Datasets:
PatronusAI
/
openai-gpt-4-turbo-drop-generations

Dataset card Data Studio Files Community
response
stringlengths
266
1.38k
label
stringclasses
2 values
id
stringlengths
36
36
{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the number of locations from which Siam failed to dislodge the Burmese.", "The DOCUMENT mentions two specific locations: Kengtung and Sipsongpanna, where Siam initially failed to dislodge the Burmese.", "The ANSWER '2' corresponds to these two locations, Kengtung and Sipsongpanna, as mentioned in the DOCUMENT.", "The DOCUMENT does not provide any additional locations where Siam failed in their efforts against the Burmese, thus supporting the ANSWER provided." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
7d68bc90-8b3d-4fb4-89a8-6a0f125e1286
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides the number of households as 18,878 and the number of families as 13,629.", "To find how many more households there are than families, subtract the number of families from the number of households: 18,878 - 13,629 = 5,249.", "The ANSWER provided is '5249', which matches the result of the calculation (5,249).", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that is not present in the DOCUMENT and accurately reflects the calculation based on the given data." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
506f2675-a8bd-40bb-a261-f74adc10d39f
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the total number of people who speak either German, Vietnamese, Korean, Arabic, or French.", "The document provides the following numbers for speakers of these languages: German: 13,444, Vietnamese: 11,330, Korean: 3,948, Arabic: 3,265, French: 8,258.", "Adding these numbers together gives: 13,444 (German) + 11,330 (Vietnamese) + 3,948 (Korean) + 3,265 (Arabic) + 8,258 (French) = 40,245.", "The answer provided is '40245', which correctly sums up the total number of speakers of the specified languages.", "The answer does not introduce any information that is not present in the document and accurately reflects the sum of the speakers of the specified languages." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
4029aace-b57a-4e15-9b00-d865bd94a0ec
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides the percentage of the population from two or more races as 1.61%.", "To find the percentage of people who were not from 2 or more races, one would subtract 1.61% from 100%, which equals 98.39%.", "The ANSWER provided is '98.39', which correctly represents the percentage of people not from 2 or more races based on the subtraction of 1.61% from 100%.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond what is stated in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
dafc2fca-cd60-4a46-9255-121a51f5ffd0
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT explicitly states that Richard Talbot held the title '1st Earl of Tyrconnell'.", "The ANSWER lists 'Earl of Tyrconnell' and '1st Earl of Tyrconnell' which are both consistent with the information provided in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any new information that contradicts or goes beyond what is stated in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
30e5c3ce-1253-4c9e-aa35-276e7fe46130
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT clearly states that the final score of the game was 27-10 in favor of the Titans.", "The QUESTION asks for the number of points for the winning side, which is the Titans.", "The ANSWER provided is '27', which correctly matches the number of points scored by the Titans as stated in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
8eba957c-9814-411f-b488-5f3f4719de06
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the lengths of the two longest touchdowns in the game.", "The document lists several touchdowns with their respective lengths: 1-yard by Tomlinson, 41-yard by Edwards, 4-yard by Martin, 3-yard by Keller, 2-yard by Keller, 26-yard by Tomlinson, and 13-yard by Johnson.", "The two longest touchdowns mentioned are the 41-yard touchdown pass to Edwards and the 26-yard touchdown run by Tomlinson.", "The answer provided lists three numbers: '41', '26', '67'.", "The numbers '41' and '26' correctly correspond to the lengths of the two longest touchdowns as per the document.", "However, the number '67' is not mentioned anywhere in the document and does not relate to any touchdown length or other measurement provided in the text.", "The inclusion of '67' introduces information not present in the document, thus making the answer unfaithful." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
172ffcd4-fafa-47ef-94c9-87894fa798ab
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT clearly states that the Percy brothers were arraigned after their defeat at Stamford Bridge.", "The ANSWER lists 'their defeat at Stamford Bridge' as the event that occurred first, which is consistent with the sequence of events described in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond what is provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
18ab4b0e-048c-406d-aa75-e9ffa1029e38
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions that Sebastian Janikowski, the Raiders kicker, made a 56-yard field goal in the first quarter.", "The QUESTION asks for the longest field goal, and based on the DOCUMENT, the longest mentioned is 56 yards.", "The ANSWER correctly identifies '56' as the longest field goal, which is consistent with the information provided in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond what is stated in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
73e66dd1-a24f-4181-b710-6aeb0fb3df4e
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the age group with the second most people.", "The DOCUMENT provides the following distribution: 25.00% under the age of 18, 17.10% from 18 to 24, 25.70% from 25 to 44, 19.30% from 45 to 64, and 12.90% who were 65 years of age or older.", "From the percentages given, the age group '25 to 44' has the highest percentage at 25.70%.", "The second highest percentage is for the age group 'under the age of 18' at 25.00%.", "The ANSWER provided, 'under the age of 18', correctly identifies the age group with the second most people according to the percentages listed in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
ec4da8ab-de70-4718-a301-3d262a599524
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT clearly states the effectiveness of the Salk vaccine against different types of polio.", "It specifies that the vaccine was 94% effective against the development of bulbar polio.", "The effectiveness against PV1 was mentioned as 60-70%, and over 90% effective against PV2 and PV3.", "Given the percentages, the Salk vaccine was most effective against bulbar polio compared to PV1 and PV2.", "The ANSWER correctly identifies 'bulbar polio' as the type against which the Salk vaccine was most effective, aligning with the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
d070b0bb-cf79-4d15-af15-ea62c9fe6812
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT lists the cities sacked by Konishi Yukinaga's First Division before reaching Pyongyang. These cities are Pyongsan, Sohung, Pungsan, Hwangju, and Chunghwa.", "The QUESTION asks for the number of cities Yukinaga sacked before reaching Pyongyang.", "The ANSWER provided is '5', which correctly matches the number of cities listed in the DOCUMENT as being sacked by Yukinaga's division on their way to Pyongyang." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
296c12aa-a1b1-4977-8a70-e06b4a16d002
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT clearly states that the Dutch East India Company fleet sailed from Batavia at the end of 1620.", "The DOCUMENT also specifies that Coen began sending scouts to the coastline of Lontor after the fleet arrived at Fort Nassau on 21 February 1621.", "The ANSWER correctly identifies that the fleet sailing from Batavia occurred first, followed by Coen sending scouts to Lontor.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
ecf237e2-2ffb-4228-9eb3-8b71bcbb1e69
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the longest field goal.", "The DOCUMENT mentions two specific field goals: one by Billy Cundiff for 38 yards and another by Jason Hanson for 22 yards.", "The DOCUMENT also mentions a 25-yard field goal, but does not specify the kicker.", "The longest field goal mentioned in the DOCUMENT is the 38-yard field goal by Billy Cundiff.", "The ANSWER lists '38' twice, which seems to be a repetition error but correctly identifies the longest field goal as 38 yards.", "Despite the repetition, the core information that the longest field goal was 38 yards is accurate and faithful to the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
d5077888-ac44-4c79-add4-7be30e28463f
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the percentage of the population that is not within the age range of 45 to 64.", "According to the DOCUMENT, 18.2% of the population is within the age range of 45 to 64.", "To find the percentage of the population not in this age range, we subtract 18.2% from 100%, which equals 81.8%.", "The ANSWER provided is '81.8', which correctly represents the percentage of the population not within the age range of 45 to 64 based on the information in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any new information beyond what is provided in the DOCUMENT, nor does it contradict any information in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
6ad256fa-dd41-4296-aace-95fad66abad3
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides conflicting information about the duration of the Russo-Polish War, mentioning different start and end dates.", "It mentions that the war is often referred to as the 'Russo-Polish War of 1919-1921', suggesting a duration of two years.", "The DOCUMENT also notes that while the ceasefire was in 1920, the official treaty ending the war was signed in March 1921, which supports the two-year duration from 1919 to 1921.", "The ANSWER '2' years aligns with the information provided in the DOCUMENT that the war lasted from 1919 to 1921." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
6b404a98-2726-46b6-8e9a-07a7955a7db9
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides specific numbers for both 'people' and 'families' residing in the county.", "According to the DOCUMENT, there were 49,129 people and 13,629 families.", "The number of people (49,129) is clearly larger than the number of families (13,629).", "The ANSWER correctly identifies 'people' as the larger group, which is consistent with the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
386b3cf6-6868-4d5f-971b-9d7c02c7a5f2
{ "REASONING": [ "The question specifically asks for the total yards accumulated by Donovan McNabb on passing touchdowns.", "The document mentions two passing touchdowns by Donovan McNabb to Greg Lewis, one for 45 yards and another for 30 yards.", "The sum of these two passing touchdowns is 75 yards (45 + 30).", "The answer provided is '15', '81', which does not match the correct total of 75 yards for the passing touchdowns.", "The numbers '15' and '81' do not correspond to any relevant data about passing touchdowns in the document." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
d6de5e7b-8089-488d-b10d-166121463351
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for ancestry groups with percentages between 7 and 8%.", "The document states that 7.9% were of English ancestry and 7.8% were of Irish ancestry.", "The answer lists 'English' and 'Irish' twice each, which correctly identifies the groups but repeats them unnecessarily.", "Despite the repetition, the core information in the answer (identifying English and Irish ancestries) is faithful to the document and does not introduce new information or contradict the document." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
77567bc6-adb8-42fa-b328-840330c1cb9f
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks which event occurred first: Gustavus Adolphus succeeding to the Swedish throne, or his pressing his brother's claim to the Russian throne.", "The DOCUMENT clearly states that Gustavus Adolphus succeeded to the Swedish throne before deciding to press his brother's claim to the Russian throne.", "The sequence of events in the DOCUMENT is: Gustavus Adolphus succeeded to the throne, and subsequently, he decided to press his brother's claim.", "The ANSWER provided, 'Gustavus Adolphus', is incomplete and does not directly answer the question regarding the sequence of events.", "The ANSWER should have explicitly stated that Gustavus Adolphus succeeding to the Swedish throne happened first, to fully and accurately respond to the question." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
a2258ac5-6b53-436e-9f2d-d0c0a4eb044b
{ "REASONING": [ "The document mentions that Austin Collie scored two touchdowns in the game.", "The first touchdown by Austin Collie was mentioned as occurring in the second quarter, giving the Colts a 13-0 lead.", "The second touchdown by Austin Collie was mentioned as occurring in the fourth quarter, increasing the Colts' lead to 27-13.", "The document specifies that after Austin Collie's second touchdown, the Colts' defense stopped the Broncos on their next possession, and no further scoring is mentioned.", "Thus, Austin Collie's second touchdown was the last touchdown of the game." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
acc895d6-b9c5-4a2b-a08c-c8d99532d521
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT clearly states that the 2004 merger of the Dutch Reformed Church, the Reformed Churches in the Netherlands, and the Evangelical Lutheran Church in the Kingdom of the Netherlands led to the formation of the Protestant Church in the Netherlands.", "It is explicitly mentioned that the 2004 merger resulted in a separation where a number of congregations and members of the Dutch Reformed Church formed the Restored Reformed Church.", "The ANSWER 'formation the Restored Reformed Church' (presumably meaning 'formation of the Restored Reformed Church') correctly identifies that the formation of the Restored Reformed Church was a result of the 2004 merger.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
cd57626b-5eab-4739-ab48-159101318a0b
{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks which language is least common between German and Spanish.", "The DOCUMENT provides specific percentages of the population that speak Spanish and German at home: 2.85% speak Spanish and 1.51% speak German.", "The ANSWER correctly identifies German as the least common language spoken at home in the county, based on the percentages provided in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
7ec86fb6-9d4a-438d-bd9e-b888964f32e5
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the player who caught a pass to give the Rams their first score in the game described.", "The document specifies that the Rams' first score was a 36-yard touchdown pass from quarterback Sam Bradford to tight end Michael Hoomanawanui.", "The answer correctly identifies Michael Hoomanawanui as the player who caught the touchdown pass, which was the Rams' first score.", "The answer does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond the details provided in the document." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
0d01b65c-e919-4132-a23e-eeb0d899b4b5
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT clearly states that the defeat at Ngasaunggyan occurred before the fall of Kaungsin.", "It mentions that after the defeat at Ngasaunggyan, Kaungsin, the next fort in line, fell six days later.", "The ANSWER correctly identifies 'Ngasaunggyan' as the defeat that occurred before the one at Kaungsin, without adding any new information or contradicting the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
315fb73b-be30-469f-be1a-5c8d041d4a72
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the number of touchdown runs that measured 5-yards or less in total yards.", "The DOCUMENT mentions two specific touchdown runs that fit this criterion:", "1. RB Frank Gore's 2-yard TD run.", "2. RB T. J. Duckett's 1-yard TD run.", "No other touchdown runs mentioned in the DOCUMENT are 5 yards or less.", "The ANSWER provided ('2') matches the number of touchdown runs described in the DOCUMENT that are 5 yards or less." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
9a252e14-2379-4a3b-a705-2d23d20144bb
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT lists the sponsors of the club in chronological order.", "According to the DOCUMENT, Bodog was a sponsor for the club during the 2011-12 season.", "Following Bodog, Zoopla was the sponsor from 2012-14.", "This clearly indicates that Bodog was a sponsor before Zoopla.", "The ANSWER correctly identifies Bodog as the sponsor before Zoopla, aligning with the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
02c175ff-a19c-400b-b08d-11b08848dbd3
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks which group is smaller between people and families in the county according to the census data.", "The DOCUMENT provides specific numbers: 15,557 people and 4,365 families.", "The ANSWER correctly identifies 'families' as the smaller group compared to 'people'.", "The ANSWER also provides the exact numbers from the DOCUMENT for both people and families, which are accurate and directly relevant to the question." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
205b0d70-82cd-4dff-8045-acd0550f2dc6
{ "REASONING": [ "The Fifteen Years War is mentioned in the document as another name for the Thirteen Years' War, which lasted from 1593 to 1606.", "The Great Turkish War is stated in the document to have occurred from 1683 to 1699.", "Calculating the years between the end of the Fifteen Years War (1606) and the start of the Great Turkish War (1683) results in 1683 - 1606 = 77 years.", "The answer provided ('77') correctly calculates the number of years separating the end of the Fifteen Years War and the beginning of the Great Turkish War based on the dates given in the document." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
a6494106-cc70-4651-ad58-a6afab470d4e
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides detailed age distribution data for Aigle, including specific percentages and population counts for various age groups.", "The age groups specified in the DOCUMENT for adults are: 20-29, 30-39, 40-49, and 50-59. These groups collectively represent the adult population.", "The total adult population can be calculated by summing the populations of the specified adult age groups: 1255 (20-29) + 1068 (30-39) + 1307 (40-49) + 1134 (50-59) = 4764.", "The DOCUMENT states that there are 1137 teenagers (10-19 years old).", "Comparing the total adult population (4764) with the teenage population (1137), it is clear that the adult population is larger.", "The ANSWER 'adults' correctly identifies that the adult population has the largest age distribution in Aigle, as supported by the population counts provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
89253786-8426-41c3-8de3-f872fb8ad8ad
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions that RB Peyton Hillis scored a 1-yard TD run for the Denver Broncos during a game against the New York Jets.", "The QUESTION asks which team Peyton Hillis plays for.", "The ANSWER correctly identifies Peyton Hillis as a player for the Broncos, which is supported by the information in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
831f909a-25bf-4d3e-82c3-f208cdc11f9e
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides the percentage of the population that is 65 years of age or older as 14.60%.", "To find the percentage of the population that is not 65 years of age or older, one would subtract 14.60% from 100%, which equals 85.4%.", "The ANSWER provided, '85.4', correctly calculates and states the percentage of the population that is not 65 years of age or older based on the information given in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any new information beyond what is provided in the DOCUMENT, nor does it contradict any existing information." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
ca9cc1bb-9915-4154-ab29-858bf8a88bf3
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the difference in population between Swedish people and English or Dutch people based on their ancestry.", "The document provides the percentages of ancestry from the census: 13.9% Swedish, 7.0% English, and Dutch ancestry is not explicitly mentioned.", "To find the difference between Swedish and English ancestry: 13.9% - 7.0% = 6.9%.", "Since Dutch ancestry is not mentioned, it cannot be considered in the calculation.", "The answer provided is ['1.5', '1.5'], which does not correspond to any calculation or data provided in the document.", "The answer should have been a single percentage or number representing the difference between Swedish and English ancestries, or possibly Swedish and the sum of English and Dutch (if Dutch were mentioned).", "The format of the answer as ['1.5', '1.5'] is unclear and does not match the expected format of a difference calculation." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
8325b66f-987a-443c-9940-ed95c9d80d6c
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the season with the second smallest number of entrants from 2004 onwards.", "The document provides the number of entrants for each FA Cup season from 2004-05 to 2014-15.", "From the data provided, the number of entrants for each season is as follows: 2004-05: 660, 2005-06: 674, 2006-07: 687, 2007-08: 731, 2008-09: 762, 2009-10: 762, 2010-11: 759, 2011-12: 763, 2012-13: 758, 2013-14: 737, 2014-15: 736.", "Sorting these numbers, the smallest number of entrants from 2004 onwards is 660 (2004-05 season), and the second smallest is 674 (2005-06 season).", "The answer provided lists two seasons: '2006-07' and '2004-05 season'.", "The correct answer for the second smallest number of entrants should be the 2005-06 season, not the 2006-07 season.", "The inclusion of the 2004-05 season in the answer is correct for the smallest number of entrants, but the question specifically asked for the second smallest.", "The answer incorrectly includes the 2006-07 season, which had 687 entrants, more than the 674 entrants in the 2005-06 season." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
3d39df5b-dc6e-4124-86f4-1cd72789f9f1
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT explicitly states that in 1665-66, a seminary was built in Ayutthaya with the approval of King Narai, specifically named the Seminary of Saint Joseph.", "The ANSWER lists 'seminary', 'seminary', 'Seminary of Saint Joseph', 'the Seminary of Saint Joseph', 'seminary in Ayutthaya' which are all consistent with the information provided in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any new information beyond what is stated in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not contradict any information in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
2500b5ab-4b76-454a-8a03-01873e6bffd1
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the bombing raids made 59,000 people homeless and killed 486 civilians.", "The QUESTION asks for the difference in numbers between those made homeless and those killed due to the bombing raids.", "The correct calculation should be 59,000 (homeless) - 486 (killed) = 58,514.", "The ANSWER provided is ['58514', '39000']. The first number, 58514, correctly represents the difference between the number of people made homeless and those killed, as per the DOCUMENT.", "However, the second number, 39000, is not mentioned or supported by any data in the DOCUMENT, introducing information that is not present or implied in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
2acc9cfc-ed29-43f4-acd5-d5dcd0af75fd
{ "REASONING": [ "The Restored Hanthawaddy Kingdom was founded in 1740.", "The Konbaung armies invaded Lower Burma in 1755.", "The time span between the founding of the Hanthawaddy Kingdom in 1740 and the invasion of Lower Burma in 1755 is 15 years.", "The answer provided ('15', '15') correctly identifies the number of years as 15, which matches the duration calculated from the dates provided in the document." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
3886d66b-fb02-40aa-9eda-3044f0b35b73
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that John V Palaiologos was overthrown and imprisoned by Andronikos IV Palaiologos in 1376.", "It further states that John V escaped and regained his throne in 1379.", "The time span from 1376 to 1379 is exactly 3 years.", "The ANSWER provided ('3', '3') correctly identifies this 3-year period between the imprisonment and the regaining of the throne.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
c8feffce-5ff3-45a0-aef1-002dbdec8a4c
{ "REASONING": [ "The document mentions three specific field goals by Stephen Gostkowski: a 38-yard, a 35-yard, and a 30-yard field goal.", "The question specifically asks for the number of field goals over 30 yards.", "From the document, the 38-yard and 35-yard field goals are the only ones that qualify as being over 30 yards.", "The 30-yard field goal does not meet the criteria of being 'over 30 yards' as it is exactly 30 yards.", "The answer provided, '2', correctly identifies the number of field goals over 30 yards as per the information given in the document." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
ed5ea5d3-53f3-4c23-9338-101e96170dc2
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions two specific instances where Michael Turner scored touchdowns.", "The first instance is described as a '2-yard TD run' by Michael Turner.", "The second instance is described as a '3-yard TD run' by Michael Turner.", "The ANSWER '2' correctly reflects the number of touchdowns Michael Turner scored, as detailed in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
29be3cd4-f5fb-4e67-a272-7e12f375eec8
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states there are approximately 93,000 Mormons.", "The DOCUMENT also states there are approximately 12,000 Muslims.", "The difference between the number of Mormons and Muslims is calculated as 93,000 - 12,000 = 81,000.", "The ANSWER provided is '81000', which correctly represents the difference between the number of Mormons and Muslims.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that is not present in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not contradict any information in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
4bae26bf-7d18-4ddb-9f38-2e16437215ea
{ "REASONING": [ "The document mentions two field goals, one by Ryan Succop and two by Sebastian Janikowski.", "Ryan Succop's field goal was from 23 yards.", "Sebastian Janikowski's field goals were from 48 yards and 54 yards, respectively.", "Both of Janikowski's field goals were longer than Succop's single 23-yard field goal.", "The answer 'Janikowski' correctly identifies the kicker who made the longer field goal based on the distances provided in the document." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
cd1e0092-028a-45a3-88b8-a68c40bb2cc7
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides the number of households as 18,878.", "The DOCUMENT provides the number of housing units as 21,779.", "The difference between the number of housing units and the number of households is calculated as 21,779 - 18,878 = 2,901.", "The ANSWER provided is '2901', which correctly represents the difference between the number of housing units and the number of households.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that is not present in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not contradict any information in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
fda62fc8-4818-4d2b-b577-e2930ba8188c
{ "REASONING": [ "The document mentions that DT Craig Terrill returned a fumble 10 yards for a touchdown, which is a defensive scoring play.", "The answer lists 'Craig Terrill' twice, which seems to be a repetition error but does not introduce new information or contradict the document.", "The document also mentions LB Patrick Willis returning an interception 86 yards for a touchdown, which is another defensive scoring play not mentioned in the answer.", "The answer fails to include LB Patrick Willis, who also scored defensive points in the game according to the document." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
98842c5f-aa44-4372-a501-948765e5a88d
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT details two specific instances where Mark Sanchez threw touchdown passes during the game.", "The first instance mentioned is a 41-yard touchdown pass to wide receiver Braylon Edwards.", "The second instance is a 2-yard touchdown reception by tight end Dustin Keller from Sanchez.", "The ANSWER correctly identifies the number of touchdowns thrown by Mark Sanchez as '2', which matches the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
808b9efc-b11d-4016-b148-5eb22316ed2c
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides a breakdown of the racial makeup of the county, listing several percentages for different racial groups.", "The smallest percentages mentioned in the DOCUMENT for any racial group are 0.1% for two different races.", "The ANSWER correctly identifies the smallest percentage as '0.1%' and specifies it applies to a 'race', which aligns with the DOCUMENT's information.", "The ANSWER does not specify which races correspond to the 0.1%, but this is acceptable as the QUESTION only asks for the percentage, not the specific races.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond what is provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
8c6a357c-438f-45e7-aa1f-37d9531205a8
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that in 2016, 3.6% of Houstonians used public transit and 2.1% walked.", "To find the percentage difference of people using public transit compared to those who walked, the calculation would be (3.6% - 2.1%) = 1.5%.", "The ANSWER provided is '1.5', which correctly represents the percentage difference calculated from the data given in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any new information beyond what is provided in the DOCUMENT and does not contradict any information in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
fcc6f355-a800-45f9-85db-1bb4a18891bc
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT specifies that the Bengals' kicker Shayne Graham made two field goals in the first half, one from 41 yards and another from 31 yards.", "The QUESTION asks specifically about the number of field goals made by the Bengals in the first half.", "The ANSWER provided, '2', correctly matches the information given in the DOCUMENT, which states two field goals were made by the Bengals in the first half." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
f38d7fa8-910c-44fd-b6ee-026fa5d585fd
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides specific numbers for Jews killed and spared in Chernihiv: 10,000 Jews were put to death and only 260 Jews were spared.", "The QUESTION asks for the difference between the number of Jews killed and spared in Chernihiv.", "The correct calculation based on the numbers provided in the DOCUMENT should be 10,000 (killed) - 260 (spared) = 9,740.", "The ANSWER provided includes two numbers: '740' and '9740'.", "The number '9740' correctly represents the difference between the number of Jews killed and spared in Chernihiv, as per the DOCUMENT.", "The number '740' does not correspond to any relevant calculation or data provided in the DOCUMENT and introduces confusion or error." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
ad711215-1c2c-4e8d-b9bf-377a62271fa8
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the player who had the longest touchdown scoring play.", "The DOCUMENT mentions a 65-yard touchdown pass from Ben Roethlisberger to Nate Washington, which is the longest touchdown mentioned.", "The ANSWER lists both 'Nate Washington' and 'Roethlisberger'.", "While Nate Washington was the receiver of the longest touchdown, Roethlisberger was the quarterback who threw the pass, making him also directly involved in the longest touchdown scoring play.", "Therefore, including both names in the ANSWER is appropriate and faithful to the DOCUMENT as it acknowledges the roles of both the passer and the receiver in the longest touchdown play." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
99a1b8be-8e8b-4e6c-a69d-5aacaa02f05c
{ "REASONING": [ "The document lists several touchdowns scored during the game:", "1. T.J. Duckett scored a 32-yard rushing touchdown for the Lions.", "2. Marion Barber scored a 20-yard rushing touchdown for the Cowboys.", "3. Kevin Jones scored a 2-yard rushing touchdown for the Lions.", "4. Kevin Jones scored another rushing touchdown, this time a 3-yard run for the Lions.", "5. Marion Barber scored a 1-yard rushing touchdown for the Cowboys.", "The answer '5' matches the total number of rushing touchdowns described in the document." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
ba6bb894-8e10-483d-a6ae-3162c38dbbea
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the yardage of the only touchdown pass in the game.", "The document mentions that Ben Roethlisberger completed a 1-yard TD pass to TE Matt Spaeth.", "This is the only touchdown pass mentioned in the document.", "The answer provided, '1', correctly matches the yardage of the touchdown pass as described in the document." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
570561ee-6d2d-4b7f-a5d2-854345fc437d
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the Czechoslovak crown was initially introduced at a 1:1 ratio to the Austro-Hungarian currency.", "The DOCUMENT later mentions that during the occupation and forced subordination of the economy to German economic interests, the crown was officially pegged to the mark at a ratio of 1:10.", "The QUESTION specifically asks for the value of the decreased Crown against the Austro-Hungarian currency, not the German mark.", "The ANSWER provided ('1:10', '1:10') refers to the ratio of the crown to the German mark during the occupation, not to the Austro-Hungarian currency.", "The ANSWER fails to address the specific query about the value of the decreased Crown against the Austro-Hungarian currency and instead provides information about a different currency pairing." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
9d7c6b3f-72c8-4d70-8045-c5d013113c20
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT clearly states that Torrey Smith caught three touchdown passes from Joe Flacco in the first quarter.", "The first touchdown was a 74-yard pass, followed by two more touchdown passes of 41 and 18 yards respectively.", "The DOCUMENT mentions that this achievement marked the 12th time in NFL history a receiver caught three touchdown passes in a single quarter, and the first time for a rookie, confirming the three touchdowns caught by Smith in the first quarter.", "The ANSWER '3, 3' indicates the number of touchdown catches by Smith in the first quarter, which is consistent with the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
be734e26-8891-402c-bed9-c2a416c190d7
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT clearly states that following the Kuwait-Najd War, Ibn Saud imposed a trade blockade against Kuwait for 14 years starting from 1923 until 1937.", "The ANSWER '1923' directly corresponds to the year mentioned in the DOCUMENT when the trade blockade began.", "There is no contradictory information in the ANSWER that deviates from the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
98f0f04a-7dbc-4717-bf97-5c272321d930
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides the percentage of New Haven's residents who are 65 years of age or older as 10.2%.", "To find the percentage of residents who are not 65 years of age or older, one would subtract the percentage of those who are 65 or older from 100%.", "100% - 10.2% = 89.8%.", "The ANSWER provided, '89.8', correctly calculates and states the percentage of residents who are not 65 years of age or older based on the information given in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any new information beyond what is provided in the DOCUMENT, nor does it contradict any existing information." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
67667038-af69-4ce1-b9a7-8bc3b73b3b39
{ "REASONING": [ "The document states that Yancey Thigpen was the team's leading receiver with 85 receptions.", "Andre Hastings had 48 catches and Ernie Mills had 39 receptions, both of which are less than Yancey Thigpen's 85 receptions.", "The answer 'Yancey Thigpen' correctly identifies the player with the most receptions among the three mentioned, based on the information provided in the document." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
3b669f59-b2b6-4fc5-ac77-1206cadd4ee5
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that the Soviet 11th Red Army's invasion of the First Republic of Armenia started on November 29, 1920.", "The DOCUMENT also states that the actual transfer of power in Yerevan occurred on December 2, 1920.", "Calculating the days between November 29, 1920, and December 2, 1920, gives a total of 3 days.", "The ANSWER provided ('3', '3', '3') indicates that the transfer of power took place 3 days after the invasion started, which is consistent with the information in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
1054b945-7a9f-4ef0-950c-89131e5c650f
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides the percentage of the population within specific age groups.", "The age group '18 to 24' has the lowest percentage of the population at 6.40%.", "The ANSWER correctly identifies '18 to 24' as the age group with the lowest amount of people based on the percentages provided in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond what is stated in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
6927db9b-5ecd-4a52-8825-f4cea9c33042
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides specific truancy percentages for various locations including South Bucks and Southampton.", "South Bucks has a truancy rate of 7.0%.", "Southampton has a truancy rate of 6.4%.", "The difference in truancy rates between South Bucks and Southampton is 7.0 - 6.4 = 0.6 percentage points.", "The ANSWER provided ('0.6') correctly calculates and states this difference in truancy rates between the two locations." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
9bdcdc6e-27b9-417f-944c-ffba5ec4fa1f
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides the racial and ethnic composition of Orem in 2011, stating that 89.3% were White American.", "To find the percentage of people who were not white in 2011, we subtract the percentage of White Americans from 100%.", "100% - 89.3% = 10.7%.", "The ANSWER provided, '10.7', correctly calculates and states the percentage of non-white residents based on the information given in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
eaf5a841-8ae4-477f-bfad-d171a41a6488
{ "REASONING": [ "The final score of the game as described in the DOCUMENT is 40-10 in favor of the Detroit Lions.", "The difference in points between the winning team (Lions) and the losing team (Packers) is 40 - 10 = 30.", "The ANSWER '30' correctly represents the point difference between the two teams as described in the DOCUMENT.", "The '0' in the ANSWER does not correspond to any relevant information in the DOCUMENT regarding the point difference between the teams." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
561e07c8-d30f-4858-83d2-dabe316d2e16
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions only one instance of John Kasay kicking a field goal, which was a 22-yard field goal.", "The QUESTION specifically asks for the number of field goals longer than 20 yards that John Kasay kicked.", "The ANSWER provided is '1', '1', '2', which is inconsistent and unclear as it should be a single number.", "The correct answer, based on the DOCUMENT, should be '1' since only one field goal by John Kasay is mentioned and it was longer than 20 yards." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
2d358d54-7144-404f-90ef-7ac8156d43a8
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT specifies that the halftime score was 6-3 in favor of Green Bay.", "The Packers scored two field goals in the first half, totaling 6 points.", "The Lions scored one field goal in the first half, totaling 3 points.", "The ANSWER lists 'Packers' and 'Green Bay' which both refer to the same team, indicating that the Green Bay Packers scored more points in the first half." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
335624ef-a7b5-4f72-866a-84ff2e166077
{ "REASONING": [ "The Treaty of Bucharest was renounced by the Alexandru Marghiloman government in October 1918.", "Romania re-entered the war on 10 November 1918.", "The time between October 1918 and 10 November 1918 is approximately one month.", "The answer '1' correctly represents the number of months between the renouncement of the treaty and Romania re-entering the war." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
bf0c5770-1e03-4a94-a336-742f6e6716cf
{ "REASONING": [ "The question specifically asks for the number of yards for touchdown runs.", "The document mentions only one touchdown run by Michael Turner, which was a 5-yard touchdown run.", "The answer lists three numbers: '7', '5', '7', which implies three touchdown runs of different yardages.", "The document does not support the existence of any touchdown runs of 7 yards, as it only mentions a 5-yard touchdown run.", "The answer introduces incorrect information not supported by the document, listing two additional touchdown runs that are not mentioned anywhere in the document." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
63dce9bb-fc12-484b-9a4d-7c4448b5fded
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the player who scored both a rushing and a passing touchdown.", "The document mentions J. P. Losman throwing a 51-yard pass for a touchdown and later scoring a 12-yard rushing touchdown himself.", "The answer '51' seems to refer to the 51-yard pass thrown by J. P. Losman, but it does not directly answer the question about who scored both types of touchdowns.", "The answer should have explicitly named J. P. Losman as the player who achieved both a rushing and a passing touchdown, rather than providing a number related to one of the plays." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
68f9daad-e0bd-4980-97f6-98e12c1623c0
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides specific numbers for the losses of artillery pieces, machine guns, and rifles by the Ottoman forces during the campaign.", "According to the DOCUMENT, the Ottoman forces lost 70 artillery pieces, 30 machine guns, and 70,000 rifles.", "The QUESTION asks which item the Ottomans lost the least of among artillery pieces, machine guns, or rifles.", "The ANSWER correctly identifies that the Ottomans lost the least number of machine guns, which is 30, compared to 70 artillery pieces and 70,000 rifles." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
c0905966-b3fc-4710-9309-afbc24d57c33
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides specific percentages for different age groups in the city's population.", "The age group '18 to 24' is stated to comprise 55.2% of the population.", "This percentage is the highest among the listed age groups, indicating that the '18 to 24' age group had the most people.", "The ANSWER correctly identifies '18 to 24' as the age group with the most people, consistently across all its entries.", "There is no additional information in the ANSWER that is not supported by the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
a8dff03e-b3f5-4079-ac03-ae50b90dea2f
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that 31.2% of evacuees were unemployed and living off government benefits.", "The DOCUMENT also states that 22.3% of evacuees were unemployed and seeking work.", "The difference between the percentage of evacuees living off government benefits and those seeking work is 31.2% - 22.3% = 8.9%.", "The ANSWER provided is '8.9', which correctly represents the difference calculated from the percentages given in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any new information beyond what is provided in the DOCUMENT, nor does it contradict any information in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
5c9b679f-75fe-4d94-8f36-4342d8c78ca5
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the difference in population between whites and African Americans in Lassen County in 2010.", "According to the document, the population of whites was 25,532 and the population of African Americans was 2,834.", "The difference between these two populations is calculated as 25,532 - 2,834 = 22,698.", "The answer provided is '22698', which correctly represents the numerical difference between the white and African American populations.", "The answer does not introduce any information that is not present in the document and accurately reflects the data provided." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
caf400b2-28c5-440b-835f-d9d516c6afed
{ "REASONING": [ "The question specifically asks for the countries where napalm was used from 1980 to 1988.", "The document lists Iran and Iraq as countries where napalm was used during the period from 1980 to 1988.", "The document also mentions Argentina using napalm in 1982, which falls within the specified time frame.", "The answer lists Iran, Iraq, Argentina, and Iraq again. The repetition of Iraq is unnecessary and could be seen as an error, but it does not introduce information outside the document's scope.", "The answer correctly identifies Iran, Iraq, and Argentina as countries where napalm was used from 1980 to 1988, despite the repetition of Iraq." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
93944496-8d4b-49d5-8c78-a4f1ac8c544a
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions that the First Indochina War occurred from 1946 to 1954.", "The DOCUMENT also states that the Algerian War of Independence occurred from 1954 to 1962.", "Both wars were ongoing in the year 1954, as the First Indochina War was concluding and the Algerian War of Independence was beginning.", "The ANSWER lists both the First Indochina War and the Algerian War of Independence as the wars going on in 1954, which aligns with the information provided in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER repeats the names of the wars, but this redundancy does not introduce any new information or contradiction." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
d19348e8-58f7-44ec-9f86-dfc938350743
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the difference in population percentages between Christians and Buddhists in Chennai.", "The document provides the religious census of 2011, stating that 7.7% of Chennai's population were Christians and 0.1% were Buddhists.", "The answer '7.6' correctly calculates the difference between the percentage of Christians (7.7%) and Buddhists (0.1%), which is 7.6%.", "The answer does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond the information provided in the document." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
c5f4258c-d2bc-4f3f-8e93-d9665d9b7c60
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for racial groups that are smaller than 2% in the county according to the 2010 Census data.", "The DOCUMENT lists the following racial percentages: 81.2% white, 12.7% black or African American, 2.4% Asian, 0.3% American Indian, 0.1% Pacific islander, 0.9% from other races, and 2.5% from two or more races.", "From the data, the racial groups that are smaller than 2% are: American Indian (0.3%), Pacific islander (0.1%), and other races (0.9%).", "The ANSWER correctly identifies 'American Indian', 'Pacific islander', and 'other' as the groups smaller than 2%.", "The ANSWER also includes the specific percentages for these groups ('0.3% American Indian', '0.1% Pacific islander', '0.9% from other races'), which are accurately reflected in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
acf5ca68-bab4-451e-91dd-2be660deb92a
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the age range with the smallest percentage of the population.", "The DOCUMENT provides percentages for various age ranges in the population of Aigle.", "According to the DOCUMENT, the age range '90 and older' has the smallest percentage of the population, which is 0.9%.", "The ANSWER correctly identifies '90 and older' as the age range with the smallest percentage of the population.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
3f52a04c-3638-4246-98d3-0221ebb50fe7
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the number of touchdowns longer than 75 yards.", "The document mentions two specific touchdowns that meet this criterion:", "1. A 76-yard touchdown pass from Matt Cassel to Randy Moss.", "2. A 78-yard touchdown pass from Matt Leinart to Larry Fitzgerald.", "Both touchdowns are clearly described in the document as being longer than 75 yards.", "The answer provided is '2', which correctly matches the number of touchdowns described in the document that are longer than 75 yards." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
23338997-d662-4f1e-9c58-db9e606f69cc
{ "REASONING": [ "The document mentions three specific field goals kicked by Stephen Gostkowski: 38 yards, 35 yards, and 30 yards.", "All three mentioned field goals are longer than 29 yards.", "The answer correctly identifies the number of field goals longer than 29 yards as three, which matches the information provided in the document." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
3971d994-7cd9-4a69-a47c-6c6e9a91fe2a
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks specifically about the number of yards Reggie Bush gained.", "The document mentions that Reggie Bush had a 15-yard touchdown run.", "The answer lists '15' and '15-yard', which directly corresponds to the information provided in the document about Bush's performance.", "There is no mention of additional yardage gained by Bush in the document, so the answer does not introduce any information beyond what is provided.", "The answer does not contradict any information in the document." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
7c451efb-71e5-47f6-8fa2-0495a4d342c5
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides the percentage of New Haven's residents who are 65 years of age or older as 10.2%.", "To find the percentage of residents who are not 65 years of age or older, one would subtract the percentage of those who are 65 or older from 100%.", "100% - 10.2% = 89.8%.", "The ANSWER provided, '89.8', correctly calculates and states the percentage of residents who are not 65 years of age or older based on the information given in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
8d0a6ef5-543c-405b-bbc3-8984d2730bde
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides specific percentages for different ethnic groups in the UK based on the 2011 Census.", "The percentage of the British Asian population is given as 39.7%.", "The percentage of the Black British population is given as 8.6%.", "To find the total percentage of the UK population that is either British Asian or Black British, these two percentages should be added together.", "Adding 39.7% (British Asian) and 8.6% (Black British) equals 48.3%.", "The ANSWER provided is '48.3', which correctly matches the sum of the percentages for British Asian and Black British populations as calculated from the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
2480d9f5-3b28-4ab3-b3d2-44cd00e3288d
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides specific percentages for different types of households.", "It states that 44.0% of households were married couples living together.", "It also states that 23.2% of all households were made up of individuals.", "Comparing these percentages directly answers the question, showing that the group of married couples living together (44.0%) is larger than the group made up of individuals (23.2%).", "The ANSWER correctly identifies 'married couples living together' as the larger group, which is consistent with the information provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
5029dc3e-adfd-46da-983a-d5ccdba66744
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that there were over 361 scholars and around 3,826 scribes in the editorial board.", "The QUESTION asks for the difference in number between scribes and scholars.", "Calculating the difference: 3826 scribes - 361 scholars = 3465.", "The ANSWER provided is '3465', which correctly represents the difference between the number of scribes and scholars as per the information given in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
9794f852-dd26-404f-94f4-40712929bdd8
{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the number of years between the last census conducted in 1932 and the study made by the Central Administration of Statistics after the independence of Lebanon.", "The DOCUMENT states that the last national census was conducted in 1932 and mentions a significant study conducted in 1970.", "The ANSWER '38' represents the calculation of the difference between 1970 (year of the study) and 1932 (year of the last census), which is indeed 38 years.", "The ANSWER directly addresses the QUESTION using the information provided in the DOCUMENT without adding any new information or contradicting the existing information." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
1d664e98-a0ea-42bd-b031-3e76383f5b0e
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the total number of males, both white and coloured, in 1727.", "The document provides the number of white and coloured males in 1727 as 910 white men and 787 coloured men.", "To find the total number of males in 1727, we need to add the number of white men (910) and coloured men (787).", "The sum of 910 and 787 is 1697, which is the total number of males in 1727.", "The answer provided is '4116', which does not match the correct total of 1697 calculated from the document.", "The answer '4116' appears to be incorrect and does not align with the information provided in the document." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
29abea72-b048-4b37-83ce-c39f8002b262
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the population numbers from the census for Ungheni and Cahul.", "The document provides the population numbers for Ungheni and Cahul as 32,828 and 28,763 respectively.", "The answer provided is '61591', which appears three times. This number is the sum of the populations of Ungheni and Cahul (32,828 + 28,763 = 61,591).", "The answer correctly calculates the total population of Ungheni and Cahul based on the data given in the document.", "The answer does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond what is provided in the document." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
90ca93ef-fa40-4ae3-8353-f337b31dd02b
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides the number of people as 49,129 and the number of families as 13,629.", "To find how many more people there are than families, the calculation would be 49,129 (people) - 13,629 (families) = 35,500.", "The ANSWER provided is '35500', which correctly reflects the result of this calculation.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that is not present in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER does not contradict any information in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
3c502e63-54c3-4517-b91e-0bbd60506c87
{ "REASONING": [ "The answer provides numbers for families and households which are directly taken from the document.", "The number '5395' in the answer does not correspond to any data provided in the document regarding households or families.", "The document clearly states there are 3,155 households and 2,240 families residing in the county.", "The inclusion of '5395' in the answer introduces information not present in the document, which makes the answer unfaithful." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
5c379ccb-20e5-4555-a750-f3d8408abf7a
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks about the companies competing with Macromedia for semi-open formats.", "The DOCUMENT mentions that Macromedia disclosed the Flash Version 3 Specification in response to competition from new and often semi-open formats.", "Specifically, the DOCUMENT lists 'Xara's Flare and Sharp's Extended Vector Animation formats' as examples of these competing semi-open formats.", "The ANSWER provided, 'Xara's Flare and Sharp's', correctly identifies the companies involved in the competition with Macromedia's SWF format.", "The ANSWER does not include the full name of Sharp's format ('Extended Vector Animation'), but it correctly identifies the companies, which is the focus of the question." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
af015bdc-2f04-4dd0-97d8-97e40f91b2c6
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that 10.1% of the population were of Irish ancestry.", "To find the percentage of the population that were not Irish, one would subtract the percentage of Irish ancestry from 100%.", "100% - 10.1% = 89.9%.", "The ANSWER provided, '89.9', correctly calculates the percentage of the population that were not Irish based on the information given in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
950f2476-04a4-45ca-aa7c-9c6a4d34864c
{ "REASONING": [ "The document provides the percentage distribution of the population across different age groups.", "The age groups and their respective percentages are: under 18 (10.1%), 18 to 24 (56.2%), 25 to 44 (16.1%), 45 to 64 (10.5%), and 65 and older (7%).", "To find the third most populous age group, we need to rank these percentages. The ranking from highest to lowest is: 18 to 24 (56.2%), 25 to 44 (16.1%), 45 to 64 (10.5%), under 18 (10.1%), and 65 and older (7%).", "According to this ranking, the age group '45 to 64' has the third highest percentage of the population.", "The answer provided, '45 to 64', correctly identifies the third most populous age group based on the information in the document." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
d9665bea-ad89-46ab-9ea7-254d8cdc7195
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT clearly states that the Irish treaty delegates involved in the negotiations of the Anglo-Irish Treaty were Arthur Griffith, Robert Barton, and Michael Collins.", "The ANSWER lists Arthur Griffith, Robert Barton, and Michael Collins as the individuals involved in the negotiations, which matches the information provided in the DOCUMENT.", "The repetition of names in the ANSWER (each name is repeated once) does not introduce new information or contradict the DOCUMENT, but rather seems to be an error in formatting or duplication.", "Despite the duplication error, the core information in the ANSWER about who was involved in the negotiations is accurate and faithful to the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
2aa85a31-c18f-4b5e-a5de-a6ee4558a50b
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks who threw the first touchdown pass of the game.", "The document specifies that the first touchdown pass of the game was completed by Kyle Orton, who threw a 13-yard touchdown pass to wide receiver Eddie Royal in the first quarter.", "The answer provided is 'Kyle Orton', which is consistent with the information in the document.", "The answer does not introduce any information that is not present in the document, nor does it contradict any information in the document." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
aa01761a-578c-4fc2-ab16-aebe5b17795b
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions that WR Reggie Williams caught a 36-yard TD pass from QB David Garrard.", "The DOCUMENT does not mention any other instances of Reggie Williams catching passes in the game.", "The ANSWER '1' correctly reflects the number of passes Reggie Williams caught as detailed in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
228808bc-1ef8-488e-a035-69be0a897ac2
{ "REASONING": [ "The document states that sheep were domesticated in Mesopotamia between 13,000 and 11,000 years ago.", "The document also mentions other animals and plants with their respective domestication times, such as cattle around 10,500 years ago, pigs around 10,500 years ago, and various crops and plants at different times.", "From the information provided, sheep are the earliest domesticated animal mentioned in the document, with domestication starting as early as 13,000 years ago.", "The answer 'Sheep' correctly identifies the animal that was cultivated (domesticated) earliest according to the information in the document.", "The repetition of 'Sheep' in the answer does not provide additional information or contradict the document but is redundant." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
ee8a5b27-a384-4f03-af0b-cedb03f95d29
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT provides specific population figures for several cities, including Cahul and Soroca.", "According to the DOCUMENT, Cahul has a population of 28,763.", "According to the DOCUMENT, Soroca has a population of 22,196.", "The QUESTION asks which city is larger between Cahul and Soroca.", "The ANSWER 'Cahul' correctly identifies that Cahul is larger than Soroca based on the population figures provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
166ee002-b0a9-43c8-a86c-f1b1462e8b77
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT states that 12.0% of the population were Polish people.", "To find the percentage of the population that were not Polish, we subtract the percentage of Polish people from 100%.", "100% - 12.0% = 88.0%.", "The ANSWER provided is '88', which correctly represents 88.0% of the population not being Polish.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond what is provided in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
4c1b0cdf-242a-4d51-a71e-20730bbf23c6
{ "REASONING": [ "The DOCUMENT mentions that Willis McGahee rushed for a 1-yard touchdown in the first quarter.", "The DOCUMENT does not provide any additional information about other rushing yards by McGahee in the game.", "The ANSWER '1' specifically refers to the 1-yard touchdown rush by McGahee, which is directly supported by the DOCUMENT.", "There is no contradiction between the ANSWER and the DOCUMENT, and the ANSWER does not introduce any information not present in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
06d52b84-a158-458e-8160-9d367840da5e
{ "REASONING": [ "The question asks for the number of deaths that occurred two weeks after the Bavarian side had already lost 1,100 men.", "The DOCUMENT specifies that the battle where 1,100 Bavarian men were lost occurred on 25 December 1705.", "It further states that about two weeks later, on 8 January 1706, the Battle of Aidenbach resulted in approximately 4,000 casualties on the Bavarian side.", "The ANSWER provided, '4000', directly corresponds to the number of casualties mentioned in the DOCUMENT for the Battle of Aidenbach, which occurred approximately two weeks after the earlier mentioned battle.", "The ANSWER does not introduce any information that contradicts or goes beyond what is stated in the DOCUMENT." ], "SCORE": "PASS" }
PASS
7c408fcc-6561-4a82-901a-f84f37609fb4
{ "REASONING": [ "The QUESTION asks for the longest passing touchdown in the game described in the DOCUMENT.", "The DOCUMENT mentions two specific passing touchdowns: a 12-yard TD pass from Kurt Warner to Larry Fitzgerald and a 99-yard interception return for a touchdown by Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie.", "The 99-yard interception return for a touchdown by Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie is the longest passing touchdown mentioned in the DOCUMENT.", "The ANSWER provided lists '12' repeatedly, which corresponds to the 12-yard touchdown pass from Kurt Warner to Larry Fitzgerald, not the 99-yard touchdown by Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie.", "The ANSWER fails to correctly identify the longest passing touchdown, which is 99 yards, not 12 yards." ], "SCORE": "FAIL" }
PASS
4fd064c1-0a10-483e-a2b0-18c3867cce40