[{"audio_id": "Wku9Ay7gR4g", "text": {"Wku9Ay7gR4g-00000-00000039-00000238": "okay so let's take a quick look at this", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00001-00000239-00000471": "one the effect of emotion management on", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00002-00000472-00000703": "nurse's job performance during pandemic", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00003-00000704-00000854": "coveted 19.", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00004-00000855-00001015": "so one of the things you'll notice is", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00005-00001016-00001191": "that unlike the other one we just looked", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00006-00001192-00001247": "at", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00007-00001248-00001478": "this one has that structured abstract", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00008-00001479-00001599": "that i was telling you about so they've", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00009-00001600-00001751": "got a background section", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00010-00001752-00001951": "a method section a results section a", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00011-00001952-00002095": "conclusion section", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00012-00002096-00002302": "and a recommendation section right in", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00013-00002303-00002447": "their abstract", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00014-00002448-00002591": "so one of the things we can look at", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00015-00002592-00002742": "right off the bat in a convenience", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00016-00002743-00002999": "sampling 110 nurses from taylor general", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00017-00003000-00003254": "hospital completed an online survey", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00018-00003255-00003511": "assessing em and np which is emotional", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00019-00003511-00003631": "management", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00020-00003632-00003870": "and nurse performance during covert 19", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00021-00003871-00003959": "climax", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00022-00003960-00004406": "levels in march and may of 2020.", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00023-00004407-00004583": "only nurses who had direct contact with", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00024-00004584-00004783": "patients diagnosed with kovid19 were", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00025-00004784-00004959": "eligible", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00026-00004960-00005222": "katherine managing emotional skill was", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00027-00005223-00005422": "used in a cross-sectional", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00028-00005423-00005683": "design to determine participants", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00029-00005684-00005822": "emotional", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00030-00005823-00006318": "management empirically", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00031-00006319-00006727": "nurse performance scale", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00032-00006728-00007063": "was measured by then that doesn't make", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00033-00007064-00007255": "sense empirically nurse", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00034-00007256-00007591": "performance scale was measured by", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00035-00007592-00007942": "nurse performance scale okay", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00036-00007943-00008207": "and again i mentioned to you know the", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00037-00008208-00008278": "idea that", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00038-00008279-00008487": "for at least four people have reviewed", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00039-00008488-00008719": "that and nobody picked up that", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00040-00008720-00008895": "error right there because that is an", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00041-00008896-00009039": "error first of all in", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00042-00009040-00009303": "ps hasn't been abbreviated prior to this", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00043-00009304-00009399": "so", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00044-00009400-00009574": "you would look for an abbreviation for", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00045-00009575-00009783": "it oddly enough it's abbreviated right", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00046-00009784-00009871": "after it", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00047-00009872-00010263": "and the nsp or nps was measured by nurse", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00048-00010264-00010374": "performance skill what i think they", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00049-00010375-00010503": "probably want to say is", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00050-00010504-00010799": "the np so nurse performance was measured", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00051-00010800-00010974": "by nurse performance scale", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00052-00010975-00011142": "but that's not what they've said but", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00053-00011143-00011399": "anyway let's get past that so i'm going", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00054-00011400-00011606": "to scroll down here", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00055-00011607-00011806": "and this is all introduction and stuff", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00056-00011807-00011991": "by the looks of it", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00057-00011992-00012214": "let's see do they actually have so", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00058-00012215-00012303": "significance", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00059-00012304-00012591": "aim of the study methodology so you can", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00060-00012592-00012855": "see they've got a specific methodology", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00061-00012856-00013055": "and their research design so this is", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00062-00013056-00013222": "actually the methodology", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00063-00013223-00013415": "it's a cross-sectional descriptive", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00064-00013416-00013535": "design so", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00065-00013536-00013743": "that descriptive research that we looked", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00066-00013744-00013943": "at as an example of one of the different", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00067-00013944-00014038": "methodologies", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00068-00014040-00014238": "this is a specific type of descriptive", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00069-00014240-00014430": "research so they actually do", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00070-00014431-00014743": "mention a methodology or design or plan", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00071-00014744-00014847": "or process", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00072-00014847-00015038": "or framework or outline whatever term", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00073-00015040-00015175": "you want to use", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00074-00015176-00015335": "now when you actually look at it while", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00075-00015336-00015583": "they go sample and sorry setting and", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00076-00015584-00015694": "sample", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00077-00015695-00015838": "and then they've got tools for data", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00078-00015840-00015999": "collection so here's what they're", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00079-00016000-00016150": "actually using to collect data", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00080-00016151-00016303": "so they've got a questionnaire which is", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00081-00016304-00016519": "just a fancy way of saying survey", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00082-00016520-00016711": "and then they've got another", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00083-00016712-00016847": "questionnaire so they've got two", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00084-00016848-00016999": "questionnaires that they're going", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00085-00017000-00017294": "to use and by the looks of it that's it", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00086-00017295-00017367": "so that's", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00087-00017368-00017607": "their methods of data collection are", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00088-00017608-00017791": "these two instruments", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00089-00017792-00017991": "and then their method of data analysis", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00090-00017992-00018263": "so you can see the scoring system here", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00091-00018264-00018535": "for each of the instruments they talk", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00092-00018536-00018703": "about the validity which is always a", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00093-00018704-00018886": "good thing they talk about reliability", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00094-00018887-00019063": "which is always a good thing", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00095-00019064-00019263": "now i won't spend a lot of time sort of", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00096-00019264-00019391": "looking at", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00097-00019392-00019639": "what is in here exactly but again", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00098-00019640-00019775": "looking at it", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00099-00019776-00020167": "you've got in what is abstentionally", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00100-00020168-00020535": "a let's see so there's not really", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00101-00020536-00020686": "anything on just a little bit on the", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00102-00020687-00020911": "first page so if you look at it", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00103-00020912-00021375": "the actual article is that's all tables", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00104-00021376-00021703": "so the article finishes on page eight so", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00105-00021704-00021767": "the actual", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00106-00021768-00021983": "written part of the article is about", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00107-00021984-00022191": "seven pages in length", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00108-00022192-00022471": "and of those seven pages there's a", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00109-00022472-00022543": "paragraph", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00110-00022544-00022886": "there and then all this page and then", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00111-00022887-00023135": "all of this column over here and that", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00112-00023136-00023327": "little bit there so", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00113-00023328-00023630": "about what two and", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00114-00023631-00023950": "three quarters maybe two and i and yeah", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00115-00023951-00024167": "two and a two thirds or sorry one and", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00116-00024168-00024367": "two thirds or one and a q", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00117-00024368-00024678": "three quarters uh of a page of seven", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00118-00024679-00024894": "pages so you're looking at", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00119-00024895-00025222": "somewhere between 20 and 25 percent of", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00120-00025223-00025478": "what's written about this article um you", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00121-00025479-00025662": "know so a quarter to a fifth of the", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00122-00025663-00025855": "actual writing of this article", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00123-00025856-00026031": "is focused specifically upon the", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00124-00026032-00026199": "methodology so that seems pretty", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00125-00026200-00026358": "detailed to me", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00126-00026360-00026639": "because they're using questionnaires and", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00127-00026639-00026799": "this one here is one that they've", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00128-00026800-00027046": "created themselves and this one here was", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00129-00027047-00027167": "adapted", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00130-00027168-00027367": "um or adopted sorry from the nurse's", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00131-00027368-00027518": "grief questionnaire so by the looks of", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00132-00027519-00027574": "it", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00133-00027575-00027814": "that when you see adopted or adapted it", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00134-00027816-00027999": "tends to mean they didn't use it exactly", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00135-00028000-00028279": "as it was written they changed it a bit", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00136-00028280-00028639": "normally they'd say emotional skill", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00137-00028639-00028911": "was measured by the nurse and grief", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00138-00028912-00029055": "questionnaire", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00139-00029056-00029335": "established by catherine 2015. so in", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00140-00029336-00029623": "those cases in an ideal world i'd like", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00141-00029624-00029767": "to be able to come down here", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00142-00029768-00030023": "and see an appendix that actually had a", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00143-00030024-00030079": "list", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00144-00030080-00030383": "of the instruments so i could actually", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00145-00030383-00030639": "see what the questions are having said", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00146-00030639-00030790": "that in all honesty and see there's", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00147-00030791-00030935": "neither one down here", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00148-00030936-00031262": "based upon all of these you can see", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00149-00031263-00031558": "they've got all of these statements here", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00150-00031560-00031767": "over here on the i guess highlighting it", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00151-00031768-00031879": "doesn't help because it goes over there", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00152-00031880-00031918": "too", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00153-00031919-00032070": "but all of this here on the left side", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00154-00032072-00032255": "same thing here on the left side", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00155-00032256-00032470": "around anxiety you've got a bunch more", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00156-00032472-00032646": "here", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00157-00032647-00032855": "so based upon that you know here's the", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00158-00032856-00033023": "statistics for nurse management of", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00159-00033024-00033102": "emotions", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00160-00033103-00033502": "so i could probably recreate the survey", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00161-00033503-00033823": "based upon just looking at", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00162-00033824-00034095": "the details that they've provided here", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00163-00034096-00034279": "in the different figures so", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00164-00034280-00034423": "you know that probably wouldn't be that", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00165-00034424-00034607": "difficult to figure out how to you know", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00166-00034608-00034846": "recreate what they've done so that way", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00167-00034847-00035135": "i could replicate their work so overall", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00168-00035136-00035199": "not a bad", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00169-00035200-00035374": "job a couple of little things to quibble", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00170-00035375-00035615": "about but again as i'm looking at this", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00171-00035616-00035790": "that's one of the things that", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00172-00035791-00036062": "um you know i'm looking at the level of", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00173-00036063-00036302": "detail is this enough that i could", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00174-00036303-00036527": "often do it again one of the things and", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00175-00036528-00036846": "i don't see it here oh yes they do here", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00176-00036847-00037118": "um yeah so the reliability they said was", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00177-00037119-00037439": "0.97 so that's a measure of quality", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00178-00037440-00037646": "that they've got there so when you're", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00179-00037647-00037839": "looking for", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00180-00037840-00038043": "measures of quality you're looking for", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00181-00038044-00038174": "0.95", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00182-00038175-00038415": "or often times it'll be written in the", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00183-00038416-00038559": "opposite where to be", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00184-00038560-00038967": "zero point sorry .05", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00185-00038968-00039199": "um you know you're looking for an alpha", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00186-00039200-00039327": "that's actually what is called an", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00187-00039328-00039727": "alpha of 0.05 or a confidence level", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00188-00039728-00040095": "of 0.95 or higher that refers to", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00189-00040096-00040367": "essentially the level of", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00190-00040368-00040671": "confidence or chance that exists in here", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00191-00040672-00040999": "so in this case basically that there's a", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00192-00041000-00041246": "97 percent chance that the results of", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00193-00041247-00041439": "the questionnaire are accurate", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00194-00041440-00041751": "there's a three percent chance that any", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00195-00041752-00042015": "results that are generated were due just", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00196-00042016-00042367": "completely to random dumb luck", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00197-00042368-00042687": "so you can say that so all of the", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00198-00042688-00042846": "things that they talk about here in the", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00199-00042847-00043055": "results all of their findings", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00200-00043056-00043255": "they can say that they're based upon", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00201-00043256-00043367": "their sample", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00202-00043368-00043607": "and statistical procedure that they used", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00203-00043608-00043815": "that they are about 97", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00204-00043816-00044046": "confident that that's what was actually", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00205-00044047-00044143": "there", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00206-00044144-00044295": "so you're looking for some sort of", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00207-00044296-00044479": "confidence level or some alpha", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00208-00044480-00044823": "level to help guide you in terms of a", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00209-00044824-00044943": "quantitative", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00210-00044944-00045111": "when you're looking at quantitative data", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00211-00045112-00045287": "analysis so", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00212-00045288-00045446": "that's the second one that we're looking", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00213-00045447-00045646": "at and hopefully it gives you some sense", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00214-00045647-00045727": "as to", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00215-00045728-00045999": "again looking through to see how much is", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00216-00046000-00046071": "in here", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00217-00046072-00046318": "and you know whether or not you feel", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00218-00046319-00046407": "that there's enough", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00219-00046408-00046662": "detail that you could do this study in", "Wku9Ay7gR4g-00220-00046663-00047087": "your particular context"}}, {"audio_id": "WkDtr68AkaI", "text": {"WkDtr68AkaI-00000-00000233-00000842": "[Music]", "WkDtr68AkaI-00001-00000843-00002783": "[Music]", "WkDtr68AkaI-00002-00002784-00003087": "welcome to moby dick in this fictional", "WkDtr68AkaI-00003-00003088-00003254": "whaling voyage that herman melville", "WkDtr68AkaI-00004-00003255-00003447": "published in 1851", "WkDtr68AkaI-00005-00003447-00003631": "the pequod's leader captain ahab", "WkDtr68AkaI-00006-00003632-00003863": "persuades his crew to follow him in his", "WkDtr68AkaI-00007-00003864-00004111": "personal conquest to hunt and kill moby", "WkDtr68AkaI-00008-00004112-00004247": "dick", "WkDtr68AkaI-00009-00004248-00004495": "all perish on this voyage except for one", "WkDtr68AkaI-00010-00004496-00004702": "the narrator ishmael", "WkDtr68AkaI-00011-00004703-00004870": "i hope you enjoy some of the vintage", "WkDtr68AkaI-00012-00004871-00005054": "documentary footage that highlights the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00013-00005055-00005231": "drama in hunting whales in the early", "WkDtr68AkaI-00014-00005232-00005375": "20th century", "WkDtr68AkaI-00015-00005376-00005527": "now", "WkDtr68AkaI-00016-00005528-00005759": "why is this tail still so engaging some", "WkDtr68AkaI-00017-00005760-00006015": "100 years after the american whaling", "WkDtr68AkaI-00018-00006016-00006318": "industry faded from existence", "WkDtr68AkaI-00019-00006319-00006550": "i'm here at arrowhead in pittsfield", "WkDtr68AkaI-00020-00006551-00006775": "massachusetts where herman melville", "WkDtr68AkaI-00021-00006776-00007198": "lived for many years of his life", "WkDtr68AkaI-00022-00007200-00007414": "born into wealthy new york city family", "WkDtr68AkaI-00023-00007415-00007598": "in 1819", "WkDtr68AkaI-00024-00007600-00007806": "his personal circumstances changed", "WkDtr68AkaI-00025-00007808-00007934": "dramatically", "WkDtr68AkaI-00026-00007936-00008263": "when 15 years later his father declared", "WkDtr68AkaI-00027-00008264-00008631": "bankruptcy and then 24 months later died", "WkDtr68AkaI-00028-00008632-00008831": "even after melville married elizabeth", "WkDtr68AkaI-00029-00008832-00009167": "shaw a well-to-do bostonian in 1847 he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00030-00009168-00009383": "could not live by writing alone to", "WkDtr68AkaI-00031-00009384-00009727": "provide for his growing family of six", "WkDtr68AkaI-00032-00009728-00010063": "his father's family had been a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00033-00010064-00010406": "relatively successful merchant family", "WkDtr68AkaI-00034-00010407-00010727": "his father had all the makings of a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00035-00010728-00011055": "successful importer exporter", "WkDtr68AkaI-00036-00011056-00011295": "businessman his mother's family was an", "WkDtr68AkaI-00037-00011296-00011495": "old dutch family", "WkDtr68AkaI-00038-00011496-00011774": "very solid many of his relatives were", "WkDtr68AkaI-00039-00011775-00012119": "quite solid good citizens alan melville", "WkDtr68AkaI-00040-00012120-00012406": "overextended himself money some money he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00041-00012407-00012599": "really didn't have and when the bottom", "WkDtr68AkaI-00042-00012600-00012846": "fell down fell out he lost everything", "WkDtr68AkaI-00043-00012847-00013038": "and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00044-00013039-00013319": "was in disgrace really fled new york in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00045-00013319-00013511": "disgrace", "WkDtr68AkaI-00046-00013512-00013711": "moved back to albany kind of started", "WkDtr68AkaI-00047-00013712-00013863": "over and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00048-00013863-00014094": "in the course of that became became sick", "WkDtr68AkaI-00049-00014095-00014366": "got pneumonia and died when melville was", "WkDtr68AkaI-00050-00014368-00014551": "12 years old", "WkDtr68AkaI-00051-00014552-00014807": "herman melville had been uh in the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00052-00014808-00015007": "pacific and had been whaling and then", "WkDtr68AkaI-00053-00015008-00015191": "and two of the four years out there he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00054-00015191-00015383": "was actually on one they cushioned it", "WkDtr68AkaI-00055-00015384-00015679": "for 18 months jumped ship went ashore", "WkDtr68AkaI-00056-00015680-00015911": "you know see the girls see the natives", "WkDtr68AkaI-00057-00015912-00016063": "see what was going on that's what the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00058-00016063-00016294": "guys wanted to do then he got picked up", "WkDtr68AkaI-00059-00016295-00016486": "by an australian whaler it was on that", "WkDtr68AkaI-00060-00016487-00016735": "for a bit then another nantucket whaler", "WkDtr68AkaI-00061-00016736-00016911": "and then he ended up in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00062-00016912-00017111": "the hawaiian island all of a sudden he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00063-00017112-00017343": "looks out and my god there's the ship he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00064-00017344-00017591": "came on uh that he had jumped ship you", "WkDtr68AkaI-00065-00017592-00017743": "cushioned it there she is out in the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00066-00017744-00017999": "harbor so he did what many men have done", "WkDtr68AkaI-00067-00018000-00018199": "the the greatest reason i can imagine", "WkDtr68AkaI-00068-00018200-00018383": "for joining the navy he wanted to get a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00069-00018384-00018599": "ride home from hawaii", "WkDtr68AkaI-00070-00018600-00018903": "so he did that he joined and he had", "WkDtr68AkaI-00071-00018904-00019222": "14 months more of navy experience", "WkDtr68AkaI-00072-00019223-00019455": "he had enormous energy", "WkDtr68AkaI-00073-00019456-00019775": "and yet at the same time enormous bouts", "WkDtr68AkaI-00074-00019776-00019863": "of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00075-00019864-00019967": "of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00076-00019968-00020222": "sickness of sciatica he was plagued by", "WkDtr68AkaI-00077-00020223-00020486": "sciatica and rheumatism", "WkDtr68AkaI-00078-00020487-00020758": "in the 1850s he was he was", "WkDtr68AkaI-00079-00020759-00021022": "for periods of time actually bedridden", "WkDtr68AkaI-00080-00021023-00021103": "with", "WkDtr68AkaI-00081-00021104-00021375": "physical ailments um and there's no", "WkDtr68AkaI-00082-00021376-00021527": "question that", "WkDtr68AkaI-00083-00021528-00021686": "that", "WkDtr68AkaI-00084-00021687-00022135": "played a role in um his", "WkDtr68AkaI-00085-00022136-00022358": "his moods his", "WkDtr68AkaI-00086-00022359-00022567": "reported and rumored though not", "WkDtr68AkaI-00087-00022568-00022727": "substantiated", "WkDtr68AkaI-00088-00022728-00023030": "outbursts of violence to family members", "WkDtr68AkaI-00089-00023031-00023222": "the frustrations he might have taken out", "WkDtr68AkaI-00090-00023223-00023478": "on the people around him", "WkDtr68AkaI-00091-00023479-00023678": "several things happened to melville in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00092-00023679-00023903": "1849", "WkDtr68AkaI-00093-00023904-00024119": "when he was in boston to await the birth", "WkDtr68AkaI-00094-00024120-00024311": "of his first son", "WkDtr68AkaI-00095-00024312-00024511": "he wasn't writing at the time this gave", "WkDtr68AkaI-00096-00024512-00024711": "him time to read", "WkDtr68AkaI-00097-00024712-00024927": "he went to plays he watched fanny", "WkDtr68AkaI-00098-00024928-00025150": "kimball play shakespeare", "WkDtr68AkaI-00099-00025151-00025367": "he heard emerson lecture", "WkDtr68AkaI-00100-00025368-00025655": "and he bought a new edition as he put it", "WkDtr68AkaI-00101-00025656-00025999": "in glorious great type of shakespeare's", "WkDtr68AkaI-00102-00026000-00026167": "plays", "WkDtr68AkaI-00103-00026168-00026583": "at some time in the next year in 1850", "WkDtr68AkaI-00104-00026583-00026774": "he made his first acquaintance first", "WkDtr68AkaI-00105-00026775-00026943": "with hawthorne's writing and then with", "WkDtr68AkaI-00106-00026944-00027183": "hawthorne himself", "WkDtr68AkaI-00107-00027183-00027574": "and in a review of 1850 called hawthorne", "WkDtr68AkaI-00108-00027575-00027774": "and his mosses", "WkDtr68AkaI-00109-00027775-00028083": "he celebrated both hawthorne and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00110-00028083-00028351": "shakespeare thereby surprising a good", "WkDtr68AkaI-00111-00028352-00028614": "many people to find shakespeare and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00112-00028616-00028967": "hawthorne mentioned in the same breath", "WkDtr68AkaI-00113-00028968-00029158": "now he was ready for moby dick the big", "WkDtr68AkaI-00114-00029160-00029414": "book on whaling and believe you me he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00115-00029416-00029743": "was loaded from his european trips uh", "WkDtr68AkaI-00116-00029744-00029935": "everything he had ever lived everything", "WkDtr68AkaI-00117-00029936-00030190": "he'd ever done everything ever been was", "WkDtr68AkaI-00118-00030191-00030535": "ready for him and he started out", "WkDtr68AkaI-00119-00030536-00030751": "melville once complained that all his", "WkDtr68AkaI-00120-00030752-00030918": "books were botches and i think that's a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00121-00030919-00031143": "famous line from his", "WkDtr68AkaI-00122-00031144-00031535": "letters and one that", "WkDtr68AkaI-00123-00031536-00031727": "can be seen in two ways", "WkDtr68AkaI-00124-00031727-00031870": "what is a botch well it's something that", "WkDtr68AkaI-00125-00031872-00032031": "doesn't work in the literary marketplace", "WkDtr68AkaI-00126-00032032-00032207": "for one thing it doesn't sell that is to", "WkDtr68AkaI-00127-00032208-00032407": "say it's a book that people don't", "WkDtr68AkaI-00128-00032408-00032758": "conventionally recognize as a book", "WkDtr68AkaI-00129-00032760-00032839": "and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00130-00032840-00032990": "repeatedly", "WkDtr68AkaI-00131-00032991-00033271": "melva was finding himself not", "WkDtr68AkaI-00132-00033272-00033543": "getting back to his literary marketplace", "WkDtr68AkaI-00133-00033544-00033711": "his readership the way he did with his", "WkDtr68AkaI-00134-00033712-00033943": "first book like taipei which was", "WkDtr68AkaI-00135-00033944-00034167": "a bestseller and quite a success", "WkDtr68AkaI-00136-00034168-00034399": "it's been said that melville began", "WkDtr68AkaI-00137-00034400-00034599": "writing moby dick as a young man and he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00138-00034600-00034839": "finished it an old man", "WkDtr68AkaI-00139-00034840-00035007": "that there was something about writing", "WkDtr68AkaI-00140-00035008-00035906": "moby dick that broke him", "WkDtr68AkaI-00141-00035907-00036574": "[Music]", "WkDtr68AkaI-00142-00036575-00036774": "melville was the first major 19th", "WkDtr68AkaI-00143-00036775-00036983": "century american novelist", "WkDtr68AkaI-00144-00036984-00037223": "to write and publish successfully", "WkDtr68AkaI-00145-00037224-00037527": "whaling and other sea lord stories", "WkDtr68AkaI-00146-00037528-00037783": "by 1850 melville was published in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00147-00037784-00038071": "america and england with his novel typie", "WkDtr68AkaI-00148-00038072-00038327": "that earmarked him as a significant", "WkDtr68AkaI-00149-00038328-00038662": "writer on the american literary scene", "WkDtr68AkaI-00150-00038663-00038918": "and his greatest literary achievement", "WkDtr68AkaI-00151-00038919-00039118": "written here at arrowhead in pittsfield", "WkDtr68AkaI-00152-00039119-00039430": "massachusetts some 150 miles from new", "WkDtr68AkaI-00153-00039431-00039679": "bedford harbor the departure setting for", "WkDtr68AkaI-00154-00039680-00039951": "captain ahab's quest for the white whale", "WkDtr68AkaI-00155-00039952-00040271": "melville completed moby dick in 1851", "WkDtr68AkaI-00156-00040272-00040462": "published by harper and brothers in new", "WkDtr68AkaI-00157-00040463-00040607": "york city", "WkDtr68AkaI-00158-00040608-00040846": "now melville secluded himself", "WkDtr68AkaI-00159-00040847-00041174": "behind here in his second story library", "WkDtr68AkaI-00160-00041175-00041527": "to write moby dick and other works", "WkDtr68AkaI-00161-00041528-00041807": "this became the book of what do we say", "WkDtr68AkaI-00162-00041808-00042118": "his his adventures in the pacific his", "WkDtr68AkaI-00163-00042119-00042487": "life his mind his emotions his doubts", "WkDtr68AkaI-00164-00042488-00042767": "his hopes his dreams his fantasies it's", "WkDtr68AkaI-00165-00042768-00043095": "all there he piled it in the book spills", "WkDtr68AkaI-00166-00043096-00043383": "over with materials", "WkDtr68AkaI-00167-00043384-00043646": "melville was soaked in the bible", "WkDtr68AkaI-00168-00043647-00043983": "old testament and new", "WkDtr68AkaI-00169-00043984-00044207": "the very fact that characters are named", "WkDtr68AkaI-00170-00044208-00044390": "ahab and ishmael", "WkDtr68AkaI-00171-00044391-00044599": "is an indication he knew his bible", "WkDtr68AkaI-00172-00044600-00044830": "virtually by heart", "WkDtr68AkaI-00173-00044831-00045111": "he was attracted moreover by the heroic", "WkDtr68AkaI-00174-00045112-00045351": "figures of the old testament job being a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00175-00045352-00045558": "price example", "WkDtr68AkaI-00176-00045559-00045846": "job is a good man who has tried almost", "WkDtr68AkaI-00177-00045847-00046062": "beyond endurance", "WkDtr68AkaI-00178-00046063-00046383": "by a god whom in ahab and shall we say a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00179-00046384-00046495": "melville", "WkDtr68AkaI-00180-00046496-00046783": "simply cannot abide melville was brought", "WkDtr68AkaI-00181-00046784-00047055": "up in the dutch reformed church", "WkDtr68AkaI-00182-00047056-00047286": "and the old testament god that comes", "WkDtr68AkaI-00183-00047287-00047390": "down", "WkDtr68AkaI-00184-00047391-00047639": "through that particular faith", "WkDtr68AkaI-00185-00047640-00048023": "is a god against which he revolted", "WkDtr68AkaI-00186-00048024-00048255": "you will overhear the bible being in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00187-00048256-00048518": "there you will know that this is uh a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00188-00048519-00048743": "kind of presence within the book this of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00189-00048744-00048943": "all things a book about wailing but you", "WkDtr68AkaI-00190-00048944-00049215": "know jonah father maple preaches a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00191-00049216-00049574": "sermon about jonah stuff like that", "WkDtr68AkaI-00192-00049575-00049727": "and there's constant reference to", "WkDtr68AkaI-00193-00049728-00049927": "characters in the bible", "WkDtr68AkaI-00194-00049928-00050230": "melville has also used ahab who was a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00195-00050231-00050471": "biblical creature the most evil among", "WkDtr68AkaI-00196-00050472-00050639": "all the uh", "WkDtr68AkaI-00197-00050640-00050974": "ancient kings of israel and he uses them", "WkDtr68AkaI-00198-00050975-00051319": "rather neatly to uh defy", "WkDtr68AkaI-00199-00051320-00051542": "the heavens in the course of of the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00200-00051544-00051799": "voyage he has some great scenes where he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00201-00051800-00052054": "you know were virtually raises his fists", "WkDtr68AkaI-00202-00052055-00052279": "to the heavens and goes on in big", "WkDtr68AkaI-00203-00052279-00052535": "shakespearean type of soliloquies", "WkDtr68AkaI-00204-00052536-00052782": "challenging the heavens and so forth", "WkDtr68AkaI-00205-00052783-00052999": "ishmael loves having ahab there and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00206-00053000-00053142": "letting ahab", "WkDtr68AkaI-00207-00053144-00053519": "challenge uh the universe raises fists", "WkDtr68AkaI-00208-00053520-00053671": "against the heavens you know for", "WkDtr68AkaI-00209-00053672-00053926": "whatever is happening uh ishmael being", "WkDtr68AkaI-00210-00053927-00054166": "the guy who who talks about it and but", "WkDtr68AkaI-00211-00054167-00054382": "keeps carefully on the side", "WkDtr68AkaI-00212-00054383-00054759": "melville was a volcanic personality and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00213-00054760-00055030": "a and a volatile human being any", "WkDtr68AkaI-00214-00055032-00055263": "creative person uh", "WkDtr68AkaI-00215-00055264-00055479": "tends to", "WkDtr68AkaI-00216-00055479-00055591": "to be", "WkDtr68AkaI-00217-00055591-00055919": "obsessed with with with his work at a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00218-00055920-00056087": "given time", "WkDtr68AkaI-00219-00056088-00056311": "to make incredible demands on family", "WkDtr68AkaI-00220-00056312-00056463": "members", "WkDtr68AkaI-00221-00056464-00056703": "melva had enormous energy", "WkDtr68AkaI-00222-00056704-00056942": "he would finish a chapter of moby dick", "WkDtr68AkaI-00223-00056944-00057111": "and you know go charging up of a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00224-00057112-00057326": "mountain and i think anyone who sat", "WkDtr68AkaI-00225-00057327-00057599": "you know fixated and trapped in front of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00226-00057600-00057847": "a a quill pen of all things where you", "WkDtr68AkaI-00227-00057848-00058047": "have to write i mean imagine writing", "WkDtr68AkaI-00228-00058048-00058326": "moby dick imagine copying moby dick with", "WkDtr68AkaI-00229-00058327-00058535": "one of those you know a goose quill pen", "WkDtr68AkaI-00230-00058536-00058807": "and the and the inkwell sitting for hour", "WkDtr68AkaI-00231-00058808-00059103": "and hour and hour after hour and then", "WkDtr68AkaI-00232-00059104-00059263": "finishing getting to that place where he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00233-00059264-00059423": "wanted to get and then just having to go", "WkDtr68AkaI-00234-00059424-00059750": "and climb a mountain", "WkDtr68AkaI-00235-00059751-00060047": "moby dick is dedicated to", "WkDtr68AkaI-00236-00060048-00060230": "nathaniel hawthorne and there's no doubt", "WkDtr68AkaI-00237-00060232-00060463": "that the influence of hawthorne", "WkDtr68AkaI-00238-00060464-00060671": "on hermann melville at the time of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00239-00060672-00061063": "writing this novel is enormous", "WkDtr68AkaI-00240-00061064-00061335": "they were living in the same area in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00241-00061336-00061654": "western massachusetts in the berkshires", "WkDtr68AkaI-00242-00061655-00061847": "hermann melville was living on a farm in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00243-00061848-00062006": "pittsfield", "WkDtr68AkaI-00244-00062007-00062230": "nathaniel hawthorne had rented a small", "WkDtr68AkaI-00245-00062232-00062494": "college cottage in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00246-00062495-00062711": "nearby lennox massachusetts they", "WkDtr68AkaI-00247-00062712-00062903": "discovered each other they found each", "WkDtr68AkaI-00248-00062904-00063142": "other they talked with each other they", "WkDtr68AkaI-00249-00063144-00063382": "wrote letters to each other and for the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00250-00063383-00063542": "year and a half or so that they were", "WkDtr68AkaI-00251-00063544-00063823": "together it was an intense friendship", "WkDtr68AkaI-00252-00063824-00064023": "he also goes on to say", "WkDtr68AkaI-00253-00064024-00064311": "that hawthorne has a great intellect in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00254-00064312-00064447": "repose", "WkDtr68AkaI-00255-00064448-00064575": "that is to say he was able", "WkDtr68AkaI-00256-00064576-00064791": "intellectually to see the deep problems", "WkDtr68AkaI-00257-00064791-00065054": "of human existence", "WkDtr68AkaI-00258-00065055-00065359": "but to handle these problems much like", "WkDtr68AkaI-00259-00065360-00065503": "ishmael does", "WkDtr68AkaI-00260-00065504-00065726": "in a form of repose", "WkDtr68AkaI-00261-00065727-00065919": "he sets out to talk about hawthorne you", "WkDtr68AkaI-00262-00065920-00066119": "can't help it he gets talking about", "WkDtr68AkaI-00263-00066120-00066255": "himself", "WkDtr68AkaI-00264-00066256-00066550": "it isn't just an ego trip though uh he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00265-00066551-00066719": "sees what the two of them are doing it's", "WkDtr68AkaI-00266-00066720-00066950": "a big deal you know here are two", "WkDtr68AkaI-00267-00066951-00067206": "american writers i mean everybody's", "WkDtr68AkaI-00268-00067207-00067415": "heard of shakespeare everybody knows", "WkDtr68AkaI-00269-00067416-00067679": "what's been going on these famous people", "WkDtr68AkaI-00270-00067680-00068015": "but look right here and now in america", "WkDtr68AkaI-00271-00068016-00068319": "we're going to get some great stuff and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00272-00068320-00068543": "hawthorne is one of the finest writers", "WkDtr68AkaI-00273-00068544-00068806": "that have ever graced the globe and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00274-00068807-00069023": "we're so proud of him and he and i", "WkDtr68AkaI-00275-00069024-00069303": "together sharing our genius are going on", "WkDtr68AkaI-00276-00069304-00069638": "and on and so it's really an ecstatic uh", "WkDtr68AkaI-00277-00069639-00069871": "uh approval of everything about", "WkDtr68AkaI-00278-00069872-00071126": "hawthorne", "WkDtr68AkaI-00279-00071127-00071375": "herman melville novelist and poet", "WkDtr68AkaI-00280-00071376-00071694": "represents both in his body of works and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00281-00071695-00071838": "personal life", "WkDtr68AkaI-00282-00071839-00072167": "the struggle of man against his destiny", "WkDtr68AkaI-00283-00072168-00072447": "at various levels of experience", "WkDtr68AkaI-00284-00072448-00072679": "melville's greatness as a writer is", "WkDtr68AkaI-00285-00072680-00072911": "something neither critic nor commentator", "WkDtr68AkaI-00286-00072912-00073159": "have yet explained", "WkDtr68AkaI-00287-00073160-00073438": "by choosing autobiographical materials", "WkDtr68AkaI-00288-00073439-00073679": "often blurred into his narratives", "WkDtr68AkaI-00289-00073680-00073943": "presenting many symbols and metaphysical", "WkDtr68AkaI-00290-00073944-00074079": "events", "WkDtr68AkaI-00291-00074080-00074326": "often juxtaposed with commonplace", "WkDtr68AkaI-00292-00074327-00074599": "realism seems to blur", "WkDtr68AkaI-00293-00074600-00074847": "his real intentions as well as the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00294-00074848-00075023": "reader's understanding", "WkDtr68AkaI-00295-00075024-00075287": "of the invented action", "WkDtr68AkaI-00296-00075288-00075526": "melville's need even", "WkDtr68AkaI-00297-00075527-00075687": "a passion for", "WkDtr68AkaI-00298-00075688-00076087": "uh questioning uh the meaning of things", "WkDtr68AkaI-00299-00076088-00076262": "where did we come from", "WkDtr68AkaI-00300-00076263-00076343": "uh", "WkDtr68AkaI-00301-00076344-00076487": "why are we here", "WkDtr68AkaI-00302-00076488-00076743": "where are we going pondering you know", "WkDtr68AkaI-00303-00076744-00077055": "always asking if always trying to find", "WkDtr68AkaI-00304-00077056-00077191": "out", "WkDtr68AkaI-00305-00077192-00077438": "why things are happening the way they", "WkDtr68AkaI-00306-00077439-00077591": "are", "WkDtr68AkaI-00307-00077592-00077806": "melville described his first two books", "WkDtr68AkaI-00308-00077807-00078206": "taipei and omu as narratives of voyages", "WkDtr68AkaI-00309-00078207-00078543": "the what i call the horizontal axis", "WkDtr68AkaI-00310-00078544-00078750": "appears and reappears in melville's", "WkDtr68AkaI-00311-00078751-00078935": "fiction from beginning to end and it's", "WkDtr68AkaI-00312-00078936-00079182": "certainly there in moby dick", "WkDtr68AkaI-00313-00079183-00079399": "beginning with marty there is what i", "WkDtr68AkaI-00314-00079400-00079671": "call a vertical axis", "WkDtr68AkaI-00315-00079672-00079950": "two characters appear yumi and babalanja", "WkDtr68AkaI-00316-00079951-00080159": "poet and philosopher", "WkDtr68AkaI-00317-00080160-00080471": "yumi soares babalanja dies", "WkDtr68AkaI-00318-00080472-00080711": "and melbal said after hearing emerson i", "WkDtr68AkaI-00319-00080712-00080991": "love all men who dive", "WkDtr68AkaI-00320-00080992-00081231": "you will see the two axes at work in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00321-00081232-00081575": "moby dick noble can can wrap everything", "WkDtr68AkaI-00322-00081576-00081743": "together literally pour all these", "WkDtr68AkaI-00323-00081744-00081959": "threads together but say up that will", "WkDtr68AkaI-00324-00081960-00082150": "that just lasts a moment you know", "WkDtr68AkaI-00325-00082151-00082391": "something else happens in life goes on", "WkDtr68AkaI-00326-00082392-00082479": "um", "WkDtr68AkaI-00327-00082480-00082559": "uh", "WkDtr68AkaI-00328-00082560-00082767": "that even that there are all sorts of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00329-00082768-00082911": "things that can combine your thought", "WkDtr68AkaI-00330-00082912-00083126": "conventional religion conventional", "WkDtr68AkaI-00331-00083127-00083294": "philosophy but even what the sentence", "WkDtr68AkaI-00332-00083295-00083447": "you just wrote", "WkDtr68AkaI-00333-00083448-00083606": "is dangerous you have to you have to", "WkDtr68AkaI-00334-00083607-00083791": "abandon that you know you just just sort", "WkDtr68AkaI-00335-00083792-00083999": "of take the pay take your own writing", "WkDtr68AkaI-00336-00084000-00084206": "and you know let it go you've written", "WkDtr68AkaI-00337-00084207-00084382": "that let it go we have more thinking we", "WkDtr68AkaI-00338-00084383-00084599": "have more writing to do and that famous", "WkDtr68AkaI-00339-00084600-00084847": "letter to hawthorne novo says perhaps", "WkDtr68AkaI-00340-00084848-00085055": "the same fingers that began the sweater", "WkDtr68AkaI-00341-00085056-00085359": "and not those that are finishing it", "WkDtr68AkaI-00342-00085360-00085582": "he makes the tri-works where they try", "WkDtr68AkaI-00343-00085583-00085855": "boiled and broiled the blubber from the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00344-00085856-00086118": "from the from the whale and so on as a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00345-00086119-00086367": "symbol of kind of an infernal hell fire", "WkDtr68AkaI-00346-00086368-00086550": "but he never talks about what it must", "WkDtr68AkaI-00347-00086551-00086767": "have been like to be in the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00348-00086768-00087023": "sleeping in a hammock with you know 500", "WkDtr68AkaI-00349-00087024-00087294": "men in a hold of a ship probably didn't", "WkDtr68AkaI-00350-00087295-00087518": "wash very much and had worked on this", "WkDtr68AkaI-00351-00087519-00087743": "whale blubber all day long and he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00352-00087744-00087943": "doesn't talk at all about that and i", "WkDtr68AkaI-00353-00087944-00088094": "just have always wondered what was it", "WkDtr68AkaI-00354-00088095-00088326": "like for a pretty fastidious", "WkDtr68AkaI-00355-00088327-00088550": "young man brought up by a genteel family", "WkDtr68AkaI-00356-00088551-00088799": "to be off on this on these whaling ships", "WkDtr68AkaI-00357-00088800-00088975": "the only thing that could could get the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00358-00088976-00089175": "soot out of the the sails and out of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00359-00089176-00089406": "their clothes was their own pee", "WkDtr68AkaI-00360-00089407-00089615": "and they had to wash sales and piss", "WkDtr68AkaI-00361-00089616-00089894": "basically to get them clean", "WkDtr68AkaI-00362-00089895-00089967": "he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00363-00089968-00090303": "re-does shakespeare's seven ages of man", "WkDtr68AkaI-00364-00090304-00090638": "but his speech ahab soliloquy goes", "WkDtr68AkaI-00365-00090639-00090823": "through and adds some things that", "WkDtr68AkaI-00366-00090824-00090991": "shakespeare never thought of he follows", "WkDtr68AkaI-00367-00090992-00091238": "human beings through a kind of cycle", "WkDtr68AkaI-00368-00091239-00091526": "as children we are very faithful as", "WkDtr68AkaI-00369-00091527-00091735": "adolescents we become skeptical and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00370-00091736-00091982": "challenge authority as we get older we", "WkDtr68AkaI-00371-00091983-00092206": "become riper and more mature until", "WkDtr68AkaI-00372-00092207-00092526": "eventually we achieve a certain kind of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00373-00092527-00092703": "repose of if", "WkDtr68AkaI-00374-00092704-00092855": "as he puts it", "WkDtr68AkaI-00375-00092856-00093143": "this repose of if is the ability to deal", "WkDtr68AkaI-00376-00093144-00093399": "with the big questions of the universe", "WkDtr68AkaI-00377-00093400-00093647": "this idea of negativity or nothingness", "WkDtr68AkaI-00378-00093648-00093871": "and also to", "WkDtr68AkaI-00379-00093872-00094055": "deal with it in repose to be relaxed", "WkDtr68AkaI-00380-00094056-00094150": "with it", "WkDtr68AkaI-00381-00094151-00094343": "but ahab's point is that even though he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00382-00094344-00094567": "can achieve this moment of wisdom the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00383-00094568-00094759": "next day he's back to being an", "WkDtr68AkaI-00384-00094760-00094950": "adolescent or a child", "WkDtr68AkaI-00385-00094951-00095287": "faith doubt skepticism repose it keeps", "WkDtr68AkaI-00386-00095288-00095526": "going around in an endless circle and he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00387-00095527-00095791": "can't handle the cyclicity of it he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00388-00095792-00096079": "wants one place and one place alone", "WkDtr68AkaI-00389-00096080-00096447": "that's ahab's mentality he needs to have", "WkDtr68AkaI-00390-00096448-00096767": "some kind of direct linear focus none of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00391-00096768-00096838": "this", "WkDtr68AkaI-00392-00096839-00096959": "cycle", "WkDtr68AkaI-00393-00096960-00097335": "but for ishmael the cycle is everything", "WkDtr68AkaI-00394-00097336-00097518": "he's often been criticized for having", "WkDtr68AkaI-00395-00097519-00097831": "very few women characters in his fiction", "WkDtr68AkaI-00396-00097832-00097943": "and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00397-00097944-00098111": "for what appear at times to be", "WkDtr68AkaI-00398-00098112-00098415": "misogynistic tendencies there's a kind", "WkDtr68AkaI-00399-00098416-00098774": "of undercurrent of sensibility", "WkDtr68AkaI-00400-00098775-00098950": "we see that in the relationship between", "WkDtr68AkaI-00401-00098951-00099238": "ishmael and queequeg", "WkDtr68AkaI-00402-00099239-00099582": "reaching out for a kind of expansion of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00403-00099583-00099767": "soul that in his day and age would have", "WkDtr68AkaI-00404-00099768-00100031": "been called feminine perhaps and that we", "WkDtr68AkaI-00405-00100032-00100287": "in our day and age perhaps are beginning", "WkDtr68AkaI-00406-00100288-00100550": "to reevaluate we're beginning to cross a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00407-00100551-00100679": "lot of those", "WkDtr68AkaI-00408-00100680-00100935": "boundaries what what were very", "WkDtr68AkaI-00409-00100936-00101103": "very much", "WkDtr68AkaI-00410-00101104-00101487": "demarcated um gender categories in in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00411-00101488-00101662": "that day and yet there were many", "WkDtr68AkaI-00412-00101663-00101879": "instances of people crossing them and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00413-00101880-00102174": "challenging them um and melville i think", "WkDtr68AkaI-00414-00102175-00102463": "was in the forefront of of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00415-00102464-00102823": "trying to get out of the straitjacket of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00416-00102824-00103118": "of any kind of convention", "WkDtr68AkaI-00417-00103119-00103327": "melville i think", "WkDtr68AkaI-00418-00103328-00103606": "puts it very nicely in the chapter where", "WkDtr68AkaI-00419-00103607-00103830": "the right whale's head and the sperm", "WkDtr68AkaI-00420-00103831-00103990": "whale's head", "WkDtr68AkaI-00421-00103991-00104094": "are", "WkDtr68AkaI-00422-00104095-00104390": "attached on each side of the pequod", "WkDtr68AkaI-00423-00104391-00104606": "making it lean first one way and then", "WkDtr68AkaI-00424-00104607-00104766": "the other", "WkDtr68AkaI-00425-00104767-00104975": "following emerson by the way who was the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00426-00104976-00105183": "source of that passage", "WkDtr68AkaI-00427-00105183-00105383": "melville remarks that these are the two", "WkDtr68AkaI-00428-00105383-00105623": "schools of philosophy the idealistic and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00429-00105624-00105871": "the empirical if you will", "WkDtr68AkaI-00430-00105872-00106110": "what he advises people to do is cast", "WkDtr68AkaI-00431-00106111-00106327": "them both aside", "WkDtr68AkaI-00432-00106328-00106543": "as leading to", "WkDtr68AkaI-00433-00106544-00106766": "nothing really productive", "WkDtr68AkaI-00434-00106767-00107039": "philosophy ultimately i think for novel", "WkDtr68AkaI-00435-00107040-00107278": "is but a slow and admire", "WkDtr68AkaI-00436-00107279-00107534": "and yet he couldn't keep his mind", "WkDtr68AkaI-00437-00107535-00107702": "or his eyes", "WkDtr68AkaI-00438-00107703-00107895": "or his fascination away from", "WkDtr68AkaI-00439-00107896-00108183": "philosophical writing and speculation as", "WkDtr68AkaI-00440-00108183-00109495": "well", "WkDtr68AkaI-00441-00109496-00109671": "in 1850", "WkDtr68AkaI-00442-00109672-00109886": "oliver wendell holmes and nathaniel", "WkDtr68AkaI-00443-00109888-00110039": "hawthorne were guests of hermann", "WkDtr68AkaI-00444-00110040-00110254": "melville for a picnic right there on the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00445-00110255-00110502": "second ledge that you can see behind me", "WkDtr68AkaI-00446-00110503-00110790": "a soaring friendship resulted between", "WkDtr68AkaI-00447-00110791-00111095": "herman melville and nathaniel hawthorne", "WkDtr68AkaI-00448-00111096-00111351": "in fact one year later herman melville", "WkDtr68AkaI-00449-00111352-00111478": "dedicated", "WkDtr68AkaI-00450-00111479-00111831": "moby dick to nathaniel hawthorne", "WkDtr68AkaI-00451-00111832-00112063": "even if you've only read the comic book", "WkDtr68AkaI-00452-00112064-00112319": "you know the opening uh uh three three", "WkDtr68AkaI-00453-00112320-00112654": "words the the the best intro for any uh", "WkDtr68AkaI-00454-00112655-00112839": "piece of fiction ever i think in some", "WkDtr68AkaI-00455-00112840-00113007": "ways people know that if they don't know", "WkDtr68AkaI-00456-00113008-00113134": "anything else", "WkDtr68AkaI-00457-00113135-00113527": "uh i think they are immensely important", "WkDtr68AkaI-00458-00113528-00113895": "the choice of the figure ishmael", "WkDtr68AkaI-00459-00113896-00114183": "from from where i stand is the crucial", "WkDtr68AkaI-00460-00114183-00114310": "act", "WkDtr68AkaI-00461-00114311-00114558": "in the course of creating moby dick", "WkDtr68AkaI-00462-00114559-00115007": "ishmael is an exile he is a pariah he is", "WkDtr68AkaI-00463-00115008-00115231": "an outcast melville reached back", "WkDtr68AkaI-00464-00115232-00115471": "melville was saturated in the bible he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00465-00115472-00115654": "knew the bible inside out he was brought", "WkDtr68AkaI-00466-00115655-00115854": "up in the dutch reformed church he's he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00467-00115855-00116086": "was loaded with old style puritanism", "WkDtr68AkaI-00468-00116088-00116343": "calvinism and so on believe you me he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00469-00116344-00116495": "had some but knocked out of him while he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00470-00116496-00116751": "was at sea for four years but anyhow he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00471-00116752-00116902": "still knew all that it's a frame of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00472-00116903-00117119": "reference for him so he reached out for", "WkDtr68AkaI-00473-00117120-00117502": "a figure and i think that his decision", "WkDtr68AkaI-00474-00117503-00117958": "to make his narrator a man named ishmael", "WkDtr68AkaI-00475-00117959-00118047": "was", "WkDtr68AkaI-00476-00118048-00118327": "a way that he allowed himself", "WkDtr68AkaI-00477-00118328-00118551": "to at once be", "WkDtr68AkaI-00478-00118552-00118831": "deeply traditional and and even ancient", "WkDtr68AkaI-00479-00118832-00119151": "as it were but the same time modern with", "WkDtr68AkaI-00480-00119152-00119623": "it and rebellious call me ishmael", "WkDtr68AkaI-00481-00119624-00119790": "this announces", "WkDtr68AkaI-00482-00119791-00120102": "our main speaker ishmael who is he and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00483-00120103-00120366": "what he's after and what his problem is", "WkDtr68AkaI-00484-00120367-00120583": "is the subject of the first chapter", "WkDtr68AkaI-00485-00120583-00120847": "looming actually ishmael is a young man", "WkDtr68AkaI-00486-00120848-00121071": "who is on the verge of a kind of nervous", "WkDtr68AkaI-00487-00121072-00121183": "breakdown", "WkDtr68AkaI-00488-00121183-00121454": "he's finding himself following", "WkDtr68AkaI-00489-00121455-00121527": "up", "WkDtr68AkaI-00490-00121528-00121719": "funeral processions and wanting to knock", "WkDtr68AkaI-00491-00121720-00121886": "people's hats off", "WkDtr68AkaI-00492-00121888-00121990": "he's", "WkDtr68AkaI-00493-00121991-00122310": "a wanderer over the seas but also a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00494-00122311-00122654": "wanderer in philosophy a wonder in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00495-00122655-00122766": "religion", "WkDtr68AkaI-00496-00122767-00122983": "and he is searching first person that he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00497-00122983-00123343": "runs into however is a polynesian native", "WkDtr68AkaI-00498-00123344-00123590": "some would call a savage named queequeg", "WkDtr68AkaI-00499-00123591-00123910": "and before long he finds himself betting", "WkDtr68AkaI-00500-00123911-00124110": "down with this individual", "WkDtr68AkaI-00501-00124111-00124358": "sharing a bed waking up the following", "WkDtr68AkaI-00502-00124359-00124647": "morning in the arms of this savage so", "WkDtr68AkaI-00503-00124648-00124919": "it's also interestingly enough a kind of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00504-00124920-00125166": "sexual searching and also something of a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00505-00125167-00125351": "racial searching all of it comes", "WkDtr68AkaI-00506-00125352-00125575": "together in these first two first 23", "WkDtr68AkaI-00507-00125576-00125702": "chapters", "WkDtr68AkaI-00508-00125703-00125854": "of moby dick", "WkDtr68AkaI-00509-00125855-00125958": "and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00510-00125959-00126263": "then the novel quickly changes", "WkDtr68AkaI-00511-00126264-00126375": "uh", "WkDtr68AkaI-00512-00126376-00126566": "ishmael and queequeg are off to see", "WkDtr68AkaI-00513-00126567-00126734": "together", "WkDtr68AkaI-00514-00126735-00127071": "and find themselves on the pequod the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00515-00127072-00127334": "captain is ahab and that's when ahab's", "WkDtr68AkaI-00516-00127335-00127486": "story begins", "WkDtr68AkaI-00517-00127488-00127743": "melville in his years in the south seas", "WkDtr68AkaI-00518-00127744-00128023": "in the early 1840s", "WkDtr68AkaI-00519-00128024-00128231": "became what i think we would call today", "WkDtr68AkaI-00520-00128232-00128510": "a kind of multiculturalist", "WkDtr68AkaI-00521-00128511-00128814": "he came to value polynesian natives for", "WkDtr68AkaI-00522-00128815-00128958": "themselves", "WkDtr68AkaI-00523-00128959-00129263": "and not simply as some peculiar", "WkDtr68AkaI-00524-00129264-00129486": "tribe outside the law who ought to be", "WkDtr68AkaI-00525-00129488-00129631": "rescued by", "WkDtr68AkaI-00526-00129632-00129910": "american or british missionaries in fact", "WkDtr68AkaI-00527-00129911-00130199": "melville came to take a rather dim view", "WkDtr68AkaI-00528-00130200-00130399": "of the excesses of not only the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00529-00130400-00130590": "missionary movement", "WkDtr68AkaI-00530-00130591-00130927": "but of what american whalers and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00531-00130928-00131278": "merchant sailors and naval sailors had", "WkDtr68AkaI-00532-00131279-00131478": "brought in the form of disease to the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00533-00131479-00131678": "south seas", "WkDtr68AkaI-00534-00131679-00131951": "your remarked somewhere that perhaps the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00535-00131952-00132223": "south seas should send missionaries to", "WkDtr68AkaI-00536-00132224-00132375": "christendom", "WkDtr68AkaI-00537-00132376-00132502": "instead of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00538-00132503-00132711": "christendom sending missionaries to the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00539-00132712-00132983": "south seas out of that remark it seems", "WkDtr68AkaI-00540-00132984-00133087": "to me", "WkDtr68AkaI-00541-00133088-00133390": "comes his conception of queequeg", "WkDtr68AkaI-00542-00133391-00133687": "who is the ultimate other for", "WkDtr68AkaI-00543-00133688-00133823": "ishmael", "WkDtr68AkaI-00544-00133824-00134039": "you will notice by the way that each of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00545-00134040-00134263": "the mates", "WkDtr68AkaI-00546-00134264-00134447": "of the pequod", "WkDtr68AkaI-00547-00134448-00134775": "has a dark-skinned harpooner", "WkDtr68AkaI-00548-00134776-00135039": "and of course ahab himself", "WkDtr68AkaI-00549-00135040-00135311": "has a mysterious fidala who is referred", "WkDtr68AkaI-00550-00135312-00135471": "to as", "WkDtr68AkaI-00551-00135472-00135775": "his darker genius", "WkDtr68AkaI-00552-00135776-00135871": "three", "WkDtr68AkaI-00553-00135872-00136199": "mates of the pequod starbuck flask and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00554-00136200-00136302": "stubb", "WkDtr68AkaI-00555-00136303-00136735": "are three whites who are", "WkDtr68AkaI-00556-00136736-00137071": "very weak very flawed very unattractive", "WkDtr68AkaI-00557-00137072-00137287": "characters really i mean starbuck is the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00558-00137288-00137487": "noblest of them all but yet it's", "WkDtr68AkaI-00559-00137488-00137839": "starbuck who standing near ahab realizes", "WkDtr68AkaI-00560-00137840-00138054": "that ahab will will take the ship to its", "WkDtr68AkaI-00561-00138055-00138319": "destruction and yet is constrained by", "WkDtr68AkaI-00562-00138320-00138583": "his conscience not to intervene flask", "WkDtr68AkaI-00563-00138584-00139031": "and stub are perceived as as two cruel", "WkDtr68AkaI-00564-00139032-00139159": "crass", "WkDtr68AkaI-00565-00139160-00139471": "unpleasant unattractive individuals", "WkDtr68AkaI-00566-00139472-00139863": "flask darts his harpoon at an ulcerated", "WkDtr68AkaI-00567-00139864-00140151": "sore on the on the whale's body", "WkDtr68AkaI-00568-00140152-00140423": "sadistically and and the the agony of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00569-00140424-00140631": "the whale is described by melville with", "WkDtr68AkaI-00570-00140632-00140863": "great sympathy and he personifies the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00571-00140864-00141119": "whale he makes the whale um", "WkDtr68AkaI-00572-00141120-00141375": "really stand for all suffering creatures", "WkDtr68AkaI-00573-00141376-00141719": "in in a way stub", "WkDtr68AkaI-00574-00141720-00141927": "abuses the black cook", "WkDtr68AkaI-00575-00141928-00142159": "fleece sort of orders him around says", "WkDtr68AkaI-00576-00142160-00142351": "cut me a piece of that whale steak", "WkDtr68AkaI-00577-00142352-00142654": "clearly devaluing the whale as one of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00578-00142655-00142935": "god's creatures devaluing the the black", "WkDtr68AkaI-00579-00142936-00143302": "cook these three men are um the lords", "WkDtr68AkaI-00580-00143303-00143478": "and rulers well the knights if you will", "WkDtr68AkaI-00581-00143479-00143631": "melville calls them the knights and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00582-00143632-00143807": "they're squires and they're all sort of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00583-00143808-00144023": "described as short and kind of well stub", "WkDtr68AkaI-00584-00144024-00144343": "is stubby um and these", "WkDtr68AkaI-00585-00144344-00144454": "three men", "WkDtr68AkaI-00586-00144455-00144902": "are served by the squires who are three", "WkDtr68AkaI-00587-00144903-00145311": "extremely noble characters queequeg", "WkDtr68AkaI-00588-00145312-00145399": "the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00589-00145400-00145590": "george washington cannibalistically", "WkDtr68AkaI-00590-00145591-00145790": "developed who becomes the sort of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00591-00145791-00146095": "matrimonial bedfellow of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00592-00146096-00146351": "of ishmael the narrator", "WkDtr68AkaI-00593-00146352-00146719": "a man described as an exiled polynesian", "WkDtr68AkaI-00594-00146720-00146959": "prince who", "WkDtr68AkaI-00595-00146960-00147207": "has a sort of a black idol celebrates", "WkDtr68AkaI-00596-00147208-00147343": "ramadan", "WkDtr68AkaI-00597-00147344-00147487": "looks like a george washington", "WkDtr68AkaI-00598-00147488-00147783": "cannibalistically developed", "WkDtr68AkaI-00599-00147784-00147983": "sleeps with a harpoon", "WkDtr68AkaI-00600-00147984-00148287": "he smokes a tomahawk peace pipe i mean", "WkDtr68AkaI-00601-00148288-00148519": "he's kind of a racial", "WkDtr68AkaI-00602-00148520-00148726": "conglomerate in a way", "WkDtr68AkaI-00603-00148727-00148990": "tashtigo a wampanoag indian from from", "WkDtr68AkaI-00604-00148991-00149407": "gay head another noble harpooner", "WkDtr68AkaI-00605-00149408-00149502": "and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00606-00149503-00149831": "dagu who from whom the golden earrings", "WkDtr68AkaI-00607-00149832-00150071": "were torn when he was taken by slave", "WkDtr68AkaI-00608-00150072-00150454": "traders from the west coast of africa", "WkDtr68AkaI-00609-00150455-00150759": "these are all regal figures figures whom", "WkDtr68AkaI-00610-00150760-00151063": "whom ishmael valorizes in his narrative", "WkDtr68AkaI-00611-00151064-00151366": "and at one point he says that flask", "WkDtr68AkaI-00612-00151367-00151678": "standing before dagu looked like", "WkDtr68AkaI-00613-00151679-00151999": "a white flag before a fortress", "WkDtr68AkaI-00614-00152000-00152263": "and the the weakness and insignificance", "WkDtr68AkaI-00615-00152264-00152551": "and sort of runtiness of these three", "WkDtr68AkaI-00616-00152552-00152831": "whites is emphasized against the the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00617-00152832-00153151": "grandeur of these three um men the the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00618-00153152-00153463": "the polynesian and the african and uh", "WkDtr68AkaI-00619-00153464-00153631": "the native american", "WkDtr68AkaI-00620-00153632-00153919": "so you have the two ishmaels the one is", "WkDtr68AkaI-00621-00153920-00154087": "the man writing the book", "WkDtr68AkaI-00622-00154088-00154326": "uh even when he's putting on a play even", "WkDtr68AkaI-00623-00154327-00154543": "when he's having a kind of ballet scene", "WkDtr68AkaI-00624-00154544-00154711": "even while he's telling jokes even when", "WkDtr68AkaI-00625-00154712-00154975": "he's not on board you know i think of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00626-00154976-00155231": "that as the pervading sensibility of the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00627-00155232-00155375": "book and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00628-00155376-00155631": "among the crewmen is a young sailor", "WkDtr68AkaI-00629-00155632-00155854": "named ishmael i think if you separate", "WkDtr68AkaI-00630-00155855-00156119": "the two you find the book a lot more", "WkDtr68AkaI-00631-00156120-00157839": "exciting", "WkDtr68AkaI-00632-00157840-00158078": "may i offer one suggestion", "WkDtr68AkaI-00633-00158079-00158239": "in reading moby dick at least for the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00634-00158240-00158583": "first time and at the first go why not", "WkDtr68AkaI-00635-00158584-00158878": "take a selection of chapters", "WkDtr68AkaI-00636-00158879-00159087": "and after that with an understanding of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00637-00159088-00159302": "those chapters perhaps someday you might", "WkDtr68AkaI-00638-00159303-00159487": "become adventurous and try the whole", "WkDtr68AkaI-00639-00159488-00159583": "novel", "WkDtr68AkaI-00640-00159584-00159911": "known as one whale of a book", "WkDtr68AkaI-00641-00159912-00160214": "and with that experience now you'll be", "WkDtr68AkaI-00642-00160215-00160502": "able to intelligently feel and enjoy the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00643-00160503-00160607": "depth", "WkDtr68AkaI-00644-00160608-00161054": "power and influence of this great novel", "WkDtr68AkaI-00645-00161055-00161214": "today we think of it as one of the great", "WkDtr68AkaI-00646-00161215-00161471": "books of of western culture", "WkDtr68AkaI-00647-00161472-00161726": "uh it's a classic that's uh you know", "WkDtr68AkaI-00648-00161727-00161919": "that's a kind of deadly thing people say", "WkDtr68AkaI-00649-00161920-00162095": "oh well it's a classic i don't have to", "WkDtr68AkaI-00650-00162096-00162271": "read it you know how it is with famous", "WkDtr68AkaI-00651-00162272-00162478": "books actually", "WkDtr68AkaI-00652-00162479-00162871": "it is exciting to the modern generation", "WkDtr68AkaI-00653-00162872-00163143": "in a way that it simply wasn't to the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00654-00163144-00163463": "middle of the 19th century this book uh", "WkDtr68AkaI-00655-00163464-00163726": "called moby dick you know about a what a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00656-00163727-00164054": "big fish well no a book about", "WkDtr68AkaI-00657-00164055-00164271": "god knows everything everything under", "WkDtr68AkaI-00658-00164272-00164535": "the sun when he got going when melvil", "WkDtr68AkaI-00659-00164536-00164783": "got going this became the book of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00660-00164784-00165054": "what we say his his adventures in the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00661-00165055-00165478": "pacific his life his mind his emotions", "WkDtr68AkaI-00662-00165479-00165711": "his doubts his hopes his dreams his", "WkDtr68AkaI-00663-00165712-00166023": "fantasies it's all there he piled it in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00664-00166024-00166343": "the book spills over with materials some", "WkDtr68AkaI-00665-00166344-00166502": "days you might feel like an ishmaelian", "WkDtr68AkaI-00666-00166503-00166711": "and want to just spend a time with one", "WkDtr68AkaI-00667-00166712-00166878": "particular chapter", "WkDtr68AkaI-00668-00166879-00167102": "that ishmael gives you about cetology", "WkDtr68AkaI-00669-00167103-00167247": "other times you might want to get up and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00670-00167248-00167454": "go and just start reading in an ahabian", "WkDtr68AkaI-00671-00167455-00167695": "sort of way get to the plot get to the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00672-00167696-00167926": "conflict get to the action get to that", "WkDtr68AkaI-00673-00167927-00168119": "kill", "WkDtr68AkaI-00674-00168120-00168302": "if you understand yourself as having one", "WkDtr68AkaI-00675-00168303-00168487": "of these urges one or the other then go", "WkDtr68AkaI-00676-00168488-00168759": "with them skip around jump around", "WkDtr68AkaI-00677-00168760-00168911": "try to get back to every part of the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00678-00168912-00169126": "novel that you possibly can", "WkDtr68AkaI-00679-00169127-00169366": "don't obsess a habitually", "WkDtr68AkaI-00680-00169367-00169614": "with trying to understand every single", "WkDtr68AkaI-00681-00169615-00169807": "line at every single moment sometimes", "WkDtr68AkaI-00682-00169808-00169966": "you need to be the ishmaelian and just", "WkDtr68AkaI-00683-00169967-00170166": "go with the flow of the language but", "WkDtr68AkaI-00684-00170167-00170383": "other times you need some pretty basic", "WkDtr68AkaI-00685-00170384-00170671": "facts and and and plot devices and then", "WkDtr68AkaI-00686-00170672-00170959": "it's time to become an ahabian", "WkDtr68AkaI-00687-00170960-00171143": "there's a story there and it's a good", "WkDtr68AkaI-00688-00171144-00171231": "one", "WkDtr68AkaI-00689-00171232-00171663": "it's men against bees beast it's a chase", "WkDtr68AkaI-00690-00171664-00171887": "it's thrilling it's exciting", "WkDtr68AkaI-00691-00171888-00172087": "you can read moby dick on that level and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00692-00172088-00172423": "i think it's a good good way to begin if", "WkDtr68AkaI-00693-00172424-00172719": "you come back to moby dick a second or a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00694-00172720-00172983": "third or heaven knows how many times as", "WkDtr68AkaI-00695-00172984-00173126": "in my case", "WkDtr68AkaI-00696-00173127-00173351": "you will see more and more on what i", "WkDtr68AkaI-00697-00173352-00173566": "have called the vertical level of the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00698-00173567-00173838": "story not the level of action not the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00699-00173839-00174102": "level of movement through space", "WkDtr68AkaI-00700-00174103-00174447": "but characterization ideas thoughts", "WkDtr68AkaI-00701-00174448-00174614": "speculation", "WkDtr68AkaI-00702-00174615-00174807": "and above all else the thing that i", "WkDtr68AkaI-00703-00174808-00175095": "think first attracted me to moby dick", "WkDtr68AkaI-00704-00175096-00175375": "that's it literary style", "WkDtr68AkaI-00705-00175376-00175687": "melville is a remarkable writer", "WkDtr68AkaI-00706-00175688-00175887": "herman melville's setting for moby dick", "WkDtr68AkaI-00707-00175888-00176119": "begins here in new bedford massachusetts", "WkDtr68AkaI-00708-00176120-00176287": "on the new england coast", "WkDtr68AkaI-00709-00176288-00176526": "where the whaling ship pequod set sail", "WkDtr68AkaI-00710-00176527-00176751": "for three years on its eventual quest", "WkDtr68AkaI-00711-00176752-00176990": "for the white whale", "WkDtr68AkaI-00712-00176991-00177183": "well melville's construction of the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00713-00177184-00177559": "pequod as a as a literary uh ship that", "WkDtr68AkaI-00714-00177560-00177823": "is certainly based loosely on his own", "WkDtr68AkaI-00715-00177824-00178135": "experience aboard the akashnet", "WkDtr68AkaI-00716-00178136-00178319": "is definitely", "WkDtr68AkaI-00717-00178320-00178478": "it's definitely an imaginative", "WkDtr68AkaI-00718-00178479-00178790": "construction that is meant to do a lot", "WkDtr68AkaI-00719-00178791-00179095": "of work a lot of cultural work for", "WkDtr68AkaI-00720-00179096-00179407": "the reader pequod is named perhaps for", "WkDtr68AkaI-00721-00179408-00179647": "the pequot indians who were exterminated", "WkDtr68AkaI-00722-00179648-00179919": "uh by the settlers during the pequot war", "WkDtr68AkaI-00723-00179920-00180190": "um it's it's described as a cannibal of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00724-00180191-00180535": "a craft tricked out in the bones of its", "WkDtr68AkaI-00725-00180536-00180663": "enemies", "WkDtr68AkaI-00726-00180664-00180911": "the tiller is a is a whale bone and the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00727-00180912-00181199": "jawbone of a whale when ishmael and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00728-00181200-00181423": "kuikwe go aboard the pequod to you know", "WkDtr68AkaI-00729-00181424-00181607": "to get their assignments and to sign on", "WkDtr68AkaI-00730-00181608-00181871": "the ship the two captains are sitting in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00731-00181872-00182119": "a sort of wigwam-like affair there's", "WkDtr68AkaI-00732-00182120-00182383": "that sense that the pequod", "WkDtr68AkaI-00733-00182384-00182535": "is", "WkDtr68AkaI-00734-00182536-00182895": "is america launched on its", "WkDtr68AkaI-00735-00182896-00183135": "voyage into the new world it's it's", "WkDtr68AkaI-00736-00183136-00183487": "self-construction it's self-creation", "WkDtr68AkaI-00737-00183488-00183814": "the first chapter of moby dick loomings", "WkDtr68AkaI-00738-00183815-00184054": "begins with ishmael", "WkDtr68AkaI-00739-00184055-00184335": "who tells us that he goes to sea", "WkDtr68AkaI-00740-00184336-00184631": "as a substitute for pistol and ball", "WkDtr68AkaI-00741-00184632-00184895": "not every reader realizes", "WkDtr68AkaI-00742-00184896-00185151": "how serious ishmil is when he talks", "WkDtr68AkaI-00743-00185152-00185454": "about bringing up the rear of funerals", "WkDtr68AkaI-00744-00185455-00185663": "and threatening to knock people's hats", "WkDtr68AkaI-00745-00185664-00185759": "off", "WkDtr68AkaI-00746-00185760-00186054": "this is ishmael's gay desperado", "WkDtr68AkaI-00747-00186055-00186359": "philosophy ishmael leads us", "WkDtr68AkaI-00748-00186360-00186663": "from new york to new england to the sea", "WkDtr68AkaI-00749-00186664-00186878": "and aboard the pequod", "WkDtr68AkaI-00750-00186879-00187038": "off to sea", "WkDtr68AkaI-00751-00187039-00187319": "into another realm another world", "WkDtr68AkaI-00752-00187320-00187599": "where he meets ahab", "WkDtr68AkaI-00753-00187600-00187847": "ahab inhabits the world of his own", "WkDtr68AkaI-00754-00187848-00188111": "perhaps matched only by pip", "WkDtr68AkaI-00755-00188112-00188319": "with their common theme of man's", "WkDtr68AkaI-00756-00188320-00188526": "insanity being heaven sense their", "WkDtr68AkaI-00757-00188527-00188783": "madness and short", "WkDtr68AkaI-00758-00188784-00188990": "it is only until the very end of the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00759-00188991-00189319": "book that the third major character moby", "WkDtr68AkaI-00760-00189320-00189454": "dick himself", "WkDtr68AkaI-00761-00189455-00189711": "looms before us", "WkDtr68AkaI-00762-00189712-00189895": "melville tends to take his novels out on", "WkDtr68AkaI-00763-00189896-00190063": "the high seas", "WkDtr68AkaI-00764-00190064-00190326": "where certain elemental conflicts are", "WkDtr68AkaI-00765-00190327-00190463": "bound to occur", "WkDtr68AkaI-00766-00190464-00190719": "the high point of this sequence of of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00767-00190720-00191078": "stage directed chapters is chapter 36", "WkDtr68AkaI-00768-00191079-00191366": "the quarter deck and here ahab comes on", "WkDtr68AkaI-00769-00191367-00191590": "and announces himself as ishmael has", "WkDtr68AkaI-00770-00191591-00191823": "announced himself in chapter one in call", "WkDtr68AkaI-00771-00191824-00192183": "me ishmael ahab announces himself to the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00772-00192184-00192295": "crew", "WkDtr68AkaI-00773-00192296-00192550": "his job at this point is to convince the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00774-00192551-00192807": "crew that they should follow him", "WkDtr68AkaI-00775-00192808-00193119": "in this hunt for the white whale from", "WkDtr68AkaI-00776-00193120-00193254": "moby dick", "WkDtr68AkaI-00777-00193255-00193495": "he has lost his leg to this whale in a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00778-00193496-00193750": "previous venture and has to a certain", "WkDtr68AkaI-00779-00193751-00194014": "extent become obsessed into a very clear", "WkDtr68AkaI-00780-00194015-00194287": "sense he's become obsessed with", "WkDtr68AkaI-00781-00194288-00194583": "capturing and killing this whale", "WkDtr68AkaI-00782-00194584-00194759": "but it's just a whale it's like any", "WkDtr68AkaI-00783-00194760-00194919": "other whale all right it's white but", "WkDtr68AkaI-00784-00194920-00195047": "that doesn't make any difference to", "WkDtr68AkaI-00785-00195048-00195231": "whalers what he has to do in this", "WkDtr68AkaI-00786-00195232-00195438": "chapter is to convince him that the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00787-00195439-00195719": "whale means something more to him and to", "WkDtr68AkaI-00788-00195720-00195831": "the crew", "WkDtr68AkaI-00789-00195832-00195943": "than just", "WkDtr68AkaI-00790-00195944-00196063": "another", "WkDtr68AkaI-00791-00196064-00196326": "30 20 or 30 barrels of sperm oil and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00792-00196327-00196638": "what he does is begin to explain to them", "WkDtr68AkaI-00793-00196639-00197038": "a kind of transcendental way of viewing", "WkDtr68AkaI-00794-00197039-00197278": "the whale it is a symbol", "WkDtr68AkaI-00795-00197279-00197390": "of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00796-00197391-00197871": "all that is covering up and masking", "WkDtr68AkaI-00797-00197872-00198023": "a deeper", "WkDtr68AkaI-00798-00198024-00198199": "malignant force", "WkDtr68AkaI-00799-00198200-00198343": "in the universe", "WkDtr68AkaI-00800-00198344-00198511": "it's not so much to say that moby dick", "WkDtr68AkaI-00801-00198512-00198799": "this dumb whale is that malignant force", "WkDtr68AkaI-00802-00198800-00199054": "but that he is the paste board mask as", "WkDtr68AkaI-00803-00199055-00199214": "ahab calls it", "WkDtr68AkaI-00804-00199215-00199583": "that is covering the malignancy", "WkDtr68AkaI-00805-00199584-00199831": "deep inside of nature the quadadek scene", "WkDtr68AkaI-00806-00199832-00200199": "is not just a turning point in literary", "WkDtr68AkaI-00807-00200200-00200359": "art not just a point in the history of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00808-00200360-00200663": "the novel but it seems to me a crucial", "WkDtr68AkaI-00809-00200664-00200823": "turning point in all of western", "WkDtr68AkaI-00810-00200824-00201111": "metaphysics uh since plato or before", "WkDtr68AkaI-00811-00201112-00201278": "plato we've been dividing the world up", "WkDtr68AkaI-00812-00201279-00201471": "into a world of appearance and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00813-00201472-00201743": "multiplicity and then a world beyond a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00814-00201744-00202047": "world of permanence a world of unity as", "WkDtr68AkaI-00815-00202048-00202319": "opposed to the the plurality of the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00816-00202320-00202614": "world we live in a world of constancy as", "WkDtr68AkaI-00817-00202615-00202790": "opposed to the world of change we live", "WkDtr68AkaI-00818-00202791-00202863": "in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00819-00202864-00202990": "and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00820-00202991-00203263": "when christianity was grafted onto", "WkDtr68AkaI-00821-00203264-00203438": "classical religion", "WkDtr68AkaI-00822-00203439-00203623": "that attained a sort of theological", "WkDtr68AkaI-00823-00203624-00203871": "importance god was in that world well", "WkDtr68AkaI-00824-00203872-00204063": "melville contemplates that world and he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00825-00204064-00204199": "says well yeah you could divide the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00826-00204200-00204454": "world that way but what if what's on the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00827-00204455-00204719": "other side of that world from appearance", "WkDtr68AkaI-00828-00204720-00205071": "and change is not good", "WkDtr68AkaI-00829-00205071-00205271": "it's something malicious", "WkDtr68AkaI-00830-00205271-00205503": "or perhaps he did ask the question maybe", "WkDtr68AkaI-00831-00205504-00205742": "there's nothing there at all", "WkDtr68AkaI-00832-00205744-00205998": "melville i think was able to hold two", "WkDtr68AkaI-00833-00206000-00206198": "completely", "WkDtr68AkaI-00834-00206200-00206542": "contradictory ideas in his mind without", "WkDtr68AkaI-00835-00206544-00206871": "having to choose without having to", "WkDtr68AkaI-00836-00206871-00207182": "narrow down or reduce but to say this is", "WkDtr68AkaI-00837-00207183-00207375": "the way life is", "WkDtr68AkaI-00838-00207376-00207631": "life is contradictory life is difficult", "WkDtr68AkaI-00839-00207632-00207775": "life is", "WkDtr68AkaI-00840-00207776-00208110": "it doesn't make sense it's absurd", "WkDtr68AkaI-00841-00208111-00208390": "after the quarter dex scene which is the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00842-00208391-00208623": "principle high point in this section of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00843-00208623-00208919": "ahab chapters that are in the form of a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00844-00208919-00209055": "play", "WkDtr68AkaI-00845-00209056-00209319": "melville", "WkDtr68AkaI-00846-00209319-00209455": "conducts the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00847-00209456-00209662": "play or directs the play", "WkDtr68AkaI-00848-00209663-00209958": "so that it culminates in a scene", "WkDtr68AkaI-00849-00209959-00210175": "involving the entire crew", "WkDtr68AkaI-00850-00210176-00210334": "these are the people that ahab has", "WkDtr68AkaI-00851-00210335-00210639": "effectively convinced to follow him he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00852-00210640-00210887": "has held up a gold doubloon and said he", "WkDtr68AkaI-00853-00210888-00211158": "who first finds or sees", "WkDtr68AkaI-00854-00211159-00211406": "uh moby dick will get this to bloom this", "WkDtr68AkaI-00855-00211407-00211671": "round gold is but the image of the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00856-00211671-00211887": "rounder globe", "WkDtr68AkaI-00857-00211888-00212158": "which like a magician's glass to each", "WkDtr68AkaI-00858-00212159-00212375": "and every man in turn", "WkDtr68AkaI-00859-00212376-00212598": "but mirrors back his own", "WkDtr68AkaI-00860-00212600-00212767": "mysterious self", "WkDtr68AkaI-00861-00212767-00212839": "we", "WkDtr68AkaI-00862-00212840-00213134": "see the members of the crew come up to", "WkDtr68AkaI-00863-00213135-00213391": "the mast where ahab has", "WkDtr68AkaI-00864-00213392-00213655": "attached this gold doubloon", "WkDtr68AkaI-00865-00213656-00213871": "they look at it and one after another", "WkDtr68AkaI-00866-00213871-00214158": "they begin to interpret its meaning", "WkDtr68AkaI-00867-00214159-00214558": "ahab sees himself in it constantly", "WkDtr68AkaI-00868-00214559-00215079": "starbuck sees domesticity", "WkDtr68AkaI-00869-00215080-00215287": "and one after another the individuals", "WkDtr68AkaI-00870-00215288-00215510": "begin to sort of tell their story about", "WkDtr68AkaI-00871-00215511-00215703": "what they see", "WkDtr68AkaI-00872-00215704-00215919": "as they begin to", "WkDtr68AkaI-00873-00215919-00216046": "celebrate", "WkDtr68AkaI-00874-00216048-00216142": "in", "WkDtr68AkaI-00875-00216144-00216406": "this final scene of the play", "WkDtr68AkaI-00876-00216407-00216623": "they begin", "WkDtr68AkaI-00877-00216623-00216831": "to drink too much they begin to get", "WkDtr68AkaI-00878-00216832-00217127": "angry and suddenly a spanish sailor", "WkDtr68AkaI-00879-00217128-00217487": "begins to insult a black sailor and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00880-00217488-00217815": "suddenly we have a racial conflict on", "WkDtr68AkaI-00881-00217816-00218119": "the middle of the deck a fight ensues", "WkDtr68AkaI-00882-00218119-00218358": "everyone full creates a ring around the", "WkDtr68AkaI-00883-00218359-00218639": "two fighters and little pip at", "WkDtr68AkaI-00884-00218640-00218815": "off on the side the cabin boy who is", "WkDtr68AkaI-00885-00218816-00219198": "himself black looks on as this fight", "WkDtr68AkaI-00886-00219200-00219423": "this race fight", "WkDtr68AkaI-00887-00219423-00219582": "ensues", "WkDtr68AkaI-00888-00219583-00219863": "till finally we get pip who at this", "WkDtr68AkaI-00889-00219864-00220063": "point has gone insane", "WkDtr68AkaI-00890-00220064-00220319": "although a kind of shakespearean wise", "WkDtr68AkaI-00891-00220319-00220639": "madness and a squall a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00892-00220640-00220919": "storm begins to come across the sea all", "WkDtr68AkaI-00893-00220919-00221142": "of it is a marvelous", "WkDtr68AkaI-00894-00221144-00221487": "conclusion to ahab's", "WkDtr68AkaI-00895-00221488-00221598": "play", "WkDtr68AkaI-00896-00221600-00221919": "but little pip in turn becomes a", "WkDtr68AkaI-00897-00221919-00222198": "a wonderful character and later on uh", "WkDtr68AkaI-00898-00222200-00222415": "with his special kind of mind sort of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00899-00222416-00222751": "divine madness that he has he is the one", "WkDtr68AkaI-00900-00222752-00222967": "that comes up to the famous doubloon", "WkDtr68AkaI-00901-00222967-00223223": "which is on the mast and stands in front", "WkDtr68AkaI-00902-00223223-00223415": "of it and says something that's", "WkDtr68AkaI-00903-00223416-00223646": "absolutely unforgettable and it's very", "WkDtr68AkaI-00904-00223648-00223903": "important to i think to criticism of", "WkDtr68AkaI-00905-00223904-00224127": "this book to the enjoyment of reading it", "WkDtr68AkaI-00906-00224128-00224255": "he says", "WkDtr68AkaI-00907-00224256-00224406": "i look", "WkDtr68AkaI-00908-00224407-00224582": "you look", "WkDtr68AkaI-00909-00224583-00224815": "he looks", "WkDtr68AkaI-00910-00224816-00224967": "we look", "WkDtr68AkaI-00911-00224967-00225158": "you look", "WkDtr68AkaI-00912-00225159-00225446": "they look and then he repeats it again", "WkDtr68AkaI-00913-00225448-00225742": "and he goes away and each of the key", "WkDtr68AkaI-00914-00225744-00225951": "characters in the book comes up and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00915-00225952-00226255": "tries to read as they say emblematically", "WkDtr68AkaI-00916-00226256-00226471": "tries to read it and see what it means", "WkDtr68AkaI-00917-00226471-00226742": "little pip has given given the cue and", "WkDtr68AkaI-00918-00226744-00226934": "this is what good readers do", "WkDtr68AkaI-00919-00226935-00227039": "i look", "WkDtr68AkaI-00920-00227040-00227342": "you look he looks we look", "WkDtr68AkaI-00921-00227344-00227463": "you look", "WkDtr68AkaI-00922-00227464-00227567": "they look", "WkDtr68AkaI-00923-00227567-00227694": "there is no", "WkDtr68AkaI-00924-00227696-00227806": "right", "WkDtr68AkaI-00925-00227807-00228094": "reading of moby dick there are as many", "WkDtr68AkaI-00926-00228096-00228358": "readings as there are", "WkDtr68AkaI-00927-00228359-00228835": "people who want to read it enjoy it"}}, {"audio_id": "WkFBmG7e2ro", "text": {"WkFBmG7e2ro-00000-00000000-00000630": "[Music]", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00001-00000631-00001230": "[Music]", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00002-00001231-00001936": "[Music]", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00003-00001937-00005770": "[Music]", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00004-00005771-00006038": "hey guys badda-bing here thanks for", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00005-00006039-00006260": "joining me today we're gonna be taking a", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00006-00006261-00006547": "look at the tokyo marui MTR 16 gas", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00007-00006548-00006845": "blowback rifle wolf armories have made", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00008-00006845-00007103": "my day once again by sending me team's", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00009-00007104-00007321": "recent gas blowback rifle to review", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00010-00007322-00007546": "they've been a big help by keeping me", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00011-00007547-00007738": "fed with all these glorious toys", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00012-00007739-00007994": "a cool crisp i-5 to them for making this", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00013-00007995-00008105": "video possible", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00014-00008106-00008318": "and a few sitting comfortably then we", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00015-00008319-00008618": "will begin TM have a new addition to", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00016-00008619-00008840": "their gas blowback rifle line with this", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00017-00008841-00009088": "new MTR 16 this is something that", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00018-00009089-00009269": "they've designed themselves well I", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00019-00009270-00009437": "actually don't think is modeled after a", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00020-00009438-00009752": "specific real-world carbine but now that", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00021-00009753-00009863": "I've said that there are countless", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00022-00009864-00010066": "amounts of AR manufacturers out there so", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00023-00010067-00010402": "it's really hard to know anyway the MTR", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00024-00010403-00010607": "borrows elements from 3-gun competition", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00025-00010608-00010991": "style rifles and as it uses the same mws", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00026-00010992-00011255": "gas system present on its older siblings", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00027-00011256-00011482": "it is a perfect candidate for high-speed", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00028-00011483-00011827": "competition shooting they are in a class", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00029-00011828-00011969": "of their own when it comes to the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00030-00011970-00012262": "presentation nobody does it better", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00031-00012263-00012503": "inside the rifle has held in place by", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00032-00012504-00012763": "the usual Falco straps and the foam", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00033-00012764-00012935": "panels within the lid that keeps", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00034-00012936-00013190": "everything in its place the manual is", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00035-00013191-00013427": "located on the lid itself tucked behind", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00036-00013428-00013715": "a cardboard sleeve inside a ziplock bag", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00037-00013716-00013916": "along with the usual paperwork", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00038-00013916-00014266": "targets and a cool MTR 16 poster", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00039-00014266-00014456": "additional accessories in the box", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00040-00014457-00014656": "include a selection of em lock bell", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00041-00014657-00014915": "panels muzzle cap two allen keys", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00042-00014916-00015194": "cleaning rod BB loader and some sample", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00043-00015194-00015541": "bb's taking the MTR in hand for the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00044-00015543-00015806": "first time reveals a solid overall frame", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00045-00015807-00016025": "that weighs two point three kilograms", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00046-00016026-00016306": "without its 20 round magazine including", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00047-00016307-00016616": "the mag it only weighs 2.6 kilograms all", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00048-00016617-00016856": "before you put any accessories onto the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00049-00016857-00017087": "rifle so this is a perfect lightweight a", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00050-00017088-00017381": "platform to build a DMR recce rifle all", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00051-00017382-00017711": "that competition rifle as I said the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00052-00017712-00017909": "construction is solid and the receivers", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00053-00017910-00018092": "are pinned together without any wobbling", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00054-00018093-00018206": "whatsoever", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00055-00018207-00018428": "I'd imagine this would change with use", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00056-00018429-00018565": "but for the time being it's all", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00057-00018566-00018746": "well-made and solid", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00058-00018747-00019004": "looking at the MTR speeches starting at", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00059-00019005-00019181": "the front we're the two-port muzzle", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00060-00019182-00019430": "brake attached to a 16 inch outer barrel", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00061-00019431-00019625": "that is finished with the spiral fluting", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00062-00019626-00019883": "running along its length a carbine", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00063-00019884-00020087": "length low-profile gas block hides", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00064-00020088-00020279": "beneath Murray's free float and lock", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00065-00020280-00020620": "bail system which is as long as a runway", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00066-00020621-00020909": "it can accept the included M lock rail", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00067-00020910-00021110": "panels on the three six and nine o'clock", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00068-00021111-00021428": "positions furthermore it has two QD", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00069-00021429-00021632": "sling points just ahead of the Perot nut", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00070-00021633-00021872": "the alignment of the twelve o'clock rail", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00071-00021873-00022220": "to the receiver is dead-on to my eye the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00072-00022221-00022418": "receiver doesn't share many components", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00073-00022419-00022652": "with its previous M force nothing looks", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00074-00022653-00022865": "standard here it would be much quicker", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00075-00022866-00023048": "to say that the only things are to both", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00076-00023049-00023384": "m4 and MT Asha are the takedown pins", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00077-00023385-00023624": "we've got an entire ambidextrous fire", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00078-00023625-00023879": "control suite magazine catch bolt catch", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00079-00023880-00024176": "selector charging handle all lefty", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00080-00024177-00024461": "friendly the magazine button and B bolt", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00081-00024462-00024608": "catch and charging handle especially", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00082-00024609-00024863": "makes it even more convenient to operate", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00083-00024864-00025067": "leaving no stone left unturned", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00084-00025068-00025222": "they've even showed the dust cover and", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00085-00025223-00025475": "trigger got some attention I'm not sure", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00086-00025476-00025601": "where they were going with the sugar", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00087-00025602-00025825": "guard but it's there", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00088-00025826-00026030": "likewise they've changed the forward", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00089-00026031-00026219": "assist well they haven't changed there", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00090-00026220-00026447": "they've just taken it out the grip is", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00091-00026448-00026636": "something else they've changed at first", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00092-00026637-00026798": "I didn't know what to make of it judging", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00093-00026799-00027002": "from the pictures that I saw but now", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00094-00027002-00027182": "that I've had hands-on experience I", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00095-00027183-00027433": "quite liked it the straighter angle felt", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00096-00027435-00027662": "awkward to begin with slowly I've", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00097-00027663-00027857": "wandered to its affections and a first", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00098-00027858-00028048": "will my rifle I'd leave it where it is", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00099-00028049-00028706": "the trigger is flat usually you have", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00100-00028707-00028840": "some indication where to place your", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00101-00028841-00029042": "finger when using a traditional AR", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00102-00029043-00029288": "trigger but I have no idea where to", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00103-00029289-00029585": "place mine on this flat surface if you", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00104-00029586-00029804": "can't tell this is my first time with a", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00105-00029805-00029995": "flat sugar I'll have to come back to you", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00106-00029997-00030302": "on this one moving along we find another", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00107-00030302-00030557": "QD sling point on the receiver end plate", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00108-00030558-00030827": "that joins another two that can be found", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00109-00030827-00031076": "on the weird and wonderful stock it's a", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00110-00031077-00031310": "low profile stock however it's anything", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00111-00031311-00031564": "but boring to look at the button to", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00112-00031566-00031771": "extend is a small piece that allows for", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00113-00031772-00031988": "five positions of adjustment and it's", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00114-00031989-00032105": "tailpiece can be", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00115-00032106-00032377": "first to create a concave surface to hug", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00116-00032379-00032848": "the natural curvature of your shoulder", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00117-00032849-00033014": "the finish of the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00118-00033015-00033332": "simply gorgeous the metal receiver set", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00119-00033333-00033542": "has a smooth to the touch cervical", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00120-00033543-00033815": "treatment in a matte gray color I'd love", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00121-00033816-00033998": "to know the actual designation of it", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00122-00033999-00034280": "the surrogate finish on my m4 and WS as", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00123-00034281-00034589": "a darker tone in comparison there's not", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00124-00034590-00034904": "much else to say it's stunning the MTR", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00125-00034905-00035105": "markings do look to be printed onto the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00126-00035106-00035333": "surface that's about the extent of the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00127-00035334-00035614": "horrors that I can see so far", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00128-00035615-00035846": "moving on City in cirno's now and", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00129-00035847-00036050": "everything looks exactly the same as", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00130-00036051-00036356": "their previous gbb ours apart from the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00131-00036357-00036527": "ambidextrous bolt catch and the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00132-00036528-00036731": "blatantly different self abort carrier", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00133-00036732-00037034": "the Marui and WS gas system has been", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00134-00037035-00037316": "combat tested by many users and the only", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00135-00037317-00037451": "thing you would have to watch out for", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00136-00037452-00037688": "our failures of the nozzle spring and", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00137-00037689-00037976": "the plastic buffer these would be the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00138-00037977-00038240": "weakest links to the TM rifle when using", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00139-00038241-00038492": "green gas but don't leather put you off", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00140-00038493-00038702": "the good thing is both of these can be", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00141-00038703-00038933": "replaced very easily and without", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00142-00038934-00039067": "breaking the bank", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00143-00039068-00039392": "I've been using green gas or mainly", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00144-00039393-00039674": "propane in my mws since day one and the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00145-00039675-00039872": "nozzle spring broke over one year into", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00146-00039873-00040112": "its service life bear in mind that this", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00147-00040113-00040340": "came from the very first mws batch heads", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00148-00040341-00040544": "of the factory and in that time it", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00149-00040545-00040742": "blasted through several thousands of", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00150-00040743-00041006": "rounds I replaced the nozzle spring with", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00151-00041007-00041198": "an upgraded set and there hasn't been a", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00152-00041199-00041489": "single fault since", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00153-00041490-00041805": "even though the MTR has a 16-inch cutter", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00154-00041806-00042117": "barrel it still uses the same 250", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00155-00042118-00042383": "millimeter in a barrel that the m4 uses", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00156-00042384-00042633": "using green gas and point twos it", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00157-00042634-00042957": "produces an FPS just over 300 which is", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00158-00042958-00043112": "about what you'd expect for an airsoft", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00159-00043113-00044999": "gun coming out of Japan the MTR is an", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00160-00045000-00045282": "incredible shooter in the same way the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00161-00045283-00047607": "m4 is every shot is so crisp and precise", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00162-00047608-00047874": "the cycle happens so quickly that it's a", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00163-00047875-00048065": "piece of cake to smash through a", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00164-00048066-00048333": "magazine in seconds and I'm not talking", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00165-00048334-00048486": "about when it's being used in from the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00166-00048487-00048749": "auto either as I've said in my previous", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00167-00048750-00049032": "review of the mws the premise of their", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00168-00049033-00049245": "gas system is grounded on the concept", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00169-00049246-00049415": "and that provides durability and", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00170-00049416-00049640": "reliability they wanted it to be", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00171-00049641-00049899": "functionally practical and not try to be", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00172-00049900-00050114": "right the physics textbooks by", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00173-00050115-00050337": "accounting for high realism and heavy", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00174-00050338-00050576": "recoil in an attempt to make it all work", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00175-00050577-00054016": "with their recommended gas", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00176-00054017-00054273": "people have asked if TM have done any", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00177-00054274-00054542": "work on the trigger to be honest I can't", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00178-00054544-00054806": "tell yes it feels better than the stock", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00179-00054807-00055007": "m4 trigger but that could all be the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00180-00055008-00055263": "fact that is still brand new a my m4 is", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00181-00055264-00055466": "well-scrubbed in at this point the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00182-00055467-00055629": "take-up is short with a clearer", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00183-00055629-00055860": "definition of the edge of the break once", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00184-00055861-00055923": "it's gone", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00185-00055924-00056126": "the reset travel is equally as short and", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00186-00056127-00056328": "ends its journey exactly on the reset", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00187-00056329-00056640": "with a positive click even though it", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00188-00056641-00056829": "feels cleaner than the stock m4 trigger", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00189-00056829-00057078": "I'm still not a fan of it not when I've", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00190-00057079-00057309": "been spoiled by the one found on the ghk", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00191-00057310-00057684": "m4 the way the mtrs set up with its", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00192-00057685-00057857": "straighter grip places your trigger", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00193-00057858-00058088": "finger in a corrected angle to take", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00194-00058089-00058287": "advantage of the natural mechanics of", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00195-00058288-00058500": "your pole which in turn means one can", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00196-00058501-00058854": "theoretically run the gun faster all it", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00197-00058854-00059103": "takes is practice I still don't know", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00198-00059104-00059294": "whether I prefer the flat edge or the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00199-00059295-00059741": "curved perhaps I'll never know the 328", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00200-00059742-00059963": "Graham 20 round magazine has enough gas", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00201-00059964-00060191": "capacity to dump those 20 shots on", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00202-00060192-00060504": "automatic with ease it also has a gas", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00203-00060504-00060750": "tank that I've recorded 40 shots total", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00204-00060751-00061016": "before it's empty so it's not bad", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00205-00061017-00061203": "considering the size of it in relation", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00206-00061204-00061413": "to what it's powering it's not too", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00207-00061414-00061572": "different to the amount of gas within a", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00208-00061573-00061953": "pistol magazine the accuracy of this", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00209-00061954-00062166": "rifle is identical to what you'd find on", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00210-00062166-00062421": "the regular mws because after all", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00211-00062422-00064913": "they're both the same underneath", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00212-00064914-00065255": "at 20 meters using Jeff's bio threes I", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00213-00065257-00065489": "put together these two sets of results", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00214-00065490-00065808": "the left target was made by my own 35", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00215-00065809-00066033": "round magazine and the right was the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00216-00066034-00066402": "short 20 Randa so out of the box the MTR", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00217-00066403-00066669": "has good accuracy as standard if this", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00218-00066670-00066885": "were mine I'd be happy to use this as it", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00219-00066886-00067077": "is and gets a lot of enjoyment from it", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00220-00067078-00067398": "I've done the same with my m4 of course", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00221-00067399-00067581": "it goes without saying it can be further", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00222-00067582-00067797": "improved with some light upgrades and", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00223-00067798-00068037": "heavier BBS you know those guys that", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00224-00068038-00068379": "only prefer wood on aks and kind of the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00225-00068380-00068595": "same when it comes to enforce anything", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00226-00068596-00068817": "that's produced nowadays is so far from", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00227-00068818-00069048": "the how they used to be I typically", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00228-00069049-00069285": "don't think they look good anymore since", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00229-00069286-00069516": "I've had this rifle to play with my", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00230-00069517-00070038": "opinion has shifted somewhat so on even", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00231-00070039-00070275": "naturally warming to their affections or", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00232-00070276-00070704": "I'm being conditioned in that argument", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00233-00070705-00070914": "is probably the latter without my", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00234-00070915-00071139": "personal tastes coming into it the tokyo", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00235-00071140-00071499": "marui MTR 16 is another fine gbbr right", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00236-00071500-00071643": "from its bar designed box", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00237-00071644-00071943": "the finish is superb it's a solidly", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00238-00071944-00072150": "constructed platform that has a crisp", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00239-00072151-00072369": "and snappy shooting performance with the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00240-00072370-00072591": "good out-of-the-box accuracy it's", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00241-00072592-00072798": "lightweight and handy the functions are", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00242-00072799-00072963": "all positive it's completely", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00243-00072964-00073167": "ambidextrous it has a wide range of", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00244-00073168-00073386": "aftermarket upgrades and it's built upon", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00245-00073387-00073629": "team's reliable gas blowback as that", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00246-00073630-00074016": "system any bad news to speak of yeah", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00247-00074017-00074214": "yeah there is but it's not really a", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00248-00074215-00074457": "letdown first of all the price of the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00249-00074458-00074703": "rifle is on the heavier side it is", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00250-00074704-00074895": "recommended to be used on weaker gas", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00251-00074896-00075138": "although everyone outside of Japan have", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00252-00075139-00075257": "been known to use green cast", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00253-00075258-00075501": "successfully the look of the rifle may", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00254-00075502-00075744": "not be - everybody's tastes hop up", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00255-00075745-00075921": "adjustement is annoying to get to as", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00256-00075922-00076194": "with the m4 the rail can be tricky to", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00257-00076195-00076457": "replace in many cases needing an adapter", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00258-00076458-00076701": "it's not as realistic as other gas", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00259-00076702-00076956": "blowback competitors an original marui", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00260-00076957-00077268": "spares can be difficult to locate so", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00261-00077269-00077478": "apart from that if you're interested in", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00262-00077479-00077706": "buying a gas blowback m4 but fancy", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00263-00077707-00077931": "something a bit different or if you're", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00264-00077932-00078084": "looking for a sweet little rocky", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00265-00078085-00078324": "rifle or competition gun I would", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00266-00078325-00078672": "wholeheartedly recommend the MTR 16 the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00267-00078673-00078897": "retail price is high this is true", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00268-00078898-00079128": "however it is a beautifully lightweight", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00269-00079129-00079347": "and maneuverable carbine that will work", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00270-00079348-00079587": "in multiple roles you've also got the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00271-00079588-00079718": "benefit of its ambidextrous controls", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00272-00079719-00079998": "which is very reminiscent of the hk416", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00273-00079999-00080340": "a5 all these enhancements are bolt onto", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00274-00080341-00080547": "a foundation that stands as one of the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00275-00080548-00080849": "best gas blowback ar-fifteens available", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00276-00080850-00081054": "a weapon system which I continue to", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00277-00081055-00081285": "describe as one that I have absolute", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00278-00081286-00081557": "confidence in then just take my word for", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00279-00081558-00081776": "it go ahead and look at the feedback on", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00280-00081777-00082080": "forums and Facebook groups check out the", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00281-00082081-00082236": "link below where you can buy your very", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00282-00082237-00082574": "own MTR 16 and once again thanks to wolf", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00283-00082575-00082767": "armories for sending me this rifle to", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00284-00082768-00082980": "review if you've enjoyed this video why", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00285-00082981-00083196": "not show me by hitting the like and if", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00286-00083197-00083387": "you're new here 1 or subscribe and be", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00287-00083388-00083581": "notified when my next video goes live", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00288-00083582-00083835": "for regular updates you can find me on", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00289-00083836-00084068": "facebook and instagram so until next", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00290-00084069-00084287": "time take care of yourselves and I catch", "WkFBmG7e2ro-00291-00084288-00084600": "you in a bit"}}, {"audio_id": "WkOJj9JMAbI", "text": {"WkOJj9JMAbI-00000-00000003-00000227": "hi my name is Daniel Connell and I've", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00001-00000228-00000419": "been running a project developing things", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00002-00000420-00000559": "you can make yourself from recycled", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00003-00000560-00000850": "materials which using basic tools with", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00004-00000851-00001049": "the idea that they be make people by", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00005-00001050-00001253": "anyone anywhere under any circumstances", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00006-00001254-00001573": "wind turbines hydro turbines cook stoves", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00007-00001574-00001864": "just basic basic human needs kind of", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00008-00001866-00002132": "stuff and then documenting it doing full", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00009-00002133-00002345": "construction tutorials on how to make it", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00010-00002346-00002597": "and use it and replicate it it's all", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00011-00002598-00002916": "open source so welcome any feedback", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00012-00002917-00003138": "especially if you do end up making this", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00013-00003139-00003365": "please let us know we've got links to", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00014-00003365-00003536": "the Facebook group and my email and the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00015-00003536-00003745": "description please post photos and all", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00016-00003746-00003974": "that sort of stuff today we're going to", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00017-00003975-00004202": "be making one of these which is a rocket", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00018-00004203-00004502": "stove optimized for cooking it's just", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00019-00004503-00004756": "made of food cans and some insulation we", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00020-00004757-00005000": "use in this case perlite a little bit of", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00021-00005001-00005288": "twisting wire and that's it all the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00022-00005289-00005866": "materials involved here are about $2", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00023-00005867-00006184": "basically just got food cans three large", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00024-00006185-00006529": "two medium three small these don't have", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00025-00006530-00006725": "to be like specifically this exact size", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00026-00006726-00006898": "like as long as they're generally about", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00027-00006900-00007130": "right and then the other materials are", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00028-00007131-00007484": "twisting wire perlite this is the only", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00029-00007484-00007673": "stuff that you're likely to end up", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00030-00007673-00007808": "paying for but it's real cheap it's", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00031-00007809-00008162": "about $2 worth here if you can't get", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00032-00008163-00008306": "this for some reason I've also used", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00033-00008307-00008564": "pumice which works really well it's like", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00034-00008565-00008837": "a small grain stuff vermiculite which is", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00035-00008838-00009071": "similar to this with the tools we'll be", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00036-00009072-00009317": "using a pretty basic just pair of tin", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00037-00009318-00009667": "snips just scissors form it'll pair of", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00038-00009668-00009869": "pliers snub-nosed is better than", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00039-00009870-00010024": "needlenose for when we'll be using this", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00040-00010025-00010564": "a twist wire a stick for poking pin", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00041-00010565-00010753": "magic like a permanent marker for", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00042-00010754-00011113": "stirring lines and I can opener for", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00043-00011114-00011620": "opening the cans I prefer this kind like", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00044-00011621-00012131": "the Jaggi tooth kind it's better for a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00045-00012132-00012281": "process which I'll explain when we get", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00046-00012282-00012470": "to that but so in terms of safety it's", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00047-00012471-00012626": "quite easy to cut your hands and bit of", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00048-00012627-00012835": "sharp bits of sharp metal so if you're", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00049-00012836-00012938": "worried about that", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00050-00012938-00013203": "wear some kind of work gloves and", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00051-00013204-00013422": "other than that is pretty safe we'll be", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00052-00013422-00013596": "going through like fire safety and all", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00053-00013597-00013746": "that sort of stuff how to use the stove", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00054-00013747-00014063": "itself at the later in the tutorial", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00055-00014063-00014408": "other than that it's yeah it's not too", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00056-00014409-00014700": "dangerous a process you will probably", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00057-00014701-00014916": "live first take one of your medium hands", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00058-00014916-00015128": "take the paper off and then we're going", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00059-00015129-00015477": "to be just like opening this 3/4 of the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00060-00015478-00015657": "way around so not taking the fourth", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00061-00015658-00016475": "thing out so that you have like a flap", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00062-00016476-00016853": "like that and then you want to draw a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00063-00016854-00017306": "line which basically starts from one end", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00064-00017307-00017565": "comes around to the other end and you", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00065-00017566-00017796": "want that to come out by about thirty", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00066-00017797-00018102": "degrees it just eyeball that like it", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00067-00018103-00018281": "doesn't need to be precise push that out", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00068-00018282-00018653": "of the way a little bit and you want to", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00069-00018654-00019178": "cut lines at about like a quarter of a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00070-00019179-00019737": "way around between the rim and that line", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00071-00019738-00020156": "you just drew fold that bottom one in", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00072-00020157-00020418": "being really this is kind of the point", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00073-00020419-00020562": "where like you want to start thinking", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00074-00020563-00020762": "about not cutting your hands so just be", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00075-00020763-00020900": "careful like take everything slowly", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00076-00020901-00021200": "don't rush and then probably using your", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00077-00021201-00021625": "pliers just to really crimp that metal", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00078-00021626-00022125": "Bend those corner flaps down so that", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00079-00022126-00022749": "they lock so then take one of your large", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00080-00022750-00023055": "cans and you're going to trace an oval", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00081-00023056-00023340": "on that which this kind of thing going", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00082-00023341-00023642": "to poke out through at a 30-degree angle", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00083-00023643-00024005": "and then just mark the center and then", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00084-00024006-00024396": "draw so half that and then quarter it", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00085-00024397-00025047": "and then third those quarters so you end", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00086-00025048-00025455": "up with twelve segments and then you can", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00087-00025456-00025640": "use a drill for this next bit but you", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00088-00025641-00025820": "can also just use your can opener just", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00089-00025822-00026364": "punch a hole in the center there", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00090-00026364-00026833": "pity roughly large enough that you can", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00091-00026833-00027302": "then get your tin snips and cut out", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00092-00027304-00027586": "those sections this doesn't need to be", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00093-00027587-00027795": "precise we've read little of this needs", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00094-00027797-00028300": "to be precise really this can be a bit", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00095-00028301-00028666": "fiddly the first couple of cuts if the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00096-00028667-00028813": "metal just goes sideways on you rather", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00097-00028814-00029020": "than cutting then just sort of try to be", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00098-00029020-00029194": "in the back flat so you can get like a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00099-00029195-00029557": "proper slice into it and again be real", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00100-00029558-00029727": "careful with your hands here because if", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00101-00029729-00029899": "you're going to cut yourself this is", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00102-00029900-00030079": "when you're going to do it so that you", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00103-00030080-00030379": "end up with that which is super rough", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00104-00030380-00030624": "but it's fine doesn't need to not be and", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00105-00030625-00031102": "then just bend these tabs out so just", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00106-00031102-00031411": "reach in with your pliers to the base of", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00107-00031412-00032080": "the triangle and and it is check that", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00108-00032081-00032458": "that goes through there basically at the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00109-00032458-00032838": "30 degree angle that is going to be on", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00110-00032839-00033124": "we're now going to do basically the same", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00111-00033125-00033403": "except in here to accommodate one of", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00112-00033404-00033613": "your small cans which will also be on", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00113-00033614-00033949": "that same 30-degree angle so take one of", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00114-00033950-00034279": "your small cans remove the top and the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00115-00034280-00034735": "bottom this is the bit that's going to", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00116-00034736-00034936": "be facing like downwards and your", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00117-00034937-00035320": "chimneys going to be on the top so draw", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00118-00035321-00035598": "an oval in that part of the face there", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00119-00035599-00035869": "and this this bit just sort of eyeball", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00120-00035870-00036396": "it and then kind of just eyeball so", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00121-00036397-00036571": "using the same width but just make it", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00122-00036572-00037183": "longer so it's in an oval and I mean if", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00123-00037184-00037390": "it turns out too small you just cut it", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00124-00037391-00037515": "larger and if it turns out too large", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00125-00037516-00037867": "will be wiring it back shut so and then", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00126-00037868-00038637": "do the same thing of marking 12 sections", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00127-00038638-00038796": "and then punching a hole and then", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00128-00038797-00040526": "cutting it out in the same way like so", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00129-00040527-00040830": "make sure that that goes nicely in there", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00130-00040831-00041202": "and then we're just going to put a loop", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00131-00041203-00041670": "of wire around there and then twist that", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00132-00041671-00042548": "off so the trick of twisting wire is to", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00133-00042549-00042867": "grab as far down as you can with your", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00134-00042868-00043098": "pliers on the twist you don't want to", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00135-00043099-00043242": "keep twisting from the top where you're", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00136-00043243-00043422": "basically like if you'd like using the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00137-00043423-00043584": "wire to twist itself if that makes sense", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00138-00043585-00043737": "then you're basically going to break it", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00139-00043738-00044142": "you want to always be getting down to", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00140-00044143-00044471": "the base of things so saying like that", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00141-00044472-00044772": "essentially and then just to stop that", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00142-00044773-00044994": "from wandering off I usually just bend a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00143-00044995-00045300": "few of these tabs down so that's the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00144-00045301-00045606": "back half of the burn tube and the first", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00145-00045607-00045906": "sort of third of the riser so you woods", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00146-00045907-00046110": "going to be in here your secondary", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00147-00046111-00046353": "combustion is going to be in here we are", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00148-00046354-00046629": "going to just like make the other half", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00149-00046630-00046905": "of the burn tube so take your can up", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00150-00046906-00047307": "note you want to cut around two-thirds", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00151-00047308-00047568": "and then leave about a centimeter each", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00152-00047569-00047817": "side of like connected metal and then", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00153-00047818-00048042": "cut out the rest so you have two cuts a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00154-00048043-00048387": "large cut and a small cut and then it's", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00155-00048388-00048689": "going to reach through carefully and", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00156-00048690-00049514": "bends that top flap out and down", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00157-00049515-00049820": "and that basically is now like a little", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00158-00049821-00050054": "shelf for setting your wood and get you", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00159-00050055-00050165": "a little bit of extra length that it's", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00160-00050166-00050321": "gonna like be held up these like a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00161-00050322-00050517": "little raised lip lip which like grabs", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00162-00050518-00050702": "onto the wood so I can't slide out as", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00163-00050703-00051035": "easily and lifts the wood up off the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00164-00051036-00051188": "bottom of the tube so it can be", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00165-00051189-00051344": "surrounded by flame and air and burn a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00166-00051345-00051617": "lot more effectively and this cut is to", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00167-00051619-00051893": "feed oxygen feed air into the coals", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00168-00051894-00052115": "which are going to collect in the bottom", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00169-00052116-00052376": "of the tube now to connect this into", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00170-00052377-00052671": "here in a sort of strong nice way this", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00171-00052672-00052868": "is gonna be on the bottom on that bottom", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00172-00052869-00053237": "side just make a little 1 centimeter or", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00173-00053238-00053499": "so like really not very not very deep", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00174-00053500-00053879": "cut and then just crushed that in with", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00175-00053880-00054291": "some force and then just compiling all", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00176-00054291-00054366": "of these together", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00177-00054366-00054791": "take your in a bit here Chuck that so", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00178-00054792-00055191": "that it's poking out through the hole", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00179-00055191-00055716": "there taking this bit here and then just", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00180-00055716-00056025": "forcing that into there very carefully", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00181-00056026-00056231": "because if you slip you're gonna touch", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00182-00056232-00056562": "the middle it's gonna take a little bit", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00183-00056563-00057273": "of force like that and then twist this", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00184-00057274-00057546": "front can so that your shelters", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00185-00057547-00057735": "horizontal so you can see this is", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00186-00057736-00057885": "starting to take shape now you've got", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00187-00057886-00058140": "the burn tube we woods going to go here", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00188-00058141-00058316": "and this is going to be your your", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00189-00058317-00058575": "chimney sort of with the double wall so", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00190-00058576-00058890": "we're just going to top and bottom your", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00191-00058891-00059250": "remaining two small cans and your large", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00192-00059251-00059516": "cans and then we'll get they will just", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00193-00059517-00059888": "be stacking those together so you've got", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00194-00059889-00060197": "those two and then just gonna be", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00195-00060198-00060551": "snipping these again like little snips", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00196-00060552-00060861": "on the edge to lock those together so", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00197-00060862-00061065": "just keeping in mind that you want if", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00198-00061066-00061268": "you've got like a inward-facing to like", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00199-00061269-00061430": "end of a can that's gonna be your outer", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00200-00061431-00061635": "whereas if you've got like the bits that", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00201-00061636-00061779": "are sort of like pokey outie", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00202-00061779-00061967": "they can be either innards or outers it", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00203-00061969-00062087": "doesn't really matter and then without", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00204-00062088-00062378": "just lodging things through much just", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00205-00062379-00062630": "jam that in there", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00206-00062631-00062973": "and so there's a chimney it's not so", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00207-00062974-00063138": "vitally important of these connection", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00208-00063139-00063426": "points be super strong because this is", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00209-00063427-00063571": "going to be like surrounded and like", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00210-00063572-00063816": "pectin in your installation anyway it is", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00211-00063817-00064171": "important that the the connection", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00212-00064172-00064396": "between the tuber and tube-like medium", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00213-00064397-00064771": "cans is strong and when these one fell", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00214-00064772-00065124": "on these ones go on here you want this", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00215-00065125-00065347": "to be strongly downwards because if", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00216-00065348-00065523": "you've got like a pot of water or", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00217-00065524-00065704": "something heavy on there you want met", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00218-00065705-00065904": "like downwards forcefully to be quite", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00219-00065905-00066111": "strong and then so we're gonna do", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00220-00066112-00066478": "similar with your large cans or cut off", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00221-00066479-00066742": "the top and bottom then I need the side", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00222-00066743-00067157": "of these you want to just make for", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00223-00067158-00067423": "really little cuts just like a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00224-00067424-00067725": "centimeter evenly spaced and then you're", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00225-00067726-00068259": "gonna have basically two tabs that go", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00226-00068260-00068793": "outside it's either gonna Bend those out", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00227-00068794-00069265": "a little bit and to the go inside but", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00228-00069266-00069480": "like two opposite ones sort of go out a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00229-00069481-00069744": "bit the other two go in a bit and then", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00230-00069745-00070805": "you're going to drop that over here that", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00231-00070806-00071055": "essentially and then the same with this", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00232-00071056-00071118": "one", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00233-00071119-00071316": "and actually don't really love this", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00234-00071317-00071440": "connection method it's good and strong", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00235-00071441-00071619": "for downwards force but it's a bit sort", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00236-00071620-00071797": "of gapi and like you can get like", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00237-00071798-00072063": "perlite spilling out of there because", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00238-00072064-00072207": "the outer wall shouldn't really get that", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00239-00072208-00072336": "hot because like you've got so much", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00240-00072337-00072612": "insulation in between you can put some", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00241-00072613-00072772": "tape like some gaffer tape or something", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00242-00072773-00072942": "around there just to seal it in but it", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00243-00072943-00073317": "seems a bit inelegant so if anybody has", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00244-00073318-00073644": "a better idea of how to do this then let", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00245-00073645-00073881": "me know there's this is all a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00246-00073882-00074229": "open-source project and like everything", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00247-00074230-00074568": "that i design so like you can hit me up", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00248-00074569-00074901": "in the comments or send me an email my", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00249-00074902-00075184": "email address is in the link in the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00250-00075185-00075450": "description also we have like a Facebook", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00251-00075451-00075630": "group which is like the discussion forum", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00252-00075631-00075950": "for all this and you can", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00253-00075951-00076136": "ask questions there but also like please", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00254-00076137-00076310": "post results like if you do make this", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00255-00076311-00076519": "please let us know and so then that's", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00256-00076520-00076906": "quite strong downwards but not", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00257-00076907-00077081": "necessarily strong upwards so if you've", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00258-00077082-00077222": "picked this up at issue when it's like", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00259-00077223-00077531": "got the instrument in there and as full", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00260-00077532-00077891": "weight that can then separate out sort", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00261-00077892-00078025": "of why I don't love this connection", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00262-00078026-00078207": "method but it is sort of good and strong", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00263-00078208-00078412": "that way especially when this is fully", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00264-00078413-00078601": "packed so just a loop of twisting wire", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00265-00078602-00078787": "or some kind of fencing wire or whatever", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00266-00078788-00079040": "you're using around the base there just", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00267-00079041-00079286": "to lock it off and then this makes sure", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00268-00079287-00079562": "that that's chimney centered one of the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00269-00079563-00079736": "last steps we're going to do is we're", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00270-00079737-00080054": "just going to basically fill this with", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00271-00080055-00080251": "perlite it can be handy to use like one", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00272-00080252-00080413": "of the lids that you cut off here just", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00273-00080414-00080597": "as I sort of like seals that you don't", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00274-00080598-00080867": "end up pouring perlite into your chimney", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00275-00080868-00081106": "there so just make sure that anything", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00276-00081107-00081248": "sort of like basically closed off", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00277-00081249-00081404": "there's only huge gaps it's gonna like", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00278-00081405-00081556": "piss out and do like it's quite", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00279-00081557-00081887": "fine-grained stuff so it can find its", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00280-00081888-00082043": "way into your burn tube here and if it's", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00281-00082044-00082250": "like the occasional bit here and there", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00282-00082251-00082361": "like that's fine but if you've got like", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00283-00082362-00082559": "a serious hole but this is going to like", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00284-00082560-00082859": "pour in there so that's what the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00285-00082860-00083159": "twisting wire was for basically and so", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00286-00083160-00083434": "that's just a matter of going in there", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00287-00083435-00083687": "get things keep them nice and centered", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00288-00083688-00084278": "and then taking your stick just making", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00289-00084279-00084659": "that nice and compact sort of fill that", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00290-00084660-00085012": "up pretty much to the level of the inner", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00291-00085013-00085742": "tube so that you end up with that kind", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00292-00085743-00086234": "of situation so on this one like the the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00293-00086235-00086443": "tube is that the burn tube is not really", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00294-00086444-00086630": "kept it's 30 degrees like it's sort of I", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00295-00086631-00086830": "feel it that so to get a little bit flat", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00296-00086831-00087173": "but it'll still do the job just remains", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00297-00087174-00087855": "to make four cuts evenly spaced", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00298-00087856-00088304": "and then is bending out from those lines", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00299-00088305-00088718": "triangles it's a bending light so", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00300-00088719-00088892": "there's bending the the corners in", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00301-00088893-00089403": "essentially and that's to give like a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00302-00089404-00089742": "gap for the fire to get out and so", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00303-00089743-00089922": "you're like a pot on here like that's", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00304-00089923-00090113": "like space for the flame to get out", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00305-00090114-00090366": "otherwise it'll it won't draw it won't", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00306-00090367-00090909": "flow but it also makes these points just", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00307-00090910-00091319": "stronger so if you just like cut down a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00308-00091320-00091542": "bit of turbine or whatever like these", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00309-00091543-00091692": "would be quite floppy but having those", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00310-00091693-00091884": "corners or like bent over makes them a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00311-00091885-00092075": "lot more stable so that they'll take", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00312-00092076-00092393": "like heavier heavier loads and then one", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00313-00092394-00092634": "last step just sort of make the thing a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00314-00092635-00092871": "bit sort of safer and nicer these um", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00315-00092872-00093335": "these tabs here just sort of give them", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00316-00093336-00093542": "just like bend them back on themselves", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00317-00093543-00094007": "basically let's curl them it's basically", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00318-00094008-00094274": "it it's important when you light it's", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00319-00094275-00094526": "the first time that you do so in a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00320-00094527-00094698": "ventilated area because there's a lot of", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00321-00094699-00094836": "plastics and metals in here which will", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00322-00094837-00095028": "burn off with that first burn when it", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00323-00095029-00095207": "gets up to full temperature and then", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00324-00095208-00095363": "after that they won't be present anymore", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00325-00095364-00095606": "but just that first time it's good like", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00326-00095607-00095796": "you know 5-10 minutes like in an empty", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00327-00095797-00096163": "space don't breathe it basically and", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00328-00096164-00096461": "after that it should be good for indoor", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00329-00096462-00096774": "indoor use necessary so this is about", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00330-00096775-00096921": "the size of wood that you want about a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00331-00096922-00097224": "centimeter or two square and yay long", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00332-00097225-00097434": "just enough that it can reach the back", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00333-00097435-00097811": "of the of the burn tube and be resting", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00334-00097812-00098172": "on the on the shelf here it's important", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00335-00098173-00098438": "that you have the woods in air as much", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00336-00098439-00098606": "as possible this is the reason of this", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00337-00098607-00098837": "little shelf here because then like you", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00338-00098838-00099072": "get air all around it you get fire all", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00339-00099073-00099280": "around that you get coals underneath it", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00340-00099281-00099656": "and it burns a lot more effectively you", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00341-00099657-00099897": "don't want to over stock this you don't", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00342-00099898-00100226": "overfeed it you want to have about like", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00343-00100227-00100371": "when it's running optimally and up to up", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00344-00100372-00100529": "to temperature you'll have like about a", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00345-00100530-00100872": "quarter full of coals a quarter full of", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00346-00100873-00101063": "wood and then half full of air that's", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00347-00101064-00101294": "optimal the more flame you can get from", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00348-00101295-00101450": "your wood the more volume of flame and", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00349-00101451-00101648": "if you can fill like your riser with", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00350-00101649-00101892": "fire then it bumps up the temperature", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00351-00101893-00102035": "you get a more complete burn it's a lot", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00352-00102036-00102246": "more efficient and it dumps all of the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00353-00102247-00102573": "energy out of your out of your fuel into", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00354-00102574-00102719": "what you're cooking like very very", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00355-00102720-00102926": "quickly and you'll have to keep like you", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00356-00102927-00103050": "know keep an eye on it it'll go out", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00357-00103051-00103178": "after like five or ten minutes because", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00358-00103179-00103364": "it was burn through the fuel but if", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00359-00103365-00103476": "you're cooking on it anyway you're going", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00360-00103477-00103596": "to be here it's not like it's sort of", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00361-00103597-00103760": "set and forget heating kind of stoves", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00362-00103761-00103934": "and cooking stoves so it's something", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00363-00103935-00104114": "that you're gonna have your eye on so", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00364-00104115-00104384": "the limitations of the stove are mostly", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00365-00104385-00104639": "the materials that it's um there's food", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00366-00104640-00104901": "tin so it's thin mild steel so this", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00367-00104902-00105038": "won't last forever this isn't meant to", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00368-00105039-00105203": "be like this isn't meant to last forever", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00369-00105204-00105345": "this isn't something you'd build into", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00370-00105346-00105536": "your house and like you know have for", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00371-00105538-00105704": "decades and pass on to your children", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00372-00105705-00105951": "this is meant to be rapidly makeable", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00373-00105952-00106197": "rapidly deployable and do a good job", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00374-00106198-00106409": "it's for low regionals and violent", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00375-00106410-00106682": "environment global southern countries", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00376-00106683-00107097": "disaster relief refugee camps camping", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00377-00107098-00107390": "prepper situation survivalist situation", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00378-00107391-00107544": "homesteading like anywhere that you need", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00379-00107545-00108029": "to be able to cook food heat water very", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00380-00108030-00108207": "quickly and easily with like basically", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00381-00108208-00108461": "nothing in materials this is a very", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00382-00108463-00108783": "cheap easy and effective design so", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00383-00108783-00109058": "lighting it is just a process of putting", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00384-00109059-00109371": "some some papers and kindling in the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00385-00109372-00109575": "bottom of the tube not too much just", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00386-00109576-00109904": "enough to hold a flame a couple of", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00387-00109905-00110163": "little wood chips some surface area and", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00388-00110164-00110516": "then a couple of long bits especially if", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00389-00110517-00110622": "you've got something which is a bit sort", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00390-00110623-00110847": "of feathered just take that initial", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00391-00110848-00111051": "flame and I find the easiest way is just", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00392-00111052-00111589": "to light it in the oxygen gap once it's", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00393-00111590-00111778": "going", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00394-00111779-00111958": "you'll know because your stop smoking", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00395-00111958-00112258": "will stop running away into coals once", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00396-00112258-00112465": "you get the coals in the bottom of your", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00397-00112466-00112765": "tube and anything you put in there it's", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00398-00112766-00113383": "gonna burst into flame essentially so", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00399-00113383-00113530": "that's that that's how you make it it's", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00400-00113531-00113749": "how you use it like I say to make one of", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00401-00113750-00113941": "your own please let us know posting the", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00402-00113942-00114151": "comments from the Facebook group I just", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00403-00114152-00114408": "wanted to add that this uses about 80", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00404-00114409-00114595": "percent less firewood then equivalent", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00405-00114596-00114673": "open fire", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00406-00114674-00114838": "so in a lot of parts of the world that", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00407-00114839-00114999": "means people have to spend less time", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00408-00115000-00115236": "gathering firewood less deforestation", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00409-00115238-00115611": "less soil erosion and less some less", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00410-00115613-00115804": "smoke means less smoke inhalation less", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00411-00115805-00115999": "respiratory disease which kills more", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00412-00116000-00116436": "people for a year than malaria and it's", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00413-00116438-00116689": "lightweight it's portable it's easy it's", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00414-00116690-00117036": "safe and it's good so yeah that's it", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00415-00117038-00117234": "thanks for thanks for watching like and", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00416-00117235-00117568": "subscribe etc", "WkOJj9JMAbI-00417-00117569-00117775": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "WkT1OQ_KuUo", "text": {"WkT1OQ_KuUo-00000-00000065-00000280": "sakharam Oh Portuguese pronunciation", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00001-00000281-00000608": "schoo M is a municipality located in the", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00002-00000609-00000911": "Brazilian state of Rio de Janeiro it's", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00003-00000911-00001121": "population is eighty-three thousand", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00004-00001122-00001400": "seven hundred and fifty 2016 and its", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00005-00001401-00001712": "area is 350 three thousand five hundred", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00006-00001713-00001946": "and sixty-six square kilometers", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00007-00001947-00002234": "it is located almost seventy three", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00008-00002235-00002573": "kilometres east of Rio de Janeiro it was", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00009-00002574-00002915": "known as Brazil surfing capital it is", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00010-00002916-00003098": "one of the most beautiful cities in", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00011-00003099-00003461": "Brazil during the mid 19th century the", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00012-00003461-00003659": "Conservative Party in its leaders were", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00013-00003660-00003859": "known as Sakura mer", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00014-00003860-00004559": "because of the base of support here", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00015-00004560-00005152": "topic the surfing capital", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00016-00005153-00005441": "sakharam through its beaches especially", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00017-00005442-00005627": "a town a beach is known as the Brazilian", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00018-00005628-00005881": "capital of surfing for its perfect waves", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00019-00005882-00006145": "and indescribable beauty and strength in", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00020-00006146-00006452": "the 70s sack Rima hosted the longing", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00021-00006453-00006770": "surfing festivals and in 2017 Sakuma", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00022-00006770-00006934": "becomes part of the world surfing", "WkT1OQ_KuUo-00023-00006936-00007309": "circuit with wsl"}}, {"audio_id": "WlRIGcPMAEY", "text": {"WlRIGcPMAEY-00000-00000026-00000296": "wealth in the United States is commonly", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00001-00000297-00000499": "measured in terms of net worth which is", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00002-00000500-00000688": "the sum of all assets including the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00003-00000689-00000899": "market value of real estate like a home", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00004-00000900-00001232": "- all liabilities the United States as", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00005-00001233-00001511": "the wealthiest country in the world for", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00006-00001512-00001771": "example a household in possession of an", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00007-00001772-00002142": "$800,000 house $5,000 in mutual funds", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00008-00002143-00002492": "$30,000 in cars $20,000 worth of stock", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00009-00002493-00002789": "in their own company and a $45,000 IRA", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00010-00002790-00003099": "would have assets totaling $900,000", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00011-00003100-00003320": "assuming that this household would have", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00012-00003321-00003740": "a $250,000 Mortgage $40,000 in car loans", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00013-00003740-00004015": "and $10,000 in credit card debt its", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00014-00004017-00004391": "debts would total $300,000 subtracting", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00015-00004392-00004541": "the debts from the worth of this house", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00016-00004542-00005026": "holds assets 900,000 - $300,000 equals", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00017-00005027-00005272": "$600,000 this household would have a net", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00018-00005273-00005629": "worth of $600,000 net worth can vary", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00019-00005630-00005804": "with fluctuations in value of the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00020-00005805-00006088": "underlying assets as one would expect", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00021-00006089-00006308": "households with greater income feature", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00022-00006309-00006517": "the highest net worth though high income", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00023-00006518-00006725": "cannot be taken as an always accurate", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00024-00006726-00006970": "indicator of net worth overall the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00025-00006972-00007166": "number of wealthier households is on the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00026-00007167-00007364": "rise with baby boomers hitting the highs", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00027-00007365-00007642": "of their careers in addition wealth is", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00028-00007643-00007834": "unevenly distributed with the wealthiest", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00029-00007836-00008159": "25 percent of US households owning 87", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00030-00008159-00008294": "percent of the wealth in the United", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00031-00008295-00008524": "States which was fifty four point two", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00032-00008525-00008821": "trillion dollars in 2009 US household", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00033-00008822-00009010": "and nonprofit organization net worth", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00034-00009011-00009217": "rose from forty four point two trillion", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00035-00009218-00009506": "dollars in q1 2002 a pre-recession peak", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00036-00009507-00009713": "of sixty seven point seven trillion", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00037-00009714-00010112": "dollars in q3 2007 it then fell thirteen", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00038-00010113-00010331": "point one trillion dollars to fifty four", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00039-00010332-00010637": "point six trillion dollars in q1 2009", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00040-00010638-00010916": "due to the subprime mortgage crisis it", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00041-00010917-00011128": "then recovered rising consistently to", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00042-00011129-00011317": "eighty six point eight trillion dollars", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00043-00011318-00011669": "by q4 2015 this is nearly double the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00044-00011670-00012119": "2000 level", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00045-00012120-00012627": "topic income versus wealth", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00046-00012628-00012860": "while income is often seen as a type of", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00047-00012861-00013091": "wealth in colloquial language use wealth", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00048-00013092-00013275": "and income are two substantially", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00049-00013276-00013419": "different measures of economic", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00050-00013419-00013694": "prosperity wealth is the total number of", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00051-00013695-00013896": "net possessions of an individual or", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00052-00013897-00014079": "household while income is the total", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00053-00014080-00014253": "inflow of wealth over a given time", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00054-00014254-00014508": "period hence the change in wealth over", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00055-00014509-00014721": "that time period is equal to the income", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00056-00014722-00014933": "minus the expenditures in that period", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00057-00014934-00015312": "income is a so-called flow variable", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00058-00015313-00015541": "while wealth is a so-called stock", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00059-00015543-00015960": "variable", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00060-00015961-00016714": "topic changes in wealth 1989 to 2001", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00061-00016715-00016933": "when observing the changes in the wealth", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00062-00016934-00017139": "among American households one can note", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00063-00017140-00017355": "an increase in wealthier individuals and", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00064-00017356-00017505": "a decrease in the number of poor", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00065-00017506-00017689": "households while net worth increased", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00066-00017690-00017908": "most substantially in semi wealthy and", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00067-00017909-00018144": "wealthy households overall the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00068-00018145-00018325": "percentage of households with a negative", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00069-00018326-00018571": "net worth more debt than assets declined", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00070-00018572-00018952": "from 9.5 percent in 1989 to 4.1 percent", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00071-00018953-00019203": "in 2001 the percentage of net worths", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00072-00019204-00019483": "ranging from $500,000 to 1 million", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00073-00019484-00019633": "doubled while the percentage of", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00074-00019634-00020017": "millionaires tripled from 1995 to 2004", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00075-00020018-00020181": "there was tremendous growth among", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00076-00020182-00020374": "household wealth as it nearly doubled", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00077-00020375-00020542": "from twenty one point nine trillion", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00078-00020543-00020730": "dollars to forty three point six", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00079-00020731-00020902": "trillion dollars but the wealthiest", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00080-00020903-00021081": "quartile of the economic distribution", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00081-00021082-00021283": "made up eighty nine percent of this", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00082-00021284-00021541": "growth during this time frame wealth", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00083-00021542-00021742": "became increasingly unequal and the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00084-00021743-00021958": "wealthiest 25 percent became even", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00085-00021959-00022252": "wealthier according to US Census Bureau", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00086-00022253-00022594": "statistics this upward shift is most", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00087-00022595-00022794": "likely the result of a booming housing", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00088-00022795-00022959": "market which caused homeowners to", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00089-00022960-00023167": "experience tremendous increases in home", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00090-00023168-00023487": "equity life cycles have also attributed", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00091-00023488-00023658": "to the rising wealth among Americans", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00092-00023659-00023908": "with more and more baby boomers reaching", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00093-00023909-00024081": "the climax of their careers and the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00094-00024082-00024271": "middle-aged population making up the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00095-00024272-00024462": "larger segment of the population now", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00096-00024463-00024615": "than ever before more and more", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00097-00024616-00024799": "households have achieved comfortable", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00098-00024800-00025158": "levels of wealth zu shoud ii 2004 notes", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00099-00025159-00025347": "that household wealth usually Peaks", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00100-00025348-00025533": "around families headed by people in", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00101-00025534-00025728": "their 50s and as a result the baby", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00102-00025729-00025933": "boomer generation reached this age range", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00103-00025933-00026427": "at the time of the analysis", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00104-00026427-00027087": "topic changes in wealth after 2007", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00105-00027088-00027405": "household net worth fell from 2007 to", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00106-00027406-00027682": "2009 by a total of seventeen point five", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00107-00027683-00027889": "trillion dollars or twenty five point", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00108-00027889-00028120": "five percent this was the equivalent", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00109-00028120-00028483": "loss of one year of GDP by the fourth", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00110-00028483-00028708": "quarter of 2010 the household net worth", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00111-00028708-00028971": "had recovered by a growth of 1.3 percent", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00112-00028972-00029214": "to a total of 56 point eight trillion", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00113-00029215-00029508": "dollars an additional growth of fifteen", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00114-00029509-00029710": "point seven percent is needed just to", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00115-00029711-00029862": "bring the value to where it was before", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00116-00029863-00030133": "the recession started in December 2007", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00117-00030133-00030480": "in 2014 a record-breaking net worth of", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00118-00030481-00030676": "80 point seven trillion dollars was", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00119-00030677-00031089": "achieved", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00120-00031091-00031601": "soppec mechanisms to gain wealth", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00121-00031602-00031855": "assets are known as the raw materials of", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00122-00031856-00032027": "wealth and they consist primarily of", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00123-00032027-00032210": "stocks and other financial and", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00124-00032211-00032443": "non-financial property particularly home", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00125-00032444-00032668": "ownership while these assets are", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00126-00032669-00032902": "unequally distributed financial assets", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00127-00032903-00033274": "are much more unequal in 2004 the top 1%", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00128-00033275-00033632": "controlled 50.3% of the financial assets", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00129-00033633-00033883": "while the bottom 90% only held fourteen", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00130-00033884-00034055": "point four percent of the total u.s.", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00131-00034056-00034310": "financial assets these discrepancies", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00132-00034311-00034517": "exist despite the availability of many", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00133-00034518-00034711": "wealth building tools established by the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00134-00034712-00035042": "federal government these include 401k", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00135-00035043-00035468": "plans 403 B plans and IRAs traditional", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00136-00035469-00035827": "IRAs 401 K and 403 B plans are tax", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00137-00035828-00036049": "shelters created for working individuals", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00138-00036050-00036337": "these plans allow for tax sheltered or", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00139-00036338-00036560": "pre-tax contributions of earned income", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00140-00036561-00036761": "directly to tax sheltered savings", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00141-00036762-00037049": "accounts annual contributions are capped", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00142-00037050-00037255": "to ensure that high earners cannot enjoy", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00143-00037256-00037535": "the tax benefit disproportionally the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00144-00037536-00037724": "Roth IRA is another tool that can help", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00145-00037725-00037895": "create wealth in the working and middle", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00146-00037896-00038237": "classes assets in Roth IRAs grow", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00147-00038238-00038455": "tax-free interests dividends and capital", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00148-00038456-00038787": "gains are all exempt from income taxes", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00149-00038788-00039032": "contributions to Roth IRAs are limited", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00150-00039033-00039224": "to those with annual incomes less than", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00151-00039225-00039410": "the threshold established yearly by the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00152-00039411-00039749": "IRS the benefits of these plans however", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00153-00039750-00039943": "are only available to workers and", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00154-00039944-00040093": "families whose incomes and expenses", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00155-00040094-00040324": "allow them excess funds to commit for a", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00156-00040325-00040555": "long period typically until the investor", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00157-00040556-00040874": "reaches age 59 and a half The effect of", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00158-00040875-00041051": "these tools are further limited by the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00159-00041052-00041287": "contribution limits placed on them", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00160-00041288-00041549": "including human capital such as skills", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00161-00041550-00041774": "the United Nations estimated the total", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00162-00041775-00042029": "wealth of the United States in 2008 to", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00163-00042030-00042527": "be 118 trillion dollars", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00164-00042528-00043083": "topic wealth distribution", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00165-00043084-00043329": "according to an analysis that excludes", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00166-00043330-00043572": "pensions and Social Security the richest", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00167-00043573-00043893": "1% of the American population in 2007", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00168-00043894-00044103": "owned thirty four point six percent of", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00169-00044104-00044283": "the country's total wealth and the next", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00170-00044284-00044540": "19% owned 50 point five percent", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00171-00044541-00044859": "thus the top 20% of Americans owned", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00172-00044860-00045027": "eighty-five percent of the country's", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00173-00045028-00045210": "wealth and the bottom 80% of the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00174-00045211-00045528": "population owned 15 percent financial", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00175-00045529-00045740": "inequality was greater than inequality", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00176-00045741-00045965": "in total wealth with the top 1% of the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00177-00045966-00046340": "population owning 42.7% the next 19", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00178-00046341-00046650": "percent of Americans owning 50.3% and", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00179-00046651-00047007": "the bottom 80% owning 7 percent However", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00180-00047008-00047190": "according to the Federal Reserve for", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00181-00047191-00047460": "most households pensions and Social", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00182-00047461-00047687": "Security are the most important sources", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00183-00047688-00047904": "of income during retirement and the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00184-00047905-00048140": "promised benefits stream constitutes a", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00185-00048141-00048342": "sizeable fraction of household wealth", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00186-00048343-00048711": "and including pensions and Social", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00187-00048712-00048906": "Security and net worth makes the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00188-00048907-00049245": "distribution more even when including", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00189-00049246-00049425": "household wealth from pensions and", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00190-00049426-00049677": "Social Security the richest 1% of the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00191-00049678-00049995": "American population in 1992 owned 16", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00192-00049996-00050187": "percent of the country's total wealth as", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00193-00050188-00050430": "opposed to 32 percent when excluding", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00194-00050431-00050745": "pensions and Social Security after the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00195-00050746-00050990": "Great Recession which started in 2007", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00196-00050991-00051180": "the share of total wealth owned by the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00197-00051181-00051404": "top one percent of the population grew", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00198-00051405-00051602": "from thirty four point six percent to", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00199-00051603-00051804": "thirty seven point one percent and that", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00200-00051804-00052026": "owned by the top 20 percent of americans", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00201-00052027-00052208": "grew from eighty five percent to eighty", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00202-00052209-00052469": "seven point seven percent the Great", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00203-00052470-00052676": "Recession also caused a drop of thirty", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00204-00052677-00052860": "six point one percent in median", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00205-00052861-00053049": "household wealth but a drop of only", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00206-00053050-00053259": "eleven point one percent for the top one", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00207-00053260-00053653": "percent", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00208-00053654-00054191": "topic income distribution", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00209-00054191-00054469": "note the IRS specifically warned that", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00210-00054470-00054674": "changes in their definition of adjusted", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00211-00054675-00054841": "gross income make it impossible to", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00212-00054842-00055211": "compare pre-1980 with post one nine", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00213-00055212-00055469": "eight seven AGI so keep in mind that", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00214-00055470-00055685": "comparisons should be in gross income or", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00215-00055686-00055975": "salary and not in AGI when reading", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00216-00055976-00056176": "statistics it behooves the reader to", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00217-00056177-00056344": "have this awareness according to the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00218-00056345-00056617": "Congressional Budget Office between 1979", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00219-00056619-00056915": "and 2007 incomes of the top one percent", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00220-00056916-00057116": "of Americans grew by an average of two", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00221-00057116-00057365": "hundred seventy five percent during the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00222-00057366-00057587": "same time period the sixty percent of", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00223-00057588-00057740": "Americans in the middle of the income", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00224-00057741-00057965": "scale saw their income rise by 40", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00225-00057966-00058391": "percent from 1992 to 2007 the top 400", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00226-00058391-00058604": "income earners in the US saw their", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00227-00058604-00058879": "income increased 392 percent and their", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00228-00058880-00059111": "average tax rate reduced by 37 percent", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00229-00059112-00059498": "in 2009 the average income of the top 1%", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00230-00059499-00059776": "was nine hundred sixty thousand dollars", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00231-00059777-00059950": "with a minimum income of three hundred", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00232-00059951-00060157": "forty-three thousand nine hundred twenty", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00233-00060158-00060353": "seven dollars during the economic", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00234-00060354-00060667": "expansion between 2002 and 2007 the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00235-00060669-00060901": "income of the top 1% grew ten times", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00236-00060902-00061109": "faster than the income of the bottom 90%", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00237-00061110-00061432": "in this period sixty-six percent of", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00238-00061433-00061610": "total income games went to the one", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00239-00061611-00061879": "percent who in 2007 had a larger share", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00240-00061880-00062067": "of total income than at any time since", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00241-00062069-00062429": "1928 according to PolitiFact and others", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00242-00062429-00062713": "the top 400 wealthiest Americans have", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00243-00062714-00062932": "more wealth than half of all Americans", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00244-00062933-00063200": "combined inherited wealth may help", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00245-00063201-00063386": "explain why many Americans who have", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00246-00063387-00063572": "become rich may have had a substantial", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00247-00063573-00063965": "head start in September 2012 according", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00248-00063966-00064235": "to the Institute for Policy Studies over", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00249-00064236-00064525": "60 percent of the Forbes richest 400", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00250-00064526-00064792": "Americans grew up in substantial", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00251-00064794-00065090": "privilege if a family has a positive net", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00252-00065091-00065246": "worth then it has more wealth than the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00253-00065247-00065455": "combined net worth of over thirty point", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00254-00065456-00065725": "six million American families this is", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00255-00065726-00065993": "because the bottom 25% of American", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00256-00065994-00066185": "families have a negative combined net", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00257-00066186-00066544": "worth", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00258-00066545-00066778": "topic complications in interpreting", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00259-00066779-00067209": "income statistics", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00260-00067210-00067449": "interpreting these income statistics is", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00261-00067450-00067626": "complicated by several factors", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00262-00067627-00067879": "membership in the top 1% changes from", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00263-00067880-00068146": "year to year the IRS made large changes", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00264-00068147-00068329": "in the definition of adjusted gross", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00265-00068330-00068578": "income in 1987 and numbers for", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00266-00068579-00068746": "particular income ranges may be", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00267-00068747-00068967": "distorted by outliers in the top segment", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00268-00068968-00069201": "and failure to include transfer payments", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00269-00069202-00069472": "in the lower segments income mobility", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00270-00069473-00069772": "the IRS occasionally studies income data", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00271-00069773-00069997": "from actual households over time usually", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00272-00069998-00070257": "over one decade they actually", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00273-00070258-00070447": "underestimate income mobility by", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00274-00070448-00070597": "excluding the most mobile population", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00275-00070598-00070898": "from their studies those under age 25", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00276-00070899-00071203": "most people only look at annual reported", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00277-00071204-00071422": "income data split into income quintiles", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00278-00071423-00071661": "it is erroneous to assume that", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00279-00071662-00071866": "individual households remain in the same", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00280-00071867-00072091": "quintile over time just as it usually is", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00281-00072092-00072385": "when using aggregate data a majority of", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00282-00072386-00072606": "households in the top income quintile in", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00283-00072607-00072810": "one year for example will have moved to", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00284-00072811-00073084": "a lower quintile within a decade three", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00285-00073085-00073353": "out of four households in the top 0.01%", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00286-00073354-00073603": "of income will no longer be in that", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00287-00073604-00073897": "small group ten years later in summary", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00288-00073898-00074140": "half of all of US households move from", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00289-00074141-00074316": "one income quintile to a different", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00290-00074317-00074607": "income quintile every decade an actual", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00291-00074608-00074805": "households who started a decade in the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00292-00074806-00075000": "lowest quintile of income when tracked", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00293-00075001-00075150": "over the next ten years will have", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00294-00075151-00075357": "proportionally more income growth than", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00295-00075358-00075567": "actual households who started the decade", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00296-00075568-00075819": "in the highest quintile of income thus", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00297-00075820-00076029": "when comparing income wealth quintile", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00298-00076030-00076198": "distributions from different time", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00299-00076199-00076437": "periods generalizations can only be made", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00300-00076438-00076603": "with regards to the households in", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00301-00076604-00076785": "aggregate for each quintile and cannot", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00302-00076786-00076986": "be made to any individual households", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00303-00076987-00077122": "over the same time period", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00304-00077123-00077430": "ie assuming the wealth value has been", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00305-00077431-00077613": "appropriately adjusted for differences", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00306-00077614-00077856": "in time one cannot infer that a decrease", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00307-00077857-00078042": "in total wealth percentage for one", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00308-00078043-00078219": "quintile over time means that the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00309-00078220-00078403": "households from that quintile have lost", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00310-00078404-00078612": "wealth as individuals but only the total", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00311-00078613-00078798": "wealth percentage has decreased for", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00312-00078799-00078960": "those in that quintile at the time of", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00313-00078961-00079332": "measurement top 20% income versus bottom", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00314-00079333-00079609": "20% income households won the average", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00315-00079610-00079806": "number of people with jobs in a top", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00316-00079807-00080025": "income quintile household as two while a", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00317-00080026-00080217": "majority of bottom income quintile", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00318-00080218-00080469": "households have no unemployed - if there", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00319-00080470-00080591": "are two adult income", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00320-00080592-00080788": "in a household who are married their", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00321-00080789-00081062": "incomes are combined on tax forms this", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00322-00081063-00081293": "is very common among top quintile income", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00323-00081294-00081500": "households the lowest quintile", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00324-00081501-00081722": "households however include a lot more", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00325-00081723-00081919": "single person households or two", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00326-00081920-00082103": "unmarried working adults living together", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00327-00082104-00082351": "and sharing expenses but reporting their", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00328-00082352-00082568": "incomes to the IRS as if they were two", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00329-00082569-00082928": "separate households 3 75% to 80% of the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00330-00082929-00083101": "actual income for bottom quintile", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00331-00083102-00083343": "households is transfer payments aka", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00332-00083344-00083668": "welfare that are not included in IRS", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00333-00083669-00083948": "income data the top income quintile gets", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00334-00083949-00084140": "a very small percentage of their actual", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00335-00084141-00084446": "income from transfer payments fourth the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00336-00084447-00084667": "IRS warns against comparisons of", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00337-00084668-00085091": "pre-1982 one 987 income data due to", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00338-00085092-00085298": "significant changes in the definition of", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00339-00085299-00085588": "adjusted gross income AGI that made top", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00340-00085589-00085784": "quintile households appear to have large", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00341-00085785-00086012": "reported income gains when in fact there", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00342-00086013-00086210": "was no change to their income at all in", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00343-00086211-00086476": "addition to the AGI changes large", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00344-00086477-00086690": "marginal tax rate reductions during the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00345-00086691-00086875": "Reagan administration caused another", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00346-00086876-00087175": "large change in tax reporting a lot of", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00347-00087176-00087392": "corporate income formerly reported on", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00348-00087393-00087590": "corporate tax returns was switched to", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00349-00087591-00087844": "lower tax rate individual tax returns as", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00350-00087845-00088168": "subchapter S corporations this reporting", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00351-00088169-00088349": "change appeared to boost top quintile", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00352-00088350-00088543": "income when in fact their incomes had", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00353-00088544-00088847": "not changed as a result the top income", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00354-00088848-00089060": "quintile for households today includes a", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00355-00089061-00089261": "lot of corporate income previously", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00356-00089262-00089474": "reported in corporate tax returns while", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00357-00089475-00089705": "subchapter S corporations who lose money", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00358-00089706-00089893": "are likely to be included in the bottom", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00359-00089894-00090149": "income quintile households income", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00360-00090150-00090503": "comparisons that compare pre-1982 Post 1", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00361-00090504-00090761": "9 8 7 income are very common but they", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00362-00090762-00091006": "are also biased according to the IRS and", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00363-00091007-00091201": "should be ignored impact of age and", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00364-00091202-00091391": "experience people that are older and", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00365-00091392-00091543": "have more experience tend to have", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00366-00091544-00091760": "considerably larger incomes that younger", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00367-00091761-00092044": "and inexperienced workers but all older", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00368-00092045-00092222": "and experienced people were young and", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00369-00092223-00092528": "inexperienced at one point so comparing", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00370-00092529-00092672": "incomes between groups without", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00371-00092673-00092897": "normalizing for age and experience as", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00372-00092898-00093265": "somewhat meaningless", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00373-00093266-00093824": "topic home ownership and race", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00374-00093825-00094028": "home ownership is one of the main", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00375-00094029-00094226": "sources of wealth among families in the", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00376-00094227-00094704": "United States", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00377-00094705-00095376": "statistics family net worth the total", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00378-00095377-00095649": "value of all US household wealth in 2000", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00379-00095650-00095894": "was approximately 44 trillion dollars", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00380-00095895-00096196": "prior to the late 2000s recession which", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00381-00096197-00096498": "began in December 2007 its value was at", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00382-00096499-00096846": "65 point nine trillion dollars after it", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00383-00096847-00097011": "plunged to forty eight point five", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00384-00097012-00097173": "trillion dollars during the first", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00385-00097174-00097521": "quarter of 2009 the total household net", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00386-00097522-00097771": "worth rose 1.3 percent by the fourth", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00387-00097772-00098076": "quarter of 2009 to 54 point two trillion", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00388-00098077-00098298": "dollars indicating the American economy", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00389-00098299-00098744": "is recovering", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00390-00098745-00099207": "topic see also", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00391-00099208-00099725": "topic references", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00392-00099726-00100104": "topic external links", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00393-00100105-00100266": "you", "WlRIGcPMAEY-00394-00100267-00100944": "wealth gap a guide AP News January 2014"}}, {"audio_id": "WlTdWQuqlh4", "text": {"WlTdWQuqlh4-00000-00000280-00000519": "it is now time for oral questions i", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00001-00000520-00000767": "recognize the member for brampton center", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00002-00000768-00001015": "thank you and good morning speaker my", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00003-00001016-00001254": "question is to the premier speaker for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00004-00001255-00001454": "far too many ontarians the cost of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00005-00001455-00001655": "housing is out of control in my", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00006-00001655-00001847": "community of brampton one of the fastest", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00007-00001848-00002047": "growing cities in canada it's so", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00008-00002048-00002207": "important that families have a shot of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00009-00002208-00002471": "buying a home that's in their community", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00010-00002472-00002671": "but that dream is increasingly out of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00011-00002672-00002879": "reach a new report by the mortgage", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00012-00002880-00003031": "professionals of canada shows that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00013-00003032-00003286": "ontario is the most expensive place in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00014-00003288-00003551": "canada they say that house prices here", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00015-00003552-00003767": "are more than 22 times higher than", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00016-00003768-00004031": "ontario's ontarians average disposable", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00017-00004032-00004238": "income which is even more expensive than", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00018-00004239-00004495": "cities like vancouver for example in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00019-00004496-00004743": "peel a two inca minimum wage household", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00020-00004744-00005070": "would need 51 years to save for a down", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00021-00005071-00005295": "payment today we have an affordability", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00022-00005296-00005551": "crisis here in the province why hasn't", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00023-00005552-00005751": "the premier taken action to make the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00024-00005752-00006031": "reality of owning a dream owning a home", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00025-00006032-00006383": "a reality for people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00026-00006384-00006534": "reply on behalf of the government the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00027-00006536-00006687": "government house leader thank you very", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00028-00006688-00006855": "much mr speaker of course we have a plan", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00029-00006856-00006975": "and we're working on that but i tell you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00030-00006976-00007206": "what the plan started back in 2018 when", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00031-00007208-00007446": "the premier said the province is open", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00032-00007447-00007574": "for business he then turned to the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00033-00007575-00007798": "minister of energy and said stabilize", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00034-00007800-00007998": "hydro rates in the province of ontario", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00035-00008000-00008287": "and cancel the plan 19 increase of the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00036-00008288-00008446": "previous liberal government he asked the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00037-00008447-00008663": "minister of indigenous affairs work with", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00038-00008664-00008839": "first nations to open up the ring of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00039-00008840-00009046": "fire and develop a critical mineral", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00040-00009047-00009271": "strategy he did that he then turned to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00041-00009272-00009423": "the minister of red tape production and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00042-00009424-00009583": "said you have to do something about", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00043-00009584-00009839": "job-killing red tape that is driving", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00044-00009840-00009999": "away investment in the province of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00045-00010000-00010214": "ontario and she did that he turned to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00046-00010215-00010359": "the minister of labor and said we need", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00047-00010360-00010599": "more skilled trades people get more in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00048-00010600-00010783": "the province change the college of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00049-00010784-00010999": "trades he did that he asked the minister", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00050-00011000-00011063": "of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00051-00011064-00011246": "colleges and university improve", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00052-00011247-00011478": "education so that the jobs of tomorrow", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00053-00011479-00011655": "the people who are in our universities", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00054-00011656-00011870": "can be trained for the jobs of tomorrow", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00055-00011871-00012038": "she has done that he then turned to the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00056-00012039-00012278": "minister of job creation and said", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00057-00012279-00012503": "negotiate a deal and he did that the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00058-00012504-00012727": "biggest deal in provinces history", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00059-00012728-00012910": "announced yesterday", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00060-00012911-00013127": "giving thousands of people the dignity", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00061-00013128-00013286": "of a job and access to morehousing", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00062-00013287-00013415": "because they can thank you thank you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00063-00013416-00013799": "very much", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00064-00013800-00014007": "speaker well what the government house", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00065-00014008-00014158": "leader fails to recognize is that you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00066-00014159-00014375": "need to have a home in order to turn the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00067-00014376-00014607": "hydro on and for most people working", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00068-00014608-00014830": "minimum wage jobs they simply cannot", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00069-00014831-00015086": "afford to call a place home the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00070-00015087-00015303": "affordability crisis is only getting", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00071-00015304-00015566": "worse under this premier tim huda with", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00072-00015568-00015758": "the ontario real estate association", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00073-00015759-00016022": "wrote last week that even as ontarians", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00074-00016023-00016271": "dream of owning a home and i'll quote", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00075-00016272-00016503": "ontario's looming housing affordability", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00076-00016504-00016767": "crisis is clouding that dream end quote", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00077-00016768-00017015": "mr hudak says the problem is really one", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00078-00017016-00017230": "of affordability and it's getting harder", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00079-00017231-00017447": "and harder for people in this province", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00080-00017448-00017727": "to own a home families like those in my", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00081-00017728-00017927": "city of brampton need a government that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00082-00017928-00018111": "will actually help build homes people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00083-00018112-00018350": "can afford as well as taking on greedy", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00084-00018351-00018630": "speculators that help push the prices up", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00085-00018631-00018886": "for working people speaker why isn't", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00086-00018887-00019055": "this government listening to working", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00087-00019056-00019271": "ontarians who want to have a roof over", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00088-00019272-00019447": "their head instead of letting this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00089-00019448-00019686": "affordability crisis continue to get", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00090-00019687-00020158": "worse day by day", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00091-00020159-00020279": "you know the first thing that people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00092-00020280-00020439": "need in order to buy a home mr speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00093-00020440-00020567": "they need a job", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00094-00020568-00020743": "they need the dignity of a job mr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00095-00020744-00020911": "speaker and yesterday the minister of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00096-00020912-00021078": "economic development job creation and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00097-00021079-00021375": "trade devel delivered the largest", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00098-00021376-00021655": "investment in canadian history for the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00099-00021656-00021919": "jobs of tomorrow mr speaker now this is", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00100-00021920-00022111": "a member college this is a member from", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00101-00022112-00022350": "brampton a member from brampton and what", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00102-00022351-00022558": "the minister yesterday delivered not", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00103-00022559-00022711": "only for the people of windsor but for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00104-00022712-00022871": "the people of brampton for the people of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00105-00022872-00023103": "all ontario it's something that we will", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00106-00023104-00023286": "see jobs and economic growth and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00107-00023287-00023630": "prosperity for decades to come mr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00108-00023631-00023863": "speaker thousands of people will have a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00109-00023864-00024039": "job they'll be able to buy their first", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00110-00024040-00024199": "home because of the work that this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00111-00024200-00024463": "government has been doing since 2018.", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00112-00024464-00024614": "when it comes to affordability the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00113-00024615-00024799": "minister of finance has been working on", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00114-00024800-00025078": "that from day one we cut taxes mr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00115-00025079-00025294": "speaker we made an environment where", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00116-00025295-00025486": "people want to finally invest in the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00117-00025487-00025694": "province of ontario that's not what the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00118-00025695-00026039": "coalition did between 2011 and 2018 but", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00119-00026039-00026239": "a strong stable progressive conservative", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00120-00026239-00026414": "majority government delivers and will", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00121-00026416-00026783": "continue to deliver after june the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00122-00026783-00026967": "final supplementary", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00123-00026968-00027158": "speaker deflecting from the reality of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00124-00027160-00027335": "the housing crisis isn't going to solve", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00125-00027336-00027543": "the problem and just in case the uh", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00126-00027544-00027687": "government house leader didn't hear me", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00127-00027688-00027943": "the first time in peel a two inca", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00128-00027944-00028199": "minimum wage household would need 51", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00129-00028200-00028367": "years to be able to save for a down", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00130-00028368-00028670": "payment speaker hardworking ontarians", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00131-00028672-00028902": "want to be on solid ground with a roof", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00132-00028904-00029111": "over their head so that they can build", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00133-00029112-00029343": "their best life but when we see prices", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00134-00029344-00029535": "skyrocket like what happened last week", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00135-00029536-00029814": "with the new benchmark of over 1.8", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00136-00029816-00030039": "million dollars just to build a new home", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00137-00030039-00030255": "in the gta is going to be really", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00138-00030256-00030446": "difficult for people to do that people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00139-00030447-00030631": "need to live affordably near their", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00140-00030632-00030807": "families their friends and in their", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00141-00030808-00031079": "communities and for some the raising", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00142-00031080-00031302": "concerns that without major changes to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00143-00031303-00031527": "make housing more affordable ontario", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00144-00031527-00031727": "will have trouble actually attracting", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00145-00031727-00031974": "workers to our province so speaker it", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00146-00031975-00032167": "shouldn't be this way homes people can't", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00147-00032168-00032351": "afford should be a priority of this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00148-00032352-00032439": "government", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00149-00032439-00032702": "not their developer friends and insiders", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00150-00032703-00032879": "where is the political will from this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00151-00032880-00033135": "government to fix the housing crisis in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00152-00033136-00033574": "ontario", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00153-00033575-00033727": "i'm going to suggest to you mr speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00154-00033728-00033879": "that the thousands of people who found", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00155-00033880-00034046": "out yesterday that they will have a job", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00156-00034047-00034246": "for generations and years to come thanks", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00157-00034247-00034399": "to the minister of economic development", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00158-00034400-00034590": "job creation and trade those are the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00159-00034591-00034783": "insiders that we are listening to mr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00160-00034784-00034990": "speaker the insiders who working on the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00161-00034991-00035167": "lines and allison who are building the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00162-00035168-00035415": "cars of tomorrow at honda those are the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00163-00035416-00035551": "insiders that we're listening to the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00164-00035552-00035743": "insiders who are working at ford mr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00165-00035744-00035951": "speaker those are the insiders that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00166-00035952-00036135": "we're listening to under the policies of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00167-00036136-00036287": "the coalition between the liberals and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00168-00036288-00036599": "ndp gm closed its facility under the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00169-00036600-00036807": "policies of this government reducing", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00170-00036808-00037087": "costs mr speaker making this an economy", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00171-00037088-00037287": "in a province that you want to invest in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00172-00037288-00037471": "they reopened and are now building the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00173-00037472-00037743": "cars of tomorrow those are the insiders", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00174-00037744-00037902": "that we're listening to mr speaker we've", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00175-00037903-00038174": "created thousands of jobs mr speaker we", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00176-00038175-00038343": "are doing even more to ensure that this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00177-00038344-00038535": "is the best province to live work invest", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00178-00038536-00038727": "and raise a family mr speaker and it's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00179-00038728-00038902": "because of the work that this government", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00180-00038903-00039190": "has been doing since 2018 under a strong", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00181-00039191-00039390": "stable progressive conservative majority", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00182-00039391-00039535": "government and that's what we will", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00183-00039536-00039743": "continue to deliver now and after june", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00184-00039744-00039887": "the second", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00185-00039888-00040287": "the next question", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00186-00040288-00040439": "thank you speaker my next question is", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00187-00040440-00040630": "also to the premier people who are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00188-00040631-00040862": "buying a home or a condo need assurances", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00189-00040863-00041046": "that the deals they sign will actually", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00190-00041047-00041295": "be fair but as we saw last year some", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00191-00041296-00041535": "greedy developers demanded huge payments", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00192-00041536-00041679": "just to complete the construction of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00193-00041680-00041990": "homes people already had contracts for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00194-00041991-00042183": "there should have been rules against", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00195-00042184-00042335": "this and there should have been", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00196-00042336-00042495": "penalties levied against those", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00197-00042496-00042718": "developers so can the premier tell us", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00198-00042719-00042918": "how many of those developers actually", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00199-00042919-00043143": "received a fine for trying to gouge", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00200-00043144-00043374": "honest people for hundreds of thousands", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00201-00043375-00043607": "of dollars for homes they'd already paid", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00202-00043608-00043943": "for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00203-00043944-00044215": "minister government consumer services", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00204-00044216-00044415": "well thank you to the member for the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00205-00044416-00044543": "question thank you speaker for the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00206-00044544-00044790": "opportunity to respond and on this side", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00207-00044791-00045030": "of the house mr speaker we are committed", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00208-00045031-00045230": "to protecting the little guy we've said", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00209-00045231-00045511": "it before and the premier said very very", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00210-00045512-00045711": "clearly that nothing burns him up more", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00211-00045712-00045871": "than when a developer tries to make", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00212-00045872-00046007": "extra money off the backs of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00213-00046008-00046239": "hard-working people and we are ensuring", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00214-00046240-00046367": "that we are going to stop those types of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00215-00046368-00046590": "practices mr speaker that is why we are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00216-00046591-00046902": "doubling fines for any persons who", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00217-00046903-00047095": "commit these types of infractions we are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00218-00047096-00047351": "going to ensure that if a developer is", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00219-00047352-00047535": "found to be breaking these types of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00220-00047536-00047695": "rules to be taking these types of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00221-00047696-00047967": "unethical practices with hard-working", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00222-00047968-00048127": "ontarians who are trying to just buy", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00223-00048128-00048286": "their first home or any other home for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00224-00048287-00048455": "that matter we're gonna", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00225-00048456-00048630": "make sure that not only are those fines", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00226-00048631-00048830": "being doubled but they can lose their", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00227-00048831-00049118": "license to build for two years mr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00228-00049119-00049351": "speaker we are taking these types of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00229-00049352-00049527": "initiatives mr speaker to ensure that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00230-00049528-00049655": "we're protecting the little guy to make", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00231-00049656-00049790": "sure that we're looking at their past", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00232-00049791-00049935": "behavior something that didn't happen in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00233-00049936-00050118": "the past to ensure that they don't lose", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00234-00050119-00050302": "money on those deposits and to make sure", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00235-00050303-00050455": "that they can get the reality of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00236-00050456-00050639": "affordable home ownership here in this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00237-00050640-00051086": "province thank you mr speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00238-00051087-00051311": "speaker we've seen this rhetoric before", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00239-00051312-00051479": "from this government and the problem", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00240-00051479-00051614": "with them is actually on the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00241-00051615-00051814": "follow-through the premier railed", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00242-00051815-00051966": "against people getting gouged in the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00243-00051967-00052182": "pandemic by greedy developers but", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00244-00052183-00052463": "according to the cbc not a single charge", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00245-00052464-00052703": "was ever actually laid", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00246-00052704-00052887": "homeowners who signed contracts to buy a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00247-00052888-00053063": "new condo shouldn't be stuck with even", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00248-00053064-00053359": "bigger bills for already pricey homes", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00249-00053360-00053566": "speaker there are already fines in place", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00250-00053567-00053759": "with the home construction regulatory", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00251-00053760-00053942": "authority how many of those fines have", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00252-00053944-00054228": "actually been levied to date", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00253-00054229-00054679": "[Applause]", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00254-00054679-00054879": "thank you again mr speaker and to the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00255-00054879-00055103": "member opposite just imagine mr speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00256-00055104-00055279": "for a moment you're a developer out", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00257-00055279-00055399": "there and you're thinking about", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00258-00055400-00055638": "canceling someone's condo project", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00259-00055639-00055782": "you now have to look in the mirror and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00260-00055783-00055950": "really ask yourself do i want to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00261-00055951-00056238": "compromise or risk a two-year suspension", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00262-00056239-00056487": "of my license to build do i want to risk", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00263-00056488-00056823": "a doubling of the fines if i'm found to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00264-00056824-00056975": "be doing something inappropriate in this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00265-00056976-00057223": "fashion do i want to carry those risks", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00266-00057224-00057430": "mr speaker absolutely not we are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00267-00057432-00057782": "ensuring that we are creating the tools", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00268-00057783-00057894": "for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00269-00057895-00058094": "agencies like hcra", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00270-00058095-00058430": "to ensure that they are able to monitor", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00271-00058432-00058630": "the actions of our builders out there to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00272-00058632-00058903": "ensure that there are teeth to the to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00273-00058904-00059150": "the regulations that are going to uh", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00274-00059151-00059303": "give people the reality of home", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00275-00059304-00059566": "ownership yet again we are protecting", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00276-00059567-00059775": "our condo buyers uh mr speaker that is", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00277-00059776-00059959": "what we're doing we're protecting and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00278-00059960-00060166": "supporting affordable housing and we're", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00279-00060167-00060399": "ensuring we're ensuring mr speaker that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00280-00060400-00060559": "developers are going to think twice", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00281-00060560-00060694": "before they try to take advantage of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00282-00060695-00061238": "hard-working ontarians again", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00283-00061239-00061399": "thank you speaker i i didn't hear an", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00284-00061400-00061575": "answer from the minister of uh", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00285-00061576-00061750": "government and consumer services so i'm", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00286-00061751-00061894": "happy to fill them in that there were", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00287-00061895-00062199": "actually 600 complaints filed last year", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00288-00062200-00062471": "that's 600 ontarians who needed this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00289-00062472-00062711": "government to take urgent action and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00290-00062712-00062926": "they didn't but the homes uh home", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00291-00062927-00063126": "construction regulatory authority lists", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00292-00063127-00063447": "only two companies two out of 600 that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00293-00063448-00063679": "were charged in the last year the cost", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00294-00063679-00063903": "of housing is out of control and the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00295-00063904-00064166": "lack of action from this government", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00296-00064167-00064519": "is helping those prices skyrocket when", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00297-00064520-00064750": "people sign a contract in ontario they", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00298-00064751-00064959": "should get what they paid for and the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00299-00064960-00065126": "government should have their backs to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00300-00065127-00065350": "ensure that bad actors aren't taking", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00301-00065351-00065623": "advantage of homeowners when will this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00302-00065624-00065847": "government hold those actors accountable", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00303-00065848-00066047": "and help the ontarians who've lost", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00304-00066048-00066303": "hundreds of thousands of dollars and the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00305-00066304-00066975": "possibility of owning their dream home", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00306-00066976-00067199": "well mr speaker the answer is now the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00307-00067200-00067519": "answer is absolutely now mr speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00308-00067520-00067719": "we are ensuring that the tools are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00309-00067720-00067935": "present to protect our homeowners", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00310-00067936-00068087": "imagine this you used to be in a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00311-00068088-00068247": "position under the former government of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00312-00068248-00068511": "course supported by the ndp 97 or 99 of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00313-00068512-00068679": "the time depending on what day we'll", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00314-00068680-00068894": "call it 100 i suppose the the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00315-00068895-00069143": "the fact is the fact is mr speaker that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00316-00069144-00069319": "you could put a deposit down and there", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00317-00069320-00069526": "was actually a negative interest rate", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00318-00069527-00069679": "you could actually see yourself lose", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00319-00069680-00069903": "money on your deposit if your condo was", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00320-00069904-00070135": "cancelled not only that but you had to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00321-00070136-00070471": "make a formal complaint in order to have", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00322-00070472-00070631": "something launched where something could", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00323-00070632-00070759": "be investigated now it's going to be", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00324-00070760-00071055": "automatic mr speaker automatic launching", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00325-00071056-00071294": "of investigations anytime a condo", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00326-00071295-00071519": "project is cancelled and for the first", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00327-00071520-00071823": "time ever we are also considering", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00328-00071824-00072087": "bad behavior of the past when these", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00329-00072088-00072255": "types of infractions occur we're now", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00330-00072256-00072399": "going to look at that to evaluate", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00331-00072400-00072559": "whether a person should face a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00332-00072560-00072750": "punishment of up to a two-year license", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00333-00072751-00073062": "suspension or should see a fine that it", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00334-00073063-00073231": "could be doubled up to 50 and in some", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00335-00073232-00073399": "cases a hundred thousand dollars mr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00336-00073400-00073567": "speaker these are going to ensure that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00337-00073568-00073775": "we're protecting condo buyers from these", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00338-00073776-00074006": "unethical practices because as our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00339-00074007-00074199": "premier said we're always going to stand", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00340-00074200-00074359": "up for the little guy mr speaker and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00341-00074360-00074503": "we're going to ensure that people have", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00342-00074504-00074679": "the opportunity", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00343-00074680-00074862": "to purchase their first home next", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00344-00074863-00074915": "question", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00345-00074916-00075279": "[Applause]", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00346-00075280-00075431": "thank you speaker my question is to the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00347-00075432-00075759": "premier almost one year ago the premier", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00348-00075760-00075950": "and minister of tourism held a press", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00349-00075951-00076135": "conference to announce the ontario", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00350-00076136-00076438": "tourism recovery program they promised a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00351-00076439-00076599": "hundred million in support for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00352-00076600-00076815": "struggling tourism operators that were", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00353-00076816-00077111": "hit first that were hit hardest by the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00354-00077112-00077335": "pandemic the minister said the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00355-00077336-00077606": "applicants should expect an eight-week", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00356-00077607-00077926": "review process after the applications", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00357-00077927-00078047": "closed", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00358-00078048-00078191": "back in november", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00359-00078192-00078503": "it has now been close to 25", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00360-00078504-00078823": "weeks and not one single dollar of the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00361-00078824-00079006": "hundred million has made it to the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00362-00079007-00079287": "tourism sector we are almost in april", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00363-00079288-00079462": "and many businesses are struggling to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00364-00079463-00079711": "find money to prepare for the upcoming", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00365-00079712-00079831": "summer", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00366-00079832-00080038": "can the premier tell the businesses", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00367-00080039-00080238": "when the ontario tourism recovery", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00368-00080239-00080991": "program funding will be released", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00369-00080992-00081159": "thank you mr speaker i think the member", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00370-00081160-00081375": "is talking about the program that he and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00371-00081376-00081543": "his colleagues voted against if i'm not", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00372-00081544-00081711": "mistaken is that is that the one that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00373-00081712-00081831": "you're talking about mr speaker i'll", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00374-00081832-00082071": "tell you what the minister of uh of uh", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00375-00082072-00082247": "tourism and culture has been working", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00376-00082248-00082479": "since the start of the pandemic really", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00377-00082480-00082662": "to try to highlight how important it was", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00378-00082663-00082926": "that the recovery post pandemic was", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00379-00082927-00083094": "quick and swift we know that those are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00380-00083095-00083255": "sectors that were hit the hardest and it", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00381-00083256-00083494": "will take the longest to recover from mr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00382-00083495-00083718": "speaker and it's not just about", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00383-00083719-00083926": "people's enjoyment of facilities mr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00384-00083927-00084087": "speaker it's about the people that work", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00385-00084088-00084318": "in them think about the amount of jobs", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00386-00084319-00084518": "that culture brings to the province of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00387-00084519-00084671": "ontario the thousands of people in the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00388-00084672-00084855": "billions of dollars of economic activity", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00389-00084856-00085038": "that's why we put supports in place for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00390-00085039-00085223": "them it's not just the actors it's the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00391-00085224-00085423": "people behind the scenes the hair", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00392-00085424-00085591": "stylists who work in the in the theater", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00393-00085592-00085799": "the plumbers the electricians all of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00394-00085800-00086023": "those people in small towns across uh", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00395-00086024-00086206": "across this uh this country in my own", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00396-00086207-00086359": "hometown of stouffville", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00397-00086360-00086543": "the strawberry festival that's an", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00398-00086544-00086767": "enormous potential for economic activity", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00399-00086768-00086967": "and that's why we put supports in place", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00400-00086968-00087103": "for all of these communities so that the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00401-00087104-00087311": "recovery could be quick and fast it's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00402-00087312-00087503": "unfortunate you voted against it mr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00403-00087504-00087847": "speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00404-00087848-00087999": "speaker it's disappointing because", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00405-00088000-00088223": "quickest quick and fast is not something", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00406-00088224-00088375": "it is which is in this government's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00407-00088376-00088647": "vocabulary bruce o'hare president of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00408-00088648-00088887": "lakeshore excursion applied for funding", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00409-00088888-00089167": "in october he has reached out to the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00410-00089168-00089438": "ministry multiple times for answers on", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00411-00089439-00089806": "his application status so far zero zilch", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00412-00089807-00090055": "nothing not even an acknowledgement same", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00413-00090056-00090255": "with kathy campbell owner of ownaway", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00414-00090256-00090447": "lodge in laksan", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00415-00090448-00090687": "who is preparing for the opening of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00416-00090688-00090943": "fishing season in just nine weeks", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00417-00090944-00091215": "she has no idea if supports will come", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00418-00091216-00091518": "her way or even make it possible", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00419-00091519-00091694": "it is critical to give businesses an", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00420-00091695-00091918": "answer on whether they will receive the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00421-00091919-00092223": "funds they've applied for months ago", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00422-00092224-00092438": "they need to plan speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00423-00092439-00092591": "some operators are worried that they", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00424-00092592-00092831": "will have to close their doors", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00425-00092832-00093094": "before they can even get an answer from", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00426-00093095-00093391": "this government i ask again", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00427-00093392-00093559": "will the premier", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00428-00093560-00093774": "when will these funds reach these", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00429-00093775-00094015": "businesses when will they reach these", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00430-00094016-00094287": "businesses and will it be in time for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00431-00094288-00094615": "the opening of this summer", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00432-00094616-00095087": "[Applause]", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00433-00095088-00095303": "it's really funny to me honestly mr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00434-00095304-00095543": "speaker it's funny to me that the ndp", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00435-00095544-00095750": "asked questions they asked questions", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00436-00095751-00096038": "about programs that they voted against", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00437-00096039-00096255": "that they did not support mr speaker if", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00438-00096256-00096462": "it was up to the members opposite none", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00439-00096463-00096615": "of these programs would have even", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00440-00096616-00096774": "existed they voted against the small", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00441-00096775-00096918": "business supports", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00442-00096919-00097103": "100 of them voted against that mr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00443-00097104-00097287": "speaker they voted against the tourism", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00444-00097288-00097518": "supports 100 of them voted against that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00445-00097519-00097703": "they voted against the broadband that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00446-00097704-00097879": "we're bringing to communities across the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00447-00097880-00098087": "province of ontario including in his", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00448-00098088-00098303": "riding where we heard tourism operators", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00449-00098304-00098503": "say that without broadband their", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00450-00098504-00098679": "businesses would be hurt how did they", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00451-00098680-00098918": "vote they voted against it mr speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00452-00098919-00099087": "they voted against the roads that the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00453-00099088-00099255": "minister of transportation is building", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00454-00099256-00099406": "into their communities so that people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00455-00099407-00099655": "can actually get to their uh their", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00456-00099656-00099967": "tourism facilities mr speaker on every", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00457-00099968-00100191": "single matter that would help smaller", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00458-00100192-00100350": "communities that would help tourism and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00459-00100351-00100550": "culture across the province of ontario", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00460-00100551-00100759": "they vote against it", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00461-00100760-00100903": "but then they come and ask questions", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00462-00100904-00101062": "about well how can we make it better", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00463-00101063-00101238": "well the way you can make it better is", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00464-00101239-00101391": "vote in favor of the measures that are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00465-00101392-00102918": "helping thousands of people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00466-00102919-00103142": "okay restart the clock next question the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00467-00103143-00103318": "member for sarnia lampton thank you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00468-00103319-00103590": "speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00469-00103591-00103790": "thank you speaker my question this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00470-00103791-00104006": "morning is to the minister of economic", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00471-00104007-00104239": "development job creation and trade", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00472-00104240-00104534": "yesterday stalantis and lg energy", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00473-00104535-00104775": "solution announced their future bathroom", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00474-00104776-00105015": "factory in windsor a massive investment", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00475-00105016-00105190": "for the community and for the electric", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00476-00105191-00105407": "vehicle industry this is great news for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00477-00105408-00105631": "ontario's automotive sector and the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00478-00105632-00105863": "local community at large i'm sure my", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00479-00105864-00106063": "constituents as well as all of ontario", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00480-00106064-00106295": "are curious to know more so through you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00481-00106296-00106543": "speaker can the minister tell us what", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00482-00106544-00106710": "this investment means for the future of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00483-00106711-00106966": "ontario's automotive and manufacturing", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00484-00106967-00107575": "sector", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00485-00107576-00107743": "thank you speaker and thank you very", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00486-00107744-00108023": "much to the member for the question yes", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00487-00108024-00108334": "speaker as you've heard several times in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00488-00108335-00108558": "this legislature this morning", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00489-00108559-00108951": "lg energy solution and stalantis have", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00490-00108952-00109334": "made a 5 billion dollar investment in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00491-00109335-00109895": "the province of ontario", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00492-00109896-00110223": "this is historic you'll hear many words", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00493-00110224-00110471": "used to describe it but it is", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00494-00110472-00110631": "the single", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00495-00110632-00110847": "largest investment", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00496-00110848-00111231": "in the auto sector in ontario's history", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00497-00111232-00111743": "speaker this is historic", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00498-00111744-00112110": "think about the two year construction", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00499-00112111-00112383": "program the thousands", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00500-00112383-00112486": "of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00501-00112488-00112743": "good paying jobs that will be required", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00502-00112744-00113110": "to build that facility response four and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00503-00113111-00113215": "a half", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00504-00113216-00113447": "million square feet the size of a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00505-00113448-00113795": "hundred and twelve hockey arenas", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00506-00113796-00115854": "2500 new jobs when the plant opens", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00507-00115855-00116071": "restart the fact supplementary well", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00508-00116072-00116310": "thank you speaker and thank you minister", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00509-00116311-00116447": "for that great answer", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00510-00116448-00116654": "this investment will be truly impactful", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00511-00116655-00116854": "for the local economy and for the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00512-00116855-00117095": "broader automotive supply chain", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00513-00117096-00117271": "under the previous liberal government", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00514-00117272-00117510": "supported by the ndp automotive and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00515-00117511-00117766": "manufacturing jobs fled this promise", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00516-00117767-00117958": "it's great to hear that our government", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00517-00117959-00118175": "is taking action to reverse the damage", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00518-00118176-00118423": "they did to our economy for over 15", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00519-00118424-00118631": "years can the minister please tell us", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00520-00118632-00118854": "how this investment will support ontario", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00521-00118855-00119295": "jobs and families for many years to come", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00522-00119296-00119478": "development", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00523-00119479-00119790": "thank you speaker so this 5 billion", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00524-00119791-00120031": "investment is to produce electric", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00525-00120032-00120302": "vehicle batteries for the electric", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00526-00120303-00120558": "vehicles of the future that are being", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00527-00120559-00120847": "built here in the province of ontario", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00528-00120848-00121143": "this investment positions ontario to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00529-00121144-00121558": "lead north america in the ev revolution", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00530-00121559-00121790": "and this investment speaker is the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00531-00121791-00122110": "culmination of our government's work to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00532-00122111-00122334": "restore the manufacturing might of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00533-00122335-00122583": "ontario it began with", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00534-00122583-00122775": "lowering the cost of doing business by", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00535-00122776-00123166": "seven billion dollars reducing wsib", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00536-00123167-00123399": "costs without reducing the premiums by", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00537-00123400-00123631": "two and a half billion dollars putting", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00538-00123632-00123854": "in an accelerated capital cost so", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00539-00123855-00124039": "businesses could write their expenses", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00540-00124040-00124343": "off in-year saving a billion dollars", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00541-00124344-00124807": "we put in clean competitive energy top", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00542-00124808-00125102": "quality manufacturing talent", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00543-00125103-00125478": "access to investment ready sites speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00544-00125479-00125790": "all this will provide a place for two", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00545-00125791-00126063": "thousand five hundred men and women to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00546-00126064-00126366": "wake up every day and go to a good", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00547-00126367-00128366": "paying job", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00548-00128367-00128519": "please restart the clock the next", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00549-00128520-00128695": "question the member for hamilton mom uh", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00550-00128696-00128863": "thank you speaker my question is for the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00551-00128864-00129134": "premiere for-profit long-term care homes", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00552-00129135-00129343": "had nearly twice as many residents", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00553-00129344-00129702": "infected with covet 19 and 78", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00554-00129703-00129975": "more deaths than not-for-profit homes", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00555-00129976-00130147": "for-profit homes have a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00556-00130148-00130390": "disproportionately higher covet 19", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00557-00130391-00130623": "mortality rate because of facility", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00558-00130624-00130847": "overcrowding and critical staffing", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00559-00130848-00131095": "shortages yet this government continues", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00560-00131096-00131351": "to award contracts to build new", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00561-00131352-00131702": "long-term care beds to private operators", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00562-00131703-00131966": "of 220 planned long-term care", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00563-00131967-00132239": "development projects over half are for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00564-00132240-00132359": "profit", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00565-00132360-00132702": "in for-profit homes long-term care is", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00566-00132703-00133047": "treated not only as a business but as a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00567-00133048-00133327": "real estate investment for shareholders", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00568-00133328-00133607": "and this is unacceptable speaker how", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00569-00133608-00133839": "would this government protect residents", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00570-00133840-00134111": "and prevent outbreaks in for-profit", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00571-00134112-00134351": "long-term care homes as coven 19", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00572-00134352-00134607": "restrictions left and will they start to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00573-00134608-00134902": "prioritize the care of seniors over", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00574-00134903-00134969": "profit", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00575-00134970-00135175": "[Music]", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00576-00135176-00135447": "to reply the minister of long-term care", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00577-00135448-00135590": "let me uh let me highlight the ways", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00578-00135591-00135671": "we're going to do we're going to do it", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00579-00135672-00135999": "by hiring 27 000 additional psws and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00580-00136000-00136327": "nurses and allied health effects", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00581-00136328-00136502": "she voted against it we're going to do", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00582-00136503-00136711": "it by building 30 000 new spaces which", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00583-00136712-00136895": "she's now telling the house that she is", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00584-00136896-00137159": "not in favor of mr speaker too bad i", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00585-00137160-00137327": "suggest they're important we're going to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00586-00137328-00137519": "do it by providing 380 million for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00587-00137520-00137711": "prevention and containment measures mr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00588-00137712-00137807": "speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00589-00137808-00137983": "voted against it we're going to do it by", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00590-00137984-00138190": "providing ipac infection prevention and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00591-00138191-00138535": "control now the coalition that existed", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00592-00138536-00138678": "should have learned", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00593-00138679-00138863": "from the sars epidemic but they did it", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00594-00138864-00139151": "mr speaker that is a failure of the ndp", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00595-00139152-00139335": "and liberal coalition time", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00596-00139336-00139487": "we learned from that mistake and we're", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00597-00139488-00139631": "making sure that infection prevention", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00598-00139632-00139878": "and control funding is in place", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00599-00139879-00140119": "and you know what mr speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00600-00140120-00140366": "they voted against it so on every", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00601-00140367-00140527": "measure that we have put in place to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00602-00140528-00140814": "improve long-term care in this province", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00603-00140815-00140935": "guess who has voted against their", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00604-00140936-00141054": "colleagues", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00605-00141055-00141319": "the ndp and the liberals both separately", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00606-00141320-00141743": "and together in coalition", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00607-00141744-00141983": "speaker properly funding", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00608-00141984-00142214": "not-for-profit long-term care is just", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00609-00142215-00142495": "one piece of this puzzle we also need to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00610-00142496-00142799": "invest in publicly funded home care to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00611-00142800-00143071": "help seniors stay independent", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00612-00143072-00143223": "because of the lack of home care", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00613-00143224-00143471": "supports more pressures are being placed", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00614-00143472-00143783": "on unpaid caregivers to support seniors", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00615-00143784-00143951": "with health challenges", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00616-00143952-00144263": "one in three unpaid caregivers report", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00617-00144264-00144590": "profound mental financial and physical", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00618-00144591-00144863": "impacts speaker this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00619-00144864-00145175": "is completely unacceptable higher rates", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00620-00145176-00145454": "of caregiver distress signal the real", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00621-00145455-00145702": "need for more effective home care", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00622-00145703-00145966": "services and community supports we need", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00623-00145967-00146214": "to make these investments to reduce the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00624-00146215-00146414": "stress of caregivers and help them", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00625-00146415-00146695": "provide proper care for those they care", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00626-00146696-00146926": "for who wish to stay at home can the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00627-00146927-00147175": "premier tell us what his government is", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00628-00147176-00147439": "doing to increase home care options for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00629-00147440-00147631": "seniors and supports for their", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00630-00147632-00147753": "caregivers", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00631-00147754-00148119": "[Applause]", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00632-00148120-00148295": "very much speaker and yes i'd be happy", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00633-00148296-00148431": "to tell you about the supports that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00634-00148432-00148639": "we've been putting into place to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00635-00148640-00148814": "increase home care supports for seniors", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00636-00148815-00148951": "and other people needing home care", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00637-00148952-00149166": "services because we had heard from", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00638-00149167-00149375": "people that this system was broken it", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00639-00149376-00149575": "was antiquated it hadn't been", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00640-00149576-00149863": "reviewed since the 1990s and that's why", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00641-00149864-00150135": "we have taken action to modernize home", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00642-00150136-00150319": "care and community care with ontario", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00643-00150320-00150526": "health teams poised to take on its", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00644-00150527-00150823": "delivery over the next coming years", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00645-00150824-00151087": "we also passed the connecting people to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00646-00151088-00151319": "home and community care act or bill 175", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00647-00151320-00151551": "which i believe you also voted against", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00648-00151552-00151831": "which was passed in 2020 and it lays the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00649-00151832-00152119": "groundwork for an integrated responsive", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00650-00152120-00152399": "and innovative home and community care", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00651-00152400-00152590": "but it's not just that we've put money", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00652-00152591-00152783": "into it as well we are investing an", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00653-00152784-00152907": "additional", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00654-00152908-00153254": "548 and a half million dollars into", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00655-00153255-00153414": "three years for the home and community", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00656-00153415-00153702": "sector and uh there's more to do with", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00657-00153703-00153919": "respect to what we're doing with the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00658-00153920-00154239": "human health care workers as well", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00659-00154240-00154383": "the next question the member for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00660-00154384-00154566": "cambridge speaker good morning two weeks", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00661-00154567-00154759": "ago the minister of municipal affairs", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00662-00154760-00154895": "informed me that i likely didn't know", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00663-00154896-00155047": "how this place worked when i asked", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00664-00155048-00155159": "whether the government was moving", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00665-00155160-00155375": "forward with a special executive order", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00666-00155376-00155535": "they granted for accelerated", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00667-00155536-00155702": "construction of a mega facility in my", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00668-00155703-00155959": "riding rumored to be for amazon of note", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00669-00155960-00156143": "speaker amazon hired the lobbying firm", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00670-00156144-00156295": "owned by the campaign manager of the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00671-00156296-00156454": "governing party a month before the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00672-00156455-00156647": "minister's order was issued speaker i", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00673-00156648-00156743": "must admit i didn't follow the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00674-00156744-00156943": "minister's advice i didn't engage in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00675-00156944-00157078": "background negotiations with city", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00676-00157079-00157183": "council and i didn't follow the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00677-00157184-00157366": "minister's actions and whine and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00678-00157367-00157511": "complain and file a legal complaint", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00679-00157512-00157702": "against advocates in my writing who have", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00680-00157703-00157887": "an opinion instead i went straight to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00681-00157888-00158054": "the people of cambridge and apparently", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00682-00158055-00158287": "speaker that works around here too now", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00683-00158288-00158439": "that council has voted against the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00684-00158440-00158639": "proposed project the minister approved", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00685-00158640-00158766": "is the minister going to pull the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00686-00158767-00158951": "special order as he previously promised", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00687-00158952-00159111": "or is he going to break his own rules", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00688-00159112-00159223": "and proceed with accelerated", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00689-00159224-00159678": "construction of the facility for amazon", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00690-00159679-00159839": "and to reply on behalf of the government", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00691-00159840-00159983": "member for storm on dundas south", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00692-00159984-00160183": "glenbury", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00693-00160184-00160311": "thank you speaker and i want to thank", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00694-00160312-00160590": "the member opted for the question um our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00695-00160591-00160839": "government has been very pro jobs and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00696-00160840-00161390": "we've been working on mzo's to to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00697-00161391-00161631": "greater results with new employment new", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00698-00161632-00161935": "housing now in the case of cambridge", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00699-00161936-00162007": "we", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00700-00162008-00162319": "we issued the mzo as a as a response to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00701-00162320-00162559": "the request from the council now council", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00702-00162560-00162775": "has not followed through on some of the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00703-00162776-00162935": "requirements that they have", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00704-00162936-00163071": "um", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00705-00163072-00163254": "their condition of the mzo now we've", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00706-00163255-00163414": "been in minister clark has been in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00707-00163415-00163663": "conversation with the council and the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00708-00163664-00163935": "mayor of cambridge and is reviewing a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00709-00163936-00164159": "letter that he received yesterday", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00710-00164160-00164438": "but we reiterate that conditions must be", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00711-00164439-00164631": "followed if they aren't then we will", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00712-00164632-00164871": "have to revoke the msido and this is a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00713-00164872-00165126": "decision of local council", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00714-00165127-00165351": "they are the heartbeat of the the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00715-00165352-00165551": "community and we're waiting and i'm", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00716-00165552-00165919": "willing to work with them here", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00717-00165920-00166095": "supplementary questions thank you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00718-00166096-00166254": "speaker i have what i need so no further", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00719-00166255-00166431": "questions", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00720-00166432-00166638": "thank you the next question", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00721-00166639-00166854": "member for oakville north burlington", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00722-00166855-00167063": "thank you speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00723-00167064-00167231": "my question is for the minister of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00724-00167232-00167438": "government and consumer services", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00725-00167439-00167623": "minister on tuesday you held an", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00726-00167624-00167823": "important announcement in the city of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00727-00167824-00168063": "london that signaled the next step our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00728-00168064-00168311": "government is taking to continue making", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00729-00168312-00168543": "life and business more attractive and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00730-00168544-00168799": "more affordable here in ontario", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00731-00168800-00169031": "business owners across ontario have long", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00732-00169032-00169238": "called on governments to support the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00733-00169239-00169502": "growth and stability of our communities", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00734-00169503-00169726": "by placing the future of our province's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00735-00169727-00169959": "service delivery at the forefront of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00736-00169960-00170095": "innovation", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00737-00170096-00170278": "as such speaker i'd like to ask the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00738-00170279-00170519": "minister to please tell us how the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00739-00170520-00170743": "government's new digital dealership", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00740-00170744-00171007": "registration will innovate how we do", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00741-00171008-00171583": "business in ontario for years to come", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00742-00171584-00171743": "the minister of government consumer", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00743-00171744-00171926": "services", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00744-00171927-00172151": "thank you uh speaker and thank you to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00745-00172152-00172390": "the outstanding member from oakville", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00746-00172391-00172759": "north burlington for her question", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00747-00172760-00173014": "this past tuesday speaker our government", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00748-00173015-00173254": "launched our new digital dealership", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00749-00173255-00173447": "registration program or as i like to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00750-00173448-00173783": "call it ddr for short and very simply", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00751-00173784-00174023": "put to the member through you mr speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00752-00174024-00174287": "this is just creating an easier faster", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00753-00174288-00174551": "simpler system for ontarians to be able", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00754-00174552-00174735": "to purchase a new vehicle", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00755-00174736-00174990": "now a purchaser of a new vehicle can", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00756-00174991-00175207": "walk into a dealership and leave on the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00757-00175208-00175447": "exact same day with their new car you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00758-00175448-00175654": "won't have to worry about taking time to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00759-00175655-00175831": "go down to the service ontario to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00760-00175832-00175990": "register your license plate to register", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00761-00175991-00176263": "your vehicle or your permit no speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00762-00176264-00176471": "we are moving forward with our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00763-00176472-00176719": "transformation in this government in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00764-00176720-00176983": "this province to ensure that we are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00765-00176984-00177190": "moving forward to give people the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00766-00177191-00177343": "opportunities", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00767-00177344-00177566": "to have easier access to the things we", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00768-00177567-00177807": "all want need mr speaker and that is why", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00769-00177808-00178071": "we are moving forward with further", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00770-00178072-00178238": "transformation here in the province of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00771-00178239-00178431": "ontario because we want to make things", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00772-00178432-00178590": "easier for the people of this province", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00773-00178591-00178814": "more affordable and we have every", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00774-00178815-00179007": "intention of continuing this initiative", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00775-00179008-00179283": "mr speaker for the next four years as we", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00776-00179284-00179447": "continue", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00777-00179448-00179790": "the supplemental question", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00778-00179791-00179951": "thank you speaker and i thank the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00779-00179952-00180223": "minister for his answer the covet 19", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00780-00180224-00180495": "pandemic has taught us many lessons", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00781-00180496-00180687": "about how we can work together to make", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00782-00180688-00180999": "public services more user friendly and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00783-00181000-00181175": "convenient for the hard-working people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00784-00181176-00181319": "of the province", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00785-00181320-00181487": "even more so we've learned how to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00786-00181488-00181743": "positively leverage technology to our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00787-00181744-00182014": "favor and open the doors for more people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00788-00182015-00182238": "to be able to access a wide range of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00789-00182239-00182447": "vital services from the safety and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00790-00182448-00182638": "comfort of their own home", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00791-00182639-00182854": "my question through the speaker is again", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00792-00182855-00182983": "for the minister of government and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00793-00182984-00183151": "consumer services", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00794-00183152-00183583": "could the minister explain how the ddr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00795-00183584-00183854": "is contributing to service delivery in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00796-00183855-00184071": "our province and what is being done to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00797-00184072-00184263": "ensure that everyone is able to use", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00798-00184264-00184478": "government services regardless of their", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00799-00184479-00184702": "ability to physically or virtually", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00800-00184703-00185166": "access them", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00801-00185167-00185390": "mr government consumer services", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00802-00185391-00185535": "well thank you speaker and thank you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00803-00185536-00185695": "again to the member from oakville north", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00804-00185696-00185878": "burlington for that very very good", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00805-00185879-00186190": "question uh speaker ddr is a major step", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00806-00186191-00186350": "forward in a series of ongoing", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00807-00186351-00186511": "innovations that we're doing here in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00808-00186512-00186799": "this province to enable online vehicle", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00809-00186800-00187087": "ownership registration transfers at full", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00810-00187088-00187311": "implementation the ddr program will help", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00811-00187312-00187590": "streamline up to 4.8", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00812-00187591-00187783": "million dealership registration", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00813-00187784-00187983": "transactions annually", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00814-00187984-00188254": "all of which must currently uh be done", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00815-00188255-00188414": "in person and now we're moving those", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00816-00188415-00188638": "online speaker not only that but the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00817-00188639-00188766": "announcement that we made this past", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00818-00188767-00189007": "tuesday marked a successful completion", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00819-00189008-00189214": "of our government's mission to improve", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00820-00189215-00189526": "or bring online the top 10 service", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00821-00189527-00189726": "ontario transactions here in the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00822-00189727-00189950": "province simply put speaker this is yet", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00823-00189951-00190247": "another occasion of a promise made and a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00824-00190248-00190471": "promise capped by premier ford and this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00825-00190472-00190702": "conservative government for the people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00826-00190703-00190902": "mr speaker and we're going to continue", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00827-00190903-00191126": "doing everything in our power to deliver", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00828-00191127-00191383": "our commitment to be a digital first but", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00829-00191384-00191559": "not a digital", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00830-00191560-00191783": "only method of service delivery here in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00831-00191784-00191983": "the province of ontario speaker we're", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00832-00191984-00192223": "just making things easier so we can", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00833-00192224-00192383": "thank you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00834-00192384-00192590": "members", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00835-00192591-00192719": "thank you speaker my questions for the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00836-00192720-00192999": "premier my constituent victoria velanosi", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00837-00193000-00193135": "who runs a small business in my writing", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00838-00193136-00193335": "of toronto center recently reached out", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00839-00193336-00193502": "to my office about delays and accessing", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00840-00193503-00193663": "small business grants", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00841-00193664-00193919": "victoria said i quote i am among those", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00842-00193920-00194078": "who have been hanging on by the skin of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00843-00194079-00194319": "our teeth for the last two years my", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00844-00194320-00194447": "business is an event and live", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00845-00194448-00194590": "performance space that caters to the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00846-00194591-00194790": "performing arts industry and as you know", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00847-00194791-00194943": "my industry has been the first to be", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00848-00194944-00195119": "mandated to shut down and the last to be", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00849-00195120-00195390": "allowed to reopen february 10th i", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00850-00195391-00195614": "applied for the third round of ontario's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00851-00195615-00195759": "ten thousand dollars for my business", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00852-00195760-00196007": "space space revolution i'm still waiting", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00853-00196008-00196183": "to learn if my application will even be", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00854-00196184-00196431": "approved end quote speaker why is this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00855-00196432-00196631": "government making small businesses like", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00856-00196632-00196814": "victoria's weight for the help that they", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00857-00196815-00196990": "desperately desperately need to survive", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00858-00196991-00197359": "this pandemic", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00859-00197360-00197535": "minister of economic development job", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00860-00197536-00197743": "creation and trade thank you for the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00861-00197744-00197911": "question premier i'm going to pick up on", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00862-00197912-00198095": "where my colleague left off of course", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00863-00198096-00198326": "this is a program that you're speaking", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00864-00198327-00198614": "about that you voted against we have now", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00865-00198615-00198743": "handed out", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00866-00198744-00199038": "over 3 billion dollars", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00867-00199039-00199175": "in support", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00868-00199176-00199431": "to small businesses", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00869-00199432-00199663": "that is one that you voted against but", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00870-00199664-00199902": "you also voted against the program she", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00871-00199903-00200135": "should be applying for which is the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00872-00200136-00200495": "electricity rebate the tax rebate those", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00873-00200496-00200719": "are all programs that are available to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00874-00200720-00200983": "small businesses there are eligibility", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00875-00200984-00201231": "requirements certainly there are there", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00876-00201232-00201478": "are good follow-ups from the 1-800", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00877-00201479-00201695": "number and from the ministries website", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00878-00201696-00201919": "again all programs that you voted", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00879-00201920-00202254": "against the three over three billion", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00880-00202255-00202471": "dollars that has been such a vital", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00881-00202472-00202678": "support to these small businesses and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00882-00202679-00203271": "has been their lifeblood", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00883-00203272-00203414": "thank you speaker respectfully back to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00884-00203415-00203663": "the minister i i don't know what planet", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00885-00203664-00203759": "you're living on but the small", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00886-00203760-00203895": "businesses in my community are telling", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00887-00203896-00204135": "you outright the money's not flowing you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00888-00204136-00204271": "can pat yourself on the back but the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00889-00204272-00204414": "money is not flowing they are waiting", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00890-00204415-00204543": "and they are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00891-00204544-00204743": "speaker small businesses can't afford to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00892-00204744-00204927": "wait any longer your program is not", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00893-00204928-00205023": "working", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00894-00205023-00205214": "victoria said i quote i have spoken with", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00895-00205215-00205334": "the relevant department about the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00896-00205335-00205510": "ontario small business supports only to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00897-00205511-00205694": "be told that my application is still", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00898-00205696-00205871": "processing and i should continue to wait", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00899-00205871-00206182": "60 calendar days but my bills can't wait", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00900-00206183-00206375": "that long the delay happening is", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00901-00206376-00206519": "defeating the entire purpose of the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00902-00206519-00206742": "program end quote speaker businesses", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00903-00206744-00206951": "like victoria's are the spaces that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00904-00206952-00207166": "ontario's ontarians are most waiting to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00905-00207167-00207382": "reopen so that they can safely gather", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00906-00207383-00207614": "and experience art and music and culture", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00907-00207615-00207846": "and theater and live performances", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00908-00207848-00208103": "businesses like victoria's help to fuel", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00909-00208104-00208351": "tourism and economic recovery we need", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00910-00208352-00208551": "them as part of our recovery plan and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00911-00208552-00208679": "they're not going to make it to be part", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00912-00208680-00208862": "of that recovery plan if you don't start", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00913-00208863-00209046": "flowing the money from your broken", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00914-00209048-00209262": "program so will you commit today fix", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00915-00209263-00209423": "your broken program and start flowing", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00916-00209423-00209646": "the money that businesses need today not", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00917-00209648-00209927": "60 days from now to stay open", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00918-00209928-00210063": "i remind the members to make their", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00919-00210064-00210239": "comments through the chair minister of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00920-00210240-00210446": "economic development to reply thank you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00921-00210448-00210646": "very much you know this round of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00922-00210648-00210879": "business funding that is out there it", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00923-00210880-00211167": "builds on the nearly three billion", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00924-00211167-00211382": "dollars that was provided last year", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00925-00211383-00211534": "through the ontario small business", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00926-00211535-00211831": "support grant now in this new small", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00927-00211832-00212039": "business relief grant we're providing", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00928-00212040-00212303": "ten thousand dollars to eligible", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00929-00212304-00212575": "businesses who are subject to closure", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00930-00212576-00212767": "these are businesses who were ordered", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00931-00212767-00213103": "closed under the modified step uh two of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00932-00213104-00213358": "the road map to reopen those who are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00933-00213359-00213663": "eligible for the previous grants were", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00934-00213664-00214006": "pre-screened to verify their eligibility", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00935-00214007-00214206": "newly established businesses the few", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00936-00214207-00214375": "hundred that were established in that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00937-00214376-00214471": "period", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00938-00214471-00214663": "they were able to apply for this new", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00939-00214664-00214887": "program now that the portal is open you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00940-00214888-00215142": "know we want these businesses that are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00941-00215144-00215415": "eligible to be supported and that's why", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00942-00215416-00215694": "there were so many opportunities for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00943-00215696-00215855": "them to apply", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00944-00215856-00216134": "to become eligible to apply for the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00945-00216135-00216382": "small business relief to supply to apply", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00946-00216383-00216734": "for the tax relief to apply for the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00947-00216735-00217015": "electricity relief and i hope that they", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00948-00217016-00217182": "thank you very much the next question", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00949-00217183-00217398": "the member from our venue", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00950-00217400-00217582": "thank you mr speaker mr speaker this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00951-00217583-00217719": "government is going ahead with the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00952-00217719-00218031": "construction of a 235-bed prison in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00953-00218032-00218182": "chemville despite", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00954-00218183-00218431": "major opposition from the campbell", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00955-00218432-00218534": "community", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00956-00218535-00218767": "residents don't agree with this mega", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00957-00218767-00218998": "project that is going to pave over acres", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00958-00219000-00219239": "of farmland the municipality doesn't", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00959-00219240-00219494": "have the infrastructure including public", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00960-00219496-00219751": "transit to support this project", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00961-00219752-00220015": "ontario labels are listening and we have", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00962-00220016-00220279": "called on the construction", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00963-00220280-00220527": "of this prison to be put on pause will", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00964-00220528-00220727": "the government commit to a moratorium on", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00965-00220728-00220942": "the construction of the campbell prison", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00966-00220944-00221151": "so that they can take the time to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00967-00221152-00221398": "actually listen to community concerns", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00968-00221400-00221615": "and answer some important questions that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00969-00221616-00221942": "the municipality has", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00970-00221944-00222182": "to reply the solicitor general thank you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00971-00222183-00222358": "speaker you know respectfully we are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00972-00222359-00222479": "working very closely with the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00973-00222480-00222663": "municipality the mayor", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00974-00222664-00222967": "the clerk and everyone who has questions", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00975-00222967-00223215": "related to what this investment will", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00976-00223216-00223391": "mean to the kemptville and area", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00977-00223392-00223719": "community when we made a commitment to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00978-00223719-00224094": "an eastern ontario expansion of a very", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00979-00224096-00224303": "needed piece of our provincial", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00980-00224304-00224567": "infrastructure on the corrections side", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00981-00224567-00224910": "it included the corrections facility in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00982-00224911-00225151": "kempfield we're in those planning stages", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00983-00225152-00225367": "now talks are continuing", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00984-00225367-00225598": "we are working directly as i said with", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00985-00225600-00225958": "the municipality including raising", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00986-00225959-00226223": "issues that directly will benefit the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00987-00226223-00226542": "community in terms of access to land and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00988-00226544-00226758": "access to additional services that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00989-00226759-00226927": "frankly wouldn't be there without this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00990-00226928-00227206": "facility thank you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00991-00227207-00227415": "documentary", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00992-00227416-00227598": "thank you mr speaker respectfully the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00993-00227600-00227767": "mayor has been asking who's going to be", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00994-00227767-00227942": "paying for these infrastructure and i", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00995-00227944-00228158": "haven't seen any answer to this question", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00996-00228159-00228367": "but i want to get to the point that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00997-00228367-00228655": "the cost to incarcerate a person in an", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00998-00228656-00229039": "ontario provincial prison costs 300 per", "WlTdWQuqlh4-00999-00229040-00229119": "day", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01000-00229119-00229391": "70 of the incarcerated people in our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01001-00229392-00229623": "provincial institutions are just", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01002-00229623-00229903": "awaiting for trial precedent has shown", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01003-00229904-00230110": "that these people can safely be allowed", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01004-00230111-00230246": "to live in their communities while", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01005-00230248-00230455": "waiting for their day in court", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01006-00230456-00230694": "the prison represents an outdated way of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01007-00230696-00230919": "thinking about the best way to reduce", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01008-00230919-00231142": "crime the government should be lifting", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01009-00231144-00231375": "people out of poverty and investing in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01010-00231376-00231663": "community rehabilitation program not", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01011-00231664-00231879": "spending massive amounts of money to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01012-00231880-00232119": "lock people up before they even have", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01013-00232119-00232375": "been convicted so does the solicitor", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01014-00232376-00232623": "general think that continuing to pour", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01015-00232623-00232831": "money into the prison system is a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01016-00232832-00233246": "fiscally responsible way to fight crime", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01017-00233248-00233503": "solicitor general if the member office's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01018-00233504-00233831": "question is will our government support", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01019-00233832-00234039": "individuals who are in our corrections", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01020-00234040-00234239": "facility whether that's a waiting trial", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01021-00234240-00234471": "or a bail the answer is absolutely", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01022-00234471-00234767": "unequivocally yes your party can", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01023-00234767-00235006": "continue to say no and pause these", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01024-00235007-00235303": "investments but what it means is the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01025-00235304-00235479": "investments are going to make a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01026-00235480-00235703": "difference for corrections officers for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01027-00235704-00235879": "individuals who are serving in our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01028-00235880-00236134": "institutions because we need the ability", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01029-00236135-00236375": "to offer those programming spaces to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01030-00236376-00236655": "keep people safe to stop recidivism and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01031-00236656-00236887": "ultimately to make sure that when people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01032-00236888-00237134": "successfully leave our institutions they", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01033-00237135-00237391": "are going to jobs to communities and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01034-00237392-00237742": "being a a part of society that will", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01035-00237744-00237887": "ensure", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01036-00237888-00238191": "we have a safer ontario at the end of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01037-00238192-00238367": "the day that's what our government is", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01038-00238367-00238631": "doing you can continue to say no we will", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01039-00238632-00239055": "make investments", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01040-00239056-00239271": "a member for aurora or bridges richmond", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01041-00239271-00239471": "hill thank you very much speaker speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01042-00239471-00239631": "my question is to the ministry of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01043-00239632-00239831": "economic development job creation and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01044-00239832-00240063": "trade speaker yesterday's announcement", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01045-00240064-00240287": "from our premier and the minister was an", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01046-00240288-00240510": "absolute game changer for the city of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01047-00240511-00240710": "windsor as well as the province itself", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01048-00240711-00240887": "speaker as we know the previous", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01049-00240888-00241046": "government abandoned", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01050-00241048-00241294": "the automotive and manufacturing sector", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01051-00241296-00241463": "and as a result speaker the cost of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01052-00241464-00241694": "doing business became so high that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01053-00241696-00241903": "businesses and jobs fled to other", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01054-00241904-00242158": "jurisdictions speaker ontarians are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01055-00242159-00242303": "looking to our government to make", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01056-00242304-00242567": "ontario open for business so through you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01057-00242567-00242734": "i'm wondering if the minister can tell", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01058-00242735-00242967": "us what his ministry is doing to help", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01059-00242967-00243198": "attract the game-changing investments", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01060-00243200-00243579": "that lg energy solutions made in our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01061-00243580-00243791": "project economic development job", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01062-00243792-00244006": "creation and trade speaker since we were", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01063-00244007-00244182": "elected we have been lowering the cost", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01064-00244183-00244415": "of business by seven billion dollars a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01065-00244416-00244782": "year since toyota's 1.4 billion dollar", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01066-00244783-00245055": "investment ontario manufacturers have", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01067-00245056-00245446": "announced a further 13 billion dollars", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01068-00245448-00245663": "in ontario and this is unprecedented in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01069-00245664-00245967": "our history 1.8 billion from ford and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01070-00245967-00246294": "oakville 1.5 billion from stalantis in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01071-00246296-00246582": "windsor general motors 1.4 billion in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01072-00246583-00246903": "ingersoll and another 1.4 billion in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01073-00246904-00247206": "oshawa honda 1.4 billion in alliston de", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01074-00247207-00247582": "fasco 1.8 billion dollars in green steel", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01075-00247583-00247934": "in hamilton and now lg and stalantis 5", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01076-00247935-00248198": "billion in windsor add our tech our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01077-00248200-00248446": "parts our critical minerals speaker we", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01078-00248448-00248734": "have everything we need to build the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01079-00248735-00248967": "cars of the future but stay tuned", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01080-00248967-00249282": "there's much more", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01081-00249283-00249623": "coming supplementary question", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01082-00249623-00249823": "thank you very much speaker and i really", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01083-00249823-00249982": "do want to thank the minister for the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01084-00249983-00250230": "answer and speaker as stated earlier by", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01085-00250231-00250358": "the government house leader this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01086-00250359-00250623": "investment will help secure ontario's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01087-00250623-00250910": "automotive sectors for decades to come", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01088-00250911-00251046": "it really is great to hear that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01089-00251048-00251294": "businesses have such renewed confidence", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01090-00251296-00251463": "in ontario's business climate that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01091-00251464-00251687": "they're willing to make multi-billion", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01092-00251688-00251846": "dollar investments here in ontario", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01093-00251848-00252119": "speaker now speaker this is in stark", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01094-00252119-00252351": "contrast to the conditions that the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01095-00252352-00252558": "liberals left ontario before we came", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01096-00252559-00252887": "into office so speaker we can't stop now", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01097-00252888-00253046": "through you to the minister of economic", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01098-00253048-00253255": "development job creation and tel and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01099-00253256-00253471": "trade will he tell this house what next", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01100-00253471-00253710": "steps our government will be taking to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01101-00253711-00253871": "support the automotive automotive", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01102-00253871-00254110": "sectors for years and decades to come in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01103-00254111-00254367": "ontario", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01104-00254367-00254558": "economic development", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01105-00254559-00254815": "thank you speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01106-00254816-00255119": "lower costs lower costs lower costs", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01107-00255119-00255279": "that's what you can expect and there's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01108-00255280-00255519": "plenty of words to describe yesterday's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01109-00255519-00255694": "five billion dollar announcement some", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01110-00255696-00255919": "would say historic some would say", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01111-00255919-00256110": "unprecedented some call it a game", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01112-00256111-00256423": "changer but mayor drew dilkens the mayor", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01113-00256423-00256598": "of windsor he may have said it best he", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01114-00256600-00256967": "said buddy we bagged a unicorn and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01115-00256967-00257119": "mayor drew", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01116-00257119-00257391": "and his windsor works team", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01117-00257392-00257575": "really worked", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01118-00257576-00257887": "our teams at our ministry the premier's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01119-00257888-00258287": "office treasury board finance caucus and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01120-00258288-00258575": "cabinet they've all been rowing with the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01121-00258576-00258998": "same set of oars so our word pre speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01122-00259000-00259167": "is teamwork", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01123-00259167-00259527": "thanks to all for giving thousands of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01124-00259528-00259694": "people hope", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01125-00259696-00259991": "but mostly for creating a place to work", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01126-00259992-00260430": "for those 2 500 people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01127-00260431-00260639": "next question the member for university", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01128-00260640-00260863": "raised there thank you speaker my", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01129-00260864-00261110": "question is to the premier arichitjala", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01130-00261111-00261327": "and smitha pradhan have a seven-year-old", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01131-00261328-00261615": "son rishi who is diagnosed with autism", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01132-00261616-00261823": "rishi's family have been forced to pay", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01133-00261823-00261998": "out of pocket for the critical therapy", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01134-00262000-00262230": "he needs due to this government's delay", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01135-00262231-00262487": "flip-flops cut and lack of support for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01136-00262488-00262647": "children with autism", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01137-00262648-00262887": "this year alone rishi's parents will pay", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01138-00262888-00263158": "approximately forty thousand dollars for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01139-00263159-00263455": "a variety of therapies far more", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01140-00263456-00263623": "far more than the five thousand dollars", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01141-00263624-00263751": "they eventually received from the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01142-00263752-00263982": "government after months of waiting", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01143-00263983-00264223": "they have seen solid improvements thanks", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01144-00264224-00264406": "to their intervention but it has come at", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01145-00264407-00264615": "the cost of real financial challenges", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01146-00264616-00264871": "because of this government's inaction", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01147-00264872-00265110": "this is my question will the premier", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01148-00265111-00265375": "make good on his previous commitments", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01149-00265376-00265543": "follow the recommendations of the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01150-00265544-00265806": "ontario autism program advisory panel", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01151-00265807-00266055": "and finally implement a needs-based", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01152-00266056-00266423": "funding system", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01153-00266424-00266599": "minister children community and social", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01154-00266600-00266703": "services", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01155-00266704-00266863": "thank you speaker thank you very much", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01156-00266864-00267039": "for the question indeed our government", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01157-00267040-00267310": "is implementing a needs-based autism", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01158-00267311-00267575": "program and we will continue to do that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01159-00267576-00267806": "we've doubled the funding we have five", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01160-00267807-00268047": "times as many children in a program", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01161-00268048-00268199": "receiving services and under the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01162-00268200-00268447": "previous government we have 40 000", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01163-00268448-00268655": "children who are receiving services that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01164-00268656-00268855": "would not have received services under", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01165-00268856-00269063": "the previous government's plan we are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01166-00269064-00269287": "dedicated and committed to making sure", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01167-00269288-00269447": "children with autism and their families", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01168-00269448-00269606": "receive the supports they want and in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01169-00269607-00269991": "fact uh we have uh 32 000 payments that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01170-00269992-00270303": "have gone out in the interim one-time", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01171-00270304-00270367": "six hundred funding", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01172-00270368-00270527": "sixty-five children are enrolled in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01173-00270528-00270679": "behavioral plans", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01174-00270680-00270815": "twelve thousand nine hundred and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01175-00270816-00270975": "fourteen families are receiving", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01176-00270976-00271158": "foundational family services the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01177-00271159-00271351": "caregiver mediated early years program", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01178-00271352-00271510": "one thousand one hundred twenty six", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01179-00271511-00271734": "children receiving services they entry", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01180-00271735-00272047": "to school program 912 children and that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01181-00272048-00272167": "list goes on", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01182-00272168-00272334": "we are we are making sure that these", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01183-00272335-00272519": "children get the services that they need", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01184-00272520-00272663": "despite the lack of effort by the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01185-00272664-00273199": "previous", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01186-00273200-00273351": "thank you speaker back to the premier", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01187-00273352-00273623": "what i am hearing from constituents who", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01188-00273624-00273767": "are impacted by this government's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01189-00273768-00274015": "neglect of children with autism is that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01190-00274016-00274223": "they don't trust this government to help", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01191-00274224-00274430": "families in need anymore", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01192-00274431-00274606": "this government promised families like", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01193-00274607-00274775": "rishis that the waitlist would be", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01194-00274776-00275015": "cleared by the end of march 2020.", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01195-00275016-00275334": "instead as we move into 2022 the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01196-00275335-00275830": "waitlist has ballooned to 50 000 people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01197-00275831-00276047": "these families need help", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01198-00276048-00276247": "it's past time to stop playing politics", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01199-00276248-00276423": "with these numbers when will this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01200-00276424-00276582": "government stop ignoring the needs of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01201-00276583-00276758": "children with autism and support", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01202-00276759-00276904": "children like rishi", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01203-00276905-00277295": "[Applause]", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01204-00277296-00277471": "thank you speaker our government is", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01205-00277472-00277630": "absolutely committed to making sure", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01206-00277631-00277847": "these children receive the the services", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01207-00277848-00278030": "and the care they need that's why forty", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01208-00278031-00278199": "thousand children approximately are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01209-00278200-00278430": "receiving the services right now funded", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01210-00278431-00278647": "through the oap program this is a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01211-00278648-00278863": "multiple pathway program it is needs", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01212-00278864-00279103": "based it is comprehensive it is family", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01213-00279104-00279287": "and individual centered to address their", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01214-00279288-00279487": "unique needs the opposition had the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01215-00279488-00279671": "chance to support children and youth", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01216-00279672-00279895": "with special needs and they said no they", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01217-00279896-00280030": "said no to the children who will be", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01218-00280031-00280199": "served by the grandview children's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01219-00280200-00280399": "treatment center in ajax they said no to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01220-00280400-00280527": "the children who will be served by the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01221-00280528-00280719": "chatham-kent children's treatment center", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01222-00280720-00280910": "and their families they said no to the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01223-00280911-00281071": "children who will be served by the one", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01224-00281072-00281230": "door for care at cheo's integrated", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01225-00281231-00281439": "treatment center they said no and voted", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01226-00281440-00281647": "against the largest investment to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01227-00281648-00281815": "support children with special needs", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01228-00281816-00282039": "including autism in two decades and they", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01229-00282040-00282334": "voted against these investments not once", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01230-00282335-00282630": "but twice in two budgets our government", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01231-00282631-00282775": "is supporting children with special", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01232-00282776-00282999": "needs with children with autism that's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01233-00283000-00283334": "why we doubled the oap budget it's why", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01234-00283335-00283639": "we had an autism advisory panel and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01235-00283640-00283815": "developed an integrated intake", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01236-00283816-00284054": "organization and building capacity that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01237-00284055-00284247": "never existed to serve this vulnerable", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01238-00284248-00284719": "population and we will continue", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01239-00284720-00285030": "the next question the member for guelph", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01240-00285031-00285247": "thank you speaker my question is for the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01241-00285248-00285358": "premier", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01242-00285359-00285687": "tuesday was world water day and most", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01243-00285688-00285958": "ontarians would be shocked to know that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01244-00285959-00286391": "gravel mines use 2 billion liters of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01245-00286392-00286615": "water each and every day", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01246-00286616-00286919": "that's almost double the amount of water", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01247-00286920-00287199": "the city of toronto consumes on a daily", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01248-00287200-00287319": "basis", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01249-00287320-00287534": "over 5 000", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01250-00287535-00287934": "gravel mines are licensed to extract 13", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01251-00287935-00288254": "times more aggregate than the province's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01252-00288255-00288454": "annual consumption", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01253-00288455-00288647": "but speaker the industry", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01254-00288648-00288854": "wants more", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01255-00288855-00289103": "something does not add up here", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01256-00289104-00289391": "so my question is will the premier", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01257-00289392-00289727": "impose an immediate moratorium on all", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01258-00289728-00289982": "new gravel mining approvals and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01259-00289983-00290271": "expansions until it undertakes an", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01260-00290272-00290606": "independent review of how much aggregate", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01261-00290607-00291079": "the province actually needs", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01262-00291080-00291239": "nursing environment conservation and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01263-00291240-00291463": "parks thank you speaker the government", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01264-00291464-00291630": "of ontario supports keeping the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01265-00291631-00291830": "province's aggregate resources as close", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01266-00291831-00292054": "to markets as possible while ensuring", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01267-00292055-00292303": "protection of the environment and human", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01268-00292304-00292606": "health enhancements to our water taking", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01269-00292607-00292806": "program recently include giving", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01270-00292807-00293023": "municipalities more say in this process", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01271-00293024-00293271": "expanding restrictions better assessment", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01272-00293272-00293495": "and management increasing transparency", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01273-00293496-00293751": "and data reporting mr speaker i could go", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01274-00293752-00293934": "on in addition we've launched the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01275-00293935-00294167": "largest freshwater cleanup of its kind", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01276-00294168-00294351": "taking place along lake ontario right", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01277-00294352-00294575": "now working alongside a number of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01278-00294576-00294815": "partners across ontario", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01279-00294816-00295087": "to ensure that we balance both the need", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01280-00295088-00295375": "for aggregates while also protecting", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01281-00295376-00295534": "human health and our environment thank", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01282-00295535-00295958": "you speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01283-00295959-00296119": "speaker with all due respect to the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01284-00296120-00296247": "minister", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01285-00296248-00296558": "amo came to this committee to this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01286-00296559-00296847": "legislature and asked the government to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01287-00296848-00297119": "indemnify municipalities legal", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01288-00297120-00297351": "obligation to protect their residents", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01289-00297352-00297630": "water because of the weakening of water", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01290-00297631-00297847": "protections brought forward by this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01291-00297848-00298182": "government people are asking why the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01292-00298183-00298430": "government is approving new license", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01293-00298431-00298671": "applications when the industry is", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01294-00298672-00299015": "already using has access to 13 more", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01295-00299016-00299319": "times aggregate than the province's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01296-00299320-00299591": "needs on an individual basis", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01297-00299592-00299727": "speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01298-00299728-00299999": "you cannot eat gravel", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01299-00300000-00300399": "you cannot drink gravel so my question", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01300-00300400-00300782": "to the premier is he said no he said no", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01301-00300783-00301015": "to an aggregate mind in milton", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01302-00301016-00301367": "will he say yes to a moratorium on new", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01303-00301368-00301575": "license applications in other", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01304-00301576-00301893": "communities across this province", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01305-00301894-00302110": "[Applause]", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01306-00302111-00302303": "mr speaker here you see the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01307-00302304-00302510": "contradictions and the pretzels this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01308-00302511-00302710": "member leader of the green party will", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01309-00302711-00303015": "twist himself into wants hospitals how", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01310-00303016-00303167": "are you going to build them", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01311-00303168-00303430": "wants to invest in public transit how", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01312-00303431-00303567": "are you going to build it aggregate", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01313-00303568-00303758": "washing and the fine-grained materials", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01314-00303759-00303887": "that are that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01315-00303888-00304103": "we we take as a result of that process", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01316-00304104-00304358": "is critical for that industry speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01317-00304359-00304558": "we're working with industry we've seen", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01318-00304559-00304839": "the largest largest investments into", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01319-00304840-00305006": "steel making the cleanest steel making", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01320-00305007-00305230": "production in ontario's history working", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01321-00305231-00305471": "with industry the largest low-carbon", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01322-00305472-00305687": "public transit investment in ontario's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01323-00305688-00305927": "history with the ontario line that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01324-00305928-00306167": "member is full of contradictions", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01325-00306168-00306534": "mr speaker he's just really saying no", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01326-00306535-00306775": "saying no to workers who get up each and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01327-00306776-00306967": "every day to build a more sustainable", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01328-00306968-00307215": "future you have to balance the two we", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01329-00307216-00307391": "understand that building a better", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01330-00307392-00307630": "ontario means investing in hospitals", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01331-00307631-00307854": "means investing in public transit means", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01332-00307855-00308047": "working with industry to reduce our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01333-00308048-00308223": "greenhouse gas emissions we're doing", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01334-00308224-00308415": "just that we're leading this nation and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01335-00308416-00308582": "we're not going to stop to the pretzel", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01336-00308583-00310122": "twisting leader thank you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01337-00310123-00310310": "[Music]", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01338-00310311-00311279": "oh", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01339-00311280-00311430": "okay", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01340-00311431-00311575": "please start the clock the next question", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01341-00311576-00311782": "the member for davenport", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01342-00311783-00312054": "thank you good morning mr speaker uh", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01343-00312055-00312263": "there's no denying right there's no", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01344-00312264-00312591": "denying that two years of a pandemic", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01345-00312592-00312910": "and the longest school closures in any", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01346-00312911-00313039": "jurisdiction", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01347-00313040-00313271": "have had a devastating impact on our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01348-00313272-00313454": "kids mental health", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01349-00313455-00313679": "experts have warned that these impacts", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01350-00313680-00313967": "will be long lasting just this week", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01351-00313968-00314215": "school principals and teachers are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01352-00314216-00314503": "sounding the alarm that the resources", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01353-00314504-00314854": "needed in our schools are simply not", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01354-00314855-00314958": "there", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01355-00314959-00315239": "but instead of marshaling resources mr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01356-00315240-00315495": "speaker to meet that challenge", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01357-00315496-00315743": "this government is rushing to bring back", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01358-00315744-00315999": "standardized eqao testing", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01359-00316000-00316191": "that's going to add to the pressure that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01360-00316192-00316471": "our students are facing every day", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01361-00316472-00316791": "premier spending millions on outdated", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01362-00316792-00316943": "standardized testing instead of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01363-00316944-00317215": "investing that money in the direct", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01364-00317216-00317391": "supports that our students need right", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01365-00317392-00317687": "now", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01366-00317688-00317830": "niagara west", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01367-00317831-00317934": "thank you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01368-00317935-00318134": "my appreciation to the member opposite", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01369-00318135-00318343": "for this question and we understand of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01370-00318344-00318534": "course as we spoke about in this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01371-00318535-00318671": "legislature over the course of the week", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01372-00318672-00318847": "the importance of continued investments", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01373-00318848-00318999": "in mental health that's why our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01374-00319000-00319343": "government has brought forward a 423", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01375-00319344-00319503": "increase in mental health funding when", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01376-00319504-00319630": "compared to the previous liberal", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01377-00319631-00319847": "government and we saw of course that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01378-00319848-00320167": "this impact of the copa 19 pandemic has", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01379-00320168-00320439": "been uh absolutely noticed on students", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01380-00320440-00320599": "and staff alike and that's why we've", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01381-00320600-00320775": "made such continual investments in this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01382-00320776-00320951": "area but i want to just address the fact", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01383-00320952-00321151": "that we've modernized eqao we've", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01384-00321152-00321447": "improved eqao assessments by digitizing", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01385-00321448-00321639": "tests so that the assessment of math and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01386-00321640-00321815": "language skills can occur and we did", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01387-00321816-00321958": "this so that we can measure progress and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01388-00321959-00322175": "make data-driven decisions and i hope", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01389-00322176-00322334": "that the ndp support data-driven", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01390-00322335-00322543": "decisions that will ensure we're lifting", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01391-00322544-00322743": "student performance and enabling success", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01392-00322744-00322943": "in literacy and numeracy and while we", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01393-00322944-00323143": "have seen that over 140 000 students", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01394-00323144-00323303": "have already taken this test we're going", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01395-00323304-00323487": "to continue to invest in support", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01396-00323488-00323623": "learning in reading and mathematics", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01397-00323624-00323887": "along with investments in mental health", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01398-00323888-00324127": "supplementary questions", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01399-00324128-00324375": "mr mr speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01400-00324376-00324510": "i can't believe how completely", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01401-00324511-00324687": "disengaged from reality this government", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01402-00324688-00324987": "is expecting an eight-year-old to type", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01403-00324988-00325334": "150 words independently that's not", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01404-00325335-00325647": "modernizing that's adding stress that's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01405-00325648-00325879": "completely disengaged for reality and it", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01406-00325880-00326063": "is not just the fact that these", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01407-00326064-00326279": "standardized tests will add enormous", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01408-00326280-00326495": "stress for our kids when they've already", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01409-00326496-00326806": "been through so much there are very real", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01410-00326807-00327110": "concerns about the politicization", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01411-00327111-00327375": "of eqao under this government starting", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01412-00327376-00327575": "with the appointment of a failed", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01413-00327576-00327899": "conservative candidate as chair with a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01414-00327900-00328206": "400 percent pay hike", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01415-00328207-00328515": "experts have long argued that these", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01416-00328516-00328823": "politicized standardized tests aren't", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01417-00328824-00329071": "even measuring what matters in our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01418-00329072-00329287": "classrooms they certainly won't be", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01419-00329288-00329510": "useful after two years of significant", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01420-00329511-00329806": "disruption so i'm asking the the premier", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01421-00329807-00330095": "again mr speaker will they finally wake", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01422-00330096-00330303": "up to the crisis that is facing this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01423-00330304-00330654": "next generation scrap the eqao test and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01424-00330655-00330910": "invest that money in direct supports for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01425-00330911-00331327": "our children", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01426-00331328-00331510": "thank you very much speaker and it's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01427-00331511-00331758": "it's disappointing to hear that the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01428-00331759-00331975": "opposition apparently doesn't believe in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01429-00331976-00332199": "evidence-based data-driven decisions", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01430-00332200-00332447": "when it comes to improving performance", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01431-00332448-00332654": "measurements for our students and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01432-00332655-00332799": "enabling success in literacy and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01433-00332800-00333015": "mathematics it's disappointing to hear", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01434-00333016-00333327": "that the member opposite and the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01435-00333328-00333495": "official opposition together with the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01436-00333496-00333671": "liberal government doesn't believe in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01437-00333672-00333910": "modernizing uqao assessments that they", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01438-00333911-00334119": "don't believe in improving uh our system", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01439-00334120-00334295": "of standardized tests to ensure that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01440-00334296-00334510": "we're able to respond and provide the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01441-00334511-00334654": "supports that are in place let's talk", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01442-00334655-00334782": "about a couple of the things that we've", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01443-00334783-00335006": "seen as a result of eqao testing we saw", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01444-00335007-00335215": "under the former liberal government over", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01445-00335216-00335519": "half of students were unable to pass the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01446-00335520-00335854": "eqao math test unbelievable reductions", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01447-00335855-00336015": "as a result of their", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01448-00336016-00336215": "failure to invest in education and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01449-00336216-00336430": "closing 600 schools what we've done as a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01450-00336431-00336615": "result of that is responded with over", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01451-00336616-00336815": "200 million dollars to improve math", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01452-00336816-00337039": "scores and a four-year math strategy to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01453-00337040-00337271": "hire over 800 board and school-based", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01454-00337272-00337463": "leads to ensure that we're providing the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01455-00337464-00337654": "supports that are necessary responding", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01456-00337655-00337815": "to the data that is before us and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01457-00337816-00337903": "ensuring that we're making", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01458-00337904-00338078": "evidence-based decision making thank you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01459-00338079-00338271": "very much", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01460-00338272-00338510": "next question the member for ottawa", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01461-00338511-00338703": "very much speaker and my question is for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01462-00338704-00339023": "the premier ontario has yet to sign a 10", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01463-00339024-00339206": "a day child care agreement with the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01464-00339207-00339463": "federal government we're dead last", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01465-00339464-00339615": "we're right at the back of the pack", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01466-00339616-00339758": "that's a place where the premier seems", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01467-00339759-00339927": "to be content to be", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01468-00339928-00340095": "and this unnecessary delay has hurt", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01469-00340096-00340287": "families for years it's cost them", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01470-00340288-00340447": "thousands of dollars and that means less", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01471-00340448-00340647": "money for things like groceries kids", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01472-00340648-00340871": "clothes kids sports kids extra", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01473-00340872-00341054": "curricular activities and it's held back", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01474-00341055-00341287": "some families from having two incomes", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01475-00341288-00341534": "the premier's message to these families", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01476-00341535-00341719": "not my problem folks", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01477-00341720-00341887": "you're just gonna have to wait", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01478-00341888-00342015": "so speaker ontario liberals have", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01479-00342016-00342230": "committed to signing a deal and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01480-00342231-00342471": "and supporting families by retroactively", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01481-00342472-00342630": "giving them twenty seven hundred and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01482-00342631-00342934": "fifty dollars a year to compensate", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01483-00342935-00343182": "for the premier's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01484-00343183-00343471": "will the premier get a deal done on", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01485-00343472-00343710": "child care and will he commit to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01486-00343711-00343951": "retroactively supporting families for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01487-00343952-00344134": "the costs that they've had to incur", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01488-00344135-00344367": "occur incur", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01489-00344368-00344630": "due to his delays", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01490-00344631-00344815": "government house leader", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01491-00344816-00344943": "speaker it", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01492-00344944-00345151": "should give great comfort to those", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01493-00345152-00345319": "families that the liberals are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01494-00345320-00345447": "suggesting that they might give them", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01495-00345448-00345575": "some money back", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01496-00345576-00345695": "now", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01497-00345696-00345943": "for 15 years the liberals put in place", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01498-00345944-00346127": "the most expensive", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01499-00346128-00346310": "child care program", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01500-00346311-00346519": "in the nation if not if not north", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01501-00346520-00346727": "america but now all of a sudden the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01502-00346728-00346854": "liberals are going to give you back a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01503-00346855-00347063": "few coins so that you can make up for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01504-00347064-00347278": "all the hundreds of thousands of dollars", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01505-00347279-00347582": "they cost them mr speaker and like the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01506-00347583-00347815": "ndp they would sign a deal before even", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01507-00347816-00347999": "reading it or looking at it they would", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01508-00348000-00348206": "sign a deal that doesn't get to the 10 a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01509-00348207-00348382": "day child care uh", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01510-00348383-00348527": "figure mr speaker i'll tell you what", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01511-00348528-00348654": "we're going to do instead what we're", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01512-00348655-00348806": "going to do is this we're going to wait", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01513-00348807-00349054": "for a deal that gives us 10 a day child", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01514-00349055-00349263": "care mr speaker not only for today", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01515-00349264-00349430": "leading into an election", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01516-00349431-00349654": "but for future generations of ontarians", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01517-00349655-00349823": "mr speaker because that's what a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01518-00349824-00349951": "responsible", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01519-00349952-00350271": "government does now there is nobody", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01520-00350272-00350430": "nobody who", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01521-00350431-00350654": "ever would believe that a liberal", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01522-00350655-00350830": "promise to put more money back in your", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01523-00350831-00351103": "pockets will ever amount to anything mr", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01524-00351104-00351334": "speaker there is just no chance people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01525-00351335-00351543": "know that and that's why", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01526-00351544-00351734": "strong stable majority progressive", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01527-00351735-00351887": "conservative government is getting the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01528-00351888-00352023": "job", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01529-00352024-00352519": "this supplementary question", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01530-00352520-00352671": "thank you speaker and it's clear that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01531-00352672-00352823": "the premier is not interested in making", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01532-00352824-00352951": "life any more affordable for these", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01533-00352952-00353143": "families and you know i with all due", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01534-00353144-00353303": "respect to the house leader i've heard", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01535-00353304-00353543": "his talking point before and i only have", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01536-00353544-00353758": "three words for him", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01537-00353759-00353999": "full day kindergarten", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01538-00354000-00354206": "right for all full day candy the same", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01539-00354207-00354391": "full day kindergarten that you all voted", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01540-00354392-00354519": "against", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01541-00354520-00354710": "the saint you all voted against it the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01542-00354711-00354975": "same full-day kindergarten that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01543-00354976-00355175": "the premier said maybe we should cut", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01544-00355176-00355358": "this about two years ago until family", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01545-00355359-00355567": "said now that's not going to happen the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01546-00355568-00355751": "same full-day kindergarten for almost a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01547-00355752-00356006": "decade that has saved families thousands", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01548-00356007-00356182": "and thousands and thousands of dollars a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01549-00356183-00356423": "year the same full-day kindergarten that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01550-00356424-00356606": "you didn't want that lifted up our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01551-00356607-00356782": "economy by allowing more people to come", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01552-00356783-00356967": "into the workforce", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01553-00356968-00357087": "so", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01554-00357088-00357247": "i'm not going to take any lessons from", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01555-00357248-00357558": "the house leader on this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01556-00357559-00357671": "right now", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01557-00357672-00357958": "is this government going to get inside a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01558-00357959-00358223": "deal done question and retroactively", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01559-00358224-00358463": "compensate families for the damage", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01560-00358464-00358719": "they've done by delaying for almost a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01561-00358720-00358871": "year", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01562-00358872-00359063": "government house leader speaker i would", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01563-00359064-00359327": "suggest that that's the problem he's not", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01564-00359328-00359503": "taking lessons from this side of the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01565-00359504-00359678": "house mr speaker", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01566-00359679-00359847": "he's not taking lessons from this side", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01567-00359848-00360006": "of the house because the coalition of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01568-00360007-00360271": "the tax spend and tax has cost this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01569-00360272-00360471": "province billions and billions of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01570-00360472-00360623": "dollars i talked about this yesterday", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01571-00360624-00360767": "the first time that these two parties", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01572-00360768-00360991": "coalesced into a coalition that was back", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01573-00360992-00361158": "in 1985", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01574-00361159-00361543": "in 10 short years they cost 78 billion", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01575-00361544-00361782": "dollars worth of debt now as i said", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01576-00361783-00361903": "yesterday they're sitting around the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01577-00361904-00362030": "illegal pool and the leader of the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01578-00362031-00362191": "liberal party's backyard that he built", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01579-00362192-00362382": "in a conservation land", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01580-00362383-00362575": "but as minister of transportation", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01581-00362576-00362743": "colleagues he didn't know that he was", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01582-00362744-00362887": "supposed to get a permit to build a pool", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01583-00362888-00363071": "on conservation lands", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01584-00363072-00363271": "oops mr speaker so as they're sitting", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01585-00363272-00363454": "around thinking what can we do to make", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01586-00363455-00363775": "life better the last time between 2011", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01587-00363776-00363943": "and 14 how much do you think that cost", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01588-00363944-00364103": "people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01589-00364104-00364391": "and 140 eight billion dollars and what", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01590-00364392-00364647": "did they get for it they got 611", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01591-00364648-00364854": "long-term carrot care beds they got a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01592-00364855-00365023": "health care system that was failing they", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01593-00365024-00365247": "didn't get subways they got an education", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01594-00365248-00365447": "system that could barely get our kids", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01595-00365448-00365678": "the math and and reading scores that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01596-00365679-00365982": "they require failure on every level", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01597-00365983-00366248": "thank you thank you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01598-00366249-00367223": "[Applause]", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01599-00367224-00367382": "thank you please restart the clock the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01600-00367383-00367558": "next question the member for hamilton", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01601-00367559-00367751": "west and castro doctors thank you", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01602-00367752-00367934": "speaker my question to the to the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01603-00367935-00368103": "premier over half of families in", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01604-00368104-00368278": "hamilton are being denied access to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01605-00368279-00368478": "essential home care services because of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01606-00368479-00368678": "the home care worker shortage that this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01607-00368679-00368871": "government has allowed to happen lucy", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01608-00368872-00369110": "morton opseu regional vp said our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01609-00369111-00369263": "member's job used to be to care for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01610-00369264-00369447": "clients now they teach families how to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01611-00369448-00369678": "care for them this is dire especially", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01612-00369679-00369847": "for families in my riding like peter and", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01613-00369848-00369967": "linda", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01614-00369968-00370143": "these home care supports provide dignity", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01615-00370144-00370367": "and essential care but when there are no", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01616-00370368-00370599": "workers available they put linda's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01617-00370600-00370791": "health at great risk", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01618-00370792-00371006": "peter and lynn are not alone over half", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01619-00371007-00371223": "of the requests for home care in this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01620-00371224-00371447": "province are going unmet so the people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01621-00371448-00371743": "of ontario do not need any historionics", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01622-00371744-00371895": "from this government they don't need to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01623-00371896-00372078": "hear more pats on the back this", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01624-00372079-00372239": "government recently said no to our", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01625-00372240-00372502": "opposition day motion to invest in a", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01626-00372503-00372702": "home care system that would allow people", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01627-00372703-00372847": "to live at home", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01628-00372848-00373071": "in dignity when will this government act", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01629-00373072-00373319": "to address this urgent crisis in home", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01630-00373320-00373543": "care for the people in hamilton and the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01631-00373544-00373751": "people of ontario that need your help", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01632-00373752-00374110": "now", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01633-00374111-00374239": "speaker and i would say to the member", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01634-00374240-00374487": "opposite we are already taking action to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01635-00374488-00374630": "deal with our home care system because", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01636-00374631-00374775": "we have heard from people that in the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01637-00374776-00374975": "past it didn't respond to their needs", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01638-00374976-00375151": "we're modernizing the system it's", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01639-00375152-00375334": "outdated that's why we brought the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01640-00375335-00375487": "connecting people to home and community", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01641-00375488-00375647": "care act which is going to form the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01642-00375648-00375854": "foundation for the modernization of the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01643-00375855-00376078": "system to provide integrated", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01644-00376079-00376302": "patient-centered care to people we know", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01645-00376303-00376423": "that many people are waiting for", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01646-00376424-00376606": "long-term care spaces many people are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01647-00376607-00376839": "also needing home care for wound care", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01648-00376840-00377039": "and other care that's why we are", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01649-00377040-00377302": "training nurses specifically to be able", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01650-00377303-00377527": "to deal with wounds which forms up to", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01651-00377528-00377823": "about 25 to 30 percent of all the home", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01652-00377824-00378006": "care that's required they need that", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01653-00378007-00378323": "specialized care we're also investing on", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01654-00378324-00378647": "548.5 million dollars to expand our home", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01655-00378648-00378895": "care services and we are also making", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01656-00378896-00379202": "sure that we have added investments of", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01657-00379203-00379519": "111 million dollars for high-intensity", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01658-00379520-00379775": "supports at home so we are already", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01659-00379776-00380030": "building a connected 21st century home", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01660-00380031-00380223": "care system that's going to serve the", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01661-00380224-00380391": "citizens of ontario", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01662-00380392-00380815": "from now and for many many years", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01663-00380816-00381023": "thank you that concludes our question", "WlTdWQuqlh4-01664-00381024-00381392": "period for this morning i understand"}}, {"audio_id": "Wmk110M6e5c", "text": {"Wmk110M6e5c-00000-00000024-00000407": "hands-on pairing over numeric comparison", "Wmk110M6e5c-00001-00000408-00000638": "pairing over numeric comparison is very", "Wmk110M6e5c-00002-00000639-00000854": "user-friendly because it requires", "Wmk110M6e5c-00003-00000855-00001135": "the user only to check that the number", "Wmk110M6e5c-00004-00001136-00001319": "displayed on both devices", "Wmk110M6e5c-00005-00001320-00001687": "is the same the stm32wb will indicate", "Wmk110M6e5c-00006-00001688-00001863": "during pairing feature exchange", "Wmk110M6e5c-00007-00001864-00002207": "that it support display and some means", "Wmk110M6e5c-00008-00002208-00002247": "to", "Wmk110M6e5c-00009-00002248-00002510": "either confirm or reject that the number", "Wmk110M6e5c-00010-00002511-00002615": "is the same", "Wmk110M6e5c-00011-00002616-00002871": "this could be as simple as as a button", "Wmk110M6e5c-00012-00002872-00003007": "for example", "Wmk110M6e5c-00013-00003008-00003295": "in cuba mix we need to change the i o", "Wmk110M6e5c-00014-00003296-00003470": "capability to display", "Wmk110M6e5c-00015-00003471-00003854": "and yes no and we can keep the man and", "Wmk110M6e5c-00016-00003855-00003951": "middle protection", "Wmk110M6e5c-00017-00003952-00004351": "as required cuba mx already generates", "Wmk110M6e5c-00018-00004352-00004527": "the event handler for the", "Wmk110M6e5c-00019-00004528-00004711": "numeric comparison value which is", "Wmk110M6e5c-00020-00004712-00004886": "generated by the ble stack", "Wmk110M6e5c-00021-00004887-00005199": "on each pairing as you can see the six", "Wmk110M6e5c-00022-00005200-00005311": "digit number", "Wmk110M6e5c-00023-00005312-00005606": "is outputted over the urs traces the", "Wmk110M6e5c-00024-00005607-00005815": "only thing we will change is the format", "Wmk110M6e5c-00025-00005816-00005999": "of this number so it's displayed in", "Wmk110M6e5c-00026-00006000-00006086": "decimal", "Wmk110M6e5c-00027-00006087-00006279": "and the format is the same as on the", "Wmk110M6e5c-00028-00006280-00006567": "phone the default is a hex", "Wmk110M6e5c-00029-00006568-00006806": "after this you see the call to aci gap", "Wmk110M6e5c-00030-00006808-00006927": "numeric comparison", "Wmk110M6e5c-00031-00006928-00007206": "value confirm yes no and as you can see", "Wmk110M6e5c-00032-00007208-00007239": "the", "Wmk110M6e5c-00033-00007240-00007503": "value is confirmed by default so", "Wmk110M6e5c-00034-00007504-00007574": "normally", "Wmk110M6e5c-00035-00007575-00007814": "you would display the number on the wb", "Wmk110M6e5c-00036-00007815-00008070": "side and wait for the user interaction", "Wmk110M6e5c-00037-00008072-00008310": "but for simplicity we'll keep the", "Wmk110M6e5c-00038-00008311-00008607": "confirmation by default", "Wmk110M6e5c-00039-00008608-00009006": "so let's go to the ble middleware", "Wmk110M6e5c-00040-00009007-00009431": "and let's set the i o capabilities", "Wmk110M6e5c-00041-00009432-00010423": "to display and yes no", "Wmk110M6e5c-00042-00010424-00011535": "and we can regenerate the project", "Wmk110M6e5c-00043-00011536-00011855": "and here in the app ble.c on", "Wmk110M6e5c-00044-00011856-00012583": "line 508", "Wmk110M6e5c-00045-00012584-00012774": "we can see the event handler for the", "Wmk110M6e5c-00046-00012775-00012943": "numeric comparison value", "Wmk110M6e5c-00047-00012944-00013255": "so here the value is outputted over the", "Wmk110M6e5c-00048-00013256-00013319": "traces", "Wmk110M6e5c-00049-00013319-00013630": "so let's just change this format of the", "Wmk110M6e5c-00050-00013631-00013719": "number", "Wmk110M6e5c-00051-00013719-00014083": "to decimal and the value will be", "Wmk110M6e5c-00052-00014084-00014199": "confirmed", "Wmk110M6e5c-00053-00014200-00014479": "by default without any user interaction", "Wmk110M6e5c-00054-00014480-00014566": "so we can", "Wmk110M6e5c-00055-00014568-00014815": "compile the code and load it into the", "Wmk110M6e5c-00056-00014816-00015166": "device", "Wmk110M6e5c-00057-00015168-00015543": "so now we open the sdble toolbox", "Wmk110M6e5c-00058-00015544-00015991": "connect to our device", "Wmk110M6e5c-00059-00015991-00016335": "and try to read the characteristic", "Wmk110M6e5c-00060-00016336-00016711": "a pairing message pops out you see the", "Wmk110M6e5c-00061-00016712-00017047": "numbers is really the same five one", "Wmk110M6e5c-00062-00017048-00017311": "five nine two so i confirm it on the", "Wmk110M6e5c-00063-00017312-00017558": "android side it's confirmed by default", "Wmk110M6e5c-00064-00017559-00017791": "by the application on wb side", "Wmk110M6e5c-00065-00017792-00018111": "and the pairing succeeds and the value", "Wmk110M6e5c-00066-00018112-00018222": "is red", "Wmk110M6e5c-00067-00018223-00018695": "and this is the end of the hand zone"}}, {"audio_id": "WmpDik4Cnyk", "text": {"WmpDik4Cnyk-00000-00000066-00000093": "[Laughter]", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00001-00000094-00001343": "[Music]", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00002-00001344-00001943": "they do what they do and now", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00003-00001944-00003231": "[Music]", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00004-00003232-00004327": "[Music]", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00005-00004328-00004575": "but then i cut myself off from the rest", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00006-00004576-00004799": "of the room i know that i can feel it", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00007-00004800-00005031": "all if you're patient and so", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00008-00005032-00005311": "it can all be worth it all the searching", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00009-00005312-00005535": "pain is never really permanent but damn", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00010-00005536-00005751": "it hurts man i can feel all of the", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00011-00005752-00005991": "turbulence and it's concerning i've been", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00012-00005992-00006199": "searching for a purpose i hope it's", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00013-00006200-00006351": "worth it", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00014-00006352-00006606": "this society is really trying me ain't", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00015-00006608-00006814": "no i didn't seek i hide to be far from", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00016-00006815-00007031": "anxiety i need my space i need my", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00017-00007031-00007231": "privacy i need some signs please you're", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00018-00007231-00007414": "all too right you don't speak quietly", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00019-00007415-00007670": "opinions violently thrown across every", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00020-00007672-00007910": "surface it makes me nervous it's the", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00021-00007911-00008110": "world honestly burning that's all i'm", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00022-00008111-00008431": "learning hope that we can make eternal", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00023-00008432-00008543": "persons", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00024-00008544-00008751": "[Music]", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00025-00008752-00008893": "work man", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00026-00008894-00009167": "[Applause]", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00027-00009168-00011238": "[Music]", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00028-00011239-00011420": "i just gotta", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00029-00011421-00012190": "[Music]", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00030-00012191-00012687": "[Music]", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00031-00012688-00012910": "just gotta get through better get", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00032-00012911-00013055": "through this life is a nuisance thought", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00033-00013056-00013263": "of some new sense i try to reach human", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00034-00013263-00013494": "find a solution my evolution", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00035-00013495-00013671": "a place like this it didn't exist you", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00036-00013672-00013807": "made it like this", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00037-00013808-00013958": "so you can go pick the bad of the good", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00038-00013959-00014255": "got a glass halfway", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00039-00014256-00014813": "[Music]", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00040-00014813-00016921": "[Music]", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00041-00016922-00017807": "[Music]", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00042-00017808-00018594": "while they stay salty", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00043-00018595-00019866": "[Music]", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00044-00019867-00021103": "[Music]", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00045-00021104-00021350": "stop if it's controlling you i know that", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00046-00021351-00021575": "time can heal it all i just gotta get", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00047-00021576-00021784": "through", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00048-00021785-00021884": "[Applause]", "WmpDik4Cnyk-00049-00021885-00022713": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "WmufIGKUPao", "text": {"WmufIGKUPao-00000-00000091-00000175": "[Music]", "WmufIGKUPao-00001-00000176-00000519": "sweet dude", "WmufIGKUPao-00002-00000520-00000911": "that guy's got to be hacking right", "WmufIGKUPao-00003-00000911-00001519": "i mean that might be", "WmufIGKUPao-00004-00001520-00001887": "yeah he's not gonna let me go", "WmufIGKUPao-00005-00001888-00002063": "the only way i can beat this is if i sit", "WmufIGKUPao-00006-00002064-00002399": "here forever", "WmufIGKUPao-00007-00002400-00002623": "oh my god you gotta know what to do", "WmufIGKUPao-00008-00002624-00002734": "actually", "WmufIGKUPao-00009-00002735-00002942": "is that guy having fun and he's still", "WmufIGKUPao-00010-00002943-00003095": "watching me there's nothing", "WmufIGKUPao-00011-00003096-00003295": "if i climb this and get in the car like", "WmufIGKUPao-00012-00003296-00003744": "real quick maybe i have a chance", "WmufIGKUPao-00013-00003745-00003994": "[Music]", "WmufIGKUPao-00014-00003995-00004175": "[Applause]", "WmufIGKUPao-00015-00004176-00004335": "i mean that's big booty cheeks right", "WmufIGKUPao-00016-00004336-00004702": "there man this guy's annoying", "WmufIGKUPao-00017-00004703-00005070": "oh i think i just saw him jump unless", "WmufIGKUPao-00018-00005071-00005767": "that was a bird", "WmufIGKUPao-00019-00005768-00005983": "i would normally go for this bounty but", "WmufIGKUPao-00020-00005984-00006095": "it's in the middle of the freaking field", "WmufIGKUPao-00021-00006096-00006238": "there's gonna be nothing there so", "WmufIGKUPao-00022-00006239-00006431": "we're gonna hit this guy get some loot", "WmufIGKUPao-00023-00006431-00006606": "out of the hangar and uh", "WmufIGKUPao-00024-00006608-00006823": "go crash some skulls", "WmufIGKUPao-00025-00006825-00007119": "[Music]", "WmufIGKUPao-00026-00007120-00007287": "this is actually probably my favorite", "WmufIGKUPao-00027-00007288-00007495": "place to land so i do feel a little at", "WmufIGKUPao-00028-00007495-00007598": "home here", "WmufIGKUPao-00029-00007600-00008703": "or i do hear a bunch of people nearby", "WmufIGKUPao-00030-00008704-00008871": "but we're just gonna fly at this guy off", "WmufIGKUPao-00031-00008872-00011799": "the rim", "WmufIGKUPao-00032-00011800-00012367": "wow we got lucky there", "WmufIGKUPao-00033-00012368-00014083": "good thing he chased me man", "WmufIGKUPao-00034-00014084-00014638": "um", "WmufIGKUPao-00035-00014640-00015175": "okay silence is huge", "WmufIGKUPao-00036-00015176-00015366": "you have this other bat yeah we're on", "WmufIGKUPao-00037-00015368-00015511": "instagram i think that's just the", "WmufIGKUPao-00038-00015512-00016567": "default one", "WmufIGKUPao-00039-00016568-00016703": "if i didn't make that jump i would have", "WmufIGKUPao-00040-00016704-00018679": "been a little shocked", "WmufIGKUPao-00041-00018680-00022150": "so that's probably who got him", "WmufIGKUPao-00042-00022151-00022407": "oh my god dude i did not think he was", "WmufIGKUPao-00043-00022408-00022711": "getting in the car", "WmufIGKUPao-00044-00022712-00023111": "oh", "WmufIGKUPao-00045-00023112-00023883": "i'm gonna keep it moving down to this", "WmufIGKUPao-00046-00023884-00024030": "though", "WmufIGKUPao-00047-00024031-00024199": "did i heard that guy plating and then he", "WmufIGKUPao-00048-00024200-00024607": "just popped in the car", "WmufIGKUPao-00049-00024608-00026935": "it's pretty terrifying", "WmufIGKUPao-00050-00026936-00027095": "you gotta get faster about now we get in", "WmufIGKUPao-00051-00027095-00029014": "that menu overhead", "WmufIGKUPao-00052-00029016-00029174": "i wish we could have stayed on that", "WmufIGKUPao-00053-00029175-00030423": "route for the window", "WmufIGKUPao-00054-00030424-00031214": "that guy sees me i was gonna say", "WmufIGKUPao-00055-00031216-00031790": "bad play buddy you had a good spot", "WmufIGKUPao-00056-00031791-00031943": "i mean if we're quick we can get this", "WmufIGKUPao-00057-00031944-00032095": "but we'll be able to get back to my", "WmufIGKUPao-00058-00032095-00032223": "vehicle there's a buy station up there", "WmufIGKUPao-00059-00032224-00032662": "so let's just go to my old car", "WmufIGKUPao-00060-00032663-00033183": "i can definitely make this one", "WmufIGKUPao-00061-00033184-00033495": "we've got a good game going so far", "WmufIGKUPao-00062-00033496-00033846": "six kills 37 left it's not a monster", "WmufIGKUPao-00063-00033847-00033935": "game but", "WmufIGKUPao-00064-00033936-00034743": "a good amount of action at the beginning", "WmufIGKUPao-00065-00034744-00035071": "i mean maybe we'll pop in advanced", "WmufIGKUPao-00066-00035072-00035231": "and then we can keep one in pocket too i", "WmufIGKUPao-00067-00035232-00035446": "think", "WmufIGKUPao-00068-00035447-00035823": "that's stuck good that it's not but the", "WmufIGKUPao-00069-00035824-00036055": "trophy's gone", "WmufIGKUPao-00070-00036056-00036343": "one good thing one bad thing we need", "WmufIGKUPao-00071-00036344-00037639": "eyes in the sky", "WmufIGKUPao-00072-00037640-00039215": "we'll cut him off", "WmufIGKUPao-00073-00039216-00040279": "uav is out of", "WmufIGKUPao-00074-00040280-00040551": "so i don't get that do people with", "WmufIGKUPao-00075-00040552-00040607": "ghosts", "WmufIGKUPao-00076-00040608-00042383": "on this thing show up or now", "WmufIGKUPao-00077-00042384-00042535": "so there were just like 10 people here", "WmufIGKUPao-00078-00042536-00043483": "now there's nothing", "WmufIGKUPao-00079-00043484-00044787": "what", "WmufIGKUPao-00080-00044788-00045879": "[Music]", "WmufIGKUPao-00081-00045880-00046471": "it's pretty frustrating not gonna lie", "WmufIGKUPao-00082-00046472-00046639": "i'm not going to go up there i don't", "WmufIGKUPao-00083-00046640-00046943": "want to go up there either", "WmufIGKUPao-00084-00046944-00047527": "honestly this is a stupid idea but", "WmufIGKUPao-00085-00047528-00047951": "what else am i supposed to do", "WmufIGKUPao-00086-00047952-00048511": "not climbing these buildings", "WmufIGKUPao-00087-00048512-00049111": "sweet dude", "WmufIGKUPao-00088-00049112-00050039": "that guy's got to be hacking right", "WmufIGKUPao-00089-00050040-00050823": "i mean that might be", "WmufIGKUPao-00090-00050824-00051199": "why all those dots disappeared", "WmufIGKUPao-00091-00051200-00051575": "yeah he's not gonna let me go", "WmufIGKUPao-00092-00051576-00051750": "the only way i can beat this is if i sit", "WmufIGKUPao-00093-00051751-00052791": "here forever", "WmufIGKUPao-00094-00052791-00053463": "oh my god", "WmufIGKUPao-00095-00053464-00054071": "you gotta know what to do actually", "WmufIGKUPao-00096-00054072-00054566": "is that guy having fun", "WmufIGKUPao-00097-00054567-00055199": "you guys see this dude", "WmufIGKUPao-00098-00055200-00055335": "and he's still watching me there's", "WmufIGKUPao-00099-00055336-00055519": "nothing if i climb this and get in the", "WmufIGKUPao-00100-00055520-00055582": "car", "WmufIGKUPao-00101-00055583-00056087": "like real quick maybe i have a chance", "WmufIGKUPao-00102-00056088-00057687": "who has to move first him or me", "WmufIGKUPao-00103-00057688-00057847": "i mean that's big booty cheeks right", "WmufIGKUPao-00104-00057848-00058279": "there", "WmufIGKUPao-00105-00058279-00059071": "man this guy's annoying", "WmufIGKUPao-00106-00059072-00059694": "dude what am i supposed to do", "WmufIGKUPao-00107-00059695-00060454": "guy comes into solos by himself", "WmufIGKUPao-00108-00060455-00060703": "this is how he has fun there's no", "WmufIGKUPao-00109-00060704-00061038": "there's nothing i can do", "WmufIGKUPao-00110-00061039-00061438": "unless he jumps first", "WmufIGKUPao-00111-00061439-00061815": "he's on that building", "WmufIGKUPao-00112-00061816-00061950": "he doesn't have a gas mask we got a", "WmufIGKUPao-00113-00061951-00062447": "chance", "WmufIGKUPao-00114-00062448-00063082": "he did stop looking is that him yeah", "WmufIGKUPao-00115-00063083-00064015": "oh", "WmufIGKUPao-00116-00064016-00064326": "i mean if we go somewhere where", "WmufIGKUPao-00117-00064327-00064575": "he has like a bunch of bullet job he", "WmufIGKUPao-00118-00064576-00066406": "can't hit us but", "WmufIGKUPao-00119-00066407-00066582": "i think i just saw him jump unless that", "WmufIGKUPao-00120-00066583-00067319": "was a bird", "WmufIGKUPao-00121-00067320-00067767": "nope he's still up there", "WmufIGKUPao-00122-00067768-00070082": "wow shacker that's right where i am", "WmufIGKUPao-00123-00070083-00070431": "so", "WmufIGKUPao-00124-00070432-00070743": "if that was him and he just lost that i", "WmufIGKUPao-00125-00070744-00070879": "want to say that was him because of the", "WmufIGKUPao-00126-00070880-00071135": "sniper", "WmufIGKUPao-00127-00071136-00071294": "but like how would he miss shots i don't", "WmufIGKUPao-00128-00071295-00071919": "know how the hacks work really", "WmufIGKUPao-00129-00071920-00072027": "[Applause]", "WmufIGKUPao-00130-00072028-00072647": "[Music]", "WmufIGKUPao-00131-00072648-00073182": "[__] it man", "WmufIGKUPao-00132-00073183-00073391": "that's why you just gotta you can never", "WmufIGKUPao-00133-00073392-00073943": "quit on it", "WmufIGKUPao-00134-00073944-00074750": "that's for georgia bill", "WmufIGKUPao-00135-00074751-00075279": "19 people left", "WmufIGKUPao-00136-00075280-00075462": "i mean after doing that like i should", "WmufIGKUPao-00137-00075463-00075687": "get i should get a bonus or something", "WmufIGKUPao-00138-00075688-00076055": "this i can't believe that guy had the", "WmufIGKUPao-00139-00076056-00076215": "balls to just fly at me like that when", "WmufIGKUPao-00140-00076216-00076335": "he's that horrible", "WmufIGKUPao-00141-00076336-00076959": "even with hacks", "WmufIGKUPao-00142-00076960-00077103": "i guess we'll just go find this bounty", "WmufIGKUPao-00143-00077104-00077631": "so this is more entertaining", "WmufIGKUPao-00144-00077632-00077967": "what'd you make for dinner tonight eh", "WmufIGKUPao-00145-00077968-00078375": "bill bill make dinner", "WmufIGKUPao-00146-00078376-00079191": "where's that car going", "WmufIGKUPao-00147-00079192-00081871": "gas is closing get to the new safe zone", "WmufIGKUPao-00148-00081872-00082518": "that sounds pretty close", "WmufIGKUPao-00149-00082519-00083406": "there's a bounty in the port", "WmufIGKUPao-00150-00083407-00084655": "gunshots didn't sound far", "WmufIGKUPao-00151-00084656-00085423": "uav would be sweet", "WmufIGKUPao-00152-00085424-00085918": "where did he go", "WmufIGKUPao-00153-00085919-00089543": "there he is what is that", "WmufIGKUPao-00154-00089544-00090062": "no way", "WmufIGKUPao-00155-00090063-00090718": "though oh wait", "WmufIGKUPao-00156-00090719-00091326": "pasta cheesesteak and empanada", "WmufIGKUPao-00157-00091327-00091503": "dude i definitely had sulfur as i bought", "WmufIGKUPao-00158-00091504-00092815": "it earlier", "WmufIGKUPao-00159-00092816-00093247": "oh almost got away", "WmufIGKUPao-00160-00093248-00093782": "almost got away pal but you didn't", "WmufIGKUPao-00161-00093783-00094191": "what do we do here", "WmufIGKUPao-00162-00094192-00094871": "that's the question", "WmufIGKUPao-00163-00094872-00095431": "that's the answer", "WmufIGKUPao-00164-00095432-00095623": "they used it when the sniper dominates", "WmufIGKUPao-00165-00095624-00095806": "oh yeah", "WmufIGKUPao-00166-00095807-00097806": "and we saw that guy on this roof", "WmufIGKUPao-00167-00097807-00098447": "headed your way", "WmufIGKUPao-00168-00098448-00099279": "if we can make someone move", "WmufIGKUPao-00169-00099280-00099511": "oh my god man you blew that one you", "WmufIGKUPao-00170-00099512-00099799": "really blew that one", "WmufIGKUPao-00171-00099800-00100503": "and just like that we're back in it", "WmufIGKUPao-00172-00100504-00101247": "there's definitely someone under us too", "WmufIGKUPao-00173-00101248-00101735": "there he is didn't expect to push", "WmufIGKUPao-00174-00101736-00102282": "wow i am amazed that this game's still", "WmufIGKUPao-00175-00102283-00103033": "alive", "WmufIGKUPao-00176-00103034-00103247": "[Applause]", "WmufIGKUPao-00177-00103248-00103478": "air strike two man we could really", "WmufIGKUPao-00178-00103479-00103886": "battle back here", "WmufIGKUPao-00179-00103888-00104118": "trophy much rather i have a daddy but if", "WmufIGKUPao-00180-00104119-00104390": "trophies all that's here", "WmufIGKUPao-00181-00104391-00105007": "i have to take it or give me that", "WmufIGKUPao-00182-00105008-00105478": "look at this", "WmufIGKUPao-00183-00105479-00105607": "all right i want to go now so i don't", "WmufIGKUPao-00184-00105608-00105863": "get caught by", "WmufIGKUPao-00185-00105864-00106271": "staring at this", "WmufIGKUPao-00186-00106272-00108110": "so there's one guy", "WmufIGKUPao-00187-00108111-00110566": "no gas mask no please", "WmufIGKUPao-00188-00110567-00111081": "that one hurts man that one hurts", "WmufIGKUPao-00189-00111082-00112431": "[Music]", "WmufIGKUPao-00190-00112432-00112640": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "Wm-PM9pCzdM", "text": {"Wm-PM9pCzdM-00000-00000169-00003911": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00001-00003913-00004759": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00002-00004760-00004995": "so", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00003-00004996-00006254": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00004-00006255-00006483": "so", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00005-00006484-00016591": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00006-00016592-00016879": "oh welcome call the christmas gutter", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00007-00016880-00023866": "welcome", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00008-00023867-00024553": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00009-00024554-00025071": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00010-00025072-00025188": "foreign", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00011-00025189-00025612": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00012-00025613-00025869": "[Laughter]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00013-00025870-00027235": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00014-00027236-00028283": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00015-00028285-00030152": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00016-00030154-00031839": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00017-00031839-00032113": "foreign", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00018-00032114-00033383": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00019-00033384-00033594": "foreign", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00020-00033595-00035122": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00021-00035123-00037935": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00022-00037936-00038033": "foreign", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00023-00038034-00038771": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00024-00038772-00040383": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00025-00040384-00040661": "foreign", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00026-00040662-00041625": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00027-00041626-00044646": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00028-00044647-00050483": "um", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00029-00050484-00051479": "foreign foreign", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00030-00051480-00053711": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00031-00053712-00055570": "do", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00032-00055571-00057254": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00033-00057255-00058111": "go", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00034-00058112-00059423": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00035-00059424-00061274": "so", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00036-00061275-00061942": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00037-00061944-00062182": "so", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00038-00062183-00064397": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00039-00064398-00067644": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00040-00067645-00069210": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00041-00069211-00069815": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00042-00069816-00071169": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00043-00071170-00073055": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00044-00073056-00073567": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00045-00073568-00073949": "so", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00046-00073950-00075782": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00047-00075783-00075984": "foreign", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00048-00075985-00082567": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00049-00082568-00082906": "hello", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00050-00082907-00083833": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00051-00083834-00086194": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00052-00086195-00086615": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00053-00086616-00089359": "no", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00054-00089360-00090535": "foreign", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00055-00090536-00091024": "foreign", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00056-00091025-00091718": "[Music]", "Wm-PM9pCzdM-00057-00091719-00091927": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "WmF1siQjfRM", "text": {"WmF1siQjfRM-00000-00000000-00000442": "live from Las Vegas it's the queue", "WmF1siQjfRM-00001-00000443-00000808": "covering Dell technologies world 2018", "WmF1siQjfRM-00002-00000809-00001094": "brought to you by Dell EMC and its", "WmF1siQjfRM-00003-00001095-00001676": "ecosystem partners and we are back live", "WmF1siQjfRM-00004-00001677-00001916": "here at Dell technologies world 2018", "WmF1siQjfRM-00005-00001917-00002201": "where the sands this week day one of", "WmF1siQjfRM-00006-00002202-00002396": "three days of coverage here on the cube", "WmF1siQjfRM-00007-00002397-00002593": "along with Stu minimun I'm John wall's", "WmF1siQjfRM-00008-00002594-00002767": "and this is really kind of the John", "WmF1siQjfRM-00009-00002768-00002850": "segment", "WmF1siQjfRM-00010-00002851-00003095": "John Kiriakou and John Siegel with us", "WmF1siQjfRM-00011-00003096-00003419": "John Greco is the CTO of the University", "WmF1siQjfRM-00012-00003420-00003590": "of Vermont Health Network John good to", "WmF1siQjfRM-00013-00003590-00003650": "see you sir", "WmF1siQjfRM-00014-00003651-00003869": "thank you thanks you bet and John Siegel", "WmF1siQjfRM-00015-00003870-00004138": "VP of Product Marketing Adel EMC John's", "WmF1siQjfRM-00016-00004139-00004352": "pleasure to have you aboard as well glad", "WmF1siQjfRM-00017-00004353-00004490": "to be here again all right let's talk", "WmF1siQjfRM-00018-00004491-00004694": "about P University if you all mean that", "WmF1siQjfRM-00019-00004695-00004835": "you I can imagine", "WmF1siQjfRM-00020-00004836-00005126": "health obviously critical data what's", "WmF1siQjfRM-00021-00005127-00005411": "your data center environment like and", "WmF1siQjfRM-00022-00005412-00005558": "how does the house cloud playing into", "WmF1siQjfRM-00023-00005559-00005809": "that right now we are a seven hospital", "WmF1siQjfRM-00024-00005810-00006104": "system with seven data centers managed", "WmF1siQjfRM-00025-00006105-00006395": "by seven different IT organizations so", "WmF1siQjfRM-00026-00006396-00006598": "the role I have is really how do we take", "WmF1siQjfRM-00027-00006600-00006784": "you still have hair too but I do but", "WmF1siQjfRM-00028-00006786-00006946": "every day it's getting thinner and", "WmF1siQjfRM-00029-00006947-00007076": "thinner and I'm going to be able to tell", "WmF1siQjfRM-00030-00007077-00007285": "with these cameras I hear what we're", "WmF1siQjfRM-00031-00007286-00007489": "trying to do is really start working as", "WmF1siQjfRM-00032-00007490-00007753": "one cohesive system give the patient the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00033-00007754-00007937": "same experience as they travel through", "WmF1siQjfRM-00034-00007938-00008128": "our system and how do we do that with", "WmF1siQjfRM-00035-00008129-00008324": "technology and what we're trying to do", "WmF1siQjfRM-00036-00008325-00008483": "is really simplify and standardize", "WmF1siQjfRM-00037-00008484-00008746": "everything we do consolidate and", "WmF1siQjfRM-00038-00008747-00008924": "centralize our data centers so we're", "WmF1siQjfRM-00039-00008925-00009099": "going from a seven data center", "WmF1siQjfRM-00040-00009100-00009398": "infrastructure growth to a two data", "WmF1siQjfRM-00041-00009399-00009662": "center platform one in New York and one", "WmF1siQjfRM-00042-00009663-00009896": "in Vermont but most likely over time", "WmF1siQjfRM-00043-00009897-00010114": "pushing as many of our workloads to the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00044-00010115-00010339": "cloud really creating a triangle where", "WmF1siQjfRM-00045-00010340-00010492": "you have your private cloud that has", "WmF1siQjfRM-00046-00010493-00010673": "rigor and resilience with our clinical", "WmF1siQjfRM-00047-00010674-00010939": "most critical workloads close or IT shop", "WmF1siQjfRM-00048-00010940-00011177": "and we leverage a lot of the non-trivial", "WmF1siQjfRM-00049-00011178-00011423": "non-value add applications into the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00050-00011424-00011674": "cloud yep John you throw it a term", "WmF1siQjfRM-00051-00011675-00011881": "private cloud yes you have defined for", "WmF1siQjfRM-00052-00011882-00012214": "us what that means to your organization", "WmF1siQjfRM-00053-00012215-00012469": "it's just like a public cloud like", "WmF1siQjfRM-00054-00012470-00012694": "Google Amazon or Microsoft Azure but", "WmF1siQjfRM-00055-00012695-00012853": "you're doing it in your local data", "WmF1siQjfRM-00056-00012854-00013084": "center itself so what we're doing at the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00057-00013085-00013309": "University of Vermont Health Network as", "WmF1siQjfRM-00058-00013310-00013546": "we're trying to make our private cloud", "WmF1siQjfRM-00059-00013547-00013762": "that's local in our data centers act and", "WmF1siQjfRM-00060-00013763-00014008": "become more of a private cloud look and", "WmF1siQjfRM-00061-00014009-00014185": "feel we understand that many of our", "WmF1siQjfRM-00062-00014186-00014380": "users are leveraging the public cloud", "WmF1siQjfRM-00063-00014381-00014635": "even in your home use so how do we bring", "WmF1siQjfRM-00064-00014636-00014838": "some of that into the private data", "WmF1siQjfRM-00065-00014840-00015069": "center that we own and manage but give", "WmF1siQjfRM-00066-00015071-00015247": "our users to look and feel of that", "WmF1siQjfRM-00067-00015247-00015580": "public cloud all right jumps eagle you", "WmF1siQjfRM-00068-00015581-00015738": "chuck it a little bit when I said", "WmF1siQjfRM-00069-00015740-00015856": "private cloud it's one of those things", "WmF1siQjfRM-00070-00015857-00016009": "we debated for a while we don't need to", "WmF1siQjfRM-00071-00016010-00016213": "get into semantics but underneath Dell", "WmF1siQjfRM-00072-00016213-00016405": "EMC provides some of the you know the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00073-00016406-00016660": "infrastructure platform for those maybe", "WmF1siQjfRM-00074-00016661-00016795": "give us a little bit of insight as to", "WmF1siQjfRM-00075-00016796-00016987": "you know what are yours you know as", "WmF1siQjfRM-00076-00016988-00017113": "we've talked about before cloud is an", "WmF1siQjfRM-00077-00017114-00017344": "operating model right not a place and I", "WmF1siQjfRM-00078-00017345-00017551": "think John and what he's done at the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00079-00017552-00017692": "University of Vermont Health Network", "WmF1siQjfRM-00080-00017693-00017986": "really I think shows that and it take it", "WmF1siQjfRM-00081-00017987-00018205": "takes a change agent by the way to not", "WmF1siQjfRM-00082-00018206-00018415": "just technology to do that I think you", "WmF1siQjfRM-00083-00018416-00018583": "know he's making it sound easy but he", "WmF1siQjfRM-00084-00018584-00018712": "can tell us about how he's done that but", "WmF1siQjfRM-00085-00018713-00019057": "it's a combination of technology how you", "WmF1siQjfRM-00086-00019058-00019186": "modernize the infrastructure but also", "WmF1siQjfRM-00087-00019187-00019336": "what are you doing to actually transform", "WmF1siQjfRM-00088-00019337-00019597": "that organization to deliver IT as a", "WmF1siQjfRM-00089-00019598-00019849": "service right because it's it this is", "WmF1siQjfRM-00090-00019850-00020056": "it's not just a plug-and-play you just", "WmF1siQjfRM-00091-00020057-00020332": "you know plug in a new infrastructure", "WmF1siQjfRM-00092-00020333-00020503": "product line and then boom it works", "WmF1siQjfRM-00093-00020504-00020728": "right it's not that simple absolutely we", "WmF1siQjfRM-00094-00020729-00020914": "want to really put a lot of our IT", "WmF1siQjfRM-00095-00020915-00021154": "talent into what I call above the value", "WmF1siQjfRM-00096-00021155-00021367": "line in my business that's closer to the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00097-00021368-00021646": "bedside the new IT is really enabling", "WmF1siQjfRM-00098-00021647-00021832": "the business to provide in my business", "WmF1siQjfRM-00099-00021833-00022042": "better care so how do we get them out of", "WmF1siQjfRM-00100-00022043-00022282": "the data center per se and into the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00101-00022283-00022462": "business to enable what they do each and", "WmF1siQjfRM-00102-00022463-00022660": "every day the way we do that is really", "WmF1siQjfRM-00103-00022661-00022860": "standardizing on a truthless", "WmF1siQjfRM-00104-00022861-00023149": "infrastructure like block rack and rail", "WmF1siQjfRM-00105-00023150-00023404": "and on top of that automating everything", "WmF1siQjfRM-00106-00023405-00023557": "we do with NIT from a workflow", "WmF1siQjfRM-00107-00023558-00023780": "perspective an example of real", "WmF1siQjfRM-00108-00023781-00023928": "example talk about the patient", "WmF1siQjfRM-00109-00023929-00024056": "experience you have seven hospitals", "WmF1siQjfRM-00110-00024057-00024305": "seven data centers seven sets of", "WmF1siQjfRM-00111-00024306-00024477": "patients if you will but are you talk", "WmF1siQjfRM-00112-00024478-00024633": "about as people migrate from him from", "WmF1siQjfRM-00113-00024634-00024764": "one healthcare facility to another", "WmF1siQjfRM-00114-00024765-00024978": "something's not going with them or what", "WmF1siQjfRM-00115-00024979-00025149": "what do you exactly are you trying to", "WmF1siQjfRM-00116-00025150-00025397": "improve in terms of real-life care for", "WmF1siQjfRM-00117-00025398-00025580": "people that that this migrations gonna", "WmF1siQjfRM-00118-00025581-00025893": "let you facility obsolete one of our", "WmF1siQjfRM-00119-00025894-00026069": "converged platforms we're running a", "WmF1siQjfRM-00120-00026070-00026249": "vendor neutral archive and it's going to", "WmF1siQjfRM-00121-00026250-00026462": "allow our patients anytime we have them", "WmF1siQjfRM-00122-00026463-00026739": "scan an image it immediately goes to a", "WmF1siQjfRM-00123-00026739-00026952": "central repository where any one of our", "WmF1siQjfRM-00124-00026952-00027168": "hospitals can then take a look at that", "WmF1siQjfRM-00125-00027169-00027351": "image and what you're going to see over", "WmF1siQjfRM-00126-00027352-00027515": "time is specialize in our seven", "WmF1siQjfRM-00127-00027516-00027827": "hospitals into certain treatments so if", "WmF1siQjfRM-00128-00027828-00028058": "we have a radiology department that we", "WmF1siQjfRM-00129-00028059-00028230": "want to spend send some of our patients", "WmF1siQjfRM-00130-00028231-00028380": "to we want to make sure they have the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00131-00028381-00028587": "data and are reading that data before", "WmF1siQjfRM-00132-00028588-00028785": "the patients there so the ability to", "WmF1siQjfRM-00133-00028786-00029010": "take the image once and read the image", "WmF1siQjfRM-00134-00029011-00029235": "while our patient is in transit to get", "WmF1siQjfRM-00135-00029236-00029436": "back here so when they arrive at that", "WmF1siQjfRM-00136-00029437-00029633": "hospital we are ready to take on that", "WmF1siQjfRM-00137-00029634-00029856": "patient and immediately provide them to", "WmF1siQjfRM-00138-00029857-00030068": "care they're therefore running on one", "WmF1siQjfRM-00139-00030069-00030318": "platform sharing that platform across", "WmF1siQjfRM-00140-00030319-00030518": "our seven hospital system so what", "WmF1siQjfRM-00141-00030519-00030717": "currently happens what's the situation", "WmF1siQjfRM-00142-00030718-00030900": "now for for a patient right now a", "WmF1siQjfRM-00143-00030901-00031056": "patient would get an image in one", "WmF1siQjfRM-00144-00031057-00031254": "Hospital travel to the other hospital", "WmF1siQjfRM-00145-00031255-00031398": "the image will not be there we would", "WmF1siQjfRM-00146-00031399-00031608": "then retake another image at that", "WmF1siQjfRM-00147-00031608-00031749": "hospital and go through the same", "WmF1siQjfRM-00148-00031750-00032030": "exercise so not only is a patient there", "WmF1siQjfRM-00149-00032031-00032246": "when they don't want to but we're going", "WmF1siQjfRM-00150-00032247-00032439": "through repetitive questioning songs", "WmF1siQjfRM-00151-00032439-00032733": "dance yeah and the outcome is a negative", "WmF1siQjfRM-00152-00032733-00032903": "patient experience", "WmF1siQjfRM-00153-00032904-00033188": "were avoiding through IT yeah you threw", "WmF1siQjfRM-00154-00033189-00033551": "out blocks rails and racks I recognize", "WmF1siQjfRM-00155-00033552-00033722": "those as you know that the Delhi MT", "WmF1siQjfRM-00156-00033723-00033929": "product well what does hyper-converged", "WmF1siQjfRM-00157-00033930-00034091": "infrastructure converged infrastructure", "WmF1siQjfRM-00158-00034092-00034283": "you know how does that impact what", "WmF1siQjfRM-00159-00034284-00034490": "you're doing and you know if a five five", "WmF1siQjfRM-00160-00034491-00034724": "five saw right you use some of each so", "WmF1siQjfRM-00161-00034725-00034937": "how do you sort that out you know how do", "WmF1siQjfRM-00162-00034938-00035060": "you integrate those pieces together", "WmF1siQjfRM-00163-00035061-00035252": "really which drives is the requirements", "WmF1siQjfRM-00164-00035253-00035450": "of the applications you're managing so", "WmF1siQjfRM-00165-00035451-00035666": "we do a deep dive with the applications", "WmF1siQjfRM-00166-00035667-00035912": "we take in and we decide based on the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00167-00035913-00036134": "requirements of that application which", "WmF1siQjfRM-00168-00036135-00036341": "of those three platforms run the best", "WmF1siQjfRM-00169-00036342-00036554": "what I've seen is a lot of our critical", "WmF1siQjfRM-00170-00036555-00036839": "mission critical have to keep up 24/7", "WmF1siQjfRM-00171-00036840-00037184": "365 workloads we are leveraging the VX", "WmF1siQjfRM-00172-00037185-00037394": "block for a lot of that we're seeing a", "WmF1siQjfRM-00173-00037395-00037586": "lot of those medium to low end workloads", "WmF1siQjfRM-00174-00037587-00037748": "on rack or rail where we have the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00175-00037749-00037945": "ability to really scale out quick and", "WmF1siQjfRM-00176-00037946-00038189": "dynamically with those smaller type", "WmF1siQjfRM-00177-00038190-00038504": "applications that are many in size where", "WmF1siQjfRM-00178-00038505-00038684": "we're trying to standardize with our", "WmF1siQjfRM-00179-00038685-00038912": "clinical ones more on our block so", "WmF1siQjfRM-00180-00038913-00039077": "really the application requirement", "WmF1siQjfRM-00181-00039078-00039305": "drives where that application sits in", "WmF1siQjfRM-00182-00039306-00039587": "our environment right so judge on how", "WmF1siQjfRM-00183-00039588-00039839": "the customers like John you know manage", "WmF1siQjfRM-00184-00039840-00040040": "that this environment then I mean you", "WmF1siQjfRM-00185-00040041-00040256": "know we want things to get simpler and", "WmF1siQjfRM-00186-00040257-00040508": "you know even if they've got to some", "WmF1siQjfRM-00187-00040509-00040739": "various products of yours how do we pull", "WmF1siQjfRM-00188-00040740-00040904": "them all together well as you know I", "WmF1siQjfRM-00189-00040905-00041114": "think the promise of converged in", "WmF1siQjfRM-00190-00041115-00041375": "hyper-converged is the simplify IT right", "WmF1siQjfRM-00191-00041376-00041510": "and I think this is I think this is what", "WmF1siQjfRM-00192-00041511-00041717": "you see in here so a lot of it is", "WmF1siQjfRM-00193-00041718-00041942": "automating everything or at least", "WmF1siQjfRM-00194-00041943-00042068": "helping to really simplify everything", "WmF1siQjfRM-00195-00042069-00042473": "from deployment right to managing the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00196-00042474-00042767": "entire infrastructure as one as well as", "WmF1siQjfRM-00197-00042768-00042953": "sustaining it lifecycle managing it is", "WmF1siQjfRM-00198-00042954-00043014": "one", "WmF1siQjfRM-00199-00043015-00043149": "right and actually simplifying the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00200-00043150-00043341": "upgrade path because I think that's that", "WmF1siQjfRM-00201-00043342-00043458": "could be the most time-consuming thing", "WmF1siQjfRM-00202-00043459-00043614": "right but that's that's the promise I", "WmF1siQjfRM-00203-00043615-00043749": "mean the promise of converged", "WmF1siQjfRM-00204-00043750-00043938": "infrastructure 70 years ago when we came", "WmF1siQjfRM-00205-00043939-00044085": "out with VX block or V block at a time", "WmF1siQjfRM-00206-00044086-00044322": "it was about you know how do we get help", "WmF1siQjfRM-00207-00044323-00044523": "customers like you get out of the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00208-00044524-00044730": "infrastructure of business day to day", "WmF1siQjfRM-00209-00044731-00044901": "that month is the mundane business if", "WmF1siQjfRM-00210-00044902-00045128": "you will so you can spend more time", "WmF1siQjfRM-00211-00045129-00045381": "really up leveling your staff to do", "WmF1siQjfRM-00212-00045382-00045654": "other more business critical you know", "WmF1siQjfRM-00213-00045655-00045882": "mission-critical task is that there it", "WmF1siQjfRM-00214-00045883-00046089": "is we have to I think we're being asked", "WmF1siQjfRM-00215-00046090-00046248": "to move the needle within the business", "WmF1siQjfRM-00216-00046249-00046488": "as Michael Dell says the business", "WmF1siQjfRM-00217-00046489-00046755": "strategy really is the IT strategy and", "WmF1siQjfRM-00218-00046756-00046953": "for that to happen we really have to", "WmF1siQjfRM-00219-00046954-00047238": "bring our IT talent up the stack into", "WmF1siQjfRM-00220-00047239-00047427": "where it's really enabling the business", "WmF1siQjfRM-00221-00047428-00047598": "and that's usually at that application", "WmF1siQjfRM-00222-00047599-00047853": "layer not at that infrastructure we want", "WmF1siQjfRM-00223-00047854-00047997": "to leverage our partners like Dell", "WmF1siQjfRM-00224-00047998-00048231": "technologies and their technology to", "WmF1siQjfRM-00225-00048232-00048495": "really run the business for us while RIT", "WmF1siQjfRM-00226-00048496-00048828": "is more in the transformative innovative", "WmF1siQjfRM-00227-00048829-00049101": "and growth of that business I love you", "WmF1siQjfRM-00228-00049102-00049287": "started out with the seven data centers", "WmF1siQjfRM-00229-00049288-00049491": "in the seven and seven and seven what's", "WmF1siQjfRM-00230-00049492-00049668": "the after state you know how does your", "WmF1siQjfRM-00231-00049669-00049965": "IT team you know look at your operations", "WmF1siQjfRM-00232-00049966-00050130": "in your technology what we're doing is", "WmF1siQjfRM-00233-00050131-00050277": "we're trying to create one shared", "WmF1siQjfRM-00234-00050278-00050469": "service model even though we'll have", "WmF1siQjfRM-00235-00050470-00050739": "people sitting at the seven hospitals we", "WmF1siQjfRM-00236-00050740-00050922": "are all working in unison we're all", "WmF1siQjfRM-00237-00050923-00051144": "leveraging the same workflows the same", "WmF1siQjfRM-00238-00051145-00051414": "technology this gains the same skill set", "WmF1siQjfRM-00239-00051415-00051615": "so in essence we become a dynamic IT", "WmF1siQjfRM-00240-00051616-00051813": "shop that I can leverage wherever", "WmF1siQjfRM-00241-00051814-00052038": "there's a need I can take IT personnel", "WmF1siQjfRM-00242-00052039-00052209": "from one hospital and have that move to", "WmF1siQjfRM-00243-00052210-00052395": "another and it's the same look and feel", "WmF1siQjfRM-00244-00052396-00052611": "just like the experience we want to give", "WmF1siQjfRM-00245-00052612-00052797": "our users the same look and feel as they", "WmF1siQjfRM-00246-00052798-00053105": "travel we want to do the same for IT one", "WmF1siQjfRM-00247-00053107-00053397": "logical shared service vision of a", "WmF1siQjfRM-00248-00053398-00053604": "department that offers services to our", "WmF1siQjfRM-00249-00053604-00053666": "Hospital", "WmF1siQjfRM-00250-00053667-00053973": "that they consume all like for life and", "WmF1siQjfRM-00251-00053974-00054126": "John just touched on this he was talking", "WmF1siQjfRM-00252-00054127-00054312": "about the mundane right and removing", "WmF1siQjfRM-00253-00054313-00054605": "that and letting you basically say get a", "WmF1siQjfRM-00254-00054607-00054744": "little more creative but if they take on", "WmF1siQjfRM-00255-00054745-00055007": "a different set of challenges so how do", "WmF1siQjfRM-00256-00055008-00055290": "you work with your with your staff in", "WmF1siQjfRM-00257-00055291-00055469": "order to get them to change that mindset", "WmF1siQjfRM-00258-00055470-00055821": "so that they can shift because it's not", "WmF1siQjfRM-00259-00055822-00056054": "just you at the top you've got to plant", "WmF1siQjfRM-00260-00056055-00056262": "this vision right my people so I'm", "WmF1siQjfRM-00261-00056263-00056417": "taking this away from you this is what I", "WmF1siQjfRM-00262-00056419-00056448": "do", "WmF1siQjfRM-00263-00056449-00056640": "right well now but we're gonna take what", "WmF1siQjfRM-00264-00056641-00056823": "you know and we're gonna let you do", "WmF1siQjfRM-00265-00056824-00057012": "something else you got to get him there", "WmF1siQjfRM-00266-00057013-00057263": "so four people may be watching that that", "WmF1siQjfRM-00267-00057264-00057569": "share that challenge maybe what would", "WmF1siQjfRM-00268-00057570-00057719": "you say to them about how you've done", "WmF1siQjfRM-00269-00057720-00057944": "that well as John mentioned you need a", "WmF1siQjfRM-00270-00057945-00058197": "change agent need a champion most likely", "WmF1siQjfRM-00271-00058198-00058353": "at the senior level that's gonna really", "WmF1siQjfRM-00272-00058354-00058584": "ride through this journey through the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00273-00058585-00058773": "ebbs and flows up the challenges you", "WmF1siQjfRM-00274-00058774-00058947": "have to deal with and when you look at", "WmF1siQjfRM-00275-00058948-00059126": "people process technology as you", "WmF1siQjfRM-00276-00059127-00059294": "mentioned changing the mind of a person", "WmF1siQjfRM-00277-00059295-00059499": "is probably the hardest thing to do up", "WmF1siQjfRM-00278-00059500-00059721": "to three but what we're trying to do is", "WmF1siQjfRM-00279-00059722-00060017": "really change one mind at a time but can", "WmF1siQjfRM-00280-00060019-00060242": "change one mine at a time persistently", "WmF1siQjfRM-00281-00060244-00060450": "as a champion of where we're going and", "WmF1siQjfRM-00282-00060451-00060741": "answer the why and the awareness and the", "WmF1siQjfRM-00283-00060741-00060990": "desire of someone wanting to go on that", "WmF1siQjfRM-00284-00060991-00061226": "journey with us on behalf of that", "WmF1siQjfRM-00285-00061227-00061551": "patient each and every day is how we're", "WmF1siQjfRM-00286-00061552-00061866": "gonna do it case by case opportunity by", "WmF1siQjfRM-00287-00061866-00062148": "opportunity mind by mind we will", "WmF1siQjfRM-00288-00062149-00062424": "eventually get them to look at what", "WmF1siQjfRM-00289-00062425-00062634": "we're doing and understand this is where", "WmF1siQjfRM-00290-00062635-00062865": "I want IT to be that's how we're gonna", "WmF1siQjfRM-00291-00062866-00063138": "do it I think the University of Vermont", "WmF1siQjfRM-00292-00063139-00063357": "has the right guy for the job", "WmF1siQjfRM-00293-00063358-00063603": "John Kirby and John and John both of you", "WmF1siQjfRM-00294-00063604-00063753": "thanks for being with us here we", "WmF1siQjfRM-00295-00063754-00063917": "appreciate you very much good luck down", "WmF1siQjfRM-00296-00063919-00064142": "the road well that's it wrapping up our", "WmF1siQjfRM-00297-00064144-00064284": "coverage here on the cube thanks for", "WmF1siQjfRM-00298-00064285-00064437": "joining us for day one we are back", "WmF1siQjfRM-00299-00064438-00064686": "tomorrow days two and three live here at", "WmF1siQjfRM-00300-00064687-00064884": "the sands until then force two minimun", "WmF1siQjfRM-00301-00064885-00065069": "and the rest of our Q crew have a good", "WmF1siQjfRM-00302-00065070-00065286": "night"}}, {"audio_id": "WmGPhpEQ598", "text": {"WmGPhpEQ598-00000-00000043-00000374": "Hades Greek hides Hades hides hides in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00001-00000375-00000553": "the ancient Greek religion and myth is", "WmGPhpEQ598-00002-00000554-00000707": "the god of the dead and the king of the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00003-00000708-00000767": "underworld", "WmGPhpEQ598-00004-00000768-00000975": "with which his name became synonymous", "WmGPhpEQ598-00005-00000976-00001237": "Hades was the eldest son of Cronus and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00006-00001238-00001424": "Rhea although the last son regurgitated", "WmGPhpEQ598-00007-00001425-00001757": "by his father he and his brothers Zeus", "WmGPhpEQ598-00008-00001757-00001942": "and Poseidon defeated their father's", "WmGPhpEQ598-00009-00001943-00002134": "generation of gods the Titans and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00010-00002135-00002447": "claimed rulership over the cosmos Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00011-00002448-00002672": "received the underworld Zeus the sky and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00012-00002673-00002867": "Poseidon the sea with the solid earth", "WmGPhpEQ598-00013-00002868-00003098": "along the province of Gaia available to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00014-00003099-00003386": "all three concurrently Hades was often", "WmGPhpEQ598-00015-00003386-00003533": "portrayed with his three-headed guard", "WmGPhpEQ598-00016-00003534-00003899": "dog Cerberus the Etruscan god ADA and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00017-00003900-00004111": "the Roman gods dis Pater and orcas were", "WmGPhpEQ598-00018-00004112-00004322": "eventually taken as equivalent to Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00019-00004323-00004568": "and merged into Pluto a Latinization of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00020-00004569-00004799": "Plowden Greek Plowden Plowden itself a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00021-00004800-00005529": "euphemistic title often given to Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00022-00005530-00006218": "topic name the origin of Hades name is", "WmGPhpEQ598-00023-00006219-00006428": "uncertain but has generally been seen as", "WmGPhpEQ598-00024-00006429-00006709": "meaning the unseen one since antiquity", "WmGPhpEQ598-00025-00006711-00006985": "an extensive section of Plato's dialogue", "WmGPhpEQ598-00026-00006986-00007192": "Cratylus is devoted to the etymology of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00027-00007193-00007391": "the gods name in which Socrates is", "WmGPhpEQ598-00028-00007392-00007598": "arguing for a folk etymology not from", "WmGPhpEQ598-00029-00007598-00007970": "unseen but from his knowledge I deny of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00030-00007970-00008278": "all noble things modern linguists have", "WmGPhpEQ598-00031-00008279-00008485": "proposed the proto Greek form asterisk", "WmGPhpEQ598-00032-00008486-00008849": "Awards unseen the earliest attested form", "WmGPhpEQ598-00033-00008850-00009038": "is aids aids which lacks the proposed", "WmGPhpEQ598-00034-00009039-00009338": "die gamma Martin Litchfield West argues", "WmGPhpEQ598-00035-00009339-00009509": "instead for an original meaning of the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00036-00009510-00009821": "one who presides over meeting up from", "WmGPhpEQ598-00037-00009822-00010160": "the universality of death in Homeric and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00038-00010161-00010403": "ionic Greek he was known as aids other", "WmGPhpEQ598-00039-00010404-00010642": "poetic variations of the name include a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00040-00010643-00010831": "dounia's a dounia's and the inflected", "WmGPhpEQ598-00041-00010832-00011141": "forms a loss a das gen IE d IE d dat and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00042-00011142-00011426": "Aida Aida a cc whose reconstructed", "WmGPhpEQ598-00043-00011427-00011635": "nominative case asterisk eyes asterisk", "WmGPhpEQ598-00044-00011636-00011956": "eyes is however not attested the name as", "WmGPhpEQ598-00045-00011957-00012142": "it came to be known in classical times", "WmGPhpEQ598-00046-00012143-00012434": "was hides but later the iota became", "WmGPhpEQ598-00047-00012435-00012659": "silent then a subscript marking hides", "WmGPhpEQ598-00048-00012660-00012844": "and finally omitted entirely at is", "WmGPhpEQ598-00049-00012845-00013021": "perhaps from fear of pronouncing his", "WmGPhpEQ598-00050-00013022-00013291": "name around the 5th century BC the Greek", "WmGPhpEQ598-00051-00013293-00013394": "started referring", "WmGPhpEQ598-00052-00013396-00013622": "Hades as Pavan Pavan Pavan with a root", "WmGPhpEQ598-00053-00013624-00013887": "meaning wealthy considering that from", "WmGPhpEQ598-00054-00013888-00014127": "the abode below ie the soil come riches", "WmGPhpEQ598-00055-00014128-00014419": "deg fertile crops medals and so on", "WmGPhpEQ598-00056-00014421-00014676": "platon became the Roman god who both", "WmGPhpEQ598-00057-00014677-00014853": "rules the underworld and distributed", "WmGPhpEQ598-00058-00014854-00015111": "riches from below this deity was a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00059-00015112-00015318": "mixture of the Greek god Hades in the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00060-00015319-00015579": "LFC nyan icon plateaus and from this he", "WmGPhpEQ598-00061-00015580-00015794": "also received a priestess which was not", "WmGPhpEQ598-00062-00015796-00016059": "previously practiced in Greece more", "WmGPhpEQ598-00063-00016060-00016257": "elaborate names of the same genre were", "WmGPhpEQ598-00064-00016258-00016470": "plateaued Oats plateaued oats or plateau", "WmGPhpEQ598-00065-00016471-00016689": "dota plateau dota meaning giver of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00066-00016690-00016965": "wealth epithets of Hades include ages", "WmGPhpEQ598-00067-00016966-00017181": "and ages and Ross and age silos age", "WmGPhpEQ598-00068-00017182-00017552": "silos both from a go at lead carry-all", "WmGPhpEQ598-00069-00017553-00018102": "fetch and Anna and man or Lao men all", "WmGPhpEQ598-00070-00018103-00018417": "people describing Hades as the God who", "WmGPhpEQ598-00071-00018418-00018675": "carries away all makanda uses the form", "WmGPhpEQ598-00072-00018676-00018966": "haggis alas negative he was also", "WmGPhpEQ598-00073-00018967-00019146": "referred to as Zeus carriage Tonio's", "WmGPhpEQ598-00074-00019147-00019398": "zeus cash Tonio's meaning the zeus of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00075-00019399-00019647": "the underworld by those avoiding his", "WmGPhpEQ598-00076-00019648-00019836": "actual name as he had complete control", "WmGPhpEQ598-00077-00019837-00021335": "over the underworld topic mythology", "WmGPhpEQ598-00078-00021336-00021962": "topic early years in Greek mythology", "WmGPhpEQ598-00079-00021963-00022221": "Hades the god of the underworld was the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00080-00022222-00022428": "firstborn son of the Titans Cronus and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00081-00022429-00022683": "Rhea he had three older sisters", "WmGPhpEQ598-00082-00022684-00022938": "Hestia Demeter and Hera as well as a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00083-00022939-00023094": "younger brother Poseidon", "WmGPhpEQ598-00084-00023095-00023250": "all of whom had been swallowed whole by", "WmGPhpEQ598-00085-00023251-00023450": "their father as soon as they were born", "WmGPhpEQ598-00086-00023451-00023706": "Zeus was the youngest child and through", "WmGPhpEQ598-00087-00023707-00023865": "the machinations of their mother", "WmGPhpEQ598-00088-00023866-00024042": "Rhea he was the only one that had", "WmGPhpEQ598-00089-00024043-00024264": "escaped this fate upon reaching", "WmGPhpEQ598-00090-00024265-00024339": "adulthood", "WmGPhpEQ598-00091-00024340-00024528": "Zeus managed to force his father to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00092-00024529-00024774": "disgorge his siblings after their", "WmGPhpEQ598-00093-00024775-00024999": "release the six younger gods along with", "WmGPhpEQ598-00094-00025000-00025194": "allies they managed together challenged", "WmGPhpEQ598-00095-00025195-00025347": "the elder gods for power in the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00096-00025348-00025689": "Titanomachy a divine war the war lasted", "WmGPhpEQ598-00097-00025689-00025872": "for ten years and ended with the victory", "WmGPhpEQ598-00098-00025873-00026112": "of the younger gods following their", "WmGPhpEQ598-00099-00026113-00026315": "victory according to a single famous", "WmGPhpEQ598-00100-00026316-00026673": "passage in the Iliad book 15 laying 187", "WmGPhpEQ598-00101-00026674-00026787": "293", "WmGPhpEQ598-00102-00026788-00026967": "ladies and his two brothers beside an", "WmGPhpEQ598-00103-00026968-00027173": "and Zeus drew lots for realms to rule", "WmGPhpEQ598-00104-00027174-00027387": "Zeus received the sky", "WmGPhpEQ598-00105-00027388-00027591": "Poseidon received the Seas and Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00106-00027592-00027770": "received the underworld the unseen realm", "WmGPhpEQ598-00107-00027772-00027981": "to which the souls of the dead go upon", "WmGPhpEQ598-00108-00027982-00028158": "leaving the world as well as any and all", "WmGPhpEQ598-00109-00028158-00028407": "things beneath the earth some myths", "WmGPhpEQ598-00110-00028408-00028614": "suggest that Hades was dissatisfied with", "WmGPhpEQ598-00111-00028614-00028818": "his Turner but had no choice and moved", "WmGPhpEQ598-00112-00028819-00028911": "to his new realm", "WmGPhpEQ598-00113-00028912-00029091": "Hades obtained his wife and Queen", "WmGPhpEQ598-00114-00029092-00029270": "Persephone through abduction at the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00115-00029272-00029532": "behest of Zeus this myth is the most", "WmGPhpEQ598-00116-00029533-00029748": "important one Hades takes part in it", "WmGPhpEQ598-00117-00029749-00029952": "also connected the LFC nyan mysteries", "WmGPhpEQ598-00118-00029952-00030150": "with the Olympian Pantheon particularly", "WmGPhpEQ598-00119-00030151-00030324": "is represented in the Homeric hymn to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00120-00030325-00030549": "Demeter which is the oldest story of the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00121-00030550-00030752": "abduction most likely dating back to the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00122-00030754-00031080": "beginning of the sixth century BC Helios", "WmGPhpEQ598-00123-00031081-00031283": "told the grieving Demeter that Hades was", "WmGPhpEQ598-00124-00031285-00031497": "not unworthy as a consort for Persephone", "WmGPhpEQ598-00125-00031498-00031827": "a dounia's the ruler of many is no", "WmGPhpEQ598-00126-00031827-00031998": "unfitting husband among the deathless", "WmGPhpEQ598-00127-00031999-00032172": "gods for your child being your own", "WmGPhpEQ598-00128-00032173-00032367": "brother and born of the same stock also", "WmGPhpEQ598-00129-00032368-00032598": "for honor he has that third share which", "WmGPhpEQ598-00130-00032599-00032778": "he received when division was made at", "WmGPhpEQ598-00131-00032779-00032955": "the first and his appointed Lord of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00132-00032956-00033738": "those among whom he dwells topic god of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00133-00033739-00034286": "underworld despite modern kana", "WmGPhpEQ598-00134-00034287-00034499": "death is evil Hades was actually more", "WmGPhpEQ598-00135-00034500-00034732": "altruistically in kind in mythology", "WmGPhpEQ598-00136-00034733-00034987": "Hades was often portrayed as passive", "WmGPhpEQ598-00137-00034988-00035174": "rather than evil his role was often", "WmGPhpEQ598-00138-00035175-00035440": "maintaining relative balance that said", "WmGPhpEQ598-00139-00035441-00035657": "he was also depicted as cold and stern", "WmGPhpEQ598-00140-00035658-00035870": "and he held all of his subjects equally", "WmGPhpEQ598-00141-00035871-00036125": "accountable to his laws any other", "WmGPhpEQ598-00142-00036126-00036278": "individual aspects of his personality", "WmGPhpEQ598-00143-00036279-00036527": "are not given as Greeks refrained from", "WmGPhpEQ598-00144-00036528-00036680": "giving him much thought to avoid", "WmGPhpEQ598-00145-00036681-00036850": "attracting his attention", "WmGPhpEQ598-00146-00036851-00037127": "Hades ruled the dead assisted by others", "WmGPhpEQ598-00147-00037128-00037400": "over whom he had complete authority the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00148-00037401-00037610": "house of Hades was described as full of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00149-00037611-00037853": "guests though he rarely left the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00150-00037854-00038071": "underworld he cared little about what", "WmGPhpEQ598-00151-00038072-00038234": "happened in the world above as his", "WmGPhpEQ598-00152-00038235-00038429": "primary attention was ensuring none of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00153-00038430-00038681": "his subjects ever left he strictly", "WmGPhpEQ598-00154-00038682-00038896": "forbade his subjects to leave his domain", "WmGPhpEQ598-00155-00038897-00039059": "and would become quite enraged when", "WmGPhpEQ598-00156-00039060-00039248": "anyone tried to leave or if someone", "WmGPhpEQ598-00157-00039249-00039431": "tried to steal the souls from his realm", "WmGPhpEQ598-00158-00039432-00039715": "his Roth was equally terrible for anyone", "WmGPhpEQ598-00159-00039716-00039890": "who tried to cheat death or otherwise", "WmGPhpEQ598-00160-00039891-00040093": "crossed him as Sisyphus and Puri first", "WmGPhpEQ598-00161-00040094-00040334": "found out to their sorrow while usually", "WmGPhpEQ598-00162-00040335-00040562": "indifferent to his subjects Hades was", "WmGPhpEQ598-00163-00040563-00040748": "very focused on the punishment of these", "WmGPhpEQ598-00164-00040749-00040967": "two people particularly Puri first as he", "WmGPhpEQ598-00165-00040968-00041135": "entered the underworld in an attempt to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00166-00041136-00041300": "steal Persephone for himself and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00167-00041301-00041540": "consequently was forced onto their chair", "WmGPhpEQ598-00168-00041541-00041821": "of forgetfulness another myth is about", "WmGPhpEQ598-00169-00041822-00041993": "the Greek god Asclepius who was", "WmGPhpEQ598-00170-00041994-00042218": "originally a demigod son of Apollo and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00171-00042219-00042542": "coronis a Thessalian princess during his", "WmGPhpEQ598-00172-00042543-00042746": "lifetime he became a famous and talented", "WmGPhpEQ598-00173-00042747-00042946": "physician who eventually was able to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00174-00042947-00043211": "bring the dead back to life feeling", "WmGPhpEQ598-00175-00043212-00043415": "cheated Plowden persuaded Zeus to kill", "WmGPhpEQ598-00176-00043416-00043667": "him with a thunderbolt after his death", "WmGPhpEQ598-00177-00043668-00043846": "he was brought to Olympus where he", "WmGPhpEQ598-00178-00043847-00044132": "became a god Hades was only depicted", "WmGPhpEQ598-00179-00044133-00044315": "outside of the underworld once in myth", "WmGPhpEQ598-00180-00044316-00044471": "and even that is believed to have been", "WmGPhpEQ598-00181-00044472-00044662": "an instance where he had just left the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00182-00044663-00044831": "gates of the underworld which was when", "WmGPhpEQ598-00183-00044832-00045035": "Heracles shot him with an arrow as Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00184-00045036-00045194": "was attempting to defend the city of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00185-00045195-00045271": "plyers", "WmGPhpEQ598-00186-00045272-00045560": "after he was shot however he traveled to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00187-00045561-00045865": "Olympus to heal besides Heracles the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00188-00045866-00046067": "only other living people who ventured to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00189-00046068-00046304": "the underworld were also heroes Odysseus", "WmGPhpEQ598-00190-00046305-00046546": "and is accompanied by the Sibyl Orpheus", "WmGPhpEQ598-00191-00046547-00046781": "who Hades showed uncharacteristic mercy", "WmGPhpEQ598-00192-00046782-00046979": "towards at Persephone's persuasion who", "WmGPhpEQ598-00193-00046980-00047144": "was moved by Orpheus music", "WmGPhpEQ598-00194-00047145-00047342": "Theseus with Pyrrhus and in a late", "WmGPhpEQ598-00195-00047343-00047561": "romance psyche none of them were pleased", "WmGPhpEQ598-00196-00047562-00047681": "with what they witnessed in the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00197-00047682-00047942": "realm of the Dead in particular the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00198-00047943-00048170": "Greek war hero Achilles whom Odysseus", "WmGPhpEQ598-00199-00048171-00048760": "conjured with a blood libation said", "WmGPhpEQ598-00200-00048761-00049415": "topic Persephone the consort of Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00201-00049416-00049598": "was Persephone daughter of Zeus and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00202-00049599-00049892": "Demeter Persephone did not submit to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00203-00049893-00050114": "Hades willingly but was abducted by him", "WmGPhpEQ598-00204-00050115-00050294": "while picking flowers in the fields of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00205-00050295-00050585": "Nysa her father Zeus had previously", "WmGPhpEQ598-00206-00050586-00050804": "given Persephone to Hades to be his wife", "WmGPhpEQ598-00207-00050805-00051020": "as is stated in the very first lines of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00208-00051021-00051311": "the Homeric hymn to Demeter in protest", "WmGPhpEQ598-00209-00051312-00051515": "of his act Demeter cast a curse on the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00210-00051516-00051691": "land and there was a great famine though", "WmGPhpEQ598-00211-00051692-00051920": "one by one the gods came to request she", "WmGPhpEQ598-00212-00051921-00052115": "lifted lest mankind perish and caused", "WmGPhpEQ598-00213-00052116-00052262": "the gods to be deprived of their", "WmGPhpEQ598-00214-00052263-00052475": "receiving gifts and sacrifices Demeter", "WmGPhpEQ598-00215-00052476-00052619": "asserted that the earth would remain", "WmGPhpEQ598-00216-00052620-00052825": "barren until she saw her daughter again", "WmGPhpEQ598-00217-00052826-00053116": "Zeus then sends for his son Hermes and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00218-00053117-00053279": "instructs him to go down to the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00219-00053279-00053453": "underworld in hopes that he may be able", "WmGPhpEQ598-00220-00053454-00053680": "to convince Hades to allow Persephone to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00221-00053682-00053873": "return to Earth so that Demeter might", "WmGPhpEQ598-00222-00053874-00054065": "see Persephone and caused the famine to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00223-00054066-00054359": "stop Hermes obeys and goes down to Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00224-00054360-00054587": "realm wherein he finds Hades seated upon", "WmGPhpEQ598-00225-00054588-00054829": "a couch Persephone seated next to him", "WmGPhpEQ598-00226-00054829-00055117": "Hermes relays Zeus message and Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00227-00055119-00055478": "complies saying go now Persephone to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00228-00055479-00055712": "your dark robe mother go and feel kindly", "WmGPhpEQ598-00229-00055713-00055898": "in your heart towards me be not so", "WmGPhpEQ598-00230-00055899-00056116": "exceedingly cast down for I shall be no", "WmGPhpEQ598-00231-00056117-00056276": "unfitting husband for you among the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00232-00056277-00056453": "deathless gods that AM own brother to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00233-00056454-00056729": "father Zeus and while you are here you", "WmGPhpEQ598-00234-00056729-00056924": "shall rule all that lives and moves and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00235-00056925-00057091": "shall have the greatest rights among the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00236-00057092-00057290": "deathless gods those who defraud you and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00237-00057291-00057464": "do not appease your power with offerings", "WmGPhpEQ598-00238-00057465-00057655": "reverently performing rights and paying", "WmGPhpEQ598-00239-00057657-00057940": "fit gifts shall be punished forevermore", "WmGPhpEQ598-00240-00057941-00058204": "afterwards hades readies his chariot but", "WmGPhpEQ598-00241-00058205-00058417": "not before he secretly gives Persephone", "WmGPhpEQ598-00242-00058419-00058625": "a pomegranate seed to eat hermes takes", "WmGPhpEQ598-00243-00058626-00058811": "the reins and he and Persephone make", "WmGPhpEQ598-00244-00058812-00058994": "their way to the earth above coming to a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00245-00058995-00059204": "halt in front of Demeter's temple at LF", "WmGPhpEQ598-00246-00059204-00059391": "sees where the goddess has been waiting", "WmGPhpEQ598-00247-00059392-00059654": "Demeter and Persephone run towards each", "WmGPhpEQ598-00248-00059654-00059870": "other and embrace one another happy that", "WmGPhpEQ598-00249-00059871-00060091": "they are reunited Demeter", "WmGPhpEQ598-00250-00060092-00060299": "however suspects that Persephone may", "WmGPhpEQ598-00251-00060300-00060452": "have eaten food while down in the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00252-00060453-00060614": "underworld and so she questions", "WmGPhpEQ598-00253-00060615-00060896": "Persephone saying my child", "WmGPhpEQ598-00254-00060897-00061061": "tell me surely you have not taste", "WmGPhpEQ598-00255-00061062-00061319": "did any food while you were below speak", "WmGPhpEQ598-00256-00061320-00061504": "out and hide nothing but let us both", "WmGPhpEQ598-00257-00061505-00061741": "know for if you have not you shall come", "WmGPhpEQ598-00258-00061742-00061946": "back from loathly Hades and live with me", "WmGPhpEQ598-00259-00061947-00062153": "and your father the dark clouded son of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00260-00062154-00062317": "Kronos and be honored by all the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00261-00062319-00062504": "deathless gods but if you have tasted", "WmGPhpEQ598-00262-00062504-00062708": "food you must go back again beneath the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00263-00062709-00062882": "secret places of the earth there did", "WmGPhpEQ598-00264-00062883-00063062": "well a third part of the seasons every", "WmGPhpEQ598-00265-00063063-00063254": "year yet for the two parts you shall be", "WmGPhpEQ598-00266-00063254-00063509": "with me and the other deathless gods but", "WmGPhpEQ598-00267-00063510-00063644": "when the earth shall bloom with the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00268-00063645-00063845": "fragrant flowers of spring in every kind", "WmGPhpEQ598-00269-00063846-00064010": "then from the realm of darkness and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00270-00064011-00064190": "gloom thou shalt come up once more to be", "WmGPhpEQ598-00271-00064191-00064469": "a wonder for gods and mortal men and now", "WmGPhpEQ598-00272-00064470-00064640": "tell me how he wrapped you away to the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00273-00064641-00064829": "realm of darkness and gloom and by what", "WmGPhpEQ598-00274-00064829-00064979": "trick did the strong host of many", "WmGPhpEQ598-00275-00064979-00065264": "beguile you Persephone does admit that", "WmGPhpEQ598-00276-00065265-00065444": "she ate the food of the dead as she", "WmGPhpEQ598-00277-00065445-00065615": "tells Demeter that Hades gave her a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00278-00065616-00065851": "pomegranate seed and forced her to EDA", "WmGPhpEQ598-00279-00065852-00066080": "Persephone's eating the pomegranate seed", "WmGPhpEQ598-00280-00066081-00066251": "binds her to Hades in the underworld", "WmGPhpEQ598-00281-00066252-00066530": "much to the dismay of Demeter zeus", "WmGPhpEQ598-00282-00066531-00066758": "however had previously proposed a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00283-00066759-00066950": "compromise to which all parties had", "WmGPhpEQ598-00284-00066951-00067133": "agreed of the year Persephone would", "WmGPhpEQ598-00285-00067134-00067325": "spend one third with her husband it is", "WmGPhpEQ598-00286-00067326-00067535": "during this time when Persephone is down", "WmGPhpEQ598-00287-00067536-00067706": "in the underworld with her husband that", "WmGPhpEQ598-00288-00067707-00067925": "winter falls upon the earth an aspect of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00289-00067926-00068714": "sadness and mourning topic Theseus and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00290-00068715-00069308": "PFS Theseus and Puri fest pledged to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00291-00069309-00069491": "kidnap and marry daughters of Zeus", "WmGPhpEQ598-00292-00069492-00069710": "Theseus chose Helen and together they", "WmGPhpEQ598-00293-00069711-00069899": "kidnapped her and decided to hold on to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00294-00069900-00070108": "her until she was old enough to marry", "WmGPhpEQ598-00295-00070109-00070361": "parathas chose Persephone they left", "WmGPhpEQ598-00296-00070362-00070574": "Helen with Theseus mother III and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00297-00070575-00070717": "traveled to the underworld", "WmGPhpEQ598-00298-00070718-00070967": "Hades knew of their plan to capture his", "WmGPhpEQ598-00299-00070968-00071147": "wife so he pretended to offer them", "WmGPhpEQ598-00300-00071148-00071375": "hospitality instead a feast as soon as", "WmGPhpEQ598-00301-00071376-00071483": "the pair sat down", "WmGPhpEQ598-00302-00071484-00071663": "snakes coiled around their feet and held", "WmGPhpEQ598-00303-00071664-00071936": "him there Theseus was eventually rescued", "WmGPhpEQ598-00304-00071937-00072182": "by Heracles but PFS remained trapped as", "WmGPhpEQ598-00305-00072183-00072359": "punishment for daring to seek the wife", "WmGPhpEQ598-00306-00072360-00073480": "of a god for his own topic Heracles", "WmGPhpEQ598-00307-00073481-00073712": "Heracles final labor was to capture", "WmGPhpEQ598-00308-00073713-00074018": "Cerberus first Heracles went to LF seas", "WmGPhpEQ598-00309-00074019-00074216": "to be initiated into the LFC near", "WmGPhpEQ598-00310-00074217-00074441": "mysteries he did this to a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00311-00074442-00074603": "solve himself of guilt for killing the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00312-00074604-00074788": "Centaurs and to learn how to enter and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00313-00074789-00075047": "exit the underworld alive he found the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00314-00075048-00075224": "entrance to the underworld at 10 a.m.", "WmGPhpEQ598-00315-00075225-00075451": "Athena and Hermes helped him through and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00316-00075452-00075731": "back from Hades Heracles asked Hades for", "WmGPhpEQ598-00317-00075732-00075980": "permission to take Cerberus Hades agreed", "WmGPhpEQ598-00318-00075981-00076187": "as long as Heracles didn't harm Cerberus", "WmGPhpEQ598-00319-00076188-00076397": "when Heracles dragged the dog out of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00320-00076398-00076588": "Hades he passed through the cavernous", "WmGPhpEQ598-00321-00076589-00077719": "shirisha topic minth II the nymph min", "WmGPhpEQ598-00322-00077720-00077948": "fee associated with the River Co situs", "WmGPhpEQ598-00323-00077949-00078169": "loved by Hades was turned into the mint", "WmGPhpEQ598-00324-00078170-00078599": "plant by a jealous Persephone topic cult", "WmGPhpEQ598-00325-00078600-00078791": "and epithets Hades as the god of the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00326-00078792-00078956": "Dead was a fearsome figure to those", "WmGPhpEQ598-00327-00078957-00079150": "still living in no hurry to meet him", "WmGPhpEQ598-00328-00079151-00079312": "they were reluctant to swear oaths in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00329-00079313-00079505": "his name and averted their faces when", "WmGPhpEQ598-00330-00079506-00079829": "sacrificing to him since too many simply", "WmGPhpEQ598-00331-00079830-00080036": "to say the word Hades was frightening", "WmGPhpEQ598-00332-00080037-00080338": "euphemisms were pressed into use since", "WmGPhpEQ598-00333-00080339-00080500": "precious minerals come from under the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00334-00080501-00080741": "earth ie the underworld ruled by Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00335-00080742-00080938": "he was considered to have control of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00336-00080939-00081110": "these as well and as such the Greeks", "WmGPhpEQ598-00337-00081111-00081323": "referred to him as Plowden grig Plowden", "WmGPhpEQ598-00338-00081324-00081682": "latin pl VT o pluto the rich one this", "WmGPhpEQ598-00339-00081683-00081890": "title is derived from the word Plato's", "WmGPhpEQ598-00340-00081891-00082174": "Greek Plato's literally wealth breeches", "WmGPhpEQ598-00341-00082175-00082381": "Sophocles explained the notion of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00342-00082382-00082580": "referring to Hades as Plowden with these", "WmGPhpEQ598-00343-00082581-00082807": "words the gloomy hades enriches himself", "WmGPhpEQ598-00344-00082808-00083099": "with our size and our tears in addition", "WmGPhpEQ598-00345-00083100-00083303": "he was called climbing as notorious", "WmGPhpEQ598-00346-00083304-00083498": "polyed Eggman who receives many and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00347-00083499-00083719": "perhaps you Bleus good counsel or well", "WmGPhpEQ598-00348-00083720-00083924": "intentioned all of them euphemisms for a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00349-00083925-00084118": "name that was unsafe to pronounce which", "WmGPhpEQ598-00350-00084119-00084416": "evolved into epithets he spent most of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00351-00084417-00084668": "the time in his dark realm formidable in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00352-00084669-00084866": "battle he proved his ferocity in the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00353-00084867-00085067": "famous Titan amake the battle of the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00354-00085068-00085243": "Olympians versus the Titans which", "WmGPhpEQ598-00355-00085244-00085525": "established the rule of Zeus feared and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00356-00085526-00085703": "loathed Hades embodied the inexorable", "WmGPhpEQ598-00357-00085704-00085934": "finality of death why do we loathe Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00358-00085935-00086123": "more than any God if not because he is", "WmGPhpEQ598-00359-00086124-00086384": "so adamantine and unyielding the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00360-00086385-00086662": "rhetorical question is Agamemnon's Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00361-00086663-00086887": "was not however an evil God for although", "WmGPhpEQ598-00362-00086888-00087149": "he was Stern cruel and unpitying he was", "WmGPhpEQ598-00363-00087150-00087425": "still just Hades ruled the underworld", "WmGPhpEQ598-00364-00087426-00087593": "and was therefore most often associated", "WmGPhpEQ598-00365-00087594-00087824": "with death and feared by men but he will", "WmGPhpEQ598-00366-00087825-00088061": "not death itself it is fana toes son of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00367-00088062-00088244": "Nixon Erebus who is the actual", "WmGPhpEQ598-00368-00088245-00088370": "personification of death", "WmGPhpEQ598-00369-00088371-00088556": "although Euripides play August Asst", "WmGPhpEQ598-00370-00088557-00088787": "States fairly clearly that Thanatos and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00371-00088788-00088967": "Hades were one in the same deity and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00372-00088968-00089138": "gives an interesting description of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00373-00089139-00089333": "Hades as being dark cloak than winged", "WmGPhpEQ598-00374-00089334-00089561": "moreover Hades was also referred to as", "WmGPhpEQ598-00375-00089562-00089735": "Hesperus Theo's god of death and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00376-00089736-00089921": "darkness when the Greeks propitiated", "WmGPhpEQ598-00377-00089922-00090083": "Hades they bang their hands on the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00378-00090084-00090230": "ground to be sure he would hear them", "WmGPhpEQ598-00379-00090231-00090485": "black animals such as sheep were", "WmGPhpEQ598-00380-00090486-00090665": "sacrificed to him and the very vehement", "WmGPhpEQ598-00381-00090666-00090866": "of the rejection of human sacrifice", "WmGPhpEQ598-00382-00090867-00091067": "expressed in myth suggests an unspoken", "WmGPhpEQ598-00383-00091068-00091346": "memory of some distant past the blood", "WmGPhpEQ598-00384-00091347-00091556": "from olsztyn exact rifice is including", "WmGPhpEQ598-00385-00091557-00091760": "those to propitiate Hades dripped into a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00386-00091761-00092036": "pit or cleft in the ground the person", "WmGPhpEQ598-00387-00092037-00092225": "who offered the sacrifice had to avert", "WmGPhpEQ598-00388-00092226-00092438": "his face one ancient source says that he", "WmGPhpEQ598-00389-00092439-00092690": "possessed the cap of invisibility his", "WmGPhpEQ598-00390-00092691-00092936": "chariot drawn by four black horses made", "WmGPhpEQ598-00391-00092937-00093092": "for a fearsome and impressive sight", "WmGPhpEQ598-00392-00093093-00093359": "these beasts were variously named as", "WmGPhpEQ598-00393-00093360-00093581": "according to Claudian Orpheus earthen", "WmGPhpEQ598-00394-00093582-00093758": "Knight Deus and Alistair while other", "WmGPhpEQ598-00395-00093759-00094016": "authors listed also na Gnaeus amethyst a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00396-00094017-00094328": "burst or Abitur and Mathias his other", "WmGPhpEQ598-00397-00094329-00094532": "ordinary attributes within our sisters", "WmGPhpEQ598-00398-00094533-00094739": "and Cypress plants the key of Hades and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00399-00094740-00095054": "Cerberus the three-headed dog in certain", "WmGPhpEQ598-00400-00095055-00095261": "portraits snakes also appeared to be", "WmGPhpEQ598-00401-00095262-00095414": "attributed to Hades as he was", "WmGPhpEQ598-00402-00095415-00095576": "occasionally portrayed to be either", "WmGPhpEQ598-00403-00095577-00095828": "holding them or accompanied by them this", "WmGPhpEQ598-00404-00095829-00096023": "is believed to hold significance as in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00405-00096024-00096242": "certain classical sources Hades ravished", "WmGPhpEQ598-00406-00096243-00096443": "core in the guise of a snake who went on", "WmGPhpEQ598-00407-00096444-00096749": "to give birth to zagreas Dionysus while", "WmGPhpEQ598-00408-00096750-00097013": "bearing the name Zeus Zeus Olympia's the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00409-00097014-00097121": "great king of the gods", "WmGPhpEQ598-00410-00097122-00097274": "noticeably differs from the zeus", "WmGPhpEQ598-00411-00097275-00097502": "militias a decidedly chieffo nyan", "WmGPhpEQ598-00412-00097503-00097727": "character often portrayed as a snake and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00413-00097728-00097910": "is seen beforehand they cannot be", "WmGPhpEQ598-00414-00097911-00098114": "different manifestations of the same God", "WmGPhpEQ598-00415-00098115-00098306": "in fact whenever another Zeus is", "WmGPhpEQ598-00416-00098307-00098532": "mentioned this always refers to Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00417-00098533-00098831": "Zeus militias and Zeus you burliest", "WmGPhpEQ598-00418-00098832-00099011": "are often referred to as being alternate", "WmGPhpEQ598-00419-00099012-00099263": "names for Hades the philosopher", "WmGPhpEQ598-00420-00099264-00099518": "Heraclitus unifying opposites declared", "WmGPhpEQ598-00421-00099519-00099662": "that Hades and Dionysus", "WmGPhpEQ598-00422-00099663-00099860": "the very essence of indestructible life", "WmGPhpEQ598-00423-00099861-00100142": "Zoe are the same God among other", "WmGPhpEQ598-00424-00100143-00100211": "evidence", "WmGPhpEQ598-00425-00100212-00100403": "Carl carinii notes in his book that the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00426-00100404-00100616": "Homeric hymn to Demeter votive marble", "WmGPhpEQ598-00427-00100617-00100826": "images and epithets all linked Hades to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00428-00100827-00101114": "being Dionysus he also notes that the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00429-00101115-00101213": "grieving goddess", "WmGPhpEQ598-00430-00101214-00101402": "Meeta refused to drink wine as she", "WmGPhpEQ598-00431-00101403-00101570": "states that it would be against Themis", "WmGPhpEQ598-00432-00101571-00101750": "for her to drink wine which is the gift", "WmGPhpEQ598-00433-00101751-00101984": "of Dionysus after Persephone's abduction", "WmGPhpEQ598-00434-00101985-00102203": "because of this association indicating", "WmGPhpEQ598-00435-00102204-00102374": "that hades may in fact have been her", "WmGPhpEQ598-00436-00102375-00102677": "cover name for the underworld Dionysus", "WmGPhpEQ598-00437-00102678-00102914": "he suggests that this dual identity may", "WmGPhpEQ598-00438-00102915-00103079": "have been familiar to those who came", "WmGPhpEQ598-00439-00103080-00103384": "into contact with the mysteries Dionysus", "WmGPhpEQ598-00440-00103385-00103592": "also shared several epithets with Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00441-00103593-00103919": "such as chief Onias the subterranean you", "WmGPhpEQ598-00442-00103920-00104225": "Berlioz good counselor and you CLIs", "WmGPhpEQ598-00443-00104226-00104714": "glorious all renowned evidence for a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00444-00104715-00104870": "cold connection is quite extensive", "WmGPhpEQ598-00445-00104871-00105041": "particularly in southern Italy", "WmGPhpEQ598-00446-00105042-00105218": "especially when considering the death", "WmGPhpEQ598-00447-00105219-00105409": "symbolism included in Dionysian worship", "WmGPhpEQ598-00448-00105410-00105647": "statues of Dionysus found in the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00449-00105648-00105833": "Plutonian at lf-cc gives further", "WmGPhpEQ598-00450-00105833-00106033": "evidence as the statue bears a striking", "WmGPhpEQ598-00451-00106034-00106208": "resemblance to the statue of you", "WmGPhpEQ598-00452-00106208-00106382": "burliest also known as the youthful", "WmGPhpEQ598-00453-00106383-00106549": "depiction of the Lord of the underworld", "WmGPhpEQ598-00454-00106550-00106838": "the statue of you bilious is described", "WmGPhpEQ598-00455-00106839-00107015": "as being radiant but disclosing a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00456-00107016-00107297": "strange inner darkness ancient portrayal", "WmGPhpEQ598-00457-00107298-00107516": "show Dionysus holding in his hand at", "WmGPhpEQ598-00458-00107517-00107710": "kantha Rose a wine jar with large", "WmGPhpEQ598-00459-00107711-00107911": "handles and occupying the place where", "WmGPhpEQ598-00460-00107913-00108194": "one would expect to see Hades archaic", "WmGPhpEQ598-00461-00108195-00108401": "artists senticles portrayed on one side", "WmGPhpEQ598-00462-00108402-00108650": "of avars Zeus Poseidon and Hades each", "WmGPhpEQ598-00463-00108651-00108848": "with his emblems of power with Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00464-00108849-00109031": "head turned back to front and on the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00465-00109032-00109256": "other side Dionysus striding forward to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00466-00109257-00109454": "meet his bride Persephone with a kantha", "WmGPhpEQ598-00467-00109455-00109649": "rose in his hand against a background of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00468-00109650-00109871": "grapes both Hades and Dionysus were", "WmGPhpEQ598-00469-00109872-00110069": "associated with a divine tripartite", "WmGPhpEQ598-00470-00110070-00110330": "deity with Zeus the or phix in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00471-00110331-00110509": "particular believed that Zeus and Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00472-00110510-00110708": "were the same deity and portrayed them", "WmGPhpEQ598-00473-00110708-00110993": "as such Zeus was portrayed as having an", "WmGPhpEQ598-00474-00110994-00111125": "incarnation in the underworld", "WmGPhpEQ598-00475-00111126-00111356": "identifying him as literally being Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00476-00111357-00111484": "and leading to Zeus and Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00477-00111485-00111728": "essentially being two representations in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00478-00111729-00111902": "different facets of the same God and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00479-00111903-00112186": "extended divine power this nature and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00480-00112188-00112397": "aspect of Hades and Zeus displayed in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00481-00112398-00112558": "the Orphic stories is the explanation", "WmGPhpEQ598-00482-00112559-00112763": "for why both Hades and Zeus are", "WmGPhpEQ598-00483-00112764-00112940": "considered to be the father of Milano", "WmGPhpEQ598-00484-00112941-00113252": "and zagreas the role of unifying Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00485-00113253-00113513": "Zeus and Dionysus as a single tripartite", "WmGPhpEQ598-00486-00113514-00113686": "God was used to represent the birth", "WmGPhpEQ598-00487-00113688-00113897": "death and resurrection of a deity and to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00488-00113898-00114104": "unify that shining realm of Zeus in the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00489-00114105-00114283": "dark realm of Hades that lay beneath the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00490-00114284-00114500": "earth among the other Appalachians under", "WmGPhpEQ598-00491-00114501-00114601": "which Hades or", "WmGPhpEQ598-00492-00114602-00114808": "is generally known are the following in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00493-00114808-00115233": "Greek Odysseus his name in Latium it is", "WmGPhpEQ598-00494-00115234-00115533": "expressive of the grace age' lastest", "WmGPhpEQ598-00495-00115534-00115828": "from his melancholy countenance age", "WmGPhpEQ598-00496-00115829-00116061": "silas expressive of his attracting all", "WmGPhpEQ598-00497-00116063-00116404": "people to his empire Ajit saw her Geddes", "WmGPhpEQ598-00498-00116405-00116638": "a name assigned to him by Pindar as to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00499-00116639-00116991": "one who conducts a dounia's this name is", "WmGPhpEQ598-00500-00116992-00117202": "probably derived from Hades having been", "WmGPhpEQ598-00501-00117203-00117391": "sometimes confounded with a king of this", "WmGPhpEQ598-00502-00117392-00117579": "name among the malossi whose daughter", "WmGPhpEQ598-00503-00117580-00117769": "Persephone Theseus and parathas", "WmGPhpEQ598-00504-00117770-00117954": "attempted to carry off", "WmGPhpEQ598-00505-00117955-00118252": "Axios esses or the Shan God a name of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00506-00118253-00118468": "Pluto in the mysteries of the khabiri he", "WmGPhpEQ598-00507-00118469-00118785": "was there represented as without hair ER", "WmGPhpEQ598-00508-00118786-00119076": "his name at Claire's a town of Ionia", "WmGPhpEQ598-00509-00119077-00119332": "Moira gates his name as guide of the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00510-00119333-00119674": "fates off use his name is the blind God", "WmGPhpEQ598-00511-00119675-00119841": "among the messing ins it was derived", "WmGPhpEQ598-00512-00119842-00120036": "from their dedicating certain August to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00513-00120038-00120190": "him whom they deprived of aid at the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00514-00120191-00120373": "moment of their birth in Latin or", "WmGPhpEQ598-00515-00120374-00120777": "Etruscan alter from Allah to nourish", "WmGPhpEQ598-00516-00120778-00121051": "fabulous from februar signifying the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00517-00121052-00121291": "sacrifices and purifications adopted in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00518-00121292-00121716": "funeral rites Fairless deus the dismal", "WmGPhpEQ598-00519-00121717-00122050": "or cruel god lactam his name among the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00520-00122051-00122404": "sarmatians la vie title sovereign of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00521-00122405-00122770": "Tartarus his name in a tree ur mantis or", "WmGPhpEQ598-00522-00122771-00122961": "Manas the diminutive of summoners and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00523-00122963-00123325": "Etruscan epithet Niger Deus black God", "WmGPhpEQ598-00524-00123326-00123496": "his epithet as God of the infernal", "WmGPhpEQ598-00525-00123497-00124011": "regions o perdus the concealed postulo a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00526-00124013-00124231": "name assigned to him by vera under which", "WmGPhpEQ598-00527-00124232-00124396": "he was worshipped on the shores of the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00528-00124397-00124600": "lake purchase from the circumstance of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00529-00124601-00124771": "the Earth's having opened at that spot", "WmGPhpEQ598-00530-00124772-00124963": "and of the Aerospace's having presumed", "WmGPhpEQ598-00531-00124964-00125133": "that the king of death thus asked for", "WmGPhpEQ598-00532-00125134-00125551": "pasta I ask sacrifices profundus Jupiter", "WmGPhpEQ598-00533-00125552-00125743": "deep or lower Jove from his being", "WmGPhpEQ598-00534-00125744-00125904": "sovereign of the deep or infernal", "WmGPhpEQ598-00535-00125905-00126003": "regions", "WmGPhpEQ598-00536-00126004-00126406": "quiet Alice from choirs breast Ruza", "WmGPhpEQ598-00537-00126407-00126625": "because all things return eventually to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00538-00126626-00126716": "the earth", "WmGPhpEQ598-00539-00126717-00127006": "salute eros Divis a name assigned to him", "WmGPhpEQ598-00540-00127007-00127188": "when he restored the dead to life", "WmGPhpEQ598-00541-00127189-00127426": "whenever the gods wish to reanimate a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00542-00127427-00127654": "body Pluto let fail some drops of nectar", "WmGPhpEQ598-00543-00127655-00127854": "from his urn upon the favored person", "WmGPhpEQ598-00544-00127855-00127982": "this may account for beer", "WmGPhpEQ598-00545-00127983-00128147": "being sometimes represented with an", "WmGPhpEQ598-00546-00128148-00128485": "inverted VARs saternus from his father", "WmGPhpEQ598-00547-00128486-00128807": "Saturn sorriness his name among the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00548-00128808-00129023": "Sabine's in the temple dedicated to him", "WmGPhpEQ598-00549-00129024-00129344": "on mount Sorek stygius from the River", "WmGPhpEQ598-00550-00129345-00129665": "Styx summoners from sumus mein iam", "WmGPhpEQ598-00551-00129666-00129817": "Prince of the Dead", "WmGPhpEQ598-00552-00129818-00130055": "telomere a name derived from those", "WmGPhpEQ598-00553-00130056-00130241": "treasures which Pluto possesses in the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00554-00130242-00130364": "recesses of the earth", "WmGPhpEQ598-00555-00130365-00130616": "teller mode denotes according to Varro", "WmGPhpEQ598-00556-00130617-00130810": "the creative power of the earth in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00557-00130811-00131038": "opposition to tell us the productive", "WmGPhpEQ598-00558-00131039-00131309": "Auriga s' expressive abyss power over", "WmGPhpEQ598-00559-00131310-00131377": "fire", "WmGPhpEQ598-00560-00131378-00131782": "ERG Asst from OG o to impel in egypt", "WmGPhpEQ598-00561-00131783-00132026": "amethyst a name of pluto among the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00562-00132027-00132338": "Egyptians Plutarch informs us that the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00563-00132339-00132524": "word amethyst has a reference to the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00564-00132525-00132695": "doctrines of the metempsychosis and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00565-00132696-00132884": "signifies the place which gives and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00566-00132885-00133073": "receives on the belief that some vast", "WmGPhpEQ598-00567-00133074-00133283": "gulf was assigned as a receptacle to the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00568-00133284-00133475": "souls which were about to animate new", "WmGPhpEQ598-00569-00133476-00134653": "bodies topic artistic representations", "WmGPhpEQ598-00570-00134654-00134909": "Hades was depicted so infrequently in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00571-00134910-00135155": "artwork as well as mythology because the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00572-00135156-00135380": "Greeks were so afraid of him his", "WmGPhpEQ598-00573-00135381-00135572": "artistic representations which are", "WmGPhpEQ598-00574-00135573-00135755": "generally found in archaic pottery are", "WmGPhpEQ598-00575-00135756-00135926": "not even concretely thought of as the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00576-00135927-00136148": "deity however at this point in time it", "WmGPhpEQ598-00577-00136149-00136289": "is heavily believed that the figures", "WmGPhpEQ598-00578-00136290-00136556": "Illustrated are indeed Hades he was", "WmGPhpEQ598-00579-00136557-00136754": "later presented in the classical arts in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00580-00136755-00136939": "the depictions of The Rape of Persephone", "WmGPhpEQ598-00581-00136940-00137210": "within these illustrations Hades was", "WmGPhpEQ598-00582-00137211-00137405": "often young yet he was also shown as", "WmGPhpEQ598-00583-00137406-00137690": "varying ages in other works due to this", "WmGPhpEQ598-00584-00137691-00137867": "lack of depictions there weren't very", "WmGPhpEQ598-00585-00137868-00138059": "strict guidelines when representing the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00586-00138060-00138383": "deity on pottery he has a dark beard and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00587-00138384-00138569": "is presented as a stately figure on an", "WmGPhpEQ598-00588-00138570-00138845": "ebony throne his attributes in art", "WmGPhpEQ598-00589-00138846-00139112": "include a scepter cornucopia rooster and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00590-00139113-00139337": "a key which both represented his control", "WmGPhpEQ598-00591-00139338-00139496": "over the underworld and acted as a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00592-00139497-00139628": "reminder that the gates of the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00593-00139629-00139793": "underworld were always locked so that", "WmGPhpEQ598-00594-00139794-00140069": "Souls could not leave even if the doors", "WmGPhpEQ598-00595-00140070-00140222": "were open Cerberus the three-headed", "WmGPhpEQ598-00596-00140223-00140474": "guard dog of the underworld ensured that", "WmGPhpEQ598-00597-00140475-00140624": "while all souls were allowed to enter", "WmGPhpEQ598-00598-00140625-00140831": "into the underworld freely none could", "WmGPhpEQ598-00599-00140832-00141104": "ever escape the dog is often portrayed", "WmGPhpEQ598-00600-00141105-00141272": "next to the God as a means of easy", "WmGPhpEQ598-00601-00141273-00141371": "identification", "WmGPhpEQ598-00602-00141372-00141590": "since no other deity relates to it so", "WmGPhpEQ598-00603-00141591-00141926": "directly sometimes artists painted Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00604-00141927-00142106": "is looking away from the other gods as", "WmGPhpEQ598-00605-00142107-00142283": "he was disliked by them as well as", "WmGPhpEQ598-00606-00142284-00142508": "humans as Plowden he was regarded in a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00607-00142509-00142613": "more positive light", "WmGPhpEQ598-00608-00142614-00142904": "he holds a cornucopia representing the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00609-00142905-00143108": "gifts he bestows upon people as well as", "WmGPhpEQ598-00610-00143109-00143836": "fertility which he becomes connected to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00611-00143837-00144500": "topic realm of Hades in older Greek", "WmGPhpEQ598-00612-00144501-00144710": "myths the realm of Hades is the misty", "WmGPhpEQ598-00613-00144711-00144914": "and gloomy abode of the Dead also called", "WmGPhpEQ598-00614-00144915-00145103": "Erebus where all mortals go when they", "WmGPhpEQ598-00615-00145104-00145394": "die very few mortals could leave Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00616-00145395-00145580": "once they entered the exceptions", "WmGPhpEQ598-00617-00145581-00145787": "Heracles and Theseus are heroic", "WmGPhpEQ598-00618-00145788-00146075": "even Odysseus in his Nakia Odyssey she", "WmGPhpEQ598-00619-00146076-00146258": "calls up the spirits of the departed", "WmGPhpEQ598-00620-00146259-00146513": "rather than dissent to them later Greek", "WmGPhpEQ598-00621-00146514-00146738": "philosophy introduced the idea that all", "WmGPhpEQ598-00622-00146739-00146918": "mortals are judged after death and are", "WmGPhpEQ598-00623-00146919-00147089": "either rewarded or cursed there were", "WmGPhpEQ598-00624-00147090-00147257": "several sections of the realm of Hades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00625-00147258-00147500": "including Elysium the asphodel meadows", "WmGPhpEQ598-00626-00147501-00147830": "and Tartarus the mythographers Polydorus", "WmGPhpEQ598-00627-00147831-00148124": "describes Tartarus 'as a gloomy place in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00628-00148125-00148343": "Hades as far distant from Earth as Earth", "WmGPhpEQ598-00629-00148344-00148750": "is distant from the sky Greek mythology", "WmGPhpEQ598-00630-00148751-00148961": "consistent about the geography of the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00631-00148962-00149231": "afterlife a contrasting myth of the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00632-00149232-00149411": "afterlife concerns the garden of the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00633-00149412-00149486": "Hesperides", "WmGPhpEQ598-00634-00149487-00149666": "often identified with the Isles of the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00635-00149667-00149843": "Blessed where the Blessed heroes may", "WmGPhpEQ598-00636-00149844-00150182": "dwell in Roman mythology the entrance to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00637-00150183-00150371": "the underworld located at a Vernis a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00638-00150372-00150566": "crater near kama was the route Aeneas", "WmGPhpEQ598-00639-00150567-00150734": "used to descend to the realm of the Dead", "WmGPhpEQ598-00640-00150735-00151097": "by synecdoche a furnace could be", "WmGPhpEQ598-00641-00151098-00151262": "substituted for the underworld as a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00642-00151263-00151499": "whole the die and fury were a collective", "WmGPhpEQ598-00643-00151500-00151793": "of underworld divinities for hélène's", "WmGPhpEQ598-00644-00151794-00151982": "the deceased entered the underworld by", "WmGPhpEQ598-00645-00151983-00152183": "crossing the Styx ferried across by", "WmGPhpEQ598-00646-00152184-00152414": "cherán care on who charged a noblesse a", "WmGPhpEQ598-00647-00152415-00152609": "small coin for passage placed in the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00648-00152610-00152839": "mouth of the deceased by pious relatives", "WmGPhpEQ598-00649-00152840-00153059": "paupers and the friendless gathered for", "WmGPhpEQ598-00650-00153060-00153206": "a hundred years on the near shore", "WmGPhpEQ598-00651-00153207-00153412": "according to book six of Virgil's Aeneid", "WmGPhpEQ598-00652-00153413-00153698": "Greeks offered propitiatory libations to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00653-00153699-00153866": "prevent the deceased from returning to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00654-00153867-00154142": "the upper world to haunt those who had", "WmGPhpEQ598-00655-00154143-00154295": "not given him a proper burial", "WmGPhpEQ598-00656-00154296-00154508": "the far side of the river was guarded by", "WmGPhpEQ598-00657-00154509-00154736": "Cerberus the three-headed dog defeated", "WmGPhpEQ598-00658-00154737-00154753": "by", "WmGPhpEQ598-00659-00154754-00155074": "Heracles Roman Hercules passing beyond", "WmGPhpEQ598-00660-00155075-00155231": "Cerberus the shades of The Departed", "WmGPhpEQ598-00661-00155232-00155398": "entered the land of the Dead to be", "WmGPhpEQ598-00662-00155399-00155684": "judged the five rivers of the realm of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00663-00155685-00155882": "Hades and their symbolic meanings are", "WmGPhpEQ598-00664-00155883-00156110": "Acheron the river of sorrow or were Co", "WmGPhpEQ598-00665-00156111-00156415": "situs lamentation Phlegethon fire leafy", "WmGPhpEQ598-00666-00156416-00156661": "oblivion and Styx hate the river upon", "WmGPhpEQ598-00667-00156662-00156829": "which even the gods swore and in which", "WmGPhpEQ598-00668-00156830-00156979": "Achilles was dipped to render him", "WmGPhpEQ598-00669-00156980-00157256": "invincible the Styx forms the boundary", "WmGPhpEQ598-00670-00157257-00157438": "between the upper and lower worlds", "WmGPhpEQ598-00671-00157439-00157822": "see also era donnas the first region of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00672-00157823-00158023": "Hades comprises the fields of asphodel", "WmGPhpEQ598-00673-00158024-00158263": "described in Odyssey XI where the shades", "WmGPhpEQ598-00674-00158264-00158459": "of Heroes wander despondently among", "WmGPhpEQ598-00675-00158460-00158635": "lesser spirits who Twitter around them", "WmGPhpEQ598-00676-00158636-00158911": "like bats only libations of blood", "WmGPhpEQ598-00677-00158912-00159049": "offered to them in the world of the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00678-00159050-00159229": "living can reawaken in them for a time", "WmGPhpEQ598-00679-00159230-00159429": "the sensations of humanity", "WmGPhpEQ598-00680-00159430-00159700": "beyond lay Erebus which could be taken", "WmGPhpEQ598-00681-00159701-00159896": "for a you Phenom of Hades whose own name", "WmGPhpEQ598-00682-00159897-00160157": "was dread there were two pools that of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00683-00160158-00160354": "leafy where the common souls flocked to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00684-00160355-00160522": "erase all memory and the pool of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00685-00160523-00160801": "Mnemosyne memory where the initiates of", "WmGPhpEQ598-00686-00160802-00161002": "the mysteries drank instead in the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00687-00161003-00161164": "forecourt of the Palace of Hades and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00688-00161165-00161369": "Persephone sit the three judges of the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00689-00161370-00161425": "underworld", "WmGPhpEQ598-00690-00161426-00161764": "- Rhadamanthus and Aeacus there are the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00691-00161765-00161950": "Trivium sacred to Hecate where three", "WmGPhpEQ598-00692-00161951-00162163": "roads meet souls are judged returned to", "WmGPhpEQ598-00693-00162164-00162325": "the fields of asphodel if they are", "WmGPhpEQ598-00694-00162326-00162523": "neither virtuous nor evil sent by the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00695-00162524-00162736": "road to Tartarus if they are impious or", "WmGPhpEQ598-00696-00162737-00162947": "evil or sent to Elysium islands of the", "WmGPhpEQ598-00697-00162948-00163360": "Blessed with thee blameless heroes in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00698-00163361-00163552": "the civilian Oracle's a curious", "WmGPhpEQ598-00699-00163553-00163711": "hodgepodge of greco-roman and", "WmGPhpEQ598-00700-00163712-00163924": "judeo-christian elements Hades again", "WmGPhpEQ598-00701-00163925-00164113": "appears as the abode of the Dead and by", "WmGPhpEQ598-00702-00164114-00164326": "way of folk etymology it even derives", "WmGPhpEQ598-00703-00164327-00164527": "Hades from the name Adam the first man", "WmGPhpEQ598-00704-00164528-00164716": "saying that is because he was the first", "WmGPhpEQ598-00705-00164717-00164974": "to enter there owing to its appearance", "WmGPhpEQ598-00706-00164975-00165143": "in the New Testament of the Bible", "WmGPhpEQ598-00707-00165144-00165344": "Hades also has a distinct meaning in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00708-00165345-00166958": "Christianity topic genealogy topic in", "WmGPhpEQ598-00709-00166959-00167044": "popular", "WmGPhpEQ598-00710-00167045-00168454": "culture topic see also equals equals", "WmGPhpEQ598-00711-00168455-00168691": "notes"}}, {"audio_id": "Wn6SNHy_3XY", "text": {"Wn6SNHy_3XY-00000-00000509-00001019": "for y'all thank you for coming this is", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00001-00001019-00001277": "Josie McDaniel Burkett who will be", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00002-00001278-00001820": "signing for us today and we will you'll", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00003-00001821-00002132": "hear from men behind me in just a second", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00004-00002133-00002399": "as you know a hurricane is coming our", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00005-00002400-00002615": "way it has now been Florence has now", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00006-00002616-00002798": "been declared a hurricane it is no", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00007-00002799-00003038": "longer tropical storm that means it is", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00008-00003039-00003238": "over 75 miles an hour and getting", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00009-00003239-00003545": "stronger there has been a slight change", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00010-00003546-00003821": "and that is the hurricane now hurricane", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00011-00003822-00004094": "is coming to us a little bit slower that", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00012-00004095-00004340": "is traveling across the ocean a little", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00013-00004341-00004550": "slower than it was yesterday in our", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00014-00004551-00004778": "direction but on the other hand it is", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00015-00004779-00005036": "spinning much faster than it was", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00016-00005037-00005291": "yesterday and all estimates are that it", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00017-00005292-00005506": "will be spinning even faster by the time", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00018-00005507-00005750": "it gets to the East Coast which", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00019-00005751-00006035": "apparently it is going to do is get to", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00020-00006036-00006197": "these coast and when it gets here it's", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00021-00006198-00006488": "estimated it may be this is an estimate", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00022-00006489-00006805": "a category 4 hurricane which is between", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00023-00006806-00007216": "130 and 156 miles an hour you see the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00024-00007217-00007570": "cone there that is not the area of which", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00025-00007571-00007952": "the hurricane is expected to affect that", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00026-00007953-00008227": "at that area there that cone that bubble", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00027-00008228-00008530": "is the area in which the eye of the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00028-00008531-00008794": "hurricane is - as of today based on", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00029-00008795-00009080": "current temporary information that is", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00030-00009081-00009223": "where the eye of the hurricane is", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00031-00009224-00009517": "expected to be at this time that is", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00032-00009518-00009709": "right now as near as we can forecast it", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00033-00009710-00009983": "may change it may go farther north it", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00034-00009984-00010231": "could go for the south Oh as you know", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00035-00010232-00010405": "the atmospheric conditions that are", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00036-00010406-00010691": "controlling all of that but everyone all", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00037-00010692-00010906": "the weather forecasters seem to be", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00038-00010907-00011278": "fairly certain that that is that's a", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00039-00011279-00011602": "good forecast for now next tomorrow it", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00040-00011603-00011830": "may it may change well what that means", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00041-00011831-00012037": "first in South Carolina is that we", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00042-00012038-00012238": "whatever happens we will have a lot of", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00043-00012239-00012316": "rain and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00044-00012317-00012730": "when even if the hurricane goes for the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00045-00012731-00012972": "north and is anticipated in in this", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00046-00012973-00013288": "graphic we still have a lot of water and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00047-00013288-00013504": "a lot of wind so what that means is we", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00048-00013505-00013722": "need to be prepared as I mentioned", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00049-00013723-00013966": "yesterday the official side of our", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00050-00013966-00014275": "preparations is being done in a", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00051-00014276-00014512": "magnificent fashion we've had practice", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00052-00014513-00014697": "doing this as you know in recent years", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00053-00014698-00015022": "in team South Carolina is on the job", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00054-00015022-00015268": "people are being activated I issued the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00055-00015269-00015463": "executive order yesterday that allowed a", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00056-00015463-00015604": "lot of things to happen and to happen", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00057-00015605-00015874": "more quickly and we're moving assets and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00058-00015875-00016057": "people to the coast getting people in", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00059-00016058-00016459": "place to respond to whatever happens but", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00060-00016460-00016768": "I say this although the official side of", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00061-00016769-00016980": "this is being done with a great", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00062-00016981-00017215": "precision great skill and great speed", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00063-00017216-00017497": "it's the unofficial side that is the the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00064-00017498-00017778": "citizens that have a a part that is", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00065-00017779-00017992": "important to play and that is make your", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00066-00017993-00018280": "plans now if you have medical pretend", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00067-00018281-00018574": "assumed presume that a major hurricane", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00068-00018575-00018865": "is going to hit right smack dab in the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00069-00018866-00019053": "middle of South Carolina and may go way", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00070-00019054-00019390": "in inshore and that means winds and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00071-00019391-00019594": "water so you have to get your medicines", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00072-00019595-00019864": "ready to go if you have prescriptions", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00073-00019865-00020028": "you need filled better get them filled", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00074-00020029-00020247": "if you have relatives who need to be", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00075-00020248-00020416": "alerted the way you might go or where", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00076-00020417-00020668": "you can go tell them take care of your", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00077-00020669-00020899": "pets be sure to lock things up because", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00078-00020900-00021127": "you may not be coming you may not be", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00079-00021128-00021346": "coming home for several days so that", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00080-00021347-00021544": "means you may need to take food you may", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00081-00021545-00021727": "need to take flashlights depending on", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00082-00021728-00021913": "where you're going to go but there's a", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00083-00021914-00022222": "lot of information that's available at s", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00084-00022223-00022780": "CMD org SCE MD dot org there's a ample", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00085-00022781-00022990": "information that provides all that we're", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00086-00022991-00023227": "discussing and also I call your", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00087-00023228-00023467": "attention again to the South Carolina", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00088-00023468-00023677": "hurricane guide this is about as good as", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00089-00023678-00024197": "it gets this online at SC MD dot org and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00090-00024198-00024462": "in some places you can pick up a hard", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00091-00024463-00024705": "copy but if you can't find those go", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00092-00024706-00024889": "online it's got everything you need to", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00093-00024890-00025117": "know it's very easy to read easy to", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00094-00025118-00025333": "understand and if we'll all just follow", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00095-00025334-00025468": "these rules and prepare", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00096-00025469-00025762": "for this what is likely going to be a", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00097-00025763-00026161": "strong hit on South Carolina we don't", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00098-00026162-00026437": "know how much we can't predict for sure", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00099-00026438-00026611": "but we know we're going to have a lot of", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00100-00026612-00026812": "wind and a lot of rain and remember it", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00101-00026813-00026941": "doesn't take much to knock down", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00102-00026942-00027199": "telephone 40 mile an hour wind can knock", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00103-00027200-00027355": "down a telephone pole and there goes", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00104-00027356-00027619": "your power until it can get fixed so be", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00105-00027620-00027945": "prepared of be ready and I need to tell", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00106-00027947-00028132": "you I submitted today to President Trump", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00107-00028133-00028335": "a request for a federal emergency", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00108-00028336-00028657": "declaration in anticipation of the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00109-00028658-00028963": "impact on South Carolina what that means", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00110-00028964-00029220": "is we're asking for authorization in", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00111-00029222-00029443": "advance to make application to get", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00112-00029444-00029707": "reimbursed for expenses for people", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00113-00029708-00029911": "machinery and assets we may need to", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00114-00029912-00030264": "clean up and fix whatever damage results", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00115-00030266-00030520": "from this of what is now a hurricane", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00116-00030520-00030775": "with that I'd like to call on the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00117-00030776-00031039": "weatherman John choir reloj of the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00118-00031039-00031423": "National Weather Service John Thank You", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00119-00031424-00031470": "governor", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00120-00031472-00031657": "good afternoon has a governor mentioned", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00121-00031658-00031833": "Florence is now a category 1 hurricane", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00122-00031833-00032115": "it's still moving slowly to the west", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00123-00032116-00032347": "about 6 miles per hour", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00124-00032348-00032490": "Florence will begin to rapidly", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00125-00032491-00032788": "strengthen becoming a major hurricane by", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00126-00032789-00033094": "Monday evening a turn to the northwest", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00127-00033095-00033315": "and an increase in forward speed that", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00128-00033316-00033463": "will then occur through the middle of", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00129-00033464-00033700": "the week Florence is expected to", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00130-00033701-00033922": "approach the southeast coast as a major", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00131-00033923-00034339": "hurricane on Thursday on this current", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00132-00034340-00034558": "track the tropical storm-force winds", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00133-00034559-00034813": "could arrive across parts of the South", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00134-00034814-00035089": "Carolina coast by Thursday morning and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00135-00035090-00035275": "as the governor mentioned given the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00136-00035276-00035407": "slower approach that's just a little bit", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00137-00035408-00035494": "later than what we were expecting", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00138-00035495-00035809": "yesterday well the official forecast", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00139-00035810-00036015": "shows Florence making landfall across", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00140-00036016-00036315": "southeast North Carolina it's still", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00141-00036316-00036463": "important to remember that the court of", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00142-00036464-00036637": "answer knee still covers the entire", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00143-00036638-00036829": "South Carolina coast as the governor", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00144-00036830-00037024": "also mentioned meaning that landfall", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00145-00037025-00037246": "along coastal South Carolina is still a", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00146-00037247-00037510": "possibility remember the storm is still", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00147-00037511-00037723": "five days out and changes to the track", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00148-00037724-00038047": "can and likely will occur in addition", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00149-00038048-00038224": "any impacts including wind heavy", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00150-00038225-00038419": "rainfall and storm surge will extend", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00151-00038420-00038690": "well away from the center of the storm", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00152-00038691-00038851": "Florence is expected", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00153-00038852-00039111": "slow or even stalled over the Carolinas", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00154-00039112-00039289": "and mid-atlantic region for at least", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00155-00039290-00039502": "several days after making landfall and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00156-00039503-00039714": "could result in significant flash", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00157-00039715-00039939": "flooding and eventually River flooding", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00158-00039940-00040252": "depending on the track so at this point", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00159-00040253-00040480": "still important to continue preparations", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00160-00040481-00040743": "and again for more hurricane safety tips", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00161-00040744-00040882": "and other resources from the Weather", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00162-00040883-00041090": "Service you can go to weather.gov slash", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00163-00041091-00041611": "safety thank you when you watch the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00164-00041612-00041842": "national weather report says most of us", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00165-00041843-00042058": "have been doing for several days now you", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00166-00042059-00042268": "remember those national reports or folk", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00167-00042269-00042535": "for a national audience they not not", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00168-00042536-00042702": "tailor-made for South Carolina what", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00169-00042703-00042835": "you're hearing from us is tailor-made", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00170-00042836-00043129": "for South Carolina we go into more depth", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00171-00043130-00043333": "in more detail and that's why when you", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00172-00043334-00043524": "see on the national weather reports you", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00173-00043525-00043743": "see what would appear to be a cone or", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00174-00043744-00043954": "the hurricane seems to be drifting the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00175-00043955-00044182": "way that that's not a prediction the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00176-00044183-00044452": "prediction is fairly well represented by", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00177-00044453-00044755": "this cone and again if the outlying edge", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00178-00044756-00044929": "is that white line going around the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00179-00044930-00045079": "outside that is where the eye of the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00180-00045080-00045315": "hurricane may be not the extent of the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00181-00045316-00045493": "winds of the hurricane I'll go up maybe", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00182-00045494-00045720": "100 miles on either side but the eye of", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00183-00045721-00045964": "the hurricane so by this prediction here", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00184-00045965-00046123": "the eye of the hurricane could come in", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00185-00046124-00046374": "down in Jasper County up around around", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00186-00046375-00046626": "Savannah or go all the way up to up to", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00187-00046627-00046882": "Maryland or any way in between so we", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00188-00046883-00047026": "don't know what's gonna happen but we", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00189-00047027-00047271": "know this the the official part of the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00190-00047272-00047514": "state the state response mechanism is in", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00191-00047515-00047808": "gear and working and is ready and we", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00192-00047809-00048085": "want all the people to to be smart and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00193-00048086-00048451": "prepare for what could be a very hard", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00194-00048452-00048645": "blow to South Carolina General", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00195-00048646-00049057": "Livingston Thank You governor based on", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00196-00049058-00049224": "the governor's executive order and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00197-00049225-00049393": "coordination with all of team South", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00198-00049394-00049671": "Carolina almost 3,000 people are being", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00199-00049672-00049908": "pre positioned for contingencies", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00200-00049909-00050101": "throughout South Carolina we've", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00201-00050102-00050437": "activated over 800 National Guardsmen to", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00202-00050438-00050674": "support state operations and we are", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00203-00050675-00050854": "coordinating with all of our neighbors", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00204-00050855-00051102": "and to tell you how fluid this storm is", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00205-00051103-00051436": "we're talking to North Carolina we're", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00206-00051437-00051676": "getting commitments of assets from them", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00207-00051677-00051864": "if something happens in South Carolina", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00208-00051865-00052038": "and they're getting commitments from us", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00209-00052039-00052237": "for assets if something happens", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00210-00052238-00052414": "North Carolina so we're making", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00211-00052415-00052759": "contingency plans for the whole range of", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00212-00052760-00053011": "impact of the storm and we will be", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00213-00053012-00053233": "prepared I will emphasize what the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00214-00053234-00053557": "governor said is your individual", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00215-00053558-00053719": "preparedness and your individual", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00216-00053720-00054085": "awareness please make sure that you are", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00217-00054086-00054451": "prepared to evacuate if necessary and we", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00218-00054452-00054670": "will be providing the governor will be", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00219-00054671-00055084": "providing timely information to allow", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00220-00055085-00055365": "you to execute those plans that you make", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00221-00055366-00055723": "if something does happen so you have to", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00222-00055724-00055978": "plan on that cone and then as the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00223-00055979-00056254": "situation develops the governor will", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00224-00056254-00056590": "officially notify you in time so that", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00225-00056591-00056866": "you can make your moves but we do", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00226-00056866-00057222": "appreciate the entire hopera", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00227-00057223-00057499": "cooperation of Team South Carolina and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00228-00057500-00057691": "that includes all the citizens of South", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00229-00057691-00057832": "Carolina thank you guys", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00230-00057833-00058234": "sir yes director of Emergency Management", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00231-00058235-00058486": "Division thank you sir", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00232-00058487-00058684": "a couple updates the State Emergency", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00233-00058685-00058888": "Operations Center which we're at right", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00234-00058889-00059194": "now is operational with partial agency", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00235-00059195-00059442": "staffing state agency staffing and will", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00236-00059444-00059611": "remain for the at least the near term", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00237-00059612-00059833": "and we'll probably ramp up the full", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00238-00059834-00060112": "staffing tomorrow on Monday response", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00239-00060113-00060354": "priorities right now our evacuation", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00240-00060355-00060661": "planning an execution to include", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00241-00060662-00060855": "sheltering if we have to do any of that", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00242-00060857-00061080": "and then also we're also taking a look", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00243-00061082-00061266": "at the follow-on operations", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00244-00061266-00061491": "potentially post evacuation and that", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00245-00061492-00061795": "would be the response and also damage", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00246-00061796-00062146": "assessment the governor also already", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00247-00062147-00062263": "mentioned about the emergency", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00248-00062264-00062521": "declaration that our FEMA federal", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00249-00062522-00062659": "coordinating officer who will be in", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00250-00062660-00062851": "charge of FEMA assets once they arrive", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00251-00062852-00063025": "here in South Carolina will be here", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00252-00063026-00063349": "Monday also with an advance team to", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00253-00063350-00063579": "start the planning process should we", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00254-00063580-00063964": "should we have to evacuate in terms of", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00255-00063965-00064153": "the local authorities in the counties we", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00256-00064154-00064414": "stay in contact with them at least twice", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00257-00064415-00064639": "a day to make sure that we understand", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00258-00064640-00064783": "what their status is and whether or not", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00259-00064784-00064915": "they have any unmet needs", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00260-00064916-00065176": "most of the County EOC s the immersive", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00261-00065177-00065341": "emergency operation centers are being", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00262-00065341-00065515": "staffed to some extent today", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00263-00065516-00065701": "and their primary focus is the same as", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00264-00065702-00065944": "ours it's the possible evacuation and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00265-00065945-00066090": "sheltering mission that we may have", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00266-00066091-00066469": "we'll also today are deploying some of", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00267-00066470-00066646": "our South Carolina emergency management", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00268-00066647-00066817": "division personnel to the coastal", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00269-00066818-00066982": "counties so they'll be embedded with the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00270-00066983-00067264": "Mercy Operations Center so we'll have", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00271-00067265-00067435": "better coordination and understanding", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00272-00067436-00067582": "and situational awareness on the ground", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00273-00067583-00067861": "down there in terms of logistics and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00274-00067862-00068050": "that's a lot of what we do here helping", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00275-00068051-00068491": "out the county's resource logistics and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00276-00068492-00068764": "we've got our contracts for commodities", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00277-00068765-00069028": "general logistical support and also", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00278-00069029-00069286": "transport and as general Livingston", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00279-00069287-00069463": "mentioned coordinating with other states", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00280-00069464-00069694": "for the possibility of receiving out of", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00281-00069695-00069934": "state assets should we need them and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00282-00069935-00070240": "we're looking at at least three areas", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00283-00070241-00070416": "right now and that's incident management", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00284-00070417-00070774": "swift water rescue and air support in", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00285-00070775-00070981": "terms of public information we continue", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00286-00070982-00071251": "to emphasize the individual preparedness", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00287-00071252-00071479": "we have an active social media campaign", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00288-00071480-00071644": "where we're pushing out information all", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00289-00071645-00071884": "the time in terms of the personal", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00290-00071885-00072022": "preparedness and the governor's already", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00291-00072023-00072369": "talked about the website and our", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00292-00072370-00072613": "hurricane guide but also would like to", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00293-00072614-00072795": "mention our emergency manager", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00294-00072796-00073018": "application that can be downloaded on", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00295-00073019-00073333": "your smartphone that has almost all the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00296-00073334-00073501": "information that's on our website and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00297-00073502-00073788": "very importantly it has the no years own", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00298-00073789-00074074": "module which will allow you to type in", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00299-00074075-00074215": "your address if you live along the coast", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00300-00074216-00074449": "and it will tell you which zone you're", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00301-00074450-00074656": "in or if you're not in a zone so we", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00302-00074657-00074890": "invite everybody to look at that and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00303-00074891-00075217": "again all those sources the app the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00304-00075218-00075421": "hurricane guide and the website have", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00305-00075422-00075649": "lots of great information to give each", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00306-00075650-00075853": "one of us prepared so we ask that", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00307-00075854-00075979": "everybody be their own personal", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00308-00075980-00076285": "emergency manager and make a plan and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00309-00076286-00076471": "make it personal and be ready for", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00310-00076472-00076549": "whatever happens", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00311-00076550-00076732": "thank you sir one question you mentioned", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00312-00076733-00076938": "these zones what are the differ", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00313-00076939-00077124": "what difference does that make to", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00314-00077125-00077499": "average Zeus right right basically most", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00315-00077500-00077688": "counties have more than one zone that", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00316-00077689-00077883": "they're divided up in and depending on", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00317-00077884-00078186": "the category of the storm and it'll go", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00318-00078187-00078339": "further inland obviously if it's a", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00319-00078340-00078609": "stronger storm so generally what we call", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00320-00078610-00078873": "the evacuation zone the Alfa's the the a", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00321-00078874-00079044": "areas are the ones that are located", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00322-00079045-00079257": "right along the cloak coast and then", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00323-00079258-00079473": "further inland there's B zones and then", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00324-00079474-00079644": "even further inland there may be C zones", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00325-00079645-00079898": "and it depends on the category of storm", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00326-00079899-00080172": "whether or not you'd have to evacuate if", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00327-00080173-00080859": "that comes to pass I think they're", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00328-00080860-00081036": "probably somewhere in the 15 to 20", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00329-00081037-00081240": "category and that's an initial planning", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00330-00081241-00081405": "group if you will", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00331-00081406-00081630": "that'll help us work specific areas", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00332-00081631-00081795": "where there's operations or logistics", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00333-00081796-00081999": "and we just have them on the ground to", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00334-00082000-00082497": "do that planning well quick no good it", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00335-00082498-00083676": "doesn't look like hurricane is coming I", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00336-00083677-00083919": "would say get ready because there the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00337-00083920-00084234": "winds on this one are predicted to be", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00338-00084235-00084426": "more powerful than the war on Hugo which", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00339-00084427-00084642": "is the one that had some very powerful", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00340-00084643-00084852": "winds and that happened or went all the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00341-00084853-00084996": "way through Columbian to Charlotte", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00342-00084997-00085188": "knocked down all the big live oak trees", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00343-00085189-00085539": "in Charlotte so I would say prepare for", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00344-00085540-00085736": "the worst and hope for the best but", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00345-00085737-00086016": "indications as indicated earlier is that", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00346-00086017-00086259": "the storm is moving very slowly although", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00347-00086260-00086427": "the winds are getting faster and faster", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00348-00086428-00086591": "as it goes over warm", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00349-00086592-00086806": "the water starts spinning more and more", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00350-00086807-00087074": "and but it's moving slowly so that means", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00351-00087075-00087275": "that it may be just parked here on top", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00352-00087276-00087562": "of us for longer than we've had one here", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00353-00087563-00087731": "before often they'll just move right", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00354-00087732-00087872": "through well this one's moving up very", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00355-00087873-00088132": "slow those high winds it could do a lot", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00356-00088133-00088328": "of damage just get prepared", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00357-00088329-00088529": "prepare for the worst but hope for the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00358-00088530-00088709": "best okay are we thinking about", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00359-00088710-00088856": "reversing the lanes on the interstates", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00360-00088857-00089050": "we're considering all of those things", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00361-00089051-00089257": "we're considering everything from A to Z", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00362-00089258-00089407": "on how to keep the people of the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00363-00089408-00089621": "property safe and we'll be making the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00364-00089622-00089794": "appropriate announcements at the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00365-00089795-00089968": "appropriate time with plenty of lead", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00366-00089969-00090238": "time and notice in advance and our team", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00367-00090239-00090451": "has been in contact with the rest of the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00368-00090452-00090665": "team all around the state and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00369-00090666-00090866": "particularly in hospitals and nursing", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00370-00090867-00091091": "homes and other things that require a", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00371-00091092-00091334": "little bit more in advance notice but", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00372-00091335-00091574": "the constant communication among the", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00373-00091575-00091961": "entire network timeline right now at", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00374-00091962-00092117": "this time you could say sometime this", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00375-00092118-00092378": "week when evacuations nobody what's that", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00376-00092379-00092465": "no sir", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00377-00092466-00092612": "well we're looking at it all the time", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00378-00092613-00092798": "we're studying there what information we", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00379-00092799-00092978": "have and things have changed a little", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00380-00092979-00093175": "bit from this time yesterday till now", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00381-00093176-00093300": "they're probably changed some more", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00382-00093301-00093413": "tomorrow", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00383-00093414-00093698": "but we are constantly constantly review", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00384-00093699-00093866": "and analyzing the information to", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00385-00093867-00094016": "determine what the best course of action", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00386-00094017-00094562": "is really really can't say now don't", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00387-00094563-00094742": "don't want to say we don't want to don't", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00388-00094743-00094831": "want to be in error", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00389-00094832-00095203": "but I would say listen to what we say in", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00390-00095204-00095435": "watching television and go go to these", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00391-00095436-00095569": "websites and there's plenty of", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00392-00095570-00095782": "information there and when there's when", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00393-00095783-00095966": "there's an announcement to make you can", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00394-00095967-00096191": "be assured we'll announce it in plenty", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00395-00096192-00096382": "of time to give everyone plenty of", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00396-00096383-00096641": "notices and we got it really a great", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00397-00096642-00096887": "team working on this so we expect to be", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00398-00096888-00097103": "very reliable for the people of this", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00399-00097104-00097398": "state", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00400-00097399-00097521": "and can we repeat the number of", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00401-00097522-00097767": "activated personnel in place to view of", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00402-00097768-00097947": "those contingency plans in the National", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00403-00097948-00098207": "Guardsmen right now we have about 800", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00404-00098208-00098499": "National Guardsmen activated but then we", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00405-00098500-00099119": "also have almost 3,000 do te and police", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00406-00099120-00099582": "personnel from the sled Department", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00407-00099583-00099801": "Natural Resources Highway Patrol that", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00408-00099802-00100200": "are moving to the coast to prepare for", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00409-00100201-00100413": "contingencies now we have plenty of", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00410-00100414-00100773": "reserve we got another 9,000 National", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00411-00100774-00101057": "Guardsmen we can activate we have people", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00412-00101058-00101280": "from neighboring states but right now we", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00413-00101281-00101475": "don't need those people and we will", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00414-00101476-00101775": "activate as we need as governor says we", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00415-00101776-00102144": "have internal plans we just have to see", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00416-00102145-00102312": "the start point and the start point is", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00417-00102313-00102524": "it dependent on this on the storm and", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00418-00102525-00102977": "flourish someone tell us everything yet", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00419-00102978-00103210": "any more questions", "Wn6SNHy_3XY-00420-00103211-00103641": "stay tuned and thank you very much"}}, {"audio_id": "Xo17vqY90_M", "text": {"Xo17vqY90_M-00000-00000034-00002493": "[Music]", "Xo17vqY90_M-00001-00002494-00003442": "[Music]", "Xo17vqY90_M-00002-00003443-00003840": "[Applause]", "Xo17vqY90_M-00003-00003842-00005502": "[Music]", "Xo17vqY90_M-00004-00005503-00006227": "[Music]", "Xo17vqY90_M-00005-00006228-00008751": "[Music]", "Xo17vqY90_M-00006-00008752-00009503": "[Music]", "Xo17vqY90_M-00007-00009504-00010038": "so", "Xo17vqY90_M-00008-00010039-00011742": "[Music]", "Xo17vqY90_M-00009-00011743-00013158": "[Music]", "Xo17vqY90_M-00010-00013159-00017079": "[Music]", "Xo17vqY90_M-00011-00017080-00017287": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "Xo2-MhHl0Xk", "text": {"Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00000-00001709-00002983": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00001-00002984-00003213": "a", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00002-00003214-00003811": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00003-00003811-00005173": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00004-00005174-00005999": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00005-00006000-00007083": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00006-00007084-00008540": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00007-00008541-00010952": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00008-00010953-00012683": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00009-00012684-00018343": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00010-00018344-00019019": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00011-00019020-00020540": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00012-00020541-00021083": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00013-00021084-00021200": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00014-00021201-00021801": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00015-00021802-00022483": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00016-00022484-00023883": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00017-00023884-00024795": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00018-00024796-00029487": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00019-00029488-00032283": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00020-00032283-00034556": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00021-00034557-00035413": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00022-00035414-00036316": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00023-00036317-00037270": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00024-00037271-00038931": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00025-00038932-00043217": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00026-00043218-00043483": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00027-00043484-00044273": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00028-00044274-00045401": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00029-00045402-00047562": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00030-00047563-00047702": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00031-00047703-00050571": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00032-00050572-00051139": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00033-00051140-00051703": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00034-00051704-00052723": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00035-00052724-00053888": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00036-00053889-00055404": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00037-00055405-00056194": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00038-00056195-00057619": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00039-00057620-00059535": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00040-00059536-00060282": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00041-00060283-00061682": "bangladesh", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00042-00061683-00063732": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00043-00063733-00066228": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00044-00066229-00070082": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00045-00070083-00072275": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00046-00072276-00072882": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00047-00072883-00074326": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00048-00074327-00075440": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00049-00075441-00076585": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00050-00076586-00079074": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00051-00079075-00079658": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00052-00079659-00079882": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00053-00079883-00081635": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00054-00081636-00084493": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00055-00084494-00086602": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00056-00086603-00088361": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00057-00088362-00089438": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00058-00089439-00089682": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00059-00089683-00094244": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00060-00094245-00095979": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00061-00095980-00096682": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00062-00096683-00098082": "foreign", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00063-00098083-00099088": "me", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00064-00099089-00100167": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00065-00100168-00100882": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00066-00100883-00101063": "my", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00067-00101064-00101646": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00068-00101647-00102471": "[Music]", "Xo2-MhHl0Xk-00069-00102472-00102679": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "Xo7PkWpIR8u", "text": {"Xo7PkWpIR8u-00000-00000003-00000586": "around town calling for help", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00001-00000587-00000923": "hey that car just ran a red light and", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00002-00000924-00001274": "hit that truck is anyone hurt I don't", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00003-00001275-00002152": "know let's call 911 interpose office on", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00004-00002153-00002359": "Charles Street it looks like a man is", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00005-00002360-00002831": "hurt yes it just happened okay thanks", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00006-00002832-00003179": "bye what did they say they're going to", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00007-00003180-00003374": "send an ambulance and a police car right", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00008-00003375-00004160": "away good they're here I hope the man is", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00009-00004161-00004517": "okay I know you have to be so careful", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00010-00004518-00005118": "when you're driving language notes hey", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00011-00005119-00005488": "this expression is used to show surprise", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00012-00005489-00005818": "notice how that car just ran a red light", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00013-00005819-00006127": "and hit that truck is said with a lot of", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00014-00006128-00006692": "energy is anyone hurt this is a yes/no", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00015-00006693-00007003": "question so the intonation rises at the", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00016-00007004-00007048": "end", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00017-00007050-00007355": "notice how this question is asked in a", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00018-00007356-00007889": "worried way 9 1 1 is the phone number", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00019-00007890-00008195": "you dial for emergency services the", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00020-00008196-00008392": "person who answers will ask you", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00021-00008393-00008617": "questions about the emergency situation", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00022-00008618-00008892": "and then send out the necessary", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00023-00008893-00009191": "emergency services which may include", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00024-00009192-00009506": "police officers firefighters and an", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00025-00009507-00009956": "ambulance I'd like to report a car", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00026-00009957-00010217": "accident near the post office on Charles", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00027-00010218-00010278": "Street", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00028-00010279-00010621": "notice how the key words car accident", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00029-00010622-00010919": "post office and Charles Street are", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00030-00010920-00011198": "stressed these are the important details", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00031-00011199-00011735": "that the emergency services need it just", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00032-00011736-00012028": "happened is a way of saying it happened", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00033-00012029-00012401": "a moment ago notice the stress on just", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00034-00012402-00012670": "which emphasizes that the accident", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00035-00012671-00013147": "happened very very recently what did", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00036-00013148-00013394": "they say notice how", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00037-00013394-00013694": "say is emphasized but the intonation", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00038-00013694-00014054": "falls at the end of the word this is a", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00039-00014055-00014210": "what question", "Xo7PkWpIR8u-00040-00014211-00014654": "so the intonation falls at the end"}}, {"audio_id": "XorBDBIz9y0", "text": {"XorBDBIz9y0-00000-00000024-00000366": "and people will", "XorBDBIz9y0-00001-00000367-00000551": "okay so we are now recording thanks so", "XorBDBIz9y0-00002-00000552-00000774": "much alan um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00003-00000775-00001103": "welcome everyone to um our 10 o'clock", "XorBDBIz9y0-00004-00001104-00001319": "session eastern standard time at oe", "XorBDBIz9y0-00005-00001320-00001391": "global", "XorBDBIz9y0-00006-00001392-00001558": "my name is lena patterson i'm so pleased", "XorBDBIz9y0-00007-00001559-00001830": "to invite you here to this presentation", "XorBDBIz9y0-00008-00001832-00002039": "um with james glapper gross guide cable", "XorBDBIz9y0-00009-00002039-00002191": "green kurt newton", "XorBDBIz9y0-00010-00002192-00002431": "and lisa petrides and i'm going to ask", "XorBDBIz9y0-00011-00002432-00002558": "them all to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00012-00002559-00002883": "introduce themselves and and take it", "XorBDBIz9y0-00013-00002884-00003231": "away", "XorBDBIz9y0-00014-00003232-00003351": "thank you so much lina for the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00015-00003352-00003622": "introduction and uh it's great to uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00016-00003623-00003854": "to see all of you turned out for this uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00017-00003855-00004038": "for this conversation really excited to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00018-00004039-00004095": "uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00019-00004096-00004279": "um reflect back on some of the work that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00020-00004280-00004438": "we've been doing in this uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00021-00004439-00004702": "open 2020 working group you know share", "XorBDBIz9y0-00022-00004703-00004791": "some of our thinking", "XorBDBIz9y0-00023-00004792-00004975": "and more importantly engage in a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00024-00004976-00005135": "conversation with you all about", "XorBDBIz9y0-00025-00005136-00005302": "um the direction that these", "XorBDBIz9y0-00026-00005303-00005486": "conversations are heading", "XorBDBIz9y0-00027-00005487-00005783": "uh as lena mentioned i'm you know joined", "XorBDBIz9y0-00028-00005784-00005854": "here by", "XorBDBIz9y0-00029-00005855-00006111": "you know several members participants in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00030-00006112-00006238": "the in the working", "XorBDBIz9y0-00031-00006239-00006567": "group um we've got the james clapper", "XorBDBIz9y0-00032-00006568-00006927": "uh gross clag cable green peter kaufman", "XorBDBIz9y0-00033-00006928-00007246": "and uh lisa petraeus um and i'll", "XorBDBIz9y0-00034-00007247-00007495": "ask them in in a moment to uh to go", "XorBDBIz9y0-00035-00007495-00007623": "around and just give a little more", "XorBDBIz9y0-00036-00007623-00007695": "introduction", "XorBDBIz9y0-00037-00007695-00007863": "you know from their perspective about", "XorBDBIz9y0-00038-00007864-00007998": "the work that they do", "XorBDBIz9y0-00039-00008000-00008255": "and uh and and how it connects into the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00040-00008256-00008327": "bigger picture", "XorBDBIz9y0-00041-00008328-00008767": "let me begin by uh reflecting on", "XorBDBIz9y0-00042-00008768-00008959": "the nature of this group where it came", "XorBDBIz9y0-00043-00008960-00009119": "from what its goals were", "XorBDBIz9y0-00044-00009120-00009359": "uh just as a way to frame the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00045-00009360-00009478": "conversation", "XorBDBIz9y0-00046-00009479-00009831": "um so the open 2020 working group was", "XorBDBIz9y0-00047-00009832-00010183": "was convened you know uh you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-00048-00010184-00010503": "by mit open learning and a number of our", "XorBDBIz9y0-00049-00010504-00010583": "colleagues", "XorBDBIz9y0-00050-00010584-00010895": "in in this broader mission", "XorBDBIz9y0-00051-00010896-00011174": "uh to just take stock of where we are", "XorBDBIz9y0-00052-00011175-00011231": "you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-00053-00011232-00011463": "roughly 20 years after the founding of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00054-00011464-00011606": "mit open courseware", "XorBDBIz9y0-00055-00011607-00011870": "and the launch of you know what really", "XorBDBIz9y0-00056-00011871-00012167": "has become a massive and diverse", "XorBDBIz9y0-00057-00012168-00012487": "movement where are we", "XorBDBIz9y0-00058-00012488-00012678": "what are the what are the what are the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00059-00012679-00012799": "grand themes that are", "XorBDBIz9y0-00060-00012800-00012966": "that are playing out there and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00061-00012967-00013207": "especially as we might be able to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00062-00013208-00013407": "to have conversations across the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00063-00013408-00013543": "different sectors", "XorBDBIz9y0-00064-00013544-00013783": "from this rich and diverse ecosystem", "XorBDBIz9y0-00065-00013784-00013943": "what are what are some new opportunities", "XorBDBIz9y0-00066-00013944-00014015": "for us to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00067-00014016-00014294": "to work together to collaborate um to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00068-00014295-00014383": "develop", "XorBDBIz9y0-00069-00014384-00014647": "you know new capacities that are that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00070-00014647-00014775": "are fitting for the next", "XorBDBIz9y0-00071-00014776-00015079": "20 years of of open learning", "XorBDBIz9y0-00072-00015080-00015247": "so we pulled people together from a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00073-00015247-00015422": "number of different sectors", "XorBDBIz9y0-00074-00015423-00015750": "uh you know tried to get together on a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00075-00015751-00015911": "occasional sort of quarterly basis", "XorBDBIz9y0-00076-00015912-00016071": "physically uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00077-00016072-00016511": "to um to bring our our visions together", "XorBDBIz9y0-00078-00016512-00016743": "think about reflect upon the best", "XorBDBIz9y0-00079-00016744-00016871": "practices that were emerging in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00080-00016872-00017071": "different sectors and uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00081-00017072-00017311": "and try to crystallize some ideas and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00082-00017312-00017630": "and move things forward", "XorBDBIz9y0-00083-00017631-00017867": "there are materials that we've", "XorBDBIz9y0-00084-00017868-00018039": "documented as we went through this", "XorBDBIz9y0-00085-00018040-00018335": "process they're available on a wiki", "XorBDBIz9y0-00086-00018336-00018614": "and i put the the link to the wiki in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00087-00018615-00018686": "the uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00088-00018687-00018847": "the description for this event but i'll", "XorBDBIz9y0-00089-00018848-00019494": "uh i'll drop it into the chat", "XorBDBIz9y0-00090-00019495-00019783": "as as we continue on with so i'll kick", "XorBDBIz9y0-00091-00019784-00019886": "off the introduction round", "XorBDBIz9y0-00092-00019887-00020199": "so i'm a director of mit opencourseware", "XorBDBIz9y0-00093-00020200-00020447": "i've uh i've worked for opencourseware", "XorBDBIz9y0-00094-00020448-00020639": "since 2004 a couple years", "XorBDBIz9y0-00095-00020640-00020886": "after it founded became director a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00096-00020887-00021014": "couple years ago", "XorBDBIz9y0-00097-00021015-00021350": "and i'm particularly you know you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-00098-00021351-00021558": "thrilled to be working at this moment", "XorBDBIz9y0-00099-00021559-00021647": "when there are", "XorBDBIz9y0-00100-00021648-00021911": "there are so many you know opportunities", "XorBDBIz9y0-00101-00021912-00022086": "that are opening up as", "XorBDBIz9y0-00102-00022087-00022350": "um the world is is understanding what", "XorBDBIz9y0-00103-00022351-00022543": "open education and open knowledge more", "XorBDBIz9y0-00104-00022544-00022607": "generally", "XorBDBIz9y0-00105-00022608-00023039": "is capable of creating um i'd like to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00106-00023040-00023350": "hand off now to uh let's see we'll go in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00107-00023351-00023439": "order of uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00108-00023440-00023750": "james cable this alphabetical james", "XorBDBIz9y0-00109-00023751-00023807": "cable", "XorBDBIz9y0-00110-00023808-00024007": "peter and lisa and if each of you would", "XorBDBIz9y0-00111-00024008-00024207": "like to just take a couple minutes to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00112-00024208-00024327": "introduce yourselves", "XorBDBIz9y0-00113-00024328-00024655": "and uh tell us about your work", "XorBDBIz9y0-00114-00024656-00024799": "sure thanks kurt hey everybody it's", "XorBDBIz9y0-00115-00024800-00025014": "great to be here good morning from los", "XorBDBIz9y0-00116-00025015-00025383": "angeles my name is james um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00117-00025384-00025599": "my day job is with college of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00118-00025600-00025806": "canyons where i'm a dean", "XorBDBIz9y0-00119-00025807-00026043": "and college of the canyons is one of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00120-00026044-00026311": "115 california community colleges and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00121-00026312-00026455": "the california community colleges", "XorBDBIz9y0-00122-00026456-00026574": "comprise", "XorBDBIz9y0-00123-00026575-00026807": "the largest system of higher education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00124-00026808-00026943": "in the united states", "XorBDBIz9y0-00125-00026944-00027158": "and community colleges overall serve", "XorBDBIz9y0-00126-00027160-00027383": "about 50 percent of all students in the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00127-00027383-00027574": "united states so uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00128-00027575-00027902": "we're very much uh uh in the mainstream", "XorBDBIz9y0-00129-00027904-00028023": "of education and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00130-00028024-00028358": "really focused on teaching my work has", "XorBDBIz9y0-00131-00028360-00028679": "focused uh most recently on helping", "XorBDBIz9y0-00132-00028680-00028895": "other community colleges to develop z", "XorBDBIz9y0-00133-00028895-00029118": "degrees or zero textbook cost", "XorBDBIz9y0-00134-00029119-00029311": "pathways built around open educational", "XorBDBIz9y0-00135-00029312-00029455": "resources", "XorBDBIz9y0-00136-00029456-00029639": "i've also been uh deeply involved with", "XorBDBIz9y0-00137-00029639-00029814": "the with our host organization open", "XorBDBIz9y0-00138-00029816-00029958": "education global i'm a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00139-00029960-00030111": "past president of the board and just", "XorBDBIz9y0-00140-00030112-00030551": "really happy to be here thanks", "XorBDBIz9y0-00141-00030552-00030751": "thanks james hi everybody my name is", "XorBDBIz9y0-00142-00030752-00030951": "cable green i'm the director of open", "XorBDBIz9y0-00143-00030952-00031007": "education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00144-00031008-00031311": "at creative commons i've been at cc for", "XorBDBIz9y0-00145-00031312-00031567": "about 10 years before that worked in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00146-00031568-00031679": "community colleges", "XorBDBIz9y0-00147-00031680-00031870": "and in systems of higher education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00148-00031872-00031990": "across the us", "XorBDBIz9y0-00149-00031991-00033007": "looking forward to today's conversation", "XorBDBIz9y0-00150-00033008-00033327": "uh peter is that you you're up next", "XorBDBIz9y0-00151-00033328-00033631": "hi sorry alphabet is tricky", "XorBDBIz9y0-00152-00033632-00033935": "um hi i'm peter kaufman at mit", "XorBDBIz9y0-00153-00033936-00034167": "open learning thank you so much everyone", "XorBDBIz9y0-00154-00034168-00034367": "for joining from all over", "XorBDBIz9y0-00155-00034368-00034662": "uh the place um i work in strategic", "XorBDBIz9y0-00156-00034663-00034751": "initiatives", "XorBDBIz9y0-00157-00034752-00035118": "and some resource development at um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00158-00035119-00035295": "at open learning and one of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00159-00035296-00035462": "strategic initiatives i've been lucky", "XorBDBIz9y0-00160-00035463-00035615": "enough to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00161-00035616-00035951": "um work on is this open 2020 working", "XorBDBIz9y0-00162-00035952-00036102": "group um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00163-00036103-00036407": "uh with kurt and and with others who are", "XorBDBIz9y0-00164-00036408-00036759": "speaking today so and others who are um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00165-00036760-00036927": "in attendance and participating on the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00166-00036928-00037118": "call today so thank you", "XorBDBIz9y0-00167-00037119-00037551": "again for the opportunity okay", "XorBDBIz9y0-00168-00037552-00037911": "i'm lisa hi i'm lisa petrinis and i", "XorBDBIz9y0-00169-00037912-00038207": "am president and founder of iscme the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00170-00038208-00038359": "institute for the study of knowledge", "XorBDBIz9y0-00171-00038360-00038543": "management and education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00172-00038544-00038951": "and since 2007 we have been", "XorBDBIz9y0-00173-00038952-00039223": "running a open education library called", "XorBDBIz9y0-00174-00039224-00039295": "oer", "XorBDBIz9y0-00175-00039296-00039599": "commons and we also run another couple", "XorBDBIz9y0-00176-00039600-00039783": "of dozen of libraries for", "XorBDBIz9y0-00177-00039784-00040079": "institutions and higher ed k-12 and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00178-00040080-00040223": "ministries of education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00179-00040224-00040607": "around the globe trying to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00180-00040608-00040943": "entice and support uh the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00181-00040944-00041167": "discovery sharing and collaboration", "XorBDBIz9y0-00182-00041168-00041255": "around open", "XorBDBIz9y0-00183-00041256-00041495": "educational resources and i'm also the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00184-00041496-00041558": "proud", "XorBDBIz9y0-00185-00041559-00041862": "uh trustee elect of uh my local", "XorBDBIz9y0-00186-00041863-00042083": "community college district here in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00187-00042084-00042207": "california", "XorBDBIz9y0-00188-00042208-00042358": "and just delighted to be here on this", "XorBDBIz9y0-00189-00042359-00042743": "conversation today with you all", "XorBDBIz9y0-00190-00042744-00043087": "yeah thanks thanks lisa yeah um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00191-00043088-00043239": "as peter noted we have a few other", "XorBDBIz9y0-00192-00043240-00043430": "members from the working group who are", "XorBDBIz9y0-00193-00043431-00043502": "also", "XorBDBIz9y0-00194-00043503-00043790": "in the participants and as we as we go", "XorBDBIz9y0-00195-00043791-00043879": "through here", "XorBDBIz9y0-00196-00043880-00044158": "you know we want this to be you know uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00197-00044159-00044343": "to open up into a dialogue and a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00198-00044344-00044415": "discussion", "XorBDBIz9y0-00199-00044416-00044679": "and uh hope that we'll get to uh to hear", "XorBDBIz9y0-00200-00044680-00044790": "from some of them as well", "XorBDBIz9y0-00201-00044791-00045167": "um we've got uh uh who did i see", "XorBDBIz9y0-00202-00045168-00045351": "ryan erickson clueless we got richard", "XorBDBIz9y0-00203-00045352-00045487": "sebastian", "XorBDBIz9y0-00204-00045488-00045799": "uh we got willam also um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00205-00045800-00046030": "i may have missed others too but i", "XorBDBIz9y0-00206-00046031-00046151": "noticed", "XorBDBIz9y0-00207-00046152-00046351": "i know at least several others coming in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00208-00046352-00046583": "on the chat so that's great", "XorBDBIz9y0-00209-00046584-00046943": "um so i wanted to start off by um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00210-00046944-00047255": "by reflecting on um this", "XorBDBIz9y0-00211-00047256-00047455": "kind of vision statement process that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00212-00047456-00047655": "began with that we began with", "XorBDBIz9y0-00213-00047656-00047799": "about 18 months ago when the group", "XorBDBIz9y0-00214-00047800-00048062": "kicked off um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00215-00048063-00048279": "acknowledging that we come from you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-00216-00048280-00048486": "you know a wide range of different", "XorBDBIz9y0-00217-00048487-00048623": "sectors and the work that we do on a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00218-00048624-00048823": "day-to-day basis is really grounded", "XorBDBIz9y0-00219-00048824-00049415": "in in all these different realities", "XorBDBIz9y0-00220-00049416-00049662": "we asked the participants in the group", "XorBDBIz9y0-00221-00049663-00049743": "to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00222-00049744-00050071": "you know uh their view of of uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00223-00050072-00050383": "what their vision statement was for for", "XorBDBIz9y0-00224-00050384-00050527": "open education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00225-00050528-00050743": "what what they what they would like it", "XorBDBIz9y0-00226-00050744-00050830": "to be", "XorBDBIz9y0-00227-00050831-00050974": "now and what they'd like to become in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00228-00050975-00051151": "the future um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00229-00051152-00051463": "a lot has gone on in the last 18 months", "XorBDBIz9y0-00230-00051464-00051742": "you know some of it i'll say planned but", "XorBDBIz9y0-00231-00051744-00051894": "a lot of it unplanned a lot of it", "XorBDBIz9y0-00232-00051895-00052087": "disruptive and i'd like to uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00233-00052088-00052454": "to ask our panelists you know to reflect", "XorBDBIz9y0-00234-00052455-00052542": "on", "XorBDBIz9y0-00235-00052544-00052799": "their view of of their vision for open", "XorBDBIz9y0-00236-00052800-00052950": "education and how that's", "XorBDBIz9y0-00237-00052951-00053191": "how that's evolved say over the past", "XorBDBIz9y0-00238-00053191-00053430": "couple years um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00239-00053432-00053750": "let me start we'll go uh we'll start by", "XorBDBIz9y0-00240-00053751-00053935": "the same uh the same order if we may", "XorBDBIz9y0-00241-00053936-00054230": "uh james would you like to uh to reflect", "XorBDBIz9y0-00242-00054232-00054359": "on that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00243-00054360-00054559": "yeah thanks kurt well you know when i", "XorBDBIz9y0-00244-00054560-00054719": "when i think back to uh was a year a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00245-00054720-00054838": "year and a half ago when we first", "XorBDBIz9y0-00246-00054839-00054919": "convened", "XorBDBIz9y0-00247-00054920-00055247": "uh one of the one of the um major points", "XorBDBIz9y0-00248-00055248-00055287": "that i", "XorBDBIz9y0-00249-00055288-00055575": "that i tried to try to make was uh to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00250-00055576-00055766": "focus on the needs of learners and what", "XorBDBIz9y0-00251-00055767-00055942": "what the ultimate needs of our learners", "XorBDBIz9y0-00252-00055944-00055999": "are", "XorBDBIz9y0-00253-00056000-00056142": "uh whether they're formal learners or", "XorBDBIz9y0-00254-00056144-00056366": "informal learners um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00255-00056367-00056535": "but our need the needs of our learners", "XorBDBIz9y0-00256-00056536-00056726": "go beyond uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00257-00056727-00056919": "simple instructional materials right if", "XorBDBIz9y0-00258-00056920-00057054": "we if we talk about", "XorBDBIz9y0-00259-00057055-00057230": "uh moving from costly instructional", "XorBDBIz9y0-00260-00057232-00057479": "materials or closed knowledge", "XorBDBIz9y0-00261-00057479-00057671": "to free instructional materials and open", "XorBDBIz9y0-00262-00057672-00057871": "knowledge that's great but that's not", "XorBDBIz9y0-00263-00057872-00058030": "really what our learners", "XorBDBIz9y0-00264-00058032-00058430": "are are after our learners are after", "XorBDBIz9y0-00265-00058432-00058799": "uh skills knowledge a better life", "XorBDBIz9y0-00266-00058800-00059111": "full participation in civil society uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00267-00059112-00059254": "particularly those of us who were", "XorBDBIz9y0-00268-00059255-00059407": "involved in community colleges you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-00269-00059408-00059519": "really focus on", "XorBDBIz9y0-00270-00059520-00059847": "expanding uh access and bringing more", "XorBDBIz9y0-00271-00059848-00060015": "people into higher education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00272-00060016-00060182": "uh i so again that that was one of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00273-00060183-00060319": "main points that i was trying to make", "XorBDBIz9y0-00274-00060320-00060438": "throughout our conversations over the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00275-00060439-00060623": "past year and a year and a half", "XorBDBIz9y0-00276-00060624-00060887": "and i think if anything uh i feel more", "XorBDBIz9y0-00277-00060888-00060950": "urgent", "XorBDBIz9y0-00278-00060951-00061263": "about that today than than when we first", "XorBDBIz9y0-00279-00061264-00061342": "convened", "XorBDBIz9y0-00280-00061344-00061647": "uh with what we see going on in in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00281-00061648-00061799": "american politics but certainly in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00282-00061800-00061966": "politics all over the world", "XorBDBIz9y0-00283-00061967-00062247": "uh uh there's there's there's more of an", "XorBDBIz9y0-00284-00062248-00062350": "attempt i think", "XorBDBIz9y0-00285-00062351-00062654": "by some traditional elites to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00286-00062655-00063006": "close knowledge and to uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00287-00063007-00063326": "erect erect barriers to access", "XorBDBIz9y0-00288-00063327-00063599": "uh and full participation in civil", "XorBDBIz9y0-00289-00063600-00063679": "society", "XorBDBIz9y0-00290-00063679-00063919": "our friend katsu shigatsu uh yesterday", "XorBDBIz9y0-00291-00063920-00064094": "in the in the opening session", "XorBDBIz9y0-00292-00064095-00064430": "uh uh uh uh giving us a tour of what's", "XorBDBIz9y0-00293-00064432-00064615": "going on in asia uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00294-00064616-00064991": "made the point that uh uh when when", "XorBDBIz9y0-00295-00064991-00065254": "japan opened courseware first started uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00296-00065255-00065311": "they were", "XorBDBIz9y0-00297-00065312-00065463": "they encountered a lot of opposition", "XorBDBIz9y0-00298-00065464-00065631": "from uh traditional", "XorBDBIz9y0-00299-00065632-00065935": "academics precisely because as he put it", "XorBDBIz9y0-00300-00065936-00066247": "uh education was about secrecy", "XorBDBIz9y0-00301-00066248-00066471": "and uh and open education threatened the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00302-00066472-00066647": "secrecy of knowledge so", "XorBDBIz9y0-00303-00066648-00066879": "i feel yeah again a greater sense of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00304-00066880-00066982": "urgency about", "XorBDBIz9y0-00305-00066983-00067191": "breaking down the barriers than i did a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00306-00067192-00067535": "year ago", "XorBDBIz9y0-00307-00067536-00067847": "okay thanks james uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00308-00067848-00068199": "cable i think you're next all right", "XorBDBIz9y0-00309-00068200-00068431": "uh let me just make sure i'm unmuted", "XorBDBIz9y0-00310-00068432-00068582": "there we go", "XorBDBIz9y0-00311-00068583-00068903": "uh let's see last few years um i would", "XorBDBIz9y0-00312-00068904-00068943": "say", "XorBDBIz9y0-00313-00068944-00069255": "two big things changed in my view", "XorBDBIz9y0-00314-00069256-00069647": "uh one was we got what's called the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00315-00069648-00069894": "unesco recommendation on open education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00316-00069895-00070055": "resources so", "XorBDBIz9y0-00317-00070056-00070263": "for those of you that follow what unesco", "XorBDBIz9y0-00318-00070264-00070391": "does in this space", "XorBDBIz9y0-00319-00070392-00070655": "they have over time all the way back to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00320-00070656-00070799": "2002", "XorBDBIz9y0-00321-00070800-00071038": "been very involved in the open education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00322-00071039-00071223": "space particularly in the open", "XorBDBIz9y0-00323-00071224-00071582": "content space in oer um in 2002 they", "XorBDBIz9y0-00324-00071583-00071679": "coined the term", "XorBDBIz9y0-00325-00071680-00072055": "oer uh in 2012 there was the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00326-00072056-00072343": "uh the declaration on oer from unesco", "XorBDBIz9y0-00327-00072344-00072447": "which was", "XorBDBIz9y0-00328-00072448-00072623": "essentially a heads up to governments", "XorBDBIz9y0-00329-00072624-00072791": "around the world that this was something", "XorBDBIz9y0-00330-00072792-00072935": "that was important that they ought to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00331-00072936-00072999": "think about", "XorBDBIz9y0-00332-00073000-00073303": "as they are planning and uh working", "XorBDBIz9y0-00333-00073304-00073526": "on reforms within their education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00334-00073527-00073615": "systems", "XorBDBIz9y0-00335-00073616-00073887": "uh and then in 2017 there was a big", "XorBDBIz9y0-00336-00073888-00074103": "world oer congress where", "XorBDBIz9y0-00337-00074104-00074271": "five years after the declaration", "XorBDBIz9y0-00338-00074272-00074431": "countries came together and said here's", "XorBDBIz9y0-00339-00074432-00074567": "the progress we've made here the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00340-00074568-00074726": "challenges we're still having", "XorBDBIz9y0-00341-00074727-00075111": "and then just this past november in 2019", "XorBDBIz9y0-00342-00075112-00075311": "the unesco member states at their", "XorBDBIz9y0-00343-00075312-00075511": "general conference unanimously", "XorBDBIz9y0-00344-00075512-00075847": "adopted the unesco recommendation on", "XorBDBIz9y0-00345-00075848-00075999": "oer so if you haven't seen this i'll", "XorBDBIz9y0-00346-00076000-00076175": "share the link in the chat after", "XorBDBIz9y0-00347-00076176-00076479": "uh after i stop talking here um it's", "XorBDBIz9y0-00348-00076480-00076655": "worth reading and what's important about", "XorBDBIz9y0-00349-00076656-00076743": "it is it's an", "XorBDBIz9y0-00350-00076744-00076991": "international framework from an", "XorBDBIz9y0-00351-00076992-00077223": "international governmental organization", "XorBDBIz9y0-00352-00077224-00077423": "and one that's part of the family of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00353-00077424-00077543": "united nations", "XorBDBIz9y0-00354-00077544-00077806": "that says hey governments of the world", "XorBDBIz9y0-00355-00077807-00077991": "open education is important", "XorBDBIz9y0-00356-00077992-00078311": "and here are the very specific actions", "XorBDBIz9y0-00357-00078312-00078638": "that your government can take to advance", "XorBDBIz9y0-00358-00078639-00078879": "open education in your countries and not", "XorBDBIz9y0-00359-00078880-00079111": "just about content but around policy", "XorBDBIz9y0-00360-00079112-00079455": "procurement sustainability uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00361-00079456-00079623": "professional development opportunities", "XorBDBIz9y0-00362-00079624-00079894": "there's a whole slate of activities", "XorBDBIz9y0-00363-00079895-00080175": "at a very specific level and then the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00364-00080176-00080375": "the various ngos of the world", "XorBDBIz9y0-00365-00080376-00080719": "iscme creative commons oe global", "XorBDBIz9y0-00366-00080720-00081023": "spark oer africa many ngos have come", "XorBDBIz9y0-00367-00081024-00081087": "together", "XorBDBIz9y0-00368-00081088-00081399": "that's not an exhaustive list to work", "XorBDBIz9y0-00369-00081400-00081703": "together to collaboratively help these", "XorBDBIz9y0-00370-00081704-00081823": "national governments", "XorBDBIz9y0-00371-00081824-00082062": "learn about and implement this", "XorBDBIz9y0-00372-00082063-00082279": "recommendation that they all voted yes", "XorBDBIz9y0-00373-00082280-00082326": "on", "XorBDBIz9y0-00374-00082327-00082471": "so i think that's a big deal that sort", "XorBDBIz9y0-00375-00082472-00082703": "of the end state of that is to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00376-00082704-00082935": "solve what's called out in sustainable", "XorBDBIz9y0-00377-00082936-00083055": "goal", "XorBDBIz9y0-00378-00083056-00083215": "sustainable development goal number four", "XorBDBIz9y0-00379-00083216-00083447": "which is all about access to education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00380-00083448-00083575": "for everybody", "XorBDBIz9y0-00381-00083576-00083726": "the second big thing uh that i think", "XorBDBIz9y0-00382-00083727-00083887": "we've seen uh really in the last", "XorBDBIz9y0-00383-00083888-00084031": "probably three years", "XorBDBIz9y0-00384-00084032-00084375": "is this um acknowledging that content is", "XorBDBIz9y0-00385-00084376-00084567": "still really important and policy work", "XorBDBIz9y0-00386-00084568-00084615": "is still", "XorBDBIz9y0-00387-00084616-00084935": "critical but to really go after and talk", "XorBDBIz9y0-00388-00084936-00085191": "a lot and spend more time and effort on", "XorBDBIz9y0-00389-00085192-00085423": "the third area of open education which", "XorBDBIz9y0-00390-00085424-00085535": "is really inclusive", "XorBDBIz9y0-00391-00085536-00085806": "pedagogy and there's uh with everything", "XorBDBIz9y0-00392-00085807-00085975": "that's been going on in the world from", "XorBDBIz9y0-00393-00085976-00086294": "covid to looking at systematic racism", "XorBDBIz9y0-00394-00086295-00086567": "in in our systems of government", "XorBDBIz9y0-00395-00086568-00086671": "education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00396-00086672-00086950": "various sectors of society a big", "XorBDBIz9y0-00397-00086951-00087143": "discussion about open education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00398-00087144-00087462": "being a place to have conversations", "XorBDBIz9y0-00399-00087463-00087567": "about", "XorBDBIz9y0-00400-00087568-00087887": "equity about social justice and um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00401-00087888-00088159": "not as the only solution for that but as", "XorBDBIz9y0-00402-00088160-00088223": "part", "XorBDBIz9y0-00403-00088224-00088375": "of the solution and so there's a lot of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00404-00088376-00088575": "work happening right now to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00405-00088576-00088806": "think about who's developing the oer", "XorBDBIz9y0-00406-00088807-00089006": "where is it coming from whose voices are", "XorBDBIz9y0-00407-00089007-00089159": "in that conversations", "XorBDBIz9y0-00408-00089160-00089406": "is it uh is it supply or demand driven", "XorBDBIz9y0-00409-00089407-00089631": "uh what do the supply chains look like", "XorBDBIz9y0-00410-00089632-00089975": "how do we make sure that uh everybody is", "XorBDBIz9y0-00411-00089976-00090159": "uh is involved in these conversations", "XorBDBIz9y0-00412-00090160-00090287": "and not just", "XorBDBIz9y0-00413-00090288-00090550": "uh not just a few from one part of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00414-00090551-00090718": "world", "XorBDBIz9y0-00415-00090719-00091238": "thanks kurt thanks", "XorBDBIz9y0-00416-00091239-00091582": "um peter over you so", "XorBDBIz9y0-00417-00091583-00091726": "i'm really grateful to be part of this", "XorBDBIz9y0-00418-00091727-00091935": "open 2020 working group as i said", "XorBDBIz9y0-00419-00091936-00092159": "because it includes so many", "XorBDBIz9y0-00420-00092160-00092367": "uh such a combination i guess of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00421-00092368-00092926": "visionaries and and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00422-00092927-00093231": "but also like practical people", "XorBDBIz9y0-00423-00093232-00093359": "implementers", "XorBDBIz9y0-00424-00093360-00093511": "if that's a word i don't know if that's", "XorBDBIz9y0-00425-00093512-00093687": "a word but let's try it", "XorBDBIz9y0-00426-00093688-00094087": "um and you know the challenges that we", "XorBDBIz9y0-00427-00094088-00094503": "face um as educators and as", "XorBDBIz9y0-00428-00094504-00094687": "people who work in the information or", "XorBDBIz9y0-00429-00094688-00094823": "even media", "XorBDBIz9y0-00430-00094824-00095206": "environment are um weirdly", "XorBDBIz9y0-00431-00095207-00095550": "growing um deepening", "XorBDBIz9y0-00432-00095551-00095855": "since even we started this in may and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00433-00095856-00096199": "thanks to the generous support of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00434-00096200-00096423": "one of our co-conveners the hewlett", "XorBDBIz9y0-00435-00096424-00096655": "foundation", "XorBDBIz9y0-00436-00096656-00096967": "where we had our last uh our third most", "XorBDBIz9y0-00437-00096968-00097062": "recent meeting", "XorBDBIz9y0-00438-00097063-00097503": "um we had a conversation at cc global", "XorBDBIz9y0-00439-00097504-00097894": "touching on some of these um challenges", "XorBDBIz9y0-00440-00097895-00098055": "um but one that i would like to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00441-00098056-00098262": "highlight for us now is like", "XorBDBIz9y0-00442-00098263-00098559": "how does the work that goes into open", "XorBDBIz9y0-00443-00098560-00098711": "education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00444-00098712-00099006": "um itself fit into the larger framework", "XorBDBIz9y0-00445-00099007-00099135": "the larger", "XorBDBIz9y0-00446-00099136-00099447": "progressive framework of information and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00447-00099448-00099526": "sort of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00448-00099527-00099782": "free knowledge the kind of things that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00449-00099783-00099855": "you will see", "XorBDBIz9y0-00450-00099856-00100103": "in if you read nothing else about this", "XorBDBIz9y0-00451-00100104-00100191": "working group", "XorBDBIz9y0-00452-00100192-00100406": "and never visit with us again just take", "XorBDBIz9y0-00453-00100407-00100511": "a look at the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00454-00100512-00100855": "um sort of the mission uh ideals vision", "XorBDBIz9y0-00455-00100856-00101006": "statements that kurt", "XorBDBIz9y0-00456-00101007-00101318": "um thought of asking our group for at", "XorBDBIz9y0-00457-00101319-00101503": "the very beginning in may of last year", "XorBDBIz9y0-00458-00101504-00101574": "they're on", "XorBDBIz9y0-00459-00101575-00101894": "on the wiki they're incredibly moving um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00460-00101895-00102135": "how does our work fit into this larger", "XorBDBIz9y0-00461-00102136-00102247": "progressive framework", "XorBDBIz9y0-00462-00102248-00102558": "of information knowledge and media that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00463-00102559-00102878": "cable uh was also addressing um between", "XorBDBIz9y0-00464-00102879-00103086": "the third meeting that we had of this", "XorBDBIz9y0-00465-00103088-00103175": "four meeting", "XorBDBIz9y0-00466-00103176-00103375": "year that we envisioned and the fourth", "XorBDBIz9y0-00467-00103376-00103527": "meeting which is still", "XorBDBIz9y0-00468-00103528-00103710": "to happen we've had like pre-meetings", "XorBDBIz9y0-00469-00103711-00103902": "and like prep meetings for the fourth", "XorBDBIz9y0-00470-00103903-00103958": "meet", "XorBDBIz9y0-00471-00103959-00104271": "but between those two meetings um you", "XorBDBIz9y0-00472-00104272-00104302": "know", "XorBDBIz9y0-00473-00104303-00104551": "a lot happened including some of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00474-00104552-00104615": "things that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00475-00104616-00104863": "um previous speakers mentioned such as", "XorBDBIz9y0-00476-00104864-00104975": "the pandemic", "XorBDBIz9y0-00477-00104976-00105278": "which flipped us all on our heads um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00478-00105279-00105543": "even though mit and others have been", "XorBDBIz9y0-00479-00105544-00105719": "thinking and prepping and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00480-00105720-00105871": "are you know probably every member of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00481-00105872-00106127": "this conversation today", "XorBDBIz9y0-00482-00106128-00106486": "about online learning um the emergency", "XorBDBIz9y0-00483-00106488-00106751": "heightened um but also you know the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00484-00106752-00106863": "country", "XorBDBIz9y0-00485-00106864-00107134": "parts of it caught on fire again and and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00486-00107135-00107215": "um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00487-00107216-00107583": "these issues of systemic racism", "XorBDBIz9y0-00488-00107583-00107758": "and i know we have a later call today", "XorBDBIz9y0-00489-00107759-00107927": "about some of these questions", "XorBDBIz9y0-00490-00107928-00108231": "like um equality", "XorBDBIz9y0-00491-00108232-00108566": "um justice and freedom became", "XorBDBIz9y0-00492-00108567-00108943": "um yeah rose to the fore in ways that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00493-00108944-00109207": "you know made our mandate even more kind", "XorBDBIz9y0-00494-00109208-00109295": "of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00495-00109296-00109631": "explicit and you know so i'll say", "XorBDBIz9y0-00496-00109632-00109902": "there's a lot of talk about suppression", "XorBDBIz9y0-00497-00109903-00109983": "in the news", "XorBDBIz9y0-00498-00109983-00110239": "these days these hours but there's a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00499-00110240-00110351": "suppression of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00500-00110352-00110678": "like basic reason that's going on of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00501-00110679-00110734": "facts", "XorBDBIz9y0-00502-00110735-00111007": "of verifiable truths and while the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00503-00111008-00111110": "rights", "XorBDBIz9y0-00504-00111111-00111375": "to publish those things are not", "XorBDBIz9y0-00505-00111376-00111534": "necessarily", "XorBDBIz9y0-00506-00111535-00111719": "part of the sustainable development", "XorBDBIz9y0-00507-00111720-00111927": "goals that we talk about sometimes in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00508-00111928-00112071": "our in our working group they're not one", "XorBDBIz9y0-00509-00112072-00112247": "of the 17.", "XorBDBIz9y0-00510-00112248-00112486": "indeed education in our country is not", "XorBDBIz9y0-00511-00112488-00112734": "an explicit right in our constitution", "XorBDBIz9y0-00512-00112735-00113039": "we have like we're they're 180 countries", "XorBDBIz9y0-00513-00113040-00113254": "where education is in the constitution", "XorBDBIz9y0-00514-00113255-00113375": "ours is not", "XorBDBIz9y0-00515-00113376-00113607": "one of them but there is a universal", "XorBDBIz9y0-00516-00113608-00113775": "declaration of human rights", "XorBDBIz9y0-00517-00113776-00114095": "that calls these things out the freedom", "XorBDBIz9y0-00518-00114096-00114190": "of expression", "XorBDBIz9y0-00519-00114191-00114439": "uh the freedom of information and the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00520-00114440-00114663": "right to education and we need to think", "XorBDBIz9y0-00521-00114664-00114758": "about", "XorBDBIz9y0-00522-00114759-00115054": "how we can do better in all of our", "XorBDBIz9y0-00523-00115055-00115166": "online work", "XorBDBIz9y0-00524-00115167-00115470": "to fulfill those grand visions", "XorBDBIz9y0-00525-00115471-00115590": "[Music]", "XorBDBIz9y0-00526-00115591-00116283": "in this moment of pandemic and systemic", "XorBDBIz9y0-00527-00116283-00116639": "racism", "XorBDBIz9y0-00528-00116640-00117015": "thank you peter uh lisa how's", "XorBDBIz9y0-00529-00117016-00117319": "how's your vision doing yeah thank you", "XorBDBIz9y0-00530-00117320-00117527": "and certainly echoing some of the things", "XorBDBIz9y0-00531-00117528-00117751": "that my colleagues have just covered", "XorBDBIz9y0-00532-00117752-00117927": "um i guess the first one i just want to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00533-00117928-00118119": "start where peter left off was around", "XorBDBIz9y0-00534-00118120-00118527": "inclusion and how the absolute necessity", "XorBDBIz9y0-00535-00118528-00118878": "of bringing a more inclusive perspective", "XorBDBIz9y0-00536-00118879-00119207": "into open education who are those", "XorBDBIz9y0-00537-00119208-00119423": "partners that can do that with us how", "XorBDBIz9y0-00538-00119424-00119599": "can they be supported", "XorBDBIz9y0-00539-00119600-00119847": "uh for bringing in their content and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00540-00119848-00120015": "their practices", "XorBDBIz9y0-00541-00120016-00120286": "uh and their stories so it isn't just", "XorBDBIz9y0-00542-00120288-00120423": "about how do we find", "XorBDBIz9y0-00543-00120424-00120758": "that content and and popularize it but", "XorBDBIz9y0-00544-00120759-00120927": "really how do we engage", "XorBDBIz9y0-00545-00120928-00121078": "uh in the collaboration of those", "XorBDBIz9y0-00546-00121079-00121254": "communities that we have not", "XorBDBIz9y0-00547-00121255-00121566": "yet really engaged with and this also", "XorBDBIz9y0-00548-00121567-00121631": "includes", "XorBDBIz9y0-00549-00121632-00121839": "uh folks who are doing just terrific", "XorBDBIz9y0-00550-00121840-00121975": "work around", "XorBDBIz9y0-00551-00121976-00122166": "social emotional learning and global", "XorBDBIz9y0-00552-00122167-00122343": "climate change and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00553-00122344-00122614": "the diversity and social justice issues", "XorBDBIz9y0-00554-00122615-00122751": "how do we really bring", "XorBDBIz9y0-00555-00122752-00122951": "them into the fold and we've started to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00556-00122952-00123214": "see i think in the last 18 months how we", "XorBDBIz9y0-00557-00123215-00123247": "can", "XorBDBIz9y0-00558-00123248-00123543": "move forward from a community that has", "XorBDBIz9y0-00559-00123544-00123607": "been", "XorBDBIz9y0-00560-00123608-00123839": "somewhat narrowly focused on kind of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00561-00123840-00124158": "principles and the ethos of open", "XorBDBIz9y0-00562-00124159-00124327": "moving towards the infrastructure and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00563-00124328-00124583": "the policy recommendations all the way", "XorBDBIz9y0-00564-00124583-00124799": "to implementations in the classroom", "XorBDBIz9y0-00565-00124800-00125102": "as we define that remotely today so", "XorBDBIz9y0-00566-00125103-00125327": "that shift i think where i'm really", "XorBDBIz9y0-00567-00125328-00125551": "really starting to see in the last 18", "XorBDBIz9y0-00568-00125552-00125727": "months particularly in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00569-00125728-00126054": "those who who really are engaging in the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00570-00126055-00126175": "community in ways that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00571-00126176-00126471": "we hadn't before i think the second", "XorBDBIz9y0-00572-00126472-00126695": "piece really kind of dovetails on that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00573-00126696-00126783": "that is", "XorBDBIz9y0-00574-00126783-00126999": "there is just much more support and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00575-00127000-00127175": "backup for the perspective around", "XorBDBIz9y0-00576-00127176-00127383": "open education so you know that it's", "XorBDBIz9y0-00577-00127383-00127566": "affordable yes that we have free", "XorBDBIz9y0-00578-00127567-00127710": "textbooks yes", "XorBDBIz9y0-00579-00127711-00127902": "you know but that now we're really", "XorBDBIz9y0-00580-00127903-00128095": "getting that collaboration and support", "XorBDBIz9y0-00581-00128096-00128231": "for teaching and learning", "XorBDBIz9y0-00582-00128232-00128375": "it's been a huge emphasis on", "XorBDBIz9y0-00583-00128376-00128583": "professional development in the last", "XorBDBIz9y0-00584-00128583-00128758": "eight months not just here in the u.s", "XorBDBIz9y0-00585-00128759-00128910": "but around the world", "XorBDBIz9y0-00586-00128911-00129143": "that's a just a welcome opportunity to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00587-00129144-00129383": "be bringing an open education approach", "XorBDBIz9y0-00588-00129383-00129678": "into that similarly the intersection of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00589-00129679-00129886": "sort of the disciplines", "XorBDBIz9y0-00590-00129888-00130190": "the professional subject areas uh and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00591-00130191-00130399": "perhaps more importantly what i'm really", "XorBDBIz9y0-00592-00130400-00130734": "seeing now is the we're finally seeing", "XorBDBIz9y0-00593-00130735-00130927": "the connection of these top-down", "XorBDBIz9y0-00594-00130928-00131159": "efforts with the bottom-up initiatives", "XorBDBIz9y0-00595-00131160-00131390": "so we've had both for some time", "XorBDBIz9y0-00596-00131391-00131743": "i think cable you mentioned unesco", "XorBDBIz9y0-00597-00131744-00131919": "and the sdg goals that's a perfect", "XorBDBIz9y0-00598-00131920-00132135": "example it was sort of a hat tip to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00599-00132136-00132247": "government saying yep", "XorBDBIz9y0-00600-00132248-00132575": "get involved we're on this and and many", "XorBDBIz9y0-00601-00132576-00132639": "were", "XorBDBIz9y0-00602-00132640-00132863": "and so they are now kind of reaching", "XorBDBIz9y0-00603-00132864-00133102": "down to the implementers and similarly", "XorBDBIz9y0-00604-00133103-00133207": "some of the amazing", "XorBDBIz9y0-00605-00133208-00133487": "grassroots efforts that have blown into", "XorBDBIz9y0-00606-00133488-00133583": "full", "XorBDBIz9y0-00607-00133584-00133831": "you know full blossom open education you", "XorBDBIz9y0-00608-00133832-00133959": "know from oer", "XorBDBIz9y0-00609-00133960-00134190": "africa to i mean there's just there's so", "XorBDBIz9y0-00610-00134191-00134319": "many of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00611-00134320-00134590": "of these um that are doing that now so", "XorBDBIz9y0-00612-00134591-00134631": "so", "XorBDBIz9y0-00613-00134632-00134783": "essentially it's the intersection it's", "XorBDBIz9y0-00614-00134784-00134975": "the finally the meeting of kind of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00615-00134976-00135063": "bottom", "XorBDBIz9y0-00616-00135064-00135463": "up initiatives and the top-down um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00617-00135464-00135711": "uh policy and mandates that really do", "XorBDBIz9y0-00618-00135712-00135854": "have to be in place", "XorBDBIz9y0-00619-00135855-00136047": "uh to make this kind of more of a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00620-00136048-00136287": "sustainable endeavor", "XorBDBIz9y0-00621-00136288-00136654": "thanks yeah i uh i", "XorBDBIz9y0-00622-00136655-00136887": "completely share uh the excitement with", "XorBDBIz9y0-00623-00136888-00137023": "the alisa about the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00624-00137024-00137271": "seeing the bottom up and top down", "XorBDBIz9y0-00625-00137272-00137407": "starting to meet in these really", "XorBDBIz9y0-00626-00137408-00137583": "interesting places", "XorBDBIz9y0-00627-00137584-00137799": "curious what people are seeing about um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00628-00137800-00137902": "how well we're doing", "XorBDBIz9y0-00629-00137903-00138295": "at um at sharing uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00630-00138296-00138478": "the things that are coming up from this", "XorBDBIz9y0-00631-00138479-00138647": "incredibly rich diverse", "XorBDBIz9y0-00632-00138648-00138975": "kind of grassroots activities that are", "XorBDBIz9y0-00633-00138976-00139175": "going on things are so grounded in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00634-00139176-00139519": "in the local needs um the way", "XorBDBIz9y0-00635-00139520-00139678": "that learners and educators are trying", "XorBDBIz9y0-00636-00139679-00139927": "to work with things how are we doing at", "XorBDBIz9y0-00637-00139928-00140223": "um sharing those learnings more broadly", "XorBDBIz9y0-00638-00140224-00140343": "in creating the kind of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00639-00140344-00140495": "collaborations and infrastructure that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00640-00140496-00140719": "we need so that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00641-00140720-00140951": "you know within that incredibly diverse", "XorBDBIz9y0-00642-00140952-00141119": "uh situation", "XorBDBIz9y0-00643-00141120-00141423": "um we're we're building we're all", "XorBDBIz9y0-00644-00141424-00141695": "building collectively um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00645-00141696-00141887": "what what are you seeing how's that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00646-00141888-00142183": "feeling to you", "XorBDBIz9y0-00647-00142184-00142390": "well i'll i'll start off kurt i i'd say", "XorBDBIz9y0-00648-00142391-00142526": "i'm i'm very uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00649-00142527-00142863": "inspired by the open education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00650-00142864-00143023": "conference that took place uh that was", "XorBDBIz9y0-00651-00143024-00143166": "centered or hosted in the united states", "XorBDBIz9y0-00652-00143167-00143278": "last week had", "XorBDBIz9y0-00653-00143279-00143623": "uh which attracted 1500 participants", "XorBDBIz9y0-00654-00143624-00143783": "uh just two years ago the conference", "XorBDBIz9y0-00655-00143784-00143959": "attracted 400 participants then last", "XorBDBIz9y0-00656-00143960-00144119": "year was 800 and this year was", "XorBDBIz9y0-00657-00144120-00144471": "1500 and the central theme of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00658-00144472-00144575": "conference was", "XorBDBIz9y0-00659-00144576-00144823": "equity diversity and inclusion so", "XorBDBIz9y0-00660-00144824-00144951": "bringing more people", "XorBDBIz9y0-00661-00144952-00145231": "into the fold and more people into the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00662-00145232-00145435": "idea of open education but also", "XorBDBIz9y0-00663-00145436-00145766": "re-centering uh or centering", "XorBDBIz9y0-00664-00145767-00145983": "the purpose and being explicit about", "XorBDBIz9y0-00665-00145984-00146207": "what the purpose is of open education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00666-00146208-00146383": "and that is to again", "XorBDBIz9y0-00667-00146384-00146695": "uh uh bring more people in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00668-00146696-00146959": "uh help more people and more", "XorBDBIz9y0-00669-00146960-00147143": "perspectives and more stories and more", "XorBDBIz9y0-00670-00147144-00147231": "voices", "XorBDBIz9y0-00671-00147232-00147447": "uh fully participate in society and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00672-00147448-00147607": "shape our future and not", "XorBDBIz9y0-00673-00147608-00147790": "receive knowledge from someone else or", "XorBDBIz9y0-00674-00147791-00147919": "some other entity", "XorBDBIz9y0-00675-00147920-00148087": "uh so i think that's incredibly", "XorBDBIz9y0-00676-00148088-00148278": "inspiring and that's coming from the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00677-00148279-00148483": "grassroots really", "XorBDBIz9y0-00678-00148484-00148790": "in that's also what i see in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00679-00148791-00149014": "in my very local work or my work in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00680-00149015-00149183": "california", "XorBDBIz9y0-00681-00149184-00149502": "namely that the uh typical", "XorBDBIz9y0-00682-00149503-00149823": "faculty member who is interested in open", "XorBDBIz9y0-00683-00149824-00149935": "education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00684-00149936-00150271": "uh or adopting oer creating oer", "XorBDBIz9y0-00685-00150272-00150623": "is doing so more uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00686-00150624-00150990": "these days out of a sense of of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00687-00150991-00151271": "reshaping the narrative reshaping the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00688-00151272-00151471": "materials that students are using in the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00689-00151472-00151590": "classroom away", "XorBDBIz9y0-00690-00151591-00151831": "from that received elite knowledge", "XorBDBIz9y0-00691-00151832-00151999": "that's produced by some commercial", "XorBDBIz9y0-00692-00152000-00152207": "publisher a million miles away", "XorBDBIz9y0-00693-00152208-00152551": "and that is more focused on uh the the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00694-00152552-00152719": "community of students that you see in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00695-00152720-00152878": "front of in front of you", "XorBDBIz9y0-00696-00152879-00153054": "so i'm really inspired by that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00697-00153055-00153190": "nevertheless as", "XorBDBIz9y0-00698-00153191-00153359": "as cable mentioned and others have", "XorBDBIz9y0-00699-00153360-00153599": "mentioned uh within the united states at", "XorBDBIz9y0-00700-00153600-00153735": "least there's a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00701-00153736-00154199": "a very urgent uh task to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00702-00154200-00154439": "bring more voices and perspectives into", "XorBDBIz9y0-00703-00154440-00154599": "the field of open education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00704-00154600-00154790": "as much as you can call open education a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00705-00154791-00154935": "field it's a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00706-00154936-00155239": "in the united states it's a a blindingly", "XorBDBIz9y0-00707-00155240-00155311": "white", "XorBDBIz9y0-00708-00155312-00155623": "field uh that reflects white culture", "XorBDBIz9y0-00709-00155624-00155807": "uh and white white approaches to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00710-00155808-00156014": "education so we we really have to be", "XorBDBIz9y0-00711-00156015-00156166": "very uh intentional about", "XorBDBIz9y0-00712-00156167-00156495": "uh uh moving beyond that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00713-00156496-00156743": "so back to you then yeah yeah that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00714-00156744-00156831": "brings to mind uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00715-00156832-00157126": "something you had a way you'd ask the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00716-00157127-00157223": "question james in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00717-00157224-00157414": "in a in a previous conversation about", "XorBDBIz9y0-00718-00157415-00157526": "like you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-00719-00157527-00157726": "to bring in those voices what if we were", "XorBDBIz9y0-00720-00157727-00157839": "more intentional about", "XorBDBIz9y0-00721-00157840-00158095": "bringing in folks who don't think of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00722-00158096-00158351": "themselves as part of open education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00723-00158352-00158575": "but whose goals are so directly aligned", "XorBDBIz9y0-00724-00158576-00158702": "with what we're doing that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00725-00158703-00158983": "um make really powerful common cause and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00726-00158984-00159054": "uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00727-00159055-00159183": "where where might some of those", "XorBDBIz9y0-00728-00159184-00159390": "opportunities be yeah well", "XorBDBIz9y0-00729-00159391-00159551": "thanks kurt you know at the risk of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00730-00159552-00159711": "being being you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-00731-00159712-00159966": "critical of myself and my my friends", "XorBDBIz9y0-00732-00159967-00160031": "here", "XorBDBIz9y0-00733-00160032-00160183": "you know i think open education to a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00734-00160184-00160302": "large extent at least in the united", "XorBDBIz9y0-00735-00160303-00160526": "states and to some extent in europe", "XorBDBIz9y0-00736-00160527-00160726": "has been quite insular and at least", "XorBDBIz9y0-00737-00160727-00160847": "referred to this quite", "XorBDBIz9y0-00738-00160848-00161111": "quite self-satisfied you know we're", "XorBDBIz9y0-00739-00161112-00161375": "doing a wonderful job because", "XorBDBIz9y0-00740-00161376-00161511": "because of whatever metrics we're", "XorBDBIz9y0-00741-00161512-00161726": "pointing to um because we have this", "XorBDBIz9y0-00742-00161727-00161854": "you know wonderful wonderful these", "XorBDBIz9y0-00743-00161855-00162014": "wonderful conferences and we have", "XorBDBIz9y0-00744-00162015-00162239": "wonderful conversations with one another", "XorBDBIz9y0-00745-00162240-00162631": "but we're not necessarily uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00746-00162632-00162823": "framing ourselves or describing", "XorBDBIz9y0-00747-00162824-00163023": "ourselves as a tool to achieve", "XorBDBIz9y0-00748-00163024-00163223": "larger goals what are the larger goals", "XorBDBIz9y0-00749-00163224-00163439": "that we're actually after is the end", "XorBDBIz9y0-00750-00163440-00163535": "goal", "XorBDBIz9y0-00751-00163536-00163743": "that everybody uses an open textbook", "XorBDBIz9y0-00752-00163744-00163902": "well no", "XorBDBIz9y0-00753-00163903-00164078": "what is the end goal that forces us to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00754-00164079-00164238": "ask that question and to present", "XorBDBIz9y0-00755-00164239-00164287": "ourselves", "XorBDBIz9y0-00756-00164288-00164590": "as tools to achieve larger goals", "XorBDBIz9y0-00757-00164591-00164951": "that align with other education reform", "XorBDBIz9y0-00758-00164952-00165159": "efforts or other civil society", "XorBDBIz9y0-00759-00165160-00165335": "organizations so that's kind of a very", "XorBDBIz9y0-00760-00165336-00165447": "broad answer to the statement but i", "XorBDBIz9y0-00761-00165448-00165687": "think it's really important for us to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00762-00165688-00165902": "to get out of our own conversation and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00763-00165903-00166023": "to join", "XorBDBIz9y0-00764-00166024-00166343": "to join other organizations thank you", "XorBDBIz9y0-00765-00166344-00166671": "yeah i want to just add to that and uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00766-00166672-00166854": "for those of you who are who have your", "XorBDBIz9y0-00767-00166855-00166975": "video on um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00768-00166976-00167199": "it was a very foggy morning here in half", "XorBDBIz9y0-00769-00167200-00167390": "moon bay and the sun just came out which", "XorBDBIz9y0-00770-00167391-00167447": "you can see", "XorBDBIz9y0-00771-00167448-00167614": "from i'm gonna have to get up and close", "XorBDBIz9y0-00772-00167615-00167807": "a shade in a minute but i'm blinded by", "XorBDBIz9y0-00773-00167808-00167966": "the light which seems to be a good", "XorBDBIz9y0-00774-00167967-00168351": "metaphor at this moment here um you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-00775-00168352-00168631": "following on what james said i i think", "XorBDBIz9y0-00776-00168632-00168678": "to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00777-00168679-00168951": "what we what we're going to see and what", "XorBDBIz9y0-00778-00168952-00169078": "what we really need to do", "XorBDBIz9y0-00779-00169079-00169326": "as a field is to acknowledge that sort", "XorBDBIz9y0-00780-00169327-00169487": "of where are these tendrils", "XorBDBIz9y0-00781-00169488-00169799": "kind of of the the groups that have not", "XorBDBIz9y0-00782-00169800-00169831": "been", "XorBDBIz9y0-00783-00169832-00170111": "actively involved in those communities", "XorBDBIz9y0-00784-00170112-00170183": "and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00785-00170184-00170414": "what does it mean to kind of have the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00786-00170415-00170535": "the power", "XorBDBIz9y0-00787-00170536-00170887": "distributed throughout these communities", "XorBDBIz9y0-00788-00170888-00170999": "as well because it has", "XorBDBIz9y0-00789-00171000-00171351": "been somewhat insular and and therefore", "XorBDBIz9y0-00790-00171352-00171559": "you know somewhat siloed from some of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00791-00171560-00171695": "these other systems and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00792-00171696-00171911": "that can be everything from technical", "XorBDBIz9y0-00793-00171912-00172087": "infrastructure like the importance of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00794-00172088-00172278": "taking all of our libraries and making", "XorBDBIz9y0-00795-00172279-00172431": "sure they integrate with everybody's", "XorBDBIz9y0-00796-00172432-00172623": "learning management systems", "XorBDBIz9y0-00797-00172624-00172975": "to uh where are other um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00798-00172976-00173190": "centers of some centers of gravity you", "XorBDBIz9y0-00799-00173191-00173278": "know where are", "XorBDBIz9y0-00800-00173279-00173638": "other um existing fields that have their", "XorBDBIz9y0-00801-00173639-00173799": "own structures and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00802-00173800-00174071": "and power structures how are how do they", "XorBDBIz9y0-00803-00174072-00174183": "now step in with", "XorBDBIz9y0-00804-00174184-00174375": "in their own communities and they don't", "XorBDBIz9y0-00805-00174376-00174502": "have to become", "XorBDBIz9y0-00806-00174503-00174799": "just sort of absorbed into what we know", "XorBDBIz9y0-00807-00174800-00174959": "as the community and i think there's a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00808-00174960-00175031": "certain", "XorBDBIz9y0-00809-00175032-00175399": "kind of letting go um of of what we have", "XorBDBIz9y0-00810-00175400-00175614": "today to be able to do that and to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00811-00175615-00175838": "really just be open and listen", "XorBDBIz9y0-00812-00175839-00176038": "to saying where are those things and you", "XorBDBIz9y0-00813-00176039-00176223": "know and they're coming from", "XorBDBIz9y0-00814-00176224-00176351": "you know they're coming from the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00815-00176352-00176487": "historically black colleges and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00816-00176488-00176663": "universities here in the us they're", "XorBDBIz9y0-00817-00176664-00176895": "coming from discipline specific", "XorBDBIz9y0-00818-00176896-00177119": "uh professional organization trade", "XorBDBIz9y0-00819-00177120-00177278": "organizations which have a lot of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00820-00177279-00177431": "content knowledge", "XorBDBIz9y0-00821-00177432-00177663": "which people haven't really bothered to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00822-00177664-00177878": "say where is that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00823-00177879-00178031": "you know where is that knowledge and how", "XorBDBIz9y0-00824-00178032-00178207": "is that knowledge being transferred", "XorBDBIz9y0-00825-00178208-00178502": "um openly um in prison education", "XorBDBIz9y0-00826-00178503-00178638": "programs right there's so", "XorBDBIz9y0-00827-00178639-00179007": "many areas that uh we have just begun", "XorBDBIz9y0-00828-00179008-00179343": "to kind of scratch the surface of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00829-00179344-00179663": "yeah yeah i think i uh i noticed uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-00830-00179664-00179838": "at opennet last week there was a section", "XorBDBIz9y0-00831-00179839-00180031": "on welding", "XorBDBIz9y0-00832-00180032-00180302": "right how exciting uh peter you've had", "XorBDBIz9y0-00833-00180303-00180383": "your hand up", "XorBDBIz9y0-00834-00180384-00180551": "uh and then we're starting to see great", "XorBDBIz9y0-00835-00180552-00180807": "some uh questions coming up in the chat", "XorBDBIz9y0-00836-00180808-00181102": "so yeah no just for a second i i it", "XorBDBIz9y0-00837-00181103-00181311": "would be great if we turn our attention", "XorBDBIz9y0-00838-00181312-00181438": "that direction too", "XorBDBIz9y0-00839-00181439-00181766": "yeah if we can like", "XorBDBIz9y0-00840-00181767-00181999": "um with our mission drive and with some", "XorBDBIz9y0-00841-00182000-00182126": "of these principles that are in the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00842-00182127-00182271": "vision statements", "XorBDBIz9y0-00843-00182272-00182711": "like jump species like the virus", "XorBDBIz9y0-00844-00182712-00183087": "does and go like outside of education to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00845-00183088-00183319": "other forms of activism and like what", "XorBDBIz9y0-00846-00183320-00183495": "how can we facilitate", "XorBDBIz9y0-00847-00183496-00183878": "as open education people the anti-racism", "XorBDBIz9y0-00848-00183879-00183959": "movement", "XorBDBIz9y0-00849-00183960-00184471": "how can we facilitate anti-you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-00850-00184472-00184790": "the right kind of activism in in the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00851-00184791-00185047": "climate challenges that we're facing", "XorBDBIz9y0-00852-00185048-00185463": "or in economic equality like what can we", "XorBDBIz9y0-00853-00185464-00185719": "do and what are you know to james's", "XorBDBIz9y0-00854-00185720-00185799": "point", "XorBDBIz9y0-00855-00185800-00186063": "which he's reiterated in our in our in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00856-00186064-00186126": "our group", "XorBDBIz9y0-00857-00186127-00186438": "conversations what is that map look like", "XorBDBIz9y0-00858-00186439-00186735": "who are those players and how do we", "XorBDBIz9y0-00859-00186736-00186926": "build those", "XorBDBIz9y0-00860-00186927-00187223": "those natural along those on those", "XorBDBIz9y0-00861-00187224-00187390": "natural affinities", "XorBDBIz9y0-00862-00187391-00187759": "um for you know identifying which which", "XorBDBIz9y0-00863-00187760-00187895": "group are we going to work with in this", "XorBDBIz9y0-00864-00187896-00187999": "area and which", "XorBDBIz9y0-00865-00188000-00188302": "that to me can then render you know a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00866-00188303-00188487": "1500 person", "XorBDBIz9y0-00867-00188488-00188783": "conference god forbid to a 15 000 person", "XorBDBIz9y0-00868-00188784-00188895": "conference and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00869-00188896-00189263": "and then some and then excellent", "XorBDBIz9y0-00870-00189264-00189590": "cable you had your hand there yeah i'll", "XorBDBIz9y0-00871-00189591-00189750": "keep it shortcut so we can get to other", "XorBDBIz9y0-00872-00189751-00189895": "people's questions um", "XorBDBIz9y0-00873-00189896-00190135": "so two quick thoughts one about vision", "XorBDBIz9y0-00874-00190136-00190199": "and one about", "XorBDBIz9y0-00875-00190200-00190478": "themes on this same idea of the open ed", "XorBDBIz9y0-00876-00190479-00190687": "field reaching out", "XorBDBIz9y0-00877-00190688-00190926": "i've been working with two organizations", "XorBDBIz9y0-00878-00190927-00191038": "recently", "XorBDBIz9y0-00879-00191039-00191278": "that are both thinking about systematic", "XorBDBIz9y0-00880-00191279-00191478": "racism but the way that they're", "XorBDBIz9y0-00881-00191479-00191838": "acting is they are building new", "XorBDBIz9y0-00882-00191839-00192023": "educational resources", "XorBDBIz9y0-00883-00192024-00192271": "for young kids who are in school so this", "XorBDBIz9y0-00884-00192272-00192431": "is like grades", "XorBDBIz9y0-00885-00192432-00192743": "two through five and they're building", "XorBDBIz9y0-00886-00192744-00192983": "a whole new curriculum that is it's", "XorBDBIz9y0-00887-00192984-00193214": "modeled on you know long arc of history", "XorBDBIz9y0-00888-00193215-00193454": "but it's you know it's an honest history", "XorBDBIz9y0-00889-00193455-00193543": "of in this", "XorBDBIz9y0-00890-00193544-00193735": "in this particular case it's targeted at", "XorBDBIz9y0-00891-00193736-00193854": "uf schools", "XorBDBIz9y0-00892-00193855-00194087": "and so they're taking you know an actual", "XorBDBIz9y0-00893-00194088-00194190": "honest look", "XorBDBIz9y0-00894-00194191-00194438": "at racism in the united states where it", "XorBDBIz9y0-00895-00194439-00194614": "came from and how it manifests itself", "XorBDBIz9y0-00896-00194615-00194678": "today", "XorBDBIz9y0-00897-00194679-00194959": "and so their vision if you will is to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00898-00194960-00195078": "get these materials", "XorBDBIz9y0-00899-00195079-00195287": "broadly adopted to provide professional", "XorBDBIz9y0-00900-00195288-00195423": "development around them", "XorBDBIz9y0-00901-00195424-00195735": "um so that the next generation of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00902-00195736-00195871": "you know students that come up through", "XorBDBIz9y0-00903-00195872-00196054": "the education system", "XorBDBIz9y0-00904-00196055-00196311": "actually have an honest look at what", "XorBDBIz9y0-00905-00196312-00196407": "actually happened", "XorBDBIz9y0-00906-00196408-00196711": "and how systematic racism why it exists", "XorBDBIz9y0-00907-00196712-00196823": "in the first place", "XorBDBIz9y0-00908-00196824-00196999": "um which is you know something that a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00909-00197000-00197295": "lot of us never got until we were in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00910-00197296-00197471": "college and were in these classes which", "XorBDBIz9y0-00911-00197472-00197695": "were you know critical thought classes", "XorBDBIz9y0-00912-00197696-00197814": "that actually looked at", "XorBDBIz9y0-00913-00197815-00198063": "how all this came to be and so when i", "XorBDBIz9y0-00914-00198064-00198223": "say vision what i mean is i'm now", "XorBDBIz9y0-00915-00198224-00198335": "talking with them saying well if that's", "XorBDBIz9y0-00916-00198336-00198438": "your vision", "XorBDBIz9y0-00917-00198439-00198631": "then you know you might consider open as", "XorBDBIz9y0-00918-00198632-00198807": "a way of accelerating", "XorBDBIz9y0-00919-00198808-00199031": "your vision putting your vision on", "XorBDBIz9y0-00920-00199032-00199247": "steroids if you will because", "XorBDBIz9y0-00921-00199248-00199478": "we can get if we openly license it if we", "XorBDBIz9y0-00922-00199479-00199702": "put it over in oer commons where people", "XorBDBIz9y0-00923-00199703-00199807": "can find it", "XorBDBIz9y0-00924-00199808-00200095": "if we you know advertise it if we do the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00925-00200096-00200150": "following", "XorBDBIz9y0-00926-00200151-00200311": "we can actually get this out it can be", "XorBDBIz9y0-00927-00200312-00200495": "translated into different languages", "XorBDBIz9y0-00928-00200496-00200702": "and that seems to be aligning and so", "XorBDBIz9y0-00929-00200703-00200926": "they're now openly licensing their works", "XorBDBIz9y0-00930-00200927-00201087": "and turning it into oer", "XorBDBIz9y0-00931-00201088-00201271": "um the second one is is themes this", "XorBDBIz9y0-00932-00201272-00201431": "really builds on what lisa and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00933-00201432-00201638": "james were saying i think there are", "XorBDBIz9y0-00934-00201639-00201799": "common themes out there that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00935-00201800-00202143": "span different uh different ngo efforts", "XorBDBIz9y0-00936-00202144-00202199": "so", "XorBDBIz9y0-00937-00202200-00202343": "you know one of them is access to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00938-00202344-00202535": "education so certainly that's what we're", "XorBDBIz9y0-00939-00202536-00202575": "about", "XorBDBIz9y0-00940-00202576-00202807": "in open education that's a big part of", "XorBDBIz9y0-00941-00202808-00202926": "why we all do it", "XorBDBIz9y0-00942-00202927-00203214": "well so does so does black lives matter", "XorBDBIz9y0-00943-00203215-00203399": "they care a lot about access to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00944-00203400-00203695": "education so does well just a few years", "XorBDBIz9y0-00945-00203696-00203863": "ago lisa brought the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00946-00203864-00204071": "national association for the advancement", "XorBDBIz9y0-00947-00204072-00204319": "of colored people the naacp", "XorBDBIz9y0-00948-00204320-00204526": "to an open education conference and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00949-00204527-00204702": "there was a rich conversation about hey", "XorBDBIz9y0-00950-00204703-00204886": "we have this shared goal", "XorBDBIz9y0-00951-00204887-00205151": "of access to education for everybody so", "XorBDBIz9y0-00952-00205152-00205319": "you know another theme is", "XorBDBIz9y0-00953-00205319-00205623": "open access to knowledge to help people", "XorBDBIz9y0-00954-00205623-00205862": "and so right now you're seeing at unesco", "XorBDBIz9y0-00955-00205863-00205975": "they already have a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00956-00205976-00206190": "recommendation on open education or on", "XorBDBIz9y0-00957-00206191-00206279": "oer", "XorBDBIz9y0-00958-00206280-00206527": "they're now building and have open for a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00959-00206528-00206806": "comment a recommendation on open science", "XorBDBIz9y0-00960-00206807-00206966": "and of course it's been accelerated", "XorBDBIz9y0-00961-00206967-00207119": "because of covid and everybody knows", "XorBDBIz9y0-00962-00207119-00207294": "that open science is the right way to do", "XorBDBIz9y0-00963-00207296-00207431": "science if we want to", "XorBDBIz9y0-00964-00207432-00207655": "cure diseases you better make sure that", "XorBDBIz9y0-00965-00207656-00207742": "the research", "XorBDBIz9y0-00966-00207744-00208014": "and the data is all openly not only", "XorBDBIz9y0-00967-00208015-00208206": "accessible and freely accessible", "XorBDBIz9y0-00968-00208207-00208398": "but is openly licensed so it can be text", "XorBDBIz9y0-00969-00208400-00208558": "and data mind etc", "XorBDBIz9y0-00970-00208559-00208919": "and so i think it's not rocket science", "XorBDBIz9y0-00971-00208919-00209023": "we just haven't", "XorBDBIz9y0-00972-00209023-00209166": "thought this way before we really have", "XorBDBIz9y0-00973-00209167-00209334": "to i think look at what are our core", "XorBDBIz9y0-00974-00209335-00209598": "themes that we care about and then do a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00975-00209600-00209823": "bit of an analysis of who else has those", "XorBDBIz9y0-00976-00209823-00209871": "core", "XorBDBIz9y0-00977-00209871-00210039": "themes or those core goals as well and", "XorBDBIz9y0-00978-00210040-00210231": "start to reach out", "XorBDBIz9y0-00979-00210232-00210479": "thanks um i see james you got your hand", "XorBDBIz9y0-00980-00210480-00210606": "up i'm also", "XorBDBIz9y0-00981-00210607-00211287": "wanting to start pulling in some of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00982-00211288-00211439": "the conversation that's going on in the", "XorBDBIz9y0-00983-00211440-00211775": "chat or may i may pull that in", "XorBDBIz9y0-00984-00211776-00211982": "the uh the chat okay so so so there's a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00985-00211983-00212119": "real brief that just to pick up on", "XorBDBIz9y0-00986-00212119-00212191": "cable's point", "XorBDBIz9y0-00987-00212192-00212382": "with a thousand percent plus plus a", "XorBDBIz9y0-00988-00212383-00212655": "thousand percent cable absolutely", "XorBDBIz9y0-00989-00212656-00213071": "and it also uh one can get to this point", "XorBDBIz9y0-00990-00213071-00213151": "by", "XorBDBIz9y0-00991-00213152-00213415": "of saying that we need to expand our", "XorBDBIz9y0-00992-00213416-00213606": "allies and present ourselves", "XorBDBIz9y0-00993-00213607-00213887": "as tools or mechanisms for other", "XorBDBIz9y0-00994-00213888-00213942": "movements", "XorBDBIz9y0-00995-00213944-00214215": "by following the data look at the data", "XorBDBIz9y0-00996-00214216-00214406": "in education at least in my context", "XorBDBIz9y0-00997-00214407-00214663": "you know you start looking at well what", "XorBDBIz9y0-00998-00214664-00214903": "groups of students are not succeeding", "XorBDBIz9y0-00999-00214904-00215015": "they're not succeeding because they", "XorBDBIz9y0-01000-00215016-00215279": "can't get in to education or they're not", "XorBDBIz9y0-01001-00215280-00215519": "succeeding because", "XorBDBIz9y0-01002-00215519-00215727": "of financial barriers you start peeling", "XorBDBIz9y0-01003-00215728-00215927": "away that data and in the united states", "XorBDBIz9y0-01004-00215928-00216006": "context", "XorBDBIz9y0-01005-00216007-00216327": "you very quickly arrive at", "XorBDBIz9y0-01006-00216328-00216863": "uh populations of students students from", "XorBDBIz9y0-01007-00216864-00217175": "ethnic minorities or racial minorities", "XorBDBIz9y0-01008-00217176-00217391": "so so that's a natural point of", "XorBDBIz9y0-01009-00217392-00217527": "connection to those organizations that", "XorBDBIz9y0-01010-00217528-00217623": "cable was mentioning", "XorBDBIz9y0-01011-00217623-00217815": "but outside the context of the united", "XorBDBIz9y0-01012-00217816-00217975": "states i would suggest that you have the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01013-00217976-00218134": "similar opportunity and you have", "XorBDBIz9y0-01014-00218135-00218382": "to to follow the data what what", "XorBDBIz9y0-01015-00218383-00218519": "populations of students", "XorBDBIz9y0-01016-00218519-00218823": "are facing barriers uh or are", "XorBDBIz9y0-01017-00218823-00218991": "are not succeeding at the rate of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01018-00218992-00219191": "majority uh students or students from", "XorBDBIz9y0-01019-00219192-00219439": "the majority culture are they linguistic", "XorBDBIz9y0-01020-00219440-00219727": "minorities in your country are they uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-01021-00219728-00219806": "people who are", "XorBDBIz9y0-01022-00219807-00220110": "minoritized or excluded for for all", "XorBDBIz9y0-01023-00220111-00220255": "kinds of different reasons", "XorBDBIz9y0-01024-00220256-00220551": "uh those uh organizations that work with", "XorBDBIz9y0-01025-00220552-00220767": "those types of students who are", "XorBDBIz9y0-01026-00220767-00220942": "not successful or who are facing", "XorBDBIz9y0-01027-00220944-00221175": "barriers uh based on the data", "XorBDBIz9y0-01028-00221176-00221479": "would also be uh likely allies so back", "XorBDBIz9y0-01029-00221480-00221575": "back to you kurt thank you", "XorBDBIz9y0-01030-00221576-00221887": "thank you yeah thanks yeah um lena asked", "XorBDBIz9y0-01031-00221888-00222006": "a few minutes ago", "XorBDBIz9y0-01032-00222007-00222198": "does openness become a principle or", "XorBDBIz9y0-01033-00222200-00222375": "value rather than a discipline", "XorBDBIz9y0-01034-00222376-00222671": "i i if i get that uh if i understand", "XorBDBIz9y0-01035-00222671-00222831": "what you're saying uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-01036-00222832-00223071": "should we have a a motto like open", "XorBDBIz9y0-01037-00223071-00223134": "education", "XorBDBIz9y0-01038-00223135-00223287": "it's not just for open education", "XorBDBIz9y0-01039-00223288-00223527": "practitioners it's for everybody", "XorBDBIz9y0-01040-00223528-00223782": "you know um that the people who are", "XorBDBIz9y0-01041-00223783-00223919": "creating this", "XorBDBIz9y0-01042-00223919-00224175": "this young person's curriculum didn't", "XorBDBIz9y0-01043-00224176-00224375": "think of themselves as open education", "XorBDBIz9y0-01044-00224376-00224455": "people but", "XorBDBIz9y0-01045-00224456-00224719": "there's huge value in that and uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-01046-00224719-00224863": "reflecting back on a", "XorBDBIz9y0-01047-00224864-00225110": "prior conversation with you lisa you had", "XorBDBIz9y0-01048-00225111-00225175": "asked", "XorBDBIz9y0-01049-00225176-00225342": "something along the lines of like what", "XorBDBIz9y0-01050-00225344-00225479": "does it look like or what do we need to", "XorBDBIz9y0-01051-00225480-00225623": "do to make", "XorBDBIz9y0-01052-00225623-00225791": "these practices really become the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01053-00225792-00225934": "default rather than", "XorBDBIz9y0-01054-00225935-00226182": "a thing that gets bolted on to the side", "XorBDBIz9y0-01055-00226183-00226303": "it feels like there's", "XorBDBIz9y0-01056-00226304-00226534": "you know tremendous opportunity you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-01057-00226535-00226623": "potential to", "XorBDBIz9y0-01058-00226623-00226927": "to get into really addressing some of", "XorBDBIz9y0-01059-00226928-00227079": "the big challenges that we", "XorBDBIz9y0-01060-00227080-00227351": "we all see uh if we can find our ways to", "XorBDBIz9y0-01061-00227352-00227494": "do that", "XorBDBIz9y0-01062-00227496-00227703": "um yeah i i would love to to address", "XorBDBIz9y0-01063-00227704-00227975": "that i think apps you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-01064-00227976-00228223": "i think that it's a we started it sort", "XorBDBIz9y0-01065-00228223-00228334": "of as a movement", "XorBDBIz9y0-01066-00228335-00228646": "you know this was 2003 2004.", "XorBDBIz9y0-01067-00228648-00228910": "uh within five or six years as we had", "XorBDBIz9y0-01068-00228911-00228982": "research", "XorBDBIz9y0-01069-00228983-00229310": "uh some great research uh from", "XorBDBIz9y0-01070-00229311-00229575": "uh from from dave wiley and i mean", "XorBDBIz9y0-01071-00229576-00229719": "there's there's been a lot of", "XorBDBIz9y0-01072-00229719-00229975": "uh ground-building work that had to be", "XorBDBIz9y0-01073-00229976-00230198": "done around just substantiating that in", "XorBDBIz9y0-01074-00230200-00230239": "fact", "XorBDBIz9y0-01075-00230240-00230575": "open was as good as uh proprietary and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01076-00230576-00230734": "then we had to look at", "XorBDBIz9y0-01077-00230735-00230927": "classroom impact and then we had to look", "XorBDBIz9y0-01078-00230928-00231134": "at educator uptake right there's been", "XorBDBIz9y0-01079-00231135-00231310": "so there's been sort of a body of", "XorBDBIz9y0-01080-00231311-00231479": "research on the ba you know that has", "XorBDBIz9y0-01081-00231480-00231534": "said", "XorBDBIz9y0-01082-00231535-00231775": "you know here's the work that where it's", "XorBDBIz9y0-01083-00231776-00232063": "moved from a movement to a field", "XorBDBIz9y0-01084-00232064-00232327": "i think that that has limited us now in", "XorBDBIz9y0-01085-00232328-00232551": "fact if we just think of it as a field", "XorBDBIz9y0-01086-00232552-00232663": "and we are not", "XorBDBIz9y0-01087-00232664-00232991": "fully integrated with", "XorBDBIz9y0-01088-00232992-00233215": "all fields and that it isn't just this", "XorBDBIz9y0-01089-00233216-00233423": "add-on piece and that in fact", "XorBDBIz9y0-01090-00233423-00233606": "it's even more than a principle i think", "XorBDBIz9y0-01091-00233607-00233751": "it's an approach", "XorBDBIz9y0-01092-00233752-00233910": "um i i think you know there's there's a", "XorBDBIz9y0-01093-00233911-00234110": "whole field of open pedagogy", "XorBDBIz9y0-01094-00234111-00234415": "now which is really uh embrace this in", "XorBDBIz9y0-01095-00234416-00234494": "this way", "XorBDBIz9y0-01096-00234496-00234679": "uh so i think the more that we continue", "XorBDBIz9y0-01097-00234680-00234894": "to think of open education sort of as", "XorBDBIz9y0-01098-00234896-00234975": "its own", "XorBDBIz9y0-01099-00234976-00235175": "field it's going to be a detriment in", "XorBDBIz9y0-01100-00235176-00235334": "some ways to", "XorBDBIz9y0-01101-00235335-00235639": "um to really thinking about how", "XorBDBIz9y0-01102-00235640-00235958": "as a public good you know education as", "XorBDBIz9y0-01103-00235959-00236215": "as a human right right we have to go all", "XorBDBIz9y0-01104-00236216-00236271": "the way", "XorBDBIz9y0-01105-00236271-00236582": "into places and people and communities", "XorBDBIz9y0-01106-00236583-00236823": "that frankly don't know about open", "XorBDBIz9y0-01107-00236823-00236894": "source", "XorBDBIz9y0-01108-00236896-00237198": "software whose shoulders we we stand on", "XorBDBIz9y0-01109-00237200-00237367": "or they don't they they don't know about", "XorBDBIz9y0-01110-00237367-00237503": "open science they might be the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01111-00237504-00237703": "beneficiaries of that", "XorBDBIz9y0-01112-00237704-00237927": "um and and i kind of want to say do they", "XorBDBIz9y0-01113-00237928-00238103": "have to know all the background of what", "XorBDBIz9y0-01114-00238104-00238206": "open is and the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01115-00238207-00238415": "arguments around licensing and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01116-00238416-00238527": "infrastructure like", "XorBDBIz9y0-01117-00238528-00238791": "like that's not even you know those were", "XorBDBIz9y0-01118-00238792-00238903": "so important", "XorBDBIz9y0-01119-00238904-00239079": "so i'm not trying to trivialize those", "XorBDBIz9y0-01120-00239080-00239334": "i'm saying building the groundswell", "XorBDBIz9y0-01121-00239335-00239527": "you know was critical to have that", "XorBDBIz9y0-01122-00239528-00239710": "research to have those conversations and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01123-00239711-00239791": "debates", "XorBDBIz9y0-01124-00239792-00239991": "it's now time to really i think bust", "XorBDBIz9y0-01125-00239992-00240551": "that open", "XorBDBIz9y0-01126-00240552-00240882": "yes", "XorBDBIz9y0-01127-00240883-00241175": "uh open it up to the panel", "XorBDBIz9y0-01128-00241176-00241775": "any other observations along those lines", "XorBDBIz9y0-01129-00241776-00242127": "no okay um i would", "XorBDBIz9y0-01130-00242128-00242319": "um encourage anybody who's in the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01131-00242319-00242446": "audience uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-01132-00242448-00242679": "to uh to continue to put your questions", "XorBDBIz9y0-01133-00242680-00242919": "and observations in on the chat", "XorBDBIz9y0-01134-00242919-00243255": "uh in fact we have from richard who", "XorBDBIz9y0-01135-00243256-00243551": "has been uh in the in the working group", "XorBDBIz9y0-01136-00243552-00243767": "with us", "XorBDBIz9y0-01137-00243767-00244182": "regarding the insularity", "XorBDBIz9y0-01138-00244183-00244367": "how can we broaden input and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01139-00244367-00244558": "participation beyond membership and hear", "XorBDBIz9y0-01140-00244559-00244710": "input from communities that we don't", "XorBDBIz9y0-01141-00244711-00244919": "hear so often", "XorBDBIz9y0-01142-00244919-00245127": "i would go so far as to say this is one", "XorBDBIz9y0-01143-00245128-00245303": "of the things that we want to do", "XorBDBIz9y0-01144-00245304-00245615": "i know is to uh is to get out of our out", "XorBDBIz9y0-01145-00245616-00245710": "of our meetings", "XorBDBIz9y0-01146-00245711-00245903": "and start to have conversations more", "XorBDBIz9y0-01147-00245904-00246023": "broadly", "XorBDBIz9y0-01148-00246023-00246246": "um but i'd love to hear thoughts from uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-01149-00246248-00246894": "from other panelists on that", "XorBDBIz9y0-01150-00246896-00247239": "peter um yeah i mean", "XorBDBIz9y0-01151-00247240-00247415": "if there's a way to jiu jitsu the whole", "XorBDBIz9y0-01152-00247416-00247558": "pandemic thing", "XorBDBIz9y0-01153-00247559-00247727": "and try to figure out how to take", "XorBDBIz9y0-01154-00247728-00247951": "advantage of what is", "XorBDBIz9y0-01155-00247952-00248191": "you know this once in a century horror", "XorBDBIz9y0-01156-00248192-00248367": "that's visiting upon us", "XorBDBIz9y0-01157-00248367-00248782": "we are educating ourselves", "XorBDBIz9y0-01158-00248783-00249079": "via zoom or other you know screen", "XorBDBIz9y0-01159-00249080-00249342": "technologies now", "XorBDBIz9y0-01160-00249344-00249527": "and we're doing it on kind of an", "XorBDBIz9y0-01161-00249528-00249703": "emergency basis", "XorBDBIz9y0-01162-00249704-00249919": "but what are the principles that we", "XorBDBIz9y0-01163-00249919-00250046": "should be thinking about", "XorBDBIz9y0-01164-00250048-00250358": "open ed and oer in particular has been a", "XorBDBIz9y0-01165-00250359-00250430": "very tech", "XorBDBIz9y0-01166-00250431-00250727": "centric movement we're now communicating", "XorBDBIz9y0-01167-00250728-00250798": "via video", "XorBDBIz9y0-01168-00250800-00251055": "and audio what are the principles that", "XorBDBIz9y0-01169-00251056-00251158": "should be", "XorBDBIz9y0-01170-00251159-00251423": "enshrined in our teaching and learning", "XorBDBIz9y0-01171-00251423-00251471": "um", "XorBDBIz9y0-01172-00251471-00251871": "in these so that we don't get caught up", "XorBDBIz9y0-01173-00251871-00252134": "in you know what 600 years of print has", "XorBDBIz9y0-01174-00252135-00252279": "brought us to date", "XorBDBIz9y0-01175-00252280-00252519": "which is a mess when it comes to this", "XorBDBIz9y0-01176-00252519-00252663": "kind of licensing", "XorBDBIz9y0-01177-00252664-00252830": "so we should be thinking about that and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01178-00252831-00252991": "we should be taking advantage of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01179-00252992-00253158": "fact that we're recording", "XorBDBIz9y0-01180-00253159-00253494": "whole loads of courses um", "XorBDBIz9y0-01181-00253496-00253823": "uh not you know everywhere uh how can we", "XorBDBIz9y0-01182-00253823-00254142": "share them", "XorBDBIz9y0-01183-00254144-00254391": "and kurt i'll pick up on that uh the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01184-00254392-00254471": "point about uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-01185-00254471-00254703": "educating ourselves or or capturing the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01186-00254704-00254782": "content that we", "XorBDBIz9y0-01187-00254783-00254998": "that we're we're producing now as part", "XorBDBIz9y0-01188-00255000-00255127": "of professional development", "XorBDBIz9y0-01189-00255128-00255463": "i think a lot of us here uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-01190-00255464-00255606": "certainly participate in professional", "XorBDBIz9y0-01191-00255607-00255758": "development or create professional", "XorBDBIz9y0-01192-00255759-00255887": "development opportunities for our", "XorBDBIz9y0-01193-00255888-00256110": "networks for our colleagues", "XorBDBIz9y0-01194-00256111-00256430": "as we're doing that let's not repeat", "XorBDBIz9y0-01195-00256431-00256591": "ourselves and let's not have", "XorBDBIz9y0-01196-00256592-00256887": "as as lisa was sort of suggesting but", "XorBDBIz9y0-01197-00256888-00257206": "let's not offer one more webinar on", "XorBDBIz9y0-01198-00257207-00257503": "licensing uh apologies to cable i guess", "XorBDBIz9y0-01199-00257504-00257646": "let's have a look on a webinar in white", "XorBDBIz9y0-01200-00257648-00257839": "licensing but let's not have a second", "XorBDBIz9y0-01201-00257840-00258103": "webinar on licensing let's have us the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01202-00258104-00258246": "second webinar", "XorBDBIz9y0-01203-00258248-00258551": "be about uh the question of anti-racism", "XorBDBIz9y0-01204-00258552-00258742": "uh another what they have the second", "XorBDBIz9y0-01205-00258744-00258934": "webinar be about the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01206-00258935-00259279": "the historical practices in whatever", "XorBDBIz9y0-01207-00259280-00259551": "part of the world you're from that made", "XorBDBIz9y0-01208-00259552-00259751": "one culture the dominant culture in", "XorBDBIz9y0-01209-00259752-00259846": "education", "XorBDBIz9y0-01210-00259848-00260198": "and other cultures minoritized", "XorBDBIz9y0-01211-00260200-00260487": "so we we all can wield that influence as", "XorBDBIz9y0-01212-00260488-00260630": "we're educating ourselves", "XorBDBIz9y0-01213-00260631-00261039": "i hope uh to move beyond the insularity", "XorBDBIz9y0-01214-00261040-00261303": "uh let's share that learning with others", "XorBDBIz9y0-01215-00261304-00261406": "uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-01216-00261407-00261639": "personally i've i've benefited from the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01217-00261640-00261767": "the generosity of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01218-00261767-00261927": "of the gila foundation in the michaelson", "XorBDBIz9y0-01219-00261928-00262127": "20 million vines foundation to", "XorBDBIz9y0-01220-00262128-00262351": "connect with other organizations in the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01221-00262352-00262495": "united states who are working on", "XorBDBIz9y0-01222-00262496-00262687": "education reform for particular", "XorBDBIz9y0-01223-00262688-00262839": "populations and i've just begun having", "XorBDBIz9y0-01224-00262840-00262967": "conversations with them", "XorBDBIz9y0-01225-00262968-00263287": "and i'll i will then be inviting them", "XorBDBIz9y0-01226-00263288-00263606": "uh to uh share their", "XorBDBIz9y0-01227-00263607-00263887": "uh their their perspectives and what", "XorBDBIz9y0-01228-00263888-00264063": "their organizations do", "XorBDBIz9y0-01229-00264064-00264279": "with groups of people that i get to work", "XorBDBIz9y0-01230-00264280-00264423": "with in the open", "XorBDBIz9y0-01231-00264424-00264599": "based on open education but i'll be", "XorBDBIz9y0-01232-00264600-00264743": "expanding the knowledge of everybody", "XorBDBIz9y0-01233-00264744-00264855": "hopefully", "XorBDBIz9y0-01234-00264856-00265110": "yeah good i'd like to welcome into the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01235-00265111-00265303": "room one of our elephants", "XorBDBIz9y0-01236-00265304-00265534": "thank you sean for bringing bringing", "XorBDBIz9y0-01237-00265535-00265639": "them in", "XorBDBIz9y0-01238-00265640-00265943": "uh the question of uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-01239-00265944-00266375": "commercial companies the tension", "XorBDBIz9y0-01240-00266376-00266687": "that exists between oer as", "XorBDBIz9y0-01241-00266688-00266999": "this ideologically free resource", "XorBDBIz9y0-01242-00267000-00267263": "and the need for it to be financially", "XorBDBIz9y0-01243-00267264-00267334": "and otherwise", "XorBDBIz9y0-01244-00267335-00267647": "sustainable this runs", "XorBDBIz9y0-01245-00267648-00267887": "you know this is a rich undercurrent", "XorBDBIz9y0-01246-00267888-00268047": "through a lot of our work and a lot of", "XorBDBIz9y0-01247-00268048-00268279": "our conversations and i'd like to uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-01248-00268280-00268455": "put that out to the panel for", "XorBDBIz9y0-01249-00268456-00268599": "reflections on", "XorBDBIz9y0-01250-00268600-00268879": "where that stands uh at this moment and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01251-00268880-00269119": "where we should be trying to lead it", "XorBDBIz9y0-01252-00269120-00269327": "i'd like to maybe at least just start by", "XorBDBIz9y0-01253-00269328-00269430": "offering kind of a", "XorBDBIz9y0-01254-00269431-00269663": "even a reframing of that question", "XorBDBIz9y0-01255-00269664-00269734": "because", "XorBDBIz9y0-01256-00269735-00270006": "for the last 10 years i think we've been", "XorBDBIz9y0-01257-00270007-00270182": "asking or this question has been asked", "XorBDBIz9y0-01258-00270183-00270263": "of us", "XorBDBIz9y0-01259-00270264-00270551": "um how can it be sustainable if it's not", "XorBDBIz9y0-01260-00270552-00270655": "commercial", "XorBDBIz9y0-01261-00270656-00270958": "and i want to reframe that and say", "XorBDBIz9y0-01262-00270959-00271230": "you know look at the cable can give us", "XorBDBIz9y0-01263-00271231-00271391": "these numbers the best probably you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-01264-00271392-00271455": "the six", "XorBDBIz9y0-01265-00271456-00271751": "billion dollars a year that are already", "XorBDBIz9y0-01266-00271752-00271815": "committed", "XorBDBIz9y0-01267-00271816-00272143": "and spent in k-12 education alone", "XorBDBIz9y0-01268-00272144-00272319": "um and then there's the of course the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01269-00272320-00272495": "higher ed numbers which are", "XorBDBIz9y0-01270-00272496-00272830": "which are even greater than that um", "XorBDBIz9y0-01271-00272831-00273127": "there's already money in our ecosystem", "XorBDBIz9y0-01272-00273128-00273151": "and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01273-00273152-00273479": "in our effort for these things the idea", "XorBDBIz9y0-01274-00273480-00273582": "they're really two", "XorBDBIz9y0-01275-00273583-00273806": "different questions about how to have a", "XorBDBIz9y0-01276-00273807-00274030": "sustainable ecosystem", "XorBDBIz9y0-01277-00274031-00274255": "versus commercial you know commercial", "XorBDBIz9y0-01278-00274256-00274455": "use and and i think that some people", "XorBDBIz9y0-01279-00274456-00274575": "might be thinking", "XorBDBIz9y0-01280-00274576-00274775": "with that question when i saw you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-01281-00274776-00274903": "sort of some of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01282-00274904-00275119": "i'm going to say the bastardizations of", "XorBDBIz9y0-01283-00275120-00275406": "open that we've seen through the years", "XorBDBIz9y0-01284-00275407-00275847": "they're now coming in the flavor and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01285-00275848-00276182": "color of things like inclusive access or", "XorBDBIz9y0-01286-00276183-00276487": "equitable access we just all saw a tweet", "XorBDBIz9y0-01287-00276488-00276519": "of", "XorBDBIz9y0-01288-00276520-00276927": "a couple of weeks ago um", "XorBDBIz9y0-01289-00276928-00277263": "these are the responses of a lot of", "XorBDBIz9y0-01290-00277264-00277471": "commercial publishers to oer", "XorBDBIz9y0-01291-00277472-00277663": "as a way to essentially let's you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-01292-00277664-00277806": "let's call the elephant what it is to", "XorBDBIz9y0-01293-00277807-00277847": "kind of", "XorBDBIz9y0-01294-00277848-00278079": "cut off open at its you know at its", "XorBDBIz9y0-01295-00278080-00278206": "knees right", "XorBDBIz9y0-01296-00278207-00278479": "so let's have those conversations and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01297-00278480-00278575": "about", "XorBDBIz9y0-01298-00278576-00278806": "commercial enterprise it's challenged to", "XorBDBIz9y0-01299-00278807-00279063": "open its partnership with open", "XorBDBIz9y0-01300-00279064-00279310": "where do we where have we seen", "XorBDBIz9y0-01301-00279311-00279439": "productive", "XorBDBIz9y0-01302-00279440-00279727": "um collaborations that were meaningful", "XorBDBIz9y0-01303-00279728-00279758": "in", "XorBDBIz9y0-01304-00279759-00280110": "in terms of outcome for students right", "XorBDBIz9y0-01305-00280111-00280334": "uh not for shareholders but for students", "XorBDBIz9y0-01306-00280335-00280495": "but then there's another conversation", "XorBDBIz9y0-01307-00280496-00280582": "about you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-01308-00280583-00280839": "what what what is sustainable and where", "XorBDBIz9y0-01309-00280840-00281023": "is the money that has already been put", "XorBDBIz9y0-01310-00281024-00281158": "into these things", "XorBDBIz9y0-01311-00281159-00281430": "and how could it be better reallocated", "XorBDBIz9y0-01312-00281431-00281471": "to", "XorBDBIz9y0-01313-00281472-00281767": "the endeavors around open i mean pd we", "XorBDBIz9y0-01314-00281768-00281927": "just were talking about but just as an", "XorBDBIz9y0-01315-00281928-00282095": "example", "XorBDBIz9y0-01316-00282096-00282247": "there's a there's been some money", "XorBDBIz9y0-01317-00282248-00282439": "flowing into education", "XorBDBIz9y0-01318-00282440-00282679": "around around the cares act and the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01319-00282680-00282791": "pandemic", "XorBDBIz9y0-01320-00282792-00283119": "and uh some you know really savvy", "XorBDBIz9y0-01321-00283120-00283406": "smart uh institutions and educators", "XorBDBIz9y0-01322-00283407-00283582": "across the country are saying hey", "XorBDBIz9y0-01323-00283583-00283799": "you know we already have all this money", "XorBDBIz9y0-01324-00283800-00283895": "for pd", "XorBDBIz9y0-01325-00283896-00284103": "now we're getting cares money for it's", "XorBDBIz9y0-01326-00284104-00284230": "not like it's you know we don't have all", "XorBDBIz9y0-01327-00284231-00284367": "the money we need for pd but money's", "XorBDBIz9y0-01328-00284368-00284463": "flowing in", "XorBDBIz9y0-01329-00284464-00284679": "into pd we're talking about remote", "XorBDBIz9y0-01330-00284680-00284847": "learning and what that means for", "XorBDBIz9y0-01331-00284848-00284951": "teaching and learning", "XorBDBIz9y0-01332-00284952-00285247": "let's make sure we embed open into part", "XorBDBIz9y0-01333-00285248-00285310": "of that", "XorBDBIz9y0-01334-00285311-00285543": "learning so what are those existing", "XorBDBIz9y0-01335-00285544-00285791": "mechanisms for the existing funds we", "XorBDBIz9y0-01336-00285792-00285951": "haven't even done that yet", "XorBDBIz9y0-01337-00285952-00286223": "so to somehow say you know commercial", "XorBDBIz9y0-01338-00286224-00286382": "has to save it because that's how you", "XorBDBIz9y0-01339-00286383-00286519": "make money to make it sustainable", "XorBDBIz9y0-01340-00286520-00286615": "they're really two", "XorBDBIz9y0-01341-00286616-00286830": "two different conversations so a", "XorBDBIz9y0-01342-00286831-00287054": "friendly kind of reframing of that at", "XorBDBIz9y0-01343-00287055-00287247": "least from my perspective", "XorBDBIz9y0-01344-00287248-00287663": "thanks thanks cable you had your hand up", "XorBDBIz9y0-01345-00287664-00287879": "yeah just to to build on what lisa was", "XorBDBIz9y0-01346-00287880-00288071": "saying um", "XorBDBIz9y0-01347-00288072-00288351": "so she's right i i do love that argument", "XorBDBIz9y0-01348-00288352-00288454": "that we", "XorBDBIz9y0-01349-00288455-00288639": "we have the money that we need i always", "XorBDBIz9y0-01350-00288640-00288806": "say we're just really bad at how we", "XorBDBIz9y0-01351-00288807-00289063": "spend it and so uh the numbers are", "XorBDBIz9y0-01352-00289064-00289119": "actually", "XorBDBIz9y0-01353-00289120-00289423": "in the us are almost double what what", "XorBDBIz9y0-01354-00289424-00289582": "lisa laid out it's in in", "XorBDBIz9y0-01355-00289583-00289895": "k-12 the u.s gov federal government puts", "XorBDBIz9y0-01356-00289896-00290191": "between 9 and 10 billion a year into", "XorBDBIz9y0-01357-00290192-00290430": "k-12 public education and it's a similar", "XorBDBIz9y0-01358-00290431-00290599": "amount in higher ed and it fluctuates", "XorBDBIz9y0-01359-00290600-00290703": "depending on the year in the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01360-00290704-00290823": "administration but", "XorBDBIz9y0-01361-00290824-00291110": "it's it's give or take 9 to 10 billion", "XorBDBIz9y0-01362-00291111-00291175": "and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01363-00291176-00291527": "um so you know for me when i think about", "XorBDBIz9y0-01364-00291528-00291727": "when i sit down with an entity whether", "XorBDBIz9y0-01365-00291728-00291903": "we're talking about uh developing a new", "XorBDBIz9y0-01366-00291904-00292015": "policy", "XorBDBIz9y0-01367-00292016-00292319": "um or we're talking you know at a", "XorBDBIz9y0-01368-00292320-00292495": "federal level or we're at a national", "XorBDBIz9y0-01369-00292496-00292679": "level or if we're talking about", "XorBDBIz9y0-01370-00292680-00292927": "um procurement of educational resources", "XorBDBIz9y0-01371-00292928-00293054": "at a local level", "XorBDBIz9y0-01372-00293055-00293303": "uh you know conversations are similar", "XorBDBIz9y0-01373-00293304-00293391": "it's is", "XorBDBIz9y0-01374-00293392-00293710": "is open if we take an open path uh is it", "XorBDBIz9y0-01375-00293711-00293903": "going to be better is it going to be", "XorBDBIz9y0-01376-00293904-00293943": "more", "XorBDBIz9y0-01377-00293944-00294263": "cost efficient almost always the answers", "XorBDBIz9y0-01378-00294264-00294591": "yes and so you know today uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-01379-00294592-00294782": "certainly in higher ed we're seeing this", "XorBDBIz9y0-01380-00294783-00294934": "this pattern and it's starting to hit", "XorBDBIz9y0-01381-00294935-00295079": "k-12 now as well", "XorBDBIz9y0-01382-00295080-00295230": "is we're seeing these models where the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01383-00295231-00295399": "commercial sector won't even", "XorBDBIz9y0-01384-00295400-00295654": "sell educational resources anymore so", "XorBDBIz9y0-01385-00295655-00295895": "the old model was in k-12 anyway", "XorBDBIz9y0-01386-00295896-00296054": "is that we'll sell you these resources", "XorBDBIz9y0-01387-00296055-00296215": "they're really expensive", "XorBDBIz9y0-01388-00296216-00296343": "and then the way that the school", "XorBDBIz9y0-01389-00296344-00296599": "districts around the country and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01390-00296600-00296758": "many countries around the world would", "XorBDBIz9y0-01391-00296759-00296927": "deal with that high cost is they would", "XorBDBIz9y0-01392-00296928-00297158": "keep those resources for over a decade", "XorBDBIz9y0-01393-00297159-00297406": "and then amortize the cost over 10 12", "XorBDBIz9y0-01394-00297407-00297471": "years", "XorBDBIz9y0-01395-00297472-00297767": "so where i live in washington state our", "XorBDBIz9y0-01396-00297768-00298030": "educational resources in k-12 on average", "XorBDBIz9y0-01397-00298031-00298254": "are about 11 and a half years old and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01398-00298255-00298399": "that's because we're amortizing", "XorBDBIz9y0-01399-00298400-00298647": "these costs which is insane right i've", "XorBDBIz9y0-01400-00298648-00298863": "got we have a son in high school", "XorBDBIz9y0-01401-00298864-00299119": "and his political science uh textbook is", "XorBDBIz9y0-01402-00299120-00299215": "10 years old", "XorBDBIz9y0-01403-00299216-00299343": "has anything interesting happen in", "XorBDBIz9y0-01404-00299344-00299543": "political science in 10 years", "XorBDBIz9y0-01405-00299544-00299782": "i think so lisa's been elected that's", "XorBDBIz9y0-01406-00299783-00299887": "what happened", "XorBDBIz9y0-01407-00299888-00300063": "so uh you know like that's that's", "XorBDBIz9y0-01408-00300064-00300239": "completely unacceptable", "XorBDBIz9y0-01409-00300240-00300406": "and now when the school district", "XorBDBIz9y0-01410-00300407-00300654": "acquires or procures uh educational", "XorBDBIz9y0-01411-00300655-00300799": "resources today", "XorBDBIz9y0-01412-00300800-00300967": "they don't even own them they're leasing", "XorBDBIz9y0-01413-00300968-00301167": "access to them so i think part of our", "XorBDBIz9y0-01414-00301168-00301223": "job", "XorBDBIz9y0-01415-00301224-00301543": "is to point out the new models which", "XorBDBIz9y0-01416-00301544-00301767": "have emerged from the commercial sector", "XorBDBIz9y0-01417-00301768-00302023": "and how damaging they are how unfair", "XorBDBIz9y0-01418-00302024-00302110": "they are", "XorBDBIz9y0-01419-00302111-00302327": "how the districts and and colleges", "XorBDBIz9y0-01420-00302328-00302495": "universities and students own", "XorBDBIz9y0-01421-00302496-00302695": "nothing and yet they pay a large amount", "XorBDBIz9y0-01422-00302696-00302854": "of money and so", "XorBDBIz9y0-01423-00302855-00303030": "going back to the oer recommendation", "XorBDBIz9y0-01424-00303031-00303199": "from unesco", "XorBDBIz9y0-01425-00303200-00303415": "one of the things that we wrote into it", "XorBDBIz9y0-01426-00303416-00303575": "was this idea of open", "XorBDBIz9y0-01427-00303576-00303775": "procurement and so you know it's one", "XorBDBIz9y0-01428-00303776-00303943": "thing to have a national", "XorBDBIz9y0-01429-00303944-00304134": "open licensing policy so for example in", "XorBDBIz9y0-01430-00304135-00304295": "the united states the departments of", "XorBDBIz9y0-01431-00304296-00304358": "labor", "XorBDBIz9y0-01432-00304359-00304679": "education several programs in state", "XorBDBIz9y0-01433-00304680-00304910": "a big chunk of usaid their early", "XorBDBIz9y0-01434-00304911-00304999": "childhood reading", "XorBDBIz9y0-01435-00305000-00305182": "they all require a creative commons", "XorBDBIz9y0-01436-00305183-00305343": "attribution license when", "XorBDBIz9y0-01437-00305344-00305558": "somebody takes a grant or contract from", "XorBDBIz9y0-01438-00305559-00305719": "them so whatever they build with this", "XorBDBIz9y0-01439-00305720-00305975": "public money must be openly licensed so", "XorBDBIz9y0-01440-00305976-00306143": "that's good that's a top-down", "XorBDBIz9y0-01441-00306144-00306351": "angle on this but it's also important", "XorBDBIz9y0-01442-00306352-00306567": "that the local school district or the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01443-00306568-00306695": "local", "XorBDBIz9y0-01444-00306696-00306934": "university or college has an open", "XorBDBIz9y0-01445-00306935-00307095": "procurement policy that says if we're", "XorBDBIz9y0-01446-00307096-00307239": "going to go spend you know a half", "XorBDBIz9y0-01447-00307240-00307391": "million euros", "XorBDBIz9y0-01448-00307392-00307663": "buying a set of educational resources we", "XorBDBIz9y0-01449-00307664-00307823": "need to make sure we're buying it", "XorBDBIz9y0-01450-00307824-00308030": "so we need to own it we need to hold", "XorBDBIz9y0-01451-00308031-00308230": "copyright and then hopefully we have an", "XorBDBIz9y0-01452-00308231-00308430": "internal open access policy that says", "XorBDBIz9y0-01453-00308431-00308639": "we'll openly license those materials", "XorBDBIz9y0-01454-00308640-00308967": "and turn them into oer and so part of", "XorBDBIz9y0-01455-00308968-00309119": "it is we don't spend our money very", "XorBDBIz9y0-01456-00309120-00309287": "wisely in", "XorBDBIz9y0-01457-00309288-00309575": "how we allocate educational resources", "XorBDBIz9y0-01458-00309576-00309703": "professional development opportunities", "XorBDBIz9y0-01459-00309704-00309839": "etc we've got the money we're just bad", "XorBDBIz9y0-01460-00309840-00309951": "at how we spend it", "XorBDBIz9y0-01461-00309952-00310223": "another part of it is our collective", "XorBDBIz9y0-01462-00310224-00310310": "failure", "XorBDBIz9y0-01463-00310311-00310551": "to recognize that as long as we the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01464-00310552-00310719": "public have the money", "XorBDBIz9y0-01465-00310720-00310999": "we have the power meaning the market", "XorBDBIz9y0-01466-00311000-00311143": "should be viewed as", "XorBDBIz9y0-01467-00311144-00311430": "work for hire for the public education", "XorBDBIz9y0-01468-00311431-00311487": "sector", "XorBDBIz9y0-01469-00311488-00311679": "so we'll give you the money as soon as", "XorBDBIz9y0-01470-00311680-00311830": "you meet our terms", "XorBDBIz9y0-01471-00311831-00312023": "and hopefully our terms are we the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01472-00312024-00312239": "public own the copyright to what we're", "XorBDBIz9y0-01473-00312240-00312334": "buying", "XorBDBIz9y0-01474-00312335-00312543": "and or we're hiring you to go build what", "XorBDBIz9y0-01475-00312544-00312734": "we want but either way we own it", "XorBDBIz9y0-01476-00312735-00312927": "you build for us we pay you then we're", "XorBDBIz9y0-01477-00312928-00313103": "going to openly license it and share it", "XorBDBIz9y0-01478-00313104-00313175": "as oer", "XorBDBIz9y0-01479-00313176-00313479": "just that step you could reduce the 9 or", "XorBDBIz9y0-01480-00313480-00313647": "10 billion in the united states", "XorBDBIz9y0-01481-00313648-00313839": "by a significant amount and then shift", "XorBDBIz9y0-01482-00313840-00313982": "that budget right we don't want to give", "XorBDBIz9y0-01483-00313983-00314175": "it back to the government we want", "XorBDBIz9y0-01484-00314176-00314343": "more professional development we want", "XorBDBIz9y0-01485-00314344-00314487": "more conversations", "XorBDBIz9y0-01486-00314488-00314687": "about open pedagogy we need better", "XorBDBIz9y0-01487-00314688-00314830": "conversations about", "XorBDBIz9y0-01488-00314831-00315015": "social justice we need to get into the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01489-00315016-00315263": "curriculum and fix the inequities", "XorBDBIz9y0-01490-00315264-00315567": "and so um you know these the opportunity", "XorBDBIz9y0-01491-00315568-00315630": "is there", "XorBDBIz9y0-01492-00315631-00315958": "how do we get there we need all of us", "XorBDBIz9y0-01493-00315959-00316110": "all of us at this conference and all the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01494-00316111-00316287": "other conferences this fall to be", "XorBDBIz9y0-01495-00316288-00316479": "involved in that work and even then it's", "XorBDBIz9y0-01496-00316480-00316663": "not enough of us which is why these", "XorBDBIz9y0-01497-00316664-00316815": "other professional development programs", "XorBDBIz9y0-01498-00316816-00316999": "that are going on to train", "XorBDBIz9y0-01499-00317000-00317182": "new leaders in open education are so", "XorBDBIz9y0-01500-00317183-00317367": "critical", "XorBDBIz9y0-01501-00317368-00317599": "well said i'm seeing a lot of applause", "XorBDBIz9y0-01502-00317600-00317871": "in the chat", "XorBDBIz9y0-01503-00317872-00318230": "uh james you have your hand up", "XorBDBIz9y0-01504-00318231-00318582": "uh you're on mute", "XorBDBIz9y0-01505-00318583-00318839": "that thank you i of course agree", "XorBDBIz9y0-01506-00318840-00318975": "completely with lease and cable", "XorBDBIz9y0-01507-00318976-00319247": "cable cable says that so so eloquently i", "XorBDBIz9y0-01508-00319248-00319382": "would just offer a couple of concrete", "XorBDBIz9y0-01509-00319383-00319471": "examples", "XorBDBIz9y0-01510-00319472-00319647": "to remind us that we're at a moment in", "XorBDBIz9y0-01511-00319648-00319879": "history one you know that it doesn't", "XorBDBIz9y0-01512-00319880-00320079": "have to be the way it is it can be what", "XorBDBIz9y0-01513-00320080-00320206": "cable's talking about", "XorBDBIz9y0-01514-00320207-00320551": "uh there was a time uh 200 years ago", "XorBDBIz9y0-01515-00320552-00320599": "when", "XorBDBIz9y0-01516-00320600-00320847": "education was not public education it", "XorBDBIz9y0-01517-00320848-00321015": "wasn't a public good there was a time", "XorBDBIz9y0-01518-00321016-00321047": "when", "XorBDBIz9y0-01519-00321048-00321319": "libraries were their purview of the rich", "XorBDBIz9y0-01520-00321320-00321382": "and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01521-00321383-00321591": "they were filled with secret information", "XorBDBIz9y0-01522-00321592-00321703": "uh like books", "XorBDBIz9y0-01523-00321704-00321943": "and there was a time when firefighters", "XorBDBIz9y0-01524-00321944-00322095": "fired fire departments", "XorBDBIz9y0-01525-00322096-00322310": "were only for the wealthy and they were", "XorBDBIz9y0-01526-00322311-00322439": "private services", "XorBDBIz9y0-01527-00322440-00322767": "uh and and somehow society has", "XorBDBIz9y0-01528-00322768-00322951": "seen that these are public goods and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01529-00322952-00323175": "they that everyone benefits when", "XorBDBIz9y0-01530-00323176-00323415": "a town doesn't burn to the ground", "XorBDBIz9y0-01531-00323416-00323599": "everyone benefits when there's literacy", "XorBDBIz9y0-01532-00323600-00323815": "and so on so it's super important that", "XorBDBIz9y0-01533-00323816-00324054": "we that we insist", "XorBDBIz9y0-01534-00324055-00324310": "on changing the framework changing the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01535-00324311-00324527": "perspective and we don't accept", "XorBDBIz9y0-01536-00324528-00324806": "the the terms of the discussion that", "XorBDBIz9y0-01537-00324807-00325063": "others give us", "XorBDBIz9y0-01538-00325064-00325375": "great good yeah um", "XorBDBIz9y0-01539-00325376-00325615": "i don't know why i just wanted to jump", "XorBDBIz9y0-01540-00325616-00325806": "in and say we actually only have", "XorBDBIz9y0-01541-00325807-00326039": "just six minutes remaining and this hour", "XorBDBIz9y0-01542-00326040-00326175": "has flown by", "XorBDBIz9y0-01543-00326176-00326510": "so i just wanted to do my duty and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01544-00326511-00326751": "give you your your warning to start", "XorBDBIz9y0-01545-00326752-00326903": "wrapping it up", "XorBDBIz9y0-01546-00326904-00327030": "yeah thank you i think this gives", "XorBDBIz9y0-01547-00327031-00327230": "everybody a a flavor for", "XorBDBIz9y0-01548-00327231-00327391": "what these conversations when the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01549-00327392-00327591": "working group gets together are like", "XorBDBIz9y0-01550-00327592-00327878": "the time does fly by um yeah i don't", "XorBDBIz9y0-01551-00327879-00327967": "know why", "XorBDBIz9y0-01552-00327968-00328119": "everything reminds me of climate change", "XorBDBIz9y0-01553-00328120-00328319": "these days this feels very similar to", "XorBDBIz9y0-01554-00328320-00328454": "the conversations about", "XorBDBIz9y0-01555-00328455-00328710": "we have this infrastructure now that", "XorBDBIz9y0-01556-00328711-00328871": "allows us to take", "XorBDBIz9y0-01557-00328872-00329230": "free resource i.e sunlight and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01558-00329231-00329439": "provide it to people in a way that we", "XorBDBIz9y0-01559-00329440-00329639": "didn't used to knowledge is like", "XorBDBIz9y0-01560-00329640-00329806": "is like sunlight right if we can build", "XorBDBIz9y0-01561-00329807-00329999": "the right infrastructure", "XorBDBIz9y0-01562-00330000-00330158": "whether it's for renewable energy or", "XorBDBIz9y0-01563-00330159-00330334": "whether it's for sharing knowledge", "XorBDBIz9y0-01564-00330335-00330519": "freely", "XorBDBIz9y0-01565-00330520-00330910": "we now have the capacity to um", "XorBDBIz9y0-01566-00330911-00331399": "uh to do that and there are", "XorBDBIz9y0-01567-00331400-00331599": "you know forces that have led us to", "XorBDBIz9y0-01568-00331600-00331710": "where we are right now", "XorBDBIz9y0-01569-00331711-00331927": "uh that you know thank god they were", "XorBDBIz9y0-01570-00331928-00332087": "there at the time you know it helped", "XorBDBIz9y0-01571-00332088-00332295": "it certainly helped a lot of uh with a", "XorBDBIz9y0-01572-00332296-00332447": "lot of development but we now have the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01573-00332448-00332575": "opportunity to really", "XorBDBIz9y0-01574-00332576-00332830": "build something new and better uh that", "XorBDBIz9y0-01575-00332831-00333151": "that meets the challenges of this moment", "XorBDBIz9y0-01576-00333152-00333503": "uh lisa hand yeah i just", "XorBDBIz9y0-01577-00333504-00333663": "i want to respond to that into what", "XorBDBIz9y0-01578-00333664-00333878": "james just said as well um", "XorBDBIz9y0-01579-00333879-00334063": "you know i worry about the statement", "XorBDBIz9y0-01580-00334064-00334239": "that everybody knows we benefit from", "XorBDBIz9y0-01581-00334240-00334367": "literacy because", "XorBDBIz9y0-01582-00334368-00334687": "uh clearly that isn't the case", "XorBDBIz9y0-01583-00334688-00334927": "not everybody believes that we should be", "XorBDBIz9y0-01584-00334928-00335095": "literate not everybody believes that we", "XorBDBIz9y0-01585-00335096-00335239": "should all be voting", "XorBDBIz9y0-01586-00335240-00335423": "i think we have some of the biggest", "XorBDBIz9y0-01587-00335424-00335654": "challenges ever here in the u.s", "XorBDBIz9y0-01588-00335655-00335823": "particularly and in other parts of the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01589-00335824-00336039": "world as well around these issues", "XorBDBIz9y0-01590-00336040-00336327": "and this idea that our our knowledge and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01591-00336328-00336551": "our public knowledge is under attack", "XorBDBIz9y0-01592-00336552-00336854": "is really cause for concern i mean", "XorBDBIz9y0-01593-00336855-00337047": "cable james you've you know raised the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01594-00337048-00337175": "issues of", "XorBDBIz9y0-01595-00337176-00337358": "you know the fact that we aren't making", "XorBDBIz9y0-01596-00337359-00337510": "in investments", "XorBDBIz9y0-01597-00337511-00337758": "that can be amortized that that we don't", "XorBDBIz9y0-01598-00337759-00337830": "even", "XorBDBIz9y0-01599-00337831-00338071": "in these inclusive access deals that you", "XorBDBIz9y0-01600-00338072-00338254": "never actually own the content", "XorBDBIz9y0-01601-00338255-00338558": "libraries uh public libraries are facing", "XorBDBIz9y0-01602-00338559-00338782": "one of the biggest challenges right now", "XorBDBIz9y0-01603-00338783-00339078": "publishers won't sell to libraries the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01604-00339079-00339143": "digital", "XorBDBIz9y0-01605-00339144-00339423": "versions and so even the knowledge that", "XorBDBIz9y0-01606-00339424-00339510": "we have so", "XorBDBIz9y0-01607-00339511-00339871": "come to uh expect and sort of demand it", "XorBDBIz9y0-01608-00339872-00340071": "in the public access to knowledge for", "XorBDBIz9y0-01609-00340072-00340382": "public libraries is under attack for the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01610-00340383-00340447": "same", "XorBDBIz9y0-01611-00340448-00340615": "challenges that we're having now to open", "XorBDBIz9y0-01612-00340616-00340791": "education so", "XorBDBIz9y0-01613-00340792-00340999": "you know i agree right up to that point", "XorBDBIz9y0-01614-00341000-00341134": "where we understand these things are", "XorBDBIz9y0-01615-00341135-00341287": "important but the idea that not", "XorBDBIz9y0-01616-00341288-00341367": "everybody", "XorBDBIz9y0-01617-00341368-00341582": "actually is on that same page is", "XorBDBIz9y0-01618-00341583-00341678": "critical and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01619-00341679-00341903": "what i think makes this need for open", "XorBDBIz9y0-01620-00341904-00341999": "education", "XorBDBIz9y0-01621-00342000-00342423": "that much stronger", "XorBDBIz9y0-01622-00342424-00342758": "indeed indeed um so we are", "XorBDBIz9y0-01623-00342759-00343127": "yeah just about out of time um", "XorBDBIz9y0-01624-00343128-00343391": "uh i'd like to just do a quick go around", "XorBDBIz9y0-01625-00343392-00343430": "any", "XorBDBIz9y0-01626-00343431-00343806": "uh closing thoughts from the panel um", "XorBDBIz9y0-01627-00343807-00344071": "peter yeah i would just echo what lisa", "XorBDBIz9y0-01628-00344072-00344247": "said our knowledge is under attack and", "XorBDBIz9y0-01629-00344248-00344382": "we need to figure out who", "XorBDBIz9y0-01630-00344383-00344671": "are who the other members of the you", "XorBDBIz9y0-01631-00344672-00344727": "know", "XorBDBIz9y0-01632-00344728-00345039": "resistance um are or you know", "XorBDBIz9y0-01633-00345040-00345319": "like the natural and organic members of", "XorBDBIz9y0-01634-00345320-00345495": "the resistance which is", "XorBDBIz9y0-01635-00345496-00345719": "maybe not a resistance maybe it's the", "XorBDBIz9y0-01636-00345720-00345847": "actual", "XorBDBIz9y0-01637-00345848-00346119": "you know maybe where we could just flip", "XorBDBIz9y0-01638-00346120-00346151": "it", "XorBDBIz9y0-01639-00346152-00346519": "um and but like those groups", "XorBDBIz9y0-01640-00346520-00346767": "that are active promoting the goals that", "XorBDBIz9y0-01641-00346768-00346951": "are in our vision statements", "XorBDBIz9y0-01642-00346952-00347206": "are our natural allies and we need to", "XorBDBIz9y0-01643-00347207-00347423": "echoing what everybody here has said", "XorBDBIz9y0-01644-00347424-00347647": "find them all over the world and figure", "XorBDBIz9y0-01645-00347648-00348054": "out ways of working with them", "XorBDBIz9y0-01646-00348055-00348487": "uh james can't improve on that", "XorBDBIz9y0-01647-00348488-00348767": "leave it with leave it with peter all", "XorBDBIz9y0-01648-00348768-00348863": "right", "XorBDBIz9y0-01649-00348864-00349167": "uh lisa any closing thoughts", "XorBDBIz9y0-01650-00349168-00349375": "i think that the call to action was my", "XorBDBIz9y0-01651-00349376-00349510": "definitely my closing", "XorBDBIz9y0-01652-00349511-00349734": "my closing thoughts let's take back", "XorBDBIz9y0-01653-00349735-00349927": "public knowledge", "XorBDBIz9y0-01654-00349928-00350319": "yeah yeah closing thoughts", "XorBDBIz9y0-01655-00350320-00350630": "oh uh yeah let's i dropped it in chat", "XorBDBIz9y0-01656-00350631-00350847": "let's make sure that uh all publicly", "XorBDBIz9y0-01657-00350848-00351023": "funded resources", "XorBDBIz9y0-01658-00351024-00351271": "are openly licensed and freely available", "XorBDBIz9y0-01659-00351272-00351375": "to the public that", "XorBDBIz9y0-01660-00351376-00351623": "paid for it and let's make sure we we", "XorBDBIz9y0-01661-00351624-00351951": "hold those resources in perpetuity", "XorBDBIz9y0-01662-00351952-00352295": "good good good all right uh", "XorBDBIz9y0-01663-00352296-00352527": "on behalf of my uh my panelist chair i", "XorBDBIz9y0-01664-00352528-00352630": "want to thank you for", "XorBDBIz9y0-01665-00352631-00352982": "joining us today uh great conversation", "XorBDBIz9y0-01666-00352983-00353199": "let's go get them", "XorBDBIz9y0-01667-00353200-00354231": "all right have a good conference"}}, {"audio_id": "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ", "text": {"Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00000-00000079-00000238": "hey guys welcome back to that video i'm", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00001-00000239-00000471": "just going for the yt as you know", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00002-00000472-00000647": "we're back in minecraft java edition", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00003-00000648-00000774": "playing today we'll play this weather", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00004-00000775-00001047": "store that you will first do that today", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00005-00001048-00001254": "called boss it's a wizard boss battle", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00006-00001255-00001798": "today the shout out to this meme", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00007-00001800-00002023": "for making this map", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00008-00002023-00002151": "click the subscribe to raise your", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00009-00002152-00002279": "channel which yeah that's what i'll be", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00010-00002280-00002463": "doing after this video it's up hopefully", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00011-00002464-00002623": "follow me on twitter so i won't i don't", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00012-00002624-00002871": "have to i have instagram snapchat though", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00013-00002872-00003047": "all right but i want you guys to do this", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00014-00003048-00003303": "first take a look at the at the graph", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00015-00003304-00003583": "this is this is what you guys do please", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00016-00003584-00003711": "please", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00017-00003711-00003854": "this is not", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00018-00003855-00004015": "i don't like when you guys all of you", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00019-00004015-00004222": "guys are not subscribed i like this is", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00020-00004223-00004399": "what i like i like when you guys when", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00021-00004400-00004583": "you all are subscribed", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00022-00004584-00004767": "meaning that i want this line to go all", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00023-00004768-00004943": "the way up not", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00024-00004944-00005238": "not like this", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00025-00005239-00005343": "okay", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00026-00005344-00005495": "in order to do that click the subscribe", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00027-00005496-00005663": "button hit the bell so you never miss a", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00028-00005664-00005886": "video i post all right let's get into", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00029-00005887-00006063": "the video", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00030-00006064-00006302": "here we go let's get started three two", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00031-00006303-00006583": "one go", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00032-00006584-00006783": "okay so we need we somehow need to get", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00033-00006784-00006887": "up here", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00034-00006888-00007046": "strapped a little more crafting a pair", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00035-00007047-00007959": "of wings", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00036-00007959-00008110": "real quick", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00037-00008111-00008903": "so", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00038-00008904-00009095": "okay so here we go", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00039-00009096-00009599": "oh crap", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00040-00009600-00009942": "hold", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00041-00009943-00010919": "you up careful gotta be careful now", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00042-00010920-00011423": "all right let's see how we got here", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00043-00011424-00011806": "okay", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00044-00011807-00012087": "ow", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00045-00012088-00012321": "oh my god", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00046-00012322-00012470": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00047-00012471-00012559": "yeah", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00048-00012560-00012759": "i'm doing a be uploading this because", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00049-00012760-00012871": "it's because", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00050-00012872-00013071": "because you decided to delete the whole", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00051-00013072-00013238": "ending without that but i said delete", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00052-00013240-00013391": "the middle of it", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00053-00013391-00013543": "because i didn't want to do that beat", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00054-00013544-00013719": "that to be not that too much long", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00055-00013719-00013838": "because", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00056-00013840-00014055": "i won't have that long yeah", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00057-00014056-00015175": "no crap", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00058-00015176-00015366": "yeah", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00059-00015368-00015703": "that should do it", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00060-00015704-00015863": "come on come on jesse should be done", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00061-00015863-00016479": "right now", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00062-00016480-00016758": "we gotta be careful though", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00063-00016759-00017863": "come on", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00064-00017864-00018063": "all right we should be almost done", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00065-00018064-00018255": "you should be almost there you guys", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00066-00018256-00018414": "watch to the end of the video and see", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00067-00018415-00018983": "how i'm going to beat this map for that", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00068-00018984-00019199": "okay because if you haven't already", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00069-00019200-00019335": "please consider subscribing to my", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00070-00019336-00019479": "channel if you do and hitting the bell", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00071-00019480-00019671": "so that we can stay tuned for videos for", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00072-00019672-00019839": "future videos", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00073-00019840-00019983": "all right", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00074-00019984-00020199": "all right put five ways of progress yep", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00075-00020200-00020486": "yep i figured out the questions", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00076-00020487-00020799": "let's go", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00077-00020800-00021486": "so i think i know what to do", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00078-00021487-00022271": "okay", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00079-00022272-00022775": "okay here we go", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00080-00022776-00023255": "you gotta be careful though", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00081-00023256-00024861": "i did not expect that to happen", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00082-00024862-00025639": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00083-00025639-00025934": "all right let's see what we got", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00084-00025935-00026118": "you guys i hope you watched the end of", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00085-00026119-00026367": "the video to see how well how far if i'm", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00086-00026368-00027614": "gonna make it with that", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00087-00027616-00027918": "i think i'm clicking too early that's", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00088-00027919-00028158": "probably that's probably the reason why", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00089-00028160-00028735": "i keep", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00090-00028736-00028911": "because i hate those things", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00091-00028912-00029246": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00092-00029247-00029423": "okay come on", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00093-00029424-00030590": "i'll be close", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00094-00031272-00031990": "all right let's keep going", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00095-00031991-00032207": "good that's one all right let's get back", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00096-00032208-00032439": "down", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00097-00032439-00032913": "oh my god gotta be careful", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00098-00032914-00033151": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00099-00033152-00033311": "let's shoot that scroll real quick let's", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00100-00033312-00033597": "go real quick", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00101-00033598-00033823": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00102-00033824-00033999": "so let's keep going we should be able to", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00103-00034000-00034351": "make it though", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00104-00034352-00035599": "okay let's see what we got here come on", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00105-00035600-00036055": "oh oh okay okay", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00106-00036056-00036535": "ow", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00107-00036536-00036751": "got one that's another one let's hurry", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00108-00036752-00037943": "up", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00109-00037944-00038351": "ow oh my god that hurt", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00110-00038352-00038511": "we need to be closed though i will put a", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00111-00038512-00038615": "link for this down description down", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00112-00038616-00039023": "below", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00113-00039024-00039359": "oh no hold up go back", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00114-00039360-00039518": "oh my god i think that i feel like i", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00115-00039519-00040318": "dropped my kickback", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00116-00040319-00040415": "no", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00117-00040416-00040902": "goddammit why", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00118-00040903-00041135": "try that again all right", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00119-00041136-00041918": "i know what i have to do", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00120-00041919-00042462": "i know what i have to do though", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00121-00042463-00042958": "i hate when i happen to be", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00122-00042959-00044471": "oh my god", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00123-00044472-00045151": "oh my gosh go", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00124-00045152-00046079": "he's almost", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00125-00046080-00046390": "oh my god holy crap that's everything oh", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00126-00046391-00046615": "my god", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00127-00046616-00047358": "oh jesus oh my god", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00128-00047359-00047535": "oh that's good that's good you're almost", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00129-00047536-00048223": "done jesse actually oh my god", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00130-00048224-00048615": "oh neither this", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00131-00048616-00048751": "go", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00132-00048752-00048927": "yeah oh there you go that'll do it all", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00133-00048928-00049015": "right", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00134-00049016-00049846": "let's keep going what we'll say", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00135-00049847-00050327": "all right come on", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00136-00050328-00050495": "let's fix that now let's see what else", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00137-00050496-00050686": "we got", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00138-00050687-00050807": "guys make sure you're watching this", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00139-00050808-00051118": "video to the end as well", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00140-00051119-00051335": "i will show you guys", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00141-00051336-00051414": "like", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00142-00051415-00051550": "because i have been reading a lot of my", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00143-00051551-00051735": "youtube viewers and i showed you", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00144-00051736-00052985": "searches and said bullet storm", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00145-00052986-00053359": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00146-00053360-00053515": "oh he disappeared", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00147-00053516-00053638": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00148-00053639-00054182": "oh nevermind he's back all right", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00149-00054183-00054391": "thank you that's the all right", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00150-00054391-00054550": "keep going", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00151-00054551-00054854": "let's go i know i have to do", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00152-00054855-00055079": "watch we gotta watch every guy watch", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00153-00055079-00055342": "those", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00154-00055344-00055615": "got one", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00155-00055616-00056207": "okay i do not wanna die", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00156-00056208-00056591": "holy crap", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00157-00056591-00057539": "all right keep going we're almost there", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00158-00057540-00057871": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00159-00057872-00058063": "i'm also going to", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00160-00058064-00058279": "what's going on is going to mark the", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00161-00058279-00058663": "fight", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00162-00058664-00058903": "i'm not going to try fine like", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00163-00058904-00059238": "it's like really", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00164-00059239-00059415": "hey guys i won't be able to upload", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00165-00059416-00059575": "videos every single day", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00166-00059576-00059735": "it's because", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00167-00059736-00059999": "um", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00168-00060000-00061430": "well this is obviously because", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00169-00061432-00062694": "let's keep going", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00170-00062695-00063799": "all right", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00171-00063800-00064015": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00172-00064016-00064166": "there's probably nothing there but let's", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00173-00064167-00064287": "just keep going", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00174-00064288-00064654": "so yeah as you know this", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00175-00064655-00064879": "oh got one let's go", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00176-00064879-00065103": "holy crap all right come on we can do", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00177-00065104-00065335": "this", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00178-00065336-00065479": "i haven't played this map in a long time", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00179-00065479-00066991": "though", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00180-00066992-00067090": "come on out", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00181-00067091-00067311": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00182-00067312-00067599": "first up", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00183-00067600-00067799": "where's the heavy stuff other", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00184-00067800-00068750": "is that what's this don't factor that", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00185-00068751-00068887": "should be around you somewhere but i", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00186-00068888-00069094": "don't see it anywhere", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00187-00069095-00069199": "well", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00188-00069200-00070167": "i don't", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00189-00070168-00070479": "but know keep going", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00190-00070480-00071031": "yeah i need to collect five", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00191-00071032-00071255": "let's keep going", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00192-00071256-00071375": "up", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00193-00071376-00071959": "come on we have to make it yeah oh", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00194-00071960-00073471": "come on i have to be close", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00195-00073472-00073687": "okay let's keep going", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00196-00073688-00074160": "that's one", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00197-00074161-00074575": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00198-00074576-00074823": "we're almost out", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00199-00074824-00075255": "we can do this", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00200-00075256-00075894": "hold up", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00201-00075895-00076415": "but", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00202-00076416-00077015": "we're almost there", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00203-00077016-00077238": "oh don't get it", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00204-00077239-00077591": "okay i got one", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00205-00077592-00078615": "hold up", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00206-00078616-00079126": "god", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00207-00079127-00079262": "yeah", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00208-00079263-00079550": "okay i don't need that yet though but", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00209-00079551-00079726": "what the hell is that window dragging me", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00210-00079727-00079862": "that", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00211-00079863-00080062": "oh both god i know where the book", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00212-00080063-00080487": "is but anyways", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00213-00080488-00080703": "i know what i have to do here", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00214-00080704-00080879": "first i need to i need to shoot these", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00215-00080880-00081399": "these guys down real quick", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00216-00081400-00082231": "on we can do this", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00217-00082232-00082406": "all right now i need to i only have 50", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00218-00082407-00082559": "seconds yes", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00219-00082560-00083167": "jesse i'll do that", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00220-00083168-00083535": "come on you can do this", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00221-00083536-00083711": "here's the hard part though i have to", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00222-00083712-00083879": "say the command block though", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00223-00083880-00084023": "can't be that hard", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00224-00084024-00084455": "let's just try it", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00225-00084456-00085255": "okay", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00226-00085256-00086111": "see it's in there oh my god", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00227-00086112-00086638": "all right let's just be careful", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00228-00086639-00087431": "yeah i'm just using the responsibility", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00229-00087432-00087567": "go", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00230-00087568-00088359": "we got 50 seconds", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00231-00088360-00088806": "did left get", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00232-00088807-00089191": "i hadn't swear i destroyed that", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00233-00089192-00089647": "i don't know if this is the bug", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00234-00089648-00089991": "i was really close though", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00235-00089992-00090140": "i don't know i was doing", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00236-00090141-00090575": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00237-00090576-00090877": "holy crap", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00238-00090878-00090999": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00239-00091000-00091326": "oh my god", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00240-00091327-00091703": "well keep going", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00241-00091704-00092701": "all right come on", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00242-00092702-00093094": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00243-00093095-00094255": "ow what's up", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00244-00094256-00094459": "oh my god", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00245-00094460-00095023": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00246-00095024-00095223": "oh we gotta be careful", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00247-00095224-00095591": "let's go", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00248-00095592-00096415": "all right let's hurry up", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00249-00096416-00096999": "i still need to continue to get that", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00250-00097000-00097774": "oh my god", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00251-00097775-00097918": "god", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00252-00097919-00098087": "gotta be careful yeah guys i hope you're", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00253-00098088-00098271": "watching this video as well because i", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00254-00098272-00098423": "really like it for four thousand one to", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00255-00098424-00098623": "one thousand subscribers if i gave them", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00256-00098624-00098815": "a thumbs up i need you guys to click the", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00257-00098816-00098991": "subscribe button and watch all the", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00258-00098992-00099679": "videos you have to get 4000 subscribers", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00259-00099680-00099951": "oh great i missed it", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00260-00099952-00100223": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00261-00100224-00100935": "oh", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00262-00100936-00101471": "come on", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00263-00101472-00101614": "all right come on hurry up let's hear it", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00264-00101615-00101982": "[Music]", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00265-00101983-00102566": "keep going", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00266-00102567-00103406": "come on let's go we can do this", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00267-00103407-00103934": "god damn it i missed i keep missing yet", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00268-00103935-00105095": "ow", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00269-00105096-00105815": "oh come on", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00270-00105816-00106207": "come on come here", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00271-00106208-00106695": "all right let's see with oh yeah", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00272-00106696-00107247": "do i do oh let's go", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00273-00107248-00107558": "let's go baby", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00274-00107559-00107727": "holy crap", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00275-00107728-00107883": "yeah", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00276-00107883-00108263": "look yeah look at this", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00277-00108264-00108783": "let's go baby", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00278-00108783-00108990": "all right i can read the words up okay", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00279-00108991-00109134": "guys that's how you place it thank you", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00280-00109135-00109283": "all for watching", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00281-00109283-00109527": "awesome remember please remember to", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00282-00109528-00109751": "subscribe hit this subscribe hit the", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00283-00109752-00109910": "bell so that way you never miss a video", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00284-00109911-00110031": "i post", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00285-00110032-00110239": "and it helps channel a lot", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00286-00110240-00110415": "and make sure you and remember to look", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00287-00110416-00110615": "at this graph also because", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00288-00110616-00110743": "look", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00289-00110744-00111007": "well i want you all subscribed i want", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00290-00111008-00111190": "i i want this whole line", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00291-00111191-00111383": "purple purple", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00292-00111383-00111543": "because i dab it for this for the", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00293-00111544-00111790": "subscribe the one not for the not for", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00294-00111791-00111990": "not subscribed", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00295-00111991-00112207": "all right ready okay guys have a great", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00296-00112208-00112310": "day", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00297-00112311-00112519": "i'll see you i'll see you all next week", "Xo_N7ZMgJEQ-00298-00112520-00112820": "goodbye"}}, {"audio_id": "XoefR3JpU5Y", "text": {"XoefR3JpU5Y-00000-00000131-00000407": "hey guys what's up its me", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00001-00000408-00000655": "Persephone I'm back with another", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00002-00000656-00000998": "inktober doodle video and I posted", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00003-00000999-00001450": "another poll on Instagram and I said who", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00004-00001451-00001627": "would you like to meet like me to draw", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00005-00001628-00001901": "on it Elsa or Belle and I think I told", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00006-00001902-00002171": "you this in yesterday's video oh and I", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00007-00002172-00002462": "was talking about Moana how mulana and", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00008-00002463-00002699": "Belle were tied and Instagram poll", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00009-00002700-00002977": "so finally Belle one and Instagram pulls", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00010-00002978-00003377": "so here is Belle now I I totally messed", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00011-00003378-00003688": "up on this because I drew this way too", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00012-00003689-00003956": "big because I wanted it to be like a", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00013-00003957-00004268": "full length Belle picture kind of", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00014-00004269-00004447": "similar to what I've been making already", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00015-00004448-00004685": "and I wanted them to all I don't know I", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00016-00004686-00004775": "was thinking about doing like a", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00017-00004776-00004988": "Photoshop project and photoshopping them", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00018-00004989-00005183": "all together and possibly making prints", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00019-00005184-00005536": "and selling them but now I totally", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00020-00005537-00005738": "messed up but I love this pose of Belle", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00021-00005739-00006017": "and have holies I've always drawn this", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00022-00006018-00006304": "particular pose of Belle from Beauty and", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00023-00006305-00006703": "the Beast but I never got it right I've", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00024-00006704-00006926": "always messed up her nose I've always", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00025-00006927-00007114": "messed up her lips the proportions of", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00026-00007115-00007358": "her face her hair everything and finally", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00027-00007359-00007838": "I got it right this time it looks so", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00028-00007839-00008087": "much better than the previous times I", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00029-00008088-00008296": "have drawn this particular pose I'm so", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00030-00008297-00008606": "happy that I have finally got this pose", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00031-00008607-00008899": "right and I've drawn this pose over and", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00032-00008900-00009217": "over and over and it's just never looked", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00033-00009218-00009385": "quite right to me so I'm happy that", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00034-00009386-00009878": "finally that I got it right but yeah I", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00035-00009879-00010184": "just I really enjoyed doodling this and", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00036-00010185-00010546": "I love the way that it turned out I'm", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00037-00010547-00010769": "kind of sad that this wasn't a regular", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00038-00010770-00011078": "watercolor because and this was an inked", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00039-00011079-00011303": "over because this would have been such a", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00040-00011304-00011563": "beautiful just the way that I finally", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00041-00011564-00011749": "drew it correctly I think that it would", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00042-00011750-00011933": "have looked so much better if it was", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00043-00011934-00012214": "actually a real watercolor but seeing as", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00044-00012215-00012463": "this is half black and white half color", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00045-00012464-00012796": "with the ink so Windsor and Newton inks", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00046-00012797-00013088": "I just oh well but and I really am sad", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00047-00013088-00013210": "that I did not make", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00048-00013211-00013504": "her I I drew her out and then I realized", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00049-00013505-00013765": "after I found out that I got her face", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00050-00013766-00013951": "just right and I didn't mess it up this", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00051-00013952-00014122": "time I saw that", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00052-00014122-00014962": "oh no the paper but yeah finally I got", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00053-00014963-00015181": "it right and I think this turned out", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00054-00015182-00015583": "awesome so yeah well hey only three more", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00055-00015584-00015859": "days of inktober let's all finish strong", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00056-00015860-00016063": "we've got this and I'm yeah and", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00057-00016063-00016252": "hopefully I can go ahead and just record", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00058-00016253-00016363": "the other inktober", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00059-00016363-00016621": "so I can just go ahead and just get them", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00060-00016622-00016924": "done so yeah guys I hope you enjoyed", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00061-00016925-00017140": "this little inktober video of Belle and", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00062-00017141-00017350": "I hope it all inspires you to do", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00063-00017351-00017694": "something half black and white F color", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00064-00017695-00018292": "with Incans Y is almost over it's a good", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00065-00018293-00018412": "thing or a bad thing it's totally up to", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00066-00018413-00018592": "you but I hope everybody enjoyed", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00067-00018593-00018829": "participating in toker this year I know", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00068-00018830-00019030": "I have it got a little crazy at the end", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00069-00019031-00019441": "but I always loved inktober and I love", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00070-00019442-00019647": "loving Topher every year and I love it", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00071-00019648-00019750": "in the end and I love it in the", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00072-00019751-00019909": "beginning and I love it in the middle I", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00073-00019910-00020113": "hope you guys enjoyed this and I'll see", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00074-00020114-00020242": "you all later", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00075-00020243-00020833": "[Music]", "XoefR3JpU5Y-00076-00020834-00021040": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "XoTIlQzi5Bu", "text": {"XoTIlQzi5Bu-00000-00000256-00000487": "blue plate special", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00001-00000488-00000686": "going out for a restaurant meal has been", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00002-00000687-00000886": "a part of saskatoon's history almost", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00003-00000888-00001103": "since its inception", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00004-00001104-00001295": "although the temperance society forbade", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00005-00001296-00001535": "alcohol dining out has long been a", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00006-00001536-00001743": "saskatoon tradition", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00007-00001744-00001967": "the chinese greek and ethnic community", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00008-00001968-00002279": "started eating establishments early on", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00009-00002280-00002463": "in fact saskatoon had a chinese", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00010-00002464-00002783": "restaurant as early as 1902.", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00011-00002784-00002958": "over the years sassatune has been", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00012-00002959-00003118": "reputed to have one of the highest", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00013-00003119-00003286": "number of restaurants per capita in", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00014-00003288-00004031": "canada", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00015-00004032-00004206": "the goose lake line was the rail line", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00016-00004207-00004470": "which ran from saskatoon to calgary", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00017-00004471-00004631": "the first tracks to the goose lake", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00018-00004632-00004902": "country of delisle tessier and rosetown", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00019-00004903-00005206": "were laid in 1907 reaching kindersley in", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00020-00005207-00005375": "1908.", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00021-00005376-00005527": "engineers and laborers on the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00022-00005528-00005806": "construction trains needed to be fed", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00023-00005807-00006006": "these cafe cars helped feed the work", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00024-00006007-00006191": "gangs as they lay track on the flat", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00025-00006192-00006983": "prairies", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00026-00006984-00007214": "the albert of albert's cafe was like the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00027-00007215-00007375": "albert hughes", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00028-00007376-00007598": "hughes was s.b dill's original partner", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00029-00007600-00007806": "when they opened the first alberts cafe", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00030-00007808-00008207": "at 112 20th street east in 1909.", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00031-00008208-00008519": "in 1912 dale would pay 75 000", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00032-00008520-00008687": "for the half interest owned by hughes", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00033-00008688-00008935": "and own the entire business", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00034-00008936-00009183": "there were soon three alberts cafes with", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00035-00009184-00009295": "restaurants on first", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00036-00009296-00009639": "avenue second avenue and third avenue", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00037-00009640-00009839": "the restaurant served short orders", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00038-00009840-00009959": "regular meals", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00039-00009960-00010246": "and sold ice cream cigars candies and", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00040-00010247-00011087": "fruit", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00041-00011088-00011327": "when the king edward hotel first opened", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00042-00011328-00011503": "its dining room was one of the largest", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00043-00011504-00011599": "in the city", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00044-00011600-00011903": "having a seating capacity for 60.", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00045-00011904-00012206": "by 1914 renovations had increased the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00046-00012207-00012438": "seating to 80 guests", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00047-00012439-00012670": "this circa 1912 view shows the dining", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00048-00012671-00012919": "room decorated for christmas", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00049-00012919-00013094": "it was described as one of the most", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00050-00013095-00013279": "inviting and attractive in the city of", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00051-00013280-00013407": "saskatoon", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00052-00013408-00013630": "where waitresses clad in sanitary", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00053-00013631-00013822": "immaculate garments flit about the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00054-00013823-00014038": "guests who crowd this popular room", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00055-00014040-00014966": "three times every day", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00056-00014968-00015247": "h kelly o'brien opened the rex cafe at", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00057-00015247-00015327": "258", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00058-00015328-00015663": "second avenue south in 1915", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00059-00015663-00015871": "previously he had operated the olympia", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00060-00015872-00016055": "cafe on 20th street east near the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00061-00016056-00016175": "phoenix building", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00062-00016176-00016527": "when he first came to saskatoon in 1910", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00063-00016528-00016791": "o'brien his brother stanley and other", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00064-00016792-00016903": "family members", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00065-00016904-00017199": "would operate the wrecks until 1919 when", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00066-00017200-00017383": "it became a chinese cafe called the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00067-00017384-00017519": "union", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00068-00017520-00017686": "kelly o'brien's involvement in the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00069-00017687-00017958": "restaurant business stopped in 1919", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00070-00017959-00018283": "when he joined the canadian northern", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00071-00018284-00018943": "railway", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00072-00018944-00019175": "only one lone customer is visible in", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00073-00019176-00019414": "this interior view of the rex cafe", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00074-00019415-00019719": "at 258 second avenue south although the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00075-00019720-00019903": "hanging coat suggests the other booths", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00076-00019904-00020079": "were occupied", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00077-00020080-00020303": "the rex cafe was advertised as the home", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00078-00020304-00020494": "of kelly's coffee", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00079-00020495-00020686": "indeed kelly o'brien operated a", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00080-00020687-00020871": "horse-drawn mobile coffee wagon he", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00081-00020872-00021055": "called the coffee cart", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00082-00021056-00021255": "he would decorate the wagon and drive it", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00083-00021256-00022214": "in the traveler's day parade", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00084-00022215-00022430": "an unidentified saskatoon banquet room", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00085-00022431-00022558": "with hardwood floors", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00086-00022559-00022855": "table set with linens and chairs the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00087-00022856-00023039": "location of this dining room remains", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00088-00023040-00023175": "unknown", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00089-00023176-00023367": "it may have been the palm room located", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00090-00023368-00023486": "in campbell's cafe", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00091-00023487-00023775": "next to the king george hotel the palm", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00092-00023776-00024807": "room was a popular dance in banquet hall", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00093-00024808-00025030": "with its signs stating nothing in this", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00094-00025031-00025230": "store over 15 cents", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00095-00025231-00025422": "the soda fountain at woolworths offered", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00096-00025423-00025702": "a wealth of temptation to the shopper", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00097-00025704-00025967": "root beer and orange crush were 5 cents", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00098-00025968-00026078": "sunday's only 10", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00099-00026079-00026399": "cents the fw woolworth company had come", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00100-00026400-00026695": "to saskatoon in 1914.", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00101-00026695-00027127": "in 1929 a new 5 10 15 cent store opened", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00102-00027127-00027231": "at 224", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00103-00027232-00027470": "21st street east complete with a", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00104-00027472-00027607": "gleaming soda fountain", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00105-00027608-00027823": "ready to serve up a palm dairy ice cream", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00106-00027824-00028983": "soda after a 5 in 10 shopping spree", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00107-00028983-00029255": "the chocolate shop at 167 second avenue", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00108-00029256-00029483": "south opened on may 24", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00109-00029483-00029855": "1922 at the time owner gus gulf boasted", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00110-00029856-00030023": "they were the finest ice cream and tea", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00111-00030024-00030262": "rooms in western canada", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00112-00030263-00030495": "called the studio of confections the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00113-00030495-00030567": "chocolate shop", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00114-00030568-00030879": "sold chocolates ice cream and lunches", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00115-00030880-00031095": "a novelty feature was the fact that all", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00116-00031095-00032079": "foods were cooked by electricity", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00117-00032080-00032255": "the chocolate shop was the last of", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00118-00032256-00032558": "gustav a golf's restaurant ventures", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00119-00032560-00032815": "golf had come to saskatoon in 1910 and", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00120-00032816-00033007": "opened the royal confectionary on 20th", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00121-00033008-00033159": "street east", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00122-00033160-00033383": "the electric baby cree on 21st street", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00123-00033384-00033631": "east and tea rooms on 2nd avenue south", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00124-00033632-00033927": "were other golf establishments the gulf", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00125-00033928-00034151": "name continues to be a part of saskatoon", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00126-00034152-00035079": "restaurant scene", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00127-00035080-00035311": "staff in the bezra hotel kitchen cooking", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00128-00035312-00035599": "its stoves in 1949", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00129-00035600-00035774": "under the supervision of chef guillaume", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00130-00035775-00036039": "schmitz the kitchens of the bisbee hotel", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00131-00036040-00036246": "could prepare some 1500 meals a day", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00132-00036247-00036471": "during convention period", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00133-00036472-00036718": "the kitchen army included a night chef", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00134-00036719-00036830": "second cook", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00135-00036831-00037143": "guard monge swingmen fry cook", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00136-00037144-00037487": "roast cook butcher vegetable cook", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00137-00037488-00037823": "vegetable boy fireman pot washer", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00138-00037824-00038143": "staff cook head still room girl pastry", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00139-00038144-00038215": "chef", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00140-00038216-00038567": "baker assistant pastry chef and pastry", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00141-00038568-00039415": "pot washer", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00142-00039416-00039646": "the biswar hotel's original cafeteria", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00143-00039647-00039823": "was located on the main floor to the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00144-00039824-00040039": "left of the entrance", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00145-00040040-00040311": "colored variegated tile walls chromium", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00146-00040312-00040551": "nickel chairs with red leather seeds", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00147-00040552-00040759": "and tables with black formica tops and", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00148-00040760-00040862": "silver trim", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00149-00040863-00041246": "were the latest in modern design in 1935", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00150-00041247-00041511": "the cafeteria offered quick service and", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00151-00041512-00041758": "meals from 25 cents to 40 cents every", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00152-00041759-00042007": "day of the week except sunday", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00153-00042008-00042302": "in 1962 the old timing was removed and", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00154-00042303-00042343": "the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00155-00042344-00043239": "cafeteria was modernized", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00156-00043240-00043446": "enjoy delicious skillfully prepared", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00157-00043447-00043615": "foods attractively served in", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00158-00043616-00043807": "surroundings reminiscent of picturesque", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00159-00043808-00043983": "algiers", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00160-00043984-00044239": "the algerian room located on the third", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00161-00044240-00044430": "floor of the eaton store at third avenue", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00162-00044431-00044599": "and 21st street", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00163-00044600-00044871": "featured soft carpeting mellow lights", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00164-00044872-00044999": "and tastefully appointed", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00165-00045000-00045335": "tables when the store opened in 1928", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00166-00045336-00045535": "at the time of this photograph the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00167-00045536-00046283": "tables had been replaced by a lunch", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00168-00046284-00046502": "counter", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00169-00046503-00046767": "harry comerford pauline schmidt stella", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00170-00046768-00046815": "mack", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00171-00046816-00047055": "and two unidentified friends stand in", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00172-00047056-00047246": "front of the quick lunch at 3 30", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00173-00047247-00047599": "20 street west located next to the roxy", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00174-00047600-00047767": "theater where pauline schmidt worked as", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00175-00047768-00047886": "a cashier", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00176-00047887-00048223": "the restaurant opened in 1932.", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00177-00048224-00048423": "jack mack stella's husband ran the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00178-00048424-00048683": "restaurant with his wife from 1934 until", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00179-00048684-00048871": "1937.", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00180-00048872-00049199": "by 1939 quick lunch disappeared to be", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00181-00049200-00050095": "replaced by another restaurant", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00182-00050096-00050343": "second avenue in the 1930s was home to", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00183-00050344-00050535": "probably nine or ten restaurants within", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00184-00050536-00050599": "two and a half", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00185-00050600-00050855": "blocks the golden gate cafe in", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00186-00050856-00051062": "confectionary at 145", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00187-00051063-00051287": "second avenue north in addition to", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00188-00051288-00051454": "dinner and candies", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00189-00051455-00051679": "offer daily tea cup readings courtesy of", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00190-00051679-00051854": "madame thwaite", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00191-00051855-00052079": "campbell's cafe and palm room located", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00192-00052079-00052238": "next to the king george hotel", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00193-00052239-00052563": "at 151 2nd avenue north was opened in", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00194-00052564-00052703": "1929", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00195-00052704-00053015": "by harry jones and james campbell it was", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00196-00053016-00053282": "described as the banquet hall of", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00197-00053283-00054071": "saskatoon", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00198-00054072-00054279": "the flickering red robin on the neon", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00199-00054279-00054415": "sign at 834", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00200-00054416-00054663": "broadway avenue welcome everyone from", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00201-00054664-00054838": "farmers to students", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00202-00054839-00055103": "to sisters from saint joseph's school", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00203-00055104-00055430": "all customers at the red robin cafe", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00204-00055432-00055654": "john heightman and raymond henderson had", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00205-00055655-00055823": "originally opened the red robin fruit", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00206-00055824-00055919": "store and cafe", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00207-00055920-00056294": "in 1929 heitmann would operate the cafe", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00208-00056295-00056599": "until 1951 when it was sold", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00209-00056600-00056887": "the restaurant closed in 1965 and the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00210-00056888-00057071": "building was demolished in september of", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00211-00057072-00057847": "that year", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00212-00057848-00058047": "at a serviceman's canteen in wartime", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00213-00058048-00058166": "saskatoon", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00214-00058167-00058423": "friends gene mcleod and bell bowers take", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00215-00058424-00058615": "a break from their jobs as stenographers", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00216-00058616-00058815": "to enjoy a meal", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00217-00058816-00059054": "their volunteer waiter is steve mckechun", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00218-00059055-00059326": "then mayor of saskatoon", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00219-00059327-00059559": "the recruiting poster behind them states", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00220-00059560-00059799": "women are urgently needed", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00221-00059800-00059991": "such fundraisers were a major part of", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00222-00059991-00060159": "the war effort", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00223-00060160-00060342": "this one may have taken place in the old", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00224-00060344-00061342": "canadian national railway station", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00225-00061344-00061559": "max colpac cook steak at the grill of", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00226-00061560-00061742": "the ritz hotel and cafe", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00227-00061744-00062054": "at 118 21st street east", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00228-00062055-00062247": "william gitos and his brother bought the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00229-00062248-00062575": "hotel and lunch counter in 1931.", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00230-00062576-00062759": "bill once told his daughter that he won", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00231-00062760-00062982": "the ritz in a card game", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00232-00062983-00063279": "when bill died in 1949 his wife effie", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00233-00063279-00063479": "took over the operation rebuilding the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00234-00063479-00063663": "cafe area", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00235-00063664-00063847": "effiegitros ran the place until her", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00236-00063848-00064071": "death in 1984.", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00237-00064072-00064263": "the day of her funeral according to her", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00238-00064264-00064494": "daughter was the only time in all that", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00239-00064495-00064599": "time the cafe was", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00240-00064600-00065423": "ever closed", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00241-00065424-00065719": "the shasta cafe at 213 second avenue", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00242-00065720-00065759": "south", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00243-00065760-00065943": "was another of saskatoon's greek owned", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00244-00065944-00066094": "restaurants", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00245-00066095-00066279": "ted gardner opened the restaurant in the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00246-00066280-00066487": "dc block in 1940", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00247-00066488-00066671": "only to have it damaged in the fire of", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00248-00066672-00066943": "december 1942", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00249-00066944-00067119": "ted gardner would manage the restaurant", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00250-00067120-00067271": "until 1950", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00251-00067272-00067559": "when joe gardner became manager during", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00252-00067560-00067750": "its history it was associated with the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00253-00067751-00068759": "saskatoon blackhawks baseball team", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00254-00068760-00068950": "when mike getter returned to saskatoon", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00255-00068951-00069150": "from serving in world war ii", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00256-00069151-00069343": "he and his wife ann opened the veterans", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00257-00069344-00069494": "cafe at 301", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00258-00069495-00069743": "20 street west where anne had previously", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00259-00069744-00069999": "operated the cylex cafe", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00260-00070000-00070206": "in 1948 they would move to the new", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00261-00070207-00070391": "corner building at 343", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00262-00070392-00070663": "20th street west they would own and", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00263-00070664-00070955": "operate the veterans cafe from 1945 to", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00264-00070956-00071103": "1962", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00265-00071104-00071294": "when the restaurant was sold and mikey", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00266-00071295-00071615": "became chef at the dunder and army camp", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00267-00071616-00072743": "by 1965 the veterans cafe was no more", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00268-00072744-00072919": "the lunch counter at belle's green and", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00269-00072920-00073119": "white service at cumberland and college", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00270-00073120-00073182": "drive", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00271-00073183-00073375": "was a favorite hangout for university", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00272-00073376-00073511": "students", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00273-00073512-00073759": "elmer bell a graduate and pharmacy from", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00274-00073760-00073950": "the university of saskatchewan", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00275-00073951-00074182": "had originally opened this meeting place", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00276-00074183-00074415": "which is not only very reasonable but", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00277-00074416-00074647": "said to put up a pretty good meal", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00278-00074648-00074831": "this is pretty important to those on our", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00279-00074832-00075719": "student budget", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00280-00075720-00075950": "the restaurant len pepper and s pappas", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00281-00075951-00076303": "open at 122nd avenue north in 1937", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00282-00076304-00076471": "was originally called the modern", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00283-00076472-00076655": "delicatessen", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00284-00076656-00076831": "later it would be known as the modern", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00285-00076832-00077031": "dale lunch and finally", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00286-00077032-00077335": "the dell changes in decor accompanied", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00287-00077336-00077535": "the changes in name", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00288-00077536-00077855": "the opening of the pioneer room in 1961", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00289-00077856-00077991": "brought with it the addition of", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00290-00077992-00078238": "gentleman jim char globe royal stakes to", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00291-00078239-00078382": "the menu", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00292-00078383-00078687": "changes in ownership in 1974 saw the end", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00293-00078688-00079543": "of the dell", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00294-00079544-00079782": "the original commodore cafe was located", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00295-00079783-00079999": "on 21st street east", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00296-00080000-00080238": "steve licos reopened the cafe at a new", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00297-00080239-00080311": "location", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00298-00080312-00080575": "at 108 second avenue north under the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00299-00080576-00080862": "name the new commodore cafe", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00300-00080863-00081075": "from this home base steve and", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00301-00081076-00081303": "sanspirolicos were great boosters of", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00302-00081304-00081367": "sport", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00303-00081368-00081694": "especially baseball the commodore cafe", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00304-00081695-00081879": "was a favorite place for players to come", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00305-00081880-00082023": "to eat", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00306-00082024-00082223": "we'll meet you at sparrows meant the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00307-00082224-00083071": "commodore cafe", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00308-00083072-00083382": "in august 1955 passengers in the new", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00309-00083383-00083575": "saskatoon airport terminal could have a", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00310-00083576-00083759": "cup of coffee or a meal while waiting", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00311-00083760-00083926": "for their flight", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00312-00083927-00084199": "the new facility boasted 24 stool coffee", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00313-00084200-00084255": "shop", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00314-00084256-00084494": "and 40-seat restaurant and came with a", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00315-00084495-00084711": "fully equipped kitchen", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00316-00084712-00084871": "a window in the restaurant overlooked", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00317-00084872-00085118": "the runway giving customers a view of", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00318-00085119-00086062": "incoming and departing flights", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00319-00086063-00086287": "you could dine and dance at the miracle", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00320-00086288-00086382": "shop cafe", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00321-00086383-00086847": "at 255 third avenue south in 1941.", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00322-00086848-00087062": "that was the year w and tape and jimmy", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00323-00087063-00087150": "wu opened an", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00324-00087151-00087435": "extension to the popular restaurant by", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00325-00087436-00087567": "1987", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00326-00087568-00087767": "the marigold has disappeared from", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00327-00087768-00088759": "saskatoon restaurant scene", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00328-00088760-00089031": "everyone loves a buffet the banquet room", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00329-00089032-00089247": "in the marigold restaurant was a popular", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00330-00089248-00089455": "location for businessman lunches and", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00331-00089456-00090375": "service club meetings", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00332-00090376-00090606": "when jack crones opened jd's restaurant", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00333-00090607-00090871": "on 8th street east in 1954", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00334-00090872-00091079": "he had to haul his own water to supply", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00335-00091080-00091247": "the restaurant", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00336-00091248-00091406": "from its modest beginnings as a", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00337-00091407-00091694": "roadhouse type cafe with curb service", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00338-00091695-00091982": "the restaurant would expand in 1964 to", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00339-00091983-00092182": "include a large banquet room", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00340-00092183-00092406": "smaller dining room and a cocktail", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00341-00092407-00092494": "lounge", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00342-00092495-00092687": "which at the time was the only such room", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00343-00092688-00093591": "on the east side of the river", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00344-00093592-00093782": "at the dalgenzad's drive-in restaurant", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00345-00093783-00093894": "on 8th street", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00346-00093895-00094079": "you could turn on your car lights and a", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00347-00094080-00094350": "car hawk would come to take your order", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00348-00094351-00094606": "in 1958 peter golf had flown to", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00349-00094607-00094774": "champaign illinois to", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00350-00094775-00094967": "acquire the canadian rights to the dog", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00351-00094968-00095167": "and suds franchise", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00352-00095168-00095406": "the first drive-in was at 2910 8th", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00353-00095407-00095567": "street east", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00354-00095568-00095735": "at one time you could get the world's", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00355-00095736-00095911": "creamiest root beer and a hot dog", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00356-00095912-00096223": "on 8th street on avenue a north and on", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00357-00096224-00097038": "22nd street", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00358-00097039-00097271": "located in the heart of chinatown the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00359-00097272-00097550": "golden dragon at 336 avenue c", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00360-00097551-00097767": "south was fixture on the chinese", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00361-00097768-00097950": "restaurant scene", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00362-00097951-00098262": "opened in 1958 by bing lam dare", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00363-00098263-00098518": "and later partnered with dare w dick the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00364-00098519-00098703": "golden dragon to many saskatoon", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00365-00098704-00098767": "residents", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00366-00098768-00099071": "signified chinese food customers could", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00367-00099072-00099287": "savor their chop suey and sweet and sour", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00368-00099288-00099518": "in either the lantern or dragon rooms", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00369-00099519-00100415": "or request delivery service", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00370-00100416-00100638": "a partnership between peter ponticus", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00371-00100639-00100887": "peter bezvez and james cosmas", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00372-00100888-00101031": "resulted in the construction and", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00373-00101032-00101279": "operation of the suburban restaurant", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00374-00101280-00101638": "located north on avenue a on highway 11.", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00375-00101639-00101879": "in addition to a dining and coffee room", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00376-00101880-00102111": "the restaurant was popular for banquets", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00377-00102112-00102382": "weddings and private parties a", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00378-00102383-00102647": "spectacular fire in 1973", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00379-00102648-00103566": "destroyed the restaurant", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00380-00103567-00103854": "in 1954 when joe young decided to serve", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00381-00103855-00103942": "colonel harlan", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00382-00103943-00104190": "sanders original recipe for chicken at", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00383-00104191-00104399": "his al rancho drive-in restaurant on 8th", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00384-00104400-00104486": "street", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00385-00104488-00104647": "it was the only the second kentucky", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00386-00104648-00104910": "fried chicken franchise in canada", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00387-00104911-00105071": "the original deal was based on a", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00388-00105072-00105254": "handshake between the colonel and joe", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00389-00105255-00105390": "young", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00390-00105391-00105575": "joe young would become the driving force", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00391-00105576-00105863": "of kfc in saskatchewan and canada", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00392-00105864-00106078": "his saskatoon based company was inducted", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00393-00106079-00106254": "into the saskatchewan business hall of", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00394-00106255-00107351": "fame in 2000.", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00395-00107352-00107527": "we hope you have enjoyed this virtual", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00396-00107528-00107823": "adaptation of loophate special", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00397-00107824-00108015": "the original show was held from february", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00398-00108016-00108175": "8th to march 11", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00399-00108176-00108502": "2005 and curated by ron giuremko with", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00400-00108503-00108783": "the assistance of local history staff", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00401-00108783-00109023": "we invite you to visit local history the", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00402-00109024-00109127": "next time you're at", "XoTIlQzi5Bu-00403-00109128-00109583": "the francis morrison central library"}}, {"audio_id": "X004EcS9x2y", "text": {"X004EcS9x2y-00000-00000014-00000343": "hi everybody it's me Deborah and it's", "X004EcS9x2y-00001-00000344-00000605": "good to be back with you I made a video", "X004EcS9x2y-00002-00000606-00000973": "yesterday for you about going away and", "X004EcS9x2y-00003-00000974-00001591": "how we get our routines out of whack and", "X004EcS9x2y-00004-00001592-00002072": "when that happens you can know they shy", "X004EcS9x2y-00005-00002073-00002231": "it's about to hit the fan", "X004EcS9x2y-00006-00002232-00002560": "but today I'm gonna talk to you about", "X004EcS9x2y-00007-00002561-00003009": "what we do as people with bipolar and", "X004EcS9x2y-00008-00003010-00003518": "borderline but more bipolar and I spoke", "X004EcS9x2y-00009-00003519-00003872": "to a few people who don't have bipolar", "X004EcS9x2y-00010-00003872-00004286": "so this helped to make what I'm saying", "X004EcS9x2y-00011-00004287-00004649": "to you the reality okay apart from what", "X004EcS9x2y-00012-00004650-00004931": "I've learned so first of all you might", "X004EcS9x2y-00013-00004932-00005276": "find that first we lose friends and", "X004EcS9x2y-00014-00005277-00005597": "family and we don't know why it's like", "X004EcS9x2y-00015-00005598-00005995": "we think that they're all idiots and", "X004EcS9x2y-00016-00005996-00006211": "we've done nothing wrong", "X004EcS9x2y-00017-00006212-00006481": "like what the hell but that's because we", "X004EcS9x2y-00018-00006483-00006875": "can't remember we don't understand at", "X004EcS9x2y-00019-00006876-00007205": "the time the way we talk the way we", "X004EcS9x2y-00020-00007206-00007573": "react to other people and it's not an", "X004EcS9x2y-00021-00007575-00007849": "excuse that I'm saying oh it's not our", "X004EcS9x2y-00022-00007850-00008227": "fault but truly it's not our fault so", "X004EcS9x2y-00023-00008228-00008576": "what happens is if someone doesn't know", "X004EcS9x2y-00024-00008577-00008971": "that you have bipolar or borderline", "X004EcS9x2y-00025-00008972-00009251": "you're going to behave in a certain way", "X004EcS9x2y-00026-00009252-00009542": "that's going to really upset them and", "X004EcS9x2y-00027-00009543-00009758": "it's not because you're gonna do it on", "X004EcS9x2y-00028-00009759-00010039": "purpose you're doing it almost as if", "X004EcS9x2y-00029-00010040-00010267": "it's just part of how you behave", "X004EcS9x2y-00030-00010268-00010781": "but it really freaks other people out we", "X004EcS9x2y-00031-00010782-00011096": "can do things like accuse people of", "X004EcS9x2y-00032-00011097-00011392": "things which didn't happen we can do", "X004EcS9x2y-00033-00011393-00011726": "things like when someone says to you for", "X004EcS9x2y-00034-00011727-00011770": "me", "X004EcS9x2y-00035-00011771-00012124": "you said X Y Z and it wouldn't be", "X004EcS9x2y-00036-00012125-00012320": "someone that would normally make a story", "X004EcS9x2y-00037-00012321-00012631": "up we will say I didn't do that the", "X004EcS9x2y-00038-00012632-00012919": "reason we'll say it is not because we're", "X004EcS9x2y-00039-00012920-00013186": "trying to protect ourselves it's because", "X004EcS9x2y-00040-00013187-00013310": "we honestly", "X004EcS9x2y-00041-00013311-00013691": "don't remember must remember was bipolar", "X004EcS9x2y-00042-00013691-00014018": "and borderline there are gaps in the", "X004EcS9x2y-00043-00014019-00014435": "memory big time we get memory lapses so", "X004EcS9x2y-00044-00014436-00014831": "I know for me it's like am I have I got", "X004EcS9x2y-00045-00014832-00015293": "dementia or what's going on no it's just", "X004EcS9x2y-00046-00015294-00015691": "the illness so again I tell you to", "X004EcS9x2y-00047-00015693-00016022": "accept your illness the more you fight", "X004EcS9x2y-00048-00016022-00016304": "it the worse it becomes because you", "X004EcS9x2y-00049-00016305-00016669": "can't then own when you screw up and", "X004EcS9x2y-00050-00016670-00016952": "when you screw up no it's the illness", "X004EcS9x2y-00051-00016953-00017342": "it's not your fault it's okay but if you", "X004EcS9x2y-00052-00017343-00017618": "own it and you say to whoever you've", "X004EcS9x2y-00053-00017619-00017813": "upset when they bring it to your", "X004EcS9x2y-00054-00017814-00018038": "attention if they do they don't just", "X004EcS9x2y-00055-00018039-00018260": "walk out and which i think is pretty", "X004EcS9x2y-00056-00018261-00018557": "nasty people should say like adults", "X004EcS9x2y-00057-00018558-00019004": "you know you said X Y Z and then you own", "X004EcS9x2y-00058-00019005-00019544": "it and apologize and try remember write", "X004EcS9x2y-00059-00019545-00019886": "it down if you have to but remember you", "X004EcS9x2y-00060-00019887-00020269": "are probably saying and doing things", "X004EcS9x2y-00061-00020270-00020638": "that are making people uncomfortable and", "X004EcS9x2y-00062-00020639-00021005": "unhappy to the point where they don't", "X004EcS9x2y-00063-00021006-00021197": "want to talk to us anymore", "X004EcS9x2y-00064-00021198-00021550": "we are seeing sometimes as toxic people", "X004EcS9x2y-00065-00021551-00021986": "but we're not it's the illness so all", "X004EcS9x2y-00066-00021987-00022259": "the time I've gotta bring this home now", "X004EcS9x2y-00067-00022260-00022703": "on the other hand we do have people who", "X004EcS9x2y-00068-00022704-00023077": "don't have bipolar or borderline or", "X004EcS9x2y-00069-00023078-00023483": "whatever who are just horrible people", "X004EcS9x2y-00070-00023484-00023738": "you know toxic this does exist we do", "X004EcS9x2y-00071-00023739-00024008": "have where I call them as dark forces", "X004EcS9x2y-00072-00024009-00024325": "people who are just toxic and get off on", "X004EcS9x2y-00073-00024326-00024602": "other people's pain as many of them in", "X004EcS9x2y-00074-00024603-00024665": "jail", "X004EcS9x2y-00075-00024666-00025006": "they don't have necessarily a mental", "X004EcS9x2y-00076-00025007-00025331": "disorder they could just be that from", "X004EcS9x2y-00077-00025332-00025661": "the heart you know just be mean people", "X004EcS9x2y-00078-00025662-00026012": "so the only way we know the difference", "X004EcS9x2y-00079-00026013-00026399": "is to get properly diagnosed and when", "X004EcS9x2y-00080-00026400-00026564": "you've been diagnosed", "X004EcS9x2y-00081-00026564-00026914": "then you know well okay it's not walking", "X004EcS9x2y-00082-00026916-00027240": "around but my fault not my fault but", "X004EcS9x2y-00083-00027241-00027650": "it's knowing that you're probably going", "X004EcS9x2y-00084-00027651-00027918": "to screw up somewhere along the line", "X004EcS9x2y-00085-00027919-00028298": "tell your friends or your family so that", "X004EcS9x2y-00086-00028299-00028529": "they know you're not doing it because", "X004EcS9x2y-00087-00028530-00028771": "you're a lousy person you're doing it", "X004EcS9x2y-00088-00028772-00029225": "because that's the illness but don't", "X004EcS9x2y-00089-00029226-00029729": "behave like an idiot nasty just because", "X004EcS9x2y-00090-00029730-00030064": "you have bipolar or borderline always", "X004EcS9x2y-00091-00030066-00030476": "try and be kind and loving sometimes we", "X004EcS9x2y-00092-00030477-00030776": "get writers as you know we can get rage", "X004EcS9x2y-00093-00030777-00031055": "as often but if you just live from your", "X004EcS9x2y-00094-00031056-00031262": "heart and I'm not preaching to you I'm", "X004EcS9x2y-00095-00031263-00031535": "telling your truth if you stop living", "X004EcS9x2y-00096-00031536-00031690": "from your head meaning", "X004EcS9x2y-00097-00031691-00032008": "oh she upset me I'm getting Sawyer it", "X004EcS9x2y-00098-00032010-00032282": "it'll be that person I'm gonna strangle", "X004EcS9x2y-00099-00032283-00032614": "them not literally but as a metaphor", "X004EcS9x2y-00100-00032616-00033104": "thing try and not always blame the", "X004EcS9x2y-00101-00033105-00033557": "illness try and take it on as I own it", "X004EcS9x2y-00102-00033558-00033923": "you know I own my mistakes but at the", "X004EcS9x2y-00103-00033924-00034349": "same time just remember as I say what", "X004EcS9x2y-00104-00034350-00034517": "they are and if you can't remember", "X004EcS9x2y-00105-00034518-00034789": "because we have gaps write it down I", "X004EcS9x2y-00106-00034790-00035312": "tend to rage when that happens and if", "X004EcS9x2y-00107-00035313-00035543": "you hit so rage and you go berserk on", "X004EcS9x2y-00108-00035544-00035921": "somebody it's okay just apologize and", "X004EcS9x2y-00109-00035922-00036299": "own it don't ever just say well I'm", "X004EcS9x2y-00110-00036300-00036554": "bipolar live with it you know", "X004EcS9x2y-00111-00036555-00036851": "it's a very selfish way of living so", "X004EcS9x2y-00112-00036852-00037136": "let's try and just we're trying to", "X004EcS9x2y-00113-00037137-00037454": "remove the stigma remember them we", "X004EcS9x2y-00114-00037455-00037748": "cannot remove the stigma as long as we", "X004EcS9x2y-00115-00037749-00038018": "walk around as if Harwell it's what our", "X004EcS9x2y-00116-00038019-00038207": "fault it's not our fault we didn't do", "X004EcS9x2y-00117-00038208-00038450": "anything that's not our fault no I can't", "X004EcS9x2y-00118-00038451-00038780": "do that and even if it's not our fault", "X004EcS9x2y-00119-00038781-00039283": "because we do screw up often it isn't", "X004EcS9x2y-00120-00039284-00039539": "our fault but when you know when someone", "X004EcS9x2y-00121-00039540-00039790": "tells you sometimes people don't say a", "X004EcS9x2y-00122-00039791-00039827": "word", "X004EcS9x2y-00123-00039828-00040190": "to say wow she or he is a really lousy", "X004EcS9x2y-00124-00040191-00040397": "person something's really wrong there", "X004EcS9x2y-00125-00040398-00040676": "I'm walking okay", "X004EcS9x2y-00126-00040677-00040912": "but sometimes you're good people who are", "X004EcS9x2y-00127-00040913-00041171": "mature enough to tell you what you've", "X004EcS9x2y-00128-00041172-00041372": "said or done that's really upset them", "X004EcS9x2y-00129-00041373-00041678": "and give you the opportunity to own it", "X004EcS9x2y-00130-00041679-00042086": "yes okay and apologize and write down", "X004EcS9x2y-00131-00042087-00042392": "what it is because that way you can look", "X004EcS9x2y-00132-00042393-00042626": "back and see are you getting better in", "X004EcS9x2y-00133-00042627-00042956": "that department in the rage Department", "X004EcS9x2y-00134-00042957-00043289": "what triggers you what makes you go off", "X004EcS9x2y-00135-00043290-00043376": "on a rage", "X004EcS9x2y-00136-00043377-00043618": "avoid those triggers like the plague", "X004EcS9x2y-00137-00043619-00043892": "just avoid them if they're coming to", "X004EcS9x2y-00138-00043893-00044096": "your space whatever the trigger might be", "X004EcS9x2y-00139-00044097-00044417": "write it so that you know when that", "X004EcS9x2y-00140-00044418-00044715": "happens for me when there's a trigger", "X004EcS9x2y-00141-00044716-00045056": "for rage I leave the room and I'm", "X004EcS9x2y-00142-00045057-00045323": "finding that is really helpful don't", "X004EcS9x2y-00143-00045324-00045635": "engage in an argument that's gonna set", "X004EcS9x2y-00144-00045636-00045923": "you off into a bipolar range like", "X004EcS9x2y-00145-00045924-00046277": "cray-cray or a borderline rash the", "X004EcS9x2y-00146-00046278-00046630": "bipolar rage is slightly more hectic but", "X004EcS9x2y-00147-00046631-00046919": "borderlines can have them too and it's", "X004EcS9x2y-00148-00046920-00047195": "all really born from the misfiring brain", "X004EcS9x2y-00149-00047196-00047492": "so I'm gonna leave it at that this is a", "X004EcS9x2y-00150-00047493-00047671": "quick video I don't want to make them", "X004EcS9x2y-00151-00047672-00047855": "too long because a lot of people don't", "X004EcS9x2y-00152-00047856-00048143": "like that but yeah I wanted to just fill", "X004EcS9x2y-00153-00048144-00048548": "you in on how we do mess up and you must", "X004EcS9x2y-00154-00048549-00048779": "own it when you mess up and write it on", "X004EcS9x2y-00155-00048780-00049085": "and just apologize that's all you can do", "X004EcS9x2y-00156-00049086-00049546": "and if they don't accept it well okay", "X004EcS9x2y-00157-00049547-00049907": "move on we're going forward not back", "X004EcS9x2y-00158-00049908-00050288": "remember that life is now and then we're", "X004EcS9x2y-00159-00050289-00050594": "moving forward that's it okay my", "X004EcS9x2y-00160-00050595-00050810": "darlings please hop on over to my", "X004EcS9x2y-00161-00050811-00051149": "patreon page I'd love it if you became", "X004EcS9x2y-00162-00051150-00051280": "one of my patrons", "X004EcS9x2y-00163-00051282-00051532": "I've is loads of things we can do", "X004EcS9x2y-00164-00051533-00051938": "together skyping and emailing and gifts", "X004EcS9x2y-00165-00051939-00052192": "and whatever visit the Etsy shop I", "X004EcS9x2y-00166-00052194-00052396": "haven't updated stuff but I'm going to", "X004EcS9x2y-00167-00052397-00052766": "I've only gotten back but three days ago", "X004EcS9x2y-00168-00052767-00052954": "so I'm sorry I haven't made any videos", "X004EcS9x2y-00169-00052955-00053391": "but I will go into the video of dealing", "X004EcS9x2y-00170-00053391-00053597": "with the funeral and what it did to me", "X004EcS9x2y-00171-00053598-00053937": "as soon as I get more settled as you can", "X004EcS9x2y-00172-00053938-00054205": "hear my voice has taken on this son", "X004EcS9x2y-00173-00054207-00054564": "husky tone or I'm losing my voice but", "X004EcS9x2y-00174-00054565-00054945": "it's fun so yeah patreon page", "X004EcS9x2y-00175-00054946-00055201": "thumbs up if you liked the video and", "X004EcS9x2y-00176-00055202-00055401": "please subscribe", "X004EcS9x2y-00177-00055402-00055770": "NEA to my new subscribers welcome to the", "X004EcS9x2y-00178-00055771-00056088": "tribe the bipolar line tribe remember we", "X004EcS9x2y-00179-00056089-00056357": "are a tribe why not we stick together", "X004EcS9x2y-00180-00056358-00056801": "Yuma's family I love you guys and see", "X004EcS9x2y-00181-00056802-00056862": "you soon", "X004EcS9x2y-00182-00056863-00057116": "remember I'll put the email address on", "X004EcS9x2y-00183-00057117-00057462": "my patreon page email me guys let me", "X004EcS9x2y-00184-00057463-00057651": "know what's up and we can always Skype", "X004EcS9x2y-00185-00057652-00058170": "all right then bloody lights ciao well", "X004EcS9x2y-00186-00058171-00058449": "this doesn't turn off"}}, {"audio_id": "X01jjaeusJg", "text": {"X01jjaeusJg-00000-00000064-00000238": "hey everybody it's darcy hope you're", "X01jjaeusJg-00001-00000239-00000327": "well", "X01jjaeusJg-00002-00000328-00000534": "i have had a busy couple weeks i'm", "X01jjaeusJg-00003-00000535-00000751": "actually back in school and i've started", "X01jjaeusJg-00004-00000752-00001023": "my sculpture class in my print media", "X01jjaeusJg-00005-00001024-00001199": "class and my", "X01jjaeusJg-00006-00001200-00001535": "studio seminar class um this", "X01jjaeusJg-00007-00001536-00001702": "video today is a watercolor", "X01jjaeusJg-00008-00001703-00001926": "unfortunately my friend lost her son", "X01jjaeusJg-00009-00001927-00002223": "in a tragic bicycle accident i did a", "X01jjaeusJg-00010-00002224-00002383": "variation of this", "X01jjaeusJg-00011-00002384-00002718": "video as a tribute for her um but this", "X01jjaeusJg-00012-00002719-00002879": "video will show you how i went about", "X01jjaeusJg-00013-00002880-00003183": "composing a still image of a", "X01jjaeusJg-00014-00003184-00003511": "bicycle which i'm sending to her anyway", "X01jjaeusJg-00015-00003511-00003663": "i hope you're great and staying", "X01jjaeusJg-00016-00003664-00004319": "safe and everything's great take care", "X01jjaeusJg-00017-00004320-00004679": "okay so this is gonna have like a lot of", "X01jjaeusJg-00018-00004680-00004767": "my paintings", "X01jjaeusJg-00019-00004768-00005111": "a lot of layers on it now the one tricky", "X01jjaeusJg-00020-00005112-00005215": "thing i did", "X01jjaeusJg-00021-00005216-00005622": "uh when i was looking at this image um", "X01jjaeusJg-00022-00005623-00005918": "i said to myself okay i should be able", "X01jjaeusJg-00023-00005919-00006111": "to take advantage of the fact that the", "X01jjaeusJg-00024-00006112-00006159": "bike", "X01jjaeusJg-00025-00006160-00006478": "needs to be in front of everything", "X01jjaeusJg-00026-00006479-00006614": "which kind of makes sense because it's", "X01jjaeusJg-00027-00006615-00006863": "leaning on a wall", "X01jjaeusJg-00028-00006864-00007063": "but the bigger advantage to this though", "X01jjaeusJg-00029-00007064-00007270": "is because i'm doing layering", "X01jjaeusJg-00030-00007272-00007631": "and because the bike is actually a dark", "X01jjaeusJg-00031-00007631-00007942": "rusted brown color basically throughout", "X01jjaeusJg-00032-00007943-00008231": "that meant i could do whatever i wanted", "X01jjaeusJg-00033-00008232-00008359": "in the background", "X01jjaeusJg-00034-00008360-00008663": "knowing full well that i'll be painting", "X01jjaeusJg-00035-00008664-00009063": "over it with the bike so for example", "X01jjaeusJg-00036-00009064-00009263": "yes i did leave some spaces here you can", "X01jjaeusJg-00037-00009264-00009374": "see right there how the", "X01jjaeusJg-00038-00009375-00009710": "tire is developing a form but if for", "X01jjaeusJg-00039-00009711-00009863": "example i", "X01jjaeusJg-00040-00009864-00010087": "painted too far into the tire where the", "X01jjaeusJg-00041-00010088-00010287": "tire was supposed to be the rim", "X01jjaeusJg-00042-00010288-00010510": "it i knew it really didn't matter", "X01jjaeusJg-00043-00010511-00010703": "because i would be painting darker", "X01jjaeusJg-00044-00010704-00011046": "colors over top of it in a glazing layer", "X01jjaeusJg-00045-00011047-00011246": "so i really took this to my advantage as", "X01jjaeusJg-00046-00011247-00011399": "best as i could", "X01jjaeusJg-00047-00011400-00011591": "just as a comparison you can imagine if", "X01jjaeusJg-00048-00011592-00011767": "this was a bright yellow bike i was", "X01jjaeusJg-00049-00011768-00011903": "trying to paint", "X01jjaeusJg-00050-00011904-00012183": "if that was the case i would have to", "X01jjaeusJg-00051-00012184-00012223": "make", "X01jjaeusJg-00052-00012224-00012551": "very sure that none of this brown or", "X01jjaeusJg-00053-00012552-00012623": "anything", "X01jjaeusJg-00054-00012624-00012815": "got into where the yellow paint would be", "X01jjaeusJg-00055-00012816-00013046": "because with watercolors", "X01jjaeusJg-00056-00013047-00013230": "you would be able to see that paint", "X01jjaeusJg-00057-00013231-00013422": "through the yellow bike and that's not", "X01jjaeusJg-00058-00013423-00013638": "what you want", "X01jjaeusJg-00059-00013640-00013838": "so i used there's probably with the", "X01jjaeusJg-00060-00013840-00014038": "palette i bet there was", "X01jjaeusJg-00061-00014040-00014375": "uh four different types of brown uh", "X01jjaeusJg-00062-00014376-00014558": "that one right there i just used that's", "X01jjaeusJg-00063-00014559-00014735": "quinacridone gold", "X01jjaeusJg-00064-00014736-00015055": "um i also used reds i went off the", "X01jjaeusJg-00065-00015056-00015103": "palette", "X01jjaeusJg-00066-00015104-00015430": "the brown paddle a little bit and threw", "X01jjaeusJg-00067-00015431-00015638": "in some oranges that were very", "X01jjaeusJg-00068-00015640-00015727": "complementary", "X01jjaeusJg-00069-00015728-00016022": "some reds as well for the uh more rust", "X01jjaeusJg-00070-00016023-00016166": "spots", "X01jjaeusJg-00071-00016168-00016366": "and a lot of people probably know this", "X01jjaeusJg-00072-00016368-00016583": "you'll see some blue in the background", "X01jjaeusJg-00073-00016584-00017055": "essentially as iron and metal oxidizes", "X01jjaeusJg-00074-00017056-00017271": "it there's sometimes a blue tinge to it", "X01jjaeusJg-00075-00017272-00017550": "so there's a little bit of blue in there", "X01jjaeusJg-00076-00017551-00017839": "now the other thing about this uh and", "X01jjaeusJg-00077-00017840-00017975": "the importance of using a reference", "X01jjaeusJg-00078-00017976-00018127": "photo because i use reference photos all", "X01jjaeusJg-00079-00018128-00018214": "the time", "X01jjaeusJg-00080-00018215-00018511": "um you when you're looking at the", "X01jjaeusJg-00081-00018512-00018679": "picture you can see how the wall in the", "X01jjaeusJg-00082-00018680-00018735": "back", "X01jjaeusJg-00083-00018736-00018943": "has some paint chipped off it and again", "X01jjaeusJg-00084-00018944-00019143": "it's rusting through there", "X01jjaeusJg-00085-00019144-00019439": "uh above the uh the gears for example", "X01jjaeusJg-00086-00019440-00019558": "you can see that's gonna be uh", "X01jjaeusJg-00087-00019559-00019839": "largely a white wall and at the very", "X01jjaeusJg-00088-00019840-00019967": "bottom you can see", "X01jjaeusJg-00089-00019968-00020167": "it's not rusted but there's just", "X01jjaeusJg-00090-00020168-00020383": "different colors of paint", "X01jjaeusJg-00091-00020384-00020743": "again indicating the wall itself", "X01jjaeusJg-00092-00020744-00021047": "so what am i trying to get at", "X01jjaeusJg-00093-00021048-00021294": "if you're looking at the picture the", "X01jjaeusJg-00094-00021295-00021439": "reason the paint", "X01jjaeusJg-00095-00021440-00021758": "got scratched off on the wall where it", "X01jjaeusJg-00096-00021759-00021847": "is", "X01jjaeusJg-00097-00021848-00022094": "was because the bike over the years was", "X01jjaeusJg-00098-00022095-00022286": "left up in different spots against the", "X01jjaeusJg-00099-00022287-00022327": "wall", "X01jjaeusJg-00100-00022328-00022527": "and maybe for example the owner of the", "X01jjaeusJg-00101-00022528-00022791": "bike skidded in and chipped some paint", "X01jjaeusJg-00102-00022792-00022999": "um but it was all because of the pedal", "X01jjaeusJg-00103-00023000-00023127": "and the gearbox", "X01jjaeusJg-00104-00023128-00023350": "um that you can see there so i wanted to", "X01jjaeusJg-00105-00023351-00023494": "make sure", "X01jjaeusJg-00106-00023495-00023711": "um i followed the reference photo and", "X01jjaeusJg-00107-00023712-00023807": "kept that same", "X01jjaeusJg-00108-00023808-00024055": "paint chipped area which is now a rusted", "X01jjaeusJg-00109-00024056-00024158": "color", "X01jjaeusJg-00110-00024159-00024391": "at the same level and again i'm", "X01jjaeusJg-00111-00024392-00024503": "repeating myself but", "X01jjaeusJg-00112-00024504-00024678": "so at the very top of the painting you", "X01jjaeusJg-00113-00024679-00024894": "wouldn't want to see paint chip because", "X01jjaeusJg-00114-00024895-00025119": "nothing was chipping the paint the bike", "X01jjaeusJg-00115-00025120-00025311": "as it was being left", "X01jjaeusJg-00116-00025312-00025542": "when it wasn't in use was only chipping", "X01jjaeusJg-00117-00025543-00025718": "where the", "X01jjaeusJg-00118-00025719-00026031": "pedal was and the gears so", "X01jjaeusJg-00119-00026032-00026231": "other than that it's a it's a pretty", "X01jjaeusJg-00120-00026232-00026399": "easy painting to do if you're looking at", "X01jjaeusJg-00121-00026400-00026574": "something like this but i can't stress", "X01jjaeusJg-00122-00026575-00026679": "enough", "X01jjaeusJg-00123-00026680-00026902": "that probably one of the most important", "X01jjaeusJg-00124-00026904-00027031": "things was", "X01jjaeusJg-00125-00027032-00027231": "following the reference photo and having", "X01jjaeusJg-00126-00027232-00027495": "a dark object in front of all the light", "X01jjaeusJg-00127-00027495-00027862": "objects so just at the very end here", "X01jjaeusJg-00128-00027863-00028070": "i'm filling in the paint at the back", "X01jjaeusJg-00129-00028072-00028199": "because it was worn", "X01jjaeusJg-00130-00028200-00028414": "it wasn't like a fresh coat of paint", "X01jjaeusJg-00131-00028416-00028574": "it's just a lot of dry brushing that i'm", "X01jjaeusJg-00132-00028575-00028646": "doing", "X01jjaeusJg-00133-00028647-00028902": "and it's definitely up and down and", "X01jjaeusJg-00134-00028904-00029102": "there goes the tape", "X01jjaeusJg-00135-00029104-00029439": "and here's the final product please like", "X01jjaeusJg-00136-00029439-00029527": "and subscribe", "X01jjaeusJg-00137-00029527-00029679": "if you like videos like this and i", "X01jjaeusJg-00138-00029680-00029799": "appreciate you watching and hope you", "X01jjaeusJg-00139-00029800-00031383": "have a great day", "X01jjaeusJg-00140-00031383-00031591": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "X0eez7H0vdg", "text": {"X0eez7H0vdg-00000-00000055-00000322": "gödel's incompleteness theorems are two", "X0eez7H0vdg-00001-00000323-00000534": "theorems of mathematical logic that", "X0eez7H0vdg-00002-00000535-00000754": "demonstrate the inherent limitations of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00003-00000755-00001008": "every formal axiomatic system capable of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00004-00001009-00001320": "modeling basic arithmetic these results", "X0eez7H0vdg-00005-00001321-00001614": "published by kurt gödel in 1931 are", "X0eez7H0vdg-00006-00001616-00001870": "important both in mathematical logic and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00007-00001871-00002143": "in the philosophy of mathematics the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00008-00002144-00002389": "theorems are widely but not universally", "X0eez7H0vdg-00009-00002390-00002578": "interpreted as showing that Hilbert's", "X0eez7H0vdg-00010-00002579-00002761": "program to find a complete and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00011-00002762-00002950": "consistent set of axioms for all", "X0eez7H0vdg-00012-00002951-00003258": "mathematics as impossible the first", "X0eez7H0vdg-00013-00003259-00003463": "incompleteness theorem states that no", "X0eez7H0vdg-00014-00003464-00003663": "consistent system of axioms whose", "X0eez7H0vdg-00015-00003664-00003868": "theorems can be listed by an effective", "X0eez7H0vdg-00016-00003869-00004159": "procedure ie an algorithm is capable of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00017-00004160-00004359": "proving all truths about the arithmetic", "X0eez7H0vdg-00018-00004360-00004627": "of the natural numbers for any such", "X0eez7H0vdg-00019-00004628-00004825": "consistent formal system there will", "X0eez7H0vdg-00020-00004826-00005020": "always be statements about the natural", "X0eez7H0vdg-00021-00005021-00005196": "numbers that are true but that are", "X0eez7H0vdg-00022-00005197-00005475": "unprovable within the system the second", "X0eez7H0vdg-00023-00005476-00005686": "incompleteness theorem an extension of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00024-00005687-00005898": "the first shows that the system cannot", "X0eez7H0vdg-00025-00005899-00006143": "demonstrate its own consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-00026-00006144-00006439": "employing a diagonal argument gödel's", "X0eez7H0vdg-00027-00006440-00006634": "incompleteness theorems were the first", "X0eez7H0vdg-00028-00006634-00006862": "of several closely related theorems on", "X0eez7H0vdg-00029-00006863-00007153": "the limitations of formal systems they", "X0eez7H0vdg-00030-00007154-00007342": "were followed by tarski zunda fine", "X0eez7H0vdg-00031-00007343-00007506": "ability theorem on the formal", "X0eez7H0vdg-00032-00007507-00007759": "undefinable ax t of truth church's proof", "X0eez7H0vdg-00033-00007759-00007963": "that Hilbert's and shadings problem is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00034-00007964-00008167": "unsolvable and Turing's theorem that", "X0eez7H0vdg-00035-00008168-00008338": "there is no algorithm to solve the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00036-00008339-00008923": "halting problem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00037-00008924-00009267": "topic formal systems completeness", "X0eez7H0vdg-00038-00009268-00009882": "consistency and effective axiomatization", "X0eez7H0vdg-00039-00009883-00010146": "the incompleteness theorems apply to", "X0eez7H0vdg-00040-00010147-00010348": "formal systems that are of sufficient", "X0eez7H0vdg-00041-00010349-00010537": "complexity to Express the basic", "X0eez7H0vdg-00042-00010538-00010741": "arithmetic of the natural numbers and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00043-00010742-00010914": "which are consistent and effectively", "X0eez7H0vdg-00044-00010915-00011163": "axiom Atty z'd these concepts being", "X0eez7H0vdg-00045-00011164-00011443": "detailed below particularly in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00046-00011444-00011644": "context of first-order logic", "X0eez7H0vdg-00047-00011645-00011857": "formal systems are also called formal", "X0eez7H0vdg-00048-00011858-00012190": "theories in general a formal system as a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00049-00012191-00012418": "deductive apparatus that consists of a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00050-00012419-00012640": "particular set of axioms along with", "X0eez7H0vdg-00051-00012641-00012885": "rules of symbolic manipulation or rules", "X0eez7H0vdg-00052-00012886-00013054": "of inference that allow for the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00053-00013055-00013237": "derivation of new theorems from the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00054-00013238-00013566": "axioms one example of such a system as", "X0eez7H0vdg-00055-00013568-00013825": "first-order peano arithmetic a system in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00056-00013826-00014005": "which all variables are intended to", "X0eez7H0vdg-00057-00014006-00014302": "denote natural numbers in other systems", "X0eez7H0vdg-00058-00014303-00014554": "such as set theory only some sentences", "X0eez7H0vdg-00059-00014555-00014782": "of the formal system Express statements", "X0eez7H0vdg-00060-00014783-00015004": "about the natural numbers the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00061-00015005-00015219": "incompleteness theorems are about formal", "X0eez7H0vdg-00062-00015220-00015391": "proved ability within these systems", "X0eez7H0vdg-00063-00015391-00015700": "rather than about prove ability in an", "X0eez7H0vdg-00064-00015701-00015985": "informal sense there are several", "X0eez7H0vdg-00065-00015986-00016188": "properties that a formal system may have", "X0eez7H0vdg-00066-00016190-00016468": "including completeness consistency and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00067-00016469-00016618": "the existence of an effective", "X0eez7H0vdg-00068-00016619-00016878": "axiomatization the incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-00069-00016879-00017119": "theorems show that systems which contain", "X0eez7H0vdg-00070-00017120-00017335": "a sufficient amount of arithmetic cannot", "X0eez7H0vdg-00071-00017336-00018021": "possess all three of these properties", "X0eez7H0vdg-00072-00018022-00018641": "topic effective axiomatization", "X0eez7H0vdg-00073-00018642-00018851": "a formal system is said to be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00074-00018852-00019085": "effectively axiom Atty also called", "X0eez7H0vdg-00075-00019086-00019289": "effectively generated if it's set of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00076-00019290-00019526": "theorems as a recursively enumerable set", "X0eez7H0vdg-00077-00019527-00020057": "Francie in 2005 P 112 this means that", "X0eez7H0vdg-00078-00020058-00020249": "there is a computer program that in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00079-00020250-00020432": "principle could enumerate all the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00080-00020433-00020624": "theorems of the system without listing", "X0eez7H0vdg-00081-00020625-00020844": "any statements that are not theorems", "X0eez7H0vdg-00082-00020845-00021086": "examples of effectively generated", "X0eez7H0vdg-00083-00021087-00021329": "theories include peano arithmetic and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00084-00021330-00021700": "Zermelo Fraenkel set theory ZF see the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00085-00021701-00021955": "theory known as true arithmetic consists", "X0eez7H0vdg-00086-00021956-00022115": "of all true statements about the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00087-00022116-00022297": "standard integers in the language of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00088-00022298-00022565": "peano arithmetic this theory is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00089-00022566-00022805": "consistent and complete and contains a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00090-00022806-00023087": "sufficient amount of arithmetic however", "X0eez7H0vdg-00091-00023088-00023240": "it does not have a recursively", "X0eez7H0vdg-00092-00023241-00023486": "enumerable set of axioms and thus does", "X0eez7H0vdg-00093-00023487-00023690": "not satisfy the hypotheses of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00094-00023691-00024294": "incompleteness theorems", "X0eez7H0vdg-00095-00024295-00024811": "topic completeness", "X0eez7H0vdg-00096-00024812-00025093": "a set of axioms as syntactically or", "X0eez7H0vdg-00097-00025094-00025327": "negation complete if for any statement", "X0eez7H0vdg-00098-00025328-00025572": "in the axioms language that statement or", "X0eez7H0vdg-00099-00025573-00025800": "its negation is provable from the axioms", "X0eez7H0vdg-00100-00025801-00026233": "Smith 2007 P 24 this is the notion", "X0eez7H0vdg-00101-00026233-00026401": "relevant for gödel's first", "X0eez7H0vdg-00102-00026402-00026623": "incompleteness theorem it is not to be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00103-00026624-00026802": "confused with semantics completeness", "X0eez7H0vdg-00104-00026804-00027007": "which means that the set of axioms", "X0eez7H0vdg-00105-00027008-00027246": "proves all the semantics tautologies of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00106-00027247-00027493": "the given language in his completeness", "X0eez7H0vdg-00107-00027494-00027568": "theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00108-00027569-00027793": "gödel proved that first-order logic is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00109-00027794-00028051": "semantically complete but it is not", "X0eez7H0vdg-00110-00028052-00028264": "syntactically complete since there are", "X0eez7H0vdg-00111-00028264-00028474": "sentences expressible in the language of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00112-00028475-00028665": "first-order logic that can be neither", "X0eez7H0vdg-00113-00028666-00028920": "proved nor disproved from the axioms of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00114-00028922-00029289": "logic alone in a mere system of logic it", "X0eez7H0vdg-00115-00029291-00029487": "would be absurd to expect syntactic", "X0eez7H0vdg-00116-00029488-00029731": "completeness but in a system of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00117-00029732-00029977": "mathematics thinkers such as Hilbert had", "X0eez7H0vdg-00118-00029977-00030142": "believed that it is just a matter of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00119-00030143-00030433": "time to find such an axiomatization that", "X0eez7H0vdg-00120-00030433-00030610": "would allow one to either prove or", "X0eez7H0vdg-00121-00030611-00030832": "disprove by proving its negation each", "X0eez7H0vdg-00122-00030833-00031177": "and every mathematical formula a formal", "X0eez7H0vdg-00123-00031177-00031395": "system might be syntactically incomplete", "X0eez7H0vdg-00124-00031397-00031665": "by design such as logics generally are", "X0eez7H0vdg-00125-00031666-00031975": "or it may be incomplete simply because", "X0eez7H0vdg-00126-00031976-00032176": "not all the necessary axioms have been", "X0eez7H0vdg-00127-00032177-00032430": "discovered or included for example", "X0eez7H0vdg-00128-00032431-00032695": "Euclidean geometry without the parallel", "X0eez7H0vdg-00129-00032695-00032911": "postulate is incomplete because some", "X0eez7H0vdg-00130-00032912-00033112": "statements in the language such as the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00131-00033113-00033312": "parallel postulate itself cannot be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00132-00033313-00033531": "proved from the remaining axioms", "X0eez7H0vdg-00133-00033532-00033793": "similarly the theory of dense linear", "X0eez7H0vdg-00134-00033794-00034006": "orders is not complete but becomes", "X0eez7H0vdg-00135-00034007-00034231": "complete with an extra axiom stating", "X0eez7H0vdg-00136-00034232-00034414": "that there are no endpoints in the order", "X0eez7H0vdg-00137-00034415-00034711": "the Continuum Hypothesis as a statement", "X0eez7H0vdg-00138-00034712-00034887": "in the language of ZFC", "X0eez7H0vdg-00139-00034888-00035218": "that is not provable within ZFC says EFC", "X0eez7H0vdg-00140-00035219-00035536": "is not complete in this case there is no", "X0eez7H0vdg-00141-00035537-00035749": "obvious candidate for a new axiom that", "X0eez7H0vdg-00142-00035750-00036046": "resolves the issue the theory of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00143-00036047-00036244": "first-order peano arithmetic is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00144-00036245-00036427": "consistent has an infinite but", "X0eez7H0vdg-00145-00036428-00036676": "recursively enumerable set of axioms and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00146-00036677-00036871": "can encode enough arithmetic for the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00147-00036872-00037092": "hypotheses of the incompleteness theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00148-00037093-00037377": "thus by the first incompleteness theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00149-00037378-00037687": "peano arithmetic is not complete the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00150-00037688-00037912": "theorem gives an explicit example of a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00151-00037913-00038098": "statement of arithmetic that is neither", "X0eez7H0vdg-00152-00038099-00038185": "provable", "X0eez7H0vdg-00153-00038186-00038439": "or disprovable in Pinos arithmetics", "X0eez7H0vdg-00154-00038440-00038704": "moreover this statement is true in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00155-00038705-00038986": "usual model moreover no effectively", "X0eez7H0vdg-00156-00038987-00039255": "axiomatic consistent extension of peano", "X0eez7H0vdg-00157-00039256-00039898": "arithmetic can be complete", "X0eez7H0vdg-00158-00039899-00040425": "topic consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-00159-00040426-00040734": "a set of axioms as simply consistent if", "X0eez7H0vdg-00160-00040735-00040932": "there is no statement such that both the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00161-00040933-00041136": "statement and its negation are provable", "X0eez7H0vdg-00162-00041137-00041325": "from the axioms and inconsistent", "X0eez7H0vdg-00163-00041326-00041679": "otherwise peano arithmetic is provably", "X0eez7H0vdg-00164-00041680-00041943": "consistent from ZFC but not from within", "X0eez7H0vdg-00165-00041944-00042032": "itself", "X0eez7H0vdg-00166-00042033-00042399": "similarly ZFC is not provably consistent", "X0eez7H0vdg-00167-00042400-00042687": "from within itself but ZFC plus there", "X0eez7H0vdg-00168-00042688-00043005": "exists an inaccessible cardinal proves", "X0eez7H0vdg-00169-00043006-00043266": "ZFC is consistent because if katha is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00170-00043267-00043488": "the least such cardinal then v kappa", "X0eez7H0vdg-00171-00043489-00043704": "sitting inside the von neumann universe", "X0eez7H0vdg-00172-00043705-00043860": "as a model of ZFC", "X0eez7H0vdg-00173-00043861-00044079": "and a theory is consistent if and only", "X0eez7H0vdg-00174-00044080-00044388": "if it has a model if one takes all", "X0eez7H0vdg-00175-00044389-00044559": "statements in the language of peano", "X0eez7H0vdg-00176-00044560-00044829": "arithmetic as axioms then this theory is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00177-00044830-00045030": "complete has a recursively enumerable", "X0eez7H0vdg-00178-00045031-00045306": "set of axioms and can describe addition", "X0eez7H0vdg-00179-00045307-00045603": "and multiplication however it is not", "X0eez7H0vdg-00180-00045604-00045918": "consistent additional examples of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00181-00045919-00046125": "inconsistent theories arise from the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00182-00046126-00046353": "paradoxes that result when the axiom", "X0eez7H0vdg-00183-00046354-00046581": "schema of unrestricted comprehension is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00184-00046582-00047195": "assumed in set theory", "X0eez7H0vdg-00185-00047196-00047680": "topic systems which contain arithmetic", "X0eez7H0vdg-00186-00047681-00047839": "you", "X0eez7H0vdg-00187-00047840-00048085": "the incompleteness theorems apply only", "X0eez7H0vdg-00188-00048086-00048283": "to formal systems which are able to", "X0eez7H0vdg-00189-00048284-00048481": "prove a sufficient collection of facts", "X0eez7H0vdg-00190-00048482-00048790": "about the natural numbers one sufficient", "X0eez7H0vdg-00191-00048791-00048973": "collection as the set of theorems of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00192-00048974-00049252": "Robinson arithmetic q some systems such", "X0eez7H0vdg-00193-00049253-00049498": "as peano arithmetic can directly express", "X0eez7H0vdg-00194-00049499-00049695": "statements about natural numbers", "X0eez7H0vdg-00195-00049696-00050008": "others such as ZF see set theory are", "X0eez7H0vdg-00196-00050009-00050190": "able to interpret statements about", "X0eez7H0vdg-00197-00050191-00050385": "natural numbers into their language", "X0eez7H0vdg-00198-00050386-00050668": "either of these options as appropriate", "X0eez7H0vdg-00199-00050669-00050886": "for the incompleteness theorems the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00200-00050887-00051190": "theory of algebraically closed fields of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00201-00051191-00051388": "a given characteristic is complete", "X0eez7H0vdg-00202-00051389-00051598": "consistent and has an infinite but", "X0eez7H0vdg-00203-00051599-00051849": "recursively enumerable set of axioms", "X0eez7H0vdg-00204-00051850-00052135": "however it is not possible to encode the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00205-00052136-00052348": "integers into this theory and the theory", "X0eez7H0vdg-00206-00052349-00052614": "cannot describe arithmetic of integers a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00207-00052615-00052882": "similar example as the theory of real", "X0eez7H0vdg-00208-00052883-00053089": "closed fields which is essentially", "X0eez7H0vdg-00209-00053090-00053287": "equivalent to tar skis axioms for", "X0eez7H0vdg-00210-00053288-00053599": "Euclidean geometry so euclidean geometry", "X0eez7H0vdg-00211-00053600-00053896": "itself in tar skis formulation is an", "X0eez7H0vdg-00212-00053897-00054085": "example of a complete consistent", "X0eez7H0vdg-00213-00054086-00054457": "effectively axiomatic theory the system", "X0eez7H0vdg-00214-00054458-00054688": "of Pressburger arithmetic consists of a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00215-00054689-00054901": "set of axioms for the natural numbers", "X0eez7H0vdg-00216-00054902-00055060": "with just the addition operation", "X0eez7H0vdg-00217-00055061-00055392": "multiplication is omitted Pressburger", "X0eez7H0vdg-00218-00055394-00055636": "arithmetic is complete consistent and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00219-00055637-00055854": "recursively enumerable and can encode", "X0eez7H0vdg-00220-00055855-00056065": "addition but not multiplication of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00221-00056066-00056287": "natural numbers showing that for gödel's", "X0eez7H0vdg-00222-00056288-00056503": "theorems one needs the theory to encode", "X0eez7H0vdg-00223-00056504-00056651": "not just addition but also", "X0eez7H0vdg-00224-00056652-00057076": "multiplication dan Willard 2001 has", "X0eez7H0vdg-00225-00057077-00057286": "studied some weak families of arithmetic", "X0eez7H0vdg-00226-00057287-00057519": "systems which allow enough arithmetic as", "X0eez7H0vdg-00227-00057520-00057703": "relations to formalize gödel numbering", "X0eez7H0vdg-00228-00057704-00057940": "but which are not strong enough to have", "X0eez7H0vdg-00229-00057941-00058179": "multiplication as a function and so fail", "X0eez7H0vdg-00230-00058180-00058326": "to prove the second incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-00231-00058327-00058566": "theorem these systems are consistent and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00232-00058567-00058747": "capable of proving their own consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-00233-00058748-00059454": "see self verifying theories", "X0eez7H0vdg-00234-00059454-00060015": "topic conflicting goals", "X0eez7H0vdg-00235-00060016-00060312": "in choosing a set of axioms one goal is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00236-00060313-00060491": "to be able to prove as many correct", "X0eez7H0vdg-00237-00060492-00060714": "results as possible without proving any", "X0eez7H0vdg-00238-00060715-00061026": "incorrect results for example we could", "X0eez7H0vdg-00239-00061027-00061272": "imagine a set of true axioms which allow", "X0eez7H0vdg-00240-00061273-00061454": "us to prove every true arithmetic", "X0eez7H0vdg-00241-00061455-00061698": "acclaim about the natural numbers Smith", "X0eez7H0vdg-00242-00061699-00062082": "2007 P 2 in the standard system of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00243-00062083-00062328": "first-order logic an inconsistent set of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00244-00062329-00062553": "axioms will prove every statement in its", "X0eez7H0vdg-00245-00062554-00062741": "language this is sometimes called the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00246-00062742-00062942": "principle of explosion and is thus", "X0eez7H0vdg-00247-00062944-00063246": "automatically complete a set of axioms", "X0eez7H0vdg-00248-00063247-00063467": "that is both complete and consistent", "X0eez7H0vdg-00249-00063469-00063692": "however proves a maximal set of non", "X0eez7H0vdg-00250-00063694-00064187": "contradictory theorems him in 2005 P 143", "X0eez7H0vdg-00251-00064188-00064470": "the pattern illustrated in the previous", "X0eez7H0vdg-00252-00064471-00064761": "sections with peano arithmetic z FC and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00253-00064762-00065085": "z FC plus there exists an inaccessible", "X0eez7H0vdg-00254-00065086-00065429": "Cardinal cannot generally be broken here", "X0eez7H0vdg-00255-00065430-00065766": "Z FC plus there exists an inaccessible", "X0eez7H0vdg-00256-00065767-00066072": "Cardinal cannot from itself be proved", "X0eez7H0vdg-00257-00066073-00066345": "consistent it is also not complete as", "X0eez7H0vdg-00258-00066346-00066648": "illustrated by the in Z FC plus there", "X0eez7H0vdg-00259-00066649-00066975": "exists an inaccessible Cardinal Theory", "X0eez7H0vdg-00260-00066976-00067311": "unresolved Continuum Hypothesis the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00261-00067312-00067518": "first incompleteness theorem shows that", "X0eez7H0vdg-00262-00067519-00067767": "in formal systems that can express basic", "X0eez7H0vdg-00263-00067768-00067956": "arithmetic a complete and consistent", "X0eez7H0vdg-00264-00067957-00068199": "finite list of axioms can never be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00265-00068200-00068357": "created each time an additional", "X0eez7H0vdg-00266-00068358-00068583": "consistent statement is added as an", "X0eez7H0vdg-00267-00068584-00068793": "axiom there are other true statements", "X0eez7H0vdg-00268-00068794-00068952": "that still cannot be proved", "X0eez7H0vdg-00269-00068953-00069258": "even with the new axiom if an axiom is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00270-00069259-00069405": "ever added that makes the system", "X0eez7H0vdg-00271-00069406-00069627": "complete it does so at the cost of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00272-00069628-00069918": "making the system inconsistent it is not", "X0eez7H0vdg-00273-00069919-00070122": "even possible for an infinite list of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00274-00070123-00070368": "axioms to be complete consistent and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00275-00070369-00071039": "effectively axiom Atty x'd", "X0eez7H0vdg-00276-00071040-00071672": "topic first incompleteness theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00277-00071673-00071915": "gödel's first incompleteness theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00278-00071916-00072265": "first appeared as theorem V in gödel's", "X0eez7H0vdg-00279-00072266-00072602": "1931 paper on formally undecidable", "X0eez7H0vdg-00280-00072603-00072793": "propositions of principia mathematica", "X0eez7H0vdg-00281-00072794-00073229": "and related systems I the hypotheses of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00282-00073230-00073418": "the theorem were improved shortly", "X0eez7H0vdg-00283-00073419-00073751": "thereafter by J Barclay Rosser 1936", "X0eez7H0vdg-00284-00073752-00074033": "using rosser's trick the resulting", "X0eez7H0vdg-00285-00074034-00074207": "theorem incorporating rosser's", "X0eez7H0vdg-00286-00074208-00074405": "improvement may be paraphrased in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00287-00074406-00074689": "English as follows where formal system", "X0eez7H0vdg-00288-00074690-00074918": "includes the assumption that the system", "X0eez7H0vdg-00289-00074919-00075212": "is effectively generated first", "X0eez7H0vdg-00290-00075213-00075470": "incompleteness theorem any consistent", "X0eez7H0vdg-00291-00075471-00075710": "formal system F within which a certain", "X0eez7H0vdg-00292-00075711-00075962": "amount of elementary arithmetic can be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00293-00075963-00076241": "carried out as incomplete ie there are", "X0eez7H0vdg-00294-00076242-00076457": "statements of the language of F which", "X0eez7H0vdg-00295-00076458-00076819": "can neither be proved nor disproved in F", "X0eez7H0vdg-00296-00076820-00077210": "raadhika in 2015 the unprovable", "X0eez7H0vdg-00297-00077211-00077438": "statement GF referred to by the theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00298-00077439-00077681": "is often referred to as the godel", "X0eez7H0vdg-00299-00077682-00077948": "sentence for the system F the proof", "X0eez7H0vdg-00300-00077949-00078167": "constructs a particular gödel sentence", "X0eez7H0vdg-00301-00078168-00078332": "for the system F but there are", "X0eez7H0vdg-00302-00078333-00078503": "infinitely many statements in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00303-00078504-00078674": "language of the system that share the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00304-00078675-00078890": "same properties such as the conjunction", "X0eez7H0vdg-00305-00078891-00079091": "of the godel sentence and any logically", "X0eez7H0vdg-00306-00079092-00079388": "valid sentence each effectively", "X0eez7H0vdg-00307-00079389-00079604": "generated system has its own gödel", "X0eez7H0vdg-00308-00079605-00079835": "sentence it is possible to define a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00309-00079836-00080075": "larger system f that contains the whole", "X0eez7H0vdg-00310-00080076-00080330": "of F plus G F as an additional axiom", "X0eez7H0vdg-00311-00080331-00080576": "this will not result in a complete", "X0eez7H0vdg-00312-00080577-00080822": "system because gödel's theorem will also", "X0eez7H0vdg-00313-00080823-00081074": "apply to F and the Ceph also cannot be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00314-00081075-00081398": "complete in this case G F is indeed a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00315-00081399-00081637": "theorem in F because it is an axiom", "X0eez7H0vdg-00316-00081638-00081920": "because G F states only that it is not", "X0eez7H0vdg-00317-00081921-00082151": "provable in F no contradiction is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00318-00082152-00082343": "presented by its proved ability with an", "X0eez7H0vdg-00319-00082344-00082625": "F however because the incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-00320-00082626-00082859": "theorem applies to F there will be a new", "X0eez7H0vdg-00321-00082860-00083153": "gödel statement GF for F showing that F", "X0eez7H0vdg-00322-00083154-00083480": "is also incomplete GF will differ from", "X0eez7H0vdg-00323-00083481-00083777": "gf in that G F will refer to F rather", "X0eez7H0vdg-00324-00083778-00084325": "than F", "X0eez7H0vdg-00325-00084326-00084628": "topic syntactic form of the godel", "X0eez7H0vdg-00326-00084629-00085010": "sentence", "X0eez7H0vdg-00327-00085011-00085268": "the godel sentence is designed to refer", "X0eez7H0vdg-00328-00085269-00085595": "indirectly to itself the sentence states", "X0eez7H0vdg-00329-00085596-00085808": "that when a particular sequence of steps", "X0eez7H0vdg-00330-00085809-00086009": "is used to construct another sentence", "X0eez7H0vdg-00331-00086010-00086201": "that constructed sentence will not be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00332-00086202-00086429": "provable in F however the sequence of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00333-00086430-00086609": "steps is such that the constructed", "X0eez7H0vdg-00334-00086610-00086921": "sentence turns out to be GF itself in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00335-00086922-00087140": "this way the godel sentence GF", "X0eez7H0vdg-00336-00087141-00087356": "indirectly states its own unprovable ax", "X0eez7H0vdg-00337-00087357-00087956": "T within F Smith 2007 P 135 to prove the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00338-00087957-00088154": "first incompleteness theorem gödel", "X0eez7H0vdg-00339-00088155-00088340": "demonstrated that the notion of proved", "X0eez7H0vdg-00340-00088341-00088511": "ability within a system could be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00341-00088512-00088709": "expressed purely in terms of arithmetic", "X0eez7H0vdg-00342-00088710-00088967": "elections that operate on gödel numbers", "X0eez7H0vdg-00343-00088968-00089273": "of sentences of the system therefore the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00344-00089274-00089486": "system which can prove certain facts", "X0eez7H0vdg-00345-00089487-00089711": "about numbers can also indirectly prove", "X0eez7H0vdg-00346-00089712-00089942": "facts about its own statements provided", "X0eez7H0vdg-00347-00089943-00090115": "that it is effectively generated", "X0eez7H0vdg-00348-00090116-00090374": "questions about the proved ability of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00349-00090375-00090533": "statements within the system are", "X0eez7H0vdg-00350-00090534-00090722": "represented as questions about the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00351-00090723-00090905": "arithmetic improper T's of numbers", "X0eez7H0vdg-00352-00090906-00091106": "themselves which would be decidable by", "X0eez7H0vdg-00353-00091107-00091400": "the system if it were complete thus", "X0eez7H0vdg-00354-00091401-00091583": "although the godel sentence refers", "X0eez7H0vdg-00355-00091584-00091820": "indirectly to sentences of the system f", "X0eez7H0vdg-00356-00091821-00092036": "when read is an arithmetic 'el statement", "X0eez7H0vdg-00357-00092037-00092252": "the godel sentence directly refers only", "X0eez7H0vdg-00358-00092253-00092555": "to natural numbers it asserts that no", "X0eez7H0vdg-00359-00092556-00092765": "natural number has a particular property", "X0eez7H0vdg-00360-00092766-00092978": "where that property is given by a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00361-00092979-00093311": "primitive recursive relation Smith 2007", "X0eez7H0vdg-00362-00093312-00093752": "P 141 as such the godel sentence can be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00363-00093753-00093929": "written in the language of arithmetic", "X0eez7H0vdg-00364-00093930-00094178": "with a simple syntactic form in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00365-00094179-00094388": "particular it can be expressed as a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00366-00094389-00094595": "formula in the language of arithmetic", "X0eez7H0vdg-00367-00094596-00094757": "consisting of a number of leading", "X0eez7H0vdg-00368-00094758-00094979": "Universal quantifiers followed by a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00369-00094980-00095234": "quantifier free-body these formulas are", "X0eez7H0vdg-00370-00095235-00095939": "at level pi 1 0 display style PI", "X0eez7H0vdg-00371-00095940-00096242": "underscore 1 carrot 0", "X0eez7H0vdg-00372-00096243-00096548": "of the earth medical hierarchy via the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00373-00096549-00096809": "mr DP theorem the godel sentence can be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00374-00096810-00096982": "re-written as a statement that a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00375-00096983-00097235": "particular polynomial in many variables", "X0eez7H0vdg-00376-00097236-00097445": "with integer coefficients never takes", "X0eez7H0vdg-00377-00097446-00097649": "the value 0 when integers are", "X0eez7H0vdg-00378-00097650-00097832": "substituted for its variables", "X0eez7H0vdg-00379-00097833-00098627": "francy in 2005 P 71", "X0eez7H0vdg-00380-00098628-00099236": "topic truth of the godel sentence", "X0eez7H0vdg-00381-00099237-00099473": "the first incompleteness theorem shows", "X0eez7H0vdg-00382-00099474-00099679": "that the godel sentence gf of an", "X0eez7H0vdg-00383-00099680-00099874": "appropriate formal theory F is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00384-00099875-00100121": "unprovable in F because when interpreted", "X0eez7H0vdg-00385-00100122-00100312": "as a statement about arithmetic this", "X0eez7H0vdg-00386-00100313-00100529": "unprovable ax T is exactly what the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00387-00100530-00100750": "sentence indirectly asserts the godel", "X0eez7H0vdg-00388-00100751-00101026": "sentence as in fact true more in ski one", "X0eez7H0vdg-00389-00101027-00101447": "nine seven seven P 825 also see Francie", "X0eez7H0vdg-00390-00101448-00101962": "in 2005 PP 28 to 33 for this reason the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00391-00101963-00102274": "sentence GF is often said to be true but", "X0eez7H0vdg-00392-00102275-00102613": "unprovable rowdy kine in 2015 however", "X0eez7H0vdg-00393-00102614-00102865": "since the godel sentence cannot itself", "X0eez7H0vdg-00394-00102866-00103060": "formally specify its intended", "X0eez7H0vdg-00395-00103061-00103282": "interpretation the truth of the sentence", "X0eez7H0vdg-00396-00103283-00103496": "gf may only be arrived at via a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00397-00103497-00103807": "meta-analysis from outside the system in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00398-00103808-00104032": "general this meta-analysis can be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00399-00104033-00104198": "carried out within the week formal", "X0eez7H0vdg-00400-00104199-00104375": "system known as primitive recursive", "X0eez7H0vdg-00401-00104376-00104614": "arithmetic which proves the implication", "X0eez7H0vdg-00402-00104615-00104948": "con f GF where con F is a canonical", "X0eez7H0vdg-00403-00104949-00105188": "sentence asserting the consistency of F", "X0eez7H0vdg-00404-00105189-00105572": "smore in ski one nine seven seven P 840", "X0eez7H0vdg-00405-00105573-00105891": "Kikuchi and Tanaka one nine nine four P", "X0eez7H0vdg-00406-00105892-00106035": "403", "X0eez7H0vdg-00407-00106036-00106252": "although the godel sentence of a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00408-00106253-00106459": "consistent theory is true as a statement", "X0eez7H0vdg-00409-00106460-00106663": "about the intended interpretation of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00410-00106664-00106858": "arithmetic the godel sentence will be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00411-00106859-00107075": "false in some non-standard models of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00412-00107076-00107290": "arithmetic as a consequence of gödel's", "X0eez7H0vdg-00413-00107291-00107410": "completeness theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00414-00107411-00107941": "francy in 2005 P 135 that theorem shows", "X0eez7H0vdg-00415-00107942-00108149": "that when a sentence is independent of a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00416-00108150-00108361": "theory the theory will have models in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00417-00108363-00108586": "which the sentence is true and models in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00418-00108588-00108877": "which the sentence is false as described", "X0eez7H0vdg-00419-00108878-00109126": "earlier the godel sentence of a system f", "X0eez7H0vdg-00420-00109127-00109315": "as an arithmetic 'el statement which", "X0eez7H0vdg-00421-00109316-00109513": "claims that no number exists with a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00422-00109514-00109781": "particular property the incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-00423-00109782-00109990": "theorem shows that this claim will be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00424-00109991-00110179": "independent of the system F and the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00425-00110180-00110389": "truth of the godel sentence follows from", "X0eez7H0vdg-00426-00110390-00110611": "the fact that no standard natural number", "X0eez7H0vdg-00427-00110613-00110911": "has the property in question any model", "X0eez7H0vdg-00428-00110913-00111098": "in which the godel sentence is false", "X0eez7H0vdg-00429-00111099-00111286": "must contain some element which", "X0eez7H0vdg-00430-00111288-00111523": "satisfies the property within that model", "X0eez7H0vdg-00431-00111524-00111926": "such a model must be non-standard it", "X0eez7H0vdg-00432-00111927-00112102": "must contain elements that do not", "X0eez7H0vdg-00433-00112103-00112309": "correspond to any standard natural", "X0eez7H0vdg-00434-00112310-00112576": "number raadhika in 2015 from", "X0eez7H0vdg-00435-00112577-00113371": "see in 2005 P 135", "X0eez7H0vdg-00436-00113372-00114057": "topic relationship with the liar paradox", "X0eez7H0vdg-00437-00114058-00114300": "gödel specifically cites Richards", "X0eez7H0vdg-00438-00114301-00114516": "paradox and the liar paradox as", "X0eez7H0vdg-00439-00114517-00114744": "semantical analogues to his syntactical", "X0eez7H0vdg-00440-00114745-00114897": "and completeness result in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00441-00114898-00115133": "introductory section of informally", "X0eez7H0vdg-00442-00115134-00115401": "undecidable propositions in principia", "X0eez7H0vdg-00443-00115402-00115770": "mathematica and related systems I the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00444-00115771-00116009": "liar paradox is the sentence this", "X0eez7H0vdg-00445-00116010-00116304": "sentence is false an analysis of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00446-00116305-00116517": "liar sentence shows that it cannot be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00447-00116518-00116772": "true for then as it asserts it is false", "X0eez7H0vdg-00448-00116773-00117051": "nor can it be false for then it is true", "X0eez7H0vdg-00449-00117052-00117393": "a godel sentence G for a system F makes", "X0eez7H0vdg-00450-00117394-00117615": "a similar assertion to the liar sentence", "X0eez7H0vdg-00451-00117616-00117809": "but with truth replaced by proved", "X0eez7H0vdg-00452-00117810-00118149": "ability G says G is not provable in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00453-00118150-00118470": "system F the analysis of the truth and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00454-00118471-00118677": "proved ability of G as a formalized", "X0eez7H0vdg-00455-00118678-00118899": "version of the analysis of the truth of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00456-00118900-00119210": "the liar sentence it is not possible to", "X0eez7H0vdg-00457-00119211-00119655": "replace not provable with false in a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00458-00119656-00119913": "godel sentence because the predicate hue", "X0eez7H0vdg-00459-00119914-00120167": "as the godel number of a false formula", "X0eez7H0vdg-00460-00120168-00120447": "cannot be represented as a formula of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00461-00120448-00120705": "arithmetic this result known as thar", "X0eez7H0vdg-00462-00120706-00120908": "skis undefinable 'ti theorem was", "X0eez7H0vdg-00463-00120909-00121128": "discovered independently both by gödel", "X0eez7H0vdg-00464-00121129-00121314": "when he was working on the proof of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00465-00121315-00121476": "incompleteness theorem and by the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00466-00121477-00122173": "theorems namesake alfred tarski", "X0eez7H0vdg-00467-00122174-00122500": "topic extensions of gödel's original", "X0eez7H0vdg-00468-00122501-00122880": "result", "X0eez7H0vdg-00469-00122881-00123108": "compared to the theorem stated in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00470-00123108-00123324": "gödel's 1931 paper", "X0eez7H0vdg-00471-00123325-00123504": "many contemporary statements of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00472-00123505-00123717": "incompleteness theorems are more general", "X0eez7H0vdg-00473-00123718-00124047": "in two ways these generalized statements", "X0eez7H0vdg-00474-00124048-00124239": "are phrased to apply to a broader class", "X0eez7H0vdg-00475-00124240-00124431": "of systems and they are phrased to", "X0eez7H0vdg-00476-00124432-00124605": "incorporate weaker consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-00477-00124606-00124718": "assumptions", "X0eez7H0vdg-00478-00124719-00125001": "gödel demonstrated the incompleteness of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00479-00125002-00125223": "the system of principia mathematica a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00480-00125224-00125445": "particular system of arithmetic but a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00481-00125446-00125646": "parallel demonstration could be given", "X0eez7H0vdg-00482-00125647-00125805": "for any effective system of a certain", "X0eez7H0vdg-00483-00125806-00126123": "expressiveness gödel commented on this", "X0eez7H0vdg-00484-00126124-00126321": "fact in the introduction to his paper", "X0eez7H0vdg-00485-00126322-00126533": "but restricted the proof to one system", "X0eez7H0vdg-00486-00126534-00126846": "for concreteness in modern statements of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00487-00126847-00127038": "the theorem it is common to state the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00488-00127039-00127182": "effectiveness and expressiveness", "X0eez7H0vdg-00489-00127183-00127389": "conditions as hypotheses for the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00490-00127390-00127593": "incompleteness theorem so that it is not", "X0eez7H0vdg-00491-00127594-00127827": "limited to any particular formal system", "X0eez7H0vdg-00492-00127828-00128100": "the terminology used to state these", "X0eez7H0vdg-00493-00128101-00128379": "conditions was not yet developed in 1931", "X0eez7H0vdg-00494-00128380-00128748": "when gödel published his results gödel's", "X0eez7H0vdg-00495-00128749-00128936": "original statement and proof of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00496-00128938-00129138": "incompleteness theorem requires the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00497-00129139-00129335": "assumption that the system is not just", "X0eez7H0vdg-00498-00129336-00129659": "consistent but Omega consistent a system", "X0eez7H0vdg-00499-00129660-00129876": "is Omega consistent if it is not Omega", "X0eez7H0vdg-00500-00129877-00130122": "inconsistent and is Omega inconsistent", "X0eez7H0vdg-00501-00130123-00130329": "if there is a predicate P such that for", "X0eez7H0vdg-00502-00130330-00130551": "every specific natural number M the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00503-00130552-00130815": "system proves tilde p.m. and yet the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00504-00130816-00131028": "system also proves that there exists a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00505-00131029-00131370": "natural number and such that P n that as", "X0eez7H0vdg-00506-00131371-00131550": "the system says that a number with", "X0eez7H0vdg-00507-00131551-00131799": "property P exists while denying that it", "X0eez7H0vdg-00508-00131800-00132066": "has any specific value the Omega", "X0eez7H0vdg-00509-00132067-00132294": "consistency of a system implies its", "X0eez7H0vdg-00510-00132295-00132522": "consistency but consistency does not", "X0eez7H0vdg-00511-00132523-00132926": "imply Omega consistency J Barkley Rosser", "X0eez7H0vdg-00512-00132927-00133173": "1936 strengthened the incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-00513-00133174-00133404": "theorem by finding a variation of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00514-00133405-00133635": "proof rosser's trick that only requires", "X0eez7H0vdg-00515-00133636-00133851": "the system to be consistent rather than", "X0eez7H0vdg-00516-00133852-00134133": "Omega consistent this is mostly of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00517-00134134-00134328": "technical interest because all true", "X0eez7H0vdg-00518-00134329-00134550": "formal theories of arithmetic theories", "X0eez7H0vdg-00519-00134551-00134730": "whose axioms are all true statements", "X0eez7H0vdg-00520-00134731-00134937": "about natural numbers are Omega", "X0eez7H0vdg-00521-00134938-00135165": "consistent and thus gödel's theorem as", "X0eez7H0vdg-00522-00135166-00135426": "originally stated applies to them the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00523-00135427-00135597": "stronger version of the incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-00524-00135598-00135840": "theorem that only assumes consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-00525-00135841-00136074": "rather than Omega consistency is now", "X0eez7H0vdg-00526-00136075-00136213": "commonly known as", "X0eez7H0vdg-00527-00136214-00136393": "dells incompleteness theorem and as the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00528-00136394-00137009": "godel Rosser theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00529-00137010-00137726": "topic ii incompleteness theorem for each", "X0eez7H0vdg-00530-00137727-00137951": "formal system F containing basic", "X0eez7H0vdg-00531-00137952-00138185": "arithmetic it is possible to canonically", "X0eez7H0vdg-00532-00138186-00138449": "define a formula cons F expressing the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00533-00138450-00138707": "consistency of F this formula expresses", "X0eez7H0vdg-00534-00138708-00138953": "the property that there does not exist a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00535-00138954-00139151": "natural number coding a formal", "X0eez7H0vdg-00536-00139152-00139385": "derivation within the system F whose", "X0eez7H0vdg-00537-00139386-00139681": "conclusion as a syntactic contradiction", "X0eez7H0vdg-00538-00139682-00139970": "the syntactic contradiction is often", "X0eez7H0vdg-00539-00139971-00140309": "taken to be 0 equals 1 in which case", "X0eez7H0vdg-00540-00140310-00140675": "cons F States there is no natural number", "X0eez7H0vdg-00541-00140676-00140963": "that codes a derivation of 0 equals 1", "X0eez7H0vdg-00542-00140964-00141303": "from the axioms of F", "X0eez7H0vdg-00543-00141304-00141549": "gödel second incompleteness theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00544-00141550-00141753": "shows that under general assumptions", "X0eez7H0vdg-00545-00141754-00141978": "this canonical consistency statement", "X0eez7H0vdg-00546-00141979-00142246": "cons F will not be provable in F the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00547-00142247-00142578": "theorem first appeared as theorem 11 in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00548-00142579-00142902": "gödel's 1931 paper unform alee", "X0eez7H0vdg-00549-00142903-00143170": "undecidable propositions in Principia", "X0eez7H0vdg-00550-00143171-00143557": "Mathematica and related systems I in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00551-00143558-00143814": "following statement the term formalized", "X0eez7H0vdg-00552-00143815-00144106": "system also includes an assumption that", "X0eez7H0vdg-00553-00144107-00144481": "F is effectively axiom Atty z'd second", "X0eez7H0vdg-00554-00144482-00144694": "incompleteness theorem assume F as a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00555-00144695-00144900": "consistent formalized system which", "X0eez7H0vdg-00556-00144901-00145371": "contains elementary arithmetic then F", "X0eez7H0vdg-00557-00145372-00145584": "cons", "X0eez7H0vdg-00558-00145585-00146128": "F display style F not V - text cons F", "X0eez7H0vdg-00559-00146129-00146556": "write ich einen 2015 this theorem is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00560-00146557-00146727": "stronger than the first incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-00561-00146728-00146891": "theorem because the statement", "X0eez7H0vdg-00562-00146892-00147069": "constructed in the first incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-00563-00147070-00147288": "theorem does not directly Express the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00564-00147289-00147570": "consistency of the system the proof of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00565-00147571-00147750": "the second incompleteness theorem is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00566-00147751-00147969": "obtained by formalizing the proof of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00567-00147970-00148161": "first incompleteness theorem within the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00568-00148162-00148751": "system F itself", "X0eez7H0vdg-00569-00148752-00149157": "topic expressing consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-00570-00149158-00149340": "you", "X0eez7H0vdg-00571-00149341-00149568": "there is a technical subtlety in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00572-00149569-00149706": "second and completeness theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00573-00149707-00149898": "regarding the method of expressing the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00574-00149899-00150132": "consistency of f as a formula in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00575-00150133-00150336": "language of F there are many ways to", "X0eez7H0vdg-00576-00150337-00150558": "express the consistency of a system and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00577-00150559-00150786": "not all of them lead to the same result", "X0eez7H0vdg-00578-00150787-00151074": "the formula cons F from the second", "X0eez7H0vdg-00579-00151075-00151275": "incompleteness theorem as a particular", "X0eez7H0vdg-00580-00151276-00151553": "expression of consistency other", "X0eez7H0vdg-00581-00151554-00151785": "formalizations of the claim that F is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00582-00151786-00152016": "consistent may be an equivalent in F and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00583-00152017-00152313": "some may even be provable for example", "X0eez7H0vdg-00584-00152314-00152580": "first-order peano arithmetic PA can", "X0eez7H0vdg-00585-00152581-00152871": "prove that the largest consistent subset", "X0eez7H0vdg-00586-00152872-00153246": "of PA is consistent but because PA is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00587-00153247-00153498": "consistent the largest consistent subset", "X0eez7H0vdg-00588-00153499-00153786": "of PA is just P a so in this sense PA", "X0eez7H0vdg-00589-00153787-00154158": "proves that it is consistent what PA", "X0eez7H0vdg-00590-00154159-00154359": "does not prove is that the largest", "X0eez7H0vdg-00591-00154360-00154659": "consistent subset of PA is in fact the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00592-00154660-00154977": "whole of PA the term largest consistent", "X0eez7H0vdg-00593-00154978-00155274": "subset of PA is meant here to be the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00594-00155275-00155484": "largest consistent initial segment of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00595-00155485-00155679": "the axioms of PA under some particular", "X0eez7H0vdg-00596-00155680-00156331": "effective enumeration", "X0eez7H0vdg-00597-00156332-00156786": "topic the hilbert béarnaise conditions", "X0eez7H0vdg-00598-00156787-00156948": "you", "X0eez7H0vdg-00599-00156949-00157151": "the standard proof of the second", "X0eez7H0vdg-00600-00157152-00157352": "incompleteness theorem assumes that the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00601-00157353-00157551": "proved ability predicate prova P", "X0eez7H0vdg-00602-00157552-00157773": "satisfies the Hilbert Bernays prove", "X0eez7H0vdg-00603-00157774-00158070": "ability conditions letting hash P", "X0eez7H0vdg-00604-00158071-00158291": "represent the godel number of a formula", "X0eez7H0vdg-00605-00158292-00158676": "P the drivability conditions say if F", "X0eez7H0vdg-00606-00158677-00159089": "proves P then F proves prova hash P F", "X0eez7H0vdg-00607-00159090-00159377": "proves one that as F proves that if F", "X0eez7H0vdg-00608-00159378-00159764": "proves P then F proves prova hash P in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00609-00159765-00160064": "other words F proves that prova hash P", "X0eez7H0vdg-00610-00160065-00160533": "implies prova hash prova hash P F proves", "X0eez7H0vdg-00611-00160534-00160841": "that if F proves that P Q and F proves P", "X0eez7H0vdg-00612-00160842-00161138": "then F proves Q in other words F proves", "X0eez7H0vdg-00613-00161139-00161465": "that prova hash PQ and prova hash P", "X0eez7H0vdg-00614-00161466-00161751": "imply prova hash queue there are systems", "X0eez7H0vdg-00615-00161752-00161982": "such as robinson arithmetic which are", "X0eez7H0vdg-00616-00161983-00162168": "strong enough to meet the assumptions of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00617-00162169-00162353": "the first incompleteness theorem but", "X0eez7H0vdg-00618-00162354-00162570": "which do not prove the hilbert Bernays", "X0eez7H0vdg-00619-00162571-00162912": "conditions peano arithmetic however is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00620-00162913-00163143": "strong enough to verify these conditions", "X0eez7H0vdg-00621-00163144-00163364": "as are all theories stronger than peano", "X0eez7H0vdg-00622-00163365-00163914": "arithmetic", "X0eez7H0vdg-00623-00163915-00164235": "topic implications for consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-00624-00164236-00164591": "proofs", "X0eez7H0vdg-00625-00164592-00164868": "gödel second incompleteness theorem also", "X0eez7H0vdg-00626-00164869-00165168": "implies that a system f1 satisfying the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00627-00165169-00165341": "technical conditions outlined above", "X0eez7H0vdg-00628-00165342-00165563": "cannot prove the consistency of any", "X0eez7H0vdg-00629-00165564-00165831": "system f2 that proves the consistency of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00630-00165832-00166199": "f1 this is because such a system f1 can", "X0eez7H0vdg-00631-00166200-00166454": "prove that if f2 proves the consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-00632-00166455-00166850": "of f1 then f1 is in fact consistent for", "X0eez7H0vdg-00633-00166851-00167106": "the claim that f1 is consistent has form", "X0eez7H0vdg-00634-00167107-00167423": "for all numbers n n has the decidable", "X0eez7H0vdg-00635-00167424-00167666": "property of not being a code for a proof", "X0eez7H0vdg-00636-00167667-00168098": "of contradiction in f1 if f1 were in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00637-00168099-00168353": "fact inconsistent then f2 would prove", "X0eez7H0vdg-00638-00168354-00168548": "for some n that n is the code of a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00639-00168549-00168897": "contradiction in f1 but if f2 also", "X0eez7H0vdg-00640-00168898-00169134": "proved that f1 is consistent that is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00641-00169135-00169332": "that there is no such n then it would", "X0eez7H0vdg-00642-00169333-00169623": "itself be inconsistent this reasoning", "X0eez7H0vdg-00643-00169624-00169877": "can be formalized in f1 to show that if", "X0eez7H0vdg-00644-00169878-00170179": "f2 is consistent then f1 is consistent", "X0eez7H0vdg-00645-00170180-00170460": "since by second incompleteness theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00646-00170461-00170714": "f1 does not prove its consistency it", "X0eez7H0vdg-00647-00170715-00170939": "cannot prove the consistency of f2", "X0eez7H0vdg-00648-00170940-00171243": "either this corollary of the second", "X0eez7H0vdg-00649-00171244-00171447": "incompleteness theorem shows that there", "X0eez7H0vdg-00650-00171448-00171674": "is no hope of proving for example the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00651-00171675-00171918": "consistency of peano arithmetic using", "X0eez7H0vdg-00652-00171919-00172110": "any finite istic means that can be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00653-00172111-00172347": "formalized in a system the consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-00654-00172348-00172514": "of which is provable in peano arithmetic", "X0eez7H0vdg-00655-00172515-00172920": "PA for example the system of primitive", "X0eez7H0vdg-00656-00172921-00173204": "recursive arithmetic pra which is widely", "X0eez7H0vdg-00657-00173205-00173445": "accepted as an accurate formalization of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00658-00173446-00173675": "finite istic mathematics is provably", "X0eez7H0vdg-00659-00173676-00174023": "consistent in PA the speed are a cannot", "X0eez7H0vdg-00660-00174024-00174329": "prove the consistency of PA this fact is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00661-00174330-00174531": "generally seen to imply that Hilbert's", "X0eez7H0vdg-00662-00174532-00174760": "program which aim to justify the use of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00663-00174761-00175098": "ideal infinite istic mathematical", "X0eez7H0vdg-00664-00175099-00175407": "principles in the proofs of real finite", "X0eez7H0vdg-00665-00175408-00175652": "istic mathematical statements by giving", "X0eez7H0vdg-00666-00175653-00175850": "a finite Cystic proof that the ideal", "X0eez7H0vdg-00667-00175851-00176063": "principles are consistent cannot be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00668-00176064-00176571": "carried out from C in 2005 P 106 the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00669-00176572-00176757": "corollary also indicates the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00670-00176758-00176973": "epistemological relevance of the second", "X0eez7H0vdg-00671-00176974-00177203": "incompleteness theorem it would actually", "X0eez7H0vdg-00672-00177204-00177461": "provide no interesting information if a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00673-00177462-00177783": "system F proved its consistency this is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00674-00177784-00177963": "because inconsistent theories", "X0eez7H0vdg-00675-00177964-00178101": "of everything including their", "X0eez7H0vdg-00676-00178102-00178386": "consistency thus a consistency proof of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00677-00178387-00178626": "fnf would give us no clue as to whether", "X0eez7H0vdg-00678-00178627-00178848": "F really is consistent no doubts about", "X0eez7H0vdg-00679-00178849-00179082": "the consistency of F would be resolved", "X0eez7H0vdg-00680-00179083-00179388": "by such a consistency proof the interest", "X0eez7H0vdg-00681-00179389-00179601": "in consistency proofs lies in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00682-00179602-00179817": "possibility of proving the consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-00683-00179818-00180057": "of a system F in some system F that is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00684-00180058-00180264": "in some sense less doubtful than F", "X0eez7H0vdg-00685-00180265-00180591": "itself for example weaker than F for", "X0eez7H0vdg-00686-00180592-00180816": "many naturally occurring theories F and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00687-00180817-00181342": "F such as F", "X0eez7H0vdg-00688-00181343-00182089": "topic Zermelo Fraenkel set theory and f", "X0eez7H0vdg-00689-00182090-00182326": "primitive recursive arithmetic the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00690-00182327-00182584": "consistency of F is provable in F and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00691-00182585-00182839": "thus F cannot prove the consistency of F", "X0eez7H0vdg-00692-00182840-00183040": "by the above corollary of the second", "X0eez7H0vdg-00693-00183041-00183310": "incompleteness theorem the second", "X0eez7H0vdg-00694-00183311-00183502": "incompleteness theorem does not rule out", "X0eez7H0vdg-00695-00183503-00183736": "consistency proofs altogether only", "X0eez7H0vdg-00696-00183737-00183907": "consistency proofs that can be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00697-00183908-00184114": "formalized in the system that is proved", "X0eez7H0vdg-00698-00184115-00184456": "consistent for example Gerhard Jensen", "X0eez7H0vdg-00699-00184457-00184636": "proved the consistency of peano", "X0eez7H0vdg-00700-00184637-00184819": "arithmetic in a different system that", "X0eez7H0vdg-00701-00184820-00185029": "includes an axiom asserting that the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00702-00185030-00185218": "ordinal called epsilon zero is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00703-00185219-00185458": "well-founded C Jensen's consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-00704-00185459-00185725": "proof Jensen's Theorem spurred the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00705-00185726-00185962": "development of ordinal analysis in proof", "X0eez7H0vdg-00706-00185963-00186477": "theory", "X0eez7H0vdg-00707-00186478-00187171": "topic examples of undecidable statements", "X0eez7H0vdg-00708-00187172-00187389": "there are two distinct senses of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00709-00187390-00187725": "word undecidable in mathematics and", "X0eez7H0vdg-00710-00187726-00187981": "computer science the first of these as", "X0eez7H0vdg-00711-00187982-00188175": "the proof theoretic sense used in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00712-00188176-00188403": "relation to gödel's theorems that of a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00713-00188404-00188611": "statement being neither provable nor", "X0eez7H0vdg-00714-00188612-00188818": "refutable in a specified deductive", "X0eez7H0vdg-00715-00188819-00189094": "system the second sense which will not", "X0eez7H0vdg-00716-00189095-00189327": "be discussed here is used in relation to", "X0eez7H0vdg-00717-00189328-00189571": "computability theory and applies not to", "X0eez7H0vdg-00718-00189572-00189760": "statements but to decision problems", "X0eez7H0vdg-00719-00189761-00189951": "which are countably infinite sets of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00720-00189952-00190164": "questions each requiring a yes-or-no", "X0eez7H0vdg-00721-00190165-00190464": "answer such a problem is said to be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00722-00190465-00190684": "undecidable if there is no computable", "X0eez7H0vdg-00723-00190685-00190894": "function that correctly answers every", "X0eez7H0vdg-00724-00190895-00191079": "question in the problem set see", "X0eez7H0vdg-00725-00191080-00191391": "undecidable problem because of the two", "X0eez7H0vdg-00726-00191392-00191596": "meanings of the word undecidable the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00727-00191597-00191787": "term independent is sometimes used", "X0eez7H0vdg-00728-00191788-00192019": "instead of undecidable for the neither", "X0eez7H0vdg-00729-00192020-00192399": "provable nor refutable sense", "X0eez7H0vdg-00730-00192400-00192636": "undecidability of a statement in a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00731-00192637-00192868": "particular deductive system does not in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00732-00192869-00193081": "and of itself address the question of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00733-00193082-00193227": "whether the truth value of the statement", "X0eez7H0vdg-00734-00193228-00193479": "is well defined or whether it can be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00735-00193480-00193776": "determined by other means undecidability", "X0eez7H0vdg-00736-00193777-00193986": "only implies that the particular", "X0eez7H0vdg-00737-00193987-00194206": "deductive system being considered does", "X0eez7H0vdg-00738-00194207-00194391": "not prove the truth or falsity of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00739-00194392-00194709": "statement whether there exists so-called", "X0eez7H0vdg-00740-00194710-00195051": "absolutely undecidable statements whose", "X0eez7H0vdg-00741-00195052-00195300": "truth value can never be known or as ill", "X0eez7H0vdg-00742-00195301-00195544": "specified is a controversial point in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00743-00195545-00195828": "the philosophy of mathematics the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00744-00195829-00196050": "combined work of gödel and Paul Cohen", "X0eez7H0vdg-00745-00196051-00196263": "has given two concrete examples of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00746-00196264-00196459": "undecidable statements in the first", "X0eez7H0vdg-00747-00196460-00196641": "sense of the term the continuum", "X0eez7H0vdg-00748-00196642-00196887": "hypothesis can neither be proved nor", "X0eez7H0vdg-00749-00196888-00197119": "refuted in ZFC the standard", "X0eez7H0vdg-00750-00197120-00197352": "axiomatization of set theory and the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00751-00197353-00197569": "axiom of choice can neither be proved", "X0eez7H0vdg-00752-00197570-00197877": "nor refuted in ZF which is all the ZFC", "X0eez7H0vdg-00753-00197878-00198196": "axioms except the axiom of choice these", "X0eez7H0vdg-00754-00198197-00198363": "results do not require the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00755-00198364-00198493": "incompleteness theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00756-00198494-00198777": "gödel proved in 1940 that neither of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00757-00198778-00198963": "these statements could be disproved in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00758-00198964-00199374": "ZF or ZF see set theory in the 1960s", "X0eez7H0vdg-00759-00199375-00199594": "Cohen proved that neither is provable", "X0eez7H0vdg-00760-00199595-00199836": "from ZF and the continuum hypothesis", "X0eez7H0vdg-00761-00199837-00200281": "cannot be proved from ZF see in 1973", "X0eez7H0vdg-00762-00200282-00200569": "siharan shelah showed that the whitehead", "X0eez7H0vdg-00763-00200570-00200806": "in group theory is undecidable in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00764-00200807-00201037": "first sense of the term in standard set", "X0eez7H0vdg-00765-00201038-00201337": "theory gregory chaitin produced", "X0eez7H0vdg-00766-00201338-00201547": "undecidable statements in algorithmic", "X0eez7H0vdg-00767-00201548-00201742": "information theory and proved another", "X0eez7H0vdg-00768-00201743-00201963": "incompleteness theorem in that setting", "X0eez7H0vdg-00769-00201964-00202222": "Chaffins incompleteness theorem states", "X0eez7H0vdg-00770-00202223-00202390": "that for any system that can represent", "X0eez7H0vdg-00771-00202391-00202600": "enough arithmetic there is an upper", "X0eez7H0vdg-00772-00202601-00202852": "bound C such that no specific number can", "X0eez7H0vdg-00773-00202853-00203014": "be proved in that system to have", "X0eez7H0vdg-00774-00203015-00203226": "Kolmogorov complexity greater than C", "X0eez7H0vdg-00775-00203227-00203515": "while gödel's theorem is related to the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00776-00203516-00203623": "liar paradox", "X0eez7H0vdg-00777-00203624-00203836": "chayton's result is related to Barry's", "X0eez7H0vdg-00778-00203837-00204396": "paradox", "X0eez7H0vdg-00779-00204397-00204744": "topic undecidable statements provable in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00780-00204745-00204843": "larger systems", "X0eez7H0vdg-00781-00204844-00205185": "[Music]", "X0eez7H0vdg-00782-00205186-00205394": "these are natural mathematical", "X0eez7H0vdg-00783-00205396-00205623": "equivalence of the godel true but", "X0eez7H0vdg-00784-00205623-00205935": "undecidable sentence they can be proved", "X0eez7H0vdg-00785-00205936-00206157": "in a larger system which is generally", "X0eez7H0vdg-00786-00206158-00206373": "accepted as a valid form of reasoning", "X0eez7H0vdg-00787-00206373-00206559": "but our undecidable in a more limited", "X0eez7H0vdg-00788-00206560-00207036": "system such as peano arithmetic in 1977", "X0eez7H0vdg-00789-00207037-00207248": "Paris and Harrington proved that the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00790-00207250-00207467": "Paris Harrington principle a version of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00791-00207469-00207630": "the infinite Ramsey theorem is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00792-00207631-00207861": "undecidable in first-order peano", "X0eez7H0vdg-00793-00207862-00208053": "arithmetic but can be proved in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00794-00208054-00208206": "stronger system of second-order", "X0eez7H0vdg-00795-00208207-00208539": "arithmetic Kerby and Paris later showed", "X0eez7H0vdg-00796-00208540-00208721": "that good Steen's theorem a statement", "X0eez7H0vdg-00797-00208723-00208938": "about sequences of natural numbers", "X0eez7H0vdg-00798-00208939-00209096": "somewhat simpler than the Paris", "X0eez7H0vdg-00799-00209098-00209342": "Harrington principle is also undecidable", "X0eez7H0vdg-00800-00209344-00209658": "in peano arithmetic kruskal's tree", "X0eez7H0vdg-00801-00209659-00209859": "theorem which has applications in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00802-00209860-00210102": "computer science is also undecidable", "X0eez7H0vdg-00803-00210103-00210323": "from peano arithmetic but provable in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00804-00210325-00210603": "set theory in fact kruskal's tree", "X0eez7H0vdg-00805-00210604-00210798": "theorem or its finite form is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00806-00210798-00211014": "undecidable in a much stronger system", "X0eez7H0vdg-00807-00211015-00211239": "codifying the principles acceptable", "X0eez7H0vdg-00808-00211240-00211455": "based on a philosophy of mathematics", "X0eez7H0vdg-00809-00211456-00211740": "called predicative ISM the related but", "X0eez7H0vdg-00810-00211741-00212037": "more general graph minor theorem 2003", "X0eez7H0vdg-00811-00212038-00212267": "has consequences for computational", "X0eez7H0vdg-00812-00212269-00212883": "complexity theory", "X0eez7H0vdg-00813-00212884-00213329": "topic relationship with computability", "X0eez7H0vdg-00814-00213330-00213531": "you", "X0eez7H0vdg-00815-00213532-00213765": "the incompleteness theorem is closely", "X0eez7H0vdg-00816-00213766-00213963": "related to several results about", "X0eez7H0vdg-00817-00213964-00214250": "undecidable sets in recursion theory", "X0eez7H0vdg-00818-00214251-00214635": "Stephen cold clean 1943 presented a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00819-00214636-00214848": "proof of gödel's incompleteness theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00820-00214848-00215046": "using basic results of computability", "X0eez7H0vdg-00821-00215046-00215367": "theory one such result shows that the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00822-00215367-00215550": "halting problem is undecidable", "X0eez7H0vdg-00823-00215551-00215760": "there is no computer program that can", "X0eez7H0vdg-00824-00215761-00216012": "correctly determine given any program P", "X0eez7H0vdg-00825-00216013-00216279": "as input whether P eventually halts when", "X0eez7H0vdg-00826-00216280-00216588": "run with a particular given input clean", "X0eez7H0vdg-00827-00216589-00216792": "showed that the existence of a complete", "X0eez7H0vdg-00828-00216792-00216984": "effective system of arithmetic with", "X0eez7H0vdg-00829-00216985-00217185": "certain consistency properties would", "X0eez7H0vdg-00830-00217186-00217346": "force the halting problem to be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00831-00217348-00217665": "decidable a contradiction this method of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00832-00217666-00217857": "proof has also been presented by", "X0eez7H0vdg-00833-00217858-00218331": "Schoenfield 1967 P 132 Charley's worth", "X0eez7H0vdg-00834-00218332-00218853": "1980 and hopcroft and ullman 1979 France", "X0eez7H0vdg-00835-00218854-00219288": "e'en 2005 P 73 explains how matthias", "X0eez7H0vdg-00836-00219289-00219473": "savages solution to Hilbert's tenth", "X0eez7H0vdg-00837-00219475-00219705": "problem can be used to obtain a proof to", "X0eez7H0vdg-00838-00219706-00219914": "gödel's first incompleteness theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00839-00219915-00220161": "matthias evich proved that there is no", "X0eez7H0vdg-00840-00220162-00220367": "algorithm that given a multivariate", "X0eez7H0vdg-00841-00220369-00220923": "polynomial P x1 x2 xk with integer", "X0eez7H0vdg-00842-00220923-00221127": "coefficients determines whether there is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00843-00221128-00221758": "an integer solution to the equation P", "X0eez7H0vdg-00844-00221759-00222163": "topic 0 because polynomials with integer", "X0eez7H0vdg-00845-00222164-00222427": "coefficients and integers themselves are", "X0eez7H0vdg-00846-00222428-00222661": "directly expressible in the language of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00847-00222662-00222910": "arithmetic if a multivariate integer", "X0eez7H0vdg-00848-00222911-00223478": "polynomial equation P", "X0eez7H0vdg-00849-00223479-00223721": "zero does have a solution in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00850-00223723-00223919": "integers than any sufficiently strong", "X0eez7H0vdg-00851-00223921-00224216": "system of arithmetic T will prove this", "X0eez7H0vdg-00852-00224217-00224484": "moreover if the system T is Omega", "X0eez7H0vdg-00853-00224485-00224700": "consistent then it will never prove that", "X0eez7H0vdg-00854-00224701-00224925": "a particular polynomial equation has a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00855-00224926-00225126": "solution when in fact there is no", "X0eez7H0vdg-00856-00225127-00225459": "solution in the integers thus if T were", "X0eez7H0vdg-00857-00225460-00225681": "complete and Omega consistent it would", "X0eez7H0vdg-00858-00225682-00225891": "be possible to determine algorithmically", "X0eez7H0vdg-00859-00225892-00226101": "whether a polynomial equation has a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00860-00226102-00226341": "solution by merely enumerate improvs of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00861-00226342-00226803": "T until either P has a solution or P has", "X0eez7H0vdg-00862-00226804-00227121": "no solution is found in contradiction to", "X0eez7H0vdg-00863-00227121-00227406": "Mattia savages theorem moreover for each", "X0eez7H0vdg-00864-00227407-00227642": "consistent effectively generated system", "X0eez7H0vdg-00865-00227644-00227880": "T it is possible to effectively generate", "X0eez7H0vdg-00866-00227881-00228146": "a multivariate polynomial P over the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00867-00228148-00228408": "integers such that the equation P equals", "X0eez7H0vdg-00868-00228409-00228690": "0 has no solutions over the integers but", "X0eez7H0vdg-00869-00228691-00228903": "the lack of solutions cannot be proved", "X0eez7H0vdg-00870-00228904-00229548": "in T Davis 2006 to 416 Jones 1980 smore", "X0eez7H0vdg-00871-00229548-00229986": "in ski 1977 P 842 shows how the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00872-00229987-00230198": "existence of recursively inseparable", "X0eez7H0vdg-00873-00230200-00230379": "sets can be used to prove the first", "X0eez7H0vdg-00874-00230380-00230648": "incompleteness theorem this proof is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00875-00230650-00230873": "often extended to show that systems such", "X0eez7H0vdg-00876-00230875-00231078": "as peano arithmetic are essentially", "X0eez7H0vdg-00877-00231079-00231708": "undecidable see clean 1967 P 274 Jaden's", "X0eez7H0vdg-00878-00231709-00231915": "incompleteness theorem gives a different", "X0eez7H0vdg-00879-00231916-00232077": "method of producing independent", "X0eez7H0vdg-00880-00232078-00232331": "sentences based on Kolmogorov complexity", "X0eez7H0vdg-00881-00232332-00232629": "like the proof presented by clean that", "X0eez7H0vdg-00882-00232630-00232851": "was mentioned above Jaden's theorem only", "X0eez7H0vdg-00883-00232852-00233058": "applies to theories with the additional", "X0eez7H0vdg-00884-00233059-00233280": "property that all their axioms are true", "X0eez7H0vdg-00885-00233281-00233463": "in the standard model of the natural", "X0eez7H0vdg-00886-00233464-00233760": "numbers gödel's incompleteness theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00887-00233761-00233969": "is distinguished by its applicability to", "X0eez7H0vdg-00888-00233971-00234150": "consistent theories that nonetheless", "X0eez7H0vdg-00889-00234151-00234381": "include statements that are false in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00890-00234382-00234588": "standard model these theories are known", "X0eez7H0vdg-00891-00234589-00235234": "as Omega inconsistent", "X0eez7H0vdg-00892-00235235-00235712": "topic proof sketch for the first theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00893-00235713-00235896": "you", "X0eez7H0vdg-00894-00235898-00236152": "the proof by contradiction has three", "X0eez7H0vdg-00895-00236153-00236448": "essential parts to begin choose a formal", "X0eez7H0vdg-00896-00236450-00236751": "system that meets the proposed criteria", "X0eez7H0vdg-00897-00236752-00236946": "statements in the system can be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00898-00236948-00237187": "represented by natural numbers known as", "X0eez7H0vdg-00899-00237188-00237469": "gödel numbers the significance of this", "X0eez7H0vdg-00900-00237469-00237739": "is that properties of statements such as", "X0eez7H0vdg-00901-00237740-00237969": "their truth and falsehood will be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00902-00237971-00238150": "equivalent to determining whether their", "X0eez7H0vdg-00903-00238151-00238344": "gödel numbers have certain properties", "X0eez7H0vdg-00904-00238346-00238533": "and that properties of the statements", "X0eez7H0vdg-00905-00238534-00238710": "can therefore be demonstrated by", "X0eez7H0vdg-00906-00238711-00238998": "examining their gödel numbers this part", "X0eez7H0vdg-00907-00239000-00239179": "culminates in the construction of a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00908-00239180-00239379": "formula expressing the idea that", "X0eez7H0vdg-00909-00239380-00239677": "statement s as provable in the system", "X0eez7H0vdg-00910-00239678-00239976": "which can be applied to any statement s", "X0eez7H0vdg-00911-00239977-00240400": "in the system in the formal system it is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00912-00240401-00240589": "possible to construct a number whose", "X0eez7H0vdg-00913-00240590-00240805": "matching statement when interpreted is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00914-00240806-00241027": "self referential and essentially says", "X0eez7H0vdg-00915-00241028-00241225": "that it is a statement itself is", "X0eez7H0vdg-00916-00241226-00241489": "unprovable this is done using a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00917-00241490-00241825": "technique called diagonalization so", "X0eez7H0vdg-00918-00241826-00241996": "called because of its origins as", "X0eez7H0vdg-00919-00241996-00242317": "Cantor's diagonal argument within the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00920-00242317-00242535": "formal system this statement permits a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00921-00242536-00242680": "demonstration that it is neither", "X0eez7H0vdg-00922-00242681-00242923": "provable nor disprovable in the system", "X0eez7H0vdg-00923-00242923-00243115": "and therefore the system cannot in fact", "X0eez7H0vdg-00924-00243116-00243448": "be Omega consistent hence the original", "X0eez7H0vdg-00925-00243448-00243655": "assumption that the proposed system met", "X0eez7H0vdg-00926-00243656-00244285": "the criteria is false", "X0eez7H0vdg-00927-00244286-00244750": "topic arithmetician of syntax", "X0eez7H0vdg-00928-00244751-00244911": "you", "X0eez7H0vdg-00929-00244912-00245123": "the main problem in fleshing out the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00930-00245125-00245352": "proof described above is that it seems", "X0eez7H0vdg-00931-00245353-00245583": "at first that to construct a statement P", "X0eez7H0vdg-00932-00245584-00245886": "that is equivalent to P cannot be proved", "X0eez7H0vdg-00933-00245887-00246126": "P would somehow have to contain a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00934-00246127-00246351": "reference to P which could easily give", "X0eez7H0vdg-00935-00246352-00246636": "rise to an infinite regress gödel's", "X0eez7H0vdg-00936-00246637-00246819": "ingenious technique is to show that", "X0eez7H0vdg-00937-00246819-00247019": "statements can be matched with numbers", "X0eez7H0vdg-00938-00247021-00247263": "often called the arithmetician of syntax", "X0eez7H0vdg-00939-00247264-00247517": "in such a way that proving a statement", "X0eez7H0vdg-00940-00247517-00247827": "can be replaced with testing whether a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00941-00247828-00248157": "number has a given property this allows", "X0eez7H0vdg-00942-00248158-00248355": "a self-referential formula to be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00943-00248356-00248546": "constructed in a way that avoids any", "X0eez7H0vdg-00944-00248548-00248850": "infinite regress of definitions the same", "X0eez7H0vdg-00945-00248851-00249057": "technique was later used by Alan Turing", "X0eez7H0vdg-00946-00249058-00249311": "in his work on the entscheidungsproblem", "X0eez7H0vdg-00947-00249312-00249642": "in simple terms a method can be devised", "X0eez7H0vdg-00948-00249642-00249867": "so that every formula or statement that", "X0eez7H0vdg-00949-00249867-00250077": "can be formulated in the system gets a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00950-00250078-00250302": "unique number called its godel number in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00951-00250303-00250473": "such a way that it is possible to", "X0eez7H0vdg-00952-00250473-00250656": "mechanically convert back and forth", "X0eez7H0vdg-00953-00250657-00250977": "between formulas and gödel numbers the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00954-00250978-00251175": "numbers involved might be very long", "X0eez7H0vdg-00955-00251176-00251430": "indeed in terms of number of digits but", "X0eez7H0vdg-00956-00251431-00251625": "this is not a barrier all that matters", "X0eez7H0vdg-00957-00251626-00251838": "is that such numbers can be constructed", "X0eez7H0vdg-00958-00251839-00252123": "a simple example as the way in which", "X0eez7H0vdg-00959-00252123-00252312": "English is stored as a sequence of", "X0eez7H0vdg-00960-00252313-00252534": "numbers in computers using ASCII or", "X0eez7H0vdg-00961-00252535-00252896": "Unicode the word hello is represented by", "X0eez7H0vdg-00962-00252898-00253206": "seven two six nine seven six seven six", "X0eez7H0vdg-00963-00253207-00253539": "seven nine using decimal ASCII ie the", "X0eez7H0vdg-00964-00253540-00253884": "number seven billion 269 million seven", "X0eez7H0vdg-00965-00253885-00254112": "hundred sixty seven thousand six hundred", "X0eez7H0vdg-00966-00254113-00254427": "seventy nine the logical statement x", "X0eez7H0vdg-00967-00254428-00254760": "equals y equals greater than y equals x", "X0eez7H0vdg-00968-00254761-00255126": "is represented by 1 200 six one one to", "X0eez7H0vdg-00969-00255127-00255794": "103 206 106 2 o 3 2 1 to 106 1 1 to O", "X0eez7H0vdg-00970-00255796-00256148": "using octal ASCII ie the number 120", "X0eez7H0vdg-00971-00256150-00256517": "octillion 61 septillion 121 six billion", "X0eez7H0vdg-00972-00256519-00256854": "32 quintillion sixty one quadrillion 62", "X0eez7H0vdg-00973-00256855-00257144": "trillion thirty two billion 121 million", "X0eez7H0vdg-00974-00257146-00257469": "sixty one thousand 120 in principle", "X0eez7H0vdg-00975-00257469-00257712": "proving a statement true or false can be", "X0eez7H0vdg-00976-00257713-00257889": "shown to be equivalent to proving that", "X0eez7H0vdg-00977-00257890-00258063": "the number matching the statement does", "X0eez7H0vdg-00978-00258064-00258246": "or doesn't have a given property", "X0eez7H0vdg-00979-00258246-00258471": "because the formal system is strong", "X0eez7H0vdg-00980-00258471-00258639": "enough to support reasoning about", "X0eez7H0vdg-00981-00258640-00258830": "numbers in general it can support", "X0eez7H0vdg-00982-00258831-00259031": "reasoning about numbers that represent", "X0eez7H0vdg-00983-00259032-00259244": "formulae and statements as well", "X0eez7H0vdg-00984-00259244-00259481": "crucially because the system can support", "X0eez7H0vdg-00985-00259482-00259677": "reasoning about properties of numbers", "X0eez7H0vdg-00986-00259678-00259907": "the results are equivalent to reasoning", "X0eez7H0vdg-00987-00259908-00260091": "about proved ability of their equivalent", "X0eez7H0vdg-00988-00260092-00260636": "statements", "X0eez7H0vdg-00989-00260637-00260927": "topic construction of a statement about", "X0eez7H0vdg-00990-00260928-00261602": "prove ability having shown that in", "X0eez7H0vdg-00991-00261603-00261817": "principle the system can indirectly make", "X0eez7H0vdg-00992-00261819-00262013": "statements about prove ability by", "X0eez7H0vdg-00993-00262014-00262220": "analyzing properties of those numbers", "X0eez7H0vdg-00994-00262221-00262391": "representing statements it is now", "X0eez7H0vdg-00995-00262392-00262556": "possible to show how to create a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00996-00262557-00262822": "statement that actually does this a", "X0eez7H0vdg-00997-00262823-00263129": "formula FX that contains exactly one", "X0eez7H0vdg-00998-00263130-00263354": "free variable X is called a statement", "X0eez7H0vdg-00999-00263355-00263684": "form or class sign as soon as X is", "X0eez7H0vdg-01000-00263685-00263894": "replaced by a specific number the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01001-00263895-00264113": "statement form turns into a bonafide a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01002-00264114-00264320": "statement and it is then either provable", "X0eez7H0vdg-01003-00264321-00264599": "in the system or not for certain", "X0eez7H0vdg-01004-00264600-00264797": "formulas one can show that for every", "X0eez7H0vdg-01005-00264798-00265109": "natural number n FN is true if and only", "X0eez7H0vdg-01006-00265110-00265286": "if it can be proved the precise", "X0eez7H0vdg-01007-00265287-00265493": "requirement in the original proof is", "X0eez7H0vdg-01008-00265494-00265691": "weaker but for the proof sketch this", "X0eez7H0vdg-01009-00265692-00266012": "will suffice in particular this is true", "X0eez7H0vdg-01010-00266013-00266252": "for every specific arithmetic operation", "X0eez7H0vdg-01011-00266253-00266453": "between a finite number of natural", "X0eez7H0vdg-01012-00266454-00266941": "numbers such as 2 times 3 equals 6", "X0eez7H0vdg-01013-00266942-00267170": "statement forms themselves are not", "X0eez7H0vdg-01014-00267171-00267365": "statements and therefore cannot be", "X0eez7H0vdg-01015-00267366-00267641": "proved or disproved but every statement", "X0eez7H0vdg-01016-00267642-00267923": "form F X can be assigned a godel number", "X0eez7H0vdg-01017-00267924-00268247": "denoted by G F the choice of the free", "X0eez7H0vdg-01018-00268248-00268526": "variable used in the form F X is not", "X0eez7H0vdg-01019-00268527-00268715": "relevant to the assignment of the godel", "X0eez7H0vdg-01020-00268716-00269069": "number G F the notion of prove ability", "X0eez7H0vdg-01021-00269070-00269303": "itself can also be encoded by gödel", "X0eez7H0vdg-01022-00269304-00269519": "numbers in the following way since a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01023-00269520-00269729": "proof as a list of statements which obey", "X0eez7H0vdg-01024-00269730-00269930": "certain rules the godel number of a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01025-00269931-00270227": "proof can be defined now for every", "X0eez7H0vdg-01026-00270228-00270467": "statement P one may ask whether a number", "X0eez7H0vdg-01027-00270468-00270752": "X as the godel number of its proof the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01028-00270753-00270962": "relation between the godel number of P", "X0eez7H0vdg-01029-00270963-00271190": "and X the potential gödel number of its", "X0eez7H0vdg-01030-00271191-00271778": "proof is an arithmetic elastane form", "X0eez7H0vdg-01031-00271779-00272461": "below Y that uses this arithmetic Elias", "X0eez7H0vdg-01032-00272462-00272897": "BEW y equals x Y as the godel number of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01033-00272898-00273131": "a formula and X as the godel number of a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01034-00273132-00273380": "proof of the formula encoded by why the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01035-00273381-00273671": "name BEW is short for be wise bar the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01036-00273672-00273995": "German word for provable this name was", "X0eez7H0vdg-01037-00273996-00274073": "originally", "X0eez7H0vdg-01038-00274074-00274241": "used by gödel to denote the proved", "X0eez7H0vdg-01039-00274242-00274582": "ability formula just described note that", "X0eez7H0vdg-01040-00274583-00274994": "BEW y is merely an abbreviation that", "X0eez7H0vdg-01041-00274995-00275219": "represents a particular very long", "X0eez7H0vdg-01042-00275220-00275462": "formula in the original language of T", "X0eez7H0vdg-01043-00275463-00275879": "the string BEW itself is not claimed to", "X0eez7H0vdg-01044-00275880-00276173": "be part of this language an important", "X0eez7H0vdg-01045-00276174-00276491": "feature of the formula BEW Y is that if", "X0eez7H0vdg-01046-00276492-00276725": "a statement P is provable in the system", "X0eez7H0vdg-01047-00276726-00277172": "then B ewg P is also provable this is", "X0eez7H0vdg-01048-00277173-00277360": "because any proof of P would have a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01049-00277361-00277607": "corresponding godel number the existence", "X0eez7H0vdg-01050-00277608-00278466": "of which causes B ewg P to be satisfied", "X0eez7H0vdg-01051-00278467-00279032": "topic diagonalization", "X0eez7H0vdg-01052-00279033-00279267": "the next step in the proof as to obtain", "X0eez7H0vdg-01053-00279268-00279527": "a statement which indirectly asserts its", "X0eez7H0vdg-01054-00279528-00279653": "own unprovable ax t", "X0eez7H0vdg-01055-00279654-00279867": "although gödel constructed this", "X0eez7H0vdg-01056-00279868-00280089": "statement directly the existence of at", "X0eez7H0vdg-01057-00280090-00280304": "least one such statement follows from", "X0eez7H0vdg-01058-00280305-00280493": "the diagonal lemma which says that for", "X0eez7H0vdg-01059-00280494-00280730": "any sufficiently strong formal system", "X0eez7H0vdg-01060-00280731-00280934": "and any statement for meth there is a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01061-00280935-00281203": "statement P such that the system proves", "X0eez7H0vdg-01062-00281204-00281627": "P left-right arrow FGP by letting F be", "X0eez7H0vdg-01063-00281628-00281942": "the negation of BEW X we obtain the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01064-00281943-00282443": "theorem P left-right arrow tilde B ewg P", "X0eez7H0vdg-01065-00282444-00282692": "and the P defined by this roughly states", "X0eez7H0vdg-01066-00282693-00282888": "that its own gödel number is the godel", "X0eez7H0vdg-01067-00282889-00283175": "number of an unprovable formula the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01068-00283176-00283409": "statement P is not literally equal to", "X0eez7H0vdg-01069-00283410-00283802": "tilde B ewg P rather P states that if a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01070-00283803-00284021": "certain calculation is performed the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01071-00284022-00284195": "resulting gödel number will be that of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01072-00284196-00284463": "an unprovable statement but when this", "X0eez7H0vdg-01073-00284464-00284712": "calculation is performed the resulting", "X0eez7H0vdg-01074-00284713-00284916": "gödel number turns out to be the godel", "X0eez7H0vdg-01075-00284917-00285218": "number of p itself this is similar to", "X0eez7H0vdg-01076-00285219-00285518": "the following sentence in English when", "X0eez7H0vdg-01077-00285519-00285749": "preceded by itself in quotes is", "X0eez7H0vdg-01078-00285750-00286073": "unprovable when preceded by itself in", "X0eez7H0vdg-01079-00286074-00286322": "quotes is unprovable this sentence does", "X0eez7H0vdg-01080-00286323-00286547": "not directly refer to itself but when", "X0eez7H0vdg-01081-00286548-00286742": "the stated transformation is made the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01082-00286743-00286919": "original sentence is obtained as a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01083-00286920-00287135": "result and thus this sentence indirectly", "X0eez7H0vdg-01084-00287136-00287402": "asserts its own unprovable ax t the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01085-00287403-00287603": "proof of the diagonal lemma employs a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01086-00287604-00287930": "similar method now assume that the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01087-00287931-00288189": "axiomatic system is Omega consistent and", "X0eez7H0vdg-01088-00288190-00288401": "let P be the statement obtained in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01089-00288402-00288765": "previous section if P were provable then", "X0eez7H0vdg-01090-00288766-00289118": "B ewg P would be provable as argued", "X0eez7H0vdg-01091-00289119-00289435": "above but P asserts the negation of B", "X0eez7H0vdg-01092-00289436-00289781": "ewg P thus the system would be", "X0eez7H0vdg-01093-00289782-00289982": "inconsistent proving both a statement", "X0eez7H0vdg-01094-00289983-00290258": "and its negation this contradiction", "X0eez7H0vdg-01095-00290259-00290613": "shows that P cannot be provable if the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01096-00290614-00291008": "negation of P were provable then BEW G P", "X0eez7H0vdg-01097-00291009-00291209": "would be provable because P was", "X0eez7H0vdg-01098-00291210-00291380": "constructed to be equivalent to the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01099-00291381-00291782": "negation of BEW g p however for each", "X0eez7H0vdg-01100-00291783-00292073": "specific number X X cannot be the godel", "X0eez7H0vdg-01101-00292074-00292295": "number of the proof of P because P is", "X0eez7H0vdg-01102-00292296-00292422": "not provable from the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01103-00292423-00292722": "previous paragraph thus on one hand the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01104-00292723-00292910": "system proves there is a number with a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01105-00292911-00293103": "certain property that it is the godel", "X0eez7H0vdg-01106-00293104-00293298": "number of the proof of P but on the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01107-00293299-00293526": "other hand for every specific number X", "X0eez7H0vdg-01108-00293527-00293724": "we can prove that it does not have this", "X0eez7H0vdg-01109-00293725-00294027": "property this is impossible in an Omega", "X0eez7H0vdg-01110-00294028-00294294": "consistent system thus the negation of P", "X0eez7H0vdg-01111-00294295-00294663": "is not provable thus the statement P is", "X0eez7H0vdg-01112-00294664-00294924": "undecidable in our axiomatic system it", "X0eez7H0vdg-01113-00294925-00295134": "can neither be proved nor disproved", "X0eez7H0vdg-01114-00295135-00295484": "within the system in fact to show that p", "X0eez7H0vdg-01115-00295485-00295683": "is not provable only requires the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01116-00295684-00295895": "assumption that the system is consistent", "X0eez7H0vdg-01117-00295896-00296145": "the stronger assumption of Omega", "X0eez7H0vdg-01118-00296146-00296382": "consistency is required to show that the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01119-00296383-00296745": "negation of P is not provable thus if P", "X0eez7H0vdg-01120-00296746-00296943": "is constructed for a particular system", "X0eez7H0vdg-01121-00296944-00297315": "if the system is Omega consistent it can", "X0eez7H0vdg-01122-00297316-00297579": "prove neither P nor its negation and so", "X0eez7H0vdg-01123-00297580-00297894": "P is undecidable if the system is", "X0eez7H0vdg-01124-00297895-00298059": "consistent it may have the same", "X0eez7H0vdg-01125-00298060-00298299": "situation or it may prove the negation", "X0eez7H0vdg-01126-00298300-00298566": "of P in the later case we have a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01127-00298567-00298878": "statement not P which is false but", "X0eez7H0vdg-01128-00298879-00299084": "provable and the system is not Omega", "X0eez7H0vdg-01129-00299085-00299334": "consistent if one tries to add the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01130-00299335-00299571": "missing axioms to avoid the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01131-00299572-00299778": "incompleteness of the system then one", "X0eez7H0vdg-01132-00299779-00300177": "has to add either P or not P as axioms", "X0eez7H0vdg-01133-00300178-00300429": "but then the definition of being a godel", "X0eez7H0vdg-01134-00300430-00300717": "number of a proof of a statement changes", "X0eez7H0vdg-01135-00300718-00301056": "which means that the formula BEW X is", "X0eez7H0vdg-01136-00301057-00301314": "now different thus when we apply the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01137-00301315-00301638": "diagonal lemma to this new BEW we obtain", "X0eez7H0vdg-01138-00301639-00301835": "a new statement P different from the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01139-00301836-00302060": "previous one which will be undecidable", "X0eez7H0vdg-01140-00302061-00302232": "in the new system if it is Omega", "X0eez7H0vdg-01141-00302233-00302786": "consistent", "X0eez7H0vdg-01142-00302787-00303421": "topic proof via berries paradox", "X0eez7H0vdg-01143-00303422-00303754": "george boolos 1989 sketches an", "X0eez7H0vdg-01144-00303755-00303901": "alternative proof of the first", "X0eez7H0vdg-01145-00303902-00304117": "incompleteness theorem that uses Barry's", "X0eez7H0vdg-01146-00304118-00304369": "paradox rather than the liar paradox to", "X0eez7H0vdg-01147-00304370-00304600": "construct a true but unprovable formula", "X0eez7H0vdg-01148-00304601-00304897": "a similar proof method was independently", "X0eez7H0vdg-01149-00304898-00305304": "discovered by saul kripke Boulos 1998 P", "X0eez7H0vdg-01150-00305305-00305659": "383 Boulos is proof proceeds by", "X0eez7H0vdg-01151-00305660-00305833": "constructing for any computable", "X0eez7H0vdg-01152-00305834-00306088": "enumerable set s of true sentences of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01153-00306089-00306271": "arithmetic another sentence which is", "X0eez7H0vdg-01154-00306272-00306523": "true but not contained in s this gives", "X0eez7H0vdg-01155-00306524-00306703": "the first incompleteness theorem as a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01156-00306704-00307027": "corollary according to boulos this proof", "X0eez7H0vdg-01157-00307028-00307225": "is interesting because it provides a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01158-00307226-00307483": "different sort of reason for the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01159-00307484-00307693": "incompleteness of effective consistent", "X0eez7H0vdg-01160-00307694-00308641": "theories of arithmetic Boulos 1998 P 388", "X0eez7H0vdg-01161-00308642-00309100": "topic computer verified proofs", "X0eez7H0vdg-01162-00309101-00309260": "you", "X0eez7H0vdg-01163-00309261-00309494": "the incompleteness theorems are among a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01164-00309495-00309692": "relatively small number of non-trivial", "X0eez7H0vdg-01165-00309693-00309914": "theorems that have been transformed into", "X0eez7H0vdg-01166-00309915-00310100": "formalized theorems that can be", "X0eez7H0vdg-01167-00310101-00310328": "completely verified by proof assistant", "X0eez7H0vdg-01168-00310329-00310628": "software gödel's original proofs of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01169-00310629-00310817": "incompleteness theorems like most", "X0eez7H0vdg-01170-00310818-00311009": "mathematical proofs were written in", "X0eez7H0vdg-01171-00311010-00311192": "natural language intended for human", "X0eez7H0vdg-01172-00311193-00311534": "readers computer verified proofs of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01173-00311535-00311690": "versions of the first incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-01174-00311691-00311906": "theorem were announced by Natarajan", "X0eez7H0vdg-01175-00311907-00312325": "Shanker in 1986 using NQ THM shanker", "X0eez7H0vdg-01176-00312326-00312704": "1994 by Russell O'Connor in 2003 using", "X0eez7H0vdg-01177-00312705-00313052": "Koch O'Connor 2005 and by John Harrison", "X0eez7H0vdg-01178-00313053-00313427": "in 2009 using whole light Harrison 2009", "X0eez7H0vdg-01179-00313428-00313724": "a computer verified proof of both", "X0eez7H0vdg-01180-00313725-00313943": "incompleteness theorems was announced by", "X0eez7H0vdg-01181-00313944-00314228": "laurence paulson in 2013 using Isabel", "X0eez7H0vdg-01182-00314229-00314878": "Paulson 2014", "X0eez7H0vdg-01183-00314879-00315160": "topic proof sketch for the second", "X0eez7H0vdg-01184-00315161-00315545": "theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-01185-00315546-00315767": "the main difficulty in proving the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01186-00315768-00315968": "second incompleteness theorem as to show", "X0eez7H0vdg-01187-00315969-00316183": "that various facts about prove ability", "X0eez7H0vdg-01188-00316184-00316325": "used in the proof of the first", "X0eez7H0vdg-01189-00316326-00316538": "incompleteness theorem can be formalized", "X0eez7H0vdg-01190-00316539-00316735": "within the system using a formal", "X0eez7H0vdg-01191-00316736-00316997": "predicate for proved ability once this", "X0eez7H0vdg-01192-00316998-00317179": "is done the second incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-01193-00317180-00317404": "theorem follows by formalizing the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01194-00317405-00317591": "entire proof of the first incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-01195-00317592-00317942": "theorem within the system itself let P", "X0eez7H0vdg-01196-00317943-00318137": "stand for the undecidable sentence", "X0eez7H0vdg-01197-00318138-00318338": "constructed above and assume that the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01198-00318339-00318548": "consistency of the system can be proved", "X0eez7H0vdg-01199-00318549-00318772": "from within the system itself the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01200-00318773-00318995": "demonstration above shows that if the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01201-00318996-00319223": "system is consistent then P is not", "X0eez7H0vdg-01202-00319224-00319487": "provable the proof of this implication", "X0eez7H0vdg-01203-00319488-00319729": "can be formalized within the system and", "X0eez7H0vdg-01204-00319730-00319957": "therefore the statement P is not", "X0eez7H0vdg-01205-00319958-00320414": "provable or not P P can be proved in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01206-00320415-00320702": "system but this last statement is", "X0eez7H0vdg-01207-00320703-00320888": "equivalent to P itself and this", "X0eez7H0vdg-01208-00320889-00321095": "equivalence can be proved in the system", "X0eez7H0vdg-01209-00321096-00321385": "so P can be proved in the system this", "X0eez7H0vdg-01210-00321386-00321604": "contradiction shows that the system must", "X0eez7H0vdg-01211-00321605-00322178": "be inconsistent", "X0eez7H0vdg-01212-00322179-00322812": "topic discussion and implications", "X0eez7H0vdg-01213-00322813-00323049": "the incompleteness results effect the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01214-00323050-00323268": "philosophy of mathematics particularly", "X0eez7H0vdg-01215-00323269-00323535": "versions of formalism which use a single", "X0eez7H0vdg-01216-00323536-00323751": "system of formal logic to define their", "X0eez7H0vdg-01217-00323752-00324299": "principles", "X0eez7H0vdg-01218-00324300-00324647": "topic consequences for logis ISM and", "X0eez7H0vdg-01219-00324648-00325109": "Hilbert second problem", "X0eez7H0vdg-01220-00325110-00325352": "the incompleteness theorem as sometimes", "X0eez7H0vdg-01221-00325353-00325542": "thought to have severe consequences for", "X0eez7H0vdg-01222-00325543-00325791": "the program of logis ism proposed by", "X0eez7H0vdg-01223-00325792-00326016": "Gottlob Frege and Bertrand Russell which", "X0eez7H0vdg-01224-00326017-00326219": "aim to define the natural numbers in", "X0eez7H0vdg-01225-00326220-00326813": "terms of logic helm in 1981 P 451 to 468", "X0eez7H0vdg-01226-00326814-00327122": "Bob Hale and Crispin Wright argue that", "X0eez7H0vdg-01227-00327123-00327323": "it is not a problem for logis ISM", "X0eez7H0vdg-01228-00327324-00327497": "because the incompleteness theorems", "X0eez7H0vdg-01229-00327498-00327738": "apply equally to first-order logic as", "X0eez7H0vdg-01230-00327739-00328010": "they do to arithmetic they argue that", "X0eez7H0vdg-01231-00328011-00328202": "only those who believe that the natural", "X0eez7H0vdg-01232-00328203-00328394": "numbers are to be defined in terms of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01233-00328395-00328737": "first order logic have this problem many", "X0eez7H0vdg-01234-00328738-00328917": "logicians believe that gödel's", "X0eez7H0vdg-01235-00328918-00329126": "incompleteness theorems struck a fatal", "X0eez7H0vdg-01236-00329127-00329330": "blow to David Hilbert second problem", "X0eez7H0vdg-01237-00329331-00329582": "which asked for a finitary consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-01238-00329583-00329844": "proof for mathematics the second", "X0eez7H0vdg-01239-00329845-00330074": "incompleteness theorem in particular is", "X0eez7H0vdg-01240-00330075-00330257": "often viewed as making the problem", "X0eez7H0vdg-01241-00330258-00330567": "impossible not all mathematicians agree", "X0eez7H0vdg-01242-00330568-00330782": "with this analysis however and the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01243-00330783-00331007": "status of Hilbert second problem has not", "X0eez7H0vdg-01244-00331008-00331314": "yet decided see modern viewpoints on the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01245-00331315-00331939": "status of the problem", "X0eez7H0vdg-01246-00331940-00332495": "topic minds and machines", "X0eez7H0vdg-01247-00332496-00332753": "authors including the philosopher jr.", "X0eez7H0vdg-01248-00332754-00333007": "Lucas and physicist Roger Penrose have", "X0eez7H0vdg-01249-00333008-00333208": "debated what if anything go Dells", "X0eez7H0vdg-01250-00333209-00333406": "incompleteness theorems imply about", "X0eez7H0vdg-01251-00333407-00333682": "human intelligence much of the debate", "X0eez7H0vdg-01252-00333683-00333890": "centers on whether the human mind is", "X0eez7H0vdg-01253-00333891-00334115": "equivalent to a Turing machine or by the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01254-00334116-00334364": "church-turing thesis any finite machine", "X0eez7H0vdg-01255-00334365-00334640": "at all if it is and if the machine is", "X0eez7H0vdg-01256-00334641-00334804": "consistent then gödel's incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-01257-00334805-00335197": "theorems would apply to it Hilary Putnam", "X0eez7H0vdg-01258-00335198-00335465": "1960 suggested that while gödel's", "X0eez7H0vdg-01259-00335466-00335648": "theorems cannot be applied to humans", "X0eez7H0vdg-01260-00335649-00335843": "since they make mistakes and are", "X0eez7H0vdg-01261-00335844-00336055": "therefore inconsistent it may be applied", "X0eez7H0vdg-01262-00336056-00336256": "to the human Faculty of science or", "X0eez7H0vdg-01263-00336257-00336551": "mathematics in general assuming that it", "X0eez7H0vdg-01264-00336552-00336749": "is consistent either it's consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-01265-00336750-00336968": "cannot be proved or it cannot be", "X0eez7H0vdg-01266-00336969-00337192": "represented by a Turing machine", "X0eez7H0vdg-01267-00337193-00337526": "avi whig derson 2010 has proposed that", "X0eez7H0vdg-01268-00337527-00337804": "the concept of mathematical knowability", "X0eez7H0vdg-01269-00337805-00338029": "should be based on computational", "X0eez7H0vdg-01270-00338030-00338213": "complexity rather than logical", "X0eez7H0vdg-01271-00338214-00338498": "decidability he writes that when no", "X0eez7H0vdg-01272-00338499-00338714": "ability is interpreted by modern", "X0eez7H0vdg-01273-00338715-00338980": "standards namely via computational", "X0eez7H0vdg-01274-00338981-00339248": "complexity the godel phenomena are very", "X0eez7H0vdg-01275-00339249-00339685": "much with us Douglas Hofstadter in his", "X0eez7H0vdg-01276-00339686-00339926": "books gödel Escher Bach and I am a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01277-00339927-00340169": "strange loop cites gödel's theorems as", "X0eez7H0vdg-01278-00340170-00340357": "an example of what he calls a strange", "X0eez7H0vdg-01279-00340358-00340577": "loop a hierarchical self-referential", "X0eez7H0vdg-01280-00340578-00340810": "structure existing within an axiomatic", "X0eez7H0vdg-01281-00340811-00341128": "formal system he argues that this is the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01282-00341129-00341335": "same kind of structure which gives rise", "X0eez7H0vdg-01283-00341336-00341653": "to consciousness the sense of AI in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01284-00341654-00341894": "human mind while the self reference in", "X0eez7H0vdg-01285-00341895-00342092": "gödel's theorem comes from the godel", "X0eez7H0vdg-01286-00342093-00342280": "sentence asserting its own unprovable", "X0eez7H0vdg-01287-00342281-00342473": "'ti within the formal system of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01288-00342474-00342716": "principia mathematica the self reference", "X0eez7H0vdg-01289-00342717-00342928": "in the human mind comes from the way in", "X0eez7H0vdg-01290-00342929-00343097": "which the brain abstracts and", "X0eez7H0vdg-01291-00343098-00343424": "categorizes stimuli into symbols or", "X0eez7H0vdg-01292-00343425-00343637": "groups of neurons which respond to", "X0eez7H0vdg-01293-00343638-00343871": "concepts in what is effectively also a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01294-00343872-00344104": "formal system eventually giving rise to", "X0eez7H0vdg-01295-00344105-00344348": "symbols modeling the concept of the very", "X0eez7H0vdg-01296-00344349-00344678": "entity doing the perception Hofstadter", "X0eez7H0vdg-01297-00344679-00344870": "argues that a strange loop in a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01298-00344871-00345106": "sufficiently complex formal system can", "X0eez7H0vdg-01299-00345107-00345523": "give rise to a downward or upside-down", "X0eez7H0vdg-01300-00345524-00345784": "causality a situation in which the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01301-00345785-00345875": "normal higher are", "X0eez7H0vdg-01302-00345876-00346058": "of cause and effect is flipped upside", "X0eez7H0vdg-01303-00346059-00346403": "down in the case of gödel's theorem this", "X0eez7H0vdg-01304-00346404-00346678": "manifests in short as the following", "X0eez7H0vdg-01305-00346679-00346976": "merely from knowing the formulas meaning", "X0eez7H0vdg-01306-00346977-00347219": "one can infer its truth or falsity", "X0eez7H0vdg-01307-00347220-00347450": "without any effort to derive it in the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01308-00347451-00347570": "old-fashioned way", "X0eez7H0vdg-01309-00347571-00347729": "which requires one to trudge", "X0eez7H0vdg-01310-00347730-00348110": "methodically upwards from the axioms", "X0eez7H0vdg-01311-00348111-00348389": "this is not just peculiar it is", "X0eez7H0vdg-01312-00348390-00348713": "astonishing normally one cannot merely", "X0eez7H0vdg-01313-00348714-00348953": "look at what a mathematical conjecture", "X0eez7H0vdg-01314-00348954-00349193": "says then simply appeal to the content", "X0eez7H0vdg-01315-00349194-00349418": "of that statement on its own to deduce", "X0eez7H0vdg-01316-00349419-00349717": "whether the statement is true or false I", "X0eez7H0vdg-01317-00349718-00349997": "am a strange loop in the case of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01318-00349998-00350252": "mind a far more complex formal system", "X0eez7H0vdg-01319-00350253-00350627": "this downward causality manifests in", "X0eez7H0vdg-01320-00350628-00350879": "Hofstadter's view as the ineffable human", "X0eez7H0vdg-01321-00350880-00351110": "instinct that the causality of our minds", "X0eez7H0vdg-01322-00351111-00351295": "lies on the high level of desires", "X0eez7H0vdg-01323-00351296-00351557": "concepts personalities thoughts and", "X0eez7H0vdg-01324-00351558-00351767": "ideas rather than on the low level of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01325-00351768-00351992": "interactions between neurons or even", "X0eez7H0vdg-01326-00351993-00352169": "fundamental particles even though", "X0eez7H0vdg-01327-00352170-00352373": "according to physics the latter seems to", "X0eez7H0vdg-01328-00352374-00352688": "possess the causal power there is thus a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01329-00352689-00352934": "curious upside down this to our normal", "X0eez7H0vdg-01330-00352935-00353195": "human way of perceiving the world we are", "X0eez7H0vdg-01331-00353196-00353441": "built to perceive big stuff rather than", "X0eez7H0vdg-01332-00353442-00353660": "small stuff even though the domain of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01333-00353661-00353897": "the tiny seems to be where the actual", "X0eez7H0vdg-01334-00353898-00354278": "motors driving reality reside I am a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01335-00354279-00354810": "strange loop", "X0eez7H0vdg-01336-00354811-00355392": "topic para consistent logic", "X0eez7H0vdg-01337-00355393-00355638": "although gödel's theorems are usually", "X0eez7H0vdg-01338-00355639-00355835": "studied in the context of classical", "X0eez7H0vdg-01339-00355836-00356060": "logic they also have a role in the study", "X0eez7H0vdg-01340-00356061-00356250": "of para consistent logic and of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01341-00356251-00356472": "inherently contradictory statements Dial", "X0eez7H0vdg-01342-00356473-00356954": "idea Graham priest 1984 2006 argues that", "X0eez7H0vdg-01343-00356955-00357195": "replacing the notion of formal proof in", "X0eez7H0vdg-01344-00357196-00357420": "gödel's theorem with the usual notion of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01345-00357421-00357608": "informal proof can be used to show that", "X0eez7H0vdg-01346-00357609-00357870": "naive mathematics is inconsistent and", "X0eez7H0vdg-01347-00357871-00358097": "uses this as evidence for dialy theism", "X0eez7H0vdg-01348-00358098-00358401": "the cause of this inconsistency is the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01349-00358402-00358596": "inclusion of a truth predicate for a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01350-00358597-00358800": "system within the language of the system", "X0eez7H0vdg-01351-00358801-00359325": "priest 2006 247 stuart shapiro 2002", "X0eez7H0vdg-01352-00359326-00359517": "gives a more mixed appraisal of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01353-00359518-00359712": "applications of gödel's theorems to", "X0eez7H0vdg-01354-00359713-00360294": "dialy theism", "X0eez7H0vdg-01355-00360295-00360573": "topic appeals to the incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-01356-00360574-00361089": "theorems in other fields", "X0eez7H0vdg-01357-00361090-00361362": "appeals and analogies are sometimes made", "X0eez7H0vdg-01358-00361363-00361542": "to the incompleteness theorems in", "X0eez7H0vdg-01359-00361543-00361727": "support of arguments that go beyond", "X0eez7H0vdg-01360-00361728-00362016": "mathematics and logic several authors", "X0eez7H0vdg-01361-00362017-00362238": "have commented negatively on such", "X0eez7H0vdg-01362-00362239-00362445": "extensions and interpretations including", "X0eez7H0vdg-01363-00362446-00362801": "torkoal France Ian 2005 penny rot ich", "X0eez7H0vdg-01364-00362802-00363160": "einen 2005 Alain Sokol and Jean bricmont", "X0eez7H0vdg-01365-00363161-00363501": "1999 and Ophelia Benson and Jeremy Stan", "X0eez7H0vdg-01366-00363502-00363969": "groom 2006 bricmont and Stan groom 2006", "X0eez7H0vdg-01367-00363970-00364266": "P 10 for example quote from Rebecca", "X0eez7H0vdg-01368-00364267-00364454": "Goldstein's comments on the disparity", "X0eez7H0vdg-01369-00364455-00364709": "between gödel's avowed Platonism and the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01370-00364710-00364952": "anti-realist uses to which his ideas are", "X0eez7H0vdg-01371-00364953-00365458": "sometimes put Sokol in bricmont 1999 P", "X0eez7H0vdg-01372-00365459-00365801": "187 criticized register braze invocation", "X0eez7H0vdg-01373-00365802-00365960": "of the theorem in the context of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01374-00365961-00366227": "sociology Debray has defended this use", "X0eez7H0vdg-01375-00366228-00366873": "as metaphorical it", "X0eez7H0vdg-01376-00366874-00367390": "topic history", "X0eez7H0vdg-01377-00367391-00367635": "after gödel published his proof of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01378-00367636-00367813": "completeness theorem as his doctoral", "X0eez7H0vdg-01379-00367814-00368133": "thesis in 1929 he turned to a second", "X0eez7H0vdg-01380-00368134-00368395": "problem for his habilitation his", "X0eez7H0vdg-01381-00368396-00368631": "original goal was to obtain a positive", "X0eez7H0vdg-01382-00368632-00368875": "solution to Hilbert second problem daus", "X0eez7H0vdg-01383-00368876-00369381": "in 1997 P 63 at the time theories of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01384-00369382-00369603": "natural numbers and real numbers similar", "X0eez7H0vdg-01385-00369604-00369827": "to second-order arithmetic were known as", "X0eez7H0vdg-01386-00369828-00370141": "analysis while theories of the natural", "X0eez7H0vdg-01387-00370142-00370505": "numbers alone were known as arithmetic", "X0eez7H0vdg-01388-00370506-00370798": "gödel was not the only person working on", "X0eez7H0vdg-01389-00370799-00371050": "the consistency problem Ackerman had", "X0eez7H0vdg-01390-00371051-00371272": "published a flawed consistency proof for", "X0eez7H0vdg-01391-00371273-00371587": "analysis in 1925 in which he attempted", "X0eez7H0vdg-01392-00371588-00371733": "to use the method of epsilon", "X0eez7H0vdg-01393-00371734-00371950": "substitution originally developed by", "X0eez7H0vdg-01394-00371951-00372274": "Hilbert later that year von Neumann was", "X0eez7H0vdg-01395-00372275-00372483": "able to correct the proof for a system", "X0eez7H0vdg-01396-00372484-00372688": "of arithmetic without any axioms of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01397-00372689-00373032": "induction by 1928 Ackerman had", "X0eez7H0vdg-01398-00373033-00373264": "communicated a modified proof to Bernays", "X0eez7H0vdg-01399-00373265-00373513": "this modified proof led Hilbert to", "X0eez7H0vdg-01400-00373514-00373777": "announce his belief in 1929 that the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01401-00373778-00373969": "consistency of arithmetic had been", "X0eez7H0vdg-01402-00373970-00374157": "demonstrated and that a consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-01403-00374158-00374365": "proof of analysis would likely soon", "X0eez7H0vdg-01404-00374366-00374626": "follow after the publication of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01405-00374627-00374826": "incompleteness theorems showed that", "X0eez7H0vdg-01406-00374827-00375037": "Ackerman's modified proof must be", "X0eez7H0vdg-01407-00375038-00375247": "erroneous von neumann produced a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01408-00375248-00375453": "concrete example showing that its main", "X0eez7H0vdg-01409-00375454-00375892": "technique was unsound Zack 2006 P 418", "X0eez7H0vdg-01410-00375893-00376390": "Zack 2003 P 33 in the course of his", "X0eez7H0vdg-01411-00376391-00376600": "research gödel discovered that although", "X0eez7H0vdg-01412-00376601-00376765": "a sentence which asserts its own", "X0eez7H0vdg-01413-00376766-00377010": "falsehood leads to paradox a sentence", "X0eez7H0vdg-01414-00377011-00377218": "that asserts its own non proved ability", "X0eez7H0vdg-01415-00377219-00377542": "does not in particular gödel was aware", "X0eez7H0vdg-01416-00377543-00377749": "of the result now called tar skis in", "X0eez7H0vdg-01417-00377750-00377947": "define ability theorem although he never", "X0eez7H0vdg-01418-00377948-00378234": "published it gödel announced his first", "X0eez7H0vdg-01419-00378235-00378483": "incompleteness theorem to Carnap Fagel", "X0eez7H0vdg-01420-00378484-00378844": "and Wiseman on august 26 1930 all four", "X0eez7H0vdg-01421-00378845-00379012": "would attend a key conference in", "X0eez7H0vdg-01422-00379013-00379669": "königsberg the following week", "X0eez7H0vdg-01423-00379670-00380174": "topic announcement", "X0eez7H0vdg-01424-00380175-00380480": "the 1930 konigsberg conference was a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01425-00380481-00380657": "joint meeting of three academic", "X0eez7H0vdg-01426-00380658-00380891": "societies with many of the key logicians", "X0eez7H0vdg-01427-00380892-00381218": "of the time in attendance carnap hating", "X0eez7H0vdg-01428-00381219-00381416": "and von neumann delivered one-hour", "X0eez7H0vdg-01429-00381417-00381596": "addresses on the mathematical", "X0eez7H0vdg-01430-00381597-00381869": "philosophies of logis ism intuition ISM", "X0eez7H0vdg-01431-00381870-00382064": "and formalism respectively", "X0eez7H0vdg-01432-00382065-00382534": "thus in 1996 P 69 the conference also", "X0eez7H0vdg-01433-00382535-00382783": "included Hilbert's retirement address as", "X0eez7H0vdg-01434-00382784-00382958": "he was leaving his position at the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01435-00382959-00383260": "University of göttingen Hilbert used the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01436-00383261-00383450": "speech to argue his belief that all", "X0eez7H0vdg-01437-00383451-00383762": "mathematical problems can be solved he", "X0eez7H0vdg-01438-00383763-00384056": "ended his address by saying for the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01439-00384057-00384278": "mathematician there is no ignorable miss", "X0eez7H0vdg-01440-00384279-00384518": "and in my opinion not at all for natural", "X0eez7H0vdg-01441-00384519-00384929": "science either the true reason why no", "X0eez7H0vdg-01442-00384930-00385121": "one has succeeded in finding an", "X0eez7H0vdg-01443-00385122-00385384": "unsolvable problem as in my opinion that", "X0eez7H0vdg-01444-00385385-00385633": "there is no unsolvable problem in", "X0eez7H0vdg-01445-00385634-00385868": "contrast to the foolish ignoramus our", "X0eez7H0vdg-01446-00385869-00386165": "credo of verse we must know we shall", "X0eez7H0vdg-01447-00386166-00386507": "know this speech quickly became known as", "X0eez7H0vdg-01448-00386508-00386683": "a summary of Hilbert's beliefs on", "X0eez7H0vdg-01449-00386684-00386921": "mathematics its final six words", "X0eez7H0vdg-01450-00386922-00387503": "wir mussen wissen wir werden wilson were", "X0eez7H0vdg-01451-00387504-00387784": "used as Hilbert's epitaph in 1943", "X0eez7H0vdg-01452-00387785-00388033": "although gödel was likely in attendance", "X0eez7H0vdg-01453-00388034-00388256": "for Hilbert's address the two never met", "X0eez7H0vdg-01454-00388257-00388805": "face to face das in 1996 P 72 gödel", "X0eez7H0vdg-01455-00388806-00388957": "announced his first incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-01456-00388958-00389114": "theorem at a roundtable discussion", "X0eez7H0vdg-01457-00389115-00389312": "session on the third day of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01458-00389313-00389594": "conference the announcement drew little", "X0eez7H0vdg-01459-00389595-00389774": "attention apart from that of von Neumann", "X0eez7H0vdg-01460-00389775-00390067": "who pulled gödel aside for conversation", "X0eez7H0vdg-01461-00390068-00390347": "later that year working independently", "X0eez7H0vdg-01462-00390348-00390473": "with knowledge of the first", "X0eez7H0vdg-01463-00390474-00390677": "incompleteness theorem von neumann", "X0eez7H0vdg-01464-00390678-00390830": "obtained a proof of the second", "X0eez7H0vdg-01465-00390831-00390989": "incompleteness theorem which he", "X0eez7H0vdg-01466-00390990-00391145": "announced to gödel in a letter dated", "X0eez7H0vdg-01467-00391146-00391666": "November 20th 1930 the sin 1996 P 70", "X0eez7H0vdg-01468-00391667-00391925": "gödel had independently obtained the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01469-00391926-00392093": "second incompleteness theorem and", "X0eez7H0vdg-01470-00392094-00392306": "included it in his submitted manuscript", "X0eez7H0vdg-01471-00392307-00392507": "which was received by Mancha for", "X0eez7H0vdg-01472-00392508-00392942": "mathematic on November 17 1930 gödel's", "X0eez7H0vdg-01473-00392943-00393146": "paper was published in the Mont chaffed", "X0eez7H0vdg-01474-00393147-00393527": "in 1931 under the title uber formal and", "X0eez7H0vdg-01475-00393528-00393815": "bear sets derp principia mathematica", "X0eez7H0vdg-01476-00393816-00394163": "n'ver wander system AI unfor Mele", "X0eez7H0vdg-01477-00394164-00394433": "undecidable propositions in Principia", "X0eez7H0vdg-01478-00394434-00394823": "Mathematica and related systems I as the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01479-00394824-00395072": "title implies gödel originally planned", "X0eez7H0vdg-01480-00395073-00395285": "to publish a second part of the paper in", "X0eez7H0vdg-01481-00395286-00395483": "the next volume of the Mont shaft the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01482-00395484-00395678": "prompt acceptance of the first paper was", "X0eez7H0vdg-01483-00395679-00395927": "one reason he changed his plans van", "X0eez7H0vdg-01484-00395928-00396967": "Heian ort 1967 to 328 footnote 68 a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01485-00396968-00397622": "topic generalization and acceptance", "X0eez7H0vdg-01486-00397623-00397882": "gödel gave a series of lectures on his", "X0eez7H0vdg-01487-00397883-00398284": "theorems at Princeton in 1933 1934 to an", "X0eez7H0vdg-01488-00398285-00398522": "audience that included church clean and", "X0eez7H0vdg-01489-00398523-00398864": "Rosser by this time gödel had grasped", "X0eez7H0vdg-01490-00398865-00399034": "that the key property his theorems", "X0eez7H0vdg-01491-00399035-00399232": "required is that the system must be", "X0eez7H0vdg-01492-00399233-00399508": "effective at the time the term general", "X0eez7H0vdg-01493-00399509-00399929": "recursive was used Rosser proved in 1936", "X0eez7H0vdg-01494-00399930-00400199": "that the hypothesis of omega consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-01495-00400200-00400384": "which was an integral part of gödel's", "X0eez7H0vdg-01496-00400385-00400601": "original proof could be replaced by", "X0eez7H0vdg-01497-00400602-00400838": "simple consistency if the godel sentence", "X0eez7H0vdg-01498-00400839-00401114": "was changed in an appropriate way these", "X0eez7H0vdg-01499-00401115-00401303": "developments left the incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-01500-00401304-00401501": "theorems in essentially their modern", "X0eez7H0vdg-01501-00401502-00401831": "form Jensen published his consistency", "X0eez7H0vdg-01502-00401832-00402199": "proof for first order arithmetic in 1936", "X0eez7H0vdg-01503-00402200-00402534": "Hilbert accepted this proof as finitary", "X0eez7H0vdg-01504-00402535-00402797": "although as gödel's theorem had already", "X0eez7H0vdg-01505-00402798-00403060": "shown it cannot be formalized within the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01506-00403061-00403247": "system of arithmetic that is being", "X0eez7H0vdg-01507-00403248-00403544": "proved consistent the impact of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01508-00403545-00403730": "incompleteness theorems on Hilbert's", "X0eez7H0vdg-01509-00403731-00403939": "program was quickly realized", "X0eez7H0vdg-01510-00403940-00404204": "Bernays included a full proof of the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01511-00404205-00404399": "incompleteness theorems in the second", "X0eez7H0vdg-01512-00404400-00404714": "volume of grun Legendre mathematic 1939", "X0eez7H0vdg-01513-00404715-00404900": "along with additional results of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01514-00404901-00405119": "Ackerman on the epsilon substitution", "X0eez7H0vdg-01515-00405120-00405344": "method and Jensen's consistency proof of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01516-00405345-00405596": "arithmetic this was the first full", "X0eez7H0vdg-01517-00405597-00405743": "published proof of the second", "X0eez7H0vdg-01518-00405744-00406331": "incompleteness theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-01519-00406332-00406684": "topic criticisms", "X0eez7H0vdg-01520-00406685-00406852": "you", "X0eez7H0vdg-01521-00406853-00407162": "you", "X0eez7H0vdg-01522-00407163-00407633": "topic fin slur", "X0eez7H0vdg-01523-00407634-00408002": "Paul fence ler 1926 used a version of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01524-00408003-00408197": "Richards paradox to construct an", "X0eez7H0vdg-01525-00408198-00408419": "expression that was false but unprovable", "X0eez7H0vdg-01526-00408420-00408656": "in a particular informal framework he", "X0eez7H0vdg-01527-00408657-00408938": "had developed gödel was unaware of this", "X0eez7H0vdg-01528-00408939-00409133": "paper when he proved the incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-01529-00409134-00409562": "theorems collected works volume IV p9", "X0eez7H0vdg-01530-00409563-00409907": "fin slur wrote to gödel in 1931 to", "X0eez7H0vdg-01531-00409908-00410120": "inform him about this paper which fin", "X0eez7H0vdg-01532-00410121-00410300": "slur felt had priority for an", "X0eez7H0vdg-01533-00410301-00410582": "incompleteness theorem fin slurs methods", "X0eez7H0vdg-01534-00410583-00410782": "did not rely on formalized proved", "X0eez7H0vdg-01535-00410783-00410978": "ability and had only a superficial", "X0eez7H0vdg-01536-00410979-00411224": "resemblance to go dolls work van Heian", "X0eez7H0vdg-01537-00411225-00411830": "ort 1967 to 328 gödel read the paper but", "X0eez7H0vdg-01538-00411831-00412049": "found it deeply flawed and his response", "X0eez7H0vdg-01539-00412050-00412268": "to fin slur laid out concerns about the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01540-00412268-00412660": "lack of formalization Dawson 89 fin slur", "X0eez7H0vdg-01541-00412662-00412871": "continued to argue for his philosophy of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01542-00412872-00413122": "mathematics which issued formalization", "X0eez7H0vdg-01543-00413124-00413737": "for the remainder of his career", "X0eez7H0vdg-01544-00413738-00414218": "topic Zermelo", "X0eez7H0vdg-01545-00414219-00414597": "in September 1931 Ernst Zermelo wrote to", "X0eez7H0vdg-01546-00414597-00414789": "gödel to announce what he described as", "X0eez7H0vdg-01547-00414789-00415124": "an essential gap in gödel's argument", "X0eez7H0vdg-01548-00415125-00415530": "Dawson 76 in October gödel replied with", "X0eez7H0vdg-01549-00415531-00415778": "a 10 page letter Dawson 76", "X0eez7H0vdg-01550-00415779-00416184": "grattan-guinness 512 to 513 where he", "X0eez7H0vdg-01551-00416185-00416378": "pointed out that Zermelo mistakenly", "X0eez7H0vdg-01552-00416379-00416580": "assumed that the notion of truth in a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01553-00416581-00416820": "system is definable in that system which", "X0eez7H0vdg-01554-00416821-00417032": "is not true in general bite our skis", "X0eez7H0vdg-01555-00417033-00417353": "undefinable ax T theorem but Zermelo did", "X0eez7H0vdg-01556-00417354-00417584": "not relent and published his criticisms", "X0eez7H0vdg-01557-00417585-00417801": "in print with a rather scathing", "X0eez7H0vdg-01558-00417802-00418034": "paragraph on his young competitor", "X0eez7H0vdg-01559-00418035-00418460": "grattan-guinness 513 gödel decided that", "X0eez7H0vdg-01560-00418462-00418641": "to pursue the matter further was", "X0eez7H0vdg-01561-00418642-00418974": "pointless and Carnap agreed Dawson 77", "X0eez7H0vdg-01562-00418975-00419264": "much of Zermelo subsequent work was", "X0eez7H0vdg-01563-00419266-00419447": "related to logic stronger than", "X0eez7H0vdg-01564-00419448-00419664": "first-order logic with which he hoped to", "X0eez7H0vdg-01565-00419664-00419877": "show both the consistency and category", "X0eez7H0vdg-01566-00419878-00420518": "city of mathematical theories", "X0eez7H0vdg-01567-00420519-00421006": "topic Wittgenstein", "X0eez7H0vdg-01568-00421007-00421259": "Ludwig Wittgenstein wrote several", "X0eez7H0vdg-01569-00421260-00421421": "passages about the incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-01570-00421422-00421564": "theorems that were published", "X0eez7H0vdg-01571-00421566-00421883": "posthumously in his 1953 remarks on the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01572-00421884-00422122": "foundations of mathematics in particular", "X0eez7H0vdg-01573-00422124-00422320": "one section sometimes called the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01574-00422321-00422642": "notorious paragraph where he seems to", "X0eez7H0vdg-01575-00422643-00423014": "confuse the notions of true and provable", "X0eez7H0vdg-01576-00423014-00423302": "in Russell's system gödel was a member", "X0eez7H0vdg-01577-00423303-00423512": "of the vienna circle during the period", "X0eez7H0vdg-01578-00423513-00423710": "in which Wittgenstein's early ideal", "X0eez7H0vdg-01579-00423710-00423908": "language philosophy and Tractatus", "X0eez7H0vdg-01580-00423909-00424133": "logico-philosophicus dominated the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01581-00424134-00424385": "circles thinking there has been some", "X0eez7H0vdg-01582-00424385-00424583": "controversy about whether Wittgenstein", "X0eez7H0vdg-01583-00424584-00424805": "misunderstood the incompleteness theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-01584-00424806-00425047": "or just expressed himself unclearly", "X0eez7H0vdg-01585-00425047-00425339": "writings in gödel's noch class expressed", "X0eez7H0vdg-01586-00425339-00425552": "the belief that Wittgenstein misread his", "X0eez7H0vdg-01587-00425553-00425893": "ideas multiple commentators have read", "X0eez7H0vdg-01588-00425895-00426122": "Wittgenstein as misunderstanding gödel", "X0eez7H0vdg-01589-00426122-00426452": "Radek 2003 although Juliette Floyd and", "X0eez7H0vdg-01590-00426453-00426713": "Hilary Putnam 2000 as well as Graham", "X0eez7H0vdg-01591-00426714-00427007": "Priest 2004 have provided textual", "X0eez7H0vdg-01592-00427008-00427217": "readings arguing that most commentary", "X0eez7H0vdg-01593-00427218-00427499": "misunderstands Wittgenstein on their", "X0eez7H0vdg-01594-00427500-00427559": "release", "X0eez7H0vdg-01595-00427560-00427772": "Bernays dumb --it & kreisel wrote", "X0eez7H0vdg-01596-00427772-00427958": "separate reviews on Wittgenstein's", "X0eez7H0vdg-01597-00427959-00428156": "remarks all of which were extremely", "X0eez7H0vdg-01598-00428157-00428621": "negative Berto 2009 to 208 the unanimity", "X0eez7H0vdg-01599-00428622-00428843": "of this criticism caused Wittgenstein's", "X0eez7H0vdg-01600-00428843-00429050": "remarks on the incompleteness theorems", "X0eez7H0vdg-01601-00429051-00429227": "to have little impact on the logic", "X0eez7H0vdg-01602-00429228-00429664": "community in 1972 gödel stated has", "X0eez7H0vdg-01603-00429666-00429868": "Wittgenstein lost his mind", "X0eez7H0vdg-01604-00429870-00430130": "does he mean it seriously he", "X0eez7H0vdg-01605-00430131-00430313": "intentionally utters trivially", "X0eez7H0vdg-01606-00430314-00430934": "nonsensical statements wrong 1996 to 179", "X0eez7H0vdg-01607-00430935-00431110": "and wrote to Carl mentor that", "X0eez7H0vdg-01608-00431112-00431303": "Wittgenstein's comments demonstrate a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01609-00431304-00431483": "misunderstanding of the incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-01610-00431484-00431804": "theorems writing it is clear from the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01611-00431805-00432050": "passages you cite that Wittgenstein did", "X0eez7H0vdg-01612-00432051-00432242": "not understand the first incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-01613-00432243-00432479": "theorem or pretended not to understand", "X0eez7H0vdg-01614-00432480-00432752": "it he interpreted it as a kind of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01615-00432753-00433001": "logical paradox while in fact as just", "X0eez7H0vdg-01616-00433002-00433214": "the opposite namely a mathematical", "X0eez7H0vdg-01617-00433214-00433357": "theorem within an absolutely", "X0eez7H0vdg-01618-00433358-00433531": "uncontroversial part of mathematics", "X0eez7H0vdg-01619-00433532-00433772": "finitary number theory or combinatorics", "X0eez7H0vdg-01620-00433772-00434192": "1 1996 to 100", "X0eez7H0vdg-01621-00434193-00434474": "Denine since the publication of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01622-00434475-00434717": "Wittgenstein's knock class in 2000 a", "X0eez7H0vdg-01623-00434718-00434935": "series of papers and philosophy have", "X0eez7H0vdg-01624-00434937-00435110": "sought to evaluate whether the original", "X0eez7H0vdg-01625-00435110-00435353": "criticism of Wittgenstein's remarks was", "X0eez7H0vdg-01626-00435354-00435746": "justified Floyd and Putnam 2000 argue", "X0eez7H0vdg-01627-00435747-00435943": "that Wittgenstein had a more complete", "X0eez7H0vdg-01628-00435945-00436097": "understanding of the incompleteness", "X0eez7H0vdg-01629-00436097-00436406": "theorem than was previously assumed they", "X0eez7H0vdg-01630-00436407-00436574": "are particularly concerned with the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01631-00436575-00436793": "interpretation of a godel sentence for", "X0eez7H0vdg-01632-00436793-00437030": "an Omega inconsistent system as actually", "X0eez7H0vdg-01633-00437031-00437327": "saying I am NOT provable since the", "X0eez7H0vdg-01634-00437328-00437543": "system has no models in which the proved", "X0eez7H0vdg-01635-00437543-00437777": "ability predicate corresponds to actual", "X0eez7H0vdg-01636-00437778-00438131": "proved ability Radek 2003 argues that", "X0eez7H0vdg-01637-00438132-00438332": "their interpretation of Wittgenstein is", "X0eez7H0vdg-01638-00438333-00438592": "not historically justified while Bayes", "X0eez7H0vdg-01639-00438593-00438905": "2004 argues against Floyd and putnams", "X0eez7H0vdg-01640-00438906-00439097": "philosophical analysis of the proved", "X0eez7H0vdg-01641-00439097-00439484": "ability predicate Berto 2009 explores", "X0eez7H0vdg-01642-00439485-00439685": "the relationship between Wittgenstein's", "X0eez7H0vdg-01643-00439685-00439892": "writing and theories of para consist of", "X0eez7H0vdg-01644-00439893-00440443": "logic", "X0eez7H0vdg-01645-00440444-00440990": "topic see also", "X0eez7H0vdg-01646-00440991-00441317": "gödel machine gödel's completeness", "X0eez7H0vdg-01647-00441318-00441418": "theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-01648-00441419-00441904": "gödel speed-up theorem gödel Escher Bach", "X0eez7H0vdg-01649-00441905-00442406": "Loubs theorem minds machines and gödel", "X0eez7H0vdg-01650-00442407-00442779": "munchausen trilemma non standard model", "X0eez7H0vdg-01651-00442780-00443202": "of arithmetic proof theory probability", "X0eez7H0vdg-01652-00443203-00443621": "logic winning terse keys undefinable", "X0eez7H0vdg-01653-00443622-00443917": "atif theorem theory of everything", "X0eez7H0vdg-01654-00443918-00444262": "hashtag geo Dalls incompleteness theorem", "X0eez7H0vdg-01655-00444263-00444651": "third man argument"}}, {"audio_id": "X0PEUD2uaru", "text": {"X0PEUD2uaru-00000-00000041-00000374": "velka Farah National Park Slovak narodny", "X0PEUD2uaru-00001-00000375-00000632": "Park Velka Farah is a national park in", "X0PEUD2uaru-00002-00000633-00000925": "Slovakia most of it lies in the southern", "X0PEUD2uaru-00003-00000926-00001112": "part of the Zelena region in a small", "X0PEUD2uaru-00004-00001113-00001295": "part in the northern part of banská", "X0PEUD2uaru-00005-00001296-00001586": "Bystrica region the National Park in its", "X0PEUD2uaru-00006-00001587-00001784": "protective zone comprised most of the", "X0PEUD2uaru-00007-00001785-00002051": "greater photo range Slovak Velka fara", "X0PEUD2uaru-00008-00002052-00002222": "which belongs to the outer western", "X0PEUD2uaru-00009-00002223-00002516": "Carpathians the National Park was", "X0PEUD2uaru-00010-00002517-00002792": "declared on the 1st of April 2002 as an", "X0PEUD2uaru-00011-00002793-00003008": "upgrade of the protected landscape area", "X0PEUD2uaru-00012-00003009-00003377": "slovak Crenna Krajina oblast chk o volka", "X0PEUD2uaru-00013-00003378-00003613": "farah of the same name established in", "X0PEUD2uaru-00014-00003614-00003893": "1972 to protect a mountain range with a", "X0PEUD2uaru-00015-00003894-00004049": "high percentage of well-preserved", "X0PEUD2uaru-00016-00004050-00004261": "Carpathian forests with prevailing", "X0PEUD2uaru-00017-00004262-00004504": "European Beach which cover 90% of the", "X0PEUD2uaru-00018-00004505-00004700": "area in combination with ridge top", "X0PEUD2uaru-00019-00004701-00004927": "cattle pastures dating back to the 15th", "X0PEUD2uaru-00020-00004928-00005150": "17th centuries to the times of the so", "X0PEUD2uaru-00021-00005151-00005347": "called will action colonization in", "X0PEUD2uaru-00022-00005348-00005611": "places there are also relics Scots pine", "X0PEUD2uaru-00023-00005612-00005795": "forests and the harmonic Valley as", "X0PEUD2uaru-00024-00005796-00005999": "notable as the richest Irish yew tree", "X0PEUD2uaru-00025-00006000-00006200": "location in Central and probably all", "X0PEUD2uaru-00026-00006201-00006509": "Europe NP velka farah is also an", "X0PEUD2uaru-00027-00006509-00006683": "important reservoir of fresh water", "X0PEUD2uaru-00028-00006684-00006869": "thanks to high rainfalls and low", "X0PEUD2uaru-00029-00006870-00007139": "evaporation in the area the core of the", "X0PEUD2uaru-00030-00007140-00007321": "range is built of granite which reaches", "X0PEUD2uaru-00031-00007322-00007546": "the surface only in places more common", "X0PEUD2uaru-00032-00007547-00007733": "or various slates creating gently", "X0PEUD2uaru-00033-00007734-00007913": "modelled ridges and summits of the so", "X0PEUD2uaru-00034-00007914-00008110": "called honah Farah and limestone and", "X0PEUD2uaru-00035-00008111-00008303": "dolomite rocks creating a rough and", "X0PEUD2uaru-00036-00008304-00008471": "picturesque terrain of the so called", "X0PEUD2uaru-00037-00008472-00008764": "Brown of Farah there are also many karst", "X0PEUD2uaru-00038-00008765-00008989": "features namely caves harmonic cave", "X0PEUD2uaru-00039-00008990-00009231": "being the only one open to the public", "X0PEUD2uaru-00040-00009232-00009470": "various rocks and therefore various", "X0PEUD2uaru-00041-00009471-00009683": "soils diverse type of terrain with", "X0PEUD2uaru-00042-00009684-00009910": "gentle upland meadows and pastures sharp", "X0PEUD2uaru-00043-00009911-00010099": "cliffs and deep valleys provide for", "X0PEUD2uaru-00044-00010100-00010352": "extremely rich flora and fauna all", "X0PEUD2uaru-00045-00010353-00010553": "species of big Central European", "X0PEUD2uaru-00046-00010554-00010742": "carnivores live abundantly there", "X0PEUD2uaru-00047-00010743-00010999": "brown bear grey wolf and Eurasian Lynx", "X0PEUD2uaru-00048-00011000-00011306": "the area is popular with tourists mainly", "X0PEUD2uaru-00049-00011307-00011480": "hikers and trekkers as they're rather", "X0PEUD2uaru-00050-00011481-00011720": "few resorts located outside the national", "X0PEUD2uaru-00051-00011721-00012013": "park the unesco world heritage village", "X0PEUD2uaru-00052-00012014-00012220": "of VL kalanick with well-preserved log", "X0PEUD2uaru-00053-00012221-00012863": "cabins lies nearby", "X0PEUD2uaru-00054-00012863-00013480": "topic small protected areas", "X0PEUD2uaru-00055-00013481-00013801": "as of February 2007 there were following", "X0PEUD2uaru-00056-00013802-00014016": "small protected areas within the NP", "X0PEUD2uaru-00057-00014018-00014615": "velka fara and its buffer zone", "X0PEUD2uaru-00058-00014616-00015147": "topic resources", "X0PEUD2uaru-00059-00015149-00015586": "Brando's attacker 2004 velka Farah sips", "X0PEUD2uaru-00060-00015587-00016168": "kuffara Ostrava sky ISBN 808 6 7 7 4 o 2", "X0PEUD2uaru-00061-00016169-00016654": "3 v KU harmonic 2003 Velka fara Eddie", "X0PEUD2uaru-00062-00016655-00016921": "shatter is to kitsch map 1 to 50000", "X0PEUD2uaru-00063-00016922-00017554": "harmonic v KU ISBN 808 o4 204 4o velka", "X0PEUD2uaru-00064-00017555-00017914": "fara retrieved the 6th of March 2007", "X0PEUD2uaru-00065-00017915-00018181": "statin eases namaz so bit knee crane", "X0PEUD2uaru-00066-00018182-00018517": "mich caste priority senior retrieved the", "X0PEUD2uaru-00067-00018518-00019160": "8th of March 2007", "X0PEUD2uaru-00068-00019161-00019696": "topic external links", "X0PEUD2uaru-00069-00019697-00020000": "velka farah national park at slovakia", "X0PEUD2uaru-00070-00020001-00020291": "travel"}}, {"audio_id": "X0UzrI5axiA", "text": {"X0UzrI5axiA-00000-00000294-00000630": "foreign", "X0UzrI5axiA-00001-00000631-00001147": "[Music]", "X0UzrI5axiA-00002-00001148-00001408": "good morning Saints today is Wednesday", "X0UzrI5axiA-00003-00001409-00001709": "November 2nd 2022. happy birthday today", "X0UzrI5axiA-00004-00001710-00002160": "to Leo Gage Mia gervancini Alex", "X0UzrI5axiA-00005-00002161-00002387": "the saint of the day today is Saint", "X0UzrI5axiA-00006-00002388-00002626": "odilio in the middle of the 11th century", "X0UzrI5axiA-00007-00002627-00002855": "Saint adilio Abbott of Clooney France", "X0UzrI5axiA-00008-00002856-00003142": "decreed the all kuniak monasteries offer", "X0UzrI5axiA-00009-00003143-00003340": "special prayers and sing the office for", "X0UzrI5axiA-00010-00003342-00003545": "the dead on November 2nd the day after", "X0UzrI5axiA-00011-00003546-00003743": "the Feast of All Saints the custom", "X0UzrI5axiA-00012-00003744-00003904": "spread from Clooney and was finally", "X0UzrI5axiA-00013-00003905-00004063": "adopted throughout the Roman Church", "X0UzrI5axiA-00014-00004064-00004325": "saints boys soccer knocked off the", "X0UzrI5axiA-00015-00004326-00004631": "number one seed Summoner which is 1-0 on", "X0UzrI5axiA-00016-00004632-00004883": "the Andrew Seger shootout to get back to", "X0UzrI5axiA-00017-00004884-00005165": "the final four for the 26th time the", "X0UzrI5axiA-00018-00005166-00005393": "third year in a row Ethan young got the", "X0UzrI5axiA-00019-00005394-00005602": "game-winning assist on a header back", "X0UzrI5axiA-00020-00005603-00006049": "across the goal then Anthony can", "X0UzrI5axiA-00021-00006050-00006377": "considera finish the voice play", "X0UzrI5axiA-00022-00006378-00006670": "undefeated maze South at humner Park in", "X0UzrI5axiA-00023-00006672-00006970": "Topeka at five o'clock on Friday the STA", "X0UzrI5axiA-00024-00006972-00007133": "musical Freaky Friday Friday premieres", "X0UzrI5axiA-00025-00007134-00007319": "this week the sooner you get tickets the", "X0UzrI5axiA-00026-00007320-00007487": "better your seats will be so buy early", "X0UzrI5axiA-00027-00007488-00007720": "last year's musical sold out don't miss", "X0UzrI5axiA-00028-00007722-00007889": "your opportunity to see this fantastic", "X0UzrI5axiA-00029-00007890-00008098": "show information and tickets can be", "X0UzrI5axiA-00030-00008100-00008441": "found at stasaints.net theater it is not", "X0UzrI5axiA-00031-00008442-00008657": "too late to register for the DC March", "X0UzrI5axiA-00032-00008658-00008842": "for Life trip you have until Friday", "X0UzrI5axiA-00033-00008843-00009119": "November 4th get registration forms from", "X0UzrI5axiA-00034-00009120-00009455": "Mrs lothman in room 124. we will have a", "X0UzrI5axiA-00035-00009456-00009677": "lot of great experience come and join us", "X0UzrI5axiA-00036-00009678-00009910": "and stand up for Life the STA musical", "X0UzrI5axiA-00037-00009911-00010067": "parents invite you to take photos of", "X0UzrI5axiA-00038-00010068-00010241": "yourself at the Freaky Friday photo op", "X0UzrI5axiA-00039-00010242-00010463": "spots in the Commons themes from the", "X0UzrI5axiA-00040-00010464-00010673": "musical are on display scavenger hunt", "X0UzrI5axiA-00041-00010674-00010859": "and a wedding Booth please take a", "X0UzrI5axiA-00042-00010860-00011063": "picture of yourself or better yet with a", "X0UzrI5axiA-00043-00011064-00011242": "group of friends and then email it to", "X0UzrI5axiA-00044-00011243-00011467": "the Student Life office to Beatrix", "X0UzrI5axiA-00045-00011468-00011687": "stacs.net and your photo will be printed", "X0UzrI5axiA-00046-00011688-00011903": "and displayed in the Commons join the", "X0UzrI5axiA-00047-00011904-00012155": "history Club Thursday during sta period", "X0UzrI5axiA-00048-00012156-00012406": "in Block 2. patriotic snacks will be", "X0UzrI5axiA-00049-00012407-00012610": "served games will be played and plans", "X0UzrI5axiA-00050-00012611-00012785": "will be made for Veterans Day and", "X0UzrI5axiA-00051-00012786-00013043": "election day we want you to be in room", "X0UzrI5axiA-00052-00013044-00013283": "127 on Thursday we're kicking off", "X0UzrI5axiA-00053-00013284-00013451": "national French week here at Aquinas", "X0UzrI5axiA-00054-00013452-00013625": "with a guest speaker sponsored by French", "X0UzrI5axiA-00055-00013626-00013847": "Club this Thursday November 3rd during", "X0UzrI5axiA-00056-00013847-00014122": "SCA period come to room 104 to learn how", "X0UzrI5axiA-00057-00014123-00014333": "French can change your life Mrs Plumb", "X0UzrI5axiA-00058-00014334-00014519": "mother of current Juniors Megan and", "X0UzrI5axiA-00059-00014519-00014680": "Caroline will be here to share her", "X0UzrI5axiA-00060-00014681-00014897": "experiences with us all are welcome", "X0UzrI5axiA-00061-00014897-00015155": "please sign up using the QR codes posted", "X0UzrI5axiA-00062-00015156-00015335": "around the building French students see", "X0UzrI5axiA-00063-00015336-00015472": "Google Classroom this week to learn", "X0UzrI5axiA-00064-00015473-00015701": "about requirements for extra credit for", "X0UzrI5axiA-00065-00015702-00015844": "seniors who have committed to play a", "X0UzrI5axiA-00066-00015845-00016061": "sport at the next level please stop by", "X0UzrI5axiA-00067-00016062-00016271": "the Student Life office to sign up for", "X0UzrI5axiA-00068-00016272-00016499": "the November 9th signing ceremony that", "X0UzrI5axiA-00069-00016500-00016685": "will be held right after school in the", "X0UzrI5axiA-00070-00016686-00016913": "main gym the deadline for the sign up is", "X0UzrI5axiA-00071-00016914-00017117": "this Friday the canned food drive is", "X0UzrI5axiA-00072-00017118-00017308": "happening right now you need to help", "X0UzrI5axiA-00073-00017309-00017465": "your grade win and bring in the most", "X0UzrI5axiA-00074-00017466-00017686": "cans the theme is Kentucky Derby", "X0UzrI5axiA-00075-00017687-00017843": "throughout this week you can wear your", "X0UzrI5axiA-00076-00017844-00018005": "canned food drive shirts with uniform", "X0UzrI5axiA-00077-00018006-00018172": "bottoms make sure to talk to your", "X0UzrI5axiA-00078-00018173-00018365": "classical leaders to see what cans you", "X0UzrI5axiA-00079-00018366-00018497": "can bring in to get the most points", "X0UzrI5axiA-00080-00018498-00018725": "attention Saints the football game has", "X0UzrI5axiA-00081-00018726-00018880": "been moved to Friday", "X0UzrI5axiA-00082-00018881-00019091": "from Friday to Thursday which is", "X0UzrI5axiA-00083-00019092-00019372": "tomorrow due to weather problems the", "X0UzrI5axiA-00084-00019373-00019577": "game will still be at Lewisburg at seven", "X0UzrI5axiA-00085-00019578-00019805": "come support our Saints on the menu", "X0UzrI5axiA-00086-00019806-00020014": "today in the sinks Cafe breakfast for", "X0UzrI5axiA-00087-00020015-00020155": "lunch", "X0UzrI5axiA-00088-00020156-00020405": "now it's time for word of the day the", "X0UzrI5axiA-00089-00020406-00020686": "word of today is fussy gate fussy gate", "X0UzrI5axiA-00090-00020687-00020939": "means to criticize severely Saints let's", "X0UzrI5axiA-00091-00020940-00021167": "not fussigate others today wow I just", "X0UzrI5axiA-00092-00021168-00021335": "did not know that thank you for watching", "X0UzrI5axiA-00093-00021336-00021491": "the Halo Morning Show we'll be back with", "X0UzrI5axiA-00094-00021492-00021689": "you tomorrow I'm Jace and I'm Peyton", "X0UzrI5axiA-00095-00021690-00021911": "signing off remember stay across the", "X0UzrI5axiA-00096-00021912-00022226": "Saints and embrace the moment"}}, {"audio_id": "X0WPQuDPGPA", "text": {"X0WPQuDPGPA-00000-00000000-00000559": "[Music]", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00001-00000560-00000711": "i tried", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00002-00000712-00001031": "how long do my sessions last", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00003-00001032-00001199": "good question", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00004-00001200-00001358": "so", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00005-00001359-00001647": "whenever you schedule", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00006-00001648-00001798": "with me i", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00007-00001800-00002110": "advise you to block out at least a three", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00008-00002111-00002287": "hour time period", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00009-00002288-00002583": "to make sure you have plenty of time", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00010-00002584-00002863": "there have been on occasions i have had", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00011-00002864-00003126": "some last a little longer than three", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00012-00003127-00003319": "hours maybe like four", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00013-00003320-00003390": "but", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00014-00003392-00003663": "i am not charging by the hour i am going", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00015-00003664-00003951": "to go as long as it takes to", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00016-00003952-00004111": "i feel like", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00017-00004112-00004303": "you have gotten what you came here to", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00018-00004304-00004543": "get my best advice is to", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00019-00004544-00004759": "block out at least three hours of your", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00020-00004760-00004879": "time", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00021-00004880-00005006": "to", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00022-00005007-00005247": "have plenty of time in between", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00023-00005248-00005415": "if need be", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00024-00005416-00005511": "after", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00025-00005512-00005711": "the session i will give you your own", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00026-00005712-00005999": "personal recording for you to listen to", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00027-00006000-00006359": "for 21 days okay 21 days", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00028-00006360-00006470": "no less", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00029-00006472-00006719": "because the mind learns by repetition", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00030-00006720-00006814": "you just", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00031-00006815-00007039": "dumped out a bunch of stuff right", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00032-00007040-00007255": "at the session we just got rid of a", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00033-00007256-00007375": "bunch of stuff", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00034-00007376-00007710": "and we put some stuff in okay well now", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00035-00007711-00007903": "we need to listen to that recording for", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00036-00007904-00008183": "21 days so we can like", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00037-00008184-00008367": "cement it and", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00038-00008368-00008678": "you can really bring that into your mind", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00039-00008679-00008783": "okay", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00040-00008784-00008999": "because you didn't get these blues all", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00041-00009000-00009127": "in one day", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00042-00009128-00009310": "you're gonna get rid of them in one day", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00043-00009311-00009513": "but you need to put some new ones in", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00044-00009514-00009623": "[Music]", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00045-00009624-00009839": "and keep repeating it and repeating it", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00046-00009840-00010142": "for that 21 days this locks in the", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00047-00010143-00010374": "changes and is a vital part of the", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00048-00010375-00010478": "process", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00049-00010479-00010678": "with that 21 days listening to your", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00050-00010679-00010967": "personal recording and no worries i", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00051-00010968-00011255": "promise the recording is very enjoyable", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00052-00011256-00011527": "and pleasant and you will love it", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00053-00011528-00011774": "everybody has always said that they love", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00054-00011775-00011870": "them", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00055-00011871-00012055": "and they're not long either they're like", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00056-00012056-00012167": "20 minutes", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00057-00012168-00012351": "he said", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00058-00012352-00012599": "anyways that's all i have for today guys", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00059-00012600-00012897": "love and life", "X0WPQuDPGPA-00060-00012899-00013906": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "X0al8Xi2VB4", "text": {"X0al8Xi2VB4-00000-00000003-00000265": "hi everyone now generally amusement", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00001-00000266-00000407": "rides are all very similar", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00002-00000408-00000601": "featuring the ordinary twists and turns", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00003-00000602-00000844": "however with that said there's actually", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00004-00000846-00001120": "much more than these usual rides so with", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00005-00001121-00001345": "that said in today's video we will be", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00006-00001346-00001532": "counting down our picks for the top five", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00007-00001533-00001775": "most unusual and insane attractions you", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00008-00001776-00001955": "probably haven't heard about before so", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00009-00001955-00002213": "without any further ado here are some of", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00010-00002214-00002375": "the most extraordinary rides that are", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00011-00002376-00002591": "not suited for the faint-hearted let's", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00012-00002592-00002792": "go now if you like these kind of videos", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00013-00002793-00002987": "and want to see more then make sure to", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00014-00002988-00003170": "leave us a like on the video subscribe", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00015-00003171-00003350": "to our Channel and turn on post", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00016-00003351-00003529": "notifications to be the first to watch", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00017-00003530-00003827": "all our new and exciting videos every", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00018-00003828-00004013": "first comment will be getting pin so", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00019-00004014-00005143": "good luck number 5 sky tower jump sky", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00020-00005144-00005384": "tower located in the Tivoli free Haydn", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00021-00005385-00005606": "theme park in Denmark suspends riders", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00022-00005607-00005879": "above a net in a harness and then cuts", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00023-00005880-00006104": "them loose sending the unfortunate rider", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00024-00006105-00006284": "plummeting down to earth at a crazy", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00025-00006285-00006620": "speed of 55 miles per hour being most", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00026-00006620-00006781": "likely one of the most crazy and insane", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00027-00006783-00007081": "theme park rides ever to exist this ride", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00028-00007083-00007245": "is definitely not for the faint-hearted", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00029-00007247-00007541": "so if you fancy being dropped from above", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00030-00007542-00007856": "100 feet at over 50 miles per hour this", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00031-00007856-00008875": "ride is definitely for you", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00032-00008876-00009290": "[Applause]", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00033-00009291-00009821": "number four the tilt observation deck if", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00034-00009822-00009969": "you're not afraid of heights and love", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00035-00009970-00010170": "beautiful panoramic views over the city", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00036-00010171-00010365": "you will most definitely love this", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00037-00010366-00010632": "attraction located in Chicago is an", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00038-00010633-00010890": "unusual observation deck known as the", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00039-00010891-00011112": "tilt which even though it isn't a ride", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00040-00011113-00011285": "we thought it deserved a place on this", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00041-00011286-00011510": "list due to its fun and extreme nature", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00042-00011511-00011766": "located on the 94th floor of the John", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00043-00011767-00011963": "Hancock Tower which also happens to be", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00044-00011964-00012149": "the tenth tallest building in the u.s.", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00045-00012150-00012410": "being the first ever sky deck that can", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00046-00012411-00012633": "tilt onlookers forward thirty degrees", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00047-00012634-00012843": "this unusual attraction holds eight", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00048-00012844-00013044": "people at the same time and hangs them", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00049-00013044-00013244": "towards the edge of the skyscraper for a", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00050-00013245-00013497": "total of one minute of absolute fear and", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00051-00013497-00013812": "anxiety so if you do ride it just hope", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00052-00013813-00014163": "the blast is strong enough", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00053-00014165-00015290": "[Music]", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00054-00015291-00015772": "number three crazy pendulum ride", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00055-00015774-00015990": "amusement ride known as the giant", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00056-00015991-00016215": "discovery gives riders the ultimate", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00057-00016216-00016419": "thrill experience as they sit in outward", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00058-00016420-00016662": "facing suspended seats that form a giant", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00059-00016663-00016887": "circle of 40 passengers that swings", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00060-00016888-00017145": "riders back and forth reaching a maximum", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00061-00017146-00017403": "speed of 68 miles per hour with riders", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00062-00017404-00017595": "also being flung upside down at a height", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00063-00017596-00017919": "of 147 feet above the ground this ride", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00064-00017920-00018180": "is surely no walk in the park being", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00065-00018181-00018363": "popular amongst thrill-seekers this", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00066-00018364-00018522": "pendulum ride will satisfy your", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00067-00018523-00019366": "adrenaline seeking needs", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00068-00019367-00020130": "[Music]", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00069-00020131-00020616": "number two underwater rollercoaster", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00070-00020617-00020848": "Cosmo world amusement park in Japan", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00071-00020849-00021082": "contains a crazy ride known as the", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00072-00021083-00021292": "vanish rollercoaster that makes riders", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00073-00021293-00021457": "disappear upon hitting the water", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00074-00021458-00021640": "the coaster actually enters an", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00075-00021641-00021838": "underwater tunnel for around two minutes", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00076-00021839-00022039": "which for a roller coaster moving at", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00077-00022040-00022249": "such a fast speed is quite a long time", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00078-00022250-00022522": "besides going underwater the ride also", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00079-00022523-00022777": "reaches heights of 114 feet above the", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00080-00022778-00024388": "surface which is absolutely crazy", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00081-00024389-00024901": "number one skyscraper roller coaster", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00082-00024902-00025133": "stratospheric scream roller coaster is", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00083-00025134-00025298": "essentially a ride dedicated to", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00084-00025299-00025597": "adrenaline junkies as it tilts riders 27", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00085-00025598-00025730": "feet off the edge of the stratosphere", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00086-00025731-00026012": "skyscraper in Las Vegas the ride takes", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00087-00026013-00026194": "advantage of the built environment to", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00088-00026195-00026377": "create a new form of thrill which in", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00089-00026379-00026555": "this case is literally dangling off a", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00090-00026556-00026839": "skyscraper moving at 30 miles per hour", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00091-00026841-00027110": "at almost 900 feet up in the air if", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00092-00027111-00027275": "you're not a fan of heights and being", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00093-00027276-00027500": "put at the edge of a skyscraper maybe", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00094-00027501-00028283": "think twice before riding", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00095-00028285-00029048": "[Music]", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00096-00029049-00029268": "anyway that has been it for today's", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00097-00029269-00029532": "video on the most unusual rides which", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00098-00029533-00029742": "was your favorite ride from the list let", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00099-00029743-00029955": "us know by leaving a comment thanks for", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00100-00029956-00030102": "watching and we hope to see you next", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00101-00030102-00030513": "time", "X0al8Xi2VB4-00102-00030514-00033437": "[Music]"}}, {"audio_id": "X1kQjenJoFQ", "text": {"X1kQjenJoFQ-00000-00000606-00000965": "Euler's first publication was in 1725 he", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00001-00000966-00001247": "died in 1783 having published over 500", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00002-00001248-00001408": "books and papers", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00003-00001409-00001607": "after his death his publication rate", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00004-00001607-00001895": "slowed and he only published about 300", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00005-00001896-00002159": "books and papers after his death", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00006-00002160-00002302": "part of the reason oily could write", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00007-00002303-00002531": "almost 900 books and papers is that he", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00008-00002532-00002734": "returned to the same problem multiple", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00009-00002735-00003203": "times with different approaches", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00010-00003204-00003436": "so after having shown that the sum of", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00011-00003438-00003617": "the reciprocal squares is pi squared", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00012-00003618-00003904": "over 6 using the relationship from the", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00013-00003905-00004063": "factorization of the McLaren series", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00014-00004064-00004343": "Euler presented a different approach in", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00015-00004344-00004733": "a 1735 paper", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00016-00004734-00004991": "and this image as follows Euler noted", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00017-00004992-00005213": "that the series expansion failed if y", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00018-00005214-00005543": "equaled zero but in that case we'd have", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00019-00005544-00005933": "where X is a solution to sine X equal to", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00020-00005934-00006322": "zero", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00021-00006323-00006598": "now one solution is x equals zero", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00022-00006600-00006827": "since x equals zero is one solution we", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00023-00006828-00007325": "can remove a factor of x to get", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00024-00007326-00007583": "and so the remaining Solutions are going", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00025-00007584-00007763": "to be from setting the second Factor", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00026-00007764-00008092": "equal to zero and as before Euler", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00027-00008093-00008664": "assumed that this could Factor as", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00028-00008665-00008945": "now these Solutions decide x equals zero", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00029-00008946-00009209": "besides x equals zero are plus or minus", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00030-00009210-00009527": "pi plus or minus 2 pi plus or minus 4 pi", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00031-00009528-00010228": "and so on so our factorization will be", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00032-00010229-00010624": "and because we have factors that are the", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00033-00010625-00010877": "sum and difference of the same terms we", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00034-00010878-00011806": "can multiply them pairwise to get", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00035-00011807-00011992": "and consequently this infinite series", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00036-00011993-00012433": "can be expressed as", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00037-00012434-00012749": "the x squared term in the expansion", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00038-00012750-00012994": "comes from the sum of the x squared", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00039-00012995-00013555": "terms in the factors and so we have", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00040-00013556-00013775": "which gives us a different way of", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00041-00013776-00014315": "deriving this summation", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00042-00014316-00014608": "but wait there's more to extend this", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00043-00014609-00014830": "result Euler use some well known at the", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00044-00014831-00015161": "time formulas so again let Alpha be the", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00045-00015162-00015544": "sum of terms and let beta be the sum of", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00046-00015545-00015875": "the pairwise products then the sum of", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00047-00015876-00016072": "the squares of the terms will be Alpha", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00048-00016073-00016636": "squared minus 2 Beta", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00049-00016637-00016949": "so from this sum we can find the sum of", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00050-00016950-00017236": "the squares if we knew the value of the", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00051-00017237-00017875": "sum of the pairwise products", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00052-00017876-00018167": "but the sum of the pairwise products is", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00053-00018168-00018335": "how we would determine the X to the", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00054-00018336-00018863": "fourth coefficient in the expansion", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00055-00018864-00019097": "and since we have", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00056-00019098-00019379": "we know that the coefficient of the X to", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00057-00019380-00019577": "the fourth term is the sum of the", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00058-00019578-00020075": "pairwise products", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00059-00020076-00020669": "and so our formulas give us", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00060-00020670-00021214": "and so we can conclude", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00061-00021215-00021436": "similarly if we have our sum", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00062-00021437-00021725": "some of the pairwise products and some", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00063-00021726-00021971": "of the triple products", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00064-00021972-00022114": "then the sum of the cubes can be", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00065-00022115-00022691": "expressed as", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00066-00022692-00022900": "and we already know the sum", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00067-00022901-00023200": "the sum of a pairwise products and the", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00068-00023201-00023350": "sum of the triple products will give us", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00069-00023351-00023561": "the X to the sixth coefficient in the", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00070-00023562-00023897": "expansion and so we have gamma equal to", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00071-00023898-00024377": "one seven factorials", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00072-00024378-00025049": "and so we find", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00073-00025050-00025355": "and in this way Euler found the sum of", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00074-00025356-00025618": "reciprocal fourth Powers the sum of the", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00075-00025619-00025834": "reciprocal sixth Towers the sum of the", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00076-00025835-00026039": "reciprocal eighth Powers tenth Powers", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00077-00026039-00026255": "twelfth powers", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00078-00026256-00026495": "with the observation that this took a", "X1kQjenJoFQ-00079-00026495-00026941": "fair deal of work for the higher powers"}}, {"audio_id": "X1oMujeqmAI", "text": {"X1oMujeqmAI-00000-00000044-00001040": "[Music]", "X1oMujeqmAI-00001-00001041-00001607": "[Applause]", "X1oMujeqmAI-00002-00001607-00001757": "hello everyone", "X1oMujeqmAI-00003-00001757-00001960": "welcome to", "X1oMujeqmAI-00004-00001961-00002242": "nptel course on remote sensing and Gis", "X1oMujeqmAI-00005-00002243-00002549": "for Rural level", "X1oMujeqmAI-00006-00002550-00002987": "this is week 2 lecture five", "X1oMujeqmAI-00007-00002988-00003322": "this is the last lecture for week two", "X1oMujeqmAI-00008-00003323-00003599": "let us see what we are going to cover in", "X1oMujeqmAI-00009-00003600-00003935": "today's lecture", "X1oMujeqmAI-00010-00003936-00004151": "you would have noticed that I already", "X1oMujeqmAI-00011-00004152-00004469": "have two other nptel courses", "X1oMujeqmAI-00012-00004470-00004720": "one focusing on groundwater because I'm", "X1oMujeqmAI-00013-00004721-00005002": "a groundwater hydrologist", "X1oMujeqmAI-00014-00005003-00005213": "I talk about groundwater hydrology and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00015-00005214-00005435": "how it is very important", "X1oMujeqmAI-00016-00005436-00005543": "and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00017-00005544-00005795": "another course on", "X1oMujeqmAI-00018-00005796-00006172": "Water Resources for Rural regions", "X1oMujeqmAI-00019-00006173-00006641": "focusing on Water Resources", "X1oMujeqmAI-00020-00006642-00006892": "in both the courses I do give some hints", "X1oMujeqmAI-00021-00006893-00007145": "about remote sensing and GIS", "X1oMujeqmAI-00022-00007145-00007510": "so that experience has given me", "X1oMujeqmAI-00023-00007511-00008077": "to have a summary slide for every week", "X1oMujeqmAI-00024-00008078-00008296": "however the week one is purely", "X1oMujeqmAI-00025-00008297-00008585": "introductory material so I may not have", "X1oMujeqmAI-00026-00008586-00008999": "had a in-depth summary so this lecture", "X1oMujeqmAI-00027-00009000-00009245": "is to summarize week one and week two", "X1oMujeqmAI-00028-00009246-00009628": "and prepare you for week three", "X1oMujeqmAI-00029-00009629-00009881": "it will also be used to link between", "X1oMujeqmAI-00030-00009882-00010073": "Week 1 and V2", "X1oMujeqmAI-00031-00010074-00010373": "and the flow of the course so always", "X1oMujeqmAI-00032-00010374-00010667": "important to reiterate so it's like", "X1oMujeqmAI-00033-00010668-00011003": "reading a paper you start with an", "X1oMujeqmAI-00034-00011004-00011321": "objective introduction go through the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00035-00011322-00011567": "results analysis and then come back", "X1oMujeqmAI-00036-00011568-00011764": "to the conclusion which supports your", "X1oMujeqmAI-00037-00011765-00011981": "first part of the paper introduction", "X1oMujeqmAI-00038-00011982-00012185": "basically", "X1oMujeqmAI-00039-00012186-00012563": "summarizing everything", "X1oMujeqmAI-00040-00012564-00012833": "so this is important to summarize what", "X1oMujeqmAI-00041-00012834-00013055": "we have learned so please join me in", "X1oMujeqmAI-00042-00013056-00013283": "today's lecture for the summary and how", "X1oMujeqmAI-00043-00013284-00013486": "to do the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00044-00013487-00013925": "preparations for future lectures", "X1oMujeqmAI-00045-00013926-00014165": "in the first week we looked at and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00046-00014166-00014399": "Define what is rural development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00047-00014400-00014597": "trust me", "X1oMujeqmAI-00048-00014597-00014843": "a lot of people struggle to Define this", "X1oMujeqmAI-00049-00014844-00015005": "plural dialogue what is rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00050-00015006-00015311": "development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00051-00015312-00015544": "and we cannot give personal experiences", "X1oMujeqmAI-00052-00015545-00015880": "and personal feelings about rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00053-00015881-00016007": "development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00054-00016008-00016277": "some may say that education is needed", "X1oMujeqmAI-00055-00016278-00016469": "some may say water is needed", "X1oMujeqmAI-00056-00016470-00016703": "and the definition of what do you mean", "X1oMujeqmAI-00057-00016704-00016817": "by", "X1oMujeqmAI-00058-00016818-00017093": "rural development which level to which", "X1oMujeqmAI-00059-00017094-00017249": "level are you talking about rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00060-00017250-00017447": "development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00061-00017448-00017585": "right", "X1oMujeqmAI-00062-00017586-00017830": "so India is a developing Nation it has", "X1oMujeqmAI-00063-00017831-00018077": "to become a developed Nation so there", "X1oMujeqmAI-00064-00018078-00018250": "are metrics so how do you keep metrics", "X1oMujeqmAI-00065-00018251-00018400": "for Rural Development so these kind of", "X1oMujeqmAI-00066-00018401-00018653": "questions will be asked", "X1oMujeqmAI-00067-00018654-00018935": "the best way out for this question is", "X1oMujeqmAI-00068-00018936-00019186": "follow the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00069-00019187-00019475": "country specific guidelines", "X1oMujeqmAI-00070-00019476-00019858": "and for India we have used the ministry", "X1oMujeqmAI-00071-00019859-00020093": "of rural developments webpage", "X1oMujeqmAI-00072-00020094-00020429": "so we have been very careful in defining", "X1oMujeqmAI-00073-00020430-00020711": "from the terms", "X1oMujeqmAI-00074-00020712-00020908": "from the Ministries", "X1oMujeqmAI-00075-00020909-00021041": "that are", "X1oMujeqmAI-00076-00021042-00021485": "putting more stakeholder", "X1oMujeqmAI-00077-00021486-00021749": "and also more budgets in rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00078-00021750-00021989": "development so it is important to go", "X1oMujeqmAI-00079-00021990-00022319": "through what the agency says the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00080-00022320-00022486": "ministry what does the ministry Define", "X1oMujeqmAI-00081-00022487-00022721": "as rural development what are the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00082-00022722-00022900": "sectors they have identified for Rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00083-00022901-00023003": "Development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00084-00023004-00023267": "and we progress on that", "X1oMujeqmAI-00085-00023268-00023578": "there may be others who would Define it", "X1oMujeqmAI-00086-00023579-00023680": "differently", "X1oMujeqmAI-00087-00023681-00024058": "but they are not the Authority for rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00088-00024059-00024293": "development in India so we are taking", "X1oMujeqmAI-00089-00024294-00024677": "our notes from the Ministries website", "X1oMujeqmAI-00090-00024678-00024983": "if you had noticed in my reading notes", "X1oMujeqmAI-00091-00024984-00025349": "and lectures I clearly indicated that", "X1oMujeqmAI-00092-00025350-00025606": "we'll be using a lot of government", "X1oMujeqmAI-00093-00025607-00025877": "records and reports", "X1oMujeqmAI-00094-00025877-00026081": "and the government records and reports", "X1oMujeqmAI-00095-00026082-00026393": "come from these agencies okay so we are", "X1oMujeqmAI-00096-00026394-00026608": "defining what is rural development by", "X1oMujeqmAI-00097-00026610-00026902": "first even defining the agency", "X1oMujeqmAI-00098-00026904-00027131": "we also looked at cases why it is", "X1oMujeqmAI-00099-00027132-00027293": "important for India's overall", "X1oMujeqmAI-00100-00027294-00027407": "development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00101-00027408-00027605": "I'll go through it again in this lecture", "X1oMujeqmAI-00102-00027606-00027874": "with some statistics", "X1oMujeqmAI-00103-00027875-00028139": "the key issues for Rural Development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00104-00028139-00028523": "and or to improve rural development is", "X1oMujeqmAI-00105-00028524-00028823": "data", "X1oMujeqmAI-00106-00028824-00029273": "data on the schemes data on the need for", "X1oMujeqmAI-00107-00029274-00029489": "the schemes and data on the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00108-00029489-00029674": "beneficiaries the cause the budget", "X1oMujeqmAI-00109-00029675-00029831": "everything", "X1oMujeqmAI-00110-00029832-00030168": "it's big budgets that come into this", "X1oMujeqmAI-00111-00030169-00030479": "development scenario", "X1oMujeqmAI-00112-00030480-00030802": "so it is important to understand these", "X1oMujeqmAI-00113-00030804-00031211": "issues", "X1oMujeqmAI-00114-00031212-00031474": "when we talk about data we have to look", "X1oMujeqmAI-00115-00031475-00031907": "at alternators for data observation data", "X1oMujeqmAI-00116-00031908-00032123": "and it has to be cost effective high", "X1oMujeqmAI-00117-00032124-00032362": "spatial and important resolution", "X1oMujeqmAI-00118-00032363-00032561": "and so we identified", "X1oMujeqmAI-00119-00032562-00032855": "remote sensing", "X1oMujeqmAI-00120-00032856-00033077": "remote cell C", "X1oMujeqmAI-00121-00033078-00033377": "has been proved to be very useful in", "X1oMujeqmAI-00122-00033378-00033599": "different parts of the globe", "X1oMujeqmAI-00123-00033600-00033977": "and even in India for urban cities", "X1oMujeqmAI-00124-00033978-00034289": "per rural it has been less study", "X1oMujeqmAI-00125-00034290-00034517": "so for that we are introducing the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00126-00034518-00034787": "concept remote sensing here so this", "X1oMujeqmAI-00127-00034788-00034996": "course itself is a very unique course", "X1oMujeqmAI-00128-00034997-00035195": "because you would see remote sensing for", "X1oMujeqmAI-00129-00035196-00035435": "glaciers Urban flood", "X1oMujeqmAI-00130-00035436-00035657": "different courses on remote sensing for", "X1oMujeqmAI-00131-00035658-00036059": "crops but as rural development it is not", "X1oMujeqmAI-00132-00036060-00036329": "there and that is why we have kept this", "X1oMujeqmAI-00133-00036330-00036652": "course", "X1oMujeqmAI-00134-00036653-00036881": "how can remote sensing and GIS augment", "X1oMujeqmAI-00135-00036882-00037205": "data we looked at multiple methods", "X1oMujeqmAI-00136-00037206-00037523": "through which", "X1oMujeqmAI-00137-00037524-00037768": "remote sensing can address the issues", "X1oMujeqmAI-00138-00037769-00038002": "that is mentioned earlier", "X1oMujeqmAI-00139-00038003-00038368": "the data issues correct so we'll be", "X1oMujeqmAI-00140-00038369-00038579": "careful in", "X1oMujeqmAI-00141-00038580-00038896": "seeing how to use the remote sensing in", "X1oMujeqmAI-00142-00038897-00039071": "GIS", "X1oMujeqmAI-00143-00039072-00039467": "always augment data not overtake or", "X1oMujeqmAI-00144-00039468-00039779": "replace data because government has a", "X1oMujeqmAI-00145-00039780-00040024": "set of data which is very very", "X1oMujeqmAI-00146-00040025-00040343": "carefully taken there are some issues", "X1oMujeqmAI-00147-00040344-00040601": "that we have mentioned as temporal", "X1oMujeqmAI-00148-00040602-00040729": "spatial", "X1oMujeqmAI-00149-00040730-00041129": "some data issues we have however it is", "X1oMujeqmAI-00150-00041130-00041362": "still a government record", "X1oMujeqmAI-00151-00041363-00041687": "so you cannot bring remote sensing and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00152-00041688-00041885": "take the government record out you have", "X1oMujeqmAI-00153-00041886-00042155": "to merge them work together and make a", "X1oMujeqmAI-00154-00042156-00042305": "augmented product", "X1oMujeqmAI-00155-00042306-00042551": "it can be called as data value addition", "X1oMujeqmAI-00156-00042552-00042857": "it can be taught defined as augmenting", "X1oMujeqmAI-00157-00042858-00042959": "data", "X1oMujeqmAI-00158-00042960-00043113": "updating data Etc", "X1oMujeqmAI-00159-00043114-00043312": "[Music]", "X1oMujeqmAI-00160-00043313-00043540": "so these all are also mentioned in the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00161-00043541-00043924": "vision of New India by nithya yo", "X1oMujeqmAI-00162-00043925-00044135": "where there is a lot of discussion on", "X1oMujeqmAI-00163-00044136-00044483": "agriculture and rural development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00164-00044484-00044815": "agriculture is still the most important", "X1oMujeqmAI-00165-00044816-00045155": "or the majority livelihood for Rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00166-00045156-00045358": "regions", "X1oMujeqmAI-00167-00045359-00045545": "and for agriculture water is more", "X1oMujeqmAI-00168-00045546-00045718": "important so you see how it is tied", "X1oMujeqmAI-00169-00045719-00046012": "together it will jump to water without", "X1oMujeqmAI-00170-00046013-00046451": "putting these in front so rural areas", "X1oMujeqmAI-00171-00046452-00046733": "need to develop and rural areas focus on", "X1oMujeqmAI-00172-00046734-00047017": "agriculture and livelihood options", "X1oMujeqmAI-00173-00047018-00047267": "agriculture is driven by water and soil", "X1oMujeqmAI-00174-00047268-00047849": "fertility", "X1oMujeqmAI-00175-00047850-00048112": "let us look at the course flow so as I", "X1oMujeqmAI-00176-00048113-00048335": "mentioned the title of this course how", "X1oMujeqmAI-00177-00048336-00048461": "it was done", "X1oMujeqmAI-00178-00048462-00048767": "we also want to let you all understand", "X1oMujeqmAI-00179-00048768-00049127": "the course flow so that you can do some", "X1oMujeqmAI-00180-00049128-00049433": "preparations before", "X1oMujeqmAI-00181-00049434-00049643": "I have seen the material that we are", "X1oMujeqmAI-00182-00049644-00049912": "going to cover asked in lot of", "X1oMujeqmAI-00183-00049913-00050118": "aptitude test", "X1oMujeqmAI-00184-00050119-00050536": "civil service exams Bank exams Etc", "X1oMujeqmAI-00185-00050537-00050902": "so I hope this kind of lectures will", "X1oMujeqmAI-00186-00050903-00051112": "help you also prepare for those kind of", "X1oMujeqmAI-00187-00051113-00051358": "aspects", "X1oMujeqmAI-00188-00051359-00051646": "very specifically it does lie in civil", "X1oMujeqmAI-00189-00051647-00051964": "Earth remote sensing uh those kind of uh", "X1oMujeqmAI-00190-00051965-00052276": "platforms", "X1oMujeqmAI-00191-00052277-00052679": "and also subjects", "X1oMujeqmAI-00192-00052679-00053104": "let's look at the course flow", "X1oMujeqmAI-00193-00053105-00053500": "in weeks one and two we will understand", "X1oMujeqmAI-00194-00053501-00053741": "rural issues", "X1oMujeqmAI-00195-00053741-00053892": "that are", "X1oMujeqmAI-00196-00053894-00054425": "stagnating rural development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00197-00054426-00054791": "and we will look at the need for", "X1oMujeqmAI-00198-00054791-00054988": "tools that can", "X1oMujeqmAI-00199-00054989-00055463": "improve the development scenario", "X1oMujeqmAI-00200-00055464-00055642": "one of the tools that we already started", "X1oMujeqmAI-00201-00055644-00056176": "with is remote sensing and GIS", "X1oMujeqmAI-00202-00056177-00056435": "since we already proposed it in the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00203-00056436-00056603": "title", "X1oMujeqmAI-00204-00056604-00056909": "and we supported our argument", "X1oMujeqmAI-00205-00056910-00057226": "with week one and week two understanding", "X1oMujeqmAI-00206-00057227-00057604": "we go to week three four and five where", "X1oMujeqmAI-00207-00057605-00057899": "we introduce the remote sensing and GIS", "X1oMujeqmAI-00208-00057900-00058121": "tools", "X1oMujeqmAI-00209-00058122-00058403": "so from week one two we go to three four", "X1oMujeqmAI-00210-00058404-00058516": "five", "X1oMujeqmAI-00211-00058517-00059207": "where we introduced remote sensing ngis", "X1oMujeqmAI-00212-00059208-00059407": "in weeks one and two you would have only", "X1oMujeqmAI-00213-00059408-00059800": "known about the issues", "X1oMujeqmAI-00214-00059801-00060197": "where data can help and why data is not", "X1oMujeqmAI-00215-00060198-00060353": "available", "X1oMujeqmAI-00216-00060354-00060659": "for example I gave the river networks", "X1oMujeqmAI-00217-00060660-00060875": "and I said suddenly the river can change", "X1oMujeqmAI-00218-00060876-00061144": "the direction but the map will tell the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00219-00061145-00061271": "previous", "X1oMujeqmAI-00220-00061272-00061541": "River Direction", "X1oMujeqmAI-00221-00061541-00061811": "so what is needed to update the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00222-00061812-00062182": "map and to update the map we need", "X1oMujeqmAI-00223-00062183-00062435": "better data", "X1oMujeqmAI-00224-00062436-00062680": "which comes from these kind of", "X1oMujeqmAI-00225-00062682-00063082": "platforms", "X1oMujeqmAI-00226-00063083-00063347": "so that will be covered in three four", "X1oMujeqmAI-00227-00063348-00063682": "five some very important introduction", "X1oMujeqmAI-00228-00063683-00063994": "material will be covered but please note", "X1oMujeqmAI-00229-00063995-00064288": "this is not a full remote sensing in GIS", "X1oMujeqmAI-00230-00064289-00064565": "course it is an application course so", "X1oMujeqmAI-00231-00064566-00064649": "please", "X1oMujeqmAI-00232-00064650-00065015": "add your understanding of remote sensing", "X1oMujeqmAI-00233-00065016-00065380": "in GIS from other nptel and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00234-00065382-00065867": "open source courses", "X1oMujeqmAI-00235-00065868-00066100": "so three four five", "X1oMujeqmAI-00236-00066101-00066341": "we will develop", "X1oMujeqmAI-00237-00066342-00066893": "key concepts of remote sensing and GIS", "X1oMujeqmAI-00238-00066894-00067132": "there are multiple tools and tools are", "X1oMujeqmAI-00239-00067133-00067511": "always updated in remote sensing and GIS", "X1oMujeqmAI-00240-00067512-00067831": "of those tools the key tools will be", "X1oMujeqmAI-00241-00067832-00068291": "specifically explained in week six seven", "X1oMujeqmAI-00242-00068292-00068609": "this will be more like a tutorial that I", "X1oMujeqmAI-00243-00068610-00068813": "will be going through on the screen you", "X1oMujeqmAI-00244-00068814-00069023": "will see I how I use the tool how the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00245-00069024-00069419": "data is created how the analysis is done", "X1oMujeqmAI-00246-00069420-00069629": "we will try our best to finish within 30", "X1oMujeqmAI-00247-00069630-00069821": "minutes", "X1oMujeqmAI-00248-00069822-00069976": "because your lecture is 30 minutes", "X1oMujeqmAI-00249-00069977-00070235": "otherwise it will be Brokenness two", "X1oMujeqmAI-00250-00070236-00070456": "sessions 30 minute one 30 minute to part", "X1oMujeqmAI-00251-00070457-00070799": "one part", "X1oMujeqmAI-00252-00070800-00071026": "so some processes in remote sensing and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00253-00071027-00071225": "GIS will be", "X1oMujeqmAI-00254-00071226-00071531": "explained in weeks 6 and 7.", "X1oMujeqmAI-00255-00071532-00071765": "moving on", "X1oMujeqmAI-00256-00071766-00072149": "we will also use a practical case for", "X1oMujeqmAI-00257-00072150-00072532": "example I said mapping of a lake", "X1oMujeqmAI-00258-00072533-00072869": "I will show you in weeks 8 9 10.", "X1oMujeqmAI-00259-00072870-00073067": "how to map a lake", "X1oMujeqmAI-00260-00073068-00073367": "how to quickly find the area of the lake", "X1oMujeqmAI-00261-00073368-00073576": "in the last 15 years", "X1oMujeqmAI-00262-00073577-00073919": "and then document if the lake area has", "X1oMujeqmAI-00263-00073920-00074081": "been", "X1oMujeqmAI-00264-00074082-00074237": "shortened", "X1oMujeqmAI-00265-00074238-00074447": "due to encroachment", "X1oMujeqmAI-00266-00074448-00074693": "or any other issue and how it's", "X1oMujeqmAI-00267-00074694-00074950": "affecting the rural development so we", "X1oMujeqmAI-00268-00074951-00075197": "start with a practical case of first", "X1oMujeqmAI-00269-00075198-00075376": "mapping a lake", "X1oMujeqmAI-00270-00075377-00075611": "mapping the area of the lake", "X1oMujeqmAI-00271-00075612-00075911": "for the perimeter", "X1oMujeqmAI-00272-00075912-00076115": "and then over time how has the perimeter", "X1oMujeqmAI-00273-00076116-00076529": "changed suppose the lake has diminished", "X1oMujeqmAI-00274-00076530-00076756": "by 60 percent", "X1oMujeqmAI-00275-00076757-00077225": "then we will go in a zoomed out", "X1oMujeqmAI-00276-00077226-00077632": "assessment to look at where are the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00277-00077633-00077975": "regions that are affecting the lake or", "X1oMujeqmAI-00278-00077976-00078155": "why is the lake depleting for example", "X1oMujeqmAI-00279-00078156-00078485": "encroachment for example people putting", "X1oMujeqmAI-00280-00078486-00078935": "landfills into the lake", "X1oMujeqmAI-00281-00078936-00079223": "land reclaimed for from the lake so", "X1oMujeqmAI-00282-00079224-00079373": "which means they basically construct", "X1oMujeqmAI-00283-00079374-00079523": "into a lake", "X1oMujeqmAI-00284-00079524-00079950": "remember Singapore has extended into the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00285-00079951-00080369": "Waters by reclaiming land", "X1oMujeqmAI-00286-00080370-00080669": "it's a big process that occurs", "X1oMujeqmAI-00287-00080670-00080867": "we don't know if it is sustainable", "X1oMujeqmAI-00288-00080868-00081119": "because a lot of flora fauna ecosystem", "X1oMujeqmAI-00289-00081120-00081400": "should have been destroyed", "X1oMujeqmAI-00290-00081401-00081694": "but it still exists right a lot of", "X1oMujeqmAI-00291-00081695-00081917": "around the world people countries do", "X1oMujeqmAI-00292-00081918-00082241": "reclaim man so the land is this much and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00293-00082242-00082535": "then there is C or an ocean let's say", "X1oMujeqmAI-00294-00082536-00082805": "see they will", "X1oMujeqmAI-00295-00082806-00083231": "extend the land by bringing", "X1oMujeqmAI-00296-00083232-00083465": "land materials from different parts", "X1oMujeqmAI-00297-00083466-00083782": "rocks sand etc etc and then putting and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00298-00083783-00084119": "then building it on top of it", "X1oMujeqmAI-00299-00084120-00084359": "the concerns are the waters are", "X1oMujeqmAI-00300-00084360-00084791": "different regions", "X1oMujeqmAI-00301-00084792-00085037": "and is it sustainable so those kind of", "X1oMujeqmAI-00302-00085038-00085294": "things we will look at in mapping", "X1oMujeqmAI-00303-00085295-00085565": "luckily India does not have that issue", "X1oMujeqmAI-00304-00085566-00085812": "our neighboring countries", "X1oMujeqmAI-00305-00085813-00086135": "have not tried to take up our coastal", "X1oMujeqmAI-00306-00086136-00086375": "regions in terms of land reclamination", "X1oMujeqmAI-00307-00086376-00086656": "but mapping helps because satellites can", "X1oMujeqmAI-00308-00086657-00086825": "always look at those regions and then we", "X1oMujeqmAI-00309-00086826-00086981": "can map", "X1oMujeqmAI-00310-00086982-00087238": "in fact while I'm talking this there has", "X1oMujeqmAI-00311-00087239-00087515": "been a satellite recently launched by", "X1oMujeqmAI-00312-00087516-00087671": "Indian government", "X1oMujeqmAI-00313-00087672-00087862": "and the first images of Gujarat have", "X1oMujeqmAI-00314-00087863-00088091": "already been shared", "X1oMujeqmAI-00315-00088092-00088403": "we will talk more about the satellite", "X1oMujeqmAI-00316-00088404-00088768": "what it was capturing and how", "X1oMujeqmAI-00317-00088769-00088955": "since the government has understood that", "X1oMujeqmAI-00318-00088956-00089141": "satellites are very very important for", "X1oMujeqmAI-00319-00089142-00089326": "monitoring and evaluation", "X1oMujeqmAI-00320-00089327-00089537": "more and more satellites are in the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00321-00089538-00089915": "pipeline to be launched", "X1oMujeqmAI-00322-00089916-00090226": "so after we get practical experiences in", "X1oMujeqmAI-00323-00090227-00090491": "the weeks 8 to 10 8 9 and 10", "X1oMujeqmAI-00324-00090492-00090803": "specifically", "X1oMujeqmAI-00325-00090804-00091253": "then we go to impact assessment", "X1oMujeqmAI-00326-00091254-00091547": "and new data using remote sensing and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00327-00091548-00091894": "GIS in weeks 11 and 12. parent we will", "X1oMujeqmAI-00328-00091895-00092179": "take a particular scheme for example", "X1oMujeqmAI-00329-00092180-00092531": "iwmp the housing scheme by the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00330-00092532-00092747": "government the rural electrification", "X1oMujeqmAI-00331-00092748-00093023": "schemes eligible mission for water any", "X1oMujeqmAI-00332-00093024-00093191": "scheme we will take", "X1oMujeqmAI-00333-00093192-00093491": "and do a small assessment", "X1oMujeqmAI-00334-00093492-00093823": "the idea is if I am doing example for", "X1oMujeqmAI-00335-00093824-00094325": "trichy in Tamil", "X1oMujeqmAI-00336-00094326-00094517": "so I can take the District boundary and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00337-00094518-00094782": "do the Monterey impact on", "X1oMujeqmAI-00338-00094783-00095015": "the district", "X1oMujeqmAI-00339-00095016-00095332": "another person can come", "X1oMujeqmAI-00340-00095333-00095681": "and do it for a district in", "X1oMujeqmAI-00341-00095682-00095909": "Kashmir", "X1oMujeqmAI-00342-00095910-00096293": "or in Rajasthan", "X1oMujeqmAI-00343-00096294-00096521": "the steps are the same because the data", "X1oMujeqmAI-00344-00096522-00096815": "is for full of Indian", "X1oMujeqmAI-00345-00096816-00096941": "correct", "X1oMujeqmAI-00346-00096942-00097276": "so how do you do these steps in", "X1oMujeqmAI-00347-00097277-00097776": "different methods to come to the same", "X1oMujeqmAI-00348-00097777-00098062": "will be covered in these sections 11 to", "X1oMujeqmAI-00349-00098063-00098429": "12. and we finish the course", "X1oMujeqmAI-00350-00098430-00098693": "but I would like you to continue this", "X1oMujeqmAI-00351-00098694-00098987": "process of understanding rural issues by", "X1oMujeqmAI-00352-00098988-00099232": "going through the circle again", "X1oMujeqmAI-00353-00099233-00099467": "so once you have finished identifying a", "X1oMujeqmAI-00354-00099468-00099600": "rural issue let's say", "X1oMujeqmAI-00355-00099601-00099862": "encroachmentization and you map new", "X1oMujeqmAI-00356-00099863-00100024": "encroachments", "X1oMujeqmAI-00357-00100025-00100318": "then go back again and do more GIS", "X1oMujeqmAI-00358-00100319-00100487": "analysis", "X1oMujeqmAI-00359-00100488-00100756": "and then get better better Maps which", "X1oMujeqmAI-00360-00100757-00100876": "can be", "X1oMujeqmAI-00361-00100877-00101074": "used for your research which can be used", "X1oMujeqmAI-00362-00101075-00101776": "by the government officials Etc", "X1oMujeqmAI-00363-00101777-00101981": "the only thing that is very very", "X1oMujeqmAI-00364-00101982-00102209": "important is is rural issues are very", "X1oMujeqmAI-00365-00102210-00102508": "complex complex in nature because it is", "X1oMujeqmAI-00366-00102509-00102808": "not from one theme one Focus or one", "X1oMujeqmAI-00367-00102809-00103097": "discipline it is multi-disciplinary it", "X1oMujeqmAI-00368-00103098-00103258": "is interdisciplinary and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00369-00103259-00103439": "intra-disciplinary", "X1oMujeqmAI-00370-00103440-00103547": "okay", "X1oMujeqmAI-00371-00103548-00103823": "so some people call it transdisciplinary", "X1oMujeqmAI-00372-00103824-00104008": "also", "X1oMujeqmAI-00373-00104009-00104386": "so my point is please", "X1oMujeqmAI-00374-00104388-00104747": "try to look at", "X1oMujeqmAI-00375-00104748-00105010": "rural issues very carefully", "X1oMujeqmAI-00376-00105011-00105310": "except it is a complex issue", "X1oMujeqmAI-00377-00105311-00105484": "and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00378-00105485-00105827": "somewhere we do need to take holistic", "X1oMujeqmAI-00379-00105828-00106054": "measurements and remote sensing helps", "X1oMujeqmAI-00380-00106055-00106234": "for that", "X1oMujeqmAI-00381-00106235-00106552": "foreign", "X1oMujeqmAI-00382-00106553-00106943": "I would like to rephrase and we assess", "X1oMujeqmAI-00383-00106944-00107195": "the importance of this course by", "X1oMujeqmAI-00384-00107196-00107363": "speaking about the rural development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00385-00107364-00107563": "again", "X1oMujeqmAI-00386-00107564-00107825": "India is still an engineering Nation", "X1oMujeqmAI-00387-00107826-00108065": "excuse me", "X1oMujeqmAI-00388-00108066-00108323": "with approximately 70 percent of", "X1oMujeqmAI-00389-00108324-00108557": "population in rural areas", "X1oMujeqmAI-00390-00108558-00109013": "69 to be more specific", "X1oMujeqmAI-00391-00109014-00109223": "and while Technologies as you could see", "X1oMujeqmAI-00392-00109224-00109367": "there is one person", "X1oMujeqmAI-00393-00109368-00109516": "[Music]", "X1oMujeqmAI-00394-00109517-00109733": "plowing the field using bullet cards and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00395-00109733-00109990": "another person using tractors and small", "X1oMujeqmAI-00396-00109991-00110140": "tractors", "X1oMujeqmAI-00397-00110141-00110260": "still", "X1oMujeqmAI-00398-00110261-00110477": "technology has not been", "X1oMujeqmAI-00399-00110478-00111065": "taken down to the rural areas evenly", "X1oMujeqmAI-00400-00111066-00111334": "there are a lot of issues and it is", "X1oMujeqmAI-00401-00111335-00111521": "complex", "X1oMujeqmAI-00402-00111522-00112001": "a lot of governments leaders", "X1oMujeqmAI-00403-00112002-00112199": "have understood that rural development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00404-00112200-00112721": "is key to National growth we cannot grow", "X1oMujeqmAI-00405-00112722-00113027": "just cities", "X1oMujeqmAI-00406-00113028-00113284": "living rule raises behind think about", "X1oMujeqmAI-00407-00113285-00113410": "your body", "X1oMujeqmAI-00408-00113411-00113573": "if you're working out", "X1oMujeqmAI-00409-00113574-00113740": "and exercising", "X1oMujeqmAI-00410-00113741-00114034": "you want the entire body to grow evenly", "X1oMujeqmAI-00411-00114035-00114251": "if one hand grows and the other hand is", "X1oMujeqmAI-00412-00114252-00114473": "very weak it is not good for your body", "X1oMujeqmAI-00413-00114474-00114881": "same thing the nation is one unit", "X1oMujeqmAI-00414-00114882-00115204": "we need to look at all", "X1oMujeqmAI-00415-00115205-00115504": "population with the same lens and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00416-00115505-00115708": "everyone has to double so", "X1oMujeqmAI-00417-00115709-00116008": "more important sustainably", "X1oMujeqmAI-00418-00116009-00116195": "rural development is important for", "X1oMujeqmAI-00419-00116196-00116543": "economic betterment of people", "X1oMujeqmAI-00420-00116544-00116747": "we need to understand this more", "X1oMujeqmAI-00421-00116748-00116969": "carefully in terms of", "X1oMujeqmAI-00422-00116970-00117239": "economics also", "X1oMujeqmAI-00423-00117240-00117497": "development doesn't just mean you are", "X1oMujeqmAI-00424-00117498-00117754": "growing more crops you have water access", "X1oMujeqmAI-00425-00117755-00118025": "Etc but is it converting to a profit for", "X1oMujeqmAI-00426-00118026-00118336": "the farmers Green Revolution has", "X1oMujeqmAI-00427-00118338-00118601": "increased the crop production in India", "X1oMujeqmAI-00428-00118602-00118786": "however", "X1oMujeqmAI-00429-00118788-00119134": "the farmers still", "X1oMujeqmAI-00430-00119135-00119416": "are not getting the due credit or due", "X1oMujeqmAI-00431-00119417-00119633": "profit", "X1oMujeqmAI-00432-00119633-00119849": "which requires more social", "X1oMujeqmAI-00433-00119850-00120208": "transformation", "X1oMujeqmAI-00434-00120209-00120425": "many stressors exist it is a complex", "X1oMujeqmAI-00435-00120426-00120581": "system", "X1oMujeqmAI-00436-00120582-00120731": "just water is not enough for", "X1oMujeqmAI-00437-00120732-00120965": "agricultural productivity just soil", "X1oMujeqmAI-00438-00120966-00121090": "fertility is not enough there are", "X1oMujeqmAI-00439-00121091-00121469": "multiple multiple other things", "X1oMujeqmAI-00440-00121470-00121660": "and that is why the ministry has been", "X1oMujeqmAI-00441-00121661-00121973": "created with multiple sub teams", "X1oMujeqmAI-00442-00121974-00122243": "increase participation is needed the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00443-00122244-00122495": "government can monitor but it also needs", "X1oMujeqmAI-00444-00122496-00122710": "monitoring from us the public who are", "X1oMujeqmAI-00445-00122711-00122999": "using the food from our farmers", "X1oMujeqmAI-00446-00123000-00123221": "and this course can give you some", "X1oMujeqmAI-00447-00123222-00123569": "aspects on how to create these kind of", "X1oMujeqmAI-00448-00123570-00123713": "data", "X1oMujeqmAI-00449-00123714-00123893": "government agency for Rural Development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00450-00123894-00124097": "has been started", "X1oMujeqmAI-00451-00124098-00124283": "currently it is called the ministry of", "X1oMujeqmAI-00452-00124283-00124558": "rural development however it's Saturday", "X1oMujeqmAI-00453-00124559-00124793": "1974 in different names", "X1oMujeqmAI-00454-00124794-00124954": "and has become", "X1oMujeqmAI-00455-00124955-00125297": "1899", "X1oMujeqmAI-00456-00125298-00125590": "why the names have changed because of", "X1oMujeqmAI-00457-00125591-00125807": "the Mandate and the Mandate has to", "X1oMujeqmAI-00458-00125808-00126113": "reflect in the name", "X1oMujeqmAI-00459-00126114-00126281": "because rural development is", "X1oMujeqmAI-00460-00126282-00126665": "multidisciplinary and complex it needs", "X1oMujeqmAI-00461-00126666-00126995": "cross-cutting theme capacities", "X1oMujeqmAI-00462-00126996-00127186": "people who are well versed in", "X1oMujeqmAI-00463-00127188-00127384": "agriculture needs to talk about rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00464-00127385-00127571": "development same as ecosystem and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00465-00127572-00127697": "livelihoods", "X1oMujeqmAI-00466-00127698-00127990": "domestic use and climate change", "X1oMujeqmAI-00467-00127991-00128231": "if we leave the people behind and just", "X1oMujeqmAI-00468-00128232-00128531": "focus on agriculture then all", "X1oMujeqmAI-00469-00128532-00128801": "development will not happen same way if", "X1oMujeqmAI-00470-00128802-00129119": "we ignore climate change and think that", "X1oMujeqmAI-00471-00129120-00129328": "water is enough for agriculture and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00472-00129329-00129707": "domestic use we will get caught", "X1oMujeqmAI-00473-00129708-00130025": "so all of this the major things I've", "X1oMujeqmAI-00474-00130026-00130313": "captured here is important for Rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00475-00130314-00130595": "Development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00476-00130596-00130733": "there are many", "X1oMujeqmAI-00477-00130733-00130919": "security issues for Rural Development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00478-00130920-00131128": "and for the nation", "X1oMujeqmAI-00479-00131129-00131278": "so", "X1oMujeqmAI-00480-00131279-00131489": "when I say some", "X1oMujeqmAI-00481-00131490-00131921": "security issues are there for rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00482-00131922-00132299": "entities it will definitely reflect on", "X1oMujeqmAI-00483-00132300-00132647": "the entire community of the nation", "X1oMujeqmAI-00484-00132648-00132943": "because", "X1oMujeqmAI-00485-00132944-00133343": "plural supports Urban systems", "X1oMujeqmAI-00486-00133344-00133571": "all these security issues the major", "X1oMujeqmAI-00487-00133572-00133823": "major ones are water", "X1oMujeqmAI-00488-00133824-00134207": "security", "X1oMujeqmAI-00489-00134208-00134471": "and food security", "X1oMujeqmAI-00490-00134472-00134677": "still most of the Cities get water from", "X1oMujeqmAI-00491-00134678-00135190": "rural regions through tankers and Etc", "X1oMujeqmAI-00492-00135191-00135473": "what does water security mean is there", "X1oMujeqmAI-00493-00135474-00135778": "good water and enough water for drinking", "X1oMujeqmAI-00494-00135779-00136025": "in human well-being", "X1oMujeqmAI-00495-00136026-00136373": "well-being is Sanitation", "X1oMujeqmAI-00496-00136374-00136727": "Evolution bathing Etc", "X1oMujeqmAI-00497-00136728-00136966": "and then is there enough water for our", "X1oMujeqmAI-00498-00136967-00137345": "ecosystem Forest Rivers Aquatic Life", "X1oMujeqmAI-00499-00137346-00137633": "insects birds every everything because", "X1oMujeqmAI-00500-00137634-00138209": "all this is tied back to the agriculture", "X1oMujeqmAI-00501-00138210-00138490": "you need birds for dispersing seeds you", "X1oMujeqmAI-00502-00138491-00138827": "need animals to control", "X1oMujeqmAI-00503-00138828-00139031": "the pest", "X1oMujeqmAI-00504-00139032-00139264": "so everything is tied together so if you", "X1oMujeqmAI-00505-00139265-00139487": "just focus on drinking water and human", "X1oMujeqmAI-00506-00139488-00139666": "well-being and take all the water from", "X1oMujeqmAI-00507-00139667-00139937": "forest it will backfire so that's what", "X1oMujeqmAI-00508-00139938-00140128": "this even water", "X1oMujeqmAI-00509-00140129-00140549": "report clearly mentions", "X1oMujeqmAI-00510-00140550-00141016": "and are there water related hazards and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00511-00141017-00141316": "accounted for during climate change", "X1oMujeqmAI-00512-00141317-00141604": "and mitigation adaptation plans", "X1oMujeqmAI-00513-00141605-00141863": "developed", "X1oMujeqmAI-00514-00141864-00142066": "for example if the coastal regions are", "X1oMujeqmAI-00515-00142067-00142295": "flooding do we have the infrastructure", "X1oMujeqmAI-00516-00142296-00142913": "to relocate them during these extremes", "X1oMujeqmAI-00517-00142914-00143104": "and the final thing which is also", "X1oMujeqmAI-00518-00143105-00143363": "important is is there enough water for", "X1oMujeqmAI-00519-00143364-00143561": "holistic economic activities and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00520-00143562-00143813": "development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00521-00143814-00144119": "which takes together your agriculture", "X1oMujeqmAI-00522-00144120-00144359": "livelihood aquaculture those kind of", "X1oMujeqmAI-00523-00144360-00144701": "aspects so water security is key", "X1oMujeqmAI-00524-00144702-00144977": "this can be broadly for urban and rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00525-00144978-00145169": "systems but if you look very closely it", "X1oMujeqmAI-00526-00145170-00145366": "is mostly for Rural systems which", "X1oMujeqmAI-00527-00145367-00145577": "support Urban systems", "X1oMujeqmAI-00528-00145578-00145823": "then film security food is mostly grown", "X1oMujeqmAI-00529-00145824-00146111": "in at least in our country most of the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00530-00146112-00146387": "food is only grown in rural regions", "X1oMujeqmAI-00531-00146388-00146687": "some vertical farming some Urban farming", "X1oMujeqmAI-00532-00146688-00146914": "is there but it is not enough the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00533-00146915-00147197": "population is still high and our rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00534-00147198-00147473": "economies have to provide it", "X1oMujeqmAI-00535-00147474-00147761": "so is there enough food for emergency", "X1oMujeqmAI-00536-00147762-00148001": "remember we did have", "X1oMujeqmAI-00537-00148002-00148277": "four issues scarcity issues relation", "X1oMujeqmAI-00538-00148278-00148397": "issues", "X1oMujeqmAI-00539-00148398-00148625": "before the 1960s", "X1oMujeqmAI-00540-00148626-00148828": "and the Green Revolution has", "X1oMujeqmAI-00541-00148829-00149231": "tremendously pulled us out of this issue", "X1oMujeqmAI-00542-00149232-00149471": "now we need to", "X1oMujeqmAI-00543-00149472-00149777": "make sure it is sustainable", "X1oMujeqmAI-00544-00149778-00150047": "Child Nutrition is very important are we", "X1oMujeqmAI-00545-00150048-00150287": "feeding the correct food the nutritious", "X1oMujeqmAI-00546-00150288-00150509": "food for children who are the next", "X1oMujeqmAI-00547-00150510-00150875": "leaders Future Leaders of the country", "X1oMujeqmAI-00548-00150876-00151090": "are the capacities being built for", "X1oMujeqmAI-00549-00151091-00151199": "farmers", "X1oMujeqmAI-00550-00151200-00151451": "youth education addressed and food", "X1oMujeqmAI-00551-00151452-00151859": "security are cheap", "X1oMujeqmAI-00552-00151860-00152057": "we also looked at where remote sensing", "X1oMujeqmAI-00553-00152058-00152459": "can be used as a data tool", "X1oMujeqmAI-00554-00152460-00152699": "along with water and food security we", "X1oMujeqmAI-00555-00152700-00152885": "also looked at removal development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00556-00152886-00153204": "infrastructures such as housing schools", "X1oMujeqmAI-00557-00153205-00153640": "hospitals roads and connectivity", "X1oMujeqmAI-00558-00153641-00153802": "why", "X1oMujeqmAI-00559-00153803-00154085": "roads differ from connectivity is here", "X1oMujeqmAI-00560-00154086-00154247": "it is mostly the internet connectivity", "X1oMujeqmAI-00561-00154248-00154751": "mobile network connectivity", "X1oMujeqmAI-00562-00154752-00154997": "and there are multiple schemes that the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00563-00154998-00155201": "government is working on in addressing", "X1oMujeqmAI-00564-00155202-00155440": "all of this which I have captured in the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00565-00155441-00155590": "next slide", "X1oMujeqmAI-00566-00155591-00155795": "if you look at this slide that we", "X1oMujeqmAI-00567-00155796-00155951": "discussed", "X1oMujeqmAI-00568-00155952-00156161": "we clearly mentioned", "X1oMujeqmAI-00569-00156162-00156545": "where the government", "X1oMujeqmAI-00570-00156546-00156773": "focuses on under the minister of rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00571-00156774-00156952": "development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00572-00156953-00157276": "you could see all the different schemes", "X1oMujeqmAI-00573-00157277-00157559": "that are given below which type back to", "X1oMujeqmAI-00574-00157560-00157811": "this slide housing schools hospitals", "X1oMujeqmAI-00575-00157812-00158243": "roles and connectivity", "X1oMujeqmAI-00576-00158244-00158543": "one other thing that is highly connected", "X1oMujeqmAI-00577-00158544-00158909": "for rural development is the labor", "X1oMujeqmAI-00578-00158910-00159383": "market which is given by the montrega", "X1oMujeqmAI-00579-00159384-00159743": "scheme", "X1oMujeqmAI-00580-00159744-00160001": "what we plan on my research plans to do", "X1oMujeqmAI-00581-00160002-00160493": "more is yes mandrega gives", "X1oMujeqmAI-00582-00160494-00160876": "100 days employment guarantee for Rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00583-00160877-00161075": "population", "X1oMujeqmAI-00584-00161076-00161363": "how can it be used for water and food", "X1oMujeqmAI-00585-00161364-00161483": "security", "X1oMujeqmAI-00586-00161484-00161687": "building roads is a different department", "X1oMujeqmAI-00587-00161688-00161837": "but at least", "X1oMujeqmAI-00588-00161838-00162071": "water and food security", "X1oMujeqmAI-00589-00162072-00162214": "can be", "X1oMujeqmAI-00590-00162215-00162581": "clubbed with the mantrika program", "X1oMujeqmAI-00591-00162582-00162790": "so when you look at these programs in", "X1oMujeqmAI-00592-00162791-00162923": "isolation", "X1oMujeqmAI-00593-00162924-00163187": "make sure that you understand that each", "X1oMujeqmAI-00594-00163188-00163552": "program has its own mandate however", "X1oMujeqmAI-00595-00163553-00163781": "there is cross cutting", "X1oMujeqmAI-00596-00163782-00164093": "teams also so mandrega work can also", "X1oMujeqmAI-00597-00164094-00164273": "slip into", "X1oMujeqmAI-00598-00164274-00164764": "the road work D2 ddu gky or rule one", "X1oMujeqmAI-00599-00164765-00164933": "word", "X1oMujeqmAI-00600-00164934-00165281": "and most importantly to the iwmp the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00601-00165282-00165790": "water management programs", "X1oMujeqmAI-00602-00165791-00166007": "so to achieve this the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00603-00166008-00166313": "Ministry has set up many schemes", "X1oMujeqmAI-00604-00166314-00166571": "however there are separate Ministries", "X1oMujeqmAI-00605-00166572-00166733": "also that are related to rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00606-00166734-00166889": "development and we did have a look at", "X1oMujeqmAI-00607-00166890-00166993": "these", "X1oMujeqmAI-00608-00166994-00167254": "various Ministries", "X1oMujeqmAI-00609-00167255-00167404": "starting from Ministry of rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00610-00167405-00167566": "development that we saw in the previous", "X1oMujeqmAI-00611-00167567-00167764": "slide there is Ministry of Health and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00612-00167765-00168007": "Family welfare for the entire nation", "X1oMujeqmAI-00613-00168008-00168545": "with more Focus or very", "X1oMujeqmAI-00614-00168546-00168701": "interesting", "X1oMujeqmAI-00615-00168702-00168904": "and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00616-00168905-00169397": "specific focus on Rural entities because", "X1oMujeqmAI-00617-00169398-00169685": "in cities even the government invest or", "X1oMujeqmAI-00618-00169686-00169859": "not", "X1oMujeqmAI-00619-00169860-00170195": "population have the bandwidth and", "X1oMujeqmAI-00620-00170196-00170357": "economic power", "X1oMujeqmAI-00621-00170358-00170590": "to take private", "X1oMujeqmAI-00622-00170591-00170873": "medical facilities let's say for example", "X1oMujeqmAI-00623-00170874-00171101": "vaccination", "X1oMujeqmAI-00624-00171102-00171395": "in iits we did bring vaccination and it", "X1oMujeqmAI-00625-00171396-00171569": "was given to", "X1oMujeqmAI-00626-00171570-00171911": "everyone at a cost", "X1oMujeqmAI-00627-00171912-00172295": "outside the government was doing free", "X1oMujeqmAI-00628-00172296-00172589": "Services also", "X1oMujeqmAI-00629-00172590-00172781": "so there are two choices you can go to", "X1oMujeqmAI-00630-00172782-00172966": "private you can go to", "X1oMujeqmAI-00631-00172967-00173290": "government schemes", "X1oMujeqmAI-00632-00173291-00173519": "in rural it is only government schemes", "X1oMujeqmAI-00633-00173520-00173752": "you do not expect a private hospital to", "X1oMujeqmAI-00634-00173753-00173945": "come and provide these kind of", "X1oMujeqmAI-00635-00173946-00174304": "life-saving vaccinations", "X1oMujeqmAI-00636-00174305-00174551": "so that is where I said this Ministry of", "X1oMujeqmAI-00637-00174552-00174797": "Health and Family River has a big focus", "X1oMujeqmAI-00638-00174798-00174971": "on Rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00639-00174972-00175283": "so there is some overlaps some synergies", "X1oMujeqmAI-00640-00175284-00175426": "that can be built", "X1oMujeqmAI-00641-00175427-00175649": "Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs", "X1oMujeqmAI-00642-00175650-00175978": "yes it is housing and within the housing", "X1oMujeqmAI-00643-00175979-00176297": "you can have rural also register of Home", "X1oMujeqmAI-00644-00176298-00176416": "affairs", "X1oMujeqmAI-00645-00176417-00176616": "minister of personal and public", "X1oMujeqmAI-00646-00176617-00176938": "reliances Ministry of environment forest", "X1oMujeqmAI-00647-00176939-00177214": "and climate change this is very very", "X1oMujeqmAI-00648-00177215-00177449": "focused to rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00649-00177450-00177838": "because environment", "X1oMujeqmAI-00650-00177839-00178157": "and Forest are mostly along the rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00651-00178158-00178288": "entities", "X1oMujeqmAI-00652-00178289-00178511": "and climate change affects these rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00653-00178512-00178685": "entities mostly", "X1oMujeqmAI-00654-00178686-00179116": "let's say Mumbai floods if Mumbai floods", "X1oMujeqmAI-00655-00179117-00179369": "the people living in the low-lying areas", "X1oMujeqmAI-00656-00179370-00179945": "house water may enter", "X1oMujeqmAI-00657-00179946-00180154": "most of them are living in flats and if", "X1oMujeqmAI-00658-00180155-00180316": "you go to the flats you'll see Stills", "X1oMujeqmAI-00659-00180317-00180538": "right so the bottom floor is only cars", "X1oMujeqmAI-00660-00180539-00180802": "cars get inundated but people still go", "X1oMujeqmAI-00661-00180803-00181163": "up in the lift and stairs and they are", "X1oMujeqmAI-00662-00181164-00181535": "safe whereas in rural areas the house is", "X1oMujeqmAI-00663-00181536-00182099": "washed away mud houses", "X1oMujeqmAI-00664-00182100-00182357": "so that is where climate change as I'm", "X1oMujeqmAI-00665-00182358-00182633": "saying is more focused in addition", "X1oMujeqmAI-00666-00182634-00182945": "climate change affects crops which is", "X1oMujeqmAI-00667-00182946-00183143": "the livelihood so when there's a flood", "X1oMujeqmAI-00668-00183144-00183311": "you can still work on your laptop in a", "X1oMujeqmAI-00669-00183312-00183581": "city you can still take classes", "X1oMujeqmAI-00670-00183582-00183947": "but a farmer when a flood comes entire", "X1oMujeqmAI-00671-00183948-00184204": "crop is lost when a drought comes entire", "X1oMujeqmAI-00672-00184205-00184337": "crop is lost", "X1oMujeqmAI-00673-00184338-00184475": "so", "X1oMujeqmAI-00674-00184476-00184702": "this ministry has a lot of focus on", "X1oMujeqmAI-00675-00184703-00184876": "Rural Development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00676-00184877-00185069": "and finally yes the minister of", "X1oMujeqmAI-00677-00185070-00185321": "Agriculture and Farmers welfare very", "X1oMujeqmAI-00678-00185322-00185537": "very focused on agriculture whereas the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00679-00185538-00185645": "minister of rural development has", "X1oMujeqmAI-00680-00185646-00186107": "agriculture water multiple multiple", "X1oMujeqmAI-00681-00186108-00186502": "schemes", "X1oMujeqmAI-00682-00186503-00186763": "so this", "X1oMujeqmAI-00683-00186764-00187240": "re-assesses or reiterates my point that", "X1oMujeqmAI-00684-00187241-00187487": "the government is very focused on Rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00685-00187488-00187666": "Development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00686-00187667-00187907": "it has one just for Ministry of rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00687-00187908-00188152": "development but multiple Ministries that", "X1oMujeqmAI-00688-00188153-00188566": "also cater to rural development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00689-00188567-00188795": "multiple schemes exist that's what we", "X1oMujeqmAI-00690-00188796-00189023": "mentioned and we saw and the government", "X1oMujeqmAI-00691-00189024-00189281": "wants feedback on how these schemes work", "X1oMujeqmAI-00692-00189282-00189557": "and how how can they improve it however", "X1oMujeqmAI-00693-00189558-00189826": "there are data issues", "X1oMujeqmAI-00694-00189827-00190366": "which limit or may limit the efficiency", "X1oMujeqmAI-00695-00190367-00190619": "let's say the school example I gave in", "X1oMujeqmAI-00696-00190620-00190961": "the last lecture", "X1oMujeqmAI-00697-00190962-00191128": "the government has built schools in", "X1oMujeqmAI-00698-00191129-00191476": "Japan however it is an excess", "X1oMujeqmAI-00699-00191477-00191740": "so now the efficiency of the school is", "X1oMujeqmAI-00700-00191741-00191993": "compromised", "X1oMujeqmAI-00701-00191994-00192166": "would you run a school for just two", "X1oMujeqmAI-00702-00192167-00192269": "students", "X1oMujeqmAI-00703-00192270-00192533": "if is it", "X1oMujeqmAI-00704-00192534-00192838": "easier for them to arrange a bus to", "X1oMujeqmAI-00705-00192839-00193073": "bring the student to one Century Located", "X1oMujeqmAI-00706-00193074-00193343": "School", "X1oMujeqmAI-00707-00193344-00193559": "the cost of a bus is definitely cheaper", "X1oMujeqmAI-00708-00193560-00193883": "than running a school", "X1oMujeqmAI-00709-00193884-00194261": "or placing the new school in between the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00710-00194262-00194537": "villages so that all Villages commute", "X1oMujeqmAI-00711-00194538-00194723": "less time to come to the school so these", "X1oMujeqmAI-00712-00194724-00194849": "kind of things", "X1oMujeqmAI-00713-00194850-00195304": "are needed to improve the efficiency", "X1oMujeqmAI-00714-00195305-00195575": "and that is what we will cover in this", "X1oMujeqmAI-00715-00195576-00195797": "course", "X1oMujeqmAI-00716-00195798-00196061": "we saw that data is an issue and for the", "X1oMujeqmAI-00717-00196062-00196390": "data issues we looked at remote sensing", "X1oMujeqmAI-00718-00196391-00196559": "where remote sensing is a very", "X1oMujeqmAI-00719-00196560-00196871": "multidisciplinary approach", "X1oMujeqmAI-00720-00196872-00197063": "remote sensing ngis are used in", "X1oMujeqmAI-00721-00197064-00197338": "biography physical geography social", "X1oMujeqmAI-00722-00197339-00197669": "geography and there's a lot of overlaps", "X1oMujeqmAI-00723-00197670-00197837": "so that is why we always use remote", "X1oMujeqmAI-00724-00197838-00198137": "sensing and GIS together cartography is", "X1oMujeqmAI-00725-00198138-00198431": "the science of making Maps it could be", "X1oMujeqmAI-00726-00198432-00198773": "made digitally then becomes GIS or on", "X1oMujeqmAI-00727-00198774-00199090": "papers and Maps like you find wall Maps", "X1oMujeqmAI-00728-00199091-00199450": "hanging so that is totally done through", "X1oMujeqmAI-00729-00199451-00199709": "surveys and stuff so we will focus on", "X1oMujeqmAI-00730-00199710-00200254": "the remote sensing and CIS", "X1oMujeqmAI-00731-00200255-00200543": "many resources to understand Basics are", "X1oMujeqmAI-00732-00200544-00200752": "remote sensing are there", "X1oMujeqmAI-00733-00200753-00200945": "I've clearly mentioned that this course", "X1oMujeqmAI-00734-00200946-00201166": "will not be able to", "X1oMujeqmAI-00735-00201167-00201466": "fully introduce remote sensing ngis", "X1oMujeqmAI-00736-00201467-00201707": "because these two are separate courses", "X1oMujeqmAI-00737-00201708-00201928": "by themselves here it will be applied", "X1oMujeqmAI-00738-00201929-00202228": "for Rural Development", "X1oMujeqmAI-00739-00202229-00202450": "I've given you links on how to learn", "X1oMujeqmAI-00740-00202451-00202787": "these softwares and also GIS", "X1oMujeqmAI-00741-00202788-00202990": "please go through it we will go through", "X1oMujeqmAI-00742-00202991-00203285": "three weeks of basic introduction again", "X1oMujeqmAI-00743-00203286-00203488": "because I will introduce some topics", "X1oMujeqmAI-00744-00203489-00203638": "that are very focused for Rural", "X1oMujeqmAI-00745-00203639-00203933": "Development so you can take my", "X1oMujeqmAI-00746-00203934-00204190": "introduction again but there are", "X1oMujeqmAI-00747-00204191-00204400": "multiple full nptel courses on", "X1oMujeqmAI-00748-00204401-00204611": "promotions and GIS", "X1oMujeqmAI-00749-00204612-00204778": "which I've given links and there's", "X1oMujeqmAI-00750-00204779-00205048": "always new courses come here", "X1oMujeqmAI-00751-00205050-00205264": "with this I would like to conclude week", "X1oMujeqmAI-00752-00205265-00205438": "one and week two", "X1oMujeqmAI-00753-00205439-00205673": "I will see you in week three", "X1oMujeqmAI-00754-00205673-00205802": "thank you", "X1oMujeqmAI-00755-00205803-00207316": "[Music]", "X1oMujeqmAI-00756-00207317-00208761": "[Applause]", "X1oMujeqmAI-00757-00208762-00209248": "[Applause]", "X1oMujeqmAI-00758-00209250-00209550": "foreign"}}, {"audio_id": "X1rF12X0f1M", "text": {"X1rF12X0f1M-00000-00000150-00000478": "hello everybody uh it's Dr Rick dropping", "X1rF12X0f1M-00001-00000479-00000857": "in on you hope everybody is as I always", "X1rF12X0f1M-00002-00000858-00001097": "say having a good day got in the middle", "X1rF12X0f1M-00003-00001098-00001397": "of a great week you know", "X1rF12X0f1M-00004-00001398-00001558": "you know before I get started I want to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00005-00001559-00001763": "remind you that we are in the middle of", "X1rF12X0f1M-00006-00001764-00001984": "a fundraising for the organization and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00007-00001985-00002237": "for black men lead which is a rite of", "X1rF12X0f1M-00008-00002238-00002549": "passage initiative coupled with", "X1rF12X0f1M-00009-00002550-00002902": "wraparound services for young black boys", "X1rF12X0f1M-00010-00002903-00003184": "and young black men", "X1rF12X0f1M-00011-00003185-00003335": "um", "X1rF12X0f1M-00012-00003336-00003665": "the organization as a whole is always in", "X1rF12X0f1M-00013-00003665-00003917": "the middle of a fundraiser but uh we", "X1rF12X0f1M-00014-00003918-00004085": "definitely need your support up I want", "X1rF12X0f1M-00015-00004086-00004253": "to talk to you", "X1rF12X0f1M-00016-00004254-00004397": "about something I'm passionate about", "X1rF12X0f1M-00017-00004398-00004570": "within the veins of", "X1rF12X0f1M-00018-00004571-00004775": "this whole fundraiser thing but not a", "X1rF12X0f1M-00019-00004776-00004961": "directly associated with it I want to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00020-00004962-00005122": "talk to you about Behavior I want to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00021-00005123-00005302": "talk to you about the current state of", "X1rF12X0f1M-00022-00005303-00005459": "affairs in the black community I want to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00023-00005460-00005591": "talk to you about the behavior of young", "X1rF12X0f1M-00024-00005592-00005861": "black boys young black girls and why we", "X1rF12X0f1M-00025-00005862-00006136": "are losing in every statistical category", "X1rF12X0f1M-00026-00006137-00006448": "uh when you measure socio-economic uh", "X1rF12X0f1M-00027-00006450-00006605": "positioning we're at the Bottom Rung of", "X1rF12X0f1M-00028-00006606-00006839": "the social economic ladder consistently", "X1rF12X0f1M-00029-00006840-00007037": "and there's a reason for it it's not", "X1rF12X0f1M-00030-00007038-00007348": "because we aren't capable despite all", "X1rF12X0f1M-00031-00007350-00007445": "the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00032-00007445-00007714": "media push to suggest that we are", "X1rF12X0f1M-00033-00007715-00007877": "inherently lazy it's definitely not", "X1rF12X0f1M-00034-00007878-00008141": "because we are lazy uh this country was", "X1rF12X0f1M-00035-00008142-00008392": "built on our backs we have a different", "X1rF12X0f1M-00036-00008393-00008645": "perspective of work because of that", "X1rF12X0f1M-00037-00008646-00008903": "experience and how our mindset about", "X1rF12X0f1M-00038-00008904-00009124": "working has passed down through", "X1rF12X0f1M-00039-00009125-00009287": "generations I don't have time to get", "X1rF12X0f1M-00040-00009288-00009496": "into it but I've written about it in", "X1rF12X0f1M-00041-00009497-00009803": "depth uh what I want to talk about is we", "X1rF12X0f1M-00042-00009804-00010006": "love to lay mad about", "X1rF12X0f1M-00043-00010007-00010264": "what black men are doing wrong we love", "X1rF12X0f1M-00044-00010265-00010588": "the Layman about the atrocities that we", "X1rF12X0f1M-00045-00010589-00010769": "see", "X1rF12X0f1M-00046-00010770-00011092": "I don't know if the person who shot the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00047-00011093-00011321": "uh worker in McDonald's in Bedford", "X1rF12X0f1M-00048-00011322-00011656": "Stafford better Bedford Stuyvesant uh", "X1rF12X0f1M-00049-00011657-00011903": "Brooklyn in Bed-Stuy I don't know if", "X1rF12X0f1M-00050-00011904-00012220": "that was a black person but it falls all", "X1rF12X0f1M-00051-00012221-00012395": "in the vein of the way that young black", "X1rF12X0f1M-00052-00012396-00012592": "young black people are behaving but I", "X1rF12X0f1M-00053-00012593-00012952": "know that we lost a prominent Pastor who", "X1rF12X0f1M-00054-00012953-00013199": "I knew personally extremely personally I", "X1rF12X0f1M-00055-00013200-00013415": "work with his young Sons when they were", "X1rF12X0f1M-00056-00013416-00013594": "moving up one of them actually made it", "X1rF12X0f1M-00057-00013595-00013780": "uh", "X1rF12X0f1M-00058-00013781-00014038": "to the NFL", "X1rF12X0f1M-00059-00014040-00014386": "my brother was his minister of music for", "X1rF12X0f1M-00060-00014387-00014533": "a couple of years", "X1rF12X0f1M-00061-00014534-00014879": "my nephew my brother son was his drummer", "X1rF12X0f1M-00062-00014880-00015077": "for a while I don't know if that's still", "X1rF12X0f1M-00063-00015078-00015347": "in but", "X1rF12X0f1M-00064-00015347-00015647": "young black Uber driver decided that he", "X1rF12X0f1M-00065-00015647-00015791": "pulled out of the car wash too", "X1rF12X0f1M-00066-00015791-00016150": "recklessly or too fast killed him", "X1rF12X0f1M-00067-00016151-00016457": "uh", "X1rF12X0f1M-00068-00016458-00016733": "two young girls in Atlanta put too much", "X1rF12X0f1M-00069-00016734-00016900": "mayonnaise and not enough mayonnaise or", "X1rF12X0f1M-00070-00016901-00017086": "something like that on the sandwich", "X1rF12X0f1M-00071-00017087-00017321": "both of them shot", "X1rF12X0f1M-00072-00017322-00017572": "one of them died", "X1rF12X0f1M-00073-00017573-00017741": "um", "X1rF12X0f1M-00074-00017742-00018053": "[Music]", "X1rF12X0f1M-00075-00018054-00018364": "a delivery driver indexed I killed", "X1rF12X0f1M-00076-00018365-00018575": "because it wasn't any Duck Sauce in the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00077-00018576-00018880": "package", "X1rF12X0f1M-00078-00018881-00019211": "not to mention all of the fracture side", "X1rF12X0f1M-00079-00019212-00019385": "that's us killing us", "X1rF12X0f1M-00080-00019386-00019691": "now I'm not one to push the black on", "X1rF12X0f1M-00081-00019692-00019967": "black crime narrative because", "X1rF12X0f1M-00082-00019968-00020333": "it's a construct created to present a", "X1rF12X0f1M-00083-00020334-00020675": "false uh a false reality the false", "X1rF12X0f1M-00084-00020676-00020891": "reality is that blacks", "X1rF12X0f1M-00085-00020892-00021197": "inherently more violent it's not that", "X1rF12X0f1M-00086-00021198-00021472": "there is a situations where blacks are", "X1rF12X0f1M-00087-00021473-00021700": "committing violence acts against blacks", "X1rF12X0f1M-00088-00021701-00021899": "we know that to be true but we also know", "X1rF12X0f1M-00089-00021900-00022133": "that proximity plays a role in that if", "X1rF12X0f1M-00090-00022134-00022361": "we were to examine for instance", "X1rF12X0f1M-00091-00022362-00022589": "a white population we will find that 84", "X1rF12X0f1M-00092-00022590-00022727": "percent of the murders are within the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00093-00022728-00022883": "white population are created by", "X1rF12X0f1M-00094-00022884-00023183": "committed by what white people simply", "X1rF12X0f1M-00095-00023184-00023442": "because you tend to uh", "X1rF12X0f1M-00096-00023443-00023699": "perpetuate Crimes of Passion around", "X1rF12X0f1M-00097-00023700-00023903": "people you tend to be around a lot and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00098-00023904-00024100": "know so", "X1rF12X0f1M-00099-00024101-00024311": "proximity plays a lot of the road in", "X1rF12X0f1M-00100-00024312-00024599": "that but we still have an issue uh the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00101-00024600-00024863": "lack of valuation of human life the lack", "X1rF12X0f1M-00102-00024864-00025078": "of a sense of purpose a lack of a sense", "X1rF12X0f1M-00103-00025079-00025319": "of direction a lack of an understanding", "X1rF12X0f1M-00104-00025320-00025535": "of where we belong and fit in this world", "X1rF12X0f1M-00105-00025536-00025696": "and it's so important especially to the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00106-00025697-00025974": "black male mind uh", "X1rF12X0f1M-00107-00025975-00026296": "females their brain their brains move", "X1rF12X0f1M-00108-00026297-00026507": "from left to right as men our brains", "X1rF12X0f1M-00109-00026508-00026758": "move move from front to back why is that", "X1rF12X0f1M-00110-00026760-00027112": "important females tend to function off", "X1rF12X0f1M-00111-00027113-00027389": "of an emotional awareness a sense of", "X1rF12X0f1M-00112-00027389-00027695": "spiritual intuition how they feel about", "X1rF12X0f1M-00113-00027695-00028079": "things men we operate on a sense of", "X1rF12X0f1M-00114-00028080-00028307": "identity and it's heavily associated", "X1rF12X0f1M-00115-00028308-00028564": "with opposition in the world what we do", "X1rF12X0f1M-00116-00028566-00028852": "with our hands what we accomplish in our", "X1rF12X0f1M-00117-00028854-00029129": "lives our accomplishments are closely", "X1rF12X0f1M-00118-00029130-00029393": "tied to our identity so when there", "X1rF12X0f1M-00119-00029394-00029711": "aren't direct and immediate access and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00120-00029712-00029939": "Pathways to certain levels of", "X1rF12X0f1M-00121-00029939-00030281": "accomplishment we start to experience", "X1rF12X0f1M-00122-00030282-00030485": "a depreciation of self-value", "X1rF12X0f1M-00123-00030486-00030646": "appreciation a depreciation of", "X1rF12X0f1M-00124-00030647-00030911": "self-worth we start to question how we", "X1rF12X0f1M-00125-00030912-00031151": "fit in where we're at we start to give", "X1rF12X0f1M-00126-00031152-00031493": "those who have a pathway and tend to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00127-00031494-00031685": "appear more successful more frequently", "X1rF12X0f1M-00128-00031686-00031973": "and more consistently a sense of higher", "X1rF12X0f1M-00129-00031974-00032207": "standing not understanding that the past", "X1rF12X0f1M-00130-00032208-00032446": "were different the access was different", "X1rF12X0f1M-00131-00032447-00032771": "that is an inequity involved and there", "X1rF12X0f1M-00132-00032772-00033011": "is a lack of a sense of identity we", "X1rF12X0f1M-00133-00033012-00033202": "don't control the past not at this point", "X1rF12X0f1M-00134-00033203-00033551": "because we have not developed a sense of", "X1rF12X0f1M-00135-00033552-00033773": "purpose when it comes to building power", "X1rF12X0f1M-00136-00033774-00034012": "that's why I am now releasing book", "X1rF12X0f1M-00137-00034013-00034390": "number 25 the war on black wealth", "X1rF12X0f1M-00138-00034391-00034709": "um breaking the code because there is no", "X1rF12X0f1M-00139-00034710-00034901": "political power", "X1rF12X0f1M-00140-00034902-00035183": "without there being economic power", "X1rF12X0f1M-00141-00035184-00035357": "you have no political weight I don't", "X1rF12X0f1M-00142-00035358-00035512": "care how many people you vote for and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00143-00035513-00035771": "what they tell you your your political", "X1rF12X0f1M-00144-00035772-00036118": "power is in your economic fluidity and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00145-00036119-00036335": "your economic Force what you are capable", "X1rF12X0f1M-00146-00036336-00036599": "of doing collectively with your money", "X1rF12X0f1M-00147-00036600-00036857": "is what's going to determine what you", "X1rF12X0f1M-00148-00036858-00037145": "get out of this political game can you", "X1rF12X0f1M-00149-00037146-00037252": "Lobby", "X1rF12X0f1M-00150-00037253-00037535": "can you put uh politicians in your", "X1rF12X0f1M-00151-00037536-00037727": "pocket that's the reality of it one of", "X1rF12X0f1M-00152-00037728-00038099": "the most crooked uh vocations or", "X1rF12X0f1M-00153-00038100-00038351": "professions to get into in the angels of", "X1rF12X0f1M-00154-00038352-00038633": "time is politics so the idea that you", "X1rF12X0f1M-00155-00038634-00038855": "can trust one of them to go up there and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00156-00038856-00039059": "just based off of their word do what", "X1rF12X0f1M-00157-00039060-00039167": "they said they're going to do is", "X1rF12X0f1M-00158-00039168-00039323": "absolutely ridiculous you got to hold", "X1rF12X0f1M-00159-00039324-00039730": "something that means something to them", "X1rF12X0f1M-00160-00039731-00039929": "that's even why those who go up there", "X1rF12X0f1M-00161-00039930-00040193": "meaning well get flipped because this", "X1rF12X0f1M-00162-00040194-00040433": "world is about power and the dollar are", "X1rF12X0f1M-00163-00040434-00040768": "money controls power but back to this", "X1rF12X0f1M-00164-00040769-00041021": "whole thing about why black males behave", "X1rF12X0f1M-00165-00041022-00041261": "in in certain things and black females", "X1rF12X0f1M-00166-00041262-00041489": "for that matter", "X1rF12X0f1M-00167-00041490-00041674": "conformity", "X1rF12X0f1M-00168-00041675-00042083": "Conformity is the construct and idea and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00169-00042084-00042358": "concept of the day everybody is doing", "X1rF12X0f1M-00170-00042359-00042562": "what everybody else does everybody wants", "X1rF12X0f1M-00171-00042563-00042785": "what everybody else has nobody is", "X1rF12X0f1M-00172-00042786-00042952": "thinking for themselves nobody has been", "X1rF12X0f1M-00173-00042953-00043162": "taught to think critically nobody has", "X1rF12X0f1M-00174-00043163-00043330": "the confidence to think outside of the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00175-00043331-00043595": "box because everybody wants to belong", "X1rF12X0f1M-00176-00043596-00043907": "and everybody wants to be accepted well", "X1rF12X0f1M-00177-00043908-00044158": "manhood isn't about being liked manhood", "X1rF12X0f1M-00178-00044159-00044380": "isn't about being accepted by the masses", "X1rF12X0f1M-00179-00044381-00044633": "manhood is about being willing to take", "X1rF12X0f1M-00180-00044634-00044873": "the necessary actions and make the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00181-00044874-00045083": "necessary statements through your", "X1rF12X0f1M-00182-00045084-00045574": "actions that will oftentimes be un uh", "X1rF12X0f1M-00183-00045575-00045708": "unpopular", "X1rF12X0f1M-00184-00045709-00046102": "unliked and even hated", "X1rF12X0f1M-00185-00046103-00046349": "the job of being a leader which is a", "X1rF12X0f1M-00186-00046350-00046649": "part of the male responsibility isn't", "X1rF12X0f1M-00187-00046650-00046901": "based on how many people you can get to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00188-00046902-00047140": "like you or who in society will accept", "X1rF12X0f1M-00189-00047141-00047501": "you or co-sign who you are that's not", "X1rF12X0f1M-00190-00047502-00047651": "where it's at where it's at is being", "X1rF12X0f1M-00191-00047652-00047789": "able to sit up and think critically", "X1rF12X0f1M-00192-00047790-00047980": "think outside of the box be willing to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00193-00047981-00048299": "move in a diametric movement or diamond", "X1rF12X0f1M-00194-00048300-00048540": "in the endometric opposition", "X1rF12X0f1M-00195-00048541-00048940": "to the standard idea of what is the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00196-00048941-00049102": "standard idea of what is beautiful", "X1rF12X0f1M-00197-00049103-00049336": "doesn't serve the black population the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00198-00049337-00049612": "standard idea of what is classy does not", "X1rF12X0f1M-00199-00049613-00049918": "uh serve the black population uh the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00200-00049919-00050105": "standard idea of what's professional in", "X1rF12X0f1M-00201-00050106-00050357": "in hair and makeup doesn't serve the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00202-00050358-00050555": "black population it is a eurocentric", "X1rF12X0f1M-00203-00050556-00050812": "Constructor eurocentric idea and that", "X1rF12X0f1M-00204-00050813-00051143": "eurocentric idea is designed to keep a", "X1rF12X0f1M-00205-00051144-00051311": "certain group in power keep a certain", "X1rF12X0f1M-00206-00051312-00051719": "group uh imaged and positioned and seen", "X1rF12X0f1M-00207-00051720-00051970": "as the the elite", "X1rF12X0f1M-00208-00051971-00052180": "and if we're ever going to change the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00209-00052182-00052349": "behavior of young boys we're going to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00210-00052350-00052549": "have to start with instilling in them", "X1rF12X0f1M-00211-00052550-00052847": "the massive the idea of the massive", "X1rF12X0f1M-00212-00052848-00053038": "potential they possess we're going to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00213-00053039-00053147": "have to start that that's called", "X1rF12X0f1M-00214-00053148-00053387": "socialization that's called Hey by the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00215-00053388-00053561": "time you're four years old you already", "X1rF12X0f1M-00216-00053562-00053837": "understand you belong here that there's", "X1rF12X0f1M-00217-00053838-00054053": "something remarkable and exceptional", "X1rF12X0f1M-00218-00054054-00054304": "about you there's something phenomenal", "X1rF12X0f1M-00219-00054305-00054544": "within you that you don't need anybody", "X1rF12X0f1M-00220-00054545-00054761": "to co-sign it you don't need anybody to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00221-00054762-00054941": "validate it you don't need anybody to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00222-00054941-00055157": "affirm it not even the people in your", "X1rF12X0f1M-00223-00055158-00055325": "family not even the people within your", "X1rF12X0f1M-00224-00055326-00055600": "direct periphery it's there you know", "X1rF12X0f1M-00225-00055601-00055792": "it's there the moment that you discover", "X1rF12X0f1M-00226-00055794-00056129": "it and you embrace it Nothing Stops you", "X1rF12X0f1M-00227-00056129-00056363": "people often ask well you know how did", "X1rF12X0f1M-00228-00056364-00056525": "you get this how did you get to doing", "X1rF12X0f1M-00229-00056526-00056692": "that how did you get to doing this and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00230-00056694-00056873": "it's one thing that I can sit up and say", "X1rF12X0f1M-00231-00056874-00057100": "and I'm real grateful for is at the age", "X1rF12X0f1M-00232-00057101-00057394": "of two and a half hours precocious so I", "X1rF12X0f1M-00233-00057395-00057575": "wasn't your average two-year-old so", "X1rF12X0f1M-00234-00057576-00057773": "let's just say four for the average four", "X1rF12X0f1M-00235-00057774-00057892": "year old I was two but the average", "X1rF12X0f1M-00236-00057894-00058121": "four-year-old my grandmother told me who", "X1rF12X0f1M-00237-00058122-00058271": "I was", "X1rF12X0f1M-00238-00058272-00058607": "she then demanded that I behaved", "X1rF12X0f1M-00239-00058608-00058780": "as if I were", "X1rF12X0f1M-00240-00058782-00059003": "she demanded that I hold myself to a", "X1rF12X0f1M-00241-00059004-00059153": "higher standard", "X1rF12X0f1M-00242-00059154-00059416": "she demanded and I'm talking three two", "X1rF12X0f1M-00243-00059417-00059621": "or three years old let me tell you a", "X1rF12X0f1M-00244-00059622-00059765": "story", "X1rF12X0f1M-00245-00059766-00059944": "it's in my bio", "X1rF12X0f1M-00246-00059945-00060154": "and a couple of other places and I've", "X1rF12X0f1M-00247-00060155-00060371": "told the story a lot but I was very", "X1rF12X0f1M-00248-00060372-00060592": "precocious I have what's known as an", "X1rF12X0f1M-00249-00060594-00060875": "eidetic memory uh it allows me to retain", "X1rF12X0f1M-00250-00060876-00061163": "a lot of information and I almost uh", "X1rF12X0f1M-00251-00061164-00061338": "verbatim detail", "X1rF12X0f1M-00252-00061339-00061823": "sometimes people call it a", "X1rF12X0f1M-00253-00061824-00062026": "a photographic memory", "X1rF12X0f1M-00254-00062027-00062315": "the truth of the matter is it's just the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00255-00062316-00062591": "way I process I naturally process an", "X1rF12X0f1M-00256-00062591-00062813": "image so everything that I see I", "X1rF12X0f1M-00257-00062814-00062992": "construct the image the average brain", "X1rF12X0f1M-00258-00062994-00063232": "does it as well but I do it in a way for", "X1rF12X0f1M-00259-00063233-00063526": "some reason uh better than average uh", "X1rF12X0f1M-00260-00063527-00063749": "everybody has a gift everybody has a", "X1rF12X0f1M-00261-00063750-00063935": "gift and the problem is very few of us", "X1rF12X0f1M-00262-00063936-00064109": "operating in it my grandmother", "X1rF12X0f1M-00263-00064110-00064259": "recognized that gift at two and a half", "X1rF12X0f1M-00264-00064260-00064432": "years old I was talking I was potty", "X1rF12X0f1M-00265-00064433-00064588": "trained at nine months walking at nine", "X1rF12X0f1M-00266-00064589-00064816": "months uh remembering songs on the radio", "X1rF12X0f1M-00267-00064817-00065021": "at two years old so she took me down", "X1rF12X0f1M-00268-00065022-00065225": "took the Bible and taught me the story", "X1rF12X0f1M-00269-00065226-00065399": "of the creation Genesis one through", "X1rF12X0f1M-00270-00065400-00065621": "three chapters one through three and she", "X1rF12X0f1M-00271-00065622-00065843": "taught me by touching each word so I", "X1rF12X0f1M-00272-00065844-00066011": "learned to read by word recognition", "X1rF12X0f1M-00273-00066012-00066226": "before I could ever sound a word out I", "X1rF12X0f1M-00274-00066227-00066479": "if it was in the King James version of", "X1rF12X0f1M-00275-00066480-00066694": "Genesis one through three I knew it and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00276-00066695-00066899": "so I could go around reading stuff drove", "X1rF12X0f1M-00277-00066900-00067367": "everybody nuts because I was just that", "X1rF12X0f1M-00278-00067368-00067673": "crazy about reading I'm going somewhere", "X1rF12X0f1M-00279-00067674-00067805": "I'm going to tell you why it's so", "X1rF12X0f1M-00280-00067806-00067991": "important to socialize to introduce a", "X1rF12X0f1M-00281-00067992-00068356": "kid to Vision into his in into his gift", "X1rF12X0f1M-00282-00068357-00068669": "and into his purpose and to his identity", "X1rF12X0f1M-00283-00068670-00068932": "so two and a half years old I'm learning", "X1rF12X0f1M-00284-00068933-00069209": "it so with a short period of time I know", "X1rF12X0f1M-00285-00069210-00069479": "it verbatim I can recite it but she", "X1rF12X0f1M-00286-00069480-00069850": "being you know theatrically related she", "X1rF12X0f1M-00287-00069851-00070132": "decided to teach me how to recite it how", "X1rF12X0f1M-00288-00070133-00070391": "to rise and fall with my speech how to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00289-00070392-00070637": "isolate on different words how to make", "X1rF12X0f1M-00290-00070638-00070979": "it come out and be alive and after she", "X1rF12X0f1M-00291-00070980-00071153": "taught it to him at age three and a half", "X1rF12X0f1M-00292-00071154-00071344": "or so she took me around to all the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00293-00071345-00071531": "churches all the schools all the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00294-00071532-00071771": "organizations in the Greater Houston", "X1rF12X0f1M-00295-00071772-00072011": "area Texas and Dallas", "X1rF12X0f1M-00296-00072012-00072250": "and put a mic in my hand and I became", "X1rF12X0f1M-00297-00072251-00072521": "known as the kid who does the creation I", "X1rF12X0f1M-00298-00072522-00072850": "recited the creation in my own way and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00299-00072851-00073055": "people would literally book me to come", "X1rF12X0f1M-00300-00073056-00073349": "so I was public speaking without knowing", "X1rF12X0f1M-00301-00073350-00073535": "that public speaking was a thing at", "X1rF12X0f1M-00302-00073536-00073631": "three", "X1rF12X0f1M-00303-00073632-00073793": "but that wasn't the thing that really", "X1rF12X0f1M-00304-00073794-00074038": "got ignited in me that made me who I am", "X1rF12X0f1M-00305-00074039-00074429": "she had ignited a passion of reading", "X1rF12X0f1M-00306-00074430-00074729": "at the age of five 1972 now I remember", "X1rF12X0f1M-00307-00074730-00074855": "this", "X1rF12X0f1M-00308-00074856-00075173": "extremely clear vividly this is still", "X1rF12X0f1M-00309-00075174-00075359": "during the time where everybody's coming", "X1rF12X0f1M-00310-00075360-00075491": "to your house to sell you something you", "X1rF12X0f1M-00311-00075492-00075647": "got the encyclopedia cells when the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00312-00075648-00075923": "vacuum salesman the dry cleaner uh the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00313-00075924-00076091": "linen people the Milkman everybody's", "X1rF12X0f1M-00314-00076092-00076306": "coming by the house so you got all these", "X1rF12X0f1M-00315-00076307-00076450": "people so having somebody to stop by", "X1rF12X0f1M-00316-00076451-00076547": "your house and try to sell you something", "X1rF12X0f1M-00317-00076548-00076762": "wasn't a foreign thing now it's", "X1rF12X0f1M-00318-00076763-00076931": "irritable as hell and it drives you nuts", "X1rF12X0f1M-00319-00076932-00077153": "but it was expected back then that's how", "X1rF12X0f1M-00320-00077154-00077344": "salesmen made their you know made their", "X1rF12X0f1M-00321-00077345-00077644": "money they came by door to door well the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00322-00077645-00077873": "encyclopedia salesman knocks on the door", "X1rF12X0f1M-00323-00077874-00078125": "here I am this kid that has this", "X1rF12X0f1M-00324-00078126-00078317": "unbelievable I'm reading the the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00325-00078318-00078587": "instructions on hair shampoo bottles I'm", "X1rF12X0f1M-00326-00078588-00078797": "just reading anything I get my hair I'm", "X1rF12X0f1M-00327-00078798-00079031": "reading it and this guy comes in and he", "X1rF12X0f1M-00328-00079032-00079469": "brings in an entire volume", "X1rF12X0f1M-00329-00079470-00079715": "World Book Encyclopedia now we forget", "X1rF12X0f1M-00330-00079716-00079919": "World Book Encyclopedia", "X1rF12X0f1M-00331-00079920-00080291": "and and I'm just mouth open", "X1rF12X0f1M-00332-00080292-00080482": "and I'm going what", "X1rF12X0f1M-00333-00080483-00080759": "and my grandmother looks over at me and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00334-00080760-00080950": "she sees this look on my face and she", "X1rF12X0f1M-00335-00080951-00081143": "buys them she reaches into her bosom", "X1rF12X0f1M-00336-00081144-00081365": "with her little sock that was wrapped in", "X1rF12X0f1M-00337-00081366-00081485": "fall", "X1rF12X0f1M-00338-00081486-00081659": "and she pulls out the money she pays him", "X1rF12X0f1M-00339-00081660-00081803": "cash for it", "X1rF12X0f1M-00340-00081804-00082012": "I was five", "X1rF12X0f1M-00341-00082013-00082553": "by the time I was 10 I had read them all", "X1rF12X0f1M-00342-00082554-00082793": "it was unleashing me", "X1rF12X0f1M-00343-00082794-00082997": "it was unleashing my mind it was", "X1rF12X0f1M-00344-00082998-00083165": "pointing me to somewhere and people said", "X1rF12X0f1M-00345-00083166-00083381": "well that's because no it's not because", "X1rF12X0f1M-00346-00083382-00083579": "I'm special it was because she saw the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00347-00083580-00083885": "gift she nurtured the gift she told me", "X1rF12X0f1M-00348-00083886-00084179": "that that made me capable", "X1rF12X0f1M-00349-00084180-00084443": "everybody is special in some way most of", "X1rF12X0f1M-00350-00084444-00084749": "the time though we are conforming we are", "X1rF12X0f1M-00351-00084750-00085012": "a world of conformist what go to school", "X1rF12X0f1M-00352-00085013-00085199": "everybody's conforming everybody's", "X1rF12X0f1M-00353-00085200-00085444": "learning the same subjects doing it the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00354-00085445-00085667": "same way being great at the same way", "X1rF12X0f1M-00355-00085668-00085925": "nobody is searching for the gift nobody", "X1rF12X0f1M-00356-00085926-00086111": "wants to unleash the mind because", "X1rF12X0f1M-00357-00086112-00086344": "everybody wants to control it", "X1rF12X0f1M-00358-00086345-00086573": "and the problem is is because we're not", "X1rF12X0f1M-00359-00086574-00086831": "socializing our boys", "X1rF12X0f1M-00360-00086832-00087041": "and we're not and for that matter our", "X1rF12X0f1M-00361-00087042-00087221": "girls", "X1rF12X0f1M-00362-00087222-00087365": "they are", "X1rF12X0f1M-00363-00087366-00087556": "they are socializing them with rap music", "X1rF12X0f1M-00364-00087557-00087761": "they're socializing them with videos", "X1rF12X0f1M-00365-00087762-00087982": "they're socializing them with horrible", "X1rF12X0f1M-00366-00087983-00088217": "video games they're socializing them", "X1rF12X0f1M-00367-00088218-00088444": "with all kind of in content that they", "X1rF12X0f1M-00368-00088445-00088835": "know their brains will automatically uh", "X1rF12X0f1M-00369-00088836-00089231": "adapt to in in in in in uh", "X1rF12X0f1M-00370-00089232-00089518": "and draw in and contain the thing is at", "X1rF12X0f1M-00371-00089519-00089735": "the most impressionable and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00372-00089736-00089944": "developmental stages they have been", "X1rF12X0f1M-00373-00089945-00090226": "bombarded with ideas about them that", "X1rF12X0f1M-00374-00090227-00090394": "does not serve them", "X1rF12X0f1M-00375-00090395-00090688": "yeah we send our kids and I literally do", "X1rF12X0f1M-00376-00090689-00090935": "this I I help parents with this we send", "X1rF12X0f1M-00377-00090936-00091079": "our little five-year-old boys into", "X1rF12X0f1M-00378-00091080-00091288": "kindergarten they are immediately", "X1rF12X0f1M-00379-00091289-00091517": "targeted for special education why", "X1rF12X0f1M-00380-00091518-00091715": "number one special education means", "X1rF12X0f1M-00381-00091716-00092038": "double the money number two uh the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00382-00092039-00092309": "largest uh population for teachers are", "X1rF12X0f1M-00383-00092310-00092512": "white middle-aged women they don't like", "X1rF12X0f1M-00384-00092513-00092644": "little black boys they're not", "X1rF12X0f1M-00385-00092645-00092776": "comfortable with them they don't feel", "X1rF12X0f1M-00386-00092777-00092987": "like uh dealing with them they already", "X1rF12X0f1M-00387-00092988-00093131": "have up in their mind that they can't", "X1rF12X0f1M-00388-00093132-00093305": "learn and they don't want them in their", "X1rF12X0f1M-00389-00093306-00093497": "classroom so the first chance they get", "X1rF12X0f1M-00390-00093498-00093641": "anything they see where they're not", "X1rF12X0f1M-00391-00093642-00093797": "keeping up with they're not being still", "X1rF12X0f1M-00392-00093798-00093965": "or they're not doing something they're", "X1rF12X0f1M-00393-00093966-00094144": "ushered off and they suggested that they", "X1rF12X0f1M-00394-00094145-00094349": "go through a special education referral", "X1rF12X0f1M-00395-00094350-00094474": "parents", "X1rF12X0f1M-00396-00094475-00094762": "very careful about that before you allow", "X1rF12X0f1M-00397-00094763-00095038": "the schools Scott's psychiatrists or", "X1rF12X0f1M-00398-00095039-00095285": "psychologist to assess your child for", "X1rF12X0f1M-00399-00095286-00095603": "special special education needs get an", "X1rF12X0f1M-00400-00095604-00095909": "individual opinion outside of the school", "X1rF12X0f1M-00401-00095910-00096221": "first why it's not that they don't need", "X1rF12X0f1M-00402-00096222-00096515": "IAP it's that you need to make sure that", "X1rF12X0f1M-00403-00096516-00096671": "they're not just being targeted I've", "X1rF12X0f1M-00404-00096672-00096785": "written a paper on the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00405-00096786-00097000": "disproportionality of special education", "X1rF12X0f1M-00406-00097001-00097205": "referrals of young African-American boys", "X1rF12X0f1M-00407-00097206-00097612": "it's it's crazy and it's available for", "X1rF12X0f1M-00408-00097613-00097847": "those who want it look", "X1rF12X0f1M-00409-00097848-00098009": "this is what I'm trying to get at so", "X1rF12X0f1M-00410-00098010-00098147": "they're in there now they're five years", "X1rF12X0f1M-00411-00098148-00098332": "old they're being referred to special", "X1rF12X0f1M-00412-00098333-00098488": "education they're being diagnosed with", "X1rF12X0f1M-00413-00098489-00098747": "Oppositional Defiant Disorder and ADHD", "X1rF12X0f1M-00414-00098748-00098885": "you say why do you keep pointing to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00415-00098886-00099071": "those two because those two allow for", "X1rF12X0f1M-00416-00099072-00099256": "medication and matter of fact those are", "X1rF12X0f1M-00417-00099257-00099521": "what they use because number one is", "X1rF12X0f1M-00418-00099522-00099773": "we're talking about ADHD and opposition", "X1rF12X0f1M-00419-00099774-00099923": "of the fine disorder these are what you", "X1rF12X0f1M-00420-00099924-00100174": "call mental disorders a mental disorder", "X1rF12X0f1M-00421-00100175-00100421": "there's no test for it it is a", "X1rF12X0f1M-00422-00100422-00100744": "subjective observation by quote unquote", "X1rF12X0f1M-00423-00100745-00101087": "a trained professional to observe and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00424-00101088-00101326": "use the DSM the diagnostic statistical", "X1rF12X0f1M-00425-00101327-00101597": "Manual of mental disorders to determine", "X1rF12X0f1M-00426-00101598-00101759": "based on the grouping of certain", "X1rF12X0f1M-00427-00101760-00102065": "symptoms what that person has", "X1rF12X0f1M-00428-00102066-00102359": "now once this", "X1rF12X0f1M-00429-00102360-00102558": "non-biased", "X1rF12X0f1M-00430-00102559-00102875": "objective really truly subjective", "X1rF12X0f1M-00431-00102876-00103060": "individuals decide that they have", "X1rF12X0f1M-00432-00103061-00103397": "Oppositional Defiant Disorder or ADHD", "X1rF12X0f1M-00433-00103398-00103654": "now I can medicate and the medications", "X1rF12X0f1M-00434-00103655-00103973": "are conservative Vyvanse uh Adderall", "X1rF12X0f1M-00435-00103974-00104125": "Ritalin", "X1rF12X0f1M-00436-00104126-00104447": "these are all schedule 2 drugs and are", "X1rF12X0f1M-00437-00104448-00104704": "stimulants that have a a reverse effect", "X1rF12X0f1M-00438-00104705-00104927": "and people who tend to have a", "X1rF12X0f1M-00439-00104928-00105202": "Hyperactive Disorder here's the problem", "X1rF12X0f1M-00440-00105203-00105610": "you now have a five-year-old child on a", "X1rF12X0f1M-00441-00105611-00105767": "highly addictive", "X1rF12X0f1M-00442-00105768-00105940": "[Music]", "X1rF12X0f1M-00443-00105941-00106073": "um", "X1rF12X0f1M-00444-00106074-00106228": "drug", "X1rF12X0f1M-00445-00106229-00106457": "to subdue them and hold them in so now", "X1rF12X0f1M-00446-00106458-00106690": "they don't feel the same they can tell", "X1rF12X0f1M-00447-00106691-00106840": "the difference in the feeling", "X1rF12X0f1M-00448-00106841-00107069": "they don't want to take it but they're", "X1rF12X0f1M-00449-00107070-00107225": "being forced to take it and most of the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00450-00107226-00107549": "time their parents are not on the level", "X1rF12X0f1M-00451-00107550-00107778": "of the people who are making the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00452-00107779-00108077": "diagnosis and prescribing the medicine", "X1rF12X0f1M-00453-00108078-00108286": "so they don't challenge it in fact the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00454-00108288-00108413": "answer is that they take the medicine", "X1rF12X0f1M-00455-00108414-00108586": "you got to take this so you do well in", "X1rF12X0f1M-00456-00108588-00108869": "school and then even if they conform to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00457-00108870-00108989": "that and do well in school school", "X1rF12X0f1M-00458-00108990-00109151": "doesn't prepare them because school is", "X1rF12X0f1M-00459-00109152-00109289": "never meant to prepare them to be", "X1rF12X0f1M-00460-00109290-00109516": "empowered to prepare them to work it", "X1rF12X0f1M-00461-00109517-00109715": "will prepare them to be trained and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00462-00109716-00109919": "pushed into different places where they", "X1rF12X0f1M-00463-00109920-00110081": "can work and then other people would", "X1rF12X0f1M-00464-00110082-00110297": "benefit from that work while giving them", "X1rF12X0f1M-00465-00110298-00110447": "Pennies on the dollar of their true", "X1rF12X0f1M-00466-00110448-00110675": "value but again because they don't know", "X1rF12X0f1M-00467-00110676-00110908": "but what normally happens is the the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00468-00110909-00111143": "black males are alienated", "X1rF12X0f1M-00469-00111144-00111484": "got alienated at a rate that is", "X1rF12X0f1M-00470-00111485-00111713": "astronomical in comparison to their", "X1rF12X0f1M-00471-00111714-00111845": "white counterparts the Asian", "X1rF12X0f1M-00472-00111846-00112078": "counterparts", "X1rF12X0f1M-00473-00112079-00112307": "in Arab counterparts and the reason is", "X1rF12X0f1M-00474-00112308-00112595": "that they are targeted literally they", "X1rF12X0f1M-00475-00112596-00112775": "are picked out", "X1rF12X0f1M-00476-00112776-00112973": "they're easy targets the parents don't", "X1rF12X0f1M-00477-00112974-00113201": "have the ability to fight back", "X1rF12X0f1M-00478-00113202-00113615": "they are the targets because parents", "X1rF12X0f1M-00479-00113616-00113873": "simply don't understand how things work", "X1rF12X0f1M-00480-00113874-00114136": "and they trust the system", "X1rF12X0f1M-00481-00114138-00114515": "system is falsely identifying them", "X1rF12X0f1M-00482-00114516-00114827": "falsely diagnosing them false", "X1rF12X0f1M-00483-00114828-00115060": "driving to them attributes that don't", "X1rF12X0f1M-00484-00115061-00115397": "serve them slowly systematically", "X1rF12X0f1M-00485-00115398-00115660": "breaking down their identity so that", "X1rF12X0f1M-00486-00115661-00115871": "they don't believe that they have value", "X1rF12X0f1M-00487-00115872-00116093": "so they start to see themselves as less", "X1rF12X0f1M-00488-00116094-00116290": "than they start to see themselves as", "X1rF12X0f1M-00489-00116291-00116536": "worthless the moment that I accept that", "X1rF12X0f1M-00490-00116538-00116878": "I have no value my life has no value and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00491-00116879-00117065": "I can't look at anyone who looks like me", "X1rF12X0f1M-00492-00117066-00117316": "and see value in them it's simply a", "X1rF12X0f1M-00493-00117317-00117539": "psychologically impossible but the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00494-00117540-00117707": "moment I see value in myself I see the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00495-00117708-00117833": "value in the light of those who look", "X1rF12X0f1M-00496-00117833-00118102": "like me I want them to excel like I want", "X1rF12X0f1M-00497-00118103-00118336": "to excel I want them to rise up and be", "X1rF12X0f1M-00498-00118338-00118631": "everything they can be like I want to be", "X1rF12X0f1M-00499-00118632-00118816": "but we are failing in that we're not", "X1rF12X0f1M-00500-00118817-00118997": "socializing and that's why black men", "X1rF12X0f1M-00501-00118998-00119201": "lead is so powerful", "X1rF12X0f1M-00502-00119202-00119447": "because we are claiming", "X1rF12X0f1M-00503-00119448-00119645": "something", "X1rF12X0f1M-00504-00119646-00119902": "for for our children we're claiming", "X1rF12X0f1M-00505-00119903-00120095": "something for our young boys I am", "X1rF12X0f1M-00506-00120096-00120389": "challenging and person to gain a better", "X1rF12X0f1M-00507-00120390-00120616": "understanding of that if you have to tap", "X1rF12X0f1M-00508-00120617-00120857": "into uh the organization if you have to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00509-00120858-00121108": "email me if you have children who are in", "X1rF12X0f1M-00510-00121109-00121307": "school especially young black males but", "X1rF12X0f1M-00511-00121308-00121499": "girls as well", "X1rF12X0f1M-00512-00121500-00121727": "they are starting to Target girls a lot", "X1rF12X0f1M-00513-00121728-00121847": "with autism", "X1rF12X0f1M-00514-00121848-00122045": "be careful it's been a boy thing big", "X1rF12X0f1M-00515-00122046-00122219": "time boy thing from now but they're", "X1rF12X0f1M-00516-00122220-00122369": "starting to Target them we need to talk", "X1rF12X0f1M-00517-00122370-00122525": "about that as well and I'm going to come", "X1rF12X0f1M-00518-00122526-00122657": "back and I'm going to talk about this", "X1rF12X0f1M-00519-00122658-00122873": "this is what I do for a living this is", "X1rF12X0f1M-00520-00122874-00123047": "what the visionetics Institute is about", "X1rF12X0f1M-00521-00123048-00123233": "it's about the spanning of the spectrum", "X1rF12X0f1M-00522-00123233-00123419": "it's about creating a vision but to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00523-00123420-00123581": "create the vision from your identity you", "X1rF12X0f1M-00524-00123582-00123851": "unleash the mind you you you unsuppress", "X1rF12X0f1M-00525-00123852-00124025": "your imagination and you become", "X1rF12X0f1M-00526-00124026-00124254": "everything that you desire to become", "X1rF12X0f1M-00527-00124255-00124451": "they are", "X1rF12X0f1M-00528-00124452-00124871": "actually suppressing the identity are", "X1rF12X0f1M-00529-00124872-00125099": "totally reconstructed and representing", "X1rF12X0f1M-00530-00125100-00125273": "it to our children and we aren't doing", "X1rF12X0f1M-00531-00125274-00125531": "anything about it that is a major issue", "X1rF12X0f1M-00532-00125532-00125707": "and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00533-00125708-00126119": "Conformity is the ghost that stole", "X1rF12X0f1M-00534-00126120-00126281": "future", "X1rF12X0f1M-00535-00126282-00126586": "what do I mean by that Conformity says", "X1rF12X0f1M-00536-00126588-00126784": "I'm going to fit in confirmity says I'm", "X1rF12X0f1M-00537-00126785-00126923": "gonna do what I'm told Conformity says", "X1rF12X0f1M-00538-00126924-00127031": "I'm not going to challenge anything", "X1rF12X0f1M-00539-00127032-00127354": "that's the one way to guarantee that you", "X1rF12X0f1M-00540-00127355-00127552": "don't get anything more than what", "X1rF12X0f1M-00541-00127553-00127721": "everybody else is getting if you want", "X1rF12X0f1M-00542-00127722-00127943": "something more than the average person", "X1rF12X0f1M-00543-00127944-00128099": "is getting you got to be willing to do", "X1rF12X0f1M-00544-00128100-00128249": "the things the average person isn't", "X1rF12X0f1M-00545-00128250-00128357": "you're going to have to get out of the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00546-00128358-00128471": "box you're gonna have to challenge the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00547-00128472-00128639": "status quo you're gonna have to question", "X1rF12X0f1M-00548-00128640-00128902": "deep down inside what's possible and", "X1rF12X0f1M-00549-00128903-00129233": "what's not", "X1rF12X0f1M-00550-00129233-00129460": "everything that exists now", "X1rF12X0f1M-00551-00129461-00129731": "once was considered impossible but the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00552-00129732-00129958": "mind that decided to explore the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00553-00129959-00130181": "imagination of what could be determined", "X1rF12X0f1M-00554-00130182-00130427": "it was possible and what we find out is", "X1rF12X0f1M-00555-00130428-00130583": "we have yet to come to a point where", "X1rF12X0f1M-00556-00130583-00130828": "nothing can't be done we just have to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00557-00130829-00131063": "have an open mind and unleash it", "X1rF12X0f1M-00558-00131064-00131243": "the god of the universe has created", "X1rF12X0f1M-00559-00131244-00131495": "everything to bring things to us that we", "X1rF12X0f1M-00560-00131496-00131699": "are able to see our mind in other words", "X1rF12X0f1M-00561-00131700-00131914": "the very fact that we can conceive", "X1rF12X0f1M-00562-00131915-00132077": "something in our minds is God's evidence", "X1rF12X0f1M-00563-00132078-00132316": "to us that it's possible", "X1rF12X0f1M-00564-00132317-00132521": "the problem is we are limiting what our", "X1rF12X0f1M-00565-00132522-00132683": "kids can see because we are forcing the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00566-00132684-00132916": "image upon them the image that was given", "X1rF12X0f1M-00567-00132917-00133114": "to us the image that was given to our", "X1rF12X0f1M-00568-00133115-00133325": "parents we aren't freeing them up we", "X1rF12X0f1M-00569-00133326-00133469": "aren't challenging them", "X1rF12X0f1M-00570-00133470-00133661": "a matter of fact we are beating it out", "X1rF12X0f1M-00571-00133662-00133823": "of them or starving it out of them", "X1rF12X0f1M-00572-00133824-00134033": "because we want them to fit in we don't", "X1rF12X0f1M-00573-00134034-00134261": "want that call from the teacher we don't", "X1rF12X0f1M-00574-00134262-00134459": "want that call from the principal so", "X1rF12X0f1M-00575-00134460-00134566": "what you're going to do is you're going", "X1rF12X0f1M-00576-00134567-00134687": "to suck it up you and where they don't", "X1rF12X0f1M-00577-00134688-00134825": "ask that question again don't challenge", "X1rF12X0f1M-00578-00134826-00134987": "that again don't go in there and say", "X1rF12X0f1M-00579-00134988-00135113": "this again don't tell them you're going", "X1rF12X0f1M-00580-00135114-00135323": "to be this again you you know this is", "X1rF12X0f1M-00581-00135324-00135454": "what they expect from you this is what", "X1rF12X0f1M-00582-00135455-00135551": "you do", "X1rF12X0f1M-00583-00135552-00135851": "stop giving them what they expect", "X1rF12X0f1M-00584-00135852-00136043": "and show them who you are", "X1rF12X0f1M-00585-00136044-00136331": "should be the message to your child male", "X1rF12X0f1M-00586-00136332-00136631": "or female", "X1rF12X0f1M-00587-00136632-00136793": "we're going to continue to do what we do", "X1rF12X0f1M-00588-00136794-00137075": "here at the Odyssey project and the work", "X1rF12X0f1M-00589-00137076-00137297": "I do at the genetics Institute as well", "X1rF12X0f1M-00590-00137298-00137549": "we're going to continue to speak to the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00591-00137550-00137687": "young mind we're going to continue to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00592-00137688-00137819": "challenge the young black mind we're", "X1rF12X0f1M-00593-00137820-00137939": "going to continue to uplift the young", "X1rF12X0f1M-00594-00137940-00138151": "black mind we're going to continue to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00595-00138152-00138413": "effectively and appropriately socialize", "X1rF12X0f1M-00596-00138414-00138640": "the young black mind so that the young", "X1rF12X0f1M-00597-00138641-00138904": "black male becomes powerful in the young", "X1rF12X0f1M-00598-00138905-00139187": "black female becomes astonishing it's", "X1rF12X0f1M-00599-00139188-00139409": "our responsibility to do it", "X1rF12X0f1M-00600-00139410-00139661": "nobody else's", "X1rF12X0f1M-00601-00139662-00139852": "this is why it's so important to support", "X1rF12X0f1M-00602-00139853-00140225": "this because this is so much bigger than", "X1rF12X0f1M-00603-00140226-00140525": "some aesthetic presentation I'm talking", "X1rF12X0f1M-00604-00140526-00140693": "about changing the lives of the black", "X1rF12X0f1M-00605-00140694-00140819": "youth in America I'm talking about", "X1rF12X0f1M-00606-00140820-00141064": "touching every night every every city", "X1rF12X0f1M-00607-00141065-00141257": "every community", "X1rF12X0f1M-00608-00141258-00141490": "and giving every black kid a sense of", "X1rF12X0f1M-00609-00141491-00141875": "self but every black kid a a a a chance", "X1rF12X0f1M-00610-00141876-00142049": "to look into their lives and imagine a", "X1rF12X0f1M-00611-00142050-00142228": "vision for themselves where they are not", "X1rF12X0f1M-00612-00142229-00142469": "powerless where they're not helpless or", "X1rF12X0f1M-00613-00142470-00142601": "they're not hopeless whether they're not", "X1rF12X0f1M-00614-00142602-00142769": "begging somebody for the crumbs on the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00615-00142770-00142973": "table where they have the ability to do", "X1rF12X0f1M-00616-00142974-00143147": "for themselves it's possible and they", "X1rF12X0f1M-00617-00143148-00143423": "need to know that", "X1rF12X0f1M-00618-00143424-00143651": "on that note look I'm out of here", "X1rF12X0f1M-00619-00143652-00143857": "I hope that what I shared with you today", "X1rF12X0f1M-00620-00143858-00144119": "illuminate something and challenges you", "X1rF12X0f1M-00621-00144120-00144340": "to do something we definitely need the", "X1rF12X0f1M-00622-00144341-00144533": "support but we also need more people to", "X1rF12X0f1M-00623-00144534-00144754": "become aware of exactly what's going on", "X1rF12X0f1M-00624-00144755-00145037": "because I can't fight this alone", "X1rF12X0f1M-00625-00145038-00145204": "on that note I'm out of here you guys", "X1rF12X0f1M-00626-00145205-00145694": "have an unbelievable day"}}, {"audio_id": "X1EDpkBnUcQ", "text": {"X1EDpkBnUcQ-00000-00000336-00000591": "people of the great soviet union", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00001-00000592-00000751": "yesterday afternoon", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00002-00000752-00001111": "german soldiers from the 297th infantry", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00003-00001112-00001350": "division rescued over 20 children", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00004-00001351-00002231": "trapped in a burning orphanage", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00005-00002232-00002415": "with no regard for the safety of the", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00006-00002416-00002526": "citizens", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00007-00002527-00003204": "thanks to the efforts of our soldiers", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00008-00003206-00004038": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00009-00004039-00004527": "enemy infantry", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00010-00004528-00006864": "uh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00011-00006865-00007119": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00012-00007120-00008504": "cover me i'm reloading", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00013-00008505-00011327": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00014-00011328-00012879": "come on", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00015-00012880-00013071": "it's about that time you showed up this", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00016-00013072-00013556": "way comradeship", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00017-00013557-00013686": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00018-00013687-00014230": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00019-00014231-00016015": "get down", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00020-00016016-00016143": "the germans are messing with", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00021-00016144-00016327": "counter-attack prepare yourself", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00022-00016328-00016607": "comedians we're too few we cannot stay", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00023-00016608-00016855": "here they will overwhelm us", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00024-00016856-00017055": "stay where you are we will hold this", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00025-00017056-00017294": "position until help arrives the eighth", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00026-00017295-00017439": "station inside", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00027-00017440-00018808": "this county enough to stop the fastest", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00028-00018809-00019647": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00029-00019648-00021806": "union and for your glorious", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00030-00021807-00022391": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00031-00022392-00024678": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00032-00024679-00027327": "where's", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00033-00027327-00030783": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00034-00030783-00032758": "now", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00035-00032760-00033959": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00036-00033960-00036487": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00037-00036488-00038446": "uh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00038-00038447-00040887": "okay", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00039-00040888-00043127": "uh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00040-00043128-00043999": "ah", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00041-00044000-00044419": "i think", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00042-00044420-00045062": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00043-00045063-00046075": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00044-00046076-00049127": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00045-00049128-00049311": "themselves on the other floor shouldn't", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00046-00049312-00049518": "we ask them to surrender conrad i lost", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00047-00049519-00049599": "them", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00048-00049600-00049839": "to hell i've got the explosives up here", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00049-00049840-00050046": "now right away come right lieutenant we", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00050-00050047-00050215": "need engineers up here get the", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00051-00050216-00050455": "explosives i've got some tnt i'll get", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00052-00050456-00050680": "started", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00053-00050681-00051511": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00054-00051512-00051694": "set these charges on the main supports", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00055-00051695-00054191": "quickly", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00056-00054191-00055230": "thank you", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00057-00055232-00055454": "the charges are set get to a safe", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00058-00055455-00056215": "distance", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00059-00056216-00056563": "the", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00060-00056564-00058926": "building let's go", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00061-00058927-00059390": "with versus", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00062-00059391-00060671": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00063-00060672-00060919": "stalingrad 1942", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00064-00060920-00061126": "german forces having reduced the city to", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00065-00061127-00061359": "rubble in a massive aerial bombardment", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00066-00061360-00061582": "meet with heavy resistance as the soviet", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00067-00061583-00061823": "red army throws its entire force into", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00068-00061824-00062063": "the defense of stalingrad in the chaos", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00069-00062064-00062303": "of constant warfare battle lines have", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00070-00062304-00062494": "dissolved the ruins of the city have", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00071-00062495-00062687": "been divided up into hard points", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00072-00062688-00062950": "surrounded by no man's land the german", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00073-00062951-00063126": "tactical advantage of the mechanized", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00074-00063127-00063359": "blitzkrieg and its coordinated infantry", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00075-00063360-00063606": "and tank attacks is rendered useless in", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00076-00063607-00063799": "the concentrated street fighting", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00077-00063800-00063935": "threatened with execution if they", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00078-00063936-00064175": "retreat the soviet troops have no choice", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00079-00064176-00065887": "but to push forward into the bloodbath", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00080-00065888-00066071": "take second squad and repair the field", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00081-00066072-00066263": "phone wire i'll clear these buildings", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00082-00066264-00066406": "with first squad and meet you on the", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00083-00066407-00066899": "other side go", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00084-00066900-00067263": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00085-00067264-00068311": "alexander", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00086-00068312-00068863": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00087-00068864-00071215": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00088-00071216-00073119": "to the west", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00089-00073120-00075911": "to the west", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00090-00075912-00078535": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00091-00078536-00082062": "enemy infantry butterfly", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00092-00082063-00083023": "stick with me", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00093-00083024-00086279": "foreign", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00094-00086280-00087262": "foreign", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00095-00087263-00089550": "is", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00096-00089551-00091998": "is", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00097-00091999-00092498": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00098-00092499-00092647": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00099-00092648-00094726": "find some color", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00100-00094727-00094835": "okay", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00101-00094836-00096559": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00102-00096560-00096682": "this", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00103-00096683-00096855": "is", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00104-00096856-00100455": "foreign", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00105-00100456-00101615": "up", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00106-00101616-00102615": "to the southeastern", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00107-00102616-00103469": "every loading", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00108-00103470-00107502": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00109-00107503-00108095": "i'm reloading", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00110-00108096-00109678": "yes", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00111-00109679-00113686": "on the left", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00112-00113688-00114114": "quick cover me i need to reload", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00113-00114115-00115735": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00114-00115736-00116551": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00115-00116552-00117843": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00116-00117844-00118139": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00117-00118140-00120534": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00118-00120535-00121916": "that's why", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00119-00121917-00123295": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00120-00123296-00124531": "get tough man", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00121-00124532-00126047": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00122-00126048-00127723": "legs", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00123-00127724-00128444": "[Laughter]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00124-00128445-00128579": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00125-00128580-00128943": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00126-00128944-00130799": "hang those bastards down", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00127-00130800-00130986": "yes", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00128-00130988-00131390": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00129-00131391-00133983": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00130-00133984-00135407": "foreign", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00131-00135408-00136902": "covered", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00132-00136903-00138231": "is", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00133-00138232-00138847": "please", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00134-00138848-00139333": "run", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00135-00139334-00141063": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00136-00141064-00144583": "hey", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00137-00144584-00146735": "come on", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00138-00146736-00148519": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00139-00148520-00151509": "on the first side", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00140-00151510-00153743": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00141-00153744-00156166": "better than me fishing", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00142-00156167-00157943": "is", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00143-00157944-00158711": "is", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00144-00158712-00161287": "three", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00145-00161288-00163239": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00146-00163240-00164159": "over to the southern", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00147-00164160-00168175": "enemies", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00148-00168176-00170775": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00149-00170776-00173231": "fire in the hole", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00150-00173232-00173686": "foreign", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00151-00173687-00175009": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00152-00175010-00175487": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00153-00175488-00175707": "let's go", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00154-00175708-00178807": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00155-00178808-00179254": "okay comrade this way let's go", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00156-00179255-00179724": "good luck comrades", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00157-00179725-00180729": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00158-00180730-00181343": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00159-00181344-00183263": "so", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00160-00183264-00184307": "hey", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00161-00184308-00184814": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00162-00184815-00185414": "foreign", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00163-00185415-00185916": "come on", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00164-00185917-00186799": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00165-00186800-00188807": "uh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00166-00188808-00192071": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00167-00192072-00194847": "right", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00168-00194848-00198159": "um", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00169-00198160-00201575": "hey what's up", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00170-00201576-00203607": "secure the station house comradeship", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00171-00203608-00204879": "okay", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00172-00204880-00208390": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00173-00208391-00209334": "yes", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00174-00209335-00210294": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00175-00210296-00212503": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00176-00212504-00213255": "we will not lose this position again", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00177-00213256-00215455": "get out of here", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00178-00215456-00215831": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00179-00215832-00218479": "stations", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00180-00218480-00218879": "that's", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00181-00218880-00219179": "is", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00182-00219180-00220287": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00183-00220288-00221842": "stations", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00184-00221842-00222223": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00185-00222223-00223327": "to the southeast", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00186-00223328-00226127": "from", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00187-00226128-00228479": "foreign", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00188-00228480-00231094": "to the southeast", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00189-00231096-00234894": "it is", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00190-00234896-00236663": "okay", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00191-00236664-00236942": "behind", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00192-00236944-00239213": "is", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00193-00239214-00239406": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00194-00239407-00239606": "another enemy heart points east of the", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00195-00239607-00240219": "station", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00196-00240219-00241758": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00197-00241759-00243191": "is", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00198-00243192-00246127": "position", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00199-00246128-00246238": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00200-00246239-00247910": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00201-00247911-00250271": "kill those fishes", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00202-00250271-00251365": "i'm on the second floor", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00203-00251366-00251779": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00204-00251780-00253127": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00205-00253128-00254769": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00206-00254771-00255630": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00207-00255631-00259436": "is", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00208-00259437-00261751": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00209-00261752-00261978": "house", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00210-00261979-00262951": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00211-00262952-00263199": "january 2nd 1943", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00212-00263200-00263471": "surrounded on all sides by soviet forces", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00213-00263472-00263687": "the german sixth army at stalingrad", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00214-00263688-00263887": "continues to crumble in the absence of a", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00215-00263888-00264127": "desperately needed supply line many", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00216-00264128-00264343": "german soldiers trapped in the city who", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00217-00264344-00264519": "are now literally starving and running", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00218-00264520-00264719": "out of ammunition continue to fight", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00219-00264720-00264951": "regardless fearing that the soviets will", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00220-00264952-00265223": "execute those who attempt to surrender", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00221-00265224-00265375": "the fighting amongst the firebombed", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00222-00265376-00265623": "ruins of the city intensifies as", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00223-00265624-00265839": "thousands of soviet infantry continue to", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00224-00265840-00267447": "retake stalingrad one block at a time", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00225-00267448-00267623": "comrades the fascists have recaptured", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00226-00267624-00267799": "several apartments along this street our", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00227-00267800-00267975": "duty is to take back these buildings one", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00228-00267976-00268158": "by one and then destroy their ammunition", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00229-00268159-00272703": "depot near city hall let's go", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00230-00272704-00273734": "those men are all dead this is suicide", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00231-00273735-00275151": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00232-00275152-00276039": "yes", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00233-00276040-00278703": "must be your peasant's luckily well done", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00234-00278704-00282919": "set those explosions", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00235-00282920-00285654": "keep moving", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00236-00285655-00285919": "hey", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00237-00285920-00288999": "these buildings are back in soviet homes", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00238-00289000-00292867": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00239-00292868-00293454": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00240-00293455-00294430": "over to the north", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00241-00294431-00298279": "three", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00242-00298280-00299471": "shoot", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00243-00299472-00300079": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00244-00300080-00304439": "reach the people", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00245-00304440-00306351": "get away from the window", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00246-00306352-00307687": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00247-00307688-00309206": "nazis", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00248-00309207-00312143": "germans", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00249-00312144-00314206": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00250-00314207-00316503": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00251-00316504-00318103": "on the other is", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00252-00318104-00319521": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00253-00319522-00321353": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00254-00321354-00321551": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00255-00321552-00322623": "me", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00256-00322624-00322775": "this is the quickest way to the city", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00257-00322776-00325536": "hall comrades through here let's go", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00258-00325537-00325775": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00259-00325776-00327751": "let's move", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00260-00327752-00330175": "enemies", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00261-00330176-00334175": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00262-00334176-00335878": "it's", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00263-00335879-00337439": "this", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00264-00337440-00339895": "better you than me fascists", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00265-00339896-00341982": "north west", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00266-00341983-00344367": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00267-00344368-00345278": "you're right cover me i'm reloading", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00268-00345279-00345447": "all right comrades through the door", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00269-00345448-00347011": "let's clear this building let's go", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00270-00347012-00348327": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00271-00348328-00348951": "often", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00272-00348952-00349369": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00273-00349370-00351230": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00274-00351231-00351534": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00275-00351535-00351719": "fish floor is clear", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00276-00351720-00352063": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00277-00352064-00352351": "get down german sniper", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00278-00352352-00353015": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00279-00353016-00353543": "first floor is clear", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00280-00353544-00354071": "heads out sniper", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00281-00354072-00354230": "good now wait for pavel to get that", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00282-00354231-00354495": "bastard's attention", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00283-00354496-00355743": "bubble do it yes", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00284-00355744-00357100": "great comrade second floor", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00285-00357101-00357401": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00286-00357402-00358327": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00287-00358328-00359668": "great building second floor", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00288-00359669-00359907": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00289-00359908-00360531": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00290-00360532-00361606": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00291-00361607-00361866": "great building second floor", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00292-00361867-00362247": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00293-00362248-00364015": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00294-00364016-00364928": "uh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00295-00364929-00366534": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00296-00366535-00368127": "i will do it yes comrade", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00297-00368128-00369358": "i will do it yes comrade", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00298-00369359-00371423": "fourth floor gray building", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00299-00371424-00372297": "ugh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00300-00372298-00374645": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00301-00374646-00377224": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00302-00377225-00379831": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00303-00379832-00380470": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00304-00380471-00380743": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00305-00380744-00380999": "he's dead good shot comrade well done", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00306-00381000-00381223": "vasily now let's move on we still have", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00307-00381224-00381863": "to secure the rest of city hall", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00308-00381864-00382023": "stick with me", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00309-00382024-00387678": "i will be right behind you comrade", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00310-00387679-00388110": "killed him", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00311-00388111-00388302": "simply pull down your weapons and", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00312-00388303-00389760": "surrender to the nearest german patrol", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00313-00389761-00391991": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00314-00391992-00392537": "foreign", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00315-00392538-00393391": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00316-00393392-00394654": "man", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00317-00394655-00396030": "those kids", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00318-00396031-00396254": "the building is secure comrades we must", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00319-00396255-00396471": "prepare for their counter-attack take up", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00320-00396472-00396823": "defensive positions", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00321-00396824-00396975": "stay close to me", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00322-00396976-00397391": "i will be right behind you the vanish", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00323-00397392-00398671": "they're starting the attack", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00324-00398672-00400071": "cover me i'm reloading", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00325-00400072-00400295": "quickly take it down", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00326-00400296-00400892": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00327-00400893-00401582": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00328-00401583-00402902": "on me", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00329-00402903-00404218": "enemy credit", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00330-00404219-00405791": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00331-00405792-00406982": "fire", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00332-00406983-00407239": "enemy infantry near the filth and kill", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00333-00407240-00408391": "the species", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00334-00408392-00409319": "open fire", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00335-00409320-00411526": "the germans", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00336-00414383-00415095": "god", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00337-00415096-00421422": "another engine", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00338-00421423-00423887": "god", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00339-00423888-00425743": "then", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00340-00425743-00427839": "here's", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00341-00427839-00428759": "mg-42", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00342-00428760-00429727": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00343-00429728-00431150": "reloading", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00344-00431151-00432710": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00345-00432712-00432927": "busily find the handy tight weapon and", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00346-00432928-00434255": "take it out", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00347-00434256-00436951": "oh", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00348-00436952-00438495": "another ng-42 gunner is trying to deploy", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00349-00438496-00439168": "here's the fountain", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00350-00439168-00440255": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00351-00440256-00442614": "kill those fashions", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00352-00442615-00446470": "take it out", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00353-00446471-00447327": "over to the north", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00354-00447328-00448127": "get out of there", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00355-00448128-00449560": "[Applause]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00356-00449562-00450287": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00357-00450288-00451487": "the tournaments are falling back", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00358-00451488-00451655": "looks like our numbers didn't come up", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00359-00451656-00451979": "today not yet anyways", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00360-00451980-00452585": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00361-00452587-00453183": "[Music]", "X1EDpkBnUcQ-00362-00453184-00453392": "you"}}]