[{"audio_id": "W6Ik1MEkbky", "text": {"W6Ik1MEkbky-00000-00000032-00000191": "i love quinn penske", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00001-00000192-00000543": "[Music]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00002-00000544-00001174": "and i love logan reese", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00003-00001175-00001803": "you used me", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00004-00001804-00003647": "[Music]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00005-00003647-00003911": "stir the tuna why do you keep saying", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00006-00003911-00003990": "that", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00007-00003992-00004511": "stomp the grapes and that", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00008-00004512-00004665": "okay", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00009-00004666-00005743": "[Applause]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00010-00005744-00006167": "[Music]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00011-00006168-00006334": "stacy", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00012-00006335-00006534": "he made me drive a stick shift oh he", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00013-00006536-00006975": "graped when he should have tuna", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00014-00006976-00007095": "stacy", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00015-00007095-00007263": "say something", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00016-00007264-00007519": "what struck me", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00017-00007520-00007855": "something slammed into my side", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00018-00007856-00008070": "i'm gonna be seriously sore", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00019-00008072-00008271": "did you hear her yeah", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00020-00008272-00008631": "stacy's asses sound normal", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00021-00008632-00008814": "say something else", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00022-00008815-00008983": "my name is stacy dilson and i'm from", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00023-00008984-00009342": "swampscott massachusetts", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00024-00009343-00009814": "oh my god my asses sound perfect", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00025-00009815-00010031": "my sister suzanne's a staff sergeant at", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00026-00010032-00010305": "saint stephen's hospital in mississippi", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00027-00010306-00010951": "[Applause]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00028-00010952-00011183": "i can't believe it", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00029-00011184-00011278": "i know", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00030-00011279-00011591": "she talks perfectly now", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00031-00011592-00012151": "chase she talks perfectly now", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00032-00012152-00012551": "michael", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00033-00012552-00012710": "all right all right don't break my", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00034-00012711-00012838": "boyfriend", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00035-00012839-00013511": "your boyfriend yeah we just got done yes", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00036-00013512-00013679": "all right can we all go dance now before", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00037-00013680-00013943": "the prom is over yeah let's dance let's", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00038-00013944-00014143": "dance all right but wait i got to move", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00039-00014144-00014286": "my car first i'll meet you there in a", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00040-00014287-00014638": "sec", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00041-00014640-00014952": "chase", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00042-00014953-00015615": "[Music]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00043-00015616-00016854": "is who i'm always going to be", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00044-00016855-00017583": "[Music]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00045-00017584-00017919": "mr takato", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00046-00017920-00018111": "hello michael", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00047-00018112-00018191": "uh", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00048-00018192-00018343": "would you please come tell my girlfriend", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00049-00018344-00018622": "that you really work here at pca oh", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00050-00018623-00018855": "i can't do that", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00051-00018856-00018975": "why not", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00052-00018976-00019094": "because", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00053-00019095-00019778": "i do not exist", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00054-00019779-00021045": "[Music]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00055-00021046-00021706": "[Music]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00056-00021707-00022343": "[Music]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00057-00022344-00022748": "here we go", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00058-00022749-00022819": "[Music]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00059-00022820-00023115": "[Applause]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00060-00023116-00024035": "[Music]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00061-00024036-00024775": "[Music]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00062-00024776-00024958": "any plans for the summer", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00063-00024959-00025175": "nope why you want to spend it with me in", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00064-00025176-00025319": "hawaii", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00065-00025320-00025455": "hawaii", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00066-00025456-00025670": "you and me all summer", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00067-00025672-00026277": "yes", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00068-00026279-00026887": "[Music]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00069-00026888-00027287": "so he's with chase", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00070-00027288-00027446": "hey there's a girl", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00071-00027447-00028002": "and her foot's stuck in the fence", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00072-00028004-00028195": "[Music]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00073-00028197-00028814": "[Applause]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00074-00028816-00029023": "it's my fault we're late did we miss", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00075-00029024-00029127": "anything good", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00076-00029127-00029358": "nah you didn't miss much it's nothing", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00077-00029360-00030606": "important no good cause cheers", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00078-00030607-00031395": "[Applause]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00079-00031397-00032374": "[Music]", "W6Ik1MEkbky-00080-00032375-00032675": "too"}}, {"audio_id": "W6VcGEHh_dI", "text": {"W6VcGEHh_dI-00000-00000053-00000316": "kay electric football club commonly", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00001-00000317-00000611": "referred to as K electric FC or simply", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00002-00000612-00000884": "known as K is a Pakistani football club", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00003-00000885-00001082": "located in Karachi Sindh", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00004-00001083-00001262": "that plays in the Pakistan Premier", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00005-00001263-00001523": "League the club's home stadium is", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00006-00001524-00001712": "people's football stadium and has", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00007-00001713-00002042": "affiliated with K electric K electric", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00008-00002043-00002252": "along with Karachi Port Trust and", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00009-00002253-00002429": "Karachi United are among the major", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00010-00002430-00002780": "football clubs from Karachi founded in", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00011-00002781-00003160": "1913 k electric won promotion in 2005", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00012-00003161-00003343": "from the Pakistan Football Federation", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00013-00003344-00003568": "league when they finished runners-up to", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00014-00003569-00003862": "Pakistan railways the club won their", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00015-00003863-00004147": "first league title in 2014-15 season", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00016-00004148-00004384": "previously finishing as runners-up in", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00017-00004385-00004606": "the past two seasons becoming the first", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00018-00004607-00004825": "club from Pakistan to have qualified for", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00019-00004826-00005209": "AFC Cup the club colours reflected in", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00020-00005210-00005411": "their crest and KITT are back in yellow", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00021-00005412-00005686": "in August 2015", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00022-00005687-00005966": "K electric FC made Pakistan football", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00023-00005967-00006196": "history by becoming the first Pakistan", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00024-00006197-00006436": "Football Club to progress into the AFC", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00025-00006437-00006631": "Cup playoffs after overcoming the", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00026-00006633-00006931": "champions of Bhutan and Mongolia they", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00027-00006933-00007139": "drew three to three with druk United", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00028-00007140-00007387": "before beating qoran Khan won 2-0", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00029-00007388-00007727": "however in the playoffs they lost to 2-0", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00030-00007728-00008087": "to all hid in October that same year k", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00031-00008088-00008315": "Electric FC competed in the sheikh kamal", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00032-00008316-00008606": "international club cup their striker", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00033-00008607-00008876": "Mohammad Rasool scored four goals in", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00034-00008877-00009045": "three games", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00035-00009046-00009294": "kay electric also organized various", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00036-00009295-00009468": "youth initiatives such as the Kay", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00037-00009469-00010253": "electric lie our EU 16 football league", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00038-00010254-00010780": "topic rivalry", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00039-00010781-00011035": "the club has a long-standing rivalry", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00040-00011036-00011242": "with Rawalpindi based Khan Research", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00041-00011243-00011551": "Laboratories the rivalry started when", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00042-00011552-00011724": "Kay electric and Kahn Research", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00043-00011725-00011914": "Laboratories faced off in two", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00044-00011915-00012142": "back-to-back Pakistan National Challenge", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00045-00012143-00012487": "Cup finals in 2011 and 2012 with Kahn", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00046-00012488-00012699": "Research Laboratories winning both the", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00047-00012700-00012937": "finals one to zero and three to one on", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00048-00012938-00013171": "penalties with game drawn zero to zero", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00049-00013172-00013450": "after extra time respectively although", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00050-00013451-00013687": "it was Kay electric that ended the reign", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00051-00013688-00013882": "of Kahn research laboratories as", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00052-00013883-00014065": "domestic champions when they won the", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00053-00014066-00014810": "league in 2014-15 season", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00054-00014811-00015663": "topic players", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00055-00015663-00016209": "topic current squad", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00056-00016210-00016497": "as of the second of November 2018 note", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00057-00016498-00016716": "flags indicate national team as defined", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00058-00016717-00016973": "under FIFA eligibility rules", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00059-00016974-00017217": "players may hold more than one non-fifa", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00060-00017218-00017818": "nationality", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00061-00017819-00018724": "topic coaching staff", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00062-00018725-00019365": "topic honors", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00063-00019366-00019602": "you", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00064-00019603-00020083": "topic winners", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00065-00020084-00020363": "Pakistan Premier League one two oh one", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00066-00020364-00020919": "four one five", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00067-00020920-00021412": "topic runner-up", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00068-00021413-00021864": "Pakistan Premier League to 201 to 1/3", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00069-00021865-00022141": "2013-14 Pakistan National Football", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00070-00022142-00022743": "Challenge Cup for 201 1 2012 2013 2014", "W6VcGEHh_dI-00071-00022744-00023203": "Eccles equals continental history"}}, {"audio_id": "W6cY8gZHeeE", "text": {"W6cY8gZHeeE-00000-00000036-00000807": "[Music]", "W6cY8gZHeeE-00001-00000808-00001710": "so", "W6cY8gZHeeE-00002-00001711-00002048": "i see lots of prey", "W6cY8gZHeeE-00003-00002049-00003118": "[Music]", "W6cY8gZHeeE-00004-00003119-00003419": "enemies"}}, {"audio_id": "W783siTlZiY", "text": {"W783siTlZiY-00000-00001188-00019216": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "W7gXu6uqcBQ", "text": {"W7gXu6uqcBQ-00000-00000041-00001166": "[Music]", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00001-00001167-00001374": "alrighty", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00002-00001375-00001491": "hello", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00003-00001492-00001814": "everyone mike here can you stop why in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00004-00001816-00002718": "the chat if you can hear me", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00005-00002719-00002895": "hello to everyone that's on here hello", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00006-00002896-00003206": "anne hello ben chris clint", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00007-00003207-00003551": "diane elaine george and barbara jackie", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00008-00003552-00003719": "linda", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00009-00003720-00004006": "mark steven vic", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00010-00004007-00004151": "hello to you all thank you all for", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00011-00004152-00004502": "coming", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00012-00004503-00004647": "excellent and my mic's working that's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00013-00004648-00005231": "always a plus", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00014-00005232-00005406": "all right", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00015-00005407-00005670": "we'll get stuck straight into it guys so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00016-00005671-00005911": "welcome today to our webinar on advanced", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00017-00005912-00006086": "manifest manifestation training for", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00018-00006087-00006334": "business owners and investors", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00019-00006335-00006567": "um so the goal of this webinar now is to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00020-00006568-00006734": "really give you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00021-00006736-00006934": "you know be able to help you transform", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00022-00006936-00007046": "your consciousness and be able to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00023-00007047-00007239": "actually have you know a structured way", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00024-00007240-00007431": "that you can manifest more abundance", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00025-00007431-00007878": "into your into your current business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00026-00007879-00008023": "so just a little bit of housekeeping as", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00027-00008023-00008231": "we start just make sure you don't um you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00028-00008232-00008383": "know your phones are turned silently you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00029-00008384-00008574": "have no distractions around you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00030-00008575-00008767": "and feel free to take handwritten notes", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00031-00008768-00008983": "there will be a recording available you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00032-00008984-00009191": "know this of this webinar for you guys", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00033-00009192-00009367": "at the end but i would highly recommend", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00034-00009368-00009527": "so you can", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00035-00009528-00009735": "start using the manifest manifestation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00036-00009736-00009910": "technique straight away", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00037-00009911-00010046": "that you are sort of you know taking", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00038-00010047-00010231": "notes of those on on the protocol that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00039-00010232-00010351": "we have", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00040-00010352-00010455": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00041-00010456-00010599": "and there will be any there will be an", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00042-00010600-00010791": "offer at the end um for more advanced", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00043-00010792-00010903": "training for those of you that are", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00044-00010904-00011095": "wanting to really you know take your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00045-00011096-00011367": "manifestation to the next level um and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00046-00011368-00011478": "obviously any questions that you have", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00047-00011479-00011678": "along the way uh feel free to just talk", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00048-00011679-00011855": "me to the chat at any point", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00049-00011856-00012078": "um i generally will see them and respond", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00050-00012079-00012231": "relatively quickly", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00051-00012232-00012414": "but if i don't respond and i'm sort of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00052-00012415-00012551": "through a slide and explaining something", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00053-00012552-00012623": "then", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00054-00012624-00012791": "just know that i'll get to it as soon as", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00055-00012792-00013183": "i can", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00056-00013184-00013343": "okay so what you'll learn today now", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00057-00013344-00013503": "you're gonna learn how everything we see", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00058-00013504-00013758": "in our physical 3d reality is a hologram", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00059-00013759-00013903": "uh how we can transform energy and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00060-00013904-00014038": "manifest a different outcome in our", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00061-00014040-00014294": "finances health and our relationships", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00062-00014295-00014463": "all through the power of our mind and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00063-00014463-00014751": "the power of our intention", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00064-00014752-00014894": "so how we can shift our intention and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00065-00014895-00015103": "our present financial consciousness to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00066-00015104-00015391": "expand our wealth exponentially", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00067-00015391-00015599": "how to clear any and shift any financial", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00068-00015600-00015743": "block which is stopping us from moving", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00069-00015744-00015927": "forward", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00070-00015928-00016103": "and how holographic manifestation skills", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00071-00016104-00016375": "can slash your taxes stop a tax order", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00072-00016376-00016511": "and even cause a speeding or parking", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00073-00016512-00016750": "fund or nasty lawsuit to completely", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00074-00016751-00016886": "vanish so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00075-00016887-00017030": "these stories once you once you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00076-00017031-00017175": "this technique and once you can clear", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00077-00017176-00017327": "things like that it's it's you know it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00078-00017328-00017463": "very it's quite simple to make these", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00079-00017464-00017599": "things kind of happen", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00080-00017600-00017758": "and we're going to go through examples", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00081-00017759-00018055": "of that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00082-00018056-00018239": "so you're going to learn how or why", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00083-00018240-00018399": "investment losses occur so how they", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00084-00018400-00018599": "remain as imprints trapped in your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00085-00018600-00018791": "morphogenetic field", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00086-00018792-00018927": "and how you can clear these imprints to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00087-00018928-00019303": "prevent these events from repeating", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00088-00019304-00019463": "learn more causes you to attract losing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00089-00019464-00019694": "investments financial drains or tax", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00090-00019695-00019855": "audits in your business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00091-00019856-00019983": "and how it relates to the energetic", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00092-00019984-00020175": "imprints from parents past traumatic", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00093-00020176-00020350": "experiences around money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00094-00020351-00020558": "negative energy of others and how you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00095-00020559-00020719": "can actually shift those in your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00096-00020720-00020886": "imprints and reprogram yourself to be", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00097-00020887-00021063": "able to actually attract in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00098-00021064-00021239": "instead of repelling all those", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00099-00021240-00021407": "um you know good opportunities around", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00100-00021408-00021822": "finances and money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00101-00021823-00021943": "you'll also learn why you're paying too", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00102-00021944-00022150": "much tax and how much of this relates to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00103-00022151-00022399": "energetic imprints again from family", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00104-00022400-00022550": "post-hypnotic suggestions from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00105-00022551-00022663": "government", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00106-00022664-00022855": "uh even past life imprints and again how", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00107-00022856-00023086": "you can imprint and shift these uh that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00108-00023087-00023230": "brainwashing you've got", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00109-00023231-00023391": "you know that we receive when we're", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00110-00023392-00023614": "young and is just programmed into us", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00111-00023615-00023735": "so again challenging some of those", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00112-00023736-00023919": "beliefs that you might have um that you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00113-00023920-00024119": "might not even realize you have", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00114-00024120-00024239": "and then again", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00115-00024240-00024407": "trying to sort of make that conscious", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00116-00024408-00024542": "and by making something that's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00117-00024543-00024750": "subconscious conscious that's how we can", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00118-00024751-00025271": "actually work and start changing it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00119-00025272-00025342": "so we are going to give you an", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00120-00025343-00025550": "introduction to our unique technology on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00121-00025551-00025750": "etheric asset protection", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00122-00025751-00025878": "uh so there's you know you can have all", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00123-00025879-00026046": "the right structures you can do all the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00124-00026047-00026255": "right things uh and you still get sued", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00125-00026256-00026367": "you still have all these problems and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00126-00026368-00026599": "governments and lawsuits against you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00127-00026600-00026702": "so we are going to teach you how you can", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00128-00026704-00026831": "create a shield of protection around", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00129-00026832-00027087": "your wealth uh and be immune", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00130-00027088-00027527": "to these lawsuits", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00131-00027527-00027735": "so for those that are keen again like i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00132-00027736-00028014": "said we i will be making an offer for an", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00133-00028016-00028246": "advanced course at the end", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00134-00028247-00028407": "um where you can actually see specific", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00135-00028408-00028599": "tangible money results", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00136-00028600-00028727": "uh you'll learn how to take control of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00137-00028727-00028935": "your 3d life hologram and create the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00138-00028936-00029127": "life you desire by transforming your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00139-00029127-00029311": "belief systems", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00140-00029312-00029455": "and clear bad experiences with", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00141-00029456-00029670": "investments government and tax", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00142-00029672-00029967": "so you can see new results", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00143-00029968-00030095": "and we have had clients that have", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00144-00030095-00030207": "increased their income from anywhere", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00145-00030208-00030399": "from 50 percent you know all the way up", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00146-00030400-00030599": "to a thousand plus uh and i'm going to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00147-00030600-00030751": "get plenty of personal experiences on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00148-00030752-00030862": "what that's done", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00149-00030863-00031055": "for me and my journey and how i learned", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00150-00031056-00031207": "it and sort of where my locks are now", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00151-00031208-00031351": "thanks to learning you know these", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00152-00031352-00031535": "techniques and implementing them into my", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00153-00031536-00031935": "life and business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00154-00031936-00032095": "so even if you don't want to do the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00155-00032095-00032223": "training then you're going to get", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00156-00032224-00032431": "immense value from this webinar today", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00157-00032432-00032574": "i'll make it very clear where the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00158-00032575-00032743": "webinar stops so for those that are not", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00159-00032744-00032959": "interested you can jump straight off um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00160-00032960-00033095": "but again you are going to get our seven", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00161-00033096-00033255": "structured seven-step structured", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00162-00033256-00033446": "protocol into how you can actually", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00163-00033447-00033607": "you know be more conscious and be more", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00164-00033608-00033839": "directive with your manifestations", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00165-00033840-00033983": "because at the end of the day you are", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00166-00033984-00034239": "you are constantly manifesting whether", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00167-00034240-00034383": "whether it's conscious or unconscious or", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00168-00034384-00034574": "subconscious um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00169-00034575-00034695": "but if you're more conscious about it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00170-00034696-00034871": "and follow this protocol", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00171-00034872-00035023": "it becomes much more powerful because", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00172-00035024-00035199": "you can actually intentionally direct", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00173-00035200-00035390": "your thoughts into bringing it about", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00174-00035391-00035862": "into your reality quicker", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00175-00035863-00036095": "so who this webinar is for", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00176-00036096-00036230": "so you're having challenges in your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00177-00036231-00036318": "business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00178-00036319-00036471": "and the current world situation so it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00179-00036472-00036702": "probably getting a little bit down", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00180-00036703-00036855": "and you're really not making the money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00181-00036856-00036967": "you desire at this time and you'd love", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00182-00036968-00037174": "to attract a whole lot more so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00183-00037175-00037295": "i'd say predominantly most of you that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00184-00037296-00037455": "are on this webinar now are on here", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00185-00037456-00037687": "because you want to have a way of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00186-00037688-00038255": "bringing in money a lot more easily", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00187-00038256-00038390": "number two so your business is doing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00188-00038391-00038590": "well but you're paying high taxes had", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00189-00038591-00038743": "issues with regulators or attracted", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00190-00038744-00038927": "problems in the past whether it's with", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00191-00038928-00039183": "governments whether it's lawsuits police", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00192-00039184-00039455": "just bad clients that kind of thing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00193-00039456-00039630": "and you may be worried about the great", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00194-00039631-00039727": "reset", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00195-00039728-00039918": "and losing your heart and wealth and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00196-00039919-00040071": "wishing to clear all these perceptions", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00197-00040072-00040262": "and doubts in this regard", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00198-00040263-00040415": "and flip that perception so it does", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00199-00040416-00040535": "become the greatest financial", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00200-00040536-00040735": "opportunity of your life", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00201-00040736-00040918": "because it can be very easy with all the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00202-00040919-00041087": "everything going around on the world at", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00203-00041088-00041318": "the moment you get sucked into that and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00204-00041319-00041518": "you know it imprints into you just from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00205-00041519-00041623": "the people that you hang around or", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00206-00041624-00041846": "things you see on tv or whatever and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00207-00041847-00041990": "suddenly all these things start to come", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00208-00041991-00042223": "into your life into your reality that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00209-00042224-00042351": "you know the opposite of what you're", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00210-00042352-00042799": "wanting", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00211-00042800-00042918": "so you're number three you're", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00212-00042919-00043102": "financially successful in your business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00213-00043103-00043230": "and doing well", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00214-00043231-00043367": "but desire to master your mind and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00215-00043368-00043567": "intuition to go to the next level", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00216-00043568-00043671": "and you'll see", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00217-00043672-00043815": "you just receiving greater results in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00218-00043816-00044071": "health relationships quality life", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00219-00044072-00044262": "but you feel there are you have current", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00220-00044263-00044399": "consciousness challenges to shift", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00221-00044400-00044567": "through so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00222-00044568-00044695": "notice that we're working with with", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00223-00044696-00044862": "people that are super successful in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00224-00044863-00044999": "business they", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00225-00045000-00045135": "tend to get to a point where the money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00226-00045136-00045407": "doesn't matter anymore or not so much", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00227-00045408-00045535": "and they're really feeling like they can", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00228-00045536-00045718": "go deeper and make life you know they're", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00229-00045719-00045855": "sick of spinning the wheels they're sick", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00230-00045856-00045943": "of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00231-00045944-00046127": "working ridiculous hours", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00232-00046128-00046271": "um they want money to be able or", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00233-00046272-00046462": "abundant to be able to attract it a lot", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00234-00046463-00046574": "more easily", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00235-00046575-00047183": "and this is going to be for you as well", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00236-00047184-00047311": "so your business is successful but", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00237-00047312-00047479": "you're ready to go to the next level", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00238-00047480-00047574": "you know there's a missing link", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00239-00047575-00047671": "somewhere", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00240-00047672-00047839": "and you're very open to alternatives", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00241-00047840-00047974": "such as working with your subconscious", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00242-00047975-00048062": "mind", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00243-00048063-00048239": "10 times your business and investments", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00244-00048240-00048486": "and explore alternative possibilities", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00245-00048487-00048718": "such as how to connect to your intuition", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00246-00048719-00048823": "and profit", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00247-00048824-00048958": "financially", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00248-00048959-00049135": "so just type a wine to the chat if this", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00249-00049136-00049302": "sounds or one of those three or this", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00250-00049303-00049495": "sounds like you and where you're at", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00251-00049496-00050743": "currently", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00252-00050744-00051143": "yep good", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00253-00051144-00051599": "beautiful", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00254-00051600-00051782": "okay so the biggest thing that we want", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00255-00051783-00051935": "to know that we want to get to the point", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00256-00051936-00052030": "where i want to get across in this", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00257-00052032-00052175": "webinar is that everything is energy", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00258-00052176-00052311": "right everything is energy and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00259-00052312-00052463": "everything can be transformed as the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00260-00052464-00052742": "great raymond grace uh has taught and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00261-00052744-00052847": "probably taught a lot of you that are on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00262-00052848-00052999": "the webinar here", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00263-00053000-00053135": "right now", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00264-00053136-00053319": "we have the power to create", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00265-00053320-00053463": "bringing anything into our reality with", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00266-00053464-00053599": "our own thoughts", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00267-00053600-00053799": "um so once you really", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00268-00053800-00053959": "you know when you really sort of accept", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00269-00053960-00054111": "that and that's how it is that your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00270-00054112-00054271": "external world is a reflection of your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00271-00054272-00054438": "current internal world", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00272-00054439-00054607": "you really do have that powerful shift", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00273-00054608-00054711": "in terms of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00274-00054712-00054863": "being able to utilize and connect to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00275-00054864-00055023": "that source energy", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00276-00055024-00055182": "of the universe to be able to bring in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00277-00055183-00055375": "you know whatever it is you want now the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00278-00055376-00055566": "speed of what you can bring it in that's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00279-00055567-00055791": "another that's another thing so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00280-00055791-00055919": "we are going to talk about a lot about", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00281-00055920-00056103": "as for how the things that stop things", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00282-00056104-00056319": "from manifesting so quickly again the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00283-00056320-00056542": "beliefs um you know blockages in energy", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00284-00056544-00056766": "blockages in your chakras um all these", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00285-00056767-00056942": "things are going to be um you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00286-00056944-00057142": "stopping those manifestations or desires", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00287-00057144-00057335": "that you have currently from from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00288-00057336-00057463": "actually coming around and coming into", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00289-00057464-00057711": "your reality so make no mistake when you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00290-00057712-00057903": "make that shift internally", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00291-00057904-00058047": "subconsciously", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00292-00058048-00058166": "and you brainwash yourself into", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00293-00058167-00058342": "believing the things that you actually", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00294-00058344-00058454": "want to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00295-00058455-00058687": "to manifest you'll be surprised how", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00296-00058688-00059263": "quickly uh your life will change", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00297-00059264-00059463": "so to understand how well where this", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00298-00059464-00059623": "sort of happened we need to talk about", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00299-00059624-00059887": "sort of dr masaru omoto so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00300-00059888-00060175": "he sort of revolutionized the idea that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00301-00060176-00060311": "our thoughts and intentions can actually", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00302-00060312-00060542": "have a direct impact on physical", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00303-00060544-00060926": "physical world right so he studied water", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00304-00060927-00061079": "and he studied water under sort of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00305-00061079-00061279": "magnetic resonance imaging", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00306-00061279-00061550": "and high speed sort of photography", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00307-00061551-00061766": "and he discovered that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00308-00061767-00061959": "when water was exposed to different", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00309-00061960-00062071": "words", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00310-00062072-00062254": "uh the shape of the crystals actually", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00311-00062255-00062359": "changed", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00312-00062360-00062591": "um so this is what he found", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00313-00062591-00062759": "you know when he was taking these photos", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00314-00062760-00062854": "as", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00315-00062855-00063047": "basically the water was exposed to these", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00316-00063048-00063175": "words", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00317-00063176-00063335": "and they observed sort of what what", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00318-00063336-00063559": "shapes these crystals took um you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00319-00063560-00063750": "the form they took on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00320-00063751-00063926": "so as you can see here you've got", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00321-00063927-00064071": "you know your compassion your thank you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00322-00064072-00064247": "your wisdom they're all very nicely", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00323-00064248-00064375": "shaped", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00324-00064376-00064950": "harmony joy angel those kind of things", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00325-00064951-00065199": "and then you can he also did comparisons", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00326-00065200-00065366": "with sound and and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00327-00065367-00065550": "you know music and things like that and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00328-00065551-00065735": "actually looked what how the water", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00329-00065736-00065967": "reacted to that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00330-00065968-00066167": "and you can see here like for example", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00331-00066168-00066311": "you know the difference between you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00332-00066312-00066535": "heavy metal music uh you know saying", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00333-00066536-00066831": "words like i will kill you or you fool", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00334-00066832-00066982": "um the difference in what it actually", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00335-00066983-00067159": "does to water so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00336-00067160-00067382": "it was really a pioneer when it came to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00337-00067383-00067559": "actually bringing that into the into the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00338-00067560-00067903": "limelight um and there's been plenty of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00339-00067904-00068103": "scientists and studies done from his", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00340-00068104-00068191": "work", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00341-00068192-00068319": "um that has actually sort of brought", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00342-00068320-00068423": "that about i mean that now there's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00343-00068424-00068575": "plenty of studies out there that are you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00344-00068576-00068767": "know that are proving that you can move", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00345-00068768-00068919": "matter and move molecules with just the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00346-00068920-00069071": "power of your thought", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00347-00069072-00069263": "it's no longer um you know it's no", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00348-00069264-00069447": "longer actually not proven", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00349-00069448-00069991": "and it all started with with a moto", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00350-00069992-00070182": "so if you're on here today you probably", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00351-00070183-00070294": "you know we can all we've all probably", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00352-00070295-00070487": "got negative money experiences", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00353-00070488-00070687": "we might have you know you might always", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00354-00070688-00070879": "be feeling like the money's just getting", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00355-00070880-00070999": "sucked out of your business whether it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00356-00071000-00071206": "through expenses whether it's through", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00357-00071207-00071462": "bad clients whether it's through", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00358-00071463-00071615": "you know anything that just seems like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00359-00071616-00071767": "it just is constantly happening over and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00360-00071768-00071911": "over again and then draining your bank", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00361-00071912-00072071": "account", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00362-00072072-00072191": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00363-00072192-00072359": "you know you would might you might find", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00364-00072360-00072535": "that you might have a negative", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00365-00072536-00072711": "association with money as well you might", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00366-00072712-00072871": "depending on sort of what kind of family", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00367-00072872-00073006": "you came from and imprints you've had on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00368-00073007-00073143": "you as a child", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00369-00073144-00073382": "um you know these would be affecting", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00370-00073383-00073655": "your relationship with money right so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00371-00073656-00073879": "you know if you for me as an example i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00372-00073880-00074094": "came from a family where", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00373-00074095-00074215": "we didn't have a lot of money when we've", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00374-00074216-00074487": "grown up we had enough but so for me i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00375-00074488-00074582": "had to work through a lot of those", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00376-00074583-00074767": "negative money associations as i was", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00377-00074768-00074967": "growing up and running business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00378-00074968-00075094": "um so i could break through and actually", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00379-00075095-00075247": "start to attract it in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00380-00075248-00075367": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00381-00075368-00075599": "you know it was sort of built into", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00382-00075600-00075799": "working ridiculous hours and grinding", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00383-00075800-00075943": "away all the time", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00384-00075944-00076167": "um so as i really you know when i had to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00385-00076168-00076367": "shift away from that and decided to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00386-00076368-00076519": "start attracting in money a lot more", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00387-00076520-00076750": "easily easily you know all these this", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00388-00076751-00076838": "sort of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00389-00076839-00077023": "subconscious programming kept coming up", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00390-00077024-00077287": "and that really afford it so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00391-00077288-00077447": "you'll have a if you yeah if you've got", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00392-00077448-00077559": "a lot of those things you can you can", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00393-00077560-00077655": "have a look at what happened in your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00394-00077656-00077838": "childhood and how the money was a lot of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00395-00077839-00077991": "the stuff that's happening in your adult", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00396-00077992-00078143": "life um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00397-00078144-00078326": "will be coming and stemming from what", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00398-00078327-00078494": "was imprinted to you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00399-00078495-00078775": "as a kid", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00400-00078776-00078894": "excuse me", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00401-00078895-00079015": "um so you might have had investment", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00402-00079016-00079231": "failures now you know you might have i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00403-00079232-00079423": "know people that have you know they're", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00404-00079424-00079582": "convinced that they have the kiss of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00405-00079583-00079806": "death when it comes to investments", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00406-00079807-00079982": "whatever they touch ends up going to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00407-00079983-00080206": "some way in some way shape or form", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00408-00080207-00080471": "um and funnily enough it's it's their", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00409-00080472-00080662": "own what they put out into the universe", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00410-00080663-00080799": "that actually attracts them into those", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00411-00080800-00080926": "situations", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00412-00080927-00081191": "um so if this is you then or you find", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00413-00081192-00081350": "that you whenever you invest that you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00414-00081351-00081535": "sort of you already sort of feel like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00415-00081536-00081662": "it's going to fail", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00416-00081663-00081791": "um you don't even know where that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00417-00081792-00081975": "feeling might come from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00418-00081976-00082167": "you know this is going to be another one", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00419-00082168-00082711": "this is going to resonate with you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00420-00082712-00082935": "tax audits so you might be the kind of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00421-00082936-00083087": "person that for whatever reason just", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00422-00083088-00083335": "keeps attracting in those tax audits", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00423-00083336-00083559": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00424-00083560-00083711": "yeah getting bogged down jackie getting", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00425-00083712-00083799": "bogged down in what's going on in the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00426-00083800-00083935": "world and stopping moving forward yeah", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00427-00083936-00084047": "exactly", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00428-00084048-00084303": "daniella yeah so me so yeah look i mean", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00429-00084304-00084526": "again you'll find there's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00430-00084527-00084638": "you just need to look at the language", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00431-00084639-00084855": "and what people their vibe around and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00432-00084856-00085055": "look it's gonna be yourself it takes a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00433-00085056-00085206": "lot of self-reflection and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00434-00085207-00085359": "self-awareness to realize if you're", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00435-00085360-00085591": "actually doing it um it can be quite", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00436-00085592-00085782": "confronting as well if when you stop and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00437-00085783-00086087": "reflect and go hang on i'm actually i'm", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00438-00086088-00086215": "actually attracting all this stuff in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00439-00086216-00086367": "you know the common denominator and all", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00440-00086368-00086494": "of this is me", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00441-00086495-00086662": "um so when you actually have that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00442-00086663-00086838": "awakening and you have that awareness", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00443-00086839-00086982": "that's actually when you can shift", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00444-00086983-00087062": "because", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00445-00087063-00087199": "if you have", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00446-00087200-00087438": "the awakening and you deny it's there", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00447-00087439-00087647": "that's your ego and the the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00448-00087648-00087847": "ego is the worst thing when it comes to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00449-00087848-00088062": "moving forward manifestation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00450-00088063-00088238": "attachment that kind of thing it's yeah", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00451-00088239-00088535": "it can be very confronting", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00452-00088536-00088679": "but again you might be that kind of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00453-00088680-00088918": "person that attracts in tax orders", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00454-00088919-00089062": "you might be that kind of person that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00455-00089063-00089287": "just constantly attracts in things like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00456-00089288-00089479": "speeding fines i mean", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00457-00089480-00089662": "there are things you can do to you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00458-00089663-00089823": "manifestations you can put in place so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00459-00089824-00089943": "that you make sure that you you're never", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00460-00089944-00090047": "going to come or you're not going to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00461-00090048-00090262": "come across a speedy camera", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00462-00090263-00090367": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00463-00090368-00090438": "you know when you're when you're", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00464-00090439-00090606": "traveling i mean i'm sure we've all read", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00465-00090607-00090918": "that story of that person who um i've", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00466-00090919-00091135": "written in an article not long ago about", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00467-00091136-00091350": "that 90 year old guy or whatever 80 year", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00468-00091351-00091543": "old guy who been driving without a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00469-00091544-00091726": "license for like 30 years or whatever 50", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00470-00091727-00091911": "years or something ridiculous but he", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00471-00091912-00092031": "obviously had that belief system that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00472-00092032-00092255": "he'd never get caught he didn't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00473-00092256-00092471": "so it can be the same with things like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00474-00092472-00092647": "speeding fines so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00475-00092648-00092838": "it's easily enough to you know get out", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00476-00092839-00092999": "of speeding fines", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00477-00093000-00093150": "if you know how to clear blockages and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00478-00093151-00093326": "you know how to sort of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00479-00093327-00094231": "shift your awareness around them", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00480-00094232-00094391": "yeah stephen that's a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00481-00094392-00094623": "yeah and that's a great belief system to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00482-00094624-00094918": "have in terms of that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00483-00094919-00095199": "so i guess why should you listen to me", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00484-00095200-00095343": "so i'll give you a bit more about", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00485-00095344-00095582": "background about my journey so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00486-00095583-00095703": "there's a picture of vegas there because", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00487-00095704-00095926": "that's where my journey spiritually", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00488-00095927-00096143": "really started um so go back to sort of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00489-00096144-00096431": "2016 end of 2016 2017", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00490-00096432-00096582": "i was actually when i started training", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00491-00096583-00096823": "warren as a client", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00492-00096824-00097006": "and he was sort of really the gateway to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00493-00097007-00097247": "my spiritual journey so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00494-00097248-00097406": "he started sort of we started with", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00495-00097407-00097559": "clearance i had a couple of issues in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00496-00097560-00097750": "business in terms of wanting to get rid", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00497-00097751-00097943": "of wanting to get rid of a staff member", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00498-00097944-00098079": "that i didn't i didn't want to have in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00499-00098080-00098311": "the business anymore um but because", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00500-00098312-00098606": "they're in contract um i i was going to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00501-00098607-00098782": "be at a financial loss by getting rid of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00502-00098783-00098935": "them early", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00503-00098936-00099159": "and just by putting in the clearing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00504-00099160-00099359": "uh the next day", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00505-00099360-00099535": "that that specific staff member actually", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00506-00099536-00099638": "text me and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00507-00099639-00099782": "wanted to move on or had an offer for", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00508-00099783-00099943": "another another role or", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00509-00099944-00100111": "something along those lines so basically", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00510-00100112-00100391": "after doing the clearing within 24 hours", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00511-00100392-00100615": "the the universe had done its thing and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00512-00100616-00100799": "you know that was where i was like wow", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00513-00100800-00100974": "this is a this is a realm that i haven't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00514-00100975-00101262": "even sort of dove into so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00515-00101263-00101487": "after that i jumped in onto warren's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00516-00101488-00101623": "mastermind and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00517-00101624-00101750": "you know through myself with everything", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00518-00101751-00101974": "you taught me and we ended up in vegas", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00519-00101975-00102215": "and learning more about um remote", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00520-00102216-00102391": "viewing and sort of manifestation from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00521-00102392-00102590": "from a real spiritual teacher over there", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00522-00102591-00102766": "a real master over there", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00523-00102767-00103039": "um and that's kind of where you know my", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00524-00103040-00103223": "life as a pt and business owner has", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00525-00103224-00103423": "transformed so my background's health", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00526-00103424-00103590": "and fitness", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00527-00103591-00103847": "i've always worked with the physical and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00528-00103848-00104078": "this was sort of my journey into into", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00529-00104079-00104263": "the into the fifth dimension if you like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00530-00104264-00104406": "and starting to work with energy and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00531-00104407-00104590": "apply that into clients", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00532-00104591-00104727": "so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00533-00104728-00104847": "my", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00534-00104848-00104966": "you know this is sort of i guess my", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00535-00104967-00105166": "images here of the people", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00536-00105167-00105431": "doing the course in um in vegas", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00537-00105432-00105647": "and through utilizing energy and and the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00538-00105648-00105790": "power of sort of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00539-00105791-00105958": "mastering your mind", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00540-00105959-00106199": "um you know i was able to turn 25 bucks", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00541-00106200-00106447": "of a chip over in the casino one of the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00542-00106448-00106583": "things we learned was how to how to play", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00543-00106583-00106702": "the casino", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00544-00106703-00106895": "you know by reading energy", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00545-00106896-00107095": "uh and on the last day i managed to turn", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00546-00107096-00107478": "a 25 chip into about 750 bucks so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00547-00107479-00107615": "yeah it was a truly transformational", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00548-00107616-00107790": "course and set me on this sort of path", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00549-00107791-00107934": "to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00550-00107935-00108102": "you know helping clients and just once i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00551-00108103-00108239": "saw the world in that light i couldn't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00552-00108240-00108358": "go back to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00553-00108359-00108534": "you know seeing it in the three in the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00554-00108535-00108678": "you know in 3d if you like it it was", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00555-00108679-00108854": "always sort of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00556-00108855-00109102": "it was sort of peripheral to the deeper", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00557-00109103-00109454": "stuff that's going on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00558-00109455-00109551": "so again", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00559-00109552-00109766": "i i really sort of you know a picture of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00560-00109767-00109951": "my family puts my door on the left um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00561-00109952-00110143": "you know i'm just like you and anyone on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00562-00110144-00110302": "this webinar i'm no different", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00563-00110303-00110551": "i sort of discovered how to use energy", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00564-00110552-00110734": "to my advantage and now you know i'm", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00565-00110735-00110910": "able to spend a lot more time and have", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00566-00110911-00111039": "that freedom", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00567-00111040-00111207": "um to be able to spend more time with my", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00568-00111208-00111366": "family and you know i spend most of my", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00569-00111367-00111527": "time at home you know with my daughter", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00570-00111528-00111766": "now so again i'm i'm no different to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00571-00111767-00111878": "either of you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00572-00111879-00112071": "any of you that are on the webinar now", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00573-00112072-00112207": "and it is the exact stuff that i'm going", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00574-00112208-00112383": "to teach you today and then throughout", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00575-00112383-00112519": "the course that if you do decide to do", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00576-00112520-00112599": "it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00577-00112600-00112710": "you know it's going to be able to allow", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00578-00112711-00113086": "you to do the same thing if you want it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00579-00113088-00113239": "so a couple of other little points got a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00580-00113240-00113439": "degree in psychology", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00581-00113440-00113615": "applied muscle testing practitioner so i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00582-00113616-00113775": "used to use kinesiology with clients as", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00583-00113776-00114039": "well so that was my first real exposure", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00584-00114040-00114343": "to um to using energy with clients", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00585-00114344-00114599": "um that was back in 2015.", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00586-00114600-00114758": "so 10 years passed as a pc in the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00587-00114759-00114895": "industry", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00588-00114896-00115031": "and then you know managing gyms and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00589-00115032-00115166": "things like that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00590-00115167-00115334": "and then six plus years in the coaching", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00591-00115335-00115510": "industry teaching people how to master", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00592-00115511-00115734": "their mindset and basically you know run", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00593-00115735-00115902": "their business more effectively and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00594-00115903-00116031": "attract in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00595-00116032-00116278": "more more abundance and money by", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00596-00116279-00116478": "utilizing energy", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00597-00116479-00116647": "uh so i spent thousands on learning i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00598-00116648-00116799": "mean obviously outside of the degree i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00599-00116800-00116958": "mean the degree is very sort of narrow", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00600-00116959-00117119": "in terms of what it teaches", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00601-00117120-00117366": "um but again learning from from masters", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00602-00117367-00117575": "people that are really you know in other", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00603-00117576-00117751": "countries and overseas you know spending", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00604-00117752-00117966": "thousands of dollars on learning how to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00605-00117967-00118183": "you know master manifestation and break", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00606-00118183-00118327": "it down so that i can teach it to people", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00607-00118328-00118678": "in a simplified version as well", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00608-00118679-00118790": "and now i make most of my income", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00609-00118791-00119071": "passively through crypto uh stocks and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00610-00119072-00119271": "even sports betting so you know that was", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00611-00119272-00119390": "one of the biggest things i had to break", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00612-00119391-00119510": "through as well was", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00613-00119511-00119719": "that mass sort of consciousness mindset", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00614-00119720-00119839": "towards that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00615-00119840-00120110": "um and once i could break through that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00616-00120111-00120254": "you know the freedom it's allowed me has", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00617-00120255-00120327": "been", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00618-00120328-00120671": "it's been phenomenal", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00619-00120672-00120790": "and obviously those who are everyone", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00620-00120791-00120910": "who's on the webinar has probably", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00621-00120911-00121071": "probably you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00622-00121072-00121190": "been exposed to warren at some point", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00623-00121191-00121414": "obviously the creator of global wealth", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00624-00121415-00121647": "club creator of the awakening within", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00625-00121648-00121799": "and well safe so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00626-00121800-00122007": "you know warren's background ten plus", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00627-00122008-00122183": "years in the tax office australian tax", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00628-00122183-00122271": "office", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00629-00122272-00122519": "uh 20 plus years of experience in um in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00630-00122520-00122727": "australian offshore tax planning asset", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00631-00122728-00122878": "protection and out of the boxing vex", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00632-00122879-00123023": "investing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00633-00123024-00123158": "uh he's also a qualified lawyer an", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00634-00123159-00123375": "accountant financial advisor", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00635-00123376-00123534": "and obviously he specializes mainly in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00636-00123535-00123654": "investing so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00637-00123655-00123823": "i really have had the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00638-00123824-00124047": "you know the best possible mentor in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00639-00124048-00124334": "terms of learning not just the 3d and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00640-00124335-00124599": "becoming abundant in the 3d but learning", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00641-00124600-00124790": "how to actually attract it in you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00642-00124791-00125023": "from from warren as a spiritual teacher", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00643-00125024-00125166": "that's again that's been where i've got", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00644-00125167-00125263": "the most", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00645-00125264-00125471": "fulfillment and most satisfaction and i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00646-00125472-00125663": "see why i teach it and get so much out", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00647-00125664-00126047": "of teaching it today", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00648-00126048-00126286": "so let's look at manifestation so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00649-00126288-00126431": "you know manifestation it's really the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00650-00126432-00126575": "art of being able to bring", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00651-00126576-00126847": "something into the present", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00652-00126848-00126951": "what you need to know again is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00653-00126952-00127143": "everything is energy time and space is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00654-00127144-00127310": "not linear but quantum so there's no", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00655-00127311-00127454": "such thing in the quantum realm in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00656-00127455-00127758": "quantum physics there's no such thing as", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00657-00127759-00127878": "the past", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00658-00127879-00128110": "and and and the future it's all now it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00659-00128111-00128231": "all present", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00660-00128232-00128399": "um our life is basically one big", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00661-00128400-00128614": "hologram of what we create", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00662-00128615-00128790": "and i'm sure you all heard you know the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00663-00128791-00128983": "elites talking about how they you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00664-00128983-00129151": "ella musk is a big", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00665-00129152-00129263": "advocate for thinking that we actually", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00666-00129264-00129431": "live in a simulation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00667-00129432-00129654": "simulation hologram it's all it's also", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00668-00129655-00129839": "the same thing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00669-00129840-00130031": "so we see what we want to see", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00670-00130032-00130239": "we see what we want to believe", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00671-00130240-00130343": "and are affected by the mass", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00672-00130344-00130471": "consciousness", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00673-00130472-00130639": "so our values are going to dictate what", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00674-00130640-00130847": "we actually see in terms of that whether", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00675-00130848-00131095": "they're conscious or subconscious", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00676-00131096-00131319": "um but your subconscious mind and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00677-00131320-00131543": "and conscious mind actually work as a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00678-00131544-00131790": "team well they should work as a team", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00679-00131791-00131927": "it's like a movie screen and is affected", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00680-00131928-00132102": "by deeper quantum layers of mind", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00681-00132103-00132471": "imprints and other forms of programming", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00682-00132472-00132631": "but your mind's like a radio transmitter", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00683-00132632-00132790": "tuning into the radio stations of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00684-00132791-00133031": "infinite realms of energy", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00685-00133032-00133199": "so obviously how scientists have learned", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00686-00133200-00133359": "to harness energy and and create", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00687-00133360-00133471": "electricity", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00688-00133472-00133711": "um you know radio waves in the internet", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00689-00133712-00133854": "we too can harness energy and bring a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00690-00133855-00134095": "new reality into the physical we just", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00691-00134096-00134263": "have to accept that it's that it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00692-00134264-00134375": "already there even though it's not", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00693-00134376-00134807": "physical", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00694-00134808-00134983": "so we are manifesting every minute every", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00695-00134984-00135071": "hour", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00696-00135072-00135247": "of the day by our thoughts and choices", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00697-00135248-00135366": "whether we want to or not whether", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00698-00135367-00135551": "they're conscious whether they're", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00699-00135552-00135727": "subconscious you know whether we intend", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00700-00135728-00135983": "them or not we are doing it our external", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00701-00135984-00136175": "world at the moment is a current", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00702-00136176-00136366": "reflection of our internal world", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00703-00136367-00136583": "so if your external world is chaotic and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00704-00136584-00136743": "you think you are quite centered and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00705-00136744-00136831": "quite", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00706-00136832-00136935": "calm", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00707-00136936-00137190": "um you know it's it's you're in denial", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00708-00137191-00137343": "it's not how it is so there's obviously", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00709-00137344-00137471": "stuff and layers that you need to get", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00710-00137472-00137551": "through", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00711-00137552-00137807": "um to sort of bring order to that chaos", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00712-00137808-00137911": "outside and it's going to come from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00713-00137912-00137999": "being", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00714-00138000-00138135": "you know internally not externally", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00715-00138136-00138431": "you've got to fix it internally first", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00716-00138432-00138535": "it's said that your presence state of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00717-00138536-00138687": "life is the sum of your last 1000", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00718-00138688-00138878": "thoughts or choices", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00719-00138879-00139087": "also the power of the spoken word uh you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00720-00139088-00139302": "know your mouth speaks your body listens", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00721-00139303-00139454": "and your uh and takes actions", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00722-00139455-00139583": "accordingly", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00723-00139584-00139766": "so words are one of the most powerful", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00724-00139767-00139911": "things when it comes to manifestation as", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00725-00139912-00140063": "well so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00726-00140064-00140199": "one of the things that i implore", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00727-00140200-00140414": "everyone on this webinar to do is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00728-00140415-00140599": "have a have a deep reflection you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00729-00140600-00140743": "if you're not happy about something in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00730-00140744-00140935": "your external world at the moment have a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00731-00140936-00141159": "look at your language and attitudes", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00732-00141160-00141302": "around it you know what do you what do", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00733-00141303-00141431": "you sort of what is your external", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00734-00141432-00141711": "dialogue towards you know whatever it is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00735-00141712-00141902": "that you're not happy with or happy with", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00736-00141903-00142143": "what is your internal dialogue", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00737-00142144-00142319": "these words you need to really pick you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00738-00142320-00142495": "need to always when you're manifesting", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00739-00142496-00142719": "pick high frequency words you never want", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00740-00142720-00143078": "to be speaking in the negative or in low", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00741-00143079-00143343": "frequency is a better word", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00742-00143344-00143478": "your subconscious mind and conscious", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00743-00143479-00143566": "mind", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00744-00143567-00143814": "they work together as a team or should", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00745-00143815-00143966": "but is indeed again like you know it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00746-00143967-00144159": "like a it's like a movie screen which is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00747-00144160-00144359": "affected by deeper layers of mind", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00748-00144360-00144511": "and imprints we want to be able to make", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00749-00144512-00145166": "sure a positive for us", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00750-00145167-00145343": "uh yeah mark so better to speak out loud", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00751-00145344-00145478": "than internally", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00752-00145479-00145639": "yeah look i think", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00753-00145640-00145759": "you know i think there is a power to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00754-00145760-00145926": "speaking out loud and singing out loud", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00755-00145927-00146071": "especially when it comes to things like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00756-00146072-00146287": "reprogramming and affirmations and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00757-00146288-00146390": "things like that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00758-00146391-00146566": "um you know you are effectively with", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00759-00146567-00146702": "affirmations trying to bring you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00760-00146703-00146919": "brainwash yourself into having a new", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00761-00146920-00147078": "default setting of your programming if", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00762-00147079-00147254": "you like and it's just going to come", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00763-00147255-00147390": "down to the individual as whether you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00764-00147391-00147526": "want to say it out loud or whatever you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00765-00147527-00147743": "want to say internally i mean i know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00766-00147744-00147895": "one of one of the techniques you can do", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00767-00147896-00148095": "is say it into the mirror", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00768-00148096-00148335": "um you know that's a great way to to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00769-00148336-00148535": "start reprogramming and start believing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00770-00148536-00148719": "and seeing the person in front of you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00771-00148720-00148878": "manifest better", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00772-00148879-00149375": "which is yourself", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00773-00149376-00149759": "but again we are manifesting 24 7", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00774-00149760-00150254": "every day every single day", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00775-00150255-00150407": "like i said your body your mouth speaks", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00776-00150408-00150631": "and your body listens so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00777-00150632-00150814": "i find all the time i have to be once", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00778-00150815-00151014": "you become really aware of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00779-00151015-00151159": "of this kind of stuff and manifestation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00780-00151160-00151343": "things you can become really attuned to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00781-00151344-00151551": "what people are saying around you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00782-00151552-00151678": "you might find", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00783-00151679-00151807": "uh as you start to raise your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00784-00151808-00151951": "consciousness in terms of understanding", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00785-00151952-00152063": "this", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00786-00152064-00152159": "certain people you're hanging around", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00787-00152160-00152295": "with before", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00788-00152296-00152423": "their frequency is too low because", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00789-00152424-00152623": "you're shifting so you might find people", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00790-00152624-00152799": "that you used to hang around with or", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00791-00152800-00152926": "friends or whatever they become", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00792-00152927-00152981": "unbearable", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00793-00152982-00153111": "[Music]", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00794-00153112-00153319": "um so you want to be making sure too", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00795-00153320-00153478": "because if you're surrounded by that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00796-00153479-00153678": "kind of energy that you're not you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00797-00153679-00153863": "you're being imprinted right other", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00798-00153864-00154063": "people's mouths when they speak your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00799-00154064-00154287": "body listens to as well right so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00800-00154288-00154454": "you really want to limit that kind of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00801-00154455-00154671": "thing that is is um you know going to be", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00802-00154672-00154887": "imprinted onto you subconsciously", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00803-00154888-00155126": "um so for me i i hate listening to the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00804-00155127-00155335": "news i hate watching the news and not to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00805-00155336-00155463": "the point where i just", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00806-00155464-00155599": "yeah i have to be in a different room if", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00807-00155600-00155751": "it's on because", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00808-00155752-00155878": "when i hear it even though i don't want", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00809-00155879-00156039": "it to and even though i think i'm pretty", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00810-00156040-00156151": "you know i've got the wall up but i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00811-00156152-00156359": "think i'm pretty sort of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00812-00156360-00156575": "centered if you like it gets imprinted", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00813-00156576-00156783": "into you subconsciously so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00814-00156784-00156919": "again you always want to be aware of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00815-00156920-00157054": "what's going into your ear whether", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00816-00157055-00157271": "you're consciously hearing it or not", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00817-00157272-00157487": "because your body will take action your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00818-00157488-00157726": "subconscious mind will take it literally", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00819-00157727-00157983": "and it will begin to bring it about into", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00820-00157984-00158175": "your reality for you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00821-00158176-00158423": "your subconscious mind doesn't care", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00822-00158424-00158702": "about positive negative false true", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00823-00158703-00158839": "whatever", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00824-00158840-00158999": "it takes everything literally and we'll", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00825-00159000-00159454": "begin to bring it back for you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00826-00159455-00159951": "just some beliefs for you all to ponder", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00827-00159952-00160223": "so common one which i'm sure most of us", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00828-00160224-00160407": "had growing up you know do you need to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00829-00160408-00160590": "go to school or university what's the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00830-00160591-00160711": "purpose", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00831-00160712-00160911": "is it for fear of security business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00832-00160912-00161063": "credibility", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00833-00161064-00161383": "social status i'll see a massive one", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00834-00161384-00161511": "and what have you told your children", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00835-00161512-00161614": "growing up", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00836-00161615-00161783": "what are the things that you have", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00837-00161784-00161926": "said that you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00838-00161927-00162111": "uh you know didn't even realize were", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00839-00162112-00162239": "things that you're going to say i mean", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00840-00162240-00162526": "that's been for me as a as a new parent", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00841-00162527-00162735": "it's something i've had to really um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00842-00162736-00162878": "it's been a very big personal", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00843-00162879-00163095": "development journey for me as well", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00844-00163096-00163263": "you know in certain certain scenarios me", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00845-00163264-00163414": "wanting to say something or me saying", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00846-00163415-00163535": "something without a big thinking and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00847-00163536-00163807": "just wondering where that come from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00848-00163808-00164007": "so again being aware of those thoughts", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00849-00164008-00164175": "that have been imprinted and often they", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00850-00164176-00164399": "are imprints of your parents at the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00851-00164400-00164599": "exact same time as you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00852-00164600-00164887": "where you were as a child", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00853-00164888-00165071": "what have you told yourself so have you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00854-00165072-00165199": "told yourself that you need to go to uni", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00855-00165200-00165335": "to be successful", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00856-00165336-00165454": "have you told yourself you need a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00857-00165455-00165559": "million dollars in the bank account to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00858-00165560-00165687": "be successful", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00859-00165688-00165878": "these kind of beliefs", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00860-00165879-00165990": "you know what did your parents tell you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00861-00165991-00166151": "about money what do they tell you about", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00862-00166152-00166390": "the government and authority", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00863-00166391-00166551": "like i said my", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00864-00166552-00166766": "my parents", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00865-00166767-00166966": "there was never a lot around so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00866-00166967-00167087": "you know for me growing up that was", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00867-00167088-00167375": "something i had to really break through", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00868-00167376-00167551": "again what do you believe about the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00869-00167552-00167766": "government how do you react when you get", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00870-00167767-00167895": "a notes", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00871-00167896-00168119": "i'm sure most of us after the last", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00872-00168120-00168287": "couple of years have some pretty strong", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00873-00168288-00168478": "views", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00874-00168479-00168687": "and what restrictions do you impose on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00875-00168688-00168807": "yourself", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00876-00168808-00168943": "you know do you restrict yourself in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00877-00168944-00169102": "terms of eating you restrict yourselves", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00878-00169103-00169319": "in terms of going on holiday", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00879-00169320-00169566": "do you go into the shop and go no we", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00880-00169567-00169671": "can't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00881-00169672-00169895": "yeah we shouldn't have that we you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00882-00169896-00170031": "we can't afford it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00883-00170032-00170166": "when in reality you can't it's just a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00884-00170167-00170543": "belief system", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00885-00170544-00170719": "what do you believe around taxes do you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00886-00170720-00170919": "think taxes are good or bad", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00887-00170920-00171087": "you know what about lawsuits speeding", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00888-00171088-00171271": "fines parking fines", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00889-00171272-00171526": "government fines generally", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00890-00171527-00171654": "do you believe investments are going to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00891-00171655-00171887": "work really work out for you do you need", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00892-00171888-00172054": "insurance you know what are the present", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00893-00172055-00172247": "realities for you and your family your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00894-00172248-00172590": "health and the state of kids", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00895-00172591-00172702": "so this is a big one this is a big", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00896-00172703-00172878": "belief for me as well obviously i've", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00897-00172879-00173063": "gone through uni now and gone done a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00898-00173064-00173223": "diploma in nutrition and that kind of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00899-00173224-00173335": "thing so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00900-00173336-00173454": "look i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00901-00173455-00173683": "i can 100 say that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00902-00173684-00173966": "i have come from again a family where", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00903-00173967-00174119": "that is the pathway", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00904-00174120-00174326": "um you know you have to go to uni you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00905-00174327-00174471": "got to get a job in a corporate", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00906-00174472-00174631": "environment you got to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00907-00174632-00174831": "work hard to work 12 hours a day that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00908-00174832-00174983": "kind of that kind of thing that was", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00909-00174984-00175151": "always a sort of a pathway and printed", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00910-00175152-00175375": "into me not not even from um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00911-00175376-00175526": "just parents but from school you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00912-00175527-00175687": "you get going to a private school you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00913-00175688-00175831": "get that drummed into you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00914-00175832-00176119": "it's almost like you view down on or i'm", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00915-00176120-00176351": "subconsciously told to view down on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00916-00176352-00176447": "people that are going to go for things", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00917-00176448-00176654": "like trades and things like that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00918-00176655-00176887": "and we all know now that you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00919-00176888-00177014": "it doesn't matter actually doesn't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00920-00177015-00177199": "matter", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00921-00177200-00177351": "so what is the actual purpose for kids", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00922-00177352-00177647": "going to going to university", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00923-00177648-00177831": "is it a status thing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00924-00177832-00177935": "yeah", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00925-00177936-00178087": "probably yeah is a status thing for the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00926-00178088-00178207": "kid or is it status thing for the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00927-00178208-00178566": "parents", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00928-00178567-00178726": "what have you told your children growing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00929-00178727-00178926": "up so have you told", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00930-00178927-00179047": "have you told you what are the things", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00931-00179048-00179223": "you've been imprinting about", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00932-00179224-00179471": "about money you know do you allow your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00933-00179472-00179647": "kids to go", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00934-00179648-00179807": "you know to be restricted in that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00935-00179808-00179966": "respect you tell your kids you can't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00936-00179967-00180095": "afford stuff", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00937-00180096-00180263": "what are the things that you're", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00938-00180264-00180799": "imprinting on to them", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00939-00180800-00180926": "what have you told yourself you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00940-00180927-00181063": "what have you told yourself about money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00941-00181064-00181263": "or you've told yourself about health", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00942-00181264-00181399": "i know for me in the fitness industry", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00943-00181400-00181654": "when i was a pt i always told myself i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00944-00181655-00181799": "needed to be in ridiculous shape i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00945-00181800-00182063": "needed to bench press 140 kilos they did", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00946-00182064-00182359": "a squat you know 200 kilos for uh to get", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00947-00182360-00182551": "any clients they were beliefs that i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00948-00182552-00182847": "told myself for a good amount of time", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00949-00182848-00183014": "did it bring me more business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00950-00183015-00183207": "maybe a little bit here and there but it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00951-00183208-00183423": "didn't make me feel better about myself", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00952-00183424-00183614": "so again why why do you tell yourself", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00953-00183615-00183743": "the things that you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00954-00183744-00183911": "are telling yourself", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00955-00183912-00184078": "who who has told you to think that way", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00956-00184079-00184263": "where does that come from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00957-00184264-00184431": "one of the most powerful breakthroughs", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00958-00184432-00184711": "i've ever had when i was in business was", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00959-00184712-00185038": "when i was with a previous mentor", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00960-00185039-00185166": "and always had this feeling of not being", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00961-00185167-00185326": "good enough you know i always was", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00962-00185327-00185551": "internally not without me even realizing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00963-00185552-00185671": "it telling myself that i wasn't good", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00964-00185672-00185766": "enough", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00965-00185767-00185919": "so he challenged me to and asked me", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00966-00185920-00186126": "where does that feeling come from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00967-00186127-00186263": "i said don't know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00968-00186264-00186511": "he said oh yeah but what if you did know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00969-00186512-00186654": "well i said i don't know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00970-00186655-00186871": "anyway this went for about five minutes", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00971-00186872-00186999": "and then i finally come to the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00972-00187000-00187119": "conclusion that it was coming from a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00973-00187120-00187254": "parent so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00974-00187255-00187526": "without even realizing i was uh carrying", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00975-00187527-00187743": "this not only through from about my", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00976-00187744-00187983": "teens but all the way through up to you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00977-00187984-00188271": "know about 24 25", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00978-00188272-00188550": "and these you know it was severely it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00979-00188551-00188702": "was like as i was hitting a ceiling in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00980-00188703-00188863": "my business so i could get to a certain", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00981-00188864-00189054": "point i would start to tell myself i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00982-00189055-00189199": "wasn't good enough i didn't deserve it i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00983-00189200-00189431": "didn't belong here get this impostor", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00984-00189432-00189654": "syndrome and then the business started", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00985-00189655-00189775": "to you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00986-00189776-00189902": "start to crumble around me because", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00987-00189903-00190087": "that's was the what i was putting out to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00988-00190088-00190254": "the universe right", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00989-00190255-00190431": "so these things can really", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00990-00190432-00190614": "hold you back and that will always pull", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00991-00190615-00190807": "you back to that default setting if you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00992-00190808-00190887": "like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00993-00190888-00191014": "which is why we want to shift it through", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00994-00191015-00191343": "manifestation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00995-00191344-00191559": "again so what did your parents teach you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00996-00191560-00191711": "about government they tell you the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00997-00191712-00191807": "government", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00998-00191808-00192087": "you know good people", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-00999-00192088-00192335": "this society", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01000-00192336-00192566": "what do you believe about the government", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01001-00192567-00192719": "do you believe the government are doing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01002-00192720-00192966": "everything in your best interests", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01003-00192967-00193143": "do you believe the government are out to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01004-00193144-00193295": "get you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01005-00193296-00193663": "uh i mean i'm sure we all have some very", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01006-00193664-00193838": "very strong yeah yeah", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01007-00193839-00194007": "uh strong views around this i mean it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01008-00194008-00194150": "been a very interesting", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01009-00194151-00194350": "um very interesting couple of years it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01010-00194351-00194583": "brought a lot of stuff to light", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01011-00194584-00194695": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01012-00194696-00194847": "and i feel like now like society is the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01013-00194848-00194926": "point where you can't even have a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01014-00194927-00195047": "conversation with people about this", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01015-00195048-00195254": "because they get so fired up about it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01016-00195255-00195359": "so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01017-00195360-00195519": "yeah this is a big one especially if", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01018-00195520-00195959": "you're in business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01019-00195960-00196102": "again what restrictions do you place on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01020-00196103-00196287": "yourself do you tell yourself you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01021-00196288-00196495": "shouldn't spend money on stuff", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01022-00196496-00196614": "anytime you find yourself telling", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01023-00196615-00196799": "yourself that you shouldn't or we", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01024-00196800-00196911": "shouldn't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01025-00196912-00197095": "should is always a projection of someone", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01026-00197096-00197295": "else's value onto you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01027-00197296-00197438": "and you need to ask yourself where that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01028-00197439-00197750": "is coming from but again you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01029-00197751-00197878": "should you only get should we only go on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01030-00197879-00198095": "one holiday should we go on two holidays", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01031-00198096-00198247": "no i shouldn't really have that car", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01032-00198248-00198350": "because it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01033-00198351-00198583": "you know xyz i shouldn't spend that kind", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01034-00198584-00198702": "of money on myself because i could be", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01035-00198703-00198854": "spending on my kids", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01036-00198855-00199390": "that kind of restriction", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01037-00199391-00199575": "what do you believe about money now if", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01038-00199576-00199702": "you're on this webinar today to be able", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01039-00199703-00199975": "to actually attract in more money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01040-00199976-00200166": "you want to have business flow to you a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01041-00200167-00200335": "lot more effectively and not feel like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01042-00200336-00200511": "you're spinning the wheel so much", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01043-00200512-00200695": "then i would really have a reflection", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01044-00200696-00200887": "around what your belief system is around", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01045-00200888-00201047": "money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01046-00201048-00201190": "what do you what do you feel when you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01047-00201191-00201399": "hear the word money you know a lot of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01048-00201400-00201526": "the time if you have a bad relationship", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01049-00201527-00201671": "with money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01050-00201672-00201775": "you will", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01051-00201776-00201943": "you're internally around the stomach", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01052-00201944-00202190": "area i feel like it's screwing up", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01053-00202191-00202375": "you feel like your body's shutting down", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01054-00202376-00202511": "and that is just a physiological", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01055-00202512-00202695": "response to the belief systems that have", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01056-00202696-00202887": "been imprinted into you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01057-00202888-00203119": "um what do you when you see someone with", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01058-00203120-00203375": "money how do you feel you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01059-00203376-00203526": "if you see someone with a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01060-00203527-00203678": "lamborghini driving down the street how", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01061-00203679-00203878": "does that make you feel", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01062-00203879-00204071": "that will explain to you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01063-00204072-00204223": "there'll be a good explanation just out", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01064-00204224-00204399": "to your relationship with money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01065-00204400-00204535": "a lot of people when they see that going", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01066-00204536-00204775": "down the street their immediate reaction", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01067-00204776-00204919": "is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01068-00204919-00205119": "you know you basically", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01069-00205119-00205271": "i mean i know i was one of them", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01070-00205271-00205510": "back back you know early days i used to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01071-00205511-00205614": "get super jealous and i used to get", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01072-00205615-00205751": "super envious", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01073-00205752-00205951": "so where does that come from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01074-00205952-00206198": "looking back with reflection childhood", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01075-00206200-00206327": "things like that i know exactly where it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01076-00206328-00206471": "comes from now", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01077-00206471-00206582": "so again", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01078-00206583-00206734": "when you figure out why you feel a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01079-00206735-00206910": "certain way with money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01080-00206911-00207006": "if it's going to work for you if it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01081-00207007-00207175": "works against you you're going to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01082-00207176-00207286": "attract", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01083-00207287-00207766": "you know either abundance in it or lack", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01084-00207767-00207942": "do you feel like you have enough money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01085-00207944-00208423": "having enough comes from a place of lack", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01086-00208423-00208646": "yeah lily election coming up", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01087-00208648-00208862": "big election on you know the next few", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01088-00208863-00209071": "days", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01089-00209071-00209271": "even more important to learn this", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01090-00209271-00209494": "in times now because", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01091-00209496-00209631": "you know my belief system is that i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01092-00209632-00209806": "don't think it was going to get better i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01093-00209807-00209998": "actually think it's going to get worse", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01094-00210000-00210127": "so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01095-00210128-00210319": "having the tools to be able to attract", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01096-00210319-00210487": "in and become more sovereign", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01097-00210488-00210679": "uh become less reliant on the government", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01098-00210680-00210846": "is going to be even more valuable for", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01099-00210848-00211055": "you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01100-00211056-00211215": "and so what is your present reality how", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01101-00211216-00211527": "far off your present reality um you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01102-00211528-00211775": "is your desired reality", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01103-00211776-00211982": "for your family you know you're living", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01104-00211983-00212158": "the life you want are you giving your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01105-00212159-00212382": "family the life they want", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01106-00212383-00212494": "what are you doing for yourself are you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01107-00212496-00212615": "restricting yourself in terms of the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01108-00212616-00212758": "things you do", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01109-00212759-00212882": "are you in good", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01110-00212883-00213110": "health never has there been a better", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01111-00213111-00213598": "time to become to be in good health", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01112-00213600-00213719": "so let's talk a bit more about the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01113-00213719-00213958": "science behind manifestation so i'm", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01114-00213959-00214087": "going to keep it nice and simple it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01115-00214088-00214239": "only going to cover four slides if", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01116-00214240-00214431": "you've got any questions let me know but", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01117-00214432-00214542": "it is something we go into a little bit", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01118-00214544-00214694": "more detail on it it can get pretty", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01119-00214696-00214903": "complicated if you if you let it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01120-00214904-00215103": "but i'm going to keep it simple so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01121-00215104-00215294": "again we chatted on number one the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01122-00215296-00215542": "universe is a giant hologram", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01123-00215544-00215679": "standard theory is the brain fail to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01124-00215680-00215975": "explain neurophysiological puzzles right", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01125-00215976-00216063": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01126-00216064-00216310": "you know the size of the memory you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01127-00216311-00216527": "remembering faces and and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01128-00216528-00216663": "you know from a long time ago things", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01129-00216664-00216831": "like that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01130-00216832-00216927": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01131-00216928-00217127": "scientists like karl proven niels bohr", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01132-00217128-00217246": "david bowm", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01133-00217248-00217479": "max planck joe dispenza", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01134-00217480-00217719": "a very popular guy they they are all at", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01135-00217719-00217846": "big advocates and talk about they're", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01136-00217848-00218206": "called the quantum or esoteric realm", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01137-00218207-00218358": "physicists realize that the holographic", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01138-00218359-00218551": "science and quantum physics explains", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01139-00218552-00218734": "many mysteries like recognizing a face", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01140-00218735-00218894": "not same for use", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01141-00218896-00219039": "how a person with one arm has a second", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01142-00219040-00219198": "arm working better", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01143-00219200-00219367": "cutting out parts of the brain and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01144-00219367-00219631": "functions that reappear in other parts", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01145-00219632-00219823": "things like phantom limb where if a limb", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01146-00219823-00220039": "is cut off you can still feel it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01147-00220040-00220246": "these things can only be explained", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01148-00220248-00220551": "through the holographic theory", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01149-00220552-00220727": "it's writing as cat which i'm sure many", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01150-00220728-00220903": "of you are familiar with that experiment", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01151-00220904-00221134": "which is a scientific experiment about", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01152-00221135-00221319": "awareness and consciousness and where a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01153-00221319-00221510": "cat was put into a box", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01154-00221511-00221646": "and something was put in you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01155-00221648-00221806": "something that was put in there that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01156-00221807-00222039": "basically could kill the cat", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01157-00222040-00222239": "and when the box was sealed up you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01158-00222240-00222391": "the argument was that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01159-00222392-00222558": "you don't know if the cat's dead or", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01160-00222559-00222831": "alive until you open the box so in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01161-00222832-00222991": "theory it's actually dead and alive at", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01162-00222992-00223191": "the same time so that was a big", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01163-00223192-00223382": "consciousness shift", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01164-00223383-00223591": "experiment that was done", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01165-00223592-00224479": "for quantum physics", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01166-00224480-00224703": "yep so diane want to be more sovereign", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01167-00224704-00224879": "yeah so i'm assuming just stop why in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01168-00224880-00225031": "the chat if that is something that you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01169-00225032-00225191": "are after with learning something like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01170-00225192-00225327": "this i mean", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01171-00225328-00225519": "being more sovereign yeah mark", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01172-00225519-00225639": "definitely yeah", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01173-00225640-00225815": "it's jackie", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01174-00225816-00226055": "it's it's one of those things where", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01175-00226056-00226223": "i don't know up until two years ago it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01176-00226223-00226398": "was kind of like yeah yeah everyone", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01177-00226400-00226591": "would work towards it and the last two", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01178-00226592-00226871": "years everyone's gone holy like i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01179-00226871-00227031": "am not sovereign at all you know like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01180-00227032-00227342": "it's i don't have the tools right like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01181-00227344-00227639": "and it's it's crazy how much how quickly", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01182-00227640-00227863": "it becomes valued when those those kind", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01183-00227864-00228015": "of friends start getting taken away from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01184-00228016-00228103": "you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01185-00228104-00228215": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01186-00228216-00228351": "but yeah never is there a better time to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01187-00228352-00228494": "master this", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01188-00228496-00228679": "so number two every part of the brain is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01189-00228680-00228894": "contained in the hull so as an example", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01190-00228896-00229046": "proven discovered every small fragment", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01191-00229048-00229246": "of a piece of holographic film uh", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01192-00229248-00229406": "contains all the information recorded in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01193-00229407-00229519": "the hull", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01194-00229519-00229631": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01195-00229632-00229831": "so in other words yeah if you cut a sort", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01196-00229832-00229942": "of going to the bottom point if you cut", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01197-00229944-00230087": "a holographic film with an apple on it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01198-00230088-00230375": "in half each half will still contain", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01199-00230376-00230646": "information about the whole image", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01200-00230648-00230846": "um but he concluded basically that the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01201-00230848-00230967": "brain worked the same in terms of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01202-00230967-00231167": "holographic film", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01203-00231167-00231327": "concluded memories are not localized at", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01204-00231328-00231463": "specific brain states but were", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01205-00231464-00231582": "distributed throughout the brain as a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01206-00231583-00231710": "whole", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01207-00231711-00231871": "and concluded only holographic theory", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01208-00231871-00232046": "could explain it so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01209-00232048-00232206": "a hologram is basically created when a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01210-00232207-00232398": "single laser light is split", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01211-00232400-00232558": "into two beams", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01212-00232559-00232687": "with the second beam colliding with the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01213-00232688-00232863": "first as it bounced off bounces off the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01214-00232864-00233079": "image to be photographed uh and then", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01215-00233080-00233215": "creating an interference pattern which", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01216-00233216-00233423": "is recorded on film that's basically how", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01217-00233423-00233591": "a hologram is created", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01218-00233592-00233791": "so being someone that's come through uni", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01219-00233792-00233991": "and done a psychology degree you know it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01220-00233992-00234198": "was it's pretty groundbreaking to learn", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01221-00234200-00234287": "this", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01222-00234288-00234367": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01223-00234367-00234558": "you know that memories were not", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01224-00234559-00234703": "not localized at certain parts of the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01225-00234704-00234863": "brain because that's what you taught", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01226-00234864-00234942": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01227-00234944-00235110": "you know it just feels like yeah it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01228-00235111-00235319": "makes a lot more sense", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01229-00235319-00235734": "holographic theory", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01230-00235735-00235863": "so number three now this is an important", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01231-00235864-00236142": "one matter precedes consciousness so it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01232-00236144-00236375": "was always thought by science it was the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01233-00236376-00236703": "other way around", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01234-00236704-00236894": "yeah that consciousness proceeds uh", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01235-00236896-00237046": "proceeds matter so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01236-00237048-00237191": "you know people argued if holographic", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01237-00237192-00237431": "holographic was true coffee cups trees", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01238-00237432-00237639": "tables lamps might not exist or even", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01239-00237640-00237775": "exist in the way we believe them to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01240-00237776-00238015": "exist it's all an illusion", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01241-00238016-00238239": "um and you know that is the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01242-00238240-00238510": "matter perceives consciousness", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01243-00238511-00238742": "so prevailing science feared uh", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01244-00238744-00238927": "holographic theory so paul pierce from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01245-00238928-00239158": "indiana university um he was basically", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01246-00239159-00239406": "heard of this theory from primum and he", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01247-00239407-00239575": "was just determined to prove it wrong", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01248-00239576-00239734": "much like most scientists are when they", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01249-00239735-00239846": "hear a theory they want to prove it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01250-00239848-00240110": "wrong", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01251-00240111-00240255": "so what he did is he used salamanders", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01252-00240256-00240423": "and removed parts of the brain to remove", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01253-00240423-00240591": "the whole brain sorry and put it back in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01254-00240592-00240775": "soon after", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01255-00240776-00240951": "so the theory was if the salamanders", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01256-00240952-00241110": "feeding behavior was localized in the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01257-00241111-00241294": "brain that the position of the brain in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01258-00241296-00241534": "the head was critical", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01259-00241535-00241646": "uh it didn't matter where it was", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01260-00241648-00241806": "positioned if it didn't matter where it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01261-00241807-00241958": "was positioned this would prove that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01262-00241959-00242191": "holographic theory was true", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01263-00242192-00242367": "so basically what would happen is that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01264-00242367-00242527": "they'd go into a stupa but once the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01265-00242528-00242734": "brain was put back in the behavior would", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01266-00242735-00242894": "return to normal", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01267-00242896-00243167": "i even put the brain in upside down", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01268-00243167-00243342": "back to front so the wrong way around", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01269-00243344-00243630": "but again it fed fed normally", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01270-00243631-00243871": "you did 700 operations like this", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01271-00243871-00244110": "but each result was exactly the same", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01272-00244111-00244423": "so this actually turned ph into a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01273-00244423-00245055": "ardent supporter of private series", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01274-00245056-00245239": "so number four", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01275-00245240-00245575": "particles can become waves so electrons", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01276-00245576-00245855": "light radio waves x-rays can manifest as", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01277-00245856-00246063": "either a particle or wave", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01278-00246064-00246151": "for example when you're shooting", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01279-00246152-00246398": "electron at a tv screen turned off a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01280-00246400-00246630": "tiny point of light appears or it can", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01281-00246631-00246975": "dissolve into energy and become a wave", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01282-00246976-00247151": "it can change from waves to particles", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01283-00247152-00247406": "and back again basically", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01284-00247407-00247575": "so this means you can't classify solely", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01285-00247576-00247782": "as waves or particles but they are", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01286-00247783-00247967": "called quanta both are called quanta and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01287-00247967-00248110": "this is basically where the whole of the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01288-00248111-00248439": "universe is made", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01289-00248440-00248775": "but it is how jesus turned war into one", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01290-00248776-00248975": "and how the yogis in india", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01291-00248976-00249182": "like sri baba created miracles now a lot", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01292-00249183-00249639": "of you know still creating miracles", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01293-00249640-00249863": "the conclusion with all of this is that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01294-00249864-00250063": "quanta only ever manifests as particles", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01295-00250064-00250239": "when we are looking at it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01296-00250240-00250439": "in other words they don't exist until we", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01297-00250440-00250582": "focus on them", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01298-00250583-00250679": "so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01299-00250680-00250846": "whatever's behind me right now that is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01300-00250848-00251110": "behind you right now that is currently", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01301-00251111-00251263": "oscillating in a wave until it's looked", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01302-00251264-00251463": "at", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01303-00251464-00251703": "which means again that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01304-00251704-00251863": "because it doesn't exist until we look", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01305-00251864-00252134": "at them we have the ability to to change", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01306-00252135-00252671": "to to manifest it quicker", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01307-00252671-00252823": "so in the book the holographic universe", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01308-00252823-00252982": "so for those who are looking at doing a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01309-00252983-00253103": "bit more", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01310-00253104-00253358": "study into the science around it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01311-00253359-00253542": "this is a brilliant book about you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01312-00253544-00253679": "all the examples of where this theory", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01313-00253680-00253871": "came from and how it actually has has", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01314-00253871-00254151": "filtered out into modern science", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01315-00254152-00254382": "um but michael talbot who wrote the book", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01316-00254383-00254494": "he looked at the issue about daily", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01317-00254496-00254679": "reality and what we manifest in our", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01318-00254680-00254871": "day-to-day lives", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01319-00254871-00255055": "he concluded that we create our own", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01320-00255056-00255175": "reality", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01321-00255176-00255439": "that the placebo effect is real", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01322-00255440-00255598": "so again the subconscious mind doesn't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01323-00255600-00255791": "know what's what's sort of real or true", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01324-00255792-00255951": "or untrue if you like it just takes you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01325-00255952-00256175": "literally", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01326-00256176-00256342": "number three the power of a faith healer", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01327-00256344-00256510": "or consciousness teacher to help you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01328-00256511-00256710": "experience a miracle in other words if", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01329-00256711-00256919": "you want to manifest things faster it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01330-00256919-00257063": "always better to have and you always do", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01331-00257064-00257198": "it a lot faster when you have a mentor", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01332-00257200-00257471": "or a teacher", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01333-00257471-00257623": "number four we have the full power to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01334-00257623-00257767": "alter our reality by our thoughts and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01335-00257767-00257958": "how we perceive things", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01336-00257959-00258175": "um he gave a couple of extraordinary", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01337-00258176-00258510": "examples", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01338-00258511-00258798": "uh yep", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01339-00258800-00258958": "so i'm just going to make", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01340-00258959-00259934": "a tone hose", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01341-00259935-00260158": "so one of the main examples that he had", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01342-00260159-00260294": "was a man who", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01343-00260296-00260494": "healed his brain tumor and basically", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01344-00260496-00260671": "brought it back again", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01345-00260671-00260751": "so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01346-00260752-00260910": "basically through his own belief so he", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01347-00260911-00261015": "went in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01348-00261016-00261182": "went into the doctor he had a brain", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01349-00261183-00261463": "tumor uh and the doctor gave him him a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01350-00261464-00261671": "new drug which fixed him", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01351-00261671-00261830": "got rid of the tumor", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01352-00261831-00262055": "um and he did his own reading about how", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01353-00262056-00262247": "the drug hadn't hadn't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01354-00262248-00262367": "you know had basically filed all the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01355-00262368-00262527": "trials and didn't work", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01356-00262528-00262703": "uh and through that belief", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01357-00262704-00262895": "brought the trooper back", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01358-00262896-00263079": "he actually went back in after that and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01359-00263080-00263182": "and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01360-00263183-00263263": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01361-00263264-00263430": "the doctor was like oh you know found", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01362-00263431-00263671": "that he had the chip the tumor came back", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01363-00263672-00263855": "and what the doctor did is he injected", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01364-00263856-00264047": "him with with water", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01365-00264048-00264199": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01366-00264200-00264351": "went away told him it was told him it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01367-00264352-00264495": "was a new drug", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01368-00264496-00264743": "so he went away um and tumor healed", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01369-00264744-00264895": "itself again", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01370-00264896-00264982": "but", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01371-00264983-00265110": "this guy", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01372-00265111-00265343": "again started reading started learning", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01373-00265344-00265710": "that you know he basically been tricked", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01374-00265711-00265903": "uh and he ended up dying so his belief", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01375-00265904-00266175": "system brought his tumor back", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01376-00266176-00266310": "even though he had didn't even have a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01377-00266311-00266463": "drug that was that could heal it his", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01378-00266464-00266599": "belief healed it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01379-00266600-00266695": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01380-00266696-00267134": "and yet he ended up dying", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01381-00267135-00267319": "the other main example that he had in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01382-00267320-00267519": "the book that he talks about is is the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01383-00267520-00267775": "the group who mentally practice piano", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01384-00267776-00267855": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01385-00267856-00268039": "in in a specific study something around", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01386-00268040-00268206": "six to eight weeks it was", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01387-00268207-00268391": "um got the same results as those who", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01388-00268392-00268582": "practiced physically", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01389-00268583-00268671": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01390-00268672-00268823": "so again it was around six to eight", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01391-00268824-00268975": "weeks they did it 30 minutes a day", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01392-00268976-00269127": "excuse me", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01393-00269128-00269271": "and they oh and they got the same they", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01394-00269272-00269503": "were as sort of their motor skills were", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01395-00269504-00269671": "basically all their proficiency in the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01396-00269672-00269951": "music that they were learning was was", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01397-00269952-00270151": "you know as a group pretty similar at", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01398-00270152-00270655": "the end or identical at the end", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01399-00270656-00270830": "so some of the scientific conclusions", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01400-00270831-00270951": "that we can have", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01401-00270952-00271119": "from this theory", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01402-00271120-00271287": "again", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01403-00271288-00271415": "traditional physics is no longer", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01404-00271416-00271630": "relevant so so if you're unaware of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01405-00271631-00271815": "quantum theory and you have all these", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01406-00271816-00271927": "other theories that are you know a lot", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01407-00271928-00272143": "of the a lot of theories that einstein", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01408-00272144-00272295": "proposed back in the day", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01409-00272296-00272471": "um they're no longer relevant especially", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01410-00272472-00272806": "the ones that come to time and space", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01411-00272807-00273015": "um the one thing he was sort of bang on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01412-00273016-00273206": "with was quantum entanglement how two", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01413-00273207-00273455": "things can be connected at a distance", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01414-00273456-00273719": "that is obviously very true which ties", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01415-00273720-00273830": "into our", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01416-00273831-00273999": "second point", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01417-00274000-00274191": "is that all things are interconnected", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01418-00274192-00274295": "you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01419-00274296-00274399": "me i mean the reason you're on this", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01420-00274400-00274703": "webinar today as you were attracted here", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01421-00274704-00274943": "uh we are all connected uh we can feel", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01422-00274944-00275158": "things so this is this explains how you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01423-00275159-00275319": "know twins can feel each other when", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01424-00275320-00275534": "they're at a distance that kind of thing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01425-00275535-00275830": "we can it can explain how we can sort of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01426-00275831-00275982": "you know someone you can feel text", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01427-00275983-00276158": "messages or the thought of someone pops", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01428-00276159-00276343": "into our head and then a minute later", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01429-00276344-00276463": "they pop up on your phone and you've got", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01430-00276464-00276591": "a message from them", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01431-00276592-00276743": "this is these are just some everyday", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01432-00276744-00276934": "examples of how we are all in connect", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01433-00276935-00277087": "interconnected throughout through our", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01434-00277088-00277191": "thoughts", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01435-00277192-00277599": "through the universe", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01436-00277600-00277710": "so this is the big one and this is a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01437-00277711-00278006": "massive with with uh with manifestation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01438-00278007-00278199": "is that linear space and time don't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01439-00278200-00278375": "exist so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01440-00278376-00278519": "no such thing as the past there's no", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01441-00278520-00278679": "such thing as the future", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01442-00278680-00278879": "it's all now so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01443-00278880-00279063": "again when your subconscious mind takes", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01444-00279064-00279230": "you literally and you're imprinting it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01445-00279231-00279343": "now", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01446-00279344-00279487": "that's when you begin to really become", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01447-00279488-00279655": "powerful manifesting and can have things", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01448-00279656-00279863": "like instant manifestation start to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01449-00279864-00280343": "happen in your life", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01450-00280344-00280558": "number four things in objects are not", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01451-00280559-00280703": "localized", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01452-00280704-00280830": "they're spread across as one big", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01453-00280831-00281110": "hologram", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01454-00281111-00281295": "again the the memories of the brain", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01455-00281296-00281455": "that's the the main example with that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01456-00281456-00281695": "one", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01457-00281696-00281919": "at number five nothing exists until it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01458-00281920-00282415": "is observed", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01459-00282416-00282606": "so if the science is correct", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01460-00282607-00282734": "you can do all the right things have the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01461-00282735-00283030": "right structures best advisors you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01462-00283031-00283263": "done your diligence on investment", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01463-00283264-00283455": "got a perfect winning trading system or", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01464-00283456-00283671": "business mode yet you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01465-00283672-00283855": "you still are going to attract you still", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01466-00283856-00284079": "can attract bad investment losses tax", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01467-00284080-00284358": "audits regular regulatory problems", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01468-00284359-00284519": "or serious losses which don't make sense", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01469-00284520-00285095": "because of your holographic beliefs", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01470-00285096-00285271": "as we've seen scientists have discovered", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01471-00285272-00285510": "everything is a hologram a mire illusion", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01472-00285511-00285703": "meaning your investment results business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01473-00285704-00285934": "outcomes tax you pay links to the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01474-00285935-00286199": "beliefs or your subconscious mind um or", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01475-00286200-00286343": "the collective consciousness of the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01476-00286344-00286503": "masses", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01477-00286504-00286710": "it's one of the biggest things that um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01478-00286711-00286879": "you know lawrence taught about as well", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01479-00286880-00286975": "is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01480-00286976-00287103": "you know governments are a reflection of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01481-00287104-00287279": "the mass consciousness of the people", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01482-00287280-00287415": "right so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01483-00287416-00287599": "um you know this is a i probably had a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01484-00287600-00287734": "bit of a sort of transformation moment", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01485-00287735-00287958": "when i when i thought of that because", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01486-00287959-00288063": "you only need to look around and see", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01487-00288064-00288263": "what people are saying i was surrounded", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01488-00288264-00288591": "by it that's a manifestation of of the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01489-00288592-00288815": "thoughts of people of the masses if you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01490-00288816-00288999": "like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01491-00289000-00289143": "so unless you're actively combating the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01492-00289144-00289358": "mass mind with clearings manifestation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01493-00289359-00289543": "protocols you're going to get collective", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01494-00289544-00289703": "manifestations around investments", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01495-00289704-00289967": "business tax etc", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01496-00289968-00290158": "also the frequency of your country as", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01497-00290159-00290399": "well yes city uh you know if you're", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01498-00290400-00290575": "stuck in a country that is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01499-00290576-00290806": "it's just you know you can feel it um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01500-00290807-00290934": "you can feel it's a low frequency", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01501-00290935-00291143": "country and the things that are going on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01502-00291144-00291303": "um you know it's even more important to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01503-00291304-00291567": "be able to clear and manifest things", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01504-00291568-00291719": "consciously", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01505-00291720-00292206": "so you can repel it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01506-00292207-00292471": "so your beliefs decide your reality you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01507-00292472-00292599": "can be a master at something but if you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01508-00292600-00292767": "have energetic blocks and imprints", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01509-00292768-00292975": "subconscious spheres and again aren't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01510-00292976-00293127": "combating the mass mind with", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01511-00293128-00293327": "manifestation and clearings it doesn't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01512-00293328-00293503": "matter what you do", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01513-00293504-00293663": "you're going to keep attracting back the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01514-00293664-00293743": "same", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01515-00293744-00293967": "hologram to you and the mastermind set", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01516-00293968-00294191": "in place for yourself um it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01517-00294192-00294358": "effectively like an elastic band that's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01518-00294359-00294551": "going to keep pulling you back to your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01519-00294552-00295006": "default setting if you like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01520-00295007-00295223": "again it's like gravity so law of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01521-00295224-00295454": "attraction frequency energy that kind of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01522-00295455-00295615": "thing doesn't doesn't care it doesn't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01523-00295616-00295767": "care about you know what's fair or", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01524-00295768-00295903": "what's unfair", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01525-00295904-00296023": "that's just how it is it's how the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01526-00296024-00296430": "universe works", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01527-00296431-00296503": "so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01528-00296504-00296910": "how do we shift our reality", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01529-00296911-00297071": "well it's pretty simple we're having a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01530-00297072-00297223": "structured manifestation protocol to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01531-00297224-00297406": "take control of the movie of your life", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01532-00297407-00297758": "that's currently playing out in the 3d", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01533-00297759-00297982": "our thoughts can become easily scattered", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01534-00297983-00298134": "and distract distracted by our belief", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01535-00298135-00298327": "systems and the everywhere energy of the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01536-00298328-00298567": "mass mind and i know personally if i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01537-00298568-00298727": "don't but i journal if i don't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01538-00298728-00298999": "constantly manifest if i skip a day all", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01539-00299000-00299175": "these kind of things like that they pull", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01540-00299176-00299319": "me out and i find them just getting", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01541-00299320-00299471": "sucked into those", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01542-00299472-00299639": "it's like a vortex of negativity a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01543-00299640-00299847": "vortex of rubbish you know like it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01544-00299848-00300047": "like a black hole of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01545-00300048-00300254": "of negative energy like it's it's very", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01546-00300255-00300423": "easy for it to to happen if you're not", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01547-00300424-00300543": "centering yourself and you're not you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01548-00300544-00300815": "know constantly manifesting and clearing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01549-00300816-00301015": "yourself of this energy", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01550-00301016-00301151": "but the good news is a structured", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01551-00301152-00301567": "protocol will bypass this", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01552-00301568-00301751": "so we use a highly structured seven-step", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01553-00301752-00301919": "protocol", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01554-00301920-00302063": "which helps us to take control of all of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01555-00302064-00302423": "our all of our manifestations", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01556-00302424-00302630": "so this is our seven step manifestation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01557-00302631-00302791": "protocol so if we write notes and be", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01558-00302792-00302982": "able to do it straight away this is the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01559-00302983-00303199": "slide to do it on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01560-00303200-00303295": "so first thing you want to do you want", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01561-00303296-00303463": "to get clear you want to create and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01562-00303464-00303663": "formulate your intention tension is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01563-00303664-00303830": "everything", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01564-00303831-00304015": "once you've got clear on what it is that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01565-00304016-00304182": "you want you know it might be something", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01566-00304183-00304319": "like you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01567-00304320-00304495": "i want to be generating", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01568-00304496-00304654": "10 000", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01569-00304655-00304887": "extra a month in my business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01570-00304888-00305030": "you might want to be you might want to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01571-00305031-00305158": "manifest your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01572-00305159-00305310": "life partner", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01573-00305311-00305447": "you've got to get clear and by writing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01574-00305448-00305767": "it on paper that makes it clear", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01575-00305768-00305887": "number two is you want to get into a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01576-00305888-00306087": "brain state that is conducive to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01577-00306088-00306230": "manifestation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01578-00306231-00306558": "to a manifestation acula act actualizing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01579-00306559-00306751": "this is where meditation comes in it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01580-00306752-00306903": "becomes very important in terms of how", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01581-00306904-00307182": "quickly you can manifest things", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01582-00307183-00307343": "so number three command the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01583-00307344-00307558": "manifestation so we use that using", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01584-00307559-00307806": "ancient codes as well which are gonna", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01585-00307807-00308079": "which is what we're gonna teach you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01586-00308080-00308279": "number four clear the blockages to that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01587-00308280-00308447": "uh to that manifestation which is done", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01588-00308448-00308623": "in the same way", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01589-00308624-00308839": "so again using clearing using codes", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01590-00308840-00308951": "consider anything needing to be", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01591-00308952-00309095": "addressed", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01592-00309096-00309319": "number five take instant action actions", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01593-00309320-00309495": "is one of the most important things or", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01594-00309496-00309710": "if not the most important thing when it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01595-00309711-00309943": "comes to you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01596-00309944-00310110": "manifestations coming back quicker and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01597-00310111-00310447": "it's often the part that's overlooked", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01598-00310448-00310630": "let go on that god so again you've got", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01599-00310631-00310910": "to detach from the outcome forget about", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01600-00310911-00311215": "it attachment will kill any chance of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01601-00311216-00311406": "the manifestation actually be coming", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01602-00311407-00311647": "into your reality", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01603-00311648-00311863": "uh number seven watching for clues in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01604-00311864-00312071": "the external environment so this is why", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01605-00312072-00312206": "it's very important to have a journal", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01606-00312207-00312406": "it's very important to be attuned into", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01607-00312407-00312575": "what's going on in your external", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01608-00312576-00312703": "environment", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01609-00312704-00312823": "things like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01610-00312824-00313006": "you know if you let's say you put a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01611-00313007-00313206": "manifestation of the money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01612-00313207-00313423": "and like like for me the next day", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01613-00313424-00313495": "you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01614-00313496-00313710": "i wanted to get in i wanted to remove a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01615-00313711-00313951": "staff member so the external", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01616-00313952-00314087": "clue", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01617-00314088-00314247": "was her resignation the next day or her", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01618-00314248-00314406": "telling me she'd had a better", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01619-00314407-00314647": "opportunity", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01620-00314648-00314839": "so again you've got to be really in tune", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01621-00314840-00314927": "and be", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01622-00314928-00315071": "shift your awareness and consciousness", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01623-00315072-00315191": "to be able to spot those clues because", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01624-00315192-00315295": "that's going to tell you where to go or", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01625-00315296-00315799": "where not to go", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01626-00315800-00316271": "so some example results", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01627-00316272-00316430": "yeah so mark sorry question on number", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01628-00316431-00316527": "two", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01629-00316528-00316734": "so uh you know are you thinking", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01630-00316735-00316934": "intention in meditation or just clearing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01631-00316935-00317039": "the mind", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01632-00317040-00317215": "so yes you well you need to clear the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01633-00317216-00317327": "mind you need to be able to get into a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01634-00317328-00317495": "brain state where the mind is clear in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01635-00317496-00317615": "other words you get out of the monkey", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01636-00317616-00317719": "mind", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01637-00317720-00317887": "you get out of those you know you might", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01638-00317888-00318054": "have voices going around your head you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01639-00318055-00318223": "might have constant ruminating thoughts", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01640-00318224-00318423": "going around in your head um that is not", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01641-00318424-00318663": "a state that is a beta mindset and your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01642-00318664-00318806": "brain is not in the state to be able to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01643-00318807-00318951": "manifest", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01644-00318952-00319223": "i mean that is the state that 90 of 95", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01645-00319224-00319375": "of people are in all the time apart from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01646-00319376-00319510": "when they're asleep", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01647-00319511-00319710": "um so yes you want to be", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01648-00319711-00319910": "planting that intention and you do it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01649-00319911-00320079": "through the command when you've sort of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01650-00320080-00320319": "meditated into that deeper state", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01651-00320320-00320751": "which i'll touch on in a sec as well", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01652-00320752-00320975": "so just some example results", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01653-00320976-00321199": "um you know this from charlotte so the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01654-00321200-00321382": "transformation's been extraordinary", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01655-00321383-00321495": "since learning how to use these", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01656-00321496-00321671": "techniques for manifestations clearing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01657-00321672-00321782": "blockages", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01658-00321783-00321879": "in my life and business are", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01659-00321880-00322015": "understanding spiritual laws and brain", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01660-00322016-00322119": "states", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01661-00322120-00322279": "i've seen exponential growth in my", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01662-00322280-00322454": "business and cash flow in fact as much", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01663-00322455-00322734": "as 10 to 15 000 per week", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01664-00322735-00323039": "and making a 250 000 tax debt disappear", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01665-00323040-00323334": "completely by a clever restructure", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01666-00323335-00323454": "i've also connected more with life", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01667-00323455-00323751": "purpose or the gym my real passion and i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01668-00323752-00323839": "cannot thank you enough for the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01669-00323840-00324263": "difference in our lives", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01670-00324264-00324495": "connor at first i was hesitant when i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01671-00324496-00324679": "was exposed to manifestations and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01672-00324680-00324854": "energetic clearings however began to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01673-00324855-00325006": "change things for me and i was in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01674-00325007-00325151": "exactly the same spot as this because i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01675-00325152-00325271": "actually did this course with connor at", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01676-00325272-00325463": "the same time", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01677-00325464-00325695": "um a colorway from earning under 50k per", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01678-00325696-00325830": "annum working with someone else to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01679-00325831-00325991": "working for himself", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01680-00325992-00326127": "and doubling his income and clearing all", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01681-00326128-00326367": "those debts within 12 months", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01682-00326368-00326479": "so not to mention the money that he", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01683-00326480-00326663": "saved through the techniques", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01684-00326664-00326815": "you know he was able to invest it wisely", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01685-00326816-00327015": "and further grow his income", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01686-00327016-00327199": "still to this day his business continues", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01687-00327200-00327343": "to grow for the help of manifestations", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01688-00327344-00327599": "and energetic clearings", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01689-00327600-00327758": "if you take the step into this program", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01690-00327759-00327903": "you know you only have a look back see", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01691-00327904-00328103": "how far you've come", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01692-00328104-00328454": "i had a very similar experience to that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01693-00328455-00328695": "uh and adrian so a more sort of real or", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01694-00328696-00328839": "more shorter term", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01695-00328840-00329006": "um result so i wrote a goal like you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01696-00329007-00329143": "said to write two days ago of earning a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01697-00329144-00329375": "thousand dollars a day trading cfds", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01698-00329376-00329534": "i wanted to have a goal i could measure", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01699-00329535-00329751": "immediately and accurately so i wrote a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01700-00329752-00329887": "thousand dollars a day and hung it on my", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01701-00329888-00330015": "computer", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01702-00330016-00330143": "then i used the technique from last", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01703-00330144-00330239": "night", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01704-00330240-00330391": "put some money in my trading account i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01705-00330392-00330615": "haven't used in months and i'm up 2 600", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01706-00330616-00330799": "in two days", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01707-00330800-00330951": "so just some real-time results for you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01708-00330952-00331167": "there", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01709-00331168-00331391": "all right the cool part so this is where", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01710-00331392-00331575": "we're going to create a manifestation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01711-00331576-00331695": "together", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01712-00331696-00331927": "using the protocol", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01713-00331928-00332143": "so just two more slides on the science", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01714-00332144-00332423": "and then we're going to do that together", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01715-00332424-00332630": "so we've got to understand the different", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01716-00332631-00332799": "brain states that are involved when it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01717-00332800-00332975": "comes to manifestation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01718-00332976-00333319": "so we have five major brain states so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01719-00333320-00333478": "you've got delta which is effectively", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01720-00333479-00333799": "your unconscious mind when you're asleep", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01721-00333800-00334175": "theta is in bold because the main", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01722-00334176-00334319": "brainwave state we want to be able to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01723-00334320-00334558": "get into to be able to manifest quicker", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01724-00334559-00334758": "the theta is considered the portal to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01725-00334759-00335015": "the universal mind um which is you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01726-00335016-00335127": "which is the effect of you know the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01727-00335128-00335334": "subconscious mind the bridge between the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01728-00335335-00335615": "unconscious and conscious", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01729-00335616-00335830": "alpha so again you can manifest in in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01730-00335831-00336015": "alpha or deep alpha", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01731-00336016-00336199": "um again it's sort of that that feeling", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01732-00336200-00336399": "you get you know where you sort of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01733-00336400-00336623": "begin to daydream you're a bit tired", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01734-00336624-00336751": "um you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01735-00336752-00336934": "for me uh i know i'm in an alpha state", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01736-00336935-00337143": "if i'm sort of driving driving somewhere", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01737-00337144-00337319": "and then if you get there and forget", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01738-00337320-00337575": "kind of remember you know the drive", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01739-00337576-00337727": "that's a classic example of your brain", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01740-00337728-00337903": "being in that state", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01741-00337904-00338151": "um yeah that daydreamy state right now", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01742-00338152-00338351": "like i said that is the monkey mind that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01743-00338352-00338487": "is what the people are", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01744-00338488-00338663": "most people are in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01745-00338664-00338830": "most of the time", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01746-00338831-00339030": "not conducive to manifestation it's more", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01747-00339031-00339199": "a fear based", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01748-00339200-00339406": "sort of brain state if you like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01749-00339407-00339543": "and then we've got gamma so this is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01750-00339544-00339743": "obviously your super high", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01751-00339744-00340063": "high awareness brain state", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01752-00340064-00340182": "sorry", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01753-00340183-00340327": "the deeper your brain state the stronger", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01754-00340328-00340503": "any programming occurring in this state", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01755-00340504-00340703": "so it's almost like hypnosis", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01756-00340704-00340830": "so this is where when you're in the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01757-00340831-00340991": "thyroid state affirmations in that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01758-00340992-00341199": "deeper state", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01759-00341200-00341367": "will have an effect on the deeper layers", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01760-00341368-00341627": "of your subconscious mind and basically", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01761-00341628-00341895": "re-re-imprint into your dna", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01762-00341896-00342223": "what your default setting is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01763-00342224-00342543": "alter your dna so to speak", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01764-00342544-00342703": "so again i mentioned this earlier your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01765-00342704-00342806": "subconscious doesn't know the difference", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01766-00342807-00343054": "between truth and what is not real", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01767-00343055-00343175": "for example if you believe you'll be", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01768-00343176-00343327": "fine in the tax order or you'll pay low", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01769-00343328-00343743": "taxes away will arise for it to happen", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01770-00343744-00343991": "um if you believe that people are out to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01771-00343992-00344271": "get you or you know your clients uh you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01772-00344272-00344478": "know that that client is bad", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01773-00344479-00344591": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01774-00344592-00344727": "there are going to be things that arise", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01775-00344728-00344958": "that support that your subconscious goes", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01776-00344959-00345158": "out and brings it back for you exactly", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01777-00345159-00345406": "what you're thinking", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01778-00345407-00345543": "some beliefs you can bring yourself", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01779-00345544-00345767": "brainwashed yourself into are", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01780-00345768-00345975": "expecting abundance to come to you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01781-00345976-00346271": "saying things like i am a money magnet", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01782-00346272-00346471": "you know i have you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01783-00346472-00346703": "i'm i'm wealthy i'm abundant those kind", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01784-00346704-00346934": "of things", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01785-00346935-00347039": "you can brainwash yourself into", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01786-00347040-00347367": "protection and safety around your wealth", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01787-00347368-00347551": "and the more money you make the less tax", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01788-00347552-00347647": "you pay", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01789-00347648-00347854": "so becoming again becoming part of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01790-00347855-00348006": "becoming a part of a group again that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01791-00348007-00348230": "have similar views as well making sure", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01792-00348231-00348430": "you're not associating with people that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01793-00348431-00348615": "will for example are trying to get your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01794-00348616-00348751": "money if you like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01795-00348752-00348878": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01796-00348879-00349087": "again making sure you ask yeah", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01797-00349088-00349182": "surrounding people with that same", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01798-00349183-00349295": "frequency and you will attract those", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01799-00349296-00349399": "people in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01800-00349400-00349495": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01801-00349496-00349695": "and then repel the people that aren't at", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01802-00349696-00350095": "that same frequency as you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01803-00350096-00350263": "okay again so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01804-00350264-00350358": "if you want to write this down i'll give", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01805-00350359-00350503": "you another", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01806-00350504-00350710": "a little quick bit now because i am", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01807-00350711-00350854": "going to get you guys to write down a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01808-00350855-00351078": "manifestation as we do it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01809-00351079-00352303": "no worries not", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01810-00352304-00352382": "cool", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01811-00352383-00352543": "and then", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01812-00352544-00353015": "we're gonna do it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01813-00353016-00353191": "okay so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01814-00353192-00353327": "i want you guys all right down there i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01815-00353328-00353471": "want you guys to all write down what it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01816-00353472-00353606": "is you actually want to manifest so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01817-00353607-00354478": "that's step one", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01818-00354479-00354615": "and once you have done", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01819-00354616-00354719": "that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01820-00354720-00355030": "i want you to start breathing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01821-00355031-00355191": "in slowly through your nose for four", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01822-00355192-00355503": "seconds", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01823-00355504-00355687": "we're gonna hold it at the top for four", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01824-00355688-00356151": "seconds", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01825-00356152-00356327": "and then i want you to breathe out for", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01826-00356328-00356663": "eight", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01827-00356664-00356815": "that is the breathing we're going to do", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01828-00356816-00357158": "as we manifest", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01829-00357159-00357358": "again being a bit later in the afternoon", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01830-00357359-00357606": "obviously the best times to manifest are", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01831-00357607-00357775": "going to be when you are naturally in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01832-00357776-00358015": "that theta state so as soon as you wake", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01833-00358016-00358158": "up and just before you're about to fall", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01834-00358159-00358319": "just fall asleep", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01835-00358320-00358463": "so know when you're feeling in a true", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01836-00358464-00358599": "sort of fabulous state is when you can", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01837-00358600-00358775": "feel that tingling up your arms that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01838-00358776-00358975": "sort of warm sort of fuzzy feeling as", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01839-00358976-00359119": "you're about to fall asleep", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01840-00359120-00359295": "that is that is how you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01841-00359296-00359454": "you know that is the feeling of data if", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01842-00359455-00359687": "you like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01843-00359688-00359815": "so once you're in that brain state once", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01844-00359816-00359934": "we do the breathing so i'm going to get", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01845-00359935-00360078": "the code up so once you've written it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01846-00360079-00360271": "down we've written the command", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01847-00360272-00360399": "we are going to we are going to do it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01848-00360400-00360878": "together", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01849-00360879-00361023": "so once you've got your intention at the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01850-00361024-00361103": "top", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01851-00361104-00361282": "we're going to write this down", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01852-00361283-00361654": "underneath directly underneath", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01853-00361655-00361815": "it is commanded by the laws of the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01854-00361816-00361991": "golden liquid realms and alchemical", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01855-00361992-00362175": "powers", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01856-00362176-00362447": "by the power and name of christ", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01857-00362448-00362647": "in the name of divine love so if you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01858-00362648-00362775": "don't resonate with by the power and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01859-00362776-00362910": "name of christ", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01860-00362911-00363039": "just write", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01861-00363040-00363191": "our chemical powers in the name of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01862-00363192-00363343": "divine love or if you resonate with the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01863-00363344-00363471": "first one write that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01864-00363472-00363791": "or write both doesn't matter", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01865-00363792-00363951": "that the tribeca code be used to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01866-00363952-00364103": "manifest and that is when you're going", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01867-00364104-00364327": "to write down what your intention was", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01868-00364328-00365215": "what it is that you want to manifest", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01869-00365216-00365334": "i'm just going to give you guys 30", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01870-00365335-00365887": "seconds to do that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01871-00365888-00366167": "then once you've written that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01872-00366168-00366287": "or as you're writing that once you've", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01873-00366288-00366478": "finished you can write any of these", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01874-00366479-00366575": "three", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01875-00366576-00366727": "underneath", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01876-00366728-00367175": "so a hum brothers me to asia into doi or", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01877-00367176-00367454": "as it is said it is done", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01878-00367455-00368087": "or i am this i am", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01879-00368088-00368334": "so i personally resonate more with the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01880-00368335-00368599": "asian to do or i am the same", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01881-00368600-00368823": "i personally use the second one", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01882-00368824-00369351": "asian today", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01883-00369352-00369551": "and just type y in the chat when that is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01884-00369552-00369719": "all done i want you to all make sure", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01885-00369720-00371919": "that you have done all that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01886-00371920-00372271": "good everyone's starting to do it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01887-00372272-00372482": "okay and once you have done", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01888-00372483-00372758": "that i want you to draw this tribeca", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01889-00372759-00373039": "code so draw the draw the circles and in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01890-00373040-00373254": "the middle where the red dot is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01891-00373255-00373406": "i want you to write", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01892-00373407-00373558": "basically you know if let's say for", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01893-00373559-00373727": "example if your manifestation or your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01894-00373728-00373878": "intention was", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01895-00373879-00374054": "you know to manifest a hundred hundred", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01896-00374055-00374206": "thousand dollars", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01897-00374207-00374343": "and in the middle of those where those", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01898-00374344-00374534": "circles interconnect", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01899-00374535-00374727": "uh just write 100k or write something", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01900-00374728-00376695": "that represents that manifestation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01901-00376696-00376806": "once you've done that i want you to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01902-00376807-00376895": "start", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01903-00376896-00377063": "i want you to literally stare at that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01904-00377064-00377239": "red dot and i want you to practice that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01905-00377240-00379015": "breathing that we were doing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01906-00379016-00379191": "i want you to keep breathing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01907-00379192-00379567": "taking good five to six breaths or more", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01908-00379568-00379799": "keep staring at that dot until it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01909-00379800-00380702": "starts to sort of go a bit blurry", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01910-00380703-00380887": "you want to sort of see it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01911-00380888-00381039": "it looks like everything goes blurry and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01912-00381040-00381182": "you start actually sort of viewing it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01913-00381183-00381367": "through your third eye if you like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01914-00381368-00382367": "restraint your third eye", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01915-00382368-00382630": "and as you were doing it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01916-00382631-00382775": "once you feel like you're in that nice", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01917-00382776-00383063": "deep state", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01918-00383064-00383230": "got your breathing doing the four", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01919-00383231-00383382": "seconds in through the nose with the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01920-00383383-00383478": "hold", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01921-00383479-00383575": "before", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01922-00383576-00383806": "then out for eight", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01923-00383807-00383967": "i want you to read out your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01924-00383968-00386039": "manifestation that you've written down", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01925-00386040-00386199": "so it is commanded by the laws of the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01926-00386200-00386391": "golden liquid realms and alchemical", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01927-00386392-00386495": "powers", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01928-00386496-00386687": "that the tribeca code be used to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01929-00386688-00386839": "manifest", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01930-00386840-00387039": "all abundance", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01931-00387040-00387343": "wealth success and prosperity", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01932-00387344-00387551": "for those that are on this webinar", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01933-00387552-00387823": "in the fastest and most effective way", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01934-00387824-00387943": "possible", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01935-00387944-00388191": "with ease and grace", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01936-00388192-00388295": "now", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01937-00388296-00390696": "to asia and today", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01938-00390697-00392191": "[Music]", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01939-00392192-00392375": "when you start imagining", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01940-00392376-00392630": "what it will feel like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01941-00392631-00392830": "the emotions that come with what it is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01942-00392831-00393039": "you're trying to manifest", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01943-00393040-00393606": "how is that going to make you feel", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01944-00393607-00393791": "way to imagine you've already got it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01945-00393792-00395878": "it's already there", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01946-00395879-00396119": "once you're finished", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01947-00396120-00396230": "if you're holding your left hand you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01948-00396231-00396375": "might feel a tingling sensation in your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01949-00396376-00397878": "left hand", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01950-00397879-00397991": "what you'll generally find if you hold", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01951-00397992-00398158": "your left hand out", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01952-00398159-00398327": "it'll feel like the the energy actually", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01953-00398328-00398599": "comes into the left palm of your hand", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01954-00398600-00398710": "and just", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01955-00398711-00400863": "cuts off when it's finished", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01956-00400864-00401063": "okay i want you to grab a drink of water", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01957-00401064-00401327": "when you're finished", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01958-00401328-00401495": "once you've experienced those emotions", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01959-00401496-00401839": "around what it's going to feel like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01960-00401840-00402110": "once you've imagined it imagination is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01961-00402111-00403078": "key to manifestation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01962-00403079-00403254": "so once you've done it as well", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01963-00403255-00403502": "i want you to drink a sip of water like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01964-00403503-00403782": "i said and detach from the outcome", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01965-00403783-00403967": "so again you don't want to be like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01966-00403968-00404054": "you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01967-00404055-00404278": "refreshing your brokerage app and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01968-00404279-00404399": "wondering when it's going to happen and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01969-00404400-00404647": "then enforcing or whatever it is you're", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01970-00404648-00404839": "you're sort of wanting you want to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01971-00404840-00405023": "actually be able to forget about it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01972-00405024-00405287": "detach from it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01973-00405288-00405471": "but keep an eye out for the cues so the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01974-00405472-00405615": "external things in your environment that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01975-00405616-00405758": "are going to be", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01976-00405759-00405943": "you know relative to you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01977-00405944-00406119": "and what you're after so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01978-00406120-00406295": "again this is things about you know if", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01979-00406296-00406406": "you haven't heard anything about", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01980-00406407-00406582": "synchronicity and how the universe works", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01981-00406583-00406727": "in that respect", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01982-00406728-00406927": "um it'd be good to do a little bit more", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01983-00406928-00407078": "about that because", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01984-00407079-00407191": "you know you'll be able to spot those", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01985-00407192-00407358": "cues a lot easier", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01986-00407359-00407510": "you know if you put a manifestation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01987-00407511-00407654": "about money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01988-00407655-00407823": "and suddenly you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01989-00407824-00408039": "get a text message about", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01990-00408040-00408191": "a client the next day or you might get a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01991-00408192-00408351": "textbook sometimes i get", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01992-00408352-00408534": "put manifestations in for money and you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01993-00408535-00408734": "know it means paying bills quicker", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01994-00408735-00408910": "obviously you're closing off that loop", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01995-00408911-00409119": "of debt energetically that thing is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01996-00409120-00409206": "sucking", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01997-00409207-00409399": "you know finances out from you once", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01998-00409400-00409903": "that's closed you attract more money in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-01999-00409904-00410078": "once you've done that you want to clear", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02000-00410079-00410366": "all your energetic blockages", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02001-00410367-00410495": "take action", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02002-00410496-00410663": "and again always be imagining and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02003-00410664-00410903": "visualizing what it was", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02004-00410904-00411047": "so once that once you've written down", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02005-00411047-00411191": "your manifestation that's it's all you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02006-00411192-00411399": "need to do you don't need to do the same", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02007-00411400-00411678": "thing daily the universe has heard", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02008-00411679-00411878": "it's now up to you to take action", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02009-00411879-00412110": "imagine and visualize and bring that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02010-00412112-00412566": "into your reality faster", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02011-00412567-00412670": "so another thing you want to be able to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02012-00412671-00412951": "do is obviously clear your blockages", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02013-00412952-00413191": "i don't have time to do that today", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02014-00413192-00413407": "but it can be as simple as doing you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02015-00413408-00413678": "know just just your own sort of commands", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02016-00413679-00413855": "around clearing blockages which would be", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02017-00413856-00413966": "done much in the same way as your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02018-00413967-00414103": "manifestations", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02019-00414104-00414230": "but then there's sort of the deeper", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02020-00414231-00414526": "deeper clearings that you want to be you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02021-00414527-00414655": "want to be doing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02022-00414656-00414870": "um that where there could be blockages", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02023-00414871-00415055": "um you know so you can bring about those", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02024-00415056-00415247": "manifestations quicker so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02025-00415247-00415374": "some of the things you know you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02026-00415375-00415582": "your chakras your crown chakra which is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02027-00415583-00415743": "about spirituality", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02028-00415743-00415870": "your third eye chakra which is about", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02029-00415871-00416207": "awareness throat chakra communication", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02030-00416208-00416487": "heart chakra love healing again going", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02031-00416488-00416607": "down through and seeing what they all", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02032-00416608-00416703": "are", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02033-00416704-00416791": "you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02034-00416792-00416918": "these are part of some of the things we", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02035-00416919-00417070": "will be teaching in terms of how to read", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02036-00417071-00417303": "energy and be able to nail that and know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02037-00417304-00417495": "where those blockages are", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02038-00417496-00417655": "so that you can then focus on that clear", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02039-00417656-00417766": "that out", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02040-00417767-00418287": "and again bring it in a lot quicker", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02041-00418288-00419407": "okay so do we have any questions guys", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02042-00419408-00419607": "how are we all feeling after that do we", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02043-00419608-00419783": "feel energized after manifestation we", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02044-00419784-00420031": "feel that was pretty simple", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02045-00420032-00420143": "do we feel", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02046-00420143-00420287": "you might find after a manifestation if", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02047-00420288-00420422": "it was big you start to feel a bit you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02048-00420423-00420667": "do you feel clogged up feel stuck", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02049-00420668-00421375": "[Music]", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02050-00421376-00421551": "what do i journal", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02051-00421552-00421799": "uh mark so i generally do journaling on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02052-00421800-00422007": "you know i do manifestations daily", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02053-00422008-00422207": "i tend to what i found is like just", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02054-00422208-00422439": "focus on one or two i wouldn't try and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02055-00422439-00422727": "do um like too many at once again it can", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02056-00422728-00422975": "overload and just end up draining you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02057-00422976-00423183": "but i mean to be in a state of receiving", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02058-00423184-00423310": "you've got to first have you've got to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02059-00423312-00423518": "have gratitude you've got to be grateful", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02060-00423519-00423710": "so i like to write down things every day", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02061-00423712-00423835": "of being grateful", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02062-00423837-00423959": "[Music]", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02063-00423960-00424070": "because if you're not grateful if you're", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02064-00424071-00424255": "resentful then you basically repel", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02065-00424256-00424447": "everything you're trying to trying to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02066-00424447-00424727": "bring about", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02067-00424728-00424879": "also right then i'll write informations", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02068-00424880-00425095": "as well", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02069-00425096-00425231": "alpha majors are a big one some people", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02070-00425232-00425335": "don't like it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02071-00425335-00425591": "i personally you know i like it i know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02072-00425592-00425727": "for me when i first started writing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02073-00425728-00425935": "affirmations like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02074-00425935-00426207": "you know i'm successful i used to write", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02075-00426208-00426422": "i used to say that out loud and i just i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02076-00426423-00426687": "could feel my body like cringe up", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02077-00426688-00426870": "so i had to do that for a long time i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02078-00426871-00427135": "had to do successful wealthy healthy all", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02079-00427135-00427303": "those kind of things i mean health was i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02080-00427304-00427431": "was in the environment so i was always", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02081-00427432-00427535": "healthy but", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02082-00427535-00427663": "especially those ones around building", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02083-00427664-00427999": "wealth and and making money yeah i had", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02084-00428000-00428127": "you know even if you are making a lot of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02085-00428128-00428263": "money you can still have those feelings", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02086-00428264-00428383": "around it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02087-00428384-00428487": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02088-00428488-00428614": "and yeah i have to work through a lot of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02089-00428615-00428935": "that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02090-00428935-00429295": "okay guys so we don't have any questions", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02091-00429296-00429470": "we i am going to move into now", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02092-00429471-00429622": "what our advancements for straight", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02093-00429623-00429814": "manifestation training looks like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02094-00429815-00430191": "we've got one", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02095-00430192-00430359": "yeah it does so the bob proctor method", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02096-00430360-00430503": "of affirmations you do you really have", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02097-00430504-00430687": "to do it for 90 days you really do have", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02098-00430688-00430799": "to build it into your part of your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02099-00430800-00430943": "routine", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02100-00430943-00431127": "you know it may be doing maybe only", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02101-00431128-00431335": "writing two or three out you know and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02102-00431335-00431463": "not going overboard you don't need to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02103-00431464-00431775": "write a a book on your affirmations", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02104-00431776-00431975": "every day like it's can be as simple as", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02105-00431976-00432191": "just writing one or two things out", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02106-00432192-00432375": "that's going to be super effective", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02107-00432376-00432495": "but what works for some people might not", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02108-00432496-00432751": "work for others", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02109-00432752-00432918": "okay so our advanced manifestation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02110-00432919-00433199": "training guys so if you are if you are", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02111-00433200-00433351": "not interested in the training this is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02112-00433352-00433495": "that was it for the web enough in terms", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02113-00433496-00433670": "of the seventh um the structured", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02114-00433671-00433870": "protocol into how you can manifest", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02115-00433871-00433975": "faster", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02116-00433976-00434191": "and if you're not wishing to to go any", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02117-00434192-00434447": "further and doing any advanced training", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02118-00434447-00434647": "then i want to thank you a lot for", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02119-00434647-00434759": "coming to the webinar and i hope you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02120-00434760-00434863": "really did", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02121-00434864-00434966": "get something out of that and you can", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02122-00434967-00435191": "now take away that structure", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02123-00435192-00435327": "and start to implement that into your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02124-00435328-00435727": "everyday life", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02125-00435728-00435983": "what we are offering is a live 10 class", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02126-00435984-00436151": "transformation for advanced", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02127-00436152-00436295": "manifestation training for business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02128-00436296-00436479": "owners and investors", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02129-00436480-00436743": "so the goal of this course is to really", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02130-00436743-00436918": "help you gain financial explosion in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02131-00436919-00437039": "your business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02132-00437039-00437270": "attracting higher frequency clients", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02133-00437271-00437383": "more", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02134-00437384-00437607": "you know higher frequency opportunities", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02135-00437608-00437783": "that kind of thing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02136-00437784-00437887": "through the power of our thoughts and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02137-00437888-00438070": "through the power of manifesting as a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02138-00438071-00438359": "group as well", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02139-00438360-00438647": "so what you get you get 10 live 90", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02140-00438647-00438855": "minute transformation classes", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02141-00438856-00439022": "uh and you get unlimited access to the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02142-00439023-00439207": "recordings of each session so you can", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02143-00439208-00439375": "then go back through you can look you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02144-00439376-00439551": "can literally look at each part or", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02145-00439552-00439847": "whatever part or whatever webinar we did", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02146-00439847-00440039": "until it becomes second nature so that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02147-00440039-00440222": "you do do it every day and can reap the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02148-00440223-00440455": "benefits from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02149-00440456-00440599": "but we are offering it at an incredibly", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02150-00440600-00440759": "low cost to receive it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02151-00440760-00441014": "and it is something combined that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02152-00441015-00441222": "warren and i have spent well over half a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02153-00441223-00441607": "million dollars learning", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02154-00441608-00441775": "so what benefits is this going to give", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02155-00441776-00441935": "you so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02156-00441935-00442063": "if you want to see a financial explosion", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02157-00442064-00442239": "in your business and splash through", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02158-00442239-00442479": "these covered 19 times", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02159-00442480-00442663": "which are obviously quite challenging", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02160-00442664-00442887": "our freedoms seem to be being eroded", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02161-00442888-00443039": "with every day i mean there's a bit of a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02162-00443039-00443143": "sort of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02163-00443143-00443343": "seems to sort of die down now which i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02164-00443343-00443703": "don't think it's going to for very long", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02165-00443704-00443863": "number two learn how to read energy and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02166-00443864-00443999": "master your mind so we are going to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02167-00444000-00444222": "teach different methods on how you can", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02168-00444223-00444431": "you know utilize energy readings you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02169-00444432-00444695": "know using a pendulum using a left hand", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02170-00444696-00444975": "using many other energy reading methods", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02171-00444976-00445143": "and so you can start mastering that that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02172-00445143-00445391": "internal dialogue that you might have", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02173-00445392-00445518": "that is preventing you from moving", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02174-00445519-00445799": "forward", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02175-00445800-00445935": "we are going to help you manifest health", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02176-00445935-00446222": "and greater relationships", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02177-00446223-00446351": "help you attract highly profitable", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02178-00446352-00446583": "investments run by people of integrity", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02179-00446584-00446751": "and basically become scam repellent to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02180-00446752-00446935": "bad opportunities bad investment", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02181-00446935-00447199": "opportunities", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02182-00447200-00447375": "again we'll help you become this course", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02183-00447376-00447535": "will help you become immune to scammers", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02184-00447535-00447655": "and tax audits and people who want to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02185-00447656-00447879": "sue your asset", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02186-00447880-00448014": "and we want to be able to help have your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02187-00448015-00448159": "wealth protected from lawsuits", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02188-00448160-00448375": "governments investigations", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02189-00448376-00448614": "neutralize speeding fines and eliminate", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02190-00448615-00448799": "tax debts energetically it's got to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02191-00448800-00449222": "start energetically", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02192-00449223-00449343": "this course will", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02193-00449343-00449551": "also help you if you're ready to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02194-00449552-00449727": "clear blockages around your finances", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02195-00449728-00449879": "stop self-sabotage happening in your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02196-00449880-00450135": "financial life", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02197-00450135-00450270": "clear negative associations with", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02198-00450271-00450431": "taxation and governments", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02199-00450432-00450583": "which subconsciously holds you back from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02200-00450584-00450870": "moving forward financially", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02201-00450871-00451022": "clear energetic blockages or beliefs", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02202-00451023-00451175": "around health and relationships which", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02203-00451176-00451383": "are keeping you sick or deeply unhappy", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02204-00451384-00451695": "or out of alignment with your purpose", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02205-00451696-00451822": "basically keep", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02206-00451823-00451983": "create an energetic shield over your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02207-00451984-00452159": "wealth so you have asset protection", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02208-00452160-00452318": "around your finances", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02209-00452319-00452591": "we help do that with things like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02210-00452592-00452751": "imagery and visualization and things", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02211-00452752-00453087": "like that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02212-00453088-00453270": "so what is covered in this training so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02213-00453271-00453399": "again we're going to give week one", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02214-00453400-00453543": "introduction to manifestation how it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02215-00453543-00453695": "works with your finances how it ties in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02216-00453696-00453879": "with that a lot more around the science", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02217-00453880-00454087": "as well and how we can use that and how", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02218-00454088-00454303": "you can sort of get more belief in it if", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02219-00454304-00454527": "you like and understanding around it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02220-00454528-00454655": "and implement that into your business so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02221-00454656-00454814": "one of the things if you're new to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02222-00454815-00454951": "manifestation you don't have a lot of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02223-00454952-00455118": "understanding around the science", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02224-00455119-00455359": "learning the science again helps imprint", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02225-00455360-00455591": "it subconsciously so they can then start", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02226-00455592-00455879": "to work for you a lot more effectively", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02227-00455880-00456055": "weeks two to five we'll talk about the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02228-00456056-00456287": "laws of manifestation so universal laws", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02229-00456288-00456527": "that are that are involved around it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02230-00456528-00456759": "spiritual laws things like that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02231-00456760-00457031": "around business investments tax", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02232-00457032-00457166": "and regulations", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02233-00457167-00457287": "so you understand why you've attracted", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02234-00457288-00457470": "your past experiences", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02235-00457471-00457622": "and how to master your subconscious mind", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02236-00457623-00457775": "and brain so you can take control of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02237-00457776-00457903": "creating what you truly want in the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02238-00457904-00458327": "financial future", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02239-00458328-00458479": "week six to eight so we're gonna do", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02240-00458480-00458622": "advanced energy reading and mastering", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02241-00458623-00458783": "your subconscious mind", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02242-00458784-00458966": "so we're gonna study the basics of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02243-00458967-00459110": "energy reading so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02244-00459112-00459231": "energy reading is super important to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02245-00459232-00459391": "manifestation it's super important to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02246-00459392-00459479": "know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02247-00459480-00459614": "to build an energy read to know where to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02248-00459615-00459831": "direct your manifestation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02249-00459832-00459910": "we're going to look at the different", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02250-00459912-00460110": "methods used like i mentioned so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02251-00460112-00460366": "you know using your pendulum left hand", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02252-00460367-00460463": "bobbers", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02253-00460464-00460718": "and things like remote viewing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02254-00460719-00460879": "uh we also do live energy readings where", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02255-00460880-00461031": "we look at specific situations for your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02256-00461032-00461231": "business investments", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02257-00461232-00461375": "and get it get answers into the wisdom", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02258-00461376-00461551": "of the higher mind", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02259-00461552-00461679": "and we're even look at how you can use", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02260-00461680-00461918": "this in trading and investing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02261-00461919-00462039": "and these are these are super fun these", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02262-00462039-00462255": "are super practical super hands-on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02263-00462256-00462455": "and this is something this is where i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02264-00462456-00462631": "had that sort of awakening and that kind", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02265-00462632-00462855": "of like wow this is this is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02266-00462856-00463022": "you know i can't pull it i can't really", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02267-00463023-00463207": "sort of you know comprehend that this is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02268-00463208-00463439": "possible that's the type of uh", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02269-00463439-00463687": "shift i had off of that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02270-00463688-00463831": "week 8 as well", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02271-00463832-00463959": "we'll go through", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02272-00463960-00464166": "energetic tax minimization and asset", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02273-00464167-00464279": "protection", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02274-00464280-00464414": "how you clear imprints and negative", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02275-00464415-00464607": "entities around the vats", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02276-00464608-00464791": "here you learn how to clear", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02277-00464792-00464927": "your negative inference blockages around", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02278-00464928-00465191": "regulators taxes lawsuits uh and create", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02279-00465192-00465447": "yourself a shield for the future", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02280-00465447-00465614": "uh this is one of the greatest secrets", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02281-00465615-00465799": "of our greatest secrets and um have not", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02282-00465800-00465959": "only used it with clients but with you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02283-00465960-00466166": "know ourselves to get rid of tax audits", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02284-00466167-00466399": "and deal with other similar stuff around", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02285-00466400-00466622": "again i used to get rid of um you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02286-00466623-00466822": "staff member i didn't like or didn't not", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02287-00466823-00466999": "didn't like but didn't you know wasn't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02288-00467000-00467222": "serving me anymore", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02289-00467223-00467375": "we also do a full auric clearing of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02290-00467376-00467559": "imprints negative energies and blocks", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02291-00467560-00468103": "around chakras", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02292-00468104-00468279": "weeks eight to nine", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02293-00468280-00468447": "again building residual income how you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02294-00468447-00468614": "can use all this that you've learned to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02295-00468615-00468759": "start to do that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02296-00468760-00468879": "build more if you've already got that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02297-00468880-00469014": "coming in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02298-00469015-00469207": "and we learn how money is energy we", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02299-00469208-00469375": "clear imprints and blocks and negative", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02300-00469376-00469583": "entities around money finances", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02301-00469584-00469775": "investments business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02302-00469776-00469895": "creating a shield to preserve your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02303-00469896-00470070": "wealth for the future", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02304-00470071-00470231": "and learn how to manifest far more money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02305-00470232-00470543": "in your life and business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02306-00470543-00470670": "and in the final week we will do a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02307-00470671-00470959": "review and practical application", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02308-00470960-00471166": "which can really consider it can consist", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02309-00471167-00471359": "of anything that we've we've covered to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02310-00471360-00471631": "maybe even a thing about remote viewing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02311-00471632-00472079": "we do really leave that one sort of open", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02312-00472080-00472207": "so the start date for this one is the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02313-00472208-00472431": "thursday the 2nd of june we're running", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02314-00472432-00472622": "at the same time at 4 p.m australian", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02315-00472623-00472791": "western standard time so 6 p.m if you're", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02316-00472792-00472935": "over east", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02317-00472935-00473095": "and we are limiting this place that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02318-00473096-00473351": "places to 20. so again two weeks time", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02319-00473352-00473670": "same time", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02320-00473671-00473847": "again live 10 week transformation", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02321-00473847-00473999": "attract more financial abundance in your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02322-00474000-00474118": "business with ease", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02323-00474119-00474270": "clear the negative energetic blockages", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02324-00474271-00474407": "around money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02325-00474408-00474591": "and really experience an exponential", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02326-00474592-00474735": "business shift in personal shift i mean", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02327-00474735-00474895": "it's you're not going to experience a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02328-00474896-00475095": "business shift an exponential business", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02329-00475096-00475199": "shift until you experience an", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02330-00475200-00475414": "exponential personal shift", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02331-00475415-00475783": "and much much more", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02332-00475784-00475983": "so this is for people i mean it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02333-00475984-00476127": "assuming that you're on the webinar now", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02334-00476128-00476255": "you're open-minded to creative", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02335-00476256-00476399": "out-of-the-box solutions and higher", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02336-00476400-00476543": "realms", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02337-00476543-00476710": "you may know that you need a financial", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02338-00476712-00476831": "miracle", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02339-00476832-00477151": "you may be fearful of where you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02340-00477152-00477303": "where your money is going", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02341-00477304-00477463": "that kind of thing being taken away from", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02342-00477464-00477639": "you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02343-00477639-00477775": "you're fed up with making bad decisions", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02344-00477776-00477895": "around money and are willing to try", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02345-00477896-00477991": "anything to solve your current", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02346-00477992-00478199": "situations clear your blockages and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02347-00478200-00478414": "transform your life to make more money", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02348-00478415-00478518": "be healthier and have better", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02349-00478519-00478718": "relationships in your life", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02350-00478719-00478959": "you're an action take taker teacher and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02351-00478960-00479070": "humble", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02352-00479071-00479270": "and prepare to basically do pretty much", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02353-00479271-00479518": "everything we say follow through", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02354-00479519-00479679": "an open mind to alternatives and good", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02355-00479680-00479895": "mentor", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02356-00479896-00480022": "this also might be for you if you're", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02357-00480023-00480207": "already successful but you're not afraid", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02358-00480208-00480407": "to invest in self growth and continually", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02359-00480408-00480510": "improve", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02360-00480512-00480935": "and prepare to do the homework", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02361-00480935-00481039": "and this isn't for people that are", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02362-00481039-00481175": "closed-minded", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02363-00481176-00481327": "this isn't people for people that you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02364-00481328-00481447": "know think they know it all aren't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02365-00481447-00481622": "teachable and only wanting to sort of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02366-00481623-00481839": "stay in that sort of third dimension", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02367-00481839-00482047": "with practical solutions", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02368-00482047-00482151": "and aren't really willing to think out", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02369-00482152-00482279": "of the box and look for alternative ways", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02370-00482280-00482470": "of doing things", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02371-00482471-00482614": "and this is definitely not for", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02372-00482615-00482807": "non-committed people unwilling to take", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02373-00482808-00482910": "action", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02374-00482912-00483047": "you know find excuses to justify the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02375-00483047-00483270": "lack of results and blame others", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02376-00483271-00483359": "you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02377-00483360-00483575": "won't put the work in one or ten classes", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02378-00483576-00483766": "you know we really want you at that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02379-00483767-00483855": "class", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02380-00483856-00484022": "um you know and basically want to have", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02381-00484023-00484214": "everything without having to do any work", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02382-00484215-00484351": "this just because you're using energy", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02383-00484352-00484518": "doesn't mean there's no work this is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02384-00484519-00484662": "effectively going to make", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02385-00484663-00484759": "you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02386-00484760-00484903": "it's going to make things happen quicker", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02387-00484904-00485222": "for you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02388-00485223-00485439": "so what you'd expect to to invest for a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02389-00485439-00485591": "deep 10-week transformative program like", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02390-00485592-00485687": "this", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02391-00485688-00485918": "you'd expect upwards of 10 grand", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02392-00485919-00486183": "us dollars", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02393-00486184-00486359": "but our price today", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02394-00486360-00486539": "we are offering this for", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02395-00486539-00486822": "3497 us dollars is a one-off upfront", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02396-00486823-00486943": "payment", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02397-00486943-00487110": "or you can do it over two installments", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02398-00487112-00487439": "of 29 and 97 u.s dollars", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02399-00487439-00487631": "and that's for 48 hours so basically", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02400-00487632-00487822": "that's a 48-hour offer for those that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02401-00487823-00487966": "are on the webinar", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02402-00487967-00488191": "and then it will go back up to 5 000 us", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02403-00488192-00488679": "dollars after that time", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02404-00488680-00488799": "so for those that are on the webinar", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02405-00488800-00488935": "today", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02406-00488935-00489183": "uh you will also get an ex extra", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02407-00489184-00489335": "personalized 60-minute one-on-one", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02408-00489335-00489462": "session with me", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02409-00489463-00489639": "uh as soon as you sort of sign up we'll", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02410-00489639-00489887": "book in for your one-on-one session", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02411-00489888-00490055": "and this is basically a guide", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02412-00490056-00490191": "um you know give yourself personal", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02413-00490192-00490303": "guidance on how you can manifest your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02414-00490304-00490462": "reality faster", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02415-00490463-00490670": "um i did this with my previous remote", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02416-00490671-00490791": "viewing students at the start of that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02417-00490792-00490879": "course", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02418-00490880-00491047": "and the ones that did take action", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02419-00491047-00491207": "quickly and and get that one-on-one", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02420-00491208-00491335": "session as well", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02421-00491335-00491647": "um yeah that really they really did that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02422-00491647-00491751": "they were their results were a lot", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02423-00491752-00491951": "faster over that course because", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02424-00491952-00492118": "it allowed me to sit down with them spot", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02425-00492119-00492335": "their limiting beliefs manifest it what", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02426-00492335-00492439": "it was that i wanted to get out of the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02427-00492439-00492655": "course uh and really sort of get to know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02428-00492656-00492759": "them a little bit more on a personal", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02429-00492760-00492855": "level", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02430-00492856-00493087": "um you know that really did help them", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02431-00493088-00493359": "get much more out of the course as well", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02432-00493360-00493566": "so it's valued at 497", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02433-00493567-00493775": "and again only valid for the 48 hours", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02434-00493776-00494135": "after the webinar", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02435-00494135-00494303": "we are going to give an extra bonus", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02436-00494304-00494575": "offer an exclusive extra bonus offer", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02437-00494576-00494839": "webinar for the action takers as well", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02438-00494839-00494943": "so you're going to get access to an", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02439-00494943-00495222": "extra 90-minute webinar with warren", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02440-00495223-00495335": "and he's going to teach you how you can", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02441-00495335-00495462": "further protect your finances", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02442-00495463-00495718": "investments energetically from loss", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02443-00495719-00495918": "during the great reset", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02444-00495919-00496047": "you know we do have an election coming", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02445-00496047-00496199": "up that's probably going to change a lot", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02446-00496200-00496335": "of things with", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02447-00496335-00496479": "you know policies and things like that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02448-00496480-00496687": "that are going to come about", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02449-00496688-00496879": "so webinar like this is going to you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02450-00496880-00497083": "know valued at 1997 getting that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02451-00497084-00497318": "included is going to be", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02452-00497319-00497847": "immense amount of value for you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02453-00497847-00497943": "now you are going to give a money back", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02454-00497943-00498135": "guarantee as well so if you attend the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02455-00498135-00498318": "first two classes and if in the unlikely", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02456-00498319-00498518": "event you decide that isn't for you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02457-00498519-00498687": "let us know before the third class and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02458-00498688-00498855": "we'll issue a prompt and courteous 100", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02459-00498856-00499431": "refund no questions asked", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02460-00499432-00499551": "but again", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02461-00499552-00499659": "the price", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02462-00499660-00499991": "3497 us dollars as an upfront one-off", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02463-00499992-00500143": "investment", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02464-00500143-00500814": "or two installments of 2097.", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02465-00500815-00501007": "so that is it guys", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02466-00501008-00501207": "that is our offer for the webinar for", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02467-00501208-00501359": "the training", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02468-00501360-00501518": "thank you all for if you've got any", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02469-00501519-00501783": "questions far away these are my details", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02470-00501784-00502062": "so i've got my email there my telegram", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02471-00502063-00502247": "um for those that are ready to commit", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02472-00502247-00502375": "ready to jump on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02473-00502376-00502535": "we have the payment link right now there", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02474-00502535-00502718": "which you should be able to click on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02475-00502719-00502943": "i will put that into", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02476-00502943-00503079": "the chat can i get that chucked into the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02477-00503080-00503447": "chat but anyone", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02478-00503447-00503575": "in other words here", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02479-00503576-00503703": "thank you for coming on i'll stay on and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02480-00503704-00503870": "for those that came to jump on and take", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02481-00503871-00503991": "action", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02482-00503992-00504110": "i look forward to working with you i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02483-00504112-00504214": "look forward to having you on the course", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02484-00504215-00504391": "and getting to know you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02485-00504392-00504503": "and really", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02486-00504504-00504679": "yeah starting to help you move your", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02487-00504680-00504831": "business in the right direction and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02488-00504832-00504966": "attracting in more abundance with ease", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02489-00504967-00505703": "and growth", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02490-00505704-00505870": "yeah i'll put the link in the chat just", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02491-00505871-00506318": "give me two sects", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02492-00506319-00506447": "yeah so i mean", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02493-00506447-00506599": "i like baron said in the chat just", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02494-00506600-00506759": "saying guys i mean i really didn't start", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02495-00506760-00506935": "getting", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02496-00506935-00507151": "any really substantial next exponential", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02497-00507152-00507310": "shifts in my business to you know who", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02498-00507312-00507455": "taught me all this stuff about", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02499-00507456-00507551": "um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02500-00507552-00507766": "about energy so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02501-00507767-00507903": "it's um", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02502-00507904-00508047": "yeah", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02503-00508047-00508207": "if you haven't been exposed before and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02504-00508208-00508359": "this kind of stuff here today was was", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02505-00508360-00508527": "sort of", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02506-00508528-00508647": "new to you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02507-00508647-00508799": "so you're not even barely scratching the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02508-00508800-00508991": "surface of the potential that you have i", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02509-00508992-00509695": "can tell you that right now", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02510-00509696-00509807": "now for those that are clicking on the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02511-00509808-00509999": "link and taking action", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02512-00510000-00510103": "the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02513-00510104-00510262": "uh we are in the process of transferring", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02514-00510263-00510518": "over to a different crm software for the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02515-00510519-00510783": "payment so if the payment pops up", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02516-00510784-00510927": "and it is substantially more it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02517-00510928-00511047": "because it's been converted to", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02518-00511047-00511207": "australian dollars already so don't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02519-00511208-00511759": "panic", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02520-00511760-00511927": "uh isto cabell yes there will be a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02521-00511928-00512118": "recording going out", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02522-00512119-00512255": "so again you are still going to be able", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02523-00512256-00512599": "to utilize this technique", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02524-00512600-00512718": "but we really want to take it to the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02525-00512719-00513247": "next level for all of you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02526-00513247-00513383": "some assuming no questions is a good", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02527-00513384-00513527": "thing", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02528-00513528-00513655": "anyone know and have any burning", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02529-00513656-00513855": "questions", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02530-00513856-00514118": "yes linda yeah so the 3497 has is", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02531-00514119-00514279": "basically converted", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02532-00514280-00514687": "uh automatically", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02533-00514688-00514887": "see i don't don't you have afraid it's", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02534-00514888-00515022": "not going to come out as", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02535-00515023-00515351": "5000 us", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02536-00515352-00515575": "okay guys so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02537-00515576-00515759": "yeah i'll put up yep that's fine i've", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02538-00515760-00515983": "got the contact details yeah for those", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02539-00515984-00516110": "wanting a bit more of a chat if you do", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02540-00516112-00516287": "have questions that you want to do with", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02541-00516288-00516559": "me privately then obviously you know", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02542-00516560-00516766": "contact me get in touch with me", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02543-00516767-00516935": "i'm just gonna put my details in the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02544-00516935-00517166": "chat so you can see them as well", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02545-00517167-00517335": "awesome linda great to have you on board", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02546-00517335-00517527": "look forward to working with you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02547-00517528-00517655": "those are looking for my details sorry", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02548-00517656-00517775": "give me two secs", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02549-00517776-00517935": "now if you do call me and i don't", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02550-00517935-00518159": "respond like i generally might not", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02551-00518160-00518247": "respond", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02552-00518247-00518366": "make sure if you call me and leave a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02553-00518367-00518566": "voicemail leave a text as well", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02554-00518567-00518799": "i will get back to you as soon as i can", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02555-00518800-00518943": "sometimes i'll miss calls that i pop in", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02556-00518943-00519222": "my phone for some reason", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02557-00519223-00519487": "something wrong with my hologram clearly", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02558-00519488-00519831": "yep sure can linda go for it", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02559-00519832-00519991": "again if anyone's wanting to chat over", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02560-00519992-00520351": "the next 48 hours got any questions", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02561-00520352-00520447": "don't know any things they want", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02562-00520447-00520791": "clarified then obviously reach out", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02563-00520792-00520975": "so um yeah do my best to get back to you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02564-00520976-00521207": "and we'll pick up a call or pick up a", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02565-00521208-00521399": "yeah pick up whatever and shout out", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02566-00521400-00521527": "thank you anne thanks for coming on and", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02567-00521528-00521655": "i hope you", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02568-00521656-00521855": "hope you enjoyed the webinar", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02569-00521856-00522080": "i really enjoyed delivering that", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02570-00522081-00522239": "[Music]", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02571-00522239-00522647": "thank you lily thank you for coming", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02572-00522647-00522775": "so we've still got quite a few on here", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02573-00522776-00522991": "i'm just going to stay on here guys so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02574-00522992-00523151": "just leave it as you as you like any", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02575-00523152-00523422": "questions assuming those are still on", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02576-00523423-00524110": "deciding what they want to do", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02577-00524112-00524222": "alrighty guys i'm going to end the", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02578-00524223-00524614": "webinar in the next minute so", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02579-00524615-00524783": "i need the link", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02580-00524784-00525270": "just click it now so it's up", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02581-00525271-00525407": "alrighty guys thank you for those who", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02582-00525408-00525836": "are still on i will see you guys soon", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02583-00525837-00526814": "[Music]", "W7gXu6uqcBQ-02584-00526815-00527023": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "W7Gd6spJQSE", "text": {"W7Gd6spJQSE-00000-00000048-00000395": "the Jewish Diaspora Hebrew letsa EPSA or", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00001-00000396-00000623": "exile Hebrew galette gal wit ye -", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00002-00000624-00000817": "goalless refers to the dispersion of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00003-00000818-00000968": "Israelites our Jews out of their", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00004-00000969-00001162": "ancestral homeland the Land of Israel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00005-00001163-00001366": "and their subsequent settlement in other", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00006-00001367-00001540": "parts of the globe in terms of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00007-00001541-00001882": "Hebrew Bible the term exile denotes the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00008-00001884-00002057": "fate of the Israelites who were taken", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00009-00002058-00002222": "into exile from the Kingdom of Israel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00010-00002223-00002447": "during the eighth century BCE and the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00011-00002448-00002624": "Judah Heights from the kingdom of Judah", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00012-00002625-00002819": "who were taken into exile during the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00013-00002820-00003155": "sixth century BCE while in exile the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00014-00003156-00003479": "Judah Heights became known as Jews yet", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00015-00003479-00003788": "via more yahudim Mordecai the Jew from", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00016-00003789-00003935": "the book of Esther being the first", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00017-00003936-00004231": "biblical mention of the term the first", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00018-00004232-00004448": "Exile was the Assyrian exile the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00019-00004449-00004661": "expulsion from the Kingdom of Israel say", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00020-00004662-00004897": "Maria begun by tiglath-pileser three of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00021-00004898-00005306": "Assyria in 733 BCE this process was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00022-00005307-00005483": "completed by Sargon - with the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00023-00005484-00005765": "destruction of the kingdom in 722 BCE", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00024-00005766-00005978": "concluding a three-year siege of say", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00025-00005979-00006212": "Maria begun by shell many servi the next", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00026-00006213-00006434": "experience of Exile was the Babylonian", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00027-00006434-00006616": "captivity in which portions of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00028-00006617-00006812": "population of the kingdom of Judah were", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00029-00006813-00007228": "deported in 597 BCE and again in 586 BCE", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00030-00007229-00007466": "by the neo-babylonian empire under the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00031-00007467-00007762": "rule of Nebuchadnezzar - a Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00032-00007763-00007966": "Diaspora existed for several centuries", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00033-00007967-00008188": "before the fall of the Second Temple and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00034-00008189-00008351": "their dwelling in other countries for", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00035-00008352-00008512": "the most part was not a result of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00036-00008513-00008788": "compulsory dislocation before the middle", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00037-00008789-00009031": "of the 1st century CE II in addition to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00038-00009032-00009308": "Judea Syria and Babylonia large Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00039-00009309-00009484": "communities existed in the Roman", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00040-00009485-00009748": "provinces of Egypt Cyrenian crete and in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00041-00009749-00009980": "rome itself after the siege of Jerusalem", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00042-00009981-00010280": "in 63 BCE when the Hasmonean kingdom", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00043-00010281-00010438": "became a protectorate of Rome", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00044-00010439-00010789": "emigration intensified in 6ee the region", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00045-00010790-00010984": "was organized as the Roman province of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00046-00010985-00011299": "Judea the Judean population revolted", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00047-00011300-00011576": "against the Roman Empire in 66 CE II in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00048-00011577-00011744": "the first jewish-roman war which", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00049-00011745-00011896": "culminated in the destruction of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00050-00011897-00012214": "Jerusalem in 70 CE II during the siege", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00051-00012215-00012394": "the Romans destroyed the second temple", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00052-00012395-00012670": "and most of Jerusalem this watershed", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00053-00012671-00012899": "moment the elimination of the symbolic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00054-00012900-00013078": "center of Judaism and Jewish identity", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00055-00013079-00013319": "constrained many Jews to reformulate a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00056-00013319-00013441": "new self-definition", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00057-00013443-00013583": "and adjust their existence to the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00058-00013584-00013775": "prospect of an indefinite period of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00059-00013776-00014164": "displacement in 132 seee Bar Kokhba led", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00060-00014165-00014356": "a rebellion against Hadrian a revolt", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00061-00014357-00014552": "connected with the renaming of Jerusalem", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00062-00014553-00014852": "as ela at Capitolina after four years of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00063-00014853-00015064": "devastating warfare the uprising was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00064-00015065-00015217": "suppressed and Jews were forbidden", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00065-00015218-00015533": "access to Jerusalem during the Middle", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00066-00015534-00015752": "Ages due to increasing migration and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00067-00015753-00015977": "resettlement Jews divided into distinct", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00068-00015978-00016136": "regional groups which today are", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00069-00016137-00016306": "generally addressed according to two", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00070-00016307-00016511": "primary geographical groupings the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00071-00016512-00016730": "Ashkenazi of northern and eastern europe", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00072-00016731-00016964": "and the Sephardic Jews of Iberia Spain", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00073-00016965-00017161": "and Portugal North Africa and the Middle", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00074-00017162-00017419": "East these groups have parallel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00075-00017420-00017584": "histories sharing many cultural", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00076-00017585-00017771": "similarities as well as a series of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00077-00017772-00018022": "massacres persecutions and expulsion 'z", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00078-00018023-00018269": "such as the expulsion from Spain in 1492", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00079-00018270-00018575": "the expulsion from England in 1290 and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00080-00018576-00018753": "the expulsion from Arab countries in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00081-00018754-00019180": "1948 to 1973 although the two branches", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00082-00019181-00019353": "comprised many unique ethno-cultural", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00083-00019354-00019586": "practices and have links to their local", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00084-00019587-00019778": "host populations such as central", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00085-00019779-00019958": "Europeans for the Ashkenazim and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00086-00019959-00020161": "Hispanics and Arabs for the Sephardic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00087-00020162-00020353": "their shared religion and ancestry as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00088-00020354-00020552": "well as their continuous communication", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00089-00020553-00020737": "and population transfers has been", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00090-00020738-00020936": "responsible for a unified sense of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00091-00020937-00021106": "cultural and religious Jewish identity", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00092-00021107-00021353": "between Sephardim and Ashkenazim from", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00093-00021354-00021905": "the late Roman period to the present", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00094-00021906-00022549": "topic origins and uses of the terms", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00095-00022550-00022888": "topic diaspora has been a common", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00096-00022889-00023062": "phenomenon for many peoples since", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00097-00023063-00023262": "antiquity but what is particularly", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00098-00023263-00023485": "instance as the pronounced negative", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00099-00023486-00023668": "religious indeed metaphysical", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00100-00023669-00023875": "connotations traditionally attached to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00101-00023876-00024112": "dispersion and exile glut to conditions", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00102-00024113-00024292": "which were conflated the English term", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00103-00024293-00024543": "diaspora which entered usage as late as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00104-00024544-00024805": "1876 and the Hebrew word glut though", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00105-00024806-00025003": "covering a similar semantic range bears", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00106-00025004-00025210": "some distinct differences in connotation", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00107-00025211-00025495": "the former has no traditional equivalent", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00108-00025496-00025728": "in Hebrew usage Stephen Bowman argues", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00109-00025729-00025927": "that diaspora in antiquity connoted", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00110-00025927-00026152": "emigration from an ancestral mother city", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00111-00026152-00026341": "with the immigrant community maintaining", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00112-00026342-00026506": "its cultural ties with the place of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00113-00026507-00026802": "origin just as the Greek city exported", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00114-00026804-00027045": "its surplus population so did Jerusalem", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00115-00027047-00027195": "while remaining the cultural and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00116-00027197-00027489": "religious center or metropolis IR VA MB", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00117-00027491-00027757": "Israel for the outlying communities it", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00118-00027758-00027958": "could have two census in biblical terms", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00119-00027958-00028186": "the idea of becoming a guiding light", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00120-00028187-00028462": "unto the nations by dwelling in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00121-00028463-00028677": "midst of Gentiles organ during the pain", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00122-00028679-00028960": "of exile from one s homeland the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00123-00028961-00029182": "conditions of diaspora in the former", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00124-00029183-00029347": "case were premise Thanh the free", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00125-00029348-00029593": "exercise of citizenship or resident", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00126-00029594-00029714": "alien status", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00127-00029716-00030033": "gilad implies by comparison living as a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00128-00030035-00030268": "denigrated minority stripped of such", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00129-00030269-00030588": "rights in the host society sometimes", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00130-00030589-00030879": "diaspora and Gullett are defined as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00131-00030880-00031258": "voluntary as opposed to involuntary", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00132-00031258-00031375": "exile", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00133-00031376-00031633": "diaspora it has been argued has a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00134-00031633-00031908": "political edge referring to geopolitical", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00135-00031910-00032170": "dispersion which may be involuntary but", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00136-00032170-00032311": "which can assume under different", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00137-00032312-00032674": "conditions a positive nuance galletas", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00138-00032675-00032917": "more teleological and connotes a sense", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00139-00032918-00033214": "of a prudent as' daniel borin defines", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00140-00033215-00033475": "diaspora as a state where people have a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00141-00033476-00033721": "dual cultural Allegiance productive of a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00142-00033722-00033949": "double consciousness and in this sense a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00143-00033950-00034168": "cultural condition not premise thanh any", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00144-00034169-00034429": "particular history as opposed to glut", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00145-00034430-00034600": "which is more descriptive of an", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00146-00034601-00034864": "existential situation that properly of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00147-00034865-00035068": "Exile conveying a particular", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00148-00035069-00035287": "psychological outlook the Greek word", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00149-00035288-00035551": "diaspora dispersion first appears as a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00150-00035552-00035800": "neologism in the translation of the Old", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00151-00035801-00035914": "Testament known as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00152-00035915-00036169": "the septuagint where it occurs 14 times", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00153-00036170-00036388": "starting with a passage reading a's", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00154-00036389-00036688": "diaspora and precised basel AI stays Jes", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00155-00036689-00036964": "now he'll be a diaspora or dispersion in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00156-00036965-00037203": "all kingdoms of the earth deuteronomy", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00157-00037204-00037753": "XXVIII 25 translating Sawa whose route", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00158-00037754-00038131": "suggests trouble terror single quote dot", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00159-00038132-00038413": "in these contexts it never translated", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00160-00038414-00038641": "any term in the original to nock drawn", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00161-00038642-00038941": "from the Hebrew root glt glow which lies", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00162-00038942-00039334": "behind gala and gola nor even galuf gola", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00163-00039335-00039643": "appears 42 times and galette in 15", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00164-00039644-00039904": "passages and first occurs in the second", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00165-00039905-00040375": "Kings chapter 17 verse 23 s reference to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00166-00040376-00040570": "the deportation of the Judean elite to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00167-00040571-00040870": "Babylonia Stefan dufoy in surveying the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00168-00040871-00041059": "textual evidence draws the following", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00169-00041060-00041350": "conclusion galette and diaspora are", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00170-00041351-00041482": "drawn from two completely different", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00171-00041483-00041818": "lexicons the first refers to episodes", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00172-00041819-00042034": "precise and dateable in the history of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00173-00042035-00042220": "the people of Israel when the latter was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00174-00042221-00042454": "subjected to a foreign occupation such", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00175-00042455-00042649": "as that of Babylon in which most of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00176-00042650-00042913": "occurrences are found the second perhaps", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00177-00042914-00043108": "with a single exception that remains", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00178-00043109-00043318": "debatable is never used to speak of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00179-00043319-00043531": "past and does not concern Babylon the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00180-00043532-00043711": "instrument of dispersion is never the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00181-00043712-00043953": "historical sovereign of another country", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00182-00043954-00044206": "diaspora is the word for chastisement", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00183-00044207-00044401": "but the dispersion in question has not", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00184-00044402-00044629": "occurred yet it is potential conditional", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00185-00044630-00044809": "on the Jews not respecting the law of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00186-00044810-00045067": "God it follows that diaspora belongs not", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00187-00045068-00045429": "to the domain of history but of theology", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00188-00045430-00045696": "in Talmudic and post Talmudic rabbinic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00189-00045697-00045900": "literature this phenomenon was referred", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00190-00045901-00046164": "to as galette exile a term with strongly", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00191-00046165-00046380": "negative connotations often contrasted", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00192-00046381-00046683": "with gula Redemption eugene Borowitz", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00193-00046684-00046926": "describes galletas fundamentally a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00194-00046927-00047199": "theological category the modern Hebrew", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00195-00047200-00047568": "concept of tefa so tpw scattered was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00196-00047569-00047805": "introduced in the 1930s by the Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00197-00047806-00048060": "American Zionist academic Simon Ravi de", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00198-00048061-00048234": "vich who to some degree argued for the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00199-00048235-00048372": "acceptance of the Jewish presence", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00200-00048373-00048591": "outside the Land of Israel as a modern", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00201-00048592-00048867": "reality and an inevitability the Greek", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00202-00048868-00049140": "term for diaspora diaspora also appears", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00203-00049141-00049338": "three times in the New Testament where", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00204-00049339-00049545": "it refers to the scattering of Israel ie", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00205-00049546-00049770": "the ten northern tribes of Israel as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00206-00049771-00049968": "opposed to the southern kingdom of Judah", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00207-00049969-00050205": "although James one-to-one refers to the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00208-00050206-00050423": "scattering of all twelve tribes in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00209-00050424-00050706": "modern times the contrasting meanings of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00210-00050707-00050889": "diaspora galette have given rise to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00211-00050890-00051201": "controversy among Jews Bowman states", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00212-00051202-00051507": "this in the following terms diaspora", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00213-00051508-00051672": "follows the Greek usage and is", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00214-00051673-00051870": "considered a positive phenomenon that", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00215-00051871-00052071": "continues the prophetic call of Israel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00216-00052072-00052298": "to be a light unto the nations and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00217-00052299-00052541": "establish homes and families among the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00218-00052542-00052812": "Gentiles the Prophet Jeremiah issues", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00219-00052813-00053019": "this call to the pre-exilic emigrants in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00220-00053020-00053313": "Egypt galette is a religious nationalist", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00221-00053314-00053499": "term which implies exile from the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00222-00053500-00053700": "homeland as a result of collective sins", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00223-00053701-00053937": "an exile that will be redeemed at yhw H", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00224-00053938-00054276": "s pleasure Jewish messianism is closely", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00225-00054277-00054554": "connected with the concept of galette in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00226-00054555-00054767": "Zionist debates a distinction was made", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00227-00054769-00055041": "between galette and goal as gola the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00228-00055041-00055209": "latter denoted social and political", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00229-00055210-00055425": "exile whereas the former while", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00230-00055426-00055607": "consequential on the latter was a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00231-00055608-00055821": "psycho-spiritual framework that was not", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00232-00055822-00055991": "wholly dependent on the conditions of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00233-00055992-00056223": "life in diasporic exile since one could", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00234-00056224-00056397": "technically remain in galette even in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00235-00056398-00056694": "Eretz Israel whereas Theodor Herzl and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00236-00056695-00056811": "his followers thought that the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00237-00056812-00056991": "establishment of a Jewish state would", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00238-00056991-00057219": "put an end to the diasporic exile a HOD", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00239-00057220-00057404": "Higham thought to the contrary that such", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00240-00057405-00057723": "a state s function would be to sustain", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00241-00057724-00058307": "Jewish nation hood in the Diaspora", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00242-00058308-00058826": "topic pre-roman diaspora", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00243-00058827-00059336": "topic in 722 BCE the Assyrians under", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00244-00059337-00059582": "Sargon - successor to shellman easer V", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00245-00059583-00059794": "conquered the Kingdom of Israel and many", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00246-00059795-00059969": "Israelites were deported to Mesopotamia", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00247-00059970-00060241": "the Jewish proper diaspora began with", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00248-00060242-00060482": "the Babylonian exile in the 6th century", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00249-00060483-00060725": "BCE after the overthrow of the kingdom", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00250-00060726-00061054": "of Judah in 586 BCE by nebuchadnezzar ii", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00251-00061055-00061334": "of babylon see babylonian captivity and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00252-00061335-00061513": "the deportation of a considerable", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00253-00061514-00061663": "portion of its inhabitants to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00254-00061664-00061910": "mesopotamia the jews had two principal", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00255-00061911-00062126": "cultural centres Babylonia in the land", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00256-00062127-00062344": "of israel deportees returned to the same", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00257-00062345-00062582": "area after the neo-babylonian empire was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00258-00062583-00062857": "in turn conquered by cyrus the great the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00259-00062858-00063107": "biblical book of Ezra includes two texts", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00260-00063108-00063296": "said to be decrees allowing the deported", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00261-00063297-00063476": "Jews to return to their homeland after", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00262-00063477-00063661": "decades and ordering the temple rebuilt", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00263-00063662-00063944": "the differences in content and tone of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00264-00063945-00064166": "the to decrease one in Hebrew and one in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00265-00064166-00064361": "Aramaic have caused some scholars to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00266-00064362-00064622": "question their authenticity the cyrus", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00267-00064623-00064829": "cylinder an ancient tablet on which has", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00268-00064829-00064979": "written a declaration in the name of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00269-00064979-00065182": "cyrus referring to restoration of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00270-00065183-00065384": "temples and repatriation of exiled", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00271-00065385-00065561": "peoples has often been taken as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00272-00065562-00065768": "corroboration of the authenticity of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00273-00065769-00066001": "biblical decrees attributed to cyrus but", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00274-00066002-00066151": "other scholars point out that the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00275-00066152-00066365": "cylinders text is specific to babylon", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00276-00066366-00066584": "and mesopotamia and makes no mention of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00277-00066585-00066854": "Judah or Jerusalem les Tyrell grab", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00278-00066855-00067073": "asserted that the alleged decree of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00279-00067074-00067373": "Cyrus regarding Judah cannot be", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00280-00067374-00067606": "considered authentic but that there was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00281-00067607-00067894": "a general policy of allowing deportees", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00282-00067895-00068254": "to return and to re-establish cult sites", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00283-00068255-00068500": "he also stated that archaeology suggests", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00284-00068501-00068812": "that the return was a trickle taking", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00285-00068813-00069028": "place over decades rather than a single", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00286-00069029-00069262": "event there is no sudden expansion of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00287-00069263-00069505": "the population base of 30,000 and no", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00288-00069506-00069700": "credible indication of any special", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00289-00069701-00069892": "interest in yahood although most of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00290-00069893-00070032": "Jewish people during this period", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00291-00070033-00070263": "especially the wealthy families were to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00292-00070264-00070486": "be found in Babylonia the existence they", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00293-00070487-00070675": "led there under the successive rulers of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00294-00070676-00070867": "the Achaemenid the Seleucids the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00295-00070868-00070926": "Parthians", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00296-00070927-00071113": "and the sasanian x' was obscure and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00297-00071114-00071353": "devoid of political influence the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00298-00071354-00071569": "poorest but most fervent of the exiles", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00299-00071570-00071746": "returned to Judah the Land of Israel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00300-00071747-00071988": "during the reign of the Achaemenids ce", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00301-00071989-00072456": "552 330 BCE there with the reconstructed", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00302-00072457-00072663": "Temple in Jerusalem as their center they", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00303-00072664-00072853": "organized themselves into a community", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00304-00072854-00073099": "animated by a remarkable religious order", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00305-00073100-00073285": "and a tenacious attachment to the Torah", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00306-00073286-00073551": "as the focus of its identity as this", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00307-00073552-00073756": "little nucleus increased in numbers with", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00308-00073757-00073942": "the accession of recruits from various", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00309-00073943-00074143": "quarters it awoke to a consciousness of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00310-00074144-00074331": "itself and strove once again for", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00311-00074332-00074518": "national independence and political", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00312-00074519-00074710": "enfranchisement and sovereignty the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00313-00074711-00074959": "first Jewish Diaspora in Egypt arose in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00314-00074960-00075136": "the last century of firaon accrual", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00315-00075137-00075306": "apparently with the settlement there", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00316-00075307-00075531": "either under Ashurbanipal or during the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00317-00075532-00075712": "reign of sometta COS of a colony of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00318-00075713-00075963": "Jewish mercenaries a military class that", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00319-00075964-00076147": "successively served the Persian the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00320-00076148-00076363": "Ptolemaic and Roman governments down to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00321-00076364-00076561": "the early decades of the 2nd century CE", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00322-00076562-00076759": "II when the revolt against Trajan", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00323-00076760-00076972": "destroyed them their presence was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00324-00076973-00077113": "buttressed by numerous Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00325-00077114-00077284": "administrators who joined them in Egypt", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00326-00077285-00077581": "s military and urban centers while", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00327-00077582-00077863": "communities in Alexandria and Rome dated", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00328-00077864-00078091": "back to before the Maccabean revolt the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00329-00078092-00078279": "population in the Jewish Diaspora", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00330-00078280-00078681": "expanded after the Pompey s campaign in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00331-00078682-00079038": "62 BC II under the Hasmonean princes who", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00332-00079039-00079194": "were at first high priests and then", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00333-00079195-00079411": "kings the Jewish state displayed even a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00334-00079412-00079585": "certain luster and annexed several", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00335-00079586-00079915": "territories soon however discord within", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00336-00079916-00080068": "the royal family and the growing", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00337-00080069-00080275": "disaffection of the pious the soul of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00338-00080276-00080446": "the nation towards rulers who no longer", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00339-00080447-00080659": "evinced any appreciation of the real", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00340-00080660-00080872": "aspirations of their subjects made the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00341-00080873-00081037": "Jewish nation easy prey for the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00342-00081038-00081193": "ambitions of the now increasingly", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00343-00081194-00081415": "autocratic and imperial Romans the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00344-00081416-00081598": "successors of the Seleucids", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00345-00081599-00081957": "in 63 BCE Pompey invaded Jerusalem the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00346-00081958-00082132": "Jewish people lost their political", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00347-00082133-00082288": "sovereignty and independence and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00348-00082289-00082498": "Gabinius subjected the Jewish people to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00349-00082499-00082827": "tribute", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00350-00082828-00083430": "topic early diaspora populations", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00351-00083431-00083811": "topic the Jewish Diaspora in Egypt was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00352-00083812-00084096": "already several centuries old it was as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00353-00084097-00084309": "old as that of the East Babylon but not", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00354-00084310-00084506": "until the early Hellenistic period did", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00355-00084507-00084710": "it achieve comparable importance", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00356-00084711-00084923": "Alexander the Great's breathtakingly", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00357-00084924-00085148": "rapid campaign of conquest led to the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00358-00085149-00085337": "Swift commercialization of the eastern", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00359-00085338-00085710": "Mediterranean after 333 BCE after", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00360-00085711-00085892": "numerous vicissitudes and especially", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00361-00085893-00086103": "owing to internal dissensions within the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00362-00086104-00086312": "Seleucid dynasty on the one hand and to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00363-00086313-00086513": "the intrested support of the pre Roman", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00364-00086514-00086772": "Empire the pre autocratic Roman Republic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00365-00086773-00086924": "on the other the cause of Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00366-00086925-00087153": "independence finally triumphed as early", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00367-00087154-00087362": "as the 3rd century BCE Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00368-00087363-00087542": "communities sprang up in the Aegean", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00369-00087543-00087792": "islands Greece Asia Minor Cyrenaica", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00370-00087793-00088122": "Italy and Egypt in Palestine under the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00371-00088123-00088341": "favorable auspices of the long period of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00372-00088342-00088544": "peace almost a whole century which", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00373-00088545-00088740": "followed the advent of the Ptolemies the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00374-00088741-00088988": "new ways were to flourish by means of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00375-00088989-00089217": "all kinds of contacts and particularly", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00376-00089218-00089385": "thanks to the development of commerce", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00377-00089386-00089618": "Hellenism infiltrated on all sides in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00378-00089619-00089849": "varying degrees the ports of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00379-00089850-00090032": "Mediterranean coast were indispensable", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00380-00090033-00090254": "to Commerce and from the very beginning", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00381-00090255-00090435": "of the Hellenistic period underwent", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00382-00090436-00090666": "great development in the Western", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00383-00090667-00090891": "diaspora Greek quickly became dominant", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00384-00090892-00091098": "in Jewish life and little sind remains", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00385-00091099-00091304": "of profound contact with Hebrew or", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00386-00091305-00091517": "Aramaic the latter probably being the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00387-00091518-00091797": "more prevalent the proportion of Jews in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00388-00091798-00092010": "the Diaspora in relation to the size of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00389-00092011-00092186": "the nation as a whole increased steadily", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00390-00092187-00092369": "throughout the Hellenistic era and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00391-00092370-00092547": "reached astonishing dimensions in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00392-00092548-00092748": "early Roman period particularly in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00393-00092749-00093015": "Alexandria it was not least for this", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00394-00093016-00093200": "reason that the Jewish people became a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00395-00093201-00093447": "major political factor especially since", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00396-00093448-00093629": "the Jews in the Diaspora notwithstanding", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00397-00093630-00093897": "strong cultural social and religious", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00398-00093898-00094086": "tensions remained firmly united with", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00399-00094087-00094160": "their homeland", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00400-00094161-00094416": "Smallwood writes that it is reasonable", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00401-00094417-00094601": "to conjecture that many such as the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00402-00094602-00094860": "settlement in Puyol II attested in 4 BCE", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00403-00094861-00095079": "went back to the late pre Roman Empire", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00404-00095080-00095310": "Roman Republic or early Empire and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00405-00095311-00095535": "originated in voluntary emigration and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00406-00095536-00095744": "the lure of trade and commerce dating", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00407-00095745-00095942": "the numerous settlements is difficult", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00408-00095943-00096188": "some settlements may have resulted from", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00409-00096189-00096465": "the Jewish revolt others such as the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00410-00096466-00096684": "Jewish community in Rome were far older", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00411-00096685-00096813": "dating back to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00412-00096814-00097085": "at least the mid second century BCE", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00413-00097086-00097371": "although it expanded greatly following", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00414-00097372-00097857": "Pompey's campaign in 62 BC II in 6ee the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00415-00097858-00098160": "Romans and X Judea only the Jews in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00416-00098161-00098394": "Babylonian remained outside of Roman", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00417-00098395-00098445": "rule", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00418-00098446-00098682": "unlike the greek-speaking Hellenized", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00419-00098683-00098916": "Jews in the West the Jewish communities", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00420-00098917-00099180": "in Babylonian and Judea continued the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00421-00099181-00099441": "use of aramaic as a primary language as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00422-00099442-00099621": "early as the middle of the second", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00423-00099622-00099876": "century BCE the jewish author of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00424-00099877-00100050": "third book of the oracle a sibling", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00425-00100051-00100509": "addressed the chosen people saying every", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00426-00100510-00100692": "land is full of the in every sea the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00427-00100693-00100917": "most diverse witnesses such as Strabo", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00428-00100918-00101166": "filo Seneca Luke the author of the Acts", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00429-00101167-00101433": "of the Apostles Cicero and Josephus all", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00430-00101434-00101625": "mentioned Jewish populations in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00431-00101626-00101808": "cities of the Mediterranean basin", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00432-00101809-00102084": "see also history of the Jews in India", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00433-00102085-00102285": "and history of the Jews in China for", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00434-00102286-00102581": "pre-roman and post diasporic populations", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00435-00102582-00102846": "King Agrippa the first in a letter to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00436-00102847-00103047": "Caligula enumerated among the provinces", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00437-00103048-00103286": "of the Jewish Diaspora almost all the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00438-00103288-00103488": "Hellenized in non Hellenized countries", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00439-00103489-00103760": "of the orient this enumeration was far", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00440-00103761-00103947": "from complete as Italy and Cyrene II", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00441-00103948-00104181": "were not included the epigraphic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00442-00104182-00104388": "discoveries from year to year augment", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00443-00104389-00104568": "the number of known Jewish communities", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00444-00104569-00104754": "but must be viewed with caution due to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00445-00104755-00104916": "the lack of precise evidence of their", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00446-00104917-00105174": "numbers according to the ancient Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00447-00105175-00105410": "historian Josephus the next most dense", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00448-00105411-00105608": "Jewish population after the Land of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00449-00105609-00105822": "Israel in Babylonia was in Syria", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00450-00105823-00106032": "particularly in Antioch and Damascus", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00451-00106033-00106257": "where ten thousand to eighteen thousand", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00452-00106258-00106413": "Jews were massacred during the great", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00453-00106414-00106638": "insurrection the ancient Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00454-00106639-00106848": "philosopher filo gives the number of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00455-00106849-00107073": "Jewish inhabitants in Egypt as 1 million", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00456-00107074-00107379": "one-eighth of the population Alexandria", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00457-00107380-00107561": "was by far the most important of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00458-00107563-00107850": "Egyptian Jewish communities the Jews in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00459-00107851-00108045": "the Egyptian diaspora were on a par with", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00460-00108046-00108246": "their Ptolemaic counterparts and close", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00461-00108247-00108455": "ties existed for them with Jerusalem as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00462-00108456-00108738": "in other Hellenistic diasporas the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00463-00108739-00108954": "Egyptian diaspora was one of choice not", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00464-00108955-00109152": "of imposition to judge by the accounts", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00465-00109153-00109464": "of wholesale massacres in 115 BCE the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00466-00109465-00109680": "number of Jewish residents in Cyrenaica", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00467-00109681-00110022": "Cyprus and Mesopotamia was also large at", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00468-00110023-00110181": "the commencement of the reign of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00469-00110182-00110406": "Caesar Augustus there were over 7,000", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00470-00110407-00110583": "Jews in Rome though this is only the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00471-00110583-00110748": "number that is said to have escorted the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00472-00110749-00110955": "envoys who came to demand the deposition", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00473-00110956-00111174": "of Archelaus compared bringin Klaus", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00474-00111175-00111408": "Ashish to der Jude and I'm altered him", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00475-00111408-00111852": "Stuttgart 2005's 202 bringin talks about", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00476-00111853-00112088": "8,000 Jews who lived in the city of Rome", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00477-00112089-00112320": "many sources say that the Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00478-00112321-00112602": "constituted a full one-tenth 10% of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00479-00112603-00112773": "population of the ancient city of Rome", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00480-00112774-00113121": "itself finally if the sums confiscated", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00481-00113122-00113343": "by the governor Lucius Valerius flaccus", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00482-00113344-00113708": "in the year 62 61st BCE represented the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00483-00113709-00113916": "tax of added drama per head for a single", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00484-00113917-00114075": "year it would imply that the Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00485-00114076-00114267": "population of Asia Minor numbered", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00486-00114268-00114477": "forty-five thousand adult males for a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00487-00114478-00114642": "total of at least one hundred eighty", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00488-00114643-00115094": "thousand persons", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00489-00115095-00115618": "topic under the Roman Empire", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00490-00115619-00116041": "topic xiii century author bar have reyes", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00491-00116042-00116227": "gave a figure of six million nine", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00492-00116228-00116433": "hundred forty four thousand jews in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00493-00116434-00116508": "roman world", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00494-00116509-00116776": "Salo wit mayer baron considered the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00495-00116777-00117004": "figure convincing the figure of seven", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00496-00117005-00117193": "million within and one million outside", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00497-00117194-00117403": "the roman world in the mid 1st century", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00498-00117404-00117609": "became widely accepted including by", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00499-00117610-00117892": "lewis Feldman however contemporary", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00500-00117893-00118099": "scholars now accept that bar he Brea", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00501-00118100-00118318": "spaced his figure on a census of total", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00502-00118319-00118522": "Roman citizens and thus included man", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00503-00118523-00118819": "Jews the figure of six million nine", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00504-00118820-00118996": "hundred forty four thousand being", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00505-00118997-00119275": "recorded in Eusebius chronicon Lewis", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00506-00119276-00119506": "Feldman previously an active supporter", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00507-00119507-00119733": "of the figure now states that he and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00508-00119734-00120064": "Baron were mistaken filo gives a figure", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00509-00120065-00120403": "of 1 million Jews living in Egypt John R", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00510-00120404-00120700": "Bartlett rejects baron s figures", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00511-00120701-00120931": "entirely arguing that we have no clue as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00512-00120932-00121129": "to the size of the jewish demographic in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00513-00121130-00121369": "the ancient world the romans did not", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00514-00121370-00121579": "distinguish between jews inside and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00515-00121580-00121867": "outside of the Land of Israel Judea they", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00516-00121868-00122085": "collected an annual temple tax from Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00517-00122086-00122338": "both in and outside of Israel the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00518-00122339-00122548": "revolts in and suppression of diaspora", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00519-00122549-00122790": "communities in Egypt Libya and Crete in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00520-00122791-00123202": "115 to 117 C II had a severe impact on", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00521-00123203-00123664": "the Jewish Diaspora", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00522-00123665-00124222": "topic roman destruction of judea", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00523-00124223-00124552": "topic it is commonly claimed that the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00524-00124553-00124741": "diaspora began with Rome's twofold", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00525-00124742-00124980": "crushing of Jewish national aspirations", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00526-00124981-00125257": "David Abra Bock / one has argued that", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00527-00125258-00125500": "much of the European Jewish Diaspora by", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00528-00125501-00125689": "which he means exile or voluntary", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00529-00125690-00125883": "migration originated with the Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00530-00125884-00126186": "Wars which occurred between 66 and 135", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00531-00126188-00126475": "CE II Martin Goodman states that it is", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00532-00126476-00126643": "only after the destruction of Jerusalem", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00533-00126644-00126871": "that Jews are found in northern Europe", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00534-00126872-00126982": "and along the western Mediterranean", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00535-00126983-00127324": "coast this widespread popular belief", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00536-00127325-00127501": "holds that there was a sudden expulsion", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00537-00127502-00127777": "of Jews from Judea Syria Palestina and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00538-00127778-00127906": "that this was crucial for the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00539-00127907-00128125": "establishment of the diaspora Israel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00540-00128126-00128326": "Bartle contends that sand is", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00541-00128327-00128530": "incorrect in ascribing this view to most", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00542-00128531-00128758": "Jewish study scholars instead arguing", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00543-00128758-00128920": "that this view is negligible among", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00544-00128921-00129208": "serious Jewish study scholars arguing", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00545-00129208-00129384": "that the growth of diaspora Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00546-00129385-00129592": "communities was a gradual process that", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00547-00129593-00129799": "occurred over the centuries starting", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00548-00129800-00129991": "with the Assyrian destruction of Israel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00549-00129992-00130222": "the Babylonian destruction of Judah the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00550-00130223-00130414": "Roman destruction of Judea and the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00551-00130415-00130579": "subsequent rule of Christians and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00552-00130580-00130843": "Muslims after the revolt the Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00553-00130844-00131058": "religious and cultural center shifted to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00554-00131059-00131263": "the Babylonian Jewish community and its", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00555-00131264-00131497": "scholars for the generations that", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00556-00131498-00131701": "followed the destruction of the Second", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00557-00131702-00131860": "Temple event came to represent a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00558-00131861-00132052": "fundamental insight about the Jews who", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00559-00132053-00132265": "had become a dispossessed and persecuted", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00560-00132266-00132417": "people for much of their history", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00561-00132418-00132673": "following the Bar Kokhba revolt Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00562-00132674-00132889": "were reduced to a holy diaspora people", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00563-00132890-00133138": "Eric as Gruen maintains for example that", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00564-00133139-00133297": "focusing on the destruction of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00565-00133298-00133477": "temple misses the point that already", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00566-00133478-00133663": "before this the Diaspora was well", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00567-00133664-00133963": "established compulsory dislocation of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00568-00133964-00134143": "people cannot explain more than a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00569-00134144-00134434": "fraction of the eventual diaspora Avram", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00570-00134435-00134629": "Ehrlich also states that already well", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00571-00134630-00134809": "before the destruction of the temple in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00572-00134810-00135085": "70 CE II more Jews lived in the Diaspora", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00573-00135086-00135373": "than in Israel according to Israel Yuval", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00574-00135374-00135589": "the Babylonian captivity created a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00575-00135590-00135748": "promise of return in the Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00576-00135749-00135919": "consciousness which had the effect of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00577-00135920-00136117": "enhancing the Jewish self perception of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00578-00136118-00136303": "exile after the destruction of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00579-00136304-00136477": "second temple albeit their dispersion", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00580-00136478-00136678": "was due to an array of non exile ik", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00581-00136679-00137194": "factors Roman rule which began in 63 BCE", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00582-00137195-00137560": "continued until a revolt from C 66 to 70", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00583-00137561-00137596": "a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00584-00137597-00137731": "Jewish uprising to fight for", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00585-00137732-00137911": "independence was eventually crushed", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00586-00137912-00138103": "after four years culminating in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00587-00138104-00138298": "capture of Jerusalem and the burning and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00588-00138299-00138490": "destruction of the temple the center of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00589-00138491-00138667": "the national and religious life of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00590-00138668-00138898": "Jews throughout the world the Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00591-00138899-00139116": "Diaspora at the time of the temple s", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00592-00139117-00139414": "destruction according to Josephus was in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00593-00139415-00139471": "Parthia", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00594-00139472-00139828": "Persia Babylonia Iraq Arabia as well as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00595-00139829-00140035": "some Jews beyond the Euphrates and in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00596-00140036-00140416": "a.d abeam Kurdistan in Josephus own", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00597-00140417-00140647": "words he hadn't formed the remotest", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00598-00140648-00140965": "Arabians about the destruction exactly", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00599-00140966-00141169": "when Roman and II Judaism began as a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00600-00141170-00141352": "question of scholarly debate however", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00601-00141353-00141604": "historian Higham Hillel been Sasson has", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00602-00141605-00141888": "proposed that uh crisis under Caligula", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00603-00141889-00142243": "37 to 41 was the first open break", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00604-00142244-00142561": "between Rome and the Jews meanwhile the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00605-00142562-00142756": "keido's war led to the destruction of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00606-00142757-00142942": "Jewish communities in Crete and North", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00607-00142943-00143272": "Africa in 117 C II and consequently the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00608-00143273-00143476": "dispersal of Jews already living outside", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00609-00143477-00143677": "of Judea to further reaches of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00610-00143678-00143905": "Empire Jerusalem had been left in ruins", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00611-00143906-00144184": "from the time of Vespasian 60 years", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00612-00144185-00144379": "later Hadrian who had been instrumental", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00613-00144380-00144586": "in the expulsion from Palestine of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00614-00144587-00144763": "Marcius turbo' after his bloody", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00615-00144764-00144982": "repression of Jews in the Diaspora in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00616-00144983-00145297": "117 C II on visiting the area of Ayodhya", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00617-00145298-00145552": "decided to rebuilt the city in 130 seee", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00618-00145553-00145786": "and settle it circumstantial evidence", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00619-00145787-00145972": "suggesting it was he who renamed it ela", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00620-00145973-00146176": "Capitolina with a Roman Colonia and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00621-00146177-00146398": "foreign cults it is commonly held that", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00622-00146399-00146572": "this was done as an insult to the Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00623-00146573-00146767": "and as a means of erasing the land s", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00624-00146768-00147046": "Jewish identity other argued that this", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00625-00147047-00147295": "project was expressive of an intention", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00626-00147296-00147523": "of establishing administratively and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00627-00147524-00147736": "culturally affirm Roman Imperial", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00628-00147737-00147931": "presence and thus incorporate the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00629-00147932-00148222": "province now called sciro Palestina into", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00630-00148223-00148522": "the Roman world system these political", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00631-00148523-00148738": "measures were according to Menachem more", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00632-00148739-00148978": "devoid of any intention to eliminate", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00633-00148979-00149248": "Judaism indeed the pagan reframing of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00634-00149249-00149497": "Jerusalem may have been a strategic move", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00635-00149498-00149731": "designed to challenge rather the growing", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00636-00149732-00149944": "threat pretensions an influence of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00637-00149945-00150154": "converts to Christianity for whom", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00638-00150155-00150412": "Jerusalem was likewise a crucial symbol", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00639-00150413-00150703": "of their faith implementation of these", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00640-00150704-00150955": "plans led to violent opposition and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00641-00150956-00151162": "triggered a full-scale insurrection with", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00642-00151163-00151645": "the revolt led by Bar Kochba 132 to 136", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00643-00151646-00152005": "EE assisted according to do Casius by", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00644-00152006-00152230": "some other people's perhaps Arabs who", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00645-00152231-00152475": "had recently been subjected by Trajan", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00646-00152476-00152734": "Jews were forbidden entrance to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00647-00152735-00152977": "Jerusalem on pain of death except for", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00648-00152978-00153313": "the day of Tisha B Avenue there was a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00649-00153314-00153514": "further shift of the center of religious", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00650-00153515-00153745": "authority from yagna as rabbis regrouped", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00651-00153746-00153952": "in Asia in the Western Galilee where the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00652-00153953-00154225": "Mishnah was composed this band struck a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00653-00154226-00154438": "blow at Jewish national identity within", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00654-00154439-00154633": "Palestine while the Romans however", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00655-00154634-00154816": "continued to allow Jews in the Diaspora", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00656-00154817-00155056": "their distinct national and religious", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00657-00155057-00155233": "identity throughout the empire the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00658-00155234-00155470": "military defeats of the Jews in Judea in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00659-00155471-00155785": "70 CE II and again in 135 CE II with", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00660-00155786-00156001": "thousands sold into slavery meant a drop", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00661-00156002-00156217": "in Palestine Jewish population was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00662-00156218-00156430": "balanced by a rise in diaspora numbers", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00663-00156431-00156667": "these slaves and their children were", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00664-00156668-00156874": "eventually manumitted and joined local", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00665-00156875-00157132": "free communities it has been argued that", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00666-00157133-00157300": "the archaeological evidence is", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00667-00157301-00157498": "suggestive of a Roman genocide taking", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00668-00157499-00157722": "place during the second revolt a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00669-00157723-00157951": "significant movement of Gentiles and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00670-00157952-00158155": "Samaritans into villages formerly with a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00671-00158156-00158344": "Jewish majority appears to have taken", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00672-00158345-00158832": "place thereafter", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00673-00158833-00159099": "topic post Roman period Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00674-00159100-00159528": "populations", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00675-00159529-00159873": "topic during the Middle Ages due to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00676-00159874-00160083": "increasing geographical dispersion and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00677-00160084-00160305": "resettlement Jews divided into distinct", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00678-00160306-00160449": "regional groups which today are", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00679-00160450-00160629": "generally addressed according to two", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00680-00160630-00160836": "primary geographical groupings the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00681-00160837-00161055": "Ashkenazi of northern and eastern europe", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00682-00161056-00161286": "and the Sephardic Jews of Iberia Spain", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00683-00161287-00161490": "and Portugal North Africa and the Middle", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00684-00161491-00161739": "East these groups have parallel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00685-00161740-00161901": "histories sharing many cultural", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00686-00161902-00162090": "similarities as well as a series of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00687-00162091-00162342": "massacres persecutions and expulsion 'z", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00688-00162343-00162588": "such as the expulsion from Spain in 1492", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00689-00162589-00162891": "the expulsion from England in 1290 and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00690-00162892-00163073": "the expulsion from Arab countries in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00691-00163074-00163479": "1948 to 1973 although the two branches", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00692-00163480-00163673": "comprised many unique ethno-cultural", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00693-00163674-00163908": "practices and have links to their local", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00694-00163909-00164100": "host populations such as central", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00695-00164101-00164277": "Europeans for the Ashkenazim and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00696-00164278-00164490": "Hispanics and Arabs for the Sephardic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00697-00164491-00164685": "their shared religion and ancestry as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00698-00164686-00164886": "well as their continuous communication", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00699-00164887-00165078": "and population transfers has been", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00700-00165079-00165279": "responsible for a unified sense of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00701-00165280-00165447": "cultural and religious Jewish identity", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00702-00165448-00165702": "between safar demand Ashkenazim from the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00703-00165703-00166107": "late roman period to the present by 1764", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00704-00166108-00166392": "there were about 750,000 Jews in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00705-00166393-00166641": "Polish Lithuanian Commonwealth the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00706-00166642-00166881": "worldwide Jewish population comprising", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00707-00166882-00167034": "the Middle East and the rest of Europe", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00708-00167035-00167525": "was estimated at 1.2 million", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00709-00167526-00168192": "topic classic period jews and samaritans", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00710-00168193-00168630": "topic the Jews Hebrew yo DM yahudim also", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00711-00168631-00168792": "known as the Jewish people are an", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00712-00168793-00168975": "ethno-religious group who mainly traced", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00713-00168976-00169170": "their origins to the ancient Israelites", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00714-00169171-00169317": "of the Levant as well as other", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00715-00169318-00169620": "contributory people's populations the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00716-00169621-00169827": "Samaritans consider themselves to be the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00717-00169828-00170001": "remaining population of the Northern", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00718-00170002-00170196": "Kingdom of Israel who were not expelled", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00719-00170197-00170382": "during the ten tribes exile and who", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00720-00170383-00170532": "joined with the incoming Assyrian", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00721-00170533-00170712": "populations to form the Samaritan", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00722-00170713-00171009": "community some biblical scholars also", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00723-00171010-00171168": "consider that parts of the Judean", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00724-00171169-00171348": "population had stayed to live in their", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00725-00171349-00171543": "homes during the Exile ik period and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00726-00171544-00171720": "later joined the returning Israelites", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00727-00171721-00171921": "from Babylon and formed the Jews of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00728-00171922-00172224": "classic and Hasmonean era after the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00729-00172225-00172542": "Persian conquest of Babylon in 539 BCE", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00730-00172543-00172797": "Judah Hebrew yebda Yehuda became a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00731-00172798-00173055": "province of the Persian Empire this", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00732-00173056-00173241": "status continued into the following", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00733-00173242-00173451": "Hellenistic period when yahood became a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00734-00173452-00173691": "disputed province of Ptolemaic Egypt and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00735-00173692-00173964": "Seleucid Syria in the early part of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00736-00173965-00174225": "second century BCE a revolt against the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00737-00174226-00174435": "Seleucids led to the establishment of an", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00738-00174436-00174606": "independent Jewish Kingdom under the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00739-00174607-00174927": "Hasmonean dynasty the Hasmoneans adopted", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00740-00174928-00175134": "a deliberate policy of imitating and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00741-00175135-00175335": "reconstituting the Davidic Kingdom and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00742-00175336-00175530": "as part of this forcibly converted to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00743-00175531-00175698": "Judaism their neighbors in the Land of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00744-00175699-00175944": "Israel the conversions included", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00745-00175945-00176181": "Nabataeans zaba Dean's and eat Orient's", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00746-00176182-00176361": "the peoples of the former Philistine", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00747-00176362-00176568": "cities the millah bites ammonites and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00748-00176569-00176841": "attempts were also made to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00749-00176842-00177024": "incorporate the Samaritans following", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00750-00177025-00177294": "takeover of say Maria the success of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00751-00177295-00177513": "mass conversions as however questionable", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00752-00177514-00177702": "as most groups retained their tribal", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00753-00177703-00177852": "separations and mostly turned", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00754-00177853-00178053": "Hellenistic or Christian with", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00755-00178054-00178227": "perhaps being the only exception to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00756-00178228-00178407": "merge into the Jewish society under", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00757-00178408-00178587": "Herodian dynasty and in the following", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00758-00178588-00178881": "period of jewish roman wars while there", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00759-00178882-00179046": "are some references to maintaining the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00760-00179047-00179253": "tribal separation among Israelites", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00761-00179254-00179472": "during the Hasmonean period the dominant", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00762-00179473-00179658": "position of the tribe of Judah as well", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00763-00179659-00179904": "as nationalistic policies of Hasmoneans", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00764-00179905-00180135": "to refer to residents of Hasmonean Judea", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00765-00180136-00180348": "as Jews practically erased a tribal", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00766-00180349-00180516": "distinction with the exception of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00767-00180517-00180729": "priestly orders of Levites and Kohanim", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00768-00180730-00180946": "tribe of Levi", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00769-00180947-00181198": "the Babylonian Jewish community though", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00770-00181199-00181362": "maintaining permanent ties with the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00771-00181363-00181575": "Hasmonean and later Herodian kingdoms", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00772-00181576-00181798": "evolved into a separate Jewish community", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00773-00181799-00181969": "which during the Talmudic period", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00774-00181970-00182136": "assembled its own practices the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00775-00182137-00182349": "Babylonian Talmud slightly differing", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00776-00182350-00182637": "from the Jerusalem Talmud the Babylonian", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00777-00182638-00182848": "jury is considered to be the predecessor", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00778-00182849-00183328": "of most Me's rahi Jewish communities", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00779-00183329-00183828": "topic Middle Ages", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00780-00183829-00184177": "topic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00781-00184178-00184699": "topic Ashkenazi Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00782-00184700-00185059": "topic Ashkenazi Jews as a general", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00783-00185060-00185260": "category of Jewish populations who", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00784-00185261-00185446": "immigrated to what is now Germany in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00785-00185447-00185614": "northeastern France during the Middle", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00786-00185615-00185818": "Ages and until modern times used to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00787-00185819-00185974": "adhere to the Yiddish culture in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00788-00185975-00186252": "Ashkenazi prayer style there is evidence", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00789-00186253-00186453": "that groups of Jews had immigrated to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00790-00186454-00186520": "Germania", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00791-00186521-00186676": "during the Roman era there were probably", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00792-00186677-00186883": "merchants who followed the Roman legions", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00793-00186884-00187147": "during their conquests to a larger", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00794-00187148-00187369": "degree modern Ashkenazi Jews are the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00795-00187370-00187570": "descendants of Jews who migrated into", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00796-00187571-00187768": "northern France and lower Germany around", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00797-00187769-00188062": "800 1000 CE II later migrating into", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00798-00188063-00188241": "Eastern Europe as well as local", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00799-00188242-00188521": "Europeans who intermixed with Jews many", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00800-00188522-00188754": "Ashkenazi Jews are also descended from", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00801-00188755-00188998": "Sephardi Jews exiled from Spain first", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00802-00188999-00189247": "during Islamic persecutions 11th 12th", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00803-00189248-00189439": "centuries and later during Christian", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00804-00189440-00189721": "reconquest s-- 1315 centuries in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00805-00189722-00189937": "Spanish Inquisition fifteen sixteenth", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00806-00189938-00190251": "centuries in this sense the modern term", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00807-00190252-00190578": "Ashkenazi refers to a subset of Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00808-00190579-00190803": "religious practices adopted over time", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00809-00190804-00191032": "rather than to a strict ethno geographic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00810-00191033-00191233": "division which became erased over time", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00811-00191234-00191674": "in 2006 a study by Doron Behar and Carl", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00812-00191675-00191869": "sketchy of the Technion and rambin", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00813-00191870-00192039": "Medical Center in Haifa Israel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00814-00192040-00192262": "demonstrated that the vast majority of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00815-00192263-00192511": "Ashkenazi Jews both men and women have", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00816-00192512-00192769": "middle-eastern ancestry according to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00817-00192770-00192993": "Nicholas Wade's 2010 autosomal study", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00818-00192994-00193234": "Ashkenazi Jews share a common ancestry", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00819-00193235-00193468": "with other Jewish groups and Ashkenazi", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00820-00193469-00193653": "and Sephardi Jews have roughly 30", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00821-00193654-00193864": "percent European ancestry with the rest", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00822-00193865-00194125": "being Middle Eastern according to hammer", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00823-00194126-00194364": "the Ashkenazi population expanded", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00824-00194365-00194608": "through a series of bottlenecks events", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00825-00194609-00194794": "that squeeze a population down to small", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00826-00194795-00195031": "numbers perhaps as it migrated from the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00827-00195032-00195216": "Middle East after the destruction of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00828-00195217-00195460": "Second Temple in 70 CE II to Italy", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00829-00195461-00195631": "reaching the Rhine Valley in the 10th", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00830-00195632-00195934": "century David Goldstein a Duke", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00831-00195935-00196144": "University geneticist and director of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00832-00196145-00196321": "the Duke Center for human genome", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00833-00196322-00196519": "variation has said that the work of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00834-00196520-00196726": "Technion and rambin team served only to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00835-00196727-00196900": "confirm that genetic drift played a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00836-00196901-00197103": "major role in shaping Ashkenazi", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00837-00197104-00197422": "mitochondrial DNA mtDNA which is", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00838-00197423-00197631": "inherited in a matrilineal manner", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00839-00197632-00197884": "Goldstein argues that the Technion and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00840-00197885-00198040": "rambin MTD and ace", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00841-00198041-00198211": "studies failed to actually establish a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00842-00198212-00198400": "statistically significant link between", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00843-00198401-00198631": "modern Jews and historic middle-eastern", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00844-00198632-00198883": "populations this differs from the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00845-00198884-00199105": "patrilineal case where Goldstein said", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00846-00199106-00199243": "there is no doubt of a middle-eastern", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00847-00199244-00199597": "origin in June 2010 Behar at all shows", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00848-00199598-00199798": "that most Jewish samples form a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00849-00199799-00200041": "remarkably tight sub cluster with common", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00850-00200042-00200275": "genetic origin that overlays Druze and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00851-00200276-00200536": "Cypriot samples but not samples from", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00852-00200537-00200764": "other Levantine populations or paired", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00853-00200765-00201133": "diaspora host populations in contrast", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00854-00201134-00201451": "Ethiopian Jews beta Israel and Indian", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00855-00201452-00201739": "Jews been a Israel and cuchini cluster", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00856-00201740-00201886": "with neighboring autochthonous", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00857-00201887-00202138": "populations in Ethiopia and western", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00858-00202139-00202375": "India respectively despite a clear", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00859-00202376-00202570": "paternal link between the Bene Israel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00860-00202571-00202885": "and the Levant the most parsimonious", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00861-00202886-00203194": "explanation for these observations as a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00862-00203195-00203401": "common genetic origin which is", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00863-00203402-00203566": "consistent with an historical", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00864-00203567-00203779": "formulation of the Jewish people as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00865-00203780-00203971": "descending from ancient Hebrew and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00866-00203972-00204231": "Israelite residents of the Levant in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00867-00204232-00204475": "conclusion the author's are stating that", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00868-00204476-00204685": "the genetic results are concordant with", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00869-00204686-00204873": "the dispersion of the people of ancient", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00870-00204875-00205155": "Israel throughout the old world", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00871-00205156-00205402": "regarding the samples he used Behar", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00872-00205403-00205657": "points out that our conclusion favoring", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00873-00205658-00205917": "common ancestry of Jewish people over", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00874-00205919-00206155": "recent admixture as further supported by", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00875-00206156-00206356": "the fact that our sample contains", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00876-00206357-00206554": "individuals that are known not to be", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00877-00206555-00206766": "admixed in the most recent one or two", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00878-00206767-00207007": "generations", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00879-00207008-00207352": "a 2013 study of Ashkenazi mitochondrial", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00880-00207353-00207571": "DNA by Kosta at all reached the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00881-00207571-00207771": "conclusion that the four major female", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00882-00207773-00207964": "founders and most of the minor female", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00883-00207965-00208141": "founders had ancestry in prehistoric", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00884-00208142-00208348": "Europe rather than the Near East or", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00885-00208348-00208609": "caucus according to the study these", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00886-00208610-00208819": "findings point to a significant role for", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00887-00208819-00208984": "the conversion of women in the formation", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00888-00208985-00209137": "of Ashkenazi communities", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00889-00209138-00209542": "a study by Haber at all 2013 noted that", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00890-00209542-00209748": "while previous studies of the Levant", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00891-00209750-00209983": "which had focused mainly on diaspora", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00892-00209984-00210321": "Jewish populations showed that the Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00893-00210323-00210523": "form a distinctive cluster in the Middle", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00894-00210523-00210573": "East", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00895-00210575-00210867": "these studies did not make clear whether", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00896-00210869-00211054": "the factors driving this structure would", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00897-00211055-00211252": "also involve other groups in the Levant", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00898-00211253-00211521": "quote dot the authors found strong", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00899-00211523-00211780": "evidence that modern Levant populations", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00900-00211781-00211981": "descend from two major apparent", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00901-00211982-00212344": "ancestral populations one set of genetic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00902-00212344-00212548": "characteristics which is shared with", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00903-00212548-00212800": "modern-day Europeans and Central Asians", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00904-00212801-00213092": "as most prominent in the Levant amongst", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00905-00213094-00213406": "Lebanese Armenians Cypriots Druze and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00906-00213407-00213655": "Jews as well as Turks Iranians and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00907-00213656-00213931": "Caucasian populations quote dot the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00908-00213932-00214135": "second set of inherited genetic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00909-00214136-00214306": "characteristics has shared with", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00910-00214307-00214537": "populations in other parts of the Middle", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00911-00214538-00214815": "East as well as some African populations", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00912-00214816-00215083": "Levant populations in this category", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00913-00215084-00215434": "today include Palestinians Jordanians", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00914-00215435-00215662": "Syrians as well as North Africans", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00915-00215663-00215979": "Ethiopians Saudis and Bedouins quote dot", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00916-00215980-00216214": "concerning this second component of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00917-00216215-00216442": "ancestry the authors remarked that while", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00918-00216442-00216721": "it correlates with the pattern of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00919-00216721-00217071": "Islamic expansion and that a pre Islamic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00920-00217073-00217282": "expansion Levant was more genetically", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00921-00217283-00217459": "similar to Europeans than to Middle", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00922-00217460-00217729": "Easterners they also say that its", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00923-00217730-00217978": "presence in Lebanese Christians Sephardi", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00924-00217979-00218191": "and Ashkenazi Jews Cypriots and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00925-00218192-00218386": "Armenians might suggest that it spread", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00926-00218387-00218569": "to the Levant could also represent an", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00927-00218569-00218844": "earlier event the authors also found a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00928-00218846-00219052": "strong correlation between religion and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00929-00219053-00219376": "apparent ancestry in the Levant all Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00930-00219377-00219613": "Sephardi and Ashkenazi cluster in one", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00931-00219614-00219814": "branch Druze from Mount Lebanon and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00932-00219815-00220006": "Druze from Mount Carmel are depicted on", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00933-00220007-00220219": "a private branch and Lebanese Christians", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00934-00220219-00220390": "form a private branch with the Chris", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00935-00220391-00220615": "in populations of Armenia and Cyprus", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00936-00220616-00220813": "placing the Lebanese Muslims as an outer", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00937-00220814-00221027": "group the predominantly Muslim", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00938-00221028-00221302": "populations of Syrians Palestinians and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00939-00221303-00221502": "Jordanians cluster on branches with", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00940-00221503-00221716": "other Muslim populations as distant as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00941-00221717-00221855": "Morocco and Yemen", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00942-00221856-00222231": "another 2013 study made by Doron M Behar", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00943-00222232-00222415": "of the Rambam healthcare campus in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00944-00222416-00222601": "Israel and others suggests that", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00945-00222602-00222930": "cumulatively our analyses point strongly", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00946-00222931-00223216": "to ancestry of Ashkenazi Jews primarily", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00947-00223217-00223394": "from European and Middle Eastern", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00948-00223396-00223669": "populations and not from populations in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00949-00223669-00223971": "or near the Caucasus region the combined", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00950-00223973-00224200": "set of approaches suggests that the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00951-00224201-00224481": "observations of Ashkenazi proximity to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00952-00224482-00224737": "European and Middle Eastern populations", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00953-00224738-00225021": "in population structure analyses reflect", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00954-00225023-00225306": "actual genetic proximity of Ashkenazi", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00955-00225307-00225521": "Jews to populations with predominantly", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00956-00225523-00225790": "European and Middle Eastern ancestry", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00957-00225791-00225969": "components and lack of visible", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00958-00225971-00226158": "introgression from the region of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00959-00226159-00226444": "hazhar khaganate particularly among the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00960-00226444-00226619": "northern Volga and North Caucasus", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00961-00226621-00227298": "populations into the Ashkenazi community", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00962-00227300-00227812": "topic Sephardic Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00963-00227813-00228147": "topic Sephardi Jews are Jews whose", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00964-00228148-00228374": "ancestors lived in Spain or Portugal", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00965-00228375-00228712": "some 300,000 Jews resided in Spain", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00966-00228713-00228903": "before the Spanish Inquisition in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00967-00228904-00229109": "15th century when the Reyes católicos", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00968-00229110-00229339": "reconquered Spain from the Arabs and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00969-00229340-00229476": "ordered the Jews to convert to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00970-00229477-00229674": "Catholicism leave the country or face", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00971-00229675-00229959": "execution without trial those who chose", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00972-00229960-00230187": "not to convert between 40,000 and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00973-00230188-00230469": "100,000 were expelled from Spain in 1492", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00974-00230471-00230735": "in the wake of the Alhambra decree", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00975-00230736-00231019": "Sephardic Jews subsequently migrated to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00976-00231019-00231249": "North Africa Maghreb Christian Europe", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00977-00231250-00231463": "Netherlands Britain France and Poland", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00978-00231464-00231667": "throughout the Ottoman Empire and even", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00979-00231667-00231862": "the newly discovered Latin America in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00980-00231863-00232162": "the Ottoman Empire the Sephardic mostly", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00981-00232163-00232344": "settled in the European portion of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00982-00232346-00232554": "Empire and mainly in the major cities", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00983-00232555-00232808": "such as Istanbul 'selenic and Bursa", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00984-00232809-00233010": "'selenic which is today known as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00985-00233011-00233215": "thessaloniki and found in modern-day", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00986-00233216-00233400": "greece had a large and flourishing", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00987-00233401-00233607": "Sephardic community as was the community", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00988-00233608-00233934": "of Maltese Jews in Malta a small number", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00989-00233935-00234159": "of Sephardic refugees who fled via the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00990-00234160-00234381": "Netherlands as Murano settled in Hamburg", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00991-00234382-00234606": "and altona Germany in the early 16th", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00992-00234607-00234804": "century eventually appropriating", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00993-00234805-00234999": "Ashkenazic Jewish rituals into their", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00994-00235000-00235281": "religious practice one famous figure", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00995-00235282-00235509": "from the Sephardic Ashkenazic population", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00996-00235510-00235800": "is glockl of Haman some relocated to the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00997-00235801-00236058": "United States establishing the country s", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00998-00236059-00236331": "first organized community of Jews and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-00999-00236332-00236577": "erecting the United States first", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01000-00236578-00236829": "synagogue nevertheless the majority of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01001-00236830-00237033": "Sephardic remained in Spain and Portugal", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01002-00237034-00237246": "as conversos which would also be the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01003-00237247-00237420": "fate for those who had migrated to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01004-00237421-00237606": "Spanish and Portuguese ruled Latin", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01005-00237607-00237916": "America Sephardic Jews evolved to form", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01006-00237917-00238074": "most of North Africa's Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01007-00238075-00238291": "communities of the modern era as well as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01008-00238292-00238524": "the bulk of the turkish-syrian Galilean", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01009-00238525-00238714": "and Jerusalemite Jews of the ottoman", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01010-00238715-00239086": "period", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01011-00239087-00239517": "pick Mizrahi Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01012-00239517-00239898": "topic mizrahi jews are jews descended", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01013-00239898-00240048": "from the jewish communities of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01014-00240048-00240213": "Middle East Central Asia and the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01015-00240214-00240417": "Caucasus largely originating from the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01016-00240417-00240630": "Babylonian jury of the classic period", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01017-00240631-00240930": "the term Mizrahi is used in Israel in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01018-00240931-00241148": "the language of politics media and some", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01019-00241150-00241365": "social scientists for Jews from the Arab", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01020-00241366-00241569": "world and adjacent primarily Muslim", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01021-00241569-00241839": "majority countries the definition of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01022-00241840-00242082": "Mizrahi includes the modern Iraqi Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01023-00242083-00242355": "Syrian Jews Lebanese Jews Persian Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01024-00242356-00242642": "Afghan Jews Bukhari and Jews Kurdish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01025-00242644-00242979": "Jews Mountain Jews George and Jews some", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01026-00242980-00243207": "also include the North African Sephardic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01027-00243208-00243408": "communities and Yemenite Jews under the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01028-00243409-00243621": "definition of Mizrahi but do that from", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01029-00243621-00243819": "rather political generalization than", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01030-00243819-00244178": "ancestral reasons", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01031-00244179-00244673": "topic Yemenite Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01032-00244675-00244998": "topic tamanna' more Jews who were living", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01033-00244998-00245210": "in Yemen prior to immigrating to Ottoman", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01034-00245211-00245523": "Palestine in Israel their Geographic and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01035-00245523-00245723": "social isolation from the rest of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01036-00245725-00245919": "Jewish community over the course of many", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01037-00245919-00246098": "centuries allowed them to develop a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01038-00246100-00246284": "liturgy and set of practices that are", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01039-00246285-00246467": "significantly distinct from those of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01040-00246469-00246644": "other oriental Jewish groups they", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01041-00246646-00246828": "themselves comprised three distinctly", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01042-00246829-00246987": "different groups though the distinction", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01043-00246988-00247184": "is one of religious law and liturgy", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01044-00247185-00247458": "rather than of ethnicity traditionally", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01045-00247459-00247634": "the genesis of the Yemenite Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01046-00247635-00247779": "community came after the Babylonian", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01047-00247780-00248046": "exile though the community most probably", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01048-00248046-00248246": "emerged during Roman times and it was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01049-00248248-00248417": "significantly reinforced during the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01050-00248419-00248609": "reign of do new juez in the 6th century", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01051-00248610-00248862": "CE II and during later Muslim conquests", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01052-00248863-00249083": "in the 7th century CE II which drove the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01053-00249084-00249553": "Arab Jewish tribes out of central Arabia", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01054-00249554-00250069": "topic carry taeju's", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01055-00250069-00250407": "topic Kraemer jews who used to live", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01056-00250408-00250656": "mostly in egypt iraq and Crimea during", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01057-00250657-00250896": "the Middle Ages they are distinguished", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01058-00250898-00251067": "by the form of Judaism which they", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01059-00251069-00251283": "observe rabbinic Jews of varying", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01060-00251284-00251454": "communities have affiliated with the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01061-00251455-00251604": "Kerry T community throughout the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01062-00251605-00251914": "millennia as such Kerry T Jews are less", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01063-00251915-00252081": "an ethnic division than they are members", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01064-00252082-00252378": "of a particular branch of Judaism Kerry", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01065-00252379-00252628": "T Judaism recognizes the Tanakh as the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01066-00252629-00252796": "single religious authority for the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01067-00252796-00253087": "Jewish people linguistic principles and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01068-00253088-00253327": "contextual exegesis are used in arriving", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01069-00253328-00253481": "at the correct meaning of the Torah", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01070-00253482-00253758": "carry t Jews strive to adhere to the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01071-00253759-00253966": "plain or most obvious understanding of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01072-00253967-00254227": "the text when interpreting the Tanakh by", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01073-00254228-00254484": "contrast rabbinical Judaism regards an", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01074-00254485-00254701": "oral law codified and recorded in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01075-00254702-00254896": "Mishnah and the Talmud as being equally", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01076-00254896-00255146": "binding on Jews and mandated by God in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01077-00255148-00255453": "rabbinical Judaism the Oral Law forms", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01078-00255454-00255660": "the basis of religion morality and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01079-00255661-00255994": "Jewish life carry T Jews rely on the use", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01080-00255994-00256189": "of sound reasoning and the application", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01081-00256190-00256371": "of linguistic tools to determine the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01082-00256373-00256528": "correct meaning of the Tanakh while", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01083-00256529-00256710": "rabbinical Judaism looks towards the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01084-00256711-00256917": "oral law codified in the Talmud to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01085-00256919-00257077": "provide the Jewish community with an", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01086-00257078-00257244": "accurate understanding of the Hebrew", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01087-00257246-00257544": "Scriptures the differences between care", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01088-00257546-00257773": "et and rabbinic Judaism go back more", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01089-00257773-00258069": "than a thousand years rabbinical Judaism", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01090-00258071-00258244": "originates from the Pharisees of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01091-00258244-00258357": "Second Temple period", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01092-00258358-00258613": "carroty Judaism may have its origins", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01093-00258614-00258798": "among the Sadducees of the same era", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01094-00258798-00259090": "carry T Jews hold the entire Hebrew", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01095-00259091-00259344": "Bible to be a religious authority as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01096-00259346-00259560": "such the vast majority of care aides", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01097-00259561-00259746": "believe in the resurrection of the Dead", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01098-00259746-00260028": "carry T Jews are widely regarded as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01099-00260029-00260194": "being halacha Clee Jewish by the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01100-00260194-00260508": "Orthodox Rabbinate similarly members of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01101-00260509-00260679": "the rabbinic community are considered", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01102-00260680-00260880": "Jews by the motuhake mean if they are", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01103-00260881-00261273": "patrilineal a Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01104-00261273-00261764": "topic modern era", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01105-00261765-00262108": "topic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01106-00262109-00262610": "topic Israeli Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01107-00262611-00262952": "topic Jews of Israel comprise an", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01108-00262953-00263159": "increasingly mixed wide range of Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01109-00263160-00263363": "communities making Aliyah from Europe", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01110-00263364-00263552": "North Africa and elsewhere in the Middle", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01111-00263553-00263822": "East while a significant portion of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01112-00263823-00264041": "Israeli Jews still retain memories of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01113-00264042-00264269": "their Sephardic Ashkenazi and Mizrahi", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01114-00264270-00264497": "origins mixed Jewish marriages among the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01115-00264498-00264740": "communities are very common there are", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01116-00264741-00264950": "also smaller groups of Yemenite Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01117-00264951-00265178": "Indian Jews and others who still retain", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01118-00265179-00265439": "a semi separate communal life there are", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01119-00265440-00265712": "also approximately 50,000 adherents of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01120-00265713-00265922": "charity Judaism most of whom live in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01121-00265923-00266129": "Israel but their exact numbers are not", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01122-00266130-00266315": "known because most care aides have not", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01123-00266316-00266534": "participated in any religious censuses", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01124-00266535-00266831": "the Bata Israel though somewhat disputed", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01125-00266832-00266969": "as the descendants of the ancient", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01126-00266970-00267167": "Israelites are widely recognized in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01127-00267168-00267593": "Israel as Ethiopian Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01128-00267594-00268097": "topic American Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01129-00268098-00268478": "topic the ancestry of most American Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01130-00268479-00268655": "goes back to Ashkenazi Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01131-00268656-00268882": "communities that immigrated to the US in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01132-00268883-00269054": "the course of the 19th and 20th", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01133-00269055-00269222": "centuries as well as more recent", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01134-00269223-00269458": "influxes of persian and other meze rahi", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01135-00269459-00269726": "Jewish immigrants the American Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01136-00269727-00269915": "community is considered to contain the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01137-00269916-00270098": "highest percentage of mixed marriages", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01138-00270099-00270334": "between Jews and non-jews resulting in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01139-00270335-00270506": "both increased assimilation and a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01140-00270507-00270728": "significant influx of non-jews becoming", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01141-00270729-00271004": "identified as Jews the most widespread", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01142-00271005-00271256": "practice in the US has reformed Judaism", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01143-00271257-00271502": "which doesn't require or see the Jews as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01144-00271503-00271721": "direct descendants of the ethnic Jews or", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01145-00271722-00271949": "biblical Israelites but rather adherents", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01146-00271950-00272123": "of the Jewish faith in its reformist", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01147-00272124-00272351": "version in contrast to Orthodox Judaism", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01148-00272352-00272594": "the mainstream practice in Israel which", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01149-00272595-00272753": "considers the Jews as a closed", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01150-00272754-00272932": "ethno-religious community with very", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01151-00272933-00273342": "strict procedures for conversion", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01152-00273343-00273833": "topic French Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01153-00273834-00274191": "topic the Jews of modern France number", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01154-00274192-00274421": "around 400 thousand persons largely", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01155-00274422-00274631": "descendants of North African communities", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01156-00274632-00274839": "some of which were Sephardic communities", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01157-00274840-00275012": "that had come from Spain and Portugal", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01158-00275013-00275285": "others were Arab and Berber Jews from", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01159-00275286-00275519": "Algeria Morocco and Tunisia who were", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01160-00275520-00275699": "already living in North Africa before", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01161-00275700-00275897": "the Jewish exodus from the Iberian", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01162-00275898-00276155": "Peninsula into a smaller degree members", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01163-00276156-00276368": "of the Ashkenazi Jewish communities who", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01164-00276369-00276853": "survived world war ii in the Holocaust", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01165-00276854-00277345": "topic mountain Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01166-00277346-00277687": "topic mountain Jews are Jews from the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01167-00277688-00277846": "eastern and northern slopes of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01168-00277847-00278101": "Caucasus mainly Azerbaijan chechnya and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01169-00278102-00278353": "dagestan they are the descendants of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01170-00278354-00278808": "Persian Jews from Iran", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01171-00278809-00279287": "topic boo car and juice", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01172-00279288-00279649": "topic Lucar and jews are an ethnic group", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01173-00279650-00279788": "from central asia who historically", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01174-00279789-00280067": "practiced judaism and spoke bukhari a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01175-00280068-00280595": "dialect of the Tajik persian language", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01176-00280596-00281041": "topic - Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01177-00281042-00281392": "topic the Chi thong Jews are members of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01178-00281393-00281607": "a small Jewish community in Chi Fung in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01179-00281608-00281788": "the Henan Province of China who have", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01180-00281789-00281995": "assimilated into Chinese society while", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01181-00281996-00282172": "preserving some Jewish traditions and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01182-00282173-00282482": "customs", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01183-00282483-00282978": "topic Cochin Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01184-00282979-00283365": "topic coach and Jews also called malabar", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01185-00283366-00283569": "Jews are the oldest group of Jews in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01186-00283570-00283734": "India with possible roots that are", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01187-00283735-00283917": "claimed to date back to the time of King", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01188-00283918-00284193": "Solomon the Cochin Jews settled in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01189-00284194-00284394": "kingdom of Cochin in South India now", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01190-00284395-00284667": "part of the state of Kerala as early as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01191-00284668-00284865": "the 12th century mentioned is made of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01192-00284866-00285120": "the black Jews in southern India the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01193-00285121-00285297": "Jewish traveller Benjamin of Tudela", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01194-00285298-00285567": "speaking of colum Keelan on the Malabar", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01195-00285568-00285957": "Coast writes in his itinerary throughout", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01196-00285958-00286161": "the island including all the towns", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01197-00286162-00286430": "thereof live several thousand Israelites", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01198-00286431-00286728": "the inhabitants are all black and the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01199-00286729-00286980": "Jews also the latter are good and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01200-00286981-00287229": "benevolent they know the law of Moses", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01201-00287230-00287427": "and the prophets and to a small extent", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01202-00287428-00287627": "the Talmud and halachah", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01203-00287628-00287886": "these people later became known as the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01204-00287887-00288162": "Malabar ejuice they built synagogues in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01205-00288163-00288336": "Kerala beginning in the 12th and 13th", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01206-00288337-00288588": "centuries they are known to have", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01207-00288589-00288840": "developed Judea Malayalam a dialect of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01208-00288841-00289212": "the Malayalam language", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01209-00289213-00289730": "topic paradesi juice", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01210-00289731-00290072": "topic paradesi jews are mainly the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01211-00290073-00290252": "descendants of Sephardic Jews who", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01212-00290253-00290432": "originally emigrated to India from", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01213-00290433-00290648": "sepharad Spain and Portugal during the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01214-00290649-00290906": "15th and 16th centuries in order to flee", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01215-00290907-00291119": "forced conversion or persecution in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01216-00291120-00291278": "wake of the Alhambra decree which", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01217-00291279-00291521": "expelled the Jews from Spain they are", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01218-00291522-00291701": "sometimes referred to as white Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01219-00291702-00291878": "although that usage is generally", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01220-00291879-00292070": "considered pejorative or discriminatory", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01221-00292071-00292259": "and it is instead used to refer to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01222-00292260-00292481": "relatively recent Jewish immigrants end", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01223-00292482-00292697": "of the 15th century onwards who are", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01224-00292698-00292904": "predominantly Sephardic the paradesi", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01225-00292905-00293075": "Jews of Cochin are a community of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01226-00293076-00293312": "Sephardic Jews whose ancestors settled", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01227-00293313-00293534": "among the larger Cochin Jewish community", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01228-00293535-00293750": "located in Kerala a coastal southern", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01229-00293751-00293966": "state of India the paradesi Jews of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01230-00293967-00294128": "Madras traded in diamonds precious", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01231-00294129-00294350": "stones and corals they had very good", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01232-00294351-00294518": "relations with the rulers of golconda", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01233-00294519-00294728": "they maintained trade connections with", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01234-00294729-00294896": "Europe and their language skills were", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01235-00294897-00295154": "useful although the Sephardic spoke", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01236-00295155-00295436": "Ladino ie Spanish her judeo-spanish in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01237-00295437-00295613": "India they learned to speak Tamil in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01238-00295614-00296140": "Judea Malayalam from the Malabar Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01239-00296141-00296596": "topic George and juice", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01240-00296597-00296938": "topic the georgian jews are considered", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01241-00296939-00297139": "ethnically and culturally distinct from", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01242-00297140-00297376": "neighboring mountain Jews they were also", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01243-00297377-00297582": "traditionally a highly separate group", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01244-00297583-00298038": "from the Ashkenazi Jews in Georgia", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01245-00298039-00298514": "topic Krim Jax", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01246-00298515-00298820": "topic the crimp Jack's are Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01247-00298821-00299029": "ethno-religious communities of Crimea", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01248-00299030-00299240": "derived from turkic-speaking adherents", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01249-00299241-00299611": "of Orthodox Judaism", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01250-00299612-00300065": "topic a news them", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01251-00300066-00300380": "topic during the history of the Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01252-00300381-00300596": "Diaspora Jews who lived in Christian", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01253-00300597-00300782": "Europe were often attacked by the local", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01254-00300783-00300956": "Christian population and they were often", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01255-00300957-00301244": "forced to convert to Christianity many", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01256-00301245-00301576": "known as the Newseum forced ones", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01257-00301577-00301859": "continued practicing Judaism in secret", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01258-00301860-00302024": "while living outwardly as ordinary", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01259-00302025-00302243": "Christians the best known in uzum", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01260-00302244-00302426": "communities were the Jews of Spain and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01261-00302427-00302579": "the Jews of Portugal although they", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01262-00302580-00302801": "existed throughout Europe in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01263-00302802-00303014": "centuries since the rise of Islam many", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01264-00303015-00303206": "Jews living in the Muslim world were", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01265-00303207-00303368": "forced to convert to Islam", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01266-00303369-00303566": "such as the Mashhadi Jews of Persia who", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01267-00303567-00303788": "continued to practice Judaism in secret", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01268-00303789-00304052": "and eventually moved to Israel many of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01269-00304053-00304211": "the UH newsome's descendants left", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01270-00304212-00304472": "judaism over the years the results of a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01271-00304473-00304673": "genetic study of the population of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01272-00304674-00304895": "Iberian Peninsula released in December", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01273-00304896-00305180": "2008 attest to a high level of religious", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01274-00305181-00305420": "conversion whether voluntary or enforced", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01275-00305421-00305612": "driven by historical episodes of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01276-00305613-00305774": "religious intolerance which ultimately", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01277-00305775-00305945": "led to the integration of the UH", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01278-00305946-00306309": "Newsom's descendants", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01279-00306310-00306823": "topic modern Samaritans", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01280-00306824-00307177": "topic the Samaritans who comprised a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01281-00307178-00307399": "comparatively large group in classical", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01282-00307400-00307717": "times now number 745 people and today", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01283-00307718-00307888": "they live in two communities in Israel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01284-00307889-00308104": "and the West Bank and they still regard", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01285-00308105-00308283": "themselves as descendants of the tribes", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01286-00308284-00308488": "of Ephraim named by them as a frame and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01287-00308489-00308715": "Manasseh named by them as Manoj", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01288-00308716-00308947": "Samaritans adhere to a version of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01289-00308948-00309142": "Torah known as the Samaritan Pentateuch", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01290-00309143-00309337": "which differs in some respects from the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01291-00309338-00309556": "Masoretic text sometimes in important", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01292-00309557-00309809": "ways unless affirmed the Septuagint the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01293-00309810-00310045": "Samaritans consider themselves bnei", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01294-00310046-00310438": "yisrael children of Israel or Israelites", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01295-00310439-00310666": "but they do not regard themselves as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01296-00310667-00310990": "yahudim Jews they view the term Jews as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01297-00310991-00311251": "a designation for followers of Judaism", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01298-00311252-00311460": "which they assert as a related but an", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01299-00311461-00311647": "altered and amended religion which was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01300-00311648-00311839": "brought back by the exiled Israelite", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01301-00311840-00312031": "returnees and is therefore not the true", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01302-00312032-00312232": "religion of the ancient Israelites which", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01303-00312233-00312634": "according to them as samaritan ism", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01304-00312635-00313135": "topic genetic studies", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01305-00313136-00313513": "topic Y DNA studies tend to imply a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01306-00313514-00313693": "small number of founders in an old", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01307-00313694-00313882": "population whose members parted and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01308-00313883-00314082": "followed different migration paths in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01309-00314083-00314386": "most Jewish populations these male line", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01310-00314387-00314569": "ancestors appear to have been mainly", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01311-00314570-00314872": "middle-eastern for example Ashkenazi", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01312-00314873-00315103": "Jews share more common paternal lineages", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01313-00315104-00315241": "with other Jewish and Middle Eastern", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01314-00315242-00315490": "groups than with non-jewish populations", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01315-00315491-00315691": "in areas where Jews lived in Eastern", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01316-00315692-00315862": "Europe Germany and the French Rhine", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01317-00315863-00316129": "Valley this is consistent with Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01318-00316130-00316312": "traditions which place most Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01319-00316313-00316498": "paternal origins in the region of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01320-00316499-00316804": "Middle East conversely the maternal", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01321-00316805-00317041": "lineages of Jewish populations studied", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01322-00317042-00317272": "by looking at mitochondrial DNA are", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01323-00317273-00317569": "generally more heterogeneous scholars", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01324-00317570-00317791": "such as Harry Oscar and Raphael Fock", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01325-00317792-00317995": "believed this indicates that many Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01326-00317996-00318202": "males found new mates from European and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01327-00318203-00318388": "other communities in the places where", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01328-00318389-00318568": "they migrated in the diaspora after", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01329-00318569-00318892": "fleeing ancient Israel in contrast Behar", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01330-00318893-00319132": "has found evidence that about 40% of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01331-00319133-00319375": "Ashkenazi Jews originate maternally from", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01332-00319376-00319567": "just four female founders who were of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01333-00319568-00319855": "Middle Eastern origin the populations of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01334-00319856-00320074": "Sephardi and Mizrahi Jewish communities", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01335-00320075-00320332": "showed no evidence for a narrow founder", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01336-00320333-00320629": "effect subsequent studies carried out by", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01337-00320630-00320863": "Feder at all confirmed the large portion", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01338-00320864-00321067": "of the non-local maternal origin among", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01339-00321068-00321340": "Ashkenazi Jews reflecting on their", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01340-00321341-00321556": "findings related to the maternal origin", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01341-00321557-00321790": "of Ashkenazi Jews the authors conclude", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01342-00321791-00322054": "clearly the differences between Jews and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01343-00322055-00322282": "non-jews are far larger than those", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01344-00322283-00322503": "observed among the Jewish communities", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01345-00322504-00322780": "hence differences between the Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01346-00322781-00322963": "communities can be overlooked when", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01347-00322964-00323268": "non-jews are included in the comparisons", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01348-00323269-00323575": "studies of autosomal DNA which look at", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01349-00323576-00323782": "the entire DNA mixture have become", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01350-00323783-00323989": "increasingly important as the technology", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01351-00323990-00324205": "develops they show that Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01352-00324206-00324373": "populations have tended to form", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01353-00324374-00324583": "relatively closely related groups in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01354-00324584-00324793": "independent communities with most people", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01355-00324794-00324976": "in a community sharing significant", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01356-00324977-00325204": "ancestry in common for Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01357-00325205-00325384": "populations of the Diaspora", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01358-00325385-00325572": "the genetic composition of Ashkenazi", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01359-00325573-00325867": "Sephardi and Mizrahi Jewish populations", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01360-00325868-00326038": "show a predominant amount of shared", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01361-00326039-00326299": "middle-eastern ancestry according to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01362-00326300-00326530": "Behar the most parsimonious explain", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01363-00326531-00326755": "for this shared middle-eastern ancestry", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01364-00326756-00326959": "is that it is consistent with the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01365-00326960-00327178": "historical formulation of the Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01366-00327179-00327418": "people as descending from ancient Hebrew", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01367-00327419-00327633": "and Israelite residents of the Levant", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01368-00327634-00327970": "and the dispersion of the people of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01369-00327971-00328245": "ancient Israel throughout the old world", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01370-00328246-00328540": "North African Italian and others of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01371-00328541-00328783": "iberian origin show variable frequencies", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01372-00328784-00329011": "of admixture with non-jewish historical", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01373-00329012-00329200": "host populations among the maternal", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01374-00329201-00329464": "lines in the case of Ashkenazi and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01375-00329465-00329704": "Sephardi Jews in particular Moroccan", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01376-00329705-00329917": "Jews who are closely related the source", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01377-00329918-00330106": "of non-jewish admixture as mainly", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01378-00330107-00330319": "southern European while Mizrahi Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01379-00330320-00330508": "show evidence of admixture with other", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01380-00330509-00330679": "Middle Eastern populations and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01381-00330680-00331012": "sub-saharan Africans Behar at all have", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01382-00331013-00331153": "remarked on an especially close", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01383-00331154-00331378": "relationship of Ashkenazi Jews and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01384-00331379-00331651": "modern Italians Jews were found to be", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01385-00331652-00331843": "more closely related to groups in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01386-00331844-00332002": "north of the Fertile Crescent Kurds", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01387-00332003-00332239": "Turks and Armenians than to Arabs the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01388-00332240-00332422": "studies also showed that persons of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01389-00332423-00332620": "Sephardic Binet and Newsom origin those", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01390-00332621-00332887": "who are descendants of the ANU 'sm who", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01391-00332888-00333016": "were forced to convert to Catholicism", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01392-00333017-00333271": "throughout today's Iberia Spain and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01393-00333272-00333508": "Portugal in ibero-america Hispanic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01394-00333509-00333733": "America and Brazil estimated that up to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01395-00333734-00333943": "19 point 8 percent of the modern", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01396-00333944-00334228": "population of Iberia and at least 10% of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01397-00334229-00334447": "the modern population of ibero-america", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01398-00334448-00334672": "has Sephardic Jewish ancestry within the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01399-00334673-00334981": "last few centuries the Bene Israel and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01400-00334982-00335215": "the Cochin Jews of India beta Israel of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01401-00335216-00335416": "Ethiopia and a portion of the lembeh", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01402-00335417-00335614": "people of southern Africa meanwhile", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01403-00335615-00335806": "despite more closely resembling the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01404-00335807-00335959": "local populations of their native", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01405-00335960-00336151": "countries also have some more remote", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01406-00336152-00336624": "ancient Jewish descent", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01407-00336625-00337338": "topic Zionist negation of the Diaspora", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01408-00337339-00337695": "topic according to Eliezer sweet the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01409-00337696-00337899": "rejection of life in the Diaspora as a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01410-00337900-00338079": "central assumption in all currents of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01411-00338080-00338358": "Zionism underlying this attitude was the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01412-00338359-00338571": "feeling that the diaspora restricted the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01413-00338572-00338853": "full growth of Jewish national life for", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01414-00338854-00339063": "instance the poet Higham Naaman Bialik", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01415-00339064-00339366": "wrote according to Swede Bialik meant", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01416-00339367-00339648": "that de-seed was the potential of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01417-00339649-00339894": "Jewish people preserved in the Diaspora", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01418-00339895-00340044": "this seed could only give rise to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01419-00340045-00340305": "deformed results however once conditions", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01420-00340306-00340470": "change the seed could still provide a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01421-00340471-00340683": "plentiful harvest in this matter Stern", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01422-00340684-00340839": "hull distinguishes two schools of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01423-00340840-00341112": "thought in Zionism one was the liberal", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01424-00341113-00341331": "or utilitarian school of Theodore Herzl", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01425-00341332-00341631": "and max Mordo especially after the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01426-00341632-00341778": "Dreyfus Affair they held that", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01427-00341779-00342000": "anti-semitism would never disappear and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01428-00342001-00342186": "they saw Zionism as a rational solution", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01429-00342187-00342519": "for Jewish individuals the other was the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01430-00342520-00342738": "organic nationalist school it was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01431-00342739-00342930": "prevalent among the Zionist olam and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01432-00342931-00343101": "they saw the movement as a project to", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01433-00343102-00343284": "rescue the Jewish nation rather than as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01434-00343285-00343467": "a project to only rescue Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01435-00343468-00343761": "individuals for them Zionism was the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01436-00343762-00344049": "rebirth of the nation contrary to the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01437-00344050-00344247": "negation of the Diaspora view the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01438-00344248-00344436": "acceptance of Jewish communities outside", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01439-00344437-00344679": "Israel was postulated by those like", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01440-00344680-00344922": "Simon Ravi de vich also a Zionist who", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01441-00344923-00345084": "viewed the Jews as a culture which had", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01442-00345085-00345405": "evolved into a new worldly entity that", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01443-00345406-00345582": "had no reason to seek an exclusive", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01444-00345583-00345807": "return either physical emotional or", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01445-00345808-00346008": "spiritual to its indigenous lands and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01446-00346009-00346164": "who believed that the Jews could remain", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01447-00346165-00346482": "one people even outside Israel it was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01448-00346483-00346674": "argued that the dynamics of the Diaspora", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01449-00346675-00346887": "which were affected by persecution", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01450-00346888-00347136": "numerous subsequent exiles as well as by", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01451-00347137-00347358": "political and economic conditions had", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01452-00347359-00347544": "created a new Jewish awareness of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01453-00347545-00347748": "world and a new awareness of the Jews by", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01454-00347749-00347982": "the world in effect there are many", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01455-00347983-00348192": "Zionists today who do not embrace the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01456-00348193-00348525": "negation of the Diaspora as any kind of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01457-00348526-00348723": "absolute and who see no conflict and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01458-00348724-00348933": "even a beneficial and worldly and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01459-00348934-00349242": "positive symbiosis between a diaspora of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01460-00349243-00349404": "healthy self-respecting Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01461-00349405-00349575": "communities such as those which have", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01462-00349576-00349794": "evolved in the United States Canada and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01463-00349795-00350004": "several other Western countries and a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01464-00350005-00350229": "vital and evolving Israeli society and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01465-00350230-00350612": "State of Israel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01466-00350613-00351188": "topic Mystikal explanation", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01467-00351189-00351601": "topic Rabbi tzvi ulema lack of de nob", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01468-00351602-00351896": "Bonet Accenture Hodesh Kislev 2:25", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01469-00351897-00352067": "explains that each exile was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01470-00352068-00352249": "characterized by a different negative", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01471-00352250-00352552": "aspect the Babylonian exile was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01472-00352553-00352750": "characterized by physical suffering and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01473-00352751-00353039": "oppression the Babylonians were lopsided", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01474-00353040-00353246": "towards the Saphira of guevara strength", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01475-00353247-00353557": "and bodily might the Persian exile was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01476-00353558-00353803": "one of emotional temptation the Persians", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01477-00353804-00353966": "were hedonists who declared that the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01478-00353967-00354175": "purpose of life is to pursue indulgence", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01479-00354176-00354433": "and lusts let us eat and drink for", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01480-00354434-00354587": "tomorrow we may die", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01481-00354588-00354826": "they were lopsided towards the quality", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01482-00354827-00355075": "of chesed attraction and kindness albeit", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01483-00355076-00355408": "to the self Hellenistic civilization was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01484-00355409-00355568": "highly cultured and sophisticated", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01485-00355569-00355783": "although the Greeks had a strong sense", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01486-00355784-00355981": "of aesthetics they were highly pompous", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01487-00355982-00356155": "and they viewed aesthetics as an end in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01488-00356156-00356206": "itself", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01489-00356207-00356441": "they were excessively attached to the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01490-00356442-00356707": "quality of Tiferet beauty this was also", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01491-00356708-00356881": "related to an appreciation of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01492-00356882-00357062": "intellects transcendence over the body", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01493-00357063-00357271": "which reveals the beauty of the spirit", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01494-00357272-00357590": "the Exile of Adam began with Rome whose", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01495-00357591-00357767": "culture lacked any clearly defined", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01496-00357768-00358027": "philosophy rather it adopted the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01497-00358028-00358207": "philosophies of all the preceding", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01498-00358208-00358423": "cultures causing Roman culture to be in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01499-00358424-00358530": "a constant flux", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01500-00358531-00358814": "although the Roman Empire has fallen the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01501-00358815-00359015": "Jews are still in the Exile of Adam and", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01502-00359016-00359222": "indeed one can find this phenomenon of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01503-00359223-00359425": "ever changing trends dominating modern", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01504-00359426-00359687": "Western society the Romans and the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01505-00359688-00359891": "various nations who inherited their rule", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01506-00359892-00360197": "eg the Holy Roman Empire the Europeans", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01507-00360198-00360400": "the Americans are lopsided towards", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01508-00360401-00360631": "mal'chik sovereignty the lowest Saphira", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01509-00360632-00360805": "which can be received from any of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01510-00360806-00360995": "others and can act as a medium for them", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01511-00360996-00361196": "the Jewish fast day of Tisha B'Av", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01512-00361197-00361348": "commemorates the destruction of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01513-00361349-00361555": "first and second temples in Jerusalem", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01514-00361556-00361735": "and the subsequent exile of the Jews", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01515-00361736-00361975": "from the land of Israel the Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01516-00361976-00362197": "tradition maintains that the Roman exile", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01517-00362198-00362366": "would be the last and that after the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01518-00362367-00362530": "people of Israel returned to their land", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01519-00362531-00362806": "they would never be exiled again this", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01520-00362807-00362983": "statement is based on the verse you", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01521-00362984-00363232": "paying for your sin is over daughter of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01522-00363233-00363695": "Zion he will not exile you any more tm-1", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01523-00363696-00364015": "beat Zanelli aus block", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01524-00364016-00364193": "you", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01525-00364194-00364779": "topic in Christian theology", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01526-00364780-00365136": "topic according to our own Oppenheimer", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01527-00365137-00365352": "the concept of the exile beginning after", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01528-00365353-00365532": "the destruction of the second Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01529-00365533-00365748": "temple was developed by early Christians", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01530-00365749-00365943": "who saw the destruction of the temple as", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01531-00365944-00366153": "a punishment for Jewish deicide and by", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01532-00366154-00366330": "extension as an affirmation of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01533-00366331-00366534": "Christians as God's new chosen people or", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01534-00366535-00366864": "the new Israel and actually in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01535-00366865-00367041": "period that followed the destruction of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01536-00367042-00367314": "the temple Jews had many freedoms the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01537-00367315-00367518": "people of Israel had religious economic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01538-00367519-00367770": "and cultural autonomy and the Bar Kochba", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01539-00367771-00368007": "revolt demonstrated the unity of Israel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01540-00368008-00368196": "and their political military power at", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01541-00368197-00368469": "that time therefore according to our own", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01542-00368470-00368676": "Oppenheimer it should be noted that the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01543-00368677-00368895": "Jewish exile only started after the Bar", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01544-00368896-00369075": "Kochba revolt which devastated the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01545-00369076-00369345": "Jewish community of Judea despite", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01546-00369346-00369534": "popular conception Jews have had a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01547-00369535-00369705": "continuous presence in the land of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01548-00369706-00369942": "Israel despite the exile of the majority", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01549-00369943-00370167": "of Judeans the Jerusalem Talmud was", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01550-00370168-00370362": "signed in the 4th century hundreds of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01551-00370363-00370629": "years after the revolt moreover many", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01552-00370630-00370857": "Jews remained in Israel even centuries", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01553-00370858-00371037": "later including during the Byzantine", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01554-00371038-00371244": "period many remnants of synagogues are", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01555-00371245-00371484": "found from this period Jews have been a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01556-00371485-00371721": "majority or a significant plurality in", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01557-00371722-00371913": "Jerusalem in the millennia since their", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01558-00371914-00372129": "exile with few exceptions including the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01559-00372130-00372336": "period following the siege of Jerusalem", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01560-00372337-00372624": "1099 by the Crusaders in the 18 years of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01561-00372625-00372816": "Jordanian occupation of Eastern", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01562-00372817-00373044": "Jerusalem in which Jerusalem's historic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01563-00373045-00373486": "Jewish quarter was expelled", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01564-00373487-00373792": "topic historical comparison of Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01565-00373793-00374202": "population", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01566-00374203-00374607": "topic a carrot Austria Czech Republic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01567-00374608-00374997": "Slovenia be carried Albania Iraq Jordan", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01568-00374998-00375417": "Lebanon Macedonia Syria Turkey see", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01569-00375418-00375843": "carrot Croatia Hungary Slovakia D carrot", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01570-00375844-00376071": "Baltic States Estonia Latvia Lithuania", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01571-00376072-00376455": "Belarus Moldova Russia including Siberia", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01572-00376456-00376812": "Ukraine II carrot Caucasus Armenia", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01573-00376813-00377052": "Azerbaijan Georgia Central Asia", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01574-00377053-00377325": "Kazakhstan Kyrgyzstan Tajikistan", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01575-00377326-00377894": "Turkmenistan Uzbekistan", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01576-00377895-00378331": "topic today", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01577-00378332-00378727": "topic as of 2010 the largest numbers of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01578-00378728-00378961": "jews live in israel five million seven", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01579-00378962-00379132": "hundred three thousand seven hundred", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01580-00379133-00379363": "united states five million two hundred", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01581-00379364-00379591": "seventy five thousand france four", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01582-00379592-00379750": "hundred eighty three thousand five", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01583-00379751-00380101": "hundred canada 375,000 the united", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01584-00380102-00380323": "kingdom two hundred sixty nine thousand", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01585-00380324-00380491": "to two hundred ninety two thousand", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01586-00380492-00380791": "russia two hundred five thousand - 1.5", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01587-00380792-00381037": "million argentina one hundred eighty two", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01588-00381038-00381232": "thousand three hundred germany one", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01589-00381233-00381523": "hundred nineteen thousand and brazil 107", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01590-00381524-00381784": "thousand three hundred twenty-nine these", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01591-00381785-00382060": "numbers reflect the core jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01592-00382061-00382150": "population", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01593-00382151-00382387": "defined as being not inclusive of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01594-00382388-00382651": "non-jewish members of Jewish households", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01595-00382652-00382906": "persons of Jewish ancestry who profess", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01596-00382907-00383152": "another monotheistic religion other non", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01597-00383153-00383404": "Jews of Jewish ancestry and other non", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01598-00383405-00383620": "Jews who may be interested in Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01599-00383621-00383968": "matters significant Jewish populations", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01600-00383969-00384160": "also remain in Middle Eastern and North", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01601-00384161-00384376": "African countries outside of Israel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01602-00384377-00384667": "particularly Iran Turkey Morocco Tunisia", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01603-00384668-00385003": "and Yemen in general these populations", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01604-00385004-00385174": "are shrinking due to low growth rates", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01605-00385175-00385309": "and high rates of emigration", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01606-00385310-00385702": "particularly since the 1960's the Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01607-00385703-00385915": "autonomous Oblast continues to be an", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01608-00385916-00386197": "autonomous Oblast of Russia the chief", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01609-00386198-00386431": "rabbi of Birobidzhan Mordechai shiner", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01610-00386432-00386689": "says there are 4,000 Jews in the capital", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01611-00386690-00386742": "city", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01612-00386743-00387034": "governor Nicolae Mikhaylovich Volkov has", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01613-00387035-00387283": "stated that he intends to support every", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01614-00387284-00387496": "valuable initiative maintained by our", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01615-00387497-00387781": "local Jewish organizations the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01616-00387782-00388072": "Birobidzhan synagogue opened in 2004 on", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01617-00388073-00388267": "the 70th anniversary of the region's", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01618-00388268-00388699": "founding in 1934 an estimated 75,000", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01619-00388700-00388921": "Jews live in the vast Siberia region", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01620-00388922-00389131": "metropolitan areas with the largest", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01621-00389132-00389365": "Jewish populations are listed below the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01622-00389366-00389602": "one source at Jewish temples org states", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01623-00389603-00389797": "that it is difficult to come up with", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01624-00389798-00390019": "exact population figures on a", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01625-00390020-00390295": "country-by-country basis let alone city", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01626-00390296-00390610": "by city around the world figures for", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01627-00390611-00390820": "Russia and other sis countries are but", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01628-00390821-00391123": "educated guesses the source cited here", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01629-00391124-00391393": "the 2010 world jewish population survey", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01630-00391394-00391654": "also notes that unlike our estimates of", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01631-00391655-00391714": "Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01632-00391715-00391963": "populations in individual countries the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01633-00391964-00392176": "data reported here on urban Jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01634-00392177-00392409": "populations do not fully adjust for", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01635-00392410-00392626": "possible double counting due to multiple", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01636-00392627-00392931": "residences the differences in the United", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01637-00392932-00393196": "States may be quite significant in the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01638-00393197-00393418": "range of tens of thousands involving", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01639-00393419-00393801": "both major and minor metropolitan areas", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01640-00393802-00394090": "gosh Dan Tel Aviv and surroundings", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01641-00394091-00394332": "Israel two million nine hundred seventy", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01642-00394333-00394639": "nine thousand nine hundred new york city", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01643-00394640-00395137": "new york us two million 7850 jerusalem", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01644-00395138-00395460": "seven hundred five thousand los angeles", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01645-00395461-00395695": "california u.s. six hundred eighty four", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01646-00395696-00396006": "thousand nine hundred fifty Haifa Israel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01647-00396007-00396244": "six hundred seventy-one thousand four", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01648-00396245-00396558": "hundred Miami Florida us four hundred", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01649-00396559-00396816": "eighty five thousand eight hundred fifty", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01650-00396817-00397134": "bear Sheva Israel three hundred sixty", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01651-00397135-00397479": "seven thousand six hundred San Francisco", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01652-00397480-00397723": "California us three hundred forty five", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01653-00397724-00398105": "thousand seven hundred Paris France", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01654-00398106-00398502": "284,000 Chicago Illinois us two hundred", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01655-00398503-00398739": "seventy thousand five hundred", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01656-00398740-00399030": "Philadelphia Pennsylvania us two hundred", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01657-00399031-00399243": "sixty three thousand eight hundred", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01658-00399244-00399510": "Boston Massachusetts us two hundred", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01659-00399511-00399758": "twenty-nine thousand one hundred", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01660-00399759-00400075": "Washington DC us two hundred fifteen", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01661-00400076-00400366": "thousand six hundred London United", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01662-00400367-00400873": "Kingdom 195,000 Toronto Canada 180", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01663-00400874-00401212": "thousand Atlanta Georgia us one hundred", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01664-00401213-00401526": "nineteen thousand eight hundred Moscow", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01665-00401527-00401859": "Russia ninety five thousand San Diego", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01666-00401860-00402231": "California u.s. 89 thousand Cleveland", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01667-00402232-00402565": "Ohio us eighty seven thousand Phoenix", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01668-00402566-00402879": "Arizona us eighty two thousand nine", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01669-00402880-00403235": "hundred Montreal Canada eighty thousand", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01670-00403236-00403900": "South Paulo Brazil seventy-five thousand", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01671-00403901-00404421": "topic see also", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01672-00404422-00404808": "topic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01673-00404809-00405328": "topic references", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01674-00405329-00405717": "topic", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01675-00405718-00406254": "topic bibliography", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01676-00406255-00406608": "topic immigration to Israel from North", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01677-00406609-00406968": "America hits 22-year high CNS news.com", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01678-00406969-00407457": "December 30th 2005 Aviv Caron des sneer", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01679-00407458-00407814": "David 2005 new Jews the end of the", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01680-00407815-00408036": "Jewish Diaspora new york new york", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01681-00408037-00408369": "university press ISBN nine trillion", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01682-00408370-00408555": "seven hundred eighty billion eight", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01683-00408556-00408735": "hundred fourteen million seven hundred", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01684-00408736-00409122": "forty thousand one hundred seventy oclc", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01685-00409123-00409565": "sixty million three hundred twenty 1977", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01686-00409566-00409920": "Feldman Lewis H nineteen ninety some", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01687-00409921-00410185": "observations on the name of Palestine", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01688-00410187-00410507": "Hebrew Union College annual Hebrew Union", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01689-00410508-00410710": "College Jewish Institute of religion", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01690-00410712-00411038": "sixty one - one - 23", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01691-00411039-00411342": "JSTOR 23 million five hundred eight", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01692-00411343-00411666": "thousand one hundred seventy Jacobsen", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01693-00411667-00412030": "David 2001 when Palestine meant Israel", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01694-00412031-00412689": "Biblical Archaeology review 27 three", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01695-00412690-00413230": "topic external links", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01696-00413231-00413572": "topic jewish diaspora at the jewish", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01697-00413572-00413910": "encyclopedia come world jewish congress", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01698-00413912-00414110": "jewish communities", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01699-00414112-00414382": "research and articles about the diaspora", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01700-00414383-00414631": "experience and israel diaspora relations", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01701-00414632-00414853": "on the berman jewish policy archive at", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01702-00414854-00415234": "nyu wagner the diaspora and Israel rich", "W7Gd6spJQSE-01703-00415235-00415464": "Cohen"}}, {"audio_id": "W7XBcwcED9Y", "text": {"W7XBcwcED9Y-00000-00000003-00000269": "therefore it is time for question period", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00001-00000270-00000416": "the member from insemination", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00002-00000417-00000617": "Thank You speaker my question this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00003-00000618-00000770": "morning is for the acting premier", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00004-00000771-00000911": "speaker we know that the opposition", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00005-00000911-00001157": "parties think that the 4.6 million", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00006-00001158-00001406": "dollar compensation package for the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00007-00001407-00001679": "Hydra one CEO is too high we know that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00008-00001680-00001939": "the Ontario public thinks that the 4.6", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00009-00001941-00002165": "million dollars in salary for the CEO at", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00010-00002166-00002405": "Hydra one is too high we now know that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00011-00002406-00002708": "the Ontario Energy Board the OEB thinks", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00012-00002709-00002912": "that the 4.6 million dollar salary for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00013-00002913-00003142": "the CEO of Hydra one is too high but", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00014-00003143-00003476": "what we don't know speaker is do the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00015-00003477-00003722": "Liberals think that the 4.6 million", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00016-00003722-00004040": "dollar salary for the CEO of Hydra 1 is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00017-00004040-00004676": "too high some economic development", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00018-00004677-00004852": "growth Superguy I'm not sure why the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00019-00004853-00005084": "opposition have such a tough time", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00020-00005085-00005272": "understanding the role of the Ontario", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00021-00005273-00005660": "Energy Board I'm not so sure why they", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00022-00005661-00005888": "seem don't have it both ways when when", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00023-00005889-00006086": "the Ontario Energy Board makes a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00024-00006087-00006251": "decision that I think you know we all", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00025-00006252-00006436": "believe is in the public interest and do", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00026-00006437-00006673": "their job they want to criticize them", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00027-00006675-00006941": "then and then they they talk about the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00028-00006942-00007120": "Ontario Energy Board not having any role", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00029-00007122-00007352": "whatsoever in trying to lead consumers", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00030-00007353-00007810": "into thinking I'm I'm not going to be", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00031-00007811-00007978": "accepting those kinds of interjections", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00032-00007979-00008348": "so be warned well actually I shouldn't", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00033-00008349-00008705": "use that word until I want to do that be", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00034-00008706-00008924": "aware that I am NOT going to accept", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00035-00008925-00009284": "those in interjections you know I think", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00036-00009285-00009458": "they're trying to lead consumers into", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00037-00009459-00009610": "thinking somehow or another that the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00038-00009611-00009778": "government sets energy rates and it's", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00039-00009779-00009980": "not the Ontario Energy Board the unitary", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00040-00009981-00010127": "Energy Board has an important role to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00041-00010128-00010328": "play mr. speaker they're doing that role", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00042-00010329-00010487": "we're proud of the role that they're", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00043-00010488-00010603": "playing they're standing up for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00044-00010604-00010817": "observers as this government did when we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00045-00010818-00011024": "cut the energy rates by 25 percent", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00046-00011025-00011132": "Americans", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00047-00011133-00011352": "supplementary speaker perhaps the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00048-00011353-00011469": "minister didn't understand the question", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00049-00011470-00011676": "but the Ontario Energy Board has ruled", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00050-00011677-00012024": "that 4.6 million dollars is too high of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00051-00012025-00012296": "a salary for the CEO at Hydra 1 that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00052-00012297-00012555": "salary was handed to the CEO by this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00053-00012556-00012810": "premier and this Liberal government two", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00054-00012811-00013046": "years ago the premier tried to defend", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00055-00013047-00013281": "this outrageous salary by saying this is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00056-00013282-00013497": "what they pay in corporate America and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00057-00013497-00013803": "that's actually less than American", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00058-00013804-00014133": "Energy CEOs so 4.6 million dollars is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00059-00014134-00014286": "acceptable is what the premier said but", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00060-00014287-00014394": "I don't think the premier", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00061-00014394-00014628": "can still spin it that way given the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00062-00014629-00014969": "decision by the OEB in the last week", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00063-00014970-00015240": "that we're paying way too much for all", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00064-00015241-00015537": "of the executives at Hydra 1 it doesn't", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00065-00015538-00016016": "require spin mr. Minister speaker mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00066-00016018-00016254": "speaker do the Liberals think that a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00067-00016255-00016449": "four it's really simple to the Liberals", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00068-00016450-00016776": "think that a 4.6 million dollar salary", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00069-00016777-00017109": "for the CEO of Hydra 1 is too high thank", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00070-00017110-00017538": "you it's funny mr. speaker a party that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00071-00017539-00017757": "used to understand the importance of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00072-00017758-00018018": "putting private sector acumen into", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00073-00018019-00018210": "decision making and some of our agencies", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00074-00018211-00018474": "it now seems to want to go the exact", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00075-00018475-00018747": "opposite direction Hydra one is now a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00076-00018748-00019062": "publicly traded company our role mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00077-00019063-00019269": "speaker is to ensure that they have the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00078-00019270-00019503": "ability to provide the best possible", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00079-00019504-00019703": "level of service to the people of this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00080-00019704-00019917": "province taking advantage of that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00081-00019918-00020166": "private sector acumen and improving the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00082-00020167-00020361": "level of service and improving the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00083-00020362-00020580": "return to the people of this province of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00084-00020581-00020903": "that now publicly traded corporation we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00085-00020904-00021042": "believe that's going to be in the public", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00086-00021043-00021203": "interest we believe we're going to see", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00087-00021204-00021390": "and we're seeing improvements in our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00088-00021391-00021639": "energy system as a result of that and we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00089-00021640-00021819": "believe the Ontario Energy Board is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00090-00021820-00022035": "doing their role and performing it very", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00091-00022036-00022236": "well in ensuring that that public", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00092-00022237-00022494": "attention is to be served I'm not sure", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00093-00022495-00022758": "where the member finds that there is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00094-00022759-00022953": "some kind of problem with with what's", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00095-00022954-00023208": "going thank you final supplementary I'm", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00096-00023209-00023381": "reading between the lines here it seems", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00097-00023382-00023625": "like the Minister believes that a 4.6", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00098-00023626-00023831": "million dollar salary for the CEO of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00099-00023832-00024051": "Hydra 1 is acceptable and this Liberal", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00100-00024052-00024249": "government believes that a 4.6 million", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00101-00024250-00024387": "dollar salary", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00102-00024388-00024813": "the CEO is exact is acceptable and I can", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00103-00024814-00024966": "tell you that people across the province", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00104-00024967-00025245": "disagree with this Liberal government", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00105-00025246-00025527": "vociferous li disagree bill kelly from", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00106-00025528-00025749": "CH ml and hamilton put it pretty well i", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00107-00025750-00025986": "thought he said that the Ontario Energy", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00108-00025987-00026327": "Board recent decision slapped down Hydra", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00109-00026329-00026529": "one because they wanted ratepayers to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00110-00026530-00026655": "quote cover what they called", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00111-00026656-00026895": "administrative costs which is a sly way", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00112-00026895-00027123": "of saying that they wanted more money to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00113-00027124-00027395": "give increases to their already overpaid", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00114-00027397-00027795": "executives in fact in the OEB ruling", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00115-00027795-00028020": "they decided that the budget needed to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00116-00028020-00028335": "be cut by thirty thirty million dollars", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00117-00028336-00028566": "so mr. speaker why did it take for the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00118-00028567-00028860": "Ontario Energy Board and not the Liberal", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00119-00028861-00029061": "government to slap down these", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00120-00029062-00029673": "high-priced executives at Hydra one just", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00121-00029674-00029847": "because this is far from the first time", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00122-00029848-00030135": "that the Ontario Energy Board has asked", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00123-00030136-00030450": "one of the the energy agencies to reduce", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00124-00030451-00030752": "their rather their rate asks so the rate", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00125-00030754-00030981": "increase asks in fact it's very very", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00126-00030982-00031251": "normal it happened almost every single", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00127-00031252-00031530": "year in every single application and I", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00128-00031531-00031701": "can I can share with the member a list", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00129-00031702-00031889": "of dozens of times where this has", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00130-00031891-00032106": "happened the entire energy board's doing", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00131-00032107-00032241": "their job they're looking out for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00132-00032242-00032457": "consumers across this province this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00133-00032458-00032655": "government's doing our job by lowering", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00134-00032656-00032880": "energy rates across this province for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00135-00032881-00033147": "those very consumers Mr Speaker I asked", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00136-00033148-00033351": "the member opposite to do his job and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00137-00033352-00033564": "tell it like it is mr. speaker that the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00138-00033565-00033849": "Energy Board is simply doing what is in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00139-00033850-00034086": "their job procedurally to ensure that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00140-00034087-00034362": "consumers interests are looked after and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00141-00034363-00034527": "at the same time we have an energy", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00142-00034528-00034785": "system that is being answered on a daily", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00143-00034786-00034995": "basis by this new publicly traded", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00144-00034996-00035274": "company I think that's good news for the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00145-00035275-00035424": "entire province of course we remember", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00146-00035425-00035480": "from", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00147-00035481-00035720": "thank you and good morning speaker my", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00148-00035721-00035852": "questions for the Minister of Finance", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00149-00035853-00036101": "last month there were two legislative", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00150-00036102-00036311": "reports on the state of Ontario's", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00151-00036312-00036553": "finances they were described as", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00152-00036554-00036842": "blistering and scathing and those", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00153-00036843-00037049": "descriptions speaker are well deserved", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00154-00037050-00037904": "both of the legislators remember from", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00155-00037905-00038168": "beaches east shore come to order and as", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00156-00038169-00038402": "I indicated to both sides I'm not going", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00157-00038403-00038725": "to tolerate the end of interjections and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00158-00038726-00038936": "you'll see how quickly I'll deal with", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00159-00038937-00039275": "them if I have to continue both of the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00160-00039276-00039503": "legislative legislatures independent", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00161-00039504-00039737": "officers openly challenged the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00162-00039738-00040007": "ministry's credibility the financial", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00163-00040008-00040199": "accountability office said that the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00164-00040200-00040433": "minister is using quote unlikely", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00165-00040434-00040700": "assumptions quote to make his debt", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00166-00040701-00040955": "claims in fact they said that if any of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00167-00040956-00041168": "these wild assumptions fall short", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00168-00041169-00041362": "the government's targets would not be", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00169-00041363-00041582": "achieved they particularly took issue", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00170-00041583-00041726": "with the government's overly optimistic", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00171-00041727-00041969": "growth projections with speaker if the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00172-00041970-00042236": "FAO doesn't believe the minister's", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00173-00042237-00042506": "numbers why should the people of Ontario", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00174-00042507-00043102": "they don't mr. speaker economist", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00175-00043103-00043337": "independent of government across Canada", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00176-00043338-00043700": "has cited this Ontario is leading the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00177-00043701-00044111": "way in economic our country The", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00178-00044112-00044309": "Conference Board of Canada has cited", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00179-00044310-00044474": "that we've outperformed that had the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00180-00044475-00044882": "most transparent levels of reporting", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00181-00044883-00045179": "than any other government in Canada mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00182-00045180-00045308": "speaker this member opposite", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00183-00045309-00045656": "continuously degrades and and talks down", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00184-00045657-00045827": "the outstanding achievements of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00185-00045828-00046064": "Ontarians and businesses in our province", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00186-00046065-00046286": "that are creating wealth creating", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00187-00046287-00046540": "greater prosperity hiring more jobs and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00188-00046541-00046751": "the lowest unemployment of any part of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00189-00046752-00046996": "this country and we are overachieving", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00190-00046997-00047215": "every single year that we put forward", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00191-00047216-00047438": "our budgets to the benefit of Ontario's", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00192-00047439-00047780": "we've reduced the deficit to under 900", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00193-00047781-00047975": "million dollars mr. speaker just last", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00194-00047976-00048167": "year and we're going forward we're", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00195-00048168-00048362": "balancing the budget this year next year", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00196-00048363-00048577": "any raft", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00197-00048578-00048904": "so from us back to the minister", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00198-00048905-00049207": "the FAO s comments were strong enough", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00199-00049208-00049468": "but speaker the Auditor General painted", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00200-00049469-00049777": "an even more damning picture of the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00201-00049778-00050029": "minister's financial reporting for the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00202-00050030-00050248": "second year in a row the auditor", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00203-00050249-00050458": "wouldn't sign off on the provinces books", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00204-00050459-00050629": "without a big asterisk", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00205-00050630-00050871": "but the auditor went further stating", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00206-00050872-00051132": "flat-out that the statements are quote", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00207-00051133-00051480": "significantly misstated quote she says", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00208-00051482-00051777": "our deficit last year was 1.4 billion", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00209-00051778-00052026": "higher than claimed and our debt is a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00210-00052027-00052239": "whopping twelve point four billion", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00211-00052240-00052546": "higher she warned us and the markets and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00212-00052547-00052788": "investors that we need to be able to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00213-00052789-00053007": "rely on government's figures being", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00214-00053008-00053371": "accurate but this year they cannot do so", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00215-00053372-00053601": "that's her quote you cannot rely on", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00216-00053602-00053863": "their numbers is her quote speaker again", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00217-00053864-00054103": "we ask and I know there be large any", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00218-00054104-00054274": "audit or I can hear their comments again", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00219-00054275-00054622": "but we asked JJ and the FAO don't", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00220-00054623-00054760": "believe the minister's numbers why", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00221-00054761-00055044": "should we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00222-00055045-00055324": "business speaker investors around the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00223-00055325-00055591": "world believe our numbers the people of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00224-00055591-00055762": "Ontario throughout Canada who buy our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00225-00055763-00055978": "bonds believe our numbers we have a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00226-00055979-00056179": "highest liquidity of trading bonds of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00227-00056179-00056517": "any government across this continent in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00228-00056519-00056836": "fact and mr. speaker our debt to GDP has", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00229-00056837-00057004": "been reduced and it continues reduced", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00230-00057004-00057282": "below 37 percent again over achieving", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00231-00057283-00057567": "our targets our community deficits which", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00232-00057569-00057787": "is a representation of that historical", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00233-00057788-00058251": "activity of Ontario's budgets today mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00234-00058252-00058474": "speaker it's at around 27% the same as", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00235-00058475-00058840": "it was 25 years ago mr. speaker are our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00236-00058841-00059029": "interests on debt as a as a percentage", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00237-00059029-00059290": "of revenue today is 8% when he was in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00238-00059291-00059473": "power when the Progressive", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00239-00059474-00059613": "Conservatives were in power mr. speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00240-00059614-00059863": "it was 50% of our revenues we are", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00241-00059864-00060076": "overachieving and we continually do so", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00242-00060077-00060301": "we are using the same standards as we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00243-00060302-00060441": "always thought including when the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00244-00060442-00060712": "Auditor General has done even as but as", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00245-00060713-00060876": "recently as three years ago Thank You", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00246-00060877-00061003": "mr. speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00247-00061004-00061241": "thank you back to the ministers so if", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00248-00061241-00061479": "the minister is comfortable using quote", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00249-00061480-00061784": "significant misstatements and quote", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00250-00061785-00062017": "unlikely assumptions then it should be", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00251-00062019-00062210": "no surprise to hear what else he", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00252-00062211-00062465": "continues to claim they continue to say", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00253-00062466-00062759": "quote we're leading the g7 in economic", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00254-00062760-00063041": "growth but Ontario is not number one", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00255-00063041-00063449": "speaker there are 27 US states ahead of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00256-00063450-00063689": "us and the minister continues to claim", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00257-00063690-00063971": "that manufacturing exports are up but", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00258-00063972-00064204": "stats can just last week reported that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00259-00064205-00064490": "Ontario manufacturing sales suffered", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00260-00064491-00064696": "their largest decline in eight years", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00261-00064697-00064922": "here are some of the recent headings", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00262-00064923-00065279": "trade deteriorates exports languish", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00263-00065279-00065507": "Ontario residents hit hard by", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00264-00065508-00065804": "manufacturing downturn international", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00265-00065805-00066092": "merchandise exports fell manufacturing", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00266-00066093-00066311": "sales slip speaker given all these", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00267-00066312-00066554": "examples plus the financial stability", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00268-00066555-00066755": "officer and the Auditor General's", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00269-00066756-00067061": "criticism how can anyone trust anything", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00270-00067062-00067871": "or fifth government says thank you", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00271-00067872-00068171": "Minister mr. speaker facts do matter and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00272-00068172-00068338": "that's odd", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00273-00068339-00068699": "well we're there from now on we're going", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00274-00068700-00068882": "into the warnings of those interjections", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00275-00068883-00069029": "in the member from Renfrew Nipissing", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00276-00069030-00069434": "Pembroke come to order you brought us to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00277-00069435-00069614": "this point", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00278-00069615-00070067": "warnings are on finish mr. speaker facts", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00279-00070068-00070318": "matter this member opposite is citing", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00280-00070319-00070865": "sources remember from Leeds Granville is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00281-00070866-00071507": "warned carry on citing references from", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00282-00071508-00071764": "years past recognizing that as of today", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00283-00071765-00072053": "Ontario is ahead of the curve our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00284-00072054-00072206": "unemployment rate is the lowest it's", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00285-00072207-00072491": "been in 16 years at 5.7 percent and mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00286-00072492-00072644": "speaker that's not to say that we're not", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00287-00072645-00072803": "continuously looking at stimulating", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00288-00072804-00073039": "economic growth around all of Ontario", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00289-00073040-00073235": "recognising some regional disparities", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00290-00073236-00073457": "exists that member opposite and that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00291-00073458-00073685": "party voted against those measures that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00292-00073686-00073957": "improve prosperity stimulate growth and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00293-00073958-00074215": "continuously balance the book thank you", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00294-00074216-00074846": "new question remember from Oshawa my", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00295-00074847-00075029": "questions to the acting premier in my", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00296-00075030-00075151": "community of Oshawa", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00297-00075152-00075293": "I have constituents come into my office", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00298-00075294-00075470": "all the time to tell me about their long", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00299-00075471-00075767": "wait times in the ER Lakeridge Health", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00300-00075768-00075992": "Oshawa is no different than hospitals in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00301-00075993-00076232": "tilson Berg or Etobicoke or Brampton or", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00302-00076233-00076444": "Toronto or Peterborough which just", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00303-00076445-00076657": "announced that it will open 24 beds", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00304-00076658-00076868": "without help from this Liberal", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00305-00076869-00077044": "government just to try and keep up with", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00306-00077045-00077261": "a number of people who need care in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00307-00077262-00077579": "February of 2017 the occupancy rate of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00308-00077580-00077669": "Lakeridge Health", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00309-00077670-00078076": "Ottawa's acute care beds reached 92%", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00310-00078077-00078380": "does the premier have a plan to fix this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00311-00078381-00078560": "unhealthy mess that she's helped create", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00312-00078561-00078878": "in Oshawa", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00313-00078879-00079223": "good health and long term care care well", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00314-00079224-00079460": "thank you mr. speaker and of course", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00315-00079461-00079816": "unlike the party opposite that simply", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00316-00079817-00080225": "opposes all of the plans that we have", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00317-00080226-00080522": "for addressing capacity and wait time", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00318-00080523-00080788": "challenges across this province", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00319-00080789-00081076": "different than the party who opposed our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00320-00081077-00081311": "500 million dollar investments in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00321-00081312-00081587": "hospitals earlier this spring we do have", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00322-00081588-00081653": "a plan", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00323-00081654-00081869": "and with Lakeridge specifically and they", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00324-00081870-00082082": "are facing challenges because the member", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00325-00082083-00082310": "knows it's a rapidly growing area we've", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00326-00082311-00082490": "given them a planning grant so that they", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00327-00082491-00082783": "can actually plan not for today but also", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00328-00082784-00083030": "20-30 years into the future for that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00329-00083031-00083345": "entire region of Durham and and in fact", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00330-00083346-00083528": "we're doing the same in Scarborough mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00331-00083529-00083843": "speaker but for for Lakeridge itself", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00332-00083844-00084059": "specifically they're working together", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00333-00084060-00084302": "with Ontario shores to open up a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00334-00084303-00084545": "brand-new behavioral support unit which", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00335-00084546-00084869": "is sensor that we provided 20 beds for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00336-00084870-00085073": "ALC patients that have mental health", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00337-00085074-00085289": "needs mr. speaker so that they can", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00338-00085290-00085493": "decant those out-of-pocket up to a more", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00339-00085494-00085739": "appropriate set of supplementary Thank", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00340-00085740-00085909": "You speaker again to the acting premier", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00341-00085910-00086210": "Lakeridge Health in Whitby is also over", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00342-00086211-00086438": "capacity in February it reached a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00343-00086439-00086693": "hundred and two percent I would like to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00344-00086694-00086993": "remind the premier again that a maximum", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00345-00086994-00087221": "of 85 percent over capacity is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00346-00087222-00087434": "considered safe the premier has said", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00347-00087435-00087623": "over and over again that she makes", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00348-00087624-00087896": "decisions based on evidence well the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00349-00087897-00088094": "evidence that Ontario's hospitals are", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00350-00088095-00088238": "facing and overcrowding and hallway", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00351-00088239-00088412": "medicine crisis is out there the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00352-00088413-00088712": "evidence is piling up literally piling", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00353-00088713-00088916": "up in the hallways why is the premier", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00354-00088917-00089228": "refusing to act on the facts Thank You", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00355-00089229-00089528": "Minister well mr. speaker I'm gratified", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00356-00089529-00089750": "that the member opposite mentioned AJAX", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00357-00089751-00090008": "Pickering hospital because which is part", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00358-00090009-00090263": "of the Lakeridge Health Corporation mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00359-00090264-00090452": "speaker and Lakeridge Health received", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00360-00090453-00090581": "this year", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00361-00090582-00091100": "alone mr. speaker a 6.6 million dollar", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00362-00091101-00091385": "increase in their operating budget to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00363-00091386-00091619": "allow them to make modifications and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00364-00091620-00091760": "provide continue to provide that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00365-00091761-00091997": "high-quality care but also when it comes", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00366-00091998-00092173": "to AJAX Pickering and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00367-00092174-00092356": "staying in line with the discussion on", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00368-00092357-00092593": "mental health that specifically we're", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00369-00092594-00092926": "opening 20 new acute care mental health", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00370-00092927-00093229": "beds at the Ajax Pickering site as well", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00371-00093230-00093394": "in addition to what we're doing at", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00372-00093395-00093655": "Ontario shores so we're listening to the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00373-00093656-00093835": "local community we're listening to the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00374-00093836-00094021": "hospital leadership and we're making", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00375-00094022-00094216": "those multi-million dollar investments", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00376-00094217-00094462": "on the operating side and on the capital", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00377-00094463-00094651": "side mr. speaker to make sure that they", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00378-00094652-00094879": "are answered competently addressed with", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00379-00094880-00095109": "the highest quality service those", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00380-00095110-00095335": "particular needs mr. thank you final", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00381-00095336-00095587": "supplementary Thank You speaker again to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00382-00095588-00095830": "the acting premier in Oshawa as", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00383-00095831-00096118": "elsewhere it's not just acute care beds", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00384-00096119-00096319": "that are over capacity mental health", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00385-00096320-00096523": "beds are also locked in a constant state", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00386-00096524-00096739": "of gridlock both Lakeridge Health in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00387-00096740-00096898": "Oshawa and the Lakeridge facility in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00388-00096899-00097099": "Whitby registered capacity numbers in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00389-00097100-00097393": "their mental health beds of a hundred", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00390-00097394-00097756": "and fifteen percent last winter the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00391-00097757-00097996": "premier cannot defend this but can the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00392-00097997-00098160": "premier tell the people of my community", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00393-00098161-00098371": "when is help from this Liberal", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00394-00098372-00098763": "government coming Thank You Minister", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00395-00098764-00099007": "well I would hope that the member", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00396-00099008-00099190": "opposite would understand and believe", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00397-00099191-00099589": "that 40 brand-new beds for mental health", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00398-00099590-00099871": "20 of them for ALC patients that have", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00399-00099872-00100126": "specific mental health challenges 20", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00400-00100127-00100387": "acute which is through Ontario shores in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00401-00100388-00100648": "concert with Lakeridge site in Oshawa as", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00402-00100649-00100981": "well as 20 acute new beds at the Ajax", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00403-00100982-00101347": "site but mr. speaker the NDP in a single", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00404-00101348-00101752": "year in 1994 announced a 53 million", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00405-00101753-00102007": "dollar cut to ten of Ontario psychiatric", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00406-00102008-00102307": "hospitals that represented up to a 17", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00407-00102308-00102541": "percent cut in the operating budget of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00408-00102542-00102759": "some hospitals in Hamilton and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00409-00102760-00102928": "Brockville and Kingston and Thunder Bay", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00410-00102929-00103204": "of London North Bay penitentiary Anto", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00411-00103205-00103519": "st. Thomas and Whitby a 4.7 million", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00412-00103520-00103753": "dollar cut in Hamilton alone a five", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00413-00103754-00103999": "million dollar cut in Whitby alone mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00414-00104000-00104296": "speaker 6.3 million dollar in Kingston", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00415-00104297-00104433": "hurt and at the end", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00416-00104434-00104623": "and DP was forced to backtrack so", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00417-00104624-00104995": "instead of 53 million they only cut 20", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00418-00104996-00105201": "million killers in a single year mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00419-00105202-00105561": "speaker thank you no question the member", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00420-00105563-00106108": "from London Fanshawe yesterday the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00421-00106108-00106249": "Minister of Health said the vast", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00422-00106250-00106432": "majority of long-term care homes in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00423-00106433-00106606": "Ontario are meeting the provinces", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00424-00106607-00106858": "minimum standards of care set out in the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00425-00106858-00107025": "various acts that they that apply to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00426-00107026-00107214": "them but what the minister and the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00427-00107215-00107439": "premier failed to realize is it seems", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00428-00107440-00107654": "that it's that this is not good enough", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00429-00107655-00107886": "families with loved ones and care have", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00430-00107887-00108039": "been coming forward speaking up for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00431-00108040-00108220": "months to tell this Liberal government", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00432-00108221-00108421": "about the heartbreaking conditions in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00433-00108422-00108711": "some of these home care homes does the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00434-00108712-00108922": "premier not care what families are", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00435-00108923-00109191": "telling her or is he's just out of touch", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00436-00109192-00109393": "with what's really going on in this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00437-00109394-00110301": "province well mr. speaker the NDP", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00438-00110302-00110514": "continues to disparage not only our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00439-00110515-00110739": "hard-working frontline workers in long", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00440-00110740-00111053": "term cares across the province but also", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00441-00111054-00111358": "does not understand in fact that we are", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00442-00111358-00111556": "listening to Ontarians we are listening", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00443-00111557-00111757": "to residents of long-term care homes who", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00444-00111758-00112041": "call long term care homes their home mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00445-00112042-00112266": "speaker and we have an obligation and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00446-00112267-00112413": "responsibility that I take very", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00447-00112414-00112584": "seriously to ensure that we're providing", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00448-00112585-00112854": "the highest quality of care but I don't", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00449-00112855-00113071": "again I need to ask the question whether", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00450-00113072-00113264": "that party is going to vote for or", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00451-00113265-00113548": "against the new legislation that has", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00452-00113549-00113778": "just been proposed last week mr. speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00453-00113779-00113998": "that actually will increase our ability", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00454-00113999-00114256": "to further inspect homes will increase", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00455-00114257-00114465": "the penalties and fines available to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00456-00114466-00114649": "government to impose upon those", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00457-00114650-00114931": "non-compliers and give other powers to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00458-00114932-00115128": "the government so we can ensure that not", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00459-00115129-00115345": "only is the appliance with the act but", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00460-00115346-00115533": "this these homes mr. speaker of the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00461-00115534-00115710": "highest quality possible--", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00462-00115711-00115884": "thank you supplementary", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00463-00115885-00116168": "speaker this is what's happening in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00464-00116169-00116283": "long-term care", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00465-00116284-00116588": "seniors are being left in beds for 18", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00466-00116589-00116845": "hours getting a bath just once a week", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00467-00116846-00117056": "constant short staffing and lack of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00468-00117057-00117308": "consistency in care vulnerable seniors", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00469-00117308-00117518": "are not even getting the basic help they", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00470-00117519-00117716": "need to make it to the bathroom on time", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00471-00117717-00118055": "these are just a few of the thousands of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00472-00118056-00118274": "stories described to me in the past few", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00473-00118275-00118481": "months by families with loved ones and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00474-00118482-00118775": "care how can the premier continue to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00475-00118776-00119006": "claim that everything is fine in these", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00476-00119007-00119204": "homes when she hears from families", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00477-00119205-00119468": "themselves that there is a crisis", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00478-00119469-00120017": "happening right under her nose well", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00479-00120018-00120248": "thank you mr. speaker and that is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00480-00120249-00120511": "precisely why this week I issued three", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00481-00120513-00120866": "C's of admissions to long-term care", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00482-00120867-00121031": "homes in this province because they", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00483-00121032-00121232": "weren't complying with the Act because", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00484-00121233-00121421": "there were directors orders against", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00485-00121422-00121748": "those homes for issues such as a fall", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00486-00121749-00121943": "taking place in that fall not being", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00487-00121944-00122168": "reported to the proper clinical", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00488-00122169-00122383": "authorities the physician that would", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00489-00122384-00122611": "then do the proper assessment that these", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00490-00122613-00122857": "are important and critically important", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00491-00122858-00123092": "activities that need to be taken that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00492-00123093-00123257": "need to be done in adherence with the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00493-00123258-00123557": "Act but I'm also mr. speaker it's", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00494-00123558-00123722": "important also important to recognize", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00495-00123723-00123994": "that we're seeing that impact from our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00496-00123995-00124238": "inspections annual inspections of a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00497-00124239-00124418": "hundred percent of our long-term care", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00498-00124419-00124667": "homes and we're seeing that since 2014", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00499-00124668-00124936": "the average number of compliance orders", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00500-00124938-00125158": "issued during an annual inspection have", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00501-00125159-00125417": "actually observed down by more than 50", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00502-00125418-00125683": "percent we are seeing the improvement", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00503-00125684-00125903": "the inspections are working but we need", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00504-00125904-00126173": "to identify and act on those that are", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00505-00126174-00126385": "not in compliance thank you final", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00506-00126386-00126634": "supplementary speaker the three ceased", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00507-00126635-00126899": "admission orders in London Mississauga", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00508-00126900-00127159": "and Fergus are indicators their systemic", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00509-00127160-00127624": "systemic problems in long-term care", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00510-00127625-00127891": "Minister over and over again we have", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00511-00127892-00128074": "told the premier and her Minister of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00512-00128075-00128259": "Health the heartbreaking stories of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00513-00128260-00128508": "neglect and even abuse in long-term care", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00514-00128509-00128773": "homes over and over again we have called", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00515-00128774-00128947": "for the wet laugh required to be", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00516-00128948-00129159": "expanded so that we can get an honest", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00517-00129160-00129397": "picture of what's happening in long in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00518-00129398-00129607": "the long term care system identify the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00519-00129608-00129943": "systemic issues and fix them but over", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00520-00129944-00130126": "and over again the premier and her", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00521-00130127-00130330": "Minister have ducked our questions and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00522-00130331-00130558": "refused to expand inquiry that would", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00523-00130558-00130833": "help thousands of people they are", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00524-00130834-00131023": "content to ignore the problems in our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00525-00131024-00131257": "long-term care system can the premier", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00526-00131258-00131488": "tell us when will there be enough", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00527-00131489-00131770": "evidence for her to take this issue or", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00528-00131771-00132346": "seriously while Mr Speaker we are taking", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00529-00132347-00132505": "it seriously and we've been taking it", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00530-00132506-00132784": "seriously for a lot longer since the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00531-00132785-00133000": "member opposite and her party have been", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00532-00133001-00133213": "raising this in a partisan fashion and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00533-00133214-00133468": "fear-mongering among this across this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00534-00133469-00133648": "province so that people in their", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00535-00133649-00133810": "long-term care homes if they're afraid", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00536-00133811-00133951": "they don't need to be afraid of the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00537-00133952-00134119": "quality of care that they're receiving", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00538-00134120-00134353": "with a few exceptions mr. speaker that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00539-00134354-00134527": "we're addressing effectively they need", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00540-00134528-00134734": "to be afraid of what the NDP party is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00541-00134735-00134983": "doing in fear mongering and suggesting", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00542-00134984-00135154": "to Ontarians that let their loved ones", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00543-00135155-00135328": "are not safe in long-term care homes", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00544-00135329-00135574": "I think it's reprehensible I think it's", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00545-00135575-00136006": "completely inappropriate remember from", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00546-00136007-00136468": "London Fanshawe has warned finish please", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00547-00136469-00136696": "be inappropriate to be elevating it to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00548-00136697-00136942": "that level of conjecture and and fear", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00549-00136943-00137125": "mongering across this province mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00550-00137126-00137407": "speaker they believe in supporting the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00551-00137408-00137617": "long-term care sector why did they vote", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00552-00137618-00137797": "against our eighty million dollar", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00553-00137798-00138066": "investment in this Ruth", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00554-00138067-00138347": "remember from Oxford very much mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00555-00138348-00138509": "speaker my question to the Afghan", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00556-00138510-00138782": "Premier two weeks ago I stood up in this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00557-00138783-00138947": "legislature and asked the premier to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00558-00138948-00139138": "change her policies that are driving", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00559-00139139-00139484": "jobs out of Ontario including the 1300", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00560-00139485-00139712": "layoffs we that have been announced in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00561-00139713-00140002": "Oxford over the last 10 months business", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00562-00140003-00140191": "after business warned this government", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00563-00140192-00140348": "that the high cost of operating in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00564-00140349-00140543": "Ontario would force them to close their", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00565-00140544-00141062": "doors or move yesterday 200 more layoffs", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00566-00141063-00141320": "were added to that total as Firestone", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00567-00141321-00141514": "announced that they are closing their", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00568-00141515-00141802": "doors after 81 years and shifting the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00569-00141803-00141968": "remaining production to north carolina", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00570-00141969-00142201": "directly well the government now finally", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00571-00142202-00142394": "admit that their policies are driving", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00572-00142395-00142631": "jobs out of Ontario and take action", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00573-00142632-00143437": "today let me stress pond to that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00574-00143438-00143665": "question in two parts mr. speaker I want", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00575-00143666-00143962": "to start off by saying that that we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00576-00143963-00144136": "share the members concerns for that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00577-00144137-00144311": "community they've been hit by a couple", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00578-00144312-00144616": "of significant layoffs in the last in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00579-00144617-00144761": "the last month or so", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00580-00144762-00145066": "and we're very aware of those challenges", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00581-00145067-00145252": "and in fact we'll continue to work with", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00582-00145253-00145547": "local authorities they're really our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00583-00145548-00145796": "focus will be on helping those workers", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00584-00145797-00146135": "find other opportunities and we'll", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00585-00146136-00146297": "continue to ensure that our training", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00586-00146298-00146558": "colleges and universities are now mais", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00587-00146559-00146933": "the will will be engaged in that as well", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00588-00146934-00147301": "more remember from LAN our product I", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00589-00147302-00147679": "think said having Tania's warned I'll", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00590-00147680-00147916": "keep doing it I mean at this time mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00591-00147917-00148034": "speaker we're talking about something", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00592-00148035-00148165": "very important to one of his colleagues", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00593-00148166-00148406": "so well I look forward to working with", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00594-00148407-00148786": "my colleague as my colleague minister to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00595-00148787-00148919": "help in any way we can in the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00596-00148920-00149156": "supplementary I'll address the issues in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00597-00149157-00149401": "Ontario's competitiveness committee", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00598-00149402-00149613": "Thank You mr. speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00599-00149614-00149890": "1500 layoffs in Oxford in less than a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00600-00149891-00150257": "year and 2800 cami employees on strike", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00601-00150258-00150562": "trying to keep their jobs in Ontario the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00602-00150563-00150758": "government can try to spend this however", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00603-00150759-00151000": "they want but that's the impact of your", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00604-00151001-00151252": "policies the people of Oxford are doing", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00605-00151253-00151389": "everything we can to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00606-00151390-00151602": "our local businesses but this government", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00607-00151603-00151851": "just adds more and more burdens until", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00608-00151852-00151989": "the companies are forced to close their", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00609-00151990-00152283": "doors how many more people have to lose", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00610-00152284-00152484": "their jobs before you're going to take", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00611-00152485-00152729": "real action and keep our businesses and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00612-00152730-00153228": "our jobs in Ontario", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00613-00153229-00153432": "mr. speaker now it's time for me to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00614-00153433-00153564": "bring the member into the real world", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00615-00153565-00153792": "because that is not the real world in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00616-00153793-00154131": "Ontario anything even close to it this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00617-00154132-00154379": "province is growing mr. speaker faster", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00618-00154380-00154608": "than the g7 zhan average we have an", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00619-00154609-00154746": "unemployment rate in this province", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00620-00154747-00155094": "that's at a 16 year low we have created", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00621-00155095-00155547": "a net 760,000 net new jobs since the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00622-00155548-00155760": "global recession so for the member to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00623-00155761-00156006": "talk down the work that's being done in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00624-00156007-00156162": "this business community in this province", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00625-00156163-00156381": "to create jobs is absolutely", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00626-00156382-00156681": "inappropriate and absolutely wrong Mr", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00627-00156682-00156903": "Speaker I understand there are", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00628-00156904-00157091": "challenges in that particular community", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00629-00157092-00157254": "there's been a couple of very", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00630-00157255-00157488": "significant layoffs and we will work", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00631-00157489-00157674": "with the member to help those workers", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00632-00157675-00157887": "but the best thing we can do is to stay", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00633-00157888-00158100": "on track and that's keep building this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00634-00158101-00158343": "strong economy in Ontario key partners", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00635-00158344-00158559": "are in leading the g7 and keep that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00636-00158560-00158778": "unemployment rate at record lows mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00637-00158779-00159426": "speaker returning to do that okay thank", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00638-00159427-00159554": "you speaker my question is to the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00639-00159555-00159707": "Minister of Children and Youth Services", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00640-00159708-00159990": "in a letter you received from Chief", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00641-00159991-00160215": "Elaine Johnson from serpent River First", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00642-00160216-00160533": "Nation if a family lives in sue Saint", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00643-00160534-00160881": "Marie line River or Elliott lake they", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00644-00160882-00161133": "have direct access to Algoma Family", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00645-00161134-00161277": "Services children's mental health", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00646-00161278-00161700": "services however if a family lives on a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00647-00161701-00161976": "First Nations community they received no", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00648-00161977-00162207": "children's mental health services from", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00649-00162208-00162462": "Algoma Family Services Minister why is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00650-00162463-00162856": "this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00651-00162857-00163078": "well thank you very much mr. speaker I'd", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00652-00163079-00163228": "like to thank the member for the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00653-00163229-00163456": "question I've been in this position now", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00654-00163457-00163684": "for just over a year and have had the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00655-00163685-00163897": "opportunity to visit many of our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00656-00163898-00164056": "indigenous communities across the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00657-00164057-00164326": "province of Ontario in fact mr. speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00658-00164327-00164584": "last two weeks ago I was in treaty that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00659-00164585-00164917": "treaty three and met with the Chiefs in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00660-00164918-00165160": "Kenora and I signed a historical", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00661-00165161-00165490": "document out there moving towards an", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00662-00165491-00165637": "agreement between our indigenous", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00663-00165638-00165823": "partners and the government of Ontario", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00664-00165824-00166036": "to put the resources and the control", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00665-00166037-00166186": "back in the hands of the community so", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00666-00166187-00166378": "young people from the indigenous", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00667-00166379-00166531": "communities can get the services they", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00668-00166532-00166804": "need and they deserve where they live", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00669-00166805-00167098": "this is the first time in the history of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00670-00167099-00167374": "this province in fact this country that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00671-00167375-00167518": "we've made a type of agreement that will", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00672-00167519-00167740": "put the responsibility and the ownership", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00673-00167741-00167983": "of the responsibility to look after", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00674-00167984-00168115": "children back in the hands of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00675-00168116-00168256": "communities where it should be answered", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00676-00168257-00168391": "and I'm very proud of this government's", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00677-00168392-00168756": "direction in regards to that policy", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00678-00168757-00169006": "again to the Minister of children youth", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00679-00169007-00169285": "and services Algoma Family Services has", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00680-00169286-00169528": "indicated that they don't have the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00681-00169529-00169774": "expertise or resources to provide any", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00682-00169775-00170044": "services to First Nations in my area or", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00683-00170045-00170284": "to indigenous children who are in the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00684-00170285-00170470": "care of not the winnaman Family and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00685-00170471-00170758": "Community Services this is why not the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00686-00170759-00170974": "winnaman has submitted a proposal to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00687-00170975-00171253": "your ministry to fund the delivery of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00688-00171254-00171493": "culturally appropriate children's mental", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00689-00171494-00171811": "health services to my area First Nations", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00690-00171812-00172081": "communities your ministry simply", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00691-00172082-00172356": "answered that there is no money for this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00692-00172357-00172639": "Minister every child matters", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00693-00172640-00172858": "why is there no money for direct", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00694-00172859-00173095": "treatment of children's mental health on", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00695-00173096-00173902": "First Nations in my area this year again", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00696-00173903-00174064": "it was a historical document it's the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00697-00174065-00174199": "first document the history of this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00698-00174200-00174571": "country that acknowledges that cultural", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00699-00174572-00174898": "a cultural approach to to working with", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00700-00174899-00175093": "communities as necessary to actually", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00701-00175094-00175366": "acknowledges that systemic racism does", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00702-00175367-00175567": "exist and indigenous communities have", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00703-00175568-00175873": "have been victims of colonialism here in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00704-00175874-00176029": "the province of Ontario and across this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00705-00176030-00176143": "country the MIS", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00706-00176144-00176296": "your speaker you know when we move", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00707-00176297-00176608": "forward with that that bill you know the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00708-00176609-00176848": "NDP did support it the Conservatives did", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00709-00176849-00177058": "not support that bill bill 89 we still", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00710-00177059-00177421": "don't know why today that they didn't", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00711-00177422-00177595": "support that bill that raised the age of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00712-00177596-00177820": "protection and actually moves forward to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00713-00177821-00177982": "build a frame up to put those resources", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00714-00177983-00178171": "back in the hands of the community mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00715-00178172-00178444": "speaker you'll see as we go forward here", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00716-00178445-00178704": "in Ontario those resources will be put", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00717-00178705-00178834": "back in the hands of the community and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00718-00178835-00178938": "it's the first government in this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00719-00178939-00179436": "country to do just that thank you Thank", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00720-00179437-00179616": "You mr. speaker my question is to the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00721-00179617-00179824": "Minister responsible for the status of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00722-00179825-00180138": "women this past week I received a very", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00723-00180139-00180429": "concerning call from my daughter she was", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00724-00180430-00180654": "walking down the street in Ottawa when", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00725-00180655-00180915": "she came across a protest Mr Speaker she", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00726-00180916-00181243": "was walking by the Morgentaler clinic we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00727-00181244-00181524": "know in recent months protests activity", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00728-00181525-00181728": "outside of several abortion clinics", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00729-00181729-00181948": "across Ontario have escalated to the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00730-00181949-00182313": "point of harassment and intimidation my", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00731-00182314-00182506": "daughter who was simply walking down the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00732-00182507-00182722": "street felt it and she called me about", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00733-00182723-00182775": "it", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00734-00182776-00183012": "let alone the women and health care", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00735-00183013-00183196": "providers that work in these clinics", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00736-00183197-00183627": "this is not right and we know that it is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00737-00183628-00183934": "happening all across this province mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00738-00183935-00184302": "speaker as a woman a mother and a member", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00739-00184303-00184531": "of this government we have a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00740-00184532-00184798": "responsibility to act question yesterday", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00741-00184799-00184960": "the government introduced legislation", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00742-00184961-00185173": "that would have passed do just that so", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00743-00185174-00185403": "mr. speaker can the Minister please tell", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00744-00185404-00185671": "us about our government's plan to to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00745-00185672-00186042": "keep", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00746-00186043-00186289": "Thank You mr. speaker I'd like to thank", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00747-00186290-00186463": "the member from Kingston and the islands", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00748-00186464-00186661": "for raising a very important question", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00749-00186662-00186958": "speaker as a woman and mother myself", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00750-00186959-00187174": "with a young daughter I have an", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00751-00187175-00187438": "obligation to not only my daughter but", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00752-00187439-00187654": "to all women in this province and their", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00753-00187655-00187933": "daughters who make a difficult choice it", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00754-00187934-00188140": "is my belief and our government's belief", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00755-00188141-00188428": "that every woman in Ontario has the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00756-00188429-00188647": "right to make decisions about her own", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00757-00188648-00188863": "health care and that they should be able", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00758-00188864-00189223": "to do so freely without fear of bullying", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00759-00189224-00189577": "intimidation or harassment in fact that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00760-00189578-00189760": "is why our government introduced safe", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00761-00189761-00190060": "access so legislation yesterday that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00762-00190061-00190384": "sends a very clear message that we will", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00763-00190385-00190642": "not tolerate any form of harassment", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00764-00190643-00190843": "against women exercising their", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00765-00190844-00191065": "fundamental right to choose these", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00766-00191066-00191257": "proposed access zones would help ensure", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00767-00191258-00191539": "that women across Ontario have safe", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00768-00191540-00191821": "access to health care services and that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00769-00191822-00192100": "their privacy and dignity are protected", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00770-00192101-00192733": "I know that the women across this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00771-00192734-00192931": "province are relieved in the staff at", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00772-00192932-00193189": "these facilities about hearing this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00773-00193190-00193507": "government's action to work towards this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00774-00193508-00193768": "however Mr Speaker I would like some", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00775-00193769-00193903": "further information about the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00776-00193904-00194128": "legislation mr. speaker the difficult", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00777-00194129-00194344": "decision that these women make is not", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00778-00194345-00194662": "one that is ever made easily it's a very", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00779-00194663-00194860": "difficult decision they live with for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00780-00194861-00195109": "the rest of their lives the reasons for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00781-00195110-00195322": "making such a decision is deeply", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00782-00195323-00195604": "personal and entirely up to them and no", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00783-00195605-00195925": "one else we have a responsibility to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00784-00195926-00196150": "ensure that privacy and emotional", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00785-00196151-00196339": "well-being of these women who make a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00786-00196340-00196600": "choice about their own physical and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00787-00196601-00196933": "emotional health this responsibility of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00788-00196934-00197191": "course also extends to health care", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00789-00197192-00197545": "providers so Mr Speaker through you to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00790-00197546-00197734": "the Minister how can we ensure that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00791-00197735-00198043": "there is safety in every clinic in every", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00792-00198044-00198437": "home and on the street", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00793-00198438-00198723": "Thank You mr. speaker the member raises", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00794-00198724-00198939": "a very good point and I can tell you", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00795-00198940-00199122": "that yesterday the health care", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00796-00199123-00199299": "professionals and advocates in the room", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00797-00199300-00199548": "were very supportive of the proposed", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00798-00199549-00199788": "changes we are making to protect their", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00799-00199789-00200019": "patients and themselves in fact they", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00800-00200020-00200262": "applauded they were telling us how much", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00801-00200263-00200538": "this legislation was needed needed to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00802-00200539-00200691": "stop women from being harassed", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00803-00200692-00201015": "intimidated and bullied this legislation", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00804-00201016-00201282": "speaker would if passed provide for the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00805-00201283-00201585": "creation of safe access tones of 50", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00806-00201586-00201813": "meters that can be increased up to a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00807-00201814-00202047": "hundred and fifty meters around abortion", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00808-00202048-00202320": "clinics speaker we can't just stop there", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00809-00202321-00202557": "we also have a duty to protect the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00810-00202558-00202827": "safety and security of the staff the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00811-00202828-00202986": "staff that offer women's reproductive", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00812-00202987-00203238": "services which is why this legislation", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00813-00203239-00203547": "would also implement safe access zones", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00814-00203548-00203769": "of a hundred and fifty meters around the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00815-00203770-00203973": "homes of the staff answer speaker we're", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00816-00203974-00204069": "moving forward with this legislation", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00817-00204070-00204342": "because we take it seriously because we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00818-00204343-00204528": "have a responsibility to the women in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00819-00204529-00205155": "this province thank you my question is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00820-00205156-00205377": "to the deputy premier deputy premier", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00821-00205378-00205644": "recently the WSIB made significant", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00822-00205644-00205848": "changes to its hearing aid program", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00823-00205848-00206100": "without properly consulting audiologist", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00824-00206101-00206390": "and WSIB recipients before the summer", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00825-00206391-00206553": "the minister of labor committed to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00826-00206554-00206823": "looking at ways to fix the mess the ws", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00827-00206823-00207156": "CBE has created however months later the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00828-00207157-00207306": "Official Opposition is still hearing", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00829-00207307-00207464": "from patients right across this province", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00830-00207465-00207660": "who cannot access the hearing aid that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00831-00207661-00207879": "works best for them we've heard stories", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00832-00207880-00208101": "of individuals limiting their time with", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00833-00208102-00208292": "loved ones because the hearing aid they", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00834-00208294-00208455": "are now forced to use is affecting their", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00835-00208456-00208694": "quality of life and hearing deputy", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00836-00208696-00208911": "premier Ontario hearing aid patients are", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00837-00208912-00209160": "asking you to put them first and reverse", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00838-00209161-00209465": "the WSIB changes that are not benefit in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00839-00209466-00209519": "any way", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00840-00209521-00209736": "Mr Speaker I asked the deputy mayor", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00841-00209737-00210167": "today will you act thank you", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00842-00210167-00210483": "labor Thank You speaker and thank you to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00843-00210484-00210687": "the member for that important question I", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00844-00210688-00210930": "think a number of us in the chamber have", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00845-00210931-00211119": "been asked about exactly the same thing", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00846-00211119-00211323": "speaker and what we need to ensure is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00847-00211323-00211530": "that the WSIB is operating in the best", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00848-00211531-00211785": "interest of workers at all time speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00849-00211786-00211962": "yeah it's an organization that was put", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00850-00211963-00212148": "in place to ensure that if somebody is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00851-00212148-00212379": "hurt on the job our preference speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00852-00212380-00212601": "is that the injury does not take place", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00853-00212602-00212757": "in the first place we work hard on", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00854-00212758-00212979": "prevention should that injury take place", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00855-00212980-00213177": "and speaker from time to time those", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00856-00213178-00213398": "injuries can include hearing loss we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00857-00213400-00213579": "need to ensure that the services that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00858-00213580-00213810": "are provided to the worker are services", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00859-00213811-00213954": "that meet the needs of the workers", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00860-00213955-00214148": "speaker whether it's a return to work", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00861-00214150-00214302": "whether it's a recovery from illness", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00862-00214303-00214554": "speaker so the information that the the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00863-00214555-00214752": "member is brought forward was a change", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00864-00214753-00215034": "in policy of the WSIB it was an attempt", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00865-00215035-00215205": "to ensure that the services that are", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00866-00215206-00215409": "brought forward in terms of hearing aid", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00867-00215410-00215607": "speaker are the ones that are best to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00868-00215608-00215754": "meet the needs of the injured worker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00869-00215755-00215994": "speaker we have talked to the WUSA be", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00870-00215994-00216192": "about this we remain in conversation", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00871-00216192-00216408": "with them we hope we can end here we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00872-00216409-00216576": "hope we can reach a resolution I'll", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00873-00216577-00216753": "address the rest and the supplementary", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00874-00216754-00217017": "with you thank you speaker to the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00875-00217017-00217278": "Minister of Labour again just one single", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00876-00217279-00217440": "audio just from my writing of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00877-00217441-00217673": "sarnia-lambton alone has sent over 30", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00878-00217675-00217835": "appeals to the WSIB", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00879-00217836-00218064": "in the last few months it takes an", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00880-00218065-00218208": "average of three to six months to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00881-00218209-00218454": "receive an answer in my ride I have met", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00882-00218455-00218612": "with more than a dozen affected", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00883-00218613-00218798": "constituents and received over 200", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00884-00218800-00219012": "handwritten petitions on this issue I", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00885-00219013-00219240": "can only imagine how many other patients", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00886-00219241-00219485": "and constituents are being acted right", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00887-00219486-00219732": "across this province mr. speaker to the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00888-00219733-00219906": "minister let's do what's right and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00889-00219907-00220116": "what's fair and make sure that injured", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00890-00220117-00220332": "workers in Ontario have access to the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00891-00220333-00220503": "hearing aid that they need without", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00892-00220504-00220755": "further delay will administer deal with", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00893-00220756-00220965": "this issue today okay thank you thank", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00894-00220966-00221238": "you mr. speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00895-00221239-00221471": "I appreciate the question from the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00896-00221473-00221646": "member and he and I have had a number of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00897-00221646-00221873": "exchanges about health and safety in his", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00898-00221875-00222063": "own writing I've always found the meters", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00899-00222064-00222252": "i've always found a member to be very", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00900-00222253-00222354": "very sincere", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00901-00222355-00222576": "Abdi brings issues to me first he", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00902-00222577-00222852": "doesn't try to he doesn't try to hijack", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00903-00222853-00223008": "the House Speaker when he brings these", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00904-00223009-00223137": "things forward so", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00905-00223138-00223367": "I'm committed to continue to work on a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00906-00223369-00223592": "variety of issues with the WSIB speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00907-00223594-00223754": "because I know they're brought forward", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00908-00223755-00223973": "sincerely in this case what I think you", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00909-00223975-00224258": "have speaker is an organization the WSIB", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00910-00224259-00224477": "that thinks it's doing the right thing", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00911-00224478-00224699": "that has looked that has looked at what", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00912-00224700-00224909": "exists today in terms of hearing aids", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00913-00224910-00225176": "that are available to the members of the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00914-00225177-00225452": "public to citizens of Ontario that need", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00915-00225453-00225644": "to avail themselves of the services of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00916-00225646-00225894": "the WSIB and have tried to provide that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00917-00225894-00226151": "service in an effective and efficient", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00918-00226152-00226323": "manner as much they possibly could", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00919-00226323-00226502": "however speak you have a number of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00920-00226503-00226689": "citizens that think that that's are not", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00921-00226690-00226874": "working for them I believe that working", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00922-00226875-00227057": "with a member we can sort this out and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00923-00227058-00227210": "everybody can get what they need at the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00924-00227211-00227828": "end of the day Thank You speaker are my", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00925-00227829-00228023": "questions to the deputy premier this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00926-00228025-00228149": "morning the Liberal government made it", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00927-00228150-00228302": "clear they don't intend to support the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00928-00228303-00228588": "NDP's push for paid leave for victims of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00929-00228589-00228908": "intimate partner violence despite clear", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00930-00228909-00229124": "evidence that too many women are afraid", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00931-00229125-00229355": "to escape because they simply cannot", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00932-00229356-00229590": "afford to we heard from unifor sue", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00933-00229591-00229788": "McKinnon at the NGO 148 hearings this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00934-00229789-00229973": "summer who described one woman's", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00935-00229975-00230030": "nightmare", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00936-00230031-00230285": "she packed her life in a basket and fled", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00937-00230286-00230477": "with her three children she was in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00938-00230478-00230717": "constant fear of making sure her kids", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00939-00230719-00230969": "were fed safe and had a roof over their", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00940-00230971-00231179": "heads and she still had to make mortgage", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00941-00231180-00231452": "payments on a home that her partner", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00942-00231453-00231632": "destroyed why is this government", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00943-00231633-00231969": "ignoring women who say paid leave will", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00944-00231969-00232204": "help them escape with their lives", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00945-00232205-00232525": "[Applause]", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00946-00232526-00232841": "earlier well Speaker I appreciate the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00947-00232842-00233075": "question but we are doing anything but", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00948-00233076-00233221": "ignoring women in the province of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00949-00233223-00233441": "Ontario you look at the impacts of Bill", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00950-00233442-00233753": "148 speaker a lot of the advantages that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00951-00233754-00233917": "will be gained by the passage of that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00952-00233919-00234146": "bill should the house presume to do that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00953-00234146-00234389": "speaker will be aimed directly at women", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00954-00234390-00234581": "who haven't been treated in the past in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00955-00234582-00234692": "the workplace the way they should", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00956-00234692-00234917": "speaker that's the whole point of this I", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00957-00234917-00235136": "was in Hamilton this morning speaking at", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00958-00235137-00235409": "the YWCA speaker and as a result of us", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00959-00235410-00235676": "taking Bill 148 out after first reading", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00960-00235677-00235859": "speaker we were able to hear from people", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00961-00235860-00236044": "around the province Ontario and one", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00962-00236046-00236207": "thing they brought forward was something", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00963-00236208-00236366": "that the members bringing forward", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00964-00236367-00236569": "against speaker and that is domestic", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00965-00236571-00236821": "violence speaker people need to know", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00966-00236823-00237014": "that when they need to take time off and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00967-00237015-00237206": "the eventualities of that speaker that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00968-00237207-00237401": "their job is not in jeopardy that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00969-00237402-00237571": "they're not and risk of being fired and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00970-00237573-00237785": "speaker that's exactly what we do with", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00971-00237786-00237941": "leaves in the province of Ontario I", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00972-00237942-00238244": "believe if we work together on bill 148", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00973-00238244-00238471": "speaker we can we can bring forward a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00974-00238473-00238706": "bill that will exactly meet the needs of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00975-00238707-00239096": "these women speaker back to the action", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00976-00239096-00239327": "Premier New Democrats have repeatedly", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00977-00239328-00239534": "called for paid leave for victims who", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00978-00239535-00239702": "need it the member from the London West", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00979-00239703-00239878": "introduced two pieces of legislation", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00980-00239879-00240155": "your government is stalling it knew", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00981-00240156-00240380": "Democrats introduced amendments to bill", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00982-00240381-00240683": "148 during the clause by Clause the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00983-00240684-00240890": "Liberal government voted against those", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00984-00240891-00241178": "amendments the NDP leader last week the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00985-00241179-00241394": "member from Hamilton centre introduced a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00986-00241394-00241637": "bill that would have ten days paid leave", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00987-00241638-00241798": "for victims of sexual and domestic", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00988-00241798-00242102": "violence so survivors can actually", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00989-00242103-00242344": "afford to take a leave so they can", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00990-00242346-00242603": "afford to have time off to file police", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00991-00242604-00242864": "reports so they can testify and have", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00992-00242865-00243110": "time off to testify in court proceedings", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00993-00243111-00243338": "against their abusers but the Liberal", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00994-00243339-00243563": "government refuses to support this why", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00995-00243564-00243885": "is that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00996-00243886-00244159": "well speaker once again I appreciate the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00997-00244160-00244391": "question but the information being", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00998-00244392-00244538": "brought forward to the house speakers", "W7XBcwcED9Y-00999-00244539-00244717": "simply is not accurate in this regard", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01000-00244719-00244930": "well I was out in Hamilton this morning", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01001-00244931-00245206": "speaker talking publicly about the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01002-00245207-00245450": "reason we took bill 148 out in the first", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01003-00245451-00245651": "place speaker the way that we have", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01004-00245652-00245798": "listened to the people of the province", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01005-00245798-00246007": "of Ontario the way we are bringing", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01006-00246008-00246319": "forward up to 17 weeks speaker of Job", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01007-00246321-00246646": "protected leave what we do in case of a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01008-00246646-00246890": "compassionate leave or these types of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01009-00246891-00247151": "leave speaker is the province under the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01010-00247152-00247328": "Employment Standards Act under the Labor", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01011-00247329-00247507": "Relations Act under the Occupational", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01012-00247508-00247691": "Health and Safety Act speaker provides", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01013-00247692-00247933": "the job protection says to the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01014-00247934-00248117": "individual your job is not in jeopardy", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01015-00248117-00248329": "during this period of time I think we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01016-00248330-00248525": "then turn to our federal counterparts in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01017-00248526-00248777": "Ottawa which I have done speaker and we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01018-00248778-00248953": "ask them to provide the income during", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01019-00248954-00249142": "that period and surrender the employment", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01020-00249144-00249319": "insurance we're doing the right thing", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01021-00249321-00249505": "here speaker we're doing right by women", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01022-00249506-00249667": "with the support of the House speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01023-00249669-00249871": "we'll get to where we need to get to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01024-00249873-00250171": "[Applause]", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01025-00250171-00250423": "Thank You mr. speaker my question today", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01026-00250425-00250571": "is for the minister of advanced", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01027-00250571-00250879": "education and Skills Development Ontario", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01028-00250880-00251050": "has one of the most highly skilled", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01029-00251051-00251329": "workforces in the world and this is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01030-00251330-00251591": "thanks in large part to the incredible", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01031-00251592-00251758": "transformation of our post-secondary", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01032-00251759-00252034": "system that we've undertaken in the last", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01033-00252035-00252377": "14 years as I'm sure all of us will", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01034-00252378-00252575": "agree increasing access to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01035-00252576-00252812": "post-secondary education by removing", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01036-00252813-00253091": "unnecessary barriers is one of the best", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01037-00253092-00253313": "ways that we as a government can help", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01038-00253314-00253598": "improve the life outcomes of Ontarians", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01039-00253598-00253865": "as such mr. speaker can the Minister", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01040-00253866-00254128": "please inform this house how we've", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01041-00254129-00254380": "removed barriers and increased access to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01042-00254381-00254627": "post-secondary education in our province", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01043-00254628-00255004": "since 2003 thank you Minister advanced", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01044-00255005-00255194": "Education and Skills Tabo thank you", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01045-00255194-00255500": "speaker and it has been a remarkable 14", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01046-00255501-00256019": "years", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01047-00256019-00256338": "said that they don't believe that cost", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01048-00256339-00256560": "and income are real barriers to post", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01049-00256561-00256758": "education or post-secondary education", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01050-00256759-00257001": "that couldn't be further from the truth", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01051-00257002-00257246": "we know that participation raised before", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01052-00257248-00257481": "kids from higher income families are far", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01053-00257482-00257655": "far greater than for lower income", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01054-00257656-00257850": "families and that's why we've moved", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01055-00257851-00257978": "forward with an extraordinary", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01056-00257979-00258194": "transformation of student assistance of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01057-00258196-00258644": "OSAP speaker this year over 200,000", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01058-00258646-00260325": "students in Ontario as well speaker the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01059-00260326-00260642": "number of students is already is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01060-00260642-00260919": "attending has also gone up dramatically", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01061-00260919-00261315": "speaker by over 38% we made it thank you", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01062-00261316-00261513": "and their pain results thank you", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01063-00261514-00261738": "supplementary Thank You speaker and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01064-00261739-00261903": "thanks to the Minister for her answer", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01065-00261904-00262086": "when our government was first elected", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01066-00262087-00262320": "our post-secondary sector was in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01067-00262321-00262500": "desperate need of significant", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01068-00262501-00262731": "investments to make sure that its", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01069-00262732-00262983": "institution could continue to provide", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01070-00262984-00263220": "the world-class education our students", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01071-00263221-00263520": "expect and deserve but we know that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01072-00263521-00263784": "world-class education and instruction", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01073-00263785-00264036": "requires world-class facilities and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01074-00264037-00264330": "faculty accordingly mr. speaker can the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01075-00264331-00264564": "Minister please share with this house", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01076-00264565-00264822": "and all Ontarians some examples of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01077-00264823-00265038": "significant investments our government", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01078-00265039-00265302": "has made to improve Ontario's colleges", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01079-00265303-00265673": "and universities in the last 14 years", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01080-00265674-00266019": "mr. speaker as I said enrolment has gone", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01081-00266020-00266340": "up by 38 percent but grants to colleges", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01082-00266341-00266526": "and universities have almost doubled", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01083-00266527-00266868": "they've gone up by 85", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01084-00266869-00267072": "allows our colleges and university to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01085-00267073-00267356": "hire top-tier instructors instructors", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01086-00267357-00267645": "and deliver state-of-the-art program", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01087-00267646-00267876": "that speakers we've also invested", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01088-00267877-00268119": "heavily in the physical structure their", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01089-00268120-00268353": "facilities as well you know speaker when", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01090-00268354-00268578": "the concerns were in power in 2000 there", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01091-00268579-00268800": "last year power they spent about a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01092-00268801-00269028": "hundred million dollars on capital for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01093-00269029-00269271": "colleges and universities speaker we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01094-00269272-00269619": "have on average invested 300 million", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01095-00269620-00269865": "dollars a year on colleges and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01096-00269866-00270332": "universities we've been able to build", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01097-00270333-00270533": "important projects such as the software", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01098-00270534-00270806": "and informatics Research Center at UOIT", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01099-00270807-00271205": "in Durham speaker debated library", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01100-00271206-00271425": "research observation cluster at Trent", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01101-00271426-00271626": "these are just two examples of the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01102-00271627-00271824": "extraordinary investments that company", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01103-00271825-00272105": "yeah request remember fulfillment under", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01104-00272106-00272301": "so fingers Thank You speaker to the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01105-00272302-00272529": "happy premier the government is no", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01106-00272530-00272700": "stranger to the nation rise when", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01107-00272701-00272858": "projects in the township of north", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01108-00272859-00272916": "Starmont", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01109-00272917-00273138": "if it's been paying any attention it", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01110-00273139-00273291": "would know that the MIS Valley doesn't", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01111-00273292-00273477": "want it and the local residents don't", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01112-00273478-00273687": "want it the minister has admitted that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01113-00273688-00273870": "the province doesn't need the power of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01114-00273871-00274101": "the nation rise or any other wind or", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01115-00274102-00274338": "solar contracts are still being offered", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01116-00274339-00274521": "signed and imposed on unwilling", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01117-00274522-00274812": "communities will generate nation rice", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01118-00274813-00275163": "core zero and all the iso's the rated", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01119-00275164-00275397": "criteria yet it was still offered a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01120-00275398-00275714": "contract he is unwanted I needed an", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01121-00275715-00275946": "unjustifiable what is this government", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01122-00275947-00276200": "waiting for why will it not cancel", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01123-00276201-00276454": "[Applause]", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01124-00276455-00276634": "development and growth mister of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01125-00276635-00276847": "Economic Development girl mr. speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01126-00276848-00277099": "the Minister of Energy and the previous", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01127-00277100-00277300": "Minister of Energy have put in place a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01128-00277301-00277637": "process now that very much takes into", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01129-00277638-00277834": "consideration the local concerns about", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01130-00277835-00278053": "these projects but time and time again", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01131-00278054-00278291": "mr. speaker the party opposite their", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01132-00278292-00278575": "true colors come out any time there's", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01133-00278576-00278816": "any resistance at all to any renewable", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01134-00278817-00279070": "project they're up on their feet talking", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01135-00279071-00279256": "about how they don't support renewable", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01136-00279257-00279559": "clean energy Mr Speaker we do have to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01137-00279560-00279713": "start thinking of the big picture here", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01138-00279714-00279901": "we need to start thinking of our kids", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01139-00279902-00280129": "and the health of our population and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01140-00280130-00280381": "that's why mr. speaker while local", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01141-00280382-00280538": "concerns are very very important and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01142-00280539-00280678": "we've taken measures to ensure that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01143-00280679-00280882": "voice is heard we're very proud to be", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01144-00280883-00281119": "the first jurisdiction anywhere in the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01145-00281120-00281332": "world to eliminate call and move to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01146-00281333-00281542": "cleaner sources of power that's going to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01147-00281543-00281746": "help our kids live longer that's going", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01148-00281747-00281963": "to save lives in this province after mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01149-00281964-00282127": "speaker it's helping to build a very", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01150-00282128-00282346": "strong clean tech sector here in the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01151-00282347-00282478": "province of Ontario Thank You", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01152-00282479-00282740": "supplementary speaker back to the deputy", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01153-00282741-00282778": "premier", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01154-00282779-00282938": "it's clear that we just don't need the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01155-00282939-00283159": "power all the independent experts who", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01156-00283160-00283306": "have taken a look at this government's", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01157-00283307-00283525": "energy records have gasp and dismayed", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01158-00283526-00283732": "that's a total mess that you've made it", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01159-00283733-00283957": "only this government could force clean", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01160-00283958-00284264": "green Bruce Jenner Bruce Power to vent", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01161-00284265-00284479": "steam to reduce generation spill", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01162-00284480-00284698": "renewable water resources over our dams", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01163-00284699-00284966": "paying wind and solar company companies", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01164-00284967-00285232": "more than the power is worth causing a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01165-00285233-00285529": "terawatt surplus and generation sell the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01166-00285530-00285737": "surplus for loss and then proclaim that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01167-00285738-00286003": "everything is just fine we already have", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01168-00286004-00286241": "a surplus of power today because nation", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01169-00286242-00286435": "right before a nation rise has even", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01170-00286436-00286702": "built this province S know the owners a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01171-00286703-00286940": "nation rise a contract but it does owe", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01172-00286941-00287185": "the citizens of North Star month a duty", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01173-00287186-00287446": "to listen and to represent the North", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01174-00287447-00287513": "Dormont", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01175-00287514-00287752": "is an unwilling host which part of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01176-00287753-00287915": "unwilling to assist government not", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01177-00287916-00288187": "understand", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01178-00288188-00288481": "Minister of Environment Mr Speaker the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01179-00288482-00288701": "environment climate change well thank", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01180-00288702-00288938": "you speaker and and thank you for for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01181-00288939-00289193": "that important question and the ability", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01182-00289194-00289541": "to once again stand up and defend green", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01183-00289542-00289804": "energy in this province speaker because", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01184-00289805-00290048": "I'm not sure if the party opposite", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01185-00290049-00290302": "actually believes in green energy mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01186-00290303-00290498": "speaker you know this government this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01187-00290499-00290683": "government takes concerns regarding the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01188-00290684-00290854": "environment and human health very", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01189-00290855-00291149": "seriously and let me say that that our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01190-00291150-00291425": "ministry adheres to a very strict", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01191-00291426-00291617": "renewable energy approvals process", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01192-00291618-00291907": "there's not speaker there's not a single", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01193-00291908-00292210": "renewable energy project that that the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01194-00292211-00292493": "PCs have ever spoken in support of here", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01195-00292494-00292775": "in this house so they have no plan to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01196-00292776-00293002": "help Ontario families and businesses", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01197-00293003-00293454": "make sustainable choices and lower", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01198-00293455-00293842": "[Applause]", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01199-00293843-00294062": "remember from Prince Edward Hastings is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01200-00294063-00294681": "Warren", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01201-00294682-00294895": "your time has expired", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01202-00294896-00295479": "new question the member from Windsor was", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01203-00295480-00295820": "the acting premier speaker last week the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01204-00295821-00295994": "Daily Bread Food Bank released their", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01205-00295995-00296257": "annual who's hungry report and Toronto", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01206-00296258-00296455": "families were shocked by how dire the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01207-00296456-00296750": "situation has become food bank visits in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01208-00296751-00296956": "Toronto are at the highest levels since", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01209-00296957-00297299": "the 2008 recession with seniors listed", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01210-00297300-00297532": "as the fastest growing group of food", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01211-00297533-00297979": "bank users up 27% from last year the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01212-00297980-00298163": "average length of dependence on food", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01213-00298164-00298469": "banks has gone from 12 to 24 months with", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01214-00298470-00298790": "Scarborough families seeing a 30%", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01215-00298791-00299078": "increase in food paint visits mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01216-00299079-00299288": "speaker these figures are heartbreaking", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01217-00299289-00299533": "people are skipping meals so they can", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01218-00299534-00299728": "pay the bills and keep a roof over their", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01219-00299729-00299978": "heads when will this premier take off", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01220-00299979-00300215": "for blinders and see that this province", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01221-00300216-00300941": "is in crisis it's responsible for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01222-00300942-00301172": "poverty reduction thank you mr. speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01223-00301173-00301346": "and I want to thank the member from", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01224-00301347-00301598": "Windsor West for the question mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01225-00301599-00301901": "speaker all Ontarians believe that no", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01226-00301902-00302099": "one should have to make the choice in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01227-00302100-00302335": "this province between feeding themselves", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01228-00302336-00302576": "through their child or paying some other", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01229-00302577-00302809": "bill we have a moral responsibility to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01230-00302810-00303146": "ensure that all Ontarians have access to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01231-00303147-00303569": "safe and good food mr. speaker we know", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01232-00303570-00303716": "throughout the research that we've done", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01233-00303717-00303904": "that there's a number of initiatives", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01234-00303905-00304207": "that need to be done we've worked on", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01235-00304208-00304624": "improving income support programs if", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01236-00304625-00304889": "approved the increase in the minimum", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01237-00304890-00305230": "wage is going to provide Ontarians a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01238-00305231-00305516": "better living wage so they can pay for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01239-00305517-00305728": "those needs that they need to we're", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01240-00305729-00306031": "working on preventing homelessness in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01241-00306032-00306215": "this province to ensure people have a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01242-00306216-00306548": "safe place to stay which includes", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01243-00306549-00306716": "supports that assists them with all", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01244-00306717-00306947": "their other daily needs mr. speaker but", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01245-00306948-00307159": "I'm happy to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01246-00307160-00307555": "thanks again to the acting premier mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01247-00307556-00307765": "speaker this government can say that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01248-00307766-00307906": "they are taking steps to address", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01249-00307907-00308161": "inequality with $15 an hour minimum wage", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01250-00308162-00308452": "and basic income but the Liberals have", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01251-00308453-00308689": "had 14 years to make life better in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01252-00308690-00309010": "Ontario and they have failed in fact", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01253-00309011-00309313": "Daily Bread Food Bank explicitly states", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01254-00309314-00309634": "well on paper the economy may be doing", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01255-00309635-00309895": "well but in the real world many people", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01256-00309896-00310198": "are not we know what the Conservatives", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01257-00310199-00310420": "have said when times get tough the last", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01258-00310421-00310594": "Conservative government told low-income", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01259-00310595-00310840": "families that they could just buy dented", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01260-00310841-00311107": "cans and eat bologna sandwiches to save", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01261-00311108-00311449": "money and in eight years they never once", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01262-00311450-00311848": "raised the minimum wage from 685 new", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01263-00311849-00312049": "Democrats will not stop fighting to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01264-00312050-00312250": "raise families up even though this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01265-00312251-00312436": "Liberal government keeps pushing them", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01266-00312437-00312667": "down when was the question for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01267-00312668-00312769": "priorities in order", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01268-00312770-00312976": "and actually start fighting for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01269-00312977-00313528": "Ontarians Thank You mr. speaker and I", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01270-00313529-00313678": "want to thank the member from Windsor", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01271-00313679-00313885": "West of reminding the house about the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01272-00313886-00314086": "damage the Conservatives did during", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01273-00314087-00314659": "their time yes sir mr. speaker I'm", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01274-00314660-00314902": "working in my ministry on the food", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01275-00314903-00315211": "security strategy which will be", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01276-00315212-00315475": "consulting on later this fall last week", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01277-00315476-00315676": "I met with the director of the Daily", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01278-00315677-00315943": "Bread Food Bank which is actually in my", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01279-00315944-00316204": "writing and she said her number one ask", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01280-00316205-00316522": "on food security it's affordable housing", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01281-00316523-00316670": "mr. speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01282-00316671-00316949": "the mr. speaker we've extended rent", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01283-00316950-00317246": "control to all Ontario tenants to make", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01284-00317247-00317435": "sure all Ontario tenants are treated", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01285-00317436-00317627": "fairly we're investing in the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01286-00317628-00317867": "homelessness prevention initiatives", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01287-00317868-00318089": "across the province mr. speaker to make", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01288-00318090-00318275": "sure people have a place to stay and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01289-00318276-00318569": "other supports including access to food", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01290-00318570-00318893": "to have a dignified life mr. speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01291-00318894-00319088": "we've been taking action for 14 years", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01292-00319089-00319295": "and we will continue to deliver for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01293-00319296-00320480": "fairness for all Ontarians", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01294-00320481-00322104": "you see the place start the park", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01295-00322105-00322395": "the question member from Ottawa vanye", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01296-00322396-00322667": "messieurs Thank You mr. speaker my", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01297-00322668-00322838": "question is for the minister responsible", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01298-00322839-00323227": "of us children and they care our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01299-00323228-00323425": "government has been a real champion of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01300-00323426-00323680": "child care taking action to make sure", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01301-00323681-00324017": "that we all have access to quality and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01302-00324018-00324274": "affordable childcare and we know that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01303-00324275-00324409": "there was a lot of work to do because", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01304-00324410-00324713": "this file was not a priority when the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01305-00324714-00324973": "party opposite was in power and I know", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01306-00324974-00325225": "as a working parent our important it is", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01307-00325226-00325555": "to have good childcare options and I", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01308-00325556-00325807": "think I want to know exactly how much", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01309-00325808-00326044": "these investment have contributed to the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01310-00326045-00326296": "life of families in Ontario can the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01311-00326297-00326588": "minister tell us what are the plans and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01312-00326589-00326803": "what the government has been doing to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01313-00326804-00326995": "meet the needs of families in this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01314-00326996-00327215": "province Thank You minister responsible", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01315-00327216-00327467": "early years in charter Thank You mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01316-00327468-00327595": "speaker and thank you to the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01317-00327596-00327791": "hard-working member from Ottawa Vanier", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01318-00327792-00328048": "for this very important question speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01319-00328049-00328255": "when we came into office the party", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01320-00328256-00328538": "opposite have no real plan for childcare", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01321-00328539-00328865": "had made no real investments and had", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01322-00328866-00329032": "made no real commitments to improve", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01323-00329033-00329368": "childcare for Ontario families speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01324-00329369-00329650": "we have been making childcare our top", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01325-00329651-00330038": "priority for 14 years for 14 years we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01326-00330039-00330226": "have been investing in early years and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01327-00330227-00330478": "childcare in fact speaker when we came", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01328-00330479-00330745": "into power less than 10 percent of the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01329-00330746-00330997": "children in Ontario had access to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01330-00330998-00331292": "childcare spaces speaker we have doubled", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01331-00331293-00331495": "doubled the number of licensed childcare", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01332-00331496-00331822": "spaces in Ontario since 2003 and in fact", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01333-00331823-00332044": "recently we committed to doubling the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01334-00332045-00332267": "number of spaces again we've also", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01335-00332268-00332509": "doubled childcare funding in Ontario to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01336-00332510-00332743": "close to 1.5 billion servers a year", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01337-00332744-00332947": "speaker we're transforming the way we're", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01338-00332948-00333113": "delivering early years in childcare", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01339-00333114-00333328": "unlike the party opposite we're working", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01340-00333329-00333506": "hard to get it right", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01341-00333507-00333670": "[Applause]", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01342-00333671-00333907": "yes see I should ease it up Thank You", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01343-00333908-00334072": "mr. speaker for all the work that she", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01344-00334073-00334276": "does on this file that is so important", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01345-00334277-00334533": "for all working parents across Ontario", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01346-00334534-00334810": "it's very encouraging I think that we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01347-00334811-00335008": "are continuing to work so hard on this", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01348-00335009-00335246": "file to address the needs of all Ontario", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01349-00335247-00335506": "families for the last 14 years I think", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01350-00335507-00335822": "we've made huge strides in the file of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01351-00335823-00336068": "child care and I know that the premier", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01352-00336069-00336259": "it's an important file for her as well", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01353-00336260-00336475": "so I think it's important for all", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01354-00336476-00336634": "Ontarians to know that the party", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01355-00336635-00336842": "opposite does not really have a plan on", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01356-00336843-00337006": "child care and I think it's very", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01357-00337007-00337207": "important that we all know that so I'm", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01358-00337208-00337412": "proud to be a member of a caucus that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01359-00337413-00337637": "believes in child care and that believes", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01360-00337638-00337820": "that working parents have a right to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01361-00337821-00338087": "have child care options for them and my", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01362-00338088-00338383": "constituents I know in Ottawa venya", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01363-00338384-00338618": "believe that as well many of them are", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01364-00338619-00338824": "young parents and continue to want to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01365-00338825-00338982": "have childcare options", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01366-00338983-00339287": "mr. speaker can the Minister tell the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01367-00339288-00339566": "house about this government's plans for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01368-00339567-00339638": "the next few years", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01369-00339639-00339907": "Thank You mr. Speaker I am pleased to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01370-00339908-00340112": "answer the members question speaker when", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01371-00340113-00340354": "the party opposite was in power there", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01372-00340355-00340565": "were no ministries dedicated to child", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01373-00340566-00340790": "care when the party opposite was in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01374-00340791-00340981": "power there was scarce funding for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01375-00340982-00341192": "childcare and when the party opposite", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01376-00341193-00341383": "was in power there were no commitments", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01377-00341384-00341608": "or investments made to improve childhood", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01378-00341609-00341891": "speakers that says volumes about the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01379-00341892-00342181": "party opposite they criticize and attack", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01380-00342182-00342583": "our hard work but the regard I said it", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01381-00342584-00343040": "once I'll say it again policy please no", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01382-00343041-00343249": "plan or track record but for us the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01383-00343250-00343415": "commitment to our children will never", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01384-00343416-00343624": "stop the premier made a historic", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01385-00343625-00343774": "commitment to ensure that a hundred", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01386-00343775-00343988": "thousand more children have access to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01387-00343989-00344152": "licensed childcare over the next five", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01388-00344153-00344390": "years the party opposite are the last", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01389-00344391-00344551": "people we take advice from they've", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01390-00344552-00344822": "consistently voted", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01391-00344823-00345371": "sit down that's disappointing new", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01392-00345372-00345808": "question remember from Nepean Carlton", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01393-00345809-00346028": "yesterday the government announced an", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01394-00346029-00346262": "opioid emergency task force to deal with", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01395-00346263-00346502": "the growing crisis around opioid abuse", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01396-00346503-00346735": "and overdoses in addition the government", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01397-00346736-00346937": "announced 220 million dollars to fight", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01398-00346938-00347153": "the opioid crisis given I've been", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01399-00347154-00347318": "calling for a task force since last", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01400-00347319-00347509": "February have openly supported these", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01401-00347510-00347654": "announcements and thanked the minister", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01402-00347655-00347840": "personally today the assembly will", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01403-00347841-00348038": "debate Nick's law which would dedicate a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01404-00348039-00348233": "portion of Ontario's advertising budget", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01405-00348234-00348458": "to opioid awareness and education and in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01406-00348459-00348685": "just 36 hours we have had over 24", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01407-00348686-00348859": "signatures on a petition calling for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01408-00348860-00349094": "this law to pass as a show of good faith", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01409-00349095-00349244": "I'm hoping that the minister will", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01410-00349245-00349787": "support this can he speak to it Mr", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01411-00349788-00349997": "Speaker I appreciate the number", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01412-00349998-00350339": "opposites advocacy on this a critically", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01413-00350340-00350642": "important subject and it is true she we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01414-00350643-00350891": "have had quite a number of conversations", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01415-00350892-00351206": "and she has been a powerful appropriate", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01416-00351207-00351451": "and tremendous advocate with regards to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01417-00351452-00351776": "Ontario facing a public health emergency", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01418-00351777-00352442": "with regards to opioids and I know that", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01419-00352443-00352664": "she's doing it from the right place and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01420-00352665-00353003": "in the spirit of wanting to make a", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01421-00353004-00353246": "difference in contribute to all our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01422-00353247-00353492": "efforts to diminish and eventually end", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01423-00353493-00353681": "this crisis I look forward to the debate", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01424-00353682-00354044": "this afternoon on her bill I applaud her", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01425-00354045-00354509": "from for for also focusing on the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01426-00354510-00354760": "reality that we among the many touch", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01427-00354761-00355007": "points we have to impact this public", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01428-00355008-00355184": "awareness and attention is a critically", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01429-00355185-00355406": "important aspect of that so thank you", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01430-00355407-00355520": "for the question I look forward to", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01431-00355521-00355634": "talking more in the supplementary in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01432-00355635-00355940": "detail on that thank you very much it", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01433-00355941-00356159": "was 2400 signatures that we got in 36", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01434-00356160-00356192": "hours", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01435-00356193-00356414": "Nick's law is named for Nick Cody who", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01436-00356415-00356594": "was a teenager when he died by overdose", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01437-00356595-00356807": "from what his dad said was just one bad", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01438-00356808-00357047": "pill the stories I hear every day would", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01439-00357048-00357287": "sink your heart kids as early as ten", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01440-00357288-00357416": "years old or taking pills that could", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01441-00357417-00357662": "contain a deadly dose of fentanyl", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01442-00357663-00357881": "yesterday I was shocked that car", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01443-00357882-00358040": "fentanyl has appeared on the streets of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01444-00358041-00358190": "the City of Ottawa just", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01445-00358191-00358381": "this into perspective it is 10,000 times", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01446-00358382-00358606": "more powerful than morphine and even", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01447-00358607-00358810": "stronger than fentanyl and it's being", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01448-00358811-00358954": "found on the streets in our city so we", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01449-00358955-00359192": "have to be much more diligent will the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01450-00359193-00359366": "Minister commit to an immediate public", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01451-00359367-00359552": "health advertising campaign to warn", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01452-00359553-00359747": "Ontarians against this deadly and potent", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01453-00359748-00359921": "drug that is now making the rounds in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01454-00359922-00360403": "Ottawa Thank You mr. speaker and we have", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01455-00360404-00360641": "committed to such a public health", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01456-00360642-00360896": "awareness and education campaign and in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01457-00360897-00361088": "fact we are implementing it mr. speaker", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01458-00361089-00361231": "so we're already working with their", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01459-00361232-00361421": "public health units providing them with", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01460-00361422-00361640": "the updated and necessary material so", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01461-00361641-00361906": "that through their ability including", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01462-00361907-00362165": "with their partners across Ontario can", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01463-00362166-00362297": "provide that critically important", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01464-00362298-00362423": "information we're working with the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01465-00362424-00362612": "Ministry of Education mr. speaker and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01466-00362613-00362873": "other ministries to ensure in the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01467-00362874-00363202": "correct way in an impactful way we are", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01468-00363203-00363430": "able to reach high school students those", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01469-00363431-00363583": "in colleges and universities who are", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01470-00363584-00363821": "working with the Minister of Higher", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01471-00363822-00364030": "Education at Advanced Education mr.", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01472-00364031-00364214": "speaker and we're also working with our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01473-00364215-00364442": "pharmacists to ensure that at the point", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01474-00364443-00364721": "of contact when an opioid prescription", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01475-00364722-00364885": "is either provided for the first time or", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01476-00364886-00365114": "renewed that that individual also have", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01477-00365115-00365278": "the requisite information and we're", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01478-00365279-00365471": "working with our bar owners and our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01479-00365472-00365701": "nightclubs so that at that point where", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01480-00365702-00365888": "we're able to reach those individuals", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01481-00365889-00366034": "appropriately with the right information", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01482-00366035-00366224": "and most importantly with our harm", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01483-00366225-00366385": "reduction work thank you for that same", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01484-00366386-00366488": "purpose", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01485-00366489-00367788": "[Applause]", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01486-00367789-00368079": "Minister of Transportation of part of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01487-00368080-00368259": "our speaker I didn't have a chance", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01488-00368260-00368472": "earlier today to welcome two guests", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01489-00368473-00368688": "Kathy and Peter Kitely who are here in", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01490-00368689-00368802": "the gallery I believe they are the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01491-00368803-00368985": "parents of my legislative assistant and", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01492-00368986-00369111": "issues manager Elana", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01493-00369112-00369669": "welcome to Queens Park I have a point of", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01494-00369670-00369825": "order for the Member of Parliament North", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01495-00369826-00370068": "Loop that we would want to hear I wish", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01496-00370069-00370329": "to inform this house with sadness the", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01497-00370330-00370653": "passing of my predecessor former MPP", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01498-00370654-00371120": "Norm Jameson NDP member for Norfolk from", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01499-00371121-00371817": "1990 to 1995 and to those of us who knew", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01500-00371818-00372327": "norm a true gentleman Friday October 6th", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01501-00372328-00372627": "is norms funeral and the flag here at", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01502-00372628-00373058": "Queen's Park will be at half-staff", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01503-00373059-00373449": "arrest us all I have another sad", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01504-00373450-00373935": "announcement", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01505-00373936-00374470": "a heavy heart this is the last day for", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01506-00374471-00374801": "our pages", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01507-00374802-00375125": "I would I would beg that we offer our", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01508-00375126-00375351": "thank you for the work that they've done", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01509-00375352-00378404": "[Applause]", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01510-00378405-00378759": "I'm glad we saved jocularity for another", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01511-00378760-00379026": "time so we will there are no deferred", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01512-00379027-00379268": "votes so therefore we will recess until", "W7XBcwcED9Y-01513-00379269-00379689": "1:00 p.m. this afternoon"}}, {"audio_id": "W7bfgDv0K9o", "text": {"W7bfgDv0K9o-00000-00000090-00000505": "[Music]", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00001-00000506-00000827": "every teacher at Warragul Road from prep", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00002-00000828-00001059": "through to year six and all of our", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00003-00001060-00001266": "specialist teachers as well is somehow", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00004-00001267-00001427": "involved in science whether they're", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00005-00001428-00001581": "teaching it in their classroom or", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00006-00001582-00001659": "supporting it", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00007-00001660-00001926": "teachers need a framework for how", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00008-00001927-00002136": "science is going to go from year level", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00009-00002137-00002343": "to year level and part of my job has", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00010-00002344-00002571": "also been to step back from the science", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00011-00002572-00002823": "curriculum and see it as a whole I've", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00012-00002824-00003069": "worked with schools that network with us", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00013-00003070-00003309": "so that they can see how we frame our", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00014-00003310-00003570": "science teaching and how we approach our", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00015-00003571-00003825": "science coaching so that our influence", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00016-00003826-00004095": "continues to grow the important thing", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00017-00004096-00004284": "about science is that it teaches you to", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00018-00004285-00004605": "look for the evidence we have so much", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00019-00004606-00004845": "information coming at our young people", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00020-00004846-00005279": "today that students need to understand", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00021-00005280-00005622": "that you need the facts I teach students", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00022-00005623-00005795": "not necessarily to look for the truth", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00023-00005796-00006024": "look for the facts when you know what", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00024-00006025-00006225": "the facts are you can work out for", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00025-00006226-00006434": "yourself what the truth is", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00026-00006436-00006659": "winning the prime minister's prize for", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00027-00006661-00006801": "excellence in science teaching in", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00028-00006802-00006980": "primary schools is for me and", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00029-00006981-00007202": "affirmation that what we're doing here", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00030-00007203-00007452": "at War Eagle Road is recognized as", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00031-00007453-00007634": "quality science teaching and that we are", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00032-00007635-00007869": "doing the best possible work for our", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00033-00007870-00008174": "students I love it when we find", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00034-00008175-00008391": "something happening in an experiment and", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00035-00008392-00008658": "the student turns to me and says mr.", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00036-00008659-00008891": "Crawford why is this going on and I can", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00037-00008892-00009121": "say to them I don't know isn't it great", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00038-00009122-00009491": "because that means that we are mutually", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00039-00009492-00009746": "learning something new it empowers them", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00040-00009747-00009930": "and then they take that on to the next", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00041-00009931-00010119": "level in the next level and you explain", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00042-00010120-00010492": "to them no not magic science", "W7bfgDv0K9o-00043-00010493-00010699": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "W8d03KOX_Eg", "text": {"W8d03KOX_Eg-00000-00000051-00000403": "Warrior is a 1979 arcade fighting game", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00001-00000404-00000596": "it is considered one of the first", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00002-00000597-00000841": "fighting games accepting several boxing", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00003-00000842-00001039": "games such as heavyweight champ released", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00004-00001040-00001385": "in 1976 an Ataris unreleased boxer which", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00005-00001386-00001648": "was cloned as 1980s boxing for the Atari", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00006-00001650-00002048": "2600 developed by Tim Skelly while", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00007-00002049-00002218": "working at cinema tronics it was", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00008-00002219-00002387": "released under the vector beam company", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00009-00002388-00002584": "name shortly before cinema tronics", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00010-00002585-00002743": "closed vector beam down they had", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00011-00002744-00003073": "purchased the company in 1978 the game", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00012-00003074-00003265": "featured two dueling Knights rendered in", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00013-00003266-00003467": "monochrome vector graphics and based on", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00014-00003468-00003749": "crude motion capture techniques due to", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00015-00003750-00003961": "the limitations of the hardware used the", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00016-00003962-00004106": "processor could not render the", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00017-00004107-00004304": "characters in gaming environment at the", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00018-00004305-00004504": "same time and backgrounds were printed", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00019-00004505-00005202": "with the characters projected on the top", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00020-00005203-00005739": "topic controls", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00021-00005740-00005941": "originally Skelly planned for a", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00022-00005942-00006151": "two-player system with each player using", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00023-00006152-00006334": "two joysticks one to control the", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00024-00006335-00006468": "movement of the player and the other", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00025-00006469-00006706": "controlling the players weapon however", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00026-00006706-00006931": "financial constraints restricted the", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00027-00006931-00007144": "cabinet to one stick for each player and", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00028-00007145-00007327": "a button to switch between character and", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00029-00007328-00007576": "weapon modes the sticks were produced", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00030-00007577-00007792": "in-house and installed in cabinets in a", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00031-00007793-00008017": "way that players found unresponsive and", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00032-00008018-00008612": "difficult to use", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00033-00008613-00009138": "topic influence", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00034-00009139-00009372": "the cabinets and hardware were produced", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00035-00009373-00009555": "on a low budget and proved to be very", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00036-00009556-00009753": "unreliable when compared to contemporary", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00037-00009754-00010110": "machines as a result very few remain in", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00038-00010111-00010251": "working order with 10 machines", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00039-00010252-00010506": "registered with Kay LOV and only one", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00040-00010507-00010695": "known restored machine in the United", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00041-00010696-00011401": "Kingdom warrior as emulated by Mae", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00042-00011402-00011906": "topic see also", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00043-00011907-00012285": "list of fighting games list of fighting", "W8d03KOX_Eg-00044-00012286-00012567": "game developers"}}, {"audio_id": "W80RjYSxr3M", "text": {"W80RjYSxr3M-00000-00000247-00002383": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00001-00002384-00002767": "[Laughter]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00002-00002768-00003091": "my mind", "W80RjYSxr3M-00003-00003092-00004047": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00004-00004047-00004448": "go go", "W80RjYSxr3M-00005-00004449-00005310": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00006-00005311-00007103": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00007-00007104-00007414": "come on kill me i'm here come on do it", "W80RjYSxr3M-00008-00007415-00008023": "now oh [__] not good", "W80RjYSxr3M-00009-00008023-00009219": "moving", "W80RjYSxr3M-00010-00009220-00009639": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00011-00009640-00010951": "hello", "W80RjYSxr3M-00012-00010952-00011151": "oh [__] not good", "W80RjYSxr3M-00013-00011152-00011510": "fast as [__]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00014-00011511-00011754": "okay let's go", "W80RjYSxr3M-00015-00011755-00012263": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00016-00012264-00013966": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00017-00013968-00014055": "hey", "W80RjYSxr3M-00018-00014056-00015958": "that's pretty good", "W80RjYSxr3M-00019-00015959-00016294": "foreign", "W80RjYSxr3M-00020-00016296-00016806": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00021-00016807-00017531": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00022-00017532-00017879": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00023-00017880-00018260": "that's quite big go go go go fast", "W80RjYSxr3M-00024-00018261-00019558": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00025-00019559-00019727": "hello", "W80RjYSxr3M-00026-00019728-00020158": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00027-00020159-00020775": "oh my god beautiful oh [__] not good", "W80RjYSxr3M-00028-00020776-00022111": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00029-00022112-00022287": "oh", "W80RjYSxr3M-00030-00022288-00023111": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00031-00023112-00023527": "brown", "W80RjYSxr3M-00032-00023528-00024191": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00033-00024192-00024448": "um", "W80RjYSxr3M-00034-00024449-00025175": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00035-00025176-00026143": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00036-00026144-00026483": "no", "W80RjYSxr3M-00037-00026483-00027695": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00038-00027695-00027911": "yeah what's up", "W80RjYSxr3M-00039-00027912-00028016": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00040-00028017-00028487": "[Laughter]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00041-00028488-00028620": "wow", "W80RjYSxr3M-00042-00028622-00030207": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00043-00030208-00030462": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00044-00030463-00030924": "nope", "W80RjYSxr3M-00045-00030925-00031999": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00046-00032000-00033170": "i got you", "W80RjYSxr3M-00047-00033171-00034295": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00048-00034296-00034766": "oh", "W80RjYSxr3M-00049-00034767-00035359": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00050-00035360-00035882": "oh [__] not good", "W80RjYSxr3M-00051-00035883-00037239": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00052-00037240-00037502": "meanwhile in our universe", "W80RjYSxr3M-00053-00037503-00037599": "yeah", "W80RjYSxr3M-00054-00037600-00037790": "i know how to be i know nobody staying", "W80RjYSxr3M-00055-00037791-00037943": "i'm trying not to get back in my ways", "W80RjYSxr3M-00056-00037944-00038055": "this life that i'm chasing ain't all", "W80RjYSxr3M-00057-00038056-00038230": "about fame i gotta go keep my head in", "W80RjYSxr3M-00058-00038231-00038390": "the game i'll never do what they wanted", "W80RjYSxr3M-00059-00038391-00038559": "me to how i did it my son went walking", "W80RjYSxr3M-00060-00038560-00038695": "me through cause for me i never had", "W80RjYSxr3M-00061-00038696-00038823": "nothing to prove and i said i'm", "W80RjYSxr3M-00062-00038824-00038959": "different y'all here in the pool know", "W80RjYSxr3M-00063-00038960-00039111": "what they think i don't pay anymore they", "W80RjYSxr3M-00064-00039112-00039283": "said they would write ain't that", "W80RjYSxr3M-00065-00039284-00039423": "anymore this [__] got me slowing me down", "W80RjYSxr3M-00066-00039424-00039623": "when i'm in the city they notice me now", "W80RjYSxr3M-00067-00039624-00039774": "cause no matter what got my mind on the", "W80RjYSxr3M-00068-00039775-00039911": "money and if you don't know me then you", "W80RjYSxr3M-00069-00039912-00040039": "shouldn't judge me", "W80RjYSxr3M-00070-00040040-00040262": "and you shouldn't judge me yeah hey they", "W80RjYSxr3M-00071-00040263-00040430": "checking on me i said girl looking out", "W80RjYSxr3M-00072-00040431-00040567": "don't wanna hear what they talking about", "W80RjYSxr3M-00073-00040568-00040695": "like do you gotta plan if [__] ain't", "W80RjYSxr3M-00074-00040696-00040846": "working out don't talk to me and keep", "W80RjYSxr3M-00075-00040847-00040958": "calming me down and i know your", "W80RjYSxr3M-00076-00040959-00041111": "intentions ain't really the worst i know", "W80RjYSxr3M-00077-00041112-00041246": "you don't know that i'm putting in work", "W80RjYSxr3M-00078-00041247-00041383": "but trying my best but this [__] really", "W80RjYSxr3M-00079-00041384-00041551": "hurt i ain't had nobody was down on my", "W80RjYSxr3M-00080-00041552-00041751": "worst i ain't had no body i was wishing", "W80RjYSxr3M-00081-00041752-00041990": "i hired somebody if i do it don't stop", "W80RjYSxr3M-00082-00041991-00042205": "me keep it moving i can't", "W80RjYSxr3M-00083-00042206-00043287": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00084-00043288-00044573": "so i could be rich forever", "W80RjYSxr3M-00085-00044574-00044911": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00086-00044912-00045071": "i never did what they wanted me to how", "W80RjYSxr3M-00087-00045072-00045215": "did it my son went walking me through", "W80RjYSxr3M-00088-00045216-00045358": "cause really i never had nothing to", "W80RjYSxr3M-00089-00045359-00045487": "prove and i said i'm different y'all", "W80RjYSxr3M-00090-00045488-00045630": "hearing the proof look what they think i", "W80RjYSxr3M-00091-00045631-00045774": "don't care anymore they said he would", "W80RjYSxr3M-00092-00045775-00045967": "write ain't that anymore this [__] got", "W80RjYSxr3M-00093-00045968-00046127": "me slowing me down when i'm in the city", "W80RjYSxr3M-00094-00046128-00046318": "they notice me now cause no matter what", "W80RjYSxr3M-00095-00046319-00046462": "got my mind on the money and if you", "W80RjYSxr3M-00096-00046463-00046583": "don't know me then you shouldn't judge", "W80RjYSxr3M-00097-00046584-00046655": "me", "W80RjYSxr3M-00098-00046656-00046967": "and you shouldn't judge me yet", "W80RjYSxr3M-00099-00046968-00047062": "yeah", "W80RjYSxr3M-00100-00047063-00047215": "i know how i'd be i know nobody's", "W80RjYSxr3M-00101-00047216-00047374": "staying i'm trying not to get back in my", "W80RjYSxr3M-00102-00047375-00047511": "ways it's like that i'm chasing ain't", "W80RjYSxr3M-00103-00047512-00047686": "all about fame i gotta go keep my head", "W80RjYSxr3M-00104-00047687-00047862": "in the game i never did what they wanted", "W80RjYSxr3M-00105-00047863-00048039": "me to how did it my son went walking me", "W80RjYSxr3M-00106-00048040-00048199": "through cause really i never had nothing", "W80RjYSxr3M-00107-00048200-00048335": "to prove and i said i'm different y'all", "W80RjYSxr3M-00108-00048336-00048479": "hearing the proof know what they think i", "W80RjYSxr3M-00109-00048480-00048623": "don't care anymore they said they would", "W80RjYSxr3M-00110-00048624-00048830": "write ain't that anymore [__] got me", "W80RjYSxr3M-00111-00048831-00048974": "slowing me down when i'm in the city", "W80RjYSxr3M-00112-00048975-00049111": "they notice me now", "W80RjYSxr3M-00113-00049112-00049271": "no matter what got my mind on the money", "W80RjYSxr3M-00114-00049272-00049374": "and if you don't know me then you", "W80RjYSxr3M-00115-00049375-00049502": "shouldn't judge me", "W80RjYSxr3M-00116-00049503-00049735": "and you shouldn't judge me yeah hey they", "W80RjYSxr3M-00117-00049736-00049895": "checking on me i said girl looking out", "W80RjYSxr3M-00118-00049896-00050039": "don't wanna hear what they talking about", "W80RjYSxr3M-00119-00050040-00050158": "like do you gotta plan if [__] ain't", "W80RjYSxr3M-00120-00050159-00050311": "working out don't talk to me if you", "W80RjYSxr3M-00121-00050312-00050423": "talking me down and i know your", "W80RjYSxr3M-00122-00050424-00050574": "intentions ain't really the worst i know", "W80RjYSxr3M-00123-00050575-00050711": "you don't know that i'm putting in work", "W80RjYSxr3M-00124-00050712-00050855": "but trying my best but this [__] really", "W80RjYSxr3M-00125-00050856-00051015": "hurt i ain't had nobody was down in my", "W80RjYSxr3M-00126-00051016-00051214": "worst i ain't had no body i was wishing", "W80RjYSxr3M-00127-00051215-00051390": "that i had somebody if i do what that", "W80RjYSxr3M-00128-00051391-00051590": "picture would stop me", "W80RjYSxr3M-00129-00051591-00052052": "i'm sorry", "W80RjYSxr3M-00130-00052053-00054040": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00131-00054041-00054687": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00132-00054688-00054830": "cause really i never had nothing to", "W80RjYSxr3M-00133-00054832-00054950": "prove and i said i'm different y'all", "W80RjYSxr3M-00134-00054951-00055103": "hearing the proof but what they think i", "W80RjYSxr3M-00135-00055104-00055238": "don't care anymore they say they will", "W80RjYSxr3M-00136-00055239-00055430": "write ain't that anymore this [__] can't", "W80RjYSxr3M-00137-00055432-00055591": "be slowing me down when i'm in the city", "W80RjYSxr3M-00138-00055591-00055775": "they notice me now there's no matter", "W80RjYSxr3M-00139-00055776-00055926": "what got my mind on the money and if you", "W80RjYSxr3M-00140-00055927-00056054": "don't know me then you shouldn't judge", "W80RjYSxr3M-00141-00056055-00056959": "me", "W80RjYSxr3M-00142-00056960-00057135": "ain't all about fame i gotta go keep my", "W80RjYSxr3M-00143-00057136-00057294": "head in the game i never did what they", "W80RjYSxr3M-00144-00057295-00057463": "wanted me to i did it my son and one", "W80RjYSxr3M-00145-00057464-00058207": "walking me", "W80RjYSxr3M-00146-00058208-00058575": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00147-00058576-00059144": "no matter what got my mind on", "W80RjYSxr3M-00148-00059145-00059726": "[Music]", "W80RjYSxr3M-00149-00059727-00059871": "honey and if you don't know me then you", "W80RjYSxr3M-00150-00059872-00059999": "shouldn't judge me", "W80RjYSxr3M-00151-00060000-00060223": "and you shouldn't judge me yeah hey they", "W80RjYSxr3M-00152-00060224-00060391": "checking on me i said good looking now", "W80RjYSxr3M-00153-00060391-00060535": "don't wanna hear what they talking about", "W80RjYSxr3M-00154-00060536-00060654": "like do you gotta plan if [__] ain't", "W80RjYSxr3M-00155-00060655-00060936": "working out don't"}}, {"audio_id": "W8qWFfX8NCM", "text": {"W8qWFfX8NCM-00000-00000098-00001702": "[Music]", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00001-00001703-00001926": "welcome to the last", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00002-00001927-00002047": "module", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00003-00002048-00002359": "of points topology course", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00004-00002360-00002710": "part one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00005-00002711-00002934": "so we shall continue the study of", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00006-00002935-00003367": "topological vector space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00007-00003368-00003647": "several important basic results you have", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00008-00003647-00003919": "derived already", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00009-00003920-00004111": "so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00010-00004112-00004438": "in this last module i will prove", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00011-00004439-00004902": "three important results about", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00012-00004903-00005286": "topological vector spaces", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00013-00005287-00005535": "the first one is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00014-00005536-00005654": "every", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00015-00005655-00006127": "finite dimensional vector subspace y", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00016-00006128-00006383": "of v", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00017-00006384-00006751": "is linearly homomorphic to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00018-00006752-00007119": "k power n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00019-00007120-00007470": "further if b is hausdorff", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00020-00007472-00007710": "which is same thing as just assuming", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00021-00007711-00007887": "t naughtness", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00022-00007888-00008023": "then", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00023-00008023-00008639": "y is a closed surface of v also", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00024-00008640-00008799": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00025-00008800-00008974": "every finite dimensional vector sub", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00026-00008975-00009135": "space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00027-00009136-00009239": "is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00028-00009240-00009446": "linearly yogi martial this linear", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00029-00009447-00009823": "isomorphism together", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00030-00009824-00010071": "without uh", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00031-00010072-00010383": "without the assumption of as darkness", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00032-00010384-00010606": "it need not be the closest of space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00033-00010607-00010791": "because you can always take indiscreet", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00034-00010792-00010951": "apology", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00035-00010952-00011310": "on any metabolized electric space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00036-00011311-00011527": "then the only", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00037-00011528-00011710": "close subsets will be empty set of the", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00038-00011711-00012006": "whole space okay so that's very easy to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00039-00012007-00012438": "see that the condition is necessary here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00040-00012439-00012735": "okay so here is a proof", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00041-00012736-00013127": "start with a basis for y", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00042-00013128-00013415": "say you are new to n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00043-00013416-00013599": "then the map", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00044-00013600-00013943": "f of e i going to ui", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00045-00013944-00014199": "extends linearly", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00046-00014200-00014455": "to an isomorphism from", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00047-00014456-00014591": "k n to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00048-00014591-00014807": "y", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00049-00014808-00015047": "right so linear part is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00050-00015047-00015199": "done", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00051-00015200-00015471": "already we have seen that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00052-00015472-00015799": "in the last uh", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00053-00015800-00016271": "corollary of the previous scenario that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00054-00016272-00016550": "any linear map is continuous so f is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00055-00016551-00016679": "continuous", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00056-00016680-00016919": "the only thing that is missing is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00057-00016920-00017183": "f inverse should be also continuous", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00058-00017184-00017503": "from y to k n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00059-00017504-00017807": "okay so this is what we have to show", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00060-00017808-00018111": "now you take s to be the unit sphere in", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00061-00018112-00018286": "k n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00062-00018287-00018486": "okay i am taking k n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00063-00018487-00018711": "this is euclidean topology i can take so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00064-00018712-00018886": "i talk about unit sphere there there is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00065-00018887-00019030": "no problem", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00066-00019031-00019350": "then we know that s is compact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00067-00019351-00019558": "under continuous image compact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00068-00019559-00019814": "substitute compact subsets so fs is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00069-00019815-00020103": "compact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00070-00020104-00020350": "now f is injective", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00071-00020351-00020550": "so f 0 goes to 0", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00072-00020551-00020814": "so non-zero vectors won't go to 0 that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00073-00020815-00021007": "means", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00074-00021008-00021367": "0 is not in f of s", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00075-00021368-00021558": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00076-00021559-00021694": "now", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00077-00021695-00022039": "b be a balanced neighborhood of zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00078-00022040-00022358": "which does not intersect fs", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00079-00022359-00022678": "see fs is a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00080-00022679-00022919": "compact subset", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00081-00022920-00023199": "okay so i can choose", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00082-00023200-00023478": "zero is not there so you can choose", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00083-00023479-00023686": "some neighborhood here which is disjoint", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00084-00023687-00023807": "from that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00085-00023808-00024071": "it's a regularity or whatever but i want", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00086-00024072-00024239": "to choose it as a balanced neighborhood", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00087-00024240-00024430": "also", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00088-00024431-00024719": "all right any two one compact subset and", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00089-00024720-00024903": "a closed subset can be separated that's", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00090-00024904-00025086": "what you have already seen", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00091-00025087-00025271": "so for that you don't need", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00092-00025272-00025503": "australism", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00093-00025504-00025599": "so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00094-00025600-00025887": "see slowly i'm using all the results we", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00095-00025888-00026111": "have proved in the past two lectures for", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00096-00026112-00026374": "topological vector spaces", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00097-00026375-00026590": "to choose a bead a balancer neighbor", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00098-00026591-00026679": "zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00099-00026680-00027135": "which does not intersect f s", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00100-00027136-00027302": "all right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00101-00027304-00027535": "put a equal to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00102-00027536-00027887": "f inverse of b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00103-00027888-00028087": "okay which is same thing as f inverse of", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00104-00028088-00028318": "b intersection y because", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00105-00028319-00028670": "the image of f is the order of y", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00106-00028672-00028855": "is contained inside y that's why it is a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00107-00028856-00029135": "figures of b intersection y", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00108-00029136-00029270": "all right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00109-00029272-00029502": "a is a neighborhood of zero because f is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00110-00029504-00029774": "continuous", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00111-00029775-00030102": "since f inverse is linear also linearity", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00112-00030103-00030239": "there is no problem", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00113-00030239-00030358": "what we are trying to prove is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00114-00030360-00030502": "continuity of f", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00115-00030503-00030670": "it follows that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00116-00030672-00031535": "this is a balanced set of", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00117-00031536-00031814": "you have to check though", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00118-00031816-00032079": "from the balanced neighborhood of b it", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00119-00032080-00032407": "hollows it a is also balanced", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00120-00032408-00032670": "so scalar multiplications comes here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00121-00032672-00032927": "because f is a bijection", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00122-00032928-00033183": "okay alpha times some vector", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00123-00033184-00033318": "is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00124-00033319-00033631": "alpha times f of some vector so that's", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00125-00033632-00033846": "all i have to use to show that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00126-00033847-00034135": "b is balanced and implies a is balanced", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00127-00034136-00034327": "in particular", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00128-00034328-00034407": "if", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00129-00034408-00034671": "z is a point inside a then the entire", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00130-00034672-00035079": "line segment 0 that will be inside a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00131-00035080-00035343": "this is the property of balance that we", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00132-00035344-00035599": "have seen all the time", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00133-00035600-00035759": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00134-00035760-00035990": "so this implies that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00135-00035991-00036223": "a is star shaped at zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00136-00036224-00036367": "all the line segments are there", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00137-00036368-00036574": "therefore in particular", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00138-00036575-00036895": "a is connected", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00139-00036896-00037046": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00140-00037047-00037415": "now a intersection s is empty", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00141-00037416-00037702": "because i have started with b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00142-00037703-00037855": "intersection", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00143-00037856-00038135": "f of s is empty", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00144-00038136-00038255": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00145-00038256-00038583": "so you know that the unit ball", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00146-00038584-00038718": "inside", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00147-00038719-00038846": "k n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00148-00038847-00039135": "okay whether it is k equal to r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00149-00039136-00039487": "r k equal to r or z unit bar", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00150-00039488-00039767": "always separate the whole whole uh k", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00151-00039768-00039983": "power n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00152-00039984-00040095": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00153-00040096-00040287": "namely those things which are strictly", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00154-00040288-00040415": "inside and those things should be", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00155-00040416-00040527": "outside", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00156-00040528-00040662": "so there are two", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00157-00040663-00040943": "disjoint open subsets right so since a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00158-00040944-00041127": "intersection s is empty", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00159-00041128-00041430": "a is connected it follows that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00160-00041431-00041702": "a must be contained in the open unit", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00161-00041703-00042207": "disk in scan center zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00162-00042208-00042367": "right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00163-00042368-00042471": "now", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00164-00042472-00042735": "given any epsilon positive it follows", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00165-00042736-00042823": "that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00166-00042824-00043207": "if you take f inverse of epsilon b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00167-00043208-00043407": "that will be epsilon times f inverse of", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00168-00043408-00043727": "b by linearity of f inverse", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00169-00043728-00043830": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00170-00043831-00044046": "but this epsilon b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00171-00044047-00044302": "that epsilon times f inverse of b is b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00172-00044303-00044390": "is a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00173-00044391-00044558": "that's epsilon a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00174-00044559-00044767": "plus epsilon a will be contained inside", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00175-00044768-00044967": "epsilon", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00176-00044968-00045199": "because a is contained inside this unit", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00177-00045200-00045279": "bar", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00178-00045280-00045358": "d", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00179-00045359-00045583": "okay i can write this as", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00180-00045584-00045862": "d power n but that's not correct because", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00181-00045863-00046127": "i don't know whether k is the r or c so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00182-00046128-00046415": "it depends upon which may be d 2 d2n or", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00183-00046416-00046711": "dn so i have just written as d unit disk", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00184-00046712-00046855": "here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00185-00046856-00047095": "this implies that now we see f inverse", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00186-00047096-00047374": "of epsilon b is continuously", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00187-00047375-00047886": "f inverse is continuous at zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00188-00047887-00048023": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00189-00048024-00048423": "so 0 is an element of y so y", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00190-00048424-00048655": "2", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00191-00048656-00048967": "k power n we have shown that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00192-00048968-00049255": "this linear map is continuous", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00193-00049256-00049486": "but why it's a linear space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00194-00049487-00049790": "y is also topological vector space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00195-00049791-00050030": "continuity at zero is inverse is enough", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00196-00050031-00050190": "to show that asphenous is continuous", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00197-00050191-00050502": "everywhere", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00198-00050503-00050739": "okay see how", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00199-00050740-00050999": "connectivity finally has been used to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00200-00051000-00051143": "show that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00201-00051144-00051775": "the inverse is continuous", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00202-00051776-00051919": "all right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00203-00051920-00052094": "so this is one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00204-00052095-00052471": "one important theorem", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00205-00052472-00052791": "well i have to show as the", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00206-00052791-00053063": "other part namely suppose", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00207-00053064-00053238": "v is house dog", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00208-00053239-00053471": "then i want to show that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00209-00053472-00053687": "y equal to y bar", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00210-00053688-00053975": "namely y is closed also", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00211-00053976-00054150": "why it is closed that's what you have to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00212-00054151-00054230": "show", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00213-00054232-00054503": "given p belong to y bar", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00214-00054504-00054759": "by continuity of scalar multiplication", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00215-00054760-00054903": "it shows that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00216-00054904-00055303": "there exists a t positive so sad", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00217-00055304-00055375": "p", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00218-00055376-00055782": "is inside t times b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00219-00055783-00056030": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00220-00056032-00056407": "all right see the wall of five actually", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00221-00056408-00056638": "there are various ways of seeing this", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00222-00056639-00056854": "the y bar is contained inside the whole", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00223-00056855-00056950": "of v", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00224-00056951-00057223": "the whole of we take any point that this", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00225-00057224-00057359": "one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00226-00057360-00057487": "the larger", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00227-00057488-00057575": "the", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00228-00057576-00057759": "the bigger and bigger multiples of b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00229-00057760-00057999": "will cover the whole of it so some t", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00230-00058000-00058142": "times b will be", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00231-00058144-00058550": "will contain b p or every p therefore", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00232-00058551-00058799": "p will be inside", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00233-00058800-00059047": "y bar intersection t b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00234-00059048-00059254": "p is already inside y bar", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00235-00059255-00059494": "and p equal to t b so it is inside this", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00236-00059495-00059823": "one you can take a closure", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00237-00059824-00059975": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00238-00059976-00060103": "so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00239-00060104-00060375": "that closure is contained inside", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00240-00060376-00060806": "f of t a bar", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00241-00060807-00060959": "right because", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00242-00060960-00061342": "a is nothing but f inverse of b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00243-00061344-00061566": "okay so if we apply f", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00244-00061567-00061823": "f of", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00245-00061824-00062087": "f itself y is what what why why itself", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00246-00062088-00062342": "is f of the whole thing right so the", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00247-00062344-00062535": "whole thing is in the image f of this so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00248-00062536-00062815": "this kind of f of t a bar so y is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00249-00062816-00062991": "something with f of k", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00250-00062991-00063126": "after all everything is there so there", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00251-00063127-00063399": "is no need to write why at all if it", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00252-00063400-00063591": "either v there was a problem so the", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00253-00063591-00063750": "whole thing is inside the image so this", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00254-00063751-00064015": "contains f of t a bar now", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00255-00064016-00064191": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00256-00064191-00064479": "but this f of t a bar", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00257-00064479-00064726": "is contained inside you can write t a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00258-00064727-00065135": "bar here and then could take the closure", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00259-00065136-00065471": "okay 50 a bar and then take the closure", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00260-00065472-00065855": "but t a bar is compact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00261-00065856-00066126": "see complex subset of k n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00262-00066127-00066311": "right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00263-00066312-00066575": "the a is a bounded subset already inside", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00264-00066576-00066743": "contained inside", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00265-00066744-00067103": "the unit is its closure is compared", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00266-00067104-00067375": "okay so it's complex", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00267-00067376-00067735": "f of t a bar", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00268-00067736-00067967": "once a bar is compared t times a bar is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00269-00067968-00068223": "also compared because t is anyway some", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00270-00068224-00068359": "scalar", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00271-00068360-00068638": "so f of t a bar will be a closed subset", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00272-00068639-00068759": "of v", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00273-00068760-00068982": "because it is compact and v is housed", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00274-00068983-00069247": "all so this is where we are using first", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00275-00069248-00069494": "time that we solved off", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00276-00069495-00069591": "that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00277-00069592-00069782": "closed subset", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00278-00069783-00070015": "uh compact subsets are close that's what", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00279-00070016-00070247": "you have used", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00280-00070248-00070511": "okay so therefore", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00281-00070512-00070591": "p", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00282-00070592-00070823": "which is inside f of t a bar there is no", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00283-00070824-00071047": "need to take the closure here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00284-00071048-00071406": "the p is inside f of t a bar but f of t", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00285-00071407-00071726": "a bar is after all inside y because", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00286-00071727-00072150": "f of whole k n is y", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00287-00072151-00072447": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00288-00072448-00072719": "so p is inside y that's what we have", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00289-00072720-00072975": "y bar is contained inside y therefore y", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00290-00072976-00073391": "bar is equal to y", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00291-00073392-00073494": "all right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00292-00073495-00073679": "so closure", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00293-00073680-00073959": "property follows by again inevitable", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00294-00073960-00074282": "theorem that close subsets of k ns are", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00295-00074283-00074447": "compact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00296-00074448-00074647": "so all very important things have been", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00297-00074648-00074831": "used here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00298-00074832-00075159": "all right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00299-00075160-00075526": "so let's go to the next result", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00300-00075527-00075750": "for which i'll make a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00301-00075751-00076038": "temporary definition", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00302-00076039-00076287": "of local compactness", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00303-00076288-00076471": "later on", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00304-00076472-00076662": "in part two we will study local", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00305-00076663-00076919": "compactness on its own", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00306-00076920-00077255": "for arbitrary topological spaces here is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00307-00077256-00077479": "a tentative definition", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00308-00077480-00077559": "for", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00309-00077560-00077975": "a topological vector space v", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00310-00077976-00078359": "is locally compact if there exists", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00311-00078360-00078743": "a neighborhood o of zero such that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00312-00078744-00079071": "the closure of o is compact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00313-00079072-00079279": "so there is a compact neighborhood", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00314-00079280-00079575": "for the", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00315-00079576-00079703": "zero element", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00316-00079704-00079982": "stead saw", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00317-00079983-00080143": "okay so that is the meaning of local", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00318-00080144-00080487": "compact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00319-00080488-00080623": "all right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00320-00080624-00080879": "with this one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00321-00080880-00080950": "so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00322-00080951-00081119": "we make this", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00323-00081120-00081606": "uh final result about", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00324-00081607-00081831": "topological vector spaces and finite", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00325-00081832-00082006": "dimensionality", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00326-00082007-00082159": "see", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00327-00082160-00082447": "we have already proved that a norm", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00328-00082448-00082623": "linear space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00329-00082624-00082750": "is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00330-00082751-00083071": "finite dimensional if filled only", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00331-00083072-00083631": "the unit sphere in it is compact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00332-00083632-00083767": "in the topological vector space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00333-00083768-00084006": "situation there is no unit sphere there", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00334-00084007-00084206": "is no way there is no concept of unit", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00335-00084207-00084503": "sphere because there is no metric", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00336-00084504-00084887": "so the local compactness is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00337-00084888-00085255": "is an indirect way of bringing that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00338-00085256-00085375": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00339-00085376-00085711": "once unit sphere is compact the disk was", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00340-00085712-00085887": "compact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00341-00085888-00085982": "so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00342-00085983-00086271": "telling that normal space unit sphere is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00343-00086272-00086559": "compact is equivalent to saying that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00344-00086560-00086862": "it has a compact neighborhood the 0 has", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00345-00086863-00087055": "a compact neighborhood", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00346-00087056-00087231": "and that compact neighborhood makes", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00347-00087232-00087487": "sense so that is the definition of local", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00348-00087488-00087662": "compactness here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00349-00087663-00087887": "so we have brought back", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00350-00087888-00088111": "you know avoiding the metric", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00351-00088112-00088335": "a compactness", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00352-00088336-00088526": "property can be always generalized so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00353-00088527-00088831": "its local compactness has come here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00354-00088832-00089055": "okay so that is what it is and the", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00355-00089056-00089311": "expected theorem here is that now", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00356-00089312-00089606": "every locally compared vector space is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00357-00089607-00089775": "finite dimensional", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00358-00089776-00089991": "and corners converse we have already", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00359-00089992-00090175": "proved", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00360-00090176-00090406": "if and only if converse we have already", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00361-00090407-00090671": "proved why because any finite", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00362-00090672-00090831": "dimensional vector space we have just", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00363-00090832-00091079": "proved that it is isomorphic to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00364-00091080-00091279": "k kn", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00365-00091280-00091479": "linearly isomorphic cane so in", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00366-00091480-00091815": "particular homeomorphism therefore", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00367-00091816-00091959": "we know that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00368-00091960-00092303": "it is locally compact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00369-00092304-00092543": "okay so we have to prove that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00370-00092544-00092735": "if it's locally compact then it is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00371-00092736-00093006": "finite dimensional", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00372-00093007-00093294": "now the proof of this one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00373-00093295-00093606": "may be little slightly longer", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00374-00093607-00093767": "i am not very sure", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00375-00093768-00094031": "but this much more elegant than the", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00376-00094032-00094223": "proof for", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00377-00094224-00094462": "normal spaces", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00378-00094463-00094550": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00379-00094551-00094799": "it's more or less canonical proof here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00380-00094800-00095006": "so just observe that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00381-00095007-00095367": "okay if part is an easy consequence of", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00382-00095368-00095559": "earlier theorem that we approached that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00383-00095560-00095735": "every", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00384-00095736-00095911": "finite dimensional vector space and", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00385-00095912-00096126": "topological vector space is isomorphic", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00386-00096127-00096238": "to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00387-00096239-00096367": "kn", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00388-00096368-00096623": "so let us prove the conversion", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00389-00096624-00096903": "now let me be hostile and locally", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00390-00096904-00097167": "compact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00391-00097168-00097391": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00392-00097392-00097703": "did i prove that holderness is forward", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00393-00097704-00098006": "first off it's hostile locally compact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00394-00098007-00098182": "and", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00395-00098183-00098494": "okay house darkness is a must here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00396-00098495-00098662": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00397-00098663-00098911": "so locally compact and finite damage", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00398-00098912-00099103": "vector spaces are automatically housed", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00399-00099104-00099303": "up right so so i don't have to worry", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00400-00099304-00099487": "about that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00401-00099488-00100015": "so a locally compact and half dollar", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00402-00100016-00100223": "so assume that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00403-00100224-00100518": "and choose a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00404-00100519-00100871": "neighborhood b is a set b bar is compact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00405-00100872-00101071": "that is local compact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00406-00101072-00101359": "so we get finite number of vectors v and", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00407-00101360-00101759": "u to v n belonging to v such that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00408-00101760-00102031": "b bar is compact is contained inside", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00409-00102032-00102262": "finitely many", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00410-00102263-00102663": "you know translates of half bar", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00411-00102664-00102918": "half the ball that is an open subset of", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00412-00102919-00103071": "the neighborhood", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00413-00103072-00103263": "x i plus this one will be a neighborhood", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00414-00103264-00103454": "of x i", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00415-00103455-00103742": "x i's are taken all over v they will", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00416-00103743-00103902": "cover b bar", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00417-00103903-00104158": "but then you can choose finite limiting", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00418-00104159-00104318": "v one v to v n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00419-00104319-00104551": "so set iron into one to n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00420-00104552-00104815": "v i plus half b will cover the whole", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00421-00104816-00105127": "thing", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00422-00105128-00105295": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00423-00105296-00105431": "so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00424-00105432-00105734": "let v prime be a linear span of v one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00425-00105735-00106007": "with v n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00426-00106008-00106278": "then v prime is a finite dimension", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00427-00106279-00106631": "because it's spanned by only n elements", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00428-00106632-00106823": "therefore by", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00429-00106824-00107223": "5.56 theorem just be approved v prime", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00430-00107224-00107654": "it's a closest of stress also", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00431-00107655-00107934": "here we have used horse darkness", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00432-00107935-00108086": "of v", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00433-00108088-00108263": "so v prime become finite dimension is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00434-00108264-00108431": "close subset this is the previous", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00435-00108432-00108766": "theorem part of previous theorem", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00436-00108767-00109007": "all right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00437-00109008-00109175": "now", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00438-00109176-00109351": "look at b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00439-00109352-00109678": "which is contained inside b bar obvious", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00440-00109679-00109902": "and that will be contained inside now v", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00441-00109903-00110127": "prime plus half b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00442-00110128-00110302": "because what is b prime it is contained", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00443-00110303-00110534": "inside all this iron 1 to n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00444-00110535-00110966": "this v 1 b 2 v n plus half b but this is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00445-00110967-00111183": "each of them is contained inside v", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00446-00111183-00111390": "so union is contained sort of v prime u", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00447-00111391-00111583": "is going to be prime so this whole thing", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00448-00111583-00111886": "i can replace it by one single element v", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00449-00111888-00112047": "prime which is very huge actually", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00450-00112048-00112223": "compared to what i have written there", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00451-00112224-00112551": "it's containing v prime plus half m", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00452-00112552-00112654": "right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00453-00112655-00112863": "now we keep using the property that v", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00454-00112864-00113127": "prime is i have vector subspace", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00455-00113128-00113327": "which is a strong thing okay so it", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00456-00113328-00113639": "follows that if you take half of b which", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00457-00113640-00113886": "will contain is half of b prime plus", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00458-00113888-00114078": "half of half of b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00459-00114079-00114310": "right but half of b prime is v prime", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00460-00114311-00114543": "itself", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00461-00114544-00114734": "it's a vector space right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00462-00114735-00114975": "so it's e prime plus half of b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00463-00114976-00115271": "so half of b is contained inside v prime", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00464-00115272-00115534": "plus one fourth of b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00465-00115535-00115719": "therefore", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00466-00115720-00115910": "start with b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00467-00115911-00116183": "which contains v prime plus half b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00468-00116183-00116399": "but half b is contained inside this one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00469-00116400-00116663": "so i can that v prime plus v prime plus", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00470-00116664-00116847": "one fourth p", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00471-00116848-00117166": "but v prime plus v prime is v prime", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00472-00117167-00117278": "so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00473-00117279-00117623": "v prime plus one fourth b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00474-00117624-00117943": "so what has happened b is contained", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00475-00117944-00118207": "inside v prime plus half b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00476-00118208-00118390": "but we have improved it to v prime plus", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00477-00118391-00118615": "one fourth b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00478-00118616-00118854": "you repeat this process next time we", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00479-00118855-00119095": "what you will get is contains v prime", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00480-00119096-00119407": "plus 1 8 b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00481-00119408-00119695": "and next time it will be 1 2 power", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00482-00119696-00119927": "4 times b and so on 16", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00483-00119928-00120151": "and so on so this just repeating this", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00484-00120152-00120447": "process that's all", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00485-00120448-00120566": "right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00486-00120567-00121031": "so what is this this is that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00487-00121032-00121263": "we get b is contained in v prime plus 1", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00488-00121264-00121639": "by 2 power n times b for every n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00489-00121640-00121823": "that is the meaning of b is contained in", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00490-00121824-00122166": "the intersection of all these", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00491-00122167-00122351": "this is a decreasing sequence of things", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00492-00122352-00122583": "right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00493-00122583-00122814": "so it's intersection of all these things", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00494-00122815-00123078": "because it's containing everything", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00495-00123079-00123407": "but you remember that this forms a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00496-00123408-00123823": "neighborhood system for zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00497-00123824-00124086": "this is what we have proved last time", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00498-00124088-00124310": "therefore", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00499-00124311-00124590": "this intersection is nothing but", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00500-00124591-00125071": "the closure of v prime", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00501-00125072-00125390": "but the closure of v prime", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00502-00125391-00125743": "what's that closure of v prime is v", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00503-00125744-00126063": "prime itself", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00504-00126064-00126286": "all right since we primary clause we", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00505-00126288-00126551": "conclude that b is contained inside v", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00506-00126552-00126839": "prime", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00507-00126840-00127143": "the moment in open subset non-empty open", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00508-00127144-00127483": "subset is contained inside a vector", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00509-00127483-00127783": "subspace that vector subspace must be", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00510-00127783-00128134": "the wall of the space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00511-00128135-00128399": "okay so this follows from", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00512-00128400-00128623": "other lemma that we have we already use", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00513-00128624-00128751": "namely", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00514-00128752-00129047": "v is contained inside", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00515-00129048-00129399": "powers of 2 times b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00516-00129400-00129702": "union of all those things", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00517-00129703-00129983": "any increasing sequence of numbers will", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00518-00129983-00130199": "do this job", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00519-00130200-00130343": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00520-00130344-00130510": "increasing sequence and strictly", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00521-00130511-00130702": "increasing square root increasing", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00522-00130703-00131007": "converging to infinity i should say okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00523-00131008-00131231": "so that is same thing as now", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00524-00131232-00131463": "it's contained inside union of all two", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00525-00131464-00131647": "power and times v prime because b is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00526-00131648-00131935": "continuously prime but 2 n times e prime", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00527-00131936-00132119": "is v prime itself", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00528-00132120-00132566": "so its union of e prime is just b prime", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00529-00132567-00132735": "the entire vector space is contained", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00530-00132736-00132927": "inside the subspace that means they are", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00531-00132928-00133271": "equal", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00532-00133272-00133495": "so what we have done", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00533-00133496-00133807": "we started with v", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00534-00133808-00133911": "we", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00535-00133912-00134207": "produced some finitely many elements", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00536-00134208-00134478": "with certain properties and then we took", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00537-00134479-00134687": "the linear span of that and then we", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00538-00134688-00134799": "showed that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00539-00134800-00135007": "v is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00540-00135008-00135190": "equal to v prime", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00541-00135191-00135463": "anyway so what we have done is that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00542-00135464-00135799": "v is finite dimensional", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00543-00135800-00135959": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00544-00135960-00136311": "under the assumption that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00545-00136312-00137054": "it is house door and locally compact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00546-00137055-00137478": "all right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00547-00137479-00137599": "so two", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00548-00137600-00137814": "very important theorems we have done", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00549-00137815-00137927": "very", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00550-00137928-00138159": "nice and elegant theorem", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00551-00138160-00138511": "the third one is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00552-00138512-00138887": "again curiosity", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00553-00138888-00139119": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00554-00139120-00139351": "see you have proved that a topological", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00555-00139352-00139454": "vector", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00556-00139455-00139775": "topological group is regular space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00557-00139776-00140023": "without any assumption with any further", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00558-00140024-00140135": "assumption", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00559-00140136-00140359": "so what is the best thing you can say", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00560-00140360-00140607": "about a topological", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00561-00140608-00140751": "vector space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00562-00140752-00140959": "so here is one namely", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00563-00140960-00141231": "every topological vector space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00564-00141232-00141671": "is completely regular", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00565-00141672-00141823": "by the way", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00566-00141824-00142054": "it's very important computer regular", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00567-00142055-00142326": "regularity we cannot in this course you", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00568-00142327-00142639": "could not see any of these important", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00569-00142640-00142895": "one is about embeddability theorems", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00570-00142896-00143063": "because continuous functions are coming", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00571-00143064-00143302": "there right another one is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00572-00143303-00143463": "what is called as", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00573-00143464-00143678": "uniform uniform", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00574-00143679-00143895": "topologies", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00575-00143896-00144231": "so this will not be able to discuss here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00576-00144232-00144502": "so there is something important in", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00577-00144503-00144751": "saying that something is a completely", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00578-00144752-00144990": "regular and that is what is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00579-00144991-00145351": "it namely every topological vector space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00580-00145352-00145463": "is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00581-00145464-00145623": "completely regular", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00582-00145624-00145975": "if we assume t1 s it will be t3 and half", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00583-00145976-00146439": "space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00584-00146440-00146583": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00585-00146584-00146863": "so this is just false sort of normality", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00586-00146864-00147119": "if we would prove the normality then you", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00587-00147120-00147319": "have been even great but that is not", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00588-00147320-00147543": "true generally perhaps okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00589-00147544-00147678": "so i am not", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00590-00147679-00147902": "very keen on that one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00591-00147903-00148183": "now let us prove this first okay it", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00592-00148184-00148366": "takes a little more time", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00593-00148367-00148726": "but let us prove that that every", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00594-00148727-00149039": "topology vector space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00595-00149040-00149231": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00596-00149232-00149566": "given any point and a closed subset i", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00597-00149567-00149814": "must find a continuous one but you don't", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00598-00149815-00150063": "have to do any other point because", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00599-00150064-00150287": "we are working at applied vector space a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00600-00150288-00150559": "point can always be", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00601-00150560-00150726": "specialized to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00602-00150727-00150902": "the zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00603-00150903-00151231": "okay given any neighborhood view of zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00604-00151232-00151511": "we must find a continuous function f", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00605-00151512-00151614": "from", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00606-00151615-00152023": "entire vector space to 0 1 such that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00607-00152024-00152335": "f of 0 is 0", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00608-00152336-00152447": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00609-00152448-00152566": "and", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00610-00152567-00152887": "f of the complement of u", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00611-00152888-00153087": "is singleton one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00612-00153088-00153423": "the entire complement of the open set is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00613-00153424-00153583": "goes to one point", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00614-00153584-00153951": "the zero goes to another point", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00615-00153952-00154143": "those two points can be chosen anything", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00616-00154144-00154399": "arbitrarily but we will conveniently", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00617-00154400-00154639": "choose them zero to one and", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00618-00154640-00154847": "the interval also the domain to be also", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00619-00154848-00154999": "zero one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00620-00155000-00155207": "okay you could have their net a comma b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00621-00155208-00155495": "and so there's no problem", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00622-00155496-00155766": "this is what we have to prove", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00623-00155767-00156047": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00624-00156048-00156183": "so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00625-00156184-00156343": "somewhat like", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00626-00156344-00156566": "in the theorem of eurizon we have to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00627-00156567-00156726": "work but", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00628-00156727-00156854": "it is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00629-00156855-00157095": "easier than that perhaps here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00630-00157096-00157359": "start with u naught", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00631-00157360-00157599": "equal to u", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00632-00157600-00157831": "inductively we are going to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00633-00157832-00158143": "find the sequence of open subsets", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00634-00158144-00158271": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00635-00158272-00158447": "now we are using topological vector", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00636-00158448-00158719": "space condition here so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00637-00158720-00158943": "it is easier than doing it in an", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00638-00158944-00159183": "arbitrary normal space", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00639-00159184-00159335": "inductively", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00640-00159336-00159671": "q symmetric open neighborhoods u n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00641-00159672-00159839": "of 0", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00642-00159840-00159990": "such that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00643-00159991-00160287": "u n plus u n is contained inside u n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00644-00160288-00160575": "minus 1 remember symmetric means u n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00645-00160576-00160919": "inverse is u n but here inverse is minus", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00646-00160920-00161023": "u n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00647-00161024-00161287": "so i could have put here minus also then", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00648-00161288-00161439": "that and also it should be same thing", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00649-00161440-00161663": "okay u n plus u n or u n minus u n is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00650-00161664-00161951": "same thing because u n is symmetric", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00651-00161952-00162166": "symmetric here with respect to the", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00652-00162167-00162319": "addition", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00653-00162320-00162566": "okay so u n plus u n is contained inside", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00654-00162567-00162854": "u n minus 1 for every n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00655-00162855-00163135": "so what i do start with u naught take a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00656-00163136-00163390": "u 1 which has this property u 1 plus u 1", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00657-00163391-00163607": "is contained is i u naught and", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00658-00163608-00163838": "keep doing that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00659-00163839-00163943": "ok", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00660-00163944-00164231": "now let d denote the set of all", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00661-00164232-00164551": "data rationals", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00662-00164552-00164711": "including 0", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00663-00164712-00164911": "to 1 over", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00664-00164912-00165143": "what are the direct rationales", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00665-00165144-00165407": "each are inside d", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00666-00165408-00165663": "as a unique representation", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00667-00165664-00165951": "r from 0 to infinity", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00668-00165952-00166126": "c i r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00669-00166127-00166471": "2 power r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00670-00166472-00166614": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00671-00166615-00166766": "1 by 2", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00672-00166767-00167087": "1 by 2 plus 1 by", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00673-00167088-00167535": "1 by 4 or just 1 by 4 and so on", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00674-00167536-00167823": "okay so you can take", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00675-00167824-00168102": "any anything like that so it's a unique", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00676-00168103-00168278": "representation here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00677-00168279-00168383": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00678-00168384-00168719": "where all these", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00679-00168720-00168935": "c i are", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00680-00168936-00169390": "the denominators either 0 or 1", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00681-00169391-00169471": "ok", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00682-00169472-00169838": "and only finitely many c i f r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00683-00169839-00170071": "are known zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00684-00170072-00170271": "so this is my definition of these", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00685-00170272-00170478": "dynamic rationals", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00686-00170479-00170726": "i have given you complete uh description", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00687-00170727-00171095": "of this what are these things put a r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00688-00171096-00171311": "equal to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00689-00171312-00171438": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00690-00171439-00172031": "v if r is greater than equal to 1", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00691-00172032-00172351": "okay so this r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00692-00172352-00172487": "i don't know what it is it's not", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00693-00172488-00172766": "rational r is given about 1 i put a r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00694-00172767-00173175": "and if r is inside d 0 to 1 open", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00695-00173176-00173375": "okay that's inside d then", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00696-00173376-00173566": "put a r equal to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00697-00173567-00173943": "these look at these numbers 0 and 1", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00698-00173944-00174190": "they are the scalars right so i can put", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00699-00174191-00174399": "ci of r times ui", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00700-00174400-00174631": "this makes sense because we are working", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00701-00174632-00174951": "in a topological vector space the uis", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00702-00174952-00175263": "are subsets of v capital v", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00703-00175264-00175614": "so zero times u i means just zero that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00704-00175615-00175814": "is a zero vector", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00705-00175815-00176319": "c i r times c is one it is just ui", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00706-00176320-00176543": "okay then you are taking the sum of all", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00707-00176544-00176711": "these", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00708-00176712-00176902": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00709-00176903-00177183": "so what i should mention is here you can", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00710-00177184-00177487": "take these things that only just finite", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00711-00177488-00177614": "sum", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00712-00177615-00177975": "only finitely many cirs are non-zero i", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00713-00177976-00178231": "have put infinity here as if convergent", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00714-00178232-00178502": "sequence and so on but the added classes", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00715-00178503-00178719": "are only finitely many ci's are zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00716-00178720-00178919": "non-zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00717-00178920-00179119": "okay i don't want to stop here and so on", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00718-00179120-00179335": "then n could be infinity so this is just", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00719-00179336-00179543": "0 to n and then going to infinity all of", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00720-00179544-00179687": "them are there right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00721-00179688-00179919": "so 3 i's are non-zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00722-00179920-00180190": "so most of them are 0 here so this is a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00723-00180191-00180431": "finite sum", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00724-00180432-00180735": "okay i didn't want to something u1 maybe", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00725-00180736-00181095": "u3 maybe u5 and so on so these are", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00726-00181096-00181295": "this is the finite sum but this makes", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00727-00181296-00181559": "sense the uis are open and each of them", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00728-00181560-00181871": "will be open subsets", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00729-00181872-00182102": "all right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00730-00182103-00182359": "we first make a few observations on the", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00731-00182360-00182638": "subsets ar", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00732-00182639-00182871": "each ar is a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00733-00182872-00183126": "open neighborhood of zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00734-00183127-00183495": "and a r is contained inside u naught", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00735-00183496-00183751": "contained inside equal to u that's by", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00736-00183752-00184007": "definition", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00737-00184008-00184511": "see u 1 plus u 1 is contained inside", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00738-00184512-00184726": "right u 1 plus u naught you also want", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00739-00184727-00184871": "any that is 1 because u naught is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00740-00184872-00185126": "already contained so on so a r is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00741-00185127-00185278": "contained inside", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00742-00185279-00185487": "you are not this important", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00743-00185488-00185831": "if r is less than s", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00744-00185832-00186014": "okay inside d", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00745-00186015-00186511": "then a r will be contained inside a s", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00746-00186512-00186671": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00747-00186672-00186926": "so these are similar to what you have", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00748-00186927-00187087": "done when", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00749-00187088-00187247": "proving your results lemma somewhat", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00750-00187248-00187519": "similar but easier steps here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00751-00187520-00187783": "okay so hawaii this is true but choose", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00752-00187784-00187990": "the smallest k", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00753-00187991-00188383": "such that c r c k of r is zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00754-00188384-00188583": "once you have r there are one c one c", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00755-00188584-00188750": "two c case right gives you the smallest", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00756-00188751-00189083": "c k so c k of r is zero and c k of", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00757-00189084-00189343": "s is one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00758-00189344-00189695": "among the r and s you keep comparing", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00759-00189696-00189814": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00760-00189815-00190102": "so some zeros you may get", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00761-00190103-00190335": "so first time this means s and the these", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00762-00190336-00190526": "things are zero that's what i have", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00763-00190527-00190790": "then a r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00764-00190791-00191038": "will be contained in say a 1 by 2 power", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00765-00191039-00191254": "k", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00766-00191255-00191607": "once 1 by 2 a or 1 by 2 power k a s", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00767-00191608-00191847": "will be even even bigger than that the", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00768-00191848-00192078": "more elements will be there that means", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00769-00192079-00192343": "this has u k already", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00770-00192344-00192502": "and then some play plus something so on", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00771-00192503-00192678": "so that will be contained in here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00772-00192679-00192911": "yes", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00773-00192912-00193150": "okay a s will have uk plus plus", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00774-00193151-00193278": "something more so that's why it's", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00775-00193279-00193583": "contained in that one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00776-00193584-00193671": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00777-00193672-00193871": "recall that if a and b are symmetric", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00778-00193872-00194111": "neighborhoods of zero then", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00779-00194112-00194431": "a bar union b bar is containing a and b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00780-00194432-00194683": "a a plus b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00781-00194684-00194847": "right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00782-00194848-00195190": "this is what we have seen uh for", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00783-00195191-00195350": "for uh", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00784-00195351-00195599": "topological groups itself", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00785-00195600-00195687": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00786-00195688-00196095": "given r less than s", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00787-00196096-00196326": "choose n such that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00788-00196327-00196726": "1 by 2 or n is less than s minus r which", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00789-00196727-00196983": "is some positive number", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00790-00196984-00197207": "so r is less than s s minus r will be", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00791-00197208-00197471": "some positive number so choose n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00792-00197472-00197726": "sufficiently large", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00793-00197727-00197838": "then", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00794-00197839-00198087": "a r bar", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00795-00198088-00198343": "will be contained inside a r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00796-00198344-00198543": "plus", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00797-00198544-00198966": "u of 1 by 2 over n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00798-00198967-00199126": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00799-00199127-00199287": "see you all", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00800-00199288-00199366": "uh", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00801-00199367-00199638": "this notation what are u naught u n and", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00802-00199639-00199902": "so on i i could have just put a suffix", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00803-00199903-00200071": "here but i have put a bracket here it", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00804-00200072-00200454": "doesn't matter u power one by two over n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00805-00200455-00200750": "contained inside a s", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00806-00200751-00200999": "because of this probability", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00807-00201000-00201199": "1 by 2 power n is less than s minus r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00808-00201200-00201726": "what you are adding here is less than s", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00809-00201727-00201950": "all right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00810-00201951-00202719": "so a b c we have probe", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00811-00202720-00202807": "now", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00812-00202808-00203031": "let us define", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00813-00203032-00203335": "f x equal to infimum of r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00814-00203336-00203871": "for all x belonging to a r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00815-00203872-00203983": "you see", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00816-00203984-00204278": "if you have direct rational", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00817-00204279-00204375": "then", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00818-00204376-00204590": "you have to choose it to be smaller than", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00819-00204591-00204879": "that it's infimum of those things", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00820-00204880-00205231": "but if there are no direct rationals", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00821-00205232-00205398": "then remember", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00822-00205400-00205558": "this will be", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00823-00205559-00205766": "the whole of a and this will be r equal", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00824-00205767-00205958": "to 1", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00825-00205959-00206214": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00826-00206215-00206414": "so there we have points of vr there like", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00827-00206415-00206598": "that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00828-00206600-00206951": "all right so f x will be 1", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00829-00206952-00207086": "by a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00830-00207087-00207279": "it follows that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00831-00207280-00207638": "f of b minus u is one because the moment", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00832-00207639-00207790": "it's outside you", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00833-00207791-00208094": "you have defined it to be r to be one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00834-00208096-00208310": "so the infirma in frame of this should", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00835-00208311-00208406": "be on", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00836-00208407-00208682": "suppose by definition", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00837-00208683-00208934": "also since u", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00838-00208935-00209166": "0 is inside u n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00839-00209167-00209319": "and u n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00840-00209319-00209455": "is a of", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00841-00209456-00209694": "1 by 2 power n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00842-00209696-00210031": "okay if you just take a r what is a r l", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00843-00210032-00210279": "just call car all these properties i", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00844-00210280-00210382": "have told", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00845-00210383-00210623": "but what is a r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00846-00210623-00210782": "a r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00847-00210783-00211103": "is the sum of all these but when r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00848-00211104-00211310": "equals 1 by 2 power n there is only only", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00849-00211311-00211575": "one element there right so that will be", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00850-00211576-00211679": "u", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00851-00211680-00211775": "uh", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00852-00211776-00211998": "u n or u whatever", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00853-00212000-00213182": "notation that is the notation u n comes", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00854-00213183-00213519": "u n is a 1 by 2 over n", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00855-00213519-00213758": "for all n this is case", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00856-00213759-00213903": "therefore", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00857-00213904-00214215": "if 1 by 2 power n is there for all n in", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00858-00214216-00214639": "minimum will be 0. so f zero is zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00859-00214640-00214894": "it remains to prove that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00860-00214896-00215110": "y f is continuous", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00861-00215111-00215358": "we have proved that f zero is zero", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00862-00215359-00215655": "f of p minus u is one that is fine", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00863-00215656-00216167": "continuity of f is what we have to do", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00864-00216167-00216287": "so there is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00865-00216288-00216510": "full analogy", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00866-00216511-00216646": "between", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00867-00216648-00216903": "eurozone's lemma and this one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00868-00216904-00217127": "if you had not understood eurozone's", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00869-00217128-00217382": "lemma you won't have been able to prove", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00870-00217383-00217639": "this one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00871-00217640-00217823": "okay i don't claim that if you", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00872-00217823-00218006": "understand why you would be able to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00873-00218007-00218191": "prove this one but", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00874-00218192-00218487": "but now you have adopted those ideas", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00875-00218488-00218663": "in the case of", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00876-00218664-00219023": "topological vector spaces", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00877-00219023-00219446": "so y f is continuous", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00878-00219448-00219567": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00879-00219567-00219823": "ready", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00880-00219823-00220206": "start with any point x in v", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00881-00220207-00220479": "and put f x equal to t", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00882-00220480-00220831": "and epsilon positive", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00883-00220832-00220958": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00884-00220959-00221342": "choose r and s belonging to d", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00885-00221344-00221542": "such that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00886-00221544-00221806": "t minus epsilon is less than or less", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00887-00221807-00222094": "than s less than t", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00888-00222096-00222351": "the effects equal to t", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00889-00222352-00222551": "what is what is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00890-00222552-00222719": "the definition", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00891-00222719-00222934": "its infimum option set", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00892-00222935-00223110": "okay so therefore", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00893-00223111-00223342": "you will have r and s inside the radical", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00894-00223344-00223510": "rationale such that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00895-00223511-00223798": "t minus epsilon", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00896-00223800-00224087": "t t minus epsilon is less than f x right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00897-00224088-00224382": "which less than or less than s less than", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00898-00224383-00224455": "t", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00899-00224456-00224863": "so between r and t t is larger", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00900-00224864-00225303": "t s is smaller", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00901-00225304-00225391": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00902-00225392-00225591": "so you can choose one some r here and", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00903-00225592-00225687": "then", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00904-00225688-00225927": "smaller than that one t minus between t", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00905-00225928-00226167": "minus epsilon t plus epsilon you can", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00906-00226167-00226446": "choose two numbers because this is all", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00907-00226448-00226791": "uh dense subset of zero comma one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00908-00226792-00226910": "that's all i'm using here there's", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00909-00226911-00227103": "nothing more than that okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00910-00227104-00227239": "so then", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00911-00227240-00227710": "a r bar will be contained into the s", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00912-00227711-00227982": "and x is not inside", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00913-00227983-00228639": "a s", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00914-00228640-00228982": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00915-00228983-00229246": "because f x is t which is smaller than", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00916-00229248-00229406": "is bigger than t", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00917-00229407-00229679": "so this this this cannot be", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00918-00229680-00229951": "inside a s", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00919-00229952-00230110": "which inside is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00920-00230111-00230271": "the the value of this one would be", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00921-00230271-00230487": "smaller than that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00922-00230488-00230663": "so this means that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00923-00230664-00231142": "if you take w you could v minus a r bar", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00924-00231144-00231455": "okay a r bar is closed so v minus a r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00925-00231456-00231975": "bar is an open neighborhood of x", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00926-00231976-00232127": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00927-00232128-00232519": "so this implies that f of w", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00928-00232519-00232871": "this contains an r to 1", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00929-00232871-00233231": "so the least t is yeah it cannot be", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00930-00233232-00233463": "anything lower than that is not there so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00931-00233464-00233687": "it has to be bigger than", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00932-00233688-00233782": "r", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00933-00233783-00234175": "so it's r to 1. it cannot be", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00934-00234176-00234431": "bigger than 1 anyway all of them are", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00935-00234432-00234623": "less than equal to 1 only", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00936-00234623-00235071": "okay so f w is going to be r 1", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00937-00235071-00235279": "ok this already completes a proof of", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00938-00235280-00235479": "continuity in the case t equal to 1 we", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00939-00235480-00235687": "have formed a neighborhood", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00940-00235688-00235782": "if t", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00941-00235783-00236055": "i don't say t is equal to 1 start with f", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00942-00236056-00236134": "x", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00943-00236135-00236398": "start with x f x put f x equal to t", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00944-00236400-00236575": "that's all", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00945-00236576-00236903": "ok it may happen that this t is one then", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00946-00236904-00237167": "this argument says that already", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00947-00237167-00237246": "that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00948-00237248-00237479": "the continuity of", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00949-00237480-00237710": "the the function f at", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00950-00237711-00238158": "points x as f x equal to one is prone", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00951-00238159-00238503": "okay that is a special case", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00952-00238504-00238615": "all right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00953-00238616-00238927": "now you assume t is less than 1", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00954-00238928-00239167": "so we are inside now static rationals", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00955-00239167-00239271": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00956-00239271-00239663": "choose p belong to d such that t less", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00957-00239664-00239975": "than p less than t plus epsilon", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00958-00239976-00240271": "given any epsilon i will produce a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00959-00240271-00240398": "neighborhood", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00960-00240400-00240591": "okay that's what i have to do", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00961-00240592-00240839": "then it follows that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00962-00240840-00241119": "x is inside ap", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00963-00241119-00241327": "because t is even smaller f of x is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00964-00241328-00241430": "smaller", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00965-00241431-00241703": "so it must be inside a b", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00966-00241704-00241855": "right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00967-00241856-00241958": "now", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00968-00241959-00242127": "f of a p", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00969-00242128-00242382": "points inside a p", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00970-00242383-00242782": "they must be between 0 and p", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00971-00242783-00242958": "once it's already p", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00972-00242959-00243167": "it may be even smaller so but it may be", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00973-00243167-00243430": "0 and p that's what it is so it follows", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00974-00243431-00243527": "that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00975-00243528-00243751": "the same w", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00976-00243752-00244015": "okay the same thing here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00977-00244016-00244263": "intersection a p", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00978-00244264-00244439": "is a neighborhood of x", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00979-00244440-00244551": "such that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00980-00244552-00244806": "f of w intersection ap", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00981-00244807-00245063": "will be contained inside now", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00982-00245064-00245246": "t minus epsilon", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00983-00245248-00247039": "to t plus epsilon", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00984-00247040-00247423": "once t is smaller than epsilon 1", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00985-00247423-00247646": "you may assume that this epsilon is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00986-00247648-00247919": "smaller than", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00987-00247919-00248198": "1 minus t so that even after adding t it", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00988-00248200-00248455": "doesn't go out of that one", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00989-00248456-00248679": "for such epsilon you prove is fine", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00990-00248680-00249015": "otherwise anyway it can go out but it is", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00991-00249016-00249255": "inside t minus of t plus epsilon is what", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00992-00249256-00249551": "you show for everybody", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00993-00249552-00249710": "such that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00994-00249711-00249903": "you know there is some epsilon is what", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00995-00249904-00250030": "this what you have there is some", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00996-00250031-00250134": "neighborhood", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00997-00250135-00250503": "f of this w intersection ap", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00998-00250504-00250671": "will give you an apple", "W8qWFfX8NCM-00999-00250671-00251887": "remember all these aps are open subsets", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01000-00251888-00253175": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01001-00253176-00253415": "so that completes the", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01002-00253416-00253806": "plan whatever i have done to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01003-00253807-00254094": "this part one course", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01004-00254096-00254198": "i", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01005-00254200-00254487": "just repeat what were the reference", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01006-00254488-00255191": "books here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01007-00255192-00255463": "i was completely", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01008-00255464-00255855": "influenced as a student and even today", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01009-00255856-00256191": "by the book of", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01010-00256192-00256534": "siemens", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01011-00256535-00256791": "george humans", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01012-00256792-00256879": "and", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01013-00256880-00257175": "in spirit be not being content", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01014-00257176-00257479": "i have followed this book", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01015-00257480-00257742": "for example", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01016-00257744-00257967": "the definition of", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01017-00257967-00258206": "t naught space or t one space normal", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01018-00258207-00258479": "space and so on normal and t three t", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01019-00258480-00258623": "four and so on", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01020-00258623-00258871": "those things differ from", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01021-00258871-00259030": "the simmons book", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01022-00259031-00259303": "so be cautious about that i have already", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01023-00259304-00259479": "told you earlier", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01024-00259480-00259719": "be cautious about that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01025-00259719-00259991": "this teen and see back", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01026-00259992-00260255": "this book i refer to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01027-00260256-00260598": "counter examples in topology", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01028-00260600-00260975": "this book is now available online", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01029-00260976-00261055": "and", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01030-00261056-00261327": "whatever i had seen", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01031-00261328-00261582": "it has expanded much", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01032-00261583-00261663": "so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01033-00261664-00261934": "since 40 years back", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01034-00261935-00262199": "okay it has expanded a much", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01035-00262200-00262455": "so so this is good for not learning", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01036-00262456-00262575": "topology", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01037-00262576-00262758": "but as a reference book it is nice", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01038-00262759-00263055": "that's what i worship", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01039-00263056-00263503": "so my second book in topology we may say", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01040-00263504-00263710": "is kelly's book", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01041-00263711-00264047": "which is a very fantastic book but", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01042-00264048-00264271": "difficult to read", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01043-00264272-00264471": "as compared to simon simons was a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01044-00264472-00264647": "pleasant man", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01045-00264648-00265119": "but i enjoyed kelly's book also", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01046-00265120-00265382": "later when i joined uh", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01047-00265383-00265582": "iit bombay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01048-00265583-00265951": "my colleague had written a nice book", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01049-00265952-00266199": "and kd yoshi now that's introduction", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01050-00266200-00266334": "topology", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01051-00266335-00266527": "so i have borrowed a material from this", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01052-00266528-00266775": "book also", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01053-00266776-00267039": "so i have high regard for this book", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01054-00267040-00267230": "but it's okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01055-00267231-00267519": "so in fact", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01056-00267520-00267671": "the", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01057-00267672-00267895": "the existence of this book", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01058-00267896-00268358": "stopped me writing a book on my own", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01059-00268359-00268647": "on poetry topology", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01060-00268648-00268927": "all right", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01061-00268928-00269079": "before that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01062-00269080-00269382": "even in tifr this was my third book in", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01063-00269383-00269671": "topology horowitz and walmart dimension", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01064-00269672-00269934": "theory this is a very specialized book", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01065-00269935-00270223": "but it teaches you topology like", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01066-00270224-00270519": "anything so this is wonderful book", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01067-00270520-00270647": "okay this is specialized books in", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01068-00270648-00270927": "dimension theory", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01069-00270928-00271110": "and then there are", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01070-00271111-00271375": "nice books which i have just browsed", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01071-00271376-00271527": "through i have not studied them and so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01072-00271528-00271830": "on armstrong", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01073-00271831-00271982": "this", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01074-00271983-00272334": "book by", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01075-00272335-00272606": "cynic patty", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01076-00272607-00272799": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01077-00272800-00273055": "so here you can see rudy's functional", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01078-00273056-00273206": "analysis", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01079-00273207-00273430": "these are used for", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01080-00273431-00273687": "these topological vector spaces and so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01081-00273688-00273903": "on", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01082-00273904-00274103": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01083-00274104-00274199": "so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01084-00274200-00274406": "that's what it is so you can also look", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01085-00274407-00274647": "into so there are some papers here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01086-00274648-00275015": "from which i have borrowed material", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01087-00275016-00275206": "all these books they are good book", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01088-00275207-00275375": "duguji", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01089-00275376-00275575": "and", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01090-00275576-00276575": "what are the other ones here", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01091-00276576-00277110": "well that's it", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01092-00277111-00277439": "nice book on matrix basis", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01093-00277440-00277623": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01094-00277624-00277871": "so that's what it is so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01095-00277872-00278119": "however i want to tell you i remind you", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01096-00278120-00278391": "that", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01097-00278392-00278839": "i am going to give a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01098-00278840-00279103": "not and you have already", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01099-00279104-00279279": "the notes with you", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01100-00279280-00279382": "so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01101-00279383-00279606": "just to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01102-00279607-00279879": "get through this this prove this whole", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01103-00279880-00280103": "course you don't need anything else so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01104-00280104-00280447": "you just go through the notes properly", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01105-00280448-00280934": "workout and assignments you are done", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01106-00280935-00281039": "okay", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01107-00281040-00281567": "so", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01108-00281568-00281815": "yeah so that's all i wanted to tell you", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01109-00281816-00282095": "about this", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01110-00282096-00282415": "so finally", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01111-00282416-00282719": "i would like to end up this one with a", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01112-00282720-00283039": "lot of thanks to", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01113-00283040-00283382": "the nptel team", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01114-00283383-00283663": "my own", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01115-00283664-00283943": "team of tutors", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01116-00283944-00284199": "whose help has been extremely useful", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01117-00284200-00284327": "extremely", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01118-00284328-00284671": "great help moral support and so on", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01119-00284672-00284758": "in", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01120-00284759-00285047": "in bringing out this course to you", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01121-00285048-00285343": "and also big thanks to all of you", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01122-00285344-00285654": "if you have stayed with me so far", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01123-00285655-00285879": "i hope i will see you in the second part", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01124-00285880-00286079": "also", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01125-00286080-00286287": "okay thank you", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01126-00286288-00289951": "[Music]", "W8qWFfX8NCM-01127-00289952-00290159": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "W8vDOuiJsMI", "text": {"W8vDOuiJsMI-00000-00000000-00000100": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00001-00000101-00001795": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00002-00001796-00002888": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00003-00002889-00003422": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00004-00003424-00003836": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00005-00003836-00004122": "[Applause]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00006-00004123-00004331": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00007-00004332-00007193": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00008-00007194-00007817": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00009-00007818-00009380": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00010-00009381-00010552": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00011-00010553-00012413": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00012-00012414-00012835": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00013-00012836-00013828": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00014-00013829-00015911": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00015-00015912-00016733": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00016-00016734-00018457": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00017-00018458-00019847": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00018-00019848-00020400": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00019-00020401-00021805": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00020-00021806-00021808": "[Applause]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00021-00021809-00021823": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00022-00021824-00021976": "[Laughter]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00023-00021977-00022209": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00024-00022210-00022733": "[Applause]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00025-00022734-00022972": "Gina", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00026-00022973-00024203": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00027-00024204-00025829": "[Applause]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00028-00025830-00027299": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00029-00027300-00028007": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00030-00028008-00028852": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00031-00028852-00029452": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00032-00029454-00030201": "[Applause]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00033-00030202-00031212": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00034-00031213-00031714": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00035-00031716-00031894": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00036-00031895-00032939": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00037-00032940-00033593": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00038-00033594-00033759": "[Applause]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00039-00033760-00035055": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00040-00035056-00035471": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00041-00035472-00036373": "[Laughter]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00042-00036374-00037167": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00043-00037168-00037805": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00044-00037806-00038939": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00045-00038940-00039589": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00046-00039590-00041657": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00047-00041658-00043139": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00048-00043140-00043458": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00049-00043459-00045878": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00050-00045879-00046024": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00051-00046025-00048617": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00052-00048618-00048741": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00053-00048742-00051639": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00054-00051640-00052169": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00055-00052170-00052283": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00056-00052284-00052880": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00057-00052882-00053542": "[Laughter]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00058-00053544-00053628": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00059-00053629-00054071": "[Laughter]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00060-00054072-00054737": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00061-00054738-00055865": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00062-00055866-00056746": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00063-00056747-00058027": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00064-00058028-00059035": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00065-00059036-00059750": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00066-00059751-00059938": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00067-00059939-00060241": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00068-00060242-00060836": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00069-00060837-00060892": "[Applause]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00070-00060894-00061940": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00071-00061941-00063341": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00072-00063341-00063701": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00073-00063702-00064770": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00074-00064771-00065805": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00075-00065806-00067465": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00076-00067466-00069209": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00077-00069210-00075593": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00078-00075594-00078515": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00079-00078516-00078749": "Allah", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00080-00078750-00082775": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00081-00082776-00084505": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00082-00084506-00085300": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00083-00085301-00088637": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00084-00088638-00093629": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00085-00093630-00096893": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00086-00096894-00099635": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00087-00099636-00100067": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00088-00100068-00102653": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00089-00102654-00103659": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00090-00103660-00104284": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00091-00104285-00104784": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00092-00104785-00104945": "you know", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00093-00104946-00107507": "yes", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00094-00107508-00109061": "foreign", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00095-00109063-00111680": "[Music]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00096-00111681-00115132": "[Applause]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00097-00115133-00115549": "[Applause]", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00098-00115550-00115973": "I mean", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00099-00115974-00116090": "hearts", "W8vDOuiJsMI-00100-00116091-00117742": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "W8zcllLs_x8", "text": {"W8zcllLs_x8-00000-00000000-00000221": "here are five quick facts about placoon", "W8zcllLs_x8-00001-00000222-00000394": "number one during production of The", "W8zcllLs_x8-00002-00000395-00000574": "Phantom Menace the character of placoon", "W8zcllLs_x8-00003-00000575-00000778": "was initially known as pontoon after the", "W8zcllLs_x8-00004-00000779-00000958": "nickname of live-action creature effects", "W8zcllLs_x8-00005-00000959-00001127": "supervisor Nick dudman's son it was", "W8zcllLs_x8-00006-00001128-00001343": "later amended to plokun by George Lucas", "W8zcllLs_x8-00007-00001344-00001511": "before filming of the movie number two", "W8zcllLs_x8-00008-00001512-00001751": "during the order 66 Montage in Revenge", "W8zcllLs_x8-00009-00001752-00001943": "of the Sith loku was originally going to", "W8zcllLs_x8-00010-00001944-00002117": "be shown surviving his Starfighter being", "W8zcllLs_x8-00011-00002118-00002291": "shot down with him ejecting from his", "W8zcllLs_x8-00012-00002292-00002471": "cockpit only to later be shot by clone", "W8zcllLs_x8-00013-00002472-00002657": "Pilots number three during development", "W8zcllLs_x8-00014-00002658-00002831": "of the Clone Wars lokoon was originally", "W8zcllLs_x8-00015-00002832-00003010": "planned to have a Japanese accent with", "W8zcllLs_x8-00016-00003011-00003179": "the intent to portray the character as a", "W8zcllLs_x8-00017-00003180-00003365": "samurai-like warrior George Lucas", "W8zcllLs_x8-00018-00003365-00003538": "however felt that this characterization", "W8zcllLs_x8-00019-00003539-00003731": "came across as cold and uncaring and", "W8zcllLs_x8-00020-00003732-00003929": "Dave filoni ultimately took lokoon into", "W8zcllLs_x8-00021-00003929-00004103": "the direction of a more gandalf-like", "W8zcllLs_x8-00022-00004104-00004295": "character number four although his birth", "W8zcllLs_x8-00023-00004296-00004475": "date is unknown plokun was a", "W8zcllLs_x8-00024-00004476-00004649": "four-sensitive keldor born on the planet", "W8zcllLs_x8-00025-00004650-00004847": "Doran and number five while in a mission", "W8zcllLs_x8-00026-00004848-00005033": "to the planet Chile placoon found a", "W8zcllLs_x8-00027-00005034-00005201": "three-year-old Ahsoka Tano because of", "W8zcllLs_x8-00028-00005202-00005363": "her Force sensitivity Master ploke", "W8zcllLs_x8-00029-00005364-00005531": "brought Ahsoka back to the Jedi Temple", "W8zcllLs_x8-00030-00005532-00005693": "so she could be trained as a Jedi and", "W8zcllLs_x8-00031-00005694-00005872": "the two Jedi went on to maintain a close", "W8zcllLs_x8-00032-00005873-00006152": "Bond and friendship"}}, {"audio_id": "W8VOX7nDbUQ", "text": {"W8VOX7nDbUQ-00000-00000183-00000415": "okay hello everybody", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00001-00000416-00000711": "um and welcome to the cultural panel for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00002-00000712-00001039": "serge's 14th annual china u.s symposium", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00003-00001040-00001254": "it's great to see all you here and i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00004-00001255-00001462": "hope you're excited to learn more about", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00005-00001463-00001655": "from chinese digital media and its", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00006-00001655-00001887": "interesting role in china-us relations", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00007-00001888-00002102": "my name is megan starcis i'm a sophomore", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00008-00002103-00002287": "here at tufts planning to major in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00009-00002288-00002487": "international relations and economics", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00010-00002488-00002639": "and i am the panel lead for today's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00011-00002640-00002934": "socio cultural discussion i'm also", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00012-00002935-00003102": "currently the marketing director for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00013-00003103-00003335": "tough search", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00014-00003336-00003463": "hello everyone my name is jake", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00015-00003464-00003638": "rubinstein and i'll be co-hosting with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00016-00003639-00003927": "megan today i'm currently a freshman um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00017-00003928-00004103": "here at tufts majoring in international", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00018-00004104-00004295": "relations we're so excited to have you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00019-00004296-00004551": "all here today", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00020-00004552-00004743": "hello everyone my name is caitlin wells", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00021-00004744-00004935": "and i'll also be co-hosting this panel", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00022-00004936-00005175": "with megan and jake i'm a first-year", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00023-00005176-00005327": "student planning on majoring in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00024-00005328-00005495": "international relations and civic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00025-00005496-00005695": "studies it's a great honor to be able to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00026-00005696-00005895": "learn from the fantastic speakers we", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00027-00005896-00006063": "have coming up we hope you enjoy the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00028-00006064-00006327": "panel", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00029-00006328-00006495": "so with that i'm just going to give you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00030-00006495-00006734": "all some more context about what exactly", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00031-00006736-00006919": "we will be discussing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00032-00006920-00007142": "so as china enters a new globalized era", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00033-00007143-00007351": "in terms of communication and social", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00034-00007352-00007446": "media", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00035-00007447-00007574": "the question of how the chinese", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00036-00007575-00007783": "government will manage and engage in its", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00037-00007784-00008046": "evolving digital culture is a matter of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00038-00008047-00008310": "pressing concern its decisions to censor", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00039-00008311-00008471": "and contain certain types of digital", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00040-00008472-00008695": "content will not only affect those in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00041-00008696-00008910": "china but also the rest of the world", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00042-00008911-00009087": "because china's cultural influence", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00043-00009088-00009278": "continues to expand beyond the scope of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00044-00009279-00009519": "the sinosphere this panel will explore", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00045-00009520-00009735": "the multifaceted capacities of chinese", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00046-00009736-00010046": "digital media platforms like weibo and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00047-00010047-00010223": "the relevant cultural implications on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00048-00010224-00010446": "chinese society as well as the american", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00049-00010447-00010687": "perceptions of that media however the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00050-00010688-00010878": "panelists here are free to discuss any", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00051-00010879-00011031": "aspect of this topic that they find", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00052-00011032-00011310": "particularly interesting", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00053-00011311-00011519": "the first speaker we have today is daria", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00054-00011520-00011751": "berg from the university of saint gallin", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00055-00011752-00011927": "although she's not able to be here to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00056-00011928-00012174": "present virtually today we will be", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00057-00012175-00012391": "presenting her pre-recorded lecture over", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00058-00012392-00012487": "zoom", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00059-00012488-00012631": "she has a philosophy doctorate in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00060-00012632-00012791": "chinese studies from university of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00061-00012792-00013007": "oxford and is chair professor of chinese", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00062-00013008-00013230": "culture and society at the university of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00063-00013231-00013430": "saint galan in switzerland", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00064-00013431-00013647": "she has published extensively on chinese", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00065-00013647-00013886": "literature art popular culture and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00066-00013887-00014143": "cultural history including her monograph", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00067-00014144-00014327": "carnival in china a reading of the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00068-00014328-00014566": "shinshur inuintron", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00069-00014568-00014783": "some of her edited works include reading", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00070-00014784-00014999": "china fiction history and the dynamics", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00071-00015000-00015119": "of discourse", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00072-00015119-00015343": "the quest for gentility in china and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00073-00015344-00015575": "transforming book culture in china", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00074-00015576-00015783": "her monograph women in the literary", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00075-00015784-00015975": "world in early modern china won the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00076-00015976-00016135": "international convention of asia", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00077-00016136-00016391": "scholars book prize their 2015", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00078-00016392-00016647": "specialist publication accolades", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00079-00016648-00016815": "her current research explores urban", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00080-00016816-00017047": "culture in contemporary china including", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00081-00017048-00017319": "new digital media literate literature", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00082-00017320-00017630": "art gender audio visual culture and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00083-00017631-00017927": "internet culture", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00084-00017928-00018167": "the second speaker we have is being", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00085-00018168-00018367": "from the london school of economics she", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00086-00018368-00018511": "is a professor in the department for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00087-00018512-00018694": "media and communications where she", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00088-00018695-00018863": "directs the masters of sciences double", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00089-00018864-00019039": "degree program in global media and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00090-00019040-00019271": "communications with fudan university", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00091-00019272-00019455": "she is also the co-director of the lse", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00092-00019456-00019735": "furan global public policy research", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00093-00019736-00019967": "center her research interests include", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00094-00019968-00020127": "gender in the media the political", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00095-00020128-00020311": "economy of media industries", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00096-00020312-00020575": "communication governments governance and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00097-00020576-00020791": "comparative media studies she has", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00098-00020792-00020950": "published widely on these topics in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00099-00020951-00021222": "leading academic journals from 2020 to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00100-00021223-00021478": "21 she served as a senior fellow of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00101-00021479-00021750": "global governance teachers 2035", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00102-00021751-00021935": "organized by the global public policy", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00103-00021936-00022094": "institute in berlin under the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00104-00022095-00022319": "sponsorship of the bosch foundation", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00105-00022320-00022543": "her book the politics of chinese media", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00106-00022544-00022783": "consensus and contestation was published", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00107-00022784-00023071": "by paul grab in early 2018", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00108-00023072-00023207": "she is currently working on another", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00109-00023208-00023399": "monograph under contract with columbia", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00110-00023400-00023647": "university press about ai industries in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00111-00023648-00024071": "china", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00112-00024072-00024286": "our final speaker is florian schneider", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00113-00024287-00024486": "from the university of leiden", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00114-00024487-00024711": "he holds a phd from sheffield university", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00115-00024712-00024903": "and is a senior university lecturer in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00116-00024904-00025086": "the politics of modern china at the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00117-00025087-00025283": "leiden university institute for area", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00118-00025284-00025542": "studies he is the managing editor of age", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00119-00025543-00025822": "escape digital asia and director of the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00120-00025823-00026062": "leiden asia center also the author of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00121-00026063-00026262": "three books", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00122-00026263-00026414": "these include", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00123-00026416-00026607": "staging china the politics of mass", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00124-00026608-00026902": "spectacle china's digital nationalism", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00125-00026904-00027143": "and visual political communication in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00126-00027144-00027374": "popular chinese television series in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00127-00027375-00027614": "2017 he was awarded the leiden", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00128-00027616-00027807": "university teaching prize for his", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00129-00027808-00028023": "innovative work as an educator his", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00130-00028024-00028190": "research interests include the questions", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00131-00028191-00028423": "of governance political communication", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00132-00028424-00028646": "and digital media in china as well as", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00133-00028647-00028814": "international relations in the east", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00134-00028816-00029070": "asian region", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00135-00029072-00029287": "wonderful so the way this panel will", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00136-00029288-00029487": "work is after i'm done speaking each", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00137-00029488-00029711": "panelist has about 10 to 15 minutes for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00138-00029712-00029935": "a presentation with a slideshow and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00139-00029936-00030207": "other visual tools they choose to use um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00140-00030208-00030335": "if you in the audience have any", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00141-00030336-00030479": "questions that come up during any of the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00142-00030480-00030679": "presentations please feel free to leave", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00143-00030680-00030870": "them in the chat and we'll address them", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00144-00030872-00031118": "after everybody is done speaking um then", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00145-00031119-00031262": "the panelists will have a chance to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00146-00031263-00031455": "address each other's remarks i'll ask", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00147-00031456-00031711": "them a few guiding questions for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00148-00031712-00031902": "discussion and then the last 20 minutes", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00149-00031903-00032102": "will be used as a q a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00150-00032103-00032358": "um so without further ado", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00151-00032360-00032631": "we're going to allow professor berg to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00152-00032632-00032846": "present first so i will play her", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00153-00032847-00034646": "recorded video", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00154-00034647-00036279": "is everybody able to see this", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00155-00036280-00036767": "oh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00156-00036768-00040071": "um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00157-00040072-00044167": "i have to reshare", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00158-00044168-00044943": "yes story telling", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00159-00044944-00045335": "hello and welcome to my presentation", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00160-00045336-00045583": "on celebrity and post-socialist china is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00161-00045584-00045879": "transmedia storyline telling the authors", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00162-00045880-00046135": "are daria berg uh from the university of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00163-00046136-00046318": "saint island in switzerland and judges", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00164-00046319-00046607": "strafella from pallaki university in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00165-00046608-00047135": "olives", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00166-00047136-00047335": "the research area", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00167-00047336-00047607": "is connected to the areas of celebrity", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00168-00047608-00047815": "culture creative industries and cultural", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00169-00047816-00048079": "entrepreneurship women entrepreneurs and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00170-00048080-00048327": "trans media storytelling", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00171-00048328-00048511": "the aim of this research is to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00172-00048512-00048743": "understand celebrity culture", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00173-00048744-00048927": "and the cultural transformation in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00174-00048928-00049230": "post-socialist china's media sphere and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00175-00049231-00049543": "their social political implications", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00176-00049544-00049758": "research questions include how do", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00177-00049759-00050015": "china's celebrities use the different", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00178-00050016-00050327": "media social traditional etc for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00179-00050328-00050535": "cultural production self-fashioning and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00180-00050536-00050679": "communication", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00181-00050680-00050943": "the sources are printed media tv visual", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00182-00050944-00051183": "arts etc web-based literature blogs and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00183-00051184-00051463": "micro blogs the best set is an analysis", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00184-00051464-00051702": "of print and web-based sources and has", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00185-00051703-00051902": "to do with both the contents and also", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00186-00051903-00052166": "the frames to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00187-00052167-00052326": "draw connections to the commercial", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00188-00052327-00052550": "context", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00189-00052551-00052847": "market reforms and cultural commodities", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00190-00052848-00053023": "play an important role here is there a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00191-00053024-00053279": "return to the republican era or even", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00192-00053279-00053447": "early modern china", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00193-00053448-00053654": "market principles pervade the cultural", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00194-00053655-00054054": "sphere in the late 1980s and early 1990s", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00195-00054055-00054342": "are there seats of a creative class", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00196-00054344-00054566": "this is marginal to the system and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00197-00054567-00054830": "stigmatized by intellectuals the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00198-00054832-00055126": "eleven's five-year plan in 2006 said", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00199-00055127-00055375": "that homegrown creativity appears as an", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00200-00055376-00055599": "economic policy imperative", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00201-00055600-00055815": "there's partial reform consumers and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00202-00055816-00055982": "cultural entrepreneurs", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00203-00055983-00056271": "are between politics and the market", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00204-00056272-00056535": "there are so-called social benefits", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00205-00056536-00056719": "between has discovered the value of the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00206-00056720-00056935": "individual creative self-expression and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00207-00056936-00057103": "grassroots energy in transforming", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00208-00057104-00057342": "chinese economy and society", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00209-00057344-00057482": "jin wang", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00210-00057483-00057638": "says", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00211-00057639-00057950": "consumption celebrity is an important", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00212-00057951-00058207": "concept in this context what fiction", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00213-00058208-00058447": "prince fiction and non-fiction", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00214-00058448-00058742": "about life in the culture of consumption", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00215-00058744-00059111": "and are the texts that we are looking at", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00216-00059112-00059294": "the author um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00217-00059295-00059607": "of the book the society of spectacle", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00218-00059608-00059791": "guidebook", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00219-00059791-00060047": "describes consumption celebrity", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00220-00060048-00060342": "celebrity he says is a key element of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00221-00060344-00060630": "the panelization of the modern world", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00222-00060632-00060926": "one example is only bobby the internet", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00223-00060927-00061030": "writer", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00224-00061032-00061294": "and whose real name is lydia she's the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00225-00061295-00061526": "best-selling novelist a blogger editor", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00226-00061527-00061823": "and columnist a photographer and more", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00227-00061824-00062254": "recently a buddhist recluse who now", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00228-00062255-00062519": "writes no longer under the name anybody", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00229-00062520-00062750": "or any baby but", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00230-00062751-00062966": "which is a buddhist name modern on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00231-00062967-00063366": "traditional women writers and she also", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00232-00063367-00063919": "writes similarly in this case as authors", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00233-00063920-00064287": "who've also retreated into reclusion", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00234-00064288-00064535": "the consum assumption celebrity finds", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00235-00064536-00064711": "all of her persona linked with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00236-00064712-00064863": "consumption", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00237-00064864-00065030": "hon han is another example of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00238-00065032-00065263": "consumption celebrity he's a high school", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00239-00065264-00065519": "dropout who appears in the media as a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00240-00065520-00065775": "multi-personality he's a best-selling", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00241-00065776-00065991": "teenage novelist a car racing champion", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00242-00065992-00066206": "the world's number one blogger", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00243-00066207-00066367": "a public intellectual", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00244-00066368-00066623": "a singer and film director also named as", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00245-00066624-00066959": "a playboy or a consumption celebrity all", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00246-00066960-00067150": "his persona are linked with consumption", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00247-00067151-00067471": "and he also ranks among china's top 10", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00248-00067472-00067767": "best-paid writers", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00249-00067768-00068038": "the propaganda department's honors", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00250-00068039-00068255": "are something that we can look here and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00251-00068256-00068535": "in this slide out of 30 top", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00252-00068536-00068815": "personalities the only two or four women", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00253-00068816-00069143": "if you look at the years 2016 to 2019", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00254-00069144-00069415": "for example the stage director wang", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00255-00069416-00069526": "chaka", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00256-00069527-00069847": "the tv producer akawa sun mei the dance", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00257-00069848-00070399": "show produces um junction", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00258-00070400-00070599": "the list of personalities are praised", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00259-00070600-00070823": "for contribution to tourism the local", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00260-00070824-00071150": "economies and the official media etc", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00261-00071151-00071311": "are they marginal", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00262-00071312-00071550": "above you see images of the video", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00263-00071551-00071847": "blogger papi tiang on the left", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00264-00071848-00072135": "tin sing a dancer and choreographer in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00265-00072136-00072399": "davos", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00266-00072400-00072606": "at the intersection of culture and cash", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00267-00072607-00072823": "that's where elizabeth's curry has", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00268-00072824-00073126": "placed such celebrities", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00269-00073127-00073267": "the creation and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00270-00073268-00073431": "conversationalization of cultural", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00271-00073432-00073631": "products marketing business ventures and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00272-00073632-00074006": "self-promotion play important roles here", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00273-00074007-00074247": "and the celebrity has both an", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00274-00074248-00074550": "ideological and economic role", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00275-00074551-00074759": "it is about exchanging cultural goods", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00276-00074760-00074975": "while adding to the menus of beliefs", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00277-00074976-00075231": "mindsets and cultural preferences from", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00278-00075232-00075494": "which others choose here i am referring", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00279-00075495-00076023": "to joel marcus research", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00280-00076024-00076167": "as i mentioned", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00281-00076168-00076567": "um is the pen name of lydia", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00282-00076568-00076847": "she became famous", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00283-00076848-00077062": "in on the literary website on the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00284-00077063-00077423": "internet um under the banyan tree and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00285-00077424-00077662": "she became one of the pioneers of online", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00286-00077663-00077967": "literature in 1997 she published a short", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00287-00077968-00078262": "story galbia", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00288-00078263-00078382": "vivian", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00289-00078383-00078494": "under the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00290-00078495-00078831": "pseudonym of any baby or anybody", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00291-00078832-00078982": "she said she had no publishing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00292-00078983-00079182": "connections playing around mar an", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00293-00079183-00079462": "important concept in the literature of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00294-00079463-00079703": "the reform era writing out of bought", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00295-00079704-00079943": "them just for fun", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00296-00079944-00080262": "around 2000 she actually changed from a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00297-00080263-00080711": "web writer or a hack uh esther shaw to a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00298-00080712-00080950": "more prestigious print author or", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00299-00080951-00081311": "tortilla by publishing her books only in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00300-00081312-00081567": "print after um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00301-00081568-00081959": "that the year 2000. she has now about 15", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00302-00081960-00082159": "books and is the member of the official", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00303-00082160-00082415": "chinese writers association she's also", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00304-00082416-00082694": "active as an editor translator colonist", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00305-00082695-00082855": "and so on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00306-00082856-00083118": "on social media she is known for her", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00307-00083119-00083323": "book promotion and self-fashioning as a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00308-00083324-00083623": "buddhism-inspired traveler", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00309-00083624-00083871": "and i managed to get an interview with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00310-00083872-00084071": "her also she normally never gets", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00311-00084072-00084262": "interviews so i was very happy to be", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00312-00084263-00084535": "able to interview her she told me so", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00313-00084536-00084726": "once i was able to get my writings", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00314-00084727-00084918": "publishers books i just stopped my", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00315-00084919-00085094": "online writings", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00316-00085095-00085335": "not only was this a successful move from", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00317-00085336-00085559": "online to the then more prestigious", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00318-00085560-00085775": "print and rebranding", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00319-00085776-00086006": "it also points to the dense and complex", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00320-00086007-00086191": "connections between multiple traditional", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00321-00086192-00086431": "and digital media in today's mature", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00322-00086432-00086599": "media media sphere", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00323-00086600-00086806": "another example is shooting lei the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00324-00086807-00086967": "actress film director and producer", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00325-00086968-00087167": "writer editor and blogger", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00326-00087168-00087582": "from my father and i um to go la lago", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00327-00087583-00087799": "there's a range of diverse characters", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00328-00087800-00088071": "that she impersonated and played that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00329-00088072-00088338": "hint at the real life shooting lane", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00330-00088339-00088591": "transmediality as an all-around creative", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00331-00088592-00088950": "promotional strategy has been and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00332-00088951-00089118": "character has been characterizing her", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00333-00089119-00089350": "career it's not just products but", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00334-00089351-00089638": "transmedia celebrity her trans media", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00335-00089639-00089950": "celebrity persona that is important for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00336-00089951-00090103": "her marketing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00337-00090104-00090343": "and so fashioning", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00338-00090344-00090718": "a shelter inside is a shooting lace", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00339-00090719-00090911": "that is shooting lace individuality and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00340-00090912-00091118": "personal life in dominguez with her film", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00341-00091119-00091343": "rose and together create the shooting", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00342-00091344-00091606": "lay phenomenon", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00343-00091607-00091743": "so sitting there can also be", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00344-00091744-00091935": "investigated in the context of the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00345-00091936-00092167": "transmedia celebrities here i would like", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00346-00092168-00092359": "to point to a better course distinction", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00347-00092360-00092550": "between the empirical author the model", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00348-00092551-00092862": "author and a character and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00349-00092863-00092943": "and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00350-00092944-00093135": "or as a narrator", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00351-00093136-00093303": "with trump's media strategy and the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00352-00093304-00093487": "social media for example the illusion of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00353-00093488-00093687": "contact with the author there's a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00354-00093688-00093855": "flattening of the multi-layered", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00355-00093856-00094023": "characters onto the identity of the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00356-00094024-00094231": "awesome both sides of the cultural", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00357-00094232-00094447": "entrepreneur's identity", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00358-00094448-00094623": "are the promotion of the product and the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00359-00094624-00094838": "promotion of the mindset or lifestyle", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00360-00094839-00094959": "for example", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00361-00094960-00095191": "a strong woman character more than an um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00362-00095192-00095615": "lifestyle exotic romance and so on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00363-00095616-00095782": "another example of a cultural", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00364-00095783-00095950": "entrepreneur is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00365-00095951-00096159": "the woman artist sophie she's a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00366-00096160-00096374": "multimedia artist and international art", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00367-00096375-00096631": "celebrity she won a chinese contemporary", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00368-00096632-00096911": "art award as best young artist in 2006", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00369-00096912-00097303": "and best artist award in 2016.", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00370-00097304-00097503": "salvi's art reflects on china's social", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00371-00097504-00097759": "cultural transformation from a detached", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00372-00097760-00098015": "sometimes satirical standpoint", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00373-00098016-00098391": "she wants to comment not criticize the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00374-00098392-00098662": "new york times reports", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00375-00098663-00098943": "this points at globalization in internet", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00376-00098944-00099223": "age for example her work on renminbi", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00377-00099224-00099535": "city and one of the themes that she", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00378-00099536-00099887": "discusses or hints at", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00379-00099888-00100174": "is the alien nation", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00380-00100175-00100462": "on social media or instagram she shapes", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00381-00100463-00100662": "her artistic storytelling while", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00382-00100663-00100887": "projecting an image of a successful", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00383-00100888-00101071": "global artist", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00384-00101072-00101359": "here is an example from her instagram", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00385-00101360-00101806": "shining a light on chinese workers", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00386-00101807-00102047": "room number one and number two", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00387-00102048-00102326": "and normal art are works commissioned", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00388-00102327-00102686": "and exhibited by gucci", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00389-00102688-00103054": "sauerfe's other project was the bmw art", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00390-00103055-00103239": "car number 18", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00391-00103240-00103463": "called unmanned which was commissioned", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00392-00103464-00103647": "by bmw", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00393-00103648-00103871": "it augmented reality", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00394-00103872-00104263": "uh in her art and she also um added a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00395-00104264-00104710": "short film on a car the w a bmw art car", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00396-00104711-00105095": "number 18 which is based on the bmw m6", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00397-00105096-00105358": "gt3 is inspired by the speed of racing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00398-00105359-00105519": "cars and the tremendous changes of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00399-00105520-00105766": "chinese society over the past decades", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00400-00105767-00106134": "she says on her website", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00401-00106135-00106319": "taofas", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00402-00106320-00106510": "it's obvious case we can see how most", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00403-00106511-00106751": "experimental of creative industries have", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00404-00106752-00106966": "broken separation between the elite", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00405-00106967-00107110": "serious culture and intense", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00406-00107111-00107278": "commercialization and social media", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00407-00107279-00107407": "promotion", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00408-00107408-00107623": "most avant-garde cultural languages and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00409-00107624-00107839": "darkest commentary on modern society are", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00410-00107840-00108110": "fully integrated in the market logics", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00411-00108111-00108463": "of the creative industries", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00412-00108464-00108686": "to conclude there's a relative", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00413-00108688-00108839": "marginalization", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00414-00108840-00109047": "the commercial limelight in which these", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00415-00109048-00109254": "celebrities find themselves versus the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00416-00109255-00109502": "lack of political cooperation", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00417-00109503-00109654": "there's a complex relation between", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00418-00109655-00109839": "traditional and new media such as the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00419-00109840-00110031": "digital media with regard to symbolic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00420-00110032-00110334": "capital and creative activities", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00421-00110335-00110566": "transmediality appears in cultural", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00422-00110567-00110831": "creation or communication and the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00423-00110832-00111095": "shaping of the cultural entrepreneurs", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00424-00111096-00111351": "public persona as a multimedia", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00425-00111352-00111495": "personality", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00426-00111496-00111727": "artistic experimentation appears as a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00427-00111728-00112054": "function of cultural entrepreneurship", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00428-00112055-00112943": "thank you very much", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00429-00112944-00113127": "great we are so grateful for professor", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00430-00113128-00113327": "berg's participation in the seminar", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00431-00113328-00113534": "given her very busy schedule", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00432-00113535-00113639": "a fascinating", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00433-00113640-00113878": "presentation as always so again thank", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00434-00113879-00114151": "you to professor berg", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00435-00114152-00114366": "now let's welcome professor mung who", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00436-00114367-00114839": "will be presenting next", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00437-00114840-00115902": "okay let me try to share screen first", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00438-00115903-00116086": "is it okay for you guys now", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00439-00116088-00116263": "oh good", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00440-00116264-00116510": "all right well the nice thing about", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00441-00116511-00116719": "doing a pre-recorded lecture is that you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00442-00116720-00116902": "can make sure that you don't go over", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00443-00116903-00117151": "time um i i do have a tendency of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00444-00117152-00117366": "talking too long though so and jake", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00445-00117367-00117695": "maybe you could remind me if i reach the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00446-00117696-00118063": "12 13 minutes point and then i will know", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00447-00118064-00118199": "what time you need", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00448-00118200-00118519": "when to wrap up um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00449-00118520-00118607": "so", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00450-00118608-00118878": "my talk today is based on a project that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00451-00118879-00119039": "i recently", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00452-00119040-00119407": "completed with two phd students about", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00453-00119408-00119615": "the experience of chinese overseas", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00454-00119616-00119910": "students during the pandemic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00455-00119911-00120223": "and when jake extended the invitation to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00456-00120224-00120575": "take part in this symposium i thought", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00457-00120576-00120902": "it's related to the overall theme of the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00458-00120903-00121023": "panel", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00459-00121024-00121302": "in two ways one is because the overall", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00460-00121303-00121486": "theme of the symposium has to do with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00461-00121488-00121614": "final", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00462-00121615-00121975": "us relation and engagement", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00463-00121976-00122054": "and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00464-00122055-00122295": "what we did in this project is to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00465-00122296-00122478": "conduct in-depth interviews with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00466-00122479-00122727": "students who were studying", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00467-00122728-00123063": "um either in the uk or the in in the u.s", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00468-00123064-00123158": "during", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00469-00123159-00123447": "the pandemic and a lot of the questions", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00470-00123448-00123719": "have to do with how", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00471-00123720-00123871": "their views", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00472-00123872-00124119": "of the different political system and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00473-00124120-00124439": "also their personal experience with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00474-00124440-00124783": "xenophobia with anti-china", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00475-00124783-00125023": "sort of shaped also their their value", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00476-00125024-00125319": "during this this time so that that's one", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00477-00125320-00125558": "connection there and secondly", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00478-00125559-00125766": "we call this mediated", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00479-00125767-00126047": "pandemic experience also because", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00480-00126048-00126271": "in our interview there's a large chunk", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00481-00126272-00126566": "of the the topic guide actually asked", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00482-00126567-00126863": "about people's digital media usage", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00483-00126864-00127214": "because in a way this current pandemic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00484-00127215-00127447": "compared with all the previous public", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00485-00127448-00127839": "health crisis is intensely mediated in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00486-00127840-00128047": "an unprecedented way", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00487-00128048-00128239": "and for overseas chinese students", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00488-00128240-00128471": "because of the prevalence", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00489-00128472-00128766": "of social media usage", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00490-00128767-00129054": "they basically live in different", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00491-00129055-00129407": "media environments so they get", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00492-00129408-00129590": "the mainstream media from their host", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00493-00129591-00129686": "country", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00494-00129688-00129975": "but also they are closely monitoring and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00495-00129976-00130278": "also very intensely engaged", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00496-00130279-00130383": "with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00497-00130383-00130575": "social media accounts", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00498-00130576-00130863": "on wechat on weibo and constantly also", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00499-00130864-00131063": "getting messages from their parents and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00500-00131064-00131247": "family back home", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00501-00131248-00131495": "so it's in a way it's quite a unique", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00502-00131496-00131799": "mediated experience for these um chinese", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00503-00131800-00131935": "students", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00504-00131936-00132054": "um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00505-00132055-00132327": "so that's that's why i think maybe it's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00506-00132328-00132527": "it's it will be relevant and interesting", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00507-00132528-00132799": "to talk about this project although i i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00508-00132800-00132999": "do realize you know given the nature of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00509-00133000-00133278": "this symposium i'm not this is not", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00510-00133279-00133566": "exactly a research conference so i'm", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00511-00133567-00133831": "gonna skip some of the parts that have", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00512-00133832-00134071": "um you know focus more on the the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00513-00134072-00134327": "methodology and the research design", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00514-00134328-00134647": "um but first just to set the thing a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00515-00134648-00134839": "little bit and thinking about the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00516-00134840-00135047": "context um i think you know there are a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00517-00135048-00135239": "few things to note here", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00518-00135240-00135502": "one is the outbreak of the kobe 19 takes", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00519-00135503-00135783": "place at the high point of um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00520-00135784-00136102": "neoliberal globalization when both", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00521-00136103-00136295": "global interconnection and the backlash", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00522-00136296-00136407": "against it", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00523-00136408-00136559": "on various fronts have reached an", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00524-00136560-00136711": "unprecedented", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00525-00136712-00136799": "level", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00526-00136800-00137054": "um already you know before the pandemic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00527-00137055-00137247": "there was discussion about the so-called", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00528-00137248-00137575": "decoupling of the us and china there was", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00529-00137576-00137799": "a trade war there's also the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00530-00137800-00138078": "um the the talking about whether we are", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00531-00138079-00138177": "witnessing um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00532-00138178-00138327": "[Music]", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00533-00138328-00138511": "cold war 2.0", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00534-00138512-00138727": "so it's uh you know really two sides of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00535-00138728-00139047": "the same coin we see in um unprecedented", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00536-00139048-00139247": "interconnection but also there's very", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00537-00139248-00139454": "strong backlash against it", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00538-00139455-00139687": "and economically and geopolitically um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00539-00139688-00139975": "compared to the 2003 stars epic epidemic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00540-00139976-00140231": "china now also occupies a very different", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00541-00140232-00140566": "position in the global capitalist orders", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00542-00140567-00140871": "um and for the overseas chinese students", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00543-00140872-00141190": "as they and and i you know this is also", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00544-00141191-00141511": "partly the reason why i um started this", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00545-00141512-00141727": "project i started this project really", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00546-00141728-00141966": "because i was witnessing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00547-00141967-00142287": "um the kind of experience that my", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00548-00142288-00142478": "chinese students were going through", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00549-00142479-00142790": "especially around 2020", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00550-00142791-00143126": "so in the early 2020s when china was the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00551-00143127-00143343": "epic center", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00552-00143344-00143623": "and chinese students were experiencing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00553-00143624-00143975": "all the anxiety and they had to make the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00554-00143976-00144183": "difficult decision about where whether", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00555-00144184-00144351": "they should wear masks coming to the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00556-00144352-00144599": "class because at that time it's not", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00557-00144600-00144799": "happening you know it's not really", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00558-00144800-00145007": "erupting in europe yet", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00559-00145008-00145366": "um and they were also there was also a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00560-00145367-00145607": "very you know ugly", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00561-00145608-00145775": "racist um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00562-00145776-00146078": "attack and racial abuse happening in the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00563-00146079-00146366": "uk in the at the beginning of 2020", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00564-00146367-00146575": "because chinese students were somehow", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00565-00146576-00146823": "considered being you know infectious", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00566-00146824-00146966": "contagious or", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00567-00146967-00147263": "simply because they were wearing musk", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00568-00147264-00147543": "but then as the epic center shifted from", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00569-00147544-00147783": "china as things were put under control", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00570-00147784-00147959": "in china and then the epic center", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00571-00147960-00148254": "shifted to europe and as uk went into", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00572-00148255-00148431": "lockdown", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00573-00148432-00148535": "they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00574-00148536-00148814": "then also experience also intense", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00575-00148815-00149023": "anxiety about whether they should stay", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00576-00149024-00149111": "here", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00577-00149112-00149366": "um or um and especially after all the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00578-00149367-00149526": "teaching went online and whether they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00579-00149527-00149711": "should go back home and if they decide", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00580-00149712-00149902": "to go back home is it possible to do", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00581-00149903-00150071": "that some of them", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00582-00150072-00150359": "bought multiple air tickets just to make", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00583-00150360-00150623": "sure that they can finally make the trip", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00584-00150624-00150702": "home", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00585-00150703-00150959": "so this was really um you know", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00586-00150960-00151214": "partly the project was really triggered", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00587-00151215-00151543": "by what i witnessed as as the the the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00588-00151544-00151790": "struggle and the stress and anxiety that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00589-00151791-00152031": "my chinese students were going through", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00590-00152032-00152607": "at that time", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00591-00152608-00152847": "but putting this um you know in an", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00592-00152848-00153126": "academic context the questions we are", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00593-00153127-00153247": "asking", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00594-00153248-00153551": "um in this project is what have been the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00595-00153552-00153751": "lived experience of chinese overseas", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00596-00153752-00154031": "students during the kobe 19 pandemic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00597-00154032-00154247": "especially in relation to racism", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00598-00154248-00154526": "xenophobia and nationalism", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00599-00154527-00154790": "and what are the main discrepancies and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00600-00154791-00154983": "incongruences that chinese overseas", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00601-00154984-00155175": "students have to negotiate", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00602-00155176-00155414": "in their mediated understanding of the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00603-00155415-00155623": "crisis as i mentioned at the beginning", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00604-00155624-00155751": "because you know they are getting", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00605-00155752-00155983": "information from both media outlets in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00606-00155984-00156207": "their host country and also from their", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00607-00156208-00156487": "their home country um and also because", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00608-00156488-00156783": "of the the omnipresence of social media", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00609-00156784-00157063": "um you know they were basically", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00610-00157064-00157311": "if they choose to they can stay online", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00611-00157312-00157551": "24 7. and i'm going to talk about later", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00612-00157552-00157735": "how they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00613-00157736-00157975": "then learn to manage their own media", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00614-00157976-00158087": "consumption", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00615-00158088-00158431": "as a way also to manage anxiety and and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00616-00158432-00158566": "stress", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00617-00158567-00158735": "um and then", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00618-00158736-00158895": "have their assessment of the political", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00619-00158896-00159071": "system in both china and their host", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00620-00159072-00159287": "country in any way affected by the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00621-00159288-00159511": "pandemic and this of course is the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00622-00159512-00159743": "continuation of the the first research", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00623-00159744-00159951": "question about how you know their", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00624-00159952-00160319": "um they experience um racism xenophobia", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00625-00160320-00160790": "and nationalism", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00626-00160791-00160983": "and putting this in a bit of a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00627-00160984-00161278": "theoretical context so basically there", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00628-00161279-00161566": "are two sort of theoretical threats here", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00629-00161567-00161695": "one is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00630-00161696-00162039": "uric backs notion of risk society", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00631-00162040-00162247": "and the extent to which the risk of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00632-00162248-00162483": "society should mobilize", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00633-00162484-00162766": "a cosmopolitan", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00634-00162767-00163102": "cooperation and also to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00635-00163103-00163454": "mobilize a cosmopolitan mindset", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00636-00163455-00163678": "so his argument is that you know as the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00637-00163679-00163999": "the anticipation of global risk", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00638-00164000-00164207": "could result in everybody", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00639-00164208-00164414": "an everyday global awareness among", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00640-00164415-00164638": "citizens of modern societies and give", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00641-00164639-00164951": "rise to cosmopolitan in imperatives of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00642-00164952-00165071": "cooperation", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00643-00165072-00165335": "um so this is you know of course you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00644-00165336-00165526": "know he", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00645-00165527-00165759": "his notion of cosmopolitan imperative", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00646-00165760-00166038": "has both a normative and analytical", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00647-00166039-00166319": "dimension and what we want to ask is to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00648-00166320-00166519": "problemize this and ask the question to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00649-00166520-00166647": "what extent", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00650-00166648-00166854": "or whether this has really you know the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00651-00166855-00167135": "current global crisis um has", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00652-00167136-00167366": "contributed to um the rise of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00653-00167367-00167671": "cosmopolitan imperative and another sort", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00654-00167672-00167926": "of um theoretical threat here is is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00655-00167927-00168247": "about diaspora and media consumption and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00656-00168248-00168407": "especially", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00657-00168408-00168623": "at this day and age of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00658-00168624-00168766": "social media", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00659-00168767-00168935": "pervasiveness", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00660-00168936-00169175": "how have the diaspora population", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00661-00169176-00169407": "negotiated their national identity and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00662-00169408-00169551": "political legions", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00663-00169552-00169759": "with vocabularies and discursive", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00664-00169760-00170023": "resources provided", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00665-00170024-00170302": "by both you know media from their home", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00666-00170303-00170566": "country and also media in the host", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00667-00170567-00170759": "country", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00668-00170760-00170838": "um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00669-00170839-00171207": "and you know so based on this um sort of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00670-00171208-00171407": "deriving from these two theoretical", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00671-00171408-00171663": "threats uh we want to better understand", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00672-00171664-00171895": "how is the current public health risk uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00673-00171896-00172095": "makes it made sense of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00674-00172096-00172343": "by an elite group that epitomizes", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00675-00172344-00172599": "mobility and connectivity and we do", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00676-00172600-00172878": "recognize very much the the the very", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00677-00172879-00173135": "strong elite band in our sample", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00678-00173136-00173366": "uh because these are students um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00679-00173367-00173478": "studying", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00680-00173479-00173935": "in um elite uk and u.s universities and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00681-00173936-00174183": "some of them even started their overseas", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00682-00174184-00174502": "education from secondary school", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00683-00174503-00174711": "so we are talking about a particular", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00684-00174712-00174919": "group that used to take", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00685-00174920-00175159": "mobility and connectivity for granted", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00686-00175160-00175351": "and then suddenly during the pandemic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00687-00175352-00175631": "this mobility and connectivity", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00688-00175632-00175735": "are", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00689-00175736-00175847": "halted", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00690-00175848-00176038": "and which also prompt", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00691-00176039-00176319": "a lot of deliberation and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00692-00176320-00176551": "reconsideration", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00693-00176552-00176751": "and how individuals navigate the young", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00694-00176752-00176975": "incongruous and uncertainty by piecing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00695-00176976-00177111": "together", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00696-00177112-00177351": "very diversity resources in an effort to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00697-00177352-00177631": "articulate a coherent", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00698-00177632-00177895": "narrative", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00699-00177896-00178190": "so i'm going to skip this um slides", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00700-00178191-00178463": "about the researches with design and um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00701-00178464-00178743": "but just to note that basically the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00702-00178744-00178999": "topic guide has three", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00703-00179000-00179319": "main components and and one of these", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00704-00179320-00179623": "components is asking about their daily", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00705-00179624-00179783": "media usage", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00706-00179784-00180143": "um and i'll also skip this slide about", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00707-00180144-00180326": "the sample but", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00708-00180327-00180551": "generally we try to achieve", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00709-00180552-00180766": "a balance in terms of gender", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00710-00180767-00181031": "major and also the length of study", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00711-00181032-00181302": "overseas but but as you can see here we", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00712-00181303-00181575": "have quite a number of interviewees who", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00713-00181576-00181854": "had more than five years of studying so", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00714-00181855-00182047": "this would um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00715-00182048-00182359": "often include part of the secondary", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00716-00182360-00182878": "education", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00717-00182879-00183151": "and um you know this is this is a quote", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00718-00183152-00183366": "from um this is with an article", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00719-00183367-00183502": "published um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00720-00183503-00183719": "during the pandemic um so the um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00721-00183720-00183895": "colombia-based um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00722-00183896-00184183": "historian adam tooth and he was saying", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00723-00184184-00184302": "uh that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00724-00184303-00184535": "back is the most important maybe", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00725-00184536-00184743": "sociologists that could help us", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00726-00184744-00185063": "understand the current crisis and in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00727-00185064-00185351": "this quote um in particular", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00728-00185352-00185566": "um he talked about how back was talking", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00729-00185567-00185695": "about you know in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00730-00185696-00186047": "contemporary risk a global risk society", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00731-00186048-00186319": "there is this almost this demand for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00732-00186320-00186463": "individuals", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00733-00186464-00186599": "to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00734-00186600-00186831": "acquire more knowledge acquire more", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00735-00186832-00187071": "information and to become the so-called", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00736-00187072-00187271": "private expert", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00737-00187272-00187759": "on a very complicated issue", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00738-00187760-00188207": "so partly um you know the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00739-00188208-00188454": "our interview question dealing with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00740-00188455-00188726": "media usage and media consumption", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00741-00188727-00188911": "really highlights", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00742-00188912-00189223": "um the cost of becoming the private", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00743-00189224-00189535": "experts on the risk of modernization and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00744-00189536-00189663": "in this case", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00745-00189664-00189838": "the pandemic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00746-00189839-00190126": "now generally speaking in terms of media", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00747-00190127-00190366": "literacy and media usage across the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00748-00190367-00190575": "board because of the nature of the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00749-00190576-00190895": "demographic feature of this this group", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00750-00190896-00191071": "we see a very", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00751-00191072-00191295": "high level of information literacy and a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00752-00191296-00191590": "fairly sophisticated pattern of media", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00753-00191591-00191799": "consumption", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00754-00191800-00192031": "and often when we ask them where they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00755-00192032-00192159": "get their", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00756-00192160-00192319": "news from", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00757-00192320-00192399": "they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00758-00192400-00192702": "were able to make uh this distinction", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00759-00192703-00192935": "between different types of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00760-00192936-00193302": "um english language news media and they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00761-00193303-00193687": "are critical of institutional media on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00762-00193688-00193911": "both sides on both the their home", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00763-00193912-00194095": "country and the host country", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00764-00194096-00194278": "but even more so", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00765-00194279-00194583": "of the mainstream", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00766-00194584-00194943": "news media in the u.s and the uk", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00767-00194944-00195175": "and i think partly this has to do with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00768-00195176-00195319": "the fact that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00769-00195320-00195623": "it's a given that they understand that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00770-00195624-00195871": "media environment in china is heavily", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00771-00195872-00195983": "censored", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00772-00195984-00196278": "so but many of them said at least when", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00773-00196279-00196390": "they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00774-00196391-00196687": "come to study in the uk or or in the us", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00775-00196688-00196950": "they were expecting something different", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00776-00196951-00197175": "but they were many of them were bitterly", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00777-00197176-00197431": "disappointed during the pandemic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00778-00197432-00197654": "especially at the beginning of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00779-00197655-00197863": "the pandemic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00780-00197864-00198063": "because of the way that international", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00781-00198064-00198335": "news media reported on the situation in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00782-00198336-00198487": "china", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00783-00198488-00198814": "and in terms of social media usage also", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00784-00198815-00199078": "they demonstrate very um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00785-00199079-00199278": "nuanced understanding of different types", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00786-00199279-00199535": "of social media platforms in terms of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00787-00199536-00199823": "you know i go to this media platform for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00788-00199824-00200087": "this type of information but i don't go", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00789-00200088-00200278": "there for such and such", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00790-00200279-00200511": "so i go to xiaohungshui if i want some", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00791-00200512-00200871": "everyday you know live daily life tips", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00792-00200872-00201126": "but i would go to juhu if i want to find", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00793-00201127-00201311": "more reliable", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00794-00201312-00201519": "informational content", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00795-00201520-00201823": "so they were able to to make these", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00796-00201824-00202095": "distinctions", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00797-00202096-00202366": "and this this very um you know because", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00798-00202367-00202647": "of the the very high level of media", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00799-00202648-00202878": "literacy and information literacy this", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00800-00202879-00203102": "daily curation of media consumption is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00801-00203103-00203431": "often deployed as a protective mechanism", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00802-00203432-00203654": "to shield themselves from negative", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00803-00203655-00203926": "feelings such as anger distress or", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00804-00203927-00204159": "anxiety", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00805-00204160-00204238": "and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00806-00204239-00204463": "in reality these students experience", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00807-00204464-00204678": "often an acute sense of fragmentation", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00808-00204679-00204951": "confusion and contradiction while living", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00809-00204952-00205255": "abroad during the pandemic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00810-00205256-00205423": "as much as", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00811-00205423-00205646": "these feelings were psychologically", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00812-00205648-00205934": "discomforting and emotionally draining", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00813-00205935-00206238": "they also enabled um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00814-00206239-00206479": "opportunities of introspection and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00815-00206480-00206614": "reflection", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00816-00206615-00206823": "which is um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00817-00206823-00207214": "sort of the the second part of our um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00818-00207215-00207542": "the result of our data analysis so we", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00819-00207544-00207798": "call it the the personal is is political", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00820-00207800-00207958": "so", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00821-00207959-00208142": "you know in the meantime as they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00822-00208144-00208479": "experience anxiety trauma um and and and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00823-00208480-00208758": "all this um you know the the stress", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00824-00208759-00208942": "there was also a sense of political", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00825-00208944-00209079": "awakening", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00826-00209080-00209366": "um and this happened of course not just", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00827-00209367-00209590": "during the pandemic some of them said it", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00828-00209591-00209846": "happened after they leave mainland china", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00829-00209848-00210087": "um and one of the the interviews said", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00830-00210088-00210294": "here um you know when i was in china i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00831-00210296-00210471": "was discouraged to to talk about", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00832-00210471-00210719": "political issues but when i was studying", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00833-00210719-00210975": "in hong kong i suddenly realized that i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00834-00210976-00211206": "am part of the political discussion of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00835-00211207-00211446": "other people so there's no way for me", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00836-00211448-00211806": "even to escape this this discussion", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00837-00211807-00211903": "um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00838-00211904-00212015": "they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00839-00212016-00212198": "also um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00840-00212200-00212391": "feeling there is also you know a sense", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00841-00212392-00212591": "of feeling stuck in an increasingly", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00842-00212592-00212767": "polarized world", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00843-00212767-00212991": "in the sense that they feel that they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00844-00212992-00213206": "are constantly compelled", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00845-00213207-00213534": "um or demanded to take sides um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00846-00213535-00213806": "and often they say you know the issue is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00847-00213807-00214015": "more complicated i don't always want", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00848-00214016-00214303": "just what want to to take sides but i'm", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00849-00214304-00214551": "you know called upon all the time to do", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00850-00214552-00214767": "that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00851-00214767-00214846": "and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00852-00214848-00214934": "they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00853-00214935-00215142": "as a coping strategy they try to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00854-00215144-00215487": "separate the political from the personal", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00855-00215488-00215742": "but of course this is not always", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00856-00215744-00215910": "possible", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00857-00215911-00216142": "and actually in the article", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00858-00216144-00216327": "probably this is a very long quote you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00859-00216328-00216663": "won't be able to to read through it", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00860-00216664-00216863": "given the limited time but in the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00861-00216864-00217063": "article we had", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00862-00217064-00217327": "quite a few lengthy on original quotes", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00863-00217328-00217575": "from interview transcripts is when our", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00864-00217576-00217734": "interviewees", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00865-00217735-00217951": "really open up and talk about their", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00866-00217952-00218167": "personal experience", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00867-00218167-00218319": "with um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00868-00218319-00218727": "with race with with class and sometimes", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00869-00218728-00219142": "also this experience is also really um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00870-00219144-00219455": "closely connected with their", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00871-00219456-00219703": "the intimate relationship that they went", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00872-00219704-00220182": "through", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00873-00220183-00220351": "so", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00874-00220352-00220598": "you know partly as a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00875-00220600-00220863": "because we are talking again i'm talking", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00876-00220864-00221039": "about an elite group", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00877-00221040-00221351": "who have very high level of cognitive", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00878-00221352-00221471": "capacity", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00879-00221471-00221710": "so in the middle of this kind of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00880-00221711-00222071": "confusion um and the um you know the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00881-00222071-00222175": "stress", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00882-00222176-00222510": "there is also a conscious effort", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00883-00222511-00222767": "trying to articulate", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00884-00222767-00223063": "a counter-harmonic discourse trying to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00885-00223064-00223287": "trying to make sense of all this and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00886-00223288-00223494": "trying to also make sense of the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00887-00223496-00223646": "discrepancy", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00888-00223648-00223791": "and the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00889-00223792-00224039": "incongruence that they went through", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00890-00224040-00224255": "after leaving china and after going", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00891-00224256-00224487": "through the pandemic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00892-00224488-00224639": "um so we", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00893-00224640-00224910": "were able to schematize um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00894-00224911-00225151": "what we call four types of counter-her", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00895-00225152-00225342": "demonic discourses", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00896-00225344-00225591": "um the first one is the you know at the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00897-00225592-00225798": "most surface level the criticism of the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00898-00225800-00226079": "political system in the u.s or the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00899-00226080-00226198": "uh the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00900-00226200-00226415": "the uk", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00901-00226416-00226719": "and the um you know the also the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00902-00226719-00227063": "shifting boundary of multiple identities", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00903-00227064-00227351": "and this is related to what i said", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00904-00227352-00227646": "earlier about this discontent", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00905-00227648-00228015": "with the imperative of taking sides in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00906-00228016-00228527": "the polarized world", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00907-00228528-00228606": "and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00908-00228607-00228879": "um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00909-00228880-00229087": "the the four types of um counter", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00910-00229088-00229382": "harmonic this courses we identified um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00911-00229383-00229719": "there's a there's a tiny slice among all", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00912-00229719-00230031": "our um 45 interviews there was actually", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00913-00230032-00230134": "one", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00914-00230135-00230623": "vocal trump supporter um and he", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00915-00230623-00231023": "was able to articulate a a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00916-00231023-00231279": "you know a reason for for for being that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00917-00231280-00231534": "um and he was also very much aware that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00918-00231535-00231806": "he said no i'm probably in the minority", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00919-00231807-00231975": "and i don't always tell my friends that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00920-00231976-00232206": "i support um trump", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00921-00232207-00232582": "um and there's also anoth a second type", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00922-00232583-00232894": "which has is is also more or less in the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00923-00232896-00233215": "minority among our interviewees", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00924-00233216-00233527": "but um it's of larger number than the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00925-00233528-00233639": "first one", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00926-00233640-00233919": "that those are the people who", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00927-00233919-00234127": "were able to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00928-00234128-00234294": "link", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00929-00234296-00234503": "the racial", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00930-00234504-00234758": "problem and racial tension in the u.s or", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00931-00234759-00235046": "the uk with the class issue and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00932-00235048-00235279": "sometimes they say you know this is not", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00933-00235280-00235487": "about race it's about class", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00934-00235488-00235639": "and and they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00935-00235640-00235887": "were actually able to claim that i'll", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00936-00235888-00236206": "actually now i'm rediscovering marx that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00937-00236207-00236439": "even though i was sort of indoctrinated", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00938-00236440-00236694": "in my middle class politics", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00939-00236696-00236951": "textbook back in china and i never liked", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00940-00236952-00237206": "it and suddenly now i'm rediscovering", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00941-00237207-00237519": "so so that's that's the second um type", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00942-00237519-00237742": "of counter-hardmonic of course", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00943-00237744-00237967": "and the third one is what we call the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00944-00237967-00238082": "status", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00945-00238083-00238239": "developmentalism", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00946-00238240-00238534": "people and this is probably i would say", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00947-00238535-00238742": "more in the mature more or less in the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00948-00238744-00238887": "majority", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00949-00238888-00239191": "and this is also the group that has the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00950-00239192-00239431": "strongest the nationalist", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00951-00239432-00239542": "tendency", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00952-00239544-00239839": "in the sense that the way they evaluate", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00953-00239840-00240119": "different political systems is based on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00954-00240119-00240287": "economic growth", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00955-00240288-00240567": "um and the ability to govern or the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00956-00240567-00240742": "efficiency to govern", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00957-00240744-00240879": "so in that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00958-00240880-00241134": "you know regard when they compare", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00959-00241135-00241439": "they um you know the the effort the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00960-00241440-00241630": "government-led effort against the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00961-00241631-00241894": "pandemic it's quite clear for them you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00962-00241896-00242175": "know which which side or which system is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00963-00242176-00242334": "is better", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00964-00242335-00242582": "but there's also another i would say", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00965-00242583-00242710": "probably", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00966-00242711-00242982": "um also in the minority um an", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00967-00242983-00243239": "articulation of or more of a social", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00968-00243240-00243463": "democratic value those are the people", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00969-00243464-00243682": "who were questioning this", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00970-00243683-00244103": "developmentalism mindset um and um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00971-00244104-00244342": "some of them were even saying that i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00972-00244344-00244527": "don't understand how people in china", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00973-00244528-00244758": "nowadays can evaluate everything based", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00974-00244759-00244942": "on economic development that's just", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00975-00244944-00245063": "insane", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00976-00245064-00245271": "so so these are the people who are", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00977-00245271-00245534": "questioning whether a good society", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00978-00245535-00245806": "requires more than the efficiency of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00979-00245807-00246175": "governance and economic growth", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00980-00246176-00246455": "but they are also very critical of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00981-00246456-00246694": "the new liberalism in that the witness", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00982-00246696-00247142": "they witnessed in um us and the uk", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00983-00247144-00247415": "um so in in conclusion i know i'm going", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00984-00247416-00247551": "over time", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00985-00247552-00247710": "um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00986-00247711-00247975": "we we would um conclude that leaving", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00987-00247976-00248191": "china has been an enabling and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00988-00248192-00248471": "empowering experience but um returning", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00989-00248471-00248671": "for many of them when they we asked", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00990-00248671-00248863": "about their longer-term plan", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00991-00248864-00249094": "um returning is an increasingly", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00992-00249096-00249351": "desirable option for many", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00993-00249352-00249567": "and the pandemic serves as a prism", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00994-00249567-00249758": "through which overseas chinese students", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00995-00249759-00249958": "reflect on a host of interesting", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00996-00249959-00250191": "intersecting issues including race", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00997-00250192-00250406": "national identity and ideological", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00998-00250407-00250615": "affiliation", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-00999-00250616-00250887": "and the elite population has more", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01000-00250888-00251030": "resources", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01001-00251031-00251279": "undoubtedly including the capacity of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01002-00251280-00251519": "buying multiple tickets just to make", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01003-00251519-00251694": "sure that they can eventually travel", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01004-00251696-00251919": "back home and they are definitely", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01005-00251919-00252046": "privileges", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01006-00252048-00252263": "both that they have the both the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01007-00252264-00252494": "material and the intellectual privilege", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01008-00252496-00252823": "in mitigating the global uh risk", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01009-00252823-00253110": "um but they are also experiencing and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01010-00253111-00253334": "some of them were already able to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01011-00253335-00253694": "articulate the frustration with um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01012-00253696-00254046": "neoliberal globalization and their very", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01013-00254048-00254239": "critical comments on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01014-00254240-00254423": "liberal democracy", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01015-00254423-00254655": "so i think it remains an open question", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01016-00254656-00254855": "if we think about you know these are the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01017-00254856-00255103": "people who are going to occupy", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01018-00255104-00255358": "um you know important positions in the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01019-00255359-00255551": "future and think about", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01020-00255552-00255767": "the sort of longer term", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01021-00255767-00256039": "implication of of this experience i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01022-00256040-00256351": "think a lot of the issues remain", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01023-00256352-00256503": "open-ended", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01024-00256504-00256751": "depending on you know how", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01025-00256752-00256951": "their trajectories develop", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01026-00256952-00257167": "but um this is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01027-00257167-00257391": "the gist of our study", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01028-00257392-00257958": "thank you for your time and attention", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01029-00257959-00258167": "thank you so much professor hmong we", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01030-00258167-00258303": "really appreciate it that was a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01031-00258304-00258582": "fantastic presentation our final speaker", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01032-00258583-00258742": "will be professor schneider from the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01033-00258744-00259039": "university of leiden um you may go ahead", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01034-00259040-00259294": "and share your screen all right well let", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01035-00259296-00259527": "me go ahead and uh see if you can see", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01036-00259528-00259839": "this my prezi here just gonna switch to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01037-00259840-00259982": "full screen", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01038-00259983-00260255": "uh yeah so let me switch to a topic uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01039-00260256-00260382": "that is slightly different from what", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01040-00260383-00260534": "we've heard so far i think you're going", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01041-00260535-00260671": "to notice a whole lot of connections in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01042-00260671-00260855": "the moment i'll try to stick to 15", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01043-00260856-00261103": "minutes i myself work mostly on digital", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01044-00261104-00261239": "nationalism but today i wanted to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01045-00261240-00261430": "reflect a little bit more broadly about", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01046-00261431-00261582": "what happens when people come together", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01047-00261583-00261839": "online what kind of community formations", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01048-00261840-00261991": "we see coming together and what that has", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01049-00261992-00262199": "to do with politics specifically uh in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01050-00262200-00262367": "the cases where the community sentiments", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01051-00262368-00262558": "turn into a kind of tribalism the sort", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01052-00262559-00262719": "of thing that you do indeed see in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01053-00262720-00262919": "nationalist movements so just to get us", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01054-00262920-00263095": "started i wanted to create a little bit", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01055-00263096-00263230": "of a connection", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01056-00263231-00263519": "to politics more broadly and to give you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01057-00263520-00263767": "a brief rundown of why looking at", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01058-00263768-00264103": "popular culture at uh subculture groups", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01059-00264104-00264247": "might have something to do with politics", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01060-00264248-00264391": "and i'm going to start us off with the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01061-00264392-00264615": "us so that you have that connection and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01062-00264616-00264775": "then you'll see in a moment uh what we", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01063-00264776-00265023": "might uncover in the chinese instances", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01064-00265024-00265263": "uh so uh this is just a brief", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01065-00265264-00265591": "relationship diagram here from the 2014", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01066-00265592-00265839": "uh infamous gamergate case", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01067-00265840-00265958": "you know the age that you might know", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01068-00265959-00266103": "this right so um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01069-00266104-00266415": "in 2014 there was this uh moment where", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01070-00266416-00266519": "um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01071-00266520-00266823": "right-wing gamers were criticizing women", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01072-00266824-00266975": "in gaming and gaming in the gaming", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01073-00266976-00267255": "industry uh designers and journalists", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01074-00267256-00267527": "under the guise of trying to criticize", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01075-00267528-00267710": "game journalism and supposedly the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01076-00267711-00267830": "corruption happening in gaming", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01077-00267831-00267982": "journalism there was really just a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01078-00267983-00268343": "misogynist rant against women in gaming", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01079-00268344-00268519": "to the extent that a lot of women were", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01080-00268520-00268663": "receiving death threats", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01081-00268664-00268855": "you can see this here at the bottom", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01082-00268856-00269047": "freight threats of rape uh was", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01083-00269048-00269367": "absolutely horrific uh and it was um at", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01084-00269368-00269551": "the time by a lot of gamers brushed away", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01085-00269552-00269767": "as oh yes either boys being boys was", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01086-00269768-00269943": "just it's just games", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01087-00269944-00270158": "and a lot of people were if they weren't", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01088-00270159-00270334": "in the gaming industry and and plugged", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01089-00270335-00270567": "in with cultures and subcultures weren't", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01090-00270568-00270703": "really paying a whole lot of attention", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01091-00270704-00270927": "to this but they should because as uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01092-00270928-00271047": "subsequent", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01093-00271048-00271199": "research and especially investigative", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01094-00271200-00271463": "journalism has shown a lot of the themes", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01095-00271464-00271743": "that have come up in that 2014 movement", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01096-00271744-00271982": "directly informed other right-wing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01097-00271983-00272182": "themes and connected with groups like", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01098-00272183-00272415": "the so-called alt-right or the incel", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01099-00272416-00272567": "movement if you're not familiar the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01100-00272568-00272791": "people who think the men who think that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01101-00272792-00272991": "their inability to find a sexual partner", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01102-00272992-00273263": "is somehow involuntary and is caused by", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01103-00273264-00273463": "evil women who are all inferior to men", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01104-00273464-00273679": "so an absolutely misogynist group of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01105-00273680-00273958": "people um some even qualify them now as", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01106-00273959-00274143": "a terrorist movement uh because they're", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01107-00274144-00274327": "out to murder women", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01108-00274328-00274479": "and then there's the maga movement which", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01109-00274480-00274671": "has an interesting intersection with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01110-00274672-00274847": "some of these groups as well", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01111-00274848-00274991": "and all of that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01112-00274992-00275230": "provides a foundation of right-wing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01113-00275231-00275439": "discourses and practices", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01114-00275440-00275703": "and cultural themes that all provide the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01115-00275704-00275919": "feeding ground for what we've seen most", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01116-00275920-00276127": "recently and that is not to say that the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01117-00276128-00276279": "gamergate people are the same people who", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01118-00276280-00276479": "are here in this picture storming the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01119-00276480-00276679": "capital but just to say that they have", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01120-00276680-00276830": "provided much of the foundation that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01121-00276831-00277015": "then later in terms of discourses", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01122-00277016-00277247": "symbols uh practice and so on uh lived", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01123-00277248-00277439": "on in these other more egregious", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01124-00277440-00277630": "contexts or similarly egregious but now", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01125-00277631-00277855": "very very political context now let's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01126-00277856-00278055": "turn to the chinese case", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01127-00278056-00278334": "where fandom practices are uh in some", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01128-00278335-00278503": "cases even more extreme than what you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01129-00278504-00278751": "see in europe or america i mean fan", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01130-00278752-00278951": "groups are often", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01131-00278952-00279136": "very emotional and engaged and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01132-00279137-00279271": "[Music]", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01133-00279272-00279503": "often also very activists all around the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01134-00279504-00279743": "world but in china these dynamics often", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01135-00279744-00279958": "take on a whole new dimension and a good", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01136-00279959-00280175": "example is what happened in 2020 i don't", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01137-00280176-00280375": "know if you're familiar uh with uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01138-00280376-00280703": "xiaojian who's a famous uh actor soap", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01139-00280704-00280982": "opera actor really uh he was in a tv", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01140-00280983-00281127": "series called the untamed which had", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01141-00281128-00281391": "hormone erotic undertones", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01142-00281392-00281630": "and was a big hit and so a lot of his", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01143-00281631-00281927": "fans started writing gay fan fiction", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01144-00281928-00282182": "about him and about his character uh on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01145-00282183-00282327": "archive of our own which is a fan", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01146-00282328-00282599": "fiction uh website and another group of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01147-00282600-00282782": "his fans got so upset with this because", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01148-00282783-00282934": "they didn't want", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01149-00282935-00283199": "their icon to have this gay label that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01150-00283200-00283382": "they petitioned the government and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01151-00283383-00283558": "agitated against archive of our own", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01152-00283559-00283703": "until the ccp", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01153-00283704-00283903": "shut down access from within china to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01154-00283904-00283999": "this", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01155-00284000-00284206": "resource for cultural production and so", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01156-00284207-00284430": "the archive of our own folks were", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01157-00284431-00284703": "infuriated and there was a backlash", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01158-00284704-00284975": "calling for a boycott of the actor um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01159-00284976-00285119": "and of the boycott of all the brands he", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01160-00285120-00285310": "was associated with doing significant", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01161-00285311-00285519": "amount of damage and was really just a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01162-00285520-00285887": "toxic uh slugfest between these two", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01163-00285888-00286182": "groups of fans uh over who owned the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01164-00286183-00286391": "symbol of xiaojian and what it should", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01165-00286392-00286543": "mean and there's so much to unpack i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01166-00286544-00286767": "don't have enough time to unwrap at all", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01167-00286768-00286919": "in terms of the political economy in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01168-00286920-00287095": "china and how all of this", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01169-00287096-00287223": "works but what i wanted to draw", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01170-00287224-00287391": "attention to you here", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01171-00287392-00287487": "is how", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01172-00287488-00287630": "some of the practices that we see on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01173-00287631-00287839": "display here have been on display also", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01174-00287840-00288015": "much earlier and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01175-00288016-00288143": "all across", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01176-00288144-00288463": "cultural forums in china when fandoms", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01177-00288464-00288703": "emerge and how that can be connected to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01178-00288704-00288839": "politics and for example also to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01179-00288840-00289015": "nationalism so my question here", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01180-00289016-00289110": "i want to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01181-00289111-00289382": "discuss with you is how do digital media", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01182-00289383-00289599": "interact with tribalism in china and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01183-00289600-00289806": "with these kind of community sentiments", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01184-00289807-00289991": "and i myself as i said work a lot on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01185-00289992-00290151": "nationalism so you also see the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01186-00290152-00290319": "nationals and then spilling into the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01187-00290320-00290519": "streets for example when uh diaspora", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01188-00290520-00290687": "students in this case in london uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01189-00290688-00290982": "protest um this was uh on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01190-00290983-00291263": "hong kong and uh we've heard from", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01191-00291264-00291495": "professor among the the complexities of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01192-00291496-00291663": "how people try to come to grips with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01193-00291664-00291887": "their chineseness in often quite hostile", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01194-00291888-00292103": "environments but a lot of that is also", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01195-00292104-00292399": "underscored by activities online and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01196-00292400-00292743": "here's another example this is a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01197-00292744-00292982": "satire i suppose rather tasteless one", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01198-00292983-00293167": "that appeared in a danish broadsheet at", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01199-00293168-00293399": "the start of the pandemic which casts", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01200-00293400-00293743": "the prc's national flag as on these", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01201-00293744-00293903": "viral particles", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01202-00293904-00294087": "this did not go over well with a lot of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01203-00294088-00294191": "people", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01204-00294192-00294423": "especially of course people from the prc", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01205-00294424-00294495": "the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01206-00294496-00294623": "ambassador", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01207-00294624-00294839": "to denmark the chinese ambassador even", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01208-00294840-00294951": "wrote a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01209-00294952-00295263": "follow-up piece in which he was", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01210-00295264-00295527": "attacking essentially the danish people", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01211-00295528-00295727": "for having heard the chinese people's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01212-00295728-00295863": "feeling you have to always imagine the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01213-00295864-00296079": "scare quotes i'm putting in here uh so", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01214-00296080-00296223": "that's already quite interesting that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01215-00296224-00296430": "state active state officials would get", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01216-00296431-00296582": "involved and have opinions on this and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01217-00296583-00296743": "voice them but of course the cultural", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01218-00296744-00296934": "sphere was very quickly ablaze with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01219-00296935-00297206": "retaliation with chinese uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01220-00297207-00297447": "internet users creating memes and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01221-00297448-00297558": "mocking", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01222-00297559-00297791": "the danes and using the danish flag in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01223-00297792-00297910": "various", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01224-00297911-00298158": "more or less offensive ways to drive", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01225-00298159-00298351": "home that point but then there was a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01226-00298352-00298519": "backlash to the backlash as well", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01227-00298520-00298727": "especially among people from taiwan from", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01228-00298728-00298854": "hong kong", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01229-00298855-00299110": "people who are critical of the prc", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01230-00299111-00299287": "who picked up the original symbolism of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01231-00299288-00299454": "the flag and the viral particles and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01232-00299455-00299623": "then reproduced it in all sorts of other", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01233-00299624-00299775": "cultural products this is a video game", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01234-00299776-00299982": "that was very briefly available in april", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01235-00299983-00300263": "2020 on the steam platform a very simple", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01236-00300264-00300479": "game really but um yeah offensive racist", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01237-00300480-00300734": "really uh pretending or making you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01238-00300735-00300991": "pretend that you are murdering all the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01239-00300992-00301158": "evil chinese zombie folks who are trying", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01240-00301159-00301406": "to leave the prc to spread the virus on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01241-00301407-00301551": "i don't know why how it fits that you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01242-00301552-00301758": "are playing the virus but yes that's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01243-00301759-00301967": "that was the premise and it got pulled", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01244-00301968-00302167": "relatively quickly because it uh doesn't", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01245-00302168-00302406": "meet the the platform criteria but i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01246-00302407-00302534": "have also looked at the discussions", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01247-00302535-00302687": "around that game in the comment sections", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01248-00302688-00302847": "while it was still available", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01249-00302848-00303030": "and you very quickly see these", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01250-00303031-00303279": "entrenched groups uh forming each", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01251-00303280-00303463": "defending its own side not really having", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01252-00303464-00303671": "any conversation with each other and you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01253-00303672-00303863": "know what does that remind us of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01254-00303864-00304127": "so overall these kind of fan practices", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01255-00304128-00304310": "are important because they already", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01256-00304311-00304654": "establish a set of uh of strategies of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01257-00304655-00304879": "tactics of how to behave online how to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01258-00304880-00305079": "agitate and how to achieve things that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01259-00305080-00305295": "includes doxing people so identifying", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01260-00305296-00305447": "who is doing things online and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01261-00305448-00305615": "identifying where they are available in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01262-00305616-00305847": "the real world for retaliation bullying", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01263-00305848-00306063": "people cyber bullying informing on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01264-00306064-00306295": "people in sensitive context so that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01265-00306296-00306527": "their employees that their employers", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01266-00306528-00306743": "might punish them as employees", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01267-00306744-00306991": "or drowning out opposition or sometimes", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01268-00306992-00307206": "called the water army and we can talk a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01269-00307207-00307358": "little bit more also about the 50 cent", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01270-00307359-00307510": "army the more official", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01271-00307511-00307687": "people who are going online to defend", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01272-00307688-00307879": "the prc but there's a lot of voluntary", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01273-00307880-00308119": "defenders as well and they use a lot of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01274-00308120-00308279": "these strategies that people have", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01275-00308280-00308495": "developed in fandom communities now i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01276-00308496-00308775": "want to say a thing to you about really", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01277-00308776-00308958": "three factors that i think", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01278-00308959-00309182": "drive how these kind of dynamics can", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01279-00309183-00309454": "turn especially toxic how they congeal", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01280-00309455-00309623": "into communities and what that might", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01281-00309624-00309854": "mean not just in china but also for the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01282-00309855-00309967": "rest of us", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01283-00309968-00310175": "both in terms of how maybe people in the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01284-00310176-00310263": "us", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01285-00310264-00310382": "deal with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01286-00310383-00310567": "chinese online culture and interact with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01287-00310568-00310751": "it but also how we might deal with our", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01288-00310752-00310943": "own internet cultures in various", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01289-00310944-00311167": "different places so let me just uh so", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01290-00311168-00311399": "three three points one is technology one", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01291-00311400-00311543": "is political economy and one is the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01292-00311544-00311751": "state let me start with technology", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01293-00311752-00311903": "and just point out to you that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01294-00311904-00312103": "communities are pretty much always", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01295-00312104-00312327": "constructed right they're often imagined", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01296-00312328-00312510": "uh when we see and know people face to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01297-00312511-00312734": "face that has a very specific dynamic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01298-00312735-00312854": "but as soon as we're talking about", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01299-00312855-00313039": "people who you don't all know all", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01300-00313040-00313230": "communities are imagine whether it's you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01301-00313231-00313391": "know all the all the students at tufts", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01302-00313392-00313519": "university you don't know everyone right", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01303-00313520-00313734": "that's an imagined community but so are", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01304-00313735-00313999": "nations uh so our fan groups so they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01305-00314000-00314127": "already have something in common they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01306-00314128-00314263": "really exist because people are", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01307-00314264-00314439": "circulating symbols and engaging in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01308-00314440-00314582": "rituals with each other that are", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01309-00314583-00314806": "recognizable to others and that creates", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01310-00314807-00314999": "this uh illusion really in people's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01311-00315000-00315158": "minds that they all have something in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01312-00315159-00315351": "common and that illusion can become real", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01313-00315352-00315503": "because people are able to leverage it", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01314-00315504-00315703": "and mobilize around it in certain", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01315-00315704-00315903": "moments under certain conditions what's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01316-00315904-00316095": "important when people share", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01317-00316096-00316319": "these discourses these symbols is that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01318-00316320-00316527": "they're using media and so the medium", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01319-00316528-00316710": "matters as a delivery mechanism i'm", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01320-00316711-00316879": "always reminded of marshall mcluhan's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01321-00316880-00317151": "famous victim that the medium is message", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01322-00317152-00317391": "uh it matters that something happens uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01323-00317392-00317567": "in social media rather than just in the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01324-00317568-00317767": "newspaper or on television the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01325-00317768-00317887": "technology", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01326-00317888-00318110": "has its own affordances that it enables", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01327-00318111-00318334": "so um this is another famous historian", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01328-00318335-00318558": "of technology who said that technology", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01329-00318559-00318710": "is neither good nor bad so we should be", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01330-00318711-00318903": "careful with technological determinism", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01331-00318904-00319119": "but it's also not mutual right design", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01332-00319120-00319295": "matters we design things for certain", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01333-00319296-00319447": "purposes and the way something is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01334-00319448-00319630": "designed like facebook the fact that you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01335-00319631-00319910": "can have a angry button or sad button", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01336-00319911-00320087": "changes the dynamic of a conversation", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01337-00320088-00320254": "compared to if you only had like buttons", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01338-00320255-00320454": "for instance right and so that is true", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01339-00320455-00320679": "for technology all around and certainly", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01340-00320680-00320903": "also in the chinese context this is an", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01341-00320904-00321182": "example for me studying uh sino-japanese", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01342-00321183-00321358": "relations and how they played out", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01343-00321359-00321527": "especially in 2012 when there was a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01344-00321528-00321758": "major dispute between the two countries", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01345-00321759-00321934": "and i was looking at uh issues in the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01346-00321935-00322143": "east china sea as one of my cases the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01347-00322144-00322375": "diauria islands in china senkaku islands", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01348-00322376-00322615": "and japan and if you put diarrhoea", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01349-00322616-00322782": "islands into", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01350-00322783-00322975": "baidu which is the chinese search engine", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01351-00322976-00323175": "comparable in a way to google in terms", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01352-00323176-00323367": "of certainly it's market share it's very", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01353-00323368-00323487": "influential", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01354-00323488-00323663": "if you put uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01355-00323664-00323871": "dao into the search engine what comes up", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01356-00323872-00324103": "among other things is a widget that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01357-00324104-00324303": "shows you the weather on these rocks", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01358-00324304-00324487": "which doesn't make any sense because you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01359-00324488-00324647": "cannot go there it doesn't matter other", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01360-00324648-00324799": "than to maybe some fishermen what the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01361-00324800-00325015": "weather there might be like and even the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01362-00325016-00325247": "fishermen might have trouble uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01363-00325248-00325415": "going to those waters considering their", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01364-00325416-00325639": "controversial nature and yet you get the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01365-00325640-00325791": "impression here that it's just a place", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01366-00325792-00325975": "just like shanghai or beijing it goes", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01367-00325976-00326191": "even a little bit further by the actual", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01368-00326192-00326375": "website chinese weather whether", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01369-00326376-00326654": "logging this as the dyawi islands china", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01370-00326655-00326767": "if you speak chinese you can see here", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01371-00326768-00326951": "that the autocomplete automatically adds", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01372-00326952-00327087": "this as china", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01373-00327088-00327375": "and it even registers the yawi islands", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01374-00327376-00327654": "as a city district bizarrely", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01375-00327655-00327895": "in fujian province which makes very", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01376-00327896-00328078": "little sense uh but this tells you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01377-00328079-00328239": "already a little bit about how seemingly", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01378-00328240-00328495": "banal uh little choices which are", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01379-00328496-00328671": "informed by a combination of social", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01380-00328672-00328782": "interaction and technological", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01381-00328783-00328967": "interaction someone inputting something", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01382-00328968-00329191": "algorithms doing the rest creates an", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01383-00329192-00329406": "impression that people may not even", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01384-00329407-00329606": "notice is quite political", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01385-00329607-00329815": "here's another example a little bit", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01386-00329816-00330078": "older one from 2010 but you see comments", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01387-00330079-00330319": "like this on the internet of course on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01388-00330320-00330551": "all internets all the time", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01389-00330552-00330663": "this is a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01390-00330664-00330887": "hate comment by someone commenting on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01391-00330888-00330999": "the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01392-00331000-00331134": "news paper article on the nanjing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01393-00331135-00331239": "massacre", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01394-00331240-00331471": "and writing that you know anyone uh who", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01395-00331472-00331719": "kills a japanese person will receive a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01396-00331720-00331878": "thousand rmb you know once this person", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01397-00331879-00332054": "has some money and then just says kilco", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01398-00332055-00332134": "kill", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01399-00332135-00332263": "over and over so i'm not showing you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01400-00332264-00332463": "this to imply that everyone on china's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01401-00332464-00332639": "internet produces this kind of garbage", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01402-00332640-00332847": "that's not the case uh this might just", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01403-00332848-00333039": "be a quite exceptional comment in many", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01404-00333040-00333295": "ways but when these kind of discourses", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01405-00333296-00333575": "emerge they sometimes float to the top", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01406-00333576-00333823": "of algorithmically governed", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01407-00333824-00334023": "platforms as is the case here you can", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01408-00334024-00334223": "see on the top right a red stamp and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01409-00334224-00334406": "even if you don't read chinese you can", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01410-00334407-00334630": "see this must be important it means", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01411-00334631-00334887": "particularly popular response to that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01412-00334888-00335119": "article and that comes up because people", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01413-00335120-00335303": "have liked it and interacted with it", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01414-00335304-00335510": "shared it and commented on this comment", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01415-00335511-00335695": "enough for it to move to the front and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01416-00335696-00335878": "so you know of course these popularity", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01417-00335879-00336015": "mechanisms that you also see on other", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01418-00336016-00336247": "platforms like reddit and so on that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01419-00336248-00336447": "then also produce", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01420-00336448-00336591": "the impression that some things that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01421-00336592-00336743": "might not even be worth of much", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01422-00336744-00336854": "attention", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01423-00336855-00337030": "are actually representative and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01424-00337031-00337215": "important a final example here", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01425-00337216-00337343": "technologically", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01426-00337344-00337591": "is billy billy this is a video sharing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01427-00337592-00337910": "and streaming platform which has this", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01428-00337911-00338110": "special feature where you comment or can", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01429-00338111-00338327": "comment on the video in the video itself", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01430-00338328-00338471": "or sort of across the video which is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01431-00338472-00338623": "called the bullet commentary or bullet", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01432-00338624-00338710": "curtain", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01433-00338711-00339006": "and i did a study on bullet commentary", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01434-00339007-00339191": "on videos that dealt with covet at the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01435-00339192-00339343": "beginning of the pandemic during the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01436-00339344-00339527": "wuhan lockdown and one of the things", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01437-00339528-00339671": "that i found", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01438-00339672-00339854": "was that these comments often", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01439-00339855-00339991": "are almost like people just leaving the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01440-00339992-00340191": "note you know i've been here it's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01441-00340192-00340334": "asynchronous by the way so you leave a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01442-00340335-00340503": "comment and weeks later people will", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01443-00340504-00340727": "still see that comment together with all", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01444-00340728-00340903": "the other comments but they also then", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01445-00340904-00341247": "sort of start merging into a conform", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01446-00341248-00341503": "message where people start", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01447-00341504-00341663": "commenting in the same manner because", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01448-00341664-00341734": "they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01449-00341735-00341975": "presumably assume that this is expected", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01450-00341976-00342191": "this is the correct way to write about", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01451-00342192-00342351": "things so you can see in these videos", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01452-00342352-00342551": "that people frequently use phrases like", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01453-00342552-00342830": "uh go wuhan go china right jungkook yaya", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01454-00342831-00343103": "or wuhanjay obviously that's a classic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01455-00343104-00343254": "comment at that time", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01456-00343255-00343543": "and similar uh phrases recurring phrases", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01457-00343544-00343727": "that mark them both as", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01458-00343728-00343975": "all being part of a similar", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01459-00343976-00344247": "community with a repertoire of signs and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01460-00344248-00344543": "language but also that signal to others", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01461-00344544-00344687": "you know i know what i'm supposed to be", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01462-00344688-00344903": "doing i'm getting active here uh even", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01463-00344904-00345110": "though it's probably mostly clicktivism", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01464-00345111-00345295": "as it's sometimes called but i'm", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01465-00345296-00345558": "interacting with these materials in the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01466-00345559-00345734": "appropriate manner whereas other people", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01467-00345735-00345982": "who might have criticism or", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01468-00345983-00346127": "have more nuanced", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01469-00346128-00346343": "views don't find necessarily the space", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01470-00346344-00346567": "in this forum on this format to voice", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01471-00346568-00346767": "them or they stay silent because they're", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01472-00346768-00346951": "worried about not", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01473-00346952-00347143": "offending the the mainstream in these", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01474-00347144-00347351": "instances so i've called that viral", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01475-00347352-00347606": "villages i refer to networks of social", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01476-00347607-00347791": "technical engagement that generate", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01477-00347792-00348015": "recursive feedback loops in which these", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01478-00348016-00348143": "various kinds of people share their", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01479-00348144-00348310": "community sentiment and it becomes", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01480-00348311-00348495": "amplified and amplified through these", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01481-00348496-00348806": "algorithmic mechanisms and i use the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01482-00348807-00348999": "word village viral village because i'm", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01483-00349000-00349206": "again i like marshall mcluhan on what he", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01484-00349207-00349439": "wrote about villages uh he used the term", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01485-00349440-00349606": "global village and coined it but he", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01486-00349607-00349758": "didn't mean what people often mean which", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01487-00349759-00349951": "is of the cosmopolitan wonderful world", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01488-00349952-00350199": "were all closer together he meant this", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01489-00350200-00350358": "when people get close together they get", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01490-00350359-00350599": "more and more savage impatient with each", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01491-00350600-00350815": "other village people aren't that much in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01492-00350816-00351006": "love with each other and the global", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01493-00351007-00351182": "village is a place of very arduous", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01494-00351183-00351439": "interfaces and very abrasive situations", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01495-00351440-00351551": "and so you can probably see why i have", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01496-00351552-00351791": "this quote here this is from 1977 and i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01497-00351792-00351934": "think marshall mcluhan would have", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01498-00351935-00352103": "recognized many of what we're much of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01499-00352104-00352319": "what we're going through in that context", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01500-00352320-00352447": "now i'm pretty much out of time but i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01501-00352448-00352591": "just wanted to point out beyond the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01502-00352592-00352815": "technological level uh the state level", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01503-00352816-00353039": "the way that uh nationalism and techno", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01504-00353040-00353206": "nationalism on this chinese state side", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01505-00353207-00353399": "and the communist party side is creating", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01506-00353400-00353663": "a context in which national discourses", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01507-00353664-00353806": "and that kind of tribalism that they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01508-00353807-00353895": "breed", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01509-00353896-00354182": "are a logical response to politics and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01510-00354183-00354367": "to international affairs even though the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01511-00354368-00354510": "communist party has a very specific", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01512-00354511-00354678": "understanding of what it thinks", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01513-00354679-00354895": "patriotism means compared to what people", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01514-00354896-00355071": "in china mean and then also many many", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01515-00355072-00355319": "different nationalisms in china emerge", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01516-00355320-00355527": "but there is already a infrastructure", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01517-00355528-00355678": "that pushes a particular kind of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01518-00355679-00355967": "national and nationalist narrative and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01519-00355968-00356143": "perspective in china", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01520-00356144-00356303": "and then there is the commodification", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01521-00356304-00356471": "the political economy", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01522-00356472-00356751": "that the digital capitalism really that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01523-00356752-00356951": "fuels these various platforms just one", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01524-00356952-00357206": "image a trigger warning this is uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01525-00357207-00357519": "pornography and some violence as well uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01526-00357520-00357775": "these are images from a supposedly a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01527-00357776-00358047": "military history picture archive uh but", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01528-00358048-00358391": "it's mostly porn snuff film um really", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01529-00358392-00358719": "nasty stuff in many ways which sits", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01530-00358720-00358910": "alongside political commentary and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01531-00358911-00359199": "discussion of sino-japanese relations", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01532-00359200-00359343": "and that is because the people who run a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01533-00359344-00359534": "platform like this notice that people", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01534-00359535-00359743": "click this stuff and so that's what", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01535-00359744-00359919": "gives them money what makes the money", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01536-00359920-00360215": "and the algorithm feeds back into it uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01537-00360216-00360367": "signaling to the makers that this is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01538-00360368-00360495": "something that is lucrative and so they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01539-00360496-00360743": "produce more and more racy content and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01540-00360744-00360887": "it kind of spirals out of control", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01541-00360888-00361023": "regardless of what the people who make", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01542-00361024-00361206": "the content might think about it or what", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01543-00361207-00361382": "even the viewers and people click on it", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01544-00361383-00361558": "think about it we don't really know but", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01545-00361559-00361782": "it creates a context in which discourse", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01546-00361783-00361975": "becomes more and more toxic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01547-00361976-00362158": "so let me just conclude very briefly", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01548-00362159-00362343": "here by uh telling you why any of this", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01549-00362344-00362495": "matters matters because these guys think", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01550-00362496-00362767": "it matters right so legitimacy concerns", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01551-00362768-00362910": "are at the top of what the chinese", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01552-00362911-00363078": "communist party has to worry about", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01553-00363079-00363327": "domestically to assure social stability", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01554-00363328-00363527": "um the uh party", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01555-00363528-00363815": "monitors uh big data social media data", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01556-00363816-00364015": "bizarrely it has sort of a dual track", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01557-00364016-00364182": "goal on the one hand it's trying to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01558-00364183-00364351": "guide public opinion on social media at", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01559-00364352-00364503": "the same time it is trying to measure", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01560-00364504-00364782": "public opinion on uh weibo for instance", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01561-00364783-00364999": "in order to inform politics uh create", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01562-00365000-00365175": "five-year plans that are responsive to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01563-00365176-00365382": "the audience and so on uh but that means", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01564-00365383-00365519": "that they're basically measuring", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01565-00365520-00365695": "something of their own creation and that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01566-00365696-00365854": "also means that some of the problems", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01567-00365855-00366039": "i've just outlined now might feed back", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01568-00366040-00366263": "into policy making choices by convincing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01569-00366264-00366471": "politicians that the nationalists might", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01570-00366472-00366615": "be more influential than they actually", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01571-00366616-00366799": "are in making choices that are more", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01572-00366800-00367063": "radically say anti-western anti-american", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01573-00367064-00367263": "anti-anything else really and more", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01574-00367264-00367510": "domestically oriented uh then might be", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01575-00367511-00367678": "uh good from a more cosmopolitan", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01576-00367679-00367791": "perspective", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01577-00367792-00367999": "and so in the end we have a construction", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01578-00368000-00368254": "of a sense of homeland as an existential", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01579-00368255-00368415": "problem whether it's during political", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01580-00368416-00368663": "crises whether it's during pandemics", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01581-00368664-00368815": "that combine the human psychology of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01582-00368816-00369023": "what people do online with technological", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01583-00369024-00369230": "design uh the state's position and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01584-00369231-00369519": "commercial rationales and that uh then", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01585-00369520-00369727": "gets feet fed back through various other", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01586-00369728-00369847": "groups as they challenge these", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01587-00369848-00370039": "narratives and create more conflict i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01588-00370040-00370199": "could say more about the milk tea", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01589-00370200-00370391": "alliance if we have time in the in the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01590-00370392-00370623": "section uh or in the q a in a moment but", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01591-00370624-00370871": "essentially what emerges here is um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01592-00370872-00371006": "nationalism or various forms of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01593-00371007-00371254": "nationalism that are despite or attempts", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01594-00371255-00371471": "uh to the contrary not under anyone's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01595-00371472-00371678": "control also not the ccps so i'm going", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01596-00371679-00371910": "to conclude here looking forward to your", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01597-00371911-00372134": "questions and comments uh and yeah thank", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01598-00372135-00372606": "you for your attention", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01599-00372607-00372839": "thank you so much professor schneider", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01600-00372840-00373158": "that was really amazing um so now we'll", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01601-00373159-00373295": "open up the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01602-00373296-00373534": "floor to anybody in the audience who", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01603-00373535-00373758": "wants to ask a specific question", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01604-00373759-00373975": "um or if the panelists themselves would", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01605-00373976-00374095": "like to address each other's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01606-00374096-00374254": "presentations anything they find", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01607-00374255-00374599": "interesting we can also do that um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01608-00374600-00374815": "so yeah", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01609-00374816-00375806": "leave any and all questions in the chat", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01610-00375807-00375958": "people are a little bit scared to ask a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01611-00375959-00376182": "question i do have one for professor", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01612-00376183-00376375": "hmong in a moment but uh well maybe", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01613-00376376-00376639": "we'll give our participants a chance", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01614-00376640-00376895": "first right", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01615-00376896-00377182": "um i'll give a general question to start", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01616-00377183-00377399": "um professor schneider and hmong feel", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01617-00377400-00377510": "free to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01618-00377511-00377847": "answer as you see fit um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01619-00377848-00378006": "china is is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01620-00378007-00378215": "very actively digitizing many aspects of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01621-00378216-00378382": "everyday life arguably at a greater pace", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01622-00378383-00378606": "than the united states um what kind of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01623-00378607-00378934": "social consequences does this um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01624-00378935-00379127": "rapid development in technology and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01625-00379128-00379399": "government-sponsored", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01626-00379400-00379623": "acceleration of these things", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01627-00379624-00379775": "what sort of consequences and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01628-00379776-00379951": "implications does that have on the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01629-00379952-00380247": "public and the government's relation to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01630-00380248-00380854": "the public as well", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01631-00380855-00381134": "being sure you want to get get started", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01632-00381135-00381367": "sure um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01633-00381368-00381478": "well", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01634-00381479-00381758": "i i guess um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01635-00381759-00382087": "i'll mention maybe two aspects um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01636-00382088-00382282": "one is that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01637-00382283-00382615": "um they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01638-00382616-00382910": "i think this kind of very", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01639-00382911-00383191": "aggressive rolling out of digital", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01640-00383192-00383495": "technology and digital infrastructure", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01641-00383496-00383815": "is part and parcel of this state-led", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01642-00383816-00384102": "development developmentalism", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01643-00384103-00384254": "mentality", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01644-00384255-00384487": "and i think it also", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01645-00384488-00384758": "helps to reinforce that mentality and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01646-00384759-00384975": "and i see that also in some of my", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01647-00384976-00385334": "interviews for that for that study", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01648-00385335-00385639": "and it certainly also helps to because", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01649-00385640-00385863": "it's all part of that discourse", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01650-00385864-00386087": "it helps reinforcing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01651-00386088-00386391": "the legitimacy in the sense that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01652-00386392-00386663": "the legitimacy comes from development", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01653-00386664-00387006": "come from technological superiority", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01654-00387007-00387278": "and what we see is that increasingly now", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01655-00387279-00387558": "when chinese people traveling overseas", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01656-00387559-00387839": "they would initially be startled at the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01657-00387840-00388071": "backwardness of digital infrastructure i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01658-00388072-00388271": "think especially in europe", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01659-00388272-00388551": "i think in the uk for example", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01660-00388552-00388663": "um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01661-00388664-00388906": "so that firstly is part of this", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01662-00388907-00389230": "developmentalism mentality that that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01663-00389231-00389487": "adds to the the legitimacy", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01664-00389488-00389734": "um and it gives the sense of pride and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01665-00389735-00390030": "superiority but on the on the other on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01666-00390031-00390430": "the social side um what i see as a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01667-00390431-00390591": "very sort of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01668-00390592-00390910": "under discussed um negative consequence", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01669-00390911-00391134": "of this is the kind of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01670-00391135-00391423": "exclusion this creates", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01671-00391424-00391751": "and we see this very clearly during the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01672-00391752-00392102": "pandemic when the the qr code the qr", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01673-00392103-00392367": "health code was rolling out", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01674-00392368-00392647": "for the old folks who don't really know", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01675-00392648-00392863": "how to use smartphone or who don't want", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01676-00392864-00393095": "to use smartphone especially when they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01677-00393096-00393167": "are", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01678-00393168-00393358": "you know going out", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01679-00393359-00393534": "it becomes a real", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01680-00393535-00393647": "issue", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01681-00393648-00393815": "so as you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01682-00393816-00394095": "roll out this and and as you lay this", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01683-00394096-00394327": "out as the daily informational", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01684-00394328-00394478": "infrastructure", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01685-00394479-00394839": "you are also basically setting up the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01686-00394840-00395127": "the digital barriers and barriers that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01687-00395128-00395247": "make it", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01688-00395248-00395415": "um difficult", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01689-00395416-00395663": "for the underprivileged for the more", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01690-00395664-00395975": "marginalized group to enjoy the full", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01691-00395976-00396199": "service um and this is of course you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01692-00396200-00396510": "know it's not something new we've been", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01693-00396511-00396695": "talking about digital divide", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01694-00396696-00396910": "but in china i think this become", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01695-00396911-00397223": "particularly acute because", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01696-00397224-00397487": "you know now your everyday life relies", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01697-00397488-00397719": "on how much of your everyday activities", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01698-00397720-00397927": "are is now you know being conducted on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01699-00397928-00398175": "wechat it's it's being taken for granted", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01700-00398176-00398391": "but it's being taken for granted who", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01701-00398392-00398615": "have the resource and the capacity to do", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01702-00398616-00398871": "that but not for everyone so and and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01703-00398872-00399143": "then when at the moment like the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01704-00399144-00399382": "pandemic you do see the negative um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01705-00399383-00399534": "exclusive you know the negative", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01706-00399535-00399767": "consequences of this", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01707-00399768-00399982": "yeah i can only second that um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01708-00399983-00400230": "my my acquired note on what my colleague", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01709-00400231-00400343": "here around the corner dutrett", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01710-00400344-00400575": "university england hoff calls speed", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01711-00400576-00400806": "leads so only very specific groups of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01712-00400807-00401030": "people are actually in the position to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01713-00401031-00401199": "make the most use of digital technology", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01714-00401200-00401382": "and that's certainly the case in this at", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01715-00401383-00401582": "this rapid pace in china", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01716-00401583-00401758": "so you have urban audiences who are very", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01717-00401759-00401919": "good at this not everyone of course in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01718-00401920-00402087": "urban centers but it's a very different", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01719-00402088-00402527": "story in rural areas um and also the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01720-00402528-00402671": "the rollout of digital technology", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01721-00402672-00402895": "interacts with uh capitalist ambitions", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01722-00402896-00403087": "in a very interesting and often very", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01723-00403088-00403239": "worrying way", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01724-00403240-00403478": "pushing people uh to follow a highly", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01725-00403479-00403599": "individualist life i find it quite", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01726-00403600-00403719": "interesting how chinese students in the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01727-00403720-00403871": "uk are commenting on individualism in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01728-00403872-00404087": "the uk they're not wrong uh but there's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01729-00404088-00404247": "so much individualism in china as well", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01730-00404248-00404391": "when it comes to elbows out and i have", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01731-00404392-00404678": "to be on top um to the point where um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01732-00404679-00404863": "you see the the streamer culture video", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01733-00404864-00405023": "streaming people trying to make money of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01734-00405024-00405278": "that uh only the the smallest amount of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01735-00405279-00405439": "people can ever live off that and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01736-00405440-00405615": "there's a long tale of people", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01737-00405616-00405775": "uh my colleague jungkook has written on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01738-00405776-00405934": "this who are just in front of their", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01739-00405935-00406127": "camera streaming their entire lives from", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01740-00406128-00406327": "morning to evening and have zero views", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01741-00406328-00406558": "or one view right uh and they're hoping", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01742-00406559-00406767": "to at some point maybe make a buck of it", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01743-00406768-00406999": "uh it's it's incredibly depressing so", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01744-00407000-00407143": "you have an entire", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01745-00407144-00407343": "large group of society that is switched", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01746-00407344-00407447": "off and that's going to be a serious", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01747-00407448-00407534": "problem", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01748-00407535-00407775": "and you have dynamics uh in which it's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01749-00407776-00408078": "easy to make a big a quick buck uh by", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01750-00408079-00408367": "exploiting people and by scamming them", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01751-00408368-00408471": "and so that's something that a lot of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01752-00408472-00408678": "people outside of china don't always see", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01753-00408679-00408815": "and i don't want to defend the communist", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01754-00408816-00409023": "party's online regulation i have a lot", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01755-00409024-00409302": "of problems with it but a lot of it is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01756-00409303-00409534": "not informed just by the attempt to keep", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01757-00409535-00409774": "political oppositions quiet or shut down", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01758-00409775-00409959": "the activists and so on it's often a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01759-00409960-00410143": "direct response by grant from for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01760-00410143-00410278": "grassroots", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01761-00410279-00410455": "initiatives and grassroots pushes from", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01762-00410456-00410726": "the public to say you know i as an urban", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01763-00410727-00410903": "middle class person and not safe", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01764-00410904-00411159": "shopping online i get scammed you have", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01765-00411160-00411295": "to do something right or here's all", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01766-00411296-00411470": "these celebrities", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01767-00411471-00411630": "and these celebrities are cashing in in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01768-00411631-00411863": "weird ways or spreading body shaming", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01769-00411864-00412095": "images and do something about it that is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01770-00412096-00412255": "these are concerns also the sort of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01771-00412256-00412447": "misinformation fake news concerns that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01772-00412447-00412678": "we all recognize uh across the globe and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01773-00412679-00412855": "that the communist party is also acting", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01774-00412856-00413047": "on it just so happens that it then also", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01775-00413047-00413191": "happens to be one of the biggest spread", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01776-00413192-00413407": "of disinformation on the planet on top", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01777-00413408-00413534": "of everything else right but there's so", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01778-00413535-00413703": "this is a very complicated dynamic and i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01779-00413704-00413799": "think it reveals some of the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01780-00413800-00414014": "contradictions that you see emerging in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01781-00414015-00414391": "digital capitalism", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01782-00414392-00414543": "great thank you so much for those", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01783-00414543-00414782": "insights um we have a couple questions", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01784-00414783-00415030": "in the chat so the first one comes from", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01785-00415031-00415318": "michelle lynn and she says a question", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01786-00415319-00415399": "for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01787-00415400-00415639": "dr schneider would you say china's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01788-00415639-00415870": "internet controls or interests are", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01789-00415871-00416126": "threatening the liberal world order", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01790-00416127-00416343": "ah that's a big question", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01791-00416343-00416463": "um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01792-00416464-00416687": "i don't know uh i have my problems with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01793-00416688-00416999": "the threat stories um i like professor", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01794-00417000-00417247": "mong's comments on ulrich beck and on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01795-00417247-00417495": "risk i think that's a much better way to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01796-00417496-00417607": "understand", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01797-00417608-00417799": "how our world works and there are actors", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01798-00417800-00417943": "in our world that create risks for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01799-00417943-00418055": "others", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01800-00418056-00418239": "it's certainly the case that we see the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01801-00418239-00418463": "communist party rolling out a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01802-00418464-00418678": "campaign to influence public opinion", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01803-00418679-00418878": "abroad and to become active for its own", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01804-00418879-00419007": "gains", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01805-00419008-00419151": "actually i think in many cases that's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01806-00419152-00419334": "not that different from what other", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01807-00419335-00419543": "countries do necessarily", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01808-00419543-00419759": "but it is often illegal so i can see how", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01809-00419760-00419935": "liberals would be worried and we see for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01810-00419935-00420031": "example", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01811-00420032-00420366": "this is documented uh chinese uh often", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01812-00420367-00420470": "official", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01813-00420471-00420679": "actors intervening in taiwan for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01814-00420680-00420807": "instance in order to undermine", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01815-00420808-00421022": "democratic processes there or doing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01816-00421023-00421175": "similar things in hong kong also to shut", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01817-00421176-00421303": "down discussion", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01818-00421304-00421503": "so there is a concern but i'm also", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01819-00421504-00421679": "concerned about that narrative about", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01820-00421680-00421999": "threat which is so old and so tried uh i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01821-00422000-00422143": "think it creates a self-fulfilling", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01822-00422143-00422318": "prophecy in which a lot of chinese", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01823-00422319-00422631": "actors feel the need uh to step up the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01824-00422632-00422903": "more aggressive uh hawkish aspects of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01825-00422904-00423183": "their policies in response to what they", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01826-00423184-00423559": "see as a antagonistic quote-unquote west", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01827-00423560-00423727": "because china is not monolithic it's not", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01828-00423728-00423895": "just one actor it's many many different", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01829-00423896-00424063": "ministries and organizations that all", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01830-00424064-00424214": "have different interests", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01831-00424215-00424343": "and it's i think a question also for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01832-00424343-00424543": "people in europe or america who are we", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01833-00424543-00424839": "empowering with our own responses who is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01834-00424839-00425110": "served by a trade war for instance or by", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01835-00425112-00425270": "uh shutting down certain technology", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01836-00425271-00425510": "companies uh abroad and so on uh and i'm", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01837-00425512-00425687": "a bit worried that it steps on the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01838-00425688-00425903": "agenda of more liberal-minded potential", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01839-00425904-00426063": "allies in china", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01840-00426064-00426239": "and empowers the people who are maybe", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01841-00426239-00426479": "closer to the pla or the domestic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01842-00426480-00426614": "ministries that mainly care about", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01843-00426615-00426887": "domestic status development rather than", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01844-00426888-00427031": "say for ministry people who are much", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01845-00427032-00427159": "more liberal", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01846-00427160-00427383": "so i i hesitate", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01847-00427384-00427551": "as a good academic i would question the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01848-00427552-00427783": "question in that sense now to step on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01849-00427784-00427999": "michelle's uh indie very very good", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01850-00428000-00428191": "question uh but just as a little bit of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01851-00428192-00428359": "a warning on how we frame these kind of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01852-00428360-00429166": "issues i hope that answers your question", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01853-00429167-00429399": "um okay so we have um just one more", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01854-00429400-00429591": "question um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01855-00429592-00429695": "this is", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01856-00429696-00429903": "from oh we can do that two two more if", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01857-00429904-00430143": "we have time if you just want to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01858-00430143-00430318": "quickly touch on these um one is from", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01859-00430319-00430470": "artem", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01860-00430471-00430631": "how has chinese state media and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01861-00430632-00430799": "censorship responded to the public's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01862-00430800-00430999": "interest in russian in the russian", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01863-00431000-00431351": "invasion in ukraine", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01864-00431352-00431551": "england you want to start us", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01865-00431552-00431679": "um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01866-00431680-00431831": "yeah that's that's an interesting", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01867-00431832-00431983": "question i i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01868-00431984-00432191": "i don't think i've", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01869-00432192-00432535": "witnessed a lot of examples of censoring", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01870-00432535-00432783": "in this particular case because if you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01871-00432784-00432991": "think about the timing of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01872-00432992-00433343": "the russian invasion of ukraine", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01873-00433343-00433687": "that coincided with the covet situation", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01874-00433688-00433822": "getting", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01875-00433823-00434063": "out of control in shanghai", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01876-00434064-00434295": "so i think it's fairly easy for you to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01877-00434296-00434527": "draw the conclusion which one gets much", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01878-00434528-00434687": "more attention from", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01879-00434688-00434918": "the sensor which is that it is deemed as", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01880-00434919-00435047": "you know", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01881-00435047-00435135": "um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01882-00435135-00435383": "much closer management and and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01883-00435384-00435510": "monitoring", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01884-00435512-00435655": "um so i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01885-00435656-00435918": "you know at least i haven't really but", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01886-00435919-00436295": "um witnesses um the the the the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01887-00436296-00436422": "censoring", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01888-00436423-00436743": "of this case but i would also make two", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01889-00436743-00437087": "observations one is that in terms of the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01890-00437088-00437279": "state media it has", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01891-00437280-00437495": "been sticking to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01892-00437496-00437703": "the official you know foreign ministry", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01893-00437704-00437959": "sort of a spokesperson official lying", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01894-00437960-00438110": "saying that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01895-00438112-00438391": "we are against any war um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01896-00438392-00438751": "any invasion um we don't think um any", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01897-00438752-00438951": "for any country in just for the sake of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01898-00438952-00439183": "securing their border they could wage a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01899-00439184-00439263": "war", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01900-00439264-00439583": "and we stick to the you know we we are", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01901-00439584-00439759": "we have concern", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01902-00439760-00440055": "with people in ukraine and and but of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01903-00440056-00440279": "course you know as everyone know", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01904-00440280-00440479": "what happened during the week before the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01905-00440480-00440703": "winter olympics sort of this special", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01906-00440704-00440935": "sort of alliance being declared", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01907-00440935-00441231": "um so so i think the official media has", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01908-00441232-00441327": "been", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01909-00441328-00441855": "walking a very tight line here trying to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01910-00441856-00442151": "not offend both either ukraine or russia", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01911-00442152-00442535": "both are important partners to to china", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01912-00442535-00442751": "but on the other hand i think", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01913-00442752-00443007": "interestingly on social media though", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01914-00443008-00443375": "the range of views is quite", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01915-00443376-00443783": "diverse that we see people saying that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01916-00443784-00443879": "you know", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01917-00443880-00444095": "calling for the separation cheer good", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01918-00444096-00444391": "you know we need to we need to get clear", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01919-00444392-00444679": "with russia we shouldn't maintain this", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01920-00444680-00444879": "special um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01921-00444880-00445087": "relationship and that was by a quite a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01922-00445088-00445295": "high profile academic international", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01923-00445296-00445527": "nation but then on the other hand of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01924-00445528-00445775": "course there are people saying that", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01925-00445776-00446159": "um this war the the the it's because of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01926-00446160-00446383": "the expansion of nato it's because of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01927-00446384-00446631": "the u.s so russia was only responding to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01928-00446632-00446847": "that and and there was also a lot of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01929-00446847-00447127": "support and and there's also of course", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01930-00447128-00447287": "as you can imagine", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01931-00447288-00447535": "the energy between the situation in in", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01932-00447535-00447759": "taiwan so i would say generally you know", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01933-00447760-00447951": "the official media has been", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01934-00447952-00448039": "sort of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01935-00448039-00448359": "controlling the narrative quite um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01936-00448360-00448727": "carefully but there's a diverse um view", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01937-00448728-00448975": "on social media", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01938-00448976-00449118": "yeah i mean if you're interested in this", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01939-00449119-00449207": "um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01940-00449208-00449366": "i don't think it's published yet but uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01941-00449367-00449551": "our colleague jennifer punn at stanford", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01942-00449552-00449766": "university is uh doing research on this", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01943-00449767-00449935": "with a team of people and she's been", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01944-00449935-00450127": "tweeting about it so i can only repeat", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01945-00450128-00450255": "what she said which is that there's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01946-00450256-00450463": "about about fifty percent of the way", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01947-00450464-00450622": "board tweets that they've been analyzing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01948-00450623-00450839": "are pro-russian and produces kind of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01949-00450839-00450991": "misinformation that we're familiar with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01950-00450992-00451239": "also from russian television from rt", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01951-00451239-00451391": "but the rest of the commentators fall", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01952-00451392-00451543": "somewhere along all sorts of diverse", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01953-00451543-00451710": "spectrums uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01954-00451712-00451943": "including liberals and critics and so on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01955-00451943-00452151": "um so it is indeed", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01956-00452152-00452295": "quite complicated also on the chinese", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01957-00452296-00452510": "internet i am a little bit worried about", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01958-00452512-00452727": "how much disinformation is circulating", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01959-00452728-00452943": "though uh but that is not just the case", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01960-00452943-00453087": "in china you also see this in europe i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01961-00453088-00453327": "think 40 percent of people in greece uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01962-00453328-00453503": "are supporters of putin", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01963-00453504-00453679": "i mean that is that shocking in the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01964-00453680-00453847": "netherlands is 15 i find that shocking", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01965-00453847-00454079": "already but 40 so we don't have to point", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01966-00454080-00454263": "to russia to say you know added to china", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01967-00454264-00454414": "say 50", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01968-00454415-00454535": "yeah it's not that different than other", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01969-00454535-00454999": "places sometimes right", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01970-00455000-00455095": "thank you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01971-00455096-00455247": "oh yeah go ahead", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01972-00455247-00455399": "um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01973-00455400-00455631": "uh if professor mung and professor", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01974-00455632-00455799": "schneider have time for one more", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01975-00455800-00455935": "question um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01976-00455935-00456151": "there is one from", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01977-00456152-00456422": "dr straffella who co-authored", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01978-00456423-00456814": "the speech that daria berg gave today um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01979-00456815-00457031": "i know that we're over time it's about 2", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01980-00457032-00457351": "50 p.m uh here in boston um would you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01981-00457352-00457503": "like to stay behind for one more", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01982-00457504-00457622": "question", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01983-00457623-00457775": "i'm happy to stay a moment yeah actually", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01984-00457776-00457903": "no way", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01985-00457904-00458110": "wonderful", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01986-00458112-00458343": "so the question goes when researching", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01987-00458343-00458607": "online culture in china or elsewhere how", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01988-00458608-00458751": "do we deal with comments like the one", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01989-00458752-00458927": "you mentioned which", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01990-00458928-00459127": "is highlighted by the algorithm but not", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01991-00459128-00459383": "otherwise representative in our analysis", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01992-00459384-00459543": "of the culture as a whole", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01993-00459543-00459759": "this is for dr schneider", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01994-00459760-00459943": "um i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01995-00459943-00460127": "like goffman the sociologist", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01996-00460128-00460343": "anthropologist right uh and the idea of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01997-00460343-00460518": "the front stage and the backstage i find", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01998-00460519-00460695": "it very important to distinguish these", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-01999-00460696-00460951": "two things there's a public-facing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02000-00460952-00461118": "communication element that we can", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02001-00461119-00461303": "analyze but we're really just analyzing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02002-00461304-00461566": "discourses we're analyzing the resources", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02003-00461567-00461718": "the statements the symbols that are", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02004-00461719-00461959": "available to people and that they reuse", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02005-00461960-00462118": "in visible ways we're observing", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02006-00462119-00462255": "something people do", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02007-00462256-00462414": "we're never observing what people think", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02008-00462415-00462607": "we don't have no idea what people think", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02009-00462608-00462759": "um and we're also not observing what", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02010-00462760-00462918": "people do in their private home you know", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02011-00462919-00463055": "what do they take home", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02012-00463056-00463166": "uh from these comments we don't know", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02013-00463167-00463359": "who's behind this comment maybe they ate", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02014-00463360-00463503": "something bad and posted it then you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02015-00463504-00463599": "know we don't know what the people", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02016-00463600-00463735": "thought who were liking it or", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02017-00463735-00464063": "interacting with it uh so i always make", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02018-00464064-00464310": "sure to have additional caveats in place", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02019-00464312-00464551": "uh to ensure that we're not um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02020-00464552-00464727": "insinuating that we're actually studying", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02021-00464728-00464951": "public opinion like real public opinion", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02022-00464952-00465127": "uh sadly i'm not so sure the chinese", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02023-00465128-00465270": "government is always doing that because", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02024-00465271-00465391": "i think there's people there who do", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02025-00465392-00465591": "think they're studying public opinion by", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02026-00465592-00465822": "looking at big data which is never the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02027-00465823-00466087": "whole story uh so in that sense it's i", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02028-00466088-00466375": "think it's important because of the way", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02029-00466376-00466470": "these", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02030-00466471-00466759": "non-representative but very visible", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02031-00466760-00466975": "shouts and screams that we see online", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02032-00466976-00467070": "affect", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02033-00467071-00467318": "the discussion how they can push", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02034-00467319-00467487": "political decisions", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02035-00467488-00467718": "we see this in cases with a xiaojian", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02036-00467719-00467966": "example there were other cases with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02037-00467967-00468183": "a taiwanese pop star", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02038-00468184-00468351": "where it was basically became an", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02039-00468352-00468543": "international realm because she had a", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02040-00468543-00468751": "taiwanese flag and a little video", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02041-00468752-00468959": "and she got criticized extensively and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02042-00468960-00469207": "so you see these online debates and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02043-00469208-00469470": "suddenly the the polls for um saying", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02044-00469471-00469687": "when in taiwan go up by a couple of", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02045-00469688-00469863": "points because taiwanese people are so", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02046-00469864-00470031": "angry that this pop star is forced to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02047-00470032-00470270": "make an apology so words have have", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02048-00470271-00470487": "consequences right even if we don't know", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02049-00470488-00470695": "who um who's making them but we should", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02050-00470696-00470814": "be careful about what happens on the", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02051-00470815-00470935": "backstage", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02052-00470935-00471175": "um i'm always reminded of some very good", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02053-00471176-00471407": "scholarship on the soviet union um right", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02054-00471408-00471622": "before it fell all the russian experts", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02055-00471623-00471847": "the vast majority of russian experts had", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02056-00471847-00472039": "no idea uh that russians were", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02057-00472039-00472214": "dissatisfied or at the degree to which", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02058-00472215-00472447": "they were dissatisfied they thought uh", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02059-00472447-00472614": "that the story everyone was telling on", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02060-00472615-00472863": "the front end was the real story and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02061-00472864-00473087": "that's a mistake because uh that may not", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02062-00473088-00473318": "be the case right so uh careful with", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02063-00473319-00473566": "buying the propaganda or the hegemonic", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02064-00473567-00473759": "discourse it might just be there because", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02065-00473760-00473927": "it circulates the best not because", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02066-00473928-00474422": "people actually buy it", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02067-00474423-00474583": "um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02068-00474584-00475007": "great so i think that concludes our", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02069-00475008-00475303": "culture panel um a special thanks to dr", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02070-00475304-00475575": "schneider dr mong and of course uh dr", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02071-00475576-00475766": "burke who was unable to be here synchro", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02072-00475767-00475966": "synchronously today and of course dr", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02073-00475967-00476135": "straffelo who um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02074-00476135-00476383": "co-wrote her speech", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02075-00476384-00476591": "we're so appreciative of your", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02076-00476592-00476783": "contributions thank you so much for", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02077-00476784-00477063": "making this a wonderful experience", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02078-00477064-00477231": "if anybody in the audience has any more", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02079-00477232-00477383": "questions", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02080-00477384-00477510": "i'm sure", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02081-00477512-00477679": "all of our speakers would be happy to", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02082-00477680-00477879": "talk to you through email and such and", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02083-00477880-00478118": "we can provide you with those after", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02084-00478119-00478431": "in an email but uh yeah i think that's", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02085-00478432-00478822": "everything thank you guys so much um", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02086-00478823-00478935": "bye", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02087-00478935-00479095": "thanks for having me", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02088-00479096-00479183": "thank you", "W8VOX7nDbUQ-02089-00479184-00479604": "bye have a great weekend"}}, {"audio_id": "W9pEBdSxPxM", "text": {"W9pEBdSxPxM-00000-00000014-00000265": "the Dreamcast is a home video game", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00001-00000266-00000593": "console released by Sega on November 27", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00002-00000594-00001010": "1998 in Japan September 9 1999 in North", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00003-00001011-00001336": "America and October 14th 1999 in Europe", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00004-00001337-00001561": "it was the first in the sixth generation", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00005-00001562-00001864": "of video game consoles preceding Sony's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00006-00001866-00002114": "PlayStation 2 Nintendo's GameCube and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00007-00002115-00002414": "Microsoft's Xbox the Dreamcast was", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00008-00002415-00002624": "Sega's final home console marking the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00009-00002625-00002807": "end of the company's 18 years in the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00010-00002808-00003110": "console market in contrast to the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00011-00003111-00003277": "expensive hardware of the unsuccessful", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00012-00003278-00003536": "Sega Saturn the Dreamcast was designed", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00013-00003536-00003763": "to reduce costs when off-the-shelf", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00014-00003764-00004057": "components including a Hitachi shesh for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00015-00004058-00004495": "CPU and an NEC power VR 2 GPU released", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00016-00004496-00004714": "in Japan to a subdued reception the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00017-00004715-00004963": "Dreamcast enjoyed a successful US launch", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00018-00004964-00005186": "backed by a large marketing campaign but", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00019-00005187-00005389": "interest in the system steadily declined", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00020-00005390-00005554": "as Sony built hype for the upcoming", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00021-00005555-00005879": "PlayStation 2 sales did not meet Sega's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00022-00005880-00006106": "expectations despite several price cuts", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00023-00006107-00006284": "and the company continued to incur", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00024-00006285-00006563": "significant financial losses after a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00025-00006564-00006688": "change in leadership", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00026-00006689-00006910": "Sega discontinued the Dreamcast on March", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00027-00006911-00007210": "31st 2001 withdrawing from the console", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00028-00007211-00007406": "business and restructuring itself as a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00029-00007406-00007753": "third-party publisher 9.13 million", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00030-00007754-00007989": "Dreamcast units were sold worldwide", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00031-00007990-00008252": "although the Dreamcast had a short", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00032-00008253-00008470": "lifespan and limited third-party support", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00033-00008471-00008666": "reviewers have considered the console", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00034-00008667-00008948": "ahead of its time it's library contains", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00035-00008949-00009152": "many games considered creative and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00036-00009153-00009421": "innovative including Crazy Taxi Jet Set", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00037-00009422-00009620": "Radio in Shenmue as well as high-quality", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00038-00009621-00009899": "ports from Sega's Naomi arcade system", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00039-00009900-00010169": "board the Dreamcast was also the first", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00040-00010170-00010396": "console to include a built-in modem for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00041-00010397-00011076": "internet support and online play", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00042-00011077-00011575": "topic history", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00043-00011576-00011917": "you", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00044-00011918-00012635": "topic background' released in 1988 the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00045-00012636-00012844": "Sega Genesis known as the Sega Megadrive", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00046-00012846-00013094": "in Japan Europe and Brazil was Sega's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00047-00013094-00013283": "entry into the fourth generation of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00048-00013284-00013583": "video game consoles selling thirty point", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00049-00013584-00013813": "seven five million units worldwide the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00050-00013815-00014033": "genesis was the most successful console", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00051-00014034-00014321": "Sega ever released the successor to the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00052-00014322-00014558": "Genesis the Sega Saturn was released in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00053-00014559-00014927": "Japan in 1994 the Saturn was a cd-rom", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00054-00014928-00015191": "based console that displayed both 2d and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00055-00015191-00015455": "3d computer graphics but it's complex", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00056-00015456-00015674": "dual CPU architecture made it more", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00057-00015675-00015854": "difficult to program for than its chief", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00058-00015855-00016138": "competitor the Sony Playstation although", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00059-00016140-00016283": "the Saturn debuted before the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00060-00016284-00016478": "PlayStation in both Japan and the United", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00061-00016479-00016808": "States it surprised us launch which came", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00062-00016809-00016982": "four months earlier than originally", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00063-00016983-00017177": "scheduled was marred by a lack of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00064-00017178-00017399": "distribution which remained a continuing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00065-00017400-00017636": "problem for the system moreover", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00066-00017637-00017849": "Sega's early release was undermined by", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00067-00017850-00018056": "Sony's simultaneous announcement that", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00068-00018057-00018359": "the PlayStation would retail for $299", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00069-00018360-00018587": "compared to the Saturn's initial price", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00070-00018588-00018997": "of $399 Nintendo's long delay in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00071-00018998-00019250": "releasing a competing 3d console and the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00072-00019251-00019457": "damage done to Sega's reputation by", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00073-00019458-00019697": "poorly supported add-ons for the Genesis", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00074-00019698-00019978": "particularly the Sega 32x allowed so", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00075-00019979-00020144": "need to establish a foothold in the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00076-00020145-00020402": "market the PlayStation was immediately", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00077-00020403-00020636": "successful in the u.s. in part due to a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00078-00020637-00020864": "massive advertising campaign and strong", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00079-00020865-00021089": "third-party support engendered by Sony's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00080-00021090-00021284": "excellent development tools in liberal", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00081-00021285-00021617": "$10 licensing fee Sony's success was", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00082-00021618-00021809": "further aided by a price war in which", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00083-00021810-00021989": "Sega lowered the price of the Saturn", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00084-00021990-00022606": "from $399 to $299 and then from $299 to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00085-00022607-00022862": "$199 in order to match the price of the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00086-00022863-00023060": "PlayStation even though Saturn Hardware", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00087-00023061-00023264": "was more expensive to manufacture and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00088-00023265-00023428": "the PlayStation enjoyed a larger", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00089-00023429-00023722": "software library losses on the Saturn", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00090-00023723-00023953": "Hardware contributed to Sega's financial", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00091-00023954-00024158": "problems which saw the company's revenue", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00092-00024159-00024512": "decline between 1992 and 1995 as part of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00093-00024513-00024779": "an industry-wide slowdown furthermore", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00094-00024780-00024980": "Sega's focus on the Saturn over the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00095-00024981-00025139": "Genesis prevented it from fully", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00096-00025140-00025226": "capitalized", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00097-00025227-00025412": "on the continued strength of the 16-bit", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00098-00025413-00025655": "market due to long-standing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00099-00025656-00025919": "disagreements with Sega of Japan Sega of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00100-00025920-00026201": "America CEO tom kalinske became less", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00101-00026202-00026519": "interested in his position on July 16", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00102-00026520-00026807": "1996 Sega announced that sho Ichiro", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00103-00026808-00027008": "aramid Giri had been appointed chairman", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00104-00027008-00027233": "and CEO of Sega of America while", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00105-00027233-00027425": "kolinsky would be leaving Sega after", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00106-00027426-00027716": "September 30th of that year Sega also", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00107-00027717-00027858": "announced that Sega enterprises", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00108-00027860-00028106": "co-founder David Rosen and Sega of Japan", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00109-00028107-00028400": "CEO Hayao Nakayama had resigned from", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00110-00028401-00028552": "their positions as chairman and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00111-00028554-00028760": "co-chairman of Sega of America though", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00112-00028761-00028918": "both men remained with the company", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00113-00028919-00029216": "Burnie Stoller a former executive at", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00114-00029217-00029432": "Sony Computer Entertainment of America", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00115-00029433-00029660": "was named Sega of America's executive", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00116-00029661-00029831": "vice president in charge of product", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00117-00029832-00030058": "development and third-party relations", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00118-00030058-00030317": "Stoller did not support the Saturn due", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00119-00030318-00030476": "to his belief that the hardware was", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00120-00030477-00030674": "poorly designed and publicly announced", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00121-00030675-00031001": "at e3 1997 that the Saturn is not our", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00122-00031002-00031250": "future after the launch of the Nintendo", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00123-00031251-00031595": "64 sales of the Saturn and Sega's 32-bit", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00124-00031595-00031874": "software were sharply reduced as of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00125-00031875-00032255": "August 1997 Sony controlled 47% of the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00126-00032256-00032533": "console market Nintendo controlled 40%", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00127-00032535-00032849": "and Sega controlled only 12% neither", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00128-00032850-00033080": "price cuts nor high-profile games were", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00129-00033081-00033277": "proving helpful to the Saturn success", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00130-00033278-00033554": "due to the Saturn's poor performance in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00131-00033555-00033794": "North America Sega of America laid off", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00132-00033795-00034042": "60 of its 200 employees in the fall of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00133-00034043-00034390": "1997 as a result of the company's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00134-00034391-00034616": "deteriorating financial situation", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00135-00034617-00034841": "Nakayama resigned as president of Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00136-00034842-00035111": "in January 1998 in favor of Ihram", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00137-00035112-00035351": "Aguirre Stoller would subsequently", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00138-00035352-00035603": "accede to become CEO and president of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00139-00035604-00035906": "Sega of America following five years of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00140-00035907-00036101": "generally declining profits in the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00141-00036102-00036425": "fiscal year ending March 31st 1998 Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00142-00036426-00036581": "suffered its first parent and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00143-00036582-00036806": "consolidated financial losses since it's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00144-00036807-00037093": "1988 listing on the Tokyo Stock Exchange", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00145-00037094-00037472": "due to a 54.8% decline in consumer", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00146-00037473-00037700": "product sales including a seventy five", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00147-00037701-00037955": "point four percent decline overseas the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00148-00037956-00038180": "company reported a consolidated net loss", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00149-00038181-00038531": "of thirty five point six billion yen 269", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00150-00038532-00038586": "point", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00151-00038587-00038808": "million dollars shortly before", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00152-00038809-00039048": "announcing its financial losses Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00153-00039049-00039225": "revealed that it was discontinuing the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00154-00039226-00039435": "saturn in north america with the goal of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00155-00039436-00039564": "preparing for the launch of its", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00156-00039565-00039858": "successor this decision effectively left", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00157-00039859-00040047": "the Western market without Sega games", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00158-00040048-00040308": "for over one year rumors about the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00159-00040309-00040593": "upcoming Dreamcast spread mainly by Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00160-00040594-00040833": "itself leaked to the public before the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00161-00040834-00041476": "last Saturn games were released", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00162-00041477-00041960": "topic development", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00163-00041961-00042299": "as early as 1995 reports surfaced that", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00164-00042300-00042485": "Sega would collaborate with Lockheed", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00165-00042486-00042770": "Martin the 3do company Matsushita or", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00166-00042771-00042983": "Alliance semiconductor to create a new", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00167-00042984-00043142": "graphics processing unit which", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00168-00043143-00043333": "conflicting accounts said would be used", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00169-00043334-00043676": "for a 64-bit Saturn 2 or an add-on", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00170-00043677-00043924": "peripheral development of the Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00171-00043925-00044114": "was wholly unrelated to this rumored", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00172-00044115-00044351": "project in light of the Saturn's poor", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00173-00044352-00044582": "market performance pyramid jury decided", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00174-00044583-00044717": "to start looking outside of the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00175-00044718-00044905": "company's internal hardware development", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00176-00044906-00045292": "division to create a new console in 1997", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00177-00045293-00045493": "pyramid jury enlisted the services of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00178-00045494-00045776": "IBM's Tatsuo Yamamoto to lead an 11-man", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00179-00045777-00045958": "team to work on a secret Hardware", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00180-00045959-00046171": "project in the United States which was", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00181-00046172-00046508": "referred to as black belt accounts vary", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00182-00046509-00046693": "on how an internal team led by Hideki", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00183-00046694-00046970": "Sato also began development on Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00184-00046971-00047212": "Hardware one account specifies that Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00185-00047213-00047440": "of Japan tasked both teams while another", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00186-00047441-00047660": "suggests that Sato was bothered by ehre", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00187-00047661-00047836": "Madhuri's choice to begin development", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00188-00047837-00048001": "externally and chose to have his", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00189-00048002-00048299": "Hardware team begin development Sato and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00190-00048300-00048499": "his group chose the Hitachi shesh for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00191-00048500-00048689": "processor architecture and the video", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00192-00048690-00048935": "logic power VR 2 graphics processor", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00193-00048936-00049201": "manufactured by NEC in the production of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00194-00049202-00049505": "their mainboard initially known as white", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00195-00049506-00049777": "belt this project was later codename", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00196-00049778-00050093": "dural after the metallic female fighter", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00197-00050094-00050299": "from Sega's Virtua Fighter series", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00198-00050300-00050576": "Yamamoto's group opted to use 3d FX", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00199-00050577-00050810": "voodoo 2 and voodoo Banshee graphics", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00200-00050811-00051104": "processors alongside a Motorola Poe RPC", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00201-00051105-00051488": "603 II central processing unit CPU but", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00202-00051489-00051688": "Sega management later asked them to also", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00203-00051689-00051986": "use the shish for chip both processors", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00204-00051987-00052210": "have been described as off-the-shelf", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00205-00052211-00052688": "components in 1997 3dfx began its IPO", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00206-00052689-00052922": "and as a result of legal obligations", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00207-00052923-00053096": "unveiled its contracts with Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00208-00053097-00053269": "including the development of the new", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00209-00053270-00053524": "console this angered Sega of Japan", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00210-00053525-00053788": "executives who eventually decided to use", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00211-00053789-00054081": "the dural chipset and cut ties with 3dfx", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00212-00054082-00054362": "according to former Sega of America vice", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00213-00054363-00054580": "president of communications and former", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00214-00054582-00054809": "Andy C brand manager Charles Bell field", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00215-00054810-00055025": "presentations of games using the NEC", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00216-00055026-00055253": "solution showcased the performance and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00217-00055254-00055346": "low cost", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00218-00055347-00055502": "by the shish foreign power VR", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00219-00055503-00055751": "architecture he further stated that", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00220-00055752-00056017": "Sega's relationship with NEC", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00221-00056019-00056264": "a Japanese company probably made a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00222-00056265-00056504": "difference in Sega's decision to adopt", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00223-00056504-00056891": "the Japanese teams design to Stoller on", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00224-00056891-00057152": "the other hand felt the US version the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00225-00057153-00057541": "3dfx version should have been used Japan", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00226-00057542-00057785": "wanted the Japanese version and Japan", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00227-00057786-00058121": "won as a result 3dfx filed a lawsuit", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00228-00058122-00058373": "against both Sega and NEC claiming", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00229-00058374-00058516": "breach of contract which would", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00230-00058517-00058769": "eventually be settled out of court the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00231-00058770-00058988": "choice to use the power VR architecture", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00232-00058989-00059258": "Concerned Electronic Arts EA a longtime", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00233-00059259-00059579": "developer for Sega's consoles EA had", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00234-00059579-00059842": "invested in 3d FX but was unfamiliar", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00235-00059844-00060035": "with the selected architecture which was", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00236-00060036-00060323": "reportedly less powerful as recounted by", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00237-00060324-00060578": "Shiro Hagiwara a general manager at", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00238-00060579-00060794": "Sega's Hardware division and Ian Oliver", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00239-00060795-00061025": "the managing director of Sega subsidiary", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00240-00061026-00061244": "cross products the shish 4 was chosen", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00241-00061245-00061427": "while it was still in development and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00242-00061428-00061583": "following a lengthy deliberation process", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00243-00061584-00061772": "because it was the only available", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00244-00061773-00062015": "processor that could adapt to deliver", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00245-00062016-00062317": "the 3d geometry calculation performance", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00246-00062319-00062711": "necessary by February 1998 Sega had", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00247-00062712-00062992": "renamed the dural katana after the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00248-00062994-00063208": "Japanese sword although certain hardware", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00249-00063209-00063413": "specifications such as random access", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00250-00063414-00063641": "memory RAM were not yet finalized", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00251-00063641-00063827": "knowing that the Sega Saturn had been", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00252-00063828-00064004": "set back by its high production costs", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00253-00064004-00064232": "and complex Hardware Sega took a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00254-00064233-00064404": "different approach with the Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00255-00064405-00064682": "like previous Sega consoles the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00256-00064683-00064823": "Dreamcast was designed around", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00257-00064824-00065021": "intelligent subsystems working in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00258-00065022-00065189": "parallel with one another but the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00259-00065190-00065390": "selections of hardware were more in line", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00260-00065391-00065540": "with what was common in personal", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00261-00065541-00065729": "computers than video game consoles", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00262-00065730-00066020": "reducing the system's cost according to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00263-00066021-00066251": "Damian McFerrin the motherboard was a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00264-00066252-00066467": "masterpiece of clean uncluttered design", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00265-00066468-00066881": "and compatibility Chinese economists in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00266-00066882-00067145": "future Sega comm CEO Brad Huang", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00267-00067146-00067424": "convinced Sega Chairman isao okano", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00268-00067425-00067607": "to include a modem with every Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00269-00067608-00067807": "despite significant opposition from", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00270-00067808-00068102": "Okawa staff over the additional $15 cost", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00271-00068103-00068393": "per unit to account for rapid changes in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00272-00068394-00068618": "home data delivery Sega designed the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00273-00068619-00068719": "Dreamcast's mode", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00274-00068720-00069037": "to be modular Sega selected the gd-rom", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00275-00069038-00069325": "media format for the system the gd-rom", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00276-00069326-00069556": "which was jointly developed by Sega and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00277-00069557-00069722": "Yamaha corporation could be", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00278-00069723-00069916": "mass-produced at a similar price to a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00279-00069917-00070144": "normal cd-rom thus avoiding the greater", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00280-00070145-00070486": "expense of DVD rom technology as the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00281-00070487-00070697": "gd-rom format can hold about one", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00282-00070698-00070912": "gigabyte of data illegally copying", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00283-00070913-00071179": "Dreamcast games onto a 650 megabytes", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00284-00071180-00071479": "cd-rom sometimes required the removal of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00285-00071480-00071672": "certain game features although this did", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00286-00071673-00071836": "not prevent copying of Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00287-00071837-00072154": "software Microsoft developed a custom", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00288-00072155-00072385": "Dreamcast version of Windows CE II with", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00289-00072386-00072698": "DirectX API and dynamic link libraries", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00290-00072699-00072941": "making it easy to port PC games to the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00291-00072942-00073121": "platform although programmers would", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00292-00073122-00073306": "ultimately favor Sega's development", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00293-00073307-00073510": "tools over those from Microsoft Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00294-00073511-00073703": "held a public competition to name its", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00295-00073704-00073936": "new system and considered over 5,000", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00296-00073937-00074088": "different entries before choosing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00297-00074089-00074529": "Dreamcast a portmanteau of dream end", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00298-00074530-00074673": "broadcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00299-00074674-00074962": "according to Katz Toshi Iguchi Japanese", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00300-00074963-00075193": "game developer Kenji Eno submitted the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00301-00075194-00075410": "name and created the Dreamcast spiral", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00302-00075411-00075586": "logo but this claim has not been", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00303-00075587-00075901": "verified by Sega the Dreamcast startup", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00304-00075902-00076085": "sound was composed by the Japanese", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00305-00076086-00076403": "musician Ryuichi Sakamoto because the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00306-00076404-00076610": "Saturn had tarnished Sega's reputation", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00307-00076611-00076784": "the company planned to remove its name", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00308-00076785-00077005": "from the console entirely and establish", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00309-00077006-00077210": "a new gaming brand similar to Sony's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00310-00077211-00077360": "PlayStation but aramid Jerry's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00311-00077361-00077554": "management team ultimately decided to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00312-00077555-00077767": "retain Sega's logo on the Dreamcast's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00313-00077768-00078173": "exterior Sega spent $50 - 80 million on", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00314-00078174-00078560": "hardware development $150 - 200 million", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00315-00078561-00078797": "on software development and 300 million", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00316-00078798-00079073": "dollars on worldwide promotion a sum", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00317-00079074-00079267": "which Ihram a Giri a former Honda", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00318-00079268-00079468": "executive humorously compared to the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00319-00079469-00079648": "investments required to design new", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00320-00079649-00080080": "automobiles topic launch despite taking", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00321-00080081-00080293": "massive losses on the saturn including a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00322-00080294-00080591": "75% drop in half a year profits just", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00323-00080592-00080753": "before the Japanese launch of the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00324-00080754-00080984": "Dreamcast Sega felt confident about its", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00325-00080985-00081248": "new system the Dreamcast attracted", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00326-00081249-00081418": "significant interest and drew many", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00327-00081419-00081679": "pre-orders Sega announced that Sonic", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00328-00081680-00081896": "Adventure the next game starring company", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00329-00081897-00082092": "mascot Sonic the Hedgehog", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00330-00082093-00082251": "arrive in time for the Dreamcast's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00331-00082252-00082404": "launched and promoted the game with a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00332-00082405-00082623": "large-scale public demonstration at the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00333-00082624-00082803": "Tokyo caucus I forum hall", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00334-00082804-00083051": "however Sega could not achieve its", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00335-00083052-00083199": "shipping goals for the Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00336-00083200-00083409": "Japanese lunch due to a shortage of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00337-00083410-00083607": "power VR chipsets caused by a high", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00338-00083608-00083769": "failure rate in the manufacturing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00339-00083770-00084069": "process as more than half of its limited", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00340-00084070-00084282": "stock had been pre-ordered Sega stopped", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00341-00084283-00084713": "pre-orders in Japan on November 27 1998", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00342-00084714-00084936": "the Dreamcast launched in Japan at a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00343-00084937-00085200": "price of JP 29 thousand yen and the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00344-00085201-00085410": "entire stock sold out by the end of the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00345-00085411-00085682": "day however of the four games available", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00346-00085683-00085926": "at launch only one a port of Virtua", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00347-00085927-00086163": "Fighter 3 the most successful arcade", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00348-00086164-00086424": "game Sega ever released in Japan sold", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00349-00086425-00086472": "well", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00350-00086473-00086726": "Sega estimated that an additional", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00351-00086727-00087066": "200,000 to 300,000 Dreamcast units could", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00352-00087067-00087236": "have been sold with sufficient supply", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00353-00087237-00087557": "key Dreamcast games Sonic Adventure and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00354-00087558-00087794": "Sega Rally Championship - which had been", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00355-00087795-00087944": "delayed arrived within the following", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00356-00087945-00088161": "weeks but sales continued to be slower", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00357-00088162-00088446": "than expected IRRI Madhuri hoped to sell", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00358-00088447-00088698": "over 1 million Dreamcast units in Japan", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00359-00088699-00089064": "by February 1999 but less than 900,000", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00360-00089065-00089292": "were sold undermining Sega's attempts to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00361-00089293-00089487": "build up a sufficient installed base to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00362-00089488-00089691": "ensure the Dreamcast survival after the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00363-00089692-00089856": "arrival of competition from other", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00364-00089857-00090111": "manufacturers there were reports of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00365-00090112-00090297": "disappointed Japanese consumers", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00366-00090298-00090494": "returning their Dreamcast's and using", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00367-00090495-00090617": "the refund to purchase additional", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00368-00090618-00090957": "PlayStation software Seaman released in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00369-00090958-00091263": "July 1999 was considered the Dreamcast's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00370-00091264-00091551": "first major hit in Japan prior to the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00371-00091552-00091638": "Western lunch", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00372-00091639-00091839": "Sega reduced the price of the Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00373-00091840-00092223": "2jp 19900 yen effectively making the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00374-00092224-00092424": "hardware unprofitable but increasing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00375-00092425-00092715": "sales the price reduction and release of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00376-00092716-00092939": "Namco Soul Calibur helped Sega to gain", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00377-00092940-00093288": "17% on its shares working closely with", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00378-00093289-00093510": "Midway Games which developed for launch", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00379-00093511-00093678": "games for the system and taking", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00380-00093679-00093869": "advantage of the 10 months following the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00381-00093870-00094092": "Dreamcast's release in Japan Sega of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00382-00094093-00094254": "America worked to ensure a more", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00383-00094255-00094469": "successful US launch with a minimum of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00384-00094470-00094731": "15 launch games despite lingering", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00385-00094732-00094919": "bitterness over the Saturn's early", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00386-00094920-00095144": "release Stoller successfully managed to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00387-00095145-00095388": "repair relations with major US retailers", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00388-00095389-00095448": "with whom", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00389-00095449-00095811": "sega presold 300,000 Dreamcast units in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00390-00095812-00096063": "addition a pre-launch promotion enabled", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00391-00096064-00096225": "consumers to rent the system from", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00392-00096226-00096401": "Hollywood video in the months preceding", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00393-00096402-00096717": "its September launch Sega of America's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00394-00096718-00096938": "senior vice president of marketing Peter", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00395-00096939-00097169": "Moore a fan of the attitude previously", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00396-00097170-00097388": "associated with Sega's brand worked with", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00397-00097389-00097569": "foot cone and Belding and Access", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00398-00097570-00097746": "Communications to develop the its", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00399-00097747-00097956": "thinking campaign of 15-second", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00400-00097957-00098148": "television commercials which emphasized", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00401-00098149-00098432": "the Dreamcast's Hardware power according", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00402-00098433-00098619": "to Moore we needed to create something", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00403-00098620-00098793": "that would really intrigue consumers", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00404-00098794-00099015": "some would apologise for the past but", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00405-00099016-00099171": "invoke all the things we loved about", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00406-00099172-00099413": "Sega primarily from the Genesis days on", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00407-00099414-00099675": "August 11th Sega of America confirmed", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00408-00099676-00099819": "that Stoller had been fired", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00409-00099820-00100019": "leaving more to direct the launch prior", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00410-00100020-00100221": "to the Dreamcast to release Sega was", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00411-00100222-00100422": "dealt a blow when EA the largest", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00412-00100423-00100599": "third-party video game publisher", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00413-00100600-00100779": "announced it would not develop games for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00414-00100780-00101088": "the system EA executive being bored and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00415-00101089-00101346": "claimed Sega couldn't afford to give us", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00416-00101347-00101640": "EA the same kind of license that EA has", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00417-00101641-00101973": "had over the last five years but Stoller", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00418-00101974-00102210": "recounted that EA president Larry Propst", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00419-00102211-00102465": "wanted exclusive rights to be the only", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00420-00102466-00102774": "sports brand on Dreamcast which Stoller", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00421-00102775-00102975": "could not accept due to Sega's recent", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00422-00102976-00103193": "$10,000,000 purchase of sports game", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00423-00103194-00103476": "developer visual concepts while the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00424-00103477-00103634": "Dreamcast would have none of EA's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00425-00103635-00103994": "popular sports games Sega sports games", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00426-00103995-00104210": "developed mainly by visual concepts", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00427-00104211-00104379": "helped to fill that void the Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00428-00104380-00104574": "launched in North America on September", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00429-00104575-00105086": "9th 1999 at a price of $199 which Sega's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00430-00105088-00105372": "marketing dubbed the 9th of September 99", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00431-00105373-00105870": "for $199 18 launch games were available", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00432-00105871-00106131": "for the Dreamcast in the u.s. Sega set a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00433-00106132-00106397": "new sales record by selling more than", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00434-00106398-00106851": "225,000 132 Dreamcast units in 24 hours", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00435-00106852-00107036": "earning the company 98 point four", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00436-00107038-00107258": "million dollars in what Moore called the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00437-00107259-00107550": "biggest 24 hours in entertainment retail", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00438-00107551-00107898": "history within two weeks US Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00439-00107899-00108260": "sales exceeded 500,000 by Christmas", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00440-00108261-00108519": "Sega held 31% of the North American", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00441-00108520-00108710": "video game market share", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00442-00108711-00108915": "significant launch games included", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00443-00108916-00109158": "Soulcalibur an arcade fighting game that", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00444-00109158-00109350": "was graphically enhanced for the system", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00445-00109351-00109542": "and went on to sell 1 million units and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00446-00109543-00109746": "visual concepts high quality football", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00447-00109747-00110181": "simulation NFL 2k on November 4th Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00448-00110182-00110355": "announced it had sold over 1 million", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00449-00110356-00110486": "Dreamcast units", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00450-00110488-00110735": "nevertheless the launch was marred by a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00451-00110736-00110943": "glitch at one of Sega's manufacturing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00452-00110944-00111185": "plants which produced defective GD roms", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00453-00111186-00111434": "Sega released the Dreamcast in Europe on", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00454-00111435-00111801": "October 14 1999 at a price of GB two", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00455-00111802-00112188": "hundred liras by November 24th 400,000", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00456-00112189-00112449": "consoles had been sold in Europe by", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00457-00112450-00112722": "Christmas of 1999 Sega of Europe", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00458-00112723-00113019": "reported selling 500,000 units placing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00459-00113020-00113193": "it six months ahead of schedule", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00460-00113194-00113466": "sales did not continue at this pace and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00461-00113467-00113754": "by October 2000 Sega had sold only about", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00462-00113755-00114030": "1 million units in Europe as part of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00463-00114031-00114236": "Sega's promotions of the Dreamcast in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00464-00114238-00114417": "Europe the company sponsored for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00465-00114418-00114582": "European football clubs", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00466-00114583-00114836": "Arsenal FC England as saint-etienne", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00467-00114838-00115266": "France UC Sampdoria Italy and Deportivo", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00468-00115267-00115843": "de la coruña Spain", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00469-00115844-00116343": "topic competition", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00470-00116344-00116550": "though the Dreamcast launch had been", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00471-00116551-00116838": "successful Sony still held 60% of the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00472-00116839-00117054": "overall video game market share in North", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00473-00117055-00117243": "America with the PlayStation at the end", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00474-00117244-00117686": "of 1999 on March 2nd 1999 in what one", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00475-00117688-00117890": "report called a highly publicized", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00476-00117891-00118184": "vaporware like announcement Sony", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00477-00118185-00118425": "revealed the first details events next", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00478-00118426-00118692": "generation PlayStation which ken", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00479-00118693-00118905": "Kutaragi claimed would allow video games", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00480-00118906-00119190": "to convey unprecedented emotions the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00481-00119191-00119403": "center of Sony's marketing plan and the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00482-00119404-00119636": "upcoming PlayStation 2 itself was a new", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00483-00119638-00119964": "CPU clocked at 294 megahertz jointly", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00484-00119965-00120201": "developed by Sony and Toshiba the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00485-00120202-00120549": "emotion engine which Kutaragi announced", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00486-00120550-00120738": "would feature a graphics processor with", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00487-00120739-00120927": "1000 times more bandwidth than", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00488-00120928-00121191": "contemporary PC graphics processors in a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00489-00121192-00121398": "floating-point calculation performance", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00490-00121399-00121638": "of 6.2 gigaflops rivaling most", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00491-00121639-00121958": "supercomputers Sony which invested one", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00492-00121959-00122139": "point two billion dollars in to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00493-00122140-00122358": "large-scale integration semiconductor", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00494-00122358-00122574": "fabrication plants to manufacture the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00495-00122575-00122876": "PlayStation 2s emotion engine and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00496-00122877-00123180": "graphics synthesizer designed the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00497-00123181-00123396": "machine to push more raw polygons than", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00498-00123397-00123702": "any video game console in history sony", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00499-00123703-00123888": "claimed the playstation 2 could render", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00500-00123889-00124179": "75 million raw polygons per second with", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00501-00124180-00124398": "absolutely no effects and 38 million", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00502-00124399-00124572": "without accounting for features such as", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00503-00124573-00124788": "textures artificial intelligence or", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00504-00124789-00125133": "physics with such effects sony estimated", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00505-00125133-00125376": "the playstation 2 could render 7.5", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00506-00125377-00125616": "million to 16 million polygons per", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00507-00125617-00125808": "second whereas independent estimates", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00508-00125808-00126003": "ranged from 3 million to 20 million", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00509-00126004-00126189": "compared to Sega's estimates of more", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00510-00126190-00126381": "than 3 million to 6 million for the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00511-00126382-00126672": "Dreamcast the system would also utilize", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00512-00126673-00126897": "the DVD ROM format which could hold", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00513-00126898-00127065": "substantially more data than the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00514-00127066-00127398": "Dreamcast GB ROM format because it could", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00515-00127399-00127548": "connect to the Internet while playing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00516-00127549-00127811": "movies music and video games sony hype", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00517-00127813-00128013": "playstation 2 is the future of home", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00518-00128014-00128261": "entertainment rumors spread that the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00519-00128263-00128435": "playstation 2 was a supercomputer", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00520-00128436-00128628": "capable of guiding missiles and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00521-00128629-00128820": "displaying Toy Story quality graphics", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00522-00128821-00129018": "while Kutaragi boasted its online", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00523-00129019-00129209": "capabilities would give consumers the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00524-00129210-00129465": "ability to jack into the matrix", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00525-00129466-00129728": "in addition Sony emphasized", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00526-00129729-00129914": "the playstation 2 would be backwards", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00527-00129915-00130088": "compatible with hundreds of popular", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00528-00130089-00130422": "PlayStation games Sony's specifications", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00529-00130423-00130572": "appeared to render the Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00530-00130573-00130782": "obsolete months before its US launch", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00531-00130783-00130983": "although reports later emerged that the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00532-00130983-00131193": "PlayStation 2 was not as powerful as", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00533-00131194-00131394": "expected and distinctly difficult to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00534-00131395-00131709": "program games for the same year Nintendo", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00535-00131710-00131844": "announced that its next-generation", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00536-00131845-00132089": "console would meet or exceed anything on", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00537-00132090-00132248": "the market and Microsoft began", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00538-00132249-00132485": "development of its own console Sega's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00539-00132486-00132698": "initial momentum proved fleeting as US", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00540-00132699-00133010": "Dreamcast sales which exceeded 1.5", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00541-00133011-00133320": "million by the end of 1999 began to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00542-00133321-00133640": "decline as early as January 2000 Porsche", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00543-00133641-00133859": "a Panisse sales contributed to Sega's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00544-00133860-00134066": "forty two point eight eight billion yen", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00545-00134067-00134360": "404 million dollars consolidated net", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00546-00134361-00134547": "loss in the fiscal year ending March", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00547-00134548-00134784": "2000 which followed a similar loss of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00548-00134785-00134984": "forty two point eight eight one billion", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00549-00134985-00135185": "yen the previous year and marked Sega's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00550-00135186-00135434": "third consecutive annual loss although", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00551-00135435-00135645": "Sega's overall sales for the term", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00552-00135646-00135815": "increased twenty seven point four", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00553-00135816-00136028": "percent and Dreamcast sales in North", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00554-00136029-00136250": "America and Europe greatly exceeded the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00555-00136251-00136475": "company's expectations this increase in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00556-00136476-00136656": "sales coincided with a decrease in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00557-00136657-00136869": "profitability due to the investments", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00558-00136870-00137048": "required to launch the Dreamcast in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00559-00137049-00137268": "Western markets and poor software sales", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00560-00137269-00137573": "in Japan at the same time increasingly", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00561-00137574-00137772": "poor market conditions reduced the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00562-00137773-00137999": "profitability of Sega's Japanese arcade", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00563-00138000-00138214": "business prompting the company to close", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00564-00138215-00138400": "246 locations", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00565-00138401-00138653": "knowing that they have to fish where the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00566-00138654-00138884": "fish are biting Sega of America", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00567-00138885-00139109": "president Peter Moore who assumed his", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00568-00139110-00139304": "position after Stoller had been fired", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00569-00139305-00139547": "and Sega of Japan's developers focused", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00570-00139548-00139821": "on the US market to prepare for the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00571-00139822-00139983": "upcoming launch of the ps2", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00572-00139984-00140295": "to that end Sega of America launched its", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00573-00140296-00140544": "own Internet service provider Sega com", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00574-00140545-00140923": "led by CEO Brad Huang on September 7", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00575-00140924-00141359": "2007 at the Dreamcast's internet gaming", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00576-00141360-00141652": "service at a subscription price of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00577-00141653-00141819": "$21.95 per month", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00578-00141820-00142052": "although Sega had previously released", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00579-00142053-00142304": "only one Dreamcast game in the u.s. that", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00580-00142305-00142443": "featured online multiplayer", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00581-00142444-00142688": "Chuchu rocket a puzzle game developed by", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00582-00142689-00142908": "Sonic Team the launch of Sega net which", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00583-00142909-00143121": "allowed users to chat send email", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00584-00143122-00143402": "surf the web combined with NFL 2k won a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00585-00143403-00143639": "football game including a robust online", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00586-00143640-00143802": "component was intended to increase", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00587-00143803-00143997": "demand for the Dreamcast in the US", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00588-00143998-00144261": "market the service would later support", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00589-00144262-00144522": "games including Bomberman online quake 3", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00590-00144523-00144727": "arena and Unreal Tournament the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00591-00144728-00144996": "September 7th launch coincided with a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00592-00144997-00145221": "new advertising campaign to promote Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00593-00145222-00145437": "net including via the MTV Video Music", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00594-00145438-00145668": "Awards of the same day which Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00595-00145669-00145814": "sponsored for the second consecutive", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00596-00145815-00145881": "year", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00597-00145882-00146124": "Sega employed aggressive pricing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00598-00146125-00146307": "strategies with relation to online", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00599-00146308-00146591": "gaming in Japan every Dreamcast sold", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00600-00146592-00146784": "included a free year of Internet access", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00601-00146785-00147135": "which Okawa personally paid for prior to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00602-00147136-00147314": "the launch of Sega net Sega had already", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00603-00147315-00147614": "offered a $200 rebate to any Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00604-00147615-00147815": "owner who purchased 2 years of Internet", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00605-00147816-00148134": "access from Sega comm to increase Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00606-00148135-00148359": "naze appeal in the u.s. Sega dropped the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00607-00148360-00148698": "price of the Dreamcast to $149 compared", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00608-00148699-00149061": "to the ps2 s u.s. launch price of $299", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00609-00149062-00149373": "and offered a rebate for the full $149", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00610-00149374-00149556": "price of a Dreamcast and a free", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00611-00149557-00149769": "Dreamcast keyboard with every 18 months", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00612-00149770-00150077": "Sega net subscription more stated that", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00613-00150078-00150249": "the Dreamcast would need to sell 5", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00614-00150250-00150456": "million units in the US by the end of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00615-00150457-00150641": "2000 in order to remain a viable", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00616-00150642-00150885": "platform but Sega ultimately fell short", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00617-00150886-00151064": "of this goal with some 3 million units", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00618-00151065-00151134": "sold", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00619-00151135-00151379": "moreover Sega's attempts to spur", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00620-00151380-00151572": "increased Dreamcast sales through lower", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00621-00151573-00151754": "prices and cash rebates caused", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00622-00151755-00152064": "escalating financial losses instead of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00623-00152065-00152274": "an expected profit for the six months", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00624-00152275-00152535": "ending September 2000 Sega posted a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00625-00152536-00152753": "seventeen point nine eight billion yen", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00626-00152754-00152953": "one hundred sixty three point one", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00627-00152954-00153179": "$1,000,000 loss with the company", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00628-00153180-00154421": "projecting a year-end loss of 23.6%", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00629-00154422-00154701": "seven billion yen four hundred seventeen", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00630-00154702-00155025": "point five million dollars while the ps2", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00631-00155026-00155286": "s October 26 the US launch was marred by", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00632-00155287-00155619": "shortages with only 500,000 of a planned", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00633-00155620-00155793": "1 million units shipped due to a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00634-00155794-00156018": "manufacturing glitch this did not", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00635-00156019-00156201": "benefit the Dreamcast as much as", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00636-00156202-00156438": "expected as many disappointed consumers", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00637-00156439-00156498": "continued", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00638-00156499-00156843": "wait for a ps2 while the ps1 a remodeled", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00639-00156844-00157050": "version of the original PlayStation was", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00640-00157051-00157251": "the best-selling console in the u.s. at", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00641-00157252-00157572": "the start of the 2008 season according", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00642-00157573-00157851": "to more the PlayStation 2 effect that we", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00643-00157852-00158200": "were relying upon did not work for us", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00644-00158201-00158422": "people will hang on for as long as", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00645-00158423-00158624": "possible", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00646-00158625-00158834": "what effectively happened as the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00647-00158835-00159101": "PlayStation 2 lack of availability froze", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00648-00159102-00159476": "the marketplace eventually sony and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00649-00159477-00159737": "nintendo held 50 and 35 percent of the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00650-00159738-00159959": "u.s. video game market respectively", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00651-00159960-00160177": "while sega held only 15 percent", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00652-00160178-00160490": "according to Belfield dreamcast software", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00653-00160491-00160688": "sold at an 8 to 1 ratio with the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00654-00160689-00160898": "hardware but this ratio on a small", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00655-00160899-00161158": "install base didn't give us the revenue", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00656-00161159-00161426": "to keep this platform viable in the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00657-00161427-00162007": "medium to long term", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00658-00162008-00162493": "topic decline", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00659-00162494-00162858": "on may 22nd mm okay Oh replaced aramid", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00660-00162859-00163137": "Giri as president of Saiga okawa had", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00661-00163138-00163341": "long advocated that Saiga abandoned the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00662-00163342-00163582": "console business his sentiments were not", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00663-00163583-00163819": "unique Saiga co-founder David Rosen had", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00664-00163820-00164088": "always felt it was a bit of a folly for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00665-00164089-00164259": "them to be limiting their potential to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00666-00164260-00164553": "Saiga Hardware and Stoller had", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00667-00164554-00164760": "previously suggested that Saiga should", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00668-00164761-00164984": "have sold their company to Microsoft in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00669-00164985-00165273": "September 2000 in a meeting with Sega's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00670-00165274-00165481": "Japanese executives and the heads of the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00671-00165482-00165660": "company's major Japanese game", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00672-00165661-00165883": "development studios more and Belfield", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00673-00165884-00166062": "recommended that Sega abandon its", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00674-00166063-00166289": "console business and focus on software", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00675-00166290-00166519": "prompting the studio heads to walk out", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00676-00166520-00166878": "nevertheless on January 31st 2001 Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00677-00166879-00167058": "announced the discontinuation of the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00678-00167059-00167283": "Dreamcast after March 31st in the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00679-00167284-00167427": "restructuring of the company as a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00680-00167428-00167782": "platform agnostic third-party developer", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00681-00167783-00168039": "the decision was Moore's Sega also", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00682-00168040-00168256": "announced a Dreamcast price reduction to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00683-00168257-00168540": "$99 to eliminate its unsold inventory", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00684-00168541-00168706": "which was estimated at nine hundred", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00685-00168707-00168974": "thirty thousand units as of April 2001", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00686-00168975-00169338": "after a further reduction to $79 the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00687-00169339-00169628": "Dreamcast was cleared out of stores at", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00688-00169629-00169746": "$49.95", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00689-00169747-00170044": "the final Dreamcast unit manufactured", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00690-00170045-00170226": "was autographed by the heads of all nine", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00691-00170227-00170407": "of Sega's internal game development", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00692-00170408-00170608": "studios as well as the heads of visual", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00693-00170609-00170826": "concepts and wave master and given away", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00694-00170827-00171063": "with 55 first party Dreamcast games", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00695-00171064-00171249": "through a competition organized by", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00696-00171250-00171516": "GamePro magazine Okawa who had", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00697-00171517-00171762": "previously loaned Sega 500 million", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00698-00171763-00172035": "dollars in the summer of 1999 died on", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00699-00172036-00172347": "March 16 2001 shortly before his death", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00700-00172348-00172539": "he forgave Sega's debts to him and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00701-00172540-00172819": "returned his 695 million dollars worth", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00702-00172820-00173052": "of Sega and CSK stock helping the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00703-00173053-00173190": "company survive the third-party", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00704-00173191-00173448": "transition as part of this restructuring", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00705-00173449-00173668": "nearly one third of Sega's Tokyo", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00706-00173669-00173881": "workforce was laid off in the 13th of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00707-00173882-00174169": "September 2001 million Dreamcast units", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00708-00174170-00174396": "were sold worldwide after the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00709-00174397-00174619": "Dreamcast's discontinuation commercial", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00710-00174620-00174789": "games were still developed and released", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00711-00174790-00175035": "for the system particularly in Japan in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00712-00175036-00175294": "the United States game releases", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00713-00175295-00175452": "continued until the end of the first", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00714-00175453-00175833": "half of 2002 Sega of Japan continued to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00715-00175834-00175885": "repair", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00716-00175886-00176266": "REME caste units until 2007 as of 2014", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00717-00176267-00176482": "the console is still supported through", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00718-00176483-00176697": "various mill CD independent releases", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00719-00176698-00176974": "after five consecutive years of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00720-00176975-00177228": "financial losses Sega finally posted a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00721-00177229-00177415": "profit for the fiscal year ending March", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00722-00177416-00177697": "2003 reasons cited for the failure of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00723-00177698-00177973": "the Dreamcast include hype for the ps2 a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00724-00177974-00178222": "lack of support from EA and Squaresoft", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00725-00178223-00178390": "considered the most popular third", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00726-00178391-00178522": "parties in the u.s. and Japan", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00727-00178523-00178765": "respectively disagreement among Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00728-00178766-00178993": "executives over the company's future and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00729-00178994-00179164": "okaw his lack of commitment to the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00730-00179165-00179218": "product", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00731-00179219-00179434": "Sega's lack of advertising money with", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00732-00179435-00179620": "Belfield doubting that Sega spent even", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00733-00179621-00179938": "half the 100 million dollars it had", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00734-00179939-00180124": "pledged to promote the Dreamcast in the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00735-00180125-00180291": "u.s. that the market was not yet ready", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00736-00180292-00180520": "for online gaming Sega's focus on", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00737-00180521-00180811": "hardcore gamers over the mainstream", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00738-00180812-00181057": "consumer and poor timing perhaps the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00739-00181058-00181243": "most frequently cited reason as the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00740-00181244-00181456": "damage to Sega's reputation caused by", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00741-00181457-00181669": "several previous poorly supported Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00742-00181670-00181972": "platforms writing for game pro Blake's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00743-00181973-00182253": "no stated that the much-beloved console", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00744-00182254-00182410": "launched years ahead of the competition", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00745-00182411-00182662": "but ultimately struggled to shed the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00746-00182663-00182911": "negative reputation Sega had gained", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00747-00182912-00183274": "during the Saturn Sega 32x and Sega CD", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00748-00183275-00183673": "days as a result casual gamers and jaded", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00749-00183674-00183907": "third-party developers doubted Sega's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00750-00183908-00184110": "ability to deliver", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00751-00184111-00184357": "eurogamer's Dan Whitehead noted that the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00752-00184358-00184672": "wait-and-see approach of consumers in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00753-00184673-00184828": "the lack of support from EA were", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00754-00184829-00185014": "symptoms rather the cause of Sega's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00755-00185015-00185278": "decline concluding Sega's misadventures", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00756-00185279-00185557": "during the 1990s had left both gamers", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00757-00185558-00185809": "and publishers weary of any new platform", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00758-00185810-00186141": "bearing its name according to one U P", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00759-00186142-00186421": "coms Jeremy parish while it would be", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00760-00186422-00186666": "easy to point an accusatory finger at", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00761-00186667-00186850": "Sony and blame them for killing the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00762-00186851-00187215": "Dreamcast by over selling the ps2", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00763-00187216-00187483": "there's a certain level of intellectual", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00764-00187484-00187978": "dishonesty in such a stance Sega s poor", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00765-00187979-00188251": "us support for hardware like the Sega CD", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00766-00188252-00188569": "the 32x and the Saturn made gamers", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00767-00188570-00188938": "gun-shy many consumers felt burned after", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00768-00188939-00189224": "investing in expensive Sega machines and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00769-00189225-00189380": "finding the resulting libraries", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00770-00189381-00189710": "comparatively lacking the announcement", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00771-00189711-00189917": "of Sega's third-party transition was met", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00772-00189918-00190151": "with widespread enthusiasm according to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00773-00190152-00190505": "IGN's Travis fast Sega was a creatively", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00774-00190506-00190748": "fertile company with a rapidly expanding", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00775-00190749-00191045": "stable of properties to draw from it", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00776-00191046-00191198": "seemed like they were in a perfect", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00777-00191199-00191408": "position to start a new life as a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00778-00191409-00191747": "developer publisher former working", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00779-00191748-00191948": "designs president Victor Ireland wrote", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00780-00191949-00192277": "that it's actually a good thing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00781-00192278-00192565": "because now Sega will survive doing what", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00782-00192566-00192886": "they do best software the staff of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00783-00192887-00193144": "Newsweek remarked from Sonic to Shenmue", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00784-00193145-00193396": "Sega's programmers have produced some of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00785-00193397-00193615": "the most engaging experiences in the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00786-00193616-00193908": "history of interactive media", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00787-00193909-00194175": "I'm shackled by a struggling console", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00788-00194176-00194397": "platform this platoon of world-class", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00789-00194398-00194622": "software developers can do what they do", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00790-00194623-00195003": "best for any machine on the market Rosen", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00791-00195004-00195210": "predicted they have the potential to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00792-00195211-00195494": "catch Electronic Arts Game Informer", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00793-00195495-00195750": "commenting on Sega's tendency to produce", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00794-00195751-00195990": "underappreciated cult classics stated", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00795-00195991-00196203": "let us rejoice in the fact that Sega is", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00796-00196204-00196383": "making games equally among the current", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00797-00196384-00196566": "console crop so that history will not", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00798-00196567-00197157": "repeat itself", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00799-00197158-00197776": "topic technical specifications", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00800-00197777-00198122": "you", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00801-00198123-00198790": "topic Hardware physically the Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00802-00198791-00199199": "measures 190 millimeters x 195 point 8", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00803-00199200-00199493": "millimeters x 75 point five millimeters", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00804-00199494-00199760": "seven point four eight in x seven point", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00805-00199761-00200026": "seven one in x two point nine seven in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00806-00200027-00200282": "and weighs 1.5 kilograms three point", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00807-00200283-00200638": "three pounds the Dreamcast's main cpu as", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00808-00200639-00200965": "a to weigh 360 mips superscalar hitachi", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00809-00200966-00201229": "shesh for 32-bit risc clocked at 200", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00810-00201230-00201398": "megahertz with an 8k byte instruction", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00811-00201399-00201733": "cache and 16 K byte data cache in the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00812-00201734-00201998": "128-bit graphics oriented floating-point", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00813-00201999-00202418": "unit delivering 1.4 gigaflops it's 100", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00814-00202419-00202666": "megahertz and EC power v r2 rendering", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00815-00202667-00202898": "engine integrated with the system zazic", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00816-00202899-00203084": "is capable of drawing more than 3", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00817-00203085-00203270": "million polygons per second and of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00818-00203271-00203551": "deferred shading Sega estimated that the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00819-00203552-00203771": "Dreamcast was theoretically capable of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00820-00203772-00203999": "rendering 7 million raw polygons per", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00821-00204000-00204224": "second or 6 million with textures and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00822-00204225-00204475": "lighting but noted that game logic and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00823-00204476-00204727": "physics reduce peak graphic performance", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00824-00204728-00204977": "graphics hardware effects include", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00825-00204978-00205175": "trilinear filtering Goro shading", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00826-00205176-00205438": "z-buffering spatial anti-aliasing per", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00827-00205439-00205646": "pixel translucency sorting and bump", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00828-00205646-00205873": "mapping the system can output", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00829-00205875-00206107": "approximately sixteen point seven seven", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00830-00206108-00206321": "million colors simultaneously and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00831-00206321-00206548": "displays interlaced or progressive scan", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00832-00206550-00207029": "video at 640 x 480 video resolution it's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00833-00207030-00207340": "67 megahertz Yamaha a I see a sound", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00834-00207341-00207667": "processor with a 32-bit AR m7 risc cpu", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00835-00207669-00208057": "core can generate 64 voices with PCM or", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00836-00208058-00208154": "adpcm", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00837-00208155-00208369": "providing ten times the performance of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00838-00208371-00208636": "the saturn sound system the Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00839-00208637-00208906": "has 16 megabytes main Ram along with an", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00840-00208907-00209071": "additional 8 megabytes of RAM for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00841-00209073-00209308": "graphic textures and 2 megabytes of RAM", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00842-00209309-00209621": "for sound the system reads media using a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00843-00209621-00209934": "12 X speed Yamaha gd-rom drive in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00844-00209935-00210217": "addition to Windows CE II the Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00845-00210219-00210401": "supports several Sega and middleware", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00846-00210402-00210628": "application programming interfaces in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00847-00210629-00210923": "most regions the Dreamcast included a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00848-00210923-00211144": "removable modem for online connectivity", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00849-00211146-00211435": "which was modular for future upgrades", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00850-00211436-00211657": "the original Japanese model and all PAL", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00851-00211658-00211849": "models had a transfer rate of thirty", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00852-00211850-00212053": "three point six kilobits per second", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00853-00212054-00212260": "while consoles sold in the US and in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00854-00212261-00212581": "Japan after September 9 1999 featured a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00855-00212582-00213303": "56 kilobits per second dial-up modem", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00856-00213304-00213759": "topic models", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00857-00213760-00214036": "sega constructed numerous Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00858-00214037-00214242": "models most of which were exclusive to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00859-00214244-00214555": "Japan a refurbished Dreamcast known as", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00860-00214556-00214794": "the r7 was originally used as a network", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00861-00214796-00215037": "console in Japanese pachinko parlors", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00862-00215038-00215389": "another model the divers 2000 cx1", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00863-00215390-00215587": "possesses a shape similar to Sonic's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00864-00215588-00215755": "head and includes a television and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00865-00215756-00216031": "software for teleconferencing a Hello", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00866-00216032-00216265": "Kitty version limited to 2000 units", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00867-00216266-00216490": "produced was targeted at Japanese female", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00868-00216491-00216819": "gamers special editions were created for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00869-00216821-00217062": "seaman and Resident Evil Code Veronica", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00870-00217063-00217315": "color variations were sold through a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00871-00217316-00217678": "service called Dreamcast direct in Japan", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00872-00217679-00217939": "toyota also offered special edition", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00873-00217940-00218236": "dreamcast units at 160 of its dealers in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00874-00218237-00218533": "japan in North America a limited-edition", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00875-00218534-00218791": "black dreamcast was released with a sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00876-00218792-00219004": "sports logo on the lid which included", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00877-00219005-00219198": "matching Sega Sports branded black", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00878-00219200-00219817": "controllers in two games", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00879-00219819-00220325": "topic accessories", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00880-00220326-00220573": "the Dreamcast controller includes both", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00881-00220575-00220817": "an analog stick and a digital pad for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00882-00220817-00221023": "action buttons and two analog triggers", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00883-00221023-00221315": "the system has four ports for controller", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00884-00221316-00221509": "inputs although it was bundled with only", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00885-00221510-00221746": "one controller the design of the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00886-00221748-00221951": "Dreamcast's controller described by the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00887-00221952-00222223": "staff of edges an ugly evolution of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00888-00222225-00222578": "Saturn's 3d controller was called not", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00889-00222579-00222671": "that great", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00890-00222671-00223073": "by one up comm as Sam Kennedy in lame by", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00891-00223073-00223340": "Game Informer's Andy McNamara the staff", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00892-00223341-00223573": "of IGN wrote that unlike most", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00893-00223575-00223856": "controllers Sega's Pad forces the users", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00894-00223857-00224075": "hands into an uncomfortable parallel", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00895-00224076-00224444": "position in contrast to the Sega CD and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00896-00224444-00224654": "Sega Saturn which included internal", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00897-00224655-00225008": "backup memory the Dreamcast uses a 128 K", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00898-00225009-00225235": "byte memory card called the V mu or", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00899-00225236-00225602": "visual memory unit for data storage the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00900-00225603-00225878": "V mu features a small LCD screen audio", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00901-00225879-00226169": "output from a one channel pwm sound", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00902-00226169-00226417": "source non-volatile memory a directional", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00903-00226419-00226712": "pad and four buttons the V mu can", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00904-00226713-00226919": "present game information be used as a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00905-00226919-00227114": "minimal handheld gaming device and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00906-00227115-00227326": "connect to certain Sega arcade machines", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00907-00227327-00227663": "for example players use the V mu to call", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00908-00227664-00227978": "plays in NFL 2k or raise virtual pets in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00909-00227979-00228275": "Sonic Adventure Sega officials noted", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00910-00228276-00228527": "that the V mu could be used as a private", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00911-00228528-00228748": "viewing area the absence of which has", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00912-00228750-00228965": "prevented effective implementation of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00913-00228966-00229313": "many types of games in the past after a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00914-00229314-00229529": "V mu slot was incorporated into the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00915-00229530-00229742": "controllers design Sega's engineers", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00916-00229742-00229964": "found many additional uses for it so a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00917-00229965-00230240": "second slot was added this slot was", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00918-00230241-00230429": "generally used for vibration packs", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00919-00230430-00230642": "providing force feedback like Sega's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00920-00230642-00231005": "jump pack and performances tremor pack", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00921-00231006-00231242": "although it could also be used for other", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00922-00231242-00231416": "peripherals including a microphone", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00923-00231417-00231605": "enabling voice control and player", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00924-00231606-00231905": "communication various third-party cards", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00925-00231906-00232096": "provide storage and some contained the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00926-00232098-00232415": "LCD screen addition Iomega announced a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00927-00232416-00232642": "dreamcast compatible zip drive that", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00928-00232644-00232865": "could store up to 100 megabytes of data", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00929-00232866-00233071": "on removable disks but it was never", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00930-00233073-00233276": "released various third-party controllers", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00931-00233277-00233498": "from companies like Mad Catz include", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00932-00233498-00233661": "additional buttons and other", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00933-00233662-00233835": "her features third-parties also", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00934-00233836-00234060": "manufactured arcade-style joysticks for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00935-00234061-00234294": "fighting games such as aged Tex arcade", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00936-00234294-00234521": "stick and interacts alloy arcade stick", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00937-00234523-00234750": "mad cats and aged tech created racing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00938-00234751-00235014": "wheels for racing games Sega decided", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00939-00235015-00235239": "against releasing its official light gun", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00940-00235240-00235425": "in the US but some third-party light", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00941-00235426-00235671": "guns were available the Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00942-00235671-00235937": "supports a Sega fishing reel and rod", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00943-00235938-00236184": "motion controller and a keyboard for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00944-00236185-00236409": "text entry although it was designed for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00945-00236410-00236646": "fishing games such as Sega bass fishing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00946-00236646-00236841": "Soul Calibur was playable with the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00947-00236842-00237036": "fishing controller which translated", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00948-00237037-00237228": "vertical and horizontal movements into", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00949-00237229-00237435": "on-screen swordplay in a manner that was", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00950-00237436-00237657": "retro actively cited as a predecessor to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00951-00237658-00237933": "the Wii Remote the Japanese Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00952-00237934-00238167": "port of Sega's cyber troopers virtual an", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00953-00238167-00238496": "oratorio tangram supported a twin sticks", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00954-00238496-00238713": "peripheral but the game's American", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00955-00238714-00238911": "publisher Activision opted not to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00956-00238912-00239133": "release it in the US the Dreamcast could", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00957-00239134-00239382": "connect to SNK z-- Neo Geo pocket color", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00958-00239383-00239628": "predating Nintendo's GameCube game boy", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00959-00239629-00239940": "advance link cable Sega also produced", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00960-00239941-00240138": "the dream eye a digital camera that", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00961-00240139-00240330": "could be connected to the Dreamcast and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00962-00240331-00240489": "used to exchange pictures and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00963-00240490-00240681": "participate in video chat over the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00964-00240682-00240954": "system's internet connection Sega hoped", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00965-00240955-00241140": "developers would use the dream eye for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00966-00241141-00241346": "future software as some later did with", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00967-00241348-00241559": "Sony's similar I toyed peripheral in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00968-00241560-00241860": "addition Sega investigated systems that", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00969-00241861-00241986": "would have allowed users to make", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00970-00241987-00242192": "telephone calls with the Dreamcast and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00971-00242194-00242396": "discussed with Motorola the development", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00972-00242398-00242592": "of an internet-enabled cell phone that", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00973-00242592-00242744": "would have used technology from the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00974-00242746-00242948": "console to enable quick downloads of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00975-00242950-00243150": "games and other data the console can", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00976-00243151-00243309": "supply video through several different", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00977-00243310-00243617": "accessories the console came with AV", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00978-00243619-00243816": "cables considered at the time to be the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00979-00243817-00243944": "standard for video and audio", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00980-00243946-00244248": "connectivity Sega and various third", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00981-00244248-00244479": "parties also manufactured RF modulator", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00982-00244480-00244827": "connectors and s-video cables a VGA", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00983-00244828-00245061": "adapter allows Dreamcast games to be", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00984-00245062-00245292": "played on computer displays or enhanced", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00985-00245292-00246056": "definition television sets in 480p", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00986-00246057-00246605": "topic game library", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00987-00246606-00246827": "before the launch of the Dreamcast in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00988-00246828-00247046": "Japan Sega announced the release of its", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00989-00247046-00247310": "new arcade operation machine idea naomi", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00990-00247311-00247532": "arcade board which served as a cheaper", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00991-00247533-00247846": "alternative to the sega model 3 naomi", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00992-00247848-00248023": "shared the same technology as the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00993-00248025-00248273": "Dreamcast albeit with twice as much", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00994-00248273-00248615": "system video and audio memory and a 160", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00995-00248616-00248837": "M byte flash ROM board in place of a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00996-00248838-00249089": "gd-rom drive allowing nearly identical", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00997-00249090-00249416": "home conversions of arcade games games", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00998-00249417-00249626": "were ported from Naomi to the Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-00999-00249627-00249842": "by several leading Japanese arcade", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01000-00249842-00250094": "companies including Capcom Marvel vs.", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01001-00250094-00250403": "Capcom 2 and project justice techmo Dead", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01002-00250404-00250667": "or Alive to treasure Ikaruga and Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01003-00250667-00251063": "itself f355 challenge and Crazy Taxi in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01004-00251064-00251300": "what has been called a brief moment of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01005-00251301-00251648": "remarkable creativity in 2000 Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01006-00251648-00251846": "restructured its arcade and console", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01007-00251846-00251998": "development teams into nine", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01008-00251998-00252206": "semi-autonomous Studios headed by the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01009-00252207-00252536": "company's top designers studios included", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01010-00252537-00252803": "United game artists UGA headed by former", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01011-00252804-00253061": "Sega Rally Championship producer Tetsuya", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01012-00253062-00253232": "Mizuguchi hitmaker", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01013-00253233-00253484": "headed by Crazy Taxi creator and future", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01014-00253485-00253744": "Sega president Hassan Gucci smile bit", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01015-00253746-00253958": "headed by shun awry and including many", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01016-00253959-00254194": "former panzer dragoon and future yakuza", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01017-00254196-00254438": "developers from team andromeda overworks", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01018-00254439-00254687": "headed by norio xi oba and composed of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01019-00254688-00254879": "developers from Sega franchises", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01020-00254880-00255089": "including Sakura wars shinobi and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01021-00255090-00255413": "Streets of Rage Sega am-2 Sega's most", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01022-00255414-00255650": "famous arcade studio and the developer", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01023-00255651-00255854": "of Sega's Virtua Fighter fighting game", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01024-00255855-00256048": "series headed by the company's top", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01025-00256050-00256313": "developer uses uki and Sonic Team the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01026-00256314-00256502": "developer of Sega's flagship series", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01027-00256503-00256792": "Sonic the Hedgehog headed by Yuji Macha", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01028-00256792-00257057": "Sega's design houses were encouraged to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01029-00257058-00257240": "experiment and benefited from a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01030-00257241-00257426": "relatively lacks approval process", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01031-00257427-00257633": "resulting in games such as rest an", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01032-00257634-00257848": "attempt to simulate synesthesia in the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01033-00257850-00258038": "form of a rail shooter' the typing of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01034-00258039-00258217": "the dead a version of the House of the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01035-00258219-00258407": "Dead 2 remade into a touch typing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01036-00258408-00258653": "trainer seaman a pet simulator in which", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01037-00258654-00258854": "players use a microphone to interact", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01038-00258855-00259040": "with a grotesque humanoid fish whose", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01039-00259041-00259246": "growth is narrated by Leonard Nimoy and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01040-00259248-00259511": "Sega Gaga a Japan exclusive role-playing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01041-00259512-00259700": "game employing commentary on the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01042-00259701-00259880": "perceived overabundance of sequels", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01043-00259881-00259982": "produced by the vid", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01044-00259983-00260165": "game industry in which players are", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01045-00260166-00260369": "tasked with preventing Sega from going", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01046-00260369-00260453": "out of business", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01047-00260454-00260744": "Sega also revived franchises from the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01048-00260744-00260986": "Genesis era such as Ecco the Dolphin", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01049-00260987-00261203": "Sega's internal Studios were", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01050-00261204-00261479": "consolidated starting in 2003 with", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01051-00261480-00261677": "Mizoguchi leaving the company following", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01052-00261678-00261932": "the merger of UGA with sonic team UGA", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01053-00261933-00262148": "created the music game space channel 5", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01054-00262149-00262370": "in which players helped a female outer", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01055-00262371-00262586": "space news reporter named uh Lala fight", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01056-00262587-00262898": "aliens with groove energy by dancing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01057-00262899-00263252": "intended for a female casual audience", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01058-00263253-00263480": "space channel 5 is considered one of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01059-00263481-00263807": "Sega's most daring and beloved original", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01060-00263808-00264095": "properties combining a defiantly retro", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01061-00264096-00264509": "and uplifting soundtrack with dazzling", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01062-00264510-00264947": "and colorful visual presentation despite", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01063-00264948-00265198": "a lack of real gameplay substance", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01064-00265199-00265514": "neither space channel 5 nor ugh as rez", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01065-00265515-00265730": "were commercially successful and rez was", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01066-00265731-00265931": "only available in the US market through", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01067-00265932-00266105": "a ps2 port released in limited", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01068-00266106-00266411": "quantities hitmakers arcade ports", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01069-00266412-00266735": "included Crazy Taxi an open-world arcade", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01070-00266736-00266912": "racing game known for its addictive", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01071-00266913-00267098": "gameplay which sold over 1 million", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01072-00267099-00267329": "copies and has been frequently cited as", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01073-00267330-00267521": "one of the best Dreamcast games in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01074-00267522-00267812": "Virtua Tennis which revitalized the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01075-00267813-00267998": "tennis game genre with a simple two", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01076-00267999-00268163": "button control scheme and use of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01077-00268164-00268375": "minigames to test the players technique", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01078-00268376-00268703": "smile bits Jet Set Radio in which", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01079-00268704-00268928": "players control a tokyo-based gang of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01080-00268929-00269114": "youthful rebellious inline skaters", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01081-00269115-00269462": "called the Gigi's who use graffiti to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01082-00269463-00269669": "claim territory from rival gangs while", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01083-00269670-00269909": "evading an oppressive police force has", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01084-00269910-00270137": "been cited as a major example of Sega's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01085-00270138-00270344": "commitment to original game concepts", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01086-00270345-00270611": "during the Dreamcast's lifespan lauded", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01087-00270612-00270884": "for composer Hideki Naga Numis punchy", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01088-00270885-00271163": "psychedelic soundtrack incorporating", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01089-00271164-00271445": "elements of j-pop and electro funk as", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01090-00271446-00271736": "well as its message of self-expression", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01091-00271737-00272051": "and nonviolent dissent the game also", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01092-00272052-00272255": "popularized cel-shaded graphics", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01093-00272256-00272516": "despite wide praise for its style some", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01094-00272517-00272744": "criticized Jet Set radios gameplay as", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01095-00272745-00272939": "mediocre and it failed to meet Sega's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01096-00272940-00273239": "sales expectations produced by Rico", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01097-00273240-00273353": "Kodama the over", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01098-00273354-00273512": "works developed traditional role-playing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01099-00273513-00273767": "game Skies of Arcadia was acclaimed for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01100-00273768-00273998": "its surreal jules verne inspired fantasy", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01101-00273999-00274175": "world of floating islands and sky", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01102-00274176-00274421": "pirates charming protagonists unique", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01103-00274422-00274637": "emphasis on the environmental properties", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01104-00274638-00274865": "of weapons exciting airship battles and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01105-00274866-00275057": "memorable plot including a sequence", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01106-00275058-00275234": "viewed from multiple perspectives", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01107-00275235-00275495": "am2 developed what Sega hoped would be", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01108-00275496-00275695": "the Dreamcast's killer app Shenmue", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01109-00275696-00275951": "revenge epic in the tradition of Chinese", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01110-00275952-00276242": "cinema the action-adventure game", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01111-00276243-00276452": "involved the quest of protagonist Ryo", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01112-00276453-00276692": "Hazuki to avenge his father's murder but", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01113-00276693-00276890": "its main selling point was its rendition", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01114-00276891-00277103": "of the Japanese city of Yokosuka which", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01115-00277104-00277316": "included a level of detail considered", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01116-00277317-00277537": "unprecedented for a video game", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01117-00277538-00277763": "incorporating a simulated day/night", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01118-00277764-00277982": "cycle with variable weather non player", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01119-00277983-00278186": "characters with regular schedules and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01120-00278187-00278378": "the ability to pick up and examine", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01121-00278379-00278600": "detailed objects also introducing the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01122-00278601-00278756": "QuickTime event in its modern form", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01123-00278757-00278993": "Shenmue went over budget and was rumored", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01124-00278994-00279188": "to have cost Sega over 50 million", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01125-00279189-00279467": "dollars originally planned as the first", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01126-00279468-00279719": "installment in an 11 part saga Shenmue", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01127-00279720-00279938": "was eventually downsized to a trilogy", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01128-00279939-00280180": "and only one sequel was ever released", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01129-00280181-00280409": "while Shenmue was lauded for its", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01130-00280410-00280625": "innovation visuals and music its", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01131-00280626-00280832": "critical reception was mixed points of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01132-00280833-00281162": "criticism included invisible walls which", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01133-00281163-00281354": "limited the players sense of freedom", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01134-00281355-00281525": "boredom caused by the inability to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01135-00281526-00281702": "progress without waiting for events", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01136-00281703-00281906": "scheduled to occur at specific times", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01137-00281907-00282101": "excessive in-game cutscenes and a lack", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01138-00282102-00282383": "of challenge according to more Shenmue", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01139-00282384-00282707": "sold extremely well but the game had no", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01140-00282708-00282881": "chance of making a profit due to the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01141-00282882-00283105": "Dreamcast's limited installed base", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01142-00283106-00283439": "Shenmue 2 was completed for a much more", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01143-00283440-00283724": "reasonable sum while sato defended", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01144-00283725-00283952": "Shenmue as an investment which will", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01145-00283953-00284237": "someday be recouped because the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01146-00284238-00284582": "development advances we learned", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01147-00284583-00284878": "can be applied to other games", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01148-00284879-00285088": "in addition to the mixed reception for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01149-00285089-00285340": "Shenmue IGN's Travis fast stated that", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01150-00285341-00285700": "the Dreamcast era wasn't as kind to am2", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01151-00285701-00286113": "as earlier years citing among others", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01152-00286114-00286537": "f355 challenges in acclaimed arcade game", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01153-00286538-00286861": "that didn't do much at home and jenkees", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01154-00286862-00287110": "port of Virtua Fighter 3 as inferior to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01155-00287111-00287332": "the arcade version which was already a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01156-00287333-00287587": "couple years old and never as popular as", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01157-00287588-00287869": "its predecessors the Virtua Fighter", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01158-00287870-00288133": "series would experience a tremendous", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01159-00288134-00288373": "comeback with the universally acclaimed", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01160-00288374-00288661": "Virtua Fighter 4 which saw a console", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01161-00288662-00289036": "release exclusively on ps2 as the first", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01162-00289037-00289264": "fully 3d platforming game starring", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01163-00289265-00289519": "Sega's mascot Sonic the Hedgehog Sonic", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01164-00289520-00289771": "Team Sonic Adventure was considered the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01165-00289772-00290049": "centerpiece of the Dreamcast launch", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01166-00290050-00290278": "adventure garnered criticism for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01167-00290279-00290479": "technical problems including erratic", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01168-00290480-00290674": "camera angles and glitches but was", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01169-00290675-00291019": "praised for its luscious visuals vast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01170-00291020-00291322": "twisting environments and iconic set", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01171-00291323-00291541": "pieces including a segment in which", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01172-00291542-00291736": "Sonic runs down the side of a skyscraper", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01173-00291737-00291997": "and has been described as the Sonic", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01174-00291998-00292315": "series creative apex however it failed", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01175-00292316-00292567": "to catch on with players in nearly the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01176-00292568-00292926": "way that Nintendo's Mario 64 had done", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01177-00292927-00293173": "perhaps due to a perceived lack of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01178-00293174-00293260": "gameplay depth", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01179-00293261-00293458": "distinguished by its innovative use of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01180-00293459-00293695": "multiple storylines with varied forms of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01181-00293696-00293974": "play adventure sold 2.5 million copies", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01182-00293975-00294190": "making it the Dreamcast 2 best-selling", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01183-00294191-00294469": "game Sonic Team also developed the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01184-00294470-00294661": "Dreamcast's first online game", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01185-00294662-00294901": "Chuchu rocket which was widely", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01186-00294902-00295075": "complimented for its addictive puzzle", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01187-00295076-00295384": "gameplay in frantic multiplayer matches", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01188-00295385-00295618": "and the critically successful music game", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01189-00295619-00295843": "samba de amigo which was noted for its", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01190-00295844-00296029": "expensive maracas peripheral and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01191-00296030-00296275": "colourful aesthetic perhaps the most", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01192-00296276-00296497": "influential of Sonic teams Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01193-00296498-00296737": "releases was Phantasy Star Online the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01194-00296738-00297097": "first online console RPG developed after", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01195-00297098-00297328": "Okawa requested an online game from", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01196-00297329-00297502": "Sonic Team the sale was heavily", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01197-00297503-00297808": "influenced by the PC action RPG Diablo", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01198-00297809-00298033": "but refined and simplified its style of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01199-00298034-00298261": "gameplay to appeal to console audiences", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01200-00298262-00298552": "in sports visual concepts NFL 2k", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01201-00298553-00298786": "football series and it's NBA 2k", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01202-00298787-00298966": "basketball series were critically", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01203-00298967-00299290": "acclaimed NFL 2k was considered an", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01204-00299291-00299467": "outstanding launch game for its high", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01205-00299468-00299755": "quality visuals in insightful context", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01206-00299756-00300075": "friendly and yes even funny commentary", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01207-00300076-00300439": "while NFL 2k one featured groundbreaking", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01208-00300440-00300622": "online multiplayer earlier than its", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01209-00300623-00300927": "chief competitor EA's Madden NFL series", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01210-00300928-00301195": "Madden and 2k continued to compete on", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01211-00301196-00301540": "other platforms through 2004 with the 2k", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01212-00301541-00301765": "series introducing innovations such as a", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01213-00301766-00301954": "first-person perspective new to the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01214-00301955-00302224": "genre and eventually launching ESPN NFL", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01215-00302225-00302512": "2k5 at the aggressively low price point", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01216-00302513-00302740": "of $19.95", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01217-00302741-00302977": "until ea signed an exclusive agreement", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01218-00302978-00303159": "with the National Football League", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01219-00303160-00303391": "effectively putting every other pro", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01220-00303392-00303706": "football game out of business after Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01221-00303707-00303943": "sold visual concepts for 24 million", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01222-00303944-00304239": "dollars in 2005 the NBA 2k series", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01223-00304240-00304450": "continued with publisher take-two", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01224-00304451-00304684": "interactive during the Dreamcast's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01225-00304685-00304879": "lifespan visual concepts also", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01226-00304880-00305092": "collaborated with Sonic the Hedgehog", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01227-00305093-00305347": "level designer hirokazu Yasuhara on the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01228-00305348-00305572": "action-adventure game Floyd and Bros and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01229-00305573-00305695": "developed the critically successful", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01230-00305696-00305950": "action game ooh gah Booga to appeal to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01231-00305951-00306178": "the European market Sega formed a French", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01232-00306179-00306361": "affiliate called no cliche which", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01233-00306362-00306567": "developed games such as toy commander", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01234-00306568-00306835": "Sega Europe also approached Bizarre", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01235-00306836-00307024": "Creations to develop the critically", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01236-00307025-00307261": "successful racing game metropolis street", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01237-00307262-00307432": "racer which featured detailed", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01238-00307433-00307681": "recreations of London Tokyo and San", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01239-00307682-00307936": "Francisco complete with consistent time", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01240-00307937-00308211": "zones and fictional radio stations and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01241-00308212-00308536": "262 individual race tracks although", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01242-00308537-00308926": "acclaim SNK Ubisoft Midway Activision", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01243-00308927-00309148": "Infogrames and Capcom supported the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01244-00309149-00309355": "system during its first year third-party", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01245-00309356-00309553": "developer support proved difficult to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01246-00309554-00309730": "obtain due to the failure of the Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01247-00309731-00309892": "Saturn and the profitability of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01248-00309893-00310162": "publishing for the PlayStation Namco's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01249-00310163-00310384": "Soul Calibur for example was released", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01250-00310385-00310540": "for the Dreamcast because of the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01251-00310541-00310762": "relative in popularity of the SOL series", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01252-00310763-00310966": "at the time Namco's more successful", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01253-00310967-00311182": "tekken franchise was associated with the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01254-00311183-00311389": "PlayStation console and PlayStation", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01255-00311390-00311539": "based arcade boards", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01256-00311540-00311781": "nevertheless Soulcalibur received", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01257-00311782-00311962": "overwhelming critical acclaim and has", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01258-00311963-00312151": "been frequently described as one of the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01259-00312152-00312405": "best games for the system capcom", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01260-00312406-00312601": "produced a number of fighting games for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01261-00312602-00312775": "the system including the Power Stone", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01262-00312776-00312964": "series in addition to a temporary", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01263-00312965-00313192": "exclusive in the popular Resident Evil", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01264-00313193-00313366": "series called Resident Evil Code", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01265-00313367-00313675": "Veronica the Dreamcast is also known for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01266-00313676-00313888": "several shoot-'em-ups most notably", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01267-00313889-00314170": "treasures Bank IO and Ikaruga in January", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01268-00314171-00314395": "2000 three months after the system's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01269-00314396-00314617": "North American launch electronic gaming", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01270-00314618-00314791": "monthly offered praise for the game", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01271-00314792-00315199": "library stating less than pre greater", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01272-00315200-00315424": "than slash pre greater than dot-dot-dot", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01273-00315425-00315702": "width triple-a stuff like Soul Calibur", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01274-00315703-00316063": "NBA 2k and soon Crazy Taxi to kick", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01275-00316064-00316257": "around we figure you're happy you took", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01276-00316258-00316738": "the 128-bit plunge in a retrospective PC", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01277-00316739-00316966": "magazine's Jeffrey L Wilson referred to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01278-00316967-00317204": "Dreamcast's killer library and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01279-00317205-00317484": "emphasized Sega's creative influence and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01280-00317485-00317676": "visual innovation as being at its peak", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01281-00317677-00317920": "during the lifetime of the system the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01282-00317921-00318337": "staff of educational games as well as", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01283-00318338-00318565": "Sega's arcade conversions stating that", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01284-00318566-00318775": "the system delivered the first games", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01285-00318776-00318981": "that could meaningfully be described as", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01286-00318982-00319315": "arcade perfect game pro writer Blake", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01287-00319316-00319516": "snow referred to the library as being", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01288-00319517-00319897": "much celebrated Damian McFerrin of retro", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01289-00319898-00320137": "gamer praised Dreamcast's Naomie arcade", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01290-00320138-00320371": "ports opining the thrill of playing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01291-00320372-00320634": "Crazy Taxi in the arcade knowing full", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01292-00320635-00320880": "well dat a pixel perfect conversion and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01293-00320881-00321108": "not some cut-down port was set to arrive", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01294-00321109-00321327": "on the Dreamcast as an experienced", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01295-00321328-00321588": "gamers are unlikely to witness again", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01296-00321589-00321862": "Nick Montfort and mia cowan salvo", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01297-00321863-00322099": "writing and loading", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01298-00322100-00322318": "the Journal of the Canadian game Studies", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01299-00322319-00322579": "Association argued that the Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01300-00322580-00322837": "hosted a remarkable amount of video game", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01301-00322838-00323050": "development that went beyond the odd and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01302-00323051-00323248": "unusual and is interesting when", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01303-00323249-00323522": "considered as avant-garde", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01304-00323523-00323762": "it is hard to imagine a commercial", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01305-00323763-00323957": "console game expressing strong", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01306-00323958-00324200": "resistance to the commodity perspective", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01307-00324201-00324392": "into the view that game production is", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01308-00324393-00324674": "commerce but even when it comes to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01309-00324675-00324878": "resisting commercialization it is", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01310-00324879-00325100": "arguable that Dreamcast games came", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01311-00325101-00325346": "closer to expressing this attitude than", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01312-00325347-00325694": "any other console games have one up.com", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01313-00325695-00325955": "s jeremy parish favorably compared", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01314-00325956-00326180": "Sega's Dreamcast output which included", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01315-00326181-00326456": "some of the most varied creative and fun", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01316-00326457-00326816": "games the company had ever produced with", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01317-00326817-00327098": "its innovated status as a third-party", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01318-00327099-00327419": "fast noted the Dreamcast's life was", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01319-00327420-00327605": "fleeting but it was saturated with", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01320-00327606-00327833": "memorable titles most of which were", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01321-00327834-00328163": "completely new properties according to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01322-00328164-00328358": "author Steven L Kent from Sonic", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01323-00328359-00328565": "Adventure and Shenmue 2 space channel 5", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01324-00328566-00328790": "and seaman Dreamcast delivered and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01325-00328791-00329397": "delivered and delivered", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01326-00329398-00329990": "topic reception and legacy", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01327-00329991-00330352": "in December 1999 next generation rated", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01328-00330353-00330572": "the Dreamcast four out of five stars and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01329-00330573-00330740": "stated if you want the most powerful", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01330-00330741-00331051": "system available now showcasing the best", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01331-00331052-00331285": "graphics at a reasonable price this", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01332-00331286-00331589": "system is for you however next", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01333-00331590-00331825": "generation rated the Dreamcast's future", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01334-00331826-00332063": "prognosis has three stars out of five in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01335-00332064-00332264": "the same article noting that Sony would", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01336-00332265-00332479": "ship a superior hardware product in the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01337-00332480-00332677": "PlayStation 2 in the next year and that", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01338-00332678-00332867": "Nintendo had said it would do the same", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01339-00332868-00333044": "with the Gamecube at the beginning of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01340-00333045-00333317": "2000 electronic gaming monthly had five", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01341-00333318-00333494": "reviewers score the Dreamcast eight", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01342-00333495-00333722": "point five eight point five eight point", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01343-00333723-00334139": "five 8.0 and 9.0 out of ten points by", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01344-00334140-00334412": "2001 the reviewers for electronic gaming", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01345-00334413-00334699": "monthly gave the Dreamcast scores of 9.0", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01346-00334700-00335114": "9.0 9.0 9.0 and nine point five out of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01347-00335115-00335380": "ten Businessweek recognized the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01348-00335381-00335594": "Dreamcast as one of the best products of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01349-00335595-00336014": "1999 in 2009 IGN named the Dreamcast the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01350-00336015-00336218": "eighth greatest video game console of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01351-00336219-00336365": "all time giving credit to the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01352-00336366-00336574": "innovations and software for the system", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01353-00336575-00336941": "according to IGN the Dreamcast was the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01354-00336942-00337187": "first console to incorporate a built-in", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01355-00337188-00337399": "modem for online play and while the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01356-00337400-00337574": "networking lacked the polish and", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01357-00337575-00337799": "refinement of its successors it was the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01358-00337800-00338021": "first time users could seamlessly power", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01359-00338022-00338251": "on and play with users around the globe", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01360-00338252-00338669": "in 2010 PC magazine's Jeffrey L Wilson", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01361-00338670-00338870": "named the Dreamcast the greatest video", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01362-00338871-00339109": "game console emphasizing that the system", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01363-00339110-00339250": "was gone too soon", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01364-00339251-00339593": "in 2013 edge named the Dreamcast the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01365-00339594-00339794": "10th best console of the last 20 years", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01366-00339795-00339998": "highlighting innovations that it added", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01367-00339999-00340199": "to console video gaming including", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01368-00340200-00340394": "in-game voice chat downloadable content", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01369-00340395-00340622": "and second screen technology through the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01370-00340623-00340885": "use of VM use edge explained the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01371-00340886-00341083": "system's poor performance by stating", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01372-00341084-00341369": "Sega's console was undoubtedly ahead of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01373-00341370-00341564": "its time and it suffered at retail for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01374-00341565-00341769": "that reason", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01375-00341770-00342066": "be sued its influence can still be felt", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01376-00342067-00342161": "today", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01377-00342162-00342474": "writing in 1001 video games you must", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01378-00342475-00342600": "play before you die", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01379-00342601-00342831": "Duncan Harris noted one of the reasons", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01380-00342832-00343044": "that older gamers mourned the loss of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01381-00343045-00343260": "the Dreamcast was that it signaled the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01382-00343261-00343683": "demise of arcade gaming culture Sega's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01383-00343684-00343881": "console gave hope that things were not", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01384-00343882-00344091": "about to change for the worse and that", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01385-00344092-00344277": "the tenets of fast fun and bright", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01386-00344278-00344484": "attractive graphics were not about to", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01387-00344485-00344706": "sink into a brown and green bug of", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01388-00344707-00345066": "realistic war games parish writing for", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01389-00345067-00345270": "us gamer contrasted the Dreamcast", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01390-00345271-00345510": "diverse library with the suffocating", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01391-00345511-00345783": "sense of conservatism that pervaded the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01392-00345784-00345984": "gaming industry in the following decade", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01393-00345985-00346251": "Dan Whitehead of Eurogamer discussing", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01394-00346252-00346473": "the Dreamcast portrayal as a small", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01395-00346474-00346851": "square white plastic JFK commented that", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01396-00346852-00347073": "the system's short lifespan may have", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01397-00347074-00347274": "sealed its reputation as one of the", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01398-00347275-00347519": "greatest consoles ever", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01399-00347520-00347756": "nothing builds a cult like a tragic", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01400-00347757-00348044": "demise according to IGN's", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01401-00348045-00348290": "Travis fast many hardware manufacturers", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01402-00348291-00348506": "have come and gone but it's unlikely any", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01403-00348507-00348692": "will go out with half as much class as", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01404-00348693-00348861": "Sega", "W9pEBdSxPxM-01405-00348862-00349218": "equals equals notes"}}, {"audio_id": "W9tNEghQZQ0", "text": {"W9tNEghQZQ0-00000-00000048-00000719": "[Music]", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00001-00000720-00000831": "i mean in like a", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00002-00000832-00001079": "nosferatu count whatever kind of way", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00003-00001080-00001207": "listen something like 10", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00004-00001208-00001366": "of bats are rabies carriers if i got", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00005-00001367-00001511": "guys in there foaming at their mouth i", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00006-00001512-00001582": "need to know", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00007-00001583-00001726": "i don't think i mean most of the", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00008-00001727-00001975": "injuries happen in the stampede out", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00009-00001976-00002191": "anybody left inside a few stragglers", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00010-00002192-00002342": "maybe but we got cast in there still", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00011-00002343-00002487": "trapped in their rigs", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00012-00002488-00002710": "buck eddie head around back see if you", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00013-00002711-00002871": "can figure out the power situation can't", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00014-00002872-00003087": "save it we can't see honeycat", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00015-00003088-00003286": "no it's not a phobia it's not even a", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00016-00003288-00003422": "fear it's just", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00017-00003423-00003599": "rats and mice are way high up on my list", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00018-00003600-00003767": "of things that should absolutely not", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00019-00003768-00003927": "grow wings i mean how does this happen", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00020-00003928-00004103": "easy these dumb asses built a haunted", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00021-00004104-00004311": "house to meet their natural habitat", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00022-00004312-00004815": "during the damn mosquito epidemic", "W9tNEghQZQ0-00023-00004816-00005232": "ah good job boys"}}, {"audio_id": "W9x8xIGiAbI", "text": {"W9x8xIGiAbI-00000-00000012-00000293": "you're busy you work", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00001-00000294-00000503": "take care of your family", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00002-00000504-00000695": "you take care of yourself", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00003-00000696-00000928": "you know what is good for you and you", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00004-00000930-00001157": "know how to protect that and while", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00005-00001158-00001373": "you're busy taking care of what's yours", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00006-00001374-00001630": "cyber criminals are busy thinking of", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00007-00001632-00001834": "ways to take that away", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00008-00001835-00002039": "and while you're away from what you keep", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00009-00002039-00002291": "secure is when you become most", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00010-00002292-00002573": "vulnerable you're busy at work you have", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00011-00002574-00002884": "deadlines clients meetings and that long", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00012-00002885-00003166": "unfinished task list and while you focus", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00013-00003167-00003472": "on work cyber criminals are focused on", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00014-00003473-00003869": "accessing your system as you scroll you", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00015-00003870-00004175": "notice an email from HR the email says", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00016-00004176-00004336": "that you have an unplanned performance", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00017-00004337-00004559": "review later today and then you're", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00018-00004560-00004775": "struck with confused fear", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00019-00004776-00004991": "quickly you click on the calendar invite", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00020-00004992-00005219": "attachment your computer suddenly", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00021-00005220-00005452": "freezes up and while you innocently", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00022-00005453-00005699": "clicked on the attachment the Cyber", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00023-00005700-00005920": "criminal has successfully invaded your", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00024-00005921-00006209": "computer and as a byproduct your entire", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00025-00006210-00006677": "company suddenly you don't feel as safe", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00026-00006678-00006964": "keep your family and life secure but", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00027-00006965-00007151": "with a few clicks all of that can be", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00028-00007152-00007283": "compromised", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00029-00007284-00007523": "The Ransom can be set higher than your", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00030-00007523-00007763": "company's net worth causing it to", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00031-00007764-00007991": "potentially shut down imagine the", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00032-00007992-00008164": "implications of that", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00033-00008165-00008483": "no job and no financial support for your", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00034-00008484-00008639": "family", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00035-00008640-00008969": "firewalls just don't cut it anymore", "W9x8xIGiAbI-00036-00008970-00009338": "Memphis can protect your business"}}, {"audio_id": "W9Enz7oS0X8", "text": {"W9Enz7oS0X8-00000-00000010-00000150": "[Music]", "W9Enz7oS0X8-00001-00000151-00000453": "are we there yet"}}, {"audio_id": "W9cOZwARTkY", "text": {"W9cOZwARTkY-00000-00000003-00000211": "Thank You Tamar and it's a pleasure to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00001-00000212-00000548": "be here with all of you today we are", "W9cOZwARTkY-00002-00000549-00000770": "very excited to be talking about this", "W9cOZwARTkY-00003-00000771-00001129": "CEO transition case studies and and some", "W9cOZwARTkY-00004-00001130-00001310": "of the work of leading-edge what we're", "W9cOZwARTkY-00005-00001311-00001474": "going to do as Tamar mentioned there's", "W9cOZwARTkY-00006-00001475-00001634": "going to be some time for Q&A at the end", "W9cOZwARTkY-00007-00001635-00002081": "so what we wanted is the for the first", "W9cOZwARTkY-00008-00002082-00002333": "45 minutes or so for us to be in", "W9cOZwARTkY-00009-00002334-00002573": "conversation so for Evan and I to speak", "W9cOZwARTkY-00010-00002574-00002798": "about some of the stories that came out", "W9cOZwARTkY-00011-00002799-00003091": "from our CEO succession case studies and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00012-00003092-00003208": "the work that we've been doing about", "W9cOZwARTkY-00013-00003209-00003479": "search committees and then open it up", "W9cOZwARTkY-00014-00003479-00003679": "for the last 15 minutes or so for some", "W9cOZwARTkY-00015-00003680-00003995": "Q&A and as Tamar said if there anything", "W9cOZwARTkY-00016-00003996-00004235": "that comes up in the intervening time we", "W9cOZwARTkY-00017-00004236-00004390": "would love for this to be a conversation", "W9cOZwARTkY-00018-00004391-00004672": "so before we kick it off and I have tons", "W9cOZwARTkY-00019-00004673-00004811": "of questions for Evan as we've been", "W9cOZwARTkY-00020-00004812-00004979": "working together and collecting some", "W9cOZwARTkY-00021-00004980-00005143": "stories I just wanted to give a bit of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00022-00005144-00005390": "background to leading edge which Tamar", "W9cOZwARTkY-00023-00005391-00005647": "framed really beautifully which was for", "W9cOZwARTkY-00024-00005648-00005783": "the last five years we've been working", "W9cOZwARTkY-00025-00005784-00006092": "on this leadership pipeline issue it's", "W9cOZwARTkY-00026-00006093-00006313": "by some its looked at as a crisis we're", "W9cOZwARTkY-00027-00006314-00006470": "very good at crises in the Jewish", "W9cOZwARTkY-00028-00006470-00006845": "community by the way and what we we were", "W9cOZwARTkY-00029-00006845-00007016": "first thought to see this as a challenge", "W9cOZwARTkY-00030-00007017-00007202": "we see as a tremendous opportunity in", "W9cOZwARTkY-00031-00007203-00007469": "that the vast majority of leaders in the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00032-00007470-00007717": "Jewish community and society by the way", "W9cOZwARTkY-00033-00007718-00007898": "this is a demographic that's happening", "W9cOZwARTkY-00034-00007898-00008098": "writ large are turning over and have", "W9cOZwARTkY-00035-00008100-00008255": "been for the last five years and this is", "W9cOZwARTkY-00036-00008256-00008564": "a trend that will continue for certainly", "W9cOZwARTkY-00037-00008565-00008803": "the couple years to come and that time", "W9cOZwARTkY-00038-00008804-00008966": "that transition time is such an", "W9cOZwARTkY-00039-00008967-00009274": "opportunity for an organization and when", "W9cOZwARTkY-00040-00009275-00009421": "we started working on the work of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00041-00009422-00009656": "leading-edge thinking like oh my god our", "W9cOZwARTkY-00042-00009657-00009884": "leaders like the bearish ranges of the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00043-00009885-00010037": "world at combined Jewish Philanthropies", "W9cOZwARTkY-00044-00010038-00010301": "like the Ruth messengers of the world at", "W9cOZwARTkY-00045-00010302-00010481": "American Jewish World Service and on and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00046-00010482-00010853": "on are turning over who's got next the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00047-00010854-00011027": "funder is really behind leading-edge", "W9cOZwARTkY-00048-00011028-00011252": "said oh my god we really haven't talked", "W9cOZwARTkY-00049-00011253-00011405": "about this and thought about this and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00050-00011406-00011695": "led in this way to be able to hedge this", "W9cOZwARTkY-00051-00011696-00011845": "vulnerability for our community and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00052-00011846-00012080": "that's really the genesis of our work at", "W9cOZwARTkY-00053-00012081-00012220": "leading-edge that's really our purpose", "W9cOZwARTkY-00054-00012221-00012458": "and one of the things that we've been", "W9cOZwARTkY-00055-00012459-00012670": "looking at is well what does that CEO", "W9cOZwARTkY-00056-00012671-00012890": "search and succession process look like", "W9cOZwARTkY-00057-00012891-00013088": "because this is the pivotal moment", "W9cOZwARTkY-00058-00013088-00013324": "within an organization's life", "W9cOZwARTkY-00059-00013325-00013624": "that can have you know years of impact", "W9cOZwARTkY-00060-00013625-00013786": "and reverberations and potentially", "W9cOZwARTkY-00061-00013787-00014002": "consequences and that led us to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00062-00014003-00014350": "understand that CEOs are selected by", "W9cOZwARTkY-00063-00014351-00014503": "search committees and these search", "W9cOZwARTkY-00064-00014504-00014658": "committees are made by volunteers", "W9cOZwARTkY-00065-00014659-00014847": "oftentimes volunteers who have never", "W9cOZwARTkY-00066-00014849-00015076": "done this search before and so we", "W9cOZwARTkY-00067-00015077-00015222": "thought how can we make it easier for", "W9cOZwARTkY-00068-00015224-00015553": "these individuals to actually make this", "W9cOZwARTkY-00069-00015554-00015886": "search process smoother potentially", "W9cOZwARTkY-00070-00015887-00016006": "engendered with some of the best", "W9cOZwARTkY-00071-00016007-00016201": "practices in there and that's what led", "W9cOZwARTkY-00072-00016202-00016459": "us to a partnership with Evan which we", "W9cOZwARTkY-00073-00016460-00016660": "somebody we found through LinkedIn of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00074-00016661-00016936": "all things it was it was our chief", "W9cOZwARTkY-00075-00016937-00017118": "operating officer Morty walfish who", "W9cOZwARTkY-00076-00017119-00017341": "we've been reading many of the thought", "W9cOZwARTkY-00077-00017342-00017614": "leaders and related to leadership and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00078-00017615-00017872": "really loved Evans work as he has a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00079-00017873-00017986": "senior editor with Harvard Business", "W9cOZwARTkY-00080-00017987-00018217": "Review reached out to him and said can", "W9cOZwARTkY-00081-00018218-00018409": "we can we put together like a Cliff's", "W9cOZwARTkY-00082-00018410-00018672": "Notes for these search committees like a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00083-00018673-00018976": "guy that will titrate and distill down", "W9cOZwARTkY-00084-00018977-00019267": "the most important aspects of CEO search", "W9cOZwARTkY-00085-00019268-00019549": "so that when a band of volunteer leaders", "W9cOZwARTkY-00086-00019550-00019939": "are looking for their next berry or or", "W9cOZwARTkY-00087-00019940-00020269": "the next leader of organization X that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00088-00020270-00020569": "they're able to do so without having to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00089-00020570-00020788": "learn and relearn and reinvent the wheel", "W9cOZwARTkY-00090-00020789-00021085": "all the time and that's what led us to a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00091-00021086-00021300": "partnership with Evan a prolific", "W9cOZwARTkY-00092-00021301-00021589": "journalist who really enjoyed his piece", "W9cOZwARTkY-00093-00021590-00021783": "at a time and The Economist and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00094-00021784-00022057": "Washington Post etc and that was our", "W9cOZwARTkY-00095-00022058-00022258": "first foray into the CFO search and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00096-00022259-00022534": "transition kind of process and then it", "W9cOZwARTkY-00097-00022535-00022831": "was about really a year ago when we were", "W9cOZwARTkY-00098-00022832-00023053": "at a breakfast with Robert Bank who", "W9cOZwARTkY-00099-00023054-00023302": "current CEO and president of American", "W9cOZwARTkY-00100-00023303-00023436": "Jewish World Service and Ruth Messinger", "W9cOZwARTkY-00101-00023437-00023758": "who said you know what why do we keep on", "W9cOZwARTkY-00102-00023759-00023989": "just complaining about all the bad", "W9cOZwARTkY-00103-00023990-00024175": "that's happening in our community and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00104-00024176-00024412": "all of those transitions that are not", "W9cOZwARTkY-00105-00024413-00024606": "going well there are transitions that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00106-00024607-00024796": "are going well and we know that we can", "W9cOZwARTkY-00107-00024797-00024934": "unpack that and what are some of those", "W9cOZwARTkY-00108-00024935-00025108": "success stories or at least bright spots", "W9cOZwARTkY-00109-00025109-00025350": "that we might be able to lift up and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00110-00025351-00025569": "learn from and that's what got us to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00111-00025570-00025849": "this to ask the question what are some", "W9cOZwARTkY-00112-00025850-00026050": "of those stories out there of CEO", "W9cOZwARTkY-00113-00026051-00026260": "succession that was done with integrity", "W9cOZwARTkY-00114-00026261-00026508": "with thoughtfulness and and turned out", "W9cOZwARTkY-00115-00026509-00026689": "actually very well", "W9cOZwARTkY-00116-00026689-00026868": "and we might be able to learn from and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00117-00026869-00027290": "that's that's really our main topic of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00118-00027291-00027595": "this wonderful webinars is teasing out", "W9cOZwARTkY-00119-00027595-00027799": "some of those stories and understanding", "W9cOZwARTkY-00120-00027800-00027943": "what are some of those threads how we", "W9cOZwARTkY-00121-00027944-00028177": "might be able to compare ourselves to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00122-00028177-00028389": "the private sector how do we do", "W9cOZwARTkY-00123-00028391-00028737": "CEO transitions and search and what are", "W9cOZwARTkY-00124-00028738-00028902": "some of the stories that were immersed", "W9cOZwARTkY-00125-00028902-00029233": "so that's our context and and I'd love", "W9cOZwARTkY-00126-00029233-00029473": "to now keep us off actually with a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00127-00029474-00029745": "question to eben who this is the first", "W9cOZwARTkY-00128-00029747-00029887": "time that actually he and I have been", "W9cOZwARTkY-00129-00029888-00030171": "able to really talk shop in this way and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00130-00030172-00030400": "and go beyond some of the stories that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00131-00030401-00030687": "we tried to fashion and eben is as a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00132-00030688-00030910": "first question to you I'm wondering you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00133-00030911-00031114": "know you talked to over 30 people", "W9cOZwARTkY-00134-00031114-00031327": "through through this process and even", "W9cOZwARTkY-00135-00031327-00031498": "double that when we were putting", "W9cOZwARTkY-00136-00031499-00031636": "together the CEO search committee guide", "W9cOZwARTkY-00137-00031637-00031906": "and specifically as it relates to these", "W9cOZwARTkY-00138-00031907-00032125": "six transitions what were some of the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00139-00032126-00032473": "themes that came up for you that were", "W9cOZwARTkY-00140-00032474-00032698": "salient as you gathered stories for", "W9cOZwARTkY-00141-00032699-00032965": "these seats for these six transitions", "W9cOZwARTkY-00142-00032966-00033232": "yeah thanks golly I I mean the first", "W9cOZwARTkY-00143-00033233-00033373": "thing I'd noticed there was sort of a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00144-00033374-00033607": "universal recognition of the importance", "W9cOZwARTkY-00145-00033608-00033976": "of storytelling when it came to you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00146-00033977-00034221": "helping other nonprofits walk the walk", "W9cOZwARTkY-00147-00034222-00034387": "that you know a lot of the people that I", "W9cOZwARTkY-00148-00034388-00034845": "interviewed search committee members", "W9cOZwARTkY-00149-00034846-00035155": "expect sitting CEOs entering CEOs had", "W9cOZwARTkY-00150-00035156-00035412": "gone through and that was really", "W9cOZwARTkY-00151-00035413-00035731": "refreshing because you know there's a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00152-00035732-00035908": "lot of sort of image management that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00153-00035909-00036087": "goes on in the corporate world and what", "W9cOZwARTkY-00154-00036088-00036325": "I found was that everyone was incredibly", "W9cOZwARTkY-00155-00036326-00036612": "forthcoming about some of the things", "W9cOZwARTkY-00156-00036613-00036757": "they did well and some of the some of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00157-00036758-00037045": "the challenges that they faced and so", "W9cOZwARTkY-00158-00037046-00037212": "you know I think the result is a really", "W9cOZwARTkY-00159-00037213-00037443": "vibrant series of case studies that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00160-00037444-00037900": "really kind of you know presents a human", "W9cOZwARTkY-00161-00037901-00038167": "face of some of to this sort of rarefied", "W9cOZwARTkY-00162-00038168-00038390": "world of like chief executive", "W9cOZwARTkY-00163-00038391-00038618": "transitions", "W9cOZwARTkY-00164-00038619-00038826": "I guess like the headline you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00165-00038827-00039092": "shouldn't be surprising is you know the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00166-00039093-00039248": "thing that kind of came up came away was", "W9cOZwARTkY-00167-00039249-00039389": "this idea of the importance of planning", "W9cOZwARTkY-00168-00039390-00039824": "so you know that's really what separates", "W9cOZwARTkY-00169-00039825-00040217": "smooth sessions from rocky ones and you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00170-00040218-00040340": "know there is such a thing as an", "W9cOZwARTkY-00171-00040341-00040520": "emergency secession you know there is", "W9cOZwARTkY-00172-00040521-00040761": "there are CEOs that you know if I have", "W9cOZwARTkY-00173-00040762-00040955": "less god forbid or get poached or", "W9cOZwARTkY-00174-00040956-00041145": "another organization and you're left", "W9cOZwARTkY-00175-00041146-00041336": "scrambling to find you know a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00176-00041337-00041612": "replacement but too often organizations", "W9cOZwARTkY-00177-00041613-00041789": "during every succession to an emergency", "W9cOZwARTkY-00178-00041790-00042024": "secession because they have not done the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00179-00042025-00042189": "planning and that's one of the things", "W9cOZwARTkY-00180-00042190-00042593": "that I you know I I noted it you know in", "W9cOZwARTkY-00181-00042594-00042879": "in the interviews the other thing to say", "W9cOZwARTkY-00182-00042880-00043014": "the flip side of that if there are", "W9cOZwARTkY-00183-00043015-00043208": "listeners who are panicking because they", "W9cOZwARTkY-00184-00043209-00043361": "might be facing a secession they don't", "W9cOZwARTkY-00185-00043362-00043490": "feel like they planned as well forward", "W9cOZwARTkY-00186-00043491-00043658": "as they could have is it's not a death", "W9cOZwARTkY-00187-00043659-00043892": "sentence right like you know there were", "W9cOZwARTkY-00188-00043893-00044174": "organizations that we interviewed that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00189-00044175-00044520": "you know it took it took some scrambling", "W9cOZwARTkY-00190-00044521-00044924": "and it took some time to you know but", "W9cOZwARTkY-00191-00044925-00045077": "they were able to come away with a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00192-00045078-00045443": "successful secession even and it wasn't", "W9cOZwARTkY-00193-00045444-00045648": "completely sort of locked out in March", "W9cOZwARTkY-00194-00045649-00045870": "step but or a lot marched out in", "W9cOZwARTkY-00195-00045871-00046295": "lockstep but you know I thought do you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00196-00046296-00046457": "mind if we start with spur nice I mean", "W9cOZwARTkY-00197-00046458-00046589": "that felt like a really sort of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00198-00046590-00046832": "interesting to it yeah yes his furnace", "W9cOZwARTkY-00199-00046833-00047068": "was", "W9cOZwARTkY-00200-00047069-00047209": "I mean if you wanted to write a textbook", "W9cOZwARTkY-00201-00047210-00047443": "example of a smooth and a well a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00202-00047444-00047671": "well-run transition Sporus which is an", "W9cOZwARTkY-00203-00047672-00047950": "educational institution Chicago really", "W9cOZwARTkY-00204-00047951-00048166": "kind of nailed it right so this idea", "W9cOZwARTkY-00205-00048167-00048523": "that secession planning starts with", "W9cOZwARTkY-00206-00048524-00048784": "leadership and staff development you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00207-00048785-00049009": "know so arguably it starts decades", "W9cOZwARTkY-00208-00049010-00049195": "before a transition event takes place", "W9cOZwARTkY-00209-00049196-00049345": "that's literally what happened in the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00210-00049346-00049534": "cases furnace right so team Bell is now", "W9cOZwARTkY-00211-00049535-00049966": "the the CEO he joined I think in his", "W9cOZwARTkY-00212-00049967-00050266": "early to mid-20s missed in the hallway", "W9cOZwARTkY-00213-00050267-00050655": "right and he ended up being promoted and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00214-00050656-00050971": "developed he became gosh I haven't hear", "W9cOZwARTkY-00215-00050972-00051118": "director of distance education an", "W9cOZwARTkY-00216-00051119-00051277": "Associate Dean and Dean and chief", "W9cOZwARTkY-00217-00051278-00051475": "academic officer and vice president", "W9cOZwARTkY-00218-00051476-00051736": "provost and you know so he was being", "W9cOZwARTkY-00219-00051737-00052179": "groomed for decades and allowed to kind", "W9cOZwARTkY-00220-00052180-00052438": "of grow as a leader and that involved", "W9cOZwARTkY-00221-00052439-00052680": "not just promotions not just more", "W9cOZwARTkY-00222-00052682-00052917": "responsibility but just good management", "W9cOZwARTkY-00223-00052919-00053197": "right like he was given space to follow", "W9cOZwARTkY-00224-00053198-00053350": "his own interests you know long before", "W9cOZwARTkY-00225-00053351-00053509": "Google was giving all of its employees", "W9cOZwARTkY-00226-00053510-00053770": "20% time off he was given time to you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00227-00053771-00053892": "know one day a week to go do his", "W9cOZwARTkY-00228-00053894-00054103": "academic work etc that helped everything", "W9cOZwARTkY-00229-00054104-00054325": "kind of keep everything fresh and then", "W9cOZwARTkY-00230-00054326-00054469": "when it came to kind of walking the last", "W9cOZwARTkY-00231-00054470-00054709": "mile which is often you know so you can", "W9cOZwARTkY-00232-00054710-00054930": "do everything right but the last mile", "W9cOZwARTkY-00233-00054932-00055141": "the last step to the corner office is", "W9cOZwARTkY-00234-00055141-00055422": "always the most difficult that's where", "W9cOZwARTkY-00235-00055423-00055795": "you know how Luis who was the incumbent", "W9cOZwARTkY-00236-00055796-00056122": "CEO that's where he did this incredible", "W9cOZwARTkY-00237-00056123-00056308": "job now now he's in a unique situation", "W9cOZwARTkY-00238-00056309-00056521": "how literally teaches courses on", "W9cOZwARTkY-00239-00056522-00056665": "leadership transitions and Jewish", "W9cOZwARTkY-00240-00056666-00056914": "communities so he had the chance to sort", "W9cOZwARTkY-00241-00056915-00057216": "of practice what he was preaching but he", "W9cOZwARTkY-00242-00057217-00057457": "essentially told the board when it came", "W9cOZwARTkY-00243-00057458-00057652": "time to renew a three-year contract that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00244-00057653-00057835": "he would take it but it would be his", "W9cOZwARTkY-00245-00057836-00058080": "last he would freeze his pay so that he", "W9cOZwARTkY-00246-00058082-00058465": "could set up the money that he would", "W9cOZwARTkY-00247-00058466-00058636": "have otherwise taken towards leadership", "W9cOZwARTkY-00248-00058637-00058879": "development it would take it upon", "W9cOZwARTkY-00249-00058879-00059110": "himself to identify and present a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00250-00059111-00059377": "successor to the board and then he spent", "W9cOZwARTkY-00251-00059378-00059563": "three years with Dean essentially", "W9cOZwARTkY-00252-00059564-00059914": "developing those last mile skills the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00253-00059915-00060121": "Dean required and those were things like", "W9cOZwARTkY-00254-00060122-00060309": "global finances Dean had", "W9cOZwARTkY-00255-00060310-00060566": "the financials for departments but never", "W9cOZwARTkY-00256-00060567-00060858": "globally it included an understanding of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00257-00060859-00061014": "how to present to the board and how to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00258-00061015-00061248": "communicate to the board how to meet", "W9cOZwARTkY-00259-00061249-00061466": "with donors and crucially what I think", "W9cOZwARTkY-00260-00061467-00061626": "was interesting was that how that just", "W9cOZwARTkY-00261-00061627-00061935": "sort of like you know undertake", "W9cOZwARTkY-00262-00061936-00062172": "classroom learning with Dean he allowed", "W9cOZwARTkY-00263-00062173-00062361": "him to practice leadership so he would", "W9cOZwARTkY-00264-00062362-00062579": "literally like hand the PowerPoint", "W9cOZwARTkY-00265-00062580-00062775": "slides to Dean in front of the board he", "W9cOZwARTkY-00266-00062776-00062961": "would literally allow Dean to take the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00267-00062962-00063234": "lead on donor meetings and I think that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00268-00063235-00063528": "that's kind of crucial because there are", "W9cOZwARTkY-00269-00063529-00063798": "there are things about being a CEO you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00270-00063799-00064101": "just can't experience as a number two", "W9cOZwARTkY-00271-00064102-00064626": "and so by the time it came by the time", "W9cOZwARTkY-00272-00064627-00064845": "his you know his final 3-year contract", "W9cOZwARTkY-00273-00064846-00064967": "was coming to a close", "W9cOZwARTkY-00274-00064969-00065192": "how is able to present this sort of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00275-00065194-00065454": "nearly finished room candidate to the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00276-00065454-00065706": "board and sort of say you know it's up", "W9cOZwARTkY-00277-00065707-00065826": "to you whether you want to put him", "W9cOZwARTkY-00278-00065827-00066102": "against a national you know but this is", "W9cOZwARTkY-00279-00066103-00066306": "you know this is the person that I'm you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00280-00066307-00066549": "know that I put forward to you as part", "W9cOZwARTkY-00281-00066550-00066837": "of my goal and you know and how has a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00282-00066838-00067080": "nice metaphor he talks about you know in", "W9cOZwARTkY-00283-00067081-00067317": "this idea of like a candle lighting", "W9cOZwARTkY-00284-00067318-00067530": "another candle that your earth flame", "W9cOZwARTkY-00285-00067531-00067809": "does not diminish when you pass on the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00286-00067810-00068208": "torch and you know it was a wonderful", "W9cOZwARTkY-00287-00068209-00068394": "experience I think for everyone involved", "W9cOZwARTkY-00288-00068395-00068655": "and you know really as I say just this", "W9cOZwARTkY-00289-00068656-00068991": "incredible sort of textbook example how", "W9cOZwARTkY-00290-00068992-00069216": "to run a secession yeah and for those", "W9cOZwARTkY-00291-00069217-00069471": "organizations who who don't do that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00292-00069472-00069726": "since we know that the nature of work is", "W9cOZwARTkY-00293-00069727-00069930": "changing it used to be very much a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00294-00069931-00070104": "career ladder now it's a lot as people", "W9cOZwARTkY-00295-00070105-00070257": "like jump and this and that they're not", "W9cOZwARTkY-00296-00070258-00070479": "alone enough Dean's in the world who who", "W9cOZwARTkY-00297-00070480-00070674": "stay for you know decades", "W9cOZwARTkY-00298-00070675-00070989": "did you hear other stories of of ways", "W9cOZwARTkY-00299-00070990-00071330": "that there could be homegrown type of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00300-00071331-00071625": "talent that can get ready and that that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00301-00071626-00071775": "final mile I love that image because", "W9cOZwARTkY-00302-00071776-00071997": "you're right there is that you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00303-00071998-00072159": "there's that little bit that just makes", "W9cOZwARTkY-00304-00072160-00072393": "all the difference so we're there any", "W9cOZwARTkY-00305-00072394-00072672": "stories there that that came up as a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00306-00072673-00072996": "little bit less textbook II but yeah", "W9cOZwARTkY-00307-00072997-00073164": "that's right I mean so the first thing I", "W9cOZwARTkY-00308-00073165-00073446": "say is that you know you're right I mean", "W9cOZwARTkY-00309-00073447-00073547": "average you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00310-00073548-00073769": "ten years of organizations plummeted", "W9cOZwARTkY-00311-00073770-00073937": "people are betting around there's this", "W9cOZwARTkY-00312-00073938-00074147": "idea of sort of you know the tour of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00313-00074148-00074549": "duty career right it's coming you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00314-00074550-00074705": "it's being driven largely by Silicon", "W9cOZwARTkY-00315-00074706-00075134": "Valley and Reed Hoffman and others the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00316-00075135-00075365": "first thing I'd say is that you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00317-00075366-00075653": "that's not necessarily fatal for", "W9cOZwARTkY-00318-00075654-00075779": "leadership development", "W9cOZwARTkY-00319-00075780-00076145": "for two reasons one executives do come", "W9cOZwARTkY-00320-00076146-00076352": "back and in fact email left spurred us", "W9cOZwARTkY-00321-00076353-00076496": "for two years in the middle of his", "W9cOZwARTkY-00322-00076497-00076718": "career to go work at DePaul and he sort", "W9cOZwARTkY-00323-00076719-00076892": "of feels that that experience was", "W9cOZwARTkY-00324-00076893-00077072": "crucial so you know I think you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00325-00077073-00077326": "it's always good practice for managers", "W9cOZwARTkY-00326-00077327-00077681": "and CEOs and indeed boards to sort of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00327-00077682-00077891": "let go lightly and sort of don't burn", "W9cOZwARTkY-00328-00077892-00078065": "bridges when people leave don't assume", "W9cOZwARTkY-00329-00078066-00078269": "that you know it's forever broken you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00330-00078270-00078446": "know often times you have you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00331-00078447-00078806": "people will leave go off grow you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00332-00078807-00079043": "maybe they'll maybe they'll spend some", "W9cOZwARTkY-00333-00079044-00079238": "time at home with their family and then", "W9cOZwARTkY-00334-00079239-00079367": "come back to the workplace there are", "W9cOZwARTkY-00335-00079368-00079622": "these instances where you don't assume", "W9cOZwARTkY-00336-00079623-00079772": "that you've lost employee that's first", "W9cOZwARTkY-00337-00079773-00079928": "of all second of all there's actually", "W9cOZwARTkY-00338-00079929-00080195": "research out of by Joseph Bauer Harvard", "W9cOZwARTkY-00339-00080196-00080597": "Business School that executives what he", "W9cOZwARTkY-00340-00080598-00080888": "calls insider outsider leaders around", "W9cOZwARTkY-00341-00080889-00081005": "sided insider leaders I can't quite", "W9cOZwARTkY-00342-00081006-00081167": "remember which but the general gist is", "W9cOZwARTkY-00343-00081168-00081557": "that the best leaders statistically and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00344-00081558-00081755": "he you know he could get you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00345-00081756-00082013": "analysis of shareholder value creation", "W9cOZwARTkY-00346-00082014-00082208": "before and after leadership transitions", "W9cOZwARTkY-00347-00082209-00082421": "the best leaders statistically are", "W9cOZwARTkY-00348-00082422-00082844": "actually those that have you know not", "W9cOZwARTkY-00349-00082845-00083108": "been totally enculturated have spent", "W9cOZwARTkY-00350-00083109-00083282": "time outside of an organization have", "W9cOZwARTkY-00351-00083283-00083453": "come in they've spent maybe three or", "W9cOZwARTkY-00352-00083454-00083675": "four years at least at the organization", "W9cOZwARTkY-00353-00083676-00083879": "but they still have sort of a global", "W9cOZwARTkY-00354-00083880-00084191": "outsider's perspective so I do think", "W9cOZwARTkY-00355-00084192-00084296": "that you gonna work a straight a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00356-00084297-00084524": "successful transition in an era of job", "W9cOZwARTkY-00357-00084525-00084884": "hopping and short tenures but what what", "W9cOZwARTkY-00358-00084885-00085280": "it still requires is that the CEO and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00359-00085281-00085610": "the board both see it as the CEOs duty", "W9cOZwARTkY-00360-00085611-00085943": "to a CEOs Duty not their only duty but a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00361-00085944-00086216": "CEOs duty to plan for their potential", "W9cOZwARTkY-00362-00086217-00086579": "successor and have someone you know in", "W9cOZwARTkY-00363-00086580-00086909": "mind have opportunities for others that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00364-00086910-00087140": "being present immediately jump to mind", "W9cOZwARTkY-00365-00087141-00087371": "but like you know surprise you with", "W9cOZwARTkY-00366-00087372-00087515": "their opportunity with their ability to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00367-00087516-00087923": "grow except yeah and speaking of that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00368-00087924-00088349": "that the real duty of a CEO to think", "W9cOZwARTkY-00369-00088350-00088511": "about their succession I'm wondering if", "W9cOZwARTkY-00370-00088512-00088631": "you could speak a little bit about the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00371-00088632-00088841": "story you unpacked with a jws American", "W9cOZwARTkY-00372-00088842-00089039": "Jewish World Service and you know the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00373-00089040-00089225": "board there's almost like a you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00374-00089226-00089405": "triangulation there the board obviously", "W9cOZwARTkY-00375-00089406-00089489": "plays a role", "W9cOZwARTkY-00376-00089490-00089705": "there's the incumbent CEO as you put it", "W9cOZwARTkY-00377-00089706-00089891": "there's the potentially hand-picked you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00378-00089892-00090203": "know successor and you can get dicey at", "W9cOZwARTkY-00379-00090204-00090440": "times and certainly not Lydia and then", "W9cOZwARTkY-00380-00090441-00090611": "wonder if you can unpack that a bit yeah", "W9cOZwARTkY-00381-00090612-00090887": "that's right I mean you know there's a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00382-00090888-00091100": "beautiful way to think about a CEO", "W9cOZwARTkY-00383-00091101-00091373": "success a CEO succession is the last", "W9cOZwARTkY-00384-00091374-00091622": "great act or the last act of the great", "W9cOZwARTkY-00385-00091623-00091868": "CEO right this is their last sort of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00386-00091869-00092219": "like final act of value creation for the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00387-00092220-00092585": "organization but oftentimes long-serving", "W9cOZwARTkY-00388-00092586-00092822": "incumbent CEOs don't immediately see it", "W9cOZwARTkY-00389-00092823-00093280": "that way right you know they're shocking", "W9cOZwARTkY-00390-00093281-00093557": "you know I'm sympathetic right I mean", "W9cOZwARTkY-00391-00093558-00093821": "pure if you were vital if the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00392-00093822-00094127": "organization essentially has grown up", "W9cOZwARTkY-00393-00094128-00094262": "under your leadership if you're a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00394-00094263-00094442": "long-serving CEO it's difficult to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00395-00094443-00094706": "transition your mindset to think of you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00396-00094707-00094874": "know sustainable intergenerational", "W9cOZwARTkY-00397-00094875-00095132": "sustainability but that's ultimately you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00398-00095133-00095357": "know the job of the board and the CEO is", "W9cOZwARTkY-00399-00095358-00095632": "to sort of to think of kind of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00400-00095633-00096110": "stewardship and so you know so so a jws", "W9cOZwARTkY-00401-00096111-00096470": "so Ruth Messinger is this incredible", "W9cOZwARTkY-00402-00096471-00096740": "woman who I had the participate hour", "W9cOZwARTkY-00403-00096741-00097169": "with on the phone you know had high", "W9cOZwARTkY-00404-00097170-00097542": "profile figure you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00405-00097543-00097745": "the American community not just because", "W9cOZwARTkY-00406-00097746-00098094": "had essentially it wasn't the founder of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00407-00098095-00098238": "a jws but essentially it becomes", "W9cOZwARTkY-00408-00098239-00098538": "synonymous with the organization through", "W9cOZwARTkY-00409-00098539-00098882": "her sort of tireless kind of efforts and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00410-00098883-00099060": "imagination had really kind of grown the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00411-00099061-00099180": "organization to become one of the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00412-00099181-00099551": "leaders in international development and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00413-00099552-00099816": "when the board came to her to talk about", "W9cOZwARTkY-00414-00099817-00100110": "a secession plan you know it was the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00415-00100111-00100426": "timing was they had just finished a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00416-00100427-00100710": "strategic plan with the board I think", "W9cOZwARTkY-00417-00100711-00100956": "the board felt sort of empowered by that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00418-00100957-00101241": "activity and felt at the time you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00419-00101242-00101418": "the timing was right they were starting", "W9cOZwARTkY-00420-00101419-00101547": "to hear from some of the donors and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00421-00101548-00101709": "others the timing was right to start", "W9cOZwARTkY-00422-00101710-00101925": "thinking about the next chapter for ajaw", "W9cOZwARTkY-00423-00101926-00102194": "and Ruth messengers response which you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00424-00102195-00102360": "know she'll chill she'll admit to was", "W9cOZwARTkY-00425-00102361-00102627": "the only way I'm leaving my office's", "W9cOZwARTkY-00426-00102628-00102828": "feet-first right that's that's exactly", "W9cOZwARTkY-00427-00102829-00102959": "what she said like I'm not going", "W9cOZwARTkY-00428-00102960-00103350": "essentially and this is not an uncommon", "W9cOZwARTkY-00429-00103351-00103568": "situation and so the way that the board", "W9cOZwARTkY-00430-00103569-00103934": "handled it the steps that they took to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00431-00103935-00104255": "help bring her along and see that it was", "W9cOZwARTkY-00432-00104256-00104475": "an opportunity to cement her legacy and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00433-00104476-00104768": "you know credit credit is due Ruth's", "W9cOZwARTkY-00434-00104769-00105102": "ability to go from such sort of an", "W9cOZwARTkY-00435-00105103-00105327": "entrenched position to explore other", "W9cOZwARTkY-00436-00105328-00105541": "alternatives to work through what a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00437-00105542-00105849": "secession might mean was you know was", "W9cOZwARTkY-00438-00105850-00106128": "courageous on all sides um you know I", "W9cOZwARTkY-00439-00106129-00106304": "think that one of the things that helped", "W9cOZwARTkY-00440-00106305-00106548": "was this idea that a that a you know see", "W9cOZwARTkY-00441-00106549-00106731": "for someone in Rouge position it doesn't", "W9cOZwARTkY-00442-00106732-00106938": "necessarily mean retirement I mean", "W9cOZwARTkY-00443-00106939-00107082": "there's this sense you know they're", "W9cOZwARTkY-00444-00107083-00107295": "American scholars that write about this", "W9cOZwARTkY-00445-00107296-00107466": "idea of you know stepping down from the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00446-00107467-00107646": "corner offices the step in today of this", "W9cOZwARTkY-00447-00107647-00107810": "you know it's so tied up with your", "W9cOZwARTkY-00448-00107811-00108096": "identity and especially when it's coming", "W9cOZwARTkY-00449-00108097-00108249": "towards the end of your career it can", "W9cOZwARTkY-00450-00108250-00108432": "people like you're being robbed or", "W9cOZwARTkY-00451-00108433-00108643": "something incredibly personal", "W9cOZwARTkY-00452-00108644-00108907": "and so I don't you know there's always", "W9cOZwARTkY-00453-00108908-00109258": "the danger with an outgoing CEO that you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00454-00109258-00109452": "know the board just out of you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00455-00109453-00109626": "frustration just essentially creates an", "W9cOZwARTkY-00456-00109627-00109819": "empty rule for them to make it easier", "W9cOZwARTkY-00457-00109820-00110004": "psychologically for them to imagine", "W9cOZwARTkY-00458-00110005-00110170": "stepping down okay you can keep your", "W9cOZwARTkY-00459-00110171-00110336": "office and we'll give you all these", "W9cOZwARTkY-00460-00110337-00110589": "tasks to take care of but only because", "W9cOZwARTkY-00461-00110590-00110743": "you know we can't figure out any other", "W9cOZwARTkY-00462-00110744-00110883": "way to get rid of essentially right", "W9cOZwARTkY-00463-00110884-00111031": "that's not what happened with Ruth you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00464-00111032-00111339": "know what Robert Bank who was her long", "W9cOZwARTkY-00465-00111340-00111669": "serving woman actually long serving but", "W9cOZwARTkY-00466-00111670-00112101": "innovative and valued number two polish", "W9cOZwARTkY-00467-00112102-00112299": "number two who was ready to take a CEO", "W9cOZwARTkY-00468-00112300-00112633": "role and was in fact getting offers for", "W9cOZwARTkY-00469-00112633-00112818": "leadership positions elsewhere", "W9cOZwARTkY-00470-00112819-00113107": "he was really empowered to sort of work", "W9cOZwARTkY-00471-00113108-00113274": "with Ruth to come up with a role that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00472-00113275-00113446": "made sense for the organization and that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00473-00113447-00113620": "you know that included essentially", "W9cOZwARTkY-00474-00113621-00113784": "telling her that he didn't want her to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00475-00113785-00113976": "hold an office he couldn't justify the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00476-00113977-00114274": "cost in downtown Manhattan he felt it", "W9cOZwARTkY-00477-00114275-00114520": "would be difficult for the staff and so", "W9cOZwARTkY-00478-00114521-00114670": "the way they managed that relationship", "W9cOZwARTkY-00479-00114671-00114927": "and you know that you as we write about", "W9cOZwARTkY-00480-00114928-00115072": "in the case study they actually used an", "W9cOZwARTkY-00481-00115073-00115263": "executive coach to sort of go through", "W9cOZwARTkY-00482-00115264-00115764": "the timeline of the transition and you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00483-00115765-00115962": "know in the end it was kind of one of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00484-00115963-00116109": "these examples where there wasn't much", "W9cOZwARTkY-00485-00116110-00116301": "planning in place they were maybe", "W9cOZwARTkY-00486-00116302-00116449": "started behind the 8-ball", "W9cOZwARTkY-00487-00116450-00116678": "but through the dedication of the board", "W9cOZwARTkY-00488-00116679-00116835": "through Ruth's", "W9cOZwARTkY-00489-00116836-00117102": "ability to grow and see this as an", "W9cOZwARTkY-00490-00117103-00117261": "opportunity from Robert's ability to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00491-00117262-00117453": "step up and feel kind of a potential", "W9cOZwARTkY-00492-00117454-00117706": "vacuum they made it they you know they", "W9cOZwARTkY-00493-00117707-00117973": "made a successful transition mm-hmm and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00494-00117974-00118231": "such a story really like that I remember", "W9cOZwARTkY-00495-00118232-00118372": "when we were when we were thinking about", "W9cOZwARTkY-00496-00118373-00118554": "this case series at first we thought we", "W9cOZwARTkY-00497-00118555-00118819": "would only do a case study on AWS and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00498-00118820-00119001": "that was that was our initial thought", "W9cOZwARTkY-00499-00119002-00119122": "and then you were the one who pushed", "W9cOZwARTkY-00500-00119123-00119245": "back and said no no there's actually", "W9cOZwARTkY-00501-00119246-00119419": "there's a variety of ways to do this", "W9cOZwARTkY-00502-00119420-00119620": "succession and and there's a variety of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00503-00119621-00119939": "ways that we can showcase that and and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00504-00119940-00120223": "yeah and obviously a jws the story is", "W9cOZwARTkY-00505-00120224-00120477": "super rich especially given the the ways", "W9cOZwARTkY-00506-00120478-00120673": "in which things unfolded the role of the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00507-00120674-00121069": "board and yeah yeah yeah yeah it was", "W9cOZwARTkY-00508-00121070-00121219": "interesting right I mean it like be", "W9cOZwARTkY-00509-00121220-00121381": "interviewing it kind of became like", "W9cOZwARTkY-00510-00121382-00121533": "Rosamond I think it's the name that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00511-00121534-00121728": "Devon's film or like every perspective", "W9cOZwARTkY-00512-00121729-00121843": "yes", "W9cOZwARTkY-00513-00121844-00122015": "goes to show how those lay", "W9cOZwARTkY-00514-00122016-00122201": "these things are right eyewitness", "W9cOZwARTkY-00515-00122202-00122383": "accounts don't become particularly", "W9cOZwARTkY-00516-00122384-00122594": "reliable after something this emotional", "W9cOZwARTkY-00517-00122595-00122761": "and you could feel the emotion both from", "W9cOZwARTkY-00518-00122763-00123140": "the board you know who felt incredibly", "W9cOZwARTkY-00519-00123141-00123377": "indebted and grateful to Ruth but ready", "W9cOZwARTkY-00520-00123378-00123559": "and empowered to take the next step and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00521-00123560-00123764": "and Ruth herself who felt this sort of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00522-00123765-00123980": "uncertainty of how you know how she", "W9cOZwARTkY-00523-00123981-00124178": "convinced of transition you know they", "W9cOZwARTkY-00524-00124179-00124373": "came away with different memories but in", "W9cOZwARTkY-00525-00124374-00124711": "the end the outcome was the same so you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00526-00124713-00124955": "know yeah I think I think maybe the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00527-00124956-00125069": "reason they said we should do others is", "W9cOZwARTkY-00528-00125070-00125189": "because I realized pretty quickly that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00529-00125190-00125339": "you could write a whole book on this yes", "W9cOZwARTkY-00530-00125340-00125501": "exactly exactly I think people have", "W9cOZwARTkY-00531-00125502-00125822": "faced at least dissertations I'm", "W9cOZwARTkY-00532-00125823-00125999": "wondering if we can go from from one", "W9cOZwARTkY-00533-00126000-00126395": "female CEO to another and that's in that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00534-00126396-00126784": "gender and the gender lens really in our", "W9cOZwARTkY-00535-00126785-00127073": "work is something that has been that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00536-00127074-00127202": "we've certainly been sensitive to you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00537-00127203-00127369": "from the very very early days of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00538-00127370-00127571": "leading-edge and certainly in leadership", "W9cOZwARTkY-00539-00127572-00127796": "in general in that the Jewish nonprofit", "W9cOZwARTkY-00540-00127797-00128051": "sector is a sector made up of women so", "W9cOZwARTkY-00541-00128052-00128260": "our workforce is predominantly given and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00542-00128261-00128484": "yet it's led predominantly by men and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00543-00128485-00128774": "I'm wondering if there were any sort of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00544-00128775-00129080": "lessons that you teased out as as you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00545-00129081-00129263": "you unearth some of these stories and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00546-00129264-00129419": "certainly given your experience in other", "W9cOZwARTkY-00547-00129420-00129674": "ways about what are some ways that we", "W9cOZwARTkY-00548-00129675-00130043": "might be able to cajole to encourage to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00549-00130044-00130241": "support women as they think about that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00550-00130242-00130544": "final mile and the corner office yeah I", "W9cOZwARTkY-00551-00130545-00130735": "think that's that's a great question you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00552-00130736-00130940": "know I know we've got time for questions", "W9cOZwARTkY-00553-00130941-00131087": "at the end but I saw something that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00554-00131088-00131309": "popped up you know about this I think", "W9cOZwARTkY-00555-00131310-00131549": "the questions about a jjs and who they", "W9cOZwARTkY-00556-00131550-00131699": "use for consultants they actually went", "W9cOZwARTkY-00557-00131700-00131834": "through a series of consultants they", "W9cOZwARTkY-00558-00131835-00132032": "weren't entirely happy with them but if", "W9cOZwARTkY-00559-00132033-00132518": "the question is about Ruth and Robert's", "W9cOZwARTkY-00560-00132519-00132680": "transition actually what was interesting", "W9cOZwARTkY-00561-00132681-00132920": "is that Ruth volunteered to use Robert's", "W9cOZwARTkY-00562-00132921-00133145": "existing executive coach that's right it", "W9cOZwARTkY-00563-00133146-00133427": "was a really nice duster it showed that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00564-00133428-00133610": "she was gonna meet Robert on his terms", "W9cOZwARTkY-00565-00133611-00133754": "with someone that you know he was", "W9cOZwARTkY-00566-00133755-00133943": "comfortable with so that this wasn't", "W9cOZwARTkY-00567-00133944-00134159": "going to be you know that it wasn't even", "W9cOZwARTkY-00568-00134160-00134306": "going to be a neutral arbiter it was", "W9cOZwARTkY-00569-00134307-00134567": "gonna be someone who really had you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00570-00134568-00134738": "who was in Robert's corner and could", "W9cOZwARTkY-00571-00134739-00134906": "kind of like serve Robert and give", "W9cOZwARTkY-00572-00134907-00135029": "Robert what he needed for a successful", "W9cOZwARTkY-00573-00135030-00135174": "transition", "W9cOZwARTkY-00574-00135175-00135434": "um I'm not dodging the question about", "W9cOZwARTkY-00575-00135435-00135714": "you know about equality at the top of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00576-00135715-00135819": "leadership but it's just such a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00577-00135820-00136161": "complicated question and a31 to untangle", "W9cOZwARTkY-00578-00136162-00136440": "right I mean there's no there's no", "W9cOZwARTkY-00579-00136441-00136695": "there's no silver bullet there's no you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00580-00136696-00136845": "know there's so many there's so many", "W9cOZwARTkY-00581-00136846-00137007": "things that might contribute to this", "W9cOZwARTkY-00582-00137008-00137162": "gender disparity there's this you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00583-00137163-00137412": "paucity of female role models women's", "W9cOZwARTkY-00584-00137413-00137622": "lack of access to sponsors these like so", "W9cOZwARTkY-00585-00137623-00137781": "called pink ghettos where women get", "W9cOZwARTkY-00586-00137782-00137904": "stuck in certain roles or they don't", "W9cOZwARTkY-00587-00137905-00138123": "have leadership opportunities that being", "W9cOZwARTkY-00588-00138124-00138441": "said you can't pass the buck as a search", "W9cOZwARTkY-00589-00138442-00138813": "committee and as a it's your duty to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00590-00138814-00139083": "make sure that you have that you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00591-00139084-00139305": "consider a diverse pool and it's in your", "W9cOZwARTkY-00592-00139306-00139641": "interest to write I mean if you only", "W9cOZwARTkY-00593-00139642-00139788": "have people sitting in front of you that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00594-00139789-00139962": "look like you and think like you where's", "W9cOZwARTkY-00595-00139963-00140319": "the innovation gonna come from and you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00596-00140320-00140472": "know one of the one of the things that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00597-00140473-00140832": "came out of the bend the arc case was", "W9cOZwARTkY-00598-00140833-00140979": "that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00599-00140980-00141279": "how neater good intentions are you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00600-00141280-00141641": "so what what I mean by that is that you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00601-00141642-00141972": "can women will off it one of the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00602-00141973-00142183": "problems that we have is that women will", "W9cOZwARTkY-00603-00142184-00142681": "often self-select out of and I think", "W9cOZwARTkY-00604-00142682-00142911": "part of the reason is because you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00605-00142912-00143107": "women are generally more risk-averse", "W9cOZwARTkY-00606-00143108-00143269": "there's a whole host of research there's", "W9cOZwARTkY-00607-00143270-00143535": "one professor who has whose research a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00608-00143536-00143703": "site in the case study who who", "W9cOZwARTkY-00609-00143704-00144122": "interviewed potential candidates for", "W9cOZwARTkY-00610-00144123-00144423": "state government in Texas I believe and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00611-00144424-00144621": "she said what percentage chance would", "W9cOZwARTkY-00612-00144622-00144822": "you have to have to consider running for", "W9cOZwARTkY-00613-00144823-00145041": "you know governor or the next level I", "W9cOZwARTkY-00614-00145042-00145212": "can't quite remember but for men it was", "W9cOZwARTkY-00615-00145213-00145410": "like basically zero if I've got like you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00616-00145411-00145482": "know if you're telling me I got a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00617-00145483-00145650": "one-in-a-million chance of going for it", "W9cOZwARTkY-00618-00145651-00145843": "for women it was more like I need to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00619-00145844-00145977": "know I've got a very good chance of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00620-00145978-00146259": "succeeding getting and that's that you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00621-00146260-00146439": "know so with then within the arc they", "W9cOZwARTkY-00622-00146440-00146794": "had this incredibly forceful charismatic", "W9cOZwARTkY-00623-00146795-00147094": "talented executive in Stosh cutler and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00624-00147095-00147246": "then this is a tough cookie right I", "W9cOZwARTkY-00625-00147247-00147445": "think she's black belt in the martial", "W9cOZwARTkY-00626-00147446-00147678": "arts it's really kind of gritty", "W9cOZwARTkY-00627-00147679-00148089": "background and even and she's also you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00628-00148090-00148290": "know she's very active because of the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00629-00148291-00148479": "organization in progressive politics and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00630-00148480-00148611": "gender equality is something which he", "W9cOZwARTkY-00631-00148612-00148848": "thinks a lot about and so she knew she", "W9cOZwARTkY-00632-00148849-00149032": "was aware of the research that women", "W9cOZwARTkY-00633-00149033-00149208": "will often sort of duck their heads when", "W9cOZwARTkY-00634-00149209-00149388": "Kim's time to like you apply them for", "W9cOZwARTkY-00635-00149389-00149649": "CEO roles and she still almost fell for", "W9cOZwARTkY-00636-00149650-00149949": "it right she still felt like she read", "W9cOZwARTkY-00637-00149950-00150039": "the Job Description", "W9cOZwARTkY-00638-00150040-00150207": "and she's like I don't know if I can do", "W9cOZwARTkY-00639-00150208-00150351": "this I don't know if this is for me", "W9cOZwARTkY-00640-00150352-00150648": "etc and what Kate what happened is that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00641-00150649-00150852": "the board you know a couple things one", "W9cOZwARTkY-00642-00150853-00151081": "you know I think the board really you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00643-00151082-00151245": "know really pushed her really you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00644-00151246-00151413": "and they didn't sugarcoat it they said", "W9cOZwARTkY-00645-00151414-00151659": "yeah I'm sure that you have gaps and you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00646-00151660-00151827": "have weaknesses almost all the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00647-00151828-00152058": "candidates that we would look at will we", "W9cOZwARTkY-00648-00152059-00152257": "will help you fill those gaps and those", "W9cOZwARTkY-00649-00152258-00152499": "those weaknesses and I think that gave", "W9cOZwARTkY-00650-00152500-00152772": "her confidence to serve step forward and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00651-00152773-00152895": "then I think that's something else that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00652-00152896-00153057": "you know that happened that uncovers", "W9cOZwARTkY-00653-00153058-00153303": "sort of one of these how why gender", "W9cOZwARTkY-00654-00153304-00153534": "equality and rest addressed systemically", "W9cOZwARTkY-00655-00153535-00153729": "you know she had been part of a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00656-00153730-00153885": "leadership development program I think", "W9cOZwARTkY-00657-00153886-00154175": "15 years before and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00658-00154176-00154409": "the fact that she was part she was you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00659-00154410-00154742": "know in a cohort that had gone on to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00660-00154743-00154904": "become leaders in the Jewish community", "W9cOZwARTkY-00661-00154905-00155177": "provided a support network of people who", "W9cOZwARTkY-00662-00155178-00155333": "had walked the walk who could say of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00663-00155334-00155480": "course he can do this you know we know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00664-00155481-00155699": "you you're super talented like this is", "W9cOZwARTkY-00665-00155700-00155908": "this is a great opportunity for you and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00666-00155909-00156170": "so eventually she you know she put her", "W9cOZwARTkY-00667-00156171-00156395": "name forward and and and she got the job", "W9cOZwARTkY-00668-00156396-00156542": "but she couldn't you know this could", "W9cOZwARTkY-00669-00156543-00156671": "have easily had been one of those dogs", "W9cOZwARTkY-00670-00156672-00156812": "that didn't bark you might never have", "W9cOZwARTkY-00671-00156813-00157055": "known of Stosh cobblers potential as a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00672-00157056-00157241": "CEO because she never would have had the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00673-00157242-00157568": "opportunity you know if if she hadn't", "W9cOZwARTkY-00674-00157569-00157907": "have had the the sort of gentle pushing", "W9cOZwARTkY-00675-00157908-00158030": "from the board you know one other", "W9cOZwARTkY-00676-00158031-00158171": "interesting thing about that is you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00677-00158172-00158348": "to follow up with this idea of like you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00678-00158349-00158906": "know treating her professionally as", "W9cOZwARTkY-00679-00158907-00159161": "mexicali a way to instill confidence you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00680-00159162-00159266": "know they put her through the wringer", "W9cOZwARTkY-00681-00159267-00159494": "when it came time to his you know they", "W9cOZwARTkY-00682-00159495-00159578": "weren't like oh well you're nervous", "W9cOZwARTkY-00683-00159579-00159779": "about taking his position so we'll treat", "W9cOZwARTkY-00684-00159780-00159977": "with kid gloves I mean they you know and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00685-00159978-00160196": "I think that actually paradoxically sort", "W9cOZwARTkY-00686-00160197-00160652": "of you know showed her that you know she", "W9cOZwARTkY-00687-00160653-00160829": "could handle she could handle the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00688-00160830-00161123": "pressure that this was not a token", "W9cOZwARTkY-00689-00161124-00161369": "appointment that this was a serious", "W9cOZwARTkY-00690-00161370-00161597": "assessment process and it gave her more", "W9cOZwARTkY-00691-00161598-00161759": "confidence in herself and if she had", "W9cOZwARTkY-00692-00161760-00162029": "felt like she had just been yeah mentor", "W9cOZwARTkY-00693-00162030-00162155": "of mine once said you know there's a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00694-00162156-00162338": "whole business debate about our leaders", "W9cOZwARTkY-00695-00162339-00162611": "born or they made and he was like you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00696-00162612-00162866": "know what they're forged mm-hmm and that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00697-00162867-00163235": "that's a it's a beautiful way of really", "W9cOZwARTkY-00698-00163236-00163504": "what Woodstock probably endured and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00699-00163505-00163754": "certainly made her one of the most", "W9cOZwARTkY-00700-00163755-00163880": "inspiring leaders that we have in our", "W9cOZwARTkY-00701-00163881-00164177": "community when we also when we think", "W9cOZwARTkY-00702-00164178-00164420": "about search in the role of boards there", "W9cOZwARTkY-00703-00164421-00164723": "are there is this aspect of transparency", "W9cOZwARTkY-00704-00164724-00164927": "that we get a lot of calls about with", "W9cOZwARTkY-00705-00164928-00165080": "especially since we went out doing a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00706-00165081-00165359": "little bit more work in terms of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00707-00165360-00165686": "research on CEO search and and and some", "W9cOZwARTkY-00708-00165687-00165890": "of the best practices there is so people", "W9cOZwARTkY-00709-00165891-00166067": "reach out for advice and one of the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00710-00166068-00166259": "biggest questions for search committees", "W9cOZwARTkY-00711-00166260-00166454": "and specifically the chairs of search", "W9cOZwARTkY-00712-00166455-00166676": "committees is you know we run an", "W9cOZwARTkY-00713-00166677-00166853": "organization that has a lot of assets", "W9cOZwARTkY-00714-00166854-00167009": "that has concentric circles of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00715-00167010-00167246": "constituents we are not sure how to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00716-00167247-00167324": "bring them in", "W9cOZwARTkY-00717-00167325-00167603": "but what's what's a good way to manage", "W9cOZwARTkY-00718-00167604-00167761": "the communications how much is too much", "W9cOZwARTkY-00719-00167762-00168086": "there different camps some people want a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00720-00168087-00168239": "voice some people want to vote some", "W9cOZwARTkY-00721-00168240-00168494": "people want to veto help what do we do", "W9cOZwARTkY-00722-00168495-00168797": "and and I'm wondering if there's the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00723-00168798-00168932": "research and the stories may point to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00724-00168933-00169310": "some advice on that mmm yeah so thanks", "W9cOZwARTkY-00725-00169311-00169595": "that's a great question so you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00726-00169596-00169931": "death so I I've heard it described that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00727-00169932-00170120": "you know CEO sessions and you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00728-00170121-00170375": "nonprofits are sort of like marriages or", "W9cOZwARTkY-00729-00170376-00170528": "funerals they're an opportunity for the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00730-00170529-00170687": "community to kind of come together or", "W9cOZwARTkY-00731-00170688-00171086": "splinter apart and I think it needs to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00732-00171087-00171289": "be seen as an opportunity to sort of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00733-00171290-00171581": "strengthen the entire community not just", "W9cOZwARTkY-00734-00171582-00171770": "the organization and you can't do that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00735-00171771-00172166": "without transparency and buy-in from the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00736-00172167-00172801": "community you know I took", "W9cOZwARTkY-00737-00172802-00172945": "which over to healthcare for a second", "W9cOZwARTkY-00738-00172946-00173074": "you know there's this thing hits this", "W9cOZwARTkY-00739-00173075-00173380": "ball big degradation privacy and it's", "W9cOZwARTkY-00740-00173381-00173818": "all you know it's very valid and you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00741-00173819-00173929": "know it's a valid concern but I feel", "W9cOZwARTkY-00742-00173930-00174058": "like a lot of health care organizations", "W9cOZwARTkY-00743-00174059-00174217": "like hide behind HIPAA when it comes", "W9cOZwARTkY-00744-00174218-00174367": "time to like sharing patient data with", "W9cOZwARTkY-00745-00174368-00174553": "our hospitals or whatever you know I", "W9cOZwARTkY-00746-00174554-00174691": "feel like there's something similar", "W9cOZwARTkY-00747-00174692-00174871": "around confidentiality and searches", "W9cOZwARTkY-00748-00174872-00175105": "wicker there's a sensible when we have", "W9cOZwARTkY-00749-00175106-00175237": "to protect the confidentially on", "W9cOZwARTkY-00750-00175238-00175420": "confidentiality of the candidates", "W9cOZwARTkY-00751-00175421-00175668": "totally true and absolutely essential", "W9cOZwARTkY-00752-00175669-00175993": "but that doesn't mean that you recess to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00753-00175994-00176191": "like you know the darkened back room and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00754-00176192-00176455": "do the entire process you know out of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00755-00176456-00176812": "out of sight and I think that you know a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00756-00176813-00177004": "good example of that is combined Jewish", "W9cOZwARTkY-00757-00177005-00177268": "Philanthropies in Boston which was", "W9cOZwARTkY-00758-00177269-00177577": "running a very high-profile search a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00759-00177578-00177937": "very active community you know that a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00760-00177938-00178198": "lot of smart savvy people in the King to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00761-00178199-00178579": "be that have experience with you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00762-00178580-00178900": "hiring a managing high-level talent and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00763-00178901-00179053": "they could have easily sort of just", "W9cOZwARTkY-00764-00179054-00179341": "basically you know pulled pulled pulled", "W9cOZwARTkY-00765-00179342-00179485": "the curtain back and done it behind", "W9cOZwARTkY-00766-00179486-00179728": "closed doors but instead they you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00767-00179729-00179854": "they fostered this real spirit of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00768-00179855-00180004": "openness and they rent you know for", "W9cOZwARTkY-00769-00180005-00180439": "example they ran their own dedicated", "W9cOZwARTkY-00770-00180440-00180643": "website where they basically dated", "W9cOZwARTkY-00771-00180644-00180922": "updates on the search the to search", "W9cOZwARTkY-00772-00180923-00181207": "committee the to so the there's a whole", "W9cOZwARTkY-00773-00181208-00181408": "funny side story about how essentially", "W9cOZwARTkY-00774-00181409-00181552": "they've got two CEOs of billion-dollar", "W9cOZwARTkY-00775-00181553-00181744": "companies to basically run the search", "W9cOZwARTkY-00776-00181745-00181933": "which is pretty incredible but if they", "W9cOZwARTkY-00777-00181934-00182134": "had these two very high-profile people", "W9cOZwARTkY-00778-00182135-00182482": "era named good women yeah", "W9cOZwARTkY-00779-00182483-00182650": "women cheering good men yeah you're a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00780-00182651-00182983": "good man yeah CEO staples they had they", "W9cOZwARTkY-00781-00182984-00183210": "were running the search together and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00782-00183211-00183466": "Aaron basically had this open-door", "W9cOZwARTkY-00783-00183467-00183739": "policy he said I'll take a call from", "W9cOZwARTkY-00784-00183740-00183973": "anyone and he literally fielded hundreds", "W9cOZwARTkY-00785-00183974-00184237": "of calls with people and he took every", "W9cOZwARTkY-00786-00184238-00184408": "had a little book and took everyone's", "W9cOZwARTkY-00787-00184409-00184639": "recommendations they worked with a high", "W9cOZwARTkY-00788-00184640-00184819": "profile search consultant see Spencer", "W9cOZwARTkY-00789-00184820-00185422": "Stewart who sent out a survey to an", "W9cOZwARTkY-00790-00185423-00185683": "email list with over 10,000 people on it", "W9cOZwARTkY-00791-00185684-00186148": "as I understand it they ran", "W9cOZwARTkY-00792-00186149-00186493": "townhall focus groups around Boston with", "W9cOZwARTkY-00793-00186494-00186654": "various constituencies that were going", "W9cOZwARTkY-00794-00186655-00187003": "to be important and they you know they", "W9cOZwARTkY-00795-00187004-00187375": "kept a very close touch with you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00796-00187376-00187690": "their major seven figure donors now", "W9cOZwARTkY-00797-00187691-00187891": "there's kind of this open question of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00798-00187892-00188095": "what role donors should play in a search", "W9cOZwARTkY-00799-00188096-00188263": "process and you know that's something we", "W9cOZwARTkY-00800-00188264-00188413": "can explore in greater detail it's sort", "W9cOZwARTkY-00801-00188414-00188566": "of you know it's sort of unique to the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00802-00188567-00188815": "nonprofit world but I think in this", "W9cOZwARTkY-00803-00188816-00189118": "instance you know they handled it", "W9cOZwARTkY-00804-00189119-00189535": "incredibly well they had I think one or", "W9cOZwARTkY-00805-00189536-00189715": "two major donors on the search committee", "W9cOZwARTkY-00806-00189716-00189964": "but they you know their rule was if", "W9cOZwARTkY-00807-00189965-00190066": "you're gonna be on the search committee", "W9cOZwARTkY-00808-00190067-00190258": "as it generates because you have", "W9cOZwARTkY-00809-00190259-00190716": "experience hiring Tom Town um and then", "W9cOZwARTkY-00810-00190717-00190873": "for those that didn't for those that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00811-00190874-00191104": "they you know for those that they kept", "W9cOZwARTkY-00812-00191105-00191359": "off the search committee they've made", "W9cOZwARTkY-00813-00191360-00191512": "productive outreach to explain why to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00814-00191513-00191713": "explain that they wanted a diversity of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00815-00191714-00191875": "opinions and they already had a couple", "W9cOZwARTkY-00816-00191876-00192223": "major donors they explained how they", "W9cOZwARTkY-00817-00192224-00192478": "were you know doing outreach to all the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00818-00192479-00192676": "you know important constituencies and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00819-00192677-00192931": "then before the appointment was", "W9cOZwARTkY-00820-00192932-00193102": "announced they actually reached out to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00821-00193103-00193237": "all their seven-figure donors", "W9cOZwARTkY-00822-00193238-00193420": "essentially said you know here's who we", "W9cOZwARTkY-00823-00193421-00193603": "selected here's why here's why we think", "W9cOZwARTkY-00824-00193604-00193804": "it's going to be great and you know as a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00825-00193805-00193939": "courtesy we just wanted to give you a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00826-00193940-00194374": "heads up so you know but it wasn't just", "W9cOZwARTkY-00827-00194375-00194509": "the seven-figure donors right intimated", "W9cOZwARTkY-00828-00194510-00194728": "they you know if you were interested in", "W9cOZwARTkY-00829-00194729-00194950": "cjp search you had an abundance of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00830-00194951-00195364": "information and access to I mean I find", "W9cOZwARTkY-00831-00195365-00195484": "it difficult to get the CEO of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00832-00195485-00195631": "multi-billion dollar companies on the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00833-00195632-00195769": "phone but you know if you were", "W9cOZwARTkY-00834-00195770-00195928": "interested in their search at this point", "W9cOZwARTkY-00835-00195929-00196147": "you know you could have you could you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00836-00196148-00196276": "could have talked to her and I think", "W9cOZwARTkY-00837-00196277-00196447": "that's kind of you know incredible", "W9cOZwARTkY-00838-00196448-00196597": "display of openness that really I think", "W9cOZwARTkY-00839-00196598-00196912": "I think paid off yeah you know when the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00840-00196913-00197125": "search was completed yeah and we have a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00841-00197126-00197383": "question that just came in about any", "W9cOZwARTkY-00842-00197384-00197602": "best practices for how what when to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00843-00197603-00197779": "communicate with an organization's staff", "W9cOZwARTkY-00844-00197780-00197989": "and cjp is actually an interesting one", "W9cOZwARTkY-00845-00197990-00198139": "because didn't they have one of the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00846-00198140-00198469": "staff members on pasilla you know onto", "W9cOZwARTkY-00847-00198470-00198729": "the search committee mm-hmm which I", "W9cOZwARTkY-00848-00198730-00198886": "wouldn't actually I wouldn't actually", "W9cOZwARTkY-00849-00198887-00199270": "advise because if you're gonna have", "W9cOZwARTkY-00850-00199271-00199429": "confidential discussions about a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00851-00199430-00199499": "candidate's", "W9cOZwARTkY-00852-00199500-00199811": "for weakness maybe perhaps you offer the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00853-00199812-00200014": "role to your first choice they turn it", "W9cOZwARTkY-00854-00200015-00200198": "down you go to the second choice that's", "W9cOZwARTkY-00855-00200199-00200351": "not something that really I don't think", "W9cOZwARTkY-00856-00200352-00200510": "someone who works under that person", "W9cOZwARTkY-00857-00200511-00200750": "needs needs or should know I think their", "W9cOZwARTkY-00858-00200751-00200921": "minds the new executive as they come in", "W9cOZwARTkY-00859-00200922-00201110": "as they came in but in this instance", "W9cOZwARTkY-00860-00201111-00201257": "they felt that they felt they had", "W9cOZwARTkY-00861-00201258-00201569": "someone who could represent the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00862-00201570-00201683": "interests of the staff had no", "W9cOZwARTkY-00863-00201684-00201916": "aspirations for the CEO role themselves", "W9cOZwARTkY-00864-00201917-00202189": "and you know everyone said that you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00865-00202190-00202352": "including Spencer Stewart or you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00866-00202353-00202496": "well school than this and who I think at", "W9cOZwARTkY-00867-00202497-00202658": "the time advised them not to put her on", "W9cOZwARTkY-00868-00202659-00202847": "the search committee said that you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00869-00202848-00203093": "that worked out really well and I mean I", "W9cOZwARTkY-00870-00203094-00203276": "got that's a credit to the CEO that she", "W9cOZwARTkY-00871-00203277-00203402": "was able to handle that responsibility", "W9cOZwARTkY-00872-00203403-00203846": "as well um but in terms of you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00873-00203847-00204152": "staff I mean I think that like you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00874-00204153-00204320": "there's no there's no right answer I", "W9cOZwARTkY-00875-00204321-00204628": "think that you know probably the you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00876-00204629-00204994": "want to you want to undertake the sort", "W9cOZwARTkY-00877-00204996-00205346": "of fact-finding questioning that you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00878-00205346-00205564": "would for any important constituency so", "W9cOZwARTkY-00879-00205565-00205748": "you know you're asking questions such as", "W9cOZwARTkY-00880-00205748-00206011": "what are the qualities the new CEO", "W9cOZwARTkY-00881-00206012-00206260": "should have the old CEO didn't you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00882-00206261-00206477": "fast forward four or five years tell us", "W9cOZwARTkY-00883-00206478-00206644": "where you imagine this organization to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00884-00206646-00206873": "be what are some things about that you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00885-00206873-00207028": "know often just direct and their", "W9cOZwARTkY-00886-00207029-00207223": "director their question like what are", "W9cOZwARTkY-00887-00207225-00207380": "some things about the search that we", "W9cOZwARTkY-00888-00207381-00207578": "might not know that we should know you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00889-00207579-00207862": "know what one we not is there anything", "W9cOZwARTkY-00890-00207863-00208117": "that has been kind of kept from our view", "W9cOZwARTkY-00891-00208119-00208319": "by the incumbent CEO that we need to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00892-00208319-00208454": "know about you know you don't want any", "W9cOZwARTkY-00893-00208455-00208783": "blind spots as the search so early on", "W9cOZwARTkY-00894-00208784-00208969": "it's kind of a you know it's a one way", "W9cOZwARTkY-00895-00208971-00209287": "sort of listening I think once you've", "W9cOZwARTkY-00896-00209288-00209458": "all of the finalists should meet with", "W9cOZwARTkY-00897-00209459-00209576": "staff and I think they should be", "W9cOZwARTkY-00898-00209577-00209767": "introduced as finalists what I think it", "W9cOZwARTkY-00899-00209769-00209987": "should be part of their tour and I think", "W9cOZwARTkY-00900-00209988-00210142": "it's important that you let the staff", "W9cOZwARTkY-00901-00210144-00210298": "know that they're not interviewing the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00902-00210300-00210638": "candidate it's an opportunity to get to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00903-00210639-00210926": "know them etc and I you know I'm not", "W9cOZwARTkY-00904-00210927-00211331": "sure that you even asked for the staffs", "W9cOZwARTkY-00905-00211332-00211505": "assessments at that point I think", "W9cOZwARTkY-00906-00211506-00212008": "perhaps you asked for any red flags but", "W9cOZwARTkY-00907-00212009-00212279": "I think that you know that the the CEO", "W9cOZwARTkY-00908-00212280-00212489": "that the CEO finalist candidates will", "W9cOZwARTkY-00909-00212490-00212696": "want to meet the staff I want to see you", "W9cOZwARTkY-00910-00212696-00212864": "know the physical orientation", "W9cOZwARTkY-00911-00212865-00213004": "office though there's no way to really", "W9cOZwARTkY-00912-00213005-00213232": "kind of do that without sort of you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00913-00213233-00213382": "you can't pretend that they're like the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00914-00213383-00213539": "pizza delivery man right like these", "W9cOZwARTkY-00915-00213540-00213934": "before something generous or women's can", "W9cOZwARTkY-00916-00213935-00214357": "still every woman yeah so I hope that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00917-00214358-00214441": "answers that question", "W9cOZwARTkY-00918-00214442-00214648": "yeah and it sounds like more than", "W9cOZwARTkY-00919-00214650-00214780": "anything you treat them like an", "W9cOZwARTkY-00920-00214781-00215026": "important constituency like the others", "W9cOZwARTkY-00921-00215027-00215273": "so there is an attention and a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00922-00215273-00215452": "sensitivity to the fact that these folks", "W9cOZwARTkY-00923-00215453-00215635": "are going to get a new leader they're", "W9cOZwARTkY-00924-00215636-00215873": "going to need to be at least knowing", "W9cOZwARTkY-00925-00215873-00216067": "that that process is happening and some", "W9cOZwARTkY-00926-00216069-00216235": "of the details and a material depending", "W9cOZwARTkY-00927-00216236-00216502": "on gave me the process as it unfolds", "W9cOZwARTkY-00928-00216503-00216796": "over time yeah and and always always a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00929-00216798-00216994": "lot of art around that not just pure", "W9cOZwARTkY-00930-00216996-00217228": "science it looks like we have another", "W9cOZwARTkY-00931-00217229-00217523": "question that came in this is fun", "W9cOZwARTkY-00932-00217523-00217717": "common trends of hiring a new executive", "W9cOZwARTkY-00933-00217719-00217966": "and they leave within one to two years", "W9cOZwARTkY-00934-00217967-00218201": "would it be advisable to hire purely", "W9cOZwARTkY-00935-00218202-00218359": "interim executive director while the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00936-00218360-00218533": "rule is restructured also separate", "W9cOZwARTkY-00937-00218534-00218696": "questions about the trend of hiring CEO", "W9cOZwARTkY-00938-00218696-00218837": "talent from outside the nonprofit sector", "W9cOZwARTkY-00939-00218838-00219229": "alright so a lot here the this question", "W9cOZwARTkY-00940-00219230-00219437": "does go to one of the one of the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00941-00219438-00219769": "questions that I had in terms of part of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00942-00219771-00219875": "the part of the trend of these", "W9cOZwARTkY-00943-00219876-00220060": "seventy-five percent of CEOs turning", "W9cOZwARTkY-00944-00220061-00220388": "over they're taking over for for new", "W9cOZwARTkY-00945-00220389-00220567": "CEOs are going to be taking over for the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00946-00220569-00220759": "CEOs who've been there for decades so", "W9cOZwARTkY-00947-00220760-00220906": "again if we look at ruse if we look at", "W9cOZwARTkY-00948-00220907-00221134": "bear if we look at Abe Foxman at the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00949-00221135-00221305": "anti-defamation league and on and on and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00950-00221306-00221725": "on and what what there is a trend or", "W9cOZwARTkY-00951-00221726-00221956": "what we're not sure actually and this is", "W9cOZwARTkY-00952-00221957-00222112": "that but hopefully you can help us is", "W9cOZwARTkY-00953-00222113-00222448": "some of the time the the folks who the", "W9cOZwARTkY-00954-00222450-00222650": "new CEO who's taken over for that", "W9cOZwARTkY-00955-00222651-00222904": "individual who's been there for you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00956-00222905-00223077": "decades and and certainly a long tenure", "W9cOZwARTkY-00957-00223078-00223459": "do end up leaving within let's call it a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00958-00223460-00223664": "two-year window and there is sort of as", "W9cOZwARTkY-00959-00223665-00224039": "this churn of of CEOs I'm wondering if", "W9cOZwARTkY-00960-00224040-00224375": "that is something that you've seen in", "W9cOZwARTkY-00961-00224376-00224542": "our community and throughout if that is", "W9cOZwARTkY-00962-00224544-00224816": "something and what how we may be able to", "W9cOZwARTkY-00963-00224817-00224942": "mitigate that and I think the second", "W9cOZwARTkY-00964-00224942-00225242": "question of interim director might be", "W9cOZwARTkY-00965-00225242-00225598": "one of the ways in which we can mitigate", "W9cOZwARTkY-00966-00225600-00225779": "that fallout", "W9cOZwARTkY-00967-00225780-00225892": "yeah that's it so that's a great", "W9cOZwARTkY-00968-00225894-00226211": "question so and make sure that I answer", "W9cOZwARTkY-00969-00226212-00226853": "it so there is a sense often that after", "W9cOZwARTkY-00970-00226854-00227030": "a long-serving CEO you need sort of a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00971-00227031-00227417": "decompression chamber and so thinking of", "W9cOZwARTkY-00972-00227417-00227569": "it you know I don't want to call it I", "W9cOZwARTkY-00973-00227571-00227762": "like to think of an interim CEO I like", "W9cOZwARTkY-00974-00227763-00227927": "to think of that title I mean semantics", "W9cOZwARTkY-00975-00227928-00228059": "but I like to think of that title as", "W9cOZwARTkY-00976-00228060-00228263": "someone who comes in for like a period", "W9cOZwARTkY-00977-00228264-00228482": "of months to oversee like a succession", "W9cOZwARTkY-00978-00228483-00228673": "crisis during a search and perhaps a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00979-00228675-00228892": "transition CEO would be the true I would", "W9cOZwARTkY-00980-00228894-00229040": "prefer for someone who would come in and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00981-00229041-00229246": "help the organization get ready and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00982-00229248-00229433": "transition for its next long-term leader", "W9cOZwARTkY-00983-00229434-00229742": "that allows you often to bring in", "W9cOZwARTkY-00984-00229742-00230015": "someone of similar age and stature as", "W9cOZwARTkY-00985-00230016-00230342": "the outgoing CEO and you know someone", "W9cOZwARTkY-00986-00230342-00230687": "who perhaps has similarly you know has a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00987-00230688-00230864": "proven track record but just you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-00988-00230865-00231158": "isn't isn't in it for the long haul I", "W9cOZwARTkY-00989-00231159-00231473": "think that that can be a viable option", "W9cOZwARTkY-00990-00231473-00231644": "I think another instance where you might", "W9cOZwARTkY-00991-00231644-00231929": "think of a you know a tour of duty short", "W9cOZwARTkY-00992-00231930-00232160": "ten years for a turnaround you know I", "W9cOZwARTkY-00993-00232161-00232457": "saw that with the story of this JCC in", "W9cOZwARTkY-00994-00232458-00232676": "the Midwest and I don't know how long", "W9cOZwARTkY-00995-00232677-00232946": "the CEO will actually end up being in", "W9cOZwARTkY-00996-00232946-00233141": "place there but he was brought in for a", "W9cOZwARTkY-00997-00233142-00233539": "specific task which was a turnaround and", "W9cOZwARTkY-00998-00233540-00234005": "you know the CEO's that have turnaround", "W9cOZwARTkY-00999-00234006-00234167": "experience don't tend to be the type of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01000-00234167-00234326": "CEOs that want to stick around for a", "W9cOZwARTkY-01001-00234327-00234383": "couple days", "W9cOZwARTkY-01002-00234384-00234575": "Hal Lewis right it's furnace that was", "W9cOZwARTkY-01003-00234576-00234734": "yeah yeah that's right that's a good", "W9cOZwARTkY-01004-00234735-00234890": "point so how was there I think he ended", "W9cOZwARTkY-01005-00234891-00235102": "up in there I don't know like ten years", "W9cOZwARTkY-01006-00235103-00235508": "ten years yeah but he was brought in for", "W9cOZwARTkY-01007-00235509-00235673": "for a turnaround and when he felt that", "W9cOZwARTkY-01008-00235673-00235871": "hit that that you know he had sort of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01009-00235871-00236071": "righted the ship I mean when he took", "W9cOZwARTkY-01010-00236073-00236276": "over gosh it was in the wake of the 2008", "W9cOZwARTkY-01011-00236277-00236494": "crisis there was the organization it was", "W9cOZwARTkY-01012-00236496-00236627": "overextended with real estate", "W9cOZwARTkY-01013-00236628-00236869": "investments um mm-hmm", "W9cOZwARTkY-01014-00236869-00237059": "there was talk that it would go bankrupt", "W9cOZwARTkY-01015-00237060-00237317": "and he essentially you know righted the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01016-00237317-00237458": "ship and when he felt that he had", "W9cOZwARTkY-01017-00237459-00237707": "stabilized it was his time to turn it to", "W9cOZwARTkY-01018-00237708-00237983": "just a step aside so well I think that", "W9cOZwARTkY-01019-00237984-00238151": "uh you know I think that a lot of this", "W9cOZwARTkY-01020-00238152-00238454": "will be sorted through when it comes", "W9cOZwARTkY-01021-00238455-00238931": "time to do the strategic review which is", "W9cOZwARTkY-01022-00238932-00239129": "different planning but when you do", "W9cOZwARTkY-01023-00239130-00239411": "review when it comes time to just sort", "W9cOZwARTkY-01024-00239412-00239698": "of scope the role you'll start to figure", "W9cOZwARTkY-01025-00239700-00239848": "out what kind of executive are we", "W9cOZwARTkY-01026-00239850-00240500": "looking for now and you know you can", "W9cOZwARTkY-01027-00240501-00240623": "there were various tools for this you", "W9cOZwARTkY-01028-00240623-00240851": "can do kind of a SWOT analysis you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-01029-00240852-00241091": "one of the things that I you know one of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01030-00241092-00241238": "the things that I recommended in the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01031-00241239-00241442": "best practices guide that I think useful", "W9cOZwARTkY-01032-00241442-00241573": "is you need to ask these courageous", "W9cOZwARTkY-01033-00241575-00241867": "questions but should this organization", "W9cOZwARTkY-01034-00241869-00242063": "continue would we better serve the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01035-00242064-00242258": "community if we were to gift our you", "W9cOZwARTkY-01036-00242259-00242408": "know our services to another", "W9cOZwARTkY-01037-00242409-00242657": "organization and if it is going to", "W9cOZwARTkY-01038-00242658-00242858": "continue what is its unique value at", "W9cOZwARTkY-01039-00242859-00243296": "what we'll play I mean we get there and", "W9cOZwARTkY-01040-00243296-00243506": "you know when you start kind of dealing", "W9cOZwARTkY-01041-00243507-00243653": "with those questions maybe it starts to", "W9cOZwARTkY-01042-00243654-00243827": "kind of clarify in your mind what kind", "W9cOZwARTkY-01043-00243828-00244071": "of executive you're actually looking for", "W9cOZwARTkY-01044-00244073-00244519": "you know it's a it's a really great", "W9cOZwARTkY-01045-00244521-00244694": "point I'm sorry to interrupt but in some", "W9cOZwARTkY-01046-00244694-00245057": "ways this this question is is very is is", "W9cOZwARTkY-01047-00245058-00245384": "tied to the fact that we know that many", "W9cOZwARTkY-01048-00245385-00245654": "boards don't have conversations with", "W9cOZwARTkY-01049-00245655-00245834": "their CEO like you said in the beginning", "W9cOZwARTkY-01050-00245835-00246046": "of this of planning just planning it", "W9cOZwARTkY-01051-00246048-00246335": "goes to also annual evaluation only", "W9cOZwARTkY-01052-00246336-00246523": "fifty percent really of boards in", "W9cOZwARTkY-01053-00246525-00246662": "general nonprofit boards actually", "W9cOZwARTkY-01054-00246663-00246908": "annually evaluate the performance of the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01055-00246909-00247142": "CEO and so what ends up happening is", "W9cOZwARTkY-01056-00247142-00247400": "that they they do go into a CEO search", "W9cOZwARTkY-01057-00247401-00247625": "process with I will know it one will see", "W9cOZwARTkY-01058-00247626-00247988": "it kind of you know profile of which", "W9cOZwARTkY-01059-00247989-00248207": "also tends to favor men because they're", "W9cOZwARTkY-01060-00248208-00248392": "charismatic and are able to talk about", "W9cOZwARTkY-01061-00248394-00248671": "their their time so there is a there is", "W9cOZwARTkY-01062-00248673-00248900": "a contributing factor than this question", "W9cOZwARTkY-01063-00248901-00249092": "that there's always a question for me", "W9cOZwARTkY-01064-00249092-00249311": "around you know how did the organization", "W9cOZwARTkY-01065-00249312-00249491": "get this way in many ways it's because", "W9cOZwARTkY-01066-00249492-00249740": "there were there wasn't bad strategic", "W9cOZwARTkY-01067-00249741-00249923": "review process the courageous question", "W9cOZwARTkY-01068-00249923-00250082": "so like wait didn't want to be in five", "W9cOZwARTkY-01069-00250083-00250235": "years and therefore what's the profile", "W9cOZwARTkY-01070-00250236-00250448": "of the leader that we need in some ways", "W9cOZwARTkY-01071-00250448-00250553": "we saw that a little bit in the tough", "W9cOZwARTkY-01072-00250554-00250826": "pillow case right the profile of you", "W9cOZwARTkY-01073-00250827-00251036": "know do you need do you need a Jeff", "W9cOZwARTkY-01074-00251037-00251246": "summit who has been there in the role", "W9cOZwARTkY-01075-00251246-00251492": "for thirty years do we want somebody who", "W9cOZwARTkY-01076-00251492-00251825": "was in some ways that where Jeff was at", "W9cOZwARTkY-01077-00251826-00252098": "the beginning of tenure as CEO what does", "W9cOZwARTkY-01078-00252098-00252250": "the organization", "W9cOZwARTkY-01079-00252251-00252469": "mm-hmm yeah and there's no right answer", "W9cOZwARTkY-01080-00252469-00252669": "to that I mean I remember you know I", "W9cOZwARTkY-01081-00252671-00252865": "visited the JFK Museum which was outside", "W9cOZwARTkY-01082-00252866-00253092": "Boston and the Ark it's a beautiful", "W9cOZwARTkY-01083-00253094-00253267": "building and the architect for that was", "W9cOZwARTkY-01084-00253267-00253651": "selected by Jackie Onassis against you", "W9cOZwARTkY-01085-00253652-00253891": "know more experienced architects because", "W9cOZwARTkY-01086-00253892-00254110": "he got her you know he said you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-01087-00254111-00254281": "Jackie I feel like I'm on the verge of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01088-00254282-00254500": "my best work and you know and that", "W9cOZwARTkY-01089-00254501-00254665": "reminded her of you know her husband who", "W9cOZwARTkY-01090-00254666-00254857": "was herself himself a young presidents", "W9cOZwARTkY-01091-00254858-00255025": "in the sense of potential and getting", "W9cOZwARTkY-01092-00255026-00255196": "someone at the height of their powers in", "W9cOZwARTkY-01093-00255196-00255388": "their career not when they believed you", "W9cOZwARTkY-01094-00255389-00255763": "know summited but at the same time you", "W9cOZwARTkY-01095-00255764-00255919": "know it can be a shock for a young", "W9cOZwARTkY-01096-00255919-00256117": "executive to step in to to rip", "W9cOZwARTkY-01097-00256117-00256323": "immediately replace a long-serving", "W9cOZwARTkY-01098-00256323-00256626": "CEO and I think that that was that that", "W9cOZwARTkY-01099-00256627-00256876": "conversation was one that the Tufts", "W9cOZwARTkY-01100-00256877-00257107": "Hillel Board grappled with and", "W9cOZwARTkY-01101-00257108-00257292": "ultimately what they decided was that it", "W9cOZwARTkY-01102-00257294-00257469": "wasn't about ten year it wasn't about", "W9cOZwARTkY-01103-00257471-00257698": "ages about you know gravitas they", "W9cOZwARTkY-01104-00257698-00257878": "actually they needed someone who had the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01105-00257879-00258129": "same gravitas as the outgoing CEO and", "W9cOZwARTkY-01106-00258130-00258337": "you know I don't want to say that they", "W9cOZwARTkY-01107-00258338-00258559": "you know they picked like a young", "W9cOZwARTkY-01108-00258560-00258808": "replacement but you know you know I'd", "W9cOZwARTkY-01109-00258809-00258979": "say sort of mid-career kind of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01110-00258980-00259357": "replacement aalia's and but you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-01111-00259358-00259525": "with incredible scholarship behind him", "W9cOZwARTkY-01112-00259526-00259912": "etc etc so you know yeah there's no", "W9cOZwARTkY-01113-00259913-00260065": "right answer for the type of candidate", "W9cOZwARTkY-01114-00260066-00260223": "looking for there's also no right answer", "W9cOZwARTkY-01115-00260225-00260350": "as to whether your organization needs", "W9cOZwARTkY-01116-00260351-00260506": "some breathing space between two long", "W9cOZwARTkY-01117-00260507-00260721": "serving executives I don't I don't think", "W9cOZwARTkY-01118-00260723-00260959": "necessarily that having a transition CEO", "W9cOZwARTkY-01119-00260960-00261400": "is is a sign of weakness you know it can", "W9cOZwARTkY-01120-00261401-00261583": "be it can be a sign of poor planning but", "W9cOZwARTkY-01121-00261584-00261742": "doesn't need to be it's intentional", "W9cOZwARTkY-01122-00261742-00262030": "mm-hmm this goes also to the second part", "W9cOZwARTkY-01123-00262031-00262159": "of the question of you know there's", "W9cOZwARTkY-01124-00262160-00262528": "there is a in some cases a pattern I'm", "W9cOZwARTkY-01125-00262529-00262759": "not sure if it's necessarily a theme or", "W9cOZwARTkY-01126-00262760-00263149": "trend that we do end up hiring CEO", "W9cOZwARTkY-01127-00263150-00263344": "talent outside of the nonprofit space so", "W9cOZwARTkY-01128-00263345-00263571": "somehow that private sector corporate", "W9cOZwARTkY-01129-00263572-00263953": "experience the not nonprofit experience", "W9cOZwARTkY-01130-00263954-00264244": "is somehow the message that the rest of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01131-00264245-00264373": "the pipeline if you will in the field", "W9cOZwARTkY-01132-00264374-00264568": "gets is somehow that's of higher value", "W9cOZwARTkY-01133-00264569-00264781": "than what they're getting day in day out", "W9cOZwARTkY-01134-00264782-00265030": "and I'm wondering you know you the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01135-00265031-00265123": "majority of your time", "W9cOZwARTkY-01136-00265124-00265282": "honestly apart from I think this this", "W9cOZwARTkY-01137-00265283-00265410": "little project is", "W9cOZwARTkY-01138-00265411-00265588": "in the corporate sector is spent to the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01139-00265589-00265803": "private sector and I'm wondering what", "W9cOZwARTkY-01140-00265804-00266017": "what have you seen as it relates to", "W9cOZwARTkY-01141-00266018-00266272": "leadership development as it relates to", "W9cOZwARTkY-01142-00266273-00266491": "CEO succession in the corporate world", "W9cOZwARTkY-01143-00266492-00267000": "and how do we compare yeah that's a", "W9cOZwARTkY-01144-00267001-00267102": "great question", "W9cOZwARTkY-01145-00267103-00267375": "so let me address this this issue this", "W9cOZwARTkY-01146-00267376-00267565": "issue of is it advisable to hire people", "W9cOZwARTkY-01147-00267566-00267796": "from outside of them you know I think", "W9cOZwARTkY-01148-00267797-00267994": "that those people are more because in", "W9cOZwARTkY-01149-00267995-00268315": "some ways it's sort of you know surprise", "W9cOZwARTkY-01150-00268316-00268423": "I think those people end up being more", "W9cOZwARTkY-01151-00268424-00268596": "high-profile of all the six kind of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01152-00268597-00268878": "high-profile cases that we featured you", "W9cOZwARTkY-01153-00268879-00269014": "know not all of them were from within", "W9cOZwARTkY-01154-00269015-00269266": "the nonprofit sector um in fact for the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01155-00269267-00269398": "interviews that you know I know that", "W9cOZwARTkY-01156-00269399-00269577": "this is happening but it's not you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-01157-00269578-00269877": "it's it's not happening everywhere all", "W9cOZwARTkY-01158-00269878-00270289": "the time I the one person that I spoke", "W9cOZwARTkY-01159-00270290-00270472": "to in my research who was from the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01160-00270473-00270783": "for-profit world kind of made an", "W9cOZwARTkY-01161-00270784-00271039": "interesting warning which is like you", "W9cOZwARTkY-01162-00271040-00271251": "know the sense that maybe for-profit", "W9cOZwARTkY-01163-00271252-00271428": "executives will leave their high-powered", "W9cOZwARTkY-01164-00271429-00271680": "corporate job for a non-profit for", "W9cOZwARTkY-01165-00271681-00271950": "lifestyle reasons is insanity right like", "W9cOZwARTkY-01166-00271951-00272331": "a non-profit CEO is going is very much a", "W9cOZwARTkY-01167-00272332-00272580": "full-time job and very demanding and I", "W9cOZwARTkY-01168-00272581-00272842": "think that you know that needs to be", "W9cOZwARTkY-01169-00272843-00273102": "made clear to candidates who maybe feel", "W9cOZwARTkY-01170-00273103-00273231": "like they're looking they're moving to", "W9cOZwARTkY-01171-00273232-00273384": "nonprofit because they want to change a", "W9cOZwARTkY-01172-00273385-00273723": "pace or any of that constant that's just", "W9cOZwARTkY-01173-00273724-00273873": "the one inside I had from that one", "W9cOZwARTkY-01174-00273874-00274107": "interview you know spend an area where I", "W9cOZwARTkY-01175-00274108-00274246": "can't speak you know sort of more", "W9cOZwARTkY-01176-00274247-00274407": "authoritative Liana's this idea of like", "W9cOZwARTkY-01177-00274408-00274680": "the for-profit world and I gotta say", "W9cOZwARTkY-01178-00274681-00274872": "like you know there's no corporate", "W9cOZwARTkY-01179-00274873-00275076": "Savior here right like it you know if", "W9cOZwARTkY-01180-00275077-00275301": "this is something CEO secessions is not", "W9cOZwARTkY-01181-00275302-00275499": "something you know that's done", "W9cOZwARTkY-01182-00275500-00275685": "particularly well in the corporate arena", "W9cOZwARTkY-01183-00275686-00275859": "either you know that I think there is", "W9cOZwARTkY-01184-00275860-00276276": "this Stanford did the study in 2010 that", "W9cOZwARTkY-01185-00276277-00276609": "only found only 54% of boards for", "W9cOZwARTkY-01186-00276610-00276844": "grooming a specific successor and 40%", "W9cOZwARTkY-01187-00276845-00277072": "had no liable internal internal", "W9cOZwARTkY-01188-00277073-00277213": "candidate you can immediately replace", "W9cOZwARTkY-01189-00277214-00277677": "the CEO if the need arose right I think", "W9cOZwARTkY-01190-00277678-00277864": "part of what's happening is that you", "W9cOZwARTkY-01191-00277865-00278022": "know the trends that you described are", "W9cOZwARTkY-01192-00278023-00278331": "making it harder you know with job", "W9cOZwARTkY-01193-00278332-00278752": "hopping and shorter tenured", "W9cOZwARTkY-01194-00278753-00278929": "but this is at a moment in time right", "W9cOZwARTkY-01195-00278930-00279097": "when corporate secessions", "W9cOZwARTkY-01196-00279098-00279259": "are having happening more frequently", "W9cOZwARTkY-01197-00279260-00279589": "than our four right you have activist", "W9cOZwARTkY-01198-00279590-00279868": "investors pushing out CEOs you have baby", "W9cOZwARTkY-01199-00279869-00280039": "boomers themselves retiring so you've", "W9cOZwARTkY-01200-00280040-00280261": "got 15 percent or so of corporations", "W9cOZwARTkY-01201-00280262-00280489": "that need to replace their CEO but", "W9cOZwARTkY-01202-00280490-00280690": "they're you know but you know only sort", "W9cOZwARTkY-01203-00280691-00280900": "of a small majority that are actually", "W9cOZwARTkY-01204-00280901-00281275": "ready to do so that being said there are", "W9cOZwARTkY-01205-00281276-00281479": "you know there is research that shows", "W9cOZwARTkY-01206-00281480-00281725": "that those companies that do well the do", "W9cOZwARTkY-01207-00281726-00282160": "to handle this well creates a you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-01208-00282161-00282528": "an excessive amount of like value so", "W9cOZwARTkY-01209-00282529-00282775": "there was a study of you know these", "W9cOZwARTkY-01210-00282776-00283033": "so-called CEO factories such as GE e IBM", "W9cOZwARTkY-01211-00283034-00283249": "Procter and Gamble and it found the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01212-00283250-00283480": "stock market reacted positively when", "W9cOZwARTkY-01213-00283481-00283702": "CEOs that had come through these", "W9cOZwARTkY-01214-00283703-00283867": "leadership training programs were", "W9cOZwARTkY-01215-00283868-00284047": "appointed and they delivered superior", "W9cOZwARTkY-01216-00284048-00284179": "operating performance over the next", "W9cOZwARTkY-01217-00284180-00284584": "three years so there's there you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-01218-00284585-00284734": "there are companies that do well there", "W9cOZwARTkY-01219-00284735-00284875": "are companies that don't do it well and", "W9cOZwARTkY-01220-00284876-00285064": "let's also remember that the majority of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01221-00285065-00285310": "businesses in the for-profit sector are", "W9cOZwARTkY-01222-00285311-00285481": "family-owned didn't have a lot of the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01223-00285482-00285799": "same dysfunctions as you know as as the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01224-00285800-00285952": "most plaister kind of like community", "W9cOZwARTkY-01225-00285953-00286507": "nonprofit so you know my job essentially", "W9cOZwARTkY-01226-00286508-00286714": "as to is to function is to focus on", "W9cOZwARTkY-01227-00286715-00286873": "dysfunction and try and banish the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01228-00286874-00287077": "practice of bad management's so I do", "W9cOZwARTkY-01229-00287078-00287275": "focus on sort of like the things that", "W9cOZwARTkY-01230-00287276-00287494": "you know purport profit boards don't do", "W9cOZwARTkY-01231-00287495-00287670": "well but I can tell you you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-01232-00287671-00287857": "unfortunately one of those things tends", "W9cOZwARTkY-01233-00287858-00288091": "to be CEO succession reward for too busy", "W9cOZwARTkY-01234-00288092-00288253": "they're dealing with risk and dealing in", "W9cOZwARTkY-01235-00288254-00288451": "finance all kinds of other functions and", "W9cOZwARTkY-01236-00288452-00288784": "they don't put enough time aside for you", "W9cOZwARTkY-01237-00288785-00288940": "know Secession work even in the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01238-00288941-00289237": "for-profit even the way yeah in some", "W9cOZwARTkY-01239-00289238-00289393": "ways that's reassuring but that's like", "W9cOZwARTkY-01240-00289394-00289564": "you know everyone's not doing it well so", "W9cOZwARTkY-01241-00289565-00289714": "that's not a bar that we all want to", "W9cOZwARTkY-01242-00289715-00290014": "work toward but you bring up interesting", "W9cOZwARTkY-01243-00290015-00290140": "points in that we know in the Jewish", "W9cOZwARTkY-01244-00290141-00290329": "community also we have our own GES and", "W9cOZwARTkY-01245-00290330-00290503": "IBM's and whatnot you know that a lot of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01246-00290504-00290686": "the leadership Factory is run through", "W9cOZwARTkY-01247-00290687-00290917": "camps as an example this is where people", "W9cOZwARTkY-01248-00290918-00291205": "are actually able to get 360 degrees of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01249-00291206-00291373": "skill development of real you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-01250-00291374-00291739": "experiential kind of hands-on dirt under", "W9cOZwARTkY-01251-00291740-00291967": "the fingernails type of type of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01252-00291968-00292134": "experience which then led", "W9cOZwARTkY-01253-00292135-00292422": "to the the kind of skills that that can", "W9cOZwARTkY-01254-00292423-00292546": "be built upon when you when you're", "W9cOZwARTkY-01255-00292547-00292722": "thinking of senior leaders and certainly", "W9cOZwARTkY-01256-00292723-00292996": "CEOs really really interesting to think", "W9cOZwARTkY-01257-00292997-00293505": "about in that way yeah yeah yeah I guess", "W9cOZwARTkY-01258-00293506-00293625": "it goes back to that point we made with", "W9cOZwARTkY-01259-00293626-00293794": "been the Arkans that this is sort of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01260-00293795-00294108": "like the long-term payout for leadership", "W9cOZwARTkY-01261-00294109-00294603": "development programs episode guys so I'm", "W9cOZwARTkY-01262-00294604-00294796": "apologies I don't know this outside my", "W9cOZwARTkY-01263-00294797-00294994": "head but you guys run a leadership", "W9cOZwARTkY-01264-00294995-00295444": "development yes I do yeah yes we do four", "W9cOZwARTkY-01265-00295445-00295947": "new four new CEOs in fact we you can go", "W9cOZwARTkY-01266-00295948-00296119": "until one people have been asking", "W9cOZwARTkY-01267-00296120-00296263": "questions throughout so it's all good", "W9cOZwARTkY-01268-00296264-00296472": "thank you tomorrow I guess oh my", "W9cOZwARTkY-01269-00296473-00296671": "goodness it's it's 1253 on the East", "W9cOZwARTkY-01270-00296672-00297027": "Coast here um yes we do and and it's", "W9cOZwARTkY-01271-00297028-00297252": "really they're geared toward new CEOs so", "W9cOZwARTkY-01272-00297253-00297391": "CEO I've been in their world for two", "W9cOZwARTkY-01273-00297392-00297547": "years or less because there's such a", "W9cOZwARTkY-01274-00297548-00297817": "churn in the c-suite we know that no CEO", "W9cOZwARTkY-01275-00297818-00298008": "is on maintenance mode certainly not a", "W9cOZwARTkY-01276-00298009-00298219": "new CEO that has a steep learning curve", "W9cOZwARTkY-01277-00298220-00298465": "and so what we want is to ameliorate", "W9cOZwARTkY-01278-00298466-00298623": "some of the loneliness that happens just", "W9cOZwARTkY-01279-00298624-00298824": "by virtue of being in that top role so", "W9cOZwARTkY-01280-00298825-00298956": "it's a cohort based leadership", "W9cOZwARTkY-01281-00298957-00299151": "development program they get a coach", "W9cOZwARTkY-01282-00299152-00299344": "they get the kind of interventions that", "W9cOZwARTkY-01283-00299345-00299553": "ascended for creative leadership can can", "W9cOZwARTkY-01284-00299554-00299676": "really help with some of the adaptive", "W9cOZwARTkY-01285-00299677-00299821": "challenges that you're trying to lead", "W9cOZwARTkY-01286-00299822-00300190": "and we found as being incredibly helpful", "W9cOZwARTkY-01287-00300191-00300603": "from from a cohort and and support", "W9cOZwARTkY-01288-00300604-00300858": "perspective certainly from asking", "W9cOZwARTkY-01289-00300859-00301072": "questions about you know very huge", "W9cOZwARTkY-01290-00301073-00301380": "problems that they're trying to to to", "W9cOZwARTkY-01291-00301381-00301731": "change and the leadership of and how", "W9cOZwARTkY-01292-00301732-00301983": "that's manifested so those those cohort", "W9cOZwARTkY-01293-00301984-00302109": "base so how would you answer that", "W9cOZwARTkY-01294-00302110-00302247": "question about this you know this this", "W9cOZwARTkY-01295-00302248-00302467": "this concern that executives are leaving", "W9cOZwARTkY-01296-00302468-00302692": "within one or two years yeah well", "W9cOZwARTkY-01297-00302693-00302931": "honestly that's that's where we look at", "W9cOZwARTkY-01298-00302932-00303115": "okay well what were the bill of sale", "W9cOZwARTkY-01299-00303116-00303421": "that they were sold right and it all", "W9cOZwARTkY-01300-00303422-00303573": "goes back to the board I mean in many", "W9cOZwARTkY-01301-00303574-00303723": "many ways and the search committees I", "W9cOZwARTkY-01302-00303724-00303831": "mean it really goes back to the work", "W9cOZwARTkY-01303-00303832-00303997": "that we did I hate said it sound like an", "W9cOZwARTkY-01304-00303998-00304131": "infomercial something but it's it's true", "W9cOZwARTkY-01305-00304132-00304342": "there is there is a lack of planning", "W9cOZwARTkY-01306-00304343-00304513": "there's a lack of clarity about the kind", "W9cOZwARTkY-01307-00304514-00304837": "of leader that is needed a lot of times", "W9cOZwARTkY-01308-00304838-00305151": "charisma supersedes the kinds of skills", "W9cOZwARTkY-01309-00305152-00305365": "that are maybe less sexy but certainly", "W9cOZwARTkY-01310-00305366-00305497": "critical that are", "W9cOZwARTkY-01311-00305498-00305746": "organizations need and and also we know", "W9cOZwARTkY-01312-00305747-00305905": "that we're looking to some extent for", "W9cOZwARTkY-01313-00305906-00306130": "unicorns because people don't exist like", "W9cOZwARTkY-01314-00306131-00306409": "you can't do the the charisma and the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01315-00306410-00306585": "this and the that and and then be able", "W9cOZwARTkY-01316-00306586-00306697": "to like balance the books and also", "W9cOZwARTkY-01317-00306698-00306871": "manage the internal and then like do it", "W9cOZwARTkY-01318-00306872-00306994": "fart or at the beginning of everything", "W9cOZwARTkY-01319-00306995-00307162": "that's gonna you know bring tears to", "W9cOZwARTkY-01320-00307163-00307393": "people's eyes and that I think it's just", "W9cOZwARTkY-01321-00307394-00307672": "a the the kind of expectations that the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01322-00307673-00308010": "board has on the leader that being miss", "W9cOZwARTkY-01323-00308011-00308296": "mattress was heard by the new leader and", "W9cOZwARTkY-01324-00308297-00308494": "then how that's received by the actual", "W9cOZwARTkY-01325-00308495-00308749": "user and the team that's where it's just", "W9cOZwARTkY-01326-00308750-00308962": "that's where the breakdown is yeah I", "W9cOZwARTkY-01327-00308963-00309109": "mean there's a wonderful headline in an", "W9cOZwARTkY-01328-00309110-00309316": "article that we published in praise of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01329-00309317-00309550": "the incomplete leader and essentially", "W9cOZwARTkY-01330-00309551-00309829": "this idea that you know boards you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-01331-00309830-00309991": "should start thinking about team based", "W9cOZwARTkY-01332-00309992-00310213": "competency with the entire executive", "W9cOZwARTkY-01333-00310214-00310429": "suite up looking for kind of you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-01334-00310430-00310927": "the CEO Savior or the IDI Savior I you", "W9cOZwARTkY-01335-00310928-00311128": "know I think that you know I think that", "W9cOZwARTkY-01336-00311129-00311482": "might be you know an easier way to sort", "W9cOZwARTkY-01337-00311483-00311755": "of set CEOs up for success is to sort", "W9cOZwARTkY-01338-00311756-00311932": "you know when you're looking at scoping", "W9cOZwARTkY-01339-00311933-00312049": "the role you can start thinking about", "W9cOZwARTkY-01340-00312050-00312307": "the holistic executive suite that you", "W9cOZwARTkY-01341-00312308-00312694": "pass and how their talents matchup and", "W9cOZwARTkY-01342-00312695-00312898": "strengths and weaknesses yeah yeah", "W9cOZwARTkY-01343-00312899-00313129": "there's another question this is Thank", "W9cOZwARTkY-01344-00313130-00313303": "You Klarman Family Foundation this is a", "W9cOZwARTkY-01345-00313304-00313615": "very much apropos of our audience what", "W9cOZwARTkY-01346-00313616-00313801": "are some things that funders some non", "W9cOZwARTkY-01347-00313802-00313993": "board members but certainly folks who", "W9cOZwARTkY-01348-00313994-00314146": "wield influence power and certain", "W9cOZwARTkY-01349-00314147-00314443": "resources can do to help to be helpful", "W9cOZwARTkY-01350-00314444-00315085": "in succession yeah so this", "W9cOZwARTkY-01351-00315086-00315229": "back to the question we had about the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01352-00315230-00315823": "role of donors right and I can you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-01353-00315824-00315967": "I can imagine that it would be", "W9cOZwARTkY-01354-00315968-00316225": "frustrating for a foundation to see this", "W9cOZwARTkY-01355-00316226-00316516": "vacuum this competency vacuum and not", "W9cOZwARTkY-01356-00316517-00316720": "want to step in and sort of say okay", "W9cOZwARTkY-01357-00316721-00316867": "we're going to essentially you know run", "W9cOZwARTkY-01358-00316868-00317005": "the search for you or we're going to", "W9cOZwARTkY-01359-00317006-00317197": "stand up a consulting armed help with", "W9cOZwARTkY-01360-00317198-00317557": "the search but I think that you know I", "W9cOZwARTkY-01361-00317558-00318037": "don't think that that's the most", "W9cOZwARTkY-01362-00318038-00318232": "enlightened way to go about doing it I", "W9cOZwARTkY-01363-00318233-00318469": "think that like you know it's important", "W9cOZwARTkY-01364-00318470-00318868": "to understand as a large donor", "W9cOZwARTkY-01365-00318869-00319132": "organization you're one of many sort of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01366-00319133-00319297": "stakeholders and constituencies and", "W9cOZwARTkY-01367-00319298-00319564": "shouldn't dominate the process that", "W9cOZwARTkY-01368-00319565-00319753": "being said you know maybe maybe there's", "W9cOZwARTkY-01369-00319754-00319978": "opportunities to fund support from", "W9cOZwARTkY-01370-00319979-00320326": "consultants or search executives and you", "W9cOZwARTkY-01371-00320327-00320551": "know also I think that not to plug your", "W9cOZwARTkY-01372-00320552-00320683": "program but I think one of the things", "W9cOZwARTkY-01373-00320684-00320910": "we're hearing is the important like the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01374-00320911-00321196": "importance of entering earlier in the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01375-00321197-00321403": "funnel so talking to your organization's", "W9cOZwARTkY-01376-00321404-00321585": "about what are they doing to identify", "W9cOZwARTkY-01377-00321586-00321838": "successors how are they evaluating their", "W9cOZwARTkY-01378-00321839-00322090": "CEO how are they tying those evaluations", "W9cOZwARTkY-01379-00322091-00322387": "to succession planning and you know how", "W9cOZwARTkY-01380-00322388-00322555": "far how well do they know the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01381-00322556-00322744": "organization can they can they name two", "W9cOZwARTkY-01382-00322745-00322933": "or three people below the executive", "W9cOZwARTkY-01383-00322934-00323104": "director that have leadership potential", "W9cOZwARTkY-01384-00323105-00323392": "um you know and then funding some of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01385-00323393-00323599": "these cohort cohort groups for future", "W9cOZwARTkY-01386-00323600-00323815": "leaders I think you know that that pays", "W9cOZwARTkY-01387-00323816-00324094": "off as well and start building your your", "W9cOZwARTkY-01388-00324095-00324283": "bullpen and then you know we'll pull", "W9cOZwARTkY-01389-00324284-00324511": "your head out you can't find a reliever", "W9cOZwARTkY-01390-00324512-00324730": "yeah you bring up such a great point", "W9cOZwARTkY-01391-00324731-00324910": "which is questions like whenever funders", "W9cOZwARTkY-01392-00324911-00325110": "ask questions of organizations of course", "W9cOZwARTkY-01393-00325111-00325411": "we're gonna pay attention and so asking", "W9cOZwARTkY-01394-00325412-00325630": "some of those questions really sends a", "W9cOZwARTkY-01395-00325631-00325867": "subtle and not-so-subtle signal that", "W9cOZwARTkY-01396-00325868-00326137": "there's there's some there's an", "W9cOZwARTkY-01397-00326138-00326359": "importance to thinking ahead there's an", "W9cOZwARTkY-01398-00326360-00326647": "importance to wanting to know where the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01399-00326648-00326866": "organization is in planning so that it's", "W9cOZwARTkY-01400-00326867-00327121": "not an emergency and and potentially", "W9cOZwARTkY-01401-00327122-00327313": "there are some resources to help with", "W9cOZwARTkY-01402-00327314-00327631": "some of those plan that planning the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01403-00327632-00327856": "other thing that we hear honestly is is", "W9cOZwARTkY-01404-00327857-00328084": "when an organization goes through a CEO", "W9cOZwARTkY-01405-00328085-00328391": "transition and I'm not talking about the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01406-00328392-00328579": "more complicated ones and the ones that", "W9cOZwARTkY-01407-00328580-00328922": "are moving more in crisis that there", "W9cOZwARTkY-01408-00328923-00329114": "isn't this aspect from a funder", "W9cOZwARTkY-01409-00329115-00329300": "perspective of we'll wait and see what", "W9cOZwARTkY-01410-00329301-00329462": "we're gonna withhold our funding until", "W9cOZwARTkY-01411-00329463-00329618": "the new CEO comes in and then we're", "W9cOZwARTkY-01412-00329619-00329704": "gonna see if we're gonna continue", "W9cOZwARTkY-01413-00329705-00329972": "funding and that that is absolutely", "W9cOZwARTkY-01414-00329973-00330173": "something that's important to weigh in", "W9cOZwARTkY-01415-00330174-00330392": "as you know we think about different", "W9cOZwARTkY-01416-00330393-00330803": "investments in our field but the in some", "W9cOZwARTkY-01417-00330804-00330974": "ways there's an argument to be made for", "W9cOZwARTkY-01418-00330975-00331108": "an organization going through a CEO", "W9cOZwARTkY-01419-00331109-00331285": "transition for a funder to double down", "W9cOZwARTkY-01420-00331286-00331506": "during that time because it is such a", "W9cOZwARTkY-01421-00331507-00331807": "vulnerable and high-risk yet high reward", "W9cOZwARTkY-01422-00331808-00332230": "potential type of time so so not adding", "W9cOZwARTkY-01423-00332231-00332560": "to the potential risk by saying you know", "W9cOZwARTkY-01424-00332561-00332753": "we're we're we're we're gonna withhold", "W9cOZwARTkY-01425-00332754-00332972": "funding until you know we know who the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01426-00332973-00333259": "new jockey is yeah I mean this is not my", "W9cOZwARTkY-01427-00333260-00333476": "area of expertise but okay you know do", "W9cOZwARTkY-01428-00333477-00333679": "you you can do that without I mean you", "W9cOZwARTkY-01429-00333680-00333827": "can kind of like you don't need to", "W9cOZwARTkY-01430-00333828-00333968": "advertise that right you can kind of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01431-00333969-00334105": "think to yourself oh I'm not sure how", "W9cOZwARTkY-01432-00334106-00334250": "long our relationship is going to be", "W9cOZwARTkY-01433-00334251-00334427": "depending on where the leadership takes", "W9cOZwARTkY-01434-00334428-00334585": "this organization but you don't need to", "W9cOZwARTkY-01435-00334586-00334715": "like you know shove that in the board", "W9cOZwARTkY-01436-00334716-00334889": "space it's kind of right kind of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01437-00334890-00335093": "understood I would imagine like if our", "W9cOZwARTkY-01438-00335094-00335288": "new CEO blows up this organization we're", "W9cOZwARTkY-01439-00335289-00335438": "probably gonna funding is gonna try out", "W9cOZwARTkY-01440-00335439-00335615": "that's right that's right yeah different", "W9cOZwARTkY-01441-00335616-00335747": "different perspectives on that tomorrow", "W9cOZwARTkY-01442-00335748-00335951": "we're sorry we didn't have a transition", "W9cOZwARTkY-01443-00335952-00336757": "officially to Q&A participants for being", "W9cOZwARTkY-01444-00336758-00336926": "so actively involved during this session", "W9cOZwARTkY-01445-00336927-00337303": "and for rebellion I've been for being so", "W9cOZwARTkY-01446-00337304-00337574": "open to taking for taking them and going", "W9cOZwARTkY-01447-00337575-00337871": "where where the participants wanted to", "W9cOZwARTkY-01448-00337872-00338150": "go and so I wanted I know we're just out", "W9cOZwARTkY-01449-00338151-00338453": "of time but if if you have any last", "W9cOZwARTkY-01450-00338454-00338669": "words just to wrap up I knew we could go", "W9cOZwARTkY-01451-00338670-00338905": "on for hours more in this important", "W9cOZwARTkY-01452-00338906-00339125": "topic and I do want to want to reiterate", "W9cOZwARTkY-01453-00339126-00339304": "to everybody that they should read some", "W9cOZwARTkY-01454-00339305-00339467": "of the case studies or all of the key", "W9cOZwARTkY-01455-00339468-00339776": "studies I looked at it and you would", "W9cOZwARTkY-01456-00339777-00339938": "think it would be so dense and it is so", "W9cOZwARTkY-01457-00339939-00340163": "dense with data and information but is", "W9cOZwARTkY-01458-00340164-00340388": "such an easy read and I really feel like", "W9cOZwARTkY-01459-00340389-00340538": "everybody from wherever you're sitting", "W9cOZwARTkY-01460-00340539-00340838": "can gain can gain an understanding of", "W9cOZwARTkY-01461-00340839-00341008": "the search and also gain things for", "W9cOZwARTkY-01462-00341009-00341206": "themselves professionally of ways to", "W9cOZwARTkY-01463-00341207-00341329": "think so I wanted to give another", "W9cOZwARTkY-01464-00341330-00341588": "another unplug for that we're gonna have", "W9cOZwARTkY-01465-00341589-00341768": "it on the jf n website", "W9cOZwARTkY-01466-00341769-00342001": "and I'm sure you can also find it on", "W9cOZwARTkY-01467-00342002-00342256": "leading edges website so with that I", "W9cOZwARTkY-01468-00342257-00342523": "want to say thank you and then also give", "W9cOZwARTkY-01469-00342524-00342839": "you a chance to to have a quick closing", "W9cOZwARTkY-01470-00342840-00343378": "a few if you want any final words no I", "W9cOZwARTkY-01471-00343379-00343744": "think yeah I've been incredibly grateful", "W9cOZwARTkY-01472-00343745-00343906": "to collaborate with you and write for", "W9cOZwARTkY-01473-00343907-00344087": "this you know for this important", "W9cOZwARTkY-01474-00344088-00344465": "constituency and you know every crisis", "W9cOZwARTkY-01475-00344466-00344809": "is also an opportunity so you know I", "W9cOZwARTkY-01476-00344810-00345075": "think how the community handles this", "W9cOZwARTkY-01477-00345076-00345365": "what's being called a CEOs and the IDI", "W9cOZwARTkY-01478-00345366-00345544": "secession crisis in the next five or ten", "W9cOZwARTkY-01479-00345545-00345796": "years is going to have a outsized impact", "W9cOZwARTkY-01480-00345797-00346126": "on the health of and vibrancy of the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01481-00346127-00346343": "community and to be honest the country", "W9cOZwARTkY-01482-00346344-00346552": "in the world even the outsiders role the", "W9cOZwARTkY-01483-00346553-00346855": "Jews play in the health of all of that", "W9cOZwARTkY-01484-00346856-00347093": "so you know it's great to work on", "W9cOZwARTkY-01485-00347094-00347288": "something of such high impact and with", "W9cOZwARTkY-01486-00347289-00347524": "such talented people so thank you thank", "W9cOZwARTkY-01487-00347525-00347680": "you Evan and thank you Tamar and", "W9cOZwARTkY-01488-00347681-00347840": "everyone really and if there any", "W9cOZwARTkY-01489-00347841-00348089": "questions certainly looking forward to", "W9cOZwARTkY-01490-00348090-00348271": "answering any events really imagined and", "W9cOZwARTkY-01491-00348272-00348424": "wanting to keep the conversation going", "W9cOZwARTkY-01492-00348425-00348952": "I think you have to take thanks"}}, {"audio_id": "Wq2FG3mneoA", "text": {"Wq2FG3mneoA-00000-00000384-00000580": "hello everybody", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00001-00000581-00000778": "um from Dallas country", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00002-00000779-00000952": "um big thank you to Fusion for the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00003-00000953-00001097": "opportunity to have this conversation", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00004-00001098-00001199": "tonight", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00005-00001200-00001420": "so I understand that Fusion is made up", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00006-00001421-00001702": "of four parties so how many Pirates are", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00007-00001703-00001909": "there here if you want to whack your", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00008-00001910-00002165": "party affiliation if you have one into", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00009-00002166-00002333": "the chat I'd love to know exactly who", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00010-00002334-00002495": "I'm talking to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00011-00002496-00002692": "if you want no pressure", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00012-00002693-00002921": "um hi Pirates High science party um High", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00013-00002922-00003286": "secular party and Thai Boat planet", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00014-00003288-00003485": "um our end didn't tell you much about me", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00015-00003486-00003653": "so I will just give an introduction as", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00016-00003654-00003959": "to why I do what I do why I go out there", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00017-00003960-00004193": "in the big bad world and advocate for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00018-00004194-00004379": "nuclear energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00019-00004380-00004553": "so I'm actually the president of an", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00020-00004554-00004691": "organization called the Australian", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00021-00004692-00004931": "nuclear Association which is actually a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00022-00004932-00005111": "volunteer organization and it's made up", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00023-00005112-00005315": "of individuals with an interest in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00024-00005316-00005615": "nuclear topics including nuclear energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00025-00005616-00005836": "but my interest in nuclear Science and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00026-00005837-00006041": "Technology began when I was studying", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00027-00006042-00006293": "environmental engineering back in in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00028-00006294-00006539": "University I was doing environmental", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00029-00006540-00006719": "engineering and I needed an honors", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00030-00006720-00006959": "thesis topic so I thought", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00031-00006959-00007228": "why not why not nuclear waste disposal I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00032-00007229-00007409": "mean what about the waste right", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00033-00007409-00007570": "I found you here to be a little bit", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00034-00007572-00007703": "controversial and a little bit", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00035-00007704-00007948": "mysterious so I naturally wanted to know", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00036-00007950-00008189": "more so my interest in nuclear began", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00037-00008190-00008351": "when I was studying environmental", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00038-00008352-00008507": "engineering because I had an interest in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00039-00008508-00008783": "radioactive waste", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00040-00008784-00009017": "so my career took a bit of a detour and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00041-00009018-00009251": "then I worked for 14 and a half years at", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00042-00009252-00009533": "the Opel research reactor in Sydney", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00043-00009534-00009755": "I'm specializing mostly in nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00044-00009756-00010121": "safety and Licensing and regulation", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00045-00010122-00010283": "um before I join the Australian nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00046-00010284-00010469": "Association though I was a president of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00047-00010470-00010649": "another organization called women in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00048-00010650-00010901": "nuclear Australia and I guess by working", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00049-00010902-00011177": "at Australia's only nuclear reactor and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00050-00011178-00011356": "also being the president of wind it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00051-00011357-00011669": "allowed me to participate in a number of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00052-00011670-00011867": "International conferences that were", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00053-00011868-00012101": "often primarily focused on nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00054-00012102-00012274": "energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00055-00012275-00012491": "so there's surveys in the world that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00056-00012492-00012778": "show that the more people feel they know", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00057-00012779-00012988": "about nuclear energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00058-00012989-00013391": "the more they tend to support it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00059-00013391-00013643": "so I went from not knowing much about", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00060-00013644-00013877": "nuclear energy and being quite agnostic", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00061-00013878-00014069": "but curious", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00062-00014069-00014308": "um to knowing a lot and hence being well", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00063-00014309-00014555": "very supportive of it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00064-00014556-00014729": "so supportive enough that I'm now", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00065-00014730-00014908": "regularly talking to groups such as", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00066-00014909-00015143": "yourself Community uh groups political", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00067-00015144-00015358": "groups about nuclear energy there's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00068-00015359-00015575": "definitely more of an interest now and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00069-00015576-00015977": "people just want more information", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00070-00015978-00016157": "um but I just want you all to know just", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00071-00016158-00016253": "be aware", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00072-00016254-00016450": "um knowledge does tend to increase", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00073-00016451-00016721": "support so if you do stay you might find", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00074-00016722-00016943": "yourself in a position where your path", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00075-00016944-00017189": "to conversion has began if it already", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00076-00017190-00017447": "hasn't if you are not so keen on nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00077-00017448-00017621": "energy anyway", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00078-00017622-00017975": "anyway I kid around so to sum it up why", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00079-00017976-00018208": "do I advocate for nuclear energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00080-00018209-00018394": "because out of all the Technologies", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00081-00018395-00018658": "currently available to generate Nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00082-00018659-00018905": "So Sorry to generate energy I believe", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00083-00018906-00019097": "without with a fairly High degree of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00084-00019098-00019325": "confidence that nuclear energy has the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00085-00019326-00019769": "lowest overall impact on the environment", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00086-00019770-00019913": "um is it perfect", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00087-00019914-00020063": "no it's not", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00088-00020064-00020261": "uh but neither is any other energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00089-00020262-00020507": "source they all have their pros and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00090-00020508-00020758": "their cons", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00091-00020759-00020927": "um enough about me I think that's enough", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00092-00020928-00021029": "information", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00093-00021030-00021257": "um today I want to cover a few things uh", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00094-00021258-00021425": "but I'm most interested or more", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00095-00021426-00021605": "interested in hearing from you so most", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00096-00021606-00021839": "of today is really about hearing what", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00097-00021840-00022043": "you think about nuclear any areas of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00098-00022044-00022258": "concern you might have or even things", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00099-00022259-00022600": "that you like about it as well", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00100-00022601-00022841": "I've also got a question for Fusion as", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00101-00022842-00023141": "well which I'll put up in the Q a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00102-00023142-00023344": "um because I'm intrigued by one of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00103-00023345-00023639": "Fusion's policies I will cover three", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00104-00023640-00023927": "topics today so first one is what is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00105-00023928-00024058": "nuclear energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00106-00024059-00024244": "um don't worry I won't go too hard on", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00107-00024245-00024455": "the nuclear physics", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00108-00024456-00024628": "so the second thing I'll talk about is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00109-00024629-00024814": "the current nuclear situation in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00110-00024815-00025061": "Australia including the nuclear fuel", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00111-00025062-00025330": "cycle and also how nuclear energy came", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00112-00025331-00025558": "to be banned in Australia", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00113-00025559-00025750": "and lastly I'll give a summary of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00114-00025751-00025961": "nuclear energy around the world and some", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00115-00025962-00026237": "of the benefits of nuclear energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00116-00026238-00026495": "so after that we'll have some q a so I'm", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00117-00026495-00026645": "doing a bit of a backwards presentation", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00118-00026645-00026945": "I have no slides for my presentation but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00119-00026945-00027229": "I do have slides for the Q a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00120-00027230-00027785": "so first what is nuclear energy as I'm", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00121-00027786-00027995": "sure many of you are aware there are two", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00122-00027995-00028217": "different kinds of energy there's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00123-00028218-00028427": "fission and so nuclear energy there's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00124-00028427-00028655": "fission and fusion", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00125-00028656-00028985": "Fusion is the ultimate", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00126-00028986-00029320": "political party no sorry Fusion is the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00127-00029322-00029567": "ultimate energy source if you can crack", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00128-00029568-00029717": "it our days of worrying about energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00129-00029718-00029861": "will be over", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00130-00029862-00030083": "what we do have today though is nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00131-00030083-00030305": "fission and nuclear fission is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00132-00030306-00030574": "essentially all about the nucleus of an", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00133-00030575-00030868": "atom so the protons and the neutrons", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00134-00030869-00031108": "if you think back to your high school or", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00135-00031110-00031402": "university days even we learned back", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00136-00031404-00031589": "then that atoms are made up of protons", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00137-00031589-00031877": "neutrons and electrons forget about the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00138-00031877-00032074": "electrons nobody cares about these", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00139-00032075-00032285": "except for chemists okay in Phoenix", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00140-00032286-00032549": "world it's about protons and neutrons", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00141-00032550-00032693": "so these things are all held together", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00142-00032694-00033023": "tightly by a thing called the strong", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00143-00033024-00033251": "nuclear force so what nuclear energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00144-00033252-00033533": "does is it gets a neutron to hit these", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00145-00033534-00033851": "atoms to break break apart the nucleus", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00146-00033852-00034085": "of an atom and when this happens some of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00147-00034086-00034367": "the mass is converted into energy I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00148-00034368-00034696": "think um E equals MC squared", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00149-00034697-00034907": "so typically nuclear fission works by", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00150-00034908-00035249": "fissioning uranium atoms but you can use", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00151-00035250-00035501": "other kinds of atoms too", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00152-00035502-00035771": "when an atom such as uranium Does", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00153-00035772-00035999": "fission you get these things called", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00154-00036000-00036268": "fission products which are smaller atoms", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00155-00036269-00036401": "because you know you've got one atom", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00156-00036402-00036599": "it's now two atoms these are called", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00157-00036600-00036874": "fission products you also get two or", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00158-00036875-00037121": "three neutrons released one of those", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00159-00037122-00037385": "goes off and puts another atom and you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00160-00037386-00037618": "also get a release of energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00161-00037619-00037961": "so nuclear energy is the most dense form", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00162-00037962-00038183": "of energy available", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00163-00038184-00038465": "so if you had one kilogram of uranium", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00164-00038466-00038843": "235 which is a kind of uranium and you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00165-00038844-00039173": "could split every single atom in that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00166-00039174-00039467": "one kilogram of uranium you would get as", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00167-00039468-00039983": "much energy as 1.5 million kilograms of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00168-00039984-00040121": "coal", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00169-00040122-00040330": "so one kilogram if you're adding two", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00170-00040331-00040517": "through five equals one and a half", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00171-00040518-00040871": "million kilograms of coal", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00172-00040872-00041074": "so that's why I finished up this", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00173-00041075-00041243": "conversation on what nuclear energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00174-00041244-00041561": "actually is um the world has two basic", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00175-00041562-00041807": "types of nuclear reactors it has power", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00176-00041808-00042137": "reactors and it has research reactors so", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00177-00042138-00042335": "Australia has a research reactor called", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00178-00042336-00042557": "opal it's in Sydney", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00179-00042558-00042893": "so opal is designed so that you maximize", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00180-00042894-00043109": "the production of neutrons and then use", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00181-00043110-00043301": "the neutrons that come out of that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00182-00043302-00043535": "fission for various different processes", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00183-00043536-00043799": "but Power reactors are designed so that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00184-00043800-00043985": "you use the energy that comes out of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00185-00043986-00044105": "those fissions", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00186-00044106-00044417": "this energy is used to heat water which", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00187-00044418-00044668": "makes steam which turns turbines and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00188-00044669-00044921": "then electricity comes out the other end", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00189-00044922-00045149": "and people get to use it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00190-00045150-00045340": "so that's a little bit about what", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00191-00045341-00045652": "nuclear energy is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00192-00045653-00045773": "um the second thing I want to talk about", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00193-00045774-00046037": "is the uh the nuclear situation in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00194-00046038-00046174": "Australia", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00195-00046175-00046379": "so Australia's been operating research", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00196-00046380-00046805": "reactors since 1958 and we've had three", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00197-00046806-00047008": "in total", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00198-00047009-00047333": "say they were and are are probably used", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00199-00047334-00047579": "for nuclear medicine production for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00200-00047580-00047818": "Neutron science and for industrial", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00201-00047819-00047983": "purposes", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00202-00047984-00048167": "opal makes", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00203-00048168-00048496": "over half a million patient dosions of a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00204-00048497-00048695": "particular radioisotope called", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00205-00048696-00048995": "technetium 99 net M every single year", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00206-00048996-00049271": "and this is the isotope that's used in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00207-00049272-00049495": "about 80 percent of nuclear medicine", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00208-00049496-00049739": "procedures worldwide", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00209-00049740-00049949": "there has been some talk of using", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00210-00049950-00050333": "accelerators to make technician 99m but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00211-00050334-00050596": "today this method has not been used on a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00212-00050597-00050773": "commercial scale", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00213-00050774-00050980": "reactors have been preferred because", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00214-00050981-00051202": "they provide larger yields higher", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00215-00051203-00051479": "activities and they're more efficient", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00216-00051479-00051707": "um interestingly Canada is trying", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00217-00051708-00051892": "something in you they're going to use", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00218-00051894-00052066": "one of their nuclear power plants to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00219-00052067-00052330": "make technetium 99 which I think is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00220-00052332-00052432": "super cool", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00221-00052433-00052709": "but we do use things like accelerators", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00222-00052710-00052937": "and cyclotrons to make other nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00223-00052938-00053207": "medicine products", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00224-00053208-00053399": "so in Australia we use nuclear reactors", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00225-00053400-00053621": "for various things including saving", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00226-00053622-00053915": "people's lives Australia also uses", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00227-00053916-00054203": "radiological techniques across a wide", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00228-00054204-00054437": "range of applications including", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00229-00054438-00054588": "agriculture", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00230-00054589-00054844": "sterilization so we use radiation to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00231-00054845-00055007": "sterilize food", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00232-00055008-00055325": "and medical equipment and insects things", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00233-00055326-00055613": "like that we also use radiation to do", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00234-00055614-00055799": "Environmental Studies so we put", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00235-00055800-00056021": "radiation into the environment", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00236-00056022-00056297": "um to study different natural processes", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00237-00056298-00056476": "obviously if you've been to an airport", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00238-00056477-00056723": "you'll see they have x-ray machines that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00239-00056724-00056926": "is a use of radiation", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00240-00056927-00057191": "and the last use is for industry for a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00241-00057191-00057509": "whole variety of different things", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00242-00057510-00057809": "so what about uranium so uranium is the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00243-00057810-00058091": "main fuel used in in nuclear reactors", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00244-00058091-00058373": "so Australia has about a third of the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00245-00058374-00058607": "known uh resources of uranium in the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00246-00058608-00058685": "world", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00247-00058686-00058847": "but we're only the fourth largest", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00248-00058848-00058991": "producer", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00249-00058991-00059297": "so in a typical year we'll export the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00250-00059298-00059530": "same amount of uranium that we could use", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00251-00059532-00059854": "in Australia to completely power the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00252-00059855-00060149": "national energy Market", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00253-00060150-00060376": "but we have no nuclear energy in this", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00254-00060377-00060604": "country so we don't use any of the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00255-00060605-00060857": "uranium for power that we dig up", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00256-00060858-00061144": "so how much is this we export about five", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00257-00061145-00061373": "thousand to eight thousand tons of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00258-00061374-00061661": "uranium per year which isn't a lot when", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00259-00061662-00061799": "you think about it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00260-00061800-00062080": "I'll be exported as yellow cake I'm sure", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00261-00062082-00062273": "you've seen pictures of yellow barrels", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00262-00062274-00062500": "with the yellow powder in it so there's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00263-00062501-00062735": "actually laws in Australia that prevent", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00264-00062736-00062975": "us from value adding and turning that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00265-00062976-00063221": "yellow cake into nuclear fuel that we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00266-00063222-00063587": "can then sell to the world", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00267-00063588-00063844": "at the other end of the fuel cycle", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00268-00063845-00064129": "affectionately known as the back end", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00269-00064129-00064456": "Australia's policy is to reproduce sorry", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00270-00064457-00064615": "not reproduce", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00271-00064616-00064966": "reprocessed used nuclear fuel we recycle", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00272-00064967-00065237": "it so we get our use pure we send it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00273-00065238-00065506": "overseas and the country we send it to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00274-00065507-00065788": "takes out the useful ingredients", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00275-00065789-00066088": "um and send us back the waste materials", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00276-00066089-00066311": "so in terms of waste responsible there", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00277-00066312-00066575": "are many low-level disposal facilities", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00278-00066576-00066803": "operating around the world and we're", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00279-00066804-00066988": "also planning to build one in South", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00280-00066989-00067150": "Australia I'm sure you might have heard", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00281-00067151-00067319": "of that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00282-00067320-00067582": "so the reason why a waste disposal", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00283-00067583-00067769": "facility for low-level waste is so", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00284-00067770-00068032": "important is it ensures that the opal", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00285-00068033-00068249": "reactor and the people working at ansto", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00286-00068250-00068482": "can continue to make nuclear medicine", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00287-00068483-00068800": "and have adequate space available to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00288-00068801-00069071": "continue that production cycle", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00289-00069072-00069371": "it's also important I think that as", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00290-00069372-00069521": "Stone Oak will focus on what they're", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00291-00069522-00069713": "good at which is making nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00292-00069714-00070055": "um nuclear medicine and doing science", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00293-00070056-00070247": "um and putting their focus there um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00294-00070248-00070456": "instead of diverting a lot of resources", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00295-00070457-00070649": "towards Waste Management", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00296-00070650-00070835": "but I'm happy to talk about our waste", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00297-00070836-00071063": "with people later on", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00298-00071064-00071261": "uh you may or may not be aware of this", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00299-00071262-00071561": "but Australia is the only G20 nation", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00300-00071562-00071825": "that has a regulatory ban on nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00301-00071826-00071926": "energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00302-00071927-00072347": "I'm out of the G20 Nation 17 currently", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00303-00072348-00072694": "use nuclear energy and two have programs", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00304-00072695-00073121": "to establish nuclear energy programs", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00305-00073122-00073343": "um out of the Tweety then there's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00306-00073344-00073547": "Australia so we are a little in all the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00307-00073548-00073756": "way um the old one out when it comes to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00308-00073757-00073913": "the G20", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00309-00073914-00074219": "so how exactly did nuclear energy become", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00310-00074220-00074431": "banned in Australia", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00311-00074432-00074693": "I'll try to keep this short but back in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00312-00074694-00074975": "the 1990s it was identified that the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00313-00074976-00075167": "research reactor that was operating at", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00314-00075168-00075461": "the time it was called hifa was aging", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00315-00075462-00075731": "and multiple parties um including people", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00316-00075732-00075881": "like the nuclear medicine Community", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00317-00075882-00076181": "wanted it replaced", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00318-00076182-00076397": "um there was some political parties um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00319-00076398-00076637": "that weren't too keen on the idea of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00320-00076638-00076876": "building of Australia building another", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00321-00076877-00077069": "research reactor", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00322-00077070-00077303": "so the government at the time wanted to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00323-00077304-00077537": "modernize nuclear safety and radiation", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00324-00077538-00077788": "protection legislation and set up a new", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00325-00077789-00078071": "regulatory system with a new regulator", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00326-00078072-00078269": "so to do this there was a bit of a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00327-00078270-00078400": "compromise", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00328-00078401-00078635": "um on one side there was a smooth", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00329-00078636-00078791": "transition of the new laws through", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00330-00078792-00079085": "Parliament um to allow a new research", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00331-00079086-00079403": "reactor to be built in exchange for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00332-00079404-00079649": "regulatory bans on other nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00333-00079650-00079973": "activities including nuclear energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00334-00079974-00080176": "so nuclear energy wasn't banned for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00335-00080177-00080482": "technical reasons or safety reasons um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00336-00080483-00080621": "but fire", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00337-00080622-00080788": "I think it's called horse trading I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00338-00080789-00080944": "don't know too much about it horse", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00339-00080945-00081221": "trading uh with little or no Community", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00340-00081222-00081347": "input", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00341-00081348-00081515": "there might have been some", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00342-00081516-00081797": "um but there was no big debate as far as", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00343-00081798-00081947": "I'm aware", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00344-00081948-00082150": "um it was a different time in the 1990s", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00345-00082151-00082373": "though because Energy prices were low", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00346-00082374-00082673": "energy systems were reliable and climate", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00347-00082674-00082973": "change was a thing but it wasn't really", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00348-00082974-00083393": "a thing if you know what I mean", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00349-00083394-00083537": "um so just to finish off", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00350-00083538-00083694": "um the third thing I'll talk about today", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00351-00083695-00084011": "is nuclear energy in the world and some", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00352-00084012-00084256": "of the benefits of nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00353-00084257-00084431": "so what is the story of the nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00354-00084432-00084538": "energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00355-00084539-00084767": "so interests has definitely picked up", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00356-00084768-00085138": "since cop 26 which was the big climate", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00357-00085139-00085361": "change event in November last year in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00358-00085362-00085541": "Glasgow", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00359-00085542-00085859": "so cop 26 was the first noticeable big", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00360-00085860-00086159": "swing in support for nuclear energy in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00361-00086160-00086393": "possibly decades at least in Western", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00362-00086394-00086597": "countries", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00363-00086598-00086753": "um there's also been renewed interest", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00364-00086754-00086944": "this year due to the current energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00365-00086945-00087106": "crisis", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00366-00087107-00087311": "countries are really paying attention to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00367-00087312-00087593": "the fact that energy security is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00368-00087594-00087826": "important and that a lack of energy can", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00369-00087827-00088085": "have devastating economic and societal", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00370-00088086-00088271": "impacts", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00371-00088272-00088438": "combine this with the need for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00372-00088439-00088685": "sustainable climate change action and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00373-00088686-00088918": "nuclear power looks very attractive to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00374-00088919-00089050": "many countries", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00375-00089051-00089375": "but not all countries a handful are", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00376-00089376-00089675": "still trying to phase out nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00377-00089676-00089999": "um which overall isn't contributing um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00378-00090000-00090221": "to energy security the price of energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00379-00090222-00090641": "or to climate change goals", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00380-00090642-00090803": "um let's just go back for a second to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00381-00090804-00090994": "the countries that are pursuing more", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00382-00090995-00091271": "nuclear I'm just going to hand pick a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00383-00091272-00091475": "few of the country's announcements from", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00384-00091476-00091721": "the last 12 months or so", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00385-00091722-00092021": "so France announced their intention to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00386-00092022-00092279": "build new um nuclear power plants for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00387-00092280-00092531": "the first time in decades they want to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00388-00092532-00092905": "build about 6 to 14 reactors by 2050.", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00389-00092906-00093305": "the UK wants to generate around 25 of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00390-00093306-00093515": "the electricity from nuclear up from", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00391-00093516-00093761": "around 16 today", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00392-00093762-00094055": "now this might not sound like a lot but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00393-00094056-00094282": "all but one of their reactors are due to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00394-00094283-00094517": "retire by 2030.", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00395-00094518-00094888": "so this means more new builds", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00396-00094889-00095182": "Canada is a world leader in the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00397-00095183-00095399": "development and implementation of this", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00398-00095400-00095573": "particular kind of reactor called a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00399-00095574-00095735": "small modular reactor", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00400-00095736-00095938": "they have a strategic plan for the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00401-00095939-00096323": "rollout of smrs across four provinces", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00402-00096324-00096521": "um they also have a fleet of Highly", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00403-00096522-00096853": "reliable reactors called can-do reactors", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00404-00096854-00097181": "that have either had their life extended", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00405-00097182-00097409": "or are likely also or could have their", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00406-00097410-00097571": "life extended", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00407-00097572-00097918": "um by another 30 years", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00408-00097919-00098176": "the US is Awakening from its nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00409-00098177-00098411": "Slumber and is looking closely at", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00410-00098412-00098681": "possibilities for a coal to nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00411-00098682-00098962": "transition amongst other things", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00412-00098963-00099155": "um the Democrats in the US who were", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00413-00099156-00099400": "against nuclear energy for more than 40", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00414-00099401-00099755": "years are now supportive and who says a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00415-00099756-00099941": "political party can't or won't change", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00416-00099942-00100135": "their minds", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00417-00100136-00100456": "uh last but not least China plans to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00418-00100457-00100703": "build 150 nuclear reactors in the next", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00419-00100704-00100882": "15 years", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00420-00100883-00101261": "um if anyone can do this China can", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00421-00101262-00101441": "so there's actually other exciting", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00422-00101442-00101621": "things happening in other countries but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00423-00101622-00102065": "I think that's enough of that for now", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00424-00102066-00102268": "something else that might also interest", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00425-00102269-00102599": "the fusion party and everyone else here", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00426-00102600-00103049": "today is the EU taxonomy who's heard of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00427-00103050-00103499": "the EU taxonomy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00428-00103500-00103739": "a couple of one shake one hand up all", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00429-00103740-00103960": "right so if you haven't heard of the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00430-00103961-00104284": "European Union taxonomy it's a list of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00431-00104285-00104554": "economic activities that is aimed to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00432-00104555-00104801": "provide companies investors and policy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00433-00104802-00105034": "makers with appropriate definitions for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00434-00105035-00105313": "which activities can be considered", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00435-00105314-00105581": "environmentally sustainable", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00436-00105582-00105778": "so it's a bit of a guidance document for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00437-00105779-00105965": "which activities", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00438-00105966-00106163": "sort of hits those sort of environmental", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00439-00106164-00106408": "sustainable criteria and which ones", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00440-00106409-00106504": "don't", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00441-00106505-00106834": "so did nuclear energy make the list", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00442-00106835-00107057": "yes it did", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00443-00107058-00107284": "but it absolutely had to jump through", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00444-00107285-00107434": "hoops to get in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00445-00107435-00107663": "whereas other Technologies walked in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00446-00107664-00107947": "with um little or no questions asked", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00447-00107948-00108190": "unfortunately nuclear got mounted with", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00448-00108191-00108334": "gas", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00449-00108335-00108628": "in the same sort of vote so it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00450-00108629-00108808": "didn't make the decision-making process", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00451-00108809-00109021": "all that easy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00452-00109022-00109234": "so the last thing I'll do today is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00453-00109235-00109463": "finish off with a bit of a discussion on", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00454-00109464-00109660": "the answer to the question", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00455-00109661-00110045": "why nuclear why why even consider it in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00456-00110046-00110189": "Australia", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00457-00110190-00110410": "why exactly are so many other countries", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00458-00110411-00110645": "we're visiting nuclear making statements", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00459-00110646-00110927": "in support and putting in place systems", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00460-00110928-00111149": "to either build their first reactor or", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00461-00111150-00111316": "to build more to complement their", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00462-00111317-00111569": "existing fleets", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00463-00111570-00111754": "so why nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00464-00111755-00112157": "because it's been demonstrated to work", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00465-00112158-00112354": "that's the simple answer", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00466-00112355-00112625": "it's the lowest carbon generating Source", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00467-00112626-00112745": "we have", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00468-00112746-00113057": "it can decarbonize an electricity system", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00469-00113058-00113327": "it's the most reliable source of energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00470-00113328-00113602": "I can show you a few images later on um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00471-00113603-00113819": "to demonstrate this", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00472-00113820-00114047": "to your other reasons nuclear provides", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00473-00114048-00114275": "fantastic and easy security as I just", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00474-00114276-00114533": "said it has the highest capacity factor", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00475-00114533-00114736": "of all the Technologies and runs", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00476-00114738-00115019": "continuously for months or even years at", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00477-00115020-00115133": "a time", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00478-00115133-00115390": "unlike coal you can also store years", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00479-00115391-00115649": "worth of nuclear fuel at the site of the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00480-00115650-00115883": "nuclear plant", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00481-00115883-00116057": "um nuclear also contributes to a strong", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00482-00116058-00116386": "economy economy by providing uh stable", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00483-00116388-00116734": "and reliable electricity Supply", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00484-00116735-00117047": "um nuclear is also multi-use and by that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00485-00117048-00117352": "I mean it can be and it is used for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00486-00117353-00117539": "electricity generation", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00487-00117540-00117790": "heat production for industry and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00488-00117791-00118163": "Residential Heating and desalination and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00489-00118164-00118349": "one day it'll also play in the hydrogen", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00490-00118350-00118602": "production Market", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00491-00118603-00118925": "although nuclear costs are absolutely", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00492-00118926-00119147": "dominated by The Upfront Capital cost", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00493-00119148-00119423": "they have low operating costs and a very", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00494-00119424-00119669": "economical over the long term", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00495-00119670-00120052": "if deep decarbonization is your goal", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00496-00120053-00120328": "like you have a net zero Target that you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00497-00120329-00120478": "want to reach", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00498-00120479-00120689": "there's plenty of research that suggests", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00499-00120690-00120893": "that a combination of nuclear and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00500-00120894-00121060": "Renewables together", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00501-00121061-00121678": "will be the cheapest system to implement", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00502-00121679-00121978": "um also two more things nuclear has the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00503-00121979-00122260": "lowest overall environmental footprint I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00504-00122261-00122386": "can show you some data on this if", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00505-00122388-00122621": "anyone's interested but this includes", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00506-00122622-00122933": "very low land use low materials use", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00507-00122933-00123154": "and a waste stream that is fully", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00508-00123155-00123407": "accounted for and managed to very high", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00509-00123408-00123586": "regulatory standards", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00510-00123588-00123893": "unlike some other Technologies", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00511-00123894-00124133": "uh last but not least nuclear offers", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00512-00124133-00124445": "high-paying High skill jobs not for life", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00513-00124446-00124690": "but for Generations", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00514-00124691-00124889": "the kind of stable jobs where you don't", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00515-00124890-00125116": "have to move constantly or be forever", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00516-00125117-00125357": "looking for your next contract", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00517-00125358-00125689": "stable high paying and highly skills", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00518-00125690-00126095": "nuclear is a bit like a smorgasbord it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00519-00126096-00126316": "has something to offer everybody from", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00520-00126317-00126502": "climate change action to a strong", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00521-00126503-00126678": "economy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00522-00126679-00126977": "so at the end of the day people and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00523-00126978-00127223": "Industry just want access to Reliable", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00524-00127224-00127660": "electricity and energy at a decent price", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00525-00127661-00127877": "preferably clean", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00526-00127878-00128381": "nuclear can help Australia to get there", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00527-00128382-00128602": "okay thank you everybody that's my sales", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00528-00128603-00128819": "pitch for today", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00529-00128820-00128993": "but I absolutely want to see what some", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00530-00128994-00129143": "of these questions are and have a look", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00531-00129144-00129383": "at the comments and hopefully have some", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00532-00129383-00129725": "interactions so I'll pass over to Tyrone", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00533-00129726-00129886": "great thank you so much for that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00534-00129888-00130049": "presentation Joe and sorry for not", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00535-00130050-00130295": "introducing you appropriately earlier", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00536-00130296-00130516": "you did a really good job", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00537-00130517-00130697": "um all right so we do have some", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00538-00130698-00130871": "questions that I have copied across from", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00539-00130872-00131140": "the chat uh but uh Joe would really love", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00540-00131141-00131452": "to hear from you so if you I'm going to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00541-00131453-00131687": "allow people to unmute themselves but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00542-00131688-00131927": "please don't all jump in at once uh if", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00543-00131928-00132216": "you can either put your name in the chat", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00544-00132217-00132502": "uh or down the bottom you can raise your", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00545-00132503-00132737": "hands via reactions", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00546-00132738-00132923": "um and I will call your name and then", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00547-00132924-00133097": "we'll get to you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00548-00133098-00133516": "um all right so uh I will just ask one", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00549-00133517-00133709": "of the questions that was put forward in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00550-00133710-00133973": "the chat so this comes from Nicholas he", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00551-00133974-00134111": "says", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00552-00134112-00134309": "um energy Minister Chris Bowen has", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00553-00134310-00134483": "frequently claimed during question time", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00554-00134484-00134645": "that nuclear energy is the most", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00555-00134646-00134921": "expensive form of energy and cites the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00556-00134922-00135173": "csiro is backing him up on this how has", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00557-00135174-00135514": "he arrived at this conclusion", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00558-00135515-00135785": "okay so for anyone who's not familiar", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00559-00135786-00136013": "with the CSI report they put out a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00560-00136014-00136181": "report every year called the Gen cost", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00561-00136182-00136385": "report", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00562-00136386-00136595": "um not an expert on this report but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00563-00136596-00136775": "basically it does look at the I think", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00564-00136776-00136973": "called the levelized cost of electricity", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00565-00136974-00137245": "so what is the cost of one technology", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00566-00137246-00137543": "compared to another based on various", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00567-00137544-00137789": "assumptions so in the general cost", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00568-00137790-00138011": "report there is a cost per nuclear in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00569-00138012-00138251": "there that prices nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00570-00138252-00138539": "with a significantly higher levelized", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00571-00138540-00138769": "cost of electricity compared to other", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00572-00138770-00138983": "Technologies other low-carbon", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00573-00138984-00139090": "Technologies", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00574-00139091-00139297": "foreign", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00575-00139298-00139528": "with the Gen cost report from my", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00576-00139529-00139751": "perspective is I understand that the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00577-00139752-00139925": "work on the nucleus pricing was", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00578-00139926-00140159": "subcontracted from csiro to another", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00579-00140160-00140404": "party and for me there isn't a clear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00580-00140405-00140633": "transparent explanation in the Gen cross", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00581-00140634-00140831": "report as to how they arrived at their", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00582-00140832-00141101": "number how did you get to that number of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00583-00141102-00141395": "a nuclear and there's been quite a bit", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00584-00141396-00141695": "of debate and questioning from people", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00585-00141696-00141887": "who know a bit about nuclear to try to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00586-00141888-00142163": "get more information on that and to try", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00587-00142164-00142487": "to understand why a significantly higher", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00588-00142488-00142847": "number has been used for the LCD or lcoe", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00589-00142848-00142987": "for nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00590-00142988-00143254": "compared to reports out of other", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00591-00143255-00143537": "countries for example so I think what we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00592-00143538-00143789": "see at the moment is a environment", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00593-00143790-00144035": "Minister who's putting a fair bit of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00594-00144036-00144257": "confidence in a single report that is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00595-00144258-00144569": "heavily disputed in its numbers", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00596-00144570-00144863": "the thing is though what I I personally", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00597-00144864-00145054": "think Australia needs to do is look", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00598-00145055-00145378": "forward to whether it's 2050 or 2100 at", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00599-00145379-00145643": "some point and say if we truly want to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00600-00145644-00146014": "be Net Zero what systems do we need", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00601-00146015-00146243": "can you have a hundred percent", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00602-00146244-00146452": "um solar system", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00603-00146453-00146704": "with a lot of backup and a lot of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00604-00146705-00146921": "transmission lines is that is that the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00605-00146922-00147125": "ultimate cheapest most efficient and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00606-00147126-00147359": "effective system", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00607-00147360-00147713": "um and if it is then okay demonstrate it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00608-00147714-00147959": "if it isn't what combinations of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00609-00147960-00148223": "Technologies can be used together", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00610-00148224-00148409": "put them up for the cheapest most", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00611-00148410-00148619": "effective most decarbonized system that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00612-00148620-00148835": "we can come up with so there's some", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00613-00148836-00149009": "great studies out of them but out of the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00614-00149010-00149297": "MIT over in the US that show pretty", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00615-00149298-00149447": "clearly that if you want to minimize", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00616-00149448-00149663": "your cost of decarbonization a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00617-00149664-00149837": "combination of Renewables and nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00618-00149838-00150101": "together will give the overall system", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00619-00150102-00150299": "cost", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00620-00150300-00150604": "so even if solar for example or wind has", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00621-00150605-00150851": "a lower levelized cost of electricity in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00622-00150852-00151128": "the csiro gender cost report", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00623-00151129-00151385": "lcoa doesn't take into account any other", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00624-00151386-00151619": "system costs which can include things", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00625-00151620-00151907": "like Transmissions so we've already got", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00626-00151908-00152099": "the government talking about tens of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00627-00152100-00152327": "billions of dollars investment in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00628-00152328-00152489": "transition in transmission lines to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00629-00152490-00152675": "enable these Union these renewable", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00630-00152676-00152825": "Technologies", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00631-00152826-00153107": "that's okay to to put in more", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00632-00153108-00153311": "transmission lines but who's paying for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00633-00153312-00153521": "it it's the the taxpayers of Australia", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00634-00153522-00153623": "who are paying for those transmission", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00635-00153624-00153989": "lines it isn't included in the cost of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00636-00153990-00154349": "the lcoes for things like wind and solar", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00637-00154350-00154487": "you clear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00638-00154488-00154654": "a lot of work in the US looking at", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00639-00154655-00154816": "whether they can take their existing", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00640-00154817-00154997": "call sites and transition them to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00641-00154998-00155201": "nuclear why would you do that because", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00642-00155202-00155345": "your transmission lines are already", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00643-00155346-00155597": "there you're cooling intakes are there", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00644-00155598-00155776": "so much of the infrastructure can be", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00645-00155777-00155926": "reused", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00646-00155927-00156143": "so that was quite a long answer and I do", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00647-00156144-00156540": "apologize that but in summary", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00648-00156541-00156845": "lcoe not the best indicator of total", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00649-00156846-00157019": "system costs what everything's going to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00650-00157020-00157295": "cost you and plenty of other countries", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00651-00157296-00157481": "are looking at a nuclear and thinking", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00652-00157482-00157666": "it's economical and I'm not quite", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00653-00157667-00157883": "convinced yet that Australia is somehow", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00654-00157884-00158093": "different to other countries but I'm", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00655-00158094-00158333": "open to being convinced so please", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00656-00158334-00158495": "convince me", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00657-00158496-00158764": "great thank you so much Joe uh we've got", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00658-00158765-00158890": "a couple of people with their hands up", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00659-00158891-00159299": "I'll ask Michael mountainy if he would", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00660-00159300-00159593": "like to speak okay I'm going to copy a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00661-00159594-00159899": "link into the um into the chat I don't", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00662-00159900-00159989": "know if you're going to follow it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00663-00159990-00160240": "quickly I'll try", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00664-00160241-00160501": "um to cover this one then my question is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00665-00160502-00160811": "I'm just kind of Devil's Advocate in the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00666-00160812-00160913": "sense", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00667-00160914-00161363": "if nuclear energy is so straightforward", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00668-00161364-00161657": "and without any complications why do we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00669-00161658-00162047": "have facilities such as the Swedish", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00670-00162048-00162347": "waste disposal facility uh that's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00671-00162348-00162563": "described in that link that I've just", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00672-00162564-00162797": "copied into the chat there it does seem", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00673-00162798-00163073": "that disposal of waste is a big issue", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00674-00163074-00163295": "now I know that Australia isn't in quite", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00675-00163296-00163433": "a good position there and then we have", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00676-00163434-00163811": "large tracts of pretty much unused and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00677-00163812-00164116": "unusable territory where we could bury", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00678-00164117-00164266": "this stuff", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00679-00164267-00164513": "um but you can't you can't just keep", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00680-00164514-00164716": "burying it indefinitely can you it's a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00681-00164717-00165064": "way of reusing it or reducing it or are", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00682-00165065-00165449": "these huge elaborate Disposal Systems", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00683-00165450-00165814": "just actually unnecessary", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00684-00165815-00166175": "that's a fantastic question thank you so", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00685-00166176-00166349": "much Michael um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00686-00166350-00166613": "I did a whole Ted X talk on nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00687-00166614-00166925": "waste so I'll get time around if you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00688-00166926-00167045": "don't mind Tyrone if you've got a second", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00689-00167046-00167249": "to pop a link into the chat for anyone", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00690-00167250-00167411": "who's interested", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00691-00167412-00167657": "uh so you're right Sweden is probably", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00692-00167658-00167939": "the second country in the world in terms", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00693-00167940-00168149": "of their their progress towards setting", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00694-00168150-00168347": "up what's known as a deep underground", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00695-00168348-00168664": "geological disposal facility or", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00696-00168665-00168899": "repository finland's actually a little", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00697-00168900-00169114": "bit further ahead and they're expected", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00698-00169115-00169295": "to start putting their used nuclear fuel", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00699-00169296-00169690": "underground as early as 2025.", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00700-00169691-00169966": "so the reality is that scientists of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00701-00169967-00170207": "Engineers have known for decades what to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00702-00170208-00170525": "do with nuclear waste and when I say", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00703-00170526-00170735": "nuclear waste I'm referring specifically", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00704-00170736-00170969": "to use nuclear fuel because that's what", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00705-00170970-00171143": "most people are concerned about when", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00706-00171144-00171323": "they say what about the waste", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00707-00171324-00171587": "societies and Engineers have known", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00708-00171588-00171863": "the two routes that you can take with", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00709-00171864-00172139": "this waste I think Sweden is going down", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00710-00172140-00172414": "the route of sticking it Underground", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00711-00172415-00172702": "which is one option it's what other", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00712-00172703-00172926": "countries including Germany for instance", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00713-00172927-00173164": "currently do with other toxic and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00714-00173165-00173314": "hazardous wastes they put them", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00715-00173315-00173561": "underground because you can put things", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00716-00173562-00173776": "underground in in geologically stable", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00717-00173777-00173945": "areas and it's not going to go anywhere", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00718-00173946-00174166": "for the amount of time that it takes for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00719-00174167-00174431": "it to become no longer a hazard", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00720-00174432-00174647": "the other option if you don't want to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00721-00174648-00175007": "bury it is to do a recycle on it you can", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00722-00175008-00175187": "actually if you do a full recycle of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00723-00175188-00175361": "nuclear waste you can reduce how long", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00724-00175362-00175678": "that waste stays hazardous four from you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00725-00175679-00175823": "know potentially tens of thousands of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00726-00175824-00176285": "years so sort of less than 500 years", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00727-00176286-00176507": "but in this case you still need probably", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00728-00176508-00176657": "to put it underground for five years", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00729-00176658-00176831": "because that is the best place it's the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00730-00176832-00177059": "lowest that the place with the very very", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00731-00177060-00177226": "lowest likelihood that's ever going to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00732-00177227-00177466": "come in contact with people or the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00733-00177467-00177731": "environment and do harm", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00734-00177732-00177971": "so either way whether you take your used", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00735-00177972-00178169": "Fuel and put it straight underground", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00736-00178170-00178451": "like uh Finland and Sweden are planning", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00737-00178452-00178678": "on doing or whether you recycle it out", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00738-00178679-00178866": "of that everything that you possibly can", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00739-00178867-00179063": "you probably still need to put it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00740-00179064-00179266": "underground for a period of time but the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00741-00179267-00179483": "the period of time is no longer you know", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00742-00179484-00179651": "tens of thousands of years it is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00743-00179652-00179873": "literally hundreds of years is the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00744-00179874-00180076": "difference between the two things", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00745-00180077-00180371": "so technically know how to do it it's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00746-00180372-00180587": "always a political game though", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00747-00180588-00180869": "the reason that Finland and Sweden have", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00748-00180870-00181054": "been able to actually pick sites is they", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00749-00181055-00181228": "had good Community Support", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00750-00181229-00181414": "that people understand they've put their", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00751-00181415-00181781": "hands up their volunteered sites and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00752-00181782-00182063": "they've been successful", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00753-00182064-00182273": "great thank you so much Joe we will get", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00754-00182274-00182393": "to the questions that have been put in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00755-00182394-00182543": "the chat I'm just mindful that we have", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00756-00182544-00182716": "people with their hands up uh we don't", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00757-00182717-00182969": "have a name it is just iPhone so iPhone", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00758-00182970-00183209": "please ask your question", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00759-00183210-00183478": "um hi iPhone how you going sorry it's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00760-00183479-00183731": "Jonathan can you hear me absolutely yes", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00761-00183732-00184001": "yeah uh thanks for the talk Joe and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00762-00184002-00184337": "thanks for your um earlier uh TED Talks", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00763-00184338-00184493": "which I've listened to and they're very", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00764-00184494-00184643": "good", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00765-00184644-00184954": "um I I just I recently put my head up", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00766-00184955-00185219": "sort of to ask the economic question uh", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00767-00185220-00185464": "just a quick further thought on that I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00768-00185465-00185609": "reckon just in light of the current", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00769-00185610-00185735": "debate that's starting to happen in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00770-00185736-00185938": "Australia which is good to see I reckon", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00771-00185939-00186107": "the easiest response we should make at", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00772-00186108-00186275": "this stage is just", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00773-00186276-00186454": "um make it legal and let's see if", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00774-00186455-00186688": "nuclear can get the cost economic you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00775-00186689-00186916": "know let's let's just you know why not", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00776-00186917-00187240": "just make it legal and um you know and I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00777-00187241-00187361": "think that's a good response at this", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00778-00187362-00187552": "stage to the elbows and so forth who say", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00779-00187553-00187721": "oh it's too expensive or it can't work", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00780-00187722-00187913": "it's just like well let's just see if", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00781-00187914-00188075": "the industry can make it work and I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00782-00188076-00188338": "think there will be a sort of um I think", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00783-00188339-00188519": "there needs to be a bit of a process", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00784-00188520-00188723": "there because countries like Australia", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00785-00188724-00188843": "and other countries in the west haven't", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00786-00188844-00188999": "done nuclear for a while so there's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00787-00189000-00189245": "going to be a learning curve I think but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00788-00189246-00189481": "um but yeah", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00789-00189482-00189671": "essentially right Michael so you're", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00790-00189672-00189875": "absolutely right um as I kept saying to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00791-00189876-00190097": "lots of people we're moving a ban on", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00792-00190098-00190271": "nuclear energy is not an automatically", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00793-00190272-00190463": "an automatic green light to building", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00794-00190464-00190757": "nuclear power stations yeah it's just an", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00795-00190758-00190961": "indication that Australia is now open to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00796-00190962-00191111": "business", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00797-00191112-00191297": "um I've got friends who work for SMR", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00798-00191298-00191578": "vendors overseas who don't even really", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00799-00191579-00191831": "consider Australia because why are they", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00800-00191832-00192011": "even going to sort of waste their", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00801-00192012-00192190": "resources trying to come and talk to us", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00802-00192191-00192293": "about", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00803-00192294-00192419": "um about their technology and what it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00804-00192420-00192563": "could do for our country when they have", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00805-00192564-00192749": "customers in other countries putting", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00806-00192750-00193001": "their hands up to order these things", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00807-00193002-00193295": "yeah and just a quick question", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00808-00193296-00193690": "um any thoughts on uh how we can I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00809-00193691-00193835": "suppose start to persuade the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00810-00193836-00193973": "progressive side of politics but I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00811-00193974-00194183": "suppose this this zoomcast is maybe", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00812-00194184-00194375": "starting that Journey but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00813-00194376-00194566": "um yeah that's as I say the main barrier", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00814-00194567-00194771": "I mean we've seen Dutton sort of wanting", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00815-00194772-00194951": "to start a conversation and it seems", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00816-00194952-00195107": "conservative for various reasons have", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00817-00195108-00195328": "sort of been on the nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00818-00195329-00195604": "you know pro pro cab for a while but um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00819-00195605-00195778": "Progressive there's a big roadblock", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00820-00195779-00196019": "there and um I mean it's maybe some", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00821-00196020-00196181": "cracks are starting to open it with the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00822-00196182-00196361": "South Australian Premier", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00823-00196362-00196487": "um coming out a couple of days ago", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00824-00196488-00196637": "saying he wants a conversations that's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00825-00196638-00196816": "really positive but yeah just any", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00826-00196817-00197123": "thoughts on how we can start you know", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00827-00197124-00197440": "um and if you see any any hope or any um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00828-00197441-00197825": "positive signs in that direction", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00829-00197826-00197981": "yes in my talk I mentioned a little bit", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00830-00197982-00198137": "that the Democrats in the US they", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00831-00198138-00198388": "changed their position up to being not", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00832-00198389-00198587": "not necessarily for one anti-nuclear but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00833-00198588-00198790": "not supporting really any new builds for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00834-00198791-00198983": "sort of decades", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00835-00198984-00199193": "um to now saying hang on we like Nick we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00836-00199194-00199373": "know that we need this now what can we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00837-00199374-00199613": "do to help the nuclear industry and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00838-00199614-00199793": "they're actually investing quite a lot", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00839-00199794-00199925": "in things like some more modular", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00840-00199926-00200200": "reactors and also um having to subsidize", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00841-00200201-00200363": "the operating Euclid plants because", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00842-00200364-00200578": "they're really low gas prices over there", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00843-00200579-00200825": "trying to save some of those plans so", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00844-00200826-00201016": "changing a position of nuclear parties", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00845-00201017-00201257": "does happen on this topic I think", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00846-00201258-00201407": "something that might for instance", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00847-00201408-00201707": "interest the labor party is because the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00848-00201708-00201964": "jobs are stable and they're high paying", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00849-00201965-00202240": "and the highness skilled nuclear lends", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00850-00202241-00202487": "itself very nicely to a nice unionized", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00851-00202488-00202625": "Workforce", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00852-00202626-00203021": "it absolutely does some studies out of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00853-00203022-00203254": "the US looking at if you changed from a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00854-00203255-00203423": "coal plant to a nuclear plant what will", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00855-00203424-00203609": "they do for for jobs it actually", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00856-00203610-00203795": "increases the number of jobs because you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00857-00203796-00203963": "do need more workers in a new clip hat", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00858-00203964-00204149": "than you're doing a coal plant you've", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00859-00204150-00204395": "got to just transition here from people", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00860-00204396-00204557": "who can work in Coal who can go and work", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00861-00204558-00204731": "in nuclear there will be some upskilling", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00862-00204732-00204892": "but a lot of the jobs are very very", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00863-00204894-00205012": "similar", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00864-00205013-00205258": "so I think I'm not sure why the whole", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00865-00205259-00205612": "unionized work foresight of a of nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00866-00205613-00206032": "doesn't appeal to labor maybe it does", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00867-00206033-00206182": "um that's the only two I think is I've", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00868-00206183-00206386": "got but I'm asking the audience it's not", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00869-00206387-00206531": "just about my opinions I'd like to hear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00870-00206532-00206746": "yours too Michael what do you think", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00871-00206748-00206969": "uh I'm Jonathan by the way but yeah I'm", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00872-00206969-00207227": "sorry no no I mean I I think they're", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00873-00207228-00207407": "they're two things that come to mind as", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00874-00207408-00207496": "well", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00875-00207498-00207569": "um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00876-00207569-00207881": "yeah I I I I don't have any formulated", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00877-00207882-00208079": "thoughts on it really other than what", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00878-00208080-00208294": "you've just said and um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00879-00208296-00208505": "yeah I do see it as a big roadblock", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00880-00208506-00208673": "though because I can't see it making", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00881-00208673-00208846": "much I can't see the legal question", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00882-00208848-00209105": "becoming or any political part really", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00883-00209106-00209314": "political party really taking it until", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00884-00209315-00209525": "it's sort of more or less bipartisan so", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00885-00209526-00209746": "I feel like that's a crucial thing is to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00886-00209748-00210023": "try and start uh making some inroads on", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00887-00210023-00210208": "on the Progressive side of politics but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00888-00210209-00210317": "anyway", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00889-00210317-00210515": "um we'll see see what happens but yeah I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00890-00210516-00210641": "think I think the kind of arguments you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00891-00210642-00210791": "just made are the kind of ones you'd", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00892-00210792-00210934": "have to make", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00893-00210935-00211181": "as somebody who in their life will", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00894-00211182-00211319": "generally align with the more", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00895-00211319-00211606": "Progressive side of Politics on many", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00896-00211607-00211751": "issues it's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00897-00211752-00212051": "it's a it's a tough one because", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00898-00212052-00212248": "I can see all these benefits and I can", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00899-00212250-00212417": "definitely see the downsides of nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00900-00212417-00212675": "as well but I also see the opportunity", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00901-00212676-00212944": "and and I see what is the goal I mean", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00902-00212946-00213155": "climate change I'm burning things coal", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00903-00213156-00213401": "gas um dung Timber is killing eight", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00904-00213402-00213606": "million people every single year", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00905-00213607-00213821": "and even if you look at some of the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00906-00213821-00214031": "world's worst estimates from the effects", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00907-00214032-00214181": "of nuclear accidents they're nowhere", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00908-00214182-00214475": "near that right no like there's borders", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00909-00214476-00214763": "of magnitude lower than the the damage", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00910-00214764-00214960": "that burning things is doing", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00911-00214961-00215134": "um to the world's population in terms of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00912-00215135-00215358": "air pollution", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00913-00215359-00215596": "I made a bit of a loss in place if", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00914-00215598-00215741": "anyone has any ideas", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00915-00215742-00215975": "um yeah no no I think events did it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00916-00215976-00216137": "really well from my perspective so yeah", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00917-00216138-00216310": "you feel free to ask somebody else but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00918-00216311-00216467": "uh yeah", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00919-00216467-00216691": "yeah thank you Jonathan not Michael", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00920-00216692-00217006": "thanks Jonathan and thanks Joe uh okay", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00921-00217007-00217241": "the next person with the hand up is Saha", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00922-00217242-00217415": "uh", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00923-00217416-00217739": "hello thank you so much again Joe for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00924-00217740-00217925": "coming um we want to have more of these", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00925-00217926-00218165": "kinds of sessions anyway and nuclear has", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00926-00218166-00218387": "been a contentious topic we've had", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00927-00218388-00218477": "people", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00928-00218478-00218855": "um who are Faithfully against nuclear I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00929-00218856-00219131": "myself I'm a bit agnostic I mean", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00930-00219132-00219305": "um I come from the science perspective", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00931-00219306-00219629": "but I have my own reservations about", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00932-00219630-00219856": "um waste management and of course", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00933-00219857-00220048": "everyone is scared of radiation and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00934-00220050-00220379": "cancer and all of that and I think", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00935-00220380-00220541": "possibly", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00936-00220542-00220829": "education campaigns on those things need", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00937-00220830-00221027": "to happen and I'd be curious how I'm", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00938-00221028-00221284": "Sweden and Finland addressed that maybe", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00939-00221285-00221560": "they had some pretty robust education on", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00940-00221561-00221687": "that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00941-00221688-00221932": "um because that's that's where it stops", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00942-00221933-00222077": "and I think fear is a really good", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00943-00222078-00222341": "motivator for people to not approach", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00944-00222342-00222515": "anything further and see the positives", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00945-00222516-00222958": "as not being um relevant", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00946-00222959-00223229": "um so I guess my question is and I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00947-00223230-00223510": "noticed it's not really a technical one", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00948-00223511-00223763": "um it's more political one but if you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00949-00223764-00223889": "don't want to answer that I'll ask a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00950-00223890-00224027": "technical one that I just saw in the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00951-00224028-00224123": "chat", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00952-00224123-00224351": "um I noticed just around my neighborhood", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00953-00224352-00224651": "in Sydney 10 15 years ago there were um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00954-00224652-00224831": "posters everywhere saying we are a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00955-00224832-00225071": "nuclear free zone and I remember seeing", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00956-00225071-00225371": "that and thinking yeah good because I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00957-00225371-00225544": "feel safe", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00958-00225546-00225755": "um I'm just wondering if you have an", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00959-00225756-00226127": "opinion on where that came about and I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00960-00226128-00226342": "guess what you think would be a good", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00961-00226344-00226498": "idea to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00962-00226500-00226792": "um reverse that and my other question", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00963-00226794-00227206": "was to your suggestion about jobs", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00964-00227207-00227351": "um upskilling people", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00965-00227352-00227519": "um how long would that take if we were", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00966-00227519-00227831": "to upskill coal miners and workers", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00967-00227832-00228041": "no problems let's start with the um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00968-00228042-00228382": "nuclear free zones first because I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00969-00228383-00228617": "I say I have a chuckle but every time I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00970-00228617-00228881": "go to Newtown there's a new nuclear-free", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00971-00228882-00229163": "Zone sign in Newtown but there's also a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00972-00229164-00229337": "hospital I think it's Royal prints", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00973-00229338-00229541": "outfit isn't that's very close by that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00974-00229542-00229691": "does nuclear medicine and has a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00975-00229692-00230032": "cyclotron which are nuclear techniques", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00976-00230033-00230321": "right so the nuclear free zones were set", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00977-00230321-00230584": "up um I believe in the 70s and 80s and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00978-00230585-00230746": "they were mainly set up", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00979-00230748-00231017": "um to show that nuclear weapons weren't", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00980-00231017-00231094": "welcome", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00981-00231096-00231310": "in the area so let's definitely started", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00982-00231311-00231544": "off more with a nuclear weapons and a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00983-00231546-00231803": "non-proliferation theme", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00984-00231804-00231994": "um I don't think they have any legal", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00985-00231996-00232210": "basis whatsoever but it's more the local", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00986-00232211-00232348": "councils and the people don't want", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00987-00232350-00232660": "nuclear weapons in this area uh but some", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00988-00232661-00232834": "councils have gone further and said we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00989-00232835-00233021": "don't want nuclear weapons or nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00990-00233021-00233177": "energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00991-00233178-00233387": "um in in their policies which again", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00992-00233388-00233621": "don't have legal backing uh but it's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00993-00233621-00233837": "more just a statement of this is this is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00994-00233838-00233987": "what this is how we feel about these", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00995-00233988-00234151": "things", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00996-00234152-00234431": "some will also say um we don't like some", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00997-00234432-00234605": "nuclear stuff but we do like nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00998-00234606-00234808": "medicine that's okay so there's a whole", "Wq2FG3mneoA-00999-00234809-00235006": "different range I don't know how many", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01000-00235007-00235234": "councils have these uh particular", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01001-00235235-00235421": "policies but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01002-00235421-00235589": "I did try to look it up once and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01003-00235590-00235829": "couldn't easily find which ones do and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01004-00235830-00235960": "don't so", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01005-00235961-00236123": "I hope that answers your question it was", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01006-00236123-00236375": "about nuclear weapons and I don't really", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01007-00236376-00236560": "want to have nuclear weapons in my local", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01008-00236561-00236856": "government area either no thank you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01009-00236857-00237119": "thank you but I personally would be", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01010-00237119-00237341": "happy to live near a nuclear power", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01011-00237342-00237592": "reactor maybe because I know a fair bit", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01012-00237594-00237767": "about it I'm comfortable with the risks", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01013-00237767-00237923": "and the benefits because I'm exposed to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01014-00237923-00238067": "it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01015-00238067-00238223": "um the other question was about", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01016-00238223-00238444": "upskilling yeah", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01017-00238446-00238798": "so from um coal workers to yeah", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01018-00238800-00239003": "Okay so", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01019-00239004-00239231": "a lot of people who work in Coal plants", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01020-00239232-00239506": "I'm assuming come from a uh a trades", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01021-00239507-00239621": "background", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01022-00239621-00239771": "so if you look at the opal research", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01023-00239771-00240041": "reactor the dominant Workforce at opal", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01024-00240042-00240208": "is people from trades backgrounds the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01025-00240209-00240389": "people doing the maintenance the reactor", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01026-00240390-00240634": "operators from trades backgrounds or the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01027-00240635-00240784": "people doing the stuff in the reactor", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01028-00240785-00241031": "are trades backgrounds and the next", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01029-00241032-00241210": "biggest sort of a group of employees", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01030-00241211-00241408": "would be the engineers", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01031-00241409-00241558": "so at", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01032-00241559-00241775": "and a nuclear power plant it'd be very", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01033-00241776-00241894": "similar there'd be a lot of people with", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01034-00241896-00242051": "trades backgrounds who would need to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01035-00242052-00242303": "keep the plant running they would and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01036-00242304-00242525": "possibly even operate um the nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01037-00242526-00242681": "reactors and there'd be Engineers doing", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01038-00242682-00242855": "their engineering type things and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01039-00242856-00243023": "scientists and emergency response", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01040-00243023-00243221": "personnel and medical personnel and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01041-00243221-00243532": "comms people and whatever else I thought", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01042-00243533-00243658": "like this could need like sort of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01043-00243659-00243839": "outside of the direct running of the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01044-00243840-00244001": "reactor", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01045-00244002-00244289": "so a a Turbine Technician if such a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01046-00244290-00244517": "thing exists um in a coal plant could do", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01047-00244517-00244708": "the same job in a nuclear plant it's the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01048-00244709-00244792": "same", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01049-00244794-00245039": "same technology we're talking about", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01050-00245040-00245419": "so how long would it take to upskill", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01051-00245419-00245627": "there's certain things you'd have to do", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01052-00245628-00245867": "around safe the thing called Safety", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01053-00245867-00246071": "culture you expected to act a certain", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01054-00246071-00246269": "way when you're in a nuclear plant you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01055-00246269-00246419": "don't walk past a hazard you do", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01056-00246419-00246658": "something about it I'm not saying that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01057-00246659-00246905": "does happen in a coal plant but there's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01058-00246906-00247073": "a certain behavior that you'd want to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01059-00247073-00247253": "train people in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01060-00247254-00247541": "um yeah so how long would that take I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01061-00247542-00247696": "don't know some people could be on the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01062-00247698-00247955": "job I would imagine", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01063-00247956-00248141": "um but reactor operators we do have", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01064-00248142-00248423": "nuclear engineering and nuclear science", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01065-00248423-00248675": "masters in Australia already", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01066-00248676-00248855": "so we could train people you know", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01067-00248856-00249041": "through the academic side at the moment", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01068-00249042-00249341": "and then train them on the plan as well", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01069-00249342-00249544": "it takes about", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01070-00249546-00249737": "six months in Australia I think for a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01071-00249738-00249923": "reactor operator to become accredited", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01072-00249923-00250079": "throughout the job but that's right", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01073-00250080-00250229": "that's the classroom and then more time", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01074-00250230-00250434": "on the job as well so", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01075-00250435-00250732": "in the order of years I would say to get", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01076-00250733-00250877": "fully up to speed", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01077-00250878-00251063": "that sounds all right", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01078-00251064-00251260": "um it's not too bad yeah we've also got", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01079-00251261-00251446": "sorry this program called the orcus", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01080-00251448-00251608": "agreement whether you agree with", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01081-00251609-00251915": "nuclear-powered submarines or not it's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01082-00251916-00252184": "gonna bring an upskilling of Engineers", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01083-00252185-00252377": "and scientists in this country who could", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01084-00252378-00252665": "then go and work in nuclear power plants", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01085-00252666-00252841": "should we have them in future", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01086-00252842-00253060": "cool and just from what you were saying", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01087-00253061-00253277": "before about uh gen cost", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01088-00253278-00253523": "so that tends to be the argument I I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01089-00253523-00253625": "just remember", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01090-00253626-00253877": "um a labor and Green's candidate", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01091-00253878-00254044": "outright just said about nuclear it's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01092-00254046-00254332": "expensive and dropped it and that was it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01093-00254333-00254573": "and uh", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01094-00254573-00255010": "we lost Saha for a second okay", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01095-00255011-00255263": "again is something being expensive a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01096-00255264-00255556": "reason to ban it because electrically", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01097-00255557-00255742": "cars are still fairly expensive shall we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01098-00255744-00255941": "ban them of course we shouldn't because", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01099-00255942-00256115": "if you make something available in an", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01100-00256116-00256427": "option the prices will come down", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01101-00256428-00256673": "yes hopefully hopefully", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01102-00256673-00256984": "definitely yeah um all right uh so we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01103-00256985-00257123": "have one more person with their hand up", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01104-00257123-00257501": "uh brynden yep hi hello as mentioned", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01105-00257502-00258053": "earlier I've mentioned before I can see", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01106-00258054-00258377": "I was replying yourself but when I put a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01107-00258378-00258677": "quote in the chat saying nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01108-00258678-00258929": "when it's great it's great but when it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01109-00258930-00259163": "fails it fails big", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01110-00259164-00259360": "and I think most people when they refers", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01111-00259361-00259594": "that they're gonna think of I think well", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01112-00259596-00259901": "the big one would be Chernobyl but the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01113-00259902-00260146": "more recent one in in their heads would", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01114-00260148-00260356": "be Fukushima", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01115-00260357-00260579": "would be Fukushima there's three mile", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01116-00260580-00260717": "and the like", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01117-00260717-00261048": "not that other big explosions and I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01118-00261050-00261317": "screw things up and there's all sorts of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01119-00261317-00261592": "issues I know chernova work didn't they", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01120-00261594-00261773": "get effed up because mostly because the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01121-00261773-00262079": "Soviets were weakening protections", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01122-00262080-00262265": "because they wanted to boost the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01123-00262266-00262547": "byproducts and by byproducts I of course", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01124-00262548-00262932": "mean missile fuel for missiles", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01125-00262933-00263303": "and well for Fukushima a little bit old", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01126-00263304-00263525": "and it just got hit with the earthquake", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01127-00263526-00263693": "of the tsunami", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01128-00263694-00263999": "it's maybe they didn't plan as well as", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01129-00264000-00264221": "they could have but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01130-00264222-00264460": "yeah so I think a lot of people were", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01131-00264461-00264682": "trying to say is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01132-00264683-00264982": "what plans what mitigations would be", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01133-00264983-00265217": "needed to make sure that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01134-00265218-00265589": "we don't get those big fails", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01135-00265590-00265834": "okay there were big fails in terms of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01136-00265835-00266080": "they got a lot of media attention", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01137-00266081-00266249": "absolutely", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01138-00266250-00266597": "how would you like to classify big are", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01139-00266598-00266782": "we talking death rates here are we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01140-00266783-00267023": "talking like like as big as it is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01141-00267024-00267149": "subjective I just want to make sure I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01142-00267150-00267413": "can answer your question um as best as", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01143-00267414-00267551": "possible so", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01144-00267552-00267899": "I can show you some stats on the impacts", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01145-00267900-00268210": "of those two accidents in terms of death", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01146-00268211-00268355": "rates", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01147-00268356-00268553": "is that something you're interested in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01148-00268554-00268882": "or or are you more interested in other", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01149-00268883-00269075": "things so I'll let you talk", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01150-00269076-00269441": "I think probably what I was saying is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01151-00269442-00269801": "I understand that they in a big scheme", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01152-00269802-00270149": "they weren't big horrid whatever it's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01153-00270150-00270305": "just I'm thinking", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01154-00270306-00270551": "Garrett and especially because the fact", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01155-00270552-00270827": "is let's talk Chernobyl because that is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01156-00270828-00271234": "of a much greater yes Fukushima and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01157-00271235-00271367": "Chernobyl of the same classification", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01158-00271368-00271675": "which is the worst but the fact is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01159-00271676-00272113": "Chernobyl is many many factors", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01160-00272114-00272506": "worse so worse relatively speaking than", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01161-00272507-00272860": "Fukushima and we know of things that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01162-00272861-00273251": "could go even worse if necessary so I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01163-00273252-00273317": "think", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01164-00273318-00273487": "I would say", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01165-00273488-00273871": "newsworthy which is impossible", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01166-00273872-00274156": "so just thinking", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01167-00274157-00274451": "I mean I'm sorry yeah", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01168-00274452-00274630": "so maybe", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01169-00274631-00274847": "accidents that would", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01170-00274848-00275201": "deny the use of land", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01171-00275202-00275873": "for longer than", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01172-00275874-00276334": "I think 20 or probably even 10 years 10", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01173-00276335-00276623": "years okay I think which is I think that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01174-00276624-00276817": "sounds about your average", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01175-00276818-00277139": "for but then again even that's probably", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01176-00277140-00277451": "not to that because upsetting", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01177-00277452-00277708": "freakashima I know doesn't have a major", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01178-00277709-00278021": "exclusion Zone anymore I know Chernobyl", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01179-00278022-00278129": "does", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01180-00278130-00278453": "yep I I understand about 90 of the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01181-00278454-00278734": "Fukushima population has returned or", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01182-00278735-00278963": "doesn't wish to but I got that off", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01183-00278964-00279058": "Twitter", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01184-00279059-00279347": "so you may or may not be accurate and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01185-00279348-00279539": "Chernobyl does have an exclusion Zone", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01186-00279540-00279760": "and in that exclusion Zone the animals", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01187-00279761-00279989": "are thriving because there are no people", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01188-00279990-00280091": "there", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01189-00280092-00280343": "so I would argue that humans are worse", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01190-00280344-00280601": "for populations and the environment that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01191-00280602-00280991": "than radiation is if we look at the the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01192-00280992-00281123": "Chernobyl accident", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01193-00281124-00281308": "um it was a design that would not have", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01194-00281309-00281471": "got licensed in the west because it had", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01195-00281472-00281699": "a it had a design floor that apparently", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01196-00281700-00281903": "the Soviet regime knew about but didn't", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01197-00281904-00282095": "tell their operators", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01198-00282096-00282287": "the reactors also didn't have a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01199-00282288-00282515": "containment which you know Western", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01200-00282516-00282797": "reactors do to to contain", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01201-00282798-00283073": "um a lot of the radiation it's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01202-00283074-00283210": "interesting about snow because the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01203-00283211-00283475": "accident was in 1986 there was four", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01204-00283476-00283708": "reactors on that site they all shut one", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01205-00283709-00283889": "was destroyed the other three shut down", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01206-00283890-00284158": "and then started up again", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01207-00284159-00284369": "and the last one didn't shut down for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01208-00284370-00284603": "good until the year 2000 so for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01209-00284604-00284825": "effectively 14 years after the Chernobyl", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01210-00284826-00285053": "reactor accident so one of the units", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01211-00285054-00285227": "kept on operating there was people and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01212-00285228-00285347": "there still are people there working", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01213-00285348-00285593": "there every single day", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01214-00285594-00285958": "okay so as I said and I agree with that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01215-00285959-00286330": "it's just I'm thinking more how most", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01216-00286331-00286565": "people when they think of nuclear power", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01217-00286566-00286780": "they're going to think of as I mentioned", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01218-00286781-00287147": "Chernobyl Fukushima daiichi", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01219-00287148-00287513": "uh Fremont Island and a whole bunch of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01220-00287514-00287663": "and there's probably even others that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01221-00287664-00287927": "I've forgotten that are big ones have", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01222-00287928-00288113": "you heard of the um the band Shelf at", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01223-00288114-00288282": "Dan failure at all", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01224-00288283-00288605": "oh I think I can get that down until we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01225-00288606-00288779": "killed a lot more people than the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01226-00288780-00289019": "snowball ever did it did so there was a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01227-00289020-00289301": "big damp earlier in China I can't", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01228-00289302-00289439": "remember what the year was and it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01229-00289440-00289679": "tragically killed a hundred thousand", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01230-00289680-00289829": "plus people there's different estimates", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01231-00289830-00290008": "but no one not many people have heard of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01232-00290009-00290093": "it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01233-00290094-00290284": "whereas you look at something like a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01234-00290285-00290471": "snowball Fukushima because it made use", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01235-00290472-00290603": "and stayed in the news for amongst the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01236-00290604-00290795": "months and months and months", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01237-00290796-00290993": "um it was scary for people people like", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01238-00290994-00291197": "to hear about it and news media's kept", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01239-00291198-00291347": "playing it over and over again", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01240-00291348-00291430": "um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01241-00291431-00291641": "some accidents receive more attention", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01242-00291642-00291815": "than others that's all I'm saying was it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01243-00291816-00292037": "warranted for the nuclear accidents", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01244-00292038-00292169": "um that's for you to decide I'm not", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01245-00292170-00292405": "going to say to say yes or no", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01246-00292406-00292732": "in Fukushima about 20 000 people", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01247-00292733-00292919": "tragically died in the earthquake and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01248-00292920-00293177": "the tsunami and today no one has died", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01249-00293178-00293387": "from radiation exposure", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01250-00293388-00293579": "so it was a huge National event that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01251-00293580-00293747": "happened that devastated so many", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01252-00293748-00293927": "people's lives and add on top of that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01253-00293928-00294160": "having to evacuate people it's an extra", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01254-00294161-00294460": "stress and it's an extra horrible thing", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01255-00294461-00294593": "like lots of horrible things happened", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01256-00294594-00294955": "there wasn't just a nuclear meltdown", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01257-00294956-00295205": "and I agree with you with the whole", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01258-00295206-00295391": "thing I'm one of the people that could", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01259-00295392-00295673": "see I was just thinking more because I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01260-00295674-00295834": "knew that was the common", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01261-00295835-00296069": "people objecting", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01262-00296070-00296353": "all right thanks thanks Bren uh", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01263-00296354-00296651": "no no you're okay it we we need these", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01264-00296652-00296837": "kind of questions because it's all part", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01265-00296838-00297029": "of the discussion so I appreciate you uh", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01266-00297030-00297160": "raising that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01267-00297161-00297395": "um we're just moving on because we are", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01268-00297396-00297743": "approaching an hour uh so we have some", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01269-00297744-00297965": "questions from chat so a couple of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01270-00297966-00298313": "people have asked uh what is the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01271-00298314-00298632": "viability and and current uh", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01272-00298633-00298906": "commercialization stage for small", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01273-00298907-00299184": "modular reactants", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01274-00299185-00299441": "excellent question", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01275-00299442-00299680": "so there's already small body reactors", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01276-00299681-00299879": "operating on a lot of nuclear-powered", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01277-00299880-00300041": "Subs around the world that they're", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01278-00300042-00300256": "effectively small modular reactors", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01279-00300257-00300484": "but in terms of you know land-based", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01280-00300485-00300773": "reactors oh so there's also a few on our", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01281-00300774-00301060": "Russian icebreakers as well so civilian", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01282-00301061-00301156": "use", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01283-00301157-00301456": "in terms of more", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01284-00301457-00301643": "okay", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01285-00301644-00301799": "it's a difficult question and I'll tell", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01286-00301800-00302051": "you why because there's about 70 or 80", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01287-00302052-00302273": "different designs under development", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01288-00302274-00302513": "so I can pick particular countries we'll", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01289-00302514-00302795": "start with um Canada is investing quite", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01290-00302796-00303017": "heavily in small modular reactors", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01291-00303018-00303173": "one of the reasons why is that they've", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01292-00303174-00303365": "got remote populations who they have to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01293-00303366-00303617": "deliver diesel fuel to and if they don't", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01294-00303618-00303791": "people will literally freeze to death", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01295-00303792-00303929": "rights so they're very interested in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01296-00303930-00304187": "smrs um in remote communities", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01297-00304188-00304421": "they broke ground or not broke ground", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01298-00304422-00304708": "they started preparing um a site in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01299-00304709-00305021": "Ontario for their first SMR just in the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01300-00305022-00305201": "last week", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01301-00305202-00305387": "they've got a site they've got a design", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01302-00305388-00305537": "that they picked they have to get", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01303-00305538-00305717": "regulatory approvals to start", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01304-00305718-00306004": "construction but they're super keen and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01305-00306005-00306149": "they've got a deadline for the first one", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01306-00306150-00306460": "operating by 2028.", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01307-00306461-00306754": "in the U.S they're looking at how they", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01308-00306755-00306982": "can change coal to nuclear there is one", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01309-00306983-00307241": "particular uh place in Wyoming they have", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01310-00307242-00307523": "a site they have a reactor", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01311-00307524-00307708": "um the US Department of energy is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01312-00307709-00307889": "investing two billion dollars in a first", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01313-00307890-00308165": "of a kind and um the company is owned by", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01314-00308166-00308345": "Bill Gates so maybe some of his friends", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01315-00308346-00308549": "will chip in the other two billion", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01316-00308550-00308867": "that also is expected also the aim and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01317-00308868-00309173": "this is a U.S government aim is 2028 as", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01318-00309174-00309269": "well", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01319-00309270-00309569": "who else is doing things uh new another", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01320-00309570-00309677": "company there's all these other", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01321-00309678-00309869": "companies they have um customers and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01322-00309870-00310193": "clients looking at 2028 to 2031", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01323-00310194-00310408": "to have their first ones out but the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01324-00310409-00310565": "first reactor the first of anything is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01325-00310566-00310708": "always the hardest right and once you've", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01326-00310709-00310858": "got the first you've got your supply", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01327-00310859-00311021": "chain set up then you build your second", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01328-00311022-00311158": "and it gets cheaper and you're still in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01329-00311159-00311303": "your fourth", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01330-00311304-00311549": "um some of these vendors in the US uh in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01331-00311550-00311753": "Canada and the UK are actually", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01332-00311754-00311987": "um sorry US and Canada in particular are", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01333-00311988-00312221": "actually uh starting to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01334-00312222-00312467": "basically take orders for the future", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01335-00312468-00312653": "like people are countries like we want", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01336-00312654-00312827": "these things this is how many how many", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01337-00312828-00312971": "we're going to want probably how many", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01338-00312972-00313121": "we're going to order this is kind of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01339-00313122-00313384": "when we want them so it is happening but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01340-00313385-00313523": "what I want to see is actual", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01341-00313524-00313708": "construction an actual operation I don't", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01342-00313709-00313937": "know about you guys but I you can talk", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01343-00313938-00314153": "about smr's um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01344-00314154-00314423": "as much as you want but unless the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01345-00314424-00314615": "vendors and the companies are being", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01346-00314616-00314825": "successful in building them it's not", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01347-00314826-00315041": "going to happen here right", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01348-00315042-00315221": "so from Australian perspective if", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01349-00315222-00315419": "someone was to ask me when I would say", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01350-00315420-00315641": "sometime in the 2030s", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01351-00315642-00315808": "in the meantime we need to see what we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01352-00315809-00315934": "can do with Renewables and other", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01353-00315935-00316156": "Technologies right do what we can and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01354-00316157-00316330": "then bring on the new technology or when", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01355-00316331-00316558": "it is ready to go", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01356-00316559-00316793": "that being said there's plenty of other", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01357-00316794-00317003": "reactive designs that are approved and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01358-00317004-00317153": "licensed in other countries that we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01359-00317154-00317291": "could build", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01360-00317292-00317465": "like the big the big reactors right", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01361-00317466-00317675": "they're proven designs we could go down", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01362-00317676-00317819": "the big reactive route as well it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01363-00317820-00318160": "doesn't have to be um smrs", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01364-00318161-00318406": "thanks Joe uh the comparison that I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01365-00318407-00318695": "often hear is Apple spends about 1.5", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01366-00318696-00318869": "billion dollars developing each", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01367-00318870-00319180": "generation of new iPhone so the very", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01368-00319181-00319421": "first new iPhone costs 1.5 billion", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01369-00319422-00319637": "dollars for them to make the very next", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01370-00319638-00319806": "one costs 500", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01371-00319807-00320080": "so yeah the the first of a kind is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01372-00320081-00320321": "always more expensive uh but the the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01373-00320322-00320537": "better we the more we build the the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01374-00320538-00320710": "cheaper it becomes", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01375-00320711-00320867": "um all right so we have some other", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01376-00320868-00321125": "questions here Adam says we're finding", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01377-00321126-00321293": "that solar is providing issues with", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01378-00321294-00321479": "energy infrastructure and capacity to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01379-00321480-00321682": "the point where South Australia had to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01380-00321683-00321934": "turn off consumer panels last year to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01381-00321935-00322193": "normalize energy production are there", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01382-00322194-00322397": "changes to existing infrastructure that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01383-00322398-00322510": "would need to be considered to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01384-00322511-00322930": "accommodate nuclear reactors", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01385-00322931-00323075": "um was that Adam sorry Adam's question", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01386-00323076-00323315": "thank you Adam thank you Adam for that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01387-00323316-00323423": "um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01388-00323424-00323656": "the good thing about nuclear is it's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01389-00323657-00324077": "synchronous like a gas and coal are so", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01390-00324078-00324310": "what it does it will offer advantages in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01391-00324311-00324460": "terms of grid strength and grid", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01392-00324461-00324634": "reliability and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01393-00324635-00324880": "um I've got to get my my terms right I'm", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01394-00324881-00325006": "learning about this stuff at the moment", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01395-00325007-00325260": "frequency control and voltage control", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01396-00325261-00325547": "system strength", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01397-00325548-00325751": "it's like coal and gas in that respect", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01398-00325752-00325960": "so you can do a straight call to nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01399-00325961-00326201": "transition and it provides the kind of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01400-00326202-00326399": "system inertia and strength that will", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01401-00326400-00326693": "actually allow more wind and solar onto", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01402-00326694-00326843": "the system", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01403-00326844-00327173": "just this week Amo down in South", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01404-00327174-00327365": "Australia I think it was this week could", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01405-00327366-00327515": "have been last week", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01406-00327516-00327719": "um was they put out warnings every now", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01407-00327720-00327934": "and again and they sometimes people turn", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01408-00327935-00328103": "off things like wind and solar they'll", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01409-00328104-00328427": "kill curtail them and just recently they", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01410-00328428-00328625": "had to order gas to come online because", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01411-00328626-00328780": "they didn't have enough synchronous", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01412-00328781-00328979": "generation so there wasn't a problem", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01413-00328980-00329123": "with the Renewables not generating", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01414-00329124-00329404": "enough they didn't have enough stability", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01415-00329405-00329591": "uh within the system that had to order", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01416-00329592-00329830": "gas to come on", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01417-00329831-00330041": "would you rather have gas coming on or", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01418-00330042-00330232": "nuclear coming on like I I know the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01419-00330233-00330406": "answer to that one that's sort of purely", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01420-00330407-00330677": "from the the climate change perspective", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01421-00330678-00330773": "um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01422-00330774-00331030": "so nuclear does offer the ability to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01423-00331031-00331217": "help control frequency", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01424-00331218-00331480": "um and volatility and things like that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01425-00331481-00331763": "the things that Renewables need you can", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01426-00331764-00332003": "buy things called um synchronous", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01427-00332004-00332165": "condensers I think they're called if", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01428-00332166-00332447": "anyone on here knows all about the tech", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01429-00332448-00332591": "but that's an extra cost that you're", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01430-00332592-00332747": "adding to the cost of your wind and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01431-00332748-00332837": "solar", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01432-00332838-00333256": "alongside the transmission and the um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01433-00333257-00333437": "a storage and everything else that you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01434-00333438-00333977": "need to make that kind of system work", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01435-00333978-00334204": "great thanks Joe", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01436-00334205-00334625": "um the also the the big battery that was", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01437-00334626-00334804": "highly publicized a couple of years ago", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01438-00334805-00335032": "one of its primary jobs is frequency", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01439-00335033-00335182": "control", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01440-00335183-00335471": "um because it can you know respond", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01441-00335472-00335854": "within milliseconds so it's that uh but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01442-00335855-00336149": "those ancillary services are quite", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01443-00336150-00336425": "expensive and that's where these uh", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01444-00336426-00336599": "companies are making a lot of money off", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01445-00336600-00336773": "that and that's contributing to some of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01446-00336774-00337054": "the higher prices in South Australia", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01447-00337055-00337337": "um we have a question from Angus how", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01448-00337338-00337721": "does nuclear compare between land use uh", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01449-00337722-00337960": "sorry so what's the land use between", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01450-00337961-00338129": "nuclear and other forms of power", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01451-00338130-00338356": "generation", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01452-00338357-00338584": "that is a wonderful question and that's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01453-00338585-00338753": "the one thing I don't have an image on", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01454-00338754-00339004": "that I can pull up and say here you go", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01455-00339005-00339287": "look with things like solar it depends", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01456-00339288-00339449": "because you can use existing structures", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01457-00339450-00339634": "right you can use existing buildings to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01458-00339635-00339827": "put your solar panels on", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01459-00339828-00340121": "the kinds of numbers of solar panels", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01460-00340122-00340295": "we're going to need though if Australia", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01461-00340296-00340439": "is going to pursue some kind of 100", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01462-00340440-00340780": "renewable future uh is big enough that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01463-00340781-00341056": "we're going to have solar Farms as well", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01464-00341057-00341273": "cheers the numbers off the top of your", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01465-00341274-00341495": "head about how many times more land you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01466-00341496-00341813": "need I just linked it in the chat so", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01467-00341814-00342029": "thank you uh according to our world and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01468-00342030-00342413": "data nuclear uses uh 0.3 square meters", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01469-00342414-00342803": "per megawatt hour uh rooftop solar uses", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01470-00342804-00343241": "1.2 square meters per megawatt hour uh", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01471-00343242-00343439": "grid scale", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01472-00343440-00343841": "solar PV is rough is the average median", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01473-00343842-00344087": "is 12.6 square meters per megawatt hour", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01474-00344088-00344339": "and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01475-00344340-00344615": "onshore wind is 0.4 so it's the closest", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01476-00344616-00344849": "to nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01477-00344850-00345130": "um so yeah that's onshore wind", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01478-00345131-00345287": "um that's the direct impact of the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01479-00345288-00345539": "turbine itself but if you include the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01480-00345540-00345815": "whole project site that goes to uh", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01481-00345816-00346210": "greater than uh 99 square meters uh per", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01482-00346211-00346595": "megawatt hour so yeah it nuclear is the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01483-00346596-00346727": "lowest", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01484-00346728-00347099": "um in of all energy for sources nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01485-00347100-00347443": "is four times lower than rooftop solar", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01486-00347444-00347830": "40 times lower than", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01487-00347831-00347908": "um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01488-00347909-00348130": "solar farms and that kind of thing yes", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01489-00348131-00348269": "and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01490-00348270-00348599": "geez 300 times lower than", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01491-00348600-00348815": "wind if you look at the whole area and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01492-00348816-00349001": "not just the area of the two of the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01493-00349002-00349360": "turbine spinning", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01494-00349361-00349606": "it doesn't use much it's it's it's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01495-00349607-00349810": "um some of the smrs", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01496-00349811-00350189": "um talk about this site being", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01497-00350190-00350399": "how big is it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01498-00350400-00350645": "kilometer across", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01499-00350646-00350956": "I think so it fits well within a gas or", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01500-00350957-00351137": "a whole existing site I would imagine", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01501-00351138-00351347": "don't quote me on that way", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01502-00351348-00351689": "uh we have Andrea's uh", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01503-00351690-00351995": "yeah raised a hand and just in response", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01504-00351996-00352199": "to that I'm I'm just curious I might go", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01505-00352200-00352565": "and check how they calculate that um the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01506-00352566-00352810": "the footprint of rooftop solar which you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01507-00352811-00353069": "would think would be zero I'm very", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01508-00353070-00353315": "curious as to how they calculate that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01509-00353316-00353597": "um and for wind turbines yeah that it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01510-00353598-00353741": "depends I mean I've been to a wind", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01511-00353742-00353969": "turbine in Scotland where you're", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01512-00353970-00354173": "encouraged to walk around I mean", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01513-00354174-00354467": "Scotland's got a culture of um the the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01514-00354468-00354665": "common land being free for everyone to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01515-00354666-00354928": "walk around in and they've kept that up", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01516-00354929-00355175": "with wind turbines to demystify them", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01517-00355176-00355439": "um but it's it is convenient obviously", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01518-00355440-00355625": "that nuclear power stations can fit in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01519-00355626-00355787": "the footprint of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01520-00355788-00356032": "um coal power plants and gas power", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01521-00356033-00356254": "plants as we decommission them I find", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01522-00356255-00356669": "that very neat", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01523-00356670-00356915": "yeah sorry I should say that that the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01524-00356916-00357191": "data from our world and data is a life", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01525-00357192-00357430": "cycle assessment so it's including all", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01526-00357431-00357563": "the resource extraction and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01527-00357564-00357719": "Manufacturing things like that as well", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01528-00357720-00357937": "that makes sense", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01529-00357938-00358151": "uh let me just have a look what other", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01530-00358152-00358432": "questions the question here about I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01531-00358433-00358667": "think land use is not the problem for", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01532-00358668-00358823": "Australia", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01533-00358824-00359117": "um yes and no yes we have a lot of land", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01534-00359118-00359393": "but whose land is it that we're using", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01535-00359394-00359584": "and exploiting Farmers", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01536-00359585-00359765": "um indigenous populations because all", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01537-00359766-00359891": "these things aren't going to go new", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01538-00359892-00360149": "cities they're going to go further away", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01539-00360150-00360328": "um yes you have a lot of land", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01540-00360329-00360641": "but how how can we best use that land is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01541-00360642-00360917": "the best land I best use agriculture is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01542-00360918-00361078": "it rewilding should we be trying to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01543-00361079-00361421": "plant more trees is it energy production", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01544-00361422-00361625": "I don't know the answer it depends where", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01545-00361626-00361787": "it is but at the end of the day it's the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01546-00361788-00361943": "people living in remote and Rural", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01547-00361944-00362093": "communities that are going to have these", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01548-00362094-00362321": "things in their communities", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01549-00362322-00362495": "um should they be burying the brunt of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01550-00362496-00362699": "this and all the transmission lines um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01551-00362700-00363028": "just so the cities can have energy again", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01552-00363029-00363167": "this is something I think about from", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01553-00363168-00363460": "time to time I definitely don't have", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01554-00363461-00363658": "what haven't have my own thoughts but I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01555-00363659-00363815": "don't have the answer or anything like", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01556-00363816-00363941": "that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01557-00363942-00364093": "um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01558-00364094-00364345": "yeah", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01559-00364346-00364571": "it was just that just made me think of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01560-00364572-00364763": "Iceland which gets at least two-thirds", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01561-00364764-00365008": "of its power from Hydro", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01562-00365009-00365134": "um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01563-00365135-00365339": "um uh you know Damned", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01564-00365340-00365495": "Rivers", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01565-00365496-00365723": "um not pumped Hydro I don't think but um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01566-00365724-00365884": "those were there might be some sorry", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01567-00365885-00366077": "forget I said that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01568-00366078-00366365": "um the building of those dams was their", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01569-00366366-00366539": "big environmental protest moments", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01570-00366540-00366754": "because of all the the land that it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01571-00366755-00366863": "floods", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01572-00366864-00367282": "um so you would say Iceland's Iceland's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01573-00367283-00367421": "got a small population and their", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01574-00367422-00367606": "electricity generation is basically all", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01575-00367607-00367865": "renewable coming from uh geothermal", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01576-00367866-00368087": "whatever's not produced by hydropower", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01577-00368088-00368345": "but it's it's not without controversy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01578-00368346-00368578": "and damage", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01579-00368579-00368801": "I think like I said before every every", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01580-00368802-00369034": "technology has the pros and cons so like", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01581-00369035-00369263": "how can we use them all together for the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01582-00369264-00369467": "overall outcome that we want in terms of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01583-00369468-00369706": "reliable energy and low carbon emissions", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01584-00369707-00369917": "but also don't do other damage in other", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01585-00369918-00370108": "areas or as little as little damage as", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01586-00370109-00370210": "possible", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01587-00370211-00370378": "we're humans we damage things right", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01588-00370379-00370571": "that's what we do", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01589-00370572-00370847": "definitely all right uh Saha if you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01590-00370848-00371227": "would like to unmute yourself groups", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01591-00371228-00371591": "thank you uh yeah I got cut off", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01592-00371592-00371765": "unfortunately", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01593-00371766-00372023": "um it was just yeah my my phone", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01594-00372024-00372275": "um so I guess I just wanted to um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01595-00372276-00372395": "summarize what you were saying before", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01596-00372396-00372658": "about gen cost so what I got from that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01597-00372659-00372899": "was um people are saying that it's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01598-00372900-00373175": "expensive to set up the infrastructure", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01599-00373176-00373493": "to have nuclear power but they're not", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01600-00373494-00373801": "taking into account the the positive", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01601-00373802-00374075": "outcomes from that so the marginal", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01602-00374076-00374245": "benefit", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01603-00374246-00374584": "versus coal which I think could be", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01604-00374585-00374813": "comparatively cheap to continue using", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01605-00374814-00374927": "because we already have all the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01606-00374928-00375245": "infrastructure but is creating huge cost", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01607-00375246-00375377": "to the environment so they're not", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01608-00375378-00375527": "factoring that in when they're talking", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01609-00375528-00375713": "about cost so I think that's the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01610-00375714-00375995": "limitation there is that what you were", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01611-00375996-00376282": "meeting as well it's another limitation", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01612-00376283-00376432": "um that that's why it doesn't take into", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01613-00376433-00376630": "account externally what's that word", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01614-00376631-00376939": "externally oh yeah externalities", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01615-00376940-00377165": "I can't say that tonight", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01616-00377166-00377477": "um yeah lcoa my understanding is it was", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01617-00377478-00377806": "set up as a an easy way to directly", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01618-00377807-00378053": "compare say one kind of gas plant to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01619-00378054-00378239": "another kind of gas plan", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01620-00378240-00378454": "so very similar Technologies you you can", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01621-00378455-00378599": "compare them to see which one's going to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01622-00378600-00378815": "be cheaper to build and operate in the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01623-00378816-00378958": "long term right", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01624-00378959-00379265": "for something like solar which I think", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01625-00379266-00379475": "is greatly many you know applications it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01626-00379476-00379667": "has a very a relatively low capacity", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01627-00379668-00380021": "Factor it produces 25 of the time", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01628-00380022-00380273": "great you know it's not going to produce", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01629-00380274-00380404": "at night time so there is some", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01630-00380405-00380627": "predictability there but clouds go over", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01631-00380628-00380873": "a solar farm down it goes something else", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01632-00380874-00381017": "has to come up to replace it really", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01633-00381018-00381293": "really quickly so solar cheap to build", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01634-00381294-00381532": "absolutely operates 25 of the time what", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01635-00381533-00381695": "are you doing the other 75 percent of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01636-00381696-00381797": "the time", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01637-00381798-00381882": "yeah", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01638-00381883-00382097": "more expensive to build at the beginning", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01639-00382098-00382427": "absolutely true but it's capacity Factor", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01640-00382428-00382727": "the world average is about I think 83 us", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01641-00382728-00382960": "runs is at 93 percent", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01642-00382961-00383080": "it's like you know what's going to be", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01643-00383081-00383291": "operated when you need it solar and wind", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01644-00383292-00383482": "may be there when you admit it may not", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01645-00383483-00383627": "be there when you need it and if you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01646-00383628-00383771": "don't have those what's your other low", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01647-00383772-00384077": "carbon technology that you're using at", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01648-00384078-00384371": "those times so Hydro is an option yep um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01649-00384372-00384647": "some kind of batteries but the batteries", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01650-00384648-00384869": "we have now the big batches are as um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01651-00384870-00385054": "Tyrone said they're not there to back up", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01652-00385055-00385199": "the grid they're there to supply the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01653-00385200-00385421": "stability things like frequency and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01654-00385422-00385547": "voltage right they're not there if it's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01655-00385548-00385763": "a backup system", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01656-00385764-00386069": "um also lcoa does include some storage I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01657-00386070-00386267": "think by I think it's soldered with five", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01658-00386268-00386417": "hours of battery backup or something", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01659-00386418-00386543": "like that but", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01660-00386544-00386737": "what does that mean", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01661-00386738-00387047": "yeah yeah they're complicated reports", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01662-00387048-00387256": "from my perspective it's hard thing to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01663-00387257-00387454": "understand", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01664-00387455-00387628": "um but the good thing is you can use", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01665-00387629-00387815": "like some people think that nuclear and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01666-00387816-00387982": "Renewables are against each other", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01667-00387983-00388187": "I don't see that I see them as being", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01668-00388188-00388439": "very supportive of each other nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01669-00388440-00388577": "could be dispatchable in there when you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01670-00388578-00388660": "need it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01671-00388661-00388919": "and solar and wind can come and charge", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01672-00388920-00389182": "batteries and make hydrogen and do", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01673-00389183-00389332": "whatever right they can work together it", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01674-00389333-00389477": "doesn't have to be a big fight between", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01675-00389478-00389903": "the two yeah I think the main um the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01676-00389904-00390154": "main hindrance is the Fear Factor and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01677-00390155-00390382": "it's really unfortunate um that nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01678-00390383-00390671": "war is being talked about and so yeah", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01679-00390672-00390923": "people just go nuclear no thanks we'll", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01680-00390924-00391067": "have to work on that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01681-00391068-00391349": "I will show you one I was going to pull", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01682-00391350-00391528": "this one up before", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01683-00391529-00391745": "this is from our welding data again if I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01684-00391746-00391919": "can work out how to make it big is that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01685-00391920-00392056": "displaying okay", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01686-00392057-00392165": "yes", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01687-00392166-00392399": "I don't really like talking about death", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01688-00392400-00392693": "rates and this is one part of energy", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01689-00392694-00392873": "considerations because one of the other", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01690-00392874-00393082": "tragedies of shinobang Fukushima as we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01691-00393083-00393256": "said before was people getting displaced", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01692-00393257-00393497": "and having their lives turned upside", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01693-00393498-00393695": "down but if you look at the actual", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01694-00393696-00393889": "impacts of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01695-00393890-00394127": "accidents and these various Technologies", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01696-00394128-00394325": "against each other in terms of how many", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01697-00394326-00394582": "people die as a result and this does", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01698-00394583-00394823": "include because she imaginable in this", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01699-00394824-00394984": "in this data", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01700-00394985-00395249": "as I say to people nuclear is as safe as", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01701-00395250-00395495": "wind and solar", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01702-00395496-00395693": "in terms of just the the number of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01703-00395694-00395980": "fatalities um being caused by the whole", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01704-00395981-00396232": "or all aspects of these Technologies", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01705-00396233-00396749": "look at coal I mean", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01706-00396750-00396989": "another tragedy of shinovo from my", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01707-00396990-00397163": "perspective you know in particular is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01708-00397164-00397289": "that it really turned the Western", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01709-00397290-00397469": "countries off", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01710-00397470-00397691": "continue to build more nuclear so I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01711-00397692-00397841": "don't know I've seen an estimate of how", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01712-00397842-00398021": "many", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01713-00398022-00398225": "um lives have been saved by nuclear", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01714-00398226-00398478": "energy through reducing um air pollution", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01715-00398479-00398680": "something in the order of several", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01716-00398681-00398795": "million", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01717-00398796-00399041": "so just say Chernobyl hadn't happened", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01718-00399042-00399227": "um and the Western World and everyone", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01719-00399228-00399497": "kept building nuclear reactors what will", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01720-00399498-00399658": "that put us now in terms of climate", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01721-00399659-00399880": "change we want to put us now in terms of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01722-00399881-00400049": "air pollution like these things would be", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01723-00400050-00400204": "a much lesser problems than they are", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01724-00400205-00400391": "today", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01725-00400392-00400606": "anyway there's some data our building", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01726-00400607-00400787": "data they've got a great", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01727-00400788-00401002": "um okay like an article on how they get", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01728-00401003-00401213": "to these numbers too don't just take my", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01729-00401214-00401458": "word for it that nuclear is as safe as", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01730-00401459-00401627": "uh as Renewables go and have a look", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01731-00401628-00401819": "yourself just to see how they they came", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01732-00401820-00402082": "to these numbers", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01733-00402083-00402341": "fantastic thanks Joe I will probably go", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01734-00402342-00402497": "for about another five minutes and then", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01735-00402498-00402706": "we'll have to wrap up as uh we've been", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01736-00402707-00402899": "going for a little while now", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01737-00402900-00403097": "um we do have one more question from", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01738-00403098-00403408": "chats uh which was", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01739-00403409-00403739": "uh ignoring the the political issues and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01740-00403740-00403984": "the planning processes from", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01741-00403985-00404225": "starting a construction to finish to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01742-00404226-00404465": "turning their reactor on how long would", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01743-00404466-00404734": "it take to build roughly from studying", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01744-00404735-00404969": "the construction to turning the reactor", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01745-00404970-00405106": "on yeah", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01746-00405107-00405389": "it depends what you're building and that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01747-00405390-00405556": "might sound like a cop-out if you're", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01748-00405557-00405773": "building one of the bigger units you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01749-00405774-00405989": "probably", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01750-00405990-00406163": "how long is a piece of string some", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01751-00406164-00406265": "countries are really good at building", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01752-00406266-00406469": "these things at the moment South Korea", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01753-00406470-00406589": "has just built a whole lot of new", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01754-00406590-00406858": "reactors in the United Arab Emirates", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01755-00406859-00407069": "they built four reactors three are", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01756-00407070-00407267": "online the fourth ones I think", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01757-00407268-00407447": "undergoing commissioning they started in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01758-00407448-00407680": "2009", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01759-00407681-00408004": "2009 to the first one I think online 20", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01760-00408005-00408227": "well I can't remember but they almost", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01761-00408228-00408467": "got their fourth one online so what is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01762-00408468-00408658": "that 13 years", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01763-00408659-00408904": "that's for Five Points", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01764-00408905-00409265": "two gigawatts I think quite a bit", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01765-00409266-00409463": "small modular reactors the whole I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01766-00409464-00409697": "reason why they're they're popular and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01767-00409697-00409805": "they're getting promoted and they're", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01768-00409806-00409984": "getting developed and worked on is the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01769-00409985-00410224": "idea that big reactors are taking a long", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01770-00410225-00410441": "time to build", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01771-00410442-00410639": "more than half the price for a lot of", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01772-00410639-00410926": "big reactor projects isn't it is is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01773-00410927-00411172": "interest on the loans right that's a lot", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01774-00411173-00411299": "of interest that these construction", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01775-00411300-00411472": "people and then the advantages of paying", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01776-00411473-00411737": "idea about small modular reactors is you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01777-00411738-00411880": "don't build a reactor on the site and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01778-00411881-00412091": "you build a reactor in a factory it's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01779-00412092-00412270": "small you make", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01780-00412271-00412553": "the same thing over and over and over", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01781-00412554-00412816": "again to high levels of quality if you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01782-00412817-00412972": "do this you should be able to build them", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01783-00412973-00413122": "a lot more cheaply in a factory right", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01784-00413123-00413351": "than on somebody's site and then you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01785-00413352-00413566": "ship them off and they just join all the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01786-00413567-00413699": "components together", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01787-00413700-00413891": "so how long", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01788-00413892-00414172": "oh different um vendors are quoting", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01789-00414173-00414359": "different numbers and I'll pull one out", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01790-00414360-00414484": "of the air and say they're looking at", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01791-00414485-00414610": "about maybe three years of a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01792-00414612-00414820": "construction time", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01793-00414821-00415024": "does that sounded about right Tyrone you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01794-00415025-00415216": "know a fair bit about this stuff too", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01795-00415217-00415493": "yeah it uh globally the average is about", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01796-00415493-00415703": "six to eight years for a large reactor", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01797-00415704-00416003": "and the smrs are there hoping for around", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01798-00416004-00416357": "three to five years depending on the SMR", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01799-00416358-00416543": "is a very broad term you've got", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01800-00416543-00416770": "something as small as you know a couple", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01801-00416771-00417034": "of uh like a couple of dozen uh", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01802-00417035-00417370": "megawatts to something like the bwrx", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01803-00417371-00417701": "which is like 300 megawatts so it's a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01804-00417702-00417887": "big range so that that's where the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01805-00417888-00418126": "variability comes from uh it's also", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01806-00418127-00418307": "important to put this in context that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01807-00418308-00418474": "something like the star of the South", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01808-00418475-00418666": "which is the big offshore winter", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01809-00418667-00418780": "um farm that they're building off", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01810-00418781-00419020": "Victoria that's expected to take about", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01811-00419021-00419393": "10 years to construct for roughly the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01812-00419393-00419699": "same amount of megawatts as a large", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01813-00419700-00420041": "nuclear reactor so it's similar time", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01814-00420042-00420341": "scales for a similar price as well for a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01815-00420342-00420581": "similar price as well yes so it is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01816-00420582-00420809": "important to put these in context", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01817-00420810-00421325": "um that this is this is a big job to to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01818-00421326-00421607": "transition the Energy System uh which is", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01819-00421608-00421793": "not just the current electricity as well", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01820-00421793-00422087": "it's transport it's uh the chemicals", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01821-00422088-00422303": "industry it's it's all those", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01822-00422304-00422543": "um sectors that need to be electrified", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01823-00422543-00422872": "and and transitioned across so this is a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01824-00422873-00423070": "big Challenge and we really thank you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01825-00423071-00423347": "Joe for coming along and uh helping us", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01826-00423347-00423509": "this evening understand more about", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01827-00423510-00423760": "nuclear uh and as you said in your talk", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01828-00423762-00423977": "at the start it's it's more than just", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01829-00423978-00424193": "energy as well it's it's medicine and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01830-00424193-00424397": "it's it's industrial processes and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01831-00424397-00424559": "things like that", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01832-00424560-00424883": "um uh sorry Saha has one more question", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01833-00424884-00425464": "and then we will answer", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01834-00425465-00425639": "they go Saha I've given you the ability", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01835-00425639-00426016": "oh thanks oh no we just received a very", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01836-00426017-00426220": "um detailed email recently", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01837-00426221-00426497": "um from some of our members uh that have", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01838-00426497-00426695": "concerns about nuclear and I think you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01839-00426696-00426947": "know we really want to help educate", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01840-00426947-00427222": "everyone including myself just to be", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01841-00427223-00427409": "more informed about you know where we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01842-00427410-00427697": "position with nuclear so", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01843-00427697-00427889": "um if you don't mind are you happy if we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01844-00427889-00428141": "can share an email with you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01845-00428142-00428218": "um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01846-00428219-00428537": "outside of this to get your take on it I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01847-00428538-00428783": "think that would be really useful", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01848-00428784-00429010": "um absolutely I would um love to read", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01849-00429012-00429299": "the email and have a look um what I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01850-00429300-00429581": "really do enjoy though is is talking to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01851-00429582-00429755": "people and trying to understand their", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01852-00429756-00429947": "concerns and trying to come to a bit", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01853-00429947-00430114": "more of a mutual understanding so I'll", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01854-00430115-00430463": "definitely take a look and I I might", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01855-00430464-00430768": "come back and say I would love to have a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01856-00430769-00431033": "churn yeah that's a good idea coffee", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01857-00431034-00431243": "beer online if you're not in the same", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01858-00431243-00431393": "state as each other", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01859-00431393-00431543": "um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01860-00431543-00431789": "whatever works because if people have", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01861-00431789-00431968": "concerns about", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01862-00431969-00432227": "anything I mean people don't have to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01863-00432228-00432443": "engage me with me or anybody else if", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01864-00432443-00432593": "they don't choose to I'm not going to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01865-00432593-00432797": "put that sort of pressure on but the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01866-00432797-00433001": "offer is there because because maybe I'm", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01867-00433002-00433247": "wrong maybe I've missed something I", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01868-00433247-00433463": "sometimes check myself and say I think", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01869-00433464-00433727": "this technology it has its flaws and its", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01870-00433728-00433870": "faults but at the same time I think it's", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01871-00433871-00434209": "the best we've got at the moment to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01872-00434210-00434555": "decarbonize actually get to Net Zero and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01873-00434556-00434879": "also offer reliable um electricity at", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01874-00434880-00435070": "probably the lowest price in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01875-00435071-00435322": "conjunctions with Renewables as well am", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01876-00435323-00435460": "I missing something", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01877-00435462-00435575": "yeah", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01878-00435576-00435881": "maybe I am so yeah maybe I can be", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01879-00435882-00436109": "convinced that I should be talking about", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01880-00436110-00436366": "100 renewable future or some other some", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01881-00436367-00436601": "other future yeah I like that it's a", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01882-00436602-00436720": "good approach", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01883-00436721-00436943": "um we are thinking we we should have", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01884-00436943-00437081": "more of a chat", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01885-00437082-00437333": "um so I'll I'll get your take on it and", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01886-00437334-00437503": "then yeah we should have more", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01887-00437504-00437693": "intermember chats about these", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01888-00437693-00437981": "contentious topics thanks", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01889-00437982-00438287": "if the greens party in the Finland can", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01890-00438288-00438455": "go from walking out of parliament in", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01891-00438456-00438689": "about 2000 because Finland decided to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01892-00438689-00438964": "build more nuclear power plants to now", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01893-00438965-00439216": "doing a full 180 and being the first", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01894-00439217-00439493": "greens party in the world to support uh", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01895-00439493-00439672": "nuclear energy there's no reason why", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01896-00439673-00439889": "other greens parties couldn't do similar", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01897-00439889-00440225": "or other other political parties um", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01898-00440226-00440422": "I think the Scandinavians are very", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01899-00440423-00440627": "practical people", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01900-00440628-00440909": "um they can manage to get communities to", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01901-00440910-00441041": "bid", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01902-00441042-00441287": "to host a nuclear waste disposal", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01903-00441288-00441466": "facility that that's pretty good right", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01904-00441467-00441616": "they have the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01905-00441617-00441851": "the education programs and the the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01906-00441852-00442043": "communication going on that brings", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01907-00442043-00442210": "people comfort and then says yeah we'll", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01908-00442212-00442427": "have that high level waste disposal", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01909-00442428-00442685": "facility yeah we'll have it thank you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01910-00442685-00442864": "um I'm not quite sure Australia's there", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01911-00442865-00443045": "yet but I'm doing my best and other", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01912-00443046-00443170": "people are doing their best just to have", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01913-00443171-00443320": "these conversations so thank you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01914-00443321-00443453": "everyone for your wonderful questions", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01915-00443454-00443801": "and for coming on and listening", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01916-00443802-00443975": "um if you do have any other follow-up", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01917-00443976-00444125": "questions uh please send them through", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01918-00444126-00444359": "and I'll do my best to answer them", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01919-00444360-00444593": "great thank you so much Joe and thank", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01920-00444593-00444766": "you everyone for coming along this", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01921-00444767-00445007": "evening and asking your questions uh", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01922-00445008-00445193": "this is the kind of discussion that we", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01923-00445193-00445325": "want to be having so that we can", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01924-00445326-00445553": "progress policy development and just", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01925-00445554-00445768": "general Community understanding of the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01926-00445769-00445966": "different Technologies and policy areas", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01927-00445967-00446260": "uh that hopefully can make our country", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01928-00446262-00446579": "and world a better place so uh thank you", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01929-00446580-00446831": "everyone for coming and uh enjoy the", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01930-00446832-00447041": "rest of the evening", "Wq2FG3mneoA-01931-00447042-00447271": "thanks"}}, {"audio_id": "WqbAm14o5PU", "text": {"WqbAm14o5PU-00000-00000046-00000286": "[Music]", "WqbAm14o5PU-00001-00000287-00000445": "foreign", "WqbAm14o5PU-00002-00000446-00001783": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "WqbOzxRRioc", "text": {"WqbOzxRRioc-00000-00000000-00002509": "[Music]", "WqbOzxRRioc-00001-00002510-00003522": "[Music]", "WqbOzxRRioc-00002-00003524-00007482": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "WrA-Zedp3rQ", "text": {"WrA-Zedp3rQ-00000-00000000-00000218": "this is the Earl mud commit video", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00001-00000219-00000611": "comment for Earl mud commit b0 ii eight", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00002-00000612-00001043": "cf5 one Bravo zero echo eight Charlie", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00003-00001044-00001501": "Foxtrot fr5 one rather and what we got", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00004-00001502-00001918": "September 26 log test output to file if", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00005-00001919-00002129": "there's tons of log messages flying by", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00006-00002130-00002291": "it's easier to look at the logs in a", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00007-00002292-00002785": "text editor then in the shell so I'm oh", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00008-00002786-00003175": "this is all I did I use the the Linux or", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00009-00003176-00003572": "UNIX t command so you take you you set", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00010-00003572-00003809": "the path and then run make and common", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00011-00003810-00004061": "tests and that will run your makes your", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00012-00004061-00004328": "your test rather your makes and then I", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00013-00004329-00004604": "pipe that to the T command and I t that", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00014-00004605-00004879": "to the outfile so it'll it'll write that", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00015-00004880-00005069": "to the outfile but it'll also print it", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00016-00005070-00005249": "to standard out so we can see what's", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00017-00005250-00005438": "going on but then if there's tons of log", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00018-00005439-00005666": "output and there shouldn't be now at", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00019-00005667-00006202": "this at the 29th today of September 2015", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00020-00006203-00006514": "if there's tons of output to this to the", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00021-00006515-00006698": "shell you can open up a file and read", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00022-00006698-00006908": "that makes it much easier and you can do", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00023-00006909-00007039": "fine and jump around stuff like that's", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00024-00007040-00007178": "not really convenient to read in the", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00025-00007179-00007520": "shell so that is the Earl mud commit", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00026-00007520-00008131": "video comment for commit b0e 8c f 51", "WrA-Zedp3rQ-00027-00008133-00008792": "Bravo zero echo eight Charlie Foxtrot 51"}}, {"audio_id": "WrVSEES8EY8", "text": {"WrVSEES8EY8-00000-00000016-00000238": "what's good y'all welcome back to ranked", "WrVSEES8EY8-00001-00000239-00000351": "1v1", "WrVSEES8EY8-00002-00000352-00000655": "road to diamond and today we start off a", "WrVSEES8EY8-00003-00000656-00000782": "little bit different we", "WrVSEES8EY8-00004-00000783-00000991": "we doing something we don't you don't", "WrVSEES8EY8-00005-00000992-00001183": "ever really see us doing that play lance", "WrVSEES8EY8-00006-00001184-00001415": "i'm playing scarlett right now um i've", "WrVSEES8EY8-00007-00001416-00001614": "been playing her i've been playing her i", "WrVSEES8EY8-00008-00001616-00001759": "decided if you can't beat them", "WrVSEES8EY8-00009-00001760-00002039": "join them okay and i suck at doing", "WrVSEES8EY8-00010-00002039-00002183": "commentary while fighting so let me kind", "WrVSEES8EY8-00011-00002184-00002375": "of focus on this real quick", "WrVSEES8EY8-00012-00002376-00002518": "i'm gonna say things here and there but", "WrVSEES8EY8-00013-00002519-00002710": "like oh oh we lagging", "WrVSEES8EY8-00014-00002711-00003118": "are we lagging okay", "WrVSEES8EY8-00015-00003119-00003575": "all right go man watch out bro", "WrVSEES8EY8-00016-00003576-00004599": "that was cute no that's cute and all", "WrVSEES8EY8-00017-00004600-00004870": "you see this [__] bruh it's like i feel", "WrVSEES8EY8-00018-00004871-00005079": "bad playing it", "WrVSEES8EY8-00019-00005080-00005391": "but it's like at the same time like", "WrVSEES8EY8-00020-00005392-00005535": "i like scarlett she's kind of fun i'm", "WrVSEES8EY8-00021-00005536-00005727": "not gonna lie", "WrVSEES8EY8-00022-00005728-00005943": "i like hammer too like i'm gonna oh okay", "WrVSEES8EY8-00023-00005944-00006031": "i got white", "WrVSEES8EY8-00024-00006032-00006286": "i'm a hammer player so hammer hammer is", "WrVSEES8EY8-00025-00006287-00006486": "my thing", "WrVSEES8EY8-00026-00006487-00006767": "one of my first names is sentinel so now", "WrVSEES8EY8-00027-00006768-00007431": "that goes", "WrVSEES8EY8-00028-00007431-00007559": "that was a filled spike but i didn't", "WrVSEES8EY8-00029-00007559-00009471": "need it anyway so", "WrVSEES8EY8-00030-00009472-00009883": "oh he caught me slipped down a while for", "WrVSEES8EY8-00031-00009884-00010423": "that", "WrVSEES8EY8-00032-00010424-00010999": "oh no are we living we living", "WrVSEES8EY8-00033-00011000-00011223": "all right hold on because what you're", "WrVSEES8EY8-00034-00011224-00011583": "not gonna do", "WrVSEES8EY8-00035-00011584-00011903": "i got the same sick okay i got punished", "WrVSEES8EY8-00036-00011904-00012399": "for doing that okay my bad", "WrVSEES8EY8-00037-00012400-00012703": "go get out of here like like bye", "WrVSEES8EY8-00038-00012704-00012966": "like i don't want you here no more now i", "WrVSEES8EY8-00039-00012967-00013015": "gotta", "WrVSEES8EY8-00040-00013016-00015207": "now i gotta mix you up", "WrVSEES8EY8-00041-00015208-00016294": "oh nice catch", "WrVSEES8EY8-00042-00016295-00018283": "i almost folded it on myself", "WrVSEES8EY8-00043-00018284-00019919": "cool", "WrVSEES8EY8-00044-00019920-00020150": "okay we're close we're close let's not", "WrVSEES8EY8-00045-00020151-00020630": "get anxious though", "WrVSEES8EY8-00046-00020631-00021750": "be a little patient see", "WrVSEES8EY8-00047-00021751-00022030": "yes sir all right we took our first dub", "WrVSEES8EY8-00048-00022031-00022158": "let's go first", "WrVSEES8EY8-00049-00022159-00022343": "now as i can see i'm in a different clan", "WrVSEES8EY8-00050-00022344-00022494": "i was just joined today some random", "WrVSEES8EY8-00051-00022495-00022622": "people um", "WrVSEES8EY8-00052-00022623-00022903": "i figured why not uh as y'all know i", "WrVSEES8EY8-00053-00022904-00023055": "used to be in a clan called big", "WrVSEES8EY8-00054-00023056-00023375": "[__] shmeet yes it was a medium and my", "WrVSEES8EY8-00055-00023376-00023486": "friends but i was the only one in it", "WrVSEES8EY8-00056-00023487-00023583": "because i'm the only one who played on", "WrVSEES8EY8-00057-00023584-00023647": "pc", "WrVSEES8EY8-00058-00023648-00023975": "so they weren't really on it but they", "WrVSEES8EY8-00059-00023976-00026662": "were in it by spirit", "WrVSEES8EY8-00060-00026663-00028062": "i'll take it i'll take it", "WrVSEES8EY8-00061-00028063-00028311": "you see this y'all why am i playing", "WrVSEES8EY8-00062-00028312-00028446": "significantly better", "WrVSEES8EY8-00063-00028447-00028807": "with lance like what's going on huh", "WrVSEES8EY8-00064-00028808-00029483": "it's for sure not an easy mode weapon", "WrVSEES8EY8-00065-00029483-00030883": "ouch", "WrVSEES8EY8-00066-00030883-00031062": "okay", "WrVSEES8EY8-00067-00031063-00031623": "that was a good seat", "WrVSEES8EY8-00068-00031624-00031846": "what if you could steal weapons like if", "WrVSEES8EY8-00069-00031847-00032318": "y'all have the same weapon", "WrVSEES8EY8-00070-00032319-00032623": "like you can pretty much like steal it", "WrVSEES8EY8-00071-00032624-00032951": "if they throw it would that be cool", "WrVSEES8EY8-00072-00032952-00033683": "would that be broken", "WrVSEES8EY8-00073-00033684-00034799": "oh", "WrVSEES8EY8-00074-00034800-00035839": "no i wanted to live", "WrVSEES8EY8-00075-00035840-00038527": "okay bro", "WrVSEES8EY8-00076-00038528-00038862": "there we go that should be game yes sir", "WrVSEES8EY8-00077-00038863-00039271": "another w another w um okay so we have", "WrVSEES8EY8-00078-00039272-00039439": "some close matches but we're slowly", "WrVSEES8EY8-00079-00039440-00039590": "growing with scarlet we're kind of uh", "WrVSEES8EY8-00080-00039591-00039711": "getting some yellow", "WrVSEES8EY8-00081-00039712-00039879": "so i can't be too mad at it i just gotta", "WrVSEES8EY8-00082-00039880-00042087": "play a little bit more patience", "WrVSEES8EY8-00083-00042088-00043262": "oh man", "WrVSEES8EY8-00084-00043263-00043567": "oh no", "WrVSEES8EY8-00085-00043568-00043767": "oh yeah i'll take it i'll take it the", "WrVSEES8EY8-00086-00043768-00043935": "easy [__] the easy gift", "WrVSEES8EY8-00087-00043936-00046283": "actually pick that up", "WrVSEES8EY8-00088-00046284-00047574": "oh", "WrVSEES8EY8-00089-00047575-00047774": "and worst part is i have not practiced", "WrVSEES8EY8-00090-00047775-00047983": "lance at all", "WrVSEES8EY8-00091-00047984-00048207": "i just kind of just grabbed it and just", "WrVSEES8EY8-00092-00048208-00048351": "kind of knew what to do already because", "WrVSEES8EY8-00093-00048352-00049015": "i've seen it", "WrVSEES8EY8-00094-00049016-00049318": "okay we managed to take that start", "WrVSEES8EY8-00095-00049319-00049535": "we got to be a little careful because i", "WrVSEES8EY8-00096-00049536-00050007": "can tell he's definitely a good player", "WrVSEES8EY8-00097-00050008-00050207": "it's just i'm kind of okay look at this", "WrVSEES8EY8-00098-00050208-00054521": "look at this leg see i got a", "WrVSEES8EY8-00099-00054522-00054711": "[Music]", "WrVSEES8EY8-00100-00054712-00056423": "say boop", "WrVSEES8EY8-00101-00056424-00056582": "i can't let him be slick i can't let him", "WrVSEES8EY8-00102-00056583-00056815": "be slick gotta take that", "WrVSEES8EY8-00103-00056816-00057030": "that's three dubs in the road we're", "WrVSEES8EY8-00104-00057032-00057271": "doing great right now with scarlett", "WrVSEES8EY8-00105-00057272-00057623": "we're doing great okay i gotta be", "WrVSEES8EY8-00106-00057624-00057759": "careful with this dude because", "WrVSEES8EY8-00107-00057760-00058407": "he likes going up the side", "WrVSEES8EY8-00108-00058408-00058719": "but he's not even there and he's a side", "WrVSEES8EY8-00109-00058720-00058854": "area", "WrVSEES8EY8-00110-00058855-00059135": "and dash exactly so like i had to be", "WrVSEES8EY8-00111-00059136-00059215": "very aware", "WrVSEES8EY8-00112-00059216-00059535": "of how he's playing because like bro", "WrVSEES8EY8-00113-00059536-00059863": "like relax like", "WrVSEES8EY8-00114-00059864-00060903": "what are you doing", "WrVSEES8EY8-00115-00060904-00062582": "that's cool that's cool", "WrVSEES8EY8-00116-00062583-00062887": "say he attacks he's waiting for me to", "WrVSEES8EY8-00117-00062888-00064366": "move the whole time", "WrVSEES8EY8-00118-00064367-00064654": "i don't even do that they hold me and", "WrVSEES8EY8-00119-00064655-00064679": "they", "WrVSEES8EY8-00120-00064679-00065006": "get me in there got that gold in the", "WrVSEES8EY8-00121-00065007-00065094": "black and gold", "WrVSEES8EY8-00122-00065095-00065375": "okay i like that i like that i've never", "WrVSEES8EY8-00123-00065376-00065711": "seen those colors", "WrVSEES8EY8-00124-00065712-00066015": "unless that's his haunting color", "WrVSEES8EY8-00125-00066016-00068143": "where's the burning", "WrVSEES8EY8-00126-00068144-00068438": "yes sir all right we take first stop", "WrVSEES8EY8-00127-00068439-00068550": "let's just", "WrVSEES8EY8-00128-00068551-00068823": "try to you know take this one out", "WrVSEES8EY8-00129-00068824-00068911": "there's a vector", "WrVSEES8EY8-00130-00068912-00069159": "and that's exactly why i was about to", "WrVSEES8EY8-00131-00069160-00071079": "say that", "WrVSEES8EY8-00132-00071080-00071482": "did we snub that down so we took that", "WrVSEES8EY8-00133-00071483-00072055": "stock", "WrVSEES8EY8-00134-00072056-00072838": "hold on", "WrVSEES8EY8-00135-00072839-00076167": "we stop that nevermind", "WrVSEES8EY8-00136-00076168-00077671": "oh no", "WrVSEES8EY8-00137-00077672-00077806": "all right we got them down to the last", "WrVSEES8EY8-00138-00077807-00078079": "stock i don't know", "WrVSEES8EY8-00139-00078080-00078319": "it's looking pretty good i ain't gonna", "WrVSEES8EY8-00140-00078320-00079294": "jinx it", "WrVSEES8EY8-00141-00079295-00079479": "bro look how much damage i gave this man", "WrVSEES8EY8-00142-00079480-00079711": "already he has bro he has red health his", "WrVSEES8EY8-00143-00079712-00079911": "health is darker than mine", "WrVSEES8EY8-00144-00079912-00081282": "and y'all saying this weapon are broken", "WrVSEES8EY8-00145-00081283-00081959": "bro", "WrVSEES8EY8-00146-00081960-00083671": "thank you weapon", "WrVSEES8EY8-00147-00083672-00083975": "no i messed it up it's all good", "WrVSEES8EY8-00148-00083976-00084135": "i tell the russian market i ain't gonna", "WrVSEES8EY8-00149-00084136-00084318": "lie", "WrVSEES8EY8-00150-00084319-00084631": "the weapon is still broken but", "WrVSEES8EY8-00151-00084632-00084823": "i'm just low-key getting off on it i'm", "WrVSEES8EY8-00152-00084824-00085103": "exploiting it i'm exploiting it", "WrVSEES8EY8-00153-00085104-00085231": "some people don't think it's broken some", "WrVSEES8EY8-00154-00085232-00085343": "people think it should be nerfed some", "WrVSEES8EY8-00155-00085344-00085503": "people think you don't need to be nerve", "WrVSEES8EY8-00156-00085504-00085623": "you know everybody's opening is", "WrVSEES8EY8-00157-00085624-00085831": "different especially since everybody", "WrVSEES8EY8-00158-00085832-00085967": "makes different weapons", "WrVSEES8EY8-00159-00085968-00086150": "some people favorite some people hate it", "WrVSEES8EY8-00160-00086151-00086318": "you know some people are neutral", "WrVSEES8EY8-00161-00086319-00088282": "i get it but like man i don't know", "WrVSEES8EY8-00162-00088283-00089487": "so", "WrVSEES8EY8-00163-00089488-00089782": "yes sir okay we took that took out", "WrVSEES8EY8-00164-00089783-00090935": "pretty fast which is good", "WrVSEES8EY8-00165-00090936-00091726": "i touch wall i'm good", "WrVSEES8EY8-00166-00091727-00092511": "all right oh wait wait wait", "WrVSEES8EY8-00167-00092512-00094062": "that should be death there we go", "WrVSEES8EY8-00168-00094063-00096687": "now that's dead", "WrVSEES8EY8-00169-00096688-00096847": "okay i'll take it well that was a three", "WrVSEES8EY8-00170-00096848-00096991": "start", "WrVSEES8EY8-00171-00096992-00097511": "oh wow gg man gg", "WrVSEES8EY8-00172-00097512-00097823": "i'm so close we're getting that i'm", "WrVSEES8EY8-00173-00097824-00097894": "sorry y'all", "WrVSEES8EY8-00174-00097895-00098111": "we're getting it we gotta get i'm right", "WrVSEES8EY8-00175-00098112-00098199": "here i'm", "WrVSEES8EY8-00176-00098200-00098431": "literally right here i gotta i gotta win", "WrVSEES8EY8-00177-00098432-00098591": "this next one", "WrVSEES8EY8-00178-00098592-00100882": "hopefully this will be our last match", "WrVSEES8EY8-00179-00100883-00102615": "so", "WrVSEES8EY8-00180-00102616-00102751": "i kind of figured she was going to do", "WrVSEES8EY8-00181-00102752-00102910": "that too because a lot of yumiko's tend", "WrVSEES8EY8-00182-00102911-00103054": "to do that", "WrVSEES8EY8-00183-00103055-00103254": "i figured i was waiting for it so i was", "WrVSEES8EY8-00184-00103255-00103454": "like okay if he does it", "WrVSEES8EY8-00185-00103455-00107883": "again that's a free fight", "WrVSEES8EY8-00186-00107883-00108086": "oh", "WrVSEES8EY8-00187-00108088-00108599": "oh man", "WrVSEES8EY8-00188-00108600-00109158": "he wants my head right now", "WrVSEES8EY8-00189-00109159-00109390": "he disconnected oh that's for year", "WrVSEES8EY8-00190-00109391-00109502": "locked", "WrVSEES8EY8-00191-00109503-00109639": "[__] if y'all enjoyed this video wrote", "WrVSEES8EY8-00192-00109640-00109902": "to diamond um we hit plat one", "WrVSEES8EY8-00193-00109903-00110151": "which is pretty dope uh make sure to", "WrVSEES8EY8-00194-00110152-00110295": "like if you haven't already subscribed", "WrVSEES8EY8-00195-00110296-00110399": "to blue", "WrVSEES8EY8-00196-00110400-00110727": "and more road to diner videos are coming", "WrVSEES8EY8-00197-00110728-00110815": "soon", "WrVSEES8EY8-00198-00110816-00111039": "i'm still kind of on my late night daily", "WrVSEES8EY8-00199-00111040-00111190": "grind i need to change the schedule a", "WrVSEES8EY8-00200-00111191-00111334": "bit honestly because it's not a good", "WrVSEES8EY8-00201-00111335-00111439": "schedule", "WrVSEES8EY8-00202-00111440-00111663": "but you know it is what it is we don't", "WrVSEES8EY8-00203-00111664-00111766": "figure it out", "WrVSEES8EY8-00204-00111767-00112319": "but yeah let's make sure we even hit the", "WrVSEES8EY8-00205-00112320-00112783": "um can i rush your mafia to bot hold on", "WrVSEES8EY8-00206-00112783-00113134": "and we hit it 1692 i believe that one is", "WrVSEES8EY8-00207-00113135-00113510": "1681 so yeah we hit that we hit that", "WrVSEES8EY8-00208-00113511-00113807": "we're here platinum one um now it's it's", "WrVSEES8EY8-00209-00113808-00113934": "time to start climbing the rest of the", "WrVSEES8EY8-00210-00113935-00113975": "play", "WrVSEES8EY8-00211-00113976-00114127": "and we don't eventually make it to", "WrVSEES8EY8-00212-00114128-00114302": "diamond i believe we're gonna make it to", "WrVSEES8EY8-00213-00114303-00114423": "diamond the more we're playing the more", "WrVSEES8EY8-00214-00114424-00114558": "we practicing and stuff", "WrVSEES8EY8-00215-00114559-00114702": "we're gonna make it to the diamond for", "WrVSEES8EY8-00216-00114703-00114951": "sure but yeah like i said leave a like", "WrVSEES8EY8-00217-00114952-00115086": "join my discord", "WrVSEES8EY8-00218-00115088-00115278": "uh the link is in the description below", "WrVSEES8EY8-00219-00115279-00115454": "with all my socials follow my socials", "WrVSEES8EY8-00220-00115455-00115551": "and stuff", "WrVSEES8EY8-00221-00115552-00116683": "and yeah i'm gonna try the next video", "WrVSEES8EY8-00222-00116683-00117382": "[Music]", "WrVSEES8EY8-00223-00117383-00117524": "[Applause]", "WrVSEES8EY8-00224-00117525-00117577": "[Music]", "WrVSEES8EY8-00225-00117578-00118041": "[Applause]", "WrVSEES8EY8-00226-00118042-00118919": "[Music]", "WrVSEES8EY8-00227-00118920-00119135": "quick"}}]