group_id message_id message_type origin original_text clean_text annotation_type annotation_target annotation_additional team_performance performance_change sol_tracker_message sol_tracker_all 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 -1 INITIAL SYSTEM Puffin,Emu,SYSTEM,Cat,Chipmunk&&W,9,E,6 0.5 0.0 {"Puffin": ["E"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["E", "6"], "Emu": ["6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 ec79af68-f71f-4243-9841-f64e062e819a MESSAGE Cat I am not sure of my answer but if we flip a vowel we can check that the other side is even. We can also check if the even number 6 has a vowel on the other side. I am not sure of my answer but if we flip a vowel we can check that the other side is even . We can also check if the even number has a vowel on the other side . Non-probing-deliberation Reasoning complete_solution 0.438 -0.062 6 {"Puffin": ["E"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["6"], "Emu": ["6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 cfdcd0d9-e0e9-4a8a-bb86-ee8c7d15bd6f MESSAGE Puffin I think you have to flip the E I think you have to flip the Non-probing-deliberation Solution complete_solution 0.438 0.0 E {"Puffin": ["E"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["6"], "Emu": ["6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 30f025ff-f20a-41d3-a4bc-0c267b923fdd MESSAGE Emu Either the E or 6 make sense to me. Either the or make sense to me . Non-probing-deliberation Solution complete_solution 0.5 0.062 E,6 {"Puffin": ["E"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["6"], "Emu": ["E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 ac51576c-74a8-4198-8efb-417d04400944 MESSAGE Puffin 'There''s nothing that says that a card with a consonant can''t have an even number on the other side.' 'There''s nothing that says that a card with a consonant can''t have an even number on the other side .' Non-probing-deliberation Reasoning 0 0.5 0.0 {"Puffin": ["E"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["6"], "Emu": ["E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 3b1224cc-bb71-4b3d-b176-7b554fb0ca8a MESSAGE Chipmunk I think you need to flip them all - and exception could take place for every card I think you need to flip them all - and exception could take place for every card Non-probing-deliberation Reasoning complete_solution 0.5 0.0 W,9,E,6 {"Puffin": ["E"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["6"], "Emu": ["E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 be99dfd6-3b52-4013-a19f-0b64ed8df051 MESSAGE Chipmunk 'It doesn''t say you need to do only 1 or a minimum...' 'It doesn''t say you need to do only 1 or a minimum ...' Non-probing-deliberation Reasoning 0 0.5 0.0 {"Puffin": ["E"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["6"], "Emu": ["E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 777f45da-0ddc-4ab3-9d80-68596129a8db MESSAGE Cat 'Yes, I agree that you can''t really know for sure unless you flip them all' 'Yes , I agree that you can''t really know for sure unless you flip them all' Non-probing-deliberation Reasoning complete_solution 0.562 0.062 W,9,E,6 {"Puffin": ["E"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 2e725f26-c5a4-4c1c-970a-36833ea93abd SUBMIT Cat W,9,E,6 0.562 0.0 {"Puffin": ["E"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 43b67d78-0624-4f57-95f0-462277b5613b SUBMIT Puffin E,9 0.625 0.063 {"Puffin": ["E", "9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 c1408314-a027-43cf-906c-d2fde53a1f7c MESSAGE Chipmunk I suppose it does say "only" but still, who knows what is on the back of any of the cards? I suppose it does say " only " but still , who knows what is on the back of any of the cards ? Non-probing-deliberation Reasoning 0 0.625 0.0 {"Puffin": ["E", "9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 e5025fca-2517-4b26-b89e-bf42595463c1 MESSAGE Emu it does say only but then says card(s) so we could choose all it does say only but then says card ( s ) so we could choose all Non-probing-deliberation Reasoning 0 0.625 0.0 {"Puffin": ["E", "9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 526db788-4cac-4b7e-b1fc-fd9d7ee955a9 SUBMIT Emu W,9,E,6 0.625 0.0 {"Puffin": ["E", "9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 4c0f160d-82c0-41b8-a74c-c9e62922ce47 MESSAGE Chipmunk 'I''m good with that if y''all are...' 'I''m good with that if y''all are ...' Non-probing-deliberation Agree 0 0.625 0.0 {"Puffin": ["E", "9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 478f945a-4434-4a6a-9720-49c355d7518c MESSAGE Cat 'It tells us that each has a letter on one side and a number on the other. Maybe we aren''t supposed to question that part' 'It tells us that each has a letter on one side and a number on the other . Maybe we aren''t supposed to question that part' Non-probing-deliberation Reasoning 0 0.625 0.0 {"Puffin": ["E", "9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 e24a5a5a-4cba-475d-b2c4-10891c4dd977 MESSAGE Puffin 'So we have to flip the 9 because we have to see that other side isn''t odd' 'So we have to flip the because we have to see that other side isn''t odd' Non-probing-deliberation Reasoning partial_solution 0.562 -0.063 9 {"Puffin": ["9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 621bd036-4f7d-40e6-bfb9-a1c02226a5e5 MESSAGE Cat We are just testing the rule about the vowel / even number We are just testing the rule about the vowel / even number Non-probing-deliberation Reasoning 0 0.562 0.0 {"Puffin": ["9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 cc31a2c8-47e2-4d41-969e-5f8621478710 MESSAGE Puffin 'sorry isn''t a vowel' 'sorry isn''t a vowel' None 0 0 0.562 0.0 {"Puffin": ["9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 62c321ce-5c45-49ce-8448-60abc12c645c MESSAGE Cat So I say we only have to flip the E So I say we only have to flip the Non-probing-deliberation Solution complete_solution 0.625 0.063 E {"Puffin": ["9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["E"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 430eda1e-5be1-4551-956c-cf2e5f872dd5 SUBMIT Cat E 0.625 0.0 {"Puffin": ["9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["E"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 2911daad-0ea4-4654-a2dc-19bfdf4da8b9 MESSAGE Emu That was my first instinct Cat but the instructions say that most people get this task wrong. That was my first instinct but the instructions say that most people get this task wrong . Non-probing-deliberation Reasoning 0 0.625 0.0 {"Puffin": ["9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["E"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 51b8155d-4dbe-4dec-9426-193ec4b7b641 MESSAGE Cat It is only saying that all cards with vowels have an even number on the other side. So we need to just check the vowel E It is only saying that all cards with vowels have an even number on the other side . So we need to just check the vowel Non-probing-deliberation Reasoning complete_solution 0.562 -0.063 W,9,E,6 {"Puffin": ["9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 8923077d-5d75-4946-b083-100e71a7fe23 MESSAGE Cat I think I think None 0 0 0.562 0.0 {"Puffin": ["9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 ac439bbd-b09a-4326-8f12-2793d6007909 MESSAGE Cat 'It doesn''t say that all cards that are even have a vowel on the other side' 'It doesn''t say that all cards that are even have a vowel on the other side' Non-probing-deliberation Reasoning 0 0.562 0.0 W,9,E,6 {"Puffin": ["9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 0191db67-8ab6-41f3-b986-6441640f7e5b MESSAGE Chipmunk 'I''m still suspicious of the "All cards" disclaimer. What if the rule is false?' 'I''m still suspicious of the " All cards " disclaimer . What if the rule is false ?' Probing Reasoning 0 0.562 0.0 {"Puffin": ["9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 69b44fff-8bbd-4fe9-bd18-dd73d226a476 MESSAGE Puffin If there was a vowel on the other side of the 9, the rule would be broken so I think we have to check that too If there was a vowel on the other side of the , the rule would be broken so I think we have to check that too Non-probing-deliberation Reasoning partial_solution 0.562 0.0 9 {"Puffin": ["9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 b2ba883f-3bb3-4cfb-8769-ecfeca98a9bb MESSAGE Cat That makes sense, Puffin That makes sense , Non-probing-deliberation Agree 0 0.562 0.0 {"Puffin": ["9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 a25cc187-e454-4c2d-a0ff-e0e23015b27d SUBMIT Cat E,9 0.688 0.126 {"Puffin": ["9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["E", "9"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 712a9d24-cf12-4d99-996e-2e862cc9e4e9 MESSAGE Puffin 9 and E? and ? Probing Solution solution_summary 0.75 0.062 E,9 {"Puffin": ["E", "9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["E", "9"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 525c1f9c-e13f-44f5-a7d1-142d8c5f5895 MESSAGE Cat My final vote is 9 and E My final vote is and Non-probing-deliberation Solution complete_solution 0.75 0.0 E,9 {"Puffin": ["E", "9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["E", "9"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 b9e31708-65fd-416f-841b-b59953060f97 MESSAGE Chipmunk 'That is fine... let''s see what happens.' 'That is fine ... let''s see what happens .' None 0 0 0.75 0.0 {"Puffin": ["E", "9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["E", "9"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 570ccab2-b1b8-4a8e-8182-01d1c3faeb0b SUBMIT Puffin E,9 0.75 0.0 {"Puffin": ["E", "9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["E", "9"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 2f6062d2-6a38-4233-9bd0-8344685bbf5a MESSAGE Emu Ok I am good with that Ok I am good with that Non-probing-deliberation Agree 0 0.75 0.0 {"Puffin": ["E", "9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["E", "9"], "Emu": ["W", "9", "E", "6"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 31e1f303-535b-4e20-a42b-f6decbe78b82 SUBMIT Emu E,9 0.875 0.125 {"Puffin": ["E", "9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["E", "9"], "Emu": ["E", "9"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 7b41982b-c71e-49ea-af85-afd6a52025d4 SUBMIT Cat E,9 0.875 0.0 {"Puffin": ["E", "9"], "Chipmunk": ["W", "9", "E", "6"], "Cat": ["E", "9"], "Emu": ["E", "9"]} 08c890ac-c67f-4be7-aaba-8c3f31c8abc1 0cf639d4-e949-42a4-a21d-8b997784469c SUBMIT Chipmunk E,9 1.0 0.125 {"Puffin": ["E", "9"], "Chipmunk": ["E", "9"], "Cat": ["E", "9"], "Emu": ["E", "9"]}