated you know by you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01694-00474071-00474422": "oxford university affiliated off of", "TKD1MLjUc68-01695-00474423-00474879": "all center bangladesh day by day because", "TKD1MLjUc68-01696-00474880-00475127": "it was the plan of bango simaraj and", "TKD1MLjUc68-01697-00475128-00475422": "papa if young match", "TKD1MLjUc68-01698-00475423-00475735": "if my speech can touch the young badge", "TKD1MLjUc68-01699-00475735-00475935": "follow", "TKD1MLjUc68-01700-00475935-00476263": "those who are a small boy learning", "TKD1MLjUc68-01701-00476264-00476470": "more because they are going to be the", "TKD1MLjUc68-01702-00476471-00476695": "future citizens of india are in the", "TKD1MLjUc68-01703-00476696-00476966": "world", "TKD1MLjUc68-01704-00476967-00477270": "massive preaching", "TKD1MLjUc68-01705-00477271-00477414": "apollo", "TKD1MLjUc68-01706-00477415-00477670": "austria vienna here they are all", "TKD1MLjUc68-01707-00477671-00477887": "switzerland", "TKD1MLjUc68-01708-00477888-00478110": "where not", "TKD1MLjUc68-01709-00478112-00478422": "japan also", "TKD1MLjUc68-01710-00478423-00478583": "japan also", "TKD1MLjUc68-01711-00478584-00478910": "continuously for five six years totally", "TKD1MLjUc68-01712-00478912-00479263": "massive preaching after come back", "TKD1MLjUc68-01713-00479264-00479591": "from foreign india", "TKD1MLjUc68-01714-00479592-00479887": "so many incident if i go on speaking is", "TKD1MLjUc68-01715-00479888-00480270": "what epic it can become epic i cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-01716-00480271-00480566": "please excuse me what to do", "TKD1MLjUc68-01717-00480567-00480751": "i'm going to touch some important point", "TKD1MLjUc68-01718-00480752-00480862": "what to do", "TKD1MLjUc68-01719-00480863-00480999": "the ocean", "TKD1MLjUc68-01720-00481000-00481199": "really i am speaking this way ocean", "TKD1MLjUc68-01721-00481200-00481487": "vaisnava is ocean", "TKD1MLjUc68-01722-00481488-00482022": "after that finally when growing age", "TKD1MLjUc68-01723-00482023-00482327": "he wanted to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01724-00482328-00482551": "make some temple also", "TKD1MLjUc68-01725-00482552-00482879": "he already makes some some temple", "TKD1MLjUc68-01726-00482880-00483135": "in brindavan", "TKD1MLjUc68-01727-00483135-00483279": "in calcutta", "TKD1MLjUc68-01728-00483280-00483551": "in hinghal ganj not so many more because", "TKD1MLjUc68-01729-00483552-00483879": "he was when he come back he was uh", "TKD1MLjUc68-01730-00483880-00484079": "because popat gong was very", "TKD1MLjUc68-01731-00484080-00484247": "absent-minded", "TKD1MLjUc68-01732-00484247-00484483": "popagon means", "TKD1MLjUc68-01733-00484484-00484831": "backhand is he tried his best to preach", "TKD1MLjUc68-01734-00484832-00485062": "but after that he was feeling so much", "TKD1MLjUc68-01735-00485063-00485255": "separation from pogba", "TKD1MLjUc68-01736-00485256-00485543": "he also wanted to go away from the", "TKD1MLjUc68-01737-00485543-00485855": "material world so long history", "TKD1MLjUc68-01738-00485856-00486095": "finally he wanted to make his own", "TKD1MLjUc68-01739-00486096-00486255": "samadhi", "TKD1MLjUc68-01740-00486256-00486487": "he wanted to make his own samadhi before", "TKD1MLjUc68-01741-00486488-00486607": "living body", "TKD1MLjUc68-01742-00486608-00486999": "you can wonder how possible maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-01743-00487000-00487255": "how possible maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-01744-00487256-00487470": "you cannot believe but you cannot you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01745-00487471-00487559": "know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01746-00487560-00487703": "imagine even", "TKD1MLjUc68-01747-00487704-00487927": "ramanuja", "TKD1MLjUc68-01748-00487928-00488183": "ramanuja johang doing his first time", "TKD1MLjUc68-01749-00488184-00488510": "that time some of his grayashta devotee", "TKD1MLjUc68-01750-00488512-00488759": "tremendous love because gurudev can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01751-00488760-00489007": "realize guru vishnu can realize", "TKD1MLjUc68-01752-00489008-00489351": "who is having how much love for me", "TKD1MLjUc68-01753-00489352-00489559": "according to that they are going giving", "TKD1MLjUc68-01754-00489560-00489918": "kippah secretly", "TKD1MLjUc68-01755-00489919-00490083": "to whom he is giving", "TKD1MLjUc68-01756-00490084-00490407": "fifa he can realize outside people", "TKD1MLjUc68-01757-00490408-00490622": "cannot realize", "TKD1MLjUc68-01758-00490623-00490743": "outside", "TKD1MLjUc68-01759-00490743-00490910": "people can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01760-00490912-00491270": "you know do miscalculation", "TKD1MLjUc68-01761-00491271-00491431": "maybe he has", "TKD1MLjUc68-01762-00491432-00491743": "he was doing guruseva but then", "TKD1MLjUc68-01763-00491743-00491966": "i can ask i can discuss this point", "TKD1MLjUc68-01764-00491967-00492079": "someday", "TKD1MLjUc68-01765-00492080-00492318": "it not depend upon the money factor how", "TKD1MLjUc68-01766-00492319-00492670": "much money you give how much you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01767-00492671-00492951": "building you make it depends upon with", "TKD1MLjUc68-01768-00492952-00493159": "what mood", "TKD1MLjUc68-01769-00493160-00493439": "maybe you are poor", "TKD1MLjUc68-01770-00493439-00493599": "he is guru there", "TKD1MLjUc68-01771-00493600-00493807": "if you are poor give me give me i like", "TKD1MLjUc68-01772-00493808-00493910": "to get", "TKD1MLjUc68-01773-00493912-00494118": "and one rich man giving i don't like to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01774-00494119-00494414": "give or you keep money with you this is", "TKD1MLjUc68-01775-00494415-00494614": "the mood of vaisnava because they", "TKD1MLjUc68-01776-00494615-00494727": "understand", "TKD1MLjUc68-01777-00494728-00494966": "the heart of", "TKD1MLjUc68-01778-00494967-00495062": "follow", "TKD1MLjUc68-01779-00495063-00495414": "that's why they don't like to take", "TKD1MLjUc68-01780-00495415-00495655": "so when he come back he wanted to so", "TKD1MLjUc68-01781-00495656-00495839": "many things uh", "TKD1MLjUc68-01782-00495839-00496095": "someday each every year we can meet this", "TKD1MLjUc68-01783-00496096-00496279": "kind of teachi i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01784-00496280-00496487": "you know discuss", "TKD1MLjUc68-01785-00496488-00496687": "manuka shimra wanted to make you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01786-00496688-00496975": "his own samadhi he wanted to establish", "TKD1MLjUc68-01787-00496976-00497110": "bishop i know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01788-00497112-00497414": "you know gopishar mahadev", "TKD1MLjUc68-01789-00497415-00497687": "near his bhajan khuti wrong history", "TKD1MLjUc68-01790-00497688-00497966": "he makes samadhi because because if they", "TKD1MLjUc68-01791-00497967-00498191": "are going to make samadhi", "TKD1MLjUc68-01792-00498192-00498447": "they don't they not understand my mood", "TKD1MLjUc68-01793-00498447-00498631": "so he wanted to make samadhi in such a", "TKD1MLjUc68-01794-00498632-00498918": "place so that he established radha", "TKD1MLjUc68-01795-00498919-00499103": "govinda", "TKD1MLjUc68-01796-00499104-00499295": "there in mindawa", "TKD1MLjUc68-01797-00499296-00499551": "from samadhi he can daily can see", "TKD1MLjUc68-01798-00499552-00499814": "aarothi see the mood", "TKD1MLjUc68-01799-00499815-00500007": "if somebody can make here and there oh", "TKD1MLjUc68-01800-00500008-00500255": "mahara is a nice place no", "TKD1MLjUc68-01801-00500256-00500510": "he'll like to see aarothi same case with", "TKD1MLjUc68-01802-00500512-00500766": "janadan maharaj", "TKD1MLjUc68-01803-00500767-00500991": "same case", "TKD1MLjUc68-01804-00500992-00501422": "endless harikatha one day mahmoud", "TKD1MLjUc68-01805-00501423-00501695": "discussing with each other they whisper", "TKD1MLjUc68-01806-00501696-00501839": "with each other", "TKD1MLjUc68-01807-00501839-00502070": "what to make what do you think what to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01808-00502071-00502159": "make", "TKD1MLjUc68-01809-00502160-00502414": "outside people they don't understand", "TKD1MLjUc68-01810-00502415-00502639": "outside people thinking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01811-00502639-00502759": "uh", "TKD1MLjUc68-01812-00502760-00502966": "jonathan was speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01813-00502967-00503151": "and uh", "TKD1MLjUc68-01814-00503152-00503303": "our uh", "TKD1MLjUc68-01815-00503304-00503527": "brahmana what understand", "TKD1MLjUc68-01816-00503528-00503662": "what to make", "TKD1MLjUc68-01817-00503663-00503822": "which place is good", "TKD1MLjUc68-01818-00503823-00503983": "ah what do you mean", "TKD1MLjUc68-01819-00503984-00504183": "bamanga same as i think this place is", "TKD1MLjUc68-01820-00504184-00504351": "good", "TKD1MLjUc68-01821-00504352-00504543": "nobody understands", "TKD1MLjUc68-01822-00504543-00504718": "they understand each other", "TKD1MLjUc68-01823-00504719-00504983": "when he wanted to seek the permission of", "TKD1MLjUc68-01824-00504984-00505127": "you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01825-00505128-00505295": "you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01826-00505296-00505551": "where is the best place for my samadhi", "TKD1MLjUc68-01827-00505552-00505799": "allah says this place you can see", "TKD1MLjUc68-01828-00505800-00506047": "right you are.", "TKD1MLjUc68-01829-00506047-00506359": "so the mood of vaisnava is so secret you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01830-00506360-00506551": "know outside people without of their", "TKD1MLjUc68-01831-00506552-00506775": "intellect you know they cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-01832-00506776-00506927": "understand", "TKD1MLjUc68-01833-00506928-00507110": "not possible", "TKD1MLjUc68-01834-00507112-00507414": "subban maharaja makes", "TKD1MLjUc68-01835-00507415-00507814": "and i forget to tell you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01836-00507815-00508231": "he took you know teachings about", "TKD1MLjUc68-01837-00508232-00508575": "veda vedanta all", "TKD1MLjUc68-01838-00508576-00509143": "right and or not all actually has called", "TKD1MLjUc68-01839-00509143-00509343": "it's called", "TKD1MLjUc68-01840-00509343-00509679": "i forget", "TKD1MLjUc68-01841-00509680-00509887": "declaration", "TKD1MLjUc68-01842-00509888-00510118": "and after that", "TKD1MLjUc68-01843-00510119-00510239": "he is", "TKD1MLjUc68-01844-00510239-00510510": "so many things he learned so many", "TKD1MLjUc68-01845-00510512-00510687": "extraordinary brain", "TKD1MLjUc68-01846-00510688-00510935": "he is a supernatural man", "TKD1MLjUc68-01847-00510935-00511335": "he is a keeper", "TKD1MLjUc68-01848-00511335-00511639": "he took he went there", "TKD1MLjUc68-01849-00511639-00511839": "one crore", "TKD1MLjUc68-01850-00511839-00512255": "108 bel pata billapatta you give one", "TKD1MLjUc68-01851-00512256-00512470": "bill patana to sibji", "TKD1MLjUc68-01852-00512471-00512759": "one crore one hundred", "TKD1MLjUc68-01853-00512760-00513079": "eight bill pata", "TKD1MLjUc68-01854-00513080-00513159": "whole", "TKD1MLjUc68-01855-00513160-00513399": "fasting and you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01856-00513400-00513655": "after whole day gone taking some fruit", "TKD1MLjUc68-01857-00513656-00513847": "water", "TKD1MLjUc68-01858-00513847-00514814": "one carrots 108 belfast", "TKD1MLjUc68-01859-00514815-00514959": "so you can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01860-00514960-00515095": "go mad", "TKD1MLjUc68-01861-00515096-00515351": "if you hear", "TKD1MLjUc68-01862-00515352-00515639": "he took trouble to not that he used to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01863-00515639-00515839": "preach in foreign countries he also", "TKD1MLjUc68-01864-00515839-00516070": "preached in village to village all poor", "TKD1MLjUc68-01865-00516071-00516222": "people", "TKD1MLjUc68-01866-00516223-00516351": "then him", "TKD1MLjUc68-01867-00516352-00516510": "in my whole life", "TKD1MLjUc68-01868-00516512-00516687": "one time i went there", "TKD1MLjUc68-01869-00516688-00516959": "one time of no time one time", "TKD1MLjUc68-01870-00516960-00517343": "maybe 15 uh 12 years back", "TKD1MLjUc68-01871-00517343-00517495": "i went there to speak harikada", "TKD1MLjUc68-01872-00517496-00517695": "purushottam also went with me and", "TKD1MLjUc68-01873-00517696-00517983": "another holland devotee", "TKD1MLjUc68-01874-00517984-00518262": "who meet with problem there in you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01875-00518263-00518551": "that natural natural calamity he somehow", "TKD1MLjUc68-01876-00518552-00518855": "saved and let send message to him he was", "TKD1MLjUc68-01877-00518856-00519303": "supposed to die in natural camera", "TKD1MLjUc68-01878-00519304-00519422": "that was", "TKD1MLjUc68-01879-00519423-00519655": "this way", "TKD1MLjUc68-01880-00519656-00519927": "he was full of love how i can speak", "TKD1MLjUc68-01881-00519928-00520231": "about bhakti i like to stop i like to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01882-00520232-00520414": "touch with you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01883-00520415-00520703": "bhakti shogura bhakti sargasai maharaj", "TKD1MLjUc68-01884-00520704-00520895": "if i don't touch i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01885-00520896-00521214": "i cannot get excuse from bhagavan why", "TKD1MLjUc68-01886-00521215-00521518": "i wanted to discuss about him also long", "TKD1MLjUc68-01887-00521519-00521631": "discussion", "TKD1MLjUc68-01888-00521632-00521855": "but time cannot follow me someday i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01889-00521856-00521983": "discuss", "TKD1MLjUc68-01890-00521984-00522247": "maybe on avil bhakti i can discuss if", "TKD1MLjUc68-01891-00522247-00522575": "the titi is isolated and separate is", "TKD1MLjUc68-01892-00522576-00522839": "good for me if two three teaching at a", "TKD1MLjUc68-01893-00522839-00523039": "time how about i can discuss big problem", "TKD1MLjUc68-01894-00523039-00523279": "for me i'm feeling tension", "TKD1MLjUc68-01895-00523280-00523503": "i practice attention", "TKD1MLjUc68-01896-00523504-00523951": "so actually he took birth in kulla", "TKD1MLjUc68-01897-00523952-00524262": "he took birth in kulla kulla you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01898-00524263-00524455": "bangladesh", "TKD1MLjUc68-01899-00524456-00524695": "the majority of our guru bhargava all", "TKD1MLjUc68-01900-00524696-00524966": "took birth in bangladesh", "TKD1MLjUc68-01901-00524967-00525262": "my forefather everybody or in dhaka wall", "TKD1MLjUc68-01902-00525263-00525439": "i took birth here", "TKD1MLjUc68-01903-00525440-00525735": "at the bank of ganga", "TKD1MLjUc68-01904-00525736-00526055": "just near goryamat", "TKD1MLjUc68-01905-00526056-00526318": "i was lucky but still i'm not lucky i", "TKD1MLjUc68-01906-00526319-00526566": "was doing you know asa sangha is there", "TKD1MLjUc68-01907-00526567-00526766": "so", "TKD1MLjUc68-01908-00526767-00526918": "so what to do", "TKD1MLjUc68-01909-00526919-00527239": "when time come come pop address me i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01910-00527240-00527439": "and my child i used to go with my", "TKD1MLjUc68-01911-00527440-00527783": "grandmother to temple poppa temple", "TKD1MLjUc68-01912-00527784-00527951": "i don't understand watching here they", "TKD1MLjUc68-01913-00527952-00528183": "give some puzzle i'm taking", "TKD1MLjUc68-01914-00528184-00528351": "they don't understand", "TKD1MLjUc68-01915-00528352-00528566": "what they are doing", "TKD1MLjUc68-01916-00528567-00528751": "what they are doing now i understand", "TKD1MLjUc68-01917-00528752-00528927": "what they are doing", "TKD1MLjUc68-01918-00528928-00529151": "that time he couldn't", "TKD1MLjUc68-01919-00529152-00529255": "follow", "TKD1MLjUc68-01920-00529256-00529559": "this way actually maharashtra took birth", "TKD1MLjUc68-01921-00529560-00529631": "in", "TKD1MLjUc68-01922-00529632-00530039": "kulna that's a very nice family", "TKD1MLjUc68-01923-00530040-00530262": "and finally after schooling", "TKD1MLjUc68-01924-00530263-00530487": "his schooling was done near you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01925-00530488-00530662": "village nice", "TKD1MLjUc68-01926-00530663-00530903": "after that", "TKD1MLjUc68-01927-00530904-00531055": "he", "TKD1MLjUc68-01928-00531056-00531303": "went to cuttack for engineering for", "TKD1MLjUc68-01929-00531304-00531527": "special engineering course", "TKD1MLjUc68-01930-00531528-00531743": "for some special engineering course in", "TKD1MLjUc68-01931-00531744-00532022": "qatar he was taking training", "TKD1MLjUc68-01932-00532023-00532270": "that that time he got information there", "TKD1MLjUc68-01933-00532271-00532431": "is one goriamat", "TKD1MLjUc68-01934-00532432-00532575": "of uh", "TKD1MLjUc68-01935-00532576-00532759": "goriamat", "TKD1MLjUc68-01936-00532760-00532903": "after that", "TKD1MLjUc68-01937-00532904-00533231": "okay very good why should i take uh", "TKD1MLjUc68-01938-00533232-00533655": "go to hotel to take i can go to goryamat", "TKD1MLjUc68-01939-00533656-00533959": "to take russo and there was one babaji", "TKD1MLjUc68-01940-00533960-00534103": "maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-01941-00534104-00534279": "his name was", "TKD1MLjUc68-01942-00534280-00534566": "prajwabi hari babaji maharaj", "TKD1MLjUc68-01943-00534567-00534759": "he is illiterate", "TKD1MLjUc68-01944-00534760-00535022": "almost illiterate somehow can read very", "TKD1MLjUc68-01945-00535023-00535207": "slowly", "TKD1MLjUc68-01946-00535208-00535431": "he was almost illiterate", "TKD1MLjUc68-01947-00535432-00535783": "but he can read bengali language somehow", "TKD1MLjUc68-01948-00535784-00535951": "he used to read", "TKD1MLjUc68-01949-00535952-00536222": "he used to read caitanya bhagavatam", "TKD1MLjUc68-01950-00536223-00536575": "daily", "TKD1MLjUc68-01951-00536576-00536727": "he was maintaining that temple and", "TKD1MLjUc68-01952-00536728-00536975": "caught up followed goddammit but his", "TKD1MLjUc68-01953-00536976-00537262": "heart was so simple plain hard he used", "TKD1MLjUc68-01954-00537263-00537511": "to beg for pardon to everybody", "TKD1MLjUc68-01955-00537512-00537751": "is to beg for pardon to everybody", "TKD1MLjUc68-01956-00537752-00537951": "now please excuse me because i am not", "TKD1MLjUc68-01957-00537952-00538191": "educated you know so somehow i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-01958-00538192-00538455": "explain the theme we are already good", "TKD1MLjUc68-01959-00538456-00538703": "even college principal", "TKD1MLjUc68-01960-00538704-00538911": "they used to come to attend him", "TKD1MLjUc68-01961-00538912-00539103": "because his harikata was heart touching", "TKD1MLjUc68-01962-00539104-00539439": "maybe maybe he cannot speak english", "TKD1MLjUc68-01963-00539440-00539695": "he cannot pass lecture in a very lucid", "TKD1MLjUc68-01964-00539696-00540022": "way sweet way not that but his heart", "TKD1MLjUc68-01965-00540023-00540222": "speech was in a broken speech and", "TKD1MLjUc68-01966-00540223-00540566": "speaking but his heart was so plain so", "TKD1MLjUc68-01967-00540567-00540847": "plain hearted so simply hearted", "TKD1MLjUc68-01968-00540848-00541070": "is you know some magnetic attraction all", "TKD1MLjUc68-01969-00541071-00541255": "different educated people also used to", "TKD1MLjUc68-01970-00541256-00541343": "come", "TKD1MLjUc68-01971-00541344-00541670": "to here is arigath", "TKD1MLjUc68-01972-00541671-00541879": "so babaji used to say please you know i", "TKD1MLjUc68-01973-00541880-00542166": "am almost illiterate please try to catch", "TKD1MLjUc68-01974-00542167-00542279": "the theme", "TKD1MLjUc68-01975-00542280-00542551": "but my heart for my guru guru manipur", "TKD1MLjUc68-01976-00542552-00542807": "this is good with him", "TKD1MLjUc68-01977-00542808-00543062": "appoint him there", "TKD1MLjUc68-01978-00543063-00543343": "our it is you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-01979-00543344-00543607": "his name was", "TKD1MLjUc68-01980-00543608-00543791": "his name", "TKD1MLjUc68-01981-00543792-00543999": "i mean this sargo-sai maharaja is a", "TKD1MLjUc68-01982-00544000-00544255": "previous i mean home name", "TKD1MLjUc68-01983-00544256-00544439": "was", "TKD1MLjUc68-01984-00544440-00544566": "after that", "TKD1MLjUc68-01985-00544567-00544783": "when he meet with you know rajabi hari", "TKD1MLjUc68-01986-00544784-00544975": "bhava hima hearing harikath for a long", "TKD1MLjUc68-01987-00544976-00545070": "time", "TKD1MLjUc68-01988-00545071-00545335": "he gone mad are he", "TKD1MLjUc68-01989-00545336-00545575": "he anyway he was less interested to take", "TKD1MLjUc68-01990-00545576-00545870": "onion garlic you know nothing from", "TKD1MLjUc68-01991-00545871-00546055": "from childhood", "TKD1MLjUc68-01992-00546056-00546311": "and father mother was very excellent", "TKD1MLjUc68-01993-00546312-00546607": "such father mother you cannot get in", "TKD1MLjUc68-01994-00546608-00546775": "thousands of birth", "TKD1MLjUc68-01995-00546776-00547062": "because father mother is so in favor", "TKD1MLjUc68-01996-00547063-00547359": "when he writes letter to father father i", "TKD1MLjUc68-01997-00547360-00547607": "feel attraction for goriamat would you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01998-00547608-00547807": "feel is would you please mind could you", "TKD1MLjUc68-01999-00547808-00548191": "please mind if i take uh diksha harinama", "TKD1MLjUc68-02000-00548192-00548399": "other what to my what what do you think", "TKD1MLjUc68-02001-00548400-00548543": "about", "TKD1MLjUc68-02002-00548544-00548751": "i can also take", "TKD1MLjUc68-02003-00548752-00548999": "you come will you all together father", "TKD1MLjUc68-02004-00549000-00549159": "you know mother", "TKD1MLjUc68-02005-00549160-00549583": "and boy i again also you also", "TKD1MLjUc68-02006-00549584-00549751": "father become very happy you are feeling", "TKD1MLjUc68-02007-00549752-00550039": "attracted to caitanya well i can also", "TKD1MLjUc68-02008-00550040-00550214": "why you can't take a lot", "TKD1MLjUc68-02009-00550215-00550470": "then after that taking lesson there", "TKD1MLjUc68-02010-00550471-00550703": "completely going to come out whatever", "TKD1MLjUc68-02011-00550704-00550918": "engineering courses have done", "TKD1MLjUc68-02012-00550919-00551118": "what we can do in engineering course", "TKD1MLjUc68-02013-00551119-00551559": "this is the main engineering", "TKD1MLjUc68-02014-00551560-00551959": "finally coming you know calcutta", "TKD1MLjUc68-02015-00551960-00552255": "after that to mayapur father mother also", "TKD1MLjUc68-02016-00552256-00552431": "going to join him together they are", "TKD1MLjUc68-02017-00552432-00552711": "going to meet with prophet the fast side", "TKD1MLjUc68-02018-00552712-00554087": "of public oh my god", "TKD1MLjUc68-02019-00554088-00554327": "follow you don't believe me you cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-02020-00554328-00554559": "believe me", "TKD1MLjUc68-02021-00554560-00554735": "so important", "TKD1MLjUc68-02022-00554736-00554911": "they meet with prophet that the first", "TKD1MLjUc68-02023-00554912-00555111": "sight and after hearing", "TKD1MLjUc68-02024-00555112-00555422": "totally their mind and soul", "TKD1MLjUc68-02025-00555423-00555727": "soul already sold onto the lotus feet of", "TKD1MLjUc68-02026-00555728-00555855": "prabhupada", "TKD1MLjUc68-02027-00555856-00556255": "could you please give harinama yes sir", "TKD1MLjUc68-02028-00556256-00556470": "tawba giving harinama and diksha at a", "TKD1MLjUc68-02029-00556471-00556583": "time", "TKD1MLjUc68-02030-00556584-00557007": "and his name was nonigopal prabhu", "TKD1MLjUc68-02031-00557008-00557151": "hello", "TKD1MLjUc68-02032-00557152-00558718": "previous name was nanda dula", "TKD1MLjUc68-02033-00558719-00559031": "nani mean butter", "TKD1MLjUc68-02034-00559032-00559199": "nicobar brahmacharya", "TKD1MLjUc68-02035-00559200-00559479": "so after that what happens you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-02036-00559480-00559670": "is i started", "TKD1MLjUc68-02037-00559671-00559783": "seva", "TKD1MLjUc68-02038-00559784-00560007": "i like to serve this you know exalted", "TKD1MLjUc68-02039-00560008-00560647": "devotee of", "TKD1MLjUc68-02040-00560648-00560814": "and after that", "TKD1MLjUc68-02041-00560815-00561079": "i know at a time when father mother", "TKD1MLjUc68-02042-00561080-00561199": "going away", "TKD1MLjUc68-02043-00561200-00561559": "father giving one exclusive advice", "TKD1MLjUc68-02044-00561560-00561951": "very valuable advice my son", "TKD1MLjUc68-02045-00561952-00562175": "if you don't take trouble to go back to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02046-00562176-00562375": "your home", "TKD1MLjUc68-02047-00562376-00562575": "in your whole life", "TKD1MLjUc68-02048-00562576-00562847": "then i'll be very happy", "TKD1MLjUc68-02049-00562848-00563135": "could you please open me you see why i", "TKD1MLjUc68-02050-00563136-00563214": "say", "TKD1MLjUc68-02051-00563215-00563414": "this kind of father mother", "TKD1MLjUc68-02052-00563415-00563614": "my father died", "TKD1MLjUc68-02053-00563615-00563847": "thinking where my son gone", "TKD1MLjUc68-02054-00563848-00564103": "after you know six eight months six", "TKD1MLjUc68-02055-00564104-00564447": "months seven months i can't know when my", "TKD1MLjUc68-02056-00564448-00564687": "mother leave in the noon time i could", "TKD1MLjUc68-02057-00564688-00564870": "realize something", "TKD1MLjUc68-02058-00564871-00565214": "noon time in puri i was in puri", "TKD1MLjUc68-02059-00565215-00565479": "alone i was in a room i feel something", "TKD1MLjUc68-02060-00565480-00565670": "i was thinking why i give a neighbor", "TKD1MLjUc68-02061-00565671-00565870": "this kind of thing again", "TKD1MLjUc68-02062-00565871-00566311": "then i got information", "TKD1MLjUc68-02063-00566312-00566439": "this way", "TKD1MLjUc68-02064-00566440-00566743": "so who is father who is mother", "TKD1MLjUc68-02065-00566744-00567135": "my father mother all you know my", "TKD1MLjUc68-02066-00567136-00567366": "they are my bhaktivinoda mother", "TKD1MLjUc68-02067-00567367-00567575": "such countless father mother i live", "TKD1MLjUc68-02068-00567576-00567807": "anywhere they used to do bhajana ki", "TKD1MLjUc68-02069-00567808-00567935": "harinam", "TKD1MLjUc68-02070-00567936-00568214": "that is a consolation", "TKD1MLjUc68-02071-00568215-00568559": "to kareena mama", "TKD1MLjUc68-02072-00568560-00568670": "anyway", "TKD1MLjUc68-02073-00568671-00568983": "so point is that", "TKD1MLjUc68-02074-00568984-00569143": "father going to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02075-00569144-00569455": "advise son this way", "TKD1MLjUc68-02076-00569456-00569710": "after that", "TKD1MLjUc68-02077-00569711-00570007": "nanigapalpu took decision not to go to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02078-00570008-00570327": "see even father and mother in whole life", "TKD1MLjUc68-02079-00570328-00570662": "so exalted devotee", "TKD1MLjUc68-02080-00570663-00570927": "so exalted nice", "TKD1MLjUc68-02081-00570928-00571047": "you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-02082-00571048-00571262": "he was successful to get", "TKD1MLjUc68-02083-00571263-00571414": "keepa", "TKD1MLjUc68-02084-00571415-00571614": "very nice", "TKD1MLjUc68-02085-00571615-00571735": "so", "TKD1MLjUc68-02086-00571736-00571951": "bobad used to send him to different", "TKD1MLjUc68-02087-00571952-00572118": "parts of india", "TKD1MLjUc68-02088-00572119-00572375": "for preaching was irrigated man", "TKD1MLjUc68-02089-00572376-00572631": "very nice catching power is very good", "TKD1MLjUc68-02090-00572632-00573031": "just to send different places", "TKD1MLjUc68-02091-00573032-00573375": "used to engage in different seva", "TKD1MLjUc68-02092-00573376-00573655": "so", "TKD1MLjUc68-02093-00573656-00573831": "after that", "TKD1MLjUc68-02094-00573832-00574087": "he took you know actually he came later", "TKD1MLjUc68-02095-00574088-00574255": "later you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-02096-00574256-00574455": "association you got because they are", "TKD1MLjUc68-02097-00574456-00574766": "eternal person", "TKD1MLjUc68-02098-00574767-00575014": "later when prophet gone", "TKD1MLjUc68-02099-00575015-00575239": "he was under the guidance of goshen", "TKD1MLjUc68-02100-00575240-00575431": "maharaj", "TKD1MLjUc68-02101-00575432-00575631": "when prophet gone i am going to cut", "TKD1MLjUc68-02102-00575632-00575879": "shock please excuse me", "TKD1MLjUc68-02103-00575880-00576207": "in details i cannot speak", "TKD1MLjUc68-02104-00576208-00576335": "he was", "TKD1MLjUc68-02105-00576336-00576695": "editing so many languages", "TKD1MLjUc68-02106-00576696-00577087": "so many patrika used to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02107-00577088-00577366": "idea about urea language bengali english", "TKD1MLjUc68-02108-00577367-00577543": "hindi", "TKD1MLjUc68-02109-00577544-00577870": "just to edit because nodiya prokas daily", "TKD1MLjUc68-02110-00577871-00578007": "so he was a", "TKD1MLjUc68-02111-00578008-00578255": "editor my guru major also editor of", "TKD1MLjUc68-02112-00578256-00578422": "course", "TKD1MLjUc68-02113-00578423-00578559": "daily", "TKD1MLjUc68-02114-00578560-00578639": "so", "TKD1MLjUc68-02115-00578640-00578847": "very", "TKD1MLjUc68-02116-00578848-00579079": "he was appointed at the teacher of", "TKD1MLjUc68-02117-00579080-00579622": "bhaktivinoda bhakti", "TKD1MLjUc68-02118-00579623-00580255": "bhaktivinoda school", "TKD1MLjUc68-02119-00580256-00580510": "institute he was appointed teachers", "TKD1MLjUc68-02120-00580511-00580639": "of that", "TKD1MLjUc68-02121-00580640-00580862": "institute for a long time after that", "TKD1MLjUc68-02122-00580863-00581103": "papa sent him for different places for", "TKD1MLjUc68-02123-00581104-00581375": "preaching previously only because if", "TKD1MLjUc68-02124-00581376-00581527": "running condition", "TKD1MLjUc68-02125-00581528-00581759": "you know editing is impossible follow", "TKD1MLjUc68-02126-00581760-00582014": "also he used to do after that power sent", "TKD1MLjUc68-02127-00582015-00582279": "even after prabhat gone in the year of", "TKD1MLjUc68-02128-00582280-00582575": "1936", "TKD1MLjUc68-02129-00582576-00582822": "was under the guidance complete guidance", "TKD1MLjUc68-02130-00582823-00583007": "of gossip", "TKD1MLjUc68-02131-00583008-00583295": "because even not only that but also", "TKD1MLjUc68-02132-00583296-00583670": "he took sannyas from gosei marriage", "TKD1MLjUc68-02133-00583671-00584183": "so much love for gosai maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-02134-00584184-00584351": "you can stay god brother you can stay", "TKD1MLjUc68-02135-00584352-00584647": "with me it is your mouth", "TKD1MLjUc68-02136-00584648-00584814": "like mother question i told to my guru", "TKD1MLjUc68-02137-00584815-00585014": "my mother never wanted to make math it", "TKD1MLjUc68-02138-00585015-00585207": "was very simple", "TKD1MLjUc68-02139-00585208-00585455": "my guru maharaj was so simple so plain", "TKD1MLjUc68-02140-00585456-00585670": "hearted even", "TKD1MLjUc68-02141-00585671-00585847": "one five years bored this kind of", "TKD1MLjUc68-02142-00585848-00586062": "simplicity is not there now if i", "TKD1MLjUc68-02143-00586063-00586318": "remember i go mad", "TKD1MLjUc68-02144-00586319-00586543": "my kuruma is so simple", "TKD1MLjUc68-02145-00586544-00586862": "like when five years was no thought not", "TKD1MLjUc68-02146-00586863-00587255": "this kind of simplicity you cannot find", "TKD1MLjUc68-02147-00587256-00587551": "follow", "TKD1MLjUc68-02148-00587552-00587751": "for two months guru maharaj engaged me", "TKD1MLjUc68-02149-00587752-00587983": "to collect different books he liked to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02150-00587984-00588262": "go to brindavan for two months", "TKD1MLjUc68-02151-00588263-00588422": "call me", "TKD1MLjUc68-02152-00588423-00588735": "you take this book take this booth back", "TKD1MLjUc68-02153-00588736-00589022": "you took this that book he asked now you", "TKD1MLjUc68-02154-00589023-00589310": "check up maybe you miss", "TKD1MLjUc68-02155-00589311-00589596": "after two months other maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-02156-00589597-00589710": "[Music]", "TKD1MLjUc68-02157-00589711-00589847": "asking me", "TKD1MLjUc68-02158-00589848-00590087": "i am in old age how i can go to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02159-00590088-00590239": "brindavan", "TKD1MLjUc68-02160-00590240-00590479": "and somebody can get a plane ticket for", "TKD1MLjUc68-02161-00590480-00590775": "you and we can get plenty plane ticket", "TKD1MLjUc68-02162-00590776-00591055": "so costly where i can get money there", "TKD1MLjUc68-02163-00591056-00591199": "must be", "TKD1MLjUc68-02164-00591200-00591399": "where i can have no money to check my", "TKD1MLjUc68-02165-00591400-00591495": "you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-02166-00591496-00591799": "the sag they are so involved back", "TKD1MLjUc68-02167-00591800-00592007": "hardly one thousand maybe there is", "TKD1MLjUc68-02168-00592008-00592222": "closely so much", "TKD1MLjUc68-02169-00592223-00592527": "i was laughing when bhagavan going to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02170-00592528-00592687": "arrange everything for him he's thinking", "TKD1MLjUc68-02171-00592688-00592983": "where i can get money plane tickets", "TKD1MLjUc68-02172-00592984-00593222": "don't make me ticket i can afford only", "TKD1MLjUc68-02173-00593223-00593543": "10 ticket", "TKD1MLjUc68-02174-00593544-00593766": "follow this kind of simplicity even your", "TKD1MLjUc68-02175-00593767-00593975": "five years boy", "TKD1MLjUc68-02176-00593976-00594231": "you can test one five years point if", "TKD1MLjUc68-02177-00594232-00594479": "there's previous sanskrit is bad i", "TKD1MLjUc68-02178-00594480-00594807": "already tested many times i give loyance", "TKD1MLjUc68-02179-00594808-00594975": "and sweet everything", "TKD1MLjUc68-02180-00594976-00595095": "one boy", "TKD1MLjUc68-02181-00595096-00595359": "going running can take along", "TKD1MLjUc68-02182-00595360-00595743": "another boy i have seen i i'll notice", "TKD1MLjUc68-02183-00595744-00595975": "he can call sister come come come i have", "TKD1MLjUc68-02184-00595976-00596247": "sweet you can also take", "TKD1MLjUc68-02185-00596248-00596575": "this is a mood so from very childhood", "TKD1MLjUc68-02186-00596576-00596903": "so simplicity simplicity you can you can", "TKD1MLjUc68-02187-00596904-00597087": "you can think that in five years was", "TKD1MLjUc68-02188-00597088-00597318": "more simple not that", "TKD1MLjUc68-02189-00597319-00597487": "not that", "TKD1MLjUc68-02190-00597488-00597710": "i have seen the simplicity of guru", "TKD1MLjUc68-02191-00597711-00597910": "maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-02192-00597911-00598135": "so simple even though five years ago i", "TKD1MLjUc68-02193-00598136-00598255": "cannot find", "TKD1MLjUc68-02194-00598256-00598447": "so anyway", "TKD1MLjUc68-02195-00598448-00598751": "gosai maharaja finally gave his sannyas", "TKD1MLjUc68-02196-00598752-00599055": "after that his name was bhakti showroom", "TKD1MLjUc68-02197-00599056-00599279": "bhaktis for", "TKD1MLjUc68-02198-00599280-00599870": "maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-02199-00599871-00600087": "very clearly my pronunciation you cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-02200-00600088-00600222": "understand", "TKD1MLjUc68-02201-00600223-00600375": "so clean", "TKD1MLjUc68-02202-00600376-00600799": "bhakti showroom", "TKD1MLjUc68-02203-00600800-00601014": "was the editor-in-chief he has the", "TKD1MLjUc68-02204-00601015-00601287": "editor alpatiga gorilla sangha", "TKD1MLjUc68-02205-00601288-00601470": "from gaudiya sangha", "TKD1MLjUc68-02206-00601471-00601639": "they used to publish in a monthly", "TKD1MLjUc68-02207-00601640-00601999": "pathika yes they were the editor", "TKD1MLjUc68-02208-00602000-00602279": "after that took sannyas from gosai maraj", "TKD1MLjUc68-02209-00602280-00602399": "and", "TKD1MLjUc68-02210-00602400-00602743": "before gosama leaving his mod he wanted", "TKD1MLjUc68-02211-00602744-00603007": "to appoint him as the next acharya of", "TKD1MLjUc68-02212-00603008-00603166": "the temple", "TKD1MLjUc68-02213-00603167-00603414": "paulo", "TKD1MLjUc68-02214-00603415-00603735": "follow usually", "TKD1MLjUc68-02215-00603736-00604047": "one guru going to appoint his disciples", "TKD1MLjUc68-02216-00604048-00604462": "acharya but he is not quite", "TKD1MLjUc68-02217-00604463-00604727": "go say my one in written form", "TKD1MLjUc68-02218-00604728-00604935": "late one you know will", "TKD1MLjUc68-02219-00604936-00605118": "in which you write", "TKD1MLjUc68-02220-00605119-00605462": "next to me i like to appoint", "TKD1MLjUc68-02221-00605463-00605622": "bhakti", "TKD1MLjUc68-02222-00605623-00605918": "bharat saurabh bhakti sargasai maharaj", "TKD1MLjUc68-02223-00605919-00606399": "as a next president acharya president", "TKD1MLjUc68-02224-00606400-00606607": "after that he started doing it is not", "TKD1MLjUc68-02225-00606608-00606766": "his for he never wanted to become a", "TKD1MLjUc68-02226-00606767-00606918": "charity", "TKD1MLjUc68-02227-00606919-00607159": "he never wanted to become acharya so he", "TKD1MLjUc68-02228-00607160-00607407": "is there in men of bhagavan because i", "TKD1MLjUc68-02229-00607408-00607662": "deserved his arrangement", "TKD1MLjUc68-02230-00607663-00607870": "but still there was some politics", "TKD1MLjUc68-02231-00607871-00608447": "started", "TKD1MLjUc68-02232-00608448-00608566": "what to do", "TKD1MLjUc68-02233-00608567-00608710": "bad luck", "TKD1MLjUc68-02234-00608711-00608839": "after that", "TKD1MLjUc68-02235-00608840-00609070": "when sila bhakti showed about this very", "TKD1MLjUc68-02236-00609071-00609310": "very simple-hearted", "TKD1MLjUc68-02237-00609311-00609695": "all most of my guru very simple idea", "TKD1MLjUc68-02238-00609696-00609895": "most of my guru like siddhar was saying", "TKD1MLjUc68-02239-00609896-00610095": "like child", "TKD1MLjUc68-02240-00610096-00610462": "like child", "TKD1MLjUc68-02241-00610463-00610703": "maharaj is not there if marriage is", "TKD1MLjUc68-02242-00610704-00610927": "there i used to take you they catch your", "TKD1MLjUc68-02243-00610928-00611279": "hand and and go to see them see this is", "TKD1MLjUc68-02244-00611280-00611407": "called vaisnava", "TKD1MLjUc68-02245-00611408-00611535": "see this is called vaishnava", "TKD1MLjUc68-02246-00611536-00611679": "bhaktivinoda", "TKD1MLjUc68-02247-00611680-00612039": "but what to do they all live", "TKD1MLjUc68-02248-00612040-00612255": "they are leaving us anyway", "TKD1MLjUc68-02249-00612256-00612455": "so", "TKD1MLjUc68-02250-00612456-00612662": "gosei my appointment finally he", "TKD1MLjUc68-02251-00612663-00612935": "discovered some problem", "TKD1MLjUc68-02252-00612936-00613231": "he was very splendid he took decision", "TKD1MLjUc68-02253-00613232-00613543": "to give resignation later", "TKD1MLjUc68-02254-00613544-00613791": "it is because if they i also feel", "TKD1MLjUc68-02255-00613792-00613943": "problem", "TKD1MLjUc68-02256-00613944-00614175": "you believe me or not i am in bhasasana", "TKD1MLjUc68-02257-00614176-00614479": "i don't like politics from my student", "TKD1MLjUc68-02258-00614480-00614559": "life", "TKD1MLjUc68-02259-00614560-00614791": "even in college there is a boat boat you", "TKD1MLjUc68-02260-00614792-00615031": "can give both in this party that one", "TKD1MLjUc68-02261-00615032-00615310": "in that voting day i used to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02262-00615311-00615566": "become absent i don't like", "TKD1MLjUc68-02263-00615567-00615862": "in political also when i get maturity", "TKD1MLjUc68-02264-00615863-00616095": "but i know i don't like to go to give", "TKD1MLjUc68-02265-00616096-00616359": "both i hate politics", "TKD1MLjUc68-02266-00616360-00616566": "i hate politics even what to speak in", "TKD1MLjUc68-02267-00616567-00616847": "moth mundi there if there is politics a", "TKD1MLjUc68-02268-00616848-00617047": "school college if there is politics", "TKD1MLjUc68-02269-00617048-00617351": "they're all gone spoiled", "TKD1MLjUc68-02270-00617352-00617599": "so maharaja also think i think it is not", "TKD1MLjUc68-02271-00617600-00617839": "favorable for bhajan so better i can", "TKD1MLjUc68-02272-00617840-00618062": "write one resiliency later and submit to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02273-00618063-00618191": "the committee", "TKD1MLjUc68-02274-00618192-00618383": "he told me to submit", "TKD1MLjUc68-02275-00618384-00618662": "and go out of the what he crying in", "TKD1MLjUc68-02276-00618663-00618903": "front of gosammar samadhi maharaj what i", "TKD1MLjUc68-02277-00618904-00619143": "can do i wanted to serve", "TKD1MLjUc68-02278-00619144-00619399": "but this is the situation", "TKD1MLjUc68-02279-00619400-00619566": "you please excuse me", "TKD1MLjUc68-02280-00619567-00619814": "you are my sikhya guru i don't think you", "TKD1MLjUc68-02281-00619815-00620062": "are my god brother", "TKD1MLjUc68-02282-00620063-00620270": "you are crying and gone away", "TKD1MLjUc68-02283-00620271-00620462": "where to go", "TKD1MLjUc68-02284-00620463-00620670": "somebody suggesting you can open one", "TKD1MLjUc68-02285-00620671-00620903": "what i can do now i already will you", "TKD1MLjUc68-02286-00620904-00620983": "know", "TKD1MLjUc68-02287-00620984-00621247": "grow", "TKD1MLjUc68-02288-00621248-00621447": "so better i can stay with some god", "TKD1MLjUc68-02289-00621448-00621799": "brother and live life and live my body", "TKD1MLjUc68-02290-00621800-00622047": "no maharaj if you can open one more", "TKD1MLjUc68-02291-00622048-00622222": "because by that time there was so many", "TKD1MLjUc68-02292-00622223-00622335": "disciples", "TKD1MLjUc68-02293-00622336-00622695": "because he was a acharya of that much so", "TKD1MLjUc68-02294-00622696-00623079": "those are disciples where they can go", "TKD1MLjUc68-02295-00623080-00623366": "well they can come to me i can stay no", "TKD1MLjUc68-02296-00623367-00623510": "you can", "TKD1MLjUc68-02297-00623511-00623735": "where i can do i have no money", "TKD1MLjUc68-02298-00623736-00624031": "well after that our", "TKD1MLjUc68-02299-00624032-00624287": "is called god brother", "TKD1MLjUc68-02300-00624288-00624470": "our god brother should not have any", "TKD1MLjUc68-02301-00624471-00624695": "jealousy for another god brother", "TKD1MLjUc68-02302-00624696-00624959": "provided they are in line if they are", "TKD1MLjUc68-02303-00624960-00625279": "deviated surely i am going to leave them", "TKD1MLjUc68-02304-00625280-00625518": "surely that there is no question", "TKD1MLjUc68-02305-00625519-00625718": "if they are in line", "TKD1MLjUc68-02306-00625719-00625895": "if they are in line i can die if they", "TKD1MLjUc68-02307-00625896-00626118": "are in line surely", "TKD1MLjUc68-02308-00626119-00626287": "i cannot leave them", "TKD1MLjUc68-02309-00626288-00626566": "i went find some disturbance about him", "TKD1MLjUc68-02310-00626567-00626751": "i mean guru siva", "TKD1MLjUc68-02311-00626752-00626983": "but they like to they like to engage me", "TKD1MLjUc68-02312-00626984-00627214": "in their sava", "TKD1MLjUc68-02313-00627215-00627479": "i have seen everywhere", "TKD1MLjUc68-02314-00627480-00627710": "they like to use it in their own seva", "TKD1MLjUc68-02315-00627711-00627935": "they don't i say i am i like to serve", "TKD1MLjUc68-02316-00627936-00628031": "poppa", "TKD1MLjUc68-02317-00628032-00628199": "my guru told me", "TKD1MLjUc68-02318-00628200-00628359": "if you", "TKD1MLjUc68-02319-00628360-00628735": "if you serve caitanya mart it's my sava", "TKD1MLjUc68-02320-00628736-00628839": "maharaj told me", "TKD1MLjUc68-02321-00628840-00629039": "if you serve madhuba shimaraj as my", "TKD1MLjUc68-02322-00629040-00629270": "savior guru maharaj personally told me", "TKD1MLjUc68-02323-00629271-00629422": "so i took trouble but i say the", "TKD1MLjUc68-02324-00629423-00629622": "situation is different everywhere", "TKD1MLjUc68-02325-00629623-00629791": "politics", "TKD1MLjUc68-02326-00629792-00630143": "i was the only person from a whole", "TKD1MLjUc68-02327-00630144-00630327": "they'd never allow anybody to speak", "TKD1MLjUc68-02328-00630328-00630655": "harikatha then choose anyone", "TKD1MLjUc68-02329-00630656-00630855": "in front of prabhupada", "TKD1MLjUc68-02330-00630856-00631103": "was so lucky i think after that politics", "TKD1MLjUc68-02331-00631104-00631279": "said", "TKD1MLjUc68-02332-00631280-00631566": "i couldn't bear what to do", "TKD1MLjUc68-02333-00631567-00631775": "so many long history i don't like to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02334-00631776-00632022": "speak this you know it is not my bitter", "TKD1MLjUc68-02335-00632023-00632287": "experience it is my sweet experience", "TKD1MLjUc68-02336-00632288-00632599": "because due to that kind of experience", "TKD1MLjUc68-02337-00632600-00632847": "at present i can come at least up to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02338-00632848-00632951": "this", "TKD1MLjUc68-02339-00632952-00633118": "this is nothing", "TKD1MLjUc68-02340-00633119-00633383": "but still up to you can", "TKD1MLjUc68-02341-00633384-00633791": "do something i can try at least", "TKD1MLjUc68-02342-00633792-00634103": "so maharaja is going out our", "TKD1MLjUc68-02343-00634104-00634847": "bhaktha param samaras you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-02344-00634848-00635151": "one temple i don't like to name as uh is", "TKD1MLjUc68-02345-00635152-00635383": "like just like cross quarter i don't", "TKD1MLjUc68-02346-00635384-00636591": "like to name next temple this you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-02347-00636592-00636766": "going to donate", "TKD1MLjUc68-02348-00636767-00637055": "half piece of land to his good body", "TKD1MLjUc68-02349-00637056-00637262": "my brother you cannot find any land you", "TKD1MLjUc68-02350-00637263-00637614": "have no money okay i can give you", "TKD1MLjUc68-02351-00637615-00637999": "so hot piece of land give to him", "TKD1MLjUc68-02352-00638000-00638335": "happy sublime marvel so simple cannot uh", "TKD1MLjUc68-02353-00638336-00638735": "talk with somebody loud boys so simple", "TKD1MLjUc68-02354-00638736-00638966": "sar maharaj", "TKD1MLjUc68-02355-00638967-00639279": "i forget to speak so many things", "TKD1MLjUc68-02356-00639280-00639527": "maharaja opened our banana semi weapon", "TKD1MLjUc68-02357-00639528-00639831": "one oriental and uh institute of", "TKD1MLjUc68-02358-00639832-00640095": "oriental you know philosophy in", "TKD1MLjUc68-02359-00640096-00640535": "in bindavan big college", "TKD1MLjUc68-02360-00640536-00640759": "in one in in", "TKD1MLjUc68-02361-00640760-00641014": "underground there is big high school he", "TKD1MLjUc68-02362-00641015-00641118": "open", "TKD1MLjUc68-02363-00641119-00641447": "because you are sure if i can change", "TKD1MLjUc68-02364-00641448-00641662": "if i can change the whole all the heart", "TKD1MLjUc68-02365-00641663-00642110": "of this young badge i'm sure", "TKD1MLjUc68-02366-00642111-00642422": "so later on when prabhupada gone", "TKD1MLjUc68-02367-00642423-00642951": "he was declared the acharya full", "TKD1MLjUc68-02368-00642952-00643207": "i switch over to the you know back side", "TKD1MLjUc68-02369-00643208-00643455": "and front side please excuse me", "TKD1MLjUc68-02370-00643456-00643687": "he was elected as uh", "TKD1MLjUc68-02371-00643688-00643895": "he was proposed as the acharya poor", "TKD1MLjUc68-02372-00643896-00644014": "sampradaya", "TKD1MLjUc68-02373-00644015-00645343": "ramanuja sambadaya", "TKD1MLjUc68-02374-00645344-00645710": "now you understand the quality of bandus", "TKD1MLjUc68-02375-00645711-00645887": "so much book he wrote", "TKD1MLjUc68-02376-00645888-00646087": "about veda", "TKD1MLjUc68-02377-00646088-00646327": "a translation of rasam which is next to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02378-00646328-00646479": "impossible", "TKD1MLjUc68-02379-00646480-00646735": "all done so many i can discuss someday i", "TKD1MLjUc68-02380-00646736-00646983": "promise you i cannot forget up to which", "TKD1MLjUc68-02381-00646984-00647327": "point i discussed today", "TKD1MLjUc68-02382-00647328-00647447": "so", "TKD1MLjUc68-02383-00647448-00647735": "bangla maraj was now you're going to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02384-00647736-00648062": "ignore him is useless he's enough", "TKD1MLjUc68-02385-00648063-00648351": "done no seva in written form you are", "TKD1MLjUc68-02386-00648352-00648551": "writing in shaytan", "TKD1MLjUc68-02387-00648552-00648766": "that all you know all the disciples are", "TKD1MLjUc68-02388-00648767-00648983": "proper they're all useless", "TKD1MLjUc68-02389-00648984-00649191": "they're idiot", "TKD1MLjUc68-02390-00649192-00649366": "how you can write this", "TKD1MLjUc68-02391-00649367-00649639": "but one can excuse you", "TKD1MLjUc68-02392-00649640-00649847": "but one can excuse me i'm thinking", "TKD1MLjUc68-02393-00649848-00650047": "but one can excuse me", "TKD1MLjUc68-02394-00650048-00650222": "bhagavan can excuse if you are speaking", "TKD1MLjUc68-02395-00650223-00650455": "all ravish to nityananda", "TKD1MLjUc68-02396-00650456-00650679": "but one can excuse if you are going to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02397-00650680-00650935": "speak alright i mean", "TKD1MLjUc68-02398-00650936-00651110": "but bhagavan cannot excuse if you are", "TKD1MLjUc68-02399-00651111-00651439": "speaking rubbish to a pure devotee", "TKD1MLjUc68-02400-00651440-00651791": "this is siddhanta vishal anyway", "TKD1MLjUc68-02401-00651792-00652039": "we like to forget but still we'll have", "TKD1MLjUc68-02402-00652040-00652255": "to discuss otherwise all foolish people", "TKD1MLjUc68-02403-00652256-00652431": "all over the world they cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-02404-00652432-00652591": "understand they think it is a you are", "TKD1MLjUc68-02405-00652592-00652695": "stick", "TKD1MLjUc68-02406-00652696-00652847": "they can think it is a you are stick up", "TKD1MLjUc68-02407-00652848-00653022": "to this level this is a standard of", "TKD1MLjUc68-02408-00653023-00653262": "gorilla not that", "TKD1MLjUc68-02409-00653263-00653391": "not that", "TKD1MLjUc68-02410-00653392-00653583": "to understand that you are stick up", "TKD1MLjUc68-02411-00653584-00653743": "goryaman", "TKD1MLjUc68-02412-00653744-00653918": "you will have to take", "TKD1MLjUc68-02413-00653919-00654159": "you know countless parts", "TKD1MLjUc68-02414-00654160-00654447": "or you can do provided", "TKD1MLjUc68-02415-00654448-00654559": "you are", "TKD1MLjUc68-02416-00654560-00654751": "showing submission into a lotus feet of", "TKD1MLjUc68-02417-00654752-00655151": "a pure devotee who is exactly in line", "TKD1MLjUc68-02418-00655152-00655407": "with papa these two conditions either", "TKD1MLjUc68-02419-00655408-00655735": "you can take risks a countless birth or", "TKD1MLjUc68-02420-00655736-00656007": "next option you can show the submission", "TKD1MLjUc68-02421-00656008-00656183": "of the routers", "TKD1MLjUc68-02422-00656184-00656518": "these two", "TKD1MLjUc68-02423-00656519-00656814": "i cannot make any mistake in siddha not", "TKD1MLjUc68-02424-00656815-00656983": "possible", "TKD1MLjUc68-02425-00656984-00657287": "hundred percent sure about it", "TKD1MLjUc68-02426-00657288-00657447": "so anyway", "TKD1MLjUc68-02427-00657448-00657775": "so maharaja wanted to make temple", "TKD1MLjUc68-02428-00657776-00658143": "but maharaj was busy you know he", "TKD1MLjUc68-02429-00658144-00658470": "uh to arrange the situation how you can", "TKD1MLjUc68-02430-00658471-00658743": "in the meantime some refugee refuge you", "TKD1MLjUc68-02431-00658744-00658983": "know from other country they're coming", "TKD1MLjUc68-02432-00658984-00659222": "they want to make one tent in the vacant", "TKD1MLjUc68-02433-00659223-00659383": "land and", "TKD1MLjUc68-02434-00659384-00659622": "capture that land", "TKD1MLjUc68-02435-00659623-00659831": "capture the land and maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-02436-00659832-00660022": "ready how i can fight you in there how", "TKD1MLjUc68-02437-00660023-00660175": "they can come", "TKD1MLjUc68-02438-00660176-00660422": "mahwaj cannot make any walnut because no", "TKD1MLjUc68-02439-00660423-00660518": "money", "TKD1MLjUc68-02440-00660519-00660679": "manage waiting", "TKD1MLjUc68-02441-00660680-00660910": "for the deserve in the meantime some", "TKD1MLjUc68-02442-00660911-00661135": "refugees they capture the place", "TKD1MLjUc68-02443-00661136-00661391": "and one polish man", "TKD1MLjUc68-02444-00661392-00661655": "one polish man from krishnan he went to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02445-00661656-00661887": "support them because", "TKD1MLjUc68-02446-00661888-00662135": "because his policeman his father and", "TKD1MLjUc68-02447-00662136-00662327": "mother and brother was there in that", "TKD1MLjUc68-02448-00662328-00662455": "refugee", "TKD1MLjUc68-02449-00662456-00662622": "wanted to protect he wanted to give", "TKD1MLjUc68-02450-00662623-00662783": "power", "TKD1MLjUc68-02451-00662784-00662958": "to capture that land", "TKD1MLjUc68-02452-00662959-00663199": "finally maharaja speaking i cannot fight", "TKD1MLjUc68-02453-00663200-00663391": "with them so better it is maybe it is a", "TKD1MLjUc68-02454-00663392-00663495": "desire or", "TKD1MLjUc68-02455-00663496-00663687": "i don't like to fight when i cannot make", "TKD1MLjUc68-02456-00663688-00663870": "anything", "TKD1MLjUc68-02457-00663871-00664118": "follow finally", "TKD1MLjUc68-02458-00664119-00664279": "somehow", "TKD1MLjUc68-02459-00664280-00664647": "this situation came into the notice of", "TKD1MLjUc68-02460-00664648-00664910": "kesha prabhu i am in the disciple of", "TKD1MLjUc68-02461-00664911-00665031": "prabhupada", "TKD1MLjUc68-02462-00665032-00665191": "kesha prabhu who used to stay with", "TKD1MLjUc68-02463-00665192-00665422": "madhukushima madhukushima also came to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02464-00665423-00665695": "know", "TKD1MLjUc68-02465-00665696-00665975": "then our bharti march was bhamusha", "TKD1MLjUc68-02466-00665976-00666310": "stroud figure", "TKD1MLjUc68-02467-00666311-00666583": "to serve gurudev", "TKD1MLjUc68-02468-00666584-00666783": "one big stick", "TKD1MLjUc68-02469-00666784-00667047": "going in front of the refugee", "TKD1MLjUc68-02470-00667048-00667407": "you are going to leave this place or not", "TKD1MLjUc68-02471-00667408-00667695": "our bharti maharaja for guru seva what", "TKD1MLjUc68-02472-00667696-00667887": "to do we learn", "TKD1MLjUc68-02473-00667888-00668151": "you like to leave this place or not", "TKD1MLjUc68-02474-00668152-00668455": "or your son who is doing police service", "TKD1MLjUc68-02475-00668456-00668735": "in krishna are going to lose", "TKD1MLjUc68-02476-00668736-00668958": "you you you can prefer", "TKD1MLjUc68-02477-00668959-00669214": "your son can lose service you know who", "TKD1MLjUc68-02478-00669215-00669283": "am", "TKD1MLjUc68-02479-00669284-00669583": "i you have to leave this backhand i am", "TKD1MLjUc68-02480-00669584-00669791": "going to calcutta i can come back i like", "TKD1MLjUc68-02481-00669792-00670127": "to find the places backhand", "TKD1MLjUc68-02482-00670128-00670303": "they were very because he was very", "TKD1MLjUc68-02483-00670304-00670455": "strong figure", "TKD1MLjUc68-02484-00670456-00670695": "important personality birthing much", "TKD1MLjUc68-02485-00670696-00670918": "he'll look at barthima you have fear", "TKD1MLjUc68-02486-00670919-00671199": "well we expense we have some you know", "TKD1MLjUc68-02487-00671200-00671414": "expenses we look forward to make that", "TKD1MLjUc68-02488-00671415-00671670": "make the tent well i can give you yeah", "TKD1MLjUc68-02489-00671671-00671870": "no", "TKD1MLjUc68-02490-00671871-00672175": "they all backhand", "TKD1MLjUc68-02491-00672176-00672422": "policeman giving threaten", "TKD1MLjUc68-02492-00672423-00672655": "threatening to maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-02493-00672656-00672847": "and our batsman is giving threatening to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02494-00672848-00673007": "the polish man", "TKD1MLjUc68-02495-00673008-00673327": "you like to save your service or not", "TKD1MLjUc68-02496-00673328-00673487": "you speak now", "TKD1MLjUc68-02497-00673488-00673751": "if you like to save your service", "TKD1MLjUc68-02498-00673752-00673831": "go", "TKD1MLjUc68-02499-00673832-00674039": "go from here", "TKD1MLjUc68-02500-00674040-00674175": "they're gone", "TKD1MLjUc68-02501-00674176-00674510": "after that this is called guru shiva", "TKD1MLjUc68-02502-00674511-00674710": "for guru seva", "TKD1MLjUc68-02503-00674711-00674895": "if i like to speak", "TKD1MLjUc68-02504-00674896-00675399": "if i have to go up to the level", "TKD1MLjUc68-02505-00675400-00675647": "said by prabhupada i like to go if i go", "TKD1MLjUc68-02506-00675648-00675791": "to low level", "TKD1MLjUc68-02507-00675792-00676031": "to fight with some you know dirty people", "TKD1MLjUc68-02508-00676032-00676303": "that criticizing my guru", "TKD1MLjUc68-02509-00676304-00676775": "i can do i can go to polish no problem", "TKD1MLjUc68-02510-00676776-00676975": "this is called education", "TKD1MLjUc68-02511-00676976-00677366": "so now maharaja making nice temple", "TKD1MLjUc68-02512-00677367-00679095": "very nice temple and my guru maharaja", "TKD1MLjUc68-02513-00679096-00679255": "hand there", "TKD1MLjUc68-02514-00679256-00679495": "my guru has established all", "TKD1MLjUc68-02515-00679496-00679847": "and to help god brother", "TKD1MLjUc68-02516-00679848-00680062": "so i am very sorry i couldn't speak", "TKD1MLjUc68-02517-00680063-00680383": "anything about those exalted devotees", "TKD1MLjUc68-02518-00680384-00680679": "i couldn't speak anything the ocean", "TKD1MLjUc68-02519-00680680-00680935": "excuse me i like to bake for pardon", "TKD1MLjUc68-02520-00680936-00681183": "also the first look i went i wanted to", "TKD1MLjUc68-02521-00681184-00681422": "clarify the first look but time cannot", "TKD1MLjUc68-02522-00681423-00681679": "permit i will have to go and start", "TKD1MLjUc68-02523-00681680-00685599": "another save of what to do", "TKD1MLjUc68-02524-00685600-00685900": "um"}}]