guile/test-suite/tests/guardians.test

;;;; guardians.test --- test suite for Guile Guardians     -*- scheme -*-
;;;; Jim Blandy <[email protected]> --- July 1999
;;;;
;;;; 	Copyright (C) 1999, 2001, 2006, 2014 Free Software Foundation, Inc.
;;;; 
;;;; This library is free software; you can redistribute it and/or
;;;; modify it under the terms of the GNU Lesser General Public
;;;; License as published by the Free Software Foundation; either
;;;; version 3 of the License, or (at your option) any later version.
;;;; 
;;;; This library is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
;;;; but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
;;;; MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the GNU
;;;; Lesser General Public License for more details.
;;;; 
;;;; You should have received a copy of the GNU Lesser General Public
;;;; License along with this library; if not, write to the Free Software
;;;; Foundation, Inc., 51 Franklin Street, Fifth Floor, Boston, MA 02110-1301 USA

;;; These tests make some questionable assumptions.
;;;
;;; - They assume that a GC will find all dead objects, so they
;;;   will become flaky if we have a generational GC.
;;;
;;; - More generally, when a weakly referenced object doesn't disappear as
;;;   expected, it's hard to tell whether that's because of a guardian bug of
;;;   because a reference to it is being held somewhere, e.g., one some part
;;;   of the stack that hasn't been overwritten.  Thus, most tests cannot
;;;   fail, they can just throw `unresolved'.  We try hard to clear
;;;   references that may have been left on the stacks (see "clear refs left
;;;   on the stack" lines).
;;;
;;; - They assume that objects won't be saved by the guardian until
;;;   they explicitly invoke GC --- in other words, they assume that GC
;;;   won't happen too often.

(define-module (test-guardians)
  :use-module (test-suite lib)
  :use-module (ice-9 documentation)
  :use-module (ice-9 weak-vector))


;;;
;;; miscellaneous
;;;

(define (documented? object)
  (not (not (object-documentation object))))


(gc)

;;; Who guards the guardian?

;;; Note: We use strings rather than symbols because symbols are usually
;;; ``interned'', i.e., kept in a weakly-keyed hash table, thus making them
;;; inappropriate for the tests below.  Furthermore, we use `string-copy' in
;;; order to make sure that no string is kept around in the interpreter
;;; unwillingly (e.g., in the source-property weak hash table).

(gc)
(define g2 (make-guardian))
(g2 (list (string-copy "g2-garbage")))
(define g3 (make-guardian))
(g3 (list (string-copy "g3-garbage")))
(g3 g2)
(pass-if "g2-garbage not collected yet" (equal? (g2) #f))
(pass-if "g3-garbage not collected yet" (equal? (g3) #f))
(set! g2 #f)
(gc)
(let ((seen-g3-garbage #f)
      (seen-g2 #f)
      (seen-something-else #f))
  (let loop ()
    (let ((saved (g3)))
      (if saved
	  (begin
	    (cond
	     ((equal? saved (list (string-copy "g3-garbage")))
	      (set! seen-g3-garbage #t))
	     ((procedure? saved) (set! seen-g2 saved))
	     (else (pk 'junk saved) (set! seen-something-else #t)))
	    (loop)))))
  (pass-if "g3-garbage saved" (or seen-g3-garbage (throw 'unresolved)))
  (pass-if "g2-saved" (or (procedure? seen-g2) (throw 'unresolved)))
  (pass-if "nothing else saved" (not seen-something-else))

  ;; FIXME: The following test fails because the guardian for `g2-garbage'
  ;; disappared from the weak-car guardian list of `g2-garbage' right before
  ;; `g2-garbage' was finalized (in `finalize_guarded ()').  Sample session
  ;; (compiled with `-DDEBUG_GUARDIANS'):
  ;;
  ;; guile> (define g (make-guardian))
  ;; guile> (let ((g2 (make-guardian)))
  ;;          (format #t "g2 = ~x~%" (object-address g2))
  ;;          (g2 (string-copy "foo"))
  ;;          (g g2))
  ;; g2 = 81fde18
  ;; guile> (gc)
  ;; finalizing guarded 0x827f6a0 (1 guardians)
  ;;   guardian for 0x827f6a0 vanished
  ;; end of finalize (0x827f6a0)
  ;; finalizing guarded 0x81fde18 (1 guardians)
  ;; end of finalize (0x81fde18)

  (pass-if "g2-garbage saved" (or (and (procedure? seen-g2)
				       (equal? (seen-g2)
					       (list (string-copy
						      "g2-garbage"))))
				  (throw 'unresolved))))

(with-test-prefix "standard guardian functionality"

  (with-test-prefix "make-guardian"

    (pass-if "documented?"
      (documented? make-guardian))

    (pass-if "returns procedure"
      (procedure? (make-guardian)))

    (pass-if "returns new procedure each time"
      (not (equal? (make-guardian) (make-guardian)))))

  (with-test-prefix "empty guardian"

    (pass-if "returns #f"
      (eq? ((make-guardian)) #f))

    (pass-if "returns always #f"
      (let ((g (make-guardian)))
	(and (eq? (g) #f)
	     (begin (gc) (eq? (g) #f))
	     (begin (gc) (eq? (g) #f))))))

  (with-test-prefix "guarding independent objects"

    (pass-if "guarding immediate"
      (let ((g (make-guardian)))
	(g #f)
	(and (eq? (g) #f)
	     (begin (gc) (eq? (g) #f))
	     (begin (gc) (eq? (g) #f)))))

    (pass-if "guarding non-immediate"
      (let ((g (make-guardian)))
	(gc)
	(g (cons #f #f))
        (cons 'clear 'stack)  ;; clear refs left on the stack
	(if (not (eq? (g) #f))
	    (throw 'unresolved)
	    (begin
	      (gc)
	      (if (not (equal? (g) (cons #f #f)))
		  (throw 'unresolved)
		  (eq? (g) #f))))))

    (pass-if "guarding two non-immediates"
      (let ((g (make-guardian)))
	(gc)
	(g (cons #f #f))
	(g (cons #t #t))
        (cons 'clear 'stack)  ;; clear refs left on the stack
	(if (not (eq? (g) #f))
	    (throw 'unresolved)
	    (begin
	      (gc)
	      (let ((l (list (g) (g))))
		(if (not (or (equal? l (list (cons #f #f) (cons #t #t)))
			     (equal? l (list (cons #t #t) (cons #f #f)))))
		    (throw 'unresolved)
		    (eq? (g) #f)))))))

    (pass-if "re-guarding non-immediates"
      (let ((g (make-guardian)))
	(gc)
	(g (cons #f #f))
        (cons 'clear 'stack)  ;; clear refs left on the stack
	(if (not (eq? (g) #f))
	    (throw 'unresolved)
	    (begin
	      (gc)
	      (let ((p (g)))
		(if (not (equal? p (cons #f #f)))
		    (throw 'unresolved)
		    (begin
		      (g p)
		      (set! p #f)
		      (gc)
		      (if (not (equal? (g) (cons #f #f)))
			  (throw 'unresolved)
			  (eq? (g) #f)))))))))

    (pass-if "guarding living non-immediate"
      (let ((g (make-guardian))
	    (p (cons #f #f)))
	(g p)
	(if (not (eq? (g) #f))
	    (throw 'fail)
	    (begin
	      (gc)
	      (not (eq? (g) p)))))))

  (with-test-prefix "guarding weakly referenced objects"

    (pass-if "guarded weak vector element gets returned from guardian"
      (let ((g (make-guardian))
	    (v (weak-vector #f)))
	(gc)
	(let ((p (cons #f #f)))
	  (g p)
	  (weak-vector-set! v 0 p)
          (set! p #f))           ;; clear refs left on the stack
	(if (not (eq? (g) #f))
	    (throw 'unresolved)
	    (begin
	      (gc)
	      (if (not (equal? (g) (cons #f #f)))
		  (throw 'unresolved)
		  (eq? (g) #f))))))

    (pass-if "guarded element of weak vector gets eventually removed from weak vector"
      (let ((g (make-guardian))
	    (v (weak-vector #f)))
	(gc)
	(let ((p (cons #f #f)))
	  (g p)
	  (weak-vector-set! v 0 p)
          (set! p #f))        ;; clear refs left on the stack
	(begin
	  (gc)
	  (if (not (equal? (g) (cons #f #f)))
	      (throw 'unresolved)
	      (begin
		(gc)
		(or (not (weak-vector-ref v 0))
		    (throw 'unresolved))))))))

  (with-test-prefix "guarding weak containers"

    (pass-if "element of guarded weak vector gets collected"
      (let ((g (make-guardian))
	    (v (weak-vector #f)))
        ;; Note: We don't pass `(cons #f #f)' as an argument to `weak-vector'
        ;; otherwise references to it are likely to be left on the stack.
        (weak-vector-set! v 0 (cons #f #f))

	(g v)
	(gc)
	(if (equal? (weak-vector-ref v 0) (cons #f #f))
	    (throw 'unresolved)
	    #t))))

  (with-test-prefix "guarding guardians"
    #t)

  (with-test-prefix "guarding dependent objects"

    ;; We don't make any guarantees about the order objects are
    ;; returned from guardians and therefore we skip the following
    ;; test.

    (if #f
	(pass-if "guarding vector and element"
          (let ((g (make-guardian)))
	    (gc)
	    (let ((p (cons #f #f)))
	      (g p)
	      (g (vector p)))
	    (if (not (eq? (g) #f))
		(throw 'unresolved)
		(begin
		  (gc)
		  (if (not (equal? (g) (vector (cons #f #f))))
		      (throw 'unresolved)
		      (if (not (eq? (g) #f))
			  (throw 'unresolved)
			  (begin
			    (gc)
			    (if (not (equal? (g) (cons #f #f)))
				(throw 'unresolved)
				(eq? (g) #f)))))))))))

  (with-test-prefix "guarding objects more than once"

    (pass-if "guarding twice in one guardian"
       (let ((g (make-guardian)))
	 (gc)
	 (let ((p (cons #f #f)))
	   (g p)
	   (g p)
           (set! p #f))       ;; clear refs left on the stack
	 (if (not (eq? (g) #f))
	     (throw 'unresolved)
	     (begin
	       (gc)
	       (or (and (and=> (g) (lambda (o) (equal? o (cons #f #f))))
			(and=> (g) (lambda (o) (equal? o (cons #f #f)))))
		   (throw 'unresolved))))))

    (pass-if "guarding twice in two guardians"
       (let ((g (make-guardian))
	     (h (make-guardian)))
	 (gc)
	 (let ((p (cons #f #f)))
	   (g p)
	   (h p)
           (set! p #f))         ;; clear refs left on the stack
	 (if (not (eq? (g) #f))
	     (throw 'unresolved)
	     (begin
	       (gc)
	       (or (and (and=> (g) (lambda (o) (equal? o (cons #f #f))))
			(and=> (h) (lambda (o) (equal? o (cons #f #f)))))
		   (throw 'unresolved)))))))

  (with-test-prefix "guarding cyclic dependencies"
    #t)

  )